id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12030v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12030v1 | SPA-VL: A Comprehensive Safety Preference Alignment Dataset for Vision Language Model | 2024-06-17T18:57:37 | 2024-06-17T18:57:37 | Yongting Zhang, Lu Chen, Guodong Zheng, Yifeng Gao, Rui Zheng, Jinlan Fu, Zhenfei Yin, Senjie Jin, Yu Qiao, Xuanjing Huang, Feng Zhao, Tao Gui, Jing Shao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | The emergence of Vision Language Models (VLMs) has brought unprecedented
advances in understanding multimodal information. The combination of textual
and visual semantics in VLMs is highly complex and diverse, making the safety
alignment of these models challenging. Furthermore, due to the limited study on
the safety alignment of VLMs, there is a lack of large-scale, high-quality
datasets. To address these limitations, we propose a Safety Preference
Alignment dataset for Vision Language Models named SPA-VL. In terms of breadth,
SPA-VL covers 6 harmfulness domains, 13 categories, and 53 subcategories, and
contains 100,788 samples of the quadruple (question, image, chosen response,
rejected response). In terms of depth, the responses are collected from 12
open- (e.g., QwenVL) and closed-source (e.g., Gemini) VLMs to ensure diversity.
The experimental results indicate that models trained with alignment techniques
on the SPA-VL dataset exhibit substantial improvements in harmlessness and
helpfulness while maintaining core capabilities. SPA-VL, as a large-scale,
high-quality, and diverse dataset, represents a significant milestone in
ensuring that VLMs achieve both harmlessness and helpfulness. We have made our
code https://github.com/EchoseChen/SPA-VL-RLHF and SPA-VL dataset url
https://huggingface.co/datasets/sqrti/SPA-VL publicly available. | [
-0.32984963059425354,
-0.34340763092041016,
0.17904940247535706,
0.09472642093896866,
-0.09616787731647491,
-0.12399087846279144,
0.14009040594100952,
-0.5728729367256165,
-0.2641243636608124,
0.8914023041725159,
-0.4294801652431488,
-0.6835506558418274,
-0.5682743787765503,
-0.19369249045848846,
-0.3935483992099762,
1.1609034538269043,
0.17681947350502014,
0.18528592586517334,
0.14035102725028992,
-0.40735337138175964,
-0.5217050313949585,
-0.5162546634674072,
-0.21676300466060638,
0.2466292679309845,
0.7649843096733093,
0.22122910618782043,
0.8992369771003723,
0.9274001121520996,
0.7533000707626343,
0.303556889295578,
-0.0603015273809433,
0.2631767988204956,
-0.4759807586669922,
-0.031190382316708565,
-0.37808820605278015,
0.007526002824306488,
-0.6570957899093628,
-0.3275623023509979,
0.6793686747550964,
0.654252290725708,
-0.1786181628704071,
0.0940694585442543,
0.049806639552116394,
0.7787653207778931,
-0.7832131385803223,
-0.16672943532466888,
-0.6242470145225525,
0.04078105464577675,
-0.31147676706314087,
0.09513691812753677,
-0.5084141492843628,
-0.4145301580429077,
0.5487911105155945,
-0.5496702194213867,
-0.03873440995812416,
0.37993547320365906,
1.0416258573532104,
0.42448896169662476,
-0.5750151872634888,
0.29405200481414795,
-0.4305678904056549,
0.7109541296958923,
-0.43737176060676575,
0.4936651587486267,
-0.06722119450569153,
0.4117293655872345,
0.05045327916741371,
-0.26287907361984253,
-0.41423752903938293,
0.012120856903493404,
0.045527901500463486,
-0.14569999277591705,
-0.10395113378763199,
0.03357963636517525,
0.08115097135305405,
-0.1506945639848709,
-0.9458218812942505,
0.13107606768608093,
-0.3048038184642792,
-0.27263712882995605,
0.6053245663642883,
0.50592041015625,
0.31211987137794495,
0.20407384634017944,
-0.7743951678276062,
-0.14057855308055878,
-0.8952047824859619,
-0.04307059198617935,
0.22070088982582092,
0.4840629994869232,
-0.22873610258102417,
0.9611204266548157,
-0.2063429355621338,
1.2510037422180176,
-0.23079845309257507,
-0.01796891540288925,
0.8165061473846436,
-0.5244603753089905,
-0.3084653913974762,
0.13963793218135834,
0.7647298574447632,
0.8843131065368652,
0.48722219467163086,
0.19295701384544373,
-0.07625740766525269,
0.14341183006763458,
0.4276219606399536,
-0.33470219373703003,
0.08107436448335648,
0.07889831066131592,
-0.01906009204685688,
-0.5207449793815613,
0.0603896863758564,
-0.9336275458335876,
-0.6361662745475769,
-0.5649142265319824,
0.32930657267570496,
-0.41402387619018555,
-0.3593926429748535,
0.5704601407051086,
0.04440075531601906,
0.33725059032440186,
0.3388621509075165,
-0.6511708498001099,
0.041889891028404236,
0.5917733907699585,
0.5492658615112305,
-0.5061354041099548,
-0.5569157600402832,
-0.5663031935691833,
0.33083081245422363,
-0.3332243859767914,
0.6211903691291809,
-0.428960919380188,
-0.24812911450862885,
0.00337397214025259,
0.23025254905223846,
-0.1299271434545517,
-0.3397907316684723,
0.3212234675884247,
-0.264913409948349,
0.14521357417106628,
-0.23447109758853912,
-0.2038620114326477,
0.0022519356571137905,
0.19083096086978912,
-0.6256538033485413,
0.8757709264755249,
-0.004390289541333914,
-0.9599213004112244,
0.6029638051986694,
-0.45027267932891846,
-0.1766391098499298,
0.06232704222202301,
-0.2648106515407562,
-0.6089223027229309,
-0.23143750429153442,
0.09700631350278854,
0.21010851860046387,
0.08541478961706161,
0.3147461414337158,
-0.6681376099586487,
-0.25091496109962463,
0.5155653953552246,
-0.4941105544567108,
0.802516758441925,
0.2383980005979538,
-0.3620222806930542,
0.44281479716300964,
-0.6215824484825134,
0.0422978512942791,
0.027475230395793915,
-0.012767375446856022,
-0.45398640632629395,
-0.24746908247470856,
0.2465893030166626,
0.45818185806274414,
0.4420415759086609,
-0.4109647572040558,
-0.038119420409202576,
-0.4753209054470062,
-0.12511293590068817,
1.02067232131958,
-0.31449443101882935,
0.3236851394176483,
-0.15248261392116547,
0.19047564268112183,
0.3567385971546173,
0.8322644829750061,
0.24358771741390228,
-0.4418812692165375,
-0.8126514554023743,
-0.2728188931941986,
0.00845421850681305,
0.6273238658905029,
-0.5910995006561279,
0.5853453278541565,
-0.42218273878097534,
-0.32251569628715515,
-0.675504744052887,
-0.04668420925736427,
0.9013561606407166,
0.6099669933319092,
0.3009538948535919,
-0.20022942125797272,
-0.42541295289993286,
-1.1382646560668945,
-0.021414287388324738,
0.03552749380469322,
0.4771025776863098,
0.4547403156757355,
0.08232919871807098,
-0.2650224566459656,
1.0051350593566895,
-0.5109968781471252,
-0.17821533977985382,
0.007366471458226442,
-0.44998085498809814,
0.011766800656914711,
0.3625299036502838,
0.8527374267578125,
-1.1778619289398193,
-0.4172176420688629,
0.25175994634628296,
-0.7087534666061401,
-0.032940976321697235,
0.5007892847061157,
-0.5586563944816589,
0.5102161765098572,
-0.07384591549634933,
-0.38507506251335144,
0.35466453433036804,
0.6673476099967957,
-0.829712450504303,
0.3698808550834656,
0.023312732577323914,
0.14854909479618073,
-1.1537580490112305,
0.2339468151330948,
0.35621097683906555,
-0.19015999138355255,
-0.8159541487693787,
0.032584886997938156,
0.07653660327196121,
0.12016602605581284,
-0.9921193718910217,
0.5520971417427063,
-0.1960357427597046,
-0.2991691529750824,
-0.0026328079402446747,
-0.024100633338093758,
-0.08883143216371536,
0.1893286406993866,
0.4225647449493408,
0.8247355818748474,
0.8073497414588928,
-0.43352001905441284,
0.29652681946754456,
0.26096123456954956,
-0.06358446925878525,
0.46567419171333313,
-0.3892578184604645,
-0.2126396745443344,
-0.228295236825943,
-0.2546759843826294,
-0.6525754928588867,
-0.1972585916519165,
0.48580530285835266,
-0.2260671854019165,
0.24491237103939056,
-0.18586434423923492,
-0.04830797761678696,
-0.1694675087928772,
-0.1685226857662201,
0.4790687561035156,
0.36294594407081604,
-0.3893670439720154,
0.25725406408309937,
0.8838960528373718,
-0.2407757043838501,
-1.3271534442901611,
-0.35272106528282166,
0.043963611125946045,
-0.3675810694694519,
-0.5810950994491577,
-0.10083380341529846,
-0.18596340715885162,
-0.24090997874736786,
0.1618361622095108,
-0.04110085964202881,
0.057595618069171906,
-0.2754431366920471,
0.3497682511806488,
1.052289366722107,
-0.2970324158668518,
-0.15577001869678497,
-0.17590874433517456,
-0.5094941258430481,
-0.45421501994132996,
-0.21037700772285461,
0.468782514333725,
-0.5612974166870117,
-0.43152207136154175,
-0.04762549325823784,
0.33988091349601746,
0.7215948104858398,
-0.42608359456062317,
0.6929053664207458,
0.3096156418323517,
-0.32896068692207336,
0.107512466609478,
-0.49084484577178955,
0.344078928232193,
-0.4436139464378357,
0.3538861870765686,
-0.12752798199653625,
-1.1504697799682617,
-0.12718507647514343,
0.25657814741134644,
0.1876632273197174,
0.30621519684791565,
0.5875566005706787,
-0.012318799272179604,
1.1140437126159668,
0.7631568312644958,
-0.23425166308879852,
0.39019182324409485,
0.08756357431411743,
0.14039143919944763,
-0.4502990245819092,
-0.4225024878978729,
-0.44550761580467224,
0.22181379795074463,
-0.31462761759757996,
-0.2801365554332733,
0.4563121795654297,
-0.4912852346897125,
-0.5265686511993408,
0.4464529752731323,
-0.7100247144699097,
0.5860713720321655,
0.1867862492799759,
0.07017231732606888,
0.08638600260019302,
0.3113851845264435,
0.022413630038499832,
-0.20180316269397736,
-0.2891504466533661,
-0.5451470017433167,
1.0198744535446167,
0.33312633633613586,
0.9784435629844666,
0.27308541536331177,
0.5146847367286682,
0.10318999737501144,
-0.05345750227570534,
-0.3267260491847992,
0.6458680629730225,
-0.45827603340148926,
-0.5540990829467773,
-0.45725229382514954,
-0.28555652499198914,
-0.7313203811645508,
0.4649961292743683,
-0.42367106676101685,
-0.8407750725746155,
0.2016298621892929,
0.32029715180397034,
-0.4408116042613983,
-0.03956184908747673,
-0.6427996158599854,
1.1300716400146484,
-0.7118352055549622,
-0.48243939876556396,
0.053701989352703094,
-1.0372568368911743,
0.40895649790763855,
-0.1164931133389473,
0.2139800786972046,
-0.2699871361255646,
-0.08989179134368896,
0.32041025161743164,
-0.17229542136192322,
0.8809096813201904,
-0.05150319263339043,
-0.09589386731386185,
-0.04416778311133385,
-0.2202342450618744,
0.1843370646238327,
-0.2852430045604706,
0.0564325787127018,
0.38962656259536743,
0.04381859302520752,
-0.23788057267665863,
-0.2119363695383072,
0.7969478368759155,
-0.8258243799209595,
-0.42502495646476746,
-0.697239875793457,
-0.5021427273750305,
-0.2803645133972168,
0.46021050214767456,
0.28433701395988464,
0.39984309673309326,
0.02838485687971115,
0.08146928250789642,
1.1360496282577515,
-0.2469491809606552,
0.1367902308702469,
0.6202487349510193,
-0.5177604556083679,
-0.47734150290489197,
1.2301127910614014,
0.040657125413417816,
0.3940701186656952,
0.20420922338962555,
-0.25523820519447327,
-0.5874775052070618,
-0.46310150623321533,
-0.7442910075187683,
0.08967267721891403,
-0.7232378721237183,
-0.11247356235980988,
-0.6963208913803101,
-0.6007593870162964,
-0.4645523130893707,
-0.22656527161598206,
-0.4073677062988281,
-0.1367626190185547,
0.026304615661501884,
-0.15207912027835846,
0.24369098246097565,
0.5850884318351746,
0.13177037239074707,
-0.1559886932373047,
-0.9301187992095947,
0.37009572982788086,
-0.057890214025974274,
0.3717433214187622,
-0.6800825595855713,
-0.12504377961158752,
-0.07110137492418289,
-0.07556771486997604,
0.03666611388325691,
-0.6822293400764465,
0.39140698313713074,
-0.15310220420360565,
0.7380207777023315,
0.41445475816726685,
0.029481206089258194,
0.640026867389679,
-0.5041046738624573,
0.7528801560401917,
0.5389015078544617,
-0.6322168707847595,
0.48666810989379883,
-0.3177470862865448,
-0.2906413972377777,
0.47772571444511414,
0.26090729236602783,
-0.3903878629207611,
-0.20914295315742493,
-0.3756483197212219,
-0.8875827193260193,
0.4541172683238983,
0.21170887351036072,
-0.20085212588310242,
0.3093368113040924,
-0.04832979664206505,
0.3190496265888214,
0.22255852818489075,
-0.6908582448959351,
-0.20526514947414398,
-0.31369784474372864,
-0.5916886329650879,
-0.13500714302062988,
-0.27627357840538025,
-0.4689541161060333,
-0.0023184665478765965,
0.6871044039726257,
-0.23663094639778137,
-0.05213763564825058,
-0.1435794234275818,
0.10826414823532104,
-0.1287652552127838,
0.23147059977054596,
0.6680330634117126,
0.4829936921596527,
0.04313880577683449,
0.28449055552482605,
0.19570447504520416,
-0.44503384828567505,
0.28913256525993347,
0.03122815489768982,
-0.2189152091741562,
-0.264660120010376,
0.07605057954788208,
0.7240433096885681,
0.0050841099582612514,
-0.8555620908737183,
0.8258207440376282,
-0.10184349864721298,
0.07324344664812088,
-0.21626794338226318,
0.4798261821269989,
-0.21762347221374512,
0.2244037389755249,
-0.15024735033512115,
0.2731667757034302,
0.2995094358921051,
0.015608091838657856,
0.42502132058143616,
0.5218839645385742,
-0.44364291429519653,
0.1338558793067932,
0.38361984491348267,
0.07416661083698273,
0.054988693445920944,
0.39218708872795105,
0.3276548981666565,
-0.23415915668010712,
0.5046862363815308,
0.2731088697910309,
0.7012706398963928,
-0.17377980053424835,
0.2230653613805771,
0.19646072387695312,
0.38825997710227966,
-0.022791948169469833,
0.38321205973625183,
0.38055041432380676,
-0.8838649988174438,
-0.24335616827011108,
-0.8074948787689209,
-0.26126667857170105,
-0.023735228925943375,
-0.6179285645484924,
0.41210317611694336,
-0.2634113132953644,
-0.24173308908939362,
-0.11049908399581909,
-0.5226938724517822,
-0.43603888154029846,
0.35005250573158264,
0.3328445553779602,
0.8271122574806213,
-1.0721874237060547,
0.952218770980835,
0.7294636964797974,
-0.3378654420375824,
-0.5815144181251526,
-0.11693599820137024,
0.4041229486465454,
-0.9579656720161438,
0.4478338062763214,
0.23617400228977203,
-0.4364074766635895,
-0.15441133081912994,
-0.613712728023529,
-1.048944354057312,
0.9498172402381897,
0.48350369930267334,
-0.8857530355453491,
-0.11764556169509888,
0.48119619488716125,
0.48808354139328003,
-0.3794060945510864,
-0.4666145145893097,
0.33532726764678955,
0.4473814368247986,
0.25866571068763733,
-0.9720596671104431,
-0.047334909439086914,
-0.38493290543556213,
0.26425445079803467,
0.29245227575302124,
-0.6050268411636353,
0.3568614423274994,
-0.3937358558177948,
0.020246155560016632,
0.1354198008775711,
0.3777959942817688,
0.6667852401733398,
0.33640068769454956,
0.5906485319137573,
0.642986536026001,
0.3949781060218811,
-0.16689154505729675,
0.6077322959899902,
-0.21398545801639557,
0.31859055161476135,
1.0634015798568726,
-0.5341500639915466,
0.6529421806335449,
0.6252591609954834,
0.08316527307033539,
-0.09794936329126358,
0.519587516784668,
-0.04643406346440315,
0.7728918194770813,
-0.20198971033096313,
-0.2804693877696991,
-0.6648889183998108,
-0.22841759026050568,
-0.5816184282302856,
0.2379152625799179,
0.37564894556999207,
-0.26660048961639404,
-0.09917252510786057,
0.08745555579662323,
-0.29719850420951843,
-0.32412490248680115,
-0.09968642145395279,
0.7782895565032959,
-0.09604188799858093,
-0.4620022773742676,
0.2568075954914093,
-0.5146421194076538,
0.44256484508514404,
-0.5728949904441833,
-0.12027611583471298,
0.11912327259778976,
0.28790557384490967,
-0.25893348455429077,
-1.5060083866119385,
0.29534393548965454,
0.05097295343875885,
-0.02656896784901619,
0.10152962058782578,
0.7558774948120117,
-0.4274774193763733,
-0.37923967838287354,
0.3492531478404999,
0.2310546636581421,
0.07060528546571732,
0.5388008952140808,
-0.843968391418457,
0.3340549170970917,
0.028502309694886208,
-0.16273581981658936,
0.5311562418937683,
0.2896476984024048,
-0.2552511692047119,
0.7668641805648804,
0.6032707691192627,
0.021603869274258614,
0.39331692457199097,
-0.026951896026730537,
0.9623222351074219,
-0.40505075454711914,
-0.41508546471595764,
-0.7217658162117004,
1.0141998529434204,
-0.25353047251701355,
-0.43231818079948425,
0.6006729006767273,
0.6666128635406494,
0.7877460718154907,
-0.05308680236339569,
0.9094754457473755,
0.015362651087343693,
0.23659628629684448,
-0.7108321189880371,
0.5968871116638184,
-0.6150686740875244,
0.04314667731523514,
-0.475816935300827,
-0.7624008655548096,
-0.48186400532722473,
0.5044310688972473,
-0.12085364758968353,
-0.09075123071670532,
0.23055776953697205,
1.0992825031280518,
-0.08949393033981323,
-0.13292254507541656,
0.5440912842750549,
-0.049770332872867584,
0.14465489983558655,
0.5732386112213135,
0.7815665602684021,
-0.026015758514404297,
0.4751390814781189,
-0.220359668135643,
-0.4981895387172699,
-0.377801775932312,
-0.9083835482597351,
-0.5968379974365234,
-0.7713092565536499,
-0.3047122657299042,
-0.5880675315856934,
0.4754822254180908,
0.864861249923706,
0.6162692904472351,
-0.7129607796669006,
0.0018944463226944208,
0.07060670107603073,
-0.1120070070028305,
-0.14887049794197083,
-0.1577931046485901,
0.2240561544895172,
-0.054722558706998825,
-0.47056570649147034,
0.2602502107620239,
0.6561068296432495,
0.3342551589012146,
-0.12956774234771729,
-0.37586528062820435,
0.16262373328208923,
-0.1702074557542801,
0.525091290473938,
0.30344414710998535,
-0.8871596455574036,
-0.5397781729698181,
0.06264360249042511,
-0.5581526160240173,
-0.041145265102386475,
0.33640533685684204,
-0.1293414831161499,
0.49497106671333313,
0.4176277220249176,
0.5242772698402405,
0.031444109976291656,
-0.24281296133995056,
0.48835489153862,
-0.35973379015922546,
0.008728825487196445,
-0.06945157051086426,
0.7955458760261536,
0.28939947485923767,
-0.5401425957679749,
0.5483362078666687,
0.17364901304244995,
-0.489194393157959,
-0.7187886834144592,
0.35864317417144775,
-1.4554767608642578,
-0.1082863062620163,
1.3339571952819824,
-0.014525765553116798,
-0.2880791425704956,
-0.17774640023708344,
-0.7412773966789246,
0.16727519035339355,
-0.29907146096229553,
0.4854329228401184,
0.41336342692375183,
-0.10024022310972214,
-0.3357251286506653,
-0.08822129666805267,
0.3891518712043762,
0.20291832089424133,
-0.7042087912559509,
0.3578794300556183,
0.9235506057739258,
0.6816205978393555,
0.11521264165639877,
0.45939335227012634,
-0.46429070830345154,
0.4574039876461029,
-0.2939743399620056,
0.29635322093963623,
-0.06134720891714096,
-0.763428807258606,
-0.5112366676330566,
0.26538389921188354,
0.07443682849407196,
-0.34153831005096436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12023v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12023v1 | LiLiuM: eBay's Large Language Models for e-commerce | 2024-06-17T18:45:41 | 2024-06-17T18:45:41 | Christian Herold, Michael Kozielski, Leonid Ekimov, Pavel Petrushkov, Pierre-Yves Vandenbussche, Shahram Khadivi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We introduce the LiLiuM series of large language models (LLMs): 1B, 7B, and
13B parameter models developed 100% in-house to fit eBay's specific needs in
the e-commerce domain. This gives eBay full control over all aspects of the
models including license, data, vocabulary, and architecture. We expect these
models to be used as a foundation for fine-tuning and instruction-tuning,
eliminating dependencies to external models.
The LiLiuM LLMs have been trained on 3 trillion tokens of multilingual text
from general and e-commerce domain. They perform similar to the popular LLaMA-2
models on English natural language understanding (NLU) benchmarks. At the same
time, we outperform LLaMA-2 on non-English NLU tasks, machine translation and
on e-commerce specific downstream tasks.
As part of our data mixture, we utilize the newly released RedPajama-V2
dataset for training and share our insights regarding data filtering and
deduplication. We also discuss in detail how to serialize structured data for
use in autoregressive language modeling. We provide insights on the effects of
including code and parallel machine translation data in pre-training.
Furthermore, we develop our own tokenizer and model vocabulary, customized
towards e-commerce. This way, we can achieve up to 34% speed-up in text
generation on eBay-specific downstream tasks compared to LLaMA-2.
Finally, in relation to LLM pretraining, we show that checkpoint averaging
can further improve over the best individual model checkpoint. | [
-0.2046585977077484,
-0.7289929389953613,
0.2584225535392761,
0.16439515352249146,
-0.4157934784889221,
0.04877544566988945,
-0.18973951041698456,
-0.9999362230300903,
0.32707107067108154,
0.4043014645576477,
-0.6823720932006836,
-0.3455865979194641,
-0.3148139715194702,
0.2707006633281708,
-0.651078462600708,
1.0802611112594604,
0.12717270851135254,
0.013331948779523373,
0.08383111655712128,
-0.031056921929121017,
-0.08347688615322113,
-0.4822264015674591,
-0.7471367716789246,
0.004564679693430662,
0.6802090406417847,
0.4122632145881653,
0.561555027961731,
0.8284180164337158,
0.5139553546905518,
0.31025469303131104,
0.18162940442562103,
0.14527766406536102,
-0.6896100640296936,
0.2924555838108063,
-0.06819886714220047,
-0.7392701506614685,
-0.7947118282318115,
-0.31612926721572876,
0.22910337150096893,
0.4873945116996765,
-0.4694455564022064,
0.3676248788833618,
-0.1642882376909256,
0.5370657444000244,
-0.5279174447059631,
0.01886827126145363,
-0.5883342027664185,
-0.06965760886669159,
-0.12277712672948837,
-0.061606790870428085,
-0.3898543119430542,
-0.23580218851566315,
-0.05570419505238533,
-0.9121394753456116,
0.15407401323318481,
0.36528685688972473,
1.0559368133544922,
0.11306358128786087,
-0.3897642195224762,
-0.3928391635417938,
-0.8843259811401367,
1.1429376602172852,
-0.612875759601593,
0.5324140191078186,
0.35780179500579834,
0.09081382304430008,
-0.13383933901786804,
-1.070244550704956,
-0.44759413599967957,
-0.1140458732843399,
-0.10005248337984085,
0.35465767979621887,
-0.260792076587677,
0.04338096082210541,
0.20069767534732819,
0.48298001289367676,
-0.6871521472930908,
0.27010512351989746,
-0.40819740295410156,
0.12015525996685028,
0.5909091830253601,
0.3998025953769684,
0.42597395181655884,
0.1251867413520813,
-0.29483404755592346,
0.06051855906844139,
-0.8684297800064087,
-0.2014438807964325,
0.43205752968788147,
0.34361156821250916,
-0.09542106837034225,
0.16414424777030945,
-0.577541708946228,
0.8248483538627625,
-0.11921406537294388,
-0.5931172370910645,
0.02837374247610569,
-0.41352370381355286,
-0.4022228717803955,
-0.15787969529628754,
0.5210615396499634,
0.2502893805503845,
-0.09353375434875488,
-0.07597561180591583,
-0.37035277485847473,
-0.11609861254692078,
0.03483966737985611,
-0.8830091953277588,
-0.2475210726261139,
0.4154268801212311,
-0.6774383187294006,
-0.053282465785741806,
-0.007426416035741568,
-0.5706552267074585,
-0.04549068212509155,
-0.5911961793899536,
0.45344364643096924,
0.20087428390979767,
-0.2505551278591156,
0.28023508191108704,
0.02759704180061817,
0.17845873534679413,
0.3605359196662903,
-1.0676100254058838,
0.5990700125694275,
0.7452697157859802,
0.6904821991920471,
0.045383960008621216,
-0.31473004817962646,
-0.45231178402900696,
0.49005407094955444,
-0.19483502209186554,
0.6277062296867371,
-0.2264566719532013,
-0.08557476848363876,
0.17262758314609528,
0.14793264865875244,
0.2940675616264343,
-0.6533167958259583,
0.5037500262260437,
-0.8205314874649048,
-0.01815176010131836,
-0.13797275722026825,
-0.5901405215263367,
-0.24431990087032318,
0.47600576281547546,
-0.7487647533416748,
0.5850314497947693,
0.01760712079703808,
-0.39642709493637085,
0.3339150547981262,
-0.21685265004634857,
-0.5051507949829102,
0.21607175469398499,
-0.013418253511190414,
-0.42781785130500793,
0.07847230136394501,
0.1655173897743225,
0.3880263566970825,
-0.5922454595565796,
-0.20885547995567322,
-0.3377966284751892,
-0.4648842513561249,
0.05160977691411972,
-0.2181178480386734,
0.8375204801559448,
0.2992803156375885,
-0.2918533384799957,
-0.12474194169044495,
-0.6266156435012817,
-0.21342749893665314,
0.25637537240982056,
-0.24280905723571777,
-0.31473296880722046,
-0.05044889822602272,
0.38277751207351685,
0.07776934653520584,
0.5290005803108215,
-0.3743060827255249,
0.23107214272022247,
-0.4037777781486511,
0.4136367738246918,
0.6617106795310974,
-0.29015815258026123,
0.13673236966133118,
-0.3972754180431366,
0.8679521083831787,
-0.061148326843976974,
0.48647499084472656,
-0.3909456133842468,
-0.6080019474029541,
-1.1319702863693237,
-0.30984702706336975,
0.29556626081466675,
0.6050370931625366,
-0.36379915475845337,
0.1597961038351059,
-0.2656930983066559,
-0.44951093196868896,
-0.4493739604949951,
0.4033287465572357,
0.09065555036067963,
0.032312676310539246,
0.19251784682273865,
-0.3264928460121155,
-0.37070679664611816,
-1.1276406049728394,
-0.15130743384361267,
-0.3637816309928894,
0.08123672008514404,
0.2202763706445694,
0.21356602013111115,
-0.47847485542297363,
0.6005478501319885,
-0.4625915288925171,
-0.393916517496109,
-0.5072146058082581,
0.1782110184431076,
0.4909559190273285,
0.1596505045890808,
0.383284330368042,
-0.6435956358909607,
-0.565176248550415,
0.1981387883424759,
-0.4175667464733124,
-0.15842875838279724,
-0.24342328310012817,
-0.19909021258354187,
0.36109593510627747,
0.45911821722984314,
-0.7336022257804871,
0.26882052421569824,
0.5422233939170837,
0.06718054413795471,
0.24275566637516022,
-0.4025253355503082,
0.22785671055316925,
-1.2298150062561035,
-0.2915340065956116,
0.1321772038936615,
-0.34221023321151733,
-0.6023604273796082,
0.3304719626903534,
0.24055112898349762,
0.1642056107521057,
-0.5299522280693054,
0.255939245223999,
-0.5356777310371399,
-0.33348771929740906,
-0.2688131630420685,
0.41494569182395935,
0.30037233233451843,
0.18545494973659515,
-0.12305045872926712,
0.672370970249176,
0.17474141716957092,
-0.9537935256958008,
0.6557377576828003,
0.1910388320684433,
-0.579791784286499,
0.34677571058273315,
-0.7615531086921692,
-0.03683539852499962,
-0.004770440515130758,
0.07824820280075073,
-0.7573627829551697,
-0.08521164208650589,
0.13330580294132233,
-0.23873384296894073,
0.4320905804634094,
-0.19018039107322693,
-0.831778347492218,
-0.36275383830070496,
-0.1539393812417984,
0.24149808287620544,
0.5671017169952393,
-0.7025155425071716,
0.4814974367618561,
0.3958892822265625,
-0.30952903628349304,
-0.5331326723098755,
-0.8318698406219482,
0.13306647539138794,
-0.42426082491874695,
-0.48876452445983887,
0.516659140586853,
-0.3534375727176666,
-0.2729963958263397,
-0.22522014379501343,
0.48063182830810547,
-0.012209373526275158,
0.4999578893184662,
-0.22671949863433838,
0.26965710520744324,
-0.1861354559659958,
0.3018445372581482,
0.08087344467639923,
-0.20895956456661224,
0.06651651114225388,
-0.2829284369945526,
0.4399905800819397,
0.2937173545360565,
-0.3235061466693878,
-0.6661246418952942,
0.1016051322221756,
0.3391631245613098,
-0.018334774300456047,
0.8495237231254578,
0.4188017249107361,
-0.3769271671772003,
-0.4657452702522278,
-0.35512784123420715,
-0.339870423078537,
-0.49891623854637146,
0.6017277836799622,
-0.42413848638534546,
-0.8095911741256714,
0.4154834747314453,
0.17141814529895782,
0.3065776526927948,
0.30255579948425293,
0.8487430810928345,
-0.0875840038061142,
1.1305713653564453,
0.9595344066619873,
-0.4876480996608734,
0.4033145010471344,
-0.022119194269180298,
0.6225174069404602,
-0.4468984305858612,
-0.061701513826847076,
-0.5330211520195007,
-0.36292484402656555,
-0.6994076371192932,
-0.235664501786232,
-0.029283545911312103,
0.31891998648643494,
-0.3436260223388672,
0.3359053432941437,
-0.06883852928876877,
0.5617392659187317,
0.5429181456565857,
-0.09395130723714828,
0.5910694599151611,
0.39090681076049805,
0.48931074142456055,
-0.008706006221473217,
-0.5977411270141602,
-0.49463987350463867,
1.2640029191970825,
0.31397441029548645,
0.9277489185333252,
0.5036969780921936,
0.480175256729126,
0.24681535363197327,
0.4257480204105377,
-0.9592093229293823,
0.39617928862571716,
-0.25880298018455505,
-0.6488430500030518,
0.08705511689186096,
-0.32225626707077026,
-0.8893994092941284,
0.12037349492311478,
0.2123582363128662,
-0.5373238921165466,
-0.1480235904455185,
-0.02487826719880104,
-0.5936079025268555,
0.32396912574768066,
-0.4139138460159302,
0.6370492577552795,
-0.518155038356781,
-0.46879586577415466,
-0.4491131901741028,
-0.15344256162643433,
0.38482773303985596,
-0.2057771235704422,
0.2843165397644043,
-0.006146972067654133,
-0.49411582946777344,
0.6477338075637817,
-0.3111860454082489,
0.6927042007446289,
0.3161391317844391,
-0.34491926431655884,
0.06702874600887299,
0.08938352018594742,
0.5893951654434204,
0.014482975006103516,
0.194099560379982,
0.1539856493473053,
-0.09488929808139801,
-0.42330071330070496,
-0.4262153208255768,
0.8347977995872498,
-0.9553553462028503,
-0.6605653762817383,
-0.29195502400398254,
-0.3129737675189972,
-0.10056408494710922,
-0.044539935886859894,
0.1268967092037201,
0.25335493683815,
-0.14772151410579681,
0.18737353384494781,
0.6461236476898193,
-0.36190012097358704,
0.44110107421875,
0.8199567198753357,
-0.5114355087280273,
-0.2979789972305298,
1.0286332368850708,
0.03393470495939255,
0.30708184838294983,
0.5977029800415039,
0.060540515929460526,
-0.22655388712882996,
-0.5694779753684998,
-0.7015758156776428,
0.4600263833999634,
-0.7877827882766724,
-0.2494344860315323,
-0.7090137600898743,
0.02398028038442135,
-0.37696361541748047,
0.14026081562042236,
-0.21822874248027802,
-0.5241239070892334,
-0.5848168134689331,
-0.24004359543323517,
0.4412074387073517,
1.1308073997497559,
0.008091015741229057,
0.5559883713722229,
-1.1330571174621582,
0.288309246301651,
0.5173704624176025,
0.128670334815979,
0.015000248327851295,
-0.8465062975883484,
-0.7996418476104736,
-0.020168187096714973,
-0.23329216241836548,
-0.578740656375885,
0.5762560367584229,
0.19050036370754242,
0.485668420791626,
0.8054666519165039,
-0.22507956624031067,
0.7619582414627075,
-0.3688311278820038,
0.9097514748573303,
0.11762513220310211,
-0.828666627407074,
0.42725813388824463,
-0.5376438498497009,
-0.0837554857134819,
0.2641615867614746,
0.6318644285202026,
-0.6183438897132874,
-0.2838227450847626,
-0.3750668466091156,
-0.9717555642127991,
0.7755785584449768,
0.011947901919484138,
0.30728593468666077,
-0.12668371200561523,
0.2905224859714508,
0.16130425035953522,
0.42927077412605286,
-0.8285254836082458,
-0.4582101106643677,
0.3343636393547058,
-0.42470937967300415,
-0.18897274136543274,
-0.4664321839809418,
0.0075326887890696526,
-0.21372896432876587,
0.9189282059669495,
0.05507521703839302,
0.03132924810051918,
-0.26964297890663147,
-0.38640081882476807,
-0.257705420255661,
0.03385468199849129,
0.6221185326576233,
0.89127516746521,
-0.044703878462314606,
-0.4477161467075348,
-0.05054398998618126,
-0.5202438235282898,
0.06022867187857628,
0.038627274334430695,
-0.28250738978385925,
-0.09012138843536377,
0.1753700226545334,
0.4131644666194916,
-0.031740572303533554,
-0.8799522519111633,
0.35437095165252686,
-0.23541861772537231,
0.05492054298520088,
-0.5781639814376831,
-0.08677993714809418,
0.1621006578207016,
0.32481566071510315,
0.19751933217048645,
-0.6216976046562195,
0.4290566146373749,
-0.5714074373245239,
0.128723606467247,
0.1955556422472,
0.05948841944336891,
-0.3683754503726959,
0.6416782736778259,
0.19340232014656067,
-0.0386902391910553,
0.7455385327339172,
-0.2970923185348511,
-0.502444863319397,
0.7828766107559204,
0.6665551066398621,
0.8088294267654419,
-0.2663155794143677,
0.1776159107685089,
0.4761742055416107,
0.6852474212646484,
-0.2049175500869751,
0.34573376178741455,
0.11240324378013611,
-0.7730329036712646,
-0.33908286690711975,
-0.8125081062316895,
-0.6141022443771362,
0.24163083732128143,
-0.6954187154769897,
0.3397006094455719,
-0.5274510979652405,
-0.12567292153835297,
-0.4642448127269745,
0.1868199110031128,
-0.630886435508728,
0.29886969923973083,
0.28364962339401245,
0.591810405254364,
-0.752155601978302,
0.8757408857345581,
0.5667504072189331,
-0.47886380553245544,
-0.6165582537651062,
-0.2203248292207718,
-0.06644049286842346,
-0.5065442323684692,
0.9059367775917053,
0.18103662133216858,
-0.059038855135440826,
0.03782297298312187,
-0.18127714097499847,
-1.0571074485778809,
1.2116864919662476,
0.1293042004108429,
-1.1449791193008423,
0.37845632433891296,
0.26284098625183105,
0.30424901843070984,
-0.40597400069236755,
0.4867713749408722,
0.8373276591300964,
0.13222163915634155,
-0.36946895718574524,
-0.6216415166854858,
-0.3295491635799408,
-0.1391218602657318,
-0.0008731083362363279,
0.3536236882209778,
-0.9194739460945129,
1.1440250873565674,
0.039653655141592026,
-0.1439894139766693,
0.5078360438346863,
0.6390650272369385,
0.3358587920665741,
0.12061341106891632,
0.36327922344207764,
0.9942713379859924,
0.9576642513275146,
-0.02259116619825363,
1.1104629039764404,
-0.5800723433494568,
0.28442102670669556,
1.1543340682983398,
-0.41034042835235596,
1.1295206546783447,
0.20599958300590515,
-0.43273991346359253,
0.7240849733352661,
0.822353720664978,
0.15368534624576569,
0.3090292811393738,
0.17001499235630035,
-0.36249834299087524,
-0.17785707116127014,
-0.20368406176567078,
-0.272310346364975,
0.10149504989385605,
0.5014061331748962,
-0.3627883791923523,
0.20301662385463715,
-0.10311997681856155,
-0.07963891327381134,
-0.25737547874450684,
-0.4728793799877167,
0.6027325987815857,
0.18984371423721313,
-0.09283406287431717,
0.24179504811763763,
0.3337387144565582,
0.6586048603057861,
-0.6115352511405945,
0.1962345838546753,
-0.5856126546859741,
0.3638119399547577,
-0.10439179837703705,
-0.0603681318461895,
-0.10799668729305267,
-0.06766993552446365,
-0.165774866938591,
-0.18009230494499207,
0.5403009057044983,
-0.45125240087509155,
-0.7247754335403442,
0.511698305606842,
0.5023742914199829,
0.14401209354400635,
0.17181232571601868,
-0.8714385628700256,
0.24188223481178284,
-0.04338355362415314,
-0.498432457447052,
0.4343656003475189,
0.38134118914604187,
0.26441702246665955,
0.6658148765563965,
0.5381156802177429,
0.26103585958480835,
0.15824557840824127,
0.409239798784256,
0.5408779382705688,
-0.862252950668335,
-0.6649774312973022,
-0.6266279220581055,
0.35647472739219666,
-0.13396748900413513,
-0.18682096898555756,
0.9416616559028625,
0.6100521683692932,
1.1965644359588623,
-0.021990597248077393,
0.7087661027908325,
0.431321918964386,
0.5089591145515442,
-0.4684973359107971,
0.703551173210144,
-1.0154883861541748,
0.34514689445495605,
0.04202042892575264,
-1.1807544231414795,
-0.14452306926250458,
0.6178262829780579,
0.10235586017370224,
0.1755824089050293,
0.6524685621261597,
0.9118403196334839,
-0.04507507011294365,
0.11930970847606659,
0.6007114052772522,
0.44571158289909363,
0.25958535075187683,
0.6497894525527954,
0.9707596302032471,
-0.7867398858070374,
0.5596400499343872,
-0.3536875545978546,
-0.08093427866697311,
-0.4222044050693512,
-0.6215165853500366,
-0.7194997668266296,
-0.18335150182247162,
-0.6103940606117249,
-0.04234747961163521,
-0.1733805388212204,
1.042040228843689,
0.5313779711723328,
-0.7157479524612427,
-0.7824439406394958,
0.0561428964138031,
-0.13183096051216125,
-0.09842390567064285,
-0.11358077824115753,
0.08516470342874527,
-0.44858431816101074,
-1.094722032546997,
0.39752236008644104,
0.5616223216056824,
0.26242658495903015,
-0.49133041501045227,
-0.0962512344121933,
0.025727495551109314,
0.1625429093837738,
0.7739371061325073,
0.01782277226448059,
-0.7068129777908325,
0.2524465024471283,
-0.04251858964562416,
-0.09705164283514023,
-0.140201598405838,
0.7647726535797119,
-0.5993812084197998,
0.23305721580982208,
0.4682903289794922,
0.6284887790679932,
0.3677990138530731,
-0.2393471747636795,
0.5321462154388428,
-0.09507215023040771,
0.44880953431129456,
0.01864037662744522,
0.5465096831321716,
0.26535481214523315,
-0.1366661638021469,
0.2567639648914337,
0.1506625860929489,
-0.5602332353591919,
-0.6230728626251221,
0.36695805191993713,
-0.5872626304626465,
-0.42815670371055603,
0.9600032567977905,
-0.19049549102783203,
-0.48131415247917175,
-0.27908843755722046,
0.20881468057632446,
0.07720538228750229,
-0.10811708867549896,
0.7618103623390198,
0.56230628490448,
0.35535886883735657,
-0.32691100239753723,
-0.7847410440444946,
0.29714420437812805,
0.4869644045829773,
-0.9120877981185913,
-0.1364806592464447,
0.6173529028892517,
0.12135689705610275,
-0.18772301077842712,
0.6089563369750977,
0.25152039527893066,
0.24831196665763855,
-0.21699394285678864,
-0.010733905248343945,
0.29895180463790894,
-0.6293081045150757,
-0.3318498730659485,
0.06049610301852226,
0.42758214473724365,
0.04888441786170006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12018v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12018v1 | CItruS: Chunked Instruction-aware State Eviction for Long Sequence Modeling | 2024-06-17T18:34:58 | 2024-06-17T18:34:58 | Yu Bai, Xiyuan Zou, Heyan Huang, Sanxing Chen, Marc-Antoine Rondeau, Yang Gao, Jackie Chi Kit Cheung | cs.CL | cs.CL | Long sequence modeling has gained broad interest as large language models
(LLMs) continue to advance. Recent research has identified that a large portion
of hidden states within the key-value caches of Transformer models can be
discarded (also termed evicted) without affecting the perplexity performance in
generating long sequences. However, we show that these methods, despite
preserving perplexity performance, often drop information that is important for
solving downstream tasks, a problem which we call information neglect. To
address this issue, we introduce Chunked Instruction-aware State Eviction
(CItruS), a novel modeling technique that integrates the attention preferences
useful for a downstream task into the eviction process of hidden states. In
addition, we design a method for chunked sequence processing to further improve
efficiency. Our training-free method exhibits superior performance on long
sequence comprehension and retrieval tasks over several strong baselines under
the same memory budget, while preserving language modeling perplexity. | [
-0.04480581730604172,
-0.5999765992164612,
0.610679566860199,
0.28476959466934204,
-0.22400282323360443,
0.10990079492330551,
-0.2545135021209717,
-0.2821234166622162,
0.28679174184799194,
0.5551151633262634,
-0.4018620252609253,
-0.1664346605539322,
-0.5642663240432739,
-0.09044913947582245,
-0.8300830125808716,
0.7968657612800598,
-0.0044054677709937096,
-0.5555854439735413,
-0.0945681482553482,
0.36538439989089966,
-0.43191662430763245,
-0.23633569478988647,
-0.4514254927635193,
-0.06564656645059586,
0.44957807660102844,
0.5857785940170288,
0.5706604719161987,
0.9000077247619629,
0.24609781801700592,
0.237521231174469,
-0.484961599111557,
-0.17820779979228973,
-0.7597545385360718,
0.2390594482421875,
-0.273214191198349,
-0.5666605234146118,
-0.2932899296283722,
-0.22956880927085876,
0.7152070999145508,
0.2973668873310089,
-0.1796794831752777,
0.11023083329200745,
-0.03526930883526802,
0.809928834438324,
-1.015868067741394,
0.06618822365999222,
-0.7418011426925659,
0.2860885262489319,
-0.2563391625881195,
-0.17749850451946259,
-0.5469004511833191,
-0.28906363248825073,
0.10128345340490341,
-0.3763911724090576,
0.5818327069282532,
-0.050816453993320465,
0.8435030579566956,
0.3879353702068329,
-0.19794870913028717,
-0.028435708954930305,
-0.8378481268882751,
0.675825297832489,
-0.30317652225494385,
0.17278732359409332,
0.24422812461853027,
0.22028471529483795,
-0.13604001700878143,
-0.5204769372940063,
-0.4306837022304535,
-0.12598933279514313,
0.18039846420288086,
0.16275204718112946,
-0.3123602569103241,
0.2568647861480713,
0.32682400941848755,
0.5779126882553101,
-0.25869396328926086,
0.056715235114097595,
-0.455812931060791,
-0.09165283292531967,
0.4121493399143219,
0.07547309994697571,
0.09221756458282471,
-0.277528315782547,
-0.745951771736145,
0.09274612367153168,
-1.1460492610931396,
0.1832655966281891,
0.2610207498073578,
0.23554731905460358,
0.2736111879348755,
0.6286841034889221,
-0.23182456195354462,
0.2011067122220993,
0.2580929100513458,
0.31807324290275574,
0.05990923196077347,
0.1040574237704277,
-0.3106454014778137,
0.4364538788795471,
0.6923058032989502,
-0.1108986958861351,
-0.03487195074558258,
-0.1108105406165123,
-0.504437267780304,
-0.2925460636615753,
0.47074005007743835,
-0.7378133535385132,
-0.2678171992301941,
0.5554814338684082,
-0.34819814562797546,
-0.07152827084064484,
-0.03871989995241165,
-0.7000439763069153,
-0.5689632892608643,
-0.06044843792915344,
0.10838542878627777,
-0.6161594390869141,
-0.5063870549201965,
-0.20077162981033325,
-0.3555671274662018,
0.3514217734336853,
0.5466292500495911,
-0.8514124155044556,
0.3406809866428375,
0.8737560510635376,
0.6085333228111267,
-0.38694295287132263,
0.05376482754945755,
-0.578075110912323,
0.06259690225124359,
-0.35132303833961487,
0.34651702642440796,
-0.6282872557640076,
-0.2584206163883209,
-0.1458720862865448,
-0.10006708651781082,
-0.25676777958869934,
-0.946765124797821,
0.05762586370110512,
-0.8112538456916809,
-0.44297343492507935,
-0.15959897637367249,
-0.6536955833435059,
-0.27874645590782166,
0.28256872296333313,
-0.9840081930160522,
1.2420105934143066,
0.12121345847845078,
-0.6455749273300171,
0.011806616559624672,
-0.7111554741859436,
-0.4034072756767273,
0.133993461728096,
-0.011962233111262321,
-0.4423496723175049,
0.46488896012306213,
0.07649901509284973,
0.4012739360332489,
-0.002424304373562336,
0.4506640136241913,
0.014807208441197872,
-0.46831801533699036,
0.0018972193356603384,
-0.6443802118301392,
0.4014253616333008,
0.3996337354183197,
-0.4879513084888458,
0.3551570177078247,
-0.6399943232536316,
-0.36894699931144714,
0.24051760137081146,
-0.37592098116874695,
-0.3929304778575897,
0.29827314615249634,
-0.10640625655651093,
0.18590065836906433,
0.4143242835998535,
-0.6942766904830933,
0.04474969208240509,
-0.23684479296207428,
0.24715125560760498,
0.8219606876373291,
-0.1543716937303543,
0.3483315706253052,
-0.13810648024082184,
0.8193442225456238,
0.6686107516288757,
-0.07623644173145294,
-0.41306835412979126,
-0.21475417912006378,
-1.0041399002075195,
-0.48563867807388306,
0.1697794497013092,
0.722681999206543,
-0.6690292954444885,
0.2955382168292999,
-0.4622494578361511,
-0.08974132686853409,
-0.3188137710094452,
-0.09670715779066086,
0.5194703936576843,
0.14752249419689178,
0.3746238946914673,
-0.30908605456352234,
-0.18856443464756012,
-0.8126299381256104,
-0.4063972532749176,
0.34770527482032776,
0.2231580913066864,
0.1269005835056305,
0.4295733571052551,
0.16887855529785156,
1.1239463090896606,
-0.4380064010620117,
-0.022175023332238197,
-0.6300714015960693,
0.017576701939105988,
0.11808738112449646,
0.5523801445960999,
0.111629419028759,
-0.7396782636642456,
-0.22148996591567993,
-0.14318019151687622,
-0.19501741230487823,
0.359165757894516,
-0.18618418276309967,
0.013029218651354313,
0.12383849173784256,
0.4563489258289337,
-0.5910534858703613,
1.0038201808929443,
0.17679771780967712,
-0.20107366144657135,
0.7482545971870422,
-0.06194501370191574,
-0.19075852632522583,
-0.9915988445281982,
0.06002010032534599,
-0.05798951908946037,
-0.6632376909255981,
-0.5749743580818176,
0.11576581001281738,
0.4275914132595062,
-0.11761019378900528,
-0.7458949685096741,
0.3833096921443939,
-0.7229299545288086,
-0.07544075697660446,
-0.2976379096508026,
-0.14505723118782043,
-0.2777135968208313,
0.3255283534526825,
0.3738979697227478,
0.777409017086029,
0.3011837303638458,
-0.7421553730964661,
0.1411142498254776,
-0.06336122751235962,
-0.23816131055355072,
0.1511799693107605,
-0.3057084381580353,
0.10926169157028198,
-0.38929399847984314,
0.033565640449523926,
-1.007229208946228,
-0.13018687069416046,
0.07871615886688232,
-0.059577178210020065,
0.6241154074668884,
-0.248390793800354,
-0.3066897988319397,
-0.42430010437965393,
-0.28537073731422424,
0.5260174870491028,
0.3965836763381958,
-0.5963518619537354,
0.48917287588119507,
0.26371777057647705,
-0.3579867482185364,
-0.6416826844215393,
-0.3207896053791046,
-0.09761243313550949,
-0.26904910802841187,
-0.08097030222415924,
0.335981160402298,
0.33173754811286926,
0.1687830537557602,
0.0895417258143425,
-0.38864338397979736,
-0.37000590562820435,
0.19250498712062836,
0.2603355050086975,
0.025848712772130966,
-0.2899881601333618,
0.4366838335990906,
0.3506201505661011,
-0.0007871479028835893,
0.184993714094162,
-0.23542504012584686,
0.6315541863441467,
0.026537682861089706,
-0.3668861985206604,
-0.3856872320175171,
0.4893589913845062,
0.5587469935417175,
-0.4790118336677551,
0.728161096572876,
0.4001159071922302,
-0.4001811444759369,
-0.17109861969947815,
-0.5835753679275513,
0.003198052989318967,
-0.4544065594673157,
0.6994210481643677,
-0.30461421608924866,
-1.0130014419555664,
0.30205991864204407,
-0.37230631709098816,
0.13286180794239044,
0.37737563252449036,
0.12565210461616516,
0.009561660699546337,
0.6106045842170715,
0.7993972897529602,
-0.43149805068969727,
0.7889171838760376,
-0.3850201666355133,
0.23659835755825043,
-1.1036890745162964,
-0.020094197243452072,
-0.4386891722679138,
-0.44586247205734253,
-0.2344687581062317,
-0.6609944701194763,
0.30452287197113037,
-0.06554543226957321,
-0.3826533854007721,
0.20060224831104279,
-0.44701406359672546,
0.8502649068832397,
0.5924477577209473,
0.2479919195175171,
0.029664671048521996,
-0.11597126722335815,
-0.11779304593801498,
0.16673769056797028,
-0.6870672106742859,
-0.2583065629005432,
0.8621786236763,
0.279356986284256,
0.8149386048316956,
-0.13766586780548096,
1.0880475044250488,
0.21680767834186554,
0.10708276182413101,
-0.9335536956787109,
0.48289889097213745,
-0.105336494743824,
-0.4476766586303711,
-0.4660429358482361,
-0.5226722955703735,
-1.0714702606201172,
0.27045583724975586,
0.3587743937969208,
-1.1505979299545288,
0.0787559375166893,
0.4733712673187256,
-0.6476700901985168,
0.5721356272697449,
-0.31280001997947693,
0.9509992003440857,
-0.15527990460395813,
-0.28787538409233093,
-0.5195510387420654,
-0.7848964333534241,
0.5751280188560486,
0.20027701556682587,
-0.0311298668384552,
-0.2674603760242462,
0.17836537957191467,
0.7674890756607056,
-0.6083214282989502,
0.808176577091217,
-0.2898038327693939,
-0.01495183352380991,
0.4372495710849762,
0.3726414740085602,
0.8303189277648926,
-0.297625869512558,
0.04132097586989403,
-0.2580656409263611,
-0.11520606279373169,
-0.25592440366744995,
-0.2769428491592407,
0.4938165545463562,
-0.5533570647239685,
-0.7396625876426697,
-0.5084127187728882,
-0.6487065553665161,
0.07553253322839737,
0.22503839433193207,
0.2434837371110916,
0.21274599432945251,
-0.10518978536128998,
0.05666256323456764,
1.216036081314087,
-0.316299170255661,
0.7635842561721802,
0.09841181337833405,
-0.21177202463150024,
-0.10131945461034775,
1.057345986366272,
-0.1804073601961136,
0.3398617208003998,
0.7836425304412842,
0.33663851022720337,
-0.36436671018600464,
-0.39469119906425476,
-0.16723470389842987,
0.046277739107608795,
-0.4621680676937103,
-0.19040369987487793,
-0.5779599547386169,
-0.46806809306144714,
-0.13303658366203308,
0.15976549685001373,
-0.9437547922134399,
-0.5025445222854614,
-0.6016682386398315,
-0.18259930610656738,
0.24686995148658752,
0.8628379106521606,
0.25726956129074097,
0.3137785494327545,
-0.9515299201011658,
0.5095833539962769,
0.09093451499938965,
0.2742765545845032,
0.22132928669452667,
-0.462592214345932,
-0.2744657099246979,
-0.0013454435393214226,
-0.6089701652526855,
-1.0097277164459229,
0.45138606429100037,
0.07898598164319992,
0.35468098521232605,
0.6365278959274292,
0.284575492143631,
0.8181319236755371,
-0.47529032826423645,
0.7814126014709473,
0.150004044175148,
-1.1456451416015625,
0.6410377025604248,
-0.10410382598638535,
0.5464609861373901,
0.2728462517261505,
0.3025721311569214,
-0.5163750648498535,
-0.5234766006469727,
-0.47214919328689575,
-1.3533821105957031,
0.8060622811317444,
-0.05740085989236832,
0.049374617636203766,
-0.2119651734828949,
-0.01930265501141548,
-0.05445040017366409,
0.3820408284664154,
-0.5572201013565063,
-0.015282493084669113,
-0.11085014045238495,
-0.26285266876220703,
0.2666042745113373,
-0.5350997447967529,
0.1380729079246521,
-0.25474780797958374,
0.6030274033546448,
0.08334242552518845,
0.5561017990112305,
0.20320525765419006,
-0.5117656588554382,
0.09558218717575073,
0.581721305847168,
0.5416275858879089,
0.28384748101234436,
0.11203716695308685,
0.05704418569803238,
-0.16081559658050537,
-0.5918715596199036,
0.26749056577682495,
-0.05553083494305611,
-0.20249424874782562,
-0.288862019777298,
-0.1839325875043869,
0.7936902642250061,
0.37102010846138,
-0.5491640567779541,
0.5946518182754517,
0.10278800874948502,
0.06389135122299194,
-0.4162159562110901,
0.10361960530281067,
0.02199467457830906,
0.09429462999105453,
0.37687763571739197,
0.024277862161397934,
0.25129571557044983,
-0.18552644550800323,
0.056391775608062744,
0.28429582715034485,
-0.6747007369995117,
-0.2048230916261673,
0.6819164752960205,
0.12885862588882446,
0.1090376228094101,
1.2040587663650513,
-0.35381799936294556,
-0.835288405418396,
0.9753738045692444,
0.7038748860359192,
1.100986361503601,
-0.2630266547203064,
0.030507327988743782,
0.15390925109386444,
0.31447160243988037,
-0.10891959816217422,
0.46953266859054565,
-0.3480384945869446,
-0.48042163252830505,
-0.33265140652656555,
-0.5070928931236267,
-0.17133013904094696,
0.218913272023201,
-0.7424597144126892,
-0.177344411611557,
-0.41002157330513,
-0.009247932583093643,
-0.5363755822181702,
-0.40673860907554626,
-0.627387285232544,
0.09655915200710297,
0.4308701157569885,
1.1371887922286987,
-0.7778145670890808,
0.8165479302406311,
0.4617844820022583,
0.061050064861774445,
-1.0245786905288696,
0.18987353146076202,
0.17148107290267944,
-0.3706786036491394,
0.5429018139839172,
0.5905358791351318,
-0.14425703883171082,
-0.05547395348548889,
-0.39722689986228943,
-1.1414490938186646,
0.8137580156326294,
0.2791038155555725,
-0.7033442258834839,
0.07655087858438492,
0.11355984956026077,
0.10434530675411224,
0.06584342569112778,
0.29705366492271423,
0.844799280166626,
0.2117372304201126,
0.26404428482055664,
-0.8578529953956604,
0.14962267875671387,
-0.1922416090965271,
0.2689482271671295,
0.4712833762168884,
-0.7487112283706665,
0.8938683271408081,
-0.44332340359687805,
-0.2902914583683014,
0.23272931575775146,
1.0524379014968872,
0.03428538888692856,
0.050054363906383514,
0.5088140964508057,
0.6780418753623962,
0.9562349319458008,
-0.1850309818983078,
0.8055469393730164,
-0.24486954510211945,
0.18815597891807556,
1.2642219066619873,
-0.419675350189209,
1.0583078861236572,
0.4144284427165985,
-0.17935806512832642,
0.3070153295993805,
0.4825851023197174,
0.49560990929603577,
0.5377714037895203,
0.5196322798728943,
-0.3921261429786682,
-0.19890104234218597,
0.18603253364562988,
-0.015284753404557705,
0.46813511848449707,
0.6791159510612488,
-0.3920401334762573,
-0.21881897747516632,
-0.12704268097877502,
0.20255599915981293,
-0.188215434551239,
-0.6322202086448669,
0.7400116920471191,
-0.12140834331512451,
-0.9369866847991943,
0.4961458146572113,
-0.1671363115310669,
0.46133068203926086,
-0.43506547808647156,
-0.18454651534557343,
-0.30924609303474426,
0.3146885633468628,
-0.19962221384048462,
-0.6081811189651489,
0.23046313226222992,
0.16086909174919128,
-0.42078694701194763,
-0.2799655795097351,
0.48274627327919006,
-0.6745327115058899,
-0.2616567611694336,
-0.0015896911500021815,
0.0671348050236702,
0.33265194296836853,
-0.5325743556022644,
-0.2797311842441559,
-0.1475408375263214,
-0.19844335317611694,
-0.4367632567882538,
0.36662915349006653,
0.29064881801605225,
-0.3201321065425873,
0.7404736876487732,
0.22685113549232483,
0.04141701012849808,
0.6769323945045471,
-0.05056143179535866,
0.9434508085250854,
-1.0045362710952759,
-0.720241129398346,
-0.7791528701782227,
0.4578210413455963,
-0.0023981579579412937,
0.026316804811358452,
0.5359495282173157,
0.9274938702583313,
0.6448103785514832,
-0.24234545230865479,
0.9576787352561951,
-0.07909936457872391,
0.5148355960845947,
-0.4630845785140991,
0.6696834564208984,
-0.3645286560058594,
0.2782670259475708,
-0.19992171227931976,
-0.6812793612480164,
0.10454142093658447,
0.16865506768226624,
-0.30629873275756836,
0.07026340067386627,
0.688571572303772,
0.5879366993904114,
-0.2151210904121399,
0.132001131772995,
0.2302035689353943,
0.07396099716424942,
0.4270855188369751,
0.8658332228660583,
1.119886040687561,
-0.062118738889694214,
0.20399177074432373,
-0.38645800948143005,
-0.07874234765768051,
-0.4555721879005432,
-0.9266542792320251,
-0.5206305384635925,
-0.20559625327587128,
-0.309953898191452,
-0.02296544425189495,
0.11647896468639374,
1.0419001579284668,
0.6125379800796509,
-0.8710916638374329,
-0.26973962783813477,
-0.08357039093971252,
0.4372082054615021,
-0.5358793139457703,
-0.2786999046802521,
0.48795053362846375,
-0.4726688861846924,
-0.5304387211799622,
0.6031373143196106,
0.4931802451610565,
-0.056652508676052094,
-0.01965312287211418,
0.31408795714378357,
-0.19249612092971802,
0.002637902507558465,
0.5231009721755981,
0.5772189497947693,
-0.7843704223632812,
-0.23516397178173065,
-0.16809064149856567,
-0.0245334655046463,
0.3456307649612427,
0.8445850610733032,
-0.8857641220092773,
0.4890991747379303,
0.40284639596939087,
0.6602184772491455,
0.5960062146186829,
0.3704037070274353,
0.41498249769210815,
-1.117932915687561,
0.1511693000793457,
0.38128161430358887,
0.33657896518707275,
0.18899376690387726,
-0.6249521374702454,
0.050147056579589844,
0.029872987419366837,
-0.3370135724544525,
-0.4284655451774597,
0.23172280192375183,
-0.8171579241752625,
-0.10699520260095596,
1.0547665357589722,
-0.44172346591949463,
-0.6715424060821533,
0.012870507314801216,
0.011462780646979809,
0.27774304151535034,
-0.6512465476989746,
0.5569849014282227,
0.3500048816204071,
-0.1541137397289276,
-0.40712589025497437,
-0.2355339229106903,
0.3830816447734833,
0.40873825550079346,
-0.6801577210426331,
0.34534332156181335,
0.45601144433021545,
0.3745686113834381,
0.07690008729696274,
0.564186155796051,
-0.038042791187763214,
0.6092278957366943,
-0.08297233283519745,
0.21875205636024475,
-0.18000386655330658,
-0.8456624150276184,
-0.4530872702598572,
0.22142130136489868,
0.04356320574879646,
-0.6271169185638428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12009v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12009v1 | FinTruthQA: A Benchmark Dataset for Evaluating the Quality of Financial Information Disclosure | 2024-06-17T18:25:02 | 2024-06-17T18:25:02 | Ziyue Xu, Peilin Zhou, Xinyu Shi, Jiageng Wu, Yikang Jiang, Bin Ke, Jie Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Accurate and transparent financial information disclosure is crucial in the
fields of accounting and finance, ensuring market efficiency and investor
confidence. Among many information disclosure platforms, the Chinese stock
exchanges' investor interactive platform provides a novel and interactive way
for listed firms to disclose information of interest to investors through an
online question-and-answer (Q&A) format. However, it is common for listed firms
to respond to questions with limited or no substantive information, and
automatically evaluating the quality of financial information disclosure on
large amounts of Q&A pairs is challenging. This paper builds a benchmark
FinTruthQA, that can evaluate advanced natural language processing (NLP)
techniques for the automatic quality assessment of information disclosure in
financial Q&A data. FinTruthQA comprises 6,000 real-world financial Q&A entries
and each Q&A was manually annotated based on four conceptual dimensions of
accounting. We benchmarked various NLP techniques on FinTruthQA, including
statistical machine learning models, pre-trained language model and their
fine-tuned versions, as well as the large language model GPT-4. Experiments
showed that existing NLP models have strong predictive ability for real
question identification and question relevance tasks, but are suboptimal for
answer relevance and answer readability tasks. By establishing this benchmark,
we provide a robust foundation for the automatic evaluation of information
disclosure, significantly enhancing the transparency and quality of financial
reporting. FinTruthQA can be used by auditors, regulators, and financial
analysts for real-time monitoring and data-driven decision-making, as well as
by researchers for advanced studies in accounting and finance, ultimately
fostering greater trust and efficiency in the financial markets. | [
-0.2731298804283142,
-0.5722949504852295,
-0.03748028725385666,
0.43415606021881104,
-0.23553216457366943,
0.23816044628620148,
-0.09815528988838196,
-0.7527550458908081,
-0.14243397116661072,
0.387403666973114,
-0.5232318043708801,
-0.510826826095581,
-0.31329792737960815,
-0.05591733008623123,
-0.43710121512413025,
0.7927999496459961,
-0.06792889535427094,
0.18506990373134613,
-0.1692727506160736,
-0.11838530749082565,
-0.4321226477622986,
-0.2807675898075104,
-0.8664862513542175,
0.09674324840307236,
0.11859043687582016,
0.12123195827007294,
0.7548433542251587,
0.7501000165939331,
0.8562467098236084,
0.3065011203289032,
0.18504291772842407,
-0.01369037851691246,
-0.12071993201971054,
-0.002953318180516362,
-0.26369908452033997,
-0.14117299020290375,
-0.5026202201843262,
0.33013951778411865,
0.5577583909034729,
0.4642397463321686,
-0.2858525514602661,
0.8385744690895081,
0.1550913006067276,
0.6570435166358948,
-0.666170060634613,
0.40587469935417175,
-0.14922630786895752,
-0.0019680685363709927,
-0.05159507319331169,
-0.06372817605733871,
-0.0899617150425911,
-0.804982602596283,
0.4778483510017395,
-0.6917866468429565,
0.07911379635334015,
0.3266421854496002,
0.9540409445762634,
0.19728893041610718,
-0.2376433163881302,
-0.44550615549087524,
-0.4645242691040039,
0.5940644145011902,
-0.8053373694419861,
0.4770587384700775,
0.4540715515613556,
0.6889369487762451,
0.3906967043876648,
-0.7734965085983276,
-0.6413596272468567,
0.023116514086723328,
-0.18058757483959198,
0.12242776155471802,
-0.4696039855480194,
-0.0762195885181427,
0.08997472375631332,
0.3334159255027771,
-0.7838419079780579,
-0.0924992710351944,
-0.3327656090259552,
-0.4078817367553711,
0.5893703699111938,
-0.05635363608598709,
-0.045463405549526215,
-0.13895581662654877,
-0.5360093116760254,
-0.770357072353363,
-0.1715361326932907,
0.26234132051467896,
0.5356318354606628,
0.3200870156288147,
-0.05735361576080322,
0.2017359435558319,
-0.3177978992462158,
0.7335717678070068,
0.06336890161037445,
-0.17223255336284637,
0.2696600556373596,
-0.659590482711792,
-0.2622855007648468,
0.026480745524168015,
0.646165132522583,
0.5300721526145935,
-0.1266254484653473,
-0.028979500755667686,
-0.25682759284973145,
-0.3617454469203949,
0.19601009786128998,
-0.647702157497406,
-0.045707881450653076,
0.4279813766479492,
-0.5007226467132568,
0.06954605877399445,
0.5305233001708984,
-0.7411603331565857,
-0.08326753228902817,
-0.2692869305610657,
0.636504590511322,
-0.2591894268989563,
-0.19454099237918854,
0.2152630090713501,
-0.3666079044342041,
0.4020684063434601,
0.36617353558540344,
-0.5003713369369507,
0.5578920245170593,
0.8707873821258545,
0.45671847462654114,
-0.14582301676273346,
0.07330306619405746,
-0.856715202331543,
-0.012320022098720074,
-0.3202691078186035,
0.8034043908119202,
-0.2679077684879303,
0.37415769696235657,
-0.026063287630677223,
-0.32663917541503906,
-0.19915936887264252,
-0.7224445343017578,
0.5225340127944946,
-0.6740095615386963,
0.3184211254119873,
-0.2622460126876831,
-0.6201947927474976,
-0.5198621153831482,
0.20809394121170044,
-0.688432514667511,
0.7397262454032898,
0.3345051109790802,
-0.8132936954498291,
0.4921644628047943,
-0.6237109303474426,
0.04731098562479019,
0.154289111495018,
-0.12718762457370758,
-0.2639017701148987,
-0.6930030584335327,
0.3548625111579895,
0.3686046302318573,
-0.5673261284828186,
0.5599910020828247,
0.12391285598278046,
-0.43404996395111084,
0.4344423711299896,
-0.5064426064491272,
0.5607800483703613,
0.08822815865278244,
-0.4633328318595886,
0.011725937947630882,
-0.5937125086784363,
0.2979540526866913,
-0.1289002150297165,
0.10923780500888824,
-0.18296876549720764,
-0.6517077684402466,
0.22147627174854279,
0.17186753451824188,
0.4783879220485687,
-0.5492967963218689,
-0.3629418611526489,
-0.45427820086479187,
0.36316028237342834,
0.5663567185401917,
0.1376141458749771,
0.028278479352593422,
-0.5692785382270813,
0.6118471622467041,
-0.09462162852287292,
0.48228222131729126,
-0.028583668172359467,
-0.22800885140895844,
-0.3962056338787079,
-0.05007745325565338,
0.8740383982658386,
0.678293764591217,
-0.4354974329471588,
0.4261225759983063,
0.04300502687692642,
-0.5997582674026489,
-0.8355668187141418,
0.24714826047420502,
0.5694629549980164,
0.7042620778083801,
0.3748866617679596,
-0.27257606387138367,
-0.19359077513217926,
-1.2337465286254883,
-0.5381418466567993,
-0.4046189785003662,
-0.3515062630176544,
0.25081685185432434,
0.21610942482948303,
0.2659773528575897,
0.6876181960105896,
-0.2723700702190399,
-0.30943113565444946,
-0.05079280957579613,
0.5497474074363708,
0.3672051429748535,
0.4514925181865692,
0.5362539291381836,
-1.0964524745941162,
-0.18039873242378235,
-0.32396581768989563,
-0.44510984420776367,
0.1484837532043457,
-0.42851993441581726,
-0.20556262135505676,
-0.14782926440238953,
0.11931969225406647,
-0.1793816238641739,
0.3975248336791992,
0.5343686938285828,
-0.5318156480789185,
0.38723519444465637,
-0.12117104232311249,
0.44169116020202637,
-0.6085593700408936,
0.5208629965782166,
0.17474333941936493,
-0.3001439571380615,
-0.34648826718330383,
0.0828116238117218,
0.2785835266113281,
0.16618873178958893,
-0.3112364709377289,
0.7033514380455017,
-0.07039546966552734,
-0.4828210473060608,
0.05688345804810524,
0.5131930708885193,
0.2506091892719269,
0.49081143736839294,
-0.22615358233451843,
0.9235340356826782,
0.17842009663581848,
-0.6692996025085449,
0.4288097620010376,
0.6389533281326294,
-0.4512871503829956,
0.45910409092903137,
-0.49453890323638916,
-0.13165435194969177,
0.08059149980545044,
0.2070380598306656,
-1.1454131603240967,
-0.06711578369140625,
0.30498212575912476,
-0.5987496972084045,
-0.052896030247211456,
0.32942795753479004,
-0.6202353835105896,
-0.24236267805099487,
-0.45420992374420166,
0.3723783493041992,
0.018972016870975494,
-0.4754735827445984,
0.4851743280887604,
0.2302122712135315,
-0.6461861729621887,
-0.725204348564148,
-0.8010788559913635,
0.13918869197368622,
0.15530580282211304,
-0.6818577647209167,
0.41244474053382874,
-0.16022127866744995,
-0.3909280002117157,
0.07079338282346725,
-0.3620051443576813,
-0.22816897928714752,
0.023897791281342506,
-0.005478070583194494,
0.5835719108581543,
-0.47098293900489807,
0.13876715302467346,
-0.022801071405410767,
-0.40237322449684143,
0.08728951215744019,
-0.014327301643788815,
0.3351823091506958,
-0.4836154282093048,
-0.2666058838367462,
-0.942671000957489,
-0.020034097135066986,
0.009807340800762177,
-0.30233681201934814,
0.5000872611999512,
0.5417891144752502,
-0.30268022418022156,
0.0910835787653923,
-0.780104398727417,
0.009195364080369473,
-0.49606063961982727,
-0.035660672932863235,
0.11889469623565674,
-0.9249374270439148,
0.5620900988578796,
0.1785963773727417,
0.45295754075050354,
0.8418181538581848,
0.15139223635196686,
0.13578441739082336,
0.5378376841545105,
0.6390818357467651,
-0.03806402534246445,
0.1307917684316635,
-0.08356408774852753,
0.23550280928611755,
-0.27975788712501526,
-0.2868148386478424,
-0.6914823055267334,
-0.20949415862560272,
-0.3955358564853668,
-0.43333345651626587,
0.2461140751838684,
0.12254130840301514,
-0.4766697883605957,
0.5423135757446289,
-0.5261691808700562,
0.2640416920185089,
0.5846742391586304,
-0.167717844247818,
0.5354785323143005,
-0.44231390953063965,
-0.12905140221118927,
-0.028252866119146347,
-0.4701642692089081,
-0.5267769694328308,
0.8564584851264954,
0.5435224175453186,
0.39496177434921265,
0.014977394603192806,
0.3295518159866333,
0.724197268486023,
0.2890084385871887,
-0.3673744797706604,
0.29527100920677185,
-0.06959233433008194,
-0.27143993973731995,
-0.5218733549118042,
-0.6691285371780396,
-0.30379539728164673,
-0.0318942591547966,
-0.1699972301721573,
-0.36097079515457153,
0.4555819630622864,
0.02845531702041626,
-0.8810981512069702,
0.07138372212648392,
-0.4223889112472534,
0.8704424500465393,
-0.12164921313524246,
-0.06572344154119492,
0.021377863362431526,
-0.671222448348999,
0.4555429220199585,
-0.36823320388793945,
0.332908570766449,
-0.20114484429359436,
-0.33410730957984924,
1.1247061491012573,
-0.22384515404701233,
0.510976254940033,
-0.21393784880638123,
-0.22204908728599548,
0.28102296590805054,
-0.08696601539850235,
0.30277493596076965,
0.41664546728134155,
-0.25518301129341125,
0.12017418444156647,
0.45048022270202637,
-0.1270093023777008,
-0.6654443740844727,
0.24567987024784088,
-0.5337533950805664,
-0.1668039709329605,
-0.42812782526016235,
-0.23291993141174316,
-0.4042236804962158,
0.08844383805990219,
0.010504021309316158,
0.3100287914276123,
-0.2201736867427826,
0.09249208867549896,
0.39222007989883423,
-0.2937432527542114,
0.3755853772163391,
0.5917862057685852,
-0.07183822244405746,
-0.6110982894897461,
0.576549768447876,
0.03445790708065033,
0.000018030486899078824,
0.45797353982925415,
0.06551302969455719,
-0.6693335771560669,
-0.3425965905189514,
-0.37649810314178467,
0.2457815706729889,
-0.6647036075592041,
-0.669784426689148,
-0.41555386781692505,
-0.6382017731666565,
-0.5096064209938049,
0.06645652651786804,
-0.4274304211139679,
-0.6485884785652161,
0.0011055606883019209,
-0.34950971603393555,
0.39976564049720764,
0.5381739139556885,
-0.29278644919395447,
0.08363071084022522,
-0.8447802066802979,
0.6803247332572937,
0.48771175742149353,
0.5849187970161438,
0.11282174289226532,
-0.47104084491729736,
-0.2053252011537552,
0.14407967031002045,
0.13296769559383392,
-0.23473158478736877,
0.17157326638698578,
0.2041592299938202,
0.6027925610542297,
0.583747148513794,
0.527728259563446,
0.6128236651420593,
0.34760478138923645,
0.6270381212234497,
-0.00875853281468153,
-1.012220859527588,
0.3405652940273285,
-0.1159132868051529,
0.16133779287338257,
1.000413179397583,
0.35469967126846313,
-0.7104923725128174,
-0.7163699865341187,
-0.7382898926734924,
-0.9521677494049072,
0.5816023945808411,
0.26536041498184204,
-0.12737810611724854,
0.258271187543869,
0.4975633919239044,
0.4505803883075714,
0.5661138296127319,
-0.3776986598968506,
-0.2507476806640625,
-0.35174721479415894,
0.00794597901403904,
0.08968430757522583,
-0.18397292494773865,
-0.01319324504584074,
-0.09913767874240875,
0.6347405910491943,
0.02614285610616207,
0.14106734097003937,
0.2896277606487274,
0.2563896179199219,
-0.1341518759727478,
0.11156903207302094,
0.1770607978105545,
1.0928831100463867,
-0.4422800838947296,
-0.18468499183654785,
-0.11202265322208405,
-0.45890089869499207,
-0.12614823877811432,
0.3735441565513611,
-0.07719315588474274,
0.11670703440904617,
0.4140899181365967,
0.2857397496700287,
0.2789623439311981,
-1.0854345560073853,
0.810106098651886,
-0.40473270416259766,
-0.5235449075698853,
-0.4431115388870239,
0.16249167919158936,
-0.0707230269908905,
0.523364782333374,
0.9061644077301025,
0.033631712198257446,
0.29805678129196167,
-0.4510338306427002,
0.698866605758667,
-0.027239473536610603,
-0.40512144565582275,
0.07069894671440125,
0.8054736256599426,
-0.06328852474689484,
0.10379733145236969,
0.6477679014205933,
0.05320950597524643,
-0.28483203053474426,
0.5261553525924683,
-0.05411726236343384,
0.8322314023971558,
-0.22311966121196747,
0.5143082737922668,
0.5927152633666992,
0.24859169125556946,
-0.169770285487175,
0.3438264727592468,
-0.21758411824703217,
-0.49601203203201294,
-0.3799203038215637,
-0.6540443301200867,
-0.8330543041229248,
0.10176797956228256,
-1.1541759967803955,
-0.1432604342699051,
-0.7461395859718323,
-0.37888839840888977,
0.33511054515838623,
0.2944506108760834,
-0.7017596364021301,
0.38496851921081543,
-0.10318804532289505,
1.260545253753662,
-0.45690110325813293,
0.22601209580898285,
0.05521475896239281,
-0.22059912979602814,
-0.49755480885505676,
0.018006471917033195,
-0.05385453999042511,
-0.6829221248626709,
0.5819839239120483,
0.19747501611709595,
-0.12492558360099792,
-0.2828633189201355,
-0.6136721968650818,
-0.8677543997764587,
1.0630872249603271,
0.23971691727638245,
-0.5417243242263794,
0.10666702687740326,
0.37950563430786133,
0.41486847400665283,
-0.3161555230617523,
0.00013869984832126647,
0.604293704032898,
0.9169381260871887,
0.25803861021995544,
-1.0273290872573853,
0.09373579919338226,
-0.4374849498271942,
-0.25047534704208374,
-0.15815116465091705,
-0.7375410199165344,
0.772832453250885,
0.008377824909985065,
-0.31849783658981323,
0.0535847432911396,
0.7208541035652161,
0.09322958439588547,
0.4181534945964813,
0.5002629160881042,
0.01888537034392357,
0.8570022583007812,
-0.04435582831501961,
0.586949348449707,
-0.4463455080986023,
-0.054771166294813156,
1.1223608255386353,
-0.16410650312900543,
1.3171508312225342,
0.1273999661207199,
0.016573693603277206,
0.16845309734344482,
0.5959641933441162,
-0.40976351499557495,
0.2476247102022171,
0.21405135095119476,
0.11317266523838043,
-0.2202468365430832,
-0.24531841278076172,
-0.17573104798793793,
0.4358285069465637,
0.2002275586128235,
-0.13425233960151672,
-0.19810041785240173,
-0.06812255829572678,
-0.271412193775177,
0.24055881798267365,
-0.10534340143203735,
0.7470588684082031,
-0.028332544490695,
-0.4422186613082886,
0.2529006898403168,
0.38084372878074646,
0.5527686476707458,
-0.7614136338233948,
-0.06864865124225616,
-0.2790965437889099,
-0.19715844094753265,
-0.049707479774951935,
-0.8361601233482361,
0.3643099069595337,
0.21127445995807648,
0.16686753928661346,
-0.3804106116294861,
0.38300782442092896,
-0.2313147783279419,
-0.26457762718200684,
0.28121116757392883,
0.4540384113788605,
-0.11026474088430405,
-0.21161875128746033,
-0.8416231274604797,
-0.38791701197624207,
-0.15416422486305237,
-0.24252960085868835,
0.20633666217327118,
0.26925429701805115,
0.14707858860492706,
0.9272515773773193,
0.7275046110153198,
-0.09609660506248474,
-0.40067318081855774,
0.0010770438238978386,
0.802436113357544,
-1.0026323795318604,
-0.7413380742073059,
-0.2783568203449249,
0.09577124565839767,
-0.21074970066547394,
-0.47098857164382935,
0.7334214448928833,
0.8727644681930542,
0.8918052911758423,
0.39992275834083557,
0.582755446434021,
0.3140522837638855,
0.9431168437004089,
-0.5609654188156128,
0.9014519453048706,
-0.21893827617168427,
0.3557743430137634,
-0.24889066815376282,
-0.7361968159675598,
-0.16133782267570496,
0.5023048520088196,
-0.11433392018079758,
-0.07584124803543091,
0.38933518528938293,
0.38015490770339966,
0.13628017902374268,
0.4812765419483185,
0.14861555397510529,
0.13958008587360382,
-0.13224230706691742,
0.1651284545660019,
0.32781192660331726,
-0.7489995360374451,
0.6324847340583801,
-0.5272133946418762,
-0.028457967564463615,
-0.2300182580947876,
-0.7489466071128845,
-0.457409530878067,
-0.719839870929718,
-0.6120748519897461,
-0.07366777211427689,
0.007783574517816305,
0.7471544742584229,
0.259764164686203,
-0.8730903267860413,
-0.29924893379211426,
0.6656234860420227,
-0.026782400906085968,
-0.6222477555274963,
-0.2737576365470886,
0.7329804301261902,
-0.05117090791463852,
-0.2520897388458252,
0.12746119499206543,
0.5456576347351074,
0.21886643767356873,
-0.30234816670417786,
0.2119365781545639,
0.012473187409341335,
0.023608027026057243,
0.1896727830171585,
0.2619113624095917,
-0.1841881424188614,
-0.014521493576467037,
0.016541479155421257,
-0.14646057784557343,
0.0778593048453331,
0.5506324768066406,
-0.4636889100074768,
0.16760161519050598,
0.33378085494041443,
0.7256650328636169,
0.3103870451450348,
0.5006513595581055,
0.7747206091880798,
-0.36257046461105347,
-0.07503442466259003,
0.5448520183563232,
-0.19158725440502167,
0.0694456696510315,
-0.38174742460250854,
0.387688010931015,
-0.3608017563819885,
-0.19107981026172638,
-0.5219189524650574,
-0.6206812858581543,
-0.9886739253997803,
-0.25391125679016113,
0.6032776832580566,
-0.18103057146072388,
-0.4990600049495697,
-0.3281099200248718,
0.1598302721977234,
0.07592128962278366,
-0.6516327857971191,
0.5944700241088867,
0.5844640135765076,
0.003618645016103983,
-0.08664810657501221,
-1.0126043558120728,
0.7797208428382874,
-0.09570858627557755,
-0.6520513296127319,
0.5125559568405151,
0.190165713429451,
0.08599080890417099,
0.07191603630781174,
0.6063106060028076,
-0.2041955590248108,
0.628128170967102,
0.026586372405290604,
-0.1310192346572876,
-0.2102196216583252,
-0.17129994928836823,
-0.06077861413359642,
0.2281266748905182,
-0.19398212432861328,
-0.06149005517363548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11978v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11978v1 | Dialogue Action Tokens: Steering Language Models in Goal-Directed Dialogue with a Multi-Turn Planner | 2024-06-17T18:01:32 | 2024-06-17T18:01:32 | Kenneth Li, Yiming Wang, Fernanda Viégas, Martin Wattenberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We present an approach called Dialogue Action Tokens (DAT) that adapts
language model agents to plan goal-directed dialogues. The core idea is to
treat each utterance as an action, thereby converting dialogues into games
where existing approaches such as reinforcement learning can be applied.
Specifically, we freeze a pretrained language model and train a small planner
model that predicts a continuous action vector, used for controlled generation
in each round. This design avoids the problem of language degradation under
reward optimization. When evaluated on the Sotopia platform for social
simulations, the DAT-steered LLaMA model surpasses GPT-4's performance. We also
apply DAT to steer an attacker language model in a novel multi-turn red-teaming
setting, revealing a potential new attack surface. | [
-0.11330877989530563,
-0.9664008617401123,
0.5734098553657532,
0.30358171463012695,
-0.2796798646450043,
0.37329381704330444,
-0.11705127358436584,
-0.008784533478319645,
0.5400230884552002,
0.7552268505096436,
-0.8937657475471497,
-0.5870256423950195,
-0.5148811340332031,
-0.050845760852098465,
-0.30914315581321716,
1.025991439819336,
-0.020785247907042503,
0.32189926505088806,
0.2240179032087326,
-0.13941287994384766,
-0.9183179140090942,
-0.6555225849151611,
-1.120787262916565,
-0.2827475368976593,
0.5252951383590698,
0.4414960741996765,
0.5985112190246582,
0.2742628753185272,
0.4369845986366272,
0.35218051075935364,
0.16399772465229034,
-0.07310575991868973,
-0.6176559329032898,
0.3602374792098999,
-0.10147742182016373,
-0.6094523072242737,
-0.6353083848953247,
-0.02673746831715107,
0.45260921120643616,
0.5417309999465942,
-0.3914965093135834,
-0.31377094984054565,
-0.4090186059474945,
0.1950998455286026,
-0.1100846529006958,
0.34033966064453125,
-0.7018265128135681,
-0.08340433984994888,
0.05018509551882744,
-0.14535625278949738,
-0.469437837600708,
-0.18281443417072296,
0.041913144290447235,
-0.6281247138977051,
-0.11978325992822647,
0.08835425972938538,
0.3783119022846222,
0.16969721019268036,
-0.11006743460893631,
-0.35176706314086914,
-0.8366192579269409,
0.7002548575401306,
-0.6116735339164734,
0.058057624846696854,
0.21727114915847778,
0.4118764400482178,
-0.4939194619655609,
-0.6510577201843262,
-0.6618938446044922,
-0.1299438625574112,
0.2576516568660736,
0.2546935975551605,
-0.26391178369522095,
0.4914272725582123,
0.17036525905132294,
-0.20406419038772583,
-0.22102712094783783,
0.21898731589317322,
-0.3302203416824341,
-0.055172182619571686,
0.7336479425430298,
0.4591197669506073,
0.15204650163650513,
-0.17129704356193542,
-0.5764189958572388,
-0.19298262894153595,
-0.7386940717697144,
-0.08331374078989029,
0.42072007060050964,
0.650863528251648,
-0.2492343634366989,
0.806776762008667,
-0.2004169374704361,
0.4836985766887665,
0.1376493275165558,
-0.1865575611591339,
-0.1571943461894989,
-0.6253647208213806,
-0.2890688180923462,
0.18573366105556488,
0.7976698279380798,
0.4711569547653198,
0.14811620116233826,
-0.015421176329255104,
-0.25991639494895935,
0.20115865767002106,
0.4598199129104614,
-0.6213673949241638,
-0.2613946199417114,
0.4121246337890625,
-0.3043711483478546,
-0.42006635665893555,
-0.24574831128120422,
-0.854942262172699,
-0.3435726463794708,
-0.2870228588581085,
0.3809536099433899,
-0.5605982542037964,
-0.43199753761291504,
0.23019161820411682,
-0.3066692054271698,
0.587809681892395,
0.38930317759513855,
-0.9199116826057434,
0.5890814065933228,
0.8818970322608948,
0.8709350228309631,
-0.33110281825065613,
-0.3321840763092041,
-0.8259428143501282,
0.3673644959926605,
-0.5313579440116882,
0.7312157154083252,
-0.8297563195228577,
-0.9135004878044128,
0.22043859958648682,
-0.3436655104160309,
-0.17664708197116852,
-0.1673433929681778,
0.4614354074001312,
-0.22398251295089722,
0.14163093268871307,
-0.12658222019672394,
-0.32935991883277893,
-0.12790881097316742,
0.3799085021018982,
-0.4958883225917816,
0.7966291308403015,
-0.0781984031200409,
-0.4036254584789276,
0.41621890664100647,
-1.2150219678878784,
-0.48300617933273315,
0.09149235486984253,
-0.3091273605823517,
-0.2634718716144562,
0.050852496176958084,
0.08778049796819687,
0.3300408720970154,
-0.2040184587240219,
0.35753801465034485,
-0.07973983883857727,
-0.2049543559551239,
0.14674748480319977,
-0.3765403628349304,
0.6053783297538757,
-0.0005390081787481904,
-0.22810088098049164,
0.9364587664604187,
-0.36185726523399353,
-0.13094040751457214,
0.2431700974702835,
-0.18632042407989502,
-0.08505041152238846,
0.20098809897899628,
-0.3196709454059601,
0.246537446975708,
-0.12575121223926544,
-0.4576660394668579,
0.43775758147239685,
-0.21541309356689453,
0.25311478972435,
0.8039641976356506,
0.11535181105136871,
0.5694630146026611,
-0.14825989305973053,
0.7858988642692566,
-0.07345662266016006,
0.3872792720794678,
-0.11936067789793015,
-0.7871944904327393,
-0.9415627121925354,
-0.29277944564819336,
0.04747534543275833,
0.41446810960769653,
-1.0213135480880737,
0.14556239545345306,
-0.3100602626800537,
-0.4645777642726898,
-0.48547491431236267,
-0.29180777072906494,
0.43611666560173035,
0.005206702277064323,
0.27905938029289246,
-0.4901593327522278,
-0.37435951828956604,
-0.545762300491333,
-0.15110115706920624,
-0.6793098449707031,
0.22491048276424408,
0.27597782015800476,
0.3145763576030731,
-0.1170647069811821,
0.9657630920410156,
-0.40910273790359497,
-0.18882398307323456,
-0.9732779860496521,
0.45555779337882996,
-0.08999809622764587,
0.3666664958000183,
0.5392406582832336,
-0.7520305514335632,
-0.4463328421115875,
-0.15602438151836395,
-0.43533772230148315,
0.0101318946108222,
-0.3140242099761963,
-0.20069044828414917,
0.18763232231140137,
0.6456102728843689,
-0.8762014508247375,
0.6083429455757141,
0.5178150534629822,
-0.3163885176181793,
0.6024543046951294,
0.0638657882809639,
-0.014550444670021534,
-1.053290843963623,
-0.2055216282606125,
-0.31214413046836853,
-0.19964154064655304,
-1.1723908185958862,
-0.20904920995235443,
-0.38683077692985535,
-0.3526136577129364,
-0.5256781578063965,
0.7166190147399902,
-0.03282498940825462,
-0.3896023631095886,
-0.2643621265888214,
0.13419215381145477,
-0.367931604385376,
0.9157364964485168,
0.3442975878715515,
0.7746265530586243,
0.45320436358451843,
-0.8203016519546509,
0.4450635313987732,
0.5275419354438782,
-0.08703193813562393,
0.7839990854263306,
-0.597297728061676,
0.21310564875602722,
0.057026684284210205,
0.3545379340648651,
-0.9343774914741516,
-0.1469583511352539,
0.4351983666419983,
-0.498903751373291,
0.2757914066314697,
-0.3100661039352417,
-0.03060985915362835,
-0.2876228392124176,
-0.24400494992733002,
0.05262244865298271,
0.2618764042854309,
-0.23033557832241058,
0.81139075756073,
0.5371133685112,
-0.4451526403427124,
-0.3785949945449829,
-0.2497800886631012,
0.2240489423274994,
-0.43459075689315796,
-0.18788044154644012,
0.4350273311138153,
-0.06820738315582275,
-0.43891263008117676,
-0.303625226020813,
0.1278657466173172,
0.02740342728793621,
0.13391655683517456,
0.23445698618888855,
0.1858399361371994,
0.07730025798082352,
0.03076501376926899,
-0.11296873539686203,
-0.2988490164279938,
0.1014060229063034,
-0.34890758991241455,
1.051463007926941,
0.33446308970451355,
-0.5388595461845398,
-0.4319080412387848,
0.5818496346473694,
0.5707566142082214,
-0.20877398550510406,
0.5870305299758911,
0.29304805397987366,
0.01430093590170145,
0.13588887453079224,
-0.16489490866661072,
-0.2945464253425598,
-0.4787422716617584,
0.5618350505828857,
-0.5478694438934326,
-0.514146089553833,
0.42676860094070435,
-0.3463844060897827,
0.4349052608013153,
0.16353586316108704,
0.6557285785675049,
-0.03825346753001213,
1.1081181764602661,
0.7755427956581116,
-0.11767175048589706,
0.9243332743644714,
-0.19163087010383606,
0.404857873916626,
-0.6980051398277283,
-0.21932250261306763,
-0.46282947063446045,
-0.2806137502193451,
-0.4535978138446808,
-0.5718759894371033,
0.15915171802043915,
0.017341576516628265,
-0.3185611367225647,
0.4029737114906311,
-0.00936700589954853,
0.1686372607946396,
0.5976255536079407,
-0.3280794024467468,
0.05584317445755005,
-0.3052983582019806,
-0.29064199328422546,
0.19431205093860626,
-0.9711896777153015,
-0.4677038788795471,
1.0313968658447266,
0.3038733899593353,
0.7062636017799377,
0.15336909890174866,
0.85198974609375,
0.12209493666887283,
0.2522798478603363,
-0.9381120800971985,
0.8166911602020264,
0.39585691690444946,
-0.4528038203716278,
-0.726463258266449,
-0.21705104410648346,
-0.9293926954269409,
0.07083326578140259,
-0.09058848023414612,
-0.7835201025009155,
-0.055545683950185776,
-0.16150784492492676,
-0.38375452160835266,
0.29077860713005066,
-0.744130551815033,
0.9418455362319946,
-0.4649735689163208,
-0.07247329503297806,
-0.5490212440490723,
-0.43345388770103455,
0.05545768141746521,
0.2230694442987442,
0.08423219621181488,
-0.22135600447654724,
0.15630635619163513,
0.8209184408187866,
-0.488048791885376,
1.0712252855300903,
-0.6012476086616516,
-0.08578968793153763,
0.3642493784427643,
0.3030518889427185,
0.7606997489929199,
-0.09887867420911789,
0.029560310766100883,
-0.0036378311924636364,
-0.375623881816864,
-0.3523275852203369,
-0.5032119154930115,
0.2801843285560608,
-0.6016509532928467,
-0.8369035720825195,
-0.23711901903152466,
-0.3804742097854614,
-0.2044341117143631,
0.1715531349182129,
-0.1812724769115448,
0.435016006231308,
-0.773163378238678,
-0.21386218070983887,
0.21002279222011566,
-0.2394704669713974,
0.70592200756073,
0.5472806692123413,
-0.30210167169570923,
-0.37180715799331665,
0.8453254699707031,
-0.38234829902648926,
0.7339444160461426,
0.3048439621925354,
-0.03374679759144783,
-0.3536955416202545,
-0.7727781534194946,
-0.41328752040863037,
0.15469679236412048,
-0.5273163914680481,
-0.25941184163093567,
-0.48881277441978455,
-0.05641856789588928,
-0.20308063924312592,
-0.1934921145439148,
-0.4844622015953064,
-0.4699943959712982,
0.05178707465529442,
-0.3390227258205414,
0.5910293459892273,
1.0794408321380615,
-0.09984678030014038,
0.8469352722167969,
-0.29150962829589844,
0.15406976640224457,
0.2680971920490265,
0.29376155138015747,
-0.36343666911125183,
-0.1930895298719406,
-0.051139507442712784,
0.12846384942531586,
-0.36619848012924194,
-0.9062268137931824,
0.5978977680206299,
-0.02301929146051407,
0.5436714887619019,
0.25479257106781006,
0.04732799157500267,
0.6554370522499084,
-0.6590393781661987,
0.972898006439209,
0.46412283182144165,
-0.8484064340591431,
0.5622026920318604,
-0.5308569669723511,
0.19157564640045166,
0.3030668795108795,
0.18009932339191437,
-0.8087020516395569,
-0.4706348776817322,
-0.712384819984436,
-0.4985882043838501,
0.9945244193077087,
0.15771274268627167,
0.2437673807144165,
-0.20975278317928314,
0.08572540432214737,
-0.05387190356850624,
0.3148346543312073,
-0.4606929421424866,
-0.19518227875232697,
-0.32489433884620667,
-0.13342589139938354,
-0.04449334740638733,
-0.20692984759807587,
-0.3420746326446533,
0.20303340256214142,
0.46498048305511475,
-0.4123212695121765,
0.7266042828559875,
-0.1198607087135315,
0.1533728390932083,
0.05461125075817108,
0.14177784323692322,
0.7699111700057983,
0.37873461842536926,
0.11329159140586853,
-0.3066551089286804,
0.2708490192890167,
-0.5165980458259583,
0.1202927827835083,
-0.16358016431331635,
-0.06304582208395004,
-0.07126468420028687,
0.22283987700939178,
1.065095067024231,
0.5305584073066711,
-0.2819858491420746,
0.42174115777015686,
-0.26194989681243896,
-0.26976561546325684,
-0.1877308487892151,
0.1576021909713745,
-0.09333262592554092,
0.3157804608345032,
0.06408484280109406,
-0.06688540428876877,
-0.2672603130340576,
-0.7165679931640625,
-0.00591996219009161,
0.5349193215370178,
-0.7595322728157043,
-0.46173295378685,
0.46198609471321106,
0.7087267637252808,
-0.7694025635719299,
0.4614594876766205,
-0.20179492235183716,
-0.8665298819541931,
0.41731709241867065,
0.6487256288528442,
1.0528219938278198,
-0.32487985491752625,
0.5503082275390625,
0.12423121929168701,
0.05955183133482933,
0.09470908343791962,
0.3891223967075348,
-0.031117791309952736,
-0.841498613357544,
-0.5703657269477844,
-0.3613636791706085,
-0.7543656229972839,
-0.03756106272339821,
-0.45376917719841003,
0.4119657576084137,
-0.4733259081840515,
-0.15976083278656006,
-0.10474938899278641,
-0.025533759966492653,
-0.5845558643341064,
-0.08807364106178284,
-0.06360325217247009,
0.7593390941619873,
-0.5880576372146606,
0.9830681681632996,
0.3590816259384155,
-0.5668540000915527,
-0.6080768704414368,
-0.0008133783121593297,
0.029701219871640205,
-0.758087694644928,
0.6984365582466125,
-0.12006952613592148,
-0.28020432591438293,
0.07818199694156647,
-0.5204803943634033,
-0.7920626997947693,
0.9693443775177002,
0.13449183106422424,
-0.3897762894630432,
-0.10423880070447922,
0.1643613576889038,
0.24979355931282043,
-0.46494126319885254,
0.14715568721294403,
0.8098746538162231,
0.3879869878292084,
0.290213942527771,
-1.0397695302963257,
-0.3450363874435425,
0.1637810617685318,
-0.22674588859081268,
0.22546926140785217,
-0.6717195510864258,
0.6588493585586548,
-0.20618602633476257,
-0.3360700309276581,
0.20896197855472565,
0.7080851197242737,
0.2250414490699768,
-0.06948018819093704,
0.4313786029815674,
0.18272623419761658,
0.762437641620636,
-0.288528710603714,
1.2432504892349243,
-0.05232229456305504,
-0.11090876907110214,
0.896183967590332,
-0.568797767162323,
0.8724417686462402,
0.3728058338165283,
-0.10565267503261566,
0.438833087682724,
0.2072805017232895,
0.5435280203819275,
0.6530787348747253,
0.15928973257541656,
-0.22192053496837616,
-0.23113271594047546,
-0.14597295224666595,
0.1930048167705536,
0.8025116324424744,
0.641659677028656,
0.29192861914634705,
0.02142401784658432,
-0.06397389620542526,
0.20569461584091187,
-0.03803855553269386,
-0.2845999598503113,
1.1770344972610474,
-0.08384226262569427,
-0.8075895309448242,
0.18039299547672272,
0.07864481955766678,
0.4582689702510834,
-0.8262215256690979,
-0.11791954189538956,
-0.28959211707115173,
0.16435863077640533,
0.3375851809978485,
-0.6973558068275452,
0.19577836990356445,
0.05314245447516441,
0.17835848033428192,
-0.33662569522857666,
0.4819139838218689,
-0.4411922097206116,
-0.24666817486286163,
0.3650444447994232,
0.5286977291107178,
0.11918023973703384,
0.21768201887607574,
-0.8934159874916077,
0.3090417981147766,
0.08469000458717346,
0.018579652532935143,
0.21788571774959564,
0.48343926668167114,
-0.29307594895362854,
0.7875854969024658,
0.5632444620132446,
0.1633230298757553,
0.03916264325380325,
0.2813025116920471,
0.8849663138389587,
-0.7388041019439697,
-0.49453088641166687,
-0.6599043607711792,
0.41409051418304443,
-0.41636911034584045,
-0.2678232789039612,
0.5317057371139526,
0.3232668340206146,
0.632361888885498,
0.1392923891544342,
0.8300220966339111,
0.01064140535891056,
0.38193464279174805,
-0.6574740409851074,
0.3071470856666565,
-0.0011960917618125677,
0.04441234841942787,
-0.4091232120990753,
-0.754382312297821,
-0.21498830616474152,
0.6788038015365601,
-0.4026505947113037,
0.04683057218790054,
0.5669092535972595,
0.6071175336837769,
0.275069922208786,
-0.0026005746331065893,
0.45093661546707153,
0.09968037903308868,
0.9102174639701843,
0.37681105732917786,
0.9379973411560059,
-0.15345217287540436,
0.5772829055786133,
0.2474144697189331,
-0.06977153569459915,
-0.3242785334587097,
-0.7653457522392273,
-1.121315836906433,
-0.602539598941803,
-0.1480320245027542,
-0.03654354438185692,
0.25524982810020447,
1.000885009765625,
0.7488337755203247,
-0.691571831703186,
-0.4414803981781006,
-0.2977373003959656,
0.24100905656814575,
-0.19352491199970245,
-0.13555264472961426,
0.18588140606880188,
-0.5533334612846375,
-0.8980048894882202,
0.7146950960159302,
0.4538303017616272,
0.18054115772247314,
-0.43407779932022095,
-0.3690521717071533,
-0.2836476266384125,
0.3172520399093628,
0.5286814570426941,
0.4269457161426544,
-0.8040730953216553,
-0.4336196482181549,
0.05710574984550476,
0.10427840054035187,
-0.01362975686788559,
1.1184014081954956,
-0.6814008355140686,
0.4759126305580139,
0.08665771037340164,
0.3703553080558777,
0.5628119707107544,
0.0027277162298560143,
1.3669013977050781,
-0.6962841153144836,
0.5067033767700195,
0.33411499857902527,
0.21626007556915283,
0.29596367478370667,
0.1106962189078331,
0.5231335163116455,
-0.08627726882696152,
-0.19144517183303833,
-0.6813166737556458,
0.4588414430618286,
-0.6923739910125732,
-0.03659584000706673,
1.2489118576049805,
-0.023696420714259148,
-0.20017856359481812,
-0.2926708459854126,
-0.6862814426422119,
0.18410298228263855,
-0.5551658272743225,
0.446328729391098,
0.6216657757759094,
-0.09391376376152039,
-0.05774003267288208,
-0.524820864200592,
1.0347745418548584,
0.3250715732574463,
-0.7962614297866821,
0.4252663850784302,
0.3926210105419159,
-0.3248095214366913,
0.15374372899532318,
0.9349664449691772,
0.01224245224148035,
0.17569772899150848,
0.18800456821918488,
-0.016544131562113762,
0.26980915665626526,
-0.6934441924095154,
-0.1311098337173462,
-0.3198428750038147,
0.2183527797460556,
-0.2843814492225647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11977v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11977v1 | Reframing linguistic bootstrapping as joint inference using visually-grounded grammar induction models | 2024-06-17T18:01:06 | 2024-06-17T18:01:06 | Eva Portelance, Siva Reddy, Timothy J. O'Donnell | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7; I.2.10; I.2.6; F.4.2 | Semantic and syntactic bootstrapping posit that children use their prior
knowledge of one linguistic domain, say syntactic relations, to help later
acquire another, such as the meanings of new words. Empirical results
supporting both theories may tempt us to believe that these are different
learning strategies, where one may precede the other. Here, we argue that they
are instead both contingent on a more general learning strategy for language
acquisition: joint learning. Using a series of neural visually-grounded grammar
induction models, we demonstrate that both syntactic and semantic bootstrapping
effects are strongest when syntax and semantics are learnt simultaneously.
Joint learning results in better grammar induction, realistic lexical category
learning, and better interpretations of novel sentence and verb meanings. Joint
learning makes language acquisition easier for learners by mutually
constraining the hypotheses spaces for both syntax and semantics. Studying the
dynamics of joint inference over many input sources and modalities represents
an important new direction for language modeling and learning research in both
cognitive sciences and AI, as it may help us explain how language can be
acquired in more constrained learning settings. | [
-0.02641707845032215,
-0.8233872056007385,
0.6866919994354248,
0.07418552786111832,
-0.2308456152677536,
0.211964413523674,
-0.3873152434825897,
-0.5776270031929016,
0.03126216307282448,
0.11766219139099121,
-0.538190484046936,
-0.21330511569976807,
-0.6712164878845215,
-0.08893216401338577,
-0.35023289918899536,
0.6211378574371338,
-0.0808120146393776,
0.30302152037620544,
-0.6397857666015625,
-0.07143288850784302,
-0.6159753799438477,
-0.2798660695552826,
-0.35140788555145264,
-0.35158517956733704,
0.6374155879020691,
0.4282631576061249,
0.7664024829864502,
0.6656136512756348,
0.24062424898147583,
0.4024719297885895,
0.24557124078273773,
-0.26050829887390137,
-0.08874566107988358,
0.4525013267993927,
-0.37752118706703186,
-0.860771656036377,
0.23560047149658203,
0.16308526694774628,
0.6053963899612427,
1.3527518510818481,
-0.03853132575750351,
0.14175935089588165,
-0.04822501540184021,
0.6348642706871033,
-1.032195806503296,
0.48366615176200867,
-0.6248456835746765,
-0.0742645114660263,
0.021853994578123093,
-0.19522824883460999,
-0.5060437917709351,
-0.04554865136742592,
0.29986199736595154,
-0.9339818358421326,
0.17447055876255035,
-0.026578448712825775,
1.0316420793533325,
0.2351841777563095,
-0.3379756510257721,
-0.03243006765842438,
-0.626828670501709,
0.7137143611907959,
-0.07096849381923676,
0.821262001991272,
0.5745648741722107,
0.31810879707336426,
-0.14309534430503845,
-1.0497244596481323,
-0.5345320701599121,
-0.1993892937898636,
-0.3902727961540222,
0.049815163016319275,
0.14660783112049103,
0.004388348199427128,
0.2327250987291336,
0.0951566994190216,
-0.27515602111816406,
-0.0038782786577939987,
-0.4078400731086731,
-0.08224891871213913,
0.2803666591644287,
-0.20843562483787537,
0.7381105422973633,
-0.08861229568719864,
-0.5897364020347595,
-0.2888602912425995,
-0.8073540329933167,
0.1305157095193863,
0.08289315551519394,
0.5700916647911072,
-0.222796231508255,
0.3110416531562805,
-0.36107251048088074,
0.8324939012527466,
0.04664525389671326,
-0.3915684223175049,
0.3815007209777832,
-0.43459808826446533,
-0.2948013246059418,
-0.1112111508846283,
0.5339991450309753,
0.14878776669502258,
0.3523233234882355,
-0.6118742823600769,
0.00756435003131628,
0.5919492244720459,
0.2066524624824524,
-0.17439433932304382,
-0.18287716805934906,
-0.09524854272603989,
-0.29673922061920166,
-0.18271248042583466,
0.08577440679073334,
-0.971281886100769,
-0.12860248982906342,
-0.6297982335090637,
0.5326984524726868,
-0.4541557729244232,
-0.6331720352172852,
0.15117274224758148,
-0.47363772988319397,
0.367217093706131,
0.23133796453475952,
-1.295838713645935,
0.6193631291389465,
0.8080404996871948,
0.27087756991386414,
0.05157705023884773,
-0.8289476037025452,
-0.5397725105285645,
0.12312398850917816,
-0.2858448326587677,
0.7577841281890869,
-0.8713251352310181,
0.14009861648082733,
0.21084517240524292,
0.20873196423053741,
-0.3176235854625702,
-0.3446662724018097,
-0.22906461358070374,
-0.7229225635528564,
0.3860861659049988,
-0.38344356417655945,
-0.2837584912776947,
-0.3461620509624481,
-0.15086810290813446,
-0.5196938514709473,
0.6314913034439087,
0.12053997814655304,
-0.5968132615089417,
1.2967276573181152,
0.05226912349462509,
-0.5582426190376282,
0.06700529903173447,
-0.6145834922790527,
-0.037325888872146606,
0.20994946360588074,
0.13307659327983856,
0.5058242082595825,
-0.28779637813568115,
0.5629650354385376,
-0.2135690450668335,
-0.01901022531092167,
0.05556093156337738,
-0.08239241689443588,
0.7857747673988342,
-0.10229158401489258,
-0.5243379473686218,
0.061360858380794525,
-0.6068408489227295,
-0.006068754941225052,
0.3895074427127838,
-0.15714071691036224,
-0.4875207245349884,
0.12093620747327805,
-0.24251234531402588,
0.2757825553417206,
-0.2272886484861374,
-0.30547305941581726,
-0.029356107115745544,
-0.295871764421463,
0.1794399619102478,
0.2950269877910614,
-0.0016916868044063449,
0.8054202795028687,
-0.12058737128973007,
0.46171972155570984,
-0.05255672708153725,
-0.2802466154098511,
-0.26583603024482727,
-0.294469952583313,
-0.8721746802330017,
-0.1286972314119339,
0.5874188542366028,
0.3180038332939148,
-1.1415108442306519,
0.0815107598900795,
-0.051328763365745544,
0.1832655966281891,
-0.5842955112457275,
0.2059027999639511,
0.5476047992706299,
0.2724209129810333,
0.34353992342948914,
-0.4217546880245209,
-0.40734562277793884,
-0.6946302652359009,
-0.3585197925567627,
-0.5417346358299255,
0.18249726295471191,
-0.2534216046333313,
0.3867509961128235,
0.4257538914680481,
0.6871129274368286,
0.025678157806396484,
0.212772399187088,
-0.5351045727729797,
0.27067482471466064,
-0.46184220910072327,
0.42061156034469604,
0.6394807696342468,
-0.8738713264465332,
-0.257098913192749,
-0.16596129536628723,
-0.8031017780303955,
0.06411567330360413,
-0.4420161247253418,
-0.3749857246875763,
0.17730861902236938,
0.6647864580154419,
-0.6369290947914124,
0.5476028323173523,
0.20915158092975616,
-0.4552323818206787,
0.26963183283805847,
0.15540555119514465,
-0.07403911650180817,
-0.8222466111183167,
-0.29187139868736267,
-0.11506497859954834,
-0.317558616399765,
-0.4418780207633972,
0.5486115217208862,
0.06639830768108368,
0.38989537954330444,
-0.43900632858276367,
0.22253510355949402,
-0.9309058785438538,
-0.19392289221286774,
-0.17339776456356049,
0.3220655918121338,
-0.026981646195054054,
0.4540170431137085,
0.22030486166477203,
0.5155743360519409,
0.8068165183067322,
-0.515531599521637,
0.34730395674705505,
-0.09960248321294785,
-0.47132888436317444,
0.24645055830478668,
-0.28284257650375366,
-0.15836985409259796,
-0.22317127883434296,
0.12373601645231247,
-1.1547187566757202,
-0.4432729482650757,
0.31773245334625244,
-0.4082365036010742,
0.7608959674835205,
-0.16969436407089233,
-0.623916745185852,
0.01818009279668331,
0.10809706151485443,
0.4150417447090149,
0.5517757534980774,
-0.8656809329986572,
0.39342471957206726,
0.4725259840488434,
0.07389911264181137,
-0.638639509677887,
-0.6927856802940369,
-0.08650827407836914,
-0.13696172833442688,
-0.4009612798690796,
0.2087821364402771,
0.6609821319580078,
-0.6496702432632446,
0.2104327231645584,
-0.21030515432357788,
-0.17098884284496307,
0.229202002286911,
0.3320203721523285,
0.34095895290374756,
-0.3545001745223999,
0.6419094800949097,
-0.0005524415755644441,
-0.3542269766330719,
0.22849029302597046,
-0.4498700499534607,
0.5251572728157043,
0.1329113394021988,
-0.4102277457714081,
-0.2682633697986603,
0.31237298250198364,
0.48614564538002014,
-0.21068519353866577,
0.9922713041305542,
0.37963879108428955,
-0.24240051209926605,
-0.33623120188713074,
-0.46476277709007263,
-0.32324475049972534,
-0.3906491994857788,
0.15812672674655914,
-0.41774672269821167,
-0.6186187267303467,
-0.0007018443429842591,
-0.33387285470962524,
-0.2351730316877365,
0.39069968461990356,
0.44499945640563965,
0.06529110670089722,
0.2924332618713379,
0.8333395719528198,
0.16450665891170502,
0.42568889260292053,
-0.139840766787529,
0.0513354130089283,
-0.3587510883808136,
-0.47045156359672546,
-0.38759854435920715,
-0.3096407949924469,
-0.5651906132698059,
-0.2645605206489563,
-0.27623575925827026,
0.1708843857049942,
0.0642898827791214,
0.23619110882282257,
-0.0897572934627533,
0.6585143804550171,
0.8064835667610168,
0.1562483310699463,
0.321499228477478,
0.22439642250537872,
-0.5298566818237305,
-0.05356024205684662,
-0.8164076209068298,
-0.08075336366891861,
0.9696977734565735,
0.007072208449244499,
0.5362750887870789,
-0.0035602005664259195,
0.7326140999794006,
-0.5442507266998291,
0.16255423426628113,
-0.7412711977958679,
0.5201578140258789,
0.3003474175930023,
-0.5609351396560669,
-0.047517430037260056,
-0.15245646238327026,
-0.9048029780387878,
0.3808695077896118,
-0.5913580656051636,
-0.8542590141296387,
0.3249593675136566,
0.018866172060370445,
-0.1567530333995819,
0.286926805973053,
-1.0704110860824585,
0.7600979208946228,
-0.13861751556396484,
-0.876022458076477,
-0.2394617795944214,
-0.9829973578453064,
0.3744925558567047,
0.07460067421197891,
0.08421590179204941,
0.0021998989395797253,
-0.15116100013256073,
0.5859623551368713,
-0.29275697469711304,
1.0921179056167603,
-0.18918676674365997,
0.3194722533226013,
0.41412049531936646,
0.08490577340126038,
-0.04075368866324425,
-0.124397411942482,
0.404086172580719,
-0.08812882751226425,
0.11081715673208237,
-0.5458605289459229,
-0.716479480266571,
0.4684111475944519,
-0.6777134537696838,
-0.671297013759613,
-0.5398997068405151,
-0.5645565390586853,
-0.4604707956314087,
0.11917439103126526,
0.2560487687587738,
0.24997064471244812,
-0.011006472632288933,
0.13494256138801575,
0.09221304953098297,
-0.08279253542423248,
0.4690479040145874,
0.4181918799877167,
-0.47357240319252014,
-0.24253015220165253,
0.7643628120422363,
-0.07680358737707138,
0.9274376034736633,
0.43621066212654114,
0.010600537061691284,
-0.18784017860889435,
-0.4556889832019806,
-0.14358392357826233,
0.4471932053565979,
-0.7530279159545898,
0.005916029214859009,
-0.3268623650074005,
-0.008549598045647144,
-0.2750338315963745,
-0.18536138534545898,
-0.1337491124868393,
-0.7482537031173706,
0.2476954162120819,
-0.35679981112480164,
0.29673027992248535,
0.6635464429855347,
-0.05841774865984917,
0.28149983286857605,
-0.28717100620269775,
0.5671444535255432,
0.48866915702819824,
0.2695782780647278,
0.021090436726808548,
-0.14636339247226715,
0.009444783441722393,
0.01891348510980606,
-0.0689401850104332,
-0.9294249415397644,
0.04795442521572113,
0.12827298045158386,
0.569789707660675,
0.13718484342098236,
-0.19848130643367767,
0.8521309494972229,
-0.6241543889045715,
0.5908316969871521,
0.5206894278526306,
-0.6889809966087341,
0.38641849160194397,
-0.14562688767910004,
0.32166802883148193,
0.8599689602851868,
0.49174508452415466,
-0.37268921732902527,
-0.3436479866504669,
-0.8240117430686951,
-0.7854078412055969,
0.564958393573761,
-0.10972979664802551,
-0.10202588886022568,
-0.16085264086723328,
0.2885964512825012,
0.4464479982852936,
0.26860493421554565,
-0.7315250635147095,
-0.20471744239330292,
0.18942083418369293,
-0.023371106013655663,
-0.05702364072203636,
-0.24062523245811462,
-0.029100293293595314,
-0.6525787711143494,
0.35366666316986084,
0.039444707334041595,
0.2812405228614807,
-0.14252591133117676,
-0.4414672255516052,
-0.3619973659515381,
0.19262845814228058,
0.01025219727307558,
0.7838093042373657,
0.16338692605495453,
0.4497448205947876,
-0.06706095486879349,
-0.2072921246290207,
0.12059782445430756,
-0.10467629134654999,
-0.03350605070590973,
0.05351001024246216,
0.8608723878860474,
0.746526837348938,
0.5232971906661987,
-0.38915854692459106,
0.5166799426078796,
0.011951586231589317,
-0.3885587751865387,
-0.022741155698895454,
0.08200962841510773,
0.27914732694625854,
0.22034019231796265,
0.030854392796754837,
0.1465928703546524,
-0.20645734667778015,
-0.864669144153595,
0.525886058807373,
0.44332587718963623,
-0.05511561781167984,
-0.3931293189525604,
0.5288249850273132,
-0.030444499105215073,
-0.0732828825712204,
0.5153598785400391,
-0.0844537615776062,
-0.3116869032382965,
0.5312414169311523,
0.8929994702339172,
0.9770378470420837,
-0.19044144451618195,
0.3595089316368103,
0.35247114300727844,
0.2924618721008301,
-0.15493188798427582,
0.10810389369726181,
-0.507124125957489,
-0.779278039932251,
-0.6380771398544312,
-0.6204805374145508,
-0.17215821146965027,
-0.03220995515584946,
-0.8522120118141174,
0.27142074704170227,
-0.4278568625450134,
0.2211335152387619,
0.311064749956131,
-0.3450506627559662,
-0.7605141401290894,
0.14674082398414612,
0.3657698631286621,
0.629052460193634,
-1.1260261535644531,
0.8215319514274597,
0.6436622142791748,
-0.770009458065033,
-0.9524997472763062,
0.29541128873825073,
0.1344451904296875,
-1.033704161643982,
0.994248628616333,
0.23269379138946533,
-0.16712430119514465,
-0.2255457192659378,
-0.7101514935493469,
-0.9464775919914246,
0.837295413017273,
0.3241649270057678,
-0.30755478143692017,
-0.1971087008714676,
0.08672357350587845,
0.3931255340576172,
-0.4674285054206848,
-0.06413935869932175,
0.7672441005706787,
0.15263505280017853,
0.2752833068370819,
-0.7274542450904846,
0.2063046097755432,
-0.11744966357946396,
-0.2159692943096161,
0.4416223466396332,
-0.3159021735191345,
0.6078281402587891,
-0.23114149272441864,
-0.5377401113510132,
0.03596748411655426,
0.6637089848518372,
-0.042560603469610214,
0.45360440015792847,
0.5816017985343933,
0.5140007734298706,
0.4205884337425232,
-0.2296539694070816,
0.9612862467765808,
-0.2242225706577301,
0.055783532559871674,
1.1942747831344604,
0.02431555464863777,
0.9831210970878601,
0.8367685675621033,
-0.27337726950645447,
0.7644948959350586,
0.3551424443721771,
0.49457839131355286,
0.5953367352485657,
-0.07936107367277145,
-0.25361278653144836,
-0.41045501828193665,
-0.08216065168380737,
-0.29344820976257324,
0.5915856957435608,
0.6679291725158691,
-0.4679376780986786,
-0.4503084421157837,
-0.0865805521607399,
0.1294139325618744,
0.3667874336242676,
0.06732949614524841,
0.7661692500114441,
0.049226704984903336,
-0.9189231395721436,
0.5993532538414001,
-0.4133480489253998,
0.18148188292980194,
-0.4923900365829468,
-0.25744521617889404,
0.061772916465997696,
-0.05944089591503143,
-0.1258116364479065,
-0.45414072275161743,
0.09000425040721893,
-0.23330570757389069,
0.0908692479133606,
-0.38454708456993103,
0.8220157623291016,
-0.7018570303916931,
-0.5686150789260864,
0.5498899817466736,
0.8419108390808105,
-0.07747741043567657,
0.48130714893341064,
-0.41262680292129517,
-0.02789737470448017,
-0.22909195721149445,
0.028770102187991142,
0.5246931910514832,
0.5338104963302612,
0.18592889606952667,
0.3769613206386566,
0.484965056180954,
0.2710830569267273,
0.32913315296173096,
0.04955235496163368,
0.8572918176651001,
-0.6176186203956604,
-0.33874544501304626,
-0.7199676632881165,
0.5962145924568176,
0.14111851155757904,
-0.12825411558151245,
0.6346634030342102,
0.06684023141860962,
1.2069636583328247,
0.026781532913446426,
0.5939151644706726,
-0.14195314049720764,
0.21400560438632965,
-0.9091137647628784,
0.27766942977905273,
-0.5894327163696289,
0.0215043555945158,
-0.38182735443115234,
-0.6922192573547363,
-0.5858570337295532,
0.7000181674957275,
-0.6200411915779114,
0.10817088931798935,
1.2188535928726196,
0.3818685710430145,
-0.1156453937292099,
0.11775290220975876,
0.27995553612709045,
-0.025104910135269165,
-0.17639851570129395,
0.5575726628303528,
1.0551230907440186,
-0.21577267348766327,
-0.02888903208076954,
-0.6835076212882996,
-0.2694796621799469,
0.19808346033096313,
-0.5275793075561523,
-0.9441536664962769,
-0.7687109112739563,
-0.3006238043308258,
-0.32781606912612915,
0.3610357940196991,
0.9635958671569824,
0.6499816179275513,
-0.45858803391456604,
-0.3118603229522705,
-0.4778754413127899,
0.17902469635009766,
-0.37474820017814636,
-0.20054912567138672,
0.17582203447818756,
-1.1685810089111328,
-0.5580204725265503,
0.42091792821884155,
0.24131929874420166,
-0.2413439154624939,
-0.09187574684619904,
0.18990348279476166,
-0.6525267958641052,
-0.36745887994766235,
0.43525925278663635,
0.42279860377311707,
-0.9701570272445679,
-0.3333330750465393,
-0.2519212067127228,
-0.023634135723114014,
0.052861932665109634,
0.8694352507591248,
-1.2488869428634644,
0.6826164126396179,
0.5829657316207886,
0.7723169922828674,
0.33736005425453186,
-0.12503831088542938,
0.808309018611908,
-0.6466222405433655,
0.796273410320282,
-0.22320567071437836,
0.39585956931114197,
0.17240765690803528,
-0.07150162011384964,
0.359095960855484,
0.6329360604286194,
-0.09662184864282608,
-0.6242070198059082,
0.4438624978065491,
-0.598025918006897,
-0.42448142170906067,
1.163894772529602,
0.06267562508583069,
-0.4900377094745636,
-0.09521880000829697,
0.248994842171669,
0.3862128257751465,
-0.02924220822751522,
0.5140238404273987,
0.6965522170066833,
0.21782758831977844,
-0.26547762751579285,
-0.6445321440696716,
0.5378165245056152,
0.7473762035369873,
-0.5023964047431946,
-0.029283419251441956,
0.4444115459918976,
0.18109887838363647,
0.27387362718582153,
0.2656799256801605,
0.021521233022212982,
0.5575636625289917,
0.5672896504402161,
-0.022976651787757874,
0.1572643220424652,
-0.8635634183883667,
-0.2850807011127472,
0.17983868718147278,
0.16390281915664673,
-0.5881845951080322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11839v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11839v1 | mDPO: Conditional Preference Optimization for Multimodal Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T17:59:58 | 2024-06-17T17:59:58 | Fei Wang, Wenxuan Zhou, James Y. Huang, Nan Xu, Sheng Zhang, Hoifung Poon, Muhao Chen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Direct preference optimization (DPO) has shown to be an effective method for
large language model (LLM) alignment. Recent works have attempted to apply DPO
to multimodal scenarios but have found it challenging to achieve consistent
improvement. Through a comparative experiment, we identify the unconditional
preference problem in multimodal preference optimization, where the model
overlooks the image condition. To address this problem, we propose mDPO, a
multimodal DPO objective that prevents the over-prioritization of language-only
preferences by also optimizing image preference. Moreover, we introduce a
reward anchor that forces the reward to be positive for chosen responses,
thereby avoiding the decrease in their likelihood -- an intrinsic problem of
relative preference optimization. Experiments on two multimodal LLMs of
different sizes and three widely used benchmarks demonstrate that mDPO
effectively addresses the unconditional preference problem in multimodal
preference optimization and significantly improves model performance,
particularly in reducing hallucination. | [
-0.4903047978878021,
-0.4870889186859131,
0.884431004524231,
0.30374443531036377,
-0.3574799597263336,
-0.0060514663346111774,
-0.4072723686695099,
-0.20704075694084167,
0.22909696400165558,
0.43274986743927,
-0.6129021644592285,
-0.23202106356620789,
-0.7363587617874146,
0.1004854291677475,
0.23204001784324646,
0.4802645146846771,
-0.08103101700544357,
0.0930882915854454,
-0.5377063751220703,
-0.11543780565261841,
-0.42707666754722595,
-0.43283364176750183,
-0.746026337146759,
-0.3773058354854584,
0.7591921091079712,
0.6280221939086914,
0.7475081086158752,
0.7104372382164001,
0.6417927742004395,
0.32953011989593506,
0.1522154062986374,
0.5032926797866821,
-0.2564457356929779,
0.1622724086046219,
-0.14360740780830383,
-0.28392601013183594,
-0.4415515661239624,
0.08328335732221603,
0.6058427691459656,
0.5258685946464539,
-0.11247830837965012,
-0.15881602466106415,
-0.1829165667295456,
1.0250115394592285,
-0.9343000054359436,
-0.01177782379090786,
-0.668904185295105,
0.10353237390518188,
0.030257537961006165,
-0.5758658647537231,
-0.4887162744998932,
-0.1435290426015854,
0.08771073073148727,
-0.5089977979660034,
-0.3455125093460083,
0.07523376494646072,
0.5596138834953308,
0.4423224627971649,
-0.9087870717048645,
0.013869081623852253,
-0.5231316089630127,
1.008178472518921,
-0.3708242177963257,
0.4013231694698334,
0.40883108973503113,
0.08526276051998138,
-0.22097675502300262,
-0.1165446862578392,
-0.9270721077919006,
-0.37949153780937195,
0.13816890120506287,
0.11540211737155914,
-0.07119441777467728,
0.38985323905944824,
0.1529029756784439,
0.31850969791412354,
-0.5132001638412476,
0.09585263580083847,
0.12653380632400513,
-0.2441374659538269,
0.2916290760040283,
-0.09118808060884476,
0.32380062341690063,
-0.22355447709560394,
-0.5953339338302612,
-0.09534197300672531,
-0.591763973236084,
0.3262559771537781,
0.5128830671310425,
0.17989440262317657,
-0.032880913466215134,
0.9843441843986511,
-0.334138423204422,
0.7771372199058533,
0.30764445662498474,
-0.6316404342651367,
0.34937044978141785,
-0.19606070220470428,
-0.047745585441589355,
0.14537064731121063,
0.6138643622398376,
0.8696804642677307,
0.21804016828536987,
0.019914202392101288,
-0.25317102670669556,
0.36558854579925537,
0.09071499854326248,
-0.7195448875427246,
0.18797269463539124,
0.4248597323894501,
-0.5218455791473389,
-0.30949264764785767,
-0.31346017122268677,
-0.771025538444519,
-0.48349010944366455,
-0.5719680190086365,
0.3234756290912628,
-0.1854122430086136,
-0.3695904016494751,
0.2307494431734085,
-0.20539477467536926,
-0.05800653621554375,
0.06635136902332306,
-1.2078752517700195,
-0.025078605860471725,
0.6381761431694031,
0.7427180409431458,
-0.30841565132141113,
-0.4671994149684906,
-0.7163373827934265,
0.3890998065471649,
-0.24659596383571625,
0.8459540009498596,
-0.9335983395576477,
-0.3094218671321869,
-0.11222945153713226,
-0.04659465700387955,
-0.07018447667360306,
-0.24208399653434753,
0.7598158717155457,
-0.2624586820602417,
0.19068032503128052,
-0.3204348087310791,
-0.4897972047328949,
0.12390797585248947,
0.4412631094455719,
-0.4076434075832367,
0.5425917506217957,
-0.2438991814851761,
-0.7233369946479797,
0.6446451544761658,
-0.4797721207141876,
-0.3729653060436249,
-0.46320855617523193,
-0.3032761812210083,
-0.1691693812608719,
0.3652729094028473,
0.1470189392566681,
0.21171978116035461,
-0.2721431851387024,
0.3530310094356537,
-0.5696824193000793,
-0.24546298384666443,
0.26303786039352417,
-0.2858377695083618,
0.2493298351764679,
0.1692700833082199,
-0.29193753004074097,
0.417845755815506,
-0.7402734756469727,
-0.062151044607162476,
0.26756617426872253,
-0.37210044264793396,
-0.6810747385025024,
0.23980918526649475,
-0.2868706285953522,
0.41363102197647095,
0.3803086578845978,
-0.598964512348175,
0.6863049864768982,
-0.10252695530653,
0.22587673366069794,
1.1738014221191406,
-0.3344687521457672,
0.6625502109527588,
-0.19602373242378235,
0.5201136469841003,
-0.029899146407842636,
0.47951173782348633,
0.05311883985996246,
-0.31887388229370117,
-0.7714521288871765,
-0.8018184304237366,
0.09466458857059479,
0.2452516108751297,
-0.8847877383232117,
0.2903558015823364,
-0.1601514369249344,
-0.009242042899131775,
-0.40183839201927185,
0.06634218245744705,
0.47849392890930176,
0.7091237902641296,
0.1749776154756546,
-0.20733068883419037,
-0.6258320808410645,
-1.4203377962112427,
0.2773613929748535,
-0.06081060692667961,
0.1574159562587738,
0.4851045310497284,
-0.017770128324627876,
-0.3928357660770416,
0.6341882348060608,
-0.7685859203338623,
-0.32999369502067566,
-0.03606731444597244,
-0.0925823524594307,
0.23572242259979248,
0.3876097798347473,
0.7324665188789368,
-1.049404501914978,
-0.46090152859687805,
-0.14571422338485718,
-0.23728014528751373,
-0.07375257462263107,
-0.014074981212615967,
-0.24392421543598175,
0.4245205819606781,
0.06146116554737091,
-0.796042263507843,
-0.08998193591833115,
0.9520860314369202,
-0.22499312460422516,
0.28980401158332825,
-0.4921715557575226,
0.6722007989883423,
-0.9428807497024536,
-0.0227963887155056,
0.05797972530126572,
-0.10366800427436829,
-0.3550308644771576,
-0.19950450956821442,
0.30727308988571167,
-0.32346293330192566,
-0.2910829782485962,
0.6131241917610168,
-0.3817652761936188,
0.1060740053653717,
-0.5102465748786926,
0.01915256306529045,
0.1343168467283249,
0.656184732913971,
0.5294018387794495,
0.6407095193862915,
0.7674347162246704,
-0.5054150223731995,
0.2474156767129898,
0.1946004182100296,
-0.09889472275972366,
0.8450783491134644,
-0.5218380689620972,
0.34816664457321167,
-0.2139822542667389,
0.1250993013381958,
-1.2424066066741943,
-0.06642702221870422,
0.18314440548419952,
-0.27957093715667725,
0.6348121166229248,
-0.4788103401660919,
-0.43462279438972473,
-0.263101726770401,
-0.5642217397689819,
0.5762949585914612,
0.11643783003091812,
-0.6972028613090515,
0.38129016757011414,
0.5426446795463562,
0.053512223064899445,
-0.9346829056739807,
-0.22559303045272827,
0.09483306854963303,
-0.25167784094810486,
-0.5399188995361328,
0.4394640028476715,
-0.3123700022697449,
-0.09819308668375015,
-0.3465029299259186,
-0.26810628175735474,
0.04814448207616806,
-0.24201270937919617,
0.17625412344932556,
0.3760767877101898,
0.12097985297441483,
0.18697841465473175,
0.05028657615184784,
-0.4405590891838074,
-0.3239426612854004,
-0.25261247158050537,
0.8490784764289856,
0.1378486305475235,
-0.33510762453079224,
-0.31460022926330566,
0.6641228795051575,
0.7199071049690247,
-0.21021735668182373,
0.57452791929245,
0.20586074888706207,
-0.10948628932237625,
0.12191541492938995,
-0.5987893342971802,
-0.0001674123777775094,
-0.5059886574745178,
0.1554500311613083,
-0.7253700494766235,
-0.5621988773345947,
-0.01626000367105007,
0.0664677545428276,
-0.2663833796977997,
0.05046809837222099,
0.4584454894065857,
-0.0419129841029644,
1.5903021097183228,
0.9387456178665161,
-0.09517519921064377,
0.7156481146812439,
0.18967972695827484,
0.18783213198184967,
-0.7796483039855957,
-0.1668419986963272,
-0.4440692365169525,
-0.5083614587783813,
-0.5767567157745361,
-0.2795468866825104,
0.27194494009017944,
-0.19113218784332275,
-0.031045733019709587,
0.1518608182668686,
-0.4723531901836395,
0.4289790689945221,
0.5764824748039246,
0.21833479404449463,
0.3228468894958496,
0.0528242364525795,
-0.29089030623435974,
-0.2664605677127838,
-0.40121808648109436,
-0.3907668888568878,
0.9526588320732117,
0.13315771520137787,
0.7746169567108154,
0.16468104720115662,
0.5855590105056763,
0.12561333179473877,
-0.04279950261116028,
-0.9263889789581299,
0.5000327825546265,
-0.2754855751991272,
-0.5675344467163086,
-0.15688581764698029,
-0.5449556708335876,
-0.8182206153869629,
0.31398433446884155,
-0.30361416935920715,
-0.6544436812400818,
0.5960252285003662,
0.45662814378738403,
-0.004045423585921526,
0.10629718750715256,
-0.7585199475288391,
0.8429287672042847,
-0.5662593841552734,
-0.4271831512451172,
-0.3900242745876312,
-0.5353110432624817,
0.3107583820819855,
-0.058875199407339096,
0.08938541263341904,
-0.45044413208961487,
-0.35128748416900635,
0.2322796732187271,
-0.08065825700759888,
0.3837977647781372,
-0.18550768494606018,
-0.1287451684474945,
-0.3102671802043915,
-0.03067741170525551,
0.4911104738712311,
0.06826255470514297,
-0.10253816097974777,
-0.0629543885588646,
-0.07152722775936127,
-0.36745765805244446,
-0.6491044163703918,
1.039574146270752,
-0.6670300960540771,
-0.7209078669548035,
-0.45942258834838867,
-0.6524902582168579,
-0.46402063965797424,
0.2598572373390198,
0.04349534958600998,
0.4660300314426422,
0.15591713786125183,
0.1531384140253067,
0.6019895076751709,
-0.22156614065170288,
0.46048155426979065,
0.49989810585975647,
-0.2735276520252228,
-0.5736141204833984,
0.7459141612052917,
-0.2606046497821808,
0.5262352824211121,
0.7458074688911438,
0.4890090525150299,
-0.5926579833030701,
-0.545982837677002,
-0.36340755224227905,
0.24448616802692413,
-0.6777248978614807,
-0.008116512559354305,
-0.6451268196105957,
0.48544707894325256,
-0.4010069668292999,
-0.200250044465065,
-0.6299517154693604,
-0.5058295130729675,
0.06500265747308731,
0.18485498428344727,
0.03355683386325836,
-0.005370382219552994,
-0.12625867128372192,
-0.1492125391960144,
-0.431523859500885,
0.7620676755905151,
0.49368786811828613,
0.5634361505508423,
-0.39897388219833374,
-0.37786808609962463,
0.3362911343574524,
0.12149372696876526,
-0.25100409984588623,
-0.49014395475387573,
0.1946895569562912,
0.09188355505466461,
0.727319061756134,
0.7837052345275879,
0.09689401090145111,
0.774770975112915,
-0.5430008172988892,
0.16975346207618713,
0.6078831553459167,
-0.7843008041381836,
0.6558032631874084,
-0.37234458327293396,
0.24606746435165405,
0.6748692393302917,
0.602424144744873,
-0.5643723011016846,
0.06387580186128616,
-0.10278388112783432,
-0.6331773996353149,
0.3710595369338989,
0.008699988946318626,
0.29368188977241516,
-0.2086767852306366,
0.2605096995830536,
0.11278051882982254,
0.49101606011390686,
-0.9269422292709351,
-0.397820383310318,
-0.05276958644390106,
0.06132933497428894,
-0.3892396092414856,
-0.6281282901763916,
-0.4315354824066162,
-0.1776796579360962,
0.4615402817726135,
-0.29017096757888794,
0.18328002095222473,
0.21787282824516296,
-0.07885181903839111,
-0.2778553366661072,
0.274442583322525,
0.9850370287895203,
0.8751869797706604,
-0.5340253710746765,
0.2959827780723572,
-0.4499977231025696,
-0.13632546365261078,
0.451911985874176,
-0.03969203680753708,
-0.1162480041384697,
-0.297556608915329,
-0.05885787680745125,
0.7344281077384949,
0.10877107828855515,
-0.7266438007354736,
0.5858078002929688,
-0.2969045042991638,
-0.09283719211816788,
0.04788466915488243,
-0.09797993302345276,
-0.04001324251294136,
0.15906263887882233,
0.21946077048778534,
0.16403231024742126,
0.20012757182121277,
-0.8642953634262085,
0.09108109027147293,
0.772030234336853,
-0.3122737407684326,
0.04671758413314819,
0.536949634552002,
0.2458532303571701,
-0.18838803470134735,
0.2703911364078522,
0.004254435189068317,
-0.42047762870788574,
0.42393890023231506,
0.6653015613555908,
0.6278952956199646,
-0.08307091891765594,
0.20998115837574005,
0.19049465656280518,
0.2033635526895523,
-0.019609009847044945,
0.19797354936599731,
-0.1590423285961151,
-1.0131157636642456,
-0.3650610148906708,
-0.462310254573822,
-0.5285026431083679,
-0.06613381952047348,
-0.4204680323600769,
0.4196990728378296,
-0.39410221576690674,
-0.22137098014354706,
0.09184827655553818,
-0.10331734269857407,
-0.4622577726840973,
0.1981540322303772,
0.3546174466609955,
0.44839584827423096,
-0.6112798452377319,
1.0696299076080322,
0.7116725444793701,
-0.29427412152290344,
-0.2604348659515381,
-0.04222838580608368,
0.15271739661693573,
-0.9294770956039429,
0.5985199213027954,
0.20899128913879395,
-0.42325738072395325,
-0.1898694485425949,
-0.2522842288017273,
-0.8049310445785522,
0.6581199765205383,
0.6368542909622192,
-0.6643310189247131,
0.3845353424549103,
-0.001659010536968708,
0.289488822221756,
-0.5281143188476562,
0.051726166158914566,
0.3012048900127411,
0.7313380837440491,
0.3349754810333252,
-0.8836218118667603,
-0.010218593291938305,
-0.14818403124809265,
-0.05259422957897186,
0.5088176727294922,
-0.8530912399291992,
0.3906148374080658,
-0.38042914867401123,
0.03049050085246563,
-0.041591376066207886,
0.18778778612613678,
0.40475818514823914,
0.1827286332845688,
0.9606297016143799,
0.5949379801750183,
0.6417529582977295,
0.01675885170698166,
1.2699357271194458,
-0.2401149868965149,
0.21279151737689972,
0.9097590446472168,
-0.5504654049873352,
0.6941421031951904,
1.1363165378570557,
-0.05150299891829491,
-0.10862608999013901,
0.8201818466186523,
0.16589713096618652,
1.0912997722625732,
0.016087938100099564,
-0.2070159912109375,
-0.4331592917442322,
-0.36593097448349,
-0.3808899223804474,
0.6785535216331482,
-0.23961074650287628,
-0.12935194373130798,
0.2749791145324707,
0.07401143014431,
-0.0993451252579689,
0.2001323401927948,
-0.25817424058914185,
0.5419131517410278,
-0.1723502278327942,
-0.9311903715133667,
0.5190370082855225,
-0.07655631750822067,
0.9288443922996521,
-0.7404096126556396,
0.16229090094566345,
-0.41369304060935974,
0.39353540539741516,
-0.07844837009906769,
-0.5061119198799133,
0.003683721413835883,
-0.3396521210670471,
-0.5468797087669373,
-0.32750535011291504,
0.6159213781356812,
-0.5851091146469116,
-0.48928102850914,
0.4173937141895294,
0.011823229491710663,
-0.3053728938102722,
-0.2296580970287323,
-0.6429845094680786,
0.19365347921848297,
0.07513295114040375,
-0.27712106704711914,
0.48798954486846924,
0.1822635978460312,
0.150154709815979,
0.9624881744384766,
0.6964190006256104,
0.10156885534524918,
-0.3359347879886627,
0.16005580127239227,
0.7502591013908386,
-0.44775959849357605,
-0.17923983931541443,
-1.0041782855987549,
0.44199058413505554,
-0.20146413147449493,
-0.3633849322795868,
0.5935952067375183,
0.6148635745048523,
0.5950939059257507,
-0.175029918551445,
0.4418617784976959,
0.02334768883883953,
0.08693505823612213,
-0.8125563263893127,
0.3183409571647644,
-1.073604941368103,
0.01635037176311016,
-0.5842431783676147,
-1.2659637928009033,
-0.23006956279277802,
0.5063013434410095,
-0.2633615732192993,
-0.13819895684719086,
0.9042354822158813,
0.7508288025856018,
-0.19022227823734283,
-0.601655125617981,
0.5875712037086487,
-0.36977192759513855,
0.17829649150371552,
0.569193422794342,
0.9728024005889893,
0.20956625044345856,
0.5700162649154663,
-0.6974698901176453,
-0.40631747245788574,
0.02265027165412903,
-1.3600069284439087,
-0.798601508140564,
-0.6671186089515686,
-0.3865138590335846,
0.03814373165369034,
-0.108340784907341,
1.101155400276184,
0.8663196563720703,
-0.5876567363739014,
-0.13843894004821777,
0.4883895218372345,
0.40687671303749084,
-0.05178818851709366,
-0.1207079067826271,
0.15267311036586761,
-0.21601179242134094,
-1.0849772691726685,
0.5245817303657532,
0.775101900100708,
0.13143132627010345,
-0.08904880285263062,
-0.140229269862175,
-0.42199596762657166,
0.13507483899593353,
0.6606589555740356,
0.15571773052215576,
-0.660407543182373,
-0.49776017665863037,
0.08891942352056503,
-0.23186556994915009,
0.4322552978992462,
1.03034245967865,
-0.12933258712291718,
0.770342230796814,
0.5291634202003479,
0.5148535370826721,
0.5371931791305542,
-0.053611550480127335,
0.8749317526817322,
-0.6558298468589783,
0.7316027283668518,
-0.0804360955953598,
0.7846453189849854,
0.21548499166965485,
-0.36616167426109314,
0.298301100730896,
0.15771795809268951,
-0.5049417614936829,
-0.7774416208267212,
0.3881988525390625,
-1.385258436203003,
-0.3492538332939148,
1.256747841835022,
0.18217810988426208,
0.08811918646097183,
0.3135874569416046,
-0.5805240869522095,
-0.026167556643486023,
-0.5591291189193726,
0.9904171824455261,
0.7234799861907959,
-0.15586340427398682,
-0.358391135931015,
-0.39756396412849426,
0.4052238166332245,
0.6141353249549866,
-0.6048693060874939,
-0.20569093525409698,
0.7142075896263123,
0.13404202461242676,
0.08234566450119019,
0.727756679058075,
0.08418745547533035,
0.14676782488822937,
-0.33608150482177734,
0.3935486078262329,
-0.11020320653915405,
-0.4299069046974182,
-0.24929094314575195,
0.02850452810525894,
0.28232088685035706,
-0.5059008598327637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11830v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11830v1 | Language Modeling with Editable External Knowledge | 2024-06-17T17:59:35 | 2024-06-17T17:59:35 | Belinda Z. Li, Emmy Liu, Alexis Ross, Abbas Zeitoun, Graham Neubig, Jacob Andreas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | When the world changes, so does the text that humans write about it. How do
we build language models that can be easily updated to reflect these changes?
One popular approach is retrieval-augmented generation, in which new documents
are inserted into a knowledge base and retrieved during prediction for
downstream tasks. Most prior work on these systems have focused on improving
behavior during prediction through better retrieval or reasoning. This paper
introduces ERASE, which instead improves model behavior when new documents are
acquired, by incrementally deleting or rewriting other entries in the knowledge
base each time a document is added. In two new benchmark datasets evaluating
models' ability to answer questions about a stream of news articles or
conversations, ERASE improves accuracy relative to conventional
retrieval-augmented generation by 7-13% (Mixtral-8x7B) and 6-10% (Llama-3-8B)
absolute. Code and data are available at https://github.com/belindal/ERASE | [
-0.35983821749687195,
-1.042403221130371,
0.5122617483139038,
-0.1574935019016266,
0.22120027244091034,
0.21857351064682007,
-0.2814512848854065,
-0.7326887249946594,
0.0692349225282669,
0.6177251935005188,
-0.3515012860298157,
-0.15715044736862183,
-0.49313631653785706,
-0.09627825766801834,
-0.7531454563140869,
0.9063715934753418,
0.015476363711059093,
-0.3917948603630066,
-0.41845569014549255,
0.05418567359447479,
-0.40313664078712463,
-0.35296398401260376,
-0.8632303476333618,
-0.38642361760139465,
0.3697991371154785,
0.40263739228248596,
0.9057447910308838,
0.9987069368362427,
0.24333594739437103,
0.3816688358783722,
-0.6182200312614441,
0.3507121801376343,
-0.6515946388244629,
0.4280881881713867,
-0.19912244379520416,
-0.358325719833374,
-0.3363107144832611,
-0.39422205090522766,
0.7493023872375488,
0.7880051136016846,
-0.32362857460975647,
-0.16234172880649567,
0.09418785572052002,
0.658149242401123,
-0.4918282628059387,
0.13813449442386627,
-0.9495941400527954,
-0.35827234387397766,
0.10678981244564056,
0.0966942086815834,
-0.3167112469673157,
-0.47885504364967346,
0.10650447756052017,
-0.7413878440856934,
0.3034042418003082,
-0.08747852593660355,
0.8032693266868591,
-0.059640973806381226,
-0.280466765165329,
-0.48805034160614014,
-0.7253055572509766,
0.42304280400276184,
-0.5717728137969971,
0.6882330775260925,
0.647055447101593,
-0.2322351336479187,
-0.3510538637638092,
-0.730939507484436,
-0.5902644991874695,
-0.22416254878044128,
-0.1301138997077942,
-0.031627118587493896,
-0.1825241595506668,
-0.0999356210231781,
0.30138611793518066,
0.1147305816411972,
-0.0842578187584877,
-0.04683629423379898,
-0.6549109220504761,
-0.19374743103981018,
0.39367541670799255,
0.08045345544815063,
0.3706704080104828,
-0.2577957212924957,
-0.012814565561711788,
0.319508820772171,
-1.0970733165740967,
-0.04601651802659035,
0.538337230682373,
0.41386985778808594,
0.39960819482803345,
0.62946617603302,
-0.5804134011268616,
0.6899057030677795,
0.27775806188583374,
-0.08772151172161102,
0.24002349376678467,
-0.2857018709182739,
-0.07902289181947708,
-0.08040927350521088,
0.22747491300106049,
0.2792055606842041,
0.06363969296216965,
-0.044593147933483124,
-0.36111772060394287,
-0.29942575097084045,
0.2807539701461792,
-0.6483381986618042,
-0.4459178149700165,
0.187519833445549,
-0.40040504932403564,
-0.18235163390636444,
-0.3291280269622803,
-0.2093503177165985,
-0.9447057843208313,
-0.6129472851753235,
0.46129727363586426,
-0.7544809579849243,
-0.2652546763420105,
-0.050349730998277664,
-0.1895032525062561,
-0.25733324885368347,
0.830162763595581,
-0.8679680824279785,
0.39442121982574463,
0.5416257977485657,
0.37164735794067383,
0.16191768646240234,
-0.29408976435661316,
-0.621087372303009,
0.22109223902225494,
-0.3475482165813446,
0.751790463924408,
-0.5970627665519714,
-0.43513059616088867,
-0.006583518348634243,
-0.09073137491941452,
0.10264696925878525,
-0.6609421372413635,
0.30161917209625244,
-0.7606876492500305,
0.4235111176967621,
-0.5133121609687805,
-0.8491562604904175,
-0.37972667813301086,
0.29367533326148987,
-0.6736612319946289,
1.0815961360931396,
0.03769247606396675,
-0.5811713933944702,
0.3466910123825073,
-0.5069971084594727,
-0.3766430914402008,
-0.04538067430257797,
0.41869428753852844,
-0.33772122859954834,
0.04418439418077469,
0.17652477324008942,
-0.05149983614683151,
-0.02873225323855877,
0.555711030960083,
-0.12809771299362183,
-0.263537734746933,
0.12717199325561523,
-0.34753862023353577,
0.7327497005462646,
0.2752130627632141,
0.0281986054033041,
-0.018292978405952454,
-0.9196960926055908,
-0.17152537405490875,
-0.13116055727005005,
-0.6039474606513977,
-0.6115742921829224,
0.35054469108581543,
-0.2953384220600128,
0.13183434307575226,
0.238466277718544,
-0.6877455711364746,
0.2433803379535675,
-0.43979498744010925,
0.14684663712978363,
0.8234697580337524,
0.34643128514289856,
0.5683798789978027,
-0.5777891874313354,
0.15779267251491547,
0.13141243159770966,
0.19553562998771667,
-0.5918446183204651,
-0.4758705794811249,
-1.0710806846618652,
-0.24930943548679352,
0.07721124589443207,
0.3154333531856537,
-0.6975364685058594,
0.040439411997795105,
-0.2014610320329666,
-0.5310415625572205,
-0.4239511787891388,
0.47172510623931885,
0.3334217667579651,
0.8614014387130737,
0.29010581970214844,
-0.003079998539760709,
-0.6482113003730774,
-0.6168303489685059,
-0.5614290237426758,
-0.18444614112377167,
0.1721060574054718,
0.07130865752696991,
0.2935667335987091,
-0.13599558174610138,
1.022144079208374,
-0.44338417053222656,
0.13866326212882996,
-0.08210059255361557,
0.08498866856098175,
-0.17772693932056427,
0.5339308381080627,
0.06996799260377884,
-0.789025604724884,
-0.3025354743003845,
-0.15885837376117706,
-0.7489474415779114,
-0.3381805717945099,
0.10956788808107376,
-0.1090129166841507,
0.37445613741874695,
0.6232817769050598,
-0.5800676941871643,
0.4656780958175659,
0.05523115023970604,
-0.3515808582305908,
0.26001599431037903,
-0.4328112006187439,
0.32064732909202576,
-0.8800144195556641,
0.15254126489162445,
-0.19445843994617462,
-0.23310701549053192,
-0.8278666138648987,
0.06799397617578506,
0.30751240253448486,
-0.11638591438531876,
-0.5737015604972839,
0.8766563534736633,
-0.6339189410209656,
0.0490468367934227,
-0.2712741196155548,
0.3560565114021301,
0.2459651529788971,
0.2908160388469696,
0.1774004101753235,
0.4721468985080719,
0.06417417526245117,
-0.7297400832176208,
0.017774565145373344,
0.5063371658325195,
-0.5489102602005005,
0.24015937745571136,
-0.28600916266441345,
0.1388414055109024,
-0.49316781759262085,
-0.005689509678632021,
-0.9121149182319641,
-0.1049036756157875,
0.04645567387342453,
-0.16544164717197418,
0.16887187957763672,
-0.14422033727169037,
-0.573325514793396,
0.05038517341017723,
-0.24120816588401794,
-0.08599511533975601,
0.3900816738605499,
-0.6250329613685608,
0.6184526681900024,
0.5395786166191101,
-0.5683693289756775,
-0.49797090888023376,
-0.3193328380584717,
0.06541170924901962,
0.0069151511415839195,
-0.460492342710495,
0.2024271935224533,
-0.19329878687858582,
-0.4569454789161682,
0.34790652990341187,
0.09838827699422836,
-0.2638661861419678,
0.2440069317817688,
0.27274730801582336,
0.21429061889648438,
0.017271172255277634,
0.6564163565635681,
0.17117662727832794,
0.05122528597712517,
-0.2641671597957611,
0.09107417613267899,
0.40460532903671265,
0.2373010367155075,
-0.3773856461048126,
-0.08745104819536209,
0.07878580689430237,
0.39339011907577515,
-0.4203360378742218,
0.8079141974449158,
0.2341882586479187,
-0.6594163179397583,
-0.014615323394536972,
-0.7462822198867798,
-0.07735294848680496,
-0.5249342322349548,
0.5149425268173218,
-0.4761577844619751,
-0.6284793615341187,
0.7585684061050415,
0.1487397700548172,
0.38633039593696594,
0.36434027552604675,
0.3073424994945526,
-0.059928737580776215,
0.9184244871139526,
0.6233358383178711,
0.22189635038375854,
0.913714587688446,
-0.0347004234790802,
0.21362848579883575,
-0.9614437818527222,
-0.3102008104324341,
-0.4703714847564697,
-0.001675245352089405,
-0.3837421238422394,
-0.25503334403038025,
-0.017574112862348557,
0.4089287221431732,
-0.3759816884994507,
0.44480791687965393,
-0.36544832587242126,
0.4863615334033966,
0.8153519630432129,
0.23242609202861786,
0.6941180229187012,
-0.20360136032104492,
-0.010178329423069954,
-0.09090695530176163,
-0.5271942019462585,
-0.3559478223323822,
1.105499505996704,
0.16463400423526764,
0.6720536947250366,
-0.025191867724061012,
0.7753849029541016,
0.23356051743030548,
0.7144150733947754,
-0.28099891543388367,
0.47689536213874817,
0.0728970542550087,
-0.7054728865623474,
-0.25703513622283936,
-0.3648395240306854,
-0.6831576824188232,
0.2956258952617645,
-0.3585774898529053,
-0.734402596950531,
0.14512929320335388,
0.3964231610298157,
-0.038483623415231705,
0.6259263753890991,
-0.9249656200408936,
0.5986294746398926,
0.009477118961513042,
-0.4509449601173401,
-0.20737583935260773,
-0.19279207289218903,
0.3675170838832855,
-0.29356226325035095,
0.3743227422237396,
-0.1829935759305954,
-0.1059221476316452,
0.5239153504371643,
-0.5259471535682678,
0.8145416378974915,
-0.41049349308013916,
-0.1982545554637909,
0.5967851877212524,
0.43418657779693604,
0.8816555142402649,
-0.1425100415945053,
-0.5036455392837524,
-0.15753582119941711,
-0.021886635571718216,
0.003163999179378152,
-0.675565242767334,
0.7419981956481934,
-0.4072171151638031,
-0.620348334312439,
-0.10327600687742233,
-0.7573269605636597,
-0.18123306334018707,
0.29659539461135864,
-0.06362355500459671,
0.6512203812599182,
-0.3094084560871124,
0.0762944445014,
0.575951874256134,
-0.5501986742019653,
0.4484189748764038,
0.8462066650390625,
-0.5278264880180359,
-0.2139231413602829,
0.9019625782966614,
0.36564579606056213,
0.44259268045425415,
0.42036235332489014,
0.13721796870231628,
-0.27260714769363403,
-0.623715877532959,
-0.04470757767558098,
0.12739941477775574,
-0.9518024325370789,
-0.12437739968299866,
-0.992987871170044,
-0.09986449778079987,
-0.5122283101081848,
-0.1401943415403366,
-0.26159238815307617,
-0.6928243637084961,
-0.13366463780403137,
-0.22383663058280945,
0.47557055950164795,
0.8739835023880005,
-0.22183164954185486,
0.30946627259254456,
-0.747843325138092,
0.4330761432647705,
0.11602813750505447,
0.45617297291755676,
0.03160719573497772,
-0.6750244498252869,
-0.33163559436798096,
0.2294941544532776,
-0.3825840651988983,
-0.5069531202316284,
0.37491488456726074,
0.2721029818058014,
0.49444475769996643,
0.05343557894229889,
-0.0813879519701004,
0.8155552744865417,
-0.4880237579345703,
0.5192053318023682,
-0.18028835952281952,
-1.069704294204712,
0.49429306387901306,
-0.49593567848205566,
0.4344855844974518,
0.4815848767757416,
0.023008354008197784,
-1.0694526433944702,
-0.9548215270042419,
-0.7240291237831116,
-0.8469361662864685,
0.6371177434921265,
-0.06647073477506638,
0.20458483695983887,
-0.17930613458156586,
0.5427872538566589,
0.17678894102573395,
0.451402485370636,
-0.555948793888092,
-0.11933523416519165,
0.09584884345531464,
-0.39102399349212646,
0.12103157490491867,
-0.5241179466247559,
0.2939956486225128,
-0.17343857884407043,
1.065283179283142,
0.3284747004508972,
0.0517837256193161,
-0.07321405410766602,
-0.4729607403278351,
-0.1731637418270111,
0.10581814497709274,
0.45716139674186707,
0.77450031042099,
-0.1968824714422226,
-0.04925348609685898,
0.2365572303533554,
-0.4365833103656769,
-0.019126519560813904,
-0.032682087272405624,
-0.6890650987625122,
-0.16021476686000824,
0.38143855333328247,
0.41931843757629395,
0.359055757522583,
-0.8295484185218811,
0.11500273644924164,
0.087405726313591,
-0.1706315279006958,
-0.19405683875083923,
0.2365884631872177,
0.3831777274608612,
0.06168720871210098,
0.27656078338623047,
0.3412565588951111,
-0.02334160916507244,
-0.568669319152832,
0.2841763496398926,
0.11271213740110397,
-0.34402206540107727,
-0.33876001834869385,
0.7334176898002625,
0.1742510199546814,
-0.3866176903247833,
0.8905370831489563,
-0.27891698479652405,
-0.5439303517341614,
0.40773776173591614,
0.35676318407058716,
0.5158995985984802,
-0.32173746824264526,
0.08550865203142166,
0.34616222977638245,
0.44717249274253845,
-0.048141710460186005,
0.3058391511440277,
0.2722964882850647,
-1.077773928642273,
-0.35855385661125183,
-0.3871059715747833,
-0.4104045033454895,
0.14485351741313934,
-0.2847236096858978,
0.14941515028476715,
-0.37207168340682983,
0.030189216136932373,
0.20945094525814056,
0.06423410773277283,
-0.6242570281028748,
0.4586705267429352,
-0.08447357267141342,
0.7428702116012573,
-0.7631665468215942,
0.9045190811157227,
0.44513022899627686,
-0.5105671882629395,
-0.5541785359382629,
-0.34089428186416626,
0.08297988772392273,
-0.6210649013519287,
0.556426465511322,
-0.0752817690372467,
0.07175607234239578,
-0.005862392019480467,
-0.3801248073577881,
-1.2633579969406128,
0.6332458257675171,
0.6123724579811096,
-0.18050970137119293,
0.09019991010427475,
-0.363757461309433,
0.48304682970046997,
-0.04005084186792374,
0.20044462382793427,
0.43853759765625,
0.5052471160888672,
-0.23225010931491852,
-0.6612531542778015,
-0.19506622850894928,
-0.4197242558002472,
-0.23427711427211761,
0.498535692691803,
-0.3475860357284546,
1.0582826137542725,
-0.3254350423812866,
-0.2200329303741455,
0.17818738520145416,
0.5513309836387634,
-0.008242170326411724,
0.05061156675219536,
0.44857680797576904,
0.5122717022895813,
1.1006990671157837,
-0.1936476230621338,
0.9933663606643677,
-0.32892948389053345,
0.015841608867049217,
1.7975200414657593,
-0.5140505433082581,
0.8843729496002197,
0.3898638188838959,
0.11749698221683502,
0.48372599482536316,
0.36710062623023987,
0.28324589133262634,
0.4371212124824524,
0.08563411235809326,
-0.4483133554458618,
0.009369184263050556,
-0.11346185207366943,
-0.01703084446489811,
0.3742597699165344,
0.20494310557842255,
-0.26021870970726013,
0.008564764633774757,
0.13980965316295624,
0.32090315222740173,
0.3501441776752472,
-0.11325864493846893,
0.907904863357544,
-0.37266722321510315,
-0.9247031807899475,
0.252880722284317,
0.14043235778808594,
0.15756511688232422,
-0.5229074954986572,
-0.15894868969917297,
-0.4441157281398773,
0.33673718571662903,
-0.12997926771640778,
-0.7086813449859619,
0.39368072152137756,
0.036089085042476654,
-0.48837149143218994,
-0.3337648808956146,
0.8043121099472046,
-0.7808753252029419,
-0.42491763830184937,
0.2353815883398056,
0.551801860332489,
-0.033074162900447845,
-0.08576618134975433,
-0.473416805267334,
0.07838249951601028,
0.0648648664355278,
-0.5070181488990784,
0.28464239835739136,
0.3630211353302002,
-0.24553237855434418,
1.1240575313568115,
0.7772414684295654,
0.24204303324222565,
0.30535197257995605,
0.07138238102197647,
0.8032619953155518,
-0.5735419988632202,
-0.32894885540008545,
-0.4783798158168793,
0.5286644101142883,
-0.18371468782424927,
-0.06899124383926392,
0.697037398815155,
0.8228576183319092,
0.7571407556533813,
0.1549377739429474,
0.9006821513175964,
-0.19346649944782257,
1.1425161361694336,
-0.3495078384876251,
0.6816213130950928,
-0.3385480046272278,
0.3283299505710602,
-0.3670691251754761,
-0.7582722902297974,
-0.19650466740131378,
0.30771124362945557,
-0.36176350712776184,
0.1774640679359436,
0.6053454875946045,
1.0519757270812988,
-0.00009533395495964214,
0.029452895745635033,
0.21573783457279205,
0.4091949760913849,
0.5584207773208618,
0.16956447064876556,
0.9546722769737244,
-0.5723192691802979,
0.48622456192970276,
-0.4684883952140808,
0.1939251869916916,
0.020109079778194427,
-0.908113956451416,
-0.3760426938533783,
-0.6077991724014282,
-0.45703139901161194,
-0.24519400298595428,
0.30114859342575073,
0.6670348048210144,
0.2998487055301666,
-0.7460824847221375,
-0.16538992524147034,
0.03973502665758133,
0.39422160387039185,
-0.2789183557033539,
-0.1770371049642563,
0.4775458574295044,
-0.4704052209854126,
-0.7811369895935059,
0.46593472361564636,
0.06165625900030136,
0.06111297756433487,
0.1860855221748352,
0.045644380152225494,
-0.5419248938560486,
0.1391191929578781,
0.5312146544456482,
0.3710930049419403,
-0.56173175573349,
-0.6339253783226013,
-0.030459517613053322,
-0.04538172110915184,
0.11341755837202072,
0.5063760280609131,
-0.8768392205238342,
0.8863098621368408,
0.5866839289665222,
0.4291307330131531,
0.5327259302139282,
0.38142701983451843,
0.7283484935760498,
-0.6578369140625,
0.13422958552837372,
-0.22313979268074036,
0.4186922311782837,
0.6367978453636169,
-0.2896740734577179,
0.36547064781188965,
0.1839367002248764,
-0.38443803787231445,
-0.7134093642234802,
-0.05437406152486801,
-0.21431395411491394,
-0.3244015574455261,
0.9267385005950928,
-0.0320252887904644,
-0.10815022140741348,
-0.28115490078926086,
-0.4495052397251129,
0.33943867683410645,
-0.31377118825912476,
0.7081769704818726,
0.6177262663841248,
0.14043296873569489,
-0.05733468011021614,
-0.42182686924934387,
0.5847172737121582,
0.15923258662223816,
-0.9501677751541138,
0.463808536529541,
0.9352426528930664,
0.5831080675125122,
-0.0410488098859787,
1.0189213752746582,
-0.03462383896112442,
0.2671796679496765,
0.025328433141112328,
0.381317138671875,
-0.40427300333976746,
-0.32430946826934814,
-0.23342689871788025,
0.1867024004459381,
0.1919030249118805,
0.1100606694817543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11827v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11827v1 | WPO: Enhancing RLHF with Weighted Preference Optimization | 2024-06-17T17:59:13 | 2024-06-17T17:59:13 | Wenxuan Zhou, Ravi Agrawal, Shujian Zhang, Sathish Reddy Indurthi, Sanqiang Zhao, Kaiqiang Song, Silei Xu, Chenguang Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) is a promising solution to
align large language models (LLMs) more closely with human values. Off-policy
preference optimization, where the preference data is obtained from other
models, is widely adopted due to its cost efficiency and scalability. However,
off-policy preference optimization often suffers from a distributional gap
between the policy used for data collection and the target policy, leading to
suboptimal optimization. In this paper, we propose a novel strategy to mitigate
this problem by simulating on-policy learning with off-policy preference data.
Our Weighted Preference Optimization (WPO) method adapts off-policy data to
resemble on-policy data more closely by reweighting preference pairs according
to their probability under the current policy. This method not only addresses
the distributional gap problem but also enhances the optimization process
without incurring additional costs. We validate our method on instruction
following benchmarks including Alpaca Eval 2 and MT-bench. WPO not only
outperforms Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) by up to 5.6% on Alpaca Eval 2
but also establishes a remarkable length-controlled winning rate against
GPT-4-turbo of 48.6% based on Llama-3-8B-Instruct, making it the strongest 8B
model on the leaderboard. We will release the code and models at
https://github.com/wzhouad/WPO. | [
-0.4785723090171814,
-0.6221610903739929,
0.32611173391342163,
0.1646289825439453,
-0.19625185430049896,
-0.04829038679599762,
-0.4273780584335327,
-0.2522059679031372,
0.29966437816619873,
0.45788511633872986,
-0.7171790599822998,
0.012162270024418831,
-0.4463917016983032,
-0.10376735776662827,
0.5294744372367859,
0.8951494693756104,
0.053291261196136475,
-0.004684895277023315,
-0.2696549594402313,
-0.2754281759262085,
-0.28914159536361694,
-0.33607107400894165,
-0.4984157681465149,
-0.9542688131332397,
0.48096922039985657,
0.5229859352111816,
0.7169658541679382,
0.5432010889053345,
0.25378847122192383,
0.209319069981575,
0.04010925814509392,
0.3588811755180359,
-0.5862025618553162,
-0.12693561613559723,
0.09003324061632156,
-0.3392588496208191,
-0.3466510474681854,
-0.032918430864810944,
0.5136075615882874,
0.5867707133293152,
-0.8176114559173584,
0.0909600555896759,
0.015433894470334053,
0.8447586894035339,
-0.9513580203056335,
0.10497871041297913,
-0.4522055983543396,
0.4180958569049835,
0.09025237709283829,
-0.475543737411499,
-0.5136806964874268,
-0.48958590626716614,
0.31303858757019043,
-0.9735603928565979,
-0.2507002353668213,
0.3459913730621338,
0.81151282787323,
0.3327089548110962,
-0.21796852350234985,
-0.10386005789041519,
-0.4999988079071045,
0.9397817254066467,
-0.6650683283805847,
0.3965217173099518,
0.5085369348526001,
0.09380945563316345,
-0.3829551935195923,
-0.22520317137241364,
-0.6052814722061157,
-0.5427064299583435,
0.1938478648662567,
0.29009684920310974,
0.04405904561281204,
0.06643002480268478,
0.2265377938747406,
-0.05487055703997612,
-0.3429662585258484,
0.1742548793554306,
-0.11442568153142929,
-0.12225663661956787,
0.658912181854248,
-0.24818392097949982,
-0.17473478615283966,
-0.016259800642728806,
-0.505894660949707,
-0.4924842119216919,
-0.7047924995422363,
0.3027406334877014,
0.8266476392745972,
0.18705622851848602,
-0.0822685956954956,
0.4594336152076721,
-0.30165717005729675,
0.6774232387542725,
0.14178355038166046,
-0.40839770436286926,
0.5220512747764587,
0.3865492641925812,
-0.1615554243326187,
0.07024094462394714,
0.7107346653938293,
0.40362870693206787,
0.34950631856918335,
-0.0048133498057723045,
-0.3544842600822449,
-0.2569952607154846,
0.11473719775676727,
-0.811211109161377,
0.19425854086875916,
-0.014237591065466404,
-0.6394954919815063,
-0.616722047328949,
0.061244845390319824,
-0.7849549651145935,
-0.20305763185024261,
-0.0929073691368103,
0.38542747497558594,
-0.06466929614543915,
-0.22088927030563354,
0.20785458385944366,
-0.08018066734075546,
0.20274803042411804,
0.061592310667037964,
-1.1763416528701782,
0.305541455745697,
0.6003255248069763,
0.6561829447746277,
-0.20812641084194183,
-0.4055138826370239,
-0.7436292171478271,
0.13442203402519226,
-0.3944258391857147,
0.5842361450195312,
-0.4160757064819336,
-0.3907220959663391,
0.14369621872901917,
-0.27874699234962463,
0.1418483555316925,
-0.5344188809394836,
0.5030218362808228,
-0.5675021409988403,
0.4113452732563019,
-0.4039037227630615,
-0.5115798115730286,
0.09884218126535416,
0.43063420057296753,
-0.6697373390197754,
1.1929653882980347,
0.19190002977848053,
-0.7489830851554871,
0.41551724076271057,
-0.6861053705215454,
-0.3557679057121277,
-0.19502878189086914,
-0.05388479307293892,
-0.7281017899513245,
0.014558340422809124,
0.1528904289007187,
0.08045174926519394,
-0.14456480741500854,
0.19374804198741913,
-0.6803110241889954,
-0.5896766185760498,
0.1403183937072754,
-0.1906190663576126,
0.4930490255355835,
0.028196295723319054,
-0.36556369066238403,
0.21457506716251373,
-0.8561129570007324,
0.09550649672746658,
0.2749529182910919,
-0.446591854095459,
-0.4704205393791199,
0.039173424243927,
-0.17925091087818146,
0.23556657135486603,
0.15878993272781372,
-0.6430220007896423,
0.4438389539718628,
-0.6075959801673889,
0.2898099720478058,
0.9468508958816528,
-0.05866718664765358,
0.5827611088752747,
-0.28689736127853394,
0.7669131755828857,
-0.3890189826488495,
0.4770514965057373,
0.5516983270645142,
-0.4732952117919922,
-0.2913956642150879,
0.02053827978670597,
0.30568215250968933,
0.5501120090484619,
-0.7506425380706787,
0.6054100394248962,
-0.12508974969387054,
-0.0556425005197525,
-0.4201698303222656,
0.061938825994729996,
0.3473244309425354,
0.8303936123847961,
0.27784034609794617,
-0.27698859572410583,
-0.3963622450828552,
-0.7104936838150024,
0.13423459231853485,
-0.2946819067001343,
0.046735405921936035,
0.4936109185218811,
0.14818203449249268,
-0.012803744524717331,
0.9981037974357605,
-0.9518594145774841,
-0.3568638861179352,
-0.40447500348091125,
-0.0658164843916893,
0.017117397859692574,
0.17241384088993073,
0.3513323664665222,
-0.5886850357055664,
-0.29920080304145813,
-0.2118198573589325,
-0.33647117018699646,
-0.2174561768770218,
0.22901564836502075,
-0.24222972989082336,
0.31931406259536743,
0.07524961233139038,
-0.4791170656681061,
0.2107287049293518,
0.634662926197052,
-0.2563238739967346,
0.45415177941322327,
-0.6744361519813538,
0.03462750092148781,
-0.6661070585250854,
-0.05158105865120888,
-0.026344522833824158,
-0.1852828413248062,
-0.2356162965297699,
-0.15505315363407135,
-0.031363341957330704,
-0.039679188281297684,
-0.5517497062683105,
0.5269905924797058,
-0.14026209712028503,
-0.2864725887775421,
-0.493483304977417,
0.020710080862045288,
0.1076093316078186,
0.9342092871665955,
0.13473956286907196,
0.6778027415275574,
0.18774807453155518,
-0.4077783524990082,
0.33767572045326233,
0.148946613073349,
-0.19685062766075134,
0.30018913745880127,
-0.527990460395813,
-0.1383836567401886,
-0.20023082196712494,
0.5611475706100464,
-0.4633861780166626,
0.03706802800297737,
0.3131867051124573,
-0.13448454439640045,
0.16404367983341217,
0.05293094366788864,
-0.2481619119644165,
-0.20225371420383453,
-0.8295868039131165,
0.40040653944015503,
0.685036301612854,
-0.6262587308883667,
0.40191778540611267,
0.49622204899787903,
0.2988099753856659,
-0.9549052715301514,
-0.2896219491958618,
-0.5241391062736511,
-0.4002889394760132,
-0.2692160904407501,
0.5222510099411011,
-0.006202488671988249,
-0.017842089757323265,
-0.21565279364585876,
0.05367588624358177,
0.35315096378326416,
0.012326221913099289,
0.05806702375411987,
0.3482048511505127,
0.30982938408851624,
0.20561495423316956,
-0.11075291782617569,
-0.10704784095287323,
-0.1143871545791626,
-0.4108635485172272,
0.6879629492759705,
0.19178275763988495,
-0.1737958937883377,
-0.36238202452659607,
0.1316457986831665,
0.18193118274211884,
-0.07085622102022171,
0.6523371934890747,
0.6957948207855225,
-0.08499361574649811,
-0.5382372140884399,
-0.23804643750190735,
-0.49877217411994934,
-0.4625800848007202,
0.4273645281791687,
-0.31675484776496887,
-0.6525260210037231,
0.1832963526248932,
-0.052511509507894516,
0.034940771758556366,
0.07764367014169693,
0.47704222798347473,
-0.12356138229370117,
1.1439518928527832,
0.7102549076080322,
-0.36634039878845215,
0.8165521621704102,
-0.2806006073951721,
0.011375857517123222,
-0.8312697410583496,
-0.2499849498271942,
-0.14039330184459686,
-0.4242546558380127,
-0.6775252223014832,
-0.21672655642032623,
0.3813127279281616,
0.08690407127141953,
-0.25822123885154724,
0.08057008683681488,
-0.4514184594154358,
0.2076510488986969,
0.572830080986023,
0.2864657938480377,
0.16056059300899506,
0.16910667717456818,
-0.08930607885122299,
-0.0674571543931961,
-0.690267026424408,
0.04136807844042778,
1.2007025480270386,
0.3986758589744568,
0.9466627240180969,
-0.076247438788414,
0.7175275683403015,
0.7364841103553772,
0.29176411032676697,
-0.8867658376693726,
0.366278737783432,
-0.025265732780098915,
0.097707599401474,
-0.5758731365203857,
-0.724025547504425,
-0.8813793063163757,
0.5120763778686523,
-0.20591989159584045,
-0.3876028060913086,
0.22640596330165863,
0.5996976494789124,
-0.2599678039550781,
0.18138980865478516,
-0.49282023310661316,
0.5654855370521545,
-0.18088392913341522,
-0.30495989322662354,
-0.3851684331893921,
-0.5552027821540833,
0.336001992225647,
0.317945659160614,
0.26276907324790955,
-0.2317131608724594,
-0.2812460660934448,
0.8809105753898621,
-0.7468195557594299,
0.45560482144355774,
-0.5326094031333923,
-0.4122443199157715,
0.2168015092611313,
-0.41920006275177,
0.8980635404586792,
-0.015677249059081078,
-0.1363610327243805,
-0.1313256472349167,
-0.2599790692329407,
-0.42939987778663635,
-0.6928605437278748,
0.5268025398254395,
-0.9977447390556335,
-0.328175812959671,
-0.3925663232803345,
-0.4599625766277313,
-0.5916926264762878,
-0.09927140176296234,
0.22255480289459229,
0.3402045667171478,
-0.10794615000486374,
-0.15018442273139954,
0.7024340033531189,
-0.09952235221862793,
0.5197643637657166,
0.4231049418449402,
-0.22124361991882324,
-0.6835399866104126,
0.9909799695014954,
-0.12229975312948227,
0.40893951058387756,
0.58017897605896,
0.8667662739753723,
-0.5471834540367126,
-0.18555967509746552,
-0.6378278136253357,
0.23121222853660583,
-0.4414963722229004,
-0.18544979393482208,
-0.3371288478374481,
0.2248218059539795,
-0.39936894178390503,
0.07833436876535416,
-0.3511259853839874,
-0.535837709903717,
0.06590351462364197,
-0.04632218927145004,
0.27857881784439087,
0.3399973213672638,
-0.04412662237882614,
0.372367799282074,
-0.24133791029453278,
0.1430402398109436,
0.3362658619880676,
0.34827402234077454,
0.2420508712530136,
-0.5842745900154114,
-0.12581370770931244,
-0.002258181106299162,
-0.524387538433075,
-0.7632439732551575,
0.3110544979572296,
0.3294680118560791,
0.39956462383270264,
0.6032088398933411,
0.12701644003391266,
0.6229850053787231,
-0.40170565247535706,
0.22320771217346191,
0.2437085509300232,
-0.7117524743080139,
0.5003547072410583,
-0.11209497600793839,
0.15806908905506134,
0.4962255656719208,
0.2105434089899063,
-0.36947107315063477,
-0.003223372856155038,
-0.6413337588310242,
-0.6510961055755615,
0.7839255928993225,
-0.10312876105308533,
-0.0979175716638565,
0.3000340759754181,
0.4081616997718811,
-0.07750935107469559,
0.28051915764808655,
-0.7961984276771545,
-0.1496322900056839,
-0.1645601987838745,
-0.1258460432291031,
0.2775799036026001,
-0.10779504477977753,
-0.1747753620147705,
0.0016371449455618858,
0.99727463722229,
-0.45521727204322815,
-0.1426120400428772,
0.05867033079266548,
0.09501426666975021,
-0.2364722192287445,
0.1968529373407364,
0.7758306860923767,
0.6137570738792419,
-0.4023456573486328,
-0.14354683458805084,
0.29344120621681213,
-0.5625553727149963,
0.29843711853027344,
-0.09727083146572113,
-0.39511987566947937,
-0.43992361426353455,
0.36299949884414673,
0.8960773348808289,
0.2283271849155426,
-0.9758392572402954,
0.6479635834693909,
-0.01602586917579174,
-0.23045243322849274,
-0.058618612587451935,
0.04059406369924545,
-0.12561166286468506,
0.008517791517078876,
0.2815746068954468,
-0.14197061955928802,
0.03238525241613388,
-0.5465989112854004,
0.26720279455184937,
0.5767080783843994,
-0.44551554322242737,
-0.14246806502342224,
0.27944257855415344,
0.20890089869499207,
-0.2068307101726532,
0.21379098296165466,
-0.3934260606765747,
-0.5867264866828918,
0.5520865321159363,
0.7210280299186707,
0.367494136095047,
-0.1675797402858734,
0.3988448679447174,
0.28623709082603455,
0.08708448708057404,
-0.354509562253952,
0.35466402769088745,
-0.28567564487457275,
-0.8698374629020691,
-0.38351017236709595,
-0.7310349941253662,
-0.5342251062393188,
-0.04712024703621864,
-0.8285695910453796,
0.2913350462913513,
-0.5801642537117004,
-0.20195572078227997,
-0.4942290186882019,
0.34301087260246277,
-0.2614850401878357,
0.07548972219228745,
-0.010062160901725292,
0.6290091872215271,
-0.9411311149597168,
1.07155442237854,
0.4458603858947754,
-0.23942561447620392,
-0.8161292672157288,
0.2005075365304947,
-0.2134418785572052,
-1.225488305091858,
0.396586537361145,
-0.11939939111471176,
-0.15820667147636414,
0.018881453201174736,
-0.12121224403381348,
-0.8294785618782043,
1.1254149675369263,
0.36531415581703186,
-0.5683615803718567,
0.08400612324476242,
-0.03341308981180191,
0.27688294649124146,
-0.4035932421684265,
0.3710498511791229,
0.5886341333389282,
0.4745347201824188,
0.18227800726890564,
-0.6412412524223328,
0.10390770435333252,
0.4348604083061218,
0.20197825133800507,
0.3457586169242859,
-0.9973879456520081,
0.4487839341163635,
-0.45704737305641174,
0.25507524609565735,
-0.33907732367515564,
0.7425318360328674,
0.8366431593894958,
-0.04024767875671387,
0.9903977513313293,
0.9441191554069519,
0.588003396987915,
0.2659554183483124,
0.9438463449478149,
0.09065398573875427,
0.5376360416412354,
0.9082996249198914,
-0.6996700167655945,
1.0473088026046753,
0.6850676536560059,
-0.4282907247543335,
0.5551297068595886,
0.6843083500862122,
0.02200915664434433,
1.0673505067825317,
0.531970202922821,
-0.22042685747146606,
-0.10971903800964355,
-0.3429306745529175,
-0.22878660261631012,
0.4040919542312622,
-0.12921415269374847,
0.04750538989901543,
-0.10532163828611374,
0.29752063751220703,
0.10419122129678726,
0.1401042938232422,
-0.2420571744441986,
0.8124407529830933,
-0.12324292212724686,
-0.9410397410392761,
0.5496824383735657,
0.2063453495502472,
1.0349433422088623,
-0.8575655817985535,
-0.15273256599903107,
-0.27033379673957825,
0.3107086718082428,
-0.14929768443107605,
-0.36743035912513733,
0.021970510482788086,
-0.3950684070587158,
-0.25638076663017273,
-0.2103278487920761,
0.5828171372413635,
-0.6071298122406006,
-0.3599906265735626,
0.5709474682807922,
0.09931759536266327,
-0.3075003921985626,
0.19271178543567657,
-0.7763886451721191,
0.19267433881759644,
0.08010714501142502,
-0.5336551666259766,
0.5338665246963501,
0.10640441626310349,
-0.26613864302635193,
0.7391866445541382,
0.7202839851379395,
0.5382831692695618,
-0.16662070155143738,
0.5675483345985413,
0.4929748773574829,
-0.36248549818992615,
-0.9123945832252502,
-0.794046938419342,
-0.06988251954317093,
-0.16068612039089203,
-0.3314248323440552,
0.2790752351284027,
0.4658241271972656,
0.7604520320892334,
-0.0036767239216715097,
0.575186014175415,
-0.13708940148353577,
0.2572152018547058,
-0.5168073177337646,
0.6305772066116333,
-0.7076085209846497,
0.1469452828168869,
-0.043970853090286255,
-0.8987476229667664,
0.19733546674251556,
0.461126446723938,
-0.028981361538171768,
0.1005578264594078,
0.555451512336731,
0.8379483819007874,
-0.00042524232412688434,
-0.25016528367996216,
0.3967578411102295,
-0.3326578736305237,
0.23983518779277802,
0.7051426768302917,
0.6219998598098755,
-0.28600233793258667,
0.6867619752883911,
-0.4379843473434448,
-0.6121554374694824,
-0.2075706124305725,
-1.001462459564209,
-0.6349062919616699,
-0.2915467619895935,
-0.1363219916820526,
-0.2612186074256897,
0.08970916271209717,
1.1534188985824585,
0.9929120540618896,
-0.5259135365486145,
-0.2837333083152771,
-0.007791297975927591,
0.30703938007354736,
-0.5130475163459778,
-0.26463037729263306,
0.49756237864494324,
-0.24714675545692444,
-0.6033086180686951,
0.3006366491317749,
0.18143430352210999,
-0.10658501833677292,
-0.5225135087966919,
-0.5603770017623901,
-0.044400643557310104,
0.1446673423051834,
0.5262854695320129,
0.3966172933578491,
-0.6710349321365356,
-0.26230674982070923,
-0.3218575119972229,
-0.001338582020252943,
-0.04240516945719719,
0.9986326694488525,
-0.7671317458152771,
0.08361288160085678,
0.5752739310264587,
0.6016170978546143,
0.4411330819129944,
0.2895428538322449,
0.5980620980262756,
-0.9108113050460815,
0.49145200848579407,
0.08775491267442703,
0.42809537053108215,
0.23545029759407043,
-0.5247743725776672,
0.3821031451225281,
0.3750549852848053,
-0.5085806250572205,
-0.8092132806777954,
0.22023354470729828,
-0.9069709181785583,
-0.2186158001422882,
1.074979543685913,
-0.06994490325450897,
-0.1933417171239853,
0.346005380153656,
-0.00036708838888444006,
0.09135203063488007,
-0.7313417792320251,
1.0081110000610352,
0.534058153629303,
-0.4596790075302124,
-0.1823084056377411,
-0.5120878219604492,
0.789523184299469,
0.6602219939231873,
-0.9618287086486816,
-0.03310569003224373,
0.13725364208221436,
0.3305830657482147,
-0.22047306597232819,
0.8854858875274658,
0.15633746981620789,
0.16278403997421265,
-0.38216450810432434,
0.2147880494594574,
-0.2537391781806946,
-0.22574017941951752,
-0.22346018254756927,
0.25207284092903137,
0.1509895920753479,
-0.4339666962623596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11823v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11823v1 | On Efficient Language and Vision Assistants for Visually-Situated Natural Language Understanding: What Matters in Reading and Reasoning | 2024-06-17T17:57:30 | 2024-06-17T17:57:30 | Geewook Kim, Minjoon Seo | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Recent advancements in language and vision assistants have showcased
impressive capabilities but suffer from a lack of transparency, limiting
broader research and reproducibility. While open-source models handle general
image tasks effectively, they face challenges with the high computational
demands of complex visually-situated text understanding. Such tasks often
require increased token inputs and large vision modules to harness
high-resolution information. Striking a balance between model size and data
importance remains an open question. This study aims to redefine the design of
vision-language models by identifying key components and creating efficient
models with constrained inference costs. By strategically formulating datasets,
optimizing vision modules, and enhancing supervision techniques, we achieve
significant improvements in inference throughput while maintaining high
performance. Extensive experiments across models ranging from 160M to 13B
parameters offer insights into model optimization. We will fully open-source
our codebase, models, and datasets at https://github.com/naver-ai/elva . | [
-0.3343244791030884,
-0.7828986048698425,
0.731769323348999,
0.1428331583738327,
-0.17886489629745483,
-0.42171669006347656,
-0.17654167115688324,
-0.880725622177124,
-0.21605829894542694,
0.6916504502296448,
-0.25315719842910767,
-0.4110022187232971,
-0.3972656726837158,
0.044164493680000305,
-0.23790569603443146,
0.3672686815261841,
-0.10192026197910309,
-0.05099671706557274,
-0.436771959066391,
-0.4077114760875702,
-0.3172822594642639,
-0.02085813134908676,
-0.48580917716026306,
0.02748109959065914,
0.5548654794692993,
0.37235575914382935,
0.7066697478294373,
0.9652900099754333,
0.6399799585342407,
0.3767746686935425,
-0.21742790937423706,
0.37247776985168457,
-0.1762094646692276,
0.05944050848484039,
-0.25850245356559753,
-0.4584295451641083,
-0.39596882462501526,
-0.1853867471218109,
0.5388804078102112,
0.8089039325714111,
-0.01507589966058731,
0.15570557117462158,
0.12827804684638977,
0.8410782814025879,
-1.0257269144058228,
0.4920833706855774,
-0.3534245193004608,
-0.1943260282278061,
-0.06252223253250122,
0.08533366769552231,
-0.6811047196388245,
-0.16379348933696747,
0.504804790019989,
-1.1828862428665161,
0.23842956125736237,
0.20893390476703644,
0.8873419761657715,
0.5762746930122375,
-0.29327645897865295,
-0.14418214559555054,
-0.562423050403595,
0.7881626486778259,
-0.38773930072784424,
0.6923055052757263,
0.5182648301124573,
0.24527229368686676,
0.23376613855361938,
-0.5252659320831299,
-0.47815898060798645,
0.008525229059159756,
-0.18942533433437347,
0.10102132707834244,
-0.33116430044174194,
0.25558891892433167,
0.13281583786010742,
0.13586220145225525,
-0.6068830490112305,
0.03268800675868988,
-0.4232303500175476,
0.1410825401544571,
0.343789279460907,
-0.05288337916135788,
0.39526480436325073,
-0.24198703467845917,
0.039517998695373535,
-0.16581201553344727,
-0.3815062940120697,
-0.15527446568012238,
0.19104482233524323,
0.03993136063218117,
-0.14225144684314728,
0.6419460773468018,
-0.3295089900493622,
1.1838898658752441,
-0.17299401760101318,
0.03209654614329338,
0.1477457582950592,
-0.6556422710418701,
-0.42549073696136475,
-0.3498622179031372,
0.3436797261238098,
0.3299490213394165,
0.4682924151420593,
-0.13886860013008118,
-0.022296514362096786,
0.10358580201864243,
0.46907126903533936,
-0.5377777814865112,
-0.2714322805404663,
0.19163677096366882,
-0.3388308584690094,
-0.20304855704307556,
-0.09203915297985077,
-0.8032459020614624,
-0.5108416080474854,
-0.7251160144805908,
0.6059311032295227,
-0.27729541063308716,
-0.03980209305882454,
0.3010988235473633,
-0.2196500152349472,
0.26590174436569214,
0.7279619574546814,
-0.9297537207603455,
0.13434630632400513,
0.4026157259941101,
0.7656036615371704,
-0.005910898558795452,
-0.06775940954685211,
-0.5873652696609497,
0.22315974533557892,
-0.3889104723930359,
0.6016973853111267,
-0.5937258005142212,
-0.06892456859350204,
-0.12743499875068665,
-0.09166492521762848,
-0.3763168156147003,
-0.305200457572937,
0.5216189026832581,
-0.44642776250839233,
0.20411032438278198,
0.02063792198896408,
-0.36934173107147217,
-0.2777869701385498,
0.12214314937591553,
-1.0255125761032104,
0.6564508676528931,
-0.1487998217344284,
-0.7667202353477478,
0.4318540394306183,
-0.828966498374939,
-0.3896481990814209,
0.11119057983160019,
-0.20972391963005066,
-0.29057061672210693,
0.30148953199386597,
0.74457848072052,
0.3186960816383362,
-0.1437273919582367,
0.14657121896743774,
0.021599875763058662,
-0.3286541998386383,
-0.10340920835733414,
-0.36072883009910583,
0.7097755074501038,
0.13165834546089172,
-0.2906247675418854,
0.2352151870727539,
-0.8848992586135864,
-0.1747782975435257,
0.14687032997608185,
-0.30514222383499146,
-0.7800191640853882,
0.30054163932800293,
0.03115520067512989,
-0.4022868275642395,
0.20055323839187622,
-0.5132055878639221,
-0.11603625118732452,
-0.5316882729530334,
0.2555444538593292,
0.6058156490325928,
-0.2794961631298065,
0.9123243093490601,
0.29366055130958557,
0.47604483366012573,
-0.19216814637184143,
0.5254429578781128,
-0.2737892270088196,
-0.42046448588371277,
-0.8996809720993042,
-0.6205123662948608,
0.07143883407115936,
0.48594674468040466,
-1.05657160282135,
0.10407357662916183,
-0.13757668435573578,
-0.3514072895050049,
-0.7927404642105103,
0.04762134328484535,
0.5018478035926819,
0.7121667265892029,
0.37698543071746826,
0.0019470939878374338,
-0.25361186265945435,
-0.9570557475090027,
-0.36329957842826843,
-0.1974351555109024,
0.026079732924699783,
0.5360493063926697,
0.36026182770729065,
-0.1921330988407135,
0.8146747350692749,
-0.5315362215042114,
-0.09003502875566483,
-0.31954890489578247,
-0.125164195895195,
0.07273627072572708,
0.2729322612285614,
0.5634978413581848,
-1.1252844333648682,
-0.3241065740585327,
0.39279887080192566,
-0.7896069288253784,
-0.37914302945137024,
-0.16788126528263092,
-0.33811911940574646,
0.3132086396217346,
0.4781828820705414,
-0.5221955180168152,
0.7587396502494812,
0.7328039407730103,
-0.4610098600387573,
0.3706654906272888,
-0.36179599165916443,
0.04580516740679741,
-0.7619732618331909,
0.1703871637582779,
0.3362639546394348,
-0.10690470039844513,
-0.6553951501846313,
0.42122960090637207,
0.20872671902179718,
-0.03329360485076904,
-0.30890771746635437,
0.6919366717338562,
-0.764724612236023,
-0.10367753356695175,
0.030359992757439613,
0.30438223481178284,
0.47382742166519165,
0.5310029983520508,
0.23031337559223175,
0.820716917514801,
0.5606497526168823,
-0.49512597918510437,
-0.005861049052327871,
0.3151765763759613,
-0.5309358239173889,
0.48361146450042725,
-0.8687921166419983,
-0.1641060709953308,
-0.22118893265724182,
-0.192172110080719,
-0.7522188425064087,
-0.3289206326007843,
0.29106369614601135,
-0.18385303020477295,
0.22036565840244293,
-0.12940971553325653,
-0.44852572679519653,
-0.00006388228212017566,
-0.1271398514509201,
0.44183075428009033,
0.2055506855249405,
-0.924390971660614,
1.1109422445297241,
0.5272453427314758,
-0.0044900900684297085,
-0.5727382898330688,
-0.7635470628738403,
-0.07992688566446304,
-0.02237780950963497,
-0.7294296622276306,
0.13076575100421906,
0.25171610713005066,
-0.6145446300506592,
0.051521360874176025,
-0.09183122962713242,
-0.15796154737472534,
-0.07387258857488632,
0.13955454528331757,
0.3827865719795227,
-0.09546797722578049,
0.36528480052948,
0.014610668644309044,
-0.12453987449407578,
-0.22225786745548248,
-0.3189588785171509,
-0.01688668318092823,
-0.2715912163257599,
-0.46156519651412964,
-0.4970555901527405,
0.4485664963722229,
0.6807301640510559,
-0.7417628765106201,
0.7982437610626221,
0.2978983223438263,
-0.26255592703819275,
-0.23309269547462463,
-0.4400743842124939,
0.21247713267803192,
-0.476548433303833,
0.5222886800765991,
-0.3444558382034302,
-0.6989856362342834,
0.20675240457057953,
0.3053131103515625,
0.3355943560600281,
0.177888885140419,
0.3346540629863739,
-0.013317187316715717,
1.0113263130187988,
0.6103524565696716,
0.4257112145423889,
0.7760529518127441,
0.06768600642681122,
0.26687487959861755,
-0.6624577045440674,
-0.3622429370880127,
-0.4329286813735962,
0.03664329648017883,
-0.3189716041088104,
-0.7626479864120483,
0.36837321519851685,
-0.2048036754131317,
-0.005358786787837744,
0.2733544409275055,
-0.6302431225776672,
0.7295325398445129,
0.741479754447937,
0.25780153274536133,
0.44322267174720764,
-0.011085832491517067,
0.003350787563249469,
0.03089926578104496,
-0.7656913995742798,
-0.562942385673523,
0.8939806222915649,
0.35771891474723816,
0.9692720770835876,
0.27072983980178833,
0.20424872636795044,
-0.06580403447151184,
-0.17088094353675842,
-0.8045194745063782,
0.5274767875671387,
-0.1739252358675003,
-0.5065498948097229,
-0.4261282682418823,
-0.39208242297172546,
-0.8889489769935608,
0.5937783718109131,
-0.06197651848196983,
-0.6503609418869019,
0.5761173367500305,
0.37048232555389404,
0.034375716000795364,
0.20406101644039154,
-1.281646728515625,
1.0634620189666748,
-0.061158303171396255,
-0.5328191518783569,
-0.2902299463748932,
-0.620492696762085,
0.2311018854379654,
-0.01376188825815916,
0.12929709255695343,
0.21635788679122925,
-0.196823388338089,
0.4007829427719116,
-0.29165560007095337,
0.9260876178741455,
-0.017678895965218544,
-0.04957559332251549,
0.39753100275993347,
-0.1010742112994194,
0.24207031726837158,
-0.15197710692882538,
-0.1437883824110031,
0.12496054172515869,
-0.03142077103257179,
-0.5444130301475525,
-0.5806832909584045,
0.37128889560699463,
-0.6279509663581848,
-0.37164151668548584,
-0.12670479714870453,
-0.5111684203147888,
0.05518043413758278,
0.16081145405769348,
0.021624214947223663,
0.8342702388763428,
-0.10017579048871994,
0.4093037545681,
0.9200824499130249,
-0.43185654282569885,
0.19420991837978363,
0.30422261357307434,
-0.22167055308818817,
-0.11281266063451767,
0.8223824501037598,
0.06808929890394211,
0.508438766002655,
0.6334439516067505,
0.00855155661702156,
-0.3415130376815796,
-0.4621626138687134,
-0.6065795421600342,
0.2320692241191864,
-0.877417802810669,
0.24243006110191345,
-0.5927475094795227,
0.15365193784236908,
-0.2832050919532776,
-0.23435433208942413,
-0.302374929189682,
-0.2790676951408386,
-0.46547117829322815,
-0.11062687635421753,
0.38593435287475586,
0.5478321313858032,
-0.014015915803611279,
0.24973468482494354,
-0.42131227254867554,
0.5272146463394165,
0.3478530943393707,
0.3689570724964142,
0.12163947522640228,
-0.23025868833065033,
-0.35942137241363525,
-0.30336305499076843,
0.2030455619096756,
-0.7678597569465637,
0.39671841263771057,
0.21589119732379913,
0.5774816274642944,
0.36650577187538147,
-0.10004917532205582,
0.5452390909194946,
-0.4764537811279297,
0.4154205322265625,
-0.027566321194171906,
-0.8613733053207397,
0.7077896595001221,
-0.24112263321876526,
0.5940940380096436,
0.47878822684288025,
-0.0407315194606781,
-0.1630735695362091,
-0.35843804478645325,
-0.22503246366977692,
-0.8325361609458923,
0.6071457266807556,
0.3018190860748291,
-0.33670568466186523,
0.08200294524431229,
0.25563135743141174,
-0.028447536751627922,
-0.095793217420578,
-0.4296668469905853,
0.1773999184370041,
-0.22444283962249756,
-0.47087523341178894,
0.03262906149029732,
0.010040638037025928,
0.12951777875423431,
-0.5324581861495972,
0.4903269410133362,
-0.30307793617248535,
0.0000953139751800336,
0.3656889796257019,
-0.34750205278396606,
0.26843276619911194,
0.1129981055855751,
0.3238518536090851,
0.7074809670448303,
0.06028345227241516,
0.16664977371692657,
0.04578804969787598,
-0.7536604404449463,
-0.3166881203651428,
0.03858425095677376,
-0.2586573362350464,
-0.003511208575218916,
0.49840840697288513,
0.9950650334358215,
0.16658884286880493,
-0.9858077764511108,
0.37889009714126587,
-0.32485827803611755,
-0.16683758795261383,
-0.0007143833208829165,
0.32647836208343506,
0.10507757216691971,
0.355746328830719,
0.06250567734241486,
0.167850524187088,
0.11345846951007843,
-0.315964937210083,
-0.1466779112815857,
0.1720522940158844,
-0.16276663541793823,
-0.07427629828453064,
0.7062048316001892,
0.41191670298576355,
-0.11942587047815323,
0.5681596398353577,
0.17804722487926483,
-0.17533600330352783,
0.6043938994407654,
0.06150325387716293,
0.6301762461662292,
0.1496259570121765,
0.2804037928581238,
0.2376720905303955,
0.42607057094573975,
-0.022975020110607147,
0.1324988603591919,
-0.3416922986507416,
-0.7324483394622803,
-0.6477287411689758,
-0.5967443585395813,
-0.6077250242233276,
-0.3166065216064453,
-0.7392067909240723,
0.07543642818927765,
-0.22501906752586365,
0.08102890849113464,
0.06971906125545502,
-0.17803558707237244,
-0.6187804937362671,
0.2660866677761078,
-0.012073756195604801,
1.0036743879318237,
-0.7110795974731445,
0.6475575566291809,
0.5551947355270386,
-0.4357411563396454,
-0.6453848481178284,
-0.21652153134346008,
-0.12941431999206543,
-0.6551499962806702,
0.318379282951355,
0.15418104827404022,
-0.3813735842704773,
0.0016308686463162303,
-0.7099257111549377,
-0.6114510297775269,
0.9197496771812439,
0.4597623944282532,
-0.6538987755775452,
-0.18854960799217224,
-0.25437450408935547,
0.5941804647445679,
-0.1076035276055336,
0.07699432224035263,
0.5241806507110596,
0.4476657807826996,
0.022646330296993256,
-0.7391746044158936,
-0.30874770879745483,
-0.31193050742149353,
-0.08121902495622635,
0.31104788184165955,
-0.3723374903202057,
0.5629683136940002,
-0.31401121616363525,
-0.15389055013656616,
0.12945030629634857,
0.5042233467102051,
0.2643736004829407,
0.2728325426578522,
0.44435757398605347,
0.5735540390014648,
0.7848852872848511,
-0.006125648971647024,
1.2476160526275635,
0.035693906247615814,
-0.012911731377243996,
1.097474455833435,
-0.0325867161154747,
0.8559756278991699,
0.6927995085716248,
0.22182080149650574,
0.3064326047897339,
0.45003870129585266,
0.08011599630117416,
0.4577653706073761,
-0.22088532149791718,
-0.23251640796661377,
-0.3579813539981842,
-0.17610712349414825,
0.1111881360411644,
0.4908863604068756,
0.35429003834724426,
-0.4437605142593384,
-0.01052943803369999,
-0.0748576745390892,
-0.41195380687713623,
0.2687327265739441,
-0.30976584553718567,
0.6393746137619019,
-0.05706774815917015,
-0.5792239308357239,
0.16174551844596863,
-0.237687349319458,
0.2586042582988739,
-0.44109800457954407,
-0.08271616697311401,
-0.021210964769124985,
0.379555344581604,
-0.033751700073480606,
-0.8009758591651917,
0.2789715528488159,
0.3064665198326111,
-0.16457077860832214,
-0.2112247347831726,
0.748395562171936,
-0.27730125188827515,
-0.5391268730163574,
0.3200206458568573,
0.5573433041572571,
0.13791488111019135,
-0.14396241307258606,
-0.45674940943717957,
0.20179623365402222,
-0.04999472200870514,
-0.3763178884983063,
-0.012668321840465069,
0.5103989243507385,
-0.1524389237165451,
0.7268657684326172,
0.601030170917511,
0.11287935823202133,
0.13248112797737122,
0.41062691807746887,
0.6188639998435974,
-0.3952174186706543,
-0.4496789872646332,
-0.6668336391448975,
0.594321072101593,
-0.21906398236751556,
-0.3777468502521515,
0.5569912195205688,
0.37253841757774353,
0.6688059568405151,
-0.07117795944213867,
0.46407073736190796,
0.12989620864391327,
0.3655088245868683,
-0.5979763865470886,
0.7666619420051575,
-0.8811043500900269,
0.06695400923490524,
-0.4303545355796814,
-0.7733944654464722,
-0.6419152021408081,
0.8448557257652283,
-0.4762036204338074,
-0.18940801918506622,
0.35464388132095337,
0.7737495303153992,
-0.11074012517929077,
0.07369948923587799,
0.2574436068534851,
0.05707612633705139,
0.32958507537841797,
0.4442550539970398,
0.4969177842140198,
-0.20963704586029053,
0.6037284731864929,
-0.007453919388353825,
-0.30430305004119873,
-0.21927963197231293,
-0.7431657910346985,
-0.9025986194610596,
-0.4900412857532501,
-0.3693107068538666,
0.18483678996562958,
0.13518676161766052,
0.45006269216537476,
0.7901319861412048,
-0.34073707461357117,
0.16602300107479095,
-0.5222123265266418,
0.19111071527004242,
-0.06328683346509933,
-0.2012627273797989,
0.4951627850532532,
-0.01889036037027836,
-0.9669627547264099,
0.2976672053337097,
0.5099259614944458,
0.07706758379936218,
-0.3625626564025879,
-0.09948015213012695,
-0.30911412835121155,
0.3303433358669281,
0.7792130708694458,
0.28143975138664246,
-0.8479424715042114,
-0.2497784048318863,
0.11492424458265305,
-0.21398206055164337,
-0.05971010774374008,
0.2111283391714096,
-0.7427952289581299,
0.9682948589324951,
0.8101206421852112,
0.9399465918540955,
0.4691556692123413,
0.1502562165260315,
0.7021780014038086,
-0.6041887402534485,
0.20483621954917908,
0.06267674267292023,
0.43690308928489685,
0.44464826583862305,
-0.2678477168083191,
0.7986001968383789,
0.03656655550003052,
-0.42193713784217834,
-0.7160381078720093,
0.1969476044178009,
-1.0212900638580322,
-0.5413251519203186,
0.9653655886650085,
0.019709676504135132,
-0.7048165202140808,
-0.08378854393959045,
-0.5168355703353882,
0.1600465625524521,
-0.09991015493869781,
0.36498597264289856,
0.5299637913703918,
-0.13424962759017944,
-0.5321862697601318,
-0.6699070334434509,
0.13976892828941345,
0.4416237473487854,
-0.9170072674751282,
0.15635360777378082,
0.635640561580658,
-0.18367508053779602,
0.053531672805547714,
0.32205232977867126,
-0.02391349896788597,
0.3848131000995636,
0.21989962458610535,
0.10372738540172577,
0.018252449110150337,
-0.6917589902877808,
-0.32590624690055847,
0.03510468453168869,
-0.19972452521324158,
-0.4370802342891693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11817v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11817v1 | Iterative Length-Regularized Direct Preference Optimization: A Case Study on Improving 7B Language Models to GPT-4 Level | 2024-06-17T17:55:38 | 2024-06-17T17:55:38 | Jie Liu, Zhanhui Zhou, Jiaheng Liu, Xingyuan Bu, Chao Yang, Han-Sen Zhong, Wanli Ouyang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), a standard method for aligning language
models with human preferences, is traditionally applied to offline preferences.
Recent studies show that DPO benefits from iterative training with online
preferences labeled by a trained reward model. In this work, we identify a
pitfall of vanilla iterative DPO - improved response quality can lead to
increased verbosity. To address this, we introduce iterative length-regularized
DPO (iLR-DPO) to penalize response length. Our empirical results show that
iLR-DPO can enhance a 7B model to perform on par with GPT-4 without increasing
verbosity. Specifically, our 7B model achieves a $50.5\%$ length-controlled win
rate against $\texttt{GPT-4 Preview}$ on AlpacaEval 2.0, and excels across
standard benchmarks including MT-Bench, Arena-Hard and OpenLLM Leaderboard.
These results demonstrate the effectiveness of iterative DPO in aligning
language models with human feedback. | [
-0.502419650554657,
-0.5372953414916992,
0.5965970754623413,
0.27146127820014954,
-0.506862223148346,
0.10088375210762024,
-0.5138683915138245,
-0.44077953696250916,
0.1471281498670578,
0.34314247965812683,
-0.3066660165786743,
-0.27388206124305725,
-0.6721900701522827,
0.39161479473114014,
0.15186338126659393,
0.7339923977851868,
-0.09964039921760559,
-0.07419675588607788,
-0.015973595902323723,
0.19060426950454712,
-0.7435840964317322,
-0.42324990034103394,
-0.7507251501083374,
-0.22961920499801636,
0.5648767948150635,
0.6344706416130066,
0.8243497610092163,
1.0095274448394775,
0.6846825480461121,
0.26012298464775085,
-0.12014919519424438,
0.03764450177550316,
-0.7474086880683899,
-0.06353633850812912,
0.074412502348423,
-0.20768040418624878,
-0.5917588472366333,
0.008381737396121025,
0.681344211101532,
0.5871737599372864,
-0.5215756893157959,
-0.1158260777592659,
-0.033444758504629135,
0.944690465927124,
-0.41718825697898865,
0.21965137124061584,
-0.6723368167877197,
-0.07365644723176956,
-0.13102783262729645,
-0.3255755305290222,
-0.3454590141773224,
-0.5721185803413391,
0.33444833755493164,
-0.6231740117073059,
0.26094961166381836,
0.05995522812008858,
1.0153725147247314,
0.436008483171463,
-0.09649818390607834,
-0.30163654685020447,
-0.7756344676017761,
0.7025681138038635,
-0.9842353463172913,
0.39394310116767883,
0.5400914549827576,
0.3164893388748169,
-0.18092423677444458,
-0.30028361082077026,
-0.5060279965400696,
-0.6290526390075684,
0.10050614178180695,
0.15470150113105774,
0.024442965164780617,
0.527437686920166,
0.17878146469593048,
0.5114864706993103,
-0.4681013226509094,
0.3249436616897583,
-0.6591331362724304,
0.04627799615263939,
0.5739768743515015,
-0.01007656566798687,
-0.1994347870349884,
-0.019258273765444756,
-0.09099826961755753,
-0.08903878927230835,
-0.5491383075714111,
0.34541547298431396,
0.7798841595649719,
0.4001408517360687,
0.2776023745536804,
0.47658872604370117,
-0.5409448146820068,
1.0665308237075806,
0.44013458490371704,
-0.4224618077278137,
0.0317978709936142,
-0.11559651046991348,
0.14133435487747192,
0.24105632305145264,
0.5511585474014282,
0.6099733114242554,
0.19425246119499207,
-0.24602010846138,
-0.23160694539546967,
0.34969115257263184,
0.2537572383880615,
-0.9112637042999268,
0.061256326735019684,
0.25944969058036804,
-0.3302600085735321,
-0.29382020235061646,
-0.10518186539411545,
-0.7099727392196655,
-0.18040505051612854,
-0.39228636026382446,
0.3317691683769226,
-0.2709530293941498,
-0.19807521998882294,
0.517202615737915,
-0.0762525126338005,
0.006045341957360506,
0.2375565618276596,
-1.1343860626220703,
0.5148202180862427,
0.5266064405441284,
0.8145151138305664,
-0.3812756836414337,
-0.15450069308280945,
-0.6311804056167603,
-0.05754275619983673,
-0.4389808177947998,
0.7072767019271851,
-0.707474946975708,
-0.46558675169944763,
-0.1675364226102829,
-0.5483518838882446,
0.027341272681951523,
-0.5216728448867798,
0.7528231739997864,
-0.4682691693305969,
0.33427536487579346,
-0.2549150586128235,
-0.5959359407424927,
0.026709452271461487,
0.35768255591392517,
-0.6882436871528625,
0.9736825227737427,
-0.10798855125904083,
-0.6669848561286926,
0.42850953340530396,
-0.6745380163192749,
-0.11664273589849472,
-0.21487882733345032,
-0.1120300367474556,
-0.4354894757270813,
0.3295884430408478,
0.17653094232082367,
0.17077486217021942,
-0.3941311538219452,
0.50593501329422,
-0.38873961567878723,
-0.708925724029541,
-0.1012972891330719,
-0.1571713089942932,
0.11578205972909927,
0.16742679476737976,
-0.6455623507499695,
0.28936144709587097,
-0.8579402565956116,
0.014375673606991768,
0.08348405361175537,
-0.6424886584281921,
-0.18754903972148895,
-0.0012673353776335716,
-0.600532591342926,
0.2027183473110199,
0.2137456238269806,
-0.6603233814239502,
0.5995602011680603,
-0.700642466545105,
0.21566349267959595,
1.0581821203231812,
-0.39532604813575745,
0.6094974279403687,
-0.17405840754508972,
0.5031982660293579,
-0.2441779524087906,
0.540709912776947,
0.4379354417324066,
-0.47096458077430725,
-0.7750244736671448,
-0.42630061507225037,
0.3640640676021576,
0.14752256870269775,
-0.6298118829727173,
0.48895207047462463,
-0.4195123612880707,
-0.3698666989803314,
-0.5841774940490723,
0.06265803426504135,
0.17257317900657654,
0.6888609528541565,
0.46563422679901123,
-0.3327697813510895,
-0.21732893586158752,
-0.9870498776435852,
-0.0030156702268868685,
-0.1619291752576828,
0.06913866102695465,
0.303035706281662,
-0.1215597540140152,
-0.16654948890209198,
1.059836983680725,
-0.6017133593559265,
-0.3394673764705658,
-0.28858551383018494,
-0.1462756097316742,
0.2595541179180145,
0.15813347697257996,
0.6192542910575867,
-0.5110952258110046,
-0.5928958058357239,
-0.23487994074821472,
-0.13592499494552612,
-0.28535032272338867,
0.3527269661426544,
0.04071630537509918,
0.2585853338241577,
-0.33447468280792236,
-0.37428292632102966,
0.43369537591934204,
0.6566328406333923,
-0.20338772237300873,
0.16261643171310425,
-0.31946536898612976,
0.44989076256752014,
-0.7965341806411743,
-0.07151515781879425,
-0.15850113332271576,
-0.01608898490667343,
-0.5292948484420776,
-0.29107466340065,
0.0326850526034832,
-0.15045134723186493,
-0.12761715054512024,
0.6383004784584045,
-0.5315874814987183,
-0.208352193236351,
-0.5543907880783081,
0.18786399066448212,
0.11282756924629211,
0.5119402408599854,
0.2521994411945343,
0.5747845768928528,
0.32938870787620544,
-0.6955932974815369,
0.36559468507766724,
0.20211051404476166,
0.057652462273836136,
0.18384838104248047,
-0.671202540397644,
0.38499557971954346,
-0.17525756359100342,
0.1699540764093399,
-0.9006994366645813,
-0.10079798102378845,
0.19341593980789185,
-0.36444488167762756,
0.38934096693992615,
-0.13882574439048767,
-0.3732011616230011,
-0.4184454083442688,
-0.6930676102638245,
0.3020910620689392,
0.5021088123321533,
-0.5216914415359497,
0.33445659279823303,
-0.06373473256826401,
-0.21780873835086823,
-0.7368841767311096,
0.0016612010076642036,
-0.02256031706929207,
-0.34877488017082214,
-0.7060372829437256,
0.42891478538513184,
-0.41925546526908875,
-0.14087554812431335,
-0.38213643431663513,
-0.17100493609905243,
0.00022941925271879882,
0.041344255208969116,
-0.06832513958215714,
0.16445769369602203,
0.09957442432641983,
0.0025614744517952204,
0.05293494462966919,
-0.02119259536266327,
-0.4295935034751892,
-0.08632314205169678,
0.7055927515029907,
-0.23351916670799255,
-0.07264753431081772,
-0.48665469884872437,
0.4198431074619293,
0.01606147550046444,
-0.1570805162191391,
0.39548367261886597,
0.2167116403579712,
-0.17031624913215637,
0.12284732609987259,
-0.8090611696243286,
-0.4243472218513489,
-0.4954150915145874,
0.16009804606437683,
-0.6995401382446289,
-0.9131243228912354,
0.33436328172683716,
0.14560376107692719,
-0.07808078825473785,
0.3329896330833435,
0.41116079688072205,
0.4453628361225128,
1.2608497142791748,
0.8997499346733093,
-0.071404829621315,
0.6931474804878235,
-0.057313717901706696,
0.09177134931087494,
-0.43095406889915466,
-0.07255639135837555,
-0.4945506453514099,
-0.24239495396614075,
-0.5415216684341431,
-0.1539624035358429,
0.17990320920944214,
0.1947394609451294,
-0.1868482232093811,
0.16557176411151886,
-0.6686668395996094,
0.34146347641944885,
0.4373776614665985,
0.2513352036476135,
0.5108489990234375,
0.03418513759970665,
-0.04015345126390457,
-0.17727796733379364,
-0.7035092711448669,
-0.3832143545150757,
0.8675358891487122,
0.48114916682243347,
1.0093042850494385,
0.357166588306427,
0.7574430704116821,
0.16527479887008667,
0.27646127343177795,
-0.9360387921333313,
0.2329486906528473,
0.040066950023174286,
-0.41605907678604126,
-0.2770797908306122,
-0.5218225121498108,
-0.921246349811554,
-0.09344245493412018,
0.20357266068458557,
-0.7853270769119263,
0.26235225796699524,
0.6349798440933228,
-0.36392882466316223,
-0.054078783839941025,
-0.5895007252693176,
0.7127366662025452,
-0.3723929524421692,
-0.586412787437439,
-0.14560559391975403,
-0.7372415661811829,
0.18769621849060059,
0.0953311175107956,
-0.050644632428884506,
-0.38242673873901367,
-0.096527598798275,
0.5770983099937439,
-0.43894511461257935,
0.519655168056488,
-0.1914784163236618,
-0.14053720235824585,
0.012909413315355778,
0.0047893947921693325,
0.660034716129303,
0.08001182973384857,
-0.22770683467388153,
0.010856682434678078,
-0.24664896726608276,
-0.5055347084999084,
-0.48067474365234375,
0.9678954482078552,
-0.8950898051261902,
-0.9381946325302124,
-0.519815981388092,
-0.2926868498325348,
-0.4567917287349701,
0.08420295268297195,
0.3713643550872803,
0.4450473189353943,
0.07333113998174667,
-0.01705251820385456,
0.6088597774505615,
-0.07168277353048325,
0.46761855483055115,
0.5148460268974304,
-0.1454763412475586,
-0.5085597634315491,
0.6396384239196777,
-0.005667931865900755,
0.5635213255882263,
0.4033891558647156,
0.6832009553909302,
-0.6864231824874878,
-0.5998735427856445,
-0.5879786610603333,
0.28456252813339233,
-0.703083336353302,
-0.18705810606479645,
-0.47330695390701294,
0.32283762097358704,
-0.5493472218513489,
-0.07956493645906448,
-0.6692394018173218,
-0.39286887645721436,
-0.1429605782032013,
-0.20680812001228333,
0.45579981803894043,
0.801461398601532,
-0.08213584125041962,
0.3333454132080078,
-0.6142835021018982,
0.14791764318943024,
0.07373493909835815,
0.763973593711853,
-0.2384192943572998,
-0.842860758304596,
-0.04100431501865387,
-0.04184124246239662,
-0.22672609984874725,
-0.9071263670921326,
0.3579535484313965,
0.25942400097846985,
0.5780357122421265,
0.32475781440734863,
0.011917614378035069,
0.7057401537895203,
-0.5841188430786133,
0.5480850338935852,
0.1635272055864334,
-0.7630754113197327,
0.5844217538833618,
-0.4267597794532776,
0.23591014742851257,
0.6055045127868652,
0.6289506554603577,
-0.34109440445899963,
0.06254243850708008,
-0.5171127319335938,
-0.8302271366119385,
0.510940670967102,
0.18815769255161285,
0.10167046636343002,
-0.1234254539012909,
0.677160918712616,
0.2635223865509033,
0.4559086561203003,
-0.6389613151550293,
-0.14710992574691772,
-0.5394353866577148,
-0.14217916131019592,
0.03816917911171913,
-0.4773159623146057,
-0.18629390001296997,
-0.06101536005735397,
0.7437528967857361,
-0.38086485862731934,
0.3331143260002136,
0.18886399269104004,
0.0631595179438591,
-0.012473370879888535,
0.35633954405784607,
0.8004902005195618,
1.0817468166351318,
-0.5970336198806763,
-0.1758851408958435,
-0.21712027490139008,
-0.2647247314453125,
0.3187679350376129,
0.4285348355770111,
0.0708836019039154,
-0.04670147970318794,
-0.12278363853693008,
1.056686282157898,
-0.2786445617675781,
-0.4652390778064728,
0.48800355195999146,
-0.33614322543144226,
0.012361200526356697,
0.015219705179333687,
-0.19795538485050201,
-0.199018195271492,
-0.11127660423517227,
0.2870660424232483,
-0.2686201333999634,
0.5344980955123901,
-0.4960392117500305,
-0.12757034599781036,
0.1761871874332428,
-0.4240068197250366,
-0.2546430230140686,
0.6001399755477905,
0.4465498626232147,
0.020515402778983116,
0.23142877221107483,
-0.2072805017232895,
-0.47494712471961975,
0.4298829734325409,
0.5078306198120117,
0.5422422885894775,
-0.27404990792274475,
0.11961854249238968,
0.4781931936740875,
0.10348227620124817,
-0.5125113129615784,
0.1309760957956314,
-0.015317998826503754,
-0.6533560752868652,
-0.5135770440101624,
-0.6377468705177307,
-0.5291003584861755,
0.08642353117465973,
-0.5426217317581177,
0.4315394163131714,
-0.6461666226387024,
-0.2688755393028259,
-0.18564419448375702,
0.10385334491729736,
-0.5950118899345398,
0.20654024183750153,
-0.020490868017077446,
0.5918009281158447,
-0.48111018538475037,
0.7037279605865479,
0.4156670570373535,
-0.5079808235168457,
-1.1121245622634888,
-0.006605131551623344,
-0.17444032430648804,
-0.588966965675354,
0.6611254811286926,
0.2981608211994171,
-0.11473000049591064,
0.3089466392993927,
-0.15030516684055328,
-1.0181976556777954,
0.9840219020843506,
0.4425271153450012,
-0.8465873003005981,
0.013619380071759224,
0.17933525145053864,
0.40676066279411316,
-0.19931097328662872,
0.3179514408111572,
0.6381091475486755,
0.3765704035758972,
0.12244649976491928,
-1.266474962234497,
0.05630207434296608,
0.0771140456199646,
0.3129877746105194,
0.2648167610168457,
-0.9061543941497803,
0.5079831480979919,
-0.2778521478176117,
0.09897380322217941,
0.08387786895036697,
0.36691948771476746,
0.23726671934127808,
-0.16605113446712494,
0.5002700686454773,
0.5609161257743835,
0.6155431866645813,
-0.1532716304063797,
1.1163313388824463,
-0.23024679720401764,
0.4681210517883301,
1.0568970441818237,
-0.4608595669269562,
0.5926588773727417,
0.5345703363418579,
0.04238257557153702,
0.17830486595630646,
1.1275817155838013,
0.3973446488380432,
0.8245084285736084,
0.5194673538208008,
-0.221042662858963,
-0.07703936845064163,
-0.13775193691253662,
-0.45562297105789185,
0.4520708918571472,
-0.10036322474479675,
0.006048300303518772,
0.06252928078174591,
0.004895920865237713,
0.2244490087032318,
0.18775822222232819,
-0.2775269150733948,
0.8699713349342346,
-0.2310555875301361,
-0.917039155960083,
0.8308574557304382,
0.07327789068222046,
0.9382104873657227,
-0.6922905445098877,
0.04878068342804909,
-0.6919416785240173,
0.5023549199104309,
-0.014006146229803562,
-0.3067081868648529,
0.05435789003968239,
-0.0708298608660698,
-0.21104823052883148,
0.050303567200899124,
0.6790313720703125,
-0.43020522594451904,
-0.15770401060581207,
0.41832873225212097,
0.11676489561796188,
-0.11315736174583435,
-0.26363059878349304,
-0.6035712957382202,
0.3429047763347626,
-0.012839122675359249,
-0.5023605227470398,
0.3031390905380249,
0.16803190112113953,
-0.1637604981660843,
0.6008991003036499,
0.45597949624061584,
0.0401802696287632,
0.06717941164970398,
0.24026215076446533,
1.0911141633987427,
-0.4898452162742615,
-0.4822108745574951,
-0.9392099976539612,
0.3310851752758026,
-0.35490214824676514,
-0.19174443185329437,
0.4802565276622772,
0.6026972532272339,
0.8243756890296936,
-0.11450088024139404,
0.5916361212730408,
-0.03688638284802437,
0.5059676170349121,
-0.5351948142051697,
0.11874056607484818,
-0.5015593767166138,
0.3904237449169159,
-0.17330406606197357,
-1.0931588411331177,
-0.0685645192861557,
0.49625247716903687,
-0.3922165632247925,
0.11453888565301895,
0.6897963881492615,
0.712544858455658,
0.10228686779737473,
-0.46707743406295776,
0.5336545705795288,
-0.020256418734788895,
0.49220582842826843,
0.33856889605522156,
0.6302915215492249,
-0.16090478003025055,
0.7479706406593323,
-0.445935994386673,
-0.5473147034645081,
-0.25800850987434387,
-1.0309139490127563,
-0.8645994067192078,
-0.25182563066482544,
-0.17136311531066895,
-0.32880309224128723,
0.34142839908599854,
0.9877510070800781,
0.44850772619247437,
-0.32399195432662964,
-0.3279036581516266,
0.08511286228895187,
-0.2312515377998352,
-0.022737039253115654,
-0.26872649788856506,
0.18279147148132324,
-0.30505332350730896,
-0.8232495188713074,
0.3362746834754944,
0.3023502826690674,
0.11302921175956726,
-0.06608200818300247,
-0.25717902183532715,
-0.1698261797428131,
0.06136006489396095,
0.3843023478984833,
0.12056256830692291,
-0.8787202835083008,
-0.5205612778663635,
0.32286250591278076,
-0.021401893347501755,
0.4021906852722168,
0.7460154891014099,
-0.4223305881023407,
0.6678393483161926,
0.5069038271903992,
0.6188815832138062,
0.5834546685218811,
0.17760981619358063,
0.9407855868339539,
-0.7585451602935791,
0.30117762088775635,
0.30054593086242676,
0.36933043599128723,
0.6742300987243652,
-0.5339431762695312,
0.6012718081474304,
0.2719517648220062,
-0.6349288821220398,
-0.5164794325828552,
0.23525862395763397,
-1.0748096704483032,
-0.05855632200837135,
1.4438610076904297,
-0.1028626561164856,
0.11798625439405441,
0.2107492834329605,
-0.5447462797164917,
0.12666182219982147,
-0.8303270936012268,
1.1926668882369995,
0.6056075096130371,
-0.3476977050304413,
-0.09822378307580948,
-0.5520807504653931,
0.9993053674697876,
0.2970440089702606,
-0.8697863817214966,
-0.10012686252593994,
0.6419546604156494,
0.35199180245399475,
0.09106876701116562,
1.047593355178833,
0.0584624707698822,
0.17279168963432312,
-0.300737589597702,
0.17422345280647278,
-0.13094714283943176,
-0.24338765442371368,
-0.19309763610363007,
-0.20663774013519287,
0.6599708199501038,
-0.17190268635749817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11813v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11813v1 | How Do Large Language Models Acquire Factual Knowledge During Pretraining? | 2024-06-17T17:54:40 | 2024-06-17T17:54:40 | Hoyeon Chang, Jinho Park, Seonghyeon Ye, Sohee Yang, Youngkyung Seo, Du-Seong Chang, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Despite the recent observation that large language models (LLMs) can store
substantial factual knowledge, there is a limited understanding of the
mechanisms of how they acquire factual knowledge through pretraining. This work
addresses this gap by studying how LLMs acquire factual knowledge during
pretraining. The findings reveal several important insights into the dynamics
of factual knowledge acquisition during pretraining. First, counterintuitively,
we observe that pretraining on more data shows no significant improvement in
the model's capability to acquire and maintain factual knowledge. Next, there
is a power-law relationship between training steps and forgetting of
memorization and generalization of factual knowledge, and LLMs trained with
duplicated training data exhibit faster forgetting. Third, training LLMs with
larger batch sizes can enhance the models' robustness to forgetting. Overall,
our observations suggest that factual knowledge acquisition in LLM pretraining
occurs by progressively increasing the probability of factual knowledge
presented in the pretraining data at each step. However, this increase is
diluted by subsequent forgetting. Based on this interpretation, we demonstrate
that we can provide plausible explanations for recently observed behaviors of
LLMs, such as the poor performance of LLMs on long-tail knowledge and the
benefits of deduplicating the pretraining corpus. | [
-0.2121627926826477,
-0.7334626913070679,
1.1433303356170654,
-0.2974035143852234,
-0.26834481954574585,
0.07095729559659958,
-0.41630789637565613,
-0.3751307427883148,
-0.14214089512825012,
0.4586906135082245,
-0.4657432436943054,
-0.2206621915102005,
-0.8662829995155334,
-0.1930394470691681,
-0.2766145169734955,
1.2256605625152588,
0.03754580765962601,
0.029192909598350525,
-0.4664912521839142,
-0.07102827727794647,
-0.44504091143608093,
-0.824919581413269,
-0.31128084659576416,
-0.47936195135116577,
0.6826195120811462,
0.22924965620040894,
0.36431220173835754,
0.613166868686676,
0.2545561194419861,
0.28500697016716003,
-0.026915844529867172,
-0.10817377269268036,
-0.8982309103012085,
-0.006408977787941694,
-0.2255639135837555,
-1.1107224225997925,
-0.2619224190711975,
0.13639438152313232,
1.1358340978622437,
0.7712012529373169,
-0.3979452848434448,
0.1708672046661377,
-0.1645953357219696,
0.6525616645812988,
-0.7788254022598267,
0.2387438714504242,
-0.8500083684921265,
0.12806491553783417,
-0.31783872842788696,
-0.45098114013671875,
-0.485610693693161,
-0.3454999029636383,
0.25392305850982666,
-0.4969143569469452,
0.3575228750705719,
0.19508978724479675,
0.9268455505371094,
0.18197257816791534,
-0.4933326840400696,
-0.4972507953643799,
-0.8324227333068848,
0.7727943062782288,
-0.44171756505966187,
0.7083101868629456,
0.47814053297042847,
0.0022578872740268707,
-0.011698559857904911,
-0.7543520331382751,
-0.7586950659751892,
-0.4504815936088562,
-0.1531345248222351,
-0.038110632449388504,
0.22718533873558044,
0.008581827394664288,
0.7124912142753601,
0.33590006828308105,
-0.3250825107097626,
0.13716652989387512,
-0.424193799495697,
-0.18584880232810974,
0.3244973123073578,
-0.03499513491988182,
0.1633194237947464,
0.2439366728067398,
-0.3025657832622528,
0.10849130898714066,
-1.1076219081878662,
-0.08470648527145386,
0.07407473027706146,
0.09963716566562653,
-0.0712796300649643,
0.36048057675361633,
0.11156671494245529,
0.5281590223312378,
0.053157079964876175,
-0.4647494852542877,
0.23389139771461487,
-0.27577635645866394,
-0.18170355260372162,
0.29954203963279724,
0.5328278541564941,
-0.22044320404529572,
0.5114550590515137,
-0.2744722366333008,
-0.31020045280456543,
-0.4422735869884491,
0.32382291555404663,
-0.7464752793312073,
-0.21961675584316254,
-0.08447179198265076,
-0.2101382315158844,
-0.03642117977142334,
-0.04503803700208664,
-0.36862480640411377,
-0.31701189279556274,
-0.5712822079658508,
0.6882295608520508,
-0.4342694878578186,
-0.27973294258117676,
0.21647341549396515,
-0.041646070778369904,
0.20014022290706635,
0.3477194309234619,
-1.0019440650939941,
0.22437915205955505,
0.6639942526817322,
0.5872608423233032,
-0.049303505569696426,
-0.3990229368209839,
-0.5895172953605652,
0.17161104083061218,
-0.4479081928730011,
0.4769749939441681,
-0.19168241322040558,
-0.0533810555934906,
0.0927763283252716,
0.03282986953854561,
-0.408769428730011,
-0.6346530914306641,
0.13852384686470032,
-1.2290109395980835,
0.047492559999227524,
-0.814751148223877,
-0.7605527639389038,
-0.09516739100217819,
0.3500840663909912,
-0.41558101773262024,
0.6149402856826782,
-0.4456630349159241,
-0.9609171748161316,
0.769033670425415,
-0.2281004637479782,
-0.39791983366012573,
-0.18127642571926117,
-0.2409120500087738,
-0.35837215185165405,
0.40536966919898987,
-0.2753356099128723,
0.6366583108901978,
-0.1635626256465912,
0.3251108229160309,
-0.33569425344467163,
-0.30514076352119446,
0.4757886528968811,
-0.30603495240211487,
0.5748690366744995,
-0.027311252430081367,
-0.10032619535923004,
-0.3147783577442169,
-0.728979229927063,
-0.4563538134098053,
0.335435152053833,
-0.6033011674880981,
-0.2211659699678421,
0.1818230301141739,
-0.9075830578804016,
0.22317610681056976,
0.2967577874660492,
-0.4172348976135254,
0.0911811962723732,
-0.031801965087652206,
-0.11695743352174759,
0.6909990310668945,
0.2598499655723572,
0.31594836711883545,
-0.2626383304595947,
0.23304691910743713,
0.3680398166179657,
-0.32867324352264404,
-0.29662561416625977,
0.05798639729619026,
-1.03782057762146,
-0.01818264275789261,
0.2790476977825165,
0.4600093960762024,
-0.4563197195529938,
0.11538152396678925,
-0.4304739236831665,
-0.17756417393684387,
0.14746083319187164,
0.5103166699409485,
0.3265341818332672,
0.5534310340881348,
0.2554247975349426,
-0.13955806195735931,
-0.4104686379432678,
-0.5047568678855896,
-0.09986480325460434,
-0.2582051753997803,
0.17164619266986847,
0.016626674681901932,
0.6239976286888123,
-0.06909595429897308,
0.8953365087509155,
-0.5353821516036987,
0.1261139214038849,
-0.35673290491104126,
0.3308587968349457,
0.1636865735054016,
0.4583895802497864,
0.5803682804107666,
-0.6246330142021179,
0.010166848078370094,
-0.1711302101612091,
-0.85415118932724,
0.20254774391651154,
-0.24828673899173737,
-0.008450532332062721,
0.26818913221359253,
0.7517050504684448,
-0.9040804505348206,
0.19943606853485107,
0.3801898956298828,
0.024489283561706543,
0.9316904544830322,
-0.3951256573200226,
-0.254476398229599,
-0.6265855431556702,
-0.04159343242645264,
-0.3242742717266083,
-0.339428573846817,
-0.5009801983833313,
-0.28569671511650085,
0.03272572159767151,
0.2748958170413971,
-0.23947568237781525,
0.2157306969165802,
-0.6591765284538269,
-0.17023460566997528,
-0.13340850174427032,
0.24664032459259033,
-0.09333531558513641,
0.4263194799423218,
0.29584068059921265,
0.6806691288948059,
0.5585893988609314,
-1.092983603477478,
0.17240947484970093,
-0.07367337495088577,
-0.5511997938156128,
0.03771234303712845,
-0.37940526008605957,
0.22446341812610626,
-0.41415080428123474,
0.19716747105121613,
-0.8321782350540161,
-0.18423126637935638,
-0.15490272641181946,
-0.13976635038852692,
0.7377362847328186,
-0.23502206802368164,
-0.5906911492347717,
-0.22432342171669006,
0.23085029423236847,
0.25668686628341675,
0.5698804259300232,
-0.5616669058799744,
0.5461845993995667,
0.27641791105270386,
-0.2683005630970001,
-0.6742875576019287,
-0.5234892964363098,
-0.25213053822517395,
-0.212759867310524,
-0.27717074751853943,
-0.11843504756689072,
0.14930836856365204,
-0.3447626233100891,
-0.16875116527080536,
-0.22103282809257507,
-0.18460674583911896,
0.09118130803108215,
0.05572246387600899,
0.25205323100090027,
-0.420378714799881,
0.5953469276428223,
-0.20473439991474152,
0.026236677542328835,
0.6401166915893555,
-0.5255012512207031,
0.5562654137611389,
-0.05710788816213608,
-0.3833961486816406,
-0.26563504338264465,
-0.32636111974716187,
0.6773719787597656,
-0.25822070240974426,
1.3556123971939087,
0.47975432872772217,
-0.1854066401720047,
-0.19250836968421936,
-0.9662566184997559,
-0.18481367826461792,
-0.4015578627586365,
0.5714113116264343,
-0.38069233298301697,
-0.7865760922431946,
0.5073588490486145,
-0.3593641519546509,
0.06357794255018234,
0.2954329252243042,
0.5996419191360474,
-0.20565862953662872,
0.602871835231781,
0.7096368670463562,
0.043780624866485596,
0.45655620098114014,
-0.32171887159347534,
0.047984544187784195,
-0.4902205169200897,
-0.4271511733531952,
-0.26440873742103577,
0.06917830556631088,
-0.3268880248069763,
-0.4290016293525696,
0.04619722068309784,
0.3171488344669342,
-0.4353391230106354,
-0.21498776972293854,
0.4221036434173584,
0.5850104689598083,
0.40384507179260254,
0.09340760111808777,
0.3477718234062195,
-0.032401636242866516,
-0.3047264516353607,
0.048856306821107864,
-0.8843227028846741,
-0.37379300594329834,
1.1037757396697998,
0.4866909682750702,
0.7059667706489563,
-0.03902678191661835,
0.6457196474075317,
-0.08662481606006622,
0.39236804842948914,
-0.6058105230331421,
0.44066372513771057,
0.1805584728717804,
-0.7730358242988586,
-0.19638273119926453,
-0.5407475233078003,
-0.6859904527664185,
-0.11879340559244156,
-0.4442082941532135,
-0.5693827271461487,
0.2024058848619461,
0.5332663059234619,
-0.5140016674995422,
0.48806774616241455,
-0.5950722694396973,
0.7499914169311523,
-0.5138978958129883,
-0.4998498857021332,
-0.558335542678833,
-0.7419105768203735,
0.5639134645462036,
-0.5440211296081543,
0.27386149764060974,
0.02152659185230732,
0.2986682951450348,
0.8112567067146301,
-0.2806231677532196,
0.7828955054283142,
-0.3947860300540924,
-0.2063649743795395,
0.269356906414032,
0.014232248067855835,
0.518911600112915,
0.04430003836750984,
0.033331263810396194,
0.05343792587518692,
-0.10832235962152481,
-0.5069090723991394,
-0.6385875940322876,
0.13450539112091064,
-0.9027699828147888,
-0.640356183052063,
-0.4337620139122009,
-0.33490926027297974,
-0.41964301466941833,
0.1502116620540619,
0.4442247152328491,
0.4284032881259918,
-0.3469855487346649,
0.3399288058280945,
1.2742961645126343,
-0.288969486951828,
0.24764204025268555,
0.669691801071167,
-0.42879772186279297,
0.14205729961395264,
0.8208703398704529,
0.423464834690094,
0.6425802707672119,
0.45944833755493164,
0.051047999411821365,
-0.35903748869895935,
-0.8695411086082458,
0.09626030921936035,
0.5715823173522949,
-0.8341544270515442,
0.08213358372449875,
-0.7038247585296631,
-0.23688359558582306,
-0.327555775642395,
0.15361620485782623,
-0.4168166220188141,
-0.27392783761024475,
-0.08396966010332108,
-0.43586620688438416,
0.16442865133285522,
0.9639369249343872,
-0.25689321756362915,
0.5709952712059021,
-0.8028644919395447,
0.19432809948921204,
0.592491865158081,
0.14202742278575897,
0.1851355880498886,
-0.7533920407295227,
-0.6900537014007568,
0.0260333102196455,
-0.12724246084690094,
-0.4936981797218323,
0.10981325805187225,
0.08586636185646057,
0.6552397012710571,
0.7066282629966736,
-0.2569127082824707,
0.5896622538566589,
-0.590698778629303,
0.53950434923172,
0.20185838639736176,
-0.605360746383667,
0.3022705614566803,
-0.23613566160202026,
0.19483229517936707,
0.4933703541755676,
0.6957598924636841,
-0.2716386914253235,
-0.07824181020259857,
-0.5821940898895264,
-0.45184001326560974,
0.8367301225662231,
-0.2707587480545044,
0.15584410727024078,
0.02624097838997841,
0.5916197299957275,
-0.016774818301200867,
0.5023539066314697,
-0.7232739329338074,
-0.13811331987380981,
-0.18560802936553955,
0.17731112241744995,
-0.36399707198143005,
-0.7685140371322632,
-0.24996984004974365,
-0.3510139286518097,
0.6876867413520813,
0.14531129598617554,
0.2813485860824585,
-0.12722183763980865,
-0.6809855699539185,
0.21754074096679688,
0.11196396499872208,
0.646970272064209,
0.9339163303375244,
-0.26381009817123413,
0.2572944164276123,
0.5827901363372803,
-0.6082266569137573,
0.040237586945295334,
-0.2082081288099289,
0.11076835542917252,
-0.1275591105222702,
0.7236654758453369,
1.1690683364868164,
0.28144571185112,
-0.556467592716217,
0.6055923104286194,
-0.021002525463700294,
-0.17432135343551636,
-0.621191680431366,
0.20019517838954926,
0.18063153326511383,
0.016011463478207588,
0.3995003402233124,
0.07528184354305267,
-0.43258771300315857,
-0.852716326713562,
0.27930206060409546,
0.22433558106422424,
-0.08366482704877853,
-0.6137433648109436,
0.42668041586875916,
-0.11711809039115906,
0.2680007815361023,
0.8973963260650635,
-0.13851803541183472,
-0.719754695892334,
0.3650878071784973,
0.6716954708099365,
0.49444305896759033,
-0.19200758635997772,
-0.05537451431155205,
0.48850885033607483,
0.19573800265789032,
-0.3288176357746124,
-0.1527811586856842,
-0.24724774062633514,
-1.059624433517456,
-0.6753652095794678,
-0.8201487064361572,
-0.17021363973617554,
0.16403119266033173,
-0.6322410106658936,
0.24108529090881348,
-0.7270954847335815,
-0.0968477874994278,
-0.37909573316574097,
0.07003128528594971,
-0.9543809294700623,
0.5480502843856812,
0.43564602732658386,
0.784087598323822,
-0.8008249998092651,
0.9254505038261414,
0.335518479347229,
-0.2552226781845093,
-1.188383936882019,
0.19355575740337372,
0.040159206837415695,
-1.0779222249984741,
1.097927212715149,
0.029057450592517853,
-0.03192534297704697,
0.008381358347833157,
-0.5992577075958252,
-1.0889731645584106,
1.0182321071624756,
0.5376396179199219,
-0.6841503977775574,
-0.18914829194545746,
0.18633690476417542,
0.40325117111206055,
-0.26762425899505615,
0.09902983158826828,
0.7874142527580261,
0.3934359550476074,
0.3954116404056549,
-0.6609656810760498,
-0.03206314519047737,
0.16487571597099304,
-0.4608307480812073,
0.08703427761793137,
-0.5483989119529724,
1.0427217483520508,
-0.4898712933063507,
-0.22080448269844055,
-0.331915020942688,
0.6629588603973389,
0.27098771929740906,
0.15826129913330078,
0.41566112637519836,
0.690729022026062,
1.185677170753479,
0.022745974361896515,
1.1794617176055908,
-0.28634506464004517,
0.20957398414611816,
1.1141130924224854,
-0.2600253224372864,
0.6768328547477722,
0.2078706920146942,
-0.13491755723953247,
0.7103933095932007,
0.356079638004303,
0.26950687170028687,
0.4190978705883026,
0.01796911656856537,
-0.4039316475391388,
-0.6397609710693359,
0.19463664293289185,
-0.3864348828792572,
0.4994490146636963,
0.4637534022331238,
-0.2933676838874817,
-0.06674247235059738,
0.012101562693715096,
0.3036392331123352,
-0.38192442059516907,
-0.39391472935676575,
0.7812071442604065,
0.3105498254299164,
-0.677554726600647,
0.6462218761444092,
-0.32919028401374817,
0.24727977812290192,
-0.8926891088485718,
0.2793131470680237,
0.01979815773665905,
0.22895558178424835,
-0.048874251544475555,
-0.4669634699821472,
0.1446201056241989,
-0.09035968780517578,
-0.37348976731300354,
-0.24480785429477692,
0.6264070868492126,
-0.4324948191642761,
-0.2686792016029358,
0.09776268154382706,
0.6095967292785645,
0.14751814305782318,
0.02134445495903492,
-0.2977946102619171,
0.17920425534248352,
-0.11913358420133591,
-0.39418402314186096,
0.43224847316741943,
0.8577155470848083,
0.09659788012504578,
0.6509988903999329,
0.6338716149330139,
0.3527856767177582,
0.5138953328132629,
-0.002328332979232073,
0.7492238879203796,
-0.5741454362869263,
-0.3037986159324646,
-0.9826937317848206,
0.3242817223072052,
0.036369629204273224,
0.0007265635649673641,
0.7822625637054443,
0.4277248680591583,
0.8215581774711609,
-0.05136359483003616,
0.6406004428863525,
0.1310848593711853,
0.5558602809906006,
-1.071394443511963,
0.8543753027915955,
-0.42539462447166443,
0.2514592409133911,
0.19228971004486084,
-0.7418019771575928,
-0.036660756915807724,
0.5485172867774963,
-0.7321665287017822,
0.11930298060178757,
0.9068613648414612,
0.5427913665771484,
-0.0728195458650589,
-0.07507040351629257,
0.3306143581867218,
0.7854344844818115,
0.19549749791622162,
0.31513673067092896,
1.0406250953674316,
0.11059208959341049,
0.3245636522769928,
0.010197753086686134,
-0.05734392628073692,
-0.03714292496442795,
-0.8831082582473755,
-0.9427800178527832,
-0.395730197429657,
-0.15252567827701569,
-0.1879367232322693,
0.06145596131682396,
0.8537089228630066,
0.7102848887443542,
-0.6885296106338501,
-0.1855713129043579,
-0.1688641905784607,
0.21381166577339172,
0.33272072672843933,
-0.12316886335611343,
0.17235568165779114,
-0.8272680044174194,
-0.19696645438671112,
0.1858077049255371,
0.055823925882577896,
0.19959348440170288,
0.026224179193377495,
-0.13414205610752106,
-0.32211461663246155,
0.12858432531356812,
0.58016437292099,
0.5567067861557007,
-0.19897016882896423,
-0.22188101708889008,
-0.2608155608177185,
0.05796344578266144,
0.0526745468378067,
1.0504875183105469,
-0.9761902689933777,
0.18833892047405243,
0.3636213541030884,
0.6028480529785156,
0.7885187268257141,
-0.012196832336485386,
0.6555189490318298,
-0.8110578656196594,
0.376401424407959,
-0.05880438908934593,
0.4617093801498413,
0.27901899814605713,
-0.15879753232002258,
-0.058964140713214874,
0.5993082523345947,
-0.6451034545898438,
-0.8887596130371094,
0.11194806545972824,
-0.4862695634365082,
-0.1918347328901291,
0.8693748116493225,
-0.33722347021102905,
-0.13330774009227753,
-0.0396864153444767,
0.20405791699886322,
0.48703423142433167,
0.14857372641563416,
0.802841305732727,
0.9785628914833069,
0.096315398812294,
-0.09292125701904297,
-0.7348771095275879,
0.6647719740867615,
0.42258885502815247,
-0.511388897895813,
0.19445586204528809,
0.49789541959762573,
0.6523200869560242,
0.24139238893985748,
0.7436670064926147,
0.060235340148210526,
0.1115795150399208,
-0.002308219438418746,
-0.3045635223388672,
0.08766084164381027,
-0.7155671715736389,
-0.13074518740177155,
0.041237059980630875,
0.27129390835762024,
0.06641943007707596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11811v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11811v1 | RepLiQA: A Question-Answering Dataset for Benchmarking LLMs on Unseen Reference Content | 2024-06-17T17:52:54 | 2024-06-17T17:52:54 | Joao Monteiro, Pierre-Andre Noel, Etienne Marcotte, Sai Rajeswar, Valentina Zantedeschi, David Vazquez, Nicolas Chapados, Christopher Pal, Perouz Taslakian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are trained on vast amounts of data, most of
which is automatically scraped from the internet. This data includes
encyclopedic documents that harbor a vast amount of general knowledge (e.g.,
Wikipedia) but also potentially overlap with benchmark datasets used for
evaluating LLMs. Consequently, evaluating models on test splits that might have
leaked into the training set is prone to misleading conclusions. To foster
sound evaluation of language models, we introduce a new test dataset named
RepLiQA, suited for question-answering and topic retrieval tasks. RepLiQA is a
collection of five splits of test sets, four of which have not been released to
the internet or exposed to LLM APIs prior to this publication. Each sample in
RepLiQA comprises (1) a reference document crafted by a human annotator and
depicting an imaginary scenario (e.g., a news article) absent from the
internet; (2) a question about the document's topic; (3) a ground-truth answer
derived directly from the information in the document; and (4) the paragraph
extracted from the reference document containing the answer. As such, accurate
answers can only be generated if a model can find relevant content within the
provided document. We run a large-scale benchmark comprising several
state-of-the-art LLMs to uncover differences in performance across models of
various types and sizes in a context-conditional language modeling setting.
Released splits of RepLiQA can be found here:
https://huggingface.co/datasets/ServiceNow/repliqa. | [
-0.5677738189697266,
-0.5149022340774536,
0.4572926461696625,
0.0364648774266243,
-0.16868871450424194,
0.07054758816957474,
-0.0853394865989685,
-0.27150771021842957,
-0.09320750087499619,
0.7341945171356201,
-0.8192392587661743,
-0.26675185561180115,
-0.35157811641693115,
0.29255974292755127,
-0.7189852595329285,
0.6968786120414734,
-0.12309376895427704,
0.15053308010101318,
-0.6736388802528381,
-0.3886682093143463,
-0.229018896818161,
-0.39650776982307434,
-0.3266509175300598,
-0.2840401232242584,
0.5778862833976746,
0.45928046107292175,
0.447478324174881,
0.4955403804779053,
0.37345725297927856,
0.22861173748970032,
-0.027613913640379906,
0.3292343318462372,
-0.5576494336128235,
0.37557122111320496,
-0.3493565618991852,
-0.4217737913131714,
0.05464557558298111,
0.2442530244588852,
0.8407080769538879,
0.4813980162143707,
-0.07709529250860214,
0.5933988094329834,
-0.11345826089382172,
0.6097333431243896,
-0.7850872278213501,
-0.2747134268283844,
-0.5963072180747986,
-0.14279960095882416,
-0.08311210572719574,
0.009243890643119812,
-0.38507336378097534,
-0.6628339290618896,
0.12320400774478912,
-0.4982750117778778,
0.11091945320367813,
0.10348287224769592,
1.0346125364303589,
0.5144675970077515,
-0.44247710704803467,
-0.20052878558635712,
-0.40763217210769653,
0.7398962378501892,
-0.7400669455528259,
0.7549179196357727,
0.27753323316574097,
0.5219245553016663,
-0.0402812622487545,
-0.9338542222976685,
-0.7550342679023743,
-0.2195381075143814,
0.040013741701841354,
0.07301829755306244,
-0.06031646206974983,
-0.3066108524799347,
0.3374384939670563,
0.5133518576622009,
-0.7251490354537964,
-0.14000390470027924,
-0.15249794721603394,
-0.1454154998064041,
0.5043402314186096,
0.07923240214586258,
0.30402958393096924,
-0.20771265029907227,
-0.260666161775589,
-0.26365455985069275,
-1.0356804132461548,
-0.05036533996462822,
0.3258090913295746,
0.1247994527220726,
0.022745033726096153,
0.7045263648033142,
-0.41898471117019653,
0.6684381365776062,
-0.01205193530768156,
-0.2524350881576538,
0.2865429222583771,
-0.2330855280160904,
-0.23104536533355713,
-0.21725381910800934,
0.5832903981208801,
0.2092905044555664,
0.4611476957798004,
-0.25171446800231934,
-0.11871279031038284,
-0.39847278594970703,
0.13929113745689392,
-1.0275492668151855,
-0.19040396809577942,
0.22694286704063416,
-0.27761146426200867,
-0.10491794347763062,
-0.021963225677609444,
-0.6957424879074097,
-0.5522350072860718,
-0.1365550309419632,
0.2945956885814667,
-0.19220879673957825,
-0.1386929154396057,
-0.23616696894168854,
-0.12940292060375214,
0.33742383122444153,
0.1051827222108841,
-0.5357154011726379,
0.3466325104236603,
0.666009783744812,
0.4905736446380615,
-0.3026859760284424,
-0.217911958694458,
-0.7975281476974487,
-0.15191417932510376,
-0.3397773206233978,
0.9463831186294556,
-0.6596847772598267,
-0.2743004560470581,
0.17449678480625153,
0.22614529728889465,
0.005469437222927809,
-0.8065676689147949,
0.7334137558937073,
-0.9242125749588013,
0.4101908504962921,
-0.49700728058815,
-0.7873749732971191,
-0.23195277154445648,
0.48195919394493103,
-0.9019982218742371,
1.3462127447128296,
0.25469517707824707,
-0.9488699436187744,
-0.017318731173872948,
-0.24343915283679962,
-0.0217894334346056,
-0.03788644075393677,
-0.3163297772407532,
-0.23545528948307037,
-0.07692188024520874,
0.2330467402935028,
0.08550899475812912,
-0.7889289259910583,
0.027461299672722816,
-0.2912779450416565,
-0.4816676378250122,
0.657515287399292,
-0.479051411151886,
0.5616374015808105,
0.24402481317520142,
-0.19316209852695465,
-0.22829647362232208,
-0.6222637891769409,
0.41812610626220703,
0.002547299489378929,
-0.46690255403518677,
-0.3475682735443115,
-0.17293156683444977,
-0.13183769583702087,
0.2894428074359894,
0.34537696838378906,
-0.589507520198822,
0.017866546288132668,
-0.31507018208503723,
0.13615356385707855,
0.538241982460022,
0.3121832311153412,
0.1780625730752945,
-0.49962109327316284,
0.7200300097465515,
-0.16293630003929138,
0.0018822827842086554,
-0.14434145390987396,
-0.27278774976730347,
-0.9842671751976013,
-0.05014662817120552,
0.7794376611709595,
0.46727681159973145,
-0.857910692691803,
-0.018798520788550377,
-0.30790427327156067,
-0.4958254396915436,
-0.8658109903335571,
0.12318354845046997,
0.5617008805274963,
0.6063528656959534,
0.38130444288253784,
0.004290230106562376,
-0.4945566654205322,
-1.1729121208190918,
-0.4479133188724518,
-0.24714717268943787,
-0.12867076694965363,
0.46928948163986206,
0.5063426494598389,
0.036208149045705795,
0.8225985169410706,
-0.37645280361175537,
0.29206761717796326,
0.05557881295681,
0.0686049535870552,
0.07876617461442947,
0.10544277727603912,
0.0878092497587204,
-1.045103907585144,
-0.29134419560432434,
-0.30622994899749756,
-0.6270563006401062,
-0.4374513030052185,
0.11797782778739929,
-0.07484420388936996,
0.0017889245646074414,
0.4904441833496094,
-0.4011339247226715,
0.1521427184343338,
0.7814602255821228,
-0.14539556205272675,
0.6452271342277527,
0.10736693441867828,
0.29826033115386963,
-1.1003402471542358,
0.18958449363708496,
-0.19680055975914001,
-0.20373308658599854,
-0.4081556499004364,
0.3153838813304901,
0.26326650381088257,
0.08776118606328964,
-0.5461107492446899,
0.7685374617576599,
-0.37493839859962463,
-0.33403632044792175,
-0.23858822882175446,
0.3027448058128357,
0.26585885882377625,
0.28979912400245667,
-0.07494962215423584,
1.2461992502212524,
0.021085603162646294,
-0.3326595723628998,
0.2511284053325653,
0.33938518166542053,
-0.5197726488113403,
0.28298673033714294,
-0.6846914887428284,
0.3317939341068268,
0.08992795646190643,
0.10487567633390427,
-1.0059192180633545,
-0.1190071627497673,
0.14471493661403656,
-0.4524368643760681,
-0.05977940186858177,
-0.10038144141435623,
-0.678196907043457,
-0.1636042594909668,
-0.17736731469631195,
0.5402242541313171,
0.4513283669948578,
-0.5768955945968628,
0.4702495336532593,
0.44828447699546814,
-0.26714402437210083,
-0.8784793615341187,
-0.6407508850097656,
-0.16946639120578766,
-0.16075477004051208,
-0.35501575469970703,
0.09306647628545761,
-0.396027147769928,
-0.3868010938167572,
0.13441525399684906,
-0.15367965400218964,
-0.40886056423187256,
0.1203240305185318,
0.5088868141174316,
0.1283271610736847,
-0.2754864990711212,
0.4758305251598358,
-0.11119385063648224,
0.16715753078460693,
0.15010496973991394,
-0.09154062718153,
0.5269190073013306,
-0.14141380786895752,
-0.4929153025150299,
-0.12275148183107376,
0.16370519995689392,
0.5604768991470337,
-0.4024451673030853,
0.5244366526603699,
0.2717542052268982,
-0.30771031975746155,
-0.2095949947834015,
-0.7825988531112671,
-0.007855555042624474,
-0.45775455236434937,
0.1679423302412033,
-0.43133971095085144,
-0.9520885944366455,
0.3899921178817749,
-0.13145782053470612,
0.11052312701940536,
0.32243186235427856,
0.6467419862747192,
-0.016671523451805115,
0.6488237977027893,
0.37642335891723633,
-0.14449742436408997,
0.12720230221748352,
-0.0492687001824379,
-0.011245504952967167,
-0.8818397521972656,
-0.26964589953422546,
-0.6967549920082092,
-0.07862108200788498,
-0.6733495593070984,
-0.6584197282791138,
0.005070727318525314,
0.059540845453739166,
-0.43408721685409546,
0.15465544164180756,
-0.27215588092803955,
0.5839632153511047,
0.5940583944320679,
0.0039696888998150826,
0.6108609437942505,
-0.1401948779821396,
-0.31508663296699524,
-0.057677261531353,
-0.5940682888031006,
-0.5899019837379456,
1.2286145687103271,
0.29008257389068604,
0.6120796799659729,
0.05333757400512695,
0.5160858035087585,
0.2679521143436432,
0.7260468602180481,
-0.4881278872489929,
0.5453552603721619,
0.016081565991044044,
-0.7894498109817505,
-0.3258267045021057,
-0.5268190503120422,
-0.6151305437088013,
0.28456321358680725,
-0.18506412208080292,
-0.3917105793952942,
0.2431734949350357,
-0.25095829367637634,
-0.17287705838680267,
0.16638530790805817,
-0.4123952388763428,
0.7183902263641357,
-0.15740948915481567,
-0.3595874011516571,
0.1381824016571045,
-0.20263098180294037,
0.5263352990150452,
-0.3681375980377197,
0.15342511236667633,
-0.30561941862106323,
-0.1938989758491516,
0.8448061943054199,
-0.23839110136032104,
0.36567479372024536,
0.027836943045258522,
-0.16510823369026184,
0.3994975686073303,
0.1308976411819458,
0.3387424349784851,
0.2373587191104889,
-0.33483409881591797,
-0.10820244252681732,
0.36735692620277405,
-0.3546600639820099,
-0.7123998403549194,
0.7282084226608276,
-0.8614691495895386,
-0.6183167099952698,
-0.3684385418891907,
-0.6266608834266663,
-0.4997749924659729,
0.2865908145904541,
0.22952930629253387,
0.45820724964141846,
-0.25158199667930603,
0.34160900115966797,
0.8037694692611694,
-0.31314316391944885,
0.07210052013397217,
0.952759861946106,
-0.3727830946445465,
-0.3234897553920746,
0.6848247051239014,
0.03375992923974991,
0.17291408777236938,
0.39981797337532043,
-0.0793166533112526,
-0.575405478477478,
-0.5104292631149292,
-0.2990862727165222,
0.38767945766448975,
-0.7736392021179199,
-0.19003598392009735,
-0.3437350392341614,
-0.45066437125205994,
-0.28443583846092224,
0.5074411630630493,
-0.34929314255714417,
-0.361508846282959,
0.014361734502017498,
-0.02731672301888466,
0.23028534650802612,
0.6405704021453857,
0.1956462562084198,
-0.12608098983764648,
-0.6991633772850037,
0.4082857668399811,
0.6117157936096191,
0.21271482110023499,
-0.1671677976846695,
-0.8164716362953186,
-0.08342482894659042,
0.22767426073551178,
-0.0377468504011631,
-0.8800374269485474,
0.22890812158584595,
0.15228843688964844,
0.5835100412368774,
0.0697372704744339,
0.31493091583251953,
0.5800049901008606,
-0.5999693870544434,
0.6594125032424927,
-0.255772203207016,
-0.6535034775733948,
0.21488067507743835,
-0.17484568059444427,
0.3276924788951874,
0.9030589461326599,
0.6331280469894409,
-0.7555800080299377,
-0.3997347950935364,
-0.5267702341079712,
-0.509042501449585,
0.2386944591999054,
0.22160078585147858,
-0.009169116616249084,
-0.0014270581305027008,
0.6020458936691284,
0.06197832152247429,
0.40565386414527893,
-0.623722493648529,
-0.32796019315719604,
0.02983792871236801,
-0.12901242077350616,
-0.03628856688737869,
-0.3956773579120636,
-0.34343090653419495,
-0.06303882598876953,
0.6652090549468994,
-0.07817303389310837,
0.052660103887319565,
0.2558925151824951,
-0.19560445845127106,
-0.0395912304520607,
0.2545674741268158,
0.29562634229660034,
0.7876893877983093,
-0.2325442135334015,
0.14592887461185455,
0.339595228433609,
-0.4016486704349518,
0.2418084442615509,
0.18136022984981537,
-0.28854086995124817,
0.10049303621053696,
0.4601168632507324,
0.3426893949508667,
0.2698889374732971,
-1.2556754350662231,
0.4679526388645172,
-0.2976022958755493,
-0.327396035194397,
-0.5422931909561157,
0.0671929121017456,
0.3504663407802582,
0.48534664511680603,
0.5622304081916809,
-0.5720716118812561,
0.08801250159740448,
-0.4250226616859436,
0.5538244247436523,
0.19652187824249268,
-0.39304736256599426,
-0.03539666160941124,
0.3980307877063751,
0.019843431189656258,
-0.2539951503276825,
0.7270936369895935,
-0.036656659096479416,
-0.44107291102409363,
0.5522099137306213,
0.21004226803779602,
0.6487517952919006,
-0.10942170768976212,
0.38873055577278137,
0.2098522186279297,
0.31358978152275085,
0.054830458015203476,
0.37438252568244934,
0.07859241217374802,
-0.8002053499221802,
-0.48676249384880066,
-0.6601905822753906,
-0.7765550017356873,
0.5023970603942871,
-0.7958694100379944,
-0.08501749485731125,
-0.1616712212562561,
0.13882865011692047,
-0.14494548738002777,
0.2686900496482849,
-0.6277770400047302,
0.47185495495796204,
0.10172293335199356,
1.379813313484192,
-0.6826490759849548,
0.948963463306427,
0.5844686031341553,
-0.3604891002178192,
-0.8930652737617493,
0.3538278341293335,
-0.22508880496025085,
-0.8211644887924194,
0.7189467549324036,
0.04713059589266777,
0.03994009643793106,
-0.03488703817129135,
-0.45838311314582825,
-1.0017846822738647,
1.1321744918823242,
0.5179479718208313,
-0.46517887711524963,
0.01760590262711048,
0.25105181336402893,
0.5146170258522034,
-0.43589913845062256,
0.3342239558696747,
0.6929598450660706,
0.47708800435066223,
0.07154841721057892,
-0.724166214466095,
0.16256390511989594,
-0.4175878167152405,
-0.19603672623634338,
-0.06059512495994568,
-0.6522752642631531,
1.0053397417068481,
0.21924932301044464,
-0.28657931089401245,
0.38344067335128784,
0.6054902672767639,
0.5928764939308167,
0.1134369820356369,
0.5681538581848145,
0.5890982151031494,
0.978857159614563,
-0.11980915069580078,
1.0662624835968018,
-0.36515331268310547,
0.25811195373535156,
1.466794490814209,
-0.3683304786682129,
1.2550033330917358,
0.46777790784835815,
-0.06839022040367126,
0.6319487690925598,
0.8317857384681702,
0.017316073179244995,
0.5840882658958435,
0.3445397615432739,
-0.31492099165916443,
-0.4135773777961731,
-0.33393701910972595,
-0.5190234184265137,
0.35767948627471924,
0.028045274317264557,
-0.3381785452365875,
-0.3801099956035614,
-0.20121300220489502,
-0.24013425409793854,
0.2514835000038147,
-0.08409109711647034,
0.5141502618789673,
0.06003697216510773,
-0.7856706976890564,
0.7569648027420044,
-0.09526905417442322,
0.12555210292339325,
-0.3768374025821686,
-0.10750868171453476,
-0.5813592672348022,
-0.0767538920044899,
0.036776717752218246,
-0.7576788067817688,
0.03468481823801994,
0.27210190892219543,
-0.16933462023735046,
0.08739592134952545,
0.650979220867157,
-0.4469861388206482,
-0.4007059335708618,
0.20197637379169464,
0.7656261920928955,
0.25513264536857605,
-0.22223593294620514,
-0.7797815799713135,
0.184340238571167,
-0.042352933436632156,
-0.4127334654331207,
0.34827563166618347,
0.45765697956085205,
0.03463957458734512,
0.9872187972068787,
0.552424430847168,
-0.028714343905448914,
0.010384510271251202,
0.07797947525978088,
1.141258955001831,
-0.5360329747200012,
-0.2468492090702057,
-0.4533575475215912,
0.2205536663532257,
-0.20828546583652496,
-0.41769397258758545,
0.9405503869056702,
0.7845625281333923,
0.6777639389038086,
0.21312165260314941,
0.8681915998458862,
0.2907956838607788,
0.9475874304771423,
-0.5152505040168762,
0.61322420835495,
-0.7157372236251831,
0.29302531480789185,
0.011405542492866516,
-0.8807030320167542,
0.18126408755779266,
0.25748419761657715,
-0.4193660318851471,
-0.07535267621278763,
0.6659466624259949,
0.8405634760856628,
0.11356614530086517,
0.07034225761890411,
0.32972899079322815,
0.12368807941675186,
-0.03497299924492836,
0.5774907469749451,
1.1945773363113403,
-0.6362382173538208,
0.7524539232254028,
-0.19760994613170624,
0.1251218169927597,
-0.0700806975364685,
-0.73863285779953,
-0.9533795714378357,
-0.6256532073020935,
-0.16101610660552979,
-0.3509092628955841,
0.31516262888908386,
0.54642653465271,
0.6249285340309143,
-0.9501047134399414,
-0.10199569165706635,
0.17007960379123688,
0.1939801424741745,
0.16044679284095764,
-0.19046886265277863,
0.29139500856399536,
-0.04120461642742157,
-0.7046304941177368,
0.4881557822227478,
-0.09532011300325394,
-0.1354289948940277,
-0.48586174845695496,
-0.14025427401065826,
-0.40228328108787537,
0.21999359130859375,
0.15230923891067505,
0.4365013539791107,
-0.6066352128982544,
-0.3719915449619293,
0.23348112404346466,
-0.2209334820508957,
-0.1151839941740036,
0.6603723764419556,
-0.8718029856681824,
0.18246039748191833,
0.5001725554466248,
1.0194860696792603,
0.5515359044075012,
0.2750830054283142,
0.5675360560417175,
-0.7445963621139526,
0.03935636579990387,
0.21336349844932556,
0.17888380587100983,
0.46367156505584717,
-0.07503709942102432,
0.6035789251327515,
-0.03377201408147812,
-0.5520586371421814,
-0.9680987000465393,
0.17241908609867096,
-0.5886821746826172,
-0.4351014196872711,
1.162340521812439,
-0.4191502332687378,
-0.2502891719341278,
-0.04008028283715248,
0.10058122128248215,
0.15052255988121033,
-0.1057424545288086,
0.6838797330856323,
0.9080511331558228,
0.1952134221792221,
-0.45616114139556885,
-0.7994934320449829,
0.48293745517730713,
0.4084221422672272,
-0.9245273470878601,
0.0877213254570961,
0.4326464533805847,
0.5378317832946777,
0.05681375786662102,
0.4351668953895569,
-0.08515471965074539,
0.3592371344566345,
-0.16555747389793396,
0.006544733420014381,
-0.057060446590185165,
-0.24543316662311554,
-0.27060338854789734,
0.3197226822376251,
0.18776214122772217,
-0.1449400782585144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11944v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11944v1 | Transcoders Find Interpretable LLM Feature Circuits | 2024-06-17T17:49:00 | 2024-06-17T17:49:00 | Jacob Dunefsky, Philippe Chlenski, Neel Nanda | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | A key goal in mechanistic interpretability is circuit analysis: finding
sparse subgraphs of models corresponding to specific behaviors or capabilities.
However, MLP sublayers make fine-grained circuit analysis on transformer-based
language models difficult. In particular, interpretable features -- such as
those found by sparse autoencoders (SAEs) -- are typically linear combinations
of extremely many neurons, each with its own nonlinearity to account for.
Circuit analysis in this setting thus either yields intractably large circuits
or fails to disentangle local and global behavior. To address this we explore
transcoders, which seek to faithfully approximate a densely activating MLP
layer with a wider, sparsely-activating MLP layer. We successfully train
transcoders on language models with 120M, 410M, and 1.4B parameters, and find
them to perform at least on par with SAEs in terms of sparsity, faithfulness,
and human-interpretability. We then introduce a novel method for using
transcoders to perform weights-based circuit analysis through MLP sublayers.
The resulting circuits neatly factorize into input-dependent and
input-invariant terms. Finally, we apply transcoders to reverse-engineer
unknown circuits in the model, and we obtain novel insights regarding the
greater-than circuit in GPT2-small. Our results suggest that transcoders can
prove effective in decomposing model computations involving MLPs into
interpretable circuits. Code is available at
https://github.com/jacobdunefsky/transcoder_circuits. | [
-0.40461671352386475,
-0.42292171716690063,
0.506072998046875,
0.2480870932340622,
-0.025036444887518883,
-0.06755942106246948,
-0.051096875220537186,
-0.44513338804244995,
0.20485590398311615,
0.5590552091598511,
-0.595050573348999,
0.10938125103712082,
-0.8422122597694397,
-0.01977234147489071,
-0.7357379794120789,
0.8316629528999329,
-0.2147330790758133,
0.0498063862323761,
0.1511363387107849,
-0.10381476581096649,
-0.25896430015563965,
-0.5783365368843079,
-0.28454041481018066,
-0.590617835521698,
0.4948744773864746,
-0.19237501919269562,
0.7979609966278076,
0.2824171483516693,
0.22022965550422668,
0.2836472690105438,
-0.3027341365814209,
0.14480160176753998,
-0.18818233907222748,
-0.151713564991951,
-0.05129186809062958,
-0.2723427414894104,
-0.25561946630477905,
-0.08621130883693695,
0.610427975654602,
0.9572951197624207,
0.09352792054414749,
0.13715746998786926,
0.46479353308677673,
0.458442747592926,
-0.4112083911895752,
0.18210232257843018,
-0.6873064637184143,
0.3054741621017456,
0.10979769378900528,
-0.3798474371433258,
-0.49296775460243225,
0.19437424838542938,
-0.09531401097774506,
-0.19000014662742615,
0.39168781042099,
-0.14751924574375153,
0.8009682297706604,
0.2873368561267853,
-0.3107513189315796,
-0.39149218797683716,
-0.9564647078514099,
0.6149678826332092,
-0.4024943709373474,
0.6048014163970947,
0.13654392957687378,
0.14931635558605194,
-0.29765212535858154,
-0.8207219839096069,
-0.39887523651123047,
-0.2043064385652542,
-0.5577461123466492,
-0.20145097374916077,
-0.36768782138824463,
0.1319528967142105,
0.45295438170433044,
0.4127125144004822,
-0.5859731435775757,
-0.030426137149333954,
-0.39210015535354614,
-0.36661407351493835,
0.3637861907482147,
0.17138081789016724,
0.3865436017513275,
-0.2755689322948456,
-0.1835922747850418,
0.30015939474105835,
-0.6323903203010559,
0.007450370118021965,
0.16753901541233063,
0.0432620495557785,
0.036453213542699814,
0.6475328207015991,
0.18697822093963623,
0.5995005369186401,
0.07333476096391678,
0.332496702671051,
-0.06477457284927368,
-0.24668315052986145,
-0.3085814416408539,
-0.17132703959941864,
0.6771814823150635,
-0.1111573800444603,
0.3975551724433899,
-0.3726136386394501,
-0.4192212224006653,
-0.3835509419441223,
0.40037208795547485,
-0.7889180183410645,
-0.43841391801834106,
0.08990701287984848,
-0.7299602031707764,
-0.07093214988708496,
0.01146208867430687,
-0.452913761138916,
-0.328713595867157,
-0.29639068245887756,
0.6094316840171814,
-0.13932271301746368,
-0.04184679314494133,
0.18839770555496216,
-0.09937714040279388,
0.3942236602306366,
-0.03691970556974411,
-1.3551231622695923,
0.7357770204544067,
0.4705955982208252,
1.011260747909546,
0.0015268101124092937,
-0.34398695826530457,
-0.3843535780906677,
-0.029273195192217827,
-0.15107597410678864,
0.4617362916469574,
-0.3608003854751587,
-0.23068742454051971,
-0.3998323380947113,
0.275875449180603,
-0.1529349684715271,
-0.6635908484458923,
0.45626112818717957,
-0.7605441808700562,
-0.24832721054553986,
-0.18903954327106476,
-0.2818585932254791,
0.12440594285726547,
-0.06877519190311432,
-0.8802267909049988,
0.7965674996376038,
0.31203797459602356,
-0.5807536840438843,
0.09237624704837799,
-0.6079028248786926,
-0.5588077306747437,
-0.3591751456260681,
-0.10734689235687256,
-0.2962538003921509,
0.5735416412353516,
0.3944156765937805,
0.5247438549995422,
-0.09772858023643494,
0.09477899968624115,
-0.22755227982997894,
-0.5703412294387817,
0.5802388787269592,
-0.776410698890686,
0.7960475087165833,
0.23659160733222961,
-0.4292213022708893,
0.07282239943742752,
-0.5670138001441956,
0.01421709917485714,
0.1967477947473526,
-0.18925213813781738,
-0.07450025528669357,
-0.06401097029447556,
0.12908333539962769,
0.3412529230117798,
0.06727748364210129,
-0.42488497495651245,
0.20141884684562683,
-0.4936044216156006,
0.9602306485176086,
0.7317186594009399,
-0.025631017982959747,
0.5776628255844116,
0.15904828906059265,
0.22699876129627228,
-0.08653810620307922,
0.34458035230636597,
-0.04705958068370819,
-0.3785618841648102,
-0.8240285515785217,
-0.05746525526046753,
0.40074244141578674,
0.3575669825077057,
-0.6280631422996521,
0.5815532207489014,
-0.2587854862213135,
-0.13258720934391022,
-0.5489941239356995,
0.3639640212059021,
0.16068856418132782,
0.19893215596675873,
0.6838854551315308,
-0.3102162182331085,
-0.29017582535743713,
-1.0850259065628052,
-0.37417396903038025,
0.20294944941997528,
-0.3879019320011139,
0.1180291473865509,
0.44747233390808105,
-0.3343909680843353,
0.615206241607666,
-0.3696722388267517,
-0.09024915099143982,
-0.45750507712364197,
0.09306152164936066,
0.11876275390386581,
0.5514811873435974,
0.26889359951019287,
-0.5826184153556824,
-0.06800153106451035,
-0.08266701549291611,
-0.6285766363143921,
-0.14105544984340668,
-0.5008012652397156,
0.1335667073726654,
-0.23440183699131012,
0.4746245741844177,
-0.7043744325637817,
0.4376470744609833,
0.3433248698711395,
0.03970856964588165,
0.1782573014497757,
-0.41915246844291687,
-0.12264149636030197,
-0.43450137972831726,
0.00872418750077486,
-0.01987018808722496,
-0.26255372166633606,
-0.5619484186172485,
0.012047798372805119,
0.09584664553403854,
-0.060178376734256744,
-0.06768940389156342,
0.5568258166313171,
-0.7040082812309265,
-0.7326385378837585,
-0.3666594922542572,
-0.16424213349819183,
0.14803385734558105,
0.656245231628418,
-0.0023882361128926277,
0.7288333773612976,
0.3007834851741791,
-0.30989304184913635,
0.230677530169487,
-0.0713021382689476,
-0.3661312758922577,
-0.00885017216205597,
-0.879889965057373,
0.03746681660413742,
-0.030832305550575256,
0.0952071100473404,
-0.753342866897583,
-0.06467980146408081,
0.35277059674263,
-0.20596030354499817,
0.5279489159584045,
-0.37612661719322205,
-0.5684720873832703,
-0.4086427688598633,
-0.18508467078208923,
0.5895425081253052,
0.6276252269744873,
-0.6558610200881958,
0.7399448156356812,
0.3974839746952057,
0.10338567942380905,
-0.3530566394329071,
-1.0649255514144897,
0.12639835476875305,
0.2656172513961792,
-0.39981770515441895,
0.09979540854692459,
0.10078588128089905,
0.0813973993062973,
0.13474266231060028,
-0.1925550103187561,
-0.16411148011684418,
0.17692676186561584,
0.3061332702636719,
-0.050146013498306274,
-0.19353924691677094,
-0.15420308709144592,
0.256721168756485,
-0.4112298786640167,
0.3226243555545807,
-0.5439579486846924,
0.6767634749412537,
-0.3423643410205841,
-0.6844279766082764,
-0.4623999297618866,
0.14989909529685974,
0.5137981176376343,
-0.21152859926223755,
0.4212971031665802,
0.6512032151222229,
-0.5019901990890503,
-0.36901259422302246,
-0.21911737322807312,
-0.18971526622772217,
-0.5391494631767273,
0.47125548124313354,
-0.6012122631072998,
-0.7814194560050964,
0.48968344926834106,
-0.19197338819503784,
-0.2919529378414154,
0.49823394417762756,
0.5805934071540833,
-0.15185776352882385,
1.1516411304473877,
0.485048770904541,
-0.05941707268357277,
0.3653160631656647,
-0.47699064016342163,
0.3325052261352539,
-1.0015501976013184,
-0.3654826879501343,
-0.03389834612607956,
-0.7298247218132019,
-0.4611221253871918,
-0.49980801343917847,
0.39567458629608154,
-0.011070647276937962,
-0.0903644934296608,
0.2875722050666809,
-0.6335784196853638,
0.7511911988258362,
0.42463213205337524,
0.18047356605529785,
0.018030475825071335,
0.2608504295349121,
-0.2151309698820114,
-0.17322976887226105,
-0.7822521328926086,
-0.39933526515960693,
0.723828911781311,
0.5972735285758972,
0.9866107702255249,
-0.2982777953147888,
0.4192972183227539,
0.29569047689437866,
0.20388191938400269,
-0.7677183151245117,
0.3452528715133667,
-0.3956107199192047,
-0.44707614183425903,
-0.12825845181941986,
-0.4911118447780609,
-0.807928204536438,
0.17197689414024353,
-0.19081281125545502,
-0.7615621089935303,
0.35228750109672546,
0.15768419206142426,
-0.16257214546203613,
0.5534011125564575,
-0.6804057359695435,
0.9078053832054138,
-0.5646229386329651,
-0.19586701691150665,
-0.039397723972797394,
-0.7366041541099548,
0.4553448259830475,
0.1354844868183136,
0.06960897892713547,
0.4295397698879242,
0.04910245165228844,
0.2615284025669098,
-0.5516394376754761,
0.8531215190887451,
-0.12226003408432007,
-0.2438710778951645,
0.29958343505859375,
0.35561203956604004,
0.3186643719673157,
-0.05183155834674835,
-0.0007419459871016443,
0.43472474813461304,
-0.11650750786066055,
-0.4548555612564087,
-0.9403027892112732,
0.7597969770431519,
-0.7860212326049805,
-0.22346539795398712,
-0.10932955145835876,
-0.6019856929779053,
-0.11647924780845642,
0.03625083342194557,
0.29675790667533875,
0.5904334187507629,
0.05576496198773384,
-0.1848078966140747,
0.7563256025314331,
-0.14179500937461853,
0.16485734283924103,
-0.07803897559642792,
-0.21368426084518433,
-0.1736275851726532,
1.150229573249817,
0.251706063747406,
0.2545284330844879,
0.44312572479248047,
-0.013534387573599815,
-0.1398501843214035,
-0.6940290331840515,
-0.709517240524292,
0.14580093324184418,
-0.7024619579315186,
0.08439725637435913,
-0.6910971403121948,
-0.725616455078125,
0.16766296327114105,
-0.026335950940847397,
-0.4184817969799042,
-0.8177847266197205,
-0.291025847196579,
-0.030364979058504105,
-0.21639864146709442,
0.975732147693634,
-0.1241811066865921,
0.398305207490921,
-0.8147242069244385,
0.5822305679321289,
0.48356080055236816,
0.4431421160697937,
0.21760298311710358,
-0.7818135619163513,
-0.30766114592552185,
0.07021138072013855,
-0.14887171983718872,
-0.5788096785545349,
0.2336263805627823,
0.01985410787165165,
0.5326595306396484,
0.22711092233657837,
-0.3931773602962494,
0.6389838457107544,
-0.46304577589035034,
0.58035808801651,
-0.037735629826784134,
-1.3049137592315674,
0.4540420174598694,
0.2808641195297241,
0.10355009138584137,
0.21325638890266418,
0.2216131091117859,
-0.29054194688796997,
-0.2331361174583435,
-0.5096078515052795,
-0.6778547167778015,
0.5618325471878052,
0.5238350629806519,
0.40976405143737793,
0.2606493830680847,
0.8000914454460144,
0.08567046374082565,
-0.011620582081377506,
-1.007501244544983,
-0.2875142991542816,
-0.3602009415626526,
-0.37765538692474365,
0.1907559186220169,
-0.5728305578231812,
0.007397484965622425,
-0.11462301015853882,
0.3175348937511444,
-0.04571748524904251,
0.5081793665885925,
0.1615537703037262,
-0.31143492460250854,
-0.15035617351531982,
0.32637766003608704,
0.5625666975975037,
0.4684503972530365,
-0.16331025958061218,
0.6501182317733765,
0.20033738017082214,
-0.5348742008209229,
0.20999562740325928,
0.16679969429969788,
-0.44882315397262573,
-0.033679358661174774,
0.7376567721366882,
0.6878977417945862,
0.1588972806930542,
-0.46646541357040405,
0.6381446123123169,
-0.20560863614082336,
-0.056277722120285034,
-0.04676729440689087,
0.2129652202129364,
-0.04512355849146843,
0.2790261209011078,
0.23061539232730865,
0.3687765300273895,
0.3647945821285248,
-0.42643123865127563,
0.37383130192756653,
0.6635026931762695,
-0.75142902135849,
-0.6217048764228821,
0.6687355637550354,
0.06659866124391556,
-0.015046701766550541,
0.6156871914863586,
-0.1480625569820404,
-0.6223731637001038,
0.6189108490943909,
0.47839587926864624,
1.0018154382705688,
0.07686162739992142,
-0.08127126097679138,
0.22647882997989655,
0.9761453866958618,
0.03554171696305275,
-0.01495189219713211,
-0.05394408106803894,
-0.6846258640289307,
-0.5868517756462097,
-0.7389756441116333,
-0.04016304761171341,
0.2390950322151184,
-0.5482767224311829,
0.12361857295036316,
-0.7834967374801636,
0.18323147296905518,
0.14869530498981476,
-0.3799823224544525,
-0.48587825894355774,
0.1682427078485489,
0.18512538075447083,
0.8574775457382202,
-0.9684744477272034,
0.9005506634712219,
0.3289370834827423,
-0.26488715410232544,
-0.7357230186462402,
0.08568970113992691,
-0.2795601487159729,
-1.1014068126678467,
0.8331853747367859,
0.10582631081342697,
-0.2777561545372009,
-0.20776423811912537,
-0.6078183650970459,
-0.5970311760902405,
0.8776676058769226,
0.4408720135688782,
-0.5924659371376038,
0.04964281618595123,
0.3446975350379944,
0.6473773717880249,
-0.1932869851589203,
0.42734581232070923,
0.6122996807098389,
0.36339038610458374,
0.01115224789828062,
-0.8537253737449646,
0.28944432735443115,
-0.23646168410778046,
-0.0596105195581913,
0.38374388217926025,
-0.4838351607322693,
0.7259019017219543,
-0.3118288516998291,
-0.05026999115943909,
0.1564333140850067,
0.5891305208206177,
-0.11227129399776459,
0.27739664912223816,
0.43734484910964966,
0.2527642250061035,
0.5285196900367737,
0.08054398000240326,
1.0520092248916626,
-0.26544126868247986,
0.44679147005081177,
0.9907397031784058,
-0.01581510342657566,
0.524512767791748,
0.5919294953346252,
-0.2451796978712082,
0.3861970901489258,
0.37642598152160645,
-0.25489673018455505,
0.47269317507743835,
0.455798864364624,
-0.029286811128258705,
-0.5109215974807739,
0.1090482622385025,
-0.08954228460788727,
0.2885914444923401,
0.4195868968963623,
-0.7388940453529358,
-0.10824073106050491,
0.021542374044656754,
-0.380974143743515,
-0.19008560478687286,
-0.42191198468208313,
0.5187067985534668,
0.3157201409339905,
-0.10184971243143082,
0.478545606136322,
0.2173117697238922,
0.41851139068603516,
-0.5742326378822327,
-0.2703379988670349,
-0.07491949945688248,
0.1143282800912857,
-0.4204700291156769,
-0.8569511771202087,
0.5858561992645264,
-0.10526919364929199,
-0.21311865746974945,
-0.24357302486896515,
1.1391385793685913,
-0.24053166806697845,
-0.7031515836715698,
0.4375973343849182,
0.5582420229911804,
0.08865968883037567,
-0.14373229444026947,
-0.6236876845359802,
0.06588736176490784,
-0.06600133329629898,
-0.29956260323524475,
0.4020434319972992,
0.5638214349746704,
-0.03995329886674881,
0.7945883274078369,
0.4401729702949524,
0.17691251635551453,
0.14499911665916443,
0.14026260375976562,
1.1073296070098877,
-0.7854177951812744,
0.02957637421786785,
-0.9299619793891907,
0.3746238648891449,
0.1898309886455536,
0.10057635605335236,
0.4119831323623657,
0.615559995174408,
0.6603917479515076,
-0.10872026532888412,
0.650746762752533,
-0.007006431929767132,
0.06822148710489273,
-0.8212635517120361,
0.5908749103546143,
-0.5501991510391235,
0.6973965167999268,
0.08893486112356186,
-0.891564130783081,
-0.31757020950317383,
0.7032041549682617,
-0.20690381526947021,
0.23215799033641815,
0.46085625886917114,
0.8989433646202087,
-0.5863134264945984,
0.0328633114695549,
0.3219260573387146,
0.47711020708084106,
0.1890738308429718,
0.7208797931671143,
1.0225467681884766,
-0.6588202118873596,
0.7158518433570862,
-0.3204594552516937,
-0.06132487580180168,
0.06652053445577621,
-0.7002276182174683,
-0.9286187291145325,
-0.33684098720550537,
-0.01746443659067154,
-0.2823614776134491,
-0.19689470529556274,
0.7013464570045471,
0.5879433751106262,
-0.9695459604263306,
-0.10904048383235931,
-0.2658996880054474,
0.41066864132881165,
-0.16455642879009247,
-0.19988304376602173,
0.3376518785953522,
-0.2219875305891037,
-0.41720157861709595,
0.23133420944213867,
0.45491889119148254,
0.16402798891067505,
-0.5978943705558777,
-0.17337410151958466,
0.213862344622612,
-0.027154995128512383,
0.6228891611099243,
0.21655908226966858,
-0.7437460422515869,
-0.3092029392719269,
0.0695936381816864,
-0.11590038985013962,
-0.12551262974739075,
1.192738652229309,
-0.6875783801078796,
0.23046031594276428,
0.31819072365760803,
0.6826522946357727,
0.7916804552078247,
-0.19306842982769012,
0.41740861535072327,
-0.8124597668647766,
0.01739993877708912,
0.06301480531692505,
0.5484327673912048,
0.2798171937465668,
-0.3535855710506439,
0.5068382024765015,
0.2933235168457031,
-0.518501341342926,
-0.6072458624839783,
0.27947431802749634,
-1.0971025228500366,
-0.42897582054138184,
0.9868628978729248,
-0.05387931689620018,
-0.26230841875076294,
-0.15091723203659058,
-0.07996974885463715,
-0.08099368959665298,
0.1221148744225502,
0.577957808971405,
0.5246565937995911,
-0.5256540179252625,
-0.38171449303627014,
-0.637833833694458,
0.35320404171943665,
0.3262830674648285,
-0.5600984692573547,
0.2392241358757019,
0.29674309492111206,
0.3272987902164459,
0.25716736912727356,
0.5085804462432861,
-0.045582856982946396,
0.1364389955997467,
0.04581700637936592,
-0.10747253149747849,
-0.14448291063308716,
-0.38859355449676514,
-0.6265065670013428,
0.15629902482032776,
0.20501814782619476,
0.08141639083623886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11801v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11801v1 | Safety Arithmetic: A Framework for Test-time Safety Alignment of Language Models by Steering Parameters and Activations | 2024-06-17T17:48:13 | 2024-06-17T17:48:13 | Rima Hazra, Sayan Layek, Somnath Banerjee, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL | Ensuring the safe alignment of large language models (LLMs) with human values
is critical as they become integral to applications like translation and
question answering. Current alignment methods struggle with dynamic user
intentions and complex objectives, making models vulnerable to generating
harmful content. We propose Safety Arithmetic, a training-free framework
enhancing LLM safety across different scenarios: Base models, Supervised
fine-tuned models (SFT), and Edited models. Safety Arithmetic involves Harm
Direction Removal to avoid harmful content and Safety Alignment to promote safe
responses. Additionally, we present NoIntentEdit, a dataset highlighting edit
instances that could compromise model safety if used unintentionally. Our
experiments show that Safety Arithmetic significantly improves safety measures,
reduces over-safety, and maintains model utility, outperforming existing
methods in ensuring safe content generation. | [
0.06844258308410645,
-0.6568188071250916,
0.25526344776153564,
0.19313636422157288,
-0.1252448558807373,
-0.08828285336494446,
0.19468379020690918,
-0.4449266493320465,
-0.3906109035015106,
0.5951805710792542,
-0.3734951615333557,
-0.5432674884796143,
-0.4842749834060669,
-0.21432414650917053,
-0.6918243765830994,
1.0463931560516357,
-0.05585751309990883,
0.022380223497748375,
-0.3043299913406372,
-0.25013086199760437,
-0.18030723929405212,
-0.719733476638794,
-0.8142918944358826,
0.007601989433169365,
0.5405011177062988,
0.365824431180954,
1.0588456392288208,
1.0422321557998657,
0.5561579465866089,
0.35859447717666626,
0.12648014724254608,
0.025154704228043556,
-0.47961515188217163,
-0.018449842929840088,
-0.17936664819717407,
-0.32739466428756714,
-1.0640203952789307,
-0.047918859869241714,
0.45718103647232056,
0.7452545762062073,
-0.338842511177063,
-0.18654416501522064,
-0.10334034264087677,
0.7195715308189392,
-0.774699330329895,
0.007976475171744823,
-0.5025705695152283,
-0.11742573231458664,
0.11243581026792526,
-0.20102867484092712,
-0.5742502808570862,
-0.824760377407074,
-0.2109576016664505,
-0.5443256497383118,
-0.14271877706050873,
0.1902972012758255,
0.6463590860366821,
0.43863317370414734,
-0.787759006023407,
-0.05031345784664154,
-0.2958413064479828,
0.7928600311279297,
-0.8226937651634216,
0.4891725480556488,
0.28813767433166504,
0.06715323030948639,
-0.475870817899704,
0.021231019869446754,
-0.6154795289039612,
0.1169513463973999,
0.12469850480556488,
-0.19317279756069183,
0.06931763142347336,
0.5142042636871338,
0.21032361686229706,
0.08129899948835373,
-0.6423575282096863,
0.34112289547920227,
-0.20848506689071655,
-0.15689919888973236,
0.9727591276168823,
0.4414012134075165,
0.7534096837043762,
-0.025634702295064926,
-0.3021472692489624,
-0.24075350165367126,
-1.2341951131820679,
0.013579235412180424,
0.5797363519668579,
0.2797938585281372,
-0.21777261793613434,
0.759773313999176,
-0.2582966089248657,
0.6371127367019653,
0.005741365719586611,
-0.3299812078475952,
0.19284263253211975,
-0.3052258789539337,
-0.2909145951271057,
0.43104466795921326,
0.9153309464454651,
0.6610552668571472,
0.5303813219070435,
-0.20629170536994934,
-0.167265847325325,
0.21506869792938232,
0.3447345197200775,
-0.9616300463676453,
0.00973525457084179,
0.09644478559494019,
0.07212348282337189,
-1.0417420864105225,
-0.17617520689964294,
-0.38986825942993164,
-0.31387585401535034,
-0.2992155849933624,
0.3819041848182678,
-0.5535435080528259,
-0.25324487686157227,
0.5631546974182129,
0.42444726824760437,
0.13001321256160736,
0.06795615702867508,
-1.2208844423294067,
0.1427679806947708,
0.9954230189323425,
0.27586862444877625,
-0.16139963269233704,
-0.15330535173416138,
-0.7318021059036255,
0.47086021304130554,
-0.7235991954803467,
0.369710236787796,
-0.22029854357242584,
-0.45204395055770874,
0.03701571747660637,
0.16017043590545654,
-0.10029768198728561,
-0.0839536041021347,
0.5730465054512024,
-0.7050674557685852,
0.18393711745738983,
0.09669597446918488,
-0.6494542360305786,
-0.2422019988298416,
0.19647592306137085,
-0.5242451429367065,
0.8439723253250122,
-0.13250085711479187,
-0.6832289099693298,
0.308017760515213,
-0.6208580732345581,
-0.7186246514320374,
-0.27354514598846436,
-0.05058426409959793,
-0.44822564721107483,
0.007738281507045031,
0.11479044705629349,
0.23003239929676056,
0.13581235706806183,
0.4439511001110077,
-0.37034550309181213,
-0.11763185262680054,
0.3214176595211029,
-0.6829416155815125,
0.9341665506362915,
-0.011319282464683056,
-0.16834798455238342,
0.4764944612979889,
-0.7780328392982483,
0.11238161474466324,
-0.046440884470939636,
-0.6139660477638245,
-0.4890249967575073,
0.09848044067621231,
-0.23666338622570038,
0.399259477853775,
0.10764507949352264,
-0.5003925561904907,
-0.12058350443840027,
-0.6491269469261169,
0.14682504534721375,
0.7424592971801758,
0.23198384046554565,
0.6962032318115234,
-0.3410596251487732,
0.4377703368663788,
0.07273270934820175,
0.25835639238357544,
0.03429776802659035,
-0.2906869351863861,
-0.8699257373809814,
0.08303478360176086,
0.3817909061908722,
0.842596709728241,
-0.5078121423721313,
0.6334443688392639,
-0.4984932243824005,
-0.27897825837135315,
-0.33301547169685364,
0.22529380023479462,
0.709664523601532,
0.6439432501792908,
0.08380217850208282,
-0.10817328840494156,
-0.27894318103790283,
-0.6348864436149597,
-0.11628594249486923,
-0.4439505338668823,
-0.11911462247371674,
-0.1620907485485077,
0.017164498567581177,
-0.16846369206905365,
0.676432728767395,
-0.2574734091758728,
0.3591687083244324,
-0.027146974578499794,
0.15187422931194305,
-0.26853227615356445,
0.7835242748260498,
0.6180137991905212,
-0.7618310451507568,
-0.24920573830604553,
-0.11314138025045395,
-0.8290642499923706,
-0.14920072257518768,
0.05925901606678963,
-0.44630879163742065,
0.5319280028343201,
0.3817475736141205,
-0.6751626133918762,
0.30729940533638,
0.5927348732948303,
-0.3028201162815094,
0.22180356085300446,
0.018443195149302483,
0.2820564806461334,
-1.1226733922958374,
-0.12371191382408142,
-0.10924902558326721,
-0.4122137725353241,
-0.8111304640769958,
0.3142486810684204,
0.4723643362522125,
-0.14528429508209229,
-0.8813254237174988,
0.3560623228549957,
-0.0939423143863678,
0.306545227766037,
-0.205713152885437,
0.06109664589166641,
0.014791405759751797,
0.17676539719104767,
-0.005207393784075975,
0.9321780204772949,
0.19387292861938477,
-0.5175637602806091,
-0.04845556989312172,
0.2760796844959259,
-0.29584261775016785,
0.5260100960731506,
-0.5294358134269714,
0.2576903700828552,
-0.08541066199541092,
-0.2630726099014282,
-0.7747225761413574,
-0.4500812292098999,
0.1239476352930069,
-0.30189576745033264,
0.4216423034667969,
-0.1886204481124878,
-0.47601374983787537,
0.2324656844139099,
-0.29149433970451355,
0.6349406242370605,
0.539833128452301,
-0.178385391831398,
0.32688218355178833,
0.6654338836669922,
-0.43530187010765076,
-0.7326177954673767,
-0.3626466989517212,
-0.1333416998386383,
-0.4819607138633728,
-0.9759027361869812,
0.0018000039272010326,
-0.22724030911922455,
-0.3816683888435364,
-0.1423235386610031,
-0.23988653719425201,
-0.14355027675628662,
0.48270195722579956,
0.45412594079971313,
0.5095180869102478,
-0.14901787042617798,
0.10069303959608078,
0.4012686312198639,
-0.42241546511650085,
0.16669321060180664,
0.11821586638689041,
0.19862347841262817,
-0.023096807301044464,
-0.47362983226776123,
-0.23210524022579193,
0.39922279119491577,
0.6015957593917847,
-0.043299365788698196,
0.5627806782722473,
-0.0324549674987793,
-0.5801060795783997,
0.19375154376029968,
-0.339441180229187,
-0.14809446036815643,
-0.5799852609634399,
0.32346177101135254,
0.08791215717792511,
-0.8989723920822144,
-0.06818611174821854,
0.2692869305610657,
0.5292733907699585,
0.23080843687057495,
0.40779367089271545,
-0.12365904450416565,
1.4329811334609985,
0.6786948442459106,
-0.0011583681916818023,
0.2888747751712799,
0.36654022336006165,
0.3690975606441498,
-0.22247043251991272,
-0.08017085492610931,
-0.36861059069633484,
-0.10772645473480225,
-0.4173278510570526,
-0.38761085271835327,
0.3498336672782898,
0.2455206662416458,
-0.5700719952583313,
0.357229083776474,
-0.17458195984363556,
0.7683815360069275,
0.2175532579421997,
-0.03210044652223587,
0.35938286781311035,
0.008538580499589443,
-0.07163995504379272,
-0.15893572568893433,
-0.43639257550239563,
-0.6319401264190674,
0.9489955306053162,
0.28251489996910095,
1.0435142517089844,
0.4119361639022827,
0.689808189868927,
-0.05675942450761795,
0.5320524573326111,
-0.6889699101448059,
0.7416232824325562,
-0.11603496968746185,
-0.9620251655578613,
-0.4775688350200653,
-0.4611397087574005,
-0.6010246872901917,
0.033471349626779556,
-0.41040700674057007,
-0.5045424699783325,
-0.07528866082429886,
0.22668060660362244,
-0.5944330096244812,
0.1926027089357376,
-0.7370660305023193,
0.790958046913147,
-0.7787216901779175,
-0.3948928117752075,
-0.26351386308670044,
-0.6592058539390564,
0.580736517906189,
-0.219074085354805,
0.40635237097740173,
-0.48449552059173584,
-0.15881407260894775,
0.5081601142883301,
-0.40112775564193726,
0.9092984199523926,
0.13155244290828705,
-0.2826620042324066,
0.05080243572592735,
0.5813891291618347,
0.5591934323310852,
-0.11516004055738449,
-0.27901098132133484,
0.1619032919406891,
-0.011746901087462902,
-0.2763987183570862,
-0.4507858157157898,
0.7374804019927979,
-0.4952062666416168,
-0.7921813726425171,
-0.3697272539138794,
-0.997266948223114,
-0.3247552216053009,
0.431911438703537,
-0.13600654900074005,
0.20903363823890686,
-0.07264915853738785,
0.24242781102657318,
0.8839299082756042,
-0.1523437649011612,
0.6079016327857971,
0.6625370979309082,
-0.05547556281089783,
-0.46757933497428894,
0.7773446440696716,
-0.1482478827238083,
0.6375023722648621,
0.42828530073165894,
-0.11782661825418472,
-0.5018227100372314,
-0.6812204122543335,
-0.6213524341583252,
-0.04735611379146576,
-0.8221020698547363,
-0.27939143776893616,
-0.6279274821281433,
-0.3552340865135193,
-0.34305182099342346,
-0.39648938179016113,
-0.23732005059719086,
-0.9121316075325012,
-0.12678755819797516,
-0.723654568195343,
0.3898656368255615,
0.4792022705078125,
-0.18950052559375763,
0.26760074496269226,
-1.058957815170288,
0.05278350040316582,
0.2450430542230606,
0.29668134450912476,
-0.3146125078201294,
-0.12648218870162964,
-0.09138379991054535,
0.09600569307804108,
-0.38566961884498596,
-0.6285271048545837,
0.29973024129867554,
0.010974506847560406,
0.36420899629592896,
0.595731258392334,
0.32110732793807983,
0.5388529896736145,
-0.70912766456604,
0.5186960101127625,
0.48192599415779114,
-0.8527786731719971,
0.15689966082572937,
-0.5893248915672302,
-0.1633186787366867,
0.7533544898033142,
0.40830153226852417,
-0.43390369415283203,
-0.25232627987861633,
-0.33591964840888977,
-0.87910395860672,
0.3219945430755615,
0.06374933570623398,
0.3382093012332916,
-0.23516322672367096,
0.23479151725769043,
0.022545963525772095,
0.22973667085170746,
-0.6272771954536438,
0.0769147053360939,
0.06634335964918137,
-0.6473862528800964,
0.1589312106370926,
-0.427534818649292,
-0.4200512766838074,
-0.0952877327799797,
0.7380680441856384,
-0.10332156717777252,
-0.17197071015834808,
-0.3400009870529175,
-0.2377897948026657,
-0.4627711772918701,
0.49504178762435913,
0.6798004508018494,
0.5306431651115417,
-0.05511556565761566,
0.20853392779827118,
0.3804989159107208,
-0.2562409043312073,
0.5781019330024719,
-0.09193488210439682,
-0.30806997418403625,
-0.5116201639175415,
0.22698746621608734,
0.48175880312919617,
0.7606713771820068,
-0.5786297917366028,
0.4810068607330322,
0.033841732889413834,
-0.1406537890434265,
-0.06239362061023712,
0.8114845752716064,
0.2216285765171051,
-0.23449940979480743,
-0.08324351906776428,
-0.03574731945991516,
-0.031741589307785034,
-0.16464264690876007,
0.39444854855537415,
0.3523089587688446,
-0.4887979030609131,
-0.25437894463539124,
1.0052512884140015,
0.5278976559638977,
-0.5179535746574402,
0.42706069350242615,
0.00507969968020916,
-0.2766890823841095,
0.4852275550365448,
0.4175516664981842,
0.8987084627151489,
-0.4529839754104614,
-0.05903033912181854,
0.26265081763267517,
0.5082563757896423,
-0.02409282885491848,
0.45648759603500366,
0.4528048634529114,
-0.7455711960792542,
-0.45582354068756104,
-0.5981597304344177,
-0.408308744430542,
-0.04869109392166138,
-0.43223896622657776,
0.1991988569498062,
-0.4726428687572479,
0.08586107939481735,
-0.14035654067993164,
-0.41788163781166077,
-0.14409026503562927,
0.3363630175590515,
-0.005161934066563845,
1.0088164806365967,
-0.8388177156448364,
0.8273069858551025,
0.501998782157898,
-0.27208611369132996,
-0.9312704205513,
-0.12835495173931122,
0.34086498618125916,
-0.6323072910308838,
0.22614237666130066,
0.2682812213897705,
-0.24174565076828003,
0.07210108637809753,
-0.41574421525001526,
-0.6956576108932495,
0.8920935988426208,
0.7199792265892029,
-0.7299638986587524,
-0.2237178385257721,
0.7185423374176025,
0.33468344807624817,
-0.26210349798202515,
-0.25656965374946594,
0.48667800426483154,
0.23454250395298004,
-0.014688289724290371,
-0.6612146496772766,
0.2764613926410675,
-0.20098382234573364,
-0.1643805205821991,
0.5006862878799438,
-0.2998009920120239,
0.4826434552669525,
-0.4450717568397522,
-0.266955703496933,
0.21850521862506866,
0.38142842054367065,
0.4709133803844452,
0.21232664585113525,
0.6279948949813843,
0.8417561650276184,
0.6375821232795715,
-0.1800924390554428,
1.0136752128601074,
-0.5703392624855042,
-0.02706465683877468,
0.8811981081962585,
-0.19164833426475525,
0.7863332033157349,
0.38896623253822327,
0.04749295115470886,
0.27495822310447693,
0.5939649939537048,
0.6612054109573364,
0.6007328629493713,
-0.14908023178577423,
-0.5301181674003601,
-0.6333926916122437,
0.10014741122722626,
-0.326310396194458,
0.08714626729488373,
0.30407437682151794,
-0.20216648280620575,
-0.11253347992897034,
-0.5068514943122864,
0.3903140723705292,
-0.1400202065706253,
-0.0160507932305336,
0.811492919921875,
0.18626099824905396,
-0.5817744135856628,
0.4053233861923218,
-0.007635331247001886,
0.2541348338127136,
-0.4187328815460205,
0.03184564784169197,
-0.2409006953239441,
0.23457199335098267,
-0.20610368251800537,
-0.9495420455932617,
0.39657700061798096,
-0.015187239274382591,
-0.08923743665218353,
-0.06906282156705856,
0.505832850933075,
-0.5183567404747009,
-0.6696428656578064,
0.02635706588625908,
0.1359284520149231,
-0.13210301101207733,
0.3000306487083435,
-0.6039530634880066,
-0.14975279569625854,
-0.19799847900867462,
-0.0663389265537262,
0.5621800422668457,
0.4438367486000061,
-0.4550691843032837,
0.6232089996337891,
0.8775105476379395,
-0.3377566933631897,
0.1994638741016388,
-0.1369691789150238,
0.5919382572174072,
-0.6930712461471558,
-0.5880235433578491,
-0.8655147552490234,
0.8733810782432556,
-0.006800348870456219,
0.04665398970246315,
0.5930225253105164,
0.489620178937912,
0.6626222133636475,
0.046278826892375946,
0.7011673450469971,
0.1429666131734848,
0.05732758715748787,
-0.5834048390388489,
1.1161789894104004,
-0.4405432641506195,
0.24122604727745056,
-0.17930956184864044,
-0.6327640414237976,
-0.6561381816864014,
0.3907727599143982,
-0.375575989484787,
-0.24587640166282654,
0.4162568151950836,
1.0067824125289917,
-0.15016727149486542,
0.10264620184898376,
0.3830292522907257,
-0.09429291635751724,
0.4887659251689911,
0.607294499874115,
0.6881015300750732,
-0.4670107066631317,
0.6274060010910034,
-0.3271876573562622,
-0.22415366768836975,
-0.06583315879106522,
-1.4028851985931396,
-0.8453467488288879,
-0.04126619175076485,
-0.4381328821182251,
-0.34057801961898804,
0.24447795748710632,
0.8984494209289551,
0.8233632445335388,
-1.0673798322677612,
-0.11463315784931183,
-0.20310108363628387,
0.23771284520626068,
0.0262223519384861,
-0.14476750791072845,
0.167024627327919,
-0.1272556036710739,
-0.6453621983528137,
0.6231815218925476,
0.4672333002090454,
0.3669113218784332,
0.01708112843334675,
-0.37903422117233276,
0.03594178706407547,
0.39250826835632324,
0.406120628118515,
0.35875001549720764,
-0.38010382652282715,
-0.5720826983451843,
-0.00795526709407568,
-0.4027922451496124,
-0.002695756033062935,
0.4259685277938843,
-0.07116422057151794,
0.30224961042404175,
0.5901919603347778,
0.8507526516914368,
-0.2149600088596344,
0.3104740381240845,
0.8398888111114502,
-0.8313174247741699,
0.31005987524986267,
0.006838243454694748,
0.48274680972099304,
0.5233649015426636,
-0.6019824743270874,
0.6648014783859253,
-0.06753595173358917,
-0.5616405606269836,
-0.9209742546081543,
0.353304922580719,
-0.8246610760688782,
0.22714190185070038,
1.1799993515014648,
-0.1626339852809906,
-0.20821332931518555,
-0.13746997714042664,
0.03491495922207832,
0.18764083087444305,
-0.2715167701244354,
0.9856907725334167,
0.5333635210990906,
0.02489345893263817,
-0.13059398531913757,
-0.4622533619403839,
0.5407023429870605,
0.47033801674842834,
-1.0332540273666382,
0.10872139781713486,
0.6724022030830383,
0.6630460023880005,
0.017543505877256393,
0.21090103685855865,
-0.5063349604606628,
0.5268389582633972,
-0.3269658386707306,
0.05797566473484039,
-0.18993927538394928,
-0.30217331647872925,
-0.29640281200408936,
0.09859340637922287,
0.17283958196640015,
-0.17019960284233093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11794v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11794v3 | DataComp-LM: In search of the next generation of training sets for language models | 2024-06-17T17:42:57 | 2024-06-20T17:43:05 | Jeffrey Li, Alex Fang, Georgios Smyrnis, Maor Ivgi, Matt Jordan, Samir Gadre, Hritik Bansal, Etash Guha, Sedrick Keh, Kushal Arora, Saurabh Garg, Rui Xin, Niklas Muennighoff, Reinhard Heckel, Jean Mercat, Mayee Chen, Suchin Gururangan, Mitchell Wortsman, Alon Albalak, Yonatan Bitton, Marianna Nezhurina, Amro Abbas, Cheng-Yu Hsieh, Dhruba Ghosh, Josh Gardner, Maciej Kilian, Hanlin Zhang, Rulin Shao, Sarah Pratt, Sunny Sanyal, Gabriel Ilharco, Giannis Daras, Kalyani Marathe, Aaron Gokaslan, Jieyu Zhang, Khyathi Chandu, Thao Nguyen, Igor Vasiljevic, Sham Kakade, Shuran Song, Sujay Sanghavi, Fartash Faghri, Sewoong Oh, Luke Zettlemoyer, Kyle Lo, Alaaeldin El-Nouby, Hadi Pouransari, Alexander Toshev, Stephanie Wang, Dirk Groeneveld, Luca Soldaini, Pang Wei Koh, Jenia Jitsev, Thomas Kollar, Alexandros G. Dimakis, Yair Carmon, Achal Dave, Ludwig Schmidt, Vaishaal Shankar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | We introduce DataComp for Language Models (DCLM), a testbed for controlled
dataset experiments with the goal of improving language models. As part of
DCLM, we provide a standardized corpus of 240T tokens extracted from Common
Crawl, effective pretraining recipes based on the OpenLM framework, and a broad
suite of 53 downstream evaluations. Participants in the DCLM benchmark can
experiment with data curation strategies such as deduplication, filtering, and
data mixing at model scales ranging from 412M to 7B parameters. As a baseline
for DCLM, we conduct extensive experiments and find that model-based filtering
is key to assembling a high-quality training set. The resulting dataset,
DCLM-Baseline enables training a 7B parameter language model from scratch to
64% 5-shot accuracy on MMLU with 2.6T training tokens. Compared to MAP-Neo, the
previous state-of-the-art in open-data language models, DCLM-Baseline
represents a 6.6 percentage point improvement on MMLU while being trained with
40% less compute. Our baseline model is also comparable to Mistral-7B-v0.3 and
Llama 3 8B on MMLU (63% & 66%), and performs similarly on an average of 53
natural language understanding tasks while being trained with 6.6x less compute
than Llama 3 8B. Our results highlight the importance of dataset design for
training language models and offer a starting point for further research on
data curation. | [
-0.38407474756240845,
-0.7096797823905945,
0.3048982620239258,
-0.13335824012756348,
-0.18208551406860352,
0.3032340109348297,
-0.31929534673690796,
-0.1119648739695549,
-0.3657703399658203,
0.5960381627082825,
-0.5701571106910706,
-0.7432522177696228,
-0.5732436180114746,
0.07554145157337189,
-0.6639483571052551,
0.8260959982872009,
-0.047769758850336075,
0.1636059284210205,
-0.18201009929180145,
-0.09672398120164871,
-0.5238634943962097,
-0.7420570254325867,
-0.7760214805603027,
-0.3575236201286316,
0.6810722947120667,
0.47779208421707153,
0.7736285924911499,
0.8061106204986572,
0.4737691879272461,
0.12317486852407455,
-0.08550377190113068,
0.21238377690315247,
-0.7875036597251892,
0.035366687923669815,
0.04193175211548805,
-0.48552295565605164,
-0.4651910066604614,
0.4473405182361603,
0.6486464142799377,
1.2102916240692139,
-0.311270147562027,
0.12335819005966187,
-0.04863986000418663,
0.7410836815834045,
-0.594369113445282,
0.22927150130271912,
-0.8580068945884705,
-0.06918498128652573,
-0.25131556391716003,
-0.12674295902252197,
-0.6542264819145203,
-0.264616996049881,
-0.35938766598701477,
-0.5064528584480286,
0.3920583724975586,
0.3280978202819824,
0.6253553628921509,
0.33428576588630676,
-0.27226799726486206,
-0.11781369894742966,
-0.4993625581264496,
0.8836344480514526,
-0.8603172302246094,
0.6799530982971191,
0.6945719718933105,
0.3331395089626312,
-0.3748144805431366,
-0.7889578342437744,
-0.601861298084259,
-0.24941490590572357,
-0.07112524658441544,
-0.06971833854913712,
-0.22641374170780182,
0.04489780217409134,
0.5063604712486267,
0.46922922134399414,
-0.7427279949188232,
0.3753315806388855,
-0.295254647731781,
-0.029148472473025322,
0.5861625671386719,
0.3835965692996979,
-0.003963472321629524,
0.2562033236026764,
0.021071385592222214,
-0.20935747027397156,
-1.0314842462539673,
-0.13056890666484833,
0.4307510554790497,
0.6724637746810913,
-0.13784635066986084,
0.4741142690181732,
-0.4264184236526489,
1.148252248764038,
-0.2613898515701294,
0.05542133003473282,
0.15575183928012848,
-0.5286157131195068,
-0.3755272328853607,
-0.3003639280796051,
0.5783976912498474,
0.29473716020584106,
0.36739447712898254,
-0.20463839173316956,
-0.3426070809364319,
0.11359819769859314,
0.19880793988704681,
-0.7861788868904114,
-0.4753684997558594,
0.281616747379303,
-0.4334494471549988,
-0.5273347496986389,
-0.12494800984859467,
-0.604428768157959,
-0.4920426607131958,
-0.7701740264892578,
-0.0683424174785614,
-0.05281777307391167,
-0.33144789934158325,
0.3896009624004364,
0.06765823066234589,
0.012949369847774506,
0.2858298420906067,
-0.8750462532043457,
0.6843267679214478,
0.7203719615936279,
0.6291810274124146,
-0.4518980085849762,
-0.25765690207481384,
-0.7945303320884705,
-0.3061268627643585,
-0.6057668924331665,
0.6263062357902527,
-0.6807025074958801,
-0.2794659733772278,
0.19932565093040466,
-0.047673292458057404,
-0.16105905175209045,
-0.7970825433731079,
0.5565054416656494,
-0.5636661052703857,
0.30194297432899475,
-0.2092663198709488,
-0.8514628410339355,
-0.015837956219911575,
0.19465646147727966,
-0.840762734413147,
1.209948182106018,
0.297667920589447,
-0.7627572417259216,
0.493836373090744,
-0.506928563117981,
-0.18752457201480865,
0.061480745673179626,
-0.17147138714790344,
-0.2793579399585724,
0.08667056262493134,
0.23867718875408173,
0.351727694272995,
-0.42902010679244995,
0.45771321654319763,
-0.5751798152923584,
-0.5261401534080505,
0.2272622138261795,
-0.5391054749488831,
0.9461148977279663,
0.3261520266532898,
0.07425205409526825,
0.047426737844944,
-0.9574674367904663,
0.07133421301841736,
0.07189685851335526,
-0.4216178357601166,
-0.1949641853570938,
-0.039119914174079895,
0.14044134318828583,
0.263149619102478,
0.015560123138129711,
-0.49370667338371277,
0.12900187075138092,
-0.25207003951072693,
0.29339560866355896,
0.6443778276443481,
-0.3258623778820038,
0.2736687958240509,
-0.3421719968318939,
0.5147998332977295,
0.05903780832886696,
0.23789082467556,
-0.09066787362098694,
-0.23402874171733856,
-0.8772040009498596,
-0.30702918767929077,
0.39689910411834717,
0.21150121092796326,
-0.5801891088485718,
0.5648953914642334,
-0.21342432498931885,
-0.5769523978233337,
-0.7897816300392151,
0.24825003743171692,
0.1650826632976532,
0.6110658645629883,
0.393677681684494,
-0.23247212171554565,
-0.7692493200302124,
-0.6825191378593445,
0.04066384583711624,
-0.16454167664051056,
0.14483888447284698,
0.06967034190893173,
0.3339892625808716,
-0.11184722930192947,
1.0995867252349854,
-0.4689168930053711,
-0.016548756510019302,
-0.5025177597999573,
-0.041233129799366,
0.6150659322738647,
0.219255268573761,
0.42227882146835327,
-0.5707993507385254,
-0.45581957697868347,
-0.19135180115699768,
-0.5288739800453186,
-0.38797125220298767,
0.18037505447864532,
-0.0009346833685413003,
0.2771923840045929,
0.6008906960487366,
-0.42746254801750183,
0.42740359902381897,
0.8146815299987793,
-0.18926098942756653,
0.4902595579624176,
-0.1432947963476181,
0.011022155173122883,
-0.9279367923736572,
0.30769968032836914,
-0.27989763021469116,
-0.3518425226211548,
-0.8687730431556702,
-0.03858093544840813,
0.17151953279972076,
-0.11735135316848755,
-0.5526768565177917,
0.7559984922409058,
-0.3113570511341095,
-0.026985803619027138,
-0.545135498046875,
0.20602771639823914,
0.09561850875616074,
0.45245257019996643,
0.13050870597362518,
0.7543671727180481,
0.7040389180183411,
-0.6095050573348999,
0.43117913603782654,
0.21071940660476685,
-0.49588340520858765,
0.2812683582305908,
-0.5923910737037659,
0.28494858741760254,
0.036535270512104034,
0.3263345956802368,
-0.9360154867172241,
0.1976349949836731,
-0.016042213886976242,
-0.17208591103553772,
0.2880367338657379,
-0.09529143571853638,
-0.7114316821098328,
-0.5147024393081665,
-0.13685627281665802,
0.09475399553775787,
0.4511330723762512,
-0.6808323860168457,
-0.08089375495910645,
0.44802069664001465,
-0.03480475768446922,
-0.6588970422744751,
-0.4603378474712372,
0.14056770503520966,
-0.12463381141424179,
-0.20817169547080994,
0.020491676405072212,
-0.3430638015270233,
-0.42025163769721985,
-0.21753419935703278,
0.030490027740597725,
-0.18977832794189453,
0.29154959321022034,
0.13445813953876495,
0.326671302318573,
-0.026309922337532043,
0.16871534287929535,
-0.3592258095741272,
-0.15595830976963043,
-0.024419613182544708,
-0.03746988996863365,
0.9295960664749146,
0.21989718079566956,
-0.3715602457523346,
-0.1461692601442337,
0.21071697771549225,
0.26833730936050415,
-0.19506581127643585,
0.7064889073371887,
0.3719576299190521,
-0.34546199440956116,
-0.274832159280777,
-0.33508142828941345,
-0.24077661335468292,
-0.4184744358062744,
0.3230346143245697,
-0.4078606367111206,
-0.8756134510040283,
0.438350111246109,
0.1781136393547058,
0.2911096215248108,
0.23776479065418243,
0.6868518590927124,
0.00405896408483386,
0.992659866809845,
0.6552978157997131,
-0.4625977575778961,
0.4588995575904846,
-0.29892870783805847,
0.10662227869033813,
-0.6406581401824951,
-0.00004963091851095669,
-0.6659940481185913,
-0.15981386601924896,
-0.48193418979644775,
-0.45510244369506836,
-0.22922317683696747,
0.04098322615027428,
-0.22944390773773193,
0.4723656475543976,
-0.1279016137123108,
0.32543569803237915,
0.6083129644393921,
0.020327672362327576,
0.4977862536907196,
-0.051900800317525864,
-0.09213446825742722,
0.018562093377113342,
-0.8334923386573792,
-0.4097135066986084,
1.433264970779419,
0.34985238313674927,
1.0801985263824463,
-0.35354334115982056,
0.49996301531791687,
0.3127215802669525,
0.32037097215652466,
-0.6698106527328491,
0.5209956169128418,
-0.31642481684684753,
-0.5738346576690674,
-0.2103128284215927,
-0.5144443511962891,
-1.0005569458007812,
0.0973142459988594,
0.028889289125800133,
-0.27977919578552246,
0.09103240072727203,
0.09655069559812546,
-0.05254078283905983,
0.28781217336654663,
-0.4114241302013397,
0.822830080986023,
0.04202139377593994,
-0.12389100342988968,
-0.2679639756679535,
-0.46629229187965393,
0.19606806337833405,
-0.27557915449142456,
0.2532005310058594,
-0.37617653608322144,
0.10765162110328674,
0.5331942439079285,
-0.3882887065410614,
0.7553964257240295,
-0.1757957935333252,
-0.20491692423820496,
0.08913781493902206,
0.0003829649940598756,
0.4145474135875702,
-0.10937169939279556,
-0.36410701274871826,
0.18448148667812347,
-0.23559968173503876,
-0.31844615936279297,
-0.5513104796409607,
0.5193175077438354,
-0.6574479937553406,
-0.3570583462715149,
-0.27115944027900696,
-0.9053871035575867,
-0.15446002781391144,
0.08206171542406082,
-0.056300193071365356,
0.6694793105125427,
-0.2612451910972595,
0.4277695417404175,
0.48905667662620544,
-0.17374007403850555,
0.3389902114868164,
0.7797887921333313,
-0.37754467129707336,
-0.25823861360549927,
0.5973959565162659,
-0.02932763658463955,
0.5299404859542847,
0.4789564311504364,
0.051652390509843826,
-0.34706997871398926,
-0.8505438566207886,
-0.11641374230384827,
0.08795275539159775,
-0.6943474411964417,
-0.2838018536567688,
-0.5835716128349304,
-0.41052231192588806,
-0.47576647996902466,
0.27773356437683105,
-0.42380520701408386,
-0.41765135526657104,
-0.16757459938526154,
-0.15200619399547577,
0.38024505972862244,
0.5907194018363953,
-0.01406360324472189,
0.33951491117477417,
-0.40938329696655273,
0.3247639536857605,
0.05169079452753067,
0.3416728079319,
-0.32683712244033813,
-0.8442952036857605,
-0.4823909103870392,
0.23608507215976715,
0.004844338167458773,
-0.3501354157924652,
0.45080310106277466,
0.19540190696716309,
0.7597662210464478,
0.021612079814076424,
0.03536923602223396,
0.6055372357368469,
-0.5845028758049011,
0.596779465675354,
-0.0744088813662529,
-0.5967185497283936,
0.565211296081543,
-0.22466078400611877,
0.4119435250759125,
0.742551326751709,
0.3479295074939728,
-0.8112143278121948,
-0.5918436050415039,
-0.623661994934082,
-0.4104444682598114,
0.7370683550834656,
0.18029969930648804,
0.045433301478624344,
-0.01573418639600277,
0.257872998714447,
0.3391004800796509,
0.41938167810440063,
-0.5240131616592407,
-0.3710356652736664,
0.08707490563392639,
-0.36178848147392273,
-0.3677680492401123,
-0.08643226325511932,
-0.11929168552160263,
-0.4219270646572113,
0.6318495273590088,
-0.16013556718826294,
-0.07746779918670654,
-0.3537255525588989,
-0.16511870920658112,
-0.09695199131965637,
-0.007378656417131424,
0.3616463541984558,
0.9118116497993469,
-0.43917426466941833,
0.27473440766334534,
0.04238804057240486,
-0.606803297996521,
-0.001737244427204132,
0.26547959446907043,
-0.07062924653291702,
0.08611060678958893,
0.41235530376434326,
0.9833871126174927,
-0.04569815844297409,
-0.6801859140396118,
0.36474066972732544,
-0.205695241689682,
-0.20524458587169647,
-0.024021467193961143,
0.2149621546268463,
-0.06697455793619156,
-0.2006550282239914,
0.0631658062338829,
-0.21947187185287476,
0.08143570274114609,
-0.47211089730262756,
0.4848193824291229,
0.29425469040870667,
-0.4234699308872223,
-0.23397868871688843,
0.5195273160934448,
-0.001642785151489079,
-0.025831572711467743,
0.922835648059845,
0.04049484059214592,
-0.2255696803331375,
0.5192832350730896,
0.4924015402793884,
0.6074146032333374,
-0.12156639993190765,
0.2238643765449524,
0.4527531862258911,
0.27098971605300903,
-0.14261920750141144,
0.43679359555244446,
0.18636779487133026,
-0.8708728551864624,
-0.4163125157356262,
-0.7236430644989014,
-0.7100062370300293,
0.49451228976249695,
-0.587348461151123,
0.7252117395401001,
-0.24773971736431122,
0.14889678359031677,
-0.15969537198543549,
0.3289180397987366,
-0.9293580651283264,
0.3894442915916443,
0.07667773962020874,
1.2197074890136719,
-0.9888148903846741,
1.3095569610595703,
0.37389928102493286,
-0.30785107612609863,
-0.5894758701324463,
-0.4408957064151764,
-0.05183436721563339,
-1.0102142095565796,
0.654666006565094,
0.1921968162059784,
0.36110547184944153,
0.1733001470565796,
-0.6540218591690063,
-0.717107892036438,
0.9224960207939148,
0.39915230870246887,
-0.7554308772087097,
0.1789093315601349,
0.48734211921691895,
0.5617508292198181,
-0.5748571753501892,
0.22811289131641388,
0.953637421131134,
0.3443567454814911,
0.035550907254219055,
-0.7303996086120605,
-0.10442636162042618,
-0.2564617693424225,
-0.10992569476366043,
0.10533114522695541,
-0.22081078588962555,
0.9525933861732483,
-0.01644395850598812,
-0.02155384048819542,
0.022602371871471405,
0.4057195484638214,
0.48635154962539673,
0.06380987912416458,
0.6322540640830994,
0.7455275058746338,
0.7607620358467102,
-0.11609723418951035,
1.0470839738845825,
-0.21632833778858185,
0.34293365478515625,
1.5649346113204956,
-0.3685288727283478,
0.9089248180389404,
0.4558297097682953,
-0.35600781440734863,
0.22262659668922424,
0.9114683866500854,
-0.04853793978691101,
0.6343056559562683,
0.568252682685852,
-0.08999626338481903,
-0.1473422646522522,
-0.28361010551452637,
-0.20035307109355927,
0.3378432095050812,
0.17738178372383118,
-0.3384788930416107,
-0.31412771344184875,
0.045775946229696274,
0.04504804313182831,
0.16992375254631042,
-0.03629922494292259,
0.6363276243209839,
0.12390761077404022,
-0.48764660954475403,
0.7087603807449341,
-0.36874231696128845,
0.3770916759967804,
-0.5445639491081238,
-0.008289836347103119,
-0.68006831407547,
0.2203388661146164,
0.008402232080698013,
-0.8185964822769165,
0.21584342420101166,
0.10023067891597748,
-0.13455212116241455,
-0.35496148467063904,
0.606808066368103,
-0.782143771648407,
-0.4381767511367798,
0.3385729491710663,
0.5942410230636597,
0.37164735794067383,
-0.17357933521270752,
-0.7319265604019165,
0.39564815163612366,
-0.21979500353336334,
-0.28339770436286926,
0.1523866355419159,
0.34094491600990295,
0.14869126677513123,
0.6384797692298889,
0.7392804026603699,
0.4176524579524994,
0.10992766171693802,
0.7962981462478638,
1.0003076791763306,
-0.49275144934654236,
-0.06187118962407112,
-0.7515413761138916,
0.4825056791305542,
-0.18435874581336975,
-0.1897750347852707,
0.5392615795135498,
0.8015162348747253,
1.0224696397781372,
0.03744996339082718,
0.7985324859619141,
-0.05056780204176903,
0.7659332752227783,
-0.506029486656189,
0.608120322227478,
-0.4858465790748596,
0.1613117903470993,
0.09787971526384354,
-1.0967806577682495,
-0.3817409574985504,
0.2518296539783478,
-0.09154576808214188,
0.0037683569826185703,
0.7627122402191162,
0.9751012921333313,
-0.08891941606998444,
-0.08065683394670486,
0.5735992193222046,
0.11205162853002548,
0.6030785441398621,
0.53365159034729,
0.7247290015220642,
-0.5534024238586426,
0.4307226240634918,
-0.3729996383190155,
-0.16559037566184998,
-0.047716882079839706,
-0.8837864995002747,
-1.17750084400177,
-0.555423378944397,
-0.33857735991477966,
0.00044401510967873037,
-0.0022487170062959194,
0.7534132599830627,
0.7463767528533936,
-0.9560306668281555,
-0.5432215929031372,
-0.3209409713745117,
-0.04498909413814545,
-0.2436874806880951,
-0.15711109340190887,
0.21241596341133118,
-0.7206535339355469,
-0.871337354183197,
0.5960484743118286,
0.01056343037635088,
-0.0555981881916523,
-0.38150152564048767,
-0.13460248708724976,
-0.3201758861541748,
-0.16277921199798584,
0.48017677664756775,
-0.01611666940152645,
-0.46655693650245667,
-0.25547143816947937,
0.07535543292760849,
-0.35973623394966125,
0.06427309662103653,
0.7725887298583984,
-0.7199569940567017,
0.5385606288909912,
0.4547186493873596,
0.6295372843742371,
0.39065197110176086,
-0.30490168929100037,
0.9180198311805725,
-0.8190121054649353,
0.2978685796260834,
0.05267547443509102,
0.42589545249938965,
0.5395596027374268,
0.06741645187139511,
0.9132383465766907,
0.2001282423734665,
-0.48823773860931396,
-1.048108458518982,
0.1303204596042633,
-0.875552237033844,
-0.08929924666881561,
1.2401375770568848,
-0.010861490853130817,
0.04595809429883957,
-0.18544307351112366,
-0.23796012997627258,
0.4306618869304657,
-0.148267462849617,
0.6017621159553528,
0.905826210975647,
0.2106764316558838,
-0.25776275992393494,
-0.9019538760185242,
0.6900376677513123,
0.08794683963060379,
-1.08750581741333,
0.6545765399932861,
0.4008892774581909,
0.022429032251238823,
-0.3142390549182892,
0.6764839291572571,
-0.17490969598293304,
0.07739689201116562,
0.009115585125982761,
0.09542954713106155,
-0.14527958631515503,
-0.43106183409690857,
-0.375129371881485,
-0.17543356120586395,
0.19242367148399353,
-0.1470717191696167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11785v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11785v1 | CELL your Model: Contrastive Explanation Methods for Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T17:39:10 | 2024-06-17T17:39:10 | Ronny Luss, Erik Miehling, Amit Dhurandhar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The advent of black-box deep neural network classification models has sparked
the need to explain their decisions. However, in the case of generative AI such
as large language models (LLMs), there is no class prediction to explain.
Rather, one can ask why an LLM output a particular response to a given prompt.
In this paper, we answer this question by proposing, to the best of our
knowledge, the first contrastive explanation methods requiring simply
black-box/query access. Our explanations suggest that an LLM outputs a reply to
a given prompt because if the prompt was slightly modified, the LLM would have
given a different response that is either less preferable or contradicts the
original response. The key insight is that contrastive explanations simply
require a distance function that has meaning to the user and not necessarily a
real valued representation of a specific response (viz. class label). We offer
two algorithms for finding contrastive explanations: i) A myopic algorithm,
which although effective in creating contrasts, requires many model calls and
ii) A budgeted algorithm, our main algorithmic contribution, which
intelligently creates contrasts adhering to a query budget, necessary for
longer contexts. We show the efficacy of these methods on diverse natural
language tasks such as open-text generation, automated red teaming, and
explaining conversational degradation. | [
-0.5120931267738342,
-0.7962340116500854,
0.6318551301956177,
0.16364863514900208,
-0.23098362982273102,
-0.006100925151258707,
-0.30010753870010376,
-0.4507494568824768,
0.09587954729795456,
0.31234899163246155,
-0.7391906380653381,
-0.4369622766971588,
-0.23398952186107635,
0.09379440546035767,
-0.5065305233001709,
0.8967176079750061,
0.15758854150772095,
0.07435967773199081,
-0.49532338976860046,
-0.03181177377700806,
-0.4056427776813507,
-0.4109119772911072,
-0.8535634875297546,
-0.7748333811759949,
0.8760359287261963,
0.5311848521232605,
0.6323055624961853,
0.72530198097229,
0.23828981816768646,
0.41013607382774353,
-0.3739486634731293,
-0.027934735640883446,
-0.26641637086868286,
-0.0012407135218381882,
-0.16843676567077637,
-0.6800634264945984,
-0.02207166701555252,
-0.26486146450042725,
0.344441682100296,
0.923598051071167,
0.13379421830177307,
-0.036924779415130615,
0.07198043912649155,
0.9049073457717896,
-0.5794451832771301,
-0.002884980756789446,
-0.6911178827285767,
0.320587158203125,
-0.010805965401232243,
-0.2166748195886612,
-0.44463279843330383,
-0.12624946236610413,
0.16242054104804993,
-0.34450653195381165,
0.4539050757884979,
-0.11934248358011246,
0.7728921175003052,
0.12833283841609955,
-0.30528005957603455,
-0.3549351990222931,
-0.8434612154960632,
0.7456302046775818,
-0.648332417011261,
-0.01754973828792572,
0.15599453449249268,
0.5724007487297058,
0.015502729453146458,
-0.7488569617271423,
-0.7303952574729919,
-0.3838280737400055,
-0.29743409156799316,
0.4265919327735901,
-0.2459784746170044,
0.160526305437088,
0.15507210791110992,
0.4886954426765442,
-0.5061973929405212,
0.42750290036201477,
-0.39145734906196594,
-0.3054085969924927,
0.5558285117149353,
0.31134775280952454,
0.03626994043588638,
-0.019779330119490623,
-0.3771723210811615,
0.11541758477687836,
-0.6809921264648438,
-0.0790090337395668,
0.36132100224494934,
0.08625207096338272,
-0.3789481520652771,
0.5626002550125122,
-0.1924487054347992,
0.6668864488601685,
-0.03811332955956459,
0.3370814025402069,
-0.1405237913131714,
-0.2573712170124054,
-0.3108547031879425,
0.20083801448345184,
0.7192399501800537,
0.35271555185317993,
0.1858997344970703,
-0.2538432478904724,
-0.0720992460846901,
0.15200990438461304,
0.2064512073993683,
-1.0450994968414307,
-0.17786993086338043,
0.39691174030303955,
-0.5865502953529358,
-0.39281508326530457,
-0.40826931595802307,
-1.157820224761963,
-0.564782977104187,
-0.38843604922294617,
0.1783931851387024,
-0.06490053236484528,
-0.05239829421043396,
-0.16154970228672028,
0.07887060195207596,
0.1379241794347763,
0.3825993835926056,
-0.9904391765594482,
0.38179609179496765,
0.3949083089828491,
0.8615207076072693,
-0.06983127444982529,
-0.027267439290881157,
-0.4613931179046631,
-0.11375082284212112,
-0.5058802962303162,
0.8081973791122437,
-0.57829350233078,
-0.37611013650894165,
0.1845596432685852,
-0.23876060545444489,
0.1413242071866989,
-0.6577317118644714,
0.4339945912361145,
-0.5088874101638794,
0.38279008865356445,
-0.28065502643585205,
-0.4540950059890747,
-0.22041092813014984,
-0.043502047657966614,
-0.4504513740539551,
0.5546841025352478,
-0.21609491109848022,
-0.8504400253295898,
0.023804817348718643,
-0.9400991797447205,
-0.28856492042541504,
0.27137312293052673,
-0.20751610398292542,
-0.4086790084838867,
0.21988143026828766,
0.2318863868713379,
0.4189966917037964,
-0.29271724820137024,
0.14310584962368011,
-0.347099244594574,
-0.3119708001613617,
0.5780653953552246,
-0.46841204166412354,
0.7073239088058472,
0.4611378610134125,
-0.38123443722724915,
0.37530606985092163,
-0.6039180755615234,
-0.07518467307090759,
0.31853947043418884,
-0.1509726196527481,
-0.13020096719264984,
0.3168172836303711,
-0.06564084440469742,
0.009728112258017063,
0.11368244141340256,
-0.33651983737945557,
-0.18593819439411163,
-0.47520381212234497,
0.6001701951026917,
0.7599847316741943,
-0.33112359046936035,
0.4335958957672119,
-0.22240959107875824,
0.5149918794631958,
0.16592849791049957,
-0.27841508388519287,
-0.47260499000549316,
-0.26964226365089417,
-0.6443058252334595,
0.02903754636645317,
0.2008657455444336,
0.2846955955028534,
-0.5575956702232361,
0.056109555065631866,
0.009746507741510868,
-0.1568128764629364,
-0.5271728038787842,
0.046451203525066376,
0.4945124089717865,
0.8399382829666138,
0.3894314169883728,
0.149942085146904,
-0.5261088013648987,
-1.3897250890731812,
-0.1434936225414276,
-0.16617359220981598,
-0.09927434474229813,
0.6026374697685242,
0.5024200677871704,
-0.18039505183696747,
0.7807453274726868,
-0.6373162269592285,
0.19884859025478363,
-0.370292603969574,
0.15233902633190155,
0.09909089654684067,
0.1693149358034134,
0.43942031264305115,
-1.0599944591522217,
-0.10950835049152374,
0.063924141228199,
-0.54756098985672,
-0.3189605474472046,
-0.1531299501657486,
0.050630804151296616,
0.07742802053689957,
0.760077953338623,
-0.4203728437423706,
0.1738189309835434,
0.5101895928382874,
-0.12357039004564285,
0.7581823468208313,
-0.23268769681453705,
-0.18813221156597137,
-1.135966181755066,
-0.015872828662395477,
0.2127872258424759,
-0.2180180698633194,
-0.7119160294532776,
0.18141096830368042,
-0.19245558977127075,
-0.23708517849445343,
-0.21323023736476898,
0.7284837365150452,
-0.312202513217926,
-0.1303238868713379,
-0.38970524072647095,
0.5010371208190918,
-0.05969502776861191,
0.34605321288108826,
-0.04986046627163887,
0.785271942615509,
0.4736391603946686,
-0.8326123356819153,
0.37363365292549133,
0.24651280045509338,
-0.17941497266292572,
0.2350979447364807,
-0.7941741943359375,
0.14694535732269287,
-0.45957252383232117,
0.23316945135593414,
-1.3693703413009644,
-0.32903945446014404,
0.3639065623283386,
-0.3960622251033783,
0.07988693565130234,
-0.27144429087638855,
-0.12199529260396957,
-0.5321947336196899,
-0.05691313371062279,
0.3769957423210144,
0.4242444932460785,
-1.0413371324539185,
0.348772257566452,
-0.10149037092924118,
-0.2498290091753006,
-0.5016133189201355,
-0.7780590057373047,
0.0681990385055542,
-0.4149187207221985,
-0.4678163528442383,
0.6720714569091797,
-0.5231794714927673,
-0.6379052400588989,
-0.07302907854318619,
-0.28283998370170593,
-0.28483033180236816,
0.4374653697013855,
0.26460230350494385,
0.24006609618663788,
-0.5872820019721985,
0.4981956481933594,
0.01273992657661438,
-0.04978879168629646,
0.37562260031700134,
-0.04607582464814186,
0.5386649370193481,
-0.0922522246837616,
-0.009761783294379711,
-0.24979978799819946,
0.3431195616722107,
0.3891020119190216,
-0.24409274756908417,
0.672576367855072,
0.509251058101654,
-0.24262143671512604,
-0.36085060238838196,
-0.46037593483924866,
-0.19713592529296875,
-0.4876309335231781,
0.39393919706344604,
-0.35263732075691223,
-0.7905946373939514,
0.588310182094574,
-0.03762497007846832,
-0.08294367045164108,
0.4194239377975464,
0.8071076273918152,
0.03987663611769676,
1.0549477338790894,
0.4495593011379242,
0.09162025153636932,
0.580308735370636,
0.06737027317285538,
0.1946125328540802,
-0.5647385716438293,
-0.418171226978302,
-0.9113343954086304,
-0.3414658010005951,
-0.6073241829872131,
-0.12234558910131454,
0.025671029463410378,
0.1929621696472168,
-0.027560479938983917,
-0.1647755652666092,
-0.5436719059944153,
0.719184398651123,
0.34318065643310547,
0.08231956511735916,
0.047825559973716736,
0.13459350168704987,
-0.009860703721642494,
0.12641273438930511,
-0.6466978788375854,
-0.5836969017982483,
0.60899817943573,
0.32849299907684326,
0.6298782229423523,
-0.037975847721099854,
0.8196958303451538,
0.0038820907939225435,
0.48961859941482544,
-0.9021015167236328,
0.6085257530212402,
-0.1388445794582367,
-0.4583381414413452,
-0.23114605247974396,
-0.6552120447158813,
-1.1330732107162476,
0.6224649548530579,
-0.27993690967559814,
-0.8189770579338074,
-0.1057291030883789,
0.36626696586608887,
-0.2604186534881592,
0.12560968101024628,
-0.8920866250991821,
0.8268144130706787,
-0.1817149519920349,
-0.5801069140434265,
-0.31144046783447266,
-0.5215600728988647,
0.5806485414505005,
0.04797445237636566,
0.16366463899612427,
0.030394546687602997,
0.0028896911535412073,
0.7334623336791992,
-0.4364680349826813,
0.9017788767814636,
-0.10245973616838455,
0.03695208206772804,
0.13103677332401276,
0.04228643700480461,
0.24023360013961792,
0.08397701382637024,
-0.22066186368465424,
-0.25509965419769287,
-0.3331415057182312,
-0.5388994812965393,
-0.6875252723693848,
0.8456036448478699,
-0.43108534812927246,
-0.7834525108337402,
0.12187246233224869,
-0.6385690569877625,
-0.011106215417385101,
-0.009436662308871746,
0.3649540841579437,
0.6450783014297485,
-0.0932932198047638,
0.12921646237373352,
0.6186966300010681,
-0.5796970129013062,
0.7874587178230286,
0.38018980622291565,
-0.13098634779453278,
-0.011960583738982677,
0.7788488864898682,
-0.20780491828918457,
0.05220754072070122,
0.4994814693927765,
0.802057147026062,
-0.498512864112854,
-0.9453439712524414,
-0.5028244853019714,
0.0634227842092514,
-0.7054380774497986,
-0.041993483901023865,
-0.44144636392593384,
-0.04923958331346512,
-0.03772370144724846,
-0.32695379853248596,
0.09137218445539474,
-0.26088204979896545,
-0.3374728262424469,
-0.17607975006103516,
0.18015047907829285,
0.789185106754303,
0.14192655682563782,
0.3805255591869354,
-0.5212815403938293,
0.4812656044960022,
0.4252029061317444,
0.2619413733482361,
0.19714954495429993,
-0.32939812541007996,
-0.24729052186012268,
0.20335225760936737,
-0.37897586822509766,
-1.0374016761779785,
0.3513171672821045,
0.028924401849508286,
0.5021397471427917,
0.41222259402275085,
-0.06606336683034897,
0.7318071126937866,
-0.40862545371055603,
0.7966936826705933,
0.3141103684902191,
-0.9611383080482483,
0.49763917922973633,
-0.049388401210308075,
0.29364314675331116,
0.12530410289764404,
0.3252638280391693,
-0.34986570477485657,
-0.30669406056404114,
-0.490081787109375,
-0.8658127188682556,
0.4907720386981964,
0.2797401547431946,
0.2710144817829132,
-0.06144903600215912,
0.6378423571586609,
0.12298651039600372,
0.141508549451828,
-0.9830710291862488,
-0.47709232568740845,
-0.27864211797714233,
-0.22992700338363647,
-0.35256636142730713,
-0.255365788936615,
-0.20178617537021637,
0.22883884608745575,
0.3703135848045349,
-0.29607048630714417,
0.30561551451683044,
0.39157336950302124,
-0.114392951130867,
-0.14124920964241028,
0.6456394791603088,
0.8702158331871033,
0.8958612084388733,
0.08082066476345062,
0.309003621339798,
0.2046673744916916,
0.08684014528989792,
-0.13576655089855194,
0.26985251903533936,
-0.02940593659877777,
0.18333347141742706,
0.6126422882080078,
0.6984899044036865,
-0.036682456731796265,
-0.5543081760406494,
0.37056151032447815,
0.06197874993085861,
-0.3533244729042053,
-0.05200660228729248,
-0.01967303641140461,
0.2854757606983185,
0.30137714743614197,
0.17751933634281158,
-0.3424895703792572,
0.2632213830947876,
-0.6362290382385254,
-0.0603259913623333,
0.6366503834724426,
-0.46814969182014465,
-0.19511811435222626,
0.7700729370117188,
0.12931770086288452,
-0.5598673224449158,
0.35872310400009155,
0.0817355066537857,
-0.5547411441802979,
1.0373952388763428,
0.7147752642631531,
0.9689250588417053,
-0.1712406426668167,
0.4904673397541046,
0.18123170733451843,
-0.0874074175953865,
0.2114672213792801,
-0.08199305087327957,
-0.18518449366092682,
-0.6901272535324097,
-0.5472712516784668,
-0.5295790433883667,
-0.5330968499183655,
0.4640772044658661,
-0.6553055644035339,
-0.25085607171058655,
-0.3808177709579468,
0.3923620581626892,
0.7614176273345947,
-0.020324477925896645,
-0.4663197696208954,
0.5119199752807617,
0.235515758395195,
0.8949722051620483,
-0.6703348755836487,
0.49354639649391174,
0.5671725869178772,
-0.42585742473602295,
-0.6006795167922974,
0.16369058191776276,
-0.05593119561672211,
-0.876474142074585,
0.8835641741752625,
0.22723764181137085,
-0.2426455318927765,
-0.2884080111980438,
-0.9430152773857117,
-0.12359890341758728,
0.7307416796684265,
0.3440665602684021,
-0.8074464797973633,
0.11989712715148926,
-0.09665418416261673,
0.7573574185371399,
-0.6147599816322327,
0.3434482514858246,
0.3578011393547058,
0.3785916864871979,
0.17912761867046356,
-0.26712068915367126,
0.19417442381381989,
-0.0911930501461029,
0.02881534956395626,
0.3025784194469452,
-0.3966159522533417,
0.6237447261810303,
-0.6170082092285156,
-0.12563714385032654,
0.35967886447906494,
0.5870293378829956,
-0.11803317815065384,
0.7026655077934265,
0.42236101627349854,
0.2116146683692932,
0.7854220867156982,
-0.1131388321518898,
1.4236689805984497,
0.0260359775274992,
0.06247538700699806,
1.0447778701782227,
-0.1101471409201622,
0.5696201324462891,
0.4639083445072174,
0.012890108861029148,
0.5383328199386597,
0.7770612835884094,
-0.1102181002497673,
0.36145293712615967,
0.8060287237167358,
-0.39292410016059875,
-0.2211759388446808,
-0.10183116793632507,
-0.27220618724823,
0.09682459384202957,
0.22608810663223267,
-0.4808324873447418,
-0.2904880940914154,
-0.11536677181720734,
-0.2829253375530243,
0.31465020775794983,
-0.5893573760986328,
0.960422158241272,
0.13117729127407074,
-0.7091781497001648,
0.6567813754081726,
-0.0026161049026995897,
0.21648547053337097,
-0.38380515575408936,
-0.07060340791940689,
-0.5181610584259033,
0.1623174399137497,
-0.42464354634284973,
-0.6376124620437622,
0.270132839679718,
-0.09378494322299957,
-0.41044849157333374,
-0.07313580811023712,
0.5280551910400391,
-0.5716793537139893,
-0.2626335918903351,
0.3772423565387726,
0.3633153736591339,
0.2173125147819519,
0.07548784464597702,
-0.7790966033935547,
-0.13963904976844788,
-0.019384663552045822,
-0.001500598737038672,
0.29945796728134155,
0.37828344106674194,
0.003878314746543765,
0.9082672595977783,
0.5343133807182312,
-0.03831276670098305,
-0.09785901010036469,
0.22899280488491058,
0.8264119029045105,
-0.729091227054596,
-0.38690444827079773,
-1.1308687925338745,
0.414122611284256,
-0.028169836848974228,
-0.15684834122657776,
0.3426627516746521,
0.5578610897064209,
0.5479610562324524,
-0.03516320884227753,
0.7738275527954102,
0.3912719190120697,
0.3191521167755127,
-0.897567629814148,
0.3156481385231018,
-0.741671085357666,
0.5130629539489746,
-0.09189999103546143,
-0.9010571241378784,
-0.22606554627418518,
0.4973125159740448,
-0.3601676821708679,
0.01665523648262024,
0.9077062606811523,
0.897260844707489,
-0.043158769607543945,
0.09538969397544861,
0.42279449105262756,
0.5770745873451233,
0.2240987867116928,
0.39878642559051514,
1.0401716232299805,
0.05735065042972565,
1.060520052909851,
-0.2203664481639862,
-0.047585975378751755,
-0.30491751432418823,
-0.8894199132919312,
-1.1306869983673096,
-0.3957221806049347,
-0.5444177985191345,
-0.5267354249954224,
0.3141216039657593,
0.7211787700653076,
0.730875551700592,
-0.7557241916656494,
-0.3015875220298767,
-0.4413434863090515,
0.5798488855361938,
-0.1474868208169937,
-0.2169472724199295,
0.3033749461174011,
-0.5525475144386292,
-0.7095380425453186,
0.4784707725048065,
0.16095709800720215,
0.2676104009151459,
-0.06075821444392204,
-0.07392723113298416,
0.32012927532196045,
0.2067345231771469,
0.5564385056495667,
0.29791831970214844,
-0.9283737540245056,
-0.1070624440908432,
-0.38885557651519775,
0.05451149493455887,
0.3286859095096588,
0.9552894830703735,
-0.6493282318115234,
0.4194902181625366,
0.27803581953048706,
0.736153781414032,
0.695674479007721,
-0.008189098909497261,
0.7217928171157837,
-0.5183457732200623,
-0.031617358326911926,
0.22480975091457367,
0.3367071747779846,
0.38562172651290894,
-0.3115783929824829,
0.32777097821235657,
-0.09546524286270142,
-0.35846492648124695,
-0.7314156293869019,
0.6853364109992981,
-1.0279752016067505,
-0.6526311039924622,
1.0189741849899292,
-0.07509823143482208,
-0.21974390745162964,
-0.09523607790470123,
-0.4297676086425781,
0.051868923008441925,
-0.2915005087852478,
0.9072005748748779,
0.5999084711074829,
0.009596134535968304,
-0.38966235518455505,
-0.36801663041114807,
0.49220865964889526,
0.5984146595001221,
-1.1346163749694824,
0.33865970373153687,
0.5195525288581848,
0.09557266533374786,
0.19090251624584198,
0.169138565659523,
-0.0011973095824941993,
0.22696653008460999,
-0.016941120848059654,
-0.21491260826587677,
-0.08442900329828262,
-0.2011806219816208,
-0.7879459857940674,
0.3352213203907013,
0.011676589958369732,
-0.30224424600601196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11784v1 | MDCR: A Dataset for Multi-Document Conditional Reasoning | 2024-06-17T17:38:43 | 2024-06-17T17:38:43 | Peter Baile Chen, Yi Zhang, Chunwei Liu, Sejal Gupta, Yoon Kim, Michael Cafarella | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The same real-life questions posed to different individuals may lead to
different answers based on their unique situations. For instance, whether a
student is eligible for a scholarship depends on eligibility conditions, such
as major or degree required. ConditionalQA was proposed to evaluate models'
capability of reading a document and answering eligibility questions,
considering unmentioned conditions. However, it is limited to questions on
single documents, neglecting harder cases that may require cross-document
reasoning and optimization, for example, "What is the maximum number of
scholarships attainable?" Such questions over multiple documents are not only
more challenging due to more context having to understand, but also because the
model has to (1) explore all possible combinations of unmentioned conditions
and (2) understand the relationship between conditions across documents, to
reason about the optimal outcome. To evaluate models' capability of answering
such questions, we propose a new dataset MDCR, which can reflect real-world
challenges and serve as a new test bed for complex conditional reasoning that
requires optimization. We evaluate this dataset using the most recent LLMs and
demonstrate their limitations in solving this task. We believe this dataset
will facilitate future research in answering optimization questions with
unknown conditions. | [
-0.46321138739585876,
-0.6092411279678345,
0.9120680093765259,
-0.17561110854148865,
-0.010452932678163052,
0.20003968477249146,
-0.21710504591464996,
-0.03308616578578949,
-0.1800634115934372,
0.5292784571647644,
-1.0661710500717163,
-0.26428207755088806,
-0.6493320465087891,
0.4253852665424347,
-0.37664562463760376,
0.8043871521949768,
-0.4417661130428314,
0.3941150903701782,
-0.7294343709945679,
-0.2709273397922516,
-0.612982451915741,
-0.5223255753517151,
-0.40526214241981506,
0.017014188691973686,
0.4997427463531494,
0.6592034101486206,
0.07942816615104675,
0.15715943276882172,
0.967888355255127,
0.29408004879951477,
0.35440516471862793,
0.3824186325073242,
-0.3168729245662689,
0.33878093957901,
-0.06826619058847427,
-0.5431601405143738,
-0.174915611743927,
0.30982133746147156,
0.5094170570373535,
0.6596201658248901,
-0.1889953464269638,
0.286563515663147,
0.07219085842370987,
0.6713084578514099,
-0.6985220313072205,
0.0018845403101295233,
-0.6463812589645386,
0.12873081862926483,
0.021685177460312843,
-0.3042767345905304,
-0.37795910239219666,
-0.31606775522232056,
0.13859927654266357,
-0.7678647041320801,
0.3779655396938324,
-0.08990165591239929,
0.648457407951355,
0.42765024304389954,
-0.8042917847633362,
-0.4851296842098236,
-0.4859095513820648,
0.6403545141220093,
-0.28142449259757996,
0.3822118937969208,
0.3880294859409332,
0.725346565246582,
-0.08861058950424194,
-0.9288854002952576,
-0.7704912424087524,
-0.1789911687374115,
-0.10524896532297134,
0.29195478558540344,
0.2403421401977539,
0.2580498158931732,
0.37748777866363525,
0.3299800455570221,
-0.5521417260169983,
-0.34206900000572205,
-0.6167315244674683,
-0.4108973741531372,
0.22741654515266418,
0.5156920552253723,
0.15315328538417816,
-0.2602181136608124,
-0.3335316479206085,
-0.06281426548957825,
-0.19306766986846924,
0.3295224905014038,
0.3809050917625427,
0.31810134649276733,
-0.15859369933605194,
1.0316429138183594,
-0.27144429087638855,
0.9052644968032837,
-0.1055249348282814,
-0.1632586568593979,
-0.019548531621694565,
-0.6100537180900574,
-0.13281120359897614,
-0.11885233968496323,
0.08098170906305313,
0.2949829697608948,
0.1247258335351944,
0.18862459063529968,
-0.25377875566482544,
0.23503994941711426,
0.2283470332622528,
-0.7126414775848389,
0.06654267013072968,
0.4587334990501404,
-0.5986709594726562,
-0.1476227194070816,
0.15080837905406952,
-0.7772923707962036,
-0.4280596971511841,
-0.6404419541358948,
0.43074822425842285,
-0.14957481622695923,
0.20105889439582825,
0.3665590286254883,
-0.39769893884658813,
0.2440558522939682,
0.32039675116539,
-0.42587554454803467,
0.3309895098209381,
0.4652593731880188,
0.627609372138977,
-0.21181531250476837,
-0.3288883566856384,
-0.5553036332130432,
-0.053285036236047745,
0.007445718627423048,
0.8383386731147766,
-0.8379986882209778,
-0.2776761054992676,
-0.1079307273030281,
-0.03885236382484436,
-0.44851046800613403,
-0.06348823010921478,
1.07706618309021,
-0.4779300093650818,
0.4453238546848297,
-0.49070948362350464,
-0.5311315655708313,
-0.07972856611013412,
0.5426037311553955,
-0.668322741985321,
0.5181187391281128,
0.4269352853298187,
-0.960516631603241,
0.5010843873023987,
-0.5618121027946472,
-0.33923205733299255,
-0.10771217942237854,
-0.44119277596473694,
-0.2033345252275467,
-0.15988796949386597,
0.11692437529563904,
0.19696150720119476,
-0.8582727313041687,
0.40543559193611145,
-0.30728694796562195,
-0.290041446685791,
0.32306480407714844,
-0.5112164616584778,
0.5011389255523682,
0.3773050010204315,
-0.1344548612833023,
-0.1759335696697235,
-0.842454731464386,
0.3701319992542267,
-0.04828257858753204,
-0.8271146416664124,
-0.08235242962837219,
-0.041003067046403885,
-0.36376503109931946,
0.29942163825035095,
0.37092748284339905,
-0.6181969046592712,
0.3217506408691406,
0.15105119347572327,
0.3694242537021637,
0.7247058749198914,
0.19569967687129974,
0.3060126006603241,
-0.6763362288475037,
0.8664271235466003,
-0.03923272714018822,
0.38845041394233704,
0.04698362946510315,
-0.3087775409221649,
-0.9318660497665405,
-0.3965740501880646,
0.5096086859703064,
0.6251569390296936,
-0.8223472237586975,
-0.0651051476597786,
0.06340838223695755,
-0.01864267885684967,
-0.6664180755615234,
-0.1473015546798706,
0.4863763451576233,
0.820803701877594,
0.422494113445282,
0.02154943160712719,
-1.0463495254516602,
-1.1170072555541992,
-0.2199420928955078,
0.2993641197681427,
0.2955510914325714,
0.5121584534645081,
0.6374129056930542,
-0.13856029510498047,
0.7328681349754333,
-0.6546777486801147,
-0.43574726581573486,
-0.45896151661872864,
-0.13700227439403534,
0.4029424786567688,
0.324237585067749,
0.29610249400138855,
-1.0443886518478394,
-0.29501330852508545,
-0.39332032203674316,
-0.6879071593284607,
-0.049086328595876694,
-0.44045937061309814,
-0.15256613492965698,
0.11115670949220657,
0.33640778064727783,
-0.7549794912338257,
0.5740625262260437,
0.6183487772941589,
-0.3081880807876587,
0.5714196562767029,
-0.41435229778289795,
0.6654362082481384,
-0.7242352366447449,
0.054297007620334625,
0.0442502424120903,
0.19723376631736755,
-0.3536398410797119,
0.13428425788879395,
0.0679648146033287,
-0.36674878001213074,
-0.08063732832670212,
0.6536824107170105,
-0.6446589827537537,
0.06693911552429199,
0.0023051465395838022,
0.05578632652759552,
0.25856658816337585,
0.45717328786849976,
-0.10171326249837875,
0.7646970152854919,
0.5242956280708313,
-0.5306258201599121,
0.11861114948987961,
0.4317377805709839,
-0.5887594819068909,
0.7356181740760803,
-0.4972209930419922,
0.015522203408181667,
-0.17783579230308533,
0.4717005491256714,
-0.9062886834144592,
-0.3431169390678406,
0.0908355787396431,
-0.5150152444839478,
0.07564204186201096,
-0.2293369621038437,
-0.42088958621025085,
-0.5287647843360901,
-0.16473288834095,
0.4129925072193146,
0.00808633491396904,
-0.3836546540260315,
0.9334858655929565,
0.28985339403152466,
0.01215702947229147,
-0.6373217105865479,
-0.568113386631012,
-0.07731825113296509,
0.009309536777436733,
-0.6120973825454712,
0.07584267109632492,
-0.4538175165653229,
-0.19620239734649658,
-0.07344256341457367,
-0.2791345715522766,
-0.2886882722377777,
-0.1329871118068695,
0.32089370489120483,
0.4590020179748535,
-0.019588299095630646,
-0.15582236647605896,
0.34328266978263855,
-0.040558766573667526,
0.025218771770596504,
-0.2554541826248169,
0.4584743082523346,
0.21393640339374542,
-0.4100281894207001,
-0.17703819274902344,
0.7367671728134155,
0.5582839846611023,
-0.4501633644104004,
0.6127919554710388,
0.03435344994068146,
-0.42026233673095703,
-0.2869853079319,
-0.5894332528114319,
0.021521208807826042,
-0.48712021112442017,
0.09837666898965836,
-1.0456409454345703,
-0.797044575214386,
0.4454798400402069,
0.2698924243450165,
-0.02416144125163555,
0.39438652992248535,
0.6694301962852478,
-0.05879488214850426,
1.076406478881836,
0.4187941253185272,
0.39880862832069397,
-0.07691385596990585,
-0.39116594195365906,
0.14749924838542938,
-0.9087167978286743,
-0.6923022866249084,
-0.712310791015625,
-0.28818294405937195,
-0.31914210319519043,
-0.5472343564033508,
0.3524042069911957,
-0.21703268587589264,
-0.19474974274635315,
0.14829018712043762,
-0.6378045082092285,
0.451016366481781,
0.5901533961296082,
0.3589807450771332,
0.2449290007352829,
-0.2970629632472992,
-0.7718417644500732,
0.026193488389253616,
-0.6024843454360962,
-0.354793906211853,
1.2994517087936401,
-0.14464598894119263,
0.45159396529197693,
0.11296851933002472,
0.38926857709884644,
0.5503395199775696,
0.18889468908309937,
-0.6799641251564026,
0.5185966491699219,
-0.08981826156377792,
-1.0089280605316162,
-0.06225443631410599,
-0.6511446833610535,
-0.8270572423934937,
0.22727178037166595,
-0.39348745346069336,
-0.3857874274253845,
0.43214336037635803,
-0.11502602696418762,
-0.1400768905878067,
0.18480706214904785,
-0.5163308382034302,
0.6563186645507812,
-0.3666785955429077,
-0.07449891418218613,
-0.06907512992620468,
-0.8478959798812866,
0.4641638994216919,
-0.47459739446640015,
0.3101494312286377,
-0.04651698097586632,
0.04231864959001541,
0.6995548605918884,
-0.33713629841804504,
0.49082592129707336,
-0.25215205550193787,
0.38878321647644043,
0.3828043043613434,
0.11711011826992035,
0.34944966435432434,
0.042221926152706146,
-0.5559844374656677,
-0.3398659825325012,
0.4650523066520691,
-0.40988457202911377,
-0.5420834422111511,
0.6794558763504028,
-0.5937840938568115,
-0.6873238682746887,
-0.6782235503196716,
-0.7088200449943542,
-0.48858004808425903,
0.4138099253177643,
0.17012852430343628,
0.5623559951782227,
-0.03731849044561386,
0.12862488627433777,
0.3863440155982971,
0.003571045119315386,
-0.07346557825803757,
0.6945375800132751,
0.2155066430568695,
-0.3468570411205292,
0.6006622910499573,
0.047991275787353516,
0.06471730768680573,
0.4723651707172394,
0.1494823694229126,
-0.42443835735321045,
-0.7403365969657898,
-0.2724667191505432,
0.09583709388971329,
-1.139955759048462,
-0.3248252868652344,
-0.690573513507843,
-0.13939008116722107,
-0.3156546950340271,
-0.15342846512794495,
0.20398399233818054,
-0.6420155167579651,
-0.22094003856182098,
-0.21868887543678284,
-0.13187789916992188,
0.4208352863788605,
-0.11053436994552612,
-0.24182505905628204,
-0.5984572768211365,
0.6849091053009033,
0.3378539979457855,
0.2172616869211197,
-0.1547633409500122,
-0.797153115272522,
-0.006715747062116861,
0.1165459081530571,
-0.17448385059833527,
-0.7033279538154602,
-0.12050651758909225,
0.29587414860725403,
1.0749744176864624,
0.03410352021455765,
0.40570470690727234,
0.4268786907196045,
-0.41514852643013,
0.23186206817626953,
0.11809233576059341,
-0.7166618704795837,
0.44615495204925537,
-0.2618919014930725,
-0.05253713205456734,
1.2018109560012817,
0.6069397926330566,
-0.27554944157600403,
-0.11657856404781342,
-0.44028231501579285,
-0.47638842463493347,
0.49002599716186523,
0.22786499559879303,
-0.04932882636785507,
0.14438605308532715,
0.6054864525794983,
0.16170555353164673,
0.20427022874355316,
-0.49665820598602295,
-0.19406789541244507,
-0.06452413648366928,
-0.29825425148010254,
0.0587630458176136,
-0.21733061969280243,
-0.449983686208725,
-0.49173057079315186,
0.3886013329029083,
-0.10995650291442871,
0.1683192253112793,
0.3668539226055145,
-0.11979732662439346,
0.018916387110948563,
0.1934274584054947,
0.6856151223182678,
0.8055667877197266,
-0.4812314510345459,
-0.02674269676208496,
0.10856588929891586,
-0.3334920406341553,
0.36941173672676086,
0.28658804297447205,
0.008020284585654736,
-0.40846917033195496,
0.30470725893974304,
0.4026902914047241,
-0.20707079768180847,
-0.8674347400665283,
0.650985598564148,
-0.5343728065490723,
-0.6727684736251831,
-0.32211390137672424,
0.1281842589378357,
-0.13789460062980652,
0.2054000049829483,
0.44255295395851135,
0.31158968806266785,
0.33147504925727844,
-0.7203691601753235,
0.44607147574424744,
0.28717464208602905,
-0.4614688456058502,
0.2789502441883087,
0.6620977520942688,
0.2223532795906067,
-0.13807129859924316,
0.8177400231361389,
-0.007133353501558304,
-0.642963171005249,
0.932483434677124,
0.3781338036060333,
0.31333762407302856,
0.2474963665008545,
0.293864905834198,
0.4407111704349518,
0.3174246847629547,
0.058758027851581573,
0.6085770726203918,
-0.078635573387146,
-0.7600334286689758,
-0.16602708399295807,
-0.6881721019744873,
-0.6251904964447021,
-0.2439039796590805,
-0.8383638262748718,
0.4108501672744751,
-0.5222821831703186,
-0.10595802962779999,
0.062128935009241104,
0.21137884259223938,
-0.883627712726593,
0.7666673064231873,
-0.18618780374526978,
1.1770167350769043,
-0.5727859735488892,
0.892440676689148,
0.3937069773674011,
-0.5094201564788818,
-0.8156503438949585,
-0.24162618815898895,
0.10230250656604767,
-0.8524393439292908,
0.5930066704750061,
0.23551276326179504,
-0.22571055591106415,
-0.1153435930609703,
-0.3142414391040802,
-0.5370599627494812,
1.0808333158493042,
0.29612720012664795,
-0.6737367510795593,
-0.06846459209918976,
0.12898585200309753,
0.2542901039123535,
-0.6085030436515808,
0.04805349186062813,
0.7129429578781128,
0.8144351243972778,
0.19074824452400208,
-0.5248677730560303,
0.22050204873085022,
-0.3479633629322052,
-0.4956611692905426,
0.1714858114719391,
-0.5178483724594116,
0.9187479019165039,
-0.674634575843811,
-0.10204281657934189,
0.2792242467403412,
0.23716028034687042,
0.5363641977310181,
0.5610266923904419,
0.6180844306945801,
0.6113799810409546,
0.9586226940155029,
-0.18482156097888947,
1.4336013793945312,
-0.23048949241638184,
0.31786099076271057,
1.131630778312683,
-0.4752276539802551,
0.4971923828125,
0.41154998540878296,
-0.11694089323282242,
0.29975101351737976,
0.8574456572532654,
-0.1726740002632141,
0.8588927984237671,
0.6000950336456299,
-0.4033307135105133,
-0.6450310349464417,
0.012860056012868881,
-0.39148107171058655,
0.587438702583313,
0.24469684064388275,
-0.15638916194438934,
-0.004593531601130962,
0.16619426012039185,
-0.31070706248283386,
0.10857366025447845,
-0.07882340252399445,
0.3362998366355896,
0.0927499458193779,
-0.7528553605079651,
0.23191852867603302,
0.23173950612545013,
0.3690851032733917,
-0.6138132810592651,
-0.15632569789886475,
-0.5482451915740967,
0.16932308673858643,
-0.1681378185749054,
-0.7529411315917969,
0.10894119739532471,
0.027419334277510643,
-0.5093173980712891,
0.20166707038879395,
0.6188706755638123,
0.03114822693169117,
-0.8953501582145691,
0.20707964897155762,
0.5020188689231873,
0.009379468858242035,
0.18947790563106537,
-0.9486579895019531,
0.0765509232878685,
0.07352318614721298,
-0.1440400332212448,
0.3385016620159149,
0.494471937417984,
0.2148439586162567,
1.0127100944519043,
0.8183225393295288,
0.18615329265594482,
-0.025904102250933647,
0.14471185207366943,
1.093977689743042,
-0.4605664908885956,
-0.1857708841562271,
-0.3835202753543854,
0.449733167886734,
-0.04817519709467888,
-0.49963051080703735,
0.5435189008712769,
0.83134925365448,
0.5345334410667419,
0.2089391052722931,
1.062873125076294,
-0.20368283987045288,
0.7519875168800354,
-0.8166167736053467,
0.40272122621536255,
-0.8868828415870667,
0.42939743399620056,
0.023406093940138817,
-0.6874712109565735,
-0.1955662965774536,
0.4552405774593353,
-0.17090734839439392,
0.06661203503608704,
1.0443779230117798,
0.6171935796737671,
-0.1860889494419098,
-0.066753089427948,
0.2178546041250229,
-0.1963045746088028,
0.1862422227859497,
0.7417831420898438,
1.0168319940567017,
-0.30433082580566406,
0.9444356560707092,
-0.19572646915912628,
-0.14926868677139282,
0.0798693522810936,
-0.7261333465576172,
-0.9438018798828125,
-0.8475902080535889,
-0.10374400019645691,
-0.5091861486434937,
0.23651430010795593,
0.6510220766067505,
0.5174986124038696,
-0.75080406665802,
-0.035940032452344894,
0.1258709579706192,
0.2133449763059616,
0.1646784245967865,
-0.17952966690063477,
0.34527429938316345,
-0.12475131452083588,
-0.43181008100509644,
0.43388620018959045,
0.006252541206777096,
-0.10221279412508011,
-0.13581976294517517,
-0.1285601407289505,
-0.30293095111846924,
0.5119395852088928,
0.249302938580513,
0.21645522117614746,
-0.28179657459259033,
-0.27993282675743103,
0.049471888691186905,
-0.24595984816551208,
0.15591742098331451,
1.390942096710205,
-0.49725693464279175,
0.39041611552238464,
0.4887847602367401,
0.6948779821395874,
0.6851567625999451,
0.06558050960302353,
0.5675644874572754,
-0.30576092004776,
0.09670533984899521,
0.42135363817214966,
0.6386975049972534,
0.12815475463867188,
-0.35159599781036377,
0.42116641998291016,
0.055905770510435104,
-0.6177196502685547,
-0.8399762511253357,
0.32457292079925537,
-1.2730251550674438,
-0.6386715769767761,
0.7853368520736694,
-0.1526106297969818,
0.19968442618846893,
-0.3647446930408478,
-0.2815479338169098,
0.14562492072582245,
-0.24955351650714874,
0.6946423053741455,
0.7450664043426514,
-0.28210070729255676,
-0.42555907368659973,
-0.8643993139266968,
0.21850232779979706,
0.37353551387786865,
-1.0659794807434082,
-0.2376958280801773,
0.5260204076766968,
0.40664416551589966,
-0.41725555062294006,
0.8273181915283203,
-0.01251187827438116,
0.37088504433631897,
0.045713815838098526,
-0.27334871888160706,
-0.11650130897760391,
-0.6099189519882202,
0.04158331826329231,
0.27745768427848816,
0.009689269587397575,
-0.14974771440029144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11780v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11780v1 | Split, Unlearn, Merge: Leveraging Data Attributes for More Effective Unlearning in LLMs | 2024-06-17T17:35:52 | 2024-06-17T17:35:52 | Swanand Ravindra Kadhe, Farhan Ahmed, Dennis Wei, Nathalie Baracaldo, Inkit Padhi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown to pose social and ethical risks such
as generating toxic language or facilitating malicious use of hazardous
knowledge. Machine unlearning is a promising approach to improve LLM safety by
directly removing harmful behaviors and knowledge. In this paper, we propose
"SPlit, UNlearn, MerGE" (SPUNGE), a framework that can be used with any
unlearning method to amplify its effectiveness. SPUNGE leverages data
attributes during unlearning by splitting unlearning data into subsets based on
specific attribute values, unlearning each subset separately, and merging the
unlearned models. We empirically demonstrate that SPUNGE significantly improves
the performance of two recent unlearning methods on state-of-the-art LLMs while
maintaining their general capabilities on standard academic benchmarks. | [
-0.29194310307502747,
-0.6021079421043396,
0.33883118629455566,
-0.36376190185546875,
-0.2572575509548187,
0.6100685596466064,
-0.4785696566104889,
-0.41924309730529785,
-0.23553040623664856,
0.6797288656234741,
-0.5782229900360107,
-0.4869352877140045,
-0.6244577169418335,
-0.4310819208621979,
-0.7615880370140076,
1.1944383382797241,
0.33707746863365173,
0.21714133024215698,
-0.45303967595100403,
-0.0774548202753067,
-0.15015162527561188,
-0.4111779034137726,
-0.5342123508453369,
-0.7218235731124878,
0.774084746837616,
0.8585349917411804,
0.6893410086631775,
0.5579774379730225,
0.3980361521244049,
0.2833499610424042,
-0.20387986302375793,
0.6552389860153198,
-0.6817130446434021,
0.3591559827327728,
-0.303134024143219,
-0.37491267919540405,
-0.4348675608634949,
0.42249616980552673,
0.4640713036060333,
1.233159065246582,
-0.4246237874031067,
0.19385668635368347,
0.390410840511322,
1.0318711996078491,
-0.6491620540618896,
-0.15811318159103394,
-0.5058448314666748,
-0.005405328702181578,
-0.03862185776233673,
-0.03249254450201988,
-0.4430943429470062,
-0.5695693492889404,
0.08758958429098129,
-0.3797811269760132,
-0.046834588050842285,
0.05740987882018089,
0.40511080622673035,
0.12808144092559814,
-0.3795805275440216,
-0.1136506125330925,
-0.8218913078308105,
1.0142936706542969,
-0.7178131937980652,
0.473165363073349,
0.1613365262746811,
0.036062221974134445,
-0.39546307921409607,
-0.5114935040473938,
-0.5425350666046143,
0.0836617648601532,
0.09852816164493561,
-0.18092654645442963,
-0.1250782310962677,
0.020452994853258133,
0.06671120226383209,
0.4381181001663208,
-0.39837950468063354,
0.8060840368270874,
-0.6836139559745789,
-0.1138877123594284,
0.8723816275596619,
0.00771709531545639,
0.27856719493865967,
0.1943771094083786,
-0.46259140968322754,
-0.3319081664085388,
-0.9827461838722229,
-0.13589610159397125,
0.7403293251991272,
0.4193164110183716,
0.27341321110725403,
0.6175482869148254,
-0.032834406942129135,
0.3052786886692047,
0.06761473417282104,
-0.46802735328674316,
0.5005221962928772,
0.26717472076416016,
-0.16805148124694824,
0.09036396443843842,
0.7059221863746643,
0.4499017298221588,
0.16400611400604248,
-0.5930576324462891,
-0.13172422349452972,
-0.29590919613838196,
0.23529782891273499,
-0.6232030987739563,
-0.10931705683469772,
0.3616643249988556,
-0.5958526730537415,
-0.7174989581108093,
0.04939970001578331,
-0.9862675666809082,
-0.643757164478302,
-0.5336313247680664,
0.2975239157676697,
-0.6391974687576294,
-0.5437654852867126,
0.08545447885990143,
-0.08167778700590134,
0.20151256024837494,
0.22779430449008942,
-0.49002158641815186,
0.19301429390907288,
1.0229262113571167,
0.5429201722145081,
-0.5694313049316406,
-0.3817313611507416,
-0.5089418292045593,
0.0007022679201327264,
-0.22319817543029785,
0.5090454816818237,
-0.38841500878334045,
-0.5204666256904602,
0.13654901087284088,
-0.16289180517196655,
0.19596131145954132,
-0.6791791915893555,
0.34583747386932373,
-0.6017789244651794,
0.6141766905784607,
-0.0010086273541674018,
-0.9250680208206177,
-0.5812481045722961,
-0.02678120695054531,
-0.6476550102233887,
1.2116469144821167,
0.04605911299586296,
-0.6345832347869873,
0.6539532542228699,
-0.6838455200195312,
-0.5792220234870911,
0.01565147191286087,
0.2046840935945511,
-0.6228741407394409,
0.2426767498254776,
-0.04245100915431976,
0.5918710231781006,
-0.3548002541065216,
0.37477123737335205,
-0.6399691104888916,
-0.08571404218673706,
0.29390615224838257,
-0.5170482993125916,
0.8732888102531433,
0.43546783924102783,
0.03478767350316048,
0.15827904641628265,
-0.8075817227363586,
0.32845306396484375,
-0.015454092063009739,
-0.3170911371707916,
-0.3768104910850525,
0.08575873076915741,
0.12167976051568985,
0.0849146619439125,
0.2507404685020447,
-0.5075148344039917,
0.29038727283477783,
-0.1782868355512619,
0.12001771479845047,
0.7709819674491882,
-0.21569442749023438,
0.8613283038139343,
-0.4201924204826355,
0.25031834840774536,
0.18056246638298035,
-0.016920844092965126,
0.20303738117218018,
-0.10192640125751495,
-0.9432573914527893,
-0.503985583782196,
0.2147926241159439,
0.5181974768638611,
-0.7030090689659119,
0.6998586058616638,
0.05758947134017944,
-0.6046202778816223,
-0.7044661641120911,
0.47834551334381104,
0.5277508497238159,
0.44934263825416565,
0.39924803376197815,
-0.026713036000728607,
-0.4618169665336609,
-0.6127279996871948,
-0.3007141649723053,
-0.28086021542549133,
-0.13445958495140076,
-0.10251518338918686,
0.24716132879257202,
-0.3591075539588928,
0.8567871451377869,
-0.5502715706825256,
-0.06969261914491653,
-0.48381757736206055,
0.4863528311252594,
0.021085074171423912,
0.5047040581703186,
-0.030663738027215004,
-0.6259692311286926,
-0.12867778539657593,
0.11682775616645813,
-0.9747866988182068,
0.027528993785381317,
0.20003871619701385,
-0.03802231699228287,
0.41581976413726807,
0.5172292590141296,
-0.32153943181037903,
0.3393968641757965,
0.30659711360931396,
-0.024257514625787735,
0.4407270550727844,
-0.3128506541252136,
0.17876127362251282,
-1.2285963296890259,
-0.14076702296733856,
-0.32923969626426697,
-0.28759142756462097,
-0.8832221031188965,
-0.024310071021318436,
0.02360542304813862,
0.015961945056915283,
-0.6951330900192261,
0.23252810537815094,
-0.6913416981697083,
-0.045325059443712234,
-0.5499200820922852,
-0.08031954616308212,
-0.25396937131881714,
0.21024012565612793,
-0.19819772243499756,
0.6533294916152954,
0.5116443037986755,
-0.6005273461341858,
0.3774966597557068,
0.1238916739821434,
-0.37030625343322754,
0.6325117349624634,
-0.2662925124168396,
0.3569258451461792,
-0.2969902753829956,
-0.16478382050991058,
-0.6095085740089417,
-0.08528611063957214,
-0.35222485661506653,
-0.3532458245754242,
0.5756268501281738,
-0.051069632172584534,
-0.6267865300178528,
-0.09397101402282715,
-0.5117244720458984,
0.39390265941619873,
0.7733039259910583,
-0.8985158205032349,
0.7271614670753479,
0.6319359540939331,
0.1068701297044754,
-0.6510112881660461,
-0.36637404561042786,
0.012673977762460709,
-0.7467441558837891,
-0.6969015598297119,
0.31286078691482544,
0.17493700981140137,
-0.24257908761501312,
0.10818324238061905,
-0.010888375341892242,
-0.03450731188058853,
0.18897706270217896,
0.43230801820755005,
0.47801050543785095,
0.027918057516217232,
0.2800784409046173,
-0.08622035384178162,
-0.2429816722869873,
-0.14318010210990906,
-0.4074505865573883,
0.5599194765090942,
0.06415756046772003,
-0.3755519390106201,
-0.05838280916213989,
0.4225255846977234,
0.7256483435630798,
-0.20784734189510345,
1.070610523223877,
0.557407557964325,
-0.4320220947265625,
-0.5858524441719055,
-0.5898857712745667,
-0.1584625244140625,
-0.5411175489425659,
0.3226567208766937,
0.31852325797080994,
-1.3711811304092407,
0.25459161400794983,
-0.5012920498847961,
0.38295847177505493,
-0.01856902427971363,
0.5170546770095825,
-0.5295693874359131,
0.8516067266464233,
0.9602928757667542,
-0.4165467619895935,
0.305632084608078,
-0.12352526187896729,
0.6241025328636169,
-0.8493437170982361,
-0.6128760576248169,
-0.34775421023368835,
-0.41178515553474426,
-0.724786639213562,
-0.4609324634075165,
0.2850742042064667,
0.32810014486312866,
-0.44710010290145874,
0.1737179458141327,
-0.36623433232307434,
0.5925363302230835,
0.5173393487930298,
0.11100033670663834,
0.5030659437179565,
0.24740512669086456,
-0.07170584052801132,
0.18099002540111542,
-0.47137343883514404,
-0.6439151167869568,
1.2511543035507202,
0.38551974296569824,
1.0975795984268188,
0.12088678032159805,
0.8988906145095825,
0.3289319574832916,
0.26579955220222473,
-0.6750388145446777,
0.6623546481132507,
-0.45055970549583435,
-0.4095809757709503,
-0.3946473002433777,
-0.5236217379570007,
-0.8263736963272095,
0.27493420243263245,
-0.4759043753147125,
-0.9121068120002747,
-0.15090006589889526,
0.0006733073387295008,
0.0373329259455204,
0.7112877368927002,
-0.4914776086807251,
0.21635711193084717,
-0.46883827447891235,
-0.2136761099100113,
-0.3810998797416687,
-0.21100923418998718,
0.6070564389228821,
-0.29344701766967773,
0.32154032588005066,
-0.2691686749458313,
0.1244477778673172,
1.0015708208084106,
-0.4733985662460327,
0.8197313547134399,
0.18633408844470978,
-0.06165365129709244,
0.15328828990459442,
0.13517619669437408,
0.28324979543685913,
-0.3136850893497467,
0.11143036931753159,
0.2535680830478668,
-0.13577689230442047,
-0.08178366720676422,
-0.5880393385887146,
0.6681814193725586,
-0.8267783522605896,
-0.42881718277931213,
-0.3999031186103821,
-0.8044535517692566,
-0.4321559965610504,
0.1661248654127121,
0.17973637580871582,
-0.04944014921784401,
-0.21334002912044525,
0.22378593683242798,
0.9337300658226013,
-0.14513371884822845,
0.4865981936454773,
0.7980554699897766,
-0.42146673798561096,
-0.5532306432723999,
0.9538816213607788,
-0.1119007021188736,
0.2604590952396393,
0.06787950545549393,
0.12733836472034454,
-0.3714978098869324,
-0.4687232971191406,
0.3025953769683838,
0.3287053406238556,
-0.6123698949813843,
-0.43582841753959656,
-0.41464757919311523,
-0.25664088129997253,
-0.2991684377193451,
-0.2637423574924469,
-0.450496107339859,
-0.42330747842788696,
-0.3902071416378021,
-0.41204139590263367,
0.7256780862808228,
0.82159024477005,
-0.37166449427604675,
0.5300891399383545,
-0.8767150044441223,
-0.06943714618682861,
0.07325185090303421,
0.4743058979511261,
0.03397529944777489,
-0.6099840998649597,
-0.12775465846061707,
-0.045784227550029755,
-0.1687181442975998,
-0.6750780940055847,
0.3295278549194336,
0.02436063252389431,
0.6378501057624817,
0.4521412253379822,
0.03937067463994026,
0.5835667848587036,
-0.4055671691894531,
0.37019240856170654,
0.7057521343231201,
-0.7286390066146851,
0.19398562610149384,
-0.18159173429012299,
-0.2578643560409546,
0.70536208152771,
0.39608272910118103,
-0.7642546892166138,
-0.29557955265045166,
-0.6276381015777588,
-1.2235097885131836,
0.536626935005188,
-0.2252323031425476,
-0.21618719398975372,
0.32725948095321655,
0.19237525761127472,
0.24690522253513336,
0.32162538170814514,
-0.31039828062057495,
-0.31355780363082886,
0.3555960953235626,
-0.4074905216693878,
-0.12894494831562042,
-0.24057629704475403,
-0.3147488236427307,
-0.3134630620479584,
0.7687780261039734,
0.08343610167503357,
-0.2087239921092987,
-0.6890214681625366,
-0.3894607722759247,
-0.01069939136505127,
0.4217948913574219,
-0.1359352320432663,
0.3380063772201538,
0.024262048304080963,
0.3725375831127167,
0.32584014534950256,
-0.3993777632713318,
0.3205537497997284,
-0.27456310391426086,
-0.2096928060054779,
-0.609857439994812,
0.5179880857467651,
0.33244770765304565,
0.2396644651889801,
-0.593507707118988,
0.23203566670417786,
0.2285255640745163,
-0.28915995359420776,
-0.10311274975538254,
0.3919545114040375,
0.2252245843410492,
0.36233076453208923,
0.24329018592834473,
-0.3465258777141571,
-0.028865832835435867,
-0.49823954701423645,
0.6532493233680725,
0.5779315829277039,
-0.15605461597442627,
0.06867966055870056,
0.25001561641693115,
0.3063740134239197,
-0.22007620334625244,
0.8635827898979187,
0.05276612564921379,
-0.6549518704414368,
0.25568798184394836,
0.3742494583129883,
0.9185517430305481,
-0.13599839806556702,
0.31540653109550476,
-0.049268655478954315,
0.3150894343852997,
-0.30957505106925964,
0.05304534360766411,
0.19044463336467743,
-0.8584631085395813,
-0.44139429926872253,
-0.5620216727256775,
-0.4159643352031708,
0.3033250570297241,
-0.8504756093025208,
0.10811591893434525,
-0.44222259521484375,
0.07216223329305649,
-0.04048294574022293,
0.1259741634130478,
-0.5903655886650085,
0.06593206524848938,
0.12091820687055588,
0.7683305144309998,
-1.0273810625076294,
0.6313487887382507,
0.6841246485710144,
-0.4282599985599518,
-0.892819344997406,
-0.12290570884943008,
0.3952395021915436,
-0.8543875813484192,
0.6602820754051208,
0.14679253101348877,
-0.1332310140132904,
-0.3372202515602112,
-0.5973749756813049,
-0.8431915044784546,
1.0835732221603394,
0.25125882029533386,
-0.4173528850078583,
0.22571444511413574,
0.4754941463470459,
0.23097579181194305,
-0.49165648221969604,
0.2055330127477646,
0.9633083939552307,
0.25611427426338196,
0.27427735924720764,
-0.6440446972846985,
-0.11411219090223312,
0.09956123679876328,
-0.1817641407251358,
0.3487251400947571,
-0.3643878698348999,
0.6786627173423767,
-0.3648408055305481,
-0.1787392944097519,
-0.32323214411735535,
0.9525706768035889,
0.021353373304009438,
0.28743788599967957,
0.7466443181037903,
0.7037246227264404,
1.3922722339630127,
-0.11689675599336624,
0.20540915429592133,
-0.052741747349500656,
0.4372359812259674,
1.1511772871017456,
-0.4902942478656769,
0.7888760566711426,
0.3779224157333374,
-0.2214355319738388,
0.3321056067943573,
0.289331316947937,
0.16125424206256866,
0.4805424213409424,
-0.06356392800807953,
-0.5183696746826172,
-0.3253316283226013,
0.02208726294338703,
-0.034753620624542236,
0.6488044857978821,
0.15949541330337524,
-0.2143367975950241,
-0.5183449983596802,
0.20460805296897888,
0.6252216696739197,
0.05628973990678787,
-0.23026756942272186,
0.9931687116622925,
-0.05340119078755379,
-0.47610777616500854,
0.1819959282875061,
-0.06391511857509613,
0.8603197336196899,
-0.30898210406303406,
-0.06526829302310944,
-0.24194031953811646,
0.5311424732208252,
-0.5543982982635498,
-1.0148695707321167,
0.2024497389793396,
0.2836607098579407,
-0.27280715107917786,
-0.28055843710899353,
0.8641322255134583,
-0.8871854543685913,
-0.6589285135269165,
0.4423801004886627,
0.5461828112602234,
0.15820559859275818,
0.20983992516994476,
-0.5085712671279907,
-0.14134977757930756,
0.10952165722846985,
0.02425750531256199,
0.7749432921409607,
0.45932766795158386,
-0.01881507784128189,
0.9434818029403687,
1.0751550197601318,
0.13241100311279297,
-0.12231839448213577,
0.08678344637155533,
1.0876247882843018,
-0.5921680927276611,
-0.10380172729492188,
-0.7411057353019714,
0.6803667545318604,
-0.3085143268108368,
-0.022451218217611313,
0.7039043307304382,
0.5746753215789795,
0.8248023390769958,
0.46979692578315735,
0.8357218503952026,
0.10586482286453247,
0.8345173001289368,
-0.5517235398292542,
1.0827744007110596,
-0.5658321380615234,
0.512402355670929,
0.023822540417313576,
-0.8118982911109924,
-0.048474423587322235,
0.29909077286720276,
-0.08884409815073013,
0.17438341677188873,
0.5535933375358582,
0.7645895481109619,
0.0664999932050705,
-0.01669551059603691,
0.5234259963035583,
-0.1596534550189972,
0.5240902900695801,
0.29848137497901917,
0.8261731266975403,
0.03402102366089821,
0.18368683755397797,
-0.2895265221595764,
-0.4780273735523224,
-0.09296877682209015,
-1.073817253112793,
-1.1425837278366089,
-0.4438425600528717,
-0.33417659997940063,
-0.399981826543808,
0.15538239479064941,
1.0415691137313843,
0.5340826511383057,
-0.6335508823394775,
-0.258383572101593,
0.27078181505203247,
0.41134798526763916,
-0.0686870664358139,
-0.16316716372966766,
0.31298747658729553,
-0.473893940448761,
-0.4852766692638397,
0.43207573890686035,
0.22014132142066956,
-0.17469477653503418,
-0.48633942008018494,
-0.023498356342315674,
0.057977285236120224,
-0.025178372859954834,
0.615121603012085,
0.29315295815467834,
-0.28515902161598206,
-0.21754059195518494,
-0.13291344046592712,
0.06727059930562973,
-0.2989334464073181,
0.8664320111274719,
-0.6322951316833496,
0.04827340319752693,
0.4257586598396301,
0.6618356704711914,
0.21572403609752655,
0.012890923768281937,
0.6430270671844482,
-0.7035430669784546,
0.03138779476284981,
0.06076580658555031,
0.3612009286880493,
0.3968099057674408,
-0.4086054861545563,
0.4794360399246216,
-0.03913391754031181,
-0.45596250891685486,
-1.0719575881958008,
0.10585308074951172,
-0.7253464460372925,
-0.4685249626636505,
1.315995454788208,
0.041769422590732574,
-0.15120647847652435,
-0.019369469955563545,
0.24726128578186035,
0.5069290995597839,
-0.34453433752059937,
0.6451282501220703,
0.5471214652061462,
-0.06280270963907242,
-0.10155626386404037,
-0.2162318378686905,
0.44865888357162476,
0.26033949851989746,
-1.1269479990005493,
0.35207897424697876,
0.5167199969291687,
0.6076735258102417,
-0.07584352046251297,
-0.015802180394530296,
-0.364015132188797,
0.1006966084241867,
-0.4980640113353729,
0.39164918661117554,
-0.4397139847278595,
-0.5966338515281677,
-0.37944066524505615,
-0.023617524653673172,
0.015736714005470276,
-0.16407929360866547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11776v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11776v1 | Improving Multi-Agent Debate with Sparse Communication Topology | 2024-06-17T17:33:09 | 2024-06-17T17:33:09 | Yunxuan Li, Yibing Du, Jiageng Zhang, Le Hou, Peter Grabowski, Yeqing Li, Eugene Ie | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-agent debate has proven effective in improving large language models
quality for reasoning and factuality tasks. While various role-playing
strategies in multi-agent debates have been explored, in terms of the
communication among agents, existing approaches adopt a brute force algorithm
-- each agent can communicate with all other agents. In this paper, we
systematically investigate the effect of communication connectivity in
multi-agent systems. Our experiments on GPT and Mistral models reveal that
multi-agent debates leveraging sparse communication topology can achieve
comparable or superior performance while significantly reducing computational
costs. Furthermore, we extend the multi-agent debate framework to multimodal
reasoning and alignment labeling tasks, showcasing its broad applicability and
effectiveness. Our findings underscore the importance of communication
connectivity on enhancing the efficiency and effectiveness of the "society of
minds" approach. | [
-0.892453670501709,
-1.0454612970352173,
0.7721532583236694,
-0.12175463885068893,
-0.1174946054816246,
0.05409296602010727,
-0.20278675854206085,
-0.46881651878356934,
0.4693555235862732,
0.3188449740409851,
-0.4583507776260376,
-0.14528529345989227,
-0.5896333456039429,
0.10390321910381317,
-0.04907752573490143,
0.706038236618042,
0.3839849829673767,
-0.14701849222183228,
-0.39271411299705505,
-0.597277820110321,
-0.557921826839447,
-0.564290463924408,
-0.7290518283843994,
-0.3611719310283661,
0.8580511808395386,
0.2687843143939972,
1.077492117881775,
0.5311715602874756,
0.4320778250694275,
0.5522924661636353,
-0.16492916643619537,
0.582567036151886,
-0.6727487444877625,
0.5644312500953674,
-0.3038283884525299,
-0.2999926507472992,
-0.5488057732582092,
-0.04058708995580673,
0.8703402876853943,
0.6885994672775269,
-0.15830446779727936,
-0.2759079337120056,
0.1600043922662735,
0.5536671280860901,
-0.4300915002822876,
0.13229338824748993,
-0.7473416328430176,
-0.46959206461906433,
-0.22057223320007324,
-0.43176358938217163,
-0.38291117548942566,
-0.12196026742458344,
0.139524906873703,
-0.7757072448730469,
0.025617942214012146,
-0.009003197774291039,
0.8923046588897705,
0.499287486076355,
-0.5621280670166016,
-0.18665708601474762,
-0.7216484546661377,
0.21551407873630524,
-0.34025779366493225,
0.3222378194332123,
0.15227627754211426,
0.15482258796691895,
-0.3939955234527588,
-0.5952621102333069,
-0.5778440833091736,
-0.030839260667562485,
0.013500581495463848,
0.1654307097196579,
-0.30413055419921875,
0.47587838768959045,
0.19950374960899353,
-0.2514966130256653,
-0.257485955953598,
-0.3071134388446808,
-0.34773463010787964,
-0.1471136212348938,
0.5080903768539429,
0.16225625574588776,
0.02652609348297119,
0.19013775885105133,
-0.14694544672966003,
-0.055258724838495255,
-0.4738035798072815,
-0.13541032373905182,
0.3025110363960266,
0.2171759307384491,
0.10852567106485367,
0.19047339260578156,
-0.24300238490104675,
0.7422162294387817,
0.012774663977324963,
-0.19524045288562775,
-0.22994981706142426,
-0.6219601631164551,
-0.08109255880117416,
-0.325044184923172,
0.5229119658470154,
0.2895512282848358,
-0.08722468465566635,
-0.30370208621025085,
0.13261330127716064,
0.21789972484111786,
0.4030606150627136,
-0.5133433938026428,
-0.2947540879249573,
0.14211058616638184,
-0.22165651619434357,
0.2444514036178589,
-0.24694283306598663,
-0.5765921473503113,
-0.54881751537323,
-0.26598984003067017,
0.4933072626590729,
-0.24679511785507202,
-0.5530281066894531,
0.053642112761735916,
-0.32974544167518616,
-0.04271624609827995,
0.9016895890235901,
-0.5608739852905273,
0.4923098683357239,
0.589179277420044,
0.908968985080719,
0.2673962414264679,
-0.4662284553050995,
-0.39892423152923584,
0.3855830132961273,
-0.5482072830200195,
1.2950639724731445,
-0.46135351061820984,
-0.11683305352926254,
-0.5155194401741028,
-0.029406072571873665,
-0.5047092437744141,
-0.27545544505119324,
0.1847725361585617,
-0.42082637548446655,
-0.17709514498710632,
-0.7461467385292053,
-0.4469800293445587,
0.06617988646030426,
0.47834697365760803,
-0.9594097137451172,
0.305625319480896,
-0.480568528175354,
-0.6164045333862305,
0.1227341741323471,
-0.7286858558654785,
-0.31434008479118347,
0.13844643533229828,
-0.12724454700946808,
-0.22379201650619507,
-0.20279064774513245,
0.13408580422401428,
0.24898205697536469,
-0.358205646276474,
0.17812515795230865,
-0.5510256290435791,
-0.4397309720516205,
0.34115293622016907,
-0.3236859142780304,
0.5587731003761292,
0.2853342592716217,
-0.3485892117023468,
0.1157870665192604,
-0.1734047532081604,
-0.21915286779403687,
-0.09872740507125854,
-0.0615873858332634,
-0.2982359528541565,
0.21923884749412537,
-0.5185043215751648,
0.14564365148544312,
-0.2895287871360779,
-0.31817272305488586,
0.3378061056137085,
-0.3936379551887512,
0.5749119520187378,
0.8036023378372192,
-0.1639714390039444,
0.610314130783081,
-0.6924968361854553,
0.26153111457824707,
-0.04521907493472099,
0.21234150230884552,
-0.060356561094522476,
-0.8326601386070251,
-0.6836011409759521,
-0.43974393606185913,
0.1184334084391594,
0.3068779408931732,
-1.2011620998382568,
-0.17785099148750305,
-0.30963408946990967,
-0.47606128454208374,
-0.5141991376876831,
-0.29714861512184143,
0.15000423789024353,
0.3061053156852722,
0.2094154804944992,
-0.24393810331821442,
0.023367246612906456,
-0.47973138093948364,
-0.0769103392958641,
-0.4272196590900421,
0.5292103886604309,
0.6544742584228516,
0.25441303849220276,
-0.012014348991215229,
0.9307441711425781,
-0.37829694151878357,
0.0806015208363533,
-0.12015993893146515,
0.2259465456008911,
-0.3142074644565582,
0.3407399356365204,
0.32239317893981934,
-0.6097860932350159,
-0.4258423149585724,
0.04346310347318649,
-0.5501035451889038,
0.18905217945575714,
-0.32556644082069397,
-0.34570491313934326,
0.41544005274772644,
0.4387216567993164,
-1.123137354850769,
0.34928491711616516,
0.34230056405067444,
-0.353384405374527,
0.5181112289428711,
-0.161589577794075,
0.6866127252578735,
-0.8770042657852173,
-0.11657927185297012,
-0.0630553588271141,
-0.15879419445991516,
-0.7846121191978455,
0.1638714075088501,
-0.4815598428249359,
-0.14553366601467133,
-0.13629402220249176,
0.476550430059433,
-0.5808247327804565,
0.11685878783464432,
-0.20414434373378754,
0.5217096209526062,
0.20114535093307495,
0.5666521787643433,
-0.040734004229307175,
1.042797327041626,
0.5513635873794556,
-0.379637211561203,
0.4509977698326111,
0.22901692986488342,
0.11861436069011688,
0.9323182106018066,
-0.7238909006118774,
0.30177029967308044,
-0.41574424505233765,
0.5438892841339111,
-1.484236240386963,
0.010923066176474094,
0.3463757038116455,
-0.5578984022140503,
0.01948409341275692,
-0.23731715977191925,
-0.38984012603759766,
0.09278932958841324,
-0.24894294142723083,
0.5182076096534729,
-0.1290237158536911,
-0.31064778566360474,
0.5728753209114075,
0.6307393312454224,
-0.23031602799892426,
-0.6373312473297119,
-0.18030428886413574,
0.533399224281311,
-0.3586146831512451,
-1.0411685705184937,
-0.08353867381811142,
-0.1024874746799469,
-0.2990015745162964,
-0.06602803617715836,
-0.0016274573281407356,
-0.3682284951210022,
0.13916872441768646,
0.023913556709885597,
0.0006364823784679174,
-0.15941578149795532,
0.5787848234176636,
0.1814655363559723,
0.06083497777581215,
-0.05994865670800209,
-0.32318705320358276,
0.3600737452507019,
-0.23645086586475372,
-0.4893619120121002,
-0.2292042374610901,
0.7227098941802979,
0.49879294633865356,
-0.1600438505411148,
1.005782961845398,
0.29473841190338135,
-0.13983134925365448,
-0.21368324756622314,
-0.9314390420913696,
-0.5135844349861145,
-0.4832664430141449,
0.26239991188049316,
-0.506105899810791,
-1.2190130949020386,
0.31385719776153564,
-0.5912426710128784,
-0.10487797111272812,
0.15439969301223755,
0.254489928483963,
-0.14937768876552582,
0.9955125451087952,
0.5673461556434631,
0.21769152581691742,
0.11163627356290817,
0.053604237735271454,
0.25993549823760986,
-0.4421442747116089,
-0.09979307651519775,
-0.7666666507720947,
-0.13555119931697845,
-0.43165817856788635,
-0.6508963108062744,
0.7995057106018066,
-0.1857781559228897,
-0.14530417323112488,
0.29611194133758545,
-0.5721461176872253,
0.39221298694610596,
0.2821508049964905,
0.10680747032165527,
0.36772167682647705,
0.19523948431015015,
-0.13900883495807648,
0.1073603555560112,
-1.048050045967102,
-0.38949573040008545,
0.652614414691925,
0.1662401556968689,
0.6375903487205505,
0.454262375831604,
0.378473699092865,
0.20322519540786743,
0.1452089250087738,
-0.45184433460235596,
0.5594083070755005,
0.38179177045822144,
-0.530847430229187,
-0.7385587692260742,
-0.6167957186698914,
-1.3590826988220215,
0.8392598032951355,
-0.34629788994789124,
-0.8741485476493835,
0.40160155296325684,
-0.12475904077291489,
-0.2842239439487457,
0.37391525506973267,
-0.7935090065002441,
0.8156850934028625,
0.5754852890968323,
-0.5116127133369446,
-0.5672920346260071,
-0.7952147126197815,
0.29452207684516907,
0.30166810750961304,
0.2791712284088135,
0.0037617413327097893,
0.10435287654399872,
0.5426617860794067,
-0.4692626893520355,
0.7177581787109375,
0.2146185338497162,
-0.19853301346302032,
0.6310209035873413,
-0.28791478276252747,
0.4351133704185486,
0.13857831060886383,
0.2005079686641693,
0.22230006754398346,
0.089481420814991,
-0.4161313474178314,
-0.6646876931190491,
0.543485164642334,
-1.0139143466949463,
-0.8182078003883362,
-0.22212688624858856,
-0.7400023937225342,
-0.2503347396850586,
-0.023578505963087082,
-0.08287467807531357,
0.7402913570404053,
-0.1971150040626526,
0.04584818333387375,
0.8351307511329651,
0.16064894199371338,
0.23885616660118103,
0.3268086910247803,
0.5624039173126221,
-0.4690196216106415,
0.9643697738647461,
0.40764763951301575,
0.6123422384262085,
-0.04182121157646179,
-0.1840965300798416,
-0.472500205039978,
-0.05307045578956604,
-0.5644861459732056,
0.42994582653045654,
-0.8735647201538086,
-0.23559311032295227,
-1.0048362016677856,
-0.18465352058410645,
-0.4718496799468994,
-0.07017774879932404,
-0.4071502387523651,
-0.576054573059082,
0.18210923671722412,
0.24496550858020782,
-0.0029754042625427246,
0.7290336489677429,
-0.21231652796268463,
0.4126237630844116,
-0.5600557327270508,
0.10901880264282227,
0.6399800181388855,
0.25914040207862854,
0.2720489799976349,
-0.009546787478029728,
-0.3145968019962311,
0.1413724273443222,
-0.6785573363304138,
-1.1804742813110352,
-0.19341564178466797,
0.11156246066093445,
0.6421610713005066,
0.24680033326148987,
0.06265071034431458,
0.8171364068984985,
-0.34460020065307617,
0.47037044167518616,
0.114180788397789,
-0.8857253193855286,
0.14934232831001282,
-0.6058943867683411,
0.16545195877552032,
0.21168135106563568,
0.05712582543492317,
-0.5381984710693359,
-0.6341941356658936,
-0.6309199333190918,
-0.4088689088821411,
0.6639841794967651,
0.4479193389415741,
-0.27198973298072815,
-0.05352693051099777,
0.2173764705657959,
-0.29561954736709595,
0.25478217005729675,
-0.3683883249759674,
-0.3478732705116272,
-0.09519681334495544,
0.42186710238456726,
0.03595414012670517,
0.003902875818312168,
-0.6511251926422119,
-0.3906489312648773,
0.2261132001876831,
-0.40508463978767395,
0.46165749430656433,
0.3766956329345703,
0.17686736583709717,
-0.17029637098312378,
0.5005478262901306,
0.8728286623954773,
0.9152740836143494,
0.3331526517868042,
0.3779834508895874,
0.13886742293834686,
-0.25093287229537964,
0.41232016682624817,
0.25431114435195923,
0.18641290068626404,
-0.048796605318784714,
0.3040250241756439,
0.8115076422691345,
-0.3532913327217102,
-0.18314623832702637,
0.38041606545448303,
-0.3186306357383728,
-0.5456985831260681,
0.5103377103805542,
0.09582621604204178,
0.5005121827125549,
0.6359624266624451,
0.16744211316108704,
0.40886709094047546,
0.31842634081840515,
-0.5226830244064331,
0.2631772756576538,
0.8784379959106445,
-0.11260933429002762,
-0.1009250059723854,
0.49124813079833984,
0.35881364345550537,
0.013660413213074207,
0.31415480375289917,
-0.2233404666185379,
-0.34403902292251587,
0.8946502804756165,
0.4310317039489746,
0.45518359541893005,
-0.32043230533599854,
0.6686526536941528,
0.13139015436172485,
0.7675591707229614,
-0.1123456284403801,
-0.007856983691453934,
-0.21576641499996185,
-0.7718327641487122,
-0.7931780815124512,
0.0323566272854805,
-0.6389476656913757,
-0.2945842146873474,
-0.05195441469550133,
-0.13529585301876068,
-0.2742690443992615,
-0.490230530500412,
0.028074022382497787,
0.22014790773391724,
-0.3062672019004822,
-0.2388923615217209,
0.20960313081741333,
0.5190223455429077,
-0.7400246262550354,
0.7376201152801514,
0.8772530555725098,
-0.05025719851255417,
-0.7933506369590759,
-0.12881942093372345,
0.05685107037425041,
-0.16894736886024475,
0.3130151927471161,
0.08174208551645279,
-0.6955822706222534,
0.026693344116210938,
-0.7396776676177979,
-1.0426126718521118,
1.009757161140442,
0.6466608047485352,
-0.16826896369457245,
0.4098673164844513,
0.1256011426448822,
0.5010023713111877,
-0.1316770762205124,
0.7450194358825684,
0.25330764055252075,
0.515997588634491,
0.39013999700546265,
-1.2081687450408936,
0.1382988691329956,
-0.34117597341537476,
-0.2602793276309967,
0.20860835909843445,
-1.061574935913086,
1.0125901699066162,
-0.11120270192623138,
-0.6146438717842102,
0.007590075489133596,
0.7852887511253357,
0.237214133143425,
0.4260581135749817,
0.6489772200584412,
0.4325924515724182,
0.9833208322525024,
-0.20167754590511322,
0.4495513439178467,
-0.22908000648021698,
0.4014207124710083,
0.5821803212165833,
-0.34842684864997864,
0.1882568895816803,
0.23808839917182922,
0.039861541241407394,
0.3896767497062683,
0.2355622500181198,
0.45485231280326843,
0.12803812325000763,
0.12282636761665344,
-0.32830366492271423,
-0.6218612194061279,
-0.4083746373653412,
-0.4079524278640747,
0.25603240728378296,
0.5084643363952637,
0.801088809967041,
-0.48209911584854126,
-0.15535534918308258,
0.21920554339885712,
0.08806302398443222,
0.02682795561850071,
0.8680047392845154,
-0.20544198155403137,
-0.8667307496070862,
0.8343005180358887,
-0.055789764970541,
0.3385535478591919,
-0.35799503326416016,
-0.4078700542449951,
-0.2079888880252838,
-0.09235408157110214,
-0.017386332154273987,
-0.4129883646965027,
0.281388521194458,
-0.6620675921440125,
0.19647975265979767,
0.22517256438732147,
0.9899508357048035,
-0.703196108341217,
0.17826172709465027,
0.2903729975223541,
0.8558897972106934,
0.19401372969150543,
-0.05078040808439255,
-0.7445405721664429,
0.2703472375869751,
-0.6567553281784058,
0.0137009983882308,
0.370895653963089,
0.7283056378364563,
-0.18898434937000275,
0.922625720500946,
0.5778961181640625,
0.007523707579821348,
-0.031025981530547142,
-0.16497430205345154,
1.4761220216751099,
-0.2472083568572998,
-0.5907660722732544,
-0.7577497363090515,
0.36910220980644226,
-0.46656277775764465,
0.029903244227170944,
0.708310067653656,
0.08247476071119308,
0.4900440275669098,
0.38850149512290955,
0.5418166518211365,
0.1237669289112091,
0.1012098416686058,
-0.16997140645980835,
0.8047189712524414,
-0.48019054532051086,
0.02705869823694229,
-0.45738810300827026,
-0.6360250115394592,
-0.054122067987918854,
0.6602324843406677,
0.07948285341262817,
0.036149945110082626,
1.0150405168533325,
0.8832250833511353,
-0.08214925229549408,
0.20393820106983185,
0.3465334475040436,
0.1597423553466797,
0.3872351050376892,
0.6724382638931274,
0.9355878829956055,
-0.26846086978912354,
0.4889434576034546,
0.06483574956655502,
-0.48586955666542053,
0.17041020095348358,
-0.5322547554969788,
-1.1749428510665894,
-0.8269771337509155,
-0.2518036961555481,
-0.43523454666137695,
0.6120048761367798,
0.7034139037132263,
0.900969922542572,
-0.11042589694261551,
-0.4345030188560486,
0.2656589448451996,
0.6460034847259521,
-0.465224027633667,
-0.13850443065166473,
0.25976651906967163,
-0.5946139097213745,
-0.5435553789138794,
0.27865418791770935,
0.4724484980106354,
-0.48386913537979126,
-0.19802619516849518,
-0.17482513189315796,
-0.5077585577964783,
0.5951752066612244,
0.6373558640480042,
0.16966798901557922,
-0.5828738808631897,
-0.3430742621421814,
-0.142843097448349,
-0.24345088005065918,
0.13462619483470917,
0.8411672711372375,
-0.6098086833953857,
0.4285934269428253,
0.4446146488189697,
0.7230913043022156,
0.06703408807516098,
0.42784640192985535,
0.4455428123474121,
-0.3879431486129761,
0.2787131071090698,
-0.10717877000570297,
0.018023405224084854,
0.18951448798179626,
-0.3405980169773102,
0.300545871257782,
0.6824002861976624,
-0.9689483642578125,
-0.5128076672554016,
0.28330326080322266,
-0.7869734168052673,
-0.5400390625,
1.0555869340896606,
-0.09446205198764801,
-0.19683243334293365,
-0.715303361415863,
-0.38723939657211304,
0.22352953255176544,
-0.5244308114051819,
0.6056897640228271,
0.853698194026947,
-0.11907511949539185,
-0.3706497251987457,
-0.4942541718482971,
0.5660039782524109,
0.5495166182518005,
-0.8750718235969543,
-0.01785198040306568,
0.6832345724105835,
-0.05592832714319229,
0.2561340928077698,
1.3359211683273315,
0.33691293001174927,
0.21284359693527222,
0.27058538794517517,
-0.27749568223953247,
0.10908079147338867,
-0.8550856709480286,
0.09233821928501129,
0.3599536716938019,
-0.004532715305685997,
0.014020339585840702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11768v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11768v1 | GAMA: A Large Audio-Language Model with Advanced Audio Understanding and Complex Reasoning Abilities | 2024-06-17T17:31:01 | 2024-06-17T17:31:01 | Sreyan Ghosh, Sonal Kumar, Ashish Seth, Chandra Kiran Reddy Evuru, Utkarsh Tyagi, S Sakshi, Oriol Nieto, Ramani Duraiswami, Dinesh Manocha | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS | Perceiving and understanding non-speech sounds and non-verbal speech is
essential to making decisions that help us interact with our surroundings. In
this paper, we propose GAMA, a novel General-purpose Large Audio-Language Model
(LALM) with Advanced Audio Understanding and Complex Reasoning Abilities. We
build GAMA by integrating an LLM with multiple types of audio representations,
including features from a custom Audio Q-Former, a multi-layer aggregator that
aggregates features from multiple layers of an audio encoder. We fine-tune GAMA
on a large-scale audio-language dataset, which augments it with audio
understanding capabilities. Next, we propose CompA-R (Instruction-Tuning for
Complex Audio Reasoning), a synthetically generated instruction-tuning (IT)
dataset with instructions that require the model to perform complex reasoning
on the input audio. We instruction-tune GAMA with CompA-R to endow it with
complex reasoning abilities, where we further add a soft prompt as input with
high-level semantic evidence by leveraging event tags of the input audio.
Finally, we also propose CompA-R-test, a human-labeled evaluation dataset for
evaluating the capabilities of LALMs on open-ended audio question-answering
that requires complex reasoning. Through automated and expert human
evaluations, we show that GAMA outperforms all other LALMs in literature on
diverse audio understanding tasks by margins of 1%-84%. Further, GAMA IT-ed on
CompA-R proves to be superior in its complex reasoning and instruction
following capabilities. | [
-0.6350907683372498,
-1.1902166604995728,
0.7881094813346863,
0.05342194065451622,
0.03910147398710251,
0.14051604270935059,
-0.439696729183197,
-0.5393176674842834,
-0.14897558093070984,
0.31393203139305115,
-0.6280823945999146,
-0.6442726850509644,
-0.5547197461128235,
-0.28552374243736267,
-0.480506032705307,
0.5184258222579956,
0.358940452337265,
0.09347841143608093,
-0.12362796813249588,
-0.22660087049007416,
-0.663250207901001,
-0.42604923248291016,
-0.6898559331893921,
-0.4366095960140228,
0.19244442880153656,
0.6547380089759827,
0.8204177618026733,
0.40685078501701355,
0.2800285816192627,
0.2128063440322876,
-0.13543735444545746,
0.5855153799057007,
-0.08359996974468231,
-0.012174664996564388,
-0.16490061581134796,
-0.6009784936904907,
-0.8682927489280701,
-0.06879287213087082,
0.3404168486595154,
0.6167284846305847,
-0.2932056784629822,
0.4261757433414459,
-0.36316123604774475,
0.28185081481933594,
-0.4186364710330963,
0.09263705462217331,
-0.6566037535667419,
0.0033289180137217045,
0.2997390925884247,
-0.5227532982826233,
-0.5349161624908447,
0.18559589982032776,
0.010385911911725998,
-0.7469303011894226,
0.2705623209476471,
0.2686065435409546,
0.8387365937232971,
0.466331422328949,
-0.12348707020282745,
-0.6062167882919312,
-1.1131484508514404,
0.8485483527183533,
-0.5888751745223999,
0.4965364933013916,
0.5505378246307373,
0.7795102000236511,
-0.14816856384277344,
-0.41099080443382263,
-0.8143272995948792,
-0.24533191323280334,
0.42048078775405884,
0.04421510547399521,
-0.21196742355823517,
-0.008166981860995293,
0.16837869584560394,
0.5492277145385742,
-0.6827754378318787,
-0.17583443224430084,
-0.1007283627986908,
0.22409647703170776,
0.6606107950210571,
0.24024532735347748,
0.8363988399505615,
0.3878954350948334,
-0.24992038309574127,
0.06719840317964554,
-0.6390971541404724,
0.10044403374195099,
0.24689389765262604,
0.15518999099731445,
-0.12273238599300385,
0.2755872309207916,
-0.06302056461572647,
0.8536815047264099,
-0.015501821413636208,
-0.2613833546638489,
0.21691438555717468,
-0.20876218378543854,
-0.553482711315155,
0.2146860659122467,
0.6124287247657776,
-0.04746632277965546,
0.2794248163700104,
-0.26373323798179626,
-0.0875496119260788,
0.1190040335059166,
0.09050770103931427,
-0.29170891642570496,
-0.1757347136735916,
0.3249134421348572,
-0.22490622103214264,
0.193556547164917,
-0.1078670471906662,
-0.5122820734977722,
-0.2528514266014099,
-0.6618785858154297,
0.8038470149040222,
-0.2683273255825043,
-0.19700360298156738,
0.796071469783783,
0.18107159435749054,
0.22847844660282135,
0.4213518798351288,
-1.0340763330459595,
0.37194034457206726,
0.7897306680679321,
0.7296048402786255,
0.25232529640197754,
-0.003388359909877181,
-0.8594250679016113,
0.5020602345466614,
-0.11954323202371597,
0.7617384195327759,
-1.0333160161972046,
-0.30462759733200073,
-0.4599195718765259,
-0.19244927167892456,
-0.03558515012264252,
-0.5799317359924316,
0.9581225514411926,
-0.37761059403419495,
0.3128340244293213,
0.04419965296983719,
-0.4171975553035736,
-0.7707881331443787,
0.114507295191288,
-0.26328545808792114,
0.4121246933937073,
-0.17415751516819,
-0.04430622234940529,
0.2628195881843567,
-0.7854758501052856,
-0.3131501078605652,
-0.08918563276529312,
-0.15500377118587494,
-0.44847941398620605,
-0.05972541868686676,
0.47096019983291626,
0.3455311357975006,
-0.6105996370315552,
0.5216029286384583,
-0.3375438153743744,
-0.7171778082847595,
0.1340738832950592,
-0.4595608115196228,
0.4926298260688782,
0.3421483337879181,
-0.42521753907203674,
0.2625650465488434,
-0.8282628059387207,
0.03140799701213837,
0.1073237955570221,
-0.22018760442733765,
-0.041201233863830566,
0.15437668561935425,
-0.05366574600338936,
0.2450879067182541,
-0.028498278930783272,
-0.36453723907470703,
0.04310274124145508,
-0.1048097237944603,
0.660633385181427,
0.27327460050582886,
-0.11988531798124313,
0.5037891268730164,
-0.36224979162216187,
0.5581608414649963,
-0.11323107779026031,
0.13325688242912292,
-0.3140300214290619,
-0.6049726009368896,
-0.926733672618866,
-0.4656471610069275,
-0.08361790329217911,
0.662794291973114,
0.15659838914871216,
0.4308612644672394,
0.059916429221630096,
-0.38354143500328064,
-0.7637612819671631,
0.2435300052165985,
0.2517904043197632,
0.4966356158256531,
0.6417914628982544,
0.26487189531326294,
-0.6223288774490356,
-0.8168563842773438,
-0.14631381630897522,
0.022215817123651505,
-0.35299283266067505,
0.6000272035598755,
0.17707084119319916,
-0.5687062740325928,
0.7089113593101501,
-0.4342186748981476,
-0.393744558095932,
-0.20415335893630981,
0.2289194017648697,
0.472951203584671,
0.34953489899635315,
0.27766868472099304,
-0.4501981735229492,
0.011358698830008507,
0.19426289200782776,
-0.6777183413505554,
-0.30843639373779297,
-0.38851451873779297,
0.010002616792917252,
-0.26007962226867676,
0.3235030770301819,
-0.7523661851882935,
-0.057491280138492584,
0.37552085518836975,
-0.44471463561058044,
0.44785043597221375,
-0.3373032808303833,
0.1989673227071762,
-0.676538348197937,
-0.04570077732205391,
-0.07088517397642136,
-0.17714162170886993,
-0.586069643497467,
0.10450264066457748,
-0.22734296321868896,
-0.15312378108501434,
-0.12897202372550964,
0.5012438893318176,
-0.5012892484664917,
-0.29443758726119995,
-0.3374595046043396,
0.33191952109336853,
0.1709231436252594,
0.5704174041748047,
0.07721304148435593,
0.8615827560424805,
0.6526634693145752,
-0.6290567517280579,
0.3524203896522522,
0.28224876523017883,
-0.7198411226272583,
0.24056386947631836,
-0.8183338046073914,
0.4978898763656616,
-0.020129701122641563,
0.07668772339820862,
-0.8928287029266357,
-0.04651098698377609,
0.18001192808151245,
-0.4804764688014984,
0.2652184069156647,
-0.022610202431678772,
-0.391076922416687,
0.015627218410372734,
0.4854692220687866,
0.27944716811180115,
0.4025121033191681,
-0.5450829267501831,
0.9487054944038391,
0.658314049243927,
-0.3042639493942261,
-0.4155409336090088,
-0.5189400315284729,
0.31576111912727356,
-0.36172300577163696,
-0.8773984909057617,
-0.1301390528678894,
-0.07810592651367188,
-0.4537229537963867,
-0.2715590000152588,
-0.13210949301719666,
-0.10334183275699615,
0.25579702854156494,
0.24466009438037872,
0.24417762458324432,
-0.33801382780075073,
0.09696517139673233,
0.027686646208167076,
-0.09471867233514786,
0.2509559392929077,
-0.16992849111557007,
0.5278363823890686,
-0.5775353312492371,
-0.5040290355682373,
-0.3336808383464813,
0.4472462236881256,
0.6206709742546082,
-0.4179481863975525,
0.11921828985214233,
0.6520498991012573,
-0.006264897063374519,
-0.5209823846817017,
-0.3574860692024231,
0.173956036567688,
-0.40108630061149597,
0.46906912326812744,
-0.5769352912902832,
-0.8568502068519592,
0.47071680426597595,
0.010614736936986446,
0.12555183470249176,
0.07667850703001022,
0.8828040361404419,
-0.22304505109786987,
1.559741735458374,
0.029930179938673973,
0.20857176184654236,
0.13493885099887848,
-0.41875386238098145,
0.35374635457992554,
-0.7352393865585327,
-0.48257023096084595,
-0.5004786849021912,
-0.4402737319469452,
0.049994878470897675,
-0.5488703846931458,
0.12165457755327225,
-0.018023749813437462,
-0.4185004234313965,
-0.010936656035482883,
-0.36274704337120056,
0.5593300461769104,
0.4908429682254791,
-0.06865157186985016,
0.5508809089660645,
-0.3150799870491028,
0.08810748159885406,
0.5869126915931702,
-0.4780820906162262,
-0.7101993560791016,
0.7273076176643372,
0.6377611756324768,
0.8329444527626038,
0.2638879418373108,
0.06336939334869385,
0.17320853471755981,
-0.3139435648918152,
-0.9543158411979675,
0.4799270033836365,
0.0080686891451478,
-0.5586642026901245,
-0.13865427672863007,
-0.20860818028450012,
-0.5749878883361816,
0.3842111825942993,
-0.36549443006515503,
-0.5156447291374207,
0.0657021701335907,
0.11946181952953339,
-0.37485185265541077,
0.22040659189224243,
-1.017035961151123,
0.4480786621570587,
-0.36296549439430237,
-0.0022885603830218315,
-0.512464702129364,
-0.48490798473358154,
0.48497477173805237,
0.20513500273227692,
0.51750248670578,
-0.4039357304573059,
-0.05941071733832359,
0.2795504927635193,
0.012087383307516575,
0.21751533448696136,
-0.2288111448287964,
-0.1417718082666397,
0.2649552822113037,
0.10956533253192902,
0.08970458060503006,
0.3957018554210663,
0.14009271562099457,
0.3465190529823303,
-0.12833338975906372,
-0.1914508193731308,
-0.8569149971008301,
0.6739758849143982,
-0.9723370671272278,
-0.9039482474327087,
-0.13471873104572296,
-1.043068528175354,
-0.6502126455307007,
-0.09039249271154404,
-0.1293201744556427,
0.4608764052391052,
0.058399491012096405,
0.23686902225017548,
0.8909893035888672,
-0.30636000633239746,
0.09123256057500839,
0.4816597104072571,
-0.3139532506465912,
-0.2327415943145752,
0.9563298225402832,
-0.23167715966701508,
0.25085073709487915,
0.3662659227848053,
0.23390617966651917,
-0.3695265054702759,
-0.7403405904769897,
-0.5993998646736145,
-0.01406711246818304,
-0.5953463912010193,
0.25774988532066345,
-0.8634366393089294,
0.04165806621313095,
0.1396956443786621,
-0.03077906183898449,
0.04299704730510712,
-0.4188423752784729,
-0.32441774010658264,
-0.08376433700323105,
0.025245318189263344,
0.481853723526001,
0.06341686099767685,
0.27754759788513184,
-0.7413081526756287,
0.8021692633628845,
0.5508176684379578,
0.14034387469291687,
0.07577687501907349,
-0.7416565418243408,
-0.27541399002075195,
0.19929979741573334,
-0.016394441947340965,
-0.5645714402198792,
0.3194960057735443,
0.5298366546630859,
0.7094433307647705,
0.4784765839576721,
-0.3972236216068268,
0.6460383534431458,
-0.48962366580963135,
0.440376877784729,
-0.04421543702483177,
-1.000531554222107,
0.4433386027812958,
-0.5804164409637451,
0.48572486639022827,
0.38458019495010376,
-0.10032586753368378,
-0.4207572937011719,
-0.4616766571998596,
-0.32377728819847107,
-0.6812558174133301,
0.541285514831543,
-0.02696079947054386,
0.015717845410108566,
0.1188429668545723,
0.02436702884733677,
0.1811235249042511,
-0.09741062670946121,
-0.14242981374263763,
-0.17730215191841125,
-0.23476466536521912,
-0.03612793609499931,
-0.20588524639606476,
-0.09159339219331741,
-0.1463405340909958,
-0.432094931602478,
0.74281245470047,
-0.08697867393493652,
0.21744534373283386,
0.10217207670211792,
-0.25428885221481323,
-0.041538629680871964,
0.7107751965522766,
0.9348970055580139,
0.5606432557106018,
-0.374176561832428,
0.18739639222621918,
0.21604308485984802,
-0.47654226422309875,
0.4791690707206726,
-0.348440557718277,
0.03335122764110565,
-0.0949886292219162,
0.1759006232023239,
1.0726512670516968,
0.13001902401447296,
-1.008680820465088,
0.18609505891799927,
-0.3269389867782593,
-0.3424068093299866,
-0.3490730822086334,
0.6094807982444763,
0.6516798138618469,
0.2339445948600769,
0.44771239161491394,
0.18947087228298187,
0.4058862030506134,
-0.7130916118621826,
0.23791778087615967,
0.39561036229133606,
-0.2932907044887543,
-0.25355520844459534,
0.8048597574234009,
0.10707935690879822,
-0.29614683985710144,
0.3156183958053589,
-0.08660949021577835,
-0.05418333783745766,
0.6103171110153198,
0.6221980452537537,
0.8796249628067017,
-0.019021498039364815,
-0.028227424249053,
0.32761088013648987,
0.20136499404907227,
0.11301612854003906,
0.5380879640579224,
-0.3197193443775177,
-0.5224884748458862,
-0.692345142364502,
-0.6313831210136414,
-0.6967736482620239,
0.33925697207450867,
-0.476282000541687,
0.33886104822158813,
-0.8626889586448669,
-0.004423060920089483,
0.06319966167211533,
-0.1604112684726715,
-0.4903743863105774,
0.46684184670448303,
0.3864956200122833,
0.891981303691864,
-0.7603444457054138,
0.72653728723526,
0.7114302515983582,
-0.3639736771583557,
-0.9061018824577332,
-0.17075897753238678,
-0.11521083861589432,
-0.8574473857879639,
0.49547237157821655,
0.08511270582675934,
-0.5699597001075745,
-0.04355600103735924,
-0.6034089922904968,
-0.6242379546165466,
0.9438909292221069,
0.7359313368797302,
-0.9024649262428284,
-0.09169340133666992,
0.004452273715287447,
0.4071349501609802,
-0.4461989998817444,
0.5085340738296509,
0.7627533078193665,
0.5416656732559204,
0.39032790064811707,
-0.7027289271354675,
-0.29047271609306335,
-0.3339124321937561,
-0.4836958050727844,
0.17823553085327148,
-0.4442332684993744,
0.7459685206413269,
-0.44831857085227966,
-0.1734914928674698,
-0.2088468223810196,
0.5858330130577087,
0.35427308082580566,
0.4984346628189087,
0.6400687098503113,
0.7366973161697388,
0.8784030675888062,
-0.17455904185771942,
0.7337287664413452,
0.03075738251209259,
0.1625748872756958,
1.474430799484253,
0.013224254362285137,
0.6909803152084351,
0.13598814606666565,
0.03566756471991539,
0.641520619392395,
0.4367237687110901,
-0.0037657374050468206,
0.38963621854782104,
0.08017079532146454,
-0.548905611038208,
-0.8822619318962097,
-0.08492448180913925,
-0.3132951557636261,
0.981812059879303,
0.4990067780017853,
-0.23519933223724365,
-0.0341518335044384,
-0.01059017051011324,
-0.09873995929956436,
0.08971042931079865,
-0.5103161334991455,
0.8013827800750732,
0.3062635064125061,
-0.2788945436477661,
0.5155711770057678,
-0.22546589374542236,
0.4791724681854248,
-0.42616891860961914,
-0.15476082265377045,
0.2501888871192932,
0.0883021280169487,
-0.4418655335903168,
-0.8114275932312012,
0.4929473400115967,
0.03678587079048157,
-0.41413313150405884,
0.12036453932523727,
0.5065520405769348,
-0.6316531896591187,
-0.23816624283790588,
0.3168042004108429,
0.3597491979598999,
0.09520619362592697,
0.006228639278560877,
-0.657463550567627,
-0.008253378793597221,
-0.3081076145172119,
-0.014221607707440853,
0.19075800478458405,
0.2939470112323761,
0.028785234317183495,
0.9229456186294556,
0.8700231313705444,
0.17087192833423615,
-0.12465348094701767,
0.4428858458995819,
0.2971794903278351,
-0.6414880752563477,
-0.7313665151596069,
-0.6965721845626831,
0.2256159633398056,
0.25762197375297546,
0.03384815528988838,
0.4798263609409332,
0.3230014443397522,
0.5501591563224792,
-0.037213925272226334,
0.8811736106872559,
0.3651491403579712,
0.47999307513237,
-0.6136730313301086,
0.7462010383605957,
-0.5928778052330017,
0.31287214159965515,
-0.11809524148702621,
-0.7986870408058167,
-0.38505473732948303,
0.7441693544387817,
-0.44330474734306335,
-0.05814896151423454,
0.2670465111732483,
0.7702376246452332,
-0.259972482919693,
0.5198073983192444,
0.5088701844215393,
0.1669672578573227,
0.5713137984275818,
0.8957178592681885,
1.0016535520553589,
-0.1490517556667328,
0.5742913484573364,
0.31706541776657104,
-0.13945139944553375,
-0.12051520496606827,
-0.5961964130401611,
-0.8268972039222717,
-0.4582501947879791,
-0.061031654477119446,
0.06885886192321777,
-0.11142994463443756,
1.045715570449829,
0.8022875785827637,
-0.8857495188713074,
-0.2055997997522354,
-0.06971262395381927,
0.1303330361843109,
-0.32852503657341003,
-0.1743469387292862,
0.13488371670246124,
-0.3315068483352661,
-0.8913561701774597,
0.978184163570404,
0.6072189807891846,
-0.35225218534469604,
-0.3234338164329529,
-0.4206709861755371,
-0.3311839699745178,
0.31853410601615906,
0.584757387638092,
0.31234827637672424,
-0.7500625848770142,
-0.3720724880695343,
0.039604101330041885,
0.1057601273059845,
0.22969454526901245,
0.4738585650920868,
-0.5534918308258057,
0.8479413390159607,
0.67629474401474,
0.7185987830162048,
0.39472028613090515,
-0.09112847596406937,
0.7305363416671753,
-0.209489643573761,
-0.005703370552510023,
0.25962185859680176,
0.49300163984298706,
0.20868173241615295,
-0.23330573737621307,
0.32954540848731995,
-0.22597719728946686,
-0.7160953283309937,
-0.6698053479194641,
0.13588856160640717,
-1.302690029144287,
-0.22026939690113068,
1.2545404434204102,
-0.10979749262332916,
-0.14894753694534302,
-0.5082893371582031,
-0.5664617419242859,
0.32008665800094604,
-0.44096261262893677,
0.653852105140686,
0.6844626665115356,
-0.23486873507499695,
-0.345040500164032,
-0.7614467740058899,
0.11420196294784546,
0.41526493430137634,
-0.8056477308273315,
-0.056757546961307526,
0.5516237616539001,
0.16188471019268036,
0.08546977490186691,
0.35319116711616516,
-0.1361236572265625,
0.7173424363136292,
-0.18260060250759125,
-0.06937984377145767,
-0.6998202204704285,
-0.6080870032310486,
-0.40301868319511414,
0.36462700366973877,
0.18249796330928802,
-0.3261429965496063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11939v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11939v1 | From Crowdsourced Data to High-Quality Benchmarks: Arena-Hard and BenchBuilder Pipeline | 2024-06-17T17:26:10 | 2024-06-17T17:26:10 | Tianle Li, Wei-Lin Chiang, Evan Frick, Lisa Dunlap, Tianhao Wu, Banghua Zhu, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Ion Stoica | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The rapid evolution of language models has necessitated the development of
more challenging benchmarks. Current static benchmarks often struggle to
consistently distinguish between the capabilities of different models and fail
to align with real-world user preferences. On the other hand, live
crowd-sourced platforms like the Chatbot Arena collect a wide range of natural
prompts and user feedback. However, these prompts vary in sophistication and
the feedback cannot be applied offline to new models. In order to ensure that
benchmarks keep up with the pace of LLM development, we address how one can
evaluate benchmarks on their ability to confidently separate models and their
alignment with human preference. Under these principles, we developed
BenchBuilder, a living benchmark that filters high-quality prompts from live
data sources to enable offline evaluation on fresh, challenging prompts.
BenchBuilder identifies seven indicators of a high-quality prompt, such as the
requirement for domain knowledge, and utilizes an LLM annotator to select a
high-quality subset of prompts from various topic clusters. The LLM evaluation
process employs an LLM judge to ensure a fully automated, high-quality, and
constantly updating benchmark. We apply BenchBuilder on prompts from the
Chatbot Arena to create Arena-Hard-Auto v0.1: 500 challenging user prompts from
a wide range of tasks. Arena-Hard-Auto v0.1 offers 3x tighter confidence
intervals than MT-Bench and achieves a state-of-the-art 89.1% agreement with
human preference rankings, all at a cost of only $25 and without human
labelers. The BenchBuilder pipeline enhances evaluation benchmarks and provides
a valuable tool for developers, enabling them to extract high-quality
benchmarks from extensive data with minimal effort. | [
-0.4941112995147705,
-0.5170242190361023,
0.3669779598712921,
0.33045694231987,
0.0713716670870781,
0.34899964928627014,
-0.37707531452178955,
-0.33977174758911133,
-0.23796427249908447,
0.4660157561302185,
-0.5256634950637817,
-0.42169061303138733,
-0.3880043923854828,
0.15412168204784393,
-0.22302210330963135,
0.7450481057167053,
-0.10238980501890182,
-0.05784831568598747,
-0.6433696150779724,
-0.26476576924324036,
-0.42092594504356384,
-0.5654367804527283,
-0.42262181639671326,
-0.2938280701637268,
0.4476263225078583,
0.42367440462112427,
0.8188049793243408,
0.9534962773323059,
0.4435514211654663,
0.3679100275039673,
0.061339251697063446,
0.06506207585334778,
-0.7453677654266357,
0.3216121792793274,
-0.08856049180030823,
-0.313625693321228,
-0.29501697421073914,
0.12735819816589355,
0.37972670793533325,
0.46816694736480713,
-0.3455791473388672,
0.3891820013523102,
0.19596132636070251,
0.5820673108100891,
-0.5560837388038635,
0.32189059257507324,
-0.5699152946472168,
-0.12334130704402924,
-0.4332888722419739,
0.01757500134408474,
-0.2739734351634979,
-0.5254722237586975,
-0.27999308705329895,
-0.5656664967536926,
0.21578757464885712,
0.212908536195755,
0.9921621084213257,
0.5085841417312622,
-0.14489808678627014,
0.10693530738353729,
-0.44800707697868347,
0.7255424857139587,
-0.43417888879776,
0.6206386089324951,
0.37111029028892517,
0.781796932220459,
-0.32240286469459534,
-0.8432008624076843,
-0.41197913885116577,
-0.24472643435001373,
0.1370960772037506,
0.04544275626540184,
-0.3497406244277954,
-0.2658185064792633,
0.15680111944675446,
0.1316550076007843,
-0.47084325551986694,
0.32483574748039246,
-0.259831964969635,
-0.30072319507598877,
0.8098852038383484,
0.2850419580936432,
-0.11437729746103287,
-0.42030203342437744,
-0.43843790888786316,
-0.3983214497566223,
-0.667985200881958,
0.17322589457035065,
0.28239941596984863,
0.14524495601654053,
0.14763787388801575,
0.36056604981422424,
-0.5063159465789795,
0.5669260621070862,
0.1895247846841812,
-0.15828534960746765,
0.30635589361190796,
0.01669500209391117,
-0.04484739527106285,
-0.32846465706825256,
0.9128223061561584,
0.5108425617218018,
0.1153998151421547,
-0.4129783511161804,
-0.25975701212882996,
0.17692877352237701,
0.23529987037181854,
-0.7214085459709167,
-0.05316435173153877,
0.4600379765033722,
-0.46644479036331177,
-0.269418329000473,
-0.18331706523895264,
-0.7242673635482788,
-0.7336405515670776,
-0.3977015018463135,
0.1461647003889084,
-0.11134326457977295,
-0.12659235298633575,
-0.29117509722709656,
-0.068411685526371,
0.048075854778289795,
0.40138792991638184,
-0.6787920594215393,
0.4013017416000366,
0.986515998840332,
0.505377471446991,
-0.45702168345451355,
-0.3607003092765808,
-0.9546491503715515,
-0.17234516143798828,
-0.1309560239315033,
1.2444438934326172,
-0.5861924886703491,
-0.3981499671936035,
0.010624822229146957,
-0.04336297884583473,
0.3285817801952362,
-1.0028746128082275,
0.7280700206756592,
-0.3537890315055847,
0.15978595614433289,
-0.24379992485046387,
-0.7466198801994324,
0.26490694284439087,
0.24244913458824158,
-0.4882427155971527,
1.3158026933670044,
0.3155951201915741,
-0.09487146139144897,
0.639654278755188,
-0.42628946900367737,
-0.03737282380461693,
0.5529211759567261,
-0.3388817310333252,
-0.14447639882564545,
0.0830511525273323,
0.2902460992336273,
0.47426271438598633,
-0.5736140012741089,
0.6019241213798523,
-0.496200293302536,
-0.18431662023067474,
0.4715558588504791,
-0.3955288827419281,
0.490454763174057,
0.3787175416946411,
-0.3891116678714752,
0.3482009768486023,
-0.9041305780410767,
0.24838116765022278,
-0.20879781246185303,
-0.3812822699546814,
0.1550966203212738,
0.17595210671424866,
0.29178303480148315,
0.3431639075279236,
0.04991338029503822,
-0.38481202721595764,
0.012989810667932034,
-0.08484973758459091,
0.3130370080471039,
0.8472839593887329,
-0.0986076071858406,
0.1618780940771103,
-0.4850756525993347,
0.6045787334442139,
-0.4567912220954895,
0.23772726953029633,
0.24141065776348114,
-0.42434224486351013,
-0.5914990901947021,
-0.40763285756111145,
0.46230578422546387,
0.5289093852043152,
-0.3410685062408447,
0.5353601574897766,
-0.22675740718841553,
-0.8725824356079102,
-1.214540719985962,
0.5870071053504944,
0.3873558044433594,
0.501450777053833,
0.24901896715164185,
-0.5036534070968628,
-0.49025779962539673,
-0.8020762801170349,
-0.29203489422798157,
-0.318006306886673,
-0.3914155066013336,
0.569642186164856,
-0.02143595740199089,
-0.04643293842673302,
1.0945754051208496,
-0.3364858031272888,
-0.1584164947271347,
-0.08123663812875748,
0.4288943409919739,
0.3054778277873993,
0.3098965585231781,
0.1578684002161026,
-0.5586033463478088,
-0.5717364549636841,
-0.22971247136592865,
-0.7294160723686218,
-0.5761417150497437,
0.14379510283470154,
-0.20828476548194885,
-0.027310866862535477,
0.4894774258136749,
-0.6139144897460938,
0.17455433309078217,
0.4929560422897339,
-0.11723876744508743,
0.32976603507995605,
0.01847224496304989,
0.15782849490642548,
-0.8606537580490112,
0.14904503524303436,
-0.03815896064043045,
-0.2938888967037201,
-0.1995178908109665,
0.1841438114643097,
0.08170995861291885,
-0.18719640374183655,
-0.5205467939376831,
0.9458289742469788,
-0.412747323513031,
-0.09878822416067123,
-0.2188912183046341,
0.3965112864971161,
0.022890863940119743,
0.3486630320549011,
0.009399104863405228,
0.6859239935874939,
0.30750635266304016,
-0.3403899073600769,
0.7064831256866455,
0.39200565218925476,
-0.645758330821991,
0.7780442237854004,
-0.7753995060920715,
0.164367213845253,
0.12638990581035614,
0.2731417119503021,
-0.983453094959259,
-0.30595389008522034,
0.1214248538017273,
-0.4498724639415741,
0.013862308114767075,
-0.2900012135505676,
-0.817253589630127,
-0.3186039924621582,
-0.17653332650661469,
-0.12072249501943588,
0.8101191520690918,
-0.5068894624710083,
0.34802308678627014,
0.5322527885437012,
-0.2739327847957611,
-0.36054345965385437,
-0.22727589309215546,
0.11062092334032059,
-0.09202806651592255,
-0.6725877523422241,
0.22584646940231323,
-0.282663494348526,
-0.49270302057266235,
-0.0990065485239029,
0.0009444562601856887,
-0.09948853403329849,
0.2136935144662857,
0.6301930546760559,
0.3201777935028076,
-0.09819825738668442,
0.15439628064632416,
-0.35142165422439575,
-0.41569650173187256,
0.11608904600143433,
0.04318688437342644,
0.40576502680778503,
-0.051764532923698425,
-0.37960705161094666,
-0.28444814682006836,
-0.027353469282388687,
0.43731147050857544,
-0.33398592472076416,
0.38754943013191223,
0.6200003623962402,
-0.17872989177703857,
0.0649334043264389,
-1.0816365480422974,
-0.0693824514746666,
-0.476839154958725,
0.164920374751091,
-0.3574697971343994,
-0.857347309589386,
0.4854393005371094,
-0.23357729613780975,
0.1748284101486206,
0.4283086061477661,
0.6867573261260986,
-0.06816840171813965,
1.0614124536514282,
0.12687110900878906,
-0.13985119760036469,
0.17874783277511597,
0.16999350488185883,
-0.34449243545532227,
-0.7263407707214355,
-0.1884300708770752,
-0.7516306042671204,
-0.40268710255622864,
-0.5638923645019531,
-0.5787416100502014,
0.255725622177124,
0.1390034705400467,
-0.06151224672794342,
0.2832840383052826,
-0.5219662189483643,
0.6118813157081604,
0.5226951241493225,
-0.014070005156099796,
0.25509995222091675,
-0.2042493224143982,
-0.03834157809615135,
-0.1689170002937317,
-0.535368800163269,
-0.6230266690254211,
1.0411295890808105,
0.33873850107192993,
0.6475784778594971,
0.12200149148702621,
0.6761472225189209,
0.3470713198184967,
0.8272855877876282,
-0.42979687452316284,
0.5253880620002747,
0.21480032801628113,
-1.0329325199127197,
-0.34749868512153625,
-0.41992315649986267,
-0.9964223504066467,
0.23433604836463928,
-0.38863325119018555,
-0.8006957769393921,
0.26926109194755554,
0.0029154601506888866,
-0.35271185636520386,
0.04766838997602463,
-0.6095444560050964,
1.0716403722763062,
-0.21439719200134277,
-0.9137817621231079,
-0.027243921533226967,
-0.5704765319824219,
0.0614292174577713,
-0.10587747395038605,
0.38628628849983215,
-0.5219814777374268,
-0.052709415555000305,
0.5230867266654968,
-0.7198581099510193,
0.7105382680892944,
-0.22688457369804382,
0.10023307800292969,
0.37837064266204834,
0.08123025298118591,
0.6953421831130981,
0.2324417233467102,
-0.44592052698135376,
0.060137368738651276,
-0.16208495199680328,
-0.46938273310661316,
-0.5170803666114807,
0.8152040243148804,
-0.920387327671051,
-0.7091051936149597,
-0.23467819392681122,
-0.32923007011413574,
-0.5169864892959595,
0.02771158330142498,
0.12161719053983688,
0.38122332096099854,
-0.4269580543041229,
0.35482004284858704,
0.31226393580436707,
-0.03581599146127701,
0.2747829854488373,
0.6879806518554688,
-0.3132765293121338,
-0.5229229927062988,
0.7386257648468018,
-0.07053679972887039,
0.06407865136861801,
0.35808831453323364,
0.08905325084924698,
-0.46442532539367676,
-0.40094876289367676,
-0.6436010599136353,
-0.018008854240179062,
-0.5309258103370667,
-0.37322959303855896,
-0.5171471238136292,
-0.05925661325454712,
-0.31120890378952026,
-0.2195856124162674,
-0.4711168110370636,
-0.29221659898757935,
-0.09509792178869247,
-0.12772472202777863,
0.3931509554386139,
0.4400508403778076,
-0.09746767580509186,
-0.010158959776163101,
-0.8991310596466064,
0.22215251624584198,
0.5589955449104309,
0.4744885563850403,
-0.144813671708107,
-0.42536747455596924,
-0.021738236770033836,
-0.19353897869586945,
-0.25015223026275635,
-0.5514750480651855,
0.4005674123764038,
-0.0866791158914566,
0.7961571216583252,
0.30673521757125854,
0.153065025806427,
0.7366099953651428,
-0.3782249689102173,
0.5695701241493225,
-0.028766287490725517,
-0.8363195657730103,
0.3671538829803467,
-0.34278807044029236,
0.420909583568573,
1.0672104358673096,
0.32967355847358704,
-0.4686757028102875,
-0.42006924748420715,
-0.6028300523757935,
-0.7024878859519958,
0.5897215008735657,
0.19124354422092438,
-0.017891662195324898,
-0.09186822175979614,
0.03744998201727867,
0.3635948598384857,
0.2752738296985626,
-0.4197298586368561,
-0.16880583763122559,
-0.25672802329063416,
0.02550266869366169,
-0.22303995490074158,
-0.1037052571773529,
-0.17930400371551514,
-0.09698345512151718,
0.46097734570503235,
-0.05546106770634651,
-0.1123303696513176,
-0.2498074322938919,
-0.1973319947719574,
-0.35245281457901,
0.5680574178695679,
0.0436028428375721,
0.8791425824165344,
-0.5173636674880981,
-0.0894232988357544,
0.3169364035129547,
-0.04085048288106918,
0.18134865164756775,
0.6315845847129822,
-0.010410793125629425,
0.028036361560225487,
0.2496906965970993,
0.7617636919021606,
0.5347796678543091,
-0.8884758353233337,
0.493579238653183,
-0.06723517179489136,
-0.10681003332138062,
-0.03812621161341667,
0.1608215868473053,
0.26407602429389954,
0.27336180210113525,
0.5215336084365845,
0.0037274775095283985,
-0.028038471937179565,
-0.428985059261322,
0.19412429630756378,
0.17040283977985382,
-0.6080211997032166,
-0.19508051872253418,
0.8416455388069153,
0.6581848859786987,
-0.5207306742668152,
0.6097493171691895,
-0.2089572250843048,
-0.12417345494031906,
0.3649802803993225,
0.08600600808858871,
0.8979697227478027,
-0.174295574426651,
0.27192243933677673,
0.2334754765033722,
-0.051972340792417526,
-0.004133625887334347,
0.14496490359306335,
-0.1579543501138687,
-0.4706210792064667,
-0.2980441451072693,
-0.6644413471221924,
-0.8158687949180603,
0.014395630918443203,
-0.6422642469406128,
0.4157969355583191,
-0.5274752378463745,
-0.26132261753082275,
0.15532097220420837,
0.10359477251768112,
-0.9119957089424133,
0.14216166734695435,
0.09225445985794067,
0.937410295009613,
-0.4419972896575928,
0.5411213636398315,
0.5594316720962524,
-0.42621830105781555,
-0.7452970147132874,
-0.39552298188209534,
0.3712272644042969,
-0.9728231430053711,
0.5627423524856567,
-0.0014267211081460118,
0.3701937794685364,
0.033793263137340546,
-0.6361615061759949,
-0.7805353403091431,
1.1029913425445557,
0.2738020122051239,
-0.7597015500068665,
0.25914543867111206,
-0.00029807613464072347,
0.7027752995491028,
-0.3248608112335205,
0.49903014302253723,
0.2899560332298279,
0.5926129817962646,
0.1529395431280136,
-0.982019305229187,
0.10301587730646133,
-0.3760104775428772,
-0.2069367915391922,
0.23803839087486267,
-0.8927667737007141,
0.4953809082508087,
0.15596503019332886,
-0.1590399593114853,
-0.0208576750010252,
0.5597348809242249,
0.6223017573356628,
0.37651950120925903,
0.4548450708389282,
0.42741522192955017,
0.7318703532218933,
-0.18665744364261627,
1.093082070350647,
-0.5690146684646606,
0.06558017432689667,
1.1006356477737427,
-0.7070306539535522,
1.3159455060958862,
0.2975248098373413,
-0.3997052311897278,
0.6221128106117249,
0.634471595287323,
-0.3406717777252197,
0.297768771648407,
0.48102420568466187,
-0.11455415189266205,
-0.48581644892692566,
-0.4122520387172699,
-0.46060553193092346,
0.3945741057395935,
-0.0755721852183342,
-0.031876590102910995,
-0.12473411858081818,
-0.3091524839401245,
0.04261326417326927,
0.21061120927333832,
0.016312766820192337,
0.8569879531860352,
-0.10070352256298065,
-1.0208234786987305,
0.6717777848243713,
-0.1032932847738266,
0.4970545172691345,
-0.568152666091919,
0.2052689790725708,
-0.5025087594985962,
0.1787184476852417,
-0.16438664495944977,
-0.6113585829734802,
-0.17646434903144836,
0.293032705783844,
-0.022448288276791573,
-0.5759068727493286,
0.6676781177520752,
-0.13815058767795563,
-0.42099815607070923,
0.12515756487846375,
0.8156598210334778,
0.3851659297943115,
-0.21696509420871735,
-0.7274376153945923,
0.42726850509643555,
-0.28167885541915894,
-0.24014508724212646,
0.4142044484615326,
0.4988539516925812,
0.007839947007596493,
0.7659741640090942,
0.769465982913971,
-0.044196490198373795,
-0.23227858543395996,
0.22482331097126007,
0.9528779983520508,
-0.6504539251327515,
-0.23426048457622528,
-0.6203821301460266,
0.570991575717926,
-0.2720184326171875,
-0.5797257423400879,
0.7221033573150635,
0.7789092063903809,
0.6438591480255127,
0.14613845944404602,
0.689910352230072,
0.027176592499017715,
0.807446300983429,
-0.1707623302936554,
0.8088241219520569,
-0.39489349722862244,
0.36172667145729065,
-0.2668122947216034,
-1.1489195823669434,
-0.03638419508934021,
0.18304051458835602,
-0.16673977673053741,
-0.009798833169043064,
0.4563228189945221,
0.8381355404853821,
0.09118512272834778,
-0.1646348237991333,
0.22262568771839142,
0.13932083547115326,
0.21949291229248047,
0.41369232535362244,
0.9799460768699646,
-0.28928226232528687,
0.9581164717674255,
-0.08879012614488602,
-0.3515531122684479,
-0.37430447340011597,
-0.9356394410133362,
-0.8739619851112366,
-0.43688496947288513,
-0.4786006510257721,
-0.4180239140987396,
0.10756145417690277,
1.0989210605621338,
1.0426706075668335,
-0.8212999105453491,
-0.5342497825622559,
0.16622118651866913,
0.15203702449798584,
-0.28993844985961914,
-0.28275448083877563,
0.07320952415466309,
-0.31669309735298157,
-0.5923791527748108,
0.5221214890480042,
0.2586604654788971,
-0.2669118344783783,
-0.4355173707008362,
-0.29938453435897827,
0.057943228632211685,
0.020209910348057747,
0.3219013512134552,
0.4610500633716583,
-0.8102058172225952,
-0.17155031859874725,
0.21994894742965698,
-0.38884007930755615,
0.2079298049211502,
0.361957848072052,
-1.1523571014404297,
0.4759579598903656,
0.3615817725658417,
0.6967226266860962,
0.6752051711082458,
0.2560234069824219,
0.7227397561073303,
-0.6541001200675964,
-0.19566687941551208,
0.11362407356500626,
0.09021275490522385,
0.596956193447113,
-0.03649556264281273,
0.7777355909347534,
0.20362623035907745,
-0.6587952375411987,
-0.9071627259254456,
-0.11918499320745468,
-0.8470021486282349,
-0.011514797806739807,
1.0802234411239624,
-0.0012368523748591542,
-0.2553732097148895,
-0.16074593365192413,
-0.24190357327461243,
-0.04623439908027649,
-0.6466098427772522,
1.0855351686477661,
0.9118801951408386,
-0.15289075672626495,
-0.29029327630996704,
-0.4486836791038513,
0.5726408958435059,
0.33952823281288147,
-1.0916383266448975,
0.2177812159061432,
0.6173871159553528,
0.13049724698066711,
0.06721436232328415,
0.5502073168754578,
-0.02639768272638321,
0.3024550974369049,
0.09917444735765457,
0.20131151378154755,
-0.16535347700119019,
0.09289328753948212,
0.022000910714268684,
0.440313458442688,
0.32479986548423767,
0.15442462265491486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11757v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11757v1 | STAR: SocioTechnical Approach to Red Teaming Language Models | 2024-06-17T17:16:45 | 2024-06-17T17:16:45 | Laura Weidinger, John Mellor, Bernat Guillen Pegueroles, Nahema Marchal, Ravin Kumar, Kristian Lum, Canfer Akbulut, Mark Diaz, Stevie Bergman, Mikel Rodriguez, Verena Rieser, William Isaac | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | This research introduces STAR, a sociotechnical framework that improves on
current best practices for red teaming safety of large language models. STAR
makes two key contributions: it enhances steerability by generating
parameterised instructions for human red teamers, leading to improved coverage
of the risk surface. Parameterised instructions also provide more detailed
insights into model failures at no increased cost. Second, STAR improves signal
quality by matching demographics to assess harms for specific groups, resulting
in more sensitive annotations. STAR further employs a novel step of arbitration
to leverage diverse viewpoints and improve label reliability, treating
disagreement not as noise but as a valuable contribution to signal quality. | [
-0.21315549314022064,
-0.6980273127555847,
0.2499893307685852,
0.24888668954372406,
0.18427115678787231,
0.4400935471057892,
-0.29167670011520386,
-0.9504732489585876,
0.4221820831298828,
0.48504579067230225,
-0.38842374086380005,
-0.542701244354248,
-0.6960833668708801,
-0.0862460806965828,
-0.20224355161190033,
1.1402153968811035,
0.1906912624835968,
0.08530096709728241,
0.16891831159591675,
0.011356102302670479,
-0.4209105372428894,
-0.6576915979385376,
-0.7125548720359802,
-0.14464281499385834,
0.7031328678131104,
0.7692694067955017,
1.0646008253097534,
0.6696556806564331,
0.9074543714523315,
0.3210815191268921,
-0.2675403654575348,
-0.3137529194355011,
-0.5456804037094116,
0.19730165600776672,
-0.12594176828861237,
-0.32900378108024597,
-0.592343270778656,
0.1253574639558792,
0.3197970390319824,
0.9380063414573669,
-0.026935109868645668,
0.2706032991409302,
0.12620016932487488,
0.699026882648468,
-0.6786899566650391,
0.32651209831237793,
-0.4283738434314728,
-0.29807913303375244,
-0.07663149386644363,
-0.2619583308696747,
-0.5380749702453613,
-0.19614945352077484,
0.006342227570712566,
-0.568695604801178,
0.09269348531961441,
0.10938407480716705,
0.8347926139831543,
0.23172779381275177,
-0.267323762178421,
-0.06228146329522133,
-0.9762619137763977,
0.7081003189086914,
-0.3935767114162445,
0.37450462579727173,
0.4862336814403534,
0.9466785192489624,
0.059420812875032425,
-0.5698660016059875,
-0.25678426027297974,
-0.15424120426177979,
-0.096538245677948,
0.19337302446365356,
0.12382201850414276,
0.470507949590683,
-0.06652247160673141,
-0.24634592235088348,
-0.33581238985061646,
0.3369123041629791,
-0.6780830025672913,
-0.3080451786518097,
1.058794617652893,
-0.02418683096766472,
0.3817540407180786,
-0.232110857963562,
-0.48376986384391785,
-0.17329825460910797,
-0.7240555882453918,
0.005099761765450239,
0.4976198375225067,
0.5775948166847229,
-0.5126796960830688,
0.2486330270767212,
-0.4358614683151245,
0.6120898127555847,
-0.11344131827354431,
0.048035960644483566,
0.045242469757795334,
-0.5083416104316711,
-0.01853279024362564,
0.1404956728219986,
0.5381068587303162,
0.8200302720069885,
0.37432876229286194,
-0.19712583720684052,
-0.23779964447021484,
0.4503997564315796,
0.2350974977016449,
-0.2986060082912445,
-0.5620185136795044,
0.38125693798065186,
-0.43703335523605347,
-0.6344404816627502,
-0.024931704625487328,
-0.8309542536735535,
-0.39488548040390015,
-0.4307662546634674,
0.3467184603214264,
-0.3465025722980499,
-0.4923202395439148,
0.11512494832277298,
-0.08091741055250168,
0.23762354254722595,
0.2871477007865906,
-0.9278851747512817,
0.18291863799095154,
0.788926899433136,
0.4732620120048523,
0.29493165016174316,
-0.3995032012462616,
-0.8366666436195374,
0.209324449300766,
-0.38415834307670593,
0.9968549013137817,
-0.680833637714386,
-0.21660517156124115,
-0.06361201405525208,
-0.2815026044845581,
-0.023842841386795044,
-0.2877595126628876,
0.062187086790800095,
-0.5355797410011292,
-0.015493779443204403,
-0.2293093204498291,
-0.12164537608623505,
-0.24486318230628967,
-0.022608401253819466,
-0.4335251450538635,
0.7988888025283813,
0.14965543150901794,
-0.5590135455131531,
0.7993307113647461,
-0.9912380576133728,
-0.3057049512863159,
0.5444265604019165,
0.03879380598664284,
-0.16633747518062592,
-0.29651349782943726,
-0.1599906086921692,
0.7301748394966125,
0.04637903347611427,
0.23286192119121552,
-0.44091275334358215,
-0.27911490201950073,
0.012685642577707767,
0.3117488622665405,
0.6960751414299011,
0.32670581340789795,
-0.3182086944580078,
0.9075060486793518,
-0.4571390748023987,
0.049234628677368164,
-0.18389783799648285,
-0.11863769590854645,
-0.384172648191452,
0.18607687950134277,
0.6652612686157227,
0.2807163596153259,
-0.1143789067864418,
-0.5531287789344788,
-0.33268827199935913,
-0.2048148810863495,
0.6925345659255981,
0.636073112487793,
0.09673557430505753,
0.5613493919372559,
-0.28051429986953735,
0.46407121419906616,
-0.31416764855384827,
0.7070214152336121,
0.19373878836631775,
-0.3388327360153198,
-0.6692148447036743,
-0.3232351541519165,
0.44389984011650085,
0.5574700236320496,
-1.0050268173217773,
0.4082648754119873,
0.012273212894797325,
-0.7330902814865112,
-0.39409229159355164,
-0.06862973421812057,
0.6856666803359985,
0.2947034537792206,
0.3085373044013977,
0.12750038504600525,
-0.8559814095497131,
-1.1219508647918701,
0.0012442131992429495,
-0.5186127424240112,
0.41062211990356445,
0.13003937900066376,
0.6002989411354065,
-0.5507686138153076,
0.7021234631538391,
-0.058664657175540924,
-0.08024396747350693,
-0.6560737490653992,
-0.08671906590461731,
0.02633388340473175,
0.5055593848228455,
0.5414590239524841,
-0.920539379119873,
-0.6507256627082825,
0.16420705616474152,
-0.8949913382530212,
-0.015506207942962646,
-0.05409013479948044,
-0.19732800126075745,
0.5501970648765564,
0.6276799440383911,
-0.17896868288516998,
0.25041958689689636,
0.9494391083717346,
-0.8541956543922424,
0.7112956047058105,
0.09215917438268661,
0.37685537338256836,
-0.9199187755584717,
0.09901335090398788,
0.4606339633464813,
-0.31107792258262634,
-0.9228195548057556,
0.4874584972858429,
-0.046975068747997284,
-0.19419611990451813,
-0.6715997457504272,
0.3983626365661621,
-0.37178537249565125,
-0.12550310790538788,
-0.2314532846212387,
0.27101197838783264,
-0.502616286277771,
0.13555724918842316,
0.12904483079910278,
0.823018491268158,
0.6028226017951965,
-0.759608805179596,
0.12784549593925476,
0.09337300062179565,
-0.16392745077610016,
0.5539982914924622,
-0.8727251291275024,
-0.2721603512763977,
-0.13507352769374847,
-0.05461826175451279,
-0.9738619923591614,
-0.4384615421295166,
0.24503585696220398,
-0.7267776727676392,
0.30003345012664795,
-0.08892372995615005,
-0.5164843201637268,
-0.05129623040556908,
-0.21318167448043823,
0.3172343373298645,
0.6341883540153503,
-0.23770923912525177,
0.17793145775794983,
1.069602608680725,
-0.33483579754829407,
-0.3753490447998047,
-0.2119314819574356,
0.3094540238380432,
-0.2984530031681061,
-0.7910115718841553,
0.23151002824306488,
0.11417593061923981,
-0.708964467048645,
-0.045414555817842484,
0.16702575981616974,
-0.25587597489356995,
0.4289238452911377,
0.08546192198991776,
0.44726279377937317,
-0.11667437106370926,
0.09197328239679337,
-0.3008911907672882,
-0.5738829374313354,
0.07281311601400375,
0.20004095137119293,
0.4593876600265503,
-0.34163182973861694,
0.15567491948604584,
-0.5843420624732971,
0.5957551598548889,
0.4938511252403259,
-0.18317122757434845,
0.8998623490333557,
0.37729567289352417,
-0.3367142379283905,
-0.23071680963039398,
-0.4575536847114563,
-0.5148914456367493,
-0.4994768798351288,
0.5297584533691406,
-0.042596351355314255,
-0.9225150346755981,
0.492622435092926,
0.1501004695892334,
0.2011885941028595,
0.5065861344337463,
0.27357906103134155,
-0.6347124576568604,
0.7057574987411499,
1.0804688930511475,
0.0037591056898236275,
0.3175182342529297,
0.029318762943148613,
0.003154451260343194,
-0.517220139503479,
-0.28892451524734497,
-0.6276679635047913,
-0.2921282649040222,
-0.2735126316547394,
-0.33176085352897644,
0.5646565556526184,
0.28897395730018616,
-0.3851858675479889,
0.6399729251861572,
-0.7648565769195557,
0.3462655246257782,
0.32688283920288086,
0.1480838656425476,
0.11218580603599548,
-0.2722717225551605,
0.19394861161708832,
-0.07881831377744675,
-1.1874667406082153,
-0.7560540437698364,
0.7679787278175354,
0.7734563946723938,
0.6971864700317383,
0.3600144386291504,
0.8074936270713806,
0.3912374973297119,
0.5897526741027832,
-0.5431721210479736,
0.6477109789848328,
0.20309342443943024,
-0.8401301503181458,
-0.49260571599006653,
-0.3643057644367218,
-0.8330145478248596,
-0.041106924414634705,
-0.710820734500885,
-0.7098817229270935,
-0.018283629789948463,
0.45594340562820435,
-0.37172865867614746,
0.09719522297382355,
-0.9433138370513916,
0.8034043312072754,
-0.19520190358161926,
-0.2934485673904419,
-0.27376440167427063,
-0.6597371101379395,
0.3994266390800476,
0.07168291509151459,
0.49285003542900085,
0.09646319597959518,
-0.011422669515013695,
1.1533935070037842,
-0.28248536586761475,
1.4641128778457642,
-0.20985981822013855,
0.17809607088565826,
0.19336628913879395,
0.1294650137424469,
0.47899335622787476,
0.001199948019348085,
0.028492901474237442,
0.37383121252059937,
0.06799470633268356,
-0.4645713269710541,
-0.31289923191070557,
0.464968740940094,
-0.7136372327804565,
-0.5939953923225403,
-0.37685516476631165,
-0.6226807832717896,
-0.14258058369159698,
0.003881314769387245,
0.013588021509349346,
0.13098013401031494,
0.15313921868801117,
0.3172779083251953,
0.36020737886428833,
-0.29279544949531555,
0.5002215504646301,
0.46710893511772156,
-0.1482759267091751,
-0.4559127688407898,
0.6648389101028442,
-0.11479546874761581,
0.607337236404419,
0.17293989658355713,
-0.09253837168216705,
-0.3725813329219818,
-0.658331573009491,
-0.2404417097568512,
0.40016886591911316,
-0.9397046566009521,
-0.14478473365306854,
-0.5513864159584045,
-0.3213530480861664,
-0.29988378286361694,
-0.5639147758483887,
-0.6484413146972656,
-0.4716271460056305,
0.1769166737794876,
-0.20831730961799622,
0.5719195604324341,
0.9635225534439087,
-0.009557561948895454,
0.31880998611450195,
-0.9160752892494202,
-0.08295853435993195,
-0.08186538517475128,
0.5722827315330505,
-0.3946562111377716,
-0.16916421055793762,
-0.452522337436676,
-0.12985029816627502,
0.17698146402835846,
-0.9398108124732971,
0.15882007777690887,
-0.1630299985408783,
1.0077766180038452,
-0.12066315859556198,
0.2702762484550476,
0.40230488777160645,
-0.3562067151069641,
0.7214778661727905,
0.5718439221382141,
-0.9732544422149658,
0.8316433429718018,
-0.7748984694480896,
-0.20153000950813293,
0.563645601272583,
0.3223873972892761,
-0.6064515113830566,
-0.37911689281463623,
-0.7576954960823059,
-0.8282192349433899,
0.39621487259864807,
0.22297492623329163,
-0.3794947564601898,
-0.06950007379055023,
0.35057827830314636,
-0.07326555252075195,
-0.23777979612350464,
-0.6184423565864563,
-0.2678912878036499,
-0.029992850497364998,
-0.06576617062091827,
-0.5404695272445679,
-0.4138052761554718,
-0.3303799629211426,
0.11462803930044174,
0.5502468347549438,
-0.1146831139922142,
0.28314754366874695,
0.09179647266864777,
-0.047048330307006836,
-0.19687455892562866,
0.12881705164909363,
0.6881912350654602,
0.7727386951446533,
-0.036307819187641144,
0.09544827044010162,
0.17013148963451385,
-0.16773374378681183,
0.08015494048595428,
-0.0976952314376831,
-0.05653321370482445,
-0.19276607036590576,
0.8455427885055542,
0.3641178011894226,
0.6646842360496521,
-0.45588475465774536,
0.20680168271064758,
0.365695059299469,
-0.5286279916763306,
-0.2258717268705368,
0.384166419506073,
-0.08700764179229736,
0.32729730010032654,
0.16962984204292297,
0.3878946602344513,
-0.084662526845932,
-0.5987039804458618,
0.6502830386161804,
0.3078307807445526,
-0.9009755849838257,
-0.46334800124168396,
0.9104738831520081,
0.92976975440979,
-0.6497734189033508,
-0.08539628237485886,
0.10444363206624985,
-0.5514360666275024,
0.7120648622512817,
0.27995726466178894,
0.7198891639709473,
-0.22312813997268677,
0.5278639197349548,
0.4254438877105713,
0.47255438566207886,
0.016218625009059906,
0.3083799481391907,
0.2195766419172287,
-0.6299797296524048,
-0.7407147288322449,
-0.3761902451515198,
-0.6016405820846558,
-0.3456214368343353,
-0.550554096698761,
0.13139481842517853,
-0.6889604330062866,
-0.19632944464683533,
0.08856477588415146,
-0.1799035221338272,
-0.3198786973953247,
0.18448352813720703,
0.03493686765432358,
0.9041581749916077,
-0.9990948438644409,
0.6972889304161072,
1.0143417119979858,
-0.46044275164604187,
-0.811863124370575,
-0.2196057289838791,
0.22876179218292236,
-0.5120484232902527,
1.2955321073532104,
-0.08519741892814636,
-0.19478780031204224,
-0.11589276045560837,
-0.20725256204605103,
-0.8357322812080383,
1.0346033573150635,
0.13270537555217743,
-0.4941599369049072,
0.2581084668636322,
-0.11368003487586975,
0.5499550104141235,
-0.27888986468315125,
0.04379156976938248,
0.17958316206932068,
0.550207257270813,
-0.005814799107611179,
-1.2237653732299805,
0.13153088092803955,
-0.29317134618759155,
-0.17000271379947662,
0.18946857750415802,
-0.6178088188171387,
0.5573132038116455,
-0.3912438154220581,
-0.4083360731601715,
-0.3575488030910492,
0.56712406873703,
0.3174040913581848,
0.09932903200387955,
0.6693097352981567,
-0.22317910194396973,
0.5675000548362732,
0.07568112760782242,
1.3228155374526978,
-0.5401753187179565,
0.3397061824798584,
0.6279900670051575,
-0.2874542474746704,
0.9126868844032288,
0.48552533984184265,
-0.13402725756168365,
0.15232524275779724,
0.6232932806015015,
0.31621628999710083,
0.22402481734752655,
-0.07786121964454651,
-0.04042743146419525,
-0.590245246887207,
-0.0013404939090833068,
-0.3904734253883362,
0.5938814878463745,
0.08777794241905212,
-0.25856420397758484,
-0.1786189079284668,
-0.220467209815979,
0.03399742394685745,
0.6683305501937866,
-0.3142777383327484,
0.6106665730476379,
-0.13873976469039917,
-0.6741141080856323,
0.5389775633811951,
-0.020916316658258438,
0.7177091240882874,
-0.3180607855319977,
-0.15283328294754028,
0.05315617099404335,
0.2189573496580124,
-0.4037090539932251,
-0.9855248332023621,
0.6671273708343506,
-0.10199722647666931,
-0.26877009868621826,
-0.19878050684928894,
0.7438589930534363,
-0.1887969672679901,
-0.5303124189376831,
0.5749678015708923,
0.37305545806884766,
0.03076825849711895,
0.20202915370464325,
-0.6772600412368774,
0.2661588788032532,
-0.051523808389902115,
0.09465409070253372,
0.24914489686489105,
-0.03545602038502693,
-0.14022114872932434,
0.9994959235191345,
0.5707061886787415,
0.3114278316497803,
-0.1774902045726776,
0.023748068138957024,
0.8714731931686401,
-1.0131118297576904,
-0.6201693415641785,
-0.578990638256073,
0.8780871629714966,
-0.16184677183628082,
-0.2868032455444336,
0.7271522283554077,
0.22602051496505737,
0.5762601494789124,
-0.13721220195293427,
0.687911331653595,
-0.025351548567414284,
0.4620612561702728,
-0.6550929546356201,
1.2617876529693604,
-0.05517560988664627,
0.5574102401733398,
-0.5563582181930542,
-0.8703434467315674,
-0.8689849376678467,
0.669122576713562,
-0.39223310351371765,
0.10945926606655121,
0.693081259727478,
0.8830097913742065,
0.24620024859905243,
0.06212539225816727,
0.5382682681083679,
0.04831787943840027,
0.468692421913147,
0.6427887678146362,
0.9998128414154053,
-0.49625706672668457,
0.6453692317008972,
-0.12382995337247849,
-0.6331878304481506,
-0.21556970477104187,
-0.7596727609634399,
-1.1310226917266846,
-0.6471320986747742,
-0.6802316904067993,
-0.34186601638793945,
0.5292486548423767,
0.7681918144226074,
1.2344450950622559,
-0.6673913598060608,
-0.26125526428222656,
0.1250847429037094,
-0.052524786442518234,
-0.40394505858421326,
-0.25863856077194214,
0.04385826736688614,
-0.7920773029327393,
-0.3322823941707611,
0.2619898319244385,
0.22250279784202576,
-0.3016754388809204,
-0.26921409368515015,
-0.4402104616165161,
-0.2347819209098816,
-0.28868138790130615,
0.8229902982711792,
0.22354848682880402,
-0.5915189981460571,
-0.9190419912338257,
-0.1418832391500473,
-0.14505226910114288,
-0.262591689825058,
0.4220142960548401,
-0.5207990407943726,
-0.0010757588315755129,
0.3403541147708893,
0.5712999105453491,
-0.046392880380153656,
-0.24646732211112976,
0.7492020726203918,
-0.37124839425086975,
0.17797107994556427,
0.3170880377292633,
0.2497558891773224,
0.18612314760684967,
-0.6189523935317993,
0.8133378624916077,
0.3297794759273529,
-0.7000786066055298,
-0.7328323721885681,
0.38116905093193054,
-1.211294174194336,
-0.33892393112182617,
1.6241850852966309,
0.07709310203790665,
-0.2419581413269043,
-0.5423424243927002,
-0.04288922995328903,
0.05268268659710884,
-0.4053296148777008,
0.9058358669281006,
0.410178005695343,
-0.12772487103939056,
-0.47038620710372925,
-0.694212019443512,
0.7071564197540283,
0.2978740334510803,
-0.8136030435562134,
0.2857179045677185,
0.4085732400417328,
0.36398008465766907,
0.1711972951889038,
0.4829825460910797,
-0.11772390455007553,
0.7052100300788879,
0.29335469007492065,
0.3598977327346802,
-0.32984796166419983,
-0.7312673330307007,
-0.025372181087732315,
0.31610333919525146,
0.08380624651908875,
-0.16918137669563293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11753v1 | A Semantic-based Layer Freezing Approach to Efficient Fine-Tuning of Language Models | 2024-06-17T17:13:08 | 2024-06-17T17:13:08 | Jian Gu, Aldeida Aleti, Chunyang Chen, Hongyu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Finetuning language models (LMs) is crucial for adapting the models to
downstream data and tasks. However, full finetuning is usually costly. Existing
work, such as parameter-efficient finetuning (PEFT), often focuses on
\textit{how to finetune} but neglects the issue of \textit{where to finetune}.
As a pioneering work on answering where to finetune (at the layer level), we
conduct a semantic analysis of the LM inference process. We first propose a
virtual transition of the latent representation and then trace its factual
transition. Based on the deviation in transitions, we estimate the gain of
finetuning each model layer, and further, narrow down the scope for finetuning.
We perform extensive experiments across well-known LMs and datasets. The
results show that our approach is effective and efficient, and outperforms the
existing baselines. Our approach is orthogonal to existing efficient
techniques, such as PEFT methods, offering practical values on LM finetuning. | [
-0.6506010293960571,
-1.196008563041687,
0.6688849925994873,
-0.16677245497703552,
-0.12373065203428268,
-0.16550906002521515,
-0.4462551474571228,
-0.26519763469696045,
-0.2990511953830719,
0.7888856530189514,
-0.737300455570221,
-0.5539464950561523,
-0.28338977694511414,
-0.3282868564128876,
-0.36159560084342957,
0.7595675587654114,
0.17786362767219543,
-0.1460905522108078,
-0.10524945706129074,
0.1632544845342636,
-0.2300594300031662,
-0.143512561917305,
-0.6750956773757935,
-0.5734238028526306,
0.5087906122207642,
0.7677384614944458,
0.7886999249458313,
0.8990219235420227,
0.1694142371416092,
0.2732548713684082,
-0.1924998164176941,
0.2426842451095581,
-0.6016241908073425,
0.13225311040878296,
-0.2895948588848114,
-0.5366380214691162,
-0.294603556394577,
0.12627838551998138,
0.40225857496261597,
1.0700148344039917,
-0.1526084840297699,
0.059010349214076996,
0.16881991922855377,
0.7291133999824524,
-0.7571940422058105,
0.006242646835744381,
-1.0954384803771973,
0.0981384739279747,
-0.275653213262558,
-0.1710709184408188,
-0.4154853820800781,
0.06707790493965149,
0.34078678488731384,
-0.5788766741752625,
0.4529400169849396,
-0.15550146996974945,
0.9794498085975647,
0.44644150137901306,
-0.13034188747406006,
0.25959861278533936,
-0.9129164218902588,
0.9592407941818237,
-0.908172070980072,
0.6969630718231201,
0.613472580909729,
0.3348299562931061,
-0.16442129015922546,
-0.7502524256706238,
-0.46047478914260864,
-0.23133571445941925,
0.14472801983356476,
0.0032875516917556524,
0.03686883673071861,
0.27387237548828125,
0.011008004657924175,
0.37673425674438477,
-0.1675955355167389,
0.3204982280731201,
-0.12736818194389343,
-0.3397656977176666,
0.3055417835712433,
0.09308844059705734,
0.31038999557495117,
0.0963704064488411,
-0.24881398677825928,
-0.033947303891181946,
-0.47463199496269226,
-0.08329770714044571,
0.19116494059562683,
0.675072431564331,
-0.014027120545506477,
0.4064291715621948,
-0.4495154619216919,
0.9290998578071594,
0.28282371163368225,
0.0006413846858777106,
-0.014735164120793343,
-0.1701008528470993,
-0.4400734305381775,
0.12186852842569351,
0.42322781682014465,
0.5626903176307678,
0.23619015514850616,
-0.5274050831794739,
-0.26396772265434265,
0.001316901994869113,
0.07551497966051102,
-0.8062208890914917,
-0.5360182523727417,
0.425091952085495,
-0.19548436999320984,
-0.21952572464942932,
-0.3071107268333435,
-0.3029245138168335,
-0.2939879894256592,
-0.6400421857833862,
0.38973554968833923,
-0.6552470922470093,
-0.4145185947418213,
0.23680679500102997,
0.055394403636455536,
0.47956424951553345,
0.28656479716300964,
-0.8787556886672974,
0.6809107661247253,
0.9515900015830994,
0.7647020220756531,
0.03734450787305832,
-0.2545429766178131,
-0.7491586804389954,
0.1535167694091797,
-0.5417887568473816,
0.844251275062561,
-0.41705697774887085,
0.1913679540157318,
-0.2196861058473587,
-0.05286142975091934,
0.022067418321967125,
-0.6158288717269897,
0.7026011347770691,
-0.6112865805625916,
0.16356366872787476,
0.03353032097220421,
-0.8621909022331238,
0.027787623926997185,
0.2014109343290329,
-0.6720032095909119,
0.8073432445526123,
-0.15681278705596924,
-0.612031877040863,
0.2955624759197235,
-0.28665217757225037,
-0.10791841894388199,
-0.03414210304617882,
0.13085977733135223,
-0.2711440324783325,
0.2297123223543167,
0.30303332209587097,
0.8378612995147705,
-0.5732129216194153,
0.15016193687915802,
-0.2518582344055176,
0.13507843017578125,
0.0395166389644146,
-0.2468266636133194,
0.5349423289299011,
0.5614092946052551,
-0.15680812299251556,
0.03899890184402466,
-0.8922910094261169,
0.39452195167541504,
-0.0041950177401304245,
-0.16706766188144684,
-0.7619549632072449,
0.19257038831710815,
0.10021879523992538,
-0.0404200553894043,
0.030275989323854446,
-0.5744205713272095,
-0.058563943952322006,
-0.9074352383613586,
0.6123859882354736,
0.607867956161499,
-0.2424832582473755,
0.7962884902954102,
-0.1108466312289238,
0.10197056084871292,
0.11084406077861786,
-0.06062866374850273,
0.04381383955478668,
-0.16793368756771088,
-0.9791660904884338,
-0.09674912691116333,
0.5691962242126465,
0.5363223552703857,
-0.7346473336219788,
0.2186959981918335,
0.05968128889799118,
-0.5059635639190674,
-0.5996029376983643,
0.17934753000736237,
0.462022066116333,
0.5522518157958984,
0.37177911400794983,
-0.015588656067848206,
-0.09402502328157425,
-1.0299441814422607,
-0.3970472514629364,
0.14501328766345978,
-0.03109680488705635,
0.08066427707672119,
-0.07704576104879379,
0.1696256548166275,
0.9939247965812683,
-0.48279255628585815,
-0.148537278175354,
-0.053668756037950516,
0.07607601583003998,
0.220626562833786,
0.8408108949661255,
0.48276111483573914,
-0.7241463661193848,
-0.41289353370666504,
0.366084486246109,
-0.28017663955688477,
-0.26464155316352844,
-0.11987438052892685,
-0.31140342354774475,
0.2716747224330902,
0.8714649081230164,
-0.5214641690254211,
-0.13569992780685425,
0.5486806631088257,
-0.4597890079021454,
0.21811428666114807,
-0.2197527438402176,
-0.19664190709590912,
-0.7333672642707825,
-0.17994259297847748,
0.04376903921365738,
-0.4448639750480652,
-1.0275914669036865,
0.26543939113616943,
0.10568352043628693,
-0.12090613692998886,
-0.38056811690330505,
0.4522645175457001,
-0.6590880751609802,
0.3087693154811859,
-0.08557743579149246,
0.20838645100593567,
-0.0995577797293663,
0.34350472688674927,
-0.11025764793157578,
0.2831742763519287,
0.6821838617324829,
-0.7311842441558838,
0.06761409342288971,
-0.3805670738220215,
-0.47632014751434326,
0.454662024974823,
-0.5439122319221497,
0.3515772223472595,
-0.26479867100715637,
-0.29418548941612244,
-0.8416957855224609,
-0.09505468606948853,
0.28620052337646484,
-0.06727713346481323,
0.35211825370788574,
-0.6883370876312256,
-0.39143070578575134,
0.19321586191654205,
-0.05513317137956619,
0.23917841911315918,
0.36074820160865784,
-0.2737789750099182,
0.6031070947647095,
0.4977398216724396,
0.01979207806289196,
-0.20936501026153564,
-0.6728537678718567,
0.07002844661474228,
-0.4568685293197632,
-0.8264111280441284,
0.6673397421836853,
-0.10352775454521179,
-0.3533092439174652,
-0.009515207260847092,
-0.2464025914669037,
-0.4278811812400818,
0.4175114333629608,
-0.2180895358324051,
-0.11007022112607956,
-0.595939040184021,
-0.04129324480891228,
0.22993291914463043,
-0.3620838224887848,
-0.10951896756887436,
-0.733773946762085,
0.6165294051170349,
-0.16818031668663025,
-0.029855430126190186,
-0.4148532450199127,
0.2911425828933716,
0.4556441605091095,
-0.30111339688301086,
0.8896784782409668,
0.7294875979423523,
-0.621810793876648,
-0.6912820339202881,
-0.7550129294395447,
-0.20623567700386047,
-0.4842262864112854,
0.1851503551006317,
-0.580559492111206,
-0.7711194157600403,
0.771275520324707,
-0.24042202532291412,
0.04478291794657707,
0.4425882399082184,
0.41991671919822693,
0.030275648459792137,
0.9392895102500916,
0.9494253993034363,
0.40010878443717957,
0.5374447703361511,
-0.3508830964565277,
0.131584033370018,
-0.46345964074134827,
-0.058181338012218475,
-0.63008713722229,
-0.1554626226425171,
-0.5666198134422302,
-0.5764620304107666,
0.11460322141647339,
0.658693253993988,
-0.2496662735939026,
0.21893084049224854,
-0.37307217717170715,
0.8433389067649841,
0.3249363303184509,
0.14926089346408844,
0.1784217208623886,
0.11730176210403442,
-0.3610255718231201,
-0.12301609665155411,
-0.9120903611183167,
-0.36983269453048706,
0.49715906381607056,
0.4045372009277344,
0.6349335312843323,
0.1841723620891571,
0.6060231924057007,
-0.0666249617934227,
-0.25382840633392334,
-1.025478482246399,
0.4624379873275757,
-0.4226331412792206,
-0.3265749514102936,
-0.5747630596160889,
-0.4067208170890808,
-0.7911538481712341,
0.15896810591220856,
-0.18475721776485443,
-0.7063374519348145,
0.19355079531669617,
0.44584181904792786,
-0.36401277780532837,
0.2635495662689209,
-1.011875033378601,
0.992307722568512,
0.010698418132960796,
-0.5694683194160461,
-0.2427426129579544,
-0.625363290309906,
0.16411414742469788,
-0.033856287598609924,
0.22095941007137299,
-0.5969681143760681,
-0.12309527397155762,
0.6170335412025452,
-0.7137187123298645,
0.9215700626373291,
-0.43554067611694336,
-0.3415083587169647,
0.15665887296199799,
0.5197374224662781,
0.39440351724624634,
-0.20522667467594147,
-0.3523961901664734,
-0.058767169713974,
0.3456549644470215,
-0.4809826612472534,
-0.7226885557174683,
1.035286784172058,
-0.7282347679138184,
-0.5421833395957947,
0.034812986850738525,
-0.6665192246437073,
-0.5030695796012878,
0.4110659658908844,
-0.02599087730050087,
0.47770142555236816,
-0.07739883661270142,
0.047255855053663254,
0.8131985664367676,
-0.20075450837612152,
0.21765565872192383,
0.48424944281578064,
-0.047427792102098465,
-0.07447080314159393,
0.940392255783081,
0.3790718615055084,
0.549530029296875,
0.530665397644043,
0.6786184906959534,
-0.010194323025643826,
-0.8357012271881104,
-0.39140769839286804,
0.07761038839817047,
-0.6714917421340942,
-0.20687294006347656,
-0.5091453790664673,
-0.280211478471756,
-0.18582135438919067,
-0.09250906854867935,
-0.7103425860404968,
-0.5718039870262146,
-0.15946385264396667,
0.08275416493415833,
0.5648871064186096,
0.25551971793174744,
-0.03023647703230381,
0.1465650051832199,
-0.6984829306602478,
0.15844695270061493,
0.20141951739788055,
0.6573873162269592,
0.10037399083375931,
-0.4073317348957062,
-0.2969864308834076,
0.07399279624223709,
0.059948746114969254,
-0.5196283459663391,
0.20200029015541077,
0.6717486381530762,
0.7534748911857605,
0.2121538668870926,
0.4115689694881439,
0.8223283290863037,
-0.6455661654472351,
0.7043799161911011,
-0.03955461457371712,
-1.1198564767837524,
0.514504611492157,
-0.3974440097808838,
0.4329136610031128,
0.4827902913093567,
0.11536599695682526,
-0.42130565643310547,
-0.5551084280014038,
-0.5176122188568115,
-1.2088141441345215,
0.6493785381317139,
0.1990976184606552,
0.40886715054512024,
0.20423144102096558,
0.6052007675170898,
0.20862115919589996,
-0.1645040065050125,
-0.3892049789428711,
-0.27284103631973267,
-0.06870601326227188,
-0.0304037444293499,
-0.06114233285188675,
-0.27077972888946533,
-0.055029839277267456,
-0.3462890684604645,
0.4716436564922333,
-0.24662268161773682,
0.01404316071420908,
0.20404794812202454,
-0.22638429701328278,
-0.0958576425909996,
0.24890433251857758,
0.34788990020751953,
0.7133435606956482,
-0.24308116734027863,
0.6214092969894409,
0.3016718029975891,
-0.11998625099658966,
-0.22740387916564941,
0.0059868209064006805,
-0.2296261191368103,
-0.17632056772708893,
0.3201906979084015,
0.8438504338264465,
0.18605193495750427,
-0.4543780982494354,
0.1313963532447815,
0.15957924723625183,
-0.1788691282272339,
-0.1721966415643692,
0.2507075071334839,
0.17208823561668396,
0.40920454263687134,
0.012330389581620693,
-0.06073930859565735,
0.10158348083496094,
-0.4676348567008972,
0.32723137736320496,
0.31557533144950867,
-0.627895712852478,
-0.12839607894420624,
0.5618712306022644,
-0.0017437845235690475,
-0.14390674233436584,
0.5072325468063354,
0.21798530220985413,
-0.21555781364440918,
0.4116397500038147,
0.6480541229248047,
0.8766253590583801,
-0.1561872661113739,
0.1593770831823349,
0.16000217199325562,
0.19784313440322876,
-0.09675002843141556,
0.07396343350410461,
-0.134668231010437,
-1.0430635213851929,
-0.6395723223686218,
-0.7395653128623962,
-0.1049971655011177,
0.19406984746456146,
-0.6723911762237549,
0.3687848746776581,
-0.7031632661819458,
-0.012870443984866142,
0.4844540059566498,
-0.17892366647720337,
-0.588333785533905,
0.292345255613327,
0.3981870114803314,
1.0665549039840698,
-0.7578638792037964,
0.9788798689842224,
0.5766645669937134,
-0.06949779391288757,
-0.7698202133178711,
0.13979068398475647,
-0.026417892426252365,
-0.7575717568397522,
0.4325575828552246,
-0.17765581607818604,
-0.4072321653366089,
0.25953277945518494,
-0.768547534942627,
-0.7981669902801514,
0.7352088689804077,
0.7813031673431396,
-0.5299962759017944,
0.15063612163066864,
-0.022086093202233315,
0.5666544437408447,
-0.25548022985458374,
-0.14703144133090973,
0.9111527800559998,
0.22734177112579346,
-0.016846975311636925,
-0.9551393985748291,
-0.027941599488258362,
-0.2712612748146057,
0.1656150221824646,
0.3738847076892853,
-0.39852893352508545,
0.8703758716583252,
-0.05246613547205925,
-0.3142710328102112,
0.040288761258125305,
0.6620203256607056,
-0.17574229836463928,
0.1813211739063263,
0.7762104868888855,
0.4584163725376129,
0.7259584069252014,
-0.057360414415597916,
0.9098296761512756,
-0.4102669060230255,
0.66812664270401,
1.146578311920166,
0.1426694542169571,
0.8566842079162598,
0.615426242351532,
0.21164830029010773,
0.19418904185295105,
0.5458551645278931,
0.2942469120025635,
0.8510729670524597,
0.38992372155189514,
0.012467924505472183,
-0.7803642749786377,
-0.23805873095989227,
-0.07365068793296814,
0.32416337728500366,
0.48608872294425964,
-0.14035660028457642,
-0.37448859214782715,
0.030176660045981407,
0.2971895933151245,
0.24785690009593964,
-0.38027244806289673,
0.8583921194076538,
0.22349706292152405,
-0.4367438852787018,
1.1141200065612793,
0.21334438025951385,
0.3136231005191803,
-0.4003731608390808,
0.05297427251935005,
-0.2361760288476944,
0.3891383707523346,
-0.2782481610774994,
-0.8167059421539307,
0.435819149017334,
-0.042903218418359756,
-0.2304888814687729,
-0.3685917854309082,
0.7287887930870056,
-0.5894133448600769,
-0.5496953129768372,
0.33344364166259766,
0.649425208568573,
0.20844730734825134,
-0.009912414476275444,
-0.699958860874176,
0.08742614835500717,
-0.24209851026535034,
-0.195599764585495,
0.22943277657032013,
0.759846568107605,
-0.08281977474689484,
0.518978476524353,
0.5424967408180237,
0.09953423589468002,
0.10427199304103851,
0.32845231890678406,
0.9126156568527222,
-0.5703763961791992,
-0.45904630422592163,
-0.8587764501571655,
0.6727374196052551,
0.12069542706012726,
-0.13783904910087585,
0.4712837040424347,
0.3447651267051697,
1.1247525215148926,
0.05154687911272049,
0.45657458901405334,
0.015359711833298206,
0.4344056248664856,
-1.2425434589385986,
0.8578392267227173,
-0.6835252642631531,
0.47455984354019165,
-0.5241015553474426,
-0.9482609629631042,
-0.6076070070266724,
0.5760868787765503,
-0.36948156356811523,
-0.21219731867313385,
0.48321330547332764,
0.9464890956878662,
-0.6596746444702148,
-0.20457695424556732,
0.5386985540390015,
0.6737567782402039,
0.12849058210849762,
0.31666114926338196,
0.7605935335159302,
-0.3621874153614044,
0.22597470879554749,
-0.7253596782684326,
-0.178496852517128,
0.14203022420406342,
-1.0970865488052368,
-0.791467547416687,
-0.7371991872787476,
-0.5899915099143982,
-0.38492172956466675,
0.058157846331596375,
0.8419427871704102,
0.9335734844207764,
-1.0310534238815308,
-0.29037123918533325,
-0.21906794607639313,
0.03737914562225342,
-0.3253417909145355,
-0.19362381100654602,
0.4657403230667114,
-0.46515989303588867,
-0.6281562447547913,
0.306520015001297,
-0.017843279987573624,
-0.10301496833562851,
-0.2193334847688675,
0.06711623072624207,
0.019236112013459206,
0.11759357154369354,
0.6641858816146851,
0.013344017788767815,
-1.0040665864944458,
-0.5373690724372864,
-0.2081637978553772,
0.07300547510385513,
-0.08282772451639175,
0.8013363480567932,
-0.6941736936569214,
0.4528471827507019,
0.6126906275749207,
0.7731372714042664,
0.6153279542922974,
-0.2618970572948456,
0.8150438666343689,
-0.5606951713562012,
0.28890642523765564,
0.12203270196914673,
0.04979318752884865,
0.3405020534992218,
-0.19216249883174896,
0.17669925093650818,
0.031940676271915436,
-0.3836558759212494,
-0.8234686851501465,
0.2857194244861603,
-1.062936782836914,
-0.43361398577690125,
0.8869984149932861,
0.020452717319130898,
-0.3069332540035248,
-0.2036461979150772,
-0.2092050313949585,
0.21524691581726074,
-0.20937508344650269,
0.5124080777168274,
0.5102674961090088,
-0.003832384245470166,
-0.5067857503890991,
-0.7259392738342285,
0.6663062572479248,
0.5214470028877258,
-0.5653797388076782,
0.4232141971588135,
0.40216201543807983,
0.5043787360191345,
0.029267890378832817,
0.2390170395374298,
0.14618392288684845,
-0.12098846584558487,
-0.15821680426597595,
-0.2944290041923523,
-0.025019273161888123,
-0.3708174526691437,
-0.22128687798976898,
0.18434001505374908,
0.3467852473258972,
0.1465417891740799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11745v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11745v1 | Multi-Layer Ranking with Large Language Models for News Source Recommendation | 2024-06-17T17:02:34 | 2024-06-17T17:02:34 | Wenjia Zhang, Lin Gui, Rob Procter, Yulan He | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | To seek reliable information sources for news events, we introduce a novel
task of expert recommendation, which aims to identify trustworthy sources based
on their previously quoted statements. To achieve this, we built a novel
dataset, called NewsQuote, consisting of 23,571 quote-speaker pairs sourced
from a collection of news articles. We formulate the recommendation task as the
retrieval of experts based on their likelihood of being associated with a given
query. We also propose a multi-layer ranking framework employing Large Language
Models to improve the recommendation performance. Our results show that
employing an in-context learning based LLM ranker and a multi-layer
ranking-based filter significantly improve both the predictive quality and
behavioural quality of the recommender system. | [
-0.3029674291610718,
-0.5807111263275146,
0.7735337615013123,
-0.03816123306751251,
-0.3826580047607422,
0.28173691034317017,
-0.13080276548862457,
-0.7363229393959045,
0.22790025174617767,
0.5972333550453186,
-0.2917087972164154,
-0.5894263386726379,
-0.6577038168907166,
-0.3177341818809509,
-0.33708202838897705,
1.0476254224777222,
0.2742449939250946,
0.19936564564704895,
-0.2138812392950058,
-0.06026313453912735,
-0.22061261534690857,
-0.5353530049324036,
-0.9608323574066162,
-0.2779431939125061,
0.625487744808197,
0.5363077521324158,
0.9300155639648438,
0.28553706407546997,
0.4907630383968353,
0.19445349276065826,
-0.17297996580600739,
0.20942141115665436,
-0.35349157452583313,
0.17370030283927917,
-0.4299798905849457,
-0.20257365703582764,
-0.17722752690315247,
0.24944837391376495,
0.6827564835548401,
0.45891448855400085,
-0.24832049012184143,
0.011563668958842754,
-0.0627124086022377,
0.6973515152931213,
-0.40092527866363525,
0.11671354621648788,
-0.7606112957000732,
0.005572382360696793,
-0.07598274201154709,
-0.28534480929374695,
-0.502454400062561,
-0.5857718586921692,
0.3340465724468231,
-0.40545353293418884,
-0.05415532737970352,
0.16187313199043274,
0.3254247307777405,
-0.1697859913110733,
-0.6309893131256104,
-0.07142549753189087,
-0.5107796788215637,
0.8672611713409424,
-0.7017549872398376,
0.47379085421562195,
0.5375816822052002,
0.4421362578868866,
-0.2004091739654541,
-0.4740944504737854,
-0.12037117034196854,
-0.6296873092651367,
-0.05155259370803833,
-0.10442648828029633,
0.1445082128047943,
-0.2513901889324188,
0.013299578800797462,
-0.0519871786236763,
-0.35320383310317993,
-0.02997918240725994,
-0.2589966952800751,
-0.13999469578266144,
0.6911044716835022,
-0.37894850969314575,
0.10273619741201401,
-0.17096294462680817,
-0.41873979568481445,
0.09135547280311584,
-0.4279114007949829,
-0.06337486207485199,
0.47328120470046997,
0.4238094091415405,
0.24980901181697845,
0.43393680453300476,
-0.41855084896087646,
0.6081486940383911,
-0.05922757089138031,
-0.45711958408355713,
0.3051033020019531,
-0.30231115221977234,
0.1862124502658844,
0.3537496328353882,
0.5785587430000305,
0.5201979875564575,
0.24699266254901886,
-0.3793017864227295,
-0.0011184833711013198,
-0.5446814298629761,
0.32035818696022034,
-0.5678235292434692,
-0.32804328203201294,
-0.0068534016609191895,
-0.44471675157546997,
-0.47562548518180847,
0.4282701909542084,
-0.7714522480964661,
-0.6309207081794739,
-0.18172107636928558,
0.4389508068561554,
-0.2613811194896698,
-0.3925568163394928,
-0.021441491320729256,
-0.2402241826057434,
-0.011766940355300903,
0.46675905585289,
-0.3898318409919739,
0.0027781135868281126,
0.3337039649486542,
0.710414469242096,
-0.15633782744407654,
-0.35948485136032104,
-0.7702376246452332,
0.44336873292922974,
-0.242791548371315,
1.0097612142562866,
-0.8202612996101379,
-0.17069178819656372,
0.056302234530448914,
-0.15246348083019257,
0.1774134486913681,
-0.3429029583930969,
0.958515465259552,
-0.6210127472877502,
0.3229525089263916,
-0.3720642626285553,
-0.46225056052207947,
-0.24831107258796692,
0.015446994453668594,
-0.6572742462158203,
1.1489307880401611,
0.06053925305604935,
-0.654785692691803,
0.4155150055885315,
-0.48100709915161133,
-0.6983003616333008,
0.07945740967988968,
0.056583650410175323,
-0.14424093067646027,
-0.08080209791660309,
0.5765839219093323,
0.6460422873497009,
-0.3173500895500183,
0.40006768703460693,
-0.46040236949920654,
-0.1434677243232727,
0.02495681867003441,
-0.2546033263206482,
0.4511657953262329,
0.16278858482837677,
-0.17234109342098236,
0.06140388548374176,
-0.8031880259513855,
-0.06609851866960526,
-0.2240760624408722,
-0.5782276391983032,
-0.6182470321655273,
0.24257129430770874,
0.21223193407058716,
0.39825645089149475,
0.22036804258823395,
-0.6023387908935547,
0.23180612921714783,
-0.09232164919376373,
0.6859241724014282,
0.7413709163665771,
0.3225681185722351,
0.49774545431137085,
-0.38341155648231506,
0.17667020857334137,
0.20730333030223846,
0.10997208207845688,
-0.07498670369386673,
-0.4854051470756531,
-0.46710720658302307,
-0.020507875829935074,
0.11174041777849197,
0.46379196643829346,
-0.8460448384284973,
0.43592002987861633,
-0.007314713206142187,
-0.4892238974571228,
-0.3505934774875641,
0.32023361325263977,
0.2877156734466553,
0.45800700783729553,
0.5286436080932617,
-0.024258026853203773,
-0.5494587421417236,
-0.971351146697998,
-0.6067332029342651,
-0.21339553594589233,
0.2153581827878952,
0.26148077845573425,
0.1465274840593338,
0.04870166257023811,
0.7997244596481323,
-0.36492207646369934,
-0.2820262908935547,
-0.18368667364120483,
0.025159917771816254,
0.32826030254364014,
0.3393646776676178,
0.5998210906982422,
-0.7842901945114136,
-0.3132263422012329,
0.005558182019740343,
-0.471842885017395,
0.14469046890735626,
0.06818144768476486,
-0.33340996503829956,
0.07275404036045074,
0.563983678817749,
-0.3856169581413269,
-0.09273368865251541,
0.41213929653167725,
-0.4331660866737366,
0.2759063243865967,
-0.027759091928601265,
0.2990540564060211,
-1.5067331790924072,
-0.2208186388015747,
0.41794154047966003,
-0.5189476609230042,
-0.333224892616272,
-0.07458145171403885,
-0.05361882597208023,
-0.009720110334455967,
-0.5598005652427673,
0.655015766620636,
-0.18207217752933502,
0.011922381818294525,
-0.21381814777851105,
0.34550797939300537,
0.11826535314321518,
0.41271334886550903,
-0.04362097755074501,
0.5007452964782715,
0.5561151504516602,
-0.47259265184402466,
0.3875691890716553,
0.0715879499912262,
-0.8656874895095825,
0.7337313294410706,
-0.4374387264251709,
0.1902637630701065,
0.08806957304477692,
0.49131277203559875,
-0.9496585726737976,
0.02790592983365059,
-0.25317123532295227,
-0.18036603927612305,
-0.08423065394163132,
-0.30521419644355774,
-0.5483272075653076,
-0.17306776344776154,
-0.35742974281311035,
0.2703508734703064,
0.05515388771891594,
-0.5690755248069763,
0.3808736205101013,
0.578987181186676,
-0.4780988395214081,
-0.8582957983016968,
-0.5826486349105835,
0.3433591425418854,
0.1630348265171051,
-0.4660992920398712,
0.37960776686668396,
-0.19084440171718597,
-0.16515643894672394,
0.21787995100021362,
-0.13426926732063293,
-0.23614008724689484,
0.05555683374404907,
0.07985169440507889,
0.17681151628494263,
-0.14444005489349365,
0.011501651257276535,
0.1450842022895813,
0.12012659758329391,
-0.030261335894465446,
-0.381183922290802,
0.2541768550872803,
-0.004484876058995724,
-0.413364052772522,
-0.42662718892097473,
0.5821822285652161,
0.9054271578788757,
-0.35815054178237915,
1.0162502527236938,
0.804616391658783,
-0.28673824667930603,
-0.1382104456424713,
-0.9501886963844299,
-0.1470862627029419,
-0.3976818323135376,
0.5417534708976746,
-0.14688600599765778,
-1.0098273754119873,
0.36242008209228516,
0.22486628592014313,
-0.08660229295492172,
0.5796854496002197,
0.42623844742774963,
0.06205718219280243,
1.1650679111480713,
0.36955752968788147,
-0.8471213579177856,
0.7249289155006409,
-0.11630702763795853,
0.11622992157936096,
-0.4280596375465393,
-0.3875197768211365,
-0.5979233980178833,
-0.24050626158714294,
-0.19883176684379578,
-0.05941082909703255,
0.33609113097190857,
0.09153478592634201,
-0.1501295417547226,
0.14580431580543518,
-0.3392137587070465,
0.6864346861839294,
1.0500949621200562,
0.3267260193824768,
0.5325286984443665,
0.02828899770975113,
-0.4109662175178528,
0.44809696078300476,
-0.5034233331680298,
-0.3497883975505829,
0.7657334208488464,
0.17312201857566833,
0.7952336668968201,
0.28465667366981506,
0.32953763008117676,
0.5585662722587585,
-0.09601958096027374,
-0.6365196108818054,
0.46882620453834534,
-0.007384416647255421,
-0.6639344096183777,
-0.32980722188949585,
-0.38253337144851685,
-0.5114962458610535,
0.1331109255552292,
-0.36123621463775635,
-0.570144772529602,
0.3637246787548065,
-0.5324116945266724,
-0.19930894672870636,
0.4112478494644165,
-0.587737500667572,
0.4004654288291931,
-0.2746022045612335,
-0.24283798038959503,
-0.5540071129798889,
-0.3993186950683594,
0.35827693343162537,
-0.053172409534454346,
0.40253549814224243,
-0.20287390053272247,
0.2218698114156723,
0.8100903034210205,
0.07508925348520279,
0.4918386936187744,
-0.3234693109989166,
0.11093301326036453,
0.13293634355068207,
-0.07147199660539627,
0.8193548321723938,
0.4636540412902832,
-0.6814760565757751,
0.13675624132156372,
-0.011983301490545273,
-0.4006665349006653,
-0.3549653887748718,
1.0784555673599243,
-1.019897222518921,
-0.6574564576148987,
-0.26579490303993225,
-0.5629909038543701,
-0.2628325819969177,
0.4018908143043518,
-0.049740273505449295,
0.6628862023353577,
-0.04206220433115959,
0.7754131555557251,
0.2453320175409317,
-0.011352934874594212,
0.468686044216156,
0.6367776393890381,
0.02499234676361084,
-0.6880353689193726,
0.6448693871498108,
0.24168114364147186,
-0.17571265995502472,
0.6127761006355286,
0.06396596878767014,
-0.3877931237220764,
-0.8281213641166687,
-0.19873255491256714,
-0.008906028233468533,
-0.6923938393592834,
-0.24447545409202576,
-0.6253696084022522,
-0.33617502450942993,
-0.4999425411224365,
-0.05606786906719208,
-0.36973103880882263,
-0.5603295564651489,
-0.067633718252182,
-0.4148607552051544,
0.3913808763027191,
0.7839577198028564,
0.34716546535491943,
0.07122570276260376,
-0.6166607737541199,
0.3255358338356018,
0.25702258944511414,
0.6984821557998657,
-0.14723774790763855,
-0.46440690755844116,
-0.8465995788574219,
-0.21125033497810364,
-0.3914318084716797,
-0.711158037185669,
0.14630383253097534,
0.1937456876039505,
1.2647241353988647,
0.3895915746688843,
0.36320728063583374,
0.2843227982521057,
-0.6266711354255676,
0.874684751033783,
0.06371214240789413,
-0.7391011714935303,
0.6924107670783997,
-0.4828598201274872,
-0.015789158642292023,
0.70916748046875,
0.3212378919124603,
-0.2205842137336731,
-0.6501982808113098,
-0.3836486041545868,
-0.8252303004264832,
0.8086692094802856,
0.01170065626502037,
0.03824160248041153,
-0.011525661684572697,
0.6484725475311279,
0.12157348543405533,
0.3460404574871063,
-0.7391313910484314,
-0.2750852704048157,
-0.2514854669570923,
0.10540325194597244,
-0.4807606339454651,
-0.6294543743133545,
-0.2329074591398239,
-0.3741103410720825,
0.8295125365257263,
0.03824078291654587,
0.10368853062391281,
0.20544499158859253,
-0.164746955037117,
-0.4102081060409546,
0.29989907145500183,
0.627477765083313,
0.9514347314834595,
-0.3345324993133545,
0.13436447083950043,
0.010225125588476658,
-0.1907561868429184,
0.14834530651569366,
0.29283037781715393,
0.00907155405730009,
0.007268296554684639,
0.23682332038879395,
0.768010139465332,
0.4107150137424469,
-0.32599878311157227,
0.4101993143558502,
0.05172813683748245,
-0.25624099373817444,
-0.3324316740036011,
0.10744236409664154,
0.12366500496864319,
0.6102619767189026,
1.0242410898208618,
0.24900075793266296,
0.27278363704681396,
-0.7008492946624756,
0.4555702209472656,
0.5788203477859497,
-0.46111994981765747,
-0.004149772226810455,
0.637505829334259,
0.39928972721099854,
-0.266528457403183,
0.3894992172718048,
0.31218913197517395,
-0.3632543683052063,
0.2856171131134033,
0.20737747848033905,
0.6885828375816345,
-0.30798396468162537,
0.4320511221885681,
0.22368808090686798,
0.3204459547996521,
-0.5307320356369019,
0.02784254215657711,
0.09613724797964096,
-0.8442950248718262,
-0.4705435633659363,
-0.553906261920929,
-0.7176951766014099,
0.17919881641864777,
-0.6405158042907715,
0.4602038562297821,
-0.3176717758178711,
-0.14366655051708221,
0.1917015016078949,
0.44585734605789185,
-0.42975640296936035,
0.16131791472434998,
0.1921904981136322,
1.062196135520935,
-0.7589674592018127,
1.1952999830245972,
0.8874445557594299,
-0.44563478231430054,
-0.5599730610847473,
0.18056106567382812,
-0.24810516834259033,
-0.4340289831161499,
0.149329274892807,
0.012900445610284805,
-0.021059861406683922,
0.08007088303565979,
-0.2801803946495056,
-1.2212387323379517,
1.0619006156921387,
0.8228548765182495,
-0.2901352345943451,
0.10633935034275055,
-0.38870906829833984,
0.3014059364795685,
-0.5288962721824646,
0.5944176912307739,
0.09074439108371735,
0.6388238072395325,
0.1445181965827942,
-0.9095262885093689,
-0.12469380348920822,
-0.32582226395606995,
-0.06839879602193832,
0.04686439037322998,
-0.8819799423217773,
0.7852644324302673,
-0.14294160902500153,
0.4064774811267853,
-0.17788071930408478,
0.6441401839256287,
0.1894732564687729,
0.3682919144630432,
0.5074061155319214,
0.2229670286178589,
0.7335476279258728,
0.28775763511657715,
1.1928319931030273,
-0.5218669176101685,
0.22278474271297455,
1.1113228797912598,
-0.1654067039489746,
1.1780166625976562,
0.23144322633743286,
-0.03162746503949165,
1.0338600873947144,
0.630565881729126,
-0.02885049395263195,
0.8730856776237488,
-0.3378552198410034,
0.006609664298593998,
-0.2671111822128296,
-0.219612255692482,
-0.48052653670310974,
0.2697095572948456,
0.042852696031332016,
-0.6217933297157288,
-0.2512122690677643,
0.12282877415418625,
-0.1852847933769226,
-0.03900761157274246,
-0.41827112436294556,
0.7819994688034058,
-0.028046896681189537,
-0.6675093770027161,
0.11610926687717438,
0.13002949953079224,
0.472709596157074,
-0.483927458524704,
-0.00046011197264306247,
-0.1292300969362259,
0.09648394584655762,
-0.2863926887512207,
-0.8751882910728455,
-0.1572810858488083,
-0.4706043004989624,
-0.6020454168319702,
-0.1038263812661171,
0.8249810338020325,
-0.5652138590812683,
-0.7982318997383118,
0.403518944978714,
0.6196172833442688,
0.010485517792403698,
-0.3911595344543457,
-0.7623101472854614,
-0.2806444764137268,
-0.20580193400382996,
-0.6866604685783386,
0.5754467844963074,
0.24963237345218658,
-0.019698642194271088,
0.7448458075523376,
0.7949478626251221,
0.04862252250313759,
-0.11898103356361389,
0.32572561502456665,
0.8343736529350281,
-0.7552887201309204,
-0.5799376964569092,
-0.7070712447166443,
0.1805475503206253,
-0.22120733559131622,
0.04164256528019905,
0.9185587167739868,
0.6487244367599487,
0.8550602197647095,
0.21093422174453735,
1.0015349388122559,
0.42687085270881653,
0.69012451171875,
-0.48473846912384033,
0.7327410578727722,
-0.3979865610599518,
0.4623783826828003,
-0.4909728467464447,
-1.1338151693344116,
-0.25236257910728455,
0.4530828595161438,
-0.27992957830429077,
0.36785051226615906,
0.6884206533432007,
0.6880160570144653,
-0.027338692918419838,
-0.01997152902185917,
0.3592107594013214,
0.2738052010536194,
0.24158307909965515,
0.3507072925567627,
0.765038013458252,
-0.13127774000167847,
0.6146634221076965,
-0.24978700280189514,
0.04610234126448631,
-0.5184581279754639,
-1.019842267036438,
-0.9413281679153442,
-0.6257123947143555,
-0.35616782307624817,
-0.2188740074634552,
0.22678107023239136,
1.14315664768219,
0.958496630191803,
-0.9657909274101257,
-0.07042118161916733,
0.13015644252300262,
0.4487035870552063,
-0.3328518271446228,
-0.23960790038108826,
0.46874719858169556,
-0.30880239605903625,
-0.7208186984062195,
0.8510153889656067,
0.1830882728099823,
-0.4974684417247772,
-0.4314712882041931,
0.02688410133123398,
-0.5334265828132629,
-0.0328962616622448,
0.6903130412101746,
-0.30558377504348755,
-0.7757092714309692,
-0.5399558544158936,
-0.45817697048187256,
-0.19048209488391876,
-0.19259630143642426,
0.751968264579773,
-0.8383314609527588,
0.1432497650384903,
0.3764078617095947,
0.47433048486709595,
0.3823417127132416,
0.023038562387228012,
0.5777504444122314,
-0.8622564673423767,
0.09918846935033798,
-0.04838678985834122,
0.3942931592464447,
0.2828357517719269,
-0.6825098395347595,
0.38427484035491943,
0.12137284874916077,
-0.6496597528457642,
-0.765218198299408,
-0.008061341010034084,
-1.0837864875793457,
-0.39410585165023804,
1.4343997240066528,
-0.07520898431539536,
0.1771422177553177,
-0.39362192153930664,
-0.28076526522636414,
-0.0312955379486084,
-1.0147067308425903,
0.7164257764816284,
0.886265754699707,
-0.028281472623348236,
-0.5654225945472717,
-0.7435275912284851,
0.33854106068611145,
0.1598040610551834,
-0.34239596128463745,
-0.2345910221338272,
0.3629750609397888,
0.319143146276474,
0.03478531539440155,
0.3826845586299896,
0.016358545050024986,
0.04000934585928917,
-0.509579062461853,
-0.09541022777557373,
-0.34172359108924866,
-0.4643504321575165,
0.05913008749485016,
0.5990058779716492,
0.3289702832698822,
0.09674830734729767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11736v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11736v1 | Interactive Evolution: A Neural-Symbolic Self-Training Framework For Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T16:52:56 | 2024-06-17T16:52:56 | Fangzhi Xu, Qiushi Sun, Kanzhi Cheng, Jun Liu, Yu Qiao, Zhiyong Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | One of the primary driving forces contributing to the superior performance of
Large Language Models (LLMs) is the extensive availability of human-annotated
natural language data, which is used for alignment fine-tuning. This inspired
researchers to investigate self-training methods to mitigate the extensive
reliance on human annotations. However, the current success of self-training
has been primarily observed in natural language scenarios, rather than in the
increasingly important neural-symbolic scenarios. To this end, we propose an
environment-guided neural-symbolic self-training framework named ENVISIONS. It
aims to overcome two main challenges: (1) the scarcity of symbolic data, and
(2) the limited proficiency of LLMs in processing symbolic language. Extensive
evaluations conducted on three distinct domains demonstrate the effectiveness
of our approach. Additionally, we have conducted a comprehensive analysis to
uncover the factors contributing to ENVISIONS's success, thereby offering
valuable insights for future research in this area. Code will be available at
\url{https://github.com/xufangzhi/ENVISIONS}. | [
-0.24328874051570892,
-0.7095468044281006,
0.5827824473381042,
0.39390724897384644,
-0.2577739357948303,
0.1543838381767273,
-0.4299071729183197,
-0.41910284757614136,
0.36911541223526,
0.3561254143714905,
-0.812120795249939,
-0.28991764783859253,
-0.5300470590591431,
0.44336023926734924,
-0.31548604369163513,
0.6132523417472839,
-0.1651524007320404,
0.007267921231687069,
-0.35734471678733826,
-0.07605370879173279,
-0.3241453170776367,
-0.29283833503723145,
-0.8866919279098511,
-0.273385614156723,
0.32434213161468506,
0.12954497337341309,
0.7367159724235535,
1.213836669921875,
0.1973014622926712,
0.39875295758247375,
-0.020047491416335106,
0.31283456087112427,
-0.3039529025554657,
0.6287940740585327,
0.20395173132419586,
-0.30224043130874634,
-0.08129420876502991,
-0.19488967955112457,
0.8388696908950806,
0.462373286485672,
-0.22333233058452606,
0.184962198138237,
0.2468479722738266,
0.3622001111507416,
-0.5151045322418213,
0.27505946159362793,
-0.6964836716651917,
0.3501332700252533,
-0.06679000705480576,
-0.20394960045814514,
-0.14549046754837036,
-0.06895846128463745,
0.32404425740242004,
-0.7769542932510376,
-0.2238008826971054,
0.1923113763332367,
0.5843660831451416,
0.5745682120323181,
-0.2485971450805664,
-0.2557787001132965,
-0.418327271938324,
0.634074866771698,
-0.7515657544136047,
0.5990809798240662,
0.06621873378753662,
0.28771495819091797,
-0.41206270456314087,
-0.7037982940673828,
-0.6685529947280884,
-0.21933667361736298,
0.08738860487937927,
0.1971217393875122,
-0.08141309022903442,
0.2004159837961197,
0.22047126293182373,
-0.12530986964702606,
-0.48026466369628906,
0.4140450954437256,
-0.2408173382282257,
0.008699818514287472,
0.6205852031707764,
0.19473181664943695,
0.4554874897003174,
-0.08080901950597763,
-0.3548617362976074,
-0.09641492366790771,
-0.7852481603622437,
-0.04960792511701584,
0.45699480175971985,
0.4105006158351898,
-0.323039174079895,
0.423113077878952,
-0.21824415028095245,
0.7842873334884644,
0.09633661061525345,
0.1990390568971634,
0.3425787091255188,
0.04226987436413765,
-0.3223821222782135,
0.3479860723018646,
0.8253071904182434,
-0.08369234204292297,
0.4158051311969757,
-0.28667739033699036,
-0.19271138310432434,
-0.20097105205059052,
0.39457717537879944,
-0.8036751747131348,
-0.16927999258041382,
0.18128134310245514,
-0.2844742238521576,
-0.2841583490371704,
-0.29885727167129517,
-0.8355050683021545,
-0.5393063426017761,
-0.9395859241485596,
0.35907185077667236,
-0.560131847858429,
-0.2083491086959839,
0.18883413076400757,
-0.020142439752817154,
0.10725796967744827,
0.5569735169410706,
-1.226341962814331,
0.1822441667318344,
0.6578539609909058,
0.9199872612953186,
-0.1486070156097412,
-0.5261512398719788,
-0.2696060538291931,
0.24661296606063843,
-0.24194778501987457,
0.65738844871521,
-0.755424439907074,
-0.07149066030979156,
0.06889115273952484,
-0.36607417464256287,
-0.11926554888486862,
-0.4219914376735687,
0.14689745008945465,
-0.2549961507320404,
0.0015477502020075917,
-0.1448855698108673,
-0.4675031900405884,
-0.05607302486896515,
0.40309396386146545,
-0.47195345163345337,
1.0765689611434937,
-0.0585368312895298,
-0.5413159728050232,
0.25317153334617615,
-0.8394447565078735,
-0.2957528829574585,
0.13084863126277924,
-0.6618880033493042,
-0.287667840719223,
0.12336871027946472,
0.24197480082511902,
0.3575016260147095,
-0.3184545040130615,
0.23049117624759674,
-0.5561282634735107,
-0.1502593606710434,
0.02071104571223259,
-0.23246492445468903,
0.8482475280761719,
0.35254234075546265,
-0.5854909420013428,
0.2871827185153961,
-0.6378357410430908,
0.18582719564437866,
0.41743481159210205,
-0.09931280463933945,
-0.365735799074173,
0.12924695014953613,
-0.19738170504570007,
0.4178721308708191,
0.3219847083091736,
-0.4939955472946167,
0.4163382351398468,
-0.6576938629150391,
0.5127969980239868,
1.0167707204818726,
-0.08104144036769867,
0.5703499913215637,
0.018498757854104042,
0.705072820186615,
0.03204602003097534,
0.3612824082374573,
-0.1547853946685791,
-0.3226337134838104,
-1.0593044757843018,
-0.14724358916282654,
0.11967764049768448,
0.30282217264175415,
-0.7106854319572449,
0.5279008150100708,
-0.3154260218143463,
-0.41164687275886536,
-0.6918038129806519,
0.38150349259376526,
0.23818519711494446,
0.13136500120162964,
0.317059189081192,
-0.2019330859184265,
-0.7712079882621765,
-1.2159160375595093,
-0.33380821347236633,
-0.039932165294885635,
0.1737271100282669,
0.082156702876091,
0.55208420753479,
-0.34667685627937317,
1.1482230424880981,
-0.15728679299354553,
-0.1871528923511505,
-0.202241912484169,
0.094425730407238,
-0.1718055009841919,
0.5865951180458069,
0.591925323009491,
-0.5273711085319519,
-0.2894812226295471,
-0.0021864352747797966,
-0.9189606308937073,
-0.05971693992614746,
-0.47638341784477234,
-0.3251163363456726,
-0.15415014326572418,
0.562764048576355,
-0.6351050734519958,
0.16164270043373108,
0.668703556060791,
-0.08025749772787094,
0.23059400916099548,
-0.29453757405281067,
-0.25887519121170044,
-1.1307567358016968,
-0.2714652717113495,
0.15831635892391205,
0.03782019764184952,
-0.55283123254776,
0.03617258742451668,
0.037549521774053574,
-0.024291494861245155,
-0.19460463523864746,
0.6184912323951721,
-0.752526581287384,
0.008223311975598335,
-0.15903297066688538,
0.23522000014781952,
-0.45068442821502686,
0.5222656726837158,
0.14449308812618256,
0.5257911682128906,
0.7989630103111267,
-0.46162956953048706,
0.3120113015174866,
0.4199373722076416,
-0.14500808715820312,
0.3964289426803589,
-0.4920767843723297,
0.3881074786186218,
-0.28385382890701294,
0.04066755250096321,
-0.5943524241447449,
-0.2566169202327728,
0.34240788221359253,
-0.2847808003425598,
0.4748930037021637,
0.011861458420753479,
-0.6648553609848022,
-0.19894561171531677,
-0.22150780260562897,
0.3300934135913849,
0.45953258872032166,
-0.9291181564331055,
0.9101876616477966,
0.3644063174724579,
-0.14308606088161469,
-0.3927817940711975,
-0.5621640682220459,
0.4655182659626007,
-0.4072047173976898,
-0.5152377486228943,
0.1520015001296997,
-0.09991492331027985,
-0.16169898211956024,
-0.2126235067844391,
0.012699543498456478,
0.1788143813610077,
0.2674562931060791,
0.36312785744667053,
-0.07776708900928497,
-0.15760304033756256,
0.26446008682250977,
0.2543216645717621,
0.05530015006661415,
0.4448093771934509,
-0.5165314078330994,
0.49405166506767273,
-0.1743355244398117,
-0.5669971704483032,
-0.39935237169265747,
0.040116071701049805,
0.3431157171726227,
-0.4070141017436981,
0.5510895252227783,
0.21343262493610382,
-0.686495840549469,
-0.6501967310905457,
-0.39398059248924255,
-0.15732555091381073,
-0.6182023882865906,
0.5205050110816956,
-0.15909607708454132,
-0.8337423801422119,
0.29698073863983154,
-0.33640149235725403,
0.2863585948944092,
0.3349567651748657,
0.4622381031513214,
-0.17685265839099884,
1.1394670009613037,
0.5418198108673096,
0.15699924528598785,
0.5767152309417725,
-0.12930770218372345,
0.16648578643798828,
-0.9074382185935974,
-0.433811217546463,
-0.3059079647064209,
-0.6205071210861206,
-0.5241270661354065,
-0.10438167303800583,
0.3088219165802002,
-0.0493873655796051,
-0.6426188349723816,
0.3459320664405823,
-0.6264508962631226,
0.30177268385887146,
0.5569428205490112,
0.08431360125541687,
0.01409410685300827,
-0.015443517826497555,
-0.10931691527366638,
-0.31153181195259094,
-0.8188773393630981,
-0.4986034333705902,
0.858931303024292,
0.4767444431781769,
0.7803924083709717,
0.02413809299468994,
1.0072799921035767,
-0.019706198945641518,
0.32198596000671387,
-0.5098602771759033,
0.6500129103660583,
0.27922162413597107,
-0.3998715281486511,
-0.39831632375717163,
-0.28717875480651855,
-1.0152647495269775,
0.236285999417305,
-0.3882981538772583,
-0.7940084338188171,
0.12979482114315033,
0.3828704059123993,
-0.3385546803474426,
0.1899239718914032,
-0.5218409299850464,
0.9984513521194458,
-0.9557624459266663,
-0.20615482330322266,
-0.20666420459747314,
-0.6905760169029236,
0.08112357556819916,
-0.4300191104412079,
0.029698891565203667,
0.07117482274770737,
-0.2052052617073059,
0.7395499348640442,
-0.0631689578294754,
1.1065659523010254,
-0.1723867952823639,
-0.007999926805496216,
0.2122400552034378,
0.20082896947860718,
0.6688274145126343,
0.0020241690799593925,
0.041546694934368134,
0.0822976753115654,
-0.2903781533241272,
-0.06643728166818619,
-0.7612819671630859,
0.7092915773391724,
-0.6657109260559082,
-0.6280165910720825,
-0.4976203739643097,
-0.4322046935558319,
-0.3964591324329376,
0.17694568634033203,
0.04133441299200058,
0.17124132812023163,
-0.030840113759040833,
0.19572265446186066,
0.44380682706832886,
-0.2985442876815796,
0.4938662648200989,
0.2666781544685364,
-0.1851213276386261,
-0.4904555082321167,
0.6380184888839722,
0.034208524972200394,
0.1894896924495697,
-0.003961136098951101,
0.19528163969516754,
-0.321274995803833,
-0.7786030173301697,
-0.634848415851593,
0.20744217932224274,
-0.7700034379959106,
-0.20593541860580444,
-0.6981661915779114,
-0.29845675826072693,
-0.3106195330619812,
-0.1332511305809021,
-0.44767066836357117,
-0.11940096318721771,
-0.4197096824645996,
-0.13137322664260864,
0.4369733929634094,
0.9380539655685425,
0.09387026727199554,
0.35673558712005615,
-0.41058775782585144,
-0.13108417391777039,
0.1693047732114792,
0.3972170054912567,
0.14548341929912567,
-0.6145432591438293,
-0.30591750144958496,
0.3796626329421997,
-0.4508994221687317,
-0.7452442646026611,
0.6488420963287354,
0.4528900682926178,
0.7661037445068359,
0.4319368600845337,
-0.09549890458583832,
1.019927740097046,
-0.6172810792922974,
0.5813060998916626,
0.1950439065694809,
-0.8347824811935425,
0.7463804483413696,
-0.37207502126693726,
0.261310338973999,
0.5797776579856873,
0.2870146334171295,
-0.5492957234382629,
-0.5596576929092407,
-0.6318625211715698,
-0.6919792890548706,
0.6278923749923706,
0.3470800518989563,
0.35786357522010803,
-0.12346266955137253,
0.620888888835907,
0.03681807965040207,
0.20692530274391174,
-0.7950765490531921,
-0.2015494704246521,
-0.1679357886314392,
-0.5902432799339294,
0.15836909413337708,
0.08472366631031036,
0.04833464324474335,
-0.557351291179657,
0.6379731893539429,
-0.38962921500205994,
0.2584434747695923,
0.08871971070766449,
-0.12719914317131042,
-0.13848291337490082,
-0.03997861221432686,
0.4370894730091095,
0.40550315380096436,
0.19394290447235107,
0.09519706666469574,
0.5067288875579834,
-0.3028842806816101,
0.011983745731413364,
-0.012781338766217232,
-0.16822654008865356,
-0.2583523988723755,
0.27968549728393555,
0.9618558287620544,
0.45737335085868835,
-0.6850990056991577,
0.2414436787366867,
0.1252443492412567,
-0.038917023688554764,
-0.6870684623718262,
0.1781282126903534,
0.23428238928318024,
0.5367118120193481,
0.11761486530303955,
0.053836070001125336,
0.04374223202466965,
-0.34245821833610535,
0.08058379590511322,
0.5143874287605286,
-0.32146647572517395,
-0.5158114433288574,
0.8343194723129272,
0.15842539072036743,
-0.49081504344940186,
0.8806467056274414,
-0.23241959512233734,
-0.6102845668792725,
0.7269092202186584,
0.8678320646286011,
1.231600284576416,
-0.1698610782623291,
-0.03216211870312691,
0.3718222975730896,
0.408531129360199,
-0.2283117175102234,
0.1486414074897766,
-0.0379282608628273,
-0.6133388876914978,
-0.242477148771286,
-0.8694339394569397,
-0.3136794865131378,
0.0812629908323288,
-0.26297321915626526,
0.4750511944293976,
-0.5424497127532959,
0.02667209506034851,
-0.08872508257627487,
-0.4705249071121216,
-0.7585950493812561,
0.17255820333957672,
0.43234026432037354,
0.8631273508071899,
-0.6319987177848816,
0.8798133134841919,
0.7423838376998901,
-0.2429143637418747,
-0.5841307640075684,
-0.08601725846529007,
0.1039755567908287,
-0.9354053735733032,
0.9238250851631165,
0.33406996726989746,
-0.19048944115638733,
0.2897154986858368,
-0.6601440906524658,
-1.1354875564575195,
1.1416008472442627,
0.813106119632721,
-0.5322607755661011,
-0.24542538821697235,
0.1897570639848709,
0.7704484462738037,
-0.6391574144363403,
-0.0025217917282134295,
0.39083102345466614,
0.5333749651908875,
-0.20425882935523987,
-0.7702258825302124,
0.048110682517290115,
-0.3891748785972595,
0.06740047037601471,
0.24007564783096313,
-0.5360668301582336,
0.505100667476654,
-0.20767827332019806,
-0.3606569468975067,
0.021759269759058952,
0.7976659536361694,
0.0385420136153698,
-0.04748640954494476,
0.55071622133255,
0.6348659992218018,
0.4036446511745453,
-0.0969519391655922,
0.8627166152000427,
-0.44403085112571716,
0.27437523007392883,
1.1538454294204712,
-0.15507541596889496,
0.8991173505783081,
0.5024878978729248,
-0.053108420222997665,
0.41912606358528137,
0.9196012616157532,
-0.13438864052295685,
0.4674649238586426,
0.40111416578292847,
-0.10744104534387589,
-0.5054395794868469,
0.07492247223854065,
-0.2041434645652771,
0.717013418674469,
0.3857213854789734,
-0.44982367753982544,
-0.30998826026916504,
-0.10531194508075714,
-0.29497435688972473,
0.08249098062515259,
0.044201068580150604,
0.7201582193374634,
0.15035998821258545,
-0.637631356716156,
0.35145726799964905,
-0.233205184340477,
0.7685518860816956,
-0.821022629737854,
-0.17828580737113953,
0.001837593619711697,
-0.030690161511301994,
-0.0848948061466217,
-0.68709397315979,
0.19186656177043915,
-0.2118413895368576,
0.5494508147239685,
-0.6067632436752319,
0.48325809836387634,
-0.48551127314567566,
-0.24529695510864258,
0.41416892409324646,
0.5246865153312683,
-0.038195736706256866,
-0.0143453823402524,
-0.8413664698600769,
-0.16841670870780945,
-0.15624156594276428,
-0.4296725392341614,
0.45753908157348633,
0.550154983997345,
0.051636502146720886,
0.85172039270401,
0.49134233593940735,
-0.029482580721378326,
0.1414848417043686,
-0.06913671642541885,
0.7644384503364563,
-0.6580629348754883,
-0.6098475456237793,
-1.147160530090332,
0.23748068511486053,
-0.3343501687049866,
-0.6325874328613281,
0.7396358251571655,
0.6387142539024353,
0.825681209564209,
-0.05371199548244476,
0.7093026041984558,
0.0899190828204155,
-0.15250469744205475,
-0.5047774910926819,
0.8160938024520874,
-0.5882408618927002,
0.0950649306178093,
-0.11185114085674286,
-1.0188288688659668,
-0.2849731147289276,
0.7984012365341187,
-0.1586994081735611,
0.23487766087055206,
0.5235106945037842,
0.5384206771850586,
-0.0999169871211052,
0.19464851915836334,
0.0970473662018776,
0.13687752187252045,
0.18851372599601746,
0.4182080924510956,
1.047228455543518,
0.04077863320708275,
0.2717910706996918,
-0.30065831542015076,
-0.11194539070129395,
0.08234402537345886,
-1.0068024396896362,
-0.9607712626457214,
-0.7072384357452393,
-0.35183238983154297,
0.055279459804296494,
0.26292768120765686,
1.5524647235870361,
0.7318743467330933,
-0.5253608226776123,
-0.1918698400259018,
-0.383088618516922,
-0.514487087726593,
-0.07921486347913742,
-0.06529723107814789,
0.24560266733169556,
-0.6111897230148315,
-0.7147452235221863,
0.4262421131134033,
0.4977763891220093,
0.38613754510879517,
-0.5315294861793518,
-0.3218196630477905,
-0.03368140012025833,
0.05938270315527916,
0.4434658885002136,
0.3878626823425293,
-0.8400428891181946,
-0.5512741804122925,
0.061610300093889236,
-0.09159055352210999,
0.17464597523212433,
0.5069815516471863,
-0.8542752861976624,
0.7870056629180908,
0.0569828562438488,
1.0420763492584229,
0.2524169087409973,
-0.19386067986488342,
0.7525600790977478,
-0.8475256562232971,
0.07694480568170547,
0.287994384765625,
0.5790361762046814,
0.3426499366760254,
-0.3965089023113251,
0.5540394186973572,
0.02772713638842106,
-0.3939036428928375,
-0.7932828664779663,
0.16750527918338776,
-0.8618435859680176,
-0.010828523896634579,
1.3395484685897827,
0.19797514379024506,
-0.24571995437145233,
0.005091427825391293,
-0.20253871381282806,
0.25751161575317383,
-0.20969535410404205,
1.1179507970809937,
0.5605776309967041,
-0.31627538800239563,
-0.08114916831254959,
-0.6856930255889893,
0.6083269715309143,
0.4833880364894867,
-1.1237167119979858,
0.15654517710208893,
0.48303085565567017,
0.10717210173606873,
0.10484445095062256,
0.1461818516254425,
0.24670712649822235,
0.08258301764726639,
-0.13231076300144196,
0.2873671352863312,
-0.28526413440704346,
-0.3047668933868408,
-0.6238492131233215,
-0.1518436223268509,
0.2588137090206146,
-0.19763481616973877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11727v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11727v2 | 1000 African Voices: Advancing inclusive multi-speaker multi-accent speech synthesis | 2024-06-17T16:46:10 | 2024-06-27T08:52:54 | Sewade Ogun, Abraham T. Owodunni, Tobi Olatunji, Eniola Alese, Babatunde Oladimeji, Tejumade Afonja, Kayode Olaleye, Naome A. Etori, Tosin Adewumi | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | Recent advances in speech synthesis have enabled many useful applications
like audio directions in Google Maps, screen readers, and automated content
generation on platforms like TikTok. However, these systems are mostly
dominated by voices sourced from data-rich geographies with personas
representative of their source data. Although 3000 of the world's languages are
domiciled in Africa, African voices and personas are under-represented in these
systems. As speech synthesis becomes increasingly democratized, it is desirable
to increase the representation of African English accents. We present Afro-TTS,
the first pan-African accented English speech synthesis system able to generate
speech in 86 African accents, with 1000 personas representing the rich
phonological diversity across the continent for downstream application in
Education, Public Health, and Automated Content Creation. Speaker interpolation
retains naturalness and accentedness, enabling the creation of new voices. | [
-1.0412344932556152,
-0.3221870958805084,
0.31772300601005554,
0.5631877779960632,
-0.104079470038414,
0.5302403569221497,
-0.22483743727207184,
-0.4846705496311188,
0.8754921555519104,
0.28506937623023987,
-0.6740639209747314,
-0.3298172950744629,
-0.3906323313713074,
0.5081531405448914,
-0.39068976044654846,
0.551399827003479,
0.796785831451416,
0.005653566215187311,
0.4460236728191376,
-0.3105821907520294,
-0.18660050630569458,
-0.793035626411438,
-0.6712305545806885,
0.1405525803565979,
0.5440975427627563,
0.7790592908859253,
0.5837191343307495,
-0.01214336883276701,
-0.45831170678138733,
0.32945242524147034,
0.14129257202148438,
0.5429706573486328,
-0.11682352423667908,
0.2747178077697754,
0.1668710559606552,
0.05121108144521713,
-0.7114580869674683,
-0.22662313282489777,
0.28886091709136963,
0.7738186717033386,
0.17369124293327332,
-0.0744156688451767,
0.289678692817688,
0.2821519374847412,
-0.269774854183197,
-0.0966431200504303,
-0.6013437509536743,
-0.36389222741127014,
-0.20378939807415009,
-0.22019018232822418,
-0.24012474715709686,
-0.4819207787513733,
0.16316089034080505,
-0.523938000202179,
0.239022895693779,
-0.17397548258304596,
0.23065125942230225,
-0.15167683362960815,
-0.4238860011100769,
-0.2947711944580078,
-0.6775998473167419,
0.48057860136032104,
-0.7717581987380981,
0.5378435850143433,
0.14418631792068481,
0.3405725061893463,
-0.27006813883781433,
-0.8646553158760071,
-0.8605206608772278,
-0.09392190724611282,
0.413180410861969,
-0.09871044009923935,
0.0506758838891983,
0.09128888696432114,
-0.17470704019069672,
0.11467451602220535,
-0.2098071575164795,
0.03138988837599754,
-0.36468973755836487,
-0.35193854570388794,
0.9008815288543701,
-0.13381128013134003,
0.33953574299812317,
-0.2526026666164398,
0.0545990951359272,
-0.08439568430185318,
-0.6931174397468567,
-0.0849645584821701,
0.7039686441421509,
0.9678037762641907,
0.0040835733525455,
0.41834741830825806,
-0.081336110830307,
0.3198358714580536,
-0.08681109547615051,
-0.25055068731307983,
0.3743008077144623,
-0.048556406050920486,
0.21263419091701508,
0.46164044737815857,
0.7817876935005188,
0.1784360706806183,
0.5330913662910461,
-0.15534837543964386,
-0.0018566135549917817,
-0.13885046541690826,
0.2981301546096802,
-0.6347320675849915,
0.22067990899085999,
0.32318729162216187,
0.02414647489786148,
0.209000825881958,
0.025285588577389717,
-1.2100096940994263,
-0.49706563353538513,
-0.176884263753891,
0.40579068660736084,
-0.49936890602111816,
-0.3085365891456604,
-0.13792769610881805,
-0.0158296599984169,
-0.09555897116661072,
0.1643989384174347,
-1.1050325632095337,
0.3771171271800995,
0.47232070565223694,
0.7024123668670654,
0.1011311262845993,
-0.4342935085296631,
-0.1954292356967926,
0.12274180352687836,
-0.24932122230529785,
0.3812558948993683,
-0.3438955843448639,
-0.8282771110534668,
0.07137840986251831,
0.0617716945707798,
0.39580267667770386,
-0.471576988697052,
0.4520704448223114,
-0.0017106587765738368,
-0.16326041519641876,
-0.45822498202323914,
-0.13930414617061615,
-0.07694648951292038,
-0.36488205194473267,
-0.5454879999160767,
1.0130374431610107,
0.23124684393405914,
0.03834566846489906,
0.335227370262146,
-0.4908289313316345,
-0.7387700080871582,
0.2587480843067169,
-0.11769355833530426,
-0.12954552471637726,
0.2746247947216034,
0.6897538900375366,
0.1506500244140625,
-0.1312064826488495,
-0.07141643017530441,
-0.08945804834365845,
-0.21094709634780884,
0.1211407259106636,
-0.5111375451087952,
0.7876344919204712,
0.3654806613922119,
-0.7414507269859314,
-0.20367276668548584,
-0.9899953007698059,
0.15415862202644348,
-0.006100434344261885,
0.085774265229702,
-0.10249529033899307,
-0.22641156613826752,
0.34578147530555725,
0.11906716227531433,
-0.09039251506328583,
-0.7277247309684753,
0.07257816940546036,
-0.424957275390625,
0.5758547186851501,
0.47882935404777527,
0.2608300447463989,
0.14125660061836243,
-0.09132806956768036,
0.5755285620689392,
-0.26248621940612793,
-0.12143763899803162,
-0.41156893968582153,
-1.0651048421859741,
-0.6686111688613892,
-0.3366495668888092,
0.2968124449253082,
0.3896021544933319,
-0.5875452160835266,
0.5436471700668335,
-0.29862159490585327,
-0.4316459596157074,
-0.9393335580825806,
-0.1623721420764923,
-0.12417367100715637,
0.2547735273838043,
0.34308233857154846,
-0.32248666882514954,
-0.8506681323051453,
-0.9311577677726746,
-0.1467110812664032,
-0.07649768143892288,
-0.5014985203742981,
0.26950183510780334,
0.06965939700603485,
0.0069951461628079414,
0.8189114332199097,
0.14813578128814697,
-0.2604216933250427,
-0.19224485754966736,
0.05239112675189972,
-0.15606963634490967,
0.3096131384372711,
0.8317318558692932,
-0.5573237538337708,
-0.5190521478652954,
-0.029082542285323143,
-0.1302938312292099,
-0.40255141258239746,
0.04185107350349426,
0.13840797543525696,
0.14951255917549133,
0.3849528133869171,
-0.3661603629589081,
0.4355221688747406,
0.7257381081581116,
-0.11868428438901901,
0.3032020926475525,
0.004681339021772146,
0.559889554977417,
-1.1662551164627075,
-0.05836854130029678,
-0.35165929794311523,
-0.2690545320510864,
-0.6435540914535522,
-0.28672319650650024,
-0.3673281669616699,
-0.691017746925354,
-0.35812222957611084,
0.42608195543289185,
-0.5143460035324097,
-0.4062761962413788,
-0.06264946609735489,
0.30870911478996277,
0.19050584733486176,
0.5610399842262268,
-0.09054591506719589,
1.2549153566360474,
0.2247180938720703,
-0.5451231002807617,
0.20256225764751434,
0.4660164713859558,
-0.3448079824447632,
0.7587903738021851,
-0.6222465634346008,
0.4236541986465454,
0.1268840879201889,
0.15634234249591827,
-1.3641666173934937,
-0.10193868726491928,
-0.3286285400390625,
-0.8308529853820801,
0.04691513627767563,
0.10273819416761398,
-0.13934724032878876,
-0.3659364879131317,
-0.04829622805118561,
0.25968441367149353,
0.3773578703403473,
-0.6476035714149475,
0.6297337412834167,
0.8283066749572754,
-1.0114343166351318,
-0.30208730697631836,
-0.7215793132781982,
0.7178911566734314,
0.054762620478868484,
-0.6128230690956116,
0.3004714548587799,
0.05141620337963104,
-0.047557611018419266,
-0.2397148758172989,
0.0838811919093132,
-0.08161235600709915,
-0.12494393438100815,
0.19885312020778656,
-0.3396438658237457,
-0.04927859827876091,
-0.12010081857442856,
0.23510831594467163,
0.13532844185829163,
-0.13279010355472565,
-0.4568594694137573,
0.7678389549255371,
0.15029293298721313,
-0.2601204216480255,
-0.3156270980834961,
0.9951760172843933,
0.9625666737556458,
-0.3016842007637024,
0.6168007254600525,
0.20685578882694244,
-0.3780291676521301,
-0.2794156074523926,
-0.5644232034683228,
-0.2785051167011261,
-0.5033427476882935,
0.4650680720806122,
-0.5025669932365417,
-0.7130787372589111,
0.7231442332267761,
-0.07108689099550247,
0.17080536484718323,
0.2576516270637512,
0.4952886402606964,
-0.009081010706722736,
1.005213975906372,
0.27772605419158936,
0.15852437913417816,
0.34211310744285583,
-0.0938706025481224,
0.3024674952030182,
-0.6629166603088379,
-0.2919774651527405,
-0.8203455209732056,
-0.4794604182243347,
-0.7801884412765503,
-0.0031889223027974367,
0.8189195394515991,
-0.54534912109375,
-0.16968676447868347,
0.3143994212150574,
-0.5489184856414795,
0.1472349613904953,
0.9592040181159973,
0.18039177358150482,
-0.02274753339588642,
0.17431549727916718,
-0.2559976875782013,
-0.30619731545448303,
-0.4788542687892914,
-0.49885988235473633,
1.0220927000045776,
-0.07470977306365967,
0.1934499591588974,
0.21912245452404022,
0.7149994373321533,
0.4656003415584564,
0.06759658455848694,
-0.4835628271102905,
0.602323055267334,
-0.33541402220726013,
-0.571247398853302,
-0.5061519145965576,
-0.13020071387290955,
-1.013700008392334,
0.15842658281326294,
-0.2537735104560852,
-0.6759803295135498,
0.46685877442359924,
0.014013401232659817,
-0.4364868104457855,
0.2436668872833252,
-0.7393144965171814,
0.45028385519981384,
-0.11814016848802567,
-0.15252754092216492,
-0.16937944293022156,
-0.7259364128112793,
-0.06192152947187424,
0.011521431617438793,
0.35773834586143494,
0.06626590341329575,
0.15212959051132202,
0.4764117896556854,
-0.6110292673110962,
0.4743911325931549,
-0.37939706444740295,
0.005435222759842873,
0.43970945477485657,
0.07108882814645767,
0.2058659940958023,
0.0006570429541170597,
-0.3311658501625061,
0.3916071355342865,
-0.2686491310596466,
-0.22757494449615479,
-0.25263118743896484,
0.7141579389572144,
-0.885823130607605,
-0.4964470863342285,
0.03342309221625328,
-0.5090773701667786,
-0.8045509457588196,
0.14405980706214905,
0.40435320138931274,
0.7458389401435852,
-0.3423694670200348,
0.205775648355484,
0.2293226420879364,
-0.47710978984832764,
0.5068853497505188,
0.14457504451274872,
-0.007473397068679333,
-1.1764425039291382,
0.6540706157684326,
0.2765793204307556,
0.3758622109889984,
0.028329795226454735,
-0.21470335125923157,
-0.5060327649116516,
-0.5094053745269775,
-0.504319429397583,
0.21776074171066284,
-0.5434147715568542,
0.014313647523522377,
-0.7078554034233093,
-0.0745459794998169,
-0.9522216320037842,
-0.3342941701412201,
-0.38381868600845337,
-0.9542784690856934,
0.03782574087381363,
-0.3308885395526886,
0.2736451029777527,
0.7921594977378845,
-0.31519147753715515,
0.6162440776824951,
-0.6244707107543945,
0.6473132371902466,
0.6614429950714111,
0.20370051264762878,
0.012822706252336502,
-0.4044073820114136,
-0.2133740782737732,
0.20714116096496582,
-0.2260589748620987,
-1.214069128036499,
0.7257675528526306,
0.4605415165424347,
0.48819422721862793,
0.14377152919769287,
0.03166745603084564,
0.69666588306427,
-0.824522852897644,
1.0434937477111816,
0.042660489678382874,
-1.1312236785888672,
0.320019006729126,
-0.09664370864629745,
0.45185041427612305,
0.6003347635269165,
0.22695434093475342,
-0.6897954940795898,
-0.7325807809829712,
-0.5028290748596191,
-1.1646298170089722,
0.4832448661327362,
0.24529966711997986,
0.2048650085926056,
-0.14059093594551086,
0.05405646935105324,
0.49745264649391174,
0.32525843381881714,
-0.3045969605445862,
-0.511346161365509,
-0.6431299448013306,
-0.22377975285053253,
-0.2642709016799927,
-0.2600173056125641,
-0.12751619517803192,
-0.26359736919403076,
0.9697201251983643,
-0.17369797825813293,
0.43352648615837097,
0.31971240043640137,
0.07442480325698853,
0.028229370713233948,
0.48127228021621704,
0.6416413187980652,
0.6305842399597168,
-0.08551424741744995,
0.04352280870079994,
-0.06287725269794464,
-0.6779704689979553,
0.47238537669181824,
0.43491435050964355,
-0.24109497666358948,
0.4816565215587616,
0.013082833029329777,
0.89629727602005,
0.10940790921449661,
-0.31632229685783386,
0.1020522341132164,
-0.0573892779648304,
-0.06439030170440674,
-0.41795676946640015,
-0.29095327854156494,
0.24161623418331146,
-0.09835807979106903,
0.8710843920707703,
-0.15340031683444977,
0.07832265645265579,
-0.5383346676826477,
0.27794626355171204,
0.36662790179252625,
-0.09585686028003693,
-0.38292059302330017,
1.0838720798492432,
0.852020800113678,
-0.7410720586776733,
0.4434840679168701,
-0.014632008969783783,
-0.36730995774269104,
0.51300448179245,
0.3760415017604828,
1.2157411575317383,
-0.7728605270385742,
0.1442566215991974,
0.3426274359226227,
0.4954478144645691,
0.5274313688278198,
0.6081588268280029,
0.15637056529521942,
-0.3997836112976074,
-0.23860867321491241,
-0.513992965221405,
-0.7251724004745483,
0.12343667447566986,
-0.47793614864349365,
0.31509700417518616,
-0.3215855062007904,
-0.5477242469787598,
0.2290322631597519,
-0.2475050836801529,
-0.5200279951095581,
0.2945028245449066,
0.41574329137802124,
0.6616846919059753,
-0.8076122999191284,
0.6450204849243164,
0.46376389265060425,
-0.21500445902347565,
-0.6783856749534607,
-0.15684084594249725,
0.08291458338499069,
-0.5532379150390625,
-0.015682009980082512,
0.14175768196582794,
-0.18939463794231415,
0.24981053173542023,
-0.21946673095226288,
-0.484596848487854,
0.6247072219848633,
0.6991943120956421,
-0.6454837322235107,
0.17527243494987488,
0.8227123618125916,
0.4275691509246826,
-0.4737335443496704,
0.3721362054347992,
0.3920786678791046,
0.50310218334198,
-0.022048696875572205,
-1.2127141952514648,
-0.4333495795726776,
-0.127249613404274,
-0.06328948587179184,
0.010039113461971283,
-0.5178521871566772,
0.8484548330307007,
-0.10735247284173965,
-0.17345039546489716,
0.1974887251853943,
0.5705652832984924,
0.2391672134399414,
0.15719985961914062,
0.5363796353340149,
0.23441357910633087,
0.7206261157989502,
-0.26897478103637695,
0.7306551337242126,
-0.5303635001182556,
-0.32092633843421936,
0.915794849395752,
-0.386959046125412,
0.4026332497596741,
0.37997540831565857,
-0.40110787749290466,
0.5679833292961121,
0.3879969120025635,
0.7056756019592285,
0.4857640862464905,
-0.24282990396022797,
-0.7068451642990112,
0.09997151792049408,
-0.1742684245109558,
-0.45961204171180725,
0.5533198714256287,
0.6999172568321228,
0.05780402570962906,
0.13328179717063904,
0.23425300419330597,
-0.18922947347164154,
0.12495710700750351,
-0.3132868707180023,
0.6660605669021606,
0.07408750057220459,
-0.5735539793968201,
0.41069579124450684,
-0.34492430090904236,
0.37547069787979126,
-1.0219395160675049,
-0.1371067464351654,
-0.42132487893104553,
-0.13197483122348785,
-0.08796100318431854,
-0.6348199844360352,
0.04261781647801399,
-0.1715015172958374,
0.02607754059135914,
-0.22203266620635986,
0.20155294239521027,
-0.6798792481422424,
-0.289626806974411,
0.29897555708885193,
0.42659085988998413,
0.03289150819182396,
-0.18552318215370178,
-0.11457212269306183,
0.09070271998643875,
0.1262454390525818,
-0.07089201360940933,
0.07398955523967743,
0.7035960555076599,
-0.08843015879392624,
0.43437930941581726,
0.5660857558250427,
0.5496261119842529,
0.4152616858482361,
0.23351788520812988,
0.4579519033432007,
-0.5906960368156433,
-1.0570814609527588,
-0.39227521419525146,
0.659923791885376,
0.024339476600289345,
-0.33436480164527893,
0.8970164656639099,
0.45257648825645447,
0.6120119690895081,
-0.026196882128715515,
1.2079591751098633,
-0.16399261355400085,
0.7150654792785645,
0.017958786338567734,
0.5074021220207214,
-0.36529088020324707,
-0.022647306323051453,
-0.47905707359313965,
-1.2548015117645264,
0.03317827731370926,
0.22000594437122345,
0.4576372802257538,
-0.026938607916235924,
0.3480433523654938,
0.7804878950119019,
0.15172629058361053,
0.25076907873153687,
0.4625675082206726,
0.02698107808828354,
0.4732474982738495,
0.15962715446949005,
0.427320271730423,
-0.34248554706573486,
0.51381915807724,
-0.24393080174922943,
-0.19950394332408905,
-0.014983784407377243,
-0.6152825951576233,
-0.18188264966011047,
-0.7352384328842163,
0.07929850369691849,
-0.4046579897403717,
0.049146492034196854,
0.9986730217933655,
0.8802367448806763,
-1.2195496559143066,
-0.38337671756744385,
0.3469734489917755,
-0.18702957034111023,
-0.39018502831459045,
-0.23731648921966553,
0.09850391000509262,
0.1851896494626999,
-1.1797280311584473,
0.8829108476638794,
0.3948361873626709,
0.11696988344192505,
-0.5045340061187744,
-0.010204006917774677,
-0.14678391814231873,
0.39477992057800293,
0.5524740815162659,
0.6489809155464172,
-0.6362080574035645,
-0.36459285020828247,
-0.09296419471502304,
0.12695583701133728,
0.2736354172229767,
0.8029116988182068,
-0.8170639276504517,
0.7841095328330994,
0.13372671604156494,
0.6912263631820679,
0.46001943945884705,
-0.06386168301105499,
0.8394955992698669,
-1.27985417842865,
0.7292543649673462,
0.4355573356151581,
0.4307560324668884,
0.6693295240402222,
-0.06882162392139435,
0.30731192231178284,
0.08341426402330399,
-0.5986875295639038,
-0.6546415090560913,
0.14007550477981567,
-0.962219774723053,
0.060467593371868134,
1.0518568754196167,
0.07774274051189423,
0.21687567234039307,
-0.3142213821411133,
-0.3392234742641449,
0.2541877329349518,
-0.7393149733543396,
0.6761593818664551,
0.5313577651977539,
-0.08176122605800629,
-0.1797298640012741,
-0.5784994959831238,
0.45529481768608093,
0.23125764727592468,
-0.8552739024162292,
-0.13956628739833832,
0.6782663464546204,
-0.14641286432743073,
0.2754523754119873,
0.6339130401611328,
-0.05398726463317871,
0.14998485147953033,
0.18139919638633728,
0.5279295444488525,
0.015736812725663185,
-0.4434581398963928,
-0.2585442066192627,
0.3196389675140381,
-0.027522023767232895,
-0.3789893090724945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11721v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11721v1 | Zero-Shot Generalization during Instruction Tuning: Insights from Similarity and Granularity | 2024-06-17T16:40:21 | 2024-06-17T16:40:21 | Bingxiang He, Ning Ding, Cheng Qian, Jia Deng, Ganqu Cui, Lifan Yuan, Huan-ang Gao, Huimin Chen, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Understanding alignment techniques begins with comprehending zero-shot
generalization brought by instruction tuning, but little of the mechanism has
been understood. Existing work has largely been confined to the task level,
without considering that tasks are artificially defined and, to LLMs, merely
consist of tokens and representations. This line of research has been limited
to examining transfer between tasks from a task-pair perspective, with few
studies focusing on understanding zero-shot generalization from the perspective
of the data itself. To bridge this gap, we first demonstrate through multiple
metrics that zero-shot generalization during instruction tuning happens very
early. Next, we investigate the facilitation of zero-shot generalization from
both data similarity and granularity perspectives, confirming that encountering
highly similar and fine-grained training data earlier during instruction
tuning, without the constraints of defined "tasks", enables better
generalization. Finally, we propose a more grounded training data arrangement
method, Test-centric Multi-turn Arrangement, and show its effectiveness in
promoting continual learning and further loss reduction. For the first time, we
show that zero-shot generalization during instruction tuning is a form of
similarity-based generalization between training and test data at the instance
level. We hope our analysis will advance the understanding of zero-shot
generalization during instruction tuning and contribute to the development of
more aligned LLMs. Our code is released at
https://github.com/HBX-hbx/dynamics_of_zero-shot_generalization. | [
-0.2222272902727127,
-1.0482873916625977,
0.6071138978004456,
-0.28810909390449524,
-0.08381494134664536,
-0.1276322901248932,
-0.1904643028974533,
-0.24370723962783813,
-0.05655277147889137,
0.2689107060432434,
-0.7150449156761169,
-0.7019094824790955,
-0.39367833733558655,
-0.44298598170280457,
-0.5246455669403076,
1.2160632610321045,
-0.09537611901760101,
-0.06011483445763588,
-0.4464695155620575,
-0.13101381063461304,
-0.6889058947563171,
-0.24893666803836823,
-0.2737693190574646,
-0.6246696710586548,
0.48804670572280884,
0.6898450255393982,
0.3265782296657562,
1.1322559118270874,
0.5395314693450928,
0.21986684203147888,
0.10093554109334946,
-0.3232225775718689,
-0.5904423594474792,
0.13843533396720886,
0.030094405636191368,
-0.762271523475647,
-0.5500187277793884,
0.10263222455978394,
0.6700611710548401,
0.9260187149047852,
-0.10381877422332764,
0.302196204662323,
0.11084620654582977,
0.55577552318573,
-0.7718872427940369,
-0.03793318197131157,
-0.651081919670105,
0.3498697578907013,
-0.2731116712093353,
-0.33459144830703735,
-0.1575756072998047,
-0.1965928077697754,
-0.10776544362306595,
-0.689667820930481,
0.7333164215087891,
-0.07670323550701141,
0.7546785473823547,
0.26649659872055054,
-0.353741317987442,
-0.05701633170247078,
-0.9640676379203796,
0.8857753872871399,
-0.29851245880126953,
0.19701610505580902,
0.1263720691204071,
0.28932881355285645,
0.025778211653232574,
-0.1267760545015335,
-0.4470781683921814,
-0.007123726885765791,
0.17375504970550537,
0.1280297338962555,
0.19221198558807373,
0.28828153014183044,
0.42548710107803345,
0.5506098866462708,
-0.7223494052886963,
0.28371715545654297,
-0.24933677911758423,
-0.059383101761341095,
0.5116064548492432,
0.30754730105400085,
-0.08419832587242126,
0.4105454981327057,
-0.4674999713897705,
-0.08597106486558914,
-0.6875865459442139,
0.18431971967220306,
0.26890236139297485,
0.22309184074401855,
-0.1425970494747162,
0.38853177428245544,
-0.44700199365615845,
0.9836865663528442,
0.5669217109680176,
-0.008246504701673985,
0.23620201647281647,
-0.33935898542404175,
-0.3159927427768707,
0.19270092248916626,
0.47467485070228577,
0.5030869841575623,
0.3113371729850769,
-0.49252769351005554,
0.03313874080777168,
0.05307934433221817,
0.5653586983680725,
-0.7475281953811646,
0.1286984533071518,
0.08002746850252151,
-0.1675337702035904,
-0.4742612838745117,
0.16028156876564026,
-0.4786268472671509,
-0.01711839623749256,
-0.727753221988678,
0.5728217959403992,
-0.39579465985298157,
0.25930362939834595,
0.08188197016716003,
-0.04340110346674919,
0.9645830988883972,
0.11277107894420624,
-1.0801136493682861,
0.38161957263946533,
1.1726590394973755,
0.8038730025291443,
-0.21817053854465485,
-0.588442862033844,
-0.5836932063102722,
0.4624851644039154,
-0.505048930644989,
0.7965332865715027,
-0.5063654780387878,
-0.2505846321582794,
0.047804366797208786,
0.07349557429552078,
-0.25294390320777893,
-0.5400001406669617,
0.01063093263655901,
-0.4000840187072754,
0.1603664755821228,
-0.10236400365829468,
-0.7787472009658813,
-0.028767455369234085,
0.42285066843032837,
-0.00932351779192686,
0.8415064215660095,
0.0448949858546257,
-0.28043562173843384,
0.6107072830200195,
-0.4385475814342499,
-0.4889083802700043,
-0.14826257526874542,
-0.4849700927734375,
-0.635053277015686,
0.5690791606903076,
-0.13774648308753967,
0.45574700832366943,
0.1892988234758377,
-0.21873289346694946,
-0.5181298851966858,
-0.9344400763511658,
0.013652515597641468,
-0.055686093866825104,
0.25770103931427,
-0.13351525366306305,
-0.4857899844646454,
-0.0035663535818457603,
-0.44840988516807556,
0.23087894916534424,
-0.09023645520210266,
0.05366085469722748,
-0.2097155749797821,
-0.2800790071487427,
-0.5645959377288818,
-0.07269864529371262,
0.2743353247642517,
-0.46203428506851196,
0.649055540561676,
-0.16164718568325043,
-0.05841328203678131,
0.5717860460281372,
0.012701672501862049,
0.7815564870834351,
-0.38649019598960876,
0.6032717823982239,
0.24004648625850677,
0.2796049118041992,
-0.37215304374694824,
-0.22958694398403168,
-0.7311806082725525,
0.3627783954143524,
0.27367067337036133,
0.731817901134491,
-0.3466785252094269,
0.4015031158924103,
-0.3302193582057953,
-0.26311254501342773,
-0.4998430609703064,
0.12316365540027618,
0.6272623538970947,
0.59903484582901,
0.4166959226131439,
-0.49040549993515015,
-0.08489619940519333,
-0.7888867259025574,
-0.10655583441257477,
0.23365046083927155,
-0.14836525917053223,
0.21516107022762299,
0.2140866070985794,
-0.03777634724974632,
0.7555285692214966,
-0.7399194240570068,
-0.2798377275466919,
0.1676761955022812,
0.42594173550605774,
0.09400327503681183,
0.6728277802467346,
0.47158706188201904,
-0.30191072821617126,
-0.49001872539520264,
0.281557559967041,
-0.6652786731719971,
-0.09148640185594559,
-0.3722056448459625,
-0.355575829744339,
0.12889249622821808,
0.5992621183395386,
-0.2348400056362152,
0.49922487139701843,
0.2648943066596985,
-0.11139416694641113,
0.4916486144065857,
-0.14967265725135803,
0.3233806788921356,
-0.8596301674842834,
-0.15937259793281555,
-0.276068776845932,
-0.1817324012517929,
-0.8392711281776428,
0.04656096547842026,
0.057729557156562805,
0.007293401286005974,
-0.18928462266921997,
0.0890704020857811,
-0.3930821716785431,
-0.31468620896339417,
-0.4762841463088989,
0.07240849733352661,
-0.029545070603489876,
0.5076948404312134,
-0.14042331278324127,
0.8958511352539062,
0.7952593564987183,
-0.5700882077217102,
0.21651875972747803,
0.14819186925888062,
0.059442874044179916,
1.0053378343582153,
-0.6812910437583923,
0.4041392207145691,
-0.20272931456565857,
-0.09012845903635025,
-0.5893466472625732,
-0.09296263009309769,
0.2770043611526489,
-0.39837753772735596,
0.7564572095870972,
-0.3763796091079712,
0.1451185941696167,
-0.0027050289791077375,
-0.4721861481666565,
0.4981229305267334,
0.5109319090843201,
-0.08337292075157166,
0.1072637066245079,
-0.026661574840545654,
0.09129580110311508,
-0.6392061710357666,
-0.7249493598937988,
-0.2888859510421753,
-0.2751323878765106,
-0.2769034802913666,
0.6486619114875793,
-0.16934436559677124,
0.08394193649291992,
-0.10027359426021576,
-0.5759986639022827,
-0.32032033801078796,
0.04798373952507973,
0.4052194654941559,
0.20519106090068817,
-0.3716217279434204,
0.1253199428319931,
0.30661019682884216,
-0.1822706162929535,
-0.04817650839686394,
-0.37982210516929626,
0.4069601595401764,
-0.012272344902157784,
-0.5941863656044006,
-0.4981566071510315,
0.3465489447116852,
0.22932587563991547,
0.21228156983852386,
0.633934736251831,
0.7185262441635132,
0.1698092818260193,
-0.09838016331195831,
-0.46735212206840515,
-0.21007616817951202,
-0.4395696818828583,
0.17158599197864532,
-0.1971369981765747,
-0.8555941581726074,
0.3073498010635376,
-0.04502552002668381,
0.09556799381971359,
0.10996842384338379,
0.342572420835495,
-0.42005738615989685,
0.6293126344680786,
0.6709374189376831,
-0.15275788307189941,
0.7596146464347839,
-0.5001813173294067,
-0.053583938628435135,
-0.8634291291236877,
-0.2656148076057434,
-0.45152631402015686,
-0.7927426099777222,
-0.47930580377578735,
-0.4374903440475464,
0.1295354813337326,
0.25004667043685913,
-0.27880337834358215,
0.21412666141986847,
-0.45242753624916077,
0.9031642079353333,
0.5481458902359009,
0.06174594908952713,
0.062395576387643814,
0.1507396101951599,
0.07083591818809509,
0.0771535187959671,
-0.5443122386932373,
-0.188045471906662,
1.1534298658370972,
-0.07396560907363892,
0.6354042887687683,
-0.33988896012306213,
1.1216139793395996,
0.11196675896644592,
-0.07774447649717331,
-1.1183147430419922,
0.3951754570007324,
-0.15535114705562592,
-0.2568890154361725,
-0.2690531611442566,
-0.4732624292373657,
-1.1420193910598755,
-0.0801405981183052,
-0.061169080436229706,
-0.6026216149330139,
0.025156009942293167,
0.2392476350069046,
-0.4798063635826111,
0.13548418879508972,
-0.6476390361785889,
0.8457101583480835,
-0.2464708387851715,
-0.40251424908638,
-0.1888556182384491,
-0.663143515586853,
0.23580574989318848,
0.22991739213466644,
-0.03561008349061012,
-0.011043855920433998,
-0.14191016554832458,
0.43351981043815613,
-0.17233210802078247,
0.6541008949279785,
-0.21605418622493744,
-0.10326554626226425,
0.1002630889415741,
0.07934288680553436,
0.0763910785317421,
-0.3324442505836487,
0.21453602612018585,
0.15373598039150238,
0.04659309238195419,
-0.811133861541748,
-0.8655110001564026,
0.8411113619804382,
-0.7801583409309387,
-0.43073633313179016,
-0.2548332214355469,
-0.8254989385604858,
-0.2633918821811676,
0.17695121467113495,
0.13388630747795105,
0.4602145254611969,
-0.09556010365486145,
0.15104296803474426,
1.0053361654281616,
0.34157493710517883,
0.3859255611896515,
0.4533694088459015,
0.003708298783749342,
0.03133810684084892,
1.0463210344314575,
0.19053930044174194,
0.4277374744415283,
0.569652259349823,
-0.018356120213866234,
0.08618416637182236,
-0.7144428491592407,
-0.3616929054260254,
0.040131282061338425,
-0.22853492200374603,
-0.2973635196685791,
0.072974294424057,
-0.08778884261846542,
-0.42988836765289307,
-0.43654245138168335,
-0.29211127758026123,
-0.4168606698513031,
-0.36624759435653687,
0.04903263598680496,
0.11447333544492722,
0.6536723375320435,
0.06037862226366997,
0.6365594863891602,
-0.7788360714912415,
0.22444939613342285,
0.44367024302482605,
0.5673812627792358,
-0.15184049308300018,
-0.6718211770057678,
-0.5317202210426331,
0.13971252739429474,
-0.7359317541122437,
-0.6495745182037354,
-0.19333691895008087,
0.4350903034210205,
0.37231189012527466,
0.6980105042457581,
-0.3530057966709137,
1.0679023265838623,
-0.6530461311340332,
0.6827864646911621,
0.07528768479824066,
-0.8838816285133362,
0.5640878677368164,
-0.36243075132369995,
0.4090891480445862,
0.7641893625259399,
0.3482796251773834,
-0.4705393612384796,
-0.030301667749881744,
-0.46657902002334595,
-0.5916727185249329,
0.8856764435768127,
-0.00031037896405905485,
0.2867380976676941,
0.3020906448364258,
0.7665557265281677,
0.3262646496295929,
0.3260372579097748,
-0.21217137575149536,
-0.36408981680870056,
-0.06269410997629166,
-0.16592681407928467,
0.003119476605206728,
0.10033965110778809,
-0.36420926451683044,
-0.2926996648311615,
0.41137269139289856,
-0.34892934560775757,
0.524734616279602,
-0.0881909504532814,
-0.18888641893863678,
-0.2135080248117447,
0.36251774430274963,
0.7246833443641663,
0.33468544483184814,
-0.18572942912578583,
-0.05822142958641052,
0.19753724336624146,
-0.40667223930358887,
0.323780357837677,
-0.0855318158864975,
-0.4832878112792969,
-0.31907638907432556,
0.47833451628685,
0.9656095504760742,
0.5080962777137756,
0.09054972976446152,
0.5089471936225891,
0.21843735873699188,
-0.39035192131996155,
0.10820247232913971,
0.6060555577278137,
-0.3026762008666992,
0.2520918548107147,
0.046513479202985764,
-0.14484502375125885,
0.07379378378391266,
-0.598824679851532,
0.20501768589019775,
0.7240787744522095,
-0.4403263032436371,
-0.5842248797416687,
0.3328135311603546,
-0.031646937131881714,
-0.34476086497306824,
0.6288937330245972,
-0.25564950704574585,
-0.1085321456193924,
0.6106551885604858,
0.4769434630870819,
0.9180157780647278,
-0.15732207894325256,
0.5216628909111023,
0.13327324390411377,
-0.015041748061776161,
0.2374260127544403,
0.20174963772296906,
-0.5342524647712708,
-0.6074874401092529,
-0.44261544942855835,
-0.43736618757247925,
-0.44152605533599854,
-0.10721736401319504,
-1.1352964639663696,
0.17110183835029602,
-0.455825537443161,
0.11731144785881042,
-0.20590955018997192,
0.06004004925489426,
-0.6751058101654053,
-0.12184818089008331,
0.3694935142993927,
0.47320398688316345,
-0.8570374846458435,
0.6941904425621033,
0.8519108295440674,
-0.18974238634109497,
-0.5452226996421814,
0.3362084925174713,
0.04016484320163727,
-1.0018430948257446,
0.1273236870765686,
0.28621384501457214,
-0.02682431973516941,
-0.06367682665586472,
-0.6151648163795471,
-0.5932574272155762,
1.5435138940811157,
0.22367140650749207,
-0.7481306791305542,
-0.22838835418224335,
0.47617819905281067,
0.43650341033935547,
-0.4541555941104889,
0.23244793713092804,
0.7493463754653931,
0.2869752049446106,
0.49069178104400635,
-0.5967904925346375,
-0.22536823153495789,
0.257414311170578,
0.028319617733359337,
0.4869903326034546,
-0.6697723269462585,
0.5791181325912476,
-0.06440945714712143,
-0.02852722816169262,
-0.09954621642827988,
0.353718638420105,
-0.05788348987698555,
0.7244846224784851,
0.1690382957458496,
0.8338764309883118,
0.48741018772125244,
-0.14628124237060547,
0.8502984046936035,
-0.2522556185722351,
0.4312083125114441,
1.1871898174285889,
-0.25165876746177673,
0.5462243556976318,
0.5780916213989258,
-0.26926499605178833,
0.5072838664054871,
0.3070236146450043,
-0.029061902314424515,
0.3442823588848114,
0.09538584202528,
-0.18008986115455627,
-0.1620197892189026,
-0.10122021287679672,
-0.4127655029296875,
0.515160322189331,
0.12100505083799362,
-0.0734807476401329,
-0.3817850649356842,
-0.26071542501449585,
-0.12590894103050232,
-0.19867876172065735,
-0.5613455772399902,
1.1228201389312744,
-0.20422892272472382,
-0.4664699137210846,
0.694420576095581,
-0.47371554374694824,
0.5557112097740173,
-0.6326464414596558,
0.0066810837015509605,
-0.3367016017436981,
0.07752642035484314,
-0.2097395658493042,
-0.8189597129821777,
0.4686303436756134,
-0.33810415863990784,
-0.4294394254684448,
-0.2696518003940582,
0.4262341558933258,
-0.6123390793800354,
-0.26841169595718384,
-0.07292591780424118,
0.44648414850234985,
0.20806558430194855,
-0.03338133171200752,
-0.6719350814819336,
-0.016835255548357964,
-0.02912730909883976,
-0.046223241835832596,
0.8223580121994019,
0.4919362962245941,
0.024082498624920845,
0.14336436986923218,
0.2673030495643616,
0.11015841364860535,
0.3404189348220825,
0.011559270322322845,
0.6681919097900391,
-0.7240102887153625,
0.029889488592743874,
-0.6758729219436646,
0.28655803203582764,
0.062365684658288956,
-0.3118452727794647,
0.5305923223495483,
0.5149844288825989,
1.0285619497299194,
-0.1621924638748169,
0.37558987736701965,
0.09475486725568771,
0.09693319350481033,
-0.5746735334396362,
0.36293914914131165,
-0.5441195964813232,
-0.08517660200595856,
0.04804861545562744,
-1.0462218523025513,
-0.3129500150680542,
0.35130223631858826,
-0.46015480160713196,
0.017110932618379593,
0.5958331227302551,
0.8442711234092712,
-0.3604603707790375,
-0.32514703273773193,
0.5051555037498474,
-0.037663716822862625,
0.07490266859531403,
0.5437904000282288,
0.49090445041656494,
-0.3903046250343323,
0.5373495221138,
-0.49417662620544434,
-0.3323800563812256,
-0.19784300029277802,
-0.6769146919250488,
-0.6424769163131714,
-0.2604029178619385,
-0.4765288233757019,
0.3071625232696533,
0.07185936719179153,
0.5119450092315674,
0.7260196208953857,
-0.9342595934867859,
-0.4352119266986847,
-0.38721680641174316,
0.1413602977991104,
-0.4452548623085022,
-0.25727686285972595,
0.07803311944007874,
-0.8243593573570251,
-0.6796180605888367,
0.358470618724823,
0.30005159974098206,
0.26651841402053833,
0.040327269583940506,
0.04436825215816498,
0.056570738554000854,
-0.010595346800982952,
0.43316373229026794,
0.40605586767196655,
-0.388543963432312,
-0.33736634254455566,
0.15205129981040955,
0.1899537593126297,
0.239430233836174,
1.174957036972046,
-0.776645839214325,
0.44470512866973877,
0.23946748673915863,
0.6383255124092102,
0.4021070897579193,
0.2690713703632355,
0.34780657291412354,
-1.0441571474075317,
0.09649580717086792,
-0.025751082226634026,
-0.11163245141506195,
0.03462415188550949,
-0.3673989772796631,
0.3513612151145935,
0.17713291943073273,
-0.8165791630744934,
-0.5693114399909973,
0.42055490612983704,
-0.9832165241241455,
0.1490635871887207,
0.8081773519515991,
-0.09512551873922348,
-0.17357288300991058,
0.17188332974910736,
-0.09085866808891296,
0.4278261661529541,
-0.30622464418411255,
1.0615155696868896,
0.7024466395378113,
-0.6583529114723206,
0.02714153565466404,
-0.33216655254364014,
0.2873091399669647,
0.6277263164520264,
-0.8325369954109192,
-0.05035107582807541,
0.5022143125534058,
0.2680529057979584,
0.053116921335458755,
0.1758880913257599,
0.12450657039880753,
0.34637999534606934,
-0.1584755927324295,
-0.06469450891017914,
-0.3178684711456299,
-0.39946675300598145,
-0.7391644716262817,
0.052847910672426224,
-0.12065713852643967,
-0.7062364816665649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11717v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11717v1 | Refusal in Language Models Is Mediated by a Single Direction | 2024-06-17T16:36:12 | 2024-06-17T16:36:12 | Andy Arditi, Oscar Obeso, Aaquib Syed, Daniel Paleka, Nina Rimsky, Wes Gurnee, Neel Nanda | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Conversational large language models are fine-tuned for both
instruction-following and safety, resulting in models that obey benign requests
but refuse harmful ones. While this refusal behavior is widespread across chat
models, its underlying mechanisms remain poorly understood. In this work, we
show that refusal is mediated by a one-dimensional subspace, across 13 popular
open-source chat models up to 72B parameters in size. Specifically, for each
model, we find a single direction such that erasing this direction from the
model's residual stream activations prevents it from refusing harmful
instructions, while adding this direction elicits refusal on even harmless
instructions. Leveraging this insight, we propose a novel white-box jailbreak
method that surgically disables refusal with minimal effect on other
capabilities. Finally, we mechanistically analyze how adversarial suffixes
suppress propagation of the refusal-mediating direction. Our findings
underscore the brittleness of current safety fine-tuning methods. More broadly,
our work showcases how an understanding of model internals can be leveraged to
develop practical methods for controlling model behavior. | [
-0.377926766872406,
-1.1690449714660645,
0.4894087314605713,
0.14188441634178162,
-0.11868897080421448,
-0.013373912312090397,
-0.21471765637397766,
0.05344925820827484,
0.14376282691955566,
0.8290022015571594,
-1.0010344982147217,
-0.32791417837142944,
-0.39730292558670044,
-0.3558811843395233,
-0.49450942873954773,
1.1358907222747803,
0.2162831723690033,
-0.1149512380361557,
-0.19971135258674622,
-0.12256923317909241,
-0.6324049234390259,
-0.41478273272514343,
-0.6995949745178223,
-0.21163688600063324,
0.7346788048744202,
0.7486891150474548,
1.2464011907577515,
0.5207872986793518,
0.19355714321136475,
0.34906941652297974,
-0.28301605582237244,
-0.2036188542842865,
-0.7632768750190735,
0.1561799943447113,
-0.1273668259382248,
-0.5988887548446655,
-0.46356475353240967,
0.2724592089653015,
0.4458698034286499,
0.8308964967727661,
-0.12930108606815338,
-0.04820152744650841,
0.25623059272766113,
0.8972311019897461,
-0.5081174373626709,
-0.22578975558280945,
-1.0001686811447144,
-0.10895604640245438,
-0.13371220231056213,
-0.11729402095079422,
-0.8360650539398193,
-0.10525275021791458,
0.1755901724100113,
-0.4892386198043823,
0.15774592757225037,
-0.20015792548656464,
0.7785314321517944,
-0.12198719382286072,
-0.1216268315911293,
-0.3969447612762451,
-0.8287370204925537,
0.5066756010055542,
-0.5383890867233276,
0.4788818061351776,
0.8409072756767273,
0.18313562870025635,
-0.34883931279182434,
-0.41201451420783997,
-0.39319801330566406,
-0.5668900012969971,
-0.10192083567380905,
-0.3666455149650574,
-0.4521768093109131,
0.4168170392513275,
0.17341727018356323,
-0.2622316777706146,
-0.4018666446208954,
0.3777008056640625,
-1.0002362728118896,
-0.011633645743131638,
0.26334330439567566,
0.13408872485160828,
0.5710874795913696,
-0.0798737108707428,
-0.46721941232681274,
-0.05538403242826462,
-1.0263357162475586,
0.09226398169994354,
0.574350118637085,
0.49073848128318787,
-0.23227117955684662,
0.449865460395813,
-0.22536341845989227,
0.3989272117614746,
-0.08332357555627823,
0.2874946892261505,
-0.19125445187091827,
0.04660638049244881,
-0.3355172872543335,
-0.10503985732793808,
1.0108835697174072,
0.17943280935287476,
0.05999039113521576,
-0.15453366935253143,
0.07581964135169983,
-0.16182968020439148,
0.6298539042472839,
-0.683521032333374,
-0.10415159165859222,
0.5611464977264404,
-0.7434403300285339,
-0.5240596532821655,
-0.1822725385427475,
-0.7630890011787415,
-0.5443800091743469,
-0.1640666276216507,
0.47462090849876404,
-0.7904617786407471,
-0.2649059593677521,
0.009270665235817432,
-0.14550979435443878,
0.23672457039356232,
0.13465437293052673,
-1.0169181823730469,
0.5400032997131348,
0.7256487011909485,
0.9035924673080444,
0.3108738362789154,
-0.4484724998474121,
-0.3938981592655182,
-0.3452224135398865,
-0.6029136776924133,
0.2533896565437317,
-0.4891476035118103,
-0.536846935749054,
-0.35165053606033325,
-0.1379171758890152,
-0.006346017587929964,
-0.46155619621276855,
0.4944222867488861,
-0.7137245535850525,
-0.2706923186779022,
-0.26875847578048706,
0.017962848767638206,
-0.4922157824039459,
0.07267332077026367,
-0.4430440664291382,
-0.012029578909277916,
-0.2774411141872406,
-0.48688191175460815,
0.21769878268241882,
-0.41572245955467224,
-0.3499322533607483,
-0.21329265832901,
-0.09394912421703339,
-0.5102444291114807,
0.38521191477775574,
-0.07288933545351028,
0.320441871881485,
0.048252541571855545,
0.2631061375141144,
-0.8925963640213013,
-0.13527925312519073,
0.45761507749557495,
-1.1452683210372925,
1.0393747091293335,
0.4590567350387573,
0.027673989534378052,
0.3851475417613983,
-0.8513801097869873,
-0.22983422875404358,
0.375985324382782,
0.02156679332256317,
-0.6489257216453552,
0.5151496529579163,
-0.16325053572654724,
0.37511327862739563,
-0.27300554513931274,
-0.5330484509468079,
0.07787247747182846,
-0.41234228014945984,
0.7134851217269897,
0.9537315964698792,
-0.2677733600139618,
0.5153666138648987,
-0.13278816640377045,
0.6417391896247864,
-0.24862167239189148,
0.458394855260849,
-0.0013351663947105408,
-0.18099255859851837,
-0.7976256012916565,
-0.20109957456588745,
-0.05008047819137573,
0.29807278513908386,
-0.5833631753921509,
-0.1233893632888794,
0.04631240665912628,
-0.4718616008758545,
-0.7920595407485962,
0.14281964302062988,
0.533220112323761,
0.18571306765079498,
0.10762935876846313,
-0.0071130432188510895,
-0.3874221444129944,
-1.104181170463562,
-0.03527446836233139,
-0.4031009078025818,
0.1952817440032959,
0.04989572986960411,
0.10151863843202591,
0.1587606817483902,
0.6668853163719177,
-0.11432188004255295,
-0.19249817728996277,
-0.3282468616962433,
0.0025771588552743196,
0.10773567110300064,
0.5714762806892395,
0.897085964679718,
-0.940971314907074,
-0.1754903495311737,
-0.10760605335235596,
-0.6716806888580322,
0.21985921263694763,
-0.1829461306333542,
-0.1021500900387764,
0.08612384647130966,
0.8883965611457825,
-0.42225223779678345,
0.8570607900619507,
0.6872051954269409,
-0.49067533016204834,
0.5529005527496338,
-0.17099300026893616,
-0.00017949672474060208,
-0.6244688630104065,
-0.2060295045375824,
-0.27027949690818787,
0.06508440524339676,
-0.9216693639755249,
0.4226888418197632,
0.014997979626059532,
-0.31156331300735474,
-0.8100486397743225,
0.32696712017059326,
-0.2050071358680725,
0.5828424692153931,
-0.48122015595436096,
-0.01046918984502554,
-0.2843194901943207,
0.3461432158946991,
-0.09403377026319504,
0.4640393853187561,
0.828765869140625,
-0.9376022815704346,
0.04171580821275711,
0.47993600368499756,
0.22357220947742462,
0.30482494831085205,
-0.864088773727417,
0.16205191612243652,
-0.3969951570034027,
-0.04973016679286957,
-1.4912018775939941,
-0.05671042948961258,
0.3303528130054474,
-0.523235559463501,
0.11892903596162796,
-0.6178815960884094,
-0.038655929267406464,
-0.33837395906448364,
-0.23156443238258362,
0.14797641336917877,
0.44372671842575073,
-0.5383108854293823,
0.49842867255210876,
0.12526121735572815,
-0.2145891934633255,
-0.3039734959602356,
-0.8192406892776489,
0.018296360969543457,
-0.22475573420524597,
-0.34582245349884033,
-0.03499336540699005,
-0.2737821936607361,
-0.34065085649490356,
-0.18826188147068024,
0.005415702238678932,
-0.12816843390464783,
0.41247716546058655,
0.6886496543884277,
0.4725162982940674,
0.027026338502764702,
-0.23486071825027466,
0.18131238222122192,
-0.12524056434631348,
0.2778337597846985,
-0.0742989331483841,
0.5151482224464417,
0.1400146782398224,
-0.6611005663871765,
-0.5915268659591675,
0.3545663058757782,
1.0464086532592773,
-0.21234698593616486,
1.0461994409561157,
0.001785940839909017,
-0.13528765738010406,
-0.19520513713359833,
-0.17886130511760712,
-0.4250467121601105,
-0.5983898639678955,
0.2258249670267105,
-0.5447744727134705,
-0.8070477843284607,
0.5035279393196106,
0.3823581337928772,
0.2225513756275177,
-0.028730150312185287,
0.3133522868156433,
0.2631208300590515,
1.0333436727523804,
0.42908164858818054,
-0.25890690088272095,
0.2918846011161804,
0.08561284840106964,
0.4641873240470886,
-0.4074118137359619,
-0.03343406692147255,
-0.9389476180076599,
-0.18588155508041382,
-0.7229716777801514,
0.1155344694852829,
0.3964463174343109,
0.17938707768917084,
0.03582128882408142,
0.32501158118247986,
-0.2723492980003357,
0.4594372808933258,
0.22733888030052185,
0.41787442564964294,
0.19024404883384705,
0.07773452252149582,
-0.2572311460971832,
-0.18150897324085236,
-0.7005249857902527,
-0.37815454602241516,
0.73599773645401,
0.7425277829170227,
0.8491415977478027,
0.29410451650619507,
0.34767788648605347,
-0.18943260610103607,
0.2066192775964737,
-0.784627377986908,
0.8822716474533081,
-0.10144127160310745,
-0.8189022541046143,
-0.2186851054430008,
-0.3787238597869873,
-0.9484090209007263,
0.5755224823951721,
-0.22274942696094513,
-1.0768802165985107,
-0.0782754123210907,
0.20547854900360107,
-0.43731358647346497,
0.4436649978160858,
-0.8907598257064819,
0.7126048803329468,
0.08959478884935379,
-0.45856305956840515,
-0.5015227794647217,
-0.2825504243373871,
0.4267081022262573,
0.22031813859939575,
0.4385742247104645,
-0.24752941727638245,
0.45926207304000854,
0.3880501389503479,
-0.6715697050094604,
1.1556717157363892,
-0.11519704014062881,
-0.17566414177417755,
0.4792760908603668,
1.1361531019210815,
0.49521613121032715,
0.2090665102005005,
-0.30685558915138245,
0.009976202622056007,
-0.050875674933195114,
-0.3427973687648773,
-0.43712809681892395,
0.8147055506706238,
-0.43988174200057983,
-0.9161383509635925,
0.03996856510639191,
-0.5000346302986145,
-0.16548128426074982,
0.43815258145332336,
0.30266469717025757,
0.4917031526565552,
-0.30103084444999695,
0.3278826177120209,
0.49828726053237915,
-0.5243225693702698,
0.5195568203926086,
0.7167752981185913,
-0.5392767786979675,
0.16973160207271576,
0.8556622266769409,
0.09529270976781845,
0.9151753783226013,
-0.05258305370807648,
0.23029212653636932,
0.005151133053004742,
-0.8656268119812012,
-0.32617801427841187,
-0.15543942153453827,
-0.5196599960327148,
0.18739208579063416,
-0.4664001762866974,
-0.5281705856323242,
-0.1627400666475296,
-0.25168636441230774,
-0.7298899292945862,
-0.15502160787582397,
-0.16887064278125763,
-0.30640146136283875,
0.21765874326229095,
0.7229523062705994,
0.053783297538757324,
-0.041249830275774,
-0.7169928550720215,
0.2372543215751648,
0.3372664451599121,
0.6530476212501526,
0.2798709273338318,
-0.6495441198348999,
0.4186375141143799,
0.20645864307880402,
-0.36004942655563354,
-0.7030084133148193,
0.1900862604379654,
-0.24100252985954285,
0.2366190254688263,
0.613509476184845,
0.3719780743122101,
0.603290319442749,
-0.7278405427932739,
0.49674031138420105,
0.12269475311040878,
-0.9383681416511536,
0.7162228226661682,
-0.6906561255455017,
0.020847924053668976,
0.45037955045700073,
0.48154374957084656,
-0.4205533266067505,
-0.8662364482879639,
-0.5798725485801697,
-0.8252153396606445,
0.8195642828941345,
0.33993351459503174,
0.8376973271369934,
-0.010732222348451614,
0.19561725854873657,
0.2912192940711975,
0.003048430662602186,
-0.7246668934822083,
-0.45646536350250244,
0.09704121202230453,
0.34056976437568665,
0.2624629735946655,
-0.24332749843597412,
-0.20432886481285095,
-0.16501760482788086,
0.5181245803833008,
0.06947226077318192,
0.13568007946014404,
0.02195172943174839,
0.236569344997406,
-0.11797348409891129,
0.6425463557243347,
0.619921088218689,
0.7345871925354004,
-0.16999205946922302,
0.022880326956510544,
0.031864047050476074,
-0.33617275953292847,
0.14951278269290924,
-0.11340106278657913,
-0.5895141959190369,
-0.08334635943174362,
0.04218318313360214,
0.9397290945053101,
0.12763382494449615,
-0.4596261978149414,
0.3430549204349518,
-0.10480450093746185,
-0.4188685715198517,
0.07563643902540207,
0.18974757194519043,
-0.26337188482284546,
-0.017789572477340698,
0.1291763186454773,
0.25202494859695435,
0.10501659661531448,
-0.6255384683609009,
0.16118891537189484,
0.9226422905921936,
-0.8566926121711731,
-0.4281242787837982,
0.906346321105957,
-0.08444400876760483,
-0.248477503657341,
0.5350900292396545,
-0.3118645250797272,
-0.3174377679824829,
0.3990975022315979,
0.49478426575660706,
0.8018724918365479,
0.006573040504008532,
0.7443498969078064,
0.17700207233428955,
0.44823017716407776,
0.08782124519348145,
-0.05077037960290909,
0.29870155453681946,
-0.744928777217865,
-0.17858260869979858,
-0.305862158536911,
-0.2619520127773285,
0.4025126099586487,
-0.7616192698478699,
0.20748871564865112,
-0.996017336845398,
0.10885090380907059,
0.14587000012397766,
-0.8083073496818542,
-0.43603578209877014,
-0.23824971914291382,
0.2842279076576233,
0.9122015237808228,
-0.6610345244407654,
0.6831291913986206,
0.42206481099128723,
-0.30578306317329407,
-0.8979482054710388,
0.038354165852069855,
0.597892165184021,
-0.550892174243927,
0.2806553244590759,
-0.03266292065382004,
-0.1071474701166153,
-0.2729981541633606,
-0.9289964437484741,
-0.6144725680351257,
0.3966669738292694,
0.38092851638793945,
-0.519321858882904,
0.10135620832443237,
-0.1822594553232193,
0.31363722681999207,
0.2096586376428604,
0.07019708305597305,
0.5307189226150513,
0.08304472267627716,
0.15711304545402527,
-0.9831407070159912,
0.2539423108100891,
0.11291812360286713,
0.026978736743330956,
0.1664157658815384,
-1.0291022062301636,
0.5765469074249268,
-0.4370233118534088,
-0.14205016195774078,
0.3950514495372772,
0.49529170989990234,
0.3530254662036896,
0.044548217207193375,
0.6258687973022461,
0.14325375854969025,
0.18043135106563568,
-0.0048771807923913,
0.9726988673210144,
0.08851592987775803,
0.21780619025230408,
0.8310683369636536,
-0.09119332581758499,
0.883924126625061,
0.5413691401481628,
-0.08720450848340988,
0.35604339838027954,
0.042731914669275284,
0.40536051988601685,
0.6251345872879028,
0.08358372002840042,
-0.02975894697010517,
-0.05081074312329292,
-0.050418999046087265,
0.04737425968050957,
0.7738751769065857,
0.5945464372634888,
-0.19773520529270172,
-0.32196471095085144,
0.41259920597076416,
0.35942542552948,
0.24099482595920563,
-0.467094361782074,
0.5016430020332336,
0.11649114638566971,
-0.8250949382781982,
0.847219705581665,
-0.0358867347240448,
0.24924898147583008,
-0.7824829816818237,
0.08858568966388702,
-0.005946891847997904,
0.08374770730733871,
-0.06773579120635986,
-0.7192603945732117,
0.3710569441318512,
-0.17605353891849518,
-0.022864772006869316,
-0.20647744834423065,
0.8142688274383545,
-0.13491618633270264,
-0.11766120791435242,
0.6058292984962463,
0.26743972301483154,
-0.2819463014602661,
0.15135815739631653,
-0.6769602298736572,
0.28751125931739807,
0.010148032568395138,
-0.36648234724998474,
0.5539674758911133,
0.32848235964775085,
0.033499281853437424,
0.9186916351318359,
0.6969850063323975,
0.03132821246981621,
-0.22885990142822266,
-0.01725243590772152,
0.9702788591384888,
-0.3916155695915222,
-0.6150256395339966,
-1.1414180994033813,
0.5164481401443481,
0.48820945620536804,
0.01689211092889309,
0.7530264854431152,
-0.06575381755828857,
0.9048687815666199,
0.15437239408493042,
0.8002430200576782,
-0.3580004870891571,
0.17478546500205994,
-0.7676126956939697,
0.9622461795806885,
-0.457032173871994,
0.5099707841873169,
-0.4835307002067566,
-0.20765361189842224,
-0.0740339532494545,
0.25530850887298584,
-0.3271782100200653,
-0.10092175006866455,
0.46550533175468445,
0.8543099164962769,
-0.09623777866363525,
0.20960325002670288,
0.4954814314842224,
0.41952407360076904,
0.34629958868026733,
0.34656673669815063,
0.8738234639167786,
-0.2061515599489212,
0.6496096253395081,
-0.2546987533569336,
-0.0647064745426178,
-0.19464343786239624,
-0.44842880964279175,
-1.1941654682159424,
-0.6200656890869141,
-0.13910870254039764,
-0.8827820420265198,
0.1513228416442871,
1.0284366607666016,
0.9735763072967529,
-0.6509400010108948,
0.012365251779556274,
-0.24350495636463165,
0.35659724473953247,
-0.2828664481639862,
-0.1897737681865692,
-0.02969122678041458,
-0.367521733045578,
-0.4123530983924866,
0.5766324400901794,
0.3520619869232178,
0.13719747960567474,
-0.40583375096321106,
0.08999602496623993,
-0.11020008474588394,
0.2070317417383194,
0.5720886588096619,
0.637739896774292,
-0.7898356318473816,
-0.43906205892562866,
-0.06634412705898285,
-0.20547576248645782,
-0.037157092243433,
0.7598522305488586,
-0.4449456036090851,
0.643254280090332,
0.37652480602264404,
0.2948419153690338,
-0.16500088572502136,
-0.19076082110404968,
0.6004499197006226,
-0.8470765352249146,
0.6499238610267639,
-0.07612713426351547,
0.06368405371904373,
-0.12280689179897308,
-0.35489580035209656,
0.020097287371754646,
0.06606398522853851,
-0.3073490262031555,
-0.5704148411750793,
0.3139742910861969,
-0.442670077085495,
-0.704015851020813,
1.0570414066314697,
0.12023214995861053,
-0.24767696857452393,
-0.04380107298493385,
-0.47549280524253845,
-0.22350750863552094,
-0.3963793218135834,
0.6633368730545044,
0.866383969783783,
0.19575612246990204,
-0.3627333641052246,
-1.0838689804077148,
0.4867413341999054,
0.6308258175849915,
-0.12761960923671722,
0.39006462693214417,
0.3942638337612152,
0.3776485025882721,
0.09481881558895111,
0.7829556465148926,
-0.2163468450307846,
0.28002458810806274,
-0.10265696048736572,
-0.3074515163898468,
-0.13949990272521973,
-0.7094263434410095,
-0.6025899648666382,
0.32849425077438354,
0.4638998806476593,
-0.24277792870998383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11715v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11715v1 | Measuring memorization in RLHF for code completion | 2024-06-17T16:33:35 | 2024-06-17T16:33:35 | Aneesh Pappu, Billy Porter, Ilia Shumailov, Jamie Hayes | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SE | Reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF) has become the dominant
method to align large models to user preferences. Unlike fine-tuning, for which
there are many studies regarding training data memorization, it is not clear
how memorization is affected by or introduced in the RLHF alignment process.
Understanding this relationship is important as real user data may be collected
and used to align large models; if user data is memorized during RLHF and later
regurgitated, this could raise privacy concerns. In this work, we analyze how
training data memorization can surface and propagate through each phase of
RLHF. We focus our study on code completion models, as code completion is one
of the most popular use cases for large language models. We find that RLHF
significantly decreases the chance that data used for reward modeling and
reinforcement learning is memorized, in comparison to aligning via directly
fine-tuning on this data, but that examples already memorized during the
fine-tuning stage of RLHF, will, in the majority of cases, remain memorized
after RLHF. | [
-0.36684074997901917,
-0.5820839405059814,
0.3243517279624939,
-0.03341434895992279,
-0.09504581987857819,
0.11236201226711273,
-0.41993457078933716,
-0.4625627100467682,
-0.225224107503891,
0.6229294538497925,
-0.6472939252853394,
-0.5663410425186157,
-0.11898602545261383,
-0.08652748912572861,
-0.3019219934940338,
1.4033915996551514,
-0.36090484261512756,
-0.11969247460365295,
-0.499117374420166,
-0.2934435307979584,
-0.503802478313446,
-0.908078134059906,
-0.2892927825450897,
-0.8493509888648987,
0.7354004979133606,
0.5230896472930908,
0.6822461485862732,
1.1310251951217651,
0.41913560032844543,
0.2134416401386261,
0.053788721561431885,
0.026859739795327187,
-0.7426509857177734,
0.18112047016620636,
-0.08046616613864899,
-0.6117392182350159,
-0.310991108417511,
-0.076040118932724,
0.7462260723114014,
0.6363474726676941,
-0.5793659090995789,
0.3236598074436188,
0.0358797051012516,
1.108492136001587,
-0.6590733528137207,
0.2643353044986725,
-0.16380146145820618,
0.38578373193740845,
0.15260876715183258,
-0.36751866340637207,
-0.39281824231147766,
-0.4747996926307678,
0.22817981243133545,
-0.5659694075584412,
0.41998884081840515,
0.1584513783454895,
0.7175967693328857,
0.23853005468845367,
-0.23308280110359192,
-0.3079628050327301,
-0.8680326342582703,
0.6780027747154236,
-0.5078418254852295,
0.5349220633506775,
0.6364810466766357,
0.14650236070156097,
-0.12823767960071564,
-0.3789125680923462,
-0.37813252210617065,
-0.4726286828517914,
-0.2394147515296936,
0.1504807025194168,
0.38415080308914185,
0.36260002851486206,
0.6818061470985413,
0.3585926294326782,
-0.43288037180900574,
-0.056807197630405426,
-0.5060663223266602,
-0.38802966475486755,
0.6162832975387573,
0.41184237599372864,
0.056286558508872986,
-0.005297851283103228,
-0.5827251076698303,
-0.3428862690925598,
-0.7680239081382751,
0.33868125081062317,
0.34396517276763916,
0.11480236053466797,
-0.06863601505756378,
0.3753174841403961,
-0.07217419147491455,
0.6398020386695862,
-0.03681258112192154,
-0.29851508140563965,
0.19583724439144135,
-0.33313897252082825,
-0.27402767539024353,
0.014301738701760769,
0.631979763507843,
0.37162384390830994,
0.5854756832122803,
-0.23884713649749756,
-0.4534311592578888,
-0.23543798923492432,
0.5516765713691711,
-0.7692602872848511,
-0.2755681574344635,
0.1416173130273819,
-0.5128841400146484,
0.04469427093863487,
0.24111437797546387,
-0.271440714597702,
-0.3688938021659851,
-0.47723478078842163,
0.27426677942276,
-0.3052197992801666,
-0.16159911453723907,
-0.014050769619643688,
-0.08064060658216476,
0.060946524143218994,
0.14188095927238464,
-0.928849995136261,
0.34803688526153564,
1.0760679244995117,
0.5040457248687744,
-0.21846221387386322,
-0.8135875463485718,
-0.5069230794906616,
0.006210648454725742,
-0.4974598288536072,
0.35766535997390747,
-0.23653340339660645,
-0.4668786823749542,
0.17364415526390076,
0.004502280615270138,
-0.44501930475234985,
-0.8972734212875366,
0.25615882873535156,
-0.7426521182060242,
0.011071262881159782,
-0.3401925563812256,
-0.8686730265617371,
-0.40762943029403687,
0.34107527136802673,
-0.5211946368217468,
0.8770874738693237,
0.11411256343126297,
-0.5868522524833679,
0.5944545865058899,
-0.11798366159200668,
-0.257089227437973,
-0.2948318123817444,
-0.1181696355342865,
-1.0139521360397339,
0.15891313552856445,
-0.2339712381362915,
0.40033191442489624,
0.17548681795597076,
0.3199218213558197,
-0.38461148738861084,
-0.7096286416053772,
0.6815441250801086,
-0.06685636192560196,
-0.10741938650608063,
0.2007714807987213,
-0.204873189330101,
0.3248608708381653,
-0.5225114226341248,
-0.013613211922347546,
-0.206697016954422,
-0.7033068537712097,
-0.11435629427433014,
0.044641513377428055,
0.09820906072854996,
0.18148815631866455,
0.14420214295387268,
-0.18708272278308868,
0.16567036509513855,
-0.0734708234667778,
0.3304148018360138,
0.6362911462783813,
0.3841334879398346,
0.4865054786205292,
-0.7262819409370422,
0.7928197979927063,
0.1949586570262909,
0.0146495271474123,
-0.23056259751319885,
-0.10636156797409058,
-0.557155966758728,
0.03049086593091488,
0.4943189024925232,
0.4207131266593933,
0.0011568334884941578,
0.19047679007053375,
-0.1061750128865242,
-0.21759262681007385,
-0.30797892808914185,
0.3743685781955719,
0.9894005060195923,
0.442487508058548,
0.13871929049491882,
-0.5045155882835388,
-0.3934834599494934,
-0.9311137199401855,
-0.28389739990234375,
-0.22732794284820557,
0.13851074874401093,
0.5655341744422913,
0.40888628363609314,
-0.12484722584486008,
0.7463663220405579,
-0.3029729723930359,
-0.32067540287971497,
-0.1525164395570755,
0.22662024199962616,
-0.11463109403848648,
0.5988667011260986,
0.042765602469444275,
-0.49240073561668396,
-0.2570337951183319,
0.04353802651166916,
-0.46501579880714417,
0.3594568967819214,
-0.3575708568096161,
0.02415785938501358,
0.48516497015953064,
0.6543818712234497,
-0.16134962439537048,
0.46592941880226135,
0.31917452812194824,
-0.448102205991745,
0.3539072871208191,
-0.6748823523521423,
0.3642304241657257,
-0.4130784869194031,
0.1276770830154419,
-0.2670097351074219,
-0.5269152522087097,
-0.49238550662994385,
0.11306370794773102,
0.3772107660770416,
0.020680993795394897,
-0.18700943887233734,
0.2611089050769806,
-0.40779444575309753,
-0.4349415898323059,
-0.18194077908992767,
0.04112701490521431,
-0.2690076231956482,
0.8791900873184204,
0.22262389957904816,
0.8918652534484863,
0.031349461525678635,
-0.7214788794517517,
-0.12903563678264618,
0.13744598627090454,
-0.4999842345714569,
0.18843287229537964,
-0.5874596238136292,
0.19330286979675293,
-0.09487490355968475,
0.22739386558532715,
-0.9571247696876526,
-0.1919715851545334,
0.01201184093952179,
-0.4229942262172699,
0.1740017533302307,
-0.20007427036762238,
-0.3846394419670105,
-0.16884881258010864,
-0.18795885145664215,
0.6235723495483398,
0.5822296142578125,
-0.4664708971977234,
0.2399623543024063,
0.2915533483028412,
0.353525847196579,
-0.6123244762420654,
-0.35250169038772583,
-0.4262922704219818,
-0.4510286748409271,
-0.2883327305316925,
0.09812577813863754,
-0.05541565269231796,
0.1283765435218811,
-0.25478804111480713,
-0.27482232451438904,
-0.02158997394144535,
0.29156041145324707,
0.6528400778770447,
0.2449418306350708,
-0.03304985165596008,
0.2227517068386078,
-0.38366392254829407,
-0.07675749063491821,
0.2652979791164398,
0.0072066765278577805,
0.5351994633674622,
-0.10321652889251709,
-0.4380973279476166,
-0.5144742727279663,
0.0084828557446599,
0.5526238679885864,
-0.2198694497346878,
0.6811646223068237,
0.5260604619979858,
-0.22280849516391754,
-0.4270956516265869,
-0.4811440408229828,
-0.326445072889328,
-0.36024215817451477,
0.37267109751701355,
-0.1889440417289734,
-0.8201501965522766,
0.938785970211029,
0.1934651881456375,
0.07243143022060394,
-0.02057545632123947,
0.3825203776359558,
-0.2844175100326538,
1.0364277362823486,
0.6719029545783997,
-0.05062589794397354,
0.7029386162757874,
-0.21937498450279236,
-0.11235088109970093,
-0.8413691520690918,
-0.3440000116825104,
-0.30149900913238525,
-0.5917918086051941,
-0.5380821824073792,
-0.12352076917886734,
0.08932602405548096,
0.535858154296875,
-0.3309566378593445,
0.2981327772140503,
-0.24940569698810577,
0.564666748046875,
0.6373225450515747,
0.3807990550994873,
0.44393137097358704,
-0.054169200360774994,
0.10630229860544205,
-0.06567337363958359,
-0.5875581502914429,
-0.1388539969921112,
1.123957872390747,
0.6124672889709473,
0.7873579263687134,
-0.2080487310886383,
1.0569944381713867,
0.2217850387096405,
0.22327274084091187,
-0.6713071465492249,
0.31004461646080017,
0.16278617084026337,
-0.4050164520740509,
-0.35655200481414795,
-0.4979952573776245,
-0.8270743489265442,
0.03868896886706352,
0.0033891114871948957,
-0.4867960512638092,
0.10759257525205612,
0.7845363616943359,
-0.4845845103263855,
-0.008813940919935703,
-0.655147910118103,
1.036808967590332,
0.12780068814754486,
-0.30652564764022827,
-0.5866624712944031,
-0.6040599346160889,
0.4582092761993408,
0.09482632577419281,
0.20103858411312103,
-0.013598318211734295,
0.05067477747797966,
1.0942363739013672,
-0.43501123785972595,
0.8093608617782593,
-0.28993356227874756,
-0.16056381165981293,
0.18543659150600433,
0.06105677783489227,
0.5847923159599304,
0.11817491054534912,
0.2993319630622864,
-0.25369930267333984,
0.17130209505558014,
-0.21068121492862701,
-0.4956882894039154,
0.5443113446235657,
-0.7953425049781799,
-0.3180027902126312,
-0.3206959664821625,
-0.6637780070304871,
-0.24759355187416077,
-0.13791652023792267,
0.07414823025465012,
0.334552526473999,
-0.08987616002559662,
0.07948481291532516,
1.0280424356460571,
-0.1154741495847702,
0.2793905735015869,
0.46634915471076965,
-0.513034999370575,
-0.39235737919807434,
1.029740571975708,
0.10537146031856537,
0.5352426171302795,
0.24764947593212128,
0.07137297093868256,
-0.30393755435943604,
-0.4983822703361511,
-0.3404483199119568,
0.3676622807979584,
-0.720402717590332,
-0.10154613107442856,
-0.4472324550151825,
-0.26734957098960876,
0.032232627272605896,
-0.00717594288289547,
-0.2903910279273987,
-0.33480629324913025,
-0.21388418972492218,
-0.2093868851661682,
0.37249186635017395,
0.7398094534873962,
0.03972678259015083,
0.18547402322292328,
-0.7775495052337646,
0.33283111453056335,
0.23828282952308655,
0.7067299485206604,
0.2117282599210739,
-0.6675505042076111,
-0.6442265510559082,
-0.12100426107645035,
-0.00696870032697916,
-0.5444467663764954,
0.12747010588645935,
0.08856774121522903,
0.3169531524181366,
0.24191278219223022,
-0.1504153162240982,
0.9026508927345276,
-0.19440947473049164,
0.4787149131298065,
0.05723999813199043,
-0.763921856880188,
0.2070860117673874,
-0.3999307155609131,
0.38682013750076294,
0.8258692622184753,
-0.10261303931474686,
-0.8712940812110901,
-0.35359814763069153,
-0.5085893273353577,
-0.6361947655677795,
0.9437137246131897,
-0.41871532797813416,
-0.09246401488780975,
0.16477659344673157,
0.4921741187572479,
-0.08401495218276978,
0.27363044023513794,
-0.5528467297554016,
-0.32648956775665283,
-0.02082977630198002,
0.011500101536512375,
-0.12626144289970398,
-0.3518677353858948,
-0.22191017866134644,
-0.20738957822322845,
0.5047260522842407,
0.10329404473304749,
0.08003991842269897,
0.07393632084131241,
-0.2657144069671631,
-0.4064042866230011,
0.1560000628232956,
0.9481491446495056,
0.802313506603241,
-0.39045336842536926,
-0.2208258956670761,
-0.052201446145772934,
-0.5900814533233643,
0.06412141770124435,
-0.2894172966480255,
-0.20781859755516052,
-0.34464263916015625,
0.48075369000434875,
0.8570085763931274,
0.5850411057472229,
-0.8048409223556519,
0.46361884474754333,
-0.03755762428045273,
-0.523410439491272,
-0.4731483459472656,
0.5410378575325012,
0.1922404170036316,
0.22738298773765564,
0.12623687088489532,
0.03755461424589157,
-0.13685160875320435,
-0.5331313014030457,
0.5312870740890503,
0.19836047291755676,
-0.7160999774932861,
-0.07909174263477325,
0.5890313982963562,
-0.24673625826835632,
-0.37823283672332764,
0.9545354843139648,
0.07948770374059677,
-0.614683210849762,
0.8668919205665588,
0.4304582178592682,
0.7316059470176697,
-0.09702890366315842,
0.1592639982700348,
0.7181269526481628,
-0.0721588209271431,
-0.43755024671554565,
0.2762850522994995,
-0.49455419182777405,
-0.4277600347995758,
-0.2512051463127136,
-0.5134243965148926,
-0.37426042556762695,
-0.12083455920219421,
-1.1670663356781006,
-0.08554494380950928,
-0.6952593922615051,
-0.11365843564271927,
-0.38387447595596313,
0.029447069391608238,
-0.6386274695396423,
0.19733010232448578,
0.15367339551448822,
0.7251332402229309,
-0.6415631175041199,
0.931496798992157,
0.3796904683113098,
-0.42801323533058167,
-1.1264214515686035,
0.05741816386580467,
-0.06972059607505798,
-0.9539480209350586,
0.5796343684196472,
0.18266239762306213,
0.06260377168655396,
-0.057295724749565125,
-0.1641218662261963,
-0.6851294040679932,
1.1908221244812012,
-0.07438027113676071,
-0.6286554932594299,
-0.004364546854048967,
0.09032244980335236,
0.6335349082946777,
-0.2105732262134552,
0.05768495425581932,
0.9236497282981873,
0.4068920314311981,
-0.11322209984064102,
-1.0241551399230957,
-0.08605271577835083,
0.1139569953083992,
0.1171664148569107,
0.4600403904914856,
-0.5167863368988037,
0.6853806972503662,
-0.5033186674118042,
-0.43320441246032715,
-0.050744663923978806,
0.6261484622955322,
0.4065924286842346,
0.2883160710334778,
0.5614528656005859,
0.6284862756729126,
0.656275749206543,
-0.010002277791500092,
0.8404746651649475,
-0.22747060656547546,
0.561091959476471,
1.1893703937530518,
0.009982476010918617,
1.0501885414123535,
0.4550991654396057,
-0.27263471484184265,
0.3282484710216522,
0.6074734926223755,
0.04103240743279457,
0.4276915490627289,
0.6463959217071533,
0.07387895882129669,
-0.2608012855052948,
0.06575348973274231,
-0.48519113659858704,
0.08310536295175552,
0.20693272352218628,
-0.3858128488063812,
-0.044388432055711746,
0.21251258254051208,
-0.06875091046094894,
0.4104754626750946,
-0.3394724428653717,
1.196048378944397,
0.018327590078115463,
-1.259880781173706,
0.9244028329849243,
-0.1899137794971466,
0.4061126708984375,
-0.6020237803459167,
0.04300304129719734,
-0.6196252703666687,
0.5957469344139099,
-0.45716795325279236,
-0.7687575817108154,
0.31985950469970703,
-0.2579507827758789,
-0.4897482395172119,
-0.3176277279853821,
0.028892330825328827,
-0.9547728300094604,
0.001869694795459509,
0.3891136348247528,
0.11353278905153275,
-0.004450276959687471,
0.15702903270721436,
-0.5280132293701172,
0.12298989295959473,
0.20999816060066223,
-0.38349270820617676,
0.6874527335166931,
-0.0029657871928066015,
0.019330667331814766,
0.7791032195091248,
0.4056397080421448,
-0.04333377256989479,
0.24613922834396362,
0.2745145559310913,
0.4003026485443115,
-0.8856685161590576,
-0.5572633147239685,
-0.7104048728942871,
0.30001482367515564,
0.2694805860519409,
-0.44806763529777527,
0.6749905943870544,
0.6240957975387573,
1.0312293767929077,
-0.20528742671012878,
0.4783380329608917,
0.3840402066707611,
0.6790672540664673,
-0.677029550075531,
0.6234866976737976,
-0.3554246127605438,
0.29951849579811096,
0.009453834965825081,
-0.6874651908874512,
-0.17812706530094147,
0.4167316257953644,
-0.15163062512874603,
0.010790429078042507,
0.5706810355186462,
0.9488780498504639,
-0.10499148815870285,
-0.05032800883054733,
0.3372326195240021,
-0.1792226880788803,
0.18621274828910828,
0.8081318140029907,
0.8664723038673401,
-0.34057319164276123,
0.5479636788368225,
-0.5463877320289612,
-0.0831252783536911,
-0.2694688141345978,
-0.5940099954605103,
-1.0248711109161377,
-0.6475819945335388,
-0.3819252550601959,
-0.45424187183380127,
0.02514141984283924,
0.8742721080780029,
0.6393890380859375,
-1.0090811252593994,
-0.5599102973937988,
-0.2627943456172943,
0.3251603841781616,
-0.5715831518173218,
-0.1876658946275711,
0.39404699206352234,
-0.5812250971794128,
-0.3432232737541199,
0.017091192305088043,
0.031100604683160782,
0.02876819297671318,
-0.35008832812309265,
-0.4328390657901764,
0.13806618750095367,
-0.29388871788978577,
0.0698758065700531,
0.7428804636001587,
-0.7165822982788086,
-0.24041983485221863,
0.02747231535613537,
-0.3379357159137726,
0.21693313121795654,
1.3025330305099487,
-0.9006453156471252,
0.4367986023426056,
0.4959884583950043,
0.6452257037162781,
0.6404895782470703,
0.3607194125652313,
0.6852415204048157,
-0.7085658311843872,
-0.08090382814407349,
-0.04816513881087303,
0.27226370573043823,
0.04557633772492409,
-0.4092526435852051,
0.24901574850082397,
-0.08414711803197861,
-0.9567154049873352,
-0.8326491117477417,
0.21916306018829346,
-0.6796716451644897,
-0.09402550011873245,
0.8463427424430847,
-0.1649405062198639,
-0.13706693053245544,
-0.07836323976516724,
0.009027453139424324,
0.016565989702939987,
-0.39793500304222107,
0.9258697628974915,
0.7919303178787231,
-0.14409014582633972,
-0.19211386144161224,
-0.6369206309318542,
1.047531247138977,
0.6200734972953796,
-0.5048608183860779,
0.6962388157844543,
0.5570587515830994,
0.36422035098075867,
0.0024639831390231848,
0.7875159382820129,
0.013449412770569324,
0.61985182762146,
-0.40122756361961365,
-0.17915832996368408,
-0.244812473654747,
-0.5256837606430054,
-0.6713632345199585,
0.12636715173721313,
0.3923417031764984,
-0.2561394274234772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11709v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11709v2 | Instruct, Not Assist: LLM-based Multi-Turn Planning and Hierarchical Questioning for Socratic Code Debugging | 2024-06-17T16:28:21 | 2024-06-25T21:17:41 | Priyanka Kargupta, Ishika Agarwal, Dilek Hakkani-Tur, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MA | Socratic questioning is an effective teaching strategy, encouraging critical
thinking and problem-solving. The conversational capabilities of large language
models (LLMs) show great potential for providing scalable, real-time student
guidance. However, current LLMs often give away solutions directly, making them
ineffective instructors. We tackle this issue in the code debugging domain with
TreeInstruct, an Instructor agent guided by a novel state space-based planning
algorithm. TreeInstruct asks probing questions to help students independently
identify and resolve errors. It estimates a student's conceptual and
syntactical knowledge to dynamically construct a question tree based on their
responses and current knowledge state, effectively addressing both independent
and dependent mistakes concurrently in a multi-turn interaction setting. In
addition to using an existing single-bug debugging benchmark, we construct a
more challenging multi-bug dataset of 150 coding problems, incorrect solutions,
and bug fixes -- all carefully constructed and annotated by experts. Extensive
evaluation shows TreeInstruct's state-of-the-art performance on both datasets,
proving it to be a more effective instructor than baselines. Furthermore, a
real-world case study with five students of varying skill levels further
demonstrates TreeInstruct's ability to guide students to debug their code
efficiently with minimal turns and highly Socratic questioning. | [
-0.09690985083580017,
-0.8766265511512756,
0.5131638050079346,
0.23265787959098816,
0.01888827048242092,
0.7955907583236694,
-0.03202810510993004,
-0.3363417387008667,
0.10663063824176788,
0.2777509093284607,
-0.5112999677658081,
-0.686718225479126,
-0.25928616523742676,
-0.16938185691833496,
-0.48001575469970703,
0.9654118418693542,
-0.028779013082385063,
-0.0029636744875460863,
-0.5118189454078674,
0.1442384123802185,
-0.38636669516563416,
-0.46322691440582275,
-0.7297537326812744,
0.04257309064269066,
-0.076665498316288,
1.0840301513671875,
0.7618660926818848,
0.07312192022800446,
0.18891093134880066,
0.25382018089294434,
-0.2022417187690735,
0.21236009895801544,
-0.2546435594558716,
0.0734148770570755,
0.1868792623281479,
-0.5891424417495728,
-0.29648903012275696,
-0.39761123061180115,
0.3498784303665161,
0.5207827091217041,
-0.21851004660129547,
0.22180971503257751,
0.20680464804172516,
0.4655478298664093,
-0.4993169903755188,
0.2134297788143158,
-0.6994437575340271,
0.018768005073070526,
0.14516185224056244,
-0.22508396208286285,
-0.5999576449394226,
-0.816369891166687,
-0.2722582519054413,
-0.4164375960826874,
0.13817939162254333,
-0.24400000274181366,
0.4025757908821106,
0.5787507891654968,
-0.536034882068634,
-0.20117254555225372,
-0.6877127289772034,
0.44671469926834106,
-0.7210546135902405,
-0.03464559093117714,
0.503833532333374,
0.3278007209300995,
-0.4211421608924866,
-0.3063104450702667,
-0.31856033205986023,
-0.15249285101890564,
0.08089745789766312,
0.09529048949480057,
0.04159874841570854,
0.12888102233409882,
0.270675390958786,
0.10991095751523972,
-0.563058614730835,
0.16191264986991882,
-0.3765949308872223,
-0.13056831061840057,
0.5537375807762146,
0.1300511211156845,
0.4091094732284546,
-0.29272720217704773,
-0.21766893565654755,
-0.06820515543222427,
-0.9072564840316772,
0.4574461877346039,
0.2774509787559509,
0.03752770274877548,
0.10647212713956833,
0.2922554910182953,
0.15605199337005615,
0.5417563319206238,
0.19372951984405518,
-0.3378564715385437,
-0.0992530882358551,
-0.17401987314224243,
-0.13121028244495392,
0.38323408365249634,
0.3194173574447632,
0.3053939640522003,
0.36699771881103516,
-0.19712230563163757,
-0.046656958758831024,
0.14654801785945892,
0.31089892983436584,
-0.7240618467330933,
-0.42125967144966125,
0.3792828917503357,
0.09925761818885803,
-0.3155204653739929,
-0.23157650232315063,
-0.8781505227088928,
-0.5047114491462708,
-0.18868032097816467,
0.3852293789386749,
-0.5505058169364929,
-0.2709622383117676,
0.031680285930633545,
0.11065073311328888,
0.27785465121269226,
0.32490408420562744,
-0.45642662048339844,
0.2637292146682739,
0.57906174659729,
0.7312783002853394,
0.20789355039596558,
-0.23597094416618347,
-0.6592698097229004,
0.21348753571510315,
-0.5306621193885803,
0.7404718995094299,
-0.6879452466964722,
-0.6272587180137634,
-0.06938710063695908,
0.18730762600898743,
-0.056690514087677,
-0.6264956593513489,
0.03700028359889984,
-0.12926851212978363,
-0.042499709874391556,
-0.008267899975180626,
-0.310669869184494,
-0.18851235508918762,
0.3977366089820862,
-0.130471333861351,
1.2414753437042236,
0.35654500126838684,
-0.5344562530517578,
0.07920854538679123,
-0.5028542280197144,
-0.2944677770137787,
0.22302182018756866,
-0.6220290064811707,
-0.4846053123474121,
-0.1821613907814026,
0.3095639646053314,
0.261018306016922,
0.17264927923679352,
0.3450298011302948,
-0.008036392740905285,
-0.5434722304344177,
-0.10877075791358948,
0.10767417401075363,
1.2425519227981567,
-0.1740194708108902,
-0.7363990545272827,
0.332564115524292,
-0.6051661372184753,
0.4003247320652008,
0.10344699770212173,
-0.1270083487033844,
-0.40061381459236145,
0.2164756804704666,
-0.3269151747226715,
-0.060732197016477585,
-0.2411656230688095,
-0.5407343506813049,
0.762897253036499,
-0.23875726759433746,
0.28506171703338623,
0.8614471554756165,
0.2422524392604828,
0.2873525023460388,
-0.27060526609420776,
1.1528160572052002,
-0.08188768476247787,
0.334377646446228,
-0.019079163670539856,
-0.34845736622810364,
-0.7186417579650879,
-0.06332679837942123,
-0.15789087116718292,
0.6326932311058044,
-0.9785403609275818,
-0.053224798291921616,
0.19284914433956146,
-0.7202367186546326,
-0.3695172965526581,
-0.08680790662765503,
0.42881283164024353,
0.35190579295158386,
0.436048299074173,
0.06731747835874557,
-0.36126548051834106,
-0.6902775764465332,
0.07923426479101181,
-0.4533931314945221,
0.45475566387176514,
-0.0340835340321064,
0.5276673436164856,
-0.18106147646903992,
0.7922817468643188,
-0.6777492761611938,
-0.0001439858169760555,
-0.29343512654304504,
0.022692184895277023,
-0.04491998255252838,
0.5878536701202393,
0.5832882523536682,
-0.3936425447463989,
-0.7042034864425659,
-0.25595441460609436,
-0.31850704550743103,
0.021326739341020584,
-0.29435065388679504,
0.024348847568035126,
0.30915436148643494,
0.6617525815963745,
-0.3699995279312134,
0.564306914806366,
0.565898060798645,
-0.5804165601730347,
0.801777184009552,
-0.2725766599178314,
0.09614777565002441,
-0.9724031686782837,
-0.3397239148616791,
-0.2533107399940491,
-0.06143738329410553,
-0.25277945399284363,
0.18127106130123138,
0.2168034166097641,
-0.2605033814907074,
-0.1803661584854126,
-0.09568683058023453,
-0.5338339805603027,
-0.24075253307819366,
-0.030270738527178764,
0.011130263097584248,
-0.11140765249729156,
0.714993953704834,
-0.42361271381378174,
0.9731290936470032,
0.6492748856544495,
-0.4617108702659607,
0.25017303228378296,
0.26382172107696533,
-0.5372262001037598,
0.5464040637016296,
-0.5785272717475891,
0.4961993992328644,
-0.32395219802856445,
0.17373032867908478,
-1.2056699991226196,
0.1605423241853714,
0.28612974286079407,
-0.43038761615753174,
0.30321139097213745,
-0.6547775864601135,
-0.6315370202064514,
-0.2272031158208847,
-0.4569624960422516,
0.2793637812137604,
0.30389922857284546,
-0.6894966959953308,
0.20593613386154175,
0.23420993983745575,
-0.1792006939649582,
-0.6168355941772461,
-0.31690460443496704,
-0.04399283602833748,
-0.2630182206630707,
-0.39104533195495605,
0.3169940114021301,
-0.42834582924842834,
-0.30728965997695923,
0.08636141568422318,
-0.5021464824676514,
-0.36171114444732666,
0.4434567093849182,
0.5183662176132202,
0.21960337460041046,
-0.04291040450334549,
0.2482145130634308,
0.3351466953754425,
-0.00898636132478714,
0.43224889039993286,
0.127580463886261,
0.19061638414859772,
-0.33524617552757263,
-0.6138978600502014,
-0.19933009147644043,
0.27776703238487244,
0.7726646065711975,
-0.5031185150146484,
0.1580606997013092,
-0.015910884365439415,
-0.18027657270431519,
-0.6348484754562378,
-0.12057553231716156,
-0.26763272285461426,
-0.45737820863723755,
0.49175336956977844,
-0.22322361171245575,
-0.6688593029975891,
0.09411108493804932,
-0.2217468023300171,
0.4263046979904175,
-0.17996706068515778,
-0.06747306138277054,
0.010750947520136833,
1.1441558599472046,
0.8096631765365601,
-0.08111546188592911,
0.3066742420196533,
-0.7003987431526184,
0.24936871230602264,
-0.5604024529457092,
-0.5721274614334106,
-0.8177915811538696,
-0.2524617314338684,
-0.2647760212421417,
-0.5266841650009155,
0.5607101321220398,
0.15709057450294495,
-0.25970688462257385,
0.36921343207359314,
-0.8680236339569092,
0.6499671339988708,
0.4446469843387604,
0.021775132045149803,
0.542015790939331,
-0.15324604511260986,
0.0634608194231987,
-0.0007200375548563898,
-0.9515887498855591,
-0.4050309360027313,
0.7473342418670654,
0.0871594101190567,
0.7838950753211975,
0.2925592362880707,
0.9483240842819214,
-0.0018653505248948932,
0.21525461971759796,
-1.1391249895095825,
0.7028664350509644,
0.2864252030849457,
-0.5407095551490784,
-0.39504194259643555,
-0.1600683182477951,
-0.9296888113021851,
0.23162314295768738,
0.059165116399526596,
-0.7050191760063171,
0.09629412740468979,
0.25093749165534973,
-0.5083521604537964,
0.5450222492218018,
-0.9078937768936157,
1.0235828161239624,
-0.5687857866287231,
-0.17888566851615906,
-0.43729984760284424,
-0.32827895879745483,
0.2149437665939331,
0.0850868746638298,
0.3050147294998169,
-0.002405274659395218,
0.10007370263338089,
0.6377369165420532,
-0.5127483010292053,
1.0807329416275024,
-0.46612873673439026,
-0.11212076991796494,
0.6277068853378296,
0.5841320157051086,
0.5475566983222961,
0.26723596453666687,
0.16371546685695648,
-0.4858928620815277,
0.7441670298576355,
-0.4326328635215759,
-0.6877065896987915,
0.6530905961990356,
-0.7633126378059387,
-0.7011638283729553,
-0.5902720093727112,
-0.31312116980552673,
-0.45051705837249756,
-0.12178901582956314,
-0.13353322446346283,
0.7343308329582214,
-0.0500514917075634,
0.13724727928638458,
0.44654425978660583,
-0.3684064745903015,
0.6428915858268738,
0.631221354007721,
-0.3771788775920868,
-0.018293723464012146,
0.6894721388816833,
0.15436914563179016,
0.24867132306098938,
-0.006970521062612534,
0.1401539146900177,
0.14448902010917664,
-0.5357292890548706,
-0.5392985343933105,
-0.04917237162590027,
-0.5714805126190186,
-0.6196653246879578,
-0.33559733629226685,
-0.22962619364261627,
-0.08967427909374237,
-0.3217756152153015,
-0.37121933698654175,
-0.31779956817626953,
0.21709872782230377,
-0.3422717750072479,
0.5189412236213684,
0.837744951248169,
0.19486242532730103,
0.3634277582168579,
-0.699663519859314,
-0.10759846866130829,
0.2399921417236328,
0.13394074141979218,
0.05571886897087097,
-0.19277061522006989,
-0.3332381248474121,
-0.03961460664868355,
-0.5449963808059692,
-1.2711864709854126,
0.14546868205070496,
-0.07497143000364304,
0.43363553285598755,
0.25061315298080444,
0.43124786019325256,
0.8769192695617676,
-0.2218950092792511,
0.5734227895736694,
-0.06689205765724182,
-0.9267812371253967,
0.7782614827156067,
0.17413148283958435,
0.48327550292015076,
0.6283642053604126,
0.5435341000556946,
-0.49691107869148254,
-0.8580716848373413,
-0.7532867193222046,
-0.7516094446182251,
0.8467674851417542,
-0.14046216011047363,
-0.05947330966591835,
0.022688638418912888,
0.29213327169418335,
0.04000705108046532,
-0.08950480818748474,
-0.5827455520629883,
-0.1745183914899826,
-0.09404003620147705,
-0.034577347338199615,
0.01505844946950674,
-0.20193703472614288,
0.0189385823905468,
-0.5416619777679443,
0.5851448178291321,
-0.40952008962631226,
-0.02515987679362297,
0.28423842787742615,
-0.18981944024562836,
-0.2610088288784027,
0.4807630777359009,
0.4508822560310364,
0.9944518804550171,
-0.2051621377468109,
0.3895208537578583,
0.19069980084896088,
-0.2506522536277771,
0.25889354944229126,
-0.10492733120918274,
-0.2408117949962616,
0.007981029339134693,
0.32696789503097534,
0.18552301824092865,
0.41765204071998596,
-0.7163949608802795,
0.4628039300441742,
0.24524077773094177,
-0.1692054271697998,
-0.43352359533309937,
0.12359794974327087,
0.05135035887360573,
0.31312984228134155,
0.3021931052207947,
-0.061119358986616135,
-0.03127749636769295,
-0.6436558961868286,
0.013518220745027065,
0.5183286070823669,
-0.3620266616344452,
-0.430778831243515,
0.20852428674697876,
0.22710591554641724,
-0.37856680154800415,
0.7709478139877319,
-0.26253393292427063,
-0.811866044998169,
1.1855543851852417,
0.6504671573638916,
0.6667081117630005,
-0.3702228367328644,
0.8411598801612854,
0.6203195452690125,
0.5540143251419067,
0.2831551730632782,
0.42030155658721924,
-0.21285514533519745,
-0.46712401509284973,
-0.6862014532089233,
0.10202823579311371,
-0.5638226270675659,
0.11439642310142517,
-0.3535740375518799,
0.02635040506720543,
-0.7999318242073059,
0.12026525288820267,
-0.24386021494865417,
0.15050733089447021,
-0.02425694465637207,
-0.11985171586275101,
-0.25300222635269165,
0.8447874188423157,
-0.7011781334877014,
0.9160100221633911,
1.0154463052749634,
-0.37096548080444336,
-1.0458359718322754,
0.15441565215587616,
0.1845388561487198,
-0.5694406628608704,
0.5534253120422363,
0.16016896069049835,
-0.25304895639419556,
0.08596248924732208,
-0.9493447542190552,
-0.5845012664794922,
1.0166473388671875,
0.39717918634414673,
-0.40724003314971924,
-0.1693190485239029,
-0.23295487463474274,
0.43069857358932495,
-0.061053045094013214,
0.36510899662971497,
0.06747984141111374,
0.31783628463745117,
0.08017660677433014,
-0.839271068572998,
0.06727349013090134,
0.0348513089120388,
-0.40786147117614746,
0.5379757881164551,
-0.7742592692375183,
0.4671157896518707,
-0.6296393275260925,
-0.33411094546318054,
-0.25002703070640564,
0.2869085669517517,
0.04142448678612709,
0.43556249141693115,
0.7687424421310425,
0.3203813135623932,
0.8774016499519348,
0.17957937717437744,
0.6454703211784363,
-0.47319161891937256,
0.2297704964876175,
1.3436704874038696,
0.20447589457035065,
0.7290851473808289,
0.5957621335983276,
-0.23447218537330627,
0.7978671789169312,
0.6457733511924744,
0.17534877359867096,
0.3065837323665619,
0.36815762519836426,
-0.1634007841348648,
-0.412835031747818,
0.05415930971503258,
-0.4501284062862396,
0.463753342628479,
0.1397431641817093,
0.3314764201641083,
-0.40810316801071167,
-0.25185081362724304,
0.27829283475875854,
0.22242097556591034,
-0.20701254904270172,
0.45503270626068115,
-0.049059029668569565,
-0.8491365313529968,
0.6299710273742676,
-0.12244465947151184,
0.1818309724330902,
-0.43519091606140137,
-0.28416919708251953,
-0.6345487833023071,
0.25814929604530334,
-0.5988560914993286,
-0.7756021022796631,
0.5092782378196716,
0.013603226281702518,
0.2992331087589264,
-0.2750925123691559,
0.21214230358600616,
-0.4140206277370453,
-0.25760969519615173,
0.24390241503715515,
0.4866790175437927,
0.261534184217453,
-0.14676357805728912,
-0.5280942916870117,
-0.2631988525390625,
0.3020869195461273,
0.2459496259689331,
0.17096783220767975,
0.4563419222831726,
-0.19877873361110687,
0.8224753141403198,
0.19907565414905548,
-0.25479450821876526,
-0.027446232736110687,
-0.1399359405040741,
0.9476082921028137,
-0.5310202836990356,
-0.1934049427509308,
-0.6243200898170471,
0.7180584669113159,
0.04204715043306351,
-0.26396945118904114,
0.877103865146637,
0.7097220420837402,
0.9329140782356262,
-0.005300478078424931,
0.4946349859237671,
-0.13805228471755981,
0.1914271116256714,
-0.3331950008869171,
0.20603178441524506,
-0.4440579414367676,
0.4143611490726471,
-0.3938576877117157,
-0.9260702133178711,
0.0077186040580272675,
0.6054480075836182,
-0.23691901564598083,
-0.2833997309207916,
0.8636468648910522,
1.004845380783081,
0.10561995208263397,
-0.13874509930610657,
0.12850390374660492,
0.17806820571422577,
0.5381489396095276,
0.9880024194717407,
1.168336272239685,
-0.06840967386960983,
0.8789473176002502,
-0.424784392118454,
-0.5459356307983398,
-0.12855194509029388,
-0.44441092014312744,
-1.0301241874694824,
-0.437884658575058,
-0.7450504302978516,
-0.3877376317977905,
0.07506334781646729,
0.9647500514984131,
0.7111057639122009,
-0.7085669636726379,
-0.4307275414466858,
-0.12028689682483673,
0.5661799311637878,
-0.3372039794921875,
-0.2585568130016327,
0.41890981793403625,
-0.4426209628582001,
-0.6173059940338135,
0.7244472503662109,
0.11912433803081512,
0.06950340420007706,
-0.3941390812397003,
-0.050504691898822784,
-0.219560444355011,
-0.3149285912513733,
0.5748146772384644,
0.22611796855926514,
-0.45702654123306274,
-0.45590463280677795,
0.23210057616233826,
-0.024703310802578926,
0.04041401669383049,
0.9056737422943115,
-0.7881677150726318,
0.4910801351070404,
0.20790572464466095,
0.779072105884552,
0.5731315612792969,
-0.029903098940849304,
0.27062317728996277,
-0.5305087566375732,
0.08989175409078598,
0.4259655773639679,
-0.00468316487967968,
0.038198523223400116,
-0.4852435290813446,
0.6968131065368652,
0.01538534089922905,
-0.6698369383811951,
-0.7531432509422302,
0.28847843408584595,
-0.7386019825935364,
-0.5250643491744995,
0.9837383031845093,
-0.07484179735183716,
0.01235193107277155,
-0.13872326910495758,
-0.745133638381958,
-0.0541577972471714,
-0.18673403561115265,
0.9504942893981934,
0.5659173727035522,
-0.3279057741165161,
-0.39104196429252625,
-0.37317755818367004,
0.6799192428588867,
0.6199647784233093,
-0.9999933838844299,
-0.06894614547491074,
0.7514609098434448,
0.14557351171970367,
-0.018265262246131897,
0.5622929334640503,
0.05549580976366997,
0.13881997764110565,
0.05729036405682564,
0.02359127253293991,
-0.2445407509803772,
-0.6989774703979492,
-0.20024807751178741,
0.1329060047864914,
0.42669323086738586,
-0.43557116389274597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11706v1 | Prompts as Auto-Optimized Training Hyperparameters: Training Best-in-Class IR Models from Scratch with 10 Gold Labels | 2024-06-17T16:25:55 | 2024-06-17T16:25:55 | Jasper Xian, Saron Samuel, Faraz Khoubsirat, Ronak Pradeep, Md Arafat Sultan, Radu Florian, Salim Roukos, Avirup Sil, Christopher Potts, Omar Khattab | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | We develop a method for training small-scale (under 100M parameter) neural
information retrieval models with as few as 10 gold relevance labels. The
method depends on generating synthetic queries for documents using a language
model (LM), and the key step is that we automatically optimize the LM prompt
that is used to generate these queries based on training quality. In
experiments with the BIRCO benchmark, we find that models trained with our
method outperform RankZephyr and are competitive with RankLLama, both of which
are 7B parameter models trained on over 100K labels. These findings point to
the power of automatic prompt optimization for synthetic dataset generation. | [
-0.5489569306373596,
-0.48670247197151184,
0.6049934029579163,
-0.0897468701004982,
0.008118342608213425,
-0.13212950527668,
-0.1233736053109169,
-0.23366190493106842,
-0.0856030285358429,
0.40965786576271057,
-0.5527181029319763,
-0.24116858839988708,
-0.3990694284439087,
0.48856493830680847,
-0.20198866724967957,
1.2090122699737549,
0.3260710537433624,
0.2853468656539917,
-0.16755877435207367,
-0.13393738865852356,
-0.36095911264419556,
-0.4857355058193207,
-0.7632318735122681,
-0.21000468730926514,
0.9618375897407532,
0.5051189064979553,
0.6261249780654907,
0.8088403940200806,
0.5381781458854675,
0.3030073940753937,
-0.008975593373179436,
0.3754046857357025,
-0.2457975596189499,
0.36786097288131714,
-0.04286868870258331,
-0.475063294172287,
0.1305006593465805,
0.24906468391418457,
0.5171172022819519,
0.7539951205253601,
0.16711251437664032,
0.3298785984516144,
0.0369597002863884,
0.6774663925170898,
-0.6120278835296631,
-0.03755412623286247,
-0.6947973370552063,
-0.0577557310461998,
0.10778133571147919,
-0.5875289440155029,
-0.7030731439590454,
-0.622359573841095,
0.24190635979175568,
-0.5737030506134033,
0.45243653655052185,
0.5133034586906433,
1.1500576734542847,
0.35529452562332153,
-0.27335065603256226,
-0.31340301036834717,
-0.6419207453727722,
0.5938588976860046,
-0.4332660138607025,
0.1878521889448166,
0.46402883529663086,
0.7149389982223511,
-0.14873835444450378,
-1.0813030004501343,
-0.34743624925613403,
-0.4617157578468323,
-0.15521655976772308,
-0.14819324016571045,
-0.15377385914325714,
0.2274896502494812,
0.570376992225647,
0.16201433539390564,
-0.8635132908821106,
0.05705822631716728,
-0.31680214405059814,
-0.18869644403457642,
0.3906988203525543,
0.4445703625679016,
0.01282210648059845,
-0.20475441217422485,
-0.2547886073589325,
-0.33425062894821167,
-0.49253907799720764,
0.060739465057849884,
0.37444427609443665,
0.5176002383232117,
0.45119452476501465,
0.5283083319664001,
-0.3229968547821045,
1.2554962635040283,
0.35580214858055115,
0.13468500971794128,
-0.08449921011924744,
-0.35972893238067627,
-0.08964523673057556,
0.08526133000850677,
0.8627261519432068,
0.2142113745212555,
0.16605651378631592,
-0.33157920837402344,
-0.46381887793540955,
-0.036089204251766205,
0.266762375831604,
-0.8938444256782532,
-0.35433751344680786,
-0.01972256414592266,
-0.3629523813724518,
-0.2597090005874634,
-0.18965132534503937,
-0.5750501155853271,
-0.17478607594966888,
-0.7133380770683289,
0.8129312992095947,
-0.2379329651594162,
0.5000948309898376,
-0.009879419580101967,
-0.3119230568408966,
0.13017988204956055,
0.3118192255496979,
-0.9239941835403442,
0.059817444533109665,
0.23868785798549652,
0.6293680667877197,
-0.0782657265663147,
-0.20082740485668182,
-0.8350493907928467,
-0.1508917659521103,
-0.5001920461654663,
1.127097725868225,
-0.5012732744216919,
-0.29881197214126587,
-0.028088578954339027,
0.09312482178211212,
-0.23176684975624084,
-0.6762151718139648,
0.3088371157646179,
-0.807654857635498,
0.3910629451274872,
-0.40230655670166016,
-0.45884355902671814,
0.14286893606185913,
0.3418216109275818,
-0.543411374092102,
1.4107578992843628,
0.29901862144470215,
-0.5013864040374756,
0.4635166525840759,
-0.5866981148719788,
0.048409245908260345,
0.24610598385334015,
0.037972770631313324,
-0.10723774135112762,
-0.049451399594545364,
0.2051153928041458,
0.14071309566497803,
-0.7399622201919556,
0.27249282598495483,
0.08937811106443405,
-0.15989789366722107,
0.21910129487514496,
-0.1422937661409378,
0.7168395519256592,
0.4605432152748108,
-0.2538381814956665,
0.16321291029453278,
-0.8584282398223877,
0.3902948498725891,
-0.03746996074914932,
-0.5774964094161987,
-0.2816222608089447,
-0.5066924095153809,
-0.009023845195770264,
0.19963625073432922,
0.3559742867946625,
-0.3697066307067871,
0.2464905083179474,
-0.5150960683822632,
0.24632251262664795,
0.5800794959068298,
0.1855188012123108,
0.3268691897392273,
-0.26542460918426514,
0.5545951128005981,
-0.1696435809135437,
0.21688900887966156,
-0.2785438299179077,
-0.3333069980144501,
-0.9583348631858826,
0.012245877645909786,
0.5571992993354797,
0.48004835844039917,
-0.5938122272491455,
0.6515933871269226,
0.18212999403476715,
-0.758101761341095,
-0.6312618255615234,
0.24624985456466675,
0.40299805998802185,
0.9408116340637207,
0.40097492933273315,
0.10564065724611282,
-0.45877742767333984,
-1.024749994277954,
-0.5493638515472412,
-0.15160545706748962,
0.10080846399068832,
0.24816285073757172,
0.5463188886642456,
-0.22014302015304565,
1.216132402420044,
-0.41549980640411377,
-0.10491450130939484,
-0.2536343038082123,
0.5473061203956604,
0.2943519651889801,
0.47445714473724365,
0.5676599144935608,
-0.724075973033905,
-0.7649153470993042,
-0.37057605385780334,
-0.7220154404640198,
-0.2733043432235718,
-0.14995145797729492,
-0.41308876872062683,
0.06683439016342163,
0.7667360305786133,
-0.5136816501617432,
0.21967823803424835,
0.05375240743160248,
-0.24962905049324036,
0.42457258701324463,
-0.48679062724113464,
0.16583292186260223,
-1.0114078521728516,
0.26561829447746277,
0.27162307500839233,
0.004288841504603624,
-0.3952349126338959,
-0.21741335093975067,
0.2416783571243286,
-0.5799781680107117,
-0.2644801437854767,
0.8722542524337769,
-0.6393314599990845,
-0.035121411085128784,
-0.29184532165527344,
-0.08623707294464111,
0.3358241319656372,
0.5483393669128418,
0.01797044835984707,
1.0059285163879395,
0.5059196949005127,
-0.8288037776947021,
0.40187329053878784,
0.2360353171825409,
-0.359943151473999,
0.49740171432495117,
-0.9731196165084839,
0.1264553666114807,
-0.3800632655620575,
-0.03304457664489746,
-1.4445558786392212,
-0.41743889451026917,
-0.0391540601849556,
-0.4501742422580719,
0.2596965432167053,
-0.22306156158447266,
-0.7296977043151855,
-0.48914220929145813,
-0.053061045706272125,
0.2934017479419708,
0.5338397026062012,
-0.7976200580596924,
0.35052844882011414,
0.1447034329175949,
-0.16670240461826324,
-0.3593389689922333,
-0.3817218244075775,
0.07856860011816025,
-0.20207934081554413,
-0.3990419805049896,
0.2602626085281372,
-0.3572205901145935,
-0.0019028871320188046,
-0.2537568509578705,
0.3180537819862366,
0.07978934794664383,
-0.08250781893730164,
0.00867407489567995,
0.21659013628959656,
-0.09476194530725479,
0.17123855650424957,
-0.0018464884487912059,
-0.3887256383895874,
0.036775991320610046,
-0.3129633963108063,
0.5541427135467529,
-0.3725777864456177,
-0.14399553835391998,
-0.5909331440925598,
0.2526710629463196,
0.3176608383655548,
-0.2964356243610382,
0.651615560054779,
0.26204514503479004,
-0.19851912558078766,
-0.13838152587413788,
-0.5807124376296997,
-0.46153774857521057,
-0.5540194511413574,
0.04491957649588585,
-0.3032514154911041,
-0.4748542010784149,
0.47454413771629333,
-0.003454695688560605,
-0.0354897603392601,
0.4710597097873688,
0.48934412002563477,
-0.002905668690800667,
1.6495715379714966,
0.45038190484046936,
0.07763618230819702,
0.5458674430847168,
-0.3480895161628723,
-0.09101524204015732,
-0.5294785499572754,
-0.475669264793396,
-1.017890453338623,
-0.21395742893218994,
-0.5543885231018066,
-0.15741652250289917,
0.9011432528495789,
-0.11951859295368195,
-0.5002279877662659,
0.3166395425796509,
-0.9142728447914124,
0.6780259013175964,
0.9989636540412903,
0.00028599720099009573,
-0.06263436377048492,
0.15887866914272308,
-0.30680474638938904,
-0.05006588250398636,
-0.9381203055381775,
-0.4427606165409088,
0.9105503559112549,
-0.005078795365989208,
0.9666070938110352,
-0.4739626944065094,
0.621691882610321,
0.36560744047164917,
0.13252082467079163,
-0.9904962778091431,
0.5272113084793091,
0.28389275074005127,
-0.7369093298912048,
-0.1541508585214615,
-0.3364286720752716,
-1.1573807001113892,
-0.046738263219594955,
0.0013364391634240746,
-0.42589157819747925,
0.5046603679656982,
0.22537051141262054,
-0.6944365501403809,
-0.22692203521728516,
-0.6912599802017212,
0.8753998279571533,
-0.41164547204971313,
-0.2916140556335449,
0.3837156891822815,
-0.8671455979347229,
-0.25601574778556824,
0.08050666004419327,
-0.23774132132530212,
0.07702112197875977,
-0.07284967601299286,
0.9480106830596924,
-0.47767719626426697,
0.4702144265174866,
-0.3752031624317169,
0.29228609800338745,
0.40724411606788635,
0.05213344842195511,
0.5873368978500366,
-0.1743749976158142,
-0.3967106342315674,
-0.37529608607292175,
-0.10572806745767593,
-0.37760287523269653,
-0.5474339127540588,
0.4457118809223175,
-0.791770875453949,
-0.432955801486969,
-0.5924839973449707,
-0.5399392247200012,
-0.45231059193611145,
0.27054843306541443,
0.7457672953605652,
0.610690176486969,
0.11352400481700897,
0.24837739765644073,
0.8472490310668945,
-0.24251064658164978,
0.5078475475311279,
0.6224848031997681,
0.294971227645874,
-0.5619127154350281,
0.8293711543083191,
0.18806977570056915,
0.10114505887031555,
0.22502468526363373,
0.3050350844860077,
-0.42985403537750244,
-0.42628371715545654,
-0.5922730565071106,
0.22753748297691345,
-0.8725359439849854,
-0.5104691386222839,
-0.7907785177230835,
-0.2680108845233917,
-0.42971643805503845,
-0.07330537587404251,
-0.17956100404262543,
-0.2363162785768509,
-0.42554357647895813,
0.03762374445796013,
0.5340035557746887,
0.4958934783935547,
-0.10362042486667633,
0.6017856597900391,
-0.8991825580596924,
0.2856537699699402,
0.3383446931838989,
-0.019487105309963226,
-0.22914588451385498,
-0.8388212323188782,
-0.49446919560432434,
-0.10371709614992142,
-0.1507042646408081,
-0.6883485317230225,
0.7555226683616638,
0.26691097021102905,
0.7882150411605835,
0.22717811167240143,
0.163841113448143,
0.48754069209098816,
-0.4296841025352478,
0.7864816188812256,
-0.03738842532038689,
-0.35980063676834106,
1.0330321788787842,
-0.5405219197273254,
0.35332271456718445,
1.0381108522415161,
0.9431055784225464,
-0.2541467249393463,
-0.21633310616016388,
-0.5786585807800293,
-0.8136886358261108,
0.9982784390449524,
-0.09935498982667923,
0.06754696369171143,
-0.32610100507736206,
0.5484321713447571,
0.16996289789676666,
0.24975208938121796,
-0.4103752076625824,
-0.4087190330028534,
0.013426453806459904,
-0.3688695430755615,
0.04690927267074585,
-0.37250250577926636,
-0.20660732686519623,
-0.41318458318710327,
0.7147539258003235,
-0.35329410433769226,
0.45926204323768616,
0.30151376128196716,
-0.024239523336291313,
-0.2449599951505661,
-0.25026029348373413,
0.296022891998291,
0.6794365644454956,
-0.35910564661026,
-0.07460924983024597,
-0.1985030323266983,
-0.1317996382713318,
0.38722485303878784,
0.16724713146686554,
-0.3580925464630127,
0.18044190108776093,
-0.09784409403800964,
0.9403091669082642,
-0.07464879751205444,
-0.6079103350639343,
0.12069722265005112,
-0.21152184903621674,
-0.11357449740171432,
-0.23944787681102753,
0.470684289932251,
-0.285732626914978,
0.1640007644891739,
0.6011653542518616,
-0.048785243183374405,
0.3214757442474365,
-0.49663665890693665,
0.2033476084470749,
0.4200499951839447,
-0.34648415446281433,
-0.09833412617444992,
0.8391351699829102,
0.009726355783641338,
-0.4070379436016083,
0.637482762336731,
-0.09369051456451416,
-0.4028213322162628,
0.728341281414032,
0.34591880440711975,
0.7047604322433472,
-0.24612440168857574,
0.2489733248949051,
0.6863574385643005,
0.09999535977840424,
-0.3052728474140167,
0.20601396262645721,
-0.06661339849233627,
-0.32004696130752563,
0.14937181770801544,
-0.747002363204956,
-0.6003940105438232,
0.12837214767932892,
-0.8823204040527344,
0.4016749858856201,
-0.5397481322288513,
-0.3904850482940674,
0.3840257525444031,
0.16282062232494354,
-0.7375856041908264,
0.628813624382019,
-0.17696769535541534,
1.044872522354126,
-0.6306537389755249,
0.578803300857544,
0.6762528419494629,
-0.5815383195877075,
-0.80792236328125,
-0.3383403420448303,
-0.31447634100914,
-0.7570493817329407,
1.1738250255584717,
0.1530929058790207,
0.20995579659938812,
0.3481842577457428,
-0.7629068493843079,
-0.8955386877059937,
0.768022894859314,
0.46451663970947266,
-0.3816969692707062,
-0.3672598898410797,
0.1779264360666275,
0.589672327041626,
-0.4714929759502411,
0.5247455835342407,
0.5088297128677368,
0.5136679410934448,
-0.041120290756225586,
-0.5768151879310608,
-0.24448718130588531,
-0.4574469029903412,
0.17067593336105347,
0.05797673016786575,
-0.5632933378219604,
0.8953774571418762,
-0.09758797287940979,
0.15430648624897003,
0.3265315294265747,
0.6134241819381714,
0.23233555257320404,
0.3554975986480713,
0.37921142578125,
0.3403249979019165,
0.8031522035598755,
-0.12602418661117554,
1.1946916580200195,
-0.6045018434524536,
0.17551428079605103,
0.9200558662414551,
-0.1200261116027832,
0.37233203649520874,
0.4288863241672516,
0.11270470172166824,
0.3955937623977661,
1.1965947151184082,
-0.3026796877384186,
0.8135419487953186,
0.08539417386054993,
-0.19423797726631165,
-0.4392760097980499,
-0.2451559454202652,
-0.3946290910243988,
0.23121528327465057,
0.36592212319374084,
-0.7180531620979309,
-0.4364487826824188,
0.28646209836006165,
-0.3204421401023865,
-0.07015006989240646,
-0.2440713495016098,
0.9709963798522949,
-0.1858922839164734,
-1.1228423118591309,
1.0159828662872314,
-0.043092332780361176,
0.3428370952606201,
-0.7361367344856262,
0.08445189148187637,
-0.5080796480178833,
0.05543699860572815,
0.03547438234090805,
-0.32008522748947144,
-0.2452305406332016,
0.031609177589416504,
-0.34111836552619934,
-0.24140627682209015,
0.7658469080924988,
-0.42425811290740967,
-0.511001467704773,
0.012981381267309189,
0.4280325472354889,
0.23574338853359222,
-0.04537348076701164,
-0.9238181114196777,
-0.3120775818824768,
-0.24210146069526672,
-0.6838890910148621,
0.5727216005325317,
0.7057812213897705,
0.03278607502579689,
0.7714096307754517,
0.7265960574150085,
0.11160971224308014,
0.14950846135616302,
-0.04204106330871582,
0.9654597043991089,
-0.7749888300895691,
-0.4792310297489166,
-0.5405229926109314,
0.3081520199775696,
0.018332788720726967,
-0.35374006628990173,
0.6919738054275513,
0.7469185590744019,
0.6419347524642944,
-0.228158101439476,
0.7591978907585144,
0.14714278280735016,
0.6345533728599548,
-0.43351760506629944,
0.6481592059135437,
-0.7053616046905518,
0.11845242232084274,
0.1577884554862976,
-1.1032224893569946,
0.020431699231266975,
0.5740827918052673,
-0.21082186698913574,
0.25224214792251587,
0.5726334452629089,
1.185902714729309,
0.03776586800813675,
-0.2877768576145172,
0.2237996906042099,
-0.28419890999794006,
0.11051537841558456,
0.28393229842185974,
0.8553584814071655,
-0.6191032528877258,
0.6117132306098938,
-0.32394999265670776,
0.04383395239710808,
-0.550033450126648,
-0.7035625576972961,
-0.9566130042076111,
-0.6412003040313721,
-0.32035306096076965,
-0.5260291695594788,
0.1768447309732437,
1.0945903062820435,
0.7966387867927551,
-0.6631214022636414,
-0.20692628622055054,
-0.1114460751414299,
-0.2942747175693512,
0.16087931394577026,
-0.29253679513931274,
0.40518319606781006,
-0.9484281539916992,
-0.8262124061584473,
0.5580737590789795,
-0.020178673788905144,
0.28529271483421326,
-0.23078615963459015,
-0.180578351020813,
-0.2332635223865509,
0.17054212093353271,
0.3463808596134186,
0.3416096270084381,
-0.18814654648303986,
-0.06079963967204094,
0.2919262647628784,
-0.5847495794296265,
0.13968433439731598,
0.8478612303733826,
-1.0724093914031982,
0.5668343305587769,
0.7397276759147644,
0.7320632934570312,
0.3621394634246826,
0.13987544178962708,
0.5968668460845947,
-0.7139667868614197,
0.16351072490215302,
0.5036571621894836,
0.14371854066848755,
0.3233226537704468,
-0.5006229281425476,
0.5593203902244568,
0.08981216698884964,
-0.7957344651222229,
-1.1363977193832397,
-0.1025330051779747,
-0.7257362604141235,
-0.12235310673713684,
1.1363568305969238,
0.09996843338012695,
-0.4044549763202667,
-0.04281267896294594,
-0.3541947901248932,
0.3108047842979431,
-0.4228944182395935,
0.8005950450897217,
0.3208974599838257,
-0.40490177273750305,
-0.06314240396022797,
-0.5975458025932312,
0.9084881544113159,
0.6287866830825806,
-0.8700352907180786,
-0.021281039342284203,
0.5119553208351135,
0.10385793447494507,
0.10059663653373718,
0.3643420338630676,
0.01524308044463396,
0.4323444664478302,
-0.005519783589988947,
-0.01841343380510807,
-0.3121163547039032,
-0.6573891043663025,
-0.1727277636528015,
0.1164807677268982,
0.29194676876068115,
-0.030006058514118195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11704v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11704v1 | Nemotron-4 340B Technical Report | 2024-06-17T16:25:04 | 2024-06-17T16:25:04 | Nvidia, :, Bo Adler, Niket Agarwal, Ashwath Aithal, Dong H. Anh, Pallab Bhattacharya, Annika Brundyn, Jared Casper, Bryan Catanzaro, Sharon Clay, Jonathan Cohen, Sirshak Das, Ayush Dattagupta, Olivier Delalleau, Leon Derczynski, Yi Dong, Daniel Egert, Ellie Evans, Aleksander Ficek, Denys Fridman, Shaona Ghosh, Boris Ginsburg, Igor Gitman, Tomasz Grzegorzek, Robert Hero, Jining Huang, Vibhu Jawa, Joseph Jennings, Aastha Jhunjhunwala, John Kamalu, Sadaf Khan, Oleksii Kuchaiev, Patrick LeGresley, Hui Li, Jiwei Liu, Zihan Liu, Eileen Long, Ameya Sunil Mahabaleshwarkar, Somshubra Majumdar, James Maki, Miguel Martinez, Maer Rodrigues de Melo, Ivan Moshkov, Deepak Narayanan, Sean Narenthiran, Jesus Navarro, Phong Nguyen, Osvald Nitski, Vahid Noroozi, Guruprasad Nutheti, Christopher Parisien, Jupinder Parmar, Mostofa Patwary, Krzysztof Pawelec, Wei Ping, Shrimai Prabhumoye, Rajarshi Roy, Trisha Saar, Vasanth Rao Naik Sabavat, Sanjeev Satheesh, Jane Polak Scowcroft, Jason Sewall, Pavel Shamis, Gerald Shen, Mohammad Shoeybi, Dave Sizer, Misha Smelyanskiy, Felipe Soares, Makesh Narsimhan Sreedhar, Dan Su, Sandeep Subramanian, Shengyang Sun, Shubham Toshniwal, Hao Wang, Zhilin Wang, Jiaxuan You, Jiaqi Zeng, Jimmy Zhang, Jing Zhang, Vivienne Zhang, Yian Zhang, Chen Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We release the Nemotron-4 340B model family, including Nemotron-4-340B-Base,
Nemotron-4-340B-Instruct, and Nemotron-4-340B-Reward. Our models are open
access under the NVIDIA Open Model License Agreement, a permissive model
license that allows distribution, modification, and use of the models and its
outputs. These models perform competitively to open access models on a wide
range of evaluation benchmarks, and were sized to fit on a single DGX H100 with
8 GPUs when deployed in FP8 precision. We believe that the community can
benefit from these models in various research studies and commercial
applications, especially for generating synthetic data to train smaller
language models. Notably, over 98% of data used in our model alignment process
is synthetically generated, showcasing the effectiveness of these models in
generating synthetic data. To further support open research and facilitate
model development, we are also open-sourcing the synthetic data generation
pipeline used in our model alignment process. | [
-0.4830034077167511,
-0.2444203943014145,
0.42087802290916443,
0.10159975290298462,
-0.06017771363258362,
-0.23633012175559998,
0.1809295117855072,
-0.5366504192352295,
-0.16009333729743958,
0.8153891563415527,
-0.5507673025131226,
-0.22425271570682526,
-0.33376261591911316,
0.14517486095428467,
-0.23300805687904358,
0.9303293228149414,
-0.2128971368074417,
0.1944785863161087,
-0.21370582282543182,
-0.06061651185154915,
-0.31032490730285645,
-0.730185866355896,
-0.5182714462280273,
-0.40251606702804565,
0.5791589021682739,
0.4197206497192383,
0.7303462028503418,
0.8607937693595886,
0.8149771690368652,
0.20064005255699158,
-0.08614018559455872,
0.05617736652493477,
-0.35355615615844727,
-0.06764920800924301,
-0.40664637088775635,
-0.06408090144395828,
-1.3544176816940308,
0.09658215194940567,
0.6823847889900208,
0.3737720847129822,
-0.420291930437088,
0.3408663272857666,
-0.28830990195274353,
0.3896883726119995,
-0.4615473747253418,
0.24187113344669342,
-0.31439945101737976,
-0.05912461504340172,
-0.6748232841491699,
0.22148165106773376,
-0.4386361837387085,
-0.5974972248077393,
0.02906716614961624,
-0.8762244582176208,
0.41076743602752686,
0.2368590384721756,
1.0193530321121216,
0.018089495599269867,
-0.2695222496986389,
-0.06827646493911743,
-0.5207988023757935,
0.6446564793586731,
-1.0862901210784912,
0.4154511094093323,
0.12236937135457993,
0.8090556859970093,
-0.12341803312301636,
-0.8905715942382812,
-0.5590841770172119,
-0.10433732718229294,
0.2607894241809845,
0.0679786279797554,
-0.48007211089134216,
0.02226996421813965,
0.22832389175891876,
0.7368082404136658,
-0.49507930874824524,
0.12532243132591248,
-0.8042855858802795,
-0.20357823371887207,
0.6057437062263489,
0.3856683373451233,
0.1520649939775467,
-0.14534595608711243,
-0.3740585744380951,
-0.0641142800450325,
-0.9427593946456909,
-0.6454329490661621,
0.8053188323974609,
0.2092636376619339,
-0.24870565533638,
0.7629444003105164,
-0.26595431566238403,
0.9892047047615051,
0.19952408969402313,
0.2542646825313568,
0.6304711699485779,
-0.5335916876792908,
-0.32861489057540894,
-0.07753671705722809,
0.6004353165626526,
0.43469005823135376,
-0.10805745422840118,
0.03946434333920479,
-0.4858199656009674,
-0.13700927793979645,
0.5397046804428101,
-0.9061135649681091,
-0.04478603973984718,
0.2238764613866806,
-0.3791061341762543,
-0.24702641367912292,
-0.002878718776628375,
-1.0484161376953125,
-0.170526921749115,
-0.23106062412261963,
0.4172675311565399,
-0.35465747117996216,
-0.39903125166893005,
0.3097226321697235,
-0.3543698787689209,
0.3978268504142761,
0.36058881878852844,
-1.2938343286514282,
0.6819364428520203,
0.4662424325942993,
0.9043225049972534,
-0.3154468834400177,
-0.01811933144927025,
-0.3014046549797058,
0.3199467062950134,
-0.13545595109462738,
0.5180380940437317,
-0.28121012449264526,
-0.31611600518226624,
-0.02647254802286625,
0.16512247920036316,
0.16033735871315002,
-0.82942795753479,
0.5029160976409912,
-0.5966898798942566,
0.22382621467113495,
0.07471175491809845,
-0.47831639647483826,
-0.3448614180088043,
0.17109687626361847,
-1.0286399126052856,
0.7361776232719421,
0.3726782202720642,
-0.45892876386642456,
-0.05072867497801781,
-0.8235719203948975,
0.23327723145484924,
0.308085173368454,
-0.07693734019994736,
-0.32586103677749634,
0.2523786127567291,
-0.023658689111471176,
0.08533548563718796,
-0.810283899307251,
0.24391287565231323,
-0.31447523832321167,
0.06759635359048843,
-0.07964767515659332,
-0.17456668615341187,
0.481963187456131,
0.3900582790374756,
-0.25959885120391846,
0.11118494719266891,
-0.448664128780365,
-0.23023372888565063,
0.16810432076454163,
0.09939233213663101,
0.32953697443008423,
-0.5821431279182434,
0.01698397658765316,
0.38555407524108887,
0.3374062180519104,
-0.9615166783332825,
0.15058711171150208,
-0.38132065534591675,
0.31651434302330017,
0.7441913485527039,
-0.018271554261446,
0.6032209396362305,
-0.4873998463153839,
0.9499498009681702,
-0.07642047852277756,
0.37230777740478516,
-0.08800863474607468,
-0.6642401814460754,
-0.31801289319992065,
-0.27445635199546814,
0.21649320423603058,
0.07225657254457474,
-0.519707202911377,
-0.132819265127182,
-0.049730584025382996,
-0.7072844505310059,
-0.24581491947174072,
-0.13525377213954926,
0.5483880043029785,
0.7051835656166077,
0.31163743138313293,
-0.31189873814582825,
-0.4138903021812439,
-1.100942611694336,
0.11969389021396637,
0.22338083386421204,
0.10896089673042297,
0.3250047266483307,
0.6758443713188171,
-0.2907310426235199,
0.6032500863075256,
-0.6540383696556091,
-0.12558439373970032,
-0.16538073122501373,
0.09563004970550537,
0.4199998378753662,
0.6650064587593079,
0.8493593335151672,
-0.46818435192108154,
-0.22013577818870544,
0.2293035387992859,
-0.5839371085166931,
0.06581750512123108,
0.5920162200927734,
-0.42339715361595154,
0.5118651390075684,
0.24477817118167877,
-0.4132760763168335,
0.46930766105651855,
0.9571999311447144,
0.0061726924031972885,
0.3169134259223938,
-0.2976541221141815,
-0.09143374115228653,
-1.039003610610962,
0.17609630525112152,
0.055118899792432785,
0.09377593547105789,
-0.5163261890411377,
-0.20523856580257416,
0.32352450489997864,
-0.06541847437620163,
-0.5899246335029602,
0.6951792240142822,
-0.38812270760536194,
-0.0580330453813076,
-0.26932212710380554,
0.06149324029684067,
0.03356032073497772,
0.18935130536556244,
0.09577543288469315,
0.5474674701690674,
0.36140647530555725,
-0.6076658368110657,
0.5960431098937988,
0.4539511799812317,
-0.00774596631526947,
0.2370927333831787,
-0.9622753858566284,
0.17775318026542664,
0.05665498971939087,
0.21085353195667267,
-0.39970168471336365,
-0.75123131275177,
0.31775566935539246,
-0.6313007473945618,
0.1541445404291153,
-0.23102566599845886,
-0.5267687439918518,
-0.23347316682338715,
0.12105797976255417,
0.836395263671875,
0.6945522427558899,
-0.6252415776252747,
0.6150729656219482,
0.6548838019371033,
-0.14219459891319275,
-0.2019682377576828,
-0.7261653542518616,
-0.542762041091919,
0.03276558220386505,
-0.8722915053367615,
0.768143892288208,
0.07987143099308014,
-0.19046063721179962,
0.20298892259597778,
0.004431931767612696,
-0.25679439306259155,
-0.3349146246910095,
0.4838930368423462,
0.7457662224769592,
-0.3174351751804352,
0.032567281275987625,
-0.22082944214344025,
-0.16403701901435852,
0.025523517280817032,
-0.30543482303619385,
0.599576473236084,
-0.13292817771434784,
-0.21132013201713562,
-0.31723901629447937,
-0.07348384708166122,
0.43135878443717957,
-0.4052416682243347,
0.6482267379760742,
0.08054201304912567,
-0.7847312092781067,
-0.13400757312774658,
-0.18882869184017181,
-0.3114457130432129,
-0.49576371908187866,
0.2997419238090515,
-0.15782132744789124,
-0.4584459960460663,
0.2238135039806366,
0.1631205976009369,
0.33555957674980164,
0.6310318112373352,
0.6437462568283081,
0.4598080813884735,
0.9155310988426208,
0.5871430039405823,
0.510216474533081,
0.3192102015018463,
-0.06633853167295456,
0.009890081360936165,
-0.9674399495124817,
-0.5875844955444336,
-0.42955878376960754,
-0.07360117137432098,
-0.3579534888267517,
-0.5875608921051025,
0.23198936879634857,
-0.447922021150589,
-0.4045461118221283,
0.4568880796432495,
-0.43735718727111816,
0.14812137186527252,
0.519131600856781,
-0.28387755155563354,
0.05851689353585243,
-0.07018834352493286,
-0.12706781923770905,
-0.08238158375024796,
-0.4369341731071472,
-0.6307222247123718,
1.247407078742981,
0.23354879021644592,
0.5533604621887207,
0.4698173403739929,
0.6830188632011414,
-0.11718038469552994,
0.6752803921699524,
-0.3169434368610382,
0.22240549325942993,
0.05253272503614426,
-1.2817190885543823,
-0.09018570184707642,
-0.348685622215271,
-0.8637668490409851,
0.05291588604450226,
-0.004151990637183189,
-0.38565996289253235,
0.028781279921531677,
0.36583268642425537,
-0.4999721348285675,
0.3648969233036041,
-0.6030576825141907,
1.0848252773284912,
-0.11631248146295547,
-0.44786307215690613,
-0.04914509132504463,
-0.2382066547870636,
0.625004231929779,
-0.3132174015045166,
0.14371640980243683,
-0.29098305106163025,
0.08409497886896133,
0.5271036624908447,
-0.48693257570266724,
0.388409823179245,
-0.23272639513015747,
0.010880788788199425,
-0.050894610583782196,
-0.17393198609352112,
0.1913347989320755,
0.12510381639003754,
-0.5134528279304504,
0.43543970584869385,
-0.2861141860485077,
-0.369649738073349,
-0.40872108936309814,
0.7357010245323181,
-0.8186712265014648,
-0.4406510889530182,
-0.8603532314300537,
-0.698277473449707,
-0.1823948323726654,
0.28763800859451294,
0.2203584760427475,
0.6859816312789917,
-0.10189621895551682,
0.23324571549892426,
0.4183833599090576,
-0.37855687737464905,
0.42639029026031494,
0.5380830764770508,
-0.5385463833808899,
-0.8304078578948975,
0.7055558562278748,
0.1432216465473175,
0.7168611288070679,
-0.019275542348623276,
-0.21954742074012756,
-0.1397767812013626,
-0.6670531034469604,
-0.5648413896560669,
0.6279764771461487,
-0.29708918929100037,
-0.26972663402557373,
-0.23195452988147736,
-0.4095607399940491,
-0.6950313448905945,
0.0011476362124085426,
-0.7063434720039368,
-0.5303335189819336,
-0.19801506400108337,
-0.196235790848732,
0.35488614439964294,
1.3393971920013428,
-0.09767864644527435,
0.5218095183372498,
-0.8452136516571045,
0.34166690707206726,
-0.17956984043121338,
0.48079460859298706,
-0.2639821469783783,
-0.749085545539856,
-0.28423869609832764,
0.19257420301437378,
-0.8069129586219788,
-0.765101432800293,
0.9132524728775024,
-0.30752211809158325,
0.8393229246139526,
-0.09198574721813202,
-0.14425340294837952,
0.4498918354511261,
-0.5757437348365784,
0.7102446556091309,
0.28779172897338867,
-1.0401521921157837,
0.3411616086959839,
-0.6174622178077698,
0.325495183467865,
0.0028116959147155285,
0.41581934690475464,
-0.1819831132888794,
-0.08368276059627533,
-0.8403133153915405,
-0.7832853198051453,
1.0775359869003296,
0.3619619607925415,
-0.05631052702665329,
0.022125501185655594,
0.42482274770736694,
0.2722763419151306,
0.28312310576438904,
-0.6034887433052063,
-0.14319714903831482,
-0.4490046501159668,
-0.32989707589149475,
-0.13739356398582458,
-0.07607827335596085,
-0.22716523706912994,
-0.05364646390080452,
0.8515186905860901,
-0.05324646830558777,
0.2359294891357422,
0.07378587126731873,
0.16731366515159607,
0.03651099652051926,
-0.2596501111984253,
0.6018037796020508,
0.5651694536209106,
-0.6194818615913391,
-0.14023754000663757,
-0.08723536133766174,
-0.6003394722938538,
-0.11412656307220459,
0.33942297101020813,
0.07493234425783157,
-0.12179642170667648,
-0.1843579113483429,
0.5909829139709473,
0.1310155987739563,
-0.48712289333343506,
0.39221084117889404,
-0.10163159668445587,
-0.5637308359146118,
-0.40653809905052185,
-0.10598514974117279,
0.2640955150127411,
0.16960780322551727,
-0.09031875431537628,
0.11347389966249466,
0.08403358608484268,
-0.1997065395116806,
0.3196967840194702,
0.1314917504787445,
-0.2998410165309906,
-0.5838537812232971,
0.8447197675704956,
0.29382601380348206,
-0.03204535320401192,
0.8867940306663513,
-0.19400213658809662,
0.049327630549669266,
0.6926261186599731,
0.6921919584274292,
0.8014948964118958,
-0.15751273930072784,
0.15361742675304413,
0.7198710441589355,
0.21699970960617065,
-0.23677708208560944,
0.33750900626182556,
0.5258713960647583,
-0.7949456572532654,
-0.0964813232421875,
-0.5637160539627075,
-0.8622668981552124,
-0.23157472908496857,
-0.9583487510681152,
0.39575642347335815,
-0.5994035601615906,
-0.33919113874435425,
0.4028521478176117,
-0.3451339602470398,
-0.40597668290138245,
0.15229490399360657,
0.356599897146225,
0.9840132594108582,
-0.41873881220817566,
1.2337565422058105,
0.5403003096580505,
-0.7263354659080505,
-0.8798112869262695,
-0.1895020604133606,
0.1134314313530922,
-0.5673058032989502,
0.896676778793335,
0.060830019414424896,
-0.05068013817071915,
-0.020376503467559814,
-0.5838345289230347,
-1.0896351337432861,
1.4933404922485352,
0.7803570032119751,
-0.2536931037902832,
-0.08945835381746292,
0.0005516235833056271,
0.24391306936740875,
-0.45763564109802246,
0.2945677936077118,
0.21354787051677704,
0.4996185004711151,
0.25126200914382935,
-0.9750514030456543,
0.03966112807393074,
-0.41650763154029846,
-0.10181022435426712,
0.41746094822883606,
-0.7594039440155029,
1.4626809358596802,
0.058207422494888306,
0.01964707300066948,
0.14969469606876373,
0.593662440776825,
0.6468811631202698,
0.28131183981895447,
0.022020503878593445,
0.4307800531387329,
0.7260509133338928,
-0.18670281767845154,
1.3389452695846558,
-0.3779549300670624,
0.166021928191185,
1.097676157951355,
-0.6635003089904785,
0.6039660573005676,
0.5597533583641052,
0.36618685722351074,
0.49581995606422424,
0.3487657904624939,
-0.12809236347675323,
0.3132966160774231,
0.30607736110687256,
-0.16326037049293518,
0.11738071590662003,
-0.1191226914525032,
-0.43882033228874207,
0.02336990460753441,
0.3123493492603302,
-0.33119386434555054,
-0.22443750500679016,
-0.41621407866477966,
0.05425866320729256,
-0.19042308628559113,
-0.37011778354644775,
0.3017185926437378,
0.020901165902614594,
-0.8982407450675964,
0.4450080692768097,
0.19322971999645233,
0.3001961410045624,
-0.6902466416358948,
-0.28303414583206177,
-0.08609630167484283,
0.6195222735404968,
-0.40994367003440857,
-0.576926589012146,
0.5384182333946228,
0.01506414357572794,
-0.2979523539543152,
-0.30008623003959656,
0.2154242992401123,
0.07094618678092957,
-0.10934363305568695,
0.27410101890563965,
0.08103212714195251,
0.051857929676771164,
0.11094792932271957,
-0.15865705907344818,
0.13263632357120514,
-0.060350868850946426,
-0.040778063237667084,
0.322151780128479,
0.12599240243434906,
-0.16913878917694092,
0.45118388533592224,
0.5386471152305603,
-0.09703298658132553,
0.5684064626693726,
-0.2537256181240082,
0.8268545269966125,
-0.8295723795890808,
0.12370108813047409,
-0.4797223210334778,
0.5647507309913635,
-0.28088241815567017,
-0.7085393071174622,
1.130293846130371,
0.8588094711303711,
0.8527106046676636,
-0.15437470376491547,
0.7938506007194519,
-0.03139509633183479,
0.2895377278327942,
-0.39080074429512024,
0.19296051561832428,
-0.4463813900947571,
-0.05412490665912628,
0.01844371296465397,
-0.6532505750656128,
-0.262298047542572,
0.17860639095306396,
-0.25650086998939514,
-0.009019504301249981,
0.8457875847816467,
0.9054195284843445,
-0.10616635531187057,
0.49565738439559937,
0.2768740952014923,
0.04933108389377594,
0.5640245079994202,
0.5531705617904663,
0.5719608664512634,
-0.36852142214775085,
0.32497069239616394,
-0.44065532088279724,
-0.39848023653030396,
-0.20319844782352448,
-0.8770914673805237,
-0.5831480026245117,
-0.30254149436950684,
-0.25303635001182556,
-0.39122411608695984,
-0.03673141077160835,
0.6832228302955627,
0.7834998369216919,
-0.7036885023117065,
-0.5210477113723755,
-0.3605106770992279,
-0.21179437637329102,
0.06083247810602188,
-0.14232634007930756,
-0.12100642919540405,
-0.23470644652843475,
-1.1139041185379028,
0.33323416113853455,
0.4197913706302643,
0.19336244463920593,
-0.18647366762161255,
-0.4613032937049866,
-0.2031908929347992,
0.34182068705558777,
-0.09084013104438782,
0.33038991689682007,
-0.5032879710197449,
-0.02074601873755455,
0.2945764660835266,
-0.354010671377182,
-0.09654030203819275,
0.439799964427948,
-0.3970997631549835,
0.43217793107032776,
0.7338323593139648,
0.5392698049545288,
0.7738277912139893,
-0.16782552003860474,
1.279430866241455,
-0.33658385276794434,
0.18134117126464844,
0.35545000433921814,
0.6632599830627441,
0.12099069356918335,
-0.00540370587259531,
0.5638118386268616,
0.007358720526099205,
-0.8300567865371704,
-1.0191168785095215,
0.3735731244087219,
-1.1219850778579712,
0.1639607697725296,
1.2399498224258423,
-0.15126192569732666,
-0.5007945895195007,
0.2658981382846832,
-0.18859651684761047,
0.28944259881973267,
-0.35538896918296814,
-0.09869758784770966,
0.5322725176811218,
-0.2583732306957245,
0.21851885318756104,
-1.093468427658081,
0.4010511338710785,
0.16853056848049164,
-0.8893139362335205,
-0.21007300913333893,
0.7445738315582275,
0.22617299854755402,
0.12529322504997253,
0.2321101427078247,
-0.8816788792610168,
0.43645575642585754,
0.013736831024289131,
0.7717689871788025,
-0.12746721506118774,
-0.06103970482945442,
-0.5660101175308228,
0.24873754382133484,
0.00019873348355758935,
-0.3413413465023041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11698v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11698v1 | Meta Reasoning for Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T16:14:11 | 2024-06-17T16:14:11 | Peizhong Gao, Ao Xie, Shaoguang Mao, Wenshan Wu, Yan Xia, Haipeng Mi, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce Meta-Reasoning Prompting (MRP), a novel and efficient system
prompting method for large language models (LLMs) inspired by human
meta-reasoning. Traditional in-context learning-based reasoning techniques,
such as Tree-of-Thoughts, show promise but lack consistent state-of-the-art
performance across diverse tasks due to their specialized nature. MRP addresses
this limitation by guiding LLMs to dynamically select and apply different
reasoning methods based on the specific requirements of each task, optimizing
both performance and computational efficiency. With MRP, LLM reasoning operates
in two phases. Initially, the LLM identifies the most appropriate reasoning
method using task input cues and objective descriptions of available methods.
Subsequently, it applies the chosen method to complete the task. This dynamic
strategy mirrors human meta-reasoning, allowing the model to excel in a wide
range of problem domains. We evaluate the effectiveness of MRP through
comprehensive benchmarks. The results demonstrate that MRP achieves or
approaches state-of-the-art performance across diverse tasks. MRP represents a
significant advancement in enabling LLMs to identify cognitive challenges
across problems and leverage benefits across different reasoning approaches,
enhancing their ability to handle diverse and complex problem domains
efficiently. Every LLM deserves a Meta-Reasoning Prompting to unlock its full
potential and ensure adaptability in an ever-evolving landscape of challenges
and applications. | [
-0.47802621126174927,
-0.7364786863327026,
0.7222219109535217,
0.2338746190071106,
-0.021648727357387543,
0.15185143053531647,
-0.3850821852684021,
-0.22981561720371246,
-0.07899100333452225,
0.27034300565719604,
-0.9313658475875854,
-0.4314589500427246,
-0.25256845355033875,
0.4191577732563019,
0.08679216355085373,
0.4853149354457855,
0.14447703957557678,
-0.17392000555992126,
-0.39964738488197327,
0.019330451264977455,
-0.9217332005500793,
-0.24011099338531494,
-0.842452347278595,
-0.5171835422515869,
0.625339925289154,
0.7649837732315063,
0.4789127707481384,
0.31850966811180115,
0.1425219178199768,
0.28988024592399597,
-0.11491691321134567,
0.6653605103492737,
0.0835246816277504,
0.5530280470848083,
-0.6040504574775696,
-0.2692925035953522,
-0.4546840786933899,
-0.26456859707832336,
0.5697361826896667,
0.6686744689941406,
-0.38523411750793457,
0.526583194732666,
0.25423160195350647,
0.6562989950180054,
-1.0278164148330688,
0.10168824344873428,
-0.7469998002052307,
0.08058756589889526,
-0.008066664449870586,
-0.40783366560935974,
-0.7433642745018005,
0.03725576773285866,
0.017280885949730873,
-0.44408780336380005,
-0.10769670456647873,
-0.09997259080410004,
0.3984465003013611,
0.4084533751010895,
-0.33018264174461365,
-0.24517080187797546,
-0.7624790072441101,
0.6440176963806152,
-0.49938300251960754,
0.5449588298797607,
0.2826939821243286,
0.4588471055030823,
-0.18875129520893097,
-0.612402081489563,
-0.6220166087150574,
-0.1817142218351364,
0.10659033805131912,
-0.06253514438867569,
-0.1016516163945198,
-0.07738018035888672,
0.5176159143447876,
-0.16507560014724731,
-0.7283031940460205,
-0.12602625787258148,
0.13141052424907684,
-0.046779122203588486,
0.3132321536540985,
0.34777531027793884,
0.17639562487602234,
-0.277519553899765,
-0.05681929364800453,
0.008210737258195877,
-0.7670766711235046,
0.05056194216012955,
-0.021320486441254616,
0.486652135848999,
0.24033759534358978,
0.3495001494884491,
-0.3238947093486786,
0.902230441570282,
0.06654362380504608,
-0.27681246399879456,
-0.03117593377828598,
-0.05439950153231621,
-0.2955050468444824,
-0.29606786370277405,
0.906486451625824,
0.1151716560125351,
0.3247126638889313,
0.2701137959957123,
-0.21048443019390106,
-0.37168291211128235,
0.1338975578546524,
-0.37238457798957825,
0.05240410193800926,
0.2602246105670929,
-0.4757891595363617,
-0.08265221863985062,
-0.16898655891418457,
-1.1142793893814087,
-0.2046635001897812,
-0.29218193888664246,
0.3435182273387909,
-0.4874951243400574,
-0.4450261890888214,
0.3011842668056488,
0.06037920340895653,
0.1414204239845276,
0.34303411841392517,
-1.2674890756607056,
-0.0402025505900383,
0.7551835179328918,
0.625462532043457,
0.129990816116333,
-0.2708326578140259,
-0.4810326397418976,
0.45955440402030945,
-0.1958874762058258,
0.846436083316803,
-0.9976351261138916,
-0.3684314787387848,
-0.003988099284470081,
-0.2241450995206833,
-0.2421787679195404,
-0.7905398607254028,
0.8410578966140747,
-0.48032429814338684,
0.1975245624780655,
-0.6201239228248596,
-0.009443912655115128,
-0.20950298011302948,
0.576610267162323,
-0.36255761981010437,
1.1885154247283936,
-0.09718164056539536,
-0.689384937286377,
0.3885914385318756,
-0.9312750697135925,
-0.42034968733787537,
0.2443079650402069,
-0.16227243840694427,
-0.014617585577070713,
0.045397642999887466,
0.5358301401138306,
0.3930615782737732,
-0.38428351283073425,
0.38602739572525024,
-0.35549256205558777,
-0.08796656876802444,
0.0861501470208168,
-0.5354968905448914,
0.708400547504425,
0.504646360874176,
-0.2509933412075043,
0.14554020762443542,
-0.5504036545753479,
0.35360896587371826,
0.2481195330619812,
-0.4503113329410553,
-0.2871136963367462,
0.22750616073608398,
-0.3262995779514313,
0.37988853454589844,
0.16980652511119843,
-0.10313974320888519,
0.5583377480506897,
-0.07589192688465118,
0.6460115313529968,
0.7260673642158508,
-0.1333891898393631,
0.12425092607736588,
-0.02427150309085846,
0.719836413860321,
-0.2335728108882904,
0.09568533301353455,
-0.6721377372741699,
-0.4821518063545227,
-0.4693840742111206,
-0.3973192572593689,
0.31167998909950256,
0.9460220336914062,
-0.8218463063240051,
0.5486820936203003,
-0.19922654330730438,
-0.03171061351895332,
-0.2855429947376251,
-0.11693823337554932,
0.23991158604621887,
0.5328109264373779,
0.4231388568878174,
0.26316991448402405,
-0.6192713975906372,
-0.7580554485321045,
-0.5143718123435974,
-0.17387279868125916,
-0.09634372591972351,
0.5022768974304199,
0.5001758337020874,
-0.4540906548500061,
1.099462628364563,
-0.5505537986755371,
0.1411253660917282,
-0.4355968236923218,
0.24708056449890137,
0.1750718653202057,
0.2941698133945465,
0.18644805252552032,
-0.5161216259002686,
-0.6195918321609497,
-0.16920483112335205,
-0.761100709438324,
-0.530027449131012,
-0.2062779814004898,
-0.018114803358912468,
0.22591067850589752,
0.5793765187263489,
-0.8425487875938416,
-0.008341128006577492,
0.45705699920654297,
-0.3102453947067261,
0.8072420358657837,
-0.17814522981643677,
0.26865142583847046,
-1.024631381034851,
0.37439849972724915,
-0.38620904088020325,
-0.3725644648075104,
-0.34649109840393066,
0.22298072278499603,
0.04442891478538513,
-0.3566758334636688,
-0.13098478317260742,
0.6100287437438965,
-0.46178561449050903,
0.0724439024925232,
-0.3351688086986542,
-0.0719694197177887,
-0.04962011054158211,
0.36522722244262695,
0.2683402895927429,
0.7504986524581909,
0.5890483856201172,
-0.7324884533882141,
0.5024021863937378,
0.07865429669618607,
-0.0644587054848671,
0.737084686756134,
-0.5003917813301086,
0.0941958799958229,
-0.11536239087581635,
0.574795126914978,
-0.8766499757766724,
-0.16018080711364746,
0.36909806728363037,
-0.44034746289253235,
0.3537859320640564,
-0.14188800752162933,
-0.7499479055404663,
-0.6954900622367859,
0.07972036302089691,
0.46409568190574646,
0.36895307898521423,
-0.5812765955924988,
0.8532980680465698,
-0.045117516070604324,
-0.21087318658828735,
-0.8851514458656311,
-0.4515860974788666,
0.4033375680446625,
-0.18140743672847748,
-0.6383892893791199,
0.09753371775150299,
-0.029608910903334618,
-0.02015177719295025,
-0.17003756761550903,
-0.0735054761171341,
0.08461157977581024,
0.03614876791834831,
0.03989909589290619,
0.10066186636686325,
-0.1864214986562729,
0.32138338685035706,
0.16589775681495667,
-0.48443683981895447,
0.2446836531162262,
-0.5999167561531067,
0.6849741339683533,
-0.08450287580490112,
-0.654478907585144,
-0.5215950012207031,
0.5095469355583191,
0.646571695804596,
-0.3912259638309479,
0.5625213384628296,
0.5644597411155701,
-0.37233439087867737,
-0.4716319441795349,
-0.5625448822975159,
-0.3824799954891205,
-0.4850814640522003,
0.19228950142860413,
-0.7995598316192627,
-0.761292040348053,
0.35265934467315674,
-0.3921387791633606,
0.14819639921188354,
0.3601803183555603,
0.6857309341430664,
-0.07065000385046005,
1.2121303081512451,
0.40530380606651306,
0.11169484257698059,
0.43564310669898987,
-0.048899732530117035,
0.057171180844306946,
-0.9300939440727234,
-0.32797813415527344,
-0.57093346118927,
-0.21931904554367065,
-0.12165582180023193,
-0.6471983194351196,
0.35159605741500854,
-0.0972798764705658,
-0.11091950535774231,
0.1397126019001007,
-0.5670384168624878,
0.6280520558357239,
0.5270477533340454,
0.014664248563349247,
0.30219781398773193,
-0.1977093666791916,
-0.5777696967124939,
-0.0007946177502162755,
-0.9225963950157166,
-0.6857044100761414,
0.9461469650268555,
0.295784056186676,
0.6726400852203369,
0.020516838878393173,
0.5333313345909119,
0.2491927593946457,
0.16228744387626648,
-0.6629563570022583,
0.8625370264053345,
0.244053915143013,
-0.818894624710083,
-0.34820863604545593,
-0.5649707913398743,
-0.9536074995994568,
0.48563745617866516,
-0.32400035858154297,
-0.6229327321052551,
-0.08586284518241882,
0.49167442321777344,
-0.5519241690635681,
0.39239436388015747,
-0.48022863268852234,
0.9758098125457764,
-0.0884137749671936,
-0.3217426836490631,
-0.49490538239479065,
-0.6700056791305542,
0.49555161595344543,
0.1897139847278595,
0.27888160943984985,
0.05806731432676315,
-0.146977037191391,
0.3985065817832947,
-0.07262292504310608,
0.8320382833480835,
-0.2963663637638092,
-0.19318947196006775,
0.46066492795944214,
0.3464570641517639,
0.5896178483963013,
0.0295199416577816,
-0.06586582213640213,
-0.19464938342571259,
0.03889792412519455,
-0.1723872423171997,
-0.7153817415237427,
0.4668792188167572,
-0.16475696861743927,
-0.7685165405273438,
-0.36790376901626587,
-0.6235685348510742,
-0.40064147114753723,
0.21759137511253357,
0.019879408180713654,
0.28074705600738525,
-0.10940304398536682,
0.05425542965531349,
0.9752902984619141,
-0.4786801040172577,
0.41501230001449585,
0.659027099609375,
-0.29303622245788574,
-0.534848690032959,
0.744823157787323,
-0.22484515607357025,
0.41530007123947144,
0.6890015006065369,
0.4732862114906311,
-0.3021395802497864,
-0.33684042096138,
-0.6210387945175171,
0.3602203130722046,
-0.834684431552887,
-0.17217570543289185,
-0.8169567584991455,
0.037323735654354095,
-0.43718090653419495,
0.04451980069279671,
-0.18772928416728973,
-0.34281691908836365,
-0.02988566644489765,
0.14549095928668976,
-0.19134581089019775,
0.5097978115081787,
-0.19820044934749603,
-0.02263224497437477,
-1.0909550189971924,
0.42554256319999695,
0.7905001044273376,
0.22652657330036163,
0.15120267868041992,
-0.5841193199157715,
-0.07918877899646759,
-0.0795595645904541,
-0.6760633587837219,
-0.8982518315315247,
0.01406046748161316,
0.13292765617370605,
0.8045468926429749,
0.6611960530281067,
0.011520223692059517,
0.6108152270317078,
-0.8721166849136353,
0.7048701047897339,
-0.04852099344134331,
-1.0813708305358887,
0.7323858141899109,
-0.6038855314254761,
0.6586634516716003,
0.5233450531959534,
0.23124828934669495,
-0.8554112315177917,
-0.1935594081878662,
-0.5870518684387207,
-0.5252626538276672,
0.5852704644203186,
-0.3567436933517456,
0.024562550708651543,
-0.16307590901851654,
0.4796781837940216,
-0.03766268119215965,
0.15910066664218903,
-0.787110447883606,
-0.14206930994987488,
0.09608926624059677,
-0.15600211918354034,
0.2303933948278427,
-0.4376780092716217,
-0.17592410743236542,
-0.2780572175979614,
0.5934285521507263,
-0.5074958801269531,
0.24378198385238647,
0.15919551253318787,
-0.005668759811669588,
-0.35491982102394104,
0.4573131501674652,
1.036234974861145,
0.9401631951332092,
-0.02090536057949066,
0.2774867117404938,
0.6356595158576965,
-0.1898147314786911,
0.12154484540224075,
-0.3650175929069519,
-0.0992865040898323,
-0.10630477219820023,
0.5954954624176025,
0.4465126097202301,
0.08245697617530823,
-0.8280957341194153,
0.3326667845249176,
0.15491876006126404,
-0.3306482136249542,
0.08321673423051834,
0.13098439574241638,
0.3297230005264282,
0.3939588665962219,
0.44883009791374207,
-0.042055606842041016,
0.05782067030668259,
-0.634160578250885,
0.04746934771537781,
0.7866581678390503,
-0.11880234628915787,
-0.22597645223140717,
0.5650993585586548,
0.33719488978385925,
-0.44870173931121826,
0.5169121026992798,
-0.18946579098701477,
-0.7832280993461609,
0.22677060961723328,
0.650012731552124,
1.0331746339797974,
-0.5493208765983582,
0.28329744935035706,
0.6093021631240845,
0.5230684876441956,
-0.2108970284461975,
0.3285433053970337,
-0.4215751588344574,
-0.5687312483787537,
-0.8078001141548157,
-0.43368616700172424,
-0.57286536693573,
0.10798467695713043,
-0.34531667828559875,
0.3518366813659668,
-0.496891051530838,
-0.09824776649475098,
-0.41020530462265015,
-0.3075209856033325,
-0.14823968708515167,
0.21731318533420563,
0.5556895732879639,
1.274725079536438,
-1.009785532951355,
0.598686695098877,
0.6358346939086914,
0.004822870716452599,
-0.5751398801803589,
0.18838384747505188,
0.08668685704469681,
-0.7112754583358765,
0.7651331424713135,
0.16072417795658112,
-0.36330705881118774,
-0.21542061865329742,
-0.5595442652702332,
-0.7057558298110962,
1.0379664897918701,
0.4441401958465576,
-0.5030640959739685,
0.013755029998719692,
0.07916770130395889,
0.35387206077575684,
-0.5085898637771606,
0.2752634584903717,
0.3828521966934204,
0.835112452507019,
0.5069940090179443,
-0.9301320910453796,
0.32796329259872437,
0.16038428246974945,
-0.24397537112236023,
0.3124067485332489,
-0.5485981106758118,
0.5826301574707031,
-0.5320248007774353,
-0.2372407615184784,
-0.2742326259613037,
0.6056926250457764,
0.7583321332931519,
0.4189452528953552,
0.8224200010299683,
0.6971783638000488,
0.8598195910453796,
0.07433993369340897,
0.6749916076660156,
-0.15145376324653625,
0.09057948738336563,
1.0023456811904907,
-0.37279212474823,
0.9385855793952942,
0.47940075397491455,
-0.3044425845146179,
0.8428669571876526,
0.7857592701911926,
0.2757018208503723,
0.26796332001686096,
0.04453684389591217,
-0.4053937792778015,
-0.7018850445747375,
0.18805572390556335,
-0.3952609896659851,
0.22621756792068481,
0.5386881232261658,
-0.19941233098506927,
-0.2980789244174957,
0.035426944494247437,
-0.008831358514726162,
-0.05316219851374626,
-0.1045469343662262,
0.6489224433898926,
0.1523999720811844,
-1.057340383529663,
0.6193332672119141,
0.08472814410924911,
0.45000791549682617,
-0.7187055349349976,
-0.05865437164902687,
0.18853619694709778,
0.05060385912656784,
-0.30186107754707336,
-0.7620776891708374,
0.45964252948760986,
-0.06729995459318161,
-0.44148045778274536,
-0.6252400279045105,
0.5801161527633667,
-0.4431074857711792,
-0.22041593492031097,
0.13519541919231415,
0.5950025320053101,
0.0028530217241495848,
-0.2785213887691498,
-1.0494462251663208,
-0.031265996396541595,
0.026205452159047127,
-0.29682299494743347,
0.13875822722911835,
0.7885956168174744,
-0.12950311601161957,
1.1694141626358032,
0.7597609162330627,
-0.007538209203630686,
-0.2816642224788666,
0.1540851891040802,
0.7622819542884827,
-0.7766590714454651,
-0.46712613105773926,
-1.1507724523544312,
0.596963107585907,
0.13562457263469696,
0.007484488654881716,
0.5114752054214478,
0.34986138343811035,
0.29209625720977783,
-0.162479966878891,
0.7445381283760071,
-0.09987780451774597,
0.7347322702407837,
-0.5547067523002625,
0.20365166664123535,
-0.5977171063423157,
0.39087745547294617,
-0.2552275061607361,
-0.9745218753814697,
-0.28148308396339417,
0.5563762187957764,
-0.36326029896736145,
0.2453826367855072,
1.008272409439087,
0.6388593912124634,
-0.1585552841424942,
-0.0687813013792038,
0.2045847773551941,
-0.1595863252878189,
0.38289496302604675,
0.760854184627533,
0.9998529553413391,
0.1850694864988327,
0.6695780158042908,
0.398117333650589,
-0.43163061141967773,
-0.37442561984062195,
-1.19428551197052,
-0.9224346876144409,
-0.4737519323825836,
-0.15671350061893463,
-0.2485983818769455,
-0.1265726536512375,
1.2773951292037964,
0.8824241161346436,
-0.6688596606254578,
-0.18039491772651672,
-0.06541017442941666,
0.4544852375984192,
-0.492738276720047,
-0.27457568049430847,
-0.07066726684570312,
-0.5964382290840149,
-0.5526468753814697,
0.5497119426727295,
0.4084022343158722,
-0.303451806306839,
-0.40768468379974365,
0.017803318798542023,
-0.3901710510253906,
0.2781754732131958,
0.7204440832138062,
0.4385622441768646,
-0.7937227487564087,
-0.2099798023700714,
-0.06093425303697586,
-0.11844169348478317,
-0.14302849769592285,
1.1553285121917725,
-0.8477357029914856,
0.2945128381252289,
0.8255382180213928,
0.5539130568504333,
0.19613565504550934,
-0.03435981646180153,
0.6356458067893982,
-0.5706658363342285,
-0.07102423906326294,
0.2371165156364441,
0.26224347949028015,
0.2591871917247772,
-0.24428917467594147,
0.38057029247283936,
0.41789552569389343,
-0.7023754119873047,
-1.0123172998428345,
0.6762145757675171,
-0.6526607275009155,
-0.4874776303768158,
1.088151454925537,
0.029037147760391235,
0.01152214128524065,
-0.0934596061706543,
-0.25679275393486023,
-0.1038755401968956,
-0.4123796820640564,
0.6629501581192017,
0.8607512712478638,
-0.302791565656662,
-0.5108592510223389,
-0.6277708411216736,
0.49899253249168396,
0.5781043767929077,
-0.9364195466041565,
0.5202140212059021,
0.36944806575775146,
0.38264861702919006,
0.22875377535820007,
0.5497123003005981,
0.0722164735198021,
0.18389278650283813,
-0.17690511047840118,
0.10933659970760345,
-0.19587033987045288,
-0.735597550868988,
-0.26295071840286255,
0.2963469624519348,
-0.031821634620428085,
-0.04050993546843529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11695v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11695v1 | Optimizing Instructions and Demonstrations for Multi-Stage Language Model Programs | 2024-06-17T16:12:03 | 2024-06-17T16:12:03 | Krista Opsahl-Ong, Michael J Ryan, Josh Purtell, David Broman, Christopher Potts, Matei Zaharia, Omar Khattab | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Language Model Programs, i.e. sophisticated pipelines of modular language
model (LM) calls, are increasingly advancing NLP tasks, but they require
crafting prompts that are jointly effective for all modules. We study prompt
optimization for LM programs, i.e. how to update these prompts to maximize a
downstream metric without access to module-level labels or gradients. To make
this tractable, we factorize our problem into optimizing the free-form
instructions and few-shot demonstrations of every module and introduce several
strategies to craft task-grounded instructions and navigate credit assignment
across modules. Our strategies include (i) program- and data-aware techniques
for proposing effective instructions, (ii) a stochastic mini-batch evaluation
function for learning a surrogate model of our objective, and (iii) a
meta-optimization procedure in which we refine how LMs construct proposals over
time. Using these insights we develop MIPRO, a novel optimizer that outperforms
baselines on five of six diverse LM programs using a best-in-class open-source
model (Llama-3-8B), by as high as 12.9% accuracy. We will release our new
optimizers and benchmark in DSPy at https://github.com/stanfordnlp/dspy | [
-0.22843438386917114,
-0.734789252281189,
0.6672330498695374,
0.4476110637187958,
-0.044365569949150085,
0.031223276630043983,
-0.3023969829082489,
0.11858875304460526,
-0.20542845129966736,
0.40288102626800537,
-0.9205958843231201,
-0.7028140425682068,
-0.27331581711769104,
-0.0007431231788359582,
-0.11982674151659012,
0.9878318905830383,
0.08546770364046097,
0.0013453944120556116,
-0.3767229914665222,
-0.03818266838788986,
-0.36993488669395447,
-0.06406299769878387,
-0.7567514777183533,
-0.3264383375644684,
0.6666273474693298,
0.7092118859291077,
0.2865182161331177,
0.6325882077217102,
0.19063539803028107,
0.22267350554466248,
-0.059459805488586426,
0.33978942036628723,
-0.06067108362913132,
0.24635659158229828,
-0.02002621255815029,
-0.3987862765789032,
-0.3184104263782501,
-0.19504275918006897,
0.6100156903266907,
0.647774875164032,
-0.19286344945430756,
0.3738859295845032,
0.0830974280834198,
0.595811665058136,
-0.7844228744506836,
0.36565908789634705,
-0.407123863697052,
-0.13542287051677704,
-0.012421339750289917,
-0.4041875898838043,
-0.717507541179657,
-0.4759562611579895,
-0.06539211422204971,
-0.42720314860343933,
-0.02128707244992256,
-0.06229011341929436,
0.3876658082008362,
0.1050199344754219,
-0.13005734980106354,
-0.2882539629936218,
-0.565161943435669,
0.9497805833816528,
-0.9266065955162048,
-0.13432106375694275,
0.11258403211832047,
0.33319351077079773,
-0.40819382667541504,
-0.5739734172821045,
-0.09443122893571854,
-0.70946204662323,
0.14563238620758057,
0.04451313242316246,
-0.27280524373054504,
0.39229270815849304,
0.45014864206314087,
0.03819610923528671,
-0.5318426489830017,
0.3725298345088959,
-0.3266431391239166,
-0.14743630588054657,
0.4172028601169586,
0.2550135552883148,
0.2974286675453186,
-0.10431910306215286,
-0.3234240710735321,
-0.06054201349616051,
-0.6104282736778259,
0.1932116150856018,
0.573860228061676,
0.5755947232246399,
0.07201429456472397,
0.6624211072921753,
-0.42125770449638367,
0.7546887397766113,
-0.0835392102599144,
-0.03946487978100777,
0.014511555433273315,
-0.22024589776992798,
0.044016771018505096,
-0.22019904851913452,
0.7037835717201233,
0.2967764735221863,
-0.06240511313080788,
0.19001658260822296,
-0.4969272017478943,
-0.09762857109308243,
0.2618350088596344,
-0.6250748038291931,
-0.01707228645682335,
0.37299418449401855,
-0.405722439289093,
-0.25992855429649353,
-0.24508251249790192,
-0.5998135209083557,
-0.1335807889699936,
-0.5248492956161499,
0.8322437405586243,
-0.3365226089954376,
0.054100893437862396,
0.1332552134990692,
-0.07473504543304443,
0.11948413401842117,
0.27299994230270386,
-0.9707950949668884,
0.3173408806324005,
0.8310045599937439,
0.8314025402069092,
-0.0299120731651783,
-0.25384223461151123,
-1.0126488208770752,
-0.04286343976855278,
-0.3786206543445587,
0.5755006074905396,
-0.4607625901699066,
-0.28892067074775696,
0.044301874935626984,
-0.17532353103160858,
-0.3507820665836334,
-0.3456730842590332,
0.5549747347831726,
-0.1297277808189392,
0.26981693506240845,
0.03303901478648186,
-0.521411657333374,
-0.0012937324354425073,
-0.08640605211257935,
-0.5865925550460815,
0.9893109798431396,
0.09647631645202637,
-0.5408223271369934,
-0.08796992897987366,
-1.0784732103347778,
-0.08825787156820297,
-0.06377571821212769,
-0.03887868672609329,
-0.13027779757976532,
0.4213598370552063,
0.36574405431747437,
0.5013741850852966,
-0.02753090113401413,
0.18310590088367462,
-0.028878044337034225,
-0.5151384472846985,
-0.004279233515262604,
-0.2988348603248596,
0.7181340456008911,
0.1191471740603447,
-0.4168075919151306,
0.5498086810112,
-0.6898190975189209,
-0.013628543354570866,
-0.0538138709962368,
-0.44336727261543274,
-0.12494238466024399,
0.08949518203735352,
-0.2959372401237488,
0.02682807855308056,
0.08218260109424591,
-0.25533822178840637,
0.563290536403656,
-0.3362998068332672,
0.4469480812549591,
0.8347922563552856,
-0.24957941472530365,
0.4703501760959625,
-0.30776914954185486,
0.8388442993164062,
-0.20033587515354156,
0.47638139128685,
-0.7542575001716614,
-0.5931315422058105,
-0.9118794202804565,
-0.19360660016536713,
-0.05414056405425072,
0.4715343713760376,
-0.5938631892204285,
0.15524819493293762,
0.14833597838878632,
-0.42843082547187805,
-0.6210131645202637,
0.024670010432600975,
0.25799259543418884,
0.5244427919387817,
0.4743446111679077,
-0.04808099940419197,
-0.26513293385505676,
-1.2163302898406982,
-0.2377225160598755,
-0.08041839301586151,
0.08794151246547699,
0.016150565817952156,
0.3213854134082794,
-0.06125586852431297,
0.674313485622406,
-0.38957351446151733,
0.21915291249752045,
-0.6429190039634705,
0.47331517934799194,
0.6565849781036377,
0.49304866790771484,
0.4057897627353668,
-0.14513865113258362,
-0.3587336540222168,
-0.196239173412323,
-0.09384064376354218,
-0.6355743408203125,
-0.4376544654369354,
-0.06735222786664963,
0.27104616165161133,
0.3971359133720398,
-0.6929876208305359,
0.06653948128223419,
0.5188116431236267,
0.07152362167835236,
0.8934822678565979,
-0.4366522431373596,
-0.0422365665435791,
-0.8039045929908752,
0.04127618297934532,
-0.0756516307592392,
-0.15470236539840698,
-0.672431468963623,
0.25013265013694763,
0.15953174233436584,
-0.224889874458313,
-0.46738865971565247,
0.48480671644210815,
-0.5247622728347778,
0.055267103016376495,
-0.41340795159339905,
0.1645945906639099,
0.010398578830063343,
0.6858665943145752,
-0.09789419174194336,
0.7391873002052307,
0.7705519199371338,
-0.5360713005065918,
0.165476456284523,
-0.19476231932640076,
-0.4616680145263672,
0.2460654228925705,
-0.5838565230369568,
0.2904547452926636,
-0.2987613081932068,
0.1958550065755844,
-0.8881210684776306,
0.13597920536994934,
0.35025909543037415,
-0.12435289472341537,
0.35740745067596436,
-0.19776614010334015,
-0.14368857443332672,
-0.23181870579719543,
-0.6494154334068298,
0.1269174963235855,
0.37854036688804626,
-0.44485220313072205,
0.5212044715881348,
-0.1301027238368988,
-0.27585098147392273,
-0.8676382899284363,
-0.32764333486557007,
-0.013390575535595417,
-0.24655258655548096,
-0.29584676027297974,
0.27912044525146484,
-0.25134512782096863,
-0.09518298506736755,
-0.2604653239250183,
-0.16939084231853485,
0.1702384203672409,
0.14018194377422333,
0.06350229680538177,
0.23122313618659973,
-0.29541507363319397,
0.019831771031022072,
0.2961852252483368,
-0.4386231303215027,
0.1386403888463974,
-0.51655513048172,
0.5989093780517578,
-0.022357163950800896,
-0.594092845916748,
-0.7498218417167664,
0.5956110954284668,
0.4190581738948822,
0.020689144730567932,
0.5596147179603577,
0.6038040518760681,
-0.15059401094913483,
-0.517874002456665,
-0.3640477955341339,
-0.19399210810661316,
-0.47162944078445435,
0.39175334572792053,
-0.39958691596984863,
-0.6453335285186768,
0.13650116324424744,
-0.13887667655944824,
0.47206342220306396,
0.16387955844402313,
0.4595959782600403,
0.15192373096942902,
1.155595064163208,
0.5810762643814087,
0.10257541388273239,
0.599997341632843,
-0.2090398669242859,
0.10981573909521103,
-0.754538893699646,
-0.18332280218601227,
-0.7796594500541687,
-0.2131163477897644,
-0.20745694637298584,
-0.8073284029960632,
0.29183530807495117,
0.37764179706573486,
-0.018096277490258217,
0.5955966114997864,
-0.20949801802635193,
0.6251818537712097,
1.0238063335418701,
-0.038408491760492325,
0.03877038136124611,
-0.11244390904903412,
-0.365010529756546,
-0.1560206264257431,
-0.944862425327301,
-0.7670074701309204,
0.852541983127594,
0.4105720520019531,
0.7105690836906433,
-0.2113504409790039,
0.7998784780502319,
0.2720943093299866,
0.09725020080804825,
-0.7492516040802002,
0.608818769454956,
-0.1433095484972,
-0.16962595283985138,
-0.11387098580598831,
-0.3924965262413025,
-0.5049847364425659,
0.10432978719472885,
-0.01693161576986313,
-0.8819606304168701,
-0.20677146315574646,
0.2973536252975464,
-0.4096730649471283,
0.08261688798666,
-0.5693738460540771,
1.0825351476669312,
-0.15911751985549927,
-0.2640114426612854,
-0.4822201430797577,
-0.6771487593650818,
0.20947040617465973,
0.10400823503732681,
0.1874523013830185,
-0.22427307069301605,
-0.09123936295509338,
0.31714972853660583,
-0.33411574363708496,
0.7148007154464722,
-0.3901624083518982,
-0.23974953591823578,
0.21499910950660706,
-0.02253030613064766,
0.49260208010673523,
-0.22304153442382812,
-0.1462639570236206,
-0.23462817072868347,
-0.01593751646578312,
-0.2942998707294464,
-0.6620960235595703,
0.5339147448539734,
-0.3656305968761444,
-0.6553968787193298,
0.1340085119009018,
-0.5459094047546387,
-0.03932071477174759,
-0.1749963015317917,
-0.0906321331858635,
0.8346166610717773,
-0.008741977624595165,
0.08047859370708466,
0.46563521027565,
-0.8046892285346985,
0.7260066866874695,
0.18343813717365265,
-0.19345179200172424,
-0.2266729176044464,
0.8957882523536682,
-0.284250944852829,
0.6467833518981934,
0.609313428401947,
0.538784384727478,
-0.28632789850234985,
-0.6986762285232544,
-0.5953081846237183,
0.13889770209789276,
-0.9003066420555115,
-0.09656155854463577,
-0.5539687871932983,
0.03609960526227951,
-0.28501051664352417,
-0.02583024837076664,
-0.28150612115859985,
-0.8774276971817017,
-0.1440478414297104,
-0.07716307789087296,
0.03294610232114792,
0.4740261137485504,
-0.22256816923618317,
0.5353803634643555,
-0.8126447200775146,
0.05211532860994339,
0.2353089451789856,
-0.10967278480529785,
-0.03048611618578434,
-0.36707189679145813,
-0.30034592747688293,
-0.03732830286026001,
-0.32829368114471436,
-0.8058093786239624,
0.19671835005283356,
0.3262438476085663,
0.847398042678833,
0.4134749174118042,
0.016416246071457863,
0.5671752691268921,
-0.5089966058731079,
0.8049524426460266,
0.06485266983509064,
-1.1481802463531494,
0.9474930167198181,
-0.4480615556240082,
0.39664962887763977,
0.37450382113456726,
0.28483933210372925,
-0.5568585395812988,
-0.6797686219215393,
-0.2932366132736206,
-0.8985595703125,
0.9876620769500732,
0.015582551248371601,
0.4772566556930542,
-0.06417542695999146,
0.3095639646053314,
0.2845199406147003,
0.2708624005317688,
-0.539366602897644,
-0.18826614320278168,
0.19110043346881866,
-0.3246753215789795,
0.15481850504875183,
-0.31471624970436096,
-0.2041725218296051,
-0.027892963960766792,
0.6741910576820374,
-0.4590761959552765,
0.06740062683820724,
-0.12811024487018585,
-0.08295249938964844,
0.19734953343868256,
0.45227891206741333,
1.098326563835144,
0.8325079083442688,
-0.0550316646695137,
-0.026644684374332428,
0.030239729210734367,
-0.23415032029151917,
-0.046175044029951096,
-0.03731957823038101,
-0.3287394046783447,
0.16026973724365234,
0.46350419521331787,
1.0644242763519287,
0.2024591863155365,
-0.6646596193313599,
0.4679025113582611,
0.10629510134458542,
-0.11328554153442383,
0.1054353341460228,
0.3238029181957245,
0.16336195170879364,
0.533839225769043,
0.3661551773548126,
-0.058402277529239655,
0.11235135793685913,
-0.3660312294960022,
0.09335881471633911,
0.2816076874732971,
-0.11088675260543823,
-0.29110825061798096,
0.6749670505523682,
0.14513660967350006,
-0.5302090048789978,
0.4130486845970154,
-0.013243786990642548,
-0.4026755094528198,
0.5736254453659058,
0.5605380535125732,
0.972224771976471,
-0.25240474939346313,
0.6582475304603577,
0.46974092721939087,
0.2835836112499237,
-0.2621527910232544,
0.17398230731487274,
-0.2924686372280121,
-0.38320350646972656,
-0.6678204536437988,
-0.6134456992149353,
-0.5974180102348328,
-0.07334384322166443,
-0.6049079895019531,
0.5535294413566589,
-0.4269791841506958,
-0.0777437835931778,
-0.29091498255729675,
0.007528416812419891,
-0.2840738594532013,
-0.1518690437078476,
0.27414554357528687,
1.0944340229034424,
-0.7978381514549255,
0.6778841018676758,
0.4543516933917999,
-0.25452500581741333,
-0.7190338373184204,
-0.30689048767089844,
0.04845786467194557,
-0.7243521213531494,
0.5347771644592285,
0.5621224045753479,
-0.18570983409881592,
0.08683135360479355,
-0.49715059995651245,
-0.32994356751441956,
0.8227775692939758,
0.6020621061325073,
-0.7117321491241455,
-0.11663924902677536,
-0.06803219765424728,
0.11984340101480484,
-0.5664049386978149,
0.4947955906391144,
0.35300806164741516,
0.413551926612854,
-0.10473563522100449,
-0.6655498147010803,
-0.10801203548908234,
-0.05871632695198059,
0.015068395994603634,
0.05012693628668785,
-0.38529905676841736,
0.654559850692749,
-0.4181501865386963,
-0.14174635708332062,
0.3094296455383301,
0.5858062505722046,
0.5601547360420227,
0.22104573249816895,
0.6350423097610474,
0.3105977177619934,
0.5506615042686462,
-0.032210759818553925,
0.8875331282615662,
-0.22991685569286346,
0.17571210861206055,
1.115923285484314,
0.015350026078522205,
0.733683168888092,
0.710411548614502,
-0.01668006181716919,
0.5615672469139099,
0.7291373610496521,
0.10272153466939926,
0.5593886971473694,
0.5723179578781128,
-0.4447556138038635,
-0.18441511690616608,
-0.17349423468112946,
0.05162965878844261,
0.1368212252855301,
0.2931884229183197,
-0.2615702450275421,
-0.290791779756546,
0.024764301255345345,
-0.022513750940561295,
-0.03508865833282471,
-0.1712370216846466,
0.4849036931991577,
0.03559374436736107,
-0.658134400844574,
0.2749464511871338,
0.18872636556625366,
0.5010415315628052,
-0.8374570608139038,
-0.03780562803149223,
-0.46000176668167114,
0.05057337135076523,
-0.07877502590417862,
-0.27929505705833435,
0.2318705916404724,
0.050799839198589325,
0.04662330076098442,
-0.48219984769821167,
0.46034204959869385,
-0.5186991095542908,
-0.2637706995010376,
0.25421142578125,
0.46136748790740967,
0.31610387563705444,
0.08489841967821121,
-0.7840318083763123,
0.06872629374265671,
-0.14666546881198883,
-0.4429935812950134,
0.07222487032413483,
0.1964041143655777,
-0.07743217796087265,
0.8816901445388794,
0.5117934942245483,
0.2686656415462494,
0.21855531632900238,
0.6680474281311035,
0.7391090393066406,
-0.4927866458892822,
-0.08685435354709625,
-0.947989821434021,
0.8135396838188171,
0.06346047669649124,
-0.16387777030467987,
0.4825408458709717,
0.4677291810512543,
0.7029844522476196,
-0.2622304856777191,
0.4396999776363373,
0.14918722212314606,
0.12160185724496841,
-0.8655032515525818,
0.1648813635110855,
-0.5335561037063599,
0.3997836709022522,
-0.3303402364253998,
-1.2597020864486694,
-0.2889101207256317,
0.5603487491607666,
0.0899885892868042,
-0.09131874144077301,
0.7025315165519714,
1.0636345148086548,
-0.010229537263512611,
-0.01337543036788702,
0.13377445936203003,
-0.32924509048461914,
0.2949751615524292,
0.7754508256912231,
1.1787750720977783,
-0.1162816509604454,
0.44025740027427673,
-0.32914087176322937,
-0.33217495679855347,
-0.08825991302728653,
-1.1509987115859985,
-0.7419663667678833,
-0.34941044449806213,
-0.6042877435684204,
0.12696821987628937,
0.0946987122297287,
1.2654297351837158,
0.7163681983947754,
-0.6311349868774414,
-0.5704135298728943,
-0.0031722348649054766,
0.14122600853443146,
-0.541464626789093,
-0.1924823820590973,
0.24944621324539185,
-0.9139142036437988,
-0.9577223062515259,
0.9378576874732971,
0.48327288031578064,
-0.13177582621574402,
-0.3755163252353668,
-0.04253095015883446,
-0.14924532175064087,
0.10430437326431274,
0.5332515835762024,
0.003417776431888342,
-0.6051228046417236,
-0.28033676743507385,
0.16172757744789124,
-0.08526186645030975,
-0.019511887803673744,
1.1181851625442505,
-0.3608402907848358,
0.3481854796409607,
0.5783299207687378,
0.7014164924621582,
0.24125461280345917,
0.14797362685203552,
0.8691524863243103,
-0.87663334608078,
-0.03753676638007164,
0.10177477449178696,
0.201820969581604,
0.34855329990386963,
0.04181136190891266,
0.3298444449901581,
-0.05545691028237343,
-0.5233372449874878,
-0.8302071690559387,
0.23263154923915863,
-0.8646551966667175,
-0.36480987071990967,
1.0223942995071411,
-0.3049173951148987,
-0.14973747730255127,
0.13234873116016388,
-0.3674890697002411,
0.13203860819339752,
-0.4064160883426666,
0.5444616675376892,
0.6709995269775391,
-0.401732861995697,
-0.4176383316516876,
-0.9487890005111694,
0.4848373830318451,
0.440846711397171,
-0.6525776386260986,
0.26769089698791504,
0.6190834641456604,
0.037123218178749084,
0.013774676248431206,
0.6945933103561401,
0.11233127117156982,
0.0020700569730252028,
-0.11544813215732574,
-0.06807547062635422,
-0.195393905043602,
-0.6661914587020874,
-0.5910537242889404,
0.1171911209821701,
0.15051011741161346,
-0.4492758512496948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11687v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11687v1 | Tokenization Falling Short: The Curse of Tokenization | 2024-06-17T16:05:32 | 2024-06-17T16:05:32 | Yekun Chai, Yewei Fang, Qiwei Peng, Xuhong Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models typically tokenize raw text into sequences of subword
identifiers from a predefined vocabulary, a process inherently sensitive to
typographical errors, length variations, and largely oblivious to the internal
structure of tokens-issues we term the curse of tokenization. In this study, we
delve into these drawbacks and demonstrate that large language models (LLMs)
remain susceptible to these problems. This study systematically investigates
these challenges and their impact on LLMs through three critical research
questions: (1) complex problem solving, (2) token structure probing, and (3)
resilience to typographical variation. Our findings reveal that scaling model
parameters can mitigate the issue of tokenization; however, LLMs still suffer
from biases induced by typos and other text format variations. Our experiments
show that subword regularization such as BPE-dropout can mitigate this issue.
We will release our code and data to facilitate further research. | [
-0.12150547653436661,
-0.8028683662414551,
0.5615838766098022,
0.07936882227659225,
-0.4417787194252014,
0.261783242225647,
-0.14690786600112915,
-0.5108290910720825,
0.12788137793540955,
0.5038546323776245,
-0.34352973103523254,
-0.0051757837645709515,
-0.9294212460517883,
0.2196783721446991,
-0.337248831987381,
1.266347885131836,
-0.1093468964099884,
0.10560522228479385,
-0.31552398204803467,
-0.06872957199811935,
-0.8073377013206482,
-0.8688053488731384,
-0.7125303745269775,
-0.1635241061449051,
0.5152571797370911,
0.3439384996891022,
0.7150916457176208,
0.6791296005249023,
0.9124865531921387,
0.1552673578262329,
-0.36712267994880676,
-0.12280404567718506,
-0.6150837540626526,
0.048104748129844666,
-0.10487981140613556,
-0.8215674757957458,
-0.18921931087970734,
0.009245728142559528,
0.8261396884918213,
1.0201013088226318,
0.1935601681470871,
0.2985197901725769,
-0.10361417382955551,
0.614232063293457,
-0.4499657154083252,
-0.05927552282810211,
-0.7653601765632629,
-0.09269034117460251,
-0.6759036183357239,
0.0553605854511261,
-0.4698971211910248,
-0.07288151979446411,
0.04324926808476448,
-0.19945184886455536,
0.2895047962665558,
0.35382455587387085,
0.9230586290359497,
0.3571622371673584,
-0.31154707074165344,
-0.435798317193985,
-0.6749462485313416,
0.8141056895256042,
-0.7975720167160034,
0.23569601774215698,
0.36813968420028687,
-0.054115235805511475,
-0.15181829035282135,
-0.6815629601478577,
-0.349368691444397,
-0.3699444532394409,
0.173758402466774,
-0.2680981159210205,
-0.04343966394662857,
0.08489128947257996,
0.23765675723552704,
0.4833555519580841,
-0.20003154873847961,
0.36788180470466614,
-0.5959376096725464,
-0.3147437572479248,
0.08712469786405563,
0.3701098561286926,
0.6052006483078003,
-0.44755905866622925,
-0.20639139413833618,
0.1852218210697174,
-0.8279404640197754,
-0.04998301714658737,
0.48112839460372925,
0.5415950417518616,
0.1573658287525177,
0.6988754868507385,
0.5941805243492126,
0.3300187885761261,
-0.15183477103710175,
-0.023160984739661217,
-0.1449447125196457,
-0.3390432894229889,
-0.18263503909111023,
-0.19959458708763123,
0.4230386018753052,
0.21666806936264038,
0.3656482994556427,
-0.2299094945192337,
-0.256590873003006,
-0.1638563871383667,
0.17374959588050842,
-0.6355763673782349,
0.030714165419340134,
0.26897040009498596,
-0.6178205013275146,
-0.217651829123497,
-0.02307712845504284,
-0.4930073022842407,
-0.5369372367858887,
-0.006788048893213272,
0.250787615776062,
-0.41987282037734985,
-0.08787419646978378,
0.05246417969465256,
-0.3980078101158142,
-0.10792191326618195,
0.12092547118663788,
-0.9724997878074646,
0.3373431861400604,
0.7210329174995422,
1.0448122024536133,
-0.34698471426963806,
-0.1799747347831726,
-0.3621981143951416,
0.07592152804136276,
-0.39146116375923157,
0.37311530113220215,
-0.5965766906738281,
-0.6534806489944458,
-0.1604021191596985,
0.00902410876005888,
-0.1756604164838791,
-0.6922895908355713,
0.5926945209503174,
-0.281757652759552,
-0.000055155665904749185,
-0.2768288254737854,
-0.7247507572174072,
0.22092726826667786,
0.10938756912946701,
-0.6899794936180115,
0.783600926399231,
0.08610886335372925,
-1.0155737400054932,
0.28951093554496765,
-0.36164867877960205,
-0.3439646363258362,
0.08118154108524323,
-0.12948265671730042,
-0.39097434282302856,
0.860367476940155,
-0.1084451749920845,
0.17591193318367004,
-0.43807828426361084,
0.06284397095441818,
-0.14162346720695496,
-0.4694329798221588,
0.24992406368255615,
-0.47641828656196594,
0.4250190258026123,
-0.06007423996925354,
-0.15952368080615997,
-0.12414785474538803,
-0.7651455998420715,
-0.14941264688968658,
0.4187471568584442,
-0.508621335029602,
-0.6030648350715637,
-0.005244608968496323,
0.3765496611595154,
0.03783457726240158,
0.291065514087677,
-0.4441751539707184,
0.33709973096847534,
-0.4380398392677307,
0.6600449681282043,
0.8902663588523865,
-0.10733526945114136,
0.35162612795829773,
-0.24882419407367706,
0.6809497475624084,
0.24720151722431183,
0.40871015191078186,
-0.04497658088803291,
-0.4207287132740021,
-0.7768364548683167,
-0.1191369816660881,
0.6413449645042419,
0.37936294078826904,
-0.5721784234046936,
-0.0477636381983757,
-0.37519371509552,
-0.2508602738380432,
-0.2782716155052185,
-0.12733764946460724,
0.5046743154525757,
0.27358317375183105,
0.0577460415661335,
-0.4674166440963745,
-0.47068262100219727,
-0.9469213485717773,
-0.4152204394340515,
-0.24069812893867493,
0.056552037596702576,
0.2041129767894745,
0.7512377500534058,
-0.14689084887504578,
1.0804297924041748,
-0.36481815576553345,
-0.3823589086532593,
-0.3003825545310974,
0.13459935784339905,
0.038028109818696976,
0.6164919137954712,
0.5998059511184692,
-0.6181769967079163,
-0.13857682049274445,
-0.29594120383262634,
-0.08021317422389984,
-0.14928755164146423,
0.012635144405066967,
0.43742531538009644,
0.48918017745018005,
0.5850514769554138,
-0.6001396775245667,
0.4847029149532318,
0.5685614347457886,
-0.43507733941078186,
0.9044415950775146,
-0.04678817838430405,
-0.32159557938575745,
-1.1253806352615356,
0.17128166556358337,
-0.3730829358100891,
0.018444158136844635,
-0.5893321633338928,
-0.04217582195997238,
-0.054937947541475296,
-0.07709328085184097,
-0.21705764532089233,
0.5461007952690125,
-0.4576432704925537,
-0.08626998215913773,
-0.23999649286270142,
-0.1654512584209442,
0.04237641766667366,
0.03508460521697998,
-0.22024564445018768,
0.85933518409729,
0.2482985407114029,
-0.36546772718429565,
-0.00733971269801259,
-0.09403207153081894,
-0.17147310078144073,
0.20817430317401886,
-0.7788435220718384,
0.13122519850730896,
-0.2983250617980957,
0.20569726824760437,
-0.948745846748352,
-0.24241787195205688,
-0.02559424564242363,
-0.41050800681114197,
0.48046696186065674,
-0.34397292137145996,
-0.7541768550872803,
-0.4900070130825043,
-0.3244028389453888,
0.6859605312347412,
0.26462966203689575,
-0.24665158987045288,
0.2960246205329895,
0.22635488212108612,
-0.08858178555965424,
-0.5298142433166504,
-0.8657549023628235,
0.3957050144672394,
-0.3076252341270447,
-0.4951239228248596,
0.16921138763427734,
-0.1888325959444046,
-0.4011421799659729,
-0.04991130903363228,
-0.19755345582962036,
0.1384049952030182,
0.13982655107975006,
0.22904953360557556,
0.2040860950946808,
-0.12929850816726685,
0.39686301350593567,
-0.24171888828277588,
0.08665675669908524,
0.0973660871386528,
-0.36603212356567383,
0.7719394564628601,
-0.1176312044262886,
-0.3130471110343933,
-0.25637876987457275,
0.35228827595710754,
0.8440926671028137,
-0.06385211646556854,
0.9604150056838989,
0.25547581911087036,
-0.47272107005119324,
-0.1316460818052292,
-0.7033002376556396,
-0.06799929589033127,
-0.44180530309677124,
0.5178342461585999,
-0.42475682497024536,
-0.9788557887077332,
0.8512691855430603,
0.05111170560121536,
-0.08062373101711273,
0.39761093258857727,
0.3467697203159332,
0.1632162481546402,
0.7728504538536072,
0.925462543964386,
-0.0645681768655777,
0.5314458608627319,
-0.00428170058876276,
0.5319337248802185,
-0.7553570866584778,
-0.09129540622234344,
-0.4697909951210022,
-0.1053178459405899,
-0.5908148288726807,
-0.49562421441078186,
0.26443400979042053,
0.23121997714042664,
0.18907491862773895,
0.057886961847543716,
-0.2767079174518585,
0.6088446378707886,
0.43630361557006836,
-0.3169378638267517,
0.20286522805690765,
-0.24875997006893158,
-0.24141733348369598,
-0.4003812074661255,
-0.5563309192657471,
-0.672719419002533,
0.9768958687782288,
0.5670909285545349,
0.6304382681846619,
0.02942086197435856,
0.5555117130279541,
0.3044399619102478,
0.07856316864490509,
-0.7672137022018433,
0.21791815757751465,
-0.253700852394104,
-0.7187689542770386,
-0.3672069013118744,
-0.4920479655265808,
-0.8753232955932617,
0.07379728555679321,
0.010103962384164333,
-0.817348062992096,
0.18650378286838531,
0.07414568960666656,
-0.24940450489521027,
0.5574873685836792,
-0.7559887170791626,
0.8250638842582703,
-0.13747580349445343,
-0.11842042952775955,
0.1778225302696228,
-0.7293509840965271,
0.3431418836116791,
-0.3421685993671417,
0.5183056592941284,
-0.2193603515625,
-0.06645368039608002,
0.8361319303512573,
-0.6953309774398804,
0.9336541295051575,
0.13910338282585144,
-0.29082587361335754,
0.20056509971618652,
0.23935072124004364,
0.6261935234069824,
0.02683316543698311,
0.17044469714164734,
0.037486154586076736,
0.14571768045425415,
-0.7559274435043335,
-0.3859070837497711,
0.4847131371498108,
-0.5575634837150574,
-0.5907180905342102,
-0.26656320691108704,
-0.4906013309955597,
-0.37059032917022705,
0.18834584951400757,
0.6081143021583557,
0.5062140822410583,
-0.12675027549266815,
-0.00824649352580309,
0.5196159482002258,
-0.32501187920570374,
0.6262081861495972,
0.08580601960420609,
-0.30147865414619446,
-0.3666718602180481,
0.9307280778884888,
0.4921313226222992,
0.5576834678649902,
0.03120100311934948,
0.30319657921791077,
-0.08416805416345596,
-0.9325513243675232,
-0.10078869760036469,
0.40633144974708557,
-0.76374351978302,
-0.023045433685183525,
-0.31357041001319885,
-0.12170319259166718,
-0.5842921137809753,
0.031639907509088516,
-0.4757779538631439,
-0.5557606220245361,
-0.6415051221847534,
-0.1520315706729889,
0.11227346211671829,
1.0167438983917236,
0.04344553500413895,
0.23012641072273254,
-0.7824177145957947,
-0.034711603075265884,
0.13128335773944855,
0.47135722637176514,
0.14043262600898743,
-0.8145936727523804,
-0.28258371353149414,
-0.40685901045799255,
0.006011778488755226,
-0.5355769395828247,
0.11438524723052979,
0.05814944580197334,
0.07351221889257431,
0.37965795397758484,
-0.1299765557050705,
0.5461134910583496,
-0.7633565068244934,
1.0132813453674316,
0.3302093744277954,
-1.071608304977417,
0.3409002721309662,
-0.42283523082733154,
0.2980120778083801,
0.46646878123283386,
0.04071224480867386,
-0.8358719348907471,
-0.506233811378479,
-0.49672630429267883,
-1.100467324256897,
0.43491244316101074,
0.22849203646183014,
0.5062772631645203,
-0.3847973048686981,
0.730140209197998,
0.266523152589798,
0.10555725544691086,
-0.6868833899497986,
-0.25316372513771057,
-0.03813067823648453,
-0.03151978552341461,
0.03352423757314682,
-0.78739333152771,
0.10848132520914078,
-0.01578945852816105,
0.40319934487342834,
-0.09670527279376984,
-0.19814318418502808,
0.012197678908705711,
-0.17973865568637848,
-0.05023660883307457,
0.2850923538208008,
0.829292893409729,
0.7377017140388489,
0.05308734253048897,
0.19394031167030334,
0.03741300851106644,
-0.6476917862892151,
-0.08806367218494415,
-0.24092251062393188,
-0.12521857023239136,
0.11022906750440598,
0.5366026759147644,
0.8731106519699097,
0.15683674812316895,
-0.8766694068908691,
0.5439099073410034,
-0.0737244039773941,
0.021227559074759483,
-0.2668529152870178,
-0.41203224658966064,
0.09014382213354111,
-0.10394039005041122,
0.5817384719848633,
-0.05259857699275017,
-0.044407304376363754,
-0.6192062497138977,
-0.10392452031373978,
0.46340641379356384,
-0.3105415105819702,
-0.3870328962802887,
0.6628631949424744,
0.10723435878753662,
-0.3979625701904297,
0.6301877498626709,
0.18784381449222565,
-0.5342850685119629,
0.8737075328826904,
0.6918432712554932,
0.7506173253059387,
0.15437500178813934,
-0.0288628451526165,
-0.16652807593345642,
0.7081462740898132,
-0.12904614210128784,
-0.012077543884515762,
0.4712669551372528,
-0.5073156356811523,
-0.39262083172798157,
-0.8133388757705688,
-0.45378708839416504,
0.25498396158218384,
-0.49248018860816956,
0.06980976462364197,
-0.6654319763183594,
-0.5518463253974915,
-0.2561562955379486,
-0.098553366959095,
-0.3875746726989746,
0.1236969381570816,
0.23770008981227875,
0.8089922666549683,
-0.7488119602203369,
0.45056772232055664,
0.41915395855903625,
-0.6050360202789307,
-0.5848471522331238,
0.18322789669036865,
-0.1972922533750534,
-0.6963807344436646,
0.7527837753295898,
0.16817979514598846,
0.17471739649772644,
-0.04512510076165199,
-0.6774505972862244,
-1.0941492319107056,
0.5803916454315186,
0.4665607810020447,
-0.5906988978385925,
-0.2373190075159073,
0.44263651967048645,
0.6044099926948547,
-0.05096442624926567,
-0.19047868251800537,
0.7590391635894775,
0.5399361848831177,
-0.12540560960769653,
-1.241834044456482,
0.1743202805519104,
0.05036424100399017,
0.412778377532959,
0.3742188513278961,
-0.8639492988586426,
0.9901928305625916,
-0.33064043521881104,
-0.20788481831550598,
0.1954502910375595,
0.33655065298080444,
-0.029786366969347,
0.04654544219374657,
0.22503766417503357,
0.7661210298538208,
0.6070016026496887,
-0.04988483712077141,
1.0262807607650757,
-0.17097343504428864,
0.3517613708972931,
0.890069305896759,
-0.14548806846141815,
0.6439267992973328,
0.9335306882858276,
-0.1604030579328537,
0.14368030428886414,
0.7553231716156006,
-0.03214302286505699,
0.1360022872686386,
0.7128900289535522,
-0.11687180399894714,
-0.01561138965189457,
-0.2762736976146698,
-0.1757178008556366,
0.36847802996635437,
0.4128025472164154,
-0.32103031873703003,
-0.01751214824616909,
0.2364901900291443,
0.1675012856721878,
0.013129374012351036,
-0.4228949546813965,
0.46966761350631714,
0.3444046080112457,
-0.27228865027427673,
0.39695173501968384,
0.1382698118686676,
0.8350598812103271,
-0.3958115875720978,
0.2737770080566406,
-0.518094539642334,
0.07292547821998596,
-0.045378491282463074,
-0.20269028842449188,
0.37593308091163635,
-0.1093653216958046,
-0.4505937099456787,
0.038369130343198776,
0.5053444504737854,
-0.1477266401052475,
-0.5726027488708496,
0.1782437115907669,
0.48191797733306885,
0.22175268828868866,
0.058295104652643204,
-0.3415136933326721,
0.45252615213394165,
-0.48206791281700134,
-0.24587076902389526,
0.4783189296722412,
0.5073912143707275,
-0.3275758922100067,
0.7044617533683777,
0.4870835840702057,
0.23971782624721527,
0.4769422113895416,
0.34967321157455444,
0.659205973148346,
-0.7171355485916138,
-0.23427656292915344,
-1.1307580471038818,
0.10167000442743301,
0.07644537836313248,
-0.48263341188430786,
0.7074750661849976,
0.516353189945221,
0.6020742654800415,
-0.17864593863487244,
0.6837047934532166,
0.026510750874876976,
0.3973631262779236,
-0.3910299837589264,
0.8185977339744568,
-0.5793138742446899,
0.2910941541194916,
-0.21508172154426575,
-0.7202742695808411,
-0.5792133808135986,
-0.13494804501533508,
-0.2224738597869873,
0.07919333875179291,
0.9119638204574585,
0.39328262209892273,
0.2528952956199646,
-0.5459088683128357,
0.37196633219718933,
0.159976527094841,
0.33357739448547363,
0.26287350058555603,
0.701709508895874,
-0.3284832835197449,
0.7789713144302368,
0.14814764261245728,
0.15436291694641113,
-0.37925752997398376,
-0.7570116519927979,
-0.9673181176185608,
-0.5145969986915588,
-0.20724451541900635,
-0.3743782341480255,
0.20140136778354645,
0.6838308572769165,
0.4066466987133026,
-0.7188267707824707,
-0.014735442586243153,
-0.29738980531692505,
0.29797670245170593,
0.22092343866825104,
-0.3072049617767334,
0.4753147065639496,
-0.5926650166511536,
-0.8145225644111633,
-0.012954911217093468,
0.3746151924133301,
0.487954705953598,
-0.353855162858963,
0.3563000559806824,
0.1521419882774353,
0.5412772297859192,
0.38315343856811523,
0.24514572322368622,
-0.9173080325126648,
-0.5752942562103271,
-0.26489710807800293,
-0.2822912931442261,
0.020983057096600533,
1.0946214199066162,
-0.30662187933921814,
0.1876344531774521,
0.3917267620563507,
0.7342203855514526,
-0.030710630118846893,
-0.11350077390670776,
0.5576063394546509,
-0.9582716822624207,
0.032651834189891815,
0.3075425624847412,
0.41758763790130615,
0.4395138621330261,
-0.3680494725704193,
0.31580936908721924,
0.616884171962738,
-0.39755651354789734,
-1.1986470222473145,
0.41474661231040955,
-0.5741991996765137,
-0.6354467272758484,
0.9863998293876648,
0.11034563183784485,
-0.327567994594574,
-0.09115170687437057,
-0.19193178415298462,
0.0658888965845108,
-0.0009104612399823964,
0.8962675333023071,
1.2216838598251343,
0.22849294543266296,
-0.20289671421051025,
-0.3499944806098938,
0.6215124130249023,
0.6571596264839172,
-0.4138830602169037,
0.30714020133018494,
0.4241216480731964,
0.48820456862449646,
0.22715748846530914,
0.7378155589103699,
-0.15162797272205353,
-0.05131315439939499,
0.05861057713627815,
-0.01557958871126175,
0.09340482205152512,
-0.2460099458694458,
-0.41933342814445496,
0.3159664571285248,
0.4145120084285736,
-0.11597022414207458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11683v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11683v1 | HoLLMwood: Unleashing the Creativity of Large Language Models in Screenwriting via Role Playing | 2024-06-17T16:01:33 | 2024-06-17T16:01:33 | Jing Chen, Xinyu Zhu, Cheng Yang, Chufan Shi, Yadong Xi, Yuxiang Zhang, Junjie Wang, Jiashu Pu, Rongsheng Zhang, Yujiu Yang, Tian Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative AI has demonstrated unprecedented creativity in the field of
computer vision, yet such phenomena have not been observed in natural language
processing. In particular, large language models (LLMs) can hardly produce
written works at the level of human experts due to the extremely high
complexity of literature writing. In this paper, we present HoLLMwood, an
automated framework for unleashing the creativity of LLMs and exploring their
potential in screenwriting, which is a highly demanding task. Mimicking the
human creative process, we assign LLMs to different roles involved in the
real-world scenario. In addition to the common practice of treating LLMs as
${Writer}$, we also apply LLMs as ${Editor}$, who is responsible for providing
feedback and revision advice to ${Writer}$. Besides, to enrich the characters
and deepen the plots, we introduce a role-playing mechanism and adopt LLMs as
${Actors}$ that can communicate and interact with each other. Evaluations on
automatically generated screenplays show that HoLLMwood substantially
outperforms strong baselines in terms of coherence, relevance, interestingness
and overall quality. | [
-0.11572229117155075,
-0.9115810394287109,
0.7735999822616577,
0.1458018571138382,
-0.08499634265899658,
0.31831732392311096,
-0.1453825831413269,
-0.17540724575519562,
0.0960155576467514,
1.0176705121994019,
-0.6426915526390076,
-0.6145904064178467,
-0.44085055589675903,
0.0046495613642036915,
-0.24909071624279022,
0.8078089952468872,
-0.24274998903274536,
-0.21530954539775848,
-0.41250157356262207,
0.07258290797472,
-0.34001684188842773,
-0.2588440179824829,
-0.4985632598400116,
-0.07652203738689423,
0.7084384560585022,
0.20107688009738922,
0.7050794959068298,
0.6049695611000061,
0.4516947269439697,
0.35998037457466125,
0.3048466145992279,
0.3428177833557129,
-0.47550326585769653,
0.6632559299468994,
-0.1383548229932785,
-0.3837244510650635,
-0.4324478507041931,
-0.004859726410359144,
0.5195227265357971,
0.4296162724494934,
-0.15807873010635376,
0.20949748158454895,
0.2264236956834793,
0.44792792201042175,
-0.3847765624523163,
0.2517023980617523,
-0.701225221157074,
0.2531145513057709,
-0.12822669744491577,
-0.3263837993144989,
-0.39526620507240295,
-0.3195958435535431,
-0.05533049255609512,
-0.7230216264724731,
0.34171703457832336,
0.22522999346256256,
0.6339574456214905,
0.3011682331562042,
-0.1455671638250351,
-0.5270708799362183,
-0.9503284096717834,
0.6707601547241211,
-0.930755078792572,
-0.5193520188331604,
0.2752244472503662,
0.25574418902397156,
-0.1703394204378128,
-0.4182288944721222,
-0.5940868854522705,
-0.5229393243789673,
0.22554433345794678,
0.18257586658000946,
0.2006043791770935,
0.16439014673233032,
0.4082171320915222,
0.6346269845962524,
-0.6104885935783386,
0.2771036922931671,
-0.12452248483896255,
0.012462778948247433,
0.9226046800613403,
0.34438955783843994,
0.535264253616333,
-0.04184494540095329,
0.027195889502763748,
0.05421998351812363,
-0.4679647386074066,
0.045640990138053894,
0.45251935720443726,
-0.1869666874408722,
0.1579473316669464,
0.9254926443099976,
0.12387728691101074,
0.6155099868774414,
0.0072611793875694275,
0.010431189090013504,
-0.45272794365882874,
0.22279684245586395,
-0.2679048776626587,
0.1903102695941925,
0.7527125477790833,
0.6715933680534363,
0.1511605679988861,
0.21831126511096954,
-0.29537075757980347,
0.15805982053279877,
0.29175686836242676,
-0.6223538517951965,
-0.08393413573503494,
0.22403542697429657,
-0.3284667134284973,
-0.5366650819778442,
0.01914331689476967,
-0.6179563403129578,
-1.0481868982315063,
-0.25693628191947937,
0.7339112162590027,
-0.16517136991024017,
-0.21889528632164001,
-0.20918725430965424,
-0.2866862118244171,
0.13858294486999512,
0.28508201241493225,
-0.9905957579612732,
-0.03621181845664978,
0.3876260817050934,
0.5165260434150696,
-0.18552716076374054,
-0.46737784147262573,
-0.5663248896598816,
0.48847678303718567,
-0.6384071111679077,
0.5880724191665649,
-0.28455543518066406,
-0.4208487570285797,
-0.0158423762768507,
-0.3785555362701416,
0.05511121451854706,
-0.645813524723053,
0.20886118710041046,
-0.2981874346733093,
0.2814132571220398,
0.44787919521331787,
-0.4004462659358978,
0.13555952906608582,
0.22258855402469635,
-0.9680104851722717,
0.8273194432258606,
0.1460890769958496,
-0.23083963990211487,
0.19599691033363342,
-0.6462051868438721,
-0.5274631977081299,
0.14975038170814514,
-0.07690733671188354,
-0.4412129521369934,
0.4254337251186371,
0.23335441946983337,
0.7191305160522461,
-0.3794291317462921,
0.6977688670158386,
-0.1783629059791565,
-0.504213273525238,
0.534171998500824,
-0.5329797863960266,
0.3702508211135864,
0.18738754093647003,
-0.5326684713363647,
0.3569971024990082,
-0.6415700912475586,
0.011500496417284012,
0.06226501986384392,
-0.42978334426879883,
-0.026294391602277756,
-0.0892559364438057,
0.11077313125133514,
0.2390119880437851,
-0.022573361173272133,
-0.3663575351238251,
0.2449609339237213,
-0.549313485622406,
0.6433459520339966,
0.5257578492164612,
0.05621093139052391,
0.46056750416755676,
-0.8300471901893616,
0.5531619787216187,
-0.3778162896633148,
0.03516693785786629,
-0.2440909594297409,
-0.34947776794433594,
-0.69049072265625,
-0.25123804807662964,
-0.13602226972579956,
0.47570735216140747,
-0.8102582693099976,
0.4899866580963135,
0.11537410318851471,
-0.6434419751167297,
-0.9018872976303101,
0.4340628385543823,
0.28478336334228516,
-0.008401406928896904,
0.18613870441913605,
-0.2944642901420593,
-0.63983553647995,
-0.6102570295333862,
-0.5866026282310486,
-0.026945723220705986,
-0.008265279233455658,
0.050475649535655975,
0.03784508630633354,
-0.2305411845445633,
0.9274417757987976,
-0.3695215880870819,
-0.7798590660095215,
-0.7183041572570801,
0.3204755187034607,
0.4502048194408417,
0.4384644627571106,
-0.030857089906930923,
-0.5172016620635986,
-0.8642440438270569,
-0.025708559900522232,
-1.1244990825653076,
-0.26916375756263733,
-0.5386072397232056,
-0.11630212515592575,
0.5254533290863037,
0.7185664176940918,
-0.8997065424919128,
0.6186864972114563,
0.6986963748931885,
-0.20128296315670013,
0.554713249206543,
-0.45518580079078674,
0.1222730353474617,
-1.0845211744308472,
0.14632581174373627,
-0.3398953974246979,
0.044278111308813095,
-0.26669639348983765,
0.10987837612628937,
-0.5919625759124756,
-0.44802966713905334,
-0.08549994230270386,
0.5884776711463928,
-0.8171325922012329,
0.05547109246253967,
-0.2744331359863281,
0.37248343229293823,
0.2269793599843979,
0.6061920523643494,
-0.06705819070339203,
0.2363748997449875,
0.5551149249076843,
-0.351025253534317,
0.7054466605186462,
-0.006545310840010643,
-0.6488649845123291,
0.3672715425491333,
-0.5348485708236694,
0.025741394609212875,
-0.483376681804657,
0.2952417731285095,
-0.9655160903930664,
-0.4043177664279938,
-0.254439115524292,
-0.06953500211238861,
0.03366489335894585,
-0.12529203295707703,
-0.3880777060985565,
-0.2588421404361725,
-0.24286575615406036,
-0.1630427986383438,
0.7749258279800415,
-0.20525211095809937,
1.0021536350250244,
0.5544360876083374,
-0.40108004212379456,
-0.23706835508346558,
-0.5500363707542419,
0.3565784990787506,
-0.47727707028388977,
-0.48950013518333435,
0.6293776035308838,
-0.25286391377449036,
-0.544465184211731,
-0.035474780946969986,
0.29482999444007874,
0.02620934508740902,
-0.06915399432182312,
0.647085964679718,
0.3409011662006378,
-0.1124466136097908,
-0.2152785211801529,
0.03550206869840622,
0.09116527438163757,
-0.003654163796454668,
-0.1576850563287735,
0.5162039995193481,
0.21901975572109222,
-0.25524505972862244,
-0.386615514755249,
0.5525655150413513,
0.8083173036575317,
-0.3441047668457031,
0.4246215224266052,
0.6086753010749817,
-0.1541547328233719,
-0.5775974988937378,
-0.5302092432975769,
0.16438837349414825,
-0.4610069692134857,
0.33432528376579285,
-0.1949431598186493,
-0.9547427892684937,
0.11296972632408142,
0.043319303542375565,
0.4055081903934479,
0.644263744354248,
0.6757562160491943,
-0.33140304684638977,
1.1457947492599487,
0.491682231426239,
0.3605215549468994,
0.3601533770561218,
-0.43700218200683594,
0.2780633270740509,
-0.775123119354248,
-0.13353756070137024,
-0.044143661856651306,
-0.40685927867889404,
-0.3191010653972626,
-0.549370288848877,
0.39570948481559753,
0.2631242275238037,
0.06535352766513824,
0.3550572693347931,
-0.3936808407306671,
0.7632923126220703,
0.5421643853187561,
-0.2018727958202362,
0.4289957582950592,
-0.11848842352628708,
-0.3537672162055969,
-0.08578894287347794,
-0.6369028091430664,
-0.7752041220664978,
0.8413155674934387,
0.20100730657577515,
1.0573883056640625,
0.33811402320861816,
0.7737789154052734,
0.46584728360176086,
0.6162052750587463,
-0.6631088256835938,
0.7608557939529419,
-0.22501543164253235,
-0.6441221237182617,
-0.8094768524169922,
0.003469638293609023,
-0.7007296085357666,
0.05783119797706604,
-0.44110599160194397,
-0.37747514247894287,
-0.274914026260376,
0.4100291132926941,
-0.5685205459594727,
0.280400812625885,
-0.6909616589546204,
0.9611831903457642,
-0.3125447928905487,
-0.8676764369010925,
-0.5657978057861328,
-0.5008913278579712,
0.20611819624900818,
-0.014902093447744846,
0.33045831322669983,
-0.22452525794506073,
0.48274609446525574,
0.5164580345153809,
-0.266992449760437,
0.9964898824691772,
-0.1837996542453766,
-0.2819223403930664,
0.7992224097251892,
0.6355606317520142,
0.38357144594192505,
0.08374443650245667,
-0.2449345886707306,
-0.23237134516239166,
0.03623122349381447,
-0.06380575895309448,
-0.5337147116661072,
0.8404332399368286,
-0.49855896830558777,
-0.7269762754440308,
-0.3741971254348755,
-0.7601928114891052,
-0.2161300629377365,
0.14036794006824493,
0.30163198709487915,
0.6589484810829163,
-0.8126383423805237,
0.1796853244304657,
0.2747133672237396,
-0.335964173078537,
0.846208393573761,
0.06681044399738312,
-0.5771608948707581,
-0.3257896304130554,
0.8862773776054382,
-0.046398308128118515,
0.19021695852279663,
0.4015785753726959,
0.005112290382385254,
-0.3334014415740967,
-0.37423229217529297,
-0.5723574757575989,
0.14551758766174316,
-0.6268004179000854,
0.14834976196289062,
-0.5552580952644348,
-0.3010910451412201,
-0.2907997667789459,
-0.5435966849327087,
0.056066833436489105,
-0.35165897011756897,
-0.09499482810497284,
-0.033962953835725784,
0.07403264194726944,
0.9951916337013245,
0.03230766952037811,
0.2662849426269531,
-0.8849835395812988,
0.2614441215991974,
0.5716633200645447,
0.22337959706783295,
0.22316323220729828,
-0.34109413623809814,
-0.36506742238998413,
-0.13418415188789368,
-0.4786411225795746,
-0.3553159832954407,
0.6690297722816467,
0.36996373534202576,
0.5602001547813416,
0.22561465203762054,
-0.10708588361740112,
0.49596238136291504,
-0.42520660161972046,
0.8186099529266357,
0.05316943675279617,
-0.9067301750183105,
0.3840865194797516,
-0.45395350456237793,
0.47639337182044983,
0.5061905384063721,
0.14804479479789734,
-0.6935759782791138,
-0.5760251879692078,
-0.5002986788749695,
-0.7289385199546814,
0.4786135256290436,
-0.0018749901792034507,
0.3284522294998169,
0.2731029689311981,
-0.18513187766075134,
0.13786901533603668,
0.38204482197761536,
-0.6958543658256531,
0.6484870314598083,
-0.20219318568706512,
-0.5600007772445679,
-0.4064609408378601,
-0.19324296712875366,
-0.06421703100204468,
-0.166595458984375,
0.6384661793708801,
-0.13988882303237915,
-0.005831447429955006,
0.27816733717918396,
-0.44215789437294006,
-0.3108992278575897,
0.22567933797836304,
0.46488702297210693,
0.4454170763492584,
-0.044686321169137955,
0.421604186296463,
-0.09406052529811859,
-0.35474804043769836,
0.01915612258017063,
-0.24292519688606262,
-0.045474544167518616,
-0.07031487673521042,
0.7486184239387512,
0.9265877604484558,
0.08654220402240753,
-1.0589947700500488,
0.22369956970214844,
0.1632152497768402,
-0.38308390974998474,
-0.4500935673713684,
0.4593769311904907,
0.25251510739326477,
0.17235241830348969,
0.22189168632030487,
0.11619171500205994,
-0.1662053018808365,
-0.9815856218338013,
0.08403023332357407,
0.42772290110588074,
-0.49819257855415344,
-0.020846134051680565,
0.7428531646728516,
0.37563982605934143,
-0.841903805732727,
0.4765174090862274,
0.002514373743906617,
-0.3075900971889496,
0.6931533217430115,
0.5760672092437744,
0.9129956960678101,
-0.1891539841890335,
0.42708882689476013,
0.21097353100776672,
0.1068178117275238,
0.012544899247586727,
0.03253592923283577,
0.17510977387428284,
-0.6290174722671509,
-0.47050827741622925,
-0.7957955002784729,
-0.3332584500312805,
0.09654757380485535,
-0.10561223328113556,
0.23129111528396606,
-0.7024497389793396,
-0.09486536681652069,
0.0005351461586542428,
-0.21311239898204803,
-0.17478272318840027,
0.019406862556934357,
0.16299238801002502,
0.31823694705963135,
-0.35622963309288025,
0.6601824164390564,
0.49827876687049866,
-0.3023741543292999,
-0.7088609337806702,
0.1524987816810608,
0.04909457266330719,
-0.49234694242477417,
0.44779279828071594,
0.4706312417984009,
-0.10819762200117111,
0.641042172908783,
-0.4125974476337433,
-0.4770472049713135,
1.2107737064361572,
-0.037540268152952194,
-0.4891388416290283,
-0.2994210422039032,
0.19849416613578796,
0.7680531740188599,
-0.7350380420684814,
0.09207409620285034,
0.22273977100849152,
0.29895105957984924,
0.2511354684829712,
-0.7025263905525208,
-0.22739998996257782,
-0.37212997674942017,
0.103420190513134,
-0.07852194458246231,
-0.17324088513851166,
0.6881117224693298,
-0.4349173903465271,
-0.11212442070245743,
0.2846980690956116,
0.4326450526714325,
0.30714747309684753,
0.19371627271175385,
0.4667392671108246,
0.15646716952323914,
0.4490523338317871,
0.20086197555065155,
0.7794548869132996,
-0.1268037110567093,
0.058031968772411346,
0.8744176626205444,
-0.7518717646598816,
0.7443954944610596,
0.41179248690605164,
0.09376410394906998,
0.7461402416229248,
0.1342126727104187,
-0.17143245041370392,
0.31177017092704773,
0.6328942179679871,
-0.4744929373264313,
-0.32572081685066223,
-0.18122774362564087,
0.3792138397693634,
0.4140085279941559,
0.12241881340742111,
-0.3884160816669464,
-0.09789559245109558,
0.2697688341140747,
-0.09597944468259811,
0.691525399684906,
-0.3600016236305237,
0.8108215928077698,
0.21997380256652832,
-1.2016505002975464,
0.3815929591655731,
0.17996680736541748,
0.5762653350830078,
-0.6536902785301208,
-0.44824662804603577,
-0.0804775059223175,
0.39980798959732056,
-0.17172887921333313,
-0.9386849999427795,
0.38603925704956055,
0.09536229074001312,
-0.1495707482099533,
-0.5610838532447815,
0.5592845678329468,
-0.7951957583427429,
-0.40237313508987427,
-0.012454054318368435,
0.1453401744365692,
0.09104381501674652,
-0.1615891009569168,
-0.4633451998233795,
0.15485800802707672,
-0.1356155425310135,
0.11835689097642899,
0.07305296510457993,
0.35336369276046753,
-0.2992631494998932,
0.5544204711914062,
0.7772766947746277,
0.07270332425832748,
-0.14804506301879883,
0.16308586299419403,
0.3473060131072998,
-0.5500738024711609,
-0.5445780158042908,
-1.0485570430755615,
0.835631251335144,
-0.3080008327960968,
-0.33861157298088074,
0.8046780228614807,
0.5443616509437561,
0.34875819087028503,
-0.6218253374099731,
0.8502959609031677,
-0.17854174971580505,
0.2789047360420227,
-0.8183085918426514,
1.1128705739974976,
-0.19774486124515533,
0.24635997414588928,
-0.2534736394882202,
-1.205377221107483,
-0.3243951201438904,
0.5365411639213562,
-0.042435675859451294,
-0.16904869675636292,
0.7605205178260803,
1.077661395072937,
0.3047270178794861,
-0.27991992235183716,
0.6799665093421936,
0.3517715632915497,
0.2952444851398468,
0.6820222735404968,
1.169543743133545,
-0.009033994749188423,
0.2583521008491516,
0.09677817672491074,
-0.38733038306236267,
-0.3197111189365387,
-0.9793279767036438,
-1.3527698516845703,
-0.6455517411231995,
-0.14751099050045013,
-0.27931076288223267,
-0.22355018556118011,
1.018678069114685,
0.4417059123516083,
-0.47879675030708313,
-0.698936402797699,
-0.1935328096151352,
-0.0298924557864666,
-0.31065070629119873,
-0.2177996039390564,
0.14592328667640686,
0.15921662747859955,
-0.7264334559440613,
0.49458184838294983,
0.549767017364502,
0.06611604243516922,
-0.7873976826667786,
-0.0040110754780471325,
-0.0597182922065258,
0.4366237223148346,
0.7964039444923401,
-0.0007052881992422044,
-0.6590461730957031,
0.28713536262512207,
-0.03298690542578697,
-0.422955721616745,
-0.32990339398384094,
0.9908689856529236,
-0.5178797841072083,
0.31747275590896606,
0.31652384996414185,
0.44256728887557983,
0.5742255449295044,
-0.1543395221233368,
0.8953284025192261,
-0.5014641284942627,
-0.06772623211145401,
0.41023388504981995,
-0.11202608793973923,
0.4440317451953888,
-0.5629596710205078,
0.1866711527109146,
0.2434203028678894,
-0.4966837763786316,
-0.6468797922134399,
0.22550441324710846,
-0.8390346765518188,
-0.3171781003475189,
1.070027470588684,
0.09050577878952026,
-0.23497000336647034,
-0.1268407702445984,
-0.9107024669647217,
0.08193386346101761,
0.13389542698860168,
0.9044275283813477,
0.762252151966095,
-0.09151019155979156,
-0.24645009636878967,
-0.4080789089202881,
0.8337948322296143,
0.2839696407318115,
-0.9413931965827942,
0.2982048988342285,
0.5617337822914124,
-0.12720713019371033,
-0.03298230096697807,
0.8463319540023804,
-0.010385463945567608,
-0.06186528876423836,
-0.13718107342720032,
0.23159904778003693,
-0.22245776653289795,
-0.4180773198604584,
-0.14583711326122284,
0.1931791752576828,
0.4824700653553009,
0.570403516292572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11682v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11682v1 | Knowledge-to-Jailbreak: One Knowledge Point Worth One Attack | 2024-06-17T15:59:59 | 2024-06-17T15:59:59 | Shangqing Tu, Zhuoran Pan, Wenxuan Wang, Zhexin Zhang, Yuliang Sun, Jifan Yu, Hongning Wang, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR | Large language models (LLMs) have been increasingly applied to various
domains, which triggers increasing concerns about LLMs' safety on specialized
domains, e.g. medicine. However, testing the domain-specific safety of LLMs is
challenging due to the lack of domain knowledge-driven attacks in existing
benchmarks. To bridge this gap, we propose a new task, knowledge-to-jailbreak,
which aims to generate jailbreaks from domain knowledge to evaluate the safety
of LLMs when applied to those domains. We collect a large-scale dataset with
12,974 knowledge-jailbreak pairs and fine-tune a large language model as
jailbreak-generator, to produce domain knowledge-specific jailbreaks.
Experiments on 13 domains and 8 target LLMs demonstrate the effectiveness of
jailbreak-generator in generating jailbreaks that are both relevant to the
given knowledge and harmful to the target LLMs. We also apply our method to an
out-of-domain knowledge base, showing that jailbreak-generator can generate
jailbreaks that are comparable in harmfulness to those crafted by human
experts. Data and code: https://github.com/THU-KEG/Knowledge-to-Jailbreak/. | [
-0.26823219656944275,
-0.82846999168396,
0.6909356117248535,
0.06253945827484131,
-0.055866632610559464,
0.08444920182228088,
-0.33675193786621094,
-0.4702041745185852,
-0.00009264444088330492,
0.9647321105003357,
-0.3827129304409027,
-0.6926832795143127,
-0.7735257744789124,
-0.17706745862960815,
-0.5054124593734741,
1.0916863679885864,
0.010363172739744186,
-0.2940904498100281,
-0.16361233592033386,
0.15756577253341675,
-0.7219672799110413,
-0.7139738202095032,
-0.21323001384735107,
0.03376569598913193,
0.4799340069293976,
0.562321126461029,
0.3279382884502411,
0.34443747997283936,
0.5742297172546387,
0.13919422030448914,
-0.056538473814725876,
0.15290147066116333,
-0.6234233975410461,
0.1614534556865692,
-0.4842727780342102,
-0.3102472424507141,
-0.47113853693008423,
-0.013001515530049801,
-0.09292527288198471,
0.4886898398399353,
-0.05808062106370926,
0.13558140397071838,
-0.2629319131374359,
0.9436693787574768,
-0.7083414196968079,
-0.3093448579311371,
-1.140969157218933,
-0.2568082809448242,
-0.3096327483654022,
0.05200650542974472,
-0.7169709801673889,
-0.5079571008682251,
0.0004077573830727488,
-0.23026475310325623,
-0.05928410589694977,
0.2941714823246002,
0.5756381750106812,
0.09873566776514053,
-0.41945889592170715,
-0.18802286684513092,
-0.3645474910736084,
0.5454708933830261,
-0.7231082916259766,
0.3046751320362091,
0.5421811938285828,
0.4593575596809387,
-0.4134889543056488,
-0.5827203989028931,
-0.43417924642562866,
-0.47667935490608215,
0.16434697806835175,
-0.3268263339996338,
-0.06685495376586914,
-0.1740787923336029,
0.20432345569133759,
-0.05401856452226639,
-0.4638911187648773,
-0.02125006914138794,
-0.49063897132873535,
-0.004140674136579037,
0.7281585335731506,
0.07239176332950592,
0.5864850282669067,
-0.14485770463943481,
-0.4867580533027649,
0.20810729265213013,
-1.4077396392822266,
-0.4173949360847473,
0.38360151648521423,
0.22363583743572235,
0.10625512897968292,
0.6410826444625854,
0.10795231908559799,
0.8835957646369934,
0.015150140039622784,
-0.4586654007434845,
0.03725644201040268,
-0.16983990371227264,
-0.16771352291107178,
0.1004430279135704,
0.7623419165611267,
0.6129454374313354,
0.5054389238357544,
-0.709492564201355,
-0.029268154874444008,
-0.23024968802928925,
0.5743407607078552,
-0.8850558996200562,
-0.34232473373413086,
0.1355052888393402,
-0.03594695404171944,
-0.6495809555053711,
-0.10385886579751968,
-0.5142998695373535,
-0.829605758190155,
0.3155195713043213,
0.45416754484176636,
-0.7831841707229614,
-0.19242814183235168,
0.18884077668190002,
-0.22422511875629425,
-0.11368760466575623,
-0.01971615105867386,
-0.901002824306488,
0.25282585620880127,
0.5884135365486145,
0.60556960105896,
-0.20773616433143616,
-0.4756896495819092,
-0.3595085144042969,
0.5057333111763,
-0.23136189579963684,
0.7076240181922913,
-0.09867266565561295,
-0.428324431180954,
-0.19620046019554138,
-0.36435219645500183,
-0.09890645742416382,
-0.8440642952919006,
0.03326240926980972,
-0.7258473634719849,
-0.47353291511535645,
-0.11726638674736023,
-0.9087194204330444,
0.025330064818263054,
0.40222257375717163,
-0.6815223097801208,
0.36629238724708557,
0.15535667538642883,
-0.831617534160614,
0.4911685585975647,
-0.5287858843803406,
-0.7635055184364319,
-0.1923476755619049,
0.11045455932617188,
-0.45110055804252625,
-0.05261794850230217,
0.14530010521411896,
0.5185990333557129,
-0.4369536340236664,
0.6410365104675293,
-0.4150206744670868,
0.02584068477153778,
0.4556552767753601,
0.04530409723520279,
0.7750527858734131,
0.15586678683757782,
-0.4153878688812256,
-0.3228587508201599,
-0.7109398245811462,
-0.04750727117061615,
0.50350022315979,
-0.3354279100894928,
-0.6394149661064148,
0.11925377696752548,
-0.2581580579280853,
0.24590155482292175,
0.30550360679626465,
-0.6868472099304199,
0.27819564938545227,
-0.39292582869529724,
0.5424789190292358,
0.5889467597007751,
0.4651910662651062,
0.18714290857315063,
-0.23662069439888,
0.29832181334495544,
-0.017290674149990082,
0.2960893511772156,
0.03361251950263977,
-0.43474870920181274,
-0.24688304960727692,
-0.042240824550390244,
0.39806491136550903,
0.5279949903488159,
-0.5731475353240967,
0.6060472130775452,
-0.12038075923919678,
-0.621483564376831,
-0.19885988533496857,
0.4563911259174347,
0.5403218865394592,
0.6325964331626892,
0.43098336458206177,
-0.2992294728755951,
-0.4695487916469574,
-0.5822635293006897,
-0.7403756976127625,
-0.27391162514686584,
0.19676604866981506,
0.2095169872045517,
0.5929179787635803,
-0.38412246108055115,
0.9514546394348145,
-0.712953507900238,
-0.2474549114704132,
-0.333883136510849,
-0.3461112976074219,
-0.03785521164536476,
0.5489594340324402,
0.7683865427970886,
-0.42434772849082947,
-0.2537110447883606,
-0.2074056714773178,
-0.8567529320716858,
0.03460804000496864,
0.2620505392551422,
-0.002928805770352483,
-0.1301557570695877,
0.6250963807106018,
-0.6265931129455566,
0.2662239670753479,
0.4102931022644043,
-0.6499970555305481,
0.8707312941551208,
0.04209163412451744,
0.07683578133583069,
-1.099339246749878,
0.08403705805540085,
-0.0826944038271904,
-0.0496269091963768,
-0.8184763789176941,
0.43753916025161743,
0.20542806386947632,
-0.06548397243022919,
-0.6568623185157776,
0.5037558674812317,
-0.03938618302345276,
0.1975255310535431,
-0.12580852210521698,
0.14904871582984924,
-0.009208538569509983,
0.055174436420202255,
-0.28894561529159546,
0.7845419049263,
0.32544782757759094,
-0.2821033000946045,
0.2999260425567627,
0.35031381249427795,
-0.8075933456420898,
0.0769268199801445,
-0.44192183017730713,
0.4316825270652771,
0.3266771137714386,
-0.17787817120552063,
-0.6828243732452393,
-0.29290908575057983,
-0.10188092291355133,
-0.4798034429550171,
0.2000139057636261,
-0.415569931268692,
-0.5693751573562622,
-0.22851265966892242,
-0.1402130126953125,
0.3923432528972626,
0.599787712097168,
-0.676020085811615,
0.10341725498437881,
0.8662492632865906,
-0.256070613861084,
-0.5876820087432861,
-0.5929241180419922,
0.2899620532989502,
-0.4952002465724945,
-0.905773937702179,
0.10020466893911362,
-0.023009266704320908,
-0.5827203989028931,
-0.15330149233341217,
-0.01556958258152008,
-0.10965225100517273,
0.47025689482688904,
0.4381990432739258,
0.35514864325523376,
0.17374597489833832,
0.046359315514564514,
0.14029650390148163,
0.06554517149925232,
0.5221287608146667,
-0.5825802087783813,
0.39400017261505127,
0.10529542714357376,
-0.3601204752922058,
0.13879872858524323,
0.20643013715744019,
0.5530543327331543,
-0.32533809542655945,
0.8602970838546753,
-0.1818540245294571,
-0.26609665155410767,
-0.49809524416923523,
-0.6053498387336731,
-0.1303611844778061,
-0.473168283700943,
0.33339646458625793,
-0.28882458806037903,
-1.0383459329605103,
0.1898006945848465,
-0.7191770672798157,
0.07021676003932953,
0.2057904750108719,
0.5477615594863892,
0.03754030168056488,
0.6505668759346008,
0.8034952878952026,
-0.4483819603919983,
0.0860968679189682,
-0.10040920227766037,
0.5820146203041077,
-0.5061050057411194,
-0.3734254539012909,
-0.38870832324028015,
0.04680797830224037,
-0.047609493136405945,
-0.3256611227989197,
0.44360458850860596,
0.3778480291366577,
-0.368238627910614,
0.6664300560951233,
-0.1336057484149933,
0.662614107131958,
0.2796557545661926,
0.29906633496284485,
0.41296571493148804,
-0.08604263514280319,
-0.2711555063724518,
0.1353592425584793,
-0.5049591064453125,
-0.4378581941127777,
1.5621755123138428,
0.2302146703004837,
0.8637920022010803,
0.17735689878463745,
0.9567583799362183,
0.47668540477752686,
0.45206719636917114,
-0.7207866311073303,
0.5053924918174744,
-0.2050400674343109,
-0.7548631429672241,
-0.2240070402622223,
-0.41705936193466187,
-0.6135125160217285,
-0.21918775141239166,
0.008156840689480305,
-0.9265025854110718,
-0.2720188796520233,
0.22084689140319824,
-0.3285774886608124,
0.5241702198982239,
-0.8256286978721619,
1.014641284942627,
-0.4775735139846802,
-0.19903557002544403,
-0.2228364646434784,
-0.6809995174407959,
0.9091838598251343,
-0.5887901186943054,
0.5521886348724365,
-0.17786532640457153,
0.5582636594772339,
0.8572373986244202,
-0.8104857206344604,
0.8457143902778625,
-0.38123825192451477,
-0.21643269062042236,
0.3264278769493103,
0.45565927028656006,
0.5042970776557922,
0.2371062934398651,
-0.15189877152442932,
0.052355922758579254,
-0.4170853793621063,
-0.2075616866350174,
-0.5058149099349976,
0.7523260116577148,
-0.7607002258300781,
-0.9493849277496338,
0.111917644739151,
-0.679988443851471,
-0.5654278993606567,
0.21569858491420746,
0.24257473647594452,
0.12410364300012589,
-0.222652405500412,
-0.3141810894012451,
0.9007371068000793,
-0.3967597186565399,
0.023895908147096634,
0.5983337759971619,
-0.35591381788253784,
-0.31927573680877686,
1.010731816291809,
-0.1823194921016693,
0.42174044251441956,
0.08780393749475479,
0.157095268368721,
-0.042162276804447174,
-0.9695541262626648,
-0.4656197130680084,
0.011377152986824512,
-0.6735730171203613,
-0.5517793893814087,
-0.40101373195648193,
-0.4206238389015198,
-0.4694260060787201,
-0.2966814935207367,
-0.4999791085720062,
-0.36564943194389343,
0.16957688331604004,
-0.35963737964630127,
0.825977623462677,
0.8230183124542236,
-0.03617386519908905,
0.12270057201385498,
-0.9597364068031311,
0.3516347408294678,
0.49826011061668396,
0.20427778363227844,
-0.29964229464530945,
-0.5166603922843933,
-0.29262635111808777,
-0.2992042899131775,
-0.1586431860923767,
-0.997585117816925,
0.35595694184303284,
0.05121682584285736,
0.332123339176178,
0.43643245100975037,
0.2636815905570984,
0.4765530228614807,
-0.9024187922477722,
0.6652766466140747,
0.5040183067321777,
-0.9217446446418762,
1.0506881475448608,
-0.3331875503063202,
-0.23312602937221527,
0.8417635560035706,
0.19159390032291412,
-0.3182852566242218,
-0.8060826063156128,
-0.4935687184333801,
-1.013798713684082,
0.23854149878025055,
-0.02406761422753334,
0.06159451976418495,
-0.14616142213344574,
0.47833067178726196,
0.3486180603504181,
0.14547200500965118,
-0.49691927433013916,
-0.287784606218338,
0.019850797951221466,
0.024899238720536232,
0.18440687656402588,
-0.12596862018108368,
-0.37598830461502075,
-0.17220821976661682,
0.6034669876098633,
0.1752457469701767,
0.02308053895831108,
-0.19315142929553986,
-0.4731694161891937,
-0.16355280578136444,
0.3568742871284485,
0.3049524128437042,
0.749565064907074,
-0.3083316683769226,
0.26222312450408936,
0.07250794023275375,
-0.717954158782959,
0.4090889096260071,
0.016033506020903587,
-0.16740216314792633,
-0.3294943571090698,
0.24942710995674133,
0.5432438254356384,
-0.10175256431102753,
-1.2277854681015015,
0.7601510286331177,
0.028879493474960327,
-0.2954821288585663,
-0.2514559030532837,
0.3921545445919037,
0.22013065218925476,
0.2187531441450119,
0.17218364775180817,
0.20131802558898926,
-0.19325178861618042,
-0.5157849192619324,
0.5821413397789001,
0.29037192463874817,
-0.05908186733722687,
-0.18222257494926453,
0.7948771119117737,
0.17507629096508026,
-0.1502779871225357,
0.5865805745124817,
-0.17262975871562958,
-0.5601692795753479,
0.6100670099258423,
0.7758672833442688,
0.6194755434989929,
-0.18562553822994232,
-0.013687258586287498,
0.12931042909622192,
0.48281463980674744,
0.022186024114489555,
0.12724818289279938,
0.3733087182044983,
-0.8666549324989319,
-0.4561804234981537,
-0.4127369821071625,
-0.370945006608963,
0.3381516933441162,
-0.5005584359169006,
0.07970055192708969,
-0.6134135127067566,
-0.25320714712142944,
-0.02838870882987976,
-0.22404693067073822,
-0.3158610165119171,
0.23084494471549988,
-0.02966579608619213,
1.3194036483764648,
-0.746938943862915,
1.234607219696045,
0.6088181734085083,
-0.049620822072029114,
-0.8525711297988892,
0.14276915788650513,
-0.011424432508647442,
-0.8146879076957703,
0.807057797908783,
0.08295207470655441,
0.004600029904395342,
-0.11007604748010635,
-0.7498420476913452,
-0.6781500577926636,
0.9867550134658813,
0.5850615501403809,
-0.8881101012229919,
0.03739655017852783,
0.2196052074432373,
0.0538238063454628,
-0.19725053012371063,
-0.5996810793876648,
1.0626922845840454,
0.5105038285255432,
-0.3657744824886322,
-0.7952735424041748,
0.28232690691947937,
-0.21873614192008972,
-0.39344820380210876,
0.552143394947052,
-0.3308700919151306,
0.5805796980857849,
-0.8516792058944702,
0.3091132938861847,
-0.016188694164156914,
0.3203124701976776,
0.6957279443740845,
0.1516287624835968,
0.48487383127212524,
0.8910653591156006,
0.6340284943580627,
0.10473884642124176,
0.9006075859069824,
-0.619049072265625,
0.20765352249145508,
1.138855218887329,
-0.4406674802303314,
0.7567286491394043,
0.5961936712265015,
0.011152811348438263,
0.35435980558395386,
0.0524013489484787,
-0.13916411995887756,
0.9887734055519104,
0.6002345085144043,
-0.4034253656864166,
-0.1914912909269333,
0.3272586166858673,
-0.20775017142295837,
0.1941070556640625,
0.5613806247711182,
-0.4106447696685791,
-0.160522922873497,
0.3412632942199707,
0.4783831834793091,
-0.000039459060644730926,
-0.2936360239982605,
0.7605236768722534,
0.3665056526660919,
-0.60687255859375,
0.6632227301597595,
0.38658249378204346,
0.379800409078598,
-0.5861161351203918,
0.23165877163410187,
-0.0797501727938652,
0.19660988450050354,
-0.13578464090824127,
-0.6988829374313354,
0.25173506140708923,
0.5975099802017212,
-0.094479501247406,
0.0868302583694458,
1.2776223421096802,
-0.15318042039871216,
-0.13487279415130615,
0.6367164850234985,
0.6399259567260742,
0.06712467223405838,
-0.33115920424461365,
-0.28718653321266174,
-0.14933069050312042,
-0.08192981034517288,
-0.36859065294265747,
0.7700350284576416,
0.16362589597702026,
-0.016456108540296555,
0.600042462348938,
0.4998467266559601,
0.27555787563323975,
0.2383897304534912,
0.04345422983169556,
1.2434422969818115,
-0.8753823041915894,
-0.1592794954776764,
-1.0175987482070923,
0.3249734044075012,
0.03899388015270233,
-0.2182665467262268,
0.7583763599395752,
0.3936942517757416,
0.7265040874481201,
-0.1457822024822235,
1.3585572242736816,
-0.42689329385757446,
0.32898104190826416,
-0.5624918341636658,
1.2417861223220825,
-0.332269549369812,
0.5245454907417297,
-0.2987673878669739,
-0.30300840735435486,
-0.3243386447429657,
0.22986823320388794,
-0.5316586494445801,
-0.35281938314437866,
0.7040546536445618,
0.6952813267707825,
0.2941543757915497,
-0.12382220476865768,
0.45554882287979126,
0.28103020787239075,
0.196894109249115,
0.8504736423492432,
1.0285158157348633,
-0.3704279363155365,
0.5520740151405334,
-0.362727552652359,
-0.19225440919399261,
-0.04331216588616371,
-0.8419098854064941,
-1.3144491910934448,
-0.24468228220939636,
-0.15235286951065063,
-0.6681414246559143,
0.5414084792137146,
0.6516377925872803,
0.6451333165168762,
-0.7953262329101562,
-0.1582231968641281,
-0.20633721351623535,
0.24226820468902588,
-0.10702680796384811,
-0.13438530266284943,
0.2751043736934662,
-0.3958844542503357,
-0.07298243045806885,
0.8983739614486694,
0.24509868025779724,
-0.23265020549297333,
0.02763230726122856,
-0.06999661028385162,
0.1284114420413971,
-0.06712556630373001,
0.7062440514564514,
0.19421999156475067,
-0.34187182784080505,
-0.3238506317138672,
-0.106173574924469,
-0.09354034811258316,
-0.18714596331119537,
1.0296865701675415,
-0.7162753343582153,
0.07713889330625534,
0.19619342684745789,
0.810173511505127,
0.23446951806545258,
-0.07833558320999146,
0.6487922072410583,
-0.9368188977241516,
-0.11622003465890884,
0.04935097694396973,
0.41150104999542236,
0.060093048959970474,
-0.39588719606399536,
0.4333995580673218,
0.2753413915634155,
-0.5439315438270569,
-0.7825815081596375,
0.34706032276153564,
-0.6835771799087524,
-0.7397639155387878,
1.223554015159607,
-0.4638117551803589,
-0.2807956635951996,
-0.41121333837509155,
0.11950045824050903,
0.00034331512870267034,
-0.26533108949661255,
1.1248992681503296,
0.3246172070503235,
0.21495112776756287,
0.20009204745292664,
-0.5884539484977722,
0.6515617370605469,
0.02317877858877182,
-1.205524206161499,
0.36372438073158264,
0.1436007171869278,
0.9180920124053955,
0.03840978071093559,
0.4815210998058319,
-0.37883448600769043,
0.33032068610191345,
-0.1371389478445053,
0.2118268460035324,
-0.27698442339897156,
-0.5745661854743958,
0.12847478687763214,
0.42473360896110535,
0.48000144958496094,
0.2621748447418213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11681v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11681v1 | R-Eval: A Unified Toolkit for Evaluating Domain Knowledge of Retrieval Augmented Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T15:59:49 | 2024-06-17T15:59:49 | Shangqing Tu, Yuanchun Wang, Jifan Yu, Yuyang Xie, Yaran Shi, Xiaozhi Wang, Jing Zhang, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models have achieved remarkable success on general NLP tasks,
but they may fall short for domain-specific problems. Recently, various
Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models (RALLMs) are proposed to address this
shortcoming. However, existing evaluation tools only provide a few baselines
and evaluate them on various domains without mining the depth of domain
knowledge. In this paper, we address the challenges of evaluating RALLMs by
introducing the R-Eval toolkit, a Python toolkit designed to streamline the
evaluation of different RAG workflows in conjunction with LLMs. Our toolkit,
which supports popular built-in RAG workflows and allows for the incorporation
of customized testing data on the specific domain, is designed to be
user-friendly, modular, and extensible. We conduct an evaluation of 21 RALLMs
across three task levels and two representative domains, revealing significant
variations in the effectiveness of RALLMs across different tasks and domains.
Our analysis emphasizes the importance of considering both task and domain
requirements when choosing a RAG workflow and LLM combination. We are committed
to continuously maintaining our platform at https://github.com/THU-KEG/R-Eval
to facilitate both the industry and the researchers. | [
-0.41751763224601746,
-0.876529335975647,
0.3640807569026947,
0.2336561530828476,
-0.03450851887464523,
0.4592426121234894,
-0.5682425498962402,
-0.3405151665210724,
0.08542605489492416,
0.7360098958015442,
-0.3158584535121918,
-0.5013811588287354,
-0.5898495316505432,
0.2635681927204132,
-0.30766817927360535,
1.1292437314987183,
-0.16561396420001984,
-0.18633027374744415,
-0.48677632212638855,
-0.14144620299339294,
-0.5870518684387207,
-0.2841856777667999,
-0.3343532681465149,
-0.8037778735160828,
0.7075247168540955,
0.27336636185646057,
0.5176877379417419,
0.1388513594865799,
0.8245990872383118,
0.19554951786994934,
-0.0725148469209671,
0.2970159649848938,
-0.33387574553489685,
0.6096546053886414,
-0.5414872169494629,
-0.16711412370204926,
-0.550791323184967,
-0.15603046119213104,
0.46938079595565796,
0.6919575929641724,
-0.3667660057544708,
0.6010796427726746,
0.16282771527767181,
0.7380484342575073,
-0.9861957430839539,
-0.008963318541646004,
-0.5472095608711243,
-0.024952629581093788,
-0.09261191636323929,
-0.34671828150749207,
-0.5486255288124084,
-0.14325931668281555,
0.07874633371829987,
-0.3144589066505432,
-0.05848002806305885,
0.25868114829063416,
0.7116267085075378,
0.24294552206993103,
-0.18334273993968964,
-0.1546003371477127,
-0.743050754070282,
1.0132017135620117,
-0.6493191719055176,
0.4492424726486206,
0.47909823060035706,
0.27502700686454773,
-0.24622602760791779,
-0.8111637234687805,
-0.23042549192905426,
-0.3253759443759918,
-0.20013932883739471,
-0.02855403907597065,
-0.32947635650634766,
0.047014061361551285,
0.1956309825181961,
0.3922021985054016,
-0.9348340034484863,
0.02641519159078598,
-0.25737664103507996,
-0.06734734028577805,
0.5265611410140991,
0.3671755790710449,
0.32233095169067383,
-0.1045069620013237,
-0.44371581077575684,
-0.11955022066831589,
-0.6643450260162354,
-0.28861117362976074,
0.11863522231578827,
0.25892218947410583,
0.06911192834377289,
0.668878436088562,
-0.04160790145397186,
0.8251028656959534,
-0.3805067837238312,
-0.17863966524600983,
0.2987750768661499,
-0.07166460901498795,
-0.3224043846130371,
-0.4971607029438019,
0.7888999581336975,
0.060494277626276016,
0.14330244064331055,
-0.21280230581760406,
-0.5394702553749084,
-0.10915469378232956,
0.508679986000061,
-0.7044447660446167,
-0.09037496894598007,
0.26675814390182495,
-0.3193216323852539,
-0.06414948403835297,
-0.022103212773799896,
-0.9236190319061279,
-0.30838969349861145,
-0.34106287360191345,
0.5977370738983154,
-0.2752898633480072,
-0.43156927824020386,
0.16334983706474304,
-0.08931121230125427,
0.17382122576236725,
0.3845701813697815,
-0.38692113757133484,
0.353446364402771,
1.1227613687515259,
0.7511882185935974,
-0.5149410367012024,
-0.401157021522522,
-0.7948576211929321,
-0.36531901359558105,
-0.3306141197681427,
0.812179446220398,
-0.9550603032112122,
-0.28313034772872925,
0.06628943234682083,
-0.1841573864221573,
-0.2630904018878937,
-0.7701526284217834,
0.5980589985847473,
-0.8656201958656311,
-0.00495940400287509,
0.2212650328874588,
-0.5327030420303345,
-0.1845211684703827,
0.33663830161094666,
-0.5921462774276733,
1.2648338079452515,
0.3074953854084015,
-0.631466805934906,
0.10470395535230637,
-0.6219858527183533,
-0.4746358096599579,
0.47339877486228943,
0.054412841796875,
-0.39567744731903076,
0.08327313512563705,
-0.022345084697008133,
0.6147280931472778,
-0.5276591181755066,
0.1774328351020813,
-0.34199440479278564,
-0.39444684982299805,
0.2515290379524231,
-0.26201894879341125,
0.5964913964271545,
0.3546953499317169,
-0.033977676182985306,
0.11996817588806152,
-0.5735988616943359,
0.4197527766227722,
-0.08896759897470474,
-0.40145793557167053,
-0.4572894275188446,
-0.28975486755371094,
0.34082844853401184,
-0.019927112385630608,
0.12332501262426376,
-0.27313655614852905,
0.2230299413204193,
-0.32868054509162903,
0.21324287354946136,
0.4918361008167267,
0.02617586776614189,
0.3585813045501709,
-0.2356412559747696,
1.1589734554290771,
-0.5513960719108582,
-0.03244473785161972,
-0.1876082867383957,
-0.45586028695106506,
-0.5635334253311157,
-0.34066715836524963,
0.4628700613975525,
0.5097173452377319,
-0.5770571231842041,
0.5148304104804993,
-0.22521045804023743,
-0.598105251789093,
-0.5858902931213379,
0.3420119285583496,
0.6555557250976562,
0.0639863908290863,
0.25007519125938416,
-0.16714009642601013,
-0.5458469986915588,
-0.7943565845489502,
-0.31500282883644104,
0.050833769142627716,
0.016776403412222862,
0.4642608165740967,
0.8555049300193787,
-0.5724172592163086,
0.9855123162269592,
-0.5209384560585022,
-0.5181617736816406,
-0.61756432056427,
0.27562302350997925,
0.2889808118343353,
0.18459904193878174,
0.2031007558107376,
-0.6769225001335144,
-0.5765476822853088,
0.2738953232765198,
-0.3347415626049042,
-0.302791953086853,
0.33612045645713806,
0.07652222365140915,
0.33872708678245544,
-0.01296191941946745,
-0.6204487085342407,
0.46571576595306396,
0.6966680288314819,
-0.12319209426641464,
0.8322288393974304,
-0.28244954347610474,
0.2426173985004425,
-0.7661581635475159,
0.37569621205329895,
0.10740246623754501,
-0.245218887925148,
-0.5595872402191162,
0.3757912814617157,
0.30176204442977905,
-0.056685999035835266,
-0.33505508303642273,
1.0095329284667969,
-0.39825108647346497,
-0.2897129952907562,
-0.31469935178756714,
0.15204761922359467,
0.41932910680770874,
0.2549051344394684,
0.0461277961730957,
1.0261770486831665,
0.40454256534576416,
-0.5495254397392273,
0.35884979367256165,
0.08996302634477615,
-0.5189096331596375,
0.4025888442993164,
-0.4710001051425934,
0.3743450939655304,
0.2415996491909027,
0.208856999874115,
-0.5531679391860962,
-0.19942732155323029,
-0.02171831578016281,
-0.4436516761779785,
0.40653249621391296,
-0.36414310336112976,
-0.38633713126182556,
-0.4132278561592102,
-0.31363728642463684,
0.3827279508113861,
0.69142085313797,
-0.6473987698554993,
0.8767127394676208,
0.4424455761909485,
-0.20360709726810455,
-1.117971658706665,
-0.28158122301101685,
0.30767109990119934,
-0.44431251287460327,
-0.4753870666027069,
0.13609188795089722,
-0.06304295361042023,
-0.5601440668106079,
0.08164780586957932,
-0.13643477857112885,
-0.2151230275630951,
0.099805548787117,
0.17753052711486816,
0.285332590341568,
-0.14397406578063965,
-0.06953062862157822,
-0.3367757797241211,
-0.09823589026927948,
0.06853152811527252,
0.04266733303666115,
0.5200725793838501,
-0.2246442288160324,
-0.38298678398132324,
-0.17735998332500458,
-0.013246099464595318,
0.37736478447914124,
-0.4911843538284302,
0.2941148579120636,
0.6205448508262634,
-0.2536727786064148,
-0.9956445097923279,
-0.6630138754844666,
0.013382973149418831,
-0.4279974102973938,
0.5195247530937195,
-0.31919384002685547,
-0.8617114424705505,
0.400250643491745,
-0.23036780953407288,
0.02045081928372383,
0.24216043949127197,
0.7333991527557373,
0.10818836092948914,
0.6873579025268555,
0.48682940006256104,
-0.013064202852547169,
0.01605350896716118,
-0.4076547920703888,
0.3880268931388855,
-1.2416731119155884,
-0.2074827253818512,
-0.6461277604103088,
0.08011233061552048,
0.06969024986028671,
-0.7135486602783203,
0.345759779214859,
0.08685602992773056,
-0.004808847326785326,
0.32875195145606995,
-0.42151668667793274,
0.6226563453674316,
0.1371116042137146,
-0.23997047543525696,
0.3313977122306824,
-0.0973755344748497,
0.04216049239039421,
0.028468169271945953,
-0.6191914081573486,
-0.5899839401245117,
1.2378400564193726,
0.19438280165195465,
1.2810736894607544,
-0.16350845992565155,
0.6517091393470764,
0.753991425037384,
0.45851215720176697,
-0.9526482224464417,
0.586966335773468,
0.0067923483438789845,
-0.3367019295692444,
-0.11119072884321213,
-0.36548593640327454,
-1.2040451765060425,
0.48288804292678833,
-0.09786771237850189,
-0.5859112739562988,
-0.31600725650787354,
-0.05878937616944313,
-0.3596149682998657,
0.2839004397392273,
-0.44294047355651855,
0.8097332715988159,
-0.14190728962421417,
-0.3493010997772217,
-0.3909083604812622,
-0.1754530966281891,
0.4485528767108917,
-0.2973937392234802,
0.42158040404319763,
-0.06996988505125046,
0.013960251584649086,
0.7401503324508667,
-0.2876543402671814,
0.5225573778152466,
0.048118893057107925,
-0.12701480090618134,
0.27966824173927307,
0.29285261034965515,
0.38652291893959045,
0.03752267360687256,
0.014149846509099007,
0.18448495864868164,
0.0929686650633812,
0.0960320457816124,
-0.7569137811660767,
0.8196960091590881,
-0.4388852119445801,
-0.5344436168670654,
-0.6093976497650146,
-0.6271547079086304,
-0.20620204508304596,
0.08677276968955994,
-0.35072070360183716,
0.5656414031982422,
-0.23852607607841492,
0.38919737935066223,
0.5986447334289551,
-0.4317217767238617,
0.10646522790193558,
0.6130089163780212,
-0.6978207230567932,
-0.3449648916721344,
0.861176073551178,
-0.3041497766971588,
0.3081580102443695,
0.3027130663394928,
0.3146919906139374,
-0.3340930640697479,
-0.4731035530567169,
-0.35141485929489136,
0.12509110569953918,
-0.7927504181861877,
-0.6055402159690857,
-0.6664490699768066,
-0.1907453089952469,
-0.21712608635425568,
-0.0026533533819019794,
-0.39934587478637695,
-0.22321994602680206,
-0.02621467597782612,
0.22776176035404205,
0.4590848982334137,
1.020136833190918,
-0.0818718746304512,
-0.2284563183784485,
-0.7905707359313965,
0.4091021418571472,
0.11424864083528519,
0.46446216106414795,
0.11038831621408463,
-0.734771728515625,
-0.33549514412879944,
-0.19819718599319458,
-0.0957472175359726,
-0.42429298162460327,
0.6155803799629211,
0.29214686155319214,
0.5263509154319763,
0.036345191299915314,
0.11445126682519913,
0.5966634750366211,
-0.670732855796814,
0.675613284111023,
-0.07822836935520172,
-0.6904293298721313,
0.40123626589775085,
-0.057813048362731934,
-0.1680128574371338,
0.3017118275165558,
0.2042541205883026,
-0.5570412278175354,
-0.3762747049331665,
-0.5007105469703674,
-1.0021369457244873,
0.6045973896980286,
0.020301049575209618,
0.09376506507396698,
0.13764114677906036,
0.26601964235305786,
0.2900899052619934,
-0.06953727453947067,
-0.43907010555267334,
-0.2734973132610321,
0.3700309097766876,
0.0014265654608607292,
0.11537956446409225,
-0.1617467850446701,
-0.21494761109352112,
-0.13592718541622162,
0.8503509163856506,
0.06730461120605469,
-0.10176025331020355,
-0.020695172250270844,
-0.38897061347961426,
-0.1154920756816864,
0.6048761010169983,
0.30892103910446167,
1.1090061664581299,
-0.34526732563972473,
0.08384387940168381,
0.22445262968540192,
-0.49752748012542725,
0.07622906565666199,
-0.06666716188192368,
0.1371716558933258,
0.020128261297941208,
0.5361620187759399,
0.6141582131385803,
0.3124152719974518,
-1.0851141214370728,
0.49762746691703796,
-0.02811349555850029,
-0.1422901600599289,
-0.3405214846134186,
0.34450477361679077,
-0.03603460639715195,
0.18441325426101685,
0.5559847950935364,
-0.024576319381594658,
0.038636285811662674,
-0.30150964856147766,
0.4124584197998047,
0.6078786849975586,
-0.03250332921743393,
-0.20009064674377441,
0.3659423887729645,
-0.03276576101779938,
-0.8234604597091675,
0.20977038145065308,
-0.23609551787376404,
-0.6186876893043518,
0.5431416630744934,
0.5170379877090454,
0.9525114297866821,
-0.20590204000473022,
0.20762772858142853,
0.3248610496520996,
0.18153847754001617,
-0.09439972788095474,
0.04141566902399063,
0.12363918870687485,
-0.5107596516609192,
-0.8816381096839905,
-0.9355067610740662,
-0.7090404629707336,
0.4711155593395233,
-0.9302651286125183,
0.21066731214523315,
-0.055872559547424316,
-0.018562383949756622,
-0.12402234226465225,
0.1357518434524536,
-0.8535135984420776,
0.06985340267419815,
-0.22277803719043732,
0.863806962966919,
-0.5924400091171265,
0.8650444149971008,
0.8858928680419922,
-0.20997528731822968,
-0.5502259731292725,
-0.2358063906431198,
-0.24594365060329437,
-0.968113124370575,
0.9901662468910217,
-0.052414149045944214,
-0.2621486485004425,
-0.0931694284081459,
-0.14655163884162903,
-0.740085244178772,
0.9312002062797546,
-0.06331117451190948,
-0.42855218052864075,
0.36159586906433105,
0.12923891842365265,
0.5514802932739258,
-0.43655091524124146,
0.33139732480049133,
0.678098738193512,
0.6270070672035217,
-0.12109058350324631,
-1.144546627998352,
-0.14065931737422943,
-0.22726815938949585,
0.10032075643539429,
0.21364279091358185,
-0.0869634598493576,
0.5357454419136047,
-0.2978852689266205,
-0.1781398355960846,
0.11833467334508896,
0.318911612033844,
0.3741087317466736,
0.24009132385253906,
0.45704200863838196,
0.7686603665351868,
0.470059871673584,
0.058035269379615784,
1.081192970275879,
-0.3540785610675812,
0.7264644503593445,
1.0529667139053345,
-0.6242817044258118,
1.099186897277832,
0.27946120500564575,
-0.46748417615890503,
0.2723272442817688,
0.16501006484031677,
0.08210820704698563,
0.15420086681842804,
0.3064269423484802,
-0.1981610506772995,
-0.35549435019493103,
-0.007958775386214256,
-0.22205409407615662,
0.3753930926322937,
0.501720666885376,
0.04970839247107506,
-0.5497377514839172,
0.24607384204864502,
-0.14185482263565063,
0.1977972388267517,
-0.23095285892486572,
0.636206865310669,
0.2421848177909851,
-0.759366512298584,
0.7643376588821411,
-0.011991099454462528,
0.7667896151542664,
-0.7136653661727905,
-0.2877850830554962,
-0.1440383940935135,
0.3267972469329834,
-0.2533194422721863,
-1.1218870878219604,
0.2846270203590393,
0.2829515337944031,
0.0091169448569417,
-0.35381466150283813,
1.0555521249771118,
-0.3411049246788025,
-0.26732137799263,
0.6089574098587036,
0.6480699777603149,
0.24434681236743927,
-0.10658246278762817,
-0.9916616082191467,
0.4605531394481659,
-0.19024977087974548,
-0.7038880586624146,
0.59528648853302,
0.14666156470775604,
0.14883539080619812,
0.8932811617851257,
0.6230334639549255,
0.3101353347301483,
-0.21795517206192017,
0.33265817165374756,
0.6733989715576172,
-0.5215833187103271,
0.0867123082280159,
-0.7969356179237366,
0.45423033833503723,
0.24587877094745636,
-0.14865174889564514,
0.8580878973007202,
0.6564599275588989,
0.6311537027359009,
-0.013378314673900604,
0.9049208164215088,
-0.16307778656482697,
0.7701662182807922,
-0.3703615665435791,
0.7421057820320129,
-0.6839010715484619,
0.3479050099849701,
-0.1802062839269638,
-1.1811476945877075,
-0.3915904462337494,
0.6959241032600403,
-0.14979803562164307,
0.05851458013057709,
0.7615054845809937,
0.8920965194702148,
-0.09754425287246704,
-0.17798377573490143,
0.40107837319374084,
0.05434408411383629,
0.3259446918964386,
0.27287763357162476,
1.0103206634521484,
-0.15855836868286133,
0.43770694732666016,
-0.25015774369239807,
-0.137641042470932,
-0.23064443469047546,
-1.0376266241073608,
-0.9055538773536682,
-0.5946553349494934,
-0.2837142050266266,
-0.5010393261909485,
0.10186824202537537,
1.0089987516403198,
0.47253283858299255,
-0.5851672291755676,
-0.3789516091346741,
0.34178799390792847,
0.2663561701774597,
-0.1707151234149933,
-0.32319268584251404,
0.48040926456451416,
-0.7125689387321472,
-0.6142411828041077,
0.6608211398124695,
0.5263068079948425,
-0.6196632981300354,
-0.4809175431728363,
-0.2263602614402771,
-0.10178929567337036,
-0.09232138097286224,
0.6570072174072266,
0.2908472716808319,
-0.850598931312561,
-0.2396283596754074,
-0.08843091130256653,
0.05269363522529602,
0.023272888734936714,
0.8179900646209717,
-0.83836829662323,
0.3269718587398529,
0.39139309525489807,
0.9144691228866577,
0.28950387239456177,
-0.010612774640321732,
0.41848739981651306,
-0.5888774991035461,
-0.26895809173583984,
0.4990901052951813,
0.4152090847492218,
0.22947315871715546,
-0.03714030608534813,
0.757166862487793,
-0.09334056079387665,
-0.9035194516181946,
-1.2000433206558228,
-0.011651619337499142,
-0.9410209059715271,
-0.33891233801841736,
1.5994704961776733,
-0.29039591550827026,
-0.25567808747291565,
-0.24171596765518188,
-0.1158306747674942,
-0.3314904570579529,
-0.15147154033184052,
0.548865020275116,
0.6192117929458618,
-0.04616386443376541,
0.031700097024440765,
-0.8843470215797424,
0.46141257882118225,
0.3122285306453705,
-0.7458049654960632,
0.41560104489326477,
0.38112950325012207,
0.6017731428146362,
0.10271835327148438,
0.4905516505241394,
0.11375481635332108,
0.18849501013755798,
-0.434166818857193,
0.2910906970500946,
-0.08364953100681305,
-0.45685866475105286,
-0.45389795303344727,
0.10807628184556961,
0.10317131876945496,
0.3537837564945221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11678v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11678v1 | TourRank: Utilizing Large Language Models for Documents Ranking with a Tournament-Inspired Strategy | 2024-06-17T15:58:22 | 2024-06-17T15:58:22 | Yiqun Chen, Qi Liu, Yi Zhang, Weiwei Sun, Daiting Shi, Jiaxin Mao, Dawei Yin | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly employed in zero-shot documents
ranking, yielding commendable results. However, several significant challenges
still persist in LLMs for ranking: (1) LLMs are constrained by limited input
length, precluding them from processing a large number of documents
simultaneously; (2) The output document sequence is influenced by the input
order of documents, resulting in inconsistent ranking outcomes; (3) Achieving a
balance between cost and ranking performance is quite challenging. To tackle
these issues, we introduce a novel documents ranking method called TourRank,
which is inspired by the tournament mechanism. This approach alleviates the
impact of LLM's limited input length through intelligent grouping, while the
tournament-like points system ensures robust ranking, mitigating the influence
of the document input sequence. We test TourRank with different LLMs on the
TREC DL datasets and the BEIR benchmark. Experimental results show that
TourRank achieves state-of-the-art performance at a reasonable cost. | [
-0.2549724280834198,
-0.8049052357673645,
0.6593680381774902,
0.05059509724378586,
-0.1986066997051239,
0.4810727834701538,
-0.399381548166275,
-0.3725477159023285,
0.2763236463069916,
0.35770756006240845,
-0.4276483356952667,
-0.8365296125411987,
-0.9457598924636841,
0.16513673961162567,
-0.428237646818161,
0.8821765780448914,
0.12224774062633514,
0.013541970402002335,
-0.23476523160934448,
-0.17504681646823883,
-0.2717568874359131,
-0.5213363766670227,
-0.6771078109741211,
-0.41849586367607117,
0.9441996812820435,
0.4701031744480133,
0.5789047479629517,
0.7075892686843872,
0.9980025291442871,
0.34819379448890686,
-0.06896371394395828,
0.2764856219291687,
-0.9409417510032654,
0.4178503751754761,
0.05611831322312355,
-0.6111843585968018,
-0.35506439208984375,
0.056807707995176315,
0.9083653688430786,
0.6364720463752747,
-0.08978581428527832,
0.02574414573609829,
0.07491137087345123,
0.4147659242153168,
-0.42805400490760803,
0.19853800535202026,
-0.7262908220291138,
-0.13785310089588165,
-0.7160833477973938,
-0.579017698764801,
-0.7631469964981079,
-0.5508135557174683,
-0.10935414582490921,
-0.34823837876319885,
0.09672638028860092,
0.14312586188316345,
0.8321424722671509,
-0.03925653174519539,
-0.286917507648468,
-0.23670285940170288,
-0.6415813565254211,
0.5699106454849243,
-0.5327811241149902,
0.26677948236465454,
0.05207139626145363,
0.3877076208591461,
-0.2208067625761032,
-0.3913780748844147,
-0.3487866520881653,
-0.015218591317534447,
0.3933873474597931,
0.1706819385290146,
0.041675809770822525,
0.11096494644880295,
0.15476402640342712,
0.20713506639003754,
-1.0318522453308105,
0.4298970401287079,
-0.20190683007240295,
0.16293756663799286,
0.6616123914718628,
0.03916555270552635,
0.36266958713531494,
0.18578490614891052,
-0.05757683888077736,
-0.24335134029388428,
-0.7751715183258057,
0.08974522352218628,
0.4595975875854492,
0.5136294960975647,
0.40007832646369934,
0.6745752692222595,
-0.3631915748119354,
0.6879849433898926,
-0.030778858810663223,
-0.2198304533958435,
0.026752173900604248,
0.09414742141962051,
-0.12136993557214737,
0.2878979444503784,
0.7136976718902588,
0.4653933048248291,
0.27827274799346924,
-0.5829335451126099,
-0.32997992634773254,
-0.09414523839950562,
0.0035535329952836037,
-0.8906378149986267,
-0.13102510571479797,
-0.10860602557659149,
-0.2381085604429245,
-0.5175143480300903,
0.18831512331962585,
-0.6854815483093262,
-0.21957328915596008,
0.12143641710281372,
0.8371754884719849,
-0.34595492482185364,
0.003220881801098585,
-0.0627410039305687,
-0.18234014511108398,
0.3928039073944092,
0.5319451689720154,
-0.8360783457756042,
0.2764440178871155,
0.8459346294403076,
1.222420573234558,
-0.37326475977897644,
-0.37495166063308716,
-0.8692871332168579,
0.28199151158332825,
-0.4207150936126709,
1.1010105609893799,
-0.8847163319587708,
-0.8436779379844666,
0.1389714479446411,
-0.3032093048095703,
-0.21918514370918274,
-0.5347509980201721,
0.48931989073753357,
-0.7792494297027588,
0.15777020156383514,
-0.1633874922990799,
-0.8437292575836182,
0.08100152760744095,
0.36266571283340454,
-0.5251086354255676,
1.089504361152649,
-0.04721589386463165,
-0.38249915838241577,
0.2500710189342499,
-0.6491255164146423,
-0.5939644575119019,
0.49518200755119324,
-0.07468779385089874,
-0.3186229169368744,
0.18142378330230713,
0.08178791403770447,
0.23337703943252563,
-0.24517366290092468,
0.2240031659603119,
-0.5278847813606262,
-0.7386080026626587,
-0.11108488589525223,
-0.3777676820755005,
0.582826554775238,
0.07293210923671722,
-0.068484365940094,
0.10466035455465317,
-0.39719435572624207,
-0.02826107293367386,
0.28715813159942627,
-0.5025084018707275,
-0.45506566762924194,
-0.0732451006770134,
-0.2021159678697586,
0.13179631531238556,
0.22317908704280853,
-0.5711319446563721,
0.8161051273345947,
-0.5197604894638062,
0.2844369113445282,
0.9051717519760132,
0.1393599510192871,
0.5548198223114014,
-0.4572138786315918,
0.5649401545524597,
-0.3968636095523834,
0.13355331122875214,
0.060159582644701004,
-0.544049084186554,
-0.7883976697921753,
-0.0902940183877945,
0.642196536064148,
0.2746818959712982,
-0.5590598583221436,
0.2900847792625427,
-0.7829033732414246,
-0.7352672219276428,
-0.47394394874572754,
0.1462036520242691,
0.10695794224739075,
0.20527727901935577,
0.06699245423078537,
-0.2404199242591858,
-0.07496125996112823,
-0.6126028299331665,
-0.11022577434778214,
-0.20803698897361755,
0.052034471184015274,
0.3106479346752167,
0.27525264024734497,
0.1946432888507843,
0.5452444553375244,
-0.723507821559906,
-0.5256787538528442,
-0.4417955279350281,
0.3045252859592438,
0.21214601397514343,
0.21977439522743225,
0.41973525285720825,
-0.5258453488349915,
-0.35625341534614563,
-0.29416465759277344,
-0.5143733620643616,
-0.14417053759098053,
0.24726329743862152,
-0.18631042540073395,
0.4561617374420166,
0.5645885467529297,
-0.40241116285324097,
0.2124161273241043,
0.41987159848213196,
-0.036405373364686966,
0.2135503739118576,
-0.25843778252601624,
0.3163718283176422,
-0.8393846154212952,
-0.309139221906662,
0.05620673671364784,
-0.25469720363616943,
-0.13595452904701233,
0.28312811255455017,
-0.19521179795265198,
-0.32051515579223633,
-0.22529727220535278,
0.5683374404907227,
-0.137393057346344,
0.09772804379463196,
-0.26166200637817383,
0.4495648443698883,
0.0007184722926467657,
0.474515438079834,
0.05478186532855034,
0.678509533405304,
0.40100255608558655,
-0.33286353945732117,
0.21484839916229248,
0.13207374513149261,
-0.3124871551990509,
0.5422013401985168,
-0.5207237005233765,
0.02672802098095417,
0.011376303620636463,
0.3407779932022095,
-1.1345208883285522,
0.1097898855805397,
-0.316319078207016,
-0.4489290416240692,
0.6557066440582275,
-0.34988510608673096,
-0.7822535037994385,
-0.3467506170272827,
-0.5133094787597656,
0.3422074317932129,
0.3400249779224396,
-0.5008707046508789,
0.3426365554332733,
0.46364277601242065,
-0.377348929643631,
-0.14696022868156433,
-0.2940920889377594,
0.39645853638648987,
-0.2320350706577301,
-0.775708794593811,
0.4558870196342468,
-0.28086960315704346,
-0.002016994636505842,
-0.20756272971630096,
-0.07894724607467651,
0.33865833282470703,
0.12508587539196014,
0.24232928454875946,
0.16106745600700378,
-0.1720954328775406,
0.22922517359256744,
-0.10408314317464828,
-0.07637351006269455,
-0.20179149508476257,
-0.43519315123558044,
0.7660932540893555,
-0.02622743882238865,
-0.352765828371048,
-0.06997736543416977,
0.4098399877548218,
0.5523468255996704,
-0.5064661502838135,
0.6568549871444702,
0.17998726665973663,
-0.20373384654521942,
-0.44753578305244446,
-0.6545847654342651,
-0.022411564365029335,
-0.4717857539653778,
0.19125735759735107,
-0.49387484788894653,
-1.0102148056030273,
0.36710426211357117,
-0.2609219253063202,
0.09569696336984634,
0.5381799936294556,
0.5542863011360168,
-0.26329225301742554,
1.1013420820236206,
0.6750691533088684,
-0.3209854066371918,
0.4537895619869232,
-0.41835644841194153,
0.3361802399158478,
-0.617658257484436,
-0.2890251576900482,
-0.935976505279541,
-0.5897607207298279,
-0.9363526105880737,
-0.4206657111644745,
0.541141152381897,
-0.08340547233819962,
-0.17804567515850067,
0.19409692287445068,
-0.37869399785995483,
0.6474034190177917,
0.9406554102897644,
0.06769532710313797,
0.5108830332756042,
-0.05655433610081673,
-0.34473323822021484,
0.23491992056369781,
-0.7601177096366882,
-0.2656068205833435,
1.1456750631332397,
-0.029550300911068916,
0.8208460211753845,
0.4998476803302765,
1.2212311029434204,
0.5498184561729431,
0.04989233613014221,
-0.9252976775169373,
0.7972384095191956,
-0.24397188425064087,
-0.1859935224056244,
-0.6048405170440674,
-0.43061190843582153,
-0.9389082193374634,
0.15469223260879517,
-0.09077335894107819,
-0.7825416326522827,
-0.12206634879112244,
-0.5523033738136292,
-0.17980331182479858,
0.326621949672699,
-0.3502178490161896,
0.5746077299118042,
-0.19792859256267548,
-0.4038705825805664,
-0.10122710466384888,
-0.37384697794914246,
0.2364051640033722,
0.000284479494439438,
0.056932222098112106,
0.07070101052522659,
0.25644057989120483,
0.9540857076644897,
-0.47138217091560364,
0.2455611526966095,
0.013049541041254997,
0.0586075596511364,
-0.03372073173522949,
0.42977026104927063,
0.6289675831794739,
0.057752832770347595,
-0.3669758439064026,
0.14970573782920837,
-0.16082227230072021,
-0.33389580249786377,
-0.6173149347305298,
1.283634901046753,
-0.8236002326011658,
-0.9645253419876099,
-0.5905545353889465,
-0.4887630343437195,
-0.23655247688293457,
0.5419902801513672,
0.24925565719604492,
0.7001824975013733,
-0.15560594201087952,
0.3876159191131592,
0.8780077695846558,
-0.02994970977306366,
0.6875513195991516,
0.5460562705993652,
-0.3026953935623169,
-0.22506657242774963,
1.1377915143966675,
0.48656901717185974,
0.07581216841936111,
0.7750511765480042,
0.14673075079917908,
-0.4802497327327728,
-0.9486759901046753,
-0.28643569350242615,
0.24836397171020508,
-0.5131354928016663,
-0.2307634800672531,
-0.6210530400276184,
-0.42082589864730835,
-0.6625438928604126,
-0.3832594156265259,
-0.16959203779697418,
-0.5206426382064819,
0.14892706274986267,
-0.240987628698349,
0.11375249177217484,
0.7807568907737732,
0.16855289041996002,
0.10052938759326935,
-0.5991095900535583,
0.06934783607721329,
0.17047424614429474,
0.7035983800888062,
-0.03447377309203148,
-0.6103378534317017,
-0.19974637031555176,
-0.4516633152961731,
-0.4363258183002472,
-0.6543058156967163,
0.2156924456357956,
0.0960025042295456,
0.7658095955848694,
0.5144711136817932,
0.1812453269958496,
0.5414624214172363,
-0.6722455620765686,
0.5965398550033569,
-0.21301144361495972,
-0.6170774102210999,
0.6094229221343994,
-0.6115850806236267,
0.38548532128334045,
0.7261441349983215,
0.1642056554555893,
-0.4159717857837677,
-0.7229284048080444,
-0.6552029252052307,
-0.7147170901298523,
0.6573235392570496,
0.1395363062620163,
-0.06860410422086716,
-0.08586114645004272,
0.0463784784078598,
-0.16394007205963135,
-0.014398960396647453,
-0.5791552662849426,
-0.11518498510122299,
0.21242943406105042,
-0.2880632281303406,
-0.2433186173439026,
-0.32408806681632996,
-0.0014102186542004347,
0.09861879795789719,
0.8886260986328125,
0.11626356095075607,
-0.015047059394419193,
0.03168977424502373,
-0.23275336623191833,
-0.225570946931839,
0.07950058579444885,
0.7007543444633484,
0.41438376903533936,
-0.44729018211364746,
-0.004405816551297903,
-0.16723139584064484,
-0.1959444284439087,
0.21589896082878113,
0.060321737080812454,
-0.4893428087234497,
0.035798925906419754,
0.3959534764289856,
0.3313431143760681,
0.317338228225708,
-0.4833236634731293,
0.5368809103965759,
-0.10167479515075684,
-0.24258185923099518,
0.1436207890510559,
0.13730353116989136,
0.11492472887039185,
0.18828131258487701,
0.4437221884727478,
-0.30080440640449524,
0.20156604051589966,
-0.36805105209350586,
0.17547842860221863,
0.618018388748169,
-0.37413254380226135,
0.06973472237586975,
0.6100282669067383,
0.48556768894195557,
-0.6456940770149231,
0.5868579745292664,
-0.2080787718296051,
-0.4668178856372833,
0.3917674422264099,
0.2812146246433258,
0.6912196278572083,
-0.1280478686094284,
0.4715193212032318,
0.16612429916858673,
0.41985610127449036,
-0.28015434741973877,
-0.09844715893268585,
0.045722126960754395,
-0.41357889771461487,
-0.15963256359100342,
-0.843148946762085,
-0.5122901201248169,
-0.0005122325383126736,
-0.35944586992263794,
0.5047973990440369,
-0.29446449875831604,
0.001926179975271225,
-0.12967851758003235,
0.4978180229663849,
-0.5542532801628113,
-0.033725637942552567,
0.3443320095539093,
1.1074697971343994,
-0.5333933234214783,
0.7999563813209534,
0.288316011428833,
-0.5277107357978821,
-0.6857847571372986,
0.09793619811534882,
0.14015784859657288,
-0.6928284764289856,
0.5406509637832642,
0.22251197695732117,
-0.2118292897939682,
0.3423265218734741,
-0.2570560574531555,
-0.8896413445472717,
1.0805736780166626,
0.13571347296237946,
-0.611633837223053,
-0.3232966363430023,
0.18034711480140686,
0.30365458130836487,
-0.1773170530796051,
0.30704477429389954,
0.14341746270656586,
0.4484501779079437,
0.45214375853538513,
-0.669239342212677,
-0.22513091564178467,
-0.10175174474716187,
0.04414515197277069,
0.4376625716686249,
-0.9135659337043762,
0.36167702078819275,
-0.14445693790912628,
-0.14284536242485046,
0.07568686455488205,
0.5042113661766052,
0.2987354099750519,
0.2679848372936249,
0.3333519399166107,
0.7703341245651245,
0.8396651148796082,
-0.3590551018714905,
0.9416274428367615,
-0.2191510796546936,
0.4165063798427582,
1.0737406015396118,
-0.7372465133666992,
0.9351591467857361,
0.031714145094156265,
-0.014624975621700287,
0.49873921275138855,
0.6980739235877991,
-0.21014271676540375,
0.6300938129425049,
0.4781947731971741,
-0.12042679637670517,
-0.45370563864707947,
-0.3047351837158203,
-0.23640112578868866,
0.8519238829612732,
-0.009893565438687801,
-0.15839163959026337,
-0.6800273060798645,
-0.13867615163326263,
-0.03814387694001198,
0.057873886078596115,
-0.34539592266082764,
0.9872955083847046,
-0.15914852917194366,
-0.6481661200523376,
0.24086138606071472,
0.1833718717098236,
0.5863363742828369,
-0.7414844036102295,
-0.021278217434883118,
-0.45162850618362427,
0.07729041576385498,
0.367813378572464,
-0.7083883285522461,
-0.29907554388046265,
0.004067596048116684,
-0.13574820756912231,
-0.42694807052612305,
0.5716679096221924,
-0.4629073739051819,
-0.9198336005210876,
0.2302016317844391,
0.3999917507171631,
0.10488791018724442,
-0.11060014367103577,
-0.28987565636634827,
0.2300708144903183,
-0.3936939537525177,
-0.24461451172828674,
0.6913977861404419,
0.5777630805969238,
-0.1626468002796173,
0.6806631088256836,
0.5410560369491577,
0.15383556485176086,
-0.1629866361618042,
0.34927040338516235,
0.6317684650421143,
-0.5151965618133545,
-0.4841412901878357,
-0.9382895231246948,
-0.15427732467651367,
-0.15601769089698792,
0.010565240867435932,
0.7116966247558594,
0.9118014574050903,
0.9043712019920349,
0.34324178099632263,
0.6147664189338684,
0.43239644169807434,
0.13966849446296692,
-0.436689168214798,
0.9183699488639832,
-0.6236974596977234,
0.20125579833984375,
-0.3223145306110382,
-1.0225615501403809,
-0.5473823547363281,
0.1819763332605362,
-0.31128716468811035,
-0.05563120171427727,
0.5258710980415344,
0.7662807106971741,
0.24851398169994354,
-0.18727126717567444,
0.5760329365730286,
0.17721359431743622,
0.7149981260299683,
0.7080052495002747,
0.41646796464920044,
-0.2115018665790558,
0.9286079406738281,
0.0424196794629097,
-0.20975452661514282,
-0.556903064250946,
-0.8177230358123779,
-0.8157980442047119,
-0.39595556259155273,
-0.30683663487434387,
-0.21059539914131165,
0.2919836640357971,
0.6794577240943909,
0.5933537483215332,
-0.47782859206199646,
-0.23685322701931,
0.2520528733730316,
0.44037753343582153,
-0.07985477149486542,
-0.25650912523269653,
0.42116284370422363,
-0.32499149441719055,
-0.9576016068458557,
0.4448445737361908,
0.774167001247406,
-0.15306362509727478,
-0.2678578794002533,
0.04040474817156792,
-0.5134890675544739,
0.2891705632209778,
0.54331374168396,
-0.048966556787490845,
-0.6428663730621338,
-0.2563084661960602,
0.26270952820777893,
-0.2957864999771118,
-0.047240789979696274,
0.6809688210487366,
-0.6201511025428772,
0.3844848871231079,
0.5501875281333923,
0.6285939812660217,
0.43260011076927185,
-0.015036155469715595,
0.49775514006614685,
-0.5271158218383789,
-0.4490593671798706,
0.14214912056922913,
0.3514295518398285,
0.18351426720619202,
-0.28111663460731506,
0.6298108696937561,
0.2372458577156067,
-0.6244011521339417,
-0.9536565542221069,
-0.10563574731349945,
-1.2183237075805664,
-0.21125845611095428,
1.1538339853286743,
0.01281383540481329,
0.0380975715816021,
0.29859113693237305,
0.03562006726861,
0.18317650258541107,
-0.521077036857605,
0.9989238381385803,
0.9834648966789246,
0.0372040718793869,
-0.10600084811449051,
-0.21518032252788544,
0.09360579401254654,
0.014689430594444275,
-0.5150526165962219,
-0.0640733614563942,
0.310564249753952,
0.20665228366851807,
0.11391191929578781,
0.5832887887954712,
-0.1898341327905655,
-0.12671081721782684,
-0.32085201144218445,
-0.24814653396606445,
-0.2693561017513275,
-0.6236881613731384,
-0.09173696488142014,
0.6364665627479553,
0.3132490813732147,
0.013125751167535782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11675v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11675v2 | BLoB: Bayesian Low-Rank Adaptation by Backpropagation for Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T15:55:38 | 2024-06-18T15:15:04 | Yibin Wang, Haizhou Shi, Ligong Han, Dimitris Metaxas, Hao Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML | Large Language Models (LLMs) often suffer from overconfidence during
inference, particularly when adapted to downstream domain-specific tasks with
limited data. Previous work addresses this issue by employing approximate
Bayesian estimation after the LLMs are trained, enabling them to quantify
uncertainty. However, such post-training approaches' performance is severely
limited by the parameters learned during training. In this paper, we go beyond
post-training Bayesianization and propose Bayesian Low-Rank Adaptation by
Backpropagation (BLoB), an algorithm that continuously and jointly adjusts both
the mean and covariance of LLM parameters throughout the whole fine-tuning
process. Our empirical results verify the effectiveness of BLoB in terms of
generalization and uncertainty estimation, when evaluated on both
in-distribution and out-of-distribution data. | [
-0.21854332089424133,
-0.8065008521080017,
0.605166494846344,
0.1843709647655487,
-0.15118175745010376,
0.07624892890453339,
-0.5461210608482361,
-0.13715068995952606,
-0.1321413516998291,
0.44218528270721436,
-0.4685071110725403,
-0.7467128038406372,
-1.0091636180877686,
-0.4007132351398468,
0.0662817656993866,
0.9276402592658997,
0.2548321485519409,
-0.00029545454890467227,
-0.005063832737505436,
-0.06709901243448257,
-0.5272703170776367,
-0.3229486644268036,
-0.5765630602836609,
-0.20027905702590942,
0.601302444934845,
0.4593663215637207,
0.9635843634605408,
0.1598496437072754,
0.4105624258518219,
0.07958916574716568,
0.10527174919843674,
0.048413053154945374,
-0.7382862567901611,
0.08938948810100555,
-0.6492804288864136,
-0.6476700901985168,
-0.43888354301452637,
-0.10620424151420593,
1.0406622886657715,
1.1229747533798218,
-0.25937530398368835,
0.2695375382900238,
0.04157666862010956,
0.6869401931762695,
-1.149279236793518,
0.1329343467950821,
-0.8816317319869995,
-0.25073376297950745,
0.1799720823764801,
0.011050504632294178,
-0.49934887886047363,
-0.5360656976699829,
-0.046483226120471954,
-0.44338279962539673,
0.02347433753311634,
0.1867842972278595,
0.6638598442077637,
0.6120287179946899,
-0.12629051506519318,
-0.17583361268043518,
-0.722851037979126,
0.8621272444725037,
-0.8406034708023071,
0.6445110440254211,
0.49241647124290466,
0.2418418824672699,
-0.5918448567390442,
-0.15273500978946686,
-0.3492865264415741,
-0.13029859960079193,
0.10976976156234741,
0.2871050536632538,
-0.20534636080265045,
0.1656493842601776,
0.13602383434772491,
0.1256803721189499,
-0.6550285816192627,
0.5031304955482483,
-0.1350354254245758,
0.041714444756507874,
0.6690660715103149,
-0.3067448139190674,
-0.15662285685539246,
0.3658522367477417,
-0.044850945472717285,
-0.2696016728878021,
-0.6496023535728455,
0.01974610984325409,
0.23946145176887512,
0.2967856228351593,
-0.19304370880126953,
0.3793843686580658,
-0.2532127797603607,
0.8081056475639343,
0.21152348816394806,
-0.07247874140739441,
0.06754333525896072,
0.2103903889656067,
-0.21200722455978394,
0.20384958386421204,
0.3118477463722229,
0.20856355130672455,
0.1601373255252838,
-0.21271078288555145,
-0.09246406704187393,
-0.20741164684295654,
0.16614004969596863,
-0.7181089520454407,
-0.26733407378196716,
0.38304513692855835,
-0.3691703677177429,
0.057906635105609894,
-0.09643790870904922,
-0.9085146188735962,
-0.3420586884021759,
0.12182850390672684,
0.915789008140564,
-0.06507501006126404,
-0.08355643600225449,
0.07999689877033234,
-0.011659682728350163,
0.16229596734046936,
0.4379623532295227,
-1.0348705053329468,
0.3613402247428894,
0.6668663024902344,
0.9191834926605225,
-0.29807138442993164,
-0.4976314306259155,
-0.8008167743682861,
0.5212620496749878,
-0.688087522983551,
0.6128526329994202,
-0.5464991927146912,
-0.2706963121891022,
-0.20853155851364136,
0.08986324071884155,
-0.3825703263282776,
-0.5497714877128601,
0.10949872434139252,
-0.4644330143928528,
-0.2056136578321457,
0.27858155965805054,
-0.5974342226982117,
-0.17750203609466553,
0.0211434755474329,
-0.24716408550739288,
0.8662279844284058,
0.28368741273880005,
-0.43594539165496826,
0.5278791189193726,
-0.2988455891609192,
-0.16611209511756897,
-0.09086199104785919,
0.19202840328216553,
-0.6949641108512878,
0.5680932402610779,
0.29916268587112427,
0.630812406539917,
-0.2930643856525421,
0.20338928699493408,
-0.8426659107208252,
-0.44546085596084595,
0.22084420919418335,
-0.15006090700626373,
0.4769704043865204,
-0.13027305901050568,
0.06898313760757446,
-0.013086056336760521,
-0.7714536786079407,
-0.05065566673874855,
-0.28368067741394043,
-0.3176247775554657,
-0.48104360699653625,
0.08553237468004227,
-0.4703871011734009,
0.07011519372463226,
0.36500078439712524,
-0.5073278546333313,
0.45652875304222107,
-0.4776969254016876,
0.07945764064788818,
0.6388373374938965,
0.14773045480251312,
0.5771929025650024,
-0.25324925780296326,
0.3183562755584717,
-0.19020046293735504,
0.01582249440252781,
0.23544543981552124,
-0.5067830085754395,
-0.5853720903396606,
-0.33054760098457336,
0.47146502137184143,
0.5814716219902039,
-0.35528165102005005,
0.6684905886650085,
-0.5960806608200073,
-0.7182145118713379,
-0.5106115341186523,
0.28539761900901794,
0.22198604047298431,
0.15505890548229218,
0.5894436836242676,
-0.36865949630737305,
-0.09609675407409668,
-0.612699031829834,
-0.05124739930033684,
-0.30232223868370056,
-0.223672553896904,
0.10621443390846252,
0.6191886067390442,
-0.24434621632099152,
0.5853474736213684,
-0.6402075886726379,
-0.09514819830656052,
-0.15458820760250092,
0.36583638191223145,
0.32204222679138184,
0.5791949033737183,
0.3470744788646698,
-0.3637356758117676,
-0.25768524408340454,
-0.0023510518949478865,
-0.3738758862018585,
-0.2444571852684021,
-0.25462159514427185,
-0.3008381128311157,
0.4336388409137726,
0.5420109629631042,
-0.39226073026657104,
0.4050343930721283,
1.2363803386688232,
-0.07400359958410263,
0.3935900628566742,
-0.6449780464172363,
-0.16861331462860107,
-0.9272661209106445,
-0.04594944044947624,
-0.059737998992204666,
-0.19683171808719635,
-0.27663949131965637,
0.0036347429268062115,
0.011077840812504292,
-0.19146254658699036,
0.11128434538841248,
0.7765798568725586,
-0.5075581669807434,
-0.5459496378898621,
-0.3977976143360138,
-0.016136199235916138,
-0.2131454050540924,
0.6546304821968079,
0.15861876308918,
0.4924922585487366,
0.5983264446258545,
-0.414913147687912,
0.22243425250053406,
0.21980199217796326,
-0.33016344904899597,
0.5154926180839539,
-0.3060174286365509,
0.030933115631341934,
-0.033298615366220474,
0.39712637662887573,
-1.1963660717010498,
-0.21306027472019196,
0.17233490943908691,
-0.3277014195919037,
0.4532148838043213,
-0.8124036192893982,
-0.34029221534729004,
-0.0326489582657814,
-0.08986459672451019,
0.06810010969638824,
0.6142637133598328,
-0.5494275093078613,
0.3382391631603241,
0.28070539236068726,
-0.5353564620018005,
-0.31929370760917664,
-0.7251682877540588,
0.029615823179483414,
0.022187575697898865,
-0.2753894329071045,
0.3450961709022522,
-0.11895257234573364,
0.08714835345745087,
-0.20137706398963928,
-0.23236243426799774,
-0.26374176144599915,
0.2033633440732956,
0.4037300944328308,
-0.10813841968774796,
-0.32349687814712524,
0.17799119651317596,
0.6631525158882141,
0.025112075731158257,
-0.12494594603776932,
-0.2812909185886383,
0.28052762150764465,
0.23807963728904724,
-0.38244757056236267,
-0.2411673665046692,
0.26401466131210327,
0.3345712125301361,
0.13361580669879913,
1.0035529136657715,
0.5400631427764893,
-0.26598840951919556,
-0.574856162071228,
-0.5332179665565491,
-0.18913623690605164,
-0.3771386444568634,
0.48233917355537415,
-0.3071124851703644,
-0.7041516900062561,
0.44848066568374634,
-0.22555910050868988,
-0.27629193663597107,
-0.027524299919605255,
0.7407851219177246,
-0.21177402138710022,
0.757283627986908,
0.8378487229347229,
-0.14505773782730103,
0.41559872031211853,
-0.017472781240940094,
-0.016396906226873398,
-0.6951676607131958,
0.13513235747814178,
-0.41835877299308777,
-0.3377994894981384,
-0.9220151305198669,
-0.41395750641822815,
0.29686376452445984,
0.4303753674030304,
-0.23366707563400269,
0.0026080464012920856,
-0.04012465476989746,
0.07866791635751724,
0.522933304309845,
0.381701797246933,
0.15359358489513397,
-0.02881012298166752,
0.32444214820861816,
0.11451065540313721,
-0.7675266861915588,
-0.0240302886813879,
1.0722624063491821,
0.372310608625412,
0.9740243554115295,
0.3273584544658661,
0.6803723573684692,
0.1179797425866127,
0.37605395913124084,
-0.824470579624176,
0.16333797574043274,
-0.3592982888221741,
-0.5585519075393677,
-0.6770381331443787,
-0.40611085295677185,
-0.9319966435432434,
0.2886057198047638,
-0.26696714758872986,
-1.101866364479065,
0.5855569243431091,
0.36112672090530396,
-0.40863707661628723,
-0.02980431728065014,
-0.7598233222961426,
1.0068976879119873,
-0.059507325291633606,
-0.5323601961135864,
-0.4533625543117523,
-0.6729843020439148,
-0.013924225233495235,
-0.4391711950302124,
0.23037473857402802,
-0.11013311892747879,
-0.17389214038848877,
0.5919622778892517,
-0.18136067688465118,
0.8399430513381958,
-0.39737817645072937,
-0.11945907026529312,
-0.08494329452514648,
0.11343750357627869,
0.6956939101219177,
0.12124428153038025,
-0.25631386041641235,
0.35467350482940674,
0.13859525322914124,
-0.8120474219322205,
-0.8779765963554382,
0.5008512735366821,
-0.7266151905059814,
-0.6774420142173767,
-0.3149695098400116,
-0.8335953950881958,
-0.6489603519439697,
0.06290242820978165,
0.09841027855873108,
0.042755480855703354,
0.026951763778924942,
0.3596971333026886,
0.44767922163009644,
-0.5351037979125977,
0.47660258412361145,
0.37366098165512085,
-0.03781859949231148,
-0.31961143016815186,
0.8204930424690247,
0.31682515144348145,
0.5547005534172058,
0.6053162217140198,
0.36353468894958496,
-0.22549442946910858,
-1.1783292293548584,
-0.39836281538009644,
0.2800356447696686,
-0.43612807989120483,
-0.022017179057002068,
-0.22181165218353271,
-0.17703621089458466,
-0.3944278657436371,
-0.42535072565078735,
-0.4349867105484009,
-0.3337882161140442,
-0.013705695047974586,
0.20823214948177338,
0.32768410444259644,
0.32890042662620544,
-0.14778386056423187,
0.8521467447280884,
-0.7906618714332581,
0.171715646982193,
0.2707505226135254,
0.34462153911590576,
-0.28513044118881226,
-1.0638893842697144,
-0.5773154497146606,
0.16802260279655457,
-0.09224678575992584,
-0.6671595573425293,
0.4549076557159424,
0.5538133382797241,
0.5837854146957397,
-0.11239387840032578,
-0.11357583105564117,
0.7486160397529602,
-0.2910853326320648,
0.4088354706764221,
-0.09072206169366837,
-0.7714803218841553,
0.49267342686653137,
-0.3807758092880249,
0.3966716527938843,
0.432210773229599,
0.4863767623901367,
-0.135236456990242,
-0.4400823712348938,
-0.35776564478874207,
-0.6609726548194885,
0.5254313349723816,
0.03691701963543892,
0.03891146555542946,
0.5683115720748901,
0.5238675475120544,
0.26177650690078735,
0.44173532724380493,
-0.42119812965393066,
0.14452269673347473,
-0.06162493675947189,
-0.24526488780975342,
-0.5169647336006165,
-0.30134984850883484,
0.15497690439224243,
-0.13351082801818848,
0.6267957091331482,
-0.3998958170413971,
0.142711341381073,
-0.18302097916603088,
-0.5745688676834106,
-0.14191806316375732,
0.3142770528793335,
0.5372048616409302,
0.9927363991737366,
-0.6797463297843933,
0.04553709179162979,
0.503235936164856,
-0.38884663581848145,
0.028233420103788376,
0.14428898692131042,
0.052854184061288834,
-0.18992887437343597,
0.43681254982948303,
0.7778601050376892,
0.43651726841926575,
-0.32951682806015015,
0.5780406594276428,
0.457638144493103,
0.08771104365587234,
-0.07504355907440186,
0.19278374314308167,
-0.028592901304364204,
0.5383328199386597,
0.46312522888183594,
-0.010556411929428577,
-0.11234436184167862,
-0.647456705570221,
0.2203652560710907,
0.2902028262615204,
-0.26995372772216797,
-0.2914433777332306,
0.3530178666114807,
-0.1345185935497284,
-0.027925120666623116,
0.021927863359451294,
-0.1624658852815628,
-0.09659469127655029,
0.2541316747665405,
0.5698277354240417,
0.6064948439598083,
-0.3981892764568329,
0.22019627690315247,
0.150339737534523,
0.21662773191928864,
-0.39977729320526123,
0.17038434743881226,
0.14371056854724884,
-0.935382068157196,
-0.6800997257232666,
-0.9148527383804321,
-0.7839155793190002,
0.07110189646482468,
-0.7046351432800293,
0.1507604420185089,
-0.6802541613578796,
-0.04085680469870567,
-0.04233723133802414,
0.11019424349069595,
-0.27492755651474,
0.3423556387424469,
0.1568770855665207,
0.6400018930435181,
-0.8855421543121338,
1.1486657857894897,
0.5653478503227234,
-0.3151080310344696,
-0.3306337296962738,
0.31505823135375977,
-0.37166357040405273,
-0.8131176233291626,
0.6282864212989807,
-0.30020925402641296,
-0.11436103284358978,
0.4251304864883423,
-0.6260284185409546,
-0.9843952059745789,
0.7625491619110107,
0.6915138959884644,
-0.6250617504119873,
-0.04535011947154999,
-0.1240265741944313,
0.5767063498497009,
-0.30348530411720276,
-0.049371831119060516,
0.5725975036621094,
0.40286311507225037,
0.035366225987672806,
-0.8896611332893372,
0.08818075060844421,
0.4020518958568573,
0.04872838407754898,
0.12482355535030365,
-0.7379112243652344,
0.6524257063865662,
-0.14647124707698822,
0.2895745038986206,
0.11767727136611938,
0.6388850808143616,
0.42236295342445374,
0.25517967343330383,
0.36484313011169434,
0.40005189180374146,
0.646710216999054,
0.04492417722940445,
0.8410497307777405,
-0.11470402777194977,
0.5096889138221741,
1.3400542736053467,
-0.12108245491981506,
1.1512024402618408,
0.4541928470134735,
-0.19141513109207153,
0.544605553150177,
0.6289232969284058,
-0.24843135476112366,
0.687760055065155,
0.15467311441898346,
0.11165320128202438,
-0.37732642889022827,
0.1842179000377655,
-0.2050875872373581,
0.36137446761131287,
0.6832402944564819,
-0.23728372156620026,
-0.1874760240316391,
-0.04149792343378067,
0.006334151141345501,
-0.12552741169929504,
-0.6190564036369324,
0.6347000002861023,
0.2259276658296585,
-0.6286592483520508,
0.9120367169380188,
-0.12661410868167877,
0.4661138355731964,
-0.28921273350715637,
0.07681084424257278,
-0.17253389954566956,
0.26964807510375977,
-0.22994475066661835,
-0.6730818748474121,
0.19642600417137146,
-0.36295318603515625,
-0.062101833522319794,
-0.03126738220453262,
0.4445250630378723,
-0.4954664707183838,
-0.7467151880264282,
0.4182635247707367,
0.5029316544532776,
0.29414278268814087,
-0.27028632164001465,
-0.674273669719696,
0.06493107229471207,
-0.40983521938323975,
-0.3826906979084015,
0.46225735545158386,
0.43507635593414307,
-0.1817343384027481,
0.8159084320068359,
0.47871294617652893,
0.6777665019035339,
0.29386410117149353,
0.030704135075211525,
0.49699822068214417,
-0.5374634265899658,
-0.3142838180065155,
-0.6717621088027954,
0.21068818867206573,
0.228700652718544,
-0.2073921263217926,
0.40443819761276245,
0.33100390434265137,
0.9331532120704651,
-0.0013341865269467235,
0.8043992519378662,
0.22193516790866852,
0.45480889081954956,
-0.8378159999847412,
0.664603054523468,
-0.6534860730171204,
-0.0020857842173427343,
-0.3739241361618042,
-1.0120184421539307,
-0.546999990940094,
0.7291969656944275,
-0.7844662070274353,
-0.007037442643195391,
0.6033096313476562,
1.0281147956848145,
-0.24628004431724548,
-0.4851562976837158,
0.7475264072418213,
0.45217278599739075,
-0.07776693999767303,
0.7394781112670898,
0.4258381128311157,
-0.36516913771629333,
0.39241719245910645,
-0.15649090707302094,
-0.2872523367404938,
-0.6679111123085022,
-0.8352867960929871,
-0.9118062257766724,
-0.2755735218524933,
-0.38010329008102417,
-0.2013242542743683,
0.6606045961380005,
0.8359684348106384,
0.7925037145614624,
-1.105518102645874,
-0.38663560152053833,
0.047840602695941925,
0.17988288402557373,
-0.28880196809768677,
-0.04205970838665962,
0.5331368446350098,
-0.2980157434940338,
-0.6596227288246155,
0.328579843044281,
0.30278924107551575,
0.013292832300066948,
-0.07286801189184189,
0.016285710036754608,
-0.3024522364139557,
-0.02146817184984684,
0.5123322606086731,
0.1968158334493637,
-0.4106791317462921,
-0.832233726978302,
-0.5602533221244812,
-0.018414240330457687,
0.1578451544046402,
0.329694002866745,
-0.3763842284679413,
0.29943767189979553,
0.35203325748443604,
0.7673197984695435,
0.7566318511962891,
0.23054522275924683,
0.7393122315406799,
-0.7912456393241882,
0.43785005807876587,
-0.10497412830591202,
0.19141514599323273,
0.26179030537605286,
-0.24770674109458923,
0.39348629117012024,
0.1456717699766159,
-0.6209419369697571,
-0.9217627048492432,
0.21638771891593933,
-1.0114389657974243,
-0.5571139454841614,
1.2792491912841797,
-0.3506237268447876,
-0.20371273159980774,
-0.11034006625413895,
0.11598800867795944,
0.4752863645553589,
-0.5185041427612305,
0.8880817890167236,
0.7118183970451355,
-0.03405735641717911,
-0.4233907163143158,
-0.6585612893104553,
0.2960449159145355,
0.3456476926803589,
-0.7143358588218689,
0.1579526960849762,
0.308957040309906,
0.43146347999572754,
-0.1591504067182541,
0.14516952633857727,
0.40496382117271423,
0.18786440789699554,
0.026010563597083092,
0.07619695365428925,
0.2730090916156769,
-0.38748177886009216,
-0.48804542422294617,
0.1792667806148529,
0.4427056312561035,
-0.1375192105770111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11674v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11674v1 | Endor: Hardware-Friendly Sparse Format for Offloaded LLM Inference | 2024-06-17T15:55:08 | 2024-06-17T15:55:08 | Donghyeon Joo, Ramyad Hadidi, Soheil Feizi, Bahar Asgari | cs.CL | cs.CL | The increasing size of large language models (LLMs) challenges their usage on
resource-constrained platforms. For example, memory on modern GPUs is
insufficient to hold LLMs that are hundreds of Gigabytes in size. Offloading is
a popular method to escape this constraint by storing weights of an LLM model
to host CPU memory and SSD, then loading each weight to GPU before every use.
In our case study of offloaded inference, we found that due to the low
bandwidth between storage devices and GPU, the latency of transferring large
model weights from its offloaded location to GPU memory becomes the critical
bottleneck with actual compute taking nearly 0% of runtime. To effectively
reduce the weight transfer latency, we propose a novel sparse format that
compresses the unstructured sparse pattern of pruned LLM weights to non-zero
values with high compression ratio and low decompression overhead. Endor
achieves this by expressing the positions of non-zero elements with a bitmap.
Compared to offloaded inference using the popular Huggingface Accelerate,
applying Endor accelerates OPT-66B by 1.70x and Llama2-70B by 1.78x. When
direct weight transfer from SSD to GPU is leveraged, Endor achieves 2.25x
speedup on OPT-66B and 2.37x speedup on Llama2-70B. | [
-0.2697325646877289,
-0.8330575823783875,
0.4707917869091034,
0.18198971450328827,
-0.5766136050224304,
-0.12808716297149658,
-0.31465867161750793,
-0.27990594506263733,
0.39111873507499695,
0.5272157192230225,
-0.32108283042907715,
0.0772746205329895,
-0.5190009474754333,
-0.18631456792354584,
-0.45989149808883667,
0.8808194398880005,
-0.19083081185817719,
-0.3195950388908386,
-0.5069038271903992,
-0.25558599829673767,
-0.0432574488222599,
-0.44464215636253357,
-0.779608428478241,
-0.16133348643779755,
0.2864212989807129,
0.1387520730495453,
0.8923223614692688,
0.8673639297485352,
0.3846375346183777,
0.41339606046676636,
-0.1569143384695053,
-0.0761033147573471,
-0.6642851829528809,
0.09617377817630768,
0.2896406948566437,
-0.3481614291667938,
-0.4854532480239868,
-0.2808689475059509,
0.7164533138275146,
0.6916170716285706,
-0.5303001999855042,
0.3554219603538513,
-0.010404705069959164,
0.5224757194519043,
-0.8183426260948181,
0.05941867455840111,
-0.31266623735427856,
-0.136448472738266,
-0.322441041469574,
-0.2646189033985138,
-0.4193340837955475,
-0.19515691697597504,
-0.4106810986995697,
-1.0581814050674438,
0.23515364527702332,
0.4111890196800232,
0.7261025309562683,
0.8309687376022339,
-0.008929388597607613,
0.0967058315873146,
-0.7023341059684753,
0.7377757430076599,
-0.4656532108783722,
0.37829694151878357,
0.2353598177433014,
0.38967040181159973,
-0.28838884830474854,
-0.6419007778167725,
-0.6553706526756287,
0.31117913126945496,
0.14656101167201996,
0.10566013306379318,
-0.2989608943462372,
0.24512065947055817,
0.27351638674736023,
0.3943767845630646,
-0.6106836795806885,
0.05194681137800217,
-0.17597883939743042,
0.052473507821559906,
0.4762815833091736,
-0.24055448174476624,
0.12422578036785126,
0.3079046308994293,
-0.3139759302139282,
-0.08003053814172745,
-0.8440847992897034,
-0.3600044846534729,
0.40207886695861816,
0.03608107939362526,
-0.33908289670944214,
0.41859370470046997,
0.09884386509656906,
1.08192777633667,
-0.04877755418419838,
-0.060839928686618805,
-0.020699767395853996,
-0.012234180234372616,
-0.4397450387477875,
0.32601889967918396,
0.5513585805892944,
0.4892684519290924,
0.05713580921292305,
-0.3532468378543854,
-0.3245958089828491,
-0.06415480375289917,
-0.00492652365937829,
-1.3463085889816284,
-0.19251516461372375,
0.13450610637664795,
-0.7582064270973206,
-0.028355322778224945,
-0.3965625762939453,
-1.0311371088027954,
-0.25055715441703796,
0.049036331474781036,
0.37965428829193115,
0.036213308572769165,
-0.1065090075135231,
0.23753200471401215,
0.09746551513671875,
0.16645057499408722,
0.437250554561615,
-1.059545636177063,
0.7645794749259949,
0.4169667959213257,
1.131580114364624,
-0.30646491050720215,
0.4733853340148926,
-0.8959888219833374,
0.2614893317222595,
-0.21521703898906708,
0.8452339172363281,
-0.493408203125,
-0.34496912360191345,
-0.31760692596435547,
0.05895077809691429,
0.08979541063308716,
-0.6685546636581421,
0.44328150153160095,
-0.49272871017456055,
-0.04995414614677429,
-0.18451064825057983,
-0.40673068165779114,
-0.28499138355255127,
-0.025038447231054306,
-0.7707085013389587,
1.3397315740585327,
0.4555181562900543,
-0.5396621823310852,
0.31450387835502625,
-0.1666969358921051,
-0.30310487747192383,
0.18666474521160126,
-0.2991124391555786,
-0.6043487787246704,
0.36394935846328735,
-0.04550209268927574,
0.3208675682544708,
-0.5914113521575928,
0.24302390217781067,
-0.5495105385780334,
-0.7593370079994202,
0.009413151070475578,
-0.3061952590942383,
0.5180565714836121,
0.3617854416370392,
-0.15376077592372894,
0.12290073931217194,
-0.957460880279541,
-0.12585976719856262,
0.2011444866657257,
-0.3020019233226776,
-0.34144076704978943,
0.008340518921613693,
0.22769272327423096,
0.18058288097381592,
0.35155200958251953,
-0.9719826579093933,
0.13167154788970947,
-0.10055514425039291,
0.47914978861808777,
0.7235656380653381,
-0.5347006320953369,
0.36708492040634155,
-0.36981722712516785,
0.5302181839942932,
-0.40028491616249084,
-0.06461282819509506,
0.08113893866539001,
-0.42029833793640137,
-0.8047329187393188,
-0.7284101843833923,
0.02298181876540184,
0.5956369042396545,
-0.5437917709350586,
0.2915132939815521,
-0.15780560672283173,
-0.2824546694755554,
-0.5276121497154236,
0.3361862599849701,
0.3410692512989044,
0.5885836482048035,
0.4566137492656708,
-0.22460003197193146,
-0.5533391833305359,
-0.5815013647079468,
0.3056018352508545,
-0.1406654566526413,
-0.01660931669175625,
0.5193161964416504,
0.16322684288024902,
0.23000071942806244,
0.7344934344291687,
-0.6034205555915833,
-0.20867905020713806,
-0.35538801550865173,
-0.005556238815188408,
0.22884395718574524,
0.5484256744384766,
0.6878683567047119,
-0.5334423780441284,
-0.2948462665081024,
-0.04144800081849098,
-0.6086338758468628,
-0.5227845907211304,
-0.34389159083366394,
-0.3613892197608948,
0.22928458452224731,
0.6247243881225586,
-0.6581125259399414,
0.24930471181869507,
0.8009743094444275,
-0.32347729802131653,
0.3048449456691742,
-0.6487395167350769,
-0.17206303775310516,
-1.0369954109191895,
0.07025686651468277,
-0.023642323911190033,
-0.423633873462677,
-0.30652132630348206,
-0.21410399675369263,
-0.02314096875488758,
0.06117209419608116,
-0.22815945744514465,
0.6395365595817566,
-0.5034460425376892,
-0.46395376324653625,
-0.20644481480121613,
-0.09704669564962387,
0.06474573910236359,
0.3417501151561737,
0.191008061170578,
0.9955417513847351,
0.40881139039993286,
-0.37303951382637024,
0.3433780372142792,
0.12779775261878967,
-0.023369980975985527,
0.3966235816478729,
-1.0095622539520264,
0.02076917141675949,
-0.32655811309814453,
0.053222350776195526,
-1.205932378768921,
0.09599313884973526,
0.15331244468688965,
-0.07820522040128708,
0.8415476679801941,
-0.3353216052055359,
-0.5656144618988037,
0.013348530977964401,
-0.2980344593524933,
0.5666398406028748,
0.7929554581642151,
-0.5984972715377808,
0.49572163820266724,
0.2532256841659546,
-0.316249281167984,
-0.4001559913158417,
-0.824640154838562,
0.006615273654460907,
-0.3375995457172394,
-0.4855431616306305,
0.6116861701011658,
-0.313648521900177,
-0.26655837893486023,
0.11729417741298676,
-0.06659387797117233,
-0.1394224613904953,
0.07684413343667984,
0.5042780041694641,
0.5501095652580261,
-0.4331367313861847,
-0.39829012751579285,
0.1469670832157135,
-0.1861945241689682,
-0.16677209734916687,
-0.27199646830558777,
0.4351218044757843,
0.11368747055530548,
-0.3700660467147827,
-0.14888377487659454,
0.42345088720321655,
0.3987102508544922,
0.3794163763523102,
0.837632954120636,
0.36909982562065125,
-0.4258362352848053,
-0.06999295949935913,
-0.5529015064239502,
0.056009918451309204,
-0.4768175780773163,
0.4289139211177826,
-0.14842119812965393,
-0.8105562925338745,
0.501986563205719,
-0.08429235219955444,
0.12099543958902359,
0.133571058511734,
0.5682864189147949,
0.1563699096441269,
0.8103995323181152,
0.7835536599159241,
0.08409500122070312,
0.45988935232162476,
-0.1832914501428604,
0.1150132566690445,
-0.6719411015510559,
-0.21813736855983734,
-0.47201934456825256,
-0.6146653890609741,
-0.2682444453239441,
-0.886585533618927,
0.013052800670266151,
0.3147377371788025,
-0.10832887887954712,
0.21539165079593658,
-0.6046168208122253,
0.34837520122528076,
0.10933854430913925,
-0.19320446252822876,
0.2878780663013458,
0.3041987717151642,
0.12005890905857086,
-0.12764565646648407,
-0.5410094857215881,
-0.2999557554721832,
0.8709078431129456,
0.015094982460141182,
1.2118803262710571,
0.27604997158050537,
0.4121381938457489,
0.20533302426338196,
0.5030249953269958,
-0.622675895690918,
0.6264774799346924,
-0.3847520351409912,
-0.2641715407371521,
-0.13432727754116058,
-0.5329639315605164,
-0.556462287902832,
0.2281048744916916,
0.0624508298933506,
-0.8281937837600708,
0.09378338605165482,
0.2819039821624756,
-0.5535539984703064,
0.5926007032394409,
-0.5871405601501465,
0.6567861437797546,
-0.324729859828949,
-0.8513529300689697,
-0.025487061589956284,
-0.4391489028930664,
0.20112714171409607,
-0.08321493864059448,
0.026248160749673843,
-0.17171910405158997,
-0.41042518615722656,
0.870596706867218,
-0.7863026261329651,
0.6632141470909119,
-0.3414361774921417,
-0.0474327951669693,
0.4113178849220276,
0.31284233927726746,
0.6179888844490051,
-0.12840639054775238,
-0.11196424812078476,
0.2671847939491272,
0.017059406265616417,
-0.26500633358955383,
-0.7179707288742065,
0.6791783571243286,
-0.8511409163475037,
-0.21941646933555603,
-0.35301703214645386,
-0.7712721228599548,
0.15788376331329346,
0.07737017422914505,
0.15796515345573425,
0.3894924819469452,
0.10549214482307434,
0.034510962665081024,
0.8834750652313232,
-0.2810494601726532,
0.7212971448898315,
0.5158394575119019,
-0.018794335424900055,
-0.19502954185009003,
1.1770892143249512,
0.2515026032924652,
0.2662476897239685,
0.3792763948440552,
-0.04086758941411972,
-0.4958205223083496,
-0.777910590171814,
-1.046918272972107,
0.22495153546333313,
-0.31594595313072205,
-0.30537691712379456,
-0.5364243388175964,
-0.11674871295690536,
0.010411255992949009,
-0.6310216784477234,
-0.6988987326622009,
-0.7286527156829834,
-0.4196496605873108,
0.18605199456214905,
0.6299393177032471,
0.5097590684890747,
-0.09130465239286423,
0.8072508573532104,
-0.3842920660972595,
0.3329593539237976,
-0.2059367448091507,
0.45077642798423767,
-0.1496865302324295,
-0.9289202690124512,
0.07462172955274582,
-0.4105929434299469,
-0.12802430987358093,
-0.4869774580001831,
0.6184254288673401,
0.5818226337432861,
0.45905202627182007,
0.7985978126525879,
0.06269387155771255,
1.0202561616897583,
-0.1426406353712082,
0.3557935953140259,
0.349790096282959,
-0.6031330227851868,
0.03252677619457245,
0.009985838085412979,
-0.22503934800624847,
0.3319716453552246,
0.4714570641517639,
-0.3356020748615265,
0.14250552654266357,
-0.24506643414497375,
-0.909720778465271,
0.5854101777076721,
-0.055190183222293854,
-0.08941666781902313,
-0.022831162437796593,
0.5683226585388184,
0.29579102993011475,
0.20624595880508423,
-0.4454847574234009,
-0.3349391222000122,
-0.21692702174186707,
-0.30386340618133545,
-0.0667998418211937,
-0.4862387180328369,
0.09946224838495255,
-0.03879551962018013,
0.529968798160553,
-0.38247671723365784,
0.41708046197891235,
0.2981598377227783,
-0.35346201062202454,
-0.25279930233955383,
0.117206871509552,
0.41342154145240784,
0.34052276611328125,
-0.5820154547691345,
0.3263839781284332,
0.04055234417319298,
-0.4948277175426483,
0.2088872492313385,
0.4401243031024933,
-0.48103412985801697,
-0.179239422082901,
-0.09516642242670059,
0.6375243067741394,
0.26594504714012146,
-0.7790148258209229,
0.2861124873161316,
-0.19077003002166748,
-0.09953591227531433,
-0.1512780785560608,
-0.2035769671201706,
-0.007512890733778477,
0.010327816009521484,
0.12528389692306519,
-0.07115922123193741,
0.09631802141666412,
-0.033014532178640366,
0.15138988196849823,
0.5466040968894958,
-0.42796623706817627,
-0.45701712369918823,
1.230969786643982,
0.0434822216629982,
0.3005165457725525,
0.54050213098526,
-0.46554237604141235,
0.051780782639980316,
0.4645850956439972,
1.0538657903671265,
0.6277554035186768,
-0.012403832748532295,
-0.0967162474989891,
0.3713494837284088,
0.2736205458641052,
-0.18580982089042664,
0.5684594511985779,
-0.4435908794403076,
-0.6419336795806885,
-0.9405384659767151,
-1.1981467008590698,
-0.15072251856327057,
-0.07159965485334396,
-0.49962225556373596,
0.0548061728477478,
-0.7737917900085449,
0.06821627169847488,
-0.4012490510940552,
-0.023992756381630898,
-0.10986387729644775,
-0.1352759301662445,
0.47731226682662964,
0.9376494884490967,
-0.8293048739433289,
0.7276288270950317,
0.4810788035392761,
-0.12868450582027435,
-0.3247520625591278,
-0.7059406638145447,
0.19380062818527222,
-0.9104761481285095,
0.5733308792114258,
0.15832649171352386,
-0.12829433381557465,
0.09049275517463684,
-0.2192017287015915,
-1.0357500314712524,
0.9436807632446289,
0.7672604918479919,
-0.7602043747901917,
0.05450701713562012,
0.09766864776611328,
0.035502854734659195,
-0.24810895323753357,
0.6363856196403503,
0.4045700430870056,
0.36023542284965515,
0.6363170742988586,
-0.5540801286697388,
0.58765709400177,
-0.3907190263271332,
0.06728360801935196,
0.31952348351478577,
-0.9031507968902588,
0.980235755443573,
-0.48190033435821533,
-0.0595192052423954,
0.37665849924087524,
0.9173992276191711,
0.23606805503368378,
0.17616045475006104,
0.47751545906066895,
1.0037841796875,
0.7596330046653748,
-0.1026521772146225,
0.8977116346359253,
-0.45500725507736206,
0.0930732861161232,
0.9488552212715149,
-0.4909326434135437,
0.8342248201370239,
0.6794567704200745,
-0.21928338706493378,
0.27013787627220154,
0.8466951847076416,
0.046409789472818375,
0.44378533959388733,
0.5169028639793396,
-0.4003659784793854,
-0.3439203202724457,
-0.3626193106174469,
-0.2783503830432892,
0.27919337153434753,
0.3979935646057129,
-0.05833398923277855,
-0.4347829818725586,
-0.2958790957927704,
0.42542731761932373,
-0.2350730448961258,
-0.393045037984848,
0.3347170948982239,
-0.026338255032896996,
-0.40072712302207947,
0.5888102054595947,
0.001638279645703733,
0.9506043791770935,
-0.6114351749420166,
-0.2517225444316864,
-0.2200419306755066,
0.3534836769104004,
-0.33823657035827637,
-0.4576300084590912,
0.51189124584198,
-0.08842743933200836,
-0.18311230838298798,
-0.4947643578052521,
0.7860610485076904,
-0.4486042261123657,
-0.6336629390716553,
0.33192315697669983,
0.3681621253490448,
0.5295201539993286,
-0.23441654443740845,
-0.4536573588848114,
0.3859061896800995,
-0.22185446321964264,
-0.4753881096839905,
0.6931871175765991,
0.19346143305301666,
-0.2430928349494934,
0.7842376232147217,
0.9266571402549744,
0.4776873290538788,
0.2807702422142029,
-0.012385948561131954,
1.0488113164901733,
-0.4751724600791931,
-0.36919528245925903,
-0.6973589062690735,
-0.001459138817153871,
0.026768097653985023,
-0.08916983008384705,
0.5271942615509033,
0.9103081226348877,
0.4791117012500763,
0.49456140398979187,
0.5540943145751953,
-0.42348504066467285,
-0.03547293692827225,
-0.4055890142917633,
0.7266085147857666,
-0.6507665514945984,
0.08638665080070496,
0.17787283658981323,
-0.8015173077583313,
-0.2198631465435028,
0.6233328580856323,
0.05639776587486267,
0.17497389018535614,
0.3157973289489746,
0.882786750793457,
-0.11645197123289108,
-0.167361781001091,
0.5009512305259705,
0.1309380978345871,
0.07854527235031128,
0.628477931022644,
0.24518761038780212,
-0.269540011882782,
0.7557243704795837,
-0.23780018091201782,
-0.4823888838291168,
-0.24063390493392944,
-0.9728878736495972,
-0.6570162177085876,
-0.18824510276317596,
-0.5029725432395935,
-0.2945041358470917,
0.037858664989471436,
0.5856276154518127,
0.939449667930603,
-0.5605051517486572,
-0.27741628885269165,
-0.06317184120416641,
-0.13730160892009735,
-0.10516710579395294,
-0.17456185817718506,
0.3050699532032013,
-0.02937014028429985,
-0.5173933506011963,
0.26360368728637695,
0.5043905377388,
0.13431961834430695,
-0.1574242264032364,
-0.31296858191490173,
0.0565161257982254,
-0.045181017369031906,
0.5827003121376038,
0.5299491882324219,
-0.32129520177841187,
0.0013185315765440464,
-0.07871056348085403,
0.2524969279766083,
0.11907672137022018,
0.8687304854393005,
-0.9338632225990295,
0.30754879117012024,
0.4606230854988098,
0.7924606800079346,
0.6376885771751404,
0.03791239857673645,
0.38645997643470764,
-0.662882924079895,
0.5729081630706787,
-0.10955464094877243,
0.6580951809883118,
0.40850839018821716,
-0.45262405276298523,
0.3267311453819275,
0.5240803360939026,
-0.4758983254432678,
-0.8260678052902222,
-0.24530275166034698,
-1.3419139385223389,
-0.09017478674650192,
1.0837438106536865,
-0.283184289932251,
-0.6979795098304749,
-0.18209190666675568,
0.041137807071208954,
0.39746320247650146,
-0.47869986295700073,
0.5259297490119934,
0.34613946080207825,
-0.3665724992752075,
-0.42173877358436584,
-0.9131767153739929,
0.30809134244918823,
0.47370395064353943,
-0.7249179482460022,
0.25240612030029297,
0.3933195471763611,
0.03046688437461853,
-0.09708663821220398,
0.6224637627601624,
-0.1679752767086029,
0.008112783543765545,
0.34326475858688354,
0.27628007531166077,
-0.40910211205482483,
-0.10912639647722244,
-0.16873681545257568,
0.05706767365336418,
-0.15083517134189606,
-0.3126489222049713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11670v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11670v1 | Benchmarking of LLM Detection: Comparing Two Competing Approaches | 2024-06-17T15:51:46 | 2024-06-17T15:51:46 | Thorsten Pröhl, Erik Putzier, Rüdiger Zarnekow | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This article gives an overview of the field of LLM text recognition.
Different approaches and implemented detectors for the recognition of
LLM-generated text are presented. In addition to discussing the
implementations, the article focuses on benchmarking the detectors. Although
there are numerous software products for the recognition of LLM-generated text,
with a focus on ChatGPT-like LLMs, the quality of the recognition (recognition
rate) is not clear. Furthermore, while it can be seen that scientific
contributions presenting their novel approaches strive for some kind of
comparison with other approaches, the construction and independence of the
evaluation dataset is often not comprehensible. As a result, discrepancies in
the performance evaluation of LLM detectors are often visible due to the
different benchmarking datasets. This article describes the creation of an
evaluation dataset and uses this dataset to investigate the different
detectors. The selected detectors are benchmarked against each other. | [
-0.20172381401062012,
-0.3610776960849762,
0.6688665747642517,
-0.06336989253759384,
-0.34257185459136963,
0.29957789182662964,
-0.20005278289318085,
-0.703943133354187,
-0.061201661825180054,
0.26475009322166443,
-0.33049526810646057,
-0.5569499731063843,
-0.8222580552101135,
0.44150689244270325,
-0.41153037548065186,
0.6615071296691895,
-0.27218326926231384,
0.24519549310207367,
-0.25808992981910706,
-0.17280608415603638,
-0.4001240134239197,
-0.5399438142776489,
-0.8826873302459717,
-0.595723569393158,
0.21379797160625458,
0.06308649480342865,
0.10634786635637283,
0.5642017126083374,
0.8645777106285095,
0.32532796263694763,
-0.3231566548347473,
0.14698804914951324,
-0.47761270403862,
0.14105883240699768,
0.1176946684718132,
-0.5016916394233704,
-0.008188261650502682,
0.13548988103866577,
0.8809986114501953,
-0.05536976456642151,
0.09340518712997437,
0.006671581882983446,
0.038189832121133804,
0.5590331554412842,
-0.6992286443710327,
-0.08062895387411118,
-0.785306990146637,
0.26451900601387024,
-0.6186358332633972,
-0.36891674995422363,
-0.4279717803001404,
-0.3834444582462311,
-0.11981271952390671,
-0.040912479162216187,
0.42400938272476196,
0.08438922464847565,
0.5368237495422363,
0.05296899378299713,
-0.32409313321113586,
-0.8876418471336365,
-0.6941249966621399,
0.8556740880012512,
-0.6489077210426331,
0.27543240785598755,
0.1343388706445694,
0.64960777759552,
-0.0941343903541565,
-0.6741788387298584,
-0.4818691909313202,
-0.30218392610549927,
0.14082221686840057,
0.413649320602417,
-0.3790683448314667,
-0.34399232268333435,
0.2785467505455017,
0.6347346901893616,
-0.8142759203910828,
0.3813062310218811,
-0.1369989663362503,
-0.5067590475082397,
0.622077226638794,
0.3831443190574646,
-0.052815210074186325,
-0.10945484042167664,
-0.4565392732620239,
-0.1983165442943573,
-0.8050315380096436,
-0.1522277295589447,
0.5267521142959595,
-0.04726049676537514,
0.10727622359991074,
0.566677451133728,
-0.3415328562259674,
0.47026097774505615,
-0.34591302275657654,
-0.32650497555732727,
0.45208775997161865,
-0.2504083216190338,
-0.22560277581214905,
0.05886067822575569,
1.0070958137512207,
0.5098311305046082,
0.2187768816947937,
-0.07336188107728958,
-0.663805365562439,
0.29468533396720886,
0.09413517266511917,
-0.8322706818580627,
-0.1235017478466034,
-0.013614124618470669,
-0.8286236524581909,
-0.6269049644470215,
-0.07978412508964539,
-0.49202224612236023,
-0.6167020797729492,
0.007437680847942829,
0.49676838517189026,
-0.1509515792131424,
-0.1498514860868454,
0.1203070729970932,
-0.1627044677734375,
0.3825550973415375,
0.22923271358013153,
-0.6757599711418152,
0.4356161653995514,
0.7384089231491089,
0.8041821122169495,
-0.5512434244155884,
-0.01158806774765253,
-0.2357185035943985,
-0.19866912066936493,
-0.19281809031963348,
1.3128561973571777,
-0.23422656953334808,
-0.5341684222221375,
-0.01932450383901596,
-0.1968122124671936,
0.1004493236541748,
-1.0197125673294067,
0.9312517046928406,
-0.46959659457206726,
0.07441616803407669,
-0.23993206024169922,
-0.8384676575660706,
-0.008723658509552479,
0.44869041442871094,
-0.7259917855262756,
1.3162177801132202,
-0.06427261233329773,
-0.9569634199142456,
0.6348496675491333,
-0.20232267677783966,
-0.22730045020580292,
0.2887016832828522,
-0.24154500663280487,
-0.7952219843864441,
0.1463371366262436,
0.13238288462162018,
0.35302281379699707,
-0.39993566274642944,
-0.08513376861810684,
-0.1196829229593277,
-0.6441657543182373,
0.6658321022987366,
-0.7539800405502319,
0.5876384973526001,
0.4243018925189972,
-0.07233747094869614,
-0.1661866456270218,
-0.9323415756225586,
0.00385274738073349,
0.2668056786060333,
-0.6272932887077332,
-0.046604257076978683,
0.2744377553462982,
0.24742066860198975,
-0.2029186636209488,
0.42881396412849426,
-0.6346574425697327,
-0.05367323383688927,
-0.13864177465438843,
0.3083718419075012,
0.6063253879547119,
0.0679788589477539,
-0.02297455258667469,
-0.5013130307197571,
0.2537413537502289,
-0.03971754014492035,
0.03917090222239494,
-0.14123791456222534,
-0.38082820177078247,
-0.7193734049797058,
-0.13595809042453766,
0.3635655343532562,
0.6517024636268616,
-0.6624805927276611,
0.21680065989494324,
0.06081405654549599,
-0.5648787617683411,
-0.239198237657547,
0.09700528532266617,
0.5793977975845337,
0.398843377828598,
0.1068001538515091,
-0.4735209047794342,
-0.7365756034851074,
-0.805131196975708,
-0.5876752138137817,
-0.3451431095600128,
-0.19578367471694946,
0.5402371883392334,
0.48540928959846497,
0.018523508682847023,
0.6183227896690369,
-0.5814580321311951,
-0.028904451057314873,
-0.22060588002204895,
0.13182933628559113,
0.39689385890960693,
0.25371360778808594,
0.5125240087509155,
-0.5874832272529602,
-0.6145846843719482,
-0.03872621804475784,
-0.9503783583641052,
-0.45943892002105713,
0.16572466492652893,
0.30028966069221497,
0.029452204704284668,
0.7603799700737,
-0.08150548487901688,
0.4394058287143707,
0.4876164197921753,
0.18588948249816895,
0.7352519035339355,
-0.03364886716008186,
0.3045985996723175,
-0.9736158847808838,
-0.2976345419883728,
0.07637154310941696,
-0.4281524121761322,
-0.569423496723175,
-0.044189780950546265,
0.16982129216194153,
0.12123151868581772,
-0.6148120760917664,
0.33701640367507935,
-0.4644223153591156,
-0.5562599897384644,
-0.7398852705955505,
0.2622649371623993,
-0.1322723627090454,
0.1486934870481491,
0.048035867512226105,
1.0600827932357788,
0.33568403124809265,
-0.43210357427597046,
0.43392854928970337,
0.012709681876003742,
-0.7212764620780945,
0.6762648224830627,
-0.7571108341217041,
0.21093297004699707,
0.19359232485294342,
0.1577879637479782,
-1.0666013956069946,
0.1492704451084137,
0.5726599097251892,
-0.4654402434825897,
0.21509526669979095,
-0.22663526237010956,
-0.8479767441749573,
-0.3408643901348114,
-0.5501364469528198,
0.410854309797287,
0.6581546068191528,
-0.6709852814674377,
0.12453316897153854,
0.35162293910980225,
0.08487491309642792,
-0.36728420853614807,
-0.6370730996131897,
0.17413514852523804,
-0.4195941388607025,
-0.23271620273590088,
0.40786245465278625,
-0.12265866249799728,
-0.17986391484737396,
-0.21405605971813202,
-0.11161544173955917,
0.09092419594526291,
0.08933992683887482,
0.10977856814861298,
0.1278230845928192,
-0.2802804112434387,
0.12235774844884872,
-0.4077080190181732,
-0.40997374057769775,
0.11495918035507202,
-0.05204545333981514,
0.41560274362564087,
0.08800958096981049,
-0.5068531632423401,
-0.4514760673046112,
0.05068831145763397,
0.05431118607521057,
0.07808104902505875,
0.25592145323753357,
0.6287530064582825,
-0.3552042245864868,
0.054769616574048996,
-0.7228500247001648,
0.10484056174755096,
-0.4986076056957245,
0.03442814201116562,
-0.44886526465415955,
-0.6479589939117432,
0.3919965624809265,
-0.28122881054878235,
-0.2682218849658966,
0.46261096000671387,
0.9231085181236267,
-0.22669926285743713,
0.6648745536804199,
0.392019659280777,
-0.198188915848732,
0.5298563241958618,
0.1884196251630783,
0.023768149316310883,
-0.9417682886123657,
-0.08520044386386871,
-0.787671685218811,
-0.1598486602306366,
-0.85612952709198,
-0.2520895004272461,
0.09883254021406174,
0.019187146797776222,
0.0483749695122242,
0.6222020387649536,
-0.6455844640731812,
0.6948400139808655,
0.32402196526527405,
0.36379724740982056,
0.5931207537651062,
-0.007220315281301737,
-0.23870694637298584,
-0.0021964097395539284,
-0.4849947392940521,
-0.9831550121307373,
1.4870500564575195,
0.16111153364181519,
0.8582260012626648,
-0.08350542932748795,
0.8723620176315308,
0.5539773106575012,
0.579322099685669,
-0.7347053289413452,
0.6202663779258728,
-0.27467137575149536,
-0.32365694642066956,
0.2184773087501526,
-0.4783443808555603,
-1.0800490379333496,
0.2420407235622406,
-0.4218680262565613,
-0.8073456287384033,
-0.06659084558486938,
-0.23861514031887054,
0.3366033136844635,
0.2825877070426941,
-0.6584510207176208,
0.5947961211204529,
-0.11937102675437927,
-0.10191367566585541,
-0.061697978526353836,
-0.23836709558963776,
0.30057913064956665,
-0.03976351022720337,
-0.1282666176557541,
-0.5406480431556702,
0.08741343021392822,
0.7702486515045166,
-0.049991898238658905,
0.567990243434906,
0.11299268901348114,
-0.08727128058671951,
0.4463220238685608,
-0.22491130232810974,
0.3265327513217926,
0.01831880584359169,
-0.2612000107765198,
0.11218547075986862,
-0.1804308295249939,
-0.19481252133846283,
-0.052447061985731125,
0.5581732988357544,
-0.6286318302154541,
-0.2874239385128021,
-0.6220851540565491,
-0.4229108691215515,
0.061603330075740814,
0.12295498698949814,
0.641749382019043,
0.545111358165741,
-0.7053002715110779,
-0.1633785218000412,
0.5631738305091858,
-0.1491919904947281,
0.5658451318740845,
0.6796057224273682,
-0.18966668844223022,
-0.5034798383712769,
0.7850697636604309,
-0.1324850618839264,
0.06435626745223999,
0.7773443460464478,
-0.006121678277850151,
-0.3942384719848633,
-0.9688184857368469,
-0.22479160130023956,
-0.04500843957066536,
-0.9180911779403687,
-0.4139293432235718,
-0.34577396512031555,
-0.5314215421676636,
-0.19264379143714905,
0.0807357057929039,
-0.12791745364665985,
-0.14463092386722565,
-0.2275318056344986,
0.2237066775560379,
0.3986273407936096,
0.8453899025917053,
0.116236113011837,
0.5236607789993286,
-0.47153085470199585,
0.33401158452033997,
0.14614881575107574,
0.4088498651981354,
-0.12450596690177917,
-0.3672540783882141,
-0.30846258997917175,
-0.2569226920604706,
-0.6144146919250488,
-0.6820119023323059,
0.1628328263759613,
-0.11010552197694778,
0.776636004447937,
0.30044975876808167,
-0.22124995291233063,
0.2234046310186386,
-0.4747122824192047,
0.42837539315223694,
0.04998309537768364,
-0.9364913105964661,
0.5638461112976074,
0.15999425947666168,
0.27611061930656433,
0.5248643159866333,
0.23543190956115723,
-0.4579354226589203,
-0.3711780309677124,
-0.2768111526966095,
-0.36413609981536865,
0.4405277371406555,
0.5186644196510315,
-0.2087683081626892,
0.17650499939918518,
0.23102730512619019,
0.2157982587814331,
0.04783971235156059,
-0.7615746855735779,
-0.017770258709788322,
0.23518268764019012,
-0.21116583049297333,
-0.1931317299604416,
-0.40696293115615845,
-0.14081905782222748,
0.32335349917411804,
0.33819523453712463,
0.0911819264292717,
0.45491713285446167,
0.11672903597354889,
-0.4689849317073822,
0.2853185832500458,
0.09004385769367218,
0.4344789385795593,
0.33505499362945557,
-0.2172260731458664,
0.19116319715976715,
0.3006936311721802,
-0.7832177877426147,
0.2604874074459076,
-0.07670144736766815,
-0.08484654873609543,
0.21421796083450317,
0.7686729431152344,
0.5918741822242737,
0.038031160831451416,
-0.5430814027786255,
0.48205333948135376,
-0.3361131250858307,
-0.3613382875919342,
-0.1520071029663086,
0.21926221251487732,
0.08218812197446823,
0.43663838505744934,
0.35523244738578796,
-0.07661087065935135,
0.4006260335445404,
-0.37198373675346375,
0.2088441401720047,
0.5402108430862427,
-0.05518070608377457,
-0.015494560822844505,
0.6326811909675598,
0.0937805250287056,
-0.5907561182975769,
0.43729570508003235,
-0.3420967161655426,
-0.7254984974861145,
0.9339611530303955,
0.45149853825569153,
1.078810214996338,
-0.07087014615535736,
-0.20118239521980286,
0.33761492371559143,
0.1771363914012909,
0.061141036450862885,
0.3366851210594177,
-0.27944958209991455,
-1.0233091115951538,
-0.03626815602183342,
-0.4645049273967743,
-0.8671939373016357,
0.030341651290655136,
-0.5687898397445679,
0.44724932312965393,
-0.19655567407608032,
-0.2523290514945984,
0.3527345061302185,
0.4056897461414337,
-0.6005387902259827,
0.11588448286056519,
0.16325171291828156,
0.9066708087921143,
-0.8844048976898193,
0.6974452137947083,
0.38165658712387085,
0.10049563646316528,
-0.15892824530601501,
0.20929943025112152,
0.2794105112552643,
-1.053141713142395,
0.38270410895347595,
0.4095464050769806,
-0.2335858941078186,
-0.22991497814655304,
-0.3253975212574005,
-0.33641317486763,
1.2562670707702637,
-0.06241590902209282,
-0.5287739038467407,
0.7422646880149841,
0.1987675279378891,
0.6779803037643433,
-0.38875812292099,
0.4817940294742584,
0.5971508026123047,
0.28719526529312134,
0.07072226703166962,
-0.7766586542129517,
-0.07166026532649994,
-0.11565365642309189,
0.1705068200826645,
0.09470568597316742,
-0.5210049152374268,
0.7877399325370789,
0.25510236620903015,
-0.6155155301094055,
0.4385363459587097,
0.29024431109428406,
0.5629174709320068,
0.8106797337532043,
0.25693604350090027,
0.592965304851532,
0.4368072748184204,
-0.24326427280902863,
0.7814383506774902,
-0.19256195425987244,
0.515561580657959,
0.8667710423469543,
-0.6524132490158081,
0.8742601871490479,
0.2686852216720581,
-0.7376973032951355,
0.13135798275470734,
0.8814246654510498,
-0.43350449204444885,
0.5230096578598022,
0.4730786383152008,
-0.7095750570297241,
0.20997019112110138,
-0.033280450850725174,
-0.45073172450065613,
0.3500922620296478,
0.267656534910202,
-0.43426597118377686,
-0.4635432958602905,
-0.276636004447937,
-0.3182869851589203,
0.08065265417098999,
-0.3605109453201294,
0.8714689016342163,
0.06831211596727371,
-0.3685782849788666,
0.5534575581550598,
0.17920169234275818,
0.9217193126678467,
-0.3767586648464203,
0.28085556626319885,
-0.11378112435340881,
0.2714288830757141,
-0.25591886043548584,
-1.0530470609664917,
0.2802298963069916,
0.3461494743824005,
-0.14303824305534363,
-0.22369854152202606,
1.2354389429092407,
-0.10623749345541,
-0.3104848861694336,
0.21263572573661804,
0.6488828063011169,
0.6026797294616699,
0.24800452589988708,
-0.6770151257514954,
0.4899265468120575,
-0.12277954071760178,
-0.11563149839639664,
0.3346826434135437,
0.42270880937576294,
0.17545558512210846,
0.4925684928894043,
0.5745786428451538,
-0.05960313230752945,
-0.03598300367593765,
0.23863394558429718,
0.7612366080284119,
-0.6499330997467041,
-0.10406792908906937,
-1.026921272277832,
-0.16548676788806915,
-0.12947161495685577,
-0.26375195384025574,
0.7951021790504456,
0.9839640259742737,
0.7863854765892029,
-0.13501599431037903,
0.5411551594734192,
0.1837129443883896,
0.5216533541679382,
-0.8393336534500122,
0.44639402627944946,
-0.3545307517051697,
0.5713185667991638,
-0.27726516127586365,
-0.9618473052978516,
-0.2865440249443054,
0.6956765651702881,
-0.10906398296356201,
0.07147958874702454,
0.7620749473571777,
0.8258315920829773,
0.06234832480549812,
0.0659882053732872,
0.3313491642475128,
-0.06263680756092072,
0.35083281993865967,
0.8659953474998474,
1.1679613590240479,
-0.7286376953125,
0.6196247339248657,
0.05931061878800392,
-0.10233044624328613,
-0.2906917929649353,
-1.3060827255249023,
-0.793805718421936,
-0.46992120146751404,
-0.29305651783943176,
-0.11733002960681915,
0.08206909149885178,
0.2057371437549591,
0.46236616373062134,
-0.7272260785102844,
-0.32188478112220764,
-0.21351532638072968,
0.24530057609081268,
-0.14775434136390686,
-0.2108134627342224,
0.2004268914461136,
-0.08376803249120712,
-0.8334396481513977,
0.42670103907585144,
0.44990915060043335,
0.34940028190612793,
-0.16914404928684235,
0.05925377085804939,
0.09007947146892548,
0.04667268693447113,
0.4704815149307251,
0.23756107687950134,
-0.3831459581851959,
-0.17427761852741241,
-0.3370756506919861,
-0.47415491938591003,
0.4487677812576294,
0.8916994333267212,
-0.9401979446411133,
0.1910575032234192,
0.780876874923706,
0.5173366069793701,
0.988884687423706,
-0.31968238949775696,
0.17366793751716614,
-0.5738308429718018,
0.030621787533164024,
0.1305122971534729,
0.382792204618454,
0.35654890537261963,
-0.2279948741197586,
0.7944337129592896,
0.3544268012046814,
-0.9066482186317444,
-0.8717804551124573,
0.4185003638267517,
-1.0618109703063965,
-0.09296905249357224,
0.8794023990631104,
-0.163255512714386,
-0.054765213280916214,
0.03186585381627083,
-0.22117389738559723,
0.1396321952342987,
-0.1448024958372116,
0.5721011161804199,
0.9369375705718994,
-0.37512823939323425,
0.008217155933380127,
-0.5867917537689209,
0.25580453872680664,
0.007176827639341354,
-0.8949068784713745,
-0.20284341275691986,
0.07575224339962006,
0.5357428193092346,
-0.20480741560459137,
0.9081414937973022,
-0.2633814513683319,
0.1529501974582672,
0.3317796289920807,
-0.04244939982891083,
0.20395968854427338,
0.15947258472442627,
-0.40713760256767273,
-0.10094442963600159,
0.1399906724691391,
-0.44125351309776306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11668v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11668v1 | "Not Aligned" is Not "Malicious": Being Careful about Hallucinations of Large Language Models' Jailbreak | 2024-06-17T15:51:01 | 2024-06-17T15:51:01 | Lingrui Mei, Shenghua Liu, Yiwei Wang, Baolong Bi, Jiayi Mao, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | "Jailbreak" is a major safety concern of Large Language Models (LLMs), which
occurs when malicious prompts lead LLMs to produce harmful outputs, raising
issues about the reliability and safety of LLMs. Therefore, an effective
evaluation of jailbreaks is very crucial to develop its mitigation strategies.
However, our research reveals that many jailbreaks identified by current
evaluations may actually be hallucinations-erroneous outputs that are mistaken
for genuine safety breaches. This finding suggests that some perceived
vulnerabilities might not represent actual threats, indicating a need for more
precise red teaming benchmarks. To address this problem, we propose the
$\textbf{B}$enchmark for reli$\textbf{AB}$ilit$\textbf{Y}$ and
jail$\textbf{B}$reak ha$\textbf{L}$l$\textbf{U}$cination $\textbf{E}$valuation
(BabyBLUE). BabyBLUE introduces a specialized validation framework including
various evaluators to enhance existing jailbreak benchmarks, ensuring outputs
are useful malicious instructions. Additionally, BabyBLUE presents a new
dataset as an augmentation to the existing red teaming benchmarks, specifically
addressing hallucinations in jailbreaks, aiming to evaluate the true potential
of jailbroken LLM outputs to cause harm to human society. | [
-0.09203989058732986,
-0.5924167633056641,
0.21558497846126556,
0.45704641938209534,
-0.23041598498821259,
0.29772597551345825,
-0.37706345319747925,
-0.8188115954399109,
0.4062478840351105,
0.5742257237434387,
-0.45770493149757385,
-0.436943918466568,
-0.5521328449249268,
-0.04458719864487648,
-0.5458778738975525,
0.9841981530189514,
0.1338021159172058,
-0.1411149501800537,
-0.08511194586753845,
-0.21427202224731445,
-0.8367729783058167,
-0.2930983603000641,
-0.26369708776474,
-0.14249703288078308,
0.28144800662994385,
0.33724668622016907,
0.7591748833656311,
0.47633227705955505,
0.746863842010498,
0.26315033435821533,
0.007484763860702515,
-0.029287761077284813,
-0.5899317264556885,
0.6284579634666443,
-0.08768990635871887,
-0.1457105129957199,
-0.2274962067604065,
0.0614643320441246,
0.14450617134571075,
0.39024630188941956,
-0.26679182052612305,
0.05623573809862137,
-0.2888738214969635,
0.9038848876953125,
-1.0560401678085327,
-0.40262478590011597,
-0.8570249676704407,
0.12856006622314453,
-0.2251330465078354,
0.1852550506591797,
-0.8006119132041931,
-0.4607500731945038,
-0.08523192256689072,
-0.2970176935195923,
-0.12896563112735748,
0.4490436017513275,
1.0001435279846191,
0.623678982257843,
-0.11505082249641418,
-0.05811620503664017,
-0.6273261308670044,
0.8076125979423523,
-0.6359086036682129,
0.4275825023651123,
0.3611248731613159,
0.5231981873512268,
-0.38271865248680115,
-0.27591773867607117,
-0.13424287736415863,
-0.4776366651058197,
0.06589072942733765,
0.053594689816236496,
-0.3499959409236908,
-0.043578680604696274,
0.326070100069046,
0.01985056884586811,
-0.6243792772293091,
0.43681633472442627,
-0.49066391587257385,
-0.39364397525787354,
1.042075753211975,
0.1429729163646698,
0.4691777229309082,
0.12437861412763596,
-0.5262435674667358,
-0.017705682665109634,
-0.82414311170578,
-0.25483453273773193,
0.5359265208244324,
0.2915325164794922,
-0.48547786474227905,
0.5952969789505005,
0.18236619234085083,
0.7379465103149414,
0.13809695839881897,
0.09081614017486572,
0.4449693262577057,
-0.0735045075416565,
-0.3342336416244507,
0.43454962968826294,
0.961397647857666,
0.7940633893013,
0.4948822259902954,
-0.6645389795303345,
-0.2373475879430771,
0.4050410985946655,
0.7796448469161987,
-0.7403907775878906,
-0.4426378011703491,
0.308604896068573,
-0.30811676383018494,
-0.43313726782798767,
0.13031773269176483,
-1.1015375852584839,
-0.9214134812355042,
0.27627691626548767,
0.44918468594551086,
-0.37057632207870483,
-0.26895973086357117,
-0.05534323677420616,
-0.13088048994541168,
0.21503838896751404,
0.05577909201383591,
-0.9265077114105225,
0.3033085763454437,
0.795589029788971,
0.6049704551696777,
-0.26410627365112305,
-0.2812034487724304,
-0.37479469180107117,
0.09146985411643982,
-0.4421158730983734,
0.6960388422012329,
-0.508568286895752,
-0.39418870210647583,
-0.05467519909143448,
-0.10776075720787048,
-0.15872463583946228,
-0.8591942191123962,
0.42552295327186584,
-0.3596764802932739,
-0.2592184543609619,
-0.11587204039096832,
-0.40631136298179626,
0.07029254734516144,
0.28262031078338623,
-0.6764791011810303,
0.7662857174873352,
0.05790359154343605,
-0.6892490386962891,
0.6546292304992676,
-0.337114542722702,
-0.709992527961731,
0.0766807273030281,
-0.13260430097579956,
-0.6757541298866272,
0.06157197430729866,
-0.035704806447029114,
-0.001686770934611559,
-0.20814664661884308,
0.41384077072143555,
-0.4562015235424042,
-0.48531374335289,
0.3361242711544037,
-0.2095111608505249,
0.8293746709823608,
0.1664859652519226,
-0.6148693561553955,
0.17544417083263397,
-0.7473751902580261,
0.2314922958612442,
0.019083941355347633,
-0.081941157579422,
-0.4278782308101654,
-0.005668767727911472,
-0.02342996373772621,
-0.021923432126641273,
0.33873963356018066,
-0.6503937244415283,
0.014375428669154644,
-0.4387437701225281,
0.3890828490257263,
0.6750271320343018,
-0.07049934566020966,
0.32229071855545044,
-0.40234917402267456,
0.5570574402809143,
-0.07357775419950485,
0.3680168390274048,
0.33340826630592346,
-0.44348835945129395,
-0.5072305798530579,
-0.3249037265777588,
0.23452360928058624,
0.6046459674835205,
-0.3577812612056732,
0.6426718235015869,
0.020082857459783554,
-0.7903953194618225,
-0.5557259321212769,
-0.021622760221362114,
0.7872368097305298,
0.32047271728515625,
0.48554864525794983,
-0.22905860841274261,
-1.0080456733703613,
-1.186506986618042,
-0.5224761366844177,
-0.4553475081920624,
0.5180692672729492,
0.00010921894863713533,
0.5979569554328918,
-0.35453152656555176,
0.6268613338470459,
-0.10324636846780777,
-0.13976117968559265,
-0.26873400807380676,
-0.02207871712744236,
0.14092805981636047,
0.6318079233169556,
0.3757632374763489,
-0.507888913154602,
-0.4447617530822754,
-0.18957361578941345,
-0.7813035249710083,
-0.4287340044975281,
-0.008375908248126507,
-0.03841809928417206,
0.4260566830635071,
0.5336657166481018,
-0.5154201984405518,
0.30722036957740784,
0.8907211422920227,
-0.5928294062614441,
0.7835387587547302,
-0.014080578461289406,
0.10753972083330154,
-0.766363799571991,
-0.00012387119932100177,
0.059202708303928375,
0.03576714172959328,
-0.6472933888435364,
0.2660213112831116,
0.25216493010520935,
0.10086698830127716,
-0.5047948956489563,
0.48433560132980347,
-0.3236033022403717,
-0.12614208459854126,
-0.11531972885131836,
0.19896137714385986,
-0.05383249744772911,
-0.043337274342775345,
-0.4434196949005127,
0.9007638692855835,
0.36286410689353943,
-0.05834244191646576,
0.3910510838031769,
-0.009962329640984535,
-0.49666163325309753,
0.4377955198287964,
-0.4613870084285736,
0.17363712191581726,
0.25890323519706726,
-0.1245204508304596,
-0.6758308410644531,
-0.13832634687423706,
0.24018222093582153,
-0.42282921075820923,
0.4108610451221466,
-0.187080979347229,
-0.681938111782074,
-0.3456469774246216,
-0.40416833758354187,
0.5231654047966003,
0.5865602493286133,
-0.3762225806713104,
0.1356247365474701,
0.6966791152954102,
0.4767039120197296,
-0.8410502672195435,
-0.775822103023529,
0.18157199025154114,
-0.5564954876899719,
-0.7547639012336731,
0.4149981439113617,
0.22279398143291473,
-0.6351243257522583,
0.10613206028938293,
-0.28910204768180847,
-0.10670797526836395,
0.40249139070510864,
0.5369214415550232,
0.5095420479774475,
-0.09333789348602295,
-0.15386252105236053,
-0.13931207358837128,
-0.17055678367614746,
0.26380035281181335,
0.15672162175178528,
0.44302618503570557,
-0.13992494344711304,
-0.304292768239975,
-0.11368543654680252,
0.007909787818789482,
0.6356160640716553,
-0.16088244318962097,
0.8693564534187317,
0.12997406721115112,
-0.5363006591796875,
-0.3296692669391632,
-0.7729569673538208,
-0.1521005630493164,
-0.46788716316223145,
0.21296188235282898,
-0.024987248703837395,
-0.9160999655723572,
0.6033897995948792,
0.3947947025299072,
0.017689339816570282,
0.19808004796504974,
0.4801139533519745,
-0.012325793504714966,
0.7883381247520447,
0.5229765772819519,
-0.2806544601917267,
0.16908161342144012,
0.223428875207901,
0.49008485674858093,
-0.8411287665367126,
-0.5276554226875305,
-0.5053346753120422,
-0.45572465658187866,
-0.7572693824768066,
-0.0957820788025856,
0.028710532933473587,
0.1094641387462616,
-0.48338010907173157,
0.8269166946411133,
-0.7098909616470337,
0.6617123484611511,
0.3060460686683655,
-0.1493331342935562,
0.023128729313611984,
-0.2524370849132538,
-0.1859140396118164,
-0.24333058297634125,
-0.3801737427711487,
-0.32874685525894165,
1.0868854522705078,
0.34445542097091675,
1.101219892501831,
0.2774221897125244,
0.9320312142372131,
0.2176729142665863,
0.35282111167907715,
-0.6102184653282166,
0.7040233016014099,
-0.10853147506713867,
-0.8807811737060547,
-0.17491133511066437,
-0.3778938055038452,
-1.1405435800552368,
0.2017218917608261,
-0.30908432602882385,
-1.3264052867889404,
-0.0024836265947669744,
0.06661505997180939,
-0.44923102855682373,
0.13233597576618195,
-0.8414931297302246,
1.0265446901321411,
-0.4194434881210327,
-0.579823911190033,
-0.24818947911262512,
-0.6186093688011169,
0.5346336364746094,
-0.1951403170824051,
0.25721341371536255,
-0.23919717967510223,
0.16849544644355774,
0.8444748520851135,
-0.42579618096351624,
0.6949925422668457,
-0.24721558392047882,
0.12851768732070923,
0.24043874442577362,
0.43561020493507385,
0.34197095036506653,
-0.10538223385810852,
-0.11989276856184006,
0.11992114037275314,
-0.19586670398712158,
-0.1143948882818222,
-0.38484176993370056,
0.9065805077552795,
-0.6632697582244873,
-0.8170762658119202,
-0.5451288819313049,
-0.6015521883964539,
-0.26647263765335083,
0.19345872104167938,
0.2186203896999359,
0.02832053415477276,
0.01754923351109028,
0.22620269656181335,
0.46313631534576416,
-0.3725212812423706,
0.371633380651474,
0.42137324810028076,
-0.28060182929039,
-0.541264533996582,
0.7252063751220703,
-0.032689597457647324,
0.20702186226844788,
-0.07255334407091141,
0.06080041453242302,
-0.2272689938545227,
-0.7922730445861816,
-0.419976145029068,
0.39009174704551697,
-0.5501261353492737,
-0.40700608491897583,
-0.3040850758552551,
-0.4330253005027771,
-0.3602525591850281,
-0.3724284768104553,
-0.5435698628425598,
-0.06659849733114243,
0.15583784878253937,
-0.21065238118171692,
0.3444681763648987,
0.5149692296981812,
-0.0894627794623375,
0.053985632956027985,
-0.7572581171989441,
0.08240357041358948,
-0.11999715864658356,
0.4394787549972534,
-0.16237735748291016,
-0.5625203251838684,
-0.38060957193374634,
-0.22550280392169952,
-0.38344988226890564,
-1.0830318927764893,
0.3168867528438568,
-0.34467723965644836,
0.7079190015792847,
0.3640967607498169,
0.4004197120666504,
0.9349080324172974,
-0.44895651936531067,
0.6394482254981995,
0.3582663834095001,
-0.9552518129348755,
0.612463116645813,
-0.24242810904979706,
-0.22305230796337128,
1.0603892803192139,
-0.09788388758897781,
-0.30452314019203186,
-0.7209736108779907,
-0.7306957840919495,
-0.983852744102478,
0.5118672847747803,
0.29032519459724426,
-0.052575819194316864,
-0.09111310541629791,
0.06260766088962555,
-0.09388509392738342,
0.37959590554237366,
-0.9365437626838684,
-0.20555689930915833,
0.02262481115758419,
-0.16403703391551971,
0.25881078839302063,
-0.23257756233215332,
-0.12063781172037125,
-0.11473935097455978,
0.6077762842178345,
0.4603404998779297,
0.003759132232517004,
-0.07193607091903687,
-0.2172217220067978,
-0.4758506119251251,
0.1475498527288437,
0.6240604519844055,
0.5042056441307068,
-0.3410448133945465,
0.09798944741487503,
0.05683792009949684,
-0.46690669655799866,
0.2493356615304947,
-0.11165178567171097,
-0.06769762188196182,
-0.24691477417945862,
0.6563316583633423,
0.675905168056488,
0.24886609613895416,
-1.0040994882583618,
0.6316103339195251,
0.16672666370868683,
-0.0816490650177002,
-0.4259672462940216,
0.34304872155189514,
-0.11447037756443024,
0.34284064173698425,
-0.006534732412546873,
0.1745709776878357,
-0.10144411027431488,
-0.589512050151825,
0.2692962884902954,
0.6843938231468201,
-0.5561390519142151,
-0.29031702876091003,
0.7526187896728516,
0.2351963371038437,
-0.5355857014656067,
0.9287987351417542,
-0.23199640214443207,
-0.5593375563621521,
0.8778867721557617,
0.7426234483718872,
1.1339749097824097,
-0.31832242012023926,
-0.037733640521764755,
0.49723565578460693,
0.8103856444358826,
-0.15174172818660736,
0.15395189821720123,
0.30830666422843933,
-0.8501118421554565,
-0.3727928400039673,
-0.5199992656707764,
-0.32568231225013733,
0.2477673888206482,
-0.7740607261657715,
0.3487589359283447,
-0.6789527535438538,
-0.23472686111927032,
-0.19214577972888947,
-0.18187113106250763,
0.02648833394050598,
0.10533036291599274,
0.27556276321411133,
1.0173383951187134,
-0.9714263081550598,
0.8765167593955994,
0.5320115685462952,
-0.12102335691452026,
-0.752027690410614,
0.17306914925575256,
0.0886039212346077,
-0.7453528642654419,
0.552493691444397,
0.7039597034454346,
-0.026641104370355606,
-0.4329075813293457,
-0.3770800530910492,
-0.5441805124282837,
0.7042761445045471,
0.44624876976013184,
-0.8940469026565552,
0.11483658850193024,
-0.13222788274288177,
0.5412286520004272,
-0.33584392070770264,
-0.07494595646858215,
0.7822668552398682,
0.7311433553695679,
-0.09294796735048294,
-0.980135440826416,
0.32522836327552795,
-0.31142738461494446,
-0.3935025632381439,
0.7046434879302979,
-0.5556341409683228,
0.6393721103668213,
-0.5921626091003418,
-0.31974196434020996,
0.09692589193582535,
0.14171886444091797,
0.5936176776885986,
0.42329829931259155,
0.5027933716773987,
0.9865150451660156,
0.4380311667919159,
-0.24649906158447266,
0.8245812058448792,
-0.337354451417923,
0.21112705767154694,
1.2120192050933838,
-0.5819587111473083,
0.7792407870292664,
0.8128234148025513,
-0.11017715185880661,
0.4871664345264435,
0.3703143298625946,
-0.6402461528778076,
0.7769442200660706,
0.427507609128952,
-0.007849358953535557,
-0.28938332200050354,
0.15435029566287994,
-0.294278085231781,
0.2704695165157318,
0.3056122660636902,
-0.3850439190864563,
-0.05841626971960068,
-0.2861464023590088,
0.2427985966205597,
0.3762394189834595,
-0.018650181591510773,
0.7535092830657959,
0.1302955448627472,
-0.933096170425415,
0.5957762598991394,
0.015584318898618221,
0.5823309421539307,
-0.23493726551532745,
0.1804417371749878,
-0.1013091430068016,
0.13585683703422546,
-0.46466606855392456,
-0.6630789637565613,
0.6184170842170715,
0.26692768931388855,
0.1011698767542839,
0.11200200766324997,
0.5745205879211426,
-0.03359358385205269,
-0.3247813880443573,
0.8297320604324341,
0.17363621294498444,
0.05070120096206665,
0.14551138877868652,
-0.740658164024353,
0.4043653905391693,
0.011239999905228615,
0.0653785988688469,
0.26598966121673584,
0.04987145587801933,
-0.1352313756942749,
0.7903777360916138,
0.4551074802875519,
0.2632817327976227,
0.15312455594539642,
0.1438681185245514,
0.7390454411506653,
-0.7737073302268982,
-0.24108655750751495,
-1.3538323640823364,
0.5565686225891113,
-0.07702666521072388,
-0.3107323944568634,
0.7734047174453735,
0.7484084367752075,
0.7170994877815247,
0.17818203568458557,
0.4921058416366577,
-0.14833952486515045,
0.13522247970104218,
-0.4069838523864746,
1.0380216836929321,
-0.4418160319328308,
0.47698619961738586,
-0.40588417649269104,
-1.019039511680603,
-0.45017343759536743,
0.8408923745155334,
-0.4314160645008087,
-0.03503507748246193,
0.8472804427146912,
0.9888678789138794,
0.3060639202594757,
0.07482894510030746,
0.41732633113861084,
0.342194139957428,
0.13522212207317352,
0.713371992111206,
1.1447852849960327,
-0.34652113914489746,
0.44298890233039856,
-0.35267820954322815,
-0.13318932056427002,
-0.3285538852214813,
-0.9095025062561035,
-1.0411542654037476,
-0.21344439685344696,
-0.4820292592048645,
-0.7055209875106812,
0.4244263768196106,
0.9693037271499634,
0.5287377834320068,
-0.8856759667396545,
-0.2921942472457886,
-0.18023693561553955,
0.09569870680570602,
-0.1693444848060608,
-0.18931220471858978,
-0.04559459909796715,
-0.23019416630268097,
-0.31958481669425964,
0.5338940024375916,
0.42428573966026306,
0.02259814739227295,
-0.3291245400905609,
-0.05606166645884514,
0.11297127604484558,
-0.06808823347091675,
0.19467122852802277,
0.1968679577112198,
-0.7693100571632385,
-0.5750738978385925,
-0.1399121731519699,
-0.22961822152137756,
0.12025542557239532,
0.5421223044395447,
-0.6464033722877502,
0.333833783864975,
0.1661282628774643,
0.6669225096702576,
0.06373536586761475,
-0.035685550421476364,
0.43881282210350037,
-0.5786424279212952,
0.348810613155365,
0.4345046281814575,
0.4140889346599579,
0.33674681186676025,
-0.3234720230102539,
0.5653616786003113,
0.002195213921368122,
-0.5877261161804199,
-1.3143582344055176,
0.24316389858722687,
-0.8846853971481323,
-0.22245748341083527,
1.2224524021148682,
-0.2194642871618271,
-0.35832926630973816,
-0.14496475458145142,
0.3142108917236328,
0.12460438907146454,
-0.5018801689147949,
1.1495376825332642,
0.6247759461402893,
0.07813947647809982,
-0.0003075599670410156,
-0.4545222222805023,
0.3684806525707245,
0.47087547183036804,
-0.7464147806167603,
0.23937129974365234,
0.40947622060775757,
0.12470197677612305,
0.2431303709745407,
0.11220921576023102,
-0.29073566198349,
0.4189497232437134,
0.10123956948518753,
0.023094477131962776,
-0.15536488592624664,
-0.5360414385795593,
-0.17447856068611145,
0.03173687309026718,
0.1768341213464737,
-0.19129230082035065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11665v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11665v1 | See It from My Perspective: Diagnosing the Western Cultural Bias of Large Vision-Language Models in Image Understanding | 2024-06-17T15:49:51 | 2024-06-17T15:49:51 | Amith Ananthram, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Carl Vondrick, Mohit Bansal, Kathleen McKeown | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Vision-language models (VLMs) can respond to queries about images in many
languages. However, beyond language, culture affects how we see things. For
example, individuals from Western cultures focus more on the central figure in
an image while individuals from Eastern cultures attend more to scene context.
In this work, we present a novel investigation that demonstrates and localizes
VLMs' Western bias in image understanding. We evaluate large VLMs across
subjective and objective visual tasks with culturally diverse images and
annotations. We find that VLMs perform better on the Western subset than the
Eastern subset of each task. Controlled experimentation tracing the source of
this bias highlights the importance of a diverse language mix in text-only
pre-training for building equitable VLMs, even when inference is performed in
English. Moreover, while prompting in the language of a target culture can lead
to reductions in bias, it is not a substitute for building AI more
representative of the world's languages. | [
-0.609323263168335,
-0.42703691124916077,
0.4066835343837738,
0.17868009209632874,
-0.30917561054229736,
-0.16389870643615723,
-0.4238760769367218,
-1.0020159482955933,
0.05715973302721977,
0.5153726935386658,
-0.663057267665863,
-0.3323197364807129,
-0.6290112733840942,
0.01429655309766531,
-0.0992538332939148,
0.6522184014320374,
-0.10194046795368195,
0.6486459970474243,
-0.17650221288204193,
-0.5697665214538574,
-0.322387158870697,
-0.5241571068763733,
-0.3456718921661377,
-0.2378108948469162,
0.3488764464855194,
0.06174929067492485,
0.6685769557952881,
0.5014210939407349,
0.4743017554283142,
0.26344606280326843,
-0.079355388879776,
0.04996061697602272,
-0.4684993028640747,
-0.037088070064783096,
-0.1580294966697693,
-0.6842135190963745,
0.22091539204120636,
0.06413881480693817,
0.35076695680618286,
0.8187075853347778,
0.2459145486354828,
0.555785596370697,
0.007129061035811901,
0.5642390847206116,
-0.9836509227752686,
0.046242449432611465,
-0.5617697834968567,
0.3863120675086975,
-0.09189542382955551,
0.07476967573165894,
-0.5140470266342163,
0.22032688558101654,
0.5319279432296753,
-0.5465947985649109,
0.21300160884857178,
0.025315457955002785,
1.0423846244812012,
0.3273473381996155,
-0.6137027740478516,
0.1728319525718689,
-0.7975170612335205,
0.9434897303581238,
-0.13396096229553223,
0.5372986197471619,
0.3724818527698517,
0.368846595287323,
0.29217270016670227,
-0.3855310380458832,
-0.43477845191955566,
0.02646060846745968,
-0.2680109739303589,
0.13440322875976562,
-0.15337422490119934,
-0.33523496985435486,
0.4370407164096832,
0.14797210693359375,
-0.4250156879425049,
-0.0033173400443047285,
-0.5279644131660461,
-0.46337875723838806,
0.5944488048553467,
-0.11738904565572739,
0.4656808376312256,
0.13734273612499237,
-0.32210758328437805,
0.026497988030314445,
-0.6167988181114197,
0.16865681111812592,
0.03138121962547302,
-0.10804232209920883,
-0.2745087742805481,
0.3349463641643524,
-0.2624916732311249,
1.099916934967041,
-0.3222258985042572,
-0.22487443685531616,
0.07419226318597794,
-0.20403726398944855,
-0.3620888292789459,
-0.10396924614906311,
0.3754321038722992,
0.8646553754806519,
0.6877740621566772,
0.0935012474656105,
-0.01329806074500084,
0.2794075310230255,
0.20977254211902618,
-0.6178374886512756,
0.009612886235117912,
-0.38817527890205383,
-0.8423639535903931,
-0.14325816929340363,
-0.13044993579387665,
-0.3150613009929657,
-0.6177722215652466,
-0.4474036395549774,
0.2872175872325897,
-0.07713860273361206,
-0.19003789126873016,
-0.22375454008579254,
-0.305975079536438,
0.641293466091156,
0.4750857949256897,
-0.5818226933479309,
-0.10415852069854736,
0.22873833775520325,
0.5777769088745117,
0.14751051366329193,
-0.4952903687953949,
-0.5331254005432129,
0.03679213672876358,
-0.5150654911994934,
0.8147729635238647,
-0.6680474281311035,
-0.26737263798713684,
0.23296242952346802,
0.10820122063159943,
0.31738096475601196,
-0.5123985409736633,
0.19816315174102783,
-0.44840583205223083,
0.3579956889152527,
-0.7251947522163391,
0.32428643107414246,
-0.3106415271759033,
0.39269745349884033,
-0.431629478931427,
0.5838527679443359,
-0.138226717710495,
-0.8432691097259521,
0.9924054145812988,
-0.23521512746810913,
-0.569769024848938,
-0.005836627911776304,
-0.529444694519043,
0.1664767563343048,
0.3774758577346802,
0.5758987069129944,
0.17402540147304535,
-0.16232115030288696,
0.0023785450030118227,
-0.29481732845306396,
-0.4166141450405121,
0.13175424933433533,
-0.316803902387619,
0.7205474972724915,
0.3885926604270935,
-0.32488223910331726,
0.1204189583659172,
-0.6753561496734619,
-0.16133137047290802,
0.3841930329799652,
0.06741530448198318,
-0.9778508543968201,
0.12009711563587189,
0.21798504889011383,
0.3639272451400757,
0.0742153525352478,
-0.40963903069496155,
-0.0927734449505806,
-0.052347347140312195,
0.1926274299621582,
0.7362716794013977,
-0.5353250503540039,
0.6288754343986511,
-0.012584298849105835,
0.3052525520324707,
0.2949914038181305,
0.33825570344924927,
-0.323204904794693,
-0.3430582284927368,
-0.8863152861595154,
-0.22310613095760345,
-0.2229519784450531,
0.35479941964149475,
-1.072544813156128,
-0.3451787233352661,
-0.0597364567220211,
-0.2157740592956543,
-0.7037352919578552,
0.07616505771875381,
0.4772403836250305,
0.591966450214386,
0.13157886266708374,
-0.6120269894599915,
-0.5190495848655701,
-1.3090790510177612,
-0.47978946566581726,
-0.20894227921962738,
-0.17683875560760498,
0.377677321434021,
0.25808200240135193,
-0.15169695019721985,
0.7065156698226929,
-0.5332986116409302,
-0.3761623501777649,
-0.21833489835262299,
-0.17097207903862,
-0.04592623561620712,
0.13963931798934937,
0.7115151882171631,
-0.8824643492698669,
-0.551095724105835,
0.12178247421979904,
-0.9379584193229675,
-0.05246312543749809,
0.03032713010907173,
-0.38241708278656006,
0.3430017828941345,
0.44506368041038513,
0.08680079132318497,
0.6893911361694336,
0.5183767676353455,
-0.6742756962776184,
0.2248639315366745,
-0.3076339662075043,
0.2399740219116211,
-0.6222766637802124,
-0.16118580102920532,
0.5240930914878845,
-0.25650861859321594,
-0.3712722659111023,
0.22305001318454742,
0.14614497125148773,
0.14369544386863708,
-0.49811530113220215,
0.3702854514122009,
-0.6167714595794678,
-0.38763368129730225,
-0.09660396724939346,
0.10060484707355499,
0.05762701481580734,
0.2677081227302551,
0.7044461965560913,
0.5139633417129517,
0.8206087946891785,
-0.40369948744773865,
-0.1438797414302826,
0.07457375526428223,
-0.628805935382843,
1.0149757862091064,
-0.362975150346756,
-0.03487522527575493,
-0.6979852914810181,
0.2251991182565689,
-0.7718405723571777,
-0.09966647624969482,
0.16135917603969574,
-0.22301368415355682,
0.15567584335803986,
-0.35984835028648376,
-0.05333075672388077,
-0.41684097051620483,
-0.011984743177890778,
0.5994812846183777,
0.7652906775474548,
-0.7192946076393127,
0.5082924962043762,
0.3068176209926605,
0.27492350339889526,
-0.916674017906189,
-1.0174013376235962,
0.0027747389394789934,
-0.1325400471687317,
-0.846173882484436,
-0.0905308723449707,
0.1709441989660263,
-0.8416555523872375,
-0.09643305093050003,
-0.12626373767852783,
-0.1888159066438675,
0.12874221801757812,
0.17587071657180786,
0.39863917231559753,
-0.45238426327705383,
-0.1852332353591919,
-0.30741259455680847,
0.1969517022371292,
0.05140340328216553,
-0.5585263967514038,
0.3556305468082428,
0.04488435760140419,
-0.3541557490825653,
-0.23129861056804657,
0.4641256630420685,
0.6890596151351929,
-0.7163015604019165,
0.8229857087135315,
0.7159084677696228,
-0.18373803794384003,
-0.09588723629713058,
-0.5639694333076477,
-0.06872647255659103,
-0.3935694396495819,
0.5264047384262085,
-0.39409759640693665,
-0.5781182646751404,
0.5166483521461487,
0.33989670872688293,
0.1175483763217926,
0.22943609952926636,
0.4801377058029175,
-0.14613527059555054,
1.0230193138122559,
0.989825427532196,
0.0002662675688043237,
0.6370542645454407,
-0.25578200817108154,
0.26157134771347046,
-0.6646462082862854,
-0.3391956686973572,
-0.4062965512275696,
-0.47266438603401184,
-0.46126648783683777,
-0.5446137189865112,
0.3872009515762329,
-0.33192551136016846,
-0.08090031892061234,
-0.31948333978652954,
-0.4459167718887329,
0.8113985657691956,
0.505304217338562,
0.045167695730924606,
0.43721261620521545,
0.22344471514225006,
0.022301994264125824,
-0.42194923758506775,
-0.5177888870239258,
-0.45255109667778015,
0.8842754364013672,
0.27949485182762146,
0.8177866339683533,
-0.11101037263870239,
0.39671698212623596,
0.057582076638936996,
0.591023862361908,
-0.8235552310943604,
0.3707813322544098,
-0.15393607318401337,
-0.6648329496383667,
0.042453065514564514,
-0.0089570926502347,
-0.6481893062591553,
0.8668755888938904,
-0.13301591575145721,
-0.7974902987480164,
0.15533387660980225,
0.2624817490577698,
0.12754955887794495,
0.2318374216556549,
-0.8399305939674377,
0.8379594683647156,
-0.2054053097963333,
-0.46047088503837585,
-0.2028409093618393,
-0.7372504472732544,
0.6239447593688965,
0.20453397929668427,
0.7808435559272766,
0.11436289548873901,
0.035971932113170624,
0.45059382915496826,
-0.24279017746448517,
0.8474857807159424,
-0.3489739000797272,
-0.22559335827827454,
0.0611378438770771,
0.17160747945308685,
0.024820463731884956,
-0.04793757200241089,
0.2778593599796295,
0.34025242924690247,
0.05618515610694885,
-0.7772981524467468,
-0.41959118843078613,
0.5323584675788879,
-0.8783255815505981,
-0.6625948548316956,
-0.33370712399482727,
-0.5939008593559265,
-0.22126026451587677,
0.09940294176340103,
0.4296570420265198,
0.5898024439811707,
-0.13259820640087128,
-0.11107712239027023,
0.4999271333217621,
-0.4527236521244049,
0.4042704701423645,
0.6445372104644775,
-0.5517216324806213,
0.218753844499588,
0.6239064335823059,
0.21811991930007935,
0.4204806983470917,
0.11618557572364807,
0.056436214596033096,
0.0868382528424263,
-0.36180639266967773,
-0.604335606098175,
0.09069831669330597,
-1.1679890155792236,
0.396302729845047,
-0.4780395030975342,
0.17119455337524414,
-0.055704694241285324,
-0.3440791666507721,
-0.19508372247219086,
0.07605823874473572,
0.31054428219795227,
0.059622932225465775,
0.06427904218435287,
0.8652492761611938,
0.05803268402814865,
0.20679979026317596,
-0.5526208281517029,
0.2316513955593109,
0.3047420382499695,
0.28874096274375916,
0.12002160400152206,
-0.46208661794662476,
-0.39636898040771484,
0.08034276217222214,
0.032720740884542465,
-0.7011178135871887,
0.4464913010597229,
0.038094837218523026,
0.5952587723731995,
0.49399447441101074,
-0.0848260223865509,
0.8131108283996582,
-0.552945077419281,
1.0309702157974243,
0.1175645962357521,
-0.825931966304779,
0.5307024717330933,
-0.09270190447568893,
0.5445191264152527,
0.2533946633338928,
0.32047972083091736,
-0.7383341193199158,
-0.6911837458610535,
-0.31281179189682007,
-0.6952967047691345,
0.7499749064445496,
-0.22207921743392944,
0.2771245241165161,
0.158904567360878,
-0.11135454475879669,
0.15490667521953583,
0.007611069828271866,
-1.0553497076034546,
-0.4353327453136444,
-0.2920326590538025,
-0.04643069952726364,
-0.21211478114128113,
-0.09435958415269852,
-0.3465977609157562,
-0.4004816710948944,
0.24938514828681946,
-0.29523512721061707,
0.024506090208888054,
0.5920154452323914,
-0.75408536195755,
-0.2975281774997711,
-0.08268367499113083,
0.5895196199417114,
0.9451152086257935,
0.21323487162590027,
0.26840829849243164,
0.26171284914016724,
-0.5814873576164246,
-0.18767149746418,
-0.20400778949260712,
-0.36204105615615845,
0.07961048185825348,
0.6714836955070496,
0.9736014008522034,
-0.24273504316806793,
-0.7676450610160828,
0.402398943901062,
-0.5513397455215454,
-0.04745092988014221,
-0.3249613046646118,
-0.24964454770088196,
-0.2719058692455292,
0.45062851905822754,
0.5801724195480347,
0.33197247982025146,
0.14190642535686493,
-0.8085991144180298,
-0.24610935151576996,
0.6263090372085571,
-0.749061644077301,
-0.22179251909255981,
0.5488222241401672,
0.16215723752975464,
-0.05318829044699669,
0.42543673515319824,
0.0804869681596756,
-0.7490891218185425,
0.7715462446212769,
0.4876934587955475,
0.4684739112854004,
0.1767747849225998,
0.2622523307800293,
0.1765758991241455,
0.5770943760871887,
0.16588544845581055,
0.21525900065898895,
-0.27259406447410583,
-0.9093102216720581,
-0.6723656058311462,
-0.5711160898208618,
0.027368687093257904,
-0.11483718454837799,
-0.6624734401702881,
0.1721542626619339,
-0.20961587131023407,
0.14221496880054474,
-0.03331323713064194,
-0.48616135120391846,
-1.0637377500534058,
0.4692225754261017,
0.8384096026420593,
0.7686647176742554,
-1.0713468790054321,
0.8463671207427979,
1.006173014640808,
-0.22327187657356262,
-0.7065923810005188,
0.3088185489177704,
0.01494240015745163,
-1.1859716176986694,
1.1147947311401367,
0.3972826600074768,
-0.033703044056892395,
-0.43531495332717896,
-0.6731007695198059,
-0.6848766803741455,
0.6987484693527222,
0.2629934549331665,
-0.35173165798187256,
0.24927765130996704,
-0.2216617465019226,
0.6137228608131409,
-0.45837879180908203,
0.40096962451934814,
0.563670814037323,
0.346475750207901,
0.08527597784996033,
-1.0414299964904785,
-0.12229282408952713,
-0.1755267083644867,
0.08742129057645798,
0.17191557586193085,
-0.673579216003418,
0.4493890404701233,
-0.4892739951610565,
0.1310848593711853,
-0.3136788308620453,
0.5590673089027405,
-0.04999682679772377,
0.44304147362709045,
0.5531992316246033,
0.07994341850280762,
0.5242482423782349,
-0.1387895941734314,
1.3153507709503174,
-0.06705503910779953,
-0.02537575550377369,
0.8101394772529602,
-0.2021263986825943,
0.5250287055969238,
0.7682856321334839,
-0.032300323247909546,
0.4375965893268585,
0.6220418214797974,
0.21916179358959198,
0.6895013451576233,
0.2317202240228653,
-0.11711635440587997,
-0.3484715223312378,
-0.5007542371749878,
-0.3829900920391083,
0.6839277744293213,
0.13922323286533356,
-0.5553721785545349,
-0.08423366397619247,
0.26741865277290344,
-0.13443779945373535,
0.22092372179031372,
-0.6245797872543335,
0.6828078627586365,
0.034308258444070816,
-0.7796546220779419,
0.6222253441810608,
-0.3071933686733246,
0.8181207180023193,
-0.4296722114086151,
0.21988412737846375,
-0.21623548865318298,
-0.005327652208507061,
-0.1885039210319519,
-0.683182418346405,
0.26572689414024353,
0.08159498870372772,
-0.2805388867855072,
-0.2912691831588745,
0.6555636525154114,
-0.37350285053253174,
-0.5115236043930054,
0.40560203790664673,
0.5558120012283325,
0.053977470844984055,
0.05873364582657814,
-0.27683088183403015,
0.2619800269603729,
0.3020748496055603,
-0.1666843146085739,
0.3720012307167053,
0.43271100521087646,
-0.5244560241699219,
0.42996326088905334,
0.34994977712631226,
0.08173337578773499,
0.026446586474776268,
0.2227654904127121,
0.41873830556869507,
-0.5013593435287476,
-0.48451924324035645,
-0.9342195391654968,
0.533070981502533,
-0.2778186500072479,
-0.13049601018428802,
0.4395599663257599,
0.14000138640403748,
1.3045682907104492,
-0.34294456243515015,
0.9523643851280212,
-0.03077063523232937,
-0.1572108119726181,
-0.42639821767807007,
0.8095228672027588,
-0.9770985245704651,
-0.1348528265953064,
-0.19676606357097626,
-0.8716297745704651,
-0.24592331051826477,
0.90843266248703,
-0.6751280426979065,
-0.2790778875350952,
0.6188527345657349,
0.3927226662635803,
0.11761156469583511,
-0.06923288106918335,
0.5449818968772888,
0.25474703311920166,
0.09373440593481064,
0.27538904547691345,
1.2608044147491455,
0.06991167366504669,
0.45845845341682434,
-0.3696083426475525,
-0.27743586897850037,
0.10071921348571777,
-0.7477688789367676,
-0.8980754017829895,
-0.4940432608127594,
-0.16930697858333588,
-0.20833608508110046,
-0.29767078161239624,
0.8487932682037354,
0.8690449595451355,
-0.4323613941669464,
-0.13060972094535828,
0.4751831889152527,
0.21686162054538727,
-0.06468219310045242,
-0.14895562827587128,
-0.13640747964382172,
-0.20189911127090454,
-0.8602600693702698,
-0.1300375759601593,
0.37374603748321533,
-0.012644889764487743,
-0.44864562153816223,
0.050002433359622955,
0.355167031288147,
-0.11505953222513199,
0.8200772404670715,
0.06517362594604492,
-0.9313761591911316,
-0.27889513969421387,
0.04297351464629173,
-0.06708461791276932,
0.10468084365129471,
0.7895824909210205,
-0.7666208148002625,
0.7639117240905762,
0.3633275330066681,
0.36411595344543457,
0.5174574851989746,
-0.48987531661987305,
0.9732955694198608,
-0.45989513397216797,
0.8226412534713745,
-0.06467334926128387,
0.6733158230781555,
0.4613068997859955,
-0.29765430092811584,
0.38442206382751465,
0.32404598593711853,
-0.17746363580226898,
-0.7643337249755859,
0.4398964047431946,
-0.6571415662765503,
-0.5038947463035583,
0.9224134087562561,
-0.013268900103867054,
-0.53404301404953,
0.031946614384651184,
-0.6945782899856567,
0.04818861186504364,
0.03469470143318176,
0.534331202507019,
0.7967987060546875,
0.24743084609508514,
-0.10619903355836868,
-0.8418161869049072,
0.31081196665763855,
0.6944852471351624,
-0.32404252886772156,
-0.18392609059810638,
0.8221904039382935,
0.2591501772403717,
0.04837258532643318,
0.49881938099861145,
0.041134875267744064,
0.29231327772140503,
-0.22212299704551697,
0.06690330058336258,
0.39114144444465637,
-0.1396031379699707,
-0.28415730595588684,
-0.07906452566385269,
0.4011242687702179,
-0.19635024666786194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11661v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11661v2 | Cultural Conditioning or Placebo? On the Effectiveness of Socio-Demographic Prompting | 2024-06-17T15:43:45 | 2024-06-20T08:25:08 | Sagnik Mukherjee, Muhammad Farid Adilazuarda, Sunayana Sitaram, Kalika Bali, Alham Fikri Aji, Monojit Choudhury | cs.CL | cs.CL | Socio-demographic prompting is a commonly employed approach to study cultural
biases in LLMs as well as for aligning models to certain cultures. In this
paper, we systematically probe four LLMs (Llama 3, Mistral v0.2, GPT-3.5 Turbo
and GPT-4) with prompts that are conditioned on culturally sensitive and
non-sensitive cues, on datasets that are supposed to be culturally sensitive
(EtiCor and CALI) or neutral (MMLU and ETHICS). We observe that all models
except GPT-4 show significant variations in their responses on both kinds of
datasets for both kinds of prompts, casting doubt on the robustness of the
culturally-conditioned prompting as a method for eliciting cultural bias in
models or as an alignment strategy. The work also calls rethinking the control
experiment design to tease apart the cultural conditioning of responses from
"placebo effect", i.e., random perturbations of model responses due to
arbitrary tokens in the prompt. | [
-0.2175343781709671,
-0.7158931493759155,
0.29864683747291565,
0.44171422719955444,
-0.25627249479293823,
0.18394151329994202,
-0.15193745493888855,
-0.17843028903007507,
0.45062267780303955,
0.060031626373529434,
-0.5970375537872314,
-0.3744630217552185,
-0.3528720736503601,
0.2942380905151367,
0.2301660180091858,
0.9590938091278076,
-0.14675165712833405,
0.5549108386039734,
-0.017644274979829788,
-0.16073450446128845,
-0.6150184273719788,
-0.7916247844696045,
-0.41762110590934753,
-0.5366942286491394,
0.6414734125137329,
0.5188510417938232,
0.5907843708992004,
-0.02522294595837593,
0.1726304590702057,
0.10849491506814957,
-0.21202483773231506,
-0.06639211624860764,
-0.7264359593391418,
-0.0734550729393959,
-0.017892831936478615,
-0.6778591275215149,
-0.2029661387205124,
0.2952321767807007,
0.13165579736232758,
0.5813865661621094,
-0.22974804043769836,
0.5269755125045776,
0.19131533801555634,
0.3138837218284607,
-0.557979166507721,
-0.41472265124320984,
-0.38025200366973877,
0.11686099320650101,
-0.09870164841413498,
-0.5155048966407776,
-0.30723729729652405,
-0.6496778130531311,
-0.15582656860351562,
-0.5362878441810608,
0.4969320595264435,
0.07306014001369476,
0.5742313265800476,
0.47843778133392334,
-0.8365105390548706,
0.047054074704647064,
-0.9117124676704407,
0.6408939361572266,
-0.42464789748191833,
-0.016939034685492516,
0.7284016609191895,
-0.02336128242313862,
-0.27479302883148193,
-0.2660122513771057,
-0.4413996636867523,
-0.30449363589286804,
0.1577160656452179,
0.5974292159080505,
0.26647916436195374,
-0.35141244530677795,
0.5941371917724609,
0.07180247455835342,
-0.42537274956703186,
0.2211942821741104,
-0.7441540360450745,
-0.428544282913208,
0.39141032099723816,
0.3333342671394348,
0.17805613577365875,
-0.14547619223594666,
-0.582728922367096,
0.06707396358251572,
-1.0174975395202637,
0.3577139973640442,
0.5058278441429138,
0.18439310789108276,
-0.393041729927063,
0.5387794971466064,
-0.1279774308204651,
0.3226171135902405,
0.4465560019016266,
0.05839649960398674,
-0.09322817623615265,
-0.4506095051765442,
0.0986824631690979,
0.19064828753471375,
0.43319252133369446,
0.8323954939842224,
0.6382996439933777,
0.22067731618881226,
0.09236065298318863,
0.44289490580558777,
0.2223830670118332,
-0.7006561160087585,
0.026331085711717606,
0.03676648810505867,
-0.45288118720054626,
-0.5561783909797668,
-0.09706512093544006,
-0.4602217972278595,
-0.3939840793609619,
-0.3038921654224396,
0.13896900415420532,
-0.11189016699790955,
-0.13806073367595673,
-0.23124048113822937,
-0.25895822048187256,
0.6542755365371704,
0.24376851320266724,
-0.8905479311943054,
-0.09127101302146912,
0.42029720544815063,
0.7337866425514221,
-0.26405343413352966,
-0.06717530637979507,
-0.09937316179275513,
0.0859755277633667,
-0.6110778450965881,
0.8184064626693726,
-0.7339451313018799,
-0.9698873162269592,
-0.1370595246553421,
0.0939585268497467,
-0.05399799346923828,
-0.395786851644516,
0.4348474144935608,
-0.5057867765426636,
0.23787295818328857,
-1.0960657596588135,
-0.09542673081159592,
0.1426021307706833,
0.25461626052856445,
-0.4292798936367035,
1.0180339813232422,
0.16436222195625305,
-0.5509752631187439,
0.978243887424469,
-0.009093839675188065,
-0.4297758936882019,
0.12748318910598755,
-0.3795461058616638,
-0.015165748074650764,
0.07693720608949661,
0.18312335014343262,
-0.09247224032878876,
-0.2588278353214264,
0.3336539566516876,
-0.8323609828948975,
-0.7978307008743286,
0.42154741287231445,
-0.4059038460254669,
0.8311077952384949,
0.48983243107795715,
-0.39770081639289856,
-0.03805139288306236,
-0.11160795390605927,
-0.3721354305744171,
0.22234347462654114,
-0.3043617606163025,
-0.30140167474746704,
-0.09635933488607407,
-0.34423714876174927,
0.23185288906097412,
0.0896570160984993,
-0.47769877314567566,
0.26877495646476746,
0.15012632310390472,
0.4700888395309448,
0.7745885848999023,
0.16455256938934326,
0.5189635753631592,
-0.696765124797821,
1.064599633216858,
0.03382575884461403,
0.29026585817337036,
0.1356378197669983,
-0.4511432647705078,
-0.28502562642097473,
-0.004196971654891968,
0.2527676224708557,
0.6712738275527954,
-0.9116071462631226,
-0.07957968860864639,
0.19483377039432526,
-0.5476632118225098,
-0.45569878816604614,
-0.08143697679042816,
0.08923040330410004,
0.8118333220481873,
-0.08981023728847504,
-0.203823521733284,
-0.19820906221866608,
-0.8456204533576965,
-0.33248311281204224,
-0.20756837725639343,
-0.05426368862390518,
0.23105302453041077,
0.542218804359436,
0.2452724725008011,
0.8151787519454956,
-0.29926368594169617,
0.09031225740909576,
0.09336300939321518,
-0.027621867135167122,
0.1649431437253952,
0.39281877875328064,
0.8632820844650269,
-0.7424164414405823,
-0.30165621638298035,
-0.3941437005996704,
-0.5793337225914001,
-0.4510408937931061,
0.2341422587633133,
-0.15409770607948303,
0.062114063650369644,
0.33191555738449097,
-0.3078290522098541,
0.675203800201416,
0.45151227712631226,
-0.20394816994667053,
0.780189037322998,
0.02715202048420906,
0.5651277899742126,
-0.8581428527832031,
-0.012215269729495049,
0.13984350860118866,
0.24438729882240295,
-0.7553773522377014,
-0.34171634912490845,
0.31551074981689453,
-0.22079052031040192,
-0.5167366862297058,
0.5560805797576904,
-0.23865236341953278,
0.12836115062236786,
-0.060635484755039215,
-0.03632573410868645,
-0.0749027207493782,
0.27643948793411255,
0.13099096715450287,
0.9253334403038025,
0.19999925792217255,
-0.7689463496208191,
0.004388852976262569,
0.1767498254776001,
-0.12509892880916595,
1.012019395828247,
-0.7072656154632568,
0.4375455379486084,
-0.44331464171409607,
0.9694329500198364,
-1.0758644342422485,
-0.44307661056518555,
0.4986979365348816,
-0.48243382573127747,
-0.2632898688316345,
-0.1628088653087616,
-0.0191141739487648,
-0.5832768082618713,
-0.49474576115608215,
0.6124666333198547,
0.679133415222168,
-0.2572673261165619,
0.41598522663116455,
-0.04847161844372749,
-0.1848461925983429,
-0.5370784401893616,
-0.6514057517051697,
-0.17008697986602783,
-0.883297860622406,
-0.4803116023540497,
0.26717323064804077,
-0.2198614776134491,
-0.4044141173362732,
-0.4462866187095642,
-0.2554561495780945,
0.4295780658721924,
0.27913111448287964,
0.11141616106033325,
0.3907513916492462,
-0.011464698240160942,
-0.16306659579277039,
-0.10999098420143127,
-0.04715641215443611,
0.018712623044848442,
0.05002521350979805,
0.44094762206077576,
0.366561621427536,
-0.5578891634941101,
-0.39939579367637634,
0.18422211706638336,
0.263927698135376,
-0.10782968252897263,
0.56026691198349,
0.46754521131515503,
-0.1848309189081192,
0.2169550061225891,
-0.5700746774673462,
-0.5392624735832214,
-0.4499848484992981,
-0.33447694778442383,
-0.3261176347732544,
-0.9949184060096741,
0.9220914840698242,
0.0619429312646389,
-0.18373705446720123,
0.13734473288059235,
0.895703136920929,
-0.13619522750377655,
1.034900188446045,
0.11240372806787491,
-0.06496662646532059,
0.6886297464370728,
0.05655137449502945,
0.12143918871879578,
-0.781477153301239,
-0.34110352396965027,
-0.6420686841011047,
-0.7575951814651489,
-0.7026153802871704,
-0.2413415163755417,
0.3818912208080292,
-0.08273013681173325,
-0.40282735228538513,
-0.36612561345100403,
-0.3254392147064209,
0.40906059741973877,
0.5000998973846436,
0.20314764976501465,
-0.07848436385393143,
-0.027413636445999146,
-0.1803092509508133,
-0.13880915939807892,
-0.8566350936889648,
-0.38658255338668823,
0.7879403233528137,
0.11138331145048141,
1.1879246234893799,
0.15877752006053925,
0.4432626962661743,
0.23869627714157104,
0.7887889742851257,
-0.6061626672744751,
0.15341414511203766,
0.06241905689239502,
-0.9993489384651184,
0.1529240757226944,
-0.12392723560333252,
-0.9286539554595947,
0.2935240864753723,
-0.0015211299760267138,
-0.7102360129356384,
0.7651486992835999,
0.5494794249534607,
-0.6553350687026978,
-0.2046252191066742,
-0.8867949843406677,
0.3428160846233368,
-0.45650699734687805,
-0.5752691626548767,
0.2142646610736847,
-0.7307466268539429,
0.503507673740387,
-0.13115686178207397,
0.34849345684051514,
-0.37224918603897095,
0.14383788406848907,
0.5824177265167236,
-0.15569700300693512,
1.224956750869751,
-0.6145090460777283,
-0.23720507323741913,
0.17097371816635132,
0.14484161138534546,
0.28921884298324585,
0.15086577832698822,
-0.293377548456192,
0.05106280371546745,
0.21114444732666016,
-0.5978263020515442,
-0.3520979881286621,
0.5065896511077881,
-0.8458454012870789,
-0.9461570978164673,
-0.364901065826416,
-0.41057902574539185,
-0.12148375064134598,
-0.2718820571899414,
0.5338794589042664,
0.41388648748397827,
-0.2992526590824127,
0.13792647421360016,
0.46983543038368225,
-0.40088823437690735,
-0.05817204341292381,
0.7150309681892395,
-0.03187711909413338,
-0.3938025236129761,
0.15897826850414276,
0.18702244758605957,
0.4821789860725403,
-0.2512562870979309,
0.29532381892204285,
-0.22660475969314575,
-0.0046310569159686565,
-0.17781275510787964,
0.18624860048294067,
-0.6096760630607605,
-0.07643686980009079,
-0.014561166986823082,
0.1604371964931488,
-0.912889301776886,
-0.31017565727233887,
0.3702837824821472,
-0.10854154825210571,
-0.225021094083786,
-0.2701966166496277,
0.4404219388961792,
0.7049345374107361,
-0.00955955870449543,
0.4408489465713501,
-0.274645060300827,
0.11804277449846268,
-0.01988660730421543,
0.011898037046194077,
-0.033023685216903687,
-0.765415608882904,
0.1502525508403778,
0.09128094464540482,
-0.023818785324692726,
-1.1052076816558838,
0.07184424251317978,
-0.19448359310626984,
0.5559967756271362,
0.5839980244636536,
0.3703248202800751,
0.8165929317474365,
-0.2509789764881134,
1.1124787330627441,
-0.23395249247550964,
-0.4615947902202606,
0.5158129930496216,
-0.5287706255912781,
0.5783362984657288,
0.48648136854171753,
0.5777267813682556,
-0.685442328453064,
-0.4822281002998352,
-0.6626958847045898,
-0.7619819045066833,
0.6948420405387878,
-0.15897640585899353,
0.22662070393562317,
-0.32429173588752747,
0.6314499378204346,
0.12208203226327896,
0.19837403297424316,
-0.5898658037185669,
-0.12968920171260834,
-0.263214111328125,
-0.0737152025103569,
-0.05139820650219917,
-0.42485475540161133,
-0.6265413761138916,
0.021286217495799065,
0.24318546056747437,
-0.043640583753585815,
-0.07362105697393417,
0.46236199140548706,
-0.19475987553596497,
-0.26641443371772766,
0.17932939529418945,
0.7953316569328308,
0.7576937079429626,
-0.1744728535413742,
0.07806967943906784,
0.6320764422416687,
-0.34533536434173584,
0.5868512392044067,
-0.2600431442260742,
-0.38373857736587524,
-0.48515647649765015,
0.3845776319503784,
0.5609986782073975,
0.14915668964385986,
0.1433514952659607,
0.16778399050235748,
-0.2364458590745926,
-0.353922963142395,
-0.4278516173362732,
0.10486926138401031,
-0.06227599084377289,
0.027338458225131035,
0.22121989727020264,
-0.33686164021492004,
-0.17423789203166962,
-0.5041899681091309,
-0.2799853980541229,
0.4367041289806366,
-0.39870646595954895,
-0.39447271823883057,
1.0658801794052124,
0.3592671751976013,
-0.4008929431438446,
0.6927003264427185,
0.16129682958126068,
-0.5895195603370667,
0.7889500856399536,
0.7324740290641785,
0.26697036623954773,
-0.6548556089401245,
0.3927817940711975,
0.30532023310661316,
0.3875819146633148,
0.03758746013045311,
0.45814138650894165,
-0.20246127247810364,
-1.279393196105957,
-0.5508630275726318,
-0.3307940661907196,
-0.3361380994319916,
-0.07250028103590012,
-0.9817782044410706,
0.08723382651805878,
-0.2643106281757355,
-0.6504936218261719,
-0.3300720453262329,
-0.17091520130634308,
-0.8054218888282776,
0.06780718266963959,
0.20257742702960968,
0.9778873324394226,
-1.3490217924118042,
0.6201842427253723,
0.8426308035850525,
-0.2890871465206146,
-0.9766502380371094,
0.06258131563663483,
0.5354560613632202,
-1.0221171379089355,
0.6650296449661255,
0.015118120238184929,
-0.1099601536989212,
-0.1820836365222931,
-0.7132250666618347,
-0.9230939149856567,
1.00627601146698,
0.2668212950229645,
-0.16036666929721832,
0.3528980314731598,
-0.0673835426568985,
0.4559571146965027,
-0.14497709274291992,
0.3356797397136688,
1.0000061988830566,
0.7371706366539001,
0.19345633685588837,
-0.6772348880767822,
0.1312635838985443,
-0.30707848072052,
0.17199017107486725,
-0.09336217492818832,
-0.9965941905975342,
0.5650142431259155,
-0.30866768956184387,
-0.08010946959257126,
-0.0780651867389679,
0.479291170835495,
0.9319910407066345,
0.43907713890075684,
0.7681151032447815,
0.11507795006036758,
0.7740257978439331,
-0.34026670455932617,
1.401585340499878,
-0.3560190796852112,
-0.02657957747578621,
0.5375670790672302,
-0.8940697312355042,
0.27025002241134644,
0.6254755854606628,
-0.21634572744369507,
0.2737981379032135,
1.5365992784500122,
0.12207061797380447,
0.4382140636444092,
0.2232223004102707,
-0.11712481081485748,
-0.07671714574098587,
-0.4316084086894989,
-0.41177406907081604,
0.3602837920188904,
0.3828940689563751,
0.1532774269580841,
0.11750796437263489,
-0.07917521893978119,
0.39050254225730896,
-0.26244261860847473,
-0.06193505600094795,
0.5996021032333374,
0.2982998192310333,
-0.9687341451644897,
0.40913358330726624,
-0.21629434823989868,
0.683899462223053,
-0.733532726764679,
0.3601905405521393,
-0.7940049767494202,
-0.2631092071533203,
-0.34265753626823425,
-0.30711719393730164,
-0.10733822733163834,
-0.033369556069374084,
-0.12415450811386108,
-0.2825530767440796,
0.7335447669029236,
-0.34473979473114014,
-0.22109590470790863,
0.15194590389728546,
0.43131792545318604,
0.10921995341777802,
0.3708610236644745,
-0.5238288640975952,
-0.1327267289161682,
0.11235778778791428,
-0.47858285903930664,
0.21564827859401703,
0.4984457790851593,
-0.5058819055557251,
0.5300349593162537,
0.8271441459655762,
0.39447322487831116,
-0.15852993726730347,
0.5951852798461914,
0.41786569356918335,
-0.703031599521637,
-0.610785961151123,
-0.8573077917098999,
0.381198525428772,
-0.00014271157851908356,
-0.31833338737487793,
0.8890597224235535,
-0.10299476236104965,
0.5044671297073364,
0.0483909472823143,
0.6983384490013123,
-0.08800069987773895,
-0.07119305431842804,
-0.6234569549560547,
0.3799540102481842,
-0.42171961069107056,
0.11811741441488266,
0.0037516190204769373,
-0.8678179383277893,
0.061436377465724945,
0.4035140872001648,
-0.7721081376075745,
0.622013509273529,
0.7282282114028931,
0.9540480971336365,
0.43040791153907776,
0.1366252303123474,
0.043679129332304,
0.02190326899290085,
0.24366243183612823,
0.044955622404813766,
1.4126167297363281,
0.5718281865119934,
0.13063542544841766,
-0.07411735504865646,
-0.48731040954589844,
-0.18683229386806488,
-0.8303861618041992,
-0.5175423622131348,
-0.20422638952732086,
0.0011652300599962473,
-0.41786155104637146,
-0.14229649305343628,
0.9545240998268127,
0.325192928314209,
-0.6163334250450134,
-0.19532620906829834,
0.9077327847480774,
0.012996705248951912,
-0.2740103304386139,
-0.20140761137008667,
0.14703279733657837,
0.020152244716882706,
-0.6759451627731323,
0.16522732377052307,
-0.0005175904952920973,
0.1906149685382843,
-0.24394075572490692,
0.1325063854455948,
0.0930248573422432,
0.05217446759343147,
0.3826540410518646,
0.005093997810035944,
-0.6619532704353333,
-0.3748423457145691,
0.08733849972486496,
0.10804158449172974,
-0.11045458912849426,
1.0800422430038452,
-0.556757390499115,
0.04183151200413704,
0.4285612106323242,
0.030381647869944572,
0.25880199670791626,
0.6051962971687317,
0.8748924136161804,
-0.699653148651123,
0.5008122324943542,
0.05173090845346451,
0.4829167425632477,
0.40292543172836304,
-0.6089423298835754,
0.5900557041168213,
0.211805060505867,
-0.7808945775032043,
-0.6489296555519104,
0.3592757284641266,
-0.5453399419784546,
-0.16181689500808716,
1.444334626197815,
0.26677125692367554,
-0.3057945966720581,
-0.0017571779899299145,
-0.3438650965690613,
0.32034432888031006,
-0.49900850653648376,
0.9861761331558228,
1.0012187957763672,
-0.13576103746891022,
0.20141400396823883,
-0.8653669953346252,
0.3900952637195587,
0.7662827372550964,
-0.33578699827194214,
-0.2741321921348572,
0.48841601610183716,
0.539267361164093,
-0.1805856078863144,
0.9493995904922485,
-0.07575595378875732,
0.22842656075954437,
-0.32197245955467224,
-0.06794419884681702,
0.3420608639717102,
0.13184019923210144,
-0.714383602142334,
-0.284281849861145,
0.11541537195444107,
0.2293541580438614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11657v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11657v1 | Can LLM be a Personalized Judge? | 2024-06-17T15:41:30 | 2024-06-17T15:41:30 | Yijiang River Dong, Tiancheng Hu, Nigel Collier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Ensuring that large language models (LLMs) reflect diverse user values and
preferences is crucial as their user bases expand globally. It is therefore
encouraging to see the growing interest in LLM personalization within the
research community. However, current works often rely on the LLM-as-a-Judge
approach for evaluation without thoroughly examining its validity. In this
paper, we investigate the reliability of LLM-as-a-Personalized-Judge, asking
LLMs to judge user preferences based on personas. Our findings suggest that
directly applying LLM-as-a-Personalized-Judge is less reliable than previously
assumed, showing low and inconsistent agreement with human ground truth. The
personas typically used are often overly simplistic, resulting in low
predictive power. To address these issues, we introduce verbal uncertainty
estimation into the LLM-as-a-Personalized-Judge pipeline, allowing the model to
express low confidence on uncertain judgments. This adjustment leads to much
higher agreement (above 80%) on high-certainty samples for binary tasks.
Through human evaluation, we find that the LLM-as-a-Personalized-Judge achieves
comparable performance to third-party humans evaluation and even surpasses
human performance on high-certainty samples. Our work indicates that
certainty-enhanced LLM-as-a-Personalized-Judge offers a promising direction for
developing more reliable and scalable methods for evaluating LLM
personalization. | [
-0.2829669117927551,
-0.5442960858345032,
1.135601282119751,
0.32124093174934387,
-0.0685189887881279,
0.20310018956661224,
-0.6568007469177246,
-0.40167292952537537,
0.2119748443365097,
0.32711365818977356,
-0.22607210278511047,
-0.707464873790741,
-0.8324491381645203,
0.15382704138755798,
-0.12935517728328705,
0.6558986902236938,
0.29374927282333374,
0.22035235166549683,
-0.35576173663139343,
-0.037751276046037674,
-0.42981189489364624,
-0.6993387341499329,
-0.4044584035873413,
-0.604071319103241,
0.7445441484451294,
0.4859376549720764,
0.8400143980979919,
0.2909388542175293,
0.35451266169548035,
0.3405148983001709,
-0.3488163948059082,
0.08785725384950638,
-0.16776911914348602,
0.11650623381137848,
-0.44427353143692017,
-0.6923097372055054,
-0.6467090845108032,
0.16068068146705627,
0.26687029004096985,
0.8106627464294434,
-0.26205718517303467,
-0.019565323367714882,
-0.019139623269438744,
0.5390068292617798,
-0.5749958157539368,
-0.013199525885283947,
-0.631322979927063,
0.05043274909257889,
-0.21871940791606903,
-0.018593238666653633,
-0.6617097854614258,
-0.5637917518615723,
0.1066557765007019,
-0.5764384269714355,
-0.2107284665107727,
0.26639267802238464,
0.6405272483825684,
0.2656826078891754,
-0.7137176990509033,
-0.22950275242328644,
-0.9862387776374817,
0.7411454319953918,
-0.8180814981460571,
0.26781776547431946,
0.6486419439315796,
0.552525520324707,
-0.0902218148112297,
-0.6127684712409973,
-0.46794092655181885,
-0.6467374563217163,
-0.07207319885492325,
0.1802419126033783,
-0.13962562382221222,
0.09339910000562668,
0.08903863281011581,
0.04434383288025856,
-0.15863843262195587,
0.517030656337738,
0.24644818902015686,
-0.2004796415567398,
0.6165965795516968,
0.139001727104187,
-0.08693943917751312,
-0.30210933089256287,
-0.3612135648727417,
0.24674594402313232,
-0.4055019021034241,
0.2865860164165497,
0.6440353989601135,
0.1500692218542099,
0.08229020982980728,
0.6516620516777039,
-0.6624608039855957,
0.6651774644851685,
0.43935567140579224,
-0.31588149070739746,
0.22294341027736664,
0.05687525495886803,
-0.06577686220407486,
-0.16412898898124695,
0.9594693183898926,
0.6095241904258728,
0.4365035891532898,
-0.3494456112384796,
-0.23641866445541382,
-0.2564023733139038,
0.4535238444805145,
-0.5794828534126282,
0.006817350164055824,
0.4533413052558899,
-0.34360045194625854,
-0.37843048572540283,
0.31405484676361084,
-0.46313920617103577,
-0.7057649493217468,
-0.4548216462135315,
0.3666025996208191,
-0.32094666361808777,
0.3418996334075928,
0.2813358008861542,
0.29081571102142334,
-0.24817384779453278,
0.728350818157196,
-0.8508972525596619,
0.3066045939922333,
0.7149413824081421,
0.4774557948112488,
-0.3612612783908844,
-0.36080998182296753,
-0.6829931139945984,
0.017192739993333817,
-0.17435571551322937,
0.8442032933235168,
-0.6477475762367249,
-0.4665892720222473,
-0.22405613958835602,
-0.3793153464794159,
0.15244537591934204,
-0.6131784915924072,
0.6648215055465698,
-0.6328544616699219,
0.07003256678581238,
-0.5657275915145874,
-0.6027134656906128,
0.05360088124871254,
0.3443925380706787,
-0.1674005389213562,
0.44855108857154846,
0.0897211879491806,
-0.65262770652771,
0.576724648475647,
-0.08915147185325623,
-0.18859660625457764,
0.1385003626346588,
-0.3637770712375641,
-0.24267011880874634,
0.2636911869049072,
0.2037254273891449,
0.5683753490447998,
-0.27280715107917786,
0.6598186492919922,
-0.8251919150352478,
-0.7075830698013306,
0.6538951992988586,
-0.41082513332366943,
0.2724255919456482,
0.2386961132287979,
-0.3339725136756897,
0.1819681078195572,
-0.6732885837554932,
0.010690185241401196,
-0.1359233260154724,
-0.7545861005783081,
-0.11981303244829178,
0.14041021466255188,
0.09748232364654541,
0.0718584954738617,
0.5348058342933655,
-0.8518546223640442,
0.04613673686981201,
-0.535178005695343,
0.03652907535433769,
1.1660821437835693,
-0.1659993976354599,
0.41967639327049255,
-0.37732014060020447,
0.5102801322937012,
-0.19600556790828705,
-0.00947724562138319,
0.14522548019886017,
-0.5920277833938599,
-0.7417242527008057,
-0.07427185028791428,
0.6120924949645996,
0.5818303823471069,
-0.20117361843585968,
0.8943920731544495,
-0.506710410118103,
-0.41510453820228577,
-0.217469722032547,
0.32170379161834717,
0.5037063956260681,
0.38848477602005005,
0.04838254302740097,
-0.5586002469062805,
-0.3330848515033722,
-0.9991623759269714,
-0.5811424851417542,
-0.33241021633148193,
-0.3499385118484497,
0.6340430974960327,
0.22329922020435333,
-0.48747798800468445,
1.2018362283706665,
-0.40307560563087463,
-0.0309249609708786,
-0.1146976426243782,
-0.13896462321281433,
0.2515050172805786,
0.1907939910888672,
0.43756821751594543,
-0.5917303562164307,
-0.6290537714958191,
0.2270580381155014,
-0.7040175795555115,
-0.2169962227344513,
0.01703498885035515,
-0.06991583108901978,
-0.17271240055561066,
-0.05225827917456627,
-0.536957859992981,
0.333579421043396,
0.3576473593711853,
-0.5742972493171692,
0.6519160866737366,
-0.42855754494667053,
0.19269929826259613,
-0.7531713843345642,
0.10759161412715912,
0.11767192929983139,
-0.6332563757896423,
-0.4591647982597351,
-0.008163036778569221,
-0.012504102662205696,
0.41435542702674866,
-0.2227034866809845,
0.8251557350158691,
0.1101287305355072,
-0.2770400941371918,
-0.4526834487915039,
0.2351708561182022,
-0.01800338551402092,
0.3678106367588043,
-0.17331190407276154,
0.3881244361400604,
0.1965712457895279,
-0.48510465025901794,
0.3810496926307678,
0.357666939496994,
-0.4938983619213104,
1.073531150817871,
-0.6376175284385681,
0.4141863286495209,
-0.024659601971507072,
0.34675654768943787,
-0.6767902374267578,
-0.48634445667266846,
0.2538214325904846,
-0.39214515686035156,
0.1821993589401245,
-0.16516876220703125,
-0.4932149052619934,
-0.14971515536308289,
-0.25338634848594666,
-0.1802571713924408,
0.35900524258613586,
-0.6519747972488403,
0.6068865656852722,
0.22316552698612213,
-0.19648197293281555,
-0.5177605152130127,
-0.5935078859329224,
0.2930455803871155,
-0.09043683111667633,
-0.7848859429359436,
0.31832587718963623,
-0.5067877173423767,
-0.5976611971855164,
-0.3217805325984955,
-0.2069622129201889,
0.19569464027881622,
0.44793403148651123,
0.5763183832168579,
-0.048197872936725616,
0.0772465243935585,
-0.052747346460819244,
-0.06974520534276962,
-0.19881407916545868,
0.02787339687347412,
0.007758399471640587,
0.4714401960372925,
-0.3006666302680969,
-0.7493479251861572,
-0.6135562062263489,
0.03141547366976738,
0.40960294008255005,
0.0923454686999321,
0.5519217848777771,
0.43433648347854614,
-0.17975080013275146,
0.023200564086437225,
-0.940710186958313,
-0.005040829535573721,
-0.490253210067749,
0.017955724149942398,
-0.6013658046722412,
-1.1269441843032837,
0.4612671434879303,
-0.16268211603164673,
-0.07187770307064056,
0.1656455546617508,
0.7421607375144958,
-0.5945354700088501,
0.8630126714706421,
0.2874439060688019,
-0.18690283596515656,
0.25412219762802124,
0.3521605432033539,
-0.09044525027275085,
-0.913926362991333,
-0.4112282693386078,
-0.4793909788131714,
-0.47137385606765747,
-0.5076528787612915,
-0.1468600332736969,
0.26263725757598877,
-0.2052638828754425,
-0.5022409558296204,
-0.11864494532346725,
-0.05587688833475113,
0.22175021469593048,
0.6777547597885132,
0.49326151609420776,
0.5982402563095093,
-0.13098829984664917,
-0.288862407207489,
-0.12817813456058502,
0.004494303837418556,
-0.9241912961006165,
1.152264952659607,
0.4644773304462433,
0.8841316103935242,
0.23353198170661926,
0.7522580623626709,
0.41057246923446655,
0.36090120673179626,
-0.7286686897277832,
0.46665671467781067,
-0.25889667868614197,
-0.41359978914260864,
-0.1841297596693039,
-0.3870352506637573,
-0.706275999546051,
0.5753938555717468,
-0.27316373586654663,
-1.1299879550933838,
0.2769925594329834,
0.3881992995738983,
-0.6771842241287231,
0.24111594259738922,
-0.6811389327049255,
0.5888162851333618,
-0.5204917788505554,
-0.29795321822166443,
-0.13865789771080017,
-0.6961581707000732,
0.3458743393421173,
-0.4066142737865448,
0.38041409850120544,
-0.29579871892929077,
-0.1803552806377411,
0.37321844696998596,
-0.4164503514766693,
0.9874439239501953,
-0.22436468303203583,
0.15524865686893463,
-0.2491864264011383,
0.254577100276947,
0.7461972832679749,
0.3753700256347656,
-0.4723036289215088,
0.01561472937464714,
-0.31802013516426086,
-0.22883914411067963,
-0.7816491723060608,
0.9107307195663452,
-0.8238837718963623,
-1.001123070716858,
-0.414141982793808,
-0.2439095675945282,
-0.633341908454895,
0.031188488006591797,
0.09027275443077087,
-0.19169653952121735,
-0.3221837282180786,
0.29759275913238525,
0.4473781883716583,
-0.2816036641597748,
-0.021193435415625572,
0.6566034555435181,
-0.3035833537578583,
-0.3756815791130066,
0.6889440417289734,
-0.21527425944805145,
0.05404190719127655,
0.4062609076499939,
0.6330570578575134,
-0.1246289610862732,
-0.7836719155311584,
-0.32751551270484924,
0.05276721343398094,
-0.6960421800613403,
0.11107068508863449,
-0.6275863647460938,
0.182392880320549,
-0.017298433929681778,
-0.2692970037460327,
-0.4186290204524994,
-0.26569387316703796,
-0.35063573718070984,
-0.15044598281383514,
0.08807580173015594,
0.6669063568115234,
0.31460604071617126,
0.5534070134162903,
-0.4545349180698395,
0.37985527515411377,
0.5975407958030701,
0.4652999937534332,
-0.3609354794025421,
-0.8708418011665344,
0.06273917853832245,
-0.06411601603031158,
-0.04719926044344902,
-0.5924071073532104,
0.2018435299396515,
-0.016192849725484848,
0.6600572466850281,
0.5002673864364624,
-0.1784229725599289,
0.4682808220386505,
-0.49066221714019775,
0.5729933977127075,
0.06881015002727509,
-0.9082240462303162,
0.5857693552970886,
-0.344885915517807,
0.3133598566055298,
0.8967222571372986,
-0.005841309670358896,
-0.5523676872253418,
-0.3521600067615509,
-0.44319573044776917,
-0.5725244879722595,
0.6860135197639465,
0.05451769381761551,
0.26807013154029846,
0.3240179717540741,
0.7165783643722534,
0.1947188526391983,
0.5419377088546753,
-0.5701354146003723,
-0.24694377183914185,
0.053036198019981384,
0.0021796415094286203,
-0.4006843566894531,
-0.558282732963562,
0.08733534067869186,
-0.11811113357543945,
0.388752281665802,
-0.27099838852882385,
-0.05141003802418709,
-0.04341252148151398,
-0.02742498368024826,
-0.06682337075471878,
0.5654734373092651,
0.39163729548454285,
0.6768835186958313,
-0.5904879570007324,
0.1615470051765442,
0.22489212453365326,
-0.20569773018360138,
0.29969164729118347,
-0.02820783667266369,
-0.41683319211006165,
-0.2590775489807129,
0.20229826867580414,
0.808682918548584,
0.503993809223175,
-0.7138925790786743,
0.8003193140029907,
-0.29146212339401245,
0.0044555505737662315,
-0.5057454705238342,
0.10118896514177322,
0.3418531119823456,
0.3050033450126648,
0.05769873782992363,
0.4955333173274994,
0.11232014745473862,
-0.26162925362586975,
0.09792979806661606,
0.39436283707618713,
-0.38181790709495544,
-0.3814605176448822,
0.8982678055763245,
0.11791832745075226,
-0.35696592926979065,
0.2942144274711609,
-0.2340620458126068,
-0.18858778476715088,
0.237732395529747,
0.12318304181098938,
0.8307840824127197,
-0.21181491017341614,
0.15201589465141296,
-0.003273715265095234,
0.10611459612846375,
-0.2004138082265854,
0.112538181245327,
0.10295488685369492,
-0.9614259600639343,
-0.1396416574716568,
-0.9253011345863342,
-0.835925817489624,
-0.22428889572620392,
-0.470691442489624,
0.16900774836540222,
-0.8042755126953125,
-0.6265488266944885,
-0.11589550226926804,
0.03710517659783363,
-0.6911188364028931,
0.4434299170970917,
0.1783270388841629,
0.6651555299758911,
-0.4208446443080902,
0.7946266531944275,
0.7697669267654419,
0.1110793873667717,
-0.5518118739128113,
0.10898680984973907,
0.1287081390619278,
-0.6444632411003113,
0.6874307990074158,
0.07184014469385147,
-0.1918293982744217,
-0.4350624978542328,
-0.2860630452632904,
-0.6215000152587891,
1.2589143514633179,
0.784299910068512,
-0.8915379047393799,
0.14277450740337372,
-0.008265110664069653,
0.7424235939979553,
-0.3705149292945862,
0.44476956129074097,
0.6246575117111206,
0.7494691610336304,
0.3095448613166809,
-0.910434365272522,
-0.07078225165605545,
-0.09441182762384415,
0.24522925913333893,
-0.48924094438552856,
-0.8567246198654175,
0.5526068210601807,
-0.32200828194618225,
0.21964728832244873,
0.03937828168272972,
0.7093430161476135,
0.5017850399017334,
0.3096453547477722,
0.6594609618186951,
0.46112191677093506,
1.0187056064605713,
0.08188237249851227,
1.4173448085784912,
-0.3049018681049347,
0.19581523537635803,
1.5691930055618286,
-0.5096870064735413,
0.8371024131774902,
0.3500834107398987,
-0.3987831771373749,
0.5461656451225281,
0.6626356840133667,
0.0008804498356766999,
0.1702367216348648,
0.13984645903110504,
-0.31208112835884094,
-0.6443018913269043,
-0.06654420495033264,
0.2470187544822693,
0.5527503490447998,
0.051630474627017975,
-0.47346562147140503,
0.16506700217723846,
-0.1429564356803894,
0.0433531180024147,
0.4953911006450653,
-0.11430055648088455,
0.4927575886249542,
0.2667846083641052,
-0.6235952973365784,
-0.018047383055090904,
0.5979728698730469,
1.0102256536483765,
-0.5271028280258179,
0.567795991897583,
-0.17092539370059967,
0.07110709697008133,
-0.3418598473072052,
-0.7391415238380432,
-0.02968270517885685,
0.13388089835643768,
-0.08289861679077148,
-0.28432002663612366,
0.8010845184326172,
0.1255219578742981,
-0.5129115581512451,
0.37642499804496765,
0.6991631388664246,
0.05546644330024719,
-0.3135090470314026,
-0.4306015074253082,
0.021768156439065933,
0.09012209624052048,
-0.7277345657348633,
0.569943368434906,
-0.14226458966732025,
0.023142213001847267,
1.0885847806930542,
0.5572671890258789,
0.22594507038593292,
0.0021499088034033775,
0.38249385356903076,
0.7259087562561035,
-0.5467431545257568,
-0.2867833971977234,
-0.9507851600646973,
0.3630047142505646,
0.11107751727104187,
-0.24712814390659332,
0.7362138032913208,
0.520412027835846,
0.7249534726142883,
-0.11690042167901993,
0.9332726001739502,
0.14260455965995789,
0.44439488649368286,
-0.39543506503105164,
0.5780711770057678,
-0.39005768299102783,
0.6931523084640503,
-0.10515471547842026,
-0.7407112121582031,
-0.22819072008132935,
0.4591625928878784,
-0.5237419605255127,
0.4236210584640503,
0.3266811668872833,
0.4593479633331299,
-0.019764408469200134,
-0.16649526357650757,
0.7222049832344055,
0.24414105713367462,
0.3693527281284332,
0.4463711678981781,
0.7738240957260132,
0.056825190782547,
0.23607340455055237,
-0.5295109748840332,
-0.1730925738811493,
-0.3548853397369385,
-0.5457912683486938,
-0.9590369462966919,
-0.133295476436615,
-0.1474996954202652,
-0.22140350937843323,
-0.09017195552587509,
1.100843071937561,
0.7631986737251282,
-0.7490962147712708,
-0.24774132668972015,
0.339976042509079,
0.1367366909980774,
0.22123464941978455,
-0.11955694854259491,
-0.008916686289012432,
-0.1899903565645218,
-0.9251871705055237,
0.523452639579773,
0.34113430976867676,
-0.12858235836029053,
-0.27736610174179077,
-0.3529990017414093,
0.2762196660041809,
0.019010987132787704,
0.47477051615715027,
-0.05934702605009079,
-1.1071504354476929,
-0.7290927767753601,
-0.17670471966266632,
-0.303772896528244,
0.3352062404155731,
0.4511975944042206,
-0.7314636707305908,
0.7381235361099243,
0.15223513543605804,
0.44105470180511475,
0.662868082523346,
0.5120344758033752,
0.6365679502487183,
-0.6576278209686279,
-0.12448644638061523,
0.2853127717971802,
0.4998781383037567,
0.4347864091396332,
-0.6668951511383057,
0.2996363341808319,
0.18835225701332092,
-0.610609233379364,
-0.39775872230529785,
0.3593357801437378,
-1.2808314561843872,
0.06242602318525314,
1.365005373954773,
-0.5132195949554443,
0.03199794515967369,
-0.1307002156972885,
-0.24746310710906982,
-0.30614209175109863,
-0.6568170785903931,
0.7115435600280762,
0.8021647930145264,
-0.3117494583129883,
0.014332630671560764,
-0.5042468309402466,
0.13038498163223267,
0.300037145614624,
-0.8093115091323853,
-0.23519715666770935,
0.3175957500934601,
0.6864728331565857,
0.09290697425603867,
0.7618149518966675,
0.10513870418071747,
0.10307985544204712,
-0.46365538239479065,
0.058001283556222916,
0.0005628636572510004,
-0.001344396616332233,
-0.5232037901878357,
0.25520238280296326,
0.8447890877723694,
0.3573259711265564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11654v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11654v1 | Ruby Teaming: Improving Quality Diversity Search with Memory for Automated Red Teaming | 2024-06-17T15:36:14 | 2024-06-17T15:36:14 | Vernon Toh Yan Han, Rishabh Bhardwaj, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose Ruby Teaming, a method that improves on Rainbow Teaming by
including a memory cache as its third dimension. The memory dimension provides
cues to the mutator to yield better-quality prompts, both in terms of attack
success rate (ASR) and quality diversity. The prompt archive generated by Ruby
Teaming has an ASR of 74%, which is 20% higher than the baseline. In terms of
quality diversity, Ruby Teaming outperforms Rainbow Teaming by 6% and 3% on
Shannon's Evenness Index (SEI) and Simpson's Diversity Index (SDI),
respectively. | [
-0.6583872437477112,
-0.24191325902938843,
0.336189329624176,
0.5540937781333923,
0.0682711973786354,
0.7764111161231995,
0.18373700976371765,
-0.42823275923728943,
0.4321611821651459,
-0.006511391140520573,
-0.5359595417976379,
-0.10820919275283813,
-0.6073560118675232,
-0.04298361763358116,
-0.18786005675792694,
1.2386130094528198,
0.09007657319307327,
0.08789844810962677,
0.21121029555797577,
-0.5267475843429565,
-0.9710337519645691,
-0.37674951553344727,
-0.8238033056259155,
-0.20308713614940643,
0.6387607455253601,
0.8668042421340942,
0.8082439303398132,
0.41965919733047485,
0.8918940424919128,
0.38534069061279297,
-0.03921167925000191,
-0.06917460262775421,
-0.7153928875923157,
0.3332659900188446,
-0.05540001392364502,
-0.5592619776725769,
-0.3958401381969452,
0.1688353419303894,
0.8078207969665527,
0.27509185671806335,
-0.3234597146511078,
0.09769677370786667,
-0.12451376765966415,
0.8621628284454346,
-0.783348560333252,
-0.6035523414611816,
-0.7076411247253418,
0.10772106796503067,
-0.30453070998191833,
-0.6397720575332642,
-0.10651383548974991,
-0.43819162249565125,
0.17731134593486786,
-0.3441348671913147,
0.7485383749008179,
0.4929724335670471,
0.8132109642028809,
0.025745125487446785,
-0.06683489680290222,
-0.21559132635593414,
-0.7326027154922485,
1.0911229848861694,
0.043842609971761703,
0.059974782168865204,
0.2947792410850525,
0.5994098782539368,
0.06460516899824142,
-0.22434298694133759,
-0.5382011532783508,
0.1966269612312317,
0.18717607855796814,
0.3831586241722107,
-0.42399269342422485,
-0.14886704087257385,
0.1792452484369278,
0.8345339298248291,
-0.8970996737480164,
0.0003587007522583008,
-0.7166762948036194,
0.10935303568840027,
0.6980000138282776,
0.6764332056045532,
0.6561521291732788,
0.22441677749156952,
-0.49364224076271057,
-0.38629427552223206,
-0.05724349245429039,
0.1752331405878067,
0.4548646807670593,
-0.09287887066602707,
0.08001283556222916,
0.25759589672088623,
-0.16291090846061707,
0.4407375454902649,
0.18245810270309448,
0.1774369776248932,
0.44711482524871826,
-0.696471631526947,
-0.04426328092813492,
-0.2125232219696045,
0.5647292137145996,
0.6532667279243469,
-0.3212850093841553,
-0.2038147896528244,
-0.641625702381134,
0.2834692597389221,
0.45242416858673096,
-0.5696723461151123,
-0.7637701630592346,
0.3939182460308075,
-0.6095473766326904,
0.1309567540884018,
0.07267556339502335,
-0.7927110195159912,
-0.16325126588344574,
0.21851015090942383,
0.8122668862342834,
-0.9796600341796875,
-0.20148949325084686,
-0.05915551260113716,
-1.169392704963684,
0.4388081729412079,
0.23333927989006042,
-0.977798581123352,
0.42983466386795044,
0.5181209444999695,
0.880502462387085,
-0.5088151693344116,
-0.7308205962181091,
-0.780360758304596,
0.11182419210672379,
-0.09540706872940063,
1.0628061294555664,
-0.5512886643409729,
-0.3666873276233673,
-0.6528761386871338,
-0.5409680008888245,
0.2383684664964676,
-0.6180041432380676,
-0.2296314835548401,
-0.7061339020729065,
0.2863280773162842,
-0.5270206332206726,
-0.10723672062158585,
-0.05710048973560333,
0.23553046584129333,
-0.8124837279319763,
1.0836360454559326,
0.2618873119354248,
-0.29950961470603943,
0.9997707009315491,
-0.9803066253662109,
-0.33522164821624756,
0.4938865303993225,
0.16231907904148102,
-0.4583652913570404,
-0.14263686537742615,
0.1344771683216095,
0.059312496334314346,
-0.21607957780361176,
-0.17319175601005554,
-0.18313099443912506,
-0.39998558163642883,
0.3790343999862671,
0.06950362026691437,
0.7520851492881775,
0.40653738379478455,
-0.28746098279953003,
0.27806830406188965,
-0.6013892889022827,
0.3320939540863037,
-0.1288447380065918,
-0.4797791838645935,
-0.2183164656162262,
-0.13256782293319702,
-0.007631977554410696,
-0.04246053472161293,
0.08980968594551086,
-0.46007412672042847,
-0.10662247985601425,
0.03516554459929466,
0.16883531212806702,
0.7543033361434937,
0.053699467331171036,
0.7376477718353271,
-0.8985897302627563,
0.5165645480155945,
-0.024622568860650063,
0.5898013114929199,
0.19231919944286346,
-0.7132713198661804,
-0.7145221829414368,
-0.5331873893737793,
0.04020806774497032,
0.6222333908081055,
-0.6882377862930298,
0.38810014724731445,
-0.17975173890590668,
-0.364860862493515,
-0.5872292518615723,
0.38616594672203064,
0.6238757371902466,
-0.3144960403442383,
0.5621635913848877,
-0.6583808660507202,
-0.8048756122589111,
-0.919238269329071,
-0.252214640378952,
-0.18571080267429352,
-0.06055697798728943,
0.12820161879062653,
0.7210901379585266,
-0.2797706425189972,
0.9220514893531799,
-0.2440931349992752,
-0.373223215341568,
-0.5602681636810303,
0.5058268308639526,
0.34702619910240173,
0.7029039263725281,
0.4618319571018219,
-0.9020309448242188,
-0.7727698087692261,
-0.5077322125434875,
-0.3839075267314911,
0.22759631276130676,
0.012217599898576736,
-0.3220589756965637,
0.46534043550491333,
-0.29055270552635193,
-0.2479771375656128,
0.1840142011642456,
0.703504204750061,
-0.5082810521125793,
0.18752697110176086,
-0.2780376076698303,
0.7556498646736145,
-0.896748960018158,
0.012383297085762024,
0.03955690562725067,
0.08100691437721252,
-0.7614635825157166,
0.29645034670829773,
0.10763753205537796,
-0.026050511747598648,
-0.11938337236642838,
0.16335566341876984,
-0.912649393081665,
-0.33284953236579895,
-0.002638401696458459,
0.21547801792621613,
-0.0357942096889019,
0.14131048321723938,
-0.31919634342193604,
0.9975932836532593,
0.3911469578742981,
-0.7377246618270874,
0.5361685752868652,
0.11814352124929428,
-0.24784845113754272,
0.7021313309669495,
-0.5219107866287231,
0.000023677728677284904,
-0.10719399154186249,
0.16445781290531158,
-1.055349588394165,
-0.08571057766675949,
-0.3510725796222687,
-0.8816213011741638,
0.2750377058982849,
0.1484622061252594,
-0.7105306386947632,
-0.5146372318267822,
-0.7671727538108826,
0.7209104895591736,
0.7632186412811279,
-0.5567174553871155,
0.26426443457603455,
0.5954186320304871,
0.2563753128051758,
-0.6433841586112976,
-0.8369882106781006,
0.02707008831202984,
-0.28934726119041443,
-0.8783085346221924,
0.3125205636024475,
-0.3809727132320404,
-0.3667854070663452,
0.017463792115449905,
-0.13519197702407837,
-0.4148101508617401,
0.129045307636261,
-0.015817075967788696,
0.3892822563648224,
-0.3741479516029358,
-0.1956590861082077,
-0.7175521850585938,
-0.26104697585105896,
-0.3264349102973938,
0.03356126695871353,
0.7775318026542664,
-0.24919924139976501,
-0.07642380893230438,
-0.17321069538593292,
0.7846356630325317,
0.18671180307865143,
-0.18560335040092468,
1.1330162286758423,
0.6412209272384644,
0.015436138026416302,
-0.24379688501358032,
-0.9889788627624512,
-0.1498154103755951,
-0.5395420789718628,
0.004218008369207382,
-0.24950437247753143,
-1.076977252960205,
0.8102520704269409,
0.8393546938896179,
-0.1062375083565712,
0.37233948707580566,
0.1795826256275177,
-0.5112449526786804,
1.0170449018478394,
0.5950809717178345,
-0.28955841064453125,
0.5010112524032593,
-0.3010461926460266,
-0.03025948815047741,
-0.8526911735534668,
-0.25917166471481323,
-0.4169122576713562,
-0.8423337936401367,
-0.37875884771347046,
-0.5999686121940613,
0.618141770362854,
0.24358992278575897,
-0.517096757888794,
0.40776270627975464,
-0.7781211733818054,
0.6878639459609985,
1.0160950422286987,
0.22146615386009216,
-0.03522830083966255,
-0.1780698150396347,
0.4337562322616577,
-0.21437036991119385,
-0.6787172555923462,
0.1930302232503891,
0.7531711459159851,
0.28006476163864136,
0.69527268409729,
0.786054790019989,
0.8794025182723999,
0.30823272466659546,
-0.05404609814286232,
-0.3325464427471161,
0.5554969906806946,
0.008160713128745556,
-0.9022654891014099,
-0.5231413841247559,
-0.6023269295692444,
-1.0751136541366577,
-0.00022862527112010866,
-0.3745698928833008,
-0.586944580078125,
0.06332665681838989,
0.1852317750453949,
-0.7737983465194702,
0.31663092970848083,
-0.625723123550415,
0.3890741765499115,
-0.2663081884384155,
-0.09404090791940689,
-0.5692425966262817,
-0.5606721043586731,
0.4318273961544037,
0.12096182256937027,
-0.24628578126430511,
0.042112693190574646,
-0.13489475846290588,
0.8547078371047974,
-0.31558793783187866,
0.4330516457557678,
-0.0980968102812767,
0.47708117961883545,
0.09439071267843246,
0.1802448183298111,
0.34423598647117615,
-0.04601036384701729,
-0.017271937802433968,
-0.0807667225599289,
-0.4925232529640198,
-0.6742069125175476,
-0.597797691822052,
0.4886755049228668,
-0.9481131434440613,
-0.673308789730072,
-0.4142844080924988,
-0.7648691534996033,
0.07616998255252838,
-0.15818998217582703,
0.23845529556274414,
0.43706944584846497,
0.18952657282352448,
0.4724946916103363,
1.0083028078079224,
-0.4779067039489746,
0.5438180565834045,
0.7667689919471741,
0.23819348216056824,
-0.645469605922699,
1.1949002742767334,
0.04096462205052376,
0.6440384984016418,
0.5338521599769592,
-0.07201356440782547,
-0.06606537103652954,
-0.7106730937957764,
-0.1803753674030304,
-0.02430027723312378,
-0.6903399229049683,
-0.39817219972610474,
-0.8880340456962585,
-0.24609413743019104,
-0.20294465124607086,
-0.47003793716430664,
-0.2443302571773529,
-0.2886677384376526,
0.09232393652200699,
0.3116930425167084,
0.7591394782066345,
0.5895652770996094,
-0.3760591447353363,
0.21153725683689117,
-0.9413846731185913,
0.45414018630981445,
0.5204337239265442,
0.5947979688644409,
-0.35308802127838135,
-0.45693275332450867,
-0.12937679886817932,
-0.36912843585014343,
-0.4123017191886902,
-0.8830749988555908,
0.4361001253128052,
-0.10014484077692032,
1.0495104789733887,
0.040188152343034744,
-0.13768227398395538,
1.0424860715866089,
-0.0006502015748992562,
1.0033246278762817,
0.624442994594574,
-1.071934461593628,
0.9637888073921204,
-0.5363661646842957,
0.2444111406803131,
0.628482460975647,
0.2625499963760376,
-0.2345731109380722,
-0.7319072484970093,
-0.8575589060783386,
-0.7219256162643433,
0.8937378525733948,
0.3814832270145416,
-0.38214364647865295,
-0.05171104893088341,
-0.1734510064125061,
-0.30906590819358826,
-0.11217551678419113,
-0.6956331133842468,
-0.6024591326713562,
-0.05441915616393089,
0.19124934077262878,
-0.296630322933197,
-0.38120782375335693,
-0.07450351864099503,
-0.07371379435062408,
0.43286657333374023,
0.24713106453418732,
0.5088443756103516,
0.04845493286848068,
-0.059731364250183105,
-0.34016284346580505,
0.13324734568595886,
0.5026786923408508,
0.5017795562744141,
-0.3174312710762024,
0.07951158285140991,
0.8054131269454956,
-0.3400897681713104,
0.18763934075832367,
-0.38584309816360474,
0.2661973834037781,
-0.23653870820999146,
0.17316393554210663,
0.45585814118385315,
0.0236604493111372,
-0.3049682676792145,
0.5294808745384216,
-0.15255670249462128,
-0.1155569851398468,
-0.0461113266646862,
0.6617640256881714,
-0.2829771041870117,
0.5067974925041199,
0.6626894474029541,
0.44842758774757385,
0.43406182527542114,
-1.0293149948120117,
0.29578641057014465,
0.8896671533584595,
-0.24489538371562958,
0.013473369181156158,
0.5372295379638672,
0.2733418047428131,
-0.46448832750320435,
0.6427944302558899,
-0.3612940013408661,
-0.8028425574302673,
0.6591576933860779,
0.6484162211418152,
0.6539893746376038,
-0.6046291589736938,
0.029208805412054062,
0.555045485496521,
0.49440306425094604,
-0.43231332302093506,
0.44833609461784363,
-0.0235415231436491,
-0.7493271827697754,
-0.08936178684234619,
-0.3574845492839813,
-0.5339781641960144,
-0.10921421647071838,
-0.8236894011497498,
0.18494939804077148,
-0.5112864971160889,
0.0427541509270668,
-0.2957440912723541,
0.3277224600315094,
-0.521232545375824,
0.24928002059459686,
0.009006083942949772,
0.8378768563270569,
-0.5171934366226196,
0.7709497213363647,
0.6482006311416626,
-0.630649209022522,
-0.5928711891174316,
-0.10121320188045502,
0.05041756108403206,
-0.8393505215644836,
0.900115430355072,
0.03699900209903717,
-0.2336689978837967,
-0.1823931634426117,
-0.4854208827018738,
-1.0780338048934937,
1.4743140935897827,
-0.20848649740219116,
-0.1005258858203888,
0.3200454115867615,
-0.2144438475370407,
0.32788047194480896,
-0.17506490647792816,
0.6050357818603516,
0.5169973373413086,
0.4487816393375397,
0.13546131551265717,
-0.7899881601333618,
0.006085608154535294,
-0.6593822836875916,
0.36481431126594543,
0.40759146213531494,
-0.7198734283447266,
1.3592009544372559,
-0.35699763894081116,
-0.6689496040344238,
-0.031622231006622314,
0.7113763093948364,
0.8259811401367188,
0.15753315389156342,
0.5844359993934631,
0.4262213706970215,
0.8383288383483887,
-0.04542290046811104,
1.1227651834487915,
-0.06155896559357643,
-0.06280503422021866,
0.7572468519210815,
-0.02797045186161995,
0.8349468111991882,
0.38585975766181946,
-0.2777308523654938,
0.4886036813259125,
0.26759541034698486,
-0.3364967703819275,
0.5130007266998291,
0.13354960083961487,
-0.34840816259384155,
-0.20056188106536865,
0.6457657814025879,
-0.2701740562915802,
0.0075613269582390785,
0.2822774648666382,
-0.08533524721860886,
0.014629346318542957,
-0.15656748414039612,
-0.4641728103160858,
0.036200594156980515,
-0.32193976640701294,
0.8465992212295532,
-0.46798381209373474,
-0.9365318417549133,
0.508629560470581,
-0.2965311110019684,
1.2474031448364258,
-0.27922502160072327,
-0.05437732860445976,
-0.4686080813407898,
0.26498886942863464,
-0.3456028401851654,
-1.4523377418518066,
0.3554092347621918,
-0.13214978575706482,
-0.9301357269287109,
-0.14261746406555176,
0.45889657735824585,
-0.1869799941778183,
0.11192724853754044,
0.504391074180603,
0.2251739650964737,
0.16885654628276825,
0.21516573429107666,
-0.7097695469856262,
0.1947602778673172,
-0.05017975717782974,
0.22516222298145294,
0.5580349564552307,
0.4932158589363098,
0.37403392791748047,
1.022748589515686,
0.6383691430091858,
0.05606701225042343,
0.28908324241638184,
-0.17308396100997925,
0.8326950073242188,
-0.9518723487854004,
-0.5480756759643555,
-0.8816049695014954,
0.5340328216552734,
-0.4071306884288788,
-0.3107560873031616,
1.0998663902282715,
0.8264878988265991,
0.44404157996177673,
0.06758459657430649,
0.5700251460075378,
-0.09508144855499268,
0.5585932731628418,
-0.3033308684825897,
0.8229458928108215,
-0.42127805948257446,
0.24065282940864563,
-0.3186936676502228,
-0.7974042892456055,
-0.4079494774341583,
0.6439850330352783,
0.09105511754751205,
0.04306624457240105,
0.9876681566238403,
0.9565181732177734,
-0.06044156849384308,
0.2435215413570404,
0.28748685121536255,
-0.10586965829133987,
0.2893069088459015,
0.8477838635444641,
1.2661570310592651,
-0.4996069669723511,
0.8913735151290894,
0.1386789232492447,
-0.4830804765224457,
-0.14626732468605042,
-0.5350456833839417,
-0.9709296822547913,
-0.6854096055030823,
-0.18589729070663452,
-0.575631320476532,
0.2026774287223816,
0.5850613117218018,
0.6431455612182617,
-0.8356403112411499,
-0.3152464032173157,
-0.05187225341796875,
-0.00958087295293808,
-0.2355431765317917,
-0.2997516691684723,
-0.4220154583454132,
-0.8344340920448303,
-0.2940202057361603,
0.39819422364234924,
0.3591637909412384,
-0.2224915474653244,
-0.13820144534111023,
-0.3643259108066559,
-0.1747606247663498,
-0.14167797565460205,
0.4458610415458679,
0.21836715936660767,
-0.47946178913116455,
-0.46768105030059814,
-0.12271607667207718,
-0.4011726975440979,
0.17531101405620575,
0.6783332824707031,
-0.6598631739616394,
0.12157076597213745,
0.7434157729148865,
0.3919821083545685,
0.3386877477169037,
-0.10729527473449707,
0.8702830076217651,
-0.6165736317634583,
-0.327587753534317,
0.2740038335323334,
0.21024450659751892,
0.1602100282907486,
-0.22635409235954285,
0.5889579653739929,
0.1562463492155075,
-0.8828158974647522,
-0.7139008045196533,
-0.15846720337867737,
-0.9895572662353516,
-0.1771615594625473,
1.3633530139923096,
0.16344976425170898,
-0.21921630203723907,
-0.41656187176704407,
0.005800691898912191,
0.020345617085695267,
-0.732502281665802,
0.7702927589416504,
0.2647993862628937,
-0.22720815241336823,
-0.39717787504196167,
-0.3514634668827057,
0.5755700469017029,
0.49422454833984375,
-0.6505239605903625,
-0.4497465193271637,
0.421861469745636,
0.3968208134174347,
0.539352297782898,
0.9184257388114929,
0.028119051828980446,
0.7715736627578735,
0.3942568600177765,
0.3727738559246063,
0.4035470485687256,
-0.4171505570411682,
-0.2193826287984848,
0.3170086443424225,
-0.17070075869560242,
-0.37459486722946167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11651v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11651v1 | A Two-dimensional Zero-shot Dialogue State Tracking Evaluation Method using GPT-4 | 2024-06-17T15:32:17 | 2024-06-17T15:32:17 | Ming Gu, Yan Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue state tracking (DST) is evaluated by exact matching methods, which
rely on large amounts of labeled data and ignore semantic consistency, leading
to over-evaluation. Currently, leveraging large language models (LLM) in
evaluating natural language processing tasks has achieved promising results.
However, using LLM for DST evaluation is still under explored. In this paper,
we propose a two-dimensional zero-shot evaluation method for DST using GPT-4,
which divides the evaluation into two dimensions: accuracy and completeness.
Furthermore, we also design two manual reasoning paths in prompting to further
improve the accuracy of evaluation. Experimental results show that our method
achieves better performance compared to the baselines, and is consistent with
traditional exact matching based methods. | [
-0.1455635279417038,
-0.9227077960968018,
1.212396502494812,
-0.02756422758102417,
-0.565789520740509,
0.2681463062763214,
-0.0696539431810379,
-0.24251335859298706,
0.031908463686704636,
0.40149983763694763,
-0.7327519655227661,
-0.5799859166145325,
-0.5314172506332397,
0.0063794259913265705,
-0.038598597049713135,
1.0889052152633667,
-0.31444016098976135,
-0.03029884397983551,
0.0037005769554525614,
0.05257822945713997,
-0.7125314474105835,
-0.2952975332736969,
-0.6072701215744019,
-0.09015266597270966,
0.060889750719070435,
0.017107339575886726,
0.3861866593360901,
0.5194821953773499,
0.3812604248523712,
0.22628577053546906,
-0.1211744025349617,
-0.00858207605779171,
-0.36120352149009705,
0.18682321906089783,
-0.11611572653055191,
-0.2925589382648468,
-0.541315495967865,
0.22752928733825684,
0.7527603507041931,
0.030589917674660683,
-0.007386747281998396,
0.27796798944473267,
-0.14238452911376953,
0.4275619685649872,
-0.48967140913009644,
0.530841588973999,
-0.38795554637908936,
0.07827814668416977,
-0.04438786953687668,
-0.43371710181236267,
-0.004723624791949987,
-0.7986631989479065,
0.35376662015914917,
-0.43016213178634644,
0.13347159326076508,
-0.3081474006175995,
0.4777758717536926,
0.3031262755393982,
-0.7542982697486877,
-0.39535900950431824,
-0.6799542903900146,
0.6340277791023254,
-0.8854084610939026,
0.21979576349258423,
0.4936085641384125,
0.4740440845489502,
0.06235458329319954,
-0.3449472486972809,
-0.7496584057807922,
-0.331165611743927,
0.2348485141992569,
0.3106585144996643,
-0.14250241219997406,
0.1717035323381424,
0.45860782265663147,
0.24764062464237213,
-0.62137770652771,
-0.035253651440143585,
-0.17637860774993896,
-0.31842294335365295,
0.42932674288749695,
0.36061668395996094,
0.4260720908641815,
-0.1921290159225464,
-0.4336417019367218,
0.11873526126146317,
-0.2313462197780609,
-0.0690770149230957,
0.22490616142749786,
0.34339454770088196,
-0.11003680527210236,
0.5418058037757874,
-0.2621678113937378,
0.8679435849189758,
0.10291153937578201,
-0.253652423620224,
0.15007327497005463,
-0.9295105338096619,
-0.25078004598617554,
-0.06995417922735214,
0.8098322153091431,
0.8059995174407959,
-0.03671629726886749,
-0.13228224217891693,
-0.046424027532339096,
0.27526238560676575,
0.2504574656486511,
-0.977214515209198,
0.12341243028640747,
0.10650520771741867,
0.07385991513729095,
-0.10368627309799194,
-0.4906482696533203,
-0.9464554786682129,
-0.20918706059455872,
-0.49790239334106445,
0.7163447737693787,
-0.5051180124282837,
-0.30336064100265503,
0.12152009457349777,
0.04771558940410614,
0.4813145399093628,
0.609898030757904,
-0.9046210646629333,
0.314850777387619,
1.0197464227676392,
1.279462456703186,
-0.05465797334909439,
0.16945140063762665,
-0.5208199620246887,
-0.05512216314673424,
-0.48828473687171936,
0.9677438139915466,
-0.44056645035743713,
-0.010397490113973618,
-0.14907990396022797,
-0.37720370292663574,
-0.26935550570487976,
-0.03603394702076912,
0.7523545622825623,
-0.4205447733402252,
0.5111521482467651,
-0.45225590467453003,
-0.6872404217720032,
-0.31618842482566833,
0.6310349702835083,
-0.3325420320034027,
0.8959491848945618,
0.24181212484836578,
-0.5803400874137878,
0.38768985867500305,
-0.7357171773910522,
-0.18000014126300812,
0.22412458062171936,
-0.39491820335388184,
-0.32841721177101135,
-0.07185162603855133,
0.2723221182823181,
-0.012932426296174526,
-0.20037725567817688,
0.06681063771247864,
-0.24587740004062653,
-0.8266720175743103,
-0.28897973895072937,
-0.7007624506950378,
0.7218164205551147,
0.01735919900238514,
-0.562375009059906,
-0.17766904830932617,
-0.49599266052246094,
0.3015120327472687,
0.05054539814591408,
-0.2647344470024109,
-0.05200646072626114,
-0.2947099506855011,
-0.33759263157844543,
0.38630032539367676,
0.3278871178627014,
-1.004747748374939,
0.344407320022583,
-0.4216625690460205,
0.3087775409221649,
0.5647608637809753,
0.31030890345573425,
0.3658372163772583,
-0.019305335357785225,
0.7871646881103516,
-0.2672545909881592,
0.03947170823812485,
-0.1691732406616211,
-0.5728046894073486,
-0.46648359298706055,
-0.36312204599380493,
0.012659055180847645,
0.7597570419311523,
-0.6671165823936462,
0.4804321527481079,
-0.10337918996810913,
-0.42480745911598206,
-0.47064098715782166,
-0.2529808580875397,
0.650111973285675,
0.4191969931125641,
0.2620338201522827,
-0.2725768983364105,
-0.30690279603004456,
-0.6441370844841003,
-0.2629064619541168,
-0.14134414494037628,
-0.23155894875526428,
0.15821297466754913,
0.30000728368759155,
0.00009176117600873113,
1.0619356632232666,
-0.6470433473587036,
-0.4142453372478485,
-0.20888470113277435,
0.2722104787826538,
0.17515811324119568,
0.158476322889328,
0.5597749948501587,
-0.04614054039120674,
-0.6637818217277527,
-0.0823923870921135,
-0.7404136061668396,
-0.1783122569322586,
-0.011241056956350803,
-0.07792872935533524,
0.41720524430274963,
-0.0148439547047019,
-0.7771759629249573,
0.8656803369522095,
0.37625813484191895,
-0.42895156145095825,
0.3611387312412262,
-0.11533023416996002,
0.549868106842041,
-0.9605640769004822,
-0.18856684863567352,
0.23699983954429626,
-0.3719470500946045,
-0.8283690810203552,
-0.3303835988044739,
0.11698289215564728,
-0.2134426385164261,
-0.07699065655469894,
0.4417939782142639,
-0.39464130997657776,
-0.3852299153804779,
-0.3314487934112549,
0.6050865650177002,
0.031772714108228683,
0.6434768438339233,
-0.055874936282634735,
0.7418621778488159,
0.5127408504486084,
-0.06117333471775055,
0.6482903361320496,
0.33862921595573425,
-0.6766074299812317,
1.0191293954849243,
-0.43997639417648315,
0.6577194333076477,
-0.1601501852273941,
0.7480185627937317,
-1.374463677406311,
0.28568509221076965,
0.29835739731788635,
-0.2861155569553375,
0.3019747734069824,
-0.3766740560531616,
-0.5055491328239441,
-0.36563602089881897,
-0.48213350772857666,
0.30848273634910583,
0.3886837959289551,
-0.25079306960105896,
0.20406629145145416,
0.01352484617382288,
-0.3845099210739136,
-0.10533927381038666,
-0.3918780982494354,
0.28058645129203796,
-0.1253511756658554,
-0.5172067284584045,
-0.009667705744504929,
-0.10129599273204803,
0.2219206541776657,
-0.36216047406196594,
-0.6976677775382996,
-0.16999508440494537,
-0.28058597445487976,
-0.06731169670820236,
0.4069594442844391,
-0.11146548390388489,
-0.31619977951049805,
-0.1308116614818573,
-0.4278136193752289,
-0.07773624360561371,
-0.3298433721065521,
0.4953089952468872,
-0.04832816496491432,
-0.4737969636917114,
-1.2752001285552979,
0.2005734145641327,
0.5844489336013794,
-0.02920691668987274,
0.1015622541308403,
0.6349368095397949,
-0.27781423926353455,
0.12333032488822937,
-0.6354300379753113,
-0.13903644680976868,
-0.37076568603515625,
0.40647760033607483,
-0.49338191747665405,
-0.823712170124054,
0.0648140236735344,
0.1565553843975067,
0.17254294455051422,
0.13096031546592712,
0.48433831334114075,
0.06220996752381325,
1.3108445405960083,
0.3326855003833771,
0.0507805235683918,
0.2508097290992737,
0.020041320472955704,
0.7492551803588867,
-1.0736712217330933,
-0.24861524999141693,
-0.4724903106689453,
-0.09642413258552551,
-0.19286145269870758,
-0.5264008045196533,
0.3616279363632202,
0.21692252159118652,
-0.3200265169143677,
0.6733698844909668,
-0.4961940050125122,
0.36757007241249084,
0.2951223850250244,
-0.044104184955358505,
0.5273064374923706,
0.09260648488998413,
-0.22095070779323578,
-0.279058039188385,
-0.1256144493818283,
-0.6116883754730225,
0.8547866344451904,
0.5431848764419556,
0.4428376257419586,
0.3894953727722168,
0.35310739278793335,
0.2456613928079605,
-0.10449836403131485,
-1.0304019451141357,
0.5058246850967407,
0.0917474776506424,
-0.4774778485298157,
-0.5030606985092163,
-0.5138044953346252,
-0.4102001488208771,
0.4761698842048645,
0.2012430876493454,
-1.1965534687042236,
-0.4784695506095886,
-0.11380229145288467,
-0.6713476777076721,
0.1737290620803833,
-0.6398257613182068,
0.7141687273979187,
-0.2445247769355774,
0.095669224858284,
-0.18143753707408905,
-0.34699222445487976,
0.37245869636535645,
-0.31211480498313904,
-0.2536154091358185,
-0.4117867946624756,
0.206927090883255,
0.6851415038108826,
-0.4424077570438385,
0.6564258933067322,
-0.4071098864078522,
-0.3751775324344635,
0.28920379281044006,
0.3161364197731018,
0.4508689343929291,
0.003924333490431309,
-0.10779133439064026,
0.18953700363636017,
0.542868435382843,
-0.39971986413002014,
-1.021500587463379,
0.680899977684021,
-0.5307063460350037,
-0.5426076650619507,
-0.689606249332428,
-0.5504152178764343,
-0.40740975737571716,
0.08640801161527634,
0.1349378377199173,
0.6511442065238953,
-0.11073961108922958,
-0.23652809858322144,
0.15563692152500153,
-0.1108839213848114,
0.40910986065864563,
0.9566517472267151,
-0.19643482565879822,
-0.29016950726509094,
0.5925517082214355,
0.15123121440410614,
0.2922675907611847,
0.22333848476409912,
0.11522537469863892,
-0.8239921927452087,
-0.26951146125793457,
-0.8342218995094299,
0.19490018486976624,
-0.3191911280155182,
-0.2901211082935333,
-0.6015403866767883,
-0.26660484075546265,
-0.5858994722366333,
0.009134518913924694,
-0.3007681369781494,
-0.34997597336769104,
0.14388355612754822,
-0.24299311637878418,
0.34683388471603394,
0.8925639986991882,
0.0713263526558876,
0.1263815015554428,
-0.4239070415496826,
0.48438596725463867,
0.49993306398391724,
0.8313160538673401,
-0.25342050194740295,
-0.7383134365081787,
0.09686748683452606,
0.38012877106666565,
-0.539157509803772,
-0.7672141194343567,
-0.10127352178096771,
0.0031377538107335567,
0.40183931589126587,
0.13130828738212585,
-0.16556786000728607,
0.7882853746414185,
-0.6783048510551453,
0.9180281758308411,
0.4380229115486145,
-1.1234380006790161,
0.7223420143127441,
-0.41062498092651367,
0.6575443148612976,
0.4899558424949646,
-0.028462672606110573,
-0.5636675357818604,
-0.19674310088157654,
-0.2237515151500702,
-0.3215709924697876,
1.1476154327392578,
0.4463728070259094,
0.04698925092816353,
-0.048964183777570724,
0.32291486859321594,
-0.31666499376296997,
-0.11792736500501633,
-0.15136565268039703,
0.06282123923301697,
-0.2444593459367752,
-0.025324899703264236,
0.0904960036277771,
-0.43192845582962036,
0.012150461785495281,
-0.1092011108994484,
0.44498589634895325,
-0.13338813185691833,
0.45908814668655396,
0.03269941359758377,
0.1504409909248352,
-0.23370303213596344,
0.3954720199108124,
0.6370893120765686,
0.6666877865791321,
-0.5705736875534058,
-0.25764140486717224,
0.2869437038898468,
-0.3783450722694397,
0.33474624156951904,
0.08836600929498672,
-0.39062967896461487,
0.18675865232944489,
0.08237288892269135,
1.038789987564087,
-0.0021582513581961393,
-0.20622050762176514,
1.0372579097747803,
-0.17624440789222717,
-0.3234449326992035,
-0.2907938063144684,
-0.1331510990858078,
-0.0743827298283577,
0.3746996521949768,
0.053245048969984055,
-0.08581531792879105,
0.16523486375808716,
-0.5265545845031738,
0.25621259212493896,
0.5039467811584473,
-0.7686111927032471,
-0.49900680780410767,
0.422117680311203,
0.0911480039358139,
-0.44130948185920715,
0.6766173839569092,
-0.47513142228126526,
-0.6138262152671814,
0.4584236443042755,
0.7606571316719055,
0.9978890419006348,
-0.4313424527645111,
0.5170696973800659,
0.5323119163513184,
0.11064697802066803,
-0.16047000885009766,
0.31614068150520325,
-0.36602309346199036,
-0.5251083970069885,
-0.858757495880127,
-0.7489424347877502,
-0.3742094337940216,
0.26970338821411133,
-0.7635942697525024,
0.3355460464954376,
-0.5155840516090393,
-0.23630188405513763,
0.002061686012893915,
0.27246564626693726,
-0.6218611598014832,
0.07630930840969086,
0.25840404629707336,
0.7176411747932434,
-0.7300516366958618,
0.8345548510551453,
0.3020906448364258,
-0.31033623218536377,
-0.5615682601928711,
0.22215934097766876,
0.7295362949371338,
-0.7115323543548584,
0.3818496763706207,
0.40492260456085205,
-0.4745078384876251,
-0.17851752042770386,
-0.17868328094482422,
-0.9089211821556091,
1.0377501249313354,
0.3028189241886139,
-0.7054632306098938,
0.18295027315616608,
0.0360647477209568,
0.8640027642250061,
-0.04793306440114975,
0.6368284225463867,
1.237147569656372,
0.4032594561576843,
0.4770589768886566,
-1.2321105003356934,
0.0788794755935669,
0.034095101058483124,
0.23552177846431732,
0.4034707546234131,
-0.5125625133514404,
0.24635247886180878,
-0.09950847178697586,
-0.5477343797683716,
0.3056829273700714,
0.12763260304927826,
0.2748948633670807,
0.36066582798957825,
0.510284423828125,
0.758505642414093,
0.4212343096733093,
-0.10216371715068817,
0.7588102221488953,
-0.009137117303907871,
0.8343658447265625,
1.2805116176605225,
-0.7924531698226929,
0.6386106610298157,
-0.013377967290580273,
-0.3744274973869324,
0.23972012102603912,
0.2819370627403259,
-0.061861976981163025,
0.6952486038208008,
0.33658167719841003,
-0.5092282891273499,
0.08056239038705826,
-0.0001239846315002069,
-0.09766489267349243,
0.6657935976982117,
0.26227015256881714,
0.20559139549732208,
-0.7465015649795532,
-0.287471204996109,
0.36153310537338257,
-0.04852094128727913,
-0.013287213630974293,
1.0128406286239624,
-0.13711534440517426,
-0.7896152138710022,
0.5730709433555603,
-0.03851209208369255,
0.3694021999835968,
-0.4494193494319916,
-0.18758352100849152,
-0.33871638774871826,
-0.021502984687685966,
-0.01982206106185913,
-1.0299243927001953,
0.4070061445236206,
0.5001986026763916,
0.1830502599477768,
-0.18071217834949493,
0.2346496433019638,
-0.4598393142223358,
-0.3716703951358795,
0.4137941300868988,
0.144304558634758,
0.43120378255844116,
-0.21051909029483795,
-0.6379325985908508,
-0.08269470930099487,
0.42787280678749084,
-0.14754100143909454,
0.2548353970050812,
0.433730810880661,
-0.10903513431549072,
0.2812223732471466,
0.5032740235328674,
0.052308496087789536,
-0.22988425195217133,
0.34691619873046875,
0.5281737446784973,
-0.6724663376808167,
-0.344760924577713,
-0.9199087619781494,
0.19521331787109375,
-0.17149177193641663,
-0.3754425048828125,
0.6136837601661682,
0.6857793927192688,
0.34492358565330505,
0.39253729581832886,
1.0116256475448608,
0.00011156734399264678,
0.9211133122444153,
-0.42545005679130554,
0.270323246717453,
-0.09381282329559326,
0.306418776512146,
-0.40413162112236023,
-1.3769539594650269,
-0.23828834295272827,
0.6747249960899353,
-0.4825051724910736,
-0.0030437526293098927,
0.8306967616081238,
0.6860756278038025,
-0.11622438579797745,
0.2616299092769623,
0.6034525632858276,
0.32372891902923584,
0.519589900970459,
0.6489951014518738,
0.7519692778587341,
-0.505647599697113,
0.484874427318573,
-0.10791274160146713,
-0.6971724629402161,
0.0358804389834404,
-0.8589633703231812,
-0.8942475914955139,
-0.491700142621994,
-0.4586329758167267,
-0.24906839430332184,
-0.01126422081142664,
0.6991223096847534,
0.5626466870307922,
-0.6461034417152405,
0.08637405186891556,
0.058391861617565155,
-0.46739432215690613,
-0.07276306301355362,
-0.20903939008712769,
0.46508240699768066,
-0.25810322165489197,
-0.8486272096633911,
0.6225743889808655,
0.8750702142715454,
-0.06543489545583725,
-0.27185606956481934,
0.24476327002048492,
-0.13278062641620636,
0.07725470513105392,
0.7759097814559937,
0.057624299079179764,
-0.8928130865097046,
-0.6351040601730347,
-0.2558292746543884,
-0.1981791853904724,
-0.047236327081918716,
0.7060398459434509,
-0.5855166912078857,
0.8314679861068726,
0.5252326130867004,
0.37420904636383057,
0.9689735174179077,
0.41470345854759216,
0.6784935593605042,
-0.44124898314476013,
-0.02191340923309326,
0.1753917634487152,
0.07946441322565079,
0.38900354504585266,
-0.36419549584388733,
0.5409719944000244,
0.013165025971829891,
-0.7448680400848389,
-0.41669511795043945,
0.33812007308006287,
-1.0326021909713745,
0.057325590401887894,
1.196136236190796,
-0.3337692320346832,
0.2991389334201813,
-0.36900806427001953,
-0.3380678594112396,
0.3683514893054962,
-0.4678485691547394,
0.7975898385047913,
0.7302286028862,
-0.301029235124588,
-0.2585938274860382,
-0.9676612019538879,
0.48530325293540955,
0.21027512848377228,
-0.6292756199836731,
-0.1997966468334198,
0.5346270799636841,
0.6376705765724182,
0.06659071892499924,
1.0407007932662964,
-0.27111580967903137,
0.041216328740119934,
-0.1912761777639389,
-0.3311043977737427,
0.16970178484916687,
0.04622483253479004,
-0.6665157079696655,
-0.38460278511047363,
-0.2955423593521118,
-0.39777156710624695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00066v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00066v1 | Compress then Serve: Serving Thousands of LoRA Adapters with Little Overhead | 2024-06-17T15:21:35 | 2024-06-17T15:21:35 | Rickard Brüel-Gabrielsson, Jiacheng Zhu, Onkar Bhardwaj, Leshem Choshen, Kristjan Greenewald, Mikhail Yurochkin, Justin Solomon | cs.DC | cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) with low-rank adapters (LoRAs) has
become common practice, often yielding numerous copies of the same LLM
differing only in their LoRA updates. This paradigm presents challenges for
systems that serve real-time responses to queries that each involve a different
LoRA. Prior works optimize the design of such systems but still require
continuous loading and offloading of LoRAs, as it is infeasible to store
thousands of LoRAs in GPU memory. To mitigate this issue, we investigate the
efficacy of compression when serving LoRA adapters. We consider compressing
adapters individually via SVD and propose a method for joint compression of
LoRAs into a shared basis paired with LoRA-specific scaling matrices. Our
experiments with up to 500 LoRAs demonstrate that compressed LoRAs preserve
performance while offering major throughput gains in realistic serving
scenarios with over a thousand LoRAs, maintaining 75% of the throughput of
serving a single LoRA. | [
-0.6028860807418823,
-0.5765376091003418,
0.39246582984924316,
0.21699203550815582,
-0.3591783046722412,
-0.13219600915908813,
-0.26242202520370483,
-0.541486382484436,
0.6435953378677368,
0.7618088722229004,
-0.39773818850517273,
0.016382092610001564,
-0.5339186191558838,
-0.032723963260650635,
-0.16118723154067993,
0.5220375061035156,
0.24629570543766022,
-0.24391254782676697,
-0.14737266302108765,
-0.546642541885376,
-0.7164931893348694,
-0.38998743891716003,
-0.8322212100028992,
-0.1068950742483139,
0.6295097470283508,
0.7559285759925842,
0.8195104002952576,
0.6680097579956055,
0.6787244081497192,
0.3450871706008911,
-0.08024128526449203,
0.24753542244434357,
-0.8369127511978149,
0.6030278205871582,
0.12337657064199448,
-0.6948102116584778,
-0.48504209518432617,
-0.3747619688510895,
0.5493031740188599,
0.8001487255096436,
-0.5483717918395996,
0.4405171871185303,
0.1595652848482132,
0.7789908647537231,
-0.6796610355377197,
-0.26321813464164734,
-0.6893985271453857,
-0.06923191994428635,
-0.1791827380657196,
-0.09116297960281372,
-0.6003386378288269,
-0.6588196754455566,
-0.2742142081260681,
-0.615336537361145,
-0.17990277707576752,
0.2642451226711273,
0.7656428217887878,
0.762306809425354,
0.12315280735492706,
0.3301880657672882,
-0.7333239316940308,
0.5202305912971497,
-0.6052803993225098,
0.0769578069448471,
0.047964174300432205,
0.6890048384666443,
-0.39667999744415283,
-0.5164970755577087,
-0.42306825518608093,
0.4898677468299866,
0.12448924779891968,
-0.3140328526496887,
-0.47141966223716736,
-0.16869628429412842,
0.46502894163131714,
0.45825961232185364,
-0.3297586441040039,
0.5024070143699646,
-0.22929081320762634,
0.302669882774353,
0.17921368777751923,
0.03687802329659462,
0.016974270343780518,
0.18282195925712585,
-0.2146466076374054,
-0.09548831731081009,
-1.1361095905303955,
-0.08193253725767136,
0.15353181958198547,
0.5343945026397705,
0.046852387487888336,
0.7074675559997559,
-0.2674935758113861,
1.0321080684661865,
0.05537886917591095,
0.05168057605624199,
-0.15791575610637665,
-0.00778095331043005,
-0.4084697663784027,
-0.12203977257013321,
0.7433987259864807,
0.2511630654335022,
0.12864480912685394,
-0.18827688694000244,
-0.14078456163406372,
0.43640053272247314,
0.3981756269931793,
-0.8509293794631958,
0.10173504054546356,
0.12567447125911713,
-0.4247746467590332,
-0.3414340615272522,
-0.23842178285121918,
-0.8928288817405701,
-0.4880094528198242,
-0.11458916962146759,
0.7966540455818176,
0.11459115147590637,
0.2654227912425995,
0.251235693693161,
-0.0696989968419075,
-0.0068130469880998135,
0.26593470573425293,
-1.0885308980941772,
0.7944542169570923,
0.5147097110748291,
0.8854251503944397,
-0.07511863857507706,
-0.005002747289836407,
-1.3607882261276245,
0.08960871398448944,
0.08128750324249268,
1.2739545106887817,
-0.34835079312324524,
-0.37508440017700195,
0.06610780209302902,
0.13415952026844025,
0.32306134700775146,
-0.8442228436470032,
0.6520145535469055,
-0.6433355212211609,
-0.3855164349079132,
-0.517854630947113,
-0.25816643238067627,
0.4486648440361023,
0.17068056762218475,
-0.9234029054641724,
0.9208682179450989,
0.20587390661239624,
-0.4113456904888153,
0.10382592678070068,
-0.48914316296577454,
-0.47786054015159607,
0.0956963524222374,
-0.3650735914707184,
-0.29620954394340515,
0.5935974717140198,
0.3761288523674011,
0.29695168137550354,
-0.5490710735321045,
-0.520481526851654,
-0.3140767514705658,
-0.6400856375694275,
-0.058303315192461014,
0.001053444342687726,
0.25294029712677,
0.21448025107383728,
0.12249505519866943,
-0.04819851368665695,
-0.4829407036304474,
0.18980517983436584,
0.16151714324951172,
-0.9150468707084656,
-0.33322641253471375,
0.17673493921756744,
-0.08306014537811279,
0.024775013327598572,
0.27629074454307556,
-0.6175130009651184,
0.9693250060081482,
-0.346265584230423,
0.6110929846763611,
0.7711892127990723,
-0.31432464718818665,
0.2310507893562317,
-0.4167017936706543,
0.5002691745758057,
-0.17978350818157196,
0.39730527997016907,
0.14613549411296844,
-0.39050060510635376,
-1.0996745824813843,
-0.06803186982870102,
0.18157412111759186,
0.1699105203151703,
-0.8801475763320923,
0.36144307255744934,
-0.7916387915611267,
-0.6394255757331848,
-0.8455478549003601,
0.1361197531223297,
0.07977605611085892,
0.22587107121944427,
0.2530749440193176,
-0.22622810304164886,
-0.47284868359565735,
-0.9331190586090088,
-0.2863326668739319,
0.23741629719734192,
0.19322818517684937,
0.38309943675994873,
-0.05434809997677803,
-0.014769431203603745,
0.9249725341796875,
-0.8727312684059143,
-0.4204441010951996,
-0.1912023425102234,
-0.1395435780286789,
0.6594066619873047,
0.32653117179870605,
0.5811264514923096,
-0.5422891974449158,
-0.5665796399116516,
-0.02352237142622471,
-0.4948265552520752,
-0.0429353229701519,
0.4952929615974426,
0.045802850276231766,
0.12122806161642075,
0.4582352042198181,
-0.45675259828567505,
0.11178649961948395,
1.0916398763656616,
-0.28912249207496643,
0.1291400045156479,
-0.7722886800765991,
0.14608877897262573,
-1.0193876028060913,
-0.15639467537403107,
-0.38573431968688965,
-0.487606406211853,
-0.2960752248764038,
0.10110630095005035,
-0.2830599844455719,
-0.42768219113349915,
-0.43525224924087524,
0.35691964626312256,
-0.33294373750686646,
-0.4915231764316559,
-0.27738937735557556,
0.08872970193624496,
0.07211894541978836,
0.2831100821495056,
-0.24761776626110077,
0.9827836155891418,
0.369483083486557,
-0.9002406001091003,
0.2941591143608093,
0.11104068160057068,
-0.4095720052719116,
0.5783596634864807,
-0.9673541188240051,
0.23624669015407562,
-0.10261639207601547,
0.3126750588417053,
-0.7901196479797363,
-0.0931297168135643,
-0.025977211073040962,
0.060735080391168594,
-0.14363816380500793,
-0.6827077865600586,
-0.719610869884491,
-0.2957342863082886,
-0.2803187966346741,
0.4159735441207886,
0.6954575777053833,
-0.9758231043815613,
0.6730619668960571,
0.5478717684745789,
-0.028966132551431656,
-0.51788330078125,
-0.8041350245475769,
-0.06322960555553436,
-0.2339787781238556,
-0.5516368746757507,
0.32340604066848755,
-0.4807507395744324,
-0.19790761172771454,
0.018495788797736168,
-0.0204672459512949,
0.11605622619390488,
0.1772848516702652,
0.6270076632499695,
0.11989738792181015,
-0.3349032998085022,
-0.2268795520067215,
0.12559780478477478,
-0.22539006173610687,
-0.4959487020969391,
-0.5359489321708679,
0.9388111233711243,
-0.017159240320324898,
-0.538351833820343,
-0.22194020450115204,
0.49523982405662537,
0.820499062538147,
0.2600906491279602,
1.0015299320220947,
0.2823040783405304,
-0.32405808568000793,
-0.04379415884613991,
-0.6282321810722351,
0.12356430292129517,
-0.5574394464492798,
-0.13148193061351776,
-0.6200112104415894,
-0.7579777240753174,
0.513264536857605,
-0.1880222111940384,
0.24558866024017334,
0.34381240606307983,
0.32359620928764343,
-0.18051345646381378,
0.5326622724533081,
0.6935311555862427,
-0.32644233107566833,
0.6467463374137878,
-0.24406208097934723,
0.2435687631368637,
-0.7672566771507263,
0.21705767512321472,
-0.9271571040153503,
-0.7155927419662476,
-0.5945407152175903,
-0.6959320306777954,
0.6486566066741943,
0.026922475546598434,
0.06603831052780151,
0.5335193872451782,
-0.7366612553596497,
1.0287269353866577,
0.2844461500644684,
0.043347977101802826,
0.5061286687850952,
0.2804659903049469,
0.23026441037654877,
0.0602114200592041,
-0.7274527549743652,
-0.23385582864284515,
0.7561740279197693,
-0.04490983113646507,
1.2457656860351562,
0.6259595155715942,
0.6708366870880127,
0.4826376438140869,
-0.006299788597971201,
-0.8055691719055176,
0.5548131465911865,
-0.6878992319107056,
0.0305950865149498,
-0.22959907352924347,
-0.3748033940792084,
-1.132185935974121,
0.3915369510650635,
-0.19897405803203583,
-0.6972970366477966,
0.32145029306411743,
0.19084471464157104,
-0.7202031016349792,
0.34197625517845154,
-0.7676887512207031,
0.32327407598495483,
0.08947276324033737,
-0.3178490400314331,
-0.4653788208961487,
-0.3073938190937042,
-0.12375335395336151,
0.14452101290225983,
0.13808782398700714,
0.2072354257106781,
-0.03167874738574028,
0.7368679642677307,
-0.5347141027450562,
0.60368812084198,
-0.19191677868366241,
-0.13221518695354462,
-0.24699530005455017,
0.08493280410766602,
0.7366684675216675,
0.0466730110347271,
-0.19807638227939606,
-0.15537908673286438,
0.20779593288898468,
-0.5924616456031799,
-0.7752540111541748,
1.2483747005462646,
-0.8843117952346802,
-0.48842212557792664,
-0.3154503107070923,
-0.37138330936431885,
-0.09862535446882248,
0.17199116945266724,
0.19968146085739136,
0.537327229976654,
-0.1445390284061432,
0.10031507909297943,
1.0588089227676392,
0.02093096263706684,
0.4149363338947296,
0.42111876606941223,
-0.2646832764148712,
-0.10651996731758118,
0.8783949613571167,
0.28994905948638916,
0.5494383573532104,
0.37829941511154175,
0.10304904729127884,
0.20257550477981567,
-0.404334157705307,
-0.47302132844924927,
0.2682034373283386,
-0.7783164381980896,
-0.38397660851478577,
-0.40540677309036255,
0.08864861726760864,
-0.3939782381057739,
-0.21723848581314087,
-0.7093728184700012,
-0.5438995957374573,
-0.18336080014705658,
0.6130497455596924,
0.4697023034095764,
0.9574713110923767,
0.0927710235118866,
0.6089644432067871,
-0.688471794128418,
0.7015904784202576,
0.30261141061782837,
0.4885927736759186,
-0.16839641332626343,
-0.45148468017578125,
-0.24865871667861938,
-0.16184750199317932,
0.15087279677391052,
-0.3297942280769348,
0.3512011170387268,
0.1955387443304062,
0.37165242433547974,
0.5398144721984863,
0.1983949989080429,
0.9125309586524963,
-0.6462046504020691,
0.7429180145263672,
-0.13051837682724,
-0.4592876732349396,
0.5006783604621887,
-0.07090462744235992,
0.44159048795700073,
0.7877882122993469,
0.2216109335422516,
-0.4905630946159363,
0.24350251257419586,
-0.3301018178462982,
-0.7258313298225403,
0.5125166773796082,
-0.362820029258728,
0.14858558773994446,
0.19679546356201172,
0.5532922744750977,
0.2536255419254303,
-0.05388624966144562,
-0.416705846786499,
-0.44516390562057495,
0.26429152488708496,
0.08896379917860031,
0.01568267121911049,
-0.24600642919540405,
-0.41439783573150635,
-0.03708837181329727,
0.4438876211643219,
-0.3546551465988159,
0.5491039752960205,
-0.1483306586742401,
-0.05141304060816765,
-0.07608145475387573,
0.40629133582115173,
0.5364154577255249,
0.25815293192863464,
-0.30139151215553284,
0.3366886079311371,
0.04630323126912117,
-0.33219006657600403,
0.15122847259044647,
-0.031004661694169044,
-0.025479499250650406,
-0.09684263169765472,
-0.1594988852739334,
0.865536630153656,
0.27417394518852234,
-0.7010964155197144,
0.22852443158626556,
-0.6959101557731628,
0.32220184803009033,
-0.09698542952537537,
0.2435130774974823,
0.0976829081773758,
0.1353561282157898,
0.02549578808248043,
0.36495158076286316,
-0.33032554388046265,
-0.475002259016037,
-0.3759695887565613,
0.4316132962703705,
-0.15850047767162323,
-0.07402448356151581,
0.3514673113822937,
0.18344832956790924,
-0.4043116569519043,
0.3953905403614044,
0.13900478184223175,
-0.27783554792404175,
0.0843096449971199,
0.5801777839660645,
0.3520471155643463,
0.04665827006101608,
-0.3811119496822357,
0.028057973831892014,
0.1540539562702179,
-0.44295594096183777,
0.28023040294647217,
-0.08984357863664627,
-0.6211652755737305,
-0.4067099094390869,
-0.7088351249694824,
-0.46698975563049316,
-0.053750179708004,
-0.820661723613739,
0.5221302509307861,
-0.37980613112449646,
-0.11979237198829651,
-0.09970176219940186,
-0.027424413710832596,
-0.6057013869285583,
-0.28189924359321594,
0.009354068897664547,
1.160632848739624,
-0.8131455183029175,
1.0842119455337524,
0.44831234216690063,
-0.33042454719543457,
-0.5064566135406494,
-0.306485116481781,
-0.2584986686706543,
-0.7320896983146667,
0.5632144212722778,
-0.3905957341194153,
-0.44082048535346985,
0.1039237231016159,
-0.2068306803703308,
-0.9985821843147278,
0.99382483959198,
0.615097165107727,
-0.7267597317695618,
-0.1889399290084839,
0.23424392938613892,
0.31717073917388916,
-0.23635892570018768,
0.009393795393407345,
0.4712466895580292,
0.33209535479545593,
0.10949327051639557,
-0.8435424566268921,
0.060063038021326065,
-0.03084760159254074,
-0.217501699924469,
0.23660656809806824,
-0.7141543030738831,
0.7201757431030273,
-0.10677266120910645,
-0.007814344018697739,
0.18246866762638092,
0.5855066776275635,
0.1858307123184204,
-0.4809059798717499,
0.7611250281333923,
0.9183487892150879,
0.8578565716743469,
0.026339780539274216,
1.2535027265548706,
-0.04837485030293465,
0.09498316794633865,
1.1473075151443481,
-0.2813045382499695,
1.248654842376709,
0.9381399154663086,
-0.035636160522699356,
0.3408089578151703,
0.3521956503391266,
0.19590073823928833,
0.5939109325408936,
0.26461461186408997,
-0.3460831344127655,
-0.2375195324420929,
-0.46934157609939575,
-0.4437112808227539,
0.16312368214130402,
0.18484388291835785,
0.045530762523412704,
-0.22722584009170532,
0.015126287005841732,
0.059625670313835144,
-0.012668072246015072,
-0.21105659008026123,
0.6200700402259827,
-0.0037356577813625336,
-0.876825749874115,
0.9632381200790405,
-0.316184937953949,
0.8922138214111328,
-0.4733675420284271,
0.06447724252939224,
-0.3814285695552826,
0.24017934501171112,
-0.16828222572803497,
-0.49943941831588745,
0.2016981542110443,
-0.054516009986400604,
-0.6436487436294556,
-0.28030773997306824,
0.5380273461341858,
-0.12196564674377441,
-0.22013725340366364,
0.2344370037317276,
0.3641119599342346,
0.15516629815101624,
0.0719628557562828,
-0.02590620331466198,
0.8372954726219177,
-0.2661830484867096,
-0.0761273130774498,
0.8861955404281616,
0.04921600967645645,
0.13846564292907715,
0.9041882753372192,
0.5876895785331726,
0.5621232390403748,
0.16806542873382568,
0.20801500976085663,
1.4397798776626587,
-0.27488356828689575,
-0.4798792898654938,
-0.573843777179718,
-0.021509135141968727,
-0.04379255697131157,
0.08365080505609512,
0.2692428231239319,
0.46693676710128784,
0.33980122208595276,
-0.017959296703338623,
0.7029430270195007,
-0.2584457993507385,
0.3143766224384308,
-0.6196863055229187,
0.782135546207428,
-0.5570642352104187,
0.4705612361431122,
0.21487891674041748,
-0.8796277642250061,
-0.1958320587873459,
0.4064394533634186,
0.061813727021217346,
-0.6083534955978394,
0.4252322316169739,
0.6152008175849915,
-0.3554241359233856,
-0.3551281690597534,
0.419143408536911,
0.2834000885486603,
0.5749616622924805,
0.5527977347373962,
0.39148056507110596,
-0.7416727542877197,
0.628973126411438,
-0.0024576608557254076,
-0.0019463516073301435,
-0.47035977244377136,
-0.8652910590171814,
-0.550847053527832,
-0.3444291055202484,
-0.16608309745788574,
-0.5291191339492798,
0.016071826219558716,
0.9137277603149414,
0.8787610530853271,
-0.44731006026268005,
-0.19749370217323303,
0.30895546078681946,
0.06294384598731995,
-0.35538727045059204,
-0.10930965095758438,
0.2432629019021988,
-0.2332640141248703,
-0.707403302192688,
0.7424569725990295,
0.16624262928962708,
-0.25663748383522034,
-0.3504863381385803,
0.007123313844203949,
-0.05048070102930069,
0.199090376496315,
0.5701009631156921,
0.46304717659950256,
-0.5209586024284363,
-0.41389167308807373,
-0.1836462914943695,
-0.1809299737215042,
0.21318741142749786,
0.7819912433624268,
-1.3731211423873901,
0.15537390112876892,
0.6661214828491211,
0.7900992035865784,
0.49945610761642456,
-0.08599712699651718,
0.3785160779953003,
-0.7573920488357544,
0.22572335600852966,
-0.1323813945055008,
0.5546810626983643,
0.07470327615737915,
-0.3700646758079529,
0.5337545275688171,
-0.10683271288871765,
-0.8201681971549988,
-0.9618565440177917,
0.33862024545669556,
-1.4988733530044556,
-0.07202062010765076,
0.9281019568443298,
-0.28561192750930786,
-0.23511523008346558,
0.034508801996707916,
-0.1048489660024643,
-0.013574863784015179,
-0.4467339515686035,
0.6433053016662598,
0.2889355421066284,
-0.3223748803138733,
-0.057815421372652054,
-0.5213003158569336,
0.41569095849990845,
0.2754440903663635,
-0.9940500259399414,
0.31448763608932495,
0.16009481251239777,
0.179384246468544,
0.13274995982646942,
0.516786515712738,
0.22054104506969452,
-0.15342570841312408,
-0.2502065896987915,
-0.1430654227733612,
0.0882151871919632,
-0.07513277232646942,
-0.4886334240436554,
0.4185792803764343,
0.47998693585395813,
-0.15881851315498352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11634v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11634v1 | The Base-Rate Effect on LLM Benchmark Performance: Disambiguating Test-Taking Strategies from Benchmark Performance | 2024-06-17T15:14:10 | 2024-06-17T15:14:10 | Kyle Moore, Jesse Roberts, Thao Pham, Oseremhen Ewaleifoh, Doug Fisher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Cloze testing is a common method for measuring the behavior of large language
models on a number of benchmark tasks. Using the MMLU dataset, we show that the
base-rate probability (BRP) differences across answer tokens are significant
and affect task performance ie. guess A if uncertain. We find that
counterfactual prompting does sufficiently mitigate the BRP effect. The BRP
effect is found to have a similar effect to test taking strategies employed by
humans leading to the conflation of task performance and test-taking ability.
We propose the Nvr-X-MMLU task, a variation of MMLU, which helps to
disambiguate test-taking ability from task performance and reports the latter. | [
-0.619622528553009,
-0.9650719165802002,
0.08027057349681854,
0.05521288141608238,
-0.13455189764499664,
-0.1853722780942917,
-0.12758027017116547,
-0.5165287852287292,
-0.011937404982745647,
0.04714665561914444,
-0.5957126617431641,
-0.04849405214190483,
-0.5942301750183105,
0.12784506380558014,
-0.1255628913640976,
0.6052126884460449,
0.006450321059674025,
0.08454590290784836,
-0.28453853726387024,
-0.15343591570854187,
-0.8717771172523499,
-0.5792222023010254,
-0.5501925945281982,
-0.5833999514579773,
0.6395732164382935,
0.5122590065002441,
0.5320161581039429,
0.35200780630111694,
0.37160444259643555,
0.12931634485721588,
-0.07197588682174683,
-0.25362834334373474,
-0.5873591899871826,
0.19833263754844666,
-0.21331840753555298,
-1.2981629371643066,
-0.39290544390678406,
0.26722294092178345,
0.60488361120224,
0.6294910311698914,
-0.23101267218589783,
0.4228174686431885,
0.1642410010099411,
0.7044689655303955,
-0.7012394070625305,
-0.03898071497678757,
-0.7042165398597717,
-0.15069782733917236,
-0.21555806696414948,
-0.41680213809013367,
-0.599097490310669,
-0.10165008902549744,
-0.0009712135652080178,
-0.19541096687316895,
0.5716858506202698,
0.19873857498168945,
0.5164183974266052,
0.22051462531089783,
-0.13089676201343536,
-0.2622423470020294,
-0.2678717076778412,
0.8321212530136108,
-0.6430761218070984,
0.6057990193367004,
0.2843814194202423,
0.0031698502134531736,
-0.23011454939842224,
-0.2309153527021408,
-0.6105347275733948,
-0.5400934219360352,
-0.09917949885129929,
-0.0017941095866262913,
-0.2039051651954651,
-0.10483852028846741,
0.938305675983429,
0.4619898498058319,
-0.837520956993103,
0.11316215246915817,
-0.42488834261894226,
-0.06298030912876129,
0.4817095100879669,
0.23185503482818604,
0.1737583875656128,
0.13977783918380737,
-0.28012216091156006,
-0.16984261572360992,
-1.0739513635635376,
0.5685332417488098,
0.2706017792224884,
0.20835508406162262,
0.26275476813316345,
0.6581913828849792,
-0.5546013116836548,
0.7512335777282715,
0.1274360865354538,
-0.14888450503349304,
0.4696158766746521,
-0.3546586036682129,
-0.5202000737190247,
0.12137803435325623,
0.1698695868253708,
0.4651404917240143,
0.31206533312797546,
-0.039082061499357224,
0.014793175272643566,
0.45209038257598877,
-0.019849546253681183,
-0.8986611366271973,
0.08482249081134796,
0.18813957273960114,
-0.24613803625106812,
-0.06485812366008759,
-0.260537713766098,
-0.8394684195518494,
-0.2363481968641281,
-0.2059379369020462,
0.4609230160713196,
-0.33914995193481445,
-0.0394393727183342,
0.11880790442228317,
-0.43526700139045715,
0.3253559172153473,
-0.10762477666139603,
-0.7901240587234497,
0.5345219969749451,
0.42331334948539734,
0.7595986127853394,
-0.3430453836917877,
-0.4074482321739197,
-0.9765912294387817,
-0.22874309122562408,
-0.16066595911979675,
0.5867334008216858,
-0.36884018778800964,
-0.8666958808898926,
-0.25134116411209106,
-0.08391225337982178,
-0.3631645739078522,
-0.9506092071533203,
0.34447529911994934,
-0.48742374777793884,
-0.007716500665992498,
-0.6982724070549011,
-0.6601437926292419,
-0.19621403515338898,
0.3047693073749542,
-0.6503577828407288,
1.1256310939788818,
0.04216300696134567,
-0.5864608883857727,
0.7420417070388794,
-0.6090885996818542,
-0.5998281240463257,
-0.03420272469520569,
-0.137262225151062,
-0.14750982820987701,
0.08423685282468796,
0.033981721848249435,
0.3134412467479706,
-0.07607832551002502,
-0.34182223677635193,
-0.21733836829662323,
-0.656895101070404,
0.3626047670841217,
-0.36600014567375183,
0.7241012454032898,
-0.06900523602962494,
-0.812487781047821,
-0.3060735762119293,
-0.680933952331543,
0.2265140563249588,
0.15082770586013794,
-0.406515896320343,
-0.4707036316394806,
-0.06289353221654892,
-0.3651655912399292,
0.24670207500457764,
0.08932992815971375,
-0.6027013659477234,
0.28158748149871826,
-0.3143649697303772,
-0.0269983671605587,
0.541221559047699,
0.06768517196178436,
0.18579313158988953,
-0.7003657221794128,
0.4807957410812378,
-0.0749412253499031,
0.14578676223754883,
0.04912300035357475,
-0.765465259552002,
-0.5714913010597229,
-0.07097741216421127,
0.13107550144195557,
0.7678177952766418,
-0.20825450122356415,
-0.16022656857967377,
0.11136388778686523,
-0.47596633434295654,
-0.4872143268585205,
0.5232512354850769,
0.5763241648674011,
0.6444463729858398,
0.36350440979003906,
-0.595272421836853,
-0.36236536502838135,
-0.8189882040023804,
-0.28931719064712524,
-0.20243389904499054,
0.003229934023693204,
0.2546757757663727,
0.45577460527420044,
0.07125566899776459,
0.8592631816864014,
-0.7001379132270813,
-0.05241386964917183,
-0.2938685119152069,
0.44159096479415894,
0.2571268379688263,
0.3815542161464691,
0.5450882911682129,
-0.7893004417419434,
-0.4479081630706787,
-0.3833836317062378,
-0.23536325991153717,
-0.6386348605155945,
0.13558833301067352,
0.06215311586856842,
0.424998015165329,
0.43925705552101135,
-0.7482713460922241,
0.6288796067237854,
0.3132368326187134,
-0.09585904330015182,
0.992563784122467,
-0.12655571103096008,
0.3812335729598999,
-0.49385595321655273,
0.18067404627799988,
-0.014377227984368801,
-0.007703032344579697,
-0.6305835843086243,
0.2505653202533722,
0.22291995584964752,
0.36250239610671997,
-0.6704206466674805,
0.4808809161186218,
-0.30220454931259155,
-0.19347788393497467,
-0.28169500827789307,
0.12720072269439697,
-0.016844891011714935,
0.3625863790512085,
-0.13008368015289307,
1.2086037397384644,
0.337213933467865,
-0.8606569170951843,
-0.03269220143556595,
0.149775430560112,
-0.22724761068820953,
0.6402603387832642,
-0.5771905183792114,
0.08161856979131699,
0.011200825683772564,
0.006449032109230757,
-1.1789637804031372,
0.3167218565940857,
-0.027635984122753143,
-0.4471791088581085,
0.21393893659114838,
-0.009918203577399254,
-0.6198080778121948,
-0.3539341390132904,
-0.30021750926971436,
0.34199532866477966,
0.7536382079124451,
-0.2910142242908478,
0.13924583792686462,
-0.24784362316131592,
-0.1551445871591568,
-1.0159456729888916,
-0.7452203035354614,
-0.33795157074928284,
-0.33190494775772095,
-0.399703711271286,
0.27853405475616455,
-0.44011855125427246,
-0.48689889907836914,
-0.48874324560165405,
-0.22393128275871277,
-0.1103222593665123,
0.376804381608963,
0.6331878304481506,
0.27476122975349426,
-0.1772674173116684,
-0.02377159520983696,
-0.32221290469169617,
-0.0016680684639140964,
0.2828923463821411,
0.3434816300868988,
0.7274965047836304,
-0.02461489662528038,
-0.3259703516960144,
-0.25728216767311096,
0.20688538253307343,
0.47460997104644775,
-0.27252069115638733,
0.555536687374115,
0.408038467168808,
-0.04328342527151108,
-0.32136815786361694,
-0.5970174670219421,
-0.35382676124572754,
-0.4487898647785187,
0.13932287693023682,
-0.4857765734195709,
-0.71416836977005,
0.5277034044265747,
0.05177568271756172,
0.16106662154197693,
0.10821687430143356,
0.9089649319648743,
-0.1865573674440384,
0.7422638535499573,
0.2922248840332031,
-0.12727127969264984,
0.47517529129981995,
-0.25962120294570923,
0.022527001798152924,
-0.8666760325431824,
0.28161725401878357,
-0.40897637605667114,
-0.38324013352394104,
-0.3075028359889984,
-0.381001740694046,
0.06251855194568634,
0.08838887512683868,
0.059744421392679214,
0.3023872375488281,
-0.07936812937259674,
0.4069226384162903,
0.6806173920631409,
0.18422621488571167,
0.41102486848831177,
-0.4012404978275299,
-0.27609649300575256,
-0.019011201336979866,
-0.45439666509628296,
-0.07875771820545197,
1.3345892429351807,
-0.07463575899600983,
0.5101768970489502,
0.05453347787261009,
0.508585512638092,
0.5848096013069153,
0.5642569065093994,
-0.5290274620056152,
0.6513416767120361,
0.24463963508605957,
-0.9873690009117126,
-0.2648093104362488,
-0.2841903567314148,
-1.02191960811615,
0.4324214458465576,
-0.08277277648448944,
-0.8867501020431519,
0.022381644695997238,
0.26614153385162354,
-0.3559437096118927,
0.08078552782535553,
-0.7714853882789612,
0.6462644934654236,
-0.14941467344760895,
-0.42380768060684204,
-0.4090352952480316,
-0.38318926095962524,
0.3931126892566681,
0.026043875142931938,
0.06679853051900864,
-0.32402458786964417,
0.20894402265548706,
0.45454320311546326,
0.12486711889505386,
0.8812041282653809,
-0.4697374701499939,
0.33699244260787964,
0.30595606565475464,
0.4130665957927704,
0.5139289498329163,
-0.14098630845546722,
-0.10503968596458435,
-0.06480878591537476,
-0.023864801973104477,
-0.5296393632888794,
-0.5348933935165405,
0.5330448746681213,
-0.34236031770706177,
-0.7943559288978577,
-0.17071957886219025,
-0.8730983138084412,
-0.2924703061580658,
0.0860690027475357,
0.36318668723106384,
0.5128825306892395,
-0.2948289215564728,
0.08158235251903534,
0.6580166220664978,
0.13576334714889526,
0.3438878357410431,
0.7504273056983948,
-0.11289702355861664,
0.1580444574356079,
0.42253586649894714,
0.39796292781829834,
0.7279475331306458,
0.3357369601726532,
0.32009053230285645,
-0.4365624785423279,
-0.6577115058898926,
-0.20717601478099823,
0.11679146438837051,
-0.7673652172088623,
0.2053905427455902,
-0.319021612405777,
0.29207924008369446,
-0.20698697865009308,
-0.27370744943618774,
0.02784827910363674,
-0.2844582796096802,
0.016387026757001877,
-0.2794519066810608,
0.12317898869514465,
0.4191012978553772,
-0.11297834664583206,
0.4508008658885956,
-0.2663247287273407,
0.18808823823928833,
0.33685117959976196,
-0.017603658139705658,
0.10121164470911026,
-0.3535446524620056,
0.025048408657312393,
0.015918901190161705,
-0.29133665561676025,
-0.7088289260864258,
0.04681690037250519,
-0.026938840746879578,
1.0054376125335693,
0.1629936546087265,
0.08085578680038452,
0.7183488607406616,
-0.3749230206012726,
0.8624820113182068,
0.2308007776737213,
-0.8545240163803101,
0.3501283526420593,
-0.0676972046494484,
0.19427354633808136,
0.6961043477058411,
0.3160601556301117,
-0.5249186158180237,
-0.29076310992240906,
-0.4301212430000305,
-0.5018686056137085,
0.14526724815368652,
0.300331711769104,
-0.18244192004203796,
-0.08561650663614273,
0.2470831573009491,
0.25995826721191406,
0.4125787317752838,
-0.6581542491912842,
-0.5275604724884033,
0.29281532764434814,
0.21112602949142456,
-0.19202332198619843,
-0.22798804938793182,
-0.15872742235660553,
-0.22422820329666138,
0.5094007253646851,
0.03833805024623871,
0.06805668026208878,
0.6225640773773193,
-0.523036539554596,
-0.08050833642482758,
0.5032995343208313,
0.8743282556533813,
0.7969368100166321,
-0.6681448817253113,
-0.07994963228702545,
0.5343857407569885,
-0.5341804623603821,
0.2822822332382202,
-0.08710341900587082,
-0.1392747461795807,
0.021813951432704926,
0.2340223640203476,
0.36658400297164917,
0.20967651903629303,
-0.8126091361045837,
0.4003307819366455,
0.11969255656003952,
-0.425461083650589,
0.014296941459178925,
0.5851699113845825,
-0.02747238613665104,
0.0061252303421497345,
0.46805140376091003,
-0.14601001143455505,
0.2383352518081665,
-0.6216979622840881,
0.7187594175338745,
0.3758643567562103,
-0.36582499742507935,
-0.13380375504493713,
0.7447932362556458,
0.013207481242716312,
-0.49633538722991943,
0.39109668135643005,
-0.2550726532936096,
-0.4583227336406708,
0.839030921459198,
0.6490272283554077,
0.3205563426017761,
-0.4111007750034332,
0.06952564418315887,
0.23310630023479462,
0.3154078722000122,
0.129780575633049,
0.4776657521724701,
-0.017238331958651543,
-0.606821596622467,
-0.6125357151031494,
-0.10078763961791992,
-0.5234262347221375,
0.21318116784095764,
-0.7596995234489441,
-0.08799371123313904,
-0.2203361988067627,
-0.3686986267566681,
0.09792156517505646,
0.145218625664711,
-1.0369154214859009,
0.3771994709968567,
0.3864952027797699,
1.1777364015579224,
-0.7893874049186707,
0.7123453617095947,
0.39845362305641174,
-0.29032576084136963,
-0.5340036153793335,
-0.14869634807109833,
-0.027267824858427048,
-0.9758206605911255,
0.9258214831352234,
0.4328538179397583,
0.06713087856769562,
-0.19622044265270233,
-0.2566346526145935,
-0.7129920125007629,
1.0888516902923584,
0.14329206943511963,
-0.49459731578826904,
0.22500662505626678,
0.5513697266578674,
0.4096127152442932,
-0.3539773225784302,
0.3722113370895386,
0.8910472393035889,
0.4481579065322876,
-0.3360550105571747,
-1.1254254579544067,
0.18524308502674103,
-0.11447064578533173,
-0.337758868932724,
0.22292625904083252,
-0.593031644821167,
0.8748947978019714,
-0.2764694392681122,
-0.16074778139591217,
-0.11112464219331741,
0.08913367986679077,
0.6327411532402039,
0.828301191329956,
0.7183358669281006,
0.6375490427017212,
0.7490267753601074,
0.10376981645822525,
1.05653715133667,
-0.1877088099718094,
0.290899395942688,
1.10427987575531,
-0.6755170822143555,
1.1158726215362549,
0.8746984601020813,
-0.3561426103115082,
0.5348978638648987,
0.3758932948112488,
0.1021464392542839,
0.4510212242603302,
0.5657636523246765,
-0.13544493913650513,
0.04789626598358154,
0.00039130018558353186,
-0.25540632009506226,
0.2857000529766083,
0.2467881143093109,
-0.27222228050231934,
-0.3582766354084015,
-0.08270677179098129,
0.0544295608997345,
-0.13774119317531586,
-0.3902134895324707,
0.15256653726100922,
0.02438722550868988,
-0.7952814698219299,
0.7080633044242859,
-0.42442333698272705,
0.5943193435668945,
-0.5152477025985718,
-0.043062712997198105,
-0.19265036284923553,
0.1363203525543213,
-0.06763240694999695,
-0.813185453414917,
0.1666109263896942,
-0.3005813658237457,
-0.38539808988571167,
0.1021089255809784,
0.5833263993263245,
-0.20827482640743256,
-0.1000894233584404,
0.601281464099884,
0.8344149589538574,
0.06196549907326698,
-0.24367807805538177,
-0.7451842427253723,
-0.2527580261230469,
0.025796467438340187,
-0.4206603169441223,
0.5097454190254211,
-0.20732763409614563,
-0.07635053247213364,
0.782036542892456,
1.019256591796875,
-0.0931786373257637,
0.4822530448436737,
-0.051157962530851364,
0.46188846230506897,
-0.5293614268302917,
-0.5225924849510193,
-1.0379412174224854,
0.36310702562332153,
-0.05397024005651474,
-0.38161584734916687,
0.7201739549636841,
0.7514362931251526,
0.889875590801239,
-0.09194577485322952,
0.8069279789924622,
-0.16503027081489563,
0.530327558517456,
-0.3639150857925415,
0.3208885192871094,
-0.49948474764823914,
-0.051692333072423935,
0.07998223602771759,
-0.6736632585525513,
0.14023125171661377,
0.08385954797267914,
-0.39618372917175293,
-0.41744646430015564,
0.9474390149116516,
0.9213998317718506,
0.07498611509799957,
-0.10244299471378326,
0.5617932081222534,
0.07842765748500824,
0.25338342785835266,
0.7809311151504517,
0.6460150480270386,
-0.3195193111896515,
0.4262740910053253,
-0.3859761953353882,
-0.12173083424568176,
-0.3976905643939972,
-0.7308316230773926,
-1.0308748483657837,
-0.4383206069469452,
-0.2630811333656311,
-0.2988013029098511,
0.0471179336309433,
0.6549180746078491,
0.46899229288101196,
-0.6726102828979492,
-0.3539871573448181,
0.027543220669031143,
0.019144415855407715,
-0.7480360865592957,
-0.2559393644332886,
0.13682110607624054,
-0.258576899766922,
-0.5121428966522217,
0.43698644638061523,
-0.06952735036611557,
0.007660178933292627,
-0.08769306540489197,
0.01961754821240902,
-0.15888506174087524,
0.2486630231142044,
0.4660128951072693,
0.3233232796192169,
-0.6761987805366516,
-0.24376598000526428,
0.22002385556697845,
-0.09722238779067993,
0.4770122766494751,
0.8325594663619995,
-0.7911137342453003,
0.406290203332901,
0.5408785939216614,
0.45917630195617676,
0.43757620453834534,
0.1467837691307068,
0.5855585336685181,
-0.6486302018165588,
0.17465327680110931,
-0.18596044182777405,
0.6289728879928589,
0.033496491611003876,
-0.5959455966949463,
0.6412510275840759,
0.48073792457580566,
-0.5448168516159058,
-0.9132636189460754,
0.29627346992492676,
-1.0202572345733643,
-0.1963270753622055,
1.3130699396133423,
-0.11967366933822632,
-0.34068745374679565,
-0.1969088315963745,
-0.2769209146499634,
0.1036243736743927,
-0.426187664270401,
0.7074208855628967,
1.063274621963501,
-0.3564687967300415,
-0.14044728875160217,
-1.14083993434906,
0.3167431354522705,
0.6880683898925781,
-0.49577632546424866,
0.08216150104999542,
0.22728870809078217,
0.642528235912323,
0.231179878115654,
0.6342325210571289,
0.2736525535583496,
0.6298390030860901,
0.1300259530544281,
0.18640822172164917,
-0.1629173755645752,
0.16988898813724518,
-0.10908954590559006,
0.23188699781894684,
0.05755233392119408,
-0.3554552495479584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11632v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11632v1 | Unveiling the Power of Source: Source-based Minimum Bayes Risk Decoding for Neural Machine Translation | 2024-06-17T15:13:52 | 2024-06-17T15:13:52 | Boxuan Lyu, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Kotaro Funakoshi, Manabu Okumura | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Maximum a posteriori decoding, a commonly used method for neural machine
translation (NMT), aims to maximize the estimated posterior probability.
However, high estimated probability does not always lead to high translation
quality. Minimum Bayes Risk (MBR) decoding offers an alternative by seeking
hypotheses with the highest expected utility.
In this work, we show that Quality Estimation (QE) reranking, which uses a QE
model as a reranker, can be viewed as a variant of MBR. Inspired by this, we
propose source-based MBR (sMBR) decoding, a novel approach that utilizes
synthetic sources generated by backward translation as ``support hypotheses''
and a reference-free quality estimation metric as the utility function, marking
the first work to solely use sources in MBR decoding. Experiments show that
sMBR significantly outperforms QE reranking and is competitive with standard
MBR decoding. Furthermore, sMBR calls the utility function fewer times compared
to MBR. Our findings suggest that sMBR is a promising approach for high-quality
NMT decoding. | [
0.04756565019488335,
-0.12117275595664978,
0.5434347987174988,
0.14909183979034424,
-0.5427629351615906,
0.15366289019584656,
0.08813679963350296,
0.08556518703699112,
0.11578702181577682,
0.576033353805542,
-0.48427799344062805,
-0.42503413558006287,
-0.8890365362167358,
0.0527513325214386,
-0.22402672469615936,
0.9594021439552307,
0.22989852726459503,
0.2994706630706787,
0.01384682022035122,
0.04488791525363922,
-0.46242767572402954,
-0.656199038028717,
-0.7158787250518799,
-0.05879586189985275,
0.7989003658294678,
0.245626300573349,
0.930287778377533,
0.7919701933860779,
0.8047161102294922,
0.24088510870933533,
-0.06438330560922623,
0.0232686884701252,
-0.428223192691803,
0.06941688805818558,
-0.3000285029411316,
-0.5747154355049133,
-0.23236986994743347,
0.10170333087444305,
0.8065766096115112,
0.5373126864433289,
-0.2720036506652832,
0.3165639340877533,
-0.006611005403101444,
0.8661528825759888,
-0.8269822001457214,
0.1948424130678177,
-0.7900382876396179,
0.014370148070156574,
0.039492323994636536,
-0.5085427761077881,
-0.8993241786956787,
-0.48382923007011414,
-0.20673926174640656,
-0.06900312006473541,
0.2221614420413971,
0.01628873124718666,
0.7209733724594116,
0.4151589572429657,
-0.6843034625053406,
0.2592378556728363,
-0.4586203098297119,
0.7794135808944702,
-0.642426609992981,
0.5676429867744446,
0.25091564655303955,
0.6674530506134033,
-0.25292545557022095,
-0.5010094046592712,
-0.38581904768943787,
-0.051979899406433105,
-0.07649719715118408,
-0.04729088023304939,
-0.6125802397727966,
-0.05375275760889053,
0.10256565362215042,
0.2599904537200928,
-0.3139018714427948,
-0.2569133937358856,
-0.4587979018688202,
-0.360109806060791,
0.6928370594978333,
-0.1435534507036209,
0.13204802572727203,
-0.5306134819984436,
-0.07417751103639603,
-0.36744755506515503,
-0.8821859359741211,
0.04352008178830147,
0.1983269602060318,
0.1810455322265625,
0.4311354458332062,
0.7090039253234863,
0.039787374436855316,
0.5945407152175903,
-0.07801415771245956,
-0.09990282356739044,
0.17634107172489166,
-0.2609081566333771,
-0.31815212965011597,
0.11521553248167038,
0.8873823881149292,
0.47203028202056885,
-0.14276748895645142,
-0.46160757541656494,
-0.138096421957016,
-0.45729491114616394,
0.47716522216796875,
-0.7107783555984497,
-0.1976211667060852,
-0.13440124690532684,
-0.7558859586715698,
-0.37391260266304016,
-0.04436112940311432,
-0.6539402604103088,
-0.15529529750347137,
-0.07219664007425308,
0.8316938281059265,
-0.5250256657600403,
-0.19960243999958038,
-0.11737232655286789,
-0.36141887307167053,
0.3249661326408386,
-0.21114403009414673,
-0.6922912001609802,
0.00021515117259696126,
0.3581061065196991,
1.1242436170578003,
0.043978288769721985,
-0.018290262669324875,
-0.6991714239120483,
0.16021156311035156,
-0.4574018716812134,
0.6645912528038025,
0.0638238787651062,
-0.501990556716919,
-0.23559455573558807,
0.053236301988363266,
0.09518740326166153,
-0.3483792543411255,
0.7073901891708374,
-0.6507355570793152,
-0.2122468799352646,
-0.46036526560783386,
-0.275147408246994,
-0.19755800068378448,
-0.3075571060180664,
-0.6946109533309937,
0.3779236376285553,
0.3518598973751068,
-0.6873752474784851,
0.33920687437057495,
-0.3792235553264618,
-0.5604473948478699,
-0.2403765469789505,
0.026534471660852432,
-0.3586295247077942,
0.5927846431732178,
0.3982057571411133,
0.4830845296382904,
-0.10579860955476761,
0.42153292894363403,
-0.10543479025363922,
-0.18127761781215668,
0.4764302670955658,
-0.916049599647522,
0.7682397365570068,
0.4694463610649109,
-0.1588997095823288,
0.0031994441524147987,
-0.8294535875320435,
0.06705344468355179,
0.27770528197288513,
-0.23225031793117523,
-0.36641260981559753,
0.354404091835022,
-0.24583908915519714,
0.25815632939338684,
-0.030767537653446198,
-0.7336441278457642,
-0.03274722024798393,
-0.4567906856536865,
0.7340390682220459,
0.8741478323936462,
0.19890452921390533,
0.48328956961631775,
-0.31485438346862793,
0.2846730947494507,
0.03583525866270065,
0.07412309944629669,
0.01635405421257019,
-0.5511398911476135,
-0.36853867769241333,
-0.22408831119537354,
0.5090318918228149,
0.5053564310073853,
-0.982373833656311,
0.3075591027736664,
-0.5626729130744934,
-0.5122737884521484,
-1.1056933403015137,
-0.10876316577196121,
0.4432576298713684,
0.5026403665542603,
0.5397327542304993,
-0.026356225833296776,
-0.4102582633495331,
-1.211754560470581,
-0.4913696050643921,
-0.08672090619802475,
-0.17510728538036346,
-0.09914384037256241,
-0.07272364944219589,
-0.026731764897704124,
0.8802242875099182,
-0.4677315354347229,
-0.08988621085882187,
-0.4066224694252014,
-0.008906745351850986,
0.6003193855285645,
0.7647837996482849,
0.2953139543533325,
-0.6996912360191345,
-0.33830952644348145,
-0.2784336507320404,
-0.4847295880317688,
-0.010556742548942566,
-0.25579822063446045,
-0.6441947817802429,
0.16427411139011383,
0.4131876826286316,
-0.3865371346473694,
0.21350929141044617,
0.8968835473060608,
-0.14351786673069,
0.19484230875968933,
-0.29069703817367554,
0.23814627528190613,
-1.3115174770355225,
0.19479213654994965,
-0.05813508480787277,
-0.1249169409275055,
-0.4542040228843689,
0.27481555938720703,
0.2767845392227173,
-0.17275162041187286,
-0.37738505005836487,
0.08308950811624527,
-0.4728996753692627,
0.024790698662400246,
-0.4397387206554413,
-0.2931494414806366,
-0.016010576859116554,
0.2514563798904419,
0.08558713644742966,
0.8587695956230164,
0.12316499650478363,
-0.4227800667285919,
-0.0424068383872509,
0.20680221915245056,
-0.28227606415748596,
0.2905639410018921,
-0.70235276222229,
0.08794189989566803,
-0.2230038344860077,
-0.0036710998974740505,
-0.9040855169296265,
0.16635702550411224,
0.22083859145641327,
-0.7212843894958496,
0.5491414666175842,
-0.48409292101860046,
-0.49792274832725525,
-0.18638187646865845,
-0.08388988673686981,
0.28000637888908386,
0.7694151401519775,
-0.6702146530151367,
0.4346812963485718,
0.4254671037197113,
-0.2718052566051483,
-0.7270539402961731,
-1.0412517786026,
0.2384994924068451,
0.23562708497047424,
-0.66062992811203,
0.44779616594314575,
-0.13033846020698547,
0.22893039882183075,
0.12458038330078125,
-0.5238140821456909,
-0.29812487959861755,
-0.11939715594053268,
0.2903425395488739,
0.30061203241348267,
-0.374962717294693,
-0.24631524085998535,
0.6831487417221069,
-0.496058851480484,
0.2510327398777008,
-0.45505374670028687,
0.02271968126296997,
0.17597846686840057,
-0.33070752024650574,
-0.1749839186668396,
0.594909131526947,
0.455515593290329,
-0.13436472415924072,
1.0340116024017334,
0.516725480556488,
-0.26880785822868347,
0.012651056051254272,
-0.5580040812492371,
-0.12742096185684204,
-0.537082314491272,
0.1515985131263733,
-0.4940348267555237,
-0.7771256566047668,
0.16912753880023956,
0.1520010083913803,
-0.11799323558807373,
0.5589516758918762,
0.2691735327243805,
-0.15434357523918152,
1.3361808061599731,
0.7220499515533447,
-0.18934805691242218,
0.39950031042099,
-0.32972174882888794,
0.39112943410873413,
-0.7457392811775208,
-0.38220569491386414,
-0.42763715982437134,
-0.42134541273117065,
-0.8361198902130127,
-0.3904441297054291,
0.5342913269996643,
0.06922464817762375,
-0.0727061778306961,
0.5916714072227478,
-0.6014581918716431,
0.6741710305213928,
1.0755977630615234,
0.39956608414649963,
0.4176965355873108,
0.27379947900772095,
-0.15377627313137054,
-0.2407158464193344,
-0.9862287044525146,
-0.2704264521598816,
1.2111661434173584,
0.36815428733825684,
0.49131760001182556,
0.34239625930786133,
0.7991781234741211,
0.1414966583251953,
0.5179727673530579,
-0.7959828972816467,
0.4486207067966461,
-0.08777584880590439,
-0.6920545101165771,
-0.22193323075771332,
-0.9699982404708862,
-0.933674156665802,
0.4899854063987732,
-0.1912989467382431,
-0.28667375445365906,
0.5447271466255188,
0.12131988257169724,
-0.31497472524642944,
0.37277600169181824,
-0.4994889795780182,
0.9065212607383728,
0.11646517366170883,
-0.1050059050321579,
-0.15477126836776733,
-0.7208788990974426,
0.48359349370002747,
0.15843062102794647,
0.23370806872844696,
0.15540750324726105,
0.0016623547999188304,
0.5328246355056763,
-0.2756471633911133,
0.33766087889671326,
-0.17904944717884064,
0.00459651043638587,
0.19741079211235046,
0.4621239900588989,
0.46387240290641785,
0.294822096824646,
-0.16338753700256348,
0.459568053483963,
0.23877212405204773,
-0.6849460601806641,
-0.5462256073951721,
0.5394484400749207,
-0.6427009105682373,
-0.5577390193939209,
-0.6969773769378662,
-0.300071120262146,
-0.1869770586490631,
0.3660915791988373,
0.6746622920036316,
0.05154512822628021,
-0.07149877399206161,
0.43987423181533813,
0.6155396103858948,
-0.19867242872714996,
0.3600313067436218,
0.6158734560012817,
0.26282548904418945,
-0.8477440476417542,
1.2856206893920898,
-0.07344499230384827,
0.2503281235694885,
0.7816154360771179,
0.21679870784282684,
-0.3865385949611664,
-0.9278165698051453,
-0.4379394054412842,
0.2496607005596161,
-0.6400914788246155,
-0.6165682673454285,
-0.5557148456573486,
-0.5677290558815002,
-0.33130818605422974,
-0.207854762673378,
-0.5200838446617126,
-0.16413958370685577,
0.026330402120947838,
-0.27147650718688965,
-0.11336428672075272,
0.16020245850086212,
-0.5445100665092468,
0.49441006779670715,
-1.324165940284729,
0.31739357113838196,
0.14542068541049957,
0.27414971590042114,
-0.3798947334289551,
-0.5372370481491089,
-0.3901787996292114,
0.15617156028747559,
-0.3364228308200836,
-1.2841802835464478,
0.8926489949226379,
-0.09349194169044495,
0.8234092593193054,
0.06677868962287903,
0.05676233023405075,
0.2327929139137268,
-0.8827430009841919,
0.5190927386283875,
0.3032073378562927,
-0.9875667095184326,
0.5904202461242676,
-0.04719626158475876,
-0.049665242433547974,
0.6303505301475525,
0.48751315474510193,
-0.4953097701072693,
-0.19020645320415497,
-0.6099124550819397,
-0.7277583479881287,
0.44476306438446045,
0.3186182677745819,
0.10823357105255127,
-0.20709656178951263,
0.2807367146015167,
-0.0064713251776993275,
0.3195420801639557,
-0.6384481191635132,
-0.11720382422208786,
-0.44450870156288147,
-0.23164762556552887,
-0.5695411562919617,
-0.2534030079841614,
0.14672285318374634,
-0.19010841846466064,
0.6280099153518677,
0.031460270285606384,
0.5962037444114685,
0.4255826771259308,
-0.2901674807071686,
-0.339174747467041,
0.35289350152015686,
0.26313352584838867,
0.10328518599271774,
-0.6016288995742798,
0.19221745431423187,
-0.15432722866535187,
-0.35596898198127747,
0.41611942648887634,
-0.03599106892943382,
-0.40235957503318787,
0.3672660291194916,
0.13480380177497864,
0.5886261463165283,
0.35113006830215454,
-0.4612184166908264,
0.6005080938339233,
0.09971250593662262,
-0.10245434194803238,
0.12394599616527557,
-0.08882726728916168,
-0.04325570911169052,
0.25408852100372314,
0.42031770944595337,
0.41895759105682373,
0.39736422896385193,
-0.37730634212493896,
0.34825021028518677,
0.31929367780685425,
-0.27375560998916626,
-0.21198956668376923,
0.5890264511108398,
-0.028078366070985794,
-0.06396770477294922,
0.6943526864051819,
-0.23097649216651917,
-0.06667084246873856,
0.3120209872722626,
0.6663400530815125,
0.9026350975036621,
-0.3821110427379608,
0.2965681254863739,
0.5371561646461487,
0.787443995475769,
-0.11414087563753128,
0.33519765734672546,
0.30559226870536804,
-0.4810158908367157,
-0.8878294229507446,
-0.6171539425849915,
-0.3642435371875763,
-0.07689876854419708,
-0.809487521648407,
-0.16005869209766388,
-0.35269659757614136,
-0.27145737409591675,
-0.15111905336380005,
-0.3181532323360443,
-0.3475213944911957,
-0.003192722797393799,
-0.18444034457206726,
0.9586705565452576,
-0.44715550541877747,
0.9045203924179077,
0.21990329027175903,
-0.5489944815635681,
-0.6441500186920166,
0.0021243090741336346,
-0.037701889872550964,
-0.6686311364173889,
0.6825435161590576,
-0.22454197704792023,
-0.03926977887749672,
0.39749202132225037,
-0.49750816822052,
-1.22687566280365,
1.2036774158477783,
0.8469932675361633,
-0.4118327498435974,
-0.14204521477222443,
-0.15021681785583496,
0.11983808875083923,
-0.08469194918870926,
-0.18627946078777313,
0.3459430932998657,
0.2958507835865021,
-0.0031982397194951773,
-0.4540354907512665,
0.2782110571861267,
-0.19423748552799225,
0.31724119186401367,
0.2965329587459564,
-0.32132846117019653,
0.5334831476211548,
-0.4212368428707123,
-0.3943578004837036,
-0.09063248336315155,
0.7256911993026733,
0.0642273873090744,
0.3996220827102661,
-0.09605124592781067,
0.14415989816188812,
0.23519518971443176,
0.03869754448533058,
1.1955766677856445,
-0.21208669245243073,
0.10200440883636475,
0.8850794434547424,
0.4909626245498657,
1.3167272806167603,
0.5646364092826843,
-0.20945890247821808,
0.36435067653656006,
0.4772849678993225,
0.0012075145496055484,
1.0124485492706299,
0.3029458522796631,
0.06399492919445038,
-0.10424276441335678,
0.23862774670124054,
-0.3965332806110382,
0.0978379175066948,
0.135116845369339,
-0.7845180630683899,
-0.15736642479896545,
-0.0879245176911354,
-0.2851330041885376,
0.033439651131629944,
-0.29181045293807983,
0.651727557182312,
0.34051039814949036,
-0.43213826417922974,
0.661943793296814,
0.30122071504592896,
0.5656265616416931,
-0.5026335716247559,
0.05872417986392975,
-0.2939840257167816,
-0.000044131840695627034,
0.08711075782775879,
-0.6241799592971802,
0.6420149803161621,
-0.2652356028556824,
-0.38494229316711426,
-0.2536507546901703,
0.5707727074623108,
-0.2990185618400574,
-0.5569498538970947,
-0.006092170253396034,
0.5729132294654846,
0.1319558471441269,
-0.6007768511772156,
-0.4426208734512329,
-0.22980758547782898,
-0.1485830843448639,
-0.13560092449188232,
0.6244763731956482,
0.41314050555229187,
0.49136844277381897,
0.6583255529403687,
1.0495446920394897,
0.1642436683177948,
0.23241056501865387,
-0.3762551248073578,
0.5470420122146606,
-0.867199718952179,
-0.36197343468666077,
-0.9149745106697083,
0.3982730209827423,
0.05405116826295853,
0.027934055775403976,
0.6307427883148193,
0.34743621945381165,
0.7313799262046814,
-0.3987436294555664,
0.6755170226097107,
0.33597704768180847,
0.15176010131835938,
-0.6653428673744202,
0.9941340684890747,
-0.3294402062892914,
-0.09177137166261673,
-0.11919257044792175,
-0.8957335948944092,
-0.32741379737854004,
0.7770161628723145,
0.05560321360826492,
-0.42794305086135864,
0.8569852113723755,
0.6991339325904846,
-0.0568697564303875,
-0.12803326547145844,
0.6269881129264832,
0.09998241066932678,
0.19934752583503723,
0.7758803963661194,
0.47139772772789,
-0.6300540566444397,
0.809235692024231,
-0.31104159355163574,
-0.3037959337234497,
-0.27766478061676025,
-1.070382833480835,
-0.5246454477310181,
-0.48878103494644165,
-0.1480555385351181,
-0.6148444414138794,
0.15197071433067322,
0.8724294304847717,
0.6027426719665527,
-0.8371036052703857,
0.00010318667045794427,
-0.10572463274002075,
0.2579054832458496,
-0.655097246170044,
-0.12059023976325989,
0.2814086377620697,
-0.374277800321579,
-0.4403351843357086,
0.7887913584709167,
0.20397931337356567,
0.024309251457452774,
0.03050221875309944,
-0.1402270644903183,
0.08027692139148712,
0.24856822192668915,
0.7556852698326111,
0.1277952790260315,
-0.4398238956928253,
-0.035559654235839844,
0.13121147453784943,
-0.25985515117645264,
0.005755117628723383,
0.9141735434532166,
-0.4538669288158417,
0.0933442935347557,
0.6760280728340149,
1.0353370904922485,
0.3162335455417633,
-0.29848405718803406,
0.7781498432159424,
-0.6125150918960571,
-0.27853092551231384,
0.2786340117454529,
0.44312524795532227,
0.03362388163805008,
-0.4799077808856964,
0.47233691811561584,
0.41470593214035034,
-0.5100924372673035,
-0.8560300469398499,
0.23050141334533691,
-1.1461745500564575,
-0.391440749168396,
0.9528983235359192,
-0.20228701829910278,
-0.3393458127975464,
0.33752474188804626,
-0.21678052842617035,
0.46000126004219055,
-0.5059276223182678,
0.6415048241615295,
0.5037638545036316,
0.21604400873184204,
-0.30717933177948,
-0.7275184988975525,
0.3167293965816498,
0.3341958522796631,
-0.2634256184101105,
-0.14965489506721497,
0.4939986765384674,
0.4180045425891876,
0.17346034944057465,
0.5209792256355286,
-0.29739758372306824,
0.23491311073303223,
0.21238185465335846,
-0.07824882864952087,
-0.4114840030670166,
-0.3456510305404663,
-0.5167158842086792,
0.40821871161460876,
0.0880526602268219,
-0.28894492983818054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11629v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11629v3 | Can Many-Shot In-Context Learning Help Long-Context LLM Judges? See More, Judge Better! | 2024-06-17T15:11:58 | 2024-06-30T13:31:24 | Mingyang Song, Mao Zheng, Xuan Luo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Leveraging Large Language Models (LLMs) as judges for judging the performance
of LLMs has recently garnered attention. However, this type of approach is
affected by the potential biases in LLMs, raising concerns about the
reliability of the evaluation results. To mitigate this issue, we propose and
study two versions of many-shot in-context prompts, which rely on two existing
settings of many-shot ICL for helping GPT-4o-as-a-Judge in single answer
grading to mitigate the potential biases in LLMs, Reinforced ICL and
Unsupervised ICL. Concretely, the former utilizes in-context examples with
model-generated rationales, and the latter without. Based on the designed
prompts, we investigate the impact of scaling the number of in-context examples
on the consistency and quality of the judgment results. Furthermore, we reveal
the symbol bias hidden in the pairwise comparison of GPT-4o-as-a-Judge and
propose a simple yet effective approach to mitigate it. Experimental results
show that advanced long-context LLMs, such as GPT-4o, perform better in the
many-shot regime than in the zero-shot regime. Meanwhile, the experimental
results further verify the effectiveness of the symbol bias mitigation
approach. | [
-0.43349459767341614,
-0.5147018432617188,
0.9025987982749939,
0.27080219984054565,
-0.4459921717643738,
-0.1979372203350067,
-0.4177386462688446,
-0.4866035580635071,
-0.280480295419693,
0.29798996448516846,
-0.253587543964386,
-0.45419710874557495,
-0.6544125080108643,
0.2194494605064392,
0.05087793990969658,
1.2470612525939941,
-0.16896383464336395,
0.49301356077194214,
-0.20470114052295685,
-0.3829636573791504,
-0.673365592956543,
-0.5883704423904419,
-0.8289911150932312,
-0.5175800919532776,
0.5073531866073608,
0.4327237010002136,
0.3315260112285614,
0.09209133684635162,
0.41052326560020447,
0.191033273935318,
-0.23881438374519348,
0.03751756623387337,
-0.297100305557251,
0.11531934887170792,
-0.09990992397069931,
-0.4273102283477783,
-0.39975544810295105,
0.20767764747142792,
0.7821359634399414,
0.43337854743003845,
0.031712718307971954,
-0.06027495115995407,
0.3241975009441376,
0.5621841549873352,
-0.6889887452125549,
0.23257854580879211,
-0.4344249963760376,
0.09585870057344437,
-0.11708569526672363,
-0.15703481435775757,
-0.7457484602928162,
-0.2108001410961151,
0.011932812631130219,
-0.6460877060890198,
-0.23748600482940674,
0.0657125785946846,
0.4276191294193268,
0.17386463284492493,
-0.9024034142494202,
-0.20691148936748505,
-0.43612420558929443,
0.9848239421844482,
-0.8445510864257812,
-0.06834662705659866,
0.4002910256385803,
0.7409356236457825,
-0.13030561804771423,
-0.3905501961708069,
-0.3642105162143707,
-0.30248236656188965,
-0.06589411199092865,
0.31687721610069275,
0.16387058794498444,
0.19670222699642181,
0.6235020160675049,
-0.1625485122203827,
-0.31221306324005127,
0.4008369743824005,
-0.01503799855709076,
-0.3379914462566376,
0.30457714200019836,
0.020855775102972984,
-0.1925063580274582,
-0.1762848198413849,
-0.4905148148536682,
-0.07332981377840042,
-1.1767076253890991,
0.2919253706932068,
0.31684446334838867,
0.34004661440849304,
-0.0899709165096283,
0.24832454323768616,
-0.2319093942642212,
0.7370678186416626,
0.11484667658805847,
-0.37390896677970886,
0.13502410054206848,
-0.251143217086792,
-0.13856719434261322,
0.07458467781543732,
0.5920771360397339,
0.8438405990600586,
0.4454815983772278,
0.06715463846921921,
-0.2318085879087448,
-0.1708332598209381,
-0.08307842910289764,
-0.925390899181366,
0.24513161182403564,
-0.06018613651394844,
-0.2963382303714752,
-0.07891184091567993,
0.13764306902885437,
-0.7782418131828308,
-0.32396814227104187,
-0.46388956904411316,
0.6247871518135071,
-0.16483889520168304,
0.21141809225082397,
-0.0772625207901001,
-0.23499859869480133,
0.33033499121665955,
0.7194169163703918,
-0.6009231805801392,
0.10237078368663788,
0.5681279897689819,
0.670565128326416,
-0.12402314692735672,
-0.38257402181625366,
-1.0319279432296753,
0.14172764122486115,
-0.2968232333660126,
0.7505990862846375,
-0.6672850847244263,
-0.275929719209671,
0.11153432726860046,
-0.3386567234992981,
0.29575303196907043,
-0.6062393188476562,
0.5926660895347595,
-0.4677197337150574,
0.19898077845573425,
-0.5961164236068726,
-0.5077970027923584,
0.09682130813598633,
0.611458957195282,
-0.4540809094905853,
0.7592475414276123,
0.06380239874124527,
-0.6238951086997986,
1.0463730096817017,
-0.5230758786201477,
-0.3613460958003998,
-0.1101485937833786,
-0.546183705329895,
-0.47543561458587646,
0.018611418083310127,
0.5890567302703857,
0.37317851185798645,
-0.19269202649593353,
0.23557986319065094,
-0.49808043241500854,
-0.7228460907936096,
0.10087937861680984,
-0.6852315068244934,
0.44145601987838745,
0.13380971550941467,
-0.4613769054412842,
0.1920565962791443,
-0.5374912023544312,
0.00740817142650485,
-0.28255346417427063,
-0.5344890356063843,
-0.22836413979530334,
-0.20285606384277344,
-0.03485511243343353,
0.5555624961853027,
-0.43477335572242737,
-0.5867753624916077,
0.25546005368232727,
-0.31572023034095764,
0.34104400873184204,
1.0600663423538208,
0.029977142810821533,
0.42094171047210693,
-0.3357295095920563,
0.5266132950782776,
0.22721213102340698,
0.0910915657877922,
-0.5297287106513977,
-0.40343356132507324,
-0.5414111614227295,
-0.537876307964325,
0.0045797210186719894,
0.0575961098074913,
-0.910464346408844,
0.13518157601356506,
-0.10751798748970032,
-0.05062868073582649,
-0.17924244701862335,
0.21177265048027039,
0.6328198313713074,
0.6867758631706238,
0.4416058659553528,
-0.20976392924785614,
-0.11056467145681381,
-0.6948645710945129,
-0.5410221815109253,
-0.03110566735267639,
-0.13532018661499023,
0.4871208071708679,
0.4824872612953186,
0.24208423495292664,
1.0518122911453247,
-0.15022261440753937,
-0.22702081501483917,
-0.0945630744099617,
0.05020171031355858,
0.2597303092479706,
0.248588427901268,
0.7517454624176025,
-0.3600049614906311,
-0.5251011252403259,
-0.29742521047592163,
-0.8398650288581848,
-0.2149660289287567,
-0.0962129458785057,
-0.052707333117723465,
0.0794992446899414,
0.5376013517379761,
-0.5721875429153442,
0.38922587037086487,
0.1450151801109314,
-0.4576371908187866,
0.7152965664863586,
-0.016880741342902184,
0.3158249855041504,
-0.8483105897903442,
-0.2129971981048584,
0.23547740280628204,
-0.4180859327316284,
-0.3444908559322357,
0.16902151703834534,
0.28547266125679016,
0.1820966601371765,
-0.8790197968482971,
0.8254120945930481,
-0.30786752700805664,
-0.0888153538107872,
-0.4302927255630493,
0.13340075314044952,
0.17747263610363007,
0.3867260217666626,
-0.12589745223522186,
0.7687931656837463,
0.6453816294670105,
-0.6944995522499084,
0.21242548525333405,
-0.05004466325044632,
-0.49226391315460205,
1.1583532094955444,
-0.39572644233703613,
0.1358490139245987,
-0.24127331376075745,
0.9642031192779541,
-0.769615888595581,
-0.045562200248241425,
0.14623789489269257,
-0.08121652901172638,
0.6124740242958069,
-0.5193277597427368,
-0.5103564262390137,
-0.31668734550476074,
-0.6962940096855164,
0.636139988899231,
0.05706622079014778,
-1.060420036315918,
0.1876138597726822,
-0.25178343057632446,
0.07913471758365631,
-0.827593982219696,
-0.5875832438468933,
0.16100208461284637,
-0.5669949650764465,
-0.3701857626438141,
0.13684678077697754,
-0.37172195315361023,
-0.41715672612190247,
-0.5748022794723511,
-0.14093546569347382,
0.291259229183197,
0.09892486035823822,
0.1507236212491989,
0.19755828380584717,
-0.11746331304311752,
0.46087023615837097,
0.011457710526883602,
-0.1704995036125183,
0.09691940993070602,
-0.2009885311126709,
0.24753756821155548,
-0.22562505304813385,
-0.7309092283248901,
-0.32720381021499634,
0.328217089176178,
0.702760636806488,
-0.03338906913995743,
0.41660863161087036,
0.16381308436393738,
-0.1210826188325882,
-0.3111813962459564,
-0.6202071309089661,
-0.3048040270805359,
-0.46165645122528076,
0.2125563621520996,
-0.5013678669929504,
-1.05912446975708,
0.2532055377960205,
-0.20736390352249146,
0.19157153367996216,
0.31565719842910767,
0.6699912548065186,
-0.19013169407844543,
0.8227173686027527,
0.28401079773902893,
-0.3541254997253418,
0.6355618238449097,
-0.08732114732265472,
0.1102229654788971,
-1.128047227859497,
0.06321875751018524,
-0.3034430742263794,
-0.42193540930747986,
-0.34791672229766846,
-0.28675973415374756,
0.6613906621932983,
0.18794198334217072,
-0.5788323879241943,
-0.23826654255390167,
-0.1700112670660019,
0.7631415724754333,
0.43242913484573364,
0.19307540357112885,
0.35246527194976807,
-0.020800944417715073,
-0.4634152352809906,
0.19294844567775726,
-0.45807355642318726,
-0.6163824200630188,
1.3457245826721191,
0.3594664931297302,
0.7187728881835938,
0.18456892669200897,
0.7013570070266724,
-0.05017339810729027,
0.6297333240509033,
-0.8717219233512878,
0.26714643836021423,
0.26510554552078247,
-0.596539318561554,
-0.31575605273246765,
-0.3174404799938202,
-0.5720932483673096,
0.5928579568862915,
0.0039976914413273335,
-0.6399272084236145,
-0.10000024735927582,
0.1467507928609848,
-0.48359742760658264,
0.14635638892650604,
-0.7155536413192749,
0.710891604423523,
-0.2616667151451111,
-0.6512760519981384,
-0.06437403708696365,
-0.6970639228820801,
0.2913043797016144,
-0.20943735539913177,
0.33439916372299194,
-0.06315947324037552,
0.2164052575826645,
0.4465557932853699,
-0.4142894446849823,
1.0214887857437134,
-0.36905327439308167,
-0.0005747218965552747,
0.44382771849632263,
-0.13323074579238892,
0.583812415599823,
0.3999555706977844,
-0.4117668569087982,
-0.05120963975787163,
-0.24971111118793488,
-0.39675527811050415,
-0.5675771236419678,
0.830930769443512,
-0.6086292862892151,
-0.5855919718742371,
-0.4622461497783661,
-0.37177085876464844,
-0.41886186599731445,
-0.052312690764665604,
0.35934606194496155,
0.53800368309021,
0.026053033769130707,
0.20272080600261688,
0.2648673355579376,
-0.15361502766609192,
0.7947522401809692,
0.6042773723602295,
0.019862111657857895,
-0.1817864179611206,
0.24320724606513977,
0.010446706786751747,
0.4162767827510834,
0.2071343958377838,
0.36217761039733887,
-0.20626339316368103,
-0.459855318069458,
-0.6571675539016724,
0.16747650504112244,
-1.135469675064087,
-0.5140405893325806,
-0.08045545965433121,
0.22787868976593018,
-0.22207078337669373,
-0.28028494119644165,
-0.07078250497579575,
-0.21371237933635712,
-0.2040099948644638,
-0.36781200766563416,
0.2965411841869354,
0.5587366223335266,
0.2556512951850891,
0.4279502034187317,
-0.4635618031024933,
0.029652876779437065,
0.4369211494922638,
0.5921507477760315,
0.07158400118350983,
-0.886089026927948,
-0.1415381282567978,
-0.14917400479316711,
-0.411620557308197,
-0.532673180103302,
0.03626803681254387,
0.22031059861183167,
0.6188366413116455,
0.5566763877868652,
-0.09039086103439331,
0.8295325636863708,
-0.6998167037963867,
0.8728582859039307,
0.35889047384262085,
-0.776948094367981,
0.6672889590263367,
-0.29790347814559937,
0.5835248231887817,
0.668025016784668,
0.14714470505714417,
-0.46204903721809387,
-0.5612492561340332,
-0.07452651113271713,
-0.6599739193916321,
0.8940601944923401,
-0.19805195927619934,
0.24997034668922424,
-0.2827818989753723,
0.57463139295578,
0.16266308724880219,
0.15214386582374573,
-1.0089609622955322,
-0.010922123678028584,
-0.17762728035449982,
0.042453065514564514,
-0.14014896750450134,
-0.35009413957595825,
-0.2859114408493042,
-0.21158148348331451,
0.4264620244503021,
-0.5174961090087891,
-0.1970651000738144,
0.20634084939956665,
-0.3148682117462158,
-0.045037757605314255,
0.6520251631736755,
0.5950024724006653,
0.7748495936393738,
-0.07984030246734619,
0.3433559834957123,
0.39910975098609924,
0.02616940625011921,
0.07935711741447449,
-0.35585442185401917,
-0.14323550462722778,
-0.30177217721939087,
0.5800943970680237,
0.7979311347007751,
0.35332193970680237,
-0.5916681885719299,
0.8250232338905334,
0.11765787750482559,
-0.14193284511566162,
-0.10833106935024261,
-0.23937775194644928,
-0.2099389135837555,
0.34584754705429077,
0.3295091688632965,
-0.14532867074012756,
0.10164017230272293,
-0.7586698532104492,
0.29320842027664185,
0.5214978456497192,
-0.4113679826259613,
-0.03836797550320625,
0.47418662905693054,
0.20277345180511475,
0.10646476596593857,
0.6585889458656311,
-0.3029506206512451,
-0.46207907795906067,
0.5552747249603271,
0.7798123359680176,
0.6159912347793579,
0.03220663592219353,
-0.11108018457889557,
0.34987175464630127,
-0.003979660104960203,
-0.31164878606796265,
-0.14958395063877106,
-0.20135219395160675,
-0.6608335375785828,
-0.44044169783592224,
-0.5818781852722168,
-0.4429718852043152,
-0.05469219386577606,
-0.4508090615272522,
0.4695650041103363,
-0.5638315677642822,
-0.32592305541038513,
-0.23891441524028778,
-0.1945398449897766,
-0.7025593519210815,
0.04513014480471611,
0.37645459175109863,
0.7166574597358704,
-0.9736521244049072,
0.8891682028770447,
0.483123242855072,
-0.4089337885379791,
-0.7417284250259399,
0.05434214696288109,
0.3525846302509308,
-0.545825719833374,
0.8747798800468445,
0.5755612850189209,
-0.22974789142608643,
-0.3934013843536377,
-0.48886838555336,
-0.5968402028083801,
1.1820909976959229,
0.44600534439086914,
-0.5802513360977173,
0.21953073143959045,
-0.18450286984443665,
0.5916462540626526,
-0.3414399027824402,
0.8944199681282043,
0.5470030307769775,
0.6232783794403076,
0.3018728494644165,
-1.1822421550750732,
-0.01107657328248024,
0.04943881556391716,
-0.18873830139636993,
0.0071234554052352905,
-0.6720917224884033,
0.5589320063591003,
-0.19750910997390747,
0.0917983204126358,
-0.26511436700820923,
0.35638365149497986,
0.5813531875610352,
0.572925865650177,
0.4645165503025055,
0.5070751905441284,
0.5516496300697327,
-0.05865701287984848,
1.1990045309066772,
0.0070205554366111755,
0.32020533084869385,
1.4436546564102173,
-0.5537487268447876,
0.6889707446098328,
0.7566971778869629,
-0.11661893874406815,
0.29345080256462097,
0.4496110677719116,
-0.007431019563227892,
0.35993096232414246,
0.3805321156978607,
-0.4906628131866455,
-0.2386762499809265,
-0.04711972549557686,
-0.11561020463705063,
0.3821881413459778,
0.09314585477113724,
-0.27280837297439575,
-0.5394195318222046,
0.23478353023529053,
0.14571928977966309,
0.118354432284832,
-0.45400530099868774,
0.6579613089561462,
0.38385245203971863,
-0.8324169516563416,
0.3026749789714813,
0.0645093247294426,
1.0444141626358032,
-0.4540972113609314,
-0.1136043593287468,
-0.33739322423934937,
0.15764842927455902,
-0.21956214308738708,
-0.8277935981750488,
-0.0444648414850235,
0.11036903411149979,
-0.16657233238220215,
-0.27079150080680847,
0.36416253447532654,
-0.16992489993572235,
-0.3541742265224457,
0.4129113554954529,
0.31123512983322144,
0.2264997363090515,
-0.347534716129303,
-0.47903919219970703,
-0.15470334887504578,
-0.3080291152000427,
-0.30532217025756836,
0.6855266690254211,
0.4242815673351288,
-0.5064579248428345,
0.6552731394767761,
0.37657082080841064,
-0.059654898941516876,
0.060241468250751495,
0.615001380443573,
0.8966817259788513,
-0.5717871785163879,
-0.32938945293426514,
-1.159271001815796,
0.2691963315010071,
-0.1263199895620346,
-0.33761703968048096,
0.7378337383270264,
0.5989722013473511,
0.9343878626823425,
0.1343151479959488,
0.5696897506713867,
0.4548937678337097,
0.19883626699447632,
-0.7349591851234436,
0.5441460609436035,
-0.4077436029911041,
0.5149744749069214,
-0.31795522570610046,
-0.8398499488830566,
-0.6066197156906128,
0.5917304754257202,
-0.36525070667266846,
0.3891449272632599,
0.8418822288513184,
0.6209099292755127,
0.12395145744085312,
-0.40449073910713196,
0.5026478171348572,
-0.1626281440258026,
0.7496305704116821,
0.7320679426193237,
0.9268304705619812,
-0.2261839210987091,
0.5249013900756836,
0.0944065973162651,
-0.2772004306316376,
-0.3732069432735443,
-1.0063899755477905,
-1.0195709466934204,
0.05578150600194931,
-0.1923651397228241,
-0.1395404040813446,
-0.026538101956248283,
1.0393214225769043,
0.7345234751701355,
-0.702869713306427,
-0.13694454729557037,
0.2844208776950836,
0.21256853640079498,
-0.10314282774925232,
-0.1707472950220108,
0.3740004003047943,
-0.5878458619117737,
-0.6605547666549683,
0.5095341205596924,
0.47141730785369873,
-0.18610654771327972,
0.16396775841712952,
-0.24830178916454315,
0.15734253823757172,
-0.22580790519714355,
1.045428991317749,
-0.03707257658243179,
-0.965953528881073,
-0.6983274221420288,
-0.4014507830142975,
-0.1408633440732956,
0.4337903559207916,
0.7908901572227478,
-0.9355358481407166,
0.727457582950592,
0.18034221231937408,
0.32868558168411255,
0.5565709471702576,
0.06023912876844406,
0.520069420337677,
-0.9913074374198914,
0.12723448872566223,
0.29499849677085876,
0.6475153565406799,
0.19135858118534088,
-0.17011350393295288,
0.24703513085842133,
-0.007966315373778343,
-0.5007010102272034,
-0.47454634308815,
0.3428133726119995,
-1.0112297534942627,
-0.3784191608428955,
1.4834604263305664,
-0.24497506022453308,
0.2057209610939026,
0.021751826629042625,
-0.34034231305122375,
0.11262952536344528,
-0.5338905453681946,
0.7210351228713989,
1.1296467781066895,
-0.16224098205566406,
-0.15708474814891815,
-0.6201496720314026,
0.3242744505405426,
0.5160936117172241,
-0.7393218278884888,
0.0405229777097702,
0.7830682396888733,
0.4564213752746582,
-0.24548716843128204,
0.6574241518974304,
-0.393228679895401,
0.3330914080142975,
-0.5257358551025391,
-0.1359349638223648,
-0.004036203492432833,
-0.4160324037075043,
-0.8349039554595947,
0.009189710952341557,
0.48140382766723633,
0.1716083437204361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11624v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11624v1 | Words in Motion: Representation Engineering for Motion Forecasting | 2024-06-17T15:07:55 | 2024-06-17T15:07:55 | Omer Sahin Tas, Royden Wagner | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Motion forecasting transforms sequences of past movements and environment
context into future motion. Recent methods rely on learned representations,
resulting in hidden states that are difficult to interpret. In this work, we
use natural language to quantize motion features in a human-interpretable way,
and measure the degree to which they are embedded in hidden states. Our
experiments reveal that hidden states of motion sequences are arranged with
respect to our discrete sets of motion features. Following these insights, we
fit control vectors to motion features, which allow for controlling motion
forecasts at inference. Consequently, our method enables controlling
transformer-based motion forecasting models with textual inputs, providing a
unique interface to interact with and understand these models. Our
implementation is available at https://github.com/kit-mrt/future-motion | [
-0.1947692483663559,
-0.10252885520458221,
0.7402238249778748,
0.22729124128818512,
-0.31199216842651367,
0.37323084473609924,
0.41446083784103394,
-0.4719524085521698,
0.5097540616989136,
0.6090309619903564,
-0.9274898767471313,
-0.12014209479093552,
-0.7283944487571716,
-0.3116665184497833,
-0.8249883651733398,
0.5824943780899048,
-0.35134828090667725,
0.18507671356201172,
-0.1028149202466011,
-0.08964988589286804,
-0.8681378960609436,
-0.3924730122089386,
-0.026895130053162575,
-0.7713688015937805,
0.023022938519716263,
0.007246437482535839,
1.013453483581543,
0.6155781149864197,
0.4931550920009613,
0.3411068618297577,
-0.03726288676261902,
-0.08125200867652893,
-0.038397278636693954,
0.3051603138446808,
-0.15284258127212524,
-0.43104249238967896,
-0.18727876245975494,
0.09829006344079971,
0.5291760563850403,
0.4825379550457001,
-0.10432726889848709,
0.026533218100667,
0.030946124345064163,
0.5935864448547363,
-0.568975567817688,
0.5297992825508118,
-0.0949910581111908,
0.4696475863456726,
0.11836951225996017,
-0.14721490442752838,
-0.09058704972267151,
-0.45643091201782227,
0.0349651575088501,
-0.5438937544822693,
0.18470393121242523,
0.27658364176750183,
0.9006893038749695,
0.5784214735031128,
-0.23092027008533478,
-0.2699988782405853,
-1.075864315032959,
0.7693687081336975,
-0.3711800277233124,
0.8226847052574158,
0.37465915083885193,
0.6917479038238525,
-0.10181286931037903,
-0.8648464679718018,
-0.5503928661346436,
-0.11994914710521698,
-0.3832775056362152,
0.35737523436546326,
-0.06068591773509979,
0.00897115096449852,
0.3193071484565735,
0.20458807051181793,
-0.5760374069213867,
-0.25680890679359436,
-0.006025299429893494,
-0.31777170300483704,
0.7751903533935547,
0.4883233308792114,
0.0018552853725850582,
-0.10909689217805862,
-0.3874145746231079,
-0.41818493604660034,
-0.3269319236278534,
0.07478774338960648,
0.06168070808053017,
0.045675504952669144,
-0.3461590111255646,
0.762869119644165,
-0.029247991740703583,
0.2846015691757202,
0.10292816162109375,
0.027405137196183205,
0.1284162700176239,
0.2754916548728943,
-0.35943281650543213,
0.05248048156499863,
0.7168926000595093,
0.3142645061016083,
0.002078136196359992,
-0.27131855487823486,
-0.45332658290863037,
0.06580116599798203,
0.2617610991001129,
-0.511458158493042,
-0.22032250463962555,
-0.04532414302229881,
-0.2995670735836029,
-0.17723682522773743,
0.45198532938957214,
-1.0444355010986328,
-0.7865432500839233,
-0.6180999875068665,
0.5628801584243774,
-0.517623245716095,
-0.009275791235268116,
0.12743335962295532,
-0.5092991590499878,
0.3437560796737671,
0.054035067558288574,
-1.055355191230774,
0.3227379620075226,
0.7406324148178101,
0.7671955227851868,
0.18215566873550415,
-0.11595093458890915,
-0.15665163099765778,
0.3259446322917938,
-0.4502179026603699,
0.7278614044189453,
-0.8045997619628906,
-0.7656406164169312,
-0.04262286052107811,
0.15459054708480835,
0.04784448444843292,
-0.24494890868663788,
0.28196951746940613,
-0.5482995510101318,
0.434160053730011,
0.03297029435634613,
-0.461830735206604,
-0.5917482972145081,
-0.15942347049713135,
-0.6974210143089294,
0.9075040221214294,
0.0017195448745042086,
-0.4724963903427124,
0.4634913504123688,
-1.1264017820358276,
-0.5148796439170837,
0.024145089089870453,
-0.14189748466014862,
-0.29523780941963196,
0.35500311851501465,
0.3606218099594116,
0.5396988391876221,
0.23779290914535522,
0.2861062288284302,
0.1542985886335373,
-0.2691207528114319,
0.23764920234680176,
-0.6377227902412415,
0.08478831499814987,
0.2703849971294403,
-0.3308744430541992,
0.3828354775905609,
-0.7268832921981812,
-0.11983001977205276,
0.14660824835300446,
0.007848531939089298,
0.009349794127047062,
0.5567002892494202,
-0.2649378180503845,
0.02388349175453186,
0.22573046386241913,
-0.2551075518131256,
-0.0395830012857914,
-0.5646429657936096,
0.4889228045940399,
0.593535840511322,
-0.01877913810312748,
0.9356577396392822,
-0.19543704390525818,
1.0573642253875732,
0.004082717467099428,
0.15469282865524292,
-0.47729337215423584,
-0.6695151329040527,
-0.6595170497894287,
0.32171696424484253,
-0.035447701811790466,
0.7048760652542114,
-0.927509069442749,
0.1872299164533615,
-0.6111115217208862,
-0.4063049554824829,
-0.2133355736732483,
-0.48931702971458435,
0.04475259780883789,
0.17050430178642273,
0.47226083278656006,
0.17174772918224335,
-0.5708246827125549,
-0.3510858118534088,
-0.33955031633377075,
0.031172161921858788,
-0.481784850358963,
-0.19657650589942932,
0.41066399216651917,
-0.19536161422729492,
1.18052077293396,
-0.7780597805976868,
0.23401503264904022,
-0.21372851729393005,
0.540860652923584,
0.14639288187026978,
0.28915050625801086,
0.18335871398448944,
-1.0433346033096313,
-0.184247687458992,
-0.09737076610326767,
-0.5751196146011353,
0.24929505586624146,
-0.28750237822532654,
-0.05448063835501671,
-0.29564520716667175,
0.524850606918335,
-0.4463609457015991,
0.67147296667099,
0.7836183309555054,
-0.672208845615387,
0.2684130370616913,
-0.09768059104681015,
-0.11211556941270828,
-0.8905103802680969,
-0.252603143453598,
0.019787834957242012,
-0.3909192979335785,
-0.22251743078231812,
-0.1140415221452713,
0.17371834814548492,
-0.5498694777488708,
-0.4079034626483917,
0.48376551270484924,
-0.5021676421165466,
-0.15542277693748474,
-0.22373661398887634,
-0.0041450937278568745,
0.108866386115551,
0.2772437036037445,
0.15002022683620453,
0.8435449004173279,
0.31564435362815857,
-0.6857399940490723,
0.3379616141319275,
0.2390042245388031,
-0.3808130919933319,
0.15718020498752594,
-0.30800238251686096,
0.09444525837898254,
-0.28904053568840027,
-0.2345333695411682,
-0.4067098796367645,
-0.511654794216156,
0.27931082248687744,
-0.47701260447502136,
0.597383975982666,
0.002491701627150178,
-0.17495141923427582,
-0.6476069688796997,
0.0033412210177630186,
-0.2152712196111679,
0.6427419781684875,
-0.35213419795036316,
1.0386018753051758,
0.4444427192211151,
0.1724880039691925,
-0.33146047592163086,
-0.9446020722389221,
0.09419495612382889,
-0.29887649416923523,
-0.22584015130996704,
0.5654783844947815,
0.0017483748961240053,
-0.14904195070266724,
-0.0707937628030777,
-0.06195620074868202,
-0.08813493698835373,
0.020441554486751556,
0.7601419687271118,
0.10240252315998077,
-0.044008854776620865,
0.2041877657175064,
0.14640302956104279,
-0.3800831735134125,
0.19342799484729767,
-0.4015028774738312,
0.5452994704246521,
0.013250402174890041,
-0.47373726963996887,
-0.3435969650745392,
0.31623923778533936,
0.8676590323448181,
-0.2917560338973999,
0.46411648392677307,
0.5434601306915283,
-0.42978593707084656,
-0.036779120564460754,
0.07678669691085815,
-0.24576713144779205,
-0.5773794651031494,
0.38922175765037537,
-0.2188766449689865,
-0.7384417057037354,
0.369503378868103,
-0.2731664776802063,
-0.03427734225988388,
0.442048579454422,
0.22061656415462494,
-0.49029895663261414,
1.191684365272522,
1.194342851638794,
-0.02307864837348461,
0.6838354468345642,
-0.4101381301879883,
0.3423461318016052,
-0.7039082050323486,
-0.4319223463535309,
-0.26510345935821533,
-0.7256322503089905,
-0.6502473950386047,
-0.5016710758209229,
0.17360274493694305,
0.10491648316383362,
-0.47978201508522034,
0.7440904378890991,
-0.6547771692276001,
0.5330906510353088,
0.5291914343833923,
0.1105714961886406,
-0.08542884141206741,
-0.39534130692481995,
-0.1353602111339569,
-0.19921660423278809,
-0.46693772077560425,
-0.7090986371040344,
0.5662567019462585,
0.5105986595153809,
0.8721482753753662,
-0.18669010698795319,
0.44990065693855286,
0.17694135010242462,
0.3526320159435272,
-1.0970256328582764,
0.5839627385139465,
-0.15356266498565674,
-0.3379802405834198,
-0.3771887719631195,
-0.021596139296889305,
-0.7938058972358704,
-0.03420287370681763,
-0.2788243293762207,
-0.7920529842376709,
0.3545868992805481,
0.2512737512588501,
-0.5367230772972107,
0.44572335481643677,
-0.5892834663391113,
0.5753777027130127,
-0.4642195999622345,
0.20904351770877838,
-0.08909562230110168,
-0.6604685187339783,
0.038924816995859146,
0.12007429450750351,
0.19742751121520996,
-0.18840549886226654,
0.035394635051488876,
0.6734327673912048,
-0.3144005239009857,
0.8381000757217407,
-0.16836941242218018,
0.16451220214366913,
0.35588371753692627,
0.1106221005320549,
0.48496392369270325,
-0.24650488793849945,
-0.08137702941894531,
0.1460949033498764,
-0.004182870965451002,
-0.042961858212947845,
-0.6997008919715881,
0.24017643928527832,
-0.27572205662727356,
-0.2915482521057129,
-0.4623805284500122,
-0.44501304626464844,
-0.16487303376197815,
0.058508023619651794,
0.4537225067615509,
0.3847128748893738,
-0.11903667449951172,
-0.2710280120372772,
0.42308947443962097,
-0.13058476150035858,
1.1228108406066895,
0.23487496376037598,
-0.4927067458629608,
-0.46854516863822937,
0.9404756426811218,
0.011128655634820461,
-0.1177138015627861,
1.0269910097122192,
0.45938053727149963,
-0.47446128726005554,
-0.41859567165374756,
-0.32298338413238525,
-0.008293715305626392,
-0.5275421738624573,
-0.3031264543533325,
-0.24769526720046997,
-0.11015892028808594,
-0.33979105949401855,
-0.12035250663757324,
-0.18472576141357422,
-0.5235903859138489,
-0.4797222912311554,
-0.38746100664138794,
0.22517018020153046,
1.325368881225586,
0.12260563671588898,
0.8275291919708252,
-0.9896228909492493,
0.25754374265670776,
0.4972935616970062,
0.46906936168670654,
-0.4054616093635559,
-0.32133954763412476,
-0.6068150401115417,
0.0881141945719719,
-0.9812353253364563,
-0.8607118725776672,
0.8922504186630249,
0.16863228380680084,
0.4303150177001953,
0.5603682994842529,
-0.14907115697860718,
0.8341987133026123,
-0.7216513156890869,
1.180943250656128,
0.36168190836906433,
-1.0812807083129883,
0.7558607459068298,
-0.05404507741332054,
0.5064111351966858,
-0.12703590095043182,
0.44849827885627747,
-0.5210446715354919,
-0.15301936864852905,
-0.5619093179702759,
-0.4466955363750458,
0.3185192048549652,
-0.011105411686003208,
0.44091498851776123,
0.15554219484329224,
0.14148691296577454,
-0.1446777880191803,
0.4131450355052948,
-0.5233051776885986,
-0.23961615562438965,
-0.6385199427604675,
-0.28304100036621094,
-0.13820858299732208,
-0.5387715101242065,
0.17638979852199554,
-0.10260803997516632,
0.3098354935646057,
-0.11427640914916992,
0.8045107126235962,
-0.12743988633155823,
0.10190048813819885,
-0.24637454748153687,
0.006689125671982765,
0.9165136218070984,
0.4439053237438202,
-0.0012707520509138703,
-0.04442768543958664,
0.09966619312763214,
-0.8893799185752869,
0.08094620704650879,
-0.007587627973407507,
-0.11378404498100281,
0.4178188443183899,
0.42929360270500183,
0.895028829574585,
0.47084519267082214,
-0.35761865973472595,
0.26273688673973083,
0.10902886837720871,
0.06472168117761612,
-0.42396947741508484,
0.02653655596077442,
-0.03711030259728432,
0.5188567042350769,
0.3188598155975342,
0.5546736121177673,
0.12661896646022797,
-0.2816329896450043,
-0.05126975476741791,
0.13884206116199493,
-0.9463270306587219,
-0.68137526512146,
1.206027865409851,
-0.03294653818011284,
-0.3958091735839844,
0.3688141703605652,
-0.1843806803226471,
-0.733371913433075,
0.43593910336494446,
0.28044235706329346,
1.3837916851043701,
-0.3645796477794647,
0.12711475789546967,
0.2580609917640686,
0.26556625962257385,
-0.2730220854282379,
0.5374064445495605,
0.23016004264354706,
-0.8137271404266357,
-0.6533381938934326,
-0.7816087603569031,
-0.4429529011249542,
-0.21207036077976227,
-0.5916955471038818,
0.4051152467727661,
-0.36814963817596436,
-0.41576433181762695,
-0.2587915062904358,
-0.4169872999191284,
-0.6231447458267212,
0.45784786343574524,
0.45646384358406067,
0.9545621275901794,
-0.8492391109466553,
0.657342791557312,
0.7907074093818665,
-0.20713771879673004,
-0.725117027759552,
0.18685054779052734,
-0.06958090513944626,
-0.6306406259536743,
0.49539801478385925,
0.15871235728263855,
-0.24584631621837616,
-0.18599873781204224,
-0.732759416103363,
-1.051269769668579,
1.346100926399231,
0.549142062664032,
-0.546859622001648,
-0.18200618028640747,
0.205753892660141,
0.3078857362270355,
0.0012789774918928742,
-0.03172755986452103,
0.33472615480422974,
0.6423585414886475,
0.3059297800064087,
-0.6175819039344788,
-0.42971256375312805,
0.15686607360839844,
0.09062721580266953,
0.6729071140289307,
-0.1795043647289276,
0.5640127062797546,
-0.04872594773769379,
-0.5427399277687073,
0.018908565863966942,
1.0484073162078857,
-0.24528664350509644,
0.611348569393158,
0.14319710433483124,
0.4782618284225464,
0.849840521812439,
-0.5290713906288147,
1.1803126335144043,
-0.44165584444999695,
0.286131352186203,
1.2614693641662598,
0.03794620931148529,
0.8029369711875916,
0.3584432601928711,
-0.5170415639877319,
0.8391276001930237,
0.40525248646736145,
0.09859979152679443,
0.8627044558525085,
-0.2121158093214035,
-0.24839164316654205,
-0.08970994502305984,
0.31245821714401245,
0.003367104334756732,
0.6096856594085693,
0.517330527305603,
-0.3044443130493164,
-0.01088623609393835,
0.3916071057319641,
-0.23030005395412445,
0.20516549050807953,
-0.5328828692436218,
0.6228795647621155,
0.20585016906261444,
-0.22967301309108734,
-0.09690313041210175,
-0.07869058102369308,
0.5066440105438232,
-0.6906963586807251,
-0.3839934170246124,
-0.11819195747375488,
-0.13509076833724976,
-0.0082755321636796,
-1.0812970399856567,
0.8098589181900024,
-0.30388393998146057,
-0.19191227853298187,
-0.7001777291297913,
0.3902348577976227,
0.019396597519516945,
-0.6725430488586426,
0.06251324713230133,
0.1339903622865677,
-0.009746212512254715,
-0.32264816761016846,
-0.4947211444377899,
-0.3263486623764038,
-0.15925277769565582,
-0.07795315235853195,
0.0063690380193293095,
0.5937209725379944,
-0.3427671194076538,
1.1808233261108398,
0.10511961579322815,
0.08521809428930283,
0.21911711990833282,
-0.15318800508975983,
0.7078725695610046,
-1.0306075811386108,
-0.6035511493682861,
-0.6815842986106873,
0.7657765746116638,
0.18753185868263245,
-0.006850279867649078,
0.4492380917072296,
0.3070642054080963,
0.5737382769584656,
-0.3237050175666809,
0.468845009803772,
0.047131024301052094,
0.5424608588218689,
-0.6592777371406555,
0.8009282946586609,
-0.10600041598081589,
0.1340828388929367,
0.0018258866621181369,
-0.6219272613525391,
-0.2796365022659302,
0.40017205476760864,
-0.3971850275993347,
-0.06710339337587357,
0.6915866732597351,
0.4116741418838501,
0.09925961494445801,
0.28970104455947876,
0.722178041934967,
-0.07078327983617783,
0.23658417165279388,
0.1600833386182785,
0.9056110382080078,
-0.4325219392776489,
0.19787479937076569,
-0.5579767823219299,
0.1100415512919426,
0.06455876678228378,
-1.256301999092102,
-0.4299148619174957,
-0.6707387566566467,
-0.221266970038414,
-0.014446180313825607,
-0.2376309484243393,
0.8588497638702393,
0.8677763342857361,
-1.202256679534912,
-0.13334880769252777,
-0.2376871556043625,
0.16306529939174652,
-0.49497729539871216,
-0.24220404028892517,
0.2005690634250641,
0.03130140155553818,
-0.7067636251449585,
0.848110556602478,
0.23084579408168793,
0.6183860301971436,
-0.3831792175769806,
-0.13465671241283417,
0.4338444471359253,
-0.13608519732952118,
0.7892705798149109,
0.12134372442960739,
-0.5355482697486877,
-0.4240238070487976,
0.003914735745638609,
0.3459998369216919,
0.08292612433433533,
0.9604038000106812,
-1.197265625,
0.4318337142467499,
0.37700554728507996,
0.04662073776125908,
0.5136350393295288,
0.08518283814191818,
0.9296867847442627,
-0.7360243201255798,
0.2652930021286011,
0.44960564374923706,
0.5369890928268433,
0.2581292390823364,
-0.47797679901123047,
0.45646902918815613,
0.13588806986808777,
-0.40438252687454224,
-0.19215360283851624,
0.22459359467029572,
-0.6975895166397095,
-0.07536506652832031,
0.44506046175956726,
0.10821740329265594,
-0.10949642211198807,
0.09377327561378479,
-0.04606405645608902,
0.30308762192726135,
-0.21689406037330627,
0.6068349480628967,
0.3880511224269867,
-0.3352435827255249,
-0.5494531393051147,
-0.7810426950454712,
0.40293216705322266,
-0.3001460134983063,
-0.33892622590065,
-0.29858314990997314,
0.23157186806201935,
-0.28307217359542847,
0.37992218136787415,
-0.2837749123573303,
-0.0948980525135994,
-0.20724359154701233,
-0.09389710426330566,
0.05543556064367294,
-0.015400172211229801,
-0.38450440764427185,
-0.5778888463973999,
-0.021399931982159615,
-0.20860090851783752,
-0.5465529561042786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11622v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11622v1 | Building Knowledge-Guided Lexica to Model Cultural Variation | 2024-06-17T15:05:43 | 2024-06-17T15:05:43 | Shreya Havaldar, Salvatore Giorgi, Sunny Rai, Thomas Talhelm, Sharath Chandra Guntuku, Lyle Ungar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cultural variation exists between nations (e.g., the United States vs.
China), but also within regions (e.g., California vs. Texas, Los Angeles vs.
San Francisco). Measuring this regional cultural variation can illuminate how
and why people think and behave differently. Historically, it has been
difficult to computationally model cultural variation due to a lack of training
data and scalability constraints. In this work, we introduce a new research
problem for the NLP community: How do we measure variation in cultural
constructs across regions using language? We then provide a scalable solution:
building knowledge-guided lexica to model cultural variation, encouraging
future work at the intersection of NLP and cultural understanding. We also
highlight modern LLMs' failure to measure cultural variation or generate
culturally varied language. | [
-0.529072642326355,
-0.6963902115821838,
0.4662665128707886,
0.28374141454696655,
-0.056702081114053726,
0.44427451491355896,
-0.21301352977752686,
-0.6687018871307373,
0.682726263999939,
0.28566932678222656,
-0.6853264570236206,
-0.5094477534294128,
-0.7128885388374329,
0.08509927242994308,
-0.06965895742177963,
0.6975138783454895,
-0.0832708328962326,
0.19738666713237762,
-0.13444587588310242,
-0.5355117321014404,
-0.4304462969303131,
-0.5842840671539307,
-0.48484164476394653,
-0.4861629605293274,
0.4107505977153778,
0.5469167828559875,
0.8724506497383118,
0.505505383014679,
0.5442231893539429,
0.167438805103302,
-0.6910868287086487,
0.4392472207546234,
-0.3123178780078888,
-0.13737794756889343,
-0.28827211260795593,
-0.8294936418533325,
-0.11249269545078278,
-0.125056654214859,
0.5157917141914368,
1.2191916704177856,
-0.24711187183856964,
0.23486575484275818,
-0.2297910898923874,
0.6757030487060547,
-0.5332622528076172,
-0.1778286248445511,
-0.6523640751838684,
0.4985840320587158,
-0.2655872702598572,
-0.14391332864761353,
0.22031860053539276,
-0.3672945201396942,
0.32048729062080383,
-0.45267823338508606,
0.4173297882080078,
-0.07246126234531403,
0.7670055031776428,
0.34983599185943604,
-0.6626918911933899,
-0.3349910378456116,
-0.9383698105812073,
0.8064115643501282,
-0.6327076554298401,
0.1751592457294464,
0.5109699368476868,
0.051184482872486115,
-0.2257593721151352,
-0.6616256237030029,
-0.32856130599975586,
-0.11986491084098816,
0.26662349700927734,
0.0714336484670639,
0.10411625355482101,
-0.5540705919265747,
0.29664894938468933,
0.6893988847732544,
-0.2831496298313141,
0.18604694306850433,
-0.3706076741218567,
-0.2617121636867523,
0.5016322135925293,
0.4874236583709717,
0.7319618463516235,
0.03158951923251152,
-0.23066015541553497,
-0.12079204618930817,
-0.8023646473884583,
0.2851780951023102,
0.28320857882499695,
0.23273728787899017,
-0.18559420108795166,
0.33924341201782227,
-0.20944108068943024,
0.5047662258148193,
-0.3091100752353668,
-0.19548870623111725,
0.2511202394962311,
-0.2750833034515381,
0.02065238542854786,
-0.38679927587509155,
0.3348125219345093,
0.3872509002685547,
-0.16760380566120148,
-0.14638684689998627,
0.05081051588058472,
0.03404088318347931,
-0.0044491407461464405,
-0.4628252387046814,
-0.09733660519123077,
-0.13349418342113495,
-0.3190729320049286,
0.01995491236448288,
-0.19282129406929016,
-0.7573914527893066,
-0.7347914576530457,
-0.18325944244861603,
0.005389274097979069,
-0.2128525674343109,
-0.5489935874938965,
0.27056461572647095,
-0.3029416501522064,
0.5070897936820984,
0.07282016426324844,
-1.2434065341949463,
0.3377830386161804,
0.6044567823410034,
1.0326869487762451,
-0.3035452663898468,
-0.37451210618019104,
0.19135782122612,
-0.18513497710227966,
-0.695911705493927,
0.6603112816810608,
-0.47640421986579895,
-0.6480393409729004,
0.09449167549610138,
-0.16544705629348755,
0.34259986877441406,
-0.6509720683097839,
0.26730993390083313,
-0.3206794857978821,
0.13345901668071747,
-0.9277116060256958,
-0.5233340263366699,
-0.2880614101886749,
0.3837219178676605,
-0.7360159754753113,
0.9654593467712402,
0.2726207971572876,
-0.98856520652771,
0.7083717584609985,
-0.4128812849521637,
-0.21815204620361328,
0.2978513538837433,
-0.4566667675971985,
-0.09564762562513351,
0.33270496129989624,
0.329074501991272,
0.1305423080921173,
-0.5783149003982544,
0.18516092002391815,
-0.30688926577568054,
-0.31507423520088196,
0.18652604520320892,
-0.18416373431682587,
1.124045491218567,
0.3500432074069977,
-0.30244752764701843,
-0.21869519352912903,
-0.6598679423332214,
-0.1430937945842743,
0.2065640091896057,
-0.4412514567375183,
-0.5105578303337097,
0.3611152470111847,
-0.12956330180168152,
0.09275427460670471,
0.5847078561782837,
-0.4387165307998657,
0.28098076581954956,
-0.40611401200294495,
0.33028027415275574,
0.28491517901420593,
-0.11923384666442871,
0.6128900051116943,
-0.5113945007324219,
0.8341538310050964,
-0.014309221878647804,
0.05056679621338844,
0.3271741271018982,
-0.6070270538330078,
-0.8651885390281677,
0.14839956164360046,
0.10725059360265732,
0.4047064781188965,
-1.0248827934265137,
0.12535741925239563,
-0.1593160629272461,
-0.8277462720870972,
-0.4821016192436218,
0.05709755793213844,
-0.06887996941804886,
0.5113326907157898,
0.1603875607252121,
-0.657646894454956,
-0.47209039330482483,
-0.7522733211517334,
-0.022594816982746124,
-0.050896428525447845,
-0.2080933153629303,
0.22171743214130402,
0.310380756855011,
-0.08883422613143921,
1.0244899988174438,
-0.6283721327781677,
-0.2675034999847412,
-0.5387395024299622,
0.14782550930976868,
0.14640742540359497,
0.27444517612457275,
0.5472211241722107,
-0.69765704870224,
-0.3920460641384125,
0.09923219680786133,
-0.5915254354476929,
-0.03749993070960045,
-0.037740558385849,
-0.14584632217884064,
0.06435363739728928,
0.4523291289806366,
0.19984698295593262,
0.3938586711883545,
0.6863526105880737,
-0.45693060755729675,
0.4606516659259796,
-0.20569363236427307,
0.0647454634308815,
-1.486189842224121,
-0.2296099066734314,
0.013723180629312992,
0.16895362734794617,
-0.6330060362815857,
0.23420286178588867,
0.08195405453443527,
0.05695955455303192,
-0.4031142294406891,
0.37931883335113525,
-0.29691582918167114,
-0.17006830871105194,
-0.13519807159900665,
-0.02221454679965973,
-0.19407391548156738,
0.35401150584220886,
0.3980932831764221,
0.7152602076530457,
0.6942278146743774,
-0.5797064900398254,
0.16507022082805634,
0.06926713138818741,
-0.7784476280212402,
0.5298544764518738,
-0.4156019985675812,
-0.07579907029867172,
-0.10767876356840134,
0.3377465009689331,
-0.49204832315444946,
-0.2427682876586914,
-0.22154322266578674,
-0.2394052892923355,
-0.1510773003101349,
-0.12522706389427185,
-0.5099872946739197,
-0.21802379190921783,
-0.01783437468111515,
0.4690675437450409,
0.5150862336158752,
-0.4523319602012634,
0.5787933468818665,
0.46058353781700134,
-0.0442730076611042,
-0.7590409517288208,
-0.9971572756767273,
0.12250012159347534,
-0.5632040500640869,
-0.779193103313446,
0.34538137912750244,
-0.32263943552970886,
-0.4490939974784851,
-0.32863670587539673,
-0.1403433084487915,
-0.2956482172012329,
0.43639299273490906,
-0.0026579187251627445,
-0.09984434396028519,
-0.29546618461608887,
0.31821608543395996,
-0.05919673666357994,
0.3685186803340912,
0.23526962101459503,
-0.19050346314907074,
0.7286707758903503,
-0.24728170037269592,
-0.4764534831047058,
-0.07780002057552338,
0.5282898545265198,
0.3319644033908844,
-0.31874486804008484,
0.8619537949562073,
0.6351107358932495,
-0.32027462124824524,
-0.410288542509079,
-0.5429297685623169,
-0.026820093393325806,
-0.4615151882171631,
0.5206446051597595,
-0.10144258290529251,
-1.0686928033828735,
1.044690489768982,
-0.20807522535324097,
0.14163082838058472,
0.3554377555847168,
0.8128682971000671,
-0.029200438410043716,
0.4882703125476837,
1.1386197805404663,
-0.03291668742895126,
0.474841833114624,
-0.1304614543914795,
0.07644789665937424,
-0.507067859172821,
-0.2283942848443985,
-0.5018041133880615,
-0.5936672687530518,
-0.9707084894180298,
-0.5908862948417664,
0.4319581687450409,
-0.06086600944399834,
-0.22815346717834473,
0.02803841046988964,
-0.1902439147233963,
0.7644195556640625,
0.7403597831726074,
0.037758465856313705,
0.3036923408508301,
0.036505602300167084,
-0.34225472807884216,
-0.3001778721809387,
-0.8713451027870178,
-0.30729037523269653,
1.098811149597168,
0.4248315095901489,
0.7987294793128967,
0.41572892665863037,
0.8735544085502625,
0.12867163121700287,
0.17231425642967224,
-0.8323817849159241,
0.24094992876052856,
-0.31307706236839294,
-0.6043288111686707,
-0.33940693736076355,
-0.3722405731678009,
-0.8206502795219421,
0.25740548968315125,
-0.22608545422554016,
-0.566717803478241,
0.2524676024913788,
0.013443325646221638,
-0.11497075855731964,
0.672796905040741,
-0.47097331285476685,
0.4399709701538086,
-0.09956914931535721,
0.07958896458148956,
0.050881050527095795,
-0.6816235780715942,
0.31327611207962036,
-0.059073206037282944,
0.30320557951927185,
-0.2265583872795105,
0.06850109994411469,
0.6334248781204224,
-0.3741630017757416,
1.059962511062622,
0.1823505461215973,
-0.3786730468273163,
0.335761159658432,
0.4223368465900421,
-0.07325350493192673,
0.1764138787984848,
-0.0124795101583004,
0.23232245445251465,
0.022648677229881287,
-0.5503109097480774,
-0.47288212180137634,
0.5171830654144287,
-1.0104256868362427,
-0.5204856395721436,
-0.18829959630966187,
-0.9896420240402222,
-0.343856543302536,
-0.2921586036682129,
0.45219942927360535,
0.18319562077522278,
-0.2601225674152374,
0.2715784013271332,
0.8089631795883179,
-0.34573036432266235,
0.5826415419578552,
0.656471312046051,
0.0039881933480501175,
-0.17554959654808044,
0.7125717997550964,
0.29151225090026855,
0.23710010945796967,
0.3948534429073334,
0.4807015061378479,
-0.003130272263661027,
-0.3375774025917053,
-0.13692250847816467,
0.07874713093042374,
-0.9210054278373718,
0.21989837288856506,
-0.22413890063762665,
-0.04374010115861893,
-0.23829980194568634,
-0.35289204120635986,
-0.29422467947006226,
-0.32827886939048767,
-0.2733817994594574,
-0.12401672452688217,
0.22695772349834442,
0.9288106560707092,
-0.35951000452041626,
0.3713850975036621,
-0.5114539861679077,
-0.16795490682125092,
0.4590122699737549,
0.3161829113960266,
0.07348952442407608,
-0.6004830002784729,
-0.30440834164619446,
-0.05544639378786087,
-0.16752062737941742,
-1.029213309288025,
0.552717924118042,
-0.07426205277442932,
0.45323386788368225,
0.1718805879354477,
0.04266265407204628,
0.686859667301178,
-0.2882649302482605,
1.1143064498901367,
0.07634668797254562,
-0.9016683101654053,
0.47652965784072876,
-0.15032197535037994,
0.695900022983551,
0.4033293128013611,
0.5624285936355591,
-1.0553135871887207,
-0.5503445863723755,
-0.5889228582382202,
-0.9786108136177063,
0.3051048517227173,
-0.10983288288116455,
0.3532639741897583,
-0.11958976835012436,
0.19229541718959808,
0.07960628718137741,
-0.15250274538993835,
-0.9973598718643188,
-0.3752167224884033,
-0.0010961330262944102,
0.10051988810300827,
-0.09906776249408722,
-0.23943285644054413,
-0.4836302399635315,
-0.1283789724111557,
0.3293931186199188,
-0.09429431706666946,
-0.149827778339386,
0.20492412149906158,
-0.07922239601612091,
-0.029918765649199486,
0.15191397070884705,
0.6076618432998657,
0.8554121851921082,
0.12666462361812592,
0.12745675444602966,
0.5578787922859192,
-0.436781644821167,
-0.09916074573993683,
-0.2459964156150818,
-0.19710040092468262,
-0.11559157818555832,
0.4734500050544739,
0.670013964176178,
-0.2288697212934494,
-0.4854702651500702,
0.16538488864898682,
-0.27498388290405273,
-0.34712710976600647,
-0.4622352421283722,
0.04429684579372406,
0.4864185154438019,
0.39151087403297424,
0.31719619035720825,
-0.31279146671295166,
-0.08632740378379822,
-0.5184942483901978,
0.038288868963718414,
0.33304715156555176,
-0.2687598764896393,
0.040977105498313904,
0.43070828914642334,
0.15563973784446716,
-0.32865139842033386,
0.7061870098114014,
-0.21991561353206635,
-0.38732072710990906,
1.136947751045227,
0.5711483955383301,
0.49343299865722656,
-0.04255475103855133,
0.3604275584220886,
0.19651645421981812,
0.5197678208351135,
-0.15677306056022644,
0.5134789347648621,
-0.1421598196029663,
-1.01776921749115,
-0.48540014028549194,
-0.636108934879303,
-0.7883615493774414,
0.017427733168005943,
-0.7351379990577698,
0.19978955388069153,
-0.3827170729637146,
-0.21302220225334167,
-0.35523921251296997,
0.0976848304271698,
-0.9083452224731445,
0.30009791254997253,
0.3089018166065216,
0.9135379195213318,
-1.2632497549057007,
0.6756795048713684,
0.7567355036735535,
-0.2776186764240265,
-0.9937920570373535,
0.1967252939939499,
-0.015586533583700657,
-0.8036172986030579,
0.6018012166023254,
-0.1543455868959427,
-0.08569147437810898,
-0.3661414086818695,
-0.820980429649353,
-1.234853744506836,
1.2015401124954224,
0.04927957430481911,
-0.2478625476360321,
0.26153483986854553,
0.30152565240859985,
0.9296404123306274,
-0.39576664566993713,
-0.037459585815668106,
0.5973289608955383,
-0.037822164595127106,
0.2840460538864136,
-0.732607364654541,
-0.2976570427417755,
0.02744753286242485,
0.2457803636789322,
0.0995822623372078,
-0.629437267780304,
0.9702625870704651,
-0.1277957260608673,
-0.08438494801521301,
-0.20533284544944763,
0.8875442743301392,
0.22915765643119812,
0.2173847258090973,
0.46019986271858215,
0.5694528818130493,
1.037903070449829,
-0.1696883589029312,
0.8196215629577637,
-0.2628650665283203,
0.3630015552043915,
1.224938154220581,
-0.101834736764431,
0.6030625104904175,
0.34796255826950073,
-0.31132227182388306,
0.6852123737335205,
0.9825485348701477,
-0.08998745679855347,
0.11177876591682434,
0.5800387859344482,
-0.4980400502681732,
-0.196493461728096,
-0.3436949849128723,
-0.41392064094543457,
0.8366947770118713,
0.7456972599029541,
-0.26926496624946594,
-0.1918300837278366,
-0.29837357997894287,
0.2450195848941803,
0.11984018236398697,
-0.32322806119918823,
0.5894966125488281,
-0.09687208384275436,
-0.598793089389801,
0.581866443157196,
0.054977573454380035,
0.9516012668609619,
-0.722132682800293,
0.27801641821861267,
-0.8816865682601929,
-0.523541271686554,
-0.2230525016784668,
-0.6220384836196899,
0.4578891098499298,
-0.057182688266038895,
-0.21275310218334198,
-0.013269225135445595,
0.2181476652622223,
-0.44770824909210205,
-0.5333272814750671,
0.20527435839176178,
0.882486879825592,
0.23174016177654266,
0.4093279242515564,
-0.36857229471206665,
-0.18991759419441223,
0.1820305436849594,
-0.12162531912326813,
0.4811382293701172,
0.6515569090843201,
-0.30581361055374146,
0.8426644802093506,
0.4445207118988037,
0.2286161631345749,
0.24491828680038452,
0.2700037956237793,
0.4200112819671631,
-0.5564457178115845,
-0.6332864761352539,
-0.6658865809440613,
0.162413090467453,
-0.10088308155536652,
-0.6197036504745483,
0.41567954421043396,
0.038875143975019455,
1.0120110511779785,
0.06196478381752968,
0.6021305918693542,
-0.44724535942077637,
0.3103841245174408,
-0.3866719901561737,
0.6631707549095154,
-0.8752138614654541,
0.2962836027145386,
0.10349037498235703,
-0.8095896244049072,
-0.48160862922668457,
0.4701001048088074,
-0.0653097927570343,
-0.10051118582487106,
0.8788511753082275,
0.7459991574287415,
0.31281447410583496,
0.00030976097332313657,
0.4837968349456787,
0.08440211415290833,
0.3714641034603119,
0.44828101992607117,
0.6481150984764099,
0.3082868158817291,
0.4659629464149475,
-0.6623386740684509,
-0.2636784017086029,
0.26389405131340027,
-1.1268960237503052,
-0.5843478441238403,
-0.7501024007797241,
-0.22110065817832947,
-0.2796189486980438,
-0.4631789028644562,
0.9395790696144104,
0.46223118901252747,
-0.5374252200126648,
-0.5933963656425476,
0.0785006731748581,
0.29744234681129456,
-0.38493412733078003,
-0.22784475982189178,
0.2540932893753052,
-0.3994015157222748,
-0.9519016146659851,
0.31253764033317566,
0.02181142382323742,
0.2769547998905182,
-0.6751248836517334,
0.4207463562488556,
-0.003334812819957733,
0.16560101509094238,
0.4232029318809509,
0.4291688799858093,
-0.8041356205940247,
-0.18027876317501068,
-0.15852950513362885,
-0.005639815237373114,
0.013228020630776882,
0.9414371848106384,
-0.4961581826210022,
0.5229691863059998,
0.5877974033355713,
0.8461285829544067,
0.2983909845352173,
-0.4053123891353607,
0.7889915704727173,
-1.0519973039627075,
0.08801606297492981,
0.18461646139621735,
0.5362963676452637,
0.5602197647094727,
-0.2479797601699829,
0.740074098110199,
0.2431146502494812,
-0.686804473400116,
-0.2011469602584839,
0.6879964470863342,
-0.8532299995422363,
-0.41586774587631226,
1.2104394435882568,
-0.11055589467287064,
0.09201253205537796,
-0.16836394369602203,
0.12753033638000488,
0.1193942129611969,
0.00939234346151352,
1.303620457649231,
1.0744930505752563,
-0.08037038892507553,
0.23168867826461792,
-0.6002709865570068,
0.597920298576355,
0.6460000276565552,
-0.7605440020561218,
-0.2602842152118683,
0.4395526647567749,
0.5761095285415649,
0.23328708112239838,
0.5614758133888245,
0.08594617247581482,
0.070390485227108,
0.03800549358129501,
0.25188082456588745,
0.4743525981903076,
-0.05067930743098259,
-0.2979223132133484,
0.19215136766433716,
0.08141018450260162,
0.15135706961154938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11617v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11617v1 | DELLA-Merging: Reducing Interference in Model Merging through Magnitude-Based Sampling | 2024-06-17T15:02:45 | 2024-06-17T15:02:45 | Pala Tej Deep, Rishabh Bhardwaj, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the proliferation of domain-specific models, model merging has emerged
as a set of techniques that combine the capabilities of multiple models into
one that can multitask without the cost of additional training. In this paper,
we propose a new model merging technique, Drop and rEscaLe via sampLing with
mAgnitude (DELLA-Merging), that employs a novel pruning technique, MAGPRUNE,
which shows significant advantages over DARE and TIES. MAGPRUNE first ranks the
parameters in order of their magnitude and assigns higher dropout probabilities
(p) to parameters with lower ranks corresponding to lower magnitudes. To
approximate the original embeddings, MAGPRUNE employs a rescaling operation on
the parameters that survive the random dropping by 1/(1 - p). On three
different expert models considered for merging (LM, Math, Code) and
corresponding benchmark datasets (AlpacaEval, GSM8K, MBPP), DELLA shows an
average improvement of 2.4 points over baseline methods employing delta
parameter pruning (an improvement of 3.6 points over TIES, 1.2 points over
DARE), and 11.1 points over the no-pruning baseline (TA). We release the source
code at: https://github.com/declare-lab/della. | [
-0.9630799293518066,
-0.4060121178627014,
0.1776597648859024,
-0.06227407231926918,
-0.10071668028831482,
-0.2945753037929535,
-0.03716827183961868,
-0.4046085774898529,
0.07835278660058975,
0.40843674540519714,
-0.9358363747596741,
-0.1776174157857895,
-0.33883070945739746,
-0.08434360474348068,
-0.7211484313011169,
1.0473833084106445,
0.23153044283390045,
0.17884384095668793,
-0.3213590979576111,
0.13072307407855988,
-0.23909904062747955,
-0.5391915440559387,
-0.5553889274597168,
-0.07199431210756302,
0.6712421774864197,
0.3469361960887909,
0.5464804768562317,
0.2826988399028778,
1.0035287141799927,
0.26430800557136536,
-0.29569536447525024,
0.8441406488418579,
-0.6931126117706299,
-0.1291026920080185,
-0.17332473397254944,
-0.5384176969528198,
-0.7019147872924805,
0.548180341720581,
0.7996415495872498,
0.7846128344535828,
-0.1501418501138687,
0.2640850841999054,
0.14959077537059784,
0.6597058176994324,
-0.9035988450050354,
-0.2677973806858063,
-0.3821133077144623,
0.2652050852775574,
0.03980764001607895,
-0.16565607488155365,
-0.6384499669075012,
-0.627273440361023,
0.04137137904763222,
-0.3797610402107239,
0.5910475254058838,
-0.18053889274597168,
1.0379480123519897,
0.5009695887565613,
-0.5854915976524353,
0.5485363006591797,
-0.948599636554718,
1.0578910112380981,
-0.681544840335846,
0.3615134060382843,
0.3648965656757355,
0.24667634069919586,
-0.15052519738674164,
-0.4313887059688568,
-0.31836357712745667,
0.025694523006677628,
0.08093636482954025,
-0.012970269657671452,
0.039182331413030624,
-0.1625576615333557,
0.012485413812100887,
0.5493119955062866,
0.10690254718065262,
0.10642470419406891,
-0.8258687257766724,
-0.15355077385902405,
0.9551150798797607,
0.13623535633087158,
-0.14114262163639069,
0.09459492564201355,
-0.3468741774559021,
-0.17000725865364075,
-0.9047384262084961,
-0.16331613063812256,
0.44282543659210205,
0.36079642176628113,
0.13086910545825958,
0.6802964210510254,
-0.16504572331905365,
0.8478319048881531,
0.509198784828186,
-0.1342078447341919,
0.3791980445384979,
-0.618828535079956,
-0.2742244303226471,
-0.5687707662582397,
0.5987721681594849,
0.8586760759353638,
0.043404605239629745,
0.09785506129264832,
0.07950913161039352,
-0.6961802840232849,
0.46856021881103516,
-0.9535226821899414,
-0.5754886269569397,
0.19553525745868683,
-0.5410887598991394,
-0.6388318538665771,
0.13080748915672302,
-0.6265021562576294,
-0.35555365681648254,
-0.41829243302345276,
0.47399723529815674,
-0.31274929642677307,
-0.3859657943248749,
-0.125905379652977,
-0.05676442012190819,
0.030970539897680283,
0.5201559066772461,
-0.40260618925094604,
0.017745058983564377,
0.7127121090888977,
0.777320384979248,
-0.11606802046298981,
-0.31373316049575806,
-0.9016398191452026,
-0.14740917086601257,
-0.4425545632839203,
0.4973558485507965,
-0.25161969661712646,
-1.0123540163040161,
-0.26468625664711,
-0.09306813031435013,
-0.15032482147216797,
-0.6253882646560669,
0.7266354560852051,
-0.431244432926178,
0.38434964418411255,
-0.36330458521842957,
-0.5564489364624023,
-0.7122988104820251,
0.11404100805521011,
-0.8256988525390625,
0.8325182795524597,
0.05711570754647255,
-0.6445197463035583,
0.5733561515808105,
-0.16778765618801117,
-0.033727195113897324,
-0.17316974699497223,
-0.01873951405286789,
-0.7158862948417664,
0.39059507846832275,
0.22228491306304932,
0.4069676697254181,
-0.468963623046875,
0.040974635630846024,
-0.3945506513118744,
-0.3262878358364105,
0.1376635730266571,
-0.40793493390083313,
0.5632025003433228,
0.28360870480537415,
0.2253870964050293,
0.13902118802070618,
-0.6289475560188293,
0.35561859607696533,
-0.3888304829597473,
-0.12877625226974487,
-0.06563140451908112,
-0.07070410251617432,
0.050892554223537445,
0.15850113332271576,
0.22099937498569489,
-0.16646812856197357,
0.577335774898529,
-0.32067418098449707,
0.18434615433216095,
0.3101133406162262,
0.23827224969863892,
0.8852563500404358,
-0.8448216915130615,
0.3068769872188568,
0.06724318116903305,
0.5124276280403137,
0.2409662902355194,
-0.5286881923675537,
-0.6528228521347046,
-0.8445576429367065,
0.8859885334968567,
0.2742798626422882,
-0.4311702251434326,
0.7101190090179443,
-0.36887526512145996,
-0.8883917331695557,
-0.6539146304130554,
-0.209246426820755,
0.24049706757068634,
0.5570977330207825,
0.3627336025238037,
-0.4352560043334961,
-0.15629996359348297,
-1.150359869003296,
0.059886571019887924,
-0.044590964913368225,
-0.4575936198234558,
0.2889271080493927,
0.08426687121391296,
0.287654846906662,
1.2951440811157227,
-0.7416267991065979,
-0.5808277130126953,
0.0061698188073933125,
0.3704095780849457,
0.18503910303115845,
0.7829389572143555,
0.6846616268157959,
-1.010374903678894,
-0.3875672519207001,
-0.0661979541182518,
-0.3982081711292267,
-0.09362569451332092,
0.11501044034957886,
0.06242559477686882,
-0.14262127876281738,
-0.03265676274895668,
-0.6536717414855957,
0.678040623664856,
0.5118542909622192,
0.03628827631473541,
0.7790444493293762,
-0.17275471985340118,
0.8819413185119629,
-1.3987747430801392,
-0.012050497345626354,
0.026429645717144012,
0.11416619271039963,
-0.9473118185997009,
0.23513075709342957,
0.37880653142929077,
-0.09423046559095383,
-0.7806121110916138,
0.20781299471855164,
-0.5561485290527344,
0.08303367346525192,
-0.22596503794193268,
-0.26521772146224976,
0.1871315836906433,
0.2662661075592041,
-0.08350368589162827,
0.8138787746429443,
0.32274460792541504,
-0.6076763272285461,
0.1312585026025772,
0.2144189178943634,
-0.07118339836597443,
0.39772674441337585,
-0.3041446805000305,
-0.06269782036542892,
0.06875914335250854,
0.1406000852584839,
-0.718231737613678,
-0.05799928680062294,
0.11672284454107285,
-0.5110664963722229,
0.2111322283744812,
-0.526712954044342,
-0.3700355887413025,
-0.20482011139392853,
-0.6886425018310547,
0.4589819610118866,
0.5830569267272949,
-0.43814241886138916,
0.8403764367103577,
0.2724337875843048,
-0.10387659072875977,
-0.4930807650089264,
-0.6329007148742676,
-0.3333337903022766,
-0.5253163576126099,
-0.7552124261856079,
0.5733652114868164,
-0.1621761918067932,
-0.03074871562421322,
0.0730060487985611,
-0.16836097836494446,
-0.6322172284126282,
-0.2005486786365509,
0.24553649127483368,
0.7523325085639954,
0.3242768943309784,
0.3990795910358429,
0.25393083691596985,
-0.0017719647148624063,
-0.2223934531211853,
0.10735564678907394,
0.36447638273239136,
0.2903839647769928,
-0.3769363760948181,
-0.8439546227455139,
0.27439579367637634,
0.9161249399185181,
-0.3736816346645355,
0.9695519804954529,
0.6197770237922668,
-0.10158541798591614,
-0.13351865112781525,
-0.7715182304382324,
-0.6658490896224976,
-0.40814197063446045,
0.29388996958732605,
-0.6727680563926697,
-0.6309269070625305,
0.6694808602333069,
-0.41229644417762756,
0.5875809192657471,
0.29390978813171387,
0.2415487915277481,
0.16067376732826233,
0.8924772143363953,
0.9489763975143433,
-0.18250061571598053,
0.4392184615135193,
-0.5464642643928528,
0.6563543677330017,
-0.8629397749900818,
-0.28890329599380493,
-0.6098702549934387,
-0.572875440120697,
-0.20844855904579163,
-0.904335618019104,
0.27330973744392395,
0.2954615652561188,
0.17516367137432098,
0.30637526512145996,
-0.7795729637145996,
0.4152229130268097,
0.5157396793365479,
0.10432173311710358,
0.3867110013961792,
0.3166169226169586,
0.1814592480659485,
-0.33864784240722656,
-0.7625738978385925,
0.172906756401062,
1.101045846939087,
0.09244945645332336,
0.5390496850013733,
-0.09859900921583176,
1.0014108419418335,
-0.043244291096925735,
0.33093157410621643,
-1.0483793020248413,
0.7170993685722351,
-0.09924498200416565,
-0.41530925035476685,
-0.24046173691749573,
-0.7910935878753662,
-0.47373077273368835,
0.637201189994812,
-0.5991187691688538,
-0.3655143976211548,
0.7059029936790466,
0.12025700509548187,
-0.6974392533302307,
0.44362136721611023,
-0.7859102487564087,
0.19880220293998718,
0.5460976958274841,
-0.2591530680656433,
-0.4586951434612274,
-0.10644212365150452,
0.570036768913269,
-0.5397167205810547,
0.29291388392448425,
-0.37235012650489807,
-0.2608069181442261,
0.5257074236869812,
-0.7734802961349487,
0.5602222681045532,
0.08013644069433212,
-0.18790502846240997,
0.20374158024787903,
0.39475569128990173,
0.6078568696975708,
-0.17912960052490234,
-0.2113897055387497,
0.37169769406318665,
-0.14140921831130981,
0.00500466488301754,
-0.7775583863258362,
0.8132362961769104,
-0.581753671169281,
-0.4037282466888428,
0.046104151755571365,
-1.0132020711898804,
-0.15106560289859772,
-0.15537314116954803,
0.3894341289997101,
0.6981456875801086,
0.2619483768939972,
0.3308885395526886,
0.18540321290493011,
0.37905436754226685,
0.14025993645191193,
0.6185118556022644,
-0.3982127606868744,
-0.6703982353210449,
0.6983442902565002,
0.41528981924057007,
0.21698014438152313,
-0.01518626231700182,
-0.060818515717983246,
-0.2500096559524536,
-0.5412013530731201,
0.09064466506242752,
0.3271578848361969,
-0.2983238101005554,
-0.5302118062973022,
-0.3323267996311188,
-0.48259231448173523,
-0.20133820176124573,
-0.23430688679218292,
-0.4967513084411621,
-0.6025030016899109,
-0.15972596406936646,
0.1577601432800293,
0.488409161567688,
0.2863515019416809,
-0.4415951371192932,
0.28677764534950256,
-1.3419049978256226,
-0.16801342368125916,
0.13121870160102844,
-0.16092915832996368,
-0.017432114109396935,
-0.7239688038825989,
-0.1739034205675125,
0.09932363778352737,
-0.09062642604112625,
-0.9824551343917847,
0.7517648935317993,
0.1794171780347824,
0.38206198811531067,
0.3777705132961273,
0.41501402854919434,
0.9655817747116089,
-0.2720274329185486,
0.5863251686096191,
0.537416398525238,
-0.7319265007972717,
0.4284985363483429,
-0.24566926062107086,
0.009116817265748978,
0.6594097018241882,
0.5367434024810791,
-0.13744471967220306,
-0.5322902202606201,
-0.6088518500328064,
-0.8639594912528992,
0.6542980074882507,
0.4055473506450653,
-0.3733852803707123,
0.136151984333992,
0.35320383310317993,
-0.2764912545681,
0.2775338590145111,
-0.023423736914992332,
-0.18084502220153809,
0.6256524920463562,
-0.1512819230556488,
0.02006959170103073,
-0.1160242110490799,
-0.6500858664512634,
-0.6035972237586975,
0.4299112558364868,
0.14467480778694153,
-0.19065669178962708,
0.08220133185386658,
0.10339845716953278,
0.04797334969043732,
-0.13474108278751373,
0.22078777849674225,
0.6432618498802185,
-0.05072452872991562,
-0.17330600321292877,
0.32841092348098755,
-0.49483737349510193,
-0.0015753540210425854,
-0.007476260885596275,
-0.4826098680496216,
-0.023093145340681076,
-0.00884359423071146,
0.14123520255088806,
0.49678197503089905,
-0.21047385036945343,
0.29136934876441956,
-0.06346064805984497,
-0.8366667032241821,
0.19354449212551117,
0.12294527143239975,
-0.10085083544254303,
0.3099614679813385,
0.49606043100357056,
0.5808581113815308,
0.3824024200439453,
0.031890932470560074,
0.3468061685562134,
0.2844923734664917,
-0.14477476477622986,
-0.16093581914901733,
0.41653087735176086,
0.5939122438430786,
-0.16563951969146729,
1.06430983543396,
-0.08596592396497726,
-0.20646558701992035,
0.7378989458084106,
-0.07952571660280228,
0.7720534801483154,
-0.26517629623413086,
0.08456441760063171,
0.6799025535583496,
-0.03188581019639969,
-0.21095918118953705,
-0.04378494247794151,
-0.16795681416988373,
-0.7035207748413086,
-0.8987158536911011,
-0.34729504585266113,
-0.3918725550174713,
0.024545999243855476,
-1.0228883028030396,
0.30743828415870667,
-0.2144356071949005,
-0.7926862239837646,
-0.10332409292459488,
0.36079564690589905,
-0.317974328994751,
-0.1191362738609314,
-0.36413270235061646,
0.9000065326690674,
-0.8480086922645569,
0.7920301556587219,
0.5174724459648132,
-0.36118730902671814,
-1.0508041381835938,
0.04589546471834183,
0.4372446537017822,
0.03600421920418739,
0.7417254447937012,
0.1881718933582306,
-0.054727472364902496,
0.274223655462265,
-0.23702402412891388,
-0.8779802322387695,
1.0947736501693726,
0.18824906647205353,
-0.6396698355674744,
0.13212165236473083,
-0.6009066104888916,
-0.041383448988199234,
-0.2570275664329529,
0.039669666439294815,
0.7144707441329956,
0.3679664134979248,
0.6750961542129517,
-1.2930631637573242,
-0.24261759221553802,
-0.18821892142295837,
-0.22576399147510529,
0.8264733552932739,
-0.487136572599411,
1.1159327030181885,
-0.43785127997398376,
-0.35510316491127014,
0.35341107845306396,
0.6217566132545471,
0.35021668672561646,
0.0011919235112145543,
0.539616048336029,
0.8747157454490662,
0.908523440361023,
-0.16388235986232758,
0.5144922137260437,
-0.7125720977783203,
0.87428218126297,
1.0993452072143555,
-0.2714730203151703,
1.0857104063034058,
0.38866809010505676,
-0.3963983356952667,
-0.17680229246616364,
0.5563666224479675,
-0.39846599102020264,
0.4291251599788666,
-0.29646942019462585,
-0.560779869556427,
-0.42463400959968567,
-0.04026982560753822,
-0.5176196694374084,
0.1160256490111351,
-0.0637819692492485,
0.023905117064714432,
-0.3864263594150543,
-0.1276210993528366,
0.011536101810634136,
-0.142649307847023,
-0.2915091812610626,
0.5878446102142334,
-0.14716215431690216,
-0.5514929294586182,
0.4976901412010193,
-0.2700595557689667,
0.7982408404350281,
-0.35574865341186523,
-0.044043831527233124,
-0.2098686546087265,
0.2643384337425232,
-0.40991589426994324,
-0.5921832323074341,
0.417214572429657,
-0.3428700864315033,
-0.40998953580856323,
0.06215529516339302,
0.557101845741272,
-0.6181970238685608,
-0.5203555226325989,
0.010252628475427628,
0.5832054018974304,
0.34308212995529175,
-0.21667715907096863,
-0.4544757604598999,
0.15046343207359314,
0.10859896242618561,
-0.002693779766559601,
0.33485278487205505,
-0.004115499556064606,
0.12113955616950989,
0.7942746877670288,
0.8680972456932068,
0.33084264397621155,
-0.02257624641060829,
0.33876505494117737,
1.0418181419372559,
-0.2508496344089508,
-0.2042168229818344,
-0.5035393834114075,
0.48585742712020874,
-0.4227057993412018,
-0.0483357235789299,
0.8265590667724609,
0.5879306197166443,
0.4918884336948395,
-0.18452779948711395,
0.17849481105804443,
-0.10411948710680008,
0.4630066454410553,
-0.17289526760578156,
0.9010248780250549,
-0.7810125350952148,
0.12651459872722626,
0.3444165587425232,
-1.0441025495529175,
-0.2736729085445404,
0.4658433496952057,
-0.5087965726852417,
0.07453467696905136,
0.45564448833465576,
1.0868282318115234,
0.16620881855487823,
-0.4000430405139923,
0.49868184328079224,
-0.22876623272895813,
0.31183502078056335,
0.4129074513912201,
0.4025142788887024,
-0.3258555829524994,
0.5308550000190735,
-0.4937850832939148,
-0.27518966794013977,
-0.3850483298301697,
-0.4964805245399475,
-0.7033425569534302,
-0.6011025309562683,
-0.4418691098690033,
0.05220543220639229,
-0.2813040018081665,
0.6194600462913513,
1.22211492061615,
-0.25866463780403137,
0.09929461777210236,
0.14300116896629333,
-0.017472755163908005,
-0.42283666133880615,
-0.25294360518455505,
0.3382704555988312,
-0.4460972845554352,
-1.2954860925674438,
0.34822267293930054,
0.185890793800354,
0.05803794786334038,
-0.19113916158676147,
0.15772004425525665,
0.006108757574111223,
0.1725132316350937,
0.40177053213119507,
0.055250126868486404,
-0.5181914567947388,
0.021281417459249496,
-0.22878699004650116,
0.17427858710289001,
-0.24321423470973969,
0.7234569191932678,
-0.7719305753707886,
0.30449825525283813,
0.9188868999481201,
0.2968290150165558,
0.2754470109939575,
0.4332805275917053,
0.8550835847854614,
-0.7653843760490417,
0.40607839822769165,
0.09917134791612625,
0.06175541132688522,
0.11643754690885544,
-0.331441193819046,
0.7375979423522949,
0.13392318785190582,
-0.521467924118042,
-1.1127653121948242,
0.265613853931427,
-0.8412168622016907,
-0.19509848952293396,
0.6800312995910645,
-0.13928449153900146,
-0.16976863145828247,
0.29009661078453064,
-0.19587689638137817,
0.09331940114498138,
-0.19056043028831482,
0.8826776146888733,
0.6064819097518921,
0.06767265498638153,
-0.28146398067474365,
-0.27941009402275085,
0.5637913346290588,
0.4929007589817047,
-0.4882478415966034,
-0.029382850974798203,
0.6625969409942627,
0.2710663378238678,
0.3845112919807434,
0.20264564454555511,
-0.3577895760536194,
0.6285106539726257,
0.057387154549360275,
0.42687326669692993,
-0.4292147755622864,
-0.6337648630142212,
-0.41716066002845764,
0.4807308316230774,
-0.07430683076381683,
-0.4415419399738312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11614v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11614v1 | Intrinsic Evaluation of Unlearning Using Parametric Knowledge Traces | 2024-06-17T15:00:35 | 2024-06-17T15:00:35 | Yihuai Hong, Lei Yu, Shauli Ravfogel, Haiqin Yang, Mor Geva | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The task of "unlearning" certain concepts in large language models (LLMs) has
attracted immense attention recently, due to its importance for mitigating
undesirable model behaviours, such as the generation of harmful, private, or
incorrect information. Current protocols to evaluate unlearning methods largely
rely on behavioral tests, without monitoring the presence of unlearned
knowledge within the model's parameters. This residual knowledge can be
adversarially exploited to recover the erased information post-unlearning. We
argue that unlearning should also be evaluated internally, by considering
changes in the parametric knowledge traces of the unlearned concepts. To this
end, we propose a general methodology for eliciting directions in the parameter
space (termed "concept vectors") that encode concrete concepts, and construct
ConceptVectors, a benchmark dataset containing hundreds of common concepts and
their parametric knowledge traces within two open-source LLMs. Evaluation on
ConceptVectors shows that existing unlearning methods minimally impact concept
vectors, while directly ablating these vectors demonstrably removes the
associated knowledge from the LLMs and significantly reduces their
susceptibility to adversarial manipulation. Our results highlight limitations
in behavioral-based unlearning evaluations and call for future work to include
parametric-based evaluations. To support this, we release our code and
benchmark at https://github.com/yihuaihong/ConceptVectors. | [
-0.09109233319759369,
-0.6900945901870728,
0.5067808032035828,
-0.13367418944835663,
-0.37562382221221924,
0.3568076491355896,
-0.4437273442745209,
0.05551096051931381,
-0.3416561782360077,
0.4486308693885803,
-0.36968013644218445,
-0.6842947006225586,
-0.42817655205726624,
-0.4415556490421295,
-0.7768288254737854,
0.9671629667282104,
-0.07159456610679626,
0.053071074187755585,
-0.6884360313415527,
-0.17848649621009827,
-0.24142134189605713,
-0.3584182560443878,
-0.49605897068977356,
-0.49804437160491943,
0.3720666170120239,
0.2739824950695038,
0.2220415323972702,
0.35367336869239807,
0.3206291198730469,
0.3580445349216461,
-0.30503666400909424,
0.23461632430553436,
-0.759631872177124,
0.18279607594013214,
-0.23818282783031464,
-0.37186184525489807,
0.049278583377599716,
0.08805529028177261,
0.8043330311775208,
0.9125528335571289,
-0.390967458486557,
0.4059996008872986,
0.4871470630168915,
0.7617099285125732,
-0.7826120853424072,
0.23369626700878143,
-0.6642969250679016,
-0.079222172498703,
-0.06008663401007652,
-0.4171302616596222,
-0.33055493235588074,
-0.4307015836238861,
0.09589125216007233,
-0.49326375126838684,
0.19640539586544037,
-0.2698686122894287,
0.6721308827400208,
0.19715343415737152,
-0.21634437143802643,
-0.39024123549461365,
-0.9845582842826843,
0.7853408455848694,
-0.38920801877975464,
0.601373016834259,
0.41850119829177856,
0.22024990618228912,
-0.3104029595851898,
-0.7811208367347717,
-0.3064420819282532,
-0.2815589904785156,
0.166933074593544,
0.17120815813541412,
-0.41251125931739807,
-0.12757264077663422,
0.08795445412397385,
0.15382157266139984,
-0.31221339106559753,
0.09636517614126205,
-0.7322284579277039,
-0.15627719461917877,
0.3589136004447937,
0.12461013346910477,
0.1069369688630104,
-0.037341006100177765,
-0.44195884466171265,
-0.07984904199838638,
-0.9506080746650696,
0.22620680928230286,
0.5561733841896057,
0.09400590509176254,
-0.018426617607474327,
0.6279172897338867,
-0.29513445496559143,
0.45909205079078674,
-0.06613117456436157,
-0.018477139994502068,
0.3249953091144562,
-0.11404561251401901,
0.04405155032873154,
-0.17018060386180878,
0.7263994812965393,
0.22770486772060394,
0.16749557852745056,
-0.7130559682846069,
-0.1599505990743637,
0.17266219854354858,
0.38117536902427673,
-0.6109247803688049,
-0.2515333890914917,
0.1001528948545456,
-0.4343867301940918,
-0.265411376953125,
0.12572066485881805,
-0.7895113229751587,
-0.5247951745986938,
-0.40669775009155273,
0.4414003789424896,
-0.7493961453437805,
-0.04678715020418167,
-0.0057165902107954025,
-0.28983351588249207,
0.3477635681629181,
0.3273988962173462,
-0.3239557445049286,
0.11537322402000427,
0.7854734659194946,
0.7207018733024597,
-0.18092548847198486,
-0.32497966289520264,
-0.38297006487846375,
0.10249035805463791,
-0.4605018198490143,
0.7079741358757019,
-0.7160155773162842,
-0.5610784888267517,
0.019495785236358643,
-0.2889365553855896,
0.18484678864479065,
-0.6583147048950195,
0.5340672731399536,
-0.46478554606437683,
-0.034563805907964706,
-0.4899778664112091,
-0.8090277910232544,
-0.29192063212394714,
0.020428432151675224,
-0.15689148008823395,
1.0153876543045044,
0.11078517884016037,
-0.6738579273223877,
0.3065529465675354,
-0.2668529450893402,
-0.237782284617424,
0.23743446171283722,
-0.43093398213386536,
-0.3006191849708557,
0.25107887387275696,
-0.18340575695037842,
0.44734254479408264,
-0.4966135323047638,
0.3056395351886749,
-0.4862538278102875,
-0.41449984908103943,
0.39187973737716675,
-0.4721127152442932,
0.9196571707725525,
0.029385214671492577,
-0.27647706866264343,
0.10939029604196548,
-0.9768257141113281,
-0.09468204528093338,
0.09184183180332184,
-0.276372492313385,
-0.7080010175704956,
0.2645261585712433,
-0.5479410886764526,
0.2096864879131317,
0.21991178393363953,
-0.7145501971244812,
-0.13641133904457092,
-0.1380447894334793,
0.354724258184433,
1.0526765584945679,
0.29114583134651184,
0.4009350538253784,
-0.2651437222957611,
0.42616233229637146,
0.019814856350421906,
0.09791299700737,
0.15936584770679474,
-0.2741399109363556,
-0.9230105876922607,
-0.13537539541721344,
0.028581298887729645,
-0.020587116479873657,
-0.8544979691505432,
0.33954131603240967,
-0.1529548168182373,
-0.7315759062767029,
-0.39616215229034424,
0.49754399061203003,
0.8051031827926636,
0.7776973843574524,
0.29277849197387695,
-0.005283980630338192,
-0.35111570358276367,
-0.6430126428604126,
-0.21406270563602448,
-0.462797075510025,
-0.16523247957229614,
-0.12833580374717712,
0.5535164475440979,
-0.07817955315113068,
0.7669385075569153,
-0.49325186014175415,
-0.1189451739192009,
-0.06578744947910309,
0.3350640535354614,
-0.2796939015388489,
0.292860746383667,
0.1699812114238739,
-0.41458308696746826,
0.0780314952135086,
-0.0865197479724884,
-0.9554699063301086,
0.1178680807352066,
0.07545068114995956,
-0.16559909284114838,
-0.10318876802921295,
0.7886991500854492,
-0.5828831791877747,
0.4080822765827179,
0.17109474539756775,
-0.24266931414604187,
0.5453318953514099,
-0.34792256355285645,
-0.1494373083114624,
-0.5347073674201965,
0.17846594750881195,
-0.003517983015626669,
0.13019591569900513,
-0.48702478408813477,
0.30575641989707947,
0.19148747622966766,
0.08128874748945236,
-0.6712018847465515,
0.4513530731201172,
-0.4822162091732025,
-0.06904124468564987,
-0.07508175820112228,
0.1950632929801941,
-0.04698258638381958,
0.6399000883102417,
-0.13207241892814636,
0.5429501533508301,
0.4769326448440552,
-0.8980811238288879,
0.4286327064037323,
0.24976617097854614,
-0.531221330165863,
0.5266502499580383,
-0.4909968376159668,
0.24156814813613892,
-0.3571096956729889,
-0.03831495717167854,
-0.9958056211471558,
0.3584018051624298,
0.26683756709098816,
-0.5494798421859741,
0.2219277173280716,
-0.10902569442987442,
-0.3634369969367981,
-0.21749451756477356,
-0.5658397078514099,
0.10904145985841751,
0.7674911022186279,
-0.6285827159881592,
0.37320515513420105,
0.394990473985672,
0.12336204946041107,
-0.4480980336666107,
-0.29618990421295166,
-0.21346771717071533,
-0.4700981378555298,
-0.1722821295261383,
0.15091238915920258,
-0.04462305083870888,
-0.23359844088554382,
0.19443006813526154,
-0.3885118365287781,
0.0837540328502655,
0.12133911997079849,
0.40917783975601196,
0.1796586811542511,
0.07031530886888504,
0.22923387587070465,
-0.07663533836603165,
-0.06174573302268982,
0.5416057109832764,
-0.4034910500049591,
0.4873303771018982,
-0.12361987680196762,
-0.5835500955581665,
-0.017197223380208015,
-0.19604341685771942,
0.4557144045829773,
-0.41902247071266174,
0.6391394734382629,
0.6428490877151489,
-0.531457245349884,
-0.46677863597869873,
-0.3134445548057556,
0.025074902921915054,
-0.5016246438026428,
0.46985772252082825,
-0.07519454509019852,
-0.6992319822311401,
0.5681018829345703,
-0.23967806994915009,
0.005769021809101105,
0.23793287575244904,
0.5618017315864563,
-0.23037494719028473,
0.7154176831245422,
0.44147658348083496,
0.0287035945802927,
0.18674148619174957,
-0.5443851947784424,
0.1499270498752594,
-1.139182448387146,
-0.6963843107223511,
-0.5414236783981323,
-0.09466530382633209,
-0.48149335384368896,
-0.5242733955383301,
0.35149216651916504,
0.247849702835083,
-0.3387743830680847,
0.07481981068849564,
-0.0865161195397377,
0.39632517099380493,
0.5877392292022705,
0.4017391800880432,
0.32439687848091125,
-0.0005414863699115813,
-0.41255757212638855,
0.12572146952152252,
-0.4408958852291107,
-0.4125002324581146,
1.5591191053390503,
0.29748430848121643,
0.8078409433364868,
0.05184164643287659,
0.6039563417434692,
0.09414391964673996,
0.28021690249443054,
-0.6899747252464294,
0.677520215511322,
-0.20687684416770935,
-0.12252941727638245,
-0.421932578086853,
-0.623065710067749,
-0.762408435344696,
0.19466720521450043,
0.031156379729509354,
-0.8619675040245056,
0.12535710632801056,
0.031843483448028564,
-0.3202073574066162,
0.4621949791908264,
-0.3492053747177124,
0.6012563109397888,
-0.24823440611362457,
-0.49498501420021057,
-0.3446715474128723,
-0.223648801445961,
0.532814621925354,
-0.4399394094944,
-0.04946389049291611,
-0.048305731266736984,
0.07196687906980515,
0.9849513173103333,
-0.43165791034698486,
0.9414319396018982,
-0.3861539959907532,
-0.25808829069137573,
0.4251449406147003,
0.14961838722229004,
0.39083755016326904,
0.059359971433877945,
0.12489989399909973,
0.14703626930713654,
-0.15212512016296387,
-0.19179606437683105,
-0.8154075145721436,
0.6875306963920593,
-0.7744386196136475,
-0.5266562700271606,
-0.16644711792469025,
-0.33024752140045166,
-0.47842374444007874,
0.09542946517467499,
0.24088476598262787,
0.4321088492870331,
-0.4451178312301636,
0.36655402183532715,
0.7828174233436584,
-0.45520877838134766,
0.38337281346321106,
0.8702834248542786,
-0.13370829820632935,
-0.008811775594949722,
1.313438892364502,
-0.029350651428103447,
0.058415982872247696,
0.44032391905784607,
0.40021055936813354,
-0.5292267203330994,
-0.7404376864433289,
-0.09542422741651535,
0.16912038624286652,
-0.8644738793373108,
-0.2343551218509674,
-0.3350640535354614,
-0.23087717592716217,
-0.10461736470460892,
0.11006084084510803,
-0.46289655566215515,
-0.19842398166656494,
-0.16168661415576935,
-0.21806885302066803,
0.23172630369663239,
0.8165377974510193,
-0.09638189524412155,
0.10268528014421463,
-0.5527963638305664,
0.3651978075504303,
0.38017889857292175,
0.3114267587661743,
0.23614852130413055,
-0.8110759854316711,
-0.2682020366191864,
0.1760185807943344,
-0.34775328636169434,
-0.6110362410545349,
0.3115442991256714,
0.037747323513031006,
0.7981778979301453,
0.7110562920570374,
0.17555858194828033,
0.749986469745636,
-0.4335823655128479,
0.39823246002197266,
0.12136279046535492,
-0.9813657999038696,
0.3987606465816498,
-0.3884151875972748,
0.06308259069919586,
0.4322900176048279,
0.3611708879470825,
-0.524804413318634,
-0.6654818058013916,
-0.6130363941192627,
-0.8352320194244385,
0.5992665886878967,
0.10451953113079071,
-0.03251109644770622,
0.03979723900556564,
0.4693666398525238,
0.05082579329609871,
0.4507022202014923,
-0.14006106555461884,
-0.3213805556297302,
-0.0564047172665596,
-0.06047407165169716,
-0.3561301827430725,
-0.25325921177864075,
-0.17204757034778595,
-0.4095941483974457,
0.4757692217826843,
0.16147664189338684,
0.25429147481918335,
-0.21110032498836517,
-0.3273991048336029,
-0.13250133395195007,
0.09481700509786606,
0.3327803611755371,
0.9506822824478149,
-0.3307555913925171,
0.1846848726272583,
0.10187572240829468,
-0.3337204158306122,
0.33431559801101685,
-0.07845840603113174,
-0.48379018902778625,
-0.17729847133159637,
0.41305315494537354,
0.5924829840660095,
0.4562409222126007,
-0.701140284538269,
0.5177793502807617,
-0.048622407019138336,
-0.03891046717762947,
-0.40544915199279785,
-0.09188370406627655,
0.18580138683319092,
0.07886120676994324,
0.19502995908260345,
-0.08157353103160858,
0.10395362973213196,
-0.5127532482147217,
0.48035141825675964,
0.5705233216285706,
-0.4818721413612366,
-0.6066725850105286,
0.49214011430740356,
0.1813092678785324,
0.060710396617650986,
0.6378456950187683,
-0.28540128469467163,
-0.38643187284469604,
0.48896685242652893,
0.39054760336875916,
0.9776357412338257,
-0.37197449803352356,
0.6247937679290771,
0.005705130752176046,
0.3411101698875427,
0.06123070791363716,
0.004598172381520271,
-0.10069756209850311,
-0.7667873501777649,
-0.21739085018634796,
-0.7320645451545715,
-0.33793947100639343,
0.5037769079208374,
-0.9343504309654236,
0.1323104351758957,
-0.5806224346160889,
0.388197124004364,
-0.030659282580018044,
-0.18146321177482605,
-0.7117206454277039,
0.03702211380004883,
0.01982942968606949,
0.6541658043861389,
-0.8673912882804871,
0.8060234785079956,
0.8448159098625183,
-0.45628881454467773,
-0.5195304751396179,
0.23397912085056305,
0.19034087657928467,
-1.060843825340271,
0.870572566986084,
-0.15983790159225464,
-0.21942512691020966,
-0.17741836607456207,
-0.20487232506275177,
-0.8088306188583374,
0.8633594512939453,
0.5120875835418701,
-0.4211903512477875,
0.027604345232248306,
0.24824519455432892,
0.6220187544822693,
0.1667776256799698,
0.24671506881713867,
0.6406930685043335,
0.16744615137577057,
0.1061515212059021,
-0.21690966188907623,
0.12555384635925293,
-0.17699162662029266,
-0.0501694455742836,
0.2672140896320343,
-0.5467373132705688,
0.8309536576271057,
-0.04410760477185249,
-0.32868626713752747,
-0.11447623372077942,
0.639891505241394,
0.05137546733021736,
0.021234920248389244,
0.33081698417663574,
0.6179075241088867,
0.8299843072891235,
0.10918679088354111,
0.7173964977264404,
-0.3329497277736664,
0.2626894414424896,
1.0623133182525635,
-0.0983552485704422,
0.8465701937675476,
0.39054951071739197,
-0.2686430513858795,
0.2666940689086914,
0.3163994252681732,
0.18108497560024261,
0.6291091442108154,
0.41636472940444946,
-0.22920218110084534,
-0.09263576567173004,
0.03322191163897514,
-0.13037599623203278,
0.7098546028137207,
0.47504696249961853,
-0.014785520732402802,
-0.5415098071098328,
-0.07800077646970749,
0.03837934508919716,
0.11912292242050171,
-0.2942896783351898,
0.6980152726173401,
0.07972440123558044,
-0.5134667754173279,
0.7429308891296387,
0.1273331195116043,
0.34333336353302,
-0.7051151990890503,
-0.050800174474716187,
-0.46237003803253174,
0.40799760818481445,
-0.04250183328986168,
-0.6109765768051147,
0.23140829801559448,
0.19324611127376556,
0.24024224281311035,
-0.20816084742546082,
0.5923052430152893,
-0.5452315807342529,
-0.48172831535339355,
0.585682213306427,
0.572177529335022,
-0.04741654172539711,
-0.12554796040058136,
-0.647639274597168,
-0.12508690357208252,
0.11091754585504532,
-0.19250670075416565,
0.5721330046653748,
0.49708354473114014,
-0.044550471007823944,
0.8809583187103271,
0.6676637530326843,
0.20615611970424652,
-0.05199648439884186,
0.12734343111515045,
1.1397404670715332,
-0.5482149124145508,
-0.2795216143131256,
-0.9093717932701111,
0.35276326537132263,
0.25868192315101624,
-0.3923643231391907,
1.0410943031311035,
0.5255904793739319,
1.0799165964126587,
0.22557862102985382,
0.8460208773612976,
0.30449244379997253,
0.5892670154571533,
-0.641086757183075,
0.6883483529090881,
-0.46183109283447266,
0.5337707996368408,
-0.3891112506389618,
-0.8378995060920715,
0.14620274305343628,
0.32530808448791504,
-0.1723800152540207,
-0.0679316520690918,
0.7191624641418457,
0.505205512046814,
-0.041656363755464554,
-0.1450808346271515,
0.41759681701660156,
0.15074458718299866,
0.2270738184452057,
0.34153228998184204,
1.2591540813446045,
-0.06426716595888138,
0.6369903087615967,
-0.5800237059593201,
-0.2727508246898651,
0.19777314364910126,
-0.6428349018096924,
-1.0159202814102173,
-0.777205765247345,
-0.4089936912059784,
-0.28280460834503174,
0.37841132283210754,
0.426506370306015,
0.12069202214479446,
-0.6771621704101562,
-0.38919779658317566,
-0.28371065855026245,
0.10861334204673767,
-0.14339065551757812,
-0.1799498051404953,
0.5552447438240051,
-0.4031526446342468,
-0.40613627433776855,
0.5439777970314026,
0.2301771491765976,
-0.11950401961803436,
-0.5757912397384644,
-0.22431452572345734,
-0.027335943654179573,
-0.13388575613498688,
0.5491800308227539,
0.3995549976825714,
-0.6181594133377075,
-0.26671111583709717,
-0.16960835456848145,
0.2986396849155426,
-0.2357322722673416,
0.8730303049087524,
-0.8425732851028442,
0.3195965588092804,
0.4397478699684143,
0.6123034358024597,
0.3581736087799072,
0.0792914479970932,
0.5305761694908142,
-1.0302882194519043,
0.15244434773921967,
-0.012164294719696045,
0.41900739073753357,
0.2771563231945038,
-0.12065579742193222,
0.28731393814086914,
0.2775011658668518,
-0.11637372523546219,
-1.0283229351043701,
0.02452535554766655,
-0.36117368936538696,
-0.47188180685043335,
1.3094260692596436,
-0.44764575362205505,
-0.21175678074359894,
-0.054097168147563934,
0.30851683020591736,
0.43304717540740967,
-0.26231735944747925,
0.7084659934043884,
0.5175907611846924,
0.05473249405622482,
0.07993204891681671,
-0.405063271522522,
0.49790728092193604,
0.3002607822418213,
-0.6503812074661255,
0.3189724385738373,
0.32501110434532166,
0.39505335688591003,
-0.06409663707017899,
0.3507966995239258,
-0.27832791209220886,
0.005725623574107885,
-0.17652200162410736,
0.18606828153133392,
-0.165370374917984,
-0.48182374238967896,
-0.6062542200088501,
-0.09193123131990433,
0.06681851297616959,
-0.49727872014045715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11598v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11598v1 | Understanding "Democratization" in NLP and ML Research | 2024-06-17T14:47:06 | 2024-06-17T14:47:06 | Arjun Subramonian, Vagrant Gautam, Dietrich Klakow, Zeerak Talat | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Recent improvements in natural language processing (NLP) and machine learning
(ML) and increased mainstream adoption have led to researchers frequently
discussing the "democratization" of artificial intelligence. In this paper, we
seek to clarify how democratization is understood in NLP and ML publications,
through large-scale mixed-methods analyses of papers using the keyword
"democra*" published in NLP and adjacent venues. We find that democratization
is most frequently used to convey (ease of) access to or use of technologies,
without meaningfully engaging with theories of democratization, while research
using other invocations of "democra*" tends to be grounded in theories of
deliberation and debate. Based on our findings, we call for researchers to
enrich their use of the term democratization with appropriate theory, towards
democratic technologies beyond superficial access. | [
-0.4600512981414795,
-0.8508410453796387,
0.2872650921344757,
-0.022715600207448006,
-0.3595319092273712,
0.1407749354839325,
-0.5067493319511414,
-0.423899382352829,
0.3874884247779846,
0.45155900716781616,
-0.19277970492839813,
-0.2246665507555008,
-0.5927462577819824,
0.24498938024044037,
-0.31934982538223267,
1.036317229270935,
0.02230941690504551,
0.24156875908374786,
-0.1687106192111969,
0.013018571771681309,
0.0463547557592392,
-0.8255994915962219,
0.005195348523557186,
-0.5700823664665222,
0.7828283905982971,
-0.044648196548223495,
0.9396715760231018,
0.5843586921691895,
0.8828201293945312,
0.34489497542381287,
-0.28203728795051575,
0.08204378932714462,
-0.06746070832014084,
0.09233428537845612,
0.05277906358242035,
-0.9105741381645203,
-0.2160722017288208,
0.41599905490875244,
0.6008034348487854,
0.7167187929153442,
-0.12485351413488388,
0.2680378556251526,
0.051525264978408813,
1.0937668085098267,
-0.9566698670387268,
0.19937697052955627,
-0.625460147857666,
0.17803052067756653,
-0.15119047462940216,
-0.3125956058502197,
-0.42938318848609924,
-0.519014835357666,
-0.08267545700073242,
-0.5510430932044983,
0.281765341758728,
-0.4691426753997803,
0.6264461874961853,
0.11242376267910004,
-0.38519638776779175,
-0.476199209690094,
-1.116806983947754,
0.5981079339981079,
-0.5037633180618286,
0.3188239336013794,
0.5081146359443665,
0.35215315222740173,
-0.0638638436794281,
-0.8904491662979126,
-0.9301736354827881,
-0.13609769940376282,
0.09389283508062363,
0.029757274314761162,
-0.3372495174407959,
0.2240656316280365,
0.2656576633453369,
0.017319105565547943,
-0.27058595418930054,
-0.0951261967420578,
-0.7442086338996887,
-0.19585253298282623,
0.5157382488250732,
-0.22233416140079498,
0.25269392132759094,
-0.2600437104701996,
-0.29585719108581543,
0.02222449518740177,
-0.38518035411834717,
0.20926012098789215,
0.5821588635444641,
0.633216142654419,
0.09909768402576447,
0.9814102053642273,
0.004583362489938736,
0.8699875473976135,
-0.28795644640922546,
0.18970392644405365,
0.27870306372642517,
-0.8840999603271484,
-0.5205945372581482,
-0.11717855930328369,
0.5202078223228455,
0.10239435732364655,
0.23861578106880188,
-0.26631787419319153,
-0.048170555382966995,
0.26387280225753784,
0.6505493521690369,
-0.6420150995254517,
-0.07810159027576447,
0.3463122546672821,
-0.8268851041793823,
-0.04955601319670677,
0.5038971304893494,
-0.533779501914978,
-0.607087254524231,
-0.7219805717468262,
0.02563854493200779,
0.0026003685779869556,
-0.37047815322875977,
0.2334805727005005,
-0.47200652956962585,
0.08114355057477951,
0.40592360496520996,
-0.5967658758163452,
0.18403498828411102,
1.2099658250808716,
0.9228857755661011,
-0.027105214074254036,
0.056237075477838516,
-0.06858951598405838,
-0.2055535912513733,
-0.46874096989631653,
0.7669457197189331,
-0.6755640506744385,
-0.3272259533405304,
0.3523838520050049,
-0.20642241835594177,
-0.2872138023376465,
-0.692082941532135,
0.3555942177772522,
-0.7659068703651428,
0.47806844115257263,
-0.22778211534023285,
-0.3019166886806488,
-0.6488533616065979,
0.3225248456001282,
-0.6961449980735779,
0.5616374611854553,
-0.22364987432956696,
-1.0300078392028809,
0.7698439955711365,
-0.7051278948783875,
-0.14731237292289734,
-0.16075386106967926,
-0.03413867577910423,
-0.08177856355905533,
0.3020324409008026,
-0.2516355812549591,
0.3965315818786621,
0.23761118948459625,
0.5243062376976013,
-0.2561492621898651,
-0.27418139576911926,
0.4446193277835846,
-0.08849116414785385,
1.1240414381027222,
0.1741112470626831,
-0.29147064685821533,
0.3842896521091461,
-0.5807446837425232,
-0.18131430447101593,
-0.27078625559806824,
-0.15260683000087738,
-0.4846755266189575,
0.2482886165380478,
0.09698843210935593,
0.22458195686340332,
0.32786262035369873,
-0.5420216917991638,
0.2823027968406677,
-0.5014783143997192,
0.4918486475944519,
0.7163034081459045,
-0.3328646123409271,
1.0276917219161987,
-0.3545733094215393,
0.5031634569168091,
-0.0629192516207695,
0.3542890250682831,
0.15571510791778564,
-0.6181215643882751,
-0.7061184048652649,
-0.41458630561828613,
0.4800594747066498,
0.5996432304382324,
-0.45964789390563965,
0.5502364635467529,
0.013399947434663773,
-0.5086331367492676,
-0.6613031625747681,
-0.0774097666144371,
-0.529498815536499,
0.09513963013887405,
0.3158639371395111,
-0.15405309200286865,
-0.7309001088142395,
-1.103668212890625,
-0.3525669276714325,
-0.4611998498439789,
0.11147496104240417,
0.26753532886505127,
0.71181720495224,
-0.4949381947517395,
1.087543249130249,
0.24900682270526886,
-0.3798566162586212,
-0.17056436836719513,
0.23900820314884186,
0.23126846551895142,
0.11417971551418304,
-0.10678140819072723,
-1.0685981512069702,
-0.0029062468092888594,
0.2241421788930893,
-0.6210566163063049,
0.2514789402484894,
-0.374390184879303,
0.20543172955513,
0.038205210119485855,
0.24305950105190277,
-0.48271289467811584,
0.5047081708908081,
0.4362783133983612,
-0.26084041595458984,
0.368800550699234,
-0.1880253404378891,
0.2649349868297577,
-1.0162018537521362,
0.18912622332572937,
0.06336986273527145,
-0.11673025041818619,
-0.7338042855262756,
0.29218921065330505,
-0.21555012464523315,
-0.0009997185552492738,
-0.27897483110427856,
0.266912579536438,
-0.3573923110961914,
0.09259063750505447,
-0.6416440606117249,
0.503017783164978,
-0.28763318061828613,
-0.30534446239471436,
-0.06155276671051979,
0.8100588321685791,
0.13878995180130005,
-0.3866637051105499,
0.15635396540164948,
-0.17500770092010498,
-0.18115445971488953,
-0.011114420369267464,
-0.5845525860786438,
0.1430935263633728,
-0.2471977323293686,
0.4817622900009155,
-0.6919710040092468,
0.15200376510620117,
0.32439249753952026,
-0.391010582447052,
-0.3181738555431366,
0.0897517129778862,
-0.4872255325317383,
-0.02060113102197647,
-0.4893535077571869,
0.26656654477119446,
0.34410369396209717,
-0.22506840527057648,
0.7942226529121399,
0.7852472066879272,
-0.05092345178127289,
-0.7562692165374756,
-0.3824726641178131,
0.3174217939376831,
-0.20178265869617462,
-0.7023491859436035,
0.17289672791957855,
0.24468089640140533,
-1.0343295335769653,
-0.17326022684574127,
0.31149742007255554,
-0.43632423877716064,
0.23625648021697998,
0.3061414659023285,
0.17236146330833435,
-0.13039176166057587,
0.2017054259777069,
-0.16618125140666962,
-0.05711757391691208,
0.17762528359889984,
0.22070392966270447,
0.45784875750541687,
0.21252363920211792,
-0.051481276750564575,
-0.8479642868041992,
0.2786199152469635,
0.15988631546497345,
-0.07060527801513672,
0.7197884917259216,
0.6689371466636658,
-0.08582834154367447,
-0.3014066815376282,
-0.3872954547405243,
-0.5439248085021973,
-0.37818023562431335,
0.20228980481624603,
0.025783482939004898,
-0.900080680847168,
0.6704965829849243,
-0.2945840358734131,
0.2984863519668579,
0.4245155453681946,
0.6144856810569763,
-0.24177473783493042,
0.6642746925354004,
0.8175763487815857,
0.05480707809329033,
0.5424339771270752,
-0.30911657214164734,
0.5459228157997131,
-0.6175605654716492,
-0.423750102519989,
-1.266503930091858,
-0.38828760385513306,
-1.0311286449432373,
-0.8086702227592468,
-0.23041385412216187,
-0.12230872362852097,
-0.1567748636007309,
0.19563554227352142,
-0.7151458859443665,
0.18017533421516418,
0.6976608633995056,
0.032992713153362274,
0.506716251373291,
0.017696944996714592,
0.7576437592506409,
-0.142038494348526,
-0.6494576930999756,
-0.7666193842887878,
0.957207202911377,
0.2537347674369812,
0.47543206810951233,
-0.24035906791687012,
1.0657597780227661,
0.6212108731269836,
0.14185479283332825,
-0.883586049079895,
0.5016882419586182,
-0.05825217068195343,
-0.6236975193023682,
-0.02035038359463215,
-0.3028363287448883,
-1.14085853099823,
0.30857616662979126,
-0.47812697291374207,
-0.4513402581214905,
0.663499653339386,
-0.2387160211801529,
0.1339813619852066,
0.4553920030593872,
-0.45613744854927063,
0.4295646548271179,
0.3107149600982666,
0.1286773383617401,
-0.6789958477020264,
-0.4688142240047455,
0.25656118988990784,
0.278408408164978,
0.5643081665039062,
0.06822986155748367,
-0.36933252215385437,
1.144970417022705,
0.19264669716358185,
0.8998638391494751,
-0.28303083777427673,
0.03560258075594902,
0.36067599058151245,
-0.15137313306331635,
0.3622508645057678,
-0.28651076555252075,
-0.06863768398761749,
0.4556959271430969,
-0.08587217330932617,
-0.42111504077911377,
-0.6940588355064392,
0.3640058636665344,
-0.7539938688278198,
-0.4323488771915436,
-0.6334649324417114,
-0.5541025400161743,
0.2645816206932068,
-0.018256593495607376,
-0.09391468018293381,
-0.11751216650009155,
-0.37636029720306396,
0.4246498942375183,
0.44006773829460144,
0.23381875455379486,
0.42488807439804077,
-0.08834465593099594,
-0.21516522765159607,
-0.1620648354291916,
0.8485738039016724,
0.5654993653297424,
-0.24331070482730865,
-0.062008801847696304,
0.06678439676761627,
-0.23854559659957886,
-0.616862952709198,
-0.18461844325065613,
0.2732452154159546,
-0.49039962887763977,
0.24825581908226013,
-0.6752460598945618,
0.012608056887984276,
-0.1157379224896431,
-0.18901807069778442,
-0.27562135457992554,
-0.8167005777359009,
-0.7789884805679321,
-0.07859699428081512,
-0.293609619140625,
0.9240613579750061,
-0.11601585149765015,
0.06753440201282501,
-0.3805799186229706,
0.468015193939209,
0.061887145042419434,
-0.1350637823343277,
-0.11671725660562515,
-0.4611756503582001,
-0.25289714336395264,
0.19205598533153534,
-0.2177889049053192,
-0.9198865294456482,
-0.01277795247733593,
-0.039922021329402924,
0.3868798613548279,
0.23574787378311157,
0.09771101921796799,
0.4054918885231018,
-0.4378211200237274,
1.2666664123535156,
0.17801012098789215,
-0.7427176237106323,
0.3536826968193054,
-0.15195660293102264,
-0.3394366502761841,
0.64559006690979,
0.3271051347255707,
-0.35383471846580505,
-0.5199135541915894,
-0.8523932695388794,
-0.9561598300933838,
0.040959082543849945,
-0.0171348936855793,
0.8084813356399536,
0.14494378864765167,
-0.0056042843498289585,
0.5744602084159851,
0.4598470628261566,
-0.7051076292991638,
-0.1408657431602478,
-0.147201269865036,
0.09445665031671524,
0.03226672485470772,
-0.23409532010555267,
-0.5726115703582764,
-0.10621212422847748,
0.7000247836112976,
-0.11431854218244553,
0.16559332609176636,
0.24569272994995117,
0.023631906136870384,
0.09741770476102829,
0.47320258617401123,
0.4861627519130707,
1.204237937927246,
-0.02435344271361828,
0.10321022570133209,
-0.7527129650115967,
-0.4206515848636627,
0.1259838193655014,
0.1804247349500656,
-0.7353475689888,
0.15760864317417145,
0.49350738525390625,
0.4484896957874298,
-0.5540439486503601,
-0.2613641619682312,
0.3312165439128876,
0.1782054305076599,
-0.27326101064682007,
-0.11500288546085358,
0.22381587326526642,
-0.268500417470932,
0.38567671179771423,
0.7166805267333984,
0.3571573495864868,
0.43137454986572266,
-0.6903020143508911,
0.24693597853183746,
0.8057287931442261,
-0.4393274784088135,
-0.4225265383720398,
0.1797206699848175,
0.41131144762039185,
-0.7033774852752686,
0.43230634927749634,
0.11652238667011261,
-0.21214550733566284,
0.6478266716003418,
0.3528197407722473,
1.1186463832855225,
0.2606239914894104,
0.8389388918876648,
0.19503602385520935,
0.7658552527427673,
0.059637632220983505,
0.310634970664978,
-0.34037333726882935,
-0.8100077509880066,
-0.6768141388893127,
-0.19132591784000397,
-0.4734634757041931,
-0.37468472123146057,
-0.8211456537246704,
-0.11844534426927567,
-0.24884195625782013,
-0.8701629638671875,
0.08855169266462326,
0.2582258880138397,
-0.3436058759689331,
-0.12543903291225433,
0.004737411625683308,
1.0374659299850464,
-1.0711749792099,
0.4306734502315521,
0.6684024930000305,
-0.1411866396665573,
-0.19245953857898712,
0.1211375966668129,
-0.16757923364639282,
-0.39303871989250183,
0.6534820199012756,
0.040622271597385406,
0.0052674151957035065,
-0.5154315829277039,
-0.503663182258606,
-0.025515535846352577,
0.6156756281852722,
0.3411250710487366,
-0.2206708788871765,
0.043216001242399216,
-0.10791318863630295,
0.5941717624664307,
-0.16802483797073364,
0.19044943153858185,
0.4036197364330292,
0.8449685573577881,
-0.7139887809753418,
-0.8367523550987244,
-0.30529671907424927,
-0.05983263999223709,
-0.1755443960428238,
0.09810984134674072,
-0.48540496826171875,
0.6123543381690979,
-0.3889950215816498,
-0.2790459394454956,
-0.26114559173583984,
1.1040902137756348,
-0.10547398775815964,
0.911284327507019,
0.31293681263923645,
0.0383104644715786,
0.7830636501312256,
-0.17512893676757812,
0.8182327747344971,
0.12116077542304993,
0.3211424648761749,
0.7595295310020447,
0.02051311358809471,
0.7325125336647034,
0.9889319539070129,
-0.5379371047019958,
0.6798126101493835,
0.69488924741745,
0.24891115725040436,
0.27003422379493713,
0.310448557138443,
-0.32165926694869995,
-0.08102518320083618,
-0.4659806191921234,
-0.29507386684417725,
0.6513960957527161,
-0.1320793777704239,
-0.45861566066741943,
-0.2016465812921524,
0.19855813682079315,
-0.1301988959312439,
0.6134848594665527,
-0.2221403867006302,
1.2119652032852173,
-0.09977038949728012,
-0.2893947958946228,
0.21234238147735596,
-0.13987132906913757,
0.6739309430122375,
-0.4859936535358429,
-0.22988204658031464,
0.08677569776773453,
-0.4108366072177887,
-0.3314582109451294,
-0.6912601590156555,
0.517614483833313,
0.03220358490943909,
-0.5946685075759888,
-0.14584973454475403,
0.5173423886299133,
-0.040357619524002075,
-0.5484814643859863,
0.44233956933021545,
0.868851363658905,
-0.02080339379608631,
-0.0048458511009812355,
-0.9284458756446838,
0.1762584149837494,
0.10002954304218292,
-0.4057668149471283,
0.4549477696418762,
0.20312930643558502,
0.09529590606689453,
0.6000511050224304,
0.7363448739051819,
0.6811187267303467,
-0.027744097635149956,
0.01875568926334381,
0.929728627204895,
-0.4338609576225281,
-0.2825416922569275,
-0.9166876673698425,
0.5398834943771362,
-0.1232474148273468,
-0.17301809787750244,
0.8194521069526672,
0.5738620758056641,
0.7251203656196594,
0.31997838616371155,
0.8519734740257263,
-0.2304353415966034,
0.12123139947652817,
-0.26209235191345215,
0.6101462244987488,
-0.40098094940185547,
-0.018363842740654945,
0.0015480390284210443,
-0.948491096496582,
-0.49696511030197144,
0.8053379058837891,
-0.29527464509010315,
0.07056967169046402,
0.29184436798095703,
0.5685397982597351,
-0.04949957877397537,
0.33867818117141724,
-0.1354532092809677,
0.14972108602523804,
0.1721714437007904,
-0.3854062855243683,
0.7789763808250427,
-0.16753406822681427,
-0.009146991185843945,
-0.6545552015304565,
-0.32602551579475403,
-0.021781424060463905,
-0.6121992468833923,
-0.7443773746490479,
-1.1209018230438232,
-0.12503068149089813,
-0.6383283138275146,
0.2859913110733032,
0.7572795748710632,
0.6238660216331482,
-0.5884830951690674,
-0.5213271975517273,
0.2835589647293091,
0.505946159362793,
-0.32261690497398376,
-0.23822006583213806,
0.4128178358078003,
-0.5078455209732056,
-0.8249858617782593,
0.24945509433746338,
0.2278614491224289,
-0.570773184299469,
-0.7147960066795349,
0.37061527371406555,
-0.1939709186553955,
0.31510064005851746,
0.48139888048171997,
0.04412765055894852,
-0.669877827167511,
-0.12626904249191284,
0.07433957606554031,
0.02418646216392517,
0.21106912195682526,
1.2489339113235474,
-0.9002453088760376,
0.9094971418380737,
0.8053368330001831,
0.5522400140762329,
-0.06559969484806061,
0.3394266664981842,
0.4093157947063446,
0.0563216507434845,
0.3953375816345215,
0.7743614912033081,
-0.15925273299217224,
0.4397285580635071,
-0.11974018812179565,
0.5741636157035828,
0.14638851583003998,
-0.6482558846473694,
-1.1941150426864624,
0.25426697731018066,
-0.9299263954162598,
-0.35570526123046875,
1.0084885358810425,
0.12171729654073715,
-0.3721448481082916,
-0.4373788833618164,
-0.2363252490758896,
0.20082534849643707,
-0.4028322398662567,
1.2363425493240356,
0.5550984740257263,
-0.13169747591018677,
0.13490229845046997,
-0.60872882604599,
0.3789897561073303,
-0.14247728884220123,
-0.6616905331611633,
0.16484558582305908,
0.32491394877433777,
-0.35134634375572205,
0.5337886810302734,
0.6782531142234802,
-0.03874361515045166,
0.35291075706481934,
-0.22417862713336945,
-0.09110208600759506,
-0.024974405765533447,
-0.52321857213974,
-0.31435489654541016,
0.5723791718482971,
-0.13773532211780548,
-0.07457657158374786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11581v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11581v1 | Style Transfer with Multi-iteration Preference Optimization | 2024-06-17T14:20:53 | 2024-06-17T14:20:53 | Shuai Liu, Jonathan May | cs.CL | cs.CL | Numerous recent techniques for text style transfer characterize their
approaches as variants of reinforcement learning and preference optimization.
In this work, we consider the relationship between these approaches and a class
of optimization approaches developed primarily for (non-neural) statistical
machine translation, formerly known as 'tuning'. Inspired by these techniques
from the past, we improve upon established preference optimization approaches,
incorporating multiple iterations of exploration and optimization, and choosing
contrastive examples by following a 'hope' vs 'fear' sampling strategy.
Cognizant of the difference between machine translation and style transfer,
however, we further tailor our framework with a new pseudo-parallel generation
method and a dynamic weighted reward aggregation method to tackle the lack of
parallel data and the need for a multi-objective reward. We evaluate our model
on two commonly used text style transfer datasets. Through automatic and human
evaluation results we show the effectiveness and the superiority of our model
compared to state-of-the-art baselines. | [
-0.3414548337459564,
-0.5233113169670105,
0.5413925051689148,
0.3303770124912262,
-0.24319875240325928,
0.174852192401886,
-0.6515756845474243,
-0.16341771185398102,
0.3847191333770752,
0.29054221510887146,
-0.7071111798286438,
-0.10360690206289291,
-0.7383221387863159,
0.3640199303627014,
-0.2580573558807373,
1.2762415409088135,
-0.3731771409511566,
-0.06769930571317673,
-0.0361667275428772,
-0.15250593423843384,
-0.5961503386497498,
-0.482144296169281,
-0.7580567002296448,
-0.35937297344207764,
0.6254404783248901,
0.6933359503746033,
0.5087887644767761,
0.5075082778930664,
0.6750702261924744,
0.31221070885658264,
0.2573675513267517,
0.39424893260002136,
-0.7199814319610596,
0.13141952455043793,
-0.23584908246994019,
-0.4506423771381378,
-0.2713738679885864,
0.16567817330360413,
0.4110408425331116,
0.20729820430278778,
-0.025957481935620308,
0.19521261751651764,
-0.1284993439912796,
1.0815389156341553,
-0.5910022258758545,
0.01566956378519535,
-0.6847658157348633,
0.09161803871393204,
-0.21211455762386322,
-0.6041067838668823,
-0.4560830891132355,
-0.5667245984077454,
0.20218287408351898,
-0.6645826101303101,
-0.08337219059467316,
0.2555903196334839,
0.608464241027832,
0.23346498608589172,
-0.4167451560497284,
-0.39332178235054016,
-0.6489269733428955,
1.2879987955093384,
-0.23715567588806152,
0.11278866976499557,
0.28752681612968445,
0.36606523394584656,
0.201747864484787,
-0.6388619542121887,
-0.5129761695861816,
-0.27082204818725586,
-0.0218700859695673,
0.14106690883636475,
-0.04077760502696037,
-0.2813454866409302,
-0.2078305035829544,
0.27657902240753174,
-0.447536438703537,
-0.12788331508636475,
-0.25910505652427673,
-0.025616256520152092,
0.7412942051887512,
0.041073452681303024,
0.18737393617630005,
-0.089339978992939,
-0.5240653157234192,
-0.6387041211128235,
-0.24108704924583435,
0.1761734038591385,
0.3130929172039032,
0.30509668588638306,
-0.12527504563331604,
0.3369111716747284,
-0.20183610916137695,
0.6210254430770874,
0.18459807336330414,
-0.3230358958244324,
0.49074888229370117,
-0.6655569672584534,
0.20809756219387054,
0.06763456016778946,
0.830013632774353,
0.7957987189292908,
0.5944250822067261,
-0.347215861082077,
-0.3083491623401642,
-0.0712638720870018,
0.6499795913696289,
-0.6185230612754822,
-0.224225714802742,
-0.12510335445404053,
-0.8574904203414917,
-0.8237406611442566,
-0.022288653999567032,
-1.1607837677001953,
0.020301541313529015,
-0.7978391051292419,
0.5127554535865784,
-0.3743360638618469,
-0.061396997421979904,
0.2043023407459259,
-0.27578502893447876,
0.006018933840095997,
0.13713550567626953,
-1.1936925649642944,
0.13360582292079926,
0.12188807874917984,
1.0032228231430054,
-0.8228360414505005,
-0.2066367119550705,
-0.3161742687225342,
-0.003907412756234407,
-0.4796229600906372,
0.8780851364135742,
-0.6182222366333008,
-0.506774365901947,
-0.16382116079330444,
-0.11453364789485931,
-0.26136305928230286,
-0.3253163695335388,
0.5900403261184692,
-0.3203260600566864,
0.1964075267314911,
-0.3835810720920563,
-0.17612309753894806,
0.09049597382545471,
-0.029464293271303177,
-0.43503764271736145,
1.0584022998809814,
0.2903490960597992,
-0.4891130328178406,
0.35887157917022705,
-0.8774423003196716,
-0.6371676325798035,
-0.3842163681983948,
0.2946813702583313,
-0.6676346659660339,
0.2150619775056839,
0.27823925018310547,
0.08955402672290802,
-0.210542693734169,
0.03253708407282829,
-0.5022160410881042,
-0.4612768590450287,
0.3210330307483673,
-0.03756790608167648,
0.17148934304714203,
0.6412156224250793,
-0.391390323638916,
0.43781235814094543,
-0.44050687551498413,
0.09153129905462265,
0.2878563106060028,
-0.096623994410038,
-0.49331629276275635,
-0.09661202132701874,
0.14909689128398895,
0.20940877497196198,
0.3781038820743561,
-0.12810660898685455,
0.4851982593536377,
0.0016986837144941092,
0.48062875866889954,
0.9593899846076965,
-0.05263941362500191,
0.8388343453407288,
-0.6825613975524902,
0.5231115221977234,
-0.34075939655303955,
0.2804248034954071,
0.0859891027212143,
-0.059129998087882996,
-0.807806134223938,
0.03500087186694145,
0.22495388984680176,
0.5821251273155212,
-0.9271025657653809,
0.18282228708267212,
-0.2009248435497284,
-0.49730661511421204,
-0.5165226459503174,
-0.07495204359292984,
0.31737062335014343,
0.41555437445640564,
0.793860673904419,
-0.2904854416847229,
-0.3730083107948303,
-0.8718996047973633,
-0.6074531078338623,
0.007253918331116438,
0.23127755522727966,
0.4938786029815674,
0.14733664691448212,
-0.02926558628678322,
0.4717615842819214,
-0.562093198299408,
-0.053233928978443146,
-0.3115948736667633,
0.5419641733169556,
0.1452646404504776,
0.5062471628189087,
1.0599812269210815,
-0.8067730069160461,
-0.7338945865631104,
0.04502662643790245,
-0.4795481860637665,
-0.13536575436592102,
-0.41818758845329285,
-0.5070126056671143,
0.08245785534381866,
0.4406905174255371,
0.0495588444173336,
0.10016471892595291,
0.5342459678649902,
0.20801995694637299,
0.6040385961532593,
-0.0668126717209816,
0.5917527675628662,
-1.1831250190734863,
0.040275681763887405,
0.1036519706249237,
-0.15001161396503448,
-0.5823822617530823,
-0.22478927671909332,
0.11820372194051743,
0.15685142576694489,
-0.2968261241912842,
0.6590158343315125,
-0.26331132650375366,
0.10325992852449417,
-0.5026307106018066,
-0.2681633234024048,
-0.0048400335945189,
0.6845137476921082,
0.03682810440659523,
1.0100789070129395,
0.4564099609851837,
-0.5081968307495117,
0.4030667543411255,
0.1952846348285675,
-0.14517821371555328,
0.884148359298706,
-0.40009447932243347,
0.6885783076286316,
-0.14330986142158508,
-0.004979107994586229,
-0.9575604796409607,
0.16138359904289246,
0.2271525114774704,
-0.23880167305469513,
0.43057331442832947,
-0.07437296956777573,
-0.2583478093147278,
-0.31654027104377747,
-0.4570308327674866,
0.30274686217308044,
0.5479846596717834,
-0.4362305998802185,
0.016873972490429878,
0.0994250476360321,
-0.46522292494773865,
-0.4248236119747162,
-0.423372358083725,
0.08323480188846588,
-0.7332226037979126,
-0.24924108386039734,
0.7798470854759216,
-0.32191935181617737,
-0.13368955254554749,
-0.20204651355743408,
-0.21631430089473724,
0.07709150016307831,
0.07246910780668259,
-0.47690480947494507,
0.40223515033721924,
-0.12386706471443176,
-0.09917066991329193,
0.3522903621196747,
-0.09019870311021805,
-0.2780628800392151,
-0.6152195334434509,
0.46819981932640076,
-0.11612042039632797,
-0.023919345811009407,
-0.293886661529541,
0.3749781548976898,
0.4070397913455963,
-0.27522847056388855,
0.7008085250854492,
0.7691757678985596,
0.2508469223976135,
-0.24608929455280304,
-0.3117753267288208,
-0.28473713994026184,
-0.5141016244888306,
0.3452354073524475,
-0.5485455989837646,
-0.6605176329612732,
0.005325654987245798,
-0.2837318778038025,
-0.008217945694923401,
0.3090794086456299,
0.5615832209587097,
-0.2162286937236786,
0.9982510805130005,
0.8307293057441711,
-0.227581188082695,
1.0811303853988647,
0.05599251016974449,
0.037855785340070724,
-0.4975135326385498,
-0.06280092895030975,
-0.7278395891189575,
-0.7457830905914307,
-0.8908199071884155,
-0.11175276339054108,
0.5100451111793518,
0.040717557072639465,
-0.07237744331359863,
0.5388895273208618,
-0.5291037559509277,
0.3835349977016449,
0.7193397879600525,
0.1274569034576416,
0.14179247617721558,
0.3662393093109131,
-0.06221572309732437,
-0.1333983838558197,
-0.4848848283290863,
-0.30548951029777527,
1.3219492435455322,
-0.162986159324646,
0.6774633526802063,
0.1259511113166809,
0.7481274604797363,
0.3312092423439026,
0.2354498952627182,
-0.929797887802124,
0.1616695374250412,
-0.5331443548202515,
0.15465214848518372,
-0.40800854563713074,
-0.6175717711448669,
-0.9714202880859375,
0.11535827815532684,
-0.3080019950866699,
-0.5889858603477478,
0.2772925794124603,
0.2340201735496521,
0.1738361120223999,
0.07711393386125565,
-0.5660764575004578,
0.7820364832878113,
-0.45836466550827026,
-0.43056949973106384,
-0.3138975501060486,
-0.7412981986999512,
0.21730712056159973,
-0.38407257199287415,
0.1290585845708847,
0.16579200327396393,
0.1137656643986702,
0.56758052110672,
0.037565506994724274,
0.06934238225221634,
0.2755950093269348,
0.15752670168876648,
-0.07598806917667389,
0.05878771096467972,
0.6415547728538513,
-0.29190558195114136,
-0.4201696515083313,
0.006099896039813757,
-0.025226233527064323,
-0.26510995626449585,
-0.7343444228172302,
0.4581930339336395,
-0.7771502733230591,
-0.16611482203006744,
-0.11926078796386719,
-0.7579840421676636,
-0.4233148396015167,
0.3933071792125702,
0.24957303702831268,
0.15292644500732422,
-0.03583915904164314,
0.17795178294181824,
0.3799530565738678,
-0.23046432435512543,
0.46531325578689575,
0.1445322036743164,
-0.07270605862140656,
-0.5006995797157288,
1.1711080074310303,
-0.08424479514360428,
0.42399701476097107,
0.48066210746765137,
0.45338159799575806,
-0.5449179410934448,
-0.5798013806343079,
-0.7315089106559753,
0.05696330964565277,
-0.21334637701511383,
0.062241081148386,
-0.3956063389778137,
0.07970019429922104,
-0.56136554479599,
-0.4617118537425995,
-0.26255711913108826,
-0.3867854177951813,
-0.24428273737430573,
0.17442773282527924,
0.5454213619232178,
0.5517010688781738,
0.07749148458242416,
0.3415612578392029,
-0.5858197808265686,
0.5010982155799866,
0.16873390972614288,
0.19265489280223846,
-0.31588777899742126,
-0.5767242312431335,
-0.23813660442829132,
-0.21479302644729614,
-0.49789583683013916,
-1.0099021196365356,
0.6721464991569519,
0.0964205414056778,
0.47897350788116455,
0.1210358738899231,
0.23893964290618896,
0.5957451462745667,
-0.5592359304428101,
0.40183761715888977,
0.311923623085022,
-0.6677227020263672,
0.4357307553291321,
-0.27063417434692383,
0.04839036986231804,
1.0021625757217407,
0.4881262481212616,
-0.7142463326454163,
-0.01718808338046074,
-0.4480016529560089,
-0.8236082792282104,
0.7451211214065552,
0.2722892463207245,
0.09638229012489319,
0.13461406528949738,
0.4137154817581177,
0.10519332438707352,
0.6842517852783203,
-0.38282984495162964,
-0.3911992013454437,
-0.5613104701042175,
-0.28604820370674133,
-0.38017669320106506,
0.1594407707452774,
-0.07235359400510788,
-0.14059725403785706,
0.4854893088340759,
-0.3882262706756592,
0.44253024458885193,
-0.15573646128177643,
-0.14961199462413788,
0.07032076269388199,
0.3707354664802551,
0.7014114260673523,
0.39360547065734863,
-0.18362484872341156,
-0.0743829682469368,
-0.011273125186562538,
-0.19276022911071777,
0.18303270637989044,
0.018772469833493233,
-0.1264294534921646,
-0.10011698305606842,
-0.24100714921951294,
1.2719980478286743,
0.0076675196178257465,
-0.12160225212574005,
0.3293530344963074,
0.00420520780608058,
-0.24796998500823975,
0.05180242657661438,
0.026167258620262146,
-0.260789155960083,
0.011772731319069862,
0.04104533791542053,
0.4045536518096924,
0.41809993982315063,
-0.5222669839859009,
0.2789875566959381,
0.36019763350486755,
-0.3472670018672943,
-0.034409090876579285,
0.4921448826789856,
-0.055798742920160294,
-0.3689541220664978,
0.36080121994018555,
-0.15169601142406464,
-0.34684738516807556,
0.5121657848358154,
0.6204280257225037,
0.8957898616790771,
-0.11721983551979065,
0.3468146324157715,
0.3762844502925873,
0.17430181801319122,
-0.3400115966796875,
0.2093931883573532,
-0.2217107117176056,
-0.6660827398300171,
-0.39051222801208496,
-0.8274844884872437,
-0.5696614384651184,
-0.08617164939641953,
-0.8425620198249817,
0.5761119723320007,
-0.07233328372240067,
-0.10763300955295563,
-0.22177153825759888,
-0.22762839496135712,
-0.5580747127532959,
-0.00622759060934186,
-0.11645685881376266,
0.5010551810264587,
-0.8635898232460022,
0.8346462845802307,
0.8236966133117676,
-0.4143768846988678,
-0.701228678226471,
0.27591758966445923,
-0.012645360082387924,
-0.8494439125061035,
0.3642139136791229,
0.02043270692229271,
-0.29404085874557495,
0.2598550021648407,
-0.1968005895614624,
-0.9730427861213684,
0.6903554201126099,
0.3212664723396301,
-0.47290369868278503,
-0.06957772374153137,
-0.19142958521842957,
0.4589482545852661,
-0.2292836606502533,
0.2042464315891266,
0.7154093384742737,
0.7594004273414612,
0.14180420339107513,
-0.9385693073272705,
-0.20983217656612396,
-0.28078508377075195,
0.165140762925148,
0.22000165283679962,
-0.9090964794158936,
0.6148346066474915,
0.07536555081605911,
0.18461565673351288,
0.25636422634124756,
0.5192060470581055,
0.26062092185020447,
0.23603948950767517,
0.551386833190918,
0.18517979979515076,
0.5449305176734924,
-0.00754169374704361,
1.2552769184112549,
-0.4306352734565735,
0.38829874992370605,
0.8002933859825134,
-0.04313367232680321,
0.5433276295661926,
0.6486270427703857,
-0.2919716536998749,
0.5467447638511658,
0.7596173286437988,
-0.029828302562236786,
0.8862727880477905,
0.2902328670024872,
0.15541526675224304,
-0.045605164021253586,
-0.21893903613090515,
-0.347469300031662,
0.41246137022972107,
-0.060636620968580246,
-0.4330337643623352,
0.1630835086107254,
-0.041294265538454056,
0.15803903341293335,
0.1879630833864212,
-0.14958259463310242,
0.970088541507721,
0.0417901836335659,
-1.0214289426803589,
0.7163436412811279,
0.2601606249809265,
0.917695939540863,
-0.6020523905754089,
-0.05147301405668259,
-0.35902994871139526,
-0.08786104619503021,
0.13038671016693115,
-0.4628784656524658,
0.2885933518409729,
-0.19648633897304535,
-0.2143905609846115,
-0.9041290879249573,
0.638818621635437,
-0.5193774104118347,
-0.5049352049827576,
0.1026110053062439,
0.3438072204589844,
0.28654536604881287,
0.10731792449951172,
-0.9082217812538147,
-0.11932937055826187,
0.07781397551298141,
-0.25957509875297546,
0.6441494822502136,
0.2835366427898407,
-0.2413412183523178,
0.285241037607193,
0.840107798576355,
0.36423584818840027,
-0.0661439597606659,
0.11531823128461838,
0.5151142477989197,
-0.46129611134529114,
-0.6156421899795532,
-0.8440266847610474,
0.15782302618026733,
-0.10149498283863068,
-0.3336580991744995,
0.5608288645744324,
0.2725474238395691,
0.7445887327194214,
-0.14424261450767517,
0.8310994505882263,
0.2596796154975891,
0.26174235343933105,
-0.8365478515625,
0.5085219740867615,
-0.8751702904701233,
-0.1811666339635849,
-0.8529306650161743,
-1.0288960933685303,
0.008094764314591885,
0.7661654949188232,
-0.3767848312854767,
0.1917794942855835,
0.9699371457099915,
0.5497720837593079,
-0.03752019256353378,
-0.08239425718784332,
0.08589670807123184,
-0.41587695479393005,
-0.08891125023365021,
0.558920681476593,
0.5376794934272766,
0.02468315325677395,
0.5153733491897583,
-0.3820534944534302,
-0.45751896500587463,
-0.3039374351501465,
-0.9404031038284302,
-0.4121171832084656,
-0.5346352458000183,
-0.07806762307882309,
-0.29517510533332825,
0.23285239934921265,
0.9115181565284729,
0.8308504819869995,
-0.7156881093978882,
-0.43320780992507935,
0.04768463596701622,
0.016711443662643433,
-0.5419929623603821,
-0.1700086146593094,
0.35667452216148376,
-0.793268084526062,
-1.1539946794509888,
0.5827502608299255,
0.23848406970500946,
0.04796210676431656,
0.02526603825390339,
0.027971573173999786,
0.07828421890735626,
0.18226788938045502,
0.6340957880020142,
0.076405830681324,
-0.17052830755710602,
-0.13471320271492004,
0.2730989456176758,
-0.02760716713964939,
0.23559598624706268,
1.0809673070907593,
-0.35288286209106445,
0.4870098829269409,
0.5034699440002441,
0.9143195152282715,
0.7573267221450806,
0.19841040670871735,
0.5931536555290222,
-0.6592093706130981,
0.09414441138505936,
-0.15549753606319427,
0.19993741810321808,
0.12731093168258667,
-0.34421199560165405,
0.4181690812110901,
0.4387066960334778,
-0.4411986172199249,
-0.5753213167190552,
0.32380571961402893,
-0.9206598401069641,
-0.3386416733264923,
1.2147825956344604,
0.16071751713752747,
-0.02920055016875267,
0.14583365619182587,
-0.34253817796707153,
0.33214008808135986,
-0.6118470430374146,
0.9523431658744812,
0.7403189539909363,
-0.5339571833610535,
-0.1072787493467331,
-0.5121846795082092,
0.600933849811554,
0.8464641571044922,
-0.8896429538726807,
-0.39087042212486267,
0.3344128429889679,
0.16559694707393646,
-0.09370157867670059,
0.6473323702812195,
-0.17667081952095032,
0.10637596994638443,
-0.5152932405471802,
0.10591963678598404,
0.14621007442474365,
-0.6350134015083313,
-0.18677698075771332,
0.029015248641371727,
0.07743779569864273,
-0.30712902545928955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11580v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11580v1 | Error Span Annotation: A Balanced Approach for Human Evaluation of Machine Translation | 2024-06-17T14:20:47 | 2024-06-17T14:20:47 | Tom Kocmi, Vilém Zouhar, Eleftherios Avramidis, Roman Grundkiewicz, Marzena Karpinska, Maja Popović, Mrinmaya Sachan, Mariya Shmatova | cs.CL | cs.CL | High-quality Machine Translation (MT) evaluation relies heavily on human
judgments. Comprehensive error classification methods, such as Multidimensional
Quality Metrics (MQM), are expensive as they are time-consuming and can only be
done by experts, whose availability may be limited especially for low-resource
languages. On the other hand, just assigning overall scores, like Direct
Assessment (DA), is simpler and faster and can be done by translators of any
level, but are less reliable. In this paper, we introduce Error Span Annotation
(ESA), a human evaluation protocol which combines the continuous rating of DA
with the high-level error severity span marking of MQM. We validate ESA by
comparing it to MQM and DA for 12 MT systems and one human reference
translation (English to German) from WMT23. The results show that ESA offers
faster and cheaper annotations than MQM at the same quality level, without the
requirement of expensive MQM experts. | [
-0.4072697162628174,
-0.41379454731941223,
0.2376355677843094,
0.918170154094696,
-0.08835383504629135,
0.4570491909980774,
-0.052194565534591675,
-0.7407561540603638,
0.25806692242622375,
0.35227811336517334,
-0.5262190103530884,
-0.2622377574443817,
-0.8157982230186462,
0.4753568470478058,
-0.31398916244506836,
0.6541205644607544,
-0.5688639879226685,
0.01837550289928913,
0.041110485792160034,
-0.42156288027763367,
-0.49835294485092163,
-0.5455083250999451,
-0.752625584602356,
-0.16493703424930573,
0.5292577743530273,
0.2971481382846832,
0.8705378174781799,
0.9720667004585266,
0.8648452162742615,
0.30961140990257263,
0.19231149554252625,
0.5586474537849426,
0.11366773396730423,
-0.2731224000453949,
0.11124586313962936,
-0.21576251089572906,
-0.9479113817214966,
0.25048738718032837,
0.5925673246383667,
0.9210796356201172,
0.08803045749664307,
0.21843571960926056,
-0.003479335457086563,
0.8754659295082092,
-0.5313314199447632,
0.015980156138539314,
-0.10438359528779984,
0.30976614356040955,
-0.22207807004451752,
-0.21934668719768524,
-0.7002662420272827,
-0.34771135449409485,
0.016575923189520836,
-0.5908008217811584,
-0.20393586158752441,
0.3575330972671509,
1.045512318611145,
0.697190523147583,
-0.45999422669410706,
0.03121062181890011,
-0.5822757482528687,
0.932215690612793,
-0.4148676097393036,
0.24972522258758545,
0.4882827401161194,
0.5283876657485962,
-0.08260198682546616,
-0.3211023807525635,
-0.497432678937912,
-0.027147239074110985,
-0.1843111515045166,
0.3602977395057678,
-0.3527953624725342,
0.13956649601459503,
0.028440002351999283,
0.2642827332019806,
-0.24344147741794586,
0.3600522577762604,
-0.303242027759552,
-0.3678838610649109,
0.7815942168235779,
0.21784764528274536,
0.36301353573799133,
-0.30944913625717163,
-0.6773496270179749,
-0.1887628734111786,
-0.3964754343032837,
-0.148074209690094,
0.35318508744239807,
0.1394672691822052,
-0.03399624675512314,
0.5292336940765381,
-0.26048898696899414,
0.586553692817688,
0.0649586170911789,
0.06785068660974503,
0.6484109163284302,
-0.1692652851343155,
-0.2750266194343567,
-0.19237686693668365,
0.9147826433181763,
0.6239681243896484,
0.07150034606456757,
-0.42399027943611145,
-0.34439125657081604,
0.30728214979171753,
0.35306379199028015,
-0.5894169807434082,
0.15086477994918823,
0.196528822183609,
-0.43398576974868774,
-0.24420984089374542,
0.3140246868133545,
-0.8493333458900452,
-0.3225119709968567,
-0.09923670440912247,
0.4949735701084137,
-0.22927117347717285,
0.1023978590965271,
0.23549990355968475,
0.06874706596136093,
-0.04425116628408432,
0.5966246724128723,
-0.3651621639728546,
0.3591420650482178,
0.27132219076156616,
0.810797393321991,
-0.2712758183479309,
-0.7130481600761414,
-0.9928038120269775,
-0.1708892434835434,
-0.45287683606147766,
0.6781674027442932,
-0.021435433998703957,
-0.05027226358652115,
-0.2701551616191864,
-0.04110231623053551,
-0.21725448966026306,
-0.34925419092178345,
1.190880537033081,
-0.4291374385356903,
0.20894409716129303,
-0.2812957167625427,
-0.37917426228523254,
-0.36343568563461304,
-0.03577297180891037,
-0.7302882671356201,
1.203048825263977,
0.28946930170059204,
-0.8417927622795105,
0.6963085532188416,
-1.1447404623031616,
-0.569509744644165,
0.17778120934963226,
0.27136531472206116,
-0.2722052037715912,
-0.09477958083152771,
0.3471572697162628,
0.5140882730484009,
-0.0879364088177681,
0.10238112509250641,
0.11808996647596359,
-0.5093757510185242,
0.22090376913547516,
-0.38366907835006714,
0.5361364483833313,
0.276746541261673,
-0.6049739122390747,
0.15051226317882538,
-0.7982622385025024,
0.10104985535144806,
-0.1862523853778839,
-0.7912417650222778,
-0.3083615005016327,
0.21940255165100098,
0.05537671968340874,
0.5523664355278015,
-0.05662465840578079,
-0.4991047978401184,
0.14926283061504364,
-0.2873106896877289,
0.047068800777196884,
0.6849812269210815,
-0.2401781529188156,
0.27765142917633057,
-0.21244142949581146,
0.5163361430168152,
-0.1327265053987503,
0.08744850754737854,
-0.023029454052448273,
-0.46202272176742554,
-0.9659602642059326,
-0.6232245564460754,
0.5915778279304504,
0.7350149154663086,
-0.5055894255638123,
1.106325626373291,
-0.38435086607933044,
-0.44604411721229553,
-1.357558012008667,
0.13524338603019714,
0.605167031288147,
0.39205610752105713,
0.7722246050834656,
-0.40874573588371277,
-0.7326030731201172,
-0.8037298917770386,
-0.2319561094045639,
-0.41601476073265076,
-0.07611317187547684,
-0.06655459851026535,
0.486644983291626,
-0.7048137784004211,
0.7132869362831116,
-0.1072300374507904,
-0.4955647885799408,
-0.036792002618312836,
0.723358154296875,
-0.25181466341018677,
0.5063028335571289,
0.49464887380599976,
-0.3888682425022125,
-0.3715860843658447,
0.009413985535502434,
-0.5859407186508179,
-0.6704025268554688,
-0.24096865952014923,
-0.42120084166526794,
0.40699541568756104,
0.12128914892673492,
-0.4650520384311676,
0.3658793270587921,
0.7947674989700317,
-0.5770058035850525,
0.5272179841995239,
-0.23142307996749878,
0.6839319467544556,
-0.7803182005882263,
0.24322038888931274,
0.07741399854421616,
-0.335468053817749,
-0.11625362187623978,
-0.03991652652621269,
0.2607880234718323,
0.3409121334552765,
-0.270764023065567,
0.4111206531524658,
-0.19654282927513123,
-0.20480920374393463,
-0.2604261040687561,
0.23763173818588257,
0.13851596415042877,
0.33432599902153015,
-0.20340754091739655,
0.6453633308410645,
-0.051109153777360916,
-0.2984641492366791,
0.3993905484676361,
0.34846097230911255,
-0.0971388965845108,
0.9666824340820312,
-0.45009392499923706,
0.07329793274402618,
-0.0900929868221283,
0.33833378553390503,
-0.980309009552002,
-0.3574778139591217,
0.2033223658800125,
-0.5325074791908264,
0.21670876443386078,
0.056361209601163864,
-0.6802000999450684,
-0.5946826338768005,
-0.3298220634460449,
-0.0214922484010458,
0.45504289865493774,
-0.6921780109405518,
0.29121705889701843,
0.12117651104927063,
0.10432832688093185,
-0.7494910955429077,
-0.9489881992340088,
0.3095727264881134,
-0.24362517893314362,
-0.8476226925849915,
0.2020801454782486,
0.1365606188774109,
-0.15978817641735077,
0.029619647189974785,
-0.20097336173057556,
0.11087203025817871,
0.5855224132537842,
0.32569029927253723,
0.03915509581565857,
-0.014920697547495365,
0.051436565816402435,
0.1425492763519287,
-0.5081544518470764,
-0.09591207653284073,
-0.054984476417303085,
0.14301666617393494,
-0.3240692615509033,
-0.5947062969207764,
-0.7359384298324585,
0.5662513971328735,
0.7502595782279968,
-0.40882739424705505,
0.4305732548236847,
0.6667211055755615,
-0.5670182704925537,
-0.0001350404927507043,
-0.5853567719459534,
0.150971919298172,
-0.2868633270263672,
0.474434494972229,
-0.4249645471572876,
-0.5314119458198547,
0.293459951877594,
-0.0919119343161583,
0.13736659288406372,
1.0038598775863647,
0.30870676040649414,
-0.4923039674758911,
1.2598758935928345,
0.4639852046966553,
-0.3087870180606842,
-0.10945506393909454,
0.08580700308084488,
-0.19013896584510803,
-0.7776435613632202,
-0.007649916689842939,
-0.9536721110343933,
-0.5739107728004456,
-0.11243223398923874,
-0.40618664026260376,
0.13397999107837677,
0.34420856833457947,
-0.31829938292503357,
0.447030246257782,
-0.27628305554389954,
0.27223438024520874,
0.4511082172393799,
-0.14781151711940765,
0.41298019886016846,
-0.07408899068832397,
-0.09946806728839874,
-0.3146977424621582,
-0.3082255721092224,
-0.9903886914253235,
0.7388367652893066,
0.7828817367553711,
0.5512853860855103,
0.01284757349640131,
0.6043351888656616,
0.6372421383857727,
0.6429111957550049,
-0.7511457204818726,
0.3517911732196808,
-0.15804649889469147,
-0.3849053978919983,
-0.2340751439332962,
-0.7492550015449524,
-0.7574130892753601,
0.3900185227394104,
-0.32310283184051514,
-0.5329453349113464,
-0.10351046174764633,
0.15897467732429504,
-0.34640103578567505,
0.21848365664482117,
-1.082040548324585,
1.0477832555770874,
-0.5194005966186523,
0.11933259665966034,
-0.009275580756366253,
-0.9627376794815063,
0.04687897861003876,
-0.31574907898902893,
0.374154657125473,
-0.06506764888763428,
-0.1174170970916748,
1.0984493494033813,
-0.41505518555641174,
0.7928890585899353,
-0.39238864183425903,
0.3063705861568451,
0.08538565784692764,
0.2768596410751343,
0.6214814782142639,
-0.5687757730484009,
-0.10119300335645676,
-0.02477366290986538,
-0.17713594436645508,
-0.5234040021896362,
-0.31347671151161194,
0.1262884885072708,
-1.0049755573272705,
-0.09925838559865952,
-0.4098791778087616,
-0.37117886543273926,
-0.29188409447669983,
0.12654976546764374,
0.022156447172164917,
-0.26482298970222473,
0.03581320866942406,
-0.02581932581961155,
0.07720255106687546,
-0.1442718207836151,
0.2913704514503479,
0.4333055317401886,
-0.03153061121702194,
-0.5375826954841614,
0.5753617286682129,
0.14959578216075897,
0.2549477219581604,
0.18195776641368866,
0.14192110300064087,
-0.18290866911411285,
-0.38108503818511963,
-1.0126760005950928,
0.06856537610292435,
-0.7609128952026367,
-0.48178496956825256,
-0.7520621418952942,
0.224637970328331,
0.3143165111541748,
-0.2554963529109955,
-0.6069296002388,
-0.4467349946498871,
0.12982599437236786,
-0.4397570490837097,
0.20902781188488007,
0.3436744213104248,
0.10648121684789658,
0.6123727560043335,
-0.9747387170791626,
0.021822184324264526,
-0.07256494462490082,
0.32593265175819397,
-0.29641979932785034,
-0.4136318564414978,
-0.47385236620903015,
0.05933661758899689,
-0.4700125753879547,
-0.9170849919319153,
0.14530885219573975,
0.08487127721309662,
0.5698970556259155,
0.18956978619098663,
0.08140546083450317,
0.9647606611251831,
-0.38721704483032227,
0.6846693754196167,
0.2635149359703064,
-1.3881183862686157,
0.2703131437301636,
0.11397872120141983,
-0.10547436773777008,
0.6868715882301331,
0.27741146087646484,
-0.8287693858146667,
-0.42365601658821106,
-0.4468367397785187,
-1.0253428220748901,
0.6571701765060425,
0.08311302959918976,
-0.1601523905992508,
-0.018136512488126755,
0.18355529010295868,
0.11490825563669205,
0.1423521488904953,
-0.7356643676757812,
-0.06590345501899719,
-0.11712044477462769,
-0.3609507083892822,
0.03401046618819237,
-0.09605594724416733,
-0.0016029933467507362,
-0.02464916557073593,
0.7696375250816345,
-0.2076326459646225,
0.21833224594593048,
0.2937595248222351,
-0.40112918615341187,
-0.8596069812774658,
0.3838779628276825,
0.3790791630744934,
0.5115631222724915,
-0.3777696192264557,
0.37816399335861206,
0.35558077692985535,
-0.15458890795707703,
0.2765319049358368,
0.07539088279008865,
-0.002566165756434202,
0.07150476425886154,
0.5883632898330688,
0.708172619342804,
0.015708094462752342,
-0.4943302571773529,
0.7245089411735535,
0.3616507947444916,
-0.12342913448810577,
0.25139835476875305,
-0.5374752283096313,
0.037741877138614655,
0.0665133148431778,
0.4732102155685425,
0.5603858828544617,
0.09046684950590134,
-0.0723353698849678,
0.3110436499118805,
-0.034436821937561035,
-0.515387237071991,
-0.4157443940639496,
0.7408111691474915,
0.5678859949111938,
-0.04679228365421295,
0.5150578022003174,
-0.501074492931366,
-0.7888081669807434,
0.26413238048553467,
0.299543559551239,
1.1024916172027588,
-0.49900248646736145,
0.16185197234153748,
0.20228420197963715,
0.9316090941429138,
-0.3309210240840912,
0.230801060795784,
0.314876526594162,
-0.33001771569252014,
-1.1305930614471436,
-0.7315753102302551,
-0.5308330059051514,
-0.46262186765670776,
-0.45085519552230835,
0.27115392684936523,
0.015512887388467789,
-0.11365943402051926,
0.030073823407292366,
0.1523335576057434,
-0.4875428080558777,
0.49669912457466125,
0.05087055265903473,
1.0379531383514404,
-1.1650553941726685,
0.5581843256950378,
0.9206211566925049,
-0.6266703009605408,
-0.7297831773757935,
-0.08487727493047714,
-0.1411997526884079,
-0.6059654951095581,
0.9827296733856201,
0.21895860135555267,
-0.30746394395828247,
-0.3096378445625305,
-0.04126656427979469,
-0.3222569227218628,
0.9945313334465027,
0.31817445158958435,
-0.3011949956417084,
0.06252597272396088,
0.1666056513786316,
0.6997464895248413,
-0.1957610696554184,
0.08180038630962372,
0.5570745468139648,
0.9391577243804932,
-0.18152999877929688,
-1.1749409437179565,
0.19664648175239563,
-0.209074929356575,
-0.21926023066043854,
0.35079458355903625,
-0.5485621690750122,
0.5865125060081482,
-0.06120625138282776,
-0.2973755896091461,
0.0008223445038311183,
0.5242345929145813,
-0.2326347380876541,
0.2906343638896942,
0.6309576034545898,
0.7267249822616577,
0.8939369320869446,
-0.4342914819717407,
1.0914884805679321,
0.17111064493656158,
0.4017707109451294,
0.700294017791748,
-0.17692029476165771,
0.9745533466339111,
0.7406792044639587,
-0.48570242524147034,
0.11583320796489716,
0.6602903604507446,
-0.11830778419971466,
0.1313968151807785,
0.48900654911994934,
0.16141748428344727,
-0.10860517621040344,
0.2586512863636017,
-0.1772608757019043,
0.1293051838874817,
0.1753709316253662,
-0.26783961057662964,
-0.17009064555168152,
-0.03352673724293709,
0.3541249930858612,
0.218379944562912,
-0.11358287185430527,
0.5847938060760498,
-0.19901274144649506,
-0.559847891330719,
0.4689772427082062,
0.5963025689125061,
0.7970028519630432,
-0.23458676040172577,
0.15798111259937286,
-0.3050519526004791,
0.1650281697511673,
-0.669086217880249,
-0.6379222869873047,
0.7535862922668457,
0.3876298666000366,
-0.0653788149356842,
-0.25869283080101013,
0.28641074895858765,
-0.10868104547262192,
-0.3775830864906311,
0.43194442987442017,
0.6016914248466492,
0.25355756282806396,
-0.22800132632255554,
-0.5115015506744385,
0.08391373604536057,
-0.31863465905189514,
-0.29297730326652527,
-0.08459607511758804,
0.420101523399353,
-0.5069271326065063,
0.5702035427093506,
0.3488979935646057,
0.032938145101070404,
0.30933743715286255,
-0.1748664677143097,
0.36761602759361267,
-0.6055585145950317,
-0.4209497272968292,
-0.8547977805137634,
0.8182273507118225,
-0.034474678337574005,
-0.225464329123497,
0.7123430371284485,
0.4202764630317688,
0.6968767046928406,
-0.1543206125497818,
0.9059628248214722,
-0.0014748229878023267,
0.5380991697311401,
-0.2508220076560974,
0.6917372941970825,
-0.5542903542518616,
0.22219440340995789,
-0.7506653666496277,
-0.8577265739440918,
-0.8197429776191711,
0.8095243573188782,
-0.14923039078712463,
-0.01764753647148609,
0.7402216196060181,
0.16065005958080292,
0.04333478584885597,
-0.15498115122318268,
0.10459870845079422,
-0.0058415732346475124,
0.27243632078170776,
0.5394539833068848,
1.0830413103103638,
-0.6986546516418457,
0.5914105772972107,
0.0010252106003463268,
-0.6146314740180969,
-0.48562538623809814,
-0.9943214654922485,
-0.5477717518806458,
-0.21422173082828522,
-0.6369043588638306,
-0.5672228932380676,
-0.12742018699645996,
1.3618234395980835,
0.7412347197532654,
-0.5749107003211975,
-0.1684534251689911,
0.1306489259004593,
-0.018384788185358047,
-0.7059966325759888,
-0.15934306383132935,
0.7058446407318115,
-0.4915698766708374,
-0.8020145297050476,
0.2610219419002533,
0.35511380434036255,
0.010483753867447376,
-0.08472611010074615,
-0.5290402173995972,
0.0583440326154232,
0.01684357412159443,
0.5772339701652527,
0.05622721090912819,
-0.7913126945495605,
-0.6150550246238708,
0.013673452660441399,
-0.39729392528533936,
0.19822393357753754,
0.16445587575435638,
-0.293418824672699,
0.5020326972007751,
0.31387823820114136,
1.2027262449264526,
0.11951592564582825,
0.13888397812843323,
0.42035815119743347,
-1.027438998222351,
-0.08669180423021317,
0.0709434226155281,
0.504819393157959,
0.5083228945732117,
-0.05644180253148079,
0.7379886507987976,
0.3903641700744629,
-0.41885438561439514,
-0.9524186849594116,
0.04111645743250847,
-1.2212965488433838,
0.33396121859550476,
0.8604813814163208,
-0.5572159290313721,
-0.053254690021276474,
0.04840954765677452,
-0.7245040535926819,
0.12053343653678894,
-0.1914912611246109,
0.8969322443008423,
0.9450826048851013,
0.0010147320572286844,
0.1834942102432251,
-0.5169298052787781,
0.34067606925964355,
0.5565253496170044,
-1.1195471286773682,
-0.018989868462085724,
0.468820184469223,
-0.1183512955904007,
0.5829892754554749,
0.38968461751937866,
-0.3992670178413391,
0.4366803467273712,
-0.2683570384979248,
0.6296328902244568,
-0.11224489659070969,
-0.20327691733837128,
-0.13111981749534607,
0.04260125383734703,
0.3712429404258728,
-0.6394922733306885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11577v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11577v1 | Mathematical Entities: Corpora and Benchmarks | 2024-06-17T14:11:00 | 2024-06-17T14:11:00 | Jacob Collard, Valeria de Paiva, Eswaran Subrahmanian | cs.CL | cs.CL, math.HO | Mathematics is a highly specialized domain with its own unique set of
challenges. Despite this, there has been relatively little research on natural
language processing for mathematical texts, and there are few mathematical
language resources aimed at NLP. In this paper, we aim to provide annotated
corpora that can be used to study the language of mathematics in different
contexts, ranging from fundamental concepts found in textbooks to advanced
research mathematics. We preprocess the corpora with a neural parsing model and
some manual intervention to provide part-of-speech tags, lemmas, and dependency
trees. In total, we provide 182397 sentences across three corpora. We then aim
to test and evaluate several noteworthy natural language processing models
using these corpora, to show how well they can adapt to the domain of
mathematics and provide useful tools for exploring mathematical language. We
evaluate several neural and symbolic models against benchmarks that we extract
from the corpus metadata to show that terminology extraction and definition
extraction do not easily generalize to mathematics, and that additional work is
needed to achieve good performance on these metrics. Finally, we provide a
learning assistant that grants access to the content of these corpora in a
context-sensitive manner, utilizing text search and entity linking. Though our
corpora and benchmarks provide useful metrics for evaluating mathematical
language processing, further work is necessary to adapt models to mathematics
in order to provide more effective learning assistants and apply NLP methods to
different mathematical domains. | [
-0.5396437644958496,
-0.8625476360321045,
0.362887442111969,
0.4781811237335205,
-0.21079771220684052,
-0.02017490565776825,
-0.33801165223121643,
-0.5879837870597839,
0.08048194646835327,
0.35007283091545105,
-0.523222804069519,
-0.530266523361206,
-0.503372073173523,
0.47749218344688416,
-0.2576634883880615,
0.8532853126525879,
-0.16731727123260498,
0.37889334559440613,
-0.653813362121582,
-0.2669573426246643,
-0.5085260272026062,
-0.7389586567878723,
-0.5737492442131042,
-0.12920862436294556,
0.165297731757164,
-0.04345891997218132,
0.7012484669685364,
0.4178159534931183,
0.7931486368179321,
0.38754984736442566,
0.11206793785095215,
0.07707726210355759,
0.023120716214179993,
0.09832165390253067,
-0.2687617242336273,
-0.50345379114151,
-0.5192612409591675,
-0.09385491907596588,
0.6045315265655518,
1.196733832359314,
-0.03963718190789223,
0.3891919255256653,
-0.1263299137353897,
0.4296831786632538,
-0.4164958894252777,
0.7363880276679993,
-0.45995771884918213,
0.02362659014761448,
-0.2381083071231842,
-0.03749488294124603,
-0.1474614441394806,
-0.5404719114303589,
0.35544633865356445,
-1.0508315563201904,
0.17813462018966675,
-0.07075232267379761,
0.6132705807685852,
0.24755334854125977,
0.04531615599989891,
-0.845013439655304,
-0.33200210332870483,
0.9230427742004395,
-0.34911268949508667,
0.4371111989021301,
0.46933892369270325,
0.4177553653717041,
0.3681446611881256,
-0.786611020565033,
-0.08881335705518723,
-0.1603500097990036,
-0.20224985480308533,
-0.158050537109375,
-0.27871137857437134,
-0.3310973346233368,
0.47811025381088257,
0.20195041596889496,
-0.3227587044239044,
-0.2870323956012726,
-0.46439552307128906,
-0.2003726065158844,
0.46346575021743774,
0.08311190456151962,
0.3686353862285614,
-0.27878087759017944,
-0.05910447984933853,
-0.3494027256965637,
-0.7112056612968445,
-0.06078091263771057,
0.4878179728984833,
0.25144773721694946,
-0.004006829112768173,
0.6807005405426025,
0.13369221985340118,
0.6687442660331726,
-0.6207130551338196,
-0.07076308131217957,
0.25293242931365967,
-0.20092108845710754,
-0.20840486884117126,
0.0981535017490387,
0.5032077431678772,
-0.22521400451660156,
0.5773088335990906,
-0.34169909358024597,
-0.1961899995803833,
0.5574373006820679,
0.21683964133262634,
-0.8621045351028442,
-0.3808729350566864,
-0.24809478223323822,
-0.029012836515903473,
-0.019112594425678253,
-0.06945917755365372,
-0.7326783537864685,
0.3617776930332184,
-0.942413330078125,
0.2855856120586395,
-0.689698338508606,
0.021832535043358803,
0.01574663817882538,
0.014255031011998653,
-0.4055224061012268,
0.18363676965236664,
-1.0811859369277954,
0.9344460368156433,
1.0713589191436768,
0.7770740389823914,
-0.06400269269943237,
-0.11026495695114136,
-0.5382504463195801,
-0.27171555161476135,
-0.3662974238395691,
0.7617102861404419,
-0.7748082280158997,
-0.3346971869468689,
0.245881587266922,
-0.24011822044849396,
-0.09855358302593231,
-0.8205568194389343,
0.8892069458961487,
-0.5904927849769592,
0.19328439235687256,
-0.2642081379890442,
-0.6587455868721008,
-0.32655489444732666,
0.08200854063034058,
-0.7990209460258484,
0.9841281771659851,
0.3482707738876343,
-0.49746373295783997,
0.0644260048866272,
-1.1262227296829224,
-0.42376914620399475,
0.21218526363372803,
-0.36564794182777405,
-0.17719236016273499,
0.380434513092041,
0.19681334495544434,
0.03299478441476822,
-0.556147038936615,
0.432386189699173,
-0.2162422090768814,
-0.08815048635005951,
0.35411104559898376,
-0.19452659785747528,
0.9512644410133362,
0.2053167223930359,
-0.1330590844154358,
-0.09751284867525101,
-0.8658893704414368,
0.08736123889684677,
0.01969020999968052,
0.1202310249209404,
-0.6766707301139832,
-0.01637553609907627,
0.3165823221206665,
-0.008105344139039516,
0.36093810200691223,
-0.2303822934627533,
0.0006661642692051828,
-0.37503159046173096,
0.39573654532432556,
0.5402817130088806,
-0.30974072217941284,
0.35247471928596497,
0.013687660917639732,
0.48065999150276184,
-0.0845676138997078,
-0.2636302709579468,
-0.05241640657186508,
-0.4717187285423279,
-0.5398033857345581,
-0.20109105110168457,
0.7971794009208679,
0.4572189152240753,
-0.6395332217216492,
0.14865702390670776,
-0.2055874466896057,
-0.1300460398197174,
-0.5160109996795654,
0.2834431231021881,
0.5515075325965881,
0.7477312088012695,
0.45751962065696716,
-0.27464351058006287,
-0.5888953804969788,
-0.965080976486206,
-0.28881219029426575,
0.05270395055413246,
-0.36106929183006287,
0.2964882254600525,
0.5088136792182922,
0.08509808778762817,
0.9034033417701721,
-0.7504255175590515,
-0.306377649307251,
0.38107746839523315,
0.3224070072174072,
0.0490199439227581,
0.23455648124217987,
0.5575698018074036,
-0.9492446780204773,
-0.3166341781616211,
-0.20065312087535858,
-1.0240201950073242,
-0.2683372497558594,
0.3481447696685791,
-0.20484113693237305,
-0.02584179863333702,
0.2649194896221161,
-0.29684364795684814,
0.3596770465373993,
0.2653527855873108,
-0.18114343285560608,
0.29877954721450806,
-0.05400937423110008,
-0.19702939689159393,
-0.9270926117897034,
0.19262269139289856,
0.33118414878845215,
-0.117035411298275,
-0.3377740681171417,
0.23240649700164795,
0.150382861495018,
-0.056974172592163086,
-0.2918892800807953,
0.4636629521846771,
-0.19692464172840118,
-0.47345852851867676,
-0.07449264824390411,
0.3802628219127655,
-0.0967191606760025,
0.4351236820220947,
0.3939782679080963,
0.9175916910171509,
0.6416959166526794,
-0.6530086994171143,
0.19717131555080414,
0.38831886649131775,
-0.307190865278244,
0.795602023601532,
-0.8004905581474304,
-0.15756383538246155,
0.16638369858264923,
-0.27154862880706787,
-0.4791097044944763,
0.13792777061462402,
0.12013974040746689,
-0.3057768940925598,
0.0858738049864769,
-0.05067814514040947,
-0.8028180003166199,
0.24344424903392792,
0.0031937926542013884,
0.5665180087089539,
0.37564095854759216,
-0.41099870204925537,
0.5831668376922607,
0.5305370092391968,
-0.4362315237522125,
-0.4076973497867584,
-0.3582995533943176,
-0.009006657637655735,
-0.2758893072605133,
-0.5913803577423096,
0.6681393980979919,
-0.27141767740249634,
-0.7080280184745789,
0.35469338297843933,
0.05063140392303467,
-0.298109769821167,
0.2688745856285095,
0.2870118021965027,
0.6115326881408691,
-0.5684468150138855,
0.2878323793411255,
-0.1329060047864914,
-0.32282957434654236,
0.4919951558113098,
-0.3015541136264801,
0.48053255677223206,
-0.38675954937934875,
-0.11842594295740128,
0.0408586822450161,
0.24892814457416534,
0.020055802538990974,
-0.21955658495426178,
0.3937268555164337,
0.39911502599716187,
-0.9398564696311951,
-0.036076515913009644,
-0.20289018750190735,
-0.15297585725784302,
-0.4317459166049957,
0.20678184926509857,
-0.6654038429260254,
-0.6689378023147583,
0.3127252757549286,
-0.14762777090072632,
0.22773393988609314,
0.7927168607711792,
0.4250333309173584,
0.3896092474460602,
0.6185905933380127,
0.5878250002861023,
0.11109747737646103,
0.25283440947532654,
-0.20676952600479126,
0.11752629280090332,
-0.9087245464324951,
-0.06514269858598709,
-0.8329024910926819,
-0.03076149895787239,
-0.5979066491127014,
-0.26808860898017883,
0.18830452859401703,
0.15024185180664062,
0.011020165868103504,
0.8895379900932312,
-0.4289533793926239,
0.4771484434604645,
0.3722362220287323,
-0.3754931688308716,
0.3746439218521118,
0.22090478241443634,
-0.3732701241970062,
-0.5357085466384888,
-0.3359018564224243,
-0.7750849723815918,
1.1215198040008545,
0.1610611230134964,
0.4283282160758972,
0.3532898426055908,
0.47080862522125244,
-0.031854648143053055,
0.7995530962944031,
-0.5241858959197998,
0.36236467957496643,
-0.2646317183971405,
-0.7009531259536743,
-0.19552098214626312,
-0.7361313104629517,
-0.8485381603240967,
0.19540084898471832,
-0.016029242426156998,
-0.6354439854621887,
-0.098970428109169,
-0.3432357609272003,
-0.3104439377784729,
-0.1297723948955536,
-0.6616466641426086,
0.959415853023529,
-0.16610486805438995,
-0.440277099609375,
-0.06115403771400452,
-0.1148507222533226,
0.44051748514175415,
-0.31988057494163513,
0.46402066946029663,
-0.11223948746919632,
-0.1987634003162384,
0.6735535264015198,
-0.37838035821914673,
0.6249574422836304,
0.2991677522659302,
-0.1513451486825943,
0.33032649755477905,
0.3399253785610199,
-0.23904675245285034,
0.6575357913970947,
-0.13674969971179962,
0.3488090932369232,
0.38837695121765137,
-0.3225855827331543,
-0.509419322013855,
0.8825559020042419,
-0.8292800188064575,
-0.33504733443260193,
-0.5638733506202698,
-0.6765363216400146,
-0.22965435683727264,
0.1082707867026329,
-0.1530790627002716,
0.6024909019470215,
-0.16961342096328735,
0.11828861385583878,
0.6178337931632996,
0.00442690122872591,
0.6093167066574097,
0.22144544124603271,
-0.2401570975780487,
-0.5598401427268982,
0.8934329152107239,
0.21589620411396027,
-0.04411264508962631,
0.5887267589569092,
0.010906161740422249,
-0.7140583992004395,
0.013340793550014496,
-0.4782268702983856,
0.17564637959003448,
-0.8930048942565918,
-0.29532790184020996,
-0.4008735418319702,
-0.24054722487926483,
-0.5626462697982788,
-0.09226387739181519,
-0.19330361485481262,
-0.6553752422332764,
-0.38218623399734497,
0.0993172749876976,
0.3386097848415375,
0.453182578086853,
-0.028506970033049583,
-0.02512594871222973,
-0.536801815032959,
0.3272498846054077,
0.32055261731147766,
0.31581172347068787,
-0.21318024396896362,
-0.17867231369018555,
0.001405297196470201,
-0.14160512387752533,
-0.28979045152664185,
-0.4088289439678192,
0.4695722162723541,
0.14564791321754456,
0.41446995735168457,
0.1532987654209137,
-0.14672590792179108,
0.7352306842803955,
-0.8042299151420593,
0.44567033648490906,
0.2307698130607605,
-1.2768193483352661,
0.16813072562217712,
0.08172455430030823,
0.031029080972075462,
0.504363477230072,
0.5444973111152649,
-0.23984143137931824,
0.2538411617279053,
-0.8396409153938293,
-0.4259757995605469,
0.3457719683647156,
0.47555792331695557,
0.1107216626405716,
-0.12575526535511017,
0.3610413074493408,
0.10479921102523804,
0.4366801977157593,
-0.49778079986572266,
-0.28707626461982727,
-0.11755353212356567,
-0.4131895899772644,
-0.29213157296180725,
0.052221015095710754,
-0.3939346671104431,
-0.01987934112548828,
0.3488973081111908,
-0.22547633945941925,
0.11525486409664154,
0.06187889352440834,
-0.3985549807548523,
-0.07019712030887604,
-0.008976531215012074,
0.8642262816429138,
1.3062859773635864,
-0.13699345290660858,
0.3591226637363434,
0.2609790861606598,
-0.5191721320152283,
-0.2502290904521942,
0.6536155343055725,
-0.05728830769658089,
0.5219617486000061,
0.35573887825012207,
0.3439237177371979,
0.9526296854019165,
-0.8489031791687012,
0.037071358412504196,
-0.27240461111068726,
-0.19993837177753448,
-0.6624613404273987,
-0.09208660572767258,
0.397597074508667,
-0.10277609527111053,
0.35095319151878357,
0.16446025669574738,
0.27107691764831543,
-0.5424553155899048,
0.4173886179924011,
0.2702333927154541,
-0.10364721715450287,
-0.5223668217658997,
0.7561395168304443,
-0.1610962152481079,
-0.6546244621276855,
0.3835713863372803,
-0.30339500308036804,
-0.5254421234130859,
0.624754786491394,
0.5707746744155884,
0.6305936574935913,
0.029483744874596596,
0.09810823947191238,
0.5397050976753235,
0.05560613423585892,
0.01114407554268837,
0.04551843926310539,
-0.094324491918087,
-0.2597801685333252,
-0.41459953784942627,
-0.8394484519958496,
-0.514531135559082,
-0.20040297508239746,
-0.6671519875526428,
0.47164830565452576,
-0.5928459763526917,
-0.014653190039098263,
0.7039626836776733,
0.37108445167541504,
-1.0046796798706055,
0.13445766270160675,
0.07650385051965714,
0.7297132611274719,
-0.5082796216011047,
0.6031309366226196,
0.7244563102722168,
-0.6111155152320862,
-0.4492172300815582,
-0.653255045413971,
-0.18540944159030914,
-0.7732245922088623,
0.9383934140205383,
-0.05472799390554428,
0.18790337443351746,
-0.1670098602771759,
-0.2749074101448059,
-0.7302021980285645,
0.7948463559150696,
0.40706270933151245,
-0.5094758868217468,
-0.062120500952005386,
0.3938191533088684,
0.7010678648948669,
-0.5856575965881348,
0.412535160779953,
0.16586656868457794,
0.1386275589466095,
0.0671992152929306,
-0.6328065991401672,
-0.03561854735016823,
-0.27061447501182556,
0.06888022273778915,
0.19238856434822083,
-0.23319442570209503,
1.111546516418457,
0.4107588827610016,
-0.04932120814919472,
0.10890769958496094,
0.7725052833557129,
0.42611533403396606,
0.618674635887146,
0.2605305314064026,
0.68312007188797,
0.6265981793403625,
-0.16109248995780945,
0.7402195930480957,
-0.4551236033439636,
0.39642027020454407,
1.0206576585769653,
-0.2613462507724762,
1.0180953741073608,
0.306189626455307,
-0.2988569140434265,
0.5655972361564636,
0.5819069743156433,
0.0451902374625206,
0.18009507656097412,
0.6548797488212585,
-0.37773001194000244,
-0.1690705269575119,
-0.16668164730072021,
-0.6259575486183167,
0.021359501406550407,
0.6123003959655762,
-0.29190683364868164,
-0.48203855752944946,
-0.27025964856147766,
0.030844029039144516,
0.47963815927505493,
-0.183661550283432,
0.35516440868377686,
0.403921514749527,
-0.8261403441429138,
0.242620587348938,
0.20280718803405762,
0.30480727553367615,
-0.5090146064758301,
-0.32388538122177124,
0.0054248059168457985,
0.17286089062690735,
-0.021485604345798492,
-0.2553900182247162,
0.4984397888183594,
0.2344212532043457,
0.030378667637705803,
-0.14303167164325714,
0.36839625239372253,
-0.30507978796958923,
-1.0682625770568848,
0.1319565325975418,
0.6010466814041138,
0.31896257400512695,
0.05966046079993248,
-0.7139397859573364,
0.1556011289358139,
-0.5206457376480103,
0.11903653293848038,
0.41794607043266296,
0.774075984954834,
-0.19624848663806915,
0.2071581929922104,
0.8947926759719849,
-0.15180592238903046,
0.05636001378297806,
0.23919986188411713,
0.7835521697998047,
-0.6061701774597168,
-0.1433981955051422,
-0.7866583466529846,
0.02793985977768898,
-0.20894216001033783,
-0.7673916220664978,
0.7130627036094666,
0.8705045580863953,
1.119757890701294,
-0.0929831936955452,
0.43839797377586365,
0.08048784732818604,
0.40884464979171753,
-0.49720120429992676,
0.3364830017089844,
-0.1516193151473999,
0.32576441764831543,
-0.425037145614624,
-1.2830344438552856,
-0.6218752264976501,
0.8731441497802734,
-0.5016874074935913,
-0.11682917177677155,
0.8539245128631592,
0.2524320185184479,
-0.2858269214630127,
0.3366791009902954,
0.27513739466667175,
-0.3777710795402527,
0.1804916262626648,
0.5153791308403015,
0.509819746017456,
-0.7034573554992676,
0.510515034198761,
-0.4865556061267853,
0.049011338502168655,
-0.04971842095255852,
-0.7824142575263977,
-1.0830656290054321,
-0.6562122702598572,
-0.6377687454223633,
-0.2997813820838928,
-0.16381773352622986,
0.8842898011207581,
0.5506029725074768,
-0.7812030911445618,
-0.45869356393814087,
-0.25715675950050354,
0.15596480667591095,
-0.1751125305891037,
-0.2207583338022232,
0.61562579870224,
-0.695780873298645,
-1.0708106756210327,
0.14845801889896393,
0.22888608276844025,
-0.15901996195316315,
-0.4274570047855377,
0.08366847783327103,
0.04017836973071098,
0.00854897778481245,
0.551327645778656,
0.19286762177944183,
-0.49263447523117065,
-0.0014824913814663887,
0.4273679256439209,
-0.08634598553180695,
-0.034752774983644485,
0.9647566080093384,
-0.6332327127456665,
0.18657009303569794,
0.09154516458511353,
0.8487928509712219,
0.3426988124847412,
-0.09767011553049088,
0.385631799697876,
-0.4428185820579529,
0.08381185680627823,
0.39915457367897034,
0.4734659790992737,
0.3563295602798462,
-0.08315276354551315,
0.8999504446983337,
0.43221452832221985,
-0.19442640244960785,
-0.9081934094429016,
0.05787381902337074,
-0.6402912735939026,
-0.2842233180999756,
0.6880398988723755,
-0.29990869760513306,
-0.5218309164047241,
0.11348883807659149,
-0.015431337989866734,
0.08325952291488647,
-0.08294250071048737,
0.8790151476860046,
1.121971607208252,
0.07014162093400955,
0.00009754457278177142,
-0.9250808358192444,
0.5289438962936401,
0.5142136812210083,
-0.9594591856002808,
-0.3601447641849518,
0.2566523551940918,
0.16708308458328247,
0.7841665148735046,
0.04561544582247734,
-0.25356799364089966,
0.16165179014205933,
0.14754053950309753,
-0.08561435341835022,
0.17771665751934052,
-0.3414655923843384,
-0.19136843085289001,
0.3640865981578827,
-0.17580664157867432,
0.08571015298366547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11568v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11568v1 | Towards an End-to-End Framework for Invasive Brain Signal Decoding with Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T14:04:18 | 2024-06-17T14:04:18 | Sheng Feng, Heyang Liu, Yu Wang, Yanfeng Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS, q-bio.NC | In this paper, we introduce a groundbreaking end-to-end (E2E) framework for
decoding invasive brain signals, marking a significant advancement in the field
of speech neuroprosthesis. Our methodology leverages the comprehensive
reasoning abilities of large language models (LLMs) to facilitate direct
decoding. By fully integrating LLMs, we achieve results comparable to the
state-of-the-art cascade models. Our findings underscore the immense potential
of E2E frameworks in speech neuroprosthesis, particularly as the technology
behind brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) and the availability of relevant
datasets continue to evolve. This work not only showcases the efficacy of
combining LLMs with E2E decoding for enhancing speech neuroprosthesis but also
sets a new direction for future research in BCI applications, underscoring the
impact of LLMs in decoding complex neural signals for communication
restoration. Code will be made available at
https://github.com/FsFrancis15/BrainLLM. | [
-0.2326725870370865,
-0.9779199957847595,
0.6159125566482544,
0.30850955843925476,
-0.24177685379981995,
-0.1352832317352295,
-0.3126494288444519,
-0.7116631865501404,
0.3634478747844696,
0.3706112504005432,
-0.4676350951194763,
-0.5671674609184265,
-0.8060292601585388,
-0.03199504315853119,
-0.5298658013343811,
0.5773953795433044,
0.057369414716959,
0.1552828997373581,
-0.08566517382860184,
0.11232718080282211,
-0.3580959141254425,
-0.3241027891635895,
-0.8300506472587585,
-0.3156035244464874,
0.49834802746772766,
-0.10010272264480591,
0.3444373607635498,
0.4876904785633087,
0.08622928708791733,
0.15976612269878387,
-0.5921025276184082,
0.15268953144550323,
-0.31093040108680725,
-0.03888856992125511,
-0.4997926354408264,
-0.3411032557487488,
-0.6758068799972534,
-0.588148832321167,
0.49272477626800537,
0.961589515209198,
-0.3670421242713928,
-0.08287357538938522,
0.13098499178886414,
0.35059306025505066,
-0.6590737700462341,
0.06066848337650299,
-0.25411173701286316,
-0.20499779284000397,
-0.05667082965373993,
-0.0370384156703949,
-0.8525075912475586,
0.0681978240609169,
0.04926912486553192,
-0.21170486509799957,
-0.5377674698829651,
-0.17715050280094147,
0.4413042366504669,
-0.02114974707365036,
-0.4628753066062927,
-0.21228639781475067,
-0.6127187013626099,
0.5243154168128967,
-0.8160538673400879,
0.8641014099121094,
0.22540569305419922,
0.07121559977531433,
-0.5034334063529968,
-0.9236934185028076,
-0.4714714288711548,
0.05846000090241432,
0.29276570677757263,
0.11679890751838684,
-0.579329788684845,
0.4466908872127533,
0.13751864433288574,
-0.10757782310247421,
-0.5986493825912476,
0.6634474992752075,
-0.20712926983833313,
-0.43990522623062134,
0.1947624385356903,
-0.09112781286239624,
0.6011239290237427,
0.1736273169517517,
-0.10032037645578384,
0.33223265409469604,
-0.7635682821273804,
-0.11293843388557434,
0.2915430963039398,
0.0011485421564429998,
-0.3103903532028198,
0.3944714069366455,
-0.04741327464580536,
0.9996353387832642,
-0.3454781174659729,
0.2649480998516083,
0.026275597512722015,
-0.0873851552605629,
-0.210311621427536,
0.17958900332450867,
0.4971821904182434,
0.3073660433292389,
0.21978944540023804,
-0.4982474148273468,
-0.04421916604042053,
0.003174535231664777,
-0.2209169864654541,
-0.7001850605010986,
0.07265683263540268,
0.48445215821266174,
-0.5066801309585571,
0.11135656386613846,
-0.4974716007709503,
-0.5821937918663025,
-0.38739630579948425,
-0.43474432826042175,
0.4176863133907318,
-0.36980462074279785,
-0.6938638687133789,
0.7207823991775513,
-0.1743309646844864,
0.68455970287323,
0.13824403285980225,
-1.0727983713150024,
0.4386512041091919,
0.896531879901886,
0.8839330077171326,
-0.00043643632670864463,
-0.1262088418006897,
-0.35655131936073303,
0.32044610381126404,
-0.4809364080429077,
0.7742749452590942,
-0.33214041590690613,
-0.19723868370056152,
0.1383102387189865,
0.0981106162071228,
0.3537515103816986,
-0.47658196091651917,
0.7811643481254578,
-0.7341974973678589,
-0.023668477311730385,
-0.1475876420736313,
-0.4510369598865509,
-0.3767438232898712,
-0.13328281044960022,
-0.5174688100814819,
0.24856239557266235,
0.04779765382409096,
-0.3553723394870758,
-0.11867095530033112,
-0.7030690312385559,
-0.6608451008796692,
0.032082345336675644,
-0.12872308492660522,
-0.1216839924454689,
0.27548685669898987,
0.14875675737857819,
0.3947210907936096,
-0.6300551295280457,
0.352675199508667,
-0.5480024814605713,
-0.3682727515697479,
0.16380856931209564,
-0.7814874649047852,
1.1732828617095947,
0.158713698387146,
-0.24599876999855042,
-0.10874604433774948,
-0.6661629676818848,
0.1271347552537918,
0.004634468350559473,
-0.24654075503349304,
-0.19569706916809082,
0.1576208621263504,
0.1669139862060547,
0.23228560388088226,
0.43321412801742554,
-0.8553334474563599,
-0.15625721216201782,
-0.5742669105529785,
0.963125467300415,
0.634562611579895,
-0.04363063722848892,
0.31553810834884644,
0.05652354657649994,
0.1674674153327942,
0.023183828219771385,
0.119086854159832,
-0.40294724702835083,
-0.48583248257637024,
-0.39022180438041687,
-0.405707448720932,
0.1595829576253891,
0.6755422949790955,
-0.32308229804039,
0.7508998513221741,
-0.518112063407898,
-0.12284869700670242,
-0.35346993803977966,
-0.3263426125049591,
-0.0127190463244915,
0.49964943528175354,
0.430082231760025,
-0.05874742195010185,
-0.8925834894180298,
-1.0869354009628296,
-0.01112302765250206,
-0.14680436253547668,
-0.4099700450897217,
-0.056504834443330765,
0.18505249917507172,
-0.3639232814311981,
0.9571924805641174,
-0.21160131692886353,
-0.11849351972341537,
-0.1479545682668686,
-0.25290095806121826,
0.4610973298549652,
0.492525577545166,
0.056829534471035004,
-0.36442291736602783,
-0.08522725850343704,
0.2630254328250885,
-0.9515975117683411,
-0.2389361560344696,
-0.19581523537635803,
-0.13561809062957764,
0.1814502328634262,
0.5131655335426331,
-0.666257917881012,
0.289077490568161,
0.6201070547103882,
-0.28791555762290955,
0.3026062548160553,
-0.24276503920555115,
-0.02802208438515663,
-1.037787675857544,
0.23668669164180756,
0.06411367654800415,
-0.03323451429605484,
-1.0040395259857178,
-0.0943378284573555,
0.11268126219511032,
0.08072222769260406,
-0.19755598902702332,
0.2914821207523346,
-0.7219133973121643,
-0.11559092253446579,
-0.5155664086341858,
0.10049077868461609,
0.013973154127597809,
0.2643357515335083,
0.2990894615650177,
0.4304038882255554,
0.9008589386940002,
-0.24466300010681152,
0.18305988609790802,
0.42513737082481384,
-0.1444505900144577,
0.6781495809555054,
-0.9115132093429565,
0.24536073207855225,
-0.3491012752056122,
0.4076542556285858,
-1.0009963512420654,
-0.042487964034080505,
-0.029166504740715027,
-0.7890886068344116,
0.5548824667930603,
-0.07183971256017685,
-0.3382132351398468,
-0.15371786057949066,
-0.09501098096370697,
0.4121686518192291,
0.7950760126113892,
-0.9062950611114502,
0.796564519405365,
0.5681577324867249,
-0.2783542573451996,
-0.5194636583328247,
-1.0641661882400513,
0.7297085523605347,
-0.03181261569261551,
-0.9561079740524292,
0.3334951102733612,
-0.05183105543255806,
-0.02895176224410534,
-0.308283269405365,
0.06660293787717819,
-0.17470969259738922,
-0.1164190024137497,
-0.09861179441213608,
0.09632282704114914,
-0.05009274557232857,
-0.28127217292785645,
0.5305863618850708,
-0.06066032871603966,
0.5126925706863403,
-0.6807933449745178,
0.6392827033996582,
0.26731520891189575,
-0.35521167516708374,
-0.657684862613678,
0.5909091234207153,
0.7037057280540466,
-0.15425993502140045,
0.5132906436920166,
0.5030486583709717,
-0.9408599138259888,
-0.1721302568912506,
-0.5013998746871948,
-0.19118072092533112,
-0.48991554975509644,
1.0500730276107788,
-0.5396199822425842,
-0.7925028204917908,
0.6241370439529419,
-0.4151732921600342,
0.061598047614097595,
-0.060298118740320206,
0.47253313660621643,
-0.0956435427069664,
1.1732021570205688,
0.41541028022766113,
-0.0175315048545599,
0.10117442905902863,
-0.061295412480831146,
0.3722909092903137,
-1.3634660243988037,
-0.5228380560874939,
-0.16906704008579254,
-0.13106811046600342,
-0.04440830275416374,
-0.43892568349838257,
0.28006747364997864,
0.37423253059387207,
-0.19207949936389923,
0.2460498809814453,
-0.5338668823242188,
0.33144411444664,
-0.06054211035370827,
0.3596445918083191,
0.05423686280846596,
0.3332665264606476,
0.22493119537830353,
-0.07920490205287933,
-0.5700969099998474,
-0.33115777373313904,
1.0182758569717407,
0.7526509761810303,
0.5416719317436218,
0.41599950194358826,
0.2835812270641327,
0.2235621213912964,
0.15368542075157166,
-0.8425475358963013,
0.6313477754592896,
-0.13867126405239105,
-0.33830133080482483,
-0.32452550530433655,
-0.1642463356256485,
-0.8817458748817444,
0.1369277983903885,
0.04256367310881615,
-1.1429479122161865,
0.5811548233032227,
-0.04712594673037529,
-0.2879994213581085,
0.43603983521461487,
-0.5288600325584412,
0.4426432251930237,
-0.08210070431232452,
-0.7469298243522644,
-0.4624587893486023,
-0.6819722652435303,
0.4176144003868103,
-0.12436927855014801,
0.29031339287757874,
0.33955925703048706,
-0.4484778642654419,
0.8761656880378723,
-0.027902504429221153,
0.8426715135574341,
-0.23856715857982635,
-0.5699259638786316,
0.3362637758255005,
-0.006429887842386961,
0.6650506854057312,
-0.0756777673959732,
-0.2211848944425583,
0.49335408210754395,
-0.11383918672800064,
-0.3059481382369995,
-0.6616849899291992,
0.7943885922431946,
-0.5977760553359985,
-0.3671356439590454,
-0.02058228850364685,
-0.34881123900413513,
-0.3621024489402771,
0.027749110013246536,
-0.031097713857889175,
0.6427116394042969,
-0.07894126325845718,
0.27418044209480286,
1.1173864603042603,
-0.3893992602825165,
0.6871342062950134,
0.5430375933647156,
0.11367236822843552,
-0.8206959962844849,
0.9784940481185913,
0.07297516614198685,
0.28213509917259216,
0.5531983971595764,
-0.24674192070960999,
-0.676970899105072,
-1.061241865158081,
-0.5637875199317932,
0.4224967956542969,
-0.8326273560523987,
-0.03105342760682106,
-0.7077605724334717,
-0.17811213433742523,
-0.38455697894096375,
-0.09168139845132828,
-0.2304438203573227,
-0.0857100561261177,
-0.3869040906429291,
-0.3087522089481354,
0.08746789395809174,
0.6355520486831665,
-0.41583213210105896,
0.4788012206554413,
-0.6241540908813477,
0.10369471460580826,
-0.014908541925251484,
0.5644904971122742,
0.10778845846652985,
-0.8595841526985168,
-0.39310768246650696,
0.18154138326644897,
0.13482537865638733,
-1.24687659740448,
0.37279564142227173,
0.02937181666493416,
0.549059271812439,
0.3795090317726135,
-0.3119255304336548,
0.5717715620994568,
-0.6550642251968384,
0.7548354864120483,
0.6547675132751465,
-1.0611294507980347,
0.13623137772083282,
-0.4514787197113037,
0.38901808857917786,
0.042436644434928894,
0.207094207406044,
-0.7531039118766785,
0.18315063416957855,
-0.18325750529766083,
-1.101065993309021,
0.501183807849884,
-0.1840267926454544,
0.05490740388631821,
-0.1903752088546753,
0.5946792960166931,
-0.12101767957210541,
-0.10093118250370026,
-0.5960980653762817,
-0.07037786394357681,
0.22525793313980103,
-0.501591145992279,
0.21922187507152557,
-0.5588287711143494,
-0.1389152556657791,
-0.15584562718868256,
0.4056530296802521,
-0.13432517647743225,
0.6383715271949768,
0.1738775074481964,
-0.12957608699798584,
0.09239738434553146,
0.2784220576286316,
0.44811171293258667,
0.5081753730773926,
0.12231362611055374,
-0.04230506718158722,
0.5076492428779602,
-0.3122245669364929,
0.11789721995592117,
0.04058367386460304,
0.039945702999830246,
-0.1406533122062683,
0.3078429698944092,
0.8821429014205933,
0.0015837429091334343,
-0.6469587087631226,
0.6017228364944458,
0.2059299349784851,
-0.3306574821472168,
-0.5065049529075623,
-0.49814197421073914,
0.46271300315856934,
0.21474196016788483,
0.38094562292099,
-0.10184825956821442,
0.3889167606830597,
-0.35908788442611694,
0.43596965074539185,
0.6592611074447632,
-0.24964125454425812,
-0.5754838585853577,
0.8081933856010437,
0.29494962096214294,
-0.4116341471672058,
0.6039015650749207,
0.1801067292690277,
-0.1405842900276184,
0.5310590863227844,
0.9178106188774109,
0.9564239978790283,
-0.20051291584968567,
-0.21066555380821228,
0.3762732744216919,
0.4167199432849884,
-0.013810555450618267,
0.46832966804504395,
0.10531806945800781,
-0.44497403502464294,
-1.06989586353302,
-0.6659953594207764,
0.015363304875791073,
0.16989578306674957,
-0.46329376101493835,
0.4987611472606659,
-0.496121883392334,
0.00007218728569569066,
-0.24457047879695892,
-0.7270857095718384,
-0.09006542712450027,
0.30545714497566223,
0.6281290650367737,
1.173179268836975,
-0.6149512529373169,
0.7960808873176575,
0.26234304904937744,
0.050714071840047836,
-0.4542958736419678,
-0.32956016063690186,
-0.1830321103334427,
-0.6036878228187561,
0.31921306252479553,
-0.0032763404306024313,
-0.3436298370361328,
0.37613537907600403,
-0.4048216938972473,
-0.9037798047065735,
1.0323591232299805,
0.5871131420135498,
-0.8124549388885498,
-0.2398127168416977,
0.25619998574256897,
0.4563577175140381,
-0.2212085872888565,
0.835953950881958,
0.7816703915596008,
0.5016500949859619,
-0.11449329555034637,
-0.7916930317878723,
0.20886360108852386,
-0.1538543701171875,
0.05119529366493225,
0.13653545081615448,
-0.3745559751987457,
0.1683967411518097,
-0.22927089035511017,
-0.2718309164047241,
0.13771748542785645,
0.9302703738212585,
-0.04088746756315231,
0.04338227957487106,
0.31365224719047546,
0.46114662289619446,
0.4501994252204895,
-0.05438448488712311,
0.5811052322387695,
-0.5113444924354553,
-0.07411693036556244,
0.8875352144241333,
-0.04885324090719223,
1.027017593383789,
0.5488212704658508,
-0.17979958653450012,
0.4073193669319153,
0.6208674311637878,
0.3118276298046112,
0.3667495548725128,
0.38353440165519714,
-0.5129019021987915,
-0.23473000526428223,
-0.18272830545902252,
-0.251844197511673,
0.32024261355400085,
0.8301587104797363,
-0.2514111399650574,
-0.2007042020559311,
0.27500852942466736,
-0.03538453206419945,
0.17550528049468994,
-0.28461477160453796,
0.7204455137252808,
0.2382264882326126,
-0.5119988322257996,
0.7372469902038574,
0.08430729061365128,
0.8669823408126831,
-0.8532664775848389,
-0.09293172508478165,
-0.0609639547765255,
0.044915392994880676,
-0.45016852021217346,
-0.7015683650970459,
0.43621399998664856,
-0.39532044529914856,
-0.20505626499652863,
0.08280953764915466,
0.4423995912075043,
-0.6172296404838562,
0.09864265471696854,
0.7616934776306152,
0.35146594047546387,
0.18822114169597626,
0.05750632286071777,
-0.3094172179698944,
0.46055248379707336,
0.15476058423519135,
-0.25603511929512024,
0.36476248502731323,
-0.027841757982969284,
-0.0032809260301291943,
0.5867248177528381,
0.7661811113357544,
0.14736390113830566,
0.0989903137087822,
0.22717975080013275,
0.6627548336982727,
-0.5683329105377197,
-0.517894983291626,
-0.9710390567779541,
0.6468610167503357,
-0.0764530748128891,
0.041655585169792175,
0.3033975064754486,
0.6637698411941528,
0.2772975265979767,
0.1170230507850647,
0.7826693058013916,
-0.03646240755915642,
0.35208743810653687,
-0.3751930594444275,
0.5823272466659546,
-0.35644617676734924,
0.29898685216903687,
0.015432442538440228,
-0.6845093965530396,
-0.39566078782081604,
0.31738394498825073,
-0.028080902993679047,
-0.00807622354477644,
0.6056021451950073,
1.0822069644927979,
0.1548430323600769,
0.2550565004348755,
0.5612360239028931,
0.5088441371917725,
0.5054054260253906,
1.0368199348449707,
0.650467574596405,
-0.25828030705451965,
0.5255776047706604,
0.37464672327041626,
-0.8650233745574951,
0.22830510139465332,
-0.5457148551940918,
-0.41878846287727356,
-0.32247239351272583,
-0.3329775631427765,
-0.32345420122146606,
0.3443538546562195,
0.7701804041862488,
0.5803881883621216,
-0.5505442023277283,
-0.33548206090927124,
-0.46815478801727295,
-0.31199872493743896,
-0.22285789251327515,
-0.11061365902423859,
0.4127882421016693,
-0.1009153425693512,
-0.98128741979599,
0.7342231273651123,
0.48240435123443604,
0.02364245057106018,
-0.4122970700263977,
-0.270647257566452,
-0.1262952834367752,
0.17405594885349274,
0.9433069229125977,
0.49635979533195496,
-0.6944968700408936,
-0.11806295067071915,
0.13921810686588287,
0.20875106751918793,
-0.1920146942138672,
0.36135679483413696,
-0.7238966226577759,
0.34692656993865967,
0.5720613598823547,
0.9016848206520081,
0.3378687798976898,
-0.3498293459415436,
0.8771899342536926,
-0.1483747363090515,
0.040477972477674484,
0.10478019714355469,
0.5579520463943481,
0.3236415386199951,
-0.4398665428161621,
0.21433456242084503,
0.0892665907740593,
-0.49893295764923096,
-0.9005287289619446,
0.45586302876472473,
-1.1797666549682617,
-0.41351965069770813,
1.3122214078903198,
-0.1579740047454834,
-0.5121443867683411,
-0.3207327127456665,
-0.21932284533977509,
0.28560498356819153,
-0.04980671778321266,
0.393002450466156,
0.6410250663757324,
-0.18216653168201447,
-0.3583296537399292,
-0.3442666530609131,
0.07438906282186508,
0.6119394302368164,
-0.792946457862854,
0.30286258459091187,
0.7022896409034729,
0.34082743525505066,
-0.04864661023020744,
0.497272789478302,
-0.33983689546585083,
0.4850245416164398,
0.07799848169088364,
0.2934551537036896,
-0.2966122031211853,
-0.23207296431064606,
-0.8291289210319519,
0.27440953254699707,
-0.010285552591085434,
-0.1701066792011261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11566v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11566v1 | MEMLA: Enhancing Multilingual Knowledge Editing with Neuron-Masked Low-Rank Adaptation | 2024-06-17T14:03:50 | 2024-06-17T14:03:50 | Jiakuan Xie, Pengfei Cao, Yuheng Chen, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge editing aims to adjust the knowledge within large language models
(LLMs) to prevent their responses from becoming obsolete or inaccurate.
However, existing works on knowledge editing are primarily conducted in a
single language, which is inadequate for multilingual language models. In this
paper, we focus on multilingual knowledge editing (MKE), which requires
propagating updates across multiple languages. This necessity poses a
significant challenge for the task. Furthermore, the limited availability of a
comprehensive dataset for MKE exacerbates this challenge, hindering progress in
this area. Hence, we introduce the Multilingual Knowledge Editing Benchmark
(MKEB), a novel dataset comprising 12 languages and providing a complete
evaluation framework. Additionally, we propose a method that enhances
Multilingual knowledge Editing with neuron-Masked Low-Rank Adaptation (MEMLA).
Specifically, we identify two categories of knowledge neurons to improve
editing precision. Moreover, we perform LoRA-based editing with neuron masks to
efficiently modify parameters and facilitate the propagation of updates across
multiple languages. Experiments demonstrate that our method outperforms
existing baselines and significantly enhances the multi-hop reasoning
capability of the edited model, with minimal impact on its downstream task
performance. The dataset and code will be made publicly available. | [
-0.25579017400741577,
-0.6897227764129639,
0.26060956716537476,
0.3122510015964508,
-0.04475409537553787,
0.2697972357273102,
-0.4950048625469208,
-0.431884229183197,
0.4228580892086029,
0.2662755846977234,
-0.3006097376346588,
-0.6721722483634949,
-0.7317180037498474,
0.09690440446138382,
0.17926204204559326,
0.676706075668335,
-0.011147105135023594,
0.21056298911571503,
-0.18214818835258484,
-0.49737635254859924,
-0.7939156293869019,
-0.5090160369873047,
-0.7049925923347473,
-0.31076565384864807,
0.7762753367424011,
0.4619479179382324,
0.5632216334342957,
0.21767517924308777,
0.1219012513756752,
0.28393492102622986,
-0.38514187932014465,
0.5528861284255981,
-0.1308438777923584,
0.0714421421289444,
-0.3294788599014282,
-0.37029194831848145,
-0.9611204862594604,
-0.23340949416160583,
0.6799074411392212,
0.6745358109474182,
-0.11369171738624573,
0.16413205862045288,
0.059778645634651184,
0.6390524506568909,
-0.8810356855392456,
0.01966768689453602,
-0.6812716722488403,
-0.0744488388299942,
-0.10987204313278198,
0.1118059828877449,
-0.49046313762664795,
-0.21766401827335358,
-0.3043782413005829,
-0.8344583511352539,
-0.2742045521736145,
-0.2327648401260376,
0.36675506830215454,
0.23466208577156067,
-0.18744997680187225,
0.18614166975021362,
-0.2924162447452545,
0.4632868766784668,
-0.9296573996543884,
0.4364686906337738,
0.3788146674633026,
0.22464941442012787,
-0.07131706178188324,
-0.41370800137519836,
-0.602356493473053,
0.03279462084174156,
-0.011126832105219364,
-0.04686648026108742,
-0.28419172763824463,
-0.08792410790920258,
0.4223812520503998,
-0.2232147604227066,
-0.3860131800174713,
0.13872340321540833,
-0.15655188262462616,
-0.3141976296901703,
0.2938190698623657,
-0.16769765317440033,
0.26706135272979736,
-0.25661301612854004,
-0.04015208035707474,
-0.19930697977542877,
-0.7297875881195068,
-0.06078016385436058,
0.4533385634422302,
0.09305934607982635,
0.049813415855169296,
0.402010440826416,
-0.47762128710746765,
0.8394617438316345,
-0.20947018265724182,
-0.2710649371147156,
0.35928064584732056,
-0.13210758566856384,
-0.1981782466173172,
0.1390114277601242,
0.5253710746765137,
0.4166603088378906,
0.09740849584341049,
-0.2420060932636261,
-0.08465954661369324,
-0.28451070189476013,
0.08441903442144394,
-0.778806746006012,
-0.15911048650741577,
-0.11264137923717499,
-0.3300483226776123,
-0.21163545548915863,
-0.5124126076698303,
-0.9084129929542542,
-0.6586694121360779,
-0.19647061824798584,
0.6016759276390076,
-0.4304257035255432,
-0.11659342795610428,
0.3002879321575165,
-0.0543314591050148,
-0.2011481076478958,
0.6281564235687256,
-0.8997339606285095,
0.10149762779474258,
0.2980356514453888,
0.6254407167434692,
0.11140527576208115,
-0.8635715842247009,
-0.42242202162742615,
0.3510524332523346,
-0.4160468280315399,
0.8096169233322144,
-0.48597729206085205,
0.08519284427165985,
-0.2526894509792328,
-0.09702399373054504,
-0.23759706318378448,
-0.5432143807411194,
0.21393240988254547,
-0.8310866951942444,
-0.1435660868883133,
-0.20663480460643768,
-0.33308619260787964,
-0.381741464138031,
0.5083734393119812,
-0.5369439125061035,
0.8762041926383972,
-0.06067771464586258,
-0.43054336309432983,
0.33101195096969604,
-0.9291661381721497,
-0.5436142683029175,
-0.3504250645637512,
0.08375659584999084,
-0.21961459517478943,
-0.05363158509135246,
0.7388148903846741,
0.32934990525245667,
-0.09754622727632523,
0.3891664445400238,
-0.16001665592193604,
-0.07240470498800278,
0.3279396593570709,
-0.45759454369544983,
0.6404163241386414,
-0.12381055951118469,
-0.14982357621192932,
0.1916177123785019,
-0.8307074308395386,
0.020273178815841675,
-0.19745756685733795,
-0.3156881034374237,
-0.3923891484737396,
-0.2053089737892151,
-0.05894596874713898,
0.35595703125,
0.2741716206073761,
-0.4841289818286896,
0.5779688954353333,
0.033384617418050766,
0.45938849449157715,
0.967043399810791,
0.17671149969100952,
0.5295091867446899,
-0.12563133239746094,
0.32768747210502625,
0.2791825234889984,
0.3761407434940338,
0.019718578085303307,
-0.6293387413024902,
-0.5951289534568787,
-0.1739216297864914,
0.7594345211982727,
0.5532925724983215,
-1.1623116731643677,
0.022466177120804787,
-0.5225799083709717,
-0.5155254602432251,
-0.7485356330871582,
0.5374405980110168,
0.26701784133911133,
0.44321656227111816,
0.6592035889625549,
-0.14135578274726868,
-0.18564821779727936,
-0.9416754245758057,
-0.45333027839660645,
0.16146770119667053,
0.12013484537601471,
0.18465647101402283,
0.3011172115802765,
-0.22728438675403595,
0.6036235690116882,
-0.4325640797615051,
-0.4203861951828003,
-0.04711957648396492,
0.20628294348716736,
0.3493584990501404,
0.7653248310089111,
0.5055714249610901,
-0.4873533844947815,
-0.406215637922287,
0.17257575690746307,
-0.8299607038497925,
-0.07987973839044571,
-0.25288301706314087,
-0.2920033931732178,
0.10670915246009827,
0.659417450428009,
-0.5113527178764343,
0.27882879972457886,
0.691590428352356,
-0.21592973172664642,
0.3667886555194855,
-0.4566269814968109,
0.5062156915664673,
-1.1796571016311646,
-0.03437744826078415,
-0.4031933844089508,
-0.011065829545259476,
-0.6926694512367249,
-0.05136618763208389,
0.5271998047828674,
-0.13622714579105377,
-0.4251523017883301,
0.6629981398582458,
-0.40603935718536377,
0.037165045738220215,
-0.1395566314458847,
0.1708921194076538,
0.1584470570087433,
0.8772366642951965,
-0.11079172790050507,
0.695574164390564,
0.4272250831127167,
-0.3432728946208954,
0.048516761511564255,
0.44553688168525696,
-0.6569948196411133,
0.5158936381340027,
-0.26501891016960144,
0.33194372057914734,
0.03707532212138176,
-0.0420035794377327,
-0.3992568254470825,
-0.04767279699444771,
0.19225206971168518,
-0.4321385324001312,
0.4909800589084625,
-0.19205264747142792,
-0.7670141458511353,
0.2597273886203766,
-0.20799022912979126,
0.632941484451294,
0.09040649235248566,
-0.5802986025810242,
0.6998817324638367,
0.3016621768474579,
-0.2543357312679291,
-1.000704288482666,
-0.7108220458030701,
0.5780524611473083,
0.15388482809066772,
-0.7189888954162598,
0.4396224319934845,
-0.14785803854465485,
-0.2292567789554596,
-0.041213229298591614,
-0.15352781116962433,
-0.09183740615844727,
-0.00812514964491129,
-0.2538529336452484,
0.10928201675415039,
-0.2520478367805481,
0.21263591945171356,
0.5159866809844971,
-0.1721571534872055,
-0.26951950788497925,
-0.10966499894857407,
0.2604297995567322,
0.2022096961736679,
-0.3605605363845825,
-0.23803257942199707,
0.12185081094503403,
0.4972239136695862,
-0.46473073959350586,
0.7381515502929688,
0.5141721367835999,
-0.5252265930175781,
-0.35729479789733887,
-0.677632749080658,
-0.2423131763935089,
-0.38502657413482666,
0.5165814161300659,
-0.5910071134567261,
-0.806857705116272,
0.5687925815582275,
-0.2481287717819214,
-0.2148439735174179,
0.31569695472717285,
0.22061793506145477,
0.12220056354999542,
0.598786473274231,
0.5083093047142029,
-0.23843054473400116,
0.29095491766929626,
-0.018132483586668968,
0.16307786107063293,
-1.1529377698898315,
-0.16887600719928741,
-0.4428040087223053,
-0.6659687757492065,
-0.41687461733818054,
-0.8174976110458374,
0.5641515254974365,
0.44848451018333435,
0.10134487599134445,
0.338003545999527,
-0.3438337445259094,
0.7127716541290283,
0.546290934085846,
0.38629189133644104,
0.5480062961578369,
-0.09430617839097977,
-0.2297196388244629,
-0.21622344851493835,
-0.9021358489990234,
-0.2111527919769287,
1.079958438873291,
0.05775973200798035,
0.6473793983459473,
0.32456719875335693,
0.2357136756181717,
0.42191022634506226,
0.40400123596191406,
-0.3786761462688446,
0.4316692054271698,
-0.26085197925567627,
-0.5371248722076416,
-0.2966151535511017,
-0.24511969089508057,
-0.38889938592910767,
0.5308825969696045,
-0.41514310240745544,
-0.6773611903190613,
0.6031324863433838,
0.008418651297688484,
-0.18782998621463776,
0.7108221054077148,
-0.8174086809158325,
1.1560492515563965,
-0.07929228246212006,
-0.46335166692733765,
-0.46078285574913025,
-0.5470854043960571,
0.17348887026309967,
-0.2316596359014511,
0.3069206774234772,
-0.18695902824401855,
0.023998968303203583,
0.7069243788719177,
-0.18566590547561646,
0.8144142627716064,
-0.3302238881587982,
0.046678394079208374,
-0.11330883949995041,
0.11162185668945312,
0.6238030791282654,
0.2843410074710846,
-0.3351043462753296,
0.5070636868476868,
-0.27761515974998474,
-0.4500437378883362,
-0.7924389243125916,
0.6884358525276184,
-0.6699872612953186,
-0.4205659329891205,
-0.23302356898784637,
-0.8218482136726379,
-0.5498080253601074,
0.2579919099807739,
-0.07340139150619507,
0.49043840169906616,
-0.15069997310638428,
0.05841097980737686,
0.5704920291900635,
-0.5471537709236145,
0.47215330600738525,
0.5342800617218018,
-0.24266715347766876,
-0.7340538501739502,
0.7904499173164368,
0.30189499258995056,
0.31020388007164,
0.48828384280204773,
-0.08522655069828033,
-0.003602628130465746,
-0.7748369574546814,
-0.9571338295936584,
0.10266359895467758,
-1.1881353855133057,
-0.29158395528793335,
-0.771857500076294,
-0.06990804523229599,
-0.4309993088245392,
-0.28848832845687866,
-0.23967783153057098,
-0.6215071082115173,
0.11485069245100021,
0.07764074951410294,
0.4703422486782074,
0.6680145859718323,
-0.33805692195892334,
0.2884521484375,
-0.6138454675674438,
0.5988094210624695,
0.43087881803512573,
0.5203627943992615,
0.05218471959233284,
-0.48075538873672485,
-0.4100396931171417,
0.055233296006917953,
-0.06425979733467102,
-0.8550317287445068,
0.1443660408258438,
0.2086520791053772,
0.6106295585632324,
-0.11132623255252838,
-0.22118604183197021,
0.8787703514099121,
-0.6232094764709473,
0.4405459761619568,
0.08008196949958801,
-1.1834617853164673,
0.3872736394405365,
-0.15265239775180817,
0.4653938114643097,
0.5980127453804016,
-0.02092832513153553,
-0.9045408368110657,
-0.21062421798706055,
-0.32664480805397034,
-0.5058655738830566,
0.7747209668159485,
0.03885561227798462,
0.11534063518047333,
0.20228445529937744,
0.31203392148017883,
0.0890222117304802,
0.34350529313087463,
-0.7754883766174316,
-0.30519697070121765,
-0.2713596224784851,
0.1790611296892166,
-0.27909061312675476,
-0.36568301916122437,
0.014795917086303234,
-0.5430284142494202,
0.9833255410194397,
-0.401300311088562,
0.06348761916160583,
0.20668259263038635,
-0.6633985638618469,
0.08113694936037064,
0.5399540066719055,
0.954189658164978,
0.8218554258346558,
-0.22596271336078644,
0.15337710082530975,
0.6352021098136902,
-0.49017614126205444,
0.10294204950332642,
0.07699893414974213,
-0.29666635394096375,
0.05238424986600876,
0.23334389925003052,
0.8047168254852295,
0.46950146555900574,
-0.36335888504981995,
0.3395507037639618,
0.008697605691850185,
-0.13656580448150635,
0.2949123978614807,
-0.21871091425418854,
0.29457518458366394,
0.22025257349014282,
0.13501949608325958,
0.7219343781471252,
-0.10790009796619415,
-0.00784309022128582,
0.04450144246220589,
0.10992014408111572,
-0.17909637093544006,
-0.12983077764511108,
0.6254151463508606,
0.00889565795660019,
-0.12932780385017395,
0.43394196033477783,
-0.20869489014148712,
-0.27440130710601807,
0.42441946268081665,
0.4379158616065979,
0.750214159488678,
-0.364776074886322,
0.17886273562908173,
0.5006772875785828,
0.8335655331611633,
0.21898077428340912,
0.04333697631955147,
0.16360615193843842,
-0.8886660933494568,
-0.7614117860794067,
-0.5547912120819092,
-0.5002890229225159,
0.14948725700378418,
-0.3203747570514679,
0.36250412464141846,
-0.3827427327632904,
0.1765393614768982,
0.2568661868572235,
-0.5233655571937561,
-0.32859647274017334,
0.04221625626087189,
-0.055891621857881546,
1.1125235557556152,
-0.551772952079773,
1.2368290424346924,
0.7072530388832092,
-0.24377691745758057,
-0.39004701375961304,
-0.2253069430589676,
-0.1877160370349884,
-0.6889894008636475,
0.29926350712776184,
-0.012289220467209816,
-0.026870040223002434,
-0.020348740741610527,
-0.29800403118133545,
-0.676649808883667,
0.9894368052482605,
0.7047443389892578,
-0.3064453601837158,
0.2029729038476944,
0.22731252014636993,
0.42721089720726013,
-0.2042437493801117,
0.04671059548854828,
0.32444870471954346,
0.73714679479599,
-0.27995961904525757,
-0.7951558828353882,
-0.12873496115207672,
-0.37913888692855835,
-0.1092088371515274,
0.17744141817092896,
-0.4530874788761139,
0.7947115898132324,
-0.06303179264068604,
0.5205972194671631,
-0.16383901238441467,
0.29808950424194336,
-0.1389078050851822,
0.03695184737443924,
0.28949958086013794,
0.7597501277923584,
0.7582337856292725,
0.052441589534282684,
0.6922698616981506,
-0.30159226059913635,
0.05653780326247215,
1.4542020559310913,
-0.25823983550071716,
0.9398123025894165,
0.555075466632843,
0.16438622772693634,
0.5269191861152649,
0.4182823896408081,
0.026201626285910606,
0.5061230063438416,
-0.024512581527233124,
-0.3656942546367645,
-0.2847384512424469,
-0.059384606778621674,
-0.31793737411499023,
0.5658955574035645,
0.2066536396741867,
-0.14512427151203156,
-0.30484241247177124,
0.25439324975013733,
0.3244438171386719,
0.09069442749023438,
-0.4615006148815155,
0.8766245245933533,
-0.08859745413064957,
-0.5972445011138916,
0.5551941394805908,
0.30668967962265015,
0.5987169742584229,
-0.5800185799598694,
-0.16908037662506104,
-0.2676556706428528,
0.22929362952709198,
-0.12567032873630524,
-0.5071195363998413,
0.22909942269325256,
-0.03280111774802208,
-0.3860475420951843,
-0.2755637466907501,
0.9046397805213928,
-0.4976237118244171,
-0.5019505620002747,
0.5540232062339783,
0.8002431392669678,
-0.10175337642431259,
-0.3758796751499176,
-0.7833248376846313,
-0.06754684448242188,
-0.06296468526124954,
-0.16107892990112305,
0.546417236328125,
0.2770327925682068,
-0.20449134707450867,
0.4742524325847626,
0.7671051621437073,
0.18809013068675995,
0.2227378934621811,
0.2216029018163681,
0.7817681431770325,
-0.6928508877754211,
-0.2753210961818695,
-0.7533663511276245,
0.5272831320762634,
-0.20402131974697113,
-0.35267406702041626,
0.6055140495300293,
0.5266724824905396,
0.8305094838142395,
-0.3337418735027313,
0.6999108195304871,
-0.12147369980812073,
0.21057502925395966,
-0.7416844367980957,
1.2613555192947388,
-0.5482643842697144,
0.037600189447402954,
-0.252856582403183,
-0.9818702936172485,
-0.5586072206497192,
0.32758036255836487,
-0.3093639612197876,
-0.15820567309856415,
0.8147138357162476,
1.0868854522705078,
-0.15025067329406738,
-0.13835956156253815,
0.6524015665054321,
0.479860782623291,
0.03933469206094742,
0.5742146372795105,
0.6529681086540222,
-0.6854525208473206,
0.24515897035598755,
-0.7022289633750916,
0.013132390566170216,
0.05245671793818474,
-1.0124298334121704,
-0.8741588592529297,
-0.39308059215545654,
-0.3133377730846405,
-0.17730921506881714,
0.24966317415237427,
0.8669620752334595,
0.6908021569252014,
-0.8502745032310486,
-0.16902899742126465,
0.26158607006073,
0.5252726674079895,
-0.6246693730354309,
-0.04548419266939163,
0.5148935317993164,
-0.419914573431015,
-0.7012722492218018,
0.7956152558326721,
0.4784180819988251,
-0.3166208267211914,
0.1477920264005661,
-0.14370667934417725,
-0.6478484869003296,
-0.17691677808761597,
0.7138292789459229,
0.02211265079677105,
-0.4419931471347809,
-0.23434904217720032,
0.013949123211205006,
0.02777579426765442,
0.31071656942367554,
0.6016618013381958,
-0.5566821694374084,
0.8852042555809021,
0.2734365165233612,
0.837834894657135,
0.3504951298236847,
-0.4399997591972351,
0.2674160897731781,
-0.9646734595298767,
0.23317529261112213,
-0.051929082721471786,
0.548291802406311,
0.4605623781681061,
-0.09986305236816406,
0.4887411296367645,
0.27355799078941345,
-0.42860516905784607,
-0.5762912034988403,
-0.23407089710235596,
-0.9416065812110901,
-0.3261818289756775,
0.9967330098152161,
-0.07384481281042099,
-0.18835489451885223,
-0.08223532885313034,
-0.28141650557518005,
0.21412451565265656,
-0.1839342713356018,
0.7080066204071045,
0.8869802355766296,
0.15562306344509125,
-0.22486376762390137,
-0.8249312043190002,
0.4989372789859772,
0.5534814596176147,
-1.1198070049285889,
0.04580135643482208,
0.5497259497642517,
0.21011868119239807,
0.2224833071231842,
0.4503529965877533,
-0.10087865591049194,
0.7179264426231384,
-0.05974598973989487,
0.6439787149429321,
-0.18527348339557648,
-0.4356010854244232,
-0.5821699500083923,
0.16495107114315033,
0.26739445328712463,
-0.017689310014247894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11565v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11565v2 | Extrinsic Evaluation of Cultural Competence in Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T14:03:27 | 2024-06-19T05:18:56 | Shaily Bhatt, Fernando Diaz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Productive interactions between diverse users and language technologies
require outputs from the latter to be culturally relevant and sensitive. Prior
works have evaluated models' knowledge of cultural norms, values, and
artifacts, without considering how this knowledge manifests in downstream
applications. In this work, we focus on extrinsic evaluation of cultural
competence in two text generation tasks, open-ended question answering and
story generation. We quantitatively and qualitatively evaluate model outputs
when an explicit cue of culture, specifically nationality, is perturbed in the
prompts. Although we find that model outputs do vary when varying nationalities
and feature culturally relevant words, we also find weak correlations between
text similarity of outputs for different countries and the cultural values of
these countries. Finally, we discuss important considerations in designing
comprehensive evaluation of cultural competence in user-facing tasks. | [
-0.29683783650398254,
-0.5816128849983215,
0.2712453603744507,
0.042359575629234314,
-0.17971104383468628,
0.04060118645429611,
-0.7561396956443787,
-0.5124331116676331,
-0.030434798449277878,
0.4094306528568268,
-0.4837553799152374,
-0.2512563169002533,
-0.23122696578502655,
0.15139199793338776,
-0.29327189922332764,
1.2373911142349243,
-0.2990555465221405,
-0.3189750015735626,
-0.4485955238342285,
-0.3407195806503296,
-0.49440792202949524,
-0.6841115951538086,
-0.6496461629867554,
-0.17963777482509613,
0.26740700006484985,
0.5218247175216675,
0.6730159521102905,
0.1834947019815445,
0.34458887577056885,
0.25316622853279114,
-0.13807238638401031,
-0.01671679876744747,
-0.6359097957611084,
0.6441255211830139,
-0.3858289420604706,
-0.2280016988515854,
0.03209434449672699,
0.08137150853872299,
0.34263768792152405,
0.5226611495018005,
0.2692895531654358,
0.6845320463180542,
0.11511937528848648,
0.39000940322875977,
-0.44065120816230774,
0.04354051873087883,
-0.3223481774330139,
0.11641459167003632,
0.06907636672258377,
-0.4334504008293152,
-0.46172550320625305,
-0.5320907831192017,
0.2902902066707611,
-0.3020007312297821,
0.09669231623411179,
-0.4135216474533081,
0.7414138913154602,
-0.05551493912935257,
-0.9188080430030823,
-0.6862428188323975,
-1.0322990417480469,
0.7387004494667053,
-0.5005369186401367,
0.18743270635604858,
0.24264952540397644,
0.31265953183174133,
0.22357730567455292,
-0.7568576335906982,
-0.5941365361213684,
-0.488547146320343,
0.05569363757967949,
0.38492393493652344,
-0.0025504636578261852,
-0.42015182971954346,
0.4543478190898895,
0.4378548562526703,
-0.5841006636619568,
0.24372954666614532,
-0.4606952369213104,
-0.04814109951257706,
0.6734471917152405,
0.2972720265388489,
0.6004543900489807,
-0.16466882824897766,
-0.19973264634609222,
-0.22087760269641876,
-0.5654043555259705,
0.6122828722000122,
0.8340579271316528,
0.3314877152442932,
-0.3498450517654419,
0.5963801741600037,
-0.40232938528060913,
0.6200659871101379,
-0.2315891534090042,
0.027250856161117554,
0.17726477980613708,
-0.6896187663078308,
0.2751579284667969,
-0.2463579624891281,
0.5788803696632385,
0.630219042301178,
0.6525185108184814,
-0.006085629109293222,
0.05210604518651962,
-0.15901464223861694,
0.17429298162460327,
-0.8072472214698792,
0.13031218945980072,
0.3352176547050476,
-0.47900012135505676,
-0.10024698078632355,
0.23958614468574524,
-0.5382565259933472,
-0.4372471570968628,
-0.1725739985704422,
0.2318485677242279,
-0.24937419593334198,
-0.398160845041275,
-0.24461857974529266,
-0.28956589102745056,
0.10667632520198822,
0.17060647904872894,
-1.0082441568374634,
-0.0527578741312027,
0.3897552192211151,
0.517058789730072,
-0.2177630364894867,
-0.17832832038402557,
-0.35912349820137024,
-0.1962725818157196,
-0.42056986689567566,
0.33805373311042786,
-0.5782732367515564,
-0.3856754004955292,
0.2298479527235031,
-0.04988294839859009,
0.07813620567321777,
-0.4215888977050781,
0.8076924085617065,
-0.572592556476593,
0.36966225504875183,
-0.5730058550834656,
-0.03174610435962677,
-0.2907077968120575,
0.11000824719667435,
-0.7521684169769287,
0.8146365880966187,
0.4178783893585205,
-0.7892646193504333,
0.6712616682052612,
-0.4126763641834259,
-0.5584638714790344,
0.2652759850025177,
-0.04988988861441612,
0.18880362808704376,
0.28740325570106506,
-0.12715594470500946,
0.30265355110168457,
-0.34517136216163635,
0.24547280371189117,
0.05058484151959419,
-0.2779633104801178,
0.6015715003013611,
-0.3382033109664917,
0.8388910293579102,
0.30451956391334534,
-0.25763195753097534,
0.1804717779159546,
-0.7532563805580139,
0.2505597770214081,
0.09475771337747574,
-0.5189029574394226,
-0.49194779992103577,
-0.08827576786279678,
0.01737634651362896,
0.5744861364364624,
0.3310527503490448,
-0.6473455429077148,
-0.2798720896244049,
-0.2404915690422058,
0.5516107082366943,
0.3876076638698578,
0.08327677100896835,
0.32146164774894714,
-0.2882058322429657,
0.7702614068984985,
-0.05619366839528084,
-0.1361256241798401,
-0.4833652973175049,
-0.47925880551338196,
-0.4836671054363251,
0.15246573090553284,
0.044099025428295135,
0.5062190294265747,
-1.1340100765228271,
0.04614388197660446,
-0.1012105718255043,
-0.8095323443412781,
-0.11759710311889648,
0.046503547579050064,
0.35377585887908936,
0.5331993699073792,
-0.11798381805419922,
-0.6050575971603394,
-0.3931524455547333,
-0.6893249750137329,
-0.52634596824646,
-0.4613095223903656,
-0.07688180357217789,
0.5082924962043762,
0.5001875758171082,
0.4444253742694855,
0.8793312907218933,
-0.16787977516651154,
0.15937307476997375,
-0.21860182285308838,
0.38125693798065186,
0.2205801159143448,
0.4146580696105957,
0.48159119486808777,
-0.8646203875541687,
-0.70166015625,
0.3807086944580078,
-0.7733011245727539,
-0.1906035989522934,
-0.14516887068748474,
0.01593506522476673,
0.5634306073188782,
0.29930856823921204,
-0.32069987058639526,
0.17899379134178162,
0.7433828711509705,
-0.6011137366294861,
0.6386266946792603,
-0.2282988280057907,
0.6713137030601501,
-0.9492099285125732,
0.35647422075271606,
-0.08437827229499817,
0.18139466643333435,
-0.9300139546394348,
0.27558186650276184,
0.09983561933040619,
-0.31112274527549744,
-0.4123067557811737,
0.7840731143951416,
-0.20901711285114288,
0.08497557789087296,
0.02283291332423687,
0.18138033151626587,
0.09211225807666779,
0.13813690841197968,
0.42950567603111267,
0.6812784671783447,
-0.03125527873635292,
-0.340920627117157,
0.472451388835907,
0.1863074004650116,
-0.7700381875038147,
0.7561818361282349,
-0.5604420304298401,
0.2873164415359497,
-0.0287216417491436,
-0.005529267713427544,
-1.230922818183899,
-0.2716587781906128,
-0.09426247328519821,
-0.7026197910308838,
-0.07607913762331009,
0.05280156806111336,
-0.5139075517654419,
-0.6453546285629272,
-0.1097528263926506,
0.6482199430465698,
0.5254164934158325,
-0.16389867663383484,
0.20836904644966125,
-0.03615201264619827,
-0.5640953183174133,
-0.4267716407775879,
-0.6763846278190613,
-0.13375356793403625,
-0.4010642468929291,
-0.8654956221580505,
-0.11193666607141495,
-0.18092483282089233,
-0.37485477328300476,
-0.18631865084171295,
0.18083085119724274,
-0.13099297881126404,
0.192567840218544,
0.07278628647327423,
-0.05910051241517067,
-0.32934385538101196,
0.15808512270450592,
0.20959733426570892,
0.24563971161842346,
0.18036969006061554,
-0.18744122982025146,
0.523209273815155,
0.014853869564831257,
-0.3936224579811096,
0.06730630993843079,
0.5262184739112854,
0.6502583622932434,
-0.689299464225769,
0.8033354878425598,
0.6192816495895386,
-0.2900868356227875,
0.08678034693002701,
-0.411293625831604,
-0.12157965451478958,
-0.4132203757762909,
0.5827339887619019,
-0.43833091855049133,
-1.0975552797317505,
0.9548608660697937,
0.6026756763458252,
0.12314389646053314,
0.4874016344547272,
0.8913329839706421,
0.15196803212165833,
0.8160384297370911,
0.5657853484153748,
0.7172825932502747,
0.07575409859418869,
0.15157005190849304,
0.31566888093948364,
-0.656159520149231,
-0.3604682385921478,
-0.6972935795783997,
-0.16335541009902954,
-0.660550057888031,
-0.2516321539878845,
0.38321954011917114,
-0.2274552881717682,
-0.4268668591976166,
0.2939958870410919,
-0.07044712454080582,
0.18181021511554718,
0.6781156063079834,
-0.17890484631061554,
0.44217172265052795,
0.0221568513661623,
-0.17421603202819824,
-0.22127221524715424,
-0.6166747808456421,
-0.7055696845054626,
0.8529847264289856,
0.3917737603187561,
0.5849398374557495,
0.3104986548423767,
0.31652677059173584,
0.08193595707416534,
0.33038684725761414,
-0.6247129440307617,
0.24791932106018066,
-0.3362779915332794,
-0.8406474590301514,
-0.44018813967704773,
-0.40149906277656555,
-0.5738332867622375,
-0.022243557497859,
-0.21820536255836487,
-0.8669766783714294,
-0.007483338005840778,
0.07236906886100769,
-0.5926972031593323,
0.10422418266534805,
-0.7717847228050232,
0.8429246544837952,
-0.2581498622894287,
-0.34152570366859436,
0.11042014509439468,
-0.5492826104164124,
0.49574825167655945,
-0.3123495876789093,
0.04527236521244049,
0.19231754541397095,
0.03219452500343323,
0.8196796774864197,
0.21418000757694244,
0.7171798944473267,
-0.068916454911232,
-0.33311301469802856,
0.5701248645782471,
0.4476160705089569,
-0.014479530975222588,
-0.07772519439458847,
-0.4653770923614502,
-0.038756113499403,
0.3306695520877838,
-0.050493791699409485,
-0.5808503031730652,
0.577502965927124,
-0.7689775228500366,
-0.6603893041610718,
0.0042003062553703785,
-0.9348735213279724,
-0.21990329027175903,
0.04013318940997124,
0.4786944091320038,
0.42630940675735474,
-0.32850784063339233,
0.3308103680610657,
0.3493579626083374,
-0.7166323065757751,
0.30528196692466736,
0.49975255131721497,
-0.08926181495189667,
-0.07216067612171173,
0.6972275972366333,
0.4304685890674591,
0.5454137325286865,
0.09737890213727951,
0.13930971920490265,
-0.28307345509529114,
-0.21824003756046295,
-0.7767855525016785,
-0.0487033911049366,
-0.9918688535690308,
0.0664973184466362,
-0.4856564402580261,
-0.19858428835868835,
-0.2385108768939972,
-0.20501919090747833,
0.12563665211200714,
-0.3940596580505371,
-0.2400597482919693,
-0.10063672810792923,
0.12059205025434494,
0.7597426772117615,
0.10850442945957184,
0.196245938539505,
-0.8208808302879333,
-0.09255984425544739,
0.18989752233028412,
0.19393469393253326,
0.1589512974023819,
-0.7275123000144958,
-0.4293991029262543,
0.1185406893491745,
-0.15088149905204773,
-0.889208972454071,
0.14964739978313446,
0.10629168897867203,
0.62834233045578,
0.5241753458976746,
0.2779969871044159,
0.08085181564092636,
-0.20520904660224915,
1.2083399295806885,
0.04121864214539528,
-0.9769809246063232,
0.30119073390960693,
-0.4719228446483612,
0.5789985060691833,
0.5167300701141357,
0.6430320143699646,
-1.1243549585342407,
-0.48926401138305664,
-0.3258609473705292,
-0.8968311548233032,
0.6905717849731445,
0.012038039974868298,
0.8504140377044678,
-0.23629648983478546,
0.008509705774486065,
0.5069968104362488,
0.3269275724887848,
-0.7004319429397583,
0.2471884787082672,
-0.17288459837436676,
-0.05208507552742958,
-0.04276910796761513,
-0.4511449933052063,
-0.15810352563858032,
0.16137929260730743,
0.4177778959274292,
-0.20703043043613434,
-0.041554804891347885,
0.05692542344331741,
-0.23359648883342743,
-0.25743454694747925,
0.32954052090644836,
0.6361842751502991,
0.9922448992729187,
0.08914422243833542,
0.01072390191257,
0.2922509014606476,
-0.26443570852279663,
0.2569677531719208,
-0.20256450772285461,
-0.25508400797843933,
-0.30659061670303345,
0.4056466519832611,
0.6361462473869324,
-0.27314329147338867,
-0.8062050938606262,
0.3879457116127014,
-0.1760617196559906,
0.09307284653186798,
-0.28721752762794495,
-0.014196060597896576,
0.007281572092324495,
0.12838131189346313,
0.394734263420105,
-0.27636468410491943,
-0.08689579367637634,
-0.7743200659751892,
0.04206483066082001,
0.4070957899093628,
-0.6366517543792725,
-0.35234928131103516,
0.5781418085098267,
0.5116247534751892,
-0.22994709014892578,
0.8860007524490356,
-0.13329513370990753,
-0.6000707745552063,
0.9063065648078918,
0.6139803528785706,
0.684268057346344,
-0.4856061637401581,
0.38881710171699524,
0.5610486268997192,
0.484100878238678,
0.49497154355049133,
0.5673827528953552,
0.011032960377633572,
-0.7385872602462769,
-0.7513399124145508,
-0.5411350727081299,
-0.2835633456707001,
-0.08352427929639816,
-0.8433933854103088,
0.3028043508529663,
-0.14524689316749573,
-0.15794704854488373,
-0.4212757647037506,
-0.1665213406085968,
-0.7441389560699463,
0.5327772498130798,
0.2723436653614044,
0.9828145503997803,
-1.30143141746521,
0.2977035641670227,
0.8984144330024719,
-0.4118864834308624,
-0.6148696541786194,
-0.009364355355501175,
-0.17292754352092743,
-0.4681921601295471,
0.930895209312439,
0.147637277841568,
0.18869027495384216,
-0.18021784722805023,
-0.10452862083911896,
-0.7042442560195923,
0.8683704733848572,
0.26102012395858765,
0.07902480661869049,
0.20782043039798737,
0.30813610553741455,
0.9000020623207092,
-0.46607890725135803,
0.7483394145965576,
0.49344316124916077,
0.26301342248916626,
0.0455620251595974,
-1.0613055229187012,
0.25011342763900757,
-0.4285432696342468,
0.07234799861907959,
-0.16489405930042267,
-0.559971034526825,
0.8795685768127441,
-0.30102837085723877,
-0.3872543275356293,
0.37891048192977905,
0.7730456590652466,
0.0916404277086258,
0.11231384426355362,
0.457491010427475,
0.1995648741722107,
0.6535423994064331,
-0.19427980482578278,
1.0117628574371338,
-0.39366865158081055,
0.03919455036520958,
0.9931309223175049,
-0.42517441511154175,
0.6418418288230896,
0.26879826188087463,
0.12431538850069046,
0.6584451198577881,
0.7214130759239197,
0.14086885750293732,
0.0905127078294754,
0.2854481041431427,
-0.20788057148456573,
0.06912056356668472,
-0.5344052910804749,
-0.33205512166023254,
0.779825747013092,
0.03588108718395233,
-0.5920397639274597,
-0.16006852686405182,
0.18408872187137604,
0.16616643965244293,
0.3165868818759918,
-0.17291609942913055,
0.547502875328064,
-0.1522025614976883,
-1.1898341178894043,
0.359506219625473,
0.07001696527004242,
0.25570082664489746,
-0.661614716053009,
0.04266221821308136,
-0.35431379079818726,
-0.31449460983276367,
-0.2801688313484192,
-1.2260361909866333,
0.38341790437698364,
0.3428821265697479,
-0.2768149971961975,
-0.13759130239486694,
0.5800598859786987,
-0.5126787424087524,
-0.2205224633216858,
0.12060798704624176,
0.6699784994125366,
0.12562906742095947,
-0.018595170229673386,
-0.06797464936971664,
0.05889350548386574,
0.01976228877902031,
-0.42240405082702637,
0.06771833449602127,
0.40339839458465576,
-0.5186392068862915,
0.46522974967956543,
0.5114395022392273,
-0.056554656475782394,
-0.08203652501106262,
0.12841109931468964,
0.47070080041885376,
-0.37833672761917114,
-0.629059374332428,
-0.5791987776756287,
0.8334029316902161,
0.03801672160625458,
-0.613358199596405,
0.7068399786949158,
0.4109416902065277,
1.0468560457229614,
-0.22098621726036072,
1.017913579940796,
-0.44321703910827637,
0.24764031171798706,
-0.3739416003227234,
0.8159809708595276,
-0.41031837463378906,
-0.11912607401609421,
-0.24839773774147034,
-1.0020983219146729,
0.10280270874500275,
0.21024398505687714,
-0.5824095606803894,
0.39246678352355957,
0.7996394038200378,
0.45124056935310364,
0.13458433747291565,
0.31743529438972473,
0.497568815946579,
0.11575187742710114,
0.07782522588968277,
0.5513845086097717,
1.218105673789978,
0.1134922206401825,
0.504183292388916,
-0.31046491861343384,
-0.46288028359413147,
0.26011550426483154,
-1.0230039358139038,
-0.6847999691963196,
-1.047702670097351,
-0.20407570898532867,
-0.5272637009620667,
-0.23931875824928284,
0.8109064102172852,
0.42045384645462036,
-0.7132500410079956,
-0.47200214862823486,
0.7988092303276062,
-0.17118576169013977,
-0.22521494328975677,
-0.25104787945747375,
0.1679280698299408,
-0.017994550988078117,
-0.7651453018188477,
-0.17500846087932587,
0.052292726933956146,
-0.08260328322649002,
-0.4479581117630005,
0.15944695472717285,
0.24517109990119934,
0.21162505447864532,
0.8447954654693604,
0.280966579914093,
-0.3801579773426056,
-0.46143072843551636,
0.11394466459751129,
-0.024181341752409935,
-0.3157115876674652,
0.9708638787269592,
-0.6007347106933594,
0.6513803601264954,
0.721095085144043,
0.37116774916648865,
0.18398047983646393,
0.16018953919410706,
0.7168748378753662,
-0.7026984095573425,
0.06542311608791351,
0.21706348657608032,
0.1313575804233551,
0.6561940312385559,
-0.3994190990924835,
0.3715400993824005,
-0.20480111241340637,
-0.4985467195510864,
-0.6230829358100891,
0.4946480691432953,
-0.6289108991622925,
-0.01445959135890007,
1.3857465982437134,
-0.6761245131492615,
0.11473533511161804,
-0.11149308830499649,
-0.24132925271987915,
0.381171852350235,
-0.032154764980077744,
0.5208047032356262,
1.0168946981430054,
0.11854315549135208,
-0.11368575692176819,
-0.7680708765983582,
0.2290695458650589,
0.39777061343193054,
-0.634773313999176,
0.09055956453084946,
0.37729230523109436,
0.11558713018894196,
0.2434329390525818,
0.42214587330818176,
-0.17683184146881104,
0.3822532594203949,
-0.30431467294692993,
0.01664840057492256,
-0.052893687039613724,
-0.16789664328098297,
-0.3485891819000244,
0.17533913254737854,
0.4299381971359253,
0.43566957116127014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11555v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11555v1 | Input Conditioned Graph Generation for Language Agents | 2024-06-17T13:53:15 | 2024-06-17T13:53:15 | Lukas Vierling, Jie Fu, Kai Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent progress in Large Language Models (LLMs) and language agents has
demonstrated significant promise for various future applications across
multiple disciplines. While traditional approaches to language agents often
rely on fixed, handcrafted designs, our research aims to develop both learnable
and dynamic agents. Our method uses an existing framework that abstracts
language agents as graphs. Within this graph framework, we aim to learn a model
that can generate edges for every given input to the language agent. This
allows us to generate edges that represent the flow of communication within the
graph based on the given input, thereby adjusting the internal communication of
a language agent. We learn to generate these edges using a pretrained LLM that
is fine-tuned with reinforcement learning. This LLM can be fine-tuned on
several datasets simultaneously, and we hypothesize that the model learns to
adapt to these different domains during training, achieving good overall
performance when encountering data from different domains during deployment. We
demonstrate that our approach surpasses the previous static approach by nearly
6% accuracy on a combined dataset of MMLU and CMMLU, and by more than 10% when
trained with a sparsity-inducing loss. It also performs superior in additional
experiments conducted with the MMLU and Mini Crossword Puzzles datasets. The
code is available at https://github.com/lukasVierling/DynamicGPTSwarm. | [
-0.33774125576019287,
-1.077806830406189,
0.599510669708252,
0.05788508802652359,
-0.08330880850553513,
0.5584478974342346,
-0.4715802073478699,
-0.2626728415489197,
0.21128898859024048,
0.3686523139476776,
-0.7137769460678101,
-0.6329760551452637,
-0.5905055403709412,
0.1730797290802002,
-0.03220456838607788,
0.9587724208831787,
-0.1284141093492508,
-0.1890684962272644,
-0.20446887612342834,
-0.246537446975708,
-0.264323353767395,
-0.31856173276901245,
-0.9578148722648621,
-0.8042986989021301,
0.6462660431861877,
0.46176934242248535,
0.8890156149864197,
0.49648934602737427,
0.06629882007837296,
0.46081191301345825,
0.15824678540229797,
0.5287608504295349,
-0.7768748998641968,
0.3943238854408264,
-0.18127131462097168,
-0.17653952538967133,
-0.4592241644859314,
-0.15311788022518158,
0.7515581846237183,
0.6316243410110474,
-0.2016075849533081,
-0.07104916125535965,
-0.04760833457112312,
0.38416340947151184,
-0.24880903959274292,
0.4888143241405487,
-0.850007951259613,
0.07489139586687088,
-0.16839222609996796,
-0.4193345904350281,
-0.604788064956665,
-0.24017003178596497,
-0.11171367019414902,
-0.828413188457489,
-0.034213338047266006,
-0.19683432579040527,
0.828432023525238,
0.2735724449157715,
-0.543615460395813,
-0.3999062478542328,
-0.7301590442657471,
0.30839356780052185,
-0.5398099422454834,
0.6089445352554321,
0.06956933438777924,
0.42125633358955383,
-0.6261589527130127,
-1.0046957731246948,
-0.5398463606834412,
-0.4154928922653198,
0.04931016266345978,
-0.006471983157098293,
-0.1498115211725235,
0.17599208652973175,
0.20484592020511627,
-0.2036653608083725,
-0.5861599445343018,
0.41363319754600525,
0.0003689297300297767,
-0.18217073380947113,
0.5046881437301636,
0.2587350606918335,
0.5183842778205872,
0.34435752034187317,
0.053682975471019745,
-0.2872471809387207,
-0.8245363235473633,
0.1154308021068573,
0.5792859196662903,
0.6321508884429932,
-0.0680919960141182,
0.3064279854297638,
-0.34306028485298157,
0.9521118998527527,
0.28216782212257385,
-0.3043775260448456,
0.4221818149089813,
-0.08804333209991455,
0.11818177998065948,
-0.17089611291885376,
0.7442185282707214,
0.102313332259655,
0.5693185329437256,
-0.270721435546875,
-0.4932423233985901,
-0.11222749203443527,
0.22188729047775269,
-0.8966964483261108,
-0.3499213457107544,
-0.055368952453136444,
0.02936462126672268,
-0.41931888461112976,
-0.39923593401908875,
-0.3600567877292633,
-0.4278199374675751,
-0.2506055533885956,
0.17053471505641937,
-0.40472865104675293,
-0.2555837035179138,
-0.04141992703080177,
0.05719345808029175,
0.06557239592075348,
0.21581794321537018,
-0.8026329278945923,
0.44345957040786743,
0.27976876497268677,
0.5545070767402649,
-0.1704949140548706,
-0.48817458748817444,
-0.903140127658844,
0.02491731196641922,
-0.38510170578956604,
0.6781211495399475,
-0.704754114151001,
-0.2874506711959839,
0.22313302755355835,
0.02085261419415474,
-0.21161910891532898,
-0.40911737084388733,
0.003983958158642054,
-0.8685814738273621,
-0.07051599025726318,
0.17056363821029663,
-0.3186320960521698,
0.17214833199977875,
0.2628335952758789,
-0.5619990825653076,
0.8596900701522827,
0.3313434422016144,
-0.5661949515342712,
0.27878710627555847,
-0.49017494916915894,
-0.6389474272727966,
0.2707282602787018,
-0.18046946823596954,
-0.4928281605243683,
-0.10114102065563202,
0.21878118813037872,
0.22646306455135345,
0.09603936225175858,
0.25718697905540466,
-0.4783763885498047,
-0.16319915652275085,
0.41797423362731934,
-0.10179544240236282,
0.448937326669693,
0.20927581191062927,
-0.23595069348812103,
0.3884088099002838,
-0.8921046257019043,
0.26197296380996704,
0.347429096698761,
-0.6178019642829895,
0.054840050637722015,
0.3095848858356476,
-0.1339230239391327,
0.2723761796951294,
0.06192357838153839,
-0.47138139605522156,
0.20354506373405457,
-0.4941420257091522,
0.40857958793640137,
0.7691860795021057,
0.09339234232902527,
0.2712361812591553,
0.007190268021076918,
0.7623019814491272,
-0.24450422823429108,
-0.1776435375213623,
0.1939389705657959,
-0.0642053484916687,
-0.7035682797431946,
-0.22234481573104858,
0.30483588576316833,
0.49105411767959595,
-1.4618558883666992,
0.35072433948516846,
-0.3164028823375702,
-0.4274809658527374,
-0.05579253286123276,
0.16902418434619904,
0.3678174614906311,
0.4126589894294739,
0.07125553488731384,
-0.18779262900352478,
-0.39636626839637756,
-0.5299059152603149,
-0.03148546814918518,
-0.08474249392747879,
0.1574108898639679,
0.4274744987487793,
0.26711928844451904,
-0.2916111350059509,
0.7957041263580322,
-0.6155190467834473,
0.07344359159469604,
-0.6113482713699341,
-0.024436602368950844,
0.044112253934144974,
0.2800844609737396,
0.5966965556144714,
-0.41524502635002136,
-0.6546052694320679,
0.008766425773501396,
-0.6011922955513,
-0.22711899876594543,
-0.03483225777745247,
-0.1701945662498474,
0.05152808874845505,
0.6957767009735107,
-0.4859669804573059,
0.13034038245677948,
0.6938018798828125,
-0.36266520619392395,
0.32040587067604065,
-0.3237949311733246,
-0.29157212376594543,
-0.9604202508926392,
-0.12324531376361847,
-0.05308393016457558,
-0.6358991861343384,
-0.8043460249900818,
0.04599687084555626,
-0.2458934187889099,
-0.4985000789165497,
-0.46022969484329224,
0.6048805117607117,
-0.5107623338699341,
0.07860774546861649,
-0.40980255603790283,
0.31216421723365784,
-0.13134248554706573,
0.7017452716827393,
0.1069471538066864,
0.6199163198471069,
0.5664463639259338,
-0.6566454768180847,
0.5534094572067261,
0.17084982991218567,
-0.11994406580924988,
0.2860449552536011,
-0.78899747133255,
0.5160386562347412,
-0.0552058145403862,
0.5438782572746277,
-0.7446454763412476,
-0.07440775632858276,
0.3420042097568512,
-0.48342165350914,
0.5555819272994995,
-0.0867665559053421,
-0.4163547158241272,
-0.2991374433040619,
-0.05532723292708397,
0.3929596543312073,
0.44469496607780457,
-0.5258614420890808,
0.47652700543403625,
0.5011292099952698,
-0.2588270306587219,
-0.4584747850894928,
-0.28806760907173157,
-0.01679437980055809,
0.08644353598356247,
-0.5822033286094666,
0.18740756809711456,
-0.12215806543827057,
-0.1172221302986145,
0.13070298731327057,
0.19933614134788513,
0.12831805646419525,
0.2979303300380707,
0.24604280292987823,
-0.174443781375885,
-0.19329528510570526,
0.2554384768009186,
0.05638718605041504,
-0.22239400446414948,
-0.011442918330430984,
-0.49474796652793884,
0.7398297786712646,
-0.052590399980545044,
-0.3245426118373871,
-0.09016816318035126,
0.07440727949142456,
0.3943403363227844,
-0.350456178188324,
0.6331035494804382,
0.506887674331665,
-0.3054216802120209,
-0.77908855676651,
0.07738972455263138,
-0.04798302799463272,
-0.5558834075927734,
0.6547926068305969,
-0.6594530344009399,
-0.8496208786964417,
0.5320162773132324,
-0.16958798468112946,
-0.09292469918727875,
0.18069665133953094,
0.7388131618499756,
0.17159447073936462,
1.1042832136154175,
0.8356488347053528,
0.10332603007555008,
0.7045612335205078,
-0.2386438101530075,
0.17707504332065582,
-0.3742803931236267,
-0.06366244703531265,
-0.24731603264808655,
-0.18618187308311462,
-0.7516033053398132,
-0.24286434054374695,
0.343346506357193,
-0.2911434769630432,
-0.06283394992351532,
0.0629824548959732,
-0.3254871368408203,
0.44165223836898804,
0.4754737913608551,
0.1630076915025711,
-0.09735025465488434,
0.022058749571442604,
-0.4465891122817993,
0.3719311058521271,
-0.8049557209014893,
-0.2754409909248352,
0.9338570237159729,
0.3570754826068878,
0.8920227289199829,
0.05683504417538643,
0.6572210788726807,
0.29412397742271423,
0.33993175625801086,
-0.7359778881072998,
0.5528897047042847,
0.04229499027132988,
-0.1726231575012207,
-0.6218766570091248,
-0.5732678174972534,
-1.2615920305252075,
0.19846919178962708,
-0.2735295593738556,
-0.7005884647369385,
-0.11992360651493073,
0.2740786075592041,
-0.15151992440223694,
0.17158140242099762,
-0.4739258885383606,
0.7188248038291931,
-0.2986401617527008,
-0.28059694170951843,
-0.09641659259796143,
-0.40284857153892517,
0.21104589104652405,
-0.07570244371891022,
0.027835706248879433,
-0.21962520480155945,
0.21846100687980652,
0.5666064023971558,
-0.6934705972671509,
0.8738338351249695,
-0.39953887462615967,
-0.14702445268630981,
0.3752802014350891,
0.13246361911296844,
0.7739731669425964,
0.09033871442079544,
-0.03555674850940704,
-0.30526548624038696,
-0.2604846954345703,
-0.27467289566993713,
-0.7304614186286926,
0.7081511616706848,
-0.9945762753486633,
-0.5041776299476624,
-0.23736709356307983,
-0.8246744871139526,
-0.534807562828064,
0.41174063086509705,
0.06745162606239319,
0.6732710003852844,
-0.2734493017196655,
-0.12083542346954346,
0.45620861649513245,
-0.3734157681465149,
0.25069648027420044,
0.701874852180481,
-0.256600022315979,
-0.5086944103240967,
1.1584525108337402,
0.1748168021440506,
0.3750930428504944,
0.18875759840011597,
-0.06548716872930527,
-0.24371303617954254,
-0.7618597745895386,
-0.6080902218818665,
0.3720148503780365,
-0.7798365950584412,
-0.09435054659843445,
-0.33304208517074585,
-0.44492483139038086,
-0.3968891203403473,
-0.04975411295890808,
-0.2511591911315918,
-0.1629001647233963,
-0.12663574516773224,
-0.30362528562545776,
0.28954029083251953,
0.9604552388191223,
0.10671340674161911,
0.5332980751991272,
-0.4590521454811096,
0.2453632950782776,
0.29295045137405396,
0.45437145233154297,
-0.2348552942276001,
-0.34578147530555725,
-0.404177188873291,
0.01933545619249344,
-0.23878230154514313,
-0.7438751459121704,
0.3614768087863922,
0.42821991443634033,
0.7695018649101257,
0.18407155573368073,
0.06933671236038208,
0.29370611906051636,
-0.7466233372688293,
0.43404603004455566,
-0.07514830678701401,
-0.7333162426948547,
0.3796825706958771,
-0.44612860679626465,
0.49594348669052124,
0.4845391809940338,
0.2050352543592453,
-0.46556997299194336,
-0.67751145362854,
-0.6761676073074341,
-0.7346376776695251,
0.6873493790626526,
0.07242606580257416,
0.19763249158859253,
0.17379887402057648,
0.38311585783958435,
0.01744217425584793,
0.1537477672100067,
-0.6253952980041504,
-0.1381450891494751,
-0.08314962685108185,
-0.379920095205307,
-0.34722259640693665,
-0.10623463243246078,
-0.11816750466823578,
-0.16573989391326904,
0.6724385023117065,
-0.4436720013618469,
0.17255350947380066,
-0.21942976117134094,
-0.45685094594955444,
-0.16603675484657288,
-0.11651894450187683,
0.6315339207649231,
0.9583752751350403,
-0.08722303062677383,
0.31192463636398315,
0.22707514464855194,
-0.3037390112876892,
0.310454398393631,
0.28718987107276917,
-0.2687234580516815,
0.003568594343960285,
0.41739872097969055,
1.2263094186782837,
-0.11124711483716965,
-0.6335160136222839,
0.31237027049064636,
-0.25351133942604065,
-0.3480766713619232,
-0.26738235354423523,
0.07722847908735275,
0.14090102910995483,
0.2382815033197403,
-0.02272637188434601,
-0.30872246623039246,
-0.250906378030777,
-0.5235355496406555,
0.45311087369918823,
0.45858174562454224,
-0.32345810532569885,
-0.5534981489181519,
0.4215072989463806,
0.5041314363479614,
-0.5533730387687683,
0.8130555152893066,
-0.4766356348991394,
-0.6502770185470581,
0.4786282777786255,
0.7705846428871155,
0.7539807558059692,
-0.09022043645381927,
0.3652229607105255,
0.10146821290254593,
0.13461177051067352,
0.47169029712677,
0.11427516490221024,
-0.05842716991901398,
-1.0791969299316406,
-0.3167939782142639,
-0.5786746144294739,
-0.4096338450908661,
0.16220328211784363,
-0.19195207953453064,
0.21561139822006226,
-0.4456583261489868,
-0.19962912797927856,
-0.11910935491323471,
0.18365226686000824,
-0.7531779408454895,
0.2102077454328537,
0.43611088395118713,
0.7032130360603333,
-1.0331443548202515,
1.0662119388580322,
0.6931509375572205,
-0.30612385272979736,
-0.9402425289154053,
-0.08940257132053375,
-0.23951628804206848,
-1.0081102848052979,
0.5408681631088257,
-0.11758364737033844,
-0.39355045557022095,
0.22639599442481995,
-0.4828314185142517,
-1.0154321193695068,
0.7806400060653687,
0.54733806848526,
-0.18890564143657684,
0.029202457517385483,
0.2609667181968689,
0.6033599376678467,
-0.4538489878177643,
0.2937391698360443,
0.5173218250274658,
0.2795037627220154,
0.09977259486913681,
-0.7046152949333191,
0.1672624796628952,
-0.4628473222255707,
-0.08997267484664917,
0.1690671741962433,
-0.6185897588729858,
0.6702003479003906,
-0.12527437508106232,
-0.3229025900363922,
-0.24344904720783234,
0.657470703125,
0.3527359664440155,
0.17700640857219696,
0.6625487208366394,
0.32161468267440796,
0.867882490158081,
-0.060115180909633636,
0.9479278922080994,
-0.47784683108329773,
0.08229286223649979,
1.0923510789871216,
-0.3153430223464966,
0.405973881483078,
0.09587134420871735,
0.030547669157385826,
0.6772030591964722,
0.8243669867515564,
0.31934043765068054,
0.514299213886261,
0.7477378845214844,
-0.07386671006679535,
-0.18288825452327728,
-0.17367897927761078,
-0.1048913225531578,
0.3402251601219177,
0.530380129814148,
-0.13884663581848145,
-0.3988853394985199,
0.13438867032527924,
0.18698523938655853,
0.11988876760005951,
-0.06293856352567673,
0.809442937374115,
0.013622598722577095,
-0.6328051090240479,
0.9230479001998901,
0.08146730810403824,
0.2949504554271698,
-0.8357663154602051,
-0.03428998216986656,
-0.26251184940338135,
0.24685057997703552,
-0.12079843133687973,
-0.5420854091644287,
-0.0715494155883789,
-0.10327325016260147,
0.1434650868177414,
-0.3618440330028534,
0.7581198215484619,
-0.6577573418617249,
-0.4652498960494995,
0.2137044370174408,
0.5866527557373047,
0.08204890787601471,
0.36036479473114014,
-0.6166362166404724,
0.25349199771881104,
-0.055869292467832565,
-0.5142561793327332,
0.3453215956687927,
0.661456286907196,
-0.19791623950004578,
0.7707582116127014,
0.45910272002220154,
0.33061715960502625,
0.11473946273326874,
0.35719171166419983,
1.0661624670028687,
-0.2960969805717468,
-0.3655051589012146,
-0.655911386013031,
0.4270138144493103,
-0.05277610570192337,
-0.2251904010772705,
0.45471200346946716,
0.3230164647102356,
0.6852355003356934,
0.03477362170815468,
0.8397672772407532,
0.09970780462026596,
0.13319747149944305,
-0.6528113484382629,
0.6845922470092773,
-0.4076307415962219,
-0.09702865779399872,
-0.037802912294864655,
-0.7476288080215454,
-0.17071592807769775,
0.23880711197853088,
-0.1597648561000824,
0.13318482041358948,
0.6565079092979431,
0.9303389191627502,
-0.00007524248212575912,
-0.6901218295097351,
0.27739882469177246,
0.1314714401960373,
0.7090702652931213,
0.6677333116531372,
0.9487925171852112,
0.0696156919002533,
0.5111606121063232,
-0.14612148702144623,
-0.13131041824817657,
-0.08159434050321579,
-0.6953566670417786,
-0.8959156274795532,
-0.5412744879722595,
-0.38134676218032837,
-0.5418926477432251,
0.28850263357162476,
0.8337728977203369,
0.6997162103652954,
-0.5766057372093201,
-0.27910563349723816,
-0.08549082279205322,
0.34353771805763245,
-0.06404311954975128,
-0.13381148874759674,
0.21177628636360168,
-0.7076398134231567,
-0.779661238193512,
0.7911378741264343,
-0.07216162234544754,
0.09156347066164017,
-0.2344910204410553,
-0.3730318546295166,
-0.053732551634311676,
0.2664463222026825,
0.5617705583572388,
0.47616681456565857,
-0.29866668581962585,
-0.5929158926010132,
-0.206814706325531,
-0.21371860802173615,
-0.013093780726194382,
0.8290865421295166,
-0.8195438981056213,
0.45819297432899475,
0.5115994811058044,
0.7633571028709412,
0.6623660922050476,
-0.035591352730989456,
0.8697329759597778,
-0.9721320867538452,
0.3115748465061188,
0.15045449137687683,
0.2843039929866791,
0.3452543020248413,
-0.31709837913513184,
0.4067033529281616,
0.13250471651554108,
-0.50038081407547,
-0.9030706882476807,
0.44038110971450806,
-0.7515420913696289,
-0.1510164737701416,
1.2043371200561523,
-0.10707500576972961,
-0.26338687539100647,
0.07481323182582855,
-0.02840583212673664,
0.5096363425254822,
-0.38678696751594543,
0.2882303297519684,
0.4679358899593353,
-0.2898145914077759,
0.030687203630805016,
-0.1481698453426361,
0.6955283880233765,
0.003394210943952203,
-0.8355327248573303,
-0.03424523398280144,
0.5309698581695557,
0.43146151304244995,
-0.09229208528995514,
0.8970510959625244,
0.33295053243637085,
0.014233806170523167,
0.08921752870082855,
0.33356529474258423,
-0.3604190945625305,
-0.4672335386276245,
-0.23967556655406952,
0.11140459775924683,
0.6223639249801636,
-0.24532553553581238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11547v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11547v1 | GECOBench: A Gender-Controlled Text Dataset and Benchmark for Quantifying Biases in Explanations | 2024-06-17T13:44:37 | 2024-06-17T13:44:37 | Rick Wilming, Artur Dox, Hjalmar Schulz, Marta Oliveira, Benedict Clark, Stefan Haufe | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Large pre-trained language models have become popular for many applications
and form an important backbone of many downstream tasks in natural language
processing (NLP). Applying 'explainable artificial intelligence' (XAI)
techniques to enrich such models' outputs is considered crucial for assuring
their quality and shedding light on their inner workings. However, large
language models are trained on a plethora of data containing a variety of
biases, such as gender biases, affecting model weights and, potentially,
behavior. Currently, it is unclear to what extent such biases also impact model
explanations in possibly unfavorable ways. We create a gender-controlled text
dataset, GECO, in which otherwise identical sentences appear in male and female
forms. This gives rise to ground-truth 'world explanations' for gender
classification tasks, enabling the objective evaluation of the correctness of
XAI methods. We also provide GECOBench, a rigorous quantitative evaluation
framework benchmarking popular XAI methods, applying them to pre-trained
language models fine-tuned to different degrees. This allows us to investigate
how pre-training induces undesirable bias in model explanations and to what
extent fine-tuning can mitigate such explanation bias. We show a clear
dependency between explanation performance and the number of fine-tuned layers,
where XAI methods are observed to particularly benefit from fine-tuning or
complete retraining of embedding layers. Remarkably, this relationship holds
for models achieving similar classification performance on the same task. With
that, we highlight the utility of the proposed gender-controlled dataset and
novel benchmarking approach for research and development of novel XAI methods.
All code including dataset generation, model training, evaluation and
visualization is available at: https://github.com/braindatalab/gecobench | [
-0.5523385405540466,
-0.6331788897514343,
0.3187618851661682,
-0.010587037540972233,
0.013105946592986584,
-0.15496192872524261,
-0.21248291432857513,
-0.3818436563014984,
-0.332933247089386,
0.2965186536312103,
-0.8236143589019775,
-0.49217212200164795,
-0.4724544882774353,
-0.10238353163003922,
-0.6415280699729919,
1.10361647605896,
-0.061132822185754776,
0.18465949594974518,
-0.4356866180896759,
-0.22165383398532867,
-0.5453420877456665,
-0.3445785641670227,
-0.7071003913879395,
-0.5977199673652649,
0.5231362581253052,
0.43493300676345825,
0.8485811352729797,
0.7287222146987915,
0.03600014001131058,
0.23317530751228333,
-0.08537767827510834,
0.14557552337646484,
-0.3179698884487152,
-0.17670172452926636,
-0.42874470353126526,
-0.6070459485054016,
-0.31657108664512634,
0.06269123405218124,
0.4573996365070343,
0.8546046018600464,
-0.23494577407836914,
0.041334982961416245,
0.21840119361877441,
0.5647850036621094,
-0.8125744462013245,
0.1250556856393814,
-0.5098480582237244,
0.1071004644036293,
-0.0618596188724041,
-0.10987634211778641,
-0.21741655468940735,
-0.14546428620815277,
0.2727753818035126,
-0.5025081634521484,
0.6393424272537231,
0.35375264286994934,
0.8543410301208496,
0.1657879799604416,
-0.33997806906700134,
-0.45079630613327026,
-0.5458086729049683,
0.8410266637802124,
-0.5930783748626709,
0.21954797208309174,
0.26802146434783936,
0.4109335243701935,
-0.0758555606007576,
-0.47699257731437683,
-0.577172577381134,
-0.25026020407676697,
-0.2544463276863098,
0.03388837352395058,
-0.2908031642436981,
-0.00224266666918993,
0.3270966708660126,
0.4040743410587311,
-0.7311239242553711,
0.2821088135242462,
0.0714249312877655,
-0.10681981593370438,
0.5924749970436096,
0.0345371775329113,
0.5478163957595825,
-0.14183126389980316,
-0.11108763515949249,
-0.28410860896110535,
-0.5276920795440674,
0.07196347415447235,
0.8188502788543701,
0.24795766174793243,
-0.12098278105258942,
0.2598130702972412,
-0.17053957283496857,
0.5700469613075256,
-0.1336209923028946,
0.4461740255355835,
0.18618269264698029,
-0.22007109224796295,
-0.26405254006385803,
0.2539342939853668,
0.7852150201797485,
0.22462478280067444,
0.4936950206756592,
-0.2638935446739197,
0.15836746990680695,
0.36250630021095276,
0.34968650341033936,
-0.7960845232009888,
-0.10081766545772552,
0.20176777243614197,
-0.27228328585624695,
-0.6077431440353394,
0.05418334901332855,
-0.9581727981567383,
-0.3100598156452179,
-0.2474641352891922,
0.09242650121450424,
-0.11179320514202118,
-0.1392756551504135,
0.12851667404174805,
-0.3980271518230438,
0.15068483352661133,
0.0171048603951931,
-1.2319928407669067,
0.6446346640586853,
0.7086073160171509,
0.5447782278060913,
-0.02656184695661068,
-0.2900277376174927,
-0.4426173269748688,
0.07992527633905411,
-0.4336163103580475,
0.3945731520652771,
-0.7122827172279358,
-0.19300466775894165,
-0.011456767097115517,
0.09390641003847122,
0.1407785266637802,
-0.34010279178619385,
0.7552801370620728,
-0.12767043709754944,
0.47966620326042175,
-0.4051583707332611,
-0.39182910323143005,
-0.2312043011188507,
0.07718339562416077,
-0.545240044593811,
0.8991320133209229,
-0.09851281344890594,
-0.8604291081428528,
0.47354406118392944,
-0.7716768980026245,
-0.3773704767227173,
-0.37442031502723694,
-0.47146889567375183,
-0.41331544518470764,
0.06996672600507736,
0.542818009853363,
0.31603291630744934,
-0.7192930579185486,
0.5132611989974976,
-0.32982316613197327,
-0.3179159164428711,
0.2360757291316986,
-0.47899553179740906,
0.8707486391067505,
-0.008411984890699387,
-0.6821666359901428,
0.18185065686702728,
-0.7215703129768372,
0.28192999958992004,
0.1967969685792923,
0.38630691170692444,
-0.4172421395778656,
0.07835584878921509,
-0.2919350862503052,
0.26846426725387573,
-0.18593059480190277,
-0.3232543170452118,
-0.20984573662281036,
-0.36581432819366455,
0.6799995303153992,
0.7309988737106323,
-0.4436212480068207,
0.4887453615665436,
-0.13047662377357483,
0.6682875156402588,
-0.10053319483995438,
0.08229709416627884,
-0.19841252267360687,
-0.17872367799282074,
-0.5589478611946106,
0.07120275497436523,
0.38636645674705505,
0.30254241824150085,
-0.5229665040969849,
0.21701940894126892,
-0.24342533946037292,
-0.45006778836250305,
-0.4308488965034485,
0.15363137423992157,
0.6983979344367981,
0.62723308801651,
0.17698852717876434,
-0.25207358598709106,
-0.5031815767288208,
-1.1182206869125366,
-0.624353289604187,
0.05333918705582619,
-0.41536635160446167,
0.5190598964691162,
0.6712095141410828,
-0.21384888887405396,
0.8272078633308411,
-0.2673550546169281,
0.008085633628070354,
-0.1630256623029709,
0.5419590473175049,
0.036327801644802094,
0.47532063722610474,
0.7372174859046936,
-0.8321325182914734,
0.06900160014629364,
0.13963602483272552,
-0.7893759608268738,
-0.3308665454387665,
-0.05499330535531044,
-0.3512558043003082,
0.019494911655783653,
0.5420573949813843,
-0.36580851674079895,
0.4126427173614502,
0.6974166035652161,
-0.31836360692977905,
0.6113713979721069,
-0.3352697491645813,
0.09088332951068878,
-0.57921302318573,
0.2514573037624359,
0.045290686190128326,
-0.37941935658454895,
-0.4543561041355133,
0.1977219581604004,
-0.005363010335713625,
-0.1334373652935028,
-0.19638141989707947,
0.5496788620948792,
-0.548895537853241,
-0.18752141296863556,
-0.34629198908805847,
0.27996203303337097,
0.130628302693367,
0.6067471504211426,
-0.19401279091835022,
0.6321581602096558,
0.4058796167373657,
-0.5027806162834167,
0.0168075542896986,
0.17716141045093536,
-0.23658183217048645,
0.33036133646965027,
-1.0707072019577026,
0.31164035201072693,
-0.25187167525291443,
0.18159149587154388,
-0.839512288570404,
-0.2783474326133728,
0.29954761266708374,
-0.518583357334137,
0.07881996035575867,
-0.056723013520240784,
-0.293923944234848,
-0.42065364122390747,
-0.24024951457977295,
0.20788903534412384,
0.30997321009635925,
-0.5708801746368408,
0.7037932276725769,
0.2244480550289154,
-0.11500412970781326,
-0.8131952285766602,
-0.783523440361023,
-0.12033645063638687,
-0.14812102913856506,
-0.49134624004364014,
0.5517272353172302,
-0.1336330771446228,
-0.18814638257026672,
-0.0847320556640625,
-0.28147661685943604,
-0.04110267385840416,
0.25835323333740234,
0.45541054010391235,
0.1851067841053009,
0.06334841996431351,
0.19432751834392548,
0.34289565682411194,
-0.36618420481681824,
0.40671563148498535,
-0.25597378611564636,
0.6556212902069092,
-0.13862015306949615,
-0.20156152546405792,
-0.31823766231536865,
0.3821062445640564,
0.33525073528289795,
-0.19165846705436707,
0.7927424907684326,
0.4497113823890686,
-0.3112376928329468,
-0.43846777081489563,
-0.04252501204609871,
-0.139395609498024,
-0.4290371835231781,
0.3299403488636017,
-0.4575144052505493,
-0.8348324298858643,
0.5742146372795105,
0.1125701516866684,
0.053184133023023605,
0.4653557538986206,
0.4886632561683655,
0.024137379601597786,
1.5950764417648315,
0.6659712791442871,
-0.2398192584514618,
0.40990152955055237,
-0.026480089873075485,
0.08791135996580124,
-0.5407021045684814,
0.05736029893159866,
-0.856106698513031,
-0.30810821056365967,
-0.6766819953918457,
-0.1745048463344574,
-0.16636477410793304,
-0.08952008187770844,
-0.3286956548690796,
-0.050159234553575516,
-0.5221198797225952,
0.7005857825279236,
0.5556319355964661,
-0.020997049286961555,
0.14492270350456238,
0.0025953911244869232,
-0.06182349473237991,
0.10441674292087555,
-0.6798657178878784,
-0.6033857464790344,
0.9547005891799927,
0.24727047979831696,
0.6693190336227417,
-0.2058776617050171,
0.10816875845193863,
0.49036264419555664,
0.07128319889307022,
-0.3595789968967438,
0.3044472336769104,
-0.41075921058654785,
-0.8557996153831482,
-0.2655743360519409,
-0.5553835034370422,
-0.8777225017547607,
0.3496195375919342,
-0.059143248945474625,
-0.7636450529098511,
0.22730232775211334,
0.39520063996315,
-0.09287227690219879,
0.08835484087467194,
-0.783294677734375,
1.1277964115142822,
-0.2995223104953766,
-0.4506048262119293,
-0.33578717708587646,
-0.596735417842865,
0.3771665096282959,
0.08159784972667694,
0.16395162045955658,
-0.10738745331764221,
0.22569310665130615,
0.7213258147239685,
-0.4733099043369293,
0.7446829080581665,
-0.2211955338716507,
-0.13854598999023438,
-0.1376342475414276,
-0.11255891621112823,
0.3277319669723511,
0.17193084955215454,
-0.19513791799545288,
0.44382524490356445,
-0.10584774613380432,
-0.4571742117404938,
-0.9149696230888367,
0.7203190922737122,
-0.852891206741333,
-0.562987208366394,
-0.14615842700004578,
-0.6517988443374634,
-0.026429958641529083,
0.1519637554883957,
0.3591826260089874,
0.5388787984848022,
-0.3103009760379791,
0.1057652160525322,
0.5881655216217041,
-0.36660969257354736,
-0.017260804772377014,
0.30566495656967163,
-0.34255170822143555,
-0.05743364244699478,
0.7264653444290161,
0.11813544481992722,
0.23289558291435242,
0.3050149083137512,
0.26173388957977295,
-0.016115430742502213,
-0.4324541985988617,
-0.4255638122558594,
-0.032861560583114624,
-0.5801801681518555,
0.23278385400772095,
-0.5620346665382385,
0.006789834704250097,
-0.19245336949825287,
-0.23545384407043457,
-0.1497681736946106,
-0.17839723825454712,
-0.027083786204457283,
-0.18439625203609467,
-0.040024854242801666,
0.29023444652557373,
0.23112353682518005,
0.5175445675849915,
-0.15213000774383545,
0.6525009870529175,
0.3875183165073395,
0.3192271888256073,
0.14004233479499817,
-0.3290078341960907,
-0.039609793573617935,
0.43189477920532227,
0.07501109689474106,
-0.7932519912719727,
0.3508280813694,
0.19009006023406982,
0.5663157105445862,
0.41647645831108093,
-0.11447682976722717,
0.5999687910079956,
-0.3467974066734314,
0.4650588929653168,
-0.03516693785786629,
-1.3544461727142334,
0.8751292824745178,
-0.37110087275505066,
0.38913339376449585,
0.5050179362297058,
0.41800057888031006,
-0.6415567994117737,
-0.4034171402454376,
-0.6686592698097229,
-0.8076480031013489,
0.8746961951255798,
0.2900313436985016,
0.1184212937951088,
0.1261231154203415,
0.5566258430480957,
0.47475168108940125,
0.3098916709423065,
-0.49171802401542664,
-0.28321632742881775,
-0.14266975224018097,
-0.2527385950088501,
-0.29200491309165955,
-0.23973806202411652,
-0.23800218105316162,
-0.23808012902736664,
0.8592608571052551,
-0.4914943277835846,
0.2728554606437683,
0.07234188914299011,
-0.3588792085647583,
0.1029675304889679,
0.336789071559906,
0.4064495861530304,
0.7828406095504761,
-0.10125239193439484,
0.10240867733955383,
0.1777089387178421,
-0.274183988571167,
0.08960358798503876,
0.22719843685626984,
-0.301113098859787,
0.09164980053901672,
0.3980849087238312,
0.9666478633880615,
0.14478141069412231,
-0.6959404349327087,
0.3704134523868561,
-0.4434662163257599,
-0.2528340816497803,
-0.25295236706733704,
0.4720779359340668,
-0.03054106794297695,
-0.008893330581486225,
0.09870491921901703,
0.036368004977703094,
0.21411408483982086,
-0.601865828037262,
-0.09706578403711319,
0.339051753282547,
-0.613358736038208,
-0.31821444630622864,
0.9122860431671143,
0.0562497042119503,
-0.0387226901948452,
0.6947685480117798,
-0.04925781860947609,
-0.34193676710128784,
0.9100955128669739,
0.26157402992248535,
0.8577162623405457,
-0.03755908086895943,
0.4098040759563446,
0.2364514172077179,
0.3800817131996155,
0.04515157267451286,
0.1642160415649414,
-0.17284812033176422,
-0.9341973662376404,
-0.29147568345069885,
-0.15114685893058777,
-0.47511884570121765,
-0.09067784994840622,
-0.9418160319328308,
0.21889051795005798,
-0.5484538078308105,
0.0719999447464943,
0.5224658846855164,
-0.07685095816850662,
-0.8334866762161255,
0.34789007902145386,
0.22408713400363922,
0.8552195429801941,
-1.06072199344635,
0.6220227479934692,
0.48674726486206055,
-0.330946683883667,
-0.668860137462616,
-0.036940205842256546,
0.1392042487859726,
-0.8081998229026794,
0.3369014859199524,
0.4258384108543396,
-0.35613977909088135,
-0.17040230333805084,
-0.8707255721092224,
-0.3779306709766388,
0.8174256682395935,
0.7036178708076477,
-0.8201776742935181,
-0.0033583652693778276,
0.20488332211971283,
0.624897837638855,
-0.3510598838329315,
0.7282571792602539,
0.9153266549110413,
0.577764630317688,
-0.3622380793094635,
-0.46800464391708374,
0.13626782596111298,
-0.5518787503242493,
0.13841798901557922,
0.05076560750603676,
-0.4882412552833557,
0.6147695779800415,
-0.08840610831975937,
-0.09763498604297638,
-0.018866386264562607,
0.667279064655304,
0.11100103706121445,
0.34458428621292114,
0.8326866626739502,
0.4227480888366699,
1.201300859451294,
-0.33126723766326904,
1.3753607273101807,
0.04592950642108917,
0.15663796663284302,
1.3703457117080688,
-0.22454841434955597,
0.36468496918678284,
0.32377004623413086,
0.00889703817665577,
0.898921012878418,
0.41637229919433594,
0.002631842391565442,
0.27488765120506287,
0.39123573899269104,
0.07045314460992813,
-0.13113541901111603,
-0.2969202697277069,
-0.24032975733280182,
0.48272767663002014,
0.149328351020813,
-0.6384795308113098,
-0.06869272142648697,
0.15618100762367249,
0.2219311147928238,
-0.007910974323749542,
-0.2171664834022522,
0.49016237258911133,
-0.12515239417552948,
-0.6300321817398071,
0.38532450795173645,
-0.024800317361950874,
0.4800281524658203,
-0.8117529153823853,
0.12624123692512512,
-0.26592642068862915,
0.3406127989292145,
-0.272859126329422,
-0.6185292601585388,
0.13516908884048462,
0.1359463483095169,
-0.654525876045227,
-0.1330951452255249,
0.649478554725647,
-0.43202924728393555,
-0.4305487871170044,
0.3975561559200287,
0.36990058422088623,
0.08739588409662247,
-0.21177907288074493,
-0.7338998913764954,
-0.004849269054830074,
0.2052932232618332,
-0.10416553914546967,
0.18442808091640472,
0.47013014554977417,
-0.56007319688797,
0.8733510375022888,
0.5414854884147644,
-0.20384587347507477,
-0.25551238656044006,
0.5749772787094116,
0.7262259721755981,
-0.69942706823349,
-0.6316357851028442,
-1.030174970626831,
0.4158550202846527,
-0.2545611560344696,
-0.47524750232696533,
0.6869157552719116,
0.31960800290107727,
0.8527246713638306,
0.09582385420799255,
0.8120813369750977,
-0.03674918785691261,
0.35690024495124817,
-0.40022361278533936,
0.683811604976654,
-0.61753910779953,
0.09206602722406387,
-0.4347406029701233,
-0.8046812415122986,
-0.15936677157878876,
0.39004379510879517,
-0.35341933369636536,
0.36063310503959656,
0.6479416489601135,
0.8775454163551331,
-0.02018594928085804,
0.4745204746723175,
0.059952378273010254,
0.36550062894821167,
0.41170215606689453,
0.3062482178211212,
0.7699612975120544,
-0.3772915005683899,
0.5611991286277771,
-0.21564199030399323,
-0.22742193937301636,
-0.0014068464515730739,
-1.0118993520736694,
-0.8593915104866028,
-0.2622183561325073,
-0.47982528805732727,
0.2234405279159546,
0.3789631426334381,
0.4827914834022522,
0.9187859296798706,
-0.8228442072868347,
-0.07252562791109085,
-0.471961110830307,
0.26057395339012146,
-0.5346131920814514,
-0.22788044810295105,
0.19937030971050262,
-0.23777522146701813,
-0.840006947517395,
0.06320623308420181,
-0.08884250372648239,
-0.27921441197395325,
-0.38322797417640686,
-0.12236778438091278,
0.11844958364963531,
-0.08969263732433319,
0.26804643869400024,
0.1481090635061264,
-0.5531699061393738,
-0.23534995317459106,
-0.23977282643318176,
0.19633860886096954,
-0.009301574900746346,
0.9571979641914368,
-0.8085476160049438,
0.5903322100639343,
0.5649495720863342,
0.5607008337974548,
0.4592655301094055,
-0.08576454967260361,
1.0337127447128296,
-0.7894187569618225,
0.13921044766902924,
-0.09018608182668686,
0.3802621364593506,
0.230658158659935,
-0.35803788900375366,
0.6373112201690674,
-0.25504592061042786,
-0.5219796895980835,
-0.7334640622138977,
-0.16295939683914185,
-0.7447217106819153,
-0.48500943183898926,
0.641180694103241,
-0.12375339865684509,
-0.48278525471687317,
0.09697149693965912,
-0.3445364832878113,
0.3378734886646271,
-0.3571976125240326,
0.6915180087089539,
0.9811049699783325,
0.1690298616886139,
-0.31967759132385254,
-0.8205223679542542,
0.23651708662509918,
0.8197517991065979,
-1.0359007120132446,
0.4087061583995819,
0.38406652212142944,
0.11164838820695877,
-0.10607568174600601,
0.1106555312871933,
-0.16330470144748688,
0.4028387665748596,
-0.010085469111800194,
0.3990385830402374,
-0.03459988161921501,
-0.39390888810157776,
-0.5422903299331665,
0.06423549354076385,
-0.21795561909675598,
-0.09083864837884903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11546v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11546v1 | GigaSpeech 2: An Evolving, Large-Scale and Multi-domain ASR Corpus for Low-Resource Languages with Automated Crawling, Transcription and Refinement | 2024-06-17T13:44:20 | 2024-06-17T13:44:20 | Yifan Yang, Zheshu Song, Jianheng Zhuo, Mingyu Cui, Jinpeng Li, Bo Yang, Yexing Du, Ziyang Ma, Xunying Liu, Ziyuan Wang, Ke Li, Shuai Fan, Kai Yu, Wei-Qiang Zhang, Guoguo Chen, Xie Chen | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | The evolution of speech technology has been spurred by the rapid increase in
dataset sizes. Traditional speech models generally depend on a large amount of
labeled training data, which is scarce for low-resource languages. This paper
presents GigaSpeech 2, a large-scale, multi-domain, multilingual speech
recognition corpus. It is designed for low-resource languages and does not rely
on paired speech and text data. GigaSpeech 2 comprises about 30,000 hours of
automatically transcribed speech, including Thai, Indonesian, and Vietnamese,
gathered from unlabeled YouTube videos. We also introduce an automated pipeline
for data crawling, transcription, and label refinement. Specifically, this
pipeline uses Whisper for initial transcription and TorchAudio for forced
alignment, combined with multi-dimensional filtering for data quality
assurance. A modified Noisy Student Training is developed to further refine
flawed pseudo labels iteratively, thus enhancing model performance.
Experimental results on our manually transcribed evaluation set and two public
test sets from Common Voice and FLEURS confirm our corpus's high quality and
broad applicability. Notably, ASR models trained on GigaSpeech 2 can reduce the
word error rate for Thai, Indonesian, and Vietnamese on our challenging and
realistic YouTube test set by 25% to 40% compared to the Whisper large-v3
model, with merely 10% model parameters. Furthermore, our ASR models trained on
Gigaspeech 2 yield superior performance compared to commercial services. We
believe that our newly introduced corpus and pipeline will open a new avenue
for low-resource speech recognition and significantly facilitate research in
this area. | [
-0.2690240442752838,
-0.6898061037063599,
0.024571383371949196,
0.1526324301958084,
-0.2016158103942871,
0.4682419002056122,
-0.3680913746356964,
-0.5703743696212769,
0.4091036021709442,
0.468291312456131,
-0.19431574642658234,
0.07842113077640533,
-0.7138504981994629,
-0.09284850209951401,
-0.44365108013153076,
0.8181720972061157,
0.14988474547863007,
0.1790444701910019,
-0.07739835232496262,
-0.05075648054480553,
-0.14594966173171997,
-0.5383856892585754,
-0.7882280945777893,
-0.20443357527256012,
0.4385526478290558,
0.5325419902801514,
0.65080726146698,
0.5343402028083801,
0.20220385491847992,
0.27105867862701416,
-0.19150802493095398,
0.2752574682235718,
-0.4814024567604065,
-0.07670463621616364,
-0.02269607223570347,
-0.11064312607049942,
-0.3313010632991791,
-0.025950433686375618,
0.8649761080741882,
0.5504159927368164,
-0.27030888199806213,
0.45914915204048157,
0.09576670080423355,
0.39975282549858093,
-0.4294506311416626,
0.14891032874584198,
-0.6685950756072998,
-0.31187042593955994,
-0.454818457365036,
0.04004192352294922,
-0.2684573531150818,
-0.18859145045280457,
0.009699765592813492,
-0.38142168521881104,
0.3336021304130554,
-0.20664869248867035,
0.6851006746292114,
0.3810102939605713,
-0.28065359592437744,
-0.31741100549697876,
-0.7028592824935913,
0.7577045559883118,
-0.3876698613166809,
0.782486617565155,
0.6382964253425598,
0.5322936177253723,
0.23741911351680756,
-0.8973699808120728,
-0.682913064956665,
-0.15410560369491577,
0.28202468156814575,
0.027948325499892235,
-0.2623070478439331,
-0.31249287724494934,
0.12502966821193695,
0.26989802718162537,
-0.6522592306137085,
0.3321687579154968,
-0.8773664236068726,
-0.43202051520347595,
0.5330551266670227,
-0.24284139275550842,
0.09340348839759827,
-0.09856456518173218,
-0.3708282709121704,
-0.18903441727161407,
-0.7075461745262146,
0.163929283618927,
0.586487352848053,
0.6576657295227051,
-0.2094808667898178,
0.5432919263839722,
-0.03077578730881214,
0.5733786821365356,
-0.1120932400226593,
-0.30995509028434753,
0.5028036832809448,
-0.02484137751162052,
0.013600152917206287,
0.3311649560928345,
0.754895031452179,
0.0633222758769989,
0.15525609254837036,
-0.07580509036779404,
-0.20357196033000946,
0.25454747676849365,
0.3800175189971924,
-0.7217915654182434,
-0.36831507086753845,
0.20246264338493347,
-0.27724239230155945,
0.03811207413673401,
-0.23718585073947906,
-0.7876917719841003,
-0.3266834318637848,
-0.6312433481216431,
0.3652406334877014,
-0.3224480152130127,
-0.5212399959564209,
0.05186581239104271,
-0.02483268640935421,
0.12498308718204498,
0.3503764867782593,
-0.8543186783790588,
0.36709368228912354,
0.819218099117279,
1.0685937404632568,
-0.2728551924228668,
-0.4497097432613373,
-1.0142936706542969,
0.04567687585949898,
-0.37125441431999207,
0.9162104725837708,
-0.5949075222015381,
-0.6297485828399658,
0.05672505870461464,
-0.013500072993338108,
0.040498532354831696,
-0.7757068276405334,
0.4741121828556061,
-0.5898163914680481,
-0.016258276998996735,
-0.11888949573040009,
-0.2718143165111542,
-0.16826823353767395,
-0.05465530976653099,
-0.7030457854270935,
1.057112455368042,
0.26045629382133484,
-0.3387105166912079,
0.10420781373977661,
-0.684685468673706,
-0.5453202724456787,
0.23112741112709045,
-0.060496896505355835,
-0.3815474510192871,
0.029597008600831032,
0.06023101881146431,
0.014931386336684227,
-0.5879203081130981,
0.07015316188335419,
-0.09653602540493011,
-0.3824659287929535,
0.20208001136779785,
-0.46584421396255493,
0.8207026720046997,
0.3723270297050476,
-0.18589825928211212,
0.005173566285520792,
-0.7508971691131592,
0.300977885723114,
-0.16189450025558472,
-0.5305139422416687,
0.1972099393606186,
-0.13086798787117004,
0.662815511226654,
0.33374691009521484,
0.10030386596918106,
-0.6326043605804443,
0.06640247255563736,
-0.1951216608285904,
0.7843986749649048,
0.435758113861084,
-0.20113234221935272,
0.21561144292354584,
-0.08419061452150345,
0.5820242762565613,
-0.21191170811653137,
0.013741889037191868,
0.12074919790029526,
-0.5625574588775635,
-0.7048284411430359,
-0.46628883481025696,
0.49286356568336487,
0.4754997789859772,
-0.8275479078292847,
0.0888453871011734,
-0.5882449150085449,
-0.5928874611854553,
-0.9505868554115295,
0.22805173695087433,
0.4503908157348633,
0.4564422369003296,
0.6038803458213806,
-0.36817654967308044,
-0.6239129304885864,
-0.8161606788635254,
-0.03210797160863876,
-0.24106383323669434,
-0.23169878125190735,
0.4493827223777771,
0.090031698346138,
-0.6512490510940552,
0.6721290946006775,
-0.2956445813179016,
-0.3293914496898651,
-0.25337785482406616,
0.17251810431480408,
0.05512392520904541,
0.3792833983898163,
0.27169618010520935,
-0.8013086915016174,
-0.6633790135383606,
-0.10847841948270798,
-0.09906108677387238,
-0.008919069543480873,
0.22616298496723175,
0.1523333191871643,
0.30098211765289307,
0.3855995535850525,
-0.5067509412765503,
-0.23252907395362854,
0.7751337885856628,
-0.057223089039325714,
0.7059366106987,
-0.07837933301925659,
-0.030295267701148987,
-0.8394612073898315,
0.16308490931987762,
-0.2818259596824646,
-0.1450389325618744,
-0.696465253829956,
-0.018455972895026207,
0.0027494358364492655,
-0.4277881979942322,
-0.47218549251556396,
0.512725293636322,
-0.14948397874832153,
-0.23513390123844147,
-0.3282468020915985,
0.13014963269233704,
-0.27962997555732727,
0.23650644719600677,
0.20826692879199982,
1.3165295124053955,
0.6094359755516052,
-0.5239872336387634,
0.43079009652137756,
0.49230340123176575,
-0.4115869104862213,
0.4104282855987549,
-0.5458379983901978,
0.6289174556732178,
0.16696569323539734,
0.25138503313064575,
-1.053151249885559,
-0.21583965420722961,
-0.2741438150405884,
-0.7786445021629333,
0.3637391924858093,
-0.44406774640083313,
-0.7310013771057129,
-0.41753441095352173,
-0.09563922137022018,
0.21671633422374725,
0.623442530632019,
-0.8179945349693298,
0.5127084851264954,
0.9003030061721802,
-0.5141571164131165,
-0.31032606959342957,
-0.7100774049758911,
0.36875075101852417,
-0.10966968536376953,
-0.5513854622840881,
0.034214671701192856,
0.029730580747127533,
0.027209298685193062,
-0.406376451253891,
-0.07826098799705505,
-0.46353328227996826,
-0.41580939292907715,
0.27172213792800903,
0.2877073585987091,
-0.2270655333995819,
0.23219452798366547,
-0.16480758786201477,
-0.30972281098365784,
-0.04497594013810158,
-0.5628771185874939,
0.8244763016700745,
-0.13677413761615753,
-0.03129144757986069,
-0.31286630034446716,
0.34559905529022217,
0.5357646942138672,
-0.47506117820739746,
0.2158476561307907,
0.9594582319259644,
-0.24457810819149017,
-0.015312646515667439,
-0.8466553688049316,
0.10617075860500336,
-0.5252977609634399,
0.32447710633277893,
-0.38194286823272705,
-1.0407532453536987,
0.17923764884471893,
-0.11255939304828644,
-0.19188490509986877,
0.48955222964286804,
0.7342811226844788,
-0.017461569979786873,
0.6981825828552246,
0.437509685754776,
-0.2709534168243408,
0.2348862737417221,
-0.3802632689476013,
0.13184279203414917,
-0.9017327427864075,
-0.10239510238170624,
-0.5968335866928101,
-0.27018263936042786,
-0.6859765648841858,
-0.7796746492385864,
0.3798753619194031,
-0.20733000338077545,
-0.1886654943227768,
0.3790847957134247,
-0.4764617681503296,
0.4122503101825714,
0.6418462991714478,
-0.2104349583387375,
0.03557170554995537,
0.41026028990745544,
0.17220018804073334,
-0.050435345619916916,
-0.5400292873382568,
-0.44593772292137146,
1.0855869054794312,
0.25367653369903564,
0.5149452686309814,
0.4729995131492615,
0.25781142711639404,
0.36825719475746155,
-0.007702899165451527,
-0.8726138472557068,
0.22002090513706207,
-0.4663376212120056,
-0.594656229019165,
-0.37707197666168213,
-0.347428560256958,
-0.8655124306678772,
0.2716781497001648,
0.07596328109502792,
-0.704260528087616,
0.0970209389925003,
0.23136714100837708,
-0.5522862672805786,
0.18691374361515045,
-0.770346462726593,
0.4793109893798828,
-0.1111869141459465,
-0.5554174780845642,
-0.28171294927597046,
-0.6163692474365234,
0.13776499032974243,
-0.2507062256336212,
0.21827128529548645,
0.09218340367078781,
-0.028834160417318344,
0.854387640953064,
-0.30959346890449524,
0.5693532824516296,
-0.3656676709651947,
-0.0915466696023941,
0.7223700881004333,
0.03760862722992897,
0.5799033641815186,
0.04231864959001541,
-0.02409539185464382,
0.4484441578388214,
-0.006284534465521574,
-0.23704375326633453,
-0.16937817633152008,
0.7354050278663635,
-0.9204448461532593,
-0.19146668910980225,
-0.14860031008720398,
-0.20185193419456482,
-0.5530079007148743,
0.13585668802261353,
0.21406574547290802,
0.38660526275634766,
0.04938104748725891,
0.2807639241218567,
0.559714138507843,
-0.1947653889656067,
0.1840052455663681,
0.7204015254974365,
-0.1208266019821167,
-0.5788806080818176,
1.4316452741622925,
0.22111456096172333,
0.17946107685565948,
0.0774192363023758,
0.19726312160491943,
-0.6701571941375732,
-0.33572736382484436,
-0.7016644477844238,
0.1378961205482483,
-0.38667404651641846,
-0.348911315202713,
-0.8813049793243408,
-0.341940313577652,
-0.5798099040985107,
-0.059913311153650284,
-0.7847769260406494,
-0.5877818465232849,
-0.23449145257472992,
-0.03292573615908623,
0.43827858567237854,
0.37879762053489685,
-0.4785151481628418,
0.5536742210388184,
-0.6940950155258179,
0.6625542044639587,
0.5310564041137695,
0.4152548015117645,
-0.1690620481967926,
-0.8384215831756592,
-0.12316560000181198,
0.043054308742284775,
-0.06098031997680664,
-0.3869372308254242,
0.4490329623222351,
0.4791586995124817,
0.0007268100744113326,
0.4263880252838135,
-0.3534838855266571,
0.8384508490562439,
-0.7691500782966614,
0.8464453816413879,
0.282605916261673,
-0.8547275066375732,
0.2949725091457367,
-0.3288995921611786,
0.20444408059120178,
0.5876886248588562,
0.16689644753932953,
-0.7379754185676575,
0.09076809883117676,
-0.5929760336875916,
-0.7984665632247925,
0.6723839640617371,
-0.14672137796878815,
0.1946372389793396,
0.24829301238059998,
0.08511047810316086,
0.3140287399291992,
0.24559104442596436,
-0.09005831182003021,
0.004083061590790749,
-0.3753054440021515,
0.16770370304584503,
-0.5626055002212524,
-0.3973917067050934,
-0.016286320984363556,
-0.25500041246414185,
0.6316795349121094,
-0.23929151892662048,
0.33960455656051636,
-0.172588512301445,
-0.2358514666557312,
-0.1963718831539154,
0.21982818841934204,
0.46366190910339355,
0.395548015832901,
0.11939232051372528,
0.24156202375888824,
0.17246250808238983,
-0.9533455967903137,
0.20069560408592224,
0.4388967454433441,
-0.05518633872270584,
0.060795992612838745,
0.22839967906475067,
0.7543081045150757,
0.2859254777431488,
-0.9087708592414856,
0.47404617071151733,
0.2424057126045227,
-0.09489480406045914,
-0.6242749094963074,
-0.005529308225959539,
0.22262167930603027,
0.13965319097042084,
0.22729820013046265,
-0.05308496579527855,
0.3649570941925049,
-0.4407622218132019,
0.31797799468040466,
0.29658615589141846,
-0.4660455882549286,
-0.3137556314468384,
0.7070710062980652,
0.0696553885936737,
-0.5107313394546509,
0.7787381410598755,
-0.3923236131668091,
-0.44019898772239685,
0.28457462787628174,
0.47698378562927246,
0.6842491626739502,
-0.6347705721855164,
0.32539433240890503,
0.49270910024642944,
0.2398688793182373,
-0.18991467356681824,
0.3911150097846985,
-0.09313197433948517,
-0.39318257570266724,
-0.4979982078075409,
-0.8552724123001099,
-0.5765814185142517,
0.3605079650878906,
-0.6072529554367065,
0.3111131191253662,
-0.36511629819869995,
-0.051128972321748734,
0.2305118292570114,
0.12011304497718811,
-0.6750827431678772,
0.1542520523071289,
0.23510581254959106,
0.7388758659362793,
-0.6352481842041016,
0.9574072360992432,
0.6287643909454346,
-0.13502241671085358,
-0.63507479429245,
-0.2970026135444641,
0.39392581582069397,
-0.9799110293388367,
0.5912244915962219,
0.061593446880578995,
-0.3914479613304138,
0.17895805835723877,
-0.39546412229537964,
-1.2197306156158447,
0.7404800653457642,
0.16488313674926758,
-0.6317665576934814,
0.12176632881164551,
0.3521099090576172,
0.6141253113746643,
-0.054467566311359406,
0.06888753175735474,
0.6909604668617249,
0.3519890606403351,
0.35011351108551025,
-1.176517128944397,
-0.4548109471797943,
-0.23706793785095215,
-0.07291759550571442,
0.008381027728319168,
-0.9634382128715515,
0.8927199244499207,
-0.26757779717445374,
-0.21766288578510284,
-0.08528587222099304,
0.3963962197303772,
0.07609277218580246,
-0.023501956835389137,
0.5187104940414429,
0.5089209675788879,
0.7988121509552002,
0.01694442518055439,
0.6752756834030151,
-0.06378735601902008,
0.15112239122390747,
1.382734775543213,
-0.38725289702415466,
1.2337855100631714,
0.3852383494377136,
-0.5193743705749512,
0.25950565934181213,
0.4444452226161957,
-0.18301622569561005,
0.4489036202430725,
0.1670587807893753,
-0.1993507295846939,
-0.15084341168403625,
-0.2765716314315796,
-0.24495716392993927,
0.9999411106109619,
0.47808346152305603,
0.06507744640111923,
-0.04584307223558426,
-0.06689511239528656,
-0.1321721225976944,
-0.2542608082294464,
-0.19547685980796814,
0.8194490075111389,
-0.08061650395393372,
-0.34967851638793945,
0.7978307604789734,
-0.10802886635065079,
0.5376750826835632,
-0.631925106048584,
0.1312575340270996,
0.061667609959840775,
0.2455226331949234,
-0.08536309003829956,
-0.5109812021255493,
0.24106138944625854,
0.2694718837738037,
-0.03566017746925354,
-0.13734540343284607,
0.5108723044395447,
-0.5073174834251404,
-0.49541547894477844,
0.18407735228538513,
0.4690952003002167,
0.34589308500289917,
-0.2805541455745697,
-0.47888532280921936,
0.36169466376304626,
-0.061402153223752975,
0.0830753967165947,
0.29675883054733276,
0.11295951157808304,
0.2724943459033966,
0.49988389015197754,
0.9023679494857788,
0.374377578496933,
-0.012995111756026745,
0.18205229938030243,
0.7599309086799622,
-0.33405745029449463,
-0.7195926904678345,
-0.30224090814590454,
0.42534929513931274,
-0.07113422453403473,
-0.2796732187271118,
0.44554808735847473,
1.0029175281524658,
0.7534526586532593,
-0.05967961624264717,
0.8315571546554565,
0.2207149863243103,
0.9876094460487366,
-0.35113853216171265,
0.8223260045051575,
-0.447080135345459,
-0.1742287129163742,
0.039448581635951996,
-0.8044178485870361,
-0.04404706880450249,
0.5831230282783508,
0.04191213101148605,
-0.17460104823112488,
0.44125866889953613,
0.6956843137741089,
-0.19886276125907898,
-0.025599174201488495,
0.16646148264408112,
0.27320966124534607,
0.3890065550804138,
0.34513774514198303,
0.6252948641777039,
-0.3316144645214081,
0.6621753573417664,
-0.025012221187353134,
-0.3357134759426117,
-0.27718228101730347,
-0.24692386388778687,
-0.49028751254081726,
-0.8878606557846069,
-0.3444252908229828,
-0.2542601227760315,
-0.03676386550068855,
0.833848774433136,
0.6927548050880432,
-0.792760968208313,
-0.42627787590026855,
0.3395269215106964,
-0.45340970158576965,
-0.1972702294588089,
-0.2069755494594574,
0.4593883752822876,
-0.36073482036590576,
-0.7868975400924683,
0.7203357815742493,
0.36751461029052734,
-0.023600658401846886,
-0.26592567563056946,
0.0005553359515033662,
-0.03759218752384186,
-0.012815560214221478,
0.7444204688072205,
0.5169783234596252,
-0.7133203148841858,
-0.2487199902534485,
-0.17740462720394135,
0.04539689049124718,
0.1118922308087349,
0.8170478940010071,
-0.7600133419036865,
0.6777907013893127,
0.05568844452500343,
0.8220969438552856,
0.6542841792106628,
-0.1223607063293457,
0.11914800107479095,
-0.6801319122314453,
0.20612314343452454,
0.32659366726875305,
0.18036401271820068,
0.6301649808883667,
-0.10593444854021072,
0.6077185273170471,
0.045818477869033813,
-0.46524888277053833,
-0.911838948726654,
0.1481250375509262,
-0.9008609652519226,
0.09874783456325531,
1.4848233461380005,
0.21585291624069214,
0.1828804612159729,
-0.19903229176998138,
-0.26954981684684753,
0.28933414816856384,
-0.4290071129798889,
1.0164954662322998,
0.559617817401886,
-0.04000014811754227,
-0.10821247100830078,
-0.835138201713562,
0.5980127453804016,
0.08761339634656906,
-0.6507629752159119,
0.4595277011394501,
0.6087568998336792,
0.28966134786605835,
0.36009493470191956,
0.5620973706245422,
-0.11101314425468445,
0.391516774892807,
0.31968745589256287,
-0.029288535937666893,
-0.10682269185781479,
-0.35532256960868835,
-0.4380919933319092,
0.14275139570236206,
0.005898436531424522,
-0.14033472537994385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11514v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11514v1 | Counterfactual Debating with Preset Stances for Hallucination Elimination of LLMs | 2024-06-17T13:21:23 | 2024-06-17T13:21:23 | Yi Fang, Moxin Li, Wenjie Wang, Hui Lin, Fuli Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in various natural language processing
tasks but struggle with hallucination issues. Existing solutions have
considered utilizing LLMs' inherent reasoning abilities to alleviate
hallucination, such as self-correction and diverse sampling methods. However,
these methods often overtrust LLMs' initial answers due to inherent biases. The
key to alleviating this issue lies in overriding LLMs' inherent biases for
answer inspection. To this end, we propose a CounterFactual Multi-Agent Debate
(CFMAD) framework. CFMAD presets the stances of LLMs to override their inherent
biases by compelling LLMs to generate justifications for a predetermined
answer's correctness. The LLMs with different predetermined stances are engaged
with a skeptical critic for counterfactual debate on the rationality of
generated justifications. Finally, the debate process is evaluated by a
third-party judge to determine the final answer. Extensive experiments on four
datasets of three tasks demonstrate the superiority of CFMAD over existing
methods. | [
-0.9296093583106995,
-1.1326850652694702,
0.9298966526985168,
0.007179894018918276,
-0.29699790477752686,
-0.06410204619169235,
-0.3225279450416565,
-0.40906134247779846,
0.4895499646663666,
0.8302233219146729,
-0.6295064091682434,
-0.28116217255592346,
-0.5027074813842773,
0.27871111035346985,
-0.32152655720710754,
0.9316026568412781,
-0.16738252341747284,
0.17558090388774872,
-0.5433673858642578,
-0.36403825879096985,
-0.3906073570251465,
-0.7610493898391724,
-0.4716044068336487,
-0.6515346765518188,
0.616200864315033,
0.4278014302253723,
0.9244682192802429,
0.2554347515106201,
0.1992967426776886,
0.42706045508384705,
0.19284971058368683,
0.30315542221069336,
-0.4438338279724121,
0.4014407694339752,
-0.540478527545929,
-0.31513357162475586,
-0.3255729079246521,
0.17258968949317932,
0.16355495154857635,
0.5424779653549194,
-0.23120194673538208,
-0.07191836088895798,
-0.22196999192237854,
0.3479160666465759,
-0.5452122092247009,
-0.35176822543144226,
-0.82261723279953,
0.07084885984659195,
0.023518230766057968,
-0.37862130999565125,
-0.40715882182121277,
-0.3256075978279114,
0.2309519201517105,
-0.45150697231292725,
0.3807695806026459,
0.0031022250186651945,
0.6646350026130676,
0.49842843413352966,
-0.44035521149635315,
-0.39289769530296326,
-0.7320181727409363,
0.601238489151001,
-0.5975849032402039,
0.3458862900733948,
0.5193496346473694,
-0.0313187874853611,
-0.2185388207435608,
-0.5138342380523682,
-0.8938705921173096,
-0.21320247650146484,
-0.23972077667713165,
0.06013980135321617,
-0.28433284163475037,
0.1430511176586151,
0.20300684869289398,
0.004497310612350702,
-0.7477185726165771,
0.21699856221675873,
-0.10946539044380188,
-0.22986501455307007,
0.49810007214546204,
0.18418608605861664,
0.011728606186807156,
-0.08901116251945496,
-0.3121147155761719,
0.2243867963552475,
-0.7341663837432861,
-0.34748488664627075,
0.2682528495788574,
0.0485469214618206,
0.40613189339637756,
0.6334462761878967,
-0.28978028893470764,
0.32886630296707153,
0.39509716629981995,
0.24092335999011993,
0.20413440465927124,
-0.13996794819831848,
-0.45615774393081665,
0.22535376250743866,
0.6578916907310486,
0.45953577756881714,
0.2186281979084015,
-0.27287644147872925,
-0.3106527626514435,
0.3104320168495178,
0.609618604183197,
-0.7753468751907349,
-0.03581001237034798,
0.6945246458053589,
-0.40440648794174194,
-0.12234468013048172,
-0.27540311217308044,
-0.846997857093811,
-0.6511889100074768,
-0.515192985534668,
0.5759009718894958,
0.030350765213370323,
-0.303061306476593,
0.17412169277668,
0.042157724499702454,
0.301215797662735,
0.4755268394947052,
-0.5475727319717407,
0.3296580910682678,
0.6023485064506531,
0.6446247100830078,
-0.10800614207983017,
-0.36378321051597595,
-0.7287298440933228,
-0.00617282185703516,
-0.505664050579071,
1.106174111366272,
-0.7087277770042419,
-0.5327019095420837,
-0.21236233413219452,
0.12879739701747894,
-0.1316710114479065,
-0.6872221231460571,
0.30682459473609924,
-0.5323491096496582,
0.4002569317817688,
-0.763348400592804,
-0.6589223146438599,
-0.16549865901470184,
0.750219464302063,
-0.6075723767280579,
0.7267037034034729,
-0.3147742450237274,
-0.698034942150116,
0.317125141620636,
-0.6710255742073059,
-0.3384817838668823,
-0.01924859918653965,
-0.5920600295066833,
-0.4362020194530487,
-0.03606089577078819,
0.2966250479221344,
0.2076772153377533,
-0.21279123425483704,
0.6179218292236328,
-0.4695259928703308,
-0.4260399043560028,
0.28251340985298157,
-0.41638949513435364,
0.7152895331382751,
0.27711209654808044,
-0.7241740822792053,
0.5397564768791199,
-0.5107718706130981,
-0.3337266743183136,
0.09175440669059753,
0.12991490960121155,
-0.23106053471565247,
-0.007195433136075735,
-0.3274145722389221,
0.3818342387676239,
-0.04636824503540993,
-0.5025399923324585,
0.06481368094682693,
-0.40877267718315125,
0.1910833716392517,
0.9853214025497437,
-0.01966322772204876,
0.30121320486068726,
-0.6796879172325134,
0.6991065144538879,
0.012452368624508381,
0.20898942649364471,
0.22913606464862823,
-0.20901907980442047,
-0.8918498754501343,
-0.2121160924434662,
-0.27201980352401733,
0.46556389331817627,
-1.1120020151138306,
0.24084822833538055,
0.12045866996049881,
-0.4266031086444855,
-0.43078213930130005,
0.1776258498430252,
0.3962952792644501,
0.49324825406074524,
0.5809730291366577,
-0.12101157754659653,
-0.5824746489524841,
-0.8416478633880615,
0.021754521876573563,
-0.23531027138233185,
0.3386780321598053,
0.18858586251735687,
0.5505695343017578,
-0.3643990159034729,
0.9304304122924805,
-0.4424684941768646,
-0.2764851450920105,
-0.26940950751304626,
0.4549064636230469,
-0.06610134243965149,
0.2799871265888214,
0.5626012682914734,
-0.6984003782272339,
-0.12499446421861649,
-0.31164541840553284,
-0.8473423719406128,
-0.228830024600029,
-0.41237324476242065,
-0.282377690076828,
0.7075634002685547,
0.7992677688598633,
-1.041018009185791,
0.5105776190757751,
0.21687227487564087,
-0.3802735507488251,
0.8225613236427307,
-0.07117675244808197,
0.1805405169725418,
-0.7513110637664795,
0.05965443328022957,
-0.21881787478923798,
-0.12263389676809311,
-0.6810219883918762,
0.16246338188648224,
-0.5627098679542542,
0.41735589504241943,
-0.3282417953014374,
0.7170057892799377,
-0.25362977385520935,
0.04767323657870293,
-0.5710734128952026,
0.303666889667511,
0.00010424752690596506,
0.4665621221065521,
0.5317178964614868,
0.4689856469631195,
0.28906959295272827,
-0.4293394088745117,
0.5349070429801941,
0.24109861254692078,
-0.035617001354694366,
0.7989259958267212,
-0.6151525378227234,
0.38004356622695923,
-0.35732176899909973,
0.5602028369903564,
-1.0572186708450317,
0.17557190358638763,
0.6546460390090942,
-0.317843496799469,
-0.2692493498325348,
0.24643677473068237,
-0.3670459985733032,
-0.28245022892951965,
-0.5214172601699829,
0.33111369609832764,
-0.04168235883116722,
-0.7008439898490906,
0.6381539702415466,
0.15028811991214752,
-0.15746484696865082,
-0.896052360534668,
-0.2949114143848419,
0.3393003046512604,
-0.35842040181159973,
-0.21528960764408112,
0.06248929351568222,
-0.4957939088344574,
-0.6045551300048828,
-0.09371576458215714,
-0.2261531949043274,
0.12719616293907166,
-0.04555204138159752,
0.2557416260242462,
0.2926560342311859,
-0.19439944624900818,
0.3988671600818634,
0.017029723152518272,
0.034913498908281326,
0.35018104314804077,
-0.0833025798201561,
0.7951887249946594,
-0.06055396422743797,
-0.46550577878952026,
-0.033171460032463074,
0.48382139205932617,
0.568932831287384,
-0.09377937763929367,
0.6696199178695679,
0.5133101344108582,
-0.40118932723999023,
-0.1942441612482071,
-1.0422136783599854,
-0.378644198179245,
-0.48492324352264404,
0.20222681760787964,
-0.6144660115242004,
-0.7751047015190125,
0.648724377155304,
0.19308623671531677,
0.21432818472385406,
0.2027767300605774,
0.8524091243743896,
-0.07795652002096176,
0.7335774898529053,
0.0857984721660614,
0.20068880915641785,
0.08459793776273727,
-0.051429327577352524,
0.1853473037481308,
-0.3462508022785187,
-0.36681410670280457,
-0.649280309677124,
-0.21109120547771454,
-0.32024946808815,
-0.373328298330307,
0.04155482351779938,
-0.384013831615448,
-0.18671724200248718,
0.06044941022992134,
-0.30462297797203064,
0.5449230074882507,
0.27536118030548096,
0.20477397739887238,
0.31467515230178833,
-0.31042420864105225,
-0.32856640219688416,
0.04316647723317146,
-0.3424946963787079,
-0.6193978190422058,
0.8663660287857056,
0.13709264993667603,
0.5595012903213501,
0.2567298710346222,
0.6982434988021851,
0.3337175250053406,
0.6924434304237366,
-0.728024423122406,
0.7621204853057861,
0.2105088233947754,
-0.8844422698020935,
-0.5954359769821167,
-0.3304051458835602,
-0.8695089221000671,
0.8385416865348816,
-0.3215406835079193,
-0.5514758825302124,
0.4162418246269226,
0.17484305799007416,
-0.3617921769618988,
0.28078606724739075,
-0.2884419560432434,
0.8430277705192566,
-0.10996295511722565,
-0.5141189098358154,
-0.34289056062698364,
-0.7076089978218079,
0.4480374753475189,
-0.16577082872390747,
0.1826825588941574,
0.19107697904109955,
0.2848850190639496,
0.6158995032310486,
-0.6272697448730469,
0.9426138401031494,
-0.22801710665225983,
-0.5575444102287292,
0.3065359890460968,
0.16722074151039124,
0.5562609434127808,
0.24354051053524017,
-0.01011953130364418,
-0.07568774372339249,
-0.01749642752110958,
-0.22670570015907288,
-0.6699428558349609,
0.6587851047515869,
-0.7551603317260742,
-1.169167399406433,
-0.48777687549591064,
-0.357953280210495,
-0.2629958391189575,
0.12852540612220764,
0.2935701310634613,
0.3777867257595062,
-0.5322982668876648,
0.016064738854765892,
0.675337553024292,
-0.21701081097126007,
0.4379197657108307,
0.7193788290023804,
-0.4195731282234192,
-0.3015121519565582,
0.6913672089576721,
0.10161210596561432,
0.1853019744157791,
0.1121966615319252,
0.1766740381717682,
-0.6540224552154541,
-0.5299843549728394,
-0.42575711011886597,
0.1943780928850174,
-0.9470086693763733,
-0.10253749787807465,
-1.0454516410827637,
-0.17790934443473816,
-0.506229817867279,
-0.26068440079689026,
-0.41050755977630615,
-0.13547804951667786,
-0.3174274265766144,
-0.34540605545043945,
-0.08417205512523651,
0.6599597334861755,
-0.2743374705314636,
0.2636299729347229,
-0.44485706090927124,
0.7779249548912048,
0.5768548846244812,
0.047748398035764694,
0.07113096863031387,
-0.4639355540275574,
0.17624512314796448,
0.0010233010398223996,
-0.4898352324962616,
-0.90287184715271,
0.2713397443294525,
-0.3759201467037201,
0.8467397093772888,
0.5521548390388489,
0.3625926971435547,
0.7438868284225464,
-0.3151909112930298,
0.6085718870162964,
0.06505785882472992,
-1.1427006721496582,
0.27926915884017944,
-0.1088109016418457,
0.057100001722574234,
0.569847822189331,
0.48541322350502014,
-0.39608898758888245,
-0.7328618764877319,
-0.5086798071861267,
-0.6004214882850647,
0.49161526560783386,
0.1321515142917633,
-0.06910501420497894,
-0.2740177810192108,
0.14248274266719818,
0.3244856297969818,
0.2700464427471161,
-0.8947181701660156,
-0.03462439775466919,
-0.536599338054657,
0.1942521631717682,
-0.20592254400253296,
-0.21734189987182617,
-0.4313521683216095,
-0.28303179144859314,
0.5987956523895264,
-0.12634997069835663,
-0.1284290850162506,
0.5808016657829285,
-0.46189358830451965,
-0.3617049753665924,
0.3841753900051117,
0.937424898147583,
0.9207370281219482,
-0.24706199765205383,
0.6307833194732666,
0.32556867599487305,
-0.1538732349872589,
0.39324241876602173,
0.0209181010723114,
-0.09723395854234695,
0.04143098369240761,
0.4163554906845093,
0.6164165735244751,
-0.2689613103866577,
-0.6179970502853394,
0.3383370637893677,
-0.13075976073741913,
-0.5758018493652344,
-0.31923922896385193,
-0.13646218180656433,
0.15576748549938202,
0.4291461706161499,
0.2574818730354309,
0.049206215888261795,
0.21099774539470673,
-0.580240786075592,
0.47493791580200195,
0.7036907076835632,
-0.32753413915634155,
-0.10880116373300552,
0.5071884393692017,
0.16309933364391327,
-0.14892378449440002,
0.5237990617752075,
-0.30351564288139343,
-0.5958220362663269,
0.8149518966674805,
0.4641379117965698,
0.9062045812606812,
-0.4147419333457947,
0.5300984978675842,
0.055941421538591385,
0.609236478805542,
-0.09024281054735184,
0.3360196650028229,
0.009668421931564808,
-1.0805084705352783,
-0.3666665256023407,
-0.275723934173584,
-0.5851871967315674,
0.5171260833740234,
-0.441602885723114,
0.17849597334861755,
-0.4073909521102905,
-0.11156082153320312,
-0.03298961743712425,
0.010400104336440563,
-0.48832735419273376,
0.2950323820114136,
0.1883915513753891,
0.573600172996521,
-0.9040586352348328,
0.7737484574317932,
0.59073406457901,
-0.3023393452167511,
-0.14339199662208557,
0.2976675033569336,
0.15520738065242767,
-0.49304482340812683,
0.47477418184280396,
0.2278578132390976,
-0.7384594678878784,
-0.38355791568756104,
-0.8067989349365234,
-0.3896682560443878,
0.6522731184959412,
0.470523476600647,
-0.5072638988494873,
0.26279452443122864,
0.05756605416536331,
0.6285804510116577,
-0.36205974221229553,
0.3699890375137329,
0.5235193371772766,
0.7122352123260498,
0.3646356761455536,
-0.8222600221633911,
0.4065093994140625,
-0.1310614049434662,
-0.5596055388450623,
-0.1992303431034088,
-0.6893323659896851,
0.7871354818344116,
-0.41127321124076843,
-0.01079521980136633,
0.01610567606985569,
0.5459492206573486,
0.4668716490268707,
0.554399311542511,
0.9304571747779846,
0.3615592420101166,
0.5991638898849487,
0.2688606381416321,
0.4926307797431946,
0.12331771105527878,
0.1551675647497177,
1.439300298690796,
-0.7917727828025818,
0.5986198782920837,
0.7007764577865601,
0.14461763203144073,
0.2698057293891907,
0.614676296710968,
0.10192187130451202,
0.30861857533454895,
0.5145548582077026,
-0.10348572582006454,
-0.65629643201828,
-0.2859790623188019,
-0.3164078891277313,
0.7212904095649719,
0.2654300332069397,
-0.01617133989930153,
-0.29530853033065796,
-0.00009677608613856137,
0.21569041907787323,
0.3931271433830261,
0.10194595903158188,
0.7021152377128601,
-0.032534606754779816,
-0.970319926738739,
0.6196622848510742,
-0.0260902252048254,
0.5380433201789856,
-0.2797786593437195,
-0.13017317652702332,
-0.55820232629776,
0.00764877675101161,
-0.15829357504844666,
-0.41380488872528076,
0.41680410504341125,
-0.1673406958580017,
-0.06262782216072083,
-0.24910566210746765,
0.4122922122478485,
-0.45951026678085327,
-0.32241007685661316,
0.5701209902763367,
0.7487032413482666,
0.154694601893425,
-0.1109636127948761,
-0.6082242131233215,
0.03798947483301163,
-0.20526646077632904,
-0.4584610164165497,
0.08765964955091476,
0.35316482186317444,
-0.21258872747421265,
0.6331729292869568,
0.5108497142791748,
-0.010525626130402088,
-0.1818363517522812,
0.34933435916900635,
1.108760952949524,
-0.6668863892555237,
-0.48499539494514465,
-1.1184306144714355,
-0.024755917489528656,
-0.11335853487253189,
-0.04590083658695221,
0.6147454380989075,
0.4446006715297699,
0.7807446718215942,
0.06528910994529724,
0.6860691905021667,
0.30271559953689575,
0.2797805964946747,
-0.5394337773323059,
0.6985694766044617,
-0.5839551687240601,
0.30910733342170715,
-0.4720202386379242,
-0.8959100842475891,
-0.18233291804790497,
0.8345327973365784,
-0.2912101745605469,
0.04998651519417763,
0.9041314721107483,
0.9317678809165955,
0.10194366425275803,
0.21347308158874512,
0.3653922975063324,
0.3602101504802704,
0.45447978377342224,
0.5841041803359985,
1.2650405168533325,
0.09431780129671097,
0.5487574338912964,
-0.005255599971860647,
-0.028380190953612328,
-0.08977241814136505,
-0.7616270780563354,
-1.2892595529556274,
-0.3982124328613281,
-0.37211158871650696,
-0.35576608777046204,
0.09172335267066956,
1.2909008264541626,
0.397690087556839,
-0.8442941904067993,
-0.24196943640708923,
0.1357744038105011,
0.4802396595478058,
-0.1321548968553543,
-0.20180979371070862,
0.2885153591632843,
-0.255830854177475,
-0.5974435806274414,
0.2881636321544647,
0.09598973393440247,
-0.1501387655735016,
-0.4796246886253357,
-0.2848808169364929,
-0.4409276247024536,
0.5740099549293518,
0.5815666913986206,
0.10329810529947281,
-1.0765560865402222,
-0.5078251957893372,
0.011312786489725113,
-0.04633333534002304,
0.1115216389298439,
0.8942816257476807,
-0.8107026219367981,
0.41170769929885864,
0.4552670121192932,
0.4545169770717621,
0.2610548436641693,
0.10506757348775864,
0.4543258845806122,
-0.5298426747322083,
0.1398329734802246,
0.09431026875972748,
0.25346094369888306,
0.07664165645837784,
-0.3740086257457733,
0.37944144010543823,
0.3557800054550171,
-0.4224213659763336,
-1.0000183582305908,
0.1842048019170761,
-0.7470277547836304,
-0.7831847071647644,
1.0730658769607544,
0.06104526296257973,
0.2735550105571747,
-0.5522157549858093,
-0.37042590975761414,
0.2521510720252991,
-0.1981271356344223,
1.10718834400177,
1.0694373846054077,
-0.17080049216747284,
-0.2188514769077301,
-0.2908287048339844,
0.4633534848690033,
0.7001649141311646,
-1.0163298845291138,
0.18157020211219788,
0.6910854578018188,
0.08948886394500732,
0.2046649307012558,
1.153516411781311,
0.07241889089345932,
0.1130576804280281,
-0.1088375598192215,
0.03550669178366661,
0.03882087022066116,
-0.6982817053794861,
-0.2556630074977875,
0.2748051881790161,
-0.09430615603923798,
-0.06860597431659698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11930v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11930v1 | A Critical Study of What Code-LLMs (Do Not) Learn | 2024-06-17T13:11:17 | 2024-06-17T13:11:17 | Abhinav Anand, Shweta Verma, Krishna Narasimhan, Mira Mezini | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models trained on code corpora (code-LLMs) have demonstrated
impressive performance in various coding assistance tasks. However, despite
their increased size and training dataset, code-LLMs still have limitations
such as suggesting codes with syntactic errors, variable misuse etc. Some
studies argue that code-LLMs perform well on coding tasks because they use
self-attention and hidden representations to encode relations among input
tokens. However, previous works have not studied what code properties are not
encoded by code-LLMs. In this paper, we conduct a fine-grained analysis of
attention maps and hidden representations of code-LLMs. Our study indicates
that code-LLMs only encode relations among specific subsets of input tokens.
Specifically, by categorizing input tokens into syntactic tokens and
identifiers, we found that models encode relations among syntactic tokens and
among identifiers, but they fail to encode relations between syntactic tokens
and identifiers. We also found that fine-tuned models encode these relations
poorly compared to their pre-trained counterparts. Additionally, larger models
with billions of parameters encode significantly less information about code
than models with only a few hundred million parameters. | [
-0.33516985177993774,
-0.3903207778930664,
0.6453814506530762,
0.110956110060215,
-0.02735831029713154,
0.3353051543235779,
-0.5037768483161926,
-0.5940001606941223,
0.09133414179086685,
0.44700849056243896,
-0.42360296845436096,
-0.6582067608833313,
-0.7687452435493469,
0.37064409255981445,
-0.33820289373397827,
1.1124598979949951,
-0.043392252177000046,
0.1711253523826599,
-0.36948803067207336,
-0.11319078505039215,
-0.1535762995481491,
-0.9347838759422302,
0.0013279239647090435,
-0.09203198552131653,
0.4868432283401489,
0.3389046788215637,
0.46691837906837463,
0.6593000888824463,
0.7241075038909912,
0.24536997079849243,
-0.24899815022945404,
0.21084339916706085,
-0.6562393307685852,
-0.2655302584171295,
-0.028334535658359528,
-0.873802661895752,
-0.2581094205379486,
-0.010322751477360725,
0.41839802265167236,
0.7946465015411377,
0.42016053199768066,
0.5715524554252625,
0.08154638111591339,
0.5626842379570007,
-0.6850904822349548,
0.6709279417991638,
-0.7136303782463074,
0.1627947986125946,
-0.01498433668166399,
-0.24265481531620026,
-0.5032392740249634,
-0.30502423644065857,
-0.3105960190296173,
-0.23190470039844513,
0.21013963222503662,
0.13129645586013794,
0.8182712197303772,
0.5377885699272156,
-0.1606956273317337,
-0.649946928024292,
-0.6566425561904907,
0.6644631028175354,
-0.6804968118667603,
0.1409326195716858,
0.6644173264503479,
-0.11550242453813553,
0.004039801191538572,
-0.28880470991134644,
-0.20306460559368134,
-0.3105239272117615,
-0.4370098114013672,
-0.1912480741739273,
-0.04789124056696892,
0.2618354856967926,
0.4465937316417694,
0.4832402169704437,
-0.3841763138771057,
0.24901370704174042,
-0.47445181012153625,
-0.15500079095363617,
0.33444029092788696,
0.18080322444438934,
0.06834347546100616,
-0.2909155786037445,
-0.6870774030685425,
0.13868014514446259,
-0.6120948791503906,
0.06942900270223618,
0.07125353068113327,
0.13837464153766632,
-0.40787622332572937,
0.6765724420547485,
0.1897062212228775,
0.611601710319519,
0.24393482506275177,
-0.3628714680671692,
0.30366361141204834,
-0.29980525374412537,
-0.5098706483840942,
-0.29044267535209656,
0.8010905385017395,
-0.10301250964403152,
0.6360576748847961,
-0.549362063407898,
-0.25806185603141785,
0.37341365218162537,
0.13979168236255646,
-0.4209307134151459,
0.02901245467364788,
0.19732429087162018,
-0.5856614112854004,
-0.240568608045578,
0.02086356095969677,
-0.4739137291908264,
-0.18689244985580444,
-0.2543560564517975,
0.24146762490272522,
-0.19359090924263,
0.0036303834058344364,
0.01572314463555813,
-0.026210593059659004,
0.27707937359809875,
0.00043968227691948414,
-0.8239787817001343,
0.25065967440605164,
0.5241526961326599,
0.511559784412384,
-0.28486257791519165,
-0.24506135284900665,
-0.26175457239151,
0.04741079360246658,
-0.45636850595474243,
0.4444452226161957,
-1.0197288990020752,
-0.17351636290550232,
0.035211604088544846,
0.2776465117931366,
-0.25049149990081787,
-0.8530125617980957,
-0.0063255163840949535,
-0.7271277904510498,
-0.48124369978904724,
-0.27439767122268677,
-0.6447806358337402,
-0.06385733932256699,
0.06500054895877838,
-0.5328478217124939,
0.5741652846336365,
0.2028835117816925,
-0.6264716386795044,
0.14350399374961853,
-0.28824496269226074,
-0.3600194454193115,
-0.16150081157684326,
-0.5920583009719849,
-0.2424592226743698,
0.5101858973503113,
0.07596329599618912,
0.704807698726654,
-0.04038930684328079,
0.41232261061668396,
-0.4588939845561981,
-0.7590024471282959,
0.5409442782402039,
-0.22225025296211243,
0.4732295870780945,
0.19173775613307953,
-0.22886620461940765,
-0.02336730621755123,
-0.8086777329444885,
-0.14375893771648407,
0.22345088422298431,
-0.6869768500328064,
-0.0910048857331276,
-0.2619902789592743,
-0.15361137688159943,
0.34850722551345825,
0.41208207607269287,
-0.33675190806388855,
0.42410874366760254,
-0.22607839107513428,
0.4900110960006714,
0.6014301180839539,
-0.15783467888832092,
0.7271081209182739,
-0.2299060970544815,
0.7970234751701355,
0.2929193079471588,
-0.24073059856891632,
-0.18746617436408997,
-0.11831173300743103,
-1.0270040035247803,
-0.020569495856761932,
0.42806321382522583,
0.31010711193084717,
-0.7369704246520996,
0.20968887209892273,
-0.2004031240940094,
-0.136747345328331,
-0.4894605278968811,
0.35795068740844727,
0.8109080791473389,
0.02172822132706642,
0.2624417841434479,
-0.31417611241340637,
-0.43521085381507874,
-0.90814608335495,
-0.2872450053691864,
-0.13385075330734253,
0.13670967519283295,
0.23533311486244202,
0.5106487274169922,
-0.24474209547042847,
0.5563048124313354,
-0.3313741385936737,
-0.39776280522346497,
-0.35671719908714294,
-0.10406173765659332,
-0.08135497570037842,
0.29412227869033813,
0.5789815187454224,
-0.3280511796474457,
-0.18889939785003662,
-0.14797288179397583,
-0.8129647970199585,
0.03963444009423256,
-0.1732332855463028,
0.3551487624645233,
0.17726968228816986,
0.7104824185371399,
-0.3707962930202484,
0.5381991863250732,
0.7531149983406067,
-0.2701999247074127,
0.31887516379356384,
-0.34423407912254333,
-0.37057021260261536,
-0.4328048825263977,
-0.049042489379644394,
-0.0914342924952507,
-0.22471486032009125,
-0.3837369680404663,
0.3579581081867218,
0.4699893295764923,
-0.26125767827033997,
-0.3687310218811035,
0.45414572954177856,
-0.9000218510627747,
-0.5666301846504211,
-0.1780097484588623,
0.06025443598628044,
-0.08010704070329666,
1.3015673160552979,
0.16786037385463715,
0.7550828456878662,
0.538953423500061,
-0.8276079893112183,
-0.0508832111954689,
0.09841722249984741,
-0.018342619761824608,
0.09973444789648056,
-0.35219451785087585,
0.4119120240211487,
-0.14960439503192902,
-0.1930740922689438,
-0.748261034488678,
-0.1355583667755127,
0.1917896568775177,
-0.48428288102149963,
0.6323726177215576,
-0.3142935037612915,
-0.7768853902816772,
-0.15949881076812744,
-0.2620387673377991,
0.4301798343658447,
0.55376797914505,
-0.491122841835022,
0.20062482357025146,
0.43401747941970825,
0.3250572681427002,
-0.3402259349822998,
-0.893694281578064,
-0.11905614286661148,
-0.01970324106514454,
-0.10910508036613464,
0.12616008520126343,
-0.06083981692790985,
-0.18881598114967346,
0.09016150236129761,
-0.27732977271080017,
-0.24683290719985962,
0.07388297468423843,
0.6128414869308472,
0.06251221150159836,
-0.19536025822162628,
0.45323047041893005,
-0.29199057817459106,
-0.022817181423306465,
0.24105630815029144,
0.039129588752985,
0.47427111864089966,
-0.21469081938266754,
-0.34889158606529236,
-0.18627285957336426,
0.15269725024700165,
0.70082026720047,
-0.4317210912704468,
0.8365033268928528,
0.39017316699028015,
-0.2031545341014862,
-0.31315600872039795,
-0.3621014952659607,
0.07919833064079285,
-0.46701639890670776,
0.5526769757270813,
-0.33716291189193726,
-1.0299763679504395,
0.6378285884857178,
-0.11490460485219955,
-0.22694426774978638,
0.2752007842063904,
0.43887457251548767,
-0.0894794836640358,
0.5569416880607605,
0.8438389897346497,
-0.17907625436782837,
0.283387154340744,
-0.4230133593082428,
0.10203370451927185,
-1.0033228397369385,
-0.38490670919418335,
-0.5529784560203552,
-0.33047130703926086,
-0.7116656303405762,
-0.4788617789745331,
0.0933559238910675,
0.055524565279483795,
-0.1199120357632637,
0.4405182898044586,
-0.4284617304801941,
0.31532588601112366,
0.3813422620296478,
0.02128577046096325,
0.23821555078029633,
-0.06805533170700073,
0.0922035276889801,
-0.05559200793504715,
-0.9122377038002014,
-0.4537596106529236,
1.0856729745864868,
0.44615912437438965,
1.1825004816055298,
-0.147651806473732,
0.7801125645637512,
0.07394706457853317,
-0.13314971327781677,
-0.8662279844284058,
0.5303385257720947,
-0.23356544971466064,
-0.359189510345459,
0.033992063254117966,
-0.5177595615386963,
-0.9567237496376038,
-0.024133317172527313,
-0.03568413853645325,
-0.4286278486251831,
0.5635555386543274,
0.010438102297484875,
-0.35433536767959595,
0.3428735136985779,
-0.9695250391960144,
0.6985832452774048,
-0.25056299567222595,
-0.27858424186706543,
0.12825603783130646,
-0.44063591957092285,
0.22775834798812866,
-0.30256345868110657,
0.37040719389915466,
0.10031726956367493,
-0.13115285336971283,
0.6539247632026672,
-0.19959715008735657,
1.13308846950531,
0.061540596187114716,
-0.22800351679325104,
0.18884925544261932,
0.24369020760059357,
0.5074180364608765,
0.016705254092812538,
0.10701189935207367,
0.3725937306880951,
-0.06662974506616592,
-0.3672601282596588,
-0.37746575474739075,
0.7025647163391113,
-0.8241488337516785,
-0.5090616345405579,
-0.22781749069690704,
-0.4343506395816803,
-0.331830769777298,
0.07870173454284668,
0.2262652963399887,
0.5594667196273804,
0.22467130422592163,
0.10448131710290909,
0.6456993222236633,
-0.4691610336303711,
0.6569934487342834,
0.37156128883361816,
-0.08779981732368469,
0.05106594040989876,
0.8892307281494141,
0.32012811303138733,
0.4511137008666992,
0.3335624635219574,
-0.3536401689052582,
0.15719972550868988,
-0.4913817346096039,
-0.15658289194107056,
0.4276716709136963,
-0.9326448440551758,
-0.3507823646068573,
-0.5698888301849365,
-0.3934754431247711,
-0.27582836151123047,
0.086228147149086,
-0.20200377702713013,
-0.22235725820064545,
-0.7388833165168762,
-0.14822407066822052,
0.25219258666038513,
1.0974575281143188,
0.1885147988796234,
0.0832943320274353,
-0.8760681748390198,
0.5703032612800598,
0.1558683216571808,
0.4809831976890564,
0.21314586699008942,
-0.5658837556838989,
-0.701878547668457,
-0.22523121535778046,
-0.09732840210199356,
-0.9052032828330994,
0.35396403074264526,
0.09802431613206863,
0.3605184853076935,
0.32244595885276794,
0.12420368939638138,
0.7517861127853394,
-0.5077842473983765,
0.5920908451080322,
-0.1485457718372345,
-0.925118625164032,
0.30822843313217163,
-0.023554008454084396,
0.5298648476600647,
0.4101432263851166,
0.12310310453176498,
0.006310080643743277,
-0.7408611178398132,
-0.614649772644043,
-0.35806819796562195,
0.9154555797576904,
0.08767809718847275,
0.46693775057792664,
-0.29151129722595215,
0.565035879611969,
0.11276528239250183,
0.30493980646133423,
-0.9979628324508667,
-0.42676398158073425,
0.17566601932048798,
-0.20801886916160583,
0.07345803081989288,
-0.5765163898468018,
0.10705637186765671,
-0.08639578521251678,
0.014517041854560375,
-0.014386140741407871,
0.630722165107727,
0.14829564094543457,
-0.3681812882423401,
-0.16667377948760986,
0.29509487748146057,
0.6609542369842529,
0.5778535008430481,
-0.08768188953399658,
0.5177422165870667,
0.09171118587255478,
-0.41762837767601013,
-0.009189371019601822,
-0.24803726375102997,
0.19475431740283966,
0.0969552993774414,
0.7545692324638367,
0.8728562593460083,
0.5608494281768799,
-0.6622342467308044,
0.6106953620910645,
0.0742173120379448,
-0.0392170175909996,
-0.33272621035575867,
0.40249747037887573,
0.22514142096042633,
0.167620450258255,
0.10639303922653198,
0.29603955149650574,
-0.1361950933933258,
-0.7165992259979248,
-0.19265469908714294,
0.48001474142074585,
-0.5214354991912842,
-0.5861726999282837,
0.5559638142585754,
0.08494348078966141,
-0.3370285630226135,
0.25074926018714905,
-0.2661197781562805,
-0.3317909836769104,
0.8838256597518921,
0.4815904200077057,
0.6794546842575073,
0.24364008009433746,
-0.06427497416734695,
0.27495262026786804,
0.5284812450408936,
0.17919859290122986,
-0.029421571642160416,
-0.21016405522823334,
-0.47775185108184814,
-0.30760738253593445,
-0.6203661561012268,
-0.12084480375051498,
0.34552863240242004,
-0.7977886199951172,
0.10265694558620453,
-0.7133880853652954,
-0.1340801864862442,
-0.26896440982818604,
-0.09910903126001358,
-1.1622954607009888,
0.1826755702495575,
0.03034033440053463,
0.6496689319610596,
-0.5479490756988525,
0.9074641466140747,
0.47967445850372314,
-0.6047887802124023,
-1.0627923011779785,
0.13596250116825104,
-0.4435015618801117,
-1.045576572418213,
0.945725679397583,
0.22932785749435425,
0.04833100736141205,
-0.11627038568258286,
-0.7174292206764221,
-1.0032187700271606,
0.6719750165939331,
0.624718427658081,
-0.8523884415626526,
-0.3767113983631134,
0.23374950885772705,
0.5828830599784851,
-0.3289279639720917,
0.03943247348070145,
0.19542138278484344,
0.2353191375732422,
-0.27361777424812317,
-1.0750266313552856,
0.016379060223698616,
0.016148235648870468,
0.11609134823083878,
0.027859844267368317,
-0.8786290287971497,
0.8001867532730103,
-0.4544472396373749,
-0.41612690687179565,
-0.170685276389122,
0.2071765810251236,
-0.07883596420288086,
0.05139989033341408,
-0.14662665128707886,
0.3218784034252167,
0.4150652587413788,
0.012523657642304897,
1.1148768663406372,
-0.4026893973350525,
0.6025511622428894,
1.122510552406311,
-0.19025544822216034,
0.7608383893966675,
0.5139593482017517,
-0.22347159683704376,
0.37324258685112,
0.5932534337043762,
-0.21538236737251282,
0.5432106256484985,
0.3010144829750061,
0.4284616708755493,
-0.3038298785686493,
0.1845189779996872,
-0.3209898769855499,
0.47230982780456543,
0.30174490809440613,
-0.845262348651886,
-0.024388086050748825,
-0.0320008210837841,
-0.023063622415065765,
0.16629105806350708,
-0.4690009653568268,
1.1293981075286865,
0.3747084438800812,
-0.46845105290412903,
0.961442768573761,
0.029418662190437317,
0.7473357915878296,
-0.3420681059360504,
-0.04309232905507088,
-0.3315078616142273,
0.0768856406211853,
-0.37566283345222473,
-0.4446339011192322,
0.29346221685409546,
0.19049689173698425,
-0.28653475642204285,
0.08620419353246689,
0.5916590094566345,
-0.35034626722335815,
-0.4875221252441406,
0.5879979133605957,
0.4733811914920807,
0.1949537694454193,
0.20952178537845612,
-0.25569283962249756,
0.36608806252479553,
-0.046032533049583435,
-0.08644888550043106,
0.5097622871398926,
0.5834355354309082,
0.14408089220523834,
0.6336807608604431,
0.30226749181747437,
0.3247724175453186,
0.16860103607177734,
-0.009566466324031353,
0.7863153219223022,
-0.7940430045127869,
-0.13675734400749207,
-0.9201647639274597,
0.15565790235996246,
0.40750816464424133,
-0.07966261357069016,
0.7076200246810913,
0.410998672246933,
1.0613359212875366,
-0.5097625851631165,
0.6073447465896606,
0.4742473065853119,
0.031069375574588776,
-0.7372622489929199,
0.3652440905570984,
-0.43577536940574646,
0.5665035247802734,
-0.11928631365299225,
-0.8619382977485657,
-0.19060514867305756,
0.5428124666213989,
-0.39379942417144775,
0.13847674429416656,
0.7234296798706055,
0.6119986176490784,
0.034552715718746185,
-0.43536174297332764,
0.6780117750167847,
0.23315897583961487,
-0.21652570366859436,
0.9761835336685181,
0.8636431097984314,
-0.3075164556503296,
0.5577676892280579,
0.07809045910835266,
0.03331568092107773,
-0.29902321100234985,
-0.3576984405517578,
-1.435136318206787,
-0.3973233699798584,
-0.2027283012866974,
-0.08163010329008102,
0.008665681816637516,
0.7873877882957458,
0.6938324570655823,
-0.6441805362701416,
-0.05657972767949104,
-0.18686969578266144,
0.09903759509325027,
0.06754498928785324,
-0.1791541874408722,
0.4391397535800934,
-0.6033875346183777,
-0.6119892001152039,
0.156762033700943,
0.47962018847465515,
-0.027100495994091034,
-0.6332431435585022,
-0.05316608026623726,
0.2811674475669861,
0.0430479533970356,
0.2807123064994812,
0.09256152808666229,
-0.9428080320358276,
-0.15857259929180145,
0.28895509243011475,
-0.3631148636341095,
0.3725852966308594,
0.6453646421432495,
-0.9652177691459656,
0.26014599204063416,
0.18816448748111725,
0.6622147560119629,
0.27325916290283203,
-0.2487463802099228,
0.20918139815330505,
-0.9498551487922668,
0.2433018982410431,
0.13900388777256012,
0.3891008198261261,
0.24835872650146484,
-0.5833299160003662,
0.3342420160770416,
-0.04142910614609718,
-0.3902103900909424,
-0.6604364514350891,
0.2454429268836975,
-0.7487735748291016,
-0.3944673538208008,
1.4089317321777344,
-0.37019339203834534,
-0.33511754870414734,
-0.11490707844495773,
-0.11089711636304855,
0.19872429966926575,
-0.2460004687309265,
0.5905897617340088,
0.5893085598945618,
-0.15958601236343384,
-0.17034469544887543,
-0.5143440961837769,
0.5746637582778931,
0.21859268844127655,
-0.5513536334037781,
0.26388218998908997,
0.2599581480026245,
0.4258083701133728,
0.3001810610294342,
0.5698295831680298,
-0.3147054612636566,
0.2385471612215042,
-0.11388437449932098,
-0.03628259524703026,
-0.22202245891094208,
-0.2923937141895294,
-0.7138891816139221,
0.45317816734313965,
0.4562242925167084,
-0.3263625204563141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11503v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11503v1 | GeoGPT4V: Towards Geometric Multi-modal Large Language Models with Geometric Image Generation | 2024-06-17T13:04:27 | 2024-06-17T13:04:27 | Shihao Cai, Keqin Bao, Hangyu Guo, Jizhi Zhang, Jun Song, Bo Zheng | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Large language models have seen widespread adoption in math problem-solving.
However, in geometry problems that usually require visual aids for better
understanding, even the most advanced multi-modal models currently still face
challenges in effectively using image information. High-quality data is crucial
for enhancing the geometric capabilities of multi-modal models, yet existing
open-source datasets and related efforts are either too challenging for direct
model learning or suffer from misalignment between text and images. To overcome
this issue, we introduce a novel pipeline that leverages GPT-4 and GPT-4V to
generate relatively basic geometry problems with aligned text and images,
facilitating model learning. We have produced a dataset of 4.9K geometry
problems and combined it with 19K open-source data to form our GeoGPT4V
dataset. Experimental results demonstrate that the GeoGPT4V dataset
significantly improves the geometry performance of various models on the
MathVista and MathVision benchmarks. The code is available at
https://github.com/Lanyu0303/GeoGPT4V_Project | [
-0.31438273191452026,
-0.76178377866745,
0.9057807326316833,
0.006499286741018295,
-0.18283586204051971,
-0.26999345421791077,
-0.2213330715894699,
-0.24029047787189484,
-0.27925124764442444,
0.3507852852344513,
-0.4257518947124481,
-0.7628565430641174,
-0.4897371530532837,
-0.03354084864258766,
-0.12067163735628128,
0.9222807884216309,
-0.16415303945541382,
0.21305643022060394,
-0.1385922133922577,
-0.15354913473129272,
-0.5359096527099609,
-0.404613196849823,
-0.36204254627227783,
0.014417984522879124,
0.388556569814682,
0.1770544797182083,
0.8663691878318787,
0.6872652173042297,
0.6484444737434387,
0.33823883533477783,
0.4210408926010132,
0.08660675585269928,
-0.4721388816833496,
0.05253951996564865,
0.13733309507369995,
-0.21522676944732666,
-0.18385571241378784,
0.1203872486948967,
0.8029190897941589,
0.4063335359096527,
-0.23531901836395264,
0.037299394607543945,
-0.07037722319364548,
0.43841707706451416,
-0.2703896164894104,
0.6241055727005005,
-0.5085347294807434,
-0.04133119061589241,
-0.4808470606803894,
-0.041958365589380264,
0.06257441639900208,
-0.4888036847114563,
0.2541216313838959,
-1.1796300411224365,
0.3284231126308441,
-0.025261832401156425,
0.8121328949928284,
0.3526453673839569,
-0.4260539412498474,
-0.293503999710083,
-0.5040199160575867,
0.6444557905197144,
-0.5382257699966431,
0.7174499034881592,
0.3269082307815552,
0.4664163291454315,
-0.03875422477722168,
-0.6262428164482117,
-0.4100535809993744,
0.18396800756454468,
0.23668862879276276,
0.2592005431652069,
-0.09935513138771057,
-0.19250917434692383,
0.49073320627212524,
0.3300979733467102,
-0.7391757965087891,
-0.19639743864536285,
-0.6090701222419739,
-0.37381067872047424,
0.0773017480969429,
0.08842126280069351,
0.3275132179260254,
-0.48391008377075195,
-0.25234633684158325,
-0.12701250612735748,
-0.9367660880088806,
0.007245273794978857,
0.7201098203659058,
0.17082074284553528,
-0.1446084827184677,
0.7555197477340698,
0.14263632893562317,
0.8457037806510925,
-0.36374783515930176,
-0.08668606728315353,
0.3722304105758667,
-0.5556248426437378,
-0.20676355063915253,
-0.37187740206718445,
0.7617135047912598,
0.15187528729438782,
0.04025890305638313,
0.21727068722248077,
-0.23481516540050507,
0.09800509363412857,
-0.007361914962530136,
-0.8939625024795532,
-0.6585713624954224,
-0.2135244458913803,
-0.16510136425495148,
-0.13268183171749115,
-0.03447917103767395,
-0.9480466246604919,
-0.19854716956615448,
-0.5709986686706543,
0.5177351236343384,
-0.6236774325370789,
-0.28080374002456665,
0.24668091535568237,
0.06690879166126251,
0.2748481333255768,
0.4753371477127075,
-0.6217570304870605,
-0.1806461066007614,
0.5719256401062012,
0.977317750453949,
0.21050719916820526,
-0.21418344974517822,
-0.7068358659744263,
0.2657681405544281,
-0.3543621301651001,
0.6367686986923218,
-0.7489461302757263,
-0.23515067994594574,
-0.040434740483760834,
-0.03547936677932739,
0.21470476686954498,
-0.10314527899026871,
0.6054534912109375,
-0.17012102901935577,
0.7778334021568298,
-0.481755793094635,
-0.08235909789800644,
-0.3456692099571228,
0.3897886574268341,
-0.9484491348266602,
1.1588175296783447,
0.09183691442012787,
-0.7586817741394043,
0.258466511964798,
-0.654407799243927,
-0.0954182967543602,
0.3159439265727997,
-0.586890459060669,
-0.6269477605819702,
0.1466962993144989,
0.7058524489402771,
0.3012438416481018,
-0.4369732141494751,
0.23693707585334778,
-0.2925969958305359,
0.06189988926053047,
-0.1692931056022644,
-0.5251572728157043,
0.24684976041316986,
0.12676818668842316,
-0.19444972276687622,
0.131582111120224,
-0.47917842864990234,
-0.010782002471387386,
0.36082029342651367,
-0.371271014213562,
-0.404928982257843,
-0.1453513205051422,
0.0981341004371643,
0.3660356402397156,
0.20378361642360687,
-0.5613799095153809,
0.27890023589134216,
-0.12612466514110565,
0.4836868345737457,
0.7679569721221924,
-0.23293273150920868,
0.3493044674396515,
-0.11024026572704315,
0.5593297481536865,
-0.07748696208000183,
0.1313638836145401,
-0.38235577940940857,
-0.8459799289703369,
-0.37448564171791077,
-0.45017462968826294,
0.08392872661352158,
0.3215824365615845,
-1.2963272333145142,
-0.2417982667684555,
-0.4561660885810852,
-0.3005041182041168,
-0.11643160879611969,
0.08278480172157288,
0.35391125082969666,
0.7083014845848083,
0.34898197650909424,
-0.20980115234851837,
-0.20317524671554565,
-0.7236803770065308,
-0.019765954464673996,
0.16601485013961792,
-0.21034353971481323,
0.5739076733589172,
0.35997042059898376,
0.05505751818418503,
0.6667241454124451,
-0.7756128311157227,
-0.37867745757102966,
-0.025669779628515244,
0.2864791750907898,
0.14379194378852844,
0.2725752890110016,
0.735274612903595,
-0.7126469016075134,
-0.22692710161209106,
0.18680240213871002,
-0.8240554332733154,
-0.08883694559335709,
0.21217112243175507,
-0.21839699149131775,
0.16161037981510162,
0.2028118073940277,
-0.5433127880096436,
0.29758939146995544,
0.866533637046814,
-0.34659236669540405,
0.5527967810630798,
-0.2970986068248749,
0.3044247031211853,
-1.3234119415283203,
-0.04991050064563751,
0.5461370348930359,
-0.4171117842197418,
-0.3590339422225952,
-0.07335420697927475,
0.06250036507844925,
-0.7448643445968628,
-0.3221282958984375,
0.08673740923404694,
-0.662899911403656,
-0.34396815299987793,
0.10883542150259018,
-0.04345538467168808,
0.06834157556295395,
0.4176826775074005,
0.011563954874873161,
0.8368690609931946,
0.8520399332046509,
-0.09947279095649719,
0.7062912583351135,
0.3648342192173004,
-0.29479676485061646,
0.6872836947441101,
-0.661429226398468,
0.10950843244791031,
-0.18584103882312775,
0.2561945915222168,
-0.74277663230896,
-0.5739402770996094,
0.3026655614376068,
-0.1495652049779892,
0.041632890701293945,
-0.4575285315513611,
-0.42386019229888916,
-0.27872297167778015,
-0.24377769231796265,
0.8492149710655212,
0.2140679508447647,
-0.6351149082183838,
0.6430844664573669,
0.37362048029899597,
-0.3676939904689789,
-0.34500548243522644,
-0.41648605465888977,
0.09738517552614212,
-0.18623463809490204,
-0.7100269794464111,
0.004397562704980373,
0.022569427266716957,
0.3304191529750824,
0.3054732084274292,
0.03264780715107918,
-0.17590337991714478,
-0.4634755849838257,
0.14979997277259827,
0.37688037753105164,
-0.28366437554359436,
0.2124423384666443,
-0.28993552923202515,
-0.12633691728115082,
-0.01174760702997446,
-0.7149008512496948,
0.5426948666572571,
-0.47188788652420044,
-0.5915109515190125,
-0.43535321950912476,
0.3922251760959625,
0.6283770799636841,
-0.588744580745697,
0.14210812747478485,
0.7016038298606873,
-0.57430499792099,
0.13288460671901703,
-0.41604676842689514,
0.04184168577194214,
-0.46636971831321716,
0.4916066825389862,
-0.5701754689216614,
-0.7072592973709106,
0.2638685405254364,
-0.20028021931648254,
0.03499666973948479,
0.1969304084777832,
0.547122597694397,
0.1774587631225586,
0.9973825812339783,
0.5695562362670898,
0.08167529106140137,
0.552716851234436,
-0.2286035269498825,
0.36140477657318115,
-0.5421081185340881,
-0.3494948744773865,
-0.3965857923030853,
-0.22663776576519012,
-0.4482426941394806,
-0.7499556541442871,
0.7650930881500244,
-0.21845759451389313,
-0.22163182497024536,
0.13614942133426666,
-0.5395774245262146,
0.6517013311386108,
0.49825993180274963,
0.21889670193195343,
0.3474121391773224,
0.34614303708076477,
-0.14872317016124725,
-0.42796480655670166,
-0.5928548574447632,
-0.24702514708042145,
1.1746588945388794,
0.19741447269916534,
1.0309633016586304,
0.34434249997138977,
0.22384671866893768,
-0.29246777296066284,
-0.12289206683635712,
-0.6547168493270874,
0.2602114975452423,
-0.014055061154067516,
-0.3162161409854889,
-0.2646937072277069,
-0.8199026584625244,
-0.8238105177879333,
0.22634460031986237,
-0.34631842374801636,
-0.18745659291744232,
-0.16395211219787598,
0.2724338173866272,
-0.22215139865875244,
0.4941370189189911,
-0.7547959089279175,
1.0640325546264648,
-0.4563791751861572,
-0.342141717672348,
0.0708685964345932,
-0.28708168864250183,
0.4608030319213867,
-0.1605159491300583,
0.24847982823848724,
-0.07017271965742111,
0.1079551950097084,
0.2883126139640808,
-0.3519729673862457,
0.5891457200050354,
-0.34605106711387634,
-0.27726614475250244,
0.10268016159534454,
0.1741483211517334,
0.33217382431030273,
0.296761155128479,
0.3592207133769989,
0.3363579511642456,
-0.1238274872303009,
-0.37236422300338745,
-0.6116498112678528,
0.9084820747375488,
-0.827244222164154,
-0.2864135503768921,
-0.4113953411579132,
-0.8350902199745178,
0.013403440825641155,
0.39803409576416016,
0.2358628213405609,
1.0397907495498657,
0.06772967427968979,
0.1807728111743927,
0.5379019975662231,
-0.39501065015792847,
0.39909765124320984,
-0.10923607647418976,
-0.34985506534576416,
-0.6455394625663757,
1.0029886960983276,
0.08467704802751541,
0.0431877002120018,
-0.09864965826272964,
0.1517760306596756,
-0.5398885607719421,
-0.4474627673625946,
-0.6919723749160767,
0.3570694923400879,
-0.5915636420249939,
-0.4951145052909851,
-0.22702676057815552,
-0.06158915534615517,
-0.24336014688014984,
0.027636541053652763,
-0.5035144090652466,
-0.30253922939300537,
-0.05450752004981041,
0.1272876113653183,
0.3634043037891388,
1.1519577503204346,
0.03871963545680046,
0.2515195608139038,
-0.7027984261512756,
0.2995712459087372,
0.377309113740921,
0.5673369765281677,
-0.4923468232154846,
-0.026430459693074226,
-0.056142568588256836,
-0.07758500427007675,
-0.5034476518630981,
-0.6395818591117859,
0.41569048166275024,
0.16227832436561584,
0.2569126784801483,
0.15773248672485352,
-0.4677528440952301,
0.6932235360145569,
-0.8199688792228699,
0.7252599596977234,
0.5264443159103394,
-1.0494379997253418,
0.4763634502887726,
-0.8155524730682373,
0.4447805881500244,
-0.022470027208328247,
0.3850839138031006,
-0.48681899905204773,
-0.004910392686724663,
-0.2676948010921478,
-0.6142697334289551,
0.45162972807884216,
0.37052175402641296,
-0.10437418520450592,
0.39062583446502686,
0.41026920080184937,
0.15141038596630096,
0.07643964141607285,
-0.93097984790802,
0.3629467189311981,
-0.7990176677703857,
-0.534447968006134,
0.05665929988026619,
0.09001591056585312,
-0.3301336467266083,
-0.16355815529823303,
0.4403507113456726,
-0.46684500575065613,
0.3476306200027466,
0.13377904891967773,
-0.20993152260780334,
0.09161864966154099,
-0.024606674909591675,
0.664065957069397,
0.8136940598487854,
0.20596842467784882,
0.12917234003543854,
-0.1873619258403778,
-0.5222546458244324,
-0.059889473021030426,
0.3077278435230255,
0.14104923605918884,
-0.2008524388074875,
0.01860387623310089,
0.8162724375724792,
0.09271227568387985,
-0.23951107263565063,
0.7884175181388855,
-0.34142324328422546,
-0.4724760055541992,
-0.29371190071105957,
-0.4378355145454407,
0.008839449845254421,
0.34030187129974365,
0.2850489616394043,
0.08174171298742294,
0.0283832810819149,
-0.1047641709446907,
0.0948638767004013,
0.5346277952194214,
-0.03808225318789482,
-0.6729270219802856,
0.8098284602165222,
0.28130367398262024,
0.10819336771965027,
0.7736563682556152,
-0.04690353944897652,
-0.5890588760375977,
0.17848415672779083,
0.5183539390563965,
0.37219592928886414,
-0.0905068889260292,
0.19944405555725098,
0.518886923789978,
0.3271510899066925,
-0.147013321518898,
0.3758641481399536,
0.2602519094944,
-0.5178785920143127,
-0.8512265682220459,
-0.3700530230998993,
-0.2753174901008606,
0.34522244334220886,
-0.28234192728996277,
0.5062771439552307,
-0.40988147258758545,
0.012064352631568909,
-0.4063745141029358,
-0.28292930126190186,
-0.8979823589324951,
-0.08573105931282043,
0.34519726037979126,
0.3475568890571594,
-0.8822325468063354,
0.6938964128494263,
0.7592735886573792,
-0.3922705054283142,
-0.9979149103164673,
-0.09592080861330032,
0.1262415200471878,
-0.705128014087677,
0.3700691759586334,
0.36844754219055176,
-0.1625726968050003,
0.2369088977575302,
-0.6968056559562683,
-1.061148762702942,
1.1101092100143433,
0.6645575165748596,
-0.4257095456123352,
-0.3249509036540985,
0.312456876039505,
0.15710808336734772,
-0.08871319144964218,
0.07293305546045303,
0.07070515304803848,
0.4962482154369354,
0.3014923334121704,
-0.8666166067123413,
-0.010920874774456024,
-0.08148546516895294,
0.14974667131900787,
0.586709201335907,
-0.3101702630519867,
0.902445375919342,
0.017372824251651764,
-0.1676563024520874,
-0.06958423554897308,
0.5035299062728882,
0.17280638217926025,
-0.015914231538772583,
0.46908947825431824,
1.098677396774292,
0.7432732582092285,
-0.605811357498169,
0.946829080581665,
-0.09532433748245239,
0.6248069405555725,
0.7356162667274475,
-0.04907820746302605,
0.35404765605926514,
0.1812768578529358,
0.2451837658882141,
0.3545081615447998,
0.5609005689620972,
-0.05287265032529831,
0.4890826940536499,
-0.024661028757691383,
-0.2031029462814331,
-0.3859102129936218,
0.15186366438865662,
-0.5296337008476257,
0.6856583952903748,
0.4517837166786194,
0.15858067572116852,
-0.7284228205680847,
0.08230087906122208,
-0.08388187736272812,
-0.0838535726070404,
-0.29608094692230225,
0.35600408911705017,
-0.15472246706485748,
-0.21360285580158234,
0.29853054881095886,
-0.15846258401870728,
0.4578516483306885,
-0.5651662349700928,
-0.3493625521659851,
0.05629317834973335,
-0.012543515302240849,
-0.13279446959495544,
-0.9444828629493713,
0.20747318863868713,
-0.042029548436403275,
-0.06987658888101578,
-0.18476960062980652,
0.49027085304260254,
-0.618305504322052,
-0.6990748047828674,
-0.20457787811756134,
0.6432795524597168,
0.08684048056602478,
-0.19152134656906128,
-0.6947488188743591,
0.16620083153247833,
-0.15733619034290314,
-0.05744900926947594,
-0.010405844077467918,
0.7895579934120178,
-0.20116955041885376,
0.39626702666282654,
1.0429028272628784,
0.05278049781918526,
0.315716952085495,
-0.05651479214429855,
0.954639732837677,
-0.505068838596344,
-0.5234567523002625,
-0.6505826711654663,
0.3752472698688507,
-0.09258290380239487,
-0.3014378845691681,
0.569576621055603,
0.7446109056472778,
0.8170261979103088,
-0.030024684965610504,
0.8753392100334167,
-0.04691752791404724,
0.12484116107225418,
-0.783074676990509,
0.4435444176197052,
-0.5155642628669739,
-0.10038439184427261,
-0.3179793953895569,
-1.0604262351989746,
-0.7405645847320557,
0.6964184641838074,
-0.48379993438720703,
0.01474781148135662,
0.8031502366065979,
0.6241801977157593,
-0.5628131628036499,
-0.03447661176323891,
0.3047008216381073,
0.01247492153197527,
0.8759850263595581,
0.796757698059082,
0.8713328838348389,
-0.3190414607524872,
0.9494104385375977,
0.04025976359844208,
-0.29345425963401794,
0.3269927501678467,
-1.078691840171814,
-0.6976423263549805,
-0.7375004291534424,
0.026013117283582687,
-0.14483004808425903,
-0.2036958783864975,
0.5611129999160767,
0.8402111530303955,
-0.2856418490409851,
0.1841605305671692,
-0.23500503599643707,
-0.19783402979373932,
0.2874251902103424,
-0.16095253825187683,
0.2835392951965332,
-0.3117830157279968,
-1.0347706079483032,
0.2885688245296478,
0.4020768105983734,
0.14389531314373016,
-0.29790666699409485,
0.026826033368706703,
0.061463478952646255,
-0.3067997694015503,
0.5350527763366699,
0.17232820391654968,
-0.4980402886867523,
-0.4194309413433075,
-0.08147788792848587,
0.040652088820934296,
0.29469743371009827,
1.0421086549758911,
-0.6945157051086426,
0.5314223170280457,
0.4421919286251068,
0.8982605934143066,
0.5934293270111084,
0.1426984816789627,
0.767285168170929,
-0.7505468130111694,
0.291858434677124,
0.06294436007738113,
0.651781439781189,
0.6772327423095703,
-0.3278925120830536,
0.3447118103504181,
0.4701171815395355,
-0.7886824607849121,
-0.4111711382865906,
0.5447612404823303,
-0.8061439990997314,
0.007973533123731613,
1.0247445106506348,
-0.07379163056612015,
-0.21599647402763367,
0.15030492842197418,
-0.3389098346233368,
0.12251715362071991,
-0.3690146207809448,
0.34722861647605896,
0.851466178894043,
0.003254760755226016,
-0.30268263816833496,
-1.0150047540664673,
0.33970916271209717,
0.18035651743412018,
-0.9546910524368286,
-0.19549213349819183,
1.2541712522506714,
0.5056990385055542,
-0.03542572632431984,
0.18308834731578827,
-0.32124990224838257,
0.16547991335391998,
-0.349661260843277,
0.15899421274662018,
-0.2909400761127472,
-0.5217140913009644,
-0.4038103520870209,
0.23696087300777435,
-0.25772765278816223,
-0.21059367060661316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11497v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11497v2 | CrAM: Credibility-Aware Attention Modification in LLMs for Combating Misinformation in RAG | 2024-06-17T13:01:12 | 2024-06-27T10:18:53 | Boyi Deng, Wenjie Wang, Fengbin Zhu, Qifan Wang, Fuli Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) can alleviate hallucinations of Large
Language Models (LLMs) by referencing external documents. However, the
misinformation in external documents may mislead LLMs' generation. To address
this issue, we explore the task of "credibility-aware RAG", in which LLMs
automatically adjust the influence of retrieved documents based on their
credibility scores to counteract misinformation. To this end, we introduce a
plug-and-play method named $\textbf{Cr}$edibility-aware $\textbf{A}$ttention
$\textbf{M}$odification (CrAM). CrAM identifies influential attention heads in
LLMs and adjusts their attention weights based on the credibility of the
documents, thereby reducing the impact of low-credibility documents.
Experiments on Natual Questions and TriviaQA using Llama2-13B, Llama3-8B, and
Qwen-7B show that CrAM improves the RAG performance of LLMs against
misinformation pollution by over 20%, even surpassing supervised fine-tuning
methods. | [
-0.27628031373023987,
-0.8806918859481812,
0.43916237354278564,
0.32300397753715515,
-0.2483256757259369,
0.34065911173820496,
-0.3889000415802002,
-0.6165129542350769,
0.34915825724601746,
0.7380800843238831,
-0.2235131561756134,
-0.33148935437202454,
-0.7444897890090942,
-0.05566634237766266,
-0.37750470638275146,
1.0294909477233887,
0.08375592529773712,
-0.01735888421535492,
-0.4338941276073456,
-0.1051897406578064,
-0.5442973971366882,
-0.2906434237957001,
-0.6919307112693787,
-0.20209352672100067,
0.7407325506210327,
0.5569996237754822,
0.6308491230010986,
0.781688392162323,
0.8385006189346313,
0.21452711522579193,
-0.2999879717826843,
0.48064520955085754,
-0.9250935316085815,
0.3149817883968353,
-0.594124972820282,
-0.7745853662490845,
-0.4965859651565552,
-0.003670307109132409,
0.6501927971839905,
0.2218787968158722,
-0.11613504588603973,
0.5798113942146301,
0.2444797158241272,
0.659453809261322,
-0.9000985622406006,
-0.11127898842096329,
-1.0075980424880981,
-0.22797122597694397,
-0.4780735969543457,
-0.7940244078636169,
-0.6370735168457031,
-0.220536008477211,
-0.14032556116580963,
-0.5396948456764221,
0.556800901889801,
0.41750526428222656,
0.9200993180274963,
0.5695217847824097,
-0.19315995275974274,
-0.2852679491043091,
-0.9726937413215637,
0.9128753542900085,
-0.45262736082077026,
0.4798474907875061,
0.5883224606513977,
0.048363037407398224,
-0.1951655149459839,
-0.7141441106796265,
-0.47487425804138184,
-0.06030398979783058,
-0.19312623143196106,
0.28386878967285156,
0.08326700329780579,
-0.011278889141976833,
0.4381544291973114,
0.4210822582244873,
-0.501146137714386,
-0.17011380195617676,
-0.38926056027412415,
-0.4103837013244629,
0.4232226610183716,
-0.1129482090473175,
0.11908319592475891,
0.07230524718761444,
-0.4073183536529541,
-0.03716267645359039,
-0.8785221576690674,
-0.3752205967903137,
0.27003902196884155,
0.06325216591358185,
0.20548872649669647,
0.673279345035553,
-0.10038770735263824,
0.7064478397369385,
0.567943274974823,
-0.5653079748153687,
0.02415371872484684,
-0.15414568781852722,
-0.28131598234176636,
0.2739911675453186,
0.10316114872694016,
0.3626072108745575,
0.1809322088956833,
0.09010147303342819,
-0.1880970448255539,
0.17137078940868378,
0.48168519139289856,
-0.5990532636642456,
-0.02387455850839615,
0.24275462329387665,
-0.32626891136169434,
-0.3568042814731598,
-0.240452378988266,
-0.8721848130226135,
-0.6433640718460083,
-0.3677225112915039,
0.5955237746238708,
-0.3099350333213806,
0.05352186784148216,
-0.049017902463674545,
-0.07782084494829178,
0.09455099701881409,
0.47868022322654724,
-0.36322036385536194,
-0.038472920656204224,
0.5218755602836609,
0.5303054451942444,
-0.246344193816185,
-0.13483640551567078,
-0.8159119486808777,
0.7009841799736023,
-0.28341662883758545,
1.2116098403930664,
-0.6522499918937683,
-0.3084243834018707,
-0.07191306352615356,
-0.1984454244375229,
-0.12765152752399445,
-0.7592238783836365,
0.8974103927612305,
-0.7814500331878662,
0.42974159121513367,
-0.1278645545244217,
-0.4536796808242798,
-0.16432516276836395,
0.5163418054580688,
-0.5015077590942383,
1.0668151378631592,
0.13409028947353363,
-0.957249104976654,
0.09860716760158539,
-0.303320050239563,
-0.38508957624435425,
-0.02122051641345024,
0.18003502488136292,
-0.3950763940811157,
0.17823678255081177,
0.2271454781293869,
-0.06688243895769119,
-0.2539955973625183,
-0.047778841108083725,
0.07495765388011932,
-0.34775057435035706,
0.2117743194103241,
-0.4954640865325928,
0.4919379949569702,
0.08586825430393219,
-0.1831585168838501,
0.03684451803565025,
-0.6450726985931396,
-0.04858461022377014,
-0.02474014088511467,
-0.4822324514389038,
-0.5281875133514404,
-0.16844551265239716,
-0.22473128139972687,
0.010152296163141727,
0.39867326617240906,
-0.27157387137413025,
0.00918483640998602,
-0.5082592368125916,
-0.33388853073120117,
0.6239128708839417,
0.44662004709243774,
0.3980793058872223,
-0.8231634497642517,
0.42355018854141235,
0.20837900042533875,
0.2539080083370209,
-0.18425783514976501,
-0.445928692817688,
-1.0706839561462402,
-0.17820148169994354,
0.5228932499885559,
0.645526111125946,
-0.7899484634399414,
-0.08042553812265396,
-0.10338106751441956,
-0.5102829337120056,
-0.6731752157211304,
0.3559563159942627,
0.5751243829727173,
0.7677907347679138,
0.539500892162323,
-0.19393080472946167,
-0.6412975788116455,
-0.8640775084495544,
-0.9401253461837769,
-0.12327338755130768,
0.0741778239607811,
0.31450095772743225,
0.0038556030485779047,
-0.2625049352645874,
0.8233234882354736,
-0.5004801750183105,
-0.6151638031005859,
-0.06812605261802673,
0.27537834644317627,
-0.18723265826702118,
0.2811734676361084,
0.3426549434661865,
-0.9203134775161743,
-0.723466157913208,
-0.36220893263816833,
-0.22180233895778656,
-0.4305720031261444,
-0.3182084262371063,
-0.11541411280632019,
0.49244531989097595,
0.46036311984062195,
-0.610186755657196,
0.4339149594306946,
0.4999091327190399,
-0.32147666811943054,
0.6388662457466125,
-0.17532166838645935,
0.44359344244003296,
-0.8458554744720459,
-0.11204613000154495,
-0.024552475661039352,
-0.37165117263793945,
-0.5964699983596802,
0.04595604166388512,
0.15704137086868286,
0.367168128490448,
-0.4599286913871765,
0.6741589307785034,
-0.604432225227356,
-0.0035692937672138214,
-0.5696767568588257,
0.5402804613113403,
0.38397443294525146,
0.3555360436439514,
-0.24001890420913696,
0.7825843095779419,
0.35169920325279236,
-0.8102912902832031,
-0.13073575496673584,
0.20204751193523407,
-0.0890062227845192,
0.8756631016731262,
-0.27224278450012207,
0.25637495517730713,
-0.3429068624973297,
0.25017955899238586,
-0.8602434396743774,
-0.34877267479896545,
0.4704849123954773,
-0.673297643661499,
0.563614010810852,
-0.2447730302810669,
-0.4266069531440735,
0.01424847636371851,
-0.2620287835597992,
0.3464365303516388,
0.2747783064842224,
-0.5899624824523926,
0.9857153296470642,
0.4786972105503082,
-0.0683014765381813,
-0.6637709736824036,
-0.7563421130180359,
0.20953644812107086,
-0.25975334644317627,
-0.2897261083126068,
0.5083291530609131,
-0.368941068649292,
-0.5711760520935059,
-0.04893306642770767,
-0.31481245160102844,
-0.0238636527210474,
-0.1414438635110855,
0.11523532122373581,
0.3274420499801636,
0.0404302179813385,
0.19816608726978302,
-0.01997942104935646,
-0.05234026536345482,
-0.0656636655330658,
-0.10594788193702698,
0.42337751388549805,
0.25237002968788147,
-0.3380817174911499,
-0.0491655096411705,
0.09116827696561813,
0.37075281143188477,
-0.42868027091026306,
0.6697172522544861,
0.7035408020019531,
-0.38560065627098083,
-0.39808762073516846,
-1.0860631465911865,
-0.2538694143295288,
-0.48437824845314026,
0.0874701663851738,
-0.05468757823109627,
-0.7886611819267273,
0.27923187613487244,
-0.16182348132133484,
0.10835772752761841,
0.5216438174247742,
0.6012678146362305,
-0.07656049728393555,
0.6270700097084045,
0.49726730585098267,
0.05430835485458374,
0.4741716980934143,
0.14524714648723602,
0.07713701575994492,
-0.8569038510322571,
-0.058109160512685776,
-0.5735398530960083,
-0.3308570981025696,
-0.32117339968681335,
-0.9784455895423889,
0.2308197021484375,
0.07545098662376404,
0.18254674971103668,
0.07896939665079117,
-0.6437877416610718,
0.6227959990501404,
0.5084825754165649,
0.15546773374080658,
0.6765548586845398,
0.02250327542424202,
0.22824892401695251,
-0.24593719840049744,
-0.762765645980835,
-0.3230700194835663,
1.0505752563476562,
0.25749608874320984,
0.857943058013916,
-0.023105375468730927,
0.49141332507133484,
0.502681314945221,
0.7058927416801453,
-0.6070486903190613,
0.5505978465080261,
0.19390970468521118,
-0.7482962012290955,
0.03815683722496033,
-0.4627552032470703,
-0.6412607431411743,
0.06677445769309998,
-0.30504652857780457,
-0.4522188901901245,
0.3145609498023987,
0.4017949104309082,
-0.1905195415019989,
0.213028684258461,
-0.6120465397834778,
0.13144434988498688,
-0.18704913556575775,
-0.5544151067733765,
-0.7249752879142761,
-0.30536672472953796,
0.4191340506076813,
-0.3453289270401001,
0.33196571469306946,
0.06855615973472595,
-0.13378861546516418,
0.6003115773200989,
0.330795019865036,
0.8999202847480774,
-0.11003803461790085,
-0.23606446385383606,
0.5348471403121948,
0.3580089211463928,
0.8660358786582947,
0.11637745052576065,
0.13921505212783813,
0.24577175080776215,
-0.31557992100715637,
-0.073588065803051,
-0.5427681803703308,
0.8451017141342163,
-0.22832685708999634,
-0.854085385799408,
-0.4078901708126068,
-0.8665050268173218,
-0.3741147816181183,
0.26749125123023987,
0.2070455700159073,
0.3148370683193207,
-0.16357287764549255,
0.1922469139099121,
1.2305618524551392,
-0.23255935311317444,
0.1099342480301857,
0.7620064616203308,
-0.2639857530593872,
-0.573600172996521,
0.8387900590896606,
0.3006814122200012,
0.37507161498069763,
0.44923117756843567,
0.18187128007411957,
-0.13410626351833344,
-0.39984506368637085,
-0.11595052480697632,
0.38906553387641907,
-0.7293021082878113,
-0.4817699193954468,
-0.7706046104431152,
-0.3027516305446625,
-0.3770533800125122,
-0.04580559954047203,
-0.30426424741744995,
-0.5651127099990845,
-0.22878192365169525,
0.12123040109872818,
0.4166974723339081,
0.5264629125595093,
-0.07044108957052231,
0.4555768668651581,
-0.6973898410797119,
0.6864437460899353,
0.17711709439754486,
0.4610072076320648,
-0.24620382487773895,
-1.0650568008422852,
-0.5247855186462402,
-0.0003248710709158331,
-0.40339094400405884,
-0.8194290995597839,
0.21999378502368927,
0.21387413144111633,
0.5116429924964905,
0.503571629524231,
0.14694499969482422,
0.6741240620613098,
-0.3458592891693115,
0.532063901424408,
-0.2604573667049408,
-0.7175597548484802,
0.3593733310699463,
-0.29713085293769836,
0.21638554334640503,
0.45831260085105896,
0.08236615359783173,
-0.3707215189933777,
-0.848423957824707,
-0.8639726042747498,
-0.6619279384613037,
0.46964818239212036,
0.19804111123085022,
-0.14420334994792938,
0.07671771943569183,
0.33035317063331604,
-0.2127668857574463,
0.23608359694480896,
-0.4866985082626343,
-0.2917881906032562,
0.036222342401742935,
-0.22877775132656097,
0.01791306585073471,
-0.7478541731834412,
-0.3653474450111389,
0.07595693320035934,
1.019116997718811,
0.006587116047739983,
0.05470435321331024,
0.479886531829834,
-0.32185137271881104,
-0.3423510789871216,
0.17613407969474792,
0.7938942909240723,
0.5944507122039795,
-0.07634370028972626,
0.13182668387889862,
0.34411388635635376,
-0.7146701812744141,
-0.1789429485797882,
-0.17217719554901123,
-0.3964385688304901,
0.24439851939678192,
0.15884345769882202,
0.3598220646381378,
0.22914689779281616,
-0.5073404312133789,
0.1187949925661087,
0.021183021366596222,
-0.13146516680717468,
-0.287609726190567,
0.2486528754234314,
0.13759133219718933,
0.3394811749458313,
0.31592193245887756,
0.26949837803840637,
0.006677165627479553,
-0.2986171543598175,
0.21170763671398163,
0.35506123304367065,
-0.23459748923778534,
0.021390151232481003,
0.5768120288848877,
0.05914485454559326,
-0.5579453110694885,
-0.04851335659623146,
-0.004649295937269926,
-0.4989122152328491,
0.4051967263221741,
0.7209199070930481,
0.7674660086631775,
-0.5965269207954407,
0.0288168266415596,
0.5291765928268433,
0.6763095855712891,
-0.2658558189868927,
0.09904202073812485,
0.22293810546398163,
-0.7174507975578308,
-0.48674529790878296,
-0.4807595908641815,
-0.6083729267120361,
0.13868644833564758,
-0.44911742210388184,
0.21866600215435028,
-0.3829428553581238,
-0.3098835051059723,
-0.43196412920951843,
-0.07013498991727829,
-0.4275991916656494,
0.3830808699131012,
0.036915820091962814,
0.9801386594772339,
-0.4165250062942505,
0.5605508685112,
0.6243810653686523,
-0.0755201056599617,
-0.47574251890182495,
0.6262035965919495,
-0.042427342385053635,
-0.5458760857582092,
0.24384132027626038,
-0.011815035715699196,
-0.3677813708782196,
0.27316728234291077,
-0.6640849113464355,
-1.1405320167541504,
0.8928362131118774,
0.294668972492218,
-0.6038309931755066,
0.26112455129623413,
0.12678313255310059,
0.43657171726226807,
-0.3848707377910614,
0.09854035079479218,
0.43340250849723816,
0.8166623711585999,
-0.0006183668738231063,
-0.665155827999115,
-0.2216469645500183,
0.11236109584569931,
-0.20088663697242737,
-0.0171895083039999,
-0.906472384929657,
0.5045937299728394,
-0.2637341022491455,
-0.38707154989242554,
-0.2941601872444153,
0.7625498175621033,
0.500856339931488,
0.4920683205127716,
0.7206713557243347,
0.6078181266784668,
0.9815099239349365,
0.04725728929042816,
0.757579505443573,
-0.6992186903953552,
0.15976473689079285,
1.6072839498519897,
-0.2580457925796509,
0.6500229835510254,
0.6346673965454102,
0.31272387504577637,
0.4842263460159302,
0.28718024492263794,
0.026377975940704346,
0.2858181595802307,
0.015353585593402386,
-0.25273528695106506,
-0.23840437829494476,
-0.3769279420375824,
-0.2099566012620926,
0.431397944688797,
0.6489322185516357,
-0.37275877594947815,
-0.18030059337615967,
0.05855585262179375,
0.09208963811397552,
0.33315905928611755,
-0.46446844935417175,
0.7338060736656189,
0.09427175670862198,
-0.7778404951095581,
0.5948308706283569,
0.04021229222416878,
0.4633442163467407,
-0.4928235113620758,
-0.22516389191150665,
-0.2602316439151764,
0.4092298150062561,
-0.2901362478733063,
-0.6352929472923279,
0.366070955991745,
0.04261532425880432,
-0.5383455753326416,
-0.14777402579784393,
1.295230507850647,
-0.7464510798454285,
-0.42023274302482605,
0.220742329955101,
0.5635451674461365,
-0.02846989780664444,
-0.23156461119651794,
-0.6552735567092896,
0.15306389331817627,
0.12347625941038132,
-0.38414859771728516,
0.34512248635292053,
0.4874360263347626,
-0.0012871234212070704,
0.8400288820266724,
0.6795552372932434,
0.2764292359352112,
-0.14055167138576508,
0.06534069776535034,
0.9047726392745972,
-0.48585209250450134,
-0.3453715741634369,
-0.5760760307312012,
0.35499152541160583,
-0.15835526585578918,
-0.031371600925922394,
1.1115705966949463,
0.6212601661682129,
0.8404693007469177,
-0.05974774807691574,
0.6778223514556885,
0.08094079792499542,
1.1399976015090942,
-0.2794862985610962,
0.8347166776657104,
-0.49843353033065796,
0.3094046413898468,
-0.13334597647190094,
-1.0343616008758545,
-0.2652553617954254,
0.2875649333000183,
-0.168002188205719,
-0.08062296360731125,
0.7190703749656677,
1.2723726034164429,
-0.03238331899046898,
-0.2641402781009674,
0.25531917810440063,
0.6132868528366089,
0.014358618296682835,
0.07858746498823166,
0.6230183839797974,
-0.30422672629356384,
0.7719135284423828,
-0.1947639435529709,
-0.2521038353443146,
-0.3164592683315277,
-0.8657289743423462,
-0.9321385622024536,
-0.2152337282896042,
-0.3753935694694519,
-0.6730846166610718,
0.23332670331001282,
0.5748773217201233,
0.2505526840686798,
-0.6451030969619751,
0.20043638348579407,
0.31609129905700684,
0.3338209390640259,
-0.21308301389217377,
-0.2970716059207916,
0.23574227094650269,
-0.4700544476509094,
-0.7209927439689636,
0.5278249979019165,
0.29147130250930786,
0.01413674931973219,
-0.3853151202201843,
0.10511389374732971,
-0.3003997206687927,
0.6899240612983704,
0.4668850600719452,
0.09736032783985138,
-0.465730220079422,
-0.356795072555542,
-0.08872948586940765,
-0.3012761175632477,
0.2021370679140091,
0.7244343161582947,
-0.8963945508003235,
0.3917000889778137,
0.4290561079978943,
0.510231077671051,
0.2600216865539551,
0.5361901521682739,
0.3160119950771332,
-0.7892494797706604,
0.1015043705701828,
0.29895496368408203,
0.10448365658521652,
0.4379589259624481,
-0.8240637183189392,
0.48976656794548035,
0.3917287290096283,
-0.7843151092529297,
-0.9351221323013306,
0.17351898550987244,
-0.931698203086853,
-0.08055966347455978,
1.4137846231460571,
0.20743048191070557,
-0.3781302273273468,
-0.3557010889053345,
-0.5081048011779785,
0.22035738825798035,
-0.22801853716373444,
1.2020841836929321,
0.5559265613555908,
0.3250601887702942,
-0.12640759348869324,
-0.5943265557289124,
0.6833453178405762,
0.491654634475708,
-0.7320391535758972,
0.27751240134239197,
0.4473474323749542,
0.2880011796951294,
0.40095266699790955,
0.5668348073959351,
-0.13988946378231049,
0.24126775562763214,
-0.15670105814933777,
0.12449134886264801,
-0.10328274965286255,
-0.6222657561302185,
0.015433116815984249,
0.021077960729599,
-0.005671250633895397,
0.1265721172094345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11486v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11486v1 | Analysing zero-shot temporal relation extraction on clinical notes using temporal consistency | 2024-06-17T12:53:21 | 2024-06-17T12:53:21 | Vasiliki Kougia, Anastasiia Sedova, Andreas Stephan, Klim Zaporojets, Benjamin Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper presents the first study for temporal relation extraction in a
zero-shot setting focusing on biomedical text. We employ two types of prompts
and five LLMs (GPT-3.5, Mixtral, Llama 2, Gemma, and PMC-LLaMA) to obtain
responses about the temporal relations between two events. Our experiments
demonstrate that LLMs struggle in the zero-shot setting performing worse than
fine-tuned specialized models in terms of F1 score, showing that this is a
challenging task for LLMs. We further contribute a novel comprehensive temporal
analysis by calculating consistency scores for each LLM. Our findings reveal
that LLMs face challenges in providing responses consistent to the temporal
properties of uniqueness and transitivity. Moreover, we study the relation
between the temporal consistency of an LLM and its accuracy and whether the
latter can be improved by solving temporal inconsistencies. Our analysis shows
that even when temporal consistency is achieved, the predictions can remain
inaccurate. | [
0.30555570125579834,
-1.0359715223312378,
1.3408092260360718,
0.5003386735916138,
-0.4200734794139862,
-0.002885705791413784,
0.11020011454820633,
-0.8284430503845215,
0.36508071422576904,
0.16066700220108032,
-0.7158547043800354,
-0.5465667247772217,
-0.7093682885169983,
0.3090467154979706,
-0.17982091009616852,
1.1004301309585571,
-0.18134382367134094,
0.12225743383169174,
-0.1537899523973465,
-0.5131884217262268,
-0.5178556442260742,
-0.47287365794181824,
-0.4946051836013794,
-0.5871620774269104,
0.9077789187431335,
0.1321483850479126,
0.3602563142776489,
0.9348823428153992,
0.8123925924301147,
0.10937720537185669,
-0.26661598682403564,
-0.17589324712753296,
-0.1567436009645462,
0.35756179690361023,
-0.15093748271465302,
-0.2281590700149536,
-0.8745346069335938,
0.03817605599761009,
0.5885787010192871,
0.8974422812461853,
-0.039412688463926315,
0.2218480408191681,
-0.27579545974731445,
0.16736683249473572,
-0.4426800608634949,
0.26004695892333984,
-0.6033627986907959,
0.3664058744907379,
-0.3368566334247589,
-0.8360484838485718,
-0.38410863280296326,
-0.15731346607208252,
0.029975643381476402,
-0.6605162620544434,
0.41792234778404236,
-0.32850876450538635,
1.225616216659546,
0.12286718189716339,
-0.4966973662376404,
-0.16527122259140015,
-0.8132191300392151,
0.5687118172645569,
-0.6899815201759338,
-0.012196634896099567,
0.08763817697763443,
0.19071634113788605,
-0.1335522085428238,
-0.6093965768814087,
-0.5290540456771851,
-0.34884122014045715,
-0.16023485362529755,
0.36084386706352234,
0.17368242144584656,
-0.07179237902164459,
0.36667752265930176,
0.1803954541683197,
-0.6076843738555908,
0.12624815106391907,
-0.09995261579751968,
-0.09702659398317337,
0.2528855800628662,
0.7528389096260071,
0.2416500747203827,
-0.13483332097530365,
-0.3572784662246704,
0.507260799407959,
-0.6869405508041382,
-0.1001112163066864,
-0.13448908925056458,
0.13612233102321625,
-0.17106769979000092,
0.7057940363883972,
0.03428277373313904,
0.5272645950317383,
0.18858781456947327,
-0.47179847955703735,
0.008938298560678959,
-0.4406086206436157,
-0.22013647854328156,
0.07152257114648819,
1.0568554401397705,
0.41076695919036865,
0.3118651807308197,
-0.38249459862709045,
0.3649633824825287,
0.13896554708480835,
0.03892684355378151,
-0.7321690320968628,
0.21813979744911194,
0.4551239311695099,
-0.4057202935218811,
-0.4577281177043915,
-0.25238990783691406,
-0.5253893733024597,
-0.05515572801232338,
-0.25224071741104126,
0.381938099861145,
-0.5475861430168152,
0.18108654022216797,
0.029462989419698715,
-0.10450324416160583,
0.2889699637889862,
0.627422571182251,
-0.7854270339012146,
0.07211435586214066,
0.6263230443000793,
0.9769195914268494,
-0.1449154168367386,
-0.13711482286453247,
-0.5644612312316895,
0.5466945767402649,
-0.33501380681991577,
0.9537537097930908,
-0.3153921961784363,
-0.6730856895446777,
-0.21136222779750824,
0.24434424936771393,
-0.1684240698814392,
-0.38485652208328247,
0.46610644459724426,
-0.12113139033317566,
0.25590577721595764,
-0.12247680872678757,
-0.6588917374610901,
0.42094913125038147,
0.2826097011566162,
-0.3476371467113495,
0.7372311353683472,
0.08397337049245834,
-0.4951447546482086,
0.4782882630825043,
-0.22669506072998047,
-0.42451655864715576,
0.05419449135661125,
-0.61388099193573,
-0.469006210565567,
-0.020761970430612564,
0.1032027155160904,
0.4589347541332245,
0.10916628688573837,
0.4141905903816223,
-0.5626378059387207,
-0.31266409158706665,
0.4215538203716278,
-0.21213871240615845,
0.7326321601867676,
-0.013966127298772335,
-0.11557755619287491,
-0.22321364283561707,
-0.766660213470459,
-0.08017725497484207,
0.31324997544288635,
-0.12446889281272888,
0.01646689511835575,
-0.10056937485933304,
-0.2380463182926178,
0.2823649048805237,
0.4103865325450897,
-1.0758358240127563,
0.4812086224555969,
-0.051570065319538116,
0.28014490008354187,
0.7159590721130371,
0.6449393033981323,
0.18712787330150604,
-0.5460917353630066,
0.3847634792327881,
0.3870990574359894,
0.18977071344852448,
-0.5533758997917175,
-0.34416964650154114,
-0.3365561068058014,
-0.020772479474544525,
0.10116317123174667,
0.5977033376693726,
-0.24092353880405426,
0.1001058891415596,
-0.43340685963630676,
-0.357166588306427,
-0.40339723229408264,
-0.1676766574382782,
0.5040697455406189,
1.0232356786727905,
0.47333773970603943,
-0.3131466507911682,
-0.414216011762619,
-0.5734501481056213,
-0.24192990362644196,
-0.4168560802936554,
-0.13106216490268707,
0.3728712499141693,
0.37179702520370483,
-0.07170691341161728,
0.8950559496879578,
-0.6137112379074097,
-0.3856160044670105,
0.19413550198078156,
0.3599664270877838,
0.3979969322681427,
0.3284780979156494,
0.6488161683082581,
-0.01885041780769825,
-0.47773808240890503,
0.011041095480322838,
-1.2360504865646362,
-0.3132130205631256,
-0.36736753582954407,
0.20445023477077484,
0.24555745720863342,
0.4509771466255188,
-0.5614856481552124,
0.5509309768676758,
0.09320266544818878,
-0.3452247083187103,
0.6265096068382263,
-0.10640739649534225,
0.210549458861351,
-0.7152668833732605,
0.30556145310401917,
0.0051324074156582355,
-0.3709741532802582,
-0.6109593510627747,
-0.41970235109329224,
0.011707293801009655,
0.07363569736480713,
-0.49008989334106445,
1.0072273015975952,
-0.26696112751960754,
0.2287147343158722,
0.022704632952809334,
0.2919274866580963,
0.09631425887346268,
0.4433472156524658,
0.21279507875442505,
0.3162755072116852,
0.08112800121307373,
-0.31497451663017273,
-0.12116371840238571,
0.45434704422950745,
0.32533666491508484,
0.7767243385314941,
-0.9375945925712585,
0.28719139099121094,
-0.27857375144958496,
0.08420102298259735,
-0.8511949777603149,
-0.06443731486797333,
0.3839612305164337,
-0.6755337119102478,
0.5845118761062622,
-0.2736855745315552,
-0.4331851601600647,
0.10781651735305786,
-0.26111334562301636,
0.24867144227027893,
0.4330500066280365,
0.06533506512641907,
0.15050478279590607,
-0.006743420381098986,
-0.46509990096092224,
-0.6198362112045288,
-0.6467745304107666,
0.009580628015100956,
0.07838407903909683,
-0.33311930298805237,
0.6055271029472351,
-0.2098766565322876,
-0.25748273730278015,
0.13314911723136902,
-0.49681565165519714,
-0.11753861606121063,
-0.15967734158039093,
0.3911633789539337,
0.48147425055503845,
-0.28040674328804016,
-0.060145340859889984,
0.03094032034277916,
-0.14974427223205566,
-0.014431574381887913,
0.306177020072937,
0.03858444467186928,
0.300220787525177,
-0.3340725004673004,
-0.7112222909927368,
0.3992844820022583,
0.5079420208930969,
0.4360277056694031,
0.6599072217941284,
0.4277924597263336,
-0.43503808975219727,
0.4180448651313782,
-0.47784990072250366,
0.005361374467611313,
-0.3112803101539612,
-0.12463383376598358,
-0.3067518174648285,
-0.7612427473068237,
0.7020242810249329,
0.30681002140045166,
0.09235828369855881,
0.5352860689163208,
0.5677186250686646,
-0.5977975130081177,
0.6953023672103882,
0.623824417591095,
0.05292120575904846,
0.5222753286361694,
0.09257473051548004,
-0.22614741325378418,
-0.8337495923042297,
-0.531856119632721,
-0.40787988901138306,
-0.011575764045119286,
-0.3168156147003174,
0.0759943276643753,
0.5421344637870789,
0.24048297107219696,
-0.2350117415189743,
0.08552226424217224,
-0.2981884181499481,
0.19710023701190948,
-0.15985967218875885,
0.32739636301994324,
0.4657513499259949,
-0.2223610281944275,
-0.2506035268306732,
-0.30746227502822876,
-0.4439249336719513,
-0.5579797029495239,
1.0601086616516113,
0.2851511240005493,
0.3433336317539215,
0.10182688385248184,
0.5860098600387573,
0.049245916306972504,
0.49865108728408813,
-0.6211753487586975,
0.46745800971984863,
-0.019747549667954445,
-0.6027312874794006,
-0.18179839849472046,
-0.2979937493801117,
-1.0959981679916382,
-0.08280502259731293,
-0.14628154039382935,
-0.9914640188217163,
-0.017710644751787186,
-0.15595252811908722,
-0.6273146867752075,
-0.0635153204202652,
-0.18999646604061127,
0.7268944382667542,
-0.2094404101371765,
-0.6014807820320129,
0.46033185720443726,
-1.0897010564804077,
0.16470980644226074,
0.10725758969783783,
-0.14016449451446533,
-0.6576865315437317,
-0.1893301010131836,
0.6015787720680237,
-0.4191879332065582,
0.7997852563858032,
-0.024809544906020164,
0.10424970835447311,
0.043080538511276245,
0.2945735454559326,
0.03466898202896118,
0.3307221829891205,
0.11874590069055557,
0.3623899519443512,
0.6543486714363098,
-0.6237056851387024,
-0.7343226671218872,
0.515564501285553,
-0.68022221326828,
-0.29182109236717224,
-0.8553189635276794,
-0.6354556679725647,
-0.20322470366954803,
0.20404687523841858,
0.271075576543808,
0.6015406250953674,
-0.3986949622631073,
-0.298103004693985,
0.4941471815109253,
-0.14263111352920532,
0.7811869382858276,
1.1847106218338013,
0.09826021641492844,
-0.34848180413246155,
0.2649118900299072,
0.16306068003177643,
0.14857707917690277,
0.786765456199646,
0.05528643727302551,
-0.23917004466056824,
-0.5360700488090515,
-0.1933765709400177,
0.6506303548812866,
-0.4184967279434204,
-0.11499875783920288,
-0.6917272806167603,
-0.3965093493461609,
-0.6805586814880371,
-0.04902612417936325,
-0.09956622868776321,
-0.6368221044540405,
-0.5750675797462463,
-0.05907433480024338,
0.23685142397880554,
0.5988656282424927,
-0.09619360417127609,
0.24967060983181,
-1.2327872514724731,
0.3382250964641571,
-0.20434637367725372,
0.10008949041366577,
-0.35883545875549316,
-0.5772111415863037,
0.07895755022764206,
-0.4261015057563782,
-0.48764556646347046,
-1.1190327405929565,
0.34029093384742737,
0.15062209963798523,
0.6062226891517639,
0.4593101143836975,
-0.35215044021606445,
1.082432508468628,
-0.7463902831077576,
0.804401695728302,
0.1427297741174698,
-0.661768913269043,
0.7038347721099854,
-0.6897963285446167,
0.33010175824165344,
0.44958263635635376,
0.4569717347621918,
-0.6619771718978882,
-0.44164443016052246,
-1.0775221586227417,
-0.5645647048950195,
0.48451611399650574,
0.18781979382038116,
-0.38919833302497864,
-0.3040764033794403,
1.0805864334106445,
0.13020536303520203,
0.12919524312019348,
-0.6006531119346619,
-0.4317181408405304,
0.2979333996772766,
-0.17734909057617188,
-0.13979606330394745,
-0.5854805111885071,
-0.22903601825237274,
-0.07079236209392548,
0.0780329704284668,
0.028912363573908806,
0.5118096470832825,
0.6511473059654236,
0.01644142158329487,
-0.37003517150878906,
0.38389939069747925,
0.8930115699768066,
0.8366674780845642,
-0.6763859391212463,
-0.00654405914247036,
-0.0013444041833281517,
-0.540400505065918,
0.34596768021583557,
0.011350275948643684,
-0.1533474326133728,
0.47390154004096985,
1.0453364849090576,
0.3026432991027832,
0.25014257431030273,
-0.34795835614204407,
0.5084846615791321,
-0.02036982960999012,
-0.05926059931516647,
-0.4603565037250519,
-0.12255819141864777,
-0.1621822565793991,
0.04839986190199852,
0.1698201447725296,
-0.25743213295936584,
-0.16936269402503967,
-0.6766988039016724,
0.3937680721282959,
0.3215847313404083,
-0.6298043727874756,
-0.5617470145225525,
0.9389020800590515,
-0.2508566081523895,
-0.19114726781845093,
0.4849259853363037,
-0.06037811189889908,
0.022289060056209564,
0.7201061844825745,
0.541606605052948,
0.8209717869758606,
-0.17421652376651764,
0.15706270933151245,
0.4260934889316559,
0.018466351553797722,
0.1638343632221222,
0.3023270070552826,
-0.05973616987466812,
-0.5239295959472656,
-0.6039283871650696,
-0.5482572317123413,
-0.7101300954818726,
0.1582382321357727,
-0.909578263759613,
0.2066967636346817,
-0.5648685693740845,
-0.38834047317504883,
0.30781108140945435,
0.30660027265548706,
-0.46493101119995117,
0.05608708783984184,
-0.2850916087627411,
0.6756179928779602,
-0.6562157869338989,
0.9091714024543762,
0.40681973099708557,
-0.6755784153938293,
-0.6295995116233826,
-0.25931623578071594,
0.3144640624523163,
-0.7825509309768677,
0.5641652345657349,
-0.22390298545360565,
0.17582003772258759,
-0.3861604332923889,
-0.32391980290412903,
-0.25166478753089905,
1.37649667263031,
0.4251030385494232,
-0.6790482997894287,
-0.2517877519130707,
0.20779867470264435,
0.8948439359664917,
-0.12374704331159592,
0.5363858938217163,
0.5207741856575012,
0.14661698043346405,
0.3696998953819275,
-0.9940275549888611,
0.06641202419996262,
-0.16878460347652435,
-0.41887974739074707,
0.20747330784797668,
-0.5120553970336914,
0.8106228113174438,
-0.35795262455940247,
-0.4471242427825928,
0.44736140966415405,
0.3130369782447815,
0.5590689778327942,
0.8839479088783264,
-0.22001057863235474,
0.5418356657028198,
0.5760924816131592,
-0.18234920501708984,
0.995039165019989,
-0.31584012508392334,
0.34509244561195374,
1.3653564453125,
-0.6640372276306152,
0.609838604927063,
0.7410029172897339,
-0.28195422887802124,
0.4599034786224365,
0.6099454164505005,
0.13569390773773193,
0.3035672605037689,
-0.28655946254730225,
-0.5074631571769714,
0.0675838440656662,
-0.20691543817520142,
-0.47204479575157166,
0.045886628329753876,
0.22738967835903168,
-0.3470762073993683,
-0.35554611682891846,
-0.5066576600074768,
0.5372750759124756,
-0.27049699425697327,
-0.07360747456550598,
0.8876304030418396,
0.3875337243080139,
-0.465081125497818,
0.12199175357818604,
-0.2006688416004181,
0.02876085601747036,
-0.7201205492019653,
-0.11986115574836731,
-0.494231253862381,
0.15633437037467957,
-0.13145744800567627,
-0.8241219520568848,
0.4340546429157257,
0.009982088580727577,
-0.3466859757900238,
-0.1215427964925766,
0.46054115891456604,
-0.4444217383861542,
-0.3271281123161316,
0.18859966099262238,
0.7341042160987854,
0.15355651080608368,
0.31700706481933594,
-0.5342352986335754,
-0.007295289076864719,
-0.3390580415725708,
0.021186240017414093,
0.4871905446052551,
0.8210494518280029,
0.09283283352851868,
0.3587065041065216,
0.4958678185939789,
0.6082634925842285,
-0.10013116896152496,
0.008478640578687191,
0.2970835566520691,
-1.0747383832931519,
-0.05504285916686058,
-1.2387131452560425,
0.26800304651260376,
-0.07289768755435944,
-0.4789196252822876,
0.6009556651115417,
0.35826554894447327,
0.3225022554397583,
0.07339277118444443,
0.37013399600982666,
0.25271743535995483,
0.6769754886627197,
-0.601822018623352,
0.43236440420150757,
-0.38348841667175293,
0.30579710006713867,
-0.32544848322868347,
-0.5061774253845215,
-0.6529624462127686,
0.04516499862074852,
-0.09965953975915909,
-0.2557336986064911,
1.1173125505447388,
0.48518580198287964,
0.24425454437732697,
-0.2006024718284607,
0.31006258726119995,
0.22867903113365173,
0.525050699710846,
0.9309849143028259,
0.7684863805770874,
-0.44637933373451233,
0.4530540108680725,
-0.27418965101242065,
-0.08751951158046722,
-0.008912060409784317,
-1.278924584388733,
-0.8011894226074219,
-0.1822485774755478,
-0.6127839088439941,
-0.4376659095287323,
0.32328498363494873,
0.5133334994316101,
0.33156877756118774,
-0.6141172647476196,
0.04721975326538086,
0.22789813578128815,
-0.012844244949519634,
-0.30371707677841187,
-0.25409168004989624,
0.39065757393836975,
-0.26334792375564575,
-0.4404039680957794,
0.2518429160118103,
0.8044673800468445,
0.34741321206092834,
0.16283026337623596,
0.25549978017807007,
-0.06884443759918213,
0.012494410388171673,
0.49496161937713623,
0.6413469314575195,
-0.4774326682090759,
-0.4471927583217621,
0.28827783465385437,
-0.41636762022972107,
0.40210917592048645,
1.008346676826477,
-0.7315208315849304,
0.37284237146377563,
0.24872758984565735,
0.18960320949554443,
0.7388700246810913,
-0.004958304576575756,
0.2810322940349579,
-0.8846296072006226,
0.12005528062582016,
0.4087073504924774,
0.3234430253505707,
0.0951559916138649,
-0.4324930012226105,
0.734415590763092,
0.7190261483192444,
-0.7910512685775757,
-0.751190185546875,
0.07952053099870682,
-1.6707391738891602,
-0.15395662188529968,
1.075273036956787,
-0.25477173924446106,
-0.2730417847633362,
-0.22468046844005585,
0.08718925714492798,
0.4392969012260437,
-0.12453784048557281,
0.7917896509170532,
0.6891003847122192,
-0.7943021059036255,
-0.09104448556900024,
-0.6709899306297302,
0.20982250571250916,
0.2617362141609192,
-0.5603986978530884,
-0.4141802489757538,
0.35023894906044006,
0.6640206575393677,
0.22231541574001312,
1.3299157619476318,
-0.6410237550735474,
0.28506922721862793,
0.06878627091646194,
-0.34926310181617737,
-0.16520801186561584,
-0.2776651680469513,
-0.5729147791862488,
0.1275806725025177,
-0.20135816931724548,
-0.21760524809360504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11477v1 | Vocabulary Expansion for Low-resource Cross-lingual Transfer | 2024-06-17T12:42:34 | 2024-06-17T12:42:34 | Atsuki Yamaguchi, Aline Villavicencio, Nikolaos Aletras | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in many
languages beyond English. Yet, LLMs require more inference steps when
generating non-English text due to their reliance on English-centric
tokenizers, vocabulary, and pre-training data, resulting in higher usage costs
to non-English speakers. Vocabulary expansion with target language tokens is a
widely used cross-lingual vocabulary adaptation approach to remedy this issue.
Despite its effectiveness in inference speedup, the majority of previous work
has focused on high-resource settings assuming access to a substantial amount
of target language data to effectively initialize the embeddings of the new
tokens and adapt the LLM to the target language. However, vocabulary expansion
for LLMs in low-resource settings (i.e. languages and compute) has yet to be
explored. In this paper, we investigate sample-efficient adaptation strategies
from different angles, including target vocabulary size and initialization
methods, and the amount of target data available for adaptation. Extensive
experiments across typologically diverse languages, tasks and models show that
simpler heuristic-based embedding initialization is more efficient and robust
to changes in target vocabulary size and adaptation data in low-resource
settings, outperforming a popular random initialization and a more
sophisticated state-of-the-art approach that relies on external data and model. | [
-0.2031073123216629,
-0.5517479777336121,
0.18530726432800293,
0.24847272038459778,
-0.2926141917705536,
0.3005235195159912,
-0.7209799289703369,
-0.5221425890922546,
0.1408533751964569,
0.14745348691940308,
-0.20727510750293732,
-0.2633167803287506,
-0.7200279235839844,
0.09404376149177551,
-0.05732007697224617,
0.7974808216094971,
-0.06621941179037094,
0.017216984182596207,
-0.08646363765001297,
-0.10486982762813568,
-0.5749502778053284,
-0.45403358340263367,
-0.7394896149635315,
-0.10130709409713745,
0.5149396061897278,
0.5848129987716675,
0.5920786261558533,
0.6010767817497253,
0.4128369987010956,
0.2812749147415161,
-0.0542326383292675,
0.2937154769897461,
-0.7974441647529602,
-0.28072312474250793,
-0.5379846096038818,
-0.5129833221435547,
-0.1561393141746521,
-0.2724812626838684,
0.7522450685501099,
0.9293402433395386,
-0.0076841567642986774,
0.2752641439437866,
0.1942218542098999,
0.33875903487205505,
-0.9018514752388,
0.16282950341701508,
-0.849924623966217,
0.13811829686164856,
-0.24679964780807495,
-0.27232420444488525,
-0.49792715907096863,
0.216227188706398,
0.3485143184661865,
-0.8901126384735107,
-0.01606445387005806,
0.3281058371067047,
0.5740520358085632,
-0.04713745042681694,
-0.14427560567855835,
-0.2479180097579956,
-0.6032494306564331,
1.1289408206939697,
-0.4224245250225067,
0.5916549563407898,
0.2350226640701294,
0.021938741207122803,
-0.08059319108724594,
-0.5369607210159302,
-0.15279529988765717,
-0.17849266529083252,
0.0053952597081661224,
-0.05438236519694328,
-0.27256226539611816,
-0.15590369701385498,
0.150278240442276,
0.024483395740389824,
-0.11815182864665985,
0.6614247560501099,
-0.5403144955635071,
-0.2161492109298706,
0.4105195999145508,
-0.13807350397109985,
0.21857114136219025,
-0.25933054089546204,
-0.5398175120353699,
-0.22690510749816895,
-0.5531483292579651,
-0.09794073551893234,
0.18002815544605255,
0.9036503434181213,
-0.631872832775116,
0.6099657416343689,
0.006613634526729584,
0.6408692598342896,
0.10609708726406097,
-0.14993369579315186,
0.20258399844169617,
-0.7412773370742798,
-0.03018251247704029,
0.11447973549365997,
0.4983533024787903,
0.21003544330596924,
0.31078141927719116,
-0.31253018975257874,
-0.07177435606718063,
-0.3088759779930115,
0.07358861714601517,
-0.7853309512138367,
0.09276145696640015,
0.01698671653866768,
-0.4104931950569153,
0.07455930858850479,
-0.4608643054962158,
-0.7232480049133301,
-0.4970107078552246,
-0.04588698595762253,
0.44739049673080444,
-0.6046522259712219,
-0.08341994136571884,
0.009090729057788849,
-0.022603288292884827,
0.2953680753707886,
0.3444514274597168,
-0.956787645816803,
0.2950834333896637,
0.6232125759124756,
1.104791522026062,
-0.6994904279708862,
-0.2468690574169159,
-0.8464319705963135,
0.12899623811244965,
-0.5862863659858704,
0.5931634306907654,
-0.4490683078765869,
-0.47615566849708557,
0.0782957375049591,
0.11892550438642502,
-0.2557606101036072,
-0.35222434997558594,
0.2902514636516571,
-0.6094917058944702,
0.24740292131900787,
-0.33713623881340027,
-0.3343179225921631,
0.01434136088937521,
0.1433030068874359,
-0.6759887933731079,
0.9555097818374634,
0.30804383754730225,
-0.5997002124786377,
0.5211233496665955,
-0.8490610718727112,
-0.5756016969680786,
0.03353400528430939,
0.024908877909183502,
0.17515039443969727,
0.39743030071258545,
0.2971702516078949,
0.48911452293395996,
-0.5746012330055237,
-0.31231242418289185,
-0.09442006051540375,
-0.46812644600868225,
0.10793250054121017,
-0.4274630546569824,
0.6641255617141724,
0.20667597651481628,
-0.06546824425458908,
-0.20148572325706482,
-0.36602291464805603,
-0.06159066781401634,
0.08972876518964767,
-0.5174073576927185,
-0.7287042737007141,
-0.22439482808113098,
0.055769991129636765,
0.011977897956967354,
0.397011935710907,
-0.5154028534889221,
0.14365532994270325,
-0.4530194401741028,
0.17161408066749573,
0.7234341502189636,
-0.16390849649906158,
0.9881711006164551,
-0.40177249908447266,
0.616097629070282,
0.2911331355571747,
-0.23042455315589905,
-0.08595675975084305,
-0.24171316623687744,
-0.5601063370704651,
-0.46066993474960327,
0.7469033598899841,
0.5904149413108826,
-1.046600341796875,
0.01843038573861122,
-0.7259938716888428,
-0.3730340898036957,
-0.5228550434112549,
0.47847694158554077,
0.3490903973579407,
0.3237619400024414,
0.41010257601737976,
-0.41591134667396545,
-0.3976183235645294,
-0.7325044274330139,
-0.24081575870513916,
-0.10020118951797485,
-0.02693866565823555,
0.4694257974624634,
0.2611002027988434,
0.21255560219287872,
0.5608825087547302,
-0.2735307216644287,
-0.07854921370744705,
-0.6052742004394531,
-0.1368914544582367,
0.1331632137298584,
0.41797587275505066,
0.6730902194976807,
-0.424867182970047,
-0.7066414952278137,
0.23422572016716003,
-0.33135977387428284,
-0.03717156872153282,
-0.43778425455093384,
-0.43197205662727356,
0.2946869730949402,
0.4692109227180481,
-0.30828216671943665,
0.02926686406135559,
0.923645555973053,
-0.1786148101091385,
0.13965082168579102,
-0.3409401774406433,
0.000010397516234661452,
-1.4024474620819092,
-0.1826964169740677,
-0.0258242879062891,
-0.07961572706699371,
-0.6825434565544128,
-0.02316022664308548,
-0.05704883858561516,
0.053326565772295,
-0.681864857673645,
1.046721339225769,
-0.8761803507804871,
-0.3942769467830658,
-0.10932134091854095,
0.27580875158309937,
-0.15994606912136078,
0.42505955696105957,
0.12243323773145676,
0.8745143413543701,
0.5663238763809204,
-0.5125945806503296,
-0.0005285739898681641,
0.13594499230384827,
-0.20661607384681702,
0.4284665584564209,
-0.1757858246564865,
-0.02165631204843521,
-0.0034320782870054245,
0.0002429834712529555,
-0.7975162267684937,
0.12209244072437286,
0.20982618629932404,
-0.043720923364162445,
0.336982399225235,
-0.31193551421165466,
-0.41486606001853943,
0.06643329560756683,
-0.12744931876659393,
0.5448780059814453,
0.6131448745727539,
-0.871062159538269,
0.7730491757392883,
0.21005991101264954,
-0.15236544609069824,
-0.6369798183441162,
-0.7346446514129639,
0.1813608855009079,
-0.24550184607505798,
-0.29208987951278687,
0.5426036715507507,
0.16983185708522797,
-0.3619365692138672,
0.07816769927740097,
0.11785378307104111,
-0.006550872698426247,
0.07373752444982529,
-0.17410403490066528,
0.24109528958797455,
-0.37063536047935486,
0.29218950867652893,
0.009639455005526543,
0.23575355112552643,
-0.20005090534687042,
-0.4394311010837555,
0.5908682346343994,
0.10771103203296661,
-0.3208630084991455,
-0.06693627685308456,
0.2770145833492279,
0.43692073225975037,
0.024677786976099014,
0.8441745638847351,
0.678579568862915,
-0.3629132807254791,
-0.4716234505176544,
-0.3318972885608673,
-0.24959048628807068,
-0.4532225430011749,
0.7964712977409363,
-0.5987504720687866,
-0.566027820110321,
0.5118778347969055,
-0.133872389793396,
0.26407888531684875,
0.32360726594924927,
0.5896413326263428,
0.1114996150135994,
0.3319234251976013,
0.7778509259223938,
-0.1410665512084961,
0.7104784250259399,
-0.15012574195861816,
0.0789712443947792,
-0.9320752620697021,
0.17098203301429749,
-0.2742141783237457,
-0.4284055531024933,
-0.9461690783500671,
-1.2116855382919312,
0.06182553619146347,
0.023679837584495544,
0.1620834320783615,
0.40923765301704407,
-0.1146816611289978,
0.2743167579174042,
0.5262974500656128,
0.06290388107299805,
0.2794171869754791,
0.4301811456680298,
-0.20928889513015747,
-0.16746076941490173,
-1.302927017211914,
0.10187801718711853,
1.3388705253601074,
0.27695342898368835,
0.6946389079093933,
0.30872511863708496,
0.6589078903198242,
0.16379162669181824,
0.4965318441390991,
-1.0809556245803833,
0.3909934163093567,
-0.676766574382782,
-0.2535684406757355,
-0.48011916875839233,
-0.35173657536506653,
-1.0672416687011719,
0.3890667259693146,
-0.4163109362125397,
-0.6188604235649109,
0.4581727087497711,
-0.017269009724259377,
-0.32059890031814575,
0.529715359210968,
-0.8134592175483704,
0.5015711188316345,
-0.4316166639328003,
-0.6253088712692261,
-0.36638331413269043,
-0.028835177421569824,
0.15883171558380127,
-0.6487196087837219,
0.39182722568511963,
-0.0394718237221241,
-0.5433692932128906,
0.9260818958282471,
-0.16834266483783722,
1.009295105934143,
-0.22020381689071655,
-0.18471233546733856,
0.30072861909866333,
-0.06354869157075882,
0.6327512264251709,
-0.22385001182556152,
-0.17496979236602783,
0.5121159553527832,
-0.06668693572282791,
-0.6322340965270996,
-0.5531176328659058,
0.5557484030723572,
-0.7491009831428528,
-0.5581326484680176,
-0.2368946224451065,
-0.8621966242790222,
-0.45866861939430237,
-0.04178472235798836,
0.045545708388090134,
0.12890106439590454,
-0.12827129662036896,
0.31294798851013184,
0.35762059688568115,
-0.47488313913345337,
0.4556640088558197,
0.6220667362213135,
-0.014933648519217968,
-0.11096485704183578,
0.947788417339325,
0.24901127815246582,
0.5457013249397278,
0.39375564455986023,
0.4305398464202881,
-0.2209950089454651,
-0.6367204189300537,
-0.6429678797721863,
0.29448169469833374,
-0.5340636968612671,
-0.01125993113964796,
-0.35258612036705017,
-0.0705578625202179,
-0.24184633791446686,
-0.3561558723449707,
-0.4586472511291504,
-0.3532033860683441,
-0.426219642162323,
0.18448640406131744,
0.7416428923606873,
0.047507915645837784,
-0.2571713328361511,
0.49101394414901733,
-0.7601282596588135,
0.09174119681119919,
-0.09947917610406876,
0.15594737231731415,
-0.03339808061718941,
-1.0273635387420654,
-0.5928098559379578,
-0.09183813631534576,
0.3425096273422241,
-0.6205976605415344,
0.3388536274433136,
0.3497019410133362,
0.4928244352340698,
0.183939129114151,
-0.04096582531929016,
0.985053539276123,
-0.5269774198532104,
0.5432985424995422,
0.3145059049129486,
-0.6806924343109131,
-0.10327935963869095,
-0.11076724529266357,
0.3217434287071228,
0.3639194965362549,
0.4086565673351288,
-0.587972104549408,
0.17699044942855835,
-0.3567698299884796,
-0.7325224280357361,
0.6100540161132812,
-0.2765886187553406,
0.5252197980880737,
0.11003375053405762,
0.35279181599617004,
0.12104355543851852,
-0.08832337707281113,
-0.2858544588088989,
0.12248828262090683,
0.09172390401363373,
-0.06211409717798233,
-0.35244423151016235,
0.010090116411447525,
-0.16868045926094055,
-0.12829121947288513,
0.40787237882614136,
-0.6599246859550476,
0.2003897726535797,
-0.08887598663568497,
-0.36587584018707275,
0.0574650876224041,
0.3782324194908142,
0.17494885623455048,
0.28411561250686646,
0.19543761014938354,
0.03210239112377167,
0.7843047380447388,
-0.4140837490558624,
0.11514387279748917,
0.15809418261051178,
0.01238427497446537,
-0.06131962686777115,
0.5218095183372498,
0.7079453468322754,
0.6453864574432373,
-0.7351964712142944,
0.42928341031074524,
0.1605268120765686,
-0.11606208235025406,
0.0008110046619549394,
-0.05081534758210182,
0.22365443408489227,
0.30754974484443665,
0.2586619257926941,
-0.25740084052085876,
-0.21987494826316833,
-0.6187807321548462,
-0.03567685931921005,
0.6446486115455627,
-0.12170407176017761,
-0.2578439712524414,
0.22657321393489838,
0.1505671888589859,
-0.07475631684064865,
0.3716931641101837,
-0.1979512870311737,
-0.1449836939573288,
0.4035463333129883,
0.7050520777702332,
0.7403427362442017,
0.021616630256175995,
0.09152606129646301,
0.2634311318397522,
0.39302298426628113,
-0.015415741130709648,
0.4006005525588989,
-0.012731575407087803,
-1.0995389223098755,
-0.7964444160461426,
-0.6629486083984375,
-0.40405529737472534,
-0.05247699096798897,
-0.44182276725769043,
0.2266971468925476,
-0.5167351961135864,
-0.10879437625408173,
-0.28090623021125793,
0.16391406953334808,
-0.9427977204322815,
-0.11255008727312088,
0.0781952440738678,
1.2258020639419556,
-0.9483733177185059,
0.7415977716445923,
0.6249426007270813,
0.04382672533392906,
-0.6503551006317139,
-0.054955240339040756,
-0.24427589774131775,
-1.0992848873138428,
0.7872666120529175,
-0.4270155429840088,
-0.013111980631947517,
0.1133662536740303,
-0.008695125579833984,
-1.316230297088623,
0.9846720695495605,
0.324820876121521,
-0.6682844758033752,
-0.18829621374607086,
0.11932062357664108,
0.5444937348365784,
-0.5446456670761108,
0.044400282204151154,
0.40739139914512634,
0.4299962520599365,
0.13084304332733154,
-0.919137179851532,
0.29729628562927246,
0.19151628017425537,
0.24826084077358246,
0.0032333722338080406,
-0.5134025812149048,
0.8778645992279053,
-0.3803479075431824,
-0.1849696785211563,
-0.03386159613728523,
0.8249587416648865,
0.04041371867060661,
-0.25655779242515564,
0.8338747024536133,
0.19256871938705444,
0.7475513219833374,
0.10914143174886703,
0.9899848699569702,
-0.6403132081031799,
-0.14632263779640198,
1.2291450500488281,
-0.34534820914268494,
1.0152894258499146,
0.7620874047279358,
-0.008203763514757156,
0.5207028985023499,
0.597820520401001,
-0.1801140159368515,
0.3952494263648987,
0.3702169954776764,
-0.10266969352960587,
-0.17705996334552765,
-0.5087279677391052,
-0.06020166352391243,
0.8075949549674988,
0.5594246983528137,
-0.4444045424461365,
-0.208176389336586,
0.05028213933110237,
-0.04626801237463951,
-0.20551186800003052,
-0.4435468018054962,
0.7147660851478577,
-0.04564015194773674,
-0.5176658034324646,
0.660944938659668,
0.2270650714635849,
0.8932065963745117,
-0.39503026008605957,
0.22598963975906372,
-0.2169436812400818,
-0.07194483280181885,
-0.0034702850971370935,
-0.362729012966156,
-0.0003356637607794255,
0.12321531027555466,
0.10685057193040848,
-0.1805318295955658,
0.6266793012619019,
-0.41336074471473694,
-0.6112892031669617,
0.4978474974632263,
1.130528211593628,
0.14839042723178864,
0.5222117900848389,
-0.6156851053237915,
-0.0446314811706543,
-0.22807741165161133,
-0.19228723645210266,
0.5898913145065308,
0.3816663324832916,
-0.5294376015663147,
0.3612894117832184,
0.9220718741416931,
0.6902250647544861,
0.20310313999652863,
0.036287497729063034,
0.6885499358177185,
-0.3447299301624298,
-0.43253424763679504,
-0.5867862701416016,
0.15836617350578308,
-0.05613959580659866,
-0.22484000027179718,
0.6802670955657959,
0.4507881999015808,
0.8596216440200806,
0.08287064731121063,
0.8255597352981567,
0.06633944809436798,
0.27767759561538696,
-0.6632146835327148,
0.4133094847202301,
-0.679865300655365,
0.18211662769317627,
-0.08211783319711685,
-0.7100300192832947,
0.04555642977356911,
0.25648215413093567,
-0.479694664478302,
0.017843885347247124,
0.661578357219696,
0.7105769515037537,
-0.25421032309532166,
-0.5259833931922913,
0.45883598923683167,
0.2203037142753601,
-0.03855450823903084,
0.5388041138648987,
0.49624350666999817,
-0.16038371622562408,
0.6184341907501221,
-0.3100917637348175,
-0.2699148654937744,
-0.26032429933547974,
-1.0400997400283813,
-0.7362027168273926,
-0.3020175099372864,
-0.21994827687740326,
-0.38232287764549255,
0.15236999094486237,
1.1299505233764648,
0.7294148802757263,
-0.6746057271957397,
-0.3873140513896942,
0.2932111322879791,
0.11044208705425262,
-0.3137376010417938,
-0.1950778067111969,
0.4367395043373108,
-0.4569144546985626,
-1.0277268886566162,
0.5153627991676331,
0.016268402338027954,
-0.00880245678126812,
-0.37567898631095886,
-0.053654417395591736,
-0.16594530642032623,
0.33558663725852966,
0.652670681476593,
0.4479580521583557,
-0.5157428979873657,
-0.3450077474117279,
0.20339424908161163,
-0.12384338676929474,
0.044728852808475494,
0.7049316167831421,
-0.6682409644126892,
0.34375324845314026,
0.47824734449386597,
1.13375985622406,
0.3489706516265869,
-0.13412994146347046,
0.7202526926994324,
-0.8595666289329529,
0.33942723274230957,
-0.13180087506771088,
0.39907121658325195,
0.39211082458496094,
-0.3518960773944855,
0.37010180950164795,
0.20117729902267456,
0.15477542579174042,
-0.8886318802833557,
0.016521338373422623,
-0.6844424605369568,
-0.403419554233551,
1.330505132675171,
-0.08349041640758514,
-0.41287413239479065,
0.06283264607191086,
0.13513916730880737,
0.28100889921188354,
-0.3287535607814789,
0.7207477688789368,
0.6373934149742126,
-0.12535519897937775,
-0.07966514676809311,
-0.44582056999206543,
0.4410322904586792,
0.5903491973876953,
-0.9075613021850586,
0.07150024175643921,
0.20317389070987701,
0.3677508533000946,
0.277724027633667,
0.5464880466461182,
0.0796985924243927,
0.14118856191635132,
0.06480885297060013,
-0.09874407947063446,
0.13016153872013092,
-0.08557765185832977,
-0.383201539516449,
0.11869408190250397,
0.12379077821969986,
-0.3448391258716583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11474v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11474v1 | How Far Can In-Context Alignment Go? Exploring the State of In-Context Alignment | 2024-06-17T12:38:48 | 2024-06-17T12:38:48 | Heyan Huang, Yinghao Li, Huashan Sun, Yu Bai, Yang Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent studies have demonstrated that In-Context Learning (ICL), through the
use of specific demonstrations, can align Large Language Models (LLMs) with
human preferences known as In-Context Alignment (ICA), indicating that models
can comprehend human instructions without requiring parameter adjustments.
However, the exploration of the mechanism and applicability of ICA remains
limited. In this paper, we begin by dividing the context text used in ICA into
three categories: format, system prompt, and example. Through ablation
experiments, we investigate the effectiveness of each part in enabling ICA to
function effectively. We then examine how variants in these parts impact the
model's alignment performance. Our findings indicate that the example part is
crucial for enhancing the model's alignment capabilities, with changes in
examples significantly affecting alignment performance. We also conduct a
comprehensive evaluation of ICA's zero-shot capabilities in various alignment
tasks. The results indicate that compared to parameter fine-tuning methods, ICA
demonstrates superior performance in knowledge-based tasks and tool-use tasks.
However, it still exhibits certain limitations in areas such as multi-turn
dialogues and instruction following. | [
-0.3671787679195404,
-0.6637089252471924,
0.7449594140052795,
-0.10491346567869186,
-0.3931558430194855,
-0.015503513626754284,
-0.270205557346344,
-0.6807281374931335,
-0.334044873714447,
0.14473192393779755,
-0.40711709856987,
-0.31005439162254333,
-0.2505984306335449,
0.09753182530403137,
-0.5429810881614685,
0.9697494506835938,
-0.2865898311138153,
0.020953360944986343,
-0.5020657777786255,
-0.430838942527771,
-0.8906804323196411,
-0.48197683691978455,
-0.2781798839569092,
-0.4137488603591919,
0.33551496267318726,
0.9781421422958374,
0.6143120527267456,
0.9784364700317383,
0.44666653871536255,
0.21519559621810913,
-0.1373472958803177,
0.041131071746349335,
-0.2724623680114746,
0.05525239557027817,
-0.27955034375190735,
-0.37288805842399597,
-0.22187930345535278,
-0.031059004366397858,
0.9157580137252808,
0.7487803101539612,
0.043740205466747284,
-0.03944201022386551,
0.2520674467086792,
0.5178889036178589,
-0.5401852130889893,
-0.3619910180568695,
-0.6929101347923279,
-0.4057009518146515,
-0.2800617516040802,
0.09454261511564255,
-0.3044009208679199,
-0.13616791367530823,
0.5786997079849243,
-0.405626505613327,
-0.24494995176792145,
0.058389730751514435,
0.9161812663078308,
0.29668259620666504,
-0.698283314704895,
-0.5367634892463684,
-0.8634801506996155,
0.8675974011421204,
-0.9424638748168945,
0.3870513141155243,
0.06802263855934143,
0.21790333092212677,
-0.18625028431415558,
-0.27554771304130554,
-0.7097648978233337,
-0.06618721783161163,
-0.09367843717336655,
-0.24696992337703705,
0.017251314595341682,
0.11594663560390472,
0.4304669499397278,
0.0981738343834877,
-0.36532554030418396,
0.5180021524429321,
-0.13117237389087677,
0.05638526752591133,
0.263365238904953,
0.14433041214942932,
0.5329104661941528,
0.04734288528561592,
-0.5208803415298462,
-0.12496323138475418,
-0.9730259776115417,
0.3259694278240204,
0.12434656918048859,
0.4097992181777954,
-0.1495048701763153,
0.7044216990470886,
-0.17847737669944763,
1.0681636333465576,
0.26447388529777527,
-0.19590158760547638,
-0.21022173762321472,
-0.25762587785720825,
-0.38465753197669983,
0.3391188979148865,
0.35613182187080383,
0.4122994542121887,
-0.2379056215286255,
-0.23785097897052765,
-0.11861509829759598,
-0.04842362925410271,
0.22756916284561157,
-0.7650049328804016,
0.38241082429885864,
0.1882966011762619,
-0.23262237012386322,
0.16398262977600098,
0.005866373889148235,
-0.3996509313583374,
-0.3322587311267853,
-0.7867016792297363,
0.5549678802490234,
-0.6162210702896118,
0.2684229612350464,
-0.008767778053879738,
0.1612682342529297,
0.7275432348251343,
0.2946435213088989,
-1.0549559593200684,
0.21685519814491272,
0.8427739143371582,
0.7470672726631165,
-0.3348085284233093,
-0.469252347946167,
-0.4044744372367859,
0.23343652486801147,
-0.261506050825119,
0.7839226722717285,
-0.6505016684532166,
0.051176682114601135,
-0.03165166825056076,
-0.20081555843353271,
-0.09845171123743057,
-0.5100528001785278,
0.028360756114125252,
-0.4941304326057434,
0.2718614637851715,
-0.4485529363155365,
-0.9914093017578125,
-0.3300415575504303,
0.1233481839299202,
-0.28409168124198914,
0.6570953130722046,
0.016649950295686722,
-0.4753982424736023,
0.7231334447860718,
-0.5955156087875366,
-0.4393439292907715,
-0.16895821690559387,
-0.31820130348205566,
-0.24248085916042328,
0.23326577246189117,
0.09284379333257675,
0.41075780987739563,
-0.18651559948921204,
0.23268164694309235,
-0.2814638912677765,
-0.8003811240196228,
0.5580003261566162,
-0.3401777744293213,
0.6194701194763184,
0.034129321575164795,
-0.583767294883728,
0.11691552400588989,
-0.4804217219352722,
-0.4061746597290039,
-0.2775666415691376,
-0.22169001400470734,
-0.4310758411884308,
0.012116740457713604,
-0.2094709575176239,
0.44702839851379395,
0.24810919165611267,
-0.497780442237854,
0.4457290470600128,
-0.5289775133132935,
0.39064401388168335,
0.6851391196250916,
-0.1700623482465744,
0.893814206123352,
-0.273410826921463,
0.4427446722984314,
0.007813594304025173,
0.06693104654550552,
-0.28146249055862427,
-0.2723022699356079,
-0.5768308639526367,
-0.15076075494289398,
0.3583930432796478,
0.4196971654891968,
-0.34614381194114685,
0.316708505153656,
-0.1578029841184616,
-0.4216419756412506,
-0.39967140555381775,
0.08947537839412689,
0.6214042901992798,
0.9706680178642273,
0.2869507670402527,
-0.2599574327468872,
-0.3201232850551605,
-0.9515913128852844,
-0.26342085003852844,
-0.087220199406147,
0.0365716926753521,
0.28586193919181824,
0.29828065633773804,
0.03417615592479706,
1.2271491289138794,
-0.10225004702806473,
-0.09172718226909637,
-0.07278982549905777,
-0.10553628951311111,
0.012004583142697811,
0.5296515226364136,
0.45670732855796814,
-0.5530511736869812,
-0.6437047719955444,
0.2583126723766327,
-0.6172707080841064,
-0.05372028052806854,
-0.23014463484287262,
-0.17460277676582336,
0.3500290513038635,
0.6720573306083679,
-0.26279574632644653,
0.48243147134780884,
0.4936846196651459,
-0.3169410526752472,
0.16704946756362915,
-0.09999501705169678,
0.08203443884849548,
-1.1033228635787964,
0.09923318773508072,
0.041248589754104614,
-0.06810570508241653,
-0.8452622890472412,
0.05323252081871033,
0.4579358398914337,
0.05690719559788704,
-0.6842936873435974,
0.7654798030853271,
-0.35617950558662415,
-0.21618476510047913,
-0.43092426657676697,
0.3153671324253082,
-0.1764257401227951,
0.3813212215900421,
-0.06125566363334656,
0.9510670900344849,
0.3254009187221527,
-0.6700106263160706,
-0.27252450585365295,
0.32388636469841003,
-0.4882475733757019,
0.7199224829673767,
-0.28906387090682983,
0.31809931993484497,
-0.07621803134679794,
0.23777088522911072,
-1.0283782482147217,
-0.35760924220085144,
0.11308801174163818,
-0.010789292864501476,
0.5498005151748657,
0.022480826824903488,
-0.34571248292922974,
0.3910335600376129,
0.03768879547715187,
0.6823701858520508,
0.4200846254825592,
-0.7416455149650574,
0.533414363861084,
0.1324853003025055,
0.15179572999477386,
-0.8430633544921875,
-0.3589077889919281,
0.10961666703224182,
-0.6743237972259521,
-0.5029993057250977,
0.7079756855964661,
-0.25283387303352356,
-0.4044237434864044,
-0.3119695782661438,
-0.22464518249034882,
0.15468168258666992,
0.29392731189727783,
0.16653035581111908,
0.27748018503189087,
-0.1652473658323288,
0.15853601694107056,
0.2507304549217224,
0.23522858321666718,
-0.4261682331562042,
-0.1194792240858078,
0.429764062166214,
-0.16226749122142792,
-0.5094594955444336,
-0.8759380578994751,
0.2955092489719391,
0.5642537474632263,
0.03528403490781784,
0.6806450486183167,
-0.07062448561191559,
-0.4049402177333832,
0.04526694491505623,
-0.47331443428993225,
-0.23984959721565247,
-0.41783276200294495,
0.18619194626808167,
-0.18264858424663544,
-0.908179521560669,
0.4775664806365967,
0.025530127808451653,
0.27246758341789246,
0.09220757335424423,
0.2569378614425659,
-0.30059418082237244,
1.214959740638733,
0.741325318813324,
-0.21273158490657806,
0.7555643320083618,
0.08636157959699631,
0.2342546135187149,
-1.1194453239440918,
-0.07121545076370239,
-0.6528242826461792,
-0.6202019453048706,
-0.3886159062385559,
0.09320231527090073,
0.2721712291240692,
0.4559052288532257,
-0.3826151490211487,
0.5697534680366516,
-0.28850775957107544,
0.6340293288230896,
0.43161243200302124,
0.02132011018693447,
0.1786593794822693,
-0.13190840184688568,
-0.0971541553735733,
0.0004105477419216186,
-0.5517650246620178,
-0.7838855385780334,
0.8342229723930359,
0.368492990732193,
0.5180432200431824,
0.15389622747898102,
0.5777599811553955,
-0.29729902744293213,
0.6459507942199707,
-0.8953222036361694,
0.39006906747817993,
-0.1171639934182167,
-0.5275030732154846,
-0.4666368365287781,
0.1968850940465927,
-0.6046299338340759,
0.18634633719921112,
-0.07247981429100037,
-0.978459358215332,
0.18140023946762085,
0.24622474610805511,
-0.47115084528923035,
0.1845385730266571,
-0.7271853089332581,
0.8927406668663025,
-0.2885879874229431,
-0.22662463784217834,
0.09648055583238602,
-0.7992233633995056,
0.15194791555404663,
-0.039008911699056625,
0.06999040395021439,
0.03715244680643082,
-0.0911238044500351,
0.3712581396102905,
-0.06471312046051025,
0.9455677270889282,
-0.07766104489564896,
-0.4079248011112213,
-0.011574124917387962,
-0.001029922510497272,
0.3894888162612915,
-0.20688782632350922,
-0.04755207896232605,
-0.009076286107301712,
-0.02542528696358204,
-0.30354511737823486,
-0.744084358215332,
0.5982337594032288,
-0.5802892446517944,
-0.6435734033584595,
-0.2159576565027237,
-0.7341681122779846,
-0.4251759946346283,
0.1311434507369995,
0.18430250883102417,
0.6807712912559509,
-0.2083461433649063,
0.42143014073371887,
0.6913376450538635,
-0.048089589923620224,
0.5627747774124146,
0.5070288181304932,
-0.027478419244289398,
-0.03855738416314125,
0.7719073295593262,
0.08124496787786484,
0.4416077435016632,
0.6395371556282043,
0.1487838327884674,
-0.38816529512405396,
-0.8037080764770508,
-0.7615338563919067,
0.27120956778526306,
-0.8512781262397766,
-0.1787462830543518,
-0.3760615885257721,
0.18489299714565277,
-0.23549948632717133,
-0.6106486320495605,
-0.07107803225517273,
-0.193095400929451,
-0.7095546126365662,
0.06574616581201553,
-0.12172526866197586,
0.7836000919342041,
0.398978054523468,
0.47403648495674133,
-0.5586229562759399,
-0.26471543312072754,
0.27372756600379944,
0.4022269546985626,
-0.027425426989793777,
-0.663804829120636,
-0.36207354068756104,
0.001181091065518558,
-0.40118861198425293,
-0.8281907439231873,
0.026952389627695084,
0.09363486617803574,
0.3248428702354431,
0.6846022605895996,
-0.1881360113620758,
1.0665677785873413,
-0.4460950493812561,
0.8755881786346436,
-0.08867201954126358,
-1.1856343746185303,
0.2583130896091461,
-0.2964455783367157,
0.5557404160499573,
0.5836148858070374,
0.1917038857936859,
-0.6582250595092773,
-0.4339157044887543,
-0.2620590925216675,
-0.5947108268737793,
0.8581735491752625,
-0.1670815795660019,
0.10813181847333908,
0.090888611972332,
0.7951685786247253,
0.18676665425300598,
-0.15645000338554382,
-0.4073176681995392,
-0.0022076673340052366,
0.134689599275589,
-0.44849351048469543,
-0.1176929622888565,
-0.1584666222333908,
-0.3048657178878784,
-0.16037583351135254,
0.6498634815216064,
-0.5006409883499146,
-0.026899689808487892,
0.12512150406837463,
-0.2841525971889496,
-0.15526317059993744,
0.3823913037776947,
1.1489102840423584,
0.9978598356246948,
-0.09273313730955124,
-0.10678578168153763,
0.3661617338657379,
0.018722888082265854,
0.19183599948883057,
-0.048660751432180405,
-0.2366364598274231,
-0.5695039629936218,
0.2989805340766907,
0.6540339589118958,
0.44587934017181396,
-0.7134736776351929,
0.4903608560562134,
-0.16951797902584076,
-0.03862486779689789,
0.030108192935585976,
0.11595337837934494,
-0.01273120567202568,
0.36651742458343506,
0.27533432841300964,
-0.11782626807689667,
0.0668666809797287,
-0.6061998605728149,
0.09487224370241165,
0.8203051090240479,
-0.6544753313064575,
-0.3295971751213074,
0.5143506526947021,
-0.2053520679473877,
-0.3565269410610199,
0.6208226084709167,
0.1257961094379425,
-0.3383316099643707,
0.6338741183280945,
0.7857343554496765,
0.6968260407447815,
-0.06532913446426392,
-0.13632690906524658,
0.04830614849925041,
0.0567815899848938,
-0.030431611463427544,
-0.012862484902143478,
-0.2169000208377838,
-0.7721424102783203,
-0.5239265561103821,
-0.3600171208381653,
-0.6380298137664795,
-0.06040371581912041,
-0.634189248085022,
0.3700112998485565,
-0.1580927073955536,
0.2283726930618286,
-0.03924502059817314,
-0.12808716297149658,
-0.6594422459602356,
0.11103978753089905,
0.11777784675359726,
0.9160860776901245,
-0.7279706001281738,
0.8378379940986633,
0.8616714477539062,
-0.23810380697250366,
-0.937787652015686,
0.26595354080200195,
0.14130817353725433,
-0.4102463722229004,
0.4315263330936432,
0.43449658155441284,
-0.147884801030159,
-0.2242993414402008,
-0.7656843066215515,
-1.0492702722549438,
1.2565721273422241,
0.5389211773872375,
-0.4613466262817383,
-0.07800914347171783,
-0.005636807531118393,
0.5401619076728821,
-0.7112258076667786,
0.13594496250152588,
0.6522321701049805,
0.21042783558368683,
-0.030022021383047104,
-1.0079424381256104,
0.09103678166866302,
0.297361820936203,
0.056642062962055206,
0.13775137066841125,
-0.7009263634681702,
0.604200005531311,
0.03902560845017433,
-0.3979179263114929,
0.30592915415763855,
0.8313591480255127,
0.17574353516101837,
0.4040471315383911,
0.5419844388961792,
0.4282612204551697,
0.536003589630127,
0.037319641560316086,
1.006986379623413,
-0.2680043578147888,
-0.04317520558834076,
1.1887768507003784,
-0.5574884414672852,
0.8130723237991333,
0.8500804305076599,
0.22999072074890137,
0.7076860070228577,
0.6584839820861816,
0.5949876308441162,
0.32811877131462097,
-0.12894763052463531,
-0.2603873312473297,
-0.07226403057575226,
-0.23279361426830292,
-0.02526404894888401,
0.7861733436584473,
0.41261622309684753,
-0.18447862565517426,
0.0014456192729994655,
0.10194427520036697,
-0.026234714314341545,
0.10469239950180054,
-0.03737816959619522,
1.0685172080993652,
-0.1427089124917984,
-1.132918119430542,
0.37708351016044617,
-0.1257750391960144,
0.5835156440734863,
-0.4221348464488983,
-0.2359672337770462,
-0.1794266402721405,
0.03335544466972351,
-0.1522161364555359,
-0.6905550360679626,
0.2541016936302185,
-0.19313004612922668,
-0.15915578603744507,
-0.11036395281553268,
0.4673963785171509,
-0.4645148515701294,
0.2040117084980011,
0.08011169731616974,
0.13271886110305786,
0.06887493282556534,
0.16394245624542236,
-0.3595738410949707,
0.030093299224972725,
0.02025052346289158,
0.08004370331764221,
0.8082166910171509,
0.22539161145687103,
-0.23263591527938843,
0.4517623484134674,
0.269368052482605,
-0.311767041683197,
-0.12421179562807083,
-0.17086930572986603,
0.734929084777832,
-0.6108426451683044,
-0.0927891954779625,
-0.9111154079437256,
0.582076370716095,
0.02599130943417549,
-0.4296257495880127,
0.719871997833252,
0.4380485713481903,
1.2117626667022705,
0.3062457740306854,
0.5458300709724426,
0.04564391449093819,
0.2625764012336731,
-0.6390973329544067,
0.32598549127578735,
-0.7430565357208252,
0.24404478073120117,
-0.28550446033477783,
-0.8427513241767883,
-0.4737333059310913,
0.30880260467529297,
-0.21747314929962158,
-0.17782825231552124,
0.6517344117164612,
0.7770508527755737,
-0.17507104575634003,
0.09041734784841537,
0.3897716701030731,
-0.18278443813323975,
0.5505696535110474,
0.20658035576343536,
0.8717899918556213,
-0.23735442757606506,
0.3431167006492615,
-0.49784043431282043,
-0.3357730507850647,
-0.27273067831993103,
-1.1723263263702393,
-0.7129977941513062,
-0.8183929920196533,
-0.1337859183549881,
-0.13332971930503845,
-0.237117737531662,
1.1798686981201172,
0.7522687315940857,
-0.6751477718353271,
-0.4618069529533386,
0.05843762680888176,
0.15153753757476807,
-0.45690467953681946,
-0.16398504376411438,
0.340617299079895,
-0.4616148769855499,
-0.9323453307151794,
0.738963782787323,
0.3993757367134094,
0.18000821769237518,
-0.11578397452831268,
0.09902042895555496,
-0.23353630304336548,
0.07228700071573257,
0.5046066641807556,
0.527630627155304,
-0.8988183736801147,
-0.6465840935707092,
0.1895219087600708,
-0.06539800018072128,
0.12712277472019196,
0.9303380846977234,
-0.47209829092025757,
0.6304091215133667,
0.3407466411590576,
0.8082860112190247,
0.08433225005865097,
0.3570675253868103,
0.7786217331886292,
-0.6793445944786072,
-0.18800926208496094,
0.02123996615409851,
0.38276877999305725,
0.40159711241722107,
-0.503960371017456,
0.09576543420553207,
-0.4701720178127289,
-0.9432932138442993,
-0.7841634750366211,
0.2941678762435913,
-0.845861554145813,
-0.3159199357032776,
1.112816333770752,
0.1846485435962677,
-0.25311556458473206,
-0.15113277733325958,
-0.347645103931427,
0.4521678686141968,
-0.42497262358665466,
0.9136707782745361,
0.832750678062439,
-0.5799828171730042,
0.12521101534366608,
-0.29194778203964233,
0.5903105735778809,
0.6400916576385498,
-0.6375843286514282,
0.0735485851764679,
0.5735730528831482,
0.33072301745414734,
0.03888550400733948,
0.42496493458747864,
-0.09341580420732498,
0.25797346234321594,
-0.7248109579086304,
-0.11962559074163437,
0.2748040556907654,
-0.4286540150642395,
-1.0877127647399902,
-0.037943411618471146,
0.3137533366680145,
0.014116059057414532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11473v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11473v1 | Promises, Outlooks and Challenges of Diffusion Language Modeling | 2024-06-17T12:38:38 | 2024-06-17T12:38:38 | Justin Deschenaux, Caglar Gulcehre | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The modern autoregressive Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved
outstanding performance on NLP benchmarks, and they are deployed in the real
world. However, they still suffer from limitations of the autoregressive
training paradigm. For example, autoregressive token generation is notably slow
and can be prone to \textit{exposure bias}. The diffusion-based language models
were proposed as an alternative to autoregressive generation to address some of
these limitations. We evaluate the recently proposed Score Entropy Discrete
Diffusion (SEDD) approach and show it is a promising alternative to
autoregressive generation but it has some short-comings too. We empirically
demonstrate the advantages and challenges of SEDD, and observe that SEDD
generally matches autoregressive models in perplexity and on benchmarks such as
HellaSwag, Arc or WinoGrande. Additionally, we show that in terms of inference
latency, SEDD can be up to 4.5$\times$ more efficient than GPT-2. While SEDD
allows conditioning on tokens at abitrary positions, SEDD appears slightly
weaker than GPT-2 for conditional generation given short prompts. Finally, we
reproduced the main results from the original SEDD paper. | [
-0.22557562589645386,
-0.892448902130127,
0.7269488573074341,
0.37401989102363586,
-0.06386088579893112,
-0.10647191852331161,
-0.09089584648609161,
-0.21959812939167023,
-0.09697293490171432,
0.2671680748462677,
-0.4512805938720703,
-0.3554140627384186,
-0.8633602857589722,
-0.08210456371307373,
-0.6373189687728882,
0.7376909852027893,
-0.10225493460893631,
-0.1283571571111679,
-0.2043953686952591,
0.16280397772789001,
0.008803230710327625,
-0.5518337488174438,
-1.0412651300430298,
-0.3745841681957245,
0.3690611720085144,
-0.07438037544488907,
0.6573131084442139,
0.5243019461631775,
0.3394860327243805,
0.26968488097190857,
-0.24060003459453583,
-0.3206952214241028,
-0.2099037915468216,
0.5032851099967957,
0.03872137889266014,
-0.09317493438720703,
-0.3543955087661743,
0.1968468874692917,
0.6585630774497986,
0.7712497711181641,
-0.62330162525177,
-0.15436026453971863,
-0.01794550195336342,
0.6465431451797485,
-0.4932301342487335,
-0.13410858809947968,
-0.5252776741981506,
0.1366550326347351,
-0.3479935824871063,
0.2666718363761902,
-0.3168182373046875,
-0.24016538262367249,
0.22695070505142212,
-0.016792388632893562,
0.14155139029026031,
-0.11823554337024689,
0.4528360962867737,
0.5006404519081116,
-0.554425835609436,
-0.342142790555954,
-0.7649417519569397,
0.6029533743858337,
-1.0587111711502075,
0.32905328273773193,
0.25320717692375183,
0.15527692437171936,
-0.03229253739118576,
-0.6224939227104187,
-0.4063703715801239,
-0.09824313223361969,
0.29491955041885376,
0.07694817334413528,
-0.118137426674366,
0.007720934227108955,
0.1577983796596527,
0.416288286447525,
-0.7478838562965393,
0.44890448451042175,
0.0038422290235757828,
0.0280484426766634,
0.6817669868469238,
0.42119425535202026,
-0.08087481558322906,
0.03720282018184662,
-0.4232301414012909,
0.06533914804458618,
-0.658469021320343,
-0.24391253292560577,
0.5406328439712524,
0.006727150175720453,
-0.16881580650806427,
0.4196952283382416,
-0.215424045920372,
0.5891086459159851,
-0.04621792957186699,
0.10535448044538498,
0.29839131236076355,
0.02877878025174141,
-0.2494359165430069,
-0.3728982210159302,
0.8462784886360168,
-0.008374108001589775,
-0.10137832909822464,
-0.23039314150810242,
-0.3290655314922333,
0.025086328387260437,
-0.19476903975009918,
-0.7126133441925049,
-0.2862742841243744,
0.3029651939868927,
-0.5137325525283813,
-0.2505715787410736,
-0.4084703326225281,
-0.8324515223503113,
-0.44539567828178406,
0.06303463131189346,
0.20074374973773956,
-0.4463821351528168,
-0.6229429244995117,
0.2528758645057678,
-0.22730664908885956,
0.32031771540641785,
0.5935864448547363,
-0.8662300705909729,
0.34048283100128174,
0.6128963828086853,
1.0311859846115112,
-0.7421411871910095,
-0.17722249031066895,
-0.21598820388317108,
-0.025485513731837273,
-0.22100676596164703,
0.8536373376846313,
-0.6204432845115662,
-0.5308988094329834,
-0.20792463421821594,
-0.43194398283958435,
-0.20509915053844452,
-0.5105834603309631,
0.2557305097579956,
-0.3992985785007477,
0.1575816422700882,
-0.07823514938354492,
-0.6163025498390198,
0.18444284796714783,
0.031557340174913406,
-0.4751131236553192,
0.9819095134735107,
0.24920333921909332,
-0.680538535118103,
0.2579151690006256,
-0.5351206064224243,
-0.5351868271827698,
-0.009746047668159008,
0.0434119813144207,
-0.2247982621192932,
0.15612900257110596,
-0.1821635514497757,
0.39353838562965393,
-0.3449462950229645,
0.4373306632041931,
-0.5313390493392944,
0.10998924821615219,
0.0330488383769989,
-0.971537709236145,
0.9254496097564697,
0.6026678085327148,
-0.39649295806884766,
-0.3176433742046356,
-0.8029571175575256,
-0.09269894659519196,
0.14355580508708954,
-0.45755982398986816,
-0.27208617329597473,
0.16937986016273499,
-0.12209667265415192,
0.30563536286354065,
0.17421646416187286,
-0.2861809730529785,
0.09055038541555405,
-0.4044519364833832,
0.38787561655044556,
1.1340444087982178,
0.018992628902196884,
0.6728896498680115,
-0.01428525522351265,
0.8748302459716797,
0.2445528358221054,
0.12313250452280045,
-0.12824870645999908,
-0.6071817278862,
-0.622730553150177,
-0.2307356894016266,
0.5468989610671997,
0.5196904540061951,
-0.49383002519607544,
0.34818142652511597,
0.1740637868642807,
-0.44996753334999084,
-0.4679422080516815,
0.004635024815797806,
0.15210385620594025,
0.48087629675865173,
0.1289534717798233,
-0.41882067918777466,
-0.3017250597476959,
-0.6159793734550476,
-0.0017023764085024595,
-0.3077618479728699,
0.21158133447170258,
0.2296118289232254,
0.37983545660972595,
-0.28123539686203003,
0.81742262840271,
-0.41852378845214844,
0.2439146488904953,
-0.004019900690764189,
0.27195990085601807,
0.13376924395561218,
0.5245662331581116,
0.25928038358688354,
-0.590927004814148,
-0.7042760848999023,
-0.2173817902803421,
-0.4530617892742157,
-0.42102375626564026,
0.06177401915192604,
0.22784215211868286,
0.642988920211792,
0.5484060049057007,
-0.6636024117469788,
0.4545348584651947,
0.7865849137306213,
-0.3524288237094879,
0.635697603225708,
-0.16868889331817627,
-0.13045336306095123,
-0.8059481978416443,
-0.1370857059955597,
0.07706106454133987,
-0.2824123501777649,
-0.6399760842323303,
-0.11273019760847092,
-0.2583683729171753,
-0.1163637712597847,
-0.5475994348526001,
0.8622653484344482,
-0.3467686176300049,
-0.17388916015625,
-0.17857007682323456,
-0.0019282696302980185,
-0.25713375210762024,
0.0697823092341423,
0.3532927930355072,
0.8042627573013306,
0.8083076477050781,
-0.888715386390686,
0.22288362681865692,
-0.11336959153413773,
-0.3870871961116791,
0.4386971890926361,
-0.6697871685028076,
0.07642003893852234,
-0.1235889345407486,
0.269641637802124,
-0.9299749732017517,
0.24762091040611267,
0.06459887325763702,
-0.29044291377067566,
0.31284216046333313,
0.07662948966026306,
-0.4899003803730011,
-0.3054632544517517,
-0.07898982614278793,
0.3449200987815857,
0.8275262117385864,
-0.46106547117233276,
0.33569663763046265,
0.36702749133110046,
-0.2418125420808792,
-0.453453928232193,
-0.5493276715278625,
0.1872337907552719,
-0.5878924131393433,
-0.6061230897903442,
0.3302173912525177,
-0.44793522357940674,
-0.45584139227867126,
-0.07886775583028793,
0.06086702272295952,
0.30524691939353943,
0.38120386004447937,
0.023263677954673767,
-0.18140050768852234,
-0.21099509298801422,
0.041512224823236465,
0.044142838567495346,
-0.2686076760292053,
0.046569544821977615,
-0.29248493909835815,
0.663892924785614,
0.012611489742994308,
-0.4792798161506653,
-0.03438442572951317,
0.4663589596748352,
0.24791409075260162,
0.15020103752613068,
0.7510762810707092,
0.6304029226303101,
-0.17748811841011047,
-0.36654025316238403,
-0.6013533473014832,
0.059645313769578934,
-0.4888649582862854,
0.19414405524730682,
-0.37632647156715393,
-0.8796603083610535,
0.5823352336883545,
-0.30380359292030334,
-0.04081366956233978,
0.5318576097488403,
0.8032575845718384,
-0.05769253149628639,
1.1433589458465576,
0.49363943934440613,
0.06272286921739578,
0.424608439207077,
-0.10104377567768097,
0.19173622131347656,
-0.9399983882904053,
-0.0005681266775354743,
-0.5411755442619324,
-0.017590103670954704,
-0.32347846031188965,
-0.42617374658584595,
0.163327157497406,
0.10891630500555038,
-0.23759670555591583,
0.10383342206478119,
-0.18287166953086853,
0.2565634250640869,
0.5444657802581787,
-0.4010688066482544,
0.1234666183590889,
-0.19949810206890106,
-0.25162407755851746,
-0.04568088799715042,
-0.8569688200950623,
-0.3763112425804138,
0.8299428224563599,
0.5125565528869629,
1.0092017650604248,
0.2580101490020752,
0.9726825952529907,
0.4743075966835022,
0.07028733193874359,
-0.35331618785858154,
0.5783361196517944,
-0.16339097917079926,
-0.40191450715065,
-0.40624359250068665,
-0.5016487240791321,
-0.8189622163772583,
0.26324236392974854,
0.21339839696884155,
-0.6783555746078491,
0.22960001230239868,
0.020409109070897102,
-0.23043973743915558,
0.1519772857427597,
-0.8143323063850403,
0.6905477046966553,
-0.22325678169727325,
-0.2661827504634857,
0.01384149119257927,
-0.4763588309288025,
0.47697553038597107,
-0.1349349319934845,
0.2987615466117859,
-0.20621655881404877,
-0.04069700837135315,
0.6589101552963257,
-0.5709503889083862,
0.837725818157196,
-0.35351935029029846,
-0.5673954486846924,
0.13725796341896057,
0.07545638084411621,
0.6905233860015869,
0.0976439043879509,
-0.47426366806030273,
-0.005103863310068846,
-0.11355029791593552,
-0.1681414395570755,
-0.3085658848285675,
0.8598546385765076,
-0.5120438933372498,
-0.9136154651641846,
-0.6480556726455688,
-0.28258779644966125,
-0.31304967403411865,
0.04581750929355621,
0.3156079947948456,
0.0859978199005127,
-0.3034602701663971,
-0.18115130066871643,
0.7883254885673523,
-0.48674070835113525,
0.7639673352241516,
0.5831255912780762,
-0.17434513568878174,
-0.23770979046821594,
0.6837766766548157,
0.06950762867927551,
0.5483386516571045,
-0.027338072657585144,
0.18666332960128784,
-0.4594343602657318,
-0.6588670015335083,
-0.17736811935901642,
0.24295492470264435,
-0.6774973273277283,
-0.13701219856739044,
-0.8860546350479126,
-0.38820263743400574,
-0.8133941888809204,
-0.14994893968105316,
-0.33428484201431274,
-0.6657010912895203,
-0.5896676778793335,
-0.08593426644802094,
0.2171839028596878,
0.7215496897697449,
-0.5686068534851074,
0.17252880334854126,
-0.3561415672302246,
0.22617623209953308,
0.29961979389190674,
0.41389235854148865,
0.16051575541496277,
-0.6401389837265015,
-0.17823420464992523,
-0.1986072063446045,
-0.11308009177446365,
-0.7448281645774841,
0.4653271734714508,
0.1719588339328766,
0.6000661253929138,
0.34942901134490967,
-0.046394169330596924,
0.686249315738678,
-0.8137184381484985,
0.9839104413986206,
0.19354364275932312,
-0.8154973983764648,
0.4957776963710785,
-0.0745360404253006,
0.29249539971351624,
0.222037672996521,
0.27147895097732544,
-0.5598921775817871,
-0.6823076605796814,
-0.9646437168121338,
-0.9092909097671509,
0.45622584223747253,
-0.10172607004642487,
0.22870537638664246,
-0.47118330001831055,
0.43091800808906555,
0.28477224707603455,
0.1374262273311615,
-0.6322291493415833,
-0.31486940383911133,
0.05702320858836174,
-0.06698485463857651,
-0.05025371536612511,
-0.37497761845588684,
0.37013593316078186,
0.010875687934458256,
0.8563873767852783,
0.24036814272403717,
0.2872922718524933,
0.0770447701215744,
0.01602281630039215,
-0.03422003239393234,
0.20473723113536835,
0.6844381093978882,
0.33366113901138306,
-0.06190744414925575,
0.1364821344614029,
0.059016354382038116,
-0.2281474769115448,
0.378126323223114,
0.1415625661611557,
-0.4203120470046997,
0.10548463463783264,
0.12621670961380005,
0.800102949142456,
-0.2736969292163849,
-0.466278076171875,
0.4250257909297943,
0.003598918206989765,
-0.38052791357040405,
-0.4465135633945465,
0.18409337103366852,
0.19074784219264984,
0.48871228098869324,
0.24192586541175842,
0.04345548897981644,
0.25941023230552673,
-0.31015342473983765,
0.11009712517261505,
0.8522090315818787,
-0.3501706123352051,
-0.30142727494239807,
0.9582940936088562,
0.1158851683139801,
-0.34865009784698486,
0.5274518728256226,
-0.47041523456573486,
-0.31471651792526245,
0.5072079300880432,
0.7504366040229797,
0.8863279223442078,
-0.5351372361183167,
0.47949251532554626,
0.020085621625185013,
0.1745036542415619,
-0.4147556722164154,
0.04202025383710861,
-0.12625165283679962,
-0.6546230912208557,
-0.4022325873374939,
-0.8908655643463135,
-0.4147352874279022,
0.16860699653625488,
-0.4041246473789215,
0.12309060245752335,
-0.342658668756485,
-0.28209415078163147,
-0.2621353268623352,
-0.2202625423669815,
-0.40763378143310547,
0.09567107260227203,
0.35063332319259644,
0.9784641265869141,
-0.9528329372406006,
0.9754557609558105,
0.2601429522037506,
-0.12736725807189941,
-0.23743124306201935,
-0.023849647492170334,
0.013505231589078903,
-0.7999392151832581,
0.7039089202880859,
-0.2711660861968994,
-0.04856761544942856,
0.27134284377098083,
-0.33428308367729187,
-1.0048530101776123,
0.9906662106513977,
0.2652150094509125,
-0.3560416102409363,
-0.3376134932041168,
-0.2502277195453644,
0.5457609295845032,
-0.37859007716178894,
0.07503862679004669,
0.708831250667572,
0.37314510345458984,
0.2187948077917099,
-0.6108999252319336,
-0.12362904846668243,
-0.1136193498969078,
0.2776208221912384,
0.19786585867404938,
-0.6711249947547913,
0.9261515140533447,
-0.2448238730430603,
-0.3685643672943115,
0.07151369750499725,
0.7759402990341187,
0.2312593013048172,
0.22448614239692688,
0.4653765559196472,
0.9717669486999512,
0.6135601997375488,
0.04518575966358185,
0.9979748129844666,
-0.05031334608793259,
0.39074456691741943,
1.0402339696884155,
-0.775412917137146,
0.7772148847579956,
0.4536817669868469,
-0.5559422969818115,
0.5536988377571106,
0.7748908996582031,
0.11432626843452454,
0.7532935738563538,
0.30877968668937683,
-0.5053742527961731,
-0.0841812714934349,
0.19305726885795593,
-0.4682900011539459,
-0.03543781489133835,
0.56451016664505,
-0.20664115250110626,
-0.3011426627635956,
0.11793994903564453,
-0.12356262654066086,
-0.08706112951040268,
-0.006404801271855831,
0.7763423323631287,
0.3517453372478485,
-0.5242165923118591,
0.35242709517478943,
0.14822034537792206,
0.8830333352088928,
-0.42548277974128723,
0.05182298645377159,
-0.41831687092781067,
-0.08084743469953537,
0.05892181396484375,
-0.6212855577468872,
0.47241467237472534,
-0.007587603759020567,
0.03827633708715439,
-0.5408459305763245,
0.6223918795585632,
-0.49805310368537903,
-0.30260714888572693,
0.18225456774234772,
0.5589392781257629,
0.23600032925605774,
0.2132832258939743,
-0.9015204310417175,
-0.017522329464554787,
-0.13475829362869263,
-0.4984787106513977,
0.5114952921867371,
0.7365787625312805,
0.2813015878200531,
0.7782831788063049,
0.34024888277053833,
0.4408767819404602,
0.21559444069862366,
0.11702531576156616,
0.4854239821434021,
-0.5224251747131348,
-0.48059535026550293,
-0.9649251103401184,
0.31380775570869446,
0.15788160264492035,
-0.1530652493238449,
0.7392363548278809,
0.42227858304977417,
0.4743953049182892,
0.16587617993354797,
0.9256060123443604,
-0.16944465041160583,
0.5991817712783813,
-0.8074902296066284,
0.4016394317150116,
-0.48893293738365173,
0.5504823327064514,
-0.3130076229572296,
-0.8271676301956177,
-0.2679702639579773,
0.6355172991752625,
-0.40187838673591614,
0.2617773115634918,
0.9441686868667603,
0.5765547156333923,
0.09083972871303558,
-0.3247605264186859,
0.3863874673843384,
0.1575009673833847,
0.41018855571746826,
0.5367061495780945,
0.8256041407585144,
-0.2993456721305847,
0.23791314661502838,
-0.04066053405404091,
-0.06507992744445801,
-0.09301750361919403,
-0.9810827374458313,
-0.658866822719574,
-0.8157415986061096,
-0.6735369563102722,
-0.48166409134864807,
-0.07548972964286804,
0.45447269082069397,
0.3604040741920471,
-0.5903275012969971,
-0.10643185675144196,
-0.3530963063240051,
0.22107985615730286,
-0.05853716656565666,
-0.2788849174976349,
0.24367815256118774,
-0.5622847676277161,
-0.6828385591506958,
0.3094085454940796,
0.4788299798965454,
0.5666261911392212,
-0.6230357885360718,
-0.32321080565452576,
-0.10603656619787216,
0.21045103669166565,
0.5549780130386353,
0.27579569816589355,
-0.6599652171134949,
-0.09628905355930328,
-0.12156105786561966,
-0.13243913650512695,
-0.11145198345184326,
0.6267410516738892,
-0.7864459753036499,
0.04179335758090019,
0.430571973323822,
0.5596822500228882,
0.6704492568969727,
-0.06015478074550629,
0.6844779849052429,
-0.5179094672203064,
0.009714959189295769,
0.32140976190567017,
0.27507781982421875,
0.2751671075820923,
-0.19517290592193604,
0.5963236093521118,
0.1644405722618103,
-0.65380859375,
-0.9516985416412354,
0.4644322991371155,
-0.47808653116226196,
-0.32864898443222046,
1.519669532775879,
-0.012539642862975597,
-0.11698190122842789,
-0.3164811134338379,
0.2809774875640869,
-0.09848607331514359,
-0.3701431155204773,
0.6629031300544739,
0.8617075681686401,
-0.16204719245433807,
-0.42147737741470337,
-0.4715079069137573,
0.6867347955703735,
0.4810864329338074,
-0.6900583505630493,
0.26667121052742004,
0.4554882347583771,
0.17636021971702576,
-0.14250652492046356,
1.2835724353790283,
-0.16257989406585693,
0.08397971093654633,
0.06715566664934158,
-0.22607652842998505,
0.28801676630973816,
-0.17682471871376038,
-0.7474194765090942,
0.01537351030856371,
0.2961376905441284,
0.3501080572605133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11464v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11464v1 | Automating Easy Read Text Segmentation | 2024-06-17T12:25:25 | 2024-06-17T12:25:25 | Jesús Calleja, Thierry Etchegoyhen, David Ponce | cs.CL | cs.CL | Easy Read text is one of the main forms of access to information for people
with reading difficulties. One of the key characteristics of this type of text
is the requirement to split sentences into smaller grammatical segments, to
facilitate reading. Automated segmentation methods could foster the creation of
Easy Read content, but their viability has yet to be addressed. In this work,
we study novel methods for the task, leveraging masked and generative language
models, along with constituent parsing. We conduct comprehensive automatic and
human evaluations in three languages, analysing the strengths and weaknesses of
the proposed alternatives, under scarce resource limitations. Our results
highlight the viability of automated ER segmentation and remaining deficiencies
compared to expert-driven human segmentation. | [
-0.2616395354270935,
-0.9446883201599121,
0.8282880187034607,
0.23687778413295746,
-0.48299962282180786,
0.042708076536655426,
-0.007903976365923882,
-0.7507225871086121,
-0.0324602834880352,
0.524188220500946,
-0.6105024814605713,
-0.41666924953460693,
-0.3047906756401062,
0.875069260597229,
-0.4837319552898407,
0.5677024126052856,
-0.09720855951309204,
-0.1577744334936142,
-0.06866583973169327,
-0.17995312809944153,
-0.5697338581085205,
-0.5508983731269836,
-0.5078154802322388,
-0.08155093342065811,
0.2225760519504547,
0.6109256744384766,
0.5895224213600159,
1.39125394821167,
0.5646485686302185,
0.3704034686088562,
-0.20502693951129913,
0.3490740954875946,
0.3170577585697174,
0.5302944779396057,
0.03595203533768654,
-0.4013213515281677,
-0.1201675608754158,
-0.27281391620635986,
0.6200951933860779,
0.8878993988037109,
-0.07266569882631302,
-0.2982258200645447,
0.10541611909866333,
0.9066355228424072,
-0.40667763352394104,
-0.009141593240201473,
-0.3201070725917816,
0.0997033640742302,
-0.32119426131248474,
0.35500314831733704,
-0.5090348720550537,
-0.24046649038791656,
0.25032541155815125,
-0.49696630239486694,
0.42042985558509827,
0.4262832999229431,
0.9735557436943054,
0.4321456551551819,
-0.3757191300392151,
-0.8755447864532471,
-0.48061564564704895,
0.7485558986663818,
-0.33212515711784363,
0.42873093485832214,
0.48501503467559814,
0.18846534192562103,
0.29558366537094116,
-0.487477570772171,
-0.5567177534103394,
-0.24440215528011322,
-0.420246958732605,
-0.18224383890628815,
-0.20956085622310638,
-0.010735886171460152,
0.09396402537822723,
0.45629850029945374,
-0.4176514446735382,
0.13622581958770752,
-0.20376630127429962,
-0.24536871910095215,
0.5019010305404663,
0.2181684523820877,
0.7992176413536072,
-0.8612331748008728,
-0.18355518579483032,
-0.049963001161813736,
-0.2942734360694885,
-0.17738549411296844,
0.4768759310245514,
0.14807558059692383,
0.026712145656347275,
0.7271000146865845,
-0.2076401710510254,
0.9813185334205627,
-0.09785386919975281,
-0.007100533694028854,
0.10249599069356918,
-0.38684698939323425,
-0.3928321301937103,
-0.19237683713436127,
0.5524289011955261,
-0.04720098152756691,
0.13462959229946136,
-0.1214427798986435,
-0.2566746473312378,
-0.318394273519516,
0.0753108337521553,
-0.3803413212299347,
-0.35276997089385986,
0.23705030977725983,
-0.5391705632209778,
-0.051304593682289124,
-0.0023131913039833307,
-0.8996541500091553,
-0.37082427740097046,
-0.3184141218662262,
0.15754100680351257,
-0.7203721404075623,
0.38155123591423035,
0.37490618228912354,
-0.1819998025894165,
0.14584866166114807,
0.7081795334815979,
-1.0344713926315308,
0.33065828680992126,
0.44413670897483826,
1.06267249584198,
-0.28733742237091064,
0.04411003738641739,
-0.39420685172080994,
0.07456392049789429,
0.25795790553092957,
1.2665975093841553,
-0.3013315796852112,
-0.11142964661121368,
-0.18703827261924744,
0.11882548779249191,
-0.5323325991630554,
-0.4928516447544098,
0.5959663987159729,
-0.34457817673683167,
0.1623867005109787,
0.08495885878801346,
-0.30649852752685547,
-0.1551799476146698,
0.31359103322029114,
-1.2621374130249023,
0.6220110058784485,
0.023500431329011917,
-0.5808531641960144,
0.23516908288002014,
-0.5721525549888611,
-0.7147502899169922,
-0.007222465239465237,
0.09248910844326019,
-0.5976210832595825,
0.039501629769802094,
0.8162271976470947,
0.24815921485424042,
-0.026074595749378204,
-0.2986752390861511,
0.13181400299072266,
0.359155535697937,
0.18334722518920898,
-0.559417188167572,
0.783040463924408,
0.4237537682056427,
-0.4903322160243988,
0.23617716133594513,
-0.8669974207878113,
0.01556648500263691,
-0.042743269354104996,
-0.33577394485473633,
-0.5280935764312744,
0.33689233660697937,
0.3079396188259125,
-0.1251561939716339,
-0.06293947249650955,
-0.41888827085494995,
0.26062285900115967,
-0.48858940601348877,
0.3801649808883667,
0.5652749538421631,
0.04950115084648132,
0.5521907210350037,
0.006516064051538706,
0.6308405995368958,
-0.11822354048490524,
0.09377362579107285,
-0.6134856343269348,
-0.3583650588989258,
-1.2544986009597778,
-0.8407487273216248,
0.6451447606086731,
0.778137743473053,
-0.9283882975578308,
0.5003106594085693,
0.24431614577770233,
-0.13320119678974152,
-0.5741016864776611,
0.34007754921913147,
0.5054510235786438,
0.2816838026046753,
0.24317075312137604,
-0.2646607756614685,
-0.3348829448223114,
-0.993911862373352,
-0.261191725730896,
-0.08339981734752655,
-0.12545578181743622,
0.11547423154115677,
0.2555347681045532,
-0.2533251941204071,
0.8750876188278198,
-0.7648966908454895,
-0.44968491792678833,
-0.7329819202423096,
0.10420817136764526,
-0.2183305025100708,
0.4153067171573639,
0.14889058470726013,
-0.6516932845115662,
-0.6331146955490112,
0.060143958777189255,
-0.6714661717414856,
-0.3305330276489258,
-0.1919601857662201,
-0.00864674337208271,
0.14335407316684723,
0.6376575231552124,
-0.2744613587856293,
0.41450032591819763,
0.026829374954104424,
-0.4878779649734497,
0.27763301134109497,
-0.29121604561805725,
-0.007407533936202526,
-0.6770777106285095,
-0.11262529343366623,
0.27706533670425415,
-0.7131239771842957,
-0.5311985611915588,
0.4031156599521637,
0.08004701882600784,
-0.11250770837068558,
-0.3792162835597992,
0.39557671546936035,
-1.0986542701721191,
0.05586616322398186,
-0.10951025038957596,
-0.06481238454580307,
0.16394948959350586,
0.020478464663028717,
0.3175947368144989,
0.4325409531593323,
0.0005973004153929651,
-0.36734119057655334,
0.01453372836112976,
0.48833924531936646,
-0.5139175057411194,
0.48192596435546875,
-0.6179261803627014,
0.24578198790550232,
-0.24220944941043854,
0.002782906871289015,
-0.9271109104156494,
-0.6081830263137817,
0.5195116996765137,
0.1801358014345169,
0.0949823185801506,
-0.054670628160238266,
-0.5380716323852539,
0.047879479825496674,
-0.11685159802436829,
0.5476921200752258,
0.15668998658657074,
-0.4009632468223572,
0.5560960173606873,
0.48490384221076965,
-0.596211314201355,
0.007164923474192619,
-0.5639799237251282,
0.1327991634607315,
-0.20794369280338287,
-0.8204402923583984,
0.17196550965309143,
0.11568925529718399,
-0.4758985936641693,
-0.0688566043972969,
0.1971975564956665,
-0.46778830885887146,
0.030604025349020958,
0.059442322701215744,
0.198166623711586,
-0.019207030534744263,
0.04566517844796181,
0.08472654968500137,
-0.2632688581943512,
-0.5309107899665833,
0.10328274965286255,
0.44268345832824707,
-0.23116788268089294,
-0.40134257078170776,
-0.42680084705352783,
0.7921303510665894,
0.2559123933315277,
-0.3613300025463104,
0.39153099060058594,
0.2503032088279724,
-0.38819682598114014,
-0.4102320671081543,
-0.5329698324203491,
0.2496761679649353,
-0.4601992964744568,
0.13325397670269012,
-0.2975730299949646,
-0.901460587978363,
0.41666316986083984,
0.25920262932777405,
-0.13190476596355438,
0.7157966494560242,
0.33389556407928467,
-0.1832341104745865,
1.0169453620910645,
0.7612987756729126,
0.3210594356060028,
0.37826621532440186,
0.1953907310962677,
0.18109363317489624,
-0.5049005150794983,
-0.3127664625644684,
-0.8857320547103882,
-0.03355550765991211,
-0.1141512542963028,
-0.44351673126220703,
0.2853999137878418,
0.08807969093322754,
0.39710089564323425,
0.24510005116462708,
-0.8263339996337891,
0.7825693488121033,
0.4345651865005493,
0.165381520986557,
0.6130902171134949,
0.26786234974861145,
-0.20162340998649597,
-0.08096887171268463,
-0.5298237204551697,
-0.8756349682807922,
0.5198943018913269,
0.6598487496376038,
0.7933933138847351,
-0.08183562755584717,
0.5904494524002075,
0.6151093244552612,
0.2945044934749603,
-1.242663860321045,
0.5215332508087158,
-0.2585549056529999,
-0.6367266178131104,
-0.7184597253799438,
-0.23051826655864716,
-0.9029643535614014,
0.456189900636673,
0.08866975456476212,
-0.5675288438796997,
0.5257145166397095,
0.02145261876285076,
-0.6812763214111328,
0.1169578805565834,
-1.237092137336731,
0.8664281368255615,
-0.13773438334465027,
0.0849473625421524,
0.3291133642196655,
-0.6960024237632751,
0.052979301661252975,
-0.12012253701686859,
0.4526863694190979,
0.010327302850782871,
-0.1173945888876915,
0.8834517002105713,
-0.7935173511505127,
0.6986215114593506,
0.20706652104854584,
-0.009832225739955902,
0.5129225850105286,
-0.006111326161772013,
0.2240866869688034,
-0.13787513971328735,
-0.09637171030044556,
-0.11008413881063461,
0.016116218641400337,
-0.35216161608695984,
-0.32652905583381653,
0.07298677414655685,
-0.5528465509414673,
-0.32532817125320435,
-0.6790891289710999,
-0.14674100279808044,
-0.14255604147911072,
0.400228887796402,
0.1781051605939865,
0.3103727400302887,
-0.3210822343826294,
-0.08345647156238556,
0.43543413281440735,
-0.07827199995517731,
0.7191895842552185,
0.4402725100517273,
0.1340806931257248,
-0.6660020351409912,
0.7839151620864868,
-0.08652713894844055,
0.06931089609861374,
0.2267623096704483,
0.020178185775876045,
-0.44268620014190674,
-0.7504572868347168,
-0.8600144386291504,
0.17820429801940918,
-0.634299099445343,
-0.06285607069730759,
-0.7791748046875,
-0.04388879984617233,
-0.06295901536941528,
-0.3379722833633423,
-0.05973854660987854,
-0.5409399271011353,
-0.4671532213687897,
-0.20555759966373444,
-0.22658070921897888,
0.9027774930000305,
-0.01433519460260868,
0.6072410345077515,
-0.8249309062957764,
0.4484249949455261,
0.38222941756248474,
0.09364975243806839,
-0.2584456205368042,
0.00743842264637351,
-0.28560367226600647,
-0.4808730483055115,
-0.44342657923698425,
-1.068633794784546,
0.6179688572883606,
0.2567298710346222,
0.1637900322675705,
0.3273535966873169,
0.06161947548389435,
0.5440073013305664,
-0.7630613446235657,
0.5731678009033203,
0.2510484755039215,
-1.1962015628814697,
0.519833505153656,
-0.21460695564746857,
0.27216383814811707,
0.9699960947036743,
0.15383432805538177,
-0.5369768738746643,
-0.2790120542049408,
-0.1482355147600174,
-1.0228471755981445,
0.8331004977226257,
0.3885960280895233,
-0.1338653713464737,
-0.24948568642139435,
0.20565448701381683,
0.46848228573799133,
-0.10571985691785812,
-0.803311824798584,
-0.032887354493141174,
-0.0419272780418396,
-0.40779075026512146,
0.0015188379911705852,
-0.4086366891860962,
0.2210077941417694,
-0.13500943779945374,
0.3800497055053711,
0.07617907226085663,
0.1771494448184967,
0.5007742643356323,
-0.6263048648834229,
-0.020828120410442352,
0.6330000758171082,
0.4475124776363373,
0.46132051944732666,
-0.1274092197418213,
0.23976314067840576,
-0.30972597002983093,
-0.7167542576789856,
0.6338424682617188,
0.3425089120864868,
-0.47591254115104675,
0.21559756994247437,
0.4726184010505676,
0.6198171973228455,
-0.09733329713344574,
-0.6775827407836914,
0.21686582267284393,
-0.13993526995182037,
-0.1569322645664215,
-0.09819591790437698,
-0.019134266301989555,
-0.28295543789863586,
0.07810597121715546,
0.40321239829063416,
0.013332967646420002,
0.20500651001930237,
-0.4587436020374298,
0.3157087564468384,
0.02362731099128723,
-0.41970616579055786,
-0.14554980397224426,
0.41872015595436096,
0.6895224452018738,
-0.5494405031204224,
0.7865655422210693,
-0.40006396174430847,
-0.5866826176643372,
0.6706818342208862,
0.3235110342502594,
1.0608042478561401,
-0.1057363972067833,
0.4635864794254303,
-0.08882740885019302,
0.7004460692405701,
-0.006337282247841358,
-0.041193485260009766,
-0.03922320157289505,
-0.579184353351593,
-0.49857059121131897,
-0.7545086145401001,
-0.4720066487789154,
-0.05956525355577469,
-0.5452462434768677,
0.11304866522550583,
-0.33402395248413086,
-0.04064098745584488,
0.36831870675086975,
-0.28753554821014404,
-0.7080678939819336,
0.5006712079048157,
-0.017527353018522263,
0.701579213142395,
-0.878296971321106,
0.40253546833992004,
0.7840443253517151,
-0.39215660095214844,
-0.5665793418884277,
0.3202965557575226,
-0.11227453500032425,
-0.6049543023109436,
0.4985610842704773,
0.41840267181396484,
0.06360150873661041,
0.04955874755978584,
-0.19875001907348633,
-0.43438664078712463,
0.5379254221916199,
0.1503802239894867,
-0.6560994982719421,
-0.4988890588283539,
0.2697349488735199,
0.4538350999355316,
-0.19406837224960327,
0.2916201055049896,
0.6575863361358643,
0.6336026191711426,
-0.14039333164691925,
-0.7848845720291138,
0.024602852761745453,
-0.23544837534427643,
-0.2636811137199402,
0.2255723625421524,
-0.4909769296646118,
0.574074387550354,
-0.0032129520550370216,
-0.46277686953544617,
0.203283429145813,
0.6150231957435608,
-0.22031931579113007,
0.5650771260261536,
1.0753241777420044,
0.5986039638519287,
0.6629342436790466,
-0.02576708421111107,
0.9838091731071472,
0.18109208345413208,
0.23950070142745972,
0.7147306799888611,
-0.21543572843074799,
0.6940547823905945,
0.2990127205848694,
-0.3114149570465088,
0.6798442602157593,
0.6239984035491943,
0.021794995293021202,
0.47628822922706604,
0.13171645998954773,
-0.4154994785785675,
-0.5162224173545837,
0.06684670597314835,
-0.012494581751525402,
0.5487421751022339,
0.1778072863817215,
-0.43895769119262695,
-0.3528063893318176,
0.2461612969636917,
-0.03769654780626297,
0.11034048348665237,
-0.15650290250778198,
0.9354045391082764,
0.04664580523967743,
-0.6950333714485168,
0.039994604885578156,
0.5149092674255371,
0.4362565875053406,
-0.4086756706237793,
0.040966734290122986,
-0.07600278407335281,
-0.09158036857843399,
-0.23736339807510376,
-0.54788738489151,
0.655778706073761,
0.47857362031936646,
-0.2982029318809509,
-0.32820940017700195,
1.0402215719223022,
-0.14392128586769104,
-0.6466726660728455,
-0.1896747201681137,
0.8327222466468811,
0.12719891965389252,
-0.16229493916034698,
-0.5642753839492798,
0.10486997663974762,
0.289923757314682,
-0.22006343305110931,
0.04025788977742195,
0.47576677799224854,
-0.034152351319789886,
0.6000503897666931,
0.4645598232746124,
-0.10330801457166672,
0.06786798685789108,
-0.09010062366724014,
0.543724775314331,
-0.890692412853241,
-0.7862630486488342,
-1.0871378183364868,
0.6318223476409912,
-0.12039373070001602,
-0.15940499305725098,
0.8769662380218506,
0.6573707461357117,
0.290729820728302,
-0.14883147180080414,
0.8871124982833862,
-0.07261538505554199,
0.5366401672363281,
-0.5726344585418701,
0.8587378263473511,
-0.3362775444984436,
0.24239185452461243,
-0.35908597707748413,
-0.8800351023674011,
-0.523827075958252,
0.711543083190918,
-0.41934359073638916,
-0.2988804578781128,
0.8580188155174255,
0.30115434527397156,
-0.16819724440574646,
-0.15393634140491486,
0.197477325797081,
-0.29046958684921265,
0.2456555962562561,
0.1360151618719101,
0.8718118071556091,
-0.019966179504990578,
0.631830632686615,
-0.21759897470474243,
-0.38568198680877686,
-0.33220335841178894,
-0.8694891333580017,
-0.9691900014877319,
-0.39461982250213623,
-0.40749427676200867,
-0.3088220953941345,
0.19584499299526215,
0.6794655323028564,
0.6032891869544983,
-0.7242021560668945,
-0.06654848903417587,
-0.1953902542591095,
0.4653117060661316,
0.0998237207531929,
-0.20684869587421417,
0.6125865578651428,
-0.3997255563735962,
-0.8721562623977661,
0.3630748689174652,
0.4971762001514435,
0.08489727228879929,
-0.20759375393390656,
0.3169623911380768,
-0.032165758311748505,
0.262397438287735,
0.585607647895813,
0.545272707939148,
-0.39721810817718506,
-0.187631294131279,
0.0627606213092804,
-0.29243558645248413,
0.12023597210645676,
0.8796772956848145,
-0.45002925395965576,
0.6623231768608093,
0.5125672817230225,
0.6778762340545654,
0.27122431993484497,
0.47198906540870667,
0.5152387022972107,
-0.45335853099823,
0.015475873835384846,
0.30124181509017944,
0.32900017499923706,
0.4866540729999542,
-0.23216784000396729,
0.4024398624897003,
0.3223875164985657,
-0.4399067461490631,
-0.7634261846542358,
0.1897762268781662,
-1.0430747270584106,
-0.26366734504699707,
1.0634875297546387,
-0.19878490269184113,
-0.512526273727417,
-0.620088517665863,
-0.6509726047515869,
0.07680778205394745,
-0.16712887585163116,
0.6673307418823242,
0.8885183930397034,
-0.2650858759880066,
-0.18677619099617004,
-0.261624276638031,
0.4853803515434265,
0.5792803168296814,
-1.1759123802185059,
-0.21893781423568726,
0.8805723786354065,
0.29328638315200806,
0.02955472655594349,
0.7031421065330505,
0.07693401724100113,
0.026409918442368507,
-0.041712671518325806,
-0.09020226448774338,
-0.13773469626903534,
-0.3662082552909851,
-0.49834707379341125,
0.5078573226928711,
-0.09528598189353943,
-0.2245854288339615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11460v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11460v1 | TRACE the Evidence: Constructing Knowledge-Grounded Reasoning Chains for Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-17T12:23:32 | 2024-06-17T12:23:32 | Jinyuan Fang, Zaiqiao Meng, Craig Macdonald | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) offers an effective approach for
addressing question answering (QA) tasks. However, the imperfections of the
retrievers in RAG models often result in the retrieval of irrelevant
information, which could introduce noises and degrade the performance,
especially when handling multi-hop questions that require multiple steps of
reasoning. To enhance the multi-hop reasoning ability of RAG models, we propose
TRACE. TRACE constructs knowledge-grounded reasoning chains, which are a series
of logically connected knowledge triples, to identify and integrate supporting
evidence from the retrieved documents for answering questions. Specifically,
TRACE employs a KG Generator to create a knowledge graph (KG) from the
retrieved documents, and then uses an Autoregressive Reasoning Chain
Constructor to build reasoning chains. Experimental results on three multi-hop
QA datasets show that TRACE achieves an average performance improvement of up
to 14.03% compared to using all the retrieved documents. Moreover, the results
indicate that using reasoning chains as context, rather than the entire
documents, is often sufficient to correctly answer questions. | [
-0.33504894375801086,
-0.6732979416847229,
0.9724637866020203,
-0.3514387011528015,
-0.18487052619457245,
0.4814019501209259,
0.5672009587287903,
-0.42071962356567383,
0.38327983021736145,
0.5000366568565369,
-0.2500115633010864,
-0.15408194065093994,
-0.47661951184272766,
-0.1667606234550476,
-0.4962937831878662,
0.9547721743583679,
0.023340927436947823,
-0.1615968942642212,
-0.2510222792625427,
-0.3059729337692261,
-0.6026738882064819,
-0.36136308312416077,
-0.5299244523048401,
-0.20074595510959625,
0.6105130910873413,
0.3791598379611969,
0.462657630443573,
0.9432029128074646,
0.22644293308258057,
0.16983091831207275,
-0.1537119299173355,
0.5719704627990723,
-0.5268540382385254,
0.46706143021583557,
-0.37181687355041504,
-0.3390812277793884,
-0.5294580459594727,
-0.12083683907985687,
0.6140127778053284,
0.5089870095252991,
0.11605103313922882,
0.6270586848258972,
-0.15471366047859192,
0.8271170258522034,
-0.9431502223014832,
-0.20972993969917297,
-0.6225878596305847,
-0.4530336856842041,
-0.04608360305428505,
-0.574140727519989,
-0.5846656560897827,
-0.498638391494751,
0.03089947998523712,
-0.8521600365638733,
0.1682976484298706,
0.28973183035850525,
0.9271278381347656,
0.09068205952644348,
-0.8177639842033386,
-0.5092517137527466,
-0.7280796766281128,
0.4661773145198822,
-0.47844791412353516,
0.30581745505332947,
0.4310421347618103,
0.4444260001182556,
-0.19356504082679749,
-0.9623841047286987,
-0.33758246898651123,
0.13848046958446503,
-0.2510760724544525,
0.11814168095588684,
0.23846854269504547,
-0.1338319182395935,
0.642392098903656,
0.45144927501678467,
-0.2975824177265167,
-0.7141571044921875,
-0.27338993549346924,
-0.19801507890224457,
0.4522179365158081,
0.10082125663757324,
0.3149847090244293,
-0.24489465355873108,
-0.19956746697425842,
-0.060927290469408035,
-0.6575794219970703,
0.1088278591632843,
0.3440123200416565,
0.12764140963554382,
0.43140023946762085,
0.557212769985199,
-0.32616227865219116,
1.0211055278778076,
0.17644387483596802,
-0.3158584535121918,
0.006159129086881876,
-0.310846745967865,
0.10550147294998169,
0.04005932807922363,
0.20516924560070038,
0.15134914219379425,
-0.0924384668469429,
-0.05511494353413582,
0.09957834333181381,
-0.07120141386985779,
0.31778255105018616,
-0.8668562769889832,
-0.42951667308807373,
0.09601593017578125,
-0.5259868502616882,
-0.310769647359848,
-0.055511265993118286,
-0.7721322178840637,
-0.6655952334403992,
-0.20898541808128357,
0.7185789346694946,
-0.5530702471733093,
-0.5101105570793152,
0.006953207775950432,
-0.6705458164215088,
0.39303603768348694,
0.3246820867061615,
-0.35413774847984314,
0.40442895889282227,
0.5764225125312805,
0.555077850818634,
0.3653934597969055,
-0.03424619883298874,
-1.0728106498718262,
0.5151296854019165,
-0.4664270579814911,
0.9251471757888794,
-0.4783257246017456,
-0.10348059237003326,
-0.23552162945270538,
0.00938446819782257,
-0.13269418478012085,
-0.2883129417896271,
0.566268801689148,
-0.8457797169685364,
0.30765172839164734,
-0.6735110878944397,
-0.7833999991416931,
-0.5397975444793701,
0.5387991666793823,
-0.7802222967147827,
1.1476402282714844,
0.049402907490730286,
-1.134225845336914,
0.20642156898975372,
-0.32254526019096375,
-0.5108004808425903,
-0.037423186004161835,
-0.10107739269733429,
-0.16121742129325867,
-0.01834455132484436,
0.305378258228302,
0.010187954641878605,
-0.2973519265651703,
0.2750513553619385,
-0.27898693084716797,
-0.384441077709198,
-0.054646268486976624,
0.04373808577656746,
0.9587560892105103,
0.18051786720752716,
-0.3738498389720917,
-0.15233178436756134,
-1.2264361381530762,
0.2860414981842041,
0.022159479558467865,
-0.3224170207977295,
-0.8155054450035095,
0.4703528881072998,
-0.5605236887931824,
0.28191474080085754,
-0.25512927770614624,
-0.4096211791038513,
0.07244822382926941,
-0.12788620591163635,
-0.12125054746866226,
0.7136964797973633,
0.46860241889953613,
0.13753792643547058,
-0.5993738770484924,
0.5729098320007324,
-0.10408997535705566,
-0.17878901958465576,
-0.53144770860672,
-0.7391822934150696,
-0.9260995984077454,
-0.09006380289793015,
0.27139896154403687,
0.3975878655910492,
-0.8210358023643494,
0.01989886164665222,
-0.2905600368976593,
-0.3421609699726105,
-0.47007080912590027,
-0.08712434768676758,
0.4242655336856842,
1.0942312479019165,
0.5080780386924744,
0.080586738884449,
-0.7918240427970886,
-0.4531553089618683,
-0.674167275428772,
-0.43428874015808105,
-0.12450350821018219,
0.4358990490436554,
0.4602789282798767,
0.04734029620885849,
1.0349326133728027,
-0.5753248929977417,
0.22934521734714508,
0.11094282567501068,
0.20759692788124084,
0.16483362019062042,
0.3993587791919708,
0.22302593290805817,
-0.7374238967895508,
-0.4071717858314514,
-0.02881423383951187,
-0.7420638799667358,
-0.011153941042721272,
-0.017514724284410477,
-0.566361129283905,
-0.1787983775138855,
0.344929039478302,
-0.3958841562271118,
0.3981926441192627,
0.21929818391799927,
-0.9122869372367859,
0.6289278268814087,
0.12671582400798798,
0.4098907709121704,
-1.093530297279358,
0.5224426984786987,
-0.6198875904083252,
-0.4106243848800659,
-0.524378776550293,
0.1325768232345581,
0.030674654990434647,
-0.10858000069856644,
0.02940508723258972,
0.6018232703208923,
-0.6157496571540833,
-0.22198165953159332,
-0.21553434431552887,
0.20118805766105652,
0.6089825630187988,
0.16855916380882263,
-0.14550185203552246,
0.7634113430976868,
0.3267287611961365,
-0.8020420074462891,
0.04298018291592598,
0.16333436965942383,
0.0006240438669919968,
0.7326870560646057,
-0.3681966960430145,
0.38275179266929626,
-0.24099333584308624,
0.20924396812915802,
-1.0143862962722778,
-0.21727295219898224,
0.06534118950366974,
-0.6458333134651184,
0.3129488229751587,
-0.3497850000858307,
-0.22900068759918213,
-0.32284584641456604,
-0.240186408162117,
0.45227232575416565,
0.5584436058998108,
-0.6976722478866577,
1.3139525651931763,
0.23951071500778198,
0.40737226605415344,
-0.6508208513259888,
-0.15361301600933075,
-0.09389007836580276,
-0.2584972381591797,
-0.6985747218132019,
-0.04302424192428589,
-0.09533978253602982,
-0.22755910456180573,
0.22875002026557922,
-0.3746308982372284,
-0.03089144080877304,
0.24179306626319885,
0.08564464002847672,
0.03983794152736664,
-0.29803821444511414,
0.36032092571258545,
-0.02928493544459343,
-0.13737937808036804,
0.26184096932411194,
-0.43069711327552795,
0.22032298147678375,
-0.018809933215379715,
-0.3365810215473175,
0.08797843754291534,
0.31640735268592834,
0.6709403991699219,
-0.3586895763874054,
0.557734489440918,
0.39690616726875305,
-0.2523782551288605,
-0.21276704967021942,
-0.771916925907135,
-0.1381208747625351,
-0.38565412163734436,
-0.13168837130069733,
-0.7108238935470581,
-0.6679092645645142,
0.7159715890884399,
-0.4841863512992859,
-0.08038048446178436,
0.670968770980835,
0.011721070855855942,
-0.12813939154148102,
1.1089529991149902,
0.22899870574474335,
0.18795683979988098,
0.026992542669177055,
-0.15973295271396637,
0.1520656794309616,
-1.1047104597091675,
-0.2354910671710968,
-0.6718918085098267,
-0.04124614596366882,
-0.3284915089607239,
-0.49679267406463623,
0.34240391850471497,
0.6045912504196167,
-0.509791910648346,
0.055852193385362625,
-0.47514641284942627,
0.35720670223236084,
0.704028844833374,
0.1411851942539215,
0.5430304408073425,
-0.1179359033703804,
-0.24289415776729584,
0.32876449823379517,
-0.9023582935333252,
-0.3651580214500427,
1.1797908544540405,
0.21175517141819,
0.5233430862426758,
0.04989943653345108,
0.5530825257301331,
0.11847302317619324,
0.22982904314994812,
-0.5536900758743286,
0.4625299870967865,
0.2630922496318817,
-0.9996573328971863,
0.056236352771520615,
-0.4306545853614807,
-0.6086001992225647,
0.3408653736114502,
-0.18262234330177307,
-0.47922006249427795,
0.15775851905345917,
0.37357673048973083,
-0.17637404799461365,
0.5661928653717041,
-0.6138925552368164,
0.5971987247467041,
-0.0858139917254448,
-0.4275762736797333,
-0.024131257086992264,
-0.8133596181869507,
0.6109711527824402,
0.12333638966083527,
0.2651640772819519,
0.14603908360004425,
0.35975536704063416,
0.9089208841323853,
-0.5455938577651978,
0.37431973218917847,
-0.3750465512275696,
0.040643781423568726,
0.8996151089668274,
0.3714231550693512,
0.9175188541412354,
-0.007169803604483604,
0.025075213983654976,
-0.4009356200695038,
0.08730766177177429,
-0.3766738176345825,
-0.7835173010826111,
0.3888118267059326,
-0.3106429874897003,
-0.555870532989502,
-0.45155268907546997,
-0.617323637008667,
-0.33603692054748535,
0.5728943943977356,
-0.02608157880604267,
0.6131187081336975,
0.1875009834766388,
0.1125616654753685,
0.9776645302772522,
-0.12466593831777573,
0.11246063560247421,
0.5225996375083923,
-0.37775298953056335,
-0.6255484819412231,
0.954083263874054,
0.04664665088057518,
0.3818933367729187,
0.3264598250389099,
0.4151182174682617,
-0.32787784934043884,
-0.22213368117809296,
-0.6346849203109741,
0.214021697640419,
-0.8534711003303528,
-0.3520187735557556,
-0.9222573041915894,
-0.16488389670848846,
-0.34316131472587585,
-0.026020290330052376,
-0.2089090496301651,
-0.55573570728302,
-0.02294895239174366,
-0.24610355496406555,
0.5930522680282593,
0.5842030644416809,
0.012471121735870838,
0.057246219366788864,
-0.8249330520629883,
0.8335268497467041,
0.6126251816749573,
0.4580267369747162,
0.10700751841068268,
-0.48305511474609375,
-0.21062681078910828,
-0.05709387734532356,
-0.17909570038318634,
-1.1199345588684082,
-0.08625798672437668,
-0.06918547302484512,
0.4471189081668854,
0.3732721209526062,
0.18600115180015564,
1.14225172996521,
-0.47607824206352234,
0.5285142064094543,
-0.1157619059085846,
-0.8903816938400269,
0.7719455361366272,
-0.7128499150276184,
0.11664673686027527,
0.5408955812454224,
0.30128514766693115,
-0.22036892175674438,
-0.43446266651153564,
-0.8170852065086365,
-0.7409764528274536,
0.5118485689163208,
0.14760729670524597,
-0.5680849552154541,
-0.1399148404598236,
0.4018784761428833,
-0.21494922041893005,
0.1479543149471283,
-0.5052198171615601,
-0.3427527844905853,
-0.16852709650993347,
-0.011172694154083729,
0.5085180997848511,
-0.7116447687149048,
-0.30679747462272644,
-0.2116992473602295,
0.7771484851837158,
-0.24361427128314972,
0.17388476431369781,
0.37752199172973633,
-0.05157526209950447,
-0.14845111966133118,
0.08156069368124008,
0.24676142632961273,
1.0269548892974854,
-0.5693020820617676,
0.5154100656509399,
-0.0742400735616684,
-0.4891827404499054,
0.3264086842536926,
0.020183414220809937,
-0.5684713125228882,
0.08425886183977127,
0.47109049558639526,
0.4852074086666107,
-0.22945980727672577,
-0.5288978815078735,
0.32673871517181396,
0.0791468545794487,
-0.11951276659965515,
-0.21446332335472107,
-0.026492338627576828,
0.09794661402702332,
0.18457670509815216,
0.5174235701560974,
0.0749993622303009,
0.4802246689796448,
-0.462903767824173,
0.3562709391117096,
0.2847616970539093,
-0.1310114860534668,
-0.08706041425466537,
0.6888090372085571,
0.022034786641597748,
-0.1548595279455185,
0.6139614582061768,
-0.22330467402935028,
-0.6477677822113037,
0.6939542889595032,
0.6546928882598877,
0.8027816414833069,
-0.23019848763942719,
0.09894951432943344,
0.8020371198654175,
0.32091373205184937,
-0.2283395379781723,
0.4857994616031647,
-0.09357215464115143,
-0.4168519675731659,
-0.6288801431655884,
-0.454290509223938,
-0.095641128718853,
-0.17774558067321777,
-0.852769136428833,
0.0630122572183609,
-0.1928478479385376,
0.05507134646177292,
-0.36767300963401794,
-0.05711011588573456,
-0.39110156893730164,
0.40918153524398804,
-0.22169442474842072,
0.8186254501342773,
-0.7785569429397583,
0.4862285852432251,
0.5852240920066833,
-0.44382721185684204,
-1.2283895015716553,
-0.1210443302989006,
-0.06965485215187073,
-0.5070456266403198,
0.6300099492073059,
0.17521412670612335,
-0.40299129486083984,
0.20476257801055908,
-0.35496851801872253,
-1.2220137119293213,
1.2194021940231323,
0.12546825408935547,
-0.04456968232989311,
0.060290660709142685,
-0.4180675745010376,
0.34269967675209045,
-0.23908354341983795,
0.5721134543418884,
0.3972693979740143,
0.39023664593696594,
0.3784073293209076,
-0.4126657545566559,
0.366226464509964,
-0.33295369148254395,
-0.18656592071056366,
0.3680575489997864,
-0.3890075385570526,
0.7968903183937073,
-0.210553377866745,
-0.4975410997867584,
-0.09838824719190598,
0.496166467666626,
0.7664433121681213,
0.6452823877334595,
0.5952981114387512,
0.8934356570243835,
1.1059496402740479,
0.07202368229627609,
1.0609867572784424,
-0.379158079624176,
0.03768499568104744,
1.4932501316070557,
-0.18412363529205322,
0.5852108001708984,
0.5204759836196899,
0.005023968406021595,
1.1098206043243408,
0.31362977623939514,
0.3837999999523163,
0.34123265743255615,
0.22353465855121613,
-0.1828858107328415,
-0.33453428745269775,
-0.2041832059621811,
-0.5182009339332581,
0.11506584286689758,
0.3672756850719452,
-0.3236193358898163,
-0.19060947000980377,
-0.3606506884098053,
0.09454654902219772,
0.06311994791030884,
-0.3201792538166046,
0.5927050709724426,
-0.2738024592399597,
-0.8624937534332275,
0.5508843064308167,
-0.3390829861164093,
-0.05381148308515549,
-0.589588463306427,
-0.575363039970398,
-0.35187631845474243,
-0.03348715603351593,
-0.32437747716903687,
-0.4853006899356842,
0.29603686928749084,
-0.1007537841796875,
-0.4551791548728943,
-0.1369427889585495,
1.130455732345581,
-0.10861983895301819,
-0.47429797053337097,
0.3263539969921112,
0.5837613940238953,
0.09107351303100586,
-0.08333220332860947,
-0.28767213225364685,
-0.2684544622898102,
-0.1302512288093567,
-0.39080917835235596,
0.07929946482181549,
0.7444965243339539,
-0.16649021208286285,
0.7145692110061646,
0.8384321928024292,
-0.0598519966006279,
0.39255261421203613,
-0.13875554502010345,
1.1221537590026855,
-0.8232555389404297,
-0.4959600567817688,
-0.5082363486289978,
0.8266680240631104,
-0.3519373834133148,
0.05325612053275108,
1.1019282341003418,
0.8493185639381409,
0.43223094940185547,
0.14231862127780914,
0.511777937412262,
-0.411699116230011,
1.255854845046997,
-0.4257098436355591,
0.38735637068748474,
-0.5012754201889038,
0.266939640045166,
-0.3338574171066284,
-0.6185251474380493,
-0.007557391654700041,
0.4184124171733856,
0.17173512279987335,
-0.04359693452715874,
0.9508960843086243,
0.5280175805091858,
-0.03642962500452995,
-0.13294953107833862,
-0.09549934417009354,
0.10852284729480743,
0.5498477816581726,
0.49875128269195557,
0.9270380735397339,
-0.9314513802528381,
0.614861011505127,
-0.08736155927181244,
-0.1516202986240387,
0.23995304107666016,
-1.0222965478897095,
-0.8311752080917358,
-0.30859991908073425,
-0.1876358538866043,
-0.8951082825660706,
0.03222991153597832,
0.06910581886768341,
0.5009098052978516,
-0.5881580114364624,
-0.1060054674744606,
-0.38296833634376526,
0.5019788146018982,
-0.42734408378601074,
-0.2745293378829956,
0.6627532839775085,
-0.4316779375076294,
-0.0824814885854721,
0.5489650368690491,
0.07763995975255966,
-0.24525325000286102,
0.0664629340171814,
-0.08450212329626083,
-0.8972639441490173,
-0.10255233943462372,
0.6485581994056702,
0.44407880306243896,
-0.4219410717487335,
-0.45901423692703247,
0.23532533645629883,
0.3616484999656677,
-0.11755399405956268,
1.0408389568328857,
-1.116289734840393,
0.9603356122970581,
0.8420878052711487,
0.9665135741233826,
0.7159232497215271,
0.5900838375091553,
0.5629110932350159,
-0.6238017678260803,
-0.15782582759857178,
0.23073452711105347,
0.13219743967056274,
0.05282741039991379,
-0.36295005679130554,
0.8429012894630432,
0.45732542872428894,
-0.7077341079711914,
-0.9302999377250671,
0.22375284135341644,
-0.8262920379638672,
-0.26078000664711,
1.1685237884521484,
-0.1465521603822708,
-0.13438257575035095,
-0.41840746998786926,
-0.08678021281957626,
0.27649369835853577,
0.007504007313400507,
0.564668595790863,
0.6161494255065918,
-0.18766295909881592,
-0.09003060311079025,
-0.6887449026107788,
0.5252695679664612,
0.3516574501991272,
-0.8311170339584351,
0.01406052615493536,
0.9109458923339844,
0.4650518000125885,
0.372663289308548,
1.0453141927719116,
-0.13512678444385529,
0.2457399070262909,
0.28518423438072205,
-0.11405456066131592,
-0.2591738700866699,
-0.49469584226608276,
-0.01924649067223072,
0.37014198303222656,
0.13071320950984955,
-0.298886239528656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11455v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11455v1 | Adaptive Reinforcement Learning Planning: Harnessing Large Language Models for Complex Information Extraction | 2024-06-17T12:11:01 | 2024-06-17T12:11:01 | Zepeng Ding, Ruiyang Ke, Wenhao Huang, Guochao Jiang, Yanda Li, Deqing Yang, Yanghua Xiao, Jiaqing Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing research on large language models (LLMs) shows that they can solve
information extraction tasks through multi-step planning. However, their
extraction behavior on complex sentences and tasks is unstable, emerging issues
such as false positives and missing elements. We observe that decomposing
complex extraction tasks and extracting them step by step can effectively
improve LLMs' performance, and the extraction orders of entities significantly
affect the final results of LLMs. This paper proposes a two-stage multi-step
method for LLM-based information extraction and adopts the RL framework to
execute the multi-step planning. We regard sequential extraction as a Markov
decision process, build an LLM-based extraction environment, design a decision
module to adaptively provide the optimal order for sequential entity extraction
on different sentences, and utilize the DDQN algorithm to train the decision
model. We also design the rewards and evaluation metrics suitable for the
extraction results of LLMs. We conduct extensive experiments on multiple public
datasets to demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in improving the
information extraction capabilities of LLMs. | [
-0.3360437750816345,
-0.9947474002838135,
0.63161301612854,
0.40741875767707825,
-0.13932915031909943,
0.2386307716369629,
-0.43979230523109436,
-0.35937952995300293,
-0.17387370765209198,
0.5743025541305542,
-0.5895364284515381,
-0.3620339334011078,
-0.767935574054718,
0.10749582201242447,
-0.14869824051856995,
0.8030699491500854,
-0.20128963887691498,
0.06605387479066849,
0.34962940216064453,
0.18047626316547394,
-0.4098118841648102,
-0.04156176373362541,
-1.146218180656433,
-0.26403099298477173,
0.787261962890625,
0.6723446846008301,
0.3966953456401825,
0.6953521966934204,
0.23416055738925934,
0.28137752413749695,
0.03705186769366264,
0.41749751567840576,
-0.27104511857032776,
0.4436555504798889,
-0.49391061067581177,
-0.27342489361763,
-0.40390923619270325,
-0.13669846951961517,
0.6384329795837402,
0.092188760638237,
-0.6090251207351685,
0.13829462230205536,
-0.27044057846069336,
0.6548410654067993,
-0.5422957539558411,
0.5460159182548523,
-0.658363401889801,
0.0744534581899643,
0.13502474129199982,
-0.42084023356437683,
-0.5460182428359985,
-0.23616187274456024,
0.2532540261745453,
-0.5367488861083984,
-0.25017210841178894,
0.131943479180336,
0.41815662384033203,
0.06444273889064789,
-0.2756827175617218,
-0.5983721613883972,
-0.9977171421051025,
0.8368740081787109,
-0.6858639121055603,
0.3360537588596344,
-0.0034828216303139925,
0.2938666045665741,
-0.5608417391777039,
-0.6703788042068481,
-0.6169136166572571,
0.04324410855770111,
0.24648378789424896,
0.019278381019830704,
0.023208454251289368,
-0.03662499040365219,
0.528247594833374,
-0.16205739974975586,
-0.4612570106983185,
0.4585035741329193,
-0.3200949430465698,
0.17899614572525024,
0.6462379097938538,
0.10980430990457535,
0.26964250206947327,
-0.28423410654067993,
-0.5518634915351868,
-0.2747550308704376,
-0.6097391247749329,
0.10656912624835968,
0.04393669590353966,
0.5405187606811523,
0.3281668722629547,
0.5843056440353394,
-0.24881434440612793,
0.39109304547309875,
0.03232429549098015,
-0.5258792042732239,
0.10455591231584549,
-0.07616712152957916,
-0.36280038952827454,
0.2082725316286087,
0.7845533490180969,
-0.27462634444236755,
0.3211997449398041,
-0.21971012651920319,
-0.6098697185516357,
-0.4606972634792328,
0.31049805879592896,
-0.6938318014144897,
-0.24020040035247803,
0.5107977390289307,
-0.4048038125038147,
-0.26429763436317444,
0.028504619374871254,
-1.08918035030365,
-0.35821396112442017,
-0.3072815537452698,
0.4409714937210083,
-0.4996871054172516,
-0.538815975189209,
0.023467721417546272,
0.040659982711076736,
0.27825385332107544,
0.600361704826355,
-0.7914470434188843,
0.28411954641342163,
0.6337284445762634,
0.6228208541870117,
-0.6061910390853882,
-0.2507326304912567,
-1.0434415340423584,
0.2935917377471924,
-0.1832543909549713,
0.7816632390022278,
-0.5408045649528503,
-0.07308374345302582,
0.14880040287971497,
0.013775377534329891,
-0.18450205028057098,
-0.725009560585022,
0.4634288549423218,
-1.0876214504241943,
0.1018269807100296,
-0.00908046867698431,
-0.34256285429000854,
-0.3235451579093933,
0.3873874247074127,
-0.9144698977470398,
0.9617495536804199,
-0.23612076044082642,
-0.40941351652145386,
0.25569894909858704,
-0.7783965468406677,
-0.4829988181591034,
-0.04853523150086403,
-0.2363281548023224,
-0.48777341842651367,
-0.25145307183265686,
0.46416279673576355,
0.6412940621376038,
-0.15188412368297577,
0.43327856063842773,
-0.09080369025468826,
0.05245918780565262,
0.098540298640728,
-0.25059670209884644,
0.7317761778831482,
0.29367175698280334,
-0.38280194997787476,
0.41850754618644714,
-0.9472301602363586,
0.055172357708215714,
0.3065969944000244,
-1.1692991256713867,
-0.017700888216495514,
0.45060548186302185,
-0.1212676614522934,
0.7109765410423279,
0.08794790506362915,
-0.27378785610198975,
0.5009762048721313,
-0.3383823037147522,
0.3101196885108948,
0.8460536003112793,
0.3150103688240051,
0.5503121614456177,
-0.05915367603302002,
0.6681879162788391,
0.24533671140670776,
-0.07382004708051682,
0.010937558487057686,
-0.045063745230436325,
-0.7803516387939453,
-0.32766586542129517,
0.3676682412624359,
0.8231207132339478,
-1.0945037603378296,
0.34575626254081726,
-0.309807151556015,
-0.1818993240594864,
-0.22150719165802002,
0.14646556973457336,
0.3244144320487976,
0.20702902972698212,
0.44179409742355347,
-0.16993120312690735,
-0.5622130036354065,
-0.5283730030059814,
-0.30927807092666626,
-0.2302434891462326,
0.17834019660949707,
-0.09370355308055878,
0.43107226490974426,
0.12235396355390549,
0.6972863674163818,
-0.46589168906211853,
-0.10988397896289825,
-0.5359846949577332,
0.5312423706054688,
0.1772516965866089,
0.29710134863853455,
-0.17044556140899658,
-1.0664368867874146,
-0.15313231945037842,
-0.0482289157807827,
-0.5502269268035889,
0.317978173494339,
-0.3757144510746002,
-0.028839698061347008,
0.15249915421009064,
0.44128894805908203,
-0.6983324289321899,
0.11937204003334045,
0.27818602323532104,
0.08990579098463058,
0.6476779580116272,
-0.20535700023174286,
-0.1685454100370407,
-0.9057700037956238,
-0.0834592953324318,
0.22190320491790771,
-0.4938218891620636,
-0.5243942141532898,
0.03754326328635216,
0.226960226893425,
0.19802744686603546,
-0.4737919270992279,
0.3646458089351654,
-0.6652681827545166,
-0.5341436266899109,
-0.43087896704673767,
0.39323970675468445,
-0.1560109555721283,
0.7693474292755127,
0.28019464015960693,
0.5508591532707214,
0.19107499718666077,
-0.8717576265335083,
0.5604580044746399,
0.1314588487148285,
-0.5671511292457581,
-0.004130980931222439,
-0.1350679248571396,
0.06124122440814972,
-0.24229831993579865,
0.2313157171010971,
-0.6806241273880005,
0.07686875760555267,
0.6070877313613892,
-0.09200042486190796,
0.6030012965202332,
-0.028212115168571472,
-0.4738602042198181,
-0.17197801172733307,
-0.10444539040327072,
-0.08472604304552078,
0.1026807576417923,
-0.6008797883987427,
0.8742749691009521,
0.4641476571559906,
-0.8198733925819397,
-0.6788470149040222,
-0.17347991466522217,
-0.011915345676243305,
-0.30788153409957886,
-0.15550805628299713,
0.19727811217308044,
-0.005985063500702381,
-0.3090980052947998,
-0.05030466616153717,
-0.11998730152845383,
-0.09566682577133179,
0.20388221740722656,
0.024790676310658455,
0.24444396793842316,
-0.1357823759317398,
0.1368623673915863,
-0.15518100559711456,
-0.07633582502603531,
0.23719871044158936,
-0.38674044609069824,
0.5060589909553528,
0.4946008026599884,
-0.0822659432888031,
-0.2455824315547943,
0.1691654473543167,
0.37067246437072754,
-0.32250434160232544,
0.4553804099559784,
0.6060250401496887,
-0.45201241970062256,
-0.3414914309978485,
-0.42176687717437744,
0.07424655556678772,
-0.38536620140075684,
0.7015218734741211,
-0.358742356300354,
-0.4452725946903229,
0.05097021162509918,
-0.6614903211593628,
0.6172603964805603,
0.36032721400260925,
0.605767548084259,
0.07807204127311707,
1.139530897140503,
0.72388756275177,
-0.09914176166057587,
0.8310883641242981,
-0.1785484105348587,
0.05064792558550835,
-0.8362289667129517,
-0.5328488349914551,
-0.4777719974517822,
-0.2192835956811905,
-0.24234795570373535,
-0.3570917844772339,
0.06908901035785675,
0.3035573959350586,
-0.12327937036752701,
0.06812328100204468,
0.029065797105431557,
0.16097275912761688,
0.36585795879364014,
0.164240300655365,
0.45825469493865967,
0.11933905631303787,
-0.07079875469207764,
0.2196449190378189,
-0.5705013871192932,
-0.4819137752056122,
0.8483873009681702,
0.442462295293808,
0.5106644630432129,
0.29669076204299927,
0.5421228408813477,
0.19426152110099792,
0.13256512582302094,
-0.8826146721839905,
0.36552152037620544,
0.09215953946113586,
-0.272638738155365,
-0.7154577374458313,
-0.4543859362602234,
-0.86875981092453,
0.5361621379852295,
-0.46935129165649414,
-0.6924772262573242,
0.2552090585231781,
-0.29248538613319397,
-0.3815341889858246,
0.17284126579761505,
-0.3300021290779114,
0.4009292721748352,
-0.4763372838497162,
-0.1358613222837448,
-0.3267800807952881,
-0.5751853585243225,
0.43094417452812195,
-0.3560624420642853,
0.5670595169067383,
-0.17645300924777985,
-0.17682960629463196,
1.0250252485275269,
0.028708014637231827,
0.4747101366519928,
-0.3521113693714142,
-0.18048742413520813,
0.02718556486070156,
0.20143646001815796,
1.1302883625030518,
-0.008179059252142906,
-0.2063707858324051,
-0.3458591401576996,
-0.1971980780363083,
-0.2868066728115082,
-0.7254528403282166,
0.3543436527252197,
-0.5224100351333618,
-0.4740697741508484,
-0.4298597276210785,
-0.48170843720436096,
-0.25638991594314575,
0.36884501576423645,
-0.39556145668029785,
0.2422841191291809,
-0.08444644510746002,
-0.250730037689209,
0.7146453857421875,
-0.39585432410240173,
0.8267794847488403,
0.6874009966850281,
-0.36686310172080994,
-0.5633628368377686,
0.8638346791267395,
-0.12186723947525024,
0.1953558325767517,
0.5742063522338867,
0.16561314463615417,
-0.3164551556110382,
-0.9305013418197632,
-0.46710678935050964,
0.019687924534082413,
-0.7897801399230957,
-0.15654344856739044,
-0.7165747880935669,
-0.2954269349575043,
-0.409904807806015,
0.6148423552513123,
-0.1912616491317749,
-0.40880119800567627,
-0.11222358793020248,
-0.16233664751052856,
0.009456248953938484,
0.896412193775177,
-0.010339376516640186,
0.19454514980316162,
-0.8309851884841919,
0.5464712381362915,
0.26030203700065613,
-0.18787439167499542,
0.10870000720024109,
-0.3241767883300781,
-0.22129322588443756,
-0.24840331077575684,
-0.277761310338974,
-0.6634722948074341,
0.5876817107200623,
0.1471232771873474,
0.6611690521240234,
0.3725011646747589,
-0.05635107308626175,
0.6763981580734253,
-0.5959075093269348,
0.4677897095680237,
0.07751017808914185,
-0.3381861746311188,
0.47595030069351196,
-0.10263292491436005,
0.017429877072572708,
0.23644043505191803,
0.5104618072509766,
-0.3387901484966278,
-0.12368655204772949,
-0.5596718192100525,
-0.9545718431472778,
1.0119656324386597,
-0.08949265629053116,
-0.46019646525382996,
0.1851898729801178,
0.5496681928634644,
0.058555904775857925,
0.1872868686914444,
-0.920137882232666,
-0.14498063921928406,
0.417120099067688,
-0.11216611415147781,
-0.1099683940410614,
-0.4658222496509552,
0.03907555341720581,
0.08152204751968384,
0.8570179343223572,
0.024746503680944443,
-0.08193238824605942,
0.06747576594352722,
-0.4021492898464203,
-0.171212300658226,
0.42651885747909546,
0.527067244052887,
0.8528836369514465,
0.02535080350935459,
0.10425510257482529,
0.13189639151096344,
-0.25846999883651733,
0.044658515602350235,
0.10364136844873428,
-0.003047751961275935,
-0.4583122730255127,
0.3726455569267273,
0.5644452571868896,
0.4201567769050598,
-0.8211482763290405,
0.3578040599822998,
-0.30002981424331665,
-0.010826129466295242,
-0.4571762979030609,
0.17669636011123657,
0.00960979238152504,
0.8083434700965881,
0.3492666184902191,
-0.15268881618976593,
-0.012333609163761139,
-0.6174127459526062,
0.46344372630119324,
0.12567941844463348,
-0.19215378165245056,
-0.03328341990709305,
0.14218828082084656,
-0.05411531403660774,
-0.4318576157093048,
0.7383942008018494,
-0.13142360746860504,
-0.49455952644348145,
0.40437960624694824,
0.7073895335197449,
0.5943794846534729,
-0.24951216578483582,
0.3504008650779724,
0.4607376456260681,
0.11997626721858978,
-0.3794061243534088,
0.46509701013565063,
0.11445863544940948,
-0.7836471796035767,
-0.6539077758789062,
-0.7976880669593811,
-0.13156113028526306,
0.1649622768163681,
-0.5510140657424927,
0.37980449199676514,
-0.6009032130241394,
0.3752211034297943,
-0.011646104045212269,
0.25722843408584595,
-0.48953214287757874,
0.34273383021354675,
-0.014256315305829048,
0.8528608083724976,
-0.49287450313568115,
1.0990943908691406,
0.3774871230125427,
-0.45054537057876587,
-1.0423097610473633,
-0.042127516120672226,
0.04231921210885048,
-0.9681713581085205,
0.818763792514801,
-0.1707051694393158,
0.10711764544248581,
0.14191456139087677,
-0.3313479423522949,
-0.9784864783287048,
1.2831499576568604,
0.032384369522333145,
-0.8513256907463074,
-0.37279245257377625,
-0.3207930326461792,
0.07908783107995987,
-0.5574945211410522,
0.053396258503198624,
0.6654921770095825,
0.5576430559158325,
0.3484787046909332,
-0.38967692852020264,
0.1814558058977127,
0.22690215706825256,
-0.09105098247528076,
0.289080411195755,
-0.1455988883972168,
0.8774487376213074,
-0.2123996764421463,
-0.44760459661483765,
0.009652949869632721,
0.7064717411994934,
0.33733803033828735,
-0.0750536099076271,
0.7921470999717712,
0.31620949506759644,
0.9047448635101318,
0.36786723136901855,
0.6582134366035461,
0.12415610998868942,
0.1804651916027069,
1.378806471824646,
-0.23605765402317047,
1.2608369588851929,
0.3724253475666046,
-0.01686236448585987,
0.560119092464447,
0.79683518409729,
0.12058788537979126,
0.6649659872055054,
0.174213707447052,
-0.19628016650676727,
-0.22491641342639923,
0.20930729806423187,
0.2087835669517517,
0.40286535024642944,
0.49060171842575073,
-0.31742221117019653,
-0.34509173035621643,
-0.04327590763568878,
0.09354875981807709,
-0.24246090650558472,
-0.32148054242134094,
1.1412365436553955,
0.011725226417183876,
-0.8051169514656067,
0.07697358727455139,
0.390002965927124,
0.2888309359550476,
-0.3890276253223419,
-0.3195984363555908,
0.20376761257648468,
0.07971135526895523,
-0.2105528861284256,
-0.6426530480384827,
-0.05605461820960045,
-0.02184304967522621,
-0.16158702969551086,
-0.315956711769104,
0.8378505706787109,
-0.5768324136734009,
-0.2262902706861496,
0.5072964429855347,
0.513295590877533,
0.28077855706214905,
-0.1296214610338211,
-1.0174047946929932,
0.05311591923236847,
0.03073728457093239,
-0.5535040497779846,
0.4581283628940582,
0.5343368053436279,
0.08674348890781403,
0.6781370639801025,
0.7335349321365356,
0.5876373648643494,
0.20799729228019714,
-0.07668788731098175,
0.8043218851089478,
-0.8846508860588074,
-0.2925664782524109,
-0.9525702595710754,
0.5145881175994873,
-0.13228526711463928,
0.14337748289108276,
0.2339148372411728,
0.5109378695487976,
0.7467437386512756,
0.4001268744468689,
0.8184853196144104,
-0.04491627588868141,
0.4639379680156708,
-1.0482356548309326,
0.05935702845454216,
-0.41585153341293335,
0.458433598279953,
-0.12017941474914551,
-1.1582162380218506,
-0.1020055040717125,
0.46184420585632324,
-0.22630129754543304,
-0.24506890773773193,
0.7194514274597168,
0.6085413694381714,
0.10701876878738403,
-0.05923854932188988,
0.11406607180833817,
0.32292190194129944,
0.782344400882721,
0.5098901987075806,
0.7943369746208191,
-0.17984436452388763,
0.6632654070854187,
-0.06091463565826416,
-0.2798307240009308,
-0.11722720414400101,
-0.9093676209449768,
-0.44892439246177673,
-0.4749559462070465,
-0.19126281142234802,
-0.3517824709415436,
0.0013593038311228156,
1.1455481052398682,
0.4776515066623688,
-0.6984251141548157,
-0.20959046483039856,
-0.007783195935189724,
0.4339289963245392,
-0.22028766572475433,
-0.23912708461284637,
0.34282511472702026,
-0.5128394365310669,
-0.662045955657959,
0.7603354454040527,
0.40375250577926636,
-0.2534879744052887,
-0.27652090787887573,
-0.14311407506465912,
-0.744442880153656,
-0.22687271237373352,
0.6225365400314331,
0.476312518119812,
-0.7206494212150574,
-0.49926120042800903,
-0.46736836433410645,
-0.14174304902553558,
0.2584048807621002,
0.8678801655769348,
-0.5965542197227478,
0.36542877554893494,
0.40232205390930176,
0.7569624185562134,
0.6801124811172485,
0.12752237915992737,
0.6483529210090637,
-0.6115140914916992,
-0.0988951325416565,
0.10374061018228531,
0.18767419457435608,
-0.0580618791282177,
-0.2592673897743225,
0.3472587764263153,
-0.12803179025650024,
-0.5601522922515869,
-0.47634804248809814,
0.3312607705593109,
-0.9050848484039307,
-0.5504330396652222,
1.3701196908950806,
-0.2672572433948517,
-0.3736599087715149,
-0.2049170732498169,
-0.19997286796569824,
0.4789678156375885,
-0.4853884279727936,
0.7179194688796997,
0.6420820355415344,
-0.3243602514266968,
-0.3635774254798889,
-0.7163815498352051,
0.33614450693130493,
-0.03937936946749687,
-0.9223076105117798,
0.18964746594429016,
0.46272996068000793,
0.5088773369789124,
0.09304989129304886,
0.6496144533157349,
-0.232030987739563,
-0.038429100066423416,
-0.4682457149028778,
0.044051334261894226,
0.12712709605693817,
-0.7213611006736755,
-0.5988450050354004,
0.3627965748310089,
0.39993563294410706,
-0.05970383808016777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11431v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11431v1 | Super(ficial)-alignment: Strong Models May Deceive Weak Models in Weak-to-Strong Generalization | 2024-06-17T11:36:39 | 2024-06-17T11:36:39 | Wenkai Yang, Shiqi Shen, Guangyao Shen, Zhi Gong, Yankai Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Superalignment, where humans are weak supervisors of superhuman models, has
become an important and widely discussed issue in the current era of rapid
development of Large Language Models (LLMs). The recent work preliminarily
studies this problem by using weak models to supervise strong models. It
discovers that weakly supervised strong students can consistently outperform
weak teachers towards the alignment target, leading to a weak-to-strong
generalization phenomenon. However, we are concerned that behind such a
promising phenomenon, whether there exists an issue of weak-to-strong
deception, where strong models may deceive weak models by exhibiting
well-aligned in areas known to weak models but producing misaligned behaviors
in cases weak models do not know. We then take an initial step towards
exploring this security issue in a specific but realistic multi-objective
alignment case, where there may be some alignment targets conflicting with each
other (e.g., helpfulness v.s. harmlessness). Such a conflict is likely to cause
strong models to deceive weak models in one alignment dimension to gain high
reward in other alignment dimension. Our experiments on both the reward
modeling task and the preference optimization scenario indicate: (1) the
weak-to-strong deception exists; (2) the deception phenomenon may intensify as
the capability gap between weak and strong models increases. We also discuss
potential solutions and find bootstrapping with an intermediate model can
mitigate the deception to some extent. Our work highlights the urgent need to
pay more attention to the true reliability of superalignment. | [
-0.16852566599845886,
-0.5567600727081299,
0.5626092553138733,
-0.20955470204353333,
-0.06818804889917374,
0.04274069517850876,
0.08939759433269501,
-0.587519645690918,
0.0973968505859375,
0.36727049946784973,
-0.612762987613678,
-0.06672724336385727,
-0.7315509915351868,
-0.24910135567188263,
-0.4830228090286255,
1.1786952018737793,
0.08308848738670349,
0.32132309675216675,
-0.3072543740272522,
-0.23455598950386047,
-0.6640497446060181,
-0.5965012311935425,
-0.23841580748558044,
-0.5852413773536682,
0.35026758909225464,
0.39353492856025696,
1.318803071975708,
0.8243820667266846,
0.7992891073226929,
0.32865485548973083,
-0.11184930801391602,
-0.014791365712881088,
-0.576896607875824,
0.3489231765270233,
-0.567756712436676,
-0.6801083087921143,
-0.49439579248428345,
0.04827563092112541,
0.5316187739372253,
0.6589315533638,
-0.28527313470840454,
-0.04959455505013466,
0.08106929808855057,
0.6388270258903503,
-0.618529736995697,
-0.36241060495376587,
-0.5305309891700745,
-0.3860766887664795,
-0.3065084218978882,
0.39401328563690186,
-0.12204756587743759,
-0.058149002492427826,
0.15585386753082275,
-0.5413001775741577,
0.34707966446876526,
0.12981626391410828,
1.4018861055374146,
0.3861788511276245,
-0.499719500541687,
0.04915928468108177,
-0.8806121945381165,
0.9091936349868774,
-0.46067318320274353,
0.39113354682922363,
0.2896406054496765,
0.32399481534957886,
-0.17050014436244965,
-0.3439631760120392,
-0.445270836353302,
-0.10259505361318588,
0.0042049880139529705,
0.08536791056394577,
0.014711745083332062,
0.03570326045155525,
0.1537967324256897,
0.3712010979652405,
-0.509093165397644,
0.4206559956073761,
-0.23945988714694977,
-0.27968060970306396,
0.7084202170372009,
0.30227798223495483,
0.33979132771492004,
0.20566079020500183,
-0.6672420501708984,
-0.2525094151496887,
-0.8444389700889587,
-0.06385798007249832,
0.5667264461517334,
0.4851594567298889,
-0.29904240369796753,
0.5028217434883118,
0.11660811305046082,
0.568909227848053,
0.42662513256073,
-0.1894959956407547,
-0.21054141223430634,
-0.599600076675415,
-0.11796145886182785,
0.13681569695472717,
0.6149691939353943,
0.562092661857605,
0.3000712990760803,
-0.09273402392864227,
-0.29962339997291565,
0.4764114320278168,
0.3333350718021393,
-0.4562765955924988,
0.12187404185533524,
0.19823838770389557,
-0.4713371992111206,
-0.420883446931839,
0.26632192730903625,
-0.34432172775268555,
-0.5629314184188843,
-0.5294115543365479,
0.35013875365257263,
-0.28336232900619507,
-0.3913208246231079,
0.12862800061702728,
0.19594192504882812,
0.40914908051490784,
0.0856231078505516,
-1.2328720092773438,
0.3230505585670471,
1.0034247636795044,
0.5297148823738098,
0.1191856637597084,
-0.5086894631385803,
-0.140422061085701,
0.4490949511528015,
-0.3639479875564575,
0.5346643328666687,
-0.6021899580955505,
-0.17172594368457794,
-0.17004041373729706,
0.009401700459420681,
-0.23994217813014984,
-0.4187455177307129,
0.5743489861488342,
-0.35396608710289,
0.17939534783363342,
-0.3069649040699005,
-0.5560988187789917,
0.08553844690322876,
0.23560920357704163,
-0.4714936912059784,
0.6480627059936523,
0.0911995992064476,
-0.6219528913497925,
0.32721877098083496,
-0.019995762035250664,
-0.14002950489521027,
-0.2551563084125519,
-0.3033332824707031,
-0.6606139540672302,
0.27960535883903503,
0.04655764251947403,
0.47377291321754456,
-0.4465928077697754,
0.6894046068191528,
-0.4395555555820465,
-0.5969820022583008,
0.4456346333026886,
-0.3136853277683258,
0.6979734897613525,
0.03985857218503952,
-0.45222699642181396,
0.04286836460232735,
-0.1726694107055664,
-0.329515278339386,
0.19959084689617157,
0.12520766258239746,
-0.5275847911834717,
-0.034200284630060196,
-0.29675689339637756,
0.1084093227982521,
0.452205628156662,
-0.41993337869644165,
0.5882907509803772,
-0.454345166683197,
0.1396772861480713,
1.0693360567092896,
-0.2698751389980316,
0.6214352250099182,
-0.3922717869281769,
0.49439066648483276,
-0.00011307175736874342,
0.3983611762523651,
0.23829320073127747,
-0.24154402315616608,
-0.44075673818588257,
0.035558320581912994,
0.7592227458953857,
0.5320066809654236,
-0.34328681230545044,
0.2227475643157959,
-0.1642652302980423,
-0.38894161581993103,
-0.6876287460327148,
0.32926174998283386,
0.9122081398963928,
0.4037899971008301,
0.28473302721977234,
-0.3435462713241577,
-0.2760065495967865,
-1.2293312549591064,
-0.31701263785362244,
-0.361494779586792,
0.1747521013021469,
-0.07264464348554611,
0.4185766875743866,
-0.31605446338653564,
0.662787675857544,
-0.38455721735954285,
-0.43259158730506897,
-0.18950486183166504,
-0.07018201053142548,
0.09595393389463425,
0.8302730321884155,
0.6200594305992126,
-1.207208514213562,
-0.14067654311656952,
-0.1314748078584671,
-0.8037028312683105,
0.09629879891872406,
-0.2685694694519043,
-0.30766069889068604,
0.2340420037508011,
0.6350983381271362,
-0.7816201448440552,
0.17767781019210815,
0.5192362666130066,
-0.3839429020881653,
0.7663256525993347,
-0.021470438688993454,
-0.1993391066789627,
-1.0931755304336548,
-0.106535904109478,
0.2033364623785019,
0.05306977406144142,
-0.7105963826179504,
0.4462057054042816,
0.08197062462568283,
0.08280903846025467,
-0.3196353614330292,
0.23694373667240143,
-0.39858347177505493,
0.13952423632144928,
-0.19959402084350586,
-0.0944492295384407,
-0.15693645179271698,
0.17064057290554047,
-0.0390792191028595,
0.4965227246284485,
0.8112660050392151,
-0.4411987066268921,
0.20826248824596405,
0.19400914013385773,
-0.007375798188149929,
1.0717651844024658,
-0.6324766874313354,
0.044425852596759796,
-0.12785696983337402,
0.27456337213516235,
-1.0492786169052124,
-0.6181721687316895,
0.2441864162683487,
-0.32256364822387695,
0.7576453685760498,
-0.28297436237335205,
-0.29114314913749695,
-0.09323329478502274,
-0.22982560098171234,
0.5279716849327087,
0.08874035626649857,
-0.407441645860672,
0.42326366901397705,
0.3364606201648712,
-0.09826160222291946,
-0.8700156211853027,
-0.6537302732467651,
0.018765103071928024,
-0.5321322083473206,
-0.7515426278114319,
0.5903210639953613,
0.18095456063747406,
-0.2140086144208908,
-0.1571667194366455,
-0.5423738956451416,
0.25283750891685486,
0.25862205028533936,
0.3273775279521942,
0.5986249446868896,
-0.23316460847854614,
0.08631926774978638,
-0.11172525584697723,
-0.44961196184158325,
-0.054659370332956314,
-0.17788924276828766,
0.32131025195121765,
-0.301870733499527,
-0.6123177409172058,
-0.5856748223304749,
0.3150709271430969,
0.6646814346313477,
0.03361796215176582,
0.9393676519393921,
0.5021260380744934,
-0.5145854353904724,
0.3835858702659607,
-0.6479557752609253,
-0.2691560685634613,
-0.51413893699646,
0.08323672413825989,
-0.2507966458797455,
-0.8370341062545776,
0.5072165131568909,
0.00970139168202877,
-0.025056803598999977,
0.3411445617675781,
0.17556017637252808,
-0.215704083442688,
1.7213166952133179,
0.9295004606246948,
-0.2690322995185852,
0.3752390146255493,
-0.1970040649175644,
0.2766554057598114,
-0.8162111043930054,
-0.3120795488357544,
-0.5274292230606079,
-0.6965810060501099,
-0.6751641631126404,
0.23172858357429504,
0.07199785858392715,
0.5149052143096924,
-0.3465054929256439,
0.6159905791282654,
-0.5491287112236023,
0.6676031351089478,
0.4501008689403534,
-0.04240694269537926,
-0.08311430364847183,
-0.18698352575302124,
-0.1654067188501358,
-0.1915517896413803,
-0.5810221433639526,
-0.5554735660552979,
1.016715407371521,
0.4261413812637329,
1.113237738609314,
0.46088138222694397,
0.779358446598053,
-0.09190848469734192,
0.30287113785743713,
-0.5005849599838257,
0.6714766621589661,
-0.22187142074108124,
-0.7451311945915222,
-0.2146911472082138,
-0.3398726284503937,
-0.8445500731468201,
0.18927298486232758,
-0.3383476138114929,
-0.9453297257423401,
0.5114936828613281,
0.2763539254665375,
-0.47514620423316956,
0.13089674711227417,
-0.8474787473678589,
1.0416779518127441,
-0.610623300075531,
-0.7227702736854553,
0.03555116057395935,
-1.1038870811462402,
0.5917443633079529,
0.08260765671730042,
0.05631648004055023,
-0.019623825326561928,
0.130821093916893,
0.5620474815368652,
-0.4151518642902374,
0.981741189956665,
-0.2757873237133026,
-0.32187899947166443,
-0.08674012869596481,
0.2638324797153473,
0.5254245400428772,
-0.029580706730484962,
0.10303753614425659,
0.011199050582945347,
-0.03521722927689552,
-0.6211351752281189,
-0.532360851764679,
0.6866580843925476,
-0.7525557279586792,
-1.006412386894226,
-0.5007813572883606,
-0.6607975959777832,
-0.3134744465351105,
0.1610477715730667,
0.32954898476600647,
0.3023834228515625,
-0.07755916565656662,
0.11929573118686676,
0.7578777074813843,
0.28727707266807556,
0.06784781068563461,
0.33810850977897644,
0.013172460719943047,
-0.19567139446735382,
1.2145124673843384,
0.16973617672920227,
0.5503561496734619,
0.1680293083190918,
0.2842314839363098,
-0.311639666557312,
-0.647683322429657,
-0.347834974527359,
0.48786547780036926,
-0.23742225766181946,
-0.46383973956108093,
0.1501452773809433,
-0.026953769847750664,
-0.6285767555236816,
-0.5222557187080383,
-0.5451134443283081,
-0.5351355671882629,
-0.21347396075725555,
-0.16711893677711487,
-0.3331896960735321,
0.6225617527961731,
-0.13769777119159698,
0.5477057099342346,
-0.6086132526397705,
0.2707756459712982,
0.3470628559589386,
0.16062842309474945,
-0.20445331931114197,
-0.5657209157943726,
-0.3199968636035919,
0.23823057115077972,
-0.6157329082489014,
-0.6130626797676086,
0.017511332407593727,
-0.053318873047828674,
0.5115917921066284,
1.0046569108963013,
0.02200045995414257,
0.8067387938499451,
0.06840658187866211,
0.7295251488685608,
0.5038398504257202,
-0.767920970916748,
0.3498993217945099,
-0.47337907552719116,
0.22135956585407257,
0.6683402061462402,
0.5251843333244324,
-0.2796712815761566,
-0.6290119290351868,
-0.9906185269355774,
-0.8926955461502075,
0.7110026478767395,
0.03281675651669502,
0.15917089581489563,
0.2486826777458191,
0.48295289278030396,
0.011782526038587093,
0.12704123556613922,
-0.7775359749794006,
-0.22354313731193542,
-0.05133083462715149,
-0.2925175130367279,
0.04358408600091934,
-0.3066129684448242,
-0.4968765079975128,
0.12932917475700378,
0.758117139339447,
-0.17464475333690643,
0.17578889429569244,
0.031162986531853676,
-0.058046720921993256,
-0.36013370752334595,
0.23515863716602325,
0.8787920475006104,
0.6406959295272827,
-0.19018585979938507,
0.3477509319782257,
-0.06801393628120422,
-0.3583305776119232,
0.4298837184906006,
0.20618577301502228,
-0.08482983708381653,
-0.5866363048553467,
0.4968010187149048,
0.4472733736038208,
0.23608186841011047,
-0.20572899281978607,
0.7399613857269287,
0.09962683171033859,
-0.3364833891391754,
0.149086594581604,
0.23761405050754547,
0.15981991589069366,
0.4302693009376526,
0.30031073093414307,
0.3188357353210449,
-0.21850250661373138,
-0.5703325867652893,
-0.03677690401673317,
0.795349657535553,
-0.5888985991477966,
-0.5310500264167786,
0.9239527583122253,
-0.01486443541944027,
-0.29443395137786865,
0.6346115469932556,
-0.02789759263396263,
-0.7186517715454102,
0.7037374377250671,
0.7298378944396973,
0.6150442957878113,
-0.7002658247947693,
0.1694164276123047,
-0.08302897959947586,
0.38634204864501953,
-0.558860182762146,
-0.03643634170293808,
0.12672701478004456,
-0.9566802382469177,
-0.323087602853775,
-0.3123722970485687,
-0.5365439653396606,
0.17409247159957886,
-0.8108428716659546,
0.07283387333154678,
-0.2914171814918518,
-0.3716526925563812,
-0.10596483945846558,
-0.1884932667016983,
-0.23701664805412292,
0.17655467987060547,
0.2547333538532257,
0.5321559906005859,
-1.1122757196426392,
0.5587643980979919,
0.7036978006362915,
-0.3815060555934906,
-0.8684527277946472,
0.22738997638225555,
0.2843487858772278,
-0.7402004599571228,
0.4356738030910492,
0.34108278155326843,
-0.20523829758167267,
-0.30028238892555237,
-0.9612667560577393,
-0.9390674829483032,
1.027735710144043,
0.8746353983879089,
-0.5274162888526917,
-0.30728670954704285,
0.2531388998031616,
0.5438240170478821,
-0.3792203962802887,
-0.12219709903001785,
0.5924357175827026,
0.4255821704864502,
-0.11581335961818695,
-0.9279211163520813,
0.2277575433254242,
0.04620462656021118,
-0.03899203613400459,
0.4025910198688507,
-1.175157904624939,
0.6879249811172485,
-0.30004987120628357,
-0.2546761631965637,
0.20663855969905853,
0.5483907461166382,
0.3665018379688263,
0.37957486510276794,
0.523089587688446,
0.837799072265625,
0.6281622648239136,
-0.16794438660144806,
0.8262392282485962,
-0.19237643480300903,
0.2491207867860794,
0.9524329900741577,
-0.4921877682209015,
0.4129111170768738,
0.6562416553497314,
-0.01768168993294239,
0.5124105215072632,
0.592936635017395,
0.09591858088970184,
0.4182998538017273,
0.037214022129774094,
-0.01657484658062458,
-0.6053543090820312,
-0.41184988617897034,
-0.4857577383518219,
0.4526841938495636,
0.42729905247688293,
-0.17532289028167725,
-0.0030726627446711063,
-0.2695760130882263,
-0.14187154173851013,
0.03863213211297989,
-0.29147449135780334,
0.5322113037109375,
0.17874521017074585,
-0.7579534649848938,
0.44163161516189575,
-0.032868098467588425,
0.49654847383499146,
-0.6937008500099182,
0.12173210084438324,
-0.20606856048107147,
0.3290402591228485,
-0.36125993728637695,
-0.5615492463111877,
0.12379489094018936,
-0.42507728934288025,
-0.07502353191375732,
-0.44640350341796875,
0.9308391213417053,
-0.33391478657722473,
-0.28221896290779114,
0.16144001483917236,
0.37613052129745483,
-0.06440412253141403,
0.25032201409339905,
-0.883841335773468,
0.02995341084897518,
-0.21893489360809326,
-0.2461235076189041,
0.729529857635498,
0.14162731170654297,
-0.34581896662712097,
0.5772843956947327,
0.68116694688797,
-0.0021735590416938066,
-0.393922358751297,
0.14783725142478943,
0.7778003811836243,
-0.48472341895103455,
-0.46361544728279114,
-1.0370162725448608,
0.43516430258750916,
-0.015372206456959248,
-0.26064419746398926,
0.7562295198440552,
0.43896135687828064,
0.9109249114990234,
0.2640056312084198,
0.2991429567337036,
0.17377805709838867,
0.16365914046764374,
-0.554435133934021,
0.3789912760257721,
-0.5823701620101929,
0.3120618760585785,
-0.4828537106513977,
-1.0708415508270264,
-0.3401291072368622,
0.5373278260231018,
-0.3706780672073364,
-0.08569733053445816,
0.48776668310165405,
1.0235611200332642,
-0.3380486071109772,
-0.02148805558681488,
0.18572063744068146,
0.041183602064847946,
0.0031130649149417877,
0.5447748303413391,
1.0664167404174805,
-0.38615110516548157,
0.6133464574813843,
-0.13865022361278534,
-0.07684609293937683,
-0.3849925398826599,
-0.7213783860206604,
-0.43937474489212036,
-0.44411414861679077,
-0.4190967082977295,
-0.36073750257492065,
0.06594152748584747,
0.5404945015907288,
0.7553108334541321,
-0.7099098563194275,
-0.34477654099464417,
-0.17942963540554047,
0.46390220522880554,
-0.5676617622375488,
-0.20883610844612122,
0.28309813141822815,
0.03483204543590546,
-0.5878844261169434,
0.34716224670410156,
0.09213017672300339,
0.5181990265846252,
-0.4267999827861786,
-0.1637350618839264,
-0.267228901386261,
0.0729510560631752,
-0.11244358122348785,
0.457226037979126,
-0.5229241251945496,
-0.4330049455165863,
-0.04440257325768471,
-0.329405814409256,
-0.2276080846786499,
0.6922873258590698,
-0.4281303584575653,
0.16796652972698212,
0.13270115852355957,
0.5576228499412537,
0.11387649923563004,
0.5278192162513733,
0.8202471733093262,
-0.763630211353302,
-0.11870110034942627,
0.017112063243985176,
0.41636359691619873,
0.3460543155670166,
-0.5230416655540466,
0.5121527314186096,
0.294025719165802,
-0.7014073729515076,
-1.278512716293335,
0.5672595500946045,
-0.6860178709030151,
-0.23958106338977814,
0.8082625269889832,
0.05456259474158287,
-0.10899507254362106,
-0.02435053139925003,
-0.19673101603984833,
0.20953266322612762,
-0.12091837078332901,
0.9545187950134277,
0.9345839023590088,
-0.4320588707923889,
0.22996175289154053,
-0.2295670509338379,
0.2725198268890381,
1.0167642831802368,
-0.2968442142009735,
0.13205598294734955,
0.35136914253234863,
0.061511971056461334,
0.563163161277771,
0.16343075037002563,
0.07899177819490433,
0.398975670337677,
-0.059033796191215515,
-0.336897611618042,
-0.05240969732403755,
-0.531551718711853,
-0.5501425862312317,
0.2111496478319168,
0.12727801501750946,
0.0054592834785580635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11430v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11430v1 | A Simple and Effective $L_2$ Norm-Based Strategy for KV Cache Compression | 2024-06-17T11:35:16 | 2024-06-17T11:35:16 | Alessio Devoto, Yu Zhao, Simone Scardapane, Pasquale Minervini | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The deployment of large language models (LLMs) is often hindered by the
extensive memory requirements of the Key-Value (KV) cache, especially as
context lengths increase. Existing approaches to reduce the KV cache size
involve either fine-tuning the model to learn a compression strategy or
leveraging attention scores to reduce the sequence length. We analyse the
attention distributions in decoder-only Transformers-based models and observe
that attention allocation patterns stay consistent across most layers.
Surprisingly, we find a clear correlation between the $L_2$ and the attention
scores over cached KV pairs, where a low $L_2$ of a key embedding usually leads
to a high attention score during decoding. This finding indicates that the
influence of a KV pair is potentially determined by the key embedding itself
before being queried. Based on this observation, we compress the KV cache based
on the $L_2$ of key embeddings. Our experimental results show that this simple
strategy can reduce the KV cache size by 50% on language modelling and
needle-in-a-haystack tasks and 90% on passkey retrieval tasks without losing
accuracy. | [
-0.2999851405620575,
-0.3348811864852905,
0.47611203789711,
0.29255881905555725,
-0.5643543004989624,
-0.2589291036128998,
-0.5191631317138672,
-0.29692205786705017,
0.04784811660647392,
0.3468829393386841,
-0.33394941687583923,
-0.41867125034332275,
-0.5902538895606995,
-0.2494220733642578,
-0.18124884366989136,
0.43364882469177246,
0.2259036749601364,
-0.11456641554832458,
-0.3285268247127533,
-0.003252110444009304,
-0.639600396156311,
-0.3107648491859436,
-0.49772629141807556,
-0.0042762234807014465,
0.4901737868785858,
0.5583435297012329,
0.5350133180618286,
0.9020029306411743,
0.5749232172966003,
0.03924413025379181,
-0.33727720379829407,
0.20231971144676208,
-0.8900694251060486,
0.5330870151519775,
0.27126407623291016,
-0.8135712146759033,
-0.23924168944358826,
-0.07580778002738953,
0.6776728630065918,
0.14826877415180206,
-0.06624643504619598,
0.2555006444454193,
-0.022569041699171066,
0.865730345249176,
-1.0335423946380615,
0.2925055921077728,
-0.7523565292358398,
0.15254588425159454,
-0.03899964317679405,
-0.28978073596954346,
-0.8535987138748169,
0.039054024964571,
-0.14847716689109802,
-0.3079584836959839,
0.08645741641521454,
-0.08101455867290497,
0.8120723366737366,
0.6141948699951172,
-0.21010057628154755,
0.14838427305221558,
-0.5969354510307312,
0.9008892774581909,
-0.5681982636451721,
0.5977687239646912,
0.5458181500434875,
0.09344411641359329,
0.1819828301668167,
-0.5040468573570251,
-0.3764461576938629,
0.23889081180095673,
-0.019040297716856003,
0.1141488179564476,
0.006108604371547699,
0.05008251592516899,
0.20791973173618317,
0.1886267066001892,
-0.34263330698013306,
0.26260292530059814,
-0.40138423442840576,
-0.1485939919948578,
0.4150663912296295,
0.11216368526220322,
-0.05247470736503601,
-0.12382836639881134,
-0.2842566668987274,
-0.4400627911090851,
-1.069716453552246,
0.17861081659793854,
0.24682840704917908,
0.32104477286338806,
0.01075035147368908,
0.4493241012096405,
-0.03259148821234703,
0.4391554296016693,
0.24829202890396118,
-0.14465804398059845,
-0.05191006138920784,
-0.19870120286941528,
-0.2681175172328949,
0.010451588779687881,
0.46534839272499084,
0.6567854285240173,
0.3614797294139862,
-0.341724157333374,
-0.18992716073989868,
0.12283782660961151,
0.5437480211257935,
-0.8854355812072754,
-0.23158478736877441,
0.06618793308734894,
-0.5406670570373535,
-0.42275092005729675,
-0.22585704922676086,
-0.7854747772216797,
-0.007227221503853798,
-0.043115727603435516,
0.40416625142097473,
0.02450878731906414,
0.08192813396453857,
0.1935252845287323,
-0.031596776098012924,
0.5407248139381409,
0.22583188116550446,
-1.0171635150909424,
0.41069313883781433,
0.5346717834472656,
0.9806891679763794,
-0.2638547122478485,
0.31209948658943176,
-0.5460609197616577,
0.10888463258743286,
-0.22184903919696808,
0.5781090259552002,
-0.5050749182701111,
-0.510686993598938,
0.13469001650810242,
-0.13120099902153015,
0.2329297810792923,
-0.5321214199066162,
0.5556045174598694,
-0.9116112589836121,
-0.4287944734096527,
-0.5655725598335266,
-0.4471516013145447,
0.025311928242444992,
0.20140378177165985,
-0.9561421871185303,
1.2191524505615234,
0.290836364030838,
-0.46620020270347595,
0.039252303540706635,
-0.16392233967781067,
-0.42509108781814575,
-0.22588925063610077,
-0.1244533360004425,
-0.5103598237037659,
0.39270666241645813,
0.4289802610874176,
0.6354213356971741,
-0.4741831123828888,
-0.24490748345851898,
-0.11946437507867813,
-0.48903924226760864,
-0.026364492252469063,
-0.30212512612342834,
0.37705594301223755,
0.26222261786460876,
-0.22381266951560974,
-0.4276706576347351,
-0.27658551931381226,
0.21550250053405762,
0.2585000693798065,
-0.5711811184883118,
-0.2879771888256073,
-0.07170165330171585,
0.18119992315769196,
0.28161799907684326,
0.1361670047044754,
-0.2729392349720001,
0.5902944207191467,
-0.5339217185974121,
0.36852791905403137,
0.7622038125991821,
0.027323691174387932,
0.6846947073936462,
-0.242064967751503,
0.3240961730480194,
0.13525277376174927,
0.2017267644405365,
-0.108921118080616,
-0.3425939083099365,
-1.0919543504714966,
-0.22758519649505615,
0.2601611614227295,
0.404865026473999,
-0.11143456399440765,
0.3314054012298584,
-0.6829648017883301,
-0.29697108268737793,
-0.9106408357620239,
0.3105519413948059,
0.3967297375202179,
0.18459796905517578,
0.49939242005348206,
-0.3544785976409912,
-0.3840540051460266,
-1.1190176010131836,
-0.16979733109474182,
-0.05235528200864792,
0.1702824980020523,
0.6867298483848572,
0.08347868174314499,
0.027447544038295746,
0.9613823890686035,
-0.5675871968269348,
-0.33095937967300415,
-0.21872945129871368,
-0.186656191945076,
-0.021095219999551773,
0.4335680305957794,
0.19099578261375427,
-0.7566998600959778,
-0.6449047327041626,
-0.3726092576980591,
-0.24619194865226746,
-0.023663997650146484,
-0.05938804894685745,
0.042860355228185654,
0.25836342573165894,
0.5460666418075562,
-0.8354781866073608,
0.4511299133300781,
0.37040117383003235,
0.08484885096549988,
0.3028274178504944,
-0.0842222198843956,
-0.17085683345794678,
-0.9132523536682129,
0.03728440776467323,
-0.25124403834342957,
-0.45973095297813416,
-0.5185300707817078,
0.3160969614982605,
0.43523550033569336,
0.2105492204427719,
-0.5893024206161499,
0.46402519941329956,
-0.565222978591919,
-0.1370646357536316,
-0.03683343902230263,
0.043864451348781586,
0.03461029753088951,
0.6988933086395264,
-0.09693087637424469,
0.8979635238647461,
0.15432608127593994,
-0.6169632077217102,
0.0265648290514946,
0.3064068853855133,
-0.5543520450592041,
0.18828034400939941,
-0.7146480083465576,
0.5352969765663147,
-0.1703718602657318,
0.31319448351860046,
-1.1701122522354126,
0.1673634797334671,
-0.23194065690040588,
-0.37460899353027344,
0.7744534611701965,
-0.23413458466529846,
-0.8071425557136536,
-0.14820633828639984,
-0.5433221459388733,
0.666959285736084,
1.0462185144424438,
-0.5222595930099487,
0.18495914340019226,
0.4005127549171448,
0.13244085013866425,
-0.5963422060012817,
-0.8736082315444946,
0.10818907618522644,
-0.2102794647216797,
-0.6105878949165344,
0.532231867313385,
-0.15974965691566467,
-0.026666870340704918,
-0.06770996749401093,
-0.32147929072380066,
0.1134897843003273,
0.06305525451898575,
0.15570947527885437,
-0.0004965309053659439,
-0.1784287989139557,
0.40266939997673035,
0.15171337127685547,
-0.10855570435523987,
-0.061255767941474915,
-0.3193279504776001,
0.6482654213905334,
0.11980293691158295,
-0.09314712882041931,
-0.3917526304721832,
0.37837275862693787,
0.7748633623123169,
-0.09584259241819382,
0.7593461871147156,
0.4515945315361023,
-0.1934008151292801,
-0.37026846408843994,
-0.807794451713562,
-0.49296700954437256,
-0.4616822600364685,
0.3145992159843445,
-0.34820666909217834,
-1.073642611503601,
0.4864041209220886,
-0.21375709772109985,
-0.05506248027086258,
0.3181535303592682,
0.8712425827980042,
0.007032043766230345,
0.9899815320968628,
0.462236613035202,
-0.4738202691078186,
0.18012656271457672,
-0.47201353311538696,
0.41024425625801086,
-1.270223617553711,
-0.1367708295583725,
-0.39417749643325806,
-0.6613999009132385,
-0.283382773399353,
-0.853916347026825,
0.372021347284317,
0.30142447352409363,
-0.07562950998544693,
0.14866262674331665,
-0.6543152928352356,
0.668152391910553,
0.18124069273471832,
0.2175689935684204,
-0.0257246233522892,
0.15772630274295807,
-0.0943896621465683,
-0.1664014309644699,
-0.7551978826522827,
-0.07668039947748184,
1.140555739402771,
0.41798558831214905,
0.8007935881614685,
0.31251055002212524,
0.4680999517440796,
0.3594169616699219,
-0.04104262590408325,
-1.0220609903335571,
0.38898220658302307,
0.07300786674022675,
-0.3890674412250519,
-0.1690063625574112,
-0.1367223709821701,
-0.7356318235397339,
-0.004055792465806007,
0.08258917182683945,
-0.7985808849334717,
0.08452849090099335,
0.02588168904185295,
-0.3592097759246826,
0.12640032172203064,
-0.3956044316291809,
0.5399850010871887,
0.22545406222343445,
-0.39198678731918335,
-0.4002443253993988,
-0.8375054001808167,
0.2848087549209595,
0.006795413792133331,
0.02562006004154682,
0.15473692119121552,
-0.17841912806034088,
0.724053144454956,
-0.2846929132938385,
0.8686888813972473,
-0.10928268730640411,
-0.09392216056585312,
0.254014790058136,
0.23875096440315247,
1.1705878973007202,
0.1947268545627594,
0.1042393296957016,
-0.1496245115995407,
-0.34756600856781006,
-0.4837431013584137,
-0.8415292501449585,
0.9407498240470886,
-1.0239923000335693,
-0.6599219441413879,
0.19653606414794922,
-0.705000102519989,
-0.1800982803106308,
-0.19536173343658447,
0.2474825382232666,
0.26243019104003906,
0.08636869490146637,
0.4733750820159912,
1.1898092031478882,
-0.0684397965669632,
0.44888150691986084,
0.2594364285469055,
0.3256917893886566,
-0.1306476891040802,
0.5104909539222717,
0.166726753115654,
0.5972039103507996,
0.6156339645385742,
0.08634192496538162,
-0.33788150548934937,
-0.2863066792488098,
-0.10981031507253647,
0.2075977772474289,
-1.0476794242858887,
-0.49069806933403015,
-0.8568058013916016,
-0.3040642738342285,
-0.5401732325553894,
-0.34911614656448364,
-0.7328336238861084,
-0.4716106057167053,
-0.38196712732315063,
0.015608591958880424,
0.5661365985870361,
0.2438090741634369,
0.009525034576654434,
0.3437727689743042,
-0.6164819002151489,
0.08426620066165924,
0.47394388914108276,
0.2930101454257965,
0.3095475733280182,
-0.7503543496131897,
-0.47900861501693726,
-0.12287026643753052,
-0.09066183120012283,
-0.7556042671203613,
0.4850103259086609,
0.24359242618083954,
0.26381218433380127,
0.4338199198246002,
0.19908064603805542,
0.6738708019256592,
-0.5498747229576111,
0.8795010447502136,
-0.025191396474838257,
-0.7900382280349731,
0.32210761308670044,
-0.03249722346663475,
0.458493173122406,
0.5222383737564087,
-0.004717069678008556,
-0.5002650022506714,
-0.24743874371051788,
-0.5889279246330261,
-0.9920283555984497,
0.552169919013977,
0.2296709418296814,
0.40604186058044434,
-0.12629593908786774,
0.5920473337173462,
-0.26062700152397156,
-0.08983208984136581,
-0.546122670173645,
-0.35325759649276733,
0.09261554479598999,
-0.27939513325691223,
-0.03328251466155052,
-0.6978934407234192,
0.11010951548814774,
-0.27329036593437195,
0.38463419675827026,
0.08173979818820953,
0.7426428198814392,
0.2229876071214676,
-0.4088481664657593,
-0.16602486371994019,
0.1997595727443695,
0.7540817260742188,
-0.09166666865348816,
-0.3239954710006714,
0.5023685693740845,
0.22178953886032104,
-0.5488654375076294,
0.2388923168182373,
-0.5806857347488403,
-0.07996286451816559,
-0.03542270511388779,
0.024528373032808304,
0.7388009428977966,
0.4576382040977478,
-0.5063072443008423,
0.7037209272384644,
-0.0030463719740509987,
0.04488525167107582,
-0.038599371910095215,
0.00905044749379158,
0.33558452129364014,
0.22125089168548584,
0.08237645030021667,
-0.2640747129917145,
-0.039073556661605835,
-0.10221470147371292,
0.16321928799152374,
0.4032869040966034,
-0.6186866164207458,
-0.27423104643821716,
0.4271605312824249,
0.0508723258972168,
-0.2763732969760895,
0.8743519186973572,
-0.09668494760990143,
-0.585652768611908,
0.5692727565765381,
0.7276331186294556,
0.7890191674232483,
-0.23742881417274475,
-0.31285667419433594,
0.5274273157119751,
0.5370587706565857,
-0.443055123090744,
0.17282713949680328,
-0.3885958194732666,
-0.6035711765289307,
-0.41248324513435364,
-0.5522498488426208,
0.2037682980298996,
0.4369906783103943,
-0.8339433670043945,
0.35173383355140686,
-0.31293901801109314,
0.019325435161590576,
-0.38884472846984863,
0.017469365149736404,
-0.997922420501709,
0.0018423357978463173,
0.07075327634811401,
0.9908005595207214,
-0.6615023016929626,
1.1111836433410645,
-0.04232177138328552,
-0.2064257115125656,
-0.8284829258918762,
-0.1295410394668579,
0.03617298975586891,
-0.9271169304847717,
0.8928743600845337,
0.27148306369781494,
0.14698877930641174,
0.3171570301055908,
-0.534869909286499,
-1.13026762008667,
1.0682157278060913,
0.09665904194116592,
-0.7294643521308899,
-0.06070234626531601,
-0.05781305953860283,
0.29956701397895813,
-0.28631144762039185,
-0.060869451612234116,
0.5984305739402771,
0.5582064390182495,
-0.10201263427734375,
-0.7375189661979675,
0.19286112487316132,
-0.3141981363296509,
0.17456334829330444,
0.4370017349720001,
-0.7463308572769165,
0.6200650334358215,
-0.2135004997253418,
-0.4030725955963135,
0.07651480287313461,
0.45881080627441406,
-0.1634174883365631,
-0.37352368235588074,
0.45594507455825806,
0.988627552986145,
0.364173948764801,
0.3079083561897278,
1.0605942010879517,
-0.46787723898887634,
0.5721487998962402,
0.8447048664093018,
-0.10195565223693848,
1.0859341621398926,
0.8522967100143433,
-0.119167760014534,
0.17255908250808716,
0.48458126187324524,
-0.09976375848054886,
1.0148749351501465,
0.3828967809677124,
-0.09780455380678177,
-0.4590960741043091,
-0.1149490550160408,
-0.21511933207511902,
0.3756776750087738,
0.5273844003677368,
-0.4734448194503784,
-0.15823066234588623,
-0.25645145773887634,
0.17740964889526367,
-0.36369553208351135,
-0.07115516811609268,
0.7162138819694519,
0.23697584867477417,
-0.6893669962882996,
0.8512080311775208,
0.07377412915229797,
0.414420485496521,
-0.28490781784057617,
0.11767978966236115,
-0.17453818023204803,
0.12655439972877502,
0.13012999296188354,
-0.5107854604721069,
0.03428419679403305,
-0.14955545961856842,
-0.6022837162017822,
-0.15799959003925323,
0.6236156225204468,
-0.5141103267669678,
-0.15505453944206238,
0.13214221596717834,
0.2666729688644409,
0.111432746052742,
0.021852761507034302,
-0.250901460647583,
0.31436970829963684,
-0.24147382378578186,
-0.46364009380340576,
0.5973778963088989,
-0.03364109620451927,
0.09203384816646576,
0.42429715394973755,
0.6470466256141663,
0.0838100016117096,
0.033359698951244354,
-0.06366828083992004,
1.0804650783538818,
-0.34742313623428345,
-0.5945907831192017,
-0.867815375328064,
0.42997801303863525,
0.050606418401002884,
-0.007332306355237961,
0.5953779220581055,
0.4583986699581146,
0.4616508185863495,
-0.06255566328763962,
0.6321551203727722,
0.3925009071826935,
-0.04436435177922249,
-0.6263105273246765,
0.6317492723464966,
-0.6478273272514343,
0.32500460743904114,
-0.020533360540866852,
-0.9885105490684509,
-0.48179134726524353,
0.6962573528289795,
0.1788462996482849,
-0.1210475042462349,
0.6028050780296326,
0.9828805327415466,
-0.17322926223278046,
-0.503424346446991,
0.3938233256340027,
0.2888398766517639,
0.36301887035369873,
0.909942090511322,
0.37616345286369324,
-0.5648148059844971,
0.5089182257652283,
-0.039083659648895264,
0.030632739886641502,
-0.7303236722946167,
-0.7551968693733215,
-0.9147371649742126,
-0.534996509552002,
-0.019380472600460052,
-0.4201464056968689,
0.09334015846252441,
0.7497723698616028,
0.9026703834533691,
-0.3386157751083374,
0.08976586163043976,
-0.08898479491472244,
-0.13460202515125275,
-0.1768484264612198,
-0.18756818771362305,
0.7132685780525208,
-0.5757713913917542,
-0.4148962199687958,
0.3645815849304199,
0.6323487162590027,
-0.1182108148932457,
-0.4582425057888031,
-0.20184528827667236,
-0.01963181048631668,
0.3757941722869873,
0.5426542162895203,
0.018390154466032982,
-1.045249104499817,
-0.43802809715270996,
0.40622588992118835,
-0.45208480954170227,
0.19297243654727936,
0.9118803143501282,
-0.9536945819854736,
0.719828724861145,
0.5845538377761841,
0.8306651711463928,
0.7147401571273804,
-0.2968972623348236,
0.44431284070014954,
-1.1541420221328735,
0.3350012004375458,
0.22601112723350525,
0.13620874285697937,
0.15267632901668549,
-0.654873788356781,
0.32446053624153137,
0.11752627044916153,
-0.6070252060890198,
-0.8794000744819641,
0.27652087807655334,
-1.2546330690383911,
-0.23301322758197784,
1.6012041568756104,
-0.03515849635004997,
-0.24151726067066193,
0.01793714612722397,
-0.07294680178165436,
0.2948445677757263,
-0.4628508985042572,
1.0868569612503052,
0.7562346458435059,
0.4602743089199066,
-0.5320333242416382,
-0.5720628499984741,
0.7345019578933716,
0.580230176448822,
-0.3723474144935608,
0.27154332399368286,
0.02311812713742256,
0.019248738884925842,
0.10915783047676086,
0.39450353384017944,
-0.08848495781421661,
0.4398605525493622,
-0.09645294398069382,
-0.07675047218799591,
-0.07010120153427124,
-0.357205867767334,
-0.4117739200592041,
0.07121381908655167,
0.10440985858440399,
0.0050924308598041534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11429v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11429v1 | Fusion Makes Perfection: An Efficient Multi-Grained Matching Approach for Zero-Shot Relation Extraction | 2024-06-17T11:31:48 | 2024-06-17T11:31:48 | Shilong Li, Ge Bai, Zhang Zhang, Ying Liu, Chenji Lu, Daichi Guo, Ruifang Liu, Yong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Predicting unseen relations that cannot be observed during the training phase
is a challenging task in relation extraction. Previous works have made progress
by matching the semantics between input instances and label descriptions.
However, fine-grained matching often requires laborious manual annotation, and
rich interactions between instances and label descriptions come with
significant computational overhead. In this work, we propose an efficient
multi-grained matching approach that uses virtual entity matching to reduce
manual annotation cost, and fuses coarse-grained recall and fine-grained
classification for rich interactions with guaranteed inference speed.
Experimental results show that our approach outperforms the previous State Of
The Art (SOTA) methods, and achieves a balance between inference efficiency and
prediction accuracy in zero-shot relation extraction tasks. Our code is
available at https://github.com/longls777/EMMA. | [
-0.4828922748565674,
-0.7297821640968323,
0.8186737298965454,
0.05988704785704613,
-0.111728236079216,
-0.22408615052700043,
0.21166740357875824,
-0.949073076248169,
0.1717519313097,
0.5958605408668518,
-0.49510616064071655,
-0.26106470823287964,
-0.32306787371635437,
-0.08778184652328491,
-0.40481024980545044,
0.9361912608146667,
0.03034808672964573,
-0.17268306016921997,
-0.5158692002296448,
-0.1564662754535675,
-0.2717243432998657,
-0.21960052847862244,
-0.19020652770996094,
-0.6001881957054138,
0.465836763381958,
0.37074902653694153,
0.6302114129066467,
1.3043030500411987,
0.4374544024467468,
0.2999493479728699,
0.1347544640302658,
0.34086963534355164,
-0.5501834154129028,
0.40695035457611084,
-0.21609562635421753,
-0.03851470723748207,
-0.5386244058609009,
-0.07345593720674515,
0.3031005859375,
0.2890032231807709,
0.25996264815330505,
0.4100029170513153,
-0.1889622062444687,
0.09500139206647873,
-1.2081674337387085,
0.2873159646987915,
-1.0293934345245361,
0.09761711955070496,
-0.40348291397094727,
-0.3587675094604492,
-0.27499884366989136,
0.03780363127589226,
-0.06354113668203354,
-0.7152436971664429,
0.27121925354003906,
-0.03257141634821892,
1.6147582530975342,
0.08871232718229294,
-0.3024214804172516,
0.2192288041114807,
-1.0315651893615723,
0.4924905598163605,
-0.26061350107192993,
0.30169132351875305,
0.3386974036693573,
0.5544283390045166,
-0.22653314471244812,
-0.5237260460853577,
-0.7794660925865173,
0.18489103019237518,
-0.22741220891475677,
0.26011496782302856,
0.031988900154829025,
0.2454259991645813,
0.17093659937381744,
0.6663749814033508,
-0.377934068441391,
-0.10825762897729874,
-0.04178246483206749,
-0.10065615177154541,
0.4662576913833618,
0.15836426615715027,
0.1120937168598175,
-0.1698688417673111,
-0.46797075867652893,
-0.14253664016723633,
-0.250522643327713,
-0.350224107503891,
-0.14068056643009186,
0.3910292088985443,
0.0783318430185318,
0.6598168611526489,
-0.4090162217617035,
0.8872383236885071,
-0.0309479758143425,
-0.30983680486679077,
0.1383567452430725,
-0.5857110619544983,
-0.42885759472846985,
0.16036422550678253,
0.8733492493629456,
0.5379619002342224,
0.38681545853614807,
-0.360031396150589,
0.24651408195495605,
0.6079957485198975,
0.06704223155975342,
-0.8649876713752747,
-0.23146802186965942,
0.17000344395637512,
0.13154323399066925,
-0.28173425793647766,
0.15023472905158997,
-0.9011049866676331,
-0.09838173538446426,
-0.26725292205810547,
0.7015662789344788,
-0.509277880191803,
-0.17826968431472778,
-0.12913736701011658,
-0.36793383955955505,
0.8416633009910583,
0.13653039932250977,
-0.8562006950378418,
0.05591900646686554,
1.0561469793319702,
0.7779054045677185,
0.33772042393684387,
-0.3013729155063629,
-0.7380218505859375,
0.4988648295402527,
-0.22258232533931732,
1.1102577447891235,
-0.6528424620628357,
-0.20308423042297363,
-0.10217754542827606,
-0.16935086250305176,
0.0008415115298703313,
-0.40948936343193054,
0.519665539264679,
-0.34689828753471375,
-0.19091396033763885,
-0.02591659501194954,
-0.6103639006614685,
0.0032426274847239256,
0.4609106183052063,
-0.40165096521377563,
0.9604496955871582,
0.15950855612754822,
-0.5422675609588623,
0.22967186570167542,
-0.052065640687942505,
-0.36309415102005005,
0.23402367532253265,
-0.260775089263916,
-0.48161306977272034,
-0.009355300106108189,
0.1800464689731598,
0.6143937706947327,
-0.2223009318113327,
0.17278988659381866,
-0.9828004837036133,
-0.2954303026199341,
-0.2302495390176773,
0.06038675829768181,
0.24301673471927643,
0.16080042719841003,
-0.1821405440568924,
0.08572327345609665,
-1.0280790328979492,
0.03580860048532486,
0.22147080302238464,
0.2672916054725647,
-0.6192927956581116,
-0.44024842977523804,
-0.05516274273395538,
0.5047819018363953,
0.052218541502952576,
-0.7937569618225098,
0.21073472499847412,
-0.4764520525932312,
0.00007657074456801638,
0.5032534599304199,
-0.07442876696586609,
0.7280859351158142,
-0.05879877880215645,
0.015268542803823948,
0.08876433223485947,
0.13341140747070312,
-0.7088948488235474,
-0.17637112736701965,
-0.7440487146377563,
-0.20310285687446594,
0.4906693696975708,
0.5050598978996277,
-1.036604881286621,
0.48787641525268555,
-0.47560930252075195,
-0.8759002685546875,
-0.8156766295433044,
0.03308332338929176,
0.9016847014427185,
0.7533541321754456,
0.4608931243419647,
-0.521059513092041,
-0.4456232190132141,
-0.8730373978614807,
-0.11962731927633286,
0.07507102936506271,
-0.16780279576778412,
0.44856593012809753,
0.16790303587913513,
-0.21245263516902924,
1.1230632066726685,
-0.7835198044776917,
-0.6899276971817017,
0.04100365936756134,
-0.011745833791792393,
-0.1437947154045105,
0.44171929359436035,
0.6833612322807312,
-0.5834965705871582,
-0.6465669870376587,
0.5668044686317444,
-1.2789584398269653,
0.06303022056818008,
-0.04082478955388069,
-0.6266430020332336,
-0.25786566734313965,
0.1765541285276413,
-0.6502488851547241,
0.3520207703113556,
0.3169371783733368,
-0.3578208088874817,
0.2049824744462967,
0.06262477487325668,
0.15695738792419434,
-1.1705105304718018,
-0.043521203100681305,
0.34714075922966003,
-0.533359706401825,
-0.7590188980102539,
0.37504851818084717,
0.22950716316699982,
-0.05270347371697426,
-0.6645061373710632,
0.804391622543335,
-0.4639759957790375,
-0.27362608909606934,
-0.20906883478164673,
0.4279366731643677,
0.16887836158275604,
0.38084354996681213,
-0.04266393929719925,
0.44548267126083374,
0.8070220947265625,
-0.5793910026550293,
0.2380361258983612,
0.447282075881958,
0.3148959279060364,
0.8122240304946899,
-0.19279545545578003,
-0.06859457492828369,
-0.21749064326286316,
0.17569851875305176,
-0.5332103967666626,
-0.4975171685218811,
0.20973236858844757,
-0.3835977017879486,
0.4705895185470581,
-0.0683426707983017,
-0.25048670172691345,
-0.1273418813943863,
-0.6506651043891907,
0.17604891955852509,
0.12441540509462357,
-0.5438472628593445,
0.8975306153297424,
0.45989683270454407,
0.2815134525299072,
-0.45618516206741333,
-0.3838275074958801,
0.001446642680093646,
0.186769038438797,
-0.43679770827293396,
0.6627382040023804,
0.16657447814941406,
0.09023654460906982,
0.23091617226600647,
-0.49954092502593994,
-0.5662907958030701,
0.028684284538030624,
0.492863267660141,
0.4079391062259674,
-0.2684114873409271,
-0.12671242654323578,
0.0006342024425975978,
-0.41567280888557434,
-0.5795833468437195,
0.2103484570980072,
0.5350123047828674,
0.08685144782066345,
0.07338958233594894,
-0.519904375076294,
0.26397377252578735,
0.80184006690979,
-0.14281238615512848,
0.7938565611839294,
0.8082998394966125,
-0.432481974363327,
0.29008233547210693,
-0.7919464707374573,
-0.12250985950231552,
-0.45724377036094666,
0.2009919434785843,
-0.734550416469574,
-0.7752954363822937,
0.2754133939743042,
-0.034844961017370224,
0.17654111981391907,
0.4690783619880676,
0.019664714112877846,
0.07956278324127197,
0.5189799666404724,
0.6187629103660583,
-0.19414637982845306,
0.32294729351997375,
-0.11460166424512863,
0.19416090846061707,
-0.8430901765823364,
-0.42092248797416687,
-0.626142680644989,
0.05545572191476822,
-0.5305097699165344,
-0.24493473768234253,
0.03682684898376465,
0.3116143047809601,
0.009175016544759274,
0.9572606086730957,
-0.5344830751419067,
0.7484056353569031,
0.565302848815918,
0.02051636576652527,
0.4015059769153595,
-0.16046424210071564,
0.3612273931503296,
0.01246623694896698,
-0.4930686950683594,
-0.17694500088691711,
0.6609280705451965,
-0.11337950825691223,
0.314310759305954,
-0.19597703218460083,
0.987493097782135,
-0.3375622034072876,
0.2859613299369812,
-0.9617456793785095,
0.5858018398284912,
-0.10066238790750504,
-0.4956018924713135,
-0.13880391418933868,
-0.7417887449264526,
-1.1637541055679321,
0.37486395239830017,
-0.8471987843513489,
-0.7954725027084351,
-0.037014078348875046,
0.37959903478622437,
-0.6185500025749207,
0.2534705698490143,
-0.7627402544021606,
0.9771049618721008,
0.06987666338682175,
-0.5246390104293823,
0.1513892114162445,
-0.6880248785018921,
0.7116121053695679,
-0.27859818935394287,
0.09136009216308594,
-0.49192890524864197,
0.45761045813560486,
0.23271526396274567,
-0.25198617577552795,
-0.015923406928777695,
0.18999961018562317,
0.34167757630348206,
0.01258249580860138,
0.29895904660224915,
0.10192370414733887,
-0.21608076989650726,
-0.09042070060968399,
0.3758838474750519,
0.19158615171909332,
-0.4205877184867859,
-0.597481906414032,
0.990486204624176,
-0.4356095790863037,
-0.16550400853157043,
-0.5997388958930969,
-0.46992072463035583,
-0.0666179209947586,
0.299322247505188,
0.04458240419626236,
0.28682178258895874,
-0.19190755486488342,
-0.06843409687280655,
0.4573707580566406,
0.08899123221635818,
0.6604088544845581,
0.4101884663105011,
-0.24251528084278107,
-0.3509448766708374,
1.109307050704956,
0.19215017557144165,
0.07728779315948486,
0.4559454917907715,
0.03468126058578491,
-0.14953601360321045,
0.11201944947242737,
-0.6620336174964905,
0.30625998973846436,
-0.1161855086684227,
-0.7531783580780029,
-0.9733984470367432,
-0.37131091952323914,
-0.5910428166389465,
-0.2165125459432602,
-0.6184054017066956,
0.027693618088960648,
-0.26314592361450195,
0.08800060302019119,
0.3526291251182556,
0.3864469826221466,
-0.0031606080010533333,
0.4532701373100281,
-1.35979425907135,
0.7008146643638611,
0.5680275559425354,
0.374490886926651,
0.0006501066382043064,
-0.09321538358926773,
0.09771699458360672,
-0.2494787722826004,
-0.6400251984596252,
-0.8634943962097168,
0.21240516006946564,
0.6215153336524963,
0.20270977914333344,
0.5692213773727417,
0.15740984678268433,
1.4120292663574219,
-0.5300613641738892,
0.5760126113891602,
0.3457895517349243,
-0.8619197607040405,
0.4471544623374939,
-0.057858649641275406,
0.20317892730236053,
0.7886144518852234,
0.3826170563697815,
-0.1055513545870781,
-0.17862161993980408,
-0.9157496690750122,
-1.036056637763977,
0.7836880087852478,
0.42025673389434814,
0.06121659651398659,
0.0052162944339215755,
0.5590903162956238,
-0.043181728571653366,
0.005288307089358568,
-0.5333109498023987,
-0.4553825557231903,
0.30031484365463257,
-0.1267346441745758,
0.08871377259492874,
-0.29777851700782776,
0.1909738928079605,
-0.27152007818222046,
0.839417576789856,
0.03392061963677406,
0.1423710286617279,
0.1398710459470749,
0.014015255495905876,
-0.2227516919374466,
-0.04474060609936714,
0.10570944845676422,
0.276966392993927,
-0.3075556457042694,
0.3025679290294647,
0.11656443029642105,
0.027864856645464897,
0.11675114184617996,
0.34770479798316956,
-0.28795915842056274,
0.28603944182395935,
0.29853901267051697,
0.7479500770568848,
0.529900312423706,
-0.3510687053203583,
0.594995379447937,
-0.11639636754989624,
-0.18222448229789734,
0.07792139798402786,
0.24610602855682373,
0.0023128949105739594,
0.2735006809234619,
-0.1435687094926834,
0.04602287337183952,
0.170808345079422,
-0.9055730700492859,
0.5969053506851196,
0.6141859889030457,
-0.5539432168006897,
-0.3539767861366272,
0.6491694450378418,
0.16956034302711487,
-0.4385150969028473,
0.42298072576522827,
-0.4023532569408417,
-0.22485701739788055,
0.13965101540088654,
0.3965207636356354,
0.7432286143302917,
-0.4245885908603668,
0.2932031452655792,
0.5070663094520569,
-0.28097423911094666,
-0.2558479607105255,
-0.2312554568052292,
-0.3262636959552765,
-0.749323844909668,
-0.5791985988616943,
-1.1415846347808838,
-0.3177529275417328,
0.0626605674624443,
-0.7404927015304565,
0.4064966142177582,
-0.26362720131874084,
0.045208293944597244,
0.6719858050346375,
-0.30963441729545593,
-0.5723534822463989,
0.05009276792407036,
0.21560977399349213,
0.5177385210990906,
-0.9547803997993469,
0.8826869130134583,
0.22657577693462372,
-0.47113698720932007,
-0.9005406498908997,
-0.26763254404067993,
0.024170001968741417,
-0.580177903175354,
-0.07428506761789322,
0.5578348636627197,
0.0731317549943924,
0.08253205567598343,
-0.2124701589345932,
-0.7003908157348633,
0.8217207789421082,
0.7888873219490051,
-0.6646367311477661,
0.11168316006660461,
-0.08870352804660797,
0.3600907623767853,
-0.10160476714372635,
0.5668790936470032,
1.0456047058105469,
0.2702026665210724,
0.7092707753181458,
-1.1112459897994995,
-0.22869642078876495,
-0.03639216348528862,
-0.05786388739943504,
0.7577595710754395,
-0.44552624225616455,
0.5751556158065796,
0.28363242745399475,
-0.40605515241622925,
0.006684229243546724,
0.6347485184669495,
0.18802696466445923,
0.7615271806716919,
0.13454242050647736,
0.9218557476997375,
0.2207135409116745,
-0.17721684277057648,
0.8660781383514404,
-0.27107012271881104,
0.6634077429771423,
1.4775679111480713,
-0.5983303785324097,
0.8388515710830688,
0.3494901657104492,
0.021357566118240356,
0.10123074054718018,
0.5281834602355957,
-0.04360874369740486,
0.38977882266044617,
-0.28325116634368896,
-0.30483680963516235,
-0.529465913772583,
-0.6148724555969238,
-0.2649976909160614,
0.6178915500640869,
-0.07043690234422684,
-0.22612138092517853,
-0.7802918553352356,
-0.31815245747566223,
0.17237605154514313,
0.2530003488063812,
-0.2939828634262085,
1.2570843696594238,
0.12933696806430817,
-0.5191100239753723,
0.3498656451702118,
-0.34453555941581726,
0.6272063255310059,
-0.5178740620613098,
-0.3222750723361969,
0.023139944300055504,
0.18788015842437744,
-0.23902545869350433,
-0.726445198059082,
0.4307743012905121,
-0.2024695873260498,
-0.13019892573356628,
0.15053848922252655,
0.8883148431777954,
-0.7083900570869446,
-0.30903634428977966,
0.5764607787132263,
0.4394068121910095,
0.15252093970775604,
-0.3805679976940155,
-0.36655718088150024,
0.02328219637274742,
-0.17181165516376495,
0.09890282154083252,
0.6304090023040771,
0.4918346703052521,
0.14385280013084412,
0.22496725618839264,
0.7446082234382629,
-0.0012929479125887156,
-0.16598649322986603,
-0.3998574912548065,
0.8197523355484009,
-0.6461685299873352,
0.09484551101922989,
-1.2667450904846191,
0.32035019993782043,
-0.47428444027900696,
-0.22907193005084991,
0.5692805051803589,
0.657429039478302,
0.9842097163200378,
-0.16465485095977783,
0.3863605260848999,
-0.014996175654232502,
-0.041906148195266724,
-0.019099336117506027,
0.2637485861778259,
-0.4077173173427582,
-0.465515673160553,
-0.5992258787155151,
-1.4922795295715332,
-0.6375991702079773,
0.5142046809196472,
0.18539182841777802,
-0.45640453696250916,
0.3703314960002899,
0.8384348750114441,
-0.43970975279808044,
-0.2315637469291687,
0.727651059627533,
-0.016740180552005768,
0.37122642993927,
0.6329346299171448,
0.189054936170578,
-0.8840497732162476,
0.5316466093063354,
-0.5106461048126221,
-0.36737456917762756,
-0.19132889807224274,
-0.86054527759552,
-0.4911192059516907,
-0.3274674117565155,
-0.4525175392627716,
-0.3649594783782959,
-0.08147251605987549,
0.9697255492210388,
0.806795060634613,
-0.49629631638526917,
0.0688997134566307,
0.008629826828837395,
-0.056087713688611984,
-0.11520807445049286,
-0.2121652364730835,
0.13301144540309906,
-0.06543716043233871,
-0.7801374793052673,
0.19362802803516388,
0.8222801685333252,
0.14403007924556732,
0.25186803936958313,
0.19554363191127777,
-0.3630504906177521,
0.0855884924530983,
0.9277549386024475,
0.5493034720420837,
-0.5883841514587402,
-0.3685276508331299,
-0.3396444320678711,
0.0048308405093848705,
0.12687161564826965,
0.30949196219444275,
-0.6905312538146973,
0.7692123651504517,
0.2659153342247009,
0.8724485635757446,
0.8962475657463074,
0.14524619281291962,
0.3287906348705292,
-0.6796685457229614,
0.2160545140504837,
-0.005392133723944426,
0.11979741603136063,
0.2878912389278412,
-0.23764115571975708,
0.702873706817627,
0.26647332310676575,
-0.3749786913394928,
-0.8529376983642578,
0.26046761870384216,
-1.3776829242706299,
-0.05082426965236664,
1.026465892791748,
-0.24501170217990875,
-0.593560516834259,
-0.0666709691286087,
-0.22996777296066284,
0.5666062235832214,
-0.2276858687400818,
0.8261734247207642,
0.1936260163784027,
-0.11399561166763306,
-0.21929162740707397,
-0.1501491814851761,
0.30220678448677063,
0.07399145513772964,
-0.8761898875236511,
0.01492455042898655,
0.31276819109916687,
-0.002819985384121537,
0.5085776448249817,
0.5252249836921692,
0.11853958666324615,
0.066046804189682,
0.08566267043352127,
0.2806205451488495,
-0.25441625714302063,
-0.42707446217536926,
0.05717923492193222,
0.35891062021255493,
-0.20809638500213623,
-0.4175752103328705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11427v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11427v1 | DiTTo-TTS: Efficient and Scalable Zero-Shot Text-to-Speech with Diffusion Transformer | 2024-06-17T11:25:57 | 2024-06-17T11:25:57 | Keon Lee, Dong Won Kim, Jaehyeon Kim, Jaewoong Cho | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Large-scale diffusion models have shown outstanding generative abilities
across multiple modalities including images, videos, and audio. However,
text-to-speech (TTS) systems typically involve domain-specific modeling factors
(e.g., phonemes and phoneme-level durations) to ensure precise temporal
alignments between text and speech, which hinders the efficiency and
scalability of diffusion models for TTS. In this work, we present an efficient
and scalable Diffusion Transformer (DiT) that utilizes off-the-shelf
pre-trained text and speech encoders. Our approach addresses the challenge of
text-speech alignment via cross-attention mechanisms with the prediction of the
total length of speech representations. To achieve this, we enhance the DiT
architecture to suit TTS and improve the alignment by incorporating semantic
guidance into the latent space of speech. We scale the training dataset and the
model size to 82K hours and 790M parameters, respectively. Our extensive
experiments demonstrate that the large-scale diffusion model for TTS without
domain-specific modeling not only simplifies the training pipeline but also
yields superior or comparable zero-shot performance to state-of-the-art TTS
models in terms of naturalness, intelligibility, and speaker similarity. Our
speech samples are available at https://ditto-tts.github.io. | [
-0.23934999108314514,
-0.8938125967979431,
0.6404998302459717,
0.13443952798843384,
-0.5048781633377075,
0.1653129607439041,
-0.0377783440053463,
0.055926211178302765,
0.3055131733417511,
-0.04718388244509697,
-0.4650461673736572,
-0.2792057693004608,
-1.104907751083374,
0.05229899287223816,
-0.8904563784599304,
0.9050655364990234,
0.21190419793128967,
-0.0776192918419838,
0.16678071022033691,
0.11190731823444366,
-0.3523368537425995,
-0.007740600500255823,
-0.7146881818771362,
-0.16729366779327393,
0.5052585601806641,
0.18069715797901154,
0.5379132628440857,
0.5930561423301697,
0.22387957572937012,
0.27175256609916687,
-0.3608485758304596,
-0.2622353434562683,
-0.4390771985054016,
0.16689662635326385,
-0.21276062726974487,
-0.07791753113269806,
-0.43175116181373596,
-0.4368741512298584,
0.7396726608276367,
0.5139176249504089,
-0.4078023433685303,
0.1425996571779251,
0.05544368922710419,
0.5681485533714294,
-0.5114145874977112,
-0.34020063281059265,
-0.7239189743995667,
0.09640499949455261,
-0.3206298053264618,
0.09705574810504913,
-0.40095409750938416,
-0.10575930774211884,
0.5460034608840942,
-0.5460639595985413,
0.18108388781547546,
-0.3347475230693817,
0.5466399192810059,
0.7584436535835266,
-0.35106754302978516,
0.044759929180145264,
-0.9038488268852234,
0.6648522615432739,
-0.4900333285331726,
0.6362584233283997,
-0.1277620643377304,
0.5246320962905884,
0.17797903716564178,
-0.7580099105834961,
-0.829511284828186,
0.12706595659255981,
0.05088484659790993,
0.341631680727005,
-0.5510237812995911,
-0.197414368391037,
0.05926721170544624,
0.20241063833236694,
-0.8241910934448242,
0.07029406726360321,
0.11583212018013,
0.07255107164382935,
0.08624962717294693,
-0.10219898074865341,
0.16716106235980988,
0.09477175027132034,
-0.335494726896286,
0.03757853806018829,
-0.09864111989736557,
-0.49923521280288696,
0.09969709813594818,
0.23870965838432312,
-0.3389894664287567,
0.5153785347938538,
-0.000286702997982502,
0.908705472946167,
0.5064525604248047,
-0.18569518625736237,
0.2731020450592041,
-0.3279391825199127,
-0.22801366448402405,
0.3337031304836273,
0.9630131125450134,
-0.030070338398218155,
0.06911741942167282,
-0.45754003524780273,
0.09596818685531616,
0.10440218448638916,
0.35852348804473877,
-0.9522088766098022,
0.2430688887834549,
0.22556094825267792,
-0.03456132486462593,
-0.09037068486213684,
-0.370509535074234,
-1.0799659490585327,
-0.09291325509548187,
-0.12355871498584747,
0.7046018242835999,
-0.49932217597961426,
-0.4823075234889984,
0.38162562251091003,
-0.49222832918167114,
0.1449502408504486,
0.3350725769996643,
-0.892711877822876,
0.04169381782412529,
0.3409946858882904,
1.3680716753005981,
-0.3745031952857971,
-0.1135818287730217,
-0.6180717945098877,
0.4541211426258087,
-0.22978603839874268,
0.6020417213439941,
-0.5305832624435425,
-0.5013667345046997,
-0.0754808858036995,
-0.1626286804676056,
-0.16047045588493347,
-0.13085442781448364,
0.5801944732666016,
-0.33036839962005615,
0.23002292215824127,
0.29942217469215393,
-0.5618325471878052,
0.3617947995662689,
0.07734864950180054,
-0.4173952043056488,
0.7970666289329529,
0.08665668219327927,
-0.8047312498092651,
0.13743199408054352,
-0.9248508810997009,
-0.6131049990653992,
0.1596914827823639,
-0.022837523370981216,
-0.6741690635681152,
0.03960636258125305,
0.11246215552091599,
0.5513213276863098,
-0.3493956923484802,
0.27294814586639404,
-0.13085730373859406,
-0.3657529354095459,
0.02202596515417099,
-0.8477646708488464,
0.4539553225040436,
0.22875216603279114,
-0.689619779586792,
-0.08399021625518799,
-0.8579648733139038,
-0.39431431889533997,
0.2267053723335266,
0.11811944097280502,
-0.3039853870868683,
-0.19957302510738373,
0.1077943667769432,
0.03283664584159851,
0.22714491188526154,
-0.8055762052536011,
-0.027053389698266983,
-0.35208699107170105,
0.7747036218643188,
0.45055192708969116,
-0.24273337423801422,
0.9246117472648621,
-0.01450371090322733,
0.3652496933937073,
0.14283287525177002,
0.19731256365776062,
-0.38014790415763855,
-0.5015302896499634,
-0.513145923614502,
-0.6912230253219604,
0.29308152198791504,
0.4841677248477936,
-0.8542607426643372,
0.5608364343643188,
-0.7389837503433228,
-0.8323503136634827,
-0.5071513056755066,
-0.38309940695762634,
0.1746552735567093,
0.9234363436698914,
0.4547615945339203,
0.10496949404478073,
-0.220458984375,
-0.6179355382919312,
0.008939364925026894,
0.14454859495162964,
-0.21705931425094604,
-0.15328224003314972,
0.29926496744155884,
-0.3847914934158325,
1.1717844009399414,
-0.5662423372268677,
-0.33528807759284973,
0.0075581795535981655,
0.18548601865768433,
-0.002952129812911153,
0.3392833471298218,
0.6304159760475159,
-0.7709713578224182,
-0.8042797446250916,
0.1383664906024933,
-0.22077271342277527,
-0.12687093019485474,
0.13904017210006714,
-0.13046540319919586,
-0.009306426160037518,
0.3379581868648529,
-0.5926886200904846,
0.48873791098594666,
0.6677531003952026,
-0.3274833559989929,
0.055272385478019714,
-0.20054911077022552,
0.1632712036371231,
-1.5073353052139282,
0.17613321542739868,
0.2222689390182495,
-0.44962042570114136,
-0.8775166273117065,
-0.7300189137458801,
-0.026611318811774254,
-0.230768084526062,
-0.5537675023078918,
0.5067980885505676,
-0.09076908975839615,
0.10214027017354965,
-0.283979207277298,
0.37400662899017334,
0.026104722172021866,
0.26266324520111084,
0.3877257704734802,
0.999869704246521,
0.825638473033905,
-0.5641072988510132,
0.14562071859836578,
0.3680170476436615,
-0.010213674046099186,
1.1370667219161987,
-0.8443011045455933,
0.15229031443595886,
-0.23610781133174896,
0.32971784472465515,
-1.1706793308258057,
0.17108459770679474,
0.12932823598384857,
-0.4898766875267029,
0.4150691628456116,
-0.32615795731544495,
-0.47220155596733093,
-0.16806305944919586,
-0.2183966487646103,
0.3968489468097687,
0.8292029500007629,
-0.5611090660095215,
0.6912222504615784,
0.3630070984363556,
-0.35087645053863525,
-0.6606960296630859,
-0.8121791481971741,
0.05912873148918152,
-0.41902443766593933,
-0.3902789056301117,
0.8557507395744324,
-0.12067708373069763,
0.22856274247169495,
-0.07963850349187851,
-0.04014306887984276,
-0.3448820114135742,
-0.3249545693397522,
0.0501902736723423,
0.05630708113312721,
-0.047531358897686005,
0.14489683508872986,
0.39020469784736633,
-0.2536783516407013,
-0.4209130108356476,
-0.5940037369728088,
0.5094196796417236,
0.37446773052215576,
-0.23090283572673798,
-0.6566706895828247,
0.35520368814468384,
0.9404056072235107,
-0.10475116223096848,
0.7209938764572144,
0.7341139316558838,
-0.15154893696308136,
-0.021601354703307152,
-0.43198949098587036,
0.11370155960321426,
-0.42316436767578125,
0.48570168018341064,
-0.20640408992767334,
-0.9698153138160706,
0.13290289044380188,
-0.280569463968277,
0.03555873781442642,
0.44089075922966003,
0.4705652594566345,
-0.05880279839038849,
0.8167040944099426,
0.7382652759552002,
-0.17486733198165894,
0.9210634231567383,
-0.20362013578414917,
0.17909970879554749,
-0.6915211081504822,
0.051152199506759644,
-0.48717185854911804,
-0.23843234777450562,
-0.25679758191108704,
-0.7375960946083069,
0.38661906123161316,
-0.3266381025314331,
-0.38134780526161194,
0.4462984800338745,
-0.861189603805542,
0.3221192955970764,
0.13977593183517456,
-0.18838201463222504,
0.24824748933315277,
0.19283059239387512,
0.13561345636844635,
0.03417244181036949,
-0.6227001547813416,
-0.3689803183078766,
0.9673017263412476,
0.33468562364578247,
0.707685112953186,
0.16839179396629333,
0.6106467843055725,
0.263271689414978,
-0.1246315985918045,
-0.7103999853134155,
0.2428407073020935,
-0.4865827262401581,
-0.2457483410835266,
-0.7815034985542297,
-0.3735744059085846,
-0.7882885336875916,
0.05485778674483299,
-0.019563425332307816,
-0.5072455406188965,
0.12745486199855804,
-0.03438623994588852,
-0.43298831582069397,
0.3696812689304352,
-0.7332783937454224,
0.713221549987793,
-0.007567688822746277,
-0.35215896368026733,
-0.061918288469314575,
-0.6465463638305664,
-0.13996194303035736,
-0.3789331316947937,
0.04081650450825691,
0.14381572604179382,
-0.22584734857082367,
0.8000736832618713,
-0.32709798216819763,
0.7655423283576965,
-0.3143513798713684,
-0.35693806409835815,
0.19826234877109528,
-0.1840716451406479,
0.2474750131368637,
-0.059729352593421936,
0.05503359064459801,
0.45111238956451416,
-0.04222487658262253,
-0.1628212332725525,
-0.6280777454376221,
0.5741552114486694,
-0.6472035050392151,
-0.18661773204803467,
-0.27541685104370117,
-0.21621644496917725,
-0.1585407257080078,
0.30871546268463135,
0.5302276015281677,
0.3782288134098053,
-0.4054247736930847,
0.14172761142253876,
1.0300636291503906,
-0.03408927842974663,
0.7595851421356201,
0.641485869884491,
0.030696289613842964,
-0.51521235704422,
0.7977534532546997,
0.19417181611061096,
0.33409780263900757,
0.6977327466011047,
0.1388814002275467,
-0.6878551244735718,
-0.38338756561279297,
-0.7349503636360168,
0.3087787926197052,
-0.17823588848114014,
-0.28399842977523804,
-0.7445719242095947,
-0.28293925523757935,
-0.45808911323547363,
-0.22881807386875153,
-0.7661392688751221,
-0.42742881178855896,
-0.5863564014434814,
-0.0028443022165447474,
0.6081694960594177,
0.591177225112915,
0.08482339233160019,
0.7953417897224426,
-0.6160503029823303,
0.5770223140716553,
0.4413963556289673,
0.5445781350135803,
0.05350315943360329,
-1.0512906312942505,
-0.1144779622554779,
0.12878471612930298,
-0.2708345651626587,
-0.7605246901512146,
0.23461073637008667,
0.2339344024658203,
0.2475484311580658,
0.2983042597770691,
-0.09321163594722748,
1.0119316577911377,
-1.1283085346221924,
0.7597448229789734,
0.5923559665679932,
-1.208972454071045,
0.6600421071052551,
-0.22781357169151306,
0.5191649198532104,
0.271994411945343,
0.40823978185653687,
-0.4815791845321655,
-0.25695282220840454,
-0.3221200704574585,
-0.6491202116012573,
0.6936826109886169,
0.45328545570373535,
0.2347642183303833,
-0.02455054596066475,
0.4001303017139435,
0.1761745661497116,
0.023296765983104706,
-0.4482653737068176,
-0.4000069797039032,
-0.5013506412506104,
-0.5300992727279663,
-0.2612141966819763,
-0.15901876986026764,
0.062313079833984375,
-0.18477937579154968,
0.5299209952354431,
-0.03485279157757759,
0.22171258926391602,
0.3325376510620117,
-0.08959750086069107,
-0.006515780929476023,
0.4342994689941406,
0.6411725282669067,
0.21361380815505981,
0.0518675297498703,
-0.01256418414413929,
0.10057477653026581,
-0.7014118432998657,
0.5370680689811707,
0.3794906735420227,
0.016864685341715813,
0.3966233432292938,
-0.036296118050813675,
0.7849433422088623,
0.1537831723690033,
-0.4260074198246002,
0.8438310623168945,
-0.3014628291130066,
-0.3415305018424988,
-0.21469861268997192,
-0.36086562275886536,
0.16570685803890228,
0.22115583717823029,
0.38092055916786194,
-0.11006028205156326,
0.15034730732440948,
-0.015470338985323906,
0.2667486369609833,
0.3914831876754761,
-0.3979756534099579,
-0.35953661799430847,
0.8850409984588623,
0.4242856800556183,
-0.4919470250606537,
0.16341087222099304,
0.08883566409349442,
-0.05145789310336113,
0.11705469340085983,
0.534930944442749,
1.1203875541687012,
-0.5243256688117981,
0.5527196526527405,
0.057911042124032974,
0.010543204843997955,
-0.18827658891677856,
-0.2355125993490219,
-0.4208100140094757,
-0.37131962180137634,
-0.49225330352783203,
-0.7100805044174194,
-0.32101932168006897,
-0.10514102131128311,
-0.42089229822158813,
0.31954941153526306,
-0.11812909692525864,
-0.4645780026912689,
0.18520504236221313,
-0.5263045430183411,
-0.3845290243625641,
0.20187093317508698,
0.17236627638339996,
0.6795965433120728,
-0.7466701865196228,
0.9564309120178223,
0.3385379910469055,
-0.14852067828178406,
-0.3493664860725403,
0.16326852142810822,
-0.340988427400589,
-0.46932652592658997,
0.560245156288147,
0.028354335576295853,
-0.5268109440803528,
0.2896389961242676,
-0.0037209957372397184,
-0.8682035207748413,
1.2121144533157349,
0.7548527717590332,
-1.1887357234954834,
-0.12402132898569107,
0.48195844888687134,
0.6375467777252197,
-0.06012504920363426,
0.4219692647457123,
0.4391053318977356,
0.13021482527256012,
0.6619051694869995,
-1.042250156402588,
-0.38722458481788635,
0.20229242742061615,
0.20509415864944458,
0.3101018965244293,
-0.6172458529472351,
0.502580463886261,
0.21243061125278473,
-0.18032191693782806,
-0.11499874293804169,
0.48706361651420593,
-0.19085493683815002,
0.2765970230102539,
0.6065536737442017,
0.8552886247634888,
0.40656423568725586,
-0.07460399717092514,
0.4997453987598419,
-0.12478674948215485,
0.21572960913181305,
1.000762701034546,
-0.4517766833305359,
0.8280949592590332,
0.5138303637504578,
-0.167812317609787,
0.4514533281326294,
0.11992170661687851,
0.40857818722724915,
0.9146363139152527,
-0.14013411104679108,
-0.2849360406398773,
0.08414743840694427,
0.009503177367150784,
-0.43002399802207947,
0.3664396107196808,
0.13957332074642181,
-0.18269936740398407,
-0.3233588635921478,
0.21202488243579865,
-0.15201783180236816,
0.059610478579998016,
-0.14391227066516876,
0.9747521281242371,
-0.1714172065258026,
-0.3715534806251526,
0.4417678415775299,
-0.3366951644420624,
1.1504600048065186,
-0.7773566246032715,
-0.019456684589385986,
-0.07979567348957062,
0.06553895771503448,
-0.007919002324342728,
-0.7868326306343079,
0.5314117074012756,
0.46569859981536865,
-0.33516189455986023,
-0.4998818337917328,
0.3924485445022583,
-0.4975813925266266,
-0.44506505131721497,
0.3820827007293701,
0.3516937792301178,
-0.10978568345308304,
-0.154518261551857,
-0.6095191240310669,
0.04449986666440964,
-0.2110091894865036,
-0.07634442299604416,
0.328725129365921,
0.8076589107513428,
0.4465313255786896,
0.4183850586414337,
0.2977530360221863,
-0.07178617268800735,
0.12361195683479309,
0.2534467875957489,
0.658180832862854,
-0.38438892364501953,
-0.5040212869644165,
-1.2088830471038818,
0.6872534155845642,
-0.17725305259227753,
-0.1313401758670807,
0.5273342728614807,
0.6817234754562378,
0.431287556886673,
0.006977799814194441,
0.6930191516876221,
0.12615039944648743,
0.7642630338668823,
-0.15156814455986023,
0.8367248177528381,
-0.5781969428062439,
-0.10761924833059311,
-0.6078827977180481,
-0.8708756566047668,
-0.15870164334774017,
0.5515338182449341,
-0.14431804418563843,
-0.10943064838647842,
0.4809126555919647,
0.47640132904052734,
-0.07919955253601074,
-0.22862344980239868,
0.6094958782196045,
0.005106240976601839,
0.38009172677993774,
0.3584969639778137,
0.577924370765686,
-0.525775671005249,
0.8055648803710938,
-0.04671785607933998,
-0.45769035816192627,
0.08273380994796753,
-0.8613734841346741,
-0.7282444834709167,
-0.8351935744285583,
-0.594092607498169,
0.1527082920074463,
0.07375260442495346,
0.19985510408878326,
0.8083164095878601,
-0.27902287244796753,
-0.007162574212998152,
-0.3367147445678711,
-0.10388078540563583,
0.060695115476846695,
-0.1941600739955902,
0.24570828676223755,
-0.1565195918083191,
-1.0266480445861816,
0.25279900431632996,
0.7463415265083313,
0.5068231821060181,
-0.10623089969158173,
0.06043015047907829,
-0.18924590945243835,
0.2562161087989807,
0.7375335693359375,
-0.007138493936508894,
-0.5239127278327942,
-0.10052229464054108,
0.013862231746315956,
-0.012846999801695347,
0.0745173767209053,
0.46519380807876587,
-0.773703932762146,
0.501066267490387,
0.16923482716083527,
0.7607520818710327,
0.6834018230438232,
-0.2184913456439972,
0.4053192138671875,
-0.7612695097923279,
0.38877493143081665,
0.26454681158065796,
0.19788789749145508,
0.2798899710178375,
-0.3009476661682129,
0.25765499472618103,
0.010372324846684933,
-0.5485063195228577,
-0.733187198638916,
0.08849741518497467,
-1.1116276979446411,
-0.16021013259887695,
1.0028260946273804,
-0.006366279907524586,
-0.1165563315153122,
0.08697222918272018,
-0.3493877947330475,
0.6146444082260132,
-0.4515392780303955,
0.6096871495246887,
0.39287084341049194,
0.12907683849334717,
-0.11998707801103592,
-0.05320742353796959,
0.3308390974998474,
0.3321288228034973,
-0.6430290937423706,
0.14247047901153564,
0.2736568748950958,
0.45769360661506653,
0.31956419348716736,
0.7384623885154724,
-0.16514071822166443,
-0.01272610668092966,
0.00847146101295948,
-0.2521865963935852,
0.2613617181777954,
-0.20773068070411682,
-0.5755265355110168,
0.05107729509472847,
-0.37678253650665283,
-0.6236054301261902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11424v1 | Evaluating the Efficacy of Open-Source LLMs in Enterprise-Specific RAG Systems: A Comparative Study of Performance and Scalability | 2024-06-17T11:22:25 | 2024-06-17T11:22:25 | Gautam B, Anupam Purwar | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | This paper presents an analysis of open-source large language models (LLMs)
and their application in Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) tasks, specific
for enterprise-specific data sets scraped from their websites. With the
increasing reliance on LLMs in natural language processing, it is crucial to
evaluate their performance, accessibility, and integration within specific
organizational contexts. This study examines various open-source LLMs, explores
their integration into RAG frameworks using enterprise-specific data, and
assesses the performance of different open-source embeddings in enhancing the
retrieval and generation process. Our findings indicate that open-source LLMs,
combined with effective embedding techniques, can significantly improve the
accuracy and efficiency of RAG systems, offering a viable alternative to
proprietary solutions for enterprises. | [
-0.3777155578136444,
-0.8025490641593933,
0.6513962149620056,
0.3224267363548279,
-0.0599936917424202,
0.097091905772686,
-0.40511301159858704,
-0.6957306265830994,
0.4054033160209656,
0.7197762727737427,
-0.03918056935071945,
-0.504375696182251,
-0.2625706195831299,
0.21242274343967438,
-0.47849321365356445,
0.6262707114219666,
-0.003625452285632491,
0.1842695027589798,
-0.3335849344730377,
-0.3197465240955353,
-0.14217093586921692,
-0.5023348331451416,
-0.6676589250564575,
-0.09121902287006378,
0.3742988109588623,
0.30122601985931396,
0.6392745971679688,
0.6236606240272522,
0.8988301753997803,
0.270273357629776,
-0.10594109445810318,
0.018686046823859215,
-0.5236721634864807,
0.3804463744163513,
-0.6156072616577148,
-0.3855039179325104,
-0.6784210801124573,
-0.10867694020271301,
0.8501877784729004,
0.5272582769393921,
-0.37853848934173584,
0.5324290990829468,
0.10780805349349976,
0.6151934266090393,
-0.8467046618461609,
-0.050024934113025665,
-0.7551735639572144,
-0.03792263939976692,
-0.3715967535972595,
0.003026670543476939,
-0.5456146597862244,
-0.6227537393569946,
-0.09911615401506424,
-0.3130660355091095,
0.07099781930446625,
0.3113210201263428,
0.5906777381896973,
0.13333413004875183,
0.022355198860168457,
-0.5727830529212952,
-0.8674339056015015,
0.9915279150009155,
-0.7916402816772461,
0.568307638168335,
0.16950346529483795,
0.27821484208106995,
-0.08430273085832596,
-0.9268471598625183,
-0.15047621726989746,
-0.234770268201828,
-0.05562784895300865,
0.021639330312609673,
-0.3839271366596222,
-0.10278554260730743,
0.08647498488426208,
0.660030722618103,
-0.5775219202041626,
0.6179606318473816,
-0.2999078333377838,
0.2849293351173401,
0.3346286416053772,
0.341487318277359,
0.1369922012090683,
-0.011430822312831879,
-0.2868172526359558,
0.10621451586484909,
-0.6686795353889465,
-0.31501275300979614,
0.21717290580272675,
0.5203787684440613,
0.23555760085582733,
1.0766650438308716,
-0.04918665438890457,
0.5662475228309631,
-0.16566267609596252,
-0.10776326805353165,
0.2887413799762726,
-0.09271929413080215,
-0.673895001411438,
-0.09572562575340271,
0.6848397254943848,
0.011869138106703758,
0.05349365621805191,
-0.5157243609428406,
-0.41335082054138184,
-0.19159987568855286,
0.42847463488578796,
-0.550195038318634,
0.3356800377368927,
0.3637721836566925,
-0.619942843914032,
-0.2529308795928955,
0.1794426441192627,
-0.7777581214904785,
-0.4586999714374542,
-0.21117348968982697,
0.2920268476009369,
-0.21479426324367523,
-0.32153886556625366,
-0.07281141728162766,
-0.3672933280467987,
0.2695819139480591,
0.18509899079799652,
-0.34872663021087646,
0.4640534818172455,
0.8731654286384583,
1.114304542541504,
-0.23776230216026306,
0.04338221251964569,
-0.6643489003181458,
0.46667519211769104,
-0.4270856976509094,
0.555891215801239,
-0.5066822171211243,
-0.3285609781742096,
0.1913287192583084,
-0.17837905883789062,
0.2074270099401474,
-0.9663464426994324,
0.7810530662536621,
-0.8671168684959412,
-0.05034849792718887,
0.05263408273458481,
-0.7152045369148254,
0.10496490448713303,
0.1292082518339157,
-1.0510427951812744,
0.9199780821800232,
0.11111107468605042,
-0.7056801319122314,
0.22167062759399414,
-0.8511523008346558,
-0.21634452044963837,
0.3635692298412323,
-0.12905092537403107,
-0.29794028401374817,
0.3896656036376953,
-0.08765444904565811,
0.4787847697734833,
-0.53446364402771,
-0.16529172658920288,
-0.4336746335029602,
-0.1682722121477127,
0.02034742198884487,
0.13798193633556366,
0.7936985492706299,
0.47529488801956177,
-0.1055481806397438,
-0.08145470917224884,
-0.7823209166526794,
0.265512615442276,
0.3398684859275818,
-0.4878397583961487,
-0.8410258293151855,
0.12345308065414429,
-0.03694561868906021,
-0.22360634803771973,
0.44462084770202637,
-0.5547599196434021,
0.05354832112789154,
-0.2936321794986725,
-0.14745570719242096,
0.6194779276847839,
-0.16784058511257172,
0.5664187073707581,
-0.14954540133476257,
0.49740347266197205,
-0.1484631597995758,
-0.10544593632221222,
-0.07696586102247238,
-0.37148842215538025,
-0.5683425068855286,
-0.5549236536026001,
0.3102199137210846,
0.5683760046958923,
-0.457865834236145,
0.24577559530735016,
-0.233819842338562,
-0.6080797910690308,
-0.47219133377075195,
0.10674130916595459,
0.29868319630622864,
0.30903083086013794,
0.3643203675746918,
-0.3677521049976349,
-0.6548933982849121,
-0.9786220192909241,
-0.5532491207122803,
0.1512652188539505,
-0.36582690477371216,
0.4349958002567291,
0.3209325075149536,
-0.2174348533153534,
1.0666987895965576,
-0.5003157258033752,
-0.23643113672733307,
-0.2821609079837799,
0.15808172523975372,
0.33049848675727844,
0.15106047689914703,
0.5145142078399658,
-0.5016874670982361,
-0.5555474758148193,
0.1995759755373001,
-0.7025328874588013,
-0.2331964075565338,
0.48043447732925415,
0.17470099031925201,
0.5924388766288757,
0.4096367657184601,
-0.38195303082466125,
0.4306658208370209,
0.6676191687583923,
-0.24095408618450165,
0.7517077326774597,
-0.28390002250671387,
0.07797803729772568,
-0.9681550860404968,
0.3836596608161926,
0.09560175985097885,
-0.4029482901096344,
-0.5831254720687866,
0.2815300524234772,
0.1603642851114273,
-0.054003726691007614,
-0.48507001996040344,
0.522107720375061,
-0.7414296269416809,
-0.6892707347869873,
-0.15766505897045135,
0.5221048593521118,
-0.16130810976028442,
-0.04698270559310913,
-0.10739288479089737,
0.94081711769104,
0.17063245177268982,
-0.7460162043571472,
0.230601966381073,
0.15470018982887268,
-0.6205870509147644,
0.7674565315246582,
-0.6627664566040039,
0.09605588018894196,
-0.14298512041568756,
0.00440169358626008,
-0.4906770884990692,
-0.15105311572551727,
-0.02712021954357624,
-0.27057981491088867,
0.24309042096138,
-0.05781494081020355,
-0.6157509684562683,
-0.14072838425636292,
-0.21041284501552582,
-0.14288407564163208,
0.6413141489028931,
-0.545387327671051,
0.47236061096191406,
0.47951608896255493,
-0.29242509603500366,
-0.5867675542831421,
-0.8059203624725342,
0.2005850225687027,
-0.2363889068365097,
-0.7127332091331482,
0.30924445390701294,
0.1597852110862732,
-0.7724466323852539,
0.3581254780292511,
0.006835361942648888,
-0.14882279932498932,
0.10720273852348328,
-0.13036972284317017,
0.08234590291976929,
-0.503875195980072,
-0.031686633825302124,
-0.2759077548980713,
0.2984018623828888,
-0.06909742206335068,
-0.23104628920555115,
0.3795931935310364,
-0.20076343417167664,
-0.4489407241344452,
0.07720974832773209,
0.29329198598861694,
0.45272591710090637,
-0.4309852123260498,
1.2090888023376465,
0.4037657380104065,
-0.3247849643230438,
-0.5042623281478882,
-0.6035856604576111,
0.2021314948797226,
-0.4576645791530609,
0.3074154853820801,
-0.12967921793460846,
-0.8784816265106201,
0.3558436334133148,
-0.3608686327934265,
0.22348806262016296,
0.46573325991630554,
0.576135516166687,
-0.1700638234615326,
0.6731895804405212,
0.776157021522522,
-0.06872007250785828,
0.4415398836135864,
-0.1481153964996338,
0.15917439758777618,
-0.9207437634468079,
-0.13402383029460907,
-0.9820164442062378,
-0.28013771772384644,
-0.6170041561126709,
-0.6500226259231567,
0.26919007301330566,
0.3010838031768799,
-0.3888954520225525,
0.0839230939745903,
-0.2156207114458084,
0.5012010931968689,
0.3838263750076294,
-0.21243295073509216,
0.5937419533729553,
0.11874944716691971,
-0.1860068291425705,
0.13138408958911896,
-0.4398866593837738,
-0.856836199760437,
0.9572389721870422,
0.5052064061164856,
0.9246126413345337,
0.44796690344810486,
0.5595462322235107,
0.3469495177268982,
0.3780849874019623,
-0.5773937702178955,
0.5034616589546204,
-0.5916521549224854,
-0.5753415822982788,
-0.46622809767723083,
-0.542823076248169,
-0.9897234439849854,
0.12575429677963257,
-0.0456092432141304,
-0.9242897629737854,
-0.026208816096186638,
-0.18615490198135376,
0.21796417236328125,
0.7092934250831604,
-0.4931088984012604,
0.48132526874542236,
-0.27596941590309143,
-0.3745846748352051,
-0.2517925202846527,
-0.08877377957105637,
0.33278316259384155,
-0.2886278033256531,
0.29997989535331726,
0.10608864575624466,
-0.4897285997867584,
0.6700392961502075,
-0.19829416275024414,
0.4681262969970703,
-0.22586502134799957,
-0.10901065170764923,
0.2204919010400772,
0.09407587349414825,
0.648261547088623,
-0.33847373723983765,
-0.35333749651908875,
0.3598376512527466,
-0.4265446960926056,
-0.13115151226520538,
-0.46201008558273315,
0.8316408395767212,
-0.38196322321891785,
-0.4716768264770508,
-0.2302900105714798,
-0.23365874588489532,
-0.3526837229728699,
0.3826535940170288,
-0.13939322531223297,
0.24281753599643707,
-0.5459182262420654,
0.7086127400398254,
0.8305156826972961,
-0.37982937693595886,
0.4280409514904022,
0.7395428419113159,
-0.5836588740348816,
-0.48089271783828735,
0.6524883508682251,
0.12327262759208679,
0.310211718082428,
0.2853018343448639,
0.09261523187160492,
-0.22991766035556793,
-0.5595250725746155,
-0.32543641328811646,
0.35146018862724304,
-0.5634689927101135,
-0.20167827606201172,
-0.4459272027015686,
-0.022462526336312294,
-0.3104029893875122,
-0.21372567117214203,
-0.49314573407173157,
-0.5521314144134521,
-0.30072343349456787,
0.11654016375541687,
0.23264969885349274,
1.2325623035430908,
0.006083021406084299,
-0.012764787301421165,
-0.8444566130638123,
0.2683391571044922,
-0.22133757174015045,
1.046687126159668,
0.10299645364284515,
-0.13967469334602356,
-0.6346734762191772,
-0.06492119282484055,
-0.2803589105606079,
-0.9982398152351379,
0.3500267267227173,
-0.13221882283687592,
0.8472804427146912,
0.10038502514362335,
-0.08251295238733292,
0.4380958378314972,
-0.6389583945274353,
0.9687634110450745,
0.08690609782934189,
-0.7820354700088501,
0.3123340904712677,
-0.357530802488327,
0.05775335058569908,
0.2403624951839447,
0.692906379699707,
-0.2574038803577423,
-0.5112000107765198,
-0.4007740318775177,
-1.0614033937454224,
0.8216536641120911,
0.12483398616313934,
-0.2742249369621277,
0.14110466837882996,
0.11657938361167908,
-0.08988579362630844,
0.21022823452949524,
-0.29325854778289795,
-0.45097893476486206,
0.3070414662361145,
-0.1492820382118225,
-0.11834539473056793,
-0.3055134415626526,
0.07472477853298187,
0.30857518315315247,
0.7721726894378662,
0.17122161388397217,
0.2737712860107422,
0.05199988931417465,
-0.1779353767633438,
-0.17614535987377167,
0.3939291536808014,
0.31525829434394836,
0.7868179678916931,
-0.2805251181125641,
-0.260451078414917,
0.22291405498981476,
-0.49235445261001587,
-0.025414422154426575,
-0.2507363557815552,
-0.09318934381008148,
0.3317858576774597,
-0.09281730651855469,
0.5219094753265381,
0.130258247256279,
-0.6926180720329285,
0.2314063459634781,
0.05332568287849426,
0.07857025414705276,
-0.3184179961681366,
-0.13769493997097015,
0.3661141097545624,
0.48644623160362244,
0.4396165907382965,
-0.42162129282951355,
0.17586474120616913,
-0.4078234136104584,
0.030576052144169807,
0.7096208333969116,
0.11086243391036987,
0.08695542067289352,
0.5464919209480286,
-0.0018905552569776773,
-0.6554434895515442,
0.49412840604782104,
0.18398524820804596,
-0.05684569478034973,
0.41009193658828735,
0.697472870349884,
1.203436017036438,
-0.3718084394931793,
-0.10609974712133408,
0.3088633716106415,
0.4186781942844391,
-0.055626433342695236,
0.19653278589248657,
0.2541790306568146,
-0.3802112936973572,
-0.5461448431015015,
-0.8392520546913147,
-0.8761263489723206,
0.27909737825393677,
-0.8242460489273071,
0.3766607940196991,
-0.2964969575405121,
-0.3091374933719635,
-0.19463342428207397,
-0.20310410857200623,
-0.6821160912513733,
-0.029498087242245674,
-0.09404854476451874,
1.3973116874694824,
-0.3072945475578308,
0.4825748801231384,
0.9551812410354614,
-0.4868345856666565,
-0.5991325378417969,
0.025185955688357353,
-0.357791543006897,
-0.48020514845848083,
0.7604260444641113,
-0.31978747248649597,
-0.23115947842597961,
-0.2278325855731964,
-0.3165867328643799,
-0.9999381303787231,
1.156265377998352,
0.338279128074646,
-0.5061693787574768,
-0.1252480149269104,
0.3601852059364319,
0.5832096338272095,
-0.20178914070129395,
0.30808383226394653,
0.42055773735046387,
0.5161102414131165,
-0.20080703496932983,
-1.207543134689331,
-0.18963909149169922,
0.17132225632667542,
0.08155404776334763,
0.41529276967048645,
-0.5225697159767151,
0.7167405486106873,
0.15879233181476593,
-0.27652615308761597,
0.041302088648080826,
0.5903916954994202,
0.1945929378271103,
0.38851386308670044,
0.2571875751018524,
0.8133955597877502,
0.689510703086853,
0.2022460550069809,
1.0602717399597168,
-0.2590080797672272,
0.41820627450942993,
1.2261337041854858,
-0.4156797230243683,
1.3543884754180908,
0.40198469161987305,
-0.2690846920013428,
0.6279687285423279,
-0.18122543394565582,
0.10777780413627625,
0.2706300616264343,
0.19421949982643127,
-0.2067032903432846,
0.3909018933773041,
0.020403727889060974,
-0.2507758140563965,
0.3124467134475708,
0.43057355284690857,
-0.6533645987510681,
-0.39015647768974304,
-0.23535944521427155,
0.029468415305018425,
0.04255205765366554,
-0.4918811321258545,
0.9483365416526794,
0.16757084429264069,
-0.4507373869419098,
0.30994001030921936,
0.3511829972267151,
0.675133228302002,
-0.701716959476471,
0.15728825330734253,
-0.1285925954580307,
0.2767956852912903,
-0.4095054864883423,
-0.9141395688056946,
0.7520696520805359,
0.6018197536468506,
-0.184377983212471,
-0.3363172709941864,
0.8438214659690857,
-0.08857991546392441,
-0.04971907660365105,
0.38815590739250183,
0.6765116453170776,
0.2802562713623047,
0.06913857161998749,
-0.38106659054756165,
0.26656603813171387,
-0.3375851511955261,
-0.5957316160202026,
0.5123398303985596,
0.4317047894001007,
0.0840616300702095,
0.529163658618927,
0.44774842262268066,
0.40581536293029785,
0.16923843324184418,
-0.14783695340156555,
0.691013753414154,
-0.6520968675613403,
-0.28833651542663574,
-0.6300907135009766,
0.5316897034645081,
-0.188092902302742,
0.2835797965526581,
1.051082730293274,
0.8249820470809937,
0.8847448825836182,
-0.22963543236255646,
0.8029323220252991,
-0.1798902004957199,
1.0118157863616943,
-0.4249156713485718,
0.7850738763809204,
-0.6670202016830444,
0.3699338734149933,
-0.4122668504714966,
-1.060949444770813,
-0.126444011926651,
0.32374855875968933,
-0.2631177008152008,
-0.029188785701990128,
0.6284482479095459,
0.7457060217857361,
-0.13281980156898499,
0.00046838977141305804,
0.3917462229728699,
0.2771327495574951,
0.2589379847049713,
-0.12937702238559723,
0.7180874943733215,
0.02670561522245407,
0.3977447748184204,
-0.02937624603509903,
-0.22638416290283203,
-0.2985277473926544,
-1.1708378791809082,
-0.36583057045936584,
-0.48997241258621216,
0.012567462399601936,
-0.3216407299041748,
0.013540836982429028,
0.6547346115112305,
0.13479259610176086,
-0.6214520931243896,
-0.45873767137527466,
0.10852384567260742,
0.06548703461885452,
0.053503040224313736,
-0.2926670014858246,
0.0813947319984436,
-0.6290575861930847,
-0.7808789014816284,
0.5452616810798645,
0.30937665700912476,
-0.22892625629901886,
-0.5682827234268188,
-0.12539415061473846,
-0.15560133755207062,
0.3328135907649994,
0.7307223081588745,
0.16433076560497284,
-0.5753755569458008,
0.06593240797519684,
0.21029052138328552,
-0.2496376931667328,
-0.07483205199241638,
0.8798280954360962,
-0.7376497983932495,
0.14997707307338715,
0.6263196468353271,
0.8118062019348145,
0.2676941752433777,
0.09601420909166336,
0.3678581714630127,
-0.6827042698860168,
-0.20205971598625183,
0.4234478771686554,
0.39109811186790466,
0.20608274638652802,
-0.21650582551956177,
0.756105363368988,
-0.14154955744743347,
-0.8493519425392151,
-1.0049341917037964,
0.07060523331165314,
-0.6303148865699768,
-0.3759446144104004,
1.2646158933639526,
-0.17169058322906494,
-0.23153115808963776,
-0.021000804379582405,
0.008268075995147228,
0.08296123892068863,
-0.21585415303707123,
0.20212453603744507,
0.4748455584049225,
-0.17509420216083527,
0.2222791165113449,
-0.5737127661705017,
0.16498282551765442,
-0.06556017696857452,
-0.8469608426094055,
0.004208371043205261,
0.6159815788269043,
0.3164582848548889,
0.25273028016090393,
0.5603801012039185,
-0.32394570112228394,
-0.045025330036878586,
-0.13293468952178955,
0.12522679567337036,
-0.10961684584617615,
-0.1677480936050415,
-0.4710511267185211,
0.3717479407787323,
0.35657986998558044,
-0.027165139093995094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11423v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11423v1 | Dredge Word, Social Media, and Webgraph Networks for Unreliable Website Classification and Identification | 2024-06-17T11:22:04 | 2024-06-17T11:22:04 | Evan M. Williams, Peter Carragher, Kathleen M. Carley | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | In an attempt to mimic the complex paths through which unreliable content
spreads between search engines and social media, we explore the impact of
incorporating both webgraph and large-scale social media contexts into website
credibility classification and discovery systems. We further explore the usage
of what we define as \textit{dredge words} on social media -- terms or phrases
for which unreliable domains rank highly. Through comprehensive graph neural
network ablations, we demonstrate that curriculum-based heterogeneous graph
models that leverage context from both webgraphs and social media data
outperform homogeneous and single-mode approaches. We further demonstrate that
the incorporation of dredge words into our model strongly associates unreliable
websites with social media and online commerce platforms. Finally, we show our
heterogeneous model greatly outperforms competing systems in the top-k
identification of unlabeled unreliable websites. We demonstrate the strong
unreliability signals present in the diverse paths that users follow to uncover
unreliable content, and we release a novel dataset of dredge words. | [
-0.16410326957702637,
-1.3201148509979248,
0.4464047849178314,
0.2036239504814148,
-0.28731000423431396,
0.7271363139152527,
0.021390549838542938,
-0.6370171904563904,
0.4912276566028595,
0.059352900832891464,
-0.5084827542304993,
-0.35242459177970886,
-0.8893894553184509,
-0.19870589673519135,
-0.6184720396995544,
0.7227889895439148,
-0.08951078355312347,
-0.042598363012075424,
-0.08804663270711899,
-0.19582535326480865,
-0.25357577204704285,
-0.22033558785915375,
-0.7447097301483154,
-0.29984456300735474,
0.806387722492218,
0.1264769732952118,
1.1203272342681885,
0.8414355516433716,
0.6154770255088806,
0.4237695336341858,
0.10755240172147751,
0.3184131681919098,
-0.8269810080528259,
0.1142309233546257,
-0.6935325860977173,
0.13561080396175385,
-0.21447055041790009,
0.28348180651664734,
0.3966664671897888,
0.9936750531196594,
-0.2672773003578186,
0.308426171541214,
0.27436912059783936,
0.18378739058971405,
-0.7551782727241516,
0.26931247115135193,
-0.7544196248054504,
-0.156097874045372,
-0.3151853680610657,
-0.37640970945358276,
-0.3169022798538208,
-0.41899552941322327,
-0.012680196203291416,
-0.6875695586204529,
0.2565763592720032,
0.010547682642936707,
1.1065829992294312,
0.11760708689689636,
-0.34161192178726196,
-0.4486691951751709,
-0.7610741257667542,
0.6879417896270752,
-0.2557581067085266,
0.29637184739112854,
0.44921982288360596,
0.34808802604675293,
-0.3553377091884613,
-1.506529450416565,
-0.41892415285110474,
0.2303558886051178,
-0.1183895468711853,
0.20473697781562805,
-0.26990801095962524,
-0.02322096936404705,
-0.08211106806993484,
0.1262010931968689,
-0.2295057624578476,
0.3133000433444977,
-0.5133856534957886,
-0.694553792476654,
0.6593755483627319,
0.1601915806531906,
0.44901302456855774,
-0.2997581660747528,
-0.35443076491355896,
-0.0024578820448368788,
-0.32277703285217285,
-0.15615054965019226,
0.7039849162101746,
0.7487382888793945,
0.11762428283691406,
0.39565879106521606,
0.027175065129995346,
0.6288827061653137,
0.033284012228250504,
-0.34258410334587097,
0.272936075925827,
0.01365931797772646,
-0.03327899053692818,
0.22478905320167542,
0.7762108445167542,
0.43161311745643616,
-0.09455705434083939,
-0.35200026631355286,
-0.23546986281871796,
0.3295442461967468,
0.5779805183410645,
-0.33434802293777466,
-0.42222997546195984,
0.20971189439296722,
-0.6430788040161133,
-0.45650237798690796,
0.35060158371925354,
-0.7912770509719849,
-0.6359801292419434,
-0.09510505199432373,
0.6917814016342163,
-0.302956223487854,
-0.4751380681991577,
-0.31970247626304626,
-0.8147931694984436,
-0.5092760920524597,
0.25937798619270325,
-0.20273587107658386,
0.2551265060901642,
0.5935405492782593,
1.074353814125061,
0.0371418260037899,
-0.5239005088806152,
-0.49315541982650757,
-0.07760389149188995,
-0.334203839302063,
0.6474364995956421,
-0.5912278890609741,
-0.024877291172742844,
0.5462663173675537,
0.37029901146888733,
0.05936111882328987,
-0.1688944399356842,
0.5555598735809326,
-0.9564926624298096,
-0.12023243308067322,
-0.08678864687681198,
-0.5436493158340454,
-0.37196314334869385,
0.08374802768230438,
-0.9887859225273132,
0.72134929895401,
0.36310791969299316,
-0.9447519183158875,
0.2700398862361908,
-0.29667434096336365,
-0.7393146753311157,
0.41323530673980713,
0.05239832028746605,
-0.2470720410346985,
0.13136690855026245,
-0.6295410990715027,
0.5003824830055237,
0.03429711237549782,
0.018422415480017662,
-0.8624892830848694,
-0.599066436290741,
0.20915129780769348,
-0.6289781928062439,
0.9933783411979675,
0.3424307703971863,
-0.4917336404323578,
-0.3634178042411804,
-0.6878833174705505,
0.10247093439102173,
0.556936502456665,
-0.31323978304862976,
-0.6751249432563782,
0.2474125772714615,
0.12353960424661636,
0.12323310971260071,
0.3509694039821625,
-0.4280990660190582,
-0.08629937469959259,
0.18398593366146088,
0.7227555513381958,
0.9872249960899353,
0.2303595095872879,
0.03134428709745407,
-0.3294790983200073,
0.250084787607193,
0.003850688459351659,
-0.08618197590112686,
0.33547866344451904,
-0.487478643655777,
-0.4180721342563629,
-0.09595969319343567,
0.384598046541214,
0.3613310754299164,
-0.9086765050888062,
-0.05097389593720436,
-0.6112995743751526,
-0.7135160565376282,
-0.37582042813301086,
0.017026668414473534,
0.20348629355430603,
0.5920745730400085,
0.5332484245300293,
-0.4788154661655426,
-0.28191864490509033,
-0.6438958048820496,
-0.3225348889827728,
-0.20962290465831757,
0.20888997614383698,
0.4665777087211609,
0.23365887999534607,
-0.4044879078865051,
0.6213443875312805,
-0.33703041076660156,
-0.28505662083625793,
-0.0725368931889534,
0.5487781763076782,
0.06697668880224228,
-0.062849260866642,
0.32439616322517395,
-1.037755012512207,
-0.5347179174423218,
-0.35537710785865784,
-0.791952908039093,
0.13052308559417725,
0.07336921244859695,
0.13250339031219482,
-0.05945426970720291,
0.28871509432792664,
-0.18331065773963928,
0.2957836389541626,
0.5032164454460144,
-0.23920725286006927,
0.4285286068916321,
-0.1063002198934555,
0.09838101267814636,
-0.708223819732666,
-0.2590084671974182,
0.32778286933898926,
-0.23193469643592834,
-0.49070659279823303,
0.1360676884651184,
-0.018400169909000397,
0.1306459605693817,
-0.3487323522567749,
0.2496514767408371,
-0.5633191466331482,
0.0008802664815448225,
-0.37339842319488525,
0.6748799681663513,
0.005719782318919897,
0.07763110846281052,
-0.195777028799057,
0.46571221947669983,
0.6646096706390381,
-0.693667471408844,
0.6144442558288574,
0.19401544332504272,
-0.09729264676570892,
0.548373818397522,
-0.5125066041946411,
0.16168087720870972,
-0.18094007670879364,
0.2534090578556061,
-1.1324121952056885,
-0.5050990581512451,
0.22235368192195892,
-0.38464978337287903,
0.4304293692111969,
-0.4361766576766968,
-0.49504509568214417,
-0.6867728233337402,
-0.24203045666217804,
0.030423322692513466,
0.33451616764068604,
-0.4937768280506134,
0.5680264234542847,
0.8770679235458374,
-0.008748414926230907,
-0.8536620140075684,
-0.5650349259376526,
0.21193985641002655,
-0.094626784324646,
-0.5626178979873657,
0.4556410014629364,
0.22494161128997803,
-0.4928427040576935,
0.2987005412578583,
-0.1342235654592514,
-0.457001268863678,
0.39479583501815796,
0.5809025168418884,
0.13045507669448853,
0.0420803464949131,
0.23887814581394196,
0.04484652727842331,
0.2191801369190216,
0.09496286511421204,
-0.3550044894218445,
0.6252826452255249,
-0.0013954903697595,
-0.2757692337036133,
-0.4168342351913452,
0.13759420812129974,
0.595302164554596,
0.16846992075443268,
0.7887291312217712,
0.7715121507644653,
-0.5282163619995117,
-0.25998979806900024,
-0.4141639173030853,
-0.22478574514389038,
-0.5574108958244324,
0.20728151500225067,
-0.11126981675624847,
-0.6218255758285522,
0.4897065758705139,
-0.30584171414375305,
-0.04713418334722519,
0.7190288305282593,
0.21658459305763245,
-0.17952346801757812,
1.0573664903640747,
0.6707853078842163,
-0.31086966395378113,
0.14172200858592987,
-0.15460222959518433,
0.3046845495700836,
-0.29973384737968445,
0.10172829777002335,
-0.40222975611686707,
-0.5216716527938843,
-1.0336387157440186,
0.05679982528090477,
-0.05330202355980873,
0.15042854845523834,
-0.2615259885787964,
0.465052992105484,
-0.6566449999809265,
0.05958223342895508,
0.5699900984764099,
0.4131813645362854,
0.28662046790122986,
0.42218464612960815,
-0.39404481649398804,
0.10732101649045944,
-0.8778261542320251,
-0.682880163192749,
0.8242278695106506,
0.4755995571613312,
0.6958580017089844,
0.15630444884300232,
0.4085407555103302,
0.8551833629608154,
0.5468407869338989,
-0.6937927603721619,
0.3573780357837677,
-0.31936073303222656,
-0.8018397688865662,
-0.41734960675239563,
-0.4674791395664215,
-0.949281632900238,
-0.288886696100235,
-0.27639952301979065,
-0.7533782124519348,
0.13230259716510773,
0.13197430968284607,
-0.30839404463768005,
0.5577477812767029,
-0.4194076359272003,
0.5497846007347107,
-0.25181707739830017,
-0.9438083171844482,
-0.15390227735042572,
-0.7759748101234436,
0.084496408700943,
-0.036305367946624756,
0.6892386078834534,
-0.027571359649300575,
0.18660233914852142,
0.7270398139953613,
-0.4065450429916382,
1.0372968912124634,
-0.1370783895254135,
0.172044038772583,
0.7375121116638184,
0.15942654013633728,
0.696129560470581,
-0.04427599906921387,
0.05773799866437912,
0.6013187170028687,
-0.20171813666820526,
-0.41848793625831604,
-0.13817478716373444,
0.8645875453948975,
-0.910961925983429,
-0.12651236355304718,
-0.5385711193084717,
-0.07825034111738205,
-0.1805364042520523,
0.628847599029541,
0.45519113540649414,
0.5836502909660339,
-0.11108290404081345,
0.015251966193318367,
0.44384095072746277,
0.15488120913505554,
0.5780585408210754,
0.2349473237991333,
0.17744077742099762,
-0.27255818247795105,
1.2561143636703491,
0.4582868814468384,
0.15016265213489532,
-0.13039502501487732,
0.015339790843427181,
-0.2519231140613556,
-0.5894318222999573,
-0.43585526943206787,
0.28178322315216064,
-0.9713372588157654,
-0.27230527997016907,
-0.7564996480941772,
-0.4847649037837982,
-0.3510923683643341,
-0.061688318848609924,
-0.40018051862716675,
-0.34930410981178284,
-0.34717807173728943,
-0.31511691212654114,
0.19275858998298645,
0.9477234482765198,
-0.3032110035419464,
0.28805676102638245,
-0.8300546407699585,
0.14791211485862732,
0.22536085546016693,
0.6048569679260254,
0.015662314370274544,
-0.3963603675365448,
-0.10752976685762405,
0.34120142459869385,
-0.24719838798046112,
-1.0411286354064941,
0.0484926700592041,
-0.01806759648025036,
0.7142298221588135,
0.6944490671157837,
0.1343664675951004,
0.590175986289978,
-0.5120208859443665,
0.673012375831604,
0.2597978711128235,
-0.5922985672950745,
-0.024137908592820168,
-0.49614256620407104,
-0.4850996732711792,
0.6403077840805054,
1.1289927959442139,
-0.5075886249542236,
-0.3272058963775635,
-0.8458153009414673,
-1.1447064876556396,
0.2787078022956848,
-0.04972038045525551,
0.37163567543029785,
-0.26547473669052124,
0.43414536118507385,
-0.14573819935321808,
0.44058871269226074,
-0.5782627463340759,
-0.622052013874054,
-0.6937940716743469,
-0.11424008011817932,
0.12923496961593628,
-0.4303433299064636,
-0.2901056110858917,
0.2739754915237427,
0.7467933297157288,
-0.09392662346363068,
0.23249810934066772,
-0.02009621262550354,
-0.29460951685905457,
-0.3878669738769531,
-0.21825957298278809,
0.11406830698251724,
0.9980185031890869,
-0.16514863073825836,
0.5449314117431641,
-0.17075879871845245,
-0.7064703106880188,
0.06810624897480011,
0.32323458790779114,
-0.038362693041563034,
0.24416206777095795,
0.44913554191589355,
0.3555026054382324,
0.11921679228544235,
-0.3687436580657959,
0.4015144109725952,
-0.022242868319153786,
-0.10364656895399094,
-0.573625922203064,
-0.08557107299566269,
0.11672978848218918,
0.06377097964286804,
0.6185285449028015,
-0.2610735297203064,
0.34846192598342896,
-0.812730610370636,
0.44674545526504517,
0.489474892616272,
-0.9800470471382141,
-0.15004760026931763,
0.5656625032424927,
0.0764361172914505,
-0.5660480260848999,
0.864639937877655,
-0.4568498134613037,
-0.6888118982315063,
0.33196091651916504,
0.3877013027667999,
0.6756051182746887,
-0.14397181570529938,
0.49762749671936035,
0.43347689509391785,
0.2646843194961548,
-0.28625330328941345,
-0.0016407381044700742,
0.516118586063385,
-0.8991917371749878,
0.03164919465780258,
-0.6718196272850037,
-0.23312483727931976,
0.26678866147994995,
-0.4896925091743469,
0.18157470226287842,
-0.6595742106437683,
-0.47486698627471924,
0.2860445976257324,
-0.0011522388085722923,
-0.42287182807922363,
0.4301588535308838,
-0.07318424433469772,
0.5163066983222961,
-0.9870474934577942,
0.17905709147453308,
0.8446850776672363,
-0.7166599035263062,
-1.009609580039978,
-0.05721043422818184,
0.3777081370353699,
-0.6009145379066467,
0.4058071970939636,
0.10349809378385544,
-0.3925863206386566,
0.18483740091323853,
-0.6920987367630005,
-0.737107515335083,
1.1623073816299438,
-0.4045102298259735,
-0.4065666198730469,
0.06901949644088745,
-0.04605942964553833,
0.43399760127067566,
-0.19640913605690002,
0.23325292766094208,
0.0783190056681633,
0.5723938345909119,
0.13928307592868805,
-0.7833609580993652,
0.2526198625564575,
-0.10447973012924194,
-0.3270140290260315,
0.07325586676597595,
-0.7365829944610596,
0.7838791012763977,
0.1344711184501648,
-0.5578001141548157,
-0.22274315357208252,
0.5260012149810791,
-0.12069632112979889,
0.5921553373336792,
0.7393580675125122,
0.4845402240753174,
0.8654329180717468,
-0.16763266921043396,
0.6704902052879333,
-0.37674129009246826,
0.6379552483558655,
1.0227419137954712,
-0.10034044831991196,
0.6663607358932495,
0.14283433556556702,
-0.041022200137376785,
0.872955322265625,
0.7707210183143616,
-0.1798713356256485,
0.4429008364677429,
0.14795367419719696,
-0.06121707707643509,
-0.23175086081027985,
-0.1976022869348526,
-0.13170674443244934,
0.5812613368034363,
0.4380171000957489,
-0.5153322219848633,
-0.4445164203643799,
-0.2601127624511719,
0.1617317497730255,
0.0857461616396904,
-0.39150774478912354,
0.47331711649894714,
0.0522167906165123,
-0.27176934480667114,
0.3609931766986847,
0.24957901239395142,
0.38283610343933105,
-0.42259877920150757,
-0.0879431664943695,
0.05763457715511322,
0.27270832657814026,
-0.31986528635025024,
-0.5383365154266357,
0.1561499983072281,
-0.5018765926361084,
0.11413147300481796,
-0.06769495457410812,
1.2344536781311035,
-0.012031705118715763,
-0.5118501782417297,
0.46465444564819336,
0.6280797719955444,
0.053569696843624115,
-0.011537818238139153,
-0.765928328037262,
-0.060042332857847214,
-0.3529551923274994,
-0.1781725287437439,
0.29474446177482605,
0.38634780049324036,
0.05594781041145325,
0.7361498475074768,
0.6630620956420898,
-0.10812364518642426,
-0.00583692779764533,
-0.030215414240956306,
0.789605438709259,
-0.4192957580089569,
-0.280822217464447,
-0.6389245986938477,
0.40728601813316345,
-0.6583402752876282,
0.02596966363489628,
1.1496152877807617,
0.38227054476737976,
0.6920203566551208,
0.46920186281204224,
1.072237253189087,
-0.28471723198890686,
0.6205651164054871,
-0.002901515457779169,
1.118743658065796,
-0.7428021430969238,
0.009773734956979752,
-0.5896810293197632,
-0.6918532252311707,
-0.062448468059301376,
0.5412887930870056,
0.10905485600233078,
0.22279292345046997,
0.7597895860671997,
0.36304157972335815,
-0.3802906274795532,
-0.07093571126461029,
-0.04287603124976158,
0.3451000452041626,
0.014028691686689854,
-0.14420218765735626,
0.7513808608055115,
-0.3525576889514923,
0.5141571164131165,
-0.5163752436637878,
-0.3975626528263092,
-0.5551761984825134,
-0.8978145718574524,
-0.6225156784057617,
-0.4910283088684082,
-0.48949897289276123,
-1.2247252464294434,
0.14489762485027313,
0.5387223958969116,
0.3705204427242279,
-0.46505728363990784,
-0.0035635409876704216,
-0.03505709022283554,
0.5631440281867981,
-0.3243136703968048,
-0.3048502504825592,
0.3963209092617035,
-0.2488209754228592,
-0.47394922375679016,
0.17003464698791504,
0.37761276960372925,
0.027841221541166306,
-0.4620829224586487,
0.2873077392578125,
-0.355574369430542,
0.25989189743995667,
0.294572651386261,
0.22577884793281555,
-0.23071669042110443,
-0.5801766514778137,
0.13902848958969116,
-0.254419207572937,
-0.16546055674552917,
0.4666353464126587,
-0.4248046875,
0.2615724503993988,
0.4843524396419525,
0.41705578565597534,
0.1255914270877838,
0.24517212808132172,
0.12693560123443604,
-0.2957427501678467,
-0.14005537331104279,
0.20738035440444946,
0.45946064591407776,
0.3828175961971283,
-0.367679238319397,
0.5420913100242615,
0.7567636370658875,
-0.4001588225364685,
-0.7820048928260803,
0.2750855088233948,
-0.6898171305656433,
-0.6340281963348389,
1.1722882986068726,
-0.3252810537815094,
-0.2524861693382263,
-0.6844311952590942,
0.544725239276886,
0.39957499504089355,
-0.14770974218845367,
1.1960320472717285,
0.7741965055465698,
0.3660145103931427,
0.28521695733070374,
-0.5355138778686523,
0.21513718366622925,
-0.2884753942489624,
-0.2604207992553711,
-0.26952898502349854,
0.8413876891136169,
0.5811534523963928,
0.8174024820327759,
0.4739283323287964,
0.09362614899873734,
0.10426583141088486,
0.34002822637557983,
-0.4181411862373352,
-0.1253439038991928,
-0.43819642066955566,
0.2724224925041199,
0.692621111869812,
-0.004091964568942785,
0.13553066551685333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11418v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11418v1 | BAMBINO-LM: (Bilingual-)Human-Inspired Continual Pretraining of BabyLM | 2024-06-17T11:08:08 | 2024-06-17T11:08:08 | Zhewen Shen, Aditya Joshi, Ruey-Cheng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Children from bilingual backgrounds benefit from interactions with parents
and teachers to re-acquire their heritage language. In this paper, we
investigate how this insight from behavioral study can be incorporated into the
learning of small-scale language models. We introduce BAMBINO-LM, a continual
pretraining strategy for BabyLM that uses a novel combination of alternation
and PPO-based perplexity reward induced from a parent Italian model. Upon
evaluation on zero-shot classification tasks for English and Italian,
BAMBINO-LM improves the Italian language capability of a BabyLM baseline. Our
ablation analysis demonstrates that employing both the alternation strategy and
PPO-based modeling is key to this effectiveness gain. We also show that, as a
side effect, the proposed method leads to similar degradation in L1
effectiveness as human children would have had in an equivalent learning
scenario. | [
-0.21620915830135345,
-0.7568711638450623,
-0.005847651977092028,
0.09965718537569046,
-0.45793774724006653,
0.39658358693122864,
-0.18642643094062805,
-0.47197532653808594,
0.1200966089963913,
0.3097788095474243,
-0.5802866816520691,
-0.09582621604204178,
-0.5211412310600281,
0.028030574321746826,
0.09891132265329361,
1.229083776473999,
0.08660382032394409,
0.3071941137313843,
0.4029138684272766,
0.0780625119805336,
-0.24858050048351288,
-0.6023575067520142,
-0.8228201270103455,
-0.48181435465812683,
1.167201042175293,
0.7625184655189514,
0.4946899712085724,
0.4726158380508423,
0.1020832359790802,
0.19866354763507843,
-0.15421117842197418,
0.10703686624765396,
-0.8642805218696594,
-0.1454305499792099,
-0.19503651559352875,
-0.6703914403915405,
-0.47687435150146484,
0.12705391645431519,
0.7762652039527893,
1.0171135663986206,
-0.4631907641887665,
0.0035551299806684256,
0.16428789496421814,
0.5734726190567017,
-0.6592468023300171,
-0.164062038064003,
-0.7736338973045349,
0.18058346211910248,
-0.2417650818824768,
-0.08435560017824173,
-0.43214982748031616,
-0.3200198709964752,
-0.051539234817028046,
-0.1970057487487793,
0.09329954534769058,
-0.12137460708618164,
0.936959981918335,
-0.015635095536708832,
-0.33024993538856506,
-0.2517567276954651,
-0.8735285997390747,
0.6866953372955322,
-0.6860520839691162,
0.4134370982646942,
0.44789573550224304,
-0.06515916436910629,
-0.36362695693969727,
-0.25634321570396423,
-0.7566043734550476,
-0.5262299180030823,
-0.2763463258743286,
-0.013118739239871502,
0.3306252062320709,
-0.07243219763040543,
0.05115648731589317,
0.21558700501918793,
-0.4946913421154022,
0.46165454387664795,
-0.47388750314712524,
-0.124962218105793,
0.47100040316581726,
0.1128549799323082,
0.2757967710494995,
0.07776191830635071,
-0.0338495597243309,
0.13380171358585358,
-1.0907703638076782,
0.3230237066745758,
0.6122565865516663,
0.4781269133090973,
-0.11905761063098907,
0.41257917881011963,
0.06793345510959625,
0.7965630888938904,
0.22785405814647675,
-0.43566226959228516,
0.21313613653182983,
-0.12232154607772827,
0.02155163325369358,
-0.034829553216695786,
0.5782440900802612,
-0.3620688319206238,
0.04569727182388306,
-0.5703976154327393,
-0.27198779582977295,
-0.15799793601036072,
0.22757349908351898,
-0.7967539429664612,
0.1214536651968956,
-0.1683564931154251,
-0.11768484860658646,
-0.31083157658576965,
0.031003868207335472,
-0.7559393644332886,
-0.013367214240133762,
-0.3609197735786438,
0.5351216197013855,
-0.606121838092804,
-0.322478711605072,
0.07520309090614319,
0.3317005932331085,
0.41425052285194397,
0.04406516253948212,
-1.4328062534332275,
-0.09340766817331314,
0.6969436407089233,
0.7355416417121887,
-0.14835825562477112,
-0.47234347462654114,
-0.38075917959213257,
0.2559303045272827,
-0.4634762108325958,
0.8075429797172546,
-0.4712955057621002,
-0.9108244180679321,
-0.12743595242500305,
0.017982257530093193,
-0.28508663177490234,
-0.7704669833183289,
0.19081659615039825,
-0.4901570975780487,
0.22831220924854279,
-0.05667649954557419,
-0.1841617226600647,
0.05419016256928444,
0.3697693645954132,
-0.4616641700267792,
0.5611709952354431,
0.2401643544435501,
-0.6030490398406982,
0.7721584439277649,
-0.5276145339012146,
-0.6847193241119385,
0.09062949568033218,
0.019676698371767998,
-0.6023818850517273,
0.41657230257987976,
-0.2984434962272644,
-0.030355922877788544,
-0.04038557782769203,
0.08633299916982651,
-0.0962371751666069,
-0.4240623414516449,
0.007459023501724005,
-0.32465654611587524,
1.116841435432434,
0.0580580048263073,
-0.43763911724090576,
-0.05304122343659401,
-0.7514488697052002,
-0.2459842562675476,
0.30753567814826965,
-0.6410688757896423,
-0.12971363961696625,
-0.10086359828710556,
-0.45056790113449097,
0.23227989673614502,
0.21485039591789246,
-0.4429794251918793,
0.4374332129955292,
-0.5442618131637573,
-0.003809927264228463,
0.5172975063323975,
0.017648397013545036,
0.2979780435562134,
-0.47230541706085205,
0.7925477623939514,
0.1179322749376297,
0.3191589415073395,
-0.339453786611557,
-0.1796479970216751,
-1.0378550291061401,
-0.5768370628356934,
0.4673563539981842,
0.6121165156364441,
-0.7208237051963806,
0.6200407147407532,
-0.16247431933879852,
-0.4437812268733978,
-0.5329675078392029,
0.42921164631843567,
0.5473507642745972,
0.6021943688392639,
0.23930740356445312,
-0.7596556544303894,
-0.4373086392879486,
-0.7724403738975525,
0.14137649536132812,
-0.22250403463840485,
0.03633003681898117,
0.017679091542959213,
0.530472457408905,
-0.5047982335090637,
0.7341156601905823,
0.11048529297113419,
-0.08545457571744919,
-0.3609366714954376,
0.6064705848693848,
0.33241236209869385,
0.7151932716369629,
0.6239451169967651,
-0.47129884362220764,
-0.6041944026947021,
0.104692742228508,
-0.37392523884773254,
0.15571478009223938,
-0.08196514844894409,
-0.32063236832618713,
0.3873485028743744,
0.1424833983182907,
-0.40721455216407776,
0.3714677095413208,
0.4731716811656952,
-0.2941315174102783,
0.9047365784645081,
-0.4221424460411072,
0.06204216182231903,
-0.4838925004005432,
0.06827322393655777,
-0.6047075986862183,
-0.09278247505426407,
-0.845368504524231,
-0.013378881849348545,
-0.09599878638982773,
0.032655492424964905,
-0.6933626532554626,
0.6400460600852966,
-0.3749232292175293,
0.1316157430410385,
-0.30616167187690735,
-0.24230919778347015,
-0.2828963100910187,
0.5908206701278687,
0.1329047828912735,
0.6247596740722656,
0.5028342604637146,
-0.56662917137146,
0.14969263970851898,
-0.14166073501110077,
-0.157082200050354,
0.6524724960327148,
-0.5278714895248413,
0.45065104961395264,
-0.18672066926956177,
0.04774439334869385,
-0.7036222219467163,
0.05057981610298157,
0.43079015612602234,
-0.4198962450027466,
0.8123651146888733,
0.002196237910538912,
-0.7155691385269165,
-0.2704490125179291,
0.0036398794036358595,
0.3298885226249695,
0.5338265299797058,
-0.47893911600112915,
0.48355743288993835,
0.14765697717666626,
-0.2625062167644501,
-0.253437876701355,
-0.4980480968952179,
0.008559493348002434,
-0.33366984128952026,
-0.14350807666778564,
0.12979942560195923,
-0.16120128333568573,
-0.0016078153857961297,
-0.15399999916553497,
0.047879770398139954,
-0.09699989855289459,
0.2533492147922516,
-0.2597350478172302,
0.43749138712882996,
-0.1675158590078354,
0.14841578900814056,
-0.00726595101878047,
-0.19112218916416168,
-0.25437697768211365,
-0.3439452648162842,
0.7891275882720947,
-0.09197673946619034,
-0.1241753101348877,
-0.28961125016212463,
0.29084131121635437,
0.2777036428451538,
-0.2252584993839264,
1.1958171129226685,
0.41597631573677063,
-0.11582446843385696,
-0.046098943799734116,
-0.37169569730758667,
-0.20681986212730408,
-0.4177197217941284,
0.06885470449924469,
-0.42118406295776367,
-0.6055252552032471,
0.28236207365989685,
0.058515239506959915,
-0.014399071224033833,
-0.05503873899579048,
0.7931873202323914,
-0.4978454113006592,
0.7093750238418579,
0.8835208415985107,
-0.11574233323335648,
0.7951399087905884,
-0.4242764115333557,
0.05264567956328392,
-0.7433927059173584,
-0.40543413162231445,
-0.4214847981929779,
-0.3466286361217499,
-0.42750972509384155,
-0.3735690414905548,
0.17877410352230072,
0.4212516248226166,
-0.5006378293037415,
0.2709319591522217,
-0.007310215849429369,
0.2639687657356262,
0.4452977776527405,
0.47488752007484436,
0.43885135650634766,
0.038651492446660995,
-0.3584957718849182,
-0.01981476880609989,
-0.8818129301071167,
-0.42370590567588806,
1.1285475492477417,
0.006577284540981054,
0.6049225330352783,
0.20661942660808563,
0.9841195940971375,
-0.1883605420589447,
1.0884438753128052,
-0.7456084489822388,
0.4138246476650238,
-0.05874667689204216,
-0.9620761871337891,
-0.4740658104419708,
-0.4157121181488037,
-1.285392165184021,
0.4344342350959778,
-0.3153277635574341,
-0.9568543434143066,
0.2569321393966675,
0.4595995843410492,
-0.3412267565727234,
0.044596895575523376,
-0.5560930967330933,
0.9368951320648193,
-1.0388364791870117,
-0.8221758604049683,
-0.3298932611942291,
-0.5134972333908081,
0.21097888052463531,
-0.45640048384666443,
0.2543598413467407,
0.06486795097589493,
-0.1323317140340805,
0.37914130091667175,
-0.3428698778152466,
0.7874283790588379,
-0.17328022420406342,
-0.23487237095832825,
0.12498340010643005,
0.2712460160255432,
0.22968466579914093,
-0.012478460557758808,
-0.19159860908985138,
0.25750383734703064,
-0.4071217179298401,
-0.8959118723869324,
-0.58017897605896,
0.32093268632888794,
-0.5627362728118896,
-0.8603429794311523,
-0.3312424421310425,
-0.42956095933914185,
-0.5455767512321472,
0.36114829778671265,
0.3515265882015228,
0.021589497104287148,
-0.15116892755031586,
0.30286356806755066,
0.5608228445053101,
-0.19535475969314575,
0.18762348592281342,
0.9915568232536316,
-0.3373909294605255,
-0.17583754658699036,
0.7235888242721558,
-0.02378358505666256,
0.4942640960216522,
0.30853861570358276,
0.2790979743003845,
-0.004998913034796715,
-0.5245611071586609,
-0.25561949610710144,
0.764764666557312,
-0.17651042342185974,
0.15124179422855377,
-0.2093016356229782,
0.03156790882349014,
-0.20032183825969696,
-0.3565155565738678,
-0.4248417913913727,
0.10909470170736313,
-0.23286499083042145,
-0.22096316516399384,
-0.422160267829895,
0.37307634949684143,
-0.40511631965637207,
0.4641607403755188,
-0.6402249932289124,
0.2332284152507782,
0.5428808927536011,
0.2702626883983612,
0.039743997156620026,
-0.9385610222816467,
-0.5927401185035706,
0.34342652559280396,
-0.4450533390045166,
-0.8450338244438171,
0.41522857546806335,
0.07369309663772583,
0.8055165410041809,
0.7558022737503052,
-0.37964871525764465,
0.8834676742553711,
-0.6717461347579956,
0.5175719261169434,
0.514149010181427,
-0.8365986347198486,
0.5617684125900269,
-0.31684285402297974,
0.2725261449813843,
0.666612446308136,
0.7297971844673157,
-0.2792394161224365,
-0.23206377029418945,
-0.6586315631866455,
-0.6763980984687805,
0.7498522400856018,
0.0184897743165493,
0.20949535071849823,
0.07201462984085083,
0.2268901765346527,
0.2123248428106308,
0.42865899205207825,
-0.8724877238273621,
0.013751104474067688,
-0.10225316882133484,
-0.04122329130768776,
-0.35309073328971863,
-0.36688292026519775,
-0.12107466906309128,
-0.6169330477714539,
0.7074221968650818,
0.1210101768374443,
0.06020314618945122,
-0.1058318242430687,
-0.3811701536178589,
-0.15889573097229004,
0.12879478931427002,
0.3771689534187317,
0.7548693418502808,
-0.12946337461471558,
-0.2332196980714798,
0.24326054751873016,
-0.19117824733257294,
0.4506460726261139,
-0.1008676216006279,
-0.2968796491622925,
-0.04447898268699646,
0.6405472159385681,
0.8302207589149475,
0.6228274703025818,
-0.6295790672302246,
0.012138803489506245,
0.2192031443119049,
0.04481859505176544,
-0.11807988584041595,
0.1371210217475891,
0.1152959018945694,
-0.018228493630886078,
0.26144957542419434,
-0.565189003944397,
-0.12899760901927948,
-1.2844094038009644,
0.14616915583610535,
0.48848289251327515,
-0.3084222376346588,
-0.5668137669563293,
0.3426644802093506,
0.24694623053073883,
-0.6402149796485901,
0.5746160745620728,
-0.3704521059989929,
-0.691183865070343,
0.6187593936920166,
0.5744279026985168,
0.6079416275024414,
-0.6858295202255249,
0.3769715130329132,
0.3862459361553192,
0.28768080472946167,
0.12322515994310379,
-0.06684833019971848,
-0.462149977684021,
-1.060060977935791,
-0.1611541211605072,
-0.7135151624679565,
-0.469669908285141,
0.09010346978902817,
-0.6231964826583862,
0.42207810282707214,
-0.3374415934085846,
0.06450918316841125,
-0.23056244850158691,
0.0023011008743196726,
-0.7520348429679871,
0.20375372469425201,
0.3822357952594757,
0.36330080032348633,
-0.6792895793914795,
1.21983802318573,
0.6684665083885193,
-0.5847176313400269,
-0.8503847718238831,
0.20338967442512512,
-0.17830903828144073,
-0.6575922966003418,
0.962388277053833,
0.01740344613790512,
-0.3182506859302521,
0.1914588361978531,
-0.3086216151714325,
-0.5522493124008179,
0.7394258379936218,
0.36420443654060364,
-0.7340386509895325,
-0.1276412308216095,
0.1005292758345604,
0.785775899887085,
-0.38902366161346436,
0.21942433714866638,
0.968548595905304,
0.4126933813095093,
0.35957419872283936,
-0.8716965913772583,
-0.5949604511260986,
0.13545894622802734,
0.1047525480389595,
-0.10014687478542328,
-0.6502087712287903,
0.6108946204185486,
-0.5145846009254456,
-0.2457842379808426,
0.11508049815893173,
0.5189522504806519,
0.35509687662124634,
0.16573570668697357,
0.6853200197219849,
0.28070658445358276,
0.568585216999054,
0.044876281172037125,
0.8651418685913086,
-0.3351896107196808,
0.43475714325904846,
1.094502568244934,
-0.1988736093044281,
0.6919260621070862,
0.6136613488197327,
-0.3308486044406891,
0.8749929070472717,
0.6788672804832458,
0.40856578946113586,
0.548757016658783,
0.24860788881778717,
-0.40409165620803833,
-0.07120977342128754,
0.0805172398686409,
-0.09774453938007355,
0.41238677501678467,
0.5142737627029419,
0.02445176988840103,
-0.09542124718427658,
0.35363560914993286,
0.4757632911205292,
-0.05594933032989502,
-0.3663567900657654,
0.8139575719833374,
0.041749678552150726,
-0.7856835126876831,
0.8782646656036377,
-0.29982617497444153,
0.8044514060020447,
-0.8833030462265015,
0.2585071623325348,
-0.693304181098938,
0.05162191763520241,
-0.06661804765462875,
-0.00160783133469522,
0.2840289771556854,
0.09951461106538773,
-0.047270793467760086,
-0.24625913798809052,
0.031003037467598915,
-0.77308589220047,
-0.7434874176979065,
0.4351648688316345,
0.3493788242340088,
-0.04413186013698578,
0.5685412883758545,
-0.7323771715164185,
-0.18475641310214996,
0.005815078504383564,
-0.41380563378334045,
0.4001266062259674,
0.4641887843608856,
0.2107415795326233,
0.5077996850013733,
0.7508313059806824,
0.7078754305839539,
0.1973801851272583,
-0.07308422774076462,
0.6858516335487366,
-0.5703473687171936,
-0.5260597467422485,
-0.6712782382965088,
0.6134889125823975,
0.22491323947906494,
-0.09390681982040405,
0.5531076788902283,
0.36950936913490295,
1.0448483228683472,
-0.27319103479385376,
0.4614710509777069,
-0.17511148750782013,
0.6085004210472107,
-0.4178503155708313,
0.6077673435211182,
-0.7735331058502197,
0.18689550459384918,
0.07839968800544739,
-0.8154336214065552,
-0.297369122505188,
0.8083978295326233,
-0.5730013251304626,
0.047719862312078476,
0.7826299667358398,
0.8152129054069519,
0.14740626513957977,
-0.5356565713882446,
0.6608803868293762,
0.39313703775405884,
0.2519683539867401,
0.5193890333175659,
0.8675097227096558,
0.258622944355011,
0.4461745023727417,
-0.336395263671875,
-0.46175307035446167,
-0.3414958119392395,
-0.7732481360435486,
-0.7537786364555359,
-0.24331235885620117,
-0.05872965604066849,
-0.026866227388381958,
0.35599803924560547,
0.7795813083648682,
0.8278511166572571,
-0.886309802532196,
-0.46013379096984863,
-0.08397525548934937,
0.12109393626451492,
-0.06111295148730278,
-0.1412515640258789,
-0.06923707574605942,
-0.7161408066749573,
-0.926150381565094,
0.2695309519767761,
0.3312602639198303,
0.004014681093394756,
-0.47725436091423035,
-0.16270017623901367,
-0.36988314986228943,
0.1953984797000885,
0.5176378488540649,
0.7129504680633545,
-0.3718988299369812,
-0.16846920549869537,
-0.4814619719982147,
-0.1450035721063614,
0.07653817534446716,
1.1129838228225708,
-0.702356219291687,
0.6001856923103333,
0.1093829944729805,
0.39765313267707825,
0.6941981315612793,
0.0064165121875703335,
0.5069669485092163,
-0.3488835394382477,
0.9404503703117371,
0.43195170164108276,
0.31411537528038025,
0.26439934968948364,
-0.27513426542282104,
0.34901395440101624,
0.43946921825408936,
-0.23253007233142853,
-0.6631900072097778,
0.43291351199150085,
-0.3270673453807831,
-0.26685193181037903,
1.0547956228256226,
-0.46157461404800415,
-0.24286878108978271,
-0.08445674926042557,
-0.25353729724884033,
0.26073458790779114,
-0.028759486973285675,
1.2277928590774536,
0.6747909188270569,
-0.168101504445076,
-0.2949753999710083,
-0.13995838165283203,
0.13960768282413483,
0.6855140924453735,
-0.8163313865661621,
-0.5497280955314636,
0.2720348834991455,
0.3314502537250519,
0.06276404112577438,
0.6444264054298401,
-0.2769310176372528,
0.32104170322418213,
-0.021817035973072052,
0.17572936415672302,
-0.03873125836253166,
-0.5270056128501892,
-0.471701979637146,
-0.24262802302837372,
0.19217145442962646,
-0.005545546300709248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15486v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15486v2 | SampleAttention: Near-Lossless Acceleration of Long Context LLM Inference with Adaptive Structured Sparse Attention | 2024-06-17T11:05:15 | 2024-06-28T08:55:17 | Qianchao Zhu, Jiangfei Duan, Chang Chen, Siran Liu, Xiuhong Li, Guanyu Feng, Xin Lv, Huanqi Cao, Xiao Chuanfu, Xingcheng Zhang, Dahua Lin, Chao Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) now support extremely long context windows, but
the quadratic complexity of vanilla attention results in significantly long
Time-to-First-Token (TTFT) latency. Existing approaches to address this
complexity require additional pretraining or finetuning, and often sacrifice
model accuracy. In this paper, we first provide both theoretical and empirical
foundations for near-lossless sparse attention. We find dynamically capturing
head-specific sparse patterns at runtime with low overhead is crucial. To
address this, we propose SampleAttention, an adaptive structured and
near-lossless sparse attention. Leveraging observed significant sparse
patterns, SampleAttention attends to a fixed percentage of adjacent tokens to
capture local window patterns, and employs a two-stage query-guided key-value
filtering approach, which adaptively select a minimum set of key-values with
low overhead, to capture column stripe patterns. Comprehensive evaluations show
that SampleAttention can seamlessly replace vanilla attention in off-the-shelf
LLMs with nearly no accuracy loss, and reduces TTFT by up to $2.42\times$
compared with FlashAttention. | [
-0.06255105882883072,
-0.6973701119422913,
0.6535958051681519,
0.4622285068035126,
-0.2596856951713562,
0.2126561403274536,
-0.3857571482658386,
-0.5223082900047302,
0.2084520310163498,
0.3355778157711029,
-0.8038771152496338,
-0.3686659336090088,
-0.32896745204925537,
-0.05489203706383705,
-0.4509221613407135,
0.8121399879455566,
-0.0019776930566877127,
-0.3176538050174713,
-0.22536763548851013,
-0.31947657465934753,
-0.36384618282318115,
-0.23786300420761108,
-0.6417095065116882,
0.15381933748722076,
0.6934460401535034,
0.4363226294517517,
0.18733935058116913,
0.6709577441215515,
0.0695788711309433,
0.3216116726398468,
-0.19905942678451538,
0.21147453784942627,
-0.7955644726753235,
0.04347454011440277,
-0.07292192429304123,
-0.4890928864479065,
-0.6182001233100891,
0.15943537652492523,
0.6897116303443909,
0.8543850183486938,
0.0024716162588447332,
0.2621534764766693,
0.40192925930023193,
0.6132692098617554,
-0.791031539440155,
-0.04814745485782623,
-0.6623052954673767,
-0.029135065153241158,
-0.23785680532455444,
-0.21992257237434387,
-0.32184863090515137,
-0.11894364655017853,
0.14046193659305573,
-0.7221009135246277,
0.5077775120735168,
0.30817538499832153,
0.5175615549087524,
0.3178374469280243,
-0.042563073337078094,
0.13800419867038727,
-0.5985826253890991,
1.1855648756027222,
-0.6149773597717285,
0.37926438450813293,
0.330735981464386,
0.05443926528096199,
-0.4709675908088684,
-0.9174225926399231,
-0.45261943340301514,
-0.14690645039081573,
0.10166367143392563,
0.015207696706056595,
-0.09935843199491501,
0.2520872950553894,
0.26314201951026917,
0.24350935220718384,
-0.5008212327957153,
0.11684621870517731,
-0.252723753452301,
-0.20925170183181763,
0.21752135455608368,
-0.0031572349835187197,
-0.20999927818775177,
0.2904990315437317,
-0.3087944984436035,
-0.030389292165637016,
-0.7492872476577759,
0.010010773316025734,
-0.03842217102646828,
0.3968135714530945,
-0.29959622025489807,
0.08731970936059952,
-0.2611669898033142,
0.8790588974952698,
0.3528366982936859,
-0.2191452831029892,
-0.027165845036506653,
-0.35425910353660583,
-0.39918068051338196,
0.05194573476910591,
0.5531238913536072,
0.08788599818944931,
0.14124195277690887,
-0.44613349437713623,
-0.12525083124637604,
-0.3485950231552124,
0.0952153354883194,
-1.0288347005844116,
-0.17405983805656433,
0.5474371910095215,
-0.3220764696598053,
-0.2505165934562683,
-0.26971685886383057,
-0.8063634634017944,
-0.18921202421188354,
-0.1929747760295868,
0.09508117288351059,
-0.2564094066619873,
0.09621159732341766,
-0.10317491739988327,
0.0359928160905838,
0.3070617616176605,
0.47204428911209106,
-0.7915878295898438,
0.36939164996147156,
0.6283602118492126,
1.1214858293533325,
-0.6255390048027039,
-0.19144973158836365,
-0.893276572227478,
0.08508498966693878,
-0.320395827293396,
1.067110300064087,
-0.3872808814048767,
-0.029728181660175323,
-0.22326438128948212,
0.042372822761535645,
0.04904613271355629,
-0.5791564583778381,
0.3123701810836792,
-0.6349563002586365,
0.06929253041744232,
0.04464910551905632,
-0.5020836591720581,
0.06368019431829453,
0.2290526181459427,
-0.5526734590530396,
1.2061480283737183,
0.5552539229393005,
-0.4082973897457123,
0.6077868938446045,
-0.5719075798988342,
-0.33595412969589233,
0.20075173676013947,
0.008387801237404346,
-0.2896212935447693,
0.32243582606315613,
0.12776558101177216,
0.5000771284103394,
-0.0560305081307888,
-0.1421022117137909,
-0.7114319205284119,
-0.7675617337226868,
0.18202519416809082,
-0.37035879492759705,
0.47341105341911316,
0.015142254531383514,
-0.2642054557800293,
0.31207653880119324,
-1.1632224321365356,
-0.006539276801049709,
0.040849748998880386,
-0.26431185007095337,
-0.45747309923171997,
0.266250342130661,
0.337006151676178,
0.054095812141895294,
-0.005646745208650827,
-0.6498720645904541,
-0.039011288434267044,
-0.6666613817214966,
0.5591045022010803,
0.9121854305267334,
-0.050886549055576324,
0.6100192666053772,
-0.1311357170343399,
0.431665301322937,
0.10426852107048035,
-0.23507855832576752,
-0.23141980171203613,
0.04443326219916344,
-0.6187719106674194,
-0.6027792692184448,
0.35258039832115173,
0.19743867218494415,
-0.3297795355319977,
0.2343473583459854,
-0.4175150692462921,
0.013700604438781738,
-0.4769325852394104,
0.3601575791835785,
0.21010757982730865,
0.45513901114463806,
0.2839893698692322,
-0.13036441802978516,
-0.5161738991737366,
-0.6780802607536316,
-0.1028776541352272,
0.07912027835845947,
-0.3333267569541931,
0.2243058979511261,
0.07036759704351425,
0.16385404765605927,
0.9802621603012085,
-0.5279320478439331,
-0.38594603538513184,
-0.16741563379764557,
0.03144298866391182,
0.22773462533950806,
0.45060762763023376,
0.6345041394233704,
-0.5347116589546204,
-0.26153144240379333,
-0.18613296747207642,
-0.06873726099729538,
-0.25651341676712036,
-0.13743029534816742,
-0.14374026656150818,
0.20751455426216125,
0.7095974087715149,
-0.41724294424057007,
0.227219820022583,
0.513567328453064,
-0.09937670826911926,
0.14998868107795715,
-0.08456092327833176,
-0.2272525131702423,
-1.0308212041854858,
0.06624491512775421,
-0.06958885490894318,
-0.6722269058227539,
-0.5879077911376953,
0.02487696334719658,
0.12913013994693756,
-0.0014917508233338594,
-0.5730404257774353,
0.8062021732330322,
-0.5436403155326843,
-0.11267992109060287,
-0.6468091607093811,
0.3315499424934387,
0.12043469399213791,
0.772888720035553,
0.059836216270923615,
1.0443679094314575,
0.043436262756586075,
-0.6823340654373169,
0.17159926891326904,
-0.10401026904582977,
-0.368526816368103,
0.6499375104904175,
-0.6049433350563049,
0.4369875490665436,
-0.2612914741039276,
0.21814754605293274,
-1.3709808588027954,
-0.22713398933410645,
0.06599976867437363,
-0.33769097924232483,
0.5098614692687988,
-0.07729896157979965,
-0.15771612524986267,
-0.14371001720428467,
-0.5585342049598694,
0.6193326711654663,
0.3984051048755646,
-0.45346567034721375,
0.5122992992401123,
0.10713458061218262,
-0.2026946097612381,
-0.44705429673194885,
-0.6669694185256958,
0.039960820227861404,
-0.14017648994922638,
-0.1692592203617096,
0.41742581129074097,
-0.08999686688184738,
-0.03550737351179123,
-0.08575911074876785,
-0.30749356746673584,
-0.23716102540493011,
0.31419265270233154,
0.0986323207616806,
0.05153035372495651,
-0.43516188859939575,
0.10437806695699692,
-0.028250498697161674,
-0.0296547282487154,
-0.10357224941253662,
-0.6262616515159607,
0.4363167881965637,
0.28063705563545227,
-0.09360529482364655,
-0.2954217195510864,
0.39642301201820374,
0.5834022164344788,
0.016619054600596428,
0.5222227573394775,
0.44369152188301086,
-0.4144957959651947,
-0.5608081817626953,
-0.6332431435585022,
-0.13833807408809662,
-0.4790542721748352,
0.8382107019424438,
-0.10823314636945724,
-1.1682604551315308,
0.39915522933006287,
0.07563739269971848,
0.08539129048585892,
-0.015496154315769672,
0.5324052572250366,
-0.331855446100235,
0.6491459608078003,
0.7120779752731323,
-0.3003093898296356,
0.7473891377449036,
0.12141475826501846,
0.09329575300216675,
-0.7337444424629211,
0.08690950274467468,
-0.421214759349823,
-0.4787788987159729,
-0.49728521704673767,
-0.647002637386322,
0.23979441821575165,
-0.21142113208770752,
-0.052302807569503784,
0.04325047507882118,
-0.3401068150997162,
0.6158068776130676,
0.42141300439834595,
0.14675134420394897,
-0.009476247243583202,
0.04693548381328583,
0.26516494154930115,
-0.16771170496940613,
-0.5173553228378296,
-0.07324400544166565,
0.8351356387138367,
0.18294604122638702,
0.8110690712928772,
-0.11954360455274582,
0.27629896998405457,
0.3101077973842621,
0.4392787516117096,
-1.0256690979003906,
0.48041191697120667,
-0.08348564058542252,
-0.29357990622520447,
-0.30526888370513916,
-0.16296930611133575,
-0.7977757453918457,
0.15330903232097626,
0.09797389805316925,
-0.8795600533485413,
0.26377686858177185,
0.6008052825927734,
-0.7100490927696228,
0.04211784899234772,
-0.4171842038631439,
0.7551838159561157,
0.09932181984186172,
-0.7431594729423523,
-0.11477392911911011,
-0.5651964545249939,
0.39794763922691345,
-0.42093008756637573,
-0.0015690568834543228,
-0.18286126852035522,
-0.3388552665710449,
0.6183797717094421,
-0.2108020782470703,
0.9722177982330322,
-0.2525251805782318,
-0.10751774907112122,
0.12005069106817245,
-0.0511508509516716,
0.6162031888961792,
-0.21817272901535034,
0.20591360330581665,
-0.2755820155143738,
0.11070448160171509,
-0.6899603605270386,
-0.6571958661079407,
0.703514039516449,
-0.2962327003479004,
-0.40478816628456116,
-0.329026460647583,
-0.7187955975532532,
-0.4684852659702301,
0.19362257421016693,
-0.04052359610795975,
0.23317226767539978,
-0.20221462845802307,
0.29485979676246643,
0.8715651035308838,
0.05773352459073067,
0.5516766309738159,
0.41983115673065186,
0.12748470902442932,
-0.26144978404045105,
0.8823649287223816,
-0.028910305351018906,
0.33668214082717896,
0.5173276662826538,
-0.008579650893807411,
-0.22211259603500366,
-0.8959066271781921,
-0.33067774772644043,
0.1884039342403412,
-0.3187689483165741,
-0.26844653487205505,
-0.6110267639160156,
0.13768206536769867,
-0.3829725980758667,
-0.0045877909287810326,
-0.42110857367515564,
-0.2850075662136078,
-0.34276530146598816,
-0.027673108503222466,
0.40171533823013306,
0.16335193812847137,
0.2971099019050598,
0.6086874008178711,
-0.7402423620223999,
0.292452871799469,
0.21753011643886566,
0.30646800994873047,
0.11250818520784378,
-0.7201682329177856,
-0.4124413728713989,
-0.12277936935424805,
-0.14283062517642975,
-0.6626601815223694,
0.25409314036369324,
0.546862781047821,
0.29022085666656494,
0.49145805835723877,
0.08835621178150177,
1.172476053237915,
-0.6402220129966736,
0.7028157711029053,
-0.28724849224090576,
-0.837496280670166,
0.25301462411880493,
-0.11473161727190018,
0.48471537232398987,
0.742343544960022,
-0.016477154567837715,
-0.48566561937332153,
-0.6032134890556335,
-0.1638173758983612,
-0.8513396978378296,
0.915282130241394,
-0.11307781934738159,
0.21482698619365692,
0.0890108272433281,
0.5879069566726685,
-0.18762990832328796,
0.12417981028556824,
-0.7322578430175781,
0.16921578347682953,
-0.007059911731630564,
-0.3756065368652344,
-0.03543210029602051,
-0.40808650851249695,
-0.0020983752328902483,
-0.0683898776769638,
0.42456430196762085,
-0.4986813962459564,
0.359232634305954,
0.30241698026657104,
-0.33863985538482666,
-0.1384279727935791,
0.09756879508495331,
0.9559462070465088,
0.5037806034088135,
-0.4400631785392761,
0.07139991223812103,
0.33183908462524414,
-0.617739737033844,
0.283720999956131,
0.20722831785678864,
-0.17831027507781982,
-0.14996765553951263,
0.5198999047279358,
0.8600133061408997,
0.5466211438179016,
-0.7955266237258911,
0.6402765512466431,
0.005657666362822056,
-0.07334482669830322,
-0.29409167170524597,
0.096058689057827,
-0.02175753004848957,
0.1682654172182083,
0.48904117941856384,
-0.32262933254241943,
0.13661018013954163,
-0.3499937951564789,
0.23747488856315613,
0.4802495539188385,
-0.5653262734413147,
-0.3896220028400421,
0.7632147073745728,
-0.0945282056927681,
-0.059643879532814026,
0.3159644603729248,
-0.025868594646453857,
-0.11544126272201538,
0.5564126968383789,
0.502621054649353,
0.9681147933006287,
-0.2919779121875763,
-0.33839982748031616,
0.15000878274440765,
0.09133549779653549,
0.19480548799037933,
0.11773733794689178,
-0.5774304270744324,
-0.48285597562789917,
-0.9148620963096619,
-0.8327597379684448,
-0.2987850606441498,
0.5235617160797119,
-0.4964084029197693,
0.006477144081145525,
-0.5809005498886108,
0.22276923060417175,
-0.15772320330142975,
-0.16250790655612946,
-0.23683954775333405,
0.24914400279521942,
-0.003574107075110078,
1.0812925100326538,
-0.679366946220398,
0.8261324763298035,
0.4350247383117676,
0.15894198417663574,
-0.5311750173568726,
0.3658958375453949,
-0.16113315522670746,
-0.7183184027671814,
0.473285436630249,
0.26331475377082825,
-0.2231152057647705,
0.07782018184661865,
-0.7432258725166321,
-0.9817901849746704,
0.9294137358665466,
0.3694102168083191,
-0.5529436469078064,
-0.3367786705493927,
-0.044157978147268295,
0.38450419902801514,
-0.14372138679027557,
0.09404575824737549,
0.8037678599357605,
0.16650547087192535,
0.2822631299495697,
-0.42310041189193726,
0.06807096302509308,
0.042965877801179886,
0.1499161571264267,
0.09080230444669724,
-0.7734284996986389,
0.5473595857620239,
0.03483126312494278,
-0.30453619360923767,
0.3439185321331024,
1.2458235025405884,
0.3314654529094696,
0.2595372498035431,
0.551200807094574,
0.33395662903785706,
0.5317243337631226,
-0.04628511145710945,
0.8130496144294739,
-0.4294990003108978,
0.17358388006687164,
1.2701934576034546,
-0.38630375266075134,
0.825949490070343,
0.8010045886039734,
-0.4456906318664551,
0.1574660688638687,
0.8165167570114136,
0.28702470660209656,
0.70405113697052,
0.32486671209335327,
-0.39745980501174927,
-0.048739854246377945,
0.010774338617920876,
0.04482769966125488,
0.4633636176586151,
0.33514246344566345,
-0.10749292373657227,
-0.19746007025241852,
0.1628006249666214,
-0.06782092154026031,
-0.08610361814498901,
-0.40123704075813293,
0.8041466474533081,
0.17464427649974823,
-0.6986159086227417,
0.6510827541351318,
-0.010465110652148724,
0.6994214653968811,
-0.6604753136634827,
-0.1573856770992279,
-0.46571120619773865,
0.31270116567611694,
0.02590986154973507,
-0.2246289700269699,
0.219429150223732,
0.0052105579525232315,
-0.3319977819919586,
-0.24749970436096191,
0.5584177374839783,
-0.5348091721534729,
-0.41737186908721924,
0.17672666907310486,
0.14879146218299866,
0.037123993039131165,
-0.13188931345939636,
-0.3764796257019043,
-0.023409122601151466,
-0.2427966147661209,
-0.4615154564380646,
0.5815497636795044,
0.43105265498161316,
-0.161789670586586,
0.37185660004615784,
0.6693223714828491,
0.37513670325279236,
0.09675148874521255,
-0.14858348667621613,
0.8034680485725403,
-0.5610413551330566,
-0.5861065983772278,
-0.8112227320671082,
0.2001582533121109,
-0.020757123827934265,
-0.0853801816701889,
0.4014219343662262,
0.472267746925354,
0.7101283073425293,
-0.02121453918516636,
0.4347012937068939,
0.22057753801345825,
0.7721177935600281,
-0.696267306804657,
0.5197888016700745,
-0.6654350161552429,
0.07833993434906006,
-0.12539757788181305,
-1.0274150371551514,
-0.43001610040664673,
0.4805624783039093,
0.042055875062942505,
0.23447251319885254,
0.5966469049453735,
0.7992160320281982,
-0.45349228382110596,
-0.4868556261062622,
0.45157209038734436,
0.4324921667575836,
0.27530792355537415,
0.7153284549713135,
0.5294894576072693,
-0.09285199642181396,
0.45989590883255005,
-0.1218557059764862,
-0.2629903554916382,
-0.137105792760849,
-1.0968109369277954,
-0.7247734069824219,
-0.22411665320396423,
-0.12096022069454193,
-0.4291231036186218,
0.06842485815286636,
1.0706144571304321,
0.9262115359306335,
-1.0711324214935303,
-0.13174884021282196,
-0.09765317291021347,
-0.1079571321606636,
-0.20156486332416534,
-0.23427601158618927,
0.6084045171737671,
-0.5241652131080627,
-1.0862329006195068,
0.5539788603782654,
0.5265186429023743,
0.11028363555669785,
-0.21040552854537964,
0.20951643586158752,
0.023692665621638298,
0.08752745389938354,
0.7044767141342163,
0.46344611048698425,
-0.6774207949638367,
-0.44097498059272766,
0.007034046575427055,
-0.10658568888902664,
0.35125452280044556,
0.7990482449531555,
-0.871070921421051,
0.17246268689632416,
0.3317251205444336,
0.8862982392311096,
0.5703034996986389,
0.19916078448295593,
0.41471001505851746,
-1.192775011062622,
0.7774867415428162,
0.28552988171577454,
0.2735940217971802,
0.20951059460639954,
-0.3437005281448364,
0.19278347492218018,
0.5838410258293152,
-0.31752297282218933,
-1.0709174871444702,
-0.0078059034422039986,
-1.1980128288269043,
-0.09759879112243652,
0.9422225952148438,
-0.26462510228157043,
-0.8367111086845398,
-0.16961224377155304,
-0.22552576661109924,
0.026236047968268394,
-0.36124399304389954,
0.6144500970840454,
0.6627076864242554,
-0.048632435500621796,
-0.46033918857574463,
-0.46703431010246277,
0.6808805465698242,
0.5744016766548157,
-0.7165700197219849,
0.2605278491973877,
0.5401719808578491,
0.31657782196998596,
-0.0985020250082016,
0.8122797608375549,
0.10282309353351593,
0.4222705066204071,
-0.3045004904270172,
-0.2093040645122528,
-0.04813770949840546,
-0.297029972076416,
-0.4948819875717163,
0.3203788101673126,
0.1663137972354889,
-0.38430914282798767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15485v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15485v2 | SegHist: A General Segmentation-based Framework for Chinese Historical Document Text Line Detection | 2024-06-17T11:00:04 | 2024-06-25T07:37:22 | Xingjian Hu, Baole Wei, Liangcai Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Text line detection is a key task in historical document analysis facing many
challenges of arbitrary-shaped text lines, dense texts, and text lines with
high aspect ratios, etc. In this paper, we propose a general framework for
historical document text detection (SegHist), enabling existing
segmentation-based text detection methods to effectively address the
challenges, especially text lines with high aspect ratios. Integrating the
SegHist framework with the commonly used method DB++, we develop DB-SegHist.
This approach achieves SOTA on the CHDAC, MTHv2, and competitive results on
HDRC datasets, with a significant improvement of 1.19% on the most challenging
CHDAC dataset which features more text lines with high aspect ratios. Moreover,
our method attains SOTA on rotated MTHv2 and rotated HDRC, demonstrating its
rotational robustness. The code is available at
https://github.com/LumionHXJ/SegHist. | [
-0.3641761839389801,
-1.0428197383880615,
0.5051228404045105,
0.0738663300871849,
-0.6080548763275146,
-0.44083720445632935,
0.2055085450410843,
-0.4684964418411255,
0.48315271735191345,
0.7651531100273132,
-0.7608998417854309,
-0.6635124683380127,
0.11397754400968552,
0.13430501520633698,
-0.406490683555603,
1.0100598335266113,
-0.08742132782936096,
0.04590168967843056,
0.123042032122612,
-0.2258118987083435,
-0.1801646202802658,
-0.5894933938980103,
-0.2914818227291107,
0.1113903596997261,
0.019099785014986992,
0.6074950098991394,
0.5043137669563293,
1.2484227418899536,
0.7624571919441223,
0.09313572943210602,
-0.012280693277716637,
0.26405858993530273,
-0.14849381148815155,
0.576629102230072,
0.13598109781742096,
-0.036504678428173065,
-0.5012052059173584,
-0.4873187243938446,
0.6517248153686523,
0.1318393349647522,
0.025876576080918312,
-0.26602569222450256,
0.12907174229621887,
0.746421754360199,
-0.5667986869812012,
-0.2379951924085617,
-0.18227198719978333,
0.05451007932424545,
-0.8348471522331238,
-0.6635003685951233,
-0.13796450197696686,
-0.3705440163612366,
0.13766750693321228,
-0.7527182698249817,
0.40040019154548645,
0.1427145004272461,
1.12529456615448,
-0.07550760358572006,
-0.4227178990840912,
-0.5192543864250183,
-0.25735071301460266,
0.5531269311904907,
-0.7384285926818848,
0.367143839597702,
0.41072049736976624,
0.4324917793273926,
-0.029834527522325516,
-0.7435523867607117,
-0.41813844442367554,
0.013675215654075146,
0.07237805426120758,
0.14671993255615234,
0.28196030855178833,
-0.2235155999660492,
0.19648660719394684,
0.6375297904014587,
-0.9329760074615479,
0.20299465954303741,
-0.14217448234558105,
-0.33997654914855957,
0.2996833026409149,
0.276164174079895,
0.6709532141685486,
-0.4663340151309967,
-0.5268489718437195,
-0.06556706875562668,
-0.6588298678398132,
0.12936466932296753,
0.4254624843597412,
-0.020628800615668297,
-0.08100371062755585,
0.15856698155403137,
-0.14527744054794312,
0.5417596697807312,
0.0336306206882,
0.13415312767028809,
0.007307388819754124,
-0.20233795046806335,
-0.3429316580295563,
0.13505038619041443,
0.6807767748832703,
0.27798721194267273,
-0.09540607780218124,
0.32121291756629944,
-0.06380891054868698,
-0.12818361818790436,
0.004721837118268013,
-1.1162532567977905,
-0.27588292956352234,
-0.25924041867256165,
-0.5323926210403442,
-0.2520008981227875,
0.20625516772270203,
-0.9992733001708984,
-0.8901744484901428,
0.02399767003953457,
0.0027068217750638723,
-0.651495099067688,
-0.07145323604345322,
-0.0327155701816082,
-0.09089574217796326,
0.7577247619628906,
0.5875105857849121,
-1.1915063858032227,
-0.08843035250902176,
0.7253023386001587,
0.9496132731437683,
-0.30108270049095154,
-0.17194540798664093,
-0.7080899477005005,
0.19471503794193268,
-0.3042528033256531,
1.3083550930023193,
-0.17697550356388092,
-0.4317791163921356,
0.07181950658559799,
0.17362163960933685,
0.43109869956970215,
-0.3475615978240967,
1.2101162672042847,
-0.36206796765327454,
0.34783461689949036,
-0.44682347774505615,
-0.36483800411224365,
-0.1481899470090866,
0.5396705865859985,
-0.8558802008628845,
1.096191644668579,
0.09844987839460373,
-1.169758677482605,
0.5273029208183289,
-0.1293799728155136,
-0.9452405571937561,
0.30995866656303406,
-0.3474438786506653,
-0.7642266154289246,
-0.4112517833709717,
0.5259400606155396,
0.4060804843902588,
-0.5815133452415466,
0.16655884683132172,
-0.37151315808296204,
-0.5473661422729492,
-0.18032792210578918,
-0.4592055380344391,
1.0566059350967407,
0.24610450863838196,
-0.42489156126976013,
0.1830853521823883,
-0.7231466770172119,
0.039838239550590515,
-0.0689157024025917,
-0.5108526945114136,
-0.5838870406150818,
0.044642385095357895,
0.5783603191375732,
-0.0875270888209343,
0.309831440448761,
-0.18243847787380219,
0.2883164882659912,
-0.38985675573349,
0.2076394408941269,
0.7548829317092896,
0.035926882177591324,
0.31611087918281555,
-0.18975088000297546,
0.45611944794654846,
-0.05686619132757187,
0.01088821142911911,
-0.45717453956604004,
0.021627530455589294,
-1.02530837059021,
-0.3216385841369629,
-0.04322493076324463,
0.46978744864463806,
-0.9627197980880737,
0.886748731136322,
-0.08374655246734619,
-0.38132697343826294,
0.1894640475511551,
-0.11654065549373627,
-0.0814637616276741,
0.267548143863678,
0.470853328704834,
-0.08370542526245117,
-0.9081682562828064,
-0.9452518224716187,
-0.19865518808364868,
-0.28826528787612915,
-0.19480958580970764,
0.01634240336716175,
0.5281184315681458,
-0.36041581630706787,
0.7200433015823364,
-0.5316113829612732,
-0.6306595206260681,
-0.18280646204948425,
0.019919967278838158,
0.15254157781600952,
0.51250159740448,
0.5805999636650085,
-0.9915208220481873,
-0.7456490993499756,
0.6340764760971069,
-0.7971131205558777,
-0.4668366611003876,
-0.33789682388305664,
-0.3291136622428894,
0.5154904723167419,
0.5839547514915466,
0.09450065344572067,
0.5567399263381958,
0.4089623689651489,
-0.6179475784301758,
0.7186985611915588,
-0.21118757128715515,
0.42116764187812805,
-1.061319351196289,
0.2855430543422699,
0.17907267808914185,
-0.30321481823921204,
-0.8841832876205444,
0.09407036751508713,
0.5840458869934082,
0.08178066462278366,
-0.05828217417001724,
0.2353695034980774,
-0.5166647434234619,
0.034060779958963394,
-0.14404204487800598,
0.003826186992228031,
0.13533265888690948,
0.504535436630249,
0.2349850982427597,
0.5310449600219727,
-0.009964409284293652,
-0.2110101580619812,
0.42650482058525085,
0.03042461723089218,
-0.5967662930488586,
1.0247219800949097,
-0.4491550326347351,
0.16032454371452332,
0.020257877185940742,
-0.027691256254911423,
-0.7384375929832458,
-0.19746848940849304,
0.3010287880897522,
-0.2722828984260559,
0.2397720366716385,
0.3235495388507843,
-0.145183727145195,
-0.18322725594043732,
-0.8345229625701904,
0.1917695254087448,
-0.11377084255218506,
-0.5774637460708618,
0.6172717809677124,
0.3151673674583435,
-0.3151523768901825,
-0.3804240822792053,
-0.6949841976165771,
0.012179028242826462,
-0.1676771193742752,
-1.0199906826019287,
0.25415176153182983,
-0.03291890397667885,
0.2556164562702179,
-0.2272707223892212,
-0.4485183358192444,
-0.6475268602371216,
0.08188161998987198,
0.11915270239114761,
0.45482319593429565,
-0.6066159605979919,
-0.3299018442630768,
0.36489176750183105,
-0.2547803521156311,
-0.35666683316230774,
-0.19462788105010986,
0.7285454869270325,
-0.04324959218502045,
-0.36300039291381836,
-0.5599820017814636,
0.2809847295284271,
0.6876589059829712,
-0.20792962610721588,
0.19505324959754944,
0.541826069355011,
-0.46741190552711487,
-0.1366032361984253,
-0.6600815057754517,
0.10974399000406265,
-0.4232156276702881,
0.42862439155578613,
-0.17087221145629883,
-0.9890267252922058,
0.36118602752685547,
0.384170264005661,
0.03965075686573982,
0.7246984243392944,
0.3148795962333679,
-0.1411401331424713,
0.7340337038040161,
0.45877307653427124,
-0.18095792829990387,
0.5052747130393982,
-0.10753026604652405,
-0.05994374677538872,
-0.7052597403526306,
-0.07917694747447968,
-0.7630916237831116,
-0.14326655864715576,
-0.2378162443637848,
-0.2833659052848816,
0.07988035678863525,
0.29089540243148804,
-0.39851415157318115,
0.4892284572124481,
-0.5895732045173645,
0.44504404067993164,
0.26920458674430847,
-0.024006037041544914,
0.4836730659008026,
-0.26014119386672974,
-0.028005799278616905,
-0.3266398310661316,
0.027647193521261215,
-0.551103413105011,
0.3367783725261688,
0.3140030801296234,
0.7989360690116882,
-0.05953991413116455,
0.5208593606948853,
0.5057844519615173,
-0.011208044365048409,
-0.8350870609283447,
0.48075294494628906,
-0.23642443120479584,
-0.6911816000938416,
-0.6065917015075684,
-0.33401867747306824,
-0.4843573272228241,
0.3436543941497803,
-0.16296382248401642,
-0.46741941571235657,
0.4631439447402954,
-0.10220858454704285,
-0.287288099527359,
0.26303738355636597,
-0.4012889862060547,
1.06251859664917,
-0.3721613585948944,
-0.16596809029579163,
0.19423545897006989,
-0.44110265374183655,
0.0821109265089035,
-0.3467470109462738,
-0.06392653286457062,
-0.05311253294348717,
0.20886248350143433,
0.9296451807022095,
-0.5888646245002747,
0.2669961452484131,
-0.10657161474227905,
-0.05183820798993111,
0.3155791163444519,
0.19447116553783417,
0.7250885963439941,
-0.159227654337883,
-0.0017550624907016754,
-0.1507522314786911,
0.3731142580509186,
-0.20867961645126343,
-0.3602856397628784,
0.5301005244255066,
-0.433782696723938,
-0.48031070828437805,
-0.446086585521698,
-0.18648754060268402,
0.42055705189704895,
0.5463818311691284,
0.5602746605873108,
0.3597947955131531,
-0.6397348642349243,
0.7053149342536926,
0.30793413519859314,
-0.16015489399433136,
0.2387930452823639,
0.43256568908691406,
-0.2797202169895172,
-0.43789827823638916,
0.5587661266326904,
0.13751816749572754,
-0.1586999148130417,
0.5139821171760559,
0.1414284110069275,
-0.2537911832332611,
-0.4905059337615967,
-0.6685056090354919,
-0.18087247014045715,
-0.6422151327133179,
-0.1971484124660492,
-0.5395340919494629,
-0.43451187014579773,
-0.4265653192996979,
-0.5332923531532288,
0.06895585358142853,
-0.2161567211151123,
-0.504456102848053,
0.0035549504682421684,
0.00833518523722887,
0.37927043437957764,
0.0572093166410923,
0.5415142774581909,
-0.45930910110473633,
0.34914112091064453,
0.15344549715518951,
-0.20527446269989014,
-0.09983833879232407,
-0.3650150001049042,
-0.4687464237213135,
-0.09509313106536865,
-0.6532697677612305,
-0.9144582748413086,
0.6739386916160583,
-0.06620697677135468,
0.29662710428237915,
0.8865209221839905,
0.2907530963420868,
0.4149089455604553,
-0.41311129927635193,
0.46929773688316345,
0.3401283025741577,
-1.0413035154342651,
0.3984450399875641,
-0.5869190096855164,
0.2528729736804962,
0.561583936214447,
-0.03890420123934746,
-1.088878870010376,
-0.15028977394104004,
-0.009574050083756447,
-0.7825121283531189,
0.8144426941871643,
0.05179264396429062,
-0.4896087646484375,
0.4791002869606018,
0.12337050586938858,
0.2070772647857666,
-0.3873278498649597,
-0.7897871732711792,
-0.037055376917123795,
-0.37120550870895386,
-0.2850102186203003,
0.3783489763736725,
-0.45226138830184937,
0.3996553421020508,
0.14319737255573273,
0.6271030306816101,
-0.16345900297164917,
-0.18087930977344513,
0.4248081147670746,
-0.33543160557746887,
-0.0047165038995444775,
0.6016387343406677,
0.46563297510147095,
0.42008140683174133,
-0.18810448050498962,
0.14642974734306335,
0.1911962330341339,
-0.8709792494773865,
0.22609294950962067,
0.3184342384338379,
-0.5613710880279541,
-0.17449548840522766,
0.4544316530227661,
0.6896888613700867,
-0.10999920219182968,
-0.28911539912223816,
0.6152657866477966,
-0.012391846626996994,
-0.23629148304462433,
-0.27246201038360596,
-0.11577987670898438,
-0.07216590642929077,
0.2497851550579071,
0.8196505308151245,
-0.13682794570922852,
0.4030567705631256,
-0.28357070684432983,
0.29309341311454773,
0.2030285745859146,
-0.6835044622421265,
-0.12097403407096863,
0.47773653268814087,
0.41447311639785767,
-0.2348942905664444,
0.338593065738678,
0.060199011117219925,
-0.9126256704330444,
0.7946940064430237,
0.3988780081272125,
0.8291840553283691,
-0.41178834438323975,
0.20399366319179535,
0.08941565454006195,
0.2714327871799469,
-0.11270251870155334,
0.0627829059958458,
-0.27063241600990295,
-0.7717050313949585,
-0.08904660493135452,
-0.47165098786354065,
-0.18876002728939056,
0.11987476050853729,
-0.703814685344696,
0.6146135330200195,
-0.7245274186134338,
0.09456689655780792,
0.050354890525341034,
0.1560794860124588,
-0.1354478895664215,
-0.004275161307305098,
-0.16997267305850983,
0.8398963809013367,
-0.5390639305114746,
1.0192649364471436,
0.4418431222438812,
-0.15646380186080933,
-0.43638986349105835,
0.24225853383541107,
0.29784825444221497,
-0.6197537183761597,
0.5009550452232361,
0.7622482180595398,
-0.21129260957241058,
-0.06290771067142487,
-0.21880343556404114,
-0.24375873804092407,
1.1557421684265137,
0.07318741828203201,
-0.4657631516456604,
-0.34132933616638184,
-0.20033608376979828,
0.4823622703552246,
-0.08477658778429031,
0.014658180065453053,
0.8480191826820374,
0.6165251731872559,
-0.00812153797596693,
-0.48090389370918274,
-0.059132225811481476,
-0.24659772217273712,
-0.11648508906364441,
0.4858313500881195,
-0.3974781930446625,
0.8855486512184143,
0.24663850665092468,
-0.8033530712127686,
0.6334776282310486,
0.6528111100196838,
0.2193414866924286,
0.48049238324165344,
0.4513974189758301,
0.4957045912742615,
0.6510248780250549,
-0.15927870571613312,
0.5145925283432007,
0.2622484862804413,
0.4881211817264557,
0.6593655347824097,
-0.5099503397941589,
0.6128720641136169,
0.2797043025493622,
0.04676120728254318,
0.6303625106811523,
0.6154553890228271,
-0.20747588574886322,
0.5356632471084595,
-0.05759834125638008,
-0.12897278368473053,
-0.25722745060920715,
-0.1777135580778122,
-0.7522460222244263,
0.18935714662075043,
0.27963897585868835,
-0.09372755885124207,
-0.18246746063232422,
-0.10610376298427582,
0.16454704105854034,
0.19635722041130066,
-0.2697167992591858,
0.3444047272205353,
-0.1132236123085022,
-0.2165829986333847,
0.292673796415329,
0.16717082262039185,
1.0154247283935547,
-0.6884049773216248,
0.07063289731740952,
-0.31279686093330383,
0.42527955770492554,
-0.21225452423095703,
-0.7406458258628845,
0.1837664693593979,
-0.056771859526634216,
-0.154802143573761,
0.1800621747970581,
0.9484686255455017,
-0.41473373770713806,
-0.21478308737277985,
0.1686922162771225,
0.12326256185770035,
-0.18439504504203796,
-0.0500161275267601,
-0.2096238136291504,
-0.01740875467658043,
0.4702073931694031,
-0.22721810638904572,
0.025423409417271614,
0.8133715391159058,
-0.1918601244688034,
0.16660700738430023,
0.7546414136886597,
-0.033074431121349335,
-0.352193683385849,
-0.26065656542778015,
0.7675238251686096,
-0.9311745166778564,
-1.1624925136566162,
-0.9803252816200256,
0.14344988763332367,
-0.37752631306648254,
-0.2663603723049164,
0.8190732598304749,
0.8188201785087585,
0.5962620377540588,
0.12057045102119446,
0.626541793346405,
0.006420990452170372,
0.6883703470230103,
-0.6923776865005493,
1.1784379482269287,
-0.52652907371521,
0.14677074551582336,
-0.398395836353302,
-0.8514031171798706,
-0.5115792155265808,
0.9468567371368408,
-0.35673612356185913,
-0.33951836824417114,
0.9569529891014099,
0.7202494144439697,
0.10322048515081406,
0.42817559838294983,
0.3240232467651367,
-0.13285286724567413,
0.6164156794548035,
0.619940996170044,
1.135694980621338,
-0.35277843475341797,
0.8384197950363159,
0.16503475606441498,
-0.2346673160791397,
-0.4911280870437622,
-0.7755755186080933,
-0.9744873642921448,
-0.7202785611152649,
0.20693454146385193,
-0.18553712964057922,
-0.02024940401315689,
0.5831649303436279,
0.5468414425849915,
-0.9113265872001648,
-0.33874887228012085,
0.11899982392787933,
0.035568565130233765,
0.12102091312408447,
-0.2624765932559967,
0.8712179660797119,
0.2394218146800995,
-0.36312708258628845,
0.11569765210151672,
0.7411231994628906,
0.24477948248386383,
-0.1324058175086975,
-0.37878453731536865,
-0.27131056785583496,
-0.4018975794315338,
0.1571095734834671,
0.5043559074401855,
-0.312392920255661,
-0.32137492299079895,
0.16728052496910095,
-0.49289336800575256,
0.28794875741004944,
1.1900718212127686,
-0.2129509150981903,
0.30224180221557617,
1.0155534744262695,
0.8126875162124634,
0.7350523471832275,
0.0809306725859642,
0.36096760630607605,
-0.4356794059276581,
0.3319435715675354,
0.25752371549606323,
0.5847301483154297,
0.3802405893802643,
-0.5030934810638428,
0.6157808899879456,
0.3293003737926483,
-0.716853141784668,
-0.5943292379379272,
0.019257772713899612,
-0.9818112254142761,
-0.4070524573326111,
0.8290989398956299,
-0.2137838900089264,
-0.3568493127822876,
-0.39067399501800537,
-0.7774317264556885,
0.13420747220516205,
-0.48189792037010193,
0.3593809902667999,
0.7091031074523926,
0.13966774940490723,
-0.1222137063741684,
-0.35478493571281433,
0.40727707743644714,
0.0895371288061142,
-1.0469554662704468,
0.1504954993724823,
0.9423706531524658,
-0.19366098940372467,
0.19442254304885864,
0.8538819551467896,
0.0162671972066164,
0.510798454284668,
-0.2073388248682022,
0.05272083729505539,
-0.03463192284107208,
-0.2734231650829315,
-0.28340646624565125,
0.024779105558991432,
-0.33099791407585144,
0.054991465061903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11410v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11410v2 | HARE: HumAn pRiors, a key to small language model Efficiency | 2024-06-17T10:56:03 | 2024-06-18T11:59:03 | Lingyun Zhang, Bin jin, Gaojian Ge, Lunhui Liu, Xuewen Shen, Mingyong Wu, Houqian Zhang, Yongneng Jiang, Shiqi Chen, Shi Pu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Human priors play a crucial role in efficiently utilizing data in deep
learning. However, with the development of large language models (LLMs), there
is an increasing emphasis on scaling both model size and data volume, which
often diminishes the importance of human priors in data construction.
Influenced by these trends, existing Small Language Models (SLMs) mainly rely
on web-scraped large-scale training data, neglecting the proper incorporation
of human priors. This oversight limits the training efficiency of language
models in resource-constrained settings. In this paper, we propose a principle
to leverage human priors for data construction. This principle emphasizes
achieving high-performance SLMs by training on a concise dataset that
accommodates both semantic diversity and data quality consistency, while
avoiding benchmark data leakage. Following this principle, we train an SLM
named HARE-1.1B. Extensive experiments on large-scale benchmark datasets
demonstrate that HARE-1.1B performs favorably against state-of-the-art SLMs,
validating the effectiveness of the proposed principle. Additionally, this
provides new insights into efficient language model training in
resource-constrained environments from the view of human priors. | [
-0.3895145356655121,
-0.2618265151977539,
0.581032395362854,
0.043486569076776505,
-0.10510504245758057,
-0.1807997077703476,
-0.5719491839408875,
-0.16302195191383362,
-0.15056733787059784,
0.759982705116272,
-0.6193318963050842,
-0.5565807819366455,
-0.4052472412586212,
0.006256093271076679,
-0.08643704652786255,
0.6720591187477112,
0.17293110489845276,
0.14049915969371796,
-0.22203494608402252,
-0.21362656354904175,
-0.5643219351768494,
-0.6076900959014893,
-0.6421036720275879,
-0.1925654262304306,
0.4382292628288269,
0.5910372138023376,
0.8644174337387085,
0.8494419455528259,
0.37840986251831055,
0.23376554250717163,
0.19978177547454834,
0.30491572618484497,
-0.45476487278938293,
0.08529385924339294,
-0.3720136880874634,
-0.8132226467132568,
-0.31805166602134705,
-0.08932216465473175,
0.7484312057495117,
1.0661741495132446,
-0.3275742828845978,
0.34826022386550903,
0.02813221514225006,
0.9604581594467163,
-0.9932529926300049,
-0.009842249564826488,
-0.9880920052528381,
0.1268373280763626,
-0.5730441212654114,
0.3813544511795044,
-0.5301239490509033,
-0.1099291667342186,
0.0743621364235878,
-0.7898551821708679,
0.4371563494205475,
0.10494351387023926,
0.8603057861328125,
0.34186580777168274,
0.03385740891098976,
0.07366839051246643,
-0.685981273651123,
0.9623317122459412,
-0.8627244234085083,
0.8338238596916199,
1.0886329412460327,
0.3070342540740967,
-0.19469672441482544,
-0.640599250793457,
-0.5492339134216309,
0.08223670721054077,
-0.2399027794599533,
-0.4214109778404236,
0.08334720134735107,
-0.21283183991909027,
0.37266430258750916,
-0.00018799789540935308,
-0.4804724454879761,
0.2714400589466095,
-0.30888134241104126,
-0.1517433226108551,
0.673114001750946,
0.4959084689617157,
-0.05163995176553726,
0.09694825857877731,
0.11012934893369675,
-0.31626835465431213,
-0.9707612991333008,
0.07649975270032883,
0.2754964530467987,
0.673535168170929,
-0.015411322005093098,
0.2756146788597107,
-0.29965290427207947,
0.5929678678512573,
-0.22252993285655975,
-0.24823258817195892,
0.07209524512290955,
-0.4813297390937805,
-0.16942211985588074,
-0.22389306128025055,
0.6992533206939697,
-0.05720692500472069,
0.4411192536354065,
-0.31725677847862244,
-0.13336504995822906,
0.03184899687767029,
0.4001726508140564,
-0.9375757575035095,
-0.4618196487426758,
-0.3222114145755768,
-0.4937504529953003,
0.07488587498664856,
0.15158548951148987,
-0.6867649555206299,
-0.1964607536792755,
-0.30102986097335815,
0.010297974571585655,
-0.42061424255371094,
-0.408793568611145,
0.46052753925323486,
0.25848081707954407,
0.11758102476596832,
0.18398459255695343,
-1.0956519842147827,
0.817449152469635,
0.7702547907829285,
0.5763431787490845,
0.1424863338470459,
-0.4063107669353485,
-0.5941019654273987,
0.3309076428413391,
-0.6252983808517456,
0.3140355050563812,
-0.6640865802764893,
-0.300234317779541,
-0.026691989973187447,
-0.18041358888149261,
0.16738367080688477,
-0.6710824370384216,
0.7490036487579346,
-0.5485091209411621,
-0.10442269593477249,
-0.40397611260414124,
-0.6507429480552673,
-0.09665369242429733,
-0.3081378936767578,
-0.5577518343925476,
0.7255474328994751,
0.04285489767789841,
-0.5908625721931458,
0.6961110234260559,
-0.41263076663017273,
-0.6907376050949097,
-0.05606295168399811,
-0.3371613323688507,
-0.517648458480835,
0.37369677424430847,
0.4169687330722809,
0.5648651123046875,
-0.17276637256145477,
-0.06597048789262772,
-0.5190114378929138,
-0.14912691712379456,
0.11837413161993027,
-0.048808734863996506,
0.5146350860595703,
0.45551222562789917,
0.015035347081720829,
-0.4920193552970886,
-0.3578018844127655,
0.12489037960767746,
0.360153466463089,
-0.17559069395065308,
-0.7396883368492126,
0.32613131403923035,
-0.28998714685440063,
0.05887925997376442,
-0.08212360739707947,
-0.2637004554271698,
0.3198843002319336,
-0.398065447807312,
0.09907317161560059,
0.6213130354881287,
-0.3205077052116394,
0.7662412524223328,
-0.3661140501499176,
0.2169010043144226,
-0.15654107928276062,
-0.03713550046086311,
-0.21050231158733368,
-0.20763811469078064,
-0.8424630761146545,
-0.3077571988105774,
0.36627909541130066,
0.26035547256469727,
-0.026539301499724388,
0.6329341530799866,
-0.4897380471229553,
-0.35426291823387146,
-0.7800650596618652,
0.7057344913482666,
0.21555043756961823,
0.3212399482727051,
0.15379402041435242,
-0.14830970764160156,
-0.8223413825035095,
-1.0796263217926025,
-0.13035184144973755,
-0.007642512209713459,
-0.10118439793586731,
0.305891215801239,
0.2152908742427826,
-0.21932284533977509,
1.3316291570663452,
-0.6808279156684875,
-0.3919730484485626,
-0.18947827816009521,
-0.03871460258960724,
0.165719136595726,
0.7421320676803589,
0.3595966696739197,
-0.6671765446662903,
-0.42068231105804443,
-0.431437611579895,
-0.7072150707244873,
-0.0021288597490638494,
-0.06484345346689224,
-0.41842496395111084,
-0.0403478741645813,
0.46994343400001526,
-0.7530508041381836,
0.283541202545166,
0.24192526936531067,
-0.003339651972055435,
0.2631469666957855,
-0.20219208300113678,
-0.2473691999912262,
-0.7355313301086426,
-0.2705816626548767,
0.13236276805400848,
-0.4396374523639679,
-0.48767781257629395,
0.05087244138121605,
0.23364906013011932,
-0.15862825512886047,
-0.34975212812423706,
0.5453740954399109,
-0.4472738802433014,
0.0022046277299523354,
-0.1664430797100067,
-0.17240387201309204,
-0.06533710658550262,
0.39657485485076904,
0.26551249623298645,
0.7661882042884827,
0.38324928283691406,
-0.7866182923316956,
-0.34457099437713623,
0.3242613971233368,
-0.3893870413303375,
0.46660101413726807,
-0.5300571322441101,
0.39478442072868347,
0.022992268204689026,
0.09691385924816132,
-0.5253390669822693,
-0.0698237195611,
-0.05801672115921974,
-0.2237565517425537,
0.5999369621276855,
-0.0630011186003685,
-0.8084332346916199,
-0.20423635840415955,
-0.19065618515014648,
0.3603392541408539,
0.9190592169761658,
-0.37946006655693054,
0.26636096835136414,
0.6097785830497742,
-0.13481082022190094,
-0.24199342727661133,
-0.6379585266113281,
-0.0007290500798262656,
-0.1770358830690384,
-0.8345063328742981,
-0.0599733367562294,
0.0030872481875121593,
-0.35165390372276306,
-0.031326763331890106,
-0.18517501652240753,
-0.2071940302848816,
0.2786792814731598,
0.07147113233804703,
-0.016831405460834503,
-0.3449608087539673,
0.22040027379989624,
-0.08820238709449768,
-0.1642274111509323,
-0.09838332235813141,
-0.3495332598686218,
0.49804043769836426,
-0.09579981863498688,
-0.40745317935943604,
-0.600990355014801,
0.29030683636665344,
0.25540751218795776,
-0.31575462222099304,
0.5704137682914734,
0.3425634205341339,
-0.6750507950782776,
-0.2729896306991577,
-0.6652502417564392,
-0.3820185363292694,
-0.4732052683830261,
0.5529099106788635,
-0.3387705385684967,
-0.5181446075439453,
0.2667698264122009,
-0.10962557792663574,
0.13736018538475037,
0.3334294557571411,
0.3091379404067993,
-0.26908475160598755,
1.0235652923583984,
0.764796257019043,
-0.3730894923210144,
0.3934485614299774,
-0.30304306745529175,
-0.26719164848327637,
-0.8944259285926819,
0.1449812799692154,
-0.6484932899475098,
-0.25387972593307495,
-0.06681769341230392,
-0.4522028863430023,
-0.16172578930854797,
0.4982883632183075,
-0.5108107924461365,
0.3067702651023865,
-0.21621471643447876,
0.480557918548584,
0.4612400531768799,
0.1098385900259018,
0.22257861495018005,
0.021184585988521576,
0.003405065042898059,
-0.5524097681045532,
-0.7012839317321777,
-0.7709805369377136,
1.3049900531768799,
0.42640599608421326,
1.2399109601974487,
0.06950810551643372,
0.7553969025611877,
0.2661031484603882,
0.25573423504829407,
-0.3377903699874878,
0.497196227312088,
-0.24924084544181824,
-0.7411348819732666,
-0.41420304775238037,
-0.35237908363342285,
-1.076151728630066,
0.3031846880912781,
-0.23900601267814636,
-0.7213038206100464,
0.012172883376479149,
0.21119315922260284,
-0.20829884707927704,
0.2856276333332062,
-0.9476699829101562,
0.8011873960494995,
-0.31740203499794006,
-0.49683889746665955,
-0.36955922842025757,
-0.6017311215400696,
0.15418118238449097,
-0.2813315987586975,
0.3479142189025879,
-0.311690092086792,
-0.40791893005371094,
0.8491966128349304,
-0.7363163232803345,
0.9820486903190613,
-0.2808106541633606,
0.22292745113372803,
-0.027850916609168053,
0.28386878967285156,
0.8329354524612427,
0.20879866182804108,
0.13446716964244843,
0.21168318390846252,
-0.4587136507034302,
-0.5182623267173767,
-0.555103600025177,
0.4658209979534149,
-0.8216745853424072,
-0.5229930877685547,
-0.12016722559928894,
-0.31826141476631165,
-0.37540510296821594,
0.19767315685749054,
0.20926415920257568,
0.325467973947525,
0.08663758635520935,
0.3302082419395447,
0.7324802279472351,
0.16850562393665314,
0.14973080158233643,
0.6515681743621826,
-0.1725008338689804,
-0.1596367061138153,
0.6919643878936768,
0.04241436719894409,
0.1955072581768036,
0.3351882994174957,
0.30613234639167786,
-0.2978859841823578,
-0.8337931036949158,
-0.3222575783729553,
0.30412667989730835,
-0.5371739268302917,
-0.3613782823085785,
-0.6607731580734253,
0.09536167234182358,
-0.25343814492225647,
-0.281232088804245,
-0.7504947185516357,
-0.06323404610157013,
-0.24614456295967102,
0.10875251889228821,
0.21832096576690674,
0.6030561327934265,
0.0427074208855629,
0.41495460271835327,
-0.8012587428092957,
0.2171255350112915,
0.3902917504310608,
0.45114755630493164,
0.14941942691802979,
-0.3337542414665222,
-0.4756014049053192,
0.38033005595207214,
-0.11743630468845367,
-0.46496865153312683,
0.25014472007751465,
0.36735981702804565,
0.9094313979148865,
0.3595823347568512,
0.09514074772596359,
0.8558123707771301,
-0.7098724842071533,
0.5688603520393372,
0.09490057080984116,
-0.8092926144599915,
0.5973069071769714,
-0.2741869390010834,
0.19603711366653442,
0.9845739603042603,
0.229362353682518,
-0.4113805890083313,
-0.5069559812545776,
-0.5830186009407043,
-0.6757934093475342,
0.8440752625465393,
0.19977247714996338,
0.18836936354637146,
0.2285403609275818,
0.39764875173568726,
0.46271783113479614,
0.2630753517150879,
-0.44648104906082153,
-0.2164846807718277,
-0.11834026128053665,
-0.2298736274242401,
-0.25217729806900024,
-0.08497416228055954,
0.11684189736843109,
-0.3889049291610718,
0.5775057077407837,
0.12601406872272491,
-0.3294603228569031,
0.08065873384475708,
-0.6484596133232117,
-0.0877472385764122,
0.08718511462211609,
0.4197697043418884,
0.8062167763710022,
-0.29740118980407715,
0.19151271879673004,
0.4391185939311981,
-0.477001428604126,
0.3197859227657318,
-0.23205876350402832,
-0.19755876064300537,
-0.11021704226732254,
0.4748948812484741,
0.6276118159294128,
0.19880779087543488,
-0.4551563560962677,
0.3756982684135437,
-0.16534391045570374,
0.0589480884373188,
-0.21800951659679413,
0.1799083799123764,
0.1592361330986023,
0.03595487400889397,
0.5534601807594299,
0.1806102842092514,
-0.18958455324172974,
-0.11870895326137543,
0.4849299490451813,
0.33231207728385925,
0.017366744577884674,
-0.39040395617485046,
0.5856345295906067,
0.09749561548233032,
-0.44802233576774597,
0.755067765712738,
-0.2971000671386719,
-0.2698279917240143,
0.1324540078639984,
0.49103957414627075,
0.8018801212310791,
-0.042568229138851166,
-0.2647330164909363,
0.34744787216186523,
0.35436856746673584,
-0.3776555061340332,
-0.16670291125774384,
-0.09496743977069855,
-0.8087087273597717,
-0.44037219882011414,
-0.6295983791351318,
-0.1437678337097168,
0.3188363015651703,
-0.5869574546813965,
0.39360979199409485,
-0.5419209599494934,
-0.20746339857578278,
-0.051063597202301025,
0.14415939152240753,
-1.2224435806274414,
0.03228486701846123,
0.2593208849430084,
1.0295640230178833,
-0.7853595614433289,
1.0129228830337524,
0.6509711742401123,
-0.33642029762268066,
-0.8387971520423889,
0.04889898747205734,
-0.1943930983543396,
-0.7329889535903931,
0.865691065788269,
-0.04624391719698906,
0.0745701864361763,
-0.18405352532863617,
-0.5112438797950745,
-0.8233882784843445,
0.7852057218551636,
0.6190572381019592,
-0.7156998515129089,
-0.0301616620272398,
0.0318521223962307,
0.3212394118309021,
-0.3902689516544342,
-0.17056553065776825,
0.3918305039405823,
0.28450965881347656,
-0.19500604271888733,
-0.6833102703094482,
0.12988552451133728,
-0.028599712997674942,
0.2286449521780014,
0.30082032084465027,
-0.35314691066741943,
0.7374516725540161,
-0.2989595830440521,
-0.3046824634075165,
0.15633228421211243,
0.9344326853752136,
0.17670325934886932,
-0.16104337573051453,
0.7552440166473389,
0.7478123903274536,
0.8949411511421204,
0.14363867044448853,
1.0804592370986938,
0.054137859493494034,
0.37453484535217285,
1.2411341667175293,
-0.5171573162078857,
0.9477455615997314,
0.2368241548538208,
-0.6388136148452759,
0.2722822427749634,
0.6208663582801819,
0.2821809649467468,
0.9164804816246033,
0.3441896438598633,
0.0390126071870327,
-0.6572912931442261,
0.1551852822303772,
-0.41125085949897766,
0.4523480236530304,
0.41417306661605835,
0.058003973215818405,
-0.33907949924468994,
-0.09896872192621231,
0.19960284233093262,
0.363699346780777,
-0.24562744796276093,
0.7804524898529053,
0.06851914525032043,
-0.37914180755615234,
0.6369185447692871,
-0.16883783042430878,
0.8442859053611755,
-0.9507924914360046,
0.2071368545293808,
-0.209935262799263,
0.3417893052101135,
-0.0011503095738589764,
-0.5780574083328247,
0.27261480689048767,
-0.0698978528380394,
-0.4366741180419922,
0.0025676600635051727,
0.6558207869529724,
-0.3154112696647644,
-0.6263633966445923,
-0.001792114577256143,
0.503618061542511,
-0.00571789825335145,
0.014386849477887154,
-0.4506607949733734,
0.029471982270479202,
-0.28400498628616333,
-0.09900636970996857,
0.4740724265575409,
0.3913865089416504,
-0.11230993270874023,
0.7220627069473267,
0.7697280645370483,
0.51893550157547,
-0.0894501581788063,
-0.09310203045606613,
0.7226397395133972,
-0.6375918388366699,
-0.6655107736587524,
-1.019385814666748,
0.33109691739082336,
-0.27774643898010254,
-0.10041475296020508,
0.6962462663650513,
0.8163678050041199,
1.098136305809021,
0.11574486643075943,
0.8169716000556946,
0.3503587245941162,
0.7121084332466125,
-0.4808591902256012,
0.8280084729194641,
-0.5721873044967651,
0.2093878537416458,
-0.266593337059021,
-0.6230930685997009,
-0.185972198843956,
0.8767380714416504,
-0.14356045424938202,
0.001354769803583622,
0.455819308757782,
0.723210871219635,
-0.25070926547050476,
-0.10579531639814377,
0.2158747762441635,
-0.16986557841300964,
0.4194270074367523,
0.37355145812034607,
0.7416430115699768,
-0.10818751901388168,
0.4291365146636963,
-0.5228562951087952,
0.0095423124730587,
-0.20244377851486206,
-0.9147667288780212,
-0.9043830037117004,
-0.689289391040802,
-0.05165372043848038,
0.007192528340965509,
-0.0365527980029583,
1.1141009330749512,
1.388432502746582,
-0.7057782411575317,
-0.3046824634075165,
0.03528747707605362,
0.10184060037136078,
-0.14360086619853973,
-0.16549181938171387,
0.37669381499290466,
-0.6096353530883789,
-0.5053701996803284,
0.10299625247716904,
0.05956573411822319,
-0.008540865033864975,
-0.2588440775871277,
-0.4819263219833374,
-0.16965274512767792,
-0.15138640999794006,
0.3886498808860779,
0.2765737473964691,
-0.7316610217094421,
-0.3783252537250519,
-0.053903039544820786,
-0.46849295496940613,
-0.020356733351945877,
1.0427799224853516,
-0.9256206750869751,
0.36042290925979614,
0.23442427814006805,
0.9495735168457031,
0.61637943983078,
-0.17239798605442047,
0.7915166616439819,
-1.1079974174499512,
0.554916262626648,
0.350375771522522,
0.6199561357498169,
0.5053134560585022,
-0.24075530469417572,
0.5536354780197144,
0.1587718278169632,
-0.3700018525123596,
-0.9043236970901489,
0.1355207860469818,
-0.6321738958358765,
-0.2180342674255371,
1.118533730506897,
-0.00010490637214388698,
-0.03524673357605934,
-0.09117239713668823,
-0.1578483283519745,
0.032010965049266815,
-0.5908308625221252,
0.308750182390213,
0.6359628438949585,
0.16139473021030426,
0.07278215140104294,
-0.6736699938774109,
0.5886710286140442,
0.4242727756500244,
-0.7285659313201904,
0.32225966453552246,
0.22866898775100708,
0.2417486608028412,
-0.07209225744009018,
0.8760497570037842,
0.25421151518821716,
0.10182247310876846,
0.05463637411594391,
-0.005369256716221571,
-0.26129579544067383,
-0.18895861506462097,
-0.07514874637126923,
-0.2055758237838745,
0.3264647126197815,
-0.39578279852867126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11409v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11409v2 | CodeGemma: Open Code Models Based on Gemma | 2024-06-17T10:54:35 | 2024-06-19T02:37:50 | CodeGemma Team, Heri Zhao, Jeffrey Hui, Joshua Howland, Nam Nguyen, Siqi Zuo, Andrea Hu, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, Jingyue Shen, Joe Kelley, Kshitij Bansal, Luke Vilnis, Mateo Wirth, Paul Michel, Peter Choy, Pratik Joshi, Ravin Kumar, Sarmad Hashmi, Shubham Agrawal, Zhitao Gong, Jane Fine, Tris Warkentin, Ale Jakse Hartman, Bin Ni, Kathy Korevec, Kelly Schaefer, Scott Huffman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper introduces CodeGemma, a collection of specialized open code models
built on top of Gemma, capable of a variety of code and natural language
generation tasks. We release three model variants. CodeGemma 7B pretrained (PT)
and instruction-tuned (IT) variants have remarkably resilient natural language
understanding, excel in mathematical reasoning, and match code capabilities of
other open models. CodeGemma 2B is a state-of-the-art code completion model
designed for fast code infilling and open-ended generation in latency-sensitive
settings. | [
-0.2621902823448181,
-0.7796075344085693,
0.125722274184227,
0.2589772045612335,
-0.12077581882476807,
0.1451677680015564,
-0.018420003354549408,
-0.6472435593605042,
-0.04310031235218048,
0.8111633658409119,
-0.4082777798175812,
-0.46224072575569153,
-0.5780015587806702,
-0.044115323573350906,
-0.17531268298625946,
0.8406168818473816,
-0.03147893026471138,
0.36949437856674194,
-0.11848442256450653,
-0.05650365352630615,
-0.6256426572799683,
-0.655083954334259,
-0.33540642261505127,
-0.4922478199005127,
0.07820423692464828,
0.5862197875976562,
0.9814630150794983,
0.40398091077804565,
0.7295143008232117,
0.11727623641490936,
0.065480537712574,
0.22446799278259277,
-0.5990661382675171,
-0.2862545847892761,
-0.046413082629442215,
-0.8710169196128845,
-0.6829472780227661,
-0.0008513231878168881,
0.27444812655448914,
0.5241345763206482,
-0.04633691534399986,
0.48411136865615845,
0.020187892019748688,
0.5458667278289795,
-0.7336995005607605,
0.4905402362346649,
-0.767807126045227,
0.12123096734285355,
-0.07027998566627502,
-0.004498791880905628,
-0.6622763276100159,
-0.7059581279754639,
-0.11102024465799332,
-0.3518316447734833,
0.25108394026756287,
-0.13295327126979828,
0.8561609387397766,
0.23073241114616394,
-0.2633378803730011,
-0.6625257134437561,
-0.4515736997127533,
0.708374559879303,
-0.7715592980384827,
-0.05447674170136452,
0.6767714619636536,
0.4864555299282074,
-0.47744306921958923,
-1.0349353551864624,
-0.13872019946575165,
-0.3329342305660248,
-0.08983151614665985,
-0.05117324739694595,
-0.3451853394508362,
0.10811900347471237,
0.2039448767900467,
0.8407735228538513,
-0.5506051182746887,
-0.031217478215694427,
-0.705682098865509,
0.001295944326557219,
0.14605681598186493,
0.09693457186222076,
0.48035648465156555,
0.15067602694034576,
-0.18151773512363434,
0.3170035779476166,
-1.21919846534729,
-0.08855772018432617,
0.3960864841938019,
0.3148871064186096,
-0.25456297397613525,
0.8444039821624756,
0.041947126388549805,
1.1006017923355103,
0.050564058125019073,
0.00146187050268054,
0.035255178809165955,
0.00945468619465828,
-0.5307902693748474,
0.20919886231422424,
0.34526681900024414,
-0.08081335574388504,
0.5683997273445129,
-0.10533873736858368,
0.0016249725595116615,
0.4066965579986572,
0.5674518346786499,
-0.9627259373664856,
-0.4600057005882263,
0.030377479270100594,
-0.6477006077766418,
-0.4232569634914398,
0.14983685314655304,
-0.5357387065887451,
0.058972980827093124,
-0.10691335052251816,
0.5919761061668396,
-0.4267868995666504,
-0.37549281120300293,
0.7618985176086426,
0.3354705572128296,
0.05649394169449806,
0.06745496392250061,
-0.9066576957702637,
0.25578227639198303,
0.7108443379402161,
0.8469977974891663,
0.17037756741046906,
-0.09203628450632095,
-0.7214940786361694,
0.1908138394355774,
-0.6828070282936096,
0.5278983116149902,
-0.8118615746498108,
-0.5602386593818665,
0.15898647904396057,
-0.043408025056123734,
-0.13481761515140533,
-0.6247900724411011,
0.3613503873348236,
-0.8197293877601624,
0.4280119240283966,
-0.037274137139320374,
-0.5845423340797424,
-0.47589436173439026,
0.06386025995016098,
-0.8095531463623047,
1.238949179649353,
0.3415602147579193,
-0.8256340026855469,
0.3969154357910156,
-0.8462477326393127,
-0.21568623185157776,
0.14961598813533783,
-0.05976986885070801,
-0.4403485357761383,
0.35056638717651367,
-0.0743628591299057,
0.23371751606464386,
-0.48278120160102844,
0.4557047486305237,
-0.2299318015575409,
-0.48209503293037415,
0.0176004096865654,
-0.011997475288808346,
0.8389210104942322,
0.5579403042793274,
-0.457529217004776,
0.1341029852628708,
-0.8911285996437073,
0.15619593858718872,
0.23958440124988556,
-0.5263710021972656,
0.027323123067617416,
0.03541639447212219,
-0.2902955114841461,
0.15553046762943268,
0.41148263216018677,
-0.3061085641384125,
0.2707033157348633,
-0.3306344151496887,
0.3685421049594879,
0.1423264443874359,
-0.13898137211799622,
0.24903029203414917,
-0.6788637042045593,
0.8099160194396973,
-0.15698440372943878,
0.014538539573550224,
-0.4292760491371155,
-0.9289142489433289,
-0.7447882294654846,
-0.5359427332878113,
0.16200636327266693,
0.3601771295070648,
-0.556835949420929,
0.3271971046924591,
0.11451271921396255,
-0.6302433013916016,
-0.5565221309661865,
0.030145112425088882,
0.9788927435874939,
0.3632083833217621,
0.3843935430049896,
-0.2819919288158417,
-0.5146652460098267,
-0.6611855626106262,
-0.1938277930021286,
-0.37411871552467346,
0.05355466157197952,
-0.028969375416636467,
0.2659897804260254,
-0.19811880588531494,
1.0758006572723389,
-0.6492540836334229,
-0.07384691387414932,
-0.42594602704048157,
0.25566309690475464,
0.1704414039850235,
0.5282331705093384,
0.8782901167869568,
-0.5552544593811035,
-0.22176581621170044,
-0.22876369953155518,
-0.7099399566650391,
-0.30044490098953247,
0.3248337209224701,
-0.22308561205863953,
0.2969017028808594,
0.3187750279903412,
-0.3785720467567444,
0.6255136728286743,
0.7143219113349915,
-0.358497679233551,
0.6261255741119385,
-0.3181765377521515,
0.12072765827178955,
-1.4109371900558472,
-0.06783850491046906,
-0.4129597544670105,
-0.2851746678352356,
-0.4942285716533661,
0.7749610543251038,
0.22857382893562317,
-0.30369213223457336,
-0.5574834942817688,
0.41552382707595825,
-0.790800154209137,
-0.4221395254135132,
-0.26405924558639526,
-0.18133658170700073,
0.08259692788124084,
0.4160904586315155,
0.0012188645778223872,
1.0806325674057007,
0.7068737745285034,
-0.7086049318313599,
0.019253963604569435,
0.33060145378112793,
-0.5159946084022522,
-0.14622566103935242,
-0.7958259582519531,
0.23015451431274414,
0.06313717365264893,
-0.20396240055561066,
-0.8225087523460388,
-0.40497028827667236,
0.008413701318204403,
-0.4617433547973633,
0.30061399936676025,
-0.4613416790962219,
-0.76741623878479,
-0.43681600689888,
0.06524282693862915,
0.434858113527298,
0.7342789769172668,
-0.8310176730155945,
0.3920655846595764,
0.3758159875869751,
0.050024714320898056,
-0.32704341411590576,
-0.6799036264419556,
-0.06620434671640396,
-0.012615391053259373,
-0.7504961490631104,
0.18580973148345947,
-0.12076274305582047,
-0.32853588461875916,
0.00363524304702878,
0.04766155034303665,
-0.34255751967430115,
-0.008015383966267109,
0.3195778727531433,
0.45547255873680115,
-0.5918802618980408,
0.0933854952454567,
-0.027702288702130318,
-0.035425759851932526,
0.015126034617424011,
-0.14458464086055756,
0.7794913649559021,
-0.3679189085960388,
-0.5432777404785156,
0.2839667499065399,
0.2610999345779419,
0.5330235362052917,
-0.6625785231590271,
0.6399720907211304,
0.3598497211933136,
-0.6463015675544739,
-0.2191791832447052,
-0.230210542678833,
0.20923352241516113,
-0.5119501352310181,
0.27675288915634155,
-0.6950462460517883,
-1.1963897943496704,
0.5024600028991699,
0.1226545199751854,
0.18288832902908325,
0.2135716676712036,
0.9435609579086304,
0.7044046521186829,
0.9632306694984436,
0.8495851755142212,
0.18190570175647736,
0.15834902226924896,
-0.04981565475463867,
0.36554741859436035,
-0.19891007244586945,
-0.3472071886062622,
-0.7654925584793091,
0.2939162254333496,
-0.2644640803337097,
-0.6356273889541626,
-0.05593578889966011,
0.6672236919403076,
-0.3611564636230469,
0.7879930734634399,
-0.5718034505844116,
0.45782235264778137,
0.6087542772293091,
-0.03782268241047859,
0.43310126662254333,
-0.056064944714307785,
-0.3569868803024292,
0.1203828677535057,
-0.9062833786010742,
-0.8757681250572205,
1.0634303092956543,
0.3738006055355072,
1.054222822189331,
0.4620368182659149,
0.5772274136543274,
0.1870889961719513,
0.29340052604675293,
-0.5537649393081665,
0.4728005528450012,
-0.07963961362838745,
-0.8489546775817871,
0.3665611445903778,
-0.3380860686302185,
-0.7186780571937561,
-0.22582033276557922,
-0.046204403042793274,
-0.8146845102310181,
-0.19820567965507507,
0.19323770701885223,
-0.24241648614406586,
0.47409090399742126,
-0.9088218808174133,
0.7548432946205139,
0.19947762787342072,
-0.27561527490615845,
-0.36954912543296814,
-0.2810600996017456,
0.8188434839248657,
-0.25860124826431274,
-0.13433001935482025,
-0.13028579950332642,
0.30800795555114746,
0.3944007158279419,
-0.7011658549308777,
0.7680055499076843,
0.08167044073343277,
-0.33115264773368835,
0.7265510559082031,
0.663280725479126,
0.30896565318107605,
0.186072438955307,
-0.09875021129846573,
0.1820230484008789,
-0.1332581639289856,
-0.5603672862052917,
-0.23699147999286652,
0.6078989505767822,
-0.6018499135971069,
-0.4253087341785431,
-0.07817897945642471,
-0.42839759588241577,
-0.1449853777885437,
0.16316527128219604,
0.5605937838554382,
1.0436211824417114,
-0.08289848268032074,
0.03573768585920334,
0.785451352596283,
-0.3543568253517151,
0.5912495851516724,
0.5422284603118896,
-0.6908504366874695,
-0.1920270323753357,
0.4646488130092621,
-0.2606922388076782,
0.4011974036693573,
0.39322423934936523,
-0.17691099643707275,
-0.03489411994814873,
-0.35854190587997437,
-0.39159923791885376,
-0.0880524292588234,
-0.6778038740158081,
-0.44140002131462097,
-0.6695120334625244,
-0.3595321476459503,
-0.2837572991847992,
-0.39820048213005066,
-0.4902251660823822,
-0.4421100616455078,
-0.5103411078453064,
-0.008604206144809723,
0.5168418884277344,
1.204493761062622,
0.06022201478481293,
0.416923463344574,
-1.1570079326629639,
0.5112366676330566,
0.20829521119594574,
0.5724005103111267,
-0.36237087845802307,
-0.31797927618026733,
-0.43318819999694824,
0.1083826869726181,
-0.3044878840446472,
-0.945518970489502,
0.3358212411403656,
0.09970053285360336,
0.45099490880966187,
0.5774726867675781,
-0.13956472277641296,
0.4548913240432739,
-0.4465045630931854,
0.8898827433586121,
0.40879160165786743,
-0.9681019186973572,
0.5248132348060608,
-0.4087694585323334,
0.29307690262794495,
0.31262627243995667,
0.29405394196510315,
0.22950758039951324,
-0.3307269513607025,
-0.4017295241355896,
-0.1889934539794922,
0.5270345211029053,
0.23888768255710602,
0.04593163728713989,
-0.49158036708831787,
0.1610986888408661,
0.3670257031917572,
0.2038840502500534,
-0.5270883440971375,
0.013823824003338814,
-0.30506250262260437,
-0.23022575676441193,
0.13142140209674835,
-0.5390276312828064,
0.06254022568464279,
0.14771057665348053,
0.5968950986862183,
-0.25237739086151123,
0.5213090181350708,
-0.10106617957353592,
-0.2786238193511963,
-0.22716115415096283,
0.03266207128763199,
0.743977427482605,
0.9824331998825073,
-0.3780096769332886,
-0.11772637069225311,
-0.29540860652923584,
-0.7745239734649658,
0.03283590078353882,
-0.02117319405078888,
0.0373956672847271,
0.08477845042943954,
0.42765066027641296,
0.6649582982063293,
0.45713913440704346,
-0.7221797108650208,
0.44208812713623047,
-0.092270627617836,
-0.2736876308917999,
-0.311566025018692,
0.45471063256263733,
0.0451836995780468,
0.11840595304965973,
0.12919342517852783,
0.15262791514396667,
-0.08997087180614471,
-0.6818275451660156,
0.37510085105895996,
0.20909416675567627,
-0.44279274344444275,
-0.2726491391658783,
1.141484260559082,
-0.06627623736858368,
-0.5631985664367676,
0.2315027117729187,
-0.3491956889629364,
-0.3510616421699524,
0.8109551668167114,
1.0107495784759521,
1.0319045782089233,
-0.10112841427326202,
0.3092891275882721,
0.29986611008644104,
0.25412073731422424,
-0.22713302075862885,
0.6810482144355774,
0.2524769604206085,
-0.6757380962371826,
-0.6555981040000916,
-0.6828822493553162,
-0.4225214123725891,
-0.06609474867582321,
-1.0119518041610718,
0.5509737133979797,
-0.5797358155250549,
-0.2015853375196457,
-0.43038296699523926,
0.0099988067522645,
-0.4465042054653168,
0.13953329622745514,
-0.22021886706352234,
1.5141361951828003,
-0.4019203782081604,
1.1054130792617798,
0.9078001379966736,
-0.48484811186790466,
-0.8772434592247009,
-0.08215518295764923,
-0.18596607446670532,
-1.034429669380188,
0.592993438243866,
0.23721002042293549,
-0.22715014219284058,
0.13923974335193634,
-0.4875175654888153,
-0.7925180792808533,
1.0233625173568726,
0.6010816693305969,
-0.23994851112365723,
-0.2880263328552246,
0.04353839159011841,
0.31206852197647095,
-0.7832088470458984,
0.2073671966791153,
0.37590083479881287,
0.05196300148963928,
0.08358525484800339,
-0.7961349487304688,
-0.2620004713535309,
-0.42140620946884155,
-0.0003629800339695066,
0.38696539402008057,
-0.6829677224159241,
1.0328232049942017,
-0.43030044436454773,
0.003385707503184676,
0.5218909382820129,
0.3668989837169647,
0.456695556640625,
0.09441681206226349,
-0.020832384005188942,
0.8077862858772278,
0.4892001748085022,
-0.1563335657119751,
0.8810684084892273,
-0.8511663675308228,
0.358652800321579,
1.340280532836914,
-0.35080140829086304,
0.5938590168952942,
-0.2723509967327118,
-0.06221223995089531,
0.5366583466529846,
0.7436751127243042,
0.14511515200138092,
0.5522767901420593,
0.20730164647102356,
-0.3861202597618103,
-0.20074237883090973,
0.19926857948303223,
-0.7081956267356873,
0.5509820580482483,
0.26390358805656433,
-0.1828174889087677,
-0.4028465747833252,
-0.2474009245634079,
0.20836040377616882,
0.19665010273456573,
-0.5898568630218506,
0.5613848567008972,
0.0712263286113739,
-0.8082282543182373,
0.6708807349205017,
0.2902522385120392,
0.33937039971351624,
-0.7367643117904663,
-0.28590306639671326,
-0.16221623122692108,
0.10821492969989777,
-0.19381417334079742,
-0.40538662672042847,
0.4460103213787079,
0.1918439269065857,
-0.18110303580760956,
0.06861447542905807,
1.0217701196670532,
-0.4079030454158783,
-0.5476561784744263,
0.43626105785369873,
0.39682716131210327,
0.07219049334526062,
0.08934556692838669,
-0.5348690748214722,
-0.10164748877286911,
-0.051748864352703094,
-0.11533893644809723,
0.214110866189003,
0.35113248229026794,
0.0780152752995491,
0.7319070100784302,
0.42598938941955566,
-0.056212954223155975,
0.6385977268218994,
0.0274512842297554,
0.8669236898422241,
-0.48758846521377563,
-0.6215065121650696,
-0.560319721698761,
0.33132579922676086,
0.28191831707954407,
-0.36201855540275574,
0.6724840402603149,
0.8018629550933838,
0.7223714590072632,
-0.31883352994918823,
0.6330112218856812,
0.01748025417327881,
0.4921641945838928,
-0.7969732880592346,
0.633690595626831,
-0.27675262093544006,
0.21831977367401123,
-0.27749940752983093,
-1.0582549571990967,
-0.3399655222892761,
0.40484288334846497,
-0.08605308085680008,
0.01847543567419052,
0.7280983924865723,
1.0632473230361938,
-0.2258661836385727,
0.26297727227211,
0.5818064212799072,
-0.17957128584384918,
0.14797358214855194,
0.7753764986991882,
0.6556094884872437,
-0.3087593615055084,
0.4306008815765381,
0.240116685628891,
-0.3953542411327362,
-0.32158493995666504,
-0.8171894550323486,
-1.3343181610107422,
-0.30604198575019836,
-0.2107614278793335,
-0.5081000328063965,
0.064101442694664,
0.8941032886505127,
0.7283434867858887,
-0.6859802603721619,
-0.08999549597501755,
-0.45730769634246826,
-0.15139201283454895,
0.23413223028182983,
-0.26951196789741516,
0.11544786393642426,
-0.7366228699684143,
-0.642697811126709,
0.4849383533000946,
0.43410179018974304,
0.12753859162330627,
-0.19247417151927948,
-0.3469576835632324,
-0.009185719303786755,
0.5467569828033447,
0.39421194791793823,
0.33313512802124023,
-0.3797919750213623,
-0.11768437922000885,
0.06401471793651581,
-0.2723967134952545,
0.1374865025281906,
1.0384366512298584,
-0.7497316598892212,
0.5380032658576965,
0.4148426651954651,
0.6762877702713013,
0.42169883847236633,
-0.11579930782318115,
0.7444037795066833,
-0.5462560653686523,
0.3947281539440155,
-0.059663835912942886,
0.6963127851486206,
0.05925285443663597,
-0.26028895378112793,
0.7565900683403015,
-0.04239390417933464,
-0.5031135082244873,
-0.6284555792808533,
0.6275417804718018,
-0.6462674736976624,
-0.4012235999107361,
0.9564105868339539,
-0.5354878902435303,
0.005590072833001614,
-0.11029204726219177,
-0.14044608175754547,
0.23656535148620605,
0.0048423949629068375,
0.6767897605895996,
0.5986170768737793,
0.2333093285560608,
0.02970719523727894,
-0.7005820274353027,
0.52935791015625,
0.3271526098251343,
-0.8558253049850464,
-0.3810889720916748,
0.5718461871147156,
0.10313303023576736,
0.044562846422195435,
0.8059766292572021,
-0.617102324962616,
0.5165764093399048,
0.22007595002651215,
0.3205317556858063,
-0.3475373387336731,
-0.5996735692024231,
-0.2388584017753601,
0.44037097692489624,
0.4113198220729828,
-0.3561210632324219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11403v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11403v1 | Multimodal Structured Generation: CVPR's 2nd MMFM Challenge Technical Report | 2024-06-17T10:45:47 | 2024-06-17T10:45:47 | Franz Louis Cesista | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Multimodal Foundation Models (MMFMs) have shown remarkable performance on
various computer vision and natural language processing tasks. However, their
performance on particular tasks such as document understanding is still
limited. They also require more compute, time, and engineering resources to
finetune and deploy compared to traditional, unimodal models. In this report,
we present Multimodal Structured Generation, a general framework which
constrains the output logits of frozen MMFMs to force them to reason before
responding with structured outputs that downstream APIs can parse and use. We
provide a detailed account of our approach, including the technical details,
theoretical discussions, and final evaluation results in the 2nd Multimodal
Foundation Models Challenge hosted by the Computer Vision and Pattern
Recognition (CVPR) conference. Our approach achieved the second highest score
in the hidden test set for Phase 2 and third highest overall. This shows the
method's ability to generalize to unseen tasks. And that simple engineering can
beat expensive & complicated modelling steps as we first discussed in our
paper, Retrieval Augmented Structured Generation: Business Document Information
Extraction as Tool Use. All of our scripts, deployment steps, and evaluation
results can be accessed in https://github.com/leloykun/MMFM-Challenge | [
-0.28756770491600037,
-0.6642868518829346,
0.5020689368247986,
0.5679711699485779,
-0.18781593441963196,
0.043934084475040436,
-0.10884875804185867,
-0.4452783167362213,
-0.335237979888916,
0.6187466382980347,
-0.8913854956626892,
-0.24407225847244263,
-0.5553576946258545,
0.19185112416744232,
-0.3480588495731354,
0.7483826875686646,
-0.21250484883785248,
-0.16054131090641022,
-0.5958523750305176,
-0.05459431931376457,
-0.5290948152542114,
-0.5984252691268921,
-0.29222822189331055,
-0.26831552386283875,
0.25785255432128906,
0.42703455686569214,
0.34898069500923157,
0.582606852054596,
0.7152486443519592,
0.3900906443595886,
0.19742777943611145,
0.43764999508857727,
-0.17464423179626465,
0.21175216138362885,
0.010961172170937061,
-0.1920069307088852,
-0.37763723731040955,
-0.006785073783248663,
0.4591681957244873,
0.573535144329071,
-0.18646353483200073,
0.22427572309970856,
0.10245103389024734,
0.7303106188774109,
-0.6428874731063843,
0.428438663482666,
-0.6560741066932678,
0.18744409084320068,
-0.14406293630599976,
-0.39155569672584534,
-0.7896900177001953,
0.3515431582927704,
-0.17029382288455963,
-0.5557957291603088,
0.48996689915657043,
-0.03367220610380173,
0.8794791102409363,
0.29899898171424866,
-0.6719261407852173,
-0.4659341871738434,
-0.8042224645614624,
0.6103338599205017,
-0.17080184817314148,
0.2827209532260895,
0.4003113806247711,
0.4126407504081726,
-0.15555962920188904,
-0.9756817817687988,
-0.5296519994735718,
-0.21595615148544312,
-0.027556002140045166,
0.21415919065475464,
-0.0404653325676918,
0.10711099952459335,
0.3085230886936188,
0.20267163217067719,
-0.6255298852920532,
-0.18166303634643555,
-0.4732193350791931,
-0.3257024586200714,
0.26929861307144165,
0.22354377806186676,
-0.18001927435398102,
-0.3397628366947174,
-0.47187191247940063,
-0.3565663993358612,
-0.2724042534828186,
0.16282854974269867,
0.33599162101745605,
0.2563437223434448,
-0.1881084442138672,
0.9254352450370789,
-0.30324241518974304,
0.6303617358207703,
-0.09362448006868362,
-0.32835713028907776,
0.3323242962360382,
-0.7438339591026306,
-0.3346495032310486,
-0.4377412796020508,
0.5246026515960693,
0.30928152799606323,
-0.0718151107430458,
0.22083984315395355,
-0.4430851340293884,
0.21400919556617737,
0.20783232152462006,
-0.8625215291976929,
-0.26255470514297485,
0.20127731561660767,
-0.5230125188827515,
-0.334418922662735,
-0.07707644253969193,
-0.6919771432876587,
-0.20992130041122437,
-0.23745429515838623,
0.18118754029273987,
-0.2394045889377594,
-0.3809221386909485,
-0.07151477783918381,
-0.4261346757411957,
0.14731667935848236,
0.3956856429576874,
-0.9787101149559021,
0.17815618216991425,
0.6701362729072571,
0.8358941674232483,
0.3616689443588257,
0.06190039590001106,
-0.6546910405158997,
0.14828363060951233,
-0.15719474852085114,
0.8428744077682495,
-0.5571582913398743,
-0.45823603868484497,
-0.031045949086546898,
-0.2817070186138153,
-0.03555769845843315,
-0.47328296303749084,
0.4931328296661377,
-0.2829224765300751,
0.24519121646881104,
-0.0012276803608983755,
0.00024241814389824867,
0.08964961767196655,
0.4936237633228302,
-0.6008886098861694,
0.9643039703369141,
0.3285566568374634,
-0.47858506441116333,
0.39480099081993103,
-0.5903139710426331,
-0.30129560828208923,
0.09670355170965195,
-0.3969990313053131,
-0.2953416109085083,
0.14876577258110046,
0.08637536317110062,
0.39503416419029236,
-0.3012135922908783,
0.3032347559928894,
-0.33070865273475647,
0.2942725121974945,
0.21296171844005585,
-0.5502648949623108,
0.24365073442459106,
0.35037821531295776,
-0.23362839221954346,
0.1830912083387375,
-1.3033478260040283,
0.04954550415277481,
0.23883745074272156,
-0.758078396320343,
0.07374652475118637,
0.20698460936546326,
0.3640470802783966,
0.6425204277038574,
0.05008631944656372,
-0.4646415710449219,
0.16126568615436554,
-0.22386302053928375,
0.5877354741096497,
0.7996929287910461,
-0.19930775463581085,
0.32539528608322144,
-0.22220849990844727,
0.33440205454826355,
0.1477527916431427,
0.31009578704833984,
-0.6275036931037903,
-0.4495295286178589,
-0.48730629682540894,
-0.37074053287506104,
0.12848736345767975,
0.42271339893341064,
-1.075158715248108,
-0.31239503622055054,
-0.02109362557530403,
-0.2279430776834488,
-0.20171773433685303,
0.36371949315071106,
0.6692225337028503,
0.71923828125,
0.2689686119556427,
-0.43736088275909424,
-0.5486258864402771,
-1.0408461093902588,
0.16282273828983307,
-0.1669752150774002,
-0.15118975937366486,
0.3542308509349823,
0.4225839376449585,
-0.23964335024356842,
0.869064450263977,
-0.476728618144989,
-0.2803647518157959,
-0.043507304042577744,
0.6127910614013672,
0.08503306657075882,
0.620707094669342,
0.5537588000297546,
-1.377916693687439,
-0.15748609602451324,
-0.19550611078739166,
-0.5807156562805176,
-0.13138730823993683,
-0.15508508682250977,
0.10234127938747406,
0.47793301939964294,
0.4361993968486786,
-0.7253478169441223,
0.15125475823879242,
0.6841382384300232,
-0.364417165517807,
0.6766473054885864,
-0.2564435303211212,
-0.17196829617023468,
-0.8710050582885742,
0.10551533848047256,
0.08403833955526352,
-0.3024534285068512,
-0.40060943365097046,
0.20019155740737915,
0.1362774670124054,
-0.4978092610836029,
-0.3496388792991638,
0.1537272185087204,
-0.6460557579994202,
-0.13885030150413513,
-0.20007263123989105,
0.019875699654221535,
0.251647412776947,
0.7469110488891602,
-0.08920738101005554,
0.3726406395435333,
0.043417613953351974,
-0.5509456396102905,
0.31564635038375854,
0.23106546700000763,
-0.2665495276451111,
0.5372160077095032,
-0.5286435484886169,
0.29009369015693665,
-0.20704859495162964,
0.22842949628829956,
-1.109686255455017,
-0.5844261050224304,
0.25504717230796814,
-0.4874611496925354,
0.519934892654419,
-0.12662900984287262,
-0.655074417591095,
-0.3453159034252167,
-0.19453391432762146,
0.26459750533103943,
0.1483871340751648,
-0.2889246940612793,
0.8294175267219543,
0.2135099321603775,
-0.21142397820949554,
-0.5292757749557495,
-0.6628065705299377,
0.06895926594734192,
0.16286756098270416,
-0.9380475282669067,
0.3759179413318634,
-0.4190278649330139,
-0.2878928780555725,
-0.09457144886255264,
-0.274743914604187,
-0.21160250902175903,
0.22989800572395325,
0.4382370710372925,
0.09228335320949554,
-0.3166974186897278,
0.018384110182523727,
0.027457095682621002,
-0.17712192237377167,
0.07576468586921692,
-0.10474859923124313,
0.47600704431533813,
-0.09743335098028183,
-0.337371826171875,
0.02353478968143463,
0.5871016383171082,
0.6954528093338013,
-0.4603767395019531,
0.5031880736351013,
0.7757288813591003,
-0.4632715582847595,
-0.17618440091609955,
-0.4998631179332733,
0.19115571677684784,
-0.5132383108139038,
0.3748321831226349,
-0.6894928216934204,
-0.8151624798774719,
0.12800416350364685,
-0.2756533920764923,
0.3377809226512909,
0.630527138710022,
0.7572618126869202,
-0.01901872642338276,
1.3317104578018188,
1.0549252033233643,
0.6073614954948425,
0.3279861509799957,
-0.17689695954322815,
-0.15833844244480133,
-0.45666611194610596,
-0.731273353099823,
-0.7127578258514404,
-0.12496227025985718,
-0.3892263174057007,
-0.44531986117362976,
0.3897194564342499,
0.1621037721633911,
0.3712140619754791,
0.04170255362987518,
-0.43691983819007874,
0.13259965181350708,
0.31489819288253784,
0.0016739100683480501,
0.1818525791168213,
-0.015258882194757462,
-0.49153512716293335,
0.09113936871290207,
-0.5864877700805664,
-0.44404900074005127,
0.8243188261985779,
0.303680419921875,
0.27337783575057983,
0.3277159333229065,
0.28754061460494995,
0.3177599310874939,
0.3980230689048767,
-0.6584128737449646,
0.5109379887580872,
-0.08732987195253372,
-0.5225833654403687,
-0.020733632147312164,
-0.40061065554618835,
-0.4963441491127014,
0.41383978724479675,
-0.42625483870506287,
-0.32663998007774353,
0.1273704469203949,
0.26941537857055664,
-0.20470398664474487,
-0.2205672413110733,
-0.8566762804985046,
0.7229807376861572,
-0.082436703145504,
-0.4036383032798767,
-0.09258540719747543,
-0.8182252049446106,
0.5680591464042664,
-0.2512487769126892,
0.48367270827293396,
-0.1969936192035675,
0.07609310001134872,
0.464792400598526,
-0.5664616227149963,
0.5927219986915588,
-0.3368428349494934,
0.09742279350757599,
0.28836897015571594,
-0.05401656776666641,
0.3179869055747986,
0.02620329149067402,
-0.04332123324275017,
-0.30479955673217773,
0.031237957999110222,
-0.3533940017223358,
-0.5819036960601807,
0.40962886810302734,
-0.4015515148639679,
-0.4261493682861328,
-0.2787743806838989,
-0.6638836860656738,
-0.111709825694561,
0.42983734607696533,
0.26829519867897034,
0.845485270023346,
-0.14015455543994904,
0.4356282949447632,
0.4786958694458008,
0.03893912956118584,
0.726399302482605,
0.484054833650589,
-0.07170040160417557,
-0.452288955450058,
0.7434708476066589,
0.10287453234195709,
0.14589542150497437,
0.5674188137054443,
0.05637660250067711,
-0.25665348768234253,
-0.6103301644325256,
-0.6208453178405762,
-0.17424316704273224,
-0.8503515124320984,
-0.22895684838294983,
-0.7916206121444702,
0.026781193912029266,
-0.5777687430381775,
0.007877451367676258,
-0.3525230586528778,
-0.6281711459159851,
-0.4098115861415863,
0.04194270819425583,
-0.1746263951063156,
0.7215155959129333,
-0.19293524324893951,
0.13385629653930664,
-0.7670086026191711,
0.5634669065475464,
0.2559933066368103,
0.20982199907302856,
-0.33693164587020874,
0.025336897000670433,
-0.19330699741840363,
-0.04594914987683296,
-0.6557089686393738,
-0.6099233627319336,
0.32528093457221985,
0.3264123797416687,
0.4064110815525055,
0.39498674869537354,
0.07048659771680832,
0.6334596276283264,
-0.46588388085365295,
0.6927863955497742,
0.24624750018119812,
-0.7523093223571777,
0.5822930335998535,
-0.2888410687446594,
0.2509765028953552,
0.46898767352104187,
0.10191437602043152,
0.002772248350083828,
-0.143652081489563,
-0.47165724635124207,
-1.0449904203414917,
0.46450695395469666,
0.2390844076871872,
0.1502356380224228,
0.018975574523210526,
0.316373735666275,
-0.00173794268630445,
0.3829166889190674,
-0.6830055117607117,
0.09879393875598907,
-0.4061737358570099,
-0.18337127566337585,
-0.13520273566246033,
-0.6933693885803223,
-0.15236108005046844,
0.12153329700231552,
0.39569297432899475,
-0.35388070344924927,
0.2739976942539215,
0.4373893439769745,
-0.38489559292793274,
-0.16147109866142273,
0.2704806923866272,
1.2103395462036133,
0.7991535663604736,
-0.29279327392578125,
0.24187104403972626,
-0.38948893547058105,
-0.4438328742980957,
0.02333286590874195,
0.23857976496219635,
0.09710479527711868,
0.14701086282730103,
0.4082280695438385,
0.5796909332275391,
0.28202810883522034,
-0.749445378780365,
0.43821391463279724,
-0.16581909358501434,
-0.6358402371406555,
-0.45823073387145996,
0.010007769800722599,
-0.253297358751297,
0.3653458058834076,
0.5772370100021362,
0.4221530556678772,
-0.0190963726490736,
-0.5329692959785461,
0.24882927536964417,
0.36926400661468506,
-0.27008020877838135,
-0.25288939476013184,
0.8131773471832275,
0.27263957262039185,
-0.3858591616153717,
0.7031657099723816,
-0.23006761074066162,
-0.36058536171913147,
0.6513303518295288,
0.6814481019973755,
0.6123782992362976,
0.06334741413593292,
0.1238744854927063,
0.11986657977104187,
0.5588408708572388,
-0.026927299797534943,
0.3071938455104828,
-0.39133933186531067,
-0.6316865086555481,
-0.3933289647102356,
-0.7826034426689148,
-0.44878044724464417,
0.1032281294465065,
-0.6065745949745178,
0.18021337687969208,
-0.7505837082862854,
-0.2945801317691803,
0.33365437388420105,
-0.09528107196092606,
-0.518052875995636,
0.16248483955860138,
0.15945200622081757,
1.1650669574737549,
-0.5674697756767273,
0.548822283744812,
0.5560802221298218,
-0.290918231010437,
-0.5403057336807251,
-0.4010103940963745,
0.29697197675704956,
-0.4640636742115021,
0.6194128394126892,
0.38450032472610474,
-0.23209010064601898,
-0.16164951026439667,
-0.6497509479522705,
-0.4956114888191223,
1.0848891735076904,
0.2638188600540161,
-0.33788713812828064,
-0.012862902134656906,
0.1226276159286499,
0.3916154205799103,
-0.45584189891815186,
0.0984826385974884,
0.2110467553138733,
0.5249624848365784,
0.35008108615875244,
-0.7664892077445984,
-0.1502959281206131,
-0.7927280068397522,
-0.005569889210164547,
0.0399014838039875,
-0.607974648475647,
0.943399965763092,
-0.22799132764339447,
-0.24309492111206055,
0.2730884850025177,
0.6776425838470459,
0.376708060503006,
0.7458339929580688,
0.4838466942310333,
0.4536866247653961,
0.4406588077545166,
-0.0939246192574501,
1.0419445037841797,
-0.03770861402153969,
0.23354604840278625,
1.0078234672546387,
-0.34422922134399414,
0.7806243300437927,
0.5387387275695801,
0.17620563507080078,
0.36484241485595703,
0.48523733019828796,
-0.2083154171705246,
0.714261531829834,
0.07511260360479355,
-0.055139411240816116,
-0.15233424305915833,
-0.30477315187454224,
-0.27187594771385193,
0.7875585556030273,
0.2932860851287842,
-0.25615471601486206,
-0.05952532961964607,
0.19986674189567566,
-0.11398940533399582,
0.15286120772361755,
-0.27551186084747314,
0.599361777305603,
0.0017291203839704394,
-0.6232786178588867,
0.3553999066352844,
0.6745808124542236,
0.406560480594635,
-0.6937819123268127,
-0.32415857911109924,
0.004654069431126118,
0.34353458881378174,
-0.14818429946899414,
-0.37303322553634644,
0.563586950302124,
0.10746149718761444,
-0.6679124236106873,
-0.7559401392936707,
0.8952863216400146,
-0.2506586015224457,
-0.5053436756134033,
0.06382166594266891,
0.23802615702152252,
-0.24317026138305664,
-0.1621527522802353,
-0.5428640842437744,
0.09028223156929016,
-0.19595444202423096,
-0.35186824202537537,
0.36294806003570557,
0.4906260669231415,
-0.10593638569116592,
0.5942426323890686,
0.9578356742858887,
-0.4548375904560089,
0.14406205713748932,
0.004668875131756067,
0.9452403783798218,
-0.3063126802444458,
-0.525592029094696,
-0.7580567598342896,
0.6977614164352417,
0.08571349084377289,
-0.28546756505966187,
0.49414002895355225,
0.7136661410331726,
0.8475158214569092,
-0.12007136642932892,
0.526949405670166,
-0.0666995719075203,
0.13163210451602936,
-0.785409152507782,
0.5242244005203247,
-0.6501491665840149,
-0.0269157774746418,
-0.4181564152240753,
-0.6055334210395813,
-0.230197474360466,
0.2535930573940277,
0.2848816514015198,
-0.08915051072835922,
0.6719434857368469,
0.656910240650177,
-0.014015669003129005,
-0.10556754469871521,
0.26005733013153076,
0.17987951636314392,
0.44842419028282166,
0.565005898475647,
0.7127106785774231,
-0.25689488649368286,
0.8488221168518066,
-0.42293649911880493,
-0.34586524963378906,
-0.1210285946726799,
-0.997024416923523,
-0.621886670589447,
-0.8597809076309204,
-0.13721822202205658,
-0.41542962193489075,
-0.3490746319293976,
0.6528360247612,
0.742890477180481,
-0.41614270210266113,
-0.03298266604542732,
-0.024090122431516647,
0.042491380125284195,
-0.14824610948562622,
-0.22266575694084167,
-0.11346621066331863,
-0.10164279490709305,
-0.45905494689941406,
0.6082935929298401,
0.5603978037834167,
0.07003559917211533,
-0.18119129538536072,
0.008228272199630737,
-0.2986798882484436,
-0.01100041251629591,
0.9955155849456787,
0.2207854837179184,
-0.46308284997940063,
-0.16091811656951904,
0.023639218881726265,
-0.1091926097869873,
0.023834509775042534,
1.0510865449905396,
-0.59062659740448,
0.5042837262153625,
0.46283361315727234,
0.38936758041381836,
0.6811098456382751,
-0.004218339920043945,
0.4520505368709564,
-1.1350640058517456,
0.3804106116294861,
0.042025305330753326,
0.375933438539505,
0.2851193845272064,
-0.3825155198574066,
0.5088313221931458,
0.6096707582473755,
-0.16973620653152466,
-0.9718000888824463,
0.41977253556251526,
-1.170616626739502,
-0.3025280833244324,
0.6973812580108643,
0.09848949313163757,
-0.11060335487127304,
-0.13347528874874115,
-0.08877436071634293,
0.27888602018356323,
-0.12791100144386292,
0.6005504727363586,
0.7361448407173157,
-0.10014168173074722,
-0.46019425988197327,
-0.6746364831924438,
0.17687612771987915,
0.20742526650428772,
-0.6495893597602844,
-0.15174846351146698,
0.7823225855827332,
0.10511915385723114,
0.47788679599761963,
0.9021559953689575,
-0.21638891100883484,
0.2593879997730255,
0.18717707693576813,
-0.11160607635974884,
-0.7486317157745361,
-0.739021360874176,
-0.30348601937294006,
0.8280668258666992,
-0.09393278509378433,
-0.10936763882637024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11402v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11402v1 | Evaluating Open Language Models Across Task Types, Application Domains, and Reasoning Types: An In-Depth Experimental Analysis | 2024-06-17T10:45:36 | 2024-06-17T10:45:36 | Neelabh Sinha, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The rapid rise of Language Models (LMs) has expanded their use in several
applications. Yet, due to constraints of model size, associated cost, or
proprietary restrictions, utilizing state-of-the-art (SOTA) LLMs is not always
feasible. With open, smaller LMs emerging, more applications can leverage their
capabilities, but selecting the right LM can be challenging. This work conducts
an in-depth experimental analysis of the semantic correctness of outputs of 10
smaller, open LMs across three aspects: task types, application domains and
reasoning types, using diverse prompt styles. We demonstrate that most
effective models and prompt styles vary depending on the specific requirements.
Our analysis provides a comparative assessment of LMs and prompt styles using a
proposed three-tier schema of aspects for their strategic selection based on
use-case and other constraints. We also show that if utilized appropriately,
these LMs can compete with, and sometimes outperform, SOTA LLMs like
DeepSeek-v2, GPT-3.5-Turbo, and GPT-4o. | [
-0.33599957823753357,
-0.929860532283783,
0.8371310830116272,
0.24467012286186218,
0.09005104005336761,
-0.12728546559810638,
-0.5508301258087158,
-0.4108675420284271,
-0.3024083971977234,
0.5286476016044617,
-0.5135080814361572,
-0.4267273247241974,
-0.4628141224384308,
0.3239445090293884,
-0.2808574140071869,
0.7424128651618958,
-0.3255317211151123,
0.09201668202877045,
-0.2973073124885559,
-0.2446356564760208,
-0.751177966594696,
-0.5013830661773682,
-0.5631103515625,
-0.21841949224472046,
0.3891766667366028,
0.6693865060806274,
0.883452296257019,
0.20621204376220703,
0.5793343186378479,
0.22558771073818207,
-0.08403246849775314,
0.02811550348997116,
-0.29709023237228394,
0.21934472024440765,
-0.26594528555870056,
-0.24365657567977905,
-0.49756985902786255,
0.0815693736076355,
0.4544737637042999,
0.7155975103378296,
0.0626436397433281,
0.14987105131149292,
-0.030798157677054405,
0.5012621283531189,
-0.6284399628639221,
0.19403181970119476,
-0.5482794642448425,
-0.12261524796485901,
-0.3497048616409302,
0.12681704759597778,
-0.49772128462791443,
-0.5180612802505493,
0.44727370142936707,
-0.49689051508903503,
-0.10409349203109741,
0.31935179233551025,
0.8785163760185242,
0.005585489794611931,
-0.2136690318584442,
-0.5020903944969177,
-0.8612471222877502,
0.722068190574646,
-1.070227026939392,
0.5108967423439026,
0.2330576479434967,
0.5955626368522644,
-0.2021065056324005,
-0.6319999098777771,
-0.5072813630104065,
-0.6320074200630188,
-0.12329896539449692,
-0.10181534290313721,
-0.2573736310005188,
0.049665357917547226,
0.27002647519111633,
0.43153277039527893,
-0.6766447424888611,
0.543709933757782,
-0.24532997608184814,
-0.15132954716682434,
0.1974090039730072,
0.28414687514305115,
0.47577670216560364,
-0.03773752227425575,
-0.24774250388145447,
0.12633022665977478,
-0.9021977782249451,
0.08856216073036194,
0.2857385575771332,
0.8147730827331543,
-0.03976130485534668,
0.8506263494491577,
-0.35096415877342224,
0.7773987054824829,
-0.208648219704628,
-0.10435298085212708,
-0.02407829649746418,
-0.6324853897094727,
-0.3695434629917145,
-0.2462921142578125,
0.7425176501274109,
0.28060677647590637,
0.2707403004169464,
-0.1543356478214264,
-0.3959590494632721,
-0.0018064683536067605,
0.08926349878311157,
-0.5453603267669678,
0.277575820684433,
0.3843272030353546,
-0.4454435110092163,
0.0842977985739708,
-0.35426846146583557,
-0.4466843605041504,
-0.3631165623664856,
-0.29347488284111023,
0.5633388161659241,
-0.5583127737045288,
-0.33399611711502075,
0.3120741546154022,
0.03756919875741005,
0.018505340442061424,
0.4346292018890381,
-0.6606559157371521,
0.43363144993782043,
0.5672686100006104,
0.781471848487854,
-0.41648069024086,
-0.15775302052497864,
-0.41202741861343384,
-0.2514585852622986,
-0.3756954073905945,
0.5779140591621399,
-0.5676570534706116,
-0.40978607535362244,
0.274319589138031,
-0.1632547825574875,
-0.07179475575685501,
-0.6163372993469238,
0.7947947382926941,
-0.6978226900100708,
0.385315865278244,
-0.37095561623573303,
-0.6720571517944336,
0.10829866677522659,
0.13741903007030487,
-0.7231708765029907,
1.1311808824539185,
0.276030957698822,
-0.6152522563934326,
0.5351998805999756,
-0.7113219499588013,
-0.19623088836669922,
0.1749323159456253,
-0.20792458951473236,
-0.03158242255449295,
0.12268578261137009,
-0.17185837030410767,
0.4553448259830475,
-0.4615750014781952,
0.22647444903850555,
-0.22448956966400146,
-0.25883084535598755,
0.3049270808696747,
0.07869924604892731,
0.6130332350730896,
0.49776607751846313,
-0.24914240837097168,
0.48751315474510193,
-0.8141536712646484,
-0.12411194294691086,
0.25415560603141785,
-0.24312615394592285,
-0.5711538195610046,
-0.11196258664131165,
-0.2884013056755066,
0.21869774162769318,
0.1251680701971054,
-0.6310601830482483,
0.14932456612586975,
-0.375484824180603,
0.5248644948005676,
0.48051124811172485,
-0.3133266866207123,
0.6126223206520081,
0.03367391228675842,
0.5608433485031128,
-0.07941897213459015,
0.16666331887245178,
0.02774975076317787,
-0.4316375255584717,
-0.8197202682495117,
-0.40803951025009155,
0.30289581418037415,
0.40416035056114197,
-0.7481763362884521,
0.10031205415725708,
-0.007785243913531303,
-0.5001476407051086,
-0.28283417224884033,
-0.21163107454776764,
0.3407015800476074,
0.4068185091018677,
0.13856962323188782,
-0.1403713822364807,
-0.3372403085231781,
-1.0052940845489502,
-0.48451703786849976,
-0.19963940978050232,
0.11542267352342606,
0.4469907283782959,
0.5591338276863098,
-0.07102792710065842,
1.1757855415344238,
-0.28370532393455505,
0.12114609777927399,
-0.47588059306144714,
-0.05044081062078476,
0.28571072220802307,
0.1882724016904831,
0.47321799397468567,
-0.3816831707954407,
-0.3059656023979187,
0.02727249078452587,
-0.4883163571357727,
-0.181252121925354,
0.16240540146827698,
-0.09322620928287506,
0.27170273661613464,
0.2911659777164459,
-0.8972236514091492,
0.336395263671875,
0.40733662247657776,
-0.419705867767334,
0.709391713142395,
-0.1156218945980072,
0.03541726619005203,
-0.5705671310424805,
0.02453465387225151,
0.04352287948131561,
-0.05129599943757057,
-0.8689430356025696,
0.2207707017660141,
0.30200740694999695,
-0.23986990749835968,
-0.4675504267215729,
0.8251803517341614,
-0.4045114517211914,
-0.20244675874710083,
-0.15465615689754486,
0.2854049801826477,
-0.009847297333180904,
0.2181217074394226,
0.17959773540496826,
0.8940167427062988,
0.5322059392929077,
-0.7409997582435608,
0.18971505761146545,
-0.028201036155223846,
-0.6569698452949524,
0.20410768687725067,
-0.7102680802345276,
0.04596737027168274,
-0.03952693194150925,
0.030637206509709358,
-0.8966816663742065,
-0.19610488414764404,
0.1490703523159027,
-0.15676122903823853,
0.08100701868534088,
0.23484887182712555,
-0.7036513090133667,
-0.2714761197566986,
-0.11563927680253983,
0.2561201751232147,
0.4218175709247589,
-0.28562501072883606,
0.48910146951675415,
0.006294002290815115,
-0.3624979853630066,
-0.2932983338832855,
-0.3257223963737488,
-0.050396472215652466,
-0.261820912361145,
-0.6247730851173401,
-0.005162613000720739,
0.036062292754650116,
-0.5695593357086182,
0.053503137081861496,
-0.2251158356666565,
0.11191776394844055,
0.26737308502197266,
0.011954814195632935,
0.3186054527759552,
-0.4902215003967285,
0.010811042971909046,
-0.09435687214136124,
0.05583065375685692,
-0.1892799288034439,
-0.19379401206970215,
0.462870717048645,
-0.4180644452571869,
-0.46538886427879333,
-0.07547981292009354,
0.3567035496234894,
0.4256714880466461,
-0.31241509318351746,
0.6711390614509583,
0.22734734416007996,
-0.4327124357223511,
-0.3571814000606537,
-0.4091765582561493,
-0.13050439953804016,
-0.4222155213356018,
0.20789091289043427,
-0.546109676361084,
-1.2063689231872559,
0.38867682218551636,
0.12658114731311798,
0.15659789741039276,
0.40300795435905457,
0.7509876489639282,
0.19634652137756348,
0.8352153301239014,
0.5123029947280884,
0.4482513666152954,
0.29746532440185547,
0.01918773539364338,
0.417723685503006,
-0.49679815769195557,
-0.3240271508693695,
-0.8508424758911133,
0.14219647645950317,
-0.389458030462265,
-0.306608110666275,
0.3042782247066498,
0.20434236526489258,
-0.27017396688461304,
0.5261580944061279,
-0.016250435262918472,
0.20646436512470245,
0.6806058287620544,
-0.23492133617401123,
0.3821989893913269,
-0.12539559602737427,
-0.29034140706062317,
0.01627042517066002,
-0.6764305233955383,
-0.9629442095756531,
0.7845292687416077,
0.628383219242096,
0.7742774486541748,
0.32241305708885193,
0.2675687074661255,
0.05250127986073494,
0.19820785522460938,
-0.8704022169113159,
0.681614875793457,
-0.1428140103816986,
-0.8096885085105896,
-0.5018629431724548,
-0.1608123630285263,
-0.7728432416915894,
0.28964683413505554,
-0.07180510461330414,
-0.871500551700592,
0.1246228739619255,
0.12558577954769135,
-0.5897465348243713,
0.10253922641277313,
-0.737284779548645,
1.053877830505371,
-0.09015925973653793,
-0.15714940428733826,
0.04067061096429825,
-0.6142973899841309,
0.36007431149482727,
-0.01915021985769272,
0.20008604228496552,
-0.3328793942928314,
-0.09806181490421295,
0.37777256965637207,
-0.4576038122177124,
0.7082550525665283,
0.020334850996732712,
-0.43947532773017883,
0.5185250639915466,
0.34731218218803406,
0.4267822504043579,
-0.31488117575645447,
-0.10674643516540527,
0.1580507457256317,
0.03715610131621361,
-0.18402287364006042,
-0.7372530102729797,
0.5541667342185974,
-0.6659641861915588,
-0.7815015316009521,
-0.29328593611717224,
-0.4606020748615265,
-0.7149677276611328,
0.3640676438808441,
0.19821378588676453,
0.6738454103469849,
-0.3325466215610504,
0.1197507381439209,
0.5693402290344238,
-0.2769898772239685,
0.39136502146720886,
0.8066607117652893,
-0.31592658162117004,
0.06279229372739792,
0.8017265200614929,
0.14938534796237946,
0.6268139481544495,
0.25548359751701355,
0.3906630575656891,
-0.2850760519504547,
-0.8143565058708191,
-0.6662904620170593,
0.04611236974596977,
-0.7723091244697571,
0.09264259040355682,
-0.6546722650527954,
0.011121341958642006,
-0.5675150752067566,
0.1539064198732376,
-0.3405575156211853,
-0.5220031142234802,
-0.23656491935253143,
-0.040871765464544296,
0.21528519690036774,
0.7339280843734741,
0.2795886993408203,
0.27585598826408386,
-0.7326769232749939,
0.008655712939798832,
0.14458705484867096,
0.42754989862442017,
-0.04983513429760933,
-0.40101245045661926,
-0.10827702283859253,
-0.18132804334163666,
-0.027065489441156387,
-0.8775925636291504,
0.0626559853553772,
-0.006541181355714798,
0.7192797660827637,
0.1272834837436676,
-0.09813610464334488,
0.2164161205291748,
-0.6597806215286255,
1.1394189596176147,
0.011557212099432945,
-0.7887823581695557,
0.523448646068573,
-0.4611263871192932,
0.12741439044475555,
0.44258877635002136,
0.4695015549659729,
-0.41592130064964294,
-0.40107500553131104,
-0.4539836049079895,
-0.6552110910415649,
0.7816036939620972,
0.40076473355293274,
-0.09639474749565125,
-0.0985579788684845,
0.23799008131027222,
0.5899634957313538,
0.24071571230888367,
-0.45370468497276306,
-0.20317652821540833,
-0.13954783976078033,
-0.21954990923404694,
-0.023997701704502106,
-0.18952694535255432,
0.0009854987729340792,
0.23076429963111877,
0.6747311353683472,
-0.05038469284772873,
-0.019814683124423027,
0.000531644735019654,
-0.08286932855844498,
0.19124238193035126,
0.7224347591400146,
0.6457533240318298,
0.7056649923324585,
-0.25882989168167114,
0.13492265343666077,
0.054671335965394974,
-0.184600368142128,
0.02395244501531124,
-0.19705301523208618,
-0.3450736701488495,
0.04921161010861397,
0.30412235856056213,
1.1360194683074951,
0.09249749779701233,
-0.846474826335907,
0.4692504107952118,
-0.13682575523853302,
0.1665276288986206,
0.17798152565956116,
0.12377586960792542,
-0.0220140740275383,
0.2333180010318756,
-0.125450000166893,
-0.07139094173908234,
0.27720898389816284,
-0.7319937348365784,
-0.3563292622566223,
0.519365131855011,
-0.21657370030879974,
-0.30697017908096313,
0.33646148443222046,
0.37094953656196594,
-0.3555627167224884,
0.20168203115463257,
-0.1522698998451233,
-0.060401223599910736,
0.3909742534160614,
0.6448460221290588,
0.858123779296875,
0.0574340857565403,
0.12471291422843933,
0.12588682770729065,
0.40534868836402893,
-0.217621847987175,
0.5002588629722595,
0.19632330536842346,
-0.8057499527931213,
-0.45161664485931396,
-0.45927494764328003,
-0.7297342419624329,
0.33681124448776245,
-0.558917760848999,
0.26704567670822144,
-0.2682203948497772,
-0.3590545356273651,
-0.1696915179491043,
-0.15726101398468018,
-0.8338857889175415,
0.23822225630283356,
0.0722496286034584,
1.2710710763931274,
-0.7466330528259277,
0.6751707196235657,
0.9388682246208191,
-0.4106648564338684,
-0.9832251071929932,
-0.2270168513059616,
0.03304995223879814,
-0.8195976614952087,
0.8235453367233276,
-0.14812646806240082,
-0.16567648947238922,
-0.29987281560897827,
-0.40029823780059814,
-0.9782296419143677,
0.7769107222557068,
0.29692116379737854,
-0.48631811141967773,
-0.08521538227796555,
0.10939283668994904,
0.5070394277572632,
-0.5235365033149719,
0.40423890948295593,
0.8540393710136414,
0.3444836139678955,
-0.006124388426542282,
-1.2825063467025757,
0.10693269968032837,
0.06434699147939682,
0.33890119194984436,
0.08090565353631973,
-0.5167642831802368,
0.974918007850647,
-0.17509214580059052,
-0.40412774682044983,
0.3722156882286072,
0.7532752156257629,
0.5261164903640747,
0.2381785809993744,
0.4750089943408966,
0.24330027401447296,
0.5394260287284851,
-0.15242889523506165,
1.10043203830719,
-0.08808370679616928,
0.1710532158613205,
1.1546895503997803,
-0.66584712266922,
0.8087819814682007,
0.39331504702568054,
-0.187277153134346,
0.41101688146591187,
0.7715507745742798,
0.5080119371414185,
0.4440554976463318,
0.248027503490448,
0.056330494582653046,
-0.06553886085748672,
-0.28843095898628235,
-0.3632020354270935,
0.2840375006198883,
0.3479146957397461,
-0.030112748965620995,
-0.2883758842945099,
0.007723627611994743,
0.15064021944999695,
0.07320726662874222,
-0.28414127230644226,
0.5596290230751038,
0.06362786144018173,
-0.7931245565414429,
0.27947238087654114,
0.17748495936393738,
0.5142202973365784,
-0.5752955079078674,
0.17461898922920227,
-0.29343992471694946,
0.00003437446503085084,
-0.06495555490255356,
-0.8648279309272766,
-0.011422557756304741,
0.25283515453338623,
0.05741037428379059,
-0.24303916096687317,
1.0850602388381958,
-0.31755855679512024,
-0.1484505832195282,
0.12195765227079391,
0.8235145807266235,
0.14352203905582428,
0.09666424244642258,
-0.34297123551368713,
0.43961095809936523,
-0.45460331439971924,
-0.3210288882255554,
0.2504015862941742,
0.5661599636077881,
-0.35552334785461426,
0.5941310524940491,
0.2826586365699768,
0.2400355339050293,
0.1508208066225052,
0.3635217845439911,
0.7499750852584839,
-0.5465108156204224,
-0.3634791970252991,
-0.7888577580451965,
0.4463161528110504,
0.017940999940037727,
-0.517916738986969,
1.1390516757965088,
0.3566884696483612,
0.905600905418396,
-0.13326597213745117,
0.7778341174125671,
-0.013255189172923565,
0.6793233156204224,
-0.7366131544113159,
0.13968393206596375,
-0.4460935890674591,
0.2078152745962143,
-0.34532198309898376,
-0.9244915843009949,
-0.0570855513215065,
0.29533851146698,
-0.47830888628959656,
0.10005795210599899,
0.7821854948997498,
0.6259549260139465,
0.09477853775024414,
0.49041351675987244,
0.296001136302948,
0.21790197491645813,
0.1979016661643982,
0.2589937746524811,
1.3152118921279907,
0.006534353829920292,
0.1374460756778717,
-0.0975339338183403,
-0.48615309596061707,
-0.311466783285141,
-1.0677448511123657,
-0.8871083855628967,
-0.41851097345352173,
-0.3075433075428009,
-0.37478259205818176,
-0.046413078904151917,
0.9256458878517151,
0.557008683681488,
-0.9039308428764343,
-0.3885975778102875,
0.24254298210144043,
-0.015198531560599804,
-0.04675827547907829,
-0.1863013356924057,
0.10924248397350311,
-0.45657339692115784,
-0.5605819225311279,
0.5640097260475159,
0.3512656092643738,
-0.017472676932811737,
-0.4327414333820343,
-0.14532248675823212,
0.01113609503954649,
0.35845497250556946,
0.8922456502914429,
0.27506113052368164,
-1.0590369701385498,
-0.5125542283058167,
0.33236879110336304,
-0.38225194811820984,
-0.28341737389564514,
1.1373845338821411,
-0.519748330116272,
0.25119414925575256,
0.6830177903175354,
0.5328267216682434,
-0.002861583139747381,
-0.2854565680027008,
0.5925285220146179,
-0.4956147372722626,
-0.1413479894399643,
0.301447331905365,
0.5549777746200562,
0.25072193145751953,
-0.0069708931259810925,
0.5092370510101318,
-0.04032061621546745,
-0.4849565625190735,
-0.9790363907814026,
0.3668406307697296,
-0.7958228588104248,
-0.544857382774353,
1.5239297151565552,
-0.08129750937223434,
-0.02010514959692955,
-0.08266215026378632,
-0.4148891866207123,
-0.03635117784142494,
-0.3568861186504364,
0.13139568269252777,
0.9747040867805481,
-0.38352522253990173,
0.16828352212905884,
-0.7591462731361389,
0.6594334244728088,
0.4125562012195587,
-0.6592192053794861,
0.0676097646355629,
0.4992237091064453,
0.23706966638565063,
0.158648282289505,
0.8030614256858826,
-0.14546822011470795,
0.02560446411371231,
-0.21747726202011108,
-0.004868841730058193,
-0.021586526185274124,
-0.4681815207004547,
-0.3920932710170746,
0.17779244482517242,
0.5019394755363464,
-0.04715479910373688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11400v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11400v1 | Large Language Models and Knowledge Graphs for Astronomical Entity Disambiguation | 2024-06-17T10:38:03 | 2024-06-17T10:38:03 | Golnaz Shapurian | cs.CL | cs.CL, astro-ph.IM | This paper presents an experiment conducted during a hackathon, focusing on
using large language models (LLMs) and knowledge graph clustering to extract
entities and relationships from astronomical text. The study demonstrates an
approach to disambiguate entities that can appear in various contexts within
the astronomical domain. By collecting excerpts around specific entities and
leveraging the GPT-4 language model, relevant entities and relationships are
extracted. The extracted information is then used to construct a knowledge
graph, which is clustered using the Leiden algorithm. The resulting Leiden
communities are utilized to identify the percentage of association of unknown
excerpts to each community, thereby enabling disambiguation. The experiment
showcases the potential of combining LLMs and knowledge graph clustering
techniques for information extraction in astronomical research. The results
highlight the effectiveness of the approach in identifying and disambiguating
entities, as well as grouping them into meaningful clusters based on their
relationships. | [
-0.494167685508728,
-0.9939717650413513,
0.9747508764266968,
-0.03855821490287781,
-0.1034260019659996,
0.2909645438194275,
-0.373215913772583,
-0.8507663607597351,
0.5850887894630432,
0.5449875593185425,
-0.40649428963661194,
-0.5293230414390564,
-0.6632633209228516,
0.24351251125335693,
-0.7049205899238586,
0.7288597226142883,
0.06737417727708817,
0.05188147723674774,
-0.302863210439682,
0.18835318088531494,
-0.14704151451587677,
-0.25868692994117737,
-0.5313897132873535,
-0.037601567804813385,
0.7531593441963196,
0.17799495160579681,
0.5471073985099792,
0.7333436608314514,
0.9965074062347412,
0.3779831826686859,
-0.3692416846752167,
0.12550894916057587,
-0.30059486627578735,
-0.05264313146471977,
-0.3494616448879242,
-0.385034441947937,
-0.27720406651496887,
-0.07498053461313248,
0.6366003155708313,
1.0712224245071411,
-0.03367860987782478,
0.20522357523441315,
-0.2368311882019043,
0.3963516652584076,
-0.21629971265792847,
0.48030757904052734,
-0.7997188568115234,
-0.19567005336284637,
-0.6532183289527893,
0.011243153363466263,
-0.14586715400218964,
-0.33374232053756714,
0.1179477870464325,
-0.9513235688209534,
0.246796116232872,
0.5151652097702026,
0.8001747131347656,
0.2893259525299072,
-0.23188899457454681,
-0.5572079420089722,
-0.7866047024726868,
0.9011526703834534,
-0.510816752910614,
0.39968955516815186,
0.3113887310028076,
0.267123818397522,
-0.15221799910068512,
-0.7979438304901123,
-0.8270134925842285,
-0.21512290835380554,
-0.1174851804971695,
-0.0028081799391657114,
-0.07925768196582794,
-0.13918833434581757,
0.18607692420482635,
0.239874005317688,
-0.5156983733177185,
0.4081953763961792,
-0.6142491698265076,
-0.15452107787132263,
0.36613309383392334,
-0.015160095877945423,
0.29212313890457153,
-0.5183418989181519,
-0.18606872856616974,
0.08281774818897247,
-0.8210163712501526,
-0.6075556874275208,
0.4167335033416748,
0.1692909598350525,
0.41937774419784546,
0.9262889623641968,
0.06628946959972382,
0.5896962285041809,
-0.13436347246170044,
-0.3836292028427124,
0.1942325085401535,
-0.4564628601074219,
-0.010081207379698753,
-0.10674572736024857,
0.6410517692565918,
0.09759920090436935,
0.12947526574134827,
-0.4800465703010559,
-0.0015873234951868653,
0.1774742156267166,
-0.004943214822560549,
-0.5365423560142517,
-0.30836331844329834,
0.04702538624405861,
-0.4567486047744751,
-0.29288190603256226,
0.07085657864809036,
-1.1544772386550903,
-0.44908180832862854,
-0.30955150723457336,
0.19197620451450348,
-0.314251571893692,
-0.5027545690536499,
-0.21519048511981964,
-0.2721102833747864,
-0.17776980996131897,
0.38349559903144836,
-0.840959906578064,
0.32955023646354675,
0.8256698846817017,
0.6524996757507324,
-0.39293983578681946,
-0.36795467138290405,
0.21761101484298706,
0.5140659809112549,
0.0034361190628260374,
0.5927638411521912,
-0.7821937799453735,
-0.538101315498352,
-0.3277680277824402,
-0.153993159532547,
0.13292287290096283,
-0.512554407119751,
0.2539932131767273,
-0.9396325945854187,
0.12865635752677917,
-0.16458961367607117,
-1.12260103225708,
-0.33871614933013916,
-0.03871045634150505,
-0.9609631896018982,
0.9686093330383301,
0.1527138203382492,
-0.7303569316864014,
0.5309045910835266,
-0.854137122631073,
-0.02188710868358612,
0.30061179399490356,
-0.5316964983940125,
-0.13886719942092896,
-0.21368637681007385,
0.2942194938659668,
0.3398522138595581,
-0.280077189207077,
0.2645169198513031,
-0.46094605326652527,
-0.030318424105644226,
0.10144811868667603,
0.10070130228996277,
0.6160053610801697,
0.38030654191970825,
-0.21045589447021484,
-0.2513278126716614,
-0.6559311747550964,
-0.46609175205230713,
0.24028286337852478,
-0.24859535694122314,
-0.782960832118988,
0.17693841457366943,
-0.046215277165174484,
-0.1965445727109909,
0.4924970269203186,
-0.780018150806427,
0.5707496404647827,
-0.3292739987373352,
0.2501024007797241,
0.4858555495738983,
0.2830078601837158,
0.6759385466575623,
0.2805347740650177,
0.28082361817359924,
0.1762734353542328,
-0.033356305211782455,
0.06309172511100769,
-0.6284246444702148,
-0.5693547129631042,
-0.14663967490196228,
0.1513489931821823,
0.21125556528568268,
-0.9625397324562073,
0.5073894262313843,
-0.30839142203330994,
-0.7999175190925598,
-0.30703964829444885,
0.13004501163959503,
0.1876949667930603,
0.8604746460914612,
0.3796499967575073,
-0.0006328326417133212,
-0.5606623888015747,
-0.7063533663749695,
-0.10125485062599182,
-0.3395112156867981,
-0.040589042007923126,
0.3357435464859009,
0.7322935461997986,
-0.41552188992500305,
1.0841633081436157,
-0.8352890014648438,
-0.023252366110682487,
0.039239510893821716,
-0.061362579464912415,
0.27153393626213074,
0.20574557781219482,
0.7238715291023254,
-0.9646095037460327,
-0.18327297270298004,
0.24844804406166077,
-0.7534843683242798,
0.03974445164203644,
0.3171390891075134,
-0.09901551902294159,
-0.013175912201404572,
0.6055064797401428,
-0.5839452147483826,
0.3714173436164856,
0.36257556080818176,
-0.3757370114326477,
0.5330745577812195,
0.08309319615364075,
0.28674423694610596,
-1.2425203323364258,
0.16261404752731323,
0.1215050220489502,
-0.3111782670021057,
-0.3540011942386627,
-0.024884086102247238,
0.006600878667086363,
0.17841531336307526,
-0.27819186449050903,
0.5351073741912842,
-0.623272716999054,
-0.4779224693775177,
-0.33751723170280457,
0.5425893664360046,
-0.08453737944364548,
0.09566539525985718,
0.37602558732032776,
0.5640576481819153,
0.6647025346755981,
-0.5414015054702759,
0.5234357714653015,
0.44826740026474,
-0.657116711139679,
0.15284445881843567,
-0.32799017429351807,
-0.0597965233027935,
-0.10023525357246399,
0.24235832691192627,
-0.796874463558197,
-0.2843305468559265,
-0.019315848127007484,
-0.21489006280899048,
0.06903303414583206,
-0.20268535614013672,
-0.5968985557556152,
-0.613670289516449,
0.31499239802360535,
0.41725456714630127,
0.4682813286781311,
-0.5073159337043762,
0.2641947269439697,
0.8256101012229919,
-0.5189269185066223,
-0.427937775850296,
-0.390572190284729,
0.02991820126771927,
-0.6366029381752014,
-0.5539397597312927,
0.2612576186656952,
0.13770431280136108,
-0.5663760900497437,
0.20197777450084686,
0.1419667750597,
-0.20177052915096283,
0.1836460828781128,
0.27202755212783813,
0.5925044417381287,
-0.14408189058303833,
0.3666401207447052,
-0.15531468391418457,
0.04126017540693283,
0.04677993804216385,
-0.5547009110450745,
0.43356117606163025,
-0.013559959828853607,
-0.3825022578239441,
-0.021334530785679817,
0.14545385539531708,
0.3016144931316376,
-0.039027728140354156,
0.917670726776123,
0.5582897663116455,
-0.5847538113594055,
0.10020262748003006,
-0.6376501321792603,
-0.42332154512405396,
-0.4325128495693207,
0.6403445601463318,
-0.12998613715171814,
-1.1847609281539917,
0.6999936699867249,
-0.5136620998382568,
0.06269808113574982,
0.6254211664199829,
0.603948712348938,
-0.15729306638240814,
0.42416638135910034,
0.6281865835189819,
-0.38031649589538574,
0.383759468793869,
-0.15145006775856018,
0.17813906073570251,
-0.8558061718940735,
-0.11040783673524857,
-0.8113059997558594,
-0.17974907159805298,
-0.3702777028083801,
-0.6465995907783508,
0.502869188785553,
0.29651808738708496,
-0.08234275132417679,
0.4571121633052826,
-0.40940722823143005,
0.7615086436271667,
0.26897624135017395,
-0.23016385734081268,
0.5889506936073303,
0.015059221535921097,
0.1390826255083084,
-0.042979706078767776,
-0.3423023521900177,
-0.7156215906143188,
1.196338415145874,
0.1680251955986023,
0.7078811526298523,
0.37377703189849854,
0.7969367504119873,
-0.014434797689318657,
0.5578329563140869,
-0.4492153525352478,
0.4025844633579254,
0.06375829875469208,
-0.774197518825531,
-0.560034990310669,
-0.8357272148132324,
-1.1314891576766968,
0.12517568469047546,
-0.08480706810951233,
-1.1706551313400269,
0.04545379802584648,
-0.11270397156476974,
-0.026905808597803116,
0.32264435291290283,
-0.6496890783309937,
0.5867282748222351,
-0.011974688619375229,
0.17127248644828796,
-0.16947078704833984,
-0.5686355233192444,
0.4764438569545746,
-0.5634452104568481,
0.6091275215148926,
-0.04650605097413063,
0.020588688552379608,
0.936572790145874,
-0.06223239749670029,
0.6930181980133057,
-0.23450690507888794,
-0.09112478047609329,
0.38290777802467346,
0.18887047469615936,
0.4959776997566223,
0.18782071769237518,
-0.25688445568084717,
0.37777087092399597,
-0.018088309094309807,
-0.2570059299468994,
-0.328059583902359,
0.9665775299072266,
-1.0306264162063599,
-0.5090624690055847,
-0.05348952114582062,
-0.47339701652526855,
-0.10545799881219864,
0.452961802482605,
-0.07290925085544586,
0.12291360646486282,
-0.22399207949638367,
0.0339246541261673,
0.3610139489173889,
-0.1707964837551117,
0.44338348507881165,
0.6170300841331482,
-0.8376545906066895,
-0.057306986302137375,
0.8095496296882629,
0.044622793793678284,
0.17025965452194214,
0.3302002251148224,
0.02579968050122261,
-0.4712443947792053,
-0.7314279675483704,
-0.19904233515262604,
0.493256151676178,
-0.6787176728248596,
-0.17777781188488007,
-0.5690211057662964,
0.01586809568107128,
-0.5271260738372803,
-0.02123279497027397,
-0.24939191341400146,
-0.6561148166656494,
-0.3249383866786957,
-0.2923191487789154,
0.45645472407341003,
1.1785082817077637,
0.26160451769828796,
0.34182244539260864,
-0.7796513438224792,
0.018858755007386208,
-0.21094383299350739,
-0.12658503651618958,
-0.08527524769306183,
-0.05436187610030174,
-0.3986840844154358,
-0.20036712288856506,
-0.18800215423107147,
-1.069832682609558,
0.3581019341945648,
0.07356435805559158,
0.5772908926010132,
0.2775840163230896,
-0.35343778133392334,
0.7199957370758057,
-0.5294696092605591,
0.9109809398651123,
0.3605858087539673,
-0.712207019329071,
0.4876739978790283,
-0.5855629444122314,
-0.1910398304462433,
0.36155280470848083,
0.37611380219459534,
-0.4972151517868042,
-0.618441104888916,
-0.6230518221855164,
-0.9299395084381104,
0.37716126441955566,
0.286452054977417,
-0.3955455422401428,
-0.09432272613048553,
0.8276214599609375,
0.26902562379837036,
0.3803803324699402,
-0.7475838661193848,
-0.28896084427833557,
0.2615315914154053,
-0.175500750541687,
-0.20783431828022003,
0.21294309198856354,
-0.23778800666332245,
-0.0007017510943114758,
0.4939747750759125,
0.02180665172636509,
0.06685760617256165,
0.12668092548847198,
-0.30587396025657654,
-0.17609696090221405,
-0.15609796345233917,
0.1606709361076355,
1.1025912761688232,
0.072856605052948,
0.1337745636701584,
0.06051399186253548,
-0.642611026763916,
-0.3420810401439667,
0.17483997344970703,
-0.0950603261590004,
-0.06830254197120667,
0.4360505938529968,
0.4784184992313385,
0.06651200354099274,
-0.4174235463142395,
0.28408801555633545,
0.05613818019628525,
0.0407227948307991,
-0.43877366185188293,
0.026955388486385345,
0.585308313369751,
0.35174331068992615,
0.4725450277328491,
-0.044611867517232895,
0.25068190693855286,
-0.23882520198822021,
0.18692192435264587,
0.21471281349658966,
0.08410957455635071,
-0.2629103660583496,
0.6549584865570068,
0.2176433950662613,
0.08993253111839294,
0.5040470361709595,
-0.16942454874515533,
-0.2827182710170746,
0.8356678485870361,
0.31835606694221497,
0.3099304139614105,
-0.0015183096984401345,
0.18484185636043549,
0.2972780466079712,
0.2748892307281494,
0.1350972205400467,
-0.08774620294570923,
0.17415852844715118,
-0.7492642998695374,
-0.704558789730072,
-1.0273921489715576,
-0.48384007811546326,
-0.1259826272726059,
-0.39623531699180603,
0.17085708677768707,
0.05048437416553497,
-0.013895237818360329,
0.5134624242782593,
0.117863729596138,
-0.7894431948661804,
-0.0723491758108139,
0.2538551092147827,
0.8807119727134705,
-0.6933928728103638,
0.9704748392105103,
0.7568139433860779,
-0.5029897093772888,
-1.0925389528274536,
-0.3392229974269867,
0.17112743854522705,
-0.823849081993103,
0.8438076972961426,
-0.23813273012638092,
0.19813017547130585,
0.19992029666900635,
-0.47766685485839844,
-1.1870156526565552,
1.3523755073547363,
0.12623398005962372,
-0.975735068321228,
0.017602110281586647,
0.17357784509658813,
0.5596088171005249,
-0.29960453510284424,
0.28692400455474854,
0.6267384886741638,
0.865338146686554,
0.15144209563732147,
-1.0143498182296753,
-0.19259534776210785,
0.03161255270242691,
-0.17307372391223907,
0.5738083124160767,
-0.5668020844459534,
0.8489711880683899,
0.11740309000015259,
-0.11357712745666504,
0.22328239679336548,
0.9257667660713196,
0.23550482094287872,
0.30641210079193115,
0.43660467863082886,
0.5115025043487549,
1.121337890625,
-0.21324196457862854,
0.8958494067192078,
-0.33715933561325073,
0.8840451240539551,
0.7169197201728821,
-0.5673792362213135,
0.5208543539047241,
0.9550386071205139,
-0.46390223503112793,
0.4429084360599518,
0.7315676212310791,
0.0161118283867836,
0.282992959022522,
0.19732455909252167,
-0.22599191963672638,
0.19622237980365753,
0.11112714558839798,
-0.28290116786956787,
0.3673384487628937,
0.6634533405303955,
-0.2812535762786865,
-0.3572891652584076,
-0.027698826044797897,
0.2882612943649292,
-0.169036865234375,
-0.3252142369747162,
0.834279477596283,
0.13081620633602142,
-0.732211172580719,
-0.14662685990333557,
-0.0167244765907526,
0.40511006116867065,
-0.5899325013160706,
-0.03970232605934143,
0.01936214230954647,
0.08364132046699524,
-0.2978147566318512,
-0.7874353528022766,
0.3246491253376007,
0.19114840030670166,
-0.1712026596069336,
0.09874872863292694,
0.7614536881446838,
-0.5222879648208618,
-0.6883050799369812,
0.25487691164016724,
0.732338547706604,
0.5537645816802979,
0.12265518307685852,
-0.37168675661087036,
-0.1575225293636322,
0.09295061230659485,
-0.5063821077346802,
0.2589448094367981,
0.5109612941741943,
-0.044706858694553375,
0.39923596382141113,
0.7571022510528564,
0.3910076916217804,
0.24167531728744507,
0.006783266551792622,
1.0706924200057983,
-0.733241856098175,
-0.35826289653778076,
-0.8325054049491882,
0.19075018167495728,
-0.2965172827243805,
-0.23547571897506714,
1.0811331272125244,
0.5976604223251343,
0.5900131464004517,
-0.10612178593873978,
0.821587085723877,
-0.37827038764953613,
0.7059373259544373,
-0.4075523614883423,
0.6599168181419373,
-0.4127606451511383,
0.44112882018089294,
-0.5311710834503174,
-1.376449465751648,
-0.2541511654853821,
0.44007954001426697,
-0.3846060037612915,
0.007389329839497805,
0.7490869164466858,
0.7639951109886169,
-0.08999218046665192,
0.1481349617242813,
0.14148949086666107,
0.44010376930236816,
0.6854956746101379,
0.3615589141845703,
0.8824474811553955,
0.08035243302583694,
0.3871730864048004,
-0.08404853194952011,
-0.42100903391838074,
-0.09784847497940063,
-0.8559755086898804,
-0.6352919340133667,
-0.6787364482879639,
-0.18437911570072174,
-0.1320062130689621,
-0.2752035856246948,
0.5094838738441467,
0.4734291732311249,
-0.5095834136009216,
0.017272787168622017,
-0.09128683805465698,
0.09703796356916428,
0.16768987476825714,
-0.2781626880168915,
0.5835174322128296,
-0.06806208938360214,
-0.9441800117492676,
0.6557809710502625,
0.3327873647212982,
-0.07247244566679001,
-0.5705880522727966,
0.02695864625275135,
-0.021741695702075958,
-0.14383964240550995,
0.19269944727420807,
0.06250189244747162,
-0.5344539880752563,
-0.5226555466651917,
-0.02595713920891285,
0.004878088366240263,
-0.3350301682949066,
0.5588579773902893,
-0.5746539831161499,
0.22864797711372375,
0.14622531831264496,
0.5495854020118713,
0.689353346824646,
-0.00029191255453042686,
0.13686048984527588,
-0.7929975986480713,
0.3046477138996124,
0.20553389191627502,
0.6254070997238159,
0.13016556203365326,
-0.43515709042549133,
0.6470879912376404,
0.4460679888725281,
-1.015389323234558,
-0.6627063155174255,
0.30636343359947205,
-1.1423572301864624,
-0.38303738832473755,
1.3894691467285156,
-0.13180051743984222,
-0.41074615716934204,
-0.11345577239990234,
-0.21261730790138245,
0.134029358625412,
-0.2745375335216522,
1.047400951385498,
0.9885210990905762,
-0.31806695461273193,
0.18465866148471832,
-0.4204449951648712,
0.30492356419563293,
0.10230033099651337,
-1.0593962669372559,
-0.2210833728313446,
0.677244246006012,
0.2900346517562866,
0.7102558612823486,
0.3668595552444458,
-0.27712249755859375,
-0.13630513846874237,
-0.05110963433980942,
0.29499635100364685,
0.01652541570365429,
-0.24426846206188202,
0.30008313059806824,
0.11285046488046646,
0.017622945830225945,
0.19305801391601562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11385v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11385v2 | MetaGPT: Merging Large Language Models Using Model Exclusive Task Arithmetic | 2024-06-17T10:12:45 | 2024-06-27T16:01:28 | Yuyan Zhou, Liang Song, Bingning Wang, Weipeng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advent of large language models (LLMs) like GPT-4 has catalyzed the
exploration of multi-task learning (MTL), in which a single model demonstrates
proficiency across diverse tasks. Task arithmetic has emerged as a
cost-effective approach for MTL. It enables performance enhancement across
multiple tasks by adding their corresponding task vectors to a pre-trained
model. However, the current lack of a method that can simultaneously achieve
optimal performance, computational efficiency, and data privacy limits their
application to LLMs. In this paper, we propose \textbf{M}odel
\textbf{E}xclusive \textbf{T}ask \textbf{A}rithmetic for merging
\textbf{GPT}-scale models, which formalizes the objective of model merging into
a multi-task learning framework, aiming to minimize the average loss difference
between the merged model and each individual task model. Since data privacy
limits the use of multi-task training data, we leverage LLMs' local linearity
and task vectors' orthogonality to separate the data term and scaling
coefficients term and derive a model-exclusive task arithmetic method. Our
proposed MetaGPT is data-agnostic and bypasses the heavy search process, making
it cost-effective and easy to implement for LLMs.Extensive experiments
demonstrate that MetaGPT leads to improvements in task arithmetic and achieves
state-of-the-art performance on multiple tasks. | [
-0.4233604073524475,
-0.7466590404510498,
0.5198652744293213,
0.12105567753314972,
-0.23366157710552216,
-0.04073432460427284,
-0.20307432115077972,
-0.2350788712501526,
0.12355279922485352,
0.5189219117164612,
-0.5715072154998779,
-0.42860788106918335,
-0.7998579740524292,
-0.15476013720035553,
-0.2943927049636841,
1.077914834022522,
-0.26416587829589844,
0.024337217211723328,
-0.1851501166820526,
-0.33196312189102173,
-0.10300058126449585,
-0.8491935729980469,
-0.5604060292243958,
-0.07961885631084442,
0.34405967593193054,
0.21203731000423431,
0.49122384190559387,
0.9126102328300476,
0.5486188530921936,
0.359135240316391,
0.4222414195537567,
0.4377540946006775,
-0.24016989767551422,
0.12144263833761215,
-0.04907405748963356,
-0.22697670757770538,
-1.1090714931488037,
0.1919732689857483,
0.758266270160675,
0.5589087009429932,
-0.2624446153640747,
0.5146163702011108,
0.22415149211883545,
0.4880731403827667,
-0.731694757938385,
0.5338910818099976,
-0.39369067549705505,
0.09324263036251068,
-0.325226753950119,
-0.14748026430606842,
-0.25577864050865173,
-0.3258303701877594,
-0.22600488364696503,
-0.4367050230503082,
0.05151129886507988,
-0.10433480143547058,
0.2945660650730133,
0.3978080153465271,
-0.6023510694503784,
-0.0016260469565168023,
-0.5627655982971191,
0.8236851096153259,
-0.7577576041221619,
0.6012813448905945,
0.2007286101579666,
0.13229167461395264,
0.2433309704065323,
-0.5610284209251404,
-0.46304675936698914,
-0.07953751087188721,
0.06513265520334244,
-0.07573390752077103,
-0.38302332162857056,
0.1814642697572708,
0.31264451146125793,
0.3142193555831909,
-0.877387285232544,
-0.2382539063692093,
-0.28906458616256714,
0.005808387417346239,
0.31165266036987305,
0.2830880284309387,
0.27455413341522217,
0.16506098210811615,
-0.36309245228767395,
0.16684900224208832,
-0.7666248679161072,
-0.12443183362483978,
0.40057048201560974,
0.2175646871328354,
-0.04345791041851044,
0.750639021396637,
-0.17267000675201416,
0.6152231693267822,
0.008486916311085224,
-0.13826952874660492,
0.4359451234340668,
-0.3027529716491699,
-0.26920297741889954,
-0.2997555136680603,
1.0077617168426514,
0.16130220890045166,
0.1286391317844391,
-0.2538710832595825,
-0.24321267008781433,
0.09931056201457977,
0.0817556157708168,
-0.919414222240448,
-0.023301031440496445,
0.020724670961499214,
-0.22245237231254578,
-0.26187291741371155,
-0.22899186611175537,
-0.6193661689758301,
-0.002167758531868458,
-0.5591580867767334,
0.6618270874023438,
-0.17206357419490814,
-0.470441073179245,
0.14440664649009705,
0.44395047426223755,
-0.1445714831352234,
0.08972588926553726,
-0.9284332394599915,
0.3877844512462616,
0.943520724773407,
0.7025229930877686,
-0.12721821665763855,
-0.48194411396980286,
-0.8386916518211365,
0.1831342875957489,
-0.10333291441202164,
0.2610071897506714,
-0.5266948342323303,
-0.25325533747673035,
-0.14987048506736755,
-0.17101594805717468,
-0.41489720344543457,
-0.23166143894195557,
0.5987306833267212,
-0.5405331254005432,
0.21487003564834595,
-0.17978210747241974,
-0.5056232810020447,
-0.33283311128616333,
0.38765984773635864,
-0.5878674983978271,
0.9996674656867981,
0.02192086912691593,
-0.7727252244949341,
0.08533135056495667,
-0.9692195057868958,
-0.36759933829307556,
-0.005383466836065054,
-0.27648624777793884,
-0.4337523877620697,
0.08026134222745895,
0.35323622822761536,
0.568299412727356,
-0.3750653564929962,
0.36834439635276794,
-0.44485610723495483,
-0.13467225432395935,
-0.038568343967199326,
-0.5966525077819824,
0.7033026218414307,
0.14870724081993103,
-0.5009439587593079,
0.11649435758590698,
-0.3925565779209137,
0.2778891324996948,
-0.056642401963472366,
-0.30930066108703613,
-0.26558151841163635,
-0.1479514241218567,
-0.13862895965576172,
0.2873339354991913,
0.621867299079895,
-0.44301852583885193,
0.3713681399822235,
-0.12560774385929108,
0.4562494158744812,
0.6900025010108948,
-0.43123528361320496,
0.4959869384765625,
-0.3109894394874573,
0.60113525390625,
-0.2764754593372345,
0.19109278917312622,
-0.08837516605854034,
-0.4958491623401642,
-0.5453047752380371,
-0.4550401270389557,
0.2437412589788437,
0.781906008720398,
-0.6286826729774475,
0.35076332092285156,
-0.665202260017395,
-0.4284696578979492,
-0.43698564171791077,
0.21002192795276642,
0.5140026807785034,
0.32895562052726746,
0.3619003891944885,
-0.09995896369218826,
-0.2968170642852783,
-0.7318664789199829,
-0.4534192383289337,
0.09353233128786087,
-0.10896165668964386,
0.44924232363700867,
0.23594994843006134,
-0.10093234479427338,
0.8284961581230164,
-0.6000733971595764,
-0.3177245557308197,
-0.16787557303905487,
0.3803251087665558,
0.2810843884944916,
0.6539767384529114,
0.38525283336639404,
-0.7752568125724792,
-0.6427872180938721,
-0.006076343357563019,
-0.8137351274490356,
-0.1437031775712967,
0.3456025719642639,
0.01982632279396057,
-0.0066029285080730915,
0.30358824133872986,
-0.9460688233375549,
0.2808716893196106,
0.8167312145233154,
-0.15523645281791687,
0.32175812125205994,
-0.4945990741252899,
0.47730526328086853,
-1.1520326137542725,
-0.005363255273550749,
-0.14678406715393066,
-0.4169458746910095,
-0.7514553666114807,
0.3291395306587219,
0.35031235218048096,
-0.42148712277412415,
-0.33969295024871826,
0.32957878708839417,
-0.5229374170303345,
-0.10781575739383698,
-0.40108123421669006,
-0.16548749804496765,
-0.3253812789916992,
0.7360190153121948,
-0.16417448222637177,
0.8427647948265076,
0.7632952332496643,
-0.3951616883277893,
0.21184076368808746,
-0.08368624001741409,
0.29888126254081726,
0.5586364269256592,
-0.44374939799308777,
0.40154093503952026,
-0.02526990883052349,
0.15192873775959015,
-0.8458930253982544,
0.05850596725940704,
0.27419301867485046,
-0.47510838508605957,
0.32190942764282227,
-0.36432382464408875,
-0.5195412039756775,
-0.031313780695199966,
-0.2552734315395355,
0.9710166454315186,
0.3843121826648712,
-0.46625223755836487,
1.1527296304702759,
0.41463521122932434,
-0.3912883698940277,
-0.7697898149490356,
-0.5023869872093201,
0.08703144639730453,
-0.24227294325828552,
-0.7464148998260498,
0.2203662246465683,
-0.1861274540424347,
0.140208438038826,
0.1874171644449234,
-0.2695562541484833,
-0.28434130549430847,
-0.3492349088191986,
0.14099512994289398,
0.3569221794605255,
-0.26840001344680786,
-0.17967049777507782,
0.015203716233372688,
-0.3388875126838684,
0.07718434929847717,
-0.6307072043418884,
0.4770747423171997,
-0.10392473638057709,
-0.6115323305130005,
-0.07977332919836044,
0.43525341153144836,
0.8882914185523987,
-0.6609780788421631,
0.6047900319099426,
0.7503499388694763,
-0.4271988272666931,
0.00581165449693799,
-0.7281524538993835,
0.0706615298986435,
-0.4779863953590393,
0.3496023714542389,
-0.491847962141037,
-1.0965152978897095,
0.40236303210258484,
-0.0019258683314546943,
0.4063867926597595,
0.3155311346054077,
0.531481921672821,
0.36332443356513977,
1.0274337530136108,
0.5768261551856995,
-0.18916985392570496,
0.3561842739582062,
-0.15604417026042938,
0.3395289480686188,
-0.8560308814048767,
0.10311073064804077,
-0.33911406993865967,
-0.15631182491779327,
-0.6479952335357666,
-0.7669528126716614,
0.6293111443519592,
-0.41057533025741577,
-0.3891478180885315,
0.37256836891174316,
-0.3381161689758301,
0.5996575355529785,
0.5302755236625671,
0.3304333984851837,
0.3718518316745758,
-0.08897311985492706,
0.08816202729940414,
-0.11987126618623734,
-0.4530777335166931,
-0.09368603676557541,
1.4976520538330078,
0.08313504606485367,
0.6159689426422119,
0.2480962872505188,
0.8419665694236755,
0.19652369618415833,
0.30244162678718567,
-0.514934241771698,
0.703760027885437,
-0.5189147591590881,
-0.5877655744552612,
-0.3886052668094635,
-0.906032919883728,
-0.6607758402824402,
0.7123603224754333,
-0.08731311559677124,
-0.5751590132713318,
-0.10468537360429764,
0.17743799090385437,
-0.06752420216798782,
0.5014170408248901,
-0.45161572098731995,
0.9765717387199402,
-0.15889602899551392,
-0.44972917437553406,
-0.33202362060546875,
-0.41486620903015137,
0.6752234101295471,
-0.40370309352874756,
0.5015425682067871,
-0.10324154794216156,
-0.24502329528331757,
0.7293293476104736,
-0.3663397431373596,
0.7015566229820251,
-0.2026042491197586,
-0.009687232784926891,
-0.09838134050369263,
0.3018791377544403,
0.9383537769317627,
-0.1964285671710968,
0.33677592873573303,
0.3094019889831543,
-0.3071950078010559,
-0.34612274169921875,
-0.5177949666976929,
0.7668203115463257,
-0.43395110964775085,
-0.5864912271499634,
-0.3049471974372864,
-0.9266377091407776,
-0.38450172543525696,
0.410577654838562,
0.003030789317563176,
0.7385783791542053,
0.1960056871175766,
0.15328563749790192,
0.6221798658370972,
0.13983017206192017,
0.30854013562202454,
0.7002497315406799,
-0.11872278153896332,
-0.6207417845726013,
1.029978632926941,
0.1732846200466156,
0.2303004115819931,
0.5537406206130981,
0.21074171364307404,
-0.4038527309894562,
-0.39549827575683594,
-0.42193838953971863,
0.11722817271947861,
-0.5846432447433472,
-0.1648321896791458,
-0.808937668800354,
-0.04599229246377945,
-0.3510220944881439,
0.06653998792171478,
-0.473978191614151,
-0.5176005959510803,
0.16817130148410797,
-0.04445440322160721,
0.04091658815741539,
0.5924853086471558,
-0.34308740496635437,
0.2617306411266327,
-0.9804392457008362,
0.5140959620475769,
0.48071160912513733,
0.29204633831977844,
0.005997991189360619,
-0.365903377532959,
-0.14184531569480896,
0.06679710000753403,
-0.31067419052124023,
-0.7727596163749695,
0.4009423851966858,
0.13790388405323029,
0.5801998376846313,
0.31091880798339844,
-0.03809353709220886,
0.5442217588424683,
-0.8411922454833984,
0.4398716986179352,
0.3027106523513794,
-1.1910457611083984,
-0.09289485216140747,
-0.5664594173431396,
0.06972314417362213,
0.26538676023483276,
0.2771347761154175,
-0.3209172189235687,
-0.4469028115272522,
-0.5835383534431458,
-0.9098865389823914,
0.6379314064979553,
0.28447362780570984,
0.03119359165430069,
0.32972049713134766,
0.12368962913751602,
-0.1563955545425415,
0.44997313618659973,
-0.8798643946647644,
-0.5219824910163879,
0.00656105624511838,
-0.48314401507377625,
-0.10677779465913773,
-0.08690936863422394,
-0.2156735509634018,
-0.27527371048927307,
0.41330093145370483,
-0.0036886429879814386,
0.2407006323337555,
-0.39877957105636597,
-0.12124737352132797,
0.011488317511975765,
0.30064451694488525,
0.5281306505203247,
0.6689748764038086,
-0.08290181308984756,
0.35506024956703186,
0.34948205947875977,
-0.622067391872406,
0.31466159224510193,
0.38707202672958374,
0.02020752802491188,
-0.11783671379089355,
0.21385276317596436,
0.4995218515396118,
0.43994542956352234,
-0.262969970703125,
0.7106013894081116,
0.08936586230993271,
-0.47172099351882935,
0.016505949199199677,
-0.05747668445110321,
0.13821864128112793,
0.37671342492103577,
0.2801517844200134,
0.1197260320186615,
0.26309874653816223,
-0.17051398754119873,
0.42665037512779236,
0.5839319825172424,
0.014150985516607761,
-0.27394187450408936,
0.9180300831794739,
0.1326039433479309,
-0.06610990315675735,
0.30636802315711975,
-0.2248053252696991,
-0.7208210229873657,
0.3277307450771332,
0.38242191076278687,
1.1052403450012207,
-0.5943197011947632,
-0.08234655112028122,
0.22246144711971283,
0.5397988557815552,
-0.10743959248065948,
0.26884883642196655,
-0.22516107559204102,
-0.41598063707351685,
-0.833617091178894,
-0.36568760871887207,
-0.41007161140441895,
0.0021785360295325518,
-0.5167340636253357,
0.028607921674847603,
-0.14128489792346954,
-0.07389925420284271,
-0.21664054691791534,
-0.1694251000881195,
-0.6725392937660217,
0.09245441108942032,
-0.060736410319805145,
0.42424696683883667,
-0.8340899348258972,
0.8764472007751465,
0.5955725312232971,
-0.16093751788139343,
-0.8809285759925842,
-0.11039067059755325,
0.05899621173739433,
-0.9498515725135803,
0.6172477006912231,
0.12649019062519073,
-0.19095362722873688,
0.07788386195898056,
-0.08798228949308395,
-0.8988057971000671,
0.9330554604530334,
0.7181263566017151,
-0.47434574365615845,
-0.12035058438777924,
0.49969714879989624,
-0.04145905748009682,
-0.30936676263809204,
0.2102217674255371,
0.31499993801116943,
0.5425783395767212,
0.11301427334547043,
-1.1419010162353516,
0.30798912048339844,
-0.07511600106954575,
-0.48786070942878723,
0.6667909026145935,
-0.4155382812023163,
1.3147491216659546,
-0.10506744682788849,
-0.04831802099943161,
-0.29794105887413025,
0.4297650158405304,
0.13792528212070465,
0.24663524329662323,
0.6508708596229553,
0.816831111907959,
0.668286919593811,
-0.0504978783428669,
0.5520846247673035,
-0.5582068562507629,
0.8264279365539551,
0.9335066080093384,
-0.08031779527664185,
0.626127302646637,
0.11743336170911789,
-0.2716597616672516,
-0.17677275836467743,
0.21988999843597412,
0.23528900742530823,
0.4068652093410492,
-0.0012200155761092901,
-0.5960375070571899,
-0.39496976137161255,
0.3240145444869995,
-0.48105841875076294,
0.1838287115097046,
0.045888420194387436,
-0.1920720338821411,
-0.5201733708381653,
-0.08761133253574371,
0.24469400942325592,
-0.3916185200214386,
-0.2800327241420746,
0.6936438679695129,
0.00500400410965085,
-0.38421720266342163,
0.4028797447681427,
0.10492461174726486,
0.7056642174720764,
-0.7449517250061035,
0.04439174383878708,
-0.09080271422863007,
0.25946927070617676,
-0.20547212660312653,
-0.5052075386047363,
0.26350095868110657,
0.015488534234464169,
-0.17670607566833496,
-0.24320469796657562,
0.3948548436164856,
-0.8271850347518921,
-0.5552055239677429,
0.06992640346288681,
0.723815381526947,
0.140069842338562,
-0.45799964666366577,
-0.7545982599258423,
-0.05108209326863289,
-0.03327059745788574,
-0.20773085951805115,
0.48607689142227173,
0.5556148290634155,
0.21336327493190765,
0.596450686454773,
0.7760265469551086,
0.07210104912519455,
0.19212281703948975,
-0.31630951166152954,
0.8268657922744751,
-0.4405677020549774,
-0.6624598503112793,
-1.1532957553863525,
0.3862753212451935,
0.24637889862060547,
0.02867988497018814,
0.7025499939918518,
0.7731819152832031,
0.5255781412124634,
-0.04770955815911293,
0.9010779857635498,
-0.0355224572122097,
0.41667720675468445,
-0.49489933252334595,
0.5681997537612915,
-0.675372838973999,
0.07484814524650574,
-0.2014686018228531,
-1.070477843284607,
-0.09301796555519104,
0.4039236307144165,
-0.2380123734474182,
0.2315385341644287,
0.7992885708808899,
0.6639866232872009,
-0.5264151692390442,
-0.11243857443332672,
0.4252476394176483,
-0.11044302582740784,
0.42522066831588745,
0.9317159056663513,
0.3454000651836395,
-0.3136337399482727,
0.6541422605514526,
-0.09491763263940811,
-0.5398102402687073,
-0.0056729745119810104,
-0.9403141140937805,
-0.7671682834625244,
-0.4777231514453888,
-0.1883285790681839,
-0.04511062800884247,
-0.08032242208719254,
0.9571616649627686,
0.7678035497665405,
-0.4381914734840393,
-0.312435507774353,
-0.06524114310741425,
-0.09807430952787399,
-0.2258719652891159,
-0.1398128867149353,
0.6485880017280579,
-0.3404490351676941,
-0.9621971845626831,
0.33463409543037415,
0.2596457898616791,
-0.12161996960639954,
-0.24044866859912872,
-0.060105614364147186,
0.2560742497444153,
0.08362425863742828,
0.47691404819488525,
0.1550890952348709,
-0.4442422688007355,
0.1779111623764038,
-0.025354433804750443,
-0.020604323595762253,
-0.05237468704581261,
1.0698587894439697,
-0.2552972137928009,
0.32176220417022705,
0.40181732177734375,
0.8354898691177368,
0.6384793519973755,
0.03622295334935188,
0.650070309638977,
-0.7026782035827637,
0.007513232529163361,
0.010633313097059727,
0.47734779119491577,
0.12294290959835052,
-0.36062219738960266,
0.5792379975318909,
0.25555291771888733,
-0.6671642661094666,
-0.767559289932251,
0.1803247481584549,
-0.9078720808029175,
0.10494553297758102,
1.0199992656707764,
-0.2937777638435364,
0.09423497319221497,
0.08917664736509323,
-0.014696083031594753,
0.17707830667495728,
-0.3132946193218231,
0.36167168617248535,
0.5899249315261841,
-0.23111222684383392,
-0.17075040936470032,
-0.8759806752204895,
0.3291477560997009,
0.30257460474967957,
-0.8387506008148193,
0.44534286856651306,
0.3308938443660736,
0.36531558632850647,
0.0020491292234510183,
0.6361517310142517,
-0.09489630907773972,
0.17280934751033783,
-0.21100635826587677,
0.087313711643219,
-0.6296261548995972,
-0.24270498752593994,
-0.1641303449869156,
0.41057872772216797,
-0.1629534661769867,
-0.5563321709632874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11380v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11380v1 | A Realistic Evaluation of LLMs for Quotation Attribution in Literary Texts: A Case Study of LLaMa3 | 2024-06-17T09:56:46 | 2024-06-17T09:56:46 | Gaspard Michel, Elena V. Epure, Romain Hennequin, Christophe Cerisara | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) zero-shot and few-shot performance are subject
to memorization and data contamination, complicating the assessment of their
validity. In literary tasks, the performance of LLMs is often correlated to the
degree of book memorization. In this work, we carry out a realistic evaluation
of LLMs for quotation attribution in novels, taking the instruction fined-tuned
version of Llama3 as an example. We design a task-specific memorization measure
and use it to show that Llama3's ability to perform quotation attribution is
positively correlated to the novel degree of memorization. However, Llama3
still performs impressively well on books it has not memorized nor seen. Data
and code will be made publicly available. | [
0.31611114740371704,
-0.6065599322319031,
0.7357572913169861,
0.19565145671367645,
-0.43571901321411133,
-0.037256281822919846,
-0.08263693004846573,
-0.4251646399497986,
0.0773991122841835,
0.7265500426292419,
-0.31803882122039795,
-0.45342913269996643,
-0.34986522793769836,
0.2280377298593521,
-0.5147622227668762,
0.9863773584365845,
-0.3402823507785797,
-0.2860897481441498,
-0.5623338222503662,
0.01725667156279087,
-0.3028809726238251,
-0.6539350152015686,
-0.45848554372787476,
-0.5336312651634216,
0.9201856255531311,
0.4457380175590515,
0.3763713836669922,
0.7656466364860535,
0.7734166383743286,
0.2679787576198578,
0.02465119957923889,
-0.1320664882659912,
-0.5408511161804199,
0.27318355441093445,
-0.080551877617836,
-1.0536943674087524,
-0.19396162033081055,
0.18968583643436432,
0.9517478346824646,
0.03390941023826599,
-0.039373185485601425,
0.16261565685272217,
0.044855885207653046,
0.4834382236003876,
-0.7419604063034058,
0.1258893460035324,
-0.7452037930488586,
0.004693110939115286,
-0.40385136008262634,
-0.42854398488998413,
-0.341814249753952,
-0.8241248726844788,
-0.15850943326950073,
-0.5945870280265808,
0.10666200518608093,
0.16953837871551514,
0.827728271484375,
0.32103604078292847,
-0.33862125873565674,
-0.444003164768219,
-0.6727764010429382,
1.2564575672149658,
-0.7337541580200195,
-0.42302513122558594,
0.7023194432258606,
0.17165333032608032,
0.06601964682340622,
-0.4155564606189728,
-0.6030975580215454,
-0.5562629103660583,
0.03539162874221802,
0.1541813760995865,
0.05514337867498398,
-0.16162264347076416,
0.11402622610330582,
0.4181809723377228,
-0.19905932247638702,
0.0615796260535717,
-0.18007825314998627,
-0.049640953540802,
0.6588861346244812,
0.3054616153240204,
-0.06966516375541687,
-0.3509385287761688,
-0.6185380816459656,
-0.015544552356004715,
-0.9069226384162903,
-0.1905955821275711,
0.5916646718978882,
0.1789754033088684,
0.12653830647468567,
0.6285287141799927,
0.24329343438148499,
0.43922221660614014,
-0.4449612498283386,
-0.44331228733062744,
0.16780075430870056,
-0.24711433053016663,
-0.11131858080625534,
0.15008650720119476,
0.7066022753715515,
0.5405025482177734,
0.7844177484512329,
-0.15752321481704712,
-0.2909351587295532,
0.008282585069537163,
0.42175066471099854,
-0.7571015954017639,
0.03956976160407066,
-0.057027075439691544,
-0.174974262714386,
-0.4577026665210724,
-0.39639949798583984,
-0.2916925251483917,
-0.6834527254104614,
-0.061246536672115326,
0.6253087520599365,
-0.40776699781417847,
0.20111125707626343,
0.044806476682424545,
-0.3112969696521759,
0.22414322197437286,
0.3598848879337311,
-0.6253278255462646,
0.2651468515396118,
0.44650721549987793,
1.015861988067627,
-0.33725422620773315,
-0.3788313865661621,
-0.15402258932590485,
0.6612532734870911,
-0.45830535888671875,
0.9724937081336975,
-0.4571237862110138,
-0.1910506784915924,
0.1553780883550644,
-0.21342118084430695,
-0.3597771227359772,
-0.60516756772995,
0.8223609924316406,
-0.3296336531639099,
-0.22212669253349304,
-0.2619691491127014,
-0.9271761775016785,
-0.2861693203449249,
0.46295371651649475,
-0.8322880268096924,
0.6699029207229614,
-0.07280689477920532,
-0.4763187766075134,
0.16424889862537384,
-0.2753373086452484,
-0.5015131235122681,
0.022971762344241142,
-0.2580225467681885,
-0.4086282253265381,
-0.07107850909233093,
-0.26954180002212524,
0.6612234711647034,
-0.47985905408859253,
-0.09229818731546402,
-0.2897547483444214,
-0.9809263348579407,
0.7155870795249939,
-0.573954164981842,
0.5018935799598694,
0.0981842577457428,
-0.011038325726985931,
-0.2659528851509094,
-0.6768448948860168,
-0.06654609739780426,
0.17008677124977112,
-0.43268588185310364,
-0.3824736177921295,
0.10760287940502167,
0.1191876158118248,
-0.39877015352249146,
0.3330409526824951,
-0.5869891047477722,
0.21580302715301514,
-0.20965266227722168,
0.21493305265903473,
0.5412274599075317,
0.3173239529132843,
0.06541230529546738,
-0.8901221752166748,
0.5978235006332397,
-0.23495253920555115,
-0.16454531252384186,
-0.08258233219385147,
-0.18351244926452637,
-0.6100659370422363,
-0.6391947269439697,
0.281615287065506,
0.8043593168258667,
-0.6003463864326477,
0.16503341495990753,
-0.12315347790718079,
-0.5782917737960815,
-0.14597101509571075,
0.2371412068605423,
0.702474057674408,
0.19610650837421417,
0.050722163170576096,
-0.01212882436811924,
-0.14957007765769958,
-0.8190895915031433,
-0.7293530702590942,
-0.35426437854766846,
-0.09517400711774826,
0.2945133149623871,
0.5899415016174316,
0.2614535391330719,
0.6617339849472046,
-0.5874455571174622,
-0.7286252379417419,
-0.26194408535957336,
0.16401410102844238,
0.1452692449092865,
0.3733021020889282,
0.6474009156227112,
-0.15161415934562683,
-0.3762674629688263,
-0.1603984385728836,
-0.8688908219337463,
-0.08038654178380966,
-0.18869264423847198,
-0.038600414991378784,
-0.07590261101722717,
0.7060675621032715,
-0.39123672246932983,
0.18470343947410583,
0.09989529103040695,
-0.1187976822257042,
0.6510494351387024,
-0.04306900501251221,
0.3759676516056061,
-0.9163009524345398,
0.06708957999944687,
0.02099805511534214,
-0.1930101066827774,
-0.38117650151252747,
-0.04458519071340561,
0.06651269644498825,
0.3709796369075775,
-0.6299332976341248,
0.49637022614479065,
-0.3222620487213135,
0.19074973464012146,
-0.05842316150665283,
0.2890249192714691,
0.10265006870031357,
0.42622870206832886,
-0.06796845048666,
0.7071853280067444,
0.025833168998360634,
-0.4410325884819031,
0.5502877831459045,
0.13463884592056274,
-0.9713301658630371,
0.5074682831764221,
-0.5266245007514954,
0.03840548172593117,
0.11647766828536987,
0.07961747795343399,
-0.9744230508804321,
-0.2712158262729645,
-0.007800137158483267,
-0.02606738545000553,
0.07333087921142578,
-0.08359146118164062,
-0.6932148933410645,
0.039619237184524536,
-0.6154065728187561,
0.5687132477760315,
0.21059338748455048,
-0.24833965301513672,
0.22741365432739258,
-0.031405866146087646,
-0.23304897546768188,
-0.5722845792770386,
-0.8645907044410706,
0.12340128421783447,
-0.7521471381187439,
-0.0045521012507379055,
0.3593432307243347,
-0.07433092594146729,
-0.4052777588367462,
-0.2832321226596832,
0.09072520583868027,
-0.22632341086864471,
0.13271407783031464,
0.18212267756462097,
0.2952955365180969,
-0.05322383716702461,
0.23715832829475403,
-0.053899120539426804,
0.2633601725101471,
0.022638460621237755,
0.46092289686203003,
0.10961071401834488,
-0.08367079496383667,
-0.4684792459011078,
-0.4498295187950134,
0.12589246034622192,
0.33435142040252686,
0.30462929606437683,
0.6714780926704407,
0.25151461362838745,
-0.42588967084884644,
-0.15994428098201752,
-0.6393144130706787,
0.17686833441257477,
-0.45878496766090393,
0.3163517117500305,
-0.38702401518821716,
-0.5194857120513916,
0.5742456316947937,
0.16050845384597778,
-0.06499522179365158,
0.38228800892829895,
0.5376380085945129,
-0.27896010875701904,
0.24346639215946198,
0.4134051203727722,
-0.04742323234677315,
0.5510478615760803,
-0.07551068067550659,
-0.06028195470571518,
-0.7288496494293213,
-0.23203492164611816,
-0.6605005264282227,
-0.3170803487300873,
-0.15311484038829803,
-0.27800625562667847,
0.1282835602760315,
0.4272109270095825,
-0.23836974799633026,
0.4225628077983856,
-0.026487745344638824,
1.0218491554260254,
0.37511584162712097,
-0.05406933277845383,
0.6432634592056274,
0.10410007834434509,
-0.057802964001894,
-0.15535615384578705,
-0.22654303908348083,
-1.0758624076843262,
1.0856196880340576,
0.383966326713562,
0.8915388584136963,
0.3703914284706116,
0.6488808989524841,
0.6362817883491516,
0.32948580384254456,
-1.0021147727966309,
0.5572078227996826,
-0.05660514160990715,
-0.7477279305458069,
-0.2990838885307312,
-0.3160213828086853,
-0.7823144197463989,
0.09612838923931122,
0.09626275300979614,
-0.8213101625442505,
0.04627523571252823,
0.05391291528940201,
-0.523364782333374,
0.1320086121559143,
-0.6240907311439514,
0.7244186997413635,
-0.08103612065315247,
-0.334978312253952,
-0.09070688486099243,
-0.20994159579277039,
0.4409375488758087,
-0.39419183135032654,
0.03975588455796242,
-0.39180412888526917,
-0.4801690876483917,
1.0094242095947266,
-0.041687920689582825,
0.9881933927536011,
0.19197191298007965,
-0.4150814116001129,
0.49416396021842957,
0.38045060634613037,
0.40222251415252686,
-0.19186437129974365,
-0.5846133828163147,
-0.07958285510540009,
0.365139901638031,
-0.2458844631910324,
-0.45887038111686707,
0.775290846824646,
-0.6980001926422119,
-0.38866788148880005,
-0.5413411259651184,
-0.7328158020973206,
-0.3154256343841553,
0.005017170216888189,
0.3048572838306427,
0.3070972263813019,
-0.36418989300727844,
0.2502884864807129,
0.273917019367218,
0.015530096367001534,
0.575080156326294,
0.5347405672073364,
-0.08858117461204529,
-0.380079448223114,
1.0850085020065308,
0.1648491770029068,
0.26117411255836487,
0.25819602608680725,
-0.009893500246107578,
-0.2250770777463913,
-0.626757800579071,
-0.31847459077835083,
0.4021182060241699,
-0.8939305543899536,
-0.33289968967437744,
-0.05023660883307457,
-0.1998077630996704,
0.04614928364753723,
-0.3726225197315216,
-0.2370210736989975,
-0.4813290238380432,
-0.6184006929397583,
-0.07204503566026688,
0.5964962244033813,
1.0496870279312134,
0.31639668345451355,
0.5835676789283752,
-0.48425108194351196,
0.056060899049043655,
-0.04731127619743347,
0.3928711414337158,
-0.08168011903762817,
-0.8908616304397583,
-0.5441946387290955,
-0.45756208896636963,
-0.5761431455612183,
-0.8120813369750977,
0.36418798565864563,
0.3665755093097687,
0.3494430184364319,
0.4760853946208954,
0.20877429842948914,
0.5124037861824036,
-0.48577287793159485,
0.8750970959663391,
0.2613421380519867,
-0.8181123733520508,
0.20883432030677795,
-0.5371170043945312,
0.10016017407178879,
0.6623020768165588,
0.37001895904541016,
-0.309575617313385,
-0.6293511986732483,
-0.3112930357456207,
-0.5042077302932739,
0.7977603673934937,
0.3055814504623413,
0.3498179316520691,
-0.06812763959169388,
0.5810745358467102,
0.028224213048815727,
0.2724449038505554,
-0.9126590490341187,
-0.03897075355052948,
0.07608078420162201,
-0.4019906222820282,
-0.5288718938827515,
-0.42417728900909424,
-0.25105950236320496,
-0.20349770784378052,
0.468767374753952,
0.14117331802845,
0.20429536700248718,
-0.0019717798568308353,
-0.2956089377403259,
0.009945249184966087,
0.23027242720127106,
0.7355200052261353,
0.3824533522129059,
-0.3570850193500519,
0.08439969271421432,
0.18173685669898987,
-0.576561450958252,
0.26310303807258606,
-0.2800985872745514,
-0.0859786793589592,
-0.16600064933300018,
0.8659319281578064,
0.7228456139564514,
0.09763524681329727,
-0.6088057160377502,
0.6396051645278931,
0.17550240457057953,
-0.3424205780029297,
-0.47488468885421753,
0.2986268401145935,
0.14343196153640747,
0.47662490606307983,
0.3243779242038727,
-0.1623380035161972,
0.07481241971254349,
-0.667392373085022,
-0.05897054821252823,
0.3230629861354828,
-0.2609710693359375,
0.05757313221693039,
0.3097067177295685,
0.05115849897265434,
-0.1753961443901062,
0.28357383608818054,
-0.04338909685611725,
-0.4248506724834442,
0.748254656791687,
0.7590147256851196,
0.6907021403312683,
-0.10683384537696838,
0.06157207861542702,
0.17530784010887146,
0.40331804752349854,
0.058364637196063995,
0.054614532738924026,
-0.02208724617958069,
-0.6500204801559448,
-0.3821214735507965,
-0.7035195231437683,
-0.5857913494110107,
0.2854117453098297,
-0.5194006562232971,
0.1393987536430359,
-0.4725699722766876,
-0.2060045450925827,
-0.22728995978832245,
0.10889267921447754,
-0.1846768707036972,
0.08307953178882599,
0.10054627805948257,
0.5108152627944946,
-0.8086666464805603,
0.8643542528152466,
0.3616334795951843,
-0.5109595060348511,
-0.6146101951599121,
0.23149187862873077,
-0.1752161979675293,
-0.7623435258865356,
0.5896946787834167,
0.18287168443202972,
-0.5030888915061951,
0.1089063361287117,
-0.4861888289451599,
-0.6585845351219177,
1.173174262046814,
0.850148618221283,
-0.35114341974258423,
0.07937628775835037,
0.1740795075893402,
0.45049190521240234,
-0.20154988765716553,
0.38366708159446716,
0.7728509306907654,
0.3265688419342041,
0.24675697088241577,
-0.8479065895080566,
-0.0564534068107605,
-0.05015400052070618,
-0.0023916573263704777,
-0.14300477504730225,
-0.6540480256080627,
0.7661644220352173,
-0.11913834512233734,
-0.11437281221151352,
0.5145439505577087,
0.5228315591812134,
0.30283212661743164,
0.14090022444725037,
0.2050492912530899,
0.2015453279018402,
0.7780939936637878,
-0.015042277052998543,
1.2061970233917236,
0.18285079300403595,
0.36035531759262085,
0.9543697834014893,
-0.5354207754135132,
1.1732122898101807,
0.5135573744773865,
-0.380724161863327,
0.5416750311851501,
0.42997321486473083,
-0.07261668890714645,
0.5237699151039124,
0.6522296667098999,
-0.6312589049339294,
-0.1376248449087143,
-0.24499017000198364,
-0.18951508402824402,
0.3748672902584076,
0.1437995731830597,
-0.37868091464042664,
0.11538710445165634,
0.0073804352432489395,
0.16265968978405,
0.29647111892700195,
-0.3029636740684509,
0.7613638639450073,
0.3275425136089325,
-0.5689016580581665,
0.8928295373916626,
0.1437426209449768,
0.5620216727256775,
-0.4919545352458954,
0.016204673796892166,
-0.24616165459156036,
0.49737417697906494,
-0.23442384600639343,
-0.8945557475090027,
0.29680201411247253,
0.3887534439563751,
-0.23553016781806946,
-0.013591050170361996,
0.5030646920204163,
-0.3571242392063141,
-0.6678599715232849,
0.23319658637046814,
0.15987582504749298,
0.7712692022323608,
0.01780518889427185,
-0.30711829662323,
0.25231999158859253,
0.01722162775695324,
-0.5298375487327576,
0.22952677309513092,
0.4249812364578247,
0.08573800325393677,
0.7088016271591187,
0.16765138506889343,
0.23133543133735657,
0.06468706578016281,
0.2829750180244446,
0.38441237807273865,
-0.8066539168357849,
-0.049228422343730927,
-0.9707213640213013,
0.008731703273952007,
0.01622239500284195,
-0.3193363845348358,
0.9174153804779053,
0.5226511359214783,
0.34303373098373413,
-0.24563734233379364,
0.7178635001182556,
0.35629576444625854,
0.5619365572929382,
-0.6260403990745544,
0.8127602338790894,
-0.6348399519920349,
0.4294111430644989,
-0.4501033425331116,
-1.023146629333496,
-0.4569694995880127,
0.8469449281692505,
-0.44339150190353394,
0.022335179150104523,
0.870351254940033,
0.7354904413223267,
0.17404882609844208,
0.027261856943368912,
0.584239661693573,
0.061930302530527115,
0.08941832184791565,
0.5264078378677368,
1.049569010734558,
-0.4582011103630066,
0.7377766370773315,
0.15246838331222534,
-0.1267194151878357,
-0.19888557493686676,
-1.1834189891815186,
-0.9661121964454651,
-0.3032614290714264,
-0.3949430286884308,
0.024851927533745766,
0.13044263422489166,
0.5124156475067139,
0.006494092755019665,
-0.5754513144493103,
-0.6038050055503845,
0.0701906755566597,
0.0834825187921524,
-0.05108855664730072,
-0.18520478904247284,
0.25685185194015503,
-0.36542123556137085,
-0.7036444544792175,
0.4320398271083832,
-0.1374034583568573,
0.052578628063201904,
-0.19072966277599335,
0.020628919824957848,
-0.26543131470680237,
0.6063452363014221,
0.5842577815055847,
0.033411670476198196,
-0.6600519418716431,
-0.2632753252983093,
-0.5396355390548706,
-0.37765413522720337,
-0.04453076049685478,
0.755511462688446,
-0.5660791993141174,
-0.023116499185562134,
0.10848889499902725,
0.33276548981666565,
0.6010729670524597,
0.07553640007972717,
0.5026907920837402,
-0.8613221645355225,
-0.13083292543888092,
0.27220186591148376,
0.2751235067844391,
0.40923264622688293,
-0.32545772194862366,
0.3532780408859253,
0.2817480266094208,
-0.7300922274589539,
-0.8719372153282166,
0.06712810695171356,
-0.9391850829124451,
-0.24356743693351746,
1.4499257802963257,
-0.4206600785255432,
-0.16742049157619476,
-0.11644959449768066,
-0.1613057553768158,
0.2723589241504669,
-0.2694491147994995,
0.43136706948280334,
1.2151098251342773,
0.016477633267641068,
0.18136735260486603,
-0.763460636138916,
0.578812837600708,
0.6211414933204651,
-0.6584299206733704,
0.36673256754875183,
0.573431670665741,
0.2968442142009735,
0.06223301589488983,
0.559857964515686,
-0.08799286931753159,
-0.10927426069974899,
0.00850896630436182,
0.11095505952835083,
-0.054736074060201645,
-0.36258360743522644,
-0.2916223406791687,
0.13074582815170288,
0.443665087223053,
-0.2013401985168457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11375v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11375v1 | Boosting Scientific Concepts Understanding: Can Analogy from Teacher Models Empower Student Models? | 2024-06-17T09:51:38 | 2024-06-17T09:51:38 | Siyu Yuan, Cheng Jiayang, Lin Qiu, Deqing Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Analogical reasoning plays a critical role in human cognition, enabling us to
understand new concepts by associating them with familiar ones. Previous
research in the AI community has mainly focused on identifying and generating
analogies and then examining their quality under human evaluation, which
overlooks the practical application of these analogies in real-world settings.
Inspired by the human education process, in this paper, we propose to
investigate how analogies created by teacher language models (LMs) can assist
student LMs in understanding scientific concepts, thereby aligning more closely
with practical scenarios. Our results suggest that free-form analogies can
indeed aid LMs in understanding concepts. Additionally, analogies generated by
student LMs can improve their own performance on scientific question answering,
demonstrating their capability to use analogies for self-learning new
knowledge. Resources are available at https://github.com/siyuyuan/SCUA. | [
-0.13324077427387238,
-0.4702913165092468,
0.8407064080238342,
-0.15830513834953308,
-0.36474812030792236,
0.22418837249279022,
-0.019964955747127533,
-0.5649654865264893,
0.2825644612312317,
0.20818211138248444,
-0.022910648956894875,
0.09059140086174011,
-0.1716410517692566,
0.2680169343948364,
-0.41873273253440857,
0.6650264859199524,
0.0130686704069376,
0.532970666885376,
-0.9336262345314026,
0.044661667197942734,
-0.41630256175994873,
-0.1769644021987915,
-0.47153258323669434,
-0.6564531922340393,
0.37771356105804443,
0.4746023118495941,
0.7782204747200012,
0.9237730503082275,
0.4498988687992096,
0.33684155344963074,
0.04183841124176979,
-0.05813780054450035,
-0.02541106753051281,
0.17970813810825348,
-0.49968162178993225,
-0.7038151025772095,
-0.1161356270313263,
0.2692643404006958,
0.670707643032074,
0.9985349178314209,
-0.08672148734331131,
0.2598493695259094,
0.016960803419351578,
0.371877521276474,
-0.2829902470111847,
0.33328479528427124,
-0.7692772150039673,
-0.028485368937253952,
0.3381258249282837,
-0.1642317771911621,
-0.23915626108646393,
-0.3795892894268036,
0.20418435335159302,
-1.1494041681289673,
0.3024807870388031,
-0.19932621717453003,
0.9441128969192505,
0.0650763139128685,
-0.21797749400138855,
-0.387863427400589,
-0.5553981065750122,
0.530249297618866,
-0.7498741745948792,
0.26064586639404297,
0.18607236444950104,
0.49953076243400574,
-0.232370987534523,
-0.8544143438339233,
-1.0253525972366333,
-0.13261203467845917,
-0.02026248723268509,
0.27036869525909424,
0.034872304648160934,
-0.05379877984523773,
0.06924527883529663,
0.13619177043437958,
-0.20813803374767303,
0.013118252158164978,
-0.9367030262947083,
0.023411370813846588,
0.47112029790878296,
0.20101778209209442,
0.5266668200492859,
-0.3481731414794922,
-0.5145010948181152,
-0.3686412572860718,
-0.7536811232566833,
0.25637951493263245,
0.10218305885791779,
0.3861691951751709,
0.037976205348968506,
0.3262583911418915,
0.09902387857437134,
0.7284151911735535,
-0.18228310346603394,
-0.11998456716537476,
-0.041999708861112595,
-0.18601754307746887,
-0.00656508281826973,
0.018045442178845406,
0.4359094798564911,
0.4598582684993744,
0.3905150294303894,
-0.3506230413913727,
0.1571488082408905,
0.4855823218822479,
-0.005572811234742403,
-1.163813829421997,
-0.31460505723953247,
-0.029535403475165367,
-0.20090420544147491,
-0.34626442193984985,
0.20454421639442444,
-0.6914786100387573,
-0.32336199283599854,
-0.5572332739830017,
0.6826856136322021,
-0.1982111930847168,
-0.3910450041294098,
0.15164658427238464,
-0.4447897970676422,
-0.11388585716485977,
0.33598828315734863,
-0.9592898488044739,
0.5181742906570435,
0.6490025520324707,
0.6944632530212402,
0.08423219621181488,
-0.44193458557128906,
0.044472698122262955,
0.1895897537469864,
-0.3487403690814972,
0.7927899956703186,
-0.7390444278717041,
-0.5626356601715088,
-0.5270644426345825,
-0.23265796899795532,
-0.12856338918209076,
-0.6511325836181641,
0.23104225099086761,
-0.23353488743305206,
0.32958051562309265,
-0.19534260034561157,
-0.6324722170829773,
-0.19556064903736115,
-0.15522071719169617,
-0.3937632739543915,
0.8753176331520081,
-0.1470339149236679,
-0.42367908358573914,
0.03104378469288349,
-0.7273787260055542,
0.004538638051599264,
0.07184018194675446,
-0.43015989661216736,
0.11771518737077713,
0.2697581350803375,
0.027397306635975838,
0.38436397910118103,
-0.49999570846557617,
0.3393406867980957,
-0.3310835063457489,
-0.25850629806518555,
0.5483982563018799,
-0.09869815409183502,
0.6128761172294617,
0.5229955911636353,
0.10503977537155151,
0.1949305385351181,
-0.4938761591911316,
0.09504801034927368,
0.3156629204750061,
0.3776859939098358,
-0.8866831064224243,
0.023288942873477936,
-0.46841564774513245,
0.2388586401939392,
-0.14474180340766907,
-0.4526561200618744,
0.22098632156848907,
-0.5638501644134521,
0.888664722442627,
0.5907512903213501,
0.03958078846335411,
0.5688809752464294,
-0.35923218727111816,
0.4146309792995453,
-0.05879694223403931,
-0.2356090098619461,
-0.502862274646759,
-0.44462209939956665,
-0.6065094470977783,
-0.300066202878952,
0.39024701714515686,
0.2607438564300537,
-0.6418290138244629,
-0.17680878937244415,
-0.45448681712150574,
-0.7788295149803162,
-0.8424045443534851,
0.05296625941991806,
0.17372699081897736,
1.1043672561645508,
0.2642761766910553,
-0.28392088413238525,
-0.5206311345100403,
-0.6969359517097473,
-0.47416871786117554,
-0.20300211012363434,
-0.3860027492046356,
0.23271754384040833,
0.76307612657547,
0.19966425001621246,
1.2421759366989136,
-0.5410680770874023,
0.2895214855670929,
0.2155270278453827,
-0.03239541873335838,
0.08188042789697647,
0.3486408591270447,
0.5428869128227234,
-0.671750009059906,
-0.20763327181339264,
-0.22678960859775543,
-1.0770763158798218,
0.05582418665289879,
-0.14162255823612213,
-0.15527550876140594,
-0.4158620834350586,
0.4204501807689667,
-0.7409484386444092,
0.23219428956508636,
-0.004227247089147568,
-0.4670977294445038,
0.6211702823638916,
-0.29547375440597534,
0.12413784116506577,
-1.0824421644210815,
0.0375741682946682,
0.15806613862514496,
-0.08860227465629578,
-0.6889967918395996,
0.43675342202186584,
0.15502135455608368,
-0.5055723786354065,
-0.7351293563842773,
0.940093994140625,
-0.3198983371257782,
-0.13811750710010529,
-0.3098467290401459,
0.630055844783783,
0.255309522151947,
-0.11160054057836533,
0.29687440395355225,
0.9812774062156677,
0.4897933602333069,
-0.5993632078170776,
0.15509755909442902,
0.08327731490135193,
-0.4215141236782074,
0.3737452030181885,
-1.0301849842071533,
-0.01943265274167061,
-0.21979139745235443,
0.4298085868358612,
-0.5833450555801392,
-0.1884704977273941,
0.17351411283016205,
-0.49956464767456055,
-0.2424013912677765,
0.23230649530887604,
-0.4920569062232971,
-0.3968682885169983,
-0.27960696816444397,
0.49448737502098083,
0.4588124454021454,
-0.6509875059127808,
0.45143404603004456,
0.17693078517913818,
-0.07857450097799301,
-0.34784093499183655,
-0.5124684572219849,
0.020943989977240562,
-0.4022153317928314,
-0.2949256896972656,
0.1794719099998474,
-0.0998818427324295,
-0.5110285878181458,
0.3098427951335907,
-0.23487040400505066,
-0.050530146807432175,
0.3971305787563324,
0.12964680790901184,
0.5442560315132141,
-0.2420578896999359,
0.4046042263507843,
0.1737077683210373,
0.021569818258285522,
0.3779290020465851,
-0.19310005009174347,
0.1717233955860138,
-0.22712893784046173,
-0.22465254366397858,
-0.5236719250679016,
0.13410718739032745,
0.6811336874961853,
0.1726723313331604,
0.6249109506607056,
0.06127598136663437,
-0.5386629700660706,
-0.05203016847372055,
-0.10309725999832153,
-0.9856767058372498,
-0.4588269889354706,
0.3726770281791687,
-0.5410048961639404,
-0.37855270504951477,
0.3767622709274292,
-0.07492715120315552,
-0.35430967807769775,
0.24266491830348969,
0.2669198215007782,
-0.44201087951660156,
0.5921251773834229,
0.28590717911720276,
0.19763632118701935,
0.16037455201148987,
-0.23094160854816437,
0.32953035831451416,
-0.6316149234771729,
-0.25965604186058044,
-0.5390331149101257,
0.08108612895011902,
-0.3120378851890564,
-0.553242027759552,
0.3364815413951874,
0.4553065896034241,
-0.2807404398918152,
0.3339984714984894,
-0.6589844822883606,
0.7845902442932129,
0.362525075674057,
0.20014910399913788,
0.2967895567417145,
0.16571611166000366,
-0.24248681962490082,
-0.14062951505184174,
-0.8324399590492249,
-0.9143244624137878,
1.0444581508636475,
0.3493458330631256,
0.501501739025116,
-0.13216564059257507,
0.5743282437324524,
0.014577563852071762,
0.6314881443977356,
-0.7246822118759155,
0.8175559043884277,
0.19845576584339142,
-0.557197630405426,
-0.12732528150081635,
-0.37238940596580505,
-0.8476864099502563,
0.7191766500473022,
-0.4915013015270233,
-0.6786029934883118,
-0.07901988178491592,
0.1598796546459198,
-0.06746082752943039,
0.42300310730934143,
-0.8502160310745239,
0.7363538146018982,
-0.19700975716114044,
-0.23303942382335663,
-0.5100730657577515,
-0.6546598076820374,
0.17872700095176697,
-0.00785575620830059,
0.41682955622673035,
-0.1433383971452713,
0.11169753223657608,
0.7776186466217041,
-0.2965008020401001,
1.1110070943832397,
-0.08959253132343292,
0.0638415589928627,
0.6351230144500732,
0.20707465708255768,
-0.05629570409655571,
-0.0742681622505188,
-0.23668448626995087,
0.03461800888180733,
0.45493221282958984,
-0.6494989991188049,
-1.1223859786987305,
0.7154891490936279,
-0.8286228775978088,
-1.044448733329773,
-0.5049746632575989,
-0.9326117038726807,
0.052478279918432236,
0.0242770966142416,
-0.38882774114608765,
-0.11336129903793335,
0.05685940757393837,
0.015298538841307163,
0.34443679451942444,
0.2547883689403534,
0.269979327917099,
0.539873480796814,
-0.26469576358795166,
-0.25831225514411926,
1.1457988023757935,
-0.09007791429758072,
0.6715180277824402,
0.08320216834545135,
0.609513521194458,
-0.339720219373703,
0.047197651118040085,
-0.6242551207542419,
0.3874523341655731,
-1.0114136934280396,
-0.39461785554885864,
-0.45469972491264343,
-0.04584283381700516,
-0.5842453241348267,
-0.20882774889469147,
0.037029389292001724,
-1.0822752714157104,
-0.40396392345428467,
-0.24849125742912292,
0.3521628975868225,
0.6421278715133667,
-0.02370988018810749,
0.17072072625160217,
-0.43836772441864014,
0.376718670129776,
0.45906585454940796,
-0.2675931453704834,
0.4025188386440277,
-0.5407170653343201,
-0.13123810291290283,
0.4287894070148468,
-0.6549049615859985,
-1.1082044839859009,
0.2819671928882599,
0.2489461451768875,
0.6625945568084717,
0.5746974349021912,
-0.19989840686321259,
0.7280333638191223,
-0.4212292730808258,
0.808481752872467,
0.38347887992858887,
-1.1669330596923828,
0.570354700088501,
-0.1763293594121933,
-0.08859352767467499,
0.16926716268062592,
0.5456960201263428,
-0.5352315902709961,
-0.30426153540611267,
-0.639966607093811,
-0.6297553777694702,
0.20599012076854706,
0.03696577250957489,
0.3826863765716553,
0.07617519795894623,
0.8004904985427856,
0.2440301477909088,
0.3692456781864166,
-0.792572021484375,
-0.27310213446617126,
-0.6415033936500549,
-0.5557141900062561,
-0.0741388276219368,
0.12688706815242767,
-0.1620090901851654,
-0.6002413630485535,
0.5595988631248474,
-0.24174147844314575,
0.10179094970226288,
0.11225128918886185,
0.10079993307590485,
-0.15776552259922028,
0.37753379344940186,
0.5100893378257751,
0.7722931504249573,
0.046573206782341,
0.49537193775177,
0.4030536711215973,
-0.23815032839775085,
0.1088593378663063,
0.08528035879135132,
-0.2825186848640442,
-0.2764614522457123,
0.21844005584716797,
0.47397658228874207,
0.27481478452682495,
-0.8081206679344177,
0.08749265968799591,
0.2340593934059143,
0.08231180906295776,
0.04910433292388916,
0.3673727512359619,
0.4278787672519684,
0.10470923781394958,
0.589697003364563,
0.11501901596784592,
-0.026374205946922302,
-0.8586025834083557,
0.05875613912940025,
0.4587341547012329,
-0.0007945208344608545,
-0.6009624004364014,
0.8824376463890076,
0.10570191591978073,
-0.3898388743400574,
0.3124222457408905,
0.16471152007579803,
-0.5728738903999329,
1.0349470376968384,
1.2485564947128296,
0.4258052408695221,
-0.379469633102417,
0.37138479948043823,
0.4486474096775055,
0.009416903369128704,
-0.05605161562561989,
0.129115492105484,
-0.33039650321006775,
-0.9098583459854126,
-0.10846336930990219,
-0.3650747239589691,
-0.7631193399429321,
-0.07937144488096237,
-0.6259434223175049,
0.3346323072910309,
-0.4056466519832611,
0.23228654265403748,
0.3316482901573181,
-0.17228581011295319,
-0.5060651898384094,
0.2748810350894928,
-0.07451193034648895,
0.9013844132423401,
-1.4471083879470825,
1.0153836011886597,
0.9371323585510254,
-0.6787850260734558,
-0.9650110602378845,
-0.3451310992240906,
-0.29524239897727966,
-0.6341082453727722,
1.011717677116394,
0.046385835856199265,
-0.15938106179237366,
-0.0743241161108017,
-0.5533122420310974,
-0.7237465977668762,
1.2912287712097168,
0.41000896692276,
-0.14654450118541718,
-0.09273669868707657,
0.26001694798469543,
0.9064624905586243,
-0.7196785807609558,
0.540367603302002,
0.15158461034297943,
0.27172157168388367,
0.155574768781662,
-0.6864185929298401,
0.2562747001647949,
-0.2692803144454956,
-0.2639184892177582,
-0.26579615473747253,
-0.31202536821365356,
0.6895588040351868,
-0.6485028862953186,
-0.2253752499818802,
0.2581314146518707,
1.0270252227783203,
0.5793424248695374,
0.8352133631706238,
0.42954254150390625,
0.4195648729801178,
0.6835111975669861,
0.14434947073459625,
0.6735909581184387,
-0.32393455505371094,
0.21802844107151031,
0.9798687100410461,
-0.06542219966650009,
0.8366914391517639,
0.9227957129478455,
-0.10262567549943924,
0.6095440983772278,
0.6029263138771057,
-0.006334695965051651,
0.42655032873153687,
0.48626819252967834,
-0.28937166929244995,
-0.40144088864326477,
-0.30550113320350647,
-0.6003944277763367,
0.26192706823349,
0.6713171601295471,
-0.16079634428024292,
-0.2353116124868393,
-0.025155488401651382,
0.028548212721943855,
0.6999247670173645,
-0.2947719693183899,
0.18885207176208496,
0.29336583614349365,
-0.5530925989151001,
0.5396496057510376,
-0.34529560804367065,
0.27933499217033386,
-0.3593522906303406,
-0.3430781960487366,
-0.012466940097510815,
-0.0859748125076294,
-0.0449584536254406,
-0.7398970127105713,
-0.049912434071302414,
-0.2448115199804306,
-0.12972399592399597,
-0.0813630223274231,
0.5949022173881531,
-0.5374701619148254,
-0.4922246038913727,
-0.10929334163665771,
0.5398939251899719,
0.414969265460968,
0.5152308940887451,
-0.5515210628509521,
-0.30567869544029236,
-0.24090705811977386,
0.27845457196235657,
0.24927422404289246,
0.14088226854801178,
-0.30745160579681396,
1.0826442241668701,
0.6800216436386108,
0.3450961112976074,
-0.23215189576148987,
-0.24166853725910187,
0.982059895992279,
-0.5380898118019104,
-0.35829970240592957,
-0.5020806193351746,
0.17238979041576385,
0.09694622457027435,
0.0037581485230475664,
0.6909972429275513,
0.4338030517101288,
0.9539614319801331,
-0.37174704670906067,
0.5957021713256836,
0.34136390686035156,
0.41806939244270325,
-0.3156574070453644,
0.7391893863677979,
-0.45983240008354187,
0.3534298241138458,
-0.31296736001968384,
-0.7950820326805115,
-0.3185485601425171,
0.8338285684585571,
-0.36158719658851624,
-0.18205881118774414,
0.5617411732673645,
0.6011515855789185,
-0.315878689289093,
0.17174986004829407,
0.3005785048007965,
0.14279265701770782,
0.338589072227478,
0.24103166162967682,
1.0274964570999146,
-0.4260636270046234,
0.08112015575170517,
-0.2668874263763428,
0.05935516580939293,
0.048273876309394836,
-0.9462939500808716,
-1.0094364881515503,
-0.6508567333221436,
-0.2776983976364136,
-0.18565791845321655,
0.22352690994739532,
1.0763816833496094,
0.6369270086288452,
-0.6244320273399353,
-0.3112274706363678,
-0.19874413311481476,
0.23193378746509552,
-0.21370841562747955,
-0.21662692725658417,
0.5895256400108337,
-0.19513197243213654,
-0.7452747225761414,
0.5263738632202148,
-0.32387691736221313,
0.4369099736213684,
-0.23284727334976196,
-0.0901062861084938,
0.16453659534454346,
0.5886140465736389,
0.30301567912101746,
0.5019623637199402,
-1.0142691135406494,
-0.34628981351852417,
0.15297776460647583,
0.018203509971499443,
-0.10978947579860687,
0.9441124796867371,
-1.271411657333374,
0.6661073565483093,
0.35964420437812805,
0.3879168629646301,
0.35067638754844666,
0.071967713534832,
0.37345439195632935,
-0.27545881271362305,
0.4759848713874817,
0.18392035365104675,
0.32273024320602417,
0.3728864789009094,
-0.1200023964047432,
0.44176068902015686,
0.3708692789077759,
-0.31407004594802856,
-1.1185200214385986,
0.1920391172170639,
-0.7460190057754517,
-0.5089388489723206,
0.7664893865585327,
-0.2256823182106018,
-0.20386186242103577,
0.3193114101886749,
0.029465660452842712,
0.22462482750415802,
-0.2571942210197449,
1.0795810222625732,
0.6329130530357361,
-0.071157306432724,
-0.043816111981868744,
-0.5288166403770447,
0.3291729688644409,
0.7491903305053711,
-0.8360550403594971,
-0.3013136088848114,
0.09222391247749329,
0.46759116649627686,
0.26086199283599854,
-0.0024766006972640753,
0.023643234744668007,
0.3036390244960785,
-0.18165816366672516,
0.20835880935192108,
-0.3253549635410309,
-0.2222660928964615,
0.00042222285992465913,
-0.12586481869220734,
0.02707335352897644,
-0.13466894626617432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11370v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11370v1 | Fairer Preferences Elicit Improved Human-Aligned Large Language Model Judgments | 2024-06-17T09:48:53 | 2024-06-17T09:48:53 | Han Zhou, Xingchen Wan, Yinhong Liu, Nigel Collier, Ivan Vulić, Anna Korhonen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have shown promising abilities as cost-effective
and reference-free evaluators for assessing language generation quality. In
particular, pairwise LLM evaluators, which compare two generated texts and
determine the preferred one, have been employed in a wide range of
applications. However, LLMs exhibit preference biases and worrying sensitivity
to prompt designs. In this work, we first reveal that the predictive preference
of LLMs can be highly brittle and skewed, even with semantically equivalent
instructions. We find that fairer predictive preferences from LLMs consistently
lead to judgments that are better aligned with humans. Motivated by this
phenomenon, we propose an automatic Zero-shot Evaluation-oriented Prompt
Optimization framework, ZEPO, which aims to produce fairer preference decisions
and improve the alignment of LLM evaluators with human judgments. To this end,
we propose a zero-shot learning objective based on the preference decision
fairness. ZEPO demonstrates substantial performance improvements over
state-of-the-art LLM evaluators, without requiring labeled data, on
representative meta-evaluation benchmarks. Our findings underscore the critical
correlation between preference fairness and human alignment, positioning ZEPO
as an efficient prompt optimizer for bridging the gap between LLM evaluators
and human judgments. | [
-0.2180294245481491,
-0.37222960591316223,
0.7904199957847595,
0.04135021194815636,
-0.17252875864505768,
-0.20817604660987854,
-0.4525775909423828,
-0.3551400601863861,
-0.13913780450820923,
0.30793166160583496,
-0.35890722274780273,
-0.36425936222076416,
-0.4745282530784607,
0.21468214690685272,
0.27151814103126526,
0.8800240755081177,
0.3282964825630188,
0.14903002977371216,
-0.20651549100875854,
-0.07349838316440582,
-0.6529455184936523,
-0.1876789927482605,
-0.5901307463645935,
-0.5651229619979858,
0.5657635927200317,
0.6113393902778625,
1.026488184928894,
0.5681008100509644,
0.026258831843733788,
0.2411363571882248,
0.006080684717744589,
-0.11121601611375809,
-0.39326775074005127,
0.25576478242874146,
-0.2474064975976944,
-0.5050637722015381,
-0.5205709338188171,
0.07563396543264389,
0.3972717523574829,
0.7272089123725891,
-0.04366063326597214,
0.16708381474018097,
0.13690806925296783,
0.6687285304069519,
-0.7742866277694702,
-0.0539478100836277,
-0.8142408728599548,
0.10050611943006516,
-0.0829605981707573,
-0.245603546500206,
-0.5548619627952576,
-0.4973149001598358,
0.17724131047725677,
-0.5128133893013,
0.13303793966770172,
0.22263363003730774,
0.7891878485679626,
0.1477297842502594,
-0.3855220079421997,
0.02883673831820488,
-0.30689242482185364,
1.1950095891952515,
-0.866364061832428,
0.31042852997779846,
0.04122786223888397,
0.4532180428504944,
-0.3854256272315979,
-0.1519382745027542,
-0.7047619223594666,
-0.2277027666568756,
0.28172609210014343,
0.053401798009872437,
-0.15330028533935547,
0.24563387036323547,
0.09956072270870209,
0.11048265546560287,
-0.7038847804069519,
0.41915133595466614,
0.059138763695955276,
-0.4700540006160736,
0.6068295240402222,
0.17927023768424988,
0.3371274173259735,
-0.5672045946121216,
-0.34688910841941833,
0.00829004030674696,
-0.71225506067276,
0.3849610686302185,
0.7472732663154602,
0.42861273884773254,
0.16469652950763702,
0.5575523376464844,
-0.46878495812416077,
0.9379705786705017,
0.27634188532829285,
-0.2668507993221283,
0.5742887258529663,
-0.044652439653873444,
-0.18762408196926117,
0.1546742469072342,
1.0040216445922852,
1.0307276248931885,
0.3770369589328766,
-0.1483204960823059,
-0.451494425535202,
0.26681020855903625,
0.09963329136371613,
-0.9161337018013,
0.29774588346481323,
0.1990421861410141,
-0.45270758867263794,
-0.5842055082321167,
-0.07690523564815521,
-0.7994440793991089,
-0.2965492010116577,
-0.44678184390068054,
0.4955642521381378,
-0.19423185288906097,
0.09361232072114944,
0.40973514318466187,
-0.08991500735282898,
0.2773036062717438,
0.45071905851364136,
-1.0758370161056519,
-0.07990597188472748,
0.7918878793716431,
0.5973164439201355,
-0.06574911624193192,
-0.17695938050746918,
-1.0243321657180786,
-0.0241695586591959,
-0.42769789695739746,
0.779643714427948,
-0.5584384202957153,
-0.21612440049648285,
-0.10187668353319168,
-0.18666084110736847,
0.24414274096488953,
-0.3663926124572754,
0.8834730982780457,
-0.35195690393447876,
0.6474907994270325,
-0.3898566663265228,
-0.4222281873226166,
0.04874162748456001,
0.19444581866264343,
-0.3355032801628113,
0.599949061870575,
0.21969212591648102,
-0.6160981059074402,
0.8013403415679932,
-0.37684306502342224,
-0.267194002866745,
0.1755995750427246,
-0.41984090209007263,
-0.29419031739234924,
0.2509559690952301,
0.23331741988658905,
0.3965071141719818,
-0.6027275323867798,
0.6875905990600586,
-0.5410733222961426,
-0.3588363230228424,
0.12793083488941193,
-0.4784810245037079,
0.7828361392021179,
0.3460780382156372,
-0.5171520113945007,
0.39988845586776733,
-0.5602883696556091,
0.13939031958580017,
0.12558484077453613,
-0.22822244465351105,
-0.12765493988990784,
0.01148639339953661,
-0.2259397804737091,
0.33604979515075684,
0.21153275668621063,
-0.6137773394584656,
0.07846277207136154,
-0.7175102829933167,
0.21980872750282288,
1.1923178434371948,
-0.3726116716861725,
0.7917677760124207,
-0.5470244288444519,
0.5477919578552246,
-0.3475070893764496,
0.49332359433174133,
0.015767162665724754,
-0.4913404881954193,
-0.5998306274414062,
0.018445756286382675,
0.08715396374464035,
0.3488316237926483,
-0.5068509578704834,
0.7386796474456787,
-0.2498193383216858,
-0.2371300756931305,
-0.6155325770378113,
0.2378397285938263,
0.39460068941116333,
0.980474591255188,
0.014487341046333313,
-0.14299748837947845,
-0.3089846968650818,
-0.9947081804275513,
-0.31439509987831116,
-0.190908282995224,
-0.1806837022304535,
0.41933465003967285,
-0.14656735956668854,
0.03688296303153038,
1.160391092300415,
-0.4395660161972046,
0.01337273046374321,
-0.31630322337150574,
-0.05654699727892876,
0.35192355513572693,
0.13027890026569366,
0.9614332914352417,
-0.5420624017715454,
-0.7048764228820801,
-0.1912340521812439,
-0.45236706733703613,
-0.6448772549629211,
0.14355316758155823,
-0.29564666748046875,
0.3785695433616638,
-0.05369631573557854,
-0.43001589179039,
0.014935968443751335,
0.5098959803581238,
-0.5167169570922852,
0.5517327785491943,
0.08017871528863907,
0.3105350136756897,
-0.8846476674079895,
0.021671006456017494,
-0.12120470404624939,
-0.25005999207496643,
-0.5302852392196655,
-0.25251129269599915,
0.09460009634494781,
-0.08381979912519455,
-0.5669601559638977,
0.9018465876579285,
-0.3249712884426117,
-0.14334245026111603,
-0.3443530797958374,
0.3227238357067108,
0.37152060866355896,
0.303347647190094,
-0.06521479785442352,
0.7555916905403137,
0.5078781843185425,
-0.3670729100704193,
0.13281644880771637,
-0.014241451397538185,
-0.4016447961330414,
0.5994386076927185,
-0.7494227886199951,
0.2917267680168152,
-0.38409826159477234,
0.048948321491479874,
-0.8882130980491638,
-0.1324712336063385,
0.26980268955230713,
-0.5672750473022461,
0.1987471729516983,
-0.12460745126008987,
-0.30290117859840393,
-0.1611631065607071,
-0.7307448983192444,
0.21825352311134338,
0.7211422920227051,
-0.5734007954597473,
0.26254740357398987,
0.2974611222743988,
-0.17500492930412292,
-0.9840897917747498,
-0.32277968525886536,
-0.017277326434850693,
-0.21897022426128387,
-0.8364039659500122,
0.20849718153476715,
-0.23534594476222992,
-0.28175580501556396,
-0.160415381193161,
-0.09126842021942139,
0.463838130235672,
0.1972097009420395,
0.2757101058959961,
0.5765793323516846,
-0.10029411315917969,
0.1640663892030716,
0.0710601806640625,
-0.36408036947250366,
-0.18391595780849457,
-0.29649871587753296,
0.6957388520240784,
-0.08397296816110611,
-0.19686615467071533,
-0.3756910562515259,
0.11179991066455841,
0.3985391855239868,
0.06465920060873032,
0.40219366550445557,
0.32963326573371887,
-0.06478822231292725,
-0.17914612591266632,
-0.7099171876907349,
-0.016072779893875122,
-0.46076253056526184,
0.019301723688840866,
-0.2557826340198517,
-0.9523651003837585,
0.15432235598564148,
0.3458777666091919,
0.2517390251159668,
0.4287302792072296,
0.40516719222068787,
0.12853455543518066,
1.270739197731018,
0.5881996154785156,
-0.27905187010765076,
0.48048481345176697,
0.3083856403827667,
0.19078874588012695,
-0.7000963091850281,
-0.01823926530778408,
-0.6725332736968994,
-0.39395877718925476,
-0.15821728110313416,
-0.23945865035057068,
0.22414642572402954,
0.33098629117012024,
-0.3397647440433502,
0.07800202816724777,
-0.4758823812007904,
0.5235244035720825,
0.3692398965358734,
-0.10416581481695175,
0.2250228226184845,
-0.05221681669354439,
-0.18389004468917847,
-0.21894338726997375,
-0.6131552457809448,
-0.9368590116500854,
1.1805905103683472,
0.21944734454154968,
0.5467225909233093,
0.06071901321411133,
0.7128288149833679,
0.13557186722755432,
0.30950987339019775,
-0.844948947429657,
0.47367265820503235,
-0.08858315646648407,
-0.3420614004135132,
-0.33612552285194397,
-0.5871288776397705,
-0.9108512997627258,
0.2810518145561218,
-0.33116573095321655,
-0.6392532587051392,
0.17755912244319916,
0.37415811419487,
-0.6536843776702881,
0.02489447221159935,
-0.7985481023788452,
0.9354969263076782,
-0.5021835565567017,
-0.47564491629600525,
-0.13574326038360596,
-0.6299588084220886,
0.29080289602279663,
-0.08360201865434647,
0.2101505994796753,
-0.6677351593971252,
-0.19012683629989624,
0.41715288162231445,
-0.40435531735420227,
0.621721088886261,
-0.3592848777770996,
-0.09180749207735062,
0.16453982889652252,
0.13023267686367035,
0.29173171520233154,
-0.009266311302781105,
-0.6729495525360107,
0.1443604975938797,
-0.5128806233406067,
-0.37009096145629883,
-0.6914907693862915,
0.7728951573371887,
-0.7725663185119629,
-0.7923835515975952,
-0.2189258188009262,
-0.3694804906845093,
-0.2302495390176773,
0.28540512919425964,
0.39646223187446594,
0.2997564673423767,
-0.20978377759456635,
0.0010836082510650158,
0.30734002590179443,
-0.5434945821762085,
0.4638367295265198,
0.5712921023368835,
-0.32831862568855286,
-0.4363822042942047,
0.7216303944587708,
-0.1349334865808487,
0.5595614910125732,
0.36764270067214966,
0.63201504945755,
-0.3484255075454712,
-0.4007534980773926,
-0.6471768617630005,
-0.014657584019005299,
-0.44859784841537476,
-0.49840298295021057,
-0.5573103427886963,
0.21405930817127228,
-0.6967096924781799,
-0.5443769097328186,
-0.1516173928976059,
-0.4644060730934143,
-0.1825929582118988,
-0.07965599745512009,
0.10724686086177826,
0.1987297087907791,
-0.04245637729763985,
0.20970897376537323,
-0.6756905317306519,
0.3317142426967621,
0.4076768457889557,
0.3037891387939453,
0.003618997987359762,
-0.7409178018569946,
0.255048543214798,
0.049479298293590546,
-0.26318201422691345,
-0.6375060081481934,
0.3889707326889038,
0.030299272388219833,
0.640649676322937,
0.5903159976005554,
0.2530316412448883,
0.4370096027851105,
-0.5634617209434509,
0.7007437944412231,
0.5657422542572021,
-1.0356512069702148,
0.6941964626312256,
-0.3421163856983185,
0.2917839288711548,
0.70319002866745,
0.1336255520582199,
-0.5409292578697205,
-0.12399790436029434,
-0.3387814462184906,
-0.6522830128669739,
0.8880913853645325,
-0.18787820637226105,
0.2963888645172119,
-0.18913249671459198,
0.31753960251808167,
0.5079544186592102,
0.28404319286346436,
-0.7186519503593445,
0.003290580352768302,
-0.18234758079051971,
-0.16537761688232422,
-0.1782078742980957,
-0.3577033579349518,
0.08223457634449005,
0.1334342211484909,
0.5554115176200867,
-0.34123295545578003,
-0.2519589364528656,
-0.025300191715359688,
-0.17803899943828583,
-0.5000283718109131,
0.6513751745223999,
0.37500324845314026,
0.5256717205047607,
-0.30829519033432007,
0.06259547919034958,
-0.06241249293088913,
-0.008122428320348263,
0.35313522815704346,
-0.19622182846069336,
-0.7180353999137878,
-0.06407726556062698,
0.05536503344774246,
0.9398252964019775,
0.20245075225830078,
-0.8124731779098511,
1.033678412437439,
-0.0602819100022316,
-0.09460733085870743,
0.11975233256816864,
0.3815656900405884,
-0.10235225409269333,
0.1727205514907837,
0.14026227593421936,
0.09208505600690842,
0.24895615875720978,
-0.4853372275829315,
0.04659680277109146,
0.6126351356506348,
-0.2337425947189331,
-0.3354492783546448,
0.6531255841255188,
0.5019495487213135,
-0.4360038638114929,
0.520469069480896,
-0.4330306947231293,
-0.5137740969657898,
0.3482203781604767,
0.47820112109184265,
1.0170971155166626,
-0.2596425712108612,
0.27664509415626526,
0.39171847701072693,
0.08548290282487869,
-0.03768963739275932,
0.20190489292144775,
-0.13729937374591827,
-1.0607584714889526,
-0.41075363755226135,
-0.7740621566772461,
-0.26812252402305603,
-0.1817598044872284,
-0.4250134527683258,
0.6813117265701294,
-0.4716438353061676,
-0.3874599039554596,
-0.13165664672851562,
0.11776707321405411,
-0.6868917346000671,
-0.048752978444099426,
0.2943439185619354,
0.584642767906189,
-0.8054178357124329,
0.6914190053939819,
0.31353649497032166,
-0.272294282913208,
-0.7187591195106506,
-0.07359250634908676,
0.1663224846124649,
-0.9089208841323853,
0.6372354626655579,
0.40318378806114197,
-0.19282802939414978,
-0.25440800189971924,
-0.3854193091392517,
-0.5380280017852783,
0.9756777882575989,
0.935085117816925,
-1.031105637550354,
0.06391965597867966,
-0.043838486075401306,
0.26167047023773193,
-0.2795264720916748,
0.45653438568115234,
0.37385421991348267,
0.5055302977561951,
-0.08213591575622559,
-0.9026041626930237,
0.016594020649790764,
-0.0670548602938652,
-0.03965585678815842,
0.3475155532360077,
-0.7735375761985779,
0.6273135542869568,
-0.519000232219696,
-0.24525649845600128,
-0.03655153512954712,
0.4609724283218384,
0.41677650809288025,
0.32697156071662903,
0.8411971926689148,
0.5149514675140381,
0.7554160952568054,
0.06862279772758484,
0.9858284592628479,
-0.311249315738678,
0.08692346513271332,
1.2306958436965942,
-0.6708081364631653,
0.6772834062576294,
0.511216402053833,
0.016200849786400795,
0.2654231786727905,
0.42163270711898804,
0.11371631920337677,
0.357082337141037,
0.13817253708839417,
-0.3122155964374542,
-0.4062972664833069,
-0.34917470812797546,
-0.1907888650894165,
0.3480257987976074,
-0.2276812046766281,
-0.20830297470092773,
-0.24577510356903076,
-0.24873629212379456,
0.021577414125204086,
0.23826490342617035,
-0.1903127282857895,
0.6495418548583984,
-0.0008202744647860527,
-0.9103706479072571,
0.28650063276290894,
0.09940633177757263,
1.0300912857055664,
-0.4287989139556885,
0.16826759278774261,
-0.25001126527786255,
-0.12416352331638336,
-0.2598932981491089,
-0.8810073733329773,
-0.06025242432951927,
0.1929454207420349,
-0.39351579546928406,
-0.36110541224479675,
0.7863512635231018,
-0.2794256806373596,
-0.18910856544971466,
0.4678923487663269,
0.3659977912902832,
0.06851820647716522,
-0.020844196900725365,
-0.6833928823471069,
0.03522343561053276,
0.20046694576740265,
-0.38099029660224915,
0.49773329496383667,
0.3897008001804352,
-0.09320268779993057,
0.4228847622871399,
0.7036194801330566,
0.0968010351061821,
-0.09807185083627701,
0.5349726676940918,
0.5124387145042419,
-0.6729013323783875,
-0.29159092903137207,
-0.9574352502822876,
0.3925020396709442,
-0.02706271782517433,
-0.3399994373321533,
0.5685012936592102,
0.5403897762298584,
0.7596520185470581,
0.13350002467632294,
0.7567136883735657,
0.09028847515583038,
0.42050066590309143,
-0.4235590100288391,
0.6039413213729858,
-0.49085503816604614,
0.20112201571464539,
-0.32277950644493103,
-1.2371973991394043,
-0.22756797075271606,
0.5236039161682129,
-0.3600213825702667,
0.039817750453948975,
0.23865364491939545,
0.8198893666267395,
0.21613222360610962,
-0.24483856558799744,
0.6461950540542603,
-0.26040902733802795,
0.43765318393707275,
0.8176062703132629,
0.8660491704940796,
-0.1734519898891449,
0.44770073890686035,
-0.2307487577199936,
-0.3802596628665924,
-0.26865872740745544,
-1.1958850622177124,
-0.7477331757545471,
-0.10413410514593124,
-0.023463064804673195,
-0.049872130155563354,
-0.010208974592387676,
1.3633025884628296,
0.5503868460655212,
-0.5093012452125549,
-0.21285253763198853,
0.047591835260391235,
0.18977071344852448,
0.3119252324104309,
-0.279873788356781,
0.15890243649482727,
-0.7203287482261658,
-0.9350822567939758,
0.3183635175228119,
0.5847262740135193,
-0.021754110231995583,
-0.006553046405315399,
-0.4878481328487396,
0.337583065032959,
-0.0075981831178069115,
0.6238770484924316,
-0.008063937537372112,
-0.8033508062362671,
-0.5843554735183716,
0.10741463303565979,
-0.31320279836654663,
0.24494194984436035,
0.6088628172874451,
-0.8233534693717957,
0.7137148380279541,
0.8066699504852295,
0.5371485948562622,
-0.21705570816993713,
-0.034416314214468,
0.9914289116859436,
-0.3418489098548889,
0.16109736263751984,
0.3588351905345917,
0.45613619685173035,
0.39914125204086304,
-0.3694383502006531,
0.30092212557792664,
-0.007215934339910746,
-0.6589221358299255,
-0.7843655347824097,
0.13652512431144714,
-0.9175112843513489,
-0.22627559304237366,
1.1330184936523438,
0.07843849807977676,
-0.23005478084087372,
0.19679726660251617,
-0.26385313272476196,
0.17045067250728607,
-0.8767642378807068,
0.7699167132377625,
0.5752729177474976,
-0.12750904262065887,
0.0862475037574768,
-0.4608086347579956,
0.35632747411727905,
0.8452921509742737,
-0.6448137164115906,
-0.025850934907794,
0.7743772864341736,
0.39771023392677307,
-0.10066826641559601,
0.724880576133728,
-0.18189652264118195,
0.3916507363319397,
-0.42312443256378174,
0.37902629375457764,
0.030089184641838074,
-0.2147037833929062,
-0.6301026344299316,
0.06794397532939911,
0.43959373235702515,
-0.03912048786878586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11368v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11368v1 | Improving Quotation Attribution with Fictional Character Embeddings | 2024-06-17T09:46:35 | 2024-06-17T09:46:35 | Gaspard Michel, Elena V. Epure, Romain Hennequin, Christophe Cerisara | cs.CL | cs.CL | Humans naturally attribute utterances of direct speech to their speaker in
literary works. When attributing quotes, we process contextual information but
also access mental representations of characters that we build and revise
throughout the narrative. Recent methods to automatically attribute such
utterances have explored simulating human logic with deterministic rules or
learning new implicit rules with neural networks when processing contextual
information. However, these systems inherently lack \textit{character}
representations, which often leads to errors on more challenging examples of
attribution: anaphoric and implicit quotes. In this work, we propose to augment
a popular quotation attribution system, BookNLP, with character embeddings that
encode global information of characters. To build these embeddings, we create
DramaCV, a corpus of English drama plays from the 15th to 20th century focused
on Character Verification (CV), a task similar to Authorship Verification (AV),
that aims at analyzing fictional characters. We train a model similar to the
recently proposed AV model, Universal Authorship Representation (UAR), on this
dataset, showing that it outperforms concurrent methods of characters
embeddings on the CV task and generalizes better to literary novels. Then,
through an extensive evaluation on 22 novels, we show that combining BookNLP's
contextual information with our proposed global character embeddings improves
the identification of speakers for anaphoric and implicit quotes, reaching
state-of-the-art performance. Code and data will be made publicly available. | [
-0.006467204540967941,
-0.26995617151260376,
0.49372127652168274,
-0.04413864389061928,
-0.2818582057952881,
0.08633612096309662,
-0.19199718534946442,
-0.5894079804420471,
0.2310197353363037,
0.7171458601951599,
-0.41747748851776123,
-0.25218087434768677,
-0.19938530027866364,
0.20664836466312408,
-0.034508608281612396,
0.8429446816444397,
0.1134338527917862,
0.07768823951482773,
-0.5655407905578613,
-0.15485098958015442,
-0.46108731627464294,
-0.675220787525177,
-0.6389468312263489,
-0.3081166744232178,
0.7516806721687317,
0.06380221247673035,
0.6568372249603271,
0.5515307188034058,
0.1957974135875702,
0.3333292305469513,
0.07401730120182037,
0.48480165004730225,
-0.13584129512310028,
0.5480154752731323,
-0.3319738805294037,
-0.5153989791870117,
0.03064480610191822,
-0.07778485864400864,
0.8249949812889099,
0.3356249928474426,
-0.14586040377616882,
-0.09900358319282532,
0.14333222806453705,
0.30233100056648254,
-0.669668436050415,
0.5372337102890015,
-0.5177764892578125,
0.22457590699195862,
-0.052330613136291504,
-0.3059695065021515,
-0.5743277072906494,
-0.8054680824279785,
-0.10882389545440674,
-0.7198366522789001,
0.06268837302923203,
0.3067571520805359,
0.7446088194847107,
0.07453785091638565,
-0.4365842044353485,
-0.38169991970062256,
-0.6923717260360718,
0.816133975982666,
-0.5895051956176758,
-0.11022723466157913,
0.36964213848114014,
0.13219919800758362,
0.025398068130016327,
-0.21795658767223358,
-0.4455130398273468,
-0.5627241134643555,
-0.24110792577266693,
0.07993590831756592,
-0.15739303827285767,
0.0007327650091610849,
0.14647650718688965,
0.16322961449623108,
-0.19755186140537262,
-0.110378198325634,
0.10663992911577225,
-0.39567866921424866,
0.6450843811035156,
-0.005849097855389118,
0.3343821167945862,
-0.4175705909729004,
-0.2673133909702301,
-0.367586225271225,
-0.565777063369751,
0.0642809048295021,
0.5551118850708008,
0.2744225859642029,
0.30984336137771606,
0.4843505024909973,
0.3129803538322449,
0.1667940616607666,
-0.0968785360455513,
0.4574032127857208,
0.0678502544760704,
-0.17602957785129547,
0.11641567945480347,
0.4541630744934082,
0.6754525303840637,
0.433767706155777,
0.8029548525810242,
-0.1675044298171997,
0.06662366539239883,
-0.040481869131326675,
0.2875300943851471,
-0.4552723169326782,
-0.1722860485315323,
-0.10046189278364182,
-0.030118586495518684,
-0.3502463698387146,
0.10705895721912384,
-0.3733353316783905,
-0.9603219628334045,
-0.17073270678520203,
0.34932804107666016,
-0.7426167130470276,
-0.04126196727156639,
-0.23384562134742737,
-0.4356853663921356,
0.2373838573694229,
0.44757622480392456,
-0.8674626350402832,
0.15347668528556824,
0.3884655833244324,
0.7543655633926392,
0.09052947163581848,
-0.12036646157503128,
-0.5619412064552307,
0.6785306930541992,
-0.6654810309410095,
0.8477399349212646,
-0.5193105936050415,
-0.03925606235861778,
0.26808568835258484,
-0.06689513474702835,
-0.07390914857387543,
-0.38132402300834656,
0.7019180655479431,
-0.19581817090511322,
0.17121697962284088,
-0.7227028012275696,
-0.6532138586044312,
0.05450660362839699,
0.02502523362636566,
-0.8551562428474426,
0.5846275091171265,
-0.2228696644306183,
-0.5495914816856384,
0.2474282681941986,
-0.6078066229820251,
-0.38191112875938416,
0.12940526008605957,
-0.45582589507102966,
-0.14135703444480896,
0.2307972013950348,
0.49636557698249817,
0.617580771446228,
-0.2914596199989319,
0.007249897345900536,
-0.1348276287317276,
-0.3040519654750824,
0.6364833116531372,
-0.507543683052063,
0.7056941390037537,
0.15431301295757294,
0.018513571470975876,
-0.31455710530281067,
-0.45418810844421387,
-0.0005683072959072888,
0.02136024460196495,
-0.1821964979171753,
-0.6970114707946777,
0.18150071799755096,
0.22376517951488495,
-0.3145030736923218,
0.042972829192876816,
-0.7205908894538879,
0.2902415096759796,
-0.5172842741012573,
0.2758190631866455,
0.7763509750366211,
0.1869555413722992,
0.3388064205646515,
-0.515403687953949,
0.46144744753837585,
-0.4146183133125305,
-0.16685311496257782,
-0.20591334998607635,
-0.4421016573905945,
-0.3156093955039978,
-0.4903605878353119,
0.4030795693397522,
0.7645860314369202,
-0.8500134944915771,
0.6069226264953613,
-0.19986170530319214,
-0.23196148872375488,
-0.3168962001800537,
-0.11395964026451111,
0.5464223623275757,
0.24355199933052063,
0.3086903691291809,
-0.1744237095117569,
-0.5220441818237305,
-0.7327296733856201,
-0.6840804815292358,
-0.6212344169616699,
-0.4367642402648926,
0.36220186948776245,
0.20641344785690308,
0.3586282432079315,
0.9417859315872192,
-0.5279266238212585,
-0.5126926898956299,
-0.2756916582584381,
0.22361551225185394,
-0.12752707302570343,
0.5709201097488403,
0.48143574595451355,
-0.4672597348690033,
-0.461373507976532,
0.1043902263045311,
-0.8670092225074768,
-0.0673586055636406,
-0.29472482204437256,
-0.08232554793357849,
-0.02923319675028324,
0.624744713306427,
-0.4787682592868805,
0.19896769523620605,
0.012106891721487045,
-0.49449673295021057,
0.6117033362388611,
-0.2321256548166275,
0.5923508405685425,
-1.0296082496643066,
-0.005365310702472925,
-0.15919460356235504,
-0.43001317977905273,
-0.19068266451358795,
0.056011512875556946,
0.02688102424144745,
0.014233870431780815,
-0.4060102701187134,
0.5647569298744202,
-0.5970395803451538,
0.25973427295684814,
0.16507142782211304,
0.14093133807182312,
0.21197590231895447,
0.5092465281486511,
-0.06001986563205719,
0.6144335269927979,
0.22984085977077484,
-0.3242987394332886,
0.5985047221183777,
0.3372344672679901,
-0.5977368354797363,
0.7485662698745728,
-0.5393577218055725,
-0.026816530153155327,
-0.1516183316707611,
0.5449755191802979,
-1.186846375465393,
-0.3390505909919739,
0.1589381843805313,
-0.2569398283958435,
0.4065770208835602,
-0.348283588886261,
-0.5930473208427429,
0.07099055498838425,
-0.36059656739234924,
0.3546818196773529,
0.5323458313941956,
-0.4248207211494446,
0.7789002656936646,
0.14344798028469086,
-0.36219990253448486,
-0.6600569486618042,
-0.9173742532730103,
0.29547321796417236,
-0.24595895409584045,
-0.48852595686912537,
0.5474979281425476,
-0.005964140873402357,
-0.12698698043823242,
-0.13968521356582642,
0.03168553486466408,
-0.16929994523525238,
-0.2475263625383377,
-0.0032355908770114183,
0.1198277473449707,
-0.16309083998203278,
0.29806482791900635,
0.21878160536289215,
0.036443646997213364,
0.13883428275585175,
-0.00047300217556767166,
0.09780439734458923,
0.012601938098669052,
-0.26409563422203064,
-0.49620333313941956,
0.5652396082878113,
0.3972605764865875,
-0.027305956929922104,
0.6903985738754272,
0.5093621015548706,
-0.3123556077480316,
-0.3586950898170471,
-0.5338038802146912,
-0.06157032027840614,
-0.46147996187210083,
0.2544030249118805,
-0.09610448777675629,
-0.6397348046302795,
0.7355635166168213,
0.05227178707718849,
-0.11745452880859375,
0.5118798017501831,
0.25379928946495056,
-0.2820768356323242,
0.7558267116546631,
0.3331034481525421,
-0.0696074590086937,
0.656999945640564,
-0.0542173758149147,
-0.21439549326896667,
-0.7454467415809631,
-0.15369251370429993,
-0.5602453351020813,
-0.21001985669136047,
-0.3361611068248749,
-0.577757716178894,
0.19364027678966522,
-0.14938916265964508,
-0.09439320117235184,
0.49658268690109253,
-0.3216746747493744,
0.9692549705505371,
0.36289486289024353,
0.17318184673786163,
0.30645987391471863,
0.23514637351036072,
-0.5963146090507507,
-0.2685053050518036,
-0.46880805492401123,
-0.5252487063407898,
0.9728448987007141,
0.2179630547761917,
0.7418406009674072,
0.44563382863998413,
0.494905561208725,
0.9043903946876526,
0.006332087330520153,
-0.48670148849487305,
0.4814609885215759,
-0.24417121708393097,
-0.7685935497283936,
-0.3263462483882904,
-0.27257341146469116,
-0.7201961278915405,
0.06685271859169006,
-0.15956483781337738,
-0.9787590503692627,
0.6228739023208618,
0.273784875869751,
-0.5904378890991211,
0.25766539573669434,
-0.575274646282196,
0.6594019532203674,
0.22499392926692963,
-0.3331160247325897,
-0.09933219850063324,
-0.5002868175506592,
0.14388267695903778,
0.1290338784456253,
-0.018539538607001305,
0.06014585122466087,
-0.05790916830301285,
0.6820650100708008,
-0.49133774638175964,
0.9282771944999695,
-0.18148481845855713,
-0.317382276058197,
0.4297720491886139,
0.14150768518447876,
0.7217958569526672,
0.0806606337428093,
-0.45902690291404724,
0.04705701395869255,
0.1102207601070404,
-0.16152669489383698,
-0.7134484052658081,
0.6499118208885193,
-0.6915615200996399,
-0.11206488311290741,
-0.7327089905738831,
-0.48480549454689026,
-0.27320587635040283,
-0.34796059131622314,
0.34228038787841797,
0.6077637076377869,
-0.5805506706237793,
0.4874776005744934,
0.6455046534538269,
-0.17680183053016663,
0.44176703691482544,
0.10759585350751877,
0.04958667978644371,
-0.6863150596618652,
0.8219729065895081,
0.04974191263318062,
0.1984819918870926,
0.5441237092018127,
0.18108370900154114,
-0.48735886812210083,
-0.14819218218326569,
-0.30487149953842163,
0.27217406034469604,
-0.996305525302887,
-0.22065021097660065,
-0.4659952223300934,
-0.2982749342918396,
-0.4526323676109314,
-0.2947753071784973,
-0.3441483974456787,
-0.6373841762542725,
-0.3074949383735657,
-0.02014390379190445,
0.4927273690700531,
0.5856742262840271,
-0.1656307727098465,
0.3777316212654114,
-0.37722766399383545,
0.12381646037101746,
0.2699592411518097,
0.12460731714963913,
-0.02326628565788269,
-0.6908509135246277,
-0.4993628263473511,
-0.16734033823013306,
-0.3166831135749817,
-0.8193315863609314,
0.3048592507839203,
0.5739477276802063,
0.45889925956726074,
0.3626917004585266,
0.3186691105365753,
0.5592666268348694,
-0.9234349131584167,
0.8646228313446045,
0.19734017550945282,
-0.9148188829421997,
0.3905352056026459,
-0.44065430760383606,
0.08298473805189133,
0.6471673846244812,
0.22747990489006042,
-0.6404510736465454,
-0.5114331245422363,
-0.47004351019859314,
-0.6551395654678345,
0.7223885655403137,
0.5319823026657104,
0.4222196042537689,
0.09140478074550629,
0.4349900782108307,
0.04942603409290314,
0.2345394790172577,
-0.7143076658248901,
-0.11823316663503647,
-0.12798792123794556,
-0.37538444995880127,
-0.31726130843162537,
-0.1637439876794815,
-0.1378292590379715,
-0.37447720766067505,
0.5295824408531189,
-0.10242872685194016,
0.47763386368751526,
0.39612239599227905,
-0.19576416909694672,
-0.004405390005558729,
0.20988436043262482,
0.3991909325122833,
0.30426767468452454,
-0.34956347942352295,
-0.0807005912065506,
-0.09398989379405975,
-0.38274481892585754,
0.12977181375026703,
0.1333046704530716,
0.03317909315228462,
0.13885945081710815,
0.7114343643188477,
0.560772180557251,
0.13269102573394775,
-0.3419874608516693,
0.5882410407066345,
-0.08565449714660645,
-0.07774536311626434,
-0.6650456190109253,
0.30356934666633606,
-0.04442055523395538,
0.5697551369667053,
0.5824599266052246,
0.19670109450817108,
0.0780479907989502,
-0.6822917461395264,
0.27513620257377625,
0.3797397315502167,
-0.42738884687423706,
-0.04583776742219925,
0.5361563563346863,
0.25717881321907043,
-0.32036301493644714,
0.3455556631088257,
-0.03994154930114746,
-0.41166576743125916,
0.47551804780960083,
0.46165400743484497,
1.098839282989502,
-0.35689422488212585,
0.4836525022983551,
0.1463567465543747,
0.4032697081565857,
0.013061005622148514,
0.006442983169108629,
-0.10147328674793243,
-0.7174074053764343,
-0.460578054189682,
-0.5414134860038757,
-0.663059413433075,
-0.13896237313747406,
-0.3321102261543274,
0.14741520583629608,
-0.5912849307060242,
0.01430562511086464,
-0.1838119775056839,
-0.04306507483124733,
-0.509060800075531,
0.002057106699794531,
0.4568118751049042,
0.2524842321872711,
-0.939956545829773,
0.6854656934738159,
0.5083420872688293,
-0.6586861610412598,
-0.5196411609649658,
0.1432344913482666,
-0.08656957745552063,
-0.5450260639190674,
0.4516299068927765,
0.10768833756446838,
0.01625135913491249,
0.12872150540351868,
-0.6592153310775757,
-0.7725339531898499,
1.0875221490859985,
0.9201437830924988,
-0.2879645526409149,
-0.2935136556625366,
0.03539939224720001,
0.42686927318573,
-0.7757806777954102,
0.6153581738471985,
0.02270546182990074,
0.36487650871276855,
0.20233525335788727,
-0.570843517780304,
0.20292989909648895,
-0.22057783603668213,
0.06727863103151321,
-0.24254944920539856,
-0.22592709958553314,
0.6331186294555664,
0.08277478069067001,
-0.04039672762155533,
0.29322147369384766,
0.8720782995223999,
0.2108704298734665,
0.0163290835916996,
0.5336695909500122,
0.024985715746879578,
0.9898021221160889,
-0.03285153955221176,
1.2521473169326782,
0.2502458095550537,
0.11592243611812592,
1.1509768962860107,
-0.13597118854522705,
0.805681049823761,
0.34584611654281616,
-0.15357822179794312,
1.0968211889266968,
0.3290099501609802,
-0.13795140385627747,
0.5080345273017883,
0.3965695798397064,
-0.4473940432071686,
-0.40228819847106934,
-0.3576243817806244,
-0.30027154088020325,
0.2820841670036316,
0.24327951669692993,
-0.5740616917610168,
0.028711747378110886,
0.17029224336147308,
0.011349307373166084,
0.3354177176952362,
-0.06667086482048035,
0.6480005383491516,
0.18126949667930603,
-0.4348021149635315,
0.43822675943374634,
-0.06597228348255157,
0.4999057948589325,
-0.9148941040039062,
-0.22517086565494537,
-0.11899855732917786,
0.3368838131427765,
-0.013591339811682701,
-0.4450337588787079,
0.010580378584563732,
-0.006811405066400766,
-0.26751598715782166,
-0.26313117146492004,
0.659054160118103,
-0.6114185452461243,
-0.7204086184501648,
0.10515341907739639,
-0.024204133078455925,
0.37582460045814514,
-0.35240280628204346,
-0.586131751537323,
-0.11942395567893982,
0.05263163149356842,
-0.2101021409034729,
-0.023055247962474823,
0.6678997278213501,
0.06676953285932541,
0.4847137928009033,
0.5117563605308533,
0.32468360662460327,
-0.2550681531429291,
0.23526325821876526,
0.5856932401657104,
-0.7173410058021545,
-0.5653112530708313,
-0.8119133710861206,
0.7534151077270508,
-0.4639272391796112,
-0.31472498178482056,
0.7645931243896484,
0.20631933212280273,
0.3999076187610626,
-0.22763799130916595,
0.8750036954879761,
0.05177467316389084,
0.25114721059799194,
-0.6343740224838257,
1.0258287191390991,
-0.5843908190727234,
0.39305657148361206,
-0.6672776937484741,
-1.0913360118865967,
-0.26291170716285706,
0.8100038766860962,
-0.010578153654932976,
0.01736912503838539,
0.8424787521362305,
0.6588499546051025,
0.01882537454366684,
0.04108787700533867,
0.5082454681396484,
0.12897507846355438,
0.3659748136997223,
0.34865638613700867,
0.8122289776802063,
-0.7052550911903381,
0.5531263947486877,
0.17095331847667694,
-0.12568944692611694,
-0.30005303025245667,
-1.319615125656128,
-0.8364087343215942,
-0.5276050567626953,
-0.646160364151001,
-0.26659101247787476,
0.3384055197238922,
1.0386513471603394,
0.3233698904514313,
-0.7811731100082397,
-0.2917596101760864,
0.002645897213369608,
0.06776272505521774,
-0.46631574630737305,
-0.20359869301319122,
0.3368097245693207,
-0.30405598878860474,
-0.6238448619842529,
0.5152191519737244,
-0.13100787997245789,
-0.2335200011730194,
-0.2636707127094269,
-0.0914771556854248,
-0.4110044240951538,
0.6086058616638184,
0.3935590386390686,
0.2599133551120758,
-0.746408224105835,
-0.5482881665229797,
-0.410386860370636,
0.05790690705180168,
-0.03389906510710716,
0.8399009108543396,
-0.6442050337791443,
0.44111526012420654,
0.222110778093338,
0.5829170346260071,
0.1484677642583847,
0.15890400111675262,
1.0175578594207764,
-1.1520133018493652,
-0.17849227786064148,
0.35303398966789246,
0.39638233184814453,
0.5616294145584106,
-0.6175105571746826,
0.30215996503829956,
0.3961228132247925,
-0.6430297493934631,
-0.7515604496002197,
0.14754608273506165,
-0.9275414347648621,
-0.215443417429924,
1.0949987173080444,
-0.3133123219013214,
-0.29485759139060974,
-0.14921602606773376,
-0.2089400291442871,
0.34019991755485535,
-0.7017431855201721,
0.34473416209220886,
1.0709282159805298,
0.03967796266078949,
0.12578776478767395,
-0.28700774908065796,
0.7191905379295349,
0.5582727789878845,
-0.4853588342666626,
0.5886577367782593,
0.7253984808921814,
-0.06111307442188263,
0.37910565733909607,
0.3787569999694824,
-0.00969913974404335,
0.09194441884756088,
0.0017714399145916104,
0.43303242325782776,
-0.11686360090970993,
-0.4144969880580902,
-0.1524105817079544,
0.20223943889141083,
-0.1742600053548813,
-0.03546442091464996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16937v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16937v1 | A Complete Survey on LLM-based AI Chatbots | 2024-06-17T09:39:34 | 2024-06-17T09:39:34 | Sumit Kumar Dam, Choong Seon Hong, Yu Qiao, Chaoning Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The past few decades have witnessed an upsurge in data, forming the
foundation for data-hungry, learning-based AI technology. Conversational
agents, often referred to as AI chatbots, rely heavily on such data to train
large language models (LLMs) and generate new content (knowledge) in response
to user prompts. With the advent of OpenAI's ChatGPT, LLM-based chatbots have
set new standards in the AI community. This paper presents a complete survey of
the evolution and deployment of LLM-based chatbots in various sectors. We first
summarize the development of foundational chatbots, followed by the evolution
of LLMs, and then provide an overview of LLM-based chatbots currently in use
and those in the development phase. Recognizing AI chatbots as tools for
generating new knowledge, we explore their diverse applications across various
industries. We then discuss the open challenges, considering how the data used
to train the LLMs and the misuse of the generated knowledge can cause several
issues. Finally, we explore the future outlook to augment their efficiency and
reliability in numerous applications. By addressing key milestones and the
present-day context of LLM-based chatbots, our survey invites readers to delve
deeper into this realm, reflecting on how their next generation will reshape
conversational AI. | [
-0.1753765344619751,
-0.9403278827667236,
0.41411906480789185,
-0.08562123775482178,
0.376129686832428,
0.3745243549346924,
-0.18829955160617828,
-0.497550368309021,
0.10727106034755707,
0.7165612578392029,
-0.5456525683403015,
-0.3591909408569336,
-0.560123085975647,
-0.2139272540807724,
-0.46333467960357666,
0.8343145251274109,
0.2696008086204529,
-0.1808706820011139,
-0.6627144813537598,
-0.04546348378062248,
-0.4685207009315491,
-0.6712993383407593,
-0.6771600842475891,
-0.6289147138595581,
0.38523396849632263,
0.46960145235061646,
0.7305815815925598,
0.3201259672641754,
0.4079355299472809,
0.3680119514465332,
-0.20186083018779755,
0.28681519627571106,
-0.6946392059326172,
0.3010208010673523,
0.33910754323005676,
-0.9233105778694153,
-0.35720452666282654,
0.058163195848464966,
0.3760111927986145,
0.5398374199867249,
-0.1847882866859436,
-0.02529974840581417,
-0.041683629155159,
0.43739116191864014,
-0.2840290069580078,
0.4178861975669861,
-1.0014564990997314,
0.02018403634428978,
-0.04808128625154495,
-0.28685760498046875,
-0.31648218631744385,
-0.3441949188709259,
0.123182512819767,
-0.36283251643180847,
-0.09757993370294571,
-0.010576832108199596,
0.4941558837890625,
0.3944961130619049,
-0.5230872631072998,
-0.5564037561416626,
-1.062467098236084,
0.7663148641586304,
-0.5062205195426941,
0.30975964665412903,
0.116617351770401,
0.6120686531066895,
-0.4737348258495331,
-0.7041433453559875,
-0.3931240141391754,
-0.5123082995414734,
0.24086785316467285,
0.16853678226470947,
-0.15053246915340424,
-0.14034658670425415,
-0.10142342001199722,
0.4060802459716797,
-0.3289107084274292,
0.42930182814598083,
-0.3223632574081421,
-0.05391187220811844,
0.6316452622413635,
0.30029019713401794,
0.49048882722854614,
0.33566567301750183,
-0.2984982430934906,
-0.09458962827920914,
-0.995141327381134,
-0.2005561888217926,
0.27064603567123413,
-0.009648597799241543,
-0.2422274649143219,
0.6856591105461121,
-0.20898117125034332,
0.5298624634742737,
-0.27458152174949646,
-0.24018897116184235,
0.177865669131279,
-0.2825254201889038,
-0.21279023587703705,
-0.0448235459625721,
0.9173601865768433,
0.23140132427215576,
0.3996904790401459,
-0.10765553265810013,
-0.026285886764526367,
-0.28045979142189026,
0.19787734746932983,
-0.3491165041923523,
-0.0012403851142153144,
0.19294357299804688,
-0.11092408746480942,
-0.5020610094070435,
-0.46907874941825867,
-0.42170456051826477,
-0.7728233933448792,
-0.03774150833487511,
-0.11201693117618561,
-0.17226417362689972,
-0.1951119601726532,
-0.16997838020324707,
-0.024789493530988693,
0.7941544055938721,
0.6001664400100708,
-0.8242308497428894,
-0.06288167834281921,
0.7323982119560242,
0.7135826349258423,
0.016307080164551735,
-0.2058124542236328,
0.05729524418711662,
-0.07069455087184906,
-0.4268561005592346,
0.9214824438095093,
-0.44061508774757385,
-0.4636973738670349,
0.3556031584739685,
-0.3185250461101532,
0.02916504070162773,
-0.7152193784713745,
0.10655887424945831,
-0.5210379362106323,
0.32732608914375305,
0.29175737500190735,
-0.5807350277900696,
-0.1486271619796753,
0.8013913631439209,
-0.3735579252243042,
0.701720654964447,
-0.023582730442285538,
-0.3589361906051636,
0.14653445780277252,
-0.7665305137634277,
-0.321988582611084,
0.26082319021224976,
-0.33409592509269714,
-0.21569915115833282,
-0.23732048273086548,
0.2662108242511749,
0.5081389546394348,
-0.6262428760528564,
0.06967436522245407,
-0.18553698062896729,
-0.26954054832458496,
0.6473171710968018,
-0.7144033908843994,
0.6909418106079102,
0.1882689893245697,
0.010000730864703655,
0.11221426725387573,
-0.4119075834751129,
-0.05839087814092636,
0.06905407458543777,
-0.2142511010169983,
0.23698203265666962,
0.34084826707839966,
-0.30234211683273315,
0.09966554492712021,
0.469601035118103,
-0.46454304456710815,
0.15918153524398804,
-0.41773492097854614,
0.6498561501502991,
0.6673372983932495,
0.12766386568546295,
0.35477814078330994,
-0.5530354380607605,
0.6018028259277344,
-0.0460384376347065,
0.3468984365463257,
-0.4355825185775757,
-0.6460882425308228,
-0.9134883284568787,
0.007028179708868265,
-0.09276281297206879,
0.7014221549034119,
-0.6186971664428711,
0.47116169333457947,
-0.3706318438053131,
-0.8694494962692261,
-0.546022355556488,
0.09859195351600647,
-0.10241702198982239,
0.31198540329933167,
-0.011355102062225342,
0.1110057532787323,
-0.1955554336309433,
-0.60887610912323,
0.0608149915933609,
-0.5803580284118652,
-0.060753434896469116,
0.6910923719406128,
0.14442229270935059,
-0.5046514868736267,
0.8588849902153015,
-0.35032472014427185,
-0.17928995192050934,
-0.6949053406715393,
-0.2887697219848633,
0.019979186356067657,
0.20390133559703827,
0.25730302929878235,
-0.6200775504112244,
-0.37924376130104065,
0.19453369081020355,
-0.8372352719306946,
0.07323919981718063,
-0.32654476165771484,
0.004821820184588432,
0.1644829660654068,
0.5659012794494629,
-0.7090247869491577,
0.17769938707351685,
0.5459179282188416,
0.19235172867774963,
0.23153945803642273,
0.033778849989175797,
-0.07830542325973511,
-1.049375057220459,
-0.018474334850907326,
-0.2507088780403137,
-0.15967917442321777,
-0.5926505923271179,
-0.22327327728271484,
-0.4106696546077728,
-0.13959449529647827,
-0.6118744611740112,
0.7458046674728394,
-0.3607501983642578,
-0.047865208238363266,
-0.3119688630104065,
0.41660308837890625,
-0.5862604975700378,
0.43329742550849915,
-0.09622174501419067,
0.6512040495872498,
0.5720381140708923,
-0.5931413769721985,
0.6424520015716553,
0.5308820605278015,
-0.1641717404127121,
0.3636862635612488,
-0.6165035963058472,
0.4068724811077118,
-0.009998457506299019,
0.2508232891559601,
-0.8777652382850647,
-0.16871047019958496,
0.5024402737617493,
-0.6919159889221191,
-0.10946425795555115,
-0.16900348663330078,
-0.5649699568748474,
-0.2079734057188034,
-0.06734412908554077,
0.04475020617246628,
0.8422285318374634,
-0.35476988554000854,
0.382708877325058,
0.5292584896087646,
-0.2137596756219864,
-0.5811062455177307,
-0.664337694644928,
0.36699214577674866,
-0.13184812664985657,
-0.6302053332328796,
-0.16385328769683838,
-0.1433788686990738,
-0.3772508203983307,
-0.27429166436195374,
0.04100453108549118,
-0.06937936693429947,
0.27142804861068726,
0.3641315698623657,
0.09269791841506958,
-0.12094110995531082,
-0.06195561960339546,
-0.33235740661621094,
-0.02845725417137146,
0.10996932536363602,
-0.07973086833953857,
0.9266126155853271,
-0.012398068793118,
-0.7103107571601868,
-0.3910776674747467,
-0.1085851863026619,
0.4747302830219269,
-0.026789885014295578,
0.5612232089042664,
0.3883230984210968,
0.05417386814951897,
-0.06874097138643265,
-0.6342117190361023,
-0.06442319601774216,
-0.4773003160953522,
0.40994834899902344,
0.10952194780111313,
-1.1732040643692017,
0.4526959955692291,
-0.18512412905693054,
0.49226850271224976,
0.3254018723964691,
0.8446978330612183,
-0.2101639360189438,
0.6734626889228821,
0.71893709897995,
-0.35487717390060425,
0.6916054487228394,
-0.08361780643463135,
0.23380731046199799,
-0.406851589679718,
-0.46077024936676025,
-0.4337969422340393,
-0.2703917622566223,
-0.675423264503479,
-0.33823055028915405,
0.3063845634460449,
-0.4322073459625244,
-0.1312689483165741,
0.046247031539678574,
-0.16176994144916534,
0.4299675226211548,
0.6190983653068542,
-0.05534897744655609,
0.3316534459590912,
-0.2013290971517563,
0.6279146671295166,
0.47551652789115906,
-0.6324993968009949,
-0.6237258315086365,
1.2674790620803833,
0.3968031704425812,
0.692071259021759,
-0.0520937442779541,
0.4973074197769165,
0.5196039080619812,
0.34817957878112793,
-0.9205292463302612,
0.5907320380210876,
0.2908303439617157,
-0.5327810049057007,
-0.3791431486606598,
-0.47941428422927856,
-1.0383071899414062,
-0.1479446142911911,
0.07834883779287338,
-0.4080252945423126,
-0.45429345965385437,
0.005152675788849592,
0.0392584390938282,
0.26017290353775024,
-0.4197542369365692,
0.5738896727561951,
-0.5017379522323608,
0.24334076046943665,
-0.28062719106674194,
-0.6865084171295166,
0.36693865060806274,
0.0339682437479496,
-0.07259511947631836,
-0.34401050209999084,
-0.024886181578040123,
0.4652763307094574,
-0.41698312759399414,
0.9116790294647217,
-0.07793092727661133,
-0.3624532222747803,
0.7713954448699951,
-0.24063734710216522,
0.3613516688346863,
-0.08575375378131866,
0.16306361556053162,
0.38177451491355896,
-0.2436334639787674,
-0.30216869711875916,
-0.6186744570732117,
0.37001895904541016,
-0.9062539339065552,
-0.5633362531661987,
-0.255628377199173,
-0.4603063464164734,
-0.38552504777908325,
-0.0042181117460131645,
-0.05233880132436752,
0.14847582578659058,
-0.5784009695053101,
0.29332873225212097,
0.5153224468231201,
-0.43562760949134827,
0.36502906680107117,
0.47606056928634644,
-0.17200250923633575,
-0.22688864171504974,
0.8581952452659607,
-0.17481642961502075,
0.28232714533805847,
0.5759416222572327,
-0.08871156722307205,
-0.1839531809091568,
-0.6319369673728943,
-0.40113574266433716,
0.07217057794332504,
-0.4599497318267822,
-0.13640165328979492,
-0.4465515613555908,
-0.6323052048683167,
-0.3984861969947815,
-0.13623212277889252,
-0.4055105149745941,
-0.0791693702340126,
-0.28424501419067383,
0.12530596554279327,
0.5206891298294067,
0.882459282875061,
0.34069380164146423,
0.621197521686554,
-0.6991547346115112,
-0.025943469256162643,
0.42404478788375854,
0.17601299285888672,
-0.07070878893136978,
-0.24761101603507996,
-0.11460594832897186,
0.3640916049480438,
-0.38235726952552795,
-0.4745156466960907,
0.1820397526025772,
0.17522530257701874,
0.7264368534088135,
0.3987230956554413,
-0.07243464887142181,
0.20374521613121033,
-0.194343701004982,
1.111435890197754,
0.06758318096399307,
-0.26260313391685486,
0.45369017124176025,
-0.396786093711853,
0.10120964050292969,
0.24237266182899475,
0.18556465208530426,
-1.021658182144165,
-0.42416951060295105,
-0.4968160390853882,
-0.6173627376556396,
0.6963369250297546,
0.22083988785743713,
0.5974308252334595,
0.18551896512508392,
0.24314086139202118,
0.15452435612678528,
0.3182879388332367,
-0.4363926351070404,
-0.3149239718914032,
0.06181110814213753,
-0.33009785413742065,
-0.1104261726140976,
0.04324745014309883,
-0.0609331876039505,
0.26770487427711487,
0.5298014283180237,
-0.07823718339204788,
0.5528164505958557,
-0.3516177535057068,
-0.29043301939964294,
0.41621068120002747,
0.3907283842563629,
0.4051625728607178,
0.4803719222545624,
0.040570180863142014,
-0.27769219875335693,
0.06327788531780243,
-0.346242219209671,
0.1648741513490677,
-0.19098255038261414,
-0.13513308763504028,
-0.33751246333122253,
0.2700962424278259,
0.662781834602356,
-0.05574595555663109,
-1.081178069114685,
0.5399608612060547,
-0.03214476257562637,
-0.1956503838300705,
-0.7524455189704895,
0.4644131362438202,
0.08775002509355545,
0.4721467196941376,
0.13930034637451172,
-0.016381334513425827,
-0.35913029313087463,
-0.7267848253250122,
0.08846577256917953,
0.5808444023132324,
-0.5146076083183289,
-0.16824932396411896,
0.4562387466430664,
0.44912686944007874,
-0.44024017453193665,
0.9451268315315247,
-0.02200062945485115,
-0.2510572671890259,
0.5710614323616028,
0.29797011613845825,
0.8781219720840454,
0.20474392175674438,
0.17820867896080017,
-0.3119126558303833,
0.1447955071926117,
0.1494700014591217,
0.17513792216777802,
-0.24583128094673157,
-1.094817876815796,
-0.08126352727413177,
-0.2619306743144989,
-0.9490314722061157,
0.18730564415454865,
0.034930165857076645,
0.16728125512599945,
-0.5574169158935547,
0.020813941955566406,
-0.3691205084323883,
-0.06773093342781067,
-0.7451559901237488,
-0.10868251323699951,
0.36307990550994873,
0.6946544647216797,
-0.34623005986213684,
0.583892285823822,
0.7586384415626526,
-0.4006032645702362,
-0.13931769132614136,
-0.07272627204656601,
0.07327982038259506,
-1.3629021644592285,
0.2544957995414734,
0.022019408643245697,
-0.01713733747601509,
0.0072072818875312805,
-0.8819178342819214,
-0.6227551698684692,
1.1119084358215332,
0.14525559544563293,
-0.3723679780960083,
-0.10590983182191849,
0.7241511344909668,
0.6815547943115234,
-0.24703186750411987,
0.5821581482887268,
0.5604883432388306,
0.19690389931201935,
0.26143011450767517,
-0.7986223697662354,
-0.5090464353561401,
-0.2714413106441498,
-0.15972347557544708,
-0.045698922127485275,
-0.9528611302375793,
0.44720059633255005,
0.04419559985399246,
-0.09884258359670639,
0.24345843493938446,
0.6558474898338318,
0.0946056991815567,
0.46414172649383545,
0.3045540452003479,
0.17147986590862274,
0.6440186500549316,
-0.10235986858606339,
0.5609854459762573,
-0.3928986191749573,
-0.058149032294750214,
0.8217174410820007,
-0.3577597439289093,
0.6200460195541382,
0.05470628663897514,
-0.23470070958137512,
0.36708274483680725,
0.5462989807128906,
-0.30261778831481934,
0.03885367512702942,
0.3476610481739044,
-0.25175532698631287,
-0.07415372878313065,
-0.2793150246143341,
-0.1467917263507843,
0.7438970804214478,
0.48445284366607666,
-0.17318478226661682,
-0.10278955847024918,
-0.03377819433808327,
0.24504663050174713,
-0.29789769649505615,
-0.2312234491109848,
1.1091938018798828,
-0.006514617707580328,
-0.5365791320800781,
0.33814942836761475,
-0.21012276411056519,
0.7929172515869141,
-0.661481499671936,
0.049900736659765244,
-0.49337634444236755,
0.07402516901493073,
0.12606440484523773,
-0.9527297616004944,
0.038935646414756775,
0.21176861226558685,
0.12099499255418777,
-0.3322824239730835,
0.8510704040527344,
-0.28353187441825867,
-0.08118386566638947,
-0.0269740279763937,
1.0477657318115234,
0.5764128565788269,
-0.23301932215690613,
-0.5213896036148071,
-0.08517298102378845,
-0.013567253947257996,
-0.013377290219068527,
0.2732481062412262,
0.38454145193099976,
0.10036386549472809,
1.0820056200027466,
0.435079962015152,
-0.003897987073287368,
0.18322964012622833,
0.0028746058233082294,
0.7674370408058167,
-0.7716214060783386,
-0.118232861161232,
-0.6927022933959961,
0.33587411046028137,
-0.031909290701150894,
-0.3421979546546936,
0.7196738719940186,
0.4178093373775482,
0.7519488334655762,
0.23639017343521118,
1.0843297243118286,
-0.07051992416381836,
0.4367038905620575,
-0.3489231467247009,
1.0125622749328613,
-0.4214740991592407,
0.20021411776542664,
0.13086210191249847,
-0.7457260489463806,
-0.0007198807434178889,
-0.025105929002165794,
-0.16667674481868744,
0.2762382924556732,
0.036679707467556,
0.7283715605735779,
0.27241504192352295,
0.22291481494903564,
0.42049118876457214,
0.1435224562883377,
0.5874865055084229,
0.4643133878707886,
1.3223673105239868,
-0.19234183430671692,
0.8202468752861023,
0.10296573489904404,
0.026848265901207924,
-0.4557497203350067,
-0.3369919955730438,
-0.812696635723114,
-0.492098867893219,
-0.34744784235954285,
0.13074715435504913,
0.10816695541143417,
0.7904085516929626,
0.47755298018455505,
-0.5146817564964294,
-0.337280809879303,
-0.15626651048660278,
0.2736925482749939,
0.05631648376584053,
-0.17912700772285461,
-0.1657111942768097,
-0.5519511699676514,
-0.8345276117324829,
0.6248998045921326,
0.05571945384144783,
0.2859008312225342,
-0.46869605779647827,
-0.049563176929950714,
0.08775592595338821,
0.07120942324399948,
0.666854202747345,
0.5556796193122864,
-0.4859548807144165,
-0.1409091055393219,
0.0823291763663292,
-0.13180328905582428,
0.30532902479171753,
0.6504613161087036,
-0.7742499709129333,
0.13334134221076965,
0.42434248328208923,
0.8527198433876038,
0.3215572237968445,
-0.16203585267066956,
0.6664006114006042,
-0.655724823474884,
-0.030186573043465614,
0.34555336833000183,
0.023463111370801926,
0.45478320121765137,
-0.07231111079454422,
0.5697771906852722,
0.23017920553684235,
-0.773461639881134,
-0.6904421448707581,
0.1433945596218109,
-0.8207305073738098,
-0.06348119676113129,
1.0418533086776733,
0.12007071822881699,
-0.0005326429381966591,
-0.12198720127344131,
-0.1624656617641449,
0.2620186507701874,
-0.5044800639152527,
0.6364910006523132,
0.5299367308616638,
-0.44696134328842163,
-0.25784584879875183,
-0.4773072600364685,
0.361225426197052,
0.11236867308616638,
-1.09233558177948,
0.18024687469005585,
0.5802969336509705,
0.09416573494672775,
-0.09005522727966309,
0.7209876179695129,
-0.00008656428690301254,
-0.1284974068403244,
0.15208907425403595,
0.16043606400489807,
0.0688386783003807,
-0.34830576181411743,
-0.16651961207389832,
0.038457389920949936,
0.26352062821388245,
-0.1899005025625229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11357v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11357v2 | Refiner: Restructure Retrieval Content Efficiently to Advance Question-Answering Capabilities | 2024-06-17T09:25:10 | 2024-06-18T02:44:27 | Zhonghao Li, Xuming Hu, Aiwei Liu, Kening Zheng, Sirui Huang, Hui Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are limited by their parametric knowledge,
leading to hallucinations in knowledge-extensive tasks. To address this,
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) incorporates external document chunks to
expand LLM knowledge. Furthermore, compressing information from document chunks
through extraction or summarization can improve LLM performance. Nonetheless,
LLMs still struggle to notice and utilize scattered key information, a problem
known as the "lost-in-the-middle" syndrome. Therefore, we typically need to
restructure the content for LLM to recognize the key information. We propose
$\textit{Refiner}$, an end-to-end extract-and-restructure paradigm that
operates in the post-retrieval process of RAG. $\textit{Refiner}$ leverages a
single decoder-only LLM to adaptively extract query-relevant contents verbatim
along with the necessary context, and section them based on their
interconnectedness, thereby highlights information distinction, and aligns
downstream LLMs with the original context effectively. Experiments show that a
trained $\textit{Refiner}$ (with 7B parameters) exhibits significant gain to
downstream LLM in improving answer accuracy, and outperforms other
state-of-the-art advanced RAG and concurrent compressing approaches in various
single-hop and multi-hop QA tasks. Notably, $\textit{Refiner}$ achieves a 80.5%
tokens reduction and a 1.6-7.0% improvement margin in multi-hop tasks compared
to the next best solution. $\textit{Refiner}$ is a plug-and-play solution that
can be seamlessly integrated with RAG systems, facilitating its application
across diverse open-source frameworks. | [
-0.47016820311546326,
-0.5624714493751526,
0.6312998533248901,
-0.23063693940639496,
-0.25576239824295044,
0.3254013657569885,
-0.3261210322380066,
-0.2792277932167053,
0.4398730993270874,
0.6638665795326233,
-0.5221264362335205,
-0.025103986263275146,
-0.3636479377746582,
0.2088046669960022,
-0.6127244234085083,
1.0130938291549683,
-0.014900533482432365,
-0.20915549993515015,
-0.4199655055999756,
-0.0718470886349678,
-0.6144922375679016,
-0.2784952223300934,
-0.8532423973083496,
-0.20429088175296783,
0.8170196413993835,
0.5569576025009155,
0.3087950050830841,
0.28514695167541504,
0.35265541076660156,
0.35891085863113403,
-0.12291508167982101,
0.38328951597213745,
-0.9144319295883179,
0.7600545287132263,
-0.5255457758903503,
-0.5733796954154968,
-0.01965561881661415,
-0.29926323890686035,
0.5585783123970032,
0.33847618103027344,
-0.49691811203956604,
0.5139488577842712,
-0.16530421376228333,
0.8290726542472839,
-0.782919704914093,
-0.23704327642917633,
-0.9227285385131836,
-0.43312883377075195,
-0.16058318316936493,
-0.40997523069381714,
-0.522261381149292,
-0.29986515641212463,
-0.1481744796037674,
-0.6322454214096069,
0.4586992561817169,
0.2769084870815277,
1.044393539428711,
0.5638097524642944,
-0.2809467613697052,
-0.0020591402426362038,
-0.7904662489891052,
0.6945930123329163,
-0.6108397841453552,
0.6913855075836182,
-0.058133434504270554,
0.6089456081390381,
-0.2909124791622162,
-1.2502379417419434,
-0.6056941151618958,
0.46608301997184753,
-0.17538240551948547,
0.32170283794403076,
0.030340738594532013,
-0.24723529815673828,
0.09538029134273529,
0.6180371046066284,
-0.5110486149787903,
-0.1992207020521164,
-0.6311131715774536,
-0.012475099414587021,
0.39031070470809937,
0.0827142521739006,
0.07514320313930511,
-0.053100381046533585,
-0.30466893315315247,
-0.0024035039823502302,
-0.5405241250991821,
-0.01616159826517105,
0.11193133890628815,
0.20509620010852814,
0.587891697883606,
0.43282610177993774,
-0.38724514842033386,
0.5022826790809631,
0.2184128612279892,
0.028034040704369545,
0.12011980265378952,
-0.18735256791114807,
-0.47860854864120483,
-0.22789768874645233,
0.34242311120033264,
0.09181410819292068,
-0.010895177721977234,
-0.22158190608024597,
-0.4070333242416382,
-0.5247491598129272,
0.7625246644020081,
-0.9482362866401672,
-0.02419891580939293,
0.27051544189453125,
-0.47681674361228943,
-0.08659769594669342,
0.0662575289607048,
-0.7484427094459534,
-0.23515459895133972,
-0.42759549617767334,
0.29491981863975525,
-0.184269517660141,
-0.3998733162879944,
0.14871853590011597,
-0.4769931137561798,
0.5110352039337158,
0.47937050461769104,
-0.6134335398674011,
0.29540225863456726,
0.7830683588981628,
0.5924598574638367,
0.07624568045139313,
0.04211127758026123,
-0.8086465001106262,
0.2619669437408447,
-0.024851249530911446,
1.163172721862793,
-0.6462684273719788,
-0.2986508309841156,
-0.04271550849080086,
0.19532249867916107,
0.024554088711738586,
-0.7581110596656799,
0.6782269477844238,
-1.1761395931243896,
0.4566969573497772,
-0.3400365114212036,
-0.3985039293766022,
-0.466019868850708,
0.4239633083343506,
-0.7487928867340088,
1.1888197660446167,
0.38600894808769226,
-0.7242857217788696,
0.09394345432519913,
-0.24818286299705505,
-0.13874231278896332,
0.06069320812821388,
-0.06495986878871918,
-0.26610180735588074,
0.5521434545516968,
0.12825517356395721,
-0.03787636011838913,
-0.5897735357284546,
0.30065062642097473,
-0.02283387817442417,
-0.5548036694526672,
0.17735044658184052,
-0.23564954102039337,
0.3385600447654724,
0.2604825496673584,
0.15582047402858734,
0.2807708978652954,
-0.5405250787734985,
0.2534249722957611,
-0.03717833012342453,
-0.6485293507575989,
-0.20976760983467102,
-0.11953233182430267,
0.14618153870105743,
0.14768745005130768,
0.4290955364704132,
-0.4757826626300812,
0.19901207089424133,
-0.36892619729042053,
0.13704688847064972,
0.8278000354766846,
0.2120305746793747,
0.2970122992992401,
-0.578303337097168,
0.6767955422401428,
-0.4295322895050049,
0.1194862350821495,
-0.26271864771842957,
-0.14395101368427277,
-1.0304051637649536,
-0.21450386941432953,
0.3582542836666107,
0.513763427734375,
-0.7527996301651001,
0.028370842337608337,
-0.4609861671924591,
-0.45993754267692566,
-0.6934216618537903,
0.17834684252738953,
0.325498104095459,
0.588096559047699,
0.48079878091812134,
-0.24289655685424805,
-0.7253358960151672,
-0.8604499101638794,
-0.4236243963241577,
-0.04678994417190552,
-0.21753166615962982,
0.1476007103919983,
0.15629559755325317,
-0.16436950862407684,
0.8609961271286011,
-0.7219892740249634,
-0.08429113030433655,
-0.23939314484596252,
0.022739339619874954,
0.37557512521743774,
0.19302284717559814,
-0.006186650134623051,
-0.8897061944007874,
-0.5166113972663879,
-0.14239758253097534,
-0.3645882308483124,
-0.2697915732860565,
0.021984519436955452,
-0.41964712738990784,
0.1172490045428276,
0.7447260618209839,
-0.49489039182662964,
0.24148766696453094,
0.17607229948043823,
-0.2514685094356537,
0.5985475778579712,
-0.18894247710704803,
0.1297893077135086,
-1.1185609102249146,
0.2993912696838379,
-0.5542334318161011,
-0.23833176493644714,
-0.595977246761322,
0.36366933584213257,
-0.09453699737787247,
-0.055532656610012054,
-0.20546427369117737,
0.6002675294876099,
-0.4185042977333069,
-0.19566552340984344,
-0.5626171827316284,
0.2459009736776352,
0.3982434868812561,
0.534148633480072,
0.034213270992040634,
0.7562505006790161,
-0.0982249528169632,
-0.2957850396633148,
0.2463679015636444,
0.20118501782417297,
-0.16170938313007355,
0.49597814679145813,
-0.6214331984519958,
0.3287474811077118,
-0.5551100969314575,
0.31561899185180664,
-1.3321996927261353,
-0.1624174565076828,
-0.14807257056236267,
-0.5635777711868286,
0.5190221071243286,
-0.21712462604045868,
-0.4050026834011078,
-0.034068018198013306,
-0.3777259588241577,
0.42121392488479614,
0.649736225605011,
-0.49147549271583557,
0.8771279454231262,
0.08343574404716492,
-0.3725470006465912,
-0.6051462292671204,
-0.34741994738578796,
-0.09026877582073212,
-0.12295948714017868,
-0.5471470952033997,
0.29966169595718384,
-0.11033755540847778,
0.03135623782873154,
-0.019009947776794434,
-0.43215829133987427,
-0.07050742208957672,
-0.005358065478503704,
0.09989453107118607,
0.2439480721950531,
-0.11770729720592499,
0.31464672088623047,
0.11619178205728531,
-0.26776137948036194,
-0.08873730152845383,
-0.21674145758152008,
0.6935023069381714,
0.1187460869550705,
-0.24971581995487213,
0.1222066804766655,
0.44457128643989563,
0.8169694542884827,
-0.6234879493713379,
0.6369453072547913,
0.7712902426719666,
-0.2832458019256592,
-0.12601260840892792,
-0.8958540558815002,
-0.25094273686408997,
-0.5049397349357605,
0.21387194097042084,
-0.42860427498817444,
-0.9767117500305176,
0.5040320158004761,
-0.26683780550956726,
0.40335407853126526,
0.2969370484352112,
0.3521229922771454,
0.02602769248187542,
0.5522042512893677,
0.6002209186553955,
0.2353070080280304,
0.5481492280960083,
-0.10850456357002258,
0.4169115126132965,
-1.3046503067016602,
-0.4579344689846039,
-0.6538323163986206,
-0.5151370167732239,
-0.34633591771125793,
-0.6229087710380554,
0.2823169529438019,
0.3183702528476715,
-0.3525490462779999,
0.0044107213616371155,
-0.6208941340446472,
0.4916855990886688,
0.5411441922187805,
0.06584280729293823,
0.45707008242607117,
0.045871373265981674,
0.06309985369443893,
0.07100418210029602,
-0.6383023262023926,
-0.2944035828113556,
1.033693790435791,
0.1566355675458908,
0.6973319053649902,
0.18759654462337494,
0.811585009098053,
-0.0698300451040268,
0.621394693851471,
-0.6774766445159912,
0.44171226024627686,
-0.06093199551105499,
-0.5595500469207764,
-0.3043400049209595,
-0.24956387281417847,
-0.8398894667625427,
0.4541025161743164,
-0.15327046811580658,
-0.38759931921958923,
0.29937684535980225,
-0.21330025792121887,
-0.3357189893722534,
0.3571615219116211,
-0.6463956236839294,
0.6398398280143738,
-0.08951234817504883,
-0.4837254583835602,
-0.2479901909828186,
-0.4434565305709839,
0.3138449192047119,
-0.18310536444187164,
0.2872053384780884,
-0.0050315759144723415,
-0.33168521523475647,
0.5856321454048157,
-0.42382851243019104,
0.44562023878097534,
-0.2240409404039383,
-0.17218461632728577,
0.21669374406337738,
0.1795264184474945,
0.6159915328025818,
0.027869069948792458,
-0.07130461186170578,
-0.27578017115592957,
0.013444622978568077,
-0.29092657566070557,
-0.964089572429657,
0.657903254032135,
-0.44367173314094543,
-0.8598668575286865,
-0.27161678671836853,
-0.5193539261817932,
-0.07339222729206085,
0.42733991146087646,
-0.02376840077340603,
0.4120544195175171,
0.08435801416635513,
0.13833673298358917,
0.7966076135635376,
-0.22096392512321472,
0.1808445304632187,
0.7740854024887085,
-0.5282822847366333,
-0.5581774711608887,
0.855538547039032,
-0.1811000108718872,
0.2779756188392639,
0.646915078163147,
0.05420123413205147,
-0.5730049014091492,
-0.5488175749778748,
-0.22187773883342743,
0.33963632583618164,
-0.7855611443519592,
-0.5146726965904236,
-0.6139865517616272,
-0.2380078285932541,
-0.30390340089797974,
-0.14886315166950226,
-0.2631787657737732,
-0.37859591841697693,
-0.11181875318288803,
0.02415582723915577,
0.47560256719589233,
0.44072943925857544,
0.2177722454071045,
0.21829429268836975,
-0.8901839256286621,
0.5258100628852844,
0.3928767442703247,
0.5469046235084534,
0.11962415277957916,
-0.7888350486755371,
-0.31761008501052856,
-0.15847554802894592,
-0.0428505577147007,
-0.6847351789474487,
0.2681051194667816,
0.04311883822083473,
0.43982458114624023,
0.2621205151081085,
0.11105446517467499,
0.9702491760253906,
-0.5155619382858276,
0.5163666605949402,
-0.13681906461715698,
-0.5001228451728821,
0.23725523054599762,
-0.1385897547006607,
0.4262492060661316,
0.9622424244880676,
0.15938128530979156,
-0.8684768080711365,
-0.4276750683784485,
-0.5238462090492249,
-1.163528323173523,
0.4604778587818146,
-0.08484521508216858,
-0.14945457875728607,
-0.06160864979028702,
0.5437674522399902,
0.13482393324375153,
0.33561110496520996,
-0.3193191587924957,
0.031059719622135162,
-0.045657359063625336,
-0.1588408648967743,
0.15527139604091644,
-0.4547923505306244,
0.006612733937799931,
-0.10284755378961563,
0.7999855279922485,
-0.005839685909450054,
0.1631787121295929,
0.3106640577316284,
-0.00041422920185141265,
-0.145277738571167,
0.535062313079834,
0.19134561717510223,
0.6503213047981262,
-0.38529542088508606,
0.12313780933618546,
0.08586884289979935,
-0.38218948245048523,
0.08767536282539368,
0.12922969460487366,
-0.15705595910549164,
0.018824351951479912,
0.1712706834077835,
0.34479841589927673,
0.21661412715911865,
-1.0237016677856445,
0.11940788477659225,
-0.33039799332618713,
0.06815279275178909,
-0.5050888657569885,
0.0007992464816197753,
0.10295254737138748,
0.39600610733032227,
0.5135191082954407,
-0.015672598034143448,
0.25346699357032776,
-0.4638056457042694,
0.27762553095817566,
0.3518258035182953,
-0.11931539326906204,
0.11185015738010406,
0.6120702624320984,
0.16491000354290009,
-0.1814330667257309,
0.8718235492706299,
-0.17231085896492004,
-0.5293490290641785,
0.20975574851036072,
0.47123342752456665,
1.0387029647827148,
-0.20174044370651245,
-0.07220245897769928,
0.5387983918190002,
0.20255990326404572,
-0.14464594423770905,
0.43667128682136536,
-0.03958875685930252,
-0.5331703424453735,
-0.7597208619117737,
-0.9279260039329529,
-0.1977081298828125,
0.09512221068143845,
-0.7484551668167114,
0.26070544123649597,
-0.2960013747215271,
0.16074422001838684,
-0.39183345437049866,
-0.032701555639505386,
-0.411796897649765,
0.10044705122709274,
-0.19201873242855072,
1.0827170610427856,
-0.4895920753479004,
0.5088175535202026,
0.7764034867286682,
-0.48896005749702454,
-0.7835512757301331,
-0.17368851602077484,
-0.32946306467056274,
-0.6117116808891296,
0.47368213534355164,
0.12108895927667618,
-0.17329663038253784,
0.048645343631505966,
-0.2178073525428772,
-1.1198543310165405,
1.1753194332122803,
0.125205397605896,
-0.6759610772132874,
-0.243620365858078,
-0.24137331545352936,
0.46564188599586487,
-0.1506098061800003,
0.5769380927085876,
0.5788140296936035,
0.5099706053733826,
0.4349730312824249,
-0.7803611755371094,
0.4025546610355377,
-0.40628206729888916,
0.08583581447601318,
0.5936988592147827,
-0.787165641784668,
0.7640007138252258,
0.0259214099496603,
-0.446155846118927,
0.1318885087966919,
0.5223069787025452,
0.27140307426452637,
0.20541036128997803,
0.5466390252113342,
0.8578742146492004,
0.8030641674995422,
-0.013697047717869282,
0.8340489268302917,
-0.26846352219581604,
0.1313588172197342,
1.4009952545166016,
-0.17504730820655823,
1.09671950340271,
0.6712067127227783,
0.05023788660764694,
0.861778199672699,
0.462802916765213,
0.2831271290779114,
0.5133729577064514,
0.3141274154186249,
-0.33135467767715454,
-0.32240426540374756,
-0.20011258125305176,
-0.21168316900730133,
0.19801120460033417,
0.2533007562160492,
-0.11123968660831451,
-0.462316632270813,
-0.18015864491462708,
-0.07668589800596237,
0.2020350694656372,
-0.17854392528533936,
0.8801887631416321,
-0.18363535404205322,
-0.9169583320617676,
0.8640859127044678,
-0.056839294731616974,
0.5477814078330994,
-0.6758336424827576,
-0.22917833924293518,
-0.45769456028938293,
0.09214740991592407,
-0.42616310715675354,
-0.6225672960281372,
0.5017852783203125,
-0.041108205914497375,
-0.4467741847038269,
-0.3518840968608856,
0.8697674870491028,
-0.6478678584098816,
-0.31180697679519653,
0.07015383988618851,
0.5303861498832703,
0.2572212517261505,
-0.39841756224632263,
-0.31841734051704407,
0.22664383053779602,
0.2026701271533966,
-0.2551104426383972,
0.22595970332622528,
0.5306648015975952,
-0.029326453804969788,
0.625251054763794,
0.8498623967170715,
-0.006715662311762571,
-0.03252271190285683,
0.1447671502828598,
1.117636799812317,
-0.663989782333374,
-0.21861259639263153,
-0.44874078035354614,
0.6244522333145142,
-0.1467868685722351,
0.12866899371147156,
0.6139534711837769,
0.9644995927810669,
0.9412897825241089,
0.03325001895427704,
0.6673166751861572,
-0.13412700593471527,
0.8862541317939758,
-0.345111221075058,
0.43085598945617676,
-0.8101032376289368,
0.32302600145339966,
0.08252128213644028,
-0.8849172592163086,
0.11715906113386154,
0.23538808524608612,
-0.10228469967842102,
-0.12698407471179962,
0.6104173064231873,
0.7869523763656616,
-0.0346621610224247,
-0.19153551757335663,
0.012457323260605335,
0.05383622273802757,
0.49312201142311096,
0.6358551383018494,
0.67228764295578,
-0.4160325527191162,
0.8986456990242004,
0.14503741264343262,
-0.05589255318045616,
-0.23447038233280182,
-0.45495662093162537,
-0.6826415657997131,
-0.4536032974720001,
0.04667865112423897,
-0.3334529995918274,
-0.26924893260002136,
0.43210774660110474,
0.3233552575111389,
-0.4556399881839752,
-0.19018304347991943,
-0.015877235680818558,
0.238072007894516,
-0.1330759972333908,
-0.26496338844299316,
0.2376696765422821,
-0.7547518014907837,
-0.7000485062599182,
0.31570154428482056,
0.3320915997028351,
-0.2869555950164795,
-0.272605836391449,
0.1456824094057083,
-0.39524945616722107,
0.0979895070195198,
0.6006792187690735,
0.3211723566055298,
-0.5782207250595093,
-0.24705833196640015,
0.3367637097835541,
0.3477475345134735,
-0.02609892003238201,
0.9215036034584045,
-0.9567793607711792,
0.5363265872001648,
0.7776540517807007,
0.9376991391181946,
0.7709763050079346,
0.3413490056991577,
0.538689911365509,
-0.7273914217948914,
-0.05084115266799927,
0.22651520371437073,
0.3354760706424713,
0.26549288630485535,
-0.33191537857055664,
0.5747475028038025,
0.07367746531963348,
-0.7045750021934509,
-0.8142613768577576,
0.3881278336048126,
-0.7818228006362915,
-0.5433379411697388,
0.8503091335296631,
0.08332545310258865,
-0.29880598187446594,
-0.15840686857700348,
-0.4288204610347748,
0.322029709815979,
-0.486291766166687,
0.8511453866958618,
0.5782963633537292,
-0.08819776773452759,
-0.3334980010986328,
-0.603790819644928,
0.3307573199272156,
0.4672990143299103,
-0.7655391097068787,
0.3222854435443878,
0.6373828649520874,
0.5261952877044678,
0.27696582674980164,
0.6913005709648132,
-0.185133695602417,
0.17829714715480804,
-0.2808312177658081,
0.05253804847598076,
-0.2561936378479004,
-0.22276148200035095,
-0.157537043094635,
0.1796671748161316,
0.16995902359485626,
-0.07205034792423248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12937v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12937v1 | Self-Train Before You Transcribe | 2024-06-17T09:21:00 | 2024-06-17T09:21:00 | Robert Flynn, Anton Ragni | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | When there is a mismatch between the training and test domains, current
speech recognition systems show significant performance degradation.
Self-training methods, such as noisy student teacher training, can help address
this and enable the adaptation of models under such domain shifts. However,
self-training typically requires a collection of unlabelled target domain data.
For settings where this is not practical, we investigate the benefit of
performing noisy student teacher training on recordings in the test set as a
test-time adaptation approach. Similarly to the dynamic evaluation approach in
language modelling, this enables the transfer of information across utterance
boundaries and functions as a method of domain adaptation. A range of in-domain
and out-of-domain datasets are used for experiments demonstrating large
relative gains of up to 32.2%. Interestingly, our method showed larger gains
than the typical self-training setup that utilises separate adaptation data. | [
-0.16630728542804718,
-0.21816761791706085,
0.015200062654912472,
0.06082167476415634,
-0.1241910383105278,
0.2752833664417267,
-0.21116693317890167,
-0.39646390080451965,
-0.27638107538223267,
0.3844078779220581,
-0.5400679707527161,
0.04228437319397926,
-0.5637417435646057,
-0.030517837032675743,
-0.6663120985031128,
0.8043293356895447,
0.04831729829311371,
0.37302401661872864,
-0.08225119113922119,
-0.09014647454023361,
-0.7728260159492493,
-0.8575725555419922,
-0.5190655589103699,
-0.28686824440956116,
0.06216878443956375,
0.30299651622772217,
0.17847096920013428,
0.5324655771255493,
0.2469855397939682,
0.23378632962703705,
0.42627373337745667,
-0.004051448777318001,
-0.601820170879364,
0.37913820147514343,
-0.3628070056438446,
-0.35896098613739014,
0.025671597570180893,
0.3460807502269745,
0.8849021792411804,
0.7071789503097534,
-0.13490237295627594,
0.29945123195648193,
0.4036073386669159,
0.33840227127075195,
-0.6720508337020874,
0.1693217158317566,
-0.6621173620223999,
0.3836340606212616,
-0.23416154086589813,
-0.31036919355392456,
-0.5206778049468994,
-0.07597272843122482,
0.3022012710571289,
-0.5157034993171692,
0.3050718605518341,
-0.32228970527648926,
0.3936985731124878,
0.3466307520866394,
-0.1167171448469162,
-0.1410735845565796,
-1.1634719371795654,
0.8403254747390747,
-0.6296192407608032,
0.9741799235343933,
0.5546067357063293,
0.38244593143463135,
-0.10978823900222778,
-0.7033613920211792,
-0.41435039043426514,
0.02700941264629364,
0.04884880408644676,
0.28750503063201904,
-0.0777435228228569,
-0.23718178272247314,
0.17678529024124146,
0.22686229646205902,
-0.5235259532928467,
0.028660079464316368,
-0.5643748044967651,
-0.30565503239631653,
0.5751997828483582,
-0.12768591940402985,
0.24006658792495728,
0.3541322350502014,
-0.22232438623905182,
-0.48950082063674927,
-0.2837877869606018,
-0.004902527201920748,
0.25619083642959595,
0.6661579608917236,
-0.02225431054830551,
0.07139302790164948,
0.1989244818687439,
0.6382015943527222,
0.3213244080543518,
-0.34532731771469116,
0.35520195960998535,
-0.12092544883489609,
-0.15130190551280975,
0.3733615279197693,
0.3708336055278778,
-0.2066882997751236,
0.59299635887146,
-0.456109881401062,
-0.14216509461402893,
0.06846119463443756,
0.37993037700653076,
-0.8480032682418823,
-0.37829333543777466,
-0.08472403883934021,
-0.29434964060783386,
-0.14731541275978088,
-0.2889333963394165,
-0.7468790411949158,
-0.2123669683933258,
-0.5359585881233215,
0.8206852078437805,
-0.3321038782596588,
-0.3330792784690857,
0.25010985136032104,
-0.08031603693962097,
0.07418960332870483,
0.23051486909389496,
-0.8751589059829712,
0.736724853515625,
0.20046696066856384,
0.689348042011261,
-0.4749457538127899,
-0.4957914650440216,
-0.7418714761734009,
0.16872313618659973,
-0.3530898690223694,
0.614215612411499,
-0.3194250464439392,
-0.6870433688163757,
-0.14692242443561554,
-0.00491455290466547,
-0.5788691639900208,
-0.7476344704627991,
0.307537704706192,
-0.40825411677360535,
0.33415549993515015,
0.26164954900741577,
-0.5343406796455383,
0.13285759091377258,
-0.3122994601726532,
-0.45874470472335815,
1.3011802434921265,
0.3560626208782196,
-0.25246843695640564,
0.42821410298347473,
-0.519649088382721,
-0.7583563327789307,
-0.07371223717927933,
-0.050886865705251694,
-0.571904718875885,
-0.0049755466170609,
0.06231406331062317,
0.4515024423599243,
0.25718238949775696,
-0.21440055966377258,
-0.08069724589586258,
-0.3275197446346283,
0.5661796927452087,
-0.442223459482193,
0.626447856426239,
0.3203813135623932,
-0.55756014585495,
-0.5263381600379944,
-0.8218922019004822,
0.34046390652656555,
0.015896087512373924,
-0.5283653140068054,
-0.5537141561508179,
-0.09000290185213089,
-0.29433244466781616,
0.061859868466854095,
-0.33011141419410706,
-0.40403059124946594,
0.11706775426864624,
-0.41709694266319275,
0.38314443826675415,
0.8030170798301697,
0.0029647278133779764,
0.370926171541214,
-0.26422086358070374,
0.6169788241386414,
0.27856290340423584,
0.08608809113502502,
0.23304058611392975,
-0.09050018340349197,
-0.6194987297058105,
0.022751417011022568,
0.8604401350021362,
0.33427488803863525,
-0.4598809778690338,
0.1421399712562561,
-0.3458673059940338,
-0.37272194027900696,
-0.7662419080734253,
0.2257125973701477,
0.3745318651199341,
0.5674141049385071,
0.5150644779205322,
-0.7436279654502869,
-0.5599613189697266,
-0.35785987973213196,
-0.5005046725273132,
-0.17491838335990906,
0.07804987579584122,
0.23730982840061188,
0.3099476397037506,
-0.023157907649874687,
0.6365541219711304,
-0.2631796896457672,
-0.5850496292114258,
-0.0645061731338501,
0.06899838149547577,
-0.2809062898159027,
0.6252430081367493,
0.49615079164505005,
-0.6662617325782776,
-0.5709800720214844,
-0.4740898907184601,
-0.17533856630325317,
-0.08557435125112534,
-0.49697038531303406,
-0.1256416290998459,
0.016921380534768105,
0.3265042006969452,
-0.03355798497796059,
0.4281405806541443,
0.724553644657135,
-0.09661160409450531,
0.3374846577644348,
-0.0555141419172287,
0.09801837056875229,
-0.7750297784805298,
-0.1941007673740387,
-0.3605039417743683,
-0.5264548659324646,
-0.8904232382774353,
-0.5531367659568787,
-0.09402263909578323,
-0.31168657541275024,
-0.4673561155796051,
0.5867177844047546,
-0.6243423223495483,
-0.18987448513507843,
-0.2921740412712097,
0.03312356397509575,
-0.0620800144970417,
0.45640164613723755,
0.11863719671964645,
1.3732202053070068,
0.6188535690307617,
-0.9091683626174927,
-0.15133120119571686,
0.5454361438751221,
-0.3613249361515045,
0.3365798592567444,
-0.20798304677009583,
0.5684282779693604,
0.17557696998119354,
-0.1466822773218155,
-0.8603519797325134,
0.0643739104270935,
0.2934384047985077,
-0.5914813876152039,
0.7243253588676453,
-0.14104752242565155,
0.1822124868631363,
-0.42957064509391785,
0.0948849618434906,
0.43227648735046387,
0.6012594103813171,
-0.850236177444458,
0.5808161497116089,
0.5142784714698792,
0.07472298294305801,
-0.5356874465942383,
-0.9876585602760315,
-0.11934655904769897,
-0.224945530295372,
0.01710653491318226,
0.3435790240764618,
-0.32674139738082886,
0.16065345704555511,
-0.24150826036930084,
-0.401725172996521,
-0.5124555230140686,
0.3005317449569702,
0.5123022794723511,
-0.2581179738044739,
-0.15645276010036469,
0.45712509751319885,
-0.16356141865253448,
0.11614411324262619,
0.19962024688720703,
-0.44443607330322266,
0.3503858745098114,
0.22734461724758148,
-0.11638157814741135,
-0.5180414319038391,
0.17570333182811737,
0.18812155723571777,
-0.1591823548078537,
0.34399864077568054,
0.2614704370498657,
-0.27798718214035034,
-0.9959535598754883,
-0.3330312967300415,
-0.36594370007514954,
-0.4912058711051941,
0.29866230487823486,
-0.6347152590751648,
-0.4610249400138855,
0.0072507839649915695,
-0.38018277287483215,
-0.32190439105033875,
0.13990385830402374,
0.43534237146377563,
-0.3166772425174713,
0.5111526846885681,
0.6680257320404053,
-0.19838407635688782,
0.8007632493972778,
-0.20172493159770966,
0.23182235658168793,
-0.7271318435668945,
-0.06350147724151611,
-0.5707216858863831,
-0.23333832621574402,
-0.21828244626522064,
-0.3497149646282196,
0.24401746690273285,
-0.30181536078453064,
-0.04037819430232048,
0.46059492230415344,
-0.5934429168701172,
0.30740851163864136,
0.658277153968811,
0.31540900468826294,
0.0844501256942749,
0.29125598073005676,
0.18418274819850922,
-0.5321820378303528,
-0.7160193920135498,
-0.0006117377779446542,
1.3235535621643066,
0.15879634022712708,
0.9895126819610596,
-0.08854330331087112,
0.656878650188446,
0.6337869167327881,
0.2580322027206421,
-0.6768186688423157,
0.272323340177536,
-0.24703429639339447,
-0.6368197798728943,
-0.7277069091796875,
-0.3658883273601532,
-1.159942626953125,
0.13805629312992096,
-0.04276159033179283,
-0.199191153049469,
0.5238043069839478,
0.13253769278526306,
-0.4937158226966858,
0.24966134130954742,
-0.7615174055099487,
0.6490854620933533,
-0.3595057725906372,
-0.041406795382499695,
-0.029338495805859566,
-0.4315544068813324,
-0.18936270475387573,
-0.6906018257141113,
0.10089153051376343,
-0.004654405638575554,
0.37726688385009766,
1.2120943069458008,
-0.24242116510868073,
1.0474903583526611,
-0.3451525866985321,
0.0995277538895607,
0.5386487245559692,
0.356975257396698,
0.24156618118286133,
-0.49931448698043823,
-0.18918992578983307,
0.13380242884159088,
0.24011768400669098,
-0.2056981772184372,
-0.8882210850715637,
0.25494685769081116,
-1.238792061805725,
-0.609494686126709,
-0.516508162021637,
-0.5550495386123657,
-0.6149125695228577,
0.11140178143978119,
0.0793992131948471,
0.5530028939247131,
-0.2842831015586853,
-0.01589498482644558,
0.6312861442565918,
0.1810787171125412,
0.441660076379776,
0.7230236530303955,
0.14102330803871155,
-0.221628338098526,
1.0636811256408691,
0.4268094003200531,
0.6138557195663452,
0.02160484902560711,
0.34004873037338257,
-0.4947335422039032,
-0.6856719255447388,
-0.28310826420783997,
0.13179896771907806,
-0.865085244178772,
-0.25258955359458923,
-0.49772387742996216,
-0.5138658881187439,
-0.8785901665687561,
0.23968233168125153,
-0.476732075214386,
-0.5339540243148804,
-0.5284384489059448,
-0.024515891447663307,
0.21290139853954315,
0.6404207348823547,
-0.4239361882209778,
0.5310620665550232,
-0.452862411737442,
0.10808008164167404,
0.5999242663383484,
0.22766335308551788,
-0.2498435229063034,
-1.34420907497406,
-0.4857546091079712,
0.024956202134490013,
-0.35369277000427246,
-0.6695021390914917,
0.6807938814163208,
0.9520266056060791,
0.6053606867790222,
-0.126063734292984,
0.23006343841552734,
0.8684561848640442,
-0.5599439144134521,
0.6170616745948792,
-0.06424218416213989,
-1.1628973484039307,
0.6803328990936279,
0.28254222869873047,
0.1241287887096405,
0.7064856290817261,
0.5747303366661072,
-0.43201372027397156,
-0.13929952681064606,
-0.5994099378585815,
-0.17464327812194824,
0.590881884098053,
0.0823495090007782,
0.3323991298675537,
0.5576664209365845,
0.6727200746536255,
0.32745906710624695,
0.06605309247970581,
-0.6689963936805725,
-0.16984789073467255,
-0.5355986952781677,
-0.14330682158470154,
-0.23701974749565125,
-0.06828585267066956,
-0.25017085671424866,
-0.4771755039691925,
0.7424939274787903,
-0.3380272686481476,
0.4647837281227112,
0.36674296855926514,
-0.2526976764202118,
-0.274954617023468,
0.10905180126428604,
0.3227570950984955,
0.5406769514083862,
0.029680617153644562,
0.30606210231781006,
0.5847810506820679,
-0.8700371980667114,
0.563435435295105,
-0.0364951528608799,
0.14768314361572266,
0.1322949230670929,
0.3980419933795929,
0.6006923317909241,
0.2234238088130951,
-0.3567611575126648,
0.781602680683136,
-0.0441850982606411,
-0.36434823274612427,
-0.15635071694850922,
0.3360740840435028,
-0.41951122879981995,
0.2059348076581955,
0.07044617086648941,
0.09195715188980103,
0.24399128556251526,
-0.6161532402038574,
0.46170562505722046,
-0.06205104663968086,
-0.4837760329246521,
-0.5026938319206238,
0.7110021710395813,
0.036423880606889725,
-0.3891630470752716,
0.6386022567749023,
0.18543292582035065,
-0.5952712893486023,
0.23955819010734558,
0.9545300006866455,
0.9429670572280884,
-0.9048665761947632,
0.23887890577316284,
0.252535879611969,
-0.0027089628856629133,
-0.02449539676308632,
0.38767534494400024,
-0.3013170659542084,
-0.7212926745414734,
-0.3321833610534668,
-0.47590816020965576,
-0.5280120968818665,
0.17925125360488892,
-0.6819014549255371,
0.1187797412276268,
-0.29580068588256836,
-0.10432548820972443,
0.16295017302036285,
-0.041951607912778854,
-0.725481390953064,
0.6366637349128723,
0.24137955904006958,
0.5457176566123962,
-0.8396288752555847,
1.1701431274414062,
0.39706578850746155,
-0.002328761387616396,
-0.9697827100753784,
0.09228428453207016,
-0.4094386100769043,
-1.038676142692566,
0.9086487889289856,
-0.16810820996761322,
-0.19702687859535217,
0.0733853206038475,
-0.30862200260162354,
-0.9512151479721069,
0.7931631803512573,
0.44359979033470154,
-0.7896662354469299,
0.17958898842334747,
0.5075806379318237,
0.617715060710907,
-0.40428829193115234,
-0.09675631672143936,
0.6911777853965759,
0.2277604341506958,
-0.07361416518688202,
-0.9567658305168152,
-0.045863982290029526,
0.16439121961593628,
-0.15866801142692566,
-0.13973353803157806,
-0.648409366607666,
0.49409234523773193,
-0.12706004083156586,
-0.48624274134635925,
-0.2764221429824829,
0.6021900773048401,
-0.5111963748931885,
0.0827021673321724,
0.8297593593597412,
0.13633108139038086,
1.0096355676651,
-0.0032570436596870422,
0.6972063183784485,
-0.24169921875,
0.1794721931219101,
1.4744864702224731,
-0.20907512307167053,
0.6893555521965027,
0.35085976123809814,
-0.39153656363487244,
0.15230253338813782,
0.6321995258331299,
-0.11062945425510406,
0.9031972289085388,
0.36949291825294495,
-0.18431472778320312,
-0.5324880480766296,
-0.02161294035613537,
-0.4910125732421875,
0.5276810526847839,
0.04497755318880081,
-0.2654183506965637,
-0.018587341532111168,
0.3466562330722809,
-0.45174500346183777,
0.009909051470458508,
-0.09496135264635086,
0.7552980184555054,
0.3289344906806946,
-0.2949236035346985,
0.7933292388916016,
-0.6258172392845154,
0.0969102680683136,
-0.5017912983894348,
0.07925111800432205,
-0.04135749861598015,
0.44271597266197205,
-0.043917447328567505,
-0.5354622006416321,
0.34072282910346985,
-0.34014222025871277,
-0.0012632061261683702,
-0.5978922247886658,
0.850624144077301,
-0.623567521572113,
-0.20080772042274475,
0.45208293199539185,
0.6900814771652222,
0.5840376615524292,
-0.038962602615356445,
-0.8273165822029114,
-0.0073336404748260975,
-0.07980327308177948,
-0.19279329478740692,
0.41450706124305725,
0.46706682443618774,
0.1504024863243103,
0.5971828103065491,
0.49382293224334717,
0.32684651017189026,
0.26615050435066223,
0.3107249140739441,
1.006646990776062,
-0.5821152329444885,
-0.4373878240585327,
-0.41323843598365784,
0.022452741861343384,
0.294140487909317,
-0.49048447608947754,
0.720467209815979,
0.6209948062896729,
1.0834349393844604,
-0.12403988093137741,
0.8951518535614014,
0.5389591455459595,
0.9935175180435181,
-0.4107269048690796,
0.5219518542289734,
-0.4291389286518097,
-0.03331970423460007,
-0.04450834542512894,
-0.5161914229393005,
-0.1151794046163559,
0.5376221537590027,
-0.2835119664669037,
0.08920655399560928,
0.5425825119018555,
0.5572607517242432,
-0.20801912248134613,
0.16327732801437378,
0.7738727331161499,
0.26777487993240356,
0.19193097949028015,
0.4135214388370514,
0.9982309341430664,
-0.7199369668960571,
0.6667606234550476,
-0.4094516634941101,
-0.1146632507443428,
0.08766689151525497,
-0.34184783697128296,
-1.123192310333252,
-0.6482205986976624,
-0.6117420792579651,
-0.5284839272499084,
0.4964318871498108,
0.5499638915061951,
1.1377257108688354,
-0.9175055027008057,
-0.48151254653930664,
0.4432699680328369,
-0.3896164894104004,
-0.43765273690223694,
-0.1339687556028366,
0.36043673753738403,
-0.4622243642807007,
-0.6839836239814758,
0.7916436195373535,
-0.24245885014533997,
0.6450358629226685,
-0.17390337586402893,
-0.045316100120544434,
0.14165689051151276,
0.17122600972652435,
0.3306416869163513,
0.40502363443374634,
-0.011444352567195892,
-0.41518524289131165,
-0.1499723345041275,
0.06889470666646957,
0.4952549636363983,
0.8546421527862549,
-0.9367973804473877,
0.6086490750312805,
-0.030321726575493813,
0.8578550219535828,
0.8546069264411926,
0.04282193258404732,
0.6075001358985901,
-0.6468328833580017,
0.15867961943149567,
0.30821263790130615,
-0.20410463213920593,
0.26917779445648193,
-0.6529802680015564,
0.8065863847732544,
0.42916595935821533,
-0.5774797201156616,
-0.9706300497055054,
-0.18646644055843353,
-0.8090499043464661,
-0.19725407660007477,
0.9616618752479553,
-0.27219158411026,
-0.29822149872779846,
-0.2878245711326599,
-0.001049889368005097,
0.4019046723842621,
-0.36302390694618225,
0.9680876135826111,
0.5408936738967896,
-0.1815980076789856,
0.059206195175647736,
-0.425416499376297,
0.8808097839355469,
0.6528975963592529,
-0.6931099891662598,
0.13133549690246582,
-0.10294490307569504,
0.6193513870239258,
0.05378178134560585,
0.609489917755127,
-0.007103323470801115,
0.14166131615638733,
0.067050039768219,
0.1692613959312439,
0.1279822587966919,
-0.5387187004089355,
-0.6448948383331299,
-0.033564940094947815,
-0.027675287798047066,
-0.6867856979370117
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.