id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11354v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11354v2 | Preserving Knowledge in Large Language Model with Model-Agnostic Self-Decompression | 2024-06-17T09:17:40 | 2024-06-19T11:36:30 | Zilun Zhang, Yutao Sun, Tiancheng Zhao, Leigang Sha, Ruochen Xu, Kyusong Lee, Jianwei Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Humans can retain old knowledge while learning new information, but Large
Language Models (LLMs) often suffer from catastrophic forgetting when
post-pretrained or supervised fine-tuned (SFT) on domain-specific data.
Moreover, for Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) which are composed of
the LLM base and visual projector (e.g. LLaVA), a significant decline in
performance on language benchmarks was observed compared to their
single-modality counterparts. To address these challenges, we introduce a novel
model-agnostic self-decompression method, Tree Generation (TG), that
decompresses knowledge within LLMs into the training corpus. This paper focuses
on TG-SFT, which can synthetically generate SFT data for the instruction tuning
steps. By incorporating the dumped corpus during SFT for MLLMs, we
significantly reduce the forgetting problem. | [
-0.18461863696575165,
-0.770228385925293,
0.3645900785923004,
-0.1153067946434021,
-0.21649743616580963,
0.28022903203964233,
-0.3093540072441101,
-0.11585375666618347,
-0.20829500257968903,
0.5012719035148621,
-0.5831431746482849,
-0.5810503363609314,
-0.2941254675388336,
-0.09724577516317368,
-0.3493288457393646,
0.9399264454841614,
0.008810165338218212,
-0.30355796217918396,
-0.24542300403118134,
-0.054042499512434006,
-0.3816726505756378,
-0.6476573348045349,
-0.6179234385490417,
-0.09885293245315552,
0.12157518416643143,
0.1773892045021057,
0.3236641585826874,
0.8838224411010742,
-0.01587819494307041,
0.2761498987674713,
0.033193014562129974,
0.42827531695365906,
-0.6979038119316101,
0.28051233291625977,
-0.22066520154476166,
-0.3727594017982483,
-0.37150838971138,
-0.34057822823524475,
0.9739112257957458,
0.4894237220287323,
-0.31145304441452026,
0.2557178735733032,
0.1605355143547058,
0.5479387640953064,
-0.7299089431762695,
0.4487122595310211,
-0.9505759477615356,
-0.006209792103618383,
-0.006897423882037401,
-0.47569602727890015,
-0.5372737050056458,
-0.14652548730373383,
-0.10508713126182556,
-0.4670960605144501,
0.6541462540626526,
-0.1259947270154953,
0.7555360794067383,
0.6482895612716675,
-0.28073740005493164,
0.06710285693407059,
-0.7456285357475281,
0.7221295237541199,
-0.7228540778160095,
0.46199721097946167,
0.47977501153945923,
0.1962507665157318,
-0.15167231857776642,
-0.3454906642436981,
-0.32089880108833313,
-0.19821399450302124,
0.06537846475839615,
-0.015804314985871315,
-0.09387027472257614,
0.12183091789484024,
0.29201453924179077,
0.2177152782678604,
-0.4271238446235657,
0.03493292257189751,
-0.2975342869758606,
-0.27179381251335144,
0.5534447431564331,
-0.004569457843899727,
0.15292291343212128,
-0.27510613203048706,
-0.2048092782497406,
-0.14084956049919128,
-1.1348339319229126,
-0.2973235547542572,
0.08835344016551971,
0.2389834225177765,
0.3044985830783844,
0.28700530529022217,
-0.012793444097042084,
0.6170845627784729,
0.09128700196743011,
-0.26583874225616455,
0.28655752539634705,
-0.21740911900997162,
-0.26407590508461,
-0.03692105412483215,
0.728753924369812,
0.16755075752735138,
0.41327977180480957,
-0.23515480756759644,
-0.24249647557735443,
0.16635221242904663,
0.09876945614814758,
-0.834292471408844,
-0.5215573310852051,
-0.0494595468044281,
-0.3489547073841095,
-0.10224565118551254,
-0.3392922580242157,
-0.3755536675453186,
-0.038842976093292236,
-0.17911861836910248,
0.28175556659698486,
-0.562122642993927,
-0.559004008769989,
-0.08021105825901031,
0.14800576865673065,
-0.010677013546228409,
0.1991836279630661,
-1.1102243661880493,
0.030111048370599747,
0.43363237380981445,
0.5578151941299438,
0.040991853922605515,
-0.3657568693161011,
-0.5567850470542908,
0.4991269111633301,
-0.3836885690689087,
0.571287214756012,
-0.3127591609954834,
-0.4033415913581848,
-0.09263475984334946,
0.0203071478754282,
-0.26549312472343445,
-0.6599913835525513,
0.2762288451194763,
-0.31477487087249756,
0.18631334602832794,
-0.03573795408010483,
-0.6785308122634888,
-0.14145109057426453,
0.4461178779602051,
-0.42521217465400696,
0.9289947748184204,
0.1472073793411255,
-0.6349483728408813,
0.19226358830928802,
-0.4519568383693695,
-0.37998732924461365,
0.018812531605362892,
-0.2984216511249542,
-0.6303067803382874,
0.35169553756713867,
0.36075150966644287,
0.5710809230804443,
-0.1437428593635559,
0.6347661018371582,
-0.43995940685272217,
-0.05652990937232971,
-0.26256850361824036,
-0.4875883162021637,
0.5530177354812622,
0.24611796438694,
-0.03445623442530632,
0.05693861097097397,
-0.7907972931861877,
0.18043100833892822,
0.215399369597435,
-0.45145949721336365,
-0.37420743703842163,
0.3577176332473755,
-0.30895569920539856,
0.33546575903892517,
0.17232738435268402,
-0.551346480846405,
0.49292778968811035,
-0.1842428594827652,
0.8490739464759827,
0.7007886171340942,
0.08191826939582825,
0.09992332011461258,
-0.15889336168766022,
0.5499075651168823,
0.10829812288284302,
-0.11470383405685425,
-0.6063604354858398,
0.06191674992442131,
-0.8630154132843018,
0.007890620268881321,
0.2253333032131195,
0.3621518611907959,
-0.6284944415092468,
0.3626256585121155,
-0.4364217519760132,
-0.2595294415950775,
-0.45518991351127625,
0.2273266762495041,
0.42863714694976807,
0.5246128439903259,
0.43695855140686035,
0.03133174404501915,
-0.5236433744430542,
-0.9365530610084534,
0.05048482492566109,
-0.25918295979499817,
-0.0714530348777771,
0.23603497445583344,
0.23787635564804077,
-0.3645709455013275,
0.783183217048645,
-0.48896324634552,
-0.3612654507160187,
-0.09189599007368088,
0.24275581538677216,
-0.2783028185367584,
0.6083613634109497,
0.5047241449356079,
-0.3752376437187195,
-0.17791299521923065,
-0.004653898999094963,
-0.5799017548561096,
-0.12098619341850281,
-0.1260671466588974,
0.047728024423122406,
0.6250104904174805,
0.7495474815368652,
-0.7257179021835327,
0.21376536786556244,
0.7228303551673889,
-0.22001834213733673,
0.6263904571533203,
-0.40768393874168396,
-0.05490627512335777,
-1.2194627523422241,
0.1605498194694519,
-0.36987364292144775,
-0.33266401290893555,
-0.28588375449180603,
-0.11380504816770554,
0.37286651134490967,
-0.05659257248044014,
-0.1274397373199463,
0.3854195475578308,
-0.7175419330596924,
0.08611379563808441,
-0.2885102331638336,
-0.1265115588903427,
-0.02139635942876339,
0.5930709838867188,
0.20713753998279572,
0.6212055087089539,
0.6484139561653137,
-0.6358728408813477,
-0.13193899393081665,
0.24563194811344147,
-0.1610848307609558,
0.02846861444413662,
-0.46210944652557373,
0.20610347390174866,
-0.3303877115249634,
0.2165590226650238,
-0.787009060382843,
-0.10139691829681396,
-0.13594768941402435,
-0.3080854117870331,
0.6516388058662415,
-0.3155894875526428,
-0.47877180576324463,
-0.292383074760437,
-0.08359473198652267,
0.48057320713996887,
0.5057653784751892,
-0.521702766418457,
0.5815889835357666,
0.315248042345047,
-0.1906004399061203,
-0.5516293048858643,
-0.5638401508331299,
0.12189483642578125,
-0.2752473056316376,
-0.5424850583076477,
0.3413216769695282,
-0.23196373879909515,
0.1454966515302658,
0.10727694630622864,
-0.25278642773628235,
0.1192360371351242,
0.09833182394504547,
0.14686669409275055,
0.06875919550657272,
-0.28943392634391785,
0.5519431829452515,
0.16231344640254974,
0.02472146600484848,
0.16546498239040375,
-0.4434657692909241,
0.5778777003288269,
-0.21370162069797516,
-0.2637721002101898,
0.029107065871357918,
0.32745298743247986,
0.6045114994049072,
-0.47862181067466736,
0.5270952582359314,
0.5464838147163391,
-0.32864099740982056,
-0.5947638750076294,
-0.6581565141677856,
-0.18707191944122314,
-0.4259609580039978,
0.5706538558006287,
-0.41102516651153564,
-1.1994041204452515,
0.449474573135376,
-0.37004512548446655,
0.037443533539772034,
0.5124027132987976,
0.5087990760803223,
0.007865466177463531,
1.059752345085144,
0.7621638774871826,
-0.15666557848453522,
0.48390838503837585,
-0.40968966484069824,
0.01160239614546299,
-0.7476511001586914,
0.015875959768891335,
-0.35573384165763855,
-0.05501692369580269,
-0.4258872866630554,
-0.2954404950141907,
0.2516172528266907,
0.31738004088401794,
-0.4028295874595642,
0.1419244259595871,
-0.4876324534416199,
0.5545034408569336,
0.6042906045913696,
-0.08754771947860718,
0.35190922021865845,
-0.021725568920373917,
-0.07991202920675278,
0.247334823012352,
-0.9914859533309937,
-0.25775641202926636,
0.991294264793396,
0.2308373749256134,
0.7530456781387329,
-0.12873783707618713,
0.940920889377594,
-0.055279217660427094,
0.2577725648880005,
-0.6260496973991394,
0.4607268273830414,
-0.18656130135059357,
-0.5186165571212769,
-0.3503408133983612,
-0.6208205223083496,
-0.9992638230323792,
0.159246027469635,
-0.04870207980275154,
-0.7283926606178284,
-0.0578116811811924,
0.6016968488693237,
-0.38822686672210693,
0.36201804876327515,
-0.7705988883972168,
0.9782442450523376,
-0.27626651525497437,
-0.30316492915153503,
-0.32355427742004395,
-0.5153898596763611,
0.5351344347000122,
-0.237248495221138,
0.09805260598659515,
-0.18110893666744232,
0.21091483533382416,
0.6448785662651062,
-0.3815404772758484,
0.8617897033691406,
-0.33309105038642883,
-0.2300194501876831,
0.31369367241859436,
0.3903111517429352,
0.5686495304107666,
-0.18514801561832428,
0.14957895874977112,
0.011356260627508163,
0.04066814109683037,
-0.2594465911388397,
-0.6470327377319336,
0.7676870226860046,
-0.8182797431945801,
-0.8566340208053589,
-0.036606207489967346,
-0.6065914034843445,
-0.3548640310764313,
0.27643513679504395,
0.2067345231771469,
0.2845756709575653,
-0.140403151512146,
0.3340460956096649,
0.6998431086540222,
-0.16907067596912384,
0.6027248501777649,
0.34899890422821045,
-0.33656883239746094,
-0.4382396638393402,
0.922066867351532,
0.30262577533721924,
0.48778069019317627,
0.30926159024238586,
0.330398827791214,
-0.3042370080947876,
-0.7415248155593872,
-0.40828222036361694,
0.2656768262386322,
-0.5177543759346008,
-0.5465438961982727,
-0.5326056480407715,
-0.37431600689888,
-0.34132498502731323,
0.07147239148616791,
-0.5508084297180176,
-0.451498419046402,
-0.2788361608982086,
-0.2227739691734314,
0.2884328365325928,
0.70792555809021,
-0.09670636802911758,
0.09321747720241547,
-1.0307365655899048,
0.27590763568878174,
0.2396666258573532,
0.4646623134613037,
0.04061554744839668,
-0.3949111998081207,
-0.2734542489051819,
0.12267663329839706,
-0.3327779173851013,
-0.5308864712715149,
0.5945594310760498,
0.5505501627922058,
0.5714659690856934,
0.37298786640167236,
0.09440820664167404,
0.7542992234230042,
-0.5195608139038086,
0.4667735695838928,
0.08002964407205582,
-0.9532166123390198,
0.6913707256317139,
-0.6091145277023315,
0.7289445400238037,
0.34002232551574707,
0.05417296290397644,
-0.44585978984832764,
-0.2898436486721039,
-0.645864725112915,
-0.927393913269043,
0.680043637752533,
-0.12485335767269135,
0.03328139707446098,
-0.1897905319929123,
0.19933238625526428,
0.11293325573205948,
0.22677944600582123,
-0.8253546357154846,
0.1040852963924408,
-0.4178514778614044,
-0.14334508776664734,
-0.22553901374340057,
-0.36856359243392944,
-0.042459096759557724,
-0.3005139231681824,
0.6431248784065247,
-0.3596113622188568,
0.047756802290678024,
0.05377398431301117,
-0.2079034149646759,
-0.3940231502056122,
0.29056695103645325,
0.5579473376274109,
0.6097691059112549,
-0.16810166835784912,
0.31822922825813293,
0.1221182569861412,
-0.21526947617530823,
0.19379667937755585,
0.0025807595811784267,
-0.30931320786476135,
-0.311511367559433,
0.3493855893611908,
0.7742456793785095,
0.2407863289117813,
-0.5590919852256775,
0.16038894653320312,
0.15244923532009125,
-0.342795729637146,
-0.2806848883628845,
0.12506726384162903,
0.2426624298095703,
0.051715221256017685,
0.36992278695106506,
0.18484912812709808,
-0.23138059675693512,
-0.4279455542564392,
0.2519487738609314,
0.5265808701515198,
0.051851045340299606,
-0.31705859303474426,
0.6955460906028748,
0.141643226146698,
-0.08585085719823837,
0.745140016078949,
-0.030292367562651634,
-0.5950916409492493,
0.26094046235084534,
0.7947479486465454,
1.04874849319458,
-0.5876659154891968,
0.08415311574935913,
0.572944164276123,
0.2640087306499481,
-0.2485227733850479,
0.03332139179110527,
-0.320934921503067,
-0.6450416445732117,
-0.6332804560661316,
-0.7855414748191833,
0.12747664749622345,
0.31029635667800903,
-0.3771314024925232,
0.10394704341888428,
-0.5328424572944641,
-0.010765292681753635,
-0.35932913422584534,
-0.2383863776922226,
-0.5669593214988708,
0.09891870617866516,
0.27574294805526733,
0.612377941608429,
-0.6859651207923889,
1.2542047500610352,
0.38013431429862976,
-0.17552220821380615,
-1.02528715133667,
0.08871672302484512,
-0.29148536920547485,
-0.7584794759750366,
0.6016302704811096,
0.15468914806842804,
-0.28964748978614807,
0.26630258560180664,
-0.5191094875335693,
-1.1360267400741577,
1.1105363368988037,
0.7532857060432434,
-0.7125999331474304,
-0.2684832513332367,
0.08866802603006363,
0.5844249725341797,
-0.3134253919124603,
-0.12656454741954803,
0.49203458428382874,
0.26046761870384216,
0.2187049686908722,
-0.9718204736709595,
-0.006527378689497709,
-0.33445852994918823,
0.02312658354640007,
0.43862128257751465,
-0.7295000553131104,
0.8473515510559082,
-0.26852837204933167,
-0.5179893970489502,
-0.23041965067386627,
0.4445987045764923,
0.25383323431015015,
-0.16606241464614868,
0.509090781211853,
0.7159349918365479,
0.6858910918235779,
0.09341592341661453,
0.7894601225852966,
-0.44142648577690125,
0.4448559582233429,
1.1907461881637573,
0.149098202586174,
0.9148764610290527,
0.3313951790332794,
0.11775714159011841,
0.2654590904712677,
0.5266118049621582,
0.08406348526477814,
0.4816052317619324,
0.30993759632110596,
-0.07296112924814224,
-0.5871222019195557,
0.0449051558971405,
-0.44496551156044006,
0.5818020701408386,
0.45082446932792664,
-0.4616551101207733,
-0.4338415265083313,
-0.047553904354572296,
0.12131809443235397,
-0.012028126046061516,
-0.4614521563053131,
0.8173688054084778,
-0.01669221743941307,
-0.9449253678321838,
1.2721500396728516,
-0.21085421741008759,
0.300557941198349,
-0.6241939663887024,
-0.08196592330932617,
-0.14129310846328735,
0.4038640558719635,
-0.11049281060695648,
-0.46828559041023254,
0.4096870720386505,
-0.24581262469291687,
-0.1674078404903412,
-0.45377597212791443,
0.6483606696128845,
-0.9325109720230103,
-0.5442902445793152,
0.26834243535995483,
0.5604310631752014,
-0.1340107023715973,
-0.06853822618722916,
-0.4425685405731201,
0.18919029831886292,
0.21554844081401825,
-0.3956097662448883,
0.23328658938407898,
0.537743866443634,
-0.17308162152767181,
0.910656213760376,
0.37841805815696716,
-0.08162054419517517,
0.12782010436058044,
0.007363434880971909,
0.9144316911697388,
-0.746234655380249,
-0.2949736714363098,
-0.8937084674835205,
0.3719404935836792,
0.22170835733413696,
-0.19546078145503998,
0.7498350143432617,
0.4907926023006439,
0.8086193203926086,
-0.20016513764858246,
0.9786073565483093,
0.12655535340309143,
0.5295289754867554,
-0.6117144823074341,
0.7953482866287231,
-0.5011982917785645,
0.15290330350399017,
-0.27848201990127563,
-0.8870891332626343,
-0.41880184412002563,
0.4865916073322296,
-0.13320785760879517,
0.09041313827037811,
0.648686408996582,
0.655047595500946,
-0.1352536380290985,
-0.22862711548805237,
0.42451921105384827,
0.503206193447113,
0.3834846615791321,
0.8154740333557129,
0.7783689498901367,
-0.08243551105260849,
0.6744242906570435,
-0.0824706107378006,
-0.0206682737916708,
-0.11804170906543732,
-0.9317277669906616,
-0.9593812823295593,
-0.7514550685882568,
-0.40823492407798767,
-0.12246868759393692,
0.04955630376935005,
0.8448638319969177,
0.8595019578933716,
-0.6977037191390991,
-0.09686155617237091,
-0.300784707069397,
-0.16153334081172943,
0.01761695183813572,
-0.15877027809619904,
0.6495695114135742,
-0.3546816110610962,
-0.4305172860622406,
0.5339717268943787,
0.22490639984607697,
0.21405361592769623,
-0.5516899228096008,
-0.10414750874042511,
-0.07050812244415283,
-0.22608721256256104,
0.6647863984107971,
0.4120650589466095,
-0.7717042565345764,
-0.48185813426971436,
-0.08840347081422806,
0.2381112277507782,
0.124996617436409,
0.660815417766571,
-1.1308817863464355,
0.46628960967063904,
0.31007519364356995,
0.6970202326774597,
0.7444131374359131,
0.1587745100259781,
0.7589234709739685,
-0.8832398056983948,
-0.12921471893787384,
0.30725717544555664,
0.4517446458339691,
0.42989158630371094,
-0.22372891008853912,
0.38201814889907837,
0.15158317983150482,
-0.6357507705688477,
-0.6914819478988647,
0.40869200229644775,
-0.7374182343482971,
-0.3762045204639435,
1.0530387163162231,
-0.09061771631240845,
-0.29395592212677,
0.16580486297607422,
-0.19359377026557922,
0.26954033970832825,
-0.20319411158561707,
1.1369342803955078,
0.6505634784698486,
-0.05714915320277214,
-0.5721507668495178,
-0.13194188475608826,
0.692861020565033,
0.38127097487449646,
-0.6730294227600098,
0.7138371467590332,
0.8180961012840271,
0.4099135994911194,
0.05963883548974991,
0.480158269405365,
0.06612798571586609,
0.06516816467046738,
-0.007003611885011196,
0.22966837882995605,
-0.5174108147621155,
-0.4639512598514557,
-0.1692478507757187,
0.41684234142303467,
0.13703830540180206,
-0.06402212381362915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11353v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11353v1 | $\texttt{MoE-RBench}$: Towards Building Reliable Language Models with Sparse Mixture-of-Experts | 2024-06-17T09:17:05 | 2024-06-17T09:17:05 | Guanjie Chen, Xinyu Zhao, Tianlong Chen, Yu Cheng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) has gained increasing popularity as a promising
framework for scaling up large language models (LLMs). However, the reliability
assessment of MoE lags behind its surging applications. Moreover, when
transferred to new domains such as in fine-tuning MoE models sometimes
underperform their dense counterparts. Motivated by the research gap and
counter-intuitive phenomenon, we propose $\texttt{MoE-RBench}$, the first
comprehensive assessment of SMoE reliability from three aspects: $\textit{(i)}$
safety and hallucination, $\textit{(ii)}$ resilience to adversarial attacks,
and $\textit{(iii)}$ out-of-distribution robustness. Extensive models and
datasets are tested to compare the MoE to dense networks from these reliability
dimensions. Our empirical observations suggest that with appropriate
hyperparameters, training recipes, and inference techniques, we can build the
MoE model more reliably than the dense LLM. In particular, we find that the
robustness of SMoE is sensitive to the basic training settings. We hope that
this study can provide deeper insights into how to adapt the pre-trained MoE
model to other tasks with higher-generation security, quality, and stability.
Codes are available at https://github.com/UNITES-Lab/MoE-RBench | [
-0.6176921725273132,
-0.8514074087142944,
0.3047846853733063,
0.2501883804798126,
-0.09285759180784225,
-0.21100568771362305,
-0.3954579532146454,
-0.36279886960983276,
0.24483761191368103,
0.30478882789611816,
-0.3168923258781433,
-0.09063217043876648,
-0.8971933126449585,
0.13145151734352112,
-0.3735280930995941,
0.8971802592277527,
0.3032343089580536,
-0.07910653203725815,
-0.2751866281032562,
-0.24259111285209656,
-0.5342479944229126,
-0.16918927431106567,
-0.31218454241752625,
-0.15475361049175262,
0.39956235885620117,
0.47745364904403687,
0.8143135905265808,
0.3720692992210388,
0.62668377161026,
0.30945003032684326,
0.11487651616334915,
0.004262129310518503,
-0.6638721227645874,
0.3118129372596741,
-0.11830451339483261,
-0.2677932381629944,
-0.7553844451904297,
-0.2017415314912796,
0.6505107879638672,
0.6346192955970764,
-0.5531609058380127,
-0.18865761160850525,
0.27635642886161804,
0.602871298789978,
-0.6250798106193542,
-0.19796311855316162,
-1.2113651037216187,
-0.373781681060791,
-0.26542651653289795,
-0.08174800872802734,
-0.6137112975120544,
0.24981185793876648,
0.14033572375774384,
-0.26759353280067444,
0.05984525755047798,
0.1625373810529709,
0.8036391735076904,
0.26395803689956665,
-0.3726680874824524,
-0.00470627099275589,
-0.47369906306266785,
1.1949923038482666,
-0.7261064052581787,
0.529136598110199,
0.6693885922431946,
0.3430052101612091,
-0.20999689400196075,
-0.5131781101226807,
-0.21513450145721436,
-0.6502329707145691,
0.2143658846616745,
0.14966920018196106,
0.054973240941762924,
0.004475058056414127,
-0.13901406526565552,
0.22703470289707184,
-0.5151025056838989,
0.08355430513620377,
-0.32385024428367615,
-0.18926574289798737,
0.5990301370620728,
-0.027105282992124557,
0.3398648202419281,
-0.05239264667034149,
-0.5790451765060425,
0.09125852584838867,
-0.5487108826637268,
-0.4595637321472168,
0.3055180013179779,
0.08286619186401367,
0.018473271280527115,
0.3988494277000427,
-0.0783192366361618,
0.5358831286430359,
-0.0219462551176548,
-0.16405485570430756,
0.10267166793346405,
-0.1330409198999405,
-0.09307479858398438,
-0.2605860233306885,
0.9458006024360657,
0.28986722230911255,
0.2865014374256134,
-0.4101364314556122,
-0.25161823630332947,
-0.2237875908613205,
0.5201104879379272,
-0.8657780289649963,
-0.4508413076400757,
0.35054272413253784,
-0.25552883744239807,
-0.3488115966320038,
0.18358789384365082,
-0.5694026350975037,
-0.08959925174713135,
-0.0873899981379509,
0.46695268154144287,
-0.5825560688972473,
-0.4906432032585144,
-0.15171314775943756,
0.1132175549864769,
-0.32765504717826843,
0.15507788956165314,
-0.8707771301269531,
0.16587188839912415,
0.5949383974075317,
0.7772501111030579,
-0.11763037741184235,
-0.7314531207084656,
-0.3860953450202942,
0.19004778563976288,
-0.15608488023281097,
0.6916143298149109,
-0.29644256830215454,
-0.34237655997276306,
-0.42074182629585266,
-0.15989379584789276,
-0.028581097722053528,
-0.5878297686576843,
0.3952835500240326,
-0.35698360204696655,
-0.0029745432548224926,
-0.1966799795627594,
-0.48763060569763184,
-0.06946255266666412,
0.5010769963264465,
-0.4000895917415619,
1.0648354291915894,
0.23572708666324615,
-0.900160014629364,
0.3935333490371704,
-0.3104342222213745,
-0.39820826053619385,
0.06277162581682205,
-0.18312744796276093,
-0.42701950669288635,
0.04612014442682266,
0.18289218842983246,
0.8437655568122864,
-0.3323152959346771,
0.4989275634288788,
-0.937538743019104,
-0.20929646492004395,
0.4075061082839966,
-0.759884238243103,
0.9786105155944824,
-0.036825355142354965,
-0.2814745008945465,
-0.17131361365318298,
-0.9487911462783813,
0.15632236003875732,
-0.06702924519777298,
-0.06734936684370041,
-0.2897542119026184,
0.03748052567243576,
-0.13248009979724884,
0.02437238022685051,
0.2599243223667145,
-0.43107786774635315,
-0.16217273473739624,
-0.15448467433452606,
0.49662867188453674,
1.0130641460418701,
-0.055937498807907104,
0.49978089332580566,
-0.18163873255252838,
0.33051908016204834,
-0.015000994317233562,
0.27154308557510376,
-0.05057215690612793,
-0.5908961296081543,
-0.4535572826862335,
-0.6226407289505005,
0.5100725293159485,
0.6117764115333557,
-0.7541280388832092,
0.7925296425819397,
-0.4824312925338745,
-0.5588977932929993,
-0.2702583074569702,
0.3866393268108368,
0.2971007525920868,
0.4389127194881439,
0.22854012250900269,
-0.47964802384376526,
-0.2809329628944397,
-0.8295304179191589,
0.10452041029930115,
-0.2434927225112915,
0.11040931195020676,
0.22975216805934906,
0.5578016042709351,
-0.8717465400695801,
0.8254384994506836,
-0.04363848268985748,
0.1055002361536026,
-0.17049840092658997,
0.12735523283481598,
-0.17855362594127655,
0.5027958750724792,
0.7572627067565918,
-0.4470711946487427,
-0.5813300013542175,
0.37583523988723755,
-0.7745108604431152,
0.029363926500082016,
0.34947943687438965,
-0.38153401017189026,
-0.02611733041703701,
0.07217463850975037,
-0.4425312280654907,
0.06369234621524811,
0.8573322296142578,
0.041023507714271545,
0.607070803642273,
-0.16163980960845947,
0.1621851772069931,
-1.0133532285690308,
0.03343160077929497,
-0.13795262575149536,
-0.17747406661510468,
-0.47503551840782166,
0.28931018710136414,
-0.04934663698077202,
-0.06912030279636383,
-0.1354549080133438,
0.5970996618270874,
-0.36307913064956665,
-0.03746291249990463,
-0.2689055800437927,
0.07590111345052719,
-0.24557164311408997,
0.4426168203353882,
-0.33539295196533203,
0.7565469145774841,
0.7397282719612122,
-0.6084691882133484,
0.4033433496952057,
-0.17773084342479706,
-0.3860776722431183,
0.8030288219451904,
-0.8380287289619446,
0.21201583743095398,
0.23767660558223724,
-0.2024131864309311,
-0.7111567854881287,
-0.5039876103401184,
0.09902288019657135,
-0.6192214488983154,
0.5509548783302307,
-0.028628109022974968,
-0.4459635317325592,
-0.1534336805343628,
-0.15356358885765076,
0.3531762361526489,
0.5663049221038818,
-0.24286092817783356,
0.7229908108711243,
0.5224512815475464,
-0.4152148365974426,
-0.7908016443252563,
-0.8025003671646118,
-0.07170653343200684,
0.04511445388197899,
-1.1624119281768799,
-0.23247000575065613,
-0.2295980453491211,
-0.33941537141799927,
0.03553301468491554,
-0.13828802108764648,
-0.5547277331352234,
0.4642537832260132,
0.21272321045398712,
0.07542750984430313,
-0.344856321811676,
-0.2789604663848877,
0.1653251200914383,
-0.3023720383644104,
-0.096922367811203,
0.09827268123626709,
0.2718646228313446,
-0.32086992263793945,
-0.4090055525302887,
-0.21870268881320953,
0.23515667021274567,
0.6719100475311279,
0.07193806767463684,
0.9947006702423096,
0.4580588638782501,
-0.1510321944952011,
-0.3893103301525116,
-0.6089746356010437,
-0.3918139338493347,
-0.47920072078704834,
0.5978604555130005,
-0.2154363989830017,
-0.7462599873542786,
0.5624431371688843,
0.1998595893383026,
0.19305600225925446,
0.4541180729866028,
0.6082276701927185,
-0.3257286846637726,
0.7466297149658203,
0.6085211038589478,
-0.10659782588481903,
0.34890079498291016,
0.08711829036474228,
0.13020282983779907,
-0.48755112290382385,
0.15562599897384644,
-0.3132813274860382,
-0.11523337662220001,
-0.2614192068576813,
-0.21063260734081268,
0.48448479175567627,
0.19278153777122498,
-0.023246046155691147,
0.43576499819755554,
-0.19276928901672363,
0.4029301702976227,
0.31679627299308777,
0.12233532965183258,
-0.07842515408992767,
0.21912021934986115,
-0.11038538813591003,
0.04462753236293793,
-0.8935877084732056,
-0.5285069942474365,
1.1580581665039062,
0.5314480066299438,
0.6934036612510681,
0.004743575118482113,
0.6786710023880005,
0.09966301918029785,
0.678848147392273,
-0.489246666431427,
0.6516605615615845,
-0.13936500251293182,
-0.9285349249839783,
-0.5012000203132629,
-0.8098040819168091,
-0.8034334778785706,
0.430308073759079,
-0.06713200360536575,
-0.5640801191329956,
0.11541716754436493,
0.41870298981666565,
-0.23680560290813446,
0.17057214677333832,
-0.7644999027252197,
0.68185955286026,
-0.39520207047462463,
-0.4118339419364929,
-0.17152978479862213,
-0.7093420028686523,
0.6582834124565125,
-0.12583212554454803,
0.27134963870048523,
-0.2538565397262573,
0.2586778998374939,
0.4795290529727936,
-0.5179028511047363,
0.6427431702613831,
0.14530102908611298,
-0.13091839849948883,
0.4226430654525757,
0.2171822488307953,
0.47048094868659973,
0.12430769205093384,
-0.3245435059070587,
0.40695834159851074,
-0.25772878527641296,
-0.6667476296424866,
-0.744732141494751,
0.7806404829025269,
-0.7077603936195374,
-0.0902152881026268,
-0.14432115852832794,
-0.5208404064178467,
-0.44859573245048523,
0.2722890079021454,
0.40989378094673157,
0.5278051495552063,
-0.11696233600378036,
0.6964971423149109,
0.7499083876609802,
0.15638099610805511,
-0.029581915587186813,
0.2620178759098053,
-0.037824977189302444,
-0.8071573376655579,
1.1622123718261719,
0.3526940941810608,
0.4427177906036377,
0.17712591588497162,
0.06880893558263779,
0.16118957102298737,
-0.4428013265132904,
-0.5349940061569214,
0.00044683541636914015,
-0.5078868269920349,
-0.1815754622220993,
-0.4802204966545105,
-0.26485133171081543,
-0.1953762173652649,
-0.3091268539428711,
-0.7183886170387268,
-0.17856211960315704,
-0.12864382565021515,
-0.16124965250492096,
0.08818603307008743,
0.554076611995697,
-0.0791100487112999,
0.5256808996200562,
-1.000980019569397,
0.28891438245773315,
0.606555163860321,
0.35918670892715454,
0.16151659190654755,
-0.5444032549858093,
-0.4342188835144043,
0.18274028599262238,
-0.28387874364852905,
-0.684972882270813,
0.019652100279927254,
0.11433695256710052,
0.7353977560997009,
0.6491649150848389,
-0.09795524924993515,
0.47816571593284607,
-0.47247186303138733,
0.6716453433036804,
0.30313432216644287,
-0.6666259765625,
0.24172738194465637,
-0.5649382472038269,
-0.3071524500846863,
0.725567102432251,
0.1497078239917755,
0.17354336380958557,
-0.48341214656829834,
-0.9185287952423096,
-0.9113473892211914,
0.3789982795715332,
0.480024129152298,
0.027775868773460388,
-0.10668513178825378,
0.16182895004749298,
0.35559579730033875,
0.3680090010166168,
-0.7618860006332397,
-0.23326139152050018,
-0.10380290448665619,
-0.2473273128271103,
-0.07906851172447205,
-0.7074902057647705,
-0.08035250753164291,
-0.0007091093575581908,
0.9990866780281067,
0.18215765058994293,
0.20868438482284546,
-0.23353329300880432,
-0.2868213653564453,
-0.12515538930892944,
0.3239603340625763,
0.6667490005493164,
0.8796160221099854,
-0.4404562711715698,
0.18076850473880768,
0.23890705406665802,
-0.6140262484550476,
0.1315539926290512,
-0.09133875370025635,
-0.2798038125038147,
-0.04939095303416252,
0.5869613885879517,
0.8118122816085815,
0.4354875683784485,
-0.5724362730979919,
0.5300601720809937,
0.24960607290267944,
-0.16779425740242004,
0.07554864883422852,
0.1882247030735016,
-0.23509420454502106,
-0.16559678316116333,
0.16079100966453552,
0.3731015622615814,
-0.04046258330345154,
-0.5612201690673828,
0.46046990156173706,
0.4242345094680786,
-0.3077014982700348,
-0.4241827726364136,
0.2775196433067322,
0.5528118014335632,
0.0947219505906105,
0.5202935934066772,
-0.31252753734588623,
-0.4605514705181122,
0.4657900333404541,
0.2028965801000595,
0.8178043961524963,
-0.3468741774559021,
-0.0028168067801743746,
0.06994163244962692,
0.8229908347129822,
-0.40168479084968567,
0.06502703577280045,
0.022293448448181152,
-0.6862501502037048,
-0.39069467782974243,
-0.3403063118457794,
-0.3902001678943634,
-0.2428532987833023,
-0.7258045077323914,
0.025294888764619827,
-0.4540211856365204,
-0.37499648332595825,
-0.7186949849128723,
-0.2352042943239212,
-0.34311264753341675,
0.26495450735092163,
-0.2612304091453552,
0.6518031358718872,
-0.8327633738517761,
0.6123616099357605,
0.5839608907699585,
0.06063568592071533,
-0.5380638837814331,
0.11148568987846375,
-0.30563047528266907,
-0.9287920594215393,
0.4035845994949341,
0.041100550442934036,
-0.22279146313667297,
-0.18308696150779724,
-0.6688582897186279,
-0.682930588722229,
1.0543824434280396,
0.6084312200546265,
-0.8478633761405945,
0.29793351888656616,
-0.3207811415195465,
0.2241867184638977,
0.07693055272102356,
0.3975219130516052,
0.32212576270103455,
0.32017573714256287,
-0.025042884051799774,
-0.9819655418395996,
-0.3649492859840393,
-0.12878355383872986,
-0.09454166144132614,
0.3040524423122406,
-0.7310428023338318,
0.787725031375885,
-0.19831040501594543,
-0.014391113072633743,
0.1930667757987976,
1.0684797763824463,
0.5422627925872803,
0.37821677327156067,
0.44315141439437866,
0.9134020805358887,
0.7894462943077087,
-0.02054644748568535,
1.1267858743667603,
-0.4192948639392853,
0.544211208820343,
1.1133568286895752,
-0.2125653475522995,
1.056675910949707,
0.30461758375167847,
-0.33095815777778625,
0.4682753086090088,
0.12468388676643372,
0.24524715542793274,
0.552987813949585,
-0.2219211608171463,
-0.006198836024850607,
-0.3764549493789673,
0.505411684513092,
-0.4849384129047394,
-0.12338657677173615,
0.3061535954475403,
-0.15697453916072845,
-0.009409974329173565,
0.029242848977446556,
-0.24450525641441345,
-0.3046964108943939,
-0.23415225744247437,
0.3844190537929535,
0.4072246849536896,
-0.2830169200897217,
0.34463146328926086,
-0.06531019508838654,
0.6988216638565063,
-0.7480942010879517,
0.38398823142051697,
-0.1805904358625412,
0.08403604477643967,
-0.04544878005981445,
-0.7328774333000183,
-0.0012405507732182741,
-0.20972010493278503,
-0.4546460807323456,
0.15235231816768646,
0.8284066915512085,
-0.3541123867034912,
-0.5670807361602783,
0.3320891559123993,
0.333373486995697,
0.21946531534194946,
0.0479847751557827,
-0.7795701622962952,
0.20203351974487305,
-0.14659595489501953,
-0.32164108753204346,
0.4949527382850647,
0.8076443672180176,
0.299115389585495,
0.9394380450248718,
0.3493640720844269,
0.08058766275644302,
0.5646688342094421,
-0.15547844767570496,
0.4011702835559845,
-0.26090750098228455,
-0.34163665771484375,
-0.8077272772789001,
0.8608381152153015,
0.02937592752277851,
-0.32342439889907837,
0.9167959094047546,
0.03965826332569122,
0.7321040034294128,
-0.058597467839717865,
0.8317126631736755,
-0.031125057488679886,
0.3476760685443878,
-0.48745328187942505,
0.7453289031982422,
-0.6386054158210754,
0.1215883269906044,
-0.30512991547584534,
-0.9851377606391907,
-0.02270468696951866,
0.7192237973213196,
-0.029651444405317307,
0.4291757643222809,
0.616132915019989,
0.740854024887085,
-0.45704445242881775,
-0.20706263184547424,
0.6151053309440613,
0.4805891811847687,
-0.040865473449230194,
0.2170214205980301,
0.7677960395812988,
-0.5043767690658569,
0.4480426609516144,
-0.5960193872451782,
-0.250407338142395,
-0.5357877016067505,
-0.9001111388206482,
-0.956885576248169,
-0.33878985047340393,
-0.502600908279419,
-0.3470730483531952,
-0.03140958398580551,
0.6758899688720703,
0.9008708596229553,
-0.8598658442497253,
-0.03551800921559334,
-0.14066289365291595,
0.07946686446666718,
-0.24078242480754852,
-0.22254781424999237,
-0.003755671437829733,
-0.32532361149787903,
-0.39305269718170166,
0.3252606689929962,
0.5279965996742249,
0.0305255725979805,
-0.3503898084163666,
-0.3149875998497009,
0.3128565549850464,
0.0434134304523468,
0.5784909129142761,
0.16016067564487457,
-0.7390972375869751,
-0.03917868435382843,
-0.13233797252178192,
-0.16915829479694366,
-0.22892123460769653,
0.4710005223751068,
-0.0053487918339669704,
0.43870294094085693,
0.48666977882385254,
0.9658030271530151,
-0.34130385518074036,
0.005458362400531769,
0.660196840763092,
-0.6718055009841919,
0.05471087247133255,
0.1953718215227127,
0.7212213277816772,
0.20544162392616272,
-0.17579862475395203,
0.3513924181461334,
0.35488343238830566,
-0.9451717138290405,
-1.134077787399292,
0.14503227174282074,
-1.1209605932235718,
-0.07449996471405029,
1.2238662242889404,
-0.2508425712585449,
-0.17236042022705078,
0.017959030345082283,
-0.17405448853969574,
-0.23077845573425293,
-0.4141005575656891,
0.6866616606712341,
1.0522862672805786,
0.18330270051956177,
-0.17995814979076385,
-0.5804728865623474,
-0.17908400297164917,
0.7282580733299255,
-0.5742455124855042,
-0.09666986018419266,
0.20545388758182526,
0.5125421285629272,
0.23904716968536377,
0.6034994125366211,
0.10681527853012085,
0.3039996922016144,
0.16644656658172607,
0.07168818265199661,
-0.10958435386419296,
-0.8355162739753723,
-0.03261575475335121,
0.2726748585700989,
0.29694435000419617,
0.08754555881023407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15484v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15484v1 | JobFair: A Framework for Benchmarking Gender Hiring Bias in Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T09:15:57 | 2024-06-17T09:15:57 | Ze Wang, Zekun Wu, Xin Guan, Michael Thaler, Adriano Koshiyama, Skylar Lu, Sachin Beepath, Ediz Ertekin Jr., Maria Perez-Ortiz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | This paper presents a novel framework for benchmarking hierarchical gender
hiring bias in Large Language Models (LLMs) for resume scoring, revealing
significant issues of reverse bias and overdebiasing. Our contributions are
fourfold: First, we introduce a framework using a real, anonymized resume
dataset from the Healthcare, Finance, and Construction industries, meticulously
used to avoid confounding factors. It evaluates gender hiring biases across
hierarchical levels, including Level bias, Spread bias, Taste-based bias, and
Statistical bias. This framework can be generalized to other social traits and
tasks easily. Second, we propose novel statistical and computational hiring
bias metrics based on a counterfactual approach, including Rank After Scoring
(RAS), Rank-based Impact Ratio, Permutation Test-Based Metrics, and Fixed
Effects Model-based Metrics. These metrics, rooted in labor economics, NLP, and
law, enable holistic evaluation of hiring biases. Third, we analyze hiring
biases in ten state-of-the-art LLMs. Six out of ten LLMs show significant
biases against males in healthcare and finance. An industry-effect regression
reveals that the healthcare industry is the most biased against males. GPT-4o
and GPT-3.5 are the most biased models, showing significant bias in all three
industries. Conversely, Gemini-1.5-Pro, Llama3-8b-Instruct, and
Llama3-70b-Instruct are the least biased. The hiring bias of all LLMs, except
for Llama3-8b-Instruct and Claude-3-Sonnet, remains consistent regardless of
random expansion or reduction of resume content. Finally, we offer a
user-friendly demo to facilitate adoption and practical application of the
framework. | [
0.032567862421274185,
-0.48136305809020996,
0.5208907723426819,
0.2748692035675049,
0.4979779124259949,
0.11480831354856491,
0.2744685113430023,
-0.28203266859054565,
0.06614384055137634,
0.45774102210998535,
-0.7438774704933167,
-0.49800360202789307,
-0.5526090860366821,
-0.06720571219921112,
-0.5402636528015137,
0.8554878830909729,
0.23659513890743256,
0.3391888737678528,
-0.5415900349617004,
0.025122342631220818,
-0.60356605052948,
-0.47122734785079956,
-0.6194127798080444,
-0.3427845239639282,
0.48527345061302185,
0.38612568378448486,
0.6834970712661743,
0.5288857221603394,
0.3598203957080841,
0.19161155819892883,
-0.09666083753108978,
-0.13347360491752625,
-0.6364794969558716,
0.2909434735774994,
-0.3895301818847656,
-0.32747945189476013,
-0.5601691007614136,
0.3136153519153595,
0.6737756729125977,
0.896470308303833,
-0.3576136529445648,
0.5752446055412292,
-0.2643144130706787,
0.7812941670417786,
-0.8520973324775696,
0.11273440718650818,
-0.5621418356895447,
-0.07877884805202484,
-0.24500815570354462,
-0.06366755813360214,
-0.1036444902420044,
-0.4597243368625641,
-0.006743713282048702,
-0.07014439254999161,
0.4167240560054779,
0.34044507145881653,
0.7220122814178467,
-0.1273852437734604,
-0.7344483137130737,
-0.0436241589486599,
-0.5440993905067444,
0.9435834884643555,
-0.5564436912536621,
0.7914702892303467,
0.4790292978286743,
0.438918799161911,
-0.3404473662376404,
-0.32923397421836853,
-0.3130238652229309,
-0.12595176696777344,
0.03880517929792404,
0.010249147191643715,
-0.07342217117547989,
-0.015760518610477448,
0.2029937505722046,
0.44966521859169006,
-0.5465692281723022,
0.27542251348495483,
-0.3074542284011841,
-0.03077980875968933,
0.5676043629646301,
0.164546400308609,
0.1271996945142746,
0.2586486041545868,
-0.18861941993236542,
-0.26853254437446594,
-0.7459363341331482,
0.046455271542072296,
0.9101474285125732,
0.12422169744968414,
-0.013781953603029251,
0.47729742527008057,
-0.26973164081573486,
0.5433361530303955,
0.30727308988571167,
-0.3054853081703186,
0.4137546718120575,
-0.029166871681809425,
-0.02151305601000786,
0.10752604156732559,
0.6489508748054504,
0.45721420645713806,
-0.012692025862634182,
-0.03540055453777313,
-0.31616342067718506,
-0.1456931084394455,
0.6608843207359314,
-0.7164518237113953,
0.4064176380634308,
0.15566249191761017,
-0.6211739778518677,
-0.30527082085609436,
0.08762911707162857,
-1.0455501079559326,
-0.6793447136878967,
0.10981292277574539,
0.1405780017375946,
0.20951294898986816,
-0.03339460492134094,
-0.1262623518705368,
-0.22901006042957306,
0.38548824191093445,
-0.02178916148841381,
-0.8822837471961975,
0.42622843384742737,
0.9509231448173523,
0.640950083732605,
-0.3271115720272064,
-0.32772505283355713,
-0.8280418515205383,
0.024329233914613724,
-0.6299226880073547,
0.5280956625938416,
-0.7110234498977661,
-0.2370252013206482,
0.27166634798049927,
0.023586304858326912,
-0.2049391269683838,
-0.8604540228843689,
0.6033174395561218,
-0.3392670154571533,
0.18495504558086395,
-0.3942401707172394,
-0.24557700753211975,
-0.13809609413146973,
0.36461448669433594,
-0.7513312697410583,
1.1913145780563354,
0.46310073137283325,
-0.7058196067810059,
0.7485690712928772,
-0.5729494690895081,
-0.3312954902648926,
-0.40428251028060913,
-0.7689311504364014,
-0.4793701171875,
-0.11714457720518112,
-0.08797500282526016,
0.3519679009914398,
-0.7652952075004578,
0.5255738496780396,
-0.27246251702308655,
-0.5254452228546143,
0.043137550354003906,
-0.2274937480688095,
0.7546963691711426,
-0.114824078977108,
-0.3005456030368805,
0.12363643944263458,
-0.49549272656440735,
-0.5036588907241821,
-0.13365554809570312,
-0.20358732342720032,
-0.10998300462961197,
-0.12753401696681976,
-0.0243512075394392,
0.5249456167221069,
0.09187515079975128,
-0.7314925789833069,
-0.2148807942867279,
-0.26219335198402405,
-0.03109710104763508,
0.7093299627304077,
-0.1537335216999054,
0.38775938749313354,
-0.5831908583641052,
0.8861046433448792,
0.028891438618302345,
0.10207203775644302,
0.23669752478599548,
-0.3148016929626465,
-0.1787092685699463,
-0.6506171226501465,
0.08884527534246445,
0.6286889910697937,
-0.2728164494037628,
0.46173200011253357,
-0.054045673459768295,
-0.5900706648826599,
-0.5928769111633301,
0.17388993501663208,
0.46487537026405334,
0.7416169047355652,
0.23828661441802979,
-0.35304194688796997,
-0.5920933485031128,
-1.3544479608535767,
-0.8171740174293518,
-0.3471219539642334,
0.03176908195018768,
0.1649314910173416,
0.6808626055717468,
-0.49552497267723083,
0.9774928092956543,
-0.35313379764556885,
-0.630916953086853,
-0.0871395543217659,
0.1480993777513504,
0.7365517616271973,
0.7063215374946594,
0.5248509645462036,
-0.6708162426948547,
0.1641654372215271,
-0.32145562767982483,
-0.5130472779273987,
-0.23780032992362976,
-0.07126646488904953,
-0.4138248562812805,
0.06807687133550644,
0.33073052763938904,
-0.5256595015525818,
0.4243127107620239,
0.7026746273040771,
-0.6786346435546875,
0.6729431748390198,
0.04621405526995659,
0.38055506348609924,
-0.7679669260978699,
0.4377032220363617,
0.4476962685585022,
-0.26177191734313965,
-0.4652980864048004,
0.12198393791913986,
-0.3345101773738861,
0.12913785874843597,
-0.2049717754125595,
0.7908816337585449,
-0.21283170580863953,
-0.46191203594207764,
-0.10003780573606491,
-0.3249623775482178,
0.11478531360626221,
0.2977755665779114,
-0.22717852890491486,
0.5846381187438965,
0.17752140760421753,
-0.1857624053955078,
0.17671656608581543,
0.37810376286506653,
-0.38171014189720154,
0.9651473760604858,
-0.5292391777038574,
0.09146793186664581,
-0.31292757391929626,
0.8139379024505615,
-1.1267826557159424,
0.03983084484934807,
-0.09029578417539597,
-0.1520724594593048,
0.029360223561525345,
-0.2659268379211426,
-0.4269253611564636,
-0.4106576144695282,
-0.49149566888809204,
0.5696669220924377,
0.43871641159057617,
-0.325582891702652,
0.7365685105323792,
0.5291964411735535,
-0.24719028174877167,
-1.0182918310165405,
-0.8274235725402832,
0.03176606819033623,
-0.06988595426082611,
-0.15757641196250916,
0.603351354598999,
0.09286728501319885,
-0.42788389325141907,
-0.4691610038280487,
-0.4234375059604645,
-0.48568305373191833,
0.04835643246769905,
0.5183273553848267,
0.4859672784805298,
0.13110600411891937,
-0.22797277569770813,
0.11368843913078308,
-0.09166651219129562,
0.3070133328437805,
-0.07526333630084991,
0.4027996361255646,
-0.06760266423225403,
-0.5376067161560059,
-0.11550349742174149,
0.29672959446907043,
0.6684628129005432,
0.2807387113571167,
0.7013214826583862,
0.9675796031951904,
-0.5255224108695984,
0.2299010455608368,
-1.0939033031463623,
-0.20074450969696045,
-0.40974321961402893,
0.44465863704681396,
0.009567752480506897,
-0.9744930863380432,
0.5715758800506592,
-0.007598599418997765,
0.33535444736480713,
0.5581362247467041,
0.7182667255401611,
0.10723190009593964,
0.9881766438484192,
0.7268160581588745,
-0.33883461356163025,
0.16643017530441284,
-0.1842460185289383,
0.08983584493398666,
-0.45981428027153015,
-0.349824994802475,
-0.7541660666465759,
-0.32711663842201233,
-0.7836475968360901,
-0.3774569034576416,
0.12155041098594666,
-0.21460673213005066,
-0.4027896821498871,
-0.07530529797077179,
-0.0794069692492485,
0.20666320621967316,
0.6394432187080383,
-0.09232810884714127,
0.11374002695083618,
-0.27263811230659485,
-0.36896035075187683,
-0.01593426801264286,
-0.5597761273384094,
-0.433458536863327,
0.8224540948867798,
0.6043298840522766,
0.554294228553772,
-0.013258947059512138,
0.49641066789627075,
0.6328084468841553,
0.3393610715866089,
-0.3639943301677704,
0.38019126653671265,
-0.4294862151145935,
-1.0488437414169312,
-0.24250006675720215,
-0.4627216160297394,
-0.5821918249130249,
0.304769366979599,
-0.4543484151363373,
-0.6600558757781982,
0.6878647208213806,
0.20062096416950226,
-0.04361758381128311,
0.22918814420700073,
-0.22081254422664642,
0.9732712507247925,
-0.001583111472427845,
-0.6297724843025208,
-0.17878125607967377,
-0.3591356873512268,
0.22060911357402802,
-0.343060702085495,
0.6114192008972168,
-0.3802087604999542,
-0.0657765120267868,
0.9321337342262268,
-0.468232125043869,
0.8967603445053101,
-0.40582898259162903,
-0.22003290057182312,
-0.31229519844055176,
0.26948750019073486,
0.25109395384788513,
-0.04228077083826065,
-0.7366828322410583,
0.6726516485214233,
0.27979573607444763,
-0.4129774272441864,
-0.25806161761283875,
0.6718187928199768,
-0.6198855638504028,
-0.4436758756637573,
-0.5401966571807861,
-0.5731543302536011,
-0.43416938185691833,
0.3558558225631714,
-0.04737698286771774,
0.3781719505786896,
-0.40873679518699646,
0.19626466929912567,
0.21440525352954865,
-0.45968955755233765,
-0.22353526949882507,
0.44457921385765076,
-0.34523558616638184,
-0.19527384638786316,
0.5429377555847168,
0.120214082300663,
-0.20981819927692413,
0.3308795094490051,
0.12143488228321075,
-0.2888988256454468,
-0.022936660796403885,
-0.3289964497089386,
0.2545729875564575,
-0.4877726435661316,
-0.006174643523991108,
-0.5854886174201965,
-0.07801886647939682,
-0.582179069519043,
-0.21316824853420258,
-0.5028181076049805,
0.004320039879530668,
0.18473531305789948,
-0.11609643697738647,
0.07271517813205719,
0.5837689638137817,
0.17063650488853455,
0.20133960247039795,
-0.08544623106718063,
0.5627240538597107,
0.39830389618873596,
0.7166279554367065,
0.058258458971977234,
-0.618824303150177,
-0.24551735818386078,
-0.014836919493973255,
-0.09010719507932663,
-0.5191929340362549,
0.307316392660141,
0.11458291113376617,
0.9097130298614502,
0.35989370942115784,
-0.1187753900885582,
0.4959804117679596,
-0.4262247681617737,
0.6950556635856628,
0.17020994424819946,
-0.8270655870437622,
0.16950039565563202,
-0.5662776231765747,
0.18454532325267792,
1.0965893268585205,
0.5729576945304871,
-0.6500101685523987,
-0.3561503291130066,
-0.4183880686759949,
-0.9575594663619995,
0.7694830894470215,
0.1638253927230835,
-0.006831203121691942,
-0.2931743562221527,
0.30657079815864563,
0.35595017671585083,
0.6317920088768005,
-0.35406991839408875,
-0.32362863421440125,
0.009742220863699913,
-0.3868681490421295,
0.0514303520321846,
-0.5291987061500549,
-0.1712656021118164,
-0.2737426459789276,
0.7063452005386353,
0.021457403898239136,
0.31699585914611816,
0.039609190076589584,
-0.06169836223125458,
-0.13244466483592987,
0.25663137435913086,
0.5256836414337158,
0.922814130783081,
-0.6371049284934998,
0.017483176663517952,
0.2875795066356659,
-0.611412525177002,
0.16529224812984467,
0.10772276669740677,
0.1343473196029663,
0.14445436000823975,
0.30980199575424194,
0.4060666561126709,
0.17610369622707367,
-0.9026324152946472,
0.9419870376586914,
-0.001965050818398595,
-0.46058589220046997,
-0.5183559656143188,
-0.06242528557777405,
-0.036270879209041595,
0.4406157433986664,
0.7492576837539673,
-0.22842533886432648,
0.37066400051116943,
-0.6388872861862183,
0.01654375158250332,
0.5671453475952148,
-0.8456783890724182,
0.05688057094812393,
0.7464970350265503,
0.04886579141020775,
-0.1663852483034134,
0.3862038552761078,
0.1696358472108841,
-0.18523317575454712,
0.7117841243743896,
0.5950660705566406,
0.9816223978996277,
-0.20128989219665527,
0.0456109493970871,
0.36237025260925293,
0.16722138226032257,
-0.5433232188224792,
0.2750781178474426,
0.2958976626396179,
-0.7006270885467529,
-0.26730504631996155,
-0.499826043844223,
-0.6568050980567932,
0.029701314866542816,
-0.7363885641098022,
0.07349015027284622,
-0.6577431559562683,
-0.3566487431526184,
-0.1265142261981964,
-0.23628732562065125,
-0.9913904666900635,
0.39999884366989136,
0.03650752454996109,
0.8731646537780762,
-1.0071338415145874,
0.3489612638950348,
0.9071568250656128,
-0.08662790805101395,
-0.21233433485031128,
0.07635097205638885,
0.3671725392341614,
-0.7971334457397461,
0.945527970790863,
0.36098769307136536,
-0.40082430839538574,
-0.314914345741272,
-0.15256689488887787,
-0.5926173329353333,
1.1297855377197266,
0.6055757999420166,
-0.5794298052787781,
-0.22022804617881775,
0.12440424412488937,
0.3563482463359833,
-0.6639643311500549,
0.8443812131881714,
0.7342047691345215,
0.35790517926216125,
-0.21614785492420197,
-1.1116725206375122,
0.11275052279233932,
-0.2432636320590973,
0.14571772515773773,
-0.30809256434440613,
-0.5172420144081116,
0.7175533771514893,
0.10335977375507355,
0.19205981492996216,
-0.16953012347221375,
0.2646450996398926,
0.5949887633323669,
0.36738458275794983,
0.9596286416053772,
0.16989552974700928,
0.682709813117981,
0.09325537085533142,
0.8084210753440857,
-0.3567560017108917,
0.1532638967037201,
0.8713109493255615,
-0.6704260110855103,
0.641105592250824,
0.5365438461303711,
-0.20289097726345062,
0.9793456196784973,
0.29434219002723694,
-0.0638444796204567,
0.13127341866493225,
0.3289414644241333,
0.13808414340019226,
-0.25319787859916687,
-0.5205323100090027,
-0.40656420588493347,
0.6006110906600952,
0.052414875477552414,
-0.6145766377449036,
-0.15981122851371765,
-0.21456138789653778,
0.10504699498414993,
0.028273489326238632,
-0.15490004420280457,
0.4553495943546295,
0.15100929141044617,
-0.49329251050949097,
0.2900815010070801,
0.19814562797546387,
0.8164963722229004,
-0.5254729390144348,
-0.3105522394180298,
-0.3420822024345398,
0.026371382176876068,
-0.44279909133911133,
-0.4756644070148468,
-0.011422831565141678,
-0.056900784373283386,
-0.5535770654678345,
-0.3244583308696747,
0.7206234335899353,
-0.36472535133361816,
-0.582324206829071,
0.441811740398407,
0.64732426404953,
-0.0340537428855896,
0.08658068627119064,
-0.7399332523345947,
0.05703001469373703,
-0.3402940332889557,
-0.1735270619392395,
0.5141936540603638,
-0.045701801776885986,
-0.19850705564022064,
0.7269500494003296,
0.6254072189331055,
0.22371186316013336,
-0.39619341492652893,
0.42301467061042786,
0.41780737042427063,
-0.7763830423355103,
-0.9507628679275513,
-0.8658245801925659,
0.14885421097278595,
-0.08587947487831116,
-0.29600268602371216,
0.5215065479278564,
0.7271013855934143,
0.6185123920440674,
0.03620561212301254,
0.464071661233902,
0.25390201807022095,
0.8159604072570801,
-0.1570199877023697,
0.6817178726196289,
-0.5293980240821838,
0.285395085811615,
-0.858527660369873,
-0.9696184992790222,
-0.03932729735970497,
0.5994763970375061,
-0.5308620929718018,
0.6375355124473572,
0.34119898080825806,
1.0040024518966675,
0.04877087473869324,
-0.27258428931236267,
0.23234155774116516,
0.08618304878473282,
0.13177183270454407,
0.1528225988149643,
0.5368431806564331,
-0.41737112402915955,
0.28776293992996216,
0.03523123264312744,
-0.15282298624515533,
-0.6389461159706116,
-1.0117664337158203,
-0.6816601157188416,
-0.3733501434326172,
-0.5601038932800293,
-0.3927273154258728,
0.4985642433166504,
1.0004256963729858,
0.925175130367279,
-0.6671476364135742,
-0.7267448306083679,
0.32026204466819763,
0.22393302619457245,
-0.5805202126502991,
-0.281812459230423,
0.01567010022699833,
0.07166948169469833,
-0.28006941080093384,
0.3581528067588806,
0.28795674443244934,
-0.6087526679039001,
-0.424823135137558,
-0.015866683796048164,
-0.6105353236198425,
0.026996193453669548,
0.42127764225006104,
0.17176564037799835,
-0.5366714000701904,
-0.0512753427028656,
-0.39795657992362976,
-0.3397046625614166,
-0.06671850383281708,
0.8235198855400085,
-0.7282655835151672,
0.07909487932920456,
0.36690381169319153,
0.6709531545639038,
0.24446596205234528,
0.1720716506242752,
0.8417629599571228,
-0.8117260932922363,
-0.07835635542869568,
-0.03820372000336647,
0.34704503417015076,
0.2799237370491028,
-0.43438059091567993,
0.5143884420394897,
0.20909857749938965,
-0.4117603600025177,
-0.9227701425552368,
-0.003743614535778761,
-0.768779456615448,
-0.2082892805337906,
1.2172383069992065,
0.2240666300058365,
-0.03078549914062023,
-0.26540079712867737,
0.0841471329331398,
0.24329543113708496,
-0.5677276253700256,
0.8133321404457092,
0.3909590244293213,
0.15740908682346344,
0.08086925745010376,
-1.0052998065948486,
0.3126409947872162,
0.536334753036499,
-0.4360235929489136,
0.07471422106027603,
0.6002719402313232,
0.37223419547080994,
-0.18012453615665436,
0.9101406931877136,
-0.23784886300563812,
0.6056747436523438,
-0.15750151872634888,
0.3349061608314514,
-0.03190844878554344,
-0.13548928499221802,
-0.35732409358024597,
0.108001708984375,
0.22417384386062622,
0.03981569781899452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11345v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11345v1 | Full-ECE: A Metric For Token-level Calibration on Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T09:07:58 | 2024-06-17T09:07:58 | Han Liu, Yupeng Zhang, Bingning Wang, Weipeng Chen, Xiaolin Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) excel in various domains but face challenges in
providing accurate uncertainty estimates, which are crucial for high-stakes
applications. Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently emerged as powerful
tools, demonstrating exceptional performance in language tasks. However,
traditional calibration metrics such as Expected Calibration Error (ECE) and
classwise-ECE (cw-ECE) are inadequate for LLMs due to their vast vocabularies,
data complexity, and distributional focus. To address this, we propose a novel
calibration concept called full calibration and introduce its corresponding
metric, Full-ECE. Full-ECE evaluates the entire predicted probability
distribution, offering a more accurate and robust measure of calibration for
LLMs. | [
-0.3196443021297455,
-0.43787437677383423,
0.6189892888069153,
0.02377385087311268,
-0.1770220398902893,
0.1953767091035843,
-0.7569634318351746,
-0.00756057957187295,
0.21023911237716675,
0.31280413269996643,
-0.33988678455352783,
-0.8098569512367249,
-0.7452123165130615,
-0.10000690072774887,
-0.3952416181564331,
0.6971085667610168,
-0.017609838396310806,
0.11106704920530319,
-0.031123043969273567,
-0.030823029577732086,
-0.26984265446662903,
-0.20115165412425995,
-0.7438661456108093,
-0.19292481243610382,
0.9453829526901245,
0.23399363458156586,
0.5348765254020691,
0.5729826092720032,
0.3286817669868469,
0.2266920655965805,
0.057037100195884705,
0.10352302342653275,
-0.3260844051837921,
-0.16274870932102203,
-0.18051418662071228,
-0.6467038989067078,
-0.553131103515625,
-0.10048401355743408,
0.6584869623184204,
1.0350210666656494,
-0.2758309841156006,
0.21319745481014252,
0.037043336778879166,
0.9522672295570374,
-1.038418173789978,
0.09412796050310135,
-0.5323838591575623,
0.10860786586999893,
0.09613870829343796,
0.0426950603723526,
-0.4294648766517639,
-0.08111919462680817,
0.3538229167461395,
-0.7157511115074158,
-0.07965110242366791,
-0.11743097007274628,
0.5026730895042419,
0.41888290643692017,
-0.5865128636360168,
-0.03922272473573685,
-0.7827626466751099,
0.8321440815925598,
-0.7724836468696594,
0.4315629303455353,
0.3389550447463989,
0.33452317118644714,
-0.031506091356277466,
-0.601341187953949,
-0.6124613285064697,
-0.12968945503234863,
0.41339540481567383,
0.16546905040740967,
0.025970090180635452,
0.4495048522949219,
0.019964788109064102,
0.5196775794029236,
-0.29403775930404663,
0.4804486930370331,
0.029786795377731323,
-0.2216576188802719,
0.5760459303855896,
-0.05610397085547447,
0.034646619111299515,
0.3138055205345154,
-0.20072750747203827,
-0.3368425667285919,
-0.7343776226043701,
-0.15984097123146057,
0.6044683456420898,
0.29389986395835876,
-0.15691611170768738,
0.372194766998291,
0.056314706802368164,
0.6713377833366394,
-0.22618171572685242,
0.16635002195835114,
0.052960291504859924,
-0.11262723058462143,
-0.4953760802745819,
0.09364770352840424,
0.8370860815048218,
0.2379370778799057,
0.4766573905944824,
-0.1355871558189392,
-0.12938234210014343,
-0.14059653878211975,
-0.025634760037064552,
-0.8684771060943604,
-0.23337064683437347,
0.25792232155799866,
0.17054496705532074,
-0.49997130036354065,
0.2618889808654785,
-0.742123007774353,
-0.511070191860199,
-0.5835434198379517,
0.3190024197101593,
-0.12595513463020325,
-0.35088086128234863,
0.3517411947250366,
0.2539999485015869,
0.2395644336938858,
0.40710076689720154,
-0.5780812501907349,
0.23026670515537262,
0.8495482802391052,
0.6464007496833801,
-0.039650823920965195,
-0.25475966930389404,
-0.48485231399536133,
-0.05814109742641449,
-0.7320783138275146,
0.3967505991458893,
-0.35313981771469116,
-0.185913547873497,
0.1106746643781662,
-0.044558364897966385,
0.009360362775623798,
-0.11388223618268967,
0.7371678948402405,
-0.57989102602005,
-0.06417389214038849,
0.016386032104492188,
-0.9610421657562256,
-0.37933090329170227,
0.4037614166736603,
-0.7292289733886719,
0.898691713809967,
-0.1706886887550354,
-0.5923712253570557,
0.5246551632881165,
-0.20150591433048248,
-0.06426617503166199,
0.21923084557056427,
-0.2608385682106018,
-0.20933860540390015,
0.19698379933834076,
0.20935501158237457,
0.3960483968257904,
-0.4595985412597656,
0.48550111055374146,
-0.5313355326652527,
-0.5115564465522766,
0.2340085357427597,
-1.0944187641143799,
0.6814770102500916,
-0.020302673801779747,
-0.4146774411201477,
0.06604276597499847,
-0.8338350653648376,
0.18975745141506195,
-0.3919408619403839,
-0.0669829398393631,
-0.3321347236633301,
0.11168597638607025,
-0.0640481561422348,
-0.11853013932704926,
0.3122957944869995,
-0.8698238730430603,
0.06698688864707947,
-0.6413154006004333,
0.4224707782268524,
0.8809057474136353,
-0.34430167078971863,
0.5517123937606812,
-0.04510243609547615,
0.3862159252166748,
0.1698039323091507,
-0.025826888158917427,
-0.08522145450115204,
-0.2239745855331421,
-0.8037591576576233,
-0.5354207754135132,
0.8951349258422852,
0.7246583700180054,
-0.22539596259593964,
1.221131682395935,
-0.6439318060874939,
-0.6282670497894287,
-0.45308345556259155,
0.16174258291721344,
0.03539387881755829,
0.13071535527706146,
-0.08613352477550507,
-0.053262822329998016,
-0.5020224452018738,
-0.8450223207473755,
0.024770190939307213,
-0.1408659964799881,
-0.3124794363975525,
0.3361104130744934,
0.5447729229927063,
-0.08347592502832413,
0.6530597805976868,
-0.16412310302257538,
-0.3253728151321411,
0.08984309434890747,
-0.07810298353433609,
0.40180179476737976,
0.2015083283185959,
0.17389971017837524,
-0.4842449128627777,
-0.49566587805747986,
0.0753059908747673,
-0.38420185446739197,
0.06957390904426575,
-0.05279497429728508,
-0.19230510294437408,
-0.03874383866786957,
0.1914418339729309,
-0.3666684925556183,
0.6255390048027039,
0.8000850081443787,
-0.20306508243083954,
0.4581616222858429,
-0.35917043685913086,
0.1915513426065445,
-1.0384708642959595,
0.07250407338142395,
0.28377869725227356,
-0.37074971199035645,
-0.3584604561328888,
0.17338992655277252,
0.3151807487010956,
0.16376574337482452,
-0.49212905764579773,
0.6800922155380249,
-0.34916770458221436,
-0.05117297172546387,
-0.06969678401947021,
0.49664419889450073,
0.33756300806999207,
0.141665980219841,
-0.11327937245368958,
0.8003948926925659,
0.788740873336792,
-0.5858576893806458,
0.7402506470680237,
-0.06449475139379501,
-0.6158248782157898,
0.5109429955482483,
-0.5280323624610901,
0.004396469797939062,
0.01680067926645279,
0.48689302802085876,
-1.0221120119094849,
0.014578191563487053,
-0.5434035658836365,
-0.27822044491767883,
0.5785754323005676,
0.009806888177990913,
-0.5522522330284119,
-0.45515963435173035,
-0.4375227987766266,
0.8108302354812622,
0.2660905122756958,
-0.5290849208831787,
0.43110617995262146,
0.15344974398612976,
0.2185664027929306,
-0.9883506894111633,
-0.8308828473091125,
0.4592221677303314,
0.11625179648399353,
-0.6464546918869019,
0.3446692228317261,
-0.07715185731649399,
-0.10539168119430542,
-0.22465220093727112,
0.05165776610374451,
0.01078276988118887,
0.11996500939130783,
0.05894187465310097,
0.36543071269989014,
-0.4932267367839813,
0.06068155914545059,
-0.17404749989509583,
0.06381171196699142,
-0.07059837132692337,
-0.4104669392108917,
0.6158825755119324,
-0.027699409052729607,
-0.6722339987754822,
-0.6137518286705017,
0.09084977209568024,
0.6466783881187439,
-0.10234636813402176,
0.6843950748443604,
0.3033163249492645,
-0.5767733454704285,
-0.36620819568634033,
-0.799106776714325,
-0.21966910362243652,
-0.45138150453567505,
0.7863118648529053,
-0.23960992693901062,
-0.5469000339508057,
0.7061708569526672,
0.17726147174835205,
0.10776391625404358,
0.44656193256378174,
0.4491861164569855,
0.060187965631484985,
1.088174819946289,
0.5219845175743103,
-0.17786653339862823,
0.2788679301738739,
-0.3088456094264984,
0.4603222608566284,
-1.149706482887268,
0.06396691501140594,
-0.410248339176178,
-0.619439423084259,
-0.5201032161712646,
-0.5639047622680664,
-0.05350609868764877,
0.17751547694206238,
-0.847949743270874,
0.1926930993795395,
-0.4252772331237793,
0.667698860168457,
0.5389741659164429,
0.11777704209089279,
0.2014501839876175,
-0.022791676223278046,
-0.14235208928585052,
-0.12624335289001465,
-0.15299545228481293,
-0.6859626173973083,
1.401606559753418,
0.3440621793270111,
0.6542761325836182,
-0.14562897384166718,
0.6020799279212952,
0.06605478376150131,
0.3022603392601013,
-1.0928380489349365,
0.2965187728404999,
-0.48835957050323486,
-0.6565272808074951,
-0.4453737139701843,
-0.568124532699585,
-0.6525281071662903,
0.07788505405187607,
0.13480551540851593,
-1.001230239868164,
0.177056223154068,
-0.1288699358701706,
-0.5429275035858154,
0.9047654271125793,
-0.3477579951286316,
0.8163505792617798,
-0.3569348156452179,
-0.18521209061145782,
-0.13611236214637756,
-0.26712170243263245,
0.1799682229757309,
-0.13009978830814362,
0.28011953830718994,
-0.36088091135025024,
-0.47794675827026367,
0.5494054555892944,
-0.17165561020374298,
0.8978935480117798,
-0.18673481047153473,
-0.2647448480129242,
0.3052317798137665,
0.34570130705833435,
0.5985885858535767,
0.019869567826390266,
-0.39049893617630005,
0.20891687273979187,
0.11200982332229614,
-0.43886324763298035,
-0.523909866809845,
0.8316314816474915,
-0.9865947365760803,
-0.4082321226596832,
-0.3688727617263794,
-0.4517422914505005,
-0.3957321047782898,
-0.010586312040686607,
0.20788778364658356,
0.35077354311943054,
-0.44332313537597656,
0.46403053402900696,
0.6421858668327332,
-0.5232653021812439,
0.44064605236053467,
0.308542400598526,
-0.10865435004234314,
-0.6596699953079224,
0.8026314377784729,
0.043592315167188644,
0.418866902589798,
0.6641499996185303,
0.15628254413604736,
-0.45557093620300293,
-0.3900884985923767,
-0.7194300293922424,
0.16286107897758484,
-0.6922034025192261,
-0.2981683611869812,
-0.24329175055027008,
-0.47112393379211426,
-0.07621917128562927,
-0.2612767815589905,
-0.584556519985199,
-0.42406409978866577,
-0.4657494127750397,
-0.5270819067955017,
0.24796311557292938,
0.4362216889858246,
0.02420930564403534,
0.2655210494995117,
-0.6365567445755005,
-0.40315747261047363,
0.21292002499103546,
0.5478410720825195,
0.1346275806427002,
-0.7543261051177979,
0.018620457500219345,
0.5658544301986694,
-0.23432514071464539,
-0.6451507806777954,
0.11553417146205902,
0.5847920775413513,
0.3987168073654175,
0.2572549283504486,
-0.038010068237781525,
0.5169408321380615,
-0.5463680028915405,
0.9644602537155151,
0.5321432948112488,
-0.894698441028595,
0.18868324160575867,
-0.24683526158332825,
0.10551530122756958,
0.8173558712005615,
-0.16723157465457916,
-0.8084939122200012,
-0.23356622457504272,
-0.3269509971141815,
-1.0792505741119385,
0.22208549082279205,
-0.12909194827079773,
0.7314043045043945,
-0.06446104496717453,
0.4581478238105774,
0.047042835503816605,
0.3217899203300476,
-0.630391001701355,
-0.38052448630332947,
0.05307498574256897,
-0.7619563341140747,
-0.1628192812204361,
-0.12154180556535721,
-0.10164395719766617,
-0.3084539771080017,
0.8211656212806702,
-0.2267887145280838,
0.0896570086479187,
0.035129137337207794,
-0.05447093024849892,
-0.2753719389438629,
0.32612717151641846,
0.4453573524951935,
0.6865828037261963,
-0.10336847603321075,
0.13368907570838928,
0.21863748133182526,
-0.5611591339111328,
0.34308895468711853,
-0.1083008423447609,
-0.04195906221866608,
-0.26426610350608826,
0.22788268327713013,
0.9291175603866577,
0.3769839107990265,
-0.6989884972572327,
1.2216349840164185,
-0.11128528416156769,
-0.40190398693084717,
-0.7187062501907349,
-0.2124379724264145,
0.08325739204883575,
-0.17781704664230347,
0.5339212417602539,
-0.14088164269924164,
-0.015683265402913094,
-0.23784621059894562,
0.47413498163223267,
0.3482058048248291,
-0.9004095196723938,
-0.40598538517951965,
0.6240986585617065,
0.3177665174007416,
-0.09028763324022293,
0.6839612126350403,
-0.03282764554023743,
-0.4350104331970215,
1.0233418941497803,
0.3464692234992981,
1.268708348274231,
0.030939141288399696,
0.28460797667503357,
0.5378738641738892,
0.36991211771965027,
-0.04655347764492035,
0.1608041524887085,
0.21639442443847656,
-0.8721319437026978,
-1.05185866355896,
-1.0777453184127808,
-0.33594369888305664,
0.18769660592079163,
-0.6745508313179016,
0.48523953557014465,
-0.49684104323387146,
-0.11923752725124359,
-0.1794222891330719,
0.09811712801456451,
-1.103175401687622,
0.28433942794799805,
0.550418496131897,
1.2393392324447632,
-0.5444463491439819,
0.7123952507972717,
0.5625960230827332,
0.008548663929104805,
-1.0239744186401367,
-0.3298913538455963,
-0.10337671637535095,
-0.8587288856506348,
0.5782479643821716,
0.32906901836395264,
0.033484142273664474,
0.028619952499866486,
-0.1571994423866272,
-0.89974045753479,
1.2074387073516846,
0.5114133954048157,
-1.1997171640396118,
-0.16378723084926605,
0.2991747260093689,
0.542772650718689,
-0.4322758615016937,
0.5115166306495667,
0.6086450219154358,
0.6209139823913574,
0.10156548768281937,
-1.0306364297866821,
-0.15455177426338196,
0.07796530425548553,
0.08260496705770493,
0.4267708361148834,
-0.4322252869606018,
0.5302509665489197,
-0.045472096651792526,
-0.06004111096262932,
0.12626290321350098,
0.5101398229598999,
0.01700623147189617,
-0.052317891269922256,
0.7302069067955017,
0.8945264220237732,
0.7678409814834595,
-0.30019694566726685,
0.9476969242095947,
-0.5151610970497131,
0.4941309988498688,
1.0167429447174072,
-0.362032949924469,
1.03298819065094,
0.3313616216182709,
-0.44698816537857056,
0.2049354612827301,
0.7185988426208496,
0.10511737316846848,
0.3180379569530487,
0.523983359336853,
-0.5200846195220947,
-0.4363757371902466,
0.18451820313930511,
0.013696843758225441,
0.25958946347236633,
0.527970016002655,
-0.274649441242218,
-0.07355447858572006,
-0.00884969625622034,
-0.11058885604143143,
-0.024185236543416977,
-0.5172290802001953,
0.7265627384185791,
0.3474010229110718,
-0.44694867730140686,
0.3014857769012451,
-0.26985183358192444,
0.8357784748077393,
-0.3459007143974304,
0.3346816599369049,
0.031600434333086014,
0.5032071471214294,
-0.1406843066215515,
-0.9431548118591309,
0.01967421919107437,
-0.06159443408250809,
0.1288939118385315,
0.3461167514324188,
-0.05406207591295242,
-0.5101538896560669,
-0.9381939172744751,
0.5576398968696594,
0.42799264192581177,
-0.038220204412937164,
-0.2567744553089142,
-0.6291918158531189,
-0.24520759284496307,
0.04271920770406723,
-0.6234024167060852,
0.27864518761634827,
0.7114742994308472,
0.44317427277565,
0.441998153924942,
0.43348532915115356,
0.4636169373989105,
0.284553200006485,
0.382827490568161,
0.38074806332588196,
-0.3876885771751404,
-0.29533299803733826,
-0.9712632298469543,
0.6092643737792969,
-0.151916965842247,
-0.4854528307914734,
0.23559781908988953,
0.6258202195167542,
0.804200291633606,
0.4074496924877167,
0.7125521302223206,
0.15040963888168335,
0.27330344915390015,
-0.047908395528793335,
0.6116597652435303,
-0.7762495279312134,
0.35352396965026855,
-0.13397644460201263,
-1.301289677619934,
-0.6360543966293335,
0.7153894305229187,
-0.21062640845775604,
-0.09977086633443832,
0.6321882009506226,
0.723887026309967,
-0.13716834783554077,
0.08165954798460007,
0.8094738721847534,
0.10721641033887863,
0.4188448488712311,
0.5919603705406189,
0.4889889657497406,
-0.6415700912475586,
0.5392839312553406,
-0.5229713320732117,
-0.4025201201438904,
0.0631614476442337,
-1.1369774341583252,
-0.671209990978241,
-0.4538429379463196,
-0.43738794326782227,
-0.11649711430072784,
-0.20837514102458954,
1.035231590270996,
0.8047233819961548,
-1.0534281730651855,
-0.20808932185173035,
-0.23968423902988434,
-0.3170745074748993,
-0.04354904592037201,
-0.2142462432384491,
0.49924978613853455,
-0.21037302911281586,
-0.9422487616539001,
0.11388935148715973,
0.3215964734554291,
-0.057400040328502655,
-0.5839333534240723,
0.01728000119328499,
-0.0019736234098672867,
0.4009748697280884,
0.3523825407028198,
-0.05539213865995407,
-0.7526293992996216,
-0.5687903761863708,
-0.0057189492508769035,
-0.40311139822006226,
0.04821307957172394,
0.6144258975982666,
-0.28903868794441223,
0.4420674741268158,
0.2882232666015625,
0.9807018041610718,
0.5177335739135742,
-0.5306187272071838,
0.8332021832466125,
-0.987760603427887,
0.2702334225177765,
0.5302243232727051,
0.7678826451301575,
0.46207496523857117,
-0.2313505858182907,
0.44122517108917236,
-0.15342611074447632,
-0.8352779746055603,
-1.0728529691696167,
0.35812920331954956,
-0.8405115008354187,
0.013287637382745743,
1.1165351867675781,
-0.3006323277950287,
-0.4615831673145294,
0.37782198190689087,
-0.07172568142414093,
0.2884063124656677,
-0.3523332476615906,
0.44435110688209534,
1.0058854818344116,
0.6849382519721985,
-0.07046926021575928,
-0.8611749410629272,
0.014400193467736244,
0.3532244563102722,
-0.49131160974502563,
0.3632488250732422,
0.36511996388435364,
0.3379581570625305,
0.06065107509493828,
0.11785509437322617,
0.01218933891505003,
0.08701593428850174,
-0.15037664771080017,
0.29062971472740173,
0.15229949355125427,
-0.2083663046360016,
-0.09311822056770325,
-0.12682928144931793,
0.20551609992980957,
-0.0005442010005936027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11341v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11341v1 | A Systematic Analysis of Large Language Models as Soft Reasoners: The Case of Syllogistic Inferences | 2024-06-17T08:59:04 | 2024-06-17T08:59:04 | Leonardo Bertolazzi, Albert Gatt, Raffaella Bernardi | cs.CL | cs.CL | The reasoning abilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) are becoming a
central focus of study in NLP. In this paper, we consider the case of
syllogistic reasoning, an area of deductive reasoning studied extensively in
logic and cognitive psychology. Previous research has shown that pre-trained
LLMs exhibit reasoning biases, such as $\textit{content effects}$, avoid
answering that $\textit{no conclusion follows}$, display human-like
difficulties, and struggle with multi-step reasoning. We contribute to this
research line by systematically investigating the effects of chain-of-thought
reasoning, in-context learning (ICL), and supervised fine-tuning (SFT) on
syllogistic reasoning, considering syllogisms with conclusions that support or
violate world knowledge, as well as ones with multiple premises. Crucially, we
go beyond the standard focus on accuracy, with an in-depth analysis of the
conclusions generated by the models. Our results suggest that the behavior of
pre-trained LLMs can be explained by heuristics studied in cognitive science
and that both ICL and SFT improve model performance on valid inferences,
although only the latter mitigates most reasoning biases without harming model
consistency. | [
-0.21844254434108734,
-0.9098822474479675,
0.8410255312919617,
-0.19053052365779877,
-0.2584426701068878,
-0.2992890775203705,
-0.44343140721321106,
-0.29291388392448425,
-0.18693222105503082,
0.6134648323059082,
-0.42121466994285583,
-0.38547763228416443,
-0.7192647457122803,
0.22393624484539032,
-0.33055517077445984,
1.00295889377594,
0.16097620129585266,
0.13200919330120087,
-0.15403001010417938,
-0.09168863296508789,
-0.5229395031929016,
-0.6820027828216553,
-0.491571843624115,
-0.5394987463951111,
0.3742605149745941,
-0.048375170677900314,
0.6482086181640625,
0.4178093373775482,
0.32983535528182983,
0.3052181601524353,
-0.443514883518219,
0.28619319200515747,
-0.4766065776348114,
0.5415878891944885,
-0.5637059211730957,
-0.6742927432060242,
-0.3466417193412781,
-0.03217479586601257,
0.577806293964386,
0.7189034223556519,
-0.30834347009658813,
0.038139261305332184,
0.28472277522087097,
0.42052793502807617,
-0.8358945250511169,
0.23005709052085876,
-0.8367880582809448,
-0.1871626228094101,
-0.1688198447227478,
-0.0716828778386116,
-0.8947638869285583,
-0.23007962107658386,
0.22204524278640747,
-0.49701404571533203,
-0.07625564932823181,
-0.2883237898349762,
0.5925596952438354,
0.7198388576507568,
-0.6027876138687134,
-0.15529760718345642,
-0.7496373057365417,
1.0439119338989258,
-0.9441638588905334,
0.36688336730003357,
0.26132503151893616,
0.16865003108978271,
-0.4259796738624573,
-0.6776872873306274,
-0.33497995138168335,
-0.09155053645372391,
-0.2420196831226349,
0.008396991528570652,
-0.38348668813705444,
0.42965927720069885,
0.7870725393295288,
-0.0752972960472107,
-0.4363020956516266,
0.055374015122652054,
-0.20365074276924133,
0.06547340750694275,
0.6925649046897888,
0.10974100977182388,
0.0765192061662674,
-0.15179653465747833,
-0.0724138617515564,
0.14962315559387207,
-0.7307078242301941,
0.08909042179584503,
-0.11248432844877243,
0.19727201759815216,
0.04150880500674248,
0.3371901214122772,
-0.34339791536331177,
1.2202237844467163,
-0.19436921179294586,
-0.39181143045425415,
-0.23256470263004303,
0.05452946200966835,
-0.4234914481639862,
0.17600944638252258,
0.5736374855041504,
0.10770052671432495,
0.7277079224586487,
0.055440180003643036,
-0.21204756200313568,
0.3625373840332031,
0.11103790253400803,
-0.6440972685813904,
-0.1945187896490097,
0.10968703776597977,
-0.5248957872390747,
0.020225316286087036,
-0.13099342584609985,
-0.14004558324813843,
-0.29671281576156616,
-0.6823827028274536,
0.4541420638561249,
-0.3879731297492981,
-0.1837257742881775,
0.3979305922985077,
-0.24148818850517273,
-0.051781654357910156,
0.5535402894020081,
-0.574429988861084,
0.28128349781036377,
0.9727052450180054,
0.6053443551063538,
0.1585271954536438,
-0.10888943821191788,
-0.44563013315200806,
0.3225886821746826,
-0.26764002442359924,
0.9386681914329529,
-0.4572077989578247,
-0.08953409641981125,
-0.1993238627910614,
-0.15546908974647522,
-0.15275081992149353,
-0.469537615776062,
0.1953778713941574,
-0.12917117774486542,
0.0866452008485794,
-0.1411520540714264,
-0.5007194876670837,
-0.34876713156700134,
0.36888691782951355,
-0.5020796656608582,
0.5086033940315247,
-0.2780212461948395,
-0.6827146410942078,
0.5606061220169067,
-0.13064366579055786,
-0.45778849720954895,
-0.011221859604120255,
-0.40047702193260193,
0.03421533480286598,
0.4022996425628662,
0.1076854020357132,
0.47788286209106445,
-0.46656420826911926,
0.6622225046157837,
-0.5673531889915466,
-0.3283097445964813,
0.484019935131073,
-0.47830381989479065,
0.9925075769424438,
0.11413346976041794,
-0.5223549008369446,
0.17200496792793274,
-0.3878830075263977,
0.185808464884758,
-0.26736873388290405,
-0.08984137326478958,
-0.7004470825195312,
0.3912453353404999,
-0.49366405606269836,
0.46369174122810364,
-0.1264471560716629,
-0.24191716313362122,
0.23052284121513367,
-0.5517624616622925,
0.6841784119606018,
0.9661655426025391,
-0.3088759481906891,
0.23613713681697845,
-0.07232960313558578,
0.27195268869400024,
-0.19700734317302704,
0.35545793175697327,
-0.2538914978504181,
-0.5140962600708008,
-0.652160108089447,
-0.2654685080051422,
0.08468888700008392,
0.28689491748809814,
-0.4918766915798187,
-0.06305836886167526,
0.014358315616846085,
-0.325765460729599,
-0.30964791774749756,
0.20360560715198517,
0.5359925031661987,
0.4369097352027893,
0.31717783212661743,
-0.11286552250385284,
-0.3341839611530304,
-0.8903892040252686,
-0.6419921517372131,
-0.19534067809581757,
0.23608313500881195,
0.18448463082313538,
0.44472628831863403,
-0.03736089542508125,
0.8544779419898987,
-0.4136750400066376,
-0.047956064343452454,
-0.36965125799179077,
-0.1074250265955925,
0.449078768491745,
0.23565684258937836,
0.282725065946579,
-0.5783604979515076,
-0.1027998998761177,
-0.16989703476428986,
-0.8624758124351501,
-0.21077154576778412,
0.06575106829404831,
0.008363460190594196,
0.39376169443130493,
0.6117468476295471,
-0.9940371513366699,
0.6702113151550293,
0.3028937578201294,
-0.4626702070236206,
0.5293170809745789,
-0.09653019160032272,
-0.21368037164211273,
-0.6898081302642822,
-0.06340062618255615,
0.2629963755607605,
-0.0546642430126667,
-0.43401244282722473,
0.313637912273407,
-0.2568846046924591,
0.2247937172651291,
-0.2647102177143097,
0.6877183318138123,
-0.32464003562927246,
0.1530638188123703,
-0.20679257810115814,
0.0885586366057396,
-0.04322216287255287,
0.07082240283489227,
0.21036750078201294,
0.3316488564014435,
0.2753608524799347,
-0.5695785284042358,
0.2429409772157669,
-0.11861658841371536,
-0.2107180505990982,
0.5191882252693176,
-0.6928247809410095,
-0.07621864974498749,
-0.1560194194316864,
0.6864793300628662,
-0.9209524989128113,
-0.07309398800134659,
-0.07421360164880753,
-0.1238592267036438,
0.10525291413068771,
-0.27335304021835327,
-0.5018981099128723,
-0.3395819365978241,
0.13133755326271057,
0.3638060986995697,
0.4533011317253113,
-0.3493266701698303,
0.6131427884101868,
0.38292524218559265,
0.05344817414879799,
-0.5402722358703613,
-0.43778055906295776,
-0.11287911981344223,
-0.3560599386692047,
-0.5360376834869385,
0.0291903093457222,
0.07729267328977585,
-1.0994107723236084,
-0.3141600489616394,
-0.3854140341281891,
-0.20604528486728668,
0.2446926236152649,
0.37160488963127136,
0.16074267029762268,
-0.29310768842697144,
0.4471842348575592,
0.10523253679275513,
-0.26952293515205383,
0.3006889224052429,
-0.45253607630729675,
0.48502597212791443,
-0.20264293253421783,
-0.33443304896354675,
-0.4053484797477722,
0.00020231568487361073,
0.3340966999530792,
-0.24607113003730774,
0.5903164744377136,
0.12820903956890106,
-0.3204441964626312,
-0.5966436266899109,
-0.7484394311904907,
-0.6502161622047424,
-0.393198162317276,
0.038611143827438354,
-0.413727730512619,
-1.0235415697097778,
0.1279028356075287,
-0.11214625090360641,
-0.029842372983694077,
0.4471377432346344,
0.6378269791603088,
-0.16612447798252106,
1.3846065998077393,
0.2733714282512665,
0.11702793836593628,
0.1270262897014618,
-0.29003164172172546,
0.2755744457244873,
-0.3781835436820984,
-0.29994943737983704,
-0.5314018130302429,
-0.35639679431915283,
-0.7369974851608276,
-0.3208482265472412,
0.36132949590682983,
0.09711854159832001,
-0.33809933066368103,
0.07314403355121613,
-0.5104011297225952,
0.5828210115432739,
0.3379736840724945,
0.3607449531555176,
0.3625362813472748,
-0.28348565101623535,
-0.0121754826977849,
0.1323469877243042,
-0.8606603145599365,
-0.5340064167976379,
0.8895441293716431,
0.19875361025333405,
1.115077018737793,
0.09420882910490036,
0.5326772928237915,
-0.16628137230873108,
0.23857107758522034,
-0.7890492081642151,
0.64851313829422,
-0.45182234048843384,
-0.7292928695678711,
-0.26100069284439087,
-0.35763153433799744,
-0.7551647424697876,
0.41664424538612366,
-0.1269330382347107,
-0.8364349603652954,
0.0905778780579567,
0.41524580121040344,
-0.37640371918678284,
0.250013530254364,
-0.5495022535324097,
0.8192346096038818,
-0.25787678360939026,
-0.4799509346485138,
-0.7427908778190613,
-0.7396211624145508,
0.5952240824699402,
0.16037988662719727,
0.270060271024704,
-0.21828895807266235,
0.3197622001171112,
0.6021768450737,
-0.4664784073829651,
0.9438463449478149,
-0.13497933745384216,
-0.29131418466567993,
0.30538883805274963,
0.29166412353515625,
0.19114845991134644,
0.1682756245136261,
-0.18078111112117767,
0.24133437871932983,
0.21247436106204987,
-0.27089136838912964,
-0.6879640817642212,
0.5900729894638062,
-0.4104110300540924,
-1.1396631002426147,
-0.39382749795913696,
-0.808398962020874,
-0.11773163080215454,
0.16214647889137268,
0.11091407388448715,
0.42113029956817627,
0.12933798134326935,
0.28897011280059814,
1.0624948740005493,
-0.09229879826307297,
0.18759042024612427,
0.4202129542827606,
-0.14257659018039703,
0.07196156680583954,
0.4428662955760956,
0.24500064551830292,
0.4419670104980469,
0.28290337324142456,
0.4202480614185333,
-0.13756932318210602,
-0.4270683526992798,
-0.18669916689395905,
0.3858442008495331,
-0.7440120577812195,
-0.15215392410755157,
-0.419798344373703,
-0.23368734121322632,
-0.3431534767150879,
0.010157175362110138,
-0.0646921768784523,
-0.44419437646865845,
-0.1554078608751297,
0.08207543939352036,
0.2835519313812256,
0.7811362147331238,
0.18416595458984375,
0.34415435791015625,
-0.5249560475349426,
0.13356761634349823,
0.45486125349998474,
-0.01541326753795147,
-0.044236697256565094,
-0.513666033744812,
0.014421757310628891,
0.037774235010147095,
-0.2064429223537445,
-0.736996054649353,
0.12854939699172974,
0.10202798247337341,
0.5964950323104858,
0.6223997473716736,
-0.1633480042219162,
0.8645060658454895,
-0.2765597403049469,
0.5004605054855347,
0.0125917699187994,
-0.9390489459037781,
0.9346877932548523,
-0.46566522121429443,
0.5057104825973511,
0.2719389796257019,
0.2822253406047821,
-0.30217766761779785,
-0.5600212216377258,
-0.5924178957939148,
-0.5815564393997192,
0.5248345732688904,
-0.14533326029777527,
-0.03504359722137451,
-0.1466682404279709,
0.4933759272098541,
0.1008417159318924,
0.03519190102815628,
-0.6255735158920288,
0.3056487441062927,
0.13721290230751038,
-0.04675063118338585,
-0.2451588362455368,
-0.29928088188171387,
-0.20499780774116516,
-0.4607422649860382,
0.5558260083198547,
-0.25788959860801697,
-0.4001580476760864,
0.010029357858002186,
-0.4602086842060089,
0.09176375716924667,
0.3789375424385071,
0.4154665470123291,
0.9614552855491638,
-0.049541670829057693,
0.3936273753643036,
0.24973160028457642,
-0.04826607182621956,
0.15350182354450226,
0.04300472512841225,
-0.10794077813625336,
-0.10774807631969452,
0.8075007200241089,
0.5763049125671387,
0.21316954493522644,
-0.867388129234314,
0.47543007135391235,
0.13925287127494812,
-0.0201779343187809,
-0.12046486884355545,
0.4513740539550781,
-0.0745050385594368,
0.4730719029903412,
0.14199580252170563,
-0.07694807648658752,
0.19342941045761108,
-0.5338560342788696,
0.08810579776763916,
0.7481966614723206,
-0.528278648853302,
-0.3394150137901306,
0.41768431663513184,
-0.025785567238926888,
-0.1453235149383545,
0.7400499582290649,
0.25098511576652527,
-0.5006640553474426,
0.6369884014129639,
0.7165237069129944,
0.5091180801391602,
-0.5108788013458252,
0.01104898750782013,
0.19051721692085266,
0.49137845635414124,
-0.3601562976837158,
0.25268757343292236,
-0.21106119453907013,
-0.6601532101631165,
-0.8677522540092468,
-0.6282431483268738,
-0.1143203154206276,
0.07007083296775818,
-0.5905812382698059,
0.3048235774040222,
-0.6420835256576538,
-0.40134966373443604,
0.09615006297826767,
-0.43534448742866516,
-0.530931830406189,
0.3986256718635559,
0.25102218985557556,
1.0561918020248413,
-0.8377143740653992,
0.8479466438293457,
0.6032738089561462,
-0.15167878568172455,
-0.9654040932655334,
-0.07954087853431702,
0.23630134761333466,
-0.7997358441352844,
1.0541361570358276,
0.3030407428741455,
-0.3424692749977112,
-0.014416860416531563,
-0.5387718677520752,
-0.7313969135284424,
0.8242090344429016,
0.7070447206497192,
-0.7811119556427002,
-0.1529107540845871,
-0.2216646671295166,
0.4891476631164551,
-0.043372999876737595,
0.48390263319015503,
0.8524929285049438,
0.38828662037849426,
-0.23374280333518982,
-1.109810709953308,
0.16259072721004486,
-0.04614400863647461,
-0.044645894318819046,
0.4141956865787506,
-0.4696304202079773,
0.9470034241676331,
-0.36092957854270935,
0.06538344919681549,
-0.06892786175012589,
0.27720126509666443,
0.6351968050003052,
0.3421081304550171,
0.5727106332778931,
0.8418929576873779,
0.5126790404319763,
-0.2201501727104187,
0.9544050097465515,
-0.1231761947274208,
0.21341991424560547,
1.1544537544250488,
-0.3660163879394531,
0.678489089012146,
0.6718699932098389,
-0.09187617152929306,
0.8510907888412476,
0.5165120363235474,
0.32568275928497314,
0.2466689944267273,
0.41585054993629456,
-0.2916792333126068,
-0.7957000136375427,
-0.3215889632701874,
-0.1852877140045166,
0.7500882744789124,
0.615020215511322,
-0.44173118472099304,
-0.23712502419948578,
-0.13321411609649658,
0.08449384570121765,
0.13597451150417328,
-0.40056902170181274,
0.8566098809242249,
0.5043492317199707,
-0.7230904698371887,
0.5219716429710388,
-0.24694542586803436,
0.40368419885635376,
-0.49830183386802673,
-0.17402179539203644,
0.04873954504728317,
0.4306355118751526,
-0.3706234097480774,
-0.8675376772880554,
0.25038963556289673,
-0.17196914553642273,
-0.09053806960582733,
-0.27315181493759155,
1.0318917036056519,
0.004735505674034357,
-0.18047332763671875,
0.39890769124031067,
0.5422224402427673,
0.10951299965381622,
-0.12275967746973038,
-0.5986806154251099,
-0.020907051861286163,
-0.1937071681022644,
-0.341770738363266,
0.10226429998874664,
0.517562210559845,
-0.45934435725212097,
0.7980466485023499,
0.5983284115791321,
0.2511299252510071,
-0.33209851384162903,
0.31326642632484436,
0.7036639451980591,
-0.6228507161140442,
-0.43823158740997314,
-1.4565800428390503,
0.5191490054130554,
0.04948241263628006,
-0.22316351532936096,
0.8238574862480164,
0.4155079424381256,
0.7903348803520203,
0.15217901766300201,
0.6398869156837463,
0.2392416000366211,
0.20139794051647186,
-0.7513706684112549,
0.5827316045761108,
-0.4720497727394104,
0.18098945915699005,
-0.38335052132606506,
-0.7545123100280762,
-0.44218209385871887,
0.845818281173706,
-0.7062857151031494,
0.019642435014247894,
0.6617333889007568,
0.5892030596733093,
-0.09982362389564514,
0.1233643963932991,
0.2202647179365158,
0.6395420432090759,
0.18121126294136047,
0.6568821668624878,
1.1191186904907227,
0.12377478182315826,
0.22239187359809875,
-0.055653445422649384,
-0.2664470374584198,
-0.10026815533638,
-0.766851544380188,
-1.0381739139556885,
-0.37318480014801025,
-0.05939065292477608,
-0.465927392244339,
0.33536413311958313,
0.7749049663543701,
0.6466387510299683,
-0.492534339427948,
-0.5133278369903564,
-0.1446613371372223,
0.4159156084060669,
-0.16238096356391907,
-0.17664910852909088,
0.12255323678255081,
-0.35307639837265015,
-0.26139605045318604,
0.2387077808380127,
0.48326194286346436,
-0.3658212721347809,
-0.2324364185333252,
-0.03397731855511665,
-0.10422544926404953,
0.04357686638832092,
0.9610754251480103,
-0.08713402599096298,
-1.2140130996704102,
-0.13895069062709808,
-0.2078215628862381,
0.08567579090595245,
-0.27872413396835327,
0.9989513754844666,
-1.1439939737319946,
0.38027656078338623,
0.45914244651794434,
0.09268748015165329,
0.4079725444316864,
-0.2750963866710663,
0.6096484661102295,
-0.2348782867193222,
0.35429611802101135,
0.2518097460269928,
0.4732212722301483,
-0.02985469624400139,
-0.12286877632141113,
0.45640048384666443,
0.24499908089637756,
-0.5161067247390747,
-1.0363457202911377,
0.3989393711090088,
-0.6337800621986389,
-0.7653683423995972,
1.1612335443496704,
-0.06279023736715317,
-0.17867495119571686,
-0.017158783972263336,
-0.11161673069000244,
0.27045148611068726,
-0.09399570524692535,
0.8188684582710266,
0.6980026364326477,
-0.27627360820770264,
-0.10172901302576065,
-0.6142760515213013,
0.5267191529273987,
0.5669447779655457,
-0.8714731931686401,
0.10133245587348938,
0.6025183200836182,
0.3151627779006958,
0.009011810645461082,
0.5269606113433838,
0.16076187789440155,
0.40740081667900085,
-0.37834715843200684,
-0.2124156355857849,
0.3314983546733856,
-0.49336883425712585,
-0.4849175214767456,
-0.10909181088209152,
0.16476449370384216,
0.6155492663383484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11338v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11338v1 | Fine-grained Controllable Text Generation through In-context Learning with Feedback | 2024-06-17T08:55:48 | 2024-06-17T08:55:48 | Sarubi Thillainathan, Alexander Koller | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a method for rewriting an input sentence to match specific values
of nontrivial linguistic features, such as dependency depth. In contrast to
earlier work, our method uses in-context learning rather than finetuning,
making it applicable in use cases where data is sparse. We show that our model
performs accurate rewrites and matches the state of the art on rewriting
sentences to a specified school grade level. | [
-0.21749672293663025,
-1.2700178623199463,
0.5558527708053589,
0.052829012274742126,
-0.0060942391864955425,
-0.24608011543750763,
-0.25925084948539734,
-0.3194385766983032,
0.2129453867673874,
0.737876832485199,
-0.7022184133529663,
-0.45841336250305176,
-0.22473792731761932,
-0.016773074865341187,
-0.4631779193878174,
1.2819806337356567,
-0.3840819001197815,
-0.2653156816959381,
-0.36045747995376587,
0.03727322444319725,
-0.6690860390663147,
-0.46690231561660767,
-0.587114155292511,
-0.418565034866333,
0.6467840671539307,
1.1107323169708252,
0.5711986422538757,
0.6138028502464294,
0.2866644263267517,
0.28378137946128845,
-0.16184668242931366,
0.13248015940189362,
-0.6328557133674622,
0.2980981767177582,
-0.4532003700733185,
-0.2302025556564331,
-0.21806631982326508,
-0.060226425528526306,
0.6859056949615479,
1.1165010929107666,
-0.05821157619357109,
0.04127063974738121,
0.4711414575576782,
0.5332832932472229,
-0.579233705997467,
0.006311994045972824,
-0.7462067604064941,
0.1334407925605774,
-0.05225159227848053,
-0.42809557914733887,
-0.5942708849906921,
-0.26737138628959656,
0.43165433406829834,
-0.5634157657623291,
0.6836246252059937,
-0.16238725185394287,
0.9871093034744263,
0.4771839678287506,
-0.32043522596359253,
-0.4168902039527893,
-0.6391994953155518,
0.9186578989028931,
-0.6238644123077393,
0.1875012367963791,
0.5751957893371582,
0.23654381930828094,
-0.4420817792415619,
-0.7804047465324402,
-0.32228970527648926,
-0.32635143399238586,
-0.3325819969177246,
0.011883612722158432,
0.5075237154960632,
0.10349518805742264,
0.05392521247267723,
0.5867881774902344,
0.02329486981034279,
-0.16742895543575287,
-0.45134642720222473,
-0.077023945748806,
0.5957634449005127,
0.3099885582923889,
0.029993752017617226,
-0.35478389263153076,
-0.1680615097284317,
0.08588550984859467,
-0.5018287897109985,
0.41465356945991516,
0.09847614169120789,
0.7225948572158813,
-0.01558621320873499,
0.8181539177894592,
-0.5307844877243042,
0.7435528635978699,
0.4379192590713501,
-0.4561395049095154,
0.20484265685081482,
-0.4392465054988861,
-0.47478634119033813,
0.093174509704113,
0.52420973777771,
0.4781840443611145,
0.34827595949172974,
-0.1899571418762207,
-0.43087321519851685,
-0.08252854645252228,
0.33051958680152893,
-0.8473413586616516,
-0.08348046243190765,
0.07171031832695007,
-0.4163483679294586,
-0.5711525678634644,
-0.017175516113638878,
-0.6658843755722046,
0.02715303562581539,
-0.5495476722717285,
0.45901432633399963,
-0.5209368467330933,
0.3283955454826355,
-0.049143236130476,
0.006365869659930468,
0.14819176495075226,
0.4070286154747009,
-1.0742273330688477,
0.27247154712677,
0.26598411798477173,
0.9051904082298279,
0.05124301835894585,
-0.4269731640815735,
-0.8057474493980408,
0.26889941096305847,
-0.33911699056625366,
0.7652876973152161,
-0.6767578125,
-0.3992094397544861,
0.08119626343250275,
0.10362335294485092,
0.33228808641433716,
-0.5245499610900879,
0.3136231601238251,
-0.13993465900421143,
0.34048569202423096,
0.03526226058602333,
-0.7767804265022278,
-0.1379479169845581,
0.17337556183338165,
-0.41359201073646545,
0.8425607085227966,
0.6830084323883057,
-0.630733072757721,
0.7908040881156921,
-0.23664245009422302,
-0.8222872018814087,
-0.056774985045194626,
-0.07160712778568268,
-0.6103295087814331,
0.26904383301734924,
-0.022860661149024963,
0.5044568777084351,
0.2577573359012604,
0.7197139859199524,
-0.20538891851902008,
-0.27310559153556824,
0.11527451872825623,
-0.4052569568157196,
0.2824547588825226,
0.05708392709493637,
-0.4882405400276184,
0.39228641986846924,
-1.1651859283447266,
0.2289828658103943,
-0.19260446727275848,
-0.7973244786262512,
-0.200395867228508,
0.12050735205411911,
0.29578715562820435,
0.03760060667991638,
0.2954946458339691,
-0.5276231169700623,
0.1881943792104721,
-0.596874475479126,
0.7821394801139832,
0.43673035502433777,
0.26974207162857056,
0.8065037131309509,
-0.3113582134246826,
0.24368588626384735,
-0.1344623863697052,
-0.04751136526465416,
-0.2931339740753174,
-0.10578294098377228,
-0.7286344170570374,
0.01182530727237463,
0.26477527618408203,
0.4910429120063782,
-0.8250381946563721,
0.23952992260456085,
0.20718401670455933,
-0.29613232612609863,
-0.3197808563709259,
0.2567603886127472,
0.7711980938911438,
0.866172730922699,
0.45616450905799866,
-0.28373685479164124,
-0.38411012291908264,
-0.9544519186019897,
-0.1956777125597,
0.2713983952999115,
-0.10550820827484131,
0.5393409132957458,
0.20647840201854706,
-0.39120715856552124,
1.1049302816390991,
-0.6275637149810791,
-0.5146492719650269,
-0.41163837909698486,
0.166453018784523,
-0.2811914384365082,
0.8253628015518188,
0.3007432818412781,
-0.4909557104110718,
-0.4573867917060852,
0.09545348584651947,
-0.46982601284980774,
-0.4679366946220398,
-0.2453269362449646,
-0.07576929777860641,
0.24260209500789642,
0.8687668442726135,
-0.10448633879423141,
0.6052564382553101,
0.3086357116699219,
-0.5732608437538147,
0.08764724433422089,
-0.4536638855934143,
-0.03264959156513214,
-1.23444664478302,
-0.12910866737365723,
0.06928550451993942,
-0.3689953088760376,
-0.6400357484817505,
0.1538640707731247,
0.010376647114753723,
0.06783591955900192,
-0.6402813792228699,
0.3886829912662506,
-0.1715475171804428,
0.0789281353354454,
-0.4514616131782532,
0.34901416301727295,
0.24108944833278656,
0.526725172996521,
-0.008491233922541142,
0.5813732147216797,
0.2195110023021698,
-0.6496161818504333,
0.09961628913879395,
0.30186641216278076,
-0.3299945294857025,
0.5672088861465454,
-0.6848899126052856,
-0.26348966360092163,
-0.18469347059726715,
0.23803521692752838,
-0.8134865164756775,
-0.7823896408081055,
-0.025508806109428406,
-0.2686699330806732,
0.20513272285461426,
0.03842170536518097,
-0.2987150549888611,
0.1582331359386444,
-0.1287393718957901,
0.38449719548225403,
0.06602559983730316,
-0.4603375792503357,
0.32190799713134766,
0.22806154191493988,
-0.0577019527554512,
-0.1726931929588318,
-0.8837347626686096,
-0.10451462119817734,
-0.3119439482688904,
-0.36340847611427307,
0.476687490940094,
0.11520328372716904,
-0.2256918102502823,
-0.18804292380809784,
0.24563413858413696,
-0.44363880157470703,
0.15041638910770416,
0.19169703125953674,
-0.14291901886463165,
-0.10808860510587692,
0.1447223573923111,
0.4652329981327057,
0.028109952807426453,
-0.1389114409685135,
0.06498617678880692,
0.3400796055793762,
0.048742860555648804,
0.21593999862670898,
-0.4475049376487732,
0.7766439318656921,
0.44198429584503174,
-0.09101005643606186,
0.34564921259880066,
0.08762770146131516,
-0.41544729471206665,
-0.648557722568512,
0.10206376016139984,
-0.2485823631286621,
-0.47675812244415283,
0.3131829500198364,
-0.6119565963745117,
-1.2256522178649902,
0.39491337537765503,
0.09299933165311813,
0.09917927533388138,
0.3084583580493927,
0.5625321269035339,
0.01092451624572277,
0.7607259750366211,
1.1188395023345947,
0.3341663181781769,
0.7139061689376831,
-0.09008391201496124,
0.10922214388847351,
-0.5889167785644531,
-0.18588456511497498,
-0.3450894355773926,
-0.5253081917762756,
-0.8414011001586914,
-0.0014230638043954968,
-0.16704992949962616,
0.3978448510169983,
-0.29913920164108276,
0.26970428228378296,
-0.6152214407920837,
0.6568422913551331,
0.8991745114326477,
0.3089770972728729,
0.046684250235557556,
-0.23490114510059357,
-0.10484461486339569,
-0.02421015128493309,
-0.6830112338066101,
-0.5163924098014832,
0.8565050363540649,
0.208177849650383,
0.9269195199012756,
-0.07201888412237167,
0.7489514350891113,
-0.0882381871342659,
0.3656916916370392,
-0.9834839105606079,
0.21518707275390625,
-0.41584619879722595,
-0.4093795716762543,
-0.61003577709198,
-0.3380420506000519,
-0.8996999859809875,
-0.14538195729255676,
-0.20112386345863342,
-0.5587981939315796,
0.14551492035388947,
0.24007047712802887,
-0.5461199879646301,
0.0513974204659462,
-1.108059287071228,
0.8547317981719971,
0.1824726015329361,
-0.5700262784957886,
0.1965247094631195,
-0.7278238534927368,
0.25563502311706543,
-0.19995900988578796,
-0.01119700726121664,
0.09653263539075851,
0.08079978823661804,
0.47465869784355164,
-0.8142537474632263,
1.1726799011230469,
-0.1467171311378479,
-0.37852540612220764,
0.5303794145584106,
0.31815898418426514,
0.13941916823387146,
0.3196968138217926,
0.2687305808067322,
-0.4144114553928375,
-0.03677917271852493,
-0.33923858404159546,
-0.4964599907398224,
0.9683569669723511,
-0.5949799418449402,
-0.40396106243133545,
0.006023275200277567,
-0.911111056804657,
-0.24141456186771393,
0.4559706151485443,
0.3883419334888458,
0.6424346566200256,
-0.13665007054805756,
0.21777558326721191,
0.5671512484550476,
-0.2972187399864197,
0.4740760326385498,
0.32598403096199036,
-0.21066270768642426,
-0.47059696912765503,
0.8509069681167603,
0.33071792125701904,
0.4456692337989807,
0.5179842114448547,
0.2463374137878418,
-0.03131965175271034,
-0.2558306157588959,
-0.5827483534812927,
-0.14975954592227936,
-0.7096855640411377,
-0.32259103655815125,
-0.5203017592430115,
-0.3771786391735077,
-0.24607892334461212,
-0.9354237914085388,
-0.28229770064353943,
-0.32986387610435486,
-0.4219660758972168,
-0.07306772470474243,
0.34306272864341736,
1.046329140663147,
0.11783682554960251,
0.6616224050521851,
-0.5738019943237305,
0.311652809381485,
0.32745561003685,
0.7980103492736816,
-0.1398816853761673,
-0.5163586735725403,
-0.3384316563606262,
-0.10349606722593307,
-0.5552331805229187,
-0.6387026309967041,
0.40515321493148804,
0.4588525593280792,
0.09866835176944733,
0.27156999707221985,
-0.0785878524184227,
0.7598565220832825,
-0.9525127410888672,
0.9628308415412903,
-0.19371221959590912,
-1.2130005359649658,
0.9662121534347534,
-0.29621732234954834,
0.6279405951499939,
0.8658568859100342,
-0.08258981257677078,
-0.23477046191692352,
-0.7505282759666443,
-0.7867081165313721,
-1.061794638633728,
0.496769517660141,
-0.06289014220237732,
0.2696616053581238,
-0.1768084466457367,
0.8170959949493408,
0.34028780460357666,
0.1423153132200241,
-0.46797260642051697,
0.11387813091278076,
-0.3495544493198395,
-0.344828337430954,
-0.3027494251728058,
-0.47012874484062195,
0.22188568115234375,
-0.19795240461826324,
0.3719536364078522,
-0.13837549090385437,
-0.15074923634529114,
0.45009905099868774,
-0.008084243163466454,
-0.2498226910829544,
0.3166297376155853,
0.9571294188499451,
0.4437159597873688,
-0.23248866200447083,
0.31325650215148926,
0.21908842027187347,
-0.4529758095741272,
0.21580271422863007,
-0.3812599778175354,
-0.5466814041137695,
0.1431819647550583,
0.3913475573062897,
0.5268574357032776,
0.5982375144958496,
-0.5744525194168091,
0.40892598032951355,
0.06029850244522095,
-0.6654372215270996,
-0.048807404935359955,
0.2527431845664978,
-0.19403551518917084,
0.1432332843542099,
-0.2947623133659363,
-0.007801537401974201,
0.25931456685066223,
-0.5370602011680603,
0.7481109499931335,
0.05650480091571808,
-0.6760122776031494,
-0.0985402762889862,
0.8166388869285583,
0.17419850826263428,
-0.29481419920921326,
0.37618377804756165,
-0.10762932896614075,
-0.08081759512424469,
0.41707277297973633,
0.7660393118858337,
0.8616021871566772,
-0.24014851450920105,
0.22392205893993378,
0.5603552460670471,
0.0700812041759491,
-0.04858851060271263,
0.44890084862709045,
-0.1178024411201477,
-0.5396338701248169,
-0.6072291135787964,
-0.6231687068939209,
-0.4360082745552063,
0.13446323573589325,
-0.799725353717804,
0.34129419922828674,
-0.8660555481910706,
0.05091215670108795,
0.1669808328151703,
-0.15254849195480347,
-0.21733485162258148,
0.7267459034919739,
-0.3421044945716858,
0.7616863250732422,
-0.81633061170578,
0.8379519581794739,
0.6141323447227478,
-0.5361577868461609,
-0.9936299920082092,
0.21045783162117004,
-0.2732730507850647,
-0.2384391725063324,
0.5589777827262878,
0.26359373331069946,
-0.18956708908081055,
-0.02348424308001995,
-0.7485584616661072,
-1.0666537284851074,
0.876460075378418,
0.20992673933506012,
-0.5635455846786499,
0.18394146859645844,
-0.005126611329615116,
0.6259406208992004,
-0.44633036851882935,
-0.158765971660614,
0.6356711387634277,
0.1871616393327713,
0.003168626921251416,
-0.9249818921089172,
-0.05151285603642464,
-0.10659973323345184,
0.2542300224304199,
0.29394346475601196,
-0.636354386806488,
0.8465365767478943,
-0.06371482461690903,
-0.177348330616951,
0.008858047425746918,
0.8555132746696472,
-0.044783689081668854,
0.3574593663215637,
0.3147972524166107,
0.636493444442749,
0.5862019658088684,
-0.0437590666115284,
0.8788998126983643,
-0.180640310049057,
0.41149377822875977,
1.6183074712753296,
0.04799739643931389,
0.9328956007957458,
0.6787254810333252,
0.2978530824184418,
0.5386309623718262,
0.6914704442024231,
0.17927810549736023,
0.844344437122345,
0.6212075352668762,
-0.10083546489477158,
0.0952024981379509,
-0.27416476607322693,
0.10088631510734558,
0.40575024485588074,
0.19920751452445984,
-0.5056682229042053,
-0.31731536984443665,
0.2574656307697296,
0.11513285338878632,
0.5642218589782715,
-0.5870586037635803,
0.883803129196167,
-0.07946888357400894,
-0.7847544550895691,
0.7632604837417603,
0.17087973654270172,
0.7601565718650818,
-0.2250806987285614,
-0.11221574246883392,
-0.4618953466415405,
0.40463942289352417,
-0.5003644824028015,
-0.9962466955184937,
0.8485587239265442,
0.1830693632364273,
-0.6629617214202881,
-0.3601008951663971,
0.41186752915382385,
-0.6884741187095642,
-0.48728957772254944,
0.03485295921564102,
0.18211480975151062,
0.05741368606686592,
0.21496634185314178,
-0.1890859156847,
-0.24739348888397217,
0.2865321636199951,
-0.21610872447490692,
0.17910653352737427,
0.9298802614212036,
-0.25507664680480957,
0.5116032361984253,
0.24990983307361603,
-0.20606696605682373,
0.057761404663324356,
0.2116791307926178,
0.7978690266609192,
-0.7373937964439392,
-0.4494302570819855,
-0.6230905055999756,
0.4286784827709198,
0.1877330094575882,
-0.7491908669471741,
0.573100209236145,
0.5629501938819885,
1.4123222827911377,
-0.017794936895370483,
0.8461090922355652,
-0.06532414257526398,
0.5157725811004639,
-0.5123666524887085,
0.5478748083114624,
-0.5748286843299866,
-0.15002453327178955,
-0.3537304997444153,
-0.7801796793937683,
-0.6274625062942505,
0.8070352673530579,
-0.21985532343387604,
-0.11545483022928238,
0.7115185260772705,
0.6790445446968079,
-0.06764518469572067,
-0.23222410678863525,
0.3626069128513336,
0.04996086657047272,
0.2820528447628021,
0.6427918672561646,
0.6264925003051758,
-0.3020755350589752,
0.09397045522928238,
-0.5009320974349976,
-0.45538464188575745,
-0.1651766151189804,
-0.6968477368354797,
-0.953360378742218,
-0.5635396242141724,
-0.3331652581691742,
-0.4387630820274353,
-0.33668166399002075,
0.5958007574081421,
0.4160606861114502,
-0.8976922035217285,
-0.06325661391019821,
-0.5171055197715759,
0.06648322939872742,
-0.02068524993956089,
-0.3435570299625397,
0.24762532114982605,
-0.8823122978210449,
-0.7433757781982422,
0.3151884377002716,
0.16537918150424957,
0.25102049112319946,
-0.2835533618927002,
0.11004044860601425,
-0.00676598958671093,
0.20233245193958282,
0.7685844898223877,
-0.025585690513253212,
-0.7739933133125305,
-0.6885436177253723,
-0.2053661346435547,
-0.31172746419906616,
0.029366444796323776,
0.8521685004234314,
-0.6230738162994385,
0.22782495617866516,
0.5947120189666748,
0.5189131498336792,
0.14404259622097015,
-0.028228886425495148,
0.600805401802063,
-1.0652027130126953,
0.2479659765958786,
-0.0680718645453453,
0.19898343086242676,
0.3750030994415283,
-0.5526047348976135,
0.1905890554189682,
0.03715379163622856,
-0.7571930289268494,
-0.4845614731311798,
0.3793194890022278,
-0.9006597399711609,
-0.4536565840244293,
1.1782641410827637,
-0.0868970975279808,
-0.3462222218513489,
-0.001409156247973442,
-0.6330807209014893,
0.32458651065826416,
-0.2635004222393036,
0.902888834476471,
0.5240358710289001,
0.012208142317831516,
-0.1983230710029602,
-0.3585658371448517,
0.5985787510871887,
0.20702695846557617,
-0.7163172364234924,
0.21186216175556183,
0.6403366327285767,
0.26864585280418396,
-0.0025196734350174665,
0.5084317922592163,
0.0857381820678711,
-0.034212734550237656,
0.09105194360017776,
0.005747239105403423,
0.25937381386756897,
-0.49542269110679626,
-0.13369859755039215,
0.28708070516586304,
0.013286079280078411,
-0.020315026864409447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11328v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11328v1 | Are Large Language Models True Healthcare Jacks-of-All-Trades? Benchmarking Across Health Professions Beyond Physician Exams | 2024-06-17T08:40:36 | 2024-06-17T08:40:36 | Zheheng Luo, Chenhan Yuan, Qianqian Xie, Sophia Ananiadou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated their
potential in delivering accurate answers to questions about world knowledge.
Despite this, existing benchmarks for evaluating LLMs in healthcare
predominantly focus on medical doctors, leaving other critical healthcare
professions underrepresented. To fill this research gap, we introduce the
Examinations for Medical Personnel in Chinese (EMPEC), a pioneering large-scale
healthcare knowledge benchmark in traditional Chinese. EMPEC consists of
157,803 exam questions across 124 subjects and 20 healthcare professions,
including underrepresented occupations like Optometrists and Audiologists. Each
question is tagged with its release time and source, ensuring relevance and
authenticity. We conducted extensive experiments on 17 LLMs, including
proprietary, open-source models, general domain models and medical specific
models, evaluating their performance under various settings. Our findings
reveal that while leading models like GPT-4 achieve over 75\% accuracy, they
still struggle with specialized fields and alternative medicine. Surprisingly,
general-purpose LLMs outperformed medical-specific models, and incorporating
EMPEC's training data significantly enhanced performance. Additionally, the
results on questions released after the models' training cutoff date were
consistent with overall performance trends, suggesting that the models'
performance on the test set can predict their effectiveness in addressing
unseen healthcare-related queries. The transition from traditional to
simplified Chinese characters had a negligible impact on model performance,
indicating robust linguistic versatility. Our study underscores the importance
of expanding benchmarks to cover a broader range of healthcare professions to
better assess the applicability of LLMs in real-world healthcare scenarios. | [
0.1221667006611824,
-0.5513179302215576,
0.9422488212585449,
-0.037693966180086136,
-0.013796646147966385,
-0.20355476438999176,
-0.1793488711118698,
-0.7365012764930725,
-0.07853933423757553,
0.4886452555656433,
-0.24077408015727997,
-0.4329906404018402,
-0.5851826071739197,
0.24762889742851257,
-0.08373324573040009,
0.439721941947937,
0.06903684139251709,
0.4411429166793823,
-0.11184737086296082,
-0.3617071509361267,
-0.012691684067249298,
-0.8218693137168884,
-0.7308295965194702,
-0.6294106841087341,
0.45334964990615845,
-0.188375785946846,
0.6751514673233032,
0.7237610220909119,
0.4989994764328003,
0.17840012907981873,
-0.10002636909484863,
0.2756844758987427,
-0.011592244729399681,
0.02025420591235161,
0.025637727230787277,
-0.5103737115859985,
-0.47466298937797546,
0.11252331733703613,
0.6947821974754333,
0.9266733527183533,
-0.25494277477264404,
0.03163650631904602,
-0.020332980901002884,
0.37518757581710815,
-0.49879932403564453,
0.1079416573047638,
-0.5563949942588806,
0.15380749106407166,
-0.18454742431640625,
-0.2579508423805237,
-0.3500515818595886,
-0.3616635203361511,
0.019852804020047188,
-0.2990965247154236,
-0.12699860334396362,
-0.0016827303916215897,
0.8393564820289612,
0.20619216561317444,
-0.8725218772888184,
0.028841767460107803,
-0.4852619767189026,
0.5797479152679443,
-0.8965210914611816,
0.7293891310691833,
0.29142680764198303,
0.4476065933704376,
-0.08016334474086761,
-0.8014031052589417,
-0.1949949860572815,
-0.502138078212738,
0.12482573091983795,
0.35565704107284546,
-0.020238498225808144,
0.29393044114112854,
0.3642207384109497,
0.538195013999939,
-0.42840635776519775,
0.6297423243522644,
-0.3326936364173889,
-0.015139959752559662,
0.608614981174469,
0.45829474925994873,
0.5814868211746216,
0.02812635898590088,
-0.22071343660354614,
0.09663672745227814,
-1.0173771381378174,
0.08133973181247711,
-0.32676056027412415,
-0.00805753841996193,
-0.19245703518390656,
0.4917551279067993,
0.01720215380191803,
0.6913849115371704,
-0.382240891456604,
-0.3912694454193115,
0.0920172929763794,
-0.22140997648239136,
-0.4821073114871979,
-0.1720467209815979,
0.806576669216156,
0.2128705084323883,
0.12626215815544128,
-0.18704423308372498,
-0.3289507329463959,
-0.2043990194797516,
0.3407588601112366,
-0.5288894772529602,
-0.3200700283050537,
0.25447705388069153,
-0.613190233707428,
-0.10485514998435974,
-0.02912939339876175,
-0.33950719237327576,
-0.5856831073760986,
-0.1927911788225174,
0.18237662315368652,
-0.10384686291217804,
-0.23803190886974335,
0.11309763044118881,
0.22727201879024506,
0.4294375479221344,
0.37477901577949524,
-0.787783145904541,
0.3067780137062073,
1.0081045627593994,
0.8655920624732971,
-0.10257270932197571,
-0.267115980386734,
-0.3443324863910675,
-0.11943623423576355,
-0.7192277312278748,
0.5990492105484009,
-0.42144912481307983,
-0.21762336790561676,
0.20102038979530334,
0.17800095677375793,
-0.294806569814682,
-0.8010152578353882,
0.44621437788009644,
-0.2091187834739685,
-0.1731434017419815,
-0.3401983380317688,
-0.6221117973327637,
0.054154977202415466,
0.637582004070282,
-0.5838047862052917,
0.8279880881309509,
0.21526555716991425,
-0.5157396197319031,
0.3647438883781433,
-0.419203519821167,
-0.3032523989677429,
0.14913757145404816,
-0.6460961103439331,
-0.3000656068325043,
-0.049318525940179825,
0.20891200006008148,
0.5685897469520569,
-0.9239819645881653,
0.13974450528621674,
-0.23402276635169983,
-0.3982180655002594,
0.5631723403930664,
-0.5295370221138,
0.9039532542228699,
0.07572077214717865,
-0.1904810518026352,
-0.130201518535614,
-0.3844586908817291,
0.15853410959243774,
0.1201162040233612,
-0.3431514799594879,
-0.4486849904060364,
-0.10098345577716827,
0.03444802761077881,
0.4554777443408966,
-0.20484596490859985,
-0.5815346837043762,
0.08845359086990356,
-0.4900359809398651,
0.4671196937561035,
0.5489110946655273,
0.0178968608379364,
-0.11375515908002853,
-0.557682991027832,
0.6117095947265625,
-0.2643601894378662,
0.4554439187049866,
-0.11487292498350143,
-0.7129548788070679,
-0.4133981466293335,
-0.34184497594833374,
0.39550432562828064,
0.29603466391563416,
-0.4997848570346832,
0.39743131399154663,
-0.19184261560440063,
-0.9317089915275574,
-0.7027296423912048,
-0.08070484548807144,
0.2888262867927551,
0.5291018486022949,
0.12008944153785706,
-0.18238739669322968,
0.09658229351043701,
-0.878994882106781,
-0.642047107219696,
-0.29674383997917175,
-0.42839714884757996,
0.4867739975452423,
0.35313522815704346,
-0.16231407225131989,
0.1789812296628952,
-0.38182327151298523,
-0.2972506880760193,
-0.24986077845096588,
-0.3029640316963196,
0.30912768840789795,
0.29600805044174194,
0.5648213624954224,
-0.6416534781455994,
-0.4015539884567261,
0.2512769103050232,
-0.656949520111084,
-0.18544431030750275,
-0.15485773980617523,
-0.011899095959961414,
-0.016861790791153908,
0.35005101561546326,
-0.2489405870437622,
0.01930021494626999,
0.7925772070884705,
-0.15869882702827454,
0.6077900528907776,
-0.3374285101890564,
0.28280919790267944,
-0.7480714917182922,
0.32441961765289307,
0.16906610131263733,
-0.180293008685112,
-0.6298601627349854,
0.21673916280269623,
0.41651463508605957,
-0.015993673354387283,
-0.47141599655151367,
0.7837328314781189,
-0.601905345916748,
0.020390193909406662,
-0.0008782568038441241,
0.1018354520201683,
-0.056661032140254974,
0.10275411605834961,
-0.06791935116052628,
0.3983611762523651,
0.7096519470214844,
-0.6468220949172974,
0.4188300669193268,
0.1233249083161354,
-0.4843789339065552,
0.4256565272808075,
-0.7621144652366638,
-0.0514790415763855,
0.4062081575393677,
0.14392918348312378,
-0.7640477418899536,
-0.17664498090744019,
-0.02896786481142044,
-0.14884191751480103,
0.08716964721679688,
-0.01733998768031597,
-0.7301021814346313,
-0.45207056403160095,
0.06333956122398376,
0.3183320462703705,
0.7906274199485779,
-0.5032151937484741,
0.5164393782615662,
0.4620479345321655,
0.10312927514314651,
-0.43011799454689026,
-0.9008927941322327,
-0.17862153053283691,
0.15095506608486176,
-0.5395082235336304,
0.23509016633033752,
0.30512315034866333,
-0.32191577553749084,
-0.43222805857658386,
-0.38280221819877625,
-0.42553311586380005,
0.20243975520133972,
0.018638186156749725,
0.5407847166061401,
-0.2933543026447296,
0.3200643062591553,
-0.22396866977214813,
0.24608100950717926,
0.30088725686073303,
-0.08284030854701996,
0.27098745107650757,
0.12209652364253998,
-0.8419452905654907,
-0.24755367636680603,
0.009949669241905212,
0.7489712834358215,
-0.3774584233760834,
0.6329413056373596,
0.22503186762332916,
-0.4740805923938751,
-0.01012219488620758,
-0.9090940952301025,
-0.3206537365913391,
-0.41508761048316956,
0.6171076893806458,
-0.1563275307416916,
-0.7524329423904419,
0.5401018261909485,
-0.20348916947841644,
0.4508911967277527,
0.45054298639297485,
0.5584940910339355,
0.20483601093292236,
0.9555010199546814,
0.36849233508110046,
0.06118154898285866,
0.05236438289284706,
0.19655592739582062,
0.20170098543167114,
-0.7405819892883301,
-0.3189034163951874,
-0.3959263563156128,
-0.009982704184949398,
-0.833918035030365,
-0.5301910042762756,
0.8353700041770935,
-0.3802158236503601,
-0.20414134860038757,
-0.08552964776754379,
-0.4700813591480255,
0.1971244364976883,
0.1712544560432434,
0.4246867895126343,
0.4491530656814575,
-0.4202154576778412,
-0.12846548855304718,
-0.0415082648396492,
-0.7414120435714722,
-0.3553726077079773,
1.246038556098938,
0.78117436170578,
0.78529292345047,
-0.07321494817733765,
0.3799123466014862,
-0.07058855146169662,
0.5391433238983154,
-0.8434361219406128,
0.23217624425888062,
-0.5252964496612549,
-0.6709263324737549,
-0.2726607918739319,
-0.47559061646461487,
-0.8125801086425781,
0.48673221468925476,
-0.13964106142520905,
-0.3609020709991455,
-0.022546274587512016,
0.04279191046953201,
-0.4928719997406006,
0.61823570728302,
-0.15545494854450226,
0.8800367712974548,
-0.6004545092582703,
-0.17128247022628784,
0.06815294176340103,
-0.522372305393219,
0.49887195229530334,
-0.3556349575519562,
0.12724962830543518,
-0.32181671261787415,
-0.32668378949165344,
0.653903067111969,
-0.16371896862983704,
0.7008644342422485,
0.132086843252182,
-0.3256612718105316,
-0.22019577026367188,
-0.07865022122859955,
0.27832484245300293,
-0.01374285202473402,
-0.35753029584884644,
0.4275040328502655,
0.3043360710144043,
-0.43650877475738525,
-0.5347585678100586,
0.5657538175582886,
-0.6465950012207031,
-0.6809743642807007,
-0.548048198223114,
-0.19777223467826843,
-0.5432215929031372,
0.22883503139019012,
0.16933457553386688,
0.5696757435798645,
-0.3838988244533539,
0.1498630940914154,
0.5023059248924255,
-0.44699323177337646,
-0.12567095458507538,
0.7697504162788391,
0.053231943398714066,
-0.023023219779133797,
0.3176822066307068,
0.3016347289085388,
0.4384329319000244,
0.32297712564468384,
0.32989439368247986,
-0.29293325543403625,
-0.41682782769203186,
-0.4894252419471741,
0.5995151400566101,
-0.7513189911842346,
0.06929716467857361,
-0.8646572828292847,
-0.5915091037750244,
-0.3424566984176636,
-0.05188228562474251,
-0.4966370165348053,
0.14346325397491455,
0.12717433273792267,
0.23448807001113892,
0.0174648929387331,
0.7462102174758911,
0.3284662365913391,
-0.1741282194852829,
-0.9642060995101929,
0.20570902526378632,
0.2165451943874359,
0.5152600407600403,
0.040060002356767654,
-0.5636134147644043,
-0.23935827612876892,
-0.06882129609584808,
-0.27026793360710144,
-0.7993521094322205,
0.2539350688457489,
-0.024450654163956642,
0.996419370174408,
0.6034111380577087,
0.1303316205739975,
0.32552558183670044,
-0.6508182883262634,
1.0113837718963623,
0.3375628590583801,
-0.6626459956169128,
0.09456433355808258,
-0.3531838059425354,
0.33972781896591187,
0.41318878531455994,
0.44587263464927673,
-0.9460403323173523,
-0.40111878514289856,
-0.408400297164917,
-0.6310569047927856,
0.4590819478034973,
-0.11856735497713089,
0.13560165464878082,
0.007273797877132893,
0.3199969530105591,
0.0713861808180809,
0.0054663424380123615,
-0.7402665019035339,
-0.2926191985607147,
0.2032700926065445,
-0.043921925127506256,
0.14713016152381897,
-0.03540034592151642,
-0.31618914008140564,
-0.238381028175354,
0.3335963785648346,
-0.0651865154504776,
0.2537614107131958,
0.3151458501815796,
0.31734904646873474,
0.060866501182317734,
0.5179936289787292,
0.3108041286468506,
1.0224801301956177,
0.15189135074615479,
0.016449425369501114,
0.3939691185951233,
-0.4501138925552368,
0.1252889186143875,
0.05386967211961746,
0.2310621440410614,
0.10692039877176285,
0.49354287981987,
0.35791513323783875,
0.27645766735076904,
-0.9751102924346924,
0.7487346529960632,
0.215406134724617,
-0.24763914942741394,
-0.46022507548332214,
0.027218231931328773,
-0.002699528355151415,
0.1199379414319992,
0.3159343898296356,
-0.19330860674381256,
0.10530132800340652,
-0.7009056806564331,
0.11111550033092499,
0.3832525312900543,
-0.48547789454460144,
-0.13219724595546722,
0.9159905910491943,
0.35406070947647095,
0.049662280827760696,
0.6197695136070251,
0.5136022567749023,
-0.4207139313220978,
0.8095428347587585,
0.39116111397743225,
0.688595712184906,
-0.3853578269481659,
-0.09381688386201859,
0.31029948592185974,
0.5097495317459106,
-0.4922862648963928,
0.14411263167858124,
0.23667195439338684,
-0.4982568025588989,
-0.35209351778030396,
-0.18355098366737366,
-0.8148907423019409,
0.20783931016921997,
-0.6009302139282227,
0.28068703413009644,
-0.5265089273452759,
-0.15140078961849213,
-0.061139266937971115,
-0.12838523089885712,
-0.7684665322303772,
0.45949527621269226,
0.3446499705314636,
1.0552746057510376,
-0.7805888652801514,
0.9514980912208557,
0.7583317160606384,
-0.23846718668937683,
-1.0073617696762085,
0.29830682277679443,
0.05593792721629143,
-1.0001229047775269,
0.48689910769462585,
0.19652964174747467,
0.3607819080352783,
-0.435431569814682,
-0.11965356022119522,
-0.5199196934700012,
1.0781008005142212,
0.3542262315750122,
-0.6794248819351196,
-0.4182654023170471,
0.2598933279514313,
0.6813865303993225,
-0.3569691479206085,
0.6409971117973328,
0.6910811066627502,
0.3827980160713196,
-0.3640232980251312,
-1.4858299493789673,
0.2803371250629425,
-0.22141458094120026,
-0.18583157658576965,
-0.0377633199095726,
-0.96174556016922,
1.1411367654800415,
-0.04439589008688927,
-0.16940635442733765,
0.05949632078409195,
-0.050018060952425,
0.508306086063385,
0.3170107901096344,
0.5265750885009766,
-0.07641613483428955,
0.757530689239502,
-0.297978013753891,
1.3420487642288208,
-0.3971792757511139,
0.05455394461750984,
0.5718203783035278,
-0.5974062085151672,
0.6889032125473022,
0.23346388339996338,
-0.3470444977283478,
0.14795134961605072,
0.7363699674606323,
-0.32570990920066833,
0.06658532470464706,
0.2616296112537384,
-0.17565381526947021,
-0.5665667057037354,
-0.18287917971611023,
-0.6496596336364746,
0.524258553981781,
0.13598187267780304,
-0.7358285784721375,
0.09356478601694107,
-0.15243571996688843,
-0.0656856819987297,
0.10114174336194992,
-0.3879425525665283,
0.5914679765701294,
0.4430575966835022,
-0.5899397134780884,
0.6663477420806885,
-0.1068367138504982,
0.7191871404647827,
-0.9049976468086243,
-0.08045758306980133,
-0.09633186459541321,
0.20175409317016602,
-0.07442983984947205,
-0.6711613535881042,
-0.02050645463168621,
-0.22746062278747559,
0.28174325823783875,
-0.08696296811103821,
0.5344034433364868,
-0.44043248891830444,
-0.3940638601779938,
0.37973129749298096,
0.6945034265518188,
0.38673269748687744,
-0.25992149114608765,
-0.6900831460952759,
-0.22554124891757965,
-0.14330559968948364,
-0.10604517161846161,
0.42105832695961,
0.37333571910858154,
0.07800226658582687,
0.6503414511680603,
0.42169350385665894,
0.599618673324585,
-0.17871113121509552,
0.19463685154914856,
0.7844212651252747,
-0.5991608500480652,
-0.6488179564476013,
-0.8960168957710266,
0.12285856157541275,
-0.030863316729664803,
-0.40865764021873474,
0.6931998133659363,
0.34963274002075195,
0.7007189393043518,
-0.06882229447364807,
0.8448968529701233,
0.4243760406970978,
0.5589094758033752,
-0.5702246427536011,
1.1793687343597412,
-1.0764163732528687,
0.08710875362157822,
-0.22604642808437347,
-0.5726742744445801,
-0.3281201422214508,
0.19075988233089447,
-0.3953956365585327,
0.25149276852607727,
0.7232512831687927,
0.43028753995895386,
-0.029458632692694664,
-0.030316049233078957,
0.9727938175201416,
0.05282680690288544,
0.39817604422569275,
0.6584583520889282,
0.7435137629508972,
-0.4413510859012604,
0.3965350091457367,
-0.2481895089149475,
-0.20286504924297333,
-0.18317914009094238,
-0.39049333333969116,
-1.0449812412261963,
-0.20890803635120392,
-0.2545318305492401,
-0.15420427918434143,
0.158874049782753,
1.10922110080719,
0.611217200756073,
-0.6311203241348267,
-0.1186019629240036,
0.49734804034233093,
-0.2999870181083679,
-0.6157312393188477,
-0.11408920586109161,
0.5099960565567017,
0.01625659130513668,
-0.6745684146881104,
0.34762948751449585,
0.19353801012039185,
-0.04796651005744934,
-0.36413922905921936,
0.12927235662937164,
0.06541544944047928,
0.1624421924352646,
0.4225241243839264,
0.2392355352640152,
-1.0092004537582397,
0.10951156169176102,
0.36454978585243225,
-0.5641193985939026,
0.11587006598711014,
1.0304057598114014,
-0.28280961513519287,
0.4390057325363159,
0.2602461576461792,
0.8245514035224915,
-0.12719455361366272,
-0.14836829900741577,
0.6107016205787659,
-0.32104048132896423,
0.0024511627852916718,
0.4777807593345642,
0.6217494010925293,
0.2924811840057373,
-0.510928213596344,
0.6457342505455017,
0.015390823595225811,
-0.7492368817329407,
-0.8927770853042603,
-0.15383072197437286,
-0.660498857498169,
-0.3399352431297302,
1.1972100734710693,
-0.22116097807884216,
-0.06935875862836838,
-0.396668404340744,
0.05745244026184082,
0.2689020037651062,
0.027782989665865898,
0.8315066695213318,
0.44408097863197327,
-0.25184857845306396,
-0.21929322183132172,
-1.0067805051803589,
0.4210983216762543,
0.7181856036186218,
-0.9301589131355286,
0.24475660920143127,
0.25993379950523376,
0.5244454145431519,
-0.2967946231365204,
0.9907872676849365,
-0.4767935276031494,
0.645962655544281,
0.03644906356930733,
0.10033538192510605,
-0.11436023563146591,
0.07441338151693344,
-0.18053807318210602,
-0.0877697691321373,
0.2049732357263565,
-0.06934286653995514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11925v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11925v2 | DocCGen: Document-based Controlled Code Generation | 2024-06-17T08:34:57 | 2024-07-03T09:16:27 | Sameer Pimparkhede, Mehant Kammakomati, Srikanth Tamilselvam, Prince Kumar, Ashok Pon Kumar, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent developments show that Large Language Models (LLMs) produce
state-of-the-art performance on natural language (NL) to code generation for
resource-rich general-purpose languages like C++, Java, and Python. However,
their practical usage for structured domain-specific languages (DSLs) such as
YAML, JSON is limited due to domain-specific schema, grammar, and
customizations generally unseen by LLMs during pre-training. Efforts have been
made to mitigate this challenge via in-context learning through relevant
examples or by fine-tuning. However, it suffers from problems, such as limited
DSL samples and prompt sensitivity but enterprises maintain good documentation
of the DSLs. Therefore, we propose DocCGen, a framework that can leverage such
rich knowledge by breaking the NL-to-Code generation task for structured code
languages into a two-step process. First, it detects the correct libraries
using the library documentation that best matches the NL query. Then, it
utilizes schema rules extracted from the documentation of these libraries to
constrain the decoding. We evaluate our framework for two complex structured
languages, Ansible YAML and Bash command, consisting of two settings:
Out-of-domain (OOD) and In-domain (ID). Our extensive experiments show that
DocCGen consistently improves different-sized language models across all six
evaluation metrics, reducing syntactic and semantic errors in structured code.
We plan to open-source the datasets and code to motivate research in
constrained code generation. | [
-0.3352305293083191,
-0.6841654181480408,
0.540428102016449,
0.1628199815750122,
-0.09033876657485962,
0.16502459347248077,
-0.4739351272583008,
-0.22757449746131897,
-0.24626126885414124,
0.8357561826705933,
-0.49280813336372375,
-0.8909674882888794,
-0.3787558972835541,
0.3026488423347473,
-0.4014579653739929,
0.9003684520721436,
-0.10399821400642395,
0.03849871829152107,
-0.37013939023017883,
0.22891928255558014,
0.029177367687225342,
-0.4271979033946991,
-0.3646102845668793,
0.06016379967331886,
0.10224375128746033,
0.397932231426239,
0.37799862027168274,
0.8545882105827332,
0.38828399777412415,
0.22021739184856415,
-0.010612445883452892,
0.6835218071937561,
-0.4682658016681671,
0.3525305390357971,
-0.11685652285814285,
-0.41717714071273804,
-0.40268218517303467,
-0.13109295070171356,
0.42713627219200134,
0.6471136212348938,
-0.25272393226623535,
-0.06393551826477051,
-0.1275317370891571,
0.3912619352340698,
-0.4330427050590515,
0.32402172684669495,
-0.6952616572380066,
-0.06878276914358139,
-0.010124082677066326,
-0.5472093820571899,
-0.5855808258056641,
-0.3230995833873749,
-0.3864087462425232,
-0.8165510296821594,
0.4773949980735779,
-0.11552752554416656,
0.7091285586357117,
0.46045929193496704,
-0.36586979031562805,
-0.7355884313583374,
-0.7162652015686035,
0.7113193869590759,
-0.9077728986740112,
0.3002905249595642,
0.29679355025291443,
0.021059738472104073,
-0.507850170135498,
-1.1028350591659546,
-0.5932031869888306,
-0.309285968542099,
-0.2800746560096741,
0.0005171175580471754,
0.20017977058887482,
0.06528684496879578,
0.3916759192943573,
0.29630333185195923,
-0.5684107542037964,
0.08817128837108612,
-0.5192402005195618,
-0.08224961161613464,
0.581103503704071,
0.1511336863040924,
0.29949894547462463,
-0.045308273285627365,
-0.15807166695594788,
-0.2075033187866211,
-0.8154895901679993,
-0.22717329859733582,
0.4809277057647705,
0.41780808568000793,
-0.08983561396598816,
0.46982860565185547,
-0.027382221072912216,
0.8015050292015076,
0.26931437849998474,
-0.13133235275745392,
0.09600517153739929,
-0.37579721212387085,
-0.20614302158355713,
-0.04774541035294533,
0.6815895438194275,
0.18386729061603546,
0.21165011823177338,
-0.3270600438117981,
-0.29807958006858826,
0.36661186814308167,
0.6027287840843201,
-0.7893181443214417,
0.07375775277614594,
0.42284849286079407,
-0.25916922092437744,
-0.5361396074295044,
-0.04709488898515701,
-0.6129565238952637,
-0.31746166944503784,
-0.3116946816444397,
-0.40624159574508667,
-0.3920288681983948,
-0.2170601189136505,
0.09783314168453217,
-0.31480672955513,
0.31354811787605286,
0.2618035674095154,
-0.8174247145652771,
0.25782567262649536,
0.68369060754776,
0.5780459046363831,
-0.14809271693229675,
-0.12483502924442291,
-0.6700827479362488,
0.3549225926399231,
-0.5748576521873474,
0.5325245261192322,
-0.535980224609375,
-0.8360740542411804,
0.22566156089305878,
-0.03667030483484268,
0.008246717043220997,
-0.4635099172592163,
0.4058534502983093,
-0.47533169388771057,
0.28301215171813965,
0.16610050201416016,
-0.6700332760810852,
0.36997637152671814,
0.12624868750572205,
-0.540338933467865,
0.940930187702179,
0.6038225889205933,
-0.9187094569206238,
0.5410455465316772,
-0.5682628154754639,
-0.6890096664428711,
0.3785568177700043,
-0.674993097782135,
-0.21056196093559265,
0.067703478038311,
-0.08460396528244019,
0.3365640938282013,
-0.33689621090888977,
0.3893761932849884,
-0.05269255116581917,
-0.29441219568252563,
-0.2780991196632385,
0.12705375254154205,
0.6714250445365906,
0.4883668124675751,
-0.4534465968608856,
0.09812760353088379,
-1.1004524230957031,
0.2859233617782593,
0.15168745815753937,
-0.8094239234924316,
-0.33442580699920654,
0.07255923002958298,
0.09827151894569397,
0.3481267988681793,
0.08014658093452454,
-0.45325806736946106,
0.5489407181739807,
-0.44860705733299255,
0.4530070126056671,
0.44330891966819763,
0.08527851104736328,
0.649975061416626,
0.02891278825700283,
0.6279215216636658,
-0.1107606291770935,
0.06015864387154579,
-0.253248393535614,
-0.11897536367177963,
-0.5275794267654419,
-0.35437747836112976,
0.07533040642738342,
0.48850029706954956,
-0.8863196969032288,
0.5787240266799927,
-0.21358336508274078,
-0.34195417165756226,
-0.40581315755844116,
0.46197670698165894,
0.35656389594078064,
0.6639677882194519,
0.21154247224330902,
-0.42641526460647583,
-0.5202627778053284,
-0.5979769825935364,
0.34953951835632324,
-0.21344082057476044,
-0.17801785469055176,
0.34996846318244934,
0.14722660183906555,
-0.4065049886703491,
0.932115375995636,
-0.44733893871307373,
-0.1842382401227951,
-0.4110093414783478,
0.04293323680758476,
0.020017893984913826,
0.4883332848548889,
0.46042314171791077,
-0.8806405663490295,
-0.35068050026893616,
0.12211040407419205,
-0.6591375470161438,
-0.4207298457622528,
-0.2996399402618408,
-0.033657122403383255,
0.5220608711242676,
0.9478021264076233,
-0.517989456653595,
0.21782995760440826,
0.6123752593994141,
-0.37294474244117737,
0.5174732208251953,
-0.6496054530143738,
-0.07916585355997086,
-1.0121599435806274,
0.28195181488990784,
-0.14437837898731232,
-0.1279648393392563,
-0.6493317484855652,
0.4085252285003662,
0.4194006323814392,
-0.07694696635007858,
-0.4944179356098175,
0.39758774638175964,
-0.33100610971450806,
0.04617178440093994,
-0.22164036333560944,
-0.030193032696843147,
0.2876371741294861,
0.3902897834777832,
0.34318554401397705,
0.8874656558036804,
0.4787602424621582,
-0.7572901844978333,
0.1028648316860199,
0.4414084851741791,
-0.18813827633857727,
0.535257875919342,
-0.5768091082572937,
0.2812315821647644,
0.01576581597328186,
0.33191433548927307,
-0.38138100504875183,
-0.23450103402137756,
0.10030318796634674,
-0.23905886709690094,
0.7871663570404053,
-0.25091850757598877,
-0.7398481965065002,
-0.19459380209445953,
-0.006341591943055391,
-0.10962584614753723,
0.4643127918243408,
-0.4994949698448181,
0.4306323826313019,
0.1000693216919899,
-0.06393129378557205,
-0.34044694900512695,
-0.600492000579834,
0.15708576142787933,
-0.01323757879436016,
-0.7717357277870178,
0.4579591155052185,
-0.3178873360157013,
-0.3061574399471283,
0.010426057502627373,
-0.09477713704109192,
-0.001420108019374311,
0.131508007645607,
0.19496425986289978,
0.28475049138069153,
-0.054395873099565506,
0.06539271771907806,
0.1765177696943283,
-0.11506292223930359,
-0.10266566276550293,
-0.7130560874938965,
0.625887393951416,
-0.041178636252880096,
-0.3074761927127838,
0.2685374915599823,
0.5436786413192749,
0.6253191828727722,
-0.6616613864898682,
0.491361528635025,
0.46740981936454773,
-0.013656439259648323,
-0.9374081492424011,
-0.0677381232380867,
0.04584723338484764,
-0.5085639953613281,
0.28695395588874817,
-0.23226967453956604,
-0.8517439365386963,
0.1901761144399643,
-0.3955318033695221,
0.26452428102493286,
0.2726840674877167,
0.7498431205749512,
0.11836520582437515,
0.8977513909339905,
0.8910943865776062,
0.2743849456310272,
0.24813887476921082,
-0.40079784393310547,
0.2098231166601181,
-0.4534049332141876,
-0.19576099514961243,
-0.7370865345001221,
0.23882536590099335,
-0.7899448275566101,
-0.5055968761444092,
0.11474613845348358,
0.14289063215255737,
0.12395115196704865,
0.5073830485343933,
-0.5911927223205566,
0.2554023861885071,
0.6230461001396179,
-0.29012414813041687,
0.17808230221271515,
-0.25810107588768005,
-0.4038998782634735,
0.4425507187843323,
-0.7402231693267822,
-0.5259112119674683,
1.008426547050476,
0.10954798012971878,
0.8510283827781677,
-0.14585097134113312,
1.0108352899551392,
0.4986043870449066,
-0.013636093586683273,
-0.5397912263870239,
0.4083859920501709,
-0.3635876178741455,
-0.5332326889038086,
-0.1483193039894104,
-0.6970437169075012,
-0.7135922312736511,
-0.3539043664932251,
0.0019969316199421883,
-0.29098621010780334,
0.21038247644901276,
0.005017939489334822,
0.07140453904867172,
-0.012074115686118603,
-0.7082028388977051,
0.5698168873786926,
-0.29580676555633545,
-0.44413256645202637,
-0.009796695783734322,
-0.6418959498405457,
0.21444860100746155,
-0.37387919425964355,
0.40017226338386536,
0.364613801240921,
0.16741658747196198,
0.2130132019519806,
-0.5900895595550537,
0.6676510572433472,
-0.254692018032074,
-0.45491552352905273,
0.3181542158126831,
0.13500720262527466,
0.7712964415550232,
0.07592771202325821,
-0.07111234962940216,
0.044507842510938644,
0.09454024583101273,
-0.3780164122581482,
-0.3968127369880676,
0.715934157371521,
-0.4532400071620941,
-0.48727667331695557,
0.034383829683065414,
-0.643904983997345,
-0.29510241746902466,
0.3910687565803528,
0.5040693879127502,
0.4337518513202667,
-0.1536821573972702,
0.07180974632501602,
0.8737779259681702,
-0.607414722442627,
0.1576632410287857,
0.5525631308555603,
-0.030536577105522156,
-0.07233163714408875,
0.6427490711212158,
-0.22429972887039185,
0.4295612573623657,
0.28494372963905334,
-0.10059771686792374,
-0.11445652693510056,
-0.7847669124603271,
-0.6002677083015442,
0.013587696477770805,
-0.8576117753982544,
-0.1783721148967743,
-0.5314381122589111,
-0.22444936633110046,
-0.6708952188491821,
-0.50162273645401,
-0.23104044795036316,
-0.42440664768218994,
-0.24923886358737946,
-0.2535017132759094,
0.03152335435152054,
0.71031254529953,
0.050033509731292725,
0.07873192429542542,
-0.720270574092865,
0.403978168964386,
-0.06517107784748077,
0.549051821231842,
-0.577072024345398,
-0.08178255707025528,
-0.2905392050743103,
-0.23366263508796692,
-0.059166014194488525,
-0.5287677049636841,
0.3976380527019501,
0.23957492411136627,
0.7379212975502014,
0.34422311186790466,
0.3163599669933319,
0.13798321783542633,
-0.5029248595237732,
0.6962109208106995,
-0.02347502112388611,
-0.7686525583267212,
0.6217505931854248,
-0.37580782175064087,
0.20290599763393402,
0.40470343828201294,
0.03831315040588379,
-0.48902201652526855,
-0.9181504845619202,
-0.6103518605232239,
-1.0085912942886353,
0.7323471903800964,
0.12467692047357559,
0.10437063872814178,
-0.23710736632347107,
0.30417001247406006,
0.24565166234970093,
0.23110704123973846,
-0.15852396190166473,
-0.12660928070545197,
-0.36519578099250793,
-0.26089921593666077,
-0.0075445957481861115,
0.03340088203549385,
-0.23879066109657288,
0.30750277638435364,
0.5757749080657959,
-0.3671554625034332,
0.0023152255453169346,
0.2593310475349426,
-0.27924928069114685,
-0.24241125583648682,
0.3126029968261719,
0.6429131031036377,
0.6828998923301697,
-0.38370877504348755,
0.06633161008358002,
-0.2157510221004486,
-0.49584701657295227,
-0.07423459738492966,
0.1671493500471115,
-0.4302203953266144,
0.024271994829177856,
0.43367403745651245,
0.47957539558410645,
-0.27542003989219666,
-0.9183552861213684,
0.4035661816596985,
-0.26253393292427063,
-0.5391727089881897,
-0.11155103892087936,
0.49744951725006104,
0.12274094671010971,
0.0819639042019844,
0.13053159415721893,
-0.13169993460178375,
-0.12566937506198883,
-0.3265087604522705,
0.533889651298523,
0.25544771552085876,
-0.2404821366071701,
0.022022439166903496,
0.6845957040786743,
0.3075927793979645,
-0.11682066321372986,
0.6499866843223572,
-0.46764788031578064,
-0.3478158712387085,
0.8252611756324768,
0.6173235177993774,
0.6881658434867859,
0.16244935989379883,
0.2375962734222412,
0.2731609344482422,
0.30513519048690796,
0.14365962147712708,
0.23326551914215088,
-0.24028435349464417,
-0.6074553728103638,
-0.2790597677230835,
-0.8244482278823853,
-0.2866203486919403,
0.15216830372810364,
-0.5818249583244324,
0.3659599721431732,
-0.7797811627388,
0.07707531750202179,
-0.25053662061691284,
0.12273021042346954,
-0.7969872355461121,
0.21725305914878845,
0.28910183906555176,
1.3745471239089966,
-0.5946173667907715,
1.2222989797592163,
0.523118793964386,
-0.47859734296798706,
-0.7731485366821289,
-0.10285551846027374,
-0.005775085184723139,
-0.535592257976532,
0.5144197940826416,
-0.1390368789434433,
-0.14827972650527954,
0.1283629983663559,
-0.6675116419792175,
-0.3236992359161377,
1.2109816074371338,
0.16787216067314148,
-0.617850124835968,
-0.16303491592407227,
0.08475709706544876,
0.6833745837211609,
-0.6046367883682251,
-0.1739448755979538,
0.6307805776596069,
0.4498746395111084,
0.10491011291742325,
-0.6068835258483887,
0.06434746086597443,
-0.5225776433944702,
-0.08468830585479736,
0.21777690947055817,
-0.3160538971424103,
0.478349506855011,
-0.23570844531059265,
-0.33390897512435913,
0.0018244717502966523,
0.18533645570278168,
0.2665911614894867,
0.3116367757320404,
0.3779151439666748,
0.28750619292259216,
0.8331701159477234,
0.047321200370788574,
1.2703958749771118,
-0.7533780932426453,
0.14220145344734192,
1.0126482248306274,
-0.4403776526451111,
0.40141746401786804,
0.5516265034675598,
0.08314146101474762,
0.3980123996734619,
0.4175485074520111,
-0.2612720727920532,
0.6860060095787048,
0.41408300399780273,
-0.10192567110061646,
-0.03958144783973694,
-0.2102397233247757,
-0.4557878077030182,
0.37975218892097473,
0.6188144087791443,
-0.5772159099578857,
-0.17568987607955933,
-0.42271432280540466,
0.1377260833978653,
0.2912414073944092,
-0.01933768391609192,
0.7645969390869141,
-0.039873700588941574,
-0.626564085483551,
0.5999820828437805,
0.33565932512283325,
0.5316608548164368,
-1.0530924797058105,
-0.026878757402300835,
-0.5244432687759399,
0.027400512248277664,
-0.2746996283531189,
-0.33735546469688416,
0.4406083822250366,
0.3188849985599518,
-0.12763278186321259,
-0.5653111338615417,
0.929256796836853,
-0.41301247477531433,
-0.3069225251674652,
0.4552920162677765,
0.5142787098884583,
-0.13508838415145874,
0.2957988977432251,
-0.2852321267127991,
-0.11110983788967133,
0.05122176185250282,
-0.2975696623325348,
0.30106207728385925,
0.6024891138076782,
-0.07562883198261261,
0.35492199659347534,
0.8705105781555176,
0.3890022337436676,
0.11570506542921066,
0.18585693836212158,
1.0469274520874023,
-0.4556434750556946,
-0.5481700897216797,
-0.2516915798187256,
0.2973514497280121,
-0.006376036908477545,
-0.09004590660333633,
0.4788644015789032,
0.4717935025691986,
1.0648442506790161,
-0.17864418029785156,
1.2094982862472534,
-0.45958781242370605,
0.22549472749233246,
-0.5993300676345825,
0.766852080821991,
-0.5205877423286438,
0.4517100155353546,
-0.0707162469625473,
-0.7942494750022888,
-0.293136328458786,
0.25626295804977417,
-0.05165217071771622,
-0.17277397215366364,
0.6320580244064331,
1.02238130569458,
0.08294807374477386,
-0.4182291626930237,
0.41414448618888855,
0.02038705162703991,
0.6223461031913757,
0.49367108941078186,
0.6972050070762634,
0.21810254454612732,
0.7770658731460571,
-0.1626109629869461,
-0.2209746092557907,
-0.07333339005708694,
-0.9242226481437683,
-0.7156728506088257,
-0.5099791288375854,
-0.25362589955329895,
-0.46568816900253296,
-0.12123459577560425,
0.8258906602859497,
0.6155651211738586,
-0.6313877105712891,
-0.07010442763566971,
-0.5320721864700317,
-0.06167595461010933,
-0.13488803803920746,
-0.17796455323696136,
0.3290025293827057,
-0.7425166368484497,
-0.7599940896034241,
0.574758768081665,
0.32357731461524963,
-0.060247648507356644,
-0.2738266587257385,
-0.5571596622467041,
0.18428656458854675,
0.24647767841815948,
0.33012235164642334,
0.2516699433326721,
-0.2869427800178528,
0.052185311913490295,
0.15703566372394562,
-0.6242807507514954,
-0.0016381972236558795,
1.1399116516113281,
-0.6338847279548645,
0.5359135270118713,
0.5132712721824646,
0.42766115069389343,
0.3698214292526245,
-0.02285458706319332,
0.7646435499191284,
-1.087289571762085,
0.10472697019577026,
0.18149980902671814,
0.19409584999084473,
0.36217066645622253,
-0.5137532949447632,
0.6473525762557983,
0.10791399329900742,
-0.3349018096923828,
-0.5932366251945496,
0.445947527885437,
-0.8144322633743286,
-0.6284978985786438,
1.4312909841537476,
-0.3074522018432617,
-0.16825398802757263,
-0.20069213211536407,
-0.1461997777223587,
0.434235543012619,
-0.20663945376873016,
0.7540613412857056,
0.40931084752082825,
0.16734746098518372,
0.13688738644123077,
-0.3709046244621277,
0.6911162734031677,
-0.16130930185317993,
-0.9744260907173157,
0.24923810362815857,
0.6904659867286682,
0.18516193330287933,
0.2360483855009079,
0.560566246509552,
-0.30215099453926086,
0.25237834453582764,
0.2792629897594452,
0.2909121811389923,
-0.5573521852493286,
-0.37803757190704346,
-0.21453703939914703,
0.13877134025096893,
0.25506892800331116,
0.08050962537527084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11317v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11317v1 | GUICourse: From General Vision Language Models to Versatile GUI Agents | 2024-06-17T08:30:55 | 2024-06-17T08:30:55 | Wentong Chen, Junbo Cui, Jinyi Hu, Yujia Qin, Junjie Fang, Yue Zhao, Chongyi Wang, Jun Liu, Guirong Chen, Yupeng Huo, Yuan Yao, Yankai Lin, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.HC | Utilizing Graphic User Interface (GUI) for human-computer interaction is
essential for accessing a wide range of digital tools. Recent advancements in
Vision Language Models (VLMs) highlight the compelling potential to develop
versatile agents to help humans finish GUI navigation tasks. However, current
VLMs are challenged in terms of fundamental abilities (OCR and grounding) and
GUI knowledge (the functions and control methods of GUI elements), preventing
them from becoming practical GUI agents. To solve these challenges, we
contribute GUICourse, a suite of datasets to train visual-based GUI agents from
general VLMs. First, we introduce the GUIEnv dataset to strengthen the OCR and
grounding capabilities of VLMs. Then, we introduce the GUIAct and GUIChat
datasets to enrich their knowledge of GUI components and interactions.
Experiments demonstrate that our GUI agents have better performance on common
GUI tasks than their baseline VLMs. Even the small-size GUI agent (with 3.1B
parameters) can still work well on single-step and multi-step GUI tasks.
Finally, we analyze the different varieties in the training stage of this agent
by ablation study. Our source codes and datasets are released at
https://github.com/yiye3/GUICourse. | [
-0.5003547072410583,
-0.6908405423164368,
0.3838462829589844,
-0.5320085883140564,
0.06871480494737625,
-0.0060828025452792645,
-0.06023649126291275,
-0.4765951633453369,
-0.24545130133628845,
0.9937614798545837,
-0.24428164958953857,
-0.7322867512702942,
-0.030477697029709816,
-0.22227098047733307,
-0.27089953422546387,
0.9934290051460266,
-0.12162977457046509,
-0.12853658199310303,
-0.45745816826820374,
-0.3567892611026764,
-0.2386753261089325,
-0.4124983549118042,
-0.6111562848091125,
-0.0635162889957428,
0.8379849791526794,
0.41706228256225586,
0.5897414684295654,
0.2322145700454712,
0.2656291723251343,
0.3558555841445923,
0.32805535197257996,
0.20336651802062988,
-0.3693627417087555,
0.08424048125743866,
-0.2855975925922394,
-0.35920020937919617,
-0.39781007170677185,
-0.043725453317165375,
0.27430328726768494,
0.6189049482345581,
-0.1147947907447815,
-0.22728857398033142,
-0.07442430406808853,
0.6352470517158508,
-0.7689543962478638,
0.21164117753505707,
-0.210196852684021,
-0.3791043758392334,
-0.1231788620352745,
0.29433977603912354,
-0.4585358202457428,
-0.20095676183700562,
0.24045078456401825,
-0.9607251882553101,
0.33376243710517883,
-0.002465911442413926,
0.8750189542770386,
0.15550246834754944,
-0.42510929703712463,
0.08385272324085236,
-0.49371224641799927,
0.5920947790145874,
-0.34419238567352295,
0.15725113451480865,
0.2848230004310608,
0.8592823147773743,
0.0076421587727963924,
-0.8639137744903564,
-0.32438650727272034,
-0.5455508232116699,
-0.01970602758228779,
0.1056697815656662,
0.047006797045469284,
0.6406301259994507,
0.6255838871002197,
0.06874000281095505,
-0.6532500982284546,
0.027782289311289787,
-0.21761870384216309,
-0.17593085765838623,
0.6942759156227112,
0.3335166871547699,
0.7615652680397034,
0.23755688965320587,
-0.06302937120199203,
-0.3972541093826294,
-0.3552064597606659,
0.007217517588287592,
0.23373748362064362,
0.08253469318151474,
-0.2088014781475067,
0.5523888468742371,
-0.3885461091995239,
1.0343769788742065,
-0.4514073431491852,
-0.23810400068759918,
0.12957391142845154,
-0.2152467519044876,
-0.24404160678386688,
-0.31520992517471313,
0.3570912778377533,
0.2062218338251114,
0.5595279335975647,
-0.09382625669240952,
-0.20187610387802124,
0.002529638586565852,
0.5700324773788452,
-0.5352644920349121,
-0.5448812246322632,
0.05113780498504639,
-0.09842919558286667,
-0.27709630131721497,
0.1600034385919571,
-0.3593162000179291,
-0.5363450646400452,
-0.5178961753845215,
0.4763731360435486,
-0.5139560699462891,
-0.17931711673736572,
-0.11260318756103516,
-0.5456574559211731,
0.3133887052536011,
1.1349821090698242,
-0.7189232707023621,
0.4637342095375061,
0.2855902910232544,
0.6729966402053833,
-0.18196971714496613,
-0.3570614457130432,
-0.5910857915878296,
0.16574321687221527,
-0.15862643718719482,
0.5603394508361816,
-0.516354501247406,
-0.37991511821746826,
-0.07980407029390335,
0.029805518686771393,
-0.09904886037111282,
-0.2727847993373871,
0.03660161793231964,
-0.29745838046073914,
-0.05783917009830475,
-0.23056289553642273,
-0.04163992404937744,
-0.5489279627799988,
0.30661338567733765,
-0.7638465762138367,
0.7204041481018066,
0.6184684038162231,
-0.8333553075790405,
0.3047073781490326,
-0.6641611456871033,
-0.43770068883895874,
0.2687273323535919,
-0.2802164852619171,
-0.3904632329940796,
0.07166291773319244,
0.10284831374883652,
0.27420464158058167,
-0.07609974592924118,
-0.2142113745212555,
-0.45760664343833923,
-0.37128183245658875,
-0.0030597017612308264,
-0.45499712228775024,
1.0513219833374023,
0.0243232361972332,
-0.13809052109718323,
0.05978208780288696,
-0.8742132186889648,
0.06397301703691483,
-0.06917603313922882,
0.036789216101169586,
-0.6524451375007629,
-0.16161887347698212,
0.37245404720306396,
0.0780300572514534,
0.051453590393066406,
-0.3422423303127289,
0.7190501689910889,
-0.10071113705635071,
0.18833503127098083,
0.56596440076828,
-0.09994968771934509,
0.4304315447807312,
-0.06245888024568558,
0.362788587808609,
0.1331547498703003,
0.320645809173584,
-0.1463417112827301,
-0.47300779819488525,
-0.9246491193771362,
-0.38948526978492737,
0.08965304493904114,
0.6340226531028748,
-1.482853889465332,
-0.21357254683971405,
-0.059963252395391464,
-0.564879834651947,
-0.13819441199302673,
0.02418334037065506,
0.3714200258255005,
0.4845289885997772,
0.23604527115821838,
-0.5697492361068726,
-0.1506301909685135,
-0.5621447563171387,
0.2483985722064972,
-0.26896196603775024,
-0.15560097992420197,
0.5097871422767639,
0.5725501775741577,
-0.495595782995224,
1.1748230457305908,
-0.49227628111839294,
-0.2007438987493515,
-0.27007079124450684,
0.3645278811454773,
-0.08233261853456497,
0.27347496151924133,
0.799467921257019,
-0.8235576152801514,
-0.4295575022697449,
0.5642982721328735,
-0.941010594367981,
-0.12827779352664948,
-0.07104643434286118,
-0.05688837915658951,
0.45385703444480896,
0.3016325831413269,
-0.27487751841545105,
0.889354944229126,
0.1673092097043991,
-0.21490606665611267,
0.7170661687850952,
-0.49589142203330994,
0.21201267838478088,
-0.4974227547645569,
0.18628104031085968,
0.14467042684555054,
-0.3465709388256073,
-0.7174861431121826,
-0.051636938005685806,
0.0539005808532238,
-0.1778673231601715,
-0.5273383259773254,
0.7671963572502136,
-0.6918675303459167,
-0.3765317499637604,
-0.3607015609741211,
0.013591521419584751,
0.054536204785108566,
0.6424066424369812,
0.21920959651470184,
0.8521957397460938,
0.8936672210693359,
-0.8128248453140259,
0.6079267263412476,
0.20847274363040924,
-0.2112458199262619,
0.766178548336029,
-0.48043522238731384,
0.07666440308094025,
-0.1972142457962036,
-0.0968976840376854,
-0.7673984169960022,
-0.3651784658432007,
0.29393529891967773,
-0.23321452736854553,
0.4260818362236023,
-0.2718878388404846,
-0.15390554070472717,
-0.504007875919342,
-0.04635659605264664,
0.1623692363500595,
0.5459994673728943,
-0.3718986213207245,
0.7033442854881287,
0.2143644243478775,
-0.004382712300866842,
-0.5874046087265015,
-0.39445021748542786,
0.17061351239681244,
-0.020347513258457184,
-0.5498619079589844,
-0.0823497623205185,
-0.04587486386299133,
-0.38584965467453003,
-0.03309069573879242,
0.23372136056423187,
-0.11051688343286514,
0.3249473571777344,
0.4162602424621582,
0.3524313271045685,
-0.05620591714978218,
-0.10966245085000992,
-0.1712871640920639,
-0.2849753797054291,
-0.2388041466474533,
-0.45481306314468384,
0.05008034035563469,
-0.19529150426387787,
-0.6100061535835266,
-0.15074290335178375,
0.16060929000377655,
0.5690114498138428,
-0.2406073361635208,
0.26649636030197144,
0.7080841660499573,
-0.1489080935716629,
-0.1359339952468872,
-0.4463331401348114,
0.025635020807385445,
-0.46779829263687134,
0.5220628976821899,
-0.5648784041404724,
-0.5279075503349304,
0.3735995888710022,
0.06450307369232178,
0.2789744436740875,
0.013323549181222916,
0.31962814927101135,
-0.1447947472333908,
1.1213738918304443,
0.9457384347915649,
-0.11064869165420532,
0.6650943756103516,
-0.47307974100112915,
-0.3341583013534546,
-0.6474853754043579,
-0.030518682673573494,
-0.35146206617355347,
0.06810081750154495,
-0.466644287109375,
-0.4177316427230835,
0.4122653901576996,
-0.17442820966243744,
-0.32989224791526794,
0.27044573426246643,
-0.32985299825668335,
0.48401692509651184,
0.8315678834915161,
0.23044390976428986,
0.08122051507234573,
0.35042238235473633,
-0.049123331904411316,
0.23543599247932434,
-0.579484224319458,
-0.39994296431541443,
1.0011742115020752,
0.07990255206823349,
1.2077951431274414,
-0.1311119943857193,
0.4812154173851013,
0.4756332039833069,
0.28270721435546875,
-0.6661252379417419,
0.6681501865386963,
-0.21892040967941284,
-0.1369287669658661,
-0.5845948457717896,
-0.2742033004760742,
-0.7094475626945496,
0.1309356987476349,
0.12179878354072571,
-0.8619637489318848,
0.19599653780460358,
0.054141752421855927,
0.07054917514324188,
0.3076331913471222,
-0.6833309531211853,
1.0216529369354248,
-0.5223166346549988,
-0.7734054923057556,
0.1117982417345047,
-0.834115207195282,
0.0760149359703064,
0.2769269347190857,
-0.1411459743976593,
0.10501901805400848,
-0.016017789021134377,
0.30048060417175293,
-0.5161745548248291,
0.9325215816497803,
-0.3412078022956848,
-0.20384538173675537,
0.45778021216392517,
-0.2186722755432129,
0.2747642993927002,
-0.10434853285551071,
0.07901163399219513,
0.264778196811676,
-0.13898545503616333,
-0.44797787070274353,
-0.8587716221809387,
0.2644709050655365,
-1.0084648132324219,
-0.5596069693565369,
-0.4694642126560211,
-0.276610404253006,
-0.1680242270231247,
0.2931124269962311,
0.2437194585800171,
0.6443822979927063,
-0.36901381611824036,
-0.16898787021636963,
0.7111349701881409,
-0.21850250661373138,
0.21936386823654175,
0.4540395736694336,
-0.1893347054719925,
-0.5362069606781006,
1.2128175497055054,
0.1420517861843109,
0.43976953625679016,
0.38211914896965027,
-0.3403242826461792,
-0.03413719683885574,
-0.5892004370689392,
-0.5916162729263306,
0.10248159617185593,
-0.7522648572921753,
0.029636941850185394,
-0.5187397599220276,
-0.3664949834346771,
-0.32833734154701233,
-0.43476489186286926,
0.07658293098211288,
-0.19088174402713776,
-0.3902781009674072,
0.2591743469238281,
0.3932991921901703,
0.811842679977417,
-0.10515553504228592,
0.19064471125602722,
-0.5990357398986816,
0.4219234585762024,
0.7081655263900757,
0.20355819165706635,
-0.2159574031829834,
-0.15759657323360443,
-0.4394732415676117,
0.284155935049057,
-0.3124813139438629,
-0.6536683440208435,
0.3451726734638214,
0.18919113278388977,
0.8636558651924133,
0.6166166663169861,
0.012738801538944244,
0.6606128811836243,
-0.310138463973999,
0.8202230334281921,
0.3031134605407715,
-0.5942074060440063,
0.7469267249107361,
-0.4003194570541382,
0.1402631551027298,
0.4356291592121124,
0.13946793973445892,
-0.5555905103683472,
-0.41857674717903137,
-0.480495423078537,
-0.5799070596694946,
0.8613133430480957,
0.2997640371322632,
-0.3276517391204834,
0.4229503273963928,
0.2567344009876251,
0.15089449286460876,
0.1755870282649994,
-0.3826068639755249,
-0.06579459458589554,
-0.5888780951499939,
-0.26059043407440186,
-0.30676573514938354,
0.0034252300392836332,
-0.153380885720253,
-0.14773420989513397,
0.49172934889793396,
-0.5269087553024292,
0.04202427342534065,
0.12999603152275085,
-0.4373798966407776,
0.3937828838825226,
-0.005385183729231358,
0.5421991348266602,
0.4259912967681885,
-0.1480816900730133,
-0.058522798120975494,
0.057006094604730606,
-0.8889573812484741,
0.36565905809402466,
-0.047127995640039444,
-0.3087100386619568,
-0.0658811703324318,
0.31681376695632935,
1.0306538343429565,
0.0001481616636738181,
-0.7125795483589172,
0.4515365958213806,
-0.18296295404434204,
-0.24672254920005798,
-0.18819013237953186,
0.7449159622192383,
-0.5042217373847961,
0.10090962797403336,
0.10892009735107422,
-0.08687131106853485,
0.32347187399864197,
-0.36057594418525696,
0.1773928999900818,
0.30253028869628906,
-0.52500319480896,
-0.1888902336359024,
0.6412348747253418,
0.5075013041496277,
0.05524127185344696,
0.8620569705963135,
-0.04137599095702171,
-0.30328306555747986,
0.8922392725944519,
0.20220497250556946,
1.0128114223480225,
0.02828521654009819,
0.4919876754283905,
0.2189280390739441,
0.2004823088645935,
0.03585169464349747,
0.04471159353852272,
-0.2810947299003601,
-0.5272649526596069,
0.032944902777671814,
-0.28816476464271545,
-0.7808584570884705,
-0.24854271113872528,
-0.5116289854049683,
0.44559603929519653,
-0.21514669060707092,
-0.134100079536438,
-0.355630487203598,
0.19521570205688477,
-0.7132917642593384,
0.41288670897483826,
0.2970639169216156,
0.8521478772163391,
-0.6408999562263489,
0.8775579333305359,
1.0091530084609985,
-0.7334338426589966,
-0.3342141807079315,
-0.27787846326828003,
-0.017690667882561684,
-0.6697876453399658,
0.6214312314987183,
0.166611447930336,
-0.04559113085269928,
0.056771133095026016,
-0.8272349834442139,
-0.3456490635871887,
1.169903039932251,
0.3067459762096405,
-0.45003464818000793,
-0.3453677296638489,
0.22391605377197266,
0.4301489591598511,
-0.2180764079093933,
0.7451683878898621,
0.35786476731300354,
0.42800116539001465,
0.30327337980270386,
-0.8166130781173706,
-0.30002886056900024,
-0.33585429191589355,
0.38574784994125366,
-0.12474270164966583,
-0.5356183648109436,
0.7665321826934814,
-0.5572866201400757,
-0.10915552079677582,
0.18134824931621552,
0.6121829152107239,
0.1553119421005249,
0.5261796712875366,
0.4094927906990051,
0.4567318558692932,
0.6967304348945618,
-0.23743808269500732,
0.9077544808387756,
0.14145103096961975,
0.0013761186273768544,
0.8042437434196472,
-0.4321214258670807,
0.3397012948989868,
0.03564760461449623,
0.003975356929004192,
0.531813383102417,
0.48833167552948,
0.035237058997154236,
0.36137256026268005,
0.13956835865974426,
-0.27503204345703125,
-0.4458729922771454,
0.14020124077796936,
-0.3741358816623688,
0.39963269233703613,
0.5819410681724548,
0.1811501830816269,
-0.3342568874359131,
0.7428292036056519,
-0.34362056851387024,
-0.11200310289859772,
-0.487430602312088,
0.8855839967727661,
-0.02867339365184307,
-0.45206543803215027,
0.44507545232772827,
-0.3324146866798401,
0.2350599318742752,
-0.8473714590072632,
-0.3670486509799957,
-0.3284551203250885,
-0.042574960738420486,
-0.07263939082622528,
-0.8617318272590637,
-0.2611716687679291,
-0.1601664423942566,
0.07296499609947205,
-0.04119042679667473,
1.0845476388931274,
-0.36255618929862976,
-0.25629863142967224,
-0.10842259973287582,
0.1942133903503418,
0.21066637337207794,
-0.1269080638885498,
-0.5402876734733582,
-0.1135483980178833,
-0.010401236824691296,
-0.14824971556663513,
0.2910410463809967,
0.6508232355117798,
-0.3439246118068695,
1.0106537342071533,
0.31421443819999695,
0.032824285328388214,
-0.2568496763706207,
0.29430851340293884,
0.8612325191497803,
-0.8386387228965759,
-0.49970221519470215,
-0.2510174512863159,
0.782310426235199,
-0.42157918214797974,
-0.05434264987707138,
0.7159887552261353,
0.39525458216667175,
0.7081665992736816,
-0.3453389108181,
1.2830840349197388,
-0.010754216462373734,
0.020457541570067406,
-0.6310762166976929,
0.8549591898918152,
-0.7743724584579468,
-0.08140678703784943,
-0.47829803824424744,
-0.6359145045280457,
-0.2258065789937973,
0.6219978928565979,
-0.2798786461353302,
0.2245885729789734,
0.2919427454471588,
0.6799507737159729,
-0.08580706268548965,
-0.3263748288154602,
0.7731288075447083,
-0.05399481952190399,
0.4985330104827881,
0.7882431745529175,
0.8113853335380554,
-0.2803237736225128,
0.4115689694881439,
-0.035809215158224106,
-0.3960545063018799,
-0.5912652015686035,
-0.603635311126709,
-1.1840237379074097,
-0.5554349422454834,
-0.5885281562805176,
-0.278822660446167,
0.38304346799850464,
0.22333133220672607,
0.6233097314834595,
-0.46473485231399536,
-0.200494185090065,
-0.33048051595687866,
0.28809815645217896,
-0.445802241563797,
-0.1703764647245407,
0.048931531608104706,
-0.3087006211280823,
-0.7400814294815063,
-0.2070186883211136,
0.49148285388946533,
0.6647910475730896,
-0.3710686266422272,
-0.24074332416057587,
0.2783918082714081,
-0.20895470678806305,
0.7016599774360657,
0.8485520482063293,
-0.5051169991493225,
-0.4144008755683899,
-0.08706565201282501,
-0.39331066608428955,
-0.06390880793333054,
0.6744039058685303,
-1.0922991037368774,
0.7676939964294434,
0.4384150505065918,
0.3302888870239258,
0.4880877435207367,
-0.08899668604135513,
0.5359436869621277,
-0.5207449793815613,
0.3572098910808563,
0.05414871498942375,
0.24705743789672852,
0.24823254346847534,
-0.050694771111011505,
0.6877841353416443,
0.34361985325813293,
-0.29970458149909973,
-0.5491395592689514,
0.32112082839012146,
-1.2894668579101562,
-0.19098559021949768,
1.0986350774765015,
-0.07089894264936447,
-0.5742220282554626,
-0.5070681571960449,
-0.9228952527046204,
0.0578339509665966,
-0.09976113587617874,
0.3429265320301056,
0.28101468086242676,
0.06897594779729843,
-0.3869331479072571,
-0.3306233584880829,
0.44419556856155396,
-0.33201339840888977,
-1.0895905494689941,
0.05923084542155266,
0.8463256359100342,
0.12824921309947968,
0.07001018524169922,
0.8191938400268555,
0.16478899121284485,
0.5705010890960693,
0.4464088976383209,
0.3659733831882477,
-0.3954984247684479,
-0.6347450017929077,
0.0477985180914402,
-0.01496850699186325,
0.062179531902074814,
-0.2742915451526642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11307v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11307v1 | An Empirical Investigation of Matrix Factorization Methods for Pre-trained Transformers | 2024-06-17T08:14:23 | 2024-06-17T08:14:23 | Ashim Gupta, Sina Mahdipour Saravani, P. Sadayappan, Vivek Srikumar | cs.CL | cs.CL | The increasing size of transformer-based models in NLP makes the question of
compressing them important. In this work, we present a comprehensive analysis
of factorization based model compression techniques. Specifically, we focus on
comparing straightforward low-rank factorization against the recently
introduced Monarch factorization, which exhibits impressive performance
preservation on the GLUE benchmark. To mitigate stability issues associated
with low-rank factorization of the matrices in pre-trained transformers, we
introduce a staged factorization approach wherein layers are factorized one by
one instead of being factorized simultaneously. Through this strategy we
significantly enhance the stability and reliability of the compression process.
Further, we introduce a simple block-wise low-rank factorization method, which
has a close relationship to Monarch factorization. Our experiments lead to the
surprising conclusion that straightforward low-rank factorization consistently
outperforms Monarch factorization across both different compression ratios and
six different text classification tasks. | [
-0.7806763648986816,
-0.5453252792358398,
0.15086723864078522,
0.3955613672733307,
-0.21249771118164062,
0.22635573148727417,
-0.2191697508096695,
-0.12425203621387482,
0.26197975873947144,
0.3327849507331848,
-0.45680636167526245,
-0.056438837200403214,
-0.7020363211631775,
0.38407787680625916,
-0.3886749744415283,
0.7081992030143738,
0.19618014991283417,
0.21293747425079346,
-0.34756866097450256,
0.14980192482471466,
-0.30456432700157166,
-0.9845301508903503,
-0.5021881461143494,
-0.4612881541252136,
0.49223005771636963,
0.34025800228118896,
0.843212902545929,
0.7031078338623047,
0.8796644806861877,
0.43508481979370117,
-0.18347543478012085,
0.16787227988243103,
-0.671800971031189,
-0.032396286725997925,
0.1711166650056839,
-0.3361457884311676,
-0.6133372187614441,
0.41937410831451416,
0.598068356513977,
0.7669084072113037,
-0.2789674401283264,
0.4807468354701996,
0.19796395301818848,
0.6579999923706055,
-0.5521855354309082,
0.15358389914035797,
-0.4845695197582245,
0.21340279281139374,
0.1924680769443512,
-0.745124340057373,
-0.8758955001831055,
-0.30649980902671814,
-0.2019072026014328,
-0.4069794714450836,
0.49790459871292114,
0.3217877447605133,
0.8491597175598145,
0.7085853815078735,
-0.5439612865447998,
0.10351020842790604,
-1.0606136322021484,
0.8348510265350342,
-0.48706507682800293,
0.4107297658920288,
0.4031387269496918,
0.24890685081481934,
-0.14522211253643036,
-0.6968370079994202,
-0.5966736674308777,
-0.06943438202142715,
-0.5796735882759094,
0.01726536639034748,
-0.24581344425678253,
0.17674976587295532,
0.5359361171722412,
0.5361834764480591,
-0.48317205905914307,
0.34215715527534485,
-0.3852810263633728,
-0.190489262342453,
0.3535122573375702,
-0.3065840005874634,
0.2390456646680832,
-0.4834713041782379,
-0.2886478006839752,
-0.7124875783920288,
-0.8754397630691528,
0.36162567138671875,
0.519366443157196,
0.319519579410553,
0.1780465990304947,
0.7680137753486633,
-0.09963756799697876,
0.4735197424888611,
0.47310417890548706,
-0.16972967982292175,
-0.26255980134010315,
-0.24280089139938354,
-0.33516454696655273,
0.04939386248588562,
0.5863244533538818,
0.178848996758461,
0.19026567041873932,
-0.2917894423007965,
-0.23944176733493805,
0.3633488714694977,
0.6625329256057739,
-1.0864320993423462,
-0.15037330985069275,
0.2128661572933197,
-0.8852648735046387,
-0.5616714954376221,
0.1584218442440033,
-0.5611457228660583,
-0.22605571150779724,
-0.5689499974250793,
0.749567449092865,
0.016722800210118294,
0.14732550084590912,
0.2775348126888275,
0.1702594757080078,
0.26353490352630615,
0.2687516212463379,
-0.9647262692451477,
0.31261271238327026,
1.0028680562973022,
0.5425317883491516,
-0.19019418954849243,
0.06421934068202972,
-0.8465736508369446,
-0.4056708812713623,
-0.26227807998657227,
0.8421090245246887,
-0.3526456952095032,
-0.2454526573419571,
0.1641179770231247,
-0.020495999604463577,
-0.13380815088748932,
-0.5114636421203613,
0.6353282332420349,
-0.44196826219558716,
0.24167202413082123,
-0.17705968022346497,
-0.3001556396484375,
-0.14168226718902588,
0.19092710316181183,
-0.7478488683700562,
0.9560987949371338,
0.04994863644242287,
-0.6623280644416809,
0.39002060890197754,
-0.1155688539147377,
-0.2078530490398407,
-0.22427652776241302,
-0.05677952617406845,
-0.525569498538971,
0.48042401671409607,
0.4344047009944916,
0.8047446012496948,
-0.36041340231895447,
0.13478896021842957,
-0.24364373087882996,
-0.5721897482872009,
0.22478480637073517,
-0.23594927787780762,
0.42284777760505676,
-0.31272953748703003,
0.01064461749047041,
0.17107242345809937,
-0.6458945870399475,
-0.005626274738460779,
-0.15028630197048187,
-0.4814453125,
0.24676761031150818,
0.07241048663854599,
-0.21715490520000458,
0.5862127542495728,
0.04315304383635521,
-0.3950333595275879,
0.649910569190979,
-0.24827921390533447,
0.2492828518152237,
0.647294282913208,
0.05553342029452324,
0.6219924092292786,
-0.33096837997436523,
0.7288297414779663,
0.012283730320632458,
0.3431960642337799,
-0.09857790172100067,
-0.12551531195640564,
-1.5537585020065308,
-0.12035717070102692,
0.6536896824836731,
0.5200454592704773,
-1.1532045602798462,
0.5970216393470764,
-0.8850140571594238,
-0.7222532629966736,
-0.4307444989681244,
-0.04000111669301987,
0.14008641242980957,
0.31657037138938904,
0.6353371739387512,
-0.19663257896900177,
-0.5401006937026978,
-1.1773242950439453,
0.21429303288459778,
-0.27440911531448364,
-0.3131621778011322,
-0.13096892833709717,
0.44612109661102295,
-0.05798296257853508,
0.860569179058075,
-0.49985018372535706,
-0.3524794280529022,
-0.21859952807426453,
0.6071831583976746,
0.287337064743042,
0.9337707161903381,
0.5361939072608948,
-0.5194594860076904,
-0.26415255665779114,
-0.28874075412750244,
-0.30080729722976685,
0.23939897119998932,
-0.14668366312980652,
-0.04476495459675789,
0.05693040043115616,
0.5621052980422974,
-0.6875891089439392,
0.4534580409526825,
0.8356292247772217,
-0.16062964498996735,
0.3829873204231262,
-0.19218984246253967,
0.25010690093040466,
-0.8365965485572815,
-0.011072508990764618,
0.00971230398863554,
-0.47029563784599304,
-0.8075645565986633,
0.04037947207689285,
-0.00007858606841182336,
-0.4149792790412903,
-0.32187068462371826,
-0.3035038411617279,
-0.29982858896255493,
0.05321554094552994,
-0.25207093358039856,
-0.3347608745098114,
-0.21833354234695435,
0.912711501121521,
0.20186170935630798,
0.6688944697380066,
0.20446261763572693,
-0.4263017773628235,
-0.24519816040992737,
0.41698771715164185,
-0.2337036281824112,
0.15912887454032898,
-0.8371584415435791,
0.5192750692367554,
-0.2685755789279938,
0.4403337240219116,
-0.6204856038093567,
0.29266974329948425,
-0.1623264104127884,
-0.30976590514183044,
0.6987994313240051,
-0.44341549277305603,
-0.8144561648368835,
-0.24748124182224274,
-0.5729657411575317,
0.2635391354560852,
0.722759485244751,
-0.6209867000579834,
0.8306325078010559,
0.19163890182971954,
-0.13263891637325287,
-0.6112441420555115,
-0.44424766302108765,
-0.08700907230377197,
-0.2251414656639099,
-0.6501581072807312,
0.44221606850624084,
-0.37989088892936707,
0.07535414397716522,
-0.37066349387168884,
-0.585602879524231,
0.06725572794675827,
0.15482565760612488,
0.2938404381275177,
0.41732120513916016,
-0.28975045680999756,
-0.20514461398124695,
-0.019256360828876495,
-0.39269962906837463,
-0.005078042857348919,
0.014674295671284199,
0.6785733699798584,
0.013756446540355682,
-0.06241092085838318,
-0.27693456411361694,
0.18823674321174622,
0.2562186121940613,
-0.14584538340568542,
0.9531513452529907,
0.6283441781997681,
-0.2731982469558716,
-0.3873574137687683,
-0.68612140417099,
-0.5664114356040955,
-0.5541169047355652,
-0.0832398384809494,
-0.021865854039788246,
-1.1125850677490234,
0.20857618749141693,
-0.31948116421699524,
-0.11669892817735672,
0.35668009519577026,
0.28441765904426575,
-0.176503986120224,
1.1883302927017212,
1.0336213111877441,
0.17197148501873016,
0.16637185215950012,
-0.4279112219810486,
0.6401956677436829,
-0.443163126707077,
0.1912946254014969,
-0.9726930856704712,
-0.5141892433166504,
-0.8640522956848145,
-0.7736949324607849,
0.2542458772659302,
0.43741151690483093,
-0.023286696523427963,
0.6404042840003967,
-0.6322134733200073,
0.3876902163028717,
0.3505181670188904,
-0.13051529228687286,
0.23914244771003723,
0.0399077944457531,
0.30292704701423645,
-0.04517515003681183,
-0.9031166434288025,
-0.5105090141296387,
0.7343108654022217,
0.36547553539276123,
0.47962212562561035,
0.3394070565700531,
0.6029182076454163,
0.2994881570339203,
0.49878692626953125,
-0.9517272114753723,
0.64910888671875,
-0.19368340075016022,
-0.21304884552955627,
-0.2007494419813156,
-0.3849540948867798,
-0.8728951811790466,
0.37635689973831177,
-0.9252205491065979,
-0.7304579019546509,
0.693856954574585,
0.119563527405262,
-0.3752235174179077,
-0.007307920604944229,
-0.5128828287124634,
0.5822411775588989,
0.3797866404056549,
0.020273158326745033,
-0.165171816945076,
-0.3268578350543976,
0.2874132990837097,
-0.27575165033340454,
-0.13699917495250702,
0.21478107571601868,
0.0386105515062809,
0.8381859660148621,
-0.6157762408256531,
0.5020803809165955,
0.17129391431808472,
0.10681255906820297,
-0.11481157690286636,
0.20346300303936005,
0.5570502877235413,
0.013804974034428596,
0.11708051711320877,
0.22540727257728577,
-0.07452639192342758,
-0.2682029604911804,
-1.006493091583252,
0.3910481929779053,
-0.7043694853782654,
-0.6623992323875427,
-0.3771749436855316,
-0.11541589349508286,
-0.41972464323043823,
-0.030385009944438934,
0.25392580032348633,
0.7870831489562988,
0.23698052763938904,
0.8290802836418152,
0.5839645266532898,
-0.15972504019737244,
0.7711285352706909,
0.59590083360672,
-0.23501813411712646,
-0.4196392595767975,
0.8691151142120361,
0.32531991600990295,
0.009102817624807358,
0.7141631245613098,
0.09291631728410721,
0.07650212943553925,
-0.6317013502120972,
0.03711846470832825,
0.1268235743045807,
-0.6850780248641968,
-0.5293243527412415,
-0.4841720163822174,
-0.26701343059539795,
-0.389194518327713,
-0.35566601157188416,
-0.6358097791671753,
-0.7615559697151184,
0.10488151013851166,
-0.18971973657608032,
-0.3159366846084595,
0.5197824835777283,
0.1681683212518692,
0.4240264594554901,
-0.8431105613708496,
0.3597428798675537,
0.3909696936607361,
0.05649399384856224,
0.03480101004242897,
-0.23711974918842316,
-0.36757707595825195,
-0.47229719161987305,
-0.2326478362083435,
-0.6435756683349609,
0.3088381886482239,
0.10291026532649994,
0.3491707146167755,
0.5065882802009583,
0.28089621663093567,
0.6477088332176208,
-0.6607142686843872,
0.737416684627533,
0.010189905762672424,
-0.87563556432724,
0.25769349932670593,
-0.1362428218126297,
0.04282444342970848,
0.5590112209320068,
0.5951786041259766,
-0.2416679859161377,
-0.10102052241563797,
-0.7655404210090637,
-0.868156909942627,
0.7260375618934631,
0.6092047691345215,
-0.11680883169174194,
0.21158969402313232,
0.3161983788013458,
-0.013253058306872845,
0.3554971218109131,
-0.7484556436538696,
-0.6271054744720459,
-0.15906547009944916,
0.16882409155368805,
-0.500935971736908,
-0.5855364799499512,
0.022050607949495316,
-0.5896169543266296,
0.8115401268005371,
-0.19208060204982758,
0.43851402401924133,
0.017037007957696915,
-0.5323805809020996,
0.03958233818411827,
0.2952300012111664,
0.6662001609802246,
0.4173826575279236,
-0.4045042395591736,
0.2388651818037033,
-0.13575580716133118,
-0.5436080694198608,
0.3970834016799927,
0.27023518085479736,
-0.19911973178386688,
-0.19535785913467407,
0.6050282716751099,
0.7448937296867371,
0.5954927206039429,
-0.060930974781513214,
0.5379763841629028,
-0.3053794205188751,
-0.0031294450163841248,
-0.07344045490026474,
-0.09732228517532349,
-0.1957000494003296,
-0.1857195794582367,
0.4862445294857025,
0.2515067756175995,
0.018965331837534904,
-0.27724918723106384,
-0.05648345127701759,
0.2358548641204834,
-0.302671879529953,
-0.2962786853313446,
0.3108842670917511,
0.2742154598236084,
-0.311428040266037,
0.6100140810012817,
-0.061129599809646606,
-0.4879206418991089,
0.20027725398540497,
0.23969969153404236,
0.7778844833374023,
-0.1572146862745285,
0.2669323682785034,
0.5768043398857117,
0.7174369096755981,
-0.30775728821754456,
-0.13415886461734772,
-0.26814693212509155,
-0.724625289440155,
-0.8745259046554565,
-0.7214477062225342,
-0.4305911660194397,
0.09105917811393738,
-0.7438609004020691,
0.4800553023815155,
-0.35683736205101013,
-0.411077618598938,
0.010160683654248714,
0.23560072481632233,
-0.7634256482124329,
0.042002178728580475,
0.06915296614170074,
1.0190528631210327,
-0.7543790340423584,
0.7436560988426208,
0.46423831582069397,
-0.3584285378456116,
-1.0307360887527466,
-0.09145104885101318,
-0.20265454053878784,
-0.21846719086170197,
0.6076430678367615,
0.3167639374732971,
-0.06225370615720749,
0.16732969880104065,
-0.3453947901725769,
-1.025357961654663,
1.0574243068695068,
0.3798220753669739,
-0.2511991858482361,
-0.029398243874311447,
0.3797604441642761,
0.6165232062339783,
-0.1272636502981186,
0.2896353304386139,
0.5328604578971863,
0.5378069877624512,
-0.1231103241443634,
-0.832653284072876,
0.04189203307032585,
-0.4461126923561096,
-0.012316062115132809,
0.14122433960437775,
-0.31440308690071106,
0.6947218775749207,
0.6180208325386047,
-0.3747730851173401,
-0.1020774245262146,
0.7805026769638062,
-0.06171051040291786,
-0.24340584874153137,
0.7393484115600586,
0.4579339027404785,
0.4119121730327606,
-0.2938407063484192,
1.0977741479873657,
-0.5302527546882629,
0.5536344051361084,
0.7644376754760742,
0.10117077827453613,
1.028727412223816,
0.4681381285190582,
-0.21582040190696716,
0.41229331493377686,
0.33062541484832764,
-0.18315576016902924,
0.007280029822140932,
0.19451379776000977,
0.2614184319972992,
-0.5165566802024841,
-0.21907642483711243,
-0.10575749725103378,
0.519963264465332,
-0.23813271522521973,
-0.010955801233649254,
-0.078621506690979,
-0.059442710131406784,
0.023666903376579285,
-0.05181271582841873,
-0.4002220332622528,
0.5983172655105591,
0.02651428058743477,
-0.8186774849891663,
0.5972703695297241,
0.04291514679789543,
0.882948100566864,
-0.5495214462280273,
0.04076814278960228,
-0.02721731923520565,
-0.05203494057059288,
-0.12511882185935974,
-0.04122071713209152,
0.047556910663843155,
-0.2575910985469818,
-0.309597909450531,
-0.8800224661827087,
1.0016367435455322,
-0.30930134654045105,
-0.546078085899353,
-0.06173121556639671,
0.5084159970283508,
-0.15652044117450714,
-0.1336708813905716,
-0.19152052700519562,
0.12934845685958862,
-0.33082133531570435,
-0.5588787794113159,
0.42977675795555115,
-0.2174881100654602,
0.11129513382911682,
0.6827288269996643,
0.8078793883323669,
-0.0024741345550864935,
-0.16210408508777618,
-0.05514802411198616,
0.8517933487892151,
-0.3845099210739136,
-0.36672407388687134,
-0.5637631416320801,
0.569133996963501,
-0.1587553471326828,
0.06496395915746689,
0.9240443706512451,
0.5047091841697693,
0.44757357239723206,
-0.3524075448513031,
-0.1841500848531723,
0.3405954837799072,
0.10198512673377991,
-0.5809705853462219,
0.8698410987854004,
-0.23764708638191223,
0.03964822739362717,
-0.30575820803642273,
-1.3166165351867676,
-0.31265971064567566,
0.4918307363986969,
-0.036805130541324615,
0.03075171634554863,
0.9198254346847534,
0.8113015294075012,
-0.017882034182548523,
-0.03610379621386528,
0.26002559065818787,
0.10229122638702393,
0.31841832399368286,
-0.021460428833961487,
0.8020276427268982,
-0.440510630607605,
0.4613593816757202,
-0.8092091679573059,
0.14979876577854156,
-0.14851567149162292,
-1.3029175996780396,
-1.0323151350021362,
-0.6919719576835632,
-0.5661859512329102,
-0.22527511417865753,
-0.6392835974693298,
1.057676911354065,
1.1833873987197876,
-0.5146997570991516,
-0.0030189999379217625,
0.25277990102767944,
-0.08603936433792114,
-0.2957237660884857,
-0.18924403190612793,
0.5074570775032043,
-0.06685114651918411,
-0.7882501482963562,
0.658255934715271,
0.2959548532962799,
0.09083390980958939,
-0.49765142798423767,
0.17240794003009796,
-0.028805306181311607,
0.4786857068538666,
0.6984456777572632,
-0.07434879243373871,
-0.21148337423801422,
-0.4093492031097412,
-0.029051434248685837,
0.09598584473133087,
0.08926521241664886,
1.1724234819412231,
-1.040895938873291,
-0.1269473433494568,
0.7470316886901855,
0.3294355869293213,
0.46494293212890625,
0.4016644358634949,
0.5702396631240845,
-0.9439110159873962,
0.3065977394580841,
0.13451215624809265,
0.46331238746643066,
0.39891451597213745,
-0.27994412183761597,
0.6635066866874695,
-0.06575608998537064,
-0.6789731979370117,
-1.0700018405914307,
-0.010377583093941212,
-1.4708378314971924,
-0.015354782342910767,
0.8806369304656982,
0.047960225492715836,
-0.18996229767799377,
0.26359033584594727,
-0.050758615136146545,
0.19308745861053467,
-0.1064305454492569,
0.8222060799598694,
0.7835315465927124,
-0.025797164067626,
-0.15813052654266357,
-0.4075595736503601,
0.8775114417076111,
0.2993882894515991,
-0.6933333277702332,
-0.35148653388023376,
0.1994563639163971,
-0.2541593015193939,
0.674543023109436,
0.17402133345603943,
0.18143005669116974,
0.025169776752591133,
-0.15144354104995728,
0.06906413286924362,
-0.2143595814704895,
-0.2552085220813751,
-0.6137165427207947,
0.5458872318267822,
-0.07384971529245377,
0.34255459904670715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11303v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11303v1 | VideoVista: A Versatile Benchmark for Video Understanding and Reasoning | 2024-06-17T08:09:00 | 2024-06-17T08:09:00 | Yunxin Li, Xinyu Chen, Baotian Hu, Longyue Wang, Haoyuan Shi, Min Zhang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite significant breakthroughs in video analysis driven by the rapid
development of large multimodal models (LMMs), there remains a lack of a
versatile evaluation benchmark to comprehensively assess these models'
performance in video understanding and reasoning. To address this, we present
VideoVista, a video QA benchmark that integrates challenges across diverse
content categories, durations, and abilities. Specifically, VideoVista
comprises 25,000 questions derived from 3,400 videos spanning 14 categories
(e.g., Howto, Film, and Entertainment) with durations ranging from a few
seconds to over 10 minutes. Besides, it encompasses 19 types of understanding
tasks (e.g., anomaly detection, interaction understanding) and 8 reasoning
tasks (e.g., logical reasoning, causal reasoning). To achieve this, we present
an automatic data construction framework, leveraging powerful GPT-4o alongside
advanced analysis tools (e.g., video splitting, object segmenting, and
tracking). We also utilize this framework to construct training data to enhance
the capabilities of video-related LMMs (Video-LMMs). Through a comprehensive
and quantitative evaluation of cutting-edge models, we reveal that: 1)
Video-LMMs face difficulties in fine-grained video tasks involving temporal
location, object tracking, and anomaly detection; 2) Video-LMMs present
inferior logical and relation reasoning abilities; 3) Open-source Video-LMMs'
performance is significantly lower than GPT-4o and Gemini-1.5, lagging by 20
points. This highlights the crucial role VideoVista will play in advancing LMMs
that can accurately understand videos and perform precise reasoning. | [
-0.48758435249328613,
-0.8442133069038391,
0.7962428331375122,
0.13133719563484192,
-0.3100165128707886,
0.12879200279712677,
0.10521124303340912,
-0.08720127493143082,
-0.1250322014093399,
0.31929507851600647,
-0.5887498259544373,
-0.2822963297367096,
-0.5679149031639099,
-0.01774180494248867,
-0.42812293767929077,
0.7018980383872986,
-0.4007054269313812,
-0.00011078168608946726,
-0.39188969135284424,
-0.43344956636428833,
-0.8439995646476746,
-0.33579906821250916,
-0.12740777432918549,
0.15040802955627441,
0.21055831015110016,
0.28716596961021423,
0.5513514876365662,
0.6973328590393066,
0.7716194987297058,
0.39213553071022034,
0.26236575841903687,
0.4993343949317932,
-0.14769795536994934,
0.031705453991889954,
-0.23031723499298096,
-0.21391421556472778,
-0.43994802236557007,
-0.2059527486562729,
0.7574650049209595,
0.43228450417518616,
0.02486017905175686,
0.7262794971466064,
-0.32089483737945557,
0.5524212718009949,
-1.0604861974716187,
0.1279830038547516,
-0.3947174549102783,
0.29835399985313416,
-0.089768186211586,
-0.20987343788146973,
0.04138398915529251,
-0.43731459975242615,
0.1346525400876999,
-0.6806567311286926,
0.30314117670059204,
-0.3830012083053589,
0.7530372738838196,
0.6462531685829163,
-0.4426453113555908,
0.23105721175670624,
-0.8952458500862122,
0.32998955249786377,
-0.17194393277168274,
0.7353212833404541,
0.355516254901886,
0.912837028503418,
0.35842975974082947,
-0.6623699069023132,
-0.5616607069969177,
0.13170020282268524,
0.5368822813034058,
0.05810163915157318,
-0.1928545981645584,
-0.07116882503032684,
0.4970344007015228,
0.2175261676311493,
-0.8587444424629211,
-0.15579009056091309,
-0.2978046238422394,
-0.12523135542869568,
0.4241963028907776,
0.5331931114196777,
0.13355864584445953,
-0.3367440700531006,
-0.23621496558189392,
-0.15809160470962524,
-0.1946205049753189,
0.27942633628845215,
0.28090915083885193,
-0.2770562469959259,
0.030747873708605766,
0.6503083109855652,
-0.4217981994152069,
0.4869331121444702,
-0.2706751525402069,
-0.16694331169128418,
0.34002768993377686,
-0.4897174537181854,
-0.6541251540184021,
-0.3093298375606537,
0.5786353945732117,
0.625179648399353,
0.09815625846385956,
0.20760753750801086,
-0.02799191325902939,
0.5557295083999634,
0.3657529950141907,
-0.8197416663169861,
-0.4067411720752716,
0.1523863673210144,
-0.3217806816101074,
0.16787873208522797,
0.09908580034971237,
-0.7925585508346558,
-0.24396249651908875,
-0.3105085790157318,
0.891633152961731,
-0.4027348458766937,
-0.3729344606399536,
0.17003339529037476,
-0.25942814350128174,
0.26132702827453613,
0.48642435669898987,
-0.5777427554130554,
0.5196225643157959,
0.5135721564292908,
0.7676101326942444,
-0.22299724817276,
-0.3960155248641968,
-0.9194687008857727,
0.1580074280500412,
-0.4054417014122009,
0.8919951319694519,
-0.31479573249816895,
0.010603154078125954,
0.015243467874825,
0.08335887640714645,
0.02708161063492298,
-0.5379784107208252,
0.19360962510108948,
-0.5237036943435669,
-0.0349949486553669,
-0.45410677790641785,
-0.3650525212287903,
-0.46198195219039917,
0.5510729551315308,
-0.8497870564460754,
0.8908607959747314,
0.014916506595909595,
-0.487222284078598,
0.8260690569877625,
-0.4931882321834564,
0.047705139964818954,
-0.0031766421161592007,
-0.39033910632133484,
-0.4438554346561432,
-0.1080334410071373,
0.34347137808799744,
0.32993292808532715,
-0.4233098328113556,
0.5419901609420776,
-0.41488397121429443,
-0.3229047656059265,
0.3327791094779968,
-0.673738956451416,
0.005466994363814592,
0.2532864809036255,
-0.32250747084617615,
0.24410425126552582,
-0.6225483417510986,
-0.0011927983723580837,
-0.16270111501216888,
0.12602683901786804,
0.003488639835268259,
-0.028575299307703972,
-0.10530166327953339,
0.2627866864204407,
-0.061539426445961,
-0.26644790172576904,
0.003345303935930133,
0.27177155017852783,
0.4109419286251068,
0.7325621843338013,
0.05422552302479744,
-0.006574682891368866,
0.03126301243901253,
0.7056339383125305,
0.1149408221244812,
0.5975293517112732,
-0.3274548053741455,
-0.4428407847881317,
-0.33899369835853577,
-0.352566123008728,
-0.034061070531606674,
0.382017582654953,
-0.8418553471565247,
-0.13249695301055908,
-0.3900761306285858,
-0.29864785075187683,
-0.5139258503913879,
0.34560438990592957,
0.4506753087043762,
0.49716705083847046,
0.6072279214859009,
-0.574830949306488,
-0.5963493585586548,
-0.823371946811676,
-0.05577418580651283,
-0.19785268604755402,
-0.02677624672651291,
0.14893941581249237,
0.6598907709121704,
-0.061595842242240906,
0.9385982155799866,
-0.5493242144584656,
-0.19017957150936127,
0.062052927911281586,
0.04622974246740341,
0.0549435019493103,
0.0972784087061882,
0.34354403614997864,
-1.025790810585022,
-0.2828422784805298,
-0.000005199484803597443,
-1.2402700185775757,
0.24695079028606415,
-0.05775311961770058,
0.24286136031150818,
-0.26527127623558044,
0.3309190273284912,
-0.6057217717170715,
0.4661222994327545,
0.2362232804298401,
-0.4909156262874603,
0.7219232320785522,
-0.22542181611061096,
0.648504912853241,
-0.4745483100414276,
0.014668838120996952,
0.03139815106987953,
-0.18845044076442719,
-0.35569503903388977,
-0.09067198634147644,
-0.03568285331130028,
-0.1079060360789299,
-0.6520009636878967,
0.15563374757766724,
-0.1548609584569931,
-0.691045880317688,
0.03713713958859444,
0.13042819499969482,
0.037750087678432465,
0.5523840188980103,
0.09163010120391846,
0.8970939517021179,
0.455938458442688,
-0.5951602458953857,
0.5701389908790588,
0.19959867000579834,
-0.4958949387073517,
0.709905743598938,
-0.607071042060852,
-0.10454772412776947,
-0.08723662048578262,
-0.08611473441123962,
-0.825264036655426,
-0.3334333300590515,
-0.06826015561819077,
-0.40850400924682617,
-0.3443341553211212,
-0.263462632894516,
-0.3632681369781494,
-0.19468559324741364,
-0.29629942774772644,
0.8303322792053223,
0.29682111740112305,
-0.43733420968055725,
0.6658426523208618,
0.35574090480804443,
0.12642954289913177,
-0.658493161201477,
-0.3311973810195923,
0.1911689192056656,
-0.6013288497924805,
-0.6500652432441711,
0.2233307659626007,
-0.1204100102186203,
-0.31413498520851135,
0.22650770843029022,
-0.3355271816253662,
-0.4965587556362152,
-0.19216030836105347,
0.19179823994636536,
0.1483592838048935,
-0.19960786402225494,
0.03660469874739647,
-0.09952357411384583,
0.01275524403899908,
0.24651379883289337,
-0.17792317271232605,
0.1845972090959549,
-0.32821834087371826,
-0.4475726783275604,
-0.3449229598045349,
0.33817678689956665,
0.6120300889015198,
-0.47492825984954834,
0.009102259762585163,
0.8829393982887268,
-0.270024836063385,
-0.0051789190620183945,
-0.7910133004188538,
0.1679556667804718,
-0.45790788531303406,
0.5257196426391602,
-0.6312265396118164,
-0.6114181280136108,
0.49867019057273865,
0.15026384592056274,
-0.2797030210494995,
0.24871499836444855,
0.49704667925834656,
-0.038154568523168564,
1.0467642545700073,
0.47759097814559937,
0.32005903124809265,
0.5333527326583862,
-0.41897475719451904,
-0.4393981397151947,
-0.3933318555355072,
-0.4307713210582733,
0.028175635263323784,
0.13922418653964996,
-0.4913303256034851,
-0.7571613192558289,
0.6115105152130127,
-0.2123989313840866,
-0.6471848487854004,
0.3378080725669861,
-0.28748583793640137,
0.5498685836791992,
0.18308435380458832,
0.11707773804664612,
0.45118284225463867,
-0.24401304125785828,
0.28339794278144836,
-0.19902092218399048,
-0.5804880857467651,
-0.404969185590744,
1.077930212020874,
0.5000518560409546,
0.5470482110977173,
0.4850797951221466,
0.20315119624137878,
0.6124849319458008,
-0.10625499486923218,
-0.5876891016960144,
0.6355664134025574,
-0.06976845860481262,
-0.37375137209892273,
-0.12967242300510406,
-0.38368311524391174,
-0.5412940382957458,
0.24996133148670197,
0.08882317692041397,
-0.4701360762119293,
0.11484114080667496,
0.12461075186729431,
-0.44473206996917725,
0.3346717357635498,
-0.7723703980445862,
1.1898071765899658,
-0.3685697019100189,
-0.8336166739463806,
-0.3744699954986572,
-0.5548422336578369,
0.5418718457221985,
0.011269958689808846,
0.362133651971817,
-0.09862284362316132,
-0.021448111161589622,
0.7278376221656799,
-0.4703499972820282,
0.42610031366348267,
-0.3475610911846161,
0.20349234342575073,
0.5950016975402832,
0.1544741839170456,
0.04063516482710838,
0.3990301787853241,
0.5552228689193726,
-0.15996938943862915,
0.3651556074619293,
-0.3200209438800812,
-0.9037759900093079,
0.19980080425739288,
-0.6570430397987366,
-0.42089200019836426,
-0.3237864375114441,
-0.29390931129455566,
-0.29956865310668945,
0.041883595287799835,
-0.14255227148532867,
0.43030282855033875,
-0.15207208693027496,
0.18298450112342834,
0.9427592158317566,
-0.17058712244033813,
0.3308383524417877,
0.4132708013057709,
-0.21708068251609802,
-0.6798189282417297,
1.0557154417037964,
-0.0036390265449881554,
0.18134239315986633,
0.3027367889881134,
-0.1609245240688324,
-0.25179654359817505,
-0.5000762939453125,
-0.5918323993682861,
-0.19914676249027252,
-0.8510867357254028,
-0.21015562117099762,
-0.4801384210586548,
0.041296377778053284,
-0.024876678362488747,
0.28559261560440063,
-0.6936540007591248,
-0.040098875761032104,
0.08378645777702332,
-0.4285292625427246,
0.3617894947528839,
0.4491055905818939,
-0.014556031674146652,
0.021404435858130455,
-0.733879029750824,
0.7374463081359863,
0.9358240365982056,
0.6205608248710632,
-0.31060513854026794,
-0.45868539810180664,
-0.3118366599082947,
-0.44040969014167786,
-0.37919411063194275,
-0.8053040504455566,
0.18396863341331482,
-0.08782577514648438,
0.5150448083877563,
0.4347761273384094,
-0.4764097034931183,
1.0028092861175537,
-0.42965030670166016,
0.8717359304428101,
0.19659921526908875,
-1.0025641918182373,
0.6306959390640259,
-0.4658101201057434,
0.16317206621170044,
0.6351380944252014,
0.31453967094421387,
-0.19092927873134613,
0.2612169682979584,
-0.5307432413101196,
-0.5497141480445862,
0.21736159920692444,
0.276852548122406,
-0.16465701162815094,
0.15620410442352295,
-0.06300123780965805,
0.2469869703054428,
0.30738958716392517,
-0.405155211687088,
0.29362237453460693,
-0.7412042617797852,
0.1217644065618515,
-0.025739377364516258,
0.03960835561156273,
-0.10990715771913528,
-0.3775855600833893,
0.1078324019908905,
-0.34903547167778015,
0.20997418463230133,
0.32180941104888916,
-0.3677479922771454,
-0.031053323298692703,
0.08911985903978348,
0.5002694129943848,
0.7918524742126465,
-0.6046011447906494,
0.06704780459403992,
0.3376663327217102,
-0.548760175704956,
0.36194878816604614,
0.07795806974172592,
0.21608774363994598,
-0.03808775171637535,
0.5025436878204346,
0.9301853179931641,
0.15103274583816528,
-1.1185407638549805,
0.6044971346855164,
-0.08927971869707108,
-0.3006107211112976,
-0.45385169982910156,
0.01979164406657219,
-0.3800438344478607,
0.4553219676017761,
0.26767033338546753,
-0.12008515745401382,
0.3912743031978607,
-0.6788442730903625,
0.4026194214820862,
0.2476707100868225,
-0.34753453731536865,
-0.5038714408874512,
0.8081035614013672,
-0.01720387116074562,
-0.05550706014037132,
0.4177266061306,
-0.12214604020118713,
-0.2897137701511383,
0.7715325951576233,
-0.24399064481258392,
0.9087256193161011,
-0.11203640699386597,
0.5394258499145508,
0.30835244059562683,
0.31537121534347534,
-0.23974156379699707,
0.5400182604789734,
-0.39521080255508423,
-0.5985270738601685,
-0.6095415353775024,
-0.2520550787448883,
-0.6022101640701294,
0.04567662626504898,
-0.8380753397941589,
0.2378040850162506,
-0.44078728556632996,
-0.2924310863018036,
0.14085350930690765,
-0.0757472962141037,
-1.0133191347122192,
0.4828583896160126,
0.07417614758014679,
0.835785984992981,
-0.9783159494400024,
0.755192756652832,
0.5508455634117126,
-0.8272421360015869,
-0.6704061031341553,
-0.4029381275177002,
0.017480093985795975,
-0.42624637484550476,
0.6690417528152466,
0.20406222343444824,
-0.18126210570335388,
-0.46072322130203247,
-0.2264765501022339,
-0.724990963935852,
1.2681981325149536,
0.34492960572242737,
-0.3027043044567108,
-0.1297549456357956,
0.12375547736883163,
0.5863215327262878,
-0.14747247099876404,
0.5585129261016846,
0.738842248916626,
0.3619866669178009,
0.09381715208292007,
-0.9468990564346313,
-0.18337661027908325,
-0.3889332115650177,
-0.15840992331504822,
0.16096049547195435,
-0.5253506302833557,
0.8617028594017029,
-0.11669369786977768,
0.21114012598991394,
-0.1780528724193573,
0.44997933506965637,
0.19788029789924622,
0.7300562858581543,
0.5895145535469055,
0.41766107082366943,
0.4025508463382721,
0.11205227673053741,
0.6182683110237122,
0.3481142222881317,
0.06956877559423447,
1.1173229217529297,
-0.18730096518993378,
0.6027757525444031,
0.5811501741409302,
-0.39333346486091614,
0.4665667712688446,
0.5710362195968628,
-0.3627631962299347,
0.5103333592414856,
-0.1558016687631607,
-0.10669656842947006,
-0.6712822914123535,
-0.11248263716697693,
-0.46115389466285706,
0.8078895211219788,
0.3278332054615021,
-0.09452809393405914,
-0.04476412758231163,
0.23364871740341187,
-0.4716718792915344,
0.11138737201690674,
-0.3341228663921356,
0.8041839003562927,
-0.20411686599254608,
-0.6603389382362366,
0.34162843227386475,
-0.4394475221633911,
0.2190742790699005,
-0.6977232694625854,
-0.2245240956544876,
-0.2349906861782074,
0.14620380103588104,
-0.23247502744197845,
-0.8555130362510681,
0.350187212228775,
0.4006955027580261,
-0.04879343882203102,
0.008001269772648811,
0.30969616770744324,
-0.061834175139665604,
-0.08722227066755295,
0.15756888687610626,
0.5935612916946411,
0.09977306425571442,
-0.162082239985466,
-0.33980780839920044,
0.32508495450019836,
-0.31282681226730347,
-0.1697392463684082,
0.3656765818595886,
0.49985963106155396,
-0.41770419478416443,
0.8622785210609436,
0.4272250533103943,
-0.3044770658016205,
-0.16242863237857819,
0.0657896101474762,
0.906265377998352,
-0.7800782322883606,
-0.48703429102897644,
-0.8042213916778564,
0.607589840888977,
-0.1070709154009819,
-0.41276073455810547,
0.7287123799324036,
0.6219634413719177,
0.7932832837104797,
-0.12656715512275696,
0.64503014087677,
0.10518311709165573,
0.05813763290643692,
-0.7017405033111572,
0.08710428327322006,
-0.6363465785980225,
0.29507261514663696,
-0.7197567224502563,
-0.8614508509635925,
-0.061313677579164505,
0.21221685409545898,
-0.4393545389175415,
-0.1514068841934204,
0.6141045093536377,
0.45418253540992737,
-0.26092052459716797,
0.05201679840683937,
0.2248280942440033,
-0.2015821635723114,
0.5024470686912537,
0.6883598566055298,
1.018188238143921,
-0.47033023834228516,
0.9806890487670898,
-0.18426825106143951,
-0.22195620834827423,
0.06521071493625641,
-0.7915958762168884,
-0.6439411044120789,
-0.6294496059417725,
-0.4816465675830841,
-0.014724023640155792,
0.2852766811847687,
0.7064056992530823,
0.7944429516792297,
-0.43585413694381714,
-0.3264332711696625,
0.028883209452033043,
0.06191834807395935,
-0.6142522096633911,
-0.19840781390666962,
0.35399553179740906,
0.20808593928813934,
-0.41148221492767334,
0.4076266884803772,
0.3501099944114685,
-0.27711552381515503,
-0.4506947994232178,
-0.038417041301727295,
0.003972846549004316,
-0.09150262922048569,
0.7430729269981384,
0.47686466574668884,
-0.5316802263259888,
-0.30515041947364807,
0.14645916223526,
0.3175954222679138,
0.07156311720609665,
0.909162700176239,
-0.9672443270683289,
0.7878173589706421,
0.5043861865997314,
0.614189624786377,
1.0363174676895142,
0.05840969458222389,
0.46446236968040466,
-0.4281120300292969,
0.08508719503879547,
0.18751822412014008,
0.19792470335960388,
0.3639109134674072,
-0.022997038438916206,
0.6799206137657166,
0.3653446137905121,
-0.4018499553203583,
-1.0445034503936768,
0.2567048668861389,
-0.9849899411201477,
-0.223239004611969,
0.7503774166107178,
-0.08928757905960083,
-0.0636293888092041,
-0.08157533407211304,
-0.0724623054265976,
0.1520380973815918,
-0.15784403681755066,
0.7106384038925171,
0.38150784373283386,
-0.2505996823310852,
-0.4834720194339752,
-1.0806630849838257,
0.5174641013145447,
0.5087417960166931,
-1.0012530088424683,
-0.0665305107831955,
0.6038626432418823,
0.42912808060646057,
-0.1802142858505249,
0.6204838752746582,
-0.055281076580286026,
0.8834609985351562,
0.16441558301448822,
-0.2150479108095169,
-0.34297218918800354,
-0.6926704049110413,
-0.2782956063747406,
0.44864943623542786,
-0.23101413249969482,
-0.49070414900779724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11301v1 | Optimizing and Testing Instruction-Following: Analyzing the Impact of Fine-Grained Instruction Variants on instruction-tuned LLMs | 2024-06-17T08:08:11 | 2024-06-17T08:08:11 | Jiuding Yang, Weidong Guo, Kaitong Yang, Xiangyang Li, Zhuwei Rao, Yu Xu, Di Niu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The effective alignment of Large Language Models (LLMs) with precise
instructions is essential for their application in diverse real-world
scenarios. Current methods focus on enhancing the diversity and complexity of
training and evaluation samples, yet they fall short in accurately assessing
LLMs' ability to follow similar instruction variants. We introduce an effective
data augmentation technique that decomposes complex instructions into simpler
sub-components, modifies these, and reconstructs them into new variants,
thereby preserves the original instruction's context and complexity while
introducing variability, which is critical for training and evaluating LLMs'
instruction-following precision. We developed the DeMoRecon dataset using this
method to both fine-tune and evaluate LLMs. Our findings show that LLMs
fine-tuned with DeMoRecon will gain significant performance boost on both ours
and commonly used instructions-following benchmarks. | [
-0.28350192308425903,
-0.776641845703125,
0.13743694126605988,
-0.08588901907205582,
-0.16373251378536224,
0.08774827420711517,
-0.4660557210445404,
-0.35104867815971375,
-0.19620084762573242,
0.5910699963569641,
-0.7463873028755188,
-0.6119779348373413,
-0.4722059369087219,
0.09866974502801895,
-0.23062945902347565,
0.7123803496360779,
-0.2610374987125397,
0.17488007247447968,
-0.232325479388237,
-0.07311252504587173,
-0.3683556616306305,
-0.24758601188659668,
-0.2610310912132263,
-0.3378489017486572,
0.2349000871181488,
0.8153497576713562,
0.6951004862785339,
1.0194331407546997,
0.5682289600372314,
0.3103867471218109,
-0.020759325474500656,
0.6373617649078369,
-0.6183040142059326,
-0.011881411075592041,
-0.0011218638392165303,
-0.5953982472419739,
-0.5084314942359924,
-0.10323449224233627,
0.5225205421447754,
0.8941251039505005,
-0.27421680092811584,
0.17887426912784576,
0.24444128572940826,
0.6428220868110657,
-0.8175038695335388,
0.0802091434597969,
-0.4717109203338623,
-0.2244422435760498,
0.0996808186173439,
-0.376808762550354,
-0.42394840717315674,
-0.8444823622703552,
-0.033259063959121704,
-0.42067432403564453,
0.40537229180336,
-0.07605687528848648,
0.5459524393081665,
0.2634076178073883,
-0.2257731407880783,
-0.2893069088459015,
-0.7707822322845459,
0.6977778673171997,
-0.786309540271759,
0.6905750036239624,
0.29099521040916443,
0.17000643908977509,
-0.3656737804412842,
-0.6435241103172302,
-0.24600280821323395,
-0.2701650857925415,
0.15254946053028107,
0.1218559741973877,
-0.011740525253117085,
0.26619529724121094,
0.3348236083984375,
0.5236318111419678,
-0.41743430495262146,
0.4037518799304962,
-0.453133761882782,
0.02822977490723133,
0.5195586681365967,
0.39570558071136475,
0.23835742473602295,
0.327099472284317,
-0.10133741050958633,
-0.3254946768283844,
-0.7572367787361145,
0.07423952966928482,
0.7375718355178833,
0.3937692940235138,
0.0043554482981562614,
0.6561762690544128,
-0.4354062080383301,
1.1713588237762451,
0.17152327299118042,
-0.14112819731235504,
0.31099504232406616,
-0.41028425097465515,
-0.1934315264225006,
-0.03403840586543083,
0.3546508848667145,
0.5157299637794495,
0.268292635679245,
-0.09538503736257553,
-0.27536293864250183,
-0.1959245204925537,
0.2662578523159027,
-0.9982388615608215,
-0.30502232909202576,
-0.0017401258228346705,
-0.2800428569316864,
-0.16255682706832886,
0.28572607040405273,
-0.650108277797699,
-0.14673872292041779,
-0.7715060114860535,
0.2136356681585312,
-0.5891244411468506,
0.2447431981563568,
0.42515215277671814,
-0.014140966348350048,
0.40161842107772827,
0.3584475815296173,
-1.2932873964309692,
0.34632986783981323,
1.034281849861145,
0.4565773606300354,
-0.3157197833061218,
-0.2044057548046112,
-0.5703163146972656,
0.07111227512359619,
-0.602562665939331,
0.7000263333320618,
-0.998336136341095,
-0.3284808099269867,
0.14419421553611755,
0.13192589581012726,
0.044756487011909485,
-0.8120204210281372,
0.4825495481491089,
-0.4527730643749237,
0.06486915051937103,
-0.12246786057949066,
-0.9711720943450928,
-0.07929976284503937,
0.24651622772216797,
-0.6600930690765381,
0.993510901927948,
0.3836281895637512,
-0.35377541184425354,
0.14713607728481293,
-0.1929580122232437,
-0.5129721164703369,
-0.1983412504196167,
-0.29922086000442505,
-0.17260196805000305,
0.3717960715293884,
0.21284140646457672,
0.29924675822257996,
-0.06771460920572281,
-0.37540197372436523,
-0.22854827344417572,
-0.7722326517105103,
0.10661507397890091,
-0.663343608379364,
0.5082941055297852,
-0.1540801078081131,
-0.2888941466808319,
-0.05560486391186714,
-0.8698616027832031,
0.3128604590892792,
-0.3196871280670166,
-0.5109311938285828,
-0.2426268607378006,
0.1263706088066101,
-0.4252818822860718,
-0.31677117943763733,
0.42046216130256653,
-0.3605397939682007,
0.45067790150642395,
-0.49387919902801514,
0.04109323024749756,
0.8187654614448547,
-0.04722293093800545,
0.5452116131782532,
-0.3635687232017517,
0.6311401128768921,
-0.34231626987457275,
0.39893677830696106,
-0.2836860120296478,
-0.06844944506883621,
-0.7564644813537598,
-0.11185859888792038,
0.3339727222919464,
0.6507288217544556,
-0.36389288306236267,
0.47674325108528137,
-0.23266252875328064,
-0.5684753060340881,
-0.671757161617279,
0.37677815556526184,
0.2898246645927429,
0.40598437190055847,
0.3235538601875305,
-0.2338942140340805,
-0.5886053442955017,
-0.8698441386222839,
-0.16918280720710754,
0.17010708153247833,
0.07530415803194046,
0.09457439184188843,
0.025273088365793228,
-0.36793091893196106,
0.491363525390625,
-0.605231761932373,
0.25000059604644775,
-0.1540747880935669,
-0.1233629360795021,
0.1735275834798813,
0.5110535621643066,
0.10937953740358353,
-0.4848994016647339,
-0.4471081495285034,
0.22217032313346863,
-0.22250038385391235,
-0.2517009973526001,
0.12338031828403473,
0.05535942316055298,
0.0669734999537468,
0.7191193699836731,
-0.1568121612071991,
0.3452622890472412,
0.7467129230499268,
0.18916301429271698,
0.6096493005752563,
-0.21441017091274261,
0.5393406748771667,
-0.7868461012840271,
-0.31277137994766235,
-0.27474477887153625,
-0.16856320202350616,
-0.48210737109184265,
0.13254565000534058,
0.37811926007270813,
0.24862587451934814,
-0.35209324955940247,
0.134154811501503,
-0.6267099976539612,
0.024461280554533005,
-0.4126112759113312,
-0.04555026441812515,
0.0018221703357994556,
0.22107084095478058,
-0.29991933703422546,
1.1353614330291748,
0.37343135476112366,
-0.49879708886146545,
0.41394510865211487,
-0.02436317875981331,
-0.5779750943183899,
0.23909573256969452,
-0.6125946640968323,
0.19490374624729156,
-0.12717585265636444,
-0.036362070590257645,
-1.0254740715026855,
-0.23210380971431732,
0.023646295070648193,
-0.0033777845092117786,
0.5143516063690186,
-0.2925584614276886,
-0.5584551095962524,
0.0029757393058389425,
-0.4020840525627136,
0.2681206166744232,
0.7662936449050903,
-0.5192180871963501,
0.6311691999435425,
-0.09412498027086258,
0.06337513774633408,
-0.5674243569374084,
-0.47370317578315735,
-0.3536181151866913,
0.03493744134902954,
-0.3286100924015045,
0.45493391156196594,
-0.17338591814041138,
-0.16040699183940887,
-0.27946317195892334,
-0.4807015061378479,
0.1400093287229538,
0.07125639915466309,
0.27941086888313293,
0.32579702138900757,
-0.2181885540485382,
-0.16798384487628937,
0.2056310623884201,
0.04718261957168579,
-0.15282094478607178,
-0.03799142315983772,
0.6805160045623779,
0.10112155228853226,
-0.5860689878463745,
-0.7434728145599365,
0.11793764680624008,
0.3201606571674347,
-0.061575789004564285,
0.3770826458930969,
0.33388474583625793,
-0.15643583238124847,
-0.46189644932746887,
-0.5062035918235779,
-0.3187384605407715,
-0.5740572214126587,
0.5699208378791809,
-0.18628130853176117,
-0.7179107069969177,
0.20336885750293732,
-0.399244099855423,
0.31544697284698486,
-0.032377924770116806,
0.3370817303657532,
-0.3357597887516022,
0.9350547790527344,
0.6687309145927429,
0.021961795166134834,
0.7418764233589172,
-0.267849862575531,
-0.054022032767534256,
-0.8281005620956421,
-0.16207970678806305,
-0.48739224672317505,
-0.4143930673599243,
-0.636030375957489,
-0.5918019413948059,
-0.04732728749513626,
0.2610020637512207,
-0.036999501287937164,
0.470022052526474,
-0.3950917720794678,
0.9338481426239014,
0.41195929050445557,
0.3188580274581909,
0.2932741940021515,
0.09911969304084778,
0.1568855494260788,
-0.08784220367670059,
-0.5389384031295776,
-0.7136887907981873,
1.0541685819625854,
0.16630885004997253,
1.3471568822860718,
-0.019381515681743622,
0.6825072169303894,
0.07703984528779984,
0.22560089826583862,
-0.7097642421722412,
0.5142611861228943,
-0.6871856451034546,
-0.13450568914413452,
0.029068050906062126,
-0.3638594150543213,
-0.812745988368988,
-0.10921420156955719,
0.0027232058346271515,
-0.7174959182739258,
-0.03361287713050842,
0.24615442752838135,
-0.35901156067848206,
0.07802728563547134,
-0.9424214363098145,
0.6148921251296997,
-0.2592165470123291,
0.0008314820006489754,
-0.1448628008365631,
-0.3668842911720276,
0.20723655819892883,
0.1251474767923355,
-0.17454800009727478,
0.02949836105108261,
-0.33642733097076416,
0.4547663927078247,
-0.2557147443294525,
0.978496789932251,
0.2923744022846222,
-0.30449846386909485,
0.057461779564619064,
0.10498002916574478,
0.6345755457878113,
-0.20161716639995575,
-0.08751232177019119,
-0.17424657940864563,
-0.0854804664850235,
-0.3064008951187134,
-1.0567388534545898,
0.7503371834754944,
-0.8286792635917664,
-0.7639170289039612,
0.1541454792022705,
-0.670192301273346,
-0.4359358549118042,
-0.03265759348869324,
0.16457462310791016,
0.693939745426178,
-0.14539393782615662,
0.24901780486106873,
1.0436450242996216,
0.007101607974618673,
0.1135898306965828,
0.4848993718624115,
-0.020875096321105957,
-0.4705621898174286,
0.6833049654960632,
0.0629272609949112,
0.6092785000801086,
0.5863889455795288,
-0.010608759708702564,
-0.18321846425533295,
-0.7918602228164673,
-0.391139954328537,
-0.05920366942882538,
-0.6621259450912476,
-0.16200514137744904,
-0.15936672687530518,
-0.1701408475637436,
-0.33508267998695374,
-0.15535320341587067,
-0.5224841237068176,
-0.3161889314651489,
-0.5242426991462708,
-0.1758984923362732,
0.17971989512443542,
0.5684517621994019,
0.07454022020101547,
0.5786982774734497,
-0.9276527762413025,
0.17200398445129395,
0.30621039867401123,
0.41442424058914185,
-0.21963940560817719,
-0.718988835811615,
-0.24580274522304535,
0.34704726934432983,
-0.3218841254711151,
-0.8477714657783508,
-0.1805109828710556,
0.1944449245929718,
0.6377116441726685,
0.3405468165874481,
-0.13704033195972443,
0.9699416160583496,
-0.7152125239372253,
0.5236033201217651,
-0.0331263430416584,
-0.7478116154670715,
0.5538666844367981,
0.022361233830451965,
0.3366044759750366,
0.8212670683860779,
0.3093511760234833,
-0.13648013770580292,
-0.3080243468284607,
-0.5250547528266907,
-0.6501551866531372,
0.6151543259620667,
0.02263091504573822,
0.38042715191841125,
0.21103572845458984,
0.6609910726547241,
0.3378581702709198,
-0.042714692652225494,
0.05196613445878029,
-0.4411000907421112,
0.33003222942352295,
-0.5834545493125916,
-0.12189368158578873,
-0.1814887970685959,
-0.34640929102897644,
-0.21855778992176056,
0.600516140460968,
0.0000032586838187853573,
-0.104537732899189,
-0.11138538271188736,
0.014142733998596668,
-0.09644835442304611,
0.14965097606182098,
0.814643919467926,
0.8491530418395996,
-0.3003127872943878,
0.08277421444654465,
0.34853458404541016,
-0.5583813190460205,
0.16722573339939117,
0.2354702204465866,
-0.18628118932247162,
0.038453053683042526,
0.48024114966392517,
0.8238694667816162,
0.22167426347732544,
-0.8227481245994568,
0.27341651916503906,
-0.04881203919649124,
-0.023116188123822212,
-0.07858672738075256,
0.7709688544273376,
0.055509302765131,
0.3321481943130493,
0.23315486311912537,
-0.03108351305127144,
0.07196604460477829,
-0.46680963039398193,
0.5197355151176453,
0.29977110028266907,
-0.35117775201797485,
-0.2920794188976288,
0.07919074594974518,
0.06948205083608627,
-0.48632052540779114,
0.4869277775287628,
0.02353251725435257,
-0.33531439304351807,
0.6737185120582581,
0.5645716786384583,
0.4701797664165497,
-0.38715434074401855,
0.035853639245033264,
0.26572054624557495,
0.4454199969768524,
-0.24202321469783783,
0.40010887384414673,
0.03059505857527256,
-0.5871843695640564,
-0.544032096862793,
-0.25413262844085693,
-0.5029609203338623,
-0.03884615749120712,
-0.9636227488517761,
0.42329978942871094,
-0.46001896262168884,
0.08393732458353043,
-0.08176283538341522,
-0.016184816136956215,
-0.5683342218399048,
0.12744693458080292,
0.025912541896104813,
1.187746286392212,
-0.7235154509544373,
0.6670096516609192,
0.582735538482666,
-0.06876349449157715,
-0.9974662065505981,
0.11440147459506989,
-0.17782148718833923,
-0.9525524377822876,
0.40548470616340637,
0.2720063328742981,
-0.08292721211910248,
-0.049652304500341415,
-0.6222924590110779,
-0.7026306986808777,
1.0927311182022095,
0.6044756174087524,
-1.0555498600006104,
0.20809637010097504,
0.23486961424350739,
0.4266679286956787,
-0.2517502009868622,
0.33202776312828064,
0.8667001128196716,
0.1875850409269333,
0.1548910140991211,
-0.6021988391876221,
-0.10294096916913986,
0.15086089074611664,
-0.03618919476866722,
0.49205583333969116,
-0.5841564536094666,
0.532468855381012,
-0.12223514169454575,
-0.0656777173280716,
0.05635502561926842,
0.6357298493385315,
0.21222762763500214,
-0.01551098469644785,
0.4061323404312134,
0.7092078924179077,
0.7412026524543762,
0.02129483036696911,
0.8395651578903198,
-0.2595188617706299,
0.22517871856689453,
1.5984382629394531,
-0.1460210531949997,
0.9219675660133362,
0.4987654387950897,
-0.19073700904846191,
0.6139879822731018,
0.6541630625724792,
-0.1321278065443039,
0.506605863571167,
0.3360459506511688,
-0.19021788239479065,
-0.2410595417022705,
0.055485278367996216,
-0.30243629217147827,
0.37377652525901794,
0.254123330116272,
-0.3734021782875061,
-0.3254653513431549,
-0.19166876375675201,
-0.07145730406045914,
0.17039379477500916,
-0.21044687926769257,
0.8309312462806702,
-0.18613925576210022,
-0.6214099526405334,
0.7246097326278687,
-0.032704733312129974,
0.4303451478481293,
-0.5503690838813782,
-0.36072400212287903,
-0.47357645630836487,
0.22159337997436523,
-0.24490579962730408,
-0.7963113188743591,
0.08801720291376114,
0.0015849022893235087,
-0.13071957230567932,
0.02583998814225197,
0.4086940884590149,
-0.5766143202781677,
-0.41648396849632263,
0.07162457704544067,
0.24548694491386414,
-0.02195896953344345,
0.32734376192092896,
-0.6315773129463196,
0.4873661696910858,
0.3433266878128052,
-0.1805843859910965,
0.2698225975036621,
0.4654979407787323,
0.14107564091682434,
0.5804195404052734,
0.4917847812175751,
0.08965437859296799,
0.2213013619184494,
0.2584685683250427,
0.9529092311859131,
-0.46044936776161194,
-0.0011818065540865064,
-1.0257948637008667,
0.45896798372268677,
-0.06936981528997421,
-0.3200717270374298,
0.6829937100410461,
0.80295330286026,
1.0071139335632324,
0.04498797282576561,
0.5547201633453369,
0.1720750480890274,
0.19168910384178162,
-0.7013797163963318,
0.13206368684768677,
-0.34513577818870544,
0.43172845244407654,
0.07563662528991699,
-0.9744535088539124,
-0.04842706397175789,
0.29672229290008545,
-0.10500989854335785,
0.05023123323917389,
0.45384475588798523,
1.1905755996704102,
-0.33694836497306824,
0.13271208107471466,
0.22372864186763763,
-0.11907748132944107,
0.04179468750953674,
0.46201181411743164,
0.9283790588378906,
-0.6414521336555481,
0.5852780342102051,
-0.5234862565994263,
-0.4147164225578308,
-0.12274675071239471,
-0.6452062129974365,
-0.8912118673324585,
-0.28869110345840454,
-0.4403601884841919,
-0.19868947565555573,
0.2130187302827835,
0.9722656011581421,
0.6570692658424377,
-0.8200654983520508,
-0.2761964499950409,
-0.20047421753406525,
0.05180589482188225,
-0.3485657274723053,
-0.17356398701667786,
0.3410169780254364,
-0.5061070919036865,
-0.9635961651802063,
0.4369550943374634,
0.11106130480766296,
0.30630719661712646,
-0.09918247908353806,
-0.09016204625368118,
0.04737000912427902,
0.06723388284444809,
0.3389807641506195,
0.04590190201997757,
-0.5897235870361328,
-0.31026193499565125,
0.30680349469184875,
-0.2676362693309784,
0.0022697870153933764,
0.8078353404998779,
-0.3130943775177002,
0.5130882263183594,
0.5930628180503845,
0.9823819398880005,
0.19180427491664886,
0.43284082412719727,
0.6797678470611572,
-0.7494378685951233,
-0.19646330177783966,
0.23632612824440002,
0.2096565067768097,
0.3122929334640503,
-0.24726596474647522,
0.5180198550224304,
-0.14435212314128876,
-0.5072263479232788,
-0.757866382598877,
0.17880520224571228,
-1.013412594795227,
-0.27615752816200256,
1.3207720518112183,
-0.16270384192466736,
-0.17205558717250824,
0.19279447197914124,
-0.3092101514339447,
0.2338644415140152,
-0.27927446365356445,
0.6797688603401184,
0.5865689516067505,
-0.2732399106025696,
-0.22638894617557526,
-0.5560896396636963,
0.3859298825263977,
0.3531090319156647,
-0.7989877462387085,
0.2293747067451477,
0.48716044425964355,
0.420452743768692,
-0.08946483582258224,
0.08487532287836075,
-0.08677129447460175,
0.3089500963687897,
-0.20717760920524597,
0.015020778402686119,
-0.17489337921142578,
-0.15672987699508667,
-0.37041547894477844,
-0.08788160979747772,
0.0054670399986207485,
-0.592136800289154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11924v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11924v1 | Explainable assessment of financial experts' credibility by classifying social media forecasts and checking the predictions with actual market data | 2024-06-17T08:08:03 | 2024-06-17T08:08:03 | Silvia García-Méndez, Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, Jaime González-Gonzáleza, Francisco J. González-Castaño | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Social media include diverse interaction metrics related to user popularity,
the most evident example being the number of user followers. The latter has
raised concerns about the credibility of the posts by the most popular
creators. However, most existing approaches to assess credibility in social
media strictly consider this problem a binary classification, often based on a
priori information, without checking if actual real-world facts back the users'
comments. In addition, they do not provide automatic explanations of their
predictions to foster their trustworthiness. In this work, we propose a
credibility assessment solution for financial creators in social media that
combines Natural Language Processing and Machine Learning. The reputation of
the contributors is assessed by automatically classifying their forecasts on
asset values by type and verifying these predictions with actual market data to
approximate their probability of success. The outcome of this verification is a
continuous credibility score instead of a binary result, an entirely novel
contribution by this work. Moreover, social media metrics (i.e., user context)
are exploited by calculating their correlation with the credibility rankings,
providing insights on the interest of the end-users in financial posts and
their forecasts (i.e., drop or rise). Finally, the system provides natural
language explanations of its decisions based on a model-agnostic analysis of
relevant features. | [
-0.3413769602775574,
-0.9265115261077881,
0.4930122196674347,
0.5305686593055725,
-0.3016548752784729,
0.5472730994224548,
-0.182346373796463,
-0.6617335677146912,
0.275285929441452,
0.34330442547798157,
-0.3401075601577759,
-0.6393293738365173,
-0.8447542190551758,
-0.12955555319786072,
-0.6252465844154358,
0.9460727572441101,
0.10248240828514099,
-0.07599405944347382,
-0.2567361295223236,
-0.05842914804816246,
-0.2107207328081131,
-0.25224438309669495,
-0.9737281799316406,
-0.19075055420398712,
0.3468768298625946,
0.19645093381404877,
1.0379829406738281,
0.4951850175857544,
0.6353037357330322,
0.42279723286628723,
-0.11240746080875397,
0.20646034181118011,
-0.3004820942878723,
-0.2112768292427063,
-0.34168100357055664,
0.03663574904203415,
-0.4361099898815155,
0.1980195790529251,
0.36924830079078674,
0.4735565781593323,
-0.0596880279481411,
0.560684084892273,
0.1961410790681839,
0.3945762813091278,
-0.516486406326294,
0.4020122289657593,
-0.6126983165740967,
-0.2975076138973236,
0.08387086540460587,
-0.42547956109046936,
-0.36868518590927124,
-0.7761176228523254,
0.3975568413734436,
-0.47828999161720276,
0.1202659085392952,
0.12110268324613571,
1.058996319770813,
0.02967936173081398,
-0.45933496952056885,
-0.37498652935028076,
-1.0133153200149536,
0.5508440732955933,
-0.4456581771373749,
0.2625233232975006,
0.5464007258415222,
0.8090768456459045,
0.043355707079172134,
-0.5126183032989502,
-0.4492175877094269,
-0.03675560653209686,
-0.1764651983976364,
0.09261205792427063,
-0.328079491853714,
-0.21210050582885742,
-0.01538886409252882,
0.25361961126327515,
-0.328560471534729,
-0.009087981656193733,
-0.3482036590576172,
-0.407964825630188,
0.8172946572303772,
-0.3998098373413086,
-0.11781413108110428,
-0.17256496846675873,
-0.5841373205184937,
-0.11476745456457138,
-0.35774996876716614,
0.26859280467033386,
0.5747042298316956,
0.17642873525619507,
-0.057337045669555664,
0.3072257339954376,
-0.13880431652069092,
0.44309696555137634,
0.2590855062007904,
-0.41368335485458374,
0.013551049865782261,
-0.171237513422966,
-0.11072401702404022,
0.3265969753265381,
0.7333763241767883,
0.6319534182548523,
0.37766003608703613,
-0.07926476746797562,
-0.21303649246692657,
0.13175606727600098,
0.24007724225521088,
-0.6065011620521545,
-0.1395767629146576,
0.24360355734825134,
-0.5247273445129395,
-0.6203598380088806,
0.4150455892086029,
-0.7280113697052002,
-0.3496617376804352,
-0.1915869116783142,
0.7140827178955078,
-0.3079979121685028,
-0.24595455825328827,
-0.06441863626241684,
-0.19146329164505005,
-0.15988880395889282,
0.2052970677614212,
-0.5677071213722229,
0.4235732853412628,
0.8089926838874817,
0.6924691796302795,
0.23327568173408508,
-0.023309405893087387,
-0.7974194884300232,
0.13215281069278717,
-0.29995664954185486,
1.064366102218628,
-0.27411431074142456,
-0.014728657901287079,
0.19398003816604614,
-0.17404189705848694,
0.2641336917877197,
-0.0795460194349289,
0.5306869149208069,
-0.9052293300628662,
0.061630453914403915,
-0.23117639124393463,
-0.7996855974197388,
-0.2995709180831909,
0.18682169914245605,
-0.5743144750595093,
0.8353549242019653,
0.13105788826942444,
-0.8187801241874695,
0.8251698017120361,
-0.7005270719528198,
-0.35953161120414734,
0.3694727420806885,
0.20968064665794373,
-0.35815584659576416,
-0.21227122843265533,
0.35976606607437134,
0.7315092086791992,
-0.10565688461065292,
0.5042679905891418,
-0.7039839029312134,
-0.1876804530620575,
0.827189564704895,
-0.5691859126091003,
0.4970622956752777,
0.19469523429870605,
-0.32168805599212646,
-0.07853464782238007,
-0.909289538860321,
0.05682402104139328,
-0.05497957393527031,
-0.017550049349665642,
-0.5320454835891724,
0.2121681272983551,
0.16111992299556732,
0.08802495151758194,
0.3672618269920349,
-0.563964307308197,
-0.2593752145767212,
-0.4481458365917206,
0.5032601952552795,
0.9234058856964111,
0.3370712101459503,
0.3730391263961792,
-0.4076116383075714,
0.25064557790756226,
-0.12280961871147156,
0.24584364891052246,
0.09516481310129166,
-0.5095254182815552,
-0.31657734513282776,
-0.10339140892028809,
0.5587306618690491,
0.4308699369430542,
-0.32761868834495544,
0.659612238407135,
-0.391854465007782,
-0.7832018733024597,
-0.48541781306266785,
0.37793463468551636,
0.07401187717914581,
0.7532345056533813,
0.2465045154094696,
-0.06735511869192123,
-0.4058239161968231,
-0.8480542302131653,
-0.6414290070533752,
-0.47502049803733826,
-0.21439921855926514,
0.1855042725801468,
0.2116193026304245,
-0.26842811703681946,
1.2060502767562866,
-0.4559575021266937,
-0.012653862126171589,
0.03991224616765976,
0.374011754989624,
0.2017955631017685,
0.24848084151744843,
0.6293526291847229,
-1.0596442222595215,
-0.4788185656070709,
0.18991920351982117,
-0.4888695478439331,
0.0925261527299881,
-0.37972646951675415,
0.029086757451295853,
0.037322599440813065,
0.19692306220531464,
-0.3789026439189911,
0.5322080254554749,
0.519092857837677,
-0.5541680455207825,
0.4504989981651306,
-0.153768390417099,
0.30370959639549255,
-0.9043430089950562,
0.027383415028452873,
0.5240552425384521,
-0.5499330759048462,
-0.41526490449905396,
-0.3906571567058563,
-0.09698943793773651,
0.28698062896728516,
0.018739154562354088,
0.8165972232818604,
0.06973835080862045,
-0.3476808965206146,
-0.1957368403673172,
0.25516900420188904,
-0.0949278324842453,
0.11504693329334259,
-0.20437602698802948,
0.11414124816656113,
0.6223666071891785,
-0.5900503396987915,
0.3036854565143585,
0.07853332906961441,
-0.47913357615470886,
0.5535607933998108,
-0.776382327079773,
-0.01456077117472887,
0.18793217837810516,
0.22255095839500427,
-1.3738431930541992,
-0.323382169008255,
0.31850743293762207,
-0.9383048415184021,
-0.15484070777893066,
-0.23254577815532684,
-0.6348467469215393,
-0.3847111165523529,
0.015656916424632072,
-0.12626342475414276,
0.4711216986179352,
-0.577897846698761,
0.6871998906135559,
0.2780154049396515,
-0.338741660118103,
-0.5745561122894287,
-0.43993425369262695,
0.15074139833450317,
-0.2991102337837219,
-0.8766686916351318,
0.43483689427375793,
-0.12049271911382675,
-0.7041285634040833,
0.2817637026309967,
-0.17283795773983002,
-0.24958644807338715,
0.36220934987068176,
0.3520227074623108,
0.6358307600021362,
0.01505244616419077,
0.010943264700472355,
0.20857740938663483,
-0.2645523250102997,
0.28756049275398254,
-0.28590303659439087,
0.09723580628633499,
-0.4444955289363861,
-0.13686200976371765,
-0.6320088505744934,
-0.13032139837741852,
0.4773881733417511,
0.019644716754555702,
0.9696125984191895,
0.8253566026687622,
-0.5527157783508301,
-0.03171388804912567,
-0.9198954105377197,
-0.14303942024707794,
-0.5898035764694214,
-0.21840885281562805,
0.05033393204212189,
-0.8592070937156677,
0.8528336882591248,
0.14586099982261658,
0.3413752615451813,
0.8580866456031799,
0.6696673035621643,
-0.1545156091451645,
1.0436357259750366,
0.5362746715545654,
0.08794445544481277,
0.1726173460483551,
0.06246453896164894,
0.44559818506240845,
0.2819044589996338,
-0.13366857171058655,
-0.36008238792419434,
-0.34636905789375305,
-0.6105949282646179,
-0.11817259341478348,
-0.0784347876906395,
0.08612038195133209,
-0.05376468971371651,
0.6229240298271179,
-0.3876732885837555,
0.4857589900493622,
0.4354259967803955,
-0.0023931243922561407,
0.44146814942359924,
0.06327904760837555,
0.12477733939886093,
0.0658361092209816,
-0.24736283719539642,
-0.7994597554206848,
0.9129598140716553,
0.6952587962150574,
0.562434196472168,
-0.04305099695920944,
0.5511047840118408,
0.8780101537704468,
0.8731541633605957,
-0.7134907245635986,
0.3076869547367096,
0.013876277022063732,
-0.5850299000740051,
-0.34307661652565,
-0.7780439853668213,
-0.42489761114120483,
-0.34578952193260193,
-0.4324720501899719,
-0.44990384578704834,
0.11012415587902069,
0.26102450489997864,
-0.6671745777130127,
0.12695004045963287,
-0.5781272649765015,
0.6863059997558594,
-0.40448832511901855,
-0.19531527161598206,
-0.31250879168510437,
-0.6189681887626648,
0.35311609506607056,
-0.2790226936340332,
0.7105685472488403,
-0.08665767312049866,
-0.0060477713122963905,
0.8862651586532593,
-0.4453091323375702,
0.7173671722412109,
-0.25605177879333496,
0.028082486242055893,
0.4633948504924774,
0.07966708391904831,
0.383293479681015,
0.444985955953598,
-0.15026620030403137,
0.2318921983242035,
0.19958852231502533,
-0.4195675849914551,
-0.771703839302063,
0.6918690800666809,
-0.6775180697441101,
0.023237129673361778,
-0.2626561224460602,
-0.05111503601074219,
-0.33561402559280396,
0.18148741126060486,
0.040365759283304214,
0.16074806451797485,
-0.4262593388557434,
0.2039613574743271,
0.15200626850128174,
0.21342264115810394,
0.30491572618484497,
0.5961329340934753,
-0.06330741196870804,
-0.7324959635734558,
0.9158967733383179,
0.17633190751075745,
0.006673349533230066,
0.13778303563594818,
0.6053339242935181,
-0.5860110521316528,
-0.5362030267715454,
-0.19782976806163788,
0.031950488686561584,
-0.7049789428710938,
-0.10409733653068542,
-0.3699018061161041,
-0.25622743368148804,
-0.6327566504478455,
-0.4823869466781616,
-0.3631182909011841,
-0.5004604458808899,
-0.08025684952735901,
-0.5539610385894775,
0.5228279829025269,
0.7548401951789856,
-0.21059976518154144,
0.4093863070011139,
-0.9277533888816833,
0.23719967901706696,
0.4296046793460846,
0.6207881569862366,
0.049951449036598206,
-0.48667895793914795,
-0.43358442187309265,
0.16470256447792053,
-0.07578010857105255,
-0.7667042016983032,
0.41797444224357605,
0.053681597113609314,
0.4457584619522095,
1.0930219888687134,
0.1299315094947815,
0.5919134020805359,
0.03643966093659401,
0.41816839575767517,
0.2694275677204132,
-0.9152045249938965,
0.48457080125808716,
-0.2503507733345032,
-0.47443631291389465,
0.7191545367240906,
0.680422842502594,
-0.4646550714969635,
-0.5266616344451904,
-0.9958208203315735,
-0.6485493183135986,
0.16740350425243378,
0.2939383089542389,
-0.06852897256612778,
-0.14265736937522888,
0.5513849854469299,
0.22794966399669647,
0.244833841919899,
-0.6404699683189392,
-0.15226608514785767,
-0.482369989156723,
-0.0509803369641304,
-0.10346265882253647,
-0.31736674904823303,
-0.04161519184708595,
-0.10938456654548645,
0.6730431318283081,
-0.11881006509065628,
-0.14965477585792542,
0.12008585780858994,
0.08505789190530777,
-0.3209908604621887,
-0.007504287175834179,
0.273269921541214,
1.1118340492248535,
-0.46265238523483276,
0.08556541055440903,
-0.09489859640598297,
-0.032721444964408875,
-0.09673722833395004,
0.2742663025856018,
-0.12609082460403442,
0.2484930008649826,
0.3391420841217041,
0.3434588611125946,
0.5630278587341309,
-0.5526593327522278,
0.5396198034286499,
-0.24637864530086517,
-0.3780418038368225,
-0.8530552983283997,
-0.29563748836517334,
0.2541825473308563,
0.15978148579597473,
0.6903056502342224,
0.697995126247406,
0.03538517281413078,
-0.4110028147697449,
0.4875774383544922,
0.1584635078907013,
-0.6922150254249573,
-0.49827834963798523,
0.6743829846382141,
0.2870769798755646,
-0.43118301033973694,
0.4049137532711029,
-0.1272725760936737,
-0.47159165143966675,
0.4830069839954376,
0.0969155877828598,
1.0056143999099731,
-0.22987043857574463,
0.5366718769073486,
0.49825751781463623,
0.16930542886257172,
-0.36559998989105225,
0.024174749851226807,
-0.0000809875491540879,
-0.9335852265357971,
-0.4960379898548126,
-0.9253446459770203,
-0.5246952772140503,
-0.06915490329265594,
-0.7160064578056335,
0.38809412717819214,
-0.9037488102912903,
-0.5330645442008972,
0.5475735068321228,
0.07423084229230881,
-0.5997380614280701,
0.17478303611278534,
0.09755814075469971,
0.9128259420394897,
-0.971897542476654,
0.32420313358306885,
0.45732516050338745,
-0.22672943770885468,
-0.6096388697624207,
-0.0897030308842659,
0.10329681634902954,
-0.688902735710144,
0.5283419489860535,
0.2647169232368469,
-0.1759740710258484,
-0.16367200016975403,
-0.6294190287590027,
-0.5022985935211182,
0.8445832133293152,
0.18560367822647095,
-0.24044586718082428,
0.023902418091893196,
-0.07756774127483368,
0.6797258853912354,
-0.44304633140563965,
0.0262705497443676,
0.28203117847442627,
0.6979808211326599,
0.43005508184432983,
-0.6486731171607971,
-0.14799441397190094,
-0.3214055895805359,
-0.35981065034866333,
-0.09841632097959518,
-0.33730190992355347,
0.33035117387771606,
-0.10404890030622482,
-0.2426992505788803,
-0.1549835503101349,
0.9567991495132446,
0.10289280116558075,
0.8687858581542969,
0.8244783282279968,
0.24537259340286255,
0.7991428971290588,
-0.013613673858344555,
0.9809722304344177,
-0.6643481254577637,
0.5739099383354187,
0.8104196190834045,
0.04791714996099472,
1.1193270683288574,
0.054441407322883606,
-0.09921720623970032,
0.8219789266586304,
0.9032069444656372,
-0.3717685341835022,
0.1069083884358406,
-0.1716259866952896,
-0.11544188112020493,
-0.6103161573410034,
-0.021688304841518402,
-0.005279697012156248,
0.47412094473838806,
0.4342447519302368,
-0.5744920372962952,
0.03809905797243118,
-0.3040720820426941,
0.0643337145447731,
0.30040279030799866,
-0.276090145111084,
0.569481611251831,
0.12803348898887634,
-0.5678120255470276,
0.005633339285850525,
0.18961545825004578,
0.5420982837677002,
-0.6445605158805847,
0.1741088479757309,
0.1566828340291977,
0.29517701268196106,
-0.24745744466781616,
-0.8999929428100586,
0.5212034583091736,
-0.02002880908548832,
-0.015626149252057076,
-0.5916041731834412,
0.9543309211730957,
-0.21270470321178436,
-0.7931495308876038,
0.34860774874687195,
0.4962233603000641,
-0.027690064162015915,
-0.3717338740825653,
-0.6707110404968262,
-0.4703173339366913,
-0.319423645734787,
-0.17299658060073853,
0.13726839423179626,
0.17921528220176697,
0.15267260372638702,
0.9176851511001587,
1.080199122428894,
-0.12367595732212067,
-0.4120185077190399,
-0.09271439909934998,
0.5403474569320679,
-0.4998205602169037,
-0.8266466856002808,
-1.072737693786621,
0.22025597095489502,
-0.40120986104011536,
-0.04362732544541359,
1.095943570137024,
0.44519883394241333,
0.4331143796443939,
0.2211010605096817,
0.6806257963180542,
0.18004992604255676,
0.8118712306022644,
-0.05362991616129875,
1.0621628761291504,
-0.3883533775806427,
0.34705850481987,
-0.5206639170646667,
-0.7379179000854492,
-0.18586163222789764,
0.45363709330558777,
-0.5750080347061157,
-0.05291595682501793,
0.22572557628154755,
0.4750986099243164,
0.030958833172917366,
0.18939515948295593,
-0.006708955857902765,
0.3319060504436493,
0.13732008635997772,
-0.1832398772239685,
0.5860379338264465,
-0.20182465016841888,
0.8646096587181091,
-0.608591616153717,
-0.37507838010787964,
-0.39706921577453613,
-1.0098140239715576,
-0.9925074577331543,
-0.419289767742157,
-0.5754653811454773,
-0.6728405356407166,
-0.24809342622756958,
0.7653067111968994,
0.523857593536377,
-0.832490861415863,
-0.04404456168413162,
0.2765481770038605,
0.3662026822566986,
-0.5138431787490845,
-0.350604385137558,
0.38715213537216187,
0.17383812367916107,
-0.24727840721607208,
0.18311826884746552,
0.42057934403419495,
0.1484818309545517,
-0.5181404948234558,
0.030368058010935783,
0.1938406229019165,
0.3107825219631195,
0.5947274565696716,
0.188146710395813,
-0.6360922455787659,
-0.4681309759616852,
0.14062026143074036,
0.05157692730426788,
-0.2664010226726532,
0.4298514127731323,
-0.669189453125,
0.2979292869567871,
0.5143195390701294,
0.5439258813858032,
0.2153579443693161,
0.5709835886955261,
0.552286684513092,
-0.36929529905319214,
-0.4836968183517456,
0.1086752787232399,
0.12341274321079254,
0.27223119139671326,
-0.5905812382698059,
0.17755168676376343,
0.33196282386779785,
-0.5612438917160034,
-0.6492148041725159,
-0.23557813465595245,
-1.1140280961990356,
-0.056352969259023666,
0.8347870111465454,
-0.2042042464017868,
-0.26464003324508667,
-0.2898770570755005,
0.2087084949016571,
-0.04014643654227257,
-0.6663956642150879,
1.2286996841430664,
0.9052786231040955,
0.32636892795562744,
0.14566606283187866,
-0.5576094388961792,
0.4986061751842499,
-0.13080880045890808,
-0.3835006654262543,
0.03242269530892372,
0.21486514806747437,
0.44963452219963074,
0.4409637749195099,
0.5563191175460815,
0.05093726888298988,
0.502690315246582,
-0.12751972675323486,
-0.3851434588432312,
-0.07163746654987335,
-0.11305850744247437,
0.1667356789112091,
0.3423185646533966,
-0.06140858307480812,
0.23605482280254364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11290v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11290v1 | Iterative Utility Judgment Framework via LLMs Inspired by Relevance in Philosophy | 2024-06-17T07:52:42 | 2024-06-17T07:52:42 | Hengran Zhang, Keping Bi, Jiafeng Guo, Xueqi Cheng | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Utility and topical relevance are critical measures in information retrieval
(IR), reflecting system and user perspectives, respectively. While topical
relevance has long been emphasized, utility is a higher standard of relevance
and is more useful for facilitating downstream tasks, e.g., in
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG). When we incorporate utility judgments
into RAG, we realize that the topical relevance, utility, and answering in RAG
are closely related to the three types of relevance that Schutz discussed from
a philosophical perspective. They are topical relevance, interpretational
relevance, and motivational relevance, respectively. Inspired by the dynamic
iterations of the three types of relevance, we propose an Iterative utiliTy
judgmEnt fraMework (ITEM) to promote each step of the cycle of RAG. We
conducted extensive experiments on multi-grade passage retrieval and factoid
question-answering datasets (i.e., TREC DL, WebAP, and NQ). Experimental
results demonstrate significant improvements in utility judgments, ranking of
topical relevance, and answer generation upon representative baselines,
including multiple single-shot utility judging approaches. Our code and
benchmark can be found at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/ITEM-B486/. | [
-0.2460184097290039,
-0.39606672525405884,
0.9074727892875671,
-0.06549794226884842,
-0.3742806613445282,
0.05007268488407135,
0.019496796652674675,
-0.0858461856842041,
0.30572181940078735,
0.8049934506416321,
-0.25800007581710815,
-0.5059929490089417,
-0.27803748846054077,
-0.1508444994688034,
-0.31067800521850586,
1.0548003911972046,
0.16635949909687042,
-0.15143775939941406,
-0.40763047337532043,
-0.3145029544830322,
-0.3786754310131073,
-0.21523521840572357,
-0.45150232315063477,
-0.45728978514671326,
0.7222928404808044,
0.6583799123764038,
0.5928514003753662,
0.42696747183799744,
0.8313935399055481,
0.27579209208488464,
0.08531270176172256,
0.0385986752808094,
-0.42574286460876465,
0.42372238636016846,
-0.4317103922367096,
-0.27944815158843994,
-0.29615089297294617,
0.20007923245429993,
0.3802289366722107,
0.5861229300498962,
-0.4932105243206024,
0.543931782245636,
0.18103966116905212,
0.7170742750167847,
-0.8786299228668213,
-0.27662256360054016,
-0.8997423648834229,
-0.10339231044054031,
-0.27586430311203003,
-0.9011588096618652,
-0.4775380790233612,
-0.48420336842536926,
0.31337881088256836,
-0.504061758518219,
0.33311477303504944,
0.31183671951293945,
0.7605476975440979,
0.28744035959243774,
-0.6486981511116028,
-0.33889737725257874,
-0.5206602215766907,
0.8402485847473145,
-0.3997189998626709,
0.21769043803215027,
0.4389907717704773,
0.4898309111595154,
0.18762648105621338,
-0.8186458349227905,
-0.14593587815761566,
-0.5936121344566345,
0.028438348323106766,
0.18460430204868317,
0.257045716047287,
0.019018150866031647,
0.2807477116584778,
0.7003421187400818,
-0.1046806126832962,
-0.31436553597450256,
-0.25771564245224,
0.14361560344696045,
0.43909671902656555,
0.365161657333374,
-0.17442739009857178,
-0.41165146231651306,
-0.5851134657859802,
0.15551474690437317,
-0.8725888729095459,
0.2784852385520935,
0.28307223320007324,
0.14312104880809784,
0.3525015711784363,
0.7775248289108276,
-0.03159719333052635,
0.7032977342605591,
-0.1278568059206009,
-0.42193421721458435,
0.2689020335674286,
-0.2582438886165619,
0.07239802181720734,
-0.2820700705051422,
0.2068522572517395,
0.6582145690917969,
-0.14111272990703583,
-0.2499244064092636,
-0.03249025717377663,
-0.3416052460670471,
0.9769723415374756,
-0.5952756404876709,
0.27258339524269104,
0.2560311555862427,
-0.5453223586082458,
-0.394702285528183,
0.023698702454566956,
-0.592037558555603,
-0.537713885307312,
-0.4553337097167969,
0.3055862784385681,
-0.46815094351768494,
-0.005668052472174168,
0.13234567642211914,
-0.04230041056871414,
0.2378636598587036,
0.39717403054237366,
-0.45377182960510254,
0.27280741930007935,
0.6979313492774963,
0.6851313710212708,
-0.23073464632034302,
-0.07314497232437134,
-0.7224709391593933,
0.09965241700410843,
-0.24580679833889008,
1.019140362739563,
-0.6854792833328247,
-0.40512678027153015,
-0.08619162440299988,
-0.3734667897224426,
0.16263353824615479,
-0.4871821999549866,
0.7783526182174683,
-0.9412306547164917,
0.11778141558170319,
-0.48910579085350037,
-0.4624181091785431,
-0.25562939047813416,
0.29228436946868896,
-0.6637689471244812,
1.3194310665130615,
0.20048147439956665,
-0.939693808555603,
0.5344371199607849,
-0.793982744216919,
-0.32655584812164307,
0.12145333737134933,
0.024450626224279404,
-0.2697177827358246,
0.3247189223766327,
-0.5618304014205933,
0.4263664186000824,
-0.8368943333625793,
0.4344259798526764,
-0.6072444915771484,
-0.28572878241539,
0.38538140058517456,
-0.34021520614624023,
0.32394692301750183,
0.45877593755722046,
-0.20402580499649048,
-0.04899940267205238,
-0.8728469014167786,
0.17919543385505676,
-0.13760288059711456,
-0.3859500288963318,
-0.6468734741210938,
0.25966084003448486,
-0.12886065244674683,
0.11276231706142426,
0.10820075124502182,
-0.43977120518684387,
0.04298883676528931,
-0.21357911825180054,
-0.002243803581222892,
0.9352288842201233,
0.11772970110177994,
0.6158889532089233,
-0.5354343056678772,
0.24736298620700836,
-0.25211870670318604,
-0.016558242961764336,
-0.055163733661174774,
-0.37783578038215637,
-0.5956888794898987,
-0.11995285004377365,
0.3066508173942566,
0.5185278058052063,
-0.9415979385375977,
0.09323827177286148,
-0.2757042944431305,
-0.26217150688171387,
-0.2349771112203598,
-0.07415925711393356,
0.1906936913728714,
0.5632834434509277,
0.4128989577293396,
-0.2759582996368408,
-0.08127851784229279,
-0.6057421565055847,
-0.6224409341812134,
-0.1945771723985672,
-0.2615470886230469,
0.7139757871627808,
0.11226402223110199,
0.1051834225654602,
0.9204081892967224,
-0.5015771985054016,
-0.15137402713298798,
-0.1368694305419922,
0.11214952170848846,
0.4317876696586609,
0.024930790066719055,
0.45001649856567383,
-0.9739036560058594,
-0.24085746705532074,
-0.22396457195281982,
-0.4984116852283478,
-0.3211626708507538,
0.09455446898937225,
-0.2824152410030365,
-0.18311916291713715,
0.11809258908033371,
-0.040875427424907684,
0.48912355303764343,
-0.1514149010181427,
-0.42890864610671997,
0.0655355155467987,
-0.18478618562221527,
0.4042830467224121,
-1.1887412071228027,
0.3299838602542877,
0.03469892591238022,
-0.1191512867808342,
-0.4443928301334381,
0.3728404641151428,
0.02145242691040039,
0.0952276811003685,
-0.3388347327709198,
0.6366409659385681,
-0.08817125856876373,
-0.46510064601898193,
-0.28142431378364563,
0.25902003049850464,
0.06841535866260529,
0.1064969152212143,
-0.3289234936237335,
0.9424359202384949,
0.21737633645534515,
-0.9874807000160217,
0.10062599182128906,
-0.30648526549339294,
-0.10900693386793137,
0.6523817777633667,
-0.29814693331718445,
0.08187830448150635,
-0.13422717154026031,
-0.27009257674217224,
-0.9654726386070251,
0.0065209222957491875,
0.18861046433448792,
-0.07994109392166138,
0.276835560798645,
0.12043705582618713,
-0.4901943504810333,
-0.27178338170051575,
-0.7115778923034668,
0.3583455979824066,
0.22936862707138062,
-0.41813817620277405,
0.9954599738121033,
0.3749275505542755,
-0.0029314968269318342,
-0.8991578221321106,
-0.1895214021205902,
-0.11296673119068146,
-0.4246097207069397,
-0.3688785135746002,
0.4716116786003113,
-0.24712295830249786,
-0.5597413778305054,
0.0024739259388297796,
-0.4820006191730499,
0.20513610541820526,
0.4354735016822815,
0.003014960791915655,
0.4160665273666382,
0.2253173142671585,
0.23821519315242767,
-0.04254177212715149,
-0.39731305837631226,
-0.18084335327148438,
-0.3018779754638672,
0.4066556394100189,
-0.2237672209739685,
-0.5516438484191895,
0.25870221853256226,
0.30876708030700684,
0.3779623508453369,
0.007803523447364569,
0.07001721113920212,
0.11606330424547195,
-0.0599600151181221,
0.15057852864265442,
-0.7718998789787292,
-0.015574518591165543,
-0.4920037090778351,
-0.20060782134532928,
-0.6433061361312866,
-0.9478575587272644,
0.3142223060131073,
-0.28848227858543396,
0.4345497786998749,
0.3797503411769867,
0.4847014546394348,
-0.2860832214355469,
0.46491488814353943,
0.5130535960197449,
0.29035961627960205,
0.5320229530334473,
-0.2785448729991913,
0.31009939312934875,
-0.981783926486969,
-0.11434245854616165,
-0.6695785522460938,
-0.22541390359401703,
-0.838092029094696,
-0.6493173837661743,
0.7566990852355957,
0.013246288523077965,
-0.20486484467983246,
0.1288193315267563,
-0.4444980323314667,
0.2667079567909241,
0.5514165759086609,
0.3612983524799347,
0.5053638815879822,
0.291871577501297,
-0.5013314485549927,
0.009028968401253223,
-0.4808419942855835,
-0.7653720378875732,
1.5441726446151733,
0.24485114216804504,
0.7015318274497986,
0.21911142766475677,
0.8761386275291443,
0.5140828490257263,
0.8945358991622925,
-1.0113494396209717,
0.7493852376937866,
-0.3563295304775238,
-0.49697932600975037,
-0.14109599590301514,
-0.3658280372619629,
-1.0560522079467773,
0.4726308584213257,
0.12537337839603424,
-0.8547872304916382,
0.16427122056484222,
-0.018612831830978394,
-0.3802320659160614,
0.20167936384677887,
-0.198871910572052,
0.1915578991174698,
-0.20726168155670166,
-0.916766345500946,
-0.6451713442802429,
-0.5562403202056885,
0.1988411694765091,
0.1266983151435852,
0.30140772461891174,
-0.3837403357028961,
-0.4100479185581207,
0.44921252131462097,
-0.20038028061389923,
0.25647830963134766,
-0.036761317402124405,
-0.2770701050758362,
0.2974128723144531,
0.08989191800355911,
0.1329232156276703,
0.31779745221138,
-0.6194210648536682,
-0.0709095448255539,
-0.013592313975095749,
-0.3150388300418854,
-0.5523343682289124,
0.578583836555481,
-0.25652968883514404,
-0.8795980215072632,
-0.7127608060836792,
-0.40180978178977966,
-0.31051695346832275,
0.19259406626224518,
0.16213808953762054,
0.46813473105430603,
-0.03105274960398674,
0.19604812562465668,
0.823031485080719,
-0.13033796846866608,
0.3519361913204193,
0.6873154640197754,
-0.2518027722835541,
-0.40682506561279297,
0.7127296328544617,
0.029401149600744247,
0.17834578454494476,
0.5937467813491821,
0.22526495158672333,
-0.33219990134239197,
-0.22956198453903198,
-0.3404536545276642,
0.0650235041975975,
-1.0082480907440186,
-0.5451369285583496,
-0.6769256591796875,
0.1147439181804657,
0.04502143710851669,
-0.06397020071744919,
-0.1671779602766037,
-0.3602587580680847,
-0.19972185790538788,
-0.05556987226009369,
0.4802585244178772,
0.6357150673866272,
-0.17661121487617493,
-0.12725508213043213,
-0.633399486541748,
0.6845031976699829,
0.40072864294052124,
0.6680657863616943,
-0.26683562994003296,
-0.45897376537323,
-0.047054823487997055,
-0.2924370765686035,
-0.7169818878173828,
-0.7074233293533325,
0.049616552889347076,
-0.00019912008428946137,
0.6825026869773865,
0.3465445935726166,
0.27309972047805786,
0.46363547444343567,
-0.5550258159637451,
0.7861685752868652,
0.1158645749092102,
-0.695397138595581,
0.5347429513931274,
-0.08873181790113449,
-0.2118200808763504,
0.8794146180152893,
0.2879508435726166,
-0.23200906813144684,
-0.2797282338142395,
-0.6371990442276001,
-1.181207537651062,
0.5980136394500732,
0.22535009682178497,
0.23108549416065216,
0.08049874752759933,
0.6980686783790588,
0.2275020331144333,
0.549743115901947,
-0.527344822883606,
-0.641176164150238,
-0.06462173908948898,
0.08177497982978821,
0.24455684423446655,
-0.4408327639102936,
-0.3508458435535431,
-0.09879543632268906,
0.6537292003631592,
-0.3206263780593872,
0.4774647653102875,
0.09981883317232132,
0.20538517832756042,
0.08886872977018356,
0.5983483791351318,
0.2465144395828247,
0.7292593121528625,
-0.42315906286239624,
0.08782350271940231,
0.23872748017311096,
-0.49681583046913147,
0.35648348927497864,
0.17075806856155396,
-0.2541159689426422,
0.014698785729706287,
-0.1376371532678604,
0.4957977533340454,
0.4693862497806549,
-0.3274998962879181,
0.2643550932407379,
-0.11283490806818008,
0.010885965079069138,
-0.32236620783805847,
0.16419477760791779,
-0.3574678897857666,
0.25216323137283325,
0.7568969130516052,
0.23426568508148193,
0.9078481793403625,
-0.6253155469894409,
0.27851518988609314,
0.3948095142841339,
0.11490757763385773,
0.23122814297676086,
0.41016197204589844,
0.04715360328555107,
-0.23926767706871033,
0.08951278030872345,
-0.21875543892383575,
-0.3015992045402527,
0.3551652133464813,
0.0542655847966671,
0.9950489401817322,
-0.09928151965141296,
0.2091180384159088,
0.3587493896484375,
0.010501591488718987,
-0.0578107088804245,
0.6869726777076721,
-0.5688404440879822,
-0.5647458434104919,
-0.2462559938430786,
-0.7426207065582275,
-0.5965191721916199,
-0.17148679494857788,
-0.8536578416824341,
0.2796757221221924,
-0.1712574064731598,
-0.44969189167022705,
-0.19177082180976868,
0.15246200561523438,
-0.6697855591773987,
0.12216662615537643,
-0.27925029397010803,
0.9174261093139648,
-0.1687629669904709,
0.6919245719909668,
0.80882328748703,
-0.23361699283123016,
-0.7301439642906189,
0.6476696133613586,
-0.21692559123039246,
-0.6632725596427917,
0.7169822454452515,
0.13267993927001953,
-0.597727358341217,
-0.011437298730015755,
-0.3817009925842285,
-1.2682137489318848,
1.346008539199829,
0.2926746606826782,
-0.10387491434812546,
0.15046381950378418,
-0.13347399234771729,
0.4522404968738556,
-0.297577828168869,
0.5553708672523499,
0.5334763526916504,
0.4160134196281433,
0.4933558702468872,
-0.8147878646850586,
-0.0010335041442885995,
-0.4569101631641388,
0.3859078288078308,
0.1033959686756134,
-0.5669310092926025,
0.576088011264801,
-0.34212079644203186,
-0.23532487452030182,
0.2545997202396393,
0.36271727085113525,
0.7194386720657349,
0.8135188221931458,
0.4760441482067108,
0.6127830147743225,
0.6903457641601562,
-0.20905183255672455,
1.1626861095428467,
-0.5948525071144104,
0.46701937913894653,
0.917237401008606,
-0.493602454662323,
0.6584181785583496,
0.5961889028549194,
-0.22649143636226654,
0.728035569190979,
0.6695928573608398,
0.40486961603164673,
0.9081211090087891,
0.24181821942329407,
-0.4144938290119171,
-0.23888245224952698,
-0.1463143676519394,
-0.4673844873905182,
0.3100748658180237,
0.49213725328445435,
-0.3014478385448456,
-0.4395403265953064,
0.11044721305370331,
-0.19771775603294373,
-0.052401844412088394,
-0.25595784187316895,
0.9480090737342834,
0.17526566982269287,
-0.9205490350723267,
0.43489763140678406,
0.09344865381717682,
0.3786964416503906,
-0.45639681816101074,
-0.1630392074584961,
-0.12522345781326294,
0.05243409797549248,
-0.026223566383123398,
-1.0538884401321411,
0.17037715017795563,
-0.07422520965337753,
-0.08956492692232132,
-0.5537980198860168,
0.9613212943077087,
0.23988500237464905,
-0.25493156909942627,
0.25164857506752014,
0.3742496967315674,
0.06346139311790466,
0.24566151201725006,
-0.7400296926498413,
-0.31603768467903137,
-0.23782843351364136,
-0.5431045889854431,
0.2992945611476898,
0.5623576641082764,
0.05582544207572937,
0.9365738034248352,
0.5362520217895508,
-0.12218127399682999,
-0.23043105006217957,
0.17812605202198029,
1.040346384048462,
-0.6887873411178589,
-0.5174837708473206,
-0.46617624163627625,
0.5507479310035706,
-0.340613454580307,
-0.13860957324504852,
0.6369764804840088,
0.49171632528305054,
0.4918389916419983,
0.2300095409154892,
0.7122461795806885,
-0.2650342583656311,
0.796040952205658,
-0.7119173407554626,
0.04095390811562538,
-0.8861031532287598,
0.9814718961715698,
-0.2952975034713745,
-0.7569044232368469,
-0.08319337666034698,
0.6865609288215637,
-0.5642501711845398,
0.20415182411670685,
0.8601385951042175,
0.45799773931503296,
-0.024225950241088867,
0.12162966281175613,
0.3015507757663727,
-0.25033295154571533,
0.004834702704101801,
0.13005679845809937,
0.8552164435386658,
-0.4122615158557892,
0.19870874285697937,
-0.28004541993141174,
-0.24995262920856476,
-0.262057363986969,
-1.0365605354309082,
-0.4933571517467499,
-0.5764845609664917,
-0.01017807424068451,
-0.6775072813034058,
-0.0966041088104248,
1.054564118385315,
0.2680104672908783,
-0.5319697856903076,
-0.39817747473716736,
-0.022208373993635178,
0.3533746302127838,
-0.10854495316743851,
-0.3268061578273773,
0.154245525598526,
-0.7218864560127258,
-0.3301245868206024,
0.1067676916718483,
0.7062373757362366,
-0.43382561206817627,
-0.1755555272102356,
0.15268389880657196,
-0.0875728577375412,
0.14591549336910248,
0.7966856956481934,
-0.13357733190059662,
-0.7627291083335876,
-0.2372797429561615,
0.27121058106422424,
-0.08287852257490158,
0.1379012167453766,
1.4892514944076538,
-0.8089851140975952,
0.35350555181503296,
0.3766997158527374,
0.6165041923522949,
0.5512359738349915,
-0.005015203729271889,
0.30964943766593933,
-0.5347824096679688,
-0.30112913250923157,
0.4104096293449402,
0.41787388920783997,
0.2127213180065155,
-0.6228285431861877,
0.9695678949356079,
0.21625454723834991,
-0.5702664256095886,
-0.733817458152771,
0.3911745548248291,
-0.8778390288352966,
-0.2715194821357727,
1.2964661121368408,
-0.10927975177764893,
0.05047619715332985,
-0.3692072629928589,
-0.27250853180885315,
0.013565798290073872,
-0.5541221499443054,
0.9892916679382324,
0.4112013280391693,
-0.33475711941719055,
-0.2390519231557846,
-0.6058846712112427,
0.3948045074939728,
0.35775819420814514,
-0.8107814192771912,
-0.09318974614143372,
0.4235183298587799,
0.35812756419181824,
0.4383527636528015,
0.9298028349876404,
-0.0743490681052208,
0.3770056664943695,
-0.6050011515617371,
-0.2786358594894409,
0.4917924404144287,
-0.2236211746931076,
-0.04796561598777771,
0.5150235295295715,
0.23210576176643372,
0.082767553627491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11289v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11289v1 | A Systematic Survey of Text Summarization: From Statistical Methods to Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T07:52:32 | 2024-06-17T07:52:32 | Haopeng Zhang, Philip S. Yu, Jiawei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text summarization research has undergone several significant transformations
with the advent of deep neural networks, pre-trained language models (PLMs),
and recent large language models (LLMs). This survey thus provides a
comprehensive review of the research progress and evolution in text
summarization through the lens of these paradigm shifts. It is organized into
two main parts: (1) a detailed overview of datasets, evaluation metrics, and
summarization methods before the LLM era, encompassing traditional statistical
methods, deep learning approaches, and PLM fine-tuning techniques, and (2) the
first detailed examination of recent advancements in benchmarking, modeling,
and evaluating summarization in the LLM era. By synthesizing existing
literature and presenting a cohesive overview, this survey also discusses
research trends, open challenges, and proposes promising research directions in
summarization, aiming to guide researchers through the evolving landscape of
summarization research. | [
-0.3124840557575226,
-0.7008864283561707,
0.48075413703918457,
0.0730798989534378,
-0.2339821755886078,
0.2580462694168091,
-0.319924533367157,
-0.1683635264635086,
0.4455008804798126,
0.5852800607681274,
-0.39233294129371643,
-0.5338868498802185,
-0.6548563241958618,
0.28563645482063293,
-0.614588737487793,
1.3168553113937378,
0.0006117423181422055,
0.2472907304763794,
-0.1681467890739441,
-0.015491992235183716,
-0.2608865797519684,
-0.6103204488754272,
-0.35368120670318604,
-0.34989288449287415,
0.5913476943969727,
0.14396728575229645,
0.25815874338150024,
0.2889767289161682,
0.82282954454422,
0.3103269338607788,
-0.4337320327758789,
0.289771169424057,
-0.5461183190345764,
0.2612383961677551,
0.17789475619792938,
-0.5587647557258606,
-0.8561913371086121,
-0.10978903621435165,
0.9839321374893188,
0.9699019193649292,
0.029858188703656197,
0.19582873582839966,
0.24136608839035034,
0.908935546875,
-0.5117602348327637,
0.055601052939891815,
-0.3455156683921814,
0.026496876031160355,
-0.2448369264602661,
-0.36956721544265747,
-0.31875860691070557,
-0.5542150139808655,
0.2731698453426361,
-0.24384815990924835,
0.2403932362794876,
-0.04054205119609833,
0.25627392530441284,
0.07411936670541763,
-0.6759108304977417,
-0.41231656074523926,
-0.8201569318771362,
0.9570238590240479,
-0.8872778415679932,
0.12338238954544067,
-0.18457499146461487,
0.27306056022644043,
0.02108914777636528,
-0.9816202521324158,
-0.013303263112902641,
-0.04854509234428406,
0.05886785686016083,
0.33301404118537903,
0.06964180618524551,
-0.1201404482126236,
-0.1147947832942009,
0.775184690952301,
-0.607577919960022,
0.10869380831718445,
-0.4289515018463135,
0.028475714847445488,
0.7992305159568787,
0.4936593174934387,
0.3872406482696533,
0.17624272406101227,
-0.11216825991868973,
-0.06344971805810928,
-0.6983941793441772,
-0.21540100872516632,
-0.010720820166170597,
0.09464455395936966,
-0.1720547080039978,
0.7048771381378174,
-0.34547850489616394,
0.5931623578071594,
-0.4190777838230133,
-0.3441532850265503,
0.06694699823856354,
-0.948002815246582,
-0.44933897256851196,
0.03869665041565895,
0.9114000797271729,
0.6953173279762268,
0.19805246591567993,
-0.03482529893517494,
-0.12161287665367126,
-0.4119093418121338,
-0.12420350313186646,
-0.7065460681915283,
-0.08387502282857895,
0.12320581078529358,
-0.832836925983429,
-0.44702690839767456,
0.11354998499155045,
-0.758013904094696,
-0.5302683115005493,
-0.36773526668548584,
-0.2966209053993225,
-0.07684870064258575,
-0.3286713659763336,
0.2704131007194519,
-0.4413347542285919,
0.28605496883392334,
0.4475383758544922,
-0.7070662379264832,
0.41934138536453247,
0.9056004285812378,
0.9918826818466187,
-0.29527759552001953,
-0.27066004276275635,
0.21560163795948029,
0.03361289203166962,
-0.5457788109779358,
0.8703503608703613,
-0.006204591132700443,
-0.44221800565719604,
0.27317363023757935,
-0.06847763061523438,
0.04662197455763817,
-0.4140297770500183,
0.25984272360801697,
-0.5337826609611511,
0.38017717003822327,
-0.2654798626899719,
-0.5326942801475525,
-0.32556307315826416,
0.43478459119796753,
-0.4499254524707794,
0.8122456669807434,
-0.2726213335990906,
-0.8933207392692566,
0.32352444529533386,
-0.4116831123828888,
-0.5488765835762024,
-0.25266048312187195,
0.1331469565629959,
-0.49091795086860657,
0.38561317324638367,
0.24853798747062683,
0.6203615665435791,
-0.39964717626571655,
0.3322605788707733,
-0.13147898018360138,
-0.3211822211742401,
0.41014760732650757,
-0.10006219148635864,
0.7175287008285522,
0.2188330441713333,
0.16036099195480347,
0.41145560145378113,
-0.6026253700256348,
-0.32356974482536316,
0.030037060379981995,
-0.03698388859629631,
-0.3900478184223175,
0.2159903645515442,
0.17922022938728333,
-0.13014806807041168,
0.5795415043830872,
-0.1310350000858307,
0.243489071726799,
-0.48806557059288025,
0.5045492053031921,
0.2179833948612213,
0.3392966389656067,
0.7844194173812866,
-0.4579187333583832,
0.4389423131942749,
-0.36097395420074463,
-0.08406355232000351,
-0.7704704999923706,
-0.2669810652732849,
-0.4612868130207062,
-0.11130893230438232,
0.3617038428783417,
0.5039583444595337,
-0.29107651114463806,
0.5570542216300964,
-0.520788311958313,
-0.6612717509269714,
-0.033901747316122055,
-0.13284198939800262,
0.15453670918941498,
0.1934611052274704,
0.1561547815799713,
-0.19650687277317047,
-0.5239058136940002,
-0.7460889220237732,
-0.38974544405937195,
-0.13942301273345947,
-0.2041420191526413,
-0.1542067974805832,
0.5132679343223572,
0.029473505914211273,
0.7509084939956665,
-0.702565610408783,
-0.32634079456329346,
-0.831278383731842,
0.4002116024494171,
0.25954994559288025,
0.17718744277954102,
0.5159291625022888,
-0.4654495418071747,
-0.2841557562351227,
-0.02675723098218441,
-0.736474335193634,
-0.05677488446235657,
-0.09122580289840698,
0.27621379494667053,
-0.07107061892747879,
0.7671213746070862,
-0.21297666430473328,
0.13200779259204865,
0.33331185579299927,
0.026541687548160553,
0.47137606143951416,
-0.13275998830795288,
0.33985647559165955,
-1.0986419916152954,
0.1102694496512413,
-0.05561671033501625,
-0.2293350249528885,
-0.5601035356521606,
0.060015805065631866,
-0.01939278282225132,
0.054784875363111496,
0.039910607039928436,
0.4107561409473419,
-0.7462502717971802,
-0.12775269150733948,
-0.5891858339309692,
0.11882386356592178,
-0.24272361397743225,
-0.08176469802856445,
-0.0689241886138916,
0.5842557549476624,
0.3392934799194336,
-0.6441905498504639,
0.21947690844535828,
0.25199487805366516,
-0.38705646991729736,
0.0514117106795311,
-0.6823235154151917,
-0.2865076959133148,
-0.49063706398010254,
0.6650350689888,
-1.1266816854476929,
-0.2144499272108078,
0.17086738348007202,
-0.3962092101573944,
0.17283037304878235,
0.20082233846187592,
-0.4626803994178772,
-0.060828667134046555,
-0.7447938323020935,
0.5161548256874084,
0.6409624218940735,
0.008717324584722519,
0.4196356534957886,
0.5111622214317322,
-0.847903847694397,
-0.42979851365089417,
-0.8732017278671265,
0.4823504388332367,
-0.13301584124565125,
-0.35288718342781067,
0.3043118417263031,
-0.09100042283535004,
-0.7759487628936768,
-0.36156874895095825,
-0.0028842550236731768,
-0.09694736450910568,
-0.06603280454874039,
-0.3615138828754425,
0.2524079978466034,
-0.27089256048202515,
-0.001368866884149611,
0.06056462600827217,
0.10833858698606491,
0.19945575296878815,
0.06232071295380592,
0.4826269745826721,
0.3142091929912567,
0.17810609936714172,
-0.11224327981472015,
0.22158308327198029,
0.30195340514183044,
-0.39036616683006287,
0.4380015432834625,
0.14793191850185394,
-0.0905269905924797,
-0.20204289257526398,
-0.4108749032020569,
-0.18499815464019775,
-0.32115989923477173,
0.6360021829605103,
0.07161086052656174,
-0.9808611273765564,
0.4554026126861572,
-0.16162109375,
0.5235551595687866,
0.44202637672424316,
0.6252813339233398,
-0.1179097518324852,
0.7289949655532837,
0.7750022411346436,
-0.1430729478597641,
0.4363196790218353,
-0.006110599264502525,
0.18599405884742737,
-0.6471706628799438,
-0.09575454145669937,
-0.6128376722335815,
-0.274299681186676,
-0.43874844908714294,
-0.21866554021835327,
0.430785596370697,
-0.12212172150611877,
0.2128072828054428,
0.009110997430980206,
-0.32462814450263977,
0.4308258593082428,
0.007892943918704987,
-0.1022946834564209,
0.5275908708572388,
-0.17687468230724335,
0.36614057421684265,
-0.06457457691431046,
-0.45723414421081543,
-0.4666973650455475,
1.2486109733581543,
0.5690510272979736,
0.5257835388183594,
0.018873315304517746,
0.5884398221969604,
0.2772868871688843,
0.495344877243042,
-0.6498722434043884,
0.6597258448600769,
-0.29413315653800964,
-0.5098099708557129,
-0.4665316641330719,
-0.44263413548469543,
-0.7432958483695984,
0.3646441400051117,
0.03596439212560654,
-0.27146685123443604,
-0.025685716420412064,
0.06933584064245224,
-0.15239065885543823,
0.16482028365135193,
-0.30646806955337524,
0.4578070640563965,
-0.10309901833534241,
0.17956732213497162,
-0.2820909023284912,
-0.636355996131897,
0.8278387784957886,
-0.017547788098454475,
0.3872898817062378,
-0.160519078373909,
-0.37108397483825684,
0.8945135474205017,
-0.24751339852809906,
0.6662916541099548,
0.11619149893522263,
-0.4647620916366577,
0.17601409554481506,
-0.20870430767536163,
0.31913214921951294,
0.09311755001544952,
0.15416163206100464,
0.054924216121435165,
-0.027843361720442772,
-0.31492820382118225,
-0.4706673324108124,
0.4345119893550873,
-0.2189670205116272,
-0.15207451581954956,
-0.5821457505226135,
-0.5557289123535156,
-0.17980337142944336,
0.29922157526016235,
0.32365500926971436,
0.49880653619766235,
-0.6473284363746643,
0.21627415716648102,
0.9046145081520081,
-0.3399030566215515,
0.7176985144615173,
0.3156551122665405,
-0.6000092029571533,
-0.6837818026542664,
0.7119733691215515,
0.2593153417110443,
-0.03937769681215286,
0.7539289593696594,
0.008263387717306614,
-0.22737130522727966,
-1.0178906917572021,
0.029635751619935036,
0.2553924024105072,
-0.48961856961250305,
0.025756336748600006,
-0.5985012054443359,
-0.2246084362268448,
-0.7154527306556702,
-0.23512406647205353,
-0.33881229162216187,
-0.4584886133670807,
-0.17075933516025543,
-0.06287827342748642,
-0.0325322300195694,
1.1266027688980103,
0.45698800683021545,
0.4158829152584076,
-0.7094585299491882,
0.38179418444633484,
0.17833635210990906,
0.206713005900383,
0.16713842749595642,
-0.35926586389541626,
-0.23256084322929382,
-0.2207421213388443,
0.06527216732501984,
-0.886810302734375,
0.34563004970550537,
-0.04735548794269562,
0.16285917162895203,
0.32505151629447937,
-0.10397180914878845,
0.23712529242038727,
-0.5612053275108337,
1.0452439785003662,
0.4563554525375366,
-0.5045710206031799,
0.27437934279441833,
-0.7550190091133118,
0.5882384777069092,
0.5689336657524109,
0.1851142942905426,
-0.6125668883323669,
-0.2614597678184509,
-0.14106523990631104,
-0.8739447593688965,
0.32014408707618713,
-0.03148401528596878,
-0.1298827826976776,
0.384700208902359,
0.0956430658698082,
0.2650434970855713,
0.3362847864627838,
-0.4351162612438202,
-0.37930282950401306,
0.13469785451889038,
-0.4151630401611328,
-0.5948710441589355,
-0.4180236756801605,
-0.06437225639820099,
-0.10368039458990097,
0.5961588025093079,
0.03315151855349541,
-0.05841996520757675,
0.12675897777080536,
-0.43295902013778687,
0.40957850217819214,
0.525292694568634,
0.850881040096283,
1.0993995666503906,
-0.20227943360805511,
0.010381994768977165,
0.21949465572834015,
-0.5280593037605286,
0.12651678919792175,
0.1983455866575241,
-0.4623570740222931,
0.27540382742881775,
0.636431872844696,
0.4022235870361328,
0.4336559772491455,
-0.5683808326721191,
0.6001027822494507,
-0.2825527787208557,
-0.4866345226764679,
-0.3994614779949188,
-0.23698854446411133,
-0.060650672763586044,
-0.06251773238182068,
0.4397762417793274,
-0.13890133798122406,
0.5281388759613037,
-0.3712729811668396,
-0.10284673422574997,
0.2582252323627472,
-0.2702138423919678,
-0.4588927626609802,
0.44800469279289246,
0.205438032746315,
0.06631743907928467,
0.06761998683214188,
0.25171777606010437,
0.05409352481365204,
0.507777988910675,
0.18420398235321045,
1.183052897453308,
-0.003021580632776022,
0.27449437975883484,
0.23902706801891327,
0.3281432092189789,
-0.30774790048599243,
-0.0003534227726049721,
-0.12736870348453522,
-0.3547266721725464,
-0.6212205290794373,
-0.4730727970600128,
-0.5004675984382629,
0.11213794350624084,
-0.46595871448516846,
0.23574233055114746,
-0.2532981336116791,
-0.08429034054279327,
0.2872871160507202,
-0.11321882903575897,
-0.18065525591373444,
0.08202655613422394,
0.06447113305330276,
1.0196975469589233,
-0.6378273367881775,
0.3077129125595093,
0.9334425926208496,
-0.26367053389549255,
0.12515480816364288,
0.07918543368577957,
0.1526351124048233,
-0.2755619287490845,
0.1999044120311737,
-0.16848516464233398,
-0.109923355281353,
0.0024812244810163975,
-0.567115306854248,
-0.5680609941482544,
0.9015393257141113,
-0.15519985556602478,
-0.5807475447654724,
-0.20488668978214264,
0.15139837563037872,
0.6189397573471069,
-0.13280858099460602,
0.35363689064979553,
0.6033033132553101,
0.304875910282135,
-0.2916913628578186,
-0.6704158186912537,
-0.290673166513443,
-0.20332302153110504,
0.1525803506374359,
0.3475321829319,
-0.7439491152763367,
0.7345181107521057,
0.00641334755346179,
-0.15116582810878754,
0.2609228193759918,
0.811639666557312,
0.13146895170211792,
0.5842329859733582,
0.08316946029663086,
0.3016943633556366,
0.2721966803073883,
-0.15089702606201172,
0.8097755908966064,
-0.21060071885585785,
0.09631728380918503,
1.0340602397918701,
-0.26808857917785645,
0.5639856457710266,
0.2955183684825897,
-0.32029685378074646,
0.10697080940008163,
0.5115522146224976,
0.018619919195771217,
0.24674738943576813,
0.37643635272979736,
-0.13689348101615906,
0.1514473706483841,
0.03642565757036209,
-0.5496507287025452,
0.21737822890281677,
0.10353576391935349,
-0.6078637838363647,
-0.5197082161903381,
-0.11290138214826584,
0.11039228737354279,
0.2393702268600464,
-0.5595122575759888,
1.3049925565719604,
0.1796361356973648,
-0.7129478454589844,
-0.03049478307366371,
0.1947813779115677,
0.8686402440071106,
-0.7450270652770996,
0.05865195393562317,
-0.3626217842102051,
0.06295647472143173,
-0.09417128562927246,
-0.756006121635437,
0.1690668910741806,
0.054491035640239716,
-0.375305712223053,
-0.5931441783905029,
0.9538681507110596,
-0.33091652393341064,
-0.40897753834724426,
0.02198905684053898,
0.5638075470924377,
0.24080605804920197,
0.05260081589221954,
-0.07039386034011841,
0.07575615495443344,
-0.07668707519769669,
-0.20953567326068878,
0.39069563150405884,
0.3931923806667328,
0.09188030660152435,
0.300834596157074,
0.4066793918609619,
0.2219090610742569,
0.19028359651565552,
0.292826771736145,
0.623724639415741,
-1.0573772192001343,
-0.6509891748428345,
-0.9630625247955322,
0.5777681469917297,
-0.24669528007507324,
-0.5146993398666382,
0.9399638175964355,
0.8956533670425415,
0.4549615979194641,
-0.16417139768600464,
1.0173195600509644,
0.1689608246088028,
0.7786380648612976,
-0.4798624813556671,
0.9180223941802979,
-0.36641013622283936,
0.054648954421281815,
-0.43568527698516846,
-1.0434352159500122,
-0.42314663529396057,
-0.10444146394729614,
-0.2386551797389984,
-0.15707305073738098,
0.6681305766105652,
0.3007569909095764,
0.2353021204471588,
0.18958701193332672,
-0.006175672635436058,
0.07958225160837173,
0.14696690440177917,
-0.029558056965470314,
0.881621241569519,
-0.38121622800827026,
0.35736745595932007,
0.051763877272605896,
-0.44341787695884705,
-0.31386449933052063,
-0.7361310720443726,
-0.8300826549530029,
-0.6397098302841187,
-0.3888838589191437,
0.23733197152614594,
0.23867885768413544,
0.4156724512577057,
0.18779785931110382,
-0.8476292490959167,
-0.4774949550628662,
-0.17345748841762543,
0.1547386795282364,
-0.22320877015590668,
-0.16560566425323486,
0.18431811034679413,
-0.46712422370910645,
-0.7148876190185547,
0.2989427149295807,
0.3219306468963623,
0.13888707756996155,
-0.3162529170513153,
0.12940159440040588,
0.0584479458630085,
0.03162103891372681,
0.8475554585456848,
0.25939399003982544,
-0.3621002733707428,
0.41580575704574585,
0.08013585954904556,
-0.1985512673854828,
-0.028315097093582153,
1.0570259094238281,
-0.2468900829553604,
0.06309814006090164,
0.960826575756073,
0.6271827816963196,
0.28777167201042175,
-0.13981156051158905,
0.7583423852920532,
-0.5633949637413025,
-0.0764438584446907,
0.22472062706947327,
0.22342315316200256,
0.16668438911437988,
0.046673525124788284,
0.4777313470840454,
-0.04130488634109497,
-0.6349462866783142,
-1.042573094367981,
-0.05880184844136238,
-0.964788019657135,
-0.4769535958766937,
0.9052320718765259,
0.2631319463253021,
-0.10932966321706772,
0.016990065574645996,
-0.09918994456529617,
0.18411985039710999,
-0.11643633991479874,
0.7067643404006958,
0.7269176244735718,
-0.07879561185836792,
-0.2976713180541992,
-0.33477482199668884,
0.5305166840553284,
0.2587416172027588,
-1.1356576681137085,
0.20705564320087433,
0.6725385189056396,
0.15440121293067932,
-0.0005474279751069844,
0.7535560131072998,
-0.4065248966217041,
0.009758963249623775,
-0.2846793830394745,
0.1173117607831955,
0.18333041667938232,
-0.3340940475463867,
-0.6514593362808228,
0.4124920070171356,
-0.04364200681447983,
0.20462647080421448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11288v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11288v1 | MFC-Bench: Benchmarking Multimodal Fact-Checking with Large Vision-Language Models | 2024-06-17T07:51:44 | 2024-06-17T07:51:44 | Shengkang Wang, Hongzhan Lin, Ziyang Luo, Zhen Ye, Guang Chen, Jing Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Large vision-language models (LVLMs) have significantly improved multimodal
reasoning tasks, such as visual question answering and image captioning. These
models embed multimodal facts within their parameters, rather than relying on
external knowledge bases to store factual information explicitly. However, the
content discerned by LVLMs may deviate from actual facts due to inherent bias
or incorrect inference. To address this issue, we introduce MFC-Bench, a
rigorous and comprehensive benchmark designed to evaluate the factual accuracy
of LVLMs across three tasks: Manipulation, Out-of-Context, and Veracity
Classification. Through our evaluation on MFC-Bench, we benchmarked 12 diverse
and representative LVLMs, uncovering that current models still fall short in
multimodal fact-checking and demonstrate insensitivity to various forms of
manipulated content. We hope that MFC-Bench could raise attention to the
trustworthy artificial intelligence potentially assisted by LVLMs in the
future. The MFC-Bench and accompanying resources are publicly accessible at
https://github.com/wskbest/MFC-Bench, contributing to ongoing research in the
multimodal fact-checking field. | [
-0.4336988627910614,
-0.6778528094291687,
0.7572839856147766,
0.062120839953422546,
-0.03129519149661064,
0.08807506412267685,
-0.2344479262828827,
-0.46403276920318604,
-0.35741719603538513,
0.4009729027748108,
-0.566022515296936,
-0.4599488079547882,
-0.42241528630256653,
0.06683500111103058,
-0.5096951723098755,
0.5530931949615479,
-0.23524001240730286,
0.239567831158638,
-0.7788727283477783,
-0.4756620526313782,
-0.13695451617240906,
-0.3602127730846405,
-0.039264410734176636,
-0.15854021906852722,
0.587246298789978,
0.2926236689090729,
0.6522212624549866,
0.5840518474578857,
0.7014279961585999,
0.3467714190483093,
0.37010079622268677,
0.5809793472290039,
-0.25201216340065,
0.055644452571868896,
-0.2107071727514267,
-0.4410170316696167,
-0.07605549693107605,
0.2264978438615799,
0.697747528553009,
0.2268798053264618,
-0.09508189558982849,
0.35322830080986023,
-0.25125694274902344,
0.6479595899581909,
-1.1139792203903198,
0.4704907238483429,
-0.4882800877094269,
-0.027471249923110008,
-0.10760211199522018,
0.058595921844244,
-0.6149058938026428,
-0.44542092084884644,
-0.19697044789791107,
-0.472394734621048,
0.2408083826303482,
0.2925262749195099,
0.8890181183815002,
0.5852890610694885,
-0.5281335115432739,
0.0705265924334526,
-0.36720484495162964,
0.826224148273468,
-0.4012277126312256,
1.0038412809371948,
0.479498028755188,
0.6352927684783936,
0.08335407823324203,
-0.7445842027664185,
-0.8929474353790283,
-0.5106630325317383,
-0.25628426671028137,
0.19187839329242706,
-0.09629248082637787,
-0.010465944185853004,
0.59443199634552,
-0.010867292992770672,
-0.4756253659725189,
-0.2829037010669708,
-0.2134746015071869,
-0.44458290934562683,
0.42792996764183044,
-0.0014783466467633843,
-0.06127981096506119,
-0.25909197330474854,
-0.6372201442718506,
-0.48730018734931946,
-0.6001850366592407,
0.27945733070373535,
-0.062496691942214966,
-0.005333980545401573,
-0.059218503534793854,
0.7997887134552002,
-0.5974748134613037,
0.8588520288467407,
-0.3758455514907837,
-0.6272128224372864,
0.43967631459236145,
-0.722763180732727,
-0.2391597181558609,
-0.16899418830871582,
0.6243484616279602,
0.8112395405769348,
0.13193826377391815,
-0.006497110705822706,
-0.22296316921710968,
0.14233244955539703,
0.10475194454193115,
-0.6737456321716309,
-0.1044929102063179,
0.04674811288714409,
-0.49251917004585266,
-0.1275109052658081,
0.10025643557310104,
-0.8345411419868469,
-0.6221954226493835,
-0.4784439504146576,
0.37342020869255066,
-0.3887813687324524,
-0.01825566217303276,
-0.31480154395103455,
-0.1990622878074646,
0.17699548602104187,
0.6160346865653992,
-0.4193842113018036,
-0.03558214381337166,
0.5493816137313843,
0.7323595285415649,
-0.02813245914876461,
-0.5160365700721741,
-1.011873483657837,
0.09866821020841599,
-0.19765087962150574,
0.8712666034698486,
-0.5535238981246948,
0.07492788881063461,
0.1082380935549736,
0.012348054908216,
-0.15919101238250732,
-0.4843907654285431,
0.7442184090614319,
-0.31330254673957825,
-0.23531165719032288,
-0.6872571706771851,
-0.3686690628528595,
-0.2265954315662384,
0.8045600652694702,
-0.8137441277503967,
0.9487517476081848,
-0.0657534971833229,
-0.5463595390319824,
0.6281477808952332,
-0.3828445076942444,
-0.20259997248649597,
-0.3337908387184143,
-0.4263618588447571,
-0.3315536677837372,
-0.15489308536052704,
0.26728588342666626,
0.4226575791835785,
-0.44207215309143066,
0.32012706995010376,
-0.6358144879341125,
-0.1245640218257904,
0.5736947655677795,
-0.5546355247497559,
0.40532970428466797,
0.21409080922603607,
-0.2936825454235077,
0.11282080411911011,
-0.9077572226524353,
0.06814562529325485,
-0.13708527386188507,
-0.4103487730026245,
-0.08226463943719864,
0.16247092187404633,
0.18858695030212402,
0.5035881996154785,
-0.00850899051874876,
-0.7644381523132324,
-0.06807627528905869,
0.2808024287223816,
0.10246292501688004,
0.7150161266326904,
-0.40661218762397766,
-0.039380624890327454,
-0.4349159598350525,
-0.02222270704805851,
0.191401869058609,
0.49033623933792114,
-0.2397516667842865,
-0.2775915265083313,
-0.8024094700813293,
-0.4700971245765686,
0.265310138463974,
0.5383322238922119,
-1.2174437046051025,
0.014086438342928886,
-0.2942761480808258,
-0.5213493704795837,
-0.45130565762519836,
0.332293838262558,
0.5421375632286072,
0.617484450340271,
0.5816314220428467,
-0.19514527916908264,
-0.2459438294172287,
-1.0598136186599731,
-0.2888699173927307,
-0.25511425733566284,
0.33294180035591125,
0.42509499192237854,
0.6210877895355225,
-0.1532360166311264,
0.9441110491752625,
-0.3120723366737366,
-0.27671268582344055,
0.2582992911338806,
0.32577016949653625,
-0.18024085462093353,
0.3357886075973511,
0.7059664726257324,
-1.0241334438323975,
-0.22834709286689758,
-0.0594138540327549,
-0.8543058037757874,
-0.07130036503076553,
-0.13789823651313782,
0.059071581810712814,
0.3987278640270233,
0.610602080821991,
-0.917570173740387,
0.46901535987854004,
0.6870014667510986,
-0.25729960203170776,
0.9022940397262573,
-0.05141214653849602,
0.6316974759101868,
-0.4756014049053192,
0.18818512558937073,
0.0682477205991745,
-0.3860584497451782,
-0.2805059552192688,
0.26474741101264954,
0.5804361701011658,
0.1906629204750061,
-0.6612517833709717,
0.4354884922504425,
-0.37926581501960754,
-0.23001444339752197,
-0.018980074673891068,
0.02870054356753826,
0.0981919914484024,
0.4204834997653961,
-0.12873955070972443,
0.7400595545768738,
0.27889275550842285,
-0.30687272548675537,
0.7642488479614258,
0.07766831666231155,
-0.7535860538482666,
0.6446964144706726,
-0.21903544664382935,
-0.16990379989147186,
-0.04384812340140343,
0.32601746916770935,
-1.0506601333618164,
-0.2090105414390564,
0.09755679219961166,
-0.1808302402496338,
0.1604861319065094,
-0.03978635370731354,
-0.9763060808181763,
-0.34065890312194824,
-0.3153756260871887,
0.3323724567890167,
0.10297176241874695,
-0.7837142944335938,
0.8036172986030579,
0.11052708327770233,
0.2750941514968872,
-1.047760009765625,
-0.5920507907867432,
0.11105139553546906,
0.35037705302238464,
-0.6251556873321533,
0.16230733692646027,
-0.34236273169517517,
-0.49059444665908813,
-0.03370650112628937,
-0.17941518127918243,
-0.15515758097171783,
-0.1017044186592102,
0.33673736453056335,
0.1427377462387085,
-0.2605459988117218,
0.2592929005622864,
-0.21008606255054474,
0.07457767426967621,
0.050334490835666656,
0.2559436857700348,
0.26123031973838806,
-0.46506449580192566,
-0.8168359398841858,
-0.12125244736671448,
0.0437929667532444,
0.9835766553878784,
-0.559168815612793,
0.5707352757453918,
0.9650798439979553,
-0.2039601057767868,
0.0453542061150074,
-1.0991466045379639,
-0.1742676943540573,
-0.4181268513202667,
0.22983920574188232,
-0.3506656289100647,
-0.8020455837249756,
0.14770476520061493,
0.023200491443276405,
0.13772845268249512,
0.11630997061729431,
0.5481826066970825,
-0.14234937727451324,
0.908118486404419,
0.29832369089126587,
0.13929755985736847,
0.341718852519989,
0.014697287231683731,
-0.08221568167209625,
-0.40839874744415283,
-0.2517137825489044,
-0.40548866987228394,
-0.23788410425186157,
-0.36271414160728455,
-0.8236817121505737,
0.30790120363235474,
-0.350970596075058,
0.026785654947161674,
-0.032766155898571014,
0.09824229031801224,
0.5046849846839905,
0.6141492128372192,
0.271618127822876,
0.4329957067966461,
-0.26119256019592285,
-0.2938119173049927,
0.04845499247312546,
-0.4459848999977112,
-0.21067987382411957,
0.9738328456878662,
0.14380760490894318,
0.7718867063522339,
0.18259017169475555,
0.15160368382930756,
0.32972219586372375,
0.5927539467811584,
-0.48772919178009033,
0.5796372890472412,
-0.1759033203125,
-0.8452948331832886,
-0.105033278465271,
-0.3579235076904297,
-0.23894545435905457,
0.6209482550621033,
-0.6579272150993347,
-0.4255068302154541,
0.22829106450080872,
0.24964743852615356,
-0.1788478046655655,
0.4228346645832062,
-0.7795050144195557,
0.9293450117111206,
-0.44887983798980713,
-0.8025250434875488,
-0.39765796065330505,
-0.7187153697013855,
0.6765010356903076,
0.0027586552314460278,
0.4828617572784424,
-0.41989344358444214,
0.0928206741809845,
0.26438426971435547,
-0.1661452054977417,
0.8475765585899353,
-0.2687391936779022,
0.08954373747110367,
0.09499668329954147,
0.06221664696931839,
0.42890462279319763,
0.08051366358995438,
0.08878614753484726,
0.059903331100940704,
0.23665715754032135,
-0.3325682580471039,
-0.6397504210472107,
0.6610040068626404,
-0.6235958933830261,
-0.40146952867507935,
-0.4629288613796234,
-0.6160533428192139,
-0.4370923340320587,
0.25970354676246643,
-0.21539926528930664,
0.6369622945785522,
-0.28949302434921265,
0.6822140216827393,
0.5670933127403259,
-0.06290039420127869,
0.5104352831840515,
0.7430368661880493,
-0.24855387210845947,
-0.2561722993850708,
0.7865861058235168,
-0.0137088093906641,
0.18490943312644958,
0.6971117854118347,
0.07886426895856857,
-0.5698201656341553,
-0.3792509436607361,
-0.639952540397644,
0.030418507754802704,
-1.0683423280715942,
-0.24542562663555145,
-0.6496347784996033,
0.08703508228063583,
-0.1825532764196396,
0.1750740259885788,
-0.5853520631790161,
-0.31922173500061035,
0.18110355734825134,
0.01464166585355997,
0.09139163792133331,
0.3695434331893921,
-0.02289697900414467,
-0.061187662184238434,
-0.8008420467376709,
0.5335236191749573,
0.5535728931427002,
0.48115071654319763,
-0.3217533826828003,
-0.10571904480457306,
-0.1259257197380066,
0.11214505136013031,
-0.2178928703069687,
-0.5308005809783936,
-0.15033172070980072,
0.13044044375419617,
0.8325623273849487,
0.4455696940422058,
0.06488068401813507,
0.5705530643463135,
-0.4993875324726105,
0.6265742778778076,
0.35862329602241516,
-0.7948524951934814,
0.22987376153469086,
-0.03967132419347763,
0.16010966897010803,
0.7249835133552551,
0.15436935424804688,
-0.3399752080440521,
-0.26845499873161316,
-0.27335235476493835,
-0.19574157893657684,
0.46285489201545715,
0.10253723710775375,
-0.336223840713501,
0.22621390223503113,
-0.03460251912474632,
0.08185040205717087,
0.4544949233531952,
-0.8000085949897766,
-0.16161808371543884,
-0.5379301309585571,
-0.21880827844142914,
-0.40565982460975647,
-0.20184312760829926,
-0.42825016379356384,
-0.2802976369857788,
0.37007957696914673,
-0.49115797877311707,
-0.01573006808757782,
0.3107345402240753,
-0.5380842685699463,
-0.047505054622888565,
0.2588684856891632,
0.9804638624191284,
0.9439502358436584,
-0.4286937713623047,
0.5571565628051758,
0.20012608170509338,
-0.3109737038612366,
0.06804110109806061,
0.2917654514312744,
-0.014437506906688213,
0.022233542054891586,
0.4448436200618744,
0.5728356838226318,
0.3859601616859436,
-1.0818696022033691,
0.7173945903778076,
-0.21464726328849792,
-0.36652642488479614,
-0.026953868567943573,
0.08451619744300842,
-0.03374422714114189,
0.3956649601459503,
0.16696776449680328,
0.4870830476284027,
0.08429187536239624,
-0.6191688179969788,
0.40073543787002563,
0.4703434407711029,
-0.47809550166130066,
0.018847107887268066,
0.4826267957687378,
0.14770850539207458,
0.39244315028190613,
0.487165629863739,
0.05898786708712578,
-0.37039849162101746,
0.4447881281375885,
0.13045842945575714,
0.42492416501045227,
0.0356578566133976,
0.22827023267745972,
0.37935590744018555,
0.6943812966346741,
-0.050490256398916245,
0.10512541234493256,
-0.25380298495292664,
-0.8762404322624207,
-0.5293789505958557,
-0.5043863654136658,
-0.5971096158027649,
-0.034392647445201874,
-0.4416723847389221,
0.035298045724630356,
-0.4924508035182953,
-0.13455678522586823,
0.22876574099063873,
-0.23210644721984863,
-0.8273758292198181,
0.3878103792667389,
0.27801573276519775,
1.13398277759552,
-0.6727758646011353,
0.8680329918861389,
0.6811006665229797,
-0.46764835715293884,
-0.27253586053848267,
-0.2067386507987976,
0.32295921444892883,
-0.9465156197547913,
0.7371306419372559,
0.2751312255859375,
-0.44069796800613403,
-0.43737587332725525,
-0.815592885017395,
-0.7863560914993286,
1.251487135887146,
0.4509291648864746,
-0.5651280879974365,
0.437042772769928,
0.04490593820810318,
0.2597540318965912,
-0.252256840467453,
0.31267493963241577,
0.5732018947601318,
0.9223432540893555,
0.07117988914251328,
-0.8716104626655579,
0.08645302057266235,
-0.33373233675956726,
-0.4375637471675873,
-0.02915194258093834,
-0.916273832321167,
0.8898066282272339,
-0.3081921935081482,
0.07059916108846664,
0.023371519520878792,
0.49094468355178833,
0.3797674775123596,
0.4624778628349304,
0.8276673555374146,
0.5348929762840271,
0.6568318605422974,
-0.34256064891815186,
1.121964454650879,
-0.27506116032600403,
0.24833662807941437,
0.932719349861145,
-0.5240660905838013,
0.9640969634056091,
0.620394229888916,
-0.00846716109663248,
0.5021277070045471,
0.32383811473846436,
-0.2960185706615448,
0.5479245781898499,
-0.150628000497818,
-0.18562762439250946,
-0.558411180973053,
-0.34691858291625977,
-0.3098430633544922,
0.6452227830886841,
0.23370280861854553,
-0.19374032318592072,
-0.2491161823272705,
-0.057338714599609375,
-0.18657617270946503,
-0.02015557512640953,
-0.12714318931102753,
0.46856722235679626,
-0.22117817401885986,
-0.8136818408966064,
0.546717643737793,
-0.054505832493305206,
0.3047390580177307,
-0.5850988030433655,
-0.15489478409290314,
0.02208789251744747,
0.397705614566803,
-0.09488878399133682,
-0.9736997485160828,
-0.125952810049057,
-0.04999421164393425,
-0.37929415702819824,
-0.2048327922821045,
0.7965014576911926,
-0.4632846713066101,
-0.37274348735809326,
0.2869005799293518,
0.7634140253067017,
-0.3268935978412628,
-0.26305487751960754,
-0.8280554413795471,
0.21069477498531342,
-0.09642931073904037,
-0.06319992244243622,
0.22113202512264252,
0.12844166159629822,
-0.08056261390447617,
0.8604981899261475,
0.9214662313461304,
-0.4211096167564392,
0.06095479801297188,
0.34390419721603394,
0.8412055969238281,
-0.5896410346031189,
-0.23622660338878632,
-0.8537315726280212,
0.35791173577308655,
-0.2701428532600403,
-0.2496776133775711,
0.7726694941520691,
0.6820470094680786,
0.7861328125,
-0.24348346889019012,
0.679702877998352,
-0.09527325630187988,
0.3566424250602722,
-0.8085687160491943,
0.7248620986938477,
-0.8802593946456909,
-0.3256693482398987,
-0.25011953711509705,
-0.7409123182296753,
-0.29751479625701904,
0.45342719554901123,
-0.08403167873620987,
-0.12500755488872528,
0.9281072616577148,
0.9769768118858337,
-0.21422502398490906,
0.16297146677970886,
0.5536850690841675,
0.2533968985080719,
0.23408836126327515,
0.3378927409648895,
1.2242237329483032,
-0.19500596821308136,
0.7445765733718872,
-0.5139975547790527,
-0.23512043058872223,
-0.4100121855735779,
-1.061859130859375,
-1.0160059928894043,
-0.5372350215911865,
-0.19113034009933472,
-0.18339574337005615,
0.04598564654588699,
0.8757304549217224,
0.9551821351051331,
-0.8819055557250977,
-0.05721166729927063,
0.3864063024520874,
0.3157106041908264,
-0.4471369981765747,
-0.11739645898342133,
0.22272545099258423,
-0.1925458014011383,
-0.3337215781211853,
0.4100263714790344,
0.36803674697875977,
-0.08433976024389267,
-0.20627222955226898,
-0.06105467677116394,
-0.5176946520805359,
-0.21615633368492126,
0.9342545866966248,
0.11293601989746094,
-1.02696692943573,
-0.4712074398994446,
0.09161067008972168,
-0.25414830446243286,
0.07017657905817032,
0.8385858535766602,
-0.5799016952514648,
0.7902464270591736,
0.5042544603347778,
0.6720040440559387,
0.5707216858863831,
0.10448704659938812,
0.2585163414478302,
-0.8645572066307068,
0.0960921049118042,
-0.09536702930927277,
0.7650778889656067,
0.46705198287963867,
0.1929786503314972,
0.5528169870376587,
0.5121079683303833,
-0.2961099147796631,
-0.7987041473388672,
0.06148763746023178,
-1.0919615030288696,
-0.3223385810852051,
0.9567190408706665,
-0.022132383659482002,
-0.4029083847999573,
-0.09296523779630661,
-0.28398123383522034,
0.04454067721962929,
-0.27267134189605713,
0.6701193451881409,
0.9113219976425171,
0.055875733494758606,
-0.5324501395225525,
-0.8357361555099487,
0.5780966877937317,
0.3053201138973236,
-0.9033246636390686,
0.28656691312789917,
0.776390790939331,
0.09177158772945404,
0.46817806363105774,
0.2896474003791809,
0.06993333995342255,
0.7295350432395935,
0.08314639329910278,
0.188326895236969,
-0.2995993494987488,
-0.5286626815795898,
0.25155070424079895,
0.23745585978031158,
-0.17021691799163818,
-0.04674018919467926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11285v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11285v1 | Self and Cross-Model Distillation for LLMs: Effective Methods for Refusal Pattern Alignment | 2024-06-17T07:46:45 | 2024-06-17T07:46:45 | Jie Li, Yi Liu, Chongyang Liu, Xiaoning Ren, Ling Shi, Weisong Sun, Yinxing Xue | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) like OpenAI's GPT series, Anthropic's Claude,
and Meta's LLaMa have shown remarkable capabilities in text generation.
However, their susceptibility to toxic prompts presents significant security
challenges. This paper investigates alignment techniques, including Supervised
Fine-Tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF), to
mitigate these risks. We conduct an empirical study on refusal patterns across
nine LLMs, revealing that models with uniform refusal patterns, such as
Claude3, exhibit higher security. Based on these findings, we propose
self-distilling and cross-model distilling methods to enhance LLM security. Our
results show that these methods significantly improve refusal rates and reduce
unsafe content, with cross-model distilling achieving refusal rates close to
Claude3's 94.51%. These findings underscore the potential of distillation-based
alignment in securing LLMs against toxic prompts. | [
-0.03687598183751106,
-0.822952151298523,
0.8399306535720825,
0.10787581652402878,
-0.24685454368591309,
0.2874964773654938,
0.08730565011501312,
-0.32560616731643677,
-0.27389463782310486,
0.726750910282135,
-0.8877512812614441,
-0.5051232576370239,
-0.527234673500061,
0.3881392776966095,
-0.31519636511802673,
1.231049656867981,
-0.18366944789886475,
0.11466287821531296,
-0.01714271306991577,
-0.03182782977819443,
-0.702174961566925,
-0.6678635478019714,
-0.6824358105659485,
-0.5057669878005981,
0.7805389165878296,
0.24332627654075623,
0.5501033663749695,
0.6726418733596802,
0.4390307366847992,
0.35251614451408386,
-0.08454246073961258,
0.11031802743673325,
-0.4089944064617157,
0.4584648311138153,
-0.317310094833374,
-0.4911857545375824,
-0.3629191219806671,
0.23060445487499237,
0.07665524631738663,
0.14100486040115356,
-0.3350703716278076,
0.0728338211774826,
0.4020942151546478,
0.8834752440452576,
-0.47793176770210266,
-0.26781970262527466,
-0.7512258887290955,
-0.03198590129613876,
-0.2877811789512634,
-0.1670665442943573,
-0.7100316882133484,
-0.26861128211021423,
0.1343616545200348,
-0.5355657935142517,
-0.13828562200069427,
0.19088424742221832,
0.6508838534355164,
0.41101399064064026,
-0.3420012593269348,
-0.5515386462211609,
-0.6958706974983215,
0.8384997248649597,
-0.707402229309082,
0.15104959905147552,
0.46538954973220825,
0.45491376519203186,
-0.5003634095191956,
-0.7022951245307922,
-0.3789139688014984,
-0.22847235202789307,
-0.05823354050517082,
-0.04604100435972214,
-0.1598321944475174,
0.03708949312567711,
0.27781596779823303,
0.040385812520980835,
-0.5966200828552246,
0.48318034410476685,
-0.31456416845321655,
-0.20060992240905762,
0.711837887763977,
0.38979843258857727,
0.3775962293148041,
-0.06660965085029602,
-0.6598814725875854,
-0.2814387381076813,
-0.9623554348945618,
-0.016976937651634216,
0.7641329765319824,
0.4492028057575226,
0.10854139178991318,
0.5797790884971619,
-0.2199035882949829,
0.7305773496627808,
0.30125781893730164,
-0.19083932042121887,
-0.0011012490140274167,
-0.4374947249889374,
-0.21516641974449158,
0.1889355182647705,
1.0326372385025024,
0.37068918347358704,
0.2621491253376007,
0.23901031911373138,
-0.3819422721862793,
-0.06868062913417816,
0.35329145193099976,
-0.7198529243469238,
-0.22671593725681305,
0.5269272923469543,
-0.7096808552742004,
-0.7545639872550964,
-0.0723060816526413,
-0.7892059683799744,
-0.6461172699928284,
-0.32407382130622864,
0.4146946370601654,
-0.4368728697299957,
-0.07544104009866714,
-0.11237833648920059,
-0.13178975880146027,
0.22607457637786865,
0.34558382630348206,
-1.076137900352478,
0.2355845421552658,
0.6237325668334961,
0.9288493990898132,
-0.3686063885688782,
-0.3191191256046295,
-0.6073111295700073,
0.2509343922138214,
-0.12705214321613312,
0.4384540021419525,
-0.3527826964855194,
-0.42232540249824524,
-0.25317052006721497,
-0.1935947984457016,
0.2777857780456543,
-0.6278427243232727,
0.6232739090919495,
-0.6068143248558044,
0.06597824394702911,
-0.35891199111938477,
-0.18425174057483673,
-0.029473688453435898,
0.16033302247524261,
-0.5609036087989807,
0.7239786982536316,
-0.2696320116519928,
-0.865390419960022,
0.40131545066833496,
-0.2621402144432068,
-0.31985998153686523,
-0.251465380191803,
-0.17411644756793976,
-0.7185403108596802,
0.0900857225060463,
0.44095879793167114,
0.33765411376953125,
-0.11210125684738159,
0.3170972764492035,
-0.6383296847343445,
0.004607635084539652,
0.4447818398475647,
-0.8103124499320984,
0.8818482756614685,
0.7233568429946899,
-0.23735515773296356,
0.24601531028747559,
-0.8573216795921326,
-0.1381525844335556,
0.19803857803344727,
-0.3444439470767975,
-0.5335459113121033,
0.17802809178829193,
0.011037821881473064,
0.37971872091293335,
0.08262897282838821,
-0.4390287697315216,
0.16023404896259308,
-0.09484684467315674,
0.7157616019248962,
1.084661841392517,
-0.010064666159451008,
0.21695788204669952,
-0.4752388596534729,
0.48918265104293823,
0.14883792400360107,
0.3713335394859314,
0.06810887157917023,
-0.29454588890075684,
-0.4070799946784973,
-0.21249163150787354,
0.31510481238365173,
0.7268522381782532,
-0.6636412739753723,
0.3494437634944916,
0.24613752961158752,
-0.4771603047847748,
-0.521702229976654,
0.2946457266807556,
0.43308499455451965,
0.5168026685714722,
0.23572015762329102,
-0.17534098029136658,
-0.5227541327476501,
-0.7581566572189331,
-0.32253843545913696,
-0.38870730996131897,
-0.022534141317009926,
-0.13474096357822418,
0.3056577146053314,
-0.15644195675849915,
0.9331778883934021,
-0.30889892578125,
-0.28432467579841614,
0.08080404251813889,
0.22636942565441132,
0.20531925559043884,
0.3777101933956146,
0.6547006964683533,
-0.8493376970291138,
-0.5875997543334961,
-0.09693117439746857,
-0.5890706777572632,
-0.32741352915763855,
-0.10530600696802139,
-0.03044023923575878,
0.30542609095573425,
0.7205643057823181,
-0.07146763801574707,
0.36351045966148376,
0.6069459319114685,
-0.08890001475811005,
0.4077373445034027,
-0.1503746211528778,
0.04465177282691002,
-1.2136993408203125,
-0.17338307201862335,
-0.03012983314692974,
-0.44454315304756165,
-0.70563143491745,
-0.06500153243541718,
0.018816905096173286,
-0.06124352663755417,
-0.669948160648346,
0.31373947858810425,
-0.5870871543884277,
0.518853485584259,
-0.40479177236557007,
-0.14723853766918182,
-0.19258300960063934,
0.17067548632621765,
0.10626839101314545,
0.6476912498474121,
0.5438690781593323,
-0.7246613502502441,
0.4788268208503723,
0.20703871548175812,
-0.16376207768917084,
0.7367025017738342,
-0.7441256642341614,
0.10566800087690353,
-0.09566888958215714,
0.2688980996608734,
-1.2226552963256836,
-0.06416662782430649,
0.46645858883857727,
-0.15664884448051453,
0.27115774154663086,
-0.290542870759964,
-0.08188999444246292,
-0.26534655690193176,
-0.2561197280883789,
0.3655664920806885,
0.5632485151290894,
-0.635556161403656,
0.5062856078147888,
0.06215246394276619,
-0.33179062604904175,
-0.8119285702705383,
-0.7889541983604431,
-0.006474328693002462,
-0.6079005002975464,
-0.28787586092948914,
0.018626872450113297,
-0.3425978124141693,
-0.29607272148132324,
-0.2787784934043884,
-0.11077666282653809,
0.1021423488855362,
0.3601842224597931,
0.4658472537994385,
0.3165128529071808,
0.1933232992887497,
-0.3779001235961914,
-0.051508646458387375,
-0.2507454454898834,
0.12455541640520096,
-0.3140520453453064,
0.3433963656425476,
0.23190441727638245,
-0.5185194611549377,
-0.5591462254524231,
0.2999497056007385,
0.5459252595901489,
-0.0228660199791193,
0.4471822679042816,
0.18845751881599426,
-0.12296521663665771,
-0.13859334588050842,
-0.40864893794059753,
-0.22432316839694977,
-0.5974560976028442,
-0.018661025911569595,
-0.426802396774292,
-0.910758912563324,
0.4880056381225586,
-0.07662750035524368,
0.16064873337745667,
0.1612345278263092,
0.7669888734817505,
-0.2135903537273407,
0.9306320548057556,
0.34510567784309387,
-0.3110124170780182,
0.5205404162406921,
0.46186327934265137,
0.15446165204048157,
-0.513783872127533,
-0.06680338084697723,
-0.5379989743232727,
-0.43318915367126465,
-0.7940378785133362,
-0.026006946340203285,
0.3649017810821533,
0.007728334981948137,
-0.012119663879275322,
0.2284558117389679,
-0.6325615644454956,
0.6038222312927246,
0.49785417318344116,
0.19882714748382568,
0.5952125191688538,
0.10305935889482498,
-0.384106308221817,
-0.08427399396896362,
-0.4101669490337372,
-0.6349387764930725,
1.0814801454544067,
0.5596507787704468,
1.2740144729614258,
0.19924211502075195,
1.0898693799972534,
0.180031418800354,
0.26021453738212585,
-0.3921361267566681,
0.34929823875427246,
0.19483549892902374,
-0.7418208718299866,
-0.457599014043808,
-0.48872190713882446,
-0.9858840107917786,
0.2319473922252655,
-0.17233875393867493,
-0.7036844491958618,
0.12130483239889145,
0.18893639743328094,
-0.6701090931892395,
0.15328063070774078,
-0.5813755393028259,
0.48498743772506714,
-0.4902364909648895,
-0.2019265592098236,
0.034981824457645416,
-0.5582672953605652,
0.5147433876991272,
-0.30671820044517517,
0.29697054624557495,
-0.10848818719387054,
0.023500332608819008,
0.3732614517211914,
-0.8070610761642456,
1.1873306035995483,
0.06473718583583832,
-0.727896511554718,
0.4679315388202667,
0.3632279932498932,
0.8673792481422424,
0.16615189611911774,
-0.1806923896074295,
0.01878419704735279,
0.06185280159115791,
-0.06973632425069809,
-0.44967979192733765,
0.7372287511825562,
-0.6712725758552551,
-0.902897298336029,
-0.6252521872520447,
-0.3041767477989197,
0.0397115983068943,
0.35172703862190247,
0.6501486897468567,
-0.1523585170507431,
-0.2776501476764679,
-0.23368021845817566,
0.7832497954368591,
-0.2193789780139923,
0.6261739730834961,
0.5631295442581177,
-0.30239996314048767,
-0.5638471245765686,
0.8750401735305786,
0.17320595681667328,
0.6281359791755676,
0.13123719394207,
0.2672029435634613,
-0.35339877009391785,
-0.8807184100151062,
-0.45405080914497375,
-0.1255214363336563,
-0.45347920060157776,
-0.41620808839797974,
-0.4951808452606201,
-0.2690415680408478,
-0.5186842679977417,
-0.030401665717363358,
-0.15292492508888245,
-0.2378780096769333,
-0.383619487285614,
-0.21593570709228516,
0.475464791059494,
0.8546153903007507,
-0.13004927337169647,
0.1743679940700531,
-0.9322782158851624,
0.2681334316730499,
0.43327412009239197,
0.3523305058479309,
-0.03737843036651611,
-0.4358300268650055,
0.2686431407928467,
0.07239514589309692,
-0.5301694869995117,
-0.9798797965049744,
0.2665802240371704,
-0.2853187620639801,
0.3989906907081604,
0.24982266128063202,
0.4130633771419525,
0.5173824429512024,
-0.6584345102310181,
0.5681540966033936,
0.24937622249126434,
-0.8912147283554077,
0.7945400476455688,
-0.6597475409507751,
-0.11023169010877609,
0.7391262650489807,
0.571841835975647,
-0.4405052363872528,
-0.5597521662712097,
-0.3607375919818878,
-0.8181610107421875,
0.6794544458389282,
0.28458335995674133,
0.059961508959531784,
0.19820262491703033,
0.3188328444957733,
0.29477280378341675,
0.050008375197649,
-1.0569814443588257,
-0.22717222571372986,
-0.005304936319589615,
-0.2029501348733902,
0.10443458706140518,
-0.22006063163280487,
-0.3707236647605896,
0.06952715665102005,
0.7304485440254211,
-0.09128082543611526,
-0.3950047492980957,
0.22675593197345734,
0.0077673825435340405,
-0.04212326556444168,
0.4414389431476593,
0.746566116809845,
0.45330244302749634,
-0.08328252285718918,
0.07480480521917343,
0.23360668122768402,
-0.36275285482406616,
0.7175096869468689,
-0.22531747817993164,
-0.3687543272972107,
-0.25670361518859863,
0.08038026839494705,
0.5677775144577026,
-0.28875216841697693,
-0.3059813380241394,
0.25848260521888733,
-0.22026892006397247,
-0.4015332758426666,
-0.03028850257396698,
0.294100284576416,
-0.1331155002117157,
0.2747865319252014,
0.06606420129537582,
-0.3650975227355957,
0.1478160321712494,
-0.5308618545532227,
0.21270905435085297,
0.43986034393310547,
-0.38458970189094543,
0.02790859341621399,
0.7950428128242493,
0.28114810585975647,
-0.21523581445217133,
0.5467504858970642,
0.03996103256940842,
-0.1720201075077057,
0.27956312894821167,
0.6161760091781616,
0.9316293001174927,
-0.43484416604042053,
0.2828347980976105,
0.2566062808036804,
0.36591586470603943,
-0.28772252798080444,
0.22416140139102936,
0.029647573828697205,
-0.523330807685852,
-0.2570664882659912,
-0.6360750198364258,
-0.5065200328826904,
0.1453198939561844,
-0.7147213816642761,
0.26042965054512024,
-0.7093469500541687,
-0.24210241436958313,
-0.2500920295715332,
-0.3061094284057617,
-0.11298632621765137,
-0.13483771681785583,
0.2021874487400055,
0.7526571154594421,
-1.0954704284667969,
0.7601916193962097,
0.4024825692176819,
-0.382773220539093,
-0.861911416053772,
-0.014153544791042805,
0.4344879984855652,
-0.667640209197998,
0.5200915932655334,
-0.09877310693264008,
0.08802033960819244,
-0.1389700025320053,
-0.5404849648475647,
-0.7672248482704163,
1.0775142908096313,
0.40355581045150757,
-1.0747973918914795,
-0.0358898751437664,
0.3471554219722748,
0.36906808614730835,
-0.002980221528559923,
0.0989532619714737,
0.7615999579429626,
0.6141384243965149,
0.14711304008960724,
-0.874919056892395,
0.3983707129955292,
0.1271659880876541,
0.19597919285297394,
0.21934127807617188,
-0.9258880019187927,
0.5670533180236816,
-0.18622304499149323,
-0.17740103602409363,
0.13646647334098816,
0.7200115919113159,
0.5762447714805603,
0.18645073473453522,
0.5269720554351807,
0.5803926587104797,
0.840725839138031,
-0.0485018715262413,
0.6736422777175903,
0.2664615511894226,
0.044483479112386703,
1.2773592472076416,
-0.657289981842041,
0.6492404937744141,
0.737798810005188,
-0.10223456472158432,
0.5642624497413635,
0.8434198498725891,
0.07678995281457901,
0.7468172907829285,
0.46248820424079895,
0.013830478303134441,
-0.24880823493003845,
0.14439749717712402,
-0.3018658757209778,
0.3032550811767578,
0.26341769099235535,
-0.3244529366493225,
-0.3014916479587555,
-0.009794234298169613,
-0.0963803306221962,
0.12155088037252426,
-0.1453636884689331,
1.0356736183166504,
0.4211406409740448,
-0.8053093552589417,
0.5662627220153809,
-0.07100019603967667,
0.7132681012153625,
-0.5189722180366516,
0.09932999312877655,
-0.016199123114347458,
0.009506983682513237,
-0.32683250308036804,
-0.7943285703659058,
0.2455727607011795,
0.032695215195417404,
-0.18856792151927948,
-0.5981746912002563,
0.6981242299079895,
-0.30730921030044556,
-0.27957189083099365,
0.3384072780609131,
0.24172498285770416,
-0.1739797592163086,
0.09036297351121902,
-0.8318228721618652,
0.05925360321998596,
-0.00901514571160078,
-0.3745601177215576,
0.5356519818305969,
0.6045315861701965,
-0.26356983184814453,
0.5635926127433777,
0.751504123210907,
0.08392281085252762,
0.05376124382019043,
-0.0017486403230577707,
0.7461506128311157,
-0.5461682677268982,
-0.5019053816795349,
-1.4917211532592773,
0.4138503968715668,
0.06740830838680267,
0.004596392158418894,
0.7659140825271606,
0.13355211913585663,
0.9194146990776062,
0.0726860761642456,
1.0255661010742188,
0.1888386756181717,
0.2445654422044754,
-0.8558816313743591,
0.8528981804847717,
-0.2928544580936432,
0.417097270488739,
-0.4242168366909027,
-0.8433786034584045,
-0.027153918519616127,
0.3159477114677429,
-0.057049769908189774,
0.04469076171517372,
0.4937494397163391,
0.7255118489265442,
0.11125780642032623,
-0.14921584725379944,
0.2501849830150604,
0.07868047803640366,
0.5706356763839722,
0.6833143830299377,
1.1190627813339233,
-0.3158951699733734,
0.5702483057975769,
0.051282647997140884,
-0.13123515248298645,
-0.17674562335014343,
-1.1900956630706787,
-1.080332636833191,
-0.5269594192504883,
-0.24281777441501617,
-0.6613619923591614,
-0.007471354212611914,
0.8302549719810486,
0.5108054280281067,
-0.8009787201881409,
-0.15132524073123932,
-0.1596229523420334,
0.20028747618198395,
-0.286486953496933,
-0.09311163425445557,
0.009817232377827168,
-0.31595346331596375,
-0.604819118976593,
0.35305318236351013,
0.3347031772136688,
0.6205382347106934,
-0.20769359171390533,
-0.1697675734758377,
-0.10130926221609116,
0.15008361637592316,
0.23264624178409576,
0.41905659437179565,
-0.7811943292617798,
-0.28879404067993164,
-0.16772060096263885,
-0.3935726583003998,
-0.009474219754338264,
0.8494354486465454,
-0.5312991738319397,
0.2641241252422333,
0.6924594640731812,
0.5443983674049377,
0.01244520116597414,
0.16015203297138214,
0.8704309463500977,
-0.7290717363357544,
-0.020201409235596657,
-0.0033996787387877703,
0.2840137779712677,
0.0005900851683691144,
-0.6542757153511047,
0.37212350964546204,
-0.061277974396944046,
-0.6862663626670837,
-0.8152219653129578,
0.561726987361908,
-0.6066423058509827,
-0.3289811909198761,
1.1313127279281616,
-0.039564915001392365,
-0.3672253489494324,
-0.24565885961055756,
-0.4077715277671814,
0.14429961144924164,
-0.31179192662239075,
0.8525279760360718,
1.0491039752960205,
-0.0991223081946373,
0.0216837078332901,
-0.2950649857521057,
0.79817134141922,
0.5462242364883423,
-0.6911460757255554,
0.48204848170280457,
0.3979637324810028,
0.5400505661964417,
-0.01644427888095379,
0.6577361226081848,
-0.27140089869499207,
0.09970076382160187,
-0.4843991696834564,
-0.21517343819141388,
-0.1718607246875763,
-0.4023967385292053,
-0.5957605242729187,
-0.10027977079153061,
0.3626765310764313,
-0.038933273404836655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11278v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11278v1 | Do Not Design, Learn: A Trainable Scoring Function for Uncertainty Estimation in Generative LLMs | 2024-06-17T07:30:40 | 2024-06-17T07:30:40 | Duygu Nur Yaldiz, Yavuz Faruk Bakman, Baturalp Buyukates, Chenyang Tao, Anil Ramakrishna, Dimitrios Dimitriadis, Salman Avestimehr | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we introduce the Learnable Response Scoring Function (LARS) for
Uncertainty Estimation (UE) in generative Large Language Models (LLMs). Current
scoring functions for probability-based UE, such as length-normalized scoring
and semantic contribution-based weighting, are designed to solve specific
aspects of the problem but exhibit limitations, including the inability to
handle biased probabilities and under-performance in low-resource languages
like Turkish. To address these issues, we propose LARS, a scoring function that
leverages supervised data to capture complex dependencies between tokens and
probabilities, thereby producing more reliable and calibrated response scores
in computing the uncertainty of generations. Our extensive experiments across
multiple datasets show that LARS substantially outperforms existing scoring
functions considering various probability-based UE methods. | [
-0.41791364550590515,
-0.6524320840835571,
0.6525474786758423,
0.2639380097389221,
-0.33201703429222107,
0.021705346181988716,
-0.281587690114975,
-0.24061408638954163,
0.13563387095928192,
0.12247955054044724,
-0.5755642056465149,
-0.7083450555801392,
-0.5774458646774292,
-0.14667755365371704,
-0.1332044005393982,
0.7541133761405945,
-0.05023568868637085,
0.20959874987602234,
-0.3245386779308319,
0.17093732953071594,
-0.022888872772455215,
-0.16983245313167572,
-0.7602016925811768,
-0.03467192128300667,
0.78726726770401,
0.46691057085990906,
0.38979578018188477,
0.33783242106437683,
0.5365613698959351,
0.20823241770267487,
-0.10480084270238876,
-0.03682015836238861,
-0.3289147913455963,
0.5429347157478333,
-0.12307315319776535,
-0.7208490371704102,
-0.5213454961776733,
-0.2365916669368744,
0.7306978106498718,
0.797865092754364,
-0.2642308473587036,
0.45807355642318726,
0.2699964940547943,
0.7430949807167053,
-0.8030945658683777,
0.3720487356185913,
-0.5968538522720337,
0.2721264064311981,
-0.12593285739421844,
-0.14503730833530426,
-0.6164556741714478,
-0.3493424355983734,
-0.06465304642915726,
-0.6346198320388794,
0.2548951208591461,
-0.00015710262232460082,
0.34640684723854065,
0.3089541494846344,
-0.20329581201076508,
-0.20061612129211426,
-0.7912048697471619,
1.187765121459961,
-0.6317064166069031,
0.28784307837486267,
0.5934455394744873,
0.36865854263305664,
-0.4182206690311432,
-0.5214094519615173,
-0.33133578300476074,
-0.10158131271600723,
0.3334329426288605,
0.12554721534252167,
0.0430634468793869,
0.28311270475387573,
0.19074146449565887,
0.17181611061096191,
-0.587425172328949,
0.29068291187286377,
-0.35114583373069763,
-0.19426776468753815,
0.9555397629737854,
0.22774146497249603,
-0.15788814425468445,
-0.13416734337806702,
-0.5277621746063232,
-0.3511202335357666,
-0.701734721660614,
0.14035798609256744,
0.7895249128341675,
0.6499651670455933,
-0.08635234832763672,
0.49701330065727234,
-0.17174674570560455,
0.8367314338684082,
-0.0024426807649433613,
-0.07777760177850723,
0.16140209138393402,
0.29128357768058777,
-0.36038073897361755,
-0.371539831161499,
0.9414125084877014,
0.10944417119026184,
0.2652412950992584,
-0.12270806729793549,
-0.35284948348999023,
-0.3241768181324005,
0.4394890367984772,
-0.37874582409858704,
-0.4415474236011505,
0.33748066425323486,
-0.3345646262168884,
-0.5048847198486328,
0.005696603562682867,
-1.1706395149230957,
-0.47603484988212585,
0.014264898374676704,
0.2962474226951599,
-0.4893345236778259,
-0.09270768612623215,
-0.23167598247528076,
-0.010966649278998375,
0.2903408706188202,
0.335781455039978,
-0.8596572279930115,
0.14795753359794617,
0.22315560281276703,
0.407631516456604,
-0.14586141705513,
-0.05352667719125748,
-0.5771923661231995,
-0.08102532476186752,
-0.7632047533988953,
0.633476197719574,
-0.515926718711853,
-0.6142358183860779,
0.02870579995214939,
-0.44537588953971863,
-0.21548815071582794,
-0.3014330267906189,
0.9151245951652527,
-0.7188767194747925,
0.3303051292896271,
-0.2908245921134949,
-0.6199604272842407,
-0.3780319392681122,
-0.017715780064463615,
-0.5576431155204773,
0.9214079976081848,
0.5539900064468384,
-0.7138662934303284,
0.800082266330719,
-0.6291263699531555,
-0.39490434527397156,
0.41803842782974243,
-0.1460663229227066,
-0.5204019546508789,
0.2964918911457062,
0.09420370310544968,
0.7236640453338623,
-0.09275144338607788,
0.1373322755098343,
-0.8850021958351135,
-0.4037542939186096,
0.2558271586894989,
-0.8532925248146057,
0.6025927662849426,
0.4401025176048279,
0.03068075329065323,
0.1484512835741043,
-0.8373042345046997,
0.5811572670936584,
-0.08341090381145477,
-0.8312158584594727,
-0.042471278458833694,
0.3990655839443207,
0.23952171206474304,
0.18015636503696442,
0.10964863002300262,
-0.6327210068702698,
-0.12212537229061127,
-0.16877023875713348,
-0.007180730812251568,
0.8847814798355103,
-0.12642936408519745,
0.29692551493644714,
-0.4088187515735626,
0.798466682434082,
-0.003921680152416229,
0.12499295920133591,
0.3546334207057953,
-0.3993256688117981,
-0.6239486336708069,
-0.6391842365264893,
0.744574785232544,
0.49111947417259216,
-0.8714516162872314,
0.6627334952354431,
-0.32499417662620544,
-0.4228682518005371,
-0.7077812552452087,
0.3728507161140442,
0.3328038156032562,
0.2557777762413025,
0.30630579590797424,
-0.3833170235157013,
-0.7051236033439636,
-0.7382062673568726,
-0.2627657353878021,
-0.6089316010475159,
-0.48223239183425903,
0.20221346616744995,
0.19142937660217285,
0.34088435769081116,
0.8503034710884094,
-0.48507940769195557,
-0.399042010307312,
-0.3898126184940338,
0.22826462984085083,
0.13902118802070618,
0.3543095588684082,
0.5690752267837524,
-0.796205461025238,
-0.4932342767715454,
-0.21993952989578247,
-0.8487613201141357,
0.11956840008497238,
0.1027798056602478,
0.45555979013442993,
0.45488211512565613,
0.35865646600723267,
-0.6712352633476257,
0.278963565826416,
0.5482231378555298,
-0.18541280925273895,
0.4712112843990326,
-0.221024751663208,
0.23827143013477325,
-1.0551892518997192,
0.07188371568918228,
0.18033432960510254,
-0.24883770942687988,
-0.3452089726924896,
0.18353797495365143,
0.025027917698025703,
0.4266883432865143,
-0.5148952603340149,
0.3084729313850403,
-0.3013107180595398,
0.022990526631474495,
0.12440235912799835,
-0.325240820646286,
-0.3217814266681671,
0.4163800776004791,
-0.06791386753320694,
0.70977783203125,
0.4457886517047882,
-0.685721755027771,
0.27202069759368896,
0.06154637038707733,
-0.8189793229103088,
0.841850757598877,
-0.3935687243938446,
0.016582539305090904,
-0.417422890663147,
-0.04551471024751663,
-1.016516923904419,
-0.5631223320960999,
0.2722831964492798,
-0.7773071527481079,
0.7990677356719971,
-0.4302726089954376,
-0.4502634108066559,
-0.41723114252090454,
-0.42369475960731506,
0.11541195213794708,
0.5680088400840759,
-0.38013970851898193,
0.5511320233345032,
0.19578048586845398,
-0.3493020832538605,
-0.8225315809249878,
-0.5760896801948547,
-0.05633477866649628,
-0.5581173300743103,
-0.4421765208244324,
0.01857367530465126,
-0.16208197176456451,
-0.18938559293746948,
-0.08689793199300766,
-0.04833121597766876,
-0.08943687379360199,
0.4871152639389038,
0.20701928436756134,
0.16617175936698914,
-0.23103393614292145,
0.4003881514072418,
0.10347814112901688,
0.018533317372202873,
0.13734567165374756,
-0.1500275582075119,
0.5318886041641235,
0.2806788384914398,
-0.44021540880203247,
-0.10000986605882645,
0.41821521520614624,
0.44166815280914307,
0.16860325634479523,
0.8267070651054382,
0.5931431651115417,
-0.34209662675857544,
-0.7514563202857971,
-0.25198686122894287,
0.037666864693164825,
-0.45927900075912476,
0.6976796984672546,
-0.5671838521957397,
-0.8470550179481506,
0.44577059149742126,
0.20060019195079803,
0.04922761395573616,
0.5903921127319336,
0.5823007822036743,
-0.8695389628410339,
0.8812690377235413,
0.5490139126777649,
0.015521115623414516,
0.39002835750579834,
0.10541622340679169,
0.13409404456615448,
-0.7685598134994507,
-0.23431725800037384,
-0.3874838054180145,
-0.357674241065979,
-0.6961827278137207,
-0.397649347782135,
0.4489766061306,
0.2462112307548523,
-0.26540276408195496,
0.13558346033096313,
-0.07447510212659836,
0.29517585039138794,
0.5365778207778931,
-0.13256150484085083,
-0.07195945829153061,
0.11727217584848404,
-0.15209056437015533,
-0.060328409075737,
-0.6961643695831299,
-0.32448503375053406,
1.5540452003479004,
0.48349153995513916,
1.1012775897979736,
0.2625192403793335,
0.8890869617462158,
0.6554533243179321,
0.3912651240825653,
-0.7975338697433472,
0.38461941480636597,
-0.12250962108373642,
-0.6511912941932678,
-0.7487162351608276,
-0.8678797483444214,
-0.8510600328445435,
0.28427061438560486,
-0.163289874792099,
-0.9565735459327698,
0.08914779126644135,
0.09836266934871674,
-0.44355642795562744,
0.47310271859169006,
-0.7482256889343262,
0.33182013034820557,
0.10818906873464584,
-0.26121118664741516,
0.15361706912517548,
-0.5674570202827454,
0.2816969156265259,
-0.36492806673049927,
0.36326760053634644,
-0.13521358370780945,
0.18735864758491516,
0.9090632796287537,
0.049190059304237366,
1.065909504890442,
-0.4094482660293579,
-0.2501276433467865,
0.21381765604019165,
0.26784929633140564,
0.3658336400985718,
0.011174006387591362,
-0.3187313675880432,
-0.1384212076663971,
0.14019179344177246,
-0.516625702381134,
-0.5216177701950073,
0.7685006856918335,
-0.5643143057823181,
-0.6041430234909058,
-0.3821124732494354,
-0.5165867209434509,
-0.4505552649497986,
0.06243785843253136,
0.4899151921272278,
-0.18085052073001862,
-0.4417465329170227,
0.06344550102949142,
0.7760847210884094,
0.032727863639593124,
0.6250837445259094,
0.37910327315330505,
0.02441919595003128,
-0.6373413801193237,
0.9551023244857788,
0.3078799843788147,
0.2752102315425873,
0.33139875531196594,
-0.20186226069927216,
-0.47674447298049927,
-0.507402777671814,
-0.5911024212837219,
-0.15392637252807617,
-0.7519914507865906,
-0.4288647472858429,
-0.09587675333023071,
-0.21339087188243866,
-0.23079003393650055,
-0.14424577355384827,
-0.18122556805610657,
-0.5784104466438293,
-0.2865307629108429,
-0.41713905334472656,
0.12223204970359802,
0.8047162890434265,
-0.2261190414428711,
0.3340252935886383,
-0.5412887930870056,
-0.086480513215065,
0.2043270617723465,
0.7777842879295349,
-0.21369501948356628,
-0.6409715414047241,
-0.011050584726035595,
0.06902895867824554,
-0.4117946922779083,
-0.6070680618286133,
0.25943541526794434,
0.3878729045391083,
0.7789778113365173,
0.42014163732528687,
0.41298630833625793,
0.1517382264137268,
-0.12073009461164474,
0.6684320569038391,
0.163100004196167,
-0.7863233089447021,
0.2894369959831238,
-0.3846224844455719,
-0.07899566739797592,
0.5292418003082275,
0.39803314208984375,
-0.22430738806724548,
-0.0877658799290657,
-0.5103580951690674,
-1.021864891052246,
0.756583034992218,
0.07354535162448883,
0.41030263900756836,
0.15921033918857574,
0.2809917628765106,
0.11881458014249802,
0.20503385365009308,
-0.5945450663566589,
-0.2831728756427765,
0.29345446825027466,
-0.6252074837684631,
-0.37485188245773315,
-0.5373799800872803,
-0.16769860684871674,
-0.10645239055156708,
0.7823441028594971,
-0.310004323720932,
0.22344721853733063,
-0.11309054493904114,
-0.11316104978322983,
-0.5962910056114197,
0.44703009724617004,
0.49894917011260986,
0.40331342816352844,
-0.4782424569129944,
0.0949430987238884,
0.3554382622241974,
-0.41325026750564575,
0.17122721672058105,
0.15544532239437103,
-0.18166622519493103,
-0.2149910032749176,
0.7393792867660522,
0.7202945351600647,
0.04701042175292969,
-0.499468058347702,
0.5406460762023926,
-0.004586605820804834,
-0.48192504048347473,
-0.5727489590644836,
0.17855514585971832,
0.03437236696481705,
0.13405480980873108,
0.29454272985458374,
0.09002816677093506,
0.01459820568561554,
-0.07787373661994934,
0.3507882356643677,
0.4264928102493286,
-0.8786318898200989,
-0.33656543493270874,
0.691178560256958,
0.026577457785606384,
-0.16398940980434418,
0.6420254111289978,
-0.2603287100791931,
-0.23472264409065247,
0.44434213638305664,
0.40834861993789673,
0.8698222637176514,
-0.5556192398071289,
0.7227498888969421,
0.23487038910388947,
0.25755491852760315,
0.14943136274814606,
0.7746912240982056,
-0.2079022377729416,
-0.7326558828353882,
-0.5369364023208618,
-1.107309341430664,
-0.17927908897399902,
0.01889406144618988,
-0.9234080910682678,
0.011610101908445358,
-0.49729838967323303,
-0.3599311411380768,
-0.14604789018630981,
-0.09186013042926788,
-0.7263854146003723,
0.5907575488090515,
0.263362318277359,
0.9466795325279236,
-1.0028945207595825,
0.6678299307823181,
0.7176457643508911,
-0.3601479232311249,
-0.5619934797286987,
0.04876996949315071,
-0.11545293778181076,
-0.6947726011276245,
0.6244442462921143,
-0.30426082015037537,
-0.01660640351474285,
-0.033113133162260056,
-0.6829344034194946,
-0.8951352834701538,
0.8563750982284546,
0.5032870173454285,
-0.28142672777175903,
0.047619227319955826,
0.28243330121040344,
0.5869359970092773,
-0.07309826463460922,
0.1825495809316635,
0.4077654182910919,
0.38409414887428284,
0.1586315631866455,
-0.5375918745994568,
-0.19350118935108185,
0.0062471553683280945,
0.04003368318080902,
0.4020601212978363,
-0.399655818939209,
0.6027705073356628,
-0.4351792335510254,
-0.1922844648361206,
0.21614769101142883,
0.6774999499320984,
0.06658140569925308,
0.09078040719032288,
0.4319418668746948,
0.776496946811676,
0.7853597402572632,
-0.12874078750610352,
1.0598703622817993,
-0.0029912255704402924,
0.6677197813987732,
0.9837706685066223,
-0.14277689158916473,
1.1793198585510254,
0.7153533697128296,
-0.7542051672935486,
0.36175230145454407,
0.7728821635246277,
0.06806235760450363,
0.630276620388031,
0.7055203914642334,
-0.557893693447113,
-0.7215993404388428,
0.2338576763868332,
0.04040632024407387,
0.543962836265564,
0.5996302366256714,
-0.5387016534805298,
-0.17509382963180542,
-0.40998682379722595,
-0.006847296841442585,
-0.015626555308699608,
-0.013652948662638664,
0.8001599311828613,
0.36519232392311096,
-0.46626749634742737,
0.4513499140739441,
0.07160647958517075,
0.3871261179447174,
-0.7586853504180908,
0.019673138856887817,
-0.017514875158667564,
0.20908266305923462,
-0.20795994997024536,
-1.1136640310287476,
0.21707002818584442,
-0.18397293984889984,
-0.29962700605392456,
0.15405598282814026,
0.26404067873954773,
-0.3504880666732788,
-0.7211636304855347,
0.41940921545028687,
0.47429877519607544,
0.022129423916339874,
0.184859961271286,
-0.3194362223148346,
-0.13589653372764587,
-0.06751732528209686,
-0.4390568435192108,
0.5488607287406921,
0.12913201749324799,
-0.054039642214775085,
1.0267183780670166,
0.5759953260421753,
0.0032996966037899256,
-0.05923564359545708,
-0.25505131483078003,
0.4712904691696167,
-0.3642953634262085,
-0.099007248878479,
-0.6647810339927673,
0.5250357985496521,
0.07570435851812363,
-0.5562705993652344,
0.40944617986679077,
0.3562254309654236,
0.9422681927680969,
-0.4036915600299835,
1.0886585712432861,
-0.2334103137254715,
0.5875224471092224,
-0.5905037522315979,
0.8828003406524658,
-0.47708114981651306,
0.36938318610191345,
-0.20518478751182556,
-1.048324704170227,
-0.6810989379882812,
0.5383576154708862,
-0.3273168206214905,
0.39096975326538086,
0.21057577431201935,
0.5165491104125977,
0.09428855031728745,
-0.17605067789554596,
0.8733556270599365,
0.07939007133245468,
0.2144232988357544,
0.6944746375083923,
0.7859514355659485,
-0.2783164978027344,
0.2329874485731125,
-0.15819329023361206,
-0.2755826711654663,
-0.021014254540205002,
-0.7754355669021606,
-0.7847299575805664,
-0.7330083847045898,
-0.15734301507472992,
-0.2627469003200531,
0.14291609823703766,
1.0476644039154053,
0.5812364816665649,
-1.2316038608551025,
-0.06805447489023209,
0.18194466829299927,
0.23085089027881622,
-0.23770534992218018,
-0.2325187474489212,
0.6281663179397583,
-0.6814091205596924,
-0.6793032884597778,
0.46864721179008484,
-0.0035130279138684273,
0.00527025805786252,
-0.17801260948181152,
-0.1447770893573761,
0.14690648019313812,
0.20248806476593018,
0.35637667775154114,
0.3043476343154907,
-0.5585921406745911,
-0.497691810131073,
-0.2675640881061554,
0.03436226025223732,
-0.10245635360479355,
0.25696006417274475,
-0.52818363904953,
0.5060226917266846,
0.4871096909046173,
0.394584983587265,
0.2296995371580124,
-0.16222664713859558,
0.8589897751808167,
-0.9197683334350586,
-0.3917791545391083,
0.32285431027412415,
0.4282293915748596,
0.5142852067947388,
-0.3157407343387604,
0.35859665274620056,
0.1288747489452362,
-0.29825982451438904,
-0.7119207382202148,
0.5063173770904541,
-0.8036239147186279,
-0.08970179408788681,
1.0837583541870117,
-0.5955653786659241,
-0.05331069231033325,
-0.30516254901885986,
0.1497943103313446,
0.06048809736967087,
-0.2611524760723114,
0.9726499319076538,
0.7172155380249023,
0.1400066465139389,
-0.0879160463809967,
-0.4164849519729614,
0.6999762654304504,
0.37742865085601807,
-0.45503881573677063,
-0.047246962785720825,
0.18624070286750793,
0.67977374792099,
-0.11544689536094666,
0.3239876627922058,
-0.08941033482551575,
0.28263384103775024,
0.11641962826251984,
0.26716744899749756,
0.12710024416446686,
-0.46632012724876404,
-0.44373905658721924,
0.5239666700363159,
0.5296238660812378,
-0.3843703269958496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11277v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11277v1 | Small Agent Can Also Rock! Empowering Small Language Models as Hallucination Detector | 2024-06-17T07:30:05 | 2024-06-17T07:30:05 | Xiaoxue Cheng, Junyi Li, Wayne Xin Zhao, Hongzhi Zhang, Fuzheng Zhang, Di Zhang, Kun Gai, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Hallucination detection is a challenging task for large language models
(LLMs), and existing studies heavily rely on powerful closed-source LLMs such
as GPT-4. In this paper, we propose an autonomous LLM-based agent framework,
called HaluAgent, which enables relatively smaller LLMs (e.g. Baichuan2-Chat
7B) to actively select suitable tools for detecting multiple hallucination
types such as text, code, and mathematical expression. In HaluAgent, we
integrate the LLM, multi-functional toolbox, and design a fine-grained
three-stage detection framework along with memory mechanism. To facilitate the
effectiveness of HaluAgent, we leverage existing Chinese and English datasets
to synthesize detection trajectories for fine-tuning, which endows HaluAgent
with the capability for bilingual hallucination detection. Extensive
experiments demonstrate that only using 2K samples for tuning LLMs, HaluAgent
can perform hallucination detection on various types of tasks and datasets,
achieving performance comparable to or even higher than GPT-4 without tool
enhancements on both in-domain and out-of-domain datasets. We release our
dataset and code at https://github.com/RUCAIBox/HaluAgent. | [
-0.411411851644516,
-0.8540773391723633,
0.7427719831466675,
0.22721952199935913,
-0.1738254874944687,
-0.22571074962615967,
-0.5215839147567749,
-0.5639722347259521,
0.3902721703052521,
0.5120627880096436,
-0.48134854435920715,
-0.5284742712974548,
-0.34248894453048706,
0.28119826316833496,
-0.26687201857566833,
0.7165740728378296,
0.1368623822927475,
-0.03345745429396629,
0.2080075591802597,
-0.26486334204673767,
-0.7014361023902893,
-0.25732144713401794,
-0.8866140246391296,
-0.705637514591217,
0.49675440788269043,
0.47156208753585815,
0.8436155319213867,
0.604458749294281,
0.019921552389860153,
0.2759418785572052,
0.3314417004585266,
0.37790003418922424,
-0.3502819836139679,
0.06913746148347855,
0.09737912565469742,
-0.5387341976165771,
-0.6463455557823181,
-0.3289460837841034,
0.32566404342651367,
0.43766510486602783,
-0.15655291080474854,
-0.12875132262706757,
0.19673584401607513,
0.3989274203777313,
-0.33292829990386963,
0.4127748906612396,
-0.7694494724273682,
0.030814414843916893,
-0.3466808795928955,
-0.05764629691839218,
-0.4417344629764557,
-0.22662559151649475,
-0.4768965244293213,
-0.29704922437667847,
0.3042711913585663,
0.10121648013591766,
0.4085063934326172,
0.6431868672370911,
-0.2543436586856842,
-0.6413374543190002,
-0.5752173066139221,
0.7020173668861389,
-0.7174193859100342,
0.42471879720687866,
0.6379274725914001,
0.42127200961112976,
-0.22791486978530884,
-0.5770094394683838,
-0.6953756213188171,
-0.4254276752471924,
-0.3441280126571655,
-0.29404008388519287,
-0.11919219046831131,
-0.021809112280607224,
0.012805582024157047,
0.36596399545669556,
-0.8991671800613403,
0.24263536930084229,
0.07356612384319305,
-0.43349432945251465,
0.3064097464084625,
0.12655018270015717,
0.2930638790130615,
-0.24446134269237518,
0.20283906161785126,
0.048873528838157654,
-0.6435326337814331,
-0.38075682520866394,
0.13896344602108002,
0.6663874983787537,
0.02289246767759323,
0.3101044297218323,
0.031802162528038025,
0.3046101927757263,
-0.08413732796907425,
-0.137923002243042,
0.25232192873954773,
0.023955844342708588,
-0.11388931423425674,
0.3902650475502014,
0.8629463315010071,
-0.23827382922172546,
0.07232754677534103,
-0.17562150955200195,
-0.628890335559845,
0.0797019675374031,
0.06841107457876205,
-0.8630200624465942,
-0.486766517162323,
0.24202315509319305,
-0.5333474278450012,
-0.2092355191707611,
-0.049615174531936646,
-0.6010633707046509,
-0.6870158910751343,
-0.1560249924659729,
0.5623435974121094,
-0.3295341730117798,
-0.41642263531684875,
0.15659157931804657,
0.33103758096694946,
0.11278899759054184,
0.04801466315984726,
-1.0187194347381592,
0.34991443157196045,
0.7391912341117859,
1.0518001317977905,
-0.3346761167049408,
-0.5303549766540527,
-0.854218065738678,
0.04947436600923538,
-0.5563286542892456,
0.8490400314331055,
-0.2307329922914505,
-0.39383429288864136,
0.10200876742601395,
0.3668167293071747,
0.04328126087784767,
-0.8355589509010315,
0.3967769145965576,
-0.15809744596481323,
-0.03949632868170738,
-0.11009123176336288,
-0.07215340435504913,
-0.2854345440864563,
0.09807469695806503,
-1.0976873636245728,
1.0068095922470093,
0.0025788340717554092,
-0.28009238839149475,
0.19387811422348022,
-0.5317662358283997,
-0.6320745944976807,
0.2385445386171341,
-0.5826574563980103,
-0.49179619550704956,
0.17006690800189972,
0.20624405145645142,
0.3981536626815796,
-0.19513022899627686,
0.21207363903522491,
-0.29212042689323425,
-0.669288158416748,
0.11415120959281921,
-0.4332149624824524,
0.47335758805274963,
-0.0732133537530899,
-0.8113964796066284,
0.32255879044532776,
-0.5739454627037048,
-0.35144391655921936,
0.12106641381978989,
-0.13542433083057404,
-0.11162921041250229,
-0.014055202715098858,
-0.04947289451956749,
0.11868992447853088,
0.1923595368862152,
-0.17459101974964142,
0.012098248116672039,
-0.3650616407394409,
0.1758003830909729,
0.7038033604621887,
-0.07329517602920532,
0.39123690128326416,
-0.522915244102478,
0.5586150288581848,
-0.2512246370315552,
0.003611068008467555,
0.3571785092353821,
-0.526388943195343,
-0.97882479429245,
-0.44442591071128845,
-0.06756706535816193,
0.24173955619335175,
-1.0465142726898193,
0.5054247379302979,
-0.22988609969615936,
-0.39685219526290894,
-0.6218745708465576,
0.3536684513092041,
0.2805039882659912,
0.055363476276397705,
0.3522724211215973,
0.15982824563980103,
-0.4118422567844391,
-0.8517817258834839,
-0.06488695740699768,
-0.21468296647071838,
-0.14209753274917603,
0.26543742418289185,
0.6697400808334351,
-0.516602635383606,
0.6157143712043762,
-0.26599550247192383,
-1.089375615119934,
-0.3230217397212982,
0.1755540370941162,
0.3370729684829712,
0.2767392694950104,
0.4134264588356018,
-0.5798432230949402,
-0.46722784638404846,
0.42864012718200684,
-0.9362404942512512,
-0.2993727922439575,
-0.19426746666431427,
0.00036185033968649805,
0.5368439555168152,
0.4904819428920746,
-0.635404646396637,
0.32426005601882935,
0.4100746512413025,
-0.11534309387207031,
0.47189784049987793,
-0.07624344527721405,
0.05359414219856262,
-0.7487640380859375,
-0.1785048395395279,
-0.4174308180809021,
-0.4610839784145355,
-0.7294991612434387,
-0.012291383929550648,
0.01611696183681488,
0.21168489754199982,
-0.3663800060749054,
0.5851503014564514,
-0.5558707118034363,
-0.21996623277664185,
-0.8468172550201416,
0.20173336565494537,
-0.3605627715587616,
0.5178083777427673,
0.2055063396692276,
0.7017770409584045,
0.49608859419822693,
-0.6070627570152283,
0.299091100692749,
0.13776172697544098,
-0.15428459644317627,
0.0325048454105854,
-0.4257981479167938,
0.2866528332233429,
0.24403835833072662,
0.1650945395231247,
-0.47082552313804626,
-0.3529787063598633,
0.632785439491272,
-0.4068222939968109,
0.004503184463828802,
-0.046670448035001755,
-0.8932268023490906,
-0.17702631652355194,
-0.33691275119781494,
0.3324736952781677,
0.43815329670906067,
-0.9321499466896057,
1.0481804609298706,
0.2511223554611206,
0.006919201463460922,
-0.2936970591545105,
-1.0261598825454712,
0.08506890386343002,
-0.2789953947067261,
-0.46161597967147827,
0.1211765930056572,
-0.261462926864624,
-0.18932975828647614,
-0.04312128573656082,
-0.1593770533800125,
0.1862790435552597,
0.053981006145477295,
0.4224432408809662,
-0.008404419757425785,
-0.3160896599292755,
0.2845061719417572,
0.24428939819335938,
-0.18705295026302338,
0.007622220553457737,
-0.35855451226234436,
0.990719199180603,
-0.6501474380493164,
-0.42913389205932617,
-0.19340962171554565,
0.2427487075328827,
0.39525794982910156,
0.20013825595378876,
0.5179889798164368,
0.8208137154579163,
-0.8896659016609192,
-0.7073565125465393,
-0.4187902510166168,
-0.6327586770057678,
-0.5716105699539185,
0.08605862408876419,
-0.7253872752189636,
-0.9325919151306152,
0.5293776392936707,
0.38819366693496704,
-0.21014533936977386,
0.21432247757911682,
1.186607003211975,
0.605606198310852,
1.0126323699951172,
0.5473707914352417,
-0.21516074240207672,
0.08875622600317001,
0.029242321848869324,
0.31824004650115967,
-0.3299958109855652,
0.08444008231163025,
-0.23446528613567352,
-0.03500226140022278,
-0.5313844084739685,
-0.4858284890651703,
0.3716478943824768,
-0.20887324213981628,
0.08397720009088516,
0.33069777488708496,
-0.7032386660575867,
0.5538065433502197,
0.15579913556575775,
0.0008475599461235106,
0.5047183036804199,
-0.09521553665399551,
0.10832753032445908,
0.09870892763137817,
-0.46525856852531433,
-0.6131640672683716,
0.6852455139160156,
0.3893209993839264,
0.7387518286705017,
0.3899153470993042,
0.9804420471191406,
0.49606865644454956,
0.3765503466129303,
-1.0089075565338135,
0.7999041676521301,
-0.10408655554056168,
-0.5846802592277527,
-0.4190795123577118,
-0.34434372186660767,
-1.0105847120285034,
0.529285192489624,
0.021693259477615356,
-0.6669212579727173,
0.26238709688186646,
-0.06804540753364563,
-0.3253762423992157,
0.1712186336517334,
-0.3486522436141968,
0.7307354807853699,
-0.1392216980457306,
-0.2631685137748718,
-0.23666560649871826,
-0.20612183213233948,
0.6005270481109619,
-0.42659276723861694,
0.4809221923351288,
-0.14816142618656158,
0.03954607993364334,
0.5883374214172363,
-0.3586444556713104,
1.0094472169876099,
-0.17276529967784882,
-0.33527153730392456,
0.25979170203208923,
0.48944091796875,
0.48543453216552734,
0.27054381370544434,
0.12256182730197906,
0.25268426537513733,
-0.08669993281364441,
-0.1858726292848587,
-0.5062227845191956,
1.0526297092437744,
-0.5578647255897522,
-0.5964739918708801,
-0.48756277561187744,
-0.6100802421569824,
0.1227397546172142,
0.3957734704017639,
0.18834905326366425,
0.09006013721227646,
-0.012671870179474354,
0.0939716100692749,
0.46893399953842163,
0.1369020938873291,
0.5529223084449768,
0.49929752945899963,
-0.6345707178115845,
-0.20812784135341644,
1.3909990787506104,
-0.19004885852336884,
-0.10442302376031876,
0.06716570258140564,
0.35806557536125183,
-0.17318181693553925,
-0.5859891772270203,
-0.2627282440662384,
0.5701661705970764,
-0.8659602403640747,
-0.17014554142951965,
-0.7146376967430115,
-0.2044406682252884,
-0.5706055164337158,
0.003941881470382214,
-0.4575003683567047,
-0.016001194715499878,
-0.36123690009117126,
-0.0024527672212570906,
0.2860032916069031,
0.6902775168418884,
-0.4703896939754486,
0.38234207034111023,
-0.55058354139328,
0.6641368865966797,
0.36871564388275146,
-0.0020757452584803104,
-0.012574449181556702,
-0.4359596073627472,
-0.4196392595767975,
-0.15128597617149353,
-0.0012212317669764161,
-0.6911128759384155,
0.6267426013946533,
0.1431160569190979,
0.5209931135177612,
0.6343234181404114,
0.053071536123752594,
0.4115757644176483,
-0.32482901215553284,
0.7455913424491882,
-0.2016683965921402,
-1.0334081649780273,
0.3164483308792114,
-0.19105133414268494,
-0.06011878699064255,
0.6114742159843445,
0.19497451186180115,
-0.3494274318218231,
-0.5699585676193237,
-0.11127158999443054,
-0.4016018509864807,
0.6587169766426086,
0.36392349004745483,
-0.22806061804294586,
0.001936245011165738,
0.1803601235151291,
0.5345178246498108,
0.13882455229759216,
-1.2049355506896973,
0.03632780537009239,
-0.1591131091117859,
-0.23343448340892792,
-0.11157902330160141,
0.12643831968307495,
-0.18565355241298676,
-0.06760651618242264,
0.8137123584747314,
-0.5009400248527527,
0.261149138212204,
-0.02190394513309002,
-0.4977179169654846,
-0.04408447816967964,
0.03244582191109657,
0.5102900266647339,
0.18122218549251556,
-0.24241496622562408,
0.43759551644325256,
0.1932075470685959,
-0.5014902949333191,
0.11101584881544113,
0.19203020632266998,
-0.03768414631485939,
0.19705355167388916,
0.5163422226905823,
0.6109165549278259,
0.0435870997607708,
-0.6956340670585632,
0.5162037014961243,
-0.20449605584144592,
-0.24505078792572021,
-0.6916826367378235,
0.1513097584247589,
-0.10150035470724106,
0.5652143955230713,
0.3115435242652893,
-0.2591780424118042,
0.4143739938735962,
-0.47454318404197693,
0.3298841118812561,
0.29408854246139526,
-0.3846294581890106,
-0.41513970494270325,
0.7320532202720642,
-0.14928710460662842,
-0.5289981365203857,
0.273957759141922,
-0.6180452108383179,
-0.5379003882408142,
0.3711710572242737,
0.5078200101852417,
1.0589566230773926,
-0.2940737009048462,
0.22479048371315002,
-0.09570198506116867,
0.6576549410820007,
-0.2692420184612274,
0.1808207929134369,
-0.029043124988675117,
-0.9252250790596008,
-0.03762204572558403,
-0.5026183128356934,
-0.20029881596565247,
0.37608805298805237,
-0.43622803688049316,
0.32756662368774414,
-0.3493923842906952,
0.032709475606679916,
-0.1410093903541565,
-0.009589486755430698,
-0.5150970220565796,
-0.22547383606433868,
0.3778330683708191,
0.3560311794281006,
-0.886451244354248,
1.173669457435608,
0.39766833186149597,
-0.46764126420021057,
-0.40208131074905396,
0.29499414563179016,
0.2961292564868927,
-0.9173682928085327,
0.33059343695640564,
0.6046420335769653,
-0.4980771839618683,
-0.023973990231752396,
-0.32954052090644836,
-0.33654436469078064,
1.2604823112487793,
0.057603251188993454,
-0.3851742446422577,
-0.05440819263458252,
0.19521629810333252,
0.5027198791503906,
-0.6334416270256042,
-0.015250403434038162,
1.1681900024414062,
0.6161115169525146,
-0.18742163479328156,
-0.6701502799987793,
0.3540574312210083,
-0.11169026046991348,
-0.16303566098213196,
0.08280964195728302,
-0.5544813275337219,
0.8855481147766113,
0.09673794358968735,
-0.327027291059494,
0.3048849403858185,
0.8033170700073242,
0.5927286148071289,
0.4910023510456085,
0.842061460018158,
0.16297294199466705,
0.776648998260498,
0.07347644865512848,
0.7294409871101379,
-0.37889447808265686,
0.1136602833867073,
1.1234220266342163,
-0.36392292380332947,
0.5980374813079834,
0.34502384066581726,
0.19045501947402954,
0.5290418267250061,
0.6967571973800659,
-0.19818061590194702,
0.5207489728927612,
-0.008176198229193687,
-0.49703869223594666,
-0.3163225054740906,
-0.1217179149389267,
-0.19703298807144165,
0.2802472710609436,
0.6116598844528198,
0.03369595855474472,
-0.13245588541030884,
0.5449737906455994,
0.036874331533908844,
0.007802310399711132,
-0.10596997290849686,
0.5529890656471252,
0.336879163980484,
-0.46977439522743225,
0.7911010384559631,
-0.044044241309165955,
0.758303701877594,
-0.3716064393520355,
-0.0370524637401104,
-0.3990998864173889,
0.3954237699508667,
-0.2860451638698578,
-0.3786710798740387,
0.1834835261106491,
-0.3009994626045227,
0.06264307349920273,
0.14133597910404205,
0.9064318537712097,
-0.47371453046798706,
-0.23020677268505096,
0.7132759094238281,
0.6596473455429077,
0.5853567123413086,
-0.36034002900123596,
-0.47384968400001526,
0.2672860026359558,
-0.09913807362318039,
-0.12041439116001129,
0.17032355070114136,
0.562566339969635,
-0.14889350533485413,
0.6377760767936707,
0.5301002264022827,
0.1816502809524536,
-0.015584195964038372,
0.5058614015579224,
0.7887253165245056,
-0.5060570240020752,
-0.3188968002796173,
-0.8439141511917114,
0.015044302679598331,
0.09827126562595367,
0.1358785778284073,
0.7570250034332275,
0.5439348816871643,
0.5846844911575317,
-0.1911594122648239,
0.6841603517532349,
0.04014318063855171,
0.33868953585624695,
-0.5410263538360596,
0.9517084360122681,
-0.7009996175765991,
0.373274028301239,
0.12384562194347382,
-0.9213564991950989,
-0.39322665333747864,
0.6436036229133606,
-0.15121279656887054,
0.09798941761255264,
0.9650076031684875,
1.3779139518737793,
0.017314035445451736,
-0.010093639604747295,
0.6573544144630432,
0.4086250066757202,
0.595496416091919,
0.6038802862167358,
0.8820266127586365,
-0.20924775302410126,
0.6549823880195618,
-0.23615577816963196,
-0.3667764961719513,
-0.339719295501709,
-0.47865015268325806,
-1.411758542060852,
-0.639987051486969,
-0.08368539810180664,
-0.445709228515625,
-0.1905220001935959,
0.8897998929023743,
0.6067240238189697,
-0.8604699373245239,
-0.4071841239929199,
-0.209022656083107,
0.19812603294849396,
-0.2745717167854309,
-0.28449520468711853,
0.44139161705970764,
-0.3906576633453369,
-0.7797275185585022,
0.8055198788642883,
0.2190595418214798,
0.045593686401844025,
-0.5297854542732239,
-0.33368322253227234,
0.2126438468694687,
0.041892293840646744,
0.5986301898956299,
0.22187891602516174,
-0.9656098484992981,
-0.3511026203632355,
-0.07678361982107162,
-0.1880878359079361,
-0.03733189404010773,
0.8724616765975952,
-0.5700555443763733,
0.1491619348526001,
0.18846498429775238,
0.5061607956886292,
0.5634757280349731,
-0.5087957978248596,
0.1252298355102539,
-0.6340696215629578,
0.3833172917366028,
0.32860076427459717,
0.43247756361961365,
0.24938301742076874,
-0.5011700987815857,
0.602806568145752,
0.22122742235660553,
-0.7530071139335632,
-0.9342424273490906,
0.22476553916931152,
-0.9286643266677856,
-0.535719633102417,
1.2338730096817017,
0.4207322895526886,
-0.36852145195007324,
-0.24083231389522552,
-0.2592220902442932,
0.06362631916999817,
-0.48664194345474243,
0.8816499710083008,
0.6549332737922668,
-0.3473309278488159,
-0.26533976197242737,
-0.6717008948326111,
0.6766539216041565,
0.32381370663642883,
-0.91576087474823,
0.15590181946754456,
0.581108033657074,
-0.005713944789022207,
0.22876513004302979,
0.7988256216049194,
0.07724153250455856,
0.28963643312454224,
0.20922645926475525,
0.2790037989616394,
-0.12056450545787811,
-0.6055090427398682,
-0.5528647303581238,
-0.007233739830553532,
0.1503656655550003,
-0.17811810970306396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11275v1 | Self-training Large Language Models through Knowledge Detection | 2024-06-17T07:25:09 | 2024-06-17T07:25:09 | Wei Jie Yeo, Teddy Ferdinan, Przemyslaw Kazienko, Ranjan Satapathy, Erik Cambria | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) often necessitate extensive labeled datasets and
training compute to achieve impressive performance across downstream tasks.
This paper explores a self-training paradigm, where the LLM autonomously
curates its own labels and selectively trains on unknown data samples
identified through a reference-free consistency method. Empirical evaluations
demonstrate significant improvements in reducing hallucination in generation
across multiple subjects. Furthermore, the selective training framework
mitigates catastrophic forgetting in out-of-distribution benchmarks, addressing
a critical limitation in training LLMs. Our findings suggest that such an
approach can substantially reduce the dependency on large labeled datasets,
paving the way for more scalable and cost-effective language model training. | [
-0.2877645194530487,
-0.2005981057882309,
0.6842001676559448,
0.052913110703229904,
0.06297595798969269,
-0.1350088119506836,
-0.30661115050315857,
-0.33356964588165283,
0.1339263617992401,
0.8345608115196228,
-0.5194101333618164,
-0.3988107442855835,
-0.5992196202278137,
0.03640599176287651,
-0.45880600810050964,
0.7219035029411316,
-0.050709083676338196,
-0.07135960459709167,
-0.3011924922466278,
-0.2762605845928192,
-0.40305769443511963,
-0.6979023814201355,
-0.5587782263755798,
-0.5932784080505371,
0.533748984336853,
0.23042094707489014,
0.22251716256141663,
0.9561071991920471,
0.074618861079216,
0.23785655200481415,
0.289827823638916,
0.16361624002456665,
-0.6567949056625366,
0.3812086284160614,
-0.2109076976776123,
-0.46252691745758057,
0.05738937109708786,
-0.019017426297068596,
0.8460992574691772,
0.628423273563385,
-0.10946457087993622,
0.10884649306535721,
0.06603600829839706,
0.8728988766670227,
-0.7773870229721069,
0.21051132678985596,
-0.9838132858276367,
0.1569495052099228,
-0.24309466779232025,
0.025642596185207367,
-0.5894894003868103,
0.06260433048009872,
-0.19298644363880157,
-0.43453317880630493,
0.36414554715156555,
0.010921306908130646,
0.4708116948604584,
0.5913372039794922,
-0.2807607054710388,
-0.21535556018352509,
-0.7591673731803894,
0.745110809803009,
-0.3889257609844208,
0.9080050587654114,
0.7264629006385803,
0.29186683893203735,
-0.0722559317946434,
-0.39720848202705383,
-0.35959184169769287,
-0.160548597574234,
-0.028870200738310814,
0.010756020434200764,
-0.014982755295932293,
-0.11727415025234222,
0.1593681126832962,
0.2960427701473236,
-0.5968011021614075,
0.3233848512172699,
-0.18801367282867432,
-0.3273201584815979,
0.5449537634849548,
-0.12972606718540192,
-0.0007164382841438055,
0.08011172711849213,
-0.13223612308502197,
0.047652680426836014,
-0.820282518863678,
-0.5373488664627075,
0.3432132303714752,
0.261614054441452,
0.1460542529821396,
0.3624178469181061,
-0.4866509437561035,
0.6981157064437866,
0.03513052687048912,
-0.24948546290397644,
0.3160059452056885,
0.07698333263397217,
-0.21932540833950043,
0.08683895319700241,
0.8379803895950317,
-0.34777987003326416,
0.40192845463752747,
-0.539404571056366,
-0.4673107862472534,
-0.14201241731643677,
0.12495359778404236,
-0.6084672808647156,
-0.6499468684196472,
0.1324281096458435,
-0.27615875005722046,
-0.05874171480536461,
-0.44508445262908936,
-0.23706741631031036,
-0.5345746278762817,
-0.39180687069892883,
0.3827042281627655,
-0.4406072199344635,
-0.20079143345355988,
0.11097531765699387,
-0.00017264715279452503,
-0.00453301053494215,
0.17317262291908264,
-1.330141544342041,
0.10448025166988373,
0.3703386187553406,
0.5822537541389465,
-0.09228512644767761,
-0.2703950107097626,
-0.6941566467285156,
0.5493956804275513,
-0.43842199444770813,
0.9016686677932739,
-0.34695014357566833,
-0.08554595708847046,
-0.18135809898376465,
-0.19550548493862152,
-0.1682368367910385,
-0.9850443601608276,
0.07467306405305862,
-0.6104410886764526,
-0.19872502982616425,
-0.3412899374961853,
-0.8571246266365051,
0.01908794417977333,
0.2609100937843323,
-0.649846076965332,
1.0404120683670044,
0.3196067214012146,
-0.6035855412483215,
0.49041426181793213,
-0.04751968756318092,
-0.24495190382003784,
0.2100006490945816,
-0.45554617047309875,
-0.4747962951660156,
0.05789972469210625,
0.23725049197673798,
0.5946630835533142,
-0.12670370936393738,
0.5230323076248169,
-0.46928146481513977,
-0.2412995994091034,
0.1534823477268219,
-0.39966127276420593,
0.5031887292861938,
0.29403939843177795,
-0.30110543966293335,
-0.06318004429340363,
-0.9565721154212952,
-0.14775694906711578,
0.2099534571170807,
-0.426281213760376,
-0.5048539638519287,
0.023783501237630844,
-0.3941343128681183,
0.19748294353485107,
0.16886959969997406,
-0.2829376459121704,
0.17767098546028137,
-0.29863032698631287,
0.13371379673480988,
0.8530920743942261,
-0.17726710438728333,
0.4270099699497223,
-0.2425430566072464,
0.3629266917705536,
0.11567756533622742,
0.009651766158640385,
-0.15464915335178375,
-0.08989651501178741,
-1.2300931215286255,
-0.42117956280708313,
0.1307613104581833,
0.28423011302948,
-0.6304917931556702,
0.7436188459396362,
-0.1251271516084671,
-0.3358544707298279,
-0.47576332092285156,
0.7463952898979187,
0.32583051919937134,
0.3605644404888153,
0.514492392539978,
-0.12978801131248474,
-0.5872033834457397,
-0.9973673820495605,
-0.23194821178913116,
-0.13047434389591217,
-0.053110018372535706,
0.00995494145900011,
0.5909563302993774,
-0.38164305686950684,
1.0155103206634521,
-0.2646617293357849,
-0.6674168109893799,
-0.3605645000934601,
-0.016406625509262085,
-0.11300525814294815,
0.5090632438659668,
0.28662651777267456,
-0.3158012926578522,
-0.44267934560775757,
-0.09667758643627167,
-0.9370964169502258,
-0.07661768049001694,
-0.21654517948627472,
0.2030557245016098,
0.13942156732082367,
0.8620808720588684,
-0.2619453966617584,
0.12616999447345734,
0.5641627907752991,
0.13055419921875,
0.3093728721141815,
-0.3712364137172699,
-0.45051848888397217,
-0.723297655582428,
-0.048180077224969864,
-0.09711859375238419,
-0.22085575759410858,
-0.5854804515838623,
-0.21282704174518585,
0.3074570596218109,
0.19993247091770172,
-0.06472795456647873,
0.8362890481948853,
-0.7530730366706848,
-0.11446855217218399,
-0.3483336269855499,
0.08341840654611588,
-0.18632248044013977,
0.43179383873939514,
0.35761213302612305,
0.6605331897735596,
0.6292555332183838,
-0.754132091999054,
0.2163710743188858,
0.1693972945213318,
-0.5389212965965271,
0.4376929700374603,
-0.20984840393066406,
0.36324071884155273,
-0.3852035403251648,
0.07882971316576004,
-0.918855607509613,
-0.2355584055185318,
0.413237065076828,
-0.132353276014328,
0.3598461151123047,
-0.22577263414859772,
-0.5507007241249084,
-0.392588347196579,
0.198121577501297,
0.3226258158683777,
0.4043721556663513,
-0.8637508749961853,
0.5885496735572815,
0.35887736082077026,
0.29877015948295593,
-0.5782734751701355,
-0.7327607870101929,
-0.1093062162399292,
-0.25073766708374023,
-0.13692648708820343,
-0.1383262425661087,
-0.0720556303858757,
-0.06145786494016647,
-0.2581214904785156,
-0.21668866276741028,
-0.17811526358127594,
0.1986878663301468,
0.16517315804958344,
-0.2850905954837799,
0.09274561703205109,
0.7557143568992615,
-0.1493709683418274,
-0.2004816234111786,
0.13562382757663727,
-0.6770570278167725,
0.6327352523803711,
0.19640646874904633,
-0.5521156191825867,
-0.3707803189754486,
0.15631312131881714,
0.15681922435760498,
-0.27699363231658936,
0.8315536379814148,
0.4961830675601959,
-0.26336127519607544,
-0.6392422318458557,
-0.9097830653190613,
-0.24998973309993744,
-0.5153133869171143,
0.3837222456932068,
-0.47456610202789307,
-0.8587337136268616,
0.3760368525981903,
0.006889501586556435,
-0.2045961320400238,
0.2723814845085144,
0.4919298589229584,
0.014711540192365646,
0.8234239220619202,
0.613846480846405,
-0.4296894073486328,
0.3890307545661926,
-0.0673341453075409,
0.26587820053100586,
-0.6746590733528137,
-0.24544696509838104,
-0.44809502363204956,
0.009101919829845428,
-0.2148316204547882,
-0.4589096009731293,
0.16735318303108215,
-0.008357556536793709,
-0.3217117488384247,
0.06735752522945404,
-0.5484116673469543,
0.6209889054298401,
0.6501994132995605,
0.16745595633983612,
0.421536922454834,
-0.053038615733385086,
-0.009497961960732937,
0.025997336953878403,
-0.8648907542228699,
-0.2023724615573883,
1.2903876304626465,
0.45048484206199646,
0.8809733390808105,
-0.35152366757392883,
1.0119951963424683,
0.09511438012123108,
0.5705596208572388,
-0.7899086475372314,
0.4651433527469635,
-0.03540432080626488,
-0.7274961471557617,
-0.4875214397907257,
-0.6053975820541382,
-0.9219282865524292,
0.21633084118366241,
-0.012716610915958881,
-0.6385678648948669,
0.044894278049468994,
0.37781837582588196,
-0.1521717607975006,
0.4103665351867676,
-0.5892468690872192,
0.7574222087860107,
-0.43632417917251587,
-0.012504982762038708,
-0.148532435297966,
-0.2557636797428131,
0.47878095507621765,
-0.5869817733764648,
0.2739657163619995,
-0.24174995720386505,
0.24333946406841278,
0.9297733902931213,
-0.11064064502716064,
1.0205981731414795,
-0.125520259141922,
-0.28936371207237244,
0.20733284950256348,
0.08929263055324554,
0.6886953711509705,
-0.13921767473220825,
0.08228801935911179,
-0.004790475592017174,
-0.3907141089439392,
-0.35823825001716614,
-0.45818695425987244,
0.6378348469734192,
-0.7533785700798035,
-0.7095769047737122,
-0.3630611300468445,
-0.7843539118766785,
-0.5061359405517578,
0.2065933644771576,
0.29390954971313477,
0.1782543957233429,
-0.04979258030653,
0.17542393505573273,
1.1826969385147095,
-0.17028674483299255,
0.20890766382217407,
0.4827565848827362,
-0.27327728271484375,
-0.38929319381713867,
0.9053462147712708,
0.38102298974990845,
0.3623976707458496,
0.3153535723686218,
0.11497921496629715,
-0.43342843651771545,
-0.7324557900428772,
-0.13393256068229675,
0.5288675427436829,
-1.0915616750717163,
-0.10685144364833832,
-0.9814748764038086,
-0.342302531003952,
-0.5986080765724182,
0.1492418497800827,
-0.6792383193969727,
-0.06508032232522964,
-0.33100858330726624,
-0.0871007964015007,
0.3032852113246918,
0.9324211478233337,
-0.13715578615665436,
0.48930320143699646,
-0.5159673690795898,
0.40571272373199463,
0.7155454754829407,
0.530938446521759,
0.0997229591012001,
-0.6222469210624695,
-0.5185204148292542,
-0.1394190788269043,
-0.04984015226364136,
-0.5501152873039246,
0.4199415445327759,
0.17905807495117188,
0.8559649586677551,
0.5732818245887756,
0.08171501755714417,
0.4607687294483185,
-0.3790205717086792,
0.24386928975582123,
0.18629539012908936,
-0.8306958079338074,
0.5305758118629456,
-0.34036126732826233,
0.5815439820289612,
0.5819023251533508,
0.5252783894538879,
-0.5875471830368042,
-0.5813823938369751,
-0.45268088579177856,
-0.5415849685668945,
0.63694828748703,
-0.1391959935426712,
0.006330183707177639,
-0.1758524775505066,
0.42823174595832825,
0.1168200820684433,
0.12025154381990433,
-1.0663926601409912,
-0.3326951861381531,
-0.012175933457911015,
-0.23879967629909515,
-0.2654114067554474,
-0.362506240606308,
-0.18217039108276367,
-0.29460787773132324,
0.7466640472412109,
-0.2852236330509186,
0.1346321403980255,
0.09102271497249603,
-0.3708254098892212,
0.031669218093156815,
0.09575817734003067,
0.25232431292533875,
0.48632025718688965,
0.025210503488779068,
0.3858799934387207,
0.1720709353685379,
-0.21285805106163025,
0.3630070984363556,
-0.21760062873363495,
-0.24438567459583282,
-0.148071750998497,
0.19204504787921906,
0.8618944883346558,
0.13258224725723267,
-0.5965560674667358,
0.30563169717788696,
0.22645309567451477,
-0.2567058503627777,
-0.5328080058097839,
0.3430483341217041,
0.28306588530540466,
0.23357892036437988,
0.2869793176651001,
-0.09591466933488846,
0.04420238733291626,
-0.32269325852394104,
0.3423837125301361,
0.530115008354187,
-0.5699085593223572,
-0.049671582877635956,
0.6694278120994568,
-0.10962426662445068,
0.020456058904528618,
0.7391988039016724,
-0.2851293683052063,
-0.43058425188064575,
0.3250402510166168,
0.6005530953407288,
0.8188711404800415,
-0.441500186920166,
0.2104959785938263,
0.24307698011398315,
0.4719644784927368,
-0.5203245878219604,
-0.11283775418996811,
-0.2159731388092041,
-1.1096407175064087,
-0.3245929479598999,
-0.6483403444290161,
-0.17489604651927948,
0.6570390462875366,
-0.48872649669647217,
0.13281479477882385,
-0.5167489647865295,
0.15771324932575226,
-0.231711283326149,
-0.38551652431488037,
-0.644175112247467,
0.39274755120277405,
0.35917308926582336,
0.6596847176551819,
-0.964231550693512,
1.3184609413146973,
0.18421320617198944,
-0.11493785679340363,
-0.7331568598747253,
-0.1442219614982605,
-0.11031429469585419,
-0.9678181409835815,
0.9134625196456909,
0.32992860674858093,
-0.10192304849624634,
0.11565712094306946,
-0.4620049297809601,
-1.0431621074676514,
0.6758809685707092,
0.4975833296775818,
-0.6961093544960022,
0.16559356451034546,
0.22485674917697906,
0.38672858476638794,
-0.33145633339881897,
0.01733282022178173,
0.8614846467971802,
0.36695727705955505,
-0.011320301331579685,
-0.7581611275672913,
-0.09015463292598724,
0.12166775017976761,
-0.12721551954746246,
0.20638605952262878,
-0.7105061411857605,
0.5716389417648315,
0.011855757795274258,
-0.07159608602523804,
-0.19245563447475433,
0.7984188795089722,
0.37618568539619446,
0.055311497300863266,
0.5154581069946289,
0.6721190214157104,
0.9888541102409363,
-0.0037936996668577194,
0.631047248840332,
-0.15062043070793152,
0.28932633996009827,
1.3972928524017334,
-0.3667508363723755,
0.6266127824783325,
0.4443838596343994,
0.00042725526145659387,
0.14234395325183868,
0.4912479519844055,
-0.13374365866184235,
0.6080495119094849,
0.2960672080516815,
-0.32051950693130493,
-0.7622879147529602,
0.003965979442000389,
-0.3347097933292389,
0.4706786572933197,
0.27426549792289734,
-0.3974401652812958,
-0.28022533655166626,
0.25361332297325134,
-0.015782564878463745,
0.10935278236865997,
-0.21549507975578308,
0.815015971660614,
0.0499606616795063,
-0.6060152053833008,
0.8913363218307495,
-0.408573716878891,
0.5602436661720276,
-0.6953978538513184,
0.3008131980895996,
-0.3086855113506317,
0.35538285970687866,
-0.009712960571050644,
-0.35291633009910583,
0.2199394255876541,
-0.38004574179649353,
-0.1866706758737564,
-0.5291299223899841,
0.7884659171104431,
-0.6551334261894226,
-0.27612724900245667,
0.5615628957748413,
0.5702084302902222,
0.2406260371208191,
-0.39456528425216675,
-0.43476226925849915,
0.021476205438375473,
-0.021065281704068184,
-0.3380683660507202,
0.6143447756767273,
0.5416473746299744,
-0.0064653800800442696,
1.187576174736023,
0.35475510358810425,
0.11120165139436722,
0.17800600826740265,
0.15313880145549774,
0.8104381561279297,
-0.6116982698440552,
-0.5072044730186462,
-0.6779890656471252,
-0.054366953670978546,
0.06192710995674133,
-0.07001575827598572,
0.7249895930290222,
0.607629656791687,
1.0600539445877075,
-0.2599934935569763,
1.0396745204925537,
0.41054773330688477,
0.5484091639518738,
-0.5642251968383789,
0.8107393980026245,
-0.3937230408191681,
0.4109397232532501,
0.18671393394470215,
-0.7754941582679749,
-0.364400714635849,
0.665606677532196,
-0.5044461488723755,
0.25391995906829834,
0.6448060870170593,
0.6639794111251831,
0.05438733100891113,
-0.20747528970241547,
0.6256909966468811,
0.18506720662117004,
0.14043967425823212,
0.5579941868782043,
1.0094562768936157,
-0.23153887689113617,
0.48654893040657043,
-0.38252440094947815,
0.021553775295615196,
0.022764593362808228,
-0.6333443522453308,
-1.396775722503662,
-0.6323676109313965,
-0.3324567377567291,
-0.15118424594402313,
0.030627094209194183,
0.7483989000320435,
0.9071037173271179,
-1.0044900178909302,
-0.3703947961330414,
-0.21460571885108948,
0.1012011393904686,
-0.1074109598994255,
-0.14728188514709473,
0.09442300349473953,
-0.8043563961982727,
-0.48081550002098083,
0.6843070387840271,
0.4087376296520233,
0.2944020628929138,
-0.5301414132118225,
-0.06929625570774078,
-0.05141277238726616,
-0.12673115730285645,
0.4498696029186249,
0.32565921545028687,
-0.6029424667358398,
-0.4181694984436035,
-0.1656225025653839,
-0.10121740400791168,
0.17909590899944305,
0.8138628005981445,
-1.0284430980682373,
0.5338541865348816,
0.1861078441143036,
0.7055495381355286,
0.6605766415596008,
-0.3786972463130951,
0.5047059059143066,
-0.7866020202636719,
0.30030229687690735,
0.1572975069284439,
0.3105410933494568,
0.4282931387424469,
-0.5121164321899414,
0.4922875761985779,
0.3203120231628418,
-0.6289485692977905,
-0.7123435735702515,
0.2929091453552246,
-0.5433838963508606,
-0.43719473481178284,
1.2038013935089111,
-0.06865652650594711,
-0.135793998837471,
-0.5370064377784729,
0.19064666330814362,
0.18437692523002625,
-0.18233485519886017,
0.9411674737930298,
0.7482574582099915,
0.0031354122329503298,
-0.3072492480278015,
-0.5616351366043091,
0.611355185508728,
0.5174155235290527,
-0.7832585573196411,
0.39642953872680664,
0.45993414521217346,
0.5058895945549011,
-0.12402631342411041,
0.9057927131652832,
0.2803467810153961,
-0.14185328781604767,
-0.11068836599588394,
0.35879507660865784,
0.047319114208221436,
-0.6773064136505127,
-0.41111016273498535,
0.16495640575885773,
0.22848084568977356,
0.090431809425354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11274v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11274v1 | Skip-Layer Attention: Bridging Abstract and Detailed Dependencies in Transformers | 2024-06-17T07:24:38 | 2024-06-17T07:24:38 | Qian Chen, Wen Wang, Qinglin Zhang, Siqi Zheng, Shiliang Zhang, Chong Deng, Hai Yu, Jiaqing Liu, Yukun Ma, Chong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Transformer architecture has significantly advanced deep learning,
particularly in natural language processing, by effectively managing long-range
dependencies. However, as the demand for understanding complex relationships
grows, refining the Transformer's architecture becomes critical. This paper
introduces Skip-Layer Attention (SLA) to enhance Transformer models by enabling
direct attention between non-adjacent layers. This method improves the model's
ability to capture dependencies between high-level abstract features and
low-level details. By facilitating direct attention between these diverse
feature levels, our approach overcomes the limitations of current Transformers,
which often rely on suboptimal intra-layer attention. Our implementation
extends the Transformer's functionality by enabling queries in a given layer to
interact with keys and values from both the current layer and one preceding
layer, thus enhancing the diversity of multi-head attention without additional
computational burden. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our enhanced
Transformer model achieves superior performance in language modeling tasks,
highlighting the effectiveness of our skip-layer attention mechanism. | [
-0.6270033717155457,
-0.5902496576309204,
0.5700948238372803,
0.6724516749382019,
0.21453037858009338,
0.22386939823627472,
0.21333083510398865,
-0.7898471355438232,
0.04323878884315491,
0.6812781691551208,
-0.6525282859802246,
-0.04517499729990959,
-0.6210987567901611,
-0.24455171823501587,
-0.3928731381893158,
0.9113976955413818,
0.059449490159749985,
-0.5597161650657654,
-0.268265038728714,
0.10887668281793594,
-0.4241739511489868,
-0.2427956908941269,
-0.9255598783493042,
-0.45182615518569946,
0.711242139339447,
0.2227090299129486,
0.9812344312667847,
0.6683363318443298,
0.5413287281990051,
0.2969048023223877,
-0.4797203838825226,
0.03747672960162163,
-0.3769451677799225,
0.22289994359016418,
-0.43314698338508606,
-0.2265060991048813,
-0.7170981764793396,
-0.20152783393859863,
0.47022199630737305,
0.9298776984214783,
0.37241777777671814,
0.2224263995885849,
0.1767982542514801,
0.9298551678657532,
-0.8454716205596924,
0.25569331645965576,
-0.5404123663902283,
0.24357064068317413,
0.10080430656671524,
-0.05148398503661156,
-0.6020523309707642,
0.11733844876289368,
0.5834245681762695,
-0.44282621145248413,
0.39966005086898804,
-0.29925957322120667,
0.9115407466888428,
0.6138338446617126,
-0.305730402469635,
0.2760648727416992,
-1.1112830638885498,
0.5144273042678833,
-0.3435644507408142,
0.6123422980308533,
0.3685162365436554,
0.0683804526925087,
0.35263821482658386,
-0.8493510484695435,
-0.24768148362636566,
-0.22653307020664215,
-0.4945593476295471,
0.2065914273262024,
-0.3263266980648041,
0.17735655605793,
0.3494769036769867,
0.37733593583106995,
-0.12359825521707535,
-0.021683260798454285,
-0.46285903453826904,
-0.1792631596326828,
0.17099414765834808,
0.16924813389778137,
0.2971513569355011,
0.13235712051391602,
-0.35197100043296814,
0.1294134557247162,
-0.6077919602394104,
0.1748352348804474,
0.14652597904205322,
0.35943126678466797,
-0.14337752759456635,
0.3157522678375244,
-0.17154516279697418,
0.5673881769180298,
0.4293056130409241,
0.3715287744998932,
0.2900947332382202,
-0.36579927802085876,
-0.31569555401802063,
0.057134877890348434,
0.3413904905319214,
-0.1106833890080452,
0.1635093241930008,
-0.4594845175743103,
-0.1488068699836731,
-0.10121797025203705,
0.5518584251403809,
-0.6927969455718994,
-0.2929535210132599,
0.33202987909317017,
-0.29440945386886597,
-0.20053374767303467,
-0.1901056468486786,
-0.8235793709754944,
-0.16473804414272308,
-0.4699317216873169,
0.144953653216362,
-0.20991559326648712,
-0.08800488710403442,
0.0944000706076622,
0.1677476018667221,
0.3124251067638397,
0.13449066877365112,
-0.9842551350593567,
0.46742162108421326,
0.550387442111969,
0.8198001980781555,
-0.15613065659999847,
-0.45509207248687744,
-0.7212470173835754,
0.6512746214866638,
-0.1077553778886795,
0.8478938937187195,
-0.7443190813064575,
0.05519729107618332,
-0.26269862055778503,
-0.058261506259441376,
-0.14131568372249603,
-0.46794015169143677,
0.677232563495636,
-0.7024560570716858,
0.1893860399723053,
0.14342716336250305,
-0.09852946549654007,
-0.2616160809993744,
0.10638497024774551,
-0.9641692638397217,
1.0866676568984985,
0.22064898908138275,
-0.8635647892951965,
-0.11895821988582611,
-0.8332791328430176,
-0.9130228757858276,
0.057071078568696976,
0.10253579169511795,
-0.40347057580947876,
0.13049307465553284,
0.6938779950141907,
0.3050806224346161,
-0.1493748277425766,
0.08304865658283234,
0.01923663727939129,
-0.2557694911956787,
-0.12548010051250458,
-0.2836476266384125,
0.41398003697395325,
-0.19751515984535217,
-0.5372702479362488,
0.27152785658836365,
-0.9710003137588501,
-0.35532963275909424,
0.07923054695129395,
-0.11680106818675995,
-0.28586241602897644,
-0.06849449127912521,
0.18063750863075256,
0.5853862166404724,
0.2722366452217102,
-0.17352864146232605,
-0.14389368891716003,
-0.6813765168190002,
0.3705110549926758,
0.7130638957023621,
-0.021078400313854218,
0.9677255153656006,
0.04281676188111305,
0.6511570811271667,
0.4447448253631592,
0.18501435220241547,
-0.5456637740135193,
-0.21000513434410095,
-1.162283182144165,
-0.07162849605083466,
0.26867935061454773,
0.6174635291099548,
-0.40649595856666565,
0.592026948928833,
-0.12812009453773499,
-0.26352640986442566,
-0.8289434313774109,
0.0659634992480278,
0.4111674726009369,
0.6064928770065308,
0.5505818128585815,
-0.17696404457092285,
-0.6977196335792542,
-1.1123055219650269,
-0.3927970230579376,
0.1887744963169098,
-0.16580833494663239,
0.33755695819854736,
0.1705828756093979,
-0.365501344203949,
1.0364468097686768,
-0.4524247944355011,
-0.6618554592132568,
-0.5579720139503479,
-0.19190171360969543,
0.04685012623667717,
0.30917835235595703,
0.21448250114917755,
-0.7013189792633057,
-0.4863106310367584,
0.28108835220336914,
-0.30667001008987427,
-0.02730340138077736,
-0.3054029047489166,
-0.2921798527240753,
-0.1006418839097023,
0.505778431892395,
-0.8402299284934998,
0.2976427972316742,
0.27264541387557983,
-0.2935169041156769,
0.041781309992074966,
0.16753830015659332,
-0.31557247042655945,
-0.6931058168411255,
0.30069488286972046,
0.03561309352517128,
-0.26736852526664734,
-0.9992057085037231,
0.09449271857738495,
0.03805317357182503,
-0.04041529819369316,
-0.4870137870311737,
0.519481897354126,
-0.3871878981590271,
-0.1696350872516632,
-0.31520745158195496,
0.1199825331568718,
0.26173684000968933,
0.7553988695144653,
0.15632422268390656,
0.5953191518783569,
0.7702556848526001,
-0.6692088842391968,
-0.1327003389596939,
0.28865858912467957,
0.09671830385923386,
0.17725995182991028,
-0.9316752552986145,
0.5015754103660583,
-0.34142228960990906,
0.17484091222286224,
-0.9435667991638184,
-0.1003732904791832,
0.2637645900249481,
-0.16764995455741882,
0.3010920584201813,
-0.18410751223564148,
-0.2277638018131256,
-0.17135268449783325,
-0.21043537557125092,
0.4351120889186859,
0.34489989280700684,
-0.5529635548591614,
1.2590683698654175,
0.3529965877532959,
-0.22438278794288635,
-0.7525537014007568,
-0.8029650449752808,
0.036117374897003174,
0.17657598853111267,
-0.6462847590446472,
0.49784359335899353,
0.1421864628791809,
-0.0658799335360527,
-0.03033294528722763,
-0.3908776640892029,
-0.19455887377262115,
-0.03711654990911484,
0.24969658255577087,
0.19844263792037964,
-0.29385629296302795,
-0.12067669630050659,
0.22955003380775452,
-0.4857045114040375,
0.08283860236406326,
-0.2699475884437561,
0.7665666937828064,
0.13261999189853668,
-0.14576222002506256,
-0.5725534558296204,
0.3742832541465759,
0.6589835286140442,
-0.6535114645957947,
0.5106790661811829,
0.5854089856147766,
-0.3179062008857727,
-0.2779475748538971,
-0.5805887579917908,
-0.3166392147541046,
-0.5771067142486572,
0.4934028089046478,
-0.4134865999221802,
-0.8854590654373169,
0.5624679327011108,
0.20128078758716583,
0.06875769048929214,
0.3152419924736023,
0.2728389501571655,
0.021394986659288406,
1.0111786127090454,
0.6990442872047424,
-0.414021372795105,
0.5459919571876526,
-0.005639661103487015,
0.38011130690574646,
-0.976906955242157,
-0.27926862239837646,
-0.4894818663597107,
-0.5265915393829346,
-0.12694917619228363,
-0.40293365716934204,
-0.06451524794101715,
-0.12081795930862427,
-0.21554946899414062,
0.31435805559158325,
-0.5350469946861267,
0.8470675945281982,
0.3111352026462555,
0.10219424217939377,
0.29144665598869324,
-0.04855559393763542,
0.2174152284860611,
-0.1645916998386383,
-0.41070762276649475,
-0.18962810933589935,
0.5318328738212585,
0.7706960439682007,
0.745242178440094,
-0.21455425024032593,
0.2736751139163971,
0.04614373296499252,
-0.03301091864705086,
-0.7735007405281067,
0.4989541172981262,
-0.23420007526874542,
-0.2804819941520691,
-0.11726263910531998,
-0.2934248745441437,
-0.6850103139877319,
0.4114108979701996,
0.38670840859413147,
-0.5968425273895264,
0.20949143171310425,
0.2069341391324997,
-0.4081425368785858,
0.14107835292816162,
-0.7204406261444092,
0.7306259274482727,
0.09369806200265884,
-0.2592274844646454,
-0.021837005391716957,
-0.8885964751243591,
0.3577879071235657,
0.19709265232086182,
0.031125014647841454,
0.15864549577236176,
-0.2125556468963623,
0.293485552072525,
0.2486506551504135,
1.0390756130218506,
0.02218310534954071,
-0.32177138328552246,
-0.0623432919383049,
0.09278499335050583,
0.6601821184158325,
-0.08742059767246246,
0.40711885690689087,
-0.17758871614933014,
-0.8247197866439819,
-0.4067600965499878,
-0.5390313863754272,
0.7737141847610474,
-0.6654308438301086,
-0.5842581987380981,
-0.13018923997879028,
-0.8676491379737854,
-0.35951316356658936,
0.2890211343765259,
-0.05373075604438782,
0.11320411413908005,
0.09676523506641388,
-0.007621116004884243,
1.017906904220581,
-0.04634559154510498,
0.6372858285903931,
0.2714042663574219,
-0.1027396023273468,
-0.05331183224916458,
0.7344719171524048,
-0.023024048656225204,
0.3789292275905609,
0.8097720742225647,
-0.02188153564929962,
-0.25426870584487915,
-0.46118173003196716,
-0.08591806888580322,
0.12461230903863907,
-0.78572678565979,
-0.003634984605014324,
-1.4698495864868164,
-0.7309393882751465,
-0.43292829394340515,
0.05250844359397888,
-0.4794616103172302,
-0.40035587549209595,
-0.29426243901252747,
-0.4153759777545929,
0.11402075737714767,
0.7130581736564636,
0.4710383117198944,
0.38766637444496155,
-0.8476153612136841,
0.5402514338493347,
0.39733797311782837,
0.4865933060646057,
0.5376509428024292,
-0.653372585773468,
-0.23252476751804352,
-0.6127038598060608,
-0.3584974408149719,
-0.5023064613342285,
0.23090766370296478,
0.14028190076351166,
0.614296555519104,
0.3435157239437103,
-0.22349247336387634,
0.6646237969398499,
-0.6619076728820801,
0.48142603039741516,
-0.08905947208404541,
-1.2523784637451172,
0.7008059620857239,
-0.15413415431976318,
0.8255694508552551,
0.533775806427002,
0.25518062710762024,
-0.30094149708747864,
-0.8375450968742371,
-0.5180442929267883,
-1.1977570056915283,
1.0352672338485718,
0.3609980344772339,
0.26529964804649353,
0.3270561099052429,
0.22016136348247528,
-0.02130145952105522,
-0.1900629848241806,
-1.131346344947815,
-0.33325889706611633,
-0.10119136422872543,
-0.05005143955349922,
0.21314206719398499,
-0.14661844074726105,
0.05058136582374573,
-0.20576554536819458,
0.5502297878265381,
0.033232737332582474,
-0.013865937478840351,
0.15420794486999512,
-0.32777678966522217,
-0.06465794146060944,
0.23369476199150085,
0.5945702195167542,
0.5898623466491699,
-0.05515516549348831,
0.39496710896492004,
0.19166672229766846,
-0.6190699338912964,
-0.10310997068881989,
0.18117718398571014,
-0.42586255073547363,
0.0688515231013298,
0.3336239457130432,
1.0484539270401,
0.39475420117378235,
-0.40274184942245483,
0.11597232520580292,
0.029198676347732544,
0.06347665935754776,
-0.07020960003137589,
0.009643636643886566,
0.47521018981933594,
0.26323622465133667,
0.4855101704597473,
0.5266755223274231,
0.2788558006286621,
-0.13580437004566193,
0.428086519241333,
0.14306601881980896,
-0.775617778301239,
-0.36647704243659973,
0.5847693681716919,
0.2175569236278534,
-0.41062238812446594,
0.25648215413093567,
0.3634963929653168,
-0.4480834901332855,
0.7308012247085571,
0.5571116805076599,
1.0057510137557983,
-0.4364612102508545,
0.06521425396203995,
0.22118434309959412,
0.6012322306632996,
0.11377402395009995,
-0.03283708542585373,
-0.12736445665359497,
-0.4020598530769348,
-0.6218312978744507,
-0.3457195460796356,
-0.26725539565086365,
0.2343289852142334,
-0.6280364990234375,
0.29191744327545166,
-0.6246657967567444,
0.18737401068210602,
0.10508832335472107,
-0.524930477142334,
-0.7733082175254822,
0.3130706548690796,
0.16118896007537842,
0.6271807551383972,
-0.7156609892845154,
0.7589566111564636,
0.48893967270851135,
-0.5292205214500427,
-0.4648790657520294,
0.34506550431251526,
-0.5923864841461182,
-0.49961692094802856,
0.7222428917884827,
0.5105578899383545,
-0.44902023673057556,
0.01423502154648304,
-0.23867900669574738,
-1.0094656944274902,
0.8432095646858215,
0.42607226967811584,
-0.7047484517097473,
-0.27025970816612244,
0.30683475732803345,
0.571788489818573,
-0.5122097730636597,
0.5216239094734192,
0.8255821466445923,
0.4081907868385315,
0.14072872698307037,
-0.5343303680419922,
0.11417306214570999,
-0.14976593852043152,
0.10634859651327133,
0.3118783235549927,
-0.588247537612915,
0.7198248505592346,
-0.1337127983570099,
-0.2890005111694336,
-0.27089160680770874,
1.0018812417984009,
0.04834380000829697,
0.1698472797870636,
0.7297130823135376,
0.4559941589832306,
0.16341716051101685,
0.008452491834759712,
0.9073451161384583,
-0.3134863078594208,
0.20325732231140137,
1.4711476564407349,
-0.29254546761512756,
0.7762263417243958,
0.6511005759239197,
-0.11761362850666046,
0.4281148910522461,
0.26375266909599304,
0.12077481299638748,
0.6592182517051697,
-0.1269860416650772,
-0.11575014889240265,
-0.1377856731414795,
-0.20725145936012268,
-0.29266732931137085,
0.2638305723667145,
0.23115991055965424,
-0.6542723178863525,
-0.21496015787124634,
-0.05484914034605026,
-0.2200830727815628,
-0.03322625532746315,
-0.34926125407218933,
0.917768120765686,
-0.011223937384784222,
-0.613312304019928,
0.175809845328331,
-0.2946370840072632,
0.7144185304641724,
-0.5885410904884338,
-0.03481787443161011,
-0.4369467794895172,
0.26062044501304626,
-0.38944920897483826,
-0.6677998900413513,
0.5287126302719116,
-0.17382094264030457,
-0.6579665541648865,
-0.2386574149131775,
0.9282006621360779,
-0.45731183886528015,
-0.5325081944465637,
0.7902921438217163,
0.3555484116077423,
-0.3178674876689911,
-0.18162572383880615,
-0.5483584403991699,
0.017479337751865387,
-0.08194305747747421,
-0.4900669455528259,
0.3853870928287506,
0.19366812705993652,
0.1895342916250229,
0.6398643851280212,
0.5492669939994812,
-0.22836308181285858,
0.21367698907852173,
0.6027135252952576,
1.0033966302871704,
-0.7332899570465088,
-0.6724011301994324,
-0.8791914582252502,
0.7616325616836548,
-0.164278045296669,
-0.18531034886837006,
0.34641194343566895,
0.4732951819896698,
0.7177349328994751,
-0.2692912220954895,
0.826009213924408,
0.2894499897956848,
0.467830091714859,
-0.287235826253891,
0.649728000164032,
-0.18470196425914764,
0.39000439643859863,
-0.21079693734645844,
-1.1970082521438599,
-0.5227916240692139,
0.4438510239124298,
-0.05189036577939987,
0.12574505805969238,
0.7065675854682922,
0.4759646952152252,
-0.49452176690101624,
0.011401952244341373,
0.13349755108356476,
0.4042099118232727,
0.5009250640869141,
0.682749330997467,
0.9612072110176086,
-0.4206196665763855,
0.6811214089393616,
-0.443781316280365,
-0.0007340041920542717,
0.2950664162635803,
-0.6672846078872681,
-1.145605206489563,
-0.2085982710123062,
-0.3372992277145386,
-0.23098954558372498,
-0.2192620486021042,
0.5814307332038879,
0.5821799635887146,
-0.9060895442962646,
0.006929452996701002,
-0.25585004687309265,
0.17473407089710236,
-0.37448838353157043,
-0.3393940329551697,
0.49412304162979126,
-0.6260204911231995,
-0.9166530966758728,
0.4535227119922638,
0.7817285656929016,
0.03600148856639862,
-0.514149010181427,
0.2571146786212921,
-0.19677135348320007,
0.08355932682752609,
0.7296767830848694,
0.07930038124322891,
-0.8857860565185547,
-0.1574987918138504,
0.15338656306266785,
-0.16786815226078033,
0.3362196981906891,
1.0423060655593872,
-0.9442450404167175,
-0.03058227337896824,
0.646350622177124,
1.0727442502975464,
0.6898964643478394,
-0.17542222142219543,
0.527122437953949,
-1.018308401107788,
0.3895409405231476,
0.46708837151527405,
0.21314851939678192,
0.43794119358062744,
-0.6036047339439392,
0.3936094045639038,
-0.11985725909471512,
-0.3333476781845093,
-0.5874630808830261,
0.4038277864456177,
-1.186678409576416,
0.03021129034459591,
0.879657506942749,
-0.1642495095729828,
-0.07524155080318451,
-0.5285228490829468,
-0.4049733877182007,
-0.044855255633592606,
-0.4990446865558624,
0.6764883399009705,
0.4887737035751343,
0.001074723550118506,
-0.8539451956748962,
-0.4825143814086914,
0.39595964550971985,
0.8157936930656433,
-0.97590571641922,
0.31881558895111084,
-0.02304733544588089,
-0.09235571324825287,
0.4037529230117798,
0.3513667583465576,
-0.01563798449933529,
0.2600443363189697,
-0.2774878740310669,
-0.2218800187110901,
0.00812755711376667,
-0.6846257448196411,
-0.4303778409957886,
0.5231410264968872,
-0.32749179005622864,
-0.1391163468360901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11267v1 | Mitigating Large Language Model Hallucination with Faithful Finetuning | 2024-06-17T07:16:07 | 2024-06-17T07:16:07 | Minda Hu, Bowei He, Yufei Wang, Liangyou Li, Chen Ma, Irwin King | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance on
various natural language processing tasks. However, they are prone to
generating fluent yet untruthful responses, known as "hallucinations".
Hallucinations can lead to the spread of misinformation and cause harm in
critical applications. Mitigating hallucinations is challenging as they arise
from factors such as noisy data, model overconfidence, lack of knowledge, and
the generation process itself. Recent efforts have attempted to address this
issue through representation editing and decoding algorithms, reducing
hallucinations without major structural changes or retraining. However, these
approaches either implicitly edit LLMs' behavior in latent space or suppress
the tendency to output unfaithful results during decoding instead of explicitly
modeling on hallucination. In this work, we introduce Faithful Finetuning (F2),
a novel method that explicitly models the process of faithful question
answering through carefully designed loss functions during fine-tuning. We
conduct extensive experiments on popular datasets and demonstrate that F2
achieves significant improvements over vanilla models and baselines. | [
-0.3626333177089691,
-1.221577525138855,
0.5669199824333191,
0.04004122316837311,
-0.28524670004844666,
-0.2766803205013275,
-0.3885480463504791,
-0.29742106795310974,
-0.03865711763501167,
0.8976832032203674,
-0.6481497287750244,
-0.2592417895793915,
-0.3788617253303528,
0.005798151716589928,
-0.3332769274711609,
0.946587085723877,
-0.05622103437781334,
0.328056663274765,
-0.28440061211586,
0.0024374641943722963,
-0.5689323544502258,
-0.40926241874694824,
-0.6229121685028076,
-0.43264245986938477,
0.28529900312423706,
0.39932939410209656,
0.9730017185211182,
0.42210105061531067,
0.3790310323238373,
0.2062792032957077,
-0.03011428937315941,
0.5196352601051331,
-1.0157445669174194,
0.3824595510959625,
-0.09548807889223099,
-0.6884199976921082,
-0.14596234261989594,
-0.1663869470357895,
0.5417981147766113,
0.9421128630638123,
-0.21966026723384857,
-0.047539982944726944,
0.49461495876312256,
0.6121552586555481,
-0.4678577482700348,
0.13632093369960785,
-1.0809191465377808,
-0.013528592884540558,
-0.007955051027238369,
-0.4365435242652893,
-0.5165531039237976,
-0.38385313749313354,
-0.13778215646743774,
-0.6608276963233948,
0.49657300114631653,
-0.1051851138472557,
0.8022114634513855,
0.6831129789352417,
0.15264324843883514,
-0.2935745120048523,
-0.88113933801651,
0.7438073754310608,
-0.7620190978050232,
0.5105694532394409,
0.7141534686088562,
0.08519178628921509,
-0.4383884072303772,
-0.42846643924713135,
-0.4502105116844177,
-0.21153703331947327,
-0.07357462495565414,
-0.20077238976955414,
-0.16678999364376068,
0.11412517726421356,
0.30397847294807434,
0.2512969374656677,
-0.5498482584953308,
0.008437040261924267,
-0.2780069410800934,
-0.549079954624176,
0.47195401787757874,
0.1930394470691681,
-0.02088385634124279,
0.01018291525542736,
0.0005189182702451944,
-0.04089704900979996,
-0.6595782041549683,
-0.21395200490951538,
0.35305091738700867,
0.3158930540084839,
0.32442745566368103,
0.796366274356842,
-0.13993118703365326,
0.3492893576622009,
0.1682339459657669,
0.2566041350364685,
-0.038094982504844666,
-0.10084640979766846,
-0.38758420944213867,
0.11626118421554565,
0.4292602837085724,
0.5852274894714355,
0.5855648517608643,
-0.5862590670585632,
-0.25857672095298767,
0.3134322166442871,
0.33545371890068054,
-0.9093107581138611,
-0.33002573251724243,
0.3518563508987427,
-0.41602835059165955,
-0.21710672974586487,
-0.015491520054638386,
-0.839392364025116,
-0.6495522856712341,
-0.38947737216949463,
0.4481600224971771,
-0.5901565551757812,
-0.03990180790424347,
0.30537766218185425,
0.12491493672132492,
0.28792253136634827,
0.4887241721153259,
-0.7611298561096191,
0.5823976397514343,
0.8611863851547241,
0.8247193694114685,
-0.027133651077747345,
-0.19014409184455872,
-1.0105308294296265,
0.09529773145914078,
-0.4810207486152649,
0.6097791790962219,
-0.505943238735199,
-0.08021955192089081,
-0.013470422476530075,
0.04471534863114357,
0.23047848045825958,
-0.7098414301872253,
0.4922926425933838,
-0.5033425688743591,
0.05737860128283501,
-0.16087377071380615,
-0.53742516040802,
-0.13466264307498932,
0.1898578554391861,
-0.5535097718238831,
0.8167612552642822,
-0.14298389852046967,
-0.6123734712600708,
-0.04405869543552399,
-0.17834942042827606,
-0.4026409089565277,
-0.29456332325935364,
-0.05843399092555046,
-0.581770122051239,
0.5349403619766235,
0.28641146421432495,
0.5856984853744507,
-0.092662513256073,
0.3399100601673126,
-0.33574482798576355,
-0.5169472694396973,
0.30016568303108215,
-0.637872040271759,
0.3466402292251587,
0.282758504152298,
-0.42503032088279724,
0.17648957669734955,
-0.6220609545707703,
-0.06192044913768768,
0.2215396612882614,
-0.0034414157271385193,
-0.5873014330863953,
-0.03321017324924469,
0.09466822445392609,
-0.09815208613872528,
0.0035038639325648546,
-0.34084391593933105,
0.18166455626487732,
-0.7594374418258667,
0.2583916485309601,
0.7183142900466919,
0.07654157280921936,
0.45339107513427734,
-0.48023292422294617,
0.2355572134256363,
0.08132781088352203,
0.06541793793439865,
0.009816236793994904,
-0.2988032102584839,
-0.9217966794967651,
0.24075408279895782,
0.07401178777217865,
0.5194805860519409,
-0.8424460291862488,
0.14610397815704346,
-0.09466837346553802,
-0.33945614099502563,
-0.7645667195320129,
0.31754323840141296,
0.2949916124343872,
0.37676697969436646,
0.5766453742980957,
-0.05630633234977722,
-0.45870766043663025,
-0.816709041595459,
-0.30834418535232544,
0.11901288479566574,
-0.17333896458148956,
0.05407056212425232,
0.22955696284770966,
-0.47480154037475586,
0.5896248817443848,
-0.5771730542182922,
-0.6397551894187927,
-0.09731171280145645,
0.26617854833602905,
-0.24395596981048584,
0.6277968883514404,
0.3124368488788605,
-0.6220705509185791,
0.004833790007978678,
-0.2683880925178528,
-0.5399600863456726,
-0.12378601729869843,
-0.5643611550331116,
-0.16622819006443024,
0.6010074615478516,
0.7218612432479858,
-0.7014081478118896,
0.36587244272232056,
0.32870426774024963,
-0.3438015580177307,
0.4807948172092438,
-0.17964817583560944,
-0.0015732237370684743,
-0.8622205853462219,
-0.10302062332630157,
-0.2936106324195862,
-0.23752033710479736,
-0.5596072673797607,
0.050952255725860596,
-0.10809008777141571,
0.14405487477779388,
-0.08048399537801743,
0.34666940569877625,
-0.4144185483455658,
0.1973675787448883,
-0.27082210779190063,
0.018880773335695267,
0.04677394777536392,
0.49342936277389526,
-0.05841958895325661,
0.6541867852210999,
0.39763328433036804,
-0.4329405725002289,
0.006972954608500004,
0.421301931142807,
-0.10236275941133499,
0.09833386540412903,
-0.5939704179763794,
0.3187633752822876,
-0.44906190037727356,
-0.0013279166305437684,
-1.1601457595825195,
-0.2962466776371002,
0.32515159249305725,
-0.47523435950279236,
0.25707367062568665,
-0.00012455899559427053,
-0.5561567544937134,
0.04152138531208038,
-0.5043478012084961,
0.13228629529476166,
0.35232388973236084,
-0.35588109493255615,
0.4667787253856659,
0.07755206525325775,
-0.19083093106746674,
-0.2390826940536499,
-1.109006404876709,
0.05793337523937225,
-0.11081106215715408,
-0.5156759023666382,
0.353461891412735,
-0.21370364725589752,
-0.24891623854637146,
-0.09247517585754395,
-0.3613457679748535,
-0.14117692410945892,
0.13156063854694366,
0.19605843722820282,
0.0823630541563034,
-0.2781596779823303,
0.1548798829317093,
0.2726285457611084,
-0.13652656972408295,
0.3052034378051758,
-0.09736562520265579,
0.8822548389434814,
-0.10063605010509491,
-0.20294427871704102,
-0.6545460820198059,
0.44535961747169495,
0.6343975067138672,
-0.27980273962020874,
0.8759469389915466,
0.5975287556648254,
-0.7809001207351685,
-0.3966854512691498,
-0.8690150380134583,
-0.7327350378036499,
-0.4549708962440491,
0.41638344526290894,
-0.3523477613925934,
-0.9737354516983032,
0.7184277772903442,
0.08141256868839264,
0.05286816135048866,
0.2788689434528351,
0.44109994173049927,
0.07546393573284149,
1.0462054014205933,
0.396198570728302,
0.2054039090871811,
0.21378621459007263,
-0.15946665406227112,
0.12776048481464386,
-0.6158998608589172,
-0.29238343238830566,
-0.560286819934845,
-0.08863645046949387,
-0.4802546501159668,
-0.5975714921951294,
-0.0035942173562943935,
0.37293750047683716,
-0.04648648202419281,
-0.09885219484567642,
-0.49233293533325195,
0.6094900369644165,
0.3396499454975128,
0.2483094185590744,
0.29371798038482666,
0.3137993812561035,
-0.0008070439216680825,
-0.3683403730392456,
-0.5756370425224304,
-0.6529484391212463,
1.0047061443328857,
0.4728989005088806,
1.1133067607879639,
0.016966750845313072,
0.6189501881599426,
0.07029478996992111,
0.09339286386966705,
-0.7686368823051453,
0.4676019549369812,
-0.23980633914470673,
-0.2433491051197052,
-0.5805942416191101,
-0.5824964642524719,
-0.7140190601348877,
0.08155737817287445,
-0.3193177282810211,
-0.6568551659584045,
0.07626567035913467,
0.28221723437309265,
-0.5572071671485901,
0.30178412795066833,
-0.5473592877388,
0.7094640731811523,
-0.011176569387316704,
-0.7061727643013,
-0.3065966069698334,
-0.4315248429775238,
0.3969525992870331,
-0.13225999474525452,
-0.005051007028669119,
0.18649926781654358,
0.26902323961257935,
0.6813280582427979,
-0.33976373076438904,
0.9014990925788879,
-0.2525680363178253,
-0.3082672655582428,
0.1858096718788147,
0.5886365175247192,
0.8601369261741638,
0.4466550946235657,
-0.11761798709630966,
0.13570216298103333,
0.023582659661769867,
-0.1683061420917511,
-0.7028834819793701,
0.8651671409606934,
-0.6017382144927979,
-0.5968957543373108,
-0.14369826018810272,
-0.6353866457939148,
-0.48476555943489075,
0.16731351613998413,
0.4057387113571167,
0.26132869720458984,
-0.214357390999794,
0.32268646359443665,
1.1230040788650513,
-0.2978111207485199,
0.0815911591053009,
0.10959610342979431,
-0.2676420509815216,
-0.43345215916633606,
0.7252755761146545,
0.20862659811973572,
0.24212586879730225,
0.10110580176115036,
0.29797250032424927,
-0.365844190120697,
-0.7456966638565063,
-0.11183203011751175,
0.29345616698265076,
-0.6033914685249329,
-0.33416181802749634,
-0.6474377512931824,
-0.27655309438705444,
-0.6051344871520996,
-0.020023401826620102,
-0.5626720786094666,
-0.3484288156032562,
-0.5225023031234741,
0.028688931837677956,
0.2719537615776062,
0.47363927960395813,
0.0893273651599884,
0.2014947533607483,
-0.6114566922187805,
0.837343156337738,
0.30088332295417786,
0.6498460173606873,
0.0722208246588707,
-0.5807020664215088,
0.0887347087264061,
0.3972163200378418,
-0.2351815104484558,
-0.7504119277000427,
0.2486589252948761,
0.22851237654685974,
0.43226441740989685,
0.45063188672065735,
0.30763161182403564,
1.038475513458252,
-0.5039541721343994,
0.580653965473175,
-0.030638225376605988,
-0.9815309047698975,
0.45303454995155334,
-0.23492015898227692,
0.23506952822208405,
0.6744403839111328,
0.11879713833332062,
-0.5511767864227295,
-0.720537543296814,
-0.35758310556411743,
-0.7074338793754578,
0.5984750390052795,
0.4368816018104553,
0.3847194015979767,
0.13296593725681305,
0.6411551237106323,
0.4326671063899994,
0.11856659501791,
-0.7463940978050232,
-0.041863441467285156,
-0.4106501340866089,
-0.19961842894554138,
-0.09098637104034424,
-0.5177590250968933,
-0.11079742759466171,
-0.37360864877700806,
0.7782720327377319,
-0.22665515542030334,
0.3295239508152008,
0.46572792530059814,
-0.22574064135551453,
-0.4760860204696655,
0.2138260155916214,
0.8018990159034729,
0.32259413599967957,
-0.19200146198272705,
0.2682496905326843,
0.14830408990383148,
-0.45514747500419617,
-0.22355876863002777,
0.22779317200183868,
-0.29536205530166626,
-0.01995009183883667,
0.32341453433036804,
0.6466476321220398,
-0.041417766362428665,
-0.5607481598854065,
0.2851593494415283,
-0.1352553516626358,
-0.31863629817962646,
-0.24514396488666534,
0.19005054235458374,
0.009312998503446579,
0.3064441978931427,
0.38753217458724976,
0.1803102195262909,
0.1434638500213623,
-0.4702705144882202,
0.3671403229236603,
0.4953339099884033,
-0.5253543853759766,
-0.18565435707569122,
0.9748304486274719,
-0.1564176380634308,
-0.1814252734184265,
0.8694695830345154,
-0.08286331593990326,
-0.34474194049835205,
0.3664923906326294,
0.6336305737495422,
0.9676675200462341,
-0.3309116065502167,
0.1231289729475975,
0.2547188699245453,
0.5624321699142456,
-0.27792102098464966,
0.36922159790992737,
0.1694004237651825,
-0.6772549152374268,
-0.38833826780319214,
-0.7254932522773743,
-0.05873741954565048,
0.7014799118041992,
-0.62008136510849,
0.12791576981544495,
-0.48702043294906616,
0.12742258608341217,
-0.07054093480110168,
-0.11640001088380814,
-0.46200430393218994,
0.06124667823314667,
0.27009591460227966,
0.7317574620246887,
-0.6630480885505676,
0.7957414388656616,
0.4302750527858734,
-0.26145458221435547,
-0.633155345916748,
0.45895424485206604,
-0.18829643726348877,
-0.3855530917644501,
0.0866556242108345,
0.4412124454975128,
-0.16750794649124146,
0.06760431826114655,
-0.7833508849143982,
-0.5335505604743958,
0.6456451416015625,
0.7042514681816101,
-0.7639191150665283,
0.025943327695131302,
0.541631817817688,
0.5552576780319214,
-0.1805499643087387,
-0.32013535499572754,
0.6142750382423401,
0.4473653733730316,
0.0759793147444725,
-0.5943036675453186,
0.27960434556007385,
-0.05112279951572418,
-0.05273611471056938,
0.05330590158700943,
-0.408180296421051,
0.5620314478874207,
-0.33403003215789795,
-0.22498168051242828,
0.40177121758461,
0.6644846200942993,
0.1785835325717926,
0.358317494392395,
0.5414513349533081,
0.34904953837394714,
0.8921223282814026,
-0.2681474983692169,
0.5553924441337585,
-0.09009475260972977,
0.3211909830570221,
1.277028203010559,
-0.18473941087722778,
0.8369439840316772,
0.847377359867096,
0.2708919942378998,
-0.040804244577884674,
0.47937577962875366,
-0.11563040316104889,
0.6612478494644165,
0.39783331751823425,
0.1758655458688736,
-0.6001291275024414,
-0.039400480687618256,
-0.32801228761672974,
0.43347063660621643,
0.3659469485282898,
-0.14595746994018555,
-0.2090708464384079,
0.2576409876346588,
0.14242082834243774,
0.4354284405708313,
-0.26789095997810364,
0.7673844695091248,
0.03789113089442253,
-0.7577493786811829,
0.9748639464378357,
0.051419176161289215,
0.6020553708076477,
-0.42124614119529724,
-0.32192131876945496,
-0.5689565539360046,
0.246973916888237,
-0.24375973641872406,
-0.6424093246459961,
0.8011494278907776,
-0.07482237368822098,
-0.19392533600330353,
-0.1686619520187378,
0.6212742328643799,
-0.6610193252563477,
-0.523462176322937,
0.2554514408111572,
0.3031740188598633,
0.013038428500294685,
-0.46030694246292114,
-0.5315744876861572,
0.22713543474674225,
0.13456399738788605,
-0.23565565049648285,
-0.03276851028203964,
0.49383383989334106,
-0.2304309904575348,
0.5836976766586304,
0.7255063056945801,
0.007733913138508797,
0.06414016336202621,
0.23966936767101288,
0.9544959664344788,
-0.5818382501602173,
-0.41762563586235046,
-0.8626434803009033,
0.2945111095905304,
0.13091394305229187,
-0.14385025203227997,
0.5578554272651672,
0.6519330739974976,
0.8483220934867859,
-0.275396466255188,
0.512308657169342,
0.3315187990665436,
0.3007686138153076,
-0.7984435558319092,
1.0491164922714233,
-0.6743960380554199,
0.40273547172546387,
-0.42015743255615234,
-1.077418327331543,
-0.6454706788063049,
0.7574542760848999,
-0.14546720683574677,
-0.19258828461170197,
0.5424245595932007,
1.155983328819275,
-0.1249832957983017,
-0.046385619789361954,
0.46120795607566833,
0.728245735168457,
0.19522039592266083,
0.49593859910964966,
0.8143948912620544,
-0.5498354434967041,
0.6614200472831726,
-0.43494483828544617,
0.059910133481025696,
-0.2171165943145752,
-0.5109171867370605,
-1.1168019771575928,
-0.5450583696365356,
-0.3595274090766907,
-0.4826764464378357,
0.22584658861160278,
0.742559552192688,
0.4567468464374542,
-1.0536752939224243,
0.16473326086997986,
-0.3901357352733612,
-0.028979377821087837,
-0.2242158204317093,
-0.24938294291496277,
0.3615105450153351,
-0.42879387736320496,
-0.5393024682998657,
0.1795237809419632,
-0.020317764952778816,
0.3084130585193634,
-0.4211822748184204,
-0.24039797484874725,
0.09839142858982086,
0.24615037441253662,
0.4231919050216675,
-0.1805284023284912,
-0.9929807186126709,
-0.36590448021888733,
0.09781239181756973,
-0.07312514632940292,
0.02894694358110428,
0.5135968327522278,
-0.7326383590698242,
0.36312615871429443,
0.348904550075531,
0.7104392647743225,
0.2119693160057068,
0.06757428497076035,
0.4411165416240692,
-0.5849270224571228,
0.17180617153644562,
0.3159410059452057,
0.05636010318994522,
0.4240819811820984,
-0.6376855373382568,
0.37692221999168396,
0.03764474019408226,
-0.38579684495925903,
-1.094351887702942,
0.07409609109163284,
-0.93462735414505,
-0.5208842158317566,
1.1885207891464233,
0.27757957577705383,
-0.1300496608018875,
-0.10456985235214233,
-0.48608121275901794,
0.45481595396995544,
-0.18382784724235535,
1.2110673189163208,
0.7543840408325195,
0.11397237330675125,
-0.11196376383304596,
-0.6183812022209167,
0.7456045746803284,
0.7222544550895691,
-0.7739287614822388,
0.6676998138427734,
0.7638092637062073,
0.21458007395267487,
0.03419912979006767,
0.13750877976417542,
-0.042382899671792984,
0.22840973734855652,
-0.18996860086917877,
-0.09863968193531036,
-0.19262225925922394,
-0.560546875,
-0.5677101016044617,
0.3156704604625702,
0.07102091610431671,
0.00012011641229037195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11263v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11263v1 | The Fall of ROME: Understanding the Collapse of LLMs in Model Editing | 2024-06-17T07:08:29 | 2024-06-17T07:08:29 | Wanli Yang, Fei Sun, Jiajun Tan, Xinyu Ma, Du Su, Dawei Yin, Huawei Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite significant progress in model editing methods, their application in
real-world scenarios remains challenging as they often cause large language
models (LLMs) to collapse. Among them, ROME is particularly concerning, as it
could disrupt LLMs with only a single edit. In this paper, we study the root
causes of such collapse. Through extensive analysis, we identify two primary
factors that contribute to the collapse: i) inconsistent handling of prefixed
and unprefixed keys in the parameter update equation may result in very small
denominators, causing excessively large parameter updates; ii) the subject of
collapse cases is usually the first token, whose unprefixed key distribution
significantly differs from the prefixed key distribution in autoregressive
transformers, causing the aforementioned issue to materialize. To validate our
analysis, we propose a simple yet effective approach: uniformly using prefixed
keys during editing phase and adding prefixes during the testing phase. The
experimental results show that the proposed solution can prevent model collapse
while maintaining the effectiveness of the edits. | [
-0.5714840292930603,
-0.7695779800415039,
0.7815374732017517,
-0.05522448569536209,
-0.1361415833234787,
0.14909616112709045,
-0.30332547426223755,
-0.03891218826174736,
-0.2473689764738083,
0.4254186451435089,
-0.5701772570610046,
-0.3764841854572296,
-0.7445945143699646,
0.09298399090766907,
-0.7543633580207825,
1.106846570968628,
-0.3822777569293976,
-0.055121924728155136,
-0.04707031324505806,
-0.2727806866168976,
-0.3237283527851105,
-0.4645201861858368,
-0.9016247391700745,
-0.2412302941083908,
0.3943640887737274,
0.3822026550769806,
0.8980379104614258,
0.8854050040245056,
0.6789156794548035,
0.3658641278743744,
-0.5920827388763428,
0.15882378816604614,
-0.481249064207077,
0.02882782183587551,
0.05974803864955902,
-0.5833239555358887,
-0.5389488935470581,
0.16491079330444336,
0.8754700422286987,
0.5843435525894165,
-0.2100227177143097,
0.027579933404922485,
0.13218948245048523,
0.5435359477996826,
-0.46007025241851807,
-0.13323216140270233,
-0.7107913494110107,
-0.16437852382659912,
-0.2897638976573944,
-0.11508272588253021,
-0.47051236033439636,
0.0028440114110708237,
-0.34960246086120605,
-0.43565648794174194,
0.3823052644729614,
-0.247505784034729,
0.9883697628974915,
0.5502241253852844,
-0.33381304144859314,
-0.3377422094345093,
-0.9907891154289246,
0.5486405491828918,
-0.7327401638031006,
0.38272786140441895,
-0.3973222076892853,
-0.06110665947198868,
-0.5597447752952576,
-0.6046800017356873,
-0.5734768509864807,
-0.29645466804504395,
0.05833212286233902,
-0.04320602864027023,
-0.11822212487459183,
0.20742516219615936,
0.36454498767852783,
0.4105106294155121,
-0.19955332577228546,
0.32090485095977783,
-0.2939920127391815,
0.13317783176898956,
0.2660025358200073,
0.3930358588695526,
0.5112648010253906,
-0.12413917481899261,
-0.28604570031166077,
-0.2879504859447479,
-1.2755393981933594,
-0.12347686290740967,
0.4917667508125305,
0.33043861389160156,
0.11769604682922363,
0.32867029309272766,
0.4219268560409546,
0.5808873176574707,
0.11080669611692429,
-0.3000509738922119,
-0.2633700370788574,
-0.15523134171962738,
-0.35819917917251587,
-0.21166612207889557,
0.7123938202857971,
0.38094866275787354,
0.14546537399291992,
-0.12872791290283203,
-0.08340508490800858,
-0.2357870191335678,
0.22153881192207336,
-0.5234485864639282,
0.13785085082054138,
0.13006919622421265,
-0.18548953533172607,
-0.21174754202365875,
0.14283062517642975,
-0.16220425069332123,
-0.22297970950603485,
-0.06877890974283218,
0.0760885700583458,
-0.11222372949123383,
-0.16196860373020172,
0.08421237021684647,
-0.052951350808143616,
-0.21441026031970978,
0.4690455198287964,
-0.8314645886421204,
0.5038231611251831,
0.7992138266563416,
0.7985426187515259,
-0.26619571447372437,
-0.3357512354850769,
-0.35453087091445923,
0.052370861172676086,
-0.49159717559814453,
0.3560037910938263,
-0.027699239552021027,
-0.7979698181152344,
0.10800255835056305,
0.1684987097978592,
-0.06509070843458176,
-0.46886512637138367,
0.5454676747322083,
-0.7232944965362549,
-0.06686196476221085,
-0.09406857937574387,
-0.5452598929405212,
0.06455589085817337,
0.316530704498291,
-0.7371712923049927,
0.9359666705131531,
-0.1806761622428894,
-0.8313932418823242,
0.20111116766929626,
-0.7006837129592896,
-0.31009989976882935,
-0.12502920627593994,
-0.28512170910835266,
-0.48346999287605286,
0.6755107045173645,
-0.15756350755691528,
0.11198123544454575,
-0.3250493109226227,
0.1491938680410385,
-0.2769389748573303,
-0.20882467925548553,
0.4997139573097229,
-0.37479668855667114,
0.7369891405105591,
0.043134886771440506,
-0.21033667027950287,
-0.14777709543704987,
-0.42672261595726013,
-0.21451108157634735,
0.20425082743167877,
-0.2605953812599182,
-0.38720330595970154,
0.3389260768890381,
0.13248249888420105,
0.01337773073464632,
-0.1937893033027649,
-0.2931459844112396,
0.6483190059661865,
-0.23677457869052887,
0.6718130707740784,
0.7509948015213013,
0.3578493893146515,
0.3623926043510437,
0.007687228731811047,
0.45900675654411316,
0.07139002531766891,
0.41576087474823,
0.05141555890440941,
-0.16631609201431274,
-1.0708993673324585,
-0.007654029410332441,
0.5858107209205627,
0.4251173436641693,
-0.29546231031417847,
0.00665765255689621,
-0.4382377862930298,
-0.5594831109046936,
-0.27715083956718445,
0.09347546845674515,
0.27690526843070984,
0.4184415638446808,
0.08725536614656448,
-0.000024761358872638084,
-0.173259437084198,
-0.9993956089019775,
-0.17271874845027924,
-0.6841161251068115,
0.1181861013174057,
-0.11957737058401108,
0.758404016494751,
-0.46410372853279114,
1.0279366970062256,
-0.6908755302429199,
-0.2641739249229431,
-0.20044472813606262,
0.253976434469223,
0.20841404795646667,
0.6609910726547241,
0.48972195386886597,
-0.7790822982788086,
-0.0075822919607162476,
-0.08425281941890717,
-0.31805434823036194,
-0.04145267233252525,
-0.4082624912261963,
0.1238129660487175,
0.2638329267501831,
0.7609577775001526,
-0.6097074151039124,
0.6781773567199707,
0.39624089002609253,
-0.14453986287117004,
0.6859096884727478,
-0.36756041646003723,
0.2610248923301697,
-1.1621359586715698,
-0.26217886805534363,
-0.3145308792591095,
-0.16392186284065247,
-0.542544424533844,
0.326045960187912,
0.1679309606552124,
0.038024965673685074,
-0.6752079725265503,
0.38371071219444275,
-0.5227125883102417,
-0.08477980643510818,
-0.2373882532119751,
0.33687707781791687,
-0.04741326719522476,
-0.026266295462846756,
-0.15016970038414001,
0.8259046077728271,
0.19690975546836853,
-0.7375524044036865,
0.22761084139347076,
0.5268141031265259,
0.028881574049592018,
-0.11162573844194412,
-0.7457419633865356,
0.12502256035804749,
-0.08029849082231522,
-0.09328047931194305,
-0.955971360206604,
0.029075149446725845,
-0.04683021456003189,
-0.4382456839084625,
0.4761676490306854,
-0.35564935207366943,
-0.5973364114761353,
-0.007837837561964989,
-0.29154837131500244,
0.21492955088615417,
0.19080793857574463,
-0.4950616657733917,
0.4599444568157196,
0.3033231198787689,
-0.14450661838054657,
-0.29984191060066223,
-0.9330671429634094,
0.3605440557003021,
-0.30817073583602905,
-0.7588391304016113,
0.31645894050598145,
-0.4927530288696289,
-0.8130215406417847,
0.08780492842197418,
-0.14935269951820374,
0.028376873582601547,
0.4746154546737671,
0.3916985094547272,
0.41581863164901733,
-0.015025381930172443,
0.16664475202560425,
0.25398480892181396,
-0.14168141782283783,
0.09958512336015701,
0.23531238734722137,
0.30840861797332764,
-0.15303371846675873,
-0.4054727256298065,
-0.3644789159297943,
0.2635069191455841,
1.2175874710083008,
-0.11067643016576767,
0.8761543035507202,
-0.16196425259113312,
-0.26226353645324707,
-0.21717128157615662,
-0.4804899990558624,
-0.20173852145671844,
-0.4626201093196869,
0.38198116421699524,
-0.42256414890289307,
-0.7087349891662598,
0.9012485146522522,
-0.2503015398979187,
0.35520416498184204,
0.5732461810112,
0.6657833456993103,
-0.06616966426372528,
0.7375597357749939,
1.0015946626663208,
-0.028381194919347763,
0.36936521530151367,
-0.35068854689598083,
0.24845169484615326,
-0.9874448776245117,
0.0021887465845793486,
-0.6431506872177124,
-0.06278889626264572,
-0.8000487089157104,
-0.36449140310287476,
0.4629257917404175,
0.18823601305484772,
0.08681143075227737,
0.25713735818862915,
-0.16516490280628204,
0.46972745656967163,
0.16632206737995148,
-0.21247580647468567,
0.45958393812179565,
0.04080581292510033,
-0.2262667864561081,
-0.28025269508361816,
-0.529772162437439,
-0.6589812636375427,
0.6562826037406921,
0.4100496172904968,
0.9213513731956482,
0.20459969341754913,
0.8660608530044556,
0.34127429127693176,
0.4991151690483093,
-0.6024805307388306,
0.29381173849105835,
0.015702074393630028,
-0.8067859411239624,
-0.3549160659313202,
-0.1420256346464157,
-0.3956719934940338,
0.043369028717279434,
0.08709101378917694,
-0.48787352442741394,
0.40017667412757874,
0.13817967474460602,
-0.5536181330680847,
0.319740355014801,
-0.37134259939193726,
0.9303081035614014,
-0.12150108814239502,
-0.18788151443004608,
-0.039170049130916595,
-0.3873915672302246,
0.4706784784793854,
-0.08800143748521805,
0.4504263699054718,
0.06870822608470917,
-0.31589820981025696,
0.5612560510635376,
-0.7430802583694458,
0.46688899397850037,
0.31797969341278076,
-0.2831398844718933,
-0.062463872134685516,
0.39084404706954956,
0.6358263492584229,
0.47867584228515625,
0.050666943192481995,
0.008277847431600094,
-0.2395264059305191,
-0.1260599046945572,
-0.9834473729133606,
0.926670491695404,
-0.8085668087005615,
-0.6732882857322693,
-0.6601307988166809,
-0.3605368137359619,
-0.15707656741142273,
-0.18743421137332916,
0.48624205589294434,
0.6537461876869202,
-0.25101637840270996,
-0.06456445157527924,
0.7645485401153564,
0.13324841856956482,
0.8999282717704773,
0.7706277966499329,
-0.2964843809604645,
-0.615398108959198,
0.2066260576248169,
0.368416965007782,
0.6343905925750732,
-0.39189913868904114,
-0.26439914107322693,
-0.10837318748235703,
-1.0382791757583618,
-0.5336868166923523,
0.40605559945106506,
-0.8915401697158813,
0.03764322027564049,
-0.11763371527194977,
-0.25755536556243896,
-0.42965954542160034,
-0.25330913066864014,
-0.6041727662086487,
-0.30470916628837585,
-0.4716828167438507,
-0.3537370264530182,
0.11165831983089447,
0.9667508006095886,
-0.17804090678691864,
0.5524317026138306,
-0.8539853692054749,
0.12533454596996307,
0.06710932403802872,
0.0344204343855381,
-0.1829667091369629,
-0.9012799859046936,
-0.3694576025009155,
-0.21872897446155548,
-0.10989676415920258,
-1.247571349143982,
0.3200889825820923,
0.17460988461971283,
0.21870827674865723,
0.7209300994873047,
-0.032787539064884186,
1.0813740491867065,
-0.7218006253242493,
0.556185781955719,
0.111360102891922,
-1.1520273685455322,
0.28126946091651917,
-0.35071760416030884,
0.17455442249774933,
0.6964474320411682,
0.15205630660057068,
-0.9172337055206299,
-0.642187774181366,
-0.7740200757980347,
-0.9508217573165894,
0.636054277420044,
0.4158236086368561,
0.13718172907829285,
-0.0807558223605156,
0.8796311616897583,
-0.20261676609516144,
-0.04720555618405342,
-0.6854262948036194,
-0.701801598072052,
0.5316076874732971,
0.3715614378452301,
-0.006149234715849161,
-0.6145924925804138,
-0.2496441751718521,
-0.35910165309906006,
0.9169533252716064,
0.05207233130931854,
-0.20180293917655945,
0.3501121401786804,
-0.41237297654151917,
-0.08739282935857773,
0.4247511029243469,
1.019318699836731,
0.948521614074707,
0.06537777185440063,
0.047306932508945465,
0.28542888164520264,
-0.40981578826904297,
0.355749249458313,
-0.16885361075401306,
-0.6642053723335266,
0.2373487949371338,
0.4505358636379242,
0.8862124085426331,
0.40138983726501465,
-0.449651837348938,
0.0891498550772667,
-0.3786931037902832,
-0.05578627809882164,
-0.5544406771659851,
-0.1984252631664276,
0.065227210521698,
-0.03274606913328171,
0.705900251865387,
0.09645263105630875,
0.04740569740533829,
-0.6477211117744446,
0.24905836582183838,
0.3811882734298706,
-0.20107123255729675,
-0.17830410599708557,
0.7132411599159241,
0.08292488753795624,
-0.25791215896606445,
0.7226660847663879,
-0.08680737763643265,
-0.848290205001831,
0.5736374258995056,
0.3281998932361603,
0.8421754240989685,
-0.285770058631897,
0.16648763418197632,
0.14411744475364685,
0.9640176296234131,
-0.23368579149246216,
-0.10111286491155624,
0.24313946068286896,
-0.5881631374359131,
-0.5186290144920349,
-0.4275479018688202,
-0.4730013608932495,
0.11771503835916519,
-0.7400841116905212,
0.2972370386123657,
-0.5235707759857178,
-0.33818021416664124,
-0.4179109036922455,
-0.14702820777893066,
-0.038270846009254456,
0.30521610379219055,
0.23784376680850983,
0.9636778235435486,
-1.1088082790374756,
0.49851304292678833,
0.5718628764152527,
-0.49246013164520264,
-0.6205634474754333,
0.1861608326435089,
0.051649268716573715,
-0.3034677803516388,
0.8366368412971497,
-0.2776738107204437,
0.02825041301548481,
0.024089738726615906,
-0.4074994623661041,
-1.0131635665893555,
0.6021276116371155,
0.7030906677246094,
-0.6659169793128967,
-0.2623957693576813,
0.3888860046863556,
0.4231833517551422,
-0.2979154884815216,
0.15997940301895142,
0.8054476976394653,
0.6615872979164124,
0.11131977289915085,
-0.9586333632469177,
-0.03618176281452179,
0.09724458307027817,
0.03983381763100624,
0.6661823391914368,
-0.6216981410980225,
0.8840869665145874,
-0.24035508930683136,
-0.41746824979782104,
0.09127216786146164,
0.6083173155784607,
-0.10970333218574524,
-0.15292741358280182,
0.4893638789653778,
1.0257278680801392,
0.385000616312027,
-0.3800264596939087,
0.8861298561096191,
-0.38406822085380554,
0.6990182399749756,
1.0191398859024048,
-0.028540950268507004,
1.0224406719207764,
0.5355309844017029,
-0.20767779648303986,
0.43242311477661133,
0.893722414970398,
0.09776780009269714,
0.12503942847251892,
0.2855382561683655,
-0.3449077904224396,
-0.459409236907959,
0.1549682319164276,
-0.17788687348365784,
0.2932150661945343,
0.4011397063732147,
-0.2891831696033478,
-0.4968315660953522,
0.14900395274162292,
0.46995386481285095,
-0.09267310798168182,
-0.24574296176433563,
0.6705695390701294,
0.14589151740074158,
-0.48149847984313965,
0.5760705471038818,
0.1246243491768837,
-0.06000157818198204,
-0.3758294880390167,
0.1246529296040535,
-0.41671687364578247,
0.20286697149276733,
-0.16107772290706635,
-0.22650572657585144,
0.3847486078739166,
0.0979386568069458,
-0.39188531041145325,
-0.30325934290885925,
0.09541002660989761,
-0.42385369539260864,
-0.5809856057167053,
0.48252421617507935,
0.1935233771800995,
0.11628121882677078,
-0.16994144022464752,
-0.6176537275314331,
0.8494976758956909,
-0.19386237859725952,
-0.2779252827167511,
0.04665987193584442,
0.042556241154670715,
-0.04455870762467384,
0.5535126328468323,
0.4131324589252472,
0.15251003205776215,
0.1951320767402649,
-0.2460974007844925,
1.0860130786895752,
-0.6052258014678955,
-0.07188846170902252,
-1.1633001565933228,
0.8396602869033813,
-0.045370232313871384,
-0.21684685349464417,
0.8669753074645996,
0.5777375102043152,
0.44818857312202454,
0.10434195399284363,
0.6260851621627808,
-0.010450155474245548,
0.16769175231456757,
-0.49568769335746765,
1.0109142065048218,
-0.8244554996490479,
0.288666307926178,
-0.13652217388153076,
-0.9084926247596741,
-0.42508837580680847,
-0.003888428909704089,
-0.06967610120773315,
-0.40965354442596436,
1.0837100744247437,
0.5609838366508484,
0.31754255294799805,
-0.6923180222511292,
0.46124976873397827,
0.4703742265701294,
0.47020232677459717,
0.2547728717327118,
0.6624515652656555,
-0.5739809274673462,
0.615413248538971,
0.112505242228508,
-0.02601459249854088,
-0.2178550362586975,
-0.7995907664299011,
-0.675275444984436,
-0.6509723663330078,
-0.6406509876251221,
-0.500694990158081,
0.29695987701416016,
0.6032856106758118,
0.42762935161590576,
-0.6886811256408691,
-0.2077716886997223,
-0.0340891107916832,
0.35524460673332214,
0.1696529984474182,
-0.11826696246862411,
0.32335755228996277,
-0.530430257320404,
-1.0192309617996216,
0.5045446157455444,
0.5179381370544434,
0.26602107286453247,
-0.47708678245544434,
-0.00948786549270153,
-0.03934154659509659,
0.11404720693826675,
-0.004610030446201563,
0.4657749831676483,
-0.9855948090553284,
-0.014625259675085545,
-0.14056220650672913,
-0.10771109908819199,
0.06869381666183472,
0.9250292778015137,
-0.411255806684494,
0.3813778758049011,
0.4735596477985382,
0.3927061855792999,
0.16423073410987854,
0.0683017149567604,
0.7487412095069885,
-0.5961326956748962,
0.10725705325603485,
-0.07511839270591736,
0.5979352593421936,
0.28065598011016846,
-0.09734775125980377,
0.2362307459115982,
0.3646378815174103,
-0.5807520747184753,
-1.3210340738296509,
0.20731037855148315,
-0.6586405038833618,
-0.1871996968984604,
0.8975757956504822,
-0.15112166106700897,
-0.5349196791648865,
0.045133594423532486,
-0.052436571568250656,
0.2612869143486023,
-0.1168835461139679,
0.7694197297096252,
1.150691270828247,
-0.09512555599212646,
-0.12527996301651,
-0.4177473485469818,
0.6987062692642212,
0.2500442564487457,
-0.6085516810417175,
0.337505966424942,
0.5196733474731445,
0.36095350980758667,
0.47317832708358765,
0.09589497745037079,
-0.1883343905210495,
0.39064115285873413,
-0.4238598942756653,
0.10566212981939316,
-0.11706314980983734,
-0.42396870255470276,
-0.7210106253623962,
0.3870057165622711,
0.6011489629745483,
-0.06536698341369629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11260v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11260v1 | Adversarial Style Augmentation via Large Language Model for Robust Fake News Detection | 2024-06-17T07:00:41 | 2024-06-17T07:00:41 | Sungwon Park, Sungwon Han, Meeyoung Cha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The spread of fake news negatively impacts individuals and is regarded as a
significant social challenge that needs to be addressed. A number of
algorithmic and insightful features have been identified for detecting fake
news. However, with the recent LLMs and their advanced generation capabilities,
many of the detectable features (e.g., style-conversion attacks) can be
altered, making it more challenging to distinguish from real news. This study
proposes adversarial style augmentation, AdStyle, to train a fake news detector
that remains robust against various style-conversion attacks. Our model's key
mechanism is the careful use of LLMs to automatically generate a diverse yet
coherent range of style-conversion attack prompts. This improves the generation
of prompts that are particularly difficult for the detector to handle.
Experiments show that our augmentation strategy improves robustness and
detection performance when tested on fake news benchmark datasets. | [
-0.4289848506450653,
-1.219659447669983,
0.3726118803024292,
0.160497784614563,
-0.381063312292099,
0.21963326632976532,
-0.28324976563453674,
-0.5046778321266174,
0.34395405650138855,
0.4170050024986267,
-0.59770667552948,
-0.3000282049179077,
-0.7900106906890869,
0.10243262350559235,
-0.6267449855804443,
0.9773223400115967,
-0.06225678697228432,
0.1296055167913437,
0.1277981847524643,
-0.08714430034160614,
-0.2184588611125946,
-0.5339925289154053,
-0.7344022989273071,
0.06416942924261093,
0.28821179270744324,
0.1465899646282196,
0.7670101523399353,
0.4959789514541626,
0.20096126198768616,
0.2392289936542511,
-0.01698562316596508,
0.5816214680671692,
-0.44698044657707214,
0.0030258898623287678,
0.026182634755969048,
-0.5622992515563965,
-0.3613673448562622,
0.19689014554023743,
0.411270409822464,
0.14230524003505707,
0.17753180861473083,
0.08525791764259338,
-0.16808399558067322,
0.4519349932670593,
-0.4911612868309021,
-0.2794348895549774,
-0.8248229026794434,
-0.14637182652950287,
-0.2986595630645752,
-0.30788442492485046,
-0.467187762260437,
-0.4105154275894165,
-0.3877503275871277,
-0.47771963477134705,
0.3251798748970032,
-0.03004261665046215,
0.8091661930084229,
-0.04356304556131363,
-0.6162617802619934,
-0.33926454186439514,
-0.6898502111434937,
0.41410544514656067,
-0.6961228251457214,
0.2717408835887909,
-0.031421225517988205,
0.3986440598964691,
-0.2987543046474457,
-0.5469552278518677,
-0.9408366084098816,
-0.3362008333206177,
0.03308779001235962,
-0.019023656845092773,
-0.31844204664230347,
-0.17947635054588318,
0.12354986369609833,
0.24062985181808472,
-0.583838701248169,
0.08368896692991257,
-0.23555214703083038,
-0.4012562930583954,
0.6622523665428162,
-0.1497589647769928,
0.5891622304916382,
-0.11720166355371475,
-0.4335705041885376,
-0.2616214156150818,
-0.7860495448112488,
-0.19311577081680298,
0.8724856972694397,
0.31822651624679565,
-0.03280319273471832,
0.2925698161125183,
-0.28548815846443176,
0.5155397653579712,
0.14617906510829926,
-0.27965831756591797,
0.13930368423461914,
-0.277364045381546,
0.03739940747618675,
0.24382507801055908,
0.6481075286865234,
0.35592514276504517,
0.19641508162021637,
0.11042739450931549,
-0.4294464886188507,
0.42554372549057007,
0.5313238501548767,
-0.7434073090553284,
-0.18112026154994965,
-0.12308342754840851,
-0.23792396485805511,
-0.859788179397583,
0.11235600709915161,
-0.5304404497146606,
-0.6335608959197998,
-0.22256867587566376,
0.5520178079605103,
-0.4948233962059021,
-0.14940859377384186,
0.10940959304571152,
-0.15071700513362885,
0.07762135565280914,
0.6027043461799622,
-0.3065520226955414,
-0.05197993665933609,
0.4897460341453552,
0.7633060812950134,
-0.07599455118179321,
-0.0040537286549806595,
-0.6908864378929138,
-0.08572851121425629,
-0.7222268581390381,
0.8440109491348267,
-0.41851818561553955,
-0.04459654539823532,
0.035587865859270096,
-0.006011015735566616,
0.2808900475502014,
-0.35490182042121887,
0.5763034820556641,
-0.89567631483078,
0.32995498180389404,
-0.12786734104156494,
-0.2740778625011444,
-0.14229486882686615,
0.46106067299842834,
-0.697418749332428,
0.8526409864425659,
0.09489548951387405,
-0.5989950299263,
0.3558993339538574,
-0.5023009181022644,
-0.7839335203170776,
0.027505166828632355,
0.15954674780368805,
-0.661564826965332,
0.12075526267290115,
0.6199659705162048,
0.21520604193210602,
0.27435120940208435,
0.19625741243362427,
-0.6254370808601379,
-0.41092565655708313,
0.4608422517776489,
-0.8931981325149536,
0.6123233437538147,
0.371724009513855,
-0.3704680800437927,
0.14041724801063538,
-0.7181570529937744,
-0.3560662269592285,
0.3413122892379761,
-0.3096824884414673,
-0.2980448603630066,
-0.3182508945465088,
0.17307288944721222,
0.13499419391155243,
0.26942741870880127,
-0.4288453757762909,
0.3583790361881256,
-0.34311869740486145,
0.27608901262283325,
0.8362966179847717,
0.0697893351316452,
0.4197259247303009,
-0.3509303033351898,
0.383419394493103,
-0.038368333131074905,
0.17162010073661804,
-0.296824187040329,
-0.24354681372642517,
-0.704889714717865,
-0.24742408096790314,
0.17440427839756012,
0.5915841460227966,
-1.1352331638336182,
0.47352465987205505,
-0.039760950952768326,
-0.32183557748794556,
-0.47505566477775574,
0.21893340349197388,
0.22708848118782043,
0.3391980528831482,
0.3844939172267914,
0.14814434945583344,
-0.5826974511146545,
-0.6868816614151001,
-0.7951741218566895,
-0.047653213143348694,
-0.06413189321756363,
-0.10713707655668259,
0.4358587861061096,
-0.34313735365867615,
0.6307060718536377,
-0.28534677624702454,
-0.1150260716676712,
-0.3897349238395691,
0.005243772640824318,
0.0020147247705608606,
0.2066640555858612,
0.6804805994033813,
-1.0938501358032227,
-0.39013931155204773,
-0.2259051501750946,
-0.4866538345813751,
-0.28026846051216125,
-0.4077780842781067,
0.010410815477371216,
0.2926390469074249,
0.6647320985794067,
-0.365174800157547,
0.48649805784225464,
0.5426319241523743,
-0.33698275685310364,
0.7401098608970642,
0.18012474477291107,
0.34164169430732727,
-1.271896243095398,
-0.2742995321750641,
0.28804993629455566,
-0.6040714383125305,
-0.7800655961036682,
0.14870963990688324,
0.1899280697107315,
-0.2818624675273895,
-0.5006211400032043,
0.7607488036155701,
-0.2502211034297943,
0.09053067117929459,
-0.4729054272174835,
0.0015955541748553514,
0.3456586003303528,
0.1085987538099289,
-0.13678771257400513,
0.799647331237793,
0.3389667272567749,
-0.465688556432724,
0.9007928371429443,
-0.17124223709106445,
-0.2908326983451843,
0.6407650709152222,
-0.5385234355926514,
0.11028704792261124,
-0.16036492586135864,
0.7459678649902344,
-1.1776882410049438,
-0.41878026723861694,
0.34988734126091003,
-0.6602767705917358,
0.5031769871711731,
-0.16472969949245453,
-0.8699299693107605,
-0.2838290333747864,
-0.5900733470916748,
0.028844615444540977,
0.23687340319156647,
-0.8441054224967957,
0.4778645634651184,
0.13694003224372864,
0.09885664284229279,
-0.31711819767951965,
-0.6359657049179077,
0.48453763127326965,
-0.40970778465270996,
-0.9342657327651978,
0.4256857931613922,
-0.05555811524391174,
-0.23596522212028503,
-0.10289613902568817,
-0.08497448265552521,
0.2537749409675598,
0.17854337394237518,
-0.3395690321922302,
0.3288634121417999,
-0.18029873073101044,
-0.11772851645946503,
0.03870916739106178,
0.3299122452735901,
-0.00020698236767202616,
-0.2070879340171814,
0.5626084804534912,
-0.11227120459079742,
-0.400803804397583,
-0.6919134855270386,
0.23582296073436737,
0.8950937390327454,
-0.06242196261882782,
0.8339129686355591,
1.0002143383026123,
-0.4812280535697937,
-0.5675223469734192,
-0.6797844767570496,
-0.4620409309864044,
-0.5289260149002075,
0.4422253966331482,
-0.13562710583209991,
-0.5811039209365845,
0.3663102984428406,
-0.017933014780282974,
-0.15851719677448273,
0.11209847033023834,
0.3010105490684509,
0.15957169234752655,
1.3261784315109253,
0.4343400299549103,
-0.19257239997386932,
0.7079994678497314,
-0.10790939629077911,
0.21015800535678864,
-0.5278091430664062,
0.04973340779542923,
0.030744357034564018,
-0.38278478384017944,
-0.45858776569366455,
-0.34301838278770447,
0.539959728717804,
0.05484500154852867,
0.048612430691719055,
0.3222810924053192,
-0.36026424169540405,
0.27562153339385986,
0.49610820412635803,
0.46810653805732727,
0.25929969549179077,
0.3311840295791626,
0.4198054373264313,
-0.0009170866687782109,
-0.4523506760597229,
-0.3901333808898926,
0.9500073194503784,
0.5353825092315674,
0.9591909050941467,
0.3189721703529358,
0.33636394143104553,
0.6536138653755188,
0.39781174063682556,
-0.8723811507225037,
0.504259467124939,
-0.3750864267349243,
-0.3721301555633545,
-0.08579704165458679,
-0.3570452332496643,
-0.3998590111732483,
0.2045334279537201,
-0.35333386063575745,
-0.2026543915271759,
0.0328967347741127,
0.3357650637626648,
-0.08346845209598541,
0.5784556865692139,
-0.5586344003677368,
0.39972302317619324,
-0.33153438568115234,
-0.08526435494422913,
-0.07099537551403046,
-0.23940689861774445,
0.5511888861656189,
-0.2284768521785736,
0.26903295516967773,
0.2059863954782486,
-0.002090418478474021,
0.4994989037513733,
-0.2985305190086365,
1.0648748874664307,
0.08237502723932266,
-0.12743167579174042,
0.12417048215866089,
0.24635612964630127,
1.0642991065979004,
0.12380857765674591,
0.1287163347005844,
0.02615094743669033,
-0.6136837005615234,
-0.36619648337364197,
-0.6245904564857483,
0.7119002342224121,
-0.5817518830299377,
-0.8060649633407593,
-0.4039295017719269,
-0.6411516070365906,
-0.31543853878974915,
0.055121615529060364,
0.5100840330123901,
0.5130569338798523,
-0.23892267048358917,
0.17791397869586945,
0.759781002998352,
-0.22032898664474487,
0.14386016130447388,
0.5104545950889587,
-0.16233062744140625,
-0.41148510575294495,
0.8974342942237854,
0.2017064094543457,
0.3004934787750244,
-0.013677885755896568,
0.23416438698768616,
-0.6001120209693909,
-0.6470759510993958,
-0.7789520025253296,
0.10396456718444824,
-0.7260441184043884,
-0.08606576919555664,
-0.43628379702568054,
-0.3259142339229584,
-1.0618226528167725,
-0.44150209426879883,
-0.3027297854423523,
-0.22368256747722626,
-0.49020621180534363,
-0.002428572392091155,
0.5518530607223511,
0.627395749092102,
0.10242959856987,
0.41314074397087097,
-0.49837684631347656,
0.6401672959327698,
0.48503562808036804,
-0.11671522259712219,
-0.4908279478549957,
-1.035788893699646,
0.059176553040742874,
0.2018440067768097,
-0.32666435837745667,
-1.0714690685272217,
0.6233551502227783,
0.0035327132791280746,
0.37086281180381775,
0.5872471332550049,
0.2541317939758301,
0.602108359336853,
-0.2714773118495941,
0.6670445203781128,
0.051606979221105576,
-0.7564628720283508,
0.6946157217025757,
-0.6196454167366028,
-0.0035468502901494503,
0.2582798898220062,
0.33327963948249817,
-0.49991029500961304,
-0.3824347257614136,
-0.6766476035118103,
-0.6676994562149048,
0.6038317084312439,
0.022091064602136612,
0.4140724837779999,
-0.00010279155685566366,
0.2078549861907959,
-0.21841567754745483,
0.32064053416252136,
-0.8844946026802063,
-0.25075235962867737,
-0.43323400616645813,
-0.06353864818811417,
0.1977682113647461,
-0.15269999206066132,
-0.2682555913925171,
0.02523820661008358,
0.8988720178604126,
-0.23251909017562866,
-0.05035155639052391,
-0.027310948818922043,
-0.1909511685371399,
-0.021678294986486435,
0.29068663716316223,
0.8058063983917236,
0.34162867069244385,
0.11369743943214417,
0.11958279460668564,
0.1428854912519455,
-0.4003380835056305,
0.003046217141672969,
0.16731621325016022,
-0.39004266262054443,
0.18711808323860168,
0.37771186232566833,
0.9332759380340576,
-0.2583111524581909,
-0.39319923520088196,
0.7347227334976196,
-0.01850275695323944,
-0.1199498251080513,
-0.39760470390319824,
0.1426321119070053,
-0.2236565798521042,
0.15968233346939087,
0.6620522737503052,
0.40176621079444885,
0.14283940196037292,
-0.9132221341133118,
0.2546880841255188,
0.7114276885986328,
-0.22151251137256622,
-0.27067336440086365,
0.6460099220275879,
0.22907498478889465,
-0.2358911633491516,
0.01937723346054554,
-0.4558214247226715,
-0.943832278251648,
0.5944907665252686,
0.9544815421104431,
0.5042096972465515,
-0.3961501717567444,
0.2861722409725189,
0.03742756322026253,
0.6017297506332397,
-0.28462812304496765,
-0.047092508524656296,
0.3590862452983856,
-0.8286919593811035,
-0.21455664932727814,
-0.6730512380599976,
-0.22787915170192719,
0.6994913816452026,
-0.40138697624206543,
0.619297206401825,
-0.4277123808860779,
0.11831830441951752,
-0.2293664664030075,
-0.11486371606588364,
-0.21461749076843262,
0.3411049544811249,
0.5268839597702026,
0.7870112657546997,
-1.085803747177124,
0.6259338855743408,
0.7964760661125183,
0.08947458863258362,
-0.4205138385295868,
0.46221479773521423,
0.562403678894043,
-0.8979046940803528,
0.4097498953342438,
0.34297114610671997,
-0.10588205605745316,
-0.1273188591003418,
-0.6682581305503845,
-0.7294192910194397,
0.6914891600608826,
0.6135408878326416,
-0.45456960797309875,
-0.08425488322973251,
-0.033047255128622055,
0.40953052043914795,
-0.5095512866973877,
-0.19591133296489716,
0.2789669334888458,
0.545204222202301,
0.15630415081977844,
-0.5255481004714966,
0.1801215261220932,
-0.17451919615268707,
0.06526800245046616,
0.13406725227832794,
-0.6494482159614563,
0.9029226899147034,
0.022049112245440483,
-0.37275707721710205,
-0.19152286648750305,
0.8503269553184509,
0.31877514719963074,
0.41624438762664795,
0.594243586063385,
0.5821123719215393,
0.5826496481895447,
-0.026487179100513458,
1.1170824766159058,
-0.2771120071411133,
0.03677445277571678,
0.7536198496818542,
-0.04094616323709488,
0.4344867169857025,
0.05110366269946098,
-0.029895439743995667,
0.5548881888389587,
0.5678993463516235,
-0.1280118077993393,
0.2916933596134186,
0.07300145924091339,
-0.5698211193084717,
-0.35755905508995056,
-0.15252548456192017,
-0.3777289390563965,
0.4638213813304901,
0.6679660081863403,
-0.4785799980163574,
-0.1143023893237114,
0.3847625255584717,
0.567761242389679,
0.420683354139328,
-0.5992616415023804,
0.4626365005970001,
-0.13744351267814636,
-0.3993106484413147,
0.5840041041374207,
0.2670571208000183,
1.1231777667999268,
-0.7039886713027954,
-0.015848467126488686,
-0.07674022018909454,
0.14670158922672272,
-0.187200129032135,
-0.6550287008285522,
0.20562025904655457,
-0.07349338382482529,
-0.08894707262516022,
-0.05549325793981552,
1.1534579992294312,
-0.545341432094574,
-0.6522250771522522,
0.15639494359493256,
0.19273266196250916,
-0.23172719776630402,
-0.3880966603755951,
-0.6626494526863098,
0.18203549087047577,
0.011345375329256058,
-0.41428136825561523,
0.40437260270118713,
0.2886071801185608,
-0.2709788382053375,
0.5864222645759583,
1.180328607559204,
0.4315398037433624,
0.06129295378923416,
0.09208345413208008,
1.0349912643432617,
-0.23797836899757385,
-0.6004651188850403,
-0.9062743186950684,
0.0012272654566913843,
-0.3779461979866028,
-0.12659583985805511,
1.0237212181091309,
0.28740644454956055,
0.8088424801826477,
0.08693814277648926,
0.9859634041786194,
0.29674068093299866,
0.4592128098011017,
-0.7305301427841187,
0.8217554688453674,
-0.6103633642196655,
0.4570005238056183,
-0.08799327909946442,
-0.6316469311714172,
-0.29868337512016296,
0.3516163229942322,
-0.29206955432891846,
0.08722183108329773,
0.34166592359542847,
0.9735978841781616,
-0.14342810213565826,
-0.2979130446910858,
0.420852929353714,
0.1797650009393692,
0.42271003127098083,
0.1035141572356224,
0.6387777328491211,
-0.40181538462638855,
0.8424879312515259,
-0.3256838619709015,
-0.17603453993797302,
-0.5509682893753052,
-0.8448731303215027,
-1.0471299886703491,
-0.23359334468841553,
-0.29479265213012695,
-0.8229248523712158,
0.2759461998939514,
0.754639208316803,
0.8023010492324829,
-0.7016097903251648,
0.37802854180336,
0.010801167227327824,
0.023481881245970726,
-0.06698594242334366,
-0.40043821930885315,
0.26026561856269836,
-0.23602721095085144,
-0.8804275989532471,
0.9096798896789551,
0.13524742424488068,
0.24521489441394806,
-0.5479137301445007,
0.20880334079265594,
0.0025552958250045776,
0.4866253137588501,
0.6225030422210693,
0.1889202892780304,
-0.7688347101211548,
-0.32794633507728577,
0.07588759064674377,
-0.19072598218917847,
-0.1536586880683899,
0.6985925436019897,
-0.7621322870254517,
0.49467024207115173,
0.5070825219154358,
0.7393311858177185,
0.11911827325820923,
0.3788721263408661,
0.4705452024936676,
-1.1784013509750366,
0.22246691584587097,
0.08983372151851654,
0.3676595687866211,
0.638016402721405,
-0.899648904800415,
0.07374298572540283,
0.6959377527236938,
-0.2963922619819641,
-1.0640443563461304,
0.52140873670578,
-0.6972965598106384,
-0.6442718505859375,
1.4767425060272217,
0.15847547352313995,
-0.39232906699180603,
-0.22797881066799164,
-0.22886250913143158,
0.1962103545665741,
-0.574246883392334,
0.7590392827987671,
0.4869087040424347,
0.07961960881948471,
-0.08673418313264847,
-0.40049314498901367,
0.6380408406257629,
0.10358058661222458,
-0.6932353973388672,
-0.10763867199420929,
0.5444998145103455,
0.4191252887248993,
0.2997516989707947,
0.33031392097473145,
-0.050665292888879776,
0.5022007822990417,
-0.14582471549510956,
-0.21580086648464203,
-0.41057446599006653,
-0.44452473521232605,
-0.38522961735725403,
0.0644192099571228,
-0.30532318353652954,
-0.022520339116454124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11258v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11258v1 | Enhancing Biomedical Knowledge Retrieval-Augmented Generation with Self-Rewarding Tree Search and Proximal Policy Optimization | 2024-06-17T06:48:31 | 2024-06-17T06:48:31 | Minda Hu, Licheng Zong, Hongru Wang, Jingyan Zhou, Jingjing Li, Yichen Gao, Kam-Fai Wong, Yu Li, Irwin King | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown great potential in the biomedical
domain with the advancement of retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). However,
existing retrieval-augmented approaches face challenges in addressing diverse
queries and documents, particularly for medical knowledge queries, resulting in
sub-optimal performance. To address these limitations, we propose a novel
plug-and-play LLM-based retrieval method called Self-Rewarding Tree Search
(SeRTS) based on Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) and a self-rewarding paradigm.
By combining the reasoning capabilities of LLMs with the effectiveness of tree
search, SeRTS boosts the zero-shot performance of retrieving high-quality and
informative results for RAG. We further enhance retrieval performance by
fine-tuning LLMs with Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) objectives using the
trajectories collected by SeRTS as feedback. Controlled experiments using the
BioASQ-QA dataset with GPT-3.5-Turbo and LLama2-7b demonstrate that our method
significantly improves the performance of the BM25 retriever and surpasses the
strong baseline of self-reflection in both efficiency and scalability.
Moreover, SeRTS generates higher-quality feedback for PPO training than
self-reflection. Our proposed method effectively adapts LLMs to document
retrieval tasks, enhancing their ability to retrieve highly relevant documents
for RAG in the context of medical knowledge queries. This work presents a
significant step forward in leveraging LLMs for accurate and comprehensive
biomedical question answering. | [
0.026558512821793556,
-0.558724582195282,
0.931671679019928,
-0.10616829991340637,
-0.37665268778800964,
0.3333427608013153,
0.1539018303155899,
-0.2926466763019562,
0.44072988629341125,
0.6578935384750366,
-0.443196564912796,
-0.3876212239265442,
-0.3787326514720917,
0.20838554203510284,
0.1817735731601715,
1.0602951049804688,
0.16618473827838898,
0.03033444471657276,
-0.4167575538158417,
0.065752774477005,
-0.18432532250881195,
-0.4349498748779297,
-0.5808820128440857,
-0.22983166575431824,
0.8877222537994385,
0.2677114009857178,
0.35124868154525757,
0.5977315306663513,
0.7005682587623596,
0.21529406309127808,
-0.28134649991989136,
0.508120596408844,
-0.49093055725097656,
0.324965238571167,
-0.362025648355484,
-0.3308935761451721,
-0.3386574387550354,
-0.3557550013065338,
0.4705314338207245,
0.15198524296283722,
-0.12781646847724915,
0.028945431113243103,
-0.01198504213243723,
0.6840503215789795,
-0.699727475643158,
0.17744693160057068,
-0.7494826316833496,
-0.05479063466191292,
-0.2675325274467468,
-0.937313437461853,
-0.19320647418498993,
-0.39840081334114075,
0.051342375576496124,
-0.590059220790863,
0.02536347135901451,
0.037235744297504425,
0.5879808068275452,
0.2669731080532074,
-0.462323397397995,
-0.27066269516944885,
-0.26404350996017456,
0.5321691632270813,
-0.8199454545974731,
0.2842455804347992,
0.45332783460617065,
0.2839169502258301,
-0.40623947978019714,
-0.6134918332099915,
-0.2556646168231964,
-0.28190723061561584,
-0.0656309500336647,
0.3945820927619934,
0.058547258377075195,
0.28178671002388,
0.04608054831624031,
0.2501080632209778,
-0.6032335758209229,
-0.06840158998966217,
-0.09093370288610458,
-0.11143834888935089,
0.5396890044212341,
0.02903534471988678,
-0.0181194469332695,
-0.46406546235084534,
-0.1359023153781891,
-0.191910520195961,
-0.9168781638145447,
0.1735815554857254,
0.005352785345166922,
0.09420893341302872,
0.5292867422103882,
0.5913339257240295,
-0.1919502168893814,
0.5760601162910461,
-0.1039910838007927,
-0.4359550178050995,
0.20381705462932587,
-0.36862826347351074,
0.03068491443991661,
-0.03709925711154938,
0.7544595003128052,
0.1328883171081543,
-0.264719694852829,
-0.2924938499927521,
-0.295981228351593,
-0.48381635546684265,
0.24586044251918793,
-0.9425662755966187,
-0.013515735045075417,
0.09883933514356613,
-0.2893981635570526,
-0.5652276873588562,
-0.45997267961502075,
-0.6447831988334656,
-0.3713020384311676,
0.06922996789216995,
0.7199493050575256,
-0.5843124985694885,
-0.04069211333990097,
-0.0011973031796514988,
0.03253680840134621,
-0.0872843861579895,
0.21135415136814117,
-0.7819340229034424,
0.020403094589710236,
0.43990540504455566,
0.7383294701576233,
-0.11454509943723679,
0.20008905231952667,
-0.7946496605873108,
0.4991700351238251,
-0.335724413394928,
0.7524036765098572,
-0.5687028765678406,
-0.564619779586792,
-0.19873081147670746,
0.03820713236927986,
0.04705750569701195,
-0.658454179763794,
0.5597261190414429,
-0.7508019804954529,
0.08239961415529251,
-0.3269398510456085,
-0.44191211462020874,
-0.03245489299297333,
0.2941364049911499,
-0.1464981883764267,
0.8227530717849731,
0.16344036161899567,
-0.7522425651550293,
0.218197762966156,
-0.6099931001663208,
-0.46831223368644714,
0.44802555441856384,
-0.6017551422119141,
-0.6122962832450867,
0.05339924991130829,
0.3417153060436249,
0.3949055075645447,
-0.24638791382312775,
0.44792622327804565,
-0.2062446027994156,
-0.16402702033519745,
0.09462042152881622,
-0.12843655049800873,
0.5216116309165955,
0.2807413935661316,
-0.25685441493988037,
0.029286473989486694,
-0.5625804662704468,
0.13865381479263306,
0.20772472023963928,
-0.29027223587036133,
-0.4144878387451172,
0.252702921628952,
-0.6436204314231873,
0.16719789803028107,
0.383472204208374,
-0.7819141745567322,
0.3936033546924591,
-0.6066691875457764,
0.23050904273986816,
0.5877761244773865,
0.36070534586906433,
0.13054293394088745,
-0.40620797872543335,
0.5483652353286743,
0.0668659508228302,
0.12467514723539352,
-0.13990114629268646,
-0.2903880476951599,
-0.019029811024665833,
-0.34499871730804443,
0.25306785106658936,
0.44737645983695984,
-0.8735389709472656,
0.3171660006046295,
-0.11201802641153336,
-0.3993688225746155,
-0.6762405633926392,
-0.13696090877056122,
0.5697372555732727,
0.8412689566612244,
0.6418371200561523,
-0.16419251263141632,
-0.44070908427238464,
-0.769008219242096,
-0.12054900079965591,
-0.17921361327171326,
-0.02706758677959442,
0.8347446918487549,
0.3146519958972931,
-0.23640771210193634,
0.9160212874412537,
-0.5291318893432617,
-0.3334701359272003,
0.06928334385156631,
0.12794075906276703,
0.3612155318260193,
0.42690566182136536,
0.34352028369903564,
-0.5815960168838501,
-0.20252558588981628,
0.11284911632537842,
-0.5308235287666321,
-0.22123558819293976,
0.05178622901439667,
0.008483926765620708,
0.16430963575839996,
0.2920210063457489,
-0.2905261218547821,
0.2781960964202881,
0.3326475918292999,
-0.19372738897800446,
0.6528621315956116,
-0.5697651505470276,
0.328794002532959,
-0.7821252346038818,
0.27993205189704895,
-0.4462587237358093,
-0.31957241892814636,
-0.01428068708628416,
-0.12683738768100739,
0.11269625276327133,
0.18222229182720184,
-0.26158663630485535,
0.4609420597553253,
-0.37852102518081665,
-0.18562602996826172,
-0.2968117892742157,
-0.04429585859179497,
0.04608982801437378,
0.24702873826026917,
-0.008751829154789448,
1.108608365058899,
0.31663885712623596,
-0.5314329862594604,
-0.0033638898748904467,
0.22241060435771942,
0.04387408867478371,
0.3017670512199402,
-0.5461118817329407,
-0.056010086089372635,
-0.3685623109340668,
0.23063907027244568,
-0.7303576469421387,
0.007683883886784315,
0.05062665045261383,
-0.39940962195396423,
0.3834872543811798,
-0.11552686989307404,
-0.5615337491035461,
-0.4529089629650116,
-0.30310386419296265,
0.36043885350227356,
0.5561217069625854,
-0.5372121930122375,
0.32518041133880615,
0.4407179653644562,
-0.23148113489151,
-0.5802863836288452,
-0.18341615796089172,
-0.059112560003995895,
-0.11343109607696533,
-0.3733927011489868,
0.5947750806808472,
-0.02648526057600975,
0.3715801239013672,
-0.06071576103568077,
-0.4134969115257263,
0.409951776266098,
0.02186240628361702,
-0.08166894316673279,
0.15295270085334778,
0.028366293758153915,
0.2781308889389038,
0.44568559527397156,
-0.06873273849487305,
0.04134829342365265,
-0.4487544596195221,
0.28605619072914124,
-0.015955952927470207,
-0.3124978840351105,
-0.059262845665216446,
0.050784528255462646,
0.17166341841220856,
-0.5407015681266785,
0.4237799346446991,
0.45330244302749634,
0.003110327059403062,
0.1287228763103485,
-0.6345925331115723,
-0.528071939945221,
-0.44878360629081726,
0.4293312430381775,
-0.5694822669029236,
-1.2829365730285645,
0.21167366206645966,
-0.37826621532440186,
0.03639354929327965,
0.4083619713783264,
0.547473132610321,
-0.4351116418838501,
1.332948088645935,
0.16025984287261963,
0.2614310681819916,
0.2825479209423065,
-0.24068181216716766,
0.07458315789699554,
-1.0831918716430664,
-0.4674825668334961,
-0.4364292323589325,
-0.07150972634553909,
-0.7463846802711487,
-0.5993152260780334,
0.9718278646469116,
0.1651843637228012,
-0.13097843527793884,
0.006732358131557703,
-0.7538755536079407,
0.3961509168148041,
0.6461571455001831,
0.40958303213119507,
0.4722039997577667,
0.04796213656663895,
-0.6111944317817688,
0.019367801025509834,
-1.06830894947052,
-0.30773305892944336,
1.0916755199432373,
0.09542150795459747,
0.6038026809692383,
-0.0027390625327825546,
1.1235724687576294,
-0.05846981704235077,
0.2789957523345947,
-0.3881702125072479,
0.493371844291687,
-0.27744749188423157,
-0.38145777583122253,
-0.38030296564102173,
-0.7737135291099548,
-1.315567135810852,
0.15692894160747528,
-0.12679749727249146,
-0.7578052878379822,
0.17207765579223633,
0.17062795162200928,
-0.47682449221611023,
0.2497587651014328,
-0.2483063042163849,
0.765823483467102,
-0.5395597219467163,
-0.6849958896636963,
-0.27229025959968567,
-0.8279985189437866,
0.23382046818733215,
-0.05392928421497345,
0.24540512263774872,
-0.21636657416820526,
-0.10815653204917908,
0.6764299869537354,
-0.2961861789226532,
0.35908031463623047,
-0.19959770143032074,
0.05482947826385498,
0.27697062492370605,
0.31559205055236816,
0.6223325133323669,
0.23401404917240143,
-0.015065397135913372,
-0.3029104769229889,
0.590114176273346,
-0.3083251416683197,
-0.5298159718513489,
0.638845682144165,
-0.7058318853378296,
-0.6857589483261108,
-0.550887942314148,
-0.7523383498191833,
-0.511527955532074,
0.285267174243927,
0.08366690576076508,
0.2910609245300293,
0.052270516753196716,
0.34688201546669006,
0.7986508011817932,
-0.4756809175014496,
0.08395064622163773,
0.788029670715332,
-0.49731701612472534,
-0.46920838952064514,
1.1208213567733765,
0.24123120307922363,
0.02923969365656376,
0.6537151336669922,
0.5988670587539673,
-0.6193575263023376,
-0.5991800427436829,
-0.18180713057518005,
0.5039117336273193,
-0.112545445561409,
-0.7263816595077515,
-0.8325548768043518,
-0.3641180992126465,
-0.5710667371749878,
0.14217795431613922,
-0.1499994546175003,
-0.36331427097320557,
-0.1828678399324417,
0.10817514359951019,
0.45470762252807617,
0.4852616488933563,
-0.43530410528182983,
0.3376755714416504,
-0.860750138759613,
0.31713154911994934,
0.34318938851356506,
0.4721232056617737,
-0.2922360599040985,
-0.4823661744594574,
-0.25753074884414673,
0.03234165906906128,
-0.5415324568748474,
-0.9978243112564087,
0.5197874903678894,
-0.02545413002371788,
0.566603422164917,
0.13530606031417847,
-0.04981759190559387,
0.5400669574737549,
-0.405355304479599,
0.19421978294849396,
0.06474484503269196,
-0.24100318551063538,
0.7392115592956543,
-0.6013867855072021,
0.19894391298294067,
0.5463388562202454,
0.3009846806526184,
-0.18913741409778595,
-0.3680127263069153,
-0.8521631956100464,
-0.8651949167251587,
0.6398124694824219,
0.23147052526474,
-0.3080778419971466,
-0.1829712688922882,
0.514297604560852,
-0.14912213385105133,
0.21570870280265808,
-0.2980002164840698,
0.12495587021112442,
-0.002268802607432008,
-0.19932492077350616,
0.08081967383623123,
-0.4556145668029785,
-0.247751384973526,
-0.2586643397808075,
0.9850687980651855,
-0.3792152404785156,
0.1540396511554718,
0.5867338180541992,
0.2532406449317932,
-0.14688585698604584,
0.30347341299057007,
0.2300744652748108,
0.3053477704524994,
-0.6149470806121826,
0.14237456023693085,
0.07247798889875412,
-0.2823212742805481,
0.12536506354808807,
0.24256283044815063,
-0.37146255373954773,
-0.08596396446228027,
-0.13939258456230164,
0.4713198244571686,
0.14683113992214203,
-0.8166152238845825,
0.403647780418396,
0.09739185124635696,
-0.17159241437911987,
0.15004266798496246,
0.21377688646316528,
0.17396895587444305,
0.34470728039741516,
0.46669599413871765,
-0.42935723066329956,
0.446210652589798,
-0.2489968240261078,
0.409219890832901,
0.7859457731246948,
-0.1146436482667923,
0.13316132128238678,
0.7143954634666443,
-0.0275057852268219,
-0.1835019290447235,
0.19218869507312775,
-0.33690154552459717,
-0.31449365615844727,
0.46661773324012756,
0.8019846677780151,
0.45861679315567017,
-0.3565419912338257,
0.35851171612739563,
0.5334258675575256,
0.08363094180822372,
0.03607620298862457,
0.3833109140396118,
-0.19414810836315155,
-0.40848806500434875,
-0.6342650651931763,
-0.7852932810783386,
-0.369651198387146,
0.03846914693713188,
-0.1995922178030014,
0.04165004938840866,
-0.08714465796947479,
-0.2624448835849762,
-0.3079642653465271,
0.3243510127067566,
-0.3520336151123047,
0.23639729619026184,
-0.2383047342300415,
0.7058088779449463,
-0.23917482793331146,
0.8178607821464539,
0.5436615943908691,
-0.45859766006469727,
-0.8628689646720886,
-0.27267393469810486,
-0.35947656631469727,
-0.9063794612884521,
0.5354366898536682,
-0.21974414587020874,
-0.052467573434114456,
0.40015909075737,
-0.40669935941696167,
-1.0605958700180054,
1.294943928718567,
0.30523690581321716,
-0.8521029353141785,
-0.3271869122982025,
0.10083456337451935,
0.6459570527076721,
-0.2243778258562088,
0.5523003935813904,
0.5854698419570923,
0.23996606469154358,
0.4887174367904663,
-0.7870204448699951,
-0.03856766223907471,
0.16421769559383392,
0.07435383647680283,
0.09953244030475616,
-0.5795606970787048,
0.2055288553237915,
-0.23040182888507843,
0.1816207319498062,
-0.08761551231145859,
0.4528592526912689,
1.0020756721496582,
0.404710054397583,
0.28637611865997314,
0.471567302942276,
0.7225049734115601,
0.20969600975513458,
1.0747628211975098,
-0.5019933581352234,
0.2911405563354492,
0.9027079343795776,
-0.05163184925913811,
0.5935811996459961,
0.6241084933280945,
-0.27931633591651917,
0.3248896896839142,
0.5552048087120056,
0.3035666048526764,
0.5791434645652771,
0.35260722041130066,
-0.312364786863327,
-0.31442755460739136,
-0.4232631027698517,
-0.46617063879966736,
0.19167113304138184,
0.38229355216026306,
-0.4088688790798187,
-0.3257302939891815,
-0.1104632169008255,
0.11419756710529327,
-0.07060619443655014,
-0.18447795510292053,
1.0192992687225342,
0.04640917107462883,
-0.7506409883499146,
0.47740671038627625,
-0.18975357711315155,
0.4027070701122284,
-0.6971387267112732,
-0.137408047914505,
-0.2696188986301422,
-0.09863471984863281,
-0.18934202194213867,
-0.8076192736625671,
0.11888101696968079,
-0.17109642922878265,
0.1469881385564804,
-0.18914353847503662,
0.8673717975616455,
-0.45191630721092224,
-0.4559301435947418,
0.20356304943561554,
0.6607304215431213,
0.24207636713981628,
-0.03900781273841858,
-0.7091671824455261,
-0.3337952792644501,
-0.039685461670160294,
-0.3389851748943329,
0.533318042755127,
0.6395660042762756,
-0.006976113189011812,
0.6099799871444702,
0.8389670252799988,
0.33643433451652527,
-0.1804865598678589,
-0.10280583798885345,
0.958551824092865,
-0.4457244277000427,
-0.35326799750328064,
-0.5661925077438354,
0.1028061956167221,
-0.006498128175735474,
0.14208175241947174,
0.40777793526649475,
0.8644071221351624,
0.4747786819934845,
0.13353535532951355,
0.6191509366035461,
-0.06796804815530777,
1.0266120433807373,
-0.37139755487442017,
0.6706922054290771,
-0.828907310962677,
0.27304160594940186,
-0.20492659509181976,
-0.6011332273483276,
-0.245258167386055,
0.6227191090583801,
-0.5172418355941772,
-0.010982349514961243,
0.5316584706306458,
0.974563479423523,
0.17496003210544586,
-0.2973468601703644,
0.39342713356018066,
0.4374515414237976,
0.49074020981788635,
0.5602756142616272,
0.5120536088943481,
-0.18689636886119843,
0.5687999129295349,
-0.16138732433319092,
-0.36032772064208984,
-0.2516616880893707,
-0.7420341968536377,
-0.4485815763473511,
-0.4593771696090698,
-0.09241271764039993,
-0.4168975353240967,
0.632681131362915,
0.7862675189971924,
0.6607389450073242,
-0.5758760571479797,
-0.18562637269496918,
-0.25600314140319824,
0.16657748818397522,
0.04237600043416023,
-0.19161352515220642,
0.5190434455871582,
-0.8305225372314453,
-0.22252458333969116,
0.5627970099449158,
0.4476815462112427,
-0.05979429557919502,
-0.07813204824924469,
-0.1735052466392517,
-0.3722682595252991,
-0.013831363059580326,
0.6171825528144836,
0.3689379096031189,
-0.39216649532318115,
-0.10290876775979996,
0.29173848032951355,
-0.21457238495349884,
0.28323861956596375,
0.7031570076942444,
-1.3358291387557983,
0.47785767912864685,
0.5180689096450806,
0.8937222361564636,
0.8839483857154846,
0.09114550054073334,
0.3226844370365143,
-0.5994002819061279,
-0.37504902482032776,
0.7153469324111938,
0.07404480129480362,
0.06304777413606644,
-0.47808364033699036,
0.7225751280784607,
0.3846922516822815,
-0.9788936376571655,
-0.730376124382019,
0.12137280404567719,
-0.8071431517601013,
-0.3046177923679352,
1.0389620065689087,
0.0881790891289711,
-0.3239626884460449,
0.15243209898471832,
-0.5024571418762207,
0.3931792080402374,
-0.39408257603645325,
1.003896713256836,
0.09779968112707138,
-0.5530645251274109,
-0.22571972012519836,
-0.412884920835495,
0.7866790294647217,
0.78049635887146,
-0.8993929624557495,
-0.2511497139930725,
0.4005841016769409,
0.17055559158325195,
-0.1456618309020996,
0.958042323589325,
-0.481293261051178,
0.28898555040359497,
-0.5406032800674438,
-0.04059239476919174,
-0.10608574748039246,
-0.30911123752593994,
-0.00956164114177227,
0.07438507676124573,
0.13862068951129913,
0.09591194987297058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11256v1 | Dynamic Data Mixing Maximizes Instruction Tuning for Mixture-of-Experts | 2024-06-17T06:47:03 | 2024-06-17T06:47:03 | Tong Zhu, Daize Dong, Xiaoye Qu, Jiacheng Ruan, Wenliang Chen, Yu Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) models have shown remarkable capability in
instruction tuning, especially when the number of tasks scales. However,
previous methods simply merge all training tasks (e.g. creative writing,
coding, and mathematics) and apply fixed sampling weights, without considering
the importance of different tasks as the model training state changes. In this
way, the most helpful data cannot be effectively distinguished, leading to
suboptimal model performance. To reduce the potential redundancies of datasets,
we make the first attempt and propose a novel dynamic data mixture for MoE
instruction tuning. Specifically, inspired by MoE's token routing preference,
we build dataset-level representations and then capture the subtle differences
among datasets. Finally, we propose to dynamically adjust the sampling weight
of datasets by their inter-redundancies, thus maximizing global performance
under a limited training budget. The experimental results on two MoE models
demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach on both downstream knowledge \&
reasoning tasks and open-ended queries. Code and models are available at
https://github.com/Spico197/MoE-SFT . | [
-0.5047763586044312,
-0.8065617084503174,
0.1313491314649582,
0.20639796555042267,
-0.26644718647003174,
0.42076337337493896,
-0.25291919708251953,
-0.26726940274238586,
0.3114635944366455,
0.41864079236984253,
-0.695121705532074,
-0.2747270166873932,
-0.6109483242034912,
-0.20565097033977509,
-0.47645440697669983,
0.7300227880477905,
0.026872573420405388,
0.10452920198440552,
-0.3662165105342865,
-0.07618818432092667,
-0.8470359444618225,
-0.06388784199953079,
-0.5010778307914734,
-0.22471165657043457,
0.49647390842437744,
0.6938672065734863,
0.3927435278892517,
1.089640498161316,
0.3350055515766144,
0.29598695039749146,
0.09915103018283844,
0.7157866954803467,
-0.622521698474884,
0.3868512809276581,
-0.19283534586429596,
-0.7634175419807434,
-0.4969376027584076,
-0.09496369957923889,
0.6447584629058838,
0.6389054656028748,
-0.4476974904537201,
-0.08780443668365479,
-0.003691885620355606,
0.568569540977478,
-0.7640851140022278,
0.09918323904275894,
-0.8539456725120544,
0.22599199414253235,
-0.2404680848121643,
-0.5243800282478333,
-0.28323695063591003,
-0.19139216840267181,
0.08283384889364243,
-0.7765706777572632,
0.2928359806537628,
-0.01990983821451664,
0.5147563815116882,
0.6450694799423218,
-0.6187379956245422,
-0.1772276610136032,
-0.6772180795669556,
0.9511926174163818,
-0.5022002458572388,
0.28428739309310913,
0.19775773584842682,
0.4089149236679077,
-0.17552095651626587,
-0.3154938519001007,
-0.4361249804496765,
0.1998468041419983,
0.2905612289905548,
0.28018155694007874,
0.0943366214632988,
-0.04296492412686348,
-0.036526113748550415,
0.5311052203178406,
-0.07687998563051224,
0.18063496053218842,
-0.3285161852836609,
0.06186281144618988,
0.719020664691925,
0.31061044335365295,
0.18674828112125397,
0.3304789662361145,
-0.4993022084236145,
-0.1786588728427887,
-0.5421066880226135,
-0.06275623291730881,
0.577366828918457,
0.035925596952438354,
-0.031783148646354675,
0.31047600507736206,
-0.3564218282699585,
0.883953332901001,
0.4217333197593689,
0.061552759259939194,
0.09636736661195755,
-0.17994160950183868,
0.011399383656680584,
0.12805995345115662,
0.35597866773605347,
0.48276814818382263,
0.1705724000930786,
-0.24831035733222961,
-0.3852360248565674,
-0.1635267436504364,
0.4406924545764923,
-0.6461008787155151,
-0.7268239259719849,
-0.008237519301474094,
-0.016611116006970406,
-0.49900391697883606,
0.19827066361904144,
-0.8362720608711243,
-0.3829018771648407,
-0.6764512062072754,
0.4101535677909851,
-0.3605515956878662,
-0.44253379106521606,
0.13290376961231232,
-0.13605822622776031,
-0.25544217228889465,
0.3099270462989807,
-1.1047481298446655,
0.19392868876457214,
0.8408887386322021,
0.49641796946525574,
-0.3449036180973053,
-0.12086217850446701,
-0.7298519611358643,
0.15361934900283813,
-0.30020177364349365,
0.6899079084396362,
-0.9737020134925842,
-0.47577691078186035,
-0.3565029203891754,
-0.49848467111587524,
-0.29581260681152344,
-0.8329123258590698,
0.00963252130895853,
-0.611827552318573,
0.07787603884935379,
-0.42170679569244385,
-0.7871392965316772,
-0.18626512587070465,
0.06413809955120087,
-0.5115377306938171,
1.266898274421692,
0.17344948649406433,
-0.5704725980758667,
0.4424488842487335,
-0.5863758325576782,
-0.5335355401039124,
-0.10569049417972565,
-0.3829343020915985,
-0.18229152262210846,
0.3141143023967743,
0.3763744831085205,
0.29913681745529175,
0.03743612766265869,
0.482422411441803,
-0.2106301486492157,
-0.6122792363166809,
0.055441055446863174,
-0.7035260796546936,
0.5511828660964966,
0.1266983300447464,
-0.3841332197189331,
0.13227687776088715,
-0.9312531352043152,
0.02334764413535595,
-0.07754503190517426,
-0.646050214767456,
-0.3768029510974884,
0.29803287982940674,
-0.3078474998474121,
-0.14100638031959534,
0.30594202876091003,
-0.2702142298221588,
0.4393618106842041,
-0.06305468827486038,
0.42582595348358154,
1.1285396814346313,
-0.03338802233338356,
0.5275824069976807,
-0.46576282382011414,
0.5578048229217529,
0.288944810628891,
0.0747699961066246,
-0.25503140687942505,
-0.563023567199707,
-0.9575701951980591,
-0.5103788375854492,
0.5900513529777527,
0.6964911818504333,
-0.8980507850646973,
0.6873971223831177,
-0.33524852991104126,
-0.4599992632865906,
-0.642406702041626,
0.13774697482585907,
0.06833985447883606,
0.6469548940658569,
0.524899959564209,
-0.20410336554050446,
-0.3181650936603546,
-0.6766436696052551,
-0.21317462623119354,
0.18079841136932373,
0.08595357090234756,
0.38881659507751465,
0.0893397107720375,
0.06070474535226822,
1.0434231758117676,
-0.6154803037643433,
0.21884380280971527,
-0.004818038549274206,
0.17021958529949188,
0.0729735791683197,
0.7654516100883484,
0.520552396774292,
-0.7984579205513,
-0.5740889310836792,
-0.059213798493146896,
-0.5530802607536316,
-0.27419379353523254,
-0.14746136963367462,
-0.6902006268501282,
-0.4098700284957886,
0.21618512272834778,
-0.371613085269928,
0.2141750603914261,
0.4339722990989685,
0.03232258930802345,
0.26938533782958984,
-0.28323832154273987,
0.19132137298583984,
-1.0243306159973145,
-0.40244168043136597,
-0.259724497795105,
-0.17277701199054718,
-0.2932485044002533,
0.21743537485599518,
0.1542653888463974,
0.022798500955104828,
-0.07379086315631866,
0.49083754420280457,
-0.42528584599494934,
0.23468266427516937,
-0.23585975170135498,
-0.21609172224998474,
-0.14848679304122925,
0.5730932354927063,
-0.23649542033672333,
0.859555184841156,
0.8158846497535706,
-0.7187133431434631,
0.6748932003974915,
0.018186941742897034,
-0.4161454737186432,
0.6709948778152466,
-0.5004225969314575,
0.08041639626026154,
0.06473049521446228,
0.1711236834526062,
-0.7597720623016357,
-0.5086313486099243,
0.2902958393096924,
-0.16958419978618622,
0.5938615798950195,
-0.17466121912002563,
-0.4978954493999481,
-0.12243548035621643,
-0.09921684116125107,
0.42116379737854004,
0.5950102210044861,
-0.5113434195518494,
0.7324870824813843,
0.3028717637062073,
-0.1570105105638504,
-0.5628538131713867,
-0.7395094037055969,
-0.16961520910263062,
-0.18800269067287445,
-0.4936268627643585,
0.5811213850975037,
-0.12245219200849533,
0.09414402395486832,
0.20799125730991364,
-0.5589526891708374,
-0.40140458941459656,
0.1915714144706726,
-0.08916915208101273,
0.22117380797863007,
-0.3273666203022003,
0.014226340688765049,
0.8386304378509521,
-0.11706478148698807,
-0.1412809193134308,
-0.41055434942245483,
0.3839093744754791,
0.3741472065448761,
-0.7370961904525757,
-0.4712900221347809,
0.5016027092933655,
0.637535035610199,
-0.4238079786300659,
0.835394561290741,
0.6327366232872009,
-0.12905867397785187,
-0.3927694261074066,
-0.5482540130615234,
-0.3925457298755646,
-0.5218753814697266,
0.40957897901535034,
-0.04702894017100334,
-0.49593862891197205,
0.47319817543029785,
-0.07555016130208969,
0.4335770606994629,
-0.08201079070568085,
0.28886133432388306,
-0.15161462128162384,
0.9592894911766052,
0.2551366090774536,
-0.17400869727134705,
0.8930659890174866,
-0.3208635151386261,
0.27441322803497314,
-0.5018479824066162,
-0.2338910549879074,
-0.03122294880449772,
-0.8743965029716492,
-0.37249481678009033,
-0.5032745599746704,
0.6559012532234192,
0.06160666048526764,
-0.05041380599141121,
-0.21228498220443726,
-0.5375158190727234,
0.7631339430809021,
0.9142587780952454,
0.41569793224334717,
0.07207055389881134,
0.3053310215473175,
-0.046354036778211594,
0.16758127510547638,
-1.19607412815094,
-0.12815214693546295,
1.1196293830871582,
-0.026695242151618004,
0.706687331199646,
-0.2275446057319641,
0.7794854044914246,
0.2595613896846771,
0.00595353776589036,
-0.4938373267650604,
0.7117764353752136,
-0.3063409626483917,
-0.6188585758209229,
-0.06681980192661285,
-0.7341471910476685,
-0.7136098146438599,
0.24757656455039978,
-0.36568978428840637,
-0.2081756442785263,
0.1361624300479889,
0.47598105669021606,
-0.41132211685180664,
0.5983105897903442,
-0.8431505560874939,
0.42500558495521545,
-0.30328306555747986,
-0.45982226729393005,
-0.41797417402267456,
-0.4789380431175232,
0.2655806541442871,
-0.1730901300907135,
-0.08973710238933563,
-0.06480572372674942,
-0.07583292573690414,
0.576924204826355,
-0.5000021457672119,
0.7192072868347168,
-0.29566827416419983,
-0.04684741422533989,
0.25617724657058716,
-0.05952553078532219,
0.47074151039123535,
-0.054995473474264145,
-0.15786214172840118,
0.11288748681545258,
-0.4058404266834259,
-0.7072017192840576,
-0.7897221446037292,
0.8204143643379211,
-0.7075022459030151,
-0.536638081073761,
0.07396034151315689,
-0.872782826423645,
-0.3164461553096771,
0.173570916056633,
0.16544444859027863,
0.6600428223609924,
0.4985814094543457,
0.5774537920951843,
1.0033882856369019,
0.03725077211856842,
0.018134059384465218,
0.381102979183197,
0.31600433588027954,
-0.3419923782348633,
1.1742193698883057,
0.3316434919834137,
0.19243009388446808,
0.6006417870521545,
0.15408851206302643,
0.04001724720001221,
-0.5064531564712524,
-0.5667470693588257,
-0.17946521937847137,
-0.4635084867477417,
-0.12320511043071747,
-0.41327738761901855,
-0.037548892199993134,
-0.019835473969578743,
-0.26473721861839294,
-0.5897261500358582,
-0.3106116056442261,
-0.5374400019645691,
-0.013211510144174099,
0.4037328064441681,
0.42423921823501587,
0.05448675900697708,
0.5689117312431335,
-0.887808620929718,
0.17376595735549927,
0.48706716299057007,
0.36231252551078796,
0.33663469552993774,
-0.27817678451538086,
-0.3635949194431305,
0.33063700795173645,
-0.4855134189128876,
-0.7045071721076965,
-0.02103210613131523,
0.23844464123249054,
0.7702173590660095,
0.629351019859314,
0.31940335035324097,
0.9345813393592834,
-0.4645002484321594,
0.5067692995071411,
-0.007230434566736221,
-0.6781054139137268,
0.3871276378631592,
-0.5263457894325256,
0.03731726109981537,
0.5216929316520691,
0.26866692304611206,
0.005503702908754349,
-0.4547542929649353,
-0.41332191228866577,
-1.0786949396133423,
0.8332159519195557,
0.22513598203659058,
0.258594810962677,
0.14775319397449493,
0.2615722119808197,
0.42035654187202454,
0.45936116576194763,
0.03584542125463486,
-0.20685335993766785,
-0.032457031309604645,
-0.8467185497283936,
0.3612363338470459,
0.045795563608407974,
-0.27106785774230957,
-0.509130597114563,
0.5214506387710571,
0.13595183193683624,
0.3862304985523224,
-0.4750973582267761,
0.08644383400678635,
-0.04229796305298805,
-0.22267396748065948,
0.45080476999282837,
0.7920216917991638,
-0.1110081747174263,
-0.040114875882864,
0.06792546063661575,
-0.5810175538063049,
-0.01978411339223385,
0.10305310040712357,
-0.28237462043762207,
-0.2143547385931015,
0.3444035053253174,
0.9978141784667969,
0.6808594465255737,
-0.6272695660591125,
0.2151380330324173,
0.1691880077123642,
-0.07858578860759735,
0.17549391090869904,
1.080977201461792,
-0.05723477154970169,
0.3869524598121643,
0.5451468229293823,
0.5248300433158875,
-0.20180650055408478,
-0.134069561958313,
0.12888585031032562,
0.08779345452785492,
0.20006868243217468,
-0.2123820036649704,
0.666861891746521,
0.6080725193023682,
-0.2344343662261963,
0.8518208265304565,
0.009866775013506413,
-0.36221644282341003,
0.7649794816970825,
0.17024575173854828,
0.5258246064186096,
-0.22378773987293243,
-0.028627891093492508,
-0.017391834408044815,
-0.000020418272470124066,
-0.06038390100002289,
0.2987609803676605,
-0.4707795977592468,
-0.5902537107467651,
-0.1520245373249054,
-0.2208295613527298,
-0.48556187748908997,
-0.14623616635799408,
-1.0004205703735352,
0.3469465374946594,
-0.3710249662399292,
-0.0740106925368309,
-0.38977083563804626,
-0.15879712998867035,
-0.5600229501724243,
0.21151341497898102,
-0.22219884395599365,
0.8307891488075256,
-0.7160844802856445,
0.6840989589691162,
0.846074640750885,
0.030571483075618744,
-0.6078352928161621,
0.07483964413404465,
-0.13078495860099792,
-0.8353081941604614,
0.20911739766597748,
-0.01785033941268921,
0.09577237814664841,
0.189396932721138,
-0.4097767174243927,
-0.629271388053894,
1.0400245189666748,
0.42569413781166077,
-0.7128849625587463,
-0.19415628910064697,
-0.1505347043275833,
0.12267083674669266,
-0.31151989102363586,
0.0842328891158104,
0.3348386585712433,
0.3349006474018097,
0.17661523818969727,
-0.5164667367935181,
-0.47403427958488464,
-0.34011781215667725,
-0.315684974193573,
0.22107282280921936,
-0.7366030812263489,
1.0189640522003174,
0.09956680238246918,
0.06983927637338638,
-0.19972245395183563,
0.8142160177230835,
0.2802066504955292,
0.5172719359397888,
0.6750918030738831,
0.5077155232429504,
1.2179040908813477,
-0.1685289740562439,
0.81800776720047,
-0.5769673585891724,
0.1385752409696579,
1.1239492893218994,
-0.04315713793039322,
0.6136333346366882,
0.2024541199207306,
-0.12530171871185303,
0.3593151271343231,
0.7873944044113159,
0.08417027443647385,
0.7949880361557007,
-0.06966093927621841,
-0.36639603972435,
-0.42074716091156006,
0.27151837944984436,
-0.4779910743236542,
0.3584478497505188,
0.3404753506183624,
-0.11664681136608124,
-0.10416049510240555,
-0.01576349511742592,
-0.14897571504116058,
-0.08267121016979218,
-0.26629966497421265,
0.5016294717788696,
-0.41118523478507996,
-0.6710823178291321,
0.6393136382102966,
-0.07399359345436096,
0.7293370366096497,
-0.6482771039009094,
-0.05296933650970459,
-0.4439745247364044,
0.13600096106529236,
-0.08708229660987854,
-0.7964013814926147,
0.027019016444683075,
0.04963110014796257,
-0.4049135744571686,
-0.2101830244064331,
0.30998581647872925,
-0.7988599538803101,
-0.4626934826374054,
-0.228544682264328,
0.1511683613061905,
-0.03840024396777153,
0.09257864207029343,
-0.6061229705810547,
0.028915217146277428,
0.16259437799453735,
-0.09197306632995605,
0.4009137749671936,
0.7122690081596375,
0.12663714587688446,
0.7574434876441956,
0.552212655544281,
0.24891126155853271,
0.6395379900932312,
-0.3448376953601837,
1.0874022245407104,
-0.27565446496009827,
-0.7796092629432678,
-0.5421064496040344,
0.6546328663825989,
-0.174704909324646,
-0.34555232524871826,
0.4568372070789337,
0.43119192123413086,
0.9753966331481934,
-0.10357062518596649,
0.6777222156524658,
0.22614149749279022,
0.3429765999317169,
-0.6819921135902405,
0.5440405607223511,
-0.8727242946624756,
0.3044992685317993,
0.06319856643676758,
-0.867680549621582,
0.15812744200229645,
0.6722567081451416,
-0.19849276542663574,
0.3203715980052948,
0.15421538054943085,
0.6933858394622803,
-0.6611118912696838,
0.17486652731895447,
-0.019643612205982208,
-0.09625387191772461,
0.26964423060417175,
0.5298815369606018,
0.7353376150131226,
-0.038375068455934525,
0.2171947956085205,
-0.3428494334220886,
-0.31343385577201843,
-0.6987643241882324,
-0.742127001285553,
-0.6841139197349548,
-0.22085221111774445,
-0.46535032987594604,
0.2533552944660187,
0.03640729933977127,
0.9768168926239014,
1.0685158967971802,
-0.6591432094573975,
0.10001233965158463,
-0.12986192107200623,
0.20719695091247559,
-0.4430478513240814,
-0.2405228316783905,
0.07303296774625778,
-0.23394785821437836,
-0.9727163910865784,
0.65587317943573,
0.11915064603090286,
-0.0828055888414383,
-0.12770245969295502,
0.05767107382416725,
0.05733616277575493,
0.35220858454704285,
0.36060631275177,
-0.10518056154251099,
-0.45425257086753845,
0.09809631109237671,
-0.03037399798631668,
0.1623063087463379,
-0.06972561776638031,
0.8561846017837524,
-0.45348843932151794,
0.8741312026977539,
0.6454383730888367,
1.0494850873947144,
0.13624949753284454,
0.20201343297958374,
0.5411526560783386,
-0.8891916275024414,
0.12475304305553436,
0.164381206035614,
0.11406118422746658,
0.15545512735843658,
-0.5387243032455444,
0.2624755799770355,
0.5147821307182312,
-0.383783221244812,
-0.9625059962272644,
-0.07677174359560013,
-0.8979977369308472,
-0.19630448520183563,
0.7014234066009521,
-0.1021939143538475,
0.09066381305456161,
0.22012382745742798,
-0.1624448001384735,
0.37951529026031494,
-0.5781704187393188,
0.9165396690368652,
0.8740254640579224,
-0.27935791015625,
0.08749077469110489,
-0.6755367517471313,
-0.17763571441173553,
0.5679261088371277,
-0.56266850233078,
-0.20274782180786133,
0.40015414357185364,
0.3160933554172516,
-0.3435686230659485,
0.21750296652317047,
0.34548819065093994,
0.16630980372428894,
0.1356639564037323,
-0.37121379375457764,
-0.6098834872245789,
-0.6946583986282349,
0.21429343521595,
0.09054204821586609,
-0.37085530161857605,
-0.7211926579475403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15483v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15483v1 | Duplicate Detection with GenAI | 2024-06-17T06:42:13 | 2024-06-17T06:42:13 | Ian Ormesher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.LG | Customer data is often stored as records in Customer Relations Management
systems (CRMs). Data which is manually entered into such systems by one of more
users over time leads to data replication, partial duplication or fuzzy
duplication. This in turn means that there no longer a single source of truth
for customers, contacts, accounts, etc. Downstream business processes become
increasing complex and contrived without a unique mapping between a record in a
CRM and the target customer. Current methods to detect and de-duplicate records
use traditional Natural Language Processing techniques known as Entity
Matching. In this paper we show how using the latest advancements in Large
Language Models and Generative AI can vastly improve the identification and
repair of duplicated records. On common benchmark datasets we find an
improvement in the accuracy of data de-duplication rates from 30 percent using
NLP techniques to almost 60 percent using our proposed method. | [
-0.3102627098560333,
-0.6432863473892212,
0.24998065829277039,
0.056688860058784485,
-0.13664238154888153,
0.2608415186405182,
0.20356346666812897,
-0.5722439289093018,
0.037668123841285706,
0.9118514060974121,
-0.5211260318756104,
-0.5682021975517273,
-0.17761731147766113,
0.2569754123687744,
-0.5467292070388794,
0.855614960193634,
-0.042088065296411514,
0.1074957400560379,
-0.4411003887653351,
-0.4096243679523468,
-0.6092714071273804,
-0.7416053414344788,
-0.9486170411109924,
-0.5801839828491211,
-0.018797285854816437,
0.6398647427558899,
0.6788806319236755,
0.5900243520736694,
0.5479039549827576,
0.4121626317501068,
0.07650306075811386,
0.3543686270713806,
-0.25869858264923096,
0.378086119890213,
-0.07158371061086655,
-0.7232449054718018,
-0.35293132066726685,
-0.27069592475891113,
0.7720942497253418,
0.6793599724769592,
-0.3359823524951935,
-0.03970029205083847,
0.029306717216968536,
1.0954368114471436,
-0.37724682688713074,
-0.06419473886489868,
-0.6443896293640137,
0.17433671653270721,
-0.28623324632644653,
-0.4314318895339966,
-0.23750220239162445,
-0.5192472338676453,
0.1056603491306305,
-0.6782568693161011,
0.8186166882514954,
-0.15557125210762024,
0.7329127192497253,
0.22526566684246063,
-0.36985427141189575,
-0.2855435013771057,
-1.1375923156738281,
0.6838053464889526,
-0.5255205631256104,
0.2903616726398468,
0.27025264501571655,
0.273864209651947,
-0.4093460142612457,
-0.531458854675293,
-0.672718346118927,
-0.12144863605499268,
-0.25347036123275757,
-0.12458284199237823,
-0.21423563361167908,
-0.19152279198169708,
0.6992805004119873,
0.5922718048095703,
-0.7442376613616943,
0.23644784092903137,
-0.0798349380493164,
-0.10966230183839798,
0.6462735533714294,
0.40606755018234253,
0.719954788684845,
0.008450975641608238,
-0.5587514042854309,
-0.23308095335960388,
-0.3331253230571747,
-0.25747814774513245,
0.5149291157722473,
0.1170707568526268,
0.2716645896434784,
0.3357372283935547,
-0.3940514326095581,
0.6291784048080444,
0.04376906901597977,
-0.14964182674884796,
0.5983084440231323,
-0.46999266743659973,
-0.43303826451301575,
0.10300806164741516,
0.7051860094070435,
0.07621603459119797,
0.42712265253067017,
-0.11695633828639984,
-0.027129214257001877,
0.25301221013069153,
-0.02767946571111679,
-0.28356054425239563,
-0.2472819983959198,
0.18385355174541473,
-0.4621817469596863,
0.059351492673158646,
0.26804956793785095,
-0.9143558144569397,
-0.43143895268440247,
-0.6791695356369019,
-0.269870787858963,
-0.6733223795890808,
-0.33004000782966614,
-0.026327617466449738,
-0.2715718448162079,
0.39472803473472595,
0.12007825076580048,
-0.7777511477470398,
0.1346002221107483,
1.090033769607544,
0.6000534892082214,
-0.1535584032535553,
-0.4348238706588745,
-0.4538920223712921,
0.30287376046180725,
-0.29616743326187134,
0.7640498876571655,
-0.5534229278564453,
-0.2923712730407715,
-0.04849395155906677,
-0.13968037068843842,
0.03944602981209755,
-1.2606414556503296,
0.6733781695365906,
-0.47746893763542175,
0.23180536925792694,
-0.45366376638412476,
-0.7542036771774292,
-0.18686042726039886,
0.17532534897327423,
-0.8471730351448059,
0.7512814998626709,
0.2950820028781891,
-0.424033522605896,
0.6999688744544983,
-0.31203243136405945,
-0.5713744759559631,
0.5818984508514404,
0.06997288018465042,
-0.8420910835266113,
-0.02298559620976448,
0.2718745768070221,
0.13296838104724884,
-0.24109520018100739,
0.26626989245414734,
-0.23502103984355927,
-0.15790197253227234,
0.11135993152856827,
-0.4144611656665802,
0.7407804727554321,
0.43885359168052673,
-0.17684459686279297,
-0.22582347691059113,
-0.7615800499916077,
-0.08123821765184402,
0.206512451171875,
-0.359730064868927,
-0.611379861831665,
-0.093955397605896,
0.017710402607917786,
0.07011059671640396,
0.11894595623016357,
-0.3673022985458374,
0.34917089343070984,
-0.14023026823997498,
0.19665443897247314,
0.22653985023498535,
0.1037522479891777,
0.43699774146080017,
-0.5543808937072754,
0.691008448600769,
0.34942126274108887,
0.30891793966293335,
-0.1288415938615799,
-0.5959054231643677,
-0.8173514604568481,
-0.22383347153663635,
0.2086498737335205,
0.8709472417831421,
-0.7719926834106445,
0.6346026062965393,
-0.39614221453666687,
-0.3492177724838257,
-0.6168413758277893,
0.7291706204414368,
0.2970203757286072,
0.43727296590805054,
0.20671002566814423,
-0.5048230886459351,
-0.8633853793144226,
-1.059504747390747,
-0.35307934880256653,
0.053958527743816376,
-0.18186724185943604,
0.08627640455961227,
-0.016910003498196602,
-0.6352044343948364,
1.0110958814620972,
-0.2856895625591278,
-0.8680866956710815,
-0.28520312905311584,
0.2899472713470459,
0.035613059997558594,
0.6716040372848511,
0.5429130792617798,
-1.2415410280227661,
-0.564475417137146,
-0.13489410281181335,
-1.2365895509719849,
-0.18214178085327148,
-0.37636250257492065,
-0.07886753976345062,
0.6795527338981628,
0.2554166316986084,
-0.5360892415046692,
0.49186787009239197,
0.33329764008522034,
-0.17026229202747345,
-0.15559186041355133,
-0.23511669039726257,
0.5269262790679932,
-1.0880476236343384,
-0.01045414712280035,
0.20362482964992523,
-0.41303038597106934,
-0.9033977389335632,
0.003100296715274453,
-0.04875093698501587,
-0.3770667314529419,
0.000445277604740113,
-0.17515131831169128,
-0.6229019165039062,
-0.3555571138858795,
-0.30281758308410645,
-0.018010219559073448,
-0.035599518567323685,
0.3343949317932129,
-0.18095268309116364,
0.6372179388999939,
0.3149704039096832,
-0.5443081259727478,
0.5863072872161865,
0.7287782430648804,
-0.6145766973495483,
0.9736180901527405,
-0.4698706865310669,
0.3386037051677704,
-0.31238123774528503,
0.21738804876804352,
-0.8895374536514282,
0.042245618999004364,
0.40397441387176514,
-0.5129190683364868,
0.305820107460022,
-0.265237420797348,
-0.5468249320983887,
-0.5431481599807739,
0.044702667742967606,
0.40788304805755615,
0.38903719186782837,
-0.7798853516578674,
0.7455126047134399,
0.27498406171798706,
-0.21985802054405212,
-0.4202021062374115,
-0.9002377390861511,
0.30962905287742615,
-0.020067408680915833,
-0.7820546627044678,
0.2398805320262909,
0.04707784578204155,
-0.07209362834692001,
0.05517534166574478,
0.046570777893066406,
-0.25197967886924744,
0.28093916177749634,
0.30105888843536377,
0.2715097665786743,
-0.17514151334762573,
0.25582563877105713,
-0.23506894707679749,
-0.3185393214225769,
-0.1965738981962204,
-0.3390105664730072,
0.9124181270599365,
0.028000591322779655,
-0.38525834679603577,
-1.146716833114624,
0.617516815662384,
0.7576497197151184,
-0.17413580417633057,
0.7598269581794739,
0.3003167510032654,
-0.5878856778144836,
-0.07808075845241547,
-0.8010522127151489,
0.3386808931827545,
-0.4870513379573822,
0.10773500055074692,
-0.3731345534324646,
-0.29031842947006226,
0.5688332319259644,
0.1313886046409607,
-0.23470032215118408,
0.3812887668609619,
0.20838294923305511,
0.06457846611738205,
0.8845180869102478,
0.4871153235435486,
-0.8284028768539429,
0.5439211130142212,
-0.3390302360057831,
0.49242570996284485,
-0.5651170611381531,
-0.5803300142288208,
-0.7918556928634644,
-0.33478814363479614,
-0.5541207790374756,
0.047161560505628586,
0.04926133528351784,
0.3011680543422699,
0.15391278266906738,
0.49101224541664124,
-0.6099870204925537,
0.41406747698783875,
0.7747215032577515,
0.07433540374040604,
0.791121780872345,
0.05483037978410721,
0.6183935403823853,
0.06008493900299072,
-0.392548531293869,
-0.39012715220451355,
0.8999132513999939,
0.04298487678170204,
0.630446195602417,
0.03830799087882042,
0.7944695949554443,
0.6283948421478271,
0.4915335774421692,
-0.47725144028663635,
0.5914452075958252,
-0.31508564949035645,
-0.30552738904953003,
-0.3860381543636322,
-0.8306998610496521,
-1.1295396089553833,
-0.1984073668718338,
-0.27545779943466187,
-0.24831224977970123,
0.3125733733177185,
0.3946205973625183,
-0.19901518523693085,
0.512657105922699,
-0.8053517937660217,
0.528754472732544,
-0.18454179167747498,
0.27616116404533386,
-0.12776552140712738,
-0.005787981674075127,
0.334573358297348,
-0.12355847656726837,
-0.20565809309482574,
-0.07655448466539383,
0.20711521804332733,
0.6249655485153198,
-0.5847688317298889,
0.21212852001190186,
-0.2005808800458908,
-0.061494432389736176,
0.23547641932964325,
0.038253895938396454,
0.5614227652549744,
-0.021371955052018166,
0.03381093218922615,
0.31828540563583374,
-0.27378788590431213,
-0.37941882014274597,
-0.6866233348846436,
0.987194836139679,
-0.4919423758983612,
-0.4569094479084015,
-0.25880640745162964,
-0.47277501225471497,
0.0478300005197525,
-0.05808889865875244,
0.29550570249557495,
0.08595676720142365,
-0.2115132212638855,
0.0543333925306797,
0.6264458894729614,
-0.28894782066345215,
0.2519548535346985,
0.6140758991241455,
0.07342255115509033,
-0.374156653881073,
0.7305450439453125,
-0.09611665457487106,
0.21721012890338898,
0.19480982422828674,
-0.2548663914203644,
-0.09085751324892044,
-0.2674098014831543,
-0.3453826606273651,
0.16298967599868774,
-0.4295961856842041,
-0.42916813492774963,
-0.890709638595581,
0.05443631112575531,
-0.6822136044502258,
0.17562508583068848,
-0.1880040019750595,
0.05221974477171898,
-0.2718835175037384,
0.20298635959625244,
0.18921227753162384,
0.6154269576072693,
0.09350685030221939,
0.10596098005771637,
-0.969789445400238,
0.7976447939872742,
0.5193223357200623,
0.36617180705070496,
0.07904815673828125,
-0.22874408960342407,
0.2793433368206024,
0.2355412095785141,
-0.017325496301054955,
-0.6830511093139648,
0.6027202010154724,
0.03270895779132843,
0.5722147822380066,
0.37771204113960266,
-0.21775422990322113,
0.5633774399757385,
-0.09063463658094406,
0.44609272480010986,
0.07364867627620697,
-1.0284157991409302,
0.6811090111732483,
-0.12179853022098541,
0.05482737720012665,
0.666619062423706,
0.45972734689712524,
-0.8245805501937866,
-0.07827835530042648,
-0.6248161792755127,
-0.5431987047195435,
0.5474028587341309,
0.01405375637114048,
-0.1355496048927307,
0.07443902641534805,
0.5174985527992249,
-0.03538420423865318,
0.16982527077198029,
-0.02430158481001854,
-0.4035930037498474,
0.19883137941360474,
-0.35127148032188416,
-0.2919031083583832,
-0.42801839113235474,
0.2327723205089569,
-0.12832699716091156,
0.6693277359008789,
0.17621952295303345,
0.18842357397079468,
0.24649827182292938,
-0.14642062783241272,
-0.37177538871765137,
0.28843680024147034,
0.3098084330558777,
0.7090187072753906,
-0.042420998215675354,
-0.6358045935630798,
-0.006793052423745394,
-0.34657803177833557,
0.08015277236700058,
0.2283826619386673,
-0.552636444568634,
0.30896973609924316,
0.12758968770503998,
0.49960261583328247,
-0.27868226170539856,
-0.41178062558174133,
0.4991791248321533,
-0.019638994708657265,
-0.12879879772663116,
-0.9235419034957886,
0.05085809901356697,
-0.16542616486549377,
0.08816491067409515,
0.46715667843818665,
0.03217180818319321,
0.22404366731643677,
-0.9496216177940369,
0.4134977161884308,
0.5212221741676331,
-0.07790087163448334,
0.09506484866142273,
0.476481169462204,
0.22554652392864227,
-0.9855616092681885,
1.3291754722595215,
0.0634320005774498,
-0.6886759996414185,
0.8097830414772034,
0.375617653131485,
0.9032861590385437,
-0.4525613486766815,
0.3406352996826172,
0.12089812755584717,
0.15641829371452332,
-0.3793025612831116,
0.3400781750679016,
0.214318186044693,
-0.9247370362281799,
-0.17795555293560028,
-0.210096538066864,
-0.33767402172088623,
0.465821772813797,
-1.019007921218872,
0.17249347269535065,
-0.49496838450431824,
0.010326901450753212,
0.36550402641296387,
-0.09568999707698822,
-0.9961878061294556,
0.013096497394144535,
0.21880529820919037,
0.6694408059120178,
-0.9950889348983765,
0.6513575911521912,
0.14835283160209656,
-0.598787784576416,
-0.5172619819641113,
-0.16531230509281158,
-0.043207552284002304,
-0.5896560549736023,
0.7175338268280029,
0.11483393609523773,
0.27674493193626404,
-0.19852277636528015,
-0.5049177408218384,
-0.5191736817359924,
0.9734405279159546,
0.17794132232666016,
-0.9816188812255859,
0.15101692080497742,
0.5984117388725281,
0.7175358533859253,
-0.13035155832767487,
-0.21864351630210876,
1.1587738990783691,
0.380026638507843,
-0.241767019033432,
-0.6675565838813782,
-0.1564267873764038,
-0.18187068402767181,
0.15719865262508392,
0.7699896693229675,
-0.3853716254234314,
0.7242344617843628,
0.011413813568651676,
-0.5697668790817261,
0.41828417778015137,
0.46607762575149536,
-0.01744459755718708,
0.6839612722396851,
0.6270873546600342,
1.2263774871826172,
1.0036001205444336,
-0.22229714691638947,
1.2196711301803589,
0.1275712251663208,
0.22473259270191193,
1.2346062660217285,
-0.7415818572044373,
0.4408152401447296,
0.09737148135900497,
-0.028993181884288788,
0.7088627219200134,
0.02798035368323326,
-0.5252777934074402,
0.10263901203870773,
0.14583244919776917,
-0.3225058317184448,
-0.424789160490036,
-0.17362405359745026,
-0.32208317518234253,
0.476377934217453,
0.12566731870174408,
-0.5583441853523254,
0.060266848653554916,
0.2926621735095978,
-0.2648293375968933,
0.3314717710018158,
-0.14777100086212158,
1.1003464460372925,
-0.18632398545742035,
-0.7734990119934082,
0.5459466576576233,
-0.3511682450771332,
0.6746367812156677,
-0.4033803343772888,
-0.2633593678474426,
-0.6589874625205994,
0.4592512845993042,
-0.2568931579589844,
-0.4857913553714752,
0.18697480857372284,
-0.1100163534283638,
-0.5188568234443665,
-0.15014895796775818,
0.782789945602417,
-0.6561183333396912,
-0.27019986510276794,
0.23987330496311188,
0.31058210134506226,
-0.032342638820409775,
-0.20406652987003326,
-0.6183269619941711,
-0.12793679535388947,
0.14760668575763702,
0.22455978393554688,
0.052281465381383896,
0.33679789304733276,
0.0020373750012367964,
1.099456787109375,
0.830340564250946,
0.13804471492767334,
-0.13400974869728088,
0.4802965819835663,
0.5116754174232483,
-0.856363832950592,
-0.29865485429763794,
-0.6237968802452087,
-0.13681134581565857,
-0.5346113443374634,
-0.3011556565761566,
0.566538393497467,
0.819978654384613,
1.1919376850128174,
-0.02725885808467865,
0.932162344455719,
0.37596064805984497,
0.863609254360199,
-0.4464605152606964,
0.4164825975894928,
-0.16727957129478455,
0.46890807151794434,
-0.262662410736084,
-1.0052483081817627,
-0.10180521756410599,
0.06896593421697617,
0.008010209538042545,
-0.13744625449180603,
0.43332669138908386,
0.8526737093925476,
0.05217369645833969,
0.17571000754833221,
0.1894039809703827,
-0.130812868475914,
0.3158344626426697,
0.9267963767051697,
0.9712356328964233,
-0.6763551831245422,
0.7065997123718262,
-0.18706144392490387,
-0.14301957190036774,
-0.10543728619813919,
-0.25212839245796204,
-0.7322389483451843,
-0.5015385746955872,
-0.6117075681686401,
-0.3248783349990845,
-0.022979233413934708,
0.5910131335258484,
0.3866952955722809,
-1.1724226474761963,
0.17666353285312653,
-0.09404527395963669,
0.07292088121175766,
-0.368935227394104,
-0.3252754509449005,
0.034930843859910965,
-0.29363611340522766,
-0.8069441318511963,
0.14928165078163147,
0.23970606923103333,
0.44695234298706055,
-0.06878861784934998,
0.10902377218008041,
-0.10631373524665833,
-0.35365453362464905,
0.1397808939218521,
0.6286169290542603,
-0.43270426988601685,
-0.10307995229959488,
-0.32102909684181213,
-0.21903061866760254,
0.18287307024002075,
1.2708148956298828,
-0.8216891884803772,
0.23467572033405304,
0.7730802297592163,
0.8483436107635498,
0.2780504524707794,
0.45137539505958557,
0.6722132563591003,
-0.36738574504852295,
0.025900421664118767,
0.3556021749973297,
0.5138795375823975,
0.7201964259147644,
-0.6979081630706787,
0.5908862352371216,
0.44994184374809265,
-0.6099269986152649,
-0.5136774778366089,
0.24800390005111694,
-0.9854748249053955,
-0.16788159310817719,
0.9798679947853088,
-0.026519037783145905,
0.24128444492816925,
-0.5282002091407776,
0.03098801150918007,
0.3321967124938965,
-0.25450247526168823,
0.7923167943954468,
0.35587117075920105,
0.27875545620918274,
0.07151466608047485,
-0.19945809245109558,
0.5988840460777283,
0.6237663626670837,
-1.0154322385787964,
-0.07713977992534637,
0.498428612947464,
0.4675249457359314,
0.37885668873786926,
0.45528218150138855,
-0.017558259889483452,
0.22660157084465027,
-0.30626773834228516,
0.12236720323562622,
-0.06236042082309723,
-0.29896655678749084,
-0.5982069373130798,
0.03007590025663376,
-0.3293713927268982,
-0.4803991913795471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11250v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11250v1 | Can Machines Resonate with Humans? Evaluating the Emotional and Empathic Comprehension of LMs | 2024-06-17T06:22:20 | 2024-06-17T06:22:20 | Muhammad Arslan Manzoor, Yuxia Wang, Minghan Wang, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Empathy plays a pivotal role in fostering prosocial behavior, often triggered
by the sharing of personal experiences through narratives. However, modeling
empathy using NLP approaches remains challenging due to its deep
interconnection with human interaction dynamics. Previous approaches, which
involve fine-tuning language models (LMs) on human-annotated empathic datasets,
have had limited success. In our pursuit of improving empathy understanding in
LMs, we propose several strategies, including contrastive learning with masked
LMs and supervised fine-tuning with Large Language Models (LLMs). While these
methods show improvements over previous methods, the overall results remain
unsatisfactory. To better understand this trend, we performed an analysis which
reveals a low agreement among annotators. This lack of consensus hinders
training and highlights the subjective nature of the task. We also explore the
cultural impact on annotations. To study this, we meticulously collected story
pairs in Urdu language and find that subjectivity in interpreting empathy among
annotators appears to be independent of cultural background. The insights from
our systematic exploration of LMs' understanding of empathy suggest that there
is considerable room for exploration in both task formulation and modeling. | [
-0.620794951915741,
-0.661669909954071,
0.5411852598190308,
0.16319021582603455,
-0.2874251902103424,
0.18185560405254364,
-0.30467909574508667,
-0.7405416965484619,
0.29578134417533875,
0.563824474811554,
-0.5990371108055115,
-0.443416029214859,
-0.843891441822052,
0.5486631989479065,
0.11396051943302155,
0.6528705954551697,
-0.10165379196405411,
0.031597115099430084,
0.043972909450531006,
-0.5289493203163147,
-0.1821606457233429,
-0.7639541029930115,
-0.6513293981552124,
-0.4711346924304962,
0.6273510456085205,
0.5067369937896729,
0.7484209537506104,
0.3457321226596832,
0.5752674341201782,
0.34822791814804077,
-0.2512744665145874,
0.6027013063430786,
-0.17732539772987366,
-0.008395066484808922,
-0.10163836181163788,
-0.2141028791666031,
-0.3441828787326813,
0.19774307310581207,
0.21044310927391052,
0.7927786111831665,
0.09606841951608658,
0.22858624160289764,
0.3761599063873291,
0.6524372100830078,
-0.5354500412940979,
-0.04957500845193863,
-0.19553698599338531,
0.3735225796699524,
0.4288358688354492,
-0.21134823560714722,
-0.46302279829978943,
0.034920722246170044,
0.07869463413953781,
-0.2619825005531311,
0.10961562395095825,
0.1703381985425949,
0.6517053842544556,
0.44702911376953125,
-0.4289763867855072,
-0.30112484097480774,
-0.4770265221595764,
0.9181292057037354,
-0.39995893836021423,
0.2978762984275818,
0.7084022164344788,
-0.19535382091999054,
0.11356989294290543,
-0.44514745473861694,
-0.4461708068847656,
-0.3385844826698303,
-0.397203654050827,
-0.0562480203807354,
-0.26750004291534424,
-0.03844904899597168,
0.32322168350219727,
0.2262250781059265,
-0.2583167254924774,
0.14099451899528503,
-0.24101877212524414,
-0.015864944085478783,
0.7351259589195251,
0.4510108232498169,
0.5315651297569275,
-0.19869591295719147,
-0.22980287671089172,
0.05277714878320694,
-0.12769557535648346,
0.10377910733222961,
0.3127728998661041,
0.4158325493335724,
-0.4512922763824463,
0.46886056661605835,
0.06505473703145981,
0.7152715921401978,
0.16241192817687988,
0.14028286933898926,
0.302185982465744,
0.18557389080524445,
-0.21048994362354279,
-0.05770736187696457,
0.7221306562423706,
0.8128962516784668,
0.6974176168441772,
-0.05370423570275307,
0.15785446763038635,
0.09924737364053726,
0.5458828806877136,
-0.7703709602355957,
-0.04759411886334419,
0.4335479140281677,
-0.7201487421989441,
-0.2936720550060272,
-0.09681758284568787,
-0.598095178604126,
-0.6558390259742737,
-0.5506506562232971,
0.17560023069381714,
-0.24663476645946503,
-0.5503026843070984,
0.2379034459590912,
-0.0249404888600111,
0.0612930990755558,
0.08660338073968887,
-0.9558049440383911,
0.358009397983551,
0.800925076007843,
1.0369725227355957,
0.2965276539325714,
-0.46950510144233704,
-0.4146977365016937,
-0.2131561040878296,
-0.2115568071603775,
0.5299296975135803,
-0.8577578663825989,
-0.4690278172492981,
-0.05836900323629379,
0.00655174907296896,
0.09005561470985413,
-0.5142951011657715,
0.7105610370635986,
-0.057105131447315216,
0.002962374361231923,
-0.35352379083633423,
-0.34474650025367737,
-0.25461310148239136,
0.3357314169406891,
-0.5460256934165955,
0.4493054151535034,
0.20017623901367188,
-0.8765059113502502,
0.11192101240158081,
-0.7480758428573608,
-0.40280279517173767,
-0.3439462184906006,
0.07555496692657471,
-0.15965215861797333,
0.4878893494606018,
0.39733758568763733,
0.8954266905784607,
-0.17519883811473846,
0.12655997276306152,
-0.20912104845046997,
-0.6853015422821045,
0.43058958649635315,
-0.1512659788131714,
0.4920395016670227,
0.2888873517513275,
-0.1258046180009842,
0.03877060487866402,
-0.419965535402298,
-0.2818191945552826,
0.0009461432928219438,
0.23954050242900848,
-0.4109954833984375,
-0.2098712921142578,
0.15242478251457214,
0.17699457705020905,
-0.053677208721637726,
-0.4787875711917877,
-0.03627694770693779,
-0.5505128502845764,
0.5660597085952759,
0.703059732913971,
-0.05021080747246742,
0.5025107860565186,
-0.43564510345458984,
0.5375033617019653,
0.10456887632608414,
0.21105408668518066,
-0.30846962332725525,
-0.2542089521884918,
-0.4613872170448303,
-0.4646628201007843,
-0.18178583681583405,
0.3522074818611145,
-0.24972426891326904,
0.3296959400177002,
0.14420384168624878,
-0.6774610280990601,
-1.0525994300842285,
0.15497274696826935,
0.4483834207057953,
0.4379645884037018,
0.5896693468093872,
-0.5857630968093872,
-0.5510959625244141,
-0.9664134979248047,
-0.8006927371025085,
0.05156625807285309,
-0.21223130822181702,
0.6314404606819153,
0.2206241637468338,
-0.41694703698158264,
0.6545088887214661,
-0.1886323243379593,
-0.33992698788642883,
-0.3715837597846985,
0.3591751754283905,
0.2519437074661255,
0.4278915524482727,
0.2524251937866211,
-0.8814175128936768,
-0.6038573980331421,
0.07332813739776611,
-0.7933499813079834,
-0.24730058014392853,
-0.08029726147651672,
0.06790791451931,
0.24154354631900787,
0.38567692041397095,
-0.33310452103614807,
0.3887242376804352,
0.6381565928459167,
-0.5729928612709045,
0.043992023915052414,
-0.12484870105981827,
0.45272618532180786,
-1.1103036403656006,
0.034560319036245346,
0.22265580296516418,
0.032901398837566376,
-0.7077292203903198,
-0.10211879014968872,
-0.12246528267860413,
0.06103382259607315,
-0.5594314932823181,
0.8858709335327148,
-0.48815128207206726,
0.036229316145181656,
-0.33186379075050354,
0.21550600230693817,
-0.010606912896037102,
0.536716103553772,
0.3950512409210205,
0.31717392802238464,
0.37233272194862366,
-0.31018394231796265,
0.27442502975463867,
0.26476573944091797,
0.029917137697339058,
0.808040201663971,
-0.6547355651855469,
0.26396650075912476,
-0.1010085940361023,
0.045505404472351074,
-0.5139264464378357,
-0.3314935266971588,
0.5117023587226868,
-0.6678526401519775,
0.29715603590011597,
-0.15898464620113373,
-0.3243435323238373,
-0.006351115647703409,
-0.28005361557006836,
0.3890017569065094,
0.6662460565567017,
-0.6089096665382385,
0.9264048337936401,
0.2712806463241577,
-0.18680912256240845,
-0.4157746434211731,
-0.5832075476646423,
0.30147305130958557,
-0.4637914299964905,
-0.4969030022621155,
-0.17606781423091888,
0.13109642267227173,
-0.8280954360961914,
-0.19919069111347198,
0.2027493417263031,
0.04558826610445976,
0.20501235127449036,
0.6266516447067261,
-0.19101199507713318,
0.11915522068738937,
0.22638770937919617,
0.00009000233694678172,
-0.5083624124526978,
0.1627987176179886,
0.35701096057891846,
0.5677753686904907,
-0.3471232056617737,
-0.39356210827827454,
-0.8937124609947205,
0.4823634624481201,
0.4791947603225708,
-0.25325503945350647,
0.9498502612113953,
0.9087857007980347,
-0.2828656733036041,
0.1921611726284027,
-0.5197306871414185,
-0.4349670708179474,
-0.41404423117637634,
0.29135745763778687,
-0.5365797877311707,
-1.0815690755844116,
0.41455283761024475,
-0.16883938014507294,
-0.19759872555732727,
0.13747496902942657,
0.5605283379554749,
-0.14324922859668732,
1.1632663011550903,
0.6146361231803894,
-0.2859869599342346,
0.275542289018631,
-0.0036062223371118307,
0.32966357469558716,
-1.1431593894958496,
-0.12456206232309341,
-0.36204737424850464,
-0.5650809407234192,
-0.8427150249481201,
-0.0709841176867485,
0.17080819606781006,
-0.02361481450498104,
-0.5627568364143372,
-0.1432170420885086,
-0.6190823316574097,
0.427714467048645,
0.40412697196006775,
0.5225257277488708,
0.11808771640062332,
-0.07428240031003952,
0.37290143966674805,
-0.2772967517375946,
-0.35155075788497925,
-0.9437306523323059,
0.7823929190635681,
0.503993034362793,
0.5900583267211914,
-0.04476935416460037,
0.877372682094574,
0.39707913994789124,
0.6437029838562012,
-0.5628392100334167,
0.34312132000923157,
-0.1478935331106186,
-0.1603313833475113,
-0.1636611670255661,
-0.09864459186792374,
-0.8886940479278564,
0.20727744698524475,
-0.16130301356315613,
-0.9802232384681702,
0.08000615984201431,
0.2346145659685135,
-0.2360013723373413,
0.39254945516586304,
-0.700151801109314,
0.8363887071609497,
-0.1042177677154541,
-0.5585130453109741,
-0.19783824682235718,
-0.8734548687934875,
0.04396449401974678,
0.09837603569030762,
0.4016109108924866,
-0.16774800419807434,
0.017636291682720184,
0.36910054087638855,
-0.19115887582302094,
1.2555745840072632,
-0.14108802378177643,
-0.03986140713095665,
0.01435456145554781,
0.4679308533668518,
0.174093097448349,
-0.13457851111888885,
-0.30893653631210327,
0.3752578794956207,
-0.24641203880310059,
-0.6376320719718933,
-0.5923518538475037,
0.4665403366088867,
-0.8078691959381104,
-0.6507768630981445,
-0.20852769911289215,
-0.591397225856781,
-0.12176881730556488,
-0.34116819500923157,
-0.09664533287286758,
0.01627017743885517,
-0.08422984182834625,
0.18269690871238708,
0.19558922946453094,
-0.3246518075466156,
0.06302148848772049,
0.3570481538772583,
0.06812113523483276,
-0.20571695268154144,
0.66612309217453,
-0.32698747515678406,
0.1418909728527069,
0.24499410390853882,
0.31963399052619934,
-0.009766257368028164,
0.02449805475771427,
-0.19279947876930237,
0.41997984051704407,
-0.5483475923538208,
0.10092117637395859,
-0.7874658703804016,
0.19990062713623047,
-0.17220813035964966,
-0.6519649028778076,
-0.220286563038826,
0.1683242917060852,
-0.4998050034046173,
-0.2564617097377777,
0.6495251655578613,
0.84901362657547,
-0.5251772403717041,
0.11318191140890121,
-1.0709024667739868,
0.2905723750591278,
-0.07015374302864075,
0.2267276793718338,
0.1296074539422989,
-0.7331959009170532,
-0.23034429550170898,
0.19282488524913788,
-0.029856128618121147,
-0.7288535237312317,
0.6439979076385498,
0.01406499557197094,
-0.010323082096874714,
0.46874240040779114,
0.24778637290000916,
0.5665343403816223,
-0.2806899845600128,
0.7215130925178528,
-0.037380579859018326,
-1.116884469985962,
0.52876877784729,
-0.16162970662117004,
0.006361514329910278,
0.2921443581581116,
0.6042675375938416,
-0.733670711517334,
-0.48978152871131897,
-0.7227740287780762,
-0.7591401934623718,
0.6479429006576538,
0.0333271324634552,
0.5731879472732544,
-0.10283957421779633,
0.5128812193870544,
0.1169961616396904,
-0.046304136514663696,
-0.4294700622558594,
0.047460608184337616,
0.006404560059309006,
-0.5633478760719299,
-0.5531796813011169,
-0.5240821838378906,
-0.1693442463874817,
-0.11183398216962814,
0.04375208914279938,
-0.006541516166180372,
-0.0010465742088854313,
0.4293260872364044,
0.017738377675414085,
-0.41115298867225647,
0.05609840527176857,
0.46248123049736023,
0.15763850510120392,
-0.18658064305782318,
0.22815939784049988,
0.38758745789527893,
-0.3579101264476776,
0.010935810394585133,
-0.2202591449022293,
0.39115574955940247,
-0.1875469982624054,
0.761085033416748,
0.7230595946311951,
0.2003025859594345,
-0.8815446496009827,
0.25800105929374695,
-0.058298975229263306,
-0.02453874796628952,
-0.12672409415245056,
-0.02245231345295906,
0.22202801704406738,
0.7756359577178955,
0.07059269398450851,
-0.2616831660270691,
0.1022418662905693,
-0.6149792671203613,
-0.04322979599237442,
0.2422286570072174,
-0.5146955251693726,
-0.3653924763202667,
0.3411659002304077,
0.21451935172080994,
-0.9447643160820007,
0.7630943655967712,
0.18281789124011993,
-0.7588383555412292,
0.5629512071609497,
0.15805192291736603,
0.9324330687522888,
-0.4087078869342804,
0.05941921845078468,
0.26068946719169617,
0.4208117127418518,
0.07300222665071487,
0.3135855495929718,
-0.42348578572273254,
-0.9417116641998291,
-0.20182834565639496,
-0.5745967030525208,
-0.8500635027885437,
-0.3777085244655609,
-1.062600016593933,
0.0013399720191955566,
0.02471097931265831,
-0.03815874084830284,
-0.32041674852371216,
0.060314591974020004,
-0.7640146613121033,
0.3444751799106598,
-0.10847785323858261,
0.5581227540969849,
-1.163932204246521,
0.3509301245212555,
0.6896651387214661,
-0.4345470666885376,
-0.7841053605079651,
0.08250024169683456,
-0.21860921382904053,
-0.9031471610069275,
0.8878880143165588,
0.437895804643631,
-0.1888144165277481,
0.025336073711514473,
-0.44033730030059814,
-0.19833242893218994,
0.8112401366233826,
0.14980022609233856,
-0.4042426645755768,
0.5519276857376099,
0.20810522139072418,
0.963004469871521,
-0.5803605914115906,
0.36821308732032776,
0.6064162850379944,
0.5675057768821716,
-0.344653457403183,
-0.9148326516151428,
0.09213479608297348,
-0.34942710399627686,
-0.3652493357658386,
0.10469852387905121,
-0.7158076167106628,
0.654403567314148,
-0.48079121112823486,
0.0812436118721962,
0.09429743140935898,
0.35897353291511536,
0.24827219545841217,
0.8588283061981201,
0.40281370282173157,
0.3799544870853424,
0.4014952778816223,
0.10536985844373703,
1.1729847192764282,
-0.3939206302165985,
0.16912443935871124,
1.0297470092773438,
-0.5390372276306152,
1.0962761640548706,
0.7418932318687439,
-0.07588309049606323,
0.2856440842151642,
0.8944922685623169,
0.13369138538837433,
0.014344870112836361,
0.29926663637161255,
-0.25994300842285156,
-0.48140713572502136,
-0.5981100797653198,
-0.059571508318185806,
0.52677983045578,
0.24809546768665314,
-0.7600352168083191,
0.3351753056049347,
0.11304678022861481,
0.020065484568476677,
0.47707846760749817,
-0.4054015874862671,
0.8406925201416016,
0.35799384117126465,
-0.3327876627445221,
0.27866262197494507,
-0.18948249518871307,
0.48056215047836304,
-0.0023234689142555,
-0.2144937962293625,
-0.3195921778678894,
0.05224645510315895,
-0.2762465178966522,
-0.7828620672225952,
0.34108540415763855,
0.2662520110607147,
-0.08413063734769821,
-0.3807753920555115,
0.618981659412384,
-0.2598400413990021,
-0.3735613226890564,
0.6205480098724365,
0.6809187531471252,
0.4887213706970215,
-0.23118026554584503,
-0.4287374019622803,
0.456307977437973,
-0.11424019932746887,
-0.5762151479721069,
0.3254377543926239,
0.5549938082695007,
0.1286182552576065,
0.7594435214996338,
0.5096416473388672,
-0.045053284615278244,
-0.5833222270011902,
0.2901252508163452,
0.7394284605979919,
-0.822548508644104,
0.017221059650182724,
-1.2604410648345947,
0.6808108687400818,
0.007304042112082243,
-0.07555320858955383,
0.5457079410552979,
0.09418879449367523,
0.7594062089920044,
-0.10332249104976654,
0.5029813051223755,
0.3205031454563141,
0.6883461475372314,
-0.45340555906295776,
0.6013068556785583,
-0.7606464624404907,
0.014142473228275776,
-0.33684489130973816,
-0.6931809186935425,
-0.48751094937324524,
0.8338592052459717,
-0.28548961877822876,
0.2054317593574524,
0.2835041582584381,
0.7765081524848938,
0.0833926722407341,
0.20309148728847504,
0.6426466107368469,
0.40593013167381287,
-0.11916922777891159,
0.3869961202144623,
1.0838310718536377,
-0.03208931162953377,
-0.06327973306179047,
-0.3354591429233551,
-0.17086197435855865,
-0.2632448077201843,
-0.9331903457641602,
-1.0133198499679565,
-0.5385009050369263,
-0.08520635962486267,
-0.22301414608955383,
0.021917957812547684,
1.3140910863876343,
0.3935748040676117,
-0.42751938104629517,
-0.20459099113941193,
0.20237359404563904,
0.019888678565621376,
-0.08041661977767944,
-0.1756015419960022,
0.5832079648971558,
-0.33178189396858215,
-1.0140489339828491,
-0.01509182807058096,
0.4109323024749756,
-0.19852352142333984,
-0.24145109951496124,
-0.4388790428638458,
0.2714107930660248,
0.045797690749168396,
0.6587981581687927,
0.0960172563791275,
-0.8691558837890625,
-0.4390946924686432,
0.019915871322155,
0.17585493624210358,
-0.12666437029838562,
0.8457990884780884,
-0.5731253027915955,
0.441038578748703,
-0.049719784408807755,
0.4223267138004303,
-0.06763555109500885,
0.23106038570404053,
0.5107024908065796,
-0.46589788794517517,
0.24152757227420807,
0.2852107286453247,
0.4304307699203491,
0.3587862253189087,
-0.3921896815299988,
0.6586950421333313,
-0.09310375899076462,
-0.5822960734367371,
-1.0808944702148438,
0.3539832830429077,
-0.8309127688407898,
-0.21891449391841888,
1.2344167232513428,
-0.2067784070968628,
-0.12911751866340637,
-0.20489893853664398,
-0.8062368035316467,
0.3764359652996063,
-0.20101137459278107,
0.9971253275871277,
0.6622574329376221,
-0.4145493507385254,
-0.46915650367736816,
-0.17081180214881897,
0.31036511063575745,
0.49586063623428345,
-0.35672861337661743,
0.13241656124591827,
0.23726463317871094,
-0.10623699426651001,
0.09904276579618454,
0.44233036041259766,
0.3270130753517151,
0.09369034320116043,
-0.095850870013237,
0.3506515622138977,
-0.06115163490176201,
0.011496131308376789,
-0.49363431334495544,
0.1425541639328003,
0.244598388671875,
0.04030853882431984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11243v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11243v1 | FamiCom: Further Demystifying Prompts for Language Models with Task-Agnostic Performance Estimation | 2024-06-17T06:14:55 | 2024-06-17T06:14:55 | Bangzheng Li, Ben Zhou, Xingyu Fu, Fei Wang, Dan Roth, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language models have shown impressive in-context-learning capabilities, which
allow them to benefit from input prompts and perform better on downstream end
tasks. Existing works investigate the mechanisms behind this observation, and
propose label-agnostic prompt metrics that can better estimate end-task
performances. One popular approach is using perplexity as a way to measure
models' familiarity with the prompt. While showing consistent improvements on
in-domain tasks, we found that familiarity metrics such as perplexity cannot
accurately estimate performance in complicated situations such as task or
domain transferring scenarios. In this work, we propose a revised measure
called FamiCom, providing a more comprehensive measure for task-agnostic
performance estimation. Specifically, FamiCom combines familiarity with
\textit{complexity} -- the inherent difficulty of end tasks, which is an
important factor missing from current metrics. Experiments show that FamiCom
strongly correlates with end-task performances, producing a 0.85 Spearman's
correlation, versus 0.43 of familiarity-only ones'. We further apply FamiCom to
automatic prompt and demonstration selection, and outperform existing methods
and baselines by more than 7.0% in accuracy. | [
-0.575663149356842,
-0.7095083594322205,
0.8399578928947449,
0.014934844337403774,
-0.07934881001710892,
0.07464445382356644,
-0.08269151300191879,
-0.3042562007904053,
-0.04391423240303993,
0.20810925960540771,
-0.7351500391960144,
-0.4442213475704193,
-0.9194719195365906,
0.2539520263671875,
-0.3650006949901581,
0.9126998782157898,
-0.15253286063671112,
-0.4719265103340149,
-0.6930204629898071,
-0.22401556372642517,
-0.18946322798728943,
-0.5681788921356201,
-0.38267597556114197,
-0.4898861050605774,
0.49984562397003174,
0.46594125032424927,
0.7580099701881409,
0.6248604655265808,
0.1424729824066162,
0.35779380798339844,
-0.008853229694068432,
0.1998193860054016,
-0.07517538964748383,
0.34470415115356445,
-0.30748680233955383,
-0.49997538328170776,
-0.5478407144546509,
0.19711990654468536,
0.5355832576751709,
0.8159766793251038,
0.1745082587003708,
0.041193533688783646,
0.05985664576292038,
0.5045657753944397,
-0.6270359754562378,
-0.01877872832119465,
-0.4131355881690979,
0.24069269001483917,
0.012451817281544209,
-0.172276571393013,
-0.28208282589912415,
-0.22857530415058136,
0.4443883001804352,
-0.8361713886260986,
0.3127965033054352,
0.2027997374534607,
0.7868080139160156,
0.40275081992149353,
-0.3447345495223999,
-0.5189182162284851,
-0.6685551404953003,
0.8807283639907837,
-0.5026933550834656,
0.273183673620224,
0.4151538908481598,
0.5797481536865234,
-0.18163365125656128,
-0.4558866024017334,
-0.4658617675304413,
-0.6486293077468872,
0.13078360259532928,
0.028609033674001694,
-0.6796237826347351,
0.03082449920475483,
0.5454264283180237,
0.43904954195022583,
-0.49348771572113037,
0.035343993455171585,
0.21204116940498352,
-0.2783687710762024,
0.39903122186660767,
0.4309157431125641,
0.3803181052207947,
0.27853676676750183,
-0.663184404373169,
0.08988600969314575,
-0.542655348777771,
0.4246220588684082,
0.5047526359558105,
-0.03133540228009224,
-0.07438045740127563,
0.21559025347232819,
-0.4833005666732788,
0.7205066680908203,
0.15682554244995117,
0.02523593232035637,
0.3063870072364807,
-0.2505697011947632,
-0.1929030865430832,
-0.43926864862442017,
0.6271108388900757,
0.17875425517559052,
0.2809191048145294,
-0.3528995215892792,
-0.5743992328643799,
0.13852518796920776,
0.040633659809827805,
-0.6201914548873901,
-0.42971721291542053,
0.19737616181373596,
-0.1477852761745453,
0.08315855264663696,
-0.2309521734714508,
-0.3778669238090515,
-0.46414127945899963,
-0.389016330242157,
0.5474609136581421,
-0.5988143086433411,
-0.22447451949119568,
-0.08753470331430435,
-0.02766011655330658,
-0.160673126578331,
0.6430647373199463,
-0.6159054636955261,
0.4280073344707489,
0.7126876711845398,
1.04958176612854,
-0.5666469931602478,
-0.5336000323295593,
-0.6631811261177063,
-0.15685351192951202,
-0.14012610912322998,
0.9354943633079529,
-0.6591413617134094,
-0.4747062027454376,
-0.34723150730133057,
-0.18574708700180054,
-0.3147004246711731,
-0.7001658082008362,
0.1788226068019867,
-0.3705309331417084,
0.2711476683616638,
-0.22185105085372925,
-0.8412507176399231,
-0.26930904388427734,
0.21517689526081085,
-0.5201117396354675,
0.7107239961624146,
0.1210656687617302,
-0.5479198098182678,
0.49503636360168457,
-0.633015513420105,
-0.440774142742157,
-0.15894252061843872,
-0.04098278284072876,
-0.0003347428282722831,
0.3826712965965271,
-0.03859419375658035,
0.5126076340675354,
-0.3871394991874695,
0.17129582166671753,
-0.2713416516780853,
-0.4979614019393921,
0.30633866786956787,
-0.48831573128700256,
0.668698787689209,
0.38629448413848877,
-0.29849332571029663,
0.21485546231269836,
-0.5373454689979553,
-0.30282720923423767,
-0.2197033017873764,
-0.08673655986785889,
-0.41884735226631165,
-0.282221257686615,
-0.5767393708229065,
0.27980896830558777,
0.55955570936203,
-0.37297213077545166,
0.004550520796328783,
-0.4088558554649353,
0.030741702765226364,
0.717774510383606,
-0.2726611793041229,
0.41709962487220764,
-0.5547220706939697,
0.9223223328590393,
0.16858668625354767,
0.2523883283138275,
-0.27204522490501404,
-0.5653305053710938,
-0.6303778886795044,
-0.519637405872345,
0.01377254817634821,
0.599586009979248,
-0.6153265833854675,
0.32533594965934753,
-0.06999926269054413,
-0.5433619618415833,
-0.21510933339595795,
0.21189309656620026,
0.5748146176338196,
0.5568152666091919,
0.3908965289592743,
-0.4640708565711975,
-0.21116018295288086,
-0.9801588654518127,
-0.5630123019218445,
-0.25776684284210205,
-0.19220077991485596,
0.4953368902206421,
0.3105206787586212,
-0.21109849214553833,
1.0021414756774902,
-0.4905056357383728,
-0.0908576250076294,
-0.06603425741195679,
0.49002379179000854,
0.5919512510299683,
0.4259260296821594,
0.5996688604354858,
-0.4547814726829529,
-0.48567086458206177,
-0.0935540646314621,
-0.5109122395515442,
-0.401610404253006,
0.0744420662522316,
0.2584460377693176,
0.42208927869796753,
0.2726561725139618,
-0.3283681869506836,
0.21054893732070923,
0.5167285203933716,
-0.49587658047676086,
0.9186316132545471,
-0.3403833508491516,
0.3048683702945709,
-0.8109771013259888,
0.259504109621048,
0.04381662234663963,
-0.1848510205745697,
-0.7910929322242737,
-0.1622074991464615,
-0.06411758810281754,
0.363260954618454,
-0.18042589724063873,
0.7767248749732971,
-0.5217350721359253,
-0.04010806232690811,
-0.46039995551109314,
0.0897541344165802,
-0.11967819184064865,
0.43354684114456177,
-0.0805547833442688,
1.1898711919784546,
0.7669834494590759,
-0.642277717590332,
0.18465295433998108,
0.029280830174684525,
-0.22319650650024414,
0.7150230407714844,
-0.56623774766922,
0.11257415264844894,
0.0801178365945816,
-0.056884974241256714,
-1.5377863645553589,
-0.1359586864709854,
0.07761219888925552,
-0.8538244366645813,
0.2065305858850479,
-0.05168190971016884,
-0.2270994782447815,
-0.038798894733190536,
-0.0983971655368805,
0.45014190673828125,
0.5732401609420776,
-0.28514590859413147,
0.6562160849571228,
0.2627202570438385,
-0.12229374796152115,
-0.6702577471733093,
-0.3888759911060333,
0.06417800486087799,
-0.21398800611495972,
-0.379865437746048,
-0.15327581763267517,
-0.27203094959259033,
-0.12845955789089203,
-0.5005030632019043,
-0.4714692533016205,
-0.08795946836471558,
0.5542845129966736,
0.6420428156852722,
0.12525081634521484,
-0.1456502377986908,
-0.004508407320827246,
0.197323277592659,
-0.28475087881088257,
0.3949657380580902,
-0.01688462495803833,
0.4436919689178467,
-0.13869380950927734,
-0.47270387411117554,
-0.3076750636100769,
0.11813121289014816,
0.584547221660614,
0.09834769368171692,
0.19383133947849274,
0.3871057331562042,
-0.21377187967300415,
-0.12223747372627258,
-0.5636849999427795,
-0.2221556305885315,
-0.5074043273925781,
0.06535171717405319,
-0.6765572428703308,
-1.0240426063537598,
0.7420422434806824,
-0.3656620383262634,
0.011519977822899818,
0.27226144075393677,
0.24383991956710815,
0.09159352630376816,
1.1393131017684937,
0.5135009288787842,
-0.048368826508522034,
0.41343557834625244,
0.07384119182825089,
-0.18561388552188873,
-0.5458522439002991,
-0.13837620615959167,
-0.588768720626831,
-0.11352615058422089,
-0.010265904478728771,
-0.3762555718421936,
0.36207789182662964,
-0.014485789462924004,
-0.24504972994327545,
0.32079413533210754,
0.008241374045610428,
0.1704672873020172,
0.6395814418792725,
-0.12025626748800278,
0.4318773150444031,
0.18834194540977478,
-0.5189318656921387,
0.010854184627532959,
-0.6080561280250549,
-0.5940467715263367,
0.7450589537620544,
0.27232062816619873,
0.34582939743995667,
0.10961852967739105,
0.6659127473831177,
0.43836709856987,
0.2883269190788269,
-0.6529688835144043,
0.6286338567733765,
-0.3042789399623871,
-0.4071907699108124,
-0.30628702044487,
-0.38569340109825134,
-0.8924445509910583,
-0.0004018661566078663,
-0.06425781548023224,
-0.9095244407653809,
0.029543248936533928,
0.3587467074394226,
-0.6257593631744385,
0.011379330419003963,
-0.4678310453891754,
0.7480623126029968,
0.19197864830493927,
-0.2135583758354187,
-0.16701221466064453,
-0.5881945490837097,
0.1413673311471939,
-0.13311141729354858,
0.19609645009040833,
-0.3790654242038727,
-0.4630870521068573,
0.693554699420929,
-0.26951026916503906,
0.7421228289604187,
-0.33181360363960266,
-0.29983100295066833,
0.05434493348002434,
0.4519633948802948,
0.4016205370426178,
-0.27315887808799744,
-0.13324299454689026,
0.24409832060337067,
-0.23026643693447113,
-0.2774847149848938,
-0.7829053997993469,
0.895684540271759,
-0.7626503109931946,
-0.9568650126457214,
-0.21548672020435333,
-0.8923768997192383,
-0.6109179258346558,
0.11205940693616867,
0.23745861649513245,
0.5101035833358765,
0.015489302575588226,
-0.10542836040258408,
0.7139480710029602,
-0.06695108115673065,
0.24864566326141357,
0.6227452158927917,
0.0017635948024690151,
-0.4348891079425812,
0.8476302623748779,
0.0948634147644043,
0.38343268632888794,
0.4230154752731323,
0.23708191514015198,
-0.551385760307312,
-0.6125984787940979,
-0.4548918902873993,
-0.01763490028679371,
-0.6514294743537903,
-0.02964385785162449,
-0.935846209526062,
0.23598843812942505,
-0.27720513939857483,
-0.3246435821056366,
-0.0916949212551117,
-0.6643344163894653,
-0.268503338098526,
0.08576828241348267,
0.390322208404541,
0.4311648905277252,
-0.10220549255609512,
0.4474956691265106,
-0.5181240439414978,
0.12376425415277481,
0.20879951119422913,
0.2525193989276886,
0.12056795507669449,
-0.9362810850143433,
-0.17766760289669037,
-0.044595614075660706,
-0.10756159573793411,
-0.820173442363739,
0.1310848891735077,
0.2135465294122696,
0.7822683453559875,
0.5132940411567688,
0.2928661108016968,
0.45552685856819153,
-0.21044118702411652,
0.9108744263648987,
0.3693810701370239,
-1.2608954906463623,
0.593062162399292,
-0.350837379693985,
0.5393130779266357,
0.4775255620479584,
0.6567986011505127,
-0.36021873354911804,
-0.7156881093978882,
-0.5077503323554993,
-0.8995811343193054,
0.7026675343513489,
0.04665983468294144,
-0.006351955235004425,
0.07713785022497177,
0.1632908284664154,
0.5379616022109985,
0.4370175898075104,
-0.12304605543613434,
-0.4620949327945709,
-0.019596124067902565,
-0.10972820967435837,
-0.29846858978271484,
-0.12161392718553543,
-0.11851117014884949,
-0.2613869309425354,
0.4349542260169983,
-0.25323912501335144,
0.18592490255832672,
0.24427668750286102,
-0.25523433089256287,
-0.09422776103019714,
0.1266734004020691,
0.6136049032211304,
0.8544601798057556,
-0.11760033667087555,
0.4050828516483307,
0.3861856162548065,
-0.47737136483192444,
0.4395471215248108,
0.055323436856269836,
0.02538478933274746,
0.07027112692594528,
0.3792027533054352,
0.8752515912055969,
0.18059152364730835,
-0.7584377527236938,
0.5235198140144348,
0.26226943731307983,
-0.14239129424095154,
-0.1712384819984436,
0.7091764211654663,
-0.27095919847488403,
0.390971302986145,
0.5177954435348511,
0.22704920172691345,
0.6383481025695801,
-0.23101724684238434,
0.5054745674133301,
0.36653071641921997,
-0.5900999903678894,
-0.5364132523536682,
0.7784516215324402,
0.058093905448913574,
-0.24049779772758484,
0.042888641357421875,
-0.057126402854919434,
-0.37033677101135254,
0.7627432346343994,
0.3534820079803467,
1.1430630683898926,
-0.6118282675743103,
0.19930419325828552,
0.17756718397140503,
0.11718182265758514,
0.02780313789844513,
0.23652489483356476,
-0.4326332211494446,
-0.6502951383590698,
-0.15671610832214355,
-0.29461294412612915,
-0.60170978307724,
-0.227868914604187,
-0.611243724822998,
0.03388255834579468,
-0.5606517791748047,
-0.47066524624824524,
-0.020781368017196655,
0.25628507137298584,
-0.49187251925468445,
0.2332478016614914,
0.07984914630651474,
1.131911277770996,
-0.8658628463745117,
0.6818438768386841,
1.2448559999465942,
-0.16770906746387482,
-0.4437373876571655,
0.01695466786623001,
0.10449551790952682,
-0.6023608446121216,
0.32772502303123474,
0.22567498683929443,
-0.6180351376533508,
0.03484274074435234,
-0.26375290751457214,
-0.5897771120071411,
1.1380077600479126,
0.484831839799881,
-0.4060007929801941,
0.2079056054353714,
0.12895506620407104,
0.5370638966560364,
-0.6952611804008484,
0.6233527064323425,
0.544237494468689,
0.4349726140499115,
0.18039192259311676,
-0.9130197763442993,
0.3844378590583801,
-0.20607395470142365,
0.01570781320333481,
-0.04953484609723091,
-0.4254281520843506,
0.9447619915008545,
-0.39301949739456177,
-0.424433171749115,
0.2870039939880371,
0.694042980670929,
0.5013228058815002,
0.8937575221061707,
0.8871774077415466,
0.07612504065036774,
0.7967983484268188,
0.013487329706549644,
0.8277037143707275,
-0.5185525417327881,
0.3190208971500397,
1.0058534145355225,
-0.19726724922657013,
0.5665738582611084,
0.48877623677253723,
-0.24361081421375275,
0.508703887462616,
0.47891467809677124,
0.34579432010650635,
0.3275661766529083,
-0.0028734744992107153,
-0.2794274687767029,
-0.693654477596283,
-0.08775933086872101,
-0.24812810122966766,
0.17848646640777588,
0.2393535077571869,
-0.36053022742271423,
-0.3011566698551178,
-0.03385552018880844,
0.3084433078765869,
0.14662431180477142,
-0.14943711459636688,
0.7356014251708984,
0.08185771852731705,
-0.7864599823951721,
0.9361017942428589,
-0.38380491733551025,
0.720902144908905,
-0.5853603482246399,
0.149199977517128,
-0.42729395627975464,
0.0700782835483551,
0.017894117161631584,
-0.8609833121299744,
0.21557174623012543,
-0.12190359830856323,
-0.3908312916755676,
0.06038323789834976,
0.6358868479728699,
-0.3916231393814087,
-0.02631133235991001,
0.29622700810432434,
0.7487484812736511,
0.3423406183719635,
-0.3398597836494446,
-0.6279134154319763,
-0.10998847335577011,
-0.061639148741960526,
-0.24228361248970032,
0.36706146597862244,
0.6430046558380127,
0.08350857347249985,
0.9349904656410217,
0.33741092681884766,
-0.27010050415992737,
-0.15654484927654266,
-0.29617956280708313,
0.7408472895622253,
-0.3666599988937378,
-0.42170754075050354,
-0.9450137615203857,
0.26987478137016296,
-0.07979244738817215,
-0.6690309047698975,
0.939135730266571,
0.5561586022377014,
0.612139105796814,
-0.29487988352775574,
0.7731980681419373,
0.18879716098308563,
0.4519023001194,
-0.1426369994878769,
0.6369264125823975,
-0.8739400506019592,
0.26442021131515503,
-0.46575993299484253,
-0.6780266165733337,
-0.14692862331867218,
0.33987218141555786,
-0.43053188920021057,
-0.09463401138782501,
0.3674446940422058,
0.7780753970146179,
-0.24208270013332367,
0.167604461312294,
0.7391489744186401,
0.17414020001888275,
0.10903636366128922,
0.7257240414619446,
0.9340985417366028,
-0.08732464164495468,
0.2689029574394226,
-0.16145184636116028,
-0.6972495913505554,
-0.35077840089797974,
-0.8604920506477356,
-0.8353858590126038,
-0.8534225821495056,
-0.4552135467529297,
-0.15792086720466614,
0.24780717492103577,
1.0324084758758545,
0.4321729838848114,
-0.9719487428665161,
-0.5649605989456177,
0.18899980187416077,
0.15079979598522186,
-0.5858004689216614,
-0.13656538724899292,
0.04656586796045303,
-0.5607757568359375,
-0.7616541385650635,
0.3916734457015991,
0.22473397850990295,
0.02849743701517582,
-0.13294534385204315,
-0.20141926407814026,
0.005499258637428284,
0.33973708748817444,
0.589777946472168,
0.2502167820930481,
-0.8092552423477173,
-0.31193333864212036,
0.008837200701236725,
0.05595700815320015,
-0.18174432218074799,
0.7987982034683228,
-0.87227863073349,
0.3628389537334442,
0.6321997046470642,
0.5328677892684937,
-0.17796726524829865,
0.06135605648159981,
0.7959243059158325,
-0.6515549421310425,
-0.11019739508628845,
0.010851522907614708,
0.3246784210205078,
0.19597557187080383,
-0.3086521625518799,
0.46750959753990173,
0.41993340849876404,
-0.4323830306529999,
-0.8373189568519592,
0.4477585554122925,
-0.7832745313644409,
-0.18713299930095673,
1.154073715209961,
-0.7392791509628296,
-0.18065033853054047,
-0.4683294892311096,
-0.06684519350528717,
0.1694919317960739,
-0.6060826778411865,
0.6265748739242554,
0.7344001531600952,
-0.2727217972278595,
-0.0008781386422924697,
-0.4011516571044922,
0.6220033764839172,
0.6320031881332397,
-0.3880692720413208,
0.19542595744132996,
0.6926432847976685,
0.4613654315471649,
0.28900009393692017,
0.5364174246788025,
0.2178933322429657,
0.4305710792541504,
-0.22218644618988037,
-0.12986914813518524,
-0.4113147556781769,
-0.587293267250061,
-0.46740660071372986,
0.38920506834983826,
0.24272407591342926,
-0.15720342099666595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15481v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15481v1 | CSRT: Evaluation and Analysis of LLMs using Code-Switching Red-Teaming Dataset | 2024-06-17T06:08:18 | 2024-06-17T06:08:18 | Haneul Yoo, Yongjin Yang, Hwaran Lee | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent studies in large language models (LLMs) shed light on their
multilingual ability and safety, beyond conventional tasks in language
modeling. Still, current benchmarks reveal their inability to comprehensively
evaluate them and are excessively dependent on manual annotations. In this
paper, we introduce code-switching red-teaming (CSRT), a simple yet effective
red-teaming technique that simultaneously tests multilingual understanding and
safety of LLMs. We release the CSRT dataset, which comprises 315 code-switching
queries combining up to 10 languages and eliciting a wide range of undesirable
behaviors. Through extensive experiments with ten state-of-the-art LLMs, we
demonstrate that CSRT significantly outperforms existing multilingual
red-teaming techniques, achieving 46.7% more attacks than existing methods in
English. We analyze the harmful responses toward the CSRT dataset concerning
various aspects under ablation studies with 16K samples, including but not
limited to scaling laws, unsafe behavior categories, and input conditions for
optimal data generation. Additionally, we validate the extensibility of CSRT,
by generating code-switching attack prompts with monolingual data. | [
-0.28835058212280273,
-0.9533351063728333,
-0.07077160477638245,
0.43278926610946655,
-0.141805037856102,
0.5910336971282959,
-0.5934316515922546,
-0.5864848494529724,
-0.15169094502925873,
0.45491111278533936,
-0.32881879806518555,
-0.4364500641822815,
-0.5018764734268188,
0.2808559834957123,
-0.6659290790557861,
1.144989013671875,
-0.15127336978912354,
0.22977270185947418,
-0.01647087000310421,
-0.15399734675884247,
-0.5120018124580383,
-0.8849958777427673,
-0.6750503182411194,
-0.10918506234884262,
0.5625783205032349,
0.4977060556411743,
0.5756650567054749,
0.22288459539413452,
0.9081365466117859,
0.3493058383464813,
0.06994306296110153,
-0.02229083888232708,
-0.6980514526367188,
0.11273100972175598,
0.09091340005397797,
-0.4844946563243866,
-0.2821807265281677,
-0.2553674578666687,
0.5955758094787598,
0.5379617214202881,
-0.011611365713179111,
0.25790560245513916,
0.21845954656600952,
0.5453912019729614,
-0.6223751902580261,
-0.1744525283575058,
-0.8625039458274841,
0.0763520821928978,
-0.34973278641700745,
-0.4117835760116577,
-0.9212555289268494,
-0.2703430950641632,
-0.04708088934421539,
-0.15707100927829742,
0.0776287242770195,
0.03409432992339134,
0.5493397116661072,
0.1836124062538147,
-0.49950647354125977,
-0.11262302100658417,
-0.6744946837425232,
0.9352288246154785,
-0.16072677075862885,
0.5384870767593384,
0.27077656984329224,
0.4880896806716919,
0.22054840624332428,
-0.5063691139221191,
-0.27484130859375,
-0.3920791745185852,
-0.15504810214042664,
0.2067183256149292,
-0.5633983016014099,
-0.11694027483463287,
0.08771204948425293,
-0.12046932429075241,
-0.7984744310379028,
0.11384042352437973,
-0.4389055669307709,
-0.20856183767318726,
0.6214913129806519,
0.04000140354037285,
0.5891889929771423,
0.13451483845710754,
-0.7849885821342468,
-0.21065033972263336,
-0.5386879444122314,
-0.12586194276809692,
0.13902895152568817,
0.6785538196563721,
-0.35030877590179443,
0.36938047409057617,
-0.07357721775770187,
0.45382359623908997,
-0.12565617263317108,
0.0860605463385582,
0.2485574632883072,
-0.5551703572273254,
-0.3400603234767914,
0.03924895450472832,
0.776590883731842,
0.4361921548843384,
0.2459811419248581,
-0.40399858355522156,
0.08123989403247833,
0.43879976868629456,
0.14010104537010193,
-0.5077038407325745,
-0.18877041339874268,
0.36763525009155273,
-0.26251083612442017,
-0.485194593667984,
-0.16243641078472137,
-0.8848258256912231,
-0.15708424150943756,
0.043687134981155396,
-0.05022045969963074,
-0.560026228427887,
-0.534005343914032,
0.1250925064086914,
0.024324921891093254,
0.28391024470329285,
0.02443408966064453,
-0.5405779480934143,
0.5343347191810608,
0.43906736373901367,
0.7474369406700134,
-0.7584657073020935,
-0.6880240440368652,
-0.7405677437782288,
-0.08043166995048523,
-0.09197089076042175,
0.8316107988357544,
-0.3574122190475464,
-0.45843201875686646,
-0.03655814751982689,
-0.025606878101825714,
-0.161294087767601,
-0.30199092626571655,
0.18339569866657257,
-0.6683861613273621,
-0.17571957409381866,
-0.1958872377872467,
-0.052785053849220276,
-0.002296874765306711,
0.6190375089645386,
-0.5309872031211853,
0.9772989749908447,
-0.3428407311439514,
-0.8330488801002502,
0.26206257939338684,
-0.6904146671295166,
-0.5378665328025818,
0.12152346968650818,
-0.013844764791429043,
-0.40183505415916443,
-0.3590813875198364,
-0.08679883182048798,
0.1286589801311493,
-0.11296112090349197,
-0.13290198147296906,
-0.21636489033699036,
-0.15479309856891632,
0.6254317760467529,
-0.5117698311805725,
1.0260485410690308,
0.23559647798538208,
-0.29070845246315,
0.05224820226430893,
-0.33893924951553345,
0.27188530564308167,
0.20144830644130707,
-0.4010170102119446,
-0.3932832181453705,
-0.10597071051597595,
0.3201215863227844,
0.3786861300468445,
0.2458353340625763,
-0.4857158958911896,
-0.041306156665086746,
0.09551486372947693,
0.17596760392189026,
0.45528095960617065,
0.03654805198311806,
0.3025708496570587,
-0.26674938201904297,
0.9347306489944458,
-0.2239685207605362,
0.2679310441017151,
0.20035512745380402,
-0.15100479125976562,
-0.6582139730453491,
-0.14062446355819702,
0.2329443097114563,
0.8806119561195374,
-0.8850525617599487,
-0.07967258244752884,
-0.0546637661755085,
-0.4747779965400696,
-0.15671011805534363,
0.09499545395374298,
0.7489911317825317,
0.10898539423942566,
0.413198322057724,
0.04124358296394348,
-0.6781782507896423,
-0.7970324754714966,
-0.3897705078125,
-0.19982421398162842,
0.5183934569358826,
-0.031179074198007584,
0.5580756664276123,
-0.1717047095298767,
0.6793184280395508,
-0.2341383695602417,
0.14186836779117584,
-0.654504120349884,
0.06812247633934021,
-0.24163691699504852,
0.41859012842178345,
0.38612300157546997,
-0.8070815205574036,
-0.6766005158424377,
0.32582616806030273,
-0.6311285495758057,
-0.12771448493003845,
-0.41372373700141907,
-0.1796867698431015,
0.46101266145706177,
0.7617499828338623,
-0.05545825511217117,
0.23619785904884338,
0.9393137097358704,
-0.3551746606826782,
0.7960655093193054,
0.0688757374882698,
0.3494375944137573,
-0.5332129001617432,
0.22213244438171387,
-0.04627265781164169,
-0.13764230906963348,
-0.8459116816520691,
0.43618205189704895,
0.37266233563423157,
0.14031094312667847,
-0.9528796076774597,
0.3773573040962219,
-0.5294553637504578,
-0.0197516568005085,
-0.08008939027786255,
0.03683698922395706,
-0.29686281085014343,
0.49539777636528015,
-0.02376801334321499,
0.7433267831802368,
0.1501026302576065,
-0.5017494559288025,
0.17389623820781708,
0.1635034829378128,
-0.13932208716869354,
0.4112560451030731,
-0.4255818724632263,
0.27223411202430725,
0.14245374500751495,
-0.04452003911137581,
-1.0701359510421753,
0.2155439406633377,
-0.018552688881754875,
-0.5334786176681519,
0.26924923062324524,
-0.34181466698646545,
-0.6142783761024475,
-0.1488567441701889,
-0.2659890353679657,
0.6125785112380981,
0.23809389770030975,
-0.45634666085243225,
0.2665720582008362,
0.5371751189231873,
-0.208162322640419,
-0.6837608814239502,
-1.0986703634262085,
0.3661580979824066,
-0.42405492067337036,
-0.5011997818946838,
-0.028027215972542763,
-0.24585458636283875,
-0.5778514742851257,
-0.23246143758296967,
0.09280029684305191,
-0.3428553640842438,
0.3103471100330353,
0.03913931921124458,
0.5257119536399841,
0.10026739537715912,
-0.11192071437835693,
-0.10848163068294525,
-0.25975972414016724,
0.031855423003435135,
0.20529425144195557,
0.6634475588798523,
-0.5343461632728577,
-0.47849124670028687,
-0.06207602843642235,
0.3638547360897064,
0.33179885149002075,
-0.48688197135925293,
0.3179212808609009,
0.26885971426963806,
-0.19921889901161194,
-0.24774889647960663,
-0.33235839009284973,
-0.07234791666269302,
-0.4694758951663971,
0.7048338651657104,
-0.151502788066864,
-1.0185045003890991,
0.44074809551239014,
-0.027074947953224182,
0.34284335374832153,
0.03537648543715477,
0.6957123875617981,
-0.00767991179600358,
0.8204879760742188,
0.5088487863540649,
-0.06728371232748032,
0.39525726437568665,
0.053719185292720795,
0.023581037297844887,
-0.24974001944065094,
0.002909626578912139,
-0.5658815503120422,
-0.08353087306022644,
-0.5974724888801575,
-0.5077739953994751,
0.6072779893875122,
-0.12085633724927902,
-0.2977083921432495,
0.5324294567108154,
-0.4736723005771637,
0.7608094811439514,
0.06938199698925018,
-0.011200790293514729,
0.5458412766456604,
-0.054692912846803665,
-0.2096461057662964,
-0.10160022228956223,
-0.6487122178077698,
-0.308691143989563,
1.0475778579711914,
0.29426339268684387,
0.7504419684410095,
0.3468952178955078,
0.5115749835968018,
0.27001500129699707,
0.24748340249061584,
-0.5830622911453247,
0.713586688041687,
-0.23422780632972717,
-0.6547739505767822,
-0.37339723110198975,
-0.4145026206970215,
-0.9689348340034485,
0.4091852903366089,
-0.31502866744995117,
-0.39906036853790283,
-0.12627747654914856,
0.16894753277301788,
-0.2259049266576767,
0.2774837911128998,
-0.926788330078125,
0.7111939787864685,
-0.7780341506004333,
-0.44401803612709045,
-0.24394065141677856,
-0.6531286835670471,
0.5916745662689209,
-0.24293287098407745,
0.4330611824989319,
0.23501355946063995,
-0.037096038460731506,
0.468380331993103,
-0.14534032344818115,
1.0507090091705322,
-0.0011551056522876024,
0.031906940042972565,
0.016613179817795753,
0.46433761715888977,
0.32424214482307434,
-0.01661624386906624,
-0.0931970551609993,
0.45255327224731445,
-0.06997400522232056,
-0.17295953631401062,
-0.3062412738800049,
0.5463401079177856,
-0.4913766384124756,
-0.12511298060417175,
-0.5790799260139465,
-0.4474242627620697,
-0.312060683965683,
0.41516128182411194,
0.12522245943546295,
0.10029446333646774,
-0.4307204484939575,
0.050258491188287735,
0.5972033739089966,
-0.44662395119667053,
0.43910056352615356,
0.7798320651054382,
-0.3343784213066101,
-0.38431310653686523,
0.9581203460693359,
-0.0678255632519722,
0.6314784288406372,
0.44338852167129517,
-0.020074373111128807,
-0.11545218527317047,
-0.7396117448806763,
-0.21165694296360016,
0.10528586804866791,
-0.511841893196106,
-0.28832992911338806,
-0.4387463629245758,
-0.07546642422676086,
-0.09253878146409988,
-0.3531557321548462,
-0.5533487200737,
-0.23483675718307495,
0.3282766342163086,
-0.08304186165332794,
0.34212034940719604,
0.4117168188095093,
-0.05641988292336464,
-0.007991069927811623,
-0.7153931260108948,
-0.009444160386919975,
0.2025425285100937,
0.30618932843208313,
-0.22527413070201874,
-0.009049306623637676,
-0.34143826365470886,
-0.1205272302031517,
-0.20953279733657837,
-0.9361816048622131,
0.25704336166381836,
-0.26671844720840454,
0.4668533504009247,
0.041913505643606186,
0.24849680066108704,
0.4998820722103119,
-0.404460072517395,
0.5819848775863647,
0.3484375774860382,
-0.9263882637023926,
0.2834172248840332,
-0.5082448124885559,
0.31295815110206604,
0.9364689588546753,
0.08839035034179688,
-0.8451339602470398,
-0.4963911771774292,
-0.3477126657962799,
-0.9557458162307739,
0.5151892900466919,
0.24059832096099854,
-0.3094918429851532,
-0.211639866232872,
-0.23862995207309723,
-0.0980483889579773,
-0.0474216490983963,
-0.9779630303382874,
-0.4560226500034332,
-0.041606489568948746,
0.17802448570728302,
0.12595173716545105,
0.06308455020189285,
-0.1518663913011551,
-0.03612261265516281,
0.49832606315612793,
-0.12709815800189972,
0.27935510873794556,
0.03370879963040352,
-0.4767271876335144,
-0.049166418612003326,
0.4119473695755005,
0.7514777183532715,
0.3895895183086395,
-0.00043351459316909313,
0.24656152725219727,
0.7408561706542969,
-0.4394831657409668,
-0.007386877201497555,
-0.03274032101035118,
0.1604718267917633,
-0.14636217057704926,
0.45701169967651367,
0.25042977929115295,
0.40572938323020935,
-0.828194797039032,
0.5060009956359863,
-0.2626684010028839,
-0.32801055908203125,
-0.30388519167900085,
-0.15182948112487793,
0.08463483303785324,
-0.03248022496700287,
0.11069997400045395,
0.0819830521941185,
-0.12860845029354095,
-0.17653334140777588,
0.43912187218666077,
0.6274058222770691,
-0.36110568046569824,
-0.11710935086011887,
0.3380562961101532,
0.43414172530174255,
-0.0504026934504509,
0.3434528112411499,
-0.10430894792079926,
-0.6118088960647583,
0.6752764582633972,
0.5838372111320496,
0.7876978516578674,
-0.3093029260635376,
0.1201760470867157,
0.3242212235927582,
0.7987572550773621,
0.11757392436265945,
0.2067437320947647,
0.07324347645044327,
-0.7834568619728088,
-0.4987865090370178,
-0.12277133017778397,
-0.7031336426734924,
-0.06216169148683548,
-0.856880247592926,
0.4857112169265747,
-0.3105660080909729,
0.12759099900722504,
-0.2323714792728424,
-0.13891813158988953,
-0.4910097122192383,
-0.09390812367200851,
0.1201898381114006,
1.0324885845184326,
-0.7814404964447021,
0.8244879245758057,
0.782264769077301,
-0.2187962383031845,
-0.35396572947502136,
-0.13422006368637085,
0.18235613405704498,
-1.0204362869262695,
0.6927503943443298,
-0.24887707829475403,
-0.3543652892112732,
-0.25228333473205566,
-0.4697282612323761,
-0.6745266914367676,
0.9254637360572815,
0.41490963101387024,
-0.6345012784004211,
0.24275833368301392,
0.5288745164871216,
0.39423707127571106,
0.009132929146289825,
0.2608438730239868,
0.7484052181243896,
0.4911406934261322,
-0.23850016295909882,
-1.0109220743179321,
0.02771792560815811,
-0.3473004698753357,
-0.3347114026546478,
0.3444305658340454,
-0.8852759599685669,
0.6798956394195557,
-0.24867315590381622,
-0.33749452233314514,
-0.23566581308841705,
0.23291170597076416,
0.4703114330768585,
0.1477702409029007,
0.8335035443305969,
0.12132079154253006,
0.5947456359863281,
0.11215601861476898,
0.8795309662818909,
-0.43845927715301514,
0.45172756910324097,
1.171383023262024,
-0.3874198794364929,
1.0190068483352661,
0.4831037223339081,
-0.2034069150686264,
0.1607688069343567,
0.15088315308094025,
-0.0026824777014553547,
0.39521148800849915,
0.27800479531288147,
-0.24466289579868317,
-0.411097913980484,
0.24570724368095398,
-0.43559613823890686,
0.5598791241645813,
0.17193861305713654,
-0.018139516934752464,
-0.410224586725235,
0.07879766821861267,
0.5205456018447876,
0.07907304167747498,
0.0804920345544815,
0.7211551666259766,
-0.12040916830301285,
-0.5316658020019531,
0.7345689535140991,
-0.16189874708652496,
1.0023179054260254,
-0.7638855576515198,
0.009340799413621426,
-0.2068711668252945,
0.08604562282562256,
-0.2796948552131653,
-0.6337736248970032,
0.3620261251926422,
0.38803333044052124,
-0.01702909544110298,
-0.5185595750808716,
0.5670501589775085,
-0.4801306128501892,
-0.5444526672363281,
0.5732176899909973,
0.46226295828819275,
0.06572866439819336,
0.3234182894229889,
-0.8690343499183655,
0.4298219680786133,
0.21135269105434418,
0.13085466623306274,
0.6168169975280762,
0.019718773663043976,
-0.10418391972780228,
0.600193440914154,
0.718045711517334,
0.14629283547401428,
-0.014387168921530247,
-0.08466698974370956,
0.7308571934700012,
-0.6865187287330627,
-0.45237866044044495,
-0.9470345377922058,
0.5048971772193909,
-0.014200922101736069,
-0.32809969782829285,
1.0044100284576416,
0.7187128663063049,
0.8391737937927246,
0.2566187083721161,
1.2072092294692993,
0.15582074224948883,
0.4721769094467163,
-0.46684926748275757,
0.9992834329605103,
-0.19657817482948303,
0.3743259608745575,
-0.6235591769218445,
-0.30065086483955383,
-0.6171448826789856,
0.36489197611808777,
-0.19525286555290222,
0.0006666878471150994,
1.011642575263977,
0.6907039284706116,
0.1872253715991974,
0.1295941174030304,
0.31970110535621643,
0.37121546268463135,
0.5234386324882507,
0.6554695963859558,
0.9208430647850037,
-0.2621121108531952,
1.06703782081604,
-0.21174311637878418,
-0.4766685366630554,
-0.127084881067276,
-1.0249427556991577,
-0.9267463088035583,
-0.2819911241531372,
-0.5220602750778198,
-0.42387986183166504,
0.3000946342945099,
0.7860669493675232,
0.4958237409591675,
-0.6917324066162109,
-0.6392604112625122,
-0.026004940271377563,
0.07942348718643188,
-0.43187442421913147,
-0.19270001351833344,
0.09391042590141296,
-0.46083885431289673,
-0.544243574142456,
0.5597514510154724,
0.11409305036067963,
-0.018842659890651703,
-0.21498434245586395,
-0.07913609594106674,
-0.15071235597133636,
-0.41021019220352173,
0.6973953247070312,
0.5818430185317993,
-0.30363163352012634,
-0.24829509854316711,
0.2277844399213791,
-0.16674160957336426,
-0.22653809189796448,
0.9197149276733398,
-0.4427781403064728,
0.270887553691864,
0.34769406914711,
0.7633317112922668,
0.1887865513563156,
-0.26497435569763184,
0.4839516282081604,
-0.6843137145042419,
-0.042994506657123566,
0.2136266827583313,
0.28723451495170593,
0.064537413418293,
-0.19449369609355927,
0.5627961158752441,
-0.022316856309771538,
-0.6416893005371094,
-1.1065229177474976,
0.06780349463224411,
-1.1515145301818848,
-0.3528599441051483,
1.5912469625473022,
0.11002948880195618,
-0.012606397271156311,
-0.5597960948944092,
-0.1706259548664093,
0.029734093695878983,
-0.3328850567340851,
0.6215261816978455,
0.5458061099052429,
-0.3302951157093048,
-0.03918730095028877,
-0.5925789475440979,
0.4491923451423645,
0.6239044666290283,
-0.9816385507583618,
0.4985595643520355,
0.23885586857795715,
0.35197409987449646,
0.12939020991325378,
0.6800903081893921,
-0.187388613820076,
0.6352119445800781,
-0.19385215640068054,
0.31725990772247314,
-0.09420296549797058,
-0.12339229136705399,
-0.5141941905021667,
0.28320249915122986,
0.0301265437155962,
-0.2811155319213867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11239v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11239v1 | Evading AI-Generated Content Detectors using Homoglyphs | 2024-06-17T06:07:32 | 2024-06-17T06:07:32 | Aldan Creo, Shushanta Pudasaini | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The generation of text that is increasingly human-like has been enabled by
the advent of large language models (LLMs). As the detection of AI-generated
content holds significant importance in the fight against issues such as
misinformation and academic cheating, numerous studies have been conducted to
develop reliable LLM detectors. While promising results have been demonstrated
by such detectors on test data, recent research has revealed that they can be
circumvented by employing different techniques. In this article,
homoglyph-based ($a \rightarrow {\alpha}$) attacks that can be used to
circumvent existing LLM detectors are presented. The efficacy of the attacks is
illustrated by analizing how homoglyphs shift the tokenization of the text, and
thus its token loglikelihoods. A comprehensive evaluation is conducted to
assess the effectiveness of homoglyphs on state-of-the-art LLM detectors,
including Binoculars, DetectGPT, OpenAI's detector, and watermarking
techniques, on five different datasets. A significant reduction in the
efficiency of all the studied configurations of detectors and datasets, down to
an accuracy of 0.5 (random guessing), is demonstrated by the proposed approach.
The results show that homoglyph-based attacks can effectively evade existing
LLM detectors, and the implications of these findings are discussed along with
possible defenses against such attacks. | [
-0.40626487135887146,
-1.1926571130752563,
0.413647323846817,
-0.4225703775882721,
-0.3829169273376465,
0.2602153420448303,
-0.09479646384716034,
-0.864833414554596,
0.30271244049072266,
0.28392115235328674,
-0.2058129757642746,
-0.43022751808166504,
-0.8271021842956543,
0.34499531984329224,
-0.7263267636299133,
0.721759021282196,
-0.15392956137657166,
-0.10350903868675232,
0.11009451001882553,
0.16297994554042816,
-0.21590691804885864,
-0.6593616008758545,
-0.5109900832176208,
-0.07133360952138901,
0.4101289212703705,
0.08751280605792999,
0.9522449374198914,
0.7922726273536682,
0.8170754909515381,
0.15449319779872894,
-0.19078515470027924,
0.07820295542478561,
-0.28107282519340515,
0.047248490154743195,
0.31299611926078796,
-0.3658229410648346,
-0.31138527393341064,
-0.006144591607153416,
0.8345176577568054,
0.24989823997020721,
0.09732084721326828,
0.10328375548124313,
-0.19042664766311646,
0.4502617120742798,
-0.6931110620498657,
-0.005602460820227861,
-0.8483551144599915,
0.15049488842487335,
-0.7982802987098694,
-0.245858296751976,
-0.6505629420280457,
-0.13348348438739777,
-0.2059478908777237,
-0.4530552327632904,
0.020681457594037056,
0.36511462926864624,
0.8415731191635132,
0.14330549538135529,
-0.01990385167300701,
-0.8956233859062195,
-0.7811378240585327,
0.8006139993667603,
-0.8490692377090454,
0.33977964520454407,
0.700140655040741,
0.2066732943058014,
-0.24846801161766052,
-0.6984639763832092,
-0.6630637049674988,
-0.2227775901556015,
0.0012049797223880887,
-0.06202351674437523,
-0.4584870934486389,
0.02240194007754326,
0.3331142067909241,
0.4434688091278076,
-0.5258132815361023,
0.20827993750572205,
-0.11163385957479477,
-0.42453789710998535,
0.6821507811546326,
-0.09510324150323868,
0.7511497735977173,
-0.2984497547149658,
-0.3373418152332306,
-0.2749001979827881,
-0.9803704023361206,
-0.1109161525964737,
0.6449040174484253,
0.04293619841337204,
0.225857213139534,
0.7752137780189514,
0.30780887603759766,
0.540450930595398,
0.038402754813432693,
-0.27111947536468506,
-0.1735885590314865,
-0.23739852011203766,
-0.17571453750133514,
0.2469055950641632,
0.7610943913459778,
0.13051989674568176,
0.5403241515159607,
-0.28728652000427246,
-0.4317919909954071,
0.34699901938438416,
0.364463746547699,
-0.7558684945106506,
-0.08036856353282928,
0.25360777974128723,
-0.5912348031997681,
-0.3665328919887543,
0.07945159077644348,
-0.6698641180992126,
-0.3835979104042053,
0.38344892859458923,
0.3743496537208557,
-0.4815269112586975,
0.08854272961616516,
0.07059533894062042,
-0.016371726989746094,
0.42875611782073975,
0.15556640923023224,
-1.0722615718841553,
0.15098433196544647,
0.929233968257904,
0.8469746112823486,
-0.19375616312026978,
-0.11896124482154846,
-0.8330251574516296,
0.2559982240200043,
-0.26050907373428345,
0.7779715061187744,
-0.5848380923271179,
-0.6666573286056519,
0.0017841856461018324,
-0.3756902515888214,
0.20974691212177277,
-0.4591975510120392,
0.5233193635940552,
-0.7140973210334778,
0.09876877814531326,
-0.06510446220636368,
-0.9288193583488464,
-0.13360904157161713,
0.5304883718490601,
-0.8359496593475342,
0.6308978796005249,
-0.1750342696905136,
-1.0992639064788818,
0.20151571929454803,
-0.591627836227417,
-0.6187095642089844,
0.3449009656906128,
-0.39533093571662903,
-0.5276752710342407,
0.1138194277882576,
0.39799022674560547,
0.17118267714977264,
-0.21800054609775543,
-0.08107875287532806,
-0.19094739854335785,
-0.74878990650177,
0.22772900760173798,
-0.5466914176940918,
0.6446906328201294,
0.10418060421943665,
-0.605562150478363,
0.04962930455803871,
-0.3060283064842224,
-0.27322444319725037,
0.3666321635246277,
-0.2022518664598465,
-0.5049520134925842,
0.3035597801208496,
-0.011156300082802773,
-0.2855106294155121,
0.2563806176185608,
-0.6797624230384827,
0.19663776457309723,
-0.32596439123153687,
0.1224040612578392,
0.981401264667511,
-0.02201228402554989,
0.20089851319789886,
-0.30948784947395325,
0.7333489060401917,
-0.2724015712738037,
0.4741848111152649,
-0.3193152844905853,
-0.8832545876502991,
-0.22999274730682373,
-0.4612898528575897,
0.2988284230232239,
0.5175488591194153,
-0.9619881510734558,
0.2654842734336853,
-0.0725303664803505,
-0.3036685585975647,
-0.6620434522628784,
0.17120034992694855,
0.3000434637069702,
0.41050994396209717,
0.26410871744155884,
-0.6215142011642456,
-0.32946276664733887,
-0.553123414516449,
-0.6246283650398254,
-0.6484336853027344,
-0.07629323750734329,
0.23241272568702698,
0.432350754737854,
-0.46714040637016296,
0.85512375831604,
-0.3797035813331604,
-0.04357235133647919,
0.07038111239671707,
0.050480086356401443,
-0.07891246676445007,
0.38274243474006653,
0.7142960429191589,
-0.9882075786590576,
-0.4794924259185791,
-0.1809273511171341,
-0.7935314774513245,
-0.02068488299846649,
-0.21595636010169983,
0.22626692056655884,
0.250569611787796,
0.6601011753082275,
-0.5351101756095886,
0.8781788945198059,
0.5853986740112305,
-0.4841550588607788,
0.7364791631698608,
0.17343373596668243,
0.12126019597053528,
-0.7524509429931641,
0.1347442865371704,
0.006592371966689825,
-0.4097069799900055,
-0.7561959028244019,
0.509883463382721,
-0.10437537729740143,
0.21309207379817963,
-0.374057799577713,
0.8175896406173706,
-0.318805456161499,
-0.06789054721593857,
-0.5000182390213013,
-0.10522288084030151,
-0.19630739092826843,
0.09591592848300934,
-0.2254762202501297,
0.8544953465461731,
0.5583809018135071,
-0.18158914148807526,
0.4299437701702118,
0.3389066755771637,
-0.3782646358013153,
0.4031933546066284,
-0.6290507316589355,
0.4087679088115692,
-0.23270845413208008,
0.265272319316864,
-0.9775425791740417,
-0.09786062687635422,
0.6620575785636902,
-0.5223293900489807,
0.28138574957847595,
-0.12639875710010529,
-0.775219202041626,
-0.14296682178974152,
-0.6890101432800293,
0.36858487129211426,
0.6018286347389221,
-0.8234924674034119,
0.6016110181808472,
0.38388505578041077,
-0.0673147663474083,
-0.5976841449737549,
-0.8281518220901489,
0.5459410548210144,
-0.3967457413673401,
-0.5246636867523193,
0.19260741770267487,
-0.42258602380752563,
-0.5218589305877686,
-0.13113975524902344,
-0.04781561344861984,
0.16091427206993103,
0.4013024568557739,
0.19263556599617004,
0.3731003701686859,
-0.027310984209179878,
-0.2109164595603943,
-0.2923465371131897,
-0.011389311403036118,
0.1942579448223114,
-0.131795272231102,
0.7939775586128235,
-0.047196563333272934,
-0.8467269539833069,
-0.7509350180625916,
0.36454474925994873,
0.5759282112121582,
-0.008059605956077576,
0.6069523096084595,
0.7975119352340698,
-0.5889642834663391,
0.3595007061958313,
-0.42811059951782227,
-0.3965885639190674,
-0.52048659324646,
0.1778021603822708,
-0.06928718090057373,
-0.8022937178611755,
0.4416780173778534,
0.17180687189102173,
0.3558645248413086,
0.40345075726509094,
0.5224965810775757,
-0.06870344281196594,
1.0947579145431519,
0.16378657519817352,
-0.3562481999397278,
0.5904589295387268,
0.0842498317360878,
0.23257815837860107,
-0.8672982454299927,
-0.10272668302059174,
-0.4658544063568115,
-0.314116507768631,
-0.7824219465255737,
-0.2512228488922119,
0.2339860200881958,
-0.034047070890665054,
0.11935898661613464,
0.23935212194919586,
-0.1387806087732315,
0.429583877325058,
0.32106220722198486,
-0.024391746148467064,
0.4496533274650574,
0.2691704332828522,
0.15820084512233734,
0.19422182440757751,
-0.5672906637191772,
-0.5388329029083252,
1.3546751737594604,
0.5697091817855835,
0.9339602589607239,
0.11522678285837173,
0.8216899037361145,
0.8017860054969788,
0.59403395652771,
-0.7377025485038757,
0.4298785924911499,
-0.19647285342216492,
-0.6890386939048767,
-0.27883487939834595,
-0.4400041699409485,
-0.9249562621116638,
-0.10826287418603897,
-0.28607550263404846,
-0.8250487446784973,
-0.035440415143966675,
0.022785620763897896,
0.04069053754210472,
0.7453007102012634,
-0.5465971231460571,
0.38960325717926025,
-0.23431284725666046,
-0.13962389528751373,
-0.062463026493787766,
-0.3572023808956146,
0.21923388540744781,
-0.3461580276489258,
0.44219300150871277,
0.13335144519805908,
0.10777080804109573,
0.6318252682685852,
-0.05048461630940437,
0.7797439098358154,
-0.12284918129444122,
-0.4617604613304138,
0.4427334666252136,
0.33929964900016785,
0.646543562412262,
0.13111932575702667,
-0.11769448965787888,
0.43134742975234985,
-0.36820754408836365,
-0.6563870310783386,
-0.3269268870353699,
0.4195493161678314,
-0.40879741311073303,
-0.714237630367279,
-0.31465473771095276,
-0.5298259854316711,
0.18910908699035645,
0.1408490538597107,
0.454806387424469,
0.39999938011169434,
-0.4180918037891388,
-0.03602350875735283,
0.39955684542655945,
-0.21560345590114594,
0.5879939198493958,
-0.11274933069944382,
-0.4641721248626709,
-0.3119873106479645,
0.8239699006080627,
-0.2946193218231201,
0.32882797718048096,
0.1421024203300476,
0.23011848330497742,
-0.3136861324310303,
-0.7879818677902222,
-0.6867066025733948,
0.058010682463645935,
-0.621727466583252,
-0.1690821796655655,
-0.3014577031135559,
-0.3219664990901947,
-0.46356090903282166,
-0.20148839056491852,
-0.1364540010690689,
-0.3140508532524109,
-0.2548734247684479,
0.1795814484357834,
0.18097028136253357,
0.649288535118103,
0.12615901231765747,
0.39676398038864136,
-0.7740064263343811,
0.4635239243507385,
0.44878989458084106,
0.13283059000968933,
0.1548949033021927,
-0.5211051106452942,
-0.14500856399536133,
0.1600738912820816,
-0.04184282198548317,
-0.8023906946182251,
0.2265976369380951,
0.08159199357032776,
0.3381713926792145,
0.6800421476364136,
-0.16165848076343536,
0.48093318939208984,
-0.4237578213214874,
0.653708279132843,
0.08375079184770584,
-1.0546573400497437,
0.3625830411911011,
-0.2083810716867447,
0.23317059874534607,
0.36185237765312195,
0.3501410484313965,
-0.5942682027816772,
-0.4991176128387451,
-0.6519999504089355,
-0.6651891469955444,
0.31870484352111816,
0.6097593903541565,
0.02902732603251934,
-0.09428910166025162,
0.7040836811065674,
0.0795494094491005,
0.12241929769515991,
-0.6530073285102844,
-0.28206589818000793,
-0.07419370114803314,
-0.1679796576499939,
0.11536852270364761,
-0.10806317627429962,
-0.1357579231262207,
-0.026533789932727814,
0.3964623510837555,
-0.1176515519618988,
0.22504352033138275,
0.2759833037853241,
-0.2608930170536041,
-0.1635732203722,
0.04902052506804466,
0.4657304883003235,
0.3179300129413605,
-0.20492011308670044,
0.40417230129241943,
-0.11704094707965851,
-0.9357083439826965,
-0.0905083566904068,
0.005325367208570242,
-0.5793425440788269,
0.02086315117776394,
0.7201728224754333,
0.7268846035003662,
-0.3752810060977936,
-0.9337012767791748,
0.4153846502304077,
-0.3340499699115753,
0.2625161409378052,
-0.14033429324626923,
0.11927474290132523,
-0.24068959057331085,
0.030452245846390724,
0.502070963382721,
-0.20071469247341156,
0.04261985793709755,
-0.8023977875709534,
0.3832632005214691,
0.7715323567390442,
-0.3897635340690613,
-0.38643091917037964,
0.5194904804229736,
0.03842919319868088,
-0.6413318514823914,
0.6214421987533569,
-0.2523995339870453,
-0.6222764849662781,
0.7558020353317261,
0.8161590099334717,
0.864105224609375,
-0.49373263120651245,
0.07186445593833923,
0.00419281143695116,
0.6581889986991882,
0.0403127484023571,
0.030960923060774803,
-0.05224907025694847,
-0.8949609398841858,
-0.21538281440734863,
-0.5509290099143982,
-0.6282117366790771,
-0.03670690581202507,
-0.5109390616416931,
0.056603338569402695,
-0.7837114930152893,
-0.11387919634580612,
-0.0314050056040287,
-0.1498303860425949,
-0.24323752522468567,
-0.009377384558320045,
0.7594478726387024,
0.8920405507087708,
-0.5546485781669617,
0.6044585704803467,
0.641776442527771,
0.17346081137657166,
-0.3194372355937958,
0.5145184993743896,
0.1888660341501236,
-1.0171605348587036,
0.1904630810022354,
0.27732253074645996,
-0.17203043401241302,
-0.02857956662774086,
-0.7424724698066711,
-0.48671963810920715,
0.7473255395889282,
0.20037703216075897,
-0.5597074627876282,
-0.052135538309812546,
0.30474215745925903,
0.48234638571739197,
-0.27705785632133484,
0.11455663293600082,
0.684045672416687,
0.7611132264137268,
-0.06119692698121071,
-0.6032306551933289,
0.11727440357208252,
-0.1929212361574173,
-0.30411604046821594,
0.2094494104385376,
-0.4467701315879822,
0.7390139102935791,
0.021366123110055923,
-0.41236141324043274,
0.08254426717758179,
0.5796117782592773,
0.5587105751037598,
0.3729568421840668,
0.7387378811836243,
0.33642148971557617,
0.7234044075012207,
0.11400914937257767,
1.2729343175888062,
-0.2572627067565918,
0.28485387563705444,
0.5948105454444885,
-0.2849785089492798,
0.6281126141548157,
0.7183753848075867,
0.1488254815340042,
0.4792209267616272,
0.4516274034976959,
-0.34192517399787903,
0.23033131659030914,
0.29811590909957886,
-0.2802159786224365,
-0.14939312636852264,
-0.18696656823158264,
-0.2806762456893921,
0.6865140795707703,
0.46536821126937866,
0.0203727874904871,
-0.12841707468032837,
-0.08778272569179535,
0.2815300524234772,
-0.07216903567314148,
-0.28121325373649597,
0.6150442957878113,
0.01441197656095028,
-0.37104639410972595,
0.5841119289398193,
0.19984115660190582,
1.0256707668304443,
-0.5634436011314392,
0.1548091620206833,
-0.22003352642059326,
-0.10051840543746948,
-0.20748266577720642,
-0.7322620153427124,
0.24842660129070282,
0.4814426302909851,
0.29273149371147156,
-0.19667300581932068,
0.9467951059341431,
-0.06787914782762527,
-0.4754367768764496,
0.29193270206451416,
0.21850138902664185,
0.09011146426200867,
-0.05628276988863945,
-0.5309008955955505,
0.22987623512744904,
0.05575859546661377,
-0.3110010623931885,
0.2675417363643646,
-0.0394316166639328,
-0.01860009878873825,
0.5567627549171448,
0.8942229151725769,
0.3372087776660919,
0.028773769736289978,
-0.15358173847198486,
0.7942805290222168,
-0.7270838618278503,
-0.48433053493499756,
-1.1885160207748413,
-0.18816375732421875,
0.14709170162677765,
0.12035580724477768,
0.884273886680603,
0.5075822472572327,
0.8074696063995361,
0.1820524036884308,
0.7200246453285217,
0.06937173753976822,
-0.11147420853376389,
-0.7133614420890808,
0.8284026980400085,
-0.4592701494693756,
0.5189562439918518,
-0.5497051477432251,
-0.9690159559249878,
-0.4432809054851532,
0.4865272045135498,
0.050646066665649414,
0.02400953322649002,
0.40019649267196655,
0.4846343398094177,
-0.04034195840358734,
0.3057432174682617,
0.09068883210420609,
0.13966059684753418,
0.9214207530021667,
0.5283970832824707,
1.0773186683654785,
-0.5617830157279968,
0.3896334171295166,
-0.012193392030894756,
-0.23822703957557678,
-0.21370188891887665,
-0.8546998500823975,
-1.0775973796844482,
-0.3357768654823303,
-0.182755708694458,
-0.25280624628067017,
0.1231485977768898,
0.46030178666114807,
0.4703992009162903,
-0.7344323396682739,
-0.11300085484981537,
-0.009421913884580135,
0.14567910134792328,
0.1795203536748886,
-0.14038945734500885,
0.6076235771179199,
0.11909709870815277,
-0.7669582366943359,
0.451873779296875,
0.38226208090782166,
0.3317123353481293,
-0.4245905578136444,
-0.10010725259780884,
-0.3464258313179016,
0.3459608852863312,
0.33882665634155273,
0.4508748948574066,
-0.6568933129310608,
-0.6914878487586975,
0.08881884068250656,
-0.08443781733512878,
0.18802689015865326,
0.8431917428970337,
-0.6946344375610352,
0.40065422654151917,
0.462846964597702,
0.6976360082626343,
0.3420921862125397,
0.15593551099300385,
0.1894611269235611,
-0.6787275671958923,
0.34429314732551575,
0.3021913766860962,
0.26200124621391296,
0.4689532220363617,
-0.6006377935409546,
0.31660041213035583,
0.3821515738964081,
-0.3240590989589691,
-0.9294201135635376,
0.37523993849754333,
-0.6897147297859192,
-0.4328872561454773,
1.1436810493469238,
-0.20153136551380157,
-0.4849115312099457,
0.0009598542237654328,
0.001478697289712727,
0.15094618499279022,
-0.1626451313495636,
1.3844558000564575,
0.9355797171592712,
-0.062303636223077774,
0.37444210052490234,
-0.2435542792081833,
0.4450797736644745,
0.48751193284988403,
-1.1500746011734009,
0.019081678241491318,
0.2389819622039795,
0.046183161437511444,
0.4062373638153076,
0.4296645224094391,
-0.4221931993961334,
0.34215378761291504,
-0.19411398470401764,
0.010324887000024319,
0.04241092503070831,
-0.4581893980503082,
-0.4407944977283478,
0.03150385990738869,
-0.010495668277144432,
-0.22081011533737183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11238v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11238v1 | What Kinds of Tokens Benefit from Distant Text? An Analysis on Long Context Language Modeling | 2024-06-17T06:07:29 | 2024-06-17T06:07:29 | Yutong Hu, Quzhe Huang, Kangcheng Luo, Yansong Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | As the context length that large language models can handle continues to
increase, these models demonstrate an enhanced ability to utilize distant
information for tasks such as language modeling. This capability contrasts with
human reading and writing habits, where it is uncommon to remember and use
particularly distant information, except in cases of foreshadowing. In this
paper, we aim to explore which kinds of words benefit more from long contexts
in language models. By analyzing the changes in token probabilities with
increasing context length, we find that content words (e.g., nouns, adjectives)
and the initial tokens of words benefit the most. Frequent patterns in the
context (N-grams) also significantly impact predictions. Additionally, the
model's prior knowledge plays a crucial role in influencing predictions,
especially for rare tokens. We also observe that language models become more
confident with longer contexts, resulting in sharper probability distributions.
This overconfidence may contribute to the increasing probabilities of tokens
with distant contextual information. We hope that our analysis will help the
community better understand long-text language modeling and contribute to the
design of more reliable long-context models. | [
-0.09688300639390945,
-0.8987318873405457,
0.7759697437286377,
0.21389049291610718,
-0.43520939350128174,
-0.4118281304836273,
-0.46695759892463684,
-0.9015721678733826,
0.17352503538131714,
0.4572903513908386,
-0.09609609842300415,
-0.3030606210231781,
-0.7643963098526001,
0.08653701096773148,
-0.5599779486656189,
1.2079994678497314,
0.0829203650355339,
-0.19940520823001862,
-0.3531113862991333,
0.029805410653352737,
-0.5356943011283875,
-1.0084697008132935,
-0.6105901002883911,
-0.0724763497710228,
0.8262416124343872,
0.13231371343135834,
0.6568073034286499,
0.5440173149108887,
0.42902806401252747,
0.2786065936088562,
-0.21786591410636902,
-0.228166863322258,
-0.39309993386268616,
0.2533247172832489,
-0.3957914412021637,
-0.5812225341796875,
-0.26328325271606445,
-0.1922915130853653,
0.7474673390388489,
0.949690043926239,
0.2931208610534668,
-0.09247945994138718,
0.20661915838718414,
0.6654765009880066,
-0.5996842384338379,
0.30520254373550415,
-0.4710346758365631,
-0.10275459289550781,
-0.5928701162338257,
0.04364772140979767,
-0.25481972098350525,
-0.07019399851560593,
0.4155244529247284,
-0.33553236722946167,
-0.13956569135189056,
0.14379677176475525,
0.596312403678894,
-0.19501610100269318,
-0.7551710605621338,
-0.3408626914024353,
-0.729622483253479,
1.0891985893249512,
-0.6091041564941406,
0.47705602645874023,
0.7738343477249146,
0.14732062816619873,
-0.3239210844039917,
-0.9007366299629211,
-0.4657520651817322,
-0.4232330918312073,
-0.22284866869449615,
-0.056281644850969315,
-0.12105366587638855,
0.18626420199871063,
-0.05508454889059067,
0.3678257465362549,
-0.006528638768941164,
0.2487318366765976,
-0.3827277421951294,
-0.1048959419131279,
0.26802295446395874,
0.07009048759937286,
-0.005696780979633331,
-0.47943589091300964,
-0.4117562770843506,
0.10780464857816696,
-0.722149670124054,
0.17100386321544647,
0.18011753261089325,
0.29816579818725586,
-0.08276088535785675,
0.6107378005981445,
-0.3432190418243408,
0.9366657733917236,
-0.3069194257259369,
-0.2064431756734848,
0.017487231642007828,
-0.6391711235046387,
-0.10044638812541962,
-0.17168457806110382,
0.23221859335899353,
0.4170660078525543,
0.2599857747554779,
-0.4318750500679016,
-0.18831954896450043,
-0.38749319314956665,
-0.15683144330978394,
-0.8514643907546997,
0.10440262407064438,
0.14986886084079742,
-0.8134124279022217,
-0.09153974801301956,
0.30339619517326355,
-0.6738374829292297,
-0.25157320499420166,
-0.33835792541503906,
0.22232495248317719,
-0.4697563946247101,
-0.17508406937122345,
0.1437349170446396,
-0.5249555110931396,
-0.048196062445640564,
0.12978434562683105,
-0.9915209412574768,
0.3525190055370331,
1.0209777355194092,
0.865385890007019,
-0.3728739321231842,
-0.30043694376945496,
-0.7298892736434937,
0.04910039156675339,
-0.3095533847808838,
0.6155280470848083,
-0.7015261650085449,
-0.5733858942985535,
0.22699421644210815,
0.12353209406137466,
-0.01269096415489912,
-0.21933065354824066,
0.528866171836853,
-0.4491806924343109,
0.3334190845489502,
-0.5496150851249695,
-0.7904937863349915,
-0.13923844695091248,
0.015752704814076424,
-0.7145691514015198,
0.8311356902122498,
0.04212495684623718,
-0.8830957412719727,
0.6922516226768494,
-0.5592904686927795,
-0.598442018032074,
-0.0009961816249415278,
-0.1395813226699829,
0.009368157014250755,
0.5305203795433044,
-0.2906895875930786,
0.7277936935424805,
-0.08750894665718079,
0.37333473563194275,
-0.2035144567489624,
-0.43182313442230225,
0.6633787751197815,
-0.4696318209171295,
0.08444014936685562,
0.1261100172996521,
-0.3168855309486389,
0.14061833918094635,
-0.5700798034667969,
-0.32029688358306885,
-0.1595565229654312,
-0.36260470747947693,
-0.9248858690261841,
0.3064727783203125,
0.12832888960838318,
0.27753621339797974,
0.21841691434383392,
-0.5407004952430725,
-0.019797634333372116,
-0.41096338629722595,
0.3828667402267456,
0.8318336009979248,
0.1155635267496109,
0.5716766119003296,
-0.3358692526817322,
0.33877864480018616,
0.3689659535884857,
-0.032338593155145645,
-0.4478203058242798,
-0.7834089994430542,
-0.4038439095020294,
-0.2985163927078247,
0.3600192666053772,
0.11870148032903671,
-0.48842644691467285,
0.2861882150173187,
-0.3623727858066559,
-0.12118292599916458,
0.14659978449344635,
-0.037247199565172195,
0.3059294819831848,
0.3429325520992279,
0.13256342709064484,
-0.29078570008277893,
-0.5455612540245056,
-0.8161928653717041,
-0.43046048283576965,
-0.06580325961112976,
0.050144437700510025,
0.4155829846858978,
0.6852051019668579,
-0.21028511226177216,
1.3509459495544434,
-0.6782214641571045,
-0.21015271544456482,
-0.2155310958623886,
-0.07748323678970337,
0.09307944774627686,
0.3863138258457184,
0.7646358013153076,
-0.9082883596420288,
-0.15828394889831543,
-0.09786305576562881,
-0.314255952835083,
0.19096039235591888,
-0.18593227863311768,
-0.11929913610219955,
0.33896100521087646,
0.7523919939994812,
-0.5432466268539429,
0.49678927659988403,
0.620628833770752,
-0.6601353287696838,
0.6988038420677185,
-0.08987735956907272,
-0.07183800637722015,
-1.2327769994735718,
0.21794894337654114,
-0.0891907811164856,
-0.20875869691371918,
-0.6263931393623352,
-0.12534750998020172,
-0.23024050891399384,
0.29964473843574524,
-0.3381543755531311,
1.0721927881240845,
-0.4632616937160492,
0.001531581045128405,
-0.3846457600593567,
0.22996969521045685,
-0.01980258896946907,
0.06328123062849045,
0.3305343985557556,
0.705008327960968,
0.3836687505245209,
-0.5602980852127075,
0.12335033714771271,
-0.02898249961435795,
-0.5463565587997437,
0.13176384568214417,
-0.5052357316017151,
-0.13240785896778107,
-0.2977393865585327,
0.3531932532787323,
-0.9021639823913574,
-0.35720133781433105,
-0.08075472712516785,
-0.270020455121994,
0.21504446864128113,
0.12361111491918564,
-0.5761300325393677,
-0.14363993704319,
-0.1784275472164154,
0.5229701399803162,
0.29270294308662415,
-0.38719862699508667,
0.2561969459056854,
0.2201041728258133,
-0.20850087702274323,
-0.5760577917098999,
-0.7223737835884094,
0.15732304751873016,
-0.35918092727661133,
-0.27004438638687134,
0.3969132602214813,
0.0714881643652916,
-0.6272116899490356,
-0.009037520736455917,
0.10702447593212128,
-0.11641857028007507,
0.2761805057525635,
0.5779843330383301,
0.013575161807239056,
-0.15276536345481873,
0.7406240701675415,
0.008483219891786575,
0.03186902776360512,
0.015908271074295044,
-0.5590429306030273,
0.5601345896720886,
-0.15902484953403473,
-0.05357295647263527,
0.06528358161449432,
0.677215039730072,
0.35233479738235474,
-0.05640604346990585,
1.2579420804977417,
0.33695343136787415,
-0.4849070608615875,
0.12768085300922394,
-0.4862789809703827,
-0.2648690938949585,
-0.4409545660018921,
0.7170863151550293,
-0.34246715903282166,
-1.120357871055603,
0.7674520015716553,
0.17029190063476562,
-0.10199226438999176,
0.5084056258201599,
0.29750746488571167,
0.3126208186149597,
0.6012067198753357,
0.9045524597167969,
-0.3149067163467407,
1.081926941871643,
0.24048204720020294,
0.11276127398014069,
-0.6925727725028992,
-0.24611788988113403,
-0.4258991777896881,
0.13814616203308105,
-0.5415712594985962,
-0.5818114876747131,
-0.05935271829366684,
0.2861577272415161,
0.03341161087155342,
0.16921328008174896,
-0.010872048325836658,
0.3786894977092743,
0.662204921245575,
-0.11493140459060669,
0.2498369663953781,
-0.03510342165827751,
-0.1531762033700943,
-0.11351706087589264,
-0.4588469862937927,
-0.41992244124412537,
1.0240678787231445,
0.5400901436805725,
0.37663570046424866,
0.040760934352874756,
0.6820613145828247,
0.07709331810474396,
0.1813160479068756,
-0.7581942677497864,
0.33995985984802246,
-0.24725978076457977,
-0.798496425151825,
-0.22460319101810455,
-0.25886213779449463,
-1.1827727556228638,
-0.21022666990756989,
-0.22016966342926025,
-0.8992416858673096,
0.18202298879623413,
-0.21937882900238037,
-0.31143587827682495,
0.2831791639328003,
-0.39769500494003296,
0.6390558481216431,
-0.05709344521164894,
-0.25951382517814636,
-0.12476742267608643,
-0.7731742262840271,
0.11669955402612686,
-0.29411548376083374,
0.21170686185359955,
0.2257036715745926,
-0.17869393527507782,
0.9165400266647339,
-0.16790302097797394,
0.9736754298210144,
0.1996057629585266,
-0.2639513909816742,
0.36016198992729187,
-0.15021538734436035,
0.5451741218566895,
-0.08386188000440598,
-0.3597376048564911,
0.22403782606124878,
0.02219877764582634,
-0.38456425070762634,
-0.3116360008716583,
0.7005149722099304,
-0.4458041787147522,
-0.4434538781642914,
-0.2701694965362549,
-0.3528677523136139,
0.008928157389163971,
0.40669533610343933,
0.47051742672920227,
0.6445708870887756,
-0.3203432261943817,
0.5541709065437317,
0.17327068746089935,
-0.4150017499923706,
0.6445119380950928,
0.06833267956972122,
-0.38993191719055176,
-0.2125135064125061,
0.49978384375572205,
0.18336233496665955,
0.5026910305023193,
0.5264592170715332,
0.2813921272754669,
-0.31546249985694885,
-0.33035892248153687,
-0.0889706239104271,
0.1274387240409851,
-0.8599531650543213,
-0.05263865739107132,
-0.6073618531227112,
0.027220124378800392,
-0.5329900979995728,
-0.18903550505638123,
-0.04147015139460564,
-0.5752266049385071,
-0.4046885371208191,
-0.3386423885822296,
0.6493484973907471,
0.856156587600708,
0.037800658494234085,
0.4221161901950836,
-0.8127846717834473,
-0.1299045979976654,
0.22080294787883759,
0.5826524496078491,
0.11998812854290009,
-0.21042227745056152,
-0.6083484888076782,
-0.004702057223767042,
0.1458376944065094,
-0.9525406360626221,
0.1701216995716095,
0.28142961859703064,
0.43136072158813477,
0.7566361427307129,
-0.15484170615673065,
0.7490810751914978,
-0.5333867073059082,
1.1128684282302856,
0.09758006781339645,
-0.8713241219520569,
0.059865985065698624,
-0.5241664052009583,
0.3861018121242523,
0.5901942253112793,
0.011732317507266998,
-0.9372455477714539,
-0.4511759281158447,
-0.45503830909729004,
-0.9434679746627808,
0.29987093806266785,
0.2798736095428467,
0.5016089081764221,
-0.7105652689933777,
0.7227370738983154,
0.3967798352241516,
0.41768455505371094,
-0.7618574500083923,
-0.1083778589963913,
-0.060918960720300674,
0.027398480102419853,
-0.23672735691070557,
-0.5260099172592163,
0.12297800928354263,
-0.045036692172288895,
0.22908298671245575,
-0.11576254665851593,
0.3611451983451843,
0.10648947954177856,
0.14770720899105072,
0.011186948977410793,
0.3610830008983612,
0.8283898830413818,
0.5998960733413696,
-0.0713992565870285,
0.14190617203712463,
0.2967105805873871,
-0.5802547931671143,
-0.4467054605484009,
-0.038322217762470245,
0.30511170625686646,
0.16369999945163727,
0.6142686605453491,
0.7919229865074158,
0.3699024021625519,
-0.5726478099822998,
0.6627041101455688,
0.051341500133275986,
0.29267823696136475,
-0.4194302260875702,
-0.12082752585411072,
0.1478279083967209,
0.0516972579061985,
0.5466166734695435,
-0.04743488132953644,
0.2404380738735199,
-0.8794443607330322,
0.3237571716308594,
0.44151315093040466,
-0.3598386347293854,
-0.4078191816806793,
0.48757603764533997,
0.17122071981430054,
-0.12512753903865814,
0.5326977372169495,
-0.03249356523156166,
-0.5643981099128723,
0.7151122093200684,
0.8433662056922913,
0.6754082441329956,
0.15157166123390198,
-0.11770720779895782,
0.09865996986627579,
-0.1971443146467209,
-0.21519291400909424,
-0.0074611506424844265,
-0.22596921026706696,
-0.5116541981697083,
-0.5090746283531189,
-0.8786202073097229,
0.009103725664317608,
0.007072298787534237,
-0.5513615012168884,
0.06861307471990585,
-0.21260717511177063,
-0.38467326760292053,
-0.2544585168361664,
0.024907441809773445,
-0.5829939842224121,
0.3612104058265686,
0.2021016925573349,
0.8773525953292847,
-0.7066910862922668,
0.9579209685325623,
0.4727480113506317,
-0.10948672145605087,
-0.6491885781288147,
0.13147133588790894,
-0.3402189314365387,
-0.3764682412147522,
1.153995394706726,
0.5542904138565063,
-0.2267947643995285,
-0.17580746114253998,
-0.30356985330581665,
-1.0697706937789917,
0.8891956806182861,
-0.24056610465049744,
-0.5737325549125671,
-0.34676578640937805,
0.14175431430339813,
0.7579962611198425,
-0.37810128927230835,
0.05951971188187599,
0.37240880727767944,
0.2941671311855316,
-0.059709303081035614,
-0.9292219281196594,
0.19982154667377472,
0.08706040680408478,
0.1308446079492569,
0.4980355501174927,
-0.40288814902305603,
0.9976282119750977,
-0.2465580254793167,
-0.2121879905462265,
0.4885408580303192,
0.979222297668457,
0.06758131086826324,
0.30319178104400635,
0.3776816725730896,
0.04000511392951012,
0.5048172473907471,
0.1586257964372635,
1.2440248727798462,
-0.5332403779029846,
0.22569365799427032,
1.1190763711929321,
0.005028421990573406,
1.0885109901428223,
0.6793438196182251,
0.16943864524364471,
0.803737998008728,
0.4790865480899811,
0.3689580261707306,
0.4800321161746979,
0.17243297398090363,
-0.35038241744041443,
-0.07005830854177475,
-0.14462126791477203,
-0.4336383640766144,
0.5389694571495056,
0.344435453414917,
-0.6385797262191772,
-0.013997389934957027,
0.2536638081073761,
0.28489887714385986,
-0.17521017789840698,
-0.1900448203086853,
0.7072824835777283,
0.456959992647171,
-0.9554402232170105,
-0.06343740224838257,
0.3041025996208191,
0.7345349788665771,
-0.5188727378845215,
0.11007916182279587,
-0.07348804175853729,
0.32486146688461304,
-0.07883235067129135,
-0.8563347458839417,
0.41485390067100525,
-0.26593080163002014,
-0.1625918596982956,
-0.014584911987185478,
0.8134191632270813,
-0.3532160520553589,
-0.2926790714263916,
0.388016015291214,
0.46325260400772095,
0.13303586840629578,
-0.2539060115814209,
-0.2796325385570526,
-0.30989035964012146,
-0.3619059920310974,
-0.38441628217697144,
0.434694766998291,
0.6265103220939636,
-0.4311293959617615,
0.4240129590034485,
0.7783499956130981,
0.22733625769615173,
0.016954414546489716,
-0.1521596908569336,
0.7155435085296631,
-1.0022474527359009,
-0.6648913025856018,
-1.1515251398086548,
0.3431541919708252,
-0.18715058267116547,
-0.5441735982894897,
1.0658732652664185,
0.523703396320343,
0.4319175183773041,
-0.01417702715843916,
0.4681761860847473,
0.00019312922086101025,
0.22864477336406708,
-0.5075094103813171,
0.6042769551277161,
-0.3804965317249298,
0.03293805569410324,
-0.48135513067245483,
-0.6543591022491455,
-0.3653726875782013,
0.40771493315696716,
-0.6568160057067871,
0.12358606606721878,
0.6271141767501831,
0.19280406832695007,
0.12711560726165771,
-0.12322086095809937,
0.36967915296554565,
0.05371126905083656,
0.20060434937477112,
0.3161754310131073,
0.7380266189575195,
-0.12393518537282944,
0.13243438303470612,
0.00860582385212183,
-0.027735725045204163,
-0.467751681804657,
-1.0612016916275024,
-1.0049409866333008,
-0.9189832210540771,
0.08702865242958069,
-0.27692073583602905,
0.07466273009777069,
0.7111015915870667,
0.6884324550628662,
-0.542391836643219,
0.030576074495911598,
-0.17041152715682983,
0.07831944525241852,
-0.03178625926375389,
-0.2664354741573334,
0.48249465227127075,
-0.2756127715110779,
-0.5883369445800781,
0.008897519670426846,
0.24321657419204712,
0.29739221930503845,
0.07659300416707993,
0.08744802325963974,
0.01100683119148016,
0.2950282096862793,
1.0140644311904907,
0.06149287521839142,
-0.5529312491416931,
-0.6510478854179382,
0.1707558035850525,
-0.2371879518032074,
-0.07835964858531952,
0.6987151503562927,
-0.8532010316848755,
0.3368847966194153,
0.5294276475906372,
0.12126684933900833,
0.1471005380153656,
0.2817176282405853,
0.7864579558372498,
-0.867563009262085,
0.5283723473548889,
0.11041633039712906,
0.4489707350730896,
0.2095699906349182,
-0.5469512343406677,
0.0969833955168724,
-0.016209330409765244,
-0.5338903665542603,
-0.7386446595191956,
0.47565096616744995,
-0.7061457633972168,
-0.7122045755386353,
1.68738853931427,
-0.22167783975601196,
-0.29924964904785156,
-0.20454369485378265,
-0.23647798597812653,
0.26844871044158936,
-0.24342115223407745,
0.7044726014137268,
0.9821317195892334,
0.13001097738742828,
0.23280800879001617,
-0.4260364770889282,
0.8502557873725891,
0.4666067659854889,
-0.7178518176078796,
0.06585600972175598,
0.5132874250411987,
0.45105141401290894,
0.1714630424976349,
0.47340601682662964,
-0.1737949401140213,
-0.03179937228560448,
-0.15007634460926056,
-0.5177273750305176,
0.11301963776350021,
-0.4094548225402832,
-0.35498684644699097,
0.09086303412914276,
0.20379303395748138,
-0.11620355397462845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11234v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11234v1 | MiniConGTS: A Near Ultimate Minimalist Contrastive Grid Tagging Scheme for Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction | 2024-06-17T06:01:11 | 2024-06-17T06:01:11 | Qiao Sun, Liujia Yang, Minghao Ma, Nanyang Ye, Qinying Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction (ASTE) aims to co-extract the sentiment
triplets in a given corpus. Existing approaches within the
pretraining-finetuning paradigm tend to either meticulously craft complex
tagging schemes and classification heads, or incorporate external semantic
augmentation to enhance performance. In this study, we, for the first time,
re-evaluate the redundancy in tagging schemes and the internal enhancement in
pretrained representations. We propose a method to improve and utilize
pretrained representations by integrating a minimalist tagging scheme and a
novel token-level contrastive learning strategy. The proposed approach
demonstrates comparable or superior performance compared to state-of-the-art
techniques while featuring a more compact design and reduced computational
overhead. Additionally, we are the first to formally evaluate GPT-4's
performance in few-shot learning and Chain-of-Thought scenarios for this task.
The results demonstrate that the pretraining-finetuning paradigm remains highly
effective even in the era of large language models. | [
-0.8249120116233826,
-0.18439114093780518,
0.2761591076850891,
0.07468550652265549,
-0.7168346047401428,
0.2225843220949173,
-0.33213484287261963,
-0.4000333547592163,
0.3109428584575653,
-0.020819054916501045,
-0.47646647691726685,
-0.6928392648696899,
-0.4647020995616913,
0.18963003158569336,
0.014840598218142986,
1.3357938528060913,
-0.1509745717048645,
-0.058714259415864944,
0.11731281876564026,
-0.12658126652240753,
-0.10804533213376999,
-0.47227317094802856,
-0.7711290717124939,
-0.365796834230423,
0.4178975820541382,
0.4966646134853363,
0.3458993136882782,
0.4126283824443817,
0.6451812386512756,
0.21543315052986145,
-0.013714463450014591,
0.07905859500169754,
-0.3277187645435333,
-0.29434099793434143,
-0.0855269655585289,
-0.307412326335907,
-0.5327991843223572,
0.10011235624551773,
0.5469241142272949,
0.5126875042915344,
0.17104926705360413,
0.071451835334301,
0.5430920124053955,
0.6314959526062012,
-0.6261734366416931,
0.3075088560581207,
-0.6171510815620422,
0.04733920842409134,
-0.22675128281116486,
-0.03997636213898659,
-0.051218051463365555,
-0.21101628243923187,
-0.029087020084261894,
-0.6235601305961609,
0.45416873693466187,
0.062460366636514664,
1.0038217306137085,
0.2627490162849426,
0.002903585322201252,
-0.046141367405653,
-0.40329980850219727,
0.6302011013031006,
-0.5293819904327393,
0.2617170214653015,
0.08960043638944626,
0.0018561403267085552,
0.31730103492736816,
-0.791748583316803,
-0.6095240712165833,
-0.05992623046040535,
-0.4096868932247162,
0.32937049865722656,
-0.23180760443210602,
0.40686091780662537,
0.2445245236158371,
0.6151219010353088,
-0.37472349405288696,
0.0698624923825264,
-0.15211977064609528,
-0.29609736800193787,
0.20442618429660797,
-0.042519062757492065,
-0.11376779526472092,
-0.6569611430168152,
-0.48383134603500366,
0.033075928688049316,
-0.7797863483428955,
-0.12443920969963074,
0.37884026765823364,
0.4644324779510498,
-0.21675634384155273,
0.17634756863117218,
-0.22205442190170288,
0.22806498408317566,
0.14989398419857025,
0.2588762938976288,
0.42995068430900574,
-0.7404662370681763,
-0.2421029806137085,
-0.2790963351726532,
1.1132694482803345,
0.416267067193985,
-0.39018476009368896,
0.12422970682382584,
-0.42059770226478577,
0.24639037251472473,
0.14982634782791138,
-0.6168280839920044,
-0.6829617619514465,
-0.08249825239181519,
-0.3033575713634491,
-0.21684689819812775,
-0.12514051795005798,
-0.8863465189933777,
-0.31877994537353516,
-0.3615919351577759,
0.4875143766403198,
-0.6098393797874451,
-0.3442302942276001,
-0.0728289783000946,
-0.06975490599870682,
0.3598911166191101,
0.29530012607574463,
-0.8547107577323914,
0.3462182879447937,
0.9067062139511108,
1.0139886140823364,
-0.23175477981567383,
-0.02859315648674965,
-0.21205705404281616,
-0.09272940456867218,
-0.14121372997760773,
0.9463011622428894,
-0.627081573009491,
-0.42572298645973206,
-0.16273480653762817,
-0.4177584648132324,
0.19027544558048248,
-0.41601306200027466,
0.6498745083808899,
-0.34954509139060974,
0.03665177896618843,
-0.5464131236076355,
-0.22298388183116913,
-0.08630640059709549,
0.5576790571212769,
-0.6354914307594299,
0.9781311750411987,
-0.046272967010736465,
-1.0264335870742798,
0.5781953930854797,
-0.9586887359619141,
-0.09899523109197617,
0.11196223646402359,
-0.6050381064414978,
-0.4356094002723694,
0.13733896613121033,
0.3220519423484802,
0.4511069357395172,
-0.11447436362504959,
-0.34862416982650757,
-0.18531379103660583,
-0.2785733938217163,
-0.35797548294067383,
-0.13038820028305054,
0.1523817926645279,
0.1317710131406784,
-0.37392541766166687,
0.21275776624679565,
-0.5944610834121704,
0.028553908690810204,
-0.18613754212856293,
-0.1363004595041275,
-0.26048704981803894,
-0.3791888654232025,
-0.15609309077262878,
0.31924986839294434,
0.23024189472198486,
-0.7371454834938049,
0.15016061067581177,
-0.6850686073303223,
0.34155502915382385,
0.6453385353088379,
-0.05624872073531151,
0.6734846234321594,
-0.1727583259344101,
0.46744558215141296,
0.3637232482433319,
-0.04844101145863533,
0.06506193429231644,
-0.022793345153331757,
-1.0214500427246094,
-0.3595599830150604,
0.41028594970703125,
0.18769471347332,
-1.414459228515625,
0.3082210421562195,
-0.5080683827400208,
-0.28182074427604675,
-0.6634059548377991,
0.04464394226670265,
0.7692320942878723,
0.20632719993591309,
0.6226612329483032,
-0.29641252756118774,
-0.7487363815307617,
-1.109370231628418,
-0.30033645033836365,
-0.023109350353479385,
0.10280287265777588,
-0.10647966712713242,
0.542475700378418,
-0.15945155918598175,
0.7848629355430603,
-0.4906320869922638,
-0.281202495098114,
-0.4725876450538635,
0.5361456871032715,
0.11617539823055267,
0.7357305288314819,
0.39254170656204224,
-0.5227705240249634,
-0.6453731060028076,
0.159063920378685,
-0.3604327440261841,
0.1071944311261177,
0.1578812450170517,
-0.14492613077163696,
0.22016234695911407,
0.5292431712150574,
-0.5201799869537354,
0.37221208214759827,
0.18242740631103516,
0.17341242730617523,
0.4236835539340973,
0.11608177423477173,
-0.021158788353204727,
-0.944650411605835,
-0.08185975253582001,
0.16002188622951508,
-0.4535997807979584,
-0.4952916204929352,
0.11401450634002686,
0.11364615708589554,
0.004340897314250469,
-0.34999409317970276,
0.35632646083831787,
-0.5656207203865051,
-0.07839203625917435,
-0.3317442536354065,
0.2564631998538971,
0.053658369928598404,
0.6651344299316406,
0.021678201854228973,
0.7338495254516602,
0.34781959652900696,
-0.3406536281108856,
0.14498105645179749,
0.011265616863965988,
-0.044607359915971756,
0.6986286640167236,
-0.2723328769207001,
0.40466490387916565,
-0.2722092270851135,
0.18426495790481567,
-0.8742145299911499,
0.04122128710150719,
0.45728492736816406,
-0.4389186203479767,
0.5796850919723511,
-0.15128368139266968,
-0.46569183468818665,
-0.4638991355895996,
-0.9130923748016357,
0.36940377950668335,
0.4655376672744751,
-0.6914296746253967,
0.5966241955757141,
0.10266069322824478,
-0.16285337507724762,
-0.5867317318916321,
-0.4286418557167053,
-0.10422395914793015,
-0.40049847960472107,
-0.0782347321510315,
0.33442243933677673,
0.17092913389205933,
0.12097357213497162,
-0.10613856464624405,
-0.5180673003196716,
0.17728100717067719,
-0.07310060411691666,
0.06391192972660065,
0.12711787223815918,
-0.3056751787662506,
0.14713172614574432,
-0.02036956697702408,
-0.4517749845981598,
-0.1604594588279724,
-0.3273950517177582,
0.6288597583770752,
-0.7119569182395935,
-0.1742870807647705,
-0.4830004870891571,
0.5055334568023682,
-0.23715004324913025,
-0.018499739468097687,
0.27206286787986755,
0.9037439227104187,
-0.3915703594684601,
-0.1006961315870285,
-0.5097901821136475,
-0.017484087496995926,
-0.49813395738601685,
0.4622378945350647,
-0.7052871584892273,
-1.037018060684204,
0.36371472477912903,
-0.105321504175663,
0.012277971021831036,
0.6161877512931824,
0.28054726123809814,
-0.37355837225914,
0.8317187428474426,
0.8942077159881592,
-0.02786768600344658,
0.5814195275306702,
-0.47803470492362976,
0.23833228647708893,
-1.1291582584381104,
-0.07195141911506653,
-0.4558853209018707,
-0.32847169041633606,
-0.7320072650909424,
-0.2930798828601837,
0.3939196467399597,
0.3659681975841522,
-0.3237641453742981,
0.15281647443771362,
-0.5106328129768372,
0.7645283341407776,
0.4042917490005493,
0.24360990524291992,
0.2322421818971634,
0.02877146564424038,
-0.06363308429718018,
-0.1525799185037613,
-0.6440597176551819,
-0.533310055732727,
0.9208458662033081,
0.22405530512332916,
0.6150229573249817,
0.08510962128639221,
1.1605945825576782,
-0.016815699636936188,
0.580696702003479,
-0.8827208280563354,
0.46316081285476685,
-0.41490066051483154,
-0.046734340488910675,
0.03184226155281067,
-0.35429123044013977,
-0.7478861212730408,
0.5380070209503174,
-0.17052191495895386,
-0.6609571576118469,
0.16639705002307892,
0.4233039617538452,
-0.8950015306472778,
0.28397881984710693,
-0.8452860116958618,
0.8164660334587097,
0.18092243373394012,
-0.4564528465270996,
-0.016824036836624146,
-0.7570282220840454,
0.2835497558116913,
-0.08100543916225433,
0.06518954783678055,
0.01634453982114792,
-0.41908925771713257,
0.9350032210350037,
-0.39606359601020813,
0.8355594873428345,
-0.2448940873146057,
0.3160243332386017,
0.06321538239717484,
-0.07624536007642746,
0.3183465600013733,
0.04098028689622879,
0.1454455405473709,
0.12983880937099457,
0.05378207936882973,
-0.5097266435623169,
-0.53596031665802,
0.8617522716522217,
-0.9399101138114929,
-0.7516682147979736,
-0.4080006778240204,
0.05233771726489067,
-0.5493345260620117,
0.3133090138435364,
0.5560111999511719,
0.3560430705547333,
-0.21589232981204987,
-0.13693100214004517,
0.3344750702381134,
0.2649475634098053,
0.7093620896339417,
0.08758468925952911,
-0.09533099830150604,
-0.6060475707054138,
1.0019915103912354,
-0.2417415976524353,
0.15697135031223297,
0.2459266036748886,
0.16652221977710724,
-0.3658240735530853,
-0.7770510315895081,
-0.21235856413841248,
0.46488893032073975,
-0.9524146914482117,
-0.6120466589927673,
-0.6515659689903259,
-0.0696384459733963,
-0.3093075752258301,
-0.2543504536151886,
-0.5579091906547546,
-0.11987858265638351,
-0.36107248067855835,
-0.19194020330905914,
0.06539490818977356,
0.9396243691444397,
-0.3657703101634979,
0.7990177869796753,
-0.7633863091468811,
0.285327285528183,
0.25319916009902954,
0.45645004510879517,
-0.3126412630081177,
-0.27854251861572266,
-0.2160641998052597,
-0.15321174263954163,
-0.5105040669441223,
-0.636371374130249,
0.1675305813550949,
0.24759429693222046,
0.27343547344207764,
0.23868289589881897,
-0.1350160837173462,
0.7745549082756042,
-0.3169214725494385,
0.9065847396850586,
0.6174570322036743,
-1.197993278503418,
0.3570364713668823,
-0.2702074646949768,
0.2774701714515686,
1.0387886762619019,
0.5917946100234985,
-0.29209235310554504,
-0.0029067075811326504,
-0.8879237174987793,
-0.8785988092422485,
0.8123778104782104,
0.22334343194961548,
0.0523395910859108,
-0.050884831696748734,
0.5127949714660645,
0.311831533908844,
0.3838615119457245,
-0.8134685158729553,
-0.13392406702041626,
-0.42505109310150146,
-0.3691019117832184,
-0.12188228219747543,
-0.3205842971801758,
-0.04033954069018364,
-0.46383383870124817,
0.6386357545852661,
-0.31996455788612366,
0.5048503875732422,
0.04742308333516121,
-0.11432123929262161,
0.36570852994918823,
0.29526185989379883,
0.29671353101730347,
0.18920300900936127,
-0.059171997010707855,
0.4620378017425537,
0.2418588548898697,
-0.4183773398399353,
-0.03412705659866333,
0.1441926658153534,
0.1638292372226715,
-0.017428142949938774,
0.30259114503860474,
0.9816566705703735,
0.21762880682945251,
0.20095835626125336,
0.8392270803451538,
-0.06066259369254112,
-0.10148849338293076,
-0.21872276067733765,
-0.12939533591270447,
-0.16225837171077728,
0.20055146515369415,
-0.10666681081056595,
0.3418430984020233,
0.22357802093029022,
-0.44242581725120544,
0.10064305365085602,
0.42370879650115967,
-0.6122145652770996,
-0.6106342077255249,
0.20299428701400757,
0.5064473748207092,
0.09614027291536331,
0.13386350870132446,
-0.772778332233429,
-0.7298111319541931,
0.1885751485824585,
0.23041626811027527,
0.9580314755439758,
-0.04547584056854248,
0.010961446911096573,
0.40310078859329224,
0.36867257952690125,
-0.11446121335029602,
0.35818907618522644,
-0.3404403328895569,
-0.7899298071861267,
-0.37455612421035767,
-0.5659783482551575,
-0.2147122472524643,
0.1390714943408966,
-0.6867573261260986,
0.4229852855205536,
-0.6770229339599609,
-0.2138211876153946,
0.02578568086028099,
0.19942258298397064,
-0.9731462597846985,
0.10911714285612106,
0.38649848103523254,
0.5983570218086243,
-0.8437168002128601,
0.848980188369751,
0.8998597264289856,
-0.6536415815353394,
-0.723711371421814,
0.2462705373764038,
-0.09119947999715805,
-0.6942775249481201,
0.6075811386108398,
0.40743017196655273,
-0.45088842511177063,
0.22441641986370087,
-0.6374408006668091,
-0.6501546502113342,
0.7693663239479065,
-0.04056517034769058,
-0.353011816740036,
-0.09315109252929688,
-0.07585016638040543,
0.530549168586731,
-0.3981119692325592,
0.42468512058258057,
1.090550184249878,
0.13898704946041107,
0.22084088623523712,
-0.918381929397583,
0.01925712637603283,
-0.3584461808204651,
0.08829331398010254,
0.3544306755065918,
-0.5997127890586853,
0.8541165590286255,
0.15605638921260834,
-0.5705311894416809,
-0.03673331066966057,
0.9607148766517639,
-0.09142117947340012,
0.01122178416699171,
0.5560914874076843,
0.6078466176986694,
0.6937102675437927,
-0.3088807463645935,
0.9789049625396729,
-0.060327351093292236,
0.581450879573822,
1.2477043867111206,
0.010682699270546436,
0.8785499930381775,
0.4287271499633789,
-0.19155673682689667,
0.4554029107093811,
0.6217285394668579,
0.462860107421875,
0.6194552183151245,
0.19529010355472565,
-0.3306964337825775,
-0.3251868486404419,
0.01293625496327877,
-0.3899942636489868,
0.27502214908599854,
0.5294581651687622,
-0.03822135180234909,
-0.4033823609352112,
0.15250417590141296,
0.28168365359306335,
-0.0799977257847786,
-0.6720075607299805,
1.036388874053955,
0.2662701904773712,
-0.22787970304489136,
0.5639205574989319,
-0.13945066928863525,
1.3240642547607422,
-0.41298770904541016,
0.04340343177318573,
-0.3491312861442566,
0.05213374271988869,
-0.4090006351470947,
-0.7243582010269165,
0.2765461504459381,
0.07230201363563538,
0.1424134075641632,
-0.18692147731781006,
0.6731663346290588,
-0.4184948205947876,
-0.16465571522712708,
0.020819764584302902,
0.35159045457839966,
0.05865946412086487,
-0.03838801383972168,
-0.7695949673652649,
0.07855662703514099,
0.12417908012866974,
0.01508746575564146,
0.16933809220790863,
0.4926741123199463,
0.18977150321006775,
0.11068649590015411,
0.22965732216835022,
0.19246971607208252,
-0.21247665584087372,
0.02396744303405285,
1.2811418771743774,
-0.791344165802002,
-0.7346970438957214,
-0.9409916400909424,
0.41573143005371094,
-0.40832892060279846,
-0.1490023285150528,
0.6358597278594971,
0.5217235088348389,
0.9180731773376465,
0.1275656819343567,
0.9007552266120911,
0.14666828513145447,
0.5092096328735352,
-0.625602126121521,
0.3473684787750244,
-0.461948961019516,
0.301367849111557,
-0.36795997619628906,
-0.9036814570426941,
-0.4681951701641083,
0.5297766327857971,
-0.6525582671165466,
0.2077794075012207,
1.2423726320266724,
0.6144697666168213,
-0.12182167172431946,
0.3464140295982361,
0.2465730756521225,
0.10539084672927856,
0.3857901096343994,
0.6434544324874878,
1.1235461235046387,
-0.3391259014606476,
0.4637569785118103,
-0.4215155839920044,
-0.228158101439476,
0.01152665913105011,
-0.869318962097168,
-0.8196443319320679,
-0.5392184257507324,
-0.41896480321884155,
-0.21332447230815887,
-0.08006732165813446,
1.2806165218353271,
0.4685746133327484,
-0.6277809739112854,
0.25539538264274597,
0.01074308529496193,
-0.13787861168384552,
0.2965177595615387,
-0.13347302377223969,
0.500015377998352,
-0.6051954030990601,
-0.5718814134597778,
0.02981599047780037,
0.27830424904823303,
0.07174107432365417,
-0.037670742720365524,
0.22201605141162872,
0.07331807911396027,
-0.30259665846824646,
0.6087675094604492,
0.1699639856815338,
-0.4953470826148987,
-0.7574644088745117,
-0.6722869277000427,
-0.17936314642429352,
0.4883805811405182,
0.9686447381973267,
-0.6556366086006165,
0.28657978773117065,
0.45799800753593445,
0.48797932267189026,
0.5744655728340149,
0.2330923229455948,
0.09722550213336945,
-1.069720983505249,
0.21307697892189026,
0.41819918155670166,
0.35113251209259033,
0.5754591822624207,
-0.059268414974212646,
0.275307834148407,
0.3556760549545288,
-0.15694253146648407,
-0.447279155254364,
0.37197741866111755,
-0.8613912463188171,
0.13802121579647064,
1.1918131113052368,
-0.18110224604606628,
-0.2832823693752289,
-0.30323001742362976,
-0.30015096068382263,
0.2135796993970871,
-0.509300172328949,
0.3145744800567627,
0.526360273361206,
-0.42185768485069275,
-0.15129584074020386,
-0.2953806221485138,
1.0285390615463257,
0.42198920249938965,
-0.87291020154953,
-0.12339206784963608,
0.49486610293388367,
0.1948196291923523,
0.3051856756210327,
0.8980487585067749,
-0.05742720887064934,
0.01832774095237255,
0.11161115020513535,
0.406933456659317,
0.04556824266910553,
-0.206488236784935,
-0.6626099944114685,
0.22192451357841492,
0.29619187116622925,
-0.4560996890068054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11233v1 | Probing the Decision Boundaries of In-context Learning in Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T06:00:24 | 2024-06-17T06:00:24 | Siyan Zhao, Tung Nguyen, Aditya Grover | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In-context learning is a key paradigm in large language models (LLMs) that
enables them to generalize to new tasks and domains by simply prompting these
models with a few exemplars without explicit parameter updates. Many attempts
have been made to understand in-context learning in LLMs as a function of model
scale, pretraining data, and other factors. In this work, we propose a new
mechanism to probe and understand in-context learning from the lens of decision
boundaries for in-context binary classification. Decision boundaries are
straightforward to visualize and provide important information about the
qualitative behavior of the inductive biases of standard classifiers. To our
surprise, we find that the decision boundaries learned by current LLMs in
simple binary classification tasks are often irregular and non-smooth,
regardless of linear separability in the underlying task. This paper
investigates the factors influencing these decision boundaries and explores
methods to enhance their generalizability. We assess various approaches,
including training-free and fine-tuning methods for LLMs, the impact of model
architecture, and the effectiveness of active prompting techniques for
smoothing decision boundaries in a data-efficient manner. Our findings provide
a deeper understanding of in-context learning dynamics and offer practical
improvements for enhancing robustness and generalizability of in-context
learning. | [
-0.634167492389679,
-1.1599169969558716,
0.6386603116989136,
-0.042150676250457764,
-0.2317659705877304,
-0.13759422302246094,
-0.6512609720230103,
-0.3001609742641449,
-0.28304222226142883,
0.3228178322315216,
-0.6205148696899414,
-0.4922563433647156,
-0.3863259255886078,
-0.028352346271276474,
-0.15243901312351227,
0.8923463225364685,
-0.15108458697795868,
0.13864168524742126,
-0.45425280928611755,
-0.03381688520312309,
-0.5754716396331787,
-0.5478565692901611,
-0.6061629056930542,
-0.5406231880187988,
0.3185120224952698,
0.46950653195381165,
0.36709678173065186,
0.458397775888443,
0.08949875831604004,
0.21397849917411804,
-0.32047486305236816,
0.2240525782108307,
-0.48753872513771057,
0.31405869126319885,
-0.195074662566185,
-0.5995426177978516,
-0.08025720715522766,
-0.015907185152173042,
1.0439592599868774,
1.177270531654358,
0.15607567131519318,
0.20767545700073242,
0.540192723274231,
0.5646613836288452,
-0.5458047986030579,
0.2847054600715637,
-0.6735450029373169,
0.11187106370925903,
-0.26002731919288635,
-0.28647443652153015,
-0.5532217621803284,
-0.17773213982582092,
0.2578645348548889,
-0.30400577187538147,
0.21930579841136932,
-0.17384672164916992,
0.6115729212760925,
0.28957778215408325,
-0.6098887324333191,
-0.23113387823104858,
-0.6870566606521606,
0.7682305574417114,
-0.3468267619609833,
0.7845290899276733,
0.3473535478115082,
0.3433343470096588,
-0.3951595425605774,
-0.5314314961433411,
-0.2154715210199356,
0.028501933440566063,
0.027640800923109055,
-0.32668519020080566,
0.0032793793361634016,
0.04465403035283089,
0.3603147864341736,
-0.07259680330753326,
-0.1206616759300232,
0.3847619593143463,
-0.15015223622322083,
-0.03975224867463112,
0.38534027338027954,
0.07262590527534485,
-0.0033058898989111185,
0.16922523081302643,
-0.39575791358947754,
-0.04451528191566467,
-0.913489580154419,
0.5226791501045227,
0.18870027363300323,
0.45821672677993774,
-0.2356783151626587,
0.01548696868121624,
-0.17468729615211487,
1.044205904006958,
0.3106812536716461,
-0.03434813395142555,
0.1623486876487732,
-0.039077021181583405,
-0.13845913112163544,
0.02092146687209606,
0.38811343908309937,
0.2694719433784485,
0.05614142119884491,
-0.22991855442523956,
-0.31752410531044006,
-0.2643495202064514,
0.054355867207050323,
-0.7278051972389221,
0.056759946048259735,
0.061215657740831375,
-0.2415851354598999,
-0.06222687289118767,
-0.13432897627353668,
-0.5643306374549866,
-0.16972117125988007,
-0.6964120268821716,
0.5412393808364868,
-0.3874295651912689,
-0.05343985557556152,
0.044637225568294525,
0.11429823935031891,
0.4530565142631531,
0.6064891219139099,
-0.862539529800415,
0.220352441072464,
0.6215036511421204,
0.6543903946876526,
-0.11161944270133972,
-0.23218218982219696,
-0.660346508026123,
-0.04520523548126221,
-0.38380715250968933,
0.6268190145492554,
-0.8171359300613403,
-0.24721013009548187,
0.05140962451696396,
-0.041944362223148346,
-0.11600833386182785,
-0.6777476668357849,
0.15313434600830078,
-0.5491896867752075,
0.002991586225107312,
-0.3544173240661621,
-0.5921027660369873,
-0.5056344270706177,
0.41812846064567566,
-0.3193567097187042,
0.9951965808868408,
0.1028311476111412,
-0.5812564492225647,
0.7545852661132812,
-0.5650271773338318,
-0.2427474856376648,
0.1383216679096222,
-0.4330217242240906,
-0.33447781205177307,
0.07965324074029922,
0.10368853807449341,
0.754559338092804,
-0.028609836474061012,
0.47565633058547974,
-0.3029647469520569,
-0.44637247920036316,
0.3313751816749573,
-0.37983185052871704,
0.7482401728630066,
-0.031019562855362892,
-0.4997386336326599,
0.14968019723892212,
-0.45691511034965515,
-0.04529143497347832,
-0.13555753231048584,
-0.4505562484264374,
-0.5758526921272278,
0.08359461277723312,
-0.2229447364807129,
0.1832306832075119,
-0.035635173320770264,
-0.3514627516269684,
0.29253140091896057,
-0.2578706741333008,
0.3074623942375183,
0.7621728777885437,
0.1146417036652565,
0.7504603862762451,
0.0765061154961586,
0.3427010476589203,
0.08382773399353027,
0.21489378809928894,
-0.06436284631490707,
-0.38516831398010254,
-0.6664683222770691,
-0.17121067643165588,
0.5363600254058838,
0.14843058586120605,
-0.6930081844329834,
0.2792915403842926,
-0.013621801510453224,
-0.2102586328983307,
-0.34731703996658325,
0.1999388486146927,
0.3337966799736023,
0.6562433838844299,
0.30800071358680725,
-0.40577250719070435,
-0.19447781145572662,
-0.6626802682876587,
-0.18453055620193481,
0.2511150538921356,
0.027869587764143944,
0.40988466143608093,
0.5414345860481262,
-0.45160868763923645,
1.1945399045944214,
-0.1528998762369156,
-0.0607057586312294,
-0.20520438253879547,
-0.024287613108754158,
-0.028887102380394936,
0.3883322775363922,
0.4340207576751709,
-0.9532553553581238,
-0.4013727605342865,
-0.014443939551711082,
-0.6647958755493164,
-0.1361044943332672,
-0.19053108990192413,
-0.2674140930175781,
0.19003364443778992,
0.8279937505722046,
-0.19957080483436584,
0.3648679852485657,
0.2599327266216278,
-0.29083141684532166,
0.49117419123649597,
-0.015482071787118912,
-0.2871095836162567,
-0.49013862013816833,
-0.2551330029964447,
0.22173936665058136,
-0.22165314853191376,
-0.8810896873474121,
0.21979938447475433,
0.4676091969013214,
0.2514626681804657,
-0.5695279240608215,
0.6435835361480713,
-0.5483062863349915,
-0.06009058281779289,
-0.17455638945102692,
0.09826596826314926,
-0.1953807771205902,
0.548122763633728,
0.13735361397266388,
0.40973198413848877,
0.8780112862586975,
-0.9928552508354187,
-0.12304285168647766,
0.0704338327050209,
-0.2959167957305908,
0.3885418772697449,
-0.17670951783657074,
0.19157616794109344,
-0.4617213308811188,
0.5206127166748047,
-0.9696893692016602,
-0.14906631410121918,
0.14916953444480896,
-0.2230978012084961,
0.5012348294258118,
-0.4976331293582916,
-0.34028637409210205,
0.16410064697265625,
-0.21553988754749298,
0.728678822517395,
0.29102689027786255,
-0.8406753540039062,
0.545024573802948,
0.3152409493923187,
0.15596237778663635,
-0.4380922317504883,
-0.41478073596954346,
-0.2297479510307312,
-0.5120965838432312,
-0.35706573724746704,
0.2053454965353012,
-0.09120023250579834,
-0.5889714956283569,
-0.37824052572250366,
-0.19136744737625122,
0.021187156438827515,
0.30079418420791626,
0.29837074875831604,
0.1804562360048294,
-0.01892799139022827,
0.12899109721183777,
0.3069692850112915,
0.09734035283327103,
0.26203569769859314,
-0.357280433177948,
0.6091765761375427,
-0.23105137050151825,
-0.24777479469776154,
-0.1290213167667389,
0.06004896014928818,
0.3407004773616791,
-0.3214486539363861,
0.49253228306770325,
0.39339569211006165,
-0.4438217580318451,
-0.7055396437644958,
-0.41270744800567627,
-0.3907650113105774,
-0.5003707408905029,
0.17475973069667816,
-0.4186643064022064,
-1.0764122009277344,
0.45001184940338135,
-0.4121091663837433,
0.0326412133872509,
0.13251502811908722,
0.666225254535675,
0.13981452584266663,
0.8704172968864441,
0.8091139197349548,
0.2767190635204315,
0.594976007938385,
-0.4084087014198303,
0.10893288254737854,
-0.9838301539421082,
-0.5356467366218567,
-0.3132792115211487,
-0.37413308024406433,
-0.4515956938266754,
-0.518619179725647,
0.5824866890907288,
0.2003220021724701,
-0.22305084764957428,
-0.16190409660339355,
-0.3191918730735779,
0.6107006669044495,
0.359153151512146,
0.30043825507164,
0.04233192652463913,
-0.13942784070968628,
-0.34880703687667847,
0.09109852463006973,
-0.5964422821998596,
-0.2765715420246124,
0.8505260944366455,
0.5013515949249268,
0.7064204812049866,
-0.014264454133808613,
0.5963709354400635,
-0.06885751336812973,
0.1761435568332672,
-0.9777870178222656,
0.473657488822937,
0.24725216627120972,
-0.41966429352760315,
-0.41537001729011536,
-0.4209038019180298,
-1.0193564891815186,
0.5753858089447021,
-0.3050704300403595,
-0.7532914876937866,
0.4932895302772522,
-0.0224264245480299,
-0.3621509373188019,
0.34186026453971863,
-0.7313908338546753,
0.7636222243309021,
-0.3198678195476532,
-0.5208298563957214,
0.13919594883918762,
-0.7559118270874023,
0.1684354692697525,
-0.24528971314430237,
0.3842127025127411,
0.15621790289878845,
-0.131343811750412,
0.5535165667533875,
0.059758927673101425,
1.2281241416931152,
-0.39074432849884033,
-0.26485300064086914,
0.13922342658042908,
0.3437191843986511,
0.3547740578651428,
0.008491027168929577,
0.15275351703166962,
0.20262573659420013,
-0.36910736560821533,
-0.22065256536006927,
-0.5459965467453003,
0.4362545907497406,
-0.5741400718688965,
-0.3713476359844208,
-0.14450174570083618,
-0.467833548784256,
-0.6066362857818604,
0.10182198137044907,
0.22571909427642822,
0.7539821267127991,
-0.06546498090028763,
0.2749664783477783,
1.0454492568969727,
-0.16963325440883636,
0.3944697678089142,
0.6009278893470764,
-0.28719520568847656,
0.4254513382911682,
0.6854186654090881,
0.17676162719726562,
0.34001126885414124,
0.421354740858078,
0.1572534143924713,
-0.3534693121910095,
-0.7908920645713806,
-0.35704198479652405,
0.18056751787662506,
-0.7729581594467163,
-0.07182707637548447,
-0.422518253326416,
-0.05390830338001251,
-0.12271513044834137,
-0.28619101643562317,
0.047305356711149216,
0.013834546320140362,
-0.24902783334255219,
-0.1453372985124588,
0.11310649663209915,
0.9438546299934387,
0.14195407927036285,
0.301960825920105,
-0.4365652799606323,
-0.24156735837459564,
0.28729549050331116,
0.4916498363018036,
0.18272657692432404,
-0.6349625587463379,
-0.4225994050502777,
0.024680577218532562,
-0.3019044101238251,
-0.6588361263275146,
0.20442090928554535,
0.26387372612953186,
0.5974447727203369,
0.572796642780304,
-0.055309753865003586,
0.47226372361183167,
-0.5069292187690735,
0.6206569075584412,
-0.1405467838048935,
-0.9208096265792847,
0.4352257251739502,
-0.43040549755096436,
0.3183196485042572,
0.4005385637283325,
0.6294335722923279,
-0.5256773829460144,
-0.4029366970062256,
-0.4917586147785187,
-0.995271623134613,
0.6286823153495789,
-0.2758854329586029,
0.07957907021045685,
0.1005159541964531,
0.5691571235656738,
0.44614681601524353,
0.04080845043063164,
-0.518515944480896,
-0.181576669216156,
0.13889965415000916,
0.1961219608783722,
-0.14258940517902374,
-0.09716999530792236,
-0.013891637325286865,
-0.43862512707710266,
0.3379684388637543,
-0.387634813785553,
-0.048994988203048706,
0.050261981785297394,
-0.36160537600517273,
0.0340874157845974,
0.2624507248401642,
0.3938252031803131,
0.802340030670166,
-0.1859998255968094,
0.19301243126392365,
0.4973617196083069,
-0.21800440549850464,
-0.09249810874462128,
-0.12829841673374176,
-0.21829989552497864,
-0.1220233365893364,
0.18972164392471313,
0.9971348643302917,
0.4512762725353241,
-0.6062121987342834,
0.4137800633907318,
-0.16830867528915405,
-0.2311551719903946,
-0.19137650728225708,
0.03651529178023338,
-0.28326618671417236,
0.36437249183654785,
0.42770281434059143,
0.020360734313726425,
0.24984201788902283,
-0.6977512240409851,
0.29758670926094055,
0.5129696130752563,
-0.5698006749153137,
-0.3189050853252411,
0.3671873211860657,
0.10333164781332016,
-0.10358575731515884,
0.5371392369270325,
-0.2070956528186798,
-0.5995847582817078,
0.34660378098487854,
0.5895668268203735,
0.6251590847969055,
-0.09674141556024551,
0.10480627417564392,
0.16043215990066528,
0.10847926139831543,
-0.0819036141037941,
-0.11668165028095245,
-0.49678853154182434,
-0.8226333856582642,
-0.42073512077331543,
-0.5017619729042053,
-0.6235533356666565,
0.05741855129599571,
-0.6801276803016663,
0.24916136264801025,
-0.5538367033004761,
0.00039564495091326535,
-0.11571075767278671,
-0.1053813174366951,
-0.6891645789146423,
0.32009780406951904,
0.6035576462745667,
0.9684363007545471,
-0.7681459188461304,
0.8383022546768188,
0.7559371590614319,
0.01626582257449627,
-0.7943840026855469,
0.15155333280563354,
0.011104640550911427,
-0.6526947617530823,
0.6679741740226746,
0.4506852924823761,
-0.26982581615448,
-0.14277678728103638,
-0.827833890914917,
-0.6973958611488342,
0.6980202794075012,
0.37680020928382874,
-0.3896976709365845,
-0.023307841271162033,
0.016946973279118538,
0.32643866539001465,
-0.4229763150215149,
0.3202754557132721,
0.6334245800971985,
0.4100000858306885,
-0.20825336873531342,
-0.8100618720054626,
0.16047713160514832,
-0.07194165140390396,
-0.08176625519990921,
0.5483381152153015,
-0.6187059879302979,
0.8401036858558655,
-0.06817617267370224,
-0.12710262835025787,
-0.5653382539749146,
0.5094788670539856,
0.02633255161345005,
0.2815517783164978,
0.6105480790138245,
0.27865684032440186,
0.8364185690879822,
-0.32391759753227234,
0.8571993112564087,
0.10309742391109467,
0.2898581027984619,
0.7819941639900208,
-0.09943339228630066,
0.8170968890190125,
0.4854752719402313,
0.08531656861305237,
0.6188485622406006,
0.9975901246070862,
0.2239866405725479,
0.4492635428905487,
0.35695117712020874,
-0.3323781490325928,
-0.3780786395072937,
-0.03430569916963577,
-0.1730796992778778,
0.589323878288269,
0.8067082762718201,
0.0750291645526886,
-0.40947696566581726,
0.2504633367061615,
0.04796336591243744,
-0.11101623624563217,
-0.6152980923652649,
0.7382612228393555,
0.018440769985318184,
-0.5742743611335754,
0.7169355750083923,
-0.09014493227005005,
0.9627841711044312,
-0.7167757153511047,
-0.16612836718559265,
-0.1386379599571228,
0.1279684156179428,
-0.3606874644756317,
-0.8051220774650574,
-0.0775052160024643,
-0.17740656435489655,
-0.10717736929655075,
-0.30073052644729614,
0.4652061462402344,
-0.6111122965812683,
-0.07740935683250427,
0.5080512166023254,
0.3754355013370514,
0.2145373374223709,
-0.21293118596076965,
-0.45419982075691223,
0.1775997281074524,
0.07397373765707016,
-0.14894041419029236,
0.7124536633491516,
0.7206634879112244,
-0.39853936433792114,
0.6706466674804688,
0.41170889139175415,
-0.18597343564033508,
0.16511113941669464,
0.041701383888721466,
0.7937467098236084,
-0.4929344654083252,
-0.4898836016654968,
-0.8301387429237366,
0.36373552680015564,
0.23072035610675812,
-0.25470173358917236,
0.7969717979431152,
0.44565504789352417,
1.3816176652908325,
0.21224503219127655,
0.6632472276687622,
0.10607760399580002,
0.2034631073474884,
-0.7171201705932617,
0.5731571912765503,
-0.6821538209915161,
0.17463693022727966,
0.06794239580631256,
-0.8137174844741821,
-0.3760240077972412,
0.46531927585601807,
-0.612713098526001,
0.14451512694358826,
0.5266270041465759,
0.6435571312904358,
-0.17642422020435333,
-0.0175124853849411,
0.15138638019561768,
0.15312302112579346,
0.1311071366071701,
0.42324817180633545,
0.8790659308433533,
0.053358469158411026,
0.1177050992846489,
-0.2286609709262848,
-0.6259295344352722,
-0.21512627601623535,
-0.6626342535018921,
-1.0453015565872192,
-0.7741767168045044,
-0.09263521432876587,
-0.14389021694660187,
-0.009625183418393135,
1.2213486433029175,
0.6514168381690979,
-0.5196632742881775,
-0.42717063426971436,
0.24221546947956085,
0.1971016675233841,
-0.21315257251262665,
-0.23200799524784088,
0.30269673466682434,
-0.7319333553314209,
-0.6884523630142212,
0.47956159710884094,
0.010313394479453564,
-0.004198270849883556,
-0.11356564611196518,
-0.052078649401664734,
0.030738793313503265,
-0.170528382062912,
0.7097441554069519,
0.22392110526561737,
-0.5019420981407166,
-0.17252545058727264,
-0.28299403190612793,
0.23608267307281494,
0.0424974262714386,
0.8801999092102051,
-0.8294974565505981,
0.5105026960372925,
0.20332452654838562,
0.7546927332878113,
0.5324946045875549,
-0.07830417901277542,
0.551554262638092,
-0.9336249232292175,
0.19696135818958282,
0.1639377325773239,
0.38356781005859375,
0.3802582621574402,
-0.3452593684196472,
0.27741190791130066,
-0.03401834890246391,
-0.5712242722511292,
-0.8541843891143799,
0.2789996564388275,
-0.7429481744766235,
-0.473611980676651,
1.312787652015686,
0.1995537430047989,
-0.3107779324054718,
-0.3113289177417755,
-0.16436640918254852,
0.13714440166950226,
-0.4276615083217621,
0.5533301830291748,
0.5220668911933899,
-0.31191933155059814,
0.1224314346909523,
-0.5970149636268616,
0.684681236743927,
0.26234427094459534,
-0.3846569061279297,
0.13981302082538605,
0.4959285855293274,
0.36301687359809875,
-0.12547709047794342,
0.26744726300239563,
-0.004458227660506964,
0.16293072700500488,
-0.3565175533294678,
-0.08785902708768845,
0.08841019123792648,
-0.6425241827964783,
-0.7185201644897461,
0.029823336750268936,
0.07811850309371948,
-0.05016516149044037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11231v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11231v1 | Enabling robots to follow abstract instructions and complete complex dynamic tasks | 2024-06-17T05:55:35 | 2024-06-17T05:55:35 | Ruaridh Mon-Williams, Gen Li, Ran Long, Wenqian Du, Chris Lucas | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Completing complex tasks in unpredictable settings like home kitchens
challenges robotic systems. These challenges include interpreting high-level
human commands, such as "make me a hot beverage" and performing actions like
pouring a precise amount of water into a moving mug. To address these
challenges, we present a novel framework that combines Large Language Models
(LLMs), a curated Knowledge Base, and Integrated Force and Visual Feedback
(IFVF). Our approach interprets abstract instructions, performs long-horizon
tasks, and handles various uncertainties. It utilises GPT-4 to analyse the
user's query and surroundings, then generates code that accesses a curated
database of functions during execution. It translates abstract instructions
into actionable steps. Each step involves generating custom code by employing
retrieval-augmented generalisation to pull IFVF-relevant examples from the
Knowledge Base. IFVF allows the robot to respond to noise and disturbances
during execution. We use coffee making and plate decoration to demonstrate our
approach, including components ranging from pouring to drawer opening, each
benefiting from distinct feedback types and methods. This novel advancement
marks significant progress toward a scalable, efficient robotic framework for
completing complex tasks in uncertain environments. Our findings are
illustrated in an accompanying video and supported by an open-source GitHub
repository (released upon paper acceptance). | [
-0.08935412764549255,
-0.7637308239936829,
0.7835437059402466,
0.0732756182551384,
0.25333863496780396,
0.32972252368927,
-0.2668716311454773,
-0.29990947246551514,
0.07930748164653778,
0.5777004361152649,
-0.9219802021980286,
-0.5035633444786072,
-0.6790097951889038,
-0.006348841357976198,
-0.3171805143356323,
0.7168500423431396,
-0.3822457790374756,
-0.05738751217722893,
-0.1373971849679947,
0.092128224670887,
-0.20976951718330383,
-0.35060638189315796,
-0.24475879967212677,
-0.436451256275177,
0.36855489015579224,
0.37108397483825684,
0.8739739656448364,
0.46488264203071594,
0.6189824938774109,
0.37734660506248474,
0.2284948229789734,
0.591071605682373,
-0.3372650742530823,
0.10071773082017899,
-0.44750481843948364,
-0.5009627342224121,
-0.27713578939437866,
-0.35099512338638306,
0.09988545626401901,
0.679375410079956,
-0.037961121648550034,
-0.03342359513044357,
0.1623973399400711,
0.7433747053146362,
-0.4705047607421875,
0.7676078081130981,
-0.10395649820566177,
0.23924893140792847,
0.20785850286483765,
-0.2550874352455139,
-0.2161945402622223,
-0.21618294715881348,
-0.04893316701054573,
-0.6296986937522888,
-0.31011253595352173,
-0.09398907423019409,
0.7637879848480225,
0.6046549677848816,
-0.377721905708313,
-0.5328915119171143,
-1.2396881580352783,
0.4566844403743744,
-0.5086219906806946,
0.28212377429008484,
0.35185059905052185,
0.36493727564811707,
-0.5635993480682373,
-0.8161678314208984,
-0.5603097081184387,
-0.42681679129600525,
-0.05123244225978851,
0.16408492624759674,
-0.10525193065404892,
0.22137679159641266,
0.19364722073078156,
0.015558131970465183,
-0.19363470375537872,
-0.278184175491333,
-0.16891275346279144,
0.007673243060708046,
0.3606215715408325,
0.3462740182876587,
0.29653000831604004,
-0.06370210647583008,
-0.5562301874160767,
-0.3313523828983307,
-0.3827553987503052,
0.28842100501060486,
0.3638796806335449,
0.39916959404945374,
-0.22355756163597107,
0.7888880968093872,
-0.7044916749000549,
0.7866532802581787,
-0.05742704123258591,
-0.15976963937282562,
0.12871666252613068,
-0.33374741673469543,
0.11830813437700272,
-0.38366344571113586,
0.6682617664337158,
0.5109103322029114,
0.17729799449443817,
-0.2066131830215454,
-0.5376965999603271,
0.19659112393856049,
0.26433035731315613,
-0.6140078902244568,
-0.5682396292686462,
0.4163665771484375,
-0.14271530508995056,
-0.34347042441368103,
0.28243502974510193,
-0.5388674139976501,
-0.4403637647628784,
-0.502230167388916,
0.5645518898963928,
-0.17963969707489014,
-0.09126819670200348,
0.5285088419914246,
-0.051917050033807755,
0.07176179438829422,
0.6920853853225708,
-0.6639176607131958,
0.5263290405273438,
0.521864652633667,
0.6480656862258911,
-0.017520131543278694,
-0.04598703607916832,
-0.657311737537384,
0.4397992789745331,
-0.288959264755249,
0.48966658115386963,
-0.5225120186805725,
-0.0637364611029625,
0.12383871525526047,
0.020320601761341095,
0.23811794817447662,
-0.49089232087135315,
0.3513542115688324,
-0.46090254187583923,
0.050103623420000076,
-0.1571149080991745,
-0.2738446295261383,
-0.4920859932899475,
0.38734298944473267,
-0.6053703427314758,
0.857742190361023,
0.47274264693260193,
-0.42403483390808105,
0.2027086466550827,
-0.7836199998855591,
-0.6241045594215393,
0.2591497004032135,
-0.29791516065597534,
-0.11428854614496231,
-0.38150766491889954,
0.22039715945720673,
0.791951060295105,
-0.1662008911371231,
0.2853417992591858,
-0.471165269613266,
-0.07673244178295135,
-0.06327567249536514,
-0.2310681939125061,
0.33276626467704773,
0.1784939467906952,
-0.49576833844184875,
0.5523118376731873,
-0.8121104836463928,
-0.01779911294579506,
0.044498421251773834,
-0.5111709833145142,
0.12287212163209915,
0.17710310220718384,
-0.0295795276761055,
0.19279073178768158,
0.4770814776420593,
-0.3539894223213196,
0.34090572595596313,
0.09977823495864868,
0.6642934083938599,
0.4808320701122284,
-0.11119755357503891,
0.43398019671440125,
-0.28397586941719055,
0.8056738972663879,
-0.3133712708950043,
0.1288090944290161,
-0.3406427502632141,
-0.33805811405181885,
-0.47682178020477295,
-0.409628301858902,
0.08970704674720764,
0.8859667778015137,
-1.2882155179977417,
0.5236881971359253,
-0.1879393458366394,
-0.20018412172794342,
0.03499607369303703,
0.2159101516008377,
0.36889171600341797,
0.5188988447189331,
0.28530263900756836,
-0.16126106679439545,
-0.3261274993419647,
-0.5186110138893127,
0.23097704350948334,
-0.04886496439576149,
-0.5042581558227539,
0.2477412074804306,
0.35178321599960327,
-0.4197431206703186,
0.7112584114074707,
-0.36290815472602844,
-0.38699862360954285,
-0.06579474359750748,
0.10327567160129547,
0.2957767844200134,
0.27857255935668945,
0.3267057240009308,
-0.6241793036460876,
0.08097710460424423,
0.4903685450553894,
-0.9736917614936829,
0.04020256549119949,
-0.17648422718048096,
-0.09050729870796204,
-0.2473413050174713,
0.6943668127059937,
-0.924866795539856,
0.42843976616859436,
0.3868490755558014,
-0.12876011431217194,
0.28599730134010315,
-0.08479828387498856,
0.15293636918067932,
-0.8277843594551086,
-0.25368401408195496,
-0.05450233817100525,
-0.43346336483955383,
-0.23294620215892792,
0.17429056763648987,
-0.0688009187579155,
-0.008401201106607914,
-0.41324853897094727,
0.34450671076774597,
-0.4040672183036804,
0.02913099341094494,
-0.2683587372303009,
-0.1703973114490509,
0.028753239661455154,
0.7834819555282593,
-0.04778464883565903,
0.24362421035766602,
0.32703548669815063,
-0.5098655223846436,
0.6691493391990662,
-0.09124335646629333,
-0.5195865035057068,
0.08686336129903793,
-0.5113092064857483,
-0.035295527428388596,
0.22454503178596497,
0.22223609685897827,
-1.1424756050109863,
-0.7914225459098816,
0.7724689841270447,
-0.16746605932712555,
0.18524959683418274,
-0.06941775232553482,
-0.7639355659484863,
-0.5131427049636841,
0.014794103801250458,
-0.13833892345428467,
0.21831141412258148,
-0.39107781648635864,
1.1490403413772583,
0.30883315205574036,
0.04167110100388527,
-0.4865928888320923,
-0.4391797184944153,
-0.008542416617274284,
0.1645585000514984,
-0.71745765209198,
0.11348175257444382,
-0.06221192330121994,
-0.34574639797210693,
0.08207409083843231,
-0.2849869728088379,
-0.012367602437734604,
0.05563613027334213,
0.307006299495697,
0.04168660193681717,
0.16462507843971252,
-0.23949210345745087,
0.189641073346138,
0.1887274533510208,
0.3746398687362671,
-0.41893070936203003,
0.4285286068916321,
-0.4187808930873871,
-0.48783227801322937,
-0.5723583102226257,
0.12580372393131256,
0.7977285981178284,
0.0172230564057827,
-0.03713984414935112,
0.7182655930519104,
-0.41448870301246643,
-0.4290388226509094,
-0.08138326555490494,
-0.48353078961372375,
-0.6253858208656311,
0.46315619349479675,
-0.47784850001335144,
-0.8572266697883606,
0.5655792951583862,
-0.37957999110221863,
0.3231212794780731,
-0.10965699702501297,
0.6616107225418091,
-0.3338301181793213,
0.8427459597587585,
0.43706855177879333,
0.24951142072677612,
0.3864695131778717,
-0.23845167458057404,
0.24123091995716095,
-0.3296157419681549,
-0.3864574432373047,
-0.18425951898097992,
-0.5191315412521362,
-0.40529361367225647,
-0.7700040936470032,
0.472783625125885,
-0.25702452659606934,
-0.21462616324424744,
0.24132245779037476,
-0.6567031741142273,
0.31130167841911316,
0.6014865636825562,
0.45122596621513367,
0.19341936707496643,
-0.1549040824174881,
-0.11499630659818649,
0.3080875873565674,
-0.8111987113952637,
-0.5149412155151367,
0.6689895391464233,
0.24257659912109375,
1.2118834257125854,
0.04879773408174515,
0.37966087460517883,
0.5800139307975769,
-0.005205092485994101,
-0.926542341709137,
0.6453121304512024,
0.03437873721122742,
-0.2148747742176056,
-0.47649237513542175,
-0.22086194157600403,
-0.9570769667625427,
0.07700125873088837,
-0.19445614516735077,
-0.3755949139595032,
-0.12701711058616638,
0.12538667023181915,
-0.5140561461448669,
0.3293101489543915,
-0.7973225712776184,
0.44017475843429565,
-0.44659218192100525,
-0.5481767654418945,
0.11317472904920578,
-0.9570026993751526,
0.35123133659362793,
0.35786521434783936,
0.3432534635066986,
0.012620676308870316,
-0.04036276042461395,
0.138467937707901,
-0.4507581889629364,
1.111892819404602,
-0.16434836387634277,
-0.3019082248210907,
0.3484083116054535,
0.5272009372711182,
0.637449324131012,
0.11964744329452515,
0.03650214895606041,
0.03559551015496254,
-0.08875223249197006,
-0.2042320966720581,
-1.0173903703689575,
0.4566551744937897,
-0.6818877458572388,
-0.638026773929596,
-0.27639254927635193,
-0.9138001203536987,
-0.10530689358711243,
0.26016032695770264,
-0.1509869396686554,
0.13344384729862213,
0.36257022619247437,
0.1584853231906891,
0.6533471941947937,
-0.05220859870314598,
0.2798652946949005,
0.3373909890651703,
-0.415107786655426,
-0.1756400316953659,
0.6670897006988525,
0.04525303840637207,
0.1783873289823532,
0.8807437419891357,
0.16551494598388672,
0.0025815058033913374,
-0.39283713698387146,
-0.8746947646141052,
-0.3139802813529968,
-0.6827040910720825,
-0.1955336630344391,
-0.5883983969688416,
-0.0832059234380722,
0.0816226378083229,
-0.35415664315223694,
-0.4701438546180725,
-0.3866592049598694,
-0.26763585209846497,
-0.3168718218803406,
0.5431488156318665,
1.1305893659591675,
0.04841851070523262,
0.153194397687912,
-0.7262975573539734,
0.3918573558330536,
0.34740179777145386,
0.23879097402095795,
-0.1235368549823761,
-0.110600546002388,
-0.13814951479434967,
-0.014343658462166786,
-0.09489627927541733,
-0.5207583904266357,
0.2886340022087097,
-0.241179957985878,
0.1925237625837326,
0.2389921247959137,
0.30327072739601135,
0.42605695128440857,
-0.5373860001564026,
0.7282178997993469,
0.19878406822681427,
-0.7538318634033203,
0.506563663482666,
-0.8537749648094177,
0.4666295349597931,
0.3297916650772095,
0.3263550102710724,
0.1430860459804535,
-0.3505648672580719,
-0.17551343142986298,
-1.148098111152649,
0.4193022847175598,
0.06331415474414825,
0.18868282437324524,
0.26040104031562805,
0.37355536222457886,
0.05696957930922508,
0.2807290554046631,
-0.6153653860092163,
0.12719565629959106,
0.023568682372570038,
-0.18042166531085968,
0.4747142195701599,
0.24867106974124908,
-0.5610495209693909,
-0.3046889305114746,
0.2596742808818817,
-0.34340324997901917,
0.211925208568573,
-0.02687353827059269,
0.1062534749507904,
-0.3285929560661316,
-0.1488586962223053,
0.7372742891311646,
0.6426172852516174,
-0.20104509592056274,
-0.12116561084985733,
-0.14148564636707306,
-0.2843646705150604,
-0.05045590549707413,
-0.009238894097507,
-0.04181365668773651,
-0.1867092251777649,
0.3171633780002594,
0.5520923733711243,
0.13887174427509308,
-0.7473252415657043,
0.38076600432395935,
-0.12267206609249115,
-0.2883906364440918,
-0.4562813639640808,
0.39031168818473816,
0.16913753747940063,
0.4413958489894867,
0.14231017231941223,
0.46156802773475647,
0.23076511919498444,
-0.5446687340736389,
0.5621427893638611,
0.11890467256307602,
-0.5340119004249573,
-0.5007731318473816,
0.7585694193840027,
0.3436301350593567,
-0.36866024136543274,
0.4777708351612091,
-0.35650330781936646,
-0.3862619400024414,
0.5812674164772034,
0.02759077213704586,
0.534733772277832,
0.1472761482000351,
0.21441426873207092,
0.08701599389314651,
0.36169347167015076,
-0.07398540526628494,
0.7627831697463989,
-0.46647918224334717,
-0.7788631916046143,
-0.5148990154266357,
-0.5360881686210632,
-0.7350172996520996,
-0.15433986485004425,
-0.6272721886634827,
0.22909528017044067,
-0.8559726476669312,
0.04056030511856079,
-0.2685545086860657,
-0.47016429901123047,
-0.7771216034889221,
0.20639623701572418,
0.002458633854985237,
0.3783022463321686,
-0.5356568098068237,
0.7392987012863159,
0.8334770798683167,
-0.22938337922096252,
-1.0259087085723877,
-0.03063531033694744,
0.08812147378921509,
-0.8045548796653748,
0.591439425945282,
-0.08270352333784103,
-0.8450241088867188,
-0.4885869324207306,
-0.7859681844711304,
-0.8277668952941895,
0.9082793593406677,
0.4017413258552551,
-0.7010603547096252,
0.07561216503381729,
0.060638364404439926,
0.6115719079971313,
-0.3636532425880432,
0.06917465478181839,
0.3345133662223816,
0.7028261423110962,
0.25707051157951355,
-0.7215531468391418,
0.08127818256616592,
-0.43503421545028687,
-0.1768459677696228,
0.09338907897472382,
-0.8641930818557739,
0.6191648840904236,
-0.4501913785934448,
0.23540106415748596,
0.062156833708286285,
0.766674816608429,
0.20235829055309296,
0.2781849205493927,
0.47854822874069214,
0.48957359790802,
0.7367205619812012,
-0.18275795876979828,
1.2353287935256958,
-0.3924078643321991,
-0.0516727939248085,
1.2485945224761963,
-0.48139894008636475,
0.5671294331550598,
0.334750235080719,
-0.2541770339012146,
0.6517376899719238,
0.5544798374176025,
0.08689006417989731,
0.7592604160308838,
0.43045949935913086,
-0.15478624403476715,
-0.0679064616560936,
-0.02322961576282978,
0.09011554718017578,
0.5217859148979187,
0.7255681157112122,
-0.16199281811714172,
0.10269469022750854,
0.1581704020500183,
0.062550388276577,
0.20249558985233307,
-0.07054579257965088,
0.5695204734802246,
0.04698149487376213,
-0.6909486055374146,
0.329597145318985,
-0.19691964983940125,
0.5509703159332275,
-0.5875896215438843,
-0.4579482078552246,
0.2279493361711502,
0.33245760202407837,
-0.22264596819877625,
-1.1325756311416626,
0.1824834793806076,
-0.42618075013160706,
-0.24291369318962097,
-0.4060293734073639,
0.5958563685417175,
-0.281210333108902,
-0.3323950171470642,
0.5302773118019104,
0.5060634016990662,
-0.051262740045785904,
0.16677409410476685,
-0.5085079073905945,
0.21380291879177094,
0.20193107426166534,
-0.38533249497413635,
0.1434154361486435,
0.8408560752868652,
-0.1066770926117897,
1.0599796772003174,
0.556742787361145,
-0.18752463161945343,
0.07636085897684097,
0.16432806849479675,
0.8917890191078186,
-0.31873568892478943,
-0.21230950951576233,
-0.4445308744907379,
0.568442702293396,
0.46022477746009827,
-0.2840422987937927,
0.4290914535522461,
0.17851696908473969,
1.2538303136825562,
-0.34451547265052795,
0.9276771545410156,
-0.3160627484321594,
0.15848180651664734,
-0.5118157863616943,
0.4209344983100891,
-0.510198175907135,
0.46796080470085144,
-0.19820371270179749,
-0.6464730501174927,
-0.4771679937839508,
0.7285374402999878,
-0.05102723836898804,
0.09924864768981934,
0.30079221725463867,
0.8236233592033386,
-0.01825736090540886,
-0.018156349658966064,
0.36986836791038513,
0.19955046474933624,
0.45147082209587097,
0.1979566216468811,
0.9162598252296448,
-0.10958819836378098,
0.6765581965446472,
-0.4181744158267975,
-0.19605301320552826,
0.05121111869812012,
-0.7584198117256165,
-0.6544260382652283,
-0.4973199665546417,
-0.18567398190498352,
-0.41800031065940857,
0.19778256118297577,
1.1278502941131592,
0.9721095561981201,
-0.7364766597747803,
-0.3176475167274475,
-0.11153590679168701,
-0.016039058566093445,
-0.5648130774497986,
-0.24840274453163147,
0.16412799060344696,
-0.22963076829910278,
-0.8825726509094238,
0.4658834934234619,
0.635508120059967,
-0.36338359117507935,
-0.2604879140853882,
-0.06871535629034042,
-0.06396885216236115,
-0.12092199176549911,
0.9350094795227051,
0.24669964611530304,
-0.8241404294967651,
-0.3572961390018463,
0.04303565248847008,
-0.005168238189071417,
0.14072856307029724,
0.3960186541080475,
-0.6814568638801575,
0.7130178809165955,
0.5132778286933899,
0.8957638144493103,
0.5116598010063171,
-0.15278467535972595,
0.7734457850456238,
-0.6468462944030762,
-0.037248723208904266,
0.4783558249473572,
0.4858431816101074,
0.32006242871284485,
-0.6338657140731812,
0.8807100653648376,
0.02095024473965168,
-0.4849647879600525,
-0.3939431607723236,
0.43340611457824707,
-1.2882109880447388,
-0.30426666140556335,
1.2260856628417969,
-0.24905605614185333,
-0.3555026054382324,
-0.12079906463623047,
-0.14829258620738983,
0.13512660562992096,
-0.66721111536026,
1.0113424062728882,
0.7887611389160156,
-0.5104624629020691,
-0.16119331121444702,
-0.7083891034126282,
0.16205768287181854,
0.2456626147031784,
-0.7963203191757202,
-0.12597917020320892,
0.5440058708190918,
0.24270914494991302,
0.1608477234840393,
0.19821655750274658,
-0.1691948026418686,
0.29370546340942383,
-0.1546102613210678,
0.3641890585422516,
-0.12920552492141724,
-0.6466701626777649,
0.126089945435524,
0.2720698416233063,
-0.20352678000926971,
-0.23896707594394684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11230v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11230v1 | Multimodal Needle in a Haystack: Benchmarking Long-Context Capability of Multimodal Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T05:54:06 | 2024-06-17T05:54:06 | Hengyi Wang, Haizhou Shi, Shiwei Tan, Weiyi Qin, Wenyuan Wang, Tunyu Zhang, Akshay Nambi, Tanuja Ganu, Hao Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have shown significant promise in
various applications, leading to broad interest from researchers and
practitioners alike. However, a comprehensive evaluation of their long-context
capabilities remains underexplored. To address these gaps, we introduce the
MultiModal Needle-in-a-haystack (MMNeedle) benchmark, specifically designed to
assess the long-context capabilities of MLLMs. Besides multi-image input, we
employ image stitching to further increase the input context length, and
develop a protocol to automatically generate labels for sub-image level
retrieval. Essentially, MMNeedle evaluates MLLMs by stress-testing their
capability to locate a target sub-image (needle) within a set of images
(haystack) based on textual instructions and descriptions of image contents.
This setup necessitates an advanced understanding of extensive visual contexts
and effective information retrieval within long-context image inputs. With this
benchmark, we evaluate state-of-the-art MLLMs, encompassing both API-based and
open-source models. The findings reveal that GPT-4o consistently surpasses
other models in long-context scenarios, but suffers from hallucination problems
in negative samples, i.e., when needles are not in the haystacks. Our
comprehensive long-context evaluation of MLLMs also sheds lights on the
considerable performance gap between API-based and open-source models. All the
code, data, and instructions required to reproduce the main results are
available at https://github.com/Wang-ML-Lab/multimodal-needle-in-a-haystack. | [
-0.4152274429798126,
-0.8735308051109314,
0.7735008597373962,
0.16335274279117584,
-0.30598315596580505,
-0.13590362668037415,
-0.3559979498386383,
-0.7263293862342834,
0.03542561084032059,
0.24603085219860077,
-0.4269368648529053,
-0.564479410648346,
-0.4927660822868347,
0.231822207570076,
-0.4647601246833801,
0.6874763369560242,
-0.10153166949748993,
-0.08989280462265015,
-0.42209333181381226,
-0.36070650815963745,
-0.5743805766105652,
-0.5754244327545166,
-0.1443222463130951,
0.03965819254517555,
0.7997771501541138,
-0.010231327265501022,
0.4911564290523529,
0.30980920791625977,
0.7041221857070923,
0.35004404187202454,
-0.00166166084818542,
0.15664416551589966,
-0.3653300106525421,
0.20898233354091644,
-0.020567601546645164,
0.07246928662061691,
-0.23201991617679596,
0.038894858211278915,
0.7412081360816956,
0.3991156220436096,
0.04381873831152916,
0.2699589133262634,
0.022845618426799774,
0.48522767424583435,
-0.9169166088104248,
-0.01031490508466959,
-0.7046089768409729,
-0.10727588832378387,
-0.405877947807312,
-0.11771739274263382,
-0.3922880291938782,
-0.08150619268417358,
0.16995616257190704,
-0.43925702571868896,
-0.09338580816984177,
-0.042306575924158096,
0.7839978933334351,
0.15731358528137207,
-0.726337194442749,
-0.3764041066169739,
-0.34075838327407837,
0.853249192237854,
-0.5512728095054626,
0.648482084274292,
0.4817954897880554,
0.5264967083930969,
-0.10474754869937897,
-0.8587236404418945,
-0.5320946574211121,
-0.5212625861167908,
-0.07518476992845535,
-0.001915328553877771,
0.03246626630425453,
-0.2005295604467392,
0.3344392478466034,
0.16023726761341095,
-0.6906543374061584,
-0.039080046117305756,
-0.30160799622535706,
-0.2394443154335022,
0.16044238209724426,
0.09243784844875336,
0.020995013415813446,
-0.27666720747947693,
-0.6289249062538147,
0.06444728374481201,
-0.33590570092201233,
0.11511558294296265,
0.015852270647883415,
0.18150217831134796,
-0.06694178283214569,
0.7113301157951355,
-0.07909505814313889,
0.7235092520713806,
-0.3551744520664215,
-0.19986408948898315,
0.5582881569862366,
-0.5347297787666321,
-0.14322274923324585,
-0.3633562922477722,
0.7622438073158264,
0.6361290216445923,
0.011909563094377518,
-0.0783558115363121,
-0.36949074268341064,
0.009342431090772152,
0.22490844130516052,
-0.8582296967506409,
0.09837357699871063,
0.28822940587997437,
-0.4487982988357544,
0.025125209242105484,
-0.10984117537736893,
-0.727379560470581,
-0.445470929145813,
-0.2002202272415161,
0.6040952801704407,
-0.5023480653762817,
-0.20548827946186066,
-0.13184289634227753,
-0.3712320327758789,
0.07760073989629745,
0.24343723058700562,
-0.6045547127723694,
-0.11276060342788696,
0.7654237747192383,
1.2762528657913208,
-0.2254762351512909,
-0.7341878414154053,
-0.6243170499801636,
0.195596843957901,
-0.45558932423591614,
0.7769633531570435,
-0.7781010866165161,
-0.21499522030353546,
-0.0047082542441785336,
0.1714588701725006,
0.020787976682186127,
-0.5519123673439026,
0.4102713465690613,
-0.22889989614486694,
0.09757911413908005,
-0.14555718004703522,
-0.48982369899749756,
0.018322989344596863,
0.40981635451316833,
-0.7220420837402344,
0.9676378965377808,
0.25882667303085327,
-0.5960900187492371,
0.49860283732414246,
-0.7351895570755005,
-0.2520063519477844,
-0.07769069820642471,
-0.25464075803756714,
-0.2703361213207245,
0.034544043242931366,
0.10441023111343384,
0.5336494445800781,
-0.2711409628391266,
0.24812617897987366,
-0.7468889355659485,
-0.6682559251785278,
0.4400269091129303,
-0.41727587580680847,
0.5534005761146545,
0.050121430307626724,
-0.3190876245498657,
0.43298307061195374,
-0.6094241738319397,
0.009509021416306496,
-0.005750947166234255,
-0.23388537764549255,
-0.43249616026878357,
-0.19175586104393005,
0.3637670874595642,
0.4377114474773407,
0.19142940640449524,
-0.535577654838562,
0.1567632406949997,
0.23138481378555298,
0.609108567237854,
0.8280039429664612,
-0.45007020235061646,
0.05226045474410057,
-0.054298076778650284,
0.21050843596458435,
0.10364798456430435,
0.346919447183609,
-0.5999780893325806,
-0.42944270372390747,
-0.3926611840724945,
-0.6101932525634766,
0.21517008543014526,
0.12549075484275818,
-0.82421875,
0.22490215301513672,
-0.14325383305549622,
-0.4020899534225464,
-0.5270326137542725,
0.036019716411828995,
0.3279370963573456,
0.4762251675128937,
0.5777144432067871,
-0.3853335380554199,
-0.37261340022087097,
-1.1190919876098633,
-0.034003905951976776,
0.18919438123703003,
-0.2405889928340912,
0.4928775727748871,
0.6835685968399048,
-0.6909728050231934,
0.6253172755241394,
-0.1322709619998932,
-0.427365243434906,
0.3530048727989197,
0.16389068961143494,
0.2314959168434143,
0.29717764258384705,
0.43439981341362,
-0.6433358788490295,
-0.29218530654907227,
-0.031128179281949997,
-0.8621541857719421,
0.1683439165353775,
0.035257261246442795,
-0.06775001436471939,
0.49014902114868164,
0.4118702709674835,
-0.8775192499160767,
0.33508437871932983,
0.8678240180015564,
-0.4930306077003479,
0.8118295073509216,
-0.19401921331882477,
0.43572860956192017,
-0.7514054775238037,
0.4872938394546509,
-0.05021839588880539,
-0.2022411823272705,
-0.37698888778686523,
0.18586145341396332,
0.6553183197975159,
-0.07603690028190613,
-0.39836418628692627,
0.5540282726287842,
-0.5078387260437012,
-0.25640103220939636,
-0.16407938301563263,
0.024198472499847412,
0.038477543741464615,
0.42385780811309814,
-0.06327075511217117,
0.9147356748580933,
0.49668434262275696,
-0.2454483062028885,
0.42095768451690674,
-0.19536516070365906,
-0.6067637801170349,
0.6194698214530945,
-0.4748181402683258,
0.20480205118656158,
-0.004303178284317255,
0.4439278542995453,
-0.91413813829422,
-0.17565391957759857,
-0.07331337034702301,
-0.1499093770980835,
0.1505807787179947,
-0.17634953558444977,
-0.5369290113449097,
-0.5169848203659058,
-0.5328822135925293,
0.5093727707862854,
0.31473779678344727,
-0.5372176766395569,
0.5048724412918091,
0.3332020938396454,
0.13710364699363708,
-0.7263679504394531,
-0.36426854133605957,
0.44643405079841614,
-0.31247448921203613,
-0.5065605640411377,
0.22926944494247437,
-0.19090448319911957,
0.03348128870129585,
-0.13080428540706635,
0.11046911776065826,
-0.13818076252937317,
-0.04307466000318527,
0.2679777145385742,
0.1306912899017334,
-0.2321106642484665,
0.4969225823879242,
-0.2617220878601074,
-0.14057807624340057,
-0.0437944270670414,
-0.06280694156885147,
0.5760802030563354,
-0.3641544282436371,
-0.5387541651725769,
-0.22344249486923218,
0.5519218444824219,
0.8165678381919861,
-0.3031465411186218,
0.45693638920783997,
0.9196457266807556,
-0.2003161609172821,
0.10259904712438583,
-0.7279022932052612,
-0.16375108063220978,
-0.4634304642677307,
0.5914605855941772,
-0.5754099488258362,
-0.8372226357460022,
0.2595537006855011,
0.059603068977594376,
0.04336901381611824,
0.24795345962047577,
0.55649334192276,
-0.15271882712841034,
0.8788508176803589,
0.489715576171875,
0.0404994823038578,
0.38081252574920654,
-0.014656628482043743,
-0.16086693108081818,
-1.0236929655075073,
-0.0720478743314743,
-0.1365921050310135,
-0.22517791390419006,
-0.3961932957172394,
-0.7773751020431519,
0.5350931286811829,
0.00823027640581131,
-0.13685187697410583,
0.09123656153678894,
-0.3143746554851532,
0.5439473986625671,
0.6602829098701477,
0.014015442691743374,
0.23605482280254364,
-0.2743837535381317,
-0.33149582147598267,
0.15089678764343262,
-0.370626837015152,
-0.4845990240573883,
1.138538122177124,
0.48801860213279724,
0.6409122347831726,
0.0726466178894043,
0.3959539830684662,
-0.023010047152638435,
0.2333211898803711,
-0.7320238947868347,
0.4406823217868805,
-0.10791775584220886,
-0.5444967746734619,
-0.5064533352851868,
-0.21422889828681946,
-1.048642635345459,
0.5363104343414307,
-0.2504544258117676,
-0.6280819177627563,
-0.06337133795022964,
0.052040595561265945,
-0.11896807700395584,
0.2108660787343979,
-0.7923687696456909,
1.074774146080017,
-0.28254184126853943,
-0.5591768026351929,
-0.14762982726097107,
-0.5665481686592102,
0.41445600986480713,
-0.312161922454834,
0.24305444955825806,
-0.383120059967041,
-0.27241790294647217,
0.37878668308258057,
-0.10299739241600037,
0.5357229113578796,
-0.13215649127960205,
-0.2336035668849945,
0.059357792139053345,
-0.003828376065939665,
0.3211648762226105,
-0.1582750827074051,
0.02704659104347229,
0.5962957143783569,
0.3663683831691742,
-0.3616548180580139,
-0.3313950300216675,
0.8407419323921204,
-0.424022912979126,
-0.2920140027999878,
-0.2094973623752594,
-0.5042667388916016,
-0.2027006447315216,
0.30031657218933105,
-0.044905886054039,
0.6861413717269897,
-0.04707648977637291,
0.5743415355682373,
0.10860922187566757,
-0.30071786046028137,
0.5691953897476196,
0.31666597723960876,
-0.5472285747528076,
-0.25395479798316956,
0.8218456506729126,
0.11646826565265656,
0.019208578392863274,
0.06873082369565964,
0.21642813086509705,
-0.4824281930923462,
-0.31253641843795776,
-0.7004143595695496,
0.12348055094480515,
-0.8019237518310547,
-0.15586000680923462,
-0.5580003261566162,
0.1030743345618248,
-0.35061201453208923,
0.12665557861328125,
-0.40006157755851746,
-0.01997123658657074,
0.05389689281582832,
0.36427390575408936,
0.18441304564476013,
0.6326414942741394,
0.13478748500347137,
-0.2454649806022644,
-0.815895140171051,
0.29490211606025696,
0.394897997379303,
0.8262632489204407,
0.12844900786876678,
-0.12827186286449432,
-0.39202427864074707,
-0.0420500710606575,
-0.23760449886322021,
-0.651264488697052,
0.0018929042853415012,
0.088337741792202,
0.39331451058387756,
0.3152691721916199,
-0.28600290417671204,
1.0209025144577026,
-0.827034592628479,
0.8055211305618286,
0.305269330739975,
-0.8292444348335266,
0.23786576092243195,
-0.3858804702758789,
0.6354119777679443,
0.2390684336423874,
0.34009110927581787,
-0.7180536389350891,
-0.3886990547180176,
-0.09945017099380493,
-0.8886922597885132,
0.2054099440574646,
0.15552696585655212,
0.057759422808885574,
-0.1962231993675232,
-0.16162018477916718,
0.33765265345573425,
0.17912162840366364,
-0.6405671238899231,
0.23522837460041046,
-0.26545029878616333,
-0.03662523254752159,
-0.4170210063457489,
-0.28320547938346863,
-0.23578117787837982,
-0.17804722487926483,
0.182301864027977,
-0.31623575091362,
0.2566581070423126,
0.1458340585231781,
-0.3436935245990753,
-0.043556954711675644,
0.23855623602867126,
0.9126788377761841,
1.0429189205169678,
-0.39920487999916077,
0.3452253043651581,
0.04089091345667839,
-0.34408795833587646,
-0.16801679134368896,
0.05799969285726547,
0.31234484910964966,
0.22255869209766388,
0.5443776249885559,
0.6259489059448242,
0.21472081542015076,
-1.0375405550003052,
0.6979302763938904,
-0.18287523090839386,
-0.1065068244934082,
-0.250031054019928,
-0.2677065432071686,
0.15552538633346558,
0.4954381287097931,
0.5271323323249817,
-0.2888503968715668,
0.313708633184433,
-0.6252720952033997,
0.304695725440979,
0.8256360292434692,
-0.22458894550800323,
-0.13748787343502045,
0.30698949098587036,
0.19184064865112305,
-0.1800992786884308,
0.5251621603965759,
0.20687930285930634,
-0.16816040873527527,
0.46163180470466614,
0.49361762404441833,
0.6578801870346069,
0.09105400741100311,
-0.1649046689271927,
0.334547758102417,
0.23997029662132263,
0.21344736218452454,
0.008524008095264435,
-0.14999814331531525,
-0.25375813245773315,
-0.4445328116416931,
-0.5133028030395508,
-0.2689570188522339,
0.30523326992988586,
-0.4489263594150543,
0.24809828400611877,
-0.13159389793872833,
-0.4906139075756073,
0.060741085559129715,
-0.3136477470397949,
-0.6725902557373047,
-0.1416478157043457,
0.24394828081130981,
0.7771354913711548,
-0.35915815830230713,
0.9310682415962219,
0.4041263163089752,
-0.04165719076991081,
-0.2618825137615204,
-0.12929552793502808,
0.060067079961299896,
-0.7658211588859558,
0.6376867890357971,
0.7904660701751709,
-0.2440764158964157,
-0.33482831716537476,
-0.4592365026473999,
-0.9037666916847229,
1.2132277488708496,
0.06370051950216293,
-0.6979668736457825,
0.1432858258485794,
-0.07078817486763,
0.4538499116897583,
-0.1758028119802475,
0.527641773223877,
0.3799867331981659,
0.4218224287033081,
-0.01977662183344364,
-1.359102487564087,
0.07324281334877014,
-0.3036680519580841,
0.01685459539294243,
0.39046305418014526,
-0.4442853331565857,
1.1359238624572754,
-0.1824900507926941,
-0.22740747034549713,
0.28729262948036194,
0.2892357110977173,
0.36049458384513855,
0.4138295650482178,
0.5602336525917053,
0.3973776698112488,
0.6176562309265137,
0.06555207818746567,
0.9615089893341064,
-0.283244788646698,
0.43614113330841064,
1.052835464477539,
-0.41494694352149963,
1.2134767770767212,
0.9095281362533569,
-0.026671774685382843,
0.48378750681877136,
0.47932863235473633,
-0.001148163340985775,
0.3887943625450134,
0.11547061800956726,
-0.06780644506216049,
-0.07885848730802536,
-0.008836883120238781,
-0.5879660844802856,
0.4686723053455353,
0.1841912418603897,
-0.31130892038345337,
-0.2599533498287201,
0.23068174719810486,
-0.42364782094955444,
-0.3379266560077667,
-0.05880218371748924,
0.7645125389099121,
-0.05537743493914604,
-0.5635652542114258,
0.9334514141082764,
-0.2505652904510498,
0.9566413760185242,
-0.6803979277610779,
-0.20095425844192505,
-0.01644911989569664,
0.1972767561674118,
0.18343298137187958,
-0.9193131923675537,
0.02824447490274906,
-0.02070239745080471,
0.046304043382406235,
0.052408985793590546,
0.49848467111587524,
-0.4779128134250641,
-0.3991711139678955,
0.445956826210022,
0.3222721815109253,
0.20034895837306976,
-0.1024603322148323,
-0.7523844838142395,
0.33596792817115784,
-0.532031774520874,
-0.35142982006073,
0.42039841413497925,
0.4675801992416382,
-0.09972582757472992,
0.698394775390625,
0.7649593949317932,
-0.18034325540065765,
0.0158414114266634,
0.07936282455921173,
0.7651023268699646,
-0.9362412095069885,
-0.2244516760110855,
-1.0265222787857056,
0.55734783411026,
-0.19232818484306335,
-0.4694609045982361,
0.790351152420044,
0.584906280040741,
0.8214704990386963,
-0.2069324254989624,
0.4499703347682953,
0.08950909972190857,
0.43362918496131897,
-0.6121549606323242,
0.7090498805046082,
-0.809023380279541,
-0.22350972890853882,
-0.47093823552131653,
-0.7696305513381958,
-0.2355518639087677,
0.5747528672218323,
-0.10088081657886505,
0.14236252009868622,
0.902606725692749,
0.8509148955345154,
-0.1509920209646225,
-0.325201153755188,
0.5755274891853333,
0.0725548043847084,
0.3393380045890808,
0.6162752509117126,
1.178145170211792,
-0.1576472669839859,
0.43988683819770813,
-0.33629605174064636,
-0.24015486240386963,
-0.2733210325241089,
-1.095914602279663,
-0.9635381102561951,
-0.8676817417144775,
0.21669505536556244,
-0.208779439330101,
0.008135775104165077,
0.8212605118751526,
0.8397808074951172,
-0.43465328216552734,
-0.43423089385032654,
0.52138751745224,
-0.08196423202753067,
-0.15022708475589752,
-0.17882344126701355,
0.3688695430755615,
-0.37099939584732056,
-0.5738097429275513,
0.22678333520889282,
0.564113974571228,
0.039378438144922256,
-0.34450262784957886,
-0.039453424513339996,
-0.2996678054332733,
-0.21838504076004028,
1.1637680530548096,
-0.13483719527721405,
-1.0415631532669067,
-0.38817840814590454,
-0.09494838863611221,
-0.25871750712394714,
0.034405313432216644,
0.8145825266838074,
-0.6804837584495544,
0.6145499348640442,
0.08172319829463959,
0.4892251193523407,
0.37296760082244873,
-0.1714661717414856,
0.3022654056549072,
-0.47309228777885437,
0.23521645367145538,
0.22985051572322845,
0.43841809034347534,
0.2952566146850586,
0.002741385716944933,
0.46525704860687256,
-0.034275688230991364,
-0.5727298259735107,
-1.022560477256775,
0.04943804442882538,
-0.8757719397544861,
-0.7493339776992798,
1.1555739641189575,
-0.02492479979991913,
-0.2220749706029892,
-0.023644965142011642,
-0.34466809034347534,
-0.05496394261717796,
-0.23731571435928345,
0.8775953054428101,
0.7228938937187195,
0.008633005432784557,
-0.19748719036579132,
-0.7582857608795166,
0.30846530199050903,
0.21973782777786255,
-0.6635230183601379,
0.17291352152824402,
0.8002108335494995,
0.1670670211315155,
0.14478887617588043,
0.6291170120239258,
-0.006473327521234751,
0.35928431153297424,
-0.1091693565249443,
-0.06965713202953339,
-0.1613418161869049,
-0.48024481534957886,
-0.3095194697380066,
0.20888802409172058,
-0.03569730371236801,
-0.1236005425453186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11228v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11228v1 | ComperDial: Commonsense Persona-grounded Dialogue Dataset and Benchmark | 2024-06-17T05:51:04 | 2024-06-17T05:51:04 | Hiromi Wakaki, Yuki Mitsufuji, Yoshinori Maeda, Yukiko Nishimura, Silin Gao, Mengjie Zhao, Keiichi Yamada, Antoine Bosselut | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose a new benchmark, ComperDial, which facilitates the training and
evaluation of evaluation metrics for open-domain dialogue systems. ComperDial
consists of human-scored responses for 10,395 dialogue turns in 1,485
conversations collected from 99 dialogue agents submitted to the Commonsense
Persona-grounded Dialogue (CPD) challenge. As a result, for any dialogue, our
benchmark includes multiple diverse responses with variety of characteristics
to ensure more robust evaluation of learned dialogue metrics. In addition to
single-turn response scores, ComperDial also contains dialogue-level
human-annotated scores, enabling joint assessment of multi-turn model responses
throughout a dialogue. Finally, building off ComperDial, we devise a new
automatic evaluation metric to measure the general similarity of
model-generated dialogues to human conversations. Our experimental results
demonstrate that our novel metric, CPDScore is more correlated with human
judgments than existing metrics. We release both ComperDial and CPDScore to the
community to accelerate development of automatic evaluation metrics for
open-domain dialogue systems. | [
-0.5230041146278381,
-0.42904481291770935,
0.3475065529346466,
0.13986054062843323,
-0.10479483008384705,
0.2396787703037262,
-0.31260988116264343,
-0.011900792829692364,
-0.1199851781129837,
0.5370054244995117,
-0.7922329306602478,
-0.5074834227561951,
-0.36423927545547485,
0.09604120254516602,
-0.006023322697728872,
0.7785196304321289,
0.47127899527549744,
0.31213903427124023,
-0.5516413450241089,
-0.5443037748336792,
-0.6226100921630859,
-0.5494545102119446,
-0.4354628920555115,
-0.3029022812843323,
0.04354593902826309,
0.6020290851593018,
0.7096944451332092,
-0.007160242646932602,
0.2861335873603821,
0.34001293778419495,
0.1917296200990677,
0.2786056697368622,
-0.5849521160125732,
0.14902064204216003,
-0.14979174733161926,
-0.21759890019893646,
-0.6360692381858826,
0.47930261492729187,
0.5148400068283081,
1.0758004188537598,
-0.2200065702199936,
0.36367297172546387,
0.07416786998510361,
0.39589667320251465,
-0.6194372773170471,
0.3315966725349426,
-0.3616757392883301,
0.09480895102024078,
0.24677610397338867,
-0.3557009696960449,
-0.6121006608009338,
-0.5432844161987305,
0.46206915378570557,
-0.6469496488571167,
0.2327834963798523,
0.16713863611221313,
0.2715334892272949,
0.27044326066970825,
-0.32089316844940186,
0.03074914589524269,
-0.36090123653411865,
1.0119150876998901,
-0.42302143573760986,
0.38841137290000916,
0.15669625997543335,
0.6146888136863708,
-0.01844063401222229,
-0.5899993777275085,
-0.5226889848709106,
-0.30806025862693787,
-0.10049700736999512,
0.28546780347824097,
-0.13398295640945435,
-0.03482363000512123,
0.2550305426120758,
0.2917526066303253,
-0.4741111397743225,
-0.1378871500492096,
0.04507092759013176,
-0.13396091759204865,
0.5717393159866333,
0.567002534866333,
0.06387735158205032,
-0.21624314785003662,
-0.4720214009284973,
-0.33797645568847656,
-0.457586407661438,
0.1127106249332428,
0.277830570936203,
0.1560223400592804,
-0.365334153175354,
0.30741098523139954,
-0.3778943419456482,
0.5198101997375488,
0.20992892980575562,
-0.19019398093223572,
0.38274985551834106,
-0.4416235685348511,
-0.2825590968132019,
-0.014838687144219875,
1.0236879587173462,
0.8955819606781006,
0.298758327960968,
-0.11381707340478897,
0.11800989508628845,
-0.00394973112270236,
0.26706212759017944,
-0.6986305117607117,
-0.2909500002861023,
0.09634952247142792,
-0.7875684499740601,
-0.3074309229850769,
0.22260749340057373,
-0.9967764616012573,
-0.4784150719642639,
-0.6559610962867737,
0.11520124226808548,
-0.23309306800365448,
-0.4509281814098358,
0.11502282321453094,
-0.29248398542404175,
0.32012179493904114,
0.9084429144859314,
-0.5222073197364807,
0.9707427620887756,
0.9749214053153992,
0.5693894624710083,
-0.47291556000709534,
-0.24531014263629913,
-0.9645993709564209,
-0.48115792870521545,
-0.1376485973596573,
0.7041096687316895,
-0.8314967751502991,
-0.681355357170105,
-0.10076432675123215,
-0.059609171003103256,
-0.3385954797267914,
-0.9749128818511963,
0.5768062472343445,
-0.1451389342546463,
0.2984556257724762,
-0.1489359736442566,
-0.39534494280815125,
0.05854180455207825,
0.32694071531295776,
-0.3975120782852173,
1.0309271812438965,
0.3289298117160797,
-0.5558016300201416,
0.369316428899765,
-0.7347632646560669,
0.05848388001322746,
0.106540247797966,
-0.2788155972957611,
-0.21002474427223206,
0.05830366164445877,
0.1122964471578598,
0.24584409594535828,
-0.7543951869010925,
0.3504442870616913,
-0.493832528591156,
-0.25655537843704224,
0.7201012372970581,
-0.6548824310302734,
0.9246628880500793,
0.24820491671562195,
-0.14600127935409546,
0.035952579230070114,
-0.8269878625869751,
0.31234443187713623,
-0.28479158878326416,
0.06265746802091599,
-0.05459200218319893,
-0.18225835263729095,
0.1772216111421585,
0.15637503564357758,
0.013610283844172955,
-0.7708171010017395,
-0.13392925262451172,
-0.08063795417547226,
0.17167066037654877,
0.7056162357330322,
0.29386281967163086,
0.2021595984697342,
-0.48374322056770325,
0.37132710218429565,
0.07133030146360397,
0.3243451714515686,
-0.2871303856372833,
-0.5475342869758606,
-0.6984279155731201,
-0.5053137540817261,
-0.06684763729572296,
0.340398907661438,
-0.16593734920024872,
0.7530093193054199,
-0.48075687885284424,
-0.6802360415458679,
-0.5184012055397034,
-0.05109604075551033,
0.7811200022697449,
0.5683990120887756,
0.24511930346488953,
-0.9425320625305176,
-0.20605462789535522,
-0.7455530762672424,
-0.35410523414611816,
-0.21384111046791077,
-0.1338888704776764,
0.7949071526527405,
0.3068934381008148,
0.06241863593459129,
1.212785005569458,
-0.712522029876709,
-0.21552641689777374,
-0.05657124146819115,
0.5500454902648926,
0.10888716578483582,
0.49031463265419006,
0.3735797703266144,
-0.5673045516014099,
-0.5964515209197998,
-0.21110711991786957,
-0.6355885863304138,
-0.33692851662635803,
-0.044287312775850296,
0.01029788888990879,
-0.10644539445638657,
0.43962419033050537,
-0.6131753325462341,
0.2989502251148224,
0.27694669365882874,
-0.3577096164226532,
0.7813969254493713,
0.023034168407320976,
0.47013911604881287,
-0.8202989101409912,
0.12102983891963959,
-0.11328025162220001,
-0.4489981532096863,
-0.37728920578956604,
-0.18871358036994934,
-0.1864737719297409,
-0.5359298586845398,
-0.6963343024253845,
0.6206620931625366,
-0.14065803587436676,
-0.4849819839000702,
0.271344929933548,
0.336468368768692,
0.02444428764283657,
0.8457592129707336,
0.16889221966266632,
0.9468251466751099,
0.3363080620765686,
-0.558681070804596,
0.5671109557151794,
0.8461646437644958,
-0.5624820590019226,
1.2886778116226196,
-0.8013689517974854,
0.4667624533176422,
0.31174713373184204,
0.524178147315979,
-1.016205906867981,
-0.12755154073238373,
0.1695157289505005,
-0.6250343322753906,
-0.2503727972507477,
-0.18065808713436127,
-0.49135923385620117,
-0.029316548258066177,
-0.23019084334373474,
0.4900854825973511,
0.43306100368499756,
-0.6236249804496765,
0.36977362632751465,
0.348591148853302,
-0.3545663356781006,
-0.09562966227531433,
-0.04110441356897354,
0.14521446824073792,
-0.031530044972896576,
-0.5576081871986389,
0.06899233907461166,
-0.40818554162979126,
-0.49094951152801514,
-0.29032135009765625,
-0.04877498745918274,
-0.07677967101335526,
0.11671902984380722,
0.460152268409729,
0.16685308516025543,
-0.058913469314575195,
-0.21326254308223724,
-0.24696451425552368,
-0.34613463282585144,
0.37021806836128235,
-0.0041773817501962185,
0.6979110240936279,
-0.2488144040107727,
-0.6088928580284119,
-0.6209912300109863,
0.4199727773666382,
0.8561680316925049,
-0.20376132428646088,
0.36471325159072876,
0.20151697099208832,
-0.020750703290104866,
0.10565429925918579,
-0.45186325907707214,
-0.01873035915195942,
-0.4370530843734741,
0.07473684847354889,
-0.49191614985466003,
-0.6165624856948853,
0.3302031457424164,
-0.318585604429245,
0.008064249530434608,
0.18191362917423248,
0.7685503363609314,
0.14322659373283386,
0.9374732971191406,
0.07312774658203125,
0.09624119102954865,
0.0369686596095562,
-0.18396735191345215,
0.16001924872398376,
-1.0228285789489746,
-0.37264296412467957,
-0.6708550453186035,
-0.06793519109487534,
-0.46543219685554504,
-0.5922342538833618,
0.4979233741760254,
-0.34917929768562317,
-0.35066795349121094,
0.46518340706825256,
-0.34336549043655396,
0.2586553990840912,
0.7335914969444275,
0.04474610090255737,
0.4825064241886139,
-0.42994388937950134,
-0.29588598012924194,
-0.26959115266799927,
-0.3381674885749817,
-0.6258115172386169,
1.270848035812378,
0.2820373475551605,
0.6222652196884155,
0.24349823594093323,
0.5875079035758972,
0.4819546639919281,
0.31827807426452637,
-0.6849861741065979,
0.8515591025352478,
0.22735455632209778,
-0.44164371490478516,
-0.21755537390708923,
-0.341329962015152,
-0.5645629167556763,
0.2983894646167755,
0.0075957393273711205,
-0.8173959255218506,
0.17986921966075897,
-0.21166139841079712,
-0.4835790991783142,
-0.2750760316848755,
-0.7682214379310608,
0.9443156123161316,
-0.08481715619564056,
-0.46628132462501526,
-0.522781491279602,
-0.6883085370063782,
0.1299968659877777,
0.05854227766394615,
-0.11031732708215714,
-0.22526927292346954,
0.16467830538749695,
0.6892110109329224,
-0.7033108472824097,
0.9706586003303528,
-0.40847262740135193,
-0.0050700693391263485,
0.21065790951251984,
-0.042472388595342636,
0.0291400495916605,
0.456022709608078,
-0.0678086057305336,
0.14630334079265594,
0.09048881381750107,
-0.18039630353450775,
-0.691835880279541,
0.6957716345787048,
-0.9643635153770447,
-0.3584119975566864,
-0.5344390273094177,
-0.2249210625886917,
-0.5023181438446045,
0.04615085572004318,
0.007046616170555353,
0.9268801212310791,
-0.9799018502235413,
0.29949021339416504,
0.577822744846344,
-0.5284231305122375,
0.23866593837738037,
0.7736172676086426,
0.14756032824516296,
-0.7283514142036438,
0.4917883574962616,
-0.5198306441307068,
0.5212889909744263,
0.3390544354915619,
0.00720122130587697,
-0.42412179708480835,
0.026185648515820503,
-0.25377997756004333,
-0.11307119578123093,
-0.6741095781326294,
-0.26045289635658264,
-0.8059313297271729,
-0.03601409122347832,
-0.5487093925476074,
0.029809964820742607,
-0.46347686648368835,
-0.46571362018585205,
-0.07643795758485794,
0.1433572769165039,
-0.02155996300280094,
0.33384761214256287,
0.16968931257724762,
0.24607062339782715,
-0.8095842599868774,
0.5029633641242981,
0.5352097749710083,
0.45531797409057617,
-0.16431522369384766,
-0.38615769147872925,
0.058899201452732086,
0.09577525407075882,
-0.6637946367263794,
-0.4024665951728821,
0.3429569602012634,
0.33220261335372925,
0.6368064880371094,
0.5475202202796936,
0.46343550086021423,
0.5060030221939087,
-0.5243422389030457,
0.9322769045829773,
0.45986437797546387,
-0.9607698917388916,
0.3855607807636261,
-0.5298498868942261,
0.3362884819507599,
0.9374516010284424,
0.00947571825236082,
-0.5337178111076355,
-0.35430067777633667,
-0.8417182564735413,
-0.22643138468265533,
0.8889433145523071,
0.20558226108551025,
0.215065598487854,
-0.18768121302127838,
-0.2472231090068817,
0.4785749614238739,
0.4646819829940796,
-0.22682683169841766,
-0.3305162191390991,
-0.24327434599399567,
-0.020262835547327995,
-0.13505849242210388,
-0.028881190344691277,
-0.4204701781272888,
-0.17778761684894562,
0.18280921876430511,
-0.35892459750175476,
0.6000155210494995,
0.19619567692279816,
-0.24044278264045715,
-0.10739340633153915,
0.4026230275630951,
0.4836506247520447,
0.4222332835197449,
-0.5816975831985474,
-0.20993320643901825,
-0.03062792494893074,
-0.32303082942962646,
0.15818342566490173,
0.03557274118065834,
0.29942524433135986,
-0.022287460044026375,
0.29470691084861755,
0.7935717105865479,
0.6708267331123352,
-0.8737022876739502,
0.8197923898696899,
-0.35180142521858215,
-0.26570993661880493,
-0.6859866976737976,
0.22197577357292175,
-0.25218936800956726,
-0.05108097940683365,
0.27050986886024475,
0.4821805953979492,
0.32056334614753723,
-0.6935542225837708,
0.3077664077281952,
0.3324117064476013,
-0.5447234511375427,
-0.3553496301174164,
0.39688533544540405,
0.7723751664161682,
-0.5655505657196045,
0.6581266522407532,
-0.13427503407001495,
-0.5000159740447998,
0.3167833387851715,
0.1836298257112503,
1.2168700695037842,
0.07634910941123962,
0.4739507734775543,
0.4268863797187805,
-0.3414512276649475,
0.23643368482589722,
-0.08433767408132553,
-0.5275247693061829,
-0.6923032999038696,
-0.10789413750171661,
-0.39797770977020264,
-1.089166283607483,
-0.014424096792936325,
-1.0688282251358032,
0.3088955283164978,
-0.5896883010864258,
-0.0651627779006958,
0.040971025824546814,
0.27240437269210815,
-0.8941324949264526,
0.2018594741821289,
-0.15597200393676758,
1.0754914283752441,
-0.7192375063896179,
0.483383446931839,
0.47013503313064575,
-0.2454739212989807,
-0.3616507053375244,
0.010633694939315319,
0.2444131225347519,
-0.5823037028312683,
0.8766323924064636,
0.3613252341747284,
-0.34438130259513855,
-0.01673888973891735,
-0.3793320059776306,
-0.33838769793510437,
1.0401989221572876,
0.08442863076925278,
-0.35838690400123596,
0.32576707005500793,
0.2952064573764801,
0.4989604949951172,
-0.6613860726356506,
0.7389589548110962,
0.7899255752563477,
0.3842500150203705,
-0.09091860055923462,
-1.3076369762420654,
-0.06761378794908524,
-0.5227920413017273,
-0.3491969108581543,
-0.05432501062750816,
-0.948796808719635,
0.5128529071807861,
0.045017242431640625,
-0.1497744619846344,
0.5114268660545349,
0.08967411518096924,
0.26652687788009644,
0.5213164687156677,
0.6132456064224243,
0.7830719351768494,
0.502265989780426,
-0.21411678194999695,
0.918674886226654,
-0.21608605980873108,
0.24746866524219513,
1.4415234327316284,
-0.7033529877662659,
0.6825786828994751,
0.16480930149555206,
-0.17990566790103912,
0.46037715673446655,
0.22741487622261047,
0.07515423744916916,
0.6022170782089233,
0.12000051140785217,
-0.46276718378067017,
-0.42301830649375916,
-0.2617165148258209,
-0.06044990196824074,
0.7204429507255554,
0.22178800404071808,
-0.07688059657812119,
-0.2634783685207367,
-0.07025083154439926,
-0.17226335406303406,
0.40668320655822754,
0.07392968982458115,
1.0981497764587402,
0.04959547147154808,
-1.1981613636016846,
0.6052114963531494,
-0.20527200400829315,
0.24306561052799225,
-0.2241508662700653,
-0.10745903104543686,
-0.27731797099113464,
0.41966456174850464,
0.09584376215934753,
-0.5427130460739136,
-0.022369416430592537,
0.04010521620512009,
0.16411589086055756,
-0.6042494177818298,
0.38208428025245667,
-0.10955622792243958,
0.024542395025491714,
0.1745280772447586,
0.6239863038063049,
0.13559120893478394,
-0.06444374471902847,
-0.8113524317741394,
0.06270338594913483,
-0.23073123395442963,
0.0805140808224678,
0.2686000466346741,
0.5294748544692993,
0.08057858049869537,
0.8461881875991821,
0.5352984666824341,
-0.234036386013031,
-0.2288096696138382,
0.395762175321579,
0.9458259344100952,
-0.5964771509170532,
-0.4279736876487732,
-0.24656562507152557,
0.4477948248386383,
-0.4790460765361786,
-0.6454967260360718,
0.6543040871620178,
0.8435534834861755,
0.6038421392440796,
-0.19017258286476135,
0.8784159421920776,
0.02880033850669861,
1.0318875312805176,
-0.30050086975097656,
0.422885924577713,
-0.06478792428970337,
0.2309906929731369,
-0.6156961917877197,
-1.0577373504638672,
0.118696428835392,
0.5469455122947693,
-0.274593323469162,
-0.04211924225091934,
0.864159882068634,
0.807478666305542,
-0.1286981999874115,
0.3462405204772949,
0.40301138162612915,
-0.130183607339859,
0.4284749925136566,
0.46673116087913513,
1.069244623184204,
-0.4443286657333374,
0.3860343396663666,
0.08823326230049133,
-0.36942246556282043,
-0.4196374714374542,
-0.7550879120826721,
-1.159799337387085,
-0.5310362577438354,
-0.6279982924461365,
-0.14310497045516968,
0.028763120993971825,
1.2442909479141235,
0.7861120700836182,
-0.7896885275840759,
-0.4316158890724182,
-0.15829192101955414,
-0.39198458194732666,
-0.3722669780254364,
-0.33342239260673523,
0.0177401602268219,
-0.4408174157142639,
-0.9258124828338623,
0.38525739312171936,
0.47420206665992737,
-0.269226610660553,
-0.3103179335594177,
-0.3786635398864746,
0.11759211868047714,
0.11966012418270111,
0.47809433937072754,
0.06765527278184891,
-0.5321131348609924,
-0.38161882758140564,
0.15673509240150452,
-0.11178985983133316,
0.11879555135965347,
1.1241710186004639,
-1.0602353811264038,
0.4959549605846405,
0.2453685700893402,
0.34840258955955505,
0.3158406913280487,
0.24103692173957825,
1.0848655700683594,
-0.7981823682785034,
0.2551657259464264,
0.24504293501377106,
0.181070014834404,
0.4978806972503662,
0.03548043593764305,
0.5783436298370361,
0.29238805174827576,
-0.4506767690181732,
-0.745414674282074,
0.32077422738075256,
-1.3017661571502686,
0.2559315264225006,
0.9633344411849976,
-0.4423193335533142,
0.18574784696102142,
-0.5107756853103638,
-0.3992406129837036,
-0.09628414362668991,
-0.7863178849220276,
0.49353671073913574,
0.5161685347557068,
-0.08731046319007874,
-0.33515653014183044,
-0.2822873294353485,
0.5112352967262268,
0.5258035659790039,
-0.8631477952003479,
0.48193302750587463,
0.7677742838859558,
0.2051781713962555,
0.3196878135204315,
0.9468659162521362,
-0.3597113788127899,
0.5273780226707458,
0.07958997040987015,
-0.3455861210823059,
0.06710410118103027,
-0.2509351074695587,
0.013641620054841042,
0.01671854965388775,
0.027985479682683945,
-0.23122012615203857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11218v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11218v1 | Building another Spanish dictionary, this time with GPT-4 | 2024-06-17T05:25:56 | 2024-06-17T05:25:56 | Miguel Ortega-Martín, Óscar García-Sierra, Alfonso Ardoiz, Juan Carlos Armenteros, Ignacio Garrido, Jorge Álvarez, Camilo Torrón, Iñigo Galdeano, Ignacio Arranz, Oleg Vorontsov, Adrián Alonso | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present the "Spanish Built Factual Freectianary 2.0" (Spanish-BFF-2) as
the second iteration of an AI-generated Spanish dictionary. Previously, we
developed the inaugural version of this unique free dictionary employing GPT-3.
In this study, we aim to improve the dictionary by using GPT-4-turbo instead.
Furthermore, we explore improvements made to the initial version and compare
the performance of both models. | [
-0.38058173656463623,
-0.6232157945632935,
0.4881759583950043,
0.45886218547821045,
-0.3644258677959442,
0.3929310441017151,
-0.021845892071723938,
-0.8323909044265747,
0.4500991106033325,
0.2275986522436142,
-0.6326119303703308,
-0.18323639035224915,
-0.6855468153953552,
0.29930442571640015,
-0.2613006830215454,
1.272695779800415,
-0.1015988439321518,
-0.04977915436029434,
0.09988556802272797,
-0.028406325727701187,
-0.3920708894729614,
-0.5126302242279053,
-0.7906463146209717,
-0.3898010849952698,
0.34969621896743774,
0.4629857540130615,
1.409161925315857,
0.7683094143867493,
0.6207378506660461,
0.3018549084663391,
0.3444439470767975,
-0.24152016639709473,
-0.3835258185863495,
-0.16610834002494812,
-0.3695757985115051,
-0.18198224902153015,
-0.31886765360832214,
0.10984261333942413,
0.18024642765522003,
0.0789477676153183,
-0.248724564909935,
-0.08662526309490204,
-0.19923095405101776,
0.6858845949172974,
-0.08937206119298935,
0.5437994599342346,
-0.7701417207717896,
-0.014519658870995045,
-0.2724190056324005,
-0.10346927493810654,
0.1522614061832428,
-0.5650773644447327,
0.2943294048309326,
-0.6286693215370178,
0.7360787987709045,
-0.07920472323894501,
1.2223517894744873,
0.5427356958389282,
-0.38523009419441223,
-0.5205276012420654,
-0.33163464069366455,
0.26408815383911133,
-0.39903682470321655,
0.8602715134620667,
0.3983052670955658,
0.25902077555656433,
-0.27521082758903503,
-1.2050294876098633,
-0.6897374987602234,
-0.6244987845420837,
0.12456275522708893,
0.2583719789981842,
-0.16387253999710083,
0.18198539316654205,
-0.2767133116722107,
0.45379042625427246,
-0.8058496117591858,
0.06390993297100067,
-0.5597180724143982,
-0.27455154061317444,
0.2874360680580139,
-0.3194899260997772,
0.20819811522960663,
-0.08003893494606018,
-0.28526413440704346,
0.0033290679566562176,
-0.96218341588974,
-0.4109378457069397,
0.48643383383750916,
0.17411622405052185,
0.027675025165081024,
0.7389532923698425,
-0.12060091644525528,
0.10665277391672134,
0.0005626356578432024,
-0.29916873574256897,
0.5325314998626709,
-0.42341718077659607,
-0.24326463043689728,
0.035061873495578766,
0.650861918926239,
0.6380408406257629,
0.38006848096847534,
-0.45231714844703674,
-0.13756360113620758,
0.12512053549289703,
0.16444197297096252,
-0.9916197657585144,
-0.6832581162452698,
0.20669420063495636,
-0.17364773154258728,
-0.5033956170082092,
0.2494616061449051,
-0.33701151609420776,
0.012233112938702106,
0.12128154188394547,
0.2886049449443817,
-0.3734583854675293,
-0.4082208275794983,
0.03365105763077736,
-0.32775136828422546,
-0.023679200559854507,
0.11225161701440811,
-1.0368536710739136,
0.42792314291000366,
0.9085659980773926,
1.0967462062835693,
0.179172545671463,
-0.22713668644428253,
-0.43681687116622925,
0.07134857028722763,
-0.5046293139457703,
1.0145070552825928,
0.12280477583408356,
-0.7846446633338928,
-0.14463500678539276,
0.28308385610580444,
0.47596725821495056,
-0.4489913880825043,
0.5607166886329651,
-0.48610275983810425,
0.3933449387550354,
-0.7273989319801331,
-0.20195360481739044,
-0.3034384846687317,
0.12510700523853302,
-0.8984654545783997,
1.4386111497879028,
0.5749666094779968,
-0.659892737865448,
0.599384605884552,
-0.598152220249176,
-0.5277562141418457,
0.47570672631263733,
-0.2227831482887268,
0.06771836429834366,
0.1887146532535553,
-0.12389733642339706,
0.10342101007699966,
-0.4229726493358612,
0.25060153007507324,
-0.1456742137670517,
-0.1294078826904297,
-0.3857106566429138,
-0.20745548605918884,
0.7206341624259949,
0.12415789067745209,
-0.5694549679756165,
-0.3337610363960266,
-0.6239394545555115,
-0.17104563117027283,
-0.061968907713890076,
-0.4906841218471527,
-0.0949474573135376,
0.45938238501548767,
-0.09877055883407593,
0.5010906457901001,
0.5265985727310181,
-0.7145329117774963,
0.06233692169189453,
-0.9195290207862854,
0.019710468128323555,
0.6855055689811707,
-0.033253610134124756,
0.02677329257130623,
-0.427406370639801,
0.5178623795509338,
-0.46894779801368713,
-0.14724065363407135,
0.5396436452865601,
-1.1244661808013916,
-0.6895660758018494,
-0.33772537112236023,
-0.08041597902774811,
1.0676443576812744,
-0.8082529902458191,
0.00818789005279541,
-0.21564824879169464,
-0.5604746341705322,
-0.14763523638248444,
0.37517669796943665,
0.6010376811027527,
0.6042202115058899,
0.44750142097473145,
0.05646278336644173,
-0.9455825090408325,
-0.953083872795105,
0.0031888585072010756,
-0.6008250117301941,
-0.11958970874547958,
0.09988446533679962,
0.7338680028915405,
-0.19494354724884033,
0.8986241817474365,
-0.32505330443382263,
-0.21074755489826202,
-0.13529129326343536,
0.20488029718399048,
0.1443125456571579,
0.35878869891166687,
1.0557442903518677,
-0.41841939091682434,
-0.7738973498344421,
0.401959627866745,
-0.4452136158943176,
-0.17947612702846527,
0.3472583591938019,
-0.013698652386665344,
0.30806785821914673,
0.29097574949264526,
-0.47131070494651794,
0.22616302967071533,
0.5845802426338196,
-0.6993213891983032,
0.34571772813796997,
-0.2575651705265045,
0.0021554771810770035,
-1.037616491317749,
-0.3856091797351837,
-0.23625890910625458,
-0.2246614247560501,
-0.5048672556877136,
0.2301034927368164,
0.08067218959331512,
0.5699309706687927,
-0.41937345266342163,
0.6390686631202698,
-0.33756551146507263,
0.008280854672193527,
-0.33195221424102783,
-0.05284986272454262,
-0.2492525726556778,
0.27875587344169617,
0.14905492961406708,
1.0731327533721924,
0.21106956899166107,
-0.09764451533555984,
0.7858022451400757,
0.14024189114570618,
-0.18759790062904358,
0.33083003759384155,
-1.0083962678909302,
0.1420484334230423,
-0.16486239433288574,
0.0206318199634552,
-1.0713419914245605,
-0.413119375705719,
0.1609106957912445,
-0.44668108224868774,
0.10797393321990967,
-0.004182842094451189,
-0.6844552159309387,
-0.8708664774894714,
-0.4763241112232208,
0.007503879722207785,
0.5532293319702148,
-0.7255454659461975,
0.01872665248811245,
0.21364782750606537,
-0.3232761025428772,
-0.3130962550640106,
-1.0009716749191284,
0.02253446914255619,
0.18890103697776794,
-0.8413102030754089,
0.5707573294639587,
-0.16378626227378845,
-0.44620200991630554,
0.19659903645515442,
-0.13149093091487885,
-0.18913275003433228,
0.027643509209156036,
0.19545713067054749,
0.20077529549598694,
-0.3025653064250946,
-0.031770311295986176,
0.26670581102371216,
0.1710732877254486,
0.09425463527441025,
-0.18690600991249084,
0.38833701610565186,
-0.5760507583618164,
0.09538885951042175,
-0.18996652960777283,
0.3593659996986389,
0.3216122090816498,
-0.12589161098003387,
0.5782492756843567,
0.4311893880367279,
-0.3282893896102905,
0.1292710155248642,
-0.6911861300468445,
0.3095586895942688,
-0.5568411350250244,
0.39749303460121155,
-0.7392745018005371,
-1.102638840675354,
0.5815854072570801,
0.35485509037971497,
0.038930997252464294,
0.7275174856185913,
0.8678317666053772,
0.18723933398723602,
0.9832711219787598,
0.731406569480896,
0.22699972987174988,
0.17048239707946777,
-0.11588671803474426,
0.00961468555033207,
-0.35478782653808594,
-0.594103991985321,
-0.6291977763175964,
0.0369875431060791,
-0.7035222053527832,
-0.33764341473579407,
0.16815218329429626,
0.1175352931022644,
-0.20331893861293793,
0.4367130696773529,
-0.3831643760204315,
0.5736867189407349,
0.6830139756202698,
0.05041438713669777,
0.35376256704330444,
-0.10729237645864487,
-0.4535408020019531,
0.08145488053560257,
-0.3188254237174988,
-0.18205033242702484,
1.1387361288070679,
0.275663822889328,
0.07563130557537079,
0.6171638369560242,
0.6331245303153992,
-0.05912242829799652,
0.6857116222381592,
-0.9044057130813599,
0.21137291193008423,
-0.37361207604408264,
-0.9249178171157837,
-0.06555261462926865,
0.053704503923654556,
-0.45822659134864807,
0.17988349497318268,
0.23639139533042908,
-0.6488919258117676,
-0.0004426926898304373,
0.2348296344280243,
-0.38102391362190247,
0.042413849383592606,
-0.8196091651916504,
0.8987553715705872,
-0.3657550513744354,
-0.28405484557151794,
-0.09908642619848251,
-0.5936263203620911,
0.6113026738166809,
-0.29531314969062805,
0.14954550564289093,
-0.06138768419623375,
-0.3314407765865326,
0.6287943720817566,
-1.3030858039855957,
0.1285448968410492,
-0.26749083399772644,
-0.2528779208660126,
0.4715649485588074,
0.19448222219944,
0.6046056747436523,
0.5131036043167114,
-0.14424283802509308,
0.03171724081039429,
0.20719559490680695,
-0.23337604105472565,
-0.4061727821826935,
0.7817208766937256,
-0.822147011756897,
-0.45653003454208374,
-0.6011603474617004,
-0.2157837152481079,
-0.2096102386713028,
0.30394864082336426,
0.4122389256954193,
0.27789339423179626,
-0.5486012697219849,
0.07153333723545074,
0.19159413874149323,
0.16301321983337402,
0.5288392901420593,
0.6090108752250671,
-0.22410671412944794,
-0.6272343397140503,
0.7935563325881958,
0.08969306945800781,
0.05319782346487045,
0.3792911767959595,
0.30228954553604126,
-0.859691858291626,
-0.4158966839313507,
-0.3723274767398834,
0.40205880999565125,
-0.2280462384223938,
-0.16414886713027954,
-0.4023624062538147,
0.03774106130003929,
-0.6872434020042419,
-0.39190876483917236,
-0.49684467911720276,
-0.6109839677810669,
-0.16550444066524506,
-0.5069096088409424,
0.7110422849655151,
1.017458200454712,
-0.5256379246711731,
0.6268408894538879,
-0.42801597714424133,
0.6729039549827576,
0.5372578501701355,
0.6141607761383057,
-0.5348596572875977,
-0.3206341862678528,
-0.22954870760440826,
0.031341537833213806,
-0.1182306557893753,
-1.1366214752197266,
0.3028729259967804,
0.5856396555900574,
0.3387037217617035,
0.345702588558197,
-0.5711246728897095,
0.5681119561195374,
-0.6565166115760803,
0.9825209379196167,
0.08831620961427689,
-0.570553719997406,
0.5674530863761902,
-0.4502275288105011,
0.011458366177976131,
0.7706785202026367,
0.30811482667922974,
-0.11080551147460938,
-0.2910524904727936,
-0.7479668855667114,
-0.5346029996871948,
0.5731396675109863,
0.05342575162649155,
-0.03398483246564865,
-0.6684421300888062,
0.3261302411556244,
0.06452598422765732,
0.16416339576244354,
-0.5453402400016785,
-0.17410489916801453,
-1.0976905822753906,
-0.2721858322620392,
0.028630346059799194,
-0.4992806911468506,
0.29986655712127686,
-0.6127368211746216,
0.8984082341194153,
-0.07638555765151978,
0.13447622954845428,
0.12574802339076996,
-0.00484149856492877,
0.10333050787448883,
-0.11179405450820923,
0.620985209941864,
0.23985934257507324,
-0.5894967317581177,
0.016992036253213882,
0.020387446507811546,
-1.0251673460006714,
0.1552082598209381,
0.28619399666786194,
0.026684032753109932,
0.28427985310554504,
-0.0339469239115715,
0.7770900130271912,
0.1382344663143158,
-0.5852932929992676,
0.6867501735687256,
0.007584040053188801,
-0.7802790403366089,
-0.45578327775001526,
-0.11617700010538101,
0.04592204466462135,
0.2773060202598572,
0.08270122110843658,
-0.14183254539966583,
0.07780473679304123,
-0.6618260741233826,
0.37833818793296814,
0.5960052013397217,
-0.05309775099158287,
-0.4300295412540436,
0.855172872543335,
0.1426294445991516,
-0.20492129027843475,
0.4727528393268585,
-0.8543616533279419,
-0.6585308909416199,
0.4966500699520111,
0.852526843547821,
1.0598665475845337,
-0.5045415163040161,
0.4679105877876282,
0.542820394039154,
0.5177915096282959,
-0.641272246837616,
0.9885948300361633,
-0.03178032487630844,
-0.8482756018638611,
-0.3714110255241394,
-0.6975607872009277,
-0.29884010553359985,
0.10926897823810577,
-0.1372167468070984,
0.2859863042831421,
-0.7433528304100037,
0.07799051702022552,
-0.5010274052619934,
0.3043912351131439,
-0.6785710453987122,
0.3125428855419159,
-0.41069433093070984,
0.7940728068351746,
-0.4640180468559265,
1.1676571369171143,
0.6134695410728455,
-0.5373588800430298,
-1.0633333921432495,
-0.48772501945495605,
0.3210827112197876,
-0.9738671779632568,
0.5795628428459167,
-0.16840282082557678,
-0.41994285583496094,
0.17288684844970703,
-0.3224274516105652,
-1.2695176601409912,
1.1391465663909912,
0.026542559266090393,
-0.2730382978916168,
-0.1742970049381256,
0.0876176655292511,
0.6406583189964294,
0.059708379209041595,
0.1696438491344452,
0.8674669861793518,
0.6198002696037292,
0.23389528691768646,
-1.096450686454773,
-0.01680118963122368,
-0.5720468759536743,
0.10726942867040634,
0.10039446502923965,
-0.6404946446418762,
1.0494009256362915,
-0.2870083451271057,
-0.2641337811946869,
0.42206135392189026,
1.0303620100021362,
0.056266892701387405,
-0.2896318733692169,
0.2001202404499054,
0.8697655200958252,
0.9029874801635742,
-0.233902245759964,
0.9322106838226318,
-0.569401204586029,
0.2896139323711395,
1.4307591915130615,
-0.15072090923786163,
0.6236079335212708,
0.3523986339569092,
-0.22846528887748718,
0.6733731031417847,
0.5754051208496094,
-0.2533959150314331,
0.735683798789978,
-0.03300543501973152,
-0.44370171427726746,
0.42256247997283936,
0.13798482716083527,
-0.6250893473625183,
0.5187373161315918,
0.42701759934425354,
-0.1624927818775177,
-0.4352337121963501,
-0.23994986712932587,
0.5814391374588013,
-0.3030893802642822,
-0.06862650066614151,
0.40406090021133423,
-0.35201558470726013,
-0.7876624464988708,
0.6792818307876587,
0.4224550127983093,
0.7392193078994751,
-0.19752563536167145,
0.20212987065315247,
-0.41175249218940735,
-0.06184377148747444,
-0.22770154476165771,
-0.7302449941635132,
0.5294684767723083,
0.3085750341415405,
-0.06364639848470688,
-0.0013778952416032553,
0.2765308916568756,
-0.3627129793167114,
-0.5277884602546692,
0.10167040675878525,
0.7616356015205383,
0.26771533489227295,
-0.29351934790611267,
-0.490183025598526,
-0.25564950704574585,
0.04912390932440758,
-0.3610292971134186,
-0.23940478265285492,
0.3897836208343506,
-0.13403956592082977,
0.22345256805419922,
0.6519564986228943,
0.2736160159111023,
0.36654579639434814,
0.2930549681186676,
0.47693875432014465,
-0.4202538728713989,
-0.553569495677948,
-0.8966895341873169,
0.13863785564899445,
0.22400838136672974,
-0.5470589399337769,
0.5755350589752197,
0.9563769102096558,
0.9481826424598694,
-0.02205529995262623,
0.9615416526794434,
-0.6401513814926147,
0.6986610889434814,
-0.2537979483604431,
0.497884601354599,
-0.5509063601493835,
-0.006923949811607599,
-0.44380486011505127,
-0.7935769557952881,
-0.41495710611343384,
0.7404557466506958,
0.2820316255092621,
-0.029048051685094833,
1.0830409526824951,
1.1794257164001465,
0.048946429044008255,
0.17507492005825043,
-0.0038061956875026226,
0.4989585280418396,
0.563681960105896,
0.5631059408187866,
0.4546094238758087,
-0.45173609256744385,
0.6413825154304504,
-0.7064975500106812,
-0.590888500213623,
0.03801926225423813,
-0.9858425259590149,
-0.7705462574958801,
-0.5892404913902283,
0.2084933966398239,
-0.33000943064689636,
0.22075335681438446,
0.9700334668159485,
0.24002544581890106,
-0.6956661343574524,
-0.1431112140417099,
-0.6936517357826233,
0.050974804908037186,
0.058942925184965134,
-0.1513962298631668,
0.3168817460536957,
-0.10385734587907791,
-0.6639464497566223,
0.6969134211540222,
0.19630897045135498,
0.3973747491836548,
-0.06852444261312485,
-0.2741529047489166,
0.03449230268597603,
-0.013640262186527252,
0.7056078910827637,
0.6016902923583984,
-0.6894930005073547,
-0.8441615104675293,
-0.13015533983707428,
0.019359519705176353,
0.11569993942975998,
0.4706133306026459,
-0.9462084770202637,
0.21441365778446198,
0.6738329529762268,
0.38137102127075195,
0.48566898703575134,
0.004151409491896629,
0.47481483221054077,
-0.6088499426841736,
0.44804254174232483,
-0.1173957884311676,
0.3243120312690735,
0.32246020436286926,
-0.3885938823223114,
0.7772404551506042,
0.6562666893005371,
-0.4740939736366272,
-0.41574496030807495,
0.25496745109558105,
-1.0887186527252197,
-0.0787481889128685,
1.077893853187561,
0.5470326542854309,
0.0027171329129487276,
-0.2905708849430084,
-0.35491666197776794,
0.3452673852443695,
-0.37215280532836914,
0.3909187912940979,
0.8590725064277649,
-0.3972931206226349,
0.12086763978004456,
-0.6965265870094299,
0.918276309967041,
0.027332331985235214,
-0.599177360534668,
-0.5137492418289185,
0.6299982070922852,
0.5810766816139221,
-0.11958043277263641,
1.1758933067321777,
-0.24521784484386444,
0.480757474899292,
0.13308918476104736,
-0.1112518310546875,
-0.3305293023586273,
-0.648849606513977,
0.07365060597658157,
0.22381635010242462,
0.1924707293510437,
0.06949527561664581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11217v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11217v2 | WeatherQA: Can Multimodal Language Models Reason about Severe Weather? | 2024-06-17T05:23:18 | 2024-06-24T03:55:30 | Chengqian Ma, Zhanxiang Hua, Alexandra Anderson-Frey, Vikram Iyer, Xin Liu, Lianhui Qin | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, physics.ao-ph | Severe convective weather events, such as hail, tornadoes, and thunderstorms,
often occur quickly yet cause significant damage, costing billions of dollars
every year. This highlights the importance of forecasting severe weather
threats hours in advance to better prepare meteorologists and residents in
at-risk areas. Can modern large foundation models perform such forecasting?
Existing weather benchmarks typically focus only on predicting time-series
changes in certain weather parameters (e.g., temperature, moisture) with
text-only features. In this work, we introduce WeatherQA, the first multimodal
dataset designed for machines to reason about complex combinations of weather
parameters (a.k.a., ingredients) and predict severe weather in real-world
scenarios. The dataset includes over 8,000 (multi-images, text) pairs for
diverse severe weather events. Each pair contains rich information crucial for
forecasting -- the images describe the ingredients capturing environmental
instability, surface observations, and radar reflectivity, and the text
contains forecast analyses written by human experts. With WeatherQA, we
evaluate state-of-the-art vision language models, including GPT4, Claude3.5,
Gemini-1.5, and a fine-tuned Llama3-based VLM, by designing two challenging
tasks: (1) multi-choice QA for predicting affected area and (2) classification
of the development potential of severe convection. These tasks require deep
understanding of domain knowledge (e.g., atmospheric dynamics) and complex
reasoning over multimodal data (e.g., interactions between weather parameters).
We show a substantial gap between the strongest VLM, GPT4o, and human
reasoning. Our comprehensive case study with meteorologists further reveals the
weaknesses of the models, suggesting that better training and data integration
are necessary to bridge this gap. WeatherQA link:
https://github.com/chengqianma/WeatherQA. | [
-0.493115097284317,
-0.656715989112854,
0.69353187084198,
0.4979730248451233,
-0.12712576985359192,
-0.04007013142108917,
-0.07855484634637833,
-0.6002417802810669,
-0.2317694127559662,
0.4766847491264343,
-0.6973767280578613,
-0.3570041060447693,
-0.29670968651771545,
-0.14443737268447876,
-0.6131011843681335,
0.7211982011795044,
-0.22537188231945038,
-0.0320485383272171,
-0.316861093044281,
0.08161107450723648,
-0.23214025795459747,
-0.7274211645126343,
-0.22273346781730652,
-0.3026721179485321,
0.548684298992157,
0.39806196093559265,
1.0474355220794678,
0.11234812438488007,
0.37677571177482605,
0.2934257686138153,
0.09776049107313156,
0.3430791199207306,
-0.03342688828706741,
0.3549192249774933,
-0.16846613585948944,
-0.0806681364774704,
-0.11126095801591873,
-0.07440618425607681,
0.3845435678958893,
0.46335935592651367,
-0.2855195999145508,
0.021466320380568504,
-0.07771538197994232,
0.33879247307777405,
-0.6318970322608948,
0.0036129236686974764,
-0.4711317718029022,
-0.08232379704713821,
-0.2330877035856247,
-0.0840718001127243,
-0.21886761486530304,
0.1672467291355133,
0.322537899017334,
-0.33594217896461487,
0.3041684925556183,
0.018289484083652496,
0.7778244614601135,
0.445289671421051,
-0.8370133638381958,
0.047176118940114975,
-0.8365610241889954,
0.8069791197776794,
-0.6218572854995728,
0.8230940699577332,
0.24371419847011566,
0.5191351771354675,
-0.41856110095977783,
-0.5597136616706848,
-0.7950204014778137,
0.058182474225759506,
0.3580318093299866,
0.1863834410905838,
-0.13637356460094452,
-0.0689457431435585,
0.05719694867730141,
-0.061730802059173584,
-0.67351895570755,
-0.07466566562652588,
-0.18648841977119446,
-0.343044251203537,
0.4228801429271698,
0.4147486388683319,
0.2074723243713379,
-0.349550724029541,
-0.6908588409423828,
-0.05226831138134003,
-0.5403640270233154,
0.4431171715259552,
0.05525544658303261,
0.3111475110054016,
-0.3669050931930542,
0.5046106576919556,
-0.26618918776512146,
0.701239287853241,
-0.5892655253410339,
-0.28174036741256714,
0.093904048204422,
-0.30054330825805664,
-0.5269286632537842,
-0.1863919198513031,
0.7359665632247925,
0.34165623784065247,
0.038797393441200256,
-0.17876897752285004,
-0.25062206387519836,
0.16799074411392212,
0.14660689234733582,
-0.6862872838973999,
-0.41849324107170105,
0.28311121463775635,
-0.14515499770641327,
-0.5390105843544006,
-0.18897882103919983,
-0.7602782249450684,
-0.7355105876922607,
-0.6879697442054749,
0.4469791650772095,
-0.21821631491184235,
-0.2754562795162201,
0.2073974609375,
-0.24370545148849487,
-0.1559390425682068,
0.4806591868400574,
-0.3740829825401306,
0.14817631244659424,
0.29612091183662415,
0.44754788279533386,
0.21761660277843475,
-0.46737268567085266,
-0.33966538310050964,
-0.22404953837394714,
-0.16016609966754913,
1.020193099975586,
-0.7403873801231384,
-0.015052936971187592,
-0.27745798230171204,
-0.10449725389480591,
-0.018235186114907265,
-0.3791165351867676,
0.354358047246933,
-0.529044508934021,
0.13452619314193726,
0.03857433423399925,
0.05442548543214798,
-0.4573565125465393,
0.3066798150539398,
-0.5597336292266846,
0.9572588205337524,
0.09999442845582962,
-0.6874461770057678,
0.23298166692256927,
-0.08968324214220047,
-0.3541039526462555,
-0.24368973076343536,
-0.1282711923122406,
-0.39653339982032776,
-0.009716487489640713,
0.5922039747238159,
0.48467254638671875,
-0.8071139454841614,
0.5889617800712585,
-0.5523468852043152,
0.2004864662885666,
0.5618395209312439,
-0.7113613486289978,
0.4762054681777954,
0.25605371594429016,
-0.557183027267456,
0.2837734818458557,
-0.8415260910987854,
0.20074014365673065,
0.08645351976156235,
-0.31048092246055603,
-0.15351121127605438,
0.088118776679039,
0.46170106530189514,
0.5902383327484131,
0.030891692265868187,
-0.14373186230659485,
-0.005865444429218769,
-0.18914061784744263,
0.4986761212348938,
0.7756221890449524,
-0.12359709292650223,
0.2780652344226837,
-0.42794325947761536,
0.6981980204582214,
0.41646474599838257,
0.41908296942710876,
-0.052129171788692474,
-0.6926246285438538,
-0.7157431244850159,
-0.2293040007352829,
0.09404852986335754,
0.6726315021514893,
-0.9078480005264282,
-0.42271485924720764,
0.0008770412532612681,
-0.7635840177536011,
-0.20949684083461761,
0.14713315665721893,
0.3530430793762207,
0.4075181186199188,
0.5686385035514832,
0.33015698194503784,
-0.9945834875106812,
-0.6635295748710632,
-0.0029317752923816442,
0.09344921261072159,
0.1745285987854004,
0.30947446823120117,
0.3648199439048767,
-0.4211180508136749,
0.8529720902442932,
-0.1878080517053604,
0.11755409091711044,
-0.22418546676635742,
0.04515624791383743,
0.3013898730278015,
0.1269093155860901,
0.6844930648803711,
-1.0742173194885254,
0.05839807912707329,
-0.21894073486328125,
-0.6633188128471375,
-0.1545737236738205,
-0.048760924488306046,
-0.0794297531247139,
0.05416424944996834,
0.17901387810707092,
-0.6580640077590942,
0.45706450939178467,
0.9473062753677368,
-0.5981495976448059,
0.8091762661933899,
0.11368703097105026,
0.09678056091070175,
-0.9002066254615784,
-0.1789083033800125,
0.28088614344596863,
-0.34841135144233704,
-0.5637747049331665,
0.2703125476837158,
-0.14025041460990906,
-0.34417787194252014,
-0.5504659414291382,
0.680171549320221,
-0.12983182072639465,
0.19512297213077545,
-0.10581329464912415,
-0.23166581988334656,
0.2654244005680084,
0.38441187143325806,
-0.04996475577354431,
0.3450111746788025,
0.7056125998497009,
-0.658901035785675,
0.726706326007843,
-0.010117298923432827,
-0.5030628442764282,
-0.014425231143832207,
-0.45051610469818115,
-0.07648330181837082,
-0.10697832703590393,
0.30138450860977173,
-0.7408508062362671,
-0.37082019448280334,
0.34366288781166077,
-0.2689819037914276,
-0.23794184625148773,
-0.014901614747941494,
-0.42685064673423767,
-0.27824899554252625,
-0.05191652849316597,
0.4506393074989319,
0.043363310396671295,
-0.5869378447532654,
0.9594274759292603,
0.28227078914642334,
-0.13944366574287415,
-0.5402492880821228,
-0.5618909001350403,
0.21369177103042603,
-0.033326562494039536,
-0.6779239773750305,
0.3899642825126648,
-0.2139110416173935,
-0.5187662839889526,
0.03698376193642616,
-0.21537718176841736,
-0.2751164734363556,
0.3643210232257843,
0.6903751492500305,
0.2128923237323761,
-0.2247159779071808,
0.22649282217025757,
-0.14434096217155457,
0.016895078122615814,
0.09705479443073273,
-0.32127779722213745,
0.5086337327957153,
-0.18440847098827362,
-0.01857471466064453,
-0.29762211441993713,
0.45221585035324097,
0.8797497749328613,
-0.29231777787208557,
0.6821027398109436,
0.46980196237564087,
-0.8719460964202881,
-0.22396668791770935,
-0.5085177421569824,
-0.03302457928657532,
-0.3976547420024872,
0.06885959953069687,
-0.568466067314148,
-0.4921792149543762,
0.40127110481262207,
0.11754234880208969,
-0.12079998105764389,
0.375660240650177,
0.46479153633117676,
-0.17325788736343384,
1.3392307758331299,
0.48370450735092163,
-0.05928740277886391,
0.2696031332015991,
-0.09740974754095078,
0.04045283794403076,
-0.36703425645828247,
-0.5034437775611877,
-0.405851274728775,
-0.1487767994403839,
-0.184303417801857,
-0.562285840511322,
0.36519694328308105,
0.05103611201047897,
-0.35178160667419434,
-0.00342085980810225,
-0.2615436613559723,
0.16933481395244598,
0.5016734004020691,
0.35486912727355957,
0.05232097581028938,
-0.17189551889896393,
-0.24950547516345978,
0.059876151382923126,
-0.5511877536773682,
-0.32017409801483154,
0.7594872713088989,
0.344462126493454,
0.8531996607780457,
0.28222987055778503,
0.2907223105430603,
0.18435442447662354,
0.18681137263774872,
-0.660936176776886,
0.370411217212677,
-0.011671108193695545,
-0.6932165026664734,
-0.19161687791347504,
-0.469618558883667,
-0.6190376281738281,
0.278667151927948,
-0.5891177654266357,
-0.25437822937965393,
0.2813282608985901,
0.11316359788179398,
-0.2714866101741791,
0.08165420591831207,
-0.6422610878944397,
0.9344006776809692,
-0.39028942584991455,
-0.046569038182497025,
-0.15004141628742218,
-0.4730285406112671,
0.2860477864742279,
-0.03643767163157463,
0.8449833989143372,
-0.23414744436740875,
0.16925682127475739,
0.503013551235199,
-0.4493328630924225,
0.9444943070411682,
-0.2600061595439911,
-0.0942859798669815,
0.2525422275066376,
0.14304956793785095,
0.36336639523506165,
0.24559906125068665,
-0.12375733256340027,
-0.003770548151805997,
0.21970900893211365,
-0.4956492483615875,
-0.5797244906425476,
0.6969239115715027,
-0.9591363668441772,
-0.49231231212615967,
-0.40609800815582275,
-0.4027118980884552,
-0.38067957758903503,
0.1714172512292862,
0.18915678560733795,
0.9039345383644104,
0.13339106738567352,
0.1370011419057846,
0.3434690833091736,
0.10337116569280624,
0.17685125768184662,
0.46333298087120056,
-0.4034828543663025,
-0.41940730810165405,
0.9496390223503113,
0.059769272804260254,
-0.19927337765693665,
0.45664775371551514,
0.531920850276947,
-0.06528754532337189,
-0.67876797914505,
-0.41358309984207153,
-0.1742449402809143,
-0.8149657249450684,
-0.4901081621646881,
-0.5879395604133606,
-0.17376808822155,
-0.3125169277191162,
0.022541599348187447,
-0.10987538844347,
-0.2968597710132599,
-0.28039607405662537,
-0.03410821408033371,
0.1093674972653389,
0.6476120352745056,
0.2650527358055115,
0.008131545968353748,
-0.9347008466720581,
0.48711857199668884,
0.4440860152244568,
0.029594620689749718,
-0.057269901037216187,
-0.27521610260009766,
-0.1437305361032486,
0.3367071747779846,
-0.3345411717891693,
-0.7782326936721802,
0.39539119601249695,
0.23809440433979034,
0.4602702558040619,
0.2995895743370056,
0.26398372650146484,
0.7494887113571167,
-0.28021594882011414,
0.7420781850814819,
0.119154192507267,
-1.0587221384048462,
0.5877471566200256,
-0.2396695762872696,
0.37989702820777893,
-0.02362184226512909,
0.27813008427619934,
-0.4310539662837982,
-0.4708499014377594,
-0.4004855155944824,
-0.7375500202178955,
0.49901652336120605,
0.13399015367031097,
-0.11037735641002655,
0.07268483191728592,
0.04018702730536461,
0.1526724100112915,
0.03516162559390068,
-0.5501662492752075,
0.07583058625459671,
-0.7491180896759033,
-0.23907232284545898,
-0.23082511126995087,
-0.2213459014892578,
-0.1783580631017685,
-0.15737411379814148,
0.5052151083946228,
-0.2330586463212967,
-0.06307382136583328,
0.24789349734783173,
0.0023799033369868994,
-0.011863314546644688,
0.43305444717407227,
0.841917097568512,
0.6335558891296387,
-0.054432258009910583,
0.4896092712879181,
0.24381159245967865,
-0.24692343175411224,
0.06800408661365509,
0.2952720820903778,
0.12842023372650146,
0.000911712646484375,
0.534692645072937,
0.7546371817588806,
0.513649046421051,
-0.9694868922233582,
0.6233002543449402,
-0.2721509039402008,
-0.22983136773109436,
-0.3084232807159424,
-0.08975909650325775,
-0.07875484973192215,
0.6599494218826294,
0.46694642305374146,
0.6377566456794739,
0.28367310762405396,
-0.6119275093078613,
-0.09415321052074432,
0.16843850910663605,
-0.3577443063259125,
-0.6055945158004761,
0.7768703103065491,
0.23660477995872498,
0.25575000047683716,
0.6044983863830566,
0.1359153538942337,
-0.7271898984909058,
0.8136026263237,
0.39459776878356934,
0.37802648544311523,
-0.1654365360736847,
0.17156682908535004,
-0.00046330285840667784,
0.40636682510375977,
-0.015139702707529068,
0.6977441310882568,
0.08638028055429459,
-0.9907700419425964,
-0.29217419028282166,
-0.7524486184120178,
-0.5267677903175354,
0.20059610903263092,
-0.3003981411457062,
0.3258209824562073,
-0.6281341910362244,
-0.3210637867450714,
0.30601149797439575,
-0.4002254903316498,
-1.0327231884002686,
0.6816489100456238,
0.6459743976593018,
0.9444090723991394,
-0.8057525753974915,
0.5775249600410461,
0.9227764010429382,
-0.15533722937107086,
-0.8674976229667664,
-0.19429701566696167,
0.26285818219184875,
-0.5616675615310669,
0.5782033801078796,
0.2839222550392151,
-0.23231424391269684,
-0.2686895430088043,
-0.6248803734779358,
-0.7506577372550964,
0.7934073805809021,
0.4475190341472626,
-0.6063779592514038,
-0.3112524151802063,
-0.035080790519714355,
0.26785004138946533,
-0.15014223754405975,
0.06481855362653732,
0.1069081649184227,
0.6016300320625305,
0.014855774119496346,
-0.9016919136047363,
0.13133938610553741,
-0.35934191942214966,
-0.21621735394001007,
0.3718266785144806,
-0.33893999457359314,
0.8390854597091675,
-0.5713810324668884,
-0.22483709454536438,
0.03923904523253441,
0.40750181674957275,
-0.0526268407702446,
0.7692010402679443,
0.6274020075798035,
0.667787492275238,
0.5687352418899536,
-0.18137028813362122,
0.994966447353363,
-0.08036722987890244,
0.14716416597366333,
0.9798580408096313,
-0.1449502408504486,
0.8571422696113586,
0.3439085781574249,
-0.18957115709781647,
0.686468780040741,
0.6890063285827637,
0.2816261649131775,
0.7006927728652954,
-0.13858363032341003,
-0.3503980040550232,
-0.9490633606910706,
-0.2197321355342865,
-0.41684871912002563,
0.6889832019805908,
0.557121217250824,
-0.047287438064813614,
-0.20123200118541718,
0.4692148268222809,
-0.14853137731552124,
-0.13090695440769196,
-0.21132422983646393,
0.5194123387336731,
0.16930466890335083,
-0.46095404028892517,
0.553572952747345,
0.16882270574569702,
0.2411506175994873,
-0.40223339200019836,
0.09442733228206635,
0.13996897637844086,
0.16306249797344208,
-0.5018653273582458,
-0.8889899253845215,
0.19073832035064697,
-0.18845826387405396,
-0.4160207211971283,
-0.07120490074157715,
0.40959396958351135,
-0.13450458645820618,
-0.45267346501350403,
0.20939569175243378,
0.4644743800163269,
-0.12623542547225952,
-0.5355876684188843,
-0.5401964783668518,
0.03150452300906181,
-0.21356017887592316,
-0.3479694724082947,
0.16288983821868896,
0.4976373016834259,
-0.3452616333961487,
0.8506749868392944,
0.8911117911338806,
-0.23747998476028442,
0.10455218702554703,
0.41905996203422546,
1.1882926225662231,
-0.9037115573883057,
-0.29811716079711914,
-0.7048006057739258,
0.5462252497673035,
0.34580737352371216,
-0.32250306010246277,
0.26424044370651245,
0.347578763961792,
0.4324757754802704,
0.0124014001339674,
0.856002688407898,
0.14399777352809906,
0.27755579352378845,
-0.7172728776931763,
0.20616872608661652,
-0.6679055690765381,
-0.00863916426897049,
-0.10541152954101562,
-0.775672972202301,
-0.3767531216144562,
0.049410365521907806,
-0.2105088084936142,
-0.30084729194641113,
0.5484493970870972,
0.5173529386520386,
0.11489371955394745,
0.14047633111476898,
0.20233500003814697,
0.25529131293296814,
0.5271223187446594,
0.6555852890014648,
1.1841249465942383,
-0.3262079358100891,
0.9499530792236328,
-0.40847674012184143,
-0.3220186233520508,
-0.22749832272529602,
-0.793076753616333,
-0.9043053388595581,
-0.8480800986289978,
-0.0987175703048706,
-0.41284865140914917,
-0.00016018140013329685,
1.0257258415222168,
0.6947512626647949,
-0.7364575266838074,
0.31927645206451416,
-0.022179599851369858,
0.20895834267139435,
-0.2237359881401062,
-0.23266547918319702,
0.007513449061661959,
-0.12044334411621094,
-0.33415043354034424,
0.6136617064476013,
0.1970200091600418,
0.2262066900730133,
-0.19141584634780884,
0.045450713485479355,
0.2733525335788727,
0.16301046311855316,
0.6823491454124451,
0.027990100905299187,
-0.9245170950889587,
-0.24992921948432922,
0.04812852665781975,
-0.31189602613449097,
-0.2904830873012543,
0.6107126474380493,
-1.065880298614502,
0.4874096214771271,
0.5210296511650085,
0.42749834060668945,
0.31433504819869995,
-0.2761361300945282,
0.41080304980278015,
-0.6277228593826294,
0.07879722118377686,
0.23722079396247864,
0.5359280705451965,
0.4271008372306824,
-0.22987009584903717,
0.054427120834589005,
0.3463132679462433,
-0.4448060095310211,
-0.774753749370575,
0.1795647293329239,
-1.010761022567749,
-0.3782542049884796,
1.015271782875061,
0.13582809269428253,
-0.14970697462558746,
-0.27546972036361694,
-0.40879717469215393,
-0.09401050955057144,
-0.35569366812705994,
0.8198065757751465,
0.8274993896484375,
0.07033362239599228,
-0.5339184403419495,
-0.4368414878845215,
0.409452348947525,
0.13198204338550568,
-0.657840371131897,
-0.012747039087116718,
0.40352004766464233,
0.24983830749988556,
0.12025376409292221,
0.20869268476963043,
0.29341840744018555,
0.5317063331604004,
-0.11241345852613449,
-0.059138644486665726,
-0.1889052838087082,
-0.8746062517166138,
0.1101660504937172,
0.22143714129924774,
0.04200517386198044,
0.039502713829278946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11214v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11214v1 | Global Data Constraints: Ethical and Effectiveness Challenges in Large Language Model | 2024-06-17T05:13:25 | 2024-06-17T05:13:25 | Jin Yang, Zhiqiang Wang, Yanbin Lin, Zunduo Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | The efficacy and ethical integrity of large language models (LLMs) are
profoundly influenced by the diversity and quality of their training datasets.
However, the global landscape of data accessibility presents significant
challenges, particularly in regions with stringent data privacy laws or limited
open-source information. This paper examines the multifaceted challenges
associated with acquiring high-quality training data for LLMs, focusing on data
scarcity, bias, and low-quality content across various linguistic contexts. We
highlight the technical and ethical implications of relying on publicly
available but potentially biased or irrelevant data sources, which can lead to
the generation of biased or hallucinatory content by LLMs. Through a series of
evaluations using GPT-4 and GPT-4o, we demonstrate how these data constraints
adversely affect model performance and ethical alignment. We propose and
validate several mitigation strategies designed to enhance data quality and
model robustness, including advanced data filtering techniques and ethical data
collection practices. Our findings underscore the need for a proactive approach
in developing LLMs that considers both the effectiveness and ethical
implications of data constraints, aiming to foster the creation of more
reliable and universally applicable AI systems. | [
-0.08327588438987732,
-0.6069163680076599,
0.5693535208702087,
-0.2116205096244812,
0.006614468526095152,
0.09453652799129486,
-0.33510082960128784,
-0.7111032605171204,
-0.5167660117149353,
0.7209990620613098,
-0.4468013346195221,
-0.39916592836380005,
-0.735950767993927,
0.08239598572254181,
-0.18174825608730316,
1.0358351469039917,
-0.12028391659259796,
0.2860051989555359,
-0.31878146529197693,
-0.3673814535140991,
-0.3820016086101532,
-1.0176877975463867,
-0.4429793953895569,
-0.2109452337026596,
0.2792484760284424,
0.44210973381996155,
0.9679027199745178,
0.8824522495269775,
0.5687410235404968,
0.2264489084482193,
-0.11580211669206619,
0.036575090140104294,
-0.6760482788085938,
0.11192932724952698,
-0.24185435473918915,
-0.49270665645599365,
-0.3716982305049896,
0.1931295394897461,
0.7190333008766174,
0.5984787940979004,
-0.14584606885910034,
0.20683863759040833,
0.055628854781389236,
0.4830823540687561,
-0.5754052400588989,
0.024370215833187103,
-0.578791081905365,
-0.01440481748431921,
-0.37074142694473267,
0.067336805164814,
0.005480410531163216,
-0.6041358709335327,
0.138955757021904,
-0.5688101649284363,
0.09470948576927185,
-0.03821651637554169,
0.8538610935211182,
0.372511088848114,
-0.5328971147537231,
-0.6533995866775513,
-0.9024451375007629,
0.9611209630966187,
-0.6667721271514893,
0.4911912679672241,
0.6868506669998169,
0.12850512564182281,
-0.08413196355104446,
-0.3968288004398346,
-0.41527655720710754,
-0.15948735177516937,
0.18389958143234253,
-0.2683877646923065,
0.1567957103252411,
-0.05713725462555885,
0.3458545506000519,
0.34749355912208557,
-0.2537095248699188,
0.42212536931037903,
-0.3392114043235779,
-0.23510248959064484,
0.7086807489395142,
0.15655598044395447,
0.2597835659980774,
-0.0827094092965126,
0.03289780765771866,
0.15481971204280853,
-1.1097640991210938,
-0.0672714039683342,
0.9424383640289307,
0.27400755882263184,
-0.10921071469783783,
0.5629920959472656,
0.04731527343392372,
0.3788289427757263,
-0.44964128732681274,
-0.12475010752677917,
0.1698756068944931,
-0.48351073265075684,
0.09516976028680801,
-0.2517443299293518,
0.5208944082260132,
0.09186378866434097,
0.451616108417511,
-0.09582819789648056,
-0.19649295508861542,
-0.2249653935432434,
0.1598149836063385,
-0.5141350030899048,
0.19145964086055756,
0.3455221354961395,
-0.3351593315601349,
-0.1817856729030609,
-0.0035105326678603888,
-0.7468553185462952,
-0.4680420160293579,
-0.5678054094314575,
0.28242892026901245,
-0.18917684257030487,
-0.21371214091777802,
0.028158999979496002,
0.17613230645656586,
0.2645929157733917,
0.22314170002937317,
-0.949981689453125,
0.09558327496051788,
0.7530555725097656,
0.676576554775238,
0.0701901838183403,
-0.07257352769374847,
-0.5507947206497192,
0.39856603741645813,
-0.21125470101833344,
-0.08377738296985626,
-0.7317481637001038,
-0.40715551376342773,
-0.027866236865520477,
-0.012560131028294563,
0.18946987390518188,
-0.6495043635368347,
0.6728563904762268,
-0.2977536916732788,
0.07024390250444412,
-0.4922632873058319,
-0.5222026109695435,
0.09434574097394943,
0.18134000897407532,
-0.6455563306808472,
0.7360403537750244,
0.0019832877442240715,
-0.7233808636665344,
0.36496883630752563,
-0.5409454703330994,
-0.38779568672180176,
0.07556376606225967,
-0.5838969349861145,
-0.4381699860095978,
0.1153661385178566,
0.3055574893951416,
0.45426711440086365,
-0.4150935709476471,
0.6567612290382385,
-0.28833624720573425,
-0.17894808948040009,
0.2235572338104248,
-0.7190973162651062,
0.976904034614563,
0.18970339000225067,
-0.4268948435783386,
-0.046755436807870865,
-0.9204745292663574,
-0.1802707314491272,
0.32928580045700073,
-0.3238144516944885,
-0.38483163714408875,
0.2235267460346222,
-0.03769465535879135,
0.1903507262468338,
0.01436095405369997,
-0.4507918655872345,
0.03596879914402962,
0.008799823932349682,
0.6948075294494629,
1.029421091079712,
-0.051354970782995224,
0.19558744132518768,
-0.31970420479774475,
0.5650585889816284,
-0.28303244709968567,
0.540930986404419,
0.24336358904838562,
-0.2841126024723053,
-0.3393436074256897,
-0.15938037633895874,
0.22698670625686646,
0.626698911190033,
-0.5532376766204834,
0.4214886724948883,
-0.3951363265514374,
-0.3116050362586975,
-0.7581250071525574,
0.28733694553375244,
0.24935418367385864,
0.45728468894958496,
0.08159023523330688,
-0.036707501858472824,
-0.21885628998279572,
-1.0543986558914185,
-0.13966676592826843,
0.019429776817560196,
-0.0392126627266407,
0.5509794354438782,
0.7757267951965332,
-0.12624502182006836,
0.809700071811676,
0.10942423343658447,
-0.29342085123062134,
-0.20031842589378357,
-0.20787036418914795,
0.012353931553661823,
0.8134891986846924,
0.22865808010101318,
-0.9074481725692749,
0.010459733195602894,
-0.004124668892472982,
-0.9848678708076477,
0.057027556002140045,
-0.07402771711349487,
-0.03630978241562843,
0.13174796104431152,
0.31279224157333374,
-0.5597496628761292,
0.330700159072876,
0.6409197449684143,
0.005241356324404478,
0.41587477922439575,
-0.09683670103549957,
0.12828700244426727,
-0.8172910809516907,
0.20832687616348267,
-0.11622308194637299,
-0.049464624375104904,
-0.6306837201118469,
0.19860267639160156,
-0.010586395859718323,
-0.12164612859487534,
-0.46038058400154114,
0.44755464792251587,
-0.439299613237381,
-0.09937211126089096,
0.07242085784673691,
-0.04149354621767998,
-0.1325545758008957,
0.006324651651084423,
-0.05130226910114288,
0.7855476140975952,
0.4804551601409912,
-0.4832192361354828,
0.3612145185470581,
0.43044301867485046,
-0.5189329385757446,
0.6965285539627075,
-0.5422488451004028,
0.24836811423301697,
-0.20989975333213806,
0.27148154377937317,
-0.15265609323978424,
-0.4858257472515106,
0.2830065190792084,
-0.26057058572769165,
0.3204866945743561,
-0.23319227993488312,
-0.722173810005188,
-0.03563394397497177,
-0.217876598238945,
0.6092362999916077,
0.45582786202430725,
-0.5140236616134644,
0.29713714122772217,
0.5257924199104309,
-0.22519168257713318,
-0.9983716607093811,
-0.6961978673934937,
0.2921347916126251,
-0.40405571460723877,
-0.6723504066467285,
0.04905877262353897,
0.11822201311588287,
-0.3912123143672943,
-0.06985630840063095,
-0.07822734117507935,
0.09389427304267883,
0.3935615122318268,
0.020031020045280457,
0.07825301587581635,
0.10132528841495514,
-0.08594214916229248,
-0.1602754294872284,
0.09739312529563904,
0.27021902799606323,
-0.23991546034812927,
0.3398537039756775,
0.12187320739030838,
-0.5564541220664978,
-0.5374844670295715,
0.41689208149909973,
0.46396878361701965,
-0.17648530006408691,
0.708548903465271,
0.3837892711162567,
-0.5942402482032776,
-0.16196486353874207,
-0.6141617298126221,
-0.15735119581222534,
-0.47989988327026367,
0.4516203701496124,
-0.07327782362699509,
-1.0619256496429443,
0.4791531264781952,
0.1591082066297531,
0.09129776060581207,
0.10302738100290298,
0.5253735184669495,
0.09919589012861252,
0.9138127565383911,
0.5893152356147766,
-0.26456332206726074,
0.3186572194099426,
-0.10798931121826172,
0.2512378990650177,
-0.8704970479011536,
-0.4104357063770294,
-0.7000564932823181,
-0.07816293835639954,
-0.6042794585227966,
-0.30293163657188416,
0.3861875832080841,
0.014129402115941048,
-0.38442835211753845,
-0.3370591402053833,
-0.3941934406757355,
0.6335433721542358,
0.662785530090332,
0.06755103915929794,
0.5604382753372192,
0.010984168387949467,
0.12733417749404907,
-0.17131608724594116,
-0.5869826674461365,
-0.8220124244689941,
1.2233223915100098,
0.5799224972724915,
0.8818839192390442,
0.1548531949520111,
0.43997451663017273,
0.06270235776901245,
0.05870470777153969,
-0.41120320558547974,
0.3239521086215973,
-0.025829995051026344,
-0.9964339137077332,
-0.38226234912872314,
-0.7476848363876343,
-0.8744713664054871,
-0.01673564873635769,
-0.07377596944570541,
-0.9145119190216064,
0.166188046336174,
0.03114641271531582,
-0.10977572202682495,
0.41442805528640747,
-0.45971694588661194,
0.6974447965621948,
-0.6810987591743469,
-0.6718205213546753,
-0.05558303743600845,
-0.9181817770004272,
0.3435301184654236,
-0.29793980717658997,
0.5167577266693115,
-0.3726164996623993,
0.0033860253170132637,
0.5685999393463135,
-0.3492547571659088,
0.8799881339073181,
-0.18620474636554718,
-0.3338252305984497,
0.17708909511566162,
-0.15310445427894592,
0.660308837890625,
0.2543165981769562,
-0.16829651594161987,
0.5369747281074524,
-0.16532458364963531,
-0.4959196448326111,
-0.1728878617286682,
0.6193872690200806,
-0.9393584132194519,
-0.7119110226631165,
-0.3573962152004242,
-0.6858797073364258,
-0.6069780588150024,
0.158814936876297,
0.3435428738594055,
0.31395795941352844,
-0.16123802959918976,
0.27499374747276306,
0.6547207832336426,
-0.6293172240257263,
0.067294642329216,
0.30398860573768616,
0.19020070135593414,
-0.33240386843681335,
1.0326429605484009,
0.36197829246520996,
0.5550320744514465,
-0.09941163659095764,
0.11615126579999924,
-0.3293226957321167,
-0.9510536193847656,
-0.44872918725013733,
0.254136323928833,
-0.749011218547821,
0.0931706577539444,
-0.3217110335826874,
-0.34638136625289917,
-0.4009411334991455,
-0.07843808084726334,
-0.34034550189971924,
-0.16950960457324982,
-0.3945883512496948,
-0.13128326833248138,
0.30954858660697937,
0.8063228726387024,
-0.15836471319198608,
0.08326645195484161,
-0.6813634037971497,
0.07773829996585846,
-0.10924085974693298,
0.5572961568832397,
-0.17357100546360016,
-0.3817885220050812,
-0.18681076169013977,
0.13987599313259125,
-0.12901464104652405,
-0.40623220801353455,
0.1207122653722763,
-0.02701096050441265,
0.693890392780304,
0.05972882732748985,
-0.03916444629430771,
0.43251243233680725,
-0.4203575551509857,
0.7473751902580261,
-0.2135639488697052,
-1.0139702558517456,
0.4938149154186249,
-0.686218798160553,
-0.05235325172543526,
0.5800818204879761,
0.599058210849762,
-0.42767471075057983,
-0.6155299544334412,
-0.5094248056411743,
-1.0134146213531494,
0.7217963337898254,
0.521692156791687,
0.24487490952014923,
0.38203364610671997,
0.6638501286506653,
0.3193395733833313,
0.3899252116680145,
-0.7854642271995544,
0.019334955140948296,
0.0004738554998766631,
-0.31547126173973083,
0.09109514206647873,
0.00016118798521347344,
-0.27333739399909973,
-0.16366684436798096,
0.7522684931755066,
0.057358287274837494,
-0.17725160717964172,
0.009965410456061363,
-0.09221763908863068,
0.04752977937459946,
0.3925645649433136,
0.46484553813934326,
0.7859453558921814,
-0.04050291329622269,
-0.2364695817232132,
0.0101159131154418,
-0.5054423213005066,
0.3292308747768402,
0.05815733224153519,
-0.4469488263130188,
-0.32805100083351135,
0.3337092101573944,
0.5614513754844666,
-0.1283549964427948,
-0.720142126083374,
0.3750956952571869,
0.0902988463640213,
-0.08124391734600067,
-0.29562246799468994,
0.032816387712955475,
-0.020163094624876976,
0.08371442556381226,
0.23277607560157776,
-0.35481542348861694,
-0.2013460248708725,
-0.424461305141449,
0.028126906603574753,
0.6257458925247192,
0.07243017852306366,
-0.11691329628229141,
0.8757089376449585,
0.18071109056472778,
-0.04275071248412132,
0.9079405069351196,
0.203266441822052,
-0.2565273642539978,
0.6891936659812927,
0.3596629500389099,
0.3426623046398163,
-0.2809215486049652,
0.08059413731098175,
0.017050359398126602,
0.6692351698875427,
-0.3633771240711212,
0.31924426555633545,
0.2947239875793457,
-0.7398046255111694,
-0.4403003752231598,
-0.27513647079467773,
-0.7695605754852295,
0.4498802125453949,
-0.6888846755027771,
0.10379023849964142,
-0.5489408373832703,
-0.07528440654277802,
-0.36634013056755066,
-0.04384300857782364,
-0.69634610414505,
0.03727191314101219,
0.12262612581253052,
0.45510825514793396,
-0.5904784202575684,
0.788592517375946,
0.2217807173728943,
-0.36628666520118713,
-0.6082198619842529,
-0.0860816091299057,
0.33667677640914917,
-1.0376267433166504,
0.4422611594200134,
0.08132113516330719,
0.10585273057222366,
-0.07606382668018341,
-0.7498638033866882,
-0.9694364666938782,
0.8388746380805969,
0.8351659774780273,
-0.5280143618583679,
-0.08973614871501923,
0.6063727140426636,
0.3422708809375763,
-0.02689816989004612,
-0.2256394326686859,
0.7371673583984375,
0.6104843020439148,
-0.1538260579109192,
-0.869240403175354,
0.07158652693033218,
0.037939805537462234,
-0.13612738251686096,
0.14477361738681793,
-0.7991122603416443,
0.676062285900116,
-0.06247403100132942,
-0.17094841599464417,
0.0246096383780241,
0.19616498053073883,
0.2017313539981842,
0.2165745496749878,
0.16238214075565338,
0.4015357196331024,
1.0644266605377197,
-0.07984333485364914,
1.0653924942016602,
-0.11425020545721054,
0.2907106876373291,
0.9311885237693787,
-0.694847583770752,
0.4840410649776459,
0.363514244556427,
-0.04505433142185211,
-0.17334096133708954,
0.6377949714660645,
-0.3026268780231476,
0.18079563975334167,
0.42071765661239624,
-0.24362485110759735,
0.060708384960889816,
-0.5429678559303284,
-0.41580766439437866,
0.49578389525413513,
0.5932271480560303,
-0.18991270661354065,
0.007637305650860071,
0.03893892839550972,
0.16098390519618988,
-0.04255998507142067,
-0.29581570625305176,
0.47522956132888794,
-0.004088531248271465,
-0.324954092502594,
0.26125937700271606,
-0.05197451636195183,
0.571625292301178,
-0.4535839855670929,
0.0647173523902893,
-0.16683126986026764,
0.026354070752859116,
-0.33997872471809387,
-0.5819584131240845,
0.3563026487827301,
0.2813667356967926,
0.09913846105337143,
-0.20253078639507294,
0.3992217183113098,
-0.2622907757759094,
-0.47342315316200256,
0.2263345867395401,
0.6975572109222412,
0.13691960275173187,
0.09536872059106827,
-0.6019434332847595,
0.4848752021789551,
-0.1608712375164032,
-0.2690822184085846,
0.4843786358833313,
0.3889904022216797,
-0.19932496547698975,
0.8296903371810913,
0.6245279312133789,
0.38666853308677673,
-0.07617194950580597,
0.014739447273314,
0.5619066953659058,
-0.5532102584838867,
-0.20292966067790985,
-0.9920620918273926,
0.20229655504226685,
-0.03431275486946106,
-0.3687325119972229,
0.551067590713501,
0.40914401412010193,
0.9890786409378052,
0.4553625285625458,
1.137303113937378,
0.11033540964126587,
0.34279659390449524,
-0.7645838856697083,
0.8380138874053955,
-0.4674951434135437,
0.5148176550865173,
-0.06765788048505783,
-0.7992413640022278,
-0.3990563452243805,
0.5239693522453308,
-0.25623804330825806,
0.3235466182231903,
0.35998594760894775,
0.6040948629379272,
-0.02775142714381218,
0.10628369450569153,
0.19389012455940247,
0.20810015499591827,
0.6214494109153748,
0.5474021434783936,
0.917576253414154,
-0.024325137957930565,
0.5405473709106445,
-0.27034837007522583,
-0.09472068399190903,
0.1611301302909851,
-0.9373902678489685,
-0.7106688618659973,
-0.3967607319355011,
-0.2123713344335556,
-0.3368111550807953,
0.19505122303962708,
1.003509283065796,
0.7713232040405273,
-0.73100346326828,
-0.2646749019622803,
-0.04513569921255112,
0.2734910249710083,
0.19133824110031128,
-0.19609782099723816,
0.3691713511943817,
-0.01608557254076004,
-0.7396573424339294,
0.2414623349905014,
0.08272342383861542,
0.20686344802379608,
-0.33749741315841675,
-0.11473917216062546,
0.06595455855131149,
-0.004503553733229637,
0.3116721510887146,
0.3633589744567871,
-0.6735726594924927,
-0.5584424734115601,
-0.26117032766342163,
-0.05826681852340698,
0.044723547995090485,
0.8816632628440857,
-0.2153680920600891,
0.18060168623924255,
-0.044865697622299194,
1.0982152223587036,
0.020320098847150803,
0.02442585490643978,
0.7980440855026245,
-0.6670951247215271,
0.08875931054353714,
0.6435235738754272,
0.2843874990940094,
0.5499191284179688,
-0.579115629196167,
0.6678921580314636,
0.19436950981616974,
-0.8422515988349915,
-1.0687628984451294,
0.32473084330558777,
-0.5189027786254883,
-0.19675138592720032,
1.3392572402954102,
-0.0854271948337555,
0.11131241172552109,
-0.4153887629508972,
0.05138511210680008,
0.16103631258010864,
-0.25507697463035583,
0.7484460473060608,
0.9990543127059937,
-0.14464615285396576,
-0.06614440679550171,
-1.2654738426208496,
0.4793168306350708,
0.33881232142448425,
-1.0008906126022339,
0.43244147300720215,
0.813372015953064,
0.3639354407787323,
-0.4260198771953583,
0.4337919056415558,
-0.33458060026168823,
-0.02529156766831875,
-0.24404799938201904,
-0.08899597823619843,
-0.015948720276355743,
-0.2529836893081665,
-0.5845072865486145,
0.04353455826640129,
0.030486589297652245,
0.16587668657302856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11201v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11201v2 | Fine-Tuning or Fine-Failing? Debunking Performance Myths in Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T04:35:17 | 2024-06-30T14:42:52 | Scott Barnett, Zac Brannelly, Stefanus Kurniawan, Sheng Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have the unique capability to understand and
generate human-like text from input queries. When fine-tuned, these models show
enhanced performance on domain-specific queries. OpenAI highlights the process
of fine-tuning, stating: "To fine-tune a model, you are required to provide at
least 10 examples. We typically see clear improvements from fine-tuning on 50
to 100 training examples, but the right number varies greatly based on the
exact use case." This study extends this concept to the integration of LLMs
within Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) pipelines, which aim to improve
accuracy and relevance by leveraging external corpus data for information
retrieval. However, RAG's promise of delivering optimal responses often falls
short in complex query scenarios. This study aims to specifically examine the
effects of fine-tuning LLMs on their ability to extract and integrate
contextual data to enhance the performance of RAG systems across multiple
domains. We evaluate the impact of fine-tuning on the LLMs' capacity for data
extraction and contextual understanding by comparing the accuracy and
completeness of fine-tuned models against baseline performances across datasets
from multiple domains. Our findings indicate that fine-tuning resulted in a
decline in performance compared to the baseline models, contrary to the
improvements observed in standalone LLM applications as suggested by OpenAI.
This study highlights the need for vigorous investigation and validation of
fine-tuned models for domain-specific tasks. | [
-0.6966618299484253,
-0.8438193202018738,
0.5010923147201538,
-0.09171619266271591,
-0.3247235119342804,
-0.060370512306690216,
-0.500912606716156,
-0.6488294005393982,
-0.23349271714687347,
0.6551070213317871,
-0.3956487476825714,
-0.399691104888916,
-0.5745497345924377,
0.13629108667373657,
-0.3358139097690582,
1.0555949211120605,
-0.010458370670676231,
-0.006678743753582239,
-0.17699679732322693,
-0.21091510355472565,
-0.8525805473327637,
-0.3526095151901245,
-0.7528058886528015,
-0.3981354236602783,
0.5472716093063354,
0.5322627425193787,
0.6173585057258606,
0.7270674705505371,
0.5801824331283569,
0.2160102277994156,
-0.27513405680656433,
0.8513837456703186,
-0.9093250036239624,
0.2192087173461914,
-0.5166537761688232,
-0.488561749458313,
-0.48847728967666626,
-0.03111286275088787,
0.6973022222518921,
0.7935764789581299,
0.05817817151546478,
0.3882485032081604,
0.4148273468017578,
0.7387075424194336,
-0.8814463019371033,
0.10445120930671692,
-0.9867703318595886,
-0.3140721917152405,
-0.31013303995132446,
-0.544692873954773,
-0.2819163501262665,
-0.08492504060268402,
-0.012635731138288975,
-0.48174378275871277,
0.3495880365371704,
0.21954931318759918,
0.9643332958221436,
0.5170227885246277,
-0.2716189920902252,
-0.3344762623310089,
-0.9008984565734863,
0.828886866569519,
-0.6869600415229797,
0.2045656144618988,
0.33400312066078186,
0.28239285945892334,
-0.2895655333995819,
-0.4873307943344116,
-0.4020583927631378,
-0.02172473631799221,
-0.18114081025123596,
-0.1488897055387497,
0.01723402552306652,
-0.008274680003523827,
0.4039536118507385,
0.4182174503803253,
-0.25136080384254456,
0.5099242925643921,
-0.2863463759422302,
0.160737082362175,
0.5068243145942688,
0.481876939535141,
0.0476340688765049,
-0.0719994604587555,
0.022540811449289322,
0.05569753050804138,
-0.875076413154602,
-0.005278320051729679,
0.19420766830444336,
0.8892619013786316,
0.061078108847141266,
0.6092955470085144,
-0.46360087394714355,
0.8582962155342102,
0.10652775317430496,
-0.16088733077049255,
-0.09397754073143005,
-0.3851231336593628,
-0.4171593487262726,
-0.3143762946128845,
0.424227237701416,
0.4080633521080017,
0.525224506855011,
-0.27236130833625793,
-0.553977906703949,
-0.08935734629631042,
0.2629724442958832,
-0.7963011264801025,
0.0320332869887352,
0.09213492274284363,
-0.3096291720867157,
-0.15602798759937286,
-0.09225426614284515,
-0.42881959676742554,
-0.39595869183540344,
-0.8177579641342163,
0.46508505940437317,
-0.40097448229789734,
-0.0183697659522295,
0.16901659965515137,
-0.04626781493425369,
0.0963161364197731,
0.42968428134918213,
-0.8326752185821533,
0.3198801577091217,
1.0565472841262817,
0.7182117104530334,
-0.48330026865005493,
-0.27069923281669617,
-0.7929871082305908,
0.12774908542633057,
-0.3846158981323242,
0.7781670689582825,
-0.6083155274391174,
-0.2510005831718445,
0.00425290921702981,
0.0800054520368576,
-0.1984308809041977,
-1.0069530010223389,
0.7244510054588318,
-0.7442311644554138,
-0.3448290526866913,
-0.30449166893959045,
-0.685198187828064,
0.08022983372211456,
0.11045299470424652,
-0.5318976640701294,
0.7783370018005371,
-0.01646547205746174,
-0.5182126760482788,
0.6211659908294678,
-0.4778434634208679,
-0.4837978482246399,
-0.004815161693841219,
-0.022151416167616844,
-0.2953145503997803,
0.4087662398815155,
0.12079516798257828,
0.7281414270401001,
-0.5875556468963623,
0.26386988162994385,
-0.3069906532764435,
-0.6033952832221985,
0.12991952896118164,
-0.2450522929430008,
0.31345435976982117,
0.40887877345085144,
-0.136882483959198,
-0.09208596497774124,
-0.751558244228363,
0.0980081856250763,
-0.0989711582660675,
-0.4825023114681244,
-0.5442126989364624,
0.0157641489058733,
0.16624824702739716,
-0.029398644343018532,
0.14199338853359222,
-0.29053419828414917,
0.16502414643764496,
-0.4856756031513214,
0.25954943895339966,
0.6540728807449341,
-0.049296408891677856,
0.550122857093811,
-0.4714840352535248,
0.35256704688072205,
-0.000655485549941659,
-0.16809473931789398,
-0.19917914271354675,
-0.16045233607292175,
-0.7062386274337769,
-0.1052417904138565,
0.5220114588737488,
0.31434059143066406,
-0.477963924407959,
0.0637853667140007,
-0.3378499150276184,
-0.3840518295764923,
-0.5436445474624634,
0.3583994507789612,
0.43676894903182983,
0.5310418605804443,
0.3403174579143524,
-0.23285382986068726,
-0.48607128858566284,
-0.9150642156600952,
-0.5801053643226624,
0.3623221218585968,
-0.11270742118358612,
0.6709821224212646,
0.4446743428707123,
-0.26858705282211304,
0.8807750344276428,
-0.47243115305900574,
-0.424589604139328,
-0.13408467173576355,
0.025129850953817368,
0.27331095933914185,
0.47158166766166687,
0.41341471672058105,
-0.8356891870498657,
-0.5504799485206604,
0.31590548157691956,
-0.4514296352863312,
-0.13847652077674866,
0.11137900501489639,
0.000032458145142300054,
0.35580864548683167,
0.41327905654907227,
-0.4146280884742737,
0.2772727906703949,
0.4575382471084595,
-0.0800580158829689,
0.553270161151886,
-0.2900119125843048,
0.16914798319339752,
-0.8847835063934326,
0.23529410362243652,
0.00336262839846313,
-0.14453689754009247,
-0.5117993354797363,
0.21181286871433258,
0.15996351838111877,
0.04293838515877724,
-0.2770940363407135,
0.6772218942642212,
-0.43603771924972534,
-0.19545651972293854,
-0.42951300740242004,
0.150098979473114,
-0.0038029190618544817,
0.3035431504249573,
-0.3791590929031372,
1.0589780807495117,
0.35549524426460266,
-1.0236546993255615,
-0.14951880276203156,
0.06373902410268784,
-0.49920937418937683,
0.5622852444648743,
-0.6395195126533508,
0.008706818334758282,
-0.12207601964473724,
-0.14139457046985626,
-0.7915922403335571,
-0.6008986234664917,
-0.21283386647701263,
-0.20516107976436615,
0.5842775106430054,
-0.25290119647979736,
-0.5906620025634766,
0.042949359863996506,
-0.05751940235495567,
0.2942805886268616,
0.31276172399520874,
-0.5549977421760559,
0.35457274317741394,
0.4686101973056793,
0.05627157911658287,
-0.45096251368522644,
-0.5168069005012512,
-0.005132581572979689,
-0.35664042830467224,
-0.5854138135910034,
0.4506981372833252,
0.16491879522800446,
-0.2026127427816391,
-0.18926051259040833,
-0.2068268060684204,
-0.059244051575660706,
0.3003345727920532,
0.09302903711795807,
-0.0012573163257911801,
-0.2946893870830536,
0.07716506719589233,
0.067662313580513,
0.0023332249838858843,
-0.23942503333091736,
-0.1599750816822052,
0.4821292459964752,
-0.06929647922515869,
-0.3321566879749298,
-0.3739015758037567,
0.14400307834148407,
0.649781346321106,
-0.3704293668270111,
0.8615620732307434,
0.4344441592693329,
-0.3459150493144989,
-0.34512102603912354,
-0.6968106031417847,
-0.21920514106750488,
-0.46405506134033203,
0.19225959479808807,
-0.6096079349517822,
-1.0936261415481567,
0.6038303375244141,
-0.43303442001342773,
0.02441561222076416,
0.5022427439689636,
0.4065564274787903,
-0.24365676939487457,
1.1263229846954346,
0.7502882480621338,
0.05317484587430954,
0.4310019314289093,
-0.23364898562431335,
0.0650561973452568,
-1.1259816884994507,
-0.04487823694944382,
-0.7116031646728516,
-0.38616836071014404,
-0.8244614601135254,
-0.2835642397403717,
0.36830782890319824,
0.3804086446762085,
-0.3249940276145935,
0.02573431469500065,
-0.3072826564311981,
0.6129627823829651,
0.3670538365840912,
0.0042442576959729195,
0.49258723855018616,
0.14824944734573364,
0.025097595527768135,
0.023524612188339233,
-0.7179185152053833,
-0.6958783864974976,
0.9841924905776978,
0.22668775916099548,
0.9384608864784241,
0.11254531890153885,
0.38753029704093933,
-0.0031166288536041975,
0.02139751985669136,
-0.7980997562408447,
0.34986451268196106,
-0.663506269454956,
-0.539935290813446,
-0.34360644221305847,
-0.41788914799690247,
-1.1643627882003784,
0.202626571059227,
-0.14925925433635712,
-0.6898514628410339,
0.2527519166469574,
0.19802416861057281,
-0.4308328330516815,
0.20045055449008942,
-0.6461036205291748,
0.7417487502098083,
-0.04690650478005409,
-0.47492000460624695,
-0.22221963107585907,
-0.3251834213733673,
0.33453264832496643,
-0.3791677951812744,
0.1028643324971199,
-0.20857569575309753,
0.024340536445379257,
0.44825443625450134,
-0.1189451739192009,
0.8315717577934265,
-0.02104027196764946,
-0.06950820982456207,
-0.014430577866733074,
0.1362846940755844,
0.5498288869857788,
0.06772096455097198,
-0.2831589877605438,
0.06742352247238159,
0.041410140693187714,
-0.232757568359375,
-0.4940316677093506,
0.9257279634475708,
-0.6526167392730713,
-0.6518509387969971,
0.08249585330486298,
-0.5673340559005737,
-0.425326406955719,
0.29578280448913574,
0.0841253399848938,
0.5976679921150208,
-0.036043163388967514,
0.4816805124282837,
0.8550239205360413,
-0.17216894030570984,
0.13305239379405975,
0.5839832425117493,
-0.010792121291160583,
0.0384996272623539,
0.751092791557312,
0.3220207989215851,
0.384859174489975,
0.2392365038394928,
0.08940435945987701,
-0.0180346742272377,
-0.8225655555725098,
-0.4392363429069519,
0.3029191195964813,
-0.47849318385124207,
-0.38118600845336914,
-0.4828386604785919,
-0.05332469940185547,
-0.3535483479499817,
0.06385251879692078,
-0.4588952660560608,
-0.10977476835250854,
-0.5695136785507202,
0.3351406455039978,
0.26874610781669617,
0.8091421127319336,
0.1319957971572876,
0.27653273940086365,
-0.7898615598678589,
0.30420076847076416,
-0.015986178070306778,
0.6474142074584961,
0.1155109629034996,
-0.786459743976593,
-0.5833857655525208,
0.09577878564596176,
-0.23441772162914276,
-0.3541453778743744,
0.3407982289791107,
0.38911259174346924,
0.4940946400165558,
0.11156881600618362,
-0.08463926613330841,
1.0328147411346436,
-0.642561674118042,
0.5505608916282654,
-0.4229234755039215,
-0.6234483122825623,
0.553251326084137,
-0.55125892162323,
0.45803168416023254,
0.6706829071044922,
0.3013066053390503,
-0.3413220942020416,
-0.3233200013637543,
-0.20839054882526398,
-0.8677776455879211,
0.8120262622833252,
-0.07851559668779373,
0.13918335735797882,
0.15361639857292175,
0.8093798756599426,
0.18182232975959778,
0.08093129098415375,
-0.08910076320171356,
-0.24148401618003845,
0.5689783096313477,
0.12835146486759186,
-0.2526325583457947,
-0.3226222097873688,
-0.17511436343193054,
-0.3006505072116852,
0.5425922870635986,
-0.3428536653518677,
-0.11545979231595993,
-0.03159186244010925,
-0.11977646499872208,
-0.3305717706680298,
0.18606245517730713,
0.6129063963890076,
0.9379042983055115,
-0.17480280995368958,
-0.1503715217113495,
0.3017219603061676,
-0.21810415387153625,
-0.32323750853538513,
-0.027803311124444008,
-0.17184147238731384,
-0.13985654711723328,
0.24351030588150024,
0.9292199015617371,
0.307686448097229,
-0.5674883127212524,
0.06883644312620163,
-0.12348198145627975,
0.10676532238721848,
-0.019887398928403854,
0.36681294441223145,
0.026043269783258438,
0.27904829382896423,
0.40560734272003174,
0.21249447762966156,
0.2373347133398056,
-0.5473169684410095,
0.08982629328966141,
0.7066172957420349,
0.028207411989569664,
-0.06193893402814865,
0.6181501746177673,
-0.05174074321985245,
-0.28408128023147583,
0.34265172481536865,
0.13723444938659668,
-0.1889265924692154,
0.583212673664093,
0.476447194814682,
0.6370526552200317,
0.1107235699892044,
-0.3016788363456726,
0.2912362813949585,
0.1466432809829712,
-0.20807069540023804,
0.04243059828877449,
0.026109790429472923,
-0.6893348693847656,
-0.7219610810279846,
-1.0093765258789062,
-0.39481624960899353,
0.29160866141319275,
-0.732134222984314,
0.4159443974494934,
-0.14055050909519196,
-0.15151861310005188,
0.09576187282800674,
0.11490266770124435,
-0.9877461194992065,
0.3034234642982483,
-0.03772446885704994,
0.9891510009765625,
-0.5586009621620178,
0.7773212790489197,
0.7511559724807739,
-0.19011762738227844,
-0.9362623691558838,
0.09056601673364639,
-0.31760019063949585,
-0.5885652899742126,
0.7759688496589661,
-0.007699088659137487,
-0.21859139204025269,
-0.033681001514196396,
-0.4623672068119049,
-0.993016242980957,
0.9518512487411499,
0.49696481227874756,
-0.6057679057121277,
0.04651188850402832,
0.2582473158836365,
0.7280569672584534,
-0.5060445070266724,
0.0023164425510913134,
0.9268259406089783,
0.3177221119403839,
-0.0039930082857608795,
-1.363425612449646,
-0.09444773942232132,
0.2132490575313568,
0.23701350390911102,
0.2649194002151489,
-0.5283351540565491,
0.8945392966270447,
-0.1048317477107048,
-0.3577263653278351,
0.15872353315353394,
0.37879741191864014,
0.10587260127067566,
0.3961767256259918,
0.31778064370155334,
0.5209057927131653,
0.8557704091072083,
-0.1037960797548294,
1.2549129724502563,
-0.3959962725639343,
0.326699823141098,
1.228939414024353,
-0.12184636294841766,
1.0560123920440674,
0.38066473603248596,
0.13031107187271118,
0.02598896063864231,
0.5831583142280579,
0.28706538677215576,
0.4712667167186737,
0.01245216652750969,
-0.02413157746195793,
-0.21540802717208862,
-0.16678419709205627,
-0.2453361302614212,
0.6050006151199341,
0.5273080468177795,
-0.3407713770866394,
-0.1933714747428894,
0.004144011996686459,
-0.19313257932662964,
0.11280202120542526,
-0.48660391569137573,
0.8864703178405762,
0.11313249915838242,
-0.8693260550498962,
0.9724106788635254,
0.10538040101528168,
0.7880123853683472,
-0.25289297103881836,
0.044812001287937164,
-0.32785680890083313,
0.2943089008331299,
-0.30070123076438904,
-0.7331039309501648,
0.48375892639160156,
0.079193115234375,
-0.32248640060424805,
-0.12811554968357086,
0.8983210921287537,
-0.2749965786933899,
-0.06663340330123901,
0.2032758742570877,
0.6326497793197632,
0.14967794716358185,
-0.09163137525320053,
-0.5103408098220825,
0.3700183033943176,
-0.12349744886159897,
-0.18307729065418243,
0.5859222412109375,
0.6962621212005615,
0.011920016258955002,
0.53037428855896,
0.7000163793563843,
0.17287388443946838,
-0.20053264498710632,
0.13073194026947021,
0.9413723349571228,
-0.4361476004123688,
-0.08981688320636749,
-0.9402186870574951,
0.37701183557510376,
-0.06915564090013504,
-0.3411216735839844,
0.7357891798019409,
0.5282339453697205,
1.0713034868240356,
-0.05148553475737572,
0.5250440239906311,
0.2324761003255844,
0.7662569284439087,
-0.5925235152244568,
0.7485992908477783,
-0.9432595372200012,
0.46193602681159973,
-0.10248047113418579,
-0.8829776048660278,
-0.3485795557498932,
0.265188992023468,
-0.3624478578567505,
0.05748160928487778,
0.3223125636577606,
0.9433494806289673,
-0.29069051146507263,
-0.1974201798439026,
0.48115795850753784,
0.30995985865592957,
0.23148661851882935,
0.18342998623847961,
0.564583420753479,
-0.38168805837631226,
0.2587844431400299,
-0.08978908509016037,
-0.05304766446352005,
-0.4132893979549408,
-0.7452520728111267,
-0.795283854007721,
-0.47136494517326355,
-0.0009711320162750781,
-0.11697478592395782,
0.2576972246170044,
0.5840536952018738,
0.6310144066810608,
-0.8675145506858826,
-0.20244625210762024,
0.04278799518942833,
0.10683518648147583,
0.11861425638198853,
-0.22591029107570648,
0.14488151669502258,
-0.7741449475288391,
-0.9658998250961304,
0.3907753527164459,
0.21467120945453644,
-0.23216524720191956,
-0.17441904544830322,
0.10564592480659485,
-0.06019016355276108,
0.04271148145198822,
0.678788423538208,
0.210055872797966,
-0.7540023922920227,
-0.2908044755458832,
-0.0722290650010109,
-0.24622899293899536,
-0.0212253388017416,
0.7319884300231934,
-0.8036047220230103,
0.34391462802886963,
0.4082551598548889,
0.946485698223114,
0.5006746649742126,
0.05676963925361633,
0.6261177062988281,
-0.7880625128746033,
-0.14124780893325806,
0.12416648864746094,
0.20471365749835968,
0.327846884727478,
-0.3849894106388092,
0.6406266093254089,
-0.18930906057357788,
-0.9021464586257935,
-1.0783166885375977,
0.1792527288198471,
-0.6844633221626282,
-0.3658256530761719,
1.2588801383972168,
0.1611507087945938,
-0.11060187220573425,
-0.09521318227052689,
-0.24632975459098816,
0.19514967501163483,
-0.24386538565158844,
0.6658024191856384,
0.6209047436714172,
-0.31165221333503723,
0.23627117276191711,
-0.9903297424316406,
0.6930402517318726,
0.5844878554344177,
-0.5387244820594788,
0.3005518913269043,
0.43615567684173584,
0.3750583827495575,
0.12249226123094559,
0.27210938930511475,
0.14526459574699402,
0.13649126887321472,
-0.41958287358283997,
-0.49422886967658997,
0.056702256202697754,
-0.2894379198551178,
-0.4498096704483032,
0.255536288022995,
0.342174232006073,
0.12063220888376236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11200v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11200v2 | AvaTaR: Optimizing LLM Agents for Tool-Assisted Knowledge Retrieval | 2024-06-17T04:20:02 | 2024-06-18T01:39:57 | Shirley Wu, Shiyu Zhao, Qian Huang, Kexin Huang, Michihiro Yasunaga, Kaidi Cao, Vassilis N. Ioannidis, Karthik Subbian, Jure Leskovec, James Zou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language model (LLM) agents have demonstrated impressive capability in
utilizing external tools and knowledge to boost accuracy and reduce
hallucinations. However, developing the prompting techniques that make LLM
agents able to effectively use external tools and knowledge is a heuristic and
laborious task. Here, we introduce AvaTaR, a novel and automatic framework that
optimizes an LLM agent to effectively use the provided tools and improve its
performance on a given task/domain. During optimization, we design a comparator
module to iteratively provide insightful and holistic prompts to the LLM agent
via reasoning between positive and negative examples sampled from training
data. We demonstrate AvaTaR on four complex multimodal retrieval datasets
featuring textual, visual, and relational information. We find AvaTaR
consistently outperforms state-of-the-art approaches across all four
challenging tasks and exhibits strong generalization ability when applied to
novel cases, achieving an average relative improvement of 14% on the Hit@1
metric. Code and dataset are available at https://github.com/zou-group/avatar. | [
-0.3580716848373413,
-0.7091437578201294,
0.6816586852073669,
-0.015876682475209236,
-0.25199928879737854,
0.19962060451507568,
-0.12652449309825897,
-0.287461519241333,
0.13358305394649506,
0.25640320777893066,
-0.2879005968570709,
-0.6208345293998718,
-0.4914110004901886,
0.15569186210632324,
-0.15850862860679626,
0.3625258803367615,
0.26563939452171326,
0.024339037016034126,
-0.6125470995903015,
-0.2372913956642151,
-0.5975619554519653,
-0.4127477705478668,
-0.8145178556442261,
-0.5505700707435608,
0.6586637496948242,
0.45211759209632874,
0.9389957189559937,
0.5459991097450256,
0.5781672596931458,
0.38388776779174805,
0.09990169107913971,
0.47455111145973206,
-0.5317205190658569,
0.5038843154907227,
-0.2701690196990967,
-0.6132399439811707,
-0.2166593223810196,
-0.3836236894130707,
0.38433772325515747,
0.2025403380393982,
-0.23763686418533325,
0.12967346608638763,
-0.2232140153646469,
0.4122340977191925,
-0.7277078628540039,
0.3491291403770447,
-0.7299345135688782,
0.091118723154068,
-0.04446529597043991,
-0.4793454706668854,
-0.47417059540748596,
-0.21095657348632812,
-0.13355033099651337,
-0.8727570176124573,
0.046848542988300323,
0.3314706087112427,
0.6169546246528625,
0.563057541847229,
-0.33183154463768005,
-0.07214116305112839,
-0.39250028133392334,
0.9112040400505066,
-0.34685879945755005,
0.5121833682060242,
0.3448795676231384,
0.49640369415283203,
-0.19828267395496368,
-0.5638328194618225,
-0.6820477247238159,
-0.5031903982162476,
0.07444675266742706,
-0.13981612026691437,
-0.4613591134548187,
0.1688959002494812,
0.2976463735103607,
0.2839107811450958,
-0.47991296648979187,
0.049078818410634995,
-0.001155298319645226,
-0.4740404486656189,
0.509717583656311,
0.22893126308918,
0.3494435250759125,
-0.11573949456214905,
-0.12526454031467438,
-0.4861632287502289,
-0.5765560269355774,
0.05799068138003349,
0.25013333559036255,
0.1631433665752411,
0.40050771832466125,
0.669978141784668,
-0.2742084562778473,
0.68732088804245,
-0.057052791118621826,
-0.3325381577014923,
0.43577811121940613,
-0.1178869754076004,
0.08662591129541397,
-0.11127099394798279,
0.5476569533348083,
0.5045589804649353,
-0.07337448745965958,
-0.19151237607002258,
-0.6586004495620728,
0.1833009272813797,
0.4177689552307129,
-0.6252572536468506,
0.09004589915275574,
0.09697119891643524,
-0.31264352798461914,
-0.23258431255817413,
-0.24616147577762604,
-0.3840060532093048,
-0.5260573029518127,
-0.5138994455337524,
0.9427101612091064,
-0.3681361973285675,
-0.1643902063369751,
0.07522043585777283,
-0.3823501765727997,
0.2859579622745514,
0.5727214813232422,
-0.47870782017707825,
-0.009216567501425743,
0.6857686638832092,
0.6708004474639893,
-0.2957029342651367,
0.04377195984125137,
-1.0377037525177002,
0.060643646866083145,
-0.4328179657459259,
0.9312849640846252,
-0.8085171580314636,
-0.20697352290153503,
-0.04272451624274254,
-0.34666991233825684,
0.2058163732290268,
-0.8157646059989929,
0.21111558377742767,
-0.7460430860519409,
-0.18032293021678925,
-0.196480393409729,
-0.28230634331703186,
-0.2658877670764923,
0.5113015174865723,
-0.6986029148101807,
1.021740436553955,
0.16941501200199127,
-0.27269840240478516,
0.35813501477241516,
-0.5763925909996033,
-0.27220746874809265,
0.17618295550346375,
-0.38465815782546997,
-0.16065339744091034,
0.08859021216630936,
0.50999516248703,
0.44492238759994507,
-0.4538983106613159,
0.15205755829811096,
-0.11573240160942078,
-0.5907713174819946,
-0.2334723323583603,
-0.21366076171398163,
0.39939358830451965,
0.36443892121315,
-0.17362035810947418,
0.3307492136955261,
-0.5004945397377014,
0.008949137292802334,
0.09004297852516174,
-0.44956886768341064,
-0.4329356253147125,
-0.2954469323158264,
-0.12957575917243958,
-0.10799819231033325,
0.32631582021713257,
-0.32580703496932983,
0.4373653531074524,
-0.33054032921791077,
0.04143000394105911,
0.7422676086425781,
-0.08074124157428741,
0.20945289731025696,
-0.47602829337120056,
0.8260506391525269,
0.07457435131072998,
0.2483709752559662,
-0.1460738182067871,
-0.3306306302547455,
-0.6176524758338928,
-0.28340089321136475,
-0.09256352484226227,
0.4909166693687439,
-1.4455757141113281,
0.19079849123954773,
-0.15476782619953156,
-0.4613153636455536,
-0.664712131023407,
0.3438495993614197,
0.35213610529899597,
0.36838576197624207,
0.2602498233318329,
-0.4622972011566162,
-0.28963521122932434,
-0.8397758603096008,
-0.1739174723625183,
-0.3345411419868469,
0.06872351467609406,
0.5720551013946533,
0.28328949213027954,
-0.40442702174186707,
0.8492036461830139,
-0.4023993909358978,
-0.3812960684299469,
-0.3516048789024353,
0.103546142578125,
0.2898083031177521,
0.03951414301991463,
0.28879985213279724,
-0.8262878656387329,
-0.4052428603172302,
0.18272282183170319,
-0.9682303667068481,
-0.12682873010635376,
-0.14717309176921844,
-0.2237527072429657,
0.010854932479560375,
0.6321504712104797,
-0.7197720408439636,
0.3785724639892578,
-0.04548666253685951,
-0.21780648827552795,
0.6358035802841187,
-0.21668878197669983,
0.1139410212635994,
-0.8814970850944519,
0.13511741161346436,
-0.14387230575084686,
-0.4678104817867279,
-0.3338949978351593,
0.33052289485931396,
-0.2272852659225464,
0.04784635454416275,
-0.5302677154541016,
0.8831381797790527,
-0.4279901385307312,
-0.05179935321211815,
-0.29622960090637207,
0.10622593760490417,
-0.00952519103884697,
0.5754780769348145,
-0.10458793491125107,
1.0594497919082642,
0.7633917927742004,
-0.6132813096046448,
0.7448095083236694,
0.5348823070526123,
-0.41436296701431274,
0.7896499037742615,
-0.5344863533973694,
0.3911850154399872,
-0.5426374077796936,
-0.06588511168956757,
-0.5870084762573242,
-0.1717498004436493,
0.3341657817363739,
-0.2482384741306305,
0.07523757219314575,
0.07771383225917816,
-0.8172699809074402,
-0.17857739329338074,
-0.5018595457077026,
0.4681715965270996,
0.38610726594924927,
-0.7487664222717285,
1.0711344480514526,
0.3711552917957306,
0.03850996866822243,
-0.9958908557891846,
-0.0024066739715635777,
0.3884766399860382,
-0.11332869529724121,
-0.4813646674156189,
0.2839668095111847,
-0.15869486331939697,
-0.5414366722106934,
-0.1277860552072525,
-0.13931599259376526,
0.20136485993862152,
-0.10045015811920166,
0.09127974510192871,
0.0674317330121994,
-0.1657494306564331,
0.41579338908195496,
0.0574934147298336,
-0.010017248801887035,
-0.0703263059258461,
-0.14484034478664398,
0.5076209902763367,
-0.12948420643806458,
-0.4923989474773407,
-0.29452696442604065,
0.11226615309715271,
0.34571415185928345,
-0.04526999220252037,
0.46031296253204346,
0.6597570776939392,
-0.1694040447473526,
-0.16674768924713135,
-0.8639863729476929,
-0.3078297972679138,
-0.5308247208595276,
0.5421480536460876,
-0.6380791068077087,
-0.5537800192832947,
0.33542752265930176,
-0.11100277304649353,
0.05049987509846687,
0.056145910173654556,
0.5287017226219177,
0.4133262038230896,
1.2660378217697144,
0.6243987083435059,
-0.2887323200702667,
0.6203935146331787,
-0.4304448962211609,
-0.07626032829284668,
-0.7124388217926025,
-0.29987215995788574,
-0.161983460187912,
-0.1311527043581009,
-0.1254199743270874,
-0.6051883697509766,
0.7396868467330933,
-0.15177412331104279,
-0.22320221364498138,
0.1477394700050354,
-0.560617983341217,
0.6549147367477417,
0.7506823539733887,
0.3359890282154083,
0.5797079801559448,
0.07947053015232086,
-0.35776686668395996,
0.3210870027542114,
-0.7861335873603821,
-0.4728628098964691,
0.9926431179046631,
0.1908978819847107,
1.077439785003662,
0.14968852698802948,
0.5109473466873169,
0.5224241018295288,
0.26878270506858826,
-1.0460540056228638,
0.7781943678855896,
0.1475333869457245,
-0.468178927898407,
-0.34539031982421875,
-0.3298395872116089,
-1.0425310134887695,
0.4462880492210388,
-0.09313522279262543,
-0.5192289352416992,
0.24039019644260406,
0.0728481113910675,
-0.3193366527557373,
0.012670869007706642,
-0.44325339794158936,
0.5333529710769653,
-0.24079598486423492,
-0.462787926197052,
-0.5571528673171997,
-0.5812525749206543,
-0.12342488765716553,
-0.09731046110391617,
-0.05843081325292587,
-0.10253451019525528,
-0.2398800104856491,
0.38076865673065186,
-0.2703341543674469,
0.5862407088279724,
-0.25293710827827454,
0.01606256701052189,
0.22635604441165924,
0.03152476251125336,
0.5325011610984802,
-0.012368841096758842,
-0.5159876942634583,
0.029618361964821815,
-0.014348569326102734,
-0.1789839118719101,
-0.8412886261940002,
0.4686972498893738,
-0.875127911567688,
-0.9529293775558472,
-0.24782556295394897,
-0.668526828289032,
-0.13776522874832153,
0.2672841548919678,
0.046870842576026917,
0.5193712711334229,
-0.08946489542722702,
0.19285716116428375,
0.5589386820793152,
-0.44633951783180237,
0.06103119999170303,
0.4396139085292816,
-0.2799929976463318,
-0.29160362482070923,
1.1073830127716064,
-0.21331553161144257,
-0.030966229736804962,
0.614467203617096,
0.06319560110569,
-0.4514467120170593,
-0.35859522223472595,
-0.3587849736213684,
0.19791148602962494,
-1.2698323726654053,
-0.45714864134788513,
-0.61309814453125,
-0.02363169752061367,
-0.3252430558204651,
0.0627269521355629,
-0.053952235728502274,
-0.19457830488681793,
-0.36590084433555603,
0.0493483766913414,
0.31078794598579407,
0.7055836915969849,
-0.10162019729614258,
0.30337926745414734,
-0.4089907109737396,
0.5207560658454895,
0.41936591267585754,
0.1976938098669052,
0.14421430230140686,
-0.28218892216682434,
-0.27715134620666504,
-0.30022132396698,
-0.5212175846099854,
-0.4590893089771271,
0.5084484219551086,
0.35457366704940796,
0.8036540150642395,
0.43911561369895935,
0.17991796135902405,
0.6215535998344421,
-0.24744342267513275,
0.46990883350372314,
-0.07330338656902313,
-0.7079010605812073,
0.6085302233695984,
-0.15163402259349823,
0.3843423128128052,
0.5587203502655029,
0.2729139029979706,
-0.4220525622367859,
-0.5435469746589661,
-0.18179593980312347,
-0.920444667339325,
0.671596884727478,
0.2552580237388611,
0.2193084955215454,
0.06357810646295547,
0.4941380023956299,
0.3950699269771576,
0.4644390344619751,
-0.5680890083312988,
-0.2535581886768341,
-0.02295381762087345,
-0.24280472099781036,
-0.008187861181795597,
-0.008624444715678692,
-0.13949939608573914,
-0.40397879481315613,
0.7885599136352539,
-0.5342217087745667,
0.5306097269058228,
0.20441670715808868,
-0.4852975904941559,
-0.10709773004055023,
0.0002735034504439682,
0.16957560181617737,
0.7357176542282104,
-0.020879320800304413,
0.21079279482364655,
0.15401224792003632,
-0.37806737422943115,
0.23069605231285095,
0.15511097013950348,
-0.0021999944001436234,
-0.018207257613539696,
0.2552863657474518,
0.8245399594306946,
-0.1422153264284134,
-0.926550567150116,
0.48238927125930786,
-0.31338825821876526,
0.07911836355924606,
-0.4400462210178375,
0.5465683341026306,
-0.23853284120559692,
0.6529419422149658,
0.6704078912734985,
-0.11899908632040024,
0.4129447638988495,
-0.41884511709213257,
0.23492339253425598,
0.7949776649475098,
-0.08215582370758057,
-0.06423172354698181,
0.6566610336303711,
0.06406748294830322,
-0.501215398311615,
0.6241472959518433,
-0.2854601740837097,
-0.3387375473976135,
0.4797465205192566,
0.31779614090919495,
0.6133039593696594,
0.008435534313321114,
0.2796950340270996,
0.10758812725543976,
0.013554228469729424,
-0.17615613341331482,
0.3506908416748047,
-0.28916800022125244,
-0.80251145362854,
-0.32351478934288025,
-0.501772940158844,
-0.5812520384788513,
0.06607851386070251,
-0.35301512479782104,
0.5162772536277771,
-0.2483023703098297,
-0.3478596806526184,
0.03401150926947594,
0.00884599331766367,
-0.9762563109397888,
-0.037451762706041336,
0.0745963454246521,
0.835862934589386,
-0.29110482335090637,
0.5953300595283508,
0.8134061694145203,
-0.5063929557800293,
-0.6528721451759338,
-0.09607211500406265,
-0.005224741529673338,
-1.166782021522522,
0.7356646060943604,
0.38450872898101807,
-0.3324437737464905,
0.17966903746128082,
-0.6811048984527588,
-0.7964771389961243,
1.160086989402771,
0.8308085203170776,
-0.5218595862388611,
-0.1349281221628189,
0.11385805159807205,
0.5541937351226807,
-0.4031451940536499,
0.632309079170227,
0.2933107316493988,
0.5716434121131897,
0.33833029866218567,
-0.8582943677902222,
0.0689728632569313,
-0.5052053928375244,
0.11032974720001221,
-0.11034677177667618,
-0.534571647644043,
0.3522605299949646,
-0.2908540368080139,
0.05378260463476181,
0.08916983008384705,
0.48033416271209717,
0.25359731912612915,
0.5151394605636597,
0.7434893846511841,
0.46178552508354187,
0.827822208404541,
0.2337716817855835,
1.0518935918807983,
-0.2679925858974457,
-0.04760994017124176,
0.6046222448348999,
-0.20934204757213593,
0.589764416217804,
0.45859861373901367,
0.17874933779239655,
0.49262097477912903,
0.56275475025177,
-0.019747603684663773,
0.491943359375,
0.06622088700532913,
-0.5234882831573486,
-0.6482399702072144,
-0.4506054222583771,
-0.05561619997024536,
0.49504393339157104,
0.22750738263130188,
-0.19061890244483948,
-0.1324884593486786,
0.4664001166820526,
-0.35191810131073,
-0.13332708179950714,
-0.2918699383735657,
1.0425060987472534,
0.14397430419921875,
-0.8004295229911804,
0.6790384650230408,
-0.2117680311203003,
0.6936240792274475,
-0.32977983355522156,
-0.3789101839065552,
-0.25044992566108704,
0.24954046308994293,
-0.012717326171696186,
-0.4943392276763916,
-0.026283038780093193,
-0.36224451661109924,
0.055802710354328156,
-0.1356658786535263,
0.8377407193183899,
-0.2582952082157135,
-0.343862384557724,
0.19132256507873535,
0.6699795722961426,
0.35581982135772705,
-0.32908737659454346,
-0.7762182354927063,
0.12956157326698303,
-0.19465771317481995,
-0.2666325271129608,
0.16747106611728668,
0.33804136514663696,
-0.21879391372203827,
1.247750997543335,
0.5397846698760986,
0.09600406140089035,
-0.4490911662578583,
0.2287997454404831,
1.037613868713379,
-0.607178807258606,
-0.2685548961162567,
-0.7678698897361755,
0.2908916771411896,
-0.04699817672371864,
-0.009323913604021072,
0.5693008899688721,
0.5164441466331482,
0.6565573215484619,
-0.0340096578001976,
0.6340444087982178,
0.07177567481994629,
0.2774766981601715,
-0.35119861364364624,
0.5334764122962952,
-0.8923847079277039,
0.5582287907600403,
-0.08626440912485123,
-1.075966715812683,
-0.3589441776275635,
0.7961978316307068,
-0.16555199027061462,
0.16456234455108643,
0.3906310200691223,
1.2289272546768188,
0.02185174822807312,
-0.42105695605278015,
0.6194205284118652,
0.07395640015602112,
0.486581027507782,
0.32194897532463074,
1.0420933961868286,
-0.18487577140331268,
0.6297347545623779,
-0.06706036627292633,
-0.11269419640302658,
-0.405322402715683,
-0.6670529246330261,
-0.9765968918800354,
-0.6688106656074524,
-0.3074055016040802,
-0.09938082844018936,
0.43773555755615234,
1.422171711921692,
0.7676647901535034,
-0.3900424540042877,
-0.22804546356201172,
0.22059126198291779,
0.42338988184928894,
-0.22193831205368042,
-0.22285683453083038,
0.10016756504774094,
-0.5119388103485107,
-0.6666963696479797,
0.5175389051437378,
0.22687500715255737,
-0.25281256437301636,
-0.36268144845962524,
-0.21906879544258118,
0.05621045455336571,
0.0776338130235672,
0.7583606243133545,
-0.00959757436066866,
-0.7484023571014404,
-0.3045675456523895,
0.1805938333272934,
-0.019929395988583565,
0.34511902928352356,
0.5743198990821838,
-1.2444632053375244,
0.7398861050605774,
0.3614058792591095,
0.5792274475097656,
0.29122889041900635,
0.06852251291275024,
0.6556676626205444,
-0.8520644307136536,
-0.014415946789085865,
0.40267089009284973,
0.14567987620830536,
0.46798330545425415,
-0.7493062615394592,
0.5981154441833496,
0.017950832843780518,
-0.5599440932273865,
-0.9082944989204407,
0.0034868395887315273,
-0.7520330548286438,
-0.20658014714717865,
1.1974214315414429,
0.18792662024497986,
-0.2925933301448822,
-0.3317506015300751,
-0.6034234762191772,
0.17412911355495453,
-0.8906114101409912,
1.0083118677139282,
0.4192752242088318,
-0.35245585441589355,
-0.3201884925365448,
-0.34066906571388245,
0.46851468086242676,
0.39475104212760925,
-0.6959748268127441,
-0.19050799310207367,
0.6212524175643921,
0.14217866957187653,
0.15494322776794434,
0.6640383005142212,
0.16752949357032776,
0.38024625182151794,
-0.18198461830615997,
0.14964450895786285,
-0.26672711968421936,
-0.3283040523529053,
-0.30095791816711426,
0.05089833214879036,
0.4304061532020569,
0.08652082085609436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11194v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11194v1 | In-Context Editing: Learning Knowledge from Self-Induced Distributions | 2024-06-17T04:00:04 | 2024-06-17T04:00:04 | Siyuan Qi, Bangcheng Yang, Kailin Jiang, Xiaobo Wang, Jiaqi Li, Yifan Zhong, Yaodong Yang, Zilong Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | The existing fine-tuning paradigm for language models is brittle in knowledge
editing scenarios, where the model must incorporate new information without
extensive retraining. This brittleness often results in overfitting, reduced
performance, and unnatural language generation. To address this, we propose
Consistent In-Context Editing (ICE), a novel approach that leverages the
model's in-context learning capability to tune toward a contextual distribution
rather than a one-hot target. ICE introduces a straightforward optimization
framework that includes both a target and a procedure, enhancing the robustness
and effectiveness of gradient-based tuning methods. We provide analytical
insights into ICE across four critical aspects of knowledge editing: accuracy,
locality, generalization, and linguistic quality, showing its advantages.
Experimental results across four datasets confirm the effectiveness of ICE and
demonstrate its potential for continual editing, ensuring that updated
information is incorporated while preserving the integrity of the model. | [
-0.142765074968338,
-0.8046543002128601,
0.32841092348098755,
0.1647336333990097,
-0.0763474553823471,
-0.053540218621492386,
-0.620904266834259,
-0.19383737444877625,
-0.20650696754455566,
0.3668804466724396,
-0.42130160331726074,
-0.4644269347190857,
-0.37402063608169556,
0.08955038338899612,
-0.3936287760734558,
1.2182700634002686,
-0.2346988320350647,
-0.09657052904367447,
-0.28257471323013306,
-0.3286803364753723,
-0.6664432287216187,
-0.2870890200138092,
-0.6873189806938171,
-0.0938754603266716,
0.23795044422149658,
0.6338419914245605,
0.8130092620849609,
1.13539457321167,
0.25868597626686096,
0.23063193261623383,
-0.1334628164768219,
0.3011103868484497,
-0.6339831352233887,
0.1969381421804428,
-0.5807218551635742,
-0.23930884897708893,
-0.36371734738349915,
-0.016978153958916664,
0.9154684543609619,
0.6057958602905273,
-0.1827644556760788,
0.045955974608659744,
0.42067059874534607,
0.6585311889648438,
-0.8942448496818542,
-0.2660514712333679,
-0.9964214563369751,
-0.1861667037010193,
-0.3206096887588501,
-0.05798853933811188,
-0.34027308225631714,
-0.09700628370046616,
0.06031100079417229,
-0.6776701211929321,
0.1976310908794403,
-0.17512157559394836,
0.6067142486572266,
0.6803454756736755,
-0.20788298547267914,
-0.29475462436676025,
-0.5373263359069824,
0.7303394079208374,
-0.6230620741844177,
0.544259250164032,
0.39320531487464905,
-0.050325050950050354,
-0.1973741352558136,
-0.6129332184791565,
-0.5032936334609985,
0.2317834347486496,
0.058925263583660126,
-0.08104383945465088,
-0.003946867771446705,
0.034008417278528214,
-0.08842622488737106,
-0.03335755690932274,
-0.13369441032409668,
0.08433487266302109,
0.002193945227190852,
-0.03351032733917236,
0.5716850757598877,
0.07931968569755554,
0.4159407317638397,
-0.04956645146012306,
-0.09773825854063034,
0.0952799916267395,
-0.8641018867492676,
0.008875852450728416,
0.18519309163093567,
0.2915879189968109,
-0.004575392231345177,
0.36542269587516785,
-0.28614312410354614,
0.9589745998382568,
0.54471355676651,
-0.295309841632843,
0.03787657991051674,
-0.0789351686835289,
-0.4200693666934967,
0.05181015282869339,
0.566613495349884,
0.5515554547309875,
-0.07725638896226883,
-0.34333235025405884,
-0.3403441607952118,
-0.3206517696380615,
0.10687413066625595,
-0.43084123730659485,
-0.2646123766899109,
0.14312919974327087,
-0.20743414759635925,
-0.49783948063850403,
-0.2212318629026413,
-0.5277664661407471,
-0.1915568709373474,
-0.4531400203704834,
0.36355698108673096,
-0.6516613364219666,
0.0698704645037651,
0.11902651190757751,
-0.2684367597103119,
-0.4123457670211792,
0.21993428468704224,
-1.2440308332443237,
0.1195206567645073,
0.6710785627365112,
0.7760603427886963,
-0.13333436846733093,
-0.6691115498542786,
-0.586098313331604,
0.6095893383026123,
-0.5180443525314331,
0.761253833770752,
-0.8025816082954407,
-0.19244156777858734,
-0.039576511830091476,
-0.3877981901168823,
0.011716422624886036,
-0.6473686695098877,
0.31388530135154724,
-0.502751886844635,
-0.09684567153453827,
-0.18554483354091644,
-0.9575021266937256,
0.26684099435806274,
0.0621614009141922,
-0.22489193081855774,
1.1908737421035767,
0.3531515598297119,
-0.6374819874763489,
0.9887280464172363,
-0.7174187898635864,
-0.5257571935653687,
-0.10260801762342453,
0.12101966887712479,
-0.32860103249549866,
0.19115571677684784,
0.23922821879386902,
0.4400615096092224,
0.008202772587537766,
0.5566411018371582,
-0.3122789263725281,
-0.0008535826345905662,
0.13149644434452057,
-0.0856747031211853,
0.4686327576637268,
0.3707963526248932,
-0.29256147146224976,
0.04849958047270775,
-0.7734272480010986,
-0.1343984603881836,
-0.36936184763908386,
-0.5492578148841858,
-0.5953997373580933,
0.11851616203784943,
-0.02866942062973976,
0.1352510005235672,
0.17863111197948456,
-0.5726680159568787,
0.49782776832580566,
-0.29772764444351196,
0.5167788863182068,
0.920713484287262,
0.20017999410629272,
0.9376339912414551,
-0.10596165806055069,
0.30228301882743835,
0.04122672602534294,
0.3351757526397705,
-0.040588051080703735,
-0.18570977449417114,
-0.4721980690956116,
-0.3223208785057068,
0.4570544362068176,
0.5066432356834412,
-0.8000136613845825,
0.30559420585632324,
-0.15685921907424927,
-0.47160986065864563,
-0.5310213565826416,
0.6883209943771362,
0.34509527683258057,
1.0242902040481567,
0.44507166743278503,
-0.01769762858748436,
-0.3409390449523926,
-0.7749779224395752,
-0.8036898374557495,
0.2098434567451477,
0.05525043234229088,
0.2763291299343109,
0.24793188273906708,
-0.37112849950790405,
1.3910900354385376,
-0.46338221430778503,
-0.3181779682636261,
-0.1346348226070404,
0.1712043136358261,
-0.13650451600551605,
0.9010252356529236,
0.7175595760345459,
-0.5958561897277832,
-0.8930292725563049,
0.09705980122089386,
-0.9945551753044128,
-0.22643955051898956,
-0.21849650144577026,
-0.33463388681411743,
0.07709804177284241,
0.8066625595092773,
-0.2688421905040741,
0.206901416182518,
0.4456373155117035,
-0.2450898140668869,
0.2931634783744812,
-0.23013491928577423,
0.011462586000561714,
-1.0428646802902222,
-0.13060764968395233,
0.008524972945451736,
-0.13095203042030334,
-0.8773433566093445,
0.1677713245153427,
0.4837978780269623,
-0.018774664029479027,
-0.40689197182655334,
0.8296645879745483,
-0.22360150516033173,
0.5233047008514404,
-0.10166696459054947,
0.028805656358599663,
-0.135185107588768,
0.26497918367385864,
-0.1350363940000534,
0.6934006214141846,
0.6918627619743347,
-0.6367973685264587,
0.059082552790641785,
0.29277554154396057,
-0.6557907462120056,
0.8105977177619934,
-0.48076021671295166,
0.32170921564102173,
-0.44021886587142944,
0.12986800074577332,
-0.46932536363601685,
-0.38509780168533325,
0.2533113360404968,
-0.07379798591136932,
0.5306226015090942,
-0.3646203577518463,
-0.4674091041088104,
0.4257860779762268,
-0.12517651915550232,
0.6129185557365417,
0.23280340433120728,
-0.7576874494552612,
0.36625751852989197,
0.5285011529922485,
-0.00032685743644833565,
-0.7333241701126099,
-0.5309655666351318,
0.12990902364253998,
-0.46355369687080383,
-0.7695911526679993,
0.49382227659225464,
-0.34634193778038025,
-0.3888809382915497,
0.08547855913639069,
0.048300597816705704,
-0.17834578454494476,
0.07857593148946762,
-0.25304514169692993,
-0.15489308536052704,
0.08150782436132431,
0.35281816124916077,
0.6559569835662842,
0.012306668795645237,
-0.35203343629837036,
-0.5400993227958679,
-0.05797195807099342,
0.25257888436317444,
0.0416731983423233,
-0.4482537806034088,
0.30426281690597534,
0.3689185380935669,
-0.16775567829608917,
0.7244787216186523,
0.2268342226743698,
-0.4055907130241394,
-0.3901797831058502,
-0.541938304901123,
-0.11684529483318329,
-0.5260284543037415,
0.224977046251297,
-0.6060826182365417,
-0.879584789276123,
0.4438578188419342,
-0.28813397884368896,
0.14825581014156342,
0.33554062247276306,
0.19314706325531006,
-0.29577115178108215,
0.9845215082168579,
0.8592890501022339,
-0.2393365502357483,
0.7965618968009949,
-0.006399629637598991,
0.02597220055758953,
-1.0966241359710693,
0.11809660494327545,
-0.44750967621803284,
-0.25490376353263855,
-0.4065787196159363,
-0.05041814595460892,
0.6447187662124634,
0.4983237683773041,
-0.24451789259910583,
0.12622180581092834,
-0.2848712205886841,
0.7684229016304016,
0.42593660950660706,
0.16546599566936493,
0.04386044666171074,
-0.10960336774587631,
-0.164186030626297,
-0.18772129714488983,
-1.0521737337112427,
-0.276720255613327,
1.1646792888641357,
0.19667749106884003,
0.7848086953163147,
0.1484186351299286,
0.6553539037704468,
0.28603053092956543,
0.5360831618309021,
-0.2473105937242508,
-0.041671887040138245,
-0.14420530200004578,
-0.6708882451057434,
-0.7598314881324768,
-0.3061525821685791,
-0.5717822909355164,
-0.04276357963681221,
-0.24150732159614563,
-0.8750866055488586,
0.4140182137489319,
0.7379035353660583,
-0.1401410698890686,
0.3552473187446594,
-0.628645122051239,
1.141370415687561,
0.07414114475250244,
-0.5644765496253967,
-0.22146075963974,
-0.573096752166748,
0.21854493021965027,
-0.28790509700775146,
0.5752744674682617,
0.03810489922761917,
0.1421137899160385,
0.4023417830467224,
-0.44524940848350525,
0.7765270471572876,
-0.12055017799139023,
-0.0005507366731762886,
0.21061857044696808,
0.43655720353126526,
0.747093141078949,
0.43136903643608093,
-0.29746878147125244,
0.08041047304868698,
-0.22323879599571228,
-0.39531075954437256,
-1.0537110567092896,
0.7136247158050537,
-0.7316864728927612,
-0.43210163712501526,
0.0422741137444973,
-0.6869370937347412,
-0.27922043204307556,
0.17047899961471558,
0.46715298295021057,
0.9090955853462219,
-0.183958038687706,
0.1931474804878235,
0.6426145434379578,
-0.07879772037267685,
0.321195125579834,
0.3099101781845093,
0.12147808820009232,
-0.41039106249809265,
1.0066344738006592,
0.19608426094055176,
0.5575252771377563,
0.46106618642807007,
0.34513580799102783,
0.004963147919625044,
-0.6356797814369202,
-0.7517415881156921,
0.0342988595366478,
-1.02298903465271,
-0.2370844930410385,
-0.5867295861244202,
0.11347758769989014,
-0.4928635060787201,
-0.7959110736846924,
-0.5181039571762085,
-0.1945275515317917,
-0.32861635088920593,
0.0013386682840064168,
0.3018929362297058,
0.8364248275756836,
-0.5565275549888611,
0.37153226137161255,
-0.5746910572052002,
0.09057285636663437,
0.24444492161273956,
0.6354506015777588,
-0.27260664105415344,
-0.6571536064147949,
-0.6752384901046753,
0.1508214920759201,
-0.2153923660516739,
-0.740906834602356,
0.39223864674568176,
0.7018887996673584,
0.4570355713367462,
0.42537015676498413,
-0.030345801264047623,
0.9699931144714355,
-0.6949950456619263,
0.7617006897926331,
-0.18171922862529755,
-1.4202544689178467,
0.7267792224884033,
-0.4595986604690552,
0.6527777910232544,
0.809362530708313,
0.18426914513111115,
-0.9087424874305725,
-0.7716838717460632,
-0.5435264706611633,
-0.6396623253822327,
0.5577629208564758,
-0.07373493909835815,
0.3519846200942993,
-0.30332666635513306,
0.8459774255752563,
0.23865798115730286,
0.2639453709125519,
-0.5158542394638062,
-0.3032366931438446,
-0.37629517912864685,
-0.3144598603248596,
-0.21603722870349884,
-0.37399807572364807,
-0.18837417662143707,
-0.5703891515731812,
0.8726454973220825,
-0.3750097155570984,
-0.2437754124403,
0.27067801356315613,
-0.42899441719055176,
-0.416354238986969,
0.05907532200217247,
0.7907575964927673,
0.9708019495010376,
-0.13247992098331451,
0.10080648958683014,
0.4741746485233307,
-0.26468655467033386,
-0.0925675481557846,
-0.48610031604766846,
-0.5671161413192749,
-0.2077602595090866,
0.31578007340431213,
0.7151909470558167,
0.6669619083404541,
-0.4009701907634735,
0.21059153974056244,
-0.05433366447687149,
0.007682489231228828,
0.053935736417770386,
0.24162238836288452,
-0.2690488398075104,
0.032272741198539734,
0.11355453729629517,
0.46905291080474854,
0.18750061094760895,
-0.4770127534866333,
0.3238307237625122,
0.40245166420936584,
-0.42825737595558167,
-0.23650217056274414,
0.8309581279754639,
0.059202857315540314,
-0.3096562623977661,
0.7563908696174622,
-0.12753631174564362,
-0.3547063171863556,
0.15260209143161774,
0.6052625775337219,
0.8134286403656006,
-0.2557627558708191,
0.11410805583000183,
0.38466721773147583,
0.19325540959835052,
-0.026143208146095276,
-0.030307035893201828,
-0.1180860847234726,
-1.1089881658554077,
-0.22464486956596375,
-0.4475245475769043,
-0.23763643205165863,
-0.10602676868438721,
-0.5811326503753662,
0.4027780592441559,
-0.4646373391151428,
0.14235220849514008,
-0.07735659182071686,
-0.6424925923347473,
-0.658172070980072,
0.44669613242149353,
-0.4611685872077942,
0.9548658132553101,
-0.7293174862861633,
1.0014514923095703,
0.6216607689857483,
-0.04122008755803108,
-0.6595730185508728,
0.054232239723205566,
0.13803157210350037,
-0.36970600485801697,
0.39753103256225586,
-0.3612920939922333,
0.054794639348983765,
0.13915924727916718,
-0.9215758442878723,
-1.2383419275283813,
0.858559787273407,
0.6507890224456787,
-0.33668020367622375,
0.4088360071182251,
-0.10723942518234253,
0.4281368851661682,
-0.47769099473953247,
-0.1841968595981598,
0.6753538250923157,
0.36357414722442627,
-0.1766650676727295,
-0.9759089946746826,
-0.17254503071308136,
-0.08930712193250656,
-0.12068791687488556,
0.18250446021556854,
-0.6911596655845642,
0.6692612767219543,
0.032802291214466095,
-0.17708542943000793,
-0.3082648515701294,
0.7854348421096802,
-0.16706056892871857,
-0.02049316093325615,
0.4016774594783783,
0.6231290698051453,
0.8162385821342468,
0.20155400037765503,
1.0703753232955933,
-0.7199551463127136,
0.3533014953136444,
1.359790563583374,
-0.03698398545384407,
0.6831623911857605,
0.5313521027565002,
0.4212651550769806,
0.4694949686527252,
0.6118059754371643,
0.38792330026626587,
0.9482513070106506,
-0.13817602396011353,
-0.4315848648548126,
-0.1373049020767212,
-0.08704547584056854,
-0.09446858614683151,
0.45830443501472473,
0.3255222737789154,
-0.14084267616271973,
-0.024507854133844376,
0.03991656005382538,
0.41066110134124756,
0.2412082403898239,
-0.25066426396369934,
0.8791552186012268,
-0.11488990485668182,
-0.8435773253440857,
0.5135076642036438,
0.24765558540821075,
0.482257604598999,
-0.34606435894966125,
0.08252370357513428,
-0.3156733512878418,
0.013204006478190422,
-0.16025298833847046,
-0.6558077931404114,
0.553009033203125,
-0.004473804961889982,
-0.2655782401561737,
-0.5154430270195007,
0.5602059364318848,
-0.5986744165420532,
-0.40137991309165955,
-0.06016985699534416,
0.23131752014160156,
-0.10733728855848312,
0.013240110129117966,
-0.5495615005493164,
0.116771399974823,
-0.1469331830739975,
-0.2268131524324417,
0.5282752513885498,
0.658499002456665,
0.1425119787454605,
0.7533054351806641,
0.497099906206131,
0.010379483923316002,
0.022055665031075478,
-0.13322165608406067,
0.7402611970901489,
-0.3873074948787689,
-0.6174135208129883,
-0.928354799747467,
0.7622058987617493,
-0.05473491549491882,
-0.8692068457603455,
0.5419551730155945,
0.4042988121509552,
1.145363211631775,
-0.055227410048246384,
1.025773525238037,
-0.05609271675348282,
0.22092241048812866,
-0.6665920615196228,
0.7554612755775452,
-0.6868401169776917,
-0.0210152268409729,
-0.6142370700836182,
-0.7866373062133789,
-0.5373229384422302,
0.5403773188591003,
-0.16712871193885803,
-0.32135218381881714,
0.5983177423477173,
0.7574536204338074,
-0.24580591917037964,
-0.2549082636833191,
0.40258851647377014,
0.26934993267059326,
0.22496579587459564,
0.06464879214763641,
0.46667689085006714,
-0.33642324805259705,
-0.07597685605287552,
-0.5615360140800476,
-0.331603080034256,
0.07987851649522781,
-1.0716685056686401,
-0.8352404236793518,
-0.8725094199180603,
-0.3332666754722595,
-0.11571712791919708,
0.28232279419898987,
1.18650484085083,
0.8979584574699402,
-0.6382691264152527,
-0.2338298261165619,
-0.014188253320753574,
0.24207746982574463,
-0.42778393626213074,
-0.17811737954616547,
0.3235511779785156,
-0.6979511380195618,
-0.7785540223121643,
0.7392610311508179,
0.4620032012462616,
-0.23488737642765045,
0.07967526465654373,
-0.1005588173866272,
0.0056798723526299,
0.12111278623342514,
0.5893754363059998,
0.27115297317504883,
-0.476069837808609,
-0.7746533751487732,
-0.3056187927722931,
-0.01882912963628769,
0.03254879638552666,
0.7339445352554321,
-0.45142874121665955,
0.8737744688987732,
0.22123406827449799,
0.678985595703125,
0.2702327370643616,
0.04109896719455719,
0.9881070256233215,
-0.9799750447273254,
0.10157249122858047,
-0.06737866252660751,
0.2972496449947357,
0.347150057554245,
-0.7041065692901611,
0.3096286952495575,
0.14890572428703308,
-0.7798166275024414,
-0.7839890122413635,
0.18219731748104095,
-0.5218612551689148,
-0.2813258767127991,
1.1626644134521484,
-0.11916650086641312,
-0.1719467043876648,
-0.16795945167541504,
-0.15605537593364716,
0.2555544376373291,
-0.4419225752353668,
1.160225510597229,
0.759818434715271,
-0.23636513948440552,
-0.11241249740123749,
-0.3203422725200653,
1.0750541687011719,
0.36807578802108765,
-0.6251505017280579,
0.11869259178638458,
0.5219969153404236,
0.6343340873718262,
-0.2665848135948181,
0.4854912757873535,
0.29957032203674316,
0.3358348608016968,
-0.29113686084747314,
0.07465043663978577,
0.1966945230960846,
-0.5961019992828369,
-0.4953635632991791,
0.12755602598190308,
0.23455072939395905,
0.37965404987335205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11193v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11193v1 | MMNeuron: Discovering Neuron-Level Domain-Specific Interpretation in Multimodal Large Language Model | 2024-06-17T03:59:44 | 2024-06-17T03:59:44 | Jiahao Huo, Yibo Yan, Boren Hu, Yutao Yue, Xuming Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Projecting visual features into word embedding space has become a significant
fusion strategy adopted by Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs). However,
its internal mechanisms have yet to be explored. Inspired by multilingual
research, we identify domain-specific neurons in multimodal large language
models. Specifically, we investigate the distribution of domain-specific
neurons and the mechanism of how MLLMs process features from diverse domains.
Furthermore, we propose a three-stage framework for language model modules in
MLLMs when handling projected image features, and verify this hypothesis using
logit lens. Extensive experiments indicate that while current MLLMs exhibit
Visual Question Answering (VQA) capability, they may not fully utilize
domain-specific information. Manipulating domain-specific neurons properly will
result in a 10\% change of accuracy at most, shedding light on the development
of cross-domain, all-encompassing MLLMs in the future. Our code will be
released upon paper notification. | [
-0.5539456605911255,
-0.850035548210144,
0.5330054759979248,
0.15142230689525604,
0.029479214921593666,
-0.23053573071956635,
-0.11901780217885971,
-0.39143091440200806,
0.1830599009990692,
0.3812573552131653,
-0.6519564986228943,
-0.4448503851890564,
-0.5907245874404907,
-0.20529904961585999,
-0.3803517818450928,
0.5851316452026367,
0.15363703668117523,
0.13846218585968018,
-0.291948527097702,
-0.2667844593524933,
-0.3753552734851837,
-0.668189287185669,
-0.37440112233161926,
-0.3825484812259674,
0.9089076519012451,
0.05378233641386032,
0.44186893105506897,
0.2882063090801239,
0.3723180294036865,
0.27185946702957153,
-0.13773159682750702,
0.21883033215999603,
-0.1572408229112625,
-0.06044764071702957,
-0.15469606220722198,
-0.4341779053211212,
-0.4778526723384857,
-0.26615259051322937,
0.6936870813369751,
0.777362585067749,
-0.1885126531124115,
-0.021785862743854523,
0.015370354056358337,
0.08871930092573166,
-0.6022206544876099,
0.0704573541879654,
-0.8045397400856018,
0.10128086060285568,
0.05073264241218567,
-0.277591347694397,
-0.6077147722244263,
0.20503440499305725,
0.31625866889953613,
-0.41875770688056946,
0.3710266649723053,
0.026443829759955406,
0.730786144733429,
-0.12451086193323135,
-0.5586491823196411,
0.05547754466533661,
-0.34776896238327026,
0.7914314866065979,
-0.6876698136329651,
0.31742721796035767,
0.1870657503604889,
0.2532861828804016,
0.040031202137470245,
-0.8015218377113342,
-0.7061121463775635,
-0.37339672446250916,
-0.05170268192887306,
-0.15404808521270752,
-0.1732587218284607,
0.006407338194549084,
0.2928404211997986,
0.06999537348747253,
-0.7075331211090088,
0.10833106189966202,
-0.2640047073364258,
-0.2928524911403656,
0.3669205904006958,
0.1288340538740158,
0.41140687465667725,
-0.23623308539390564,
-0.3700924813747406,
0.04814906790852547,
-0.6853723526000977,
-0.3478708863258362,
0.28716400265693665,
0.1381482630968094,
0.03478410467505455,
0.8068177103996277,
-0.05808025225996971,
0.8552594184875488,
-0.321638822555542,
0.07130994647741318,
0.4015393555164337,
-0.22530847787857056,
-0.2930324971675873,
-0.1224801167845726,
0.6081531643867493,
0.5037496089935303,
0.4057167172431946,
0.17229780554771423,
-0.3007253110408783,
-0.05294385179877281,
0.3434198498725891,
-0.6357932686805725,
-0.1352950483560562,
0.04554085433483124,
-0.5513060688972473,
-0.27388519048690796,
-0.35186320543289185,
-0.512883722782135,
-0.5244079232215881,
-0.06461453437805176,
0.5533248782157898,
-0.3510356545448303,
-0.5829495191574097,
0.10065070539712906,
-0.2990530729293823,
0.10418225824832916,
0.30167344212532043,
-1.079136848449707,
0.02934909239411354,
0.45382651686668396,
0.7801839709281921,
-0.2632887065410614,
-0.7573124170303345,
-0.25272074341773987,
0.07426635175943375,
-0.33745917677879333,
0.7579716444015503,
-0.6555923223495483,
-0.02189960703253746,
0.42276468873023987,
0.175984188914299,
-0.2759018540382385,
-0.6789448857307434,
0.29208025336265564,
-0.6385931968688965,
-0.03095468506217003,
0.04986027628183365,
-0.4439505338668823,
-0.317656934261322,
0.4291159212589264,
-0.6989331245422363,
0.5009592175483704,
-0.06887157261371613,
-0.6322259306907654,
0.3193444609642029,
-0.6848720908164978,
-0.22565999627113342,
-0.09638271480798721,
-0.2897723913192749,
-0.011308427900075912,
0.3613174259662628,
0.28621381521224976,
0.7427730560302734,
-0.12026210874319077,
0.21048285067081451,
-0.3472111225128174,
-0.06053721532225609,
0.5490182042121887,
-0.5630660653114319,
0.4810512065887451,
0.014919298700988293,
-0.19961349666118622,
0.29558926820755005,
-0.535479724407196,
0.08583500981330872,
0.11120104044675827,
-0.1403585523366928,
-0.28353139758110046,
-0.0016260332195088267,
0.19858130812644958,
0.4593178629875183,
0.1968187838792801,
-0.45290443301200867,
0.2892468273639679,
-0.07988232374191284,
0.571143627166748,
0.765537440776825,
0.04062069579958916,
0.5956614017486572,
0.11203549057245255,
0.2977493703365326,
0.395480751991272,
0.2484891563653946,
-0.3077799379825592,
-0.7813940644264221,
-0.6281657218933105,
-0.06325625628232956,
0.14462946355342865,
0.3027520477771759,
-0.9066612720489502,
-0.06387516111135483,
-0.05656212195754051,
-0.10111147165298462,
-0.4133356213569641,
0.04366186261177063,
0.31506454944610596,
0.10595626384019852,
0.36812299489974976,
-0.3300713896751404,
-0.16338509321212769,
-1.3597675561904907,
0.013786588795483112,
0.1352722942829132,
0.06401728093624115,
0.4711107015609741,
0.5659096837043762,
-0.39824023842811584,
0.2959139347076416,
-0.5098973512649536,
-0.27062150835990906,
-0.3417149484157562,
0.1691705584526062,
0.0421954020857811,
0.40899044275283813,
0.5018100142478943,
-1.0888519287109375,
-0.18296848237514496,
0.2276783436536789,
-0.8959308862686157,
0.15425041317939758,
-0.19701868295669556,
-0.1034318208694458,
-0.002922388957813382,
0.581052839756012,
-0.8741777539253235,
0.4101595878601074,
0.7827197313308716,
-0.257356196641922,
0.6028907299041748,
-0.255022794008255,
0.14208978414535522,
-0.8975711464881897,
0.028719497844576836,
0.061994388699531555,
0.06370868533849716,
-0.7544625997543335,
0.1233883872628212,
0.14056667685508728,
-0.07337161898612976,
-0.46232539415359497,
0.5005394220352173,
-0.5001772046089172,
-0.2589823305606842,
-0.3534190356731415,
0.4252883493900299,
-0.05096108838915825,
0.7281873226165771,
0.09743743389844894,
0.4889170229434967,
0.7366036176681519,
-0.4830832779407501,
0.24195140600204468,
0.24260486662387848,
-0.6356590390205383,
0.3051320016384125,
-0.4985786974430084,
-0.10785605013370514,
-0.06687110662460327,
-0.07887707650661469,
-0.9569143652915955,
-0.1327558159828186,
0.03206830471754074,
-0.6096726655960083,
0.43625470995903015,
-0.15366767346858978,
-0.3414123058319092,
-0.18479092419147491,
0.1105634793639183,
0.44769078493118286,
0.25039955973625183,
-0.4349479079246521,
0.6880729794502258,
0.4776410758495331,
-0.08626838773488998,
-0.8109390139579773,
-0.7122482657432556,
0.1903989315032959,
0.1540125608444214,
-0.6607797741889954,
0.34980013966560364,
-0.04478086531162262,
-0.10440899431705475,
0.12317756563425064,
0.0019037277670577168,
-0.22825144231319427,
-0.090208999812603,
0.22413817048072815,
0.03735503926873207,
-0.4374573230743408,
0.25539904832839966,
-0.040016382932662964,
0.0706494152545929,
0.0049011860974133015,
-0.4251827299594879,
0.8167145848274231,
0.050134073942899704,
-0.4750436842441559,
-0.14812663197517395,
0.6085591316223145,
0.6500065326690674,
-0.49708619713783264,
0.7151793241500854,
0.6926843523979187,
-0.4718458354473114,
-0.3944958448410034,
-0.4083683490753174,
-0.3177874982357025,
-0.4474916458129883,
0.7341504096984863,
-0.7335965037345886,
-0.9455916881561279,
0.32750192284584045,
-0.1326911598443985,
-0.11617248505353928,
0.4827651381492615,
0.7504965662956238,
-0.01244257390499115,
1.390896201133728,
0.9022321105003357,
0.20301800966262817,
0.4349415600299835,
-0.35813477635383606,
0.24112927913665771,
-0.9956130385398865,
-0.325780987739563,
-0.079122394323349,
-0.3706337511539459,
-0.3503592908382416,
-0.5900145769119263,
0.12428062409162521,
-0.0896046981215477,
0.2045293152332306,
0.18431143462657928,
-0.3273996412754059,
0.40444138646125793,
0.5353138446807861,
-0.043373726308345795,
-0.004232346545904875,
0.15403780341148376,
-0.6383607983589172,
0.007391110062599182,
-0.8300386667251587,
-0.23774206638336182,
0.7847387790679932,
0.20138901472091675,
0.6184227466583252,
-0.052309148013591766,
0.2656041085720062,
0.24568262696266174,
0.23342908918857574,
-0.7065166234970093,
0.6652499437332153,
-0.19428882002830505,
-0.7467842698097229,
-0.10142666846513748,
-0.2659337520599365,
-0.7530062198638916,
0.5005461573600769,
-0.2722994089126587,
-0.8002262711524963,
0.3936779499053955,
0.010198318399488926,
-0.03821484372019768,
0.4340490996837616,
-0.7493107318878174,
1.1810671091079712,
-0.13834406435489655,
-0.2519281506538391,
-0.5448581576347351,
-0.41832152009010315,
0.3402933180332184,
-0.060104046016931534,
-0.08457333594560623,
-0.07512589544057846,
-0.05961405113339424,
0.42370331287384033,
0.05280594900250435,
0.8287893533706665,
-0.295492023229599,
-0.29785844683647156,
0.2900032699108124,
0.22509494423866272,
0.05939168110489845,
-0.10557794570922852,
0.09795621782541275,
0.29541322588920593,
-0.2602299451828003,
-0.3251446485519409,
-0.9098872542381287,
1.0670572519302368,
-0.4785102903842926,
-0.5528505444526672,
-0.17891879379749298,
-0.6995049715042114,
-0.267110139131546,
-0.038168102502822876,
0.19559532403945923,
0.5894514322280884,
-0.09040225297212601,
0.11334017664194107,
0.6434174180030823,
-0.38265109062194824,
0.5976889729499817,
0.1805783212184906,
-0.5710000395774841,
-0.32885798811912537,
1.0220762491226196,
0.01900322735309601,
0.3413386940956116,
0.4749434292316437,
-0.15664967894554138,
-0.12143169343471527,
-0.7473306655883789,
-0.5638999938964844,
0.24197039008140564,
-0.9045012593269348,
0.09164083749055862,
-0.7454288005828857,
-0.29691019654273987,
-0.11087437719106674,
0.030363330617547035,
-0.15876524150371552,
-0.5250843167304993,
-0.02712932601571083,
-0.10017798095941544,
-0.051048941910266876,
0.7508742213249207,
0.05173696205019951,
0.30154895782470703,
-0.7166424989700317,
0.28328463435173035,
0.3924461901187897,
0.21408891677856445,
0.22763483226299286,
-0.42535528540611267,
-0.4072103500366211,
0.09878890216350555,
-0.04358164593577385,
-0.7555356621742249,
0.5424344539642334,
0.4093104600906372,
0.6993004083633423,
0.4910699427127838,
-0.7372391819953918,
0.5079413652420044,
-0.8565870523452759,
0.933199942111969,
0.39135974645614624,
-0.707809329032898,
0.43957823514938354,
-0.10395626723766327,
0.34483686089515686,
-0.18619230389595032,
0.5392058491706848,
-0.602061927318573,
-0.20959752798080444,
-0.5362834930419922,
-0.6829208135604858,
0.34314873814582825,
0.10602287203073502,
0.4334936738014221,
0.021126488223671913,
0.23495838046073914,
0.03358278423547745,
0.3731662929058075,
-0.7417604923248291,
-0.26459401845932007,
-0.05483134463429451,
-0.032590411603450775,
-0.37478306889533997,
-0.42247647047042847,
-0.24580644071102142,
-0.16147829592227936,
0.3118463158607483,
-0.362460196018219,
0.662010669708252,
0.24206838011741638,
-0.38074246048927307,
0.18460823595523834,
0.09869329631328583,
1.0414059162139893,
0.8252730965614319,
-0.0646466389298439,
0.45273202657699585,
-0.008977929130196571,
-0.45232826471328735,
-0.02796746976673603,
-0.1335877776145935,
-0.007676835637539625,
0.30912765860557556,
0.4466499984264374,
0.9062833786010742,
-0.10367100685834885,
-0.6005682349205017,
0.6975257396697998,
-0.09246444702148438,
-0.38515332341194153,
-0.171657994389534,
-0.07507967203855515,
0.17051228880882263,
0.47676146030426025,
0.388950914144516,
0.4237394332885742,
0.14712585508823395,
-0.5643761157989502,
0.4314287304878235,
0.4451146125793457,
-0.5409483313560486,
-0.48702272772789,
0.5086101293563843,
-0.06239816173911095,
-0.16638164222240448,
0.5455312132835388,
0.02793806418776512,
-0.5931383967399597,
0.5818809866905212,
0.6347389221191406,
0.871307373046875,
-0.18784882128238678,
0.3281262516975403,
0.2164284586906433,
0.3471018075942993,
0.16830240190029144,
0.3144723176956177,
0.21973364055156708,
-1.0385338068008423,
-0.7038975358009338,
-0.5636152625083923,
0.08557642996311188,
0.04173874482512474,
-0.3073573708534241,
-0.03549185395240784,
-0.37065809965133667,
-0.3786199986934662,
0.3946819603443146,
-0.6502211689949036,
-0.4155038893222809,
0.24835191667079926,
0.5824950337409973,
0.9472314715385437,
-0.6577728390693665,
1.1081328392028809,
0.627086877822876,
-0.39796382188796997,
-0.40395021438598633,
-0.14045554399490356,
-0.08673609048128128,
-0.9371684789657593,
1.099149465560913,
0.10106608271598816,
-0.09172888845205307,
0.0140334228053689,
-0.8534849882125854,
-0.5633730888366699,
0.673077404499054,
0.20885708928108215,
-0.44695356488227844,
-0.04030989110469818,
0.04255951568484306,
0.3605414628982544,
-0.7382678985595703,
0.19419114291667938,
0.11265780031681061,
0.2920030355453491,
-0.038749124854803085,
-0.7749235033988953,
-0.05706777423620224,
-0.43262356519699097,
-0.014594304375350475,
0.22329717874526978,
-0.0850406214594841,
0.9834438562393188,
-0.41705089807510376,
0.04355636611580849,
-0.07627600431442261,
0.5914574861526489,
-0.09294484555721283,
0.10361501574516296,
0.3745405673980713,
0.5025451183319092,
0.5599150061607361,
0.006439002696424723,
1.081391453742981,
-0.13078053295612335,
0.19069038331508636,
0.9193549752235413,
-0.1627103090286255,
1.1542835235595703,
0.7363066673278809,
0.28924018144607544,
0.5589525103569031,
0.35871604084968567,
-0.17958985269069672,
0.6651301383972168,
0.2786972224712372,
-0.5114691853523254,
-0.2993353605270386,
-0.2578221559524536,
-0.19827044010162354,
0.3083052933216095,
0.5020182728767395,
-0.6066039800643921,
0.0701335072517395,
0.34985750913619995,
-0.3542402684688568,
-0.39680278301239014,
-0.35846829414367676,
0.6243464350700378,
0.41259437799453735,
-0.5302261114120483,
0.7265152335166931,
-0.04629886895418167,
0.6283510327339172,
-0.6518286466598511,
-0.2945697605609894,
-0.08352497220039368,
0.3159961700439453,
-0.18675850331783295,
-0.9077956676483154,
0.10126353055238724,
-0.29583629965782166,
-0.20139236748218536,
-0.21234242618083954,
0.8278986811637878,
-0.5328274965286255,
-0.18790139257907867,
0.5667481422424316,
0.7565893530845642,
0.05022982880473137,
-0.3601570725440979,
-0.6412789821624756,
-0.10963621735572815,
0.08254728466272354,
-0.2021978348493576,
0.44778725504875183,
0.4718063175678253,
-0.009336101822555065,
0.7589876651763916,
0.6658433079719543,
0.021762844175100327,
0.45698094367980957,
0.48933717608451843,
0.7923802733421326,
-0.5956869125366211,
0.05590185895562172,
-0.8579334020614624,
0.691292941570282,
-0.280900239944458,
-0.34153854846954346,
0.6996359825134277,
0.3815755248069763,
0.7883473634719849,
-0.46963033080101013,
0.6174240708351135,
-0.1450037658214569,
-0.11569276452064514,
-0.5138992071151733,
0.7515130639076233,
-0.9196949601173401,
-0.13567592203617096,
-0.07649286836385727,
-1.0409787893295288,
-0.507236897945404,
0.5836437940597534,
-0.13779914379119873,
-0.182789608836174,
1.0473121404647827,
1.03739333152771,
-0.2121630758047104,
-0.2165694683790207,
0.8633946776390076,
0.22739212214946747,
0.12527988851070404,
0.5032351016998291,
1.1641217470169067,
-0.28396013379096985,
0.5581815242767334,
-0.1875268816947937,
0.04269378259778023,
-0.10981949418783188,
-0.6203681826591492,
-0.7479346990585327,
-0.8555487990379333,
-0.38666388392448425,
-0.18289847671985626,
-0.0706275999546051,
0.41590237617492676,
0.8284755945205688,
-0.6425652503967285,
-0.24565312266349792,
0.12626151740550995,
0.06558885425329208,
-0.2660599648952484,
-0.17146709561347961,
0.23469160497188568,
-0.3387082517147064,
-0.5451216101646423,
0.34370359778404236,
0.47961166501045227,
-0.021746788173913956,
-0.32866549491882324,
0.08369500935077667,
-0.5301278233528137,
-0.02698167786002159,
0.9087767601013184,
-0.08326929062604904,
-0.7533207535743713,
-0.24301308393478394,
0.2935340106487274,
-0.21145477890968323,
0.15923218429088593,
0.9700590372085571,
-0.34973663091659546,
0.43127021193504333,
0.4871034324169159,
0.5526382327079773,
0.5470508337020874,
-0.5446938276290894,
0.7020334005355835,
-0.7125446200370789,
0.15544933080673218,
0.18959639966487885,
0.6708453893661499,
0.28068432211875916,
0.06298237293958664,
0.25260087847709656,
0.23617687821388245,
-0.4550255835056305,
-0.6529247164726257,
0.4347743093967438,
-1.0250155925750732,
-0.4764215052127838,
1.1073734760284424,
-0.12890565395355225,
-0.49711135029792786,
0.14393281936645508,
-0.42514970898628235,
-0.16379058361053467,
0.05989904701709747,
0.3568018972873688,
0.7574102878570557,
-0.00024007607134990394,
-0.5677000284194946,
-0.9357040524482727,
0.44646838307380676,
0.39236709475517273,
-0.5539640188217163,
-0.12365930527448654,
0.5435515642166138,
-0.02082224003970623,
0.5274438261985779,
0.3468811511993408,
-0.015529382042586803,
0.27631399035453796,
0.14337849617004395,
0.37995296716690063,
0.2714412212371826,
-0.6214979887008667,
-0.4762599766254425,
0.42403560876846313,
0.1149778813123703,
-0.18850955367088318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11192v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11192v1 | Beyond Boundaries: Learning a Universal Entity Taxonomy across Datasets and Languages for Open Named Entity Recognition | 2024-06-17T03:57:35 | 2024-06-17T03:57:35 | Yuming Yang, Wantong Zhao, Caishuang Huang, Junjie Ye, Xiao Wang, Huiyuan Zheng, Yang Nan, Yuran Wang, Xueying Xu, Kaixin Huang, Yunke Zhang, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Open Named Entity Recognition (NER), which involves identifying arbitrary
types of entities from arbitrary domains, remains challenging for Large
Language Models (LLMs). Recent studies suggest that fine-tuning LLMs on
extensive NER data can boost their performance. However, training directly on
existing datasets faces issues due to inconsistent entity definitions and
redundant data, limiting LLMs to dataset-specific learning and hindering
out-of-domain generalization. To address this, we present B2NERD, a cohesive
and efficient dataset for Open NER, normalized from 54 existing English or
Chinese datasets using a two-step approach. First, we detect inconsistent
entity definitions across datasets and clarify them by distinguishable label
names to construct a universal taxonomy of 400+ entity types. Second, we
address redundancy using a data pruning strategy that selects fewer samples
with greater category and semantic diversity. Comprehensive evaluation shows
that B2NERD significantly improves LLMs' generalization on Open NER. Our B2NER
models, trained on B2NERD, outperform GPT-4 by 6.8-12.0 F1 points and surpass
previous methods in 3 out-of-domain benchmarks across 15 datasets and 6
languages. | [
-0.3864246606826782,
-0.36199691891670227,
0.049486178904771805,
-0.07744605094194412,
-0.1972244679927826,
-0.041243258863687515,
-0.6092330813407898,
-0.5465477705001831,
-0.22893062233924866,
0.48457857966423035,
-0.22494767606258392,
-0.5578677654266357,
-0.6006577610969543,
0.05778924375772476,
-0.020361129194498062,
1.030296802520752,
-0.22830210626125336,
0.01218374166637659,
-0.036822982132434845,
-0.34115010499954224,
-0.3908340334892273,
-0.3262672424316406,
-0.766836941242218,
-0.4070265293121338,
0.4333961308002472,
0.6281340718269348,
0.4659239649772644,
0.5667964816093445,
0.5873470902442932,
0.09486829489469528,
0.02476692572236061,
0.4517597556114197,
-0.6524528861045837,
0.09597054123878479,
-0.5962359309196472,
-0.21117697656154633,
-0.057626254856586456,
-0.4211253225803375,
0.6804972887039185,
0.8996824622154236,
-0.19173911213874817,
0.1458434760570526,
0.041309382766485214,
0.5732613801956177,
-0.6306292414665222,
0.257191002368927,
-0.7691971063613892,
0.021023256704211235,
-0.42880910634994507,
0.2289532721042633,
-0.36084702610969543,
-0.19043470919132233,
0.33633604645729065,
-0.5963167548179626,
0.34052950143814087,
-0.16943570971488953,
1.2325891256332397,
0.20471668243408203,
-0.495503693819046,
-0.19420646131038666,
-0.9575588703155518,
0.5860336422920227,
-0.20682035386562347,
0.997442364692688,
0.026053259149193764,
0.22205229103565216,
-0.14531992375850677,
-0.7960891127586365,
-0.45048433542251587,
0.4137565493583679,
-0.03777982294559479,
-0.11211036145687103,
-0.5808470845222473,
-0.062555231153965,
0.3386887013912201,
0.19282959401607513,
-0.7519021034240723,
0.4277794361114502,
-0.40890154242515564,
-0.057987749576568604,
0.5614227652549744,
-0.11414829641580582,
0.287013977766037,
0.20795808732509613,
-0.4208552837371826,
-0.14626576006412506,
-0.9758819937705994,
-0.02539394609630108,
0.0921466052532196,
0.4177760183811188,
0.00945297721773386,
0.423448383808136,
-0.04160643368959427,
0.5120673179626465,
0.05467487499117851,
0.16931094229221344,
0.28283920884132385,
-0.03841891512274742,
-0.2951701283454895,
-0.11958056688308716,
0.5074257850646973,
0.41939929127693176,
0.4269174635410309,
-0.6143592000007629,
-0.2904367446899414,
-0.04460391774773598,
-0.02942655421793461,
-0.9014345407485962,
-0.4851841926574707,
0.07198089361190796,
-0.2264646738767624,
0.3608761727809906,
0.10201103240251541,
-0.7585354447364807,
-0.1566234529018402,
-0.5966144800186157,
0.21816924214363098,
-0.3550166189670563,
-0.4304488003253937,
0.04738909751176834,
-0.0623730830848217,
0.1762075126171112,
0.2516944706439972,
-0.7919664978981018,
0.6104736924171448,
0.7576906681060791,
0.8410205245018005,
-0.149038165807724,
-0.1967678815126419,
-0.43538984656333923,
0.20909300446510315,
-0.5291671752929688,
0.5995379686355591,
-0.4793790280818939,
-0.17642994225025177,
-0.2939162254333496,
0.1141035258769989,
-0.00839664414525032,
-0.9402543902397156,
0.2145305871963501,
-0.7556647658348083,
-0.20078396797180176,
-0.23637686669826508,
-0.6453931927680969,
-0.379866361618042,
0.11928118765354156,
-0.670647919178009,
0.8901491165161133,
0.36030152440071106,
-0.661287784576416,
0.772026538848877,
-0.5064725875854492,
-0.5131161212921143,
0.4938846528530121,
-0.3414210081100464,
-0.47531020641326904,
0.23678377270698547,
0.04723614826798439,
0.3590494394302368,
-0.35868391394615173,
0.5690633654594421,
-0.15464292466640472,
-0.10669112205505371,
-0.2541864812374115,
-0.021720755845308304,
0.6923282742500305,
-0.053230490535497665,
-0.1469576060771942,
-0.2321799397468567,
-0.6941767334938049,
0.06798416376113892,
0.07713662832975388,
-0.16111277043819427,
-0.778426468372345,
-0.11532209813594818,
0.14639395475387573,
0.18661576509475708,
-0.08390644192695618,
-0.717311680316925,
0.10342918336391449,
-0.43490877747535706,
0.35207971930503845,
0.5850220918655396,
0.06818462908267975,
0.4694077968597412,
-0.015575353056192398,
0.20028139650821686,
0.218650221824646,
-0.3099665343761444,
0.1254969984292984,
-0.4188868999481201,
-0.6401857137680054,
-0.257846862077713,
0.5915108323097229,
0.4752670228481293,
-0.5590441226959229,
0.6450755000114441,
-0.5550464987754822,
-0.6379042267799377,
-0.514072060585022,
0.20740795135498047,
0.45151960849761963,
0.6644368767738342,
0.6987395286560059,
-0.4915367364883423,
-0.7622819542884827,
-0.7229250073432922,
-0.022060487419366837,
0.09941758215427399,
-0.18151132762432098,
0.4282638728618622,
0.8154574036598206,
-0.5434074997901917,
1.0579280853271484,
-0.4181857109069824,
-0.49909940361976624,
-0.09187418222427368,
-0.27584436535835266,
0.047069862484931946,
0.4180048704147339,
0.03973018378019333,
-0.854641854763031,
-0.5505577325820923,
0.4330473840236664,
-0.7757890820503235,
0.2688091993331909,
0.10136915743350983,
-0.1906459778547287,
0.2540483772754669,
0.4488247334957123,
-0.5711546540260315,
0.3022984266281128,
0.3167594373226166,
-0.11622095853090286,
0.2335079312324524,
-0.04712427034974098,
-0.5241581201553345,
-0.9470838308334351,
0.13016760349273682,
0.2253071516752243,
0.12036051601171494,
-0.7555596232414246,
0.1676904410123825,
0.23566459119319916,
-0.19270282983779907,
-0.2953672707080841,
0.9358116388320923,
-0.7396835088729858,
-0.2002425342798233,
0.05143884941935539,
0.07270442694425583,
-0.08817877620458603,
0.2730763852596283,
0.43011805415153503,
0.5970933437347412,
0.7791688442230225,
-0.7778353691101074,
0.3210018575191498,
0.5069154500961304,
-0.4117792248725891,
0.554282009601593,
-0.5482852458953857,
0.22724825143814087,
-0.3565404713153839,
0.3071082830429077,
-0.609645664691925,
-0.34323394298553467,
0.09138897061347961,
-0.28332778811454773,
0.5615329146385193,
-0.413374125957489,
-0.33688756823539734,
-0.28486207127571106,
0.22055776417255402,
0.38235872983932495,
0.44292643666267395,
-0.9887485504150391,
0.6387763619422913,
0.4703182876110077,
-0.09882353246212006,
-0.48701125383377075,
-0.8065869212150574,
0.08041919767856598,
-0.06357645988464355,
-0.628812313079834,
0.4770619571208954,
0.21029822528362274,
-0.2494937926530838,
0.13073529303073883,
-0.37133052945137024,
-0.11534592509269714,
-0.0361088365316391,
0.14728601276874542,
0.015071412548422813,
-0.3519091010093689,
0.4191538691520691,
0.11900625377893448,
-0.06855594366788864,
-0.17630000412464142,
-0.6660234332084656,
0.5127316117286682,
0.02001466602087021,
-0.08810282498598099,
-0.25283724069595337,
0.12888750433921814,
-0.09411362558603287,
-0.48392483592033386,
0.45725464820861816,
0.412648469209671,
-0.8505550026893616,
-0.46982306241989136,
-0.19968397915363312,
-0.06335403025150299,
-0.403825581073761,
0.3949908912181854,
-0.6652780771255493,
-0.9551213383674622,
0.33031508326530457,
-0.14528752863407135,
0.2164204865694046,
0.3012472689151764,
0.4805457592010498,
0.32682913541793823,
0.43398937582969666,
0.7185956835746765,
0.06425119191408157,
0.07235200703144073,
-0.425495445728302,
0.3910309076309204,
-0.9666541814804077,
-0.5276414155960083,
-0.3562330901622772,
-0.2743660807609558,
-0.6883677244186401,
-0.47211024165153503,
0.024192670360207558,
0.2582619786262512,
-0.3106094002723694,
0.41850990056991577,
-0.44716066122055054,
0.7282820343971252,
0.35065674781799316,
0.09409316629171371,
0.19813284277915955,
0.313545823097229,
-0.05698100104928017,
-0.18238236010074615,
-0.3931487798690796,
-0.29876965284347534,
1.1987959146499634,
0.4054219722747803,
0.6844533681869507,
0.36469483375549316,
0.8887065052986145,
-0.02565518394112587,
0.4018908441066742,
-0.8114796876907349,
0.352527379989624,
-0.4156211018562317,
-0.5713658928871155,
-0.4066752791404724,
-0.5627435445785522,
-1.0709608793258667,
0.30116593837738037,
0.1132267415523529,
-0.8646169900894165,
0.44367867708206177,
-0.11312209069728851,
-0.15982083976268768,
0.5076689124107361,
-0.5742828845977783,
0.747493326663971,
-0.08209418505430222,
-0.2620571553707123,
0.22762686014175415,
-0.594429612159729,
0.32896414399147034,
-0.21972113847732544,
-0.03488395735621452,
0.013836933299899101,
-0.21329262852668762,
0.6054539084434509,
-0.13828177750110626,
0.45013734698295593,
-0.2309200018644333,
-0.2046036422252655,
0.22001253068447113,
0.07995423674583435,
0.4627073109149933,
0.2840895354747772,
0.030136000365018845,
0.5605906248092651,
-0.5696802735328674,
-0.3699391186237335,
-0.48558929562568665,
0.6374569535255432,
-0.735586404800415,
-0.2630171775817871,
-0.2719263434410095,
-0.3303893506526947,
-0.2581915855407715,
0.3919735550880432,
0.39744335412979126,
0.49141940474510193,
-0.3579230010509491,
0.2051495462656021,
0.9479621052742004,
-0.09799263626337051,
0.2262324094772339,
0.5444774627685547,
0.04643392935395241,
-0.5383320450782776,
1.0263340473175049,
0.30985912680625916,
0.12026432156562805,
0.499844491481781,
-0.20261476933956146,
-0.5090807676315308,
-0.5168646574020386,
-0.622998833656311,
0.20872770249843597,
-0.6011551022529602,
-0.37753555178642273,
-0.9048898816108704,
-0.28130027651786804,
-0.45350539684295654,
0.06440554559230804,
-0.23631435632705688,
-0.0975748673081398,
-0.28175148367881775,
-0.26096686720848083,
0.18231722712516785,
0.5876492261886597,
-0.16620340943336487,
0.1218172237277031,
-0.645043134689331,
0.3197542428970337,
0.05485435575246811,
0.6773049831390381,
0.06920482963323593,
-0.49296432733535767,
-0.09050032496452332,
0.08189814537763596,
-0.050360891968011856,
-0.5888004899024963,
0.30456113815307617,
0.5538793802261353,
0.3957851827144623,
0.5033032298088074,
-0.11668941378593445,
0.5963234901428223,
-0.5787031650543213,
0.35529467463493347,
0.27230146527290344,
-0.6817536354064941,
0.35950881242752075,
-0.12945039570331573,
0.01622960902750492,
0.4302345812320709,
0.8810840845108032,
-0.7046564817428589,
0.06911273300647736,
-0.6263033747673035,
-0.9862870573997498,
0.6556591987609863,
-0.04560204595327377,
0.050040535628795624,
-0.03052571229636669,
0.39461836218833923,
0.3154069185256958,
0.023554792627692223,
-0.5712289810180664,
-0.1804111748933792,
0.05421864613890648,
-0.2088315635919571,
-0.25734636187553406,
0.0678541362285614,
0.013018574565649033,
-0.18677210807800293,
0.6691554188728333,
-0.09397923946380615,
0.043776582926511765,
0.1093706414103508,
-0.39745378494262695,
-0.14980320632457733,
0.2389882653951645,
0.13677269220352173,
0.6069177389144897,
-0.02497231587767601,
0.17417225241661072,
0.1844167709350586,
-0.40065768361091614,
0.21063344180583954,
0.32266080379486084,
-0.49880537390708923,
0.13377556204795837,
0.08044205605983734,
0.819706380367279,
-0.1498112678527832,
-0.5922127366065979,
0.31704360246658325,
-0.0213408675044775,
-0.15354982018470764,
-0.1476847231388092,
0.014306526631116867,
0.040987469255924225,
0.1836606115102768,
0.20885486900806427,
0.08808141946792603,
0.07186875492334366,
-0.34488409757614136,
0.5446980595588684,
0.30926603078842163,
-0.5185916423797607,
-0.3451550602912903,
0.4259812533855438,
0.08621677756309509,
-0.2016936093568802,
0.9725565314292908,
-0.4874967932701111,
-0.3276176154613495,
0.5869045853614807,
0.702923059463501,
0.7287134528160095,
-0.16171367466449738,
0.057975348085165024,
0.5824909806251526,
0.3156377375125885,
-0.2499931901693344,
0.3197970688343048,
0.1405831128358841,
-0.9566807746887207,
-0.24567614495754242,
-0.5800679326057434,
-0.4710569679737091,
0.4872805178165436,
-0.699877917766571,
0.43528199195861816,
-0.6548954844474792,
-0.0024932415690273046,
0.12242025882005692,
0.034638211131095886,
-0.7585433721542358,
0.366158127784729,
0.15057367086410522,
0.976226270198822,
-0.7507539391517639,
0.5946908593177795,
0.9072213768959045,
-0.44215214252471924,
-0.8576474189758301,
0.0059346831403672695,
-0.10752376914024353,
-0.4371855854988098,
0.7103670239448547,
0.3440384268760681,
0.24392244219779968,
0.29093411564826965,
-0.3358883857727051,
-0.9452361464500427,
0.8971260190010071,
0.08968494087457657,
-0.9980131983757019,
-0.20663978159427643,
-0.08669796586036682,
0.5372360348701477,
-0.3209947347640991,
0.18119651079177856,
0.7234717011451721,
0.40452325344085693,
-0.028781238943338394,
-0.7873043417930603,
0.08390749990940094,
-0.11539261043071747,
0.14877402782440186,
0.7209351658821106,
-0.6239935755729675,
0.693778395652771,
-0.5986837148666382,
-0.5044113397598267,
-0.1597263216972351,
0.7221656441688538,
0.13773351907730103,
0.37020260095596313,
0.18856437504291534,
0.9480859041213989,
1.1421693563461304,
-0.36756348609924316,
0.4828452169895172,
0.004350560251623392,
0.4096064865589142,
1.3095660209655762,
-0.7048704624176025,
0.7784639000892639,
0.10054215788841248,
-0.05823737382888794,
0.44527262449264526,
0.6405879259109497,
-0.6044337749481201,
0.49123457074165344,
0.38814860582351685,
-0.28330671787261963,
-0.11844661831855774,
-0.27032148838043213,
-0.3006170988082886,
0.4743954837322235,
0.5443785190582275,
0.0787193700671196,
-0.6333701014518738,
0.11505629122257233,
0.001655414467677474,
0.04719248041510582,
-0.3450717329978943,
0.8625490069389343,
0.08286016434431076,
-0.5923294425010681,
0.5848660469055176,
0.23486298322677612,
0.6801751255989075,
-0.24255992472171783,
0.008709797635674477,
-0.27839145064353943,
0.4494416117668152,
-0.3823106586933136,
-0.7921423316001892,
0.18856437504291534,
0.04259774461388588,
-0.18537220358848572,
0.028587481006979942,
0.7835373878479004,
-0.7093441486358643,
-0.14020086824893951,
0.5157805681228638,
0.3767208158969879,
0.17684467136859894,
-0.007509997114539146,
-0.42748022079467773,
-0.3489350378513336,
-0.06670068949460983,
0.07363766431808472,
0.32150742411613464,
0.7625344395637512,
-0.45327675342559814,
0.6324287056922913,
0.7222996354103088,
0.12883245944976807,
-0.052383121103048325,
0.062083106487989426,
0.812972366809845,
-0.612415611743927,
-0.3060593008995056,
-0.6952090263366699,
0.17009159922599792,
0.02189795672893524,
-0.5007615089416504,
0.5154942274093628,
1.0446960926055908,
1.5018376111984253,
0.09075609594583511,
0.8550909161567688,
-0.149490624666214,
0.6476626992225647,
-0.3940648138523102,
0.42448580265045166,
-0.4638379216194153,
-0.07298067957162857,
0.12105926871299744,
-0.8665618300437927,
-0.4857712686061859,
0.3604576885700226,
-0.1558845192193985,
0.007711699232459068,
0.3590036928653717,
0.7680026888847351,
-0.37759929895401,
-0.14053352177143097,
0.13004933297634125,
0.15245619416236877,
0.30902376770973206,
0.6209900975227356,
0.5644240975379944,
-0.45658206939697266,
0.4470449388027191,
-0.17487117648124695,
-0.06867362558841705,
-0.04891252517700195,
-0.5099965929985046,
-0.8896484375,
-0.3334912955760956,
-0.323679655790329,
-0.3660576343536377,
0.2465270757675171,
0.9758971929550171,
0.631308376789093,
-0.9326574802398682,
-0.15927748382091522,
-0.3327370584011078,
0.03127691149711609,
-0.03806964308023453,
-0.22385954856872559,
0.28857892751693726,
-0.2647869288921356,
-0.5397744178771973,
0.23770149052143097,
0.25024348497390747,
0.1377045065164566,
0.12011051177978516,
-0.18924938142299652,
-0.060291994363069534,
-0.15502174198627472,
0.4266625642776489,
0.44844850897789,
-0.5811259746551514,
-0.13846074044704437,
-0.005541929509490728,
-0.05784596875309944,
0.07709667086601257,
0.5964847803115845,
-0.48744821548461914,
0.3246039152145386,
0.2578885853290558,
0.7751184105873108,
0.3613000512123108,
-0.0050822230987250805,
0.42957907915115356,
-0.8887359499931335,
-0.039610348641872406,
0.3464209735393524,
0.15855349600315094,
0.48313552141189575,
-0.17071908712387085,
0.7332984209060669,
0.2729005515575409,
-0.3360729217529297,
-0.8609662652015686,
0.36636602878570557,
-0.6112907528877258,
-0.16389179229736328,
1.2370067834854126,
-0.2948914170265198,
0.02620575577020645,
-0.262800395488739,
0.2191796600818634,
0.24344073235988617,
-0.4211052358150482,
0.26842421293258667,
0.5154047608375549,
0.07412170618772507,
-0.07022131979465485,
-0.26201435923576355,
0.4856344759464264,
-0.01685221865773201,
-0.689850389957428,
0.2927156090736389,
0.4715755879878998,
0.6173029541969299,
0.04273276776075363,
0.5210829973220825,
0.00995655171573162,
0.2825948894023895,
-0.15409408509731293,
0.27387818694114685,
0.0009647467522881925,
-0.7725826501846313,
-0.5452329516410828,
-0.0953008309006691,
-0.0962395891547203,
0.12000695616006851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11191v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11191v2 | A Survey on Human Preference Learning for Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T03:52:51 | 2024-06-18T08:18:33 | Ruili Jiang, Kehai Chen, Xuefeng Bai, Zhixuan He, Juntao Li, Muyun Yang, Tiejun Zhao, Liqiang Nie, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent surge of versatile large language models (LLMs) largely depends on
aligning increasingly capable foundation models with human intentions by
preference learning, enhancing LLMs with excellent applicability and
effectiveness in a wide range of contexts. Despite the numerous related studies
conducted, a perspective on how human preferences are introduced into LLMs
remains limited, which may prevent a deeper comprehension of the relationships
between human preferences and LLMs as well as the realization of their
limitations. In this survey, we review the progress in exploring human
preference learning for LLMs from a preference-centered perspective, covering
the sources and formats of preference feedback, the modeling and usage of
preference signals, as well as the evaluation of the aligned LLMs. We first
categorize the human feedback according to data sources and formats. We then
summarize techniques for human preferences modeling and compare the advantages
and disadvantages of different schools of models. Moreover, we present various
preference usage methods sorted by the objectives to utilize human preference
signals. Finally, we summarize some prevailing approaches to evaluate LLMs in
terms of alignment with human intentions and discuss our outlooks on the human
intention alignment for LLMs. | [
-0.4938114285469055,
-0.4109645187854767,
0.7384844422340393,
-0.027784695848822594,
-0.0496680773794651,
-0.07768478989601135,
-0.8194928765296936,
-0.49748191237449646,
0.12349704653024673,
0.6275914907455444,
-0.4333173632621765,
-0.5178458094596863,
-0.4772425591945648,
-0.02220969833433628,
0.02369573898613453,
0.667741060256958,
0.0883445292711258,
0.42091643810272217,
-0.14981688559055328,
-0.03963299095630646,
-0.33354324102401733,
-0.886078953742981,
-0.5301675796508789,
-0.7410682439804077,
0.695495069026947,
0.6702700257301331,
0.6365827918052673,
0.39803168177604675,
0.21492184698581696,
0.2880336046218872,
-0.01971568539738655,
-0.011287491768598557,
-0.45407170057296753,
-0.0014194760005921125,
-0.15455208718776703,
-0.34977635741233826,
-0.49996283650398254,
0.32771050930023193,
0.6190774440765381,
1.1204988956451416,
-0.2234112173318863,
0.22756658494472504,
0.10983547568321228,
0.9046340584754944,
-0.650260329246521,
-0.10855595022439957,
-0.5229185223579407,
0.05489475652575493,
-0.19344474375247955,
-0.10130934417247772,
-0.6554573178291321,
-0.3695153295993805,
0.6352037191390991,
-0.033140648156404495,
0.055071864277124405,
0.17140869796276093,
0.3643049895763397,
0.008466150611639023,
-0.8883006572723389,
-0.21074587106704712,
-0.5904039740562439,
1.3192814588546753,
-0.4856750965118408,
0.689297080039978,
0.5139893889427185,
0.4078831970691681,
-0.20366612076759338,
-0.08804802596569061,
-0.2874123454093933,
-0.30553480982780457,
0.12553149461746216,
-0.26472207903862,
0.2760545015335083,
0.09116210788488388,
-0.15117396414279938,
0.11914987117052078,
-0.48362118005752563,
0.5235409736633301,
-0.04083634167909622,
-0.19566860795021057,
0.8853034973144531,
0.20405204594135284,
0.03893750533461571,
-0.2121741622686386,
-0.34329310059547424,
-0.1877022683620453,
-0.8970606327056885,
0.3207717537879944,
0.42953503131866455,
0.2865495979785919,
-0.02849438413977623,
0.46592897176742554,
-0.28896984457969666,
1.0742814540863037,
0.09528089314699173,
-0.31435534358024597,
0.2435995638370514,
0.2975761592388153,
-0.10584533959627151,
-0.005806546658277512,
0.6975119113922119,
0.6425107717514038,
0.3476106822490692,
-0.212882861495018,
-0.19696763157844543,
-0.1766815483570099,
0.2381903976202011,
-0.542707622051239,
0.19558201730251312,
0.02029816433787346,
-0.6288096308708191,
-0.24302388727664948,
0.09464750438928604,
-0.5380184054374695,
-0.6238862872123718,
-0.7607515454292297,
-0.07115441560745239,
0.0378652885556221,
-0.27439600229263306,
0.41982635855674744,
0.3836485743522644,
0.4310300052165985,
0.48161780834198,
-1.3880808353424072,
0.1394462138414383,
0.8167774081230164,
0.4286665916442871,
-0.536995530128479,
-0.20072925090789795,
-0.37672922015190125,
-0.07037205994129181,
-0.18516585230827332,
0.678916871547699,
-0.48611363768577576,
-0.5740587115287781,
0.016027992591261864,
-0.17690443992614746,
0.2548736035823822,
-0.5161858797073364,
0.5817728042602539,
-0.6596759557723999,
0.21384434401988983,
-0.5199190378189087,
-0.5231896638870239,
-0.28108400106430054,
0.3967556953430176,
-0.3740110695362091,
0.5695275664329529,
0.016516895964741707,
-0.4104624092578888,
0.32178765535354614,
-0.4281085133552551,
-0.3310873508453369,
-0.13187222182750702,
-0.2624844014644623,
-0.1918756365776062,
0.1313336342573166,
-0.09320244193077087,
0.7732769846916199,
-0.37801283597946167,
0.6230939626693726,
-0.47913241386413574,
-0.12090570479631424,
0.6153386235237122,
-0.40793851017951965,
0.7232989072799683,
0.35685470700263977,
-0.1541793942451477,
0.3655810058116913,
-0.4143791198730469,
-0.01227271743118763,
0.09441789239645004,
-0.5796145796775818,
-0.23187385499477386,
0.19729436933994293,
0.08020523190498352,
0.17187145352363586,
0.42082321643829346,
-0.4052978456020355,
0.36137858033180237,
-0.37474367022514343,
0.5492841005325317,
1.143206238746643,
-0.3090396821498871,
0.7297524213790894,
-0.1927495300769806,
0.35374894738197327,
-0.3144666254520416,
0.2277871072292328,
0.3518805205821991,
-0.3137193024158478,
-0.6188648343086243,
0.10261362791061401,
0.23702038824558258,
0.03788271173834801,
0.12369734048843384,
0.647803544998169,
-0.24477849900722504,
-0.2681935131549835,
-0.24813970923423767,
0.35052937269210815,
0.2700328230857849,
0.37730851769447327,
0.16418907046318054,
-0.33276355266571045,
-0.6939231157302856,
-1.0843063592910767,
-0.18208253383636475,
-0.34283581376075745,
0.13395561277866364,
0.6187018752098083,
0.06759606301784515,
-0.2456253618001938,
1.1948269605636597,
-0.653469979763031,
0.15501435101032257,
-0.4610525667667389,
-0.2692160904407501,
0.12153149396181107,
0.11332166939973831,
0.5850726962089539,
-0.9453882575035095,
-0.6683658957481384,
-0.11136314272880554,
-0.2516568601131439,
0.18958652019500732,
0.617490828037262,
-0.10502016544342041,
0.32954731583595276,
0.12700103223323822,
-0.3497166931629181,
-0.1293601244688034,
0.8675224781036377,
-0.04324118793010712,
0.5643911361694336,
0.09917561709880829,
-0.0010563057148829103,
-1.048305869102478,
0.017642268911004066,
0.13385847210884094,
-0.3121625781059265,
-0.6452628970146179,
-0.3453395962715149,
0.07725401967763901,
0.3883611857891083,
-0.6713422536849976,
0.9386212229728699,
-0.5515080690383911,
-0.3127003610134125,
-0.34786751866340637,
0.04547986760735512,
-0.15671896934509277,
0.30318188667297363,
0.5316888093948364,
0.49912112951278687,
0.2562180757522583,
-0.595338761806488,
0.4028654396533966,
0.3622901141643524,
-0.3752153217792511,
0.3694641590118408,
-0.31481674313545227,
0.4150347411632538,
-0.18411999940872192,
0.3218119442462921,
-0.9629673957824707,
-0.5318665504455566,
0.20281364023685455,
-0.3731856048107147,
0.3920784890651703,
-0.2409495711326599,
-0.08253791183233261,
-0.18433670699596405,
-0.3452621102333069,
0.20223677158355713,
0.5909072756767273,
-0.7571261525154114,
0.3280709683895111,
0.6337043046951294,
-0.024416077882051468,
-0.9011591672897339,
-0.4813022017478943,
-0.0795089453458786,
-0.37067851424217224,
-0.39567437767982483,
0.07876116037368774,
-0.21993198990821838,
-0.469836562871933,
-0.3539547622203827,
0.023744018748402596,
0.15227608382701874,
0.20482347905635834,
0.24878056347370148,
0.5062926411628723,
0.024048257619142532,
0.2009221613407135,
-0.4232798218727112,
-0.11917737871408463,
-0.06922397762537003,
-0.31002694368362427,
0.7354493141174316,
-0.28766560554504395,
-0.38332992792129517,
-0.11444820463657379,
0.09649457782506943,
0.3921492099761963,
-0.16180559992790222,
0.4989297688007355,
0.18824875354766846,
-0.18962933123111725,
-0.009682931005954742,
-0.7486730217933655,
-0.28967413306236267,
-0.4078725278377533,
0.3491077125072479,
-0.0740162804722786,
-1.212736964225769,
-0.03402579575777054,
-0.04229516163468361,
0.07210397720336914,
0.254101037979126,
0.8365470767021179,
-0.20684173703193665,
1.1705753803253174,
0.6740216612815857,
-0.6257312893867493,
0.5529317259788513,
-0.0909421369433403,
0.19669483602046967,
-0.9206877946853638,
-0.1990577131509781,
-0.5625529885292053,
-0.4563877284526825,
-0.24747507274150848,
-0.004683458246290684,
0.2678094208240509,
0.04036014899611473,
-0.2843492329120636,
-0.010252862237393856,
-0.28902488946914673,
0.354148805141449,
0.07131896167993546,
0.022001435980200768,
0.33651480078697205,
-0.061671093106269836,
0.09099774807691574,
-0.03408638760447502,
-0.4134046137332916,
-0.7653045058250427,
1.2450324296951294,
0.4361066520214081,
0.8466442823410034,
0.33525922894477844,
0.6630985736846924,
-0.07637626677751541,
0.5989688634872437,
-1.025375247001648,
0.502616286277771,
-0.17869526147842407,
-0.7378023266792297,
-0.5430806875228882,
-0.33121559023857117,
-0.9090223908424377,
0.2742365300655365,
-0.2234584242105484,
-0.9726577997207642,
0.02082650177180767,
0.41666144132614136,
-0.26306137442588806,
0.28516095876693726,
-0.8146621584892273,
0.6990163922309875,
-0.717707633972168,
-0.3531063497066498,
-0.2181311547756195,
-0.7716422080993652,
0.512177050113678,
0.14041030406951904,
0.10003536194562912,
-0.23534071445465088,
-0.04329551011323929,
0.6478899121284485,
-0.02348426729440689,
1.1022104024887085,
-0.036464761942625046,
-0.3273305296897888,
-0.023464657366275787,
-0.3757542073726654,
0.4250609874725342,
-0.07308066636323929,
-0.28814831376075745,
0.02081882953643799,
-0.44209107756614685,
-0.14858821034431458,
-0.36307665705680847,
0.833593487739563,
-1.0062958002090454,
-0.8190634846687317,
-0.29406681656837463,
-0.47354423999786377,
-0.6965219974517822,
0.22954276204109192,
0.13172294199466705,
0.21933980286121368,
-0.3800915479660034,
0.22981296479701996,
0.775273323059082,
-0.08214785158634186,
0.2681732773780823,
0.5028616189956665,
-0.5628502368927002,
-0.20524530112743378,
0.818060040473938,
-0.08236602693796158,
0.4573555588722229,
0.5073304176330566,
0.4965626895427704,
-0.742576539516449,
-0.5597788095474243,
-0.32615160942077637,
0.3880254626274109,
-0.6702712178230286,
0.13617731630802155,
-0.5680629014968872,
0.015727927908301353,
-0.4202200472354889,
-0.31766805052757263,
-0.40996357798576355,
-0.255141943693161,
-0.42245495319366455,
-0.05076855048537254,
0.1310034543275833,
0.8183230757713318,
0.38184016942977905,
0.2522590458393097,
-0.7063536643981934,
0.041660357266664505,
0.5734540820121765,
0.5818419456481934,
0.24215932190418243,
-0.33988574147224426,
-0.1098683774471283,
0.11112529039382935,
-0.2550283670425415,
-0.5425744652748108,
0.2633809745311737,
-0.21442130208015442,
0.6691985726356506,
0.8561853170394897,
0.044899631291627884,
0.27695637941360474,
-0.2302110642194748,
0.7370301485061646,
0.3358893394470215,
-0.7334719896316528,
0.18979643285274506,
-0.31039053201675415,
-0.02120072953402996,
0.5722886919975281,
0.6978145241737366,
-0.7901338934898376,
0.45339614152908325,
-0.36389264464378357,
-0.39251384139060974,
0.6848282217979431,
-0.584618091583252,
0.13898427784442902,
0.1802157163619995,
0.49734795093536377,
0.1797393560409546,
0.31126323342323303,
-0.5124133229255676,
-0.3230021595954895,
0.09473114460706711,
-0.10269232094287872,
-0.4790184199810028,
-0.4351367950439453,
-0.040162377059459686,
-0.193162739276886,
0.6258379220962524,
-0.18158726394176483,
-0.23860155045986176,
-0.34164679050445557,
-0.21244026720523834,
-0.18879538774490356,
0.7902887463569641,
0.5005715489387512,
0.7396909594535828,
-0.3491270840167999,
0.19752652943134308,
0.11219576746225357,
-0.24949443340301514,
0.4002229869365692,
-0.4924633502960205,
-0.19123396277427673,
-0.5416277647018433,
-0.02713770978152752,
0.8368678092956543,
0.24201157689094543,
-0.7131223082542419,
0.5401799082756042,
-0.14134103059768677,
-0.1807517409324646,
-0.21832601726055145,
0.16929790377616882,
0.4982580840587616,
-0.17144711315631866,
0.0675918310880661,
-0.06966020911931992,
0.02363731898367405,
-0.5809835195541382,
-0.3623911738395691,
0.7883303761482239,
-0.7005899548530579,
-0.3874663710594177,
0.21207429468631744,
0.3257902264595032,
-0.219364196062088,
0.5585570931434631,
0.10657738894224167,
-0.6396059393882751,
0.10656565427780151,
0.49983739852905273,
0.8621312379837036,
-0.43358510732650757,
0.02374161034822464,
0.2287645787000656,
-0.08326756954193115,
-0.2888393700122833,
-0.024235080927610397,
-0.24427667260169983,
-1.0764782428741455,
-0.27371668815612793,
-0.7121889591217041,
-0.6606749892234802,
0.20228071510791779,
-0.527107834815979,
0.49137061834335327,
-0.306749552488327,
-0.38198724389076233,
-0.0500309020280838,
0.05305952578783035,
-0.47804898023605347,
0.022766921669244766,
0.22330433130264282,
0.7427870035171509,
-0.6856487989425659,
0.8738152384757996,
1.086289644241333,
0.010916230268776417,
-0.811360239982605,
-0.13093912601470947,
0.3103675842285156,
-0.6887902617454529,
0.6375430822372437,
0.10375970602035522,
-0.38235706090927124,
0.027492597699165344,
-0.6015805006027222,
-0.6193181872367859,
0.7843927145004272,
0.4422746002674103,
-0.5936542749404907,
-0.057449422776699066,
0.011580748483538628,
0.35660117864608765,
-0.47725433111190796,
0.13063795864582062,
0.7739247679710388,
0.5917927622795105,
-0.03006686083972454,
-0.6591454148292542,
-0.3779757618904114,
-0.009103761054575443,
0.0495123416185379,
0.3174944221973419,
-1.0004358291625977,
0.4991745948791504,
-0.31866785883903503,
0.019183753058314323,
-0.03756941109895706,
0.47235819697380066,
0.2668049931526184,
-0.07361575216054916,
0.8466562032699585,
0.26327982544898987,
0.5793667435646057,
0.13764315843582153,
0.9920773506164551,
-0.020934702828526497,
0.2935599088668823,
0.9054538011550903,
-0.6485138535499573,
0.882079541683197,
0.5953928828239441,
-0.46587416529655457,
0.15423661470413208,
0.7761080265045166,
0.3850342631340027,
0.247935950756073,
0.2254929095506668,
-0.24520546197891235,
-0.6386618614196777,
-0.24508041143417358,
-0.2476458102464676,
0.5476346015930176,
0.25469186902046204,
-0.14907675981521606,
-0.031043069437146187,
-0.17780525982379913,
-0.1565716415643692,
0.07858201861381531,
-0.15307646989822388,
0.8015568256378174,
0.17754000425338745,
-0.8789207935333252,
0.3773960769176483,
0.12497756630182266,
0.8161991238594055,
-0.6306247115135193,
0.198732390999794,
0.11046213656663895,
0.11721941828727722,
-0.34065964818000793,
-0.8209584355354309,
-0.16308996081352234,
-0.07797674089670181,
-0.5440620183944702,
-0.2664305865764618,
0.5667754411697388,
-0.43141278624534607,
0.035210974514484406,
0.2357650250196457,
0.22390076518058777,
0.004477931652218103,
0.12628979980945587,
-0.3663887083530426,
0.06301960349082947,
0.1338645964860916,
-0.4087967574596405,
0.7069806456565857,
-0.2445107400417328,
-0.3428017795085907,
0.7829651236534119,
0.7106348872184753,
0.10709106177091599,
-0.042846497148275375,
0.22207966446876526,
0.5823643207550049,
-0.7290793657302856,
-0.3927316963672638,
-0.747530996799469,
0.1875012069940567,
0.18852916359901428,
-0.24644459784030914,
0.7285357713699341,
0.5440361499786377,
0.8728315830230713,
-0.1400069147348404,
1.054527997970581,
0.308886855840683,
0.5681619644165039,
-0.521630585193634,
0.5877121090888977,
-0.3965672552585602,
0.24506306648254395,
-0.12636202573776245,
-1.1105390787124634,
-0.23876318335533142,
0.44774124026298523,
-0.7154222726821899,
0.1722297966480255,
0.30192726850509644,
0.6070162057876587,
-0.0874921903014183,
0.15196846425533295,
0.3519420921802521,
-0.15249788761138916,
0.2626994252204895,
0.5959925651550293,
1.2229769229888916,
0.24558018147945404,
0.11334124207496643,
-0.25064313411712646,
-0.351105272769928,
-0.6059300303459167,
-0.9444704651832581,
-0.779423713684082,
-0.6349255442619324,
0.06750233471393585,
0.0697682574391365,
-0.10278487950563431,
1.5700936317443848,
0.8937454223632812,
-0.8395750522613525,
-0.634363055229187,
0.26018717885017395,
0.24172833561897278,
0.20257006585597992,
-0.10338833928108215,
0.3458017110824585,
-0.2156144082546234,
-0.8783727884292603,
0.27079322934150696,
0.2067573517560959,
0.09566013514995575,
-0.55652916431427,
-0.6513276696205139,
-0.12351815402507782,
-0.40193554759025574,
0.747842013835907,
0.5173541903495789,
-0.9870644807815552,
-0.5041943192481995,
0.2450549602508545,
-0.281632661819458,
0.1258595883846283,
1.0135440826416016,
-0.4161701798439026,
0.38186702132225037,
0.5772877931594849,
0.6618462800979614,
0.39359867572784424,
-0.006082284729927778,
0.5235680341720581,
-0.47567424178123474,
0.040900927037000656,
0.026402926072478294,
0.535649836063385,
0.5612999796867371,
-0.26058727502822876,
0.18218833208084106,
-0.16162380576133728,
-0.6843634843826294,
-0.5580500364303589,
0.42624256014823914,
-1.0542434453964233,
-0.13930943608283997,
1.2212259769439697,
0.24328739941120148,
-0.12276822328567505,
-0.11956325173377991,
-0.3313975930213928,
-0.06316514313220978,
-0.4648783504962921,
0.5616099834442139,
0.7357356548309326,
-0.3854438066482544,
0.00578561844304204,
-0.3052826523780823,
0.34271904826164246,
0.3838832676410675,
-0.5959550142288208,
0.20803913474082947,
0.71797776222229,
0.4400067925453186,
-0.09743493795394897,
0.6651158928871155,
-0.1196109876036644,
0.0780930444598198,
-1.0099164247512817,
0.3878673315048218,
0.11498288065195084,
-0.3505016565322876,
-0.7587624788284302,
-0.006826162803918123,
0.7976927757263184,
0.23712781071662903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11190v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11190v1 | Aligning Large Language Models from Self-Reference AI Feedback with one General Principle | 2024-06-17T03:51:46 | 2024-06-17T03:51:46 | Rong Bao, Rui Zheng, Shihan Dou, Xiao Wang, Enyu Zhou, Bo Wang, Qi Zhang, Liang Ding, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In aligning large language models (LLMs), utilizing feedback from existing
advanced AI rather than humans is an important method to scale supervisory
signals. However, it is highly challenging for AI to understand human
intentions and societal values, and provide accurate preference feedback based
on these. Current AI feedback methods rely on powerful LLMs, carefully designed
specific principles to describe human intentions, and are easily influenced by
position bias. To address these issues, we propose a self-reference-based AI
feedback framework that enables a 13B Llama2-Chat to provide high-quality
feedback under simple and general principles such as ``best for humanity``.
Specifically, we allow the AI to first respond to the user's instructions, then
generate criticism of other answers based on its own response as a reference,
and finally determine which answer better fits human preferences according to
the criticism. Additionally, we use a self-consistency method to further reduce
the impact of position bias, and employ semantic perplexity to calculate the
preference strength differences between different answers. Experimental results
show that our method enables 13B and 70B Llama2-Chat annotators to provide
high-quality preference feedback, and the policy models trained based on these
preference data achieve significant advantages in benchmark datasets through
reinforcement learning. | [
-0.26619887351989746,
-0.4368438422679901,
0.6629233956336975,
0.5394522547721863,
-0.06310096383094788,
-0.24000339210033417,
-0.49183389544487,
-0.3948255181312561,
0.26075252890586853,
0.6366071105003357,
-0.49554741382598877,
-0.26406222581863403,
-0.4357176423072815,
0.16985075175762177,
-0.1424180418252945,
1.0969388484954834,
0.12849044799804688,
0.07603617757558823,
-0.270045667886734,
-0.16421280801296234,
-0.476545512676239,
-0.6822813749313354,
-0.6003605127334595,
-0.6405644416809082,
0.6533092260360718,
0.6548987627029419,
0.9311918020248413,
0.7487491965293884,
0.6041387319564819,
0.3546465039253235,
0.21105808019638062,
0.3788563013076782,
-0.46736010909080505,
-0.01077379658818245,
-0.46291637420654297,
-0.26954159140586853,
-0.6636298298835754,
0.1325434446334839,
0.38430488109588623,
0.19949890673160553,
-0.3271317780017853,
0.1891797035932541,
0.19020161032676697,
0.5012813806533813,
-0.31921321153640747,
0.2613459527492523,
-0.45690426230430603,
-0.18561646342277527,
0.028306234627962112,
-0.17330099642276764,
-0.500572919845581,
-0.2527056634426117,
0.02443217672407627,
-0.5307159423828125,
-0.16103842854499817,
0.05129936710000038,
0.848305881023407,
0.7320391535758972,
-0.46131324768066406,
-0.09870781749486923,
-0.7654820084571838,
0.7666080594062805,
-0.8476894497871399,
-0.01982911303639412,
0.6479148268699646,
0.31801241636276245,
-0.10499043762683868,
-0.13971132040023804,
-0.6019824147224426,
-0.45148196816444397,
-0.10797899216413498,
0.06878145784139633,
0.06954073905944824,
-0.011850237846374512,
-0.09914211928844452,
-0.06000286713242531,
-0.19158409535884857,
0.5575209259986877,
-0.24750971794128418,
-0.1726846843957901,
1.0584741830825806,
0.14220532774925232,
-0.0792563334107399,
-0.05300303176045418,
-0.33482417464256287,
-0.33222857117652893,
-0.6880657076835632,
-0.10069472342729568,
0.34988585114479065,
0.3013360798358917,
-0.07954990863800049,
0.3865140974521637,
-0.34365344047546387,
0.37102794647216797,
0.7023426294326782,
-0.09011868387460709,
0.2893262803554535,
-0.11981742829084396,
-0.042140569537878036,
0.061444781720638275,
1.007930874824524,
0.7263824343681335,
0.2488958090543747,
-0.18509088456630707,
-0.13196961581707,
0.1434871405363083,
0.5660526752471924,
-0.6492442488670349,
0.012291103601455688,
0.1230415552854538,
-0.4680606424808502,
-0.4062286913394928,
-0.06727840006351471,
-0.5405442714691162,
-0.6186290979385376,
-0.4884474277496338,
0.34805750846862793,
0.038462329655885696,
-0.19832178950309753,
-0.22366176545619965,
0.4011339247226715,
0.3833918571472168,
0.595544159412384,
-1.2504737377166748,
0.11402831226587296,
0.5450435280799866,
0.3867951035499573,
-0.3629602789878845,
-0.33537018299102783,
-0.3500880300998688,
0.38123950362205505,
-0.39448198676109314,
0.944326639175415,
-0.47679099440574646,
-0.2557656466960907,
-0.07089562714099884,
-0.1871088743209839,
0.3726678490638733,
-0.6255395412445068,
0.43157705664634705,
-0.31166180968284607,
0.21107040345668793,
-0.21010969579219818,
-0.4822990298271179,
0.11838030815124512,
0.36319202184677124,
-0.30224788188934326,
0.9536572694778442,
-0.15213823318481445,
-0.4553055167198181,
0.2386322021484375,
-0.6472347378730774,
-0.1974712461233139,
-0.20009875297546387,
-0.39456990361213684,
-0.2961941361427307,
-0.10563982278108597,
0.4369421899318695,
0.4035041034221649,
-0.36610543727874756,
0.6137561798095703,
-0.6017360687255859,
-0.03891054168343544,
0.2877088189125061,
-0.5203947424888611,
0.21928024291992188,
0.23668181896209717,
-0.48594698309898376,
0.6358067989349365,
-0.45474275946617126,
0.0563596710562706,
0.0042693172581493855,
-0.34263670444488525,
-0.0568787045776844,
0.12145600467920303,
-0.15112163126468658,
0.2224242240190506,
0.5453131198883057,
-0.43307989835739136,
0.3498082756996155,
-0.08291435241699219,
0.42322254180908203,
1.2810935974121094,
-0.23707085847854614,
0.5237863063812256,
-0.3827269673347473,
0.26520198583602905,
-0.06934236735105515,
0.2720082402229309,
0.02083681896328926,
-0.03998357802629471,
-0.7500996589660645,
0.032671086490154266,
0.03141586109995842,
0.34375011920928955,
-0.18489623069763184,
0.8853903412818909,
-0.35295775532722473,
-0.405885249376297,
-0.6360679268836975,
0.4186004400253296,
0.3065357804298401,
0.510554313659668,
0.4557132422924042,
-0.4137689471244812,
-0.47355443239212036,
-1.0682965517044067,
0.14021919667720795,
-0.7082133889198303,
-0.011937485076487064,
0.38458994030952454,
0.011957535520195961,
-0.4022780954837799,
1.1043727397918701,
-0.16341343522071838,
-0.42677736282348633,
-0.10324569046497345,
-0.11733617633581161,
0.12425854057073593,
0.4784241318702698,
0.40857458114624023,
-0.42703279852867126,
-0.31534233689308167,
-0.18278509378433228,
-0.8445574641227722,
-0.3224451243877411,
-0.1532403528690338,
-0.5089101195335388,
0.1416388303041458,
0.4514126181602478,
-0.35665276646614075,
0.091274693608284,
0.692609429359436,
-0.2454058676958084,
0.1644839644432068,
-0.27222344279289246,
-0.06574138253927231,
-1.1647459268569946,
-0.03420892730355263,
0.014440762810409069,
-0.32018017768859863,
-0.30644068121910095,
-0.28271976113319397,
0.0900418758392334,
0.39429962635040283,
-0.12442158907651901,
0.7501773834228516,
-0.05097911134362221,
0.07247565686702728,
-0.48077791929244995,
0.12200084328651428,
-0.16141332685947418,
0.5990657806396484,
0.05800115317106247,
0.8514167070388794,
0.1046162098646164,
-0.6699886322021484,
0.5322861075401306,
0.5737948417663574,
-0.01225232519209385,
0.7871926426887512,
-0.6978958249092102,
0.47248056530952454,
-0.020108098164200783,
0.5841398239135742,
-0.8959388136863708,
-0.21932350099086761,
0.12813657522201538,
-0.4670496881008148,
0.12461547553539276,
-0.08432801067829132,
-0.23348462581634521,
-0.3025924861431122,
-0.224371537566185,
0.05885887145996094,
0.3433019518852234,
-0.6858230233192444,
0.6074681282043457,
0.6162798404693604,
-0.11812656372785568,
-0.7958007454872131,
-0.5348014831542969,
0.11190821975469589,
-0.16414275765419006,
-0.5150890946388245,
0.24118636548519135,
-0.24525144696235657,
-0.1746254861354828,
-0.12827612459659576,
-0.19712278246879578,
0.09923340380191803,
0.04840324819087982,
0.4369903802871704,
0.42444783449172974,
0.011923347599804401,
0.15021559596061707,
-0.15549758076667786,
-0.25804680585861206,
0.10505062341690063,
-0.32259243726730347,
0.521084189414978,
-0.3177851736545563,
-0.43087711930274963,
-0.5993841290473938,
0.10305985063314438,
0.5615912675857544,
-0.17352069914340973,
0.49676790833473206,
0.32638484239578247,
0.13225899636745453,
0.07534148544073105,
-0.944051206111908,
-0.36625102162361145,
-0.5211277008056641,
0.3052908778190613,
-0.019446957856416702,
-0.9490944743156433,
0.2748693525791168,
0.09171395003795624,
0.27823764085769653,
0.49215489625930786,
1.0142338275909424,
-0.31675392389297485,
1.1165446043014526,
0.6229478120803833,
-0.6903517246246338,
0.5122029185295105,
-0.04387848824262619,
0.14529670774936676,
-0.7849429249763489,
-0.16990993916988373,
-0.506496787071228,
-0.3871510922908783,
-0.3571273684501648,
-0.06674337387084961,
0.16743476688861847,
-0.17270424962043762,
-0.6104484796524048,
0.18437710404396057,
-0.39688047766685486,
0.3789995312690735,
0.8015591502189636,
0.14654874801635742,
0.10372155904769897,
-0.2220091074705124,
0.0029103029519319534,
0.13254261016845703,
-0.48778048157691956,
-0.8902781009674072,
1.0518049001693726,
0.5195172429084778,
1.2359068393707275,
0.15651023387908936,
0.7932341694831848,
0.44824114441871643,
0.6156696677207947,
-0.6406041979789734,
0.477040559053421,
0.08705120533704758,
-0.5924423933029175,
-0.5758349299430847,
-0.4143557846546173,
-0.7633095383644104,
0.18297721445560455,
-0.18302327394485474,
-0.6306061744689941,
-0.0700078159570694,
0.49022895097732544,
-0.41139695048332214,
0.029207682237029076,
-0.5951141119003296,
0.7344736456871033,
-0.47633716464042664,
-0.42699456214904785,
-0.4901342988014221,
-0.6718287467956543,
0.03617160767316818,
0.19807708263397217,
0.15966449677944183,
-0.5436795353889465,
0.25071507692337036,
0.5763164758682251,
-0.443072110414505,
1.2249844074249268,
-0.2106352150440216,
-0.4186377227306366,
0.23893269896507263,
-0.03423614054918289,
0.41840991377830505,
0.09857641905546188,
-0.07852731645107269,
0.1694214940071106,
-0.0005845107953064144,
-0.2947565019130707,
-0.5995101928710938,
0.700279712677002,
-1.4229135513305664,
-0.977695643901825,
-0.2731386721134186,
-0.482681006193161,
-0.4037778079509735,
0.11748381704092026,
-0.1379062682390213,
0.10622484236955643,
-0.11629429459571838,
0.18631349503993988,
0.2643826901912689,
0.07161012291908264,
0.3165629506111145,
0.6965432167053223,
-0.34697186946868896,
-0.43938854336738586,
0.6337944865226746,
-0.13558180630207062,
0.2151225358247757,
0.37224867939949036,
0.34576502442359924,
-0.5861022472381592,
-0.086520254611969,
-0.7404085993766785,
0.2766387462615967,
-0.6314920783042908,
-0.4569827914237976,
-0.2147127240896225,
-0.06927192956209183,
-0.5306591987609863,
-0.12272629886865616,
-0.4646822512149811,
-0.255003958940506,
-0.1905350536108017,
-0.20201562345027924,
0.30862241983413696,
0.6394150257110596,
-0.31130850315093994,
0.4158340096473694,
-0.7312501072883606,
0.1800951510667801,
0.5022754669189453,
0.4068116843700409,
0.1210581436753273,
-0.674460232257843,
-0.11746969074010849,
0.16398292779922485,
-0.4642968773841858,
-0.5675835609436035,
0.13081467151641846,
0.02239254303276539,
0.5863316655158997,
0.6732306480407715,
0.24444955587387085,
0.6540958285331726,
-0.3935020864009857,
0.6638868451118469,
0.11742756515741348,
-0.8645633459091187,
0.6440151333808899,
-0.20737692713737488,
0.17658963799476624,
0.7237994074821472,
0.13804170489311218,
-0.7860227227210999,
-0.261442095041275,
-0.5207956433296204,
-0.6795055270195007,
0.7104219794273376,
0.04279598221182823,
0.41869425773620605,
-0.027437644079327583,
0.5241411924362183,
-0.10433463752269745,
0.12452025711536407,
-0.7099984884262085,
-0.10977175831794739,
-0.2746160924434662,
-0.47966086864471436,
-0.1308613270521164,
-0.2341134399175644,
-0.3808259963989258,
0.025312386453151703,
0.7721478939056396,
-0.39802974462509155,
0.25337985157966614,
0.11913905292749405,
0.015820100903511047,
-0.25690075755119324,
0.379976749420166,
0.3290391266345978,
0.674625039100647,
-0.04272487759590149,
0.11967353522777557,
0.2759915590286255,
-0.036015622317790985,
0.44655582308769226,
-0.24735741317272186,
-0.2094939947128296,
-0.5258892774581909,
0.22513681650161743,
0.6538547873497009,
-0.0817260891199112,
-0.4929458498954773,
0.4480420649051666,
-0.036334794014692307,
0.10032215714454651,
-0.38992008566856384,
0.3384852409362793,
-0.04782506823539734,
0.36242929100990295,
0.2288370281457901,
-0.12591415643692017,
-0.20882965624332428,
-0.5772175192832947,
0.16063085198402405,
0.45922619104385376,
-0.39963772892951965,
-0.15481796860694885,
0.605039119720459,
0.5420283675193787,
-0.3040905296802521,
0.7075492143630981,
0.11822084337472916,
-0.40892964601516724,
0.4168538749217987,
0.6326178312301636,
0.6160025000572205,
-0.4008621275424957,
0.28137072920799255,
0.20863746106624603,
0.007199868559837341,
-0.20393157005310059,
0.017693020403385162,
-0.18232059478759766,
-1.0577658414840698,
-0.5088366270065308,
-0.38096368312835693,
-0.7535313963890076,
-0.08207262307405472,
-0.7499844431877136,
0.15405243635177612,
-0.7554522752761841,
-0.41473689675331116,
-0.16880618035793304,
-0.044106848537921906,
-0.49204719066619873,
0.1349344700574875,
0.24824242293834686,
0.47348642349243164,
-0.6246652603149414,
0.978506326675415,
0.5673415064811707,
-0.5823588967323303,
-1.0937129259109497,
-0.015146051533520222,
0.057619135826826096,
-1.1435699462890625,
0.5306961536407471,
0.15432633459568024,
-0.35518279671669006,
-0.17614583671092987,
-0.8535396456718445,
-1.0600407123565674,
0.9165974855422974,
0.4123050272464752,
-0.6404857635498047,
-0.07318423688411713,
-0.07006370276212692,
0.6877370476722717,
-0.37437471747398376,
0.5128313302993774,
0.49678874015808105,
0.4729894995689392,
0.12046443670988083,
-1.1082435846328735,
-0.041411448270082474,
-0.27268117666244507,
0.03502047434449196,
0.025415755808353424,
-1.1832165718078613,
0.1425780951976776,
-0.20568089187145233,
0.16600780189037323,
0.03506043553352356,
0.9988939762115479,
0.15560106933116913,
-0.02319832518696785,
0.5552182793617249,
0.4281300902366638,
0.7083472609519958,
0.15422113239765167,
0.9780795574188232,
-0.45209887623786926,
0.23485636711120605,
1.4022833108901978,
-0.4716722369194031,
0.909119188785553,
0.3873560130596161,
-0.1441074162721634,
0.5380954146385193,
0.5693879723548889,
-0.08150344341993332,
0.459154337644577,
0.10324093699455261,
0.19388967752456665,
-0.35500776767730713,
-0.33939769864082336,
-0.22180794179439545,
0.46822628378868103,
0.16475273668766022,
-0.16424180567264557,
0.038893699645996094,
-0.3928537666797638,
0.20482942461967468,
0.18632186949253082,
-0.21858403086662292,
0.9809207916259766,
-0.04436485841870308,
-0.9819555878639221,
0.46419912576675415,
0.17159020900726318,
0.7001509666442871,
-0.6502168774604797,
0.06270700693130493,
-0.4014030992984772,
0.427030473947525,
-0.19582732021808624,
-0.7174341082572937,
0.12573686242103577,
0.13033661246299744,
-0.2731417119503021,
-0.25902652740478516,
0.19132354855537415,
-0.3831630051136017,
-0.21404992043972015,
0.3121670186519623,
0.15623196959495544,
-0.06056253984570503,
0.17335310578346252,
-0.4928257167339325,
-0.024132102727890015,
-0.02645735628902912,
-0.025108931586146355,
0.3476055860519409,
0.18336711823940277,
-0.22556118667125702,
0.7706329226493835,
0.6045318841934204,
-0.018378330394625664,
-0.21403591334819794,
0.06106790527701378,
0.6797153353691101,
-0.5743694305419922,
-0.5837599635124207,
-0.889963686466217,
0.079380564391613,
-0.13883943855762482,
-0.39106136560440063,
0.6092797517776489,
0.16589456796646118,
0.8799293637275696,
0.23769330978393555,
0.8048020005226135,
0.12104061990976334,
0.5141820907592773,
-0.3979899287223816,
0.4729997515678406,
-0.19610929489135742,
0.249393492937088,
-0.18648852407932281,
-0.9861143827438354,
-0.11607126146554947,
1.0875861644744873,
-0.38167959451675415,
0.10624154657125473,
0.32697853446006775,
0.8365108370780945,
0.21155411005020142,
-0.2428043782711029,
0.1336630880832672,
0.3503314256668091,
0.6615056991577148,
0.37303322553634644,
0.9328146576881409,
0.029460350051522255,
0.589647114276886,
-0.12178763747215271,
-0.13761770725250244,
-0.33788520097732544,
-0.8607761859893799,
-0.7992435693740845,
-0.343147873878479,
-0.2138051837682724,
-0.45012569427490234,
-0.00554210040718317,
1.5546355247497559,
0.9414008259773254,
-0.8816677331924438,
-0.4665313959121704,
0.1944258213043213,
-0.1403680145740509,
-0.006265297997742891,
-0.15076303482055664,
0.40668416023254395,
-0.48716452717781067,
-0.5357205867767334,
0.3667590618133545,
0.30606940388679504,
-0.03001166135072708,
-0.6003854274749756,
-0.43597927689552307,
0.11413665115833282,
0.18555495142936707,
0.3282870948314667,
0.26107320189476013,
-1.0223325490951538,
-0.6960024237632751,
-0.19085575640201569,
-0.4265550673007965,
0.2882055640220642,
0.6288490891456604,
-0.652804970741272,
0.1686413735151291,
0.07497570663690567,
0.920981764793396,
0.4151862859725952,
0.2857138216495514,
0.7048336863517761,
-0.5067980289459229,
-0.0028153364546597004,
0.16756753623485565,
0.2450166493654251,
0.4585791230201721,
-0.5388872027397156,
0.5267631411552429,
-0.281978577375412,
-0.7918527126312256,
-0.3046405613422394,
0.1951967030763626,
-0.905822217464447,
0.11276819556951523,
1.2787352800369263,
-0.1808808147907257,
-0.1314740628004074,
0.2452360838651657,
-0.5772746801376343,
0.02323268912732601,
-0.8132818937301636,
1.227441668510437,
0.6804817318916321,
-0.3036702275276184,
-0.10069790482521057,
0.08205685019493103,
0.3302088677883148,
0.7455167770385742,
-0.8930937647819519,
0.19519266486167908,
0.6787675023078918,
0.1594412922859192,
0.15320247411727905,
0.8584942817687988,
0.08410626649856567,
0.062188100069761276,
-0.502071738243103,
0.16285280883312225,
0.11534380912780762,
-0.47790202498435974,
-0.3680391013622284,
-0.08271606266498566,
0.503044068813324,
0.016885221004486084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11177v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11177v1 | TIFG: Text-Informed Feature Generation with Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T03:29:14 | 2024-06-17T03:29:14 | Xinhao Zhang, Jinghan Zhang, Fengran Mo, Yuzhong Chen, Kunpeng Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Textual information of data is of vital importance for data mining and
feature engineering. However, existing methods focus on learning the data
structures and overlook the textual information along with the data.
Consequently, they waste this valuable resource and miss out on the deeper data
relationships embedded within the texts. In this paper, we introduce
Text-Informed Feature Generation (TIFG), a novel LLM-based text-informed
feature generation framework. TIFG utilizes the textual information to generate
features by retrieving possible relevant features within external knowledge
with Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) technology. In this approach, the
TIFG can generate new explainable features to enrich the feature space and
further mine feature relationships. We design the TIFG to be an automated
framework that continuously optimizes the feature generation process, adapts to
new data inputs, and improves downstream task performance over iterations. A
broad range of experiments in various downstream tasks showcases that our
approach can generate high-quality and meaningful features, and is
significantly superior to existing methods. | [
-0.5574963092803955,
-0.7790254354476929,
0.6474692821502686,
-0.07288052141666412,
-0.22781012952327728,
0.1662348359823227,
-0.32959768176078796,
-0.5027078986167908,
0.1672733873128891,
0.7728455066680908,
-0.6973466873168945,
-0.6587972640991211,
-0.4653976261615753,
0.09739094227552414,
-0.5322524905204773,
1.1641911268234253,
0.07606330513954163,
-0.3551256060600281,
-0.1254757046699524,
0.03950667753815651,
-0.3413567543029785,
-0.30492693185806274,
-0.5604078769683838,
-0.5549421906471252,
0.6645836234092712,
0.4375518262386322,
0.6865964531898499,
1.0410491228103638,
0.32554391026496887,
0.20527760684490204,
-0.03166135773062706,
0.40634140372276306,
-0.6361387968063354,
0.33773258328437805,
-0.12418128550052643,
-0.42423176765441895,
-0.3343564569950104,
-0.21433785557746887,
0.4393540918827057,
0.5034044981002808,
0.30230939388275146,
0.4814465641975403,
0.1743253916501999,
0.6064763069152832,
-0.39490535855293274,
0.19980482757091522,
-0.8352360129356384,
0.06959698349237442,
-0.3920762240886688,
-0.2813127338886261,
-0.300799697637558,
-0.31220734119415283,
-0.0019679972901940346,
-0.3961572051048279,
0.6627086997032166,
-0.02281798981130123,
0.8370064496994019,
0.5650964379310608,
-0.3289385735988617,
-0.39245522022247314,
-0.6075051426887512,
0.5406061410903931,
-0.4061877727508545,
0.2975943386554718,
0.45921292901039124,
0.07955841720104218,
-0.28960272669792175,
-0.7680665254592896,
-0.48554304242134094,
-0.03602272644639015,
-0.18645544350147247,
-0.12115564942359924,
0.41708460450172424,
-0.11147284507751465,
0.23496288061141968,
0.4967929720878601,
-0.5401843786239624,
-0.0835823342204094,
0.13518182933330536,
0.052070435136556625,
0.8208721280097961,
-0.10571940243244171,
0.18363825976848602,
-0.439745157957077,
-0.39739274978637695,
0.0014133121585473418,
-1.0028828382492065,
-0.07515327632427216,
0.3508118689060211,
0.4434434771537781,
0.009271572344005108,
0.6122279763221741,
0.0015384862199425697,
0.5758181214332581,
0.07865167409181595,
-0.09966792911291122,
0.1906440109014511,
-0.07565475255250931,
-0.054657623171806335,
0.1262872964143753,
0.8588125705718994,
-0.09531901776790619,
0.17458055913448334,
-0.3618004024028778,
-0.4425937235355377,
-0.10264614969491959,
-0.0005384734249673784,
-0.7552433013916016,
-0.059060897678136826,
0.18159836530685425,
-0.2985486090183258,
-0.71342533826828,
0.2298993617296219,
-0.7745891213417053,
-0.6290348172187805,
-0.1406063735485077,
0.14782458543777466,
-0.5165461897850037,
-0.5136107802391052,
-0.4120243191719055,
-0.0023084324784576893,
0.08619864284992218,
0.07990969717502594,
-1.016312837600708,
-0.1543254554271698,
0.8020584583282471,
0.6776162981987,
-0.23353885114192963,
-0.15335115790367126,
-0.9664190411567688,
0.47421982884407043,
-0.2969202697277069,
0.9624345302581787,
-0.6192920207977295,
-0.5102589130401611,
-0.09266113489866257,
-0.31985151767730713,
0.23991602659225464,
-0.5300911664962769,
0.2864292562007904,
-0.3278445303440094,
0.26259350776672363,
-0.10113471001386642,
-0.5166680812835693,
-0.3865717053413391,
0.05560971423983574,
-0.7419794201850891,
1.5651507377624512,
0.23250144720077515,
-0.996825098991394,
0.6644546389579773,
-0.6882811188697815,
-0.4921753406524658,
0.2799060046672821,
-0.3643382787704468,
-0.5474197864532471,
0.18525564670562744,
0.5128059983253479,
0.6739163398742676,
-0.4417085647583008,
0.7310333847999573,
-0.5559307932853699,
-0.28850042819976807,
0.20962436497211456,
-0.2845405340194702,
0.3046821653842926,
0.2841758131980896,
-0.2908647358417511,
0.08877890557050705,
-0.8703309893608093,
0.08954621106386185,
0.17094653844833374,
-0.47268617153167725,
-0.033069904893636703,
-0.04329199716448784,
0.15864473581314087,
0.11797629296779633,
0.26476797461509705,
-0.34851107001304626,
0.025685638189315796,
-0.44488492608070374,
0.31123074889183044,
0.5603340268135071,
0.22819823026657104,
0.635188639163971,
-0.46546223759651184,
0.6435016989707947,
-0.3219512104988098,
-0.292195588350296,
-0.4664711058139801,
-0.24432218074798584,
-0.602273166179657,
-0.31764423847198486,
0.521291196346283,
0.5666046142578125,
-1.0109282732009888,
0.5871455669403076,
-0.28439033031463623,
-0.31463539600372314,
-0.28195199370384216,
0.3308764398097992,
0.22436919808387756,
0.4757078289985657,
-0.08785103261470795,
0.1943606734275818,
-0.4772805869579315,
-0.6362897157669067,
-0.18069379031658173,
-0.2192312628030777,
-0.20319531857967377,
0.370852530002594,
0.1770397275686264,
-0.23108913004398346,
1.212241530418396,
-0.589918851852417,
-0.11960611492395401,
-0.4869893193244934,
0.2548946440219879,
0.08918445557355881,
0.12440089881420135,
0.5717769861221313,
-0.9996300935745239,
-0.22325453162193298,
0.26221123337745667,
-0.7662105560302734,
-0.3552408218383789,
-0.20404542982578278,
-0.18640804290771484,
0.4077257812023163,
0.4529014229774475,
-0.4352680742740631,
0.28359127044677734,
0.5410662293434143,
-0.22852452099323273,
0.1223357766866684,
-0.08673910796642303,
0.05158539116382599,
-1.3925575017929077,
0.2197716385126114,
0.12187176942825317,
-0.4169369637966156,
-0.39112406969070435,
-0.15867650508880615,
0.009592032991349697,
-0.33156225085258484,
-0.20020250976085663,
0.890842854976654,
-0.5266206860542297,
-0.12724114954471588,
-0.3231803774833679,
0.0905124843120575,
0.06809497624635696,
0.4516213536262512,
-0.0314520001411438,
0.7168722748756409,
0.3243296444416046,
-0.5370451807975769,
0.24315281212329865,
0.18830420076847076,
-0.01834007166326046,
0.13651491701602936,
-0.1086757704615593,
0.19197554886341095,
-0.06820111721754074,
-0.16379164159297943,
-0.7745009064674377,
-0.6064465045928955,
0.044452689588069916,
-0.7725263237953186,
0.575896143913269,
-0.264890193939209,
-0.6991680264472961,
-0.09314097464084625,
-0.27329811453819275,
-0.00422359025105834,
0.3719854950904846,
-0.7676829099655151,
0.7524648904800415,
0.5202587842941284,
-0.5186120867729187,
-0.5810478329658508,
-0.6768073439598083,
0.13130520284175873,
-0.2931056320667267,
-0.8842585682868958,
0.38490810990333557,
0.1597813367843628,
-0.05037949979305267,
0.15199631452560425,
-0.07815223932266235,
0.0158443171530962,
0.10468938946723938,
0.4287220239639282,
0.02569665014743805,
-0.12253230065107346,
0.6217825412750244,
0.06449901312589645,
-0.23861739039421082,
-0.10744782537221909,
-0.04645591229200363,
0.5307121276855469,
0.10799619555473328,
-0.20197825133800507,
0.09317430853843689,
0.29742300510406494,
0.19562451541423798,
-0.45486724376678467,
0.3049299716949463,
0.8946482539176941,
-0.4275932013988495,
-0.6948685646057129,
-0.4548701047897339,
-0.1507216840982437,
-0.4786848723888397,
0.5380439758300781,
-0.49745115637779236,
-1.0260933637619019,
0.4523136019706726,
-0.36402156949043274,
0.10200642794370651,
0.5458040833473206,
0.43873387575149536,
-0.1236497089266777,
0.9655036330223083,
1.1273486614227295,
0.17736603319644928,
0.6001645922660828,
-0.12738032639026642,
0.1505143791437149,
-0.48934534192085266,
0.002819844987243414,
-0.41020506620407104,
-0.17304052412509918,
-0.7847058176994324,
-0.3089994490146637,
0.27938610315322876,
0.30604088306427,
-0.05701194331049919,
0.032301776111125946,
-0.5343689322471619,
0.32593485713005066,
0.4023584723472595,
0.2572087049484253,
0.22307784855365753,
0.11003363132476807,
-0.07167817652225494,
0.13297909498214722,
-0.7394326329231262,
-0.585652232170105,
1.065037727355957,
0.2786285877227783,
0.6739284992218018,
-0.2324984073638916,
0.9888993501663208,
0.24511714279651642,
0.4482010006904602,
-0.6694861650466919,
0.5452715158462524,
-0.3354761302471161,
-0.1524808704853058,
-0.2564045488834381,
-0.49974021315574646,
-0.6986908912658691,
-0.1694331169128418,
-0.7697662115097046,
-0.4665836989879608,
-0.29899173974990845,
0.14862917363643646,
-0.0648561641573906,
0.2763838768005371,
-0.8587868213653564,
0.5244284272193909,
-0.4289892315864563,
-0.40182608366012573,
0.0954488217830658,
-0.1558537781238556,
0.37721654772758484,
-0.4094372093677521,
0.0818333700299263,
-0.057009872049093246,
-0.08216065168380737,
0.3896811902523041,
-0.483646959066391,
0.6412584781646729,
-0.18115375936031342,
-0.05099702998995781,
0.2168862670660019,
0.04426979273557663,
0.6878363490104675,
0.3150078356266022,
-0.42789149284362793,
0.029278814792633057,
-0.4896625876426697,
0.13072974979877472,
-0.5810587406158447,
0.6770342588424683,
-0.3993086516857147,
-0.6742744445800781,
-0.15021198987960815,
-0.6724852919578552,
-0.23850789666175842,
0.18176797032356262,
0.38578569889068604,
0.30417951941490173,
-0.12708309292793274,
0.1730964183807373,
0.8049001693725586,
-0.416559100151062,
0.604418158531189,
-0.04007229581475258,
-0.549368679523468,
-0.5827267169952393,
0.9283006191253662,
-0.015589232556521893,
-0.09404270350933075,
0.6010777950286865,
0.09799160063266754,
-0.3946061134338379,
-0.6332906484603882,
-0.658845841884613,
0.3377246558666229,
-0.45373275876045227,
-0.34871381521224976,
-0.6765444874763489,
-0.4388616681098938,
-0.24243566393852234,
-0.19618326425552368,
-0.005845220759510994,
-0.3461694121360779,
-0.32009392976760864,
-0.0899384394288063,
0.9270591735839844,
0.9916725754737854,
0.27732330560684204,
0.3028438985347748,
-0.9342347383499146,
0.3986726701259613,
0.09877173602581024,
0.5061225295066833,
-0.44605448842048645,
-0.12795130908489227,
-0.3340981900691986,
-0.18881526589393616,
-0.19652530550956726,
-0.7526671290397644,
0.39426296949386597,
0.2390013188123703,
0.487251877784729,
0.18682795763015747,
-0.03883945941925049,
0.28450310230255127,
-0.3288489580154419,
0.5795974135398865,
-0.11159799247980118,
-0.8222744464874268,
0.6638160943984985,
-0.6013028025627136,
0.4303610324859619,
0.06730883568525314,
-0.12660184502601624,
-0.3218553066253662,
-0.5636785626411438,
-0.635907769203186,
-0.8555988073348999,
0.7458576560020447,
0.2925824820995331,
-0.18067869544029236,
0.06505244970321655,
0.5949594378471375,
0.42368176579475403,
0.15768025815486908,
-0.6743611097335815,
-0.01229305099695921,
-0.017747854813933372,
-0.6383393406867981,
0.06212320178747177,
-0.2496873140335083,
0.11472056061029434,
0.39746880531311035,
0.7455365061759949,
-0.5059822797775269,
0.019965501502156258,
0.035420916974544525,
-0.25846484303474426,
-0.052175283432006836,
0.1178036779165268,
0.28429466485977173,
0.6505746841430664,
0.02192877046763897,
-0.033560171723365784,
0.19689412415027618,
-0.5107685923576355,
-0.11057168245315552,
0.40961354970932007,
-0.3882730305194855,
0.18837863206863403,
0.26046425104141235,
0.7815959453582764,
-0.1538304090499878,
-0.42280325293540955,
0.2584483027458191,
0.001173609052784741,
-0.15061156451702118,
-0.29240909218788147,
0.3868107795715332,
0.24640882015228271,
0.4284708797931671,
0.46808964014053345,
0.09143321216106415,
0.03468911722302437,
0.0035985754802823067,
0.46964994072914124,
0.4121488630771637,
-0.26367294788360596,
0.04788244515657425,
0.6855210065841675,
0.2399044930934906,
-0.1803271770477295,
0.13173876702785492,
-0.005491243675351143,
-0.2589908838272095,
0.6875814199447632,
0.1504410356283188,
1.0978156328201294,
-0.008130624890327454,
0.2522294521331787,
0.3578800559043884,
0.09624077379703522,
-0.005275136325508356,
0.2420199066400528,
-0.15107685327529907,
-0.5526300668716431,
-0.6504293084144592,
-0.8776240944862366,
-0.3022584319114685,
0.2656387388706207,
-0.20565250515937805,
0.7299182415008545,
-0.4286576211452484,
-0.3105280101299286,
-0.051833625882864,
-0.10283632576465607,
-0.6380431652069092,
0.22253155708312988,
0.2520195245742798,
0.6958757638931274,
-0.48336997628211975,
0.8198509216308594,
0.7828924655914307,
-0.2844291925430298,
-0.7524511814117432,
0.1566387265920639,
-0.007008419372141361,
-0.6848428249359131,
0.5648880004882812,
0.350969523191452,
-0.18113647401332855,
-0.0040555112063884735,
-0.3236759901046753,
-0.8805127143859863,
1.1498876810073853,
0.6441826820373535,
-0.2953945994377136,
0.03541010245680809,
0.4222341775894165,
0.34227293729782104,
-0.5972753167152405,
0.0892128199338913,
0.24690966308116913,
0.4255707263946533,
0.2917020916938782,
-0.6383165717124939,
0.10497809201478958,
-0.3882492780685425,
0.43311142921447754,
0.47338685393333435,
-0.4112407863140106,
0.46893662214279175,
-0.31324276328086853,
-0.3020164966583252,
-0.12927211821079254,
0.6288222074508667,
0.35704007744789124,
0.21937818825244904,
0.5545976758003235,
0.5573474764823914,
0.7561367154121399,
-0.23817294836044312,
0.8003053069114685,
-0.3984021842479706,
0.22748298943042755,
1.162691593170166,
-0.16226737201213837,
0.7087013721466064,
0.24269966781139374,
0.28166109323501587,
0.1801493763923645,
0.782212495803833,
-0.1489139050245285,
0.2866125702857971,
-0.004133075941354036,
-0.38256263732910156,
-0.1908651441335678,
-0.041820038110017776,
-0.17299023270606995,
0.6113359332084656,
0.3655009865760803,
-0.674389660358429,
-0.35320258140563965,
0.1020052507519722,
-0.03148966655135155,
0.21015200018882751,
-0.27200573682785034,
0.9781529307365417,
-0.13785068690776825,
-0.48724669218063354,
0.45359891653060913,
-0.05944078415632248,
0.7474235892295837,
-0.5565048456192017,
-0.30524417757987976,
-0.31592312455177307,
0.13519734144210815,
-0.3631671071052551,
-1.0253863334655762,
0.29310861229896545,
0.3471125662326813,
-0.540381908416748,
-0.5159989595413208,
1.0512601137161255,
-0.5702202916145325,
-0.47642263770103455,
0.09863743185997009,
0.5055966377258301,
-0.07390853762626648,
-0.28608015179634094,
-0.45481517910957336,
-0.1404731273651123,
0.24645449221134186,
-0.4695320427417755,
0.25318413972854614,
0.9957860708236694,
-0.2410091757774353,
0.8122413754463196,
0.697484016418457,
0.19681237637996674,
-0.08670005947351456,
0.07432600110769272,
0.7363796234130859,
-0.901871383190155,
-0.5627877116203308,
-0.7279001474380493,
0.6363375782966614,
-0.09447064995765686,
-0.04744207113981247,
0.26517292857170105,
0.6469884514808655,
0.7375434637069702,
0.10000094771385193,
1.1948174238204956,
-0.12392556667327881,
0.734941303730011,
-0.7098486423492432,
1.0224783420562744,
-0.4159756004810333,
0.352272629737854,
-0.0016457708552479744,
-1.1360044479370117,
-0.23767408728599548,
0.16813431680202484,
0.0077782138250768185,
0.3106885850429535,
0.6048420667648315,
0.9003573656082153,
0.11351905763149261,
0.1759210079908371,
0.29215145111083984,
0.11413470655679703,
0.4773586690425873,
0.3355226516723633,
0.5114997625350952,
-0.2709110975265503,
0.8047071099281311,
-0.13324898481369019,
-0.17946213483810425,
-0.004263315815478563,
-1.0146878957748413,
-0.9863966107368469,
-0.7356936931610107,
-0.18051230907440186,
-0.04539711773395538,
-0.255147784948349,
0.8309425115585327,
0.6066193580627441,
-0.5296061635017395,
0.045208241790533066,
-0.21397218108177185,
0.3293236494064331,
0.2312859445810318,
-0.3049018383026123,
0.38229310512542725,
-0.572861909866333,
-0.6730765700340271,
0.11581944674253464,
0.4805092513561249,
0.058900490403175354,
-0.25983062386512756,
-0.010914248414337635,
-0.019242383539676666,
-0.3498847186565399,
0.5032413005828857,
0.09026607871055603,
-0.5229536890983582,
-0.3851874768733978,
-0.04678677022457123,
-0.08880599588155746,
0.1551998257637024,
0.769760251045227,
-0.9810374975204468,
0.3286258578300476,
0.5683553218841553,
0.8843075633049011,
0.6852148175239563,
-0.1753513067960739,
0.8121962547302246,
-0.9264878034591675,
0.1826893389225006,
0.12030955404043198,
0.3185717761516571,
0.630682110786438,
-0.8700556755065918,
0.7031098008155823,
0.09495462477207184,
-0.48128363490104675,
-0.6055751442909241,
0.29044535756111145,
-0.6789343357086182,
-0.26940223574638367,
1.2117999792099,
0.08854595571756363,
-0.3802264630794525,
0.07332933694124222,
-0.23181647062301636,
0.4074563980102539,
-0.3527388572692871,
0.6807120442390442,
0.591594398021698,
-0.19977079331874847,
-0.4919282793998718,
-0.5268391370773315,
0.8532446026802063,
-0.12788927555084229,
-1.0275129079818726,
0.23959510028362274,
0.5096083283424377,
0.2986466586589813,
-0.1486491560935974,
0.2858152985572815,
-0.17925925552845,
0.11762761324644089,
-0.0957193449139595,
0.44212740659713745,
-0.2545253336429596,
-0.15843364596366882,
-0.0988999530673027,
0.30034080147743225,
0.1745861917734146,
0.08059640973806381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11176v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11176v1 | Watch Every Step! LLM Agent Learning via Iterative Step-Level Process Refinement | 2024-06-17T03:29:13 | 2024-06-17T03:29:13 | Weimin Xiong, Yifan Song, Xiutian Zhao, Wenhao Wu, Xun Wang, Ke Wang, Cheng Li, Wei Peng, Sujian Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language model agents have exhibited exceptional performance across a
range of complex interactive tasks. Recent approaches have utilized tuning with
expert trajectories to enhance agent performance, yet they primarily
concentrate on outcome rewards, which may lead to errors or suboptimal actions
due to the absence of process supervision signals. In this paper, we introduce
the Iterative step-level Process Refinement (IPR) framework, which provides
detailed step-by-step guidance to enhance agent training. Specifically, we
adopt the Monte Carlo method to estimate step-level rewards. During each
iteration, the agent explores along the expert trajectory and generates new
actions. These actions are then evaluated against the corresponding step of
expert trajectory using step-level rewards. Such comparison helps identify
discrepancies, yielding contrastive action pairs that serve as training data
for the agent. Our experiments on three complex agent tasks demonstrate that
our framework outperforms a variety of strong baselines. Moreover, our
analytical findings highlight the effectiveness of IPR in augmenting action
efficiency and its applicability to diverse models. | [
-0.1410278081893921,
-0.36303046345710754,
0.40008899569511414,
-0.226577490568161,
0.005557016469538212,
0.47371482849121094,
0.036614663898944855,
-0.05458413437008858,
-0.1501634120941162,
0.6326151490211487,
-0.7248688340187073,
-0.6847807765007019,
-0.6364169716835022,
-0.04711885005235672,
-0.10407412052154541,
1.0193814039230347,
-0.2985975742340088,
0.14527302980422974,
-0.0401793010532856,
0.3392588794231415,
-0.07634153962135315,
0.0422305092215538,
-1.309432029724121,
-0.791670024394989,
0.7696747779846191,
0.770984411239624,
0.29177725315093994,
0.7210070490837097,
0.525788426399231,
0.42797163128852844,
0.05707671120762825,
0.5564866065979004,
-0.7318716049194336,
0.2574107050895691,
-0.43074148893356323,
-0.3202510476112366,
-0.43591946363449097,
-0.07862890511751175,
0.4363832175731659,
0.3349821865558624,
-0.3443157970905304,
0.00277149211615324,
0.03983999416232109,
0.8108683824539185,
-0.5795313715934753,
0.5536748170852661,
-0.6051468253135681,
0.11801455914974213,
0.10371822863817215,
-0.7469877600669861,
-0.39011290669441223,
-0.1034778356552124,
-0.20013312995433807,
-0.5967589616775513,
0.48263081908226013,
-0.09028614312410355,
0.6399518251419067,
0.5109973549842834,
-0.5288198590278625,
-0.22430337965488434,
-0.8272827863693237,
0.4596906900405884,
-0.525506317615509,
-0.005453855264931917,
0.10472345352172852,
0.4647524952888489,
-0.41875341534614563,
-0.6293807029724121,
-0.3580356240272522,
-0.6134187579154968,
0.2164415419101715,
-0.005396020598709583,
0.011474011465907097,
0.4991280734539032,
0.5243163108825684,
0.15212003886699677,
-0.17670655250549316,
0.12048865109682083,
-0.21624642610549927,
-0.03431858494877815,
0.8055834174156189,
0.39944806694984436,
-0.003432587021961808,
0.6068277955055237,
-0.24817390739917755,
-0.6230536103248596,
-0.6041946411132812,
0.503180742263794,
0.3793928623199463,
0.510292649269104,
0.2347956895828247,
0.41492149233818054,
-0.4754325747489929,
0.4455086290836334,
0.36252161860466003,
-0.38574153184890747,
0.1154933050274849,
-0.013662219047546387,
0.1513376533985138,
0.026738811284303665,
0.5373978614807129,
0.1760154366493225,
0.3433823585510254,
-0.23421400785446167,
-0.5024765729904175,
-0.32868045568466187,
0.6268157362937927,
-0.9187400341033936,
-0.28255319595336914,
0.2663392722606659,
0.24164478480815887,
-0.3429764211177826,
-0.06653246283531189,
-0.24616731703281403,
-0.6844775676727295,
-0.48429563641548157,
0.6147158145904541,
-0.46608617901802063,
-0.16192002594470978,
0.018075060099363327,
0.02432473562657833,
0.4600207209587097,
0.7508886456489563,
-0.506494402885437,
0.28548508882522583,
0.9855236411094666,
0.5025961399078369,
-0.0208066888153553,
-0.4960015118122101,
-1.04103422164917,
0.06360232084989548,
-0.6551101207733154,
0.9969924092292786,
-0.7164520621299744,
-0.03477230668067932,
-0.003499826416373253,
-0.15913090109825134,
-0.20126889646053314,
-0.7418963313102722,
0.3753441870212555,
-0.4863857924938202,
-0.3800157904624939,
-0.28590500354766846,
-0.44896888732910156,
-0.35056254267692566,
0.3743417263031006,
-0.5240263342857361,
0.8331388831138611,
-0.0337851345539093,
-0.40847310423851013,
0.5626457333564758,
-0.8774968385696411,
-0.42648884654045105,
-0.08802125602960587,
0.004172520246356726,
-0.45340093970298767,
-0.020270345732569695,
0.19739724695682526,
0.4778893291950226,
-0.13925811648368835,
-0.00578520679846406,
-0.09115215390920639,
-0.6018586754798889,
-0.01818310283124447,
-0.06217117980122566,
0.16529656946659088,
0.12670111656188965,
-0.48713141679763794,
0.5847574472427368,
-0.9706886410713196,
0.0012994681019335985,
-0.1633739173412323,
-0.37139827013015747,
0.26012033224105835,
0.08860103040933609,
-0.580995500087738,
0.2592158019542694,
-0.041350383311510086,
-0.42618048191070557,
0.2577391266822815,
-0.1692836433649063,
0.08241801708936691,
0.8600748181343079,
0.2528376281261444,
0.3961068093776703,
-0.4998740255832672,
0.6815761923789978,
0.30650562047958374,
0.012887236662209034,
-0.4816226065158844,
-0.08559288084506989,
-0.8895477056503296,
-0.515120267868042,
0.013568916358053684,
0.5197121500968933,
-0.9039278030395508,
0.28939348459243774,
-0.12828761339187622,
-0.5047324895858765,
-0.7358749508857727,
0.18685778975486755,
0.30849114060401917,
0.4230499863624573,
0.22567686438560486,
-0.2610679268836975,
-0.1062435582280159,
-0.6013837456703186,
-0.18233877420425415,
-0.1557229906320572,
-0.046354927122592926,
-0.16160354018211365,
0.5034134387969971,
-0.0692516565322876,
0.6762181520462036,
0.04158797860145569,
-0.17187532782554626,
-0.2814236283302307,
0.5900118350982666,
-0.0030016014352440834,
0.5205538272857666,
-0.13231387734413147,
-0.41920676827430725,
-0.48794516921043396,
0.1928081214427948,
-0.522518515586853,
-0.046310167759656906,
-0.41487422585487366,
-0.1499699056148529,
-0.0681990310549736,
0.6333311200141907,
-0.3737544119358063,
0.4728296101093292,
0.033088646829128265,
-0.2420589178800583,
0.1806378960609436,
-0.411233127117157,
0.30077123641967773,
-0.6530491709709167,
-0.07697921991348267,
0.10024860501289368,
-0.4225931763648987,
-0.8436193466186523,
0.31938740611076355,
-0.09653333574533463,
0.06939811259508133,
-0.34974703192710876,
0.5317078232765198,
-0.5001447200775146,
-0.19485384225845337,
-0.6467991471290588,
0.020921770483255386,
-0.21605466306209564,
0.6709495782852173,
-0.02546234428882599,
0.6784518361091614,
0.6860103011131287,
-0.7159289717674255,
0.4072493612766266,
-0.1615777313709259,
-0.1974228173494339,
0.5494050979614258,
-0.517008364200592,
0.31840866804122925,
-0.49667710065841675,
0.22981953620910645,
-1.0983644723892212,
0.013037498109042645,
0.43819963932037354,
-0.4405320882797241,
0.6289010047912598,
-0.07508067786693573,
-0.49185699224472046,
-0.10134904831647873,
-0.31551623344421387,
-0.07335418462753296,
0.2081473022699356,
-0.43062469363212585,
0.8871312737464905,
-0.1484283208847046,
0.08113764226436615,
-0.7718899846076965,
-0.1632402390241623,
0.012461861595511436,
-0.059542302042245865,
-0.403917521238327,
0.04488111287355423,
-0.22647112607955933,
-0.30961641669273376,
-0.34145575761795044,
-0.3074999153614044,
0.0874055027961731,
0.21435947716236115,
0.3414609134197235,
-0.35596850514411926,
0.2377656251192093,
-0.08910025656223297,
-0.009747722186148167,
-0.28281787037849426,
-0.05176857113838196,
-0.10818774253129959,
0.41565021872520447,
0.014678659848868847,
-0.7172700762748718,
-0.5925173759460449,
0.07314170897006989,
0.400595486164093,
-0.2737200856208801,
0.4525465667247772,
0.8264150619506836,
-0.10536971688270569,
-0.4329885244369507,
-0.526703417301178,
-0.3758322298526764,
-0.5087786912918091,
0.3544822633266449,
-0.6697108745574951,
-0.7741850018501282,
0.4984695017337799,
-0.2787630558013916,
0.33511149883270264,
0.06890201568603516,
0.39835599064826965,
-0.12815533578395844,
1.1588252782821655,
0.7334701418876648,
0.14686934649944305,
0.5968436598777771,
-0.38496214151382446,
0.23796504735946655,
-0.5217921733856201,
-0.4887644350528717,
-0.3762839734554291,
-0.3931671380996704,
-0.49266883730888367,
-0.7242896556854248,
0.35111042857170105,
0.18472778797149658,
-0.5924311280250549,
0.028370732441544533,
-0.16565118730068207,
0.6176642179489136,
0.45778587460517883,
0.2132910192012787,
0.3480466306209564,
0.2158566564321518,
-0.06319911032915115,
0.20422741770744324,
-0.7466273903846741,
-0.5541173219680786,
0.9641581177711487,
0.41144636273384094,
0.8245508074760437,
-0.27968040108680725,
0.8699620366096497,
0.4786745607852936,
0.4889311194419861,
-0.7367637157440186,
0.7051109671592712,
0.28696390986442566,
-0.1000269204378128,
-0.42683547735214233,
-0.34187012910842896,
-0.8604822158813477,
0.32699114084243774,
-0.025338025763630867,
-0.5560389757156372,
0.0023990648332983255,
0.2872799038887024,
-0.10912446677684784,
0.3251006007194519,
-0.2719029486179352,
0.591923177242279,
-0.05808693543076515,
-0.6673281192779541,
-0.5646868348121643,
-0.40473267436027527,
-0.06283000111579895,
0.05872311443090439,
-0.011232626624405384,
-0.2293681502342224,
-0.22304902970790863,
0.2590571641921997,
-0.6398611068725586,
0.7740419507026672,
-0.3727395236492157,
-0.27724313735961914,
0.17842534184455872,
0.231304332613945,
1.0390069484710693,
-0.25027281045913696,
-0.26896584033966064,
-0.20896205306053162,
-0.5585976243019104,
-0.6326810121536255,
-0.5860760807991028,
0.38889431953430176,
-0.5338082909584045,
-0.7137418389320374,
-0.2777227759361267,
-0.6060618758201599,
-0.28064385056495667,
-0.10399671643972397,
-0.0319807343184948,
0.2178284227848053,
0.162638857960701,
-0.15161533653736115,
0.8186037540435791,
0.07899019867181778,
0.3052188754081726,
1.0711251497268677,
0.11418383568525314,
-0.24995176494121552,
0.7148772478103638,
-0.19260495901107788,
0.2416890263557434,
0.748688817024231,
-0.1718069463968277,
-0.08138399571180344,
-0.816534161567688,
-0.24121731519699097,
0.14195415377616882,
-0.8452903032302856,
-0.08684195578098297,
-0.4035797715187073,
-0.11370710283517838,
-0.19181586802005768,
-0.2249596118927002,
-0.4556533694267273,
0.04810233786702156,
-0.06359900534152985,
-0.40178319811820984,
0.34263330698013306,
0.7896103262901306,
-0.2637781798839569,
0.5248870849609375,
-0.5314793586730957,
0.052277762442827225,
0.2911272346973419,
0.1466776430606842,
0.08062732964754105,
-0.6085827350616455,
-0.4656932055950165,
-0.044950585812330246,
-0.33199620246887207,
-0.36077749729156494,
0.36884042620658875,
0.24583080410957336,
0.7630912661552429,
0.5354585647583008,
0.02847367152571678,
0.7555535435676575,
-0.6029109358787537,
0.49869996309280396,
-0.059408027678728104,
-0.708541989326477,
0.4816811680793762,
-0.31664666533470154,
0.2794478237628937,
0.5887029767036438,
0.5134928822517395,
-0.2013014256954193,
-0.545301616191864,
-0.49597397446632385,
-1.0891215801239014,
0.870441198348999,
0.058294132351875305,
-0.1676405519247055,
0.28976401686668396,
0.6162415742874146,
0.01917397789657116,
0.3937229812145233,
-0.5310288667678833,
-0.11543448269367218,
0.16897991299629211,
-0.057899296283721924,
-0.267473042011261,
0.13920843601226807,
-0.38030150532722473,
-0.1986677199602127,
0.7943258881568909,
-0.2990557551383972,
0.20218977332115173,
0.08112829923629761,
-0.11515013128519058,
-0.5051658749580383,
0.06343810260295868,
0.48624250292778015,
0.8525263667106628,
-0.1345033496618271,
-0.0368896909058094,
0.10005446523427963,
-0.03355766087770462,
0.3141748905181885,
0.2148873656988144,
0.15352290868759155,
-0.25544121861457825,
0.5502320528030396,
1.045115351676941,
0.11622701585292816,
-0.8295899033546448,
0.29412075877189636,
0.024583758786320686,
-0.3018134832382202,
-0.2844528555870056,
0.5059170722961426,
-0.20388799905776978,
0.893310010433197,
0.4813762903213501,
-0.10799885541200638,
0.22031384706497192,
-0.6135100722312927,
0.3617142140865326,
0.232235848903656,
-0.5379840135574341,
-0.12999819219112396,
0.43947136402130127,
0.04744645953178406,
-0.4423893392086029,
0.3941156566143036,
-0.43501850962638855,
-0.48543062806129456,
0.6248658895492554,
0.18506409227848053,
1.0292155742645264,
-0.3324717879295349,
0.5169745087623596,
0.37292057275772095,
0.31825369596481323,
-0.2950129508972168,
0.3168089985847473,
-0.38077229261398315,
-0.5834737420082092,
-0.6457573771476746,
-0.472492516040802,
-0.7319157719612122,
-0.009997055865824223,
-0.40536075830459595,
0.1717270314693451,
-0.4640262722969055,
0.198959618806839,
-0.09935561567544937,
0.14701589941978455,
-0.665984034538269,
0.3261687457561493,
0.009279349818825722,
0.8096904158592224,
-0.7245290279388428,
0.8225204944610596,
0.9187011122703552,
-0.46988338232040405,
-0.7957155704498291,
0.1862286925315857,
0.028064316138625145,
-0.9087086319923401,
0.7123216986656189,
0.08106771856546402,
-0.5830979943275452,
0.17040495574474335,
-0.6545737385749817,
-0.7770866751670837,
1.2328497171401978,
0.20601513981819153,
-0.655707597732544,
-0.002505859127268195,
0.28410330414772034,
0.8274423480033875,
-0.6577697992324829,
0.6070191264152527,
0.5067173838615417,
0.28890520334243774,
0.6839568614959717,
-0.4694366157054901,
-0.0971837043762207,
-0.3178969919681549,
0.0741691067814827,
-0.004647198598831892,
-0.6122971773147583,
0.7510705590248108,
-0.5466262102127075,
0.000928462715819478,
-0.15614059567451477,
0.49589723348617554,
0.5362124443054199,
0.5899209380149841,
0.620783269405365,
0.45043325424194336,
0.7343900799751282,
-0.08401753008365631,
0.8569623231887817,
-0.531512439250946,
0.12410668283700943,
1.0334765911102295,
-0.35905730724334717,
0.7162573337554932,
0.11604803800582886,
0.07095975428819656,
0.5672785043716431,
0.8649848699569702,
0.23230917751789093,
0.43085286021232605,
0.5219758152961731,
-0.2914063632488251,
-0.5202707052230835,
-0.059693049639463425,
0.20609822869300842,
0.16853578388690948,
0.1871768832206726,
-0.10567969083786011,
-0.3625538945198059,
0.08378840982913971,
0.1694788783788681,
0.08619017153978348,
-0.7523303031921387,
0.879533588886261,
-0.07180186361074448,
-0.6320546269416809,
0.4906790852546692,
-0.20581260323524475,
0.30921441316604614,
-0.7148820757865906,
-0.35114771127700806,
-0.3753907382488251,
0.4439062476158142,
-0.1838751584291458,
-0.5551168918609619,
-0.23716038465499878,
0.11762034893035889,
0.15519504249095917,
-0.3217112123966217,
0.5283864736557007,
-0.5991215705871582,
-0.09546321630477905,
0.3031103312969208,
0.1937432438135147,
0.2542044520378113,
-0.3195241689682007,
-0.7055802345275879,
-0.21703509986400604,
0.04042435064911842,
-0.39740872383117676,
0.314815491437912,
0.7192318439483643,
0.06950721889734268,
1.1564339399337769,
0.30885758996009827,
0.10218767076730728,
-0.1517278403043747,
0.15021836757659912,
0.7737553119659424,
-0.6499611139297485,
-0.18964461982250214,
-0.5757131576538086,
1.0037028789520264,
-0.16309963166713715,
0.07341630011796951,
0.473257839679718,
0.3745766878128052,
1.047165036201477,
0.1604248583316803,
0.6313895583152771,
0.47255727648735046,
0.5101732015609741,
-0.45327028632164,
0.16062837839126587,
-0.628682017326355,
0.588956892490387,
-0.0977751612663269,
-0.8534459471702576,
0.08384827524423599,
0.5314470529556274,
-0.22869965434074402,
0.21423687040805817,
0.5836746096611023,
1.0535999536514282,
0.19164502620697021,
-0.3731071650981903,
0.37645506858825684,
0.14064070582389832,
0.5626506209373474,
0.3490767478942871,
0.8110008835792542,
-0.18213576078414917,
0.4285149574279785,
-0.282390296459198,
-0.23487313091754913,
-0.16055132448673248,
-0.885524570941925,
-0.7265481948852539,
-0.3930187523365021,
-0.671093761920929,
-0.13972698152065277,
0.39025411009788513,
1.2579885721206665,
0.676437497138977,
-0.8265519142150879,
-0.5476772785186768,
-0.15637147426605225,
0.0366668738424778,
-0.5620719790458679,
-0.13905562460422516,
-0.10613854974508286,
-0.7554143071174622,
-0.9143304824829102,
0.6267030239105225,
0.2863845229148865,
-0.202091783285141,
-0.14643940329551697,
-0.24348561465740204,
0.06246310472488403,
0.09433044493198395,
0.40070441365242004,
0.3451457917690277,
-0.44834229350090027,
-0.11923739314079285,
-0.3458225727081299,
0.0075545418076217175,
0.21323932707309723,
0.9575865864753723,
-0.5341745018959045,
0.5610125064849854,
0.42936721444129944,
0.41932135820388794,
0.8191032409667969,
0.07843372970819473,
0.6973950862884521,
-0.6428487300872803,
-0.09361928701400757,
0.1838838905096054,
0.05728207901120186,
0.3465504050254822,
-0.22871805727481842,
0.7174037098884583,
-0.13981787860393524,
-0.6626699566841125,
-0.6906880736351013,
0.1712729036808014,
-0.8291744589805603,
-0.03921039402484894,
1.097791075706482,
-0.2604212462902069,
-0.05290018022060394,
0.07475299388170242,
-0.286522775888443,
0.4485238194465637,
-0.8510949611663818,
0.9483891725540161,
0.4410287141799927,
-0.5135043263435364,
-0.48864805698394775,
-0.44448229670524597,
0.6667808294296265,
0.04191580414772034,
-0.787137508392334,
0.012826204299926758,
0.4238196611404419,
0.29380878806114197,
-0.036750175058841705,
0.6738131046295166,
0.17345429956912994,
0.12973791360855103,
-0.024304309859871864,
0.31028610467910767,
-0.2766615152359009,
-0.6702929735183716,
-0.6836900115013123,
0.07867514342069626,
0.5071290135383606,
-0.06527311354875565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11173v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11173v2 | BSRBF-KAN: A combination of B-splines and Radial Basic Functions in Kolmogorov-Arnold Networks | 2024-06-17T03:26:02 | 2024-06-19T23:01:14 | Hoang-Thang Ta | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we introduce BSRBF-KAN, a Kolmogorov Arnold Network (KAN) that
combines Bsplines and radial basis functions (RBFs) to fit input vectors in
data training. We perform experiments with BSRBF-KAN, MLP, and other popular
KANs, including EfficientKAN, FastKAN, FasterKAN, and GottliebKAN over the
MNIST and Fashion-MNIST datasets. BSRBF-KAN shows stability in 5 training
sessions with a competitive average accuracy of 97.55% on MNIST and 89.33% on
FashionMNIST and obtains convergence better than other networks. We expect
BSRBF-KAN to open many combinations of mathematical functions to design KANs.
Our repo is publicly available at: https://github.com/hoangthangta/BSRBF-KAN. | [
-0.5003301501274109,
-0.643843948841095,
0.1972801238298416,
0.7147542834281921,
-0.5873470306396484,
0.12199262529611588,
-0.061352893710136414,
-0.4184255003929138,
0.2690439820289612,
0.3532179594039917,
-0.570314884185791,
-0.4136727452278137,
-0.36814817786216736,
0.13046181201934814,
-0.3513503968715668,
0.9982302784919739,
0.03449403494596481,
0.7732937335968018,
-0.09419386833906174,
-0.5504408478736877,
-0.3195289969444275,
-0.3871713876724243,
-0.40254753828048706,
-0.45615071058273315,
0.9217207431793213,
0.35274505615234375,
0.5787734389305115,
0.5029858350753784,
0.5756598711013794,
0.17536894977092743,
-0.001139034517109394,
0.008706548251211643,
-0.5111743807792664,
0.5715160369873047,
-0.15948715806007385,
-0.2697370946407318,
-0.007736867759376764,
-1.073222041130066,
0.9121530652046204,
0.7283143401145935,
-0.49914535880088806,
0.16169247031211853,
-0.276773065328598,
0.9783634543418884,
-0.5147560238838196,
0.005482414737343788,
-0.28467100858688354,
0.0010765090119093657,
0.0123232901096344,
0.22627919912338257,
-0.31647923588752747,
-0.7532596588134766,
0.33653226494789124,
-0.07824351638555527,
-0.03262942284345627,
0.1967540681362152,
1.0895400047302246,
0.08143167197704315,
-0.31501320004463196,
-0.1940094381570816,
-0.6070085167884827,
0.5738697052001953,
-0.5185749530792236,
0.807332456111908,
0.1674647331237793,
0.8129561543464661,
-0.14297793805599213,
-0.7203185558319092,
-0.23266549408435822,
-0.12541703879833221,
-0.011997544206678867,
-0.03363490849733353,
0.0055577512830495834,
0.26443493366241455,
0.22879871726036072,
0.09826696664094925,
-0.5986680388450623,
-0.15364471077919006,
-0.7866686582565308,
-0.0213954858481884,
0.8098346590995789,
-0.006260705646127462,
-0.041759468615055084,
-0.05244721844792366,
-0.6792668700218201,
-0.28246232867240906,
-0.6110245585441589,
-0.061054982244968414,
0.5726850032806396,
0.43123623728752136,
0.0694071352481842,
0.5890740752220154,
-0.18349185585975647,
1.124490737915039,
-0.27303940057754517,
-0.013213861733675003,
0.16399303078651428,
-0.010597217828035355,
-0.6445110440254211,
0.354661226272583,
0.6838520765304565,
0.06734143197536469,
0.16440746188163757,
-0.21730199456214905,
-0.25611457228660583,
-0.33688631653785706,
0.1122058853507042,
-0.9625298380851746,
-0.4145023822784424,
-0.11989578604698181,
-0.5660880208015442,
-0.5900307297706604,
0.0985463485121727,
-0.7792702913284302,
-0.0976686030626297,
-0.441184937953949,
0.842663049697876,
-0.37662094831466675,
-0.22243797779083252,
-0.14028066396713257,
-0.22071462869644165,
0.38036176562309265,
0.05274293199181557,
-0.5314275622367859,
0.5141957402229309,
0.1615508794784546,
0.9353827238082886,
0.41585883498191833,
-0.11894222348928452,
-0.3625360429286957,
-0.1868973672389984,
-0.4961654543876648,
0.5803330540657043,
-0.1281595379114151,
-0.5679280757904053,
0.028455691412091255,
-0.027472618967294693,
0.13814720511436462,
-0.32908695936203003,
0.15207238495349884,
-0.5511439442634583,
-0.40728890895843506,
-0.4861680567264557,
-0.14701737463474274,
-0.5805590152740479,
0.02358900010585785,
-0.6799774169921875,
1.1273624897003174,
0.24192319810390472,
-0.49833714962005615,
0.18339116871356964,
-0.3454553782939911,
-0.6896816492080688,
0.04456966370344162,
-0.14047226309776306,
-0.806024968624115,
-0.1368342936038971,
-0.15249989926815033,
0.5896720290184021,
-0.14843402802944183,
0.2919676601886749,
-1.0898431539535522,
-0.32601889967918396,
0.3855091631412506,
-0.12492880970239639,
0.8453549146652222,
0.19809725880622864,
-0.10230223089456558,
0.0797307938337326,
-1.1462931632995605,
0.2307692915201187,
-0.019318681210279465,
-0.24686382710933685,
-0.049763258546590805,
-0.24639518558979034,
0.49673956632614136,
0.03605161979794502,
-0.07079915702342987,
-0.3332659900188446,
0.08964020758867264,
-0.0005120381247252226,
0.31931573152542114,
0.969547688961029,
0.11003867536783218,
-0.024772951379418373,
-0.6117874383926392,
0.5482101440429688,
-0.4270695745944977,
-0.2807559669017792,
0.19567465782165527,
-0.5164982080459595,
-0.34617742896080017,
-0.638282060623169,
0.5960030555725098,
0.27756592631340027,
-0.6704680919647217,
0.38675469160079956,
0.12398042529821396,
-0.7825503349304199,
0.0811619982123375,
0.06593476235866547,
0.37704694271087646,
0.5646791458129883,
0.20141302049160004,
-0.20254924893379211,
-0.9557228684425354,
-1.0684374570846558,
0.05900684371590614,
-0.012750704772770405,
0.3757661283016205,
0.506803035736084,
0.39154213666915894,
-0.3442907929420471,
0.929021954536438,
-0.5182225704193115,
-0.0026884169783443213,
-0.26844435930252075,
0.11317526549100876,
0.2457374781370163,
0.37995046377182007,
0.8997344374656677,
-0.7496730089187622,
-0.87067049741745,
0.2908637225627899,
-0.47891613841056824,
-0.028122639283537865,
0.20394614338874817,
-0.3891822397708893,
0.3430483639240265,
-0.033991675823926926,
-0.35516223311424255,
0.4424411952495575,
0.5914201140403748,
-0.20048968493938446,
0.8811274766921997,
-0.08098825812339783,
-0.13718967139720917,
-1.0945063829421997,
0.47844815254211426,
0.1465536504983902,
-0.7022812366485596,
-0.45039600133895874,
-0.03212074562907219,
-0.00745686748996377,
-0.4577410817146301,
-0.15957067906856537,
0.3483075201511383,
-0.10146012902259827,
-0.45866408944129944,
0.1984274685382843,
-0.34784603118896484,
-0.3219083249568939,
0.8479647040367126,
-0.11678671091794968,
0.5095170736312866,
0.8323686718940735,
-0.4970892369747162,
0.5256505012512207,
0.37832728028297424,
-0.16983562707901,
0.44589677453041077,
-0.8513866066932678,
0.2609758675098419,
-0.33530062437057495,
0.11744790524244308,
-1.23563814163208,
-0.43227607011795044,
0.5282241702079773,
-0.47173672914505005,
0.5628042817115784,
-0.376681387424469,
-0.366152822971344,
-0.2899298071861267,
-0.17819754779338837,
0.28027117252349854,
0.37638723850250244,
-0.5670992136001587,
0.5910754799842834,
0.28488636016845703,
0.015538672916591167,
-1.050586462020874,
-0.636944055557251,
-0.5727465152740479,
0.043718304485082626,
-0.6787573099136353,
-0.15995033085346222,
-0.00503170071169734,
0.10531050711870193,
0.4443586468696594,
-0.528363049030304,
-0.4383103549480438,
-0.11487255245447159,
0.23301109671592712,
0.45619866251945496,
-0.5041220784187317,
-0.17569932341575623,
0.060184724628925323,
0.4441158175468445,
-0.22934864461421967,
-0.23713164031505585,
0.6738759875297546,
-0.4441632628440857,
0.11987114697694778,
-0.23862797021865845,
0.1996137648820877,
0.6937365531921387,
0.1752326786518097,
0.9543271064758301,
0.5315465927124023,
-0.5928404927253723,
-0.39553138613700867,
-0.1721089482307434,
0.05921689048409462,
-0.45590314269065857,
0.5232264995574951,
-0.1330345720052719,
-0.6154327392578125,
0.5052508115768433,
0.26876139640808105,
-0.11039836704730988,
0.056286606937646866,
0.3520267903804779,
-0.2849469780921936,
0.9873148798942566,
0.467262864112854,
0.1278112232685089,
0.6013610363006592,
-0.5114128589630127,
0.25399476289749146,
-0.6896624565124512,
-0.40242233872413635,
-0.4597568213939667,
-0.6921114325523376,
-0.5633235573768616,
-0.06188749521970749,
0.10130366683006287,
0.5672782063484192,
-0.5337682962417603,
0.8544089198112488,
-0.47512900829315186,
0.16113978624343872,
0.3189738094806671,
0.3346281945705414,
-0.3609670400619507,
0.11171621829271317,
-0.12749555706977844,
0.27499711513519287,
-0.9804139137268066,
0.1288605034351349,
1.382580280303955,
0.42403581738471985,
1.0009491443634033,
0.2907143235206604,
0.657911479473114,
0.08142438530921936,
0.45737558603286743,
-0.963674783706665,
0.5719532370567322,
-0.049659788608551025,
-0.7792010307312012,
-0.44179555773735046,
-0.7050080299377441,
-0.5681347250938416,
0.19012509286403656,
-0.4138808250427246,
-0.6781841516494751,
0.5336608290672302,
0.6811728477478027,
-0.2805628478527069,
0.10968288779258728,
-0.8116110563278198,
0.560543954372406,
-0.40186095237731934,
-0.26737290620803833,
-0.1164579838514328,
-0.6978704333305359,
0.31026491522789,
0.166880264878273,
-0.08648484200239182,
0.1378893107175827,
0.5792995095252991,
0.7845607995986938,
-0.5573432445526123,
0.4821855425834656,
-0.24597275257110596,
0.5596246123313904,
0.3802907168865204,
-0.05585067346692085,
0.510493278503418,
0.24289238452911377,
0.20043371617794037,
0.30456477403640747,
0.2970430254936218,
-0.3413201570510864,
-0.6691777110099792,
0.5464681386947632,
-0.7542182803153992,
0.1833067685365677,
-0.5865461230278015,
-0.1601831465959549,
-0.22575734555721283,
0.5569825768470764,
0.17950180172920227,
0.9852443337440491,
-0.0009849951602518559,
0.8607396483421326,
0.6669763922691345,
0.2950904071331024,
0.25378385186195374,
-0.27470511198043823,
-0.4709561765193939,
-1.1389254331588745,
1.1471606492996216,
0.2515058219432831,
0.17389561235904694,
0.18641126155853271,
0.21469508111476898,
-0.48002398014068604,
-0.12984012067317963,
-0.6613750457763672,
0.41167783737182617,
-0.886851966381073,
-0.5603692531585693,
-0.1504700481891632,
-0.5387555956840515,
-0.1978704035282135,
-0.212417870759964,
-0.07322832942008972,
-0.46882423758506775,
0.1631682813167572,
0.07706310600042343,
0.30766862630844116,
0.8930454850196838,
-0.2701083719730377,
0.4114989638328552,
-0.45470938086509705,
-0.010551629588007927,
0.3439268171787262,
0.45807939767837524,
0.12983405590057373,
0.11348643898963928,
-0.39898020029067993,
0.034645501524209976,
-0.274337500333786,
-1.0031993389129639,
0.2049979269504547,
0.12917138636112213,
0.5682680606842041,
0.45240485668182373,
-0.37652388215065,
0.5324019193649292,
-0.508249819278717,
0.07317554205656052,
0.7945016026496887,
-0.6417532563209534,
-0.13838498294353485,
-0.49900123476982117,
-0.23661457002162933,
0.3553801476955414,
0.6362882852554321,
-0.4673589766025543,
0.10519276559352875,
-0.5453611612319946,
-0.6115769743919373,
0.7935699224472046,
0.5171212553977966,
-0.5041235685348511,
0.4661839008331299,
0.13675320148468018,
-0.156515970826149,
0.7624617218971252,
-0.6017674207687378,
-0.5546576380729675,
-0.7502980828285217,
-0.6587846279144287,
0.22718626260757446,
-0.21507088840007782,
-0.29272836446762085,
-0.33964142203330994,
0.7330631613731384,
0.009426169097423553,
0.6549627184867859,
0.3712040185928345,
-0.055584073066711426,
-0.32659247517585754,
-0.45615729689598083,
1.0403423309326172,
0.9896831512451172,
-0.5946782827377319,
-0.11060668528079987,
0.10182211548089981,
-0.5949388742446899,
0.0616510845720768,
0.18432392179965973,
-0.0196377020329237,
0.21747492253780365,
0.15663088858127594,
1.1194748878479004,
0.47506943345069885,
-0.36008819937705994,
0.10087976604700089,
-0.02074931189417839,
-0.34679460525512695,
-0.30200615525245667,
0.1667434275150299,
-0.02504674158990383,
0.18474896252155304,
0.29932406544685364,
0.6733210682868958,
-0.15150244534015656,
-0.5537620186805725,
0.5465142130851746,
0.4383350908756256,
-0.40194928646087646,
-0.337179571390152,
0.30467766523361206,
-0.06511461734771729,
-0.7050319314002991,
0.15671293437480927,
-0.06823484599590302,
-0.7297439575195312,
0.7935689091682434,
0.6865146160125732,
0.6959762573242188,
-0.134974867105484,
0.16011185944080353,
0.6926657557487488,
0.14340737462043762,
-0.240382581949234,
0.14697368443012238,
-0.37002497911453247,
-0.6248610019683838,
-0.23228104412555695,
-0.8551934957504272,
-0.3426542282104492,
0.21317324042320251,
-0.8602357506752014,
0.6410906314849854,
-1.033841609954834,
-0.08221534639596939,
-0.06006500497460365,
-0.05377136543393135,
-0.6151543855667114,
0.31762731075286865,
-0.08012521266937256,
0.9125988483428955,
-0.6314361691474915,
0.48389190435409546,
1.0124105215072632,
-0.28562048077583313,
-0.8792513608932495,
-0.15883755683898926,
-0.4315403401851654,
-0.8677010536193848,
0.6757335662841797,
0.2427920252084732,
-0.24916335940361023,
0.12051192671060562,
-0.526007890701294,
-1.0562468767166138,
1.2599501609802246,
0.28955215215682983,
-0.6872271299362183,
-0.08681627362966537,
-0.3364468514919281,
0.23653027415275574,
-0.061667587608098984,
-0.16990838944911957,
0.13285566866397858,
0.2291851043701172,
0.5082288980484009,
-0.3845285177230835,
-0.271034836769104,
0.02315998077392578,
0.40212637186050415,
0.500146210193634,
-0.7170054912567139,
0.3246816396713257,
0.145948588848114,
0.13953058421611786,
0.2879940867424011,
0.45714208483695984,
0.61875981092453,
0.26665395498275757,
0.4929625391960144,
0.813771665096283,
0.4912288188934326,
-0.10856474190950394,
0.492311954498291,
-0.14424379169940948,
0.9097645282745361,
0.7527667880058289,
0.07004741579294205,
0.5532696843147278,
0.220052108168602,
-0.25063735246658325,
0.7672858834266663,
0.5698370933532715,
-0.020792409777641296,
0.9414560198783875,
0.34864139556884766,
-0.17914482951164246,
-0.1739206165075302,
0.7029280066490173,
-0.47364553809165955,
-0.0325046144425869,
0.36055558919906616,
-0.036553606390953064,
-0.41081297397613525,
0.061286214739084244,
-0.18507562577724457,
-0.41098058223724365,
-0.39354807138442993,
0.15856948494911194,
0.24407926201820374,
-0.22889260947704315,
0.5592175126075745,
-0.05599457025527954,
0.14903049170970917,
-1.0592914819717407,
-0.21962714195251465,
0.08663450926542282,
0.036791227757930756,
-0.18231524527072906,
-0.6915417909622192,
0.3118000626564026,
-0.4139385521411896,
-0.08491102606058121,
0.14615032076835632,
0.9274852275848389,
-0.4215804934501648,
-0.689550518989563,
0.16299965977668762,
-0.5432407259941101,
-0.14975222945213318,
0.6644513607025146,
-0.5212823152542114,
0.26226842403411865,
-0.039410483092069626,
-0.04444555938243866,
0.04315320774912834,
0.2739700973033905,
0.11178621649742126,
0.7353763580322266,
0.8824998140335083,
0.306972861289978,
0.32755550742149353,
-0.3977471590042114,
0.5619330406188965,
-0.36287280917167664,
-0.590343713760376,
-0.5503597259521484,
0.615898847579956,
-0.25069549679756165,
-0.5506914258003235,
0.30083975195884705,
0.3720282316207886,
0.7992904782295227,
-0.09800374507904053,
0.643496036529541,
-0.36637482047080994,
0.2208593636751175,
-0.49858012795448303,
1.0184282064437866,
-0.5820576548576355,
-0.3031483292579651,
-0.1572740226984024,
-1.0058012008666992,
-0.3976972699165344,
1.2256381511688232,
0.10569457709789276,
0.16702251136302948,
0.520776629447937,
0.7190538644790649,
-0.21954314410686493,
-0.033061783760786057,
0.3785143792629242,
0.0661129429936409,
0.047759760171175,
0.1493382453918457,
0.4349573850631714,
-0.39428427815437317,
0.4712296724319458,
-0.6291431784629822,
-0.08218157291412354,
-0.7658511996269226,
-0.7188447713851929,
-1.1406234502792358,
-0.8219759464263916,
-0.02359871380031109,
-0.6364570260047913,
0.20922371745109558,
1.1346890926361084,
1.003455400466919,
-0.8295985460281372,
-0.32123270630836487,
-0.5959525108337402,
0.2387862652540207,
-0.3400135934352875,
-0.2171953171491623,
0.4046005606651306,
-0.3304474651813507,
-0.10709827393293381,
0.09834261983633041,
0.2590455412864685,
0.14222374558448792,
-0.3227136433124542,
-0.3438114821910858,
-0.17055509984493256,
0.2121080607175827,
0.46814629435539246,
0.624016523361206,
-0.09806090593338013,
-0.29542237520217896,
0.2078833132982254,
0.15802131593227386,
-0.17314346134662628,
0.6634259223937988,
-0.5985922813415527,
0.5682597160339355,
0.608893871307373,
0.8976494073867798,
0.6233764886856079,
-0.03153218328952789,
0.7508581876754761,
-0.7886031270027161,
0.25725409388542175,
0.4007326364517212,
0.5637444257736206,
0.2589839696884155,
-0.3710090219974518,
0.3437568247318268,
0.5767408609390259,
-0.6762977838516235,
-1.5208760499954224,
0.2926744818687439,
-1.0741080045700073,
0.00187120889313519,
0.9255678653717041,
0.18323908746242523,
-0.6561353206634521,
0.2565106153488159,
-0.3473726511001587,
0.25173068046569824,
-0.3596521317958832,
0.5099250674247742,
0.9766000509262085,
-0.17131765186786652,
-0.16180045902729034,
-0.278672456741333,
0.6071247458457947,
0.30094394087791443,
-0.13892626762390137,
-0.5098627805709839,
0.13268034160137177,
0.6108816862106323,
0.026573024690151215,
0.4019765853881836,
0.24148981273174286,
0.7745185494422913,
-0.23453016579151154,
-0.08399055153131485,
-0.3612585663795471,
-0.700169563293457,
-0.3829787075519562,
-0.12900099158287048,
0.08018772304058075,
-0.4636666476726532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11172v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11172v1 | Enhancing Criminal Case Matching through Diverse Legal Factors | 2024-06-17T03:23:11 | 2024-06-17T03:23:11 | Jie Zhao, Ziyu Guan, Wei Zhao, Yue Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Criminal case matching endeavors to determine the relevance between different
criminal cases. Conventional methods predict the relevance solely based on
instance-level semantic features and neglect the diverse legal factors (LFs),
which are associated with diverse court judgments. Consequently,
comprehensively representing a criminal case remains a challenge for these
approaches. Moreover, extracting and utilizing these LFs for criminal case
matching face two challenges: (1) the manual annotations of LFs rely heavily on
specialized legal knowledge; (2) overlaps among LFs may potentially harm the
model's performance. In this paper, we propose a two-stage framework named
Diverse Legal Factor-enhanced Criminal Case Matching (DLF-CCM). Firstly,
DLF-CCM employs a multi-task learning framework to pre-train an LF extraction
network on a large-scale legal judgment prediction dataset. In stage two,
DLF-CCM introduces an LF de-redundancy module to learn shared LF and exclusive
LFs. Moreover, an entropy-weighted fusion strategy is introduced to dynamically
fuse the multiple relevance generated by all LFs. Experimental results validate
the effectiveness of DLF-CCM and show its significant improvements over
competitive baselines. Code: https://github.com/jiezhao6/DLF-CCM. | [
-0.378227561712265,
-0.5283513069152832,
0.8228864073753357,
0.13969194889068604,
-0.5719166994094849,
0.3691033124923706,
-0.0658477172255516,
-0.6345965266227722,
-0.028753692284226418,
0.561869740486145,
-0.4888627529144287,
-0.43684113025665283,
-0.38270998001098633,
-0.03661242127418518,
-0.2698136866092682,
0.9287291765213013,
0.24065428972244263,
0.2649948298931122,
-0.27350330352783203,
-0.4579859673976898,
-0.7658808827400208,
-0.5370899438858032,
-0.29013121128082275,
-0.3669910728931427,
0.40939435362815857,
0.2587473690509796,
0.3615914285182953,
0.5106390714645386,
0.735620379447937,
0.31009694933891296,
0.21551752090454102,
0.21829400956630707,
-0.39288729429244995,
0.2614521086215973,
-0.4496498107910156,
-0.29237350821495056,
-0.315600723028183,
-0.1335761547088623,
0.097147136926651,
0.24969379603862762,
-0.32350000739097595,
-0.18284061551094055,
-0.22923272848129272,
0.628727376461029,
-0.9730956554412842,
-0.05651119723916054,
-0.7085662484169006,
0.18559925258159637,
-0.43726199865341187,
-0.3647065758705139,
-0.22806735336780548,
-0.1893509477376938,
0.016897620633244514,
-0.7900161743164062,
0.4336041808128357,
0.002032889984548092,
0.6643465757369995,
0.27129435539245605,
-0.8348323702812195,
-0.08482173085212708,
-0.7133844494819641,
0.19369477033615112,
-0.4925838112831116,
0.017213523387908936,
0.3159986734390259,
0.41418135166168213,
-0.19652718305587769,
-0.371900737285614,
-0.6778150200843811,
-0.02250300534069538,
-0.3120950758457184,
0.2983275055885315,
0.09884954988956451,
0.28581175208091736,
0.35654598474502563,
0.34793588519096375,
-0.45387786626815796,
0.15725626051425934,
-0.32360443472862244,
-0.5160406827926636,
0.6137388944625854,
0.31607818603515625,
0.22071334719657898,
0.3235587775707245,
-0.28122806549072266,
-0.2644564211368561,
-0.5475773811340332,
0.14247719943523407,
0.7360563278198242,
0.748327374458313,
-0.1383766084909439,
0.3729637563228607,
-0.30940720438957214,
0.5299769043922424,
0.38881635665893555,
-0.35388579964637756,
0.7739685773849487,
-0.8128158450126648,
-0.16412656009197235,
0.13954704999923706,
0.7382210493087769,
0.4819648265838623,
0.05181693658232689,
0.05533107742667198,
-0.14050109684467316,
-0.15574294328689575,
0.19516927003860474,
-0.6747198104858398,
0.09833183139562607,
0.3321927785873413,
-0.31210726499557495,
-0.3178867697715759,
0.5192439556121826,
-0.7709140777587891,
-0.9063274264335632,
-0.2555960714817047,
0.3098956048488617,
-0.29342204332351685,
-0.3436327278614044,
0.011225245893001556,
-0.2885787785053253,
0.5635563731193542,
0.45454779267311096,
-0.4854743480682373,
-0.08380381017923355,
0.9099237322807312,
0.48435452580451965,
-0.18131624162197113,
0.24149839580059052,
-0.9227938652038574,
0.13536575436592102,
-0.10051508247852325,
0.41670680046081543,
-0.7909853458404541,
0.025657203048467636,
0.30367618799209595,
0.05500170961022377,
0.26156461238861084,
-0.6194724440574646,
0.823632538318634,
-0.7105290293693542,
-0.11447436362504959,
-0.6257869601249695,
-0.26584213972091675,
-0.16901928186416626,
0.23520493507385254,
-0.7627292275428772,
0.6767863631248474,
0.008804917335510254,
-0.6748910546302795,
1.0184324979782104,
-0.4030376672744751,
-0.8531873226165771,
0.4999021887779236,
-0.19724832475185394,
-0.6912699341773987,
0.014624093659222126,
0.14214347302913666,
0.4884295165538788,
-0.08243218064308167,
0.4558759927749634,
-0.8436410427093506,
-0.33615151047706604,
-0.0808858647942543,
0.10578273236751556,
0.7902176976203918,
0.4093641936779022,
-0.26758384704589844,
0.11809003353118896,
-0.783459484577179,
-0.541702389717102,
-0.03104480914771557,
-0.43837469816207886,
-0.30139485001564026,
-0.039338212460279465,
0.17904193699359894,
0.3589480221271515,
0.1253734529018402,
-0.598284900188446,
-0.2502623200416565,
-0.08023665100336075,
0.2734282612800598,
0.5239085555076599,
-0.024379121139645576,
0.4516914188861847,
-0.34048333764076233,
0.5002162456512451,
0.3494091331958771,
-0.2464398741722107,
-0.11853660643100739,
-0.12120131403207779,
-0.42059198021888733,
-0.43654149770736694,
0.20574571192264557,
0.982363760471344,
-0.6189449429512024,
0.5401509404182434,
0.08129801601171494,
-0.21907666325569153,
-0.4469633102416992,
0.22844025492668152,
0.03536209091544151,
0.07459324598312378,
0.3585890233516693,
-0.3949955999851227,
-0.6319988369941711,
-0.7937349081039429,
-0.40910524129867554,
-0.01721905916929245,
0.08990651369094849,
0.6052877306938171,
0.5223844647407532,
-0.02114175073802471,
0.7593404054641724,
-0.07485094666481018,
-0.8168566823005676,
-0.14126892387866974,
-0.068499855697155,
0.43112367391586304,
0.4396628439426422,
0.7299598455429077,
-0.9192931652069092,
-0.5949264168739319,
0.2203645259141922,
-0.6023977398872375,
-0.04479565471410751,
-0.42681825160980225,
-0.17665523290634155,
-0.4444640874862671,
0.5522513389587402,
-0.4133574366569519,
0.2622636556625366,
-0.1583363562822342,
-0.6843398809432983,
0.17668472230434418,
-0.1669550985097885,
0.5649943351745605,
-0.8143203258514404,
-0.20979468524456024,
0.23412592709064484,
-0.5233942270278931,
-0.7530108094215393,
0.5450570583343506,
0.09786418080329895,
-0.0871506854891777,
-0.6563611626625061,
0.21894292533397675,
-0.40477773547172546,
0.012725099921226501,
-0.1703120917081833,
0.3575499951839447,
-0.17690199613571167,
0.507714569568634,
-0.2854979634284973,
0.4299107789993286,
0.7232263088226318,
-0.24977122247219086,
0.44327402114868164,
-0.19702862203121185,
-0.42685070633888245,
0.9999892115592957,
-0.3490481972694397,
-0.046752940863370895,
-0.2965528964996338,
0.040271513164043427,
-0.5941723585128784,
-0.12803900241851807,
0.3318317234516144,
0.23659183084964752,
0.5364514589309692,
-0.20027001202106476,
-0.5087050199508667,
-0.2400570660829544,
-0.3304627239704132,
0.7204654812812805,
0.09587597101926804,
-0.36488205194473267,
0.9977104067802429,
0.39298900961875916,
0.04965981841087341,
-0.6918132901191711,
-0.40096724033355713,
0.04986507073044777,
-0.5532879829406738,
-0.3486410081386566,
0.685468852519989,
-0.02592211216688156,
-0.2367253601551056,
-0.08217494189739227,
-0.048803266137838364,
-0.17464779317378998,
0.3379877507686615,
0.43044188618659973,
0.223097562789917,
0.009736418724060059,
0.18098275363445282,
0.02572430670261383,
0.4246636629104614,
-0.02422703616321087,
0.032848160713911057,
0.437039852142334,
-0.12637315690517426,
-0.4612821340560913,
-0.08088155090808868,
0.5211023092269897,
0.5767073631286621,
-0.3258495032787323,
0.48686039447784424,
0.7461367845535278,
-0.3089736998081207,
0.05427929386496544,
-0.8703927993774414,
0.11984249204397202,
-0.4759511649608612,
0.6075923442840576,
-0.43558773398399353,
-1.161678671836853,
0.596544623374939,
0.07654964923858643,
0.07645239681005478,
0.37705013155937195,
0.7520260214805603,
0.1620134860277176,
0.44745999574661255,
0.6800130605697632,
-0.3027307391166687,
0.7123807668685913,
0.4772447347640991,
0.3888898491859436,
-0.5327265858650208,
-0.5192699432373047,
-0.3582087755203247,
-0.2194635272026062,
-0.6192687153816223,
-0.3575480282306671,
0.1493220180273056,
0.1886228621006012,
-0.24617554247379303,
0.37467649579048157,
-0.2081286609172821,
0.6683663725852966,
0.5078607797622681,
0.5378613471984863,
0.3284233510494232,
0.03478451818227768,
-0.3801003098487854,
0.4674374759197235,
-0.45933258533477783,
0.1896776407957077,
1.2898255586624146,
0.11722338199615479,
0.19177719950675964,
0.5133239030838013,
0.595423698425293,
0.44646430015563965,
-0.10043836385011673,
-0.5761660933494568,
0.5322147607803345,
-0.45472389459609985,
-0.7221213579177856,
-0.2600836753845215,
-0.5699317455291748,
-0.7261202931404114,
0.5475653409957886,
-0.8865711688995361,
-0.4920439124107361,
0.43615469336509705,
-0.3017432689666748,
-0.7196733951568604,
-0.008694281801581383,
-0.18419930338859558,
0.44837436079978943,
-0.26749223470687866,
-0.654153048992157,
-0.6279214024543762,
-0.43386706709861755,
0.652223527431488,
-0.4568704068660736,
0.39331740140914917,
-0.523516058921814,
0.30802667140960693,
0.5180917382240295,
-0.46689775586128235,
0.49364539980888367,
-0.19609805941581726,
0.07096324861049652,
0.255607008934021,
-0.14008589088916779,
0.380825936794281,
0.3635905086994171,
-0.0029602160211652517,
-0.028923742473125458,
0.052542876452207565,
-0.19244031608104706,
-0.3574081063270569,
0.5878730416297913,
-0.3823315501213074,
-0.8596389889717102,
-0.47500142455101013,
-0.9049767851829529,
-0.015999572351574898,
0.2519107460975647,
-0.18618561327457428,
0.23066794872283936,
-0.20281551778316498,
0.47583267092704773,
0.4215504229068756,
-0.06489553302526474,
0.47704556584358215,
0.6621876358985901,
0.47173240780830383,
-0.4190615713596344,
0.5701500177383423,
-0.34610337018966675,
-0.27652662992477417,
0.5052749514579773,
0.05147433280944824,
-0.0967184528708458,
-0.4539537727832794,
-0.1440907120704651,
0.0446527935564518,
-0.8077981472015381,
-0.47365906834602356,
-0.5051579475402832,
0.23415528237819672,
-0.31888213753700256,
0.14944149553775787,
0.04271897301077843,
0.0010891449637711048,
-0.10426118224859238,
0.041187211871147156,
0.29275304079055786,
0.19221270084381104,
-0.18719081580638885,
-0.021575361490249634,
-0.5418143272399902,
0.4436165690422058,
0.41410186886787415,
0.45202770829200745,
-0.2920352518558502,
-0.4503399729728699,
-0.20364943146705627,
-0.06355971843004227,
-0.02364395000040531,
-0.6539974212646484,
-0.18111073970794678,
0.38311508297920227,
0.7612112760543823,
0.43355593085289,
0.2587536573410034,
0.7635889649391174,
-0.4081789553165436,
0.38021135330200195,
0.48279455304145813,
-0.7176544666290283,
0.46741241216659546,
-0.10915619879961014,
-0.031512223184108734,
0.9356188178062439,
0.27072253823280334,
0.11415861546993256,
-0.4027523398399353,
-0.04346054419875145,
-0.8051777482032776,
0.7617810368537903,
0.36225625872612,
0.044980548322200775,
0.298745334148407,
0.5855672359466553,
-0.059379734098911285,
0.11259425431489944,
-0.7475738525390625,
0.02817884460091591,
-0.13717234134674072,
-0.37475693225860596,
0.12759236991405487,
0.08143270760774612,
-0.4008541703224182,
-0.4295479357242584,
0.5614123940467834,
-0.23729512095451355,
-0.04955855756998062,
-0.011396738700568676,
-0.14029404520988464,
0.09286965429782867,
0.061044350266456604,
0.5020363926887512,
0.34080806374549866,
-0.16209077835083008,
-0.17815372347831726,
0.28226807713508606,
-0.3925435245037079,
0.33328959345817566,
0.12355534732341766,
-0.07746237516403198,
-0.39082375168800354,
0.7043879628181458,
0.7037896513938904,
-0.3616781532764435,
-0.7562844157218933,
0.6205012202262878,
-0.23721933364868164,
-0.4798821806907654,
-0.25651347637176514,
0.4316917359828949,
-0.30938899517059326,
0.8002843856811523,
0.5500438809394836,
0.08485943078994751,
0.14625687897205353,
-1.04258131980896,
0.5368112921714783,
0.7302793264389038,
-0.5767715573310852,
0.30985045433044434,
0.5345650315284729,
0.3336218595504761,
-0.10542140901088715,
0.412244588136673,
-0.4264443814754486,
-0.6938763856887817,
0.6590229868888855,
0.23158110678195953,
0.7074662446975708,
0.15686598420143127,
-0.07732311636209488,
0.4014914929866791,
0.09066414833068848,
-0.42717111110687256,
0.14627760648727417,
-0.38730692863464355,
-0.8425819277763367,
-0.3185748755931854,
-0.4949726462364197,
0.11425906419754028,
0.006432150956243277,
-0.7927953600883484,
0.4490549862384796,
-0.5104240775108337,
-0.3450491428375244,
-0.2602969706058502,
0.1376618891954422,
-0.9614997506141663,
0.020171692594885826,
0.10895015299320221,
0.5158451795578003,
-0.8981391787528992,
0.7696044445037842,
0.387100487947464,
-0.3890598714351654,
-0.41164422035217285,
-0.07607845962047577,
0.27577686309814453,
-0.5728335380554199,
0.4864084720611572,
0.15352869033813477,
0.18377655744552612,
-0.4884834885597229,
-0.19061578810214996,
-0.610545814037323,
1.1584630012512207,
0.1777874082326889,
-1.0008141994476318,
0.12548348307609558,
0.2581619322299957,
0.3729405105113983,
-0.8060028553009033,
0.02760758064687252,
0.8036870956420898,
0.3361557126045227,
0.5004763603210449,
-0.5533605813980103,
0.600498616695404,
-0.35456550121307373,
-0.32507097721099854,
0.07287021726369858,
-0.3897062838077545,
0.5799652934074402,
-0.3992655277252197,
-0.31430578231811523,
0.03520692512392998,
0.5004700422286987,
0.3003045320510864,
0.33144620060920715,
0.7816095352172852,
0.7370590567588806,
0.7802892923355103,
-0.5057259798049927,
0.5462788939476013,
-0.35472187399864197,
0.36191630363464355,
1.2658061981201172,
-0.6600214242935181,
0.3887922763824463,
0.3854478895664215,
-0.15011321008205414,
0.4034643769264221,
0.6276664733886719,
-0.7176472544670105,
0.8354768753051758,
0.3049302101135254,
-0.11002213507890701,
-0.8755934238433838,
-0.17346453666687012,
-0.1873021125793457,
0.516720712184906,
0.1280003935098648,
-0.256100058555603,
-0.2530757188796997,
0.035339415073394775,
-0.5132196545600891,
0.02828362211585045,
-0.35844993591308594,
0.9106273055076599,
-0.2820364534854889,
-0.2580859363079071,
-0.1748226135969162,
0.08363401144742966,
0.6457526087760925,
-0.24708953499794006,
-0.26779767870903015,
-0.24539391696453094,
-0.0147214625030756,
-0.35895484685897827,
-0.7453163862228394,
0.162618026137352,
-0.31537100672721863,
-0.23002494871616364,
-0.0050604455173015594,
0.7881996035575867,
-0.5241443514823914,
-0.4083108603954315,
0.5906804203987122,
0.18261271715164185,
-0.30181917548179626,
-0.1791991889476776,
-0.7275474071502686,
-0.16398212313652039,
-0.1610557734966278,
0.2090441882610321,
0.5436972379684448,
0.46387580037117004,
0.13046960532665253,
0.36726850271224976,
0.8790631890296936,
0.0011859395308420062,
-0.3695654571056366,
0.43339118361473083,
0.8206976652145386,
-0.4901609420776367,
-0.391724169254303,
-0.8377403020858765,
0.5203320980072021,
-0.2692144811153412,
-0.12357357144355774,
0.2522273063659668,
0.3744466006755829,
0.7306391596794128,
0.3191818296909332,
0.5655198097229004,
-0.19114018976688385,
-0.015659227967262268,
-0.5639197826385498,
0.41130632162094116,
-0.665880024433136,
0.4336130917072296,
-0.41390547156333923,
-0.9300997853279114,
-0.14945001900196075,
0.4041953682899475,
0.3172529935836792,
0.05476156994700432,
0.40395259857177734,
0.9460039734840393,
-0.20867854356765747,
-0.24755465984344482,
0.4911383092403412,
-0.2571362257003784,
0.2367163896560669,
0.9439106583595276,
0.3663219213485718,
-0.4519565999507904,
0.6700908541679382,
-0.051632244139909744,
-0.20141135156154633,
-0.3747163414955139,
-0.9517889022827148,
-1.2410444021224976,
-0.3310758173465729,
-0.5444148778915405,
-0.26827728748321533,
-0.10501589626073837,
0.767311692237854,
0.7635564804077148,
-0.9078851342201233,
0.13018037378787994,
-0.12277615070343018,
0.11803404241800308,
-0.29626014828681946,
-0.20647691190242767,
0.0322137251496315,
-0.13684988021850586,
-0.32317855954170227,
0.3237029016017914,
0.2755400240421295,
-0.10416668653488159,
0.12460576742887497,
0.030040154233574867,
-0.2644134759902954,
0.028231287375092506,
0.6326960325241089,
-0.0846688374876976,
-0.5863556265830994,
-0.25418588519096375,
-0.33108192682266235,
-0.032270338386297226,
-0.0439082570374012,
1.1211625337600708,
-0.5959808826446533,
0.3981197476387024,
0.5078364014625549,
0.880987823009491,
0.7557222247123718,
-0.0191448163241148,
0.7481219172477722,
-0.6206879615783691,
0.21865202486515045,
-0.0030435959342867136,
0.7603772282600403,
-0.04384960979223251,
-0.6037420630455017,
0.46125659346580505,
0.4115864932537079,
-0.052086178213357925,
-0.6379600763320923,
0.4490297734737396,
-0.964874804019928,
-0.5524927973747253,
0.7606592178344727,
-0.2570808529853821,
0.2930505573749542,
-0.32981982827186584,
0.43970248103141785,
0.23619382083415985,
-0.4562952220439911,
0.6311991214752197,
0.8185577392578125,
0.2514597773551941,
-0.34430330991744995,
-0.22570906579494476,
0.316563218832016,
0.31682848930358887,
-0.5533969402313232,
-0.13465583324432373,
0.35591456294059753,
0.33172306418418884,
0.358094722032547,
0.21798765659332275,
-0.16084438562393188,
0.45015206933021545,
-0.09980395436286926,
-0.22123171389102936,
-0.5159152150154114,
-0.20939883589744568,
-0.3632477819919586,
0.5273774862289429,
-0.6027103662490845,
0.272830992937088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11171v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11171v2 | SUGARCREPE++ Dataset: Vision-Language Model Sensitivity to Semantic and Lexical Alterations | 2024-06-17T03:22:20 | 2024-06-19T00:03:42 | Sri Harsha Dumpala, Aman Jaiswal, Chandramouli Sastry, Evangelos Milios, Sageev Oore, Hassan Sajjad | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T45, 68T50, I.2.7; I.2.10 | Despite their remarkable successes, state-of-the-art large language models
(LLMs), including vision-and-language models (VLMs) and unimodal language
models (ULMs), fail to understand precise semantics. For example, semantically
equivalent sentences expressed using different lexical compositions elicit
diverging representations. The degree of this divergence and its impact on
encoded semantics is not very well understood. In this paper, we introduce the
SUGARCREPE++ dataset to analyze the sensitivity of VLMs and ULMs to lexical and
semantic alterations. Each sample in SUGARCREPE++ dataset consists of an image
and a corresponding triplet of captions: a pair of semantically equivalent but
lexically different positive captions and one hard negative caption. This poses
a 3-way semantic (in)equivalence problem to the language models. We
comprehensively evaluate VLMs and ULMs that differ in architecture,
pre-training objectives and datasets to benchmark the performance of
SUGARCREPE++ dataset. Experimental results highlight the difficulties of VLMs
in distinguishing between lexical and semantic variations, particularly in
object attributes and spatial relations. Although VLMs with larger pre-training
datasets, model sizes, and multiple pre-training objectives achieve better
performance on SUGARCREPE++, there is a significant opportunity for
improvement. We show that all the models which achieve better performance on
compositionality datasets need not perform equally well on SUGARCREPE++,
signifying that compositionality alone may not be sufficient for understanding
semantic and lexical alterations. Given the importance of the property that the
SUGARCREPE++ dataset targets, it serves as a new challenge to the
vision-and-language community. | [
-0.2556088864803314,
-0.33395877480506897,
0.46485278010368347,
-0.035776905715465546,
-0.2142808884382248,
0.19261540472507477,
-0.4737640619277954,
-0.6824113130569458,
0.06615202128887177,
0.6033177971839905,
-0.3659723997116089,
-0.4478357434272766,
-0.7840668559074402,
0.18209241330623627,
-0.5172110199928284,
0.957539439201355,
-0.05424663424491882,
0.5654805898666382,
-0.531758725643158,
-0.04915903881192207,
-0.8465688228607178,
-0.6085763573646545,
-0.10091494768857956,
-0.026889676228165627,
0.11285728216171265,
0.29578545689582825,
0.7854856252670288,
0.5369887948036194,
0.7693197131156921,
0.2283749133348465,
-0.14669111371040344,
-0.12375128269195557,
-0.34759992361068726,
-0.04070623219013214,
-0.11708259582519531,
-0.8316764831542969,
-0.2546146512031555,
-0.14065825939178467,
0.4254612922668457,
0.8597905039787292,
0.20203430950641632,
0.130668044090271,
-0.05615350604057312,
0.44801682233810425,
-0.8905499577522278,
0.16955125331878662,
-1.0091341733932495,
-0.010779275558888912,
-0.30328643321990967,
0.13997550308704376,
-0.1461951732635498,
0.14064496755599976,
0.012179167941212654,
-0.47212302684783936,
0.48053789138793945,
-0.14517870545387268,
1.0256421566009521,
0.3411533832550049,
-0.11889152973890305,
-0.26157334446907043,
-0.44079315662384033,
0.8000110387802124,
-0.5473989248275757,
0.5112419724464417,
0.19959768652915955,
0.09876184165477753,
0.0876210629940033,
-0.4949199855327606,
-0.5035682320594788,
-0.4996403455734253,
-0.26963505148887634,
0.3981066048145294,
0.10474804043769836,
-0.20662015676498413,
0.18052051961421967,
0.12273428589105606,
-0.5056354403495789,
0.005889303516596556,
-0.2951539158821106,
-0.24566446244716644,
0.36588963866233826,
0.3947427272796631,
0.13767053186893463,
-0.551923930644989,
-0.559500515460968,
-0.11007056385278702,
-0.576941192150116,
0.024072881788015366,
-0.014131213538348675,
0.4906862676143646,
-0.179155632853508,
0.6138564348220825,
0.11842997372150421,
0.8044358491897583,
-0.4128693640232086,
0.17476649582386017,
0.4782983362674713,
-0.5391947031021118,
-0.34222525358200073,
0.031596507877111435,
0.33923953771591187,
0.4469376802444458,
0.5396287441253662,
-0.04272117465734482,
-0.18276937305927277,
0.6954101324081421,
0.17786729335784912,
-0.5758378505706787,
-0.24053284525871277,
0.14441010355949402,
-0.11232498288154602,
-0.09945408999919891,
0.3098706603050232,
-0.6404006481170654,
-0.4398167133331299,
-0.5474057793617249,
0.4022568166255951,
-0.48494085669517517,
-0.1410328596830368,
0.6554859280586243,
-0.13181141018867493,
0.41658392548561096,
0.43685218691825867,
-0.7574667930603027,
0.6028826236724854,
0.8905073404312134,
0.7761181592941284,
-0.48283880949020386,
-0.49793100357055664,
-0.35215431451797485,
0.08457588404417038,
-0.29028844833374023,
0.8685948252677917,
-0.7731103301048279,
-0.19232675433158875,
-0.24088016152381897,
0.16754461824893951,
-0.4075269401073456,
-0.8105313777923584,
0.5425602793693542,
-0.173899844288826,
0.06629239022731781,
-0.1412317305803299,
-0.7123222351074219,
0.11002641171216965,
0.14571069180965424,
-0.5584841370582581,
0.6399348378181458,
0.3382214903831482,
-0.6614476442337036,
0.7076225876808167,
-0.6550211310386658,
-0.2434871345758438,
0.28636884689331055,
-0.20557156205177307,
-0.35771122574806213,
0.4610823690891266,
0.09198611974716187,
0.4411691427230835,
-0.18047203123569489,
0.17106516659259796,
-0.27130112051963806,
-0.2288517951965332,
0.2608408033847809,
-0.21282579004764557,
0.6198105216026306,
-0.16603700816631317,
-0.1166849359869957,
0.08092892915010452,
-0.7305638194084167,
-0.1378955841064453,
0.26513734459877014,
0.08248086273670197,
-0.6623691916465759,
0.052725259214639664,
0.14383216202259064,
0.11004189401865005,
0.2169407159090042,
-0.5431713461875916,
0.15676966309547424,
-0.3098892867565155,
0.31602227687835693,
0.6529390811920166,
-0.587186336517334,
0.3587667942047119,
0.11473514884710312,
0.28165122866630554,
0.4722242057323456,
0.5144097208976746,
-0.14032432436943054,
-0.3794887959957123,
-0.8498688340187073,
-0.12832194566726685,
0.38941624760627747,
0.5117018222808838,
-0.6389648914337158,
0.1587195247411728,
-0.6649338603019714,
-0.1838553100824356,
-0.532732367515564,
0.10339749604463577,
0.3653119206428528,
0.6002151966094971,
0.362321138381958,
-0.7511086463928223,
-0.3494253158569336,
-0.9657555818557739,
-0.09206531941890717,
-0.027596842497587204,
-0.1283411681652069,
0.25245681405067444,
0.6882364153862,
-0.07322146743535995,
0.8069555759429932,
-0.5867994427680969,
-0.2679581046104431,
-0.12357467412948608,
-0.38849779963493347,
0.11253761500120163,
0.2903057634830475,
0.8724564909934998,
-1.0530450344085693,
-0.34474852681159973,
-0.09937146306037903,
-0.3727201819419861,
-0.16085773706436157,
0.06680663675069809,
-0.021874120458960533,
0.1278132051229477,
0.21221470832824707,
-0.5720168352127075,
0.5949527025222778,
0.6210857629776001,
-0.6778210401535034,
0.7485184669494629,
0.19234566390514374,
0.11842477321624756,
-0.9641835689544678,
-0.014600386843085289,
-0.12085167318582535,
-0.32718709111213684,
-0.7343786954879761,
0.1215735450387001,
0.30734914541244507,
0.04205124080181122,
-0.6986664533615112,
0.42358866333961487,
-0.38209930062294006,
-0.33642053604125977,
-0.24445295333862305,
0.2527414560317993,
0.14331267774105072,
0.35712534189224243,
0.43955957889556885,
0.6705991625785828,
0.9484041333198547,
-0.5613396763801575,
0.5363823175430298,
0.5932945013046265,
-0.40689966082572937,
0.7841761708259583,
-0.5510897636413574,
-0.3162439167499542,
-0.33511748909950256,
-0.08322218805551529,
-0.7721302509307861,
-0.3093002736568451,
0.242123544216156,
-0.5069870948791504,
0.27113887667655945,
-0.09302730113267899,
-0.3434976637363434,
-0.34246793389320374,
-0.549522340297699,
0.32407668232917786,
0.10145160555839539,
-0.29186010360717773,
0.4913877844810486,
0.10053616017103195,
-0.007788548246026039,
-0.36139342188835144,
-0.8865199089050293,
0.44071486592292786,
-0.09948621690273285,
-0.6159085631370544,
0.302345871925354,
-0.22906376421451569,
-0.3155227601528168,
0.16410619020462036,
-0.08963388204574585,
0.07056861370801926,
0.08197037130594254,
0.33932965993881226,
0.3869840204715729,
-0.10185610502958298,
0.20272059738636017,
-0.5621355175971985,
-0.17376980185508728,
-0.10400877147912979,
-0.15067674219608307,
0.7433755993843079,
-0.1963663548231125,
-0.25603216886520386,
-0.18235310912132263,
0.2059227079153061,
0.4001494348049164,
-0.32883119583129883,
0.7262918949127197,
0.3918781280517578,
-0.1995716392993927,
0.18551050126552582,
-0.1619303971529007,
-0.13117028772830963,
-0.3393186032772064,
0.6313163638114929,
-0.4812019169330597,
-0.7331045269966125,
0.5761414170265198,
0.2918262481689453,
-0.19538111984729767,
0.2926326096057892,
0.5531948804855347,
0.05275268107652664,
0.7212738394737244,
0.6697002053260803,
-0.0681958869099617,
0.46771240234375,
-0.188693106174469,
-0.42856353521347046,
-0.9170945882797241,
-0.45021820068359375,
-0.49831917881965637,
-0.13156501948833466,
-0.4075179100036621,
-0.17145873606204987,
0.16307038068771362,
-0.3057081699371338,
-0.14051425457000732,
0.6643179655075073,
-0.25688090920448303,
0.5587071776390076,
0.28820282220840454,
0.11294674128293991,
0.2824336588382721,
-0.00850716419517994,
0.16732929646968842,
-0.1151391938328743,
-0.6429815888404846,
-0.27306661009788513,
0.9162873029708862,
0.0033294891472905874,
0.8121994733810425,
0.061182230710983276,
-0.03540414571762085,
0.2213185727596283,
0.13854503631591797,
-0.8231397867202759,
0.3468254804611206,
-0.6022104620933533,
-0.4478074312210083,
0.1322672963142395,
-0.4885348975658417,
-0.9142343997955322,
0.17995598912239075,
-0.284225732088089,
-0.7551600933074951,
0.3170233964920044,
0.017651477828621864,
-0.07991385459899902,
0.19120089709758759,
-0.9863260388374329,
1.0563884973526,
-0.6457515954971313,
-0.3738521933555603,
0.27454784512519836,
-1.0336169004440308,
0.16744588315486908,
-0.25084784626960754,
0.25687533617019653,
-0.15885818004608154,
-0.36841055750846863,
0.282280296087265,
-0.2896130681037903,
0.7200368642807007,
0.016099417582154274,
-0.12768346071243286,
-0.16111314296722412,
0.2917179763317108,
0.2367299199104309,
-0.06787819415330887,
0.16264274716377258,
0.3628859221935272,
0.10262052714824677,
-0.5608950853347778,
-0.5468983054161072,
0.5744830369949341,
-0.7817860841751099,
-0.3690386414527893,
-0.18372373282909393,
-0.3744719326496124,
-0.3447730541229248,
-0.03423658758401871,
0.3278098404407501,
0.5151700973510742,
0.17913390696048737,
0.11747000366449356,
0.30413609743118286,
-0.13493452966213226,
0.40444883704185486,
0.42223429679870605,
-0.25110840797424316,
-0.31479233503341675,
0.5304833650588989,
-0.2316739559173584,
0.7134785056114197,
0.37775522470474243,
-0.07419353723526001,
-0.24288436770439148,
-0.5587761402130127,
-0.40979915857315063,
0.13502942025661469,
-0.7102963924407959,
-0.36166709661483765,
-0.2831043303012848,
-0.013302076607942581,
-0.2756688892841339,
-0.06031692400574684,
-0.5175791382789612,
-0.2908814549446106,
-0.5158929228782654,
0.08779650926589966,
0.38079318404197693,
0.4943540394306183,
0.13987047970294952,
0.34767940640449524,
-0.7279754281044006,
0.2780292332172394,
-0.11974360048770905,
0.7168168425559998,
-0.327712744474411,
-0.7023153901100159,
-0.20219939947128296,
0.07831141352653503,
0.1701798141002655,
-0.7666396498680115,
0.25138577818870544,
0.46024781465530396,
0.1438417285680771,
0.07443328946828842,
-0.49799853563308716,
0.8550419211387634,
-0.3343237042427063,
0.8881677985191345,
0.08695217221975327,
-1.143478274345398,
0.4765716791152954,
0.04713597893714905,
0.4008684456348419,
0.8010897636413574,
0.19386427104473114,
-0.6081189513206482,
-0.2753671109676361,
-0.44610562920570374,
-0.7451112866401672,
0.6051880717277527,
0.43863701820373535,
0.39696964621543884,
0.21582870185375214,
0.5084301233291626,
0.36845794320106506,
0.29303881525993347,
-0.7446887493133545,
-0.0797988548874855,
-0.46610307693481445,
-0.13779160380363464,
-0.2408905029296875,
-0.04510292410850525,
0.21221332252025604,
-0.3850918412208557,
0.39411115646362305,
-0.07207020372152328,
-0.02917560562491417,
0.060296714305877686,
-0.28657665848731995,
0.16727031767368317,
0.06674250960350037,
0.48949405550956726,
0.5985456705093384,
-0.14697781205177307,
0.4112696349620819,
0.031196873635053635,
-0.8348896503448486,
-0.04421688988804817,
-0.11198551952838898,
-0.1608157753944397,
-0.05166291445493698,
0.6309660077095032,
1.011415958404541,
0.07124317437410355,
-0.9381621479988098,
0.9276134371757507,
-0.33899372816085815,
-0.11671583354473114,
-0.25342270731925964,
0.14233332872390747,
-0.19345375895500183,
-0.14973148703575134,
0.09179529547691345,
0.2501867413520813,
-0.008093416690826416,
-0.602263867855072,
0.2782726287841797,
0.40287837386131287,
-0.5132358074188232,
-0.3862893581390381,
0.6033068895339966,
-0.07194585353136063,
0.05961805582046509,
0.49442869424819946,
0.10802865028381348,
-0.6483546495437622,
0.6700611710548401,
0.31834012269973755,
0.5351839065551758,
-0.09138185530900955,
0.20707395672798157,
0.01731259375810623,
0.37010863423347473,
0.2828705608844757,
0.25619375705718994,
0.037898920476436615,
-1.0040274858474731,
-0.3827452063560486,
-0.832413911819458,
-0.057750292122364044,
0.23527199029922485,
-0.5614550709724426,
0.4614751935005188,
-0.1713673621416092,
-0.07914812862873077,
0.07561099529266357,
-0.24544459581375122,
-0.6921911835670471,
0.2791946828365326,
0.1895345151424408,
0.8101832270622253,
-1.104102373123169,
0.3732912540435791,
0.8979440927505493,
-0.32566219568252563,
-0.4964870512485504,
0.019054193049669266,
-0.20816859602928162,
-0.7572612762451172,
0.48866719007492065,
0.08673656731843948,
0.03836677223443985,
-0.19818566739559174,
-0.8247528672218323,
-0.7508528828620911,
0.7522521615028381,
0.6864789128303528,
-0.5612406134605408,
0.38279861211776733,
0.6879833340644836,
0.5926638841629028,
-0.339701384305954,
0.1900426298379898,
0.6972951889038086,
0.4884927272796631,
0.27466514706611633,
-0.9535238146781921,
-0.1590522974729538,
-0.14087502658367157,
0.08568065613508224,
0.3572174906730652,
-0.6122411489486694,
0.8538810610771179,
-0.1086382269859314,
-0.38327500224113464,
0.16176988184452057,
0.23997420072555542,
-0.056292008608579636,
0.00810055248439312,
0.3964864909648895,
0.5644862055778503,
0.19377271831035614,
-0.2587823271751404,
1.092942476272583,
-0.1533467024564743,
0.4740501642227173,
1.2132242918014526,
-0.4138096868991852,
0.7227175831794739,
0.4978580176830292,
-0.1613941341638565,
0.19629023969173431,
0.6274294257164001,
-0.3550131320953369,
0.3979201018810272,
0.2129443734884262,
-0.14930443465709686,
-0.44745346903800964,
-0.25163450837135315,
-0.1392892301082611,
0.8407095670700073,
0.25755223631858826,
-0.272414892911911,
-0.350043922662735,
0.274563729763031,
0.004067050758749247,
0.19613894820213318,
-0.5188809037208557,
0.7412882447242737,
-0.09919698536396027,
-0.20313826203346252,
0.548489511013031,
-0.24620755016803741,
0.7299985289573669,
-0.6288852095603943,
0.1615951955318451,
-0.25686848163604736,
0.17430701851844788,
-0.41487494111061096,
-0.951717734336853,
0.2821030020713806,
0.11025524884462357,
0.0839611068367958,
0.2545875906944275,
0.6519957780838013,
-0.34800970554351807,
-0.7573808431625366,
0.37526458501815796,
0.40640637278556824,
0.13310721516609192,
-0.13041089475154877,
-0.724285900592804,
0.36214572191238403,
-0.16215357184410095,
-0.03718220815062523,
0.04782089963555336,
0.24035510420799255,
-0.09033741056919098,
0.6135466694831848,
0.34486356377601624,
0.409720778465271,
0.10907894372940063,
0.36506137251853943,
0.8375483155250549,
-0.5580888986587524,
-0.07863472402095795,
-1.0268065929412842,
0.40002238750457764,
-0.005510577466338873,
-0.17442525923252106,
0.59596186876297,
0.8363048434257507,
1.2453902959823608,
-0.37903231382369995,
0.6350630521774292,
-0.18781599402427673,
0.12144655734300613,
-0.7797238230705261,
0.316175639629364,
-0.8266160488128662,
0.20356063544750214,
-0.3741320073604584,
-0.9390161037445068,
-0.7765045166015625,
0.1664050817489624,
-0.18914349377155304,
0.1574002057313919,
0.6721180081367493,
0.8044922351837158,
-0.24994219839572906,
-0.1080407053232193,
0.5117746591567993,
0.3329048454761505,
0.1772221028804779,
0.7928037643432617,
0.8173390626907349,
-0.2809918224811554,
0.3197224736213684,
0.05559771880507469,
-0.1204025000333786,
0.057242538779973984,
-0.8611568212509155,
-0.5489887595176697,
-0.8325514197349548,
-0.21780934929847717,
-0.01328711025416851,
0.21514979004859924,
0.690100371837616,
0.511317253112793,
-0.8232191801071167,
-0.09431054443120956,
-0.27341708540916443,
-0.27918583154678345,
0.05842461436986923,
-0.20318809151649475,
0.42371031641960144,
-0.0906403437256813,
-0.5317411422729492,
-0.14516393840312958,
0.4008702039718628,
0.3341180682182312,
-0.27011632919311523,
0.13427221775054932,
0.10503330826759338,
-0.09297913312911987,
0.7600893378257751,
-0.1271897703409195,
-0.5077754855155945,
-0.4996160566806793,
-0.05325865000486374,
0.08077903836965561,
0.4597051441669464,
0.7082980275154114,
-0.8201276659965515,
0.38172289729118347,
0.2302369326353073,
0.3858742117881775,
0.3918459415435791,
0.04317885637283325,
0.16032707691192627,
-0.7394149303436279,
0.14281636476516724,
0.25651437044143677,
0.4608708322048187,
0.6928626894950867,
-0.13066358864307404,
0.5082384943962097,
0.5446087121963501,
-0.10708404332399368,
-0.46470946073532104,
0.5752949714660645,
-1.0921229124069214,
-0.5244868993759155,
1.1777173280715942,
0.25516077876091003,
-0.5548518896102905,
0.022864017635583878,
-0.31409451365470886,
-0.1171247661113739,
-0.1450570970773697,
0.7056581974029541,
0.6305187344551086,
-0.09958217293024063,
-0.11655579507350922,
-0.5753213167190552,
0.4939020872116089,
0.3451431095600128,
-0.9489028453826904,
0.47100383043289185,
0.7390466928482056,
0.4461915194988251,
0.13393403589725494,
0.12498362362384796,
-0.28841540217399597,
0.12246918678283691,
-0.1316821277141571,
0.07830797880887985,
0.031840674579143524,
-0.5912507772445679,
-0.3683989346027374,
0.03587166965007782,
-0.16182954609394073,
-0.07028572261333466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15480v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15480v1 | On Giant's Shoulders: Effortless Weak to Strong by Dynamic Logits Fusion | 2024-06-17T03:07:41 | 2024-06-17T03:07:41 | Chenghao Fan, Zhenyi Lu, Wei Wei, Jie Tian, Xiaoye Qu, Dangyang Chen, Yu Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Efficient fine-tuning of large language models for task-specific applications
is imperative, yet the vast number of parameters in these models makes their
training increasingly challenging. Despite numerous proposals for effective
methods, a substantial memory overhead remains for gradient computations during
updates. \thm{Can we fine-tune a series of task-specific small models and
transfer their knowledge directly to a much larger model without additional
training?} In this paper, we explore weak-to-strong specialization using logit
arithmetic, facilitating a direct answer to this question. Existing
weak-to-strong methods often employ a static knowledge transfer ratio and a
single small model for transferring complex knowledge, which leads to
suboptimal performance. % To address this, To surmount these limitations, we
propose a dynamic logit fusion approach that works with a series of
task-specific small models, each specialized in a different task. This method
adaptively allocates weights among these models at each decoding step, learning
the weights through Kullback-Leibler divergence constrained optimization
problems. We conduct extensive experiments across various benchmarks in both
single-task and multi-task settings, achieving leading results. By transferring
expertise from the 7B model to the 13B model, our method closes the performance
gap by 96.4\% in single-task scenarios and by 86.3\% in multi-task scenarios
compared to full fine-tuning of the 13B model. Notably, we achieve surpassing
performance on unseen tasks. Moreover, we further demonstrate that our method
can effortlessly integrate in-context learning for single tasks and task
arithmetic for multi-task scenarios. (Our implementation is available in
https://github.com/Facico/Dynamic-Logit-Fusion.) | [
-0.20356328785419464,
-0.7889880537986755,
0.20841039717197418,
0.10175742954015732,
-0.37001147866249084,
0.2631283700466156,
-0.31931522488594055,
-0.612362265586853,
0.1981617957353592,
0.25318044424057007,
-0.5916019678115845,
-0.2743019759654999,
-0.7344316244125366,
-0.06817174702882767,
-0.23699752986431122,
1.0001587867736816,
0.133467435836792,
-0.08152247965335846,
0.07425647974014282,
-0.3986683487892151,
-0.6498088240623474,
-0.11524032801389694,
-0.6069733500480652,
-0.24679124355316162,
0.4662826657295227,
0.36219239234924316,
0.6938889026641846,
0.5749742388725281,
0.7274115085601807,
0.36131879687309265,
-0.288443922996521,
0.2841489315032959,
-0.8175256848335266,
-0.06735288351774216,
-0.3705894649028778,
-0.5121604204177856,
-0.6530988216400146,
-0.5650122761726379,
1.0511506795883179,
0.7782145142555237,
-0.03182744234800339,
0.17661678791046143,
-0.04204852506518364,
0.8107741475105286,
-0.6519309282302856,
-0.00639986852183938,
-0.9535594582557678,
-0.049990925937891006,
-0.1788829118013382,
0.24263839423656464,
-0.2821964919567108,
-0.03501863032579422,
-0.08699259907007217,
-0.40001311898231506,
0.35829806327819824,
-0.08324546366930008,
0.7986735105514526,
0.49693581461906433,
-0.7500535845756531,
0.018538672477006912,
-0.7723966240882874,
0.9757565855979919,
-0.5872292518615723,
0.4597584307193756,
0.10701755434274673,
0.32394784688949585,
0.018425798043608665,
-0.5480947494506836,
-0.41078561544418335,
-0.020150436088442802,
-0.17296287417411804,
-0.024088412523269653,
-0.3338775932788849,
0.16740131378173828,
0.26513683795928955,
0.603420615196228,
-0.6051467061042786,
0.1858692318201065,
-0.5166635513305664,
0.003344167023897171,
0.7813290357589722,
0.364671915769577,
0.19544193148612976,
-0.14202502369880676,
-0.13044457137584686,
-0.35000377893447876,
-0.5664617419242859,
-0.1816377192735672,
0.26473623514175415,
0.3834957778453827,
-0.1682375818490982,
0.4293016493320465,
-0.15242421627044678,
0.8192418217658997,
0.5439255833625793,
-0.2523200213909149,
0.28279802203178406,
-0.5286275148391724,
-0.41305023431777954,
0.0856127068400383,
0.5735949873924255,
-0.14678223431110382,
-0.47198599576950073,
-0.29141268134117126,
-0.4404870271682739,
0.20206044614315033,
0.24006906151771545,
-0.7381055355072021,
-0.464471697807312,
0.04883604124188423,
-0.23895053565502167,
-0.2793675661087036,
-0.29979148507118225,
-0.6510627865791321,
-0.49252384901046753,
-0.16672609746456146,
0.7891514897346497,
-0.3452461063861847,
-0.409456342458725,
0.21242429316043854,
-0.012625344097614288,
-0.05155639722943306,
0.18523263931274414,
-1.1046788692474365,
0.41254734992980957,
0.5777632594108582,
0.6367925405502319,
-0.10786799341440201,
-0.15928825736045837,
-0.7270277142524719,
0.17797178030014038,
-0.23261508345603943,
0.43780890107154846,
-0.259160578250885,
-0.27874642610549927,
-0.3332073986530304,
-0.036228716373443604,
-0.4044623076915741,
-0.6735619902610779,
0.4522475302219391,
-0.42759859561920166,
-0.30014148354530334,
-0.07868950814008713,
-0.5262001752853394,
-0.28817352652549744,
0.19162748754024506,
-0.900921642780304,
0.7909837365150452,
0.233126699924469,
-0.6034923195838928,
0.16336433589458466,
-0.5410426259040833,
-0.6651788949966431,
0.14863744378089905,
-0.12001333385705948,
-0.3253534138202667,
0.38659363985061646,
0.0018216201569885015,
0.5482327938079834,
-0.4850784242153168,
0.15551383793354034,
-0.2589258551597595,
-0.3397182524204254,
-0.17982614040374756,
-0.18891742825508118,
0.8326862454414368,
-0.004878527484834194,
-0.6158803701400757,
0.1867801398038864,
-0.7173920273780823,
-0.10189253091812134,
0.0907483771443367,
-0.30633166432380676,
-0.21463483572006226,
-0.2302209734916687,
-0.313497930765152,
-0.04804560914635658,
0.302716463804245,
-0.26507368683815,
0.4014795124530792,
-0.5551685094833374,
0.1590391844511032,
0.7535682916641235,
-0.1360301673412323,
0.7204488515853882,
-0.15558576583862305,
0.26557809114456177,
-0.06038372218608856,
-0.05978773534297943,
0.04920310527086258,
-0.17134732007980347,
-0.8358219861984253,
-0.4804535210132599,
0.38217177987098694,
0.6019118428230286,
-0.6972105503082275,
0.5383708477020264,
-0.5296205878257751,
-0.7909994125366211,
-0.446755588054657,
0.7296364903450012,
0.42221182584762573,
0.347310334444046,
0.29705071449279785,
-0.42999258637428284,
-0.348378449678421,
-1.100883960723877,
-0.24877649545669556,
-0.21757209300994873,
-0.037282541394233704,
0.2514787018299103,
0.2562864124774933,
-0.19469106197357178,
0.31928780674934387,
-0.5524464845657349,
-0.41758593916893005,
-0.40766796469688416,
0.2663640081882477,
0.5383460521697998,
0.7976029515266418,
0.4546860456466675,
-0.9936786890029907,
-0.5769693851470947,
0.21580874919891357,
-0.7784163355827332,
0.2460915744304657,
-0.21546244621276855,
-0.35642585158348083,
0.027246056124567986,
0.24017596244812012,
-1.0956145524978638,
0.015251200646162033,
0.7521678805351257,
-0.6483864188194275,
0.42834439873695374,
-0.033457983285188675,
0.06486765295267105,
-0.9225714206695557,
0.4316437840461731,
-0.08583958446979523,
-0.11193402111530304,
-0.8540713787078857,
0.38882976770401,
0.18650992214679718,
-0.21129029989242554,
-0.3552713692188263,
0.658732533454895,
-0.4591478407382965,
0.37217846512794495,
-0.12447012215852737,
-0.24369363486766815,
-0.23621276021003723,
0.6431031227111816,
-0.29808491468429565,
0.3222942054271698,
0.72126305103302,
-0.6121283173561096,
0.6756429672241211,
0.13451537489891052,
-0.4938453435897827,
0.45938289165496826,
-0.520250678062439,
0.10767663270235062,
0.010358433239161968,
0.1917516589164734,
-0.8709699511528015,
-0.27105584740638733,
0.16879886388778687,
-0.11302152276039124,
0.581584095954895,
-0.19611386954784393,
-0.6298331618309021,
-0.23734113574028015,
-0.11994782835245132,
0.8438672423362732,
0.8644033074378967,
-0.43572890758514404,
1.0247875452041626,
0.3870210647583008,
-0.07615836709737778,
-0.4981575608253479,
-0.5274666547775269,
-0.028767062351107597,
-0.2864314913749695,
-0.8771884441375732,
0.5221564769744873,
-0.16651873290538788,
-0.3358508050441742,
0.07233531028032303,
-0.3500021696090698,
-0.10282406210899353,
0.04091273993253708,
0.1399199664592743,
0.29096657037734985,
-0.2402350902557373,
0.15935978293418884,
0.24525055289268494,
-0.013731161132454872,
-0.33332300186157227,
-0.26675131916999817,
0.2080860286951065,
-0.29520633816719055,
-0.2945787310600281,
-0.22283673286437988,
0.11424058675765991,
0.742452085018158,
-0.2060297280550003,
0.7216065526008606,
0.9526687264442444,
-0.48715683817863464,
-0.06533206254243851,
-0.6768305897712708,
-0.385581910610199,
-0.538516104221344,
0.545612633228302,
-0.4796237349510193,
-0.9691881537437439,
0.41808438301086426,
-0.03778301551938057,
0.29782700538635254,
0.5883244872093201,
0.6064592003822327,
0.23722338676452637,
1.221498966217041,
0.8306148648262024,
-0.20634318888187408,
0.46831750869750977,
-0.24719467759132385,
0.4350549876689911,
-0.4619678258895874,
-0.059469934552907944,
-0.18724477291107178,
-0.7046873569488525,
-0.41511356830596924,
-0.4396032989025116,
0.600849449634552,
0.16642315685749054,
-0.1628725379705429,
0.4523696005344391,
-0.4312394857406616,
0.5334530472755432,
0.36443454027175903,
0.3723755180835724,
0.07044419646263123,
-0.0005167355411686003,
0.2094637006521225,
0.19640971720218658,
-1.0362234115600586,
0.23987223207950592,
0.7944502830505371,
0.27173787355422974,
0.8634849786758423,
0.3960254192352295,
0.46776050329208374,
0.20955640077590942,
-0.03366956487298012,
-0.736038088798523,
0.8335152268409729,
-0.5160014629364014,
-0.7033515572547913,
-0.5148463845252991,
-0.6934502124786377,
-0.8799983263015747,
0.2639389634132385,
-0.494393914937973,
-0.6765806674957275,
0.2459704875946045,
0.5392788052558899,
-0.4024893045425415,
0.62230384349823,
-0.9073907136917114,
0.9875457286834717,
-0.139086052775383,
-0.6815586090087891,
-0.816170871257782,
-0.656903862953186,
0.6382867097854614,
-0.3121143579483032,
-0.04023141786456108,
-0.2118581384420395,
0.2049117237329483,
0.7496045231819153,
-0.11839038878679276,
0.9802441000938416,
-0.12526001036167145,
-0.10456400364637375,
0.21145357191562653,
0.3579595685005188,
0.8250983357429504,
-0.03920251131057739,
-0.1219937652349472,
0.05562414973974228,
-0.24754883348941803,
-0.8020258545875549,
-0.6998133659362793,
0.8561432361602783,
-0.5842179656028748,
-0.6042355895042419,
-0.06972786784172058,
-0.7411466240882874,
-0.2875823676586151,
0.32213979959487915,
-0.10253739356994629,
0.405412882566452,
-0.032065249979496,
0.38382449746131897,
0.8771458864212036,
0.10545401275157928,
0.25198668241500854,
0.2191089242696762,
0.3537140190601349,
-0.2902540862560272,
1.1538622379302979,
-0.040253929793834686,
0.268794983625412,
0.6247295141220093,
0.20444625616073608,
-0.11640293896198273,
-0.37111008167266846,
-0.6633387804031372,
0.46465376019477844,
-0.754040539264679,
-0.3992410898208618,
-0.5120956301689148,
0.02193860523402691,
-0.20672830939292908,
-0.3152039051055908,
-0.5846758484840393,
-0.5003725290298462,
0.10151508450508118,
0.08226674795150757,
0.1545470952987671,
0.3722124993801117,
-0.036830998957157135,
0.15764212608337402,
-0.9743017554283142,
0.31693708896636963,
0.6496854424476624,
0.17629720270633698,
0.27784907817840576,
-0.5049276351928711,
-0.5928794145584106,
-0.09483054280281067,
-0.2663698196411133,
-0.649091362953186,
0.13972243666648865,
0.3125343918800354,
0.4533810019493103,
0.3512541651725769,
0.09088527411222458,
0.7031382322311401,
-0.27529510855674744,
0.6790755987167358,
0.5586198568344116,
-0.9857650399208069,
0.2479165643453598,
-0.3428408205509186,
0.7556062340736389,
0.6296249032020569,
0.32640182971954346,
-0.06569439172744751,
-0.3544948995113373,
-0.7768850922584534,
-0.9607784748077393,
0.5840023159980774,
0.16763585805892944,
0.1668117493391037,
0.4863385260105133,
0.10105671733617783,
0.09394745528697968,
0.21581591665744781,
-0.4313567280769348,
-0.00977993756532669,
0.11065460741519928,
-0.4084738492965698,
-0.22732967138290405,
-0.18092599511146545,
-0.37963077425956726,
-0.572604238986969,
0.7795515060424805,
-0.1276020109653473,
0.36972740292549133,
-0.3759758174419403,
-0.2800822854042053,
-0.31722646951675415,
-0.012241281569004059,
0.4986601173877716,
0.840377926826477,
-0.18100939691066742,
0.427109956741333,
0.7551722526550293,
-0.4646490216255188,
0.09092988818883896,
0.2192009687423706,
0.11818516254425049,
0.03932802379131317,
0.36206570267677307,
1.16355562210083,
0.5223655700683594,
-0.7840165495872498,
0.35728761553764343,
0.1656714826822281,
-0.2878120243549347,
0.07875426113605499,
0.2905372679233551,
-0.007971876300871372,
0.4054009020328522,
0.4056800305843353,
0.20664729177951813,
-0.1439233422279358,
-0.4488688111305237,
0.03353993967175484,
0.4127863347530365,
-0.21022221446037292,
-0.6236838102340698,
0.4429558515548706,
0.3611666262149811,
-0.09465038031339645,
0.6170070171356201,
-0.15156559646129608,
-0.3464333713054657,
0.48488104343414307,
0.451791912317276,
0.8108997344970703,
-0.42874643206596375,
-0.1271084100008011,
0.5287082195281982,
0.19934827089309692,
-0.18389931321144104,
-0.02132474258542061,
-0.028420906513929367,
-0.5675297379493713,
-0.582683801651001,
-0.6912772059440613,
-0.13279050588607788,
0.15806731581687927,
-0.3975103497505188,
0.44188693165779114,
-0.47968268394470215,
0.01780896820127964,
0.164517343044281,
0.11448047310113907,
-0.7617528438568115,
0.27006617188453674,
-0.05585716664791107,
0.7331801652908325,
-0.863339900970459,
0.7234883904457092,
0.8962602019309998,
-0.10208204388618469,
-0.7427465319633484,
-0.21686367690563202,
0.03154606744647026,
-0.6893148422241211,
0.5441743731498718,
-0.11553754657506943,
-0.06677306443452835,
0.18220609426498413,
-0.2960861027240753,
-0.7444401383399963,
1.019921898841858,
0.521392285823822,
-0.6015890836715698,
-0.2661520838737488,
-0.27657458186149597,
0.35266005992889404,
0.015179027803242207,
-0.09455136954784393,
0.4327472746372223,
0.5014052987098694,
0.04481692612171173,
-1.1832661628723145,
0.3688232898712158,
-0.31593814492225647,
-0.3157975971698761,
0.6964256167411804,
-0.9068686962127686,
0.7680301666259766,
-0.0791148915886879,
-0.1474682241678238,
-0.12257269024848938,
0.5949800610542297,
-0.022543465718626976,
0.04467475786805153,
0.8697789311408997,
0.5950978398323059,
0.7358723282814026,
0.21279045939445496,
0.7543090581893921,
-0.5200359225273132,
0.2618872821331024,
0.527772843837738,
0.09504123032093048,
0.6856572031974792,
0.43107208609580994,
-0.051664333790540695,
0.3914899528026581,
0.29667001962661743,
-0.16172629594802856,
0.5160133242607117,
-0.04604817181825638,
-0.737650454044342,
-0.5118371844291687,
0.05644550174474716,
-0.14198808372020721,
0.3420921862125397,
0.32185348868370056,
-0.07087884843349457,
-0.2062959372997284,
-0.05572812631726265,
-0.16937291622161865,
-0.22862951457500458,
-0.4595232903957367,
0.7694848775863647,
0.16050535440444946,
-0.6212111115455627,
1.0552886724472046,
0.12181733548641205,
0.6701036691665649,
-1.0104036331176758,
0.08407271653413773,
-0.07676246017217636,
0.4798983931541443,
-0.25021669268608093,
-0.3742470145225525,
0.3957872688770294,
-0.2169879525899887,
-0.2536925971508026,
0.019772514700889587,
1.1054623126983643,
-0.5664584636688232,
-0.6074844002723694,
-0.07678823173046112,
0.49502235651016235,
-0.017166631296277046,
0.0644034594297409,
-0.6334990859031677,
0.3128880560398102,
0.1264415681362152,
-0.0659201443195343,
0.6427476406097412,
0.2337946742773056,
0.0713556706905365,
0.5633525252342224,
0.44364476203918457,
0.0020046541467309,
-0.07528606802225113,
-0.38950273394584656,
0.9508901834487915,
-0.5526792407035828,
-0.5824769139289856,
-0.8839300870895386,
0.6670867800712585,
0.10261914879083633,
-0.10871116071939468,
0.5954649448394775,
0.4436897933483124,
0.7081800103187561,
-0.25552257895469666,
0.6186626553535461,
-0.32694345712661743,
0.1736239492893219,
-0.48726561665534973,
0.6383217573165894,
-0.8531452417373657,
-0.01074122078716755,
-0.1999058872461319,
-1.0100537538528442,
-0.40745675563812256,
0.40007027983665466,
-0.1510583460330963,
-0.18070927262306213,
0.7365382313728333,
0.7725926041603088,
-0.504869818687439,
-0.30247336626052856,
0.3770942986011505,
0.2885848581790924,
0.08860194683074951,
0.9173261523246765,
0.1708933711051941,
-0.3657025396823883,
0.7455262541770935,
-0.141339510679245,
-0.39734482765197754,
-0.41327419877052307,
-0.7694361805915833,
-0.8594911694526672,
-0.49673911929130554,
-0.3194981515407562,
-0.3959246575832367,
0.27542608976364136,
0.8097613453865051,
0.8304234743118286,
-0.5213990211486816,
-0.4979417324066162,
-0.03761176019906998,
0.1530156284570694,
-0.6896518468856812,
-0.11589890718460083,
0.531933605670929,
-0.23173923790454865,
-0.8202134966850281,
0.5105921626091003,
0.05636511370539665,
0.01778501830995083,
-0.1579636037349701,
-0.19670520722866058,
-0.04836989566683769,
-0.016745740547776222,
0.7375608682632446,
0.5304949283599854,
-0.3331836462020874,
-0.017759082838892937,
-0.14205335080623627,
0.07755900174379349,
-0.1989080160856247,
0.7523090839385986,
-0.6845757961273193,
0.37798547744750977,
0.6711452603340149,
1.0277609825134277,
0.7219418287277222,
-0.07360795140266418,
0.5369787812232971,
-0.6793530583381653,
0.2876957058906555,
0.26595139503479004,
0.07120943814516068,
0.24401114881038666,
-0.39730602502822876,
0.45571327209472656,
0.5028221607208252,
-0.36635056138038635,
-1.1498311758041382,
0.29137521982192993,
-1.1277260780334473,
-0.21881170570850372,
1.134412169456482,
0.09213736653327942,
-0.2474094033241272,
0.21193179488182068,
0.02501913346350193,
0.055333010852336884,
-0.1499447375535965,
0.8981136679649353,
0.5025004744529724,
-0.1557125747203827,
-0.12222336232662201,
-0.20804399251937866,
0.5345309376716614,
0.9361913204193115,
-0.3670366406440735,
0.09357940405607224,
0.2966999113559723,
0.060660406947135925,
0.14062939584255219,
0.48134973645210266,
0.19466744363307953,
0.34965452551841736,
0.38197433948516846,
-0.08373122662305832,
-0.019554419443011284,
-0.3239985704421997,
-0.18245673179626465,
0.270182341337204,
0.21659433841705322,
0.06096486374735832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11162v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11162v2 | How Good are LLMs at Relation Extraction under Low-Resource Scenario? Comprehensive Evaluation | 2024-06-17T03:02:04 | 2024-06-26T01:43:15 | Dawulie Jinensibieke, Mieradilijiang Maimaiti, Wentao Xiao, Yuanhang Zheng, Xiaobo Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Relation Extraction (RE) serves as a crucial technology for transforming
unstructured text into structured information, especially within the framework
of Knowledge Graph development. Its importance is emphasized by its essential
role in various downstream tasks. Besides the conventional RE methods which are
based on neural networks and pre-trained language models, large language models
(LLMs) are also utilized in the research field of RE. However, on low-resource
languages (LRLs), both conventional RE methods and LLM-based methods perform
poorly on RE due to the data scarcity issues. To this end, this paper
constructs low-resource relation extraction datasets in 10 LRLs in three
regions (Central Asia, Southeast Asia and Middle East). The corpora are
constructed by translating the original publicly available English RE datasets
(NYT10, FewRel and CrossRE) using an effective multilingual machine
translation. Then, we use the language perplexity (PPL) to filter out the
low-quality data from the translated datasets. Finally, we conduct an empirical
study and validate the performance of several open-source LLMs on these
generated LRL RE datasets. | [
-0.4110281467437744,
-0.50269615650177,
0.5453349351882935,
-0.010257975198328495,
-0.5316414833068848,
0.08445174992084503,
-0.5250023007392883,
-0.6017599701881409,
-0.029043348506093025,
0.47349998354911804,
-0.5801275372505188,
-0.5222002863883972,
-0.4822668135166168,
0.5566548109054565,
-0.11737728118896484,
0.8670271039009094,
-0.13436177372932434,
-0.1906009167432785,
-0.12046410143375397,
-0.4084721803665161,
-0.15210473537445068,
-0.6120385527610779,
-0.30035945773124695,
-0.39426982402801514,
0.5252634286880493,
0.6481674313545227,
0.766927182674408,
0.6395559906959534,
0.6624479293823242,
0.2710130512714386,
-0.17329451441764832,
0.4252556264400482,
-0.6564711332321167,
0.21231107413768768,
-0.18235743045806885,
-0.36888691782951355,
-0.3917028307914734,
0.05749233067035675,
0.5203395485877991,
0.7195771336555481,
0.1043587401509285,
0.47696438431739807,
0.0508744902908802,
0.6116378903388977,
-0.6651943325996399,
0.17024466395378113,
-0.648043692111969,
0.1624460220336914,
-0.39294350147247314,
0.01959223486483097,
-0.19684170186519623,
-0.3037062883377075,
0.4033060371875763,
-0.519189178943634,
0.06144456937909126,
0.21252188086509705,
1.1891263723373413,
0.1309492141008377,
-0.23523057997226715,
-0.20786258578300476,
-0.8668698072433472,
1.0237687826156616,
-0.7123055458068848,
0.5621485710144043,
0.46786782145500183,
0.41133445501327515,
-0.23851259052753448,
-0.7868111729621887,
-0.35457220673561096,
0.07395309209823608,
-0.42766839265823364,
0.0010934359161183238,
-0.20888438820838928,
-0.3792210519313812,
0.2268085479736328,
0.5806751251220703,
-0.12989541888237,
0.2538806200027466,
-0.20606449246406555,
-0.058524735271930695,
0.35819247364997864,
0.2681131362915039,
0.095908522605896,
-0.8083373308181763,
-0.4257243871688843,
0.13636431097984314,
-0.9947051405906677,
-0.017428193241357803,
0.2662966251373291,
0.5519753098487854,
-0.2393759787082672,
0.6038432717323303,
-0.09426849335432053,
0.49629953503608704,
-0.16939198970794678,
-0.5709574222564697,
0.0908307135105133,
-0.7706653475761414,
-0.21754328906536102,
-0.36667218804359436,
1.0746062994003296,
-0.10083530098199844,
0.48115378618240356,
-0.47800761461257935,
-0.3142992854118347,
-0.3095557987689972,
-0.27909281849861145,
-0.7080084085464478,
-0.0763571634888649,
-0.01964961178600788,
-0.7973212003707886,
-0.08257744461297989,
-0.24592341482639313,
-0.8783508539199829,
-0.27367326617240906,
-0.30277734994888306,
-0.3262733519077301,
-0.5689637064933777,
-0.4985107183456421,
-0.3359416127204895,
0.2894359529018402,
0.30363020300865173,
0.21890825033187866,
-0.42197200655937195,
0.24865807592868805,
0.44959771633148193,
0.7421859502792358,
-0.33760693669319153,
0.028929244726896286,
-0.5000799298286438,
0.017735056579113007,
-0.06976247578859329,
0.6996057033538818,
-0.35817793011665344,
-0.34501931071281433,
-0.062265343964099884,
0.13444697856903076,
0.08288559317588806,
-0.908536434173584,
0.6602981090545654,
-0.8745812177658081,
0.10259764641523361,
-0.24925756454467773,
-0.23610946536064148,
0.12462635338306427,
0.26853352785110474,
-0.8737086057662964,
0.6248785257339478,
0.16558325290679932,
-0.798057496547699,
0.15465044975280762,
-0.22374452650547028,
-0.3325755000114441,
0.0384821817278862,
-0.32937076687812805,
-0.3128030002117157,
-0.0921163558959961,
0.36782896518707275,
0.36875325441360474,
-0.8978886008262634,
0.06335301697254181,
-0.3730536997318268,
-0.0945015698671341,
0.39404454827308655,
-0.4480019509792328,
0.6972346901893616,
0.6695342659950256,
0.14442671835422516,
-0.1629982888698578,
-0.7160078287124634,
-0.001962871989235282,
0.20885080099105835,
-0.4240051209926605,
-0.6232192516326904,
-0.09757749736309052,
-0.008914748206734657,
0.5234623551368713,
0.2691097855567932,
-0.4834350645542145,
-0.10398649424314499,
-0.5086494088172913,
0.41246116161346436,
0.4765961766242981,
0.29593873023986816,
0.4940100908279419,
-0.03685968369245529,
0.7458661794662476,
0.21346567571163177,
-0.1574573963880539,
0.12073055654764175,
-0.09266020357608795,
-0.6147439479827881,
-0.396147221326828,
0.5944268703460693,
0.5298150181770325,
-1.0893858671188354,
0.19079381227493286,
-0.5887234210968018,
-0.36558961868286133,
-0.7255150079727173,
0.5465384125709534,
0.5709721446037292,
0.5751419067382812,
0.19160950183868408,
0.06820273399353027,
-0.5044182538986206,
-0.9607314467430115,
-0.08247794955968857,
0.06782930344343185,
-0.011396930553019047,
0.4027770757675171,
0.18297183513641357,
-0.09555253386497498,
1.1098254919052124,
-0.4794895648956299,
-0.2906501889228821,
-0.45249032974243164,
-0.29133495688438416,
0.49002373218536377,
-0.026403989642858505,
0.38388171792030334,
-0.8811768293380737,
-0.38578227162361145,
0.11121166497468948,
-1.0794003009796143,
0.0027141680475324392,
0.23742346465587616,
-0.1740148514509201,
0.36716362833976746,
0.25628796219825745,
-0.5935194492340088,
0.29593369364738464,
0.4507998526096344,
0.09372147172689438,
0.4434927701950073,
0.09739255905151367,
-0.024379024282097816,
-1.1339575052261353,
0.3647462725639343,
0.16801802814006805,
-0.30706626176834106,
-0.3293546140193939,
-0.05284910276532173,
-0.08283523470163345,
-0.2817896008491516,
-0.5854727625846863,
0.3767162263393402,
-0.8440224528312683,
-0.298009991645813,
0.10938076674938202,
0.6624354720115662,
-0.15571273863315582,
0.3761831820011139,
0.029438666999340057,
0.717280924320221,
-0.071919746696949,
-0.47008997201919556,
0.37542301416397095,
0.3828451931476593,
-0.47279003262519836,
0.30183979868888855,
-0.346411794424057,
0.09488610178232193,
0.15238964557647705,
-0.15912491083145142,
-0.6089556217193604,
-0.02521749958395958,
0.36392736434936523,
-0.21336141228675842,
0.25937947630882263,
-0.27340033650398254,
-0.6914129853248596,
-0.0848744809627533,
-0.17849543690681458,
0.33553847670555115,
0.3809056580066681,
-0.3896122872829437,
0.33916643261909485,
0.4823988974094391,
-0.268857479095459,
-0.773094117641449,
-0.5099722743034363,
0.023387586697936058,
-0.4138297736644745,
-0.4615577459335327,
0.07731225341558456,
0.3574651777744293,
-0.5169448852539062,
0.5058199167251587,
-0.21569207310676575,
-0.18845556676387787,
0.0015396494418382645,
0.1432938426733017,
0.3246647119522095,
-0.2840888202190399,
0.11156162619590759,
-0.4010426700115204,
-0.11487118899822235,
-0.026357455179095268,
0.3554712235927582,
0.4146259129047394,
0.015438544563949108,
-0.10337657481431961,
-0.26952287554740906,
0.09154152870178223,
0.553490936756134,
-0.22220279276371002,
0.7193534970283508,
0.3367493152618408,
-0.4372021555900574,
0.02523042820394039,
-0.4075218737125397,
-0.06457547843456268,
-0.38383471965789795,
0.5520228147506714,
-0.6869326233863831,
-0.680814802646637,
0.6944438815116882,
-0.4672276973724365,
-0.1384287029504776,
0.4212287664413452,
0.19251130521297455,
0.14349660277366638,
0.18062973022460938,
0.5779587030410767,
-0.5316506028175354,
0.2527647018432617,
-0.33452972769737244,
0.3853873610496521,
-0.9540237188339233,
-0.11880621314048767,
-0.563984215259552,
-0.0410463847219944,
-0.82672518491745,
-0.09981593489646912,
0.2184729427099228,
0.37275630235671997,
-0.023127056658267975,
0.4699671268463135,
-0.026234233751893044,
0.23773293197155,
0.16018109023571014,
0.09019991010427475,
0.7278468608856201,
0.39769089221954346,
0.11228450387716293,
-0.48499205708503723,
-0.7899287939071655,
-0.7429829239845276,
1.0133140087127686,
0.3881770372390747,
0.6595675349235535,
0.24960748851299286,
0.7466236352920532,
0.022186383605003357,
0.5645740032196045,
-0.814981997013092,
0.49646419286727905,
-0.44417551159858704,
-0.2781964838504791,
-0.4834286570549011,
-0.7577998042106628,
-1.1106034517288208,
0.22199119627475739,
-0.4201480746269226,
-0.4736657738685608,
0.21418604254722595,
-0.24229954183101654,
-0.21510635316371918,
0.40124619007110596,
-0.4446665942668915,
0.5307783484458923,
-0.22719459235668182,
-0.5447618365287781,
-0.1293216198682785,
-0.5694200396537781,
0.6977296471595764,
-0.24536703526973724,
0.46241968870162964,
-0.13881027698516846,
-0.11856874078512192,
0.6875607371330261,
-0.4594883322715759,
0.4652078151702881,
-0.021795742213726044,
-0.12476974725723267,
0.3899473547935486,
0.096202053129673,
0.4473358392715454,
0.060417503118515015,
-0.38089147210121155,
0.2993004322052002,
-0.24406565725803375,
-0.16342447698116302,
-0.40957191586494446,
0.7879508137702942,
-0.8973774909973145,
-0.4788883626461029,
-0.23232874274253845,
-0.4410175085067749,
-0.318254292011261,
0.3298490345478058,
0.28002163767814636,
0.2130298614501953,
-0.1457454115152359,
0.16424119472503662,
0.2683718502521515,
-0.46766963601112366,
0.4372117221355438,
0.4141172766685486,
-0.15154093503952026,
-0.7159007787704468,
0.8249431848526001,
0.2541923224925995,
0.25371018052101135,
0.2086932361125946,
-0.08712282031774521,
-0.15407703816890717,
-0.2484167069196701,
-0.38240858912467957,
0.5141444802284241,
-0.5935530066490173,
-0.5617144107818604,
-0.40971407294273376,
-0.39943060278892517,
-0.2711604833602905,
0.3132316470146179,
-0.4028858244419098,
-0.19701530039310455,
-0.2527632713317871,
0.14188005030155182,
0.20976439118385315,
0.5428957343101501,
0.12401359528303146,
0.04767948016524315,
-1.084739327430725,
0.3798975348472595,
-0.03481712192296982,
-0.026044156402349472,
0.12893237173557281,
-0.4756794273853302,
-0.3620864152908325,
-0.279838889837265,
-0.20443840324878693,
-0.789618968963623,
0.5623289346694946,
-0.1224304735660553,
0.46327322721481323,
0.31615447998046875,
0.29997801780700684,
0.9078903198242188,
-0.30787721276283264,
0.4256000518798828,
0.09058799594640732,
-0.5566592216491699,
0.303872674703598,
-0.17117349803447723,
0.06253917515277863,
0.5621841549873352,
0.578855574131012,
-0.37874728441238403,
-0.08123768866062164,
-0.6164900660514832,
-1.0548440217971802,
0.7938942909240723,
0.24198676645755768,
-0.22608353197574615,
0.21398939192295074,
0.6298549771308899,
0.006553629878908396,
0.288793683052063,
-0.5979016423225403,
-0.44717690348625183,
0.3036501109600067,
-0.023288661614060402,
0.04071136191487312,
-0.5526688098907471,
0.10974288731813431,
0.15147939324378967,
0.4115903079509735,
0.4042763113975525,
0.053349677473306656,
0.24450942873954773,
-0.15175211429595947,
-0.36248645186424255,
0.45381495356559753,
0.1914825737476349,
0.7142583727836609,
-0.3671504557132721,
0.1680627465248108,
0.16463090479373932,
-0.23946794867515564,
0.1779240369796753,
0.2217617928981781,
-0.03585783392190933,
0.002206983743235469,
0.7091051936149597,
0.28238919377326965,
0.2189374715089798,
-0.440828800201416,
0.3143036365509033,
-0.08192825317382812,
0.23457114398479462,
-0.39139217138290405,
-0.28782448172569275,
0.29267022013664246,
0.15528647601604462,
0.23602630198001862,
-0.2888828217983246,
-0.18411311507225037,
-0.4539426267147064,
0.08160598576068878,
0.2748448848724365,
-0.0034789920318871737,
-0.3126716613769531,
0.23986338078975677,
0.31680867075920105,
-0.210157111287117,
1.0559589862823486,
-0.22130267322063446,
-0.3423725366592407,
0.2785927355289459,
0.43033459782600403,
0.48703426122665405,
0.12752747535705566,
-0.14015190303325653,
0.42013612389564514,
0.41078755259513855,
0.1958838552236557,
-0.1279296875,
-0.09435688704252243,
-0.8724132776260376,
-0.7530022263526917,
-0.6626524329185486,
-0.4777323603630066,
0.571866512298584,
-0.6595425605773926,
0.2555696368217468,
-0.19325196743011475,
-0.2054382711648941,
-0.35594505071640015,
0.4436432123184204,
-0.8374688625335693,
-0.1064959317445755,
-0.23535855114459991,
0.735869288444519,
-0.7230408787727356,
0.9220661520957947,
0.7770374417304993,
-0.5367761850357056,
-0.8469659686088562,
0.0292535237967968,
-0.1386568546295166,
-0.7122604250907898,
1.1496576070785522,
-0.3238317370414734,
-0.23625294864177704,
-0.2398800551891327,
-0.37057632207870483,
-0.8197286128997803,
1.0849311351776123,
0.5521610379219055,
-0.7431358695030212,
0.06926921755075455,
0.23883017897605896,
0.5079103112220764,
-0.28324195742607117,
-0.11136598140001297,
0.5553188920021057,
0.3872319161891937,
-0.13880030810832977,
-0.768294632434845,
0.317179799079895,
-0.06953718513250351,
-0.05671709403395653,
0.17869743704795837,
-0.6046631932258606,
0.8041595816612244,
-0.061258964240550995,
-0.6350218057632446,
0.1430816799402237,
0.7000163197517395,
0.5222911834716797,
0.30027228593826294,
0.4850535988807678,
0.4513765573501587,
0.5929206609725952,
0.15396438539028168,
0.9199896454811096,
-0.3888097107410431,
0.21397319436073303,
1.1901671886444092,
-0.5483492016792297,
0.8434667587280273,
0.69794762134552,
-0.38155025243759155,
0.4214463233947754,
0.6053352355957031,
0.23310700058937073,
0.5249505639076233,
0.08693324774503708,
-0.060635074973106384,
-0.34032973647117615,
-0.27664148807525635,
-0.2228778898715973,
0.37294137477874756,
0.3038996160030365,
-0.36835479736328125,
-0.3687630593776703,
-0.3661530315876007,
0.341507226228714,
0.18915694952011108,
-0.08716751635074615,
0.6098259091377258,
0.5201910734176636,
-0.4597325921058655,
0.5233626961708069,
-0.017081521451473236,
0.6141982674598694,
-0.43730705976486206,
-0.05599522590637207,
-0.5392289161682129,
0.28308025002479553,
-0.2990745007991791,
-0.4884330630302429,
0.21387290954589844,
0.300263375043869,
-0.3391365706920624,
0.21808506548404694,
0.978253185749054,
-0.32648634910583496,
-0.2520926296710968,
0.574786365032196,
1.1869484186172485,
0.2362833470106125,
0.2916385531425476,
-0.43004968762397766,
0.019040726125240326,
0.010578340850770473,
-0.36579057574272156,
0.5226648449897766,
0.9721547961235046,
-0.127068892121315,
0.5394987463951111,
0.6510512232780457,
0.6706845760345459,
-0.5231658816337585,
-0.25602495670318604,
0.9194032549858093,
-0.834177553653717,
0.07000710070133209,
-0.8882320523262024,
0.07334503531455994,
-0.24234303832054138,
-0.18175607919692993,
1.011347770690918,
0.37150585651397705,
0.6085473895072937,
0.08479707688093185,
0.6791293621063232,
0.08077335357666016,
0.5762482285499573,
-0.49178704619407654,
0.6433287858963013,
-0.35772737860679626,
0.559798002243042,
-0.3220023512840271,
-1.037701964378357,
-0.266009658575058,
0.41388756036758423,
-0.5215865969657898,
-0.1270747184753418,
0.761136531829834,
0.5667762160301208,
-0.15656989812850952,
-0.24425357580184937,
0.3469783663749695,
0.13431310653686523,
0.3426675796508789,
0.6348720192909241,
0.8334121704101562,
-0.33382508158683777,
0.9335309267044067,
-0.4486232399940491,
0.0071898167952895164,
0.10950682312250137,
-0.8867098093032837,
-0.6571160554885864,
-0.23195524513721466,
-0.012993295677006245,
-0.3505963683128357,
-0.1698131412267685,
0.9022015333175659,
0.39560040831565857,
-0.5642867684364319,
-0.47794032096862793,
0.29930275678634644,
0.4053347110748291,
0.24471737444400787,
-0.2853548526763916,
0.7271119952201843,
-0.26255330443382263,
-0.5307888984680176,
0.3454420864582062,
0.12695862352848053,
-0.03401139751076698,
-0.27684009075164795,
-0.2223585546016693,
-0.2833646833896637,
-0.5024281144142151,
0.6482812166213989,
0.3442723751068115,
-0.4521387219429016,
-0.18643133342266083,
0.005025741644203663,
-0.2748964726924896,
-0.04884486272931099,
0.6925517320632935,
-0.7644925713539124,
0.022452659904956818,
0.3406337797641754,
0.6789426207542419,
0.300971120595932,
0.07388853281736374,
0.5186313390731812,
-0.6865385174751282,
0.25025075674057007,
0.021795302629470825,
0.39260151982307434,
0.5825674533843994,
-0.322781503200531,
0.9665149450302124,
0.2934723198413849,
-0.5910419225692749,
-0.9147384166717529,
0.21372483670711517,
-0.6354461312294006,
-0.14555278420448303,
1.3484439849853516,
-0.49566179513931274,
-0.3410838842391968,
-0.3065568804740906,
0.12893012166023254,
0.43896013498306274,
-0.3718084394931793,
0.617805540561676,
0.6273488402366638,
-0.3593086004257202,
-0.12190808355808258,
-0.5382065773010254,
0.4256395697593689,
0.19196955859661102,
-0.79954594373703,
0.15661218762397766,
0.44236087799072266,
0.3684329390525818,
0.3539261817932129,
0.5934106707572937,
-0.3008885681629181,
-0.13383956253528595,
-0.3150367736816406,
-0.024208644405007362,
-0.05464130640029907,
-0.010145539417862892,
-0.21415071189403534,
0.266612708568573,
0.34329333901405334,
-0.20735475420951843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15479v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15479v1 | Twin-Merging: Dynamic Integration of Modular Expertise in Model Merging | 2024-06-17T02:31:55 | 2024-06-17T02:31:55 | Zhenyi Lu, Chenghao Fan, Wei Wei, Xiaoye Qu, Dangyang Chen, Yu Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In the era of large language models, model merging is a promising way to
combine multiple task-specific models into a single multitask model without
extra training. However, two challenges remain: (a) interference between
different models and (b) heterogeneous data during testing. Traditional model
merging methods often show significant performance gaps compared to fine-tuned
models due to these issues. Additionally, a one-size-fits-all model lacks
flexibility for diverse test data, leading to performance degradation. We show
that both shared and exclusive task-specific knowledge are crucial for merging
performance, but directly merging exclusive knowledge hinders overall
performance. In view of this, we propose Twin-Merging, a method that
encompasses two principal stages: (1) modularizing knowledge into shared and
exclusive components, with compression to reduce redundancy and enhance
efficiency; (2) dynamically merging shared and task-specific knowledge based on
the input. This approach narrows the performance gap between merged and
fine-tuned models and improves adaptability to heterogeneous data. Extensive
experiments on $12$ datasets for both discriminative and generative tasks
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method, showing an average improvement of
$28.34\%$ in absolute normalized score for discriminative tasks and even
surpassing the fine-tuned upper bound on the generative tasks. (Our
implementation is available in https://github.com/LZY-the-boys/Twin-Mergin.) | [
-0.5238726139068604,
-0.8980807662010193,
0.41420698165893555,
-0.057111579924821854,
-0.026733815670013428,
0.3336974084377289,
-0.394814133644104,
-0.608833909034729,
-0.0803997740149498,
0.3498079776763916,
-0.5789099335670471,
-0.2573855519294739,
-0.559112548828125,
-0.36878111958503723,
-0.5361717343330383,
0.8963501453399658,
-0.15860779583454132,
-0.037007614970207214,
-0.5385497212409973,
-0.0764574408531189,
-0.5065926909446716,
-0.41213688254356384,
-0.33891695737838745,
-0.3507317900657654,
0.6308289766311646,
0.5192638635635376,
0.5744211077690125,
0.5833202600479126,
0.5381439924240112,
0.25332146883010864,
-0.11322546750307083,
0.5112559795379639,
-0.3343278765678406,
0.4105377197265625,
-0.13052956759929657,
-0.4031534790992737,
-0.7352515459060669,
0.10325172543525696,
0.7495507001876831,
0.865774393081665,
-0.02227005548775196,
0.26870954036712646,
0.3055267930030823,
0.5427767038345337,
-0.5785767436027527,
0.30176326632499695,
-0.38796377182006836,
0.15165506303310394,
-0.2048933207988739,
0.05969955772161484,
-0.04212349280714989,
-0.3851543366909027,
0.0779571607708931,
-0.34525179862976074,
0.2479492574930191,
-0.2381235957145691,
0.6004953384399414,
0.4613441228866577,
-0.6676388382911682,
0.2874215543270111,
-0.9763776659965515,
0.7548120617866516,
-0.6019142866134644,
0.22399301826953888,
0.13342559337615967,
0.4215805232524872,
0.17951679229736328,
-0.3149753212928772,
-0.8154029250144958,
0.08900793641805649,
-0.17832989990711212,
0.020456230267882347,
-0.1517535001039505,
0.05977853760123253,
0.23236390948295593,
0.4868009090423584,
-0.4977993667125702,
0.29567161202430725,
-0.6771027445793152,
0.05952628329396248,
0.8941181898117065,
0.2619350552558899,
0.38802704215049744,
0.1237073466181755,
-0.17066480219364166,
-0.19983366131782532,
-0.3158896863460541,
0.05170005187392235,
0.6387724876403809,
0.5659320950508118,
-0.07842573523521423,
0.643873393535614,
-0.2816622257232666,
0.6600412130355835,
0.36144745349884033,
0.05670108273625374,
0.43392348289489746,
-0.7915087938308716,
0.023843739181756973,
-0.27709388732910156,
0.5886338949203491,
0.20063255727291107,
-0.005073211621493101,
-0.30175289511680603,
-0.2094186246395111,
0.14167334139347076,
0.4264448285102844,
-0.3481241464614868,
-0.15762554109096527,
0.3310202360153198,
-0.38505789637565613,
-0.40178143978118896,
-0.084166020154953,
-0.7650982141494751,
-0.23463456332683563,
-0.6545923352241516,
0.6060382127761841,
-0.25764259696006775,
-0.6830660700798035,
0.13978762924671173,
-0.10590344667434692,
0.013843911699950695,
0.2124466747045517,
-0.7048588991165161,
0.2776487469673157,
0.9891362190246582,
0.63260418176651,
-0.6410741209983826,
-0.6195701956748962,
-0.5348708629608154,
0.03951358050107956,
-0.001560382079333067,
0.6401659846305847,
-0.38269466161727905,
-0.17688485980033875,
-0.004108462017029524,
-0.180587038397789,
-0.4029172360897064,
-0.552980363368988,
0.1471625566482544,
-0.3957073390483856,
0.39014387130737305,
-0.3032829165458679,
-0.47201043367385864,
-0.27651098370552063,
0.2472895234823227,
-0.7289001941680908,
1.114810824394226,
0.18535758554935455,
-0.6016009449958801,
0.31501102447509766,
-0.6955770254135132,
-0.5358135104179382,
0.061550140380859375,
-0.30936145782470703,
-0.3773755729198456,
0.1435292512178421,
-0.030599020421504974,
0.6220267415046692,
-0.3860403001308441,
0.26774799823760986,
-0.4353179335594177,
-0.26038169860839844,
-0.1503286361694336,
-0.0874197781085968,
0.6256403923034668,
-0.018620455637574196,
-0.37772873044013977,
0.27527177333831787,
-0.5480920672416687,
0.12374864518642426,
-0.18521751463413239,
-0.3063870668411255,
-0.12297546118497849,
-0.21375136077404022,
0.12004660069942474,
0.2853926122188568,
0.45474910736083984,
-0.30616816878318787,
0.6005090475082397,
0.04149927943944931,
0.047915250062942505,
0.5679595470428467,
-0.3269439935684204,
0.7135469317436218,
-0.6713631749153137,
0.5160824656486511,
0.1413584053516388,
0.27325761318206787,
0.12090638279914856,
-0.6482833027839661,
-0.8393369317054749,
-0.18169823288917542,
0.4128497540950775,
0.577232301235199,
-0.629876971244812,
0.6761711835861206,
-0.3581881821155548,
-0.6767835021018982,
-0.4013097882270813,
0.10857849568128586,
0.5224437713623047,
0.15637698769569397,
0.3687632977962494,
-0.633983314037323,
-0.42940953373908997,
-1.0219956636428833,
-0.25962400436401367,
-0.10169609636068344,
0.16651341319084167,
0.12636199593544006,
0.3229273855686188,
-0.1941627711057663,
0.7455886602401733,
-0.6152921915054321,
-0.2874155342578888,
-0.22177797555923462,
0.4272252321243286,
0.17555229365825653,
0.9740307927131653,
0.4238974153995514,
-0.9365299344062805,
-0.6033642292022705,
0.29214194416999817,
-0.5387021899223328,
0.08025766164064407,
0.13719885051250458,
-0.030401086434721947,
0.04110380634665489,
0.32649198174476624,
-0.625611424446106,
0.3456209599971771,
0.7343828678131104,
-0.26278483867645264,
0.7279273271560669,
-0.3179439306259155,
0.5151767134666443,
-1.16799795627594,
0.01895902492105961,
-0.3559570908546448,
-0.1092066764831543,
-0.874427080154419,
0.20490118861198425,
0.23172390460968018,
-0.017020221799612045,
-0.17157362401485443,
0.3338257074356079,
-0.5389934778213501,
0.0781397670507431,
-0.2661310136318207,
-0.22723114490509033,
-0.30997657775878906,
0.5191807150840759,
-0.3861940801143646,
0.688976526260376,
0.6301131844520569,
-0.5522119402885437,
0.5735141634941101,
0.10128190368413925,
-0.24738658964633942,
0.43846026062965393,
-0.18982473015785217,
0.28122082352638245,
-0.0015105953207239509,
0.010820169933140278,
-0.8844435811042786,
-0.32574203610420227,
-0.08768349140882492,
-0.28039008378982544,
0.47040966153144836,
-0.09638616442680359,
-0.7022697329521179,
-0.38702771067619324,
-0.0510435588657856,
0.8033537268638611,
0.7473281025886536,
-0.4612577557563782,
1.1127996444702148,
0.2902020215988159,
-0.22538289427757263,
-0.5446910858154297,
-0.7899922132492065,
-0.1699291616678238,
-0.12960053980350494,
-0.8923514485359192,
0.6156063675880432,
-0.15190239250659943,
0.08920953422784805,
0.32979974150657654,
-0.3222820460796356,
-0.5144481658935547,
-0.07021642476320267,
0.3715970516204834,
0.40498530864715576,
-0.2700183391571045,
0.18691563606262207,
0.3935084640979767,
-0.059951625764369965,
-0.32700538635253906,
-0.27004149556159973,
0.45389243960380554,
0.1303974688053131,
-0.5958358645439148,
-0.5948580503463745,
0.6461878418922424,
1.0206373929977417,
-0.36313509941101074,
0.8724392056465149,
0.7240028381347656,
-0.4109175503253937,
-0.13826091587543488,
-1.0507701635360718,
-0.23603306710720062,
-0.38449814915657043,
0.38280773162841797,
-0.46256864070892334,
-1.0352036952972412,
0.5284155607223511,
-0.031671542674303055,
0.2574837803840637,
0.3082467019557953,
0.445482075214386,
-0.0198993943631649,
1.0712701082229614,
0.8509027361869812,
0.04260585457086563,
0.4514293670654297,
-0.22919829189777374,
0.6123741269111633,
-0.5929470658302307,
-0.4232743978500366,
-0.351808100938797,
-0.6399295926094055,
-0.38951054215431213,
-0.7561646699905396,
0.2911641299724579,
-0.09827218949794769,
0.058682218194007874,
0.33919084072113037,
-0.3735264837741852,
0.5587601661682129,
0.5300973653793335,
0.17534573376178741,
0.4897216260433197,
-0.019155427813529968,
0.0009479245054535568,
0.13280336558818817,
-0.8027960062026978,
-0.12197566777467728,
1.2498834133148193,
-0.012991368770599365,
0.3725167512893677,
0.08188112080097198,
0.5888143181800842,
0.08267316222190857,
-0.23414815962314606,
-0.6169947981834412,
0.5660673975944519,
-0.6103636622428894,
-0.5133838653564453,
-0.06386364996433258,
-0.5311644077301025,
-0.6766459345817566,
0.2692519724369049,
-0.5034159421920776,
-0.5498212575912476,
0.2367456555366516,
0.3264390230178833,
-0.6222562193870544,
0.5504183173179626,
-0.825888991355896,
0.6421638131141663,
-0.06543819606304169,
-0.33697783946990967,
-0.6949842572212219,
-0.3636922538280487,
0.7249729633331299,
-0.4975297152996063,
0.1088092252612114,
-0.19928522408008575,
0.030076906085014343,
0.7239426374435425,
0.042153749614953995,
0.652816891670227,
0.0625225082039833,
0.05694024637341499,
-0.29128992557525635,
0.06744880974292755,
0.30548542737960815,
-0.29455792903900146,
0.13237586617469788,
0.14904022216796875,
0.14190880954265594,
-0.47250548005104065,
-0.8264542818069458,
0.777469277381897,
-0.6845842003822327,
-0.6388041377067566,
-0.24576281011104584,
-1.1362888813018799,
-0.4391416013240814,
0.08492323756217957,
-0.11569242924451828,
0.38548293709754944,
0.12151594460010529,
0.13487958908081055,
0.6438422799110413,
0.13437487185001373,
0.06505315005779266,
0.39487361907958984,
-0.22408625483512878,
-0.24902722239494324,
0.6514354348182678,
0.12951554358005524,
0.49790799617767334,
0.12911653518676758,
0.00409826822578907,
0.14635035395622253,
-0.4562051594257355,
0.0728832334280014,
0.16642417013645172,
-0.3156532943248749,
-0.12270993739366531,
-0.7928805351257324,
-0.30209553241729736,
-0.5138358473777771,
-0.002445230958983302,
-0.6312134265899658,
-0.5987178683280945,
0.030751077458262444,
0.17899279296398163,
0.12235627323389053,
0.8909680843353271,
-0.37554827332496643,
0.17157676815986633,
-1.0152573585510254,
0.27027902007102966,
0.5784128308296204,
0.2239556461572647,
0.13528990745544434,
-0.1930391490459442,
-0.31249842047691345,
-0.11027495563030243,
-0.09458792954683304,
-0.8190639615058899,
-0.05256342887878418,
-0.14457911252975464,
0.6222068667411804,
0.2321699559688568,
-0.0695224329829216,
0.8424829244613647,
-0.22886180877685547,
0.7137182354927063,
0.37319719791412354,
-0.8778071403503418,
0.25571849942207336,
-0.27352678775787354,
0.27553582191467285,
0.6333760023117065,
0.3217809498310089,
-0.48352646827697754,
-0.3633602559566498,
-0.5523328185081482,
-0.8273077607154846,
0.8832216858863831,
0.20265008509159088,
-0.08615822345018387,
0.6701149344444275,
0.2594788372516632,
0.2773754596710205,
0.20083704590797424,
-0.08578827232122421,
-0.21281665563583374,
0.4148162603378296,
-0.3006311058998108,
-0.1802457869052887,
-0.14749550819396973,
-0.4438982307910919,
-0.8530625700950623,
0.45275282859802246,
0.030748184770345688,
0.10423737019300461,
-0.3819991648197174,
-0.0782860592007637,
0.047553807497024536,
0.020958563312888145,
0.2627864480018616,
0.589933454990387,
-0.08112358301877975,
0.16673512756824493,
0.2648696303367615,
-0.37514668703079224,
-0.012860777787864208,
0.24803723394870758,
-0.02864227443933487,
-0.167480930685997,
0.28560200333595276,
0.671561062335968,
0.2117508500814438,
-0.3630864918231964,
0.47013792395591736,
-0.14918315410614014,
-0.3591611981391907,
0.13645051419734955,
0.31840822100639343,
0.012811336666345596,
0.6347792148590088,
0.17136035859584808,
0.48988303542137146,
-0.148340106010437,
-0.5680592656135559,
0.2372831255197525,
0.3302071988582611,
-0.12113364785909653,
-0.4469746947288513,
0.308874249458313,
0.3290017545223236,
-0.0753529891371727,
0.538144588470459,
-0.17152532935142517,
-0.8118350505828857,
0.5642381310462952,
0.10763758420944214,
0.8746015429496765,
-0.4223152995109558,
-0.002723345998674631,
0.44966068863868713,
0.09104328602552414,
-0.363474577665329,
0.2746584117412567,
-0.4314368963241577,
-0.6607966423034668,
-0.5218774676322937,
-0.14938031136989594,
-0.23710443079471588,
-0.09553239494562149,
-0.857131838798523,
0.2544940412044525,
-0.03895118832588196,
-0.24084016680717468,
-0.10804109275341034,
0.17233528196811676,
-0.8284614682197571,
-0.03919125720858574,
0.06826285272836685,
0.6768836379051208,
-1.0198732614517212,
0.8597951531410217,
0.803299605846405,
-0.36808037757873535,
-0.8138860464096069,
0.13338340818881989,
0.16403312981128693,
-0.5098156929016113,
0.6725319027900696,
0.07920774072408676,
0.17603352665901184,
-0.16365374624729156,
-0.07603383809328079,
-0.8673978447914124,
1.1174012422561646,
0.31506630778312683,
-0.5270811915397644,
-0.5458828806877136,
0.08231004327535629,
0.19986166059970856,
-0.4237304925918579,
0.08953526616096497,
0.8501262664794922,
0.576107919216156,
0.15659071505069733,
-1.5379191637039185,
0.02424761839210987,
-0.3322489261627197,
-0.18641166388988495,
0.3815130591392517,
-0.42499062418937683,
1.1042550802230835,
-0.10626775026321411,
-0.38424959778785706,
0.06347893178462982,
0.41770485043525696,
-0.04233158007264137,
0.21350698173046112,
0.819122314453125,
0.6866552233695984,
0.9210365414619446,
-0.19635024666786194,
0.6698324084281921,
-0.5007869601249695,
0.634204626083374,
1.1866146326065063,
-0.03730876371264458,
0.7656735777854919,
0.4318828582763672,
-0.09977714717388153,
0.29864171147346497,
0.22166673839092255,
0.0034016917925328016,
0.35290834307670593,
-0.16559560596942902,
-0.3394710421562195,
-0.6034513711929321,
0.03298535570502281,
-0.5863862633705139,
0.47927021980285645,
-0.1238265112042427,
0.0029592423234134912,
-0.2223503291606903,
0.10021978616714478,
-0.16883428394794464,
0.06536036729812622,
0.08454158902168274,
0.7226139307022095,
-0.2622252106666565,
-0.7861236929893494,
0.3119809627532959,
-0.35830873250961304,
1.0022221803665161,
-0.6134354472160339,
0.12425853312015533,
-0.06568768620491028,
0.30620360374450684,
-0.3720090687274933,
-0.8066352605819702,
0.5978168249130249,
-0.17792972922325134,
-0.5024062991142273,
-0.4483778476715088,
0.6016139388084412,
-0.8435569405555725,
-0.1765960156917572,
0.4093461036682129,
0.781316339969635,
-0.11278040707111359,
-0.1851409375667572,
-0.5071852803230286,
0.19317704439163208,
0.00917277205735445,
0.23878860473632812,
0.33181628584861755,
0.01203164178878069,
0.31898531317710876,
0.42715147137641907,
0.6686355471611023,
0.2092277705669403,
0.17197880148887634,
-0.14944417774677277,
0.956102192401886,
-0.5001116394996643,
-0.40537622570991516,
-0.5082900524139404,
0.7116833925247192,
-0.15025758743286133,
-0.08870384097099304,
0.5599429607391357,
0.7052944302558899,
0.9159025549888611,
0.006587820127606392,
0.7726853489875793,
-0.1926991194486618,
0.34849971532821655,
-0.3653072714805603,
0.9799977540969849,
-1.111406683921814,
-0.0230095311999321,
0.14501933753490448,
-0.885118305683136,
-0.22393079102039337,
0.005690037272870541,
-0.29788923263549805,
0.019544221460819244,
0.9395972490310669,
0.7899908423423767,
-0.4473617374897003,
-0.01523679494857788,
0.39974167943000793,
0.08872630447149277,
0.2222442626953125,
0.8383691310882568,
0.7336204648017883,
-0.3410390019416809,
0.32242369651794434,
-0.46078184247016907,
-0.3619786202907562,
-0.13310466706752777,
-0.5351893305778503,
-0.8490259647369385,
-1.0592610836029053,
-0.5585975050926208,
-0.3443358242511749,
0.15953481197357178,
0.7256159782409668,
0.9629092216491699,
-0.5786451101303101,
-0.2674114406108856,
0.15586715936660767,
0.02727886103093624,
-0.47766631841659546,
-0.17680563032627106,
0.19932304322719574,
-0.4420699179172516,
-1.000152826309204,
0.29732972383499146,
0.23997406661510468,
-0.04435485973954201,
-0.3362789750099182,
0.164817214012146,
-0.07830844819545746,
-0.017448406666517258,
0.2984054386615753,
0.10616827756166458,
-0.5981195569038391,
0.017533866688609123,
-0.2114492654800415,
-0.015695372596383095,
-0.14867043495178223,
1.167690396308899,
-0.6951724886894226,
0.605037271976471,
0.8935230374336243,
0.8364336490631104,
0.4831738770008087,
-0.0350831001996994,
0.8362501859664917,
-0.4598860442638397,
0.03448956087231636,
0.18720409274101257,
0.1824313998222351,
0.1309252381324768,
-0.3948175311088562,
0.32630041241645813,
0.2788865268230438,
-0.45127972960472107,
-1.1178231239318848,
0.3172423541545868,
-1.1413655281066895,
-0.152201309800148,
1.1001560688018799,
0.011574629694223404,
0.03775441274046898,
-0.04452619329094887,
0.16335701942443848,
0.5689604878425598,
-0.13495120406150818,
0.7557334899902344,
0.6672426462173462,
-0.18619628250598907,
0.08608641475439072,
-0.41614672541618347,
0.32668960094451904,
0.7293226718902588,
-0.9448630809783936,
0.07810141891241074,
0.20715300738811493,
0.25222086906433105,
0.278663694858551,
0.0920434221625328,
0.07760314643383026,
0.5009034872055054,
-0.04475263133645058,
0.24345892667770386,
-0.29378950595855713,
-0.3431087136268616,
-0.4717625081539154,
0.2962202727794647,
-0.34289437532424927,
-0.3276893198490143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11149v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11149v1 | GoldCoin: Grounding Large Language Models in Privacy Laws via Contextual Integrity Theory | 2024-06-17T02:27:32 | 2024-06-17T02:27:32 | Wei Fan, Haoran Li, Zheye Deng, Weiqi Wang, Yangqiu Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | Privacy issues arise prominently during the inappropriate transmission of
information between entities. Existing research primarily studies privacy by
exploring various privacy attacks, defenses, and evaluations within narrowly
predefined patterns, while neglecting that privacy is not an isolated,
context-free concept limited to traditionally sensitive data (e.g., social
security numbers), but intertwined with intricate social contexts that
complicate the identification and analysis of potential privacy violations. The
advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) offers unprecedented opportunities for
incorporating the nuanced scenarios outlined in privacy laws to tackle these
complex privacy issues. However, the scarcity of open-source relevant case
studies restricts the efficiency of LLMs in aligning with specific legal
statutes. To address this challenge, we introduce a novel framework, GoldCoin,
designed to efficiently ground LLMs in privacy laws for judicial assessing
privacy violations. Our framework leverages the theory of contextual integrity
as a bridge, creating numerous synthetic scenarios grounded in relevant privacy
statutes (e.g., HIPAA), to assist LLMs in comprehending the complex contexts
for identifying privacy risks in the real world. Extensive experimental results
demonstrate that GoldCoin markedly enhances LLMs' capabilities in recognizing
privacy risks across real court cases, surpassing the baselines on different
judicial tasks. | [
0.02561977133154869,
-1.1631134748458862,
0.6313572525978088,
0.006757690105587244,
-0.28340956568717957,
-0.055700208991765976,
-0.34436893463134766,
-0.6082385778427124,
0.08960704505443573,
1.0498775243759155,
-0.20207753777503967,
-0.6326168179512024,
-0.5278884172439575,
-0.053130559623241425,
-0.4878278374671936,
1.3885138034820557,
0.06371493637561798,
-0.4476490616798401,
-0.1617717742919922,
-0.2434098869562149,
-0.3223353326320648,
-0.8305684328079224,
-0.21782565116882324,
-0.29023221135139465,
0.48559004068374634,
0.23909378051757812,
0.6689378023147583,
0.5030412673950195,
0.46084141731262207,
0.32205283641815186,
-0.17008328437805176,
0.018039831891655922,
-0.40326136350631714,
-0.10368266701698303,
-0.24542897939682007,
-0.3273385167121887,
-0.5714025497436523,
-0.22605597972869873,
0.38129159808158875,
0.8127867579460144,
-0.14800162613391876,
0.05297710373997688,
0.06666985154151917,
0.6702530980110168,
-0.9987444281578064,
0.1464652717113495,
-0.7163347005844116,
-0.09299981594085693,
-0.2100323587656021,
-0.47009554505348206,
-0.04872424155473709,
-0.07214158028364182,
0.026264987885951996,
-0.36454638838768005,
0.00903912540525198,
0.05529196560382843,
0.774641215801239,
-0.12357538938522339,
-0.5973262786865234,
-0.250833660364151,
-0.5304099917411804,
0.3868849277496338,
-0.5653371810913086,
0.2354777753353119,
0.5587494969367981,
0.24628590047359467,
-0.026582855731248856,
-0.7385109066963196,
-0.5386949181556702,
-0.22580556571483612,
-0.11638716608285904,
-0.19549688696861267,
-0.0023042848333716393,
0.11894737184047699,
0.39048880338668823,
0.6233658790588379,
-0.39741042256355286,
-0.2228643298149109,
-0.08764804154634476,
-0.09795761853456497,
0.4909549057483673,
0.054061416536569595,
0.29713574051856995,
-0.2628704607486725,
0.06999918073415756,
0.05497114732861519,
-0.8510700464248657,
0.12780140340328217,
0.5816134214401245,
0.6834940910339355,
-0.2514777183532715,
0.534299373626709,
-0.060456931591033936,
0.5936892032623291,
0.013948464766144753,
-0.2845582962036133,
0.20913761854171753,
-0.2035321295261383,
-0.401083379983902,
0.4828591048717499,
0.5916064381599426,
0.26476070284843445,
0.20835821330547333,
-0.22017845511436462,
-0.10612724721431732,
0.07791715115308762,
0.20585113763809204,
-0.725983202457428,
-0.05570976436138153,
0.5869830250740051,
-0.3667939603328705,
-0.5157959461212158,
0.2872295677661896,
-0.32632243633270264,
-0.6658055782318115,
-0.3713753819465637,
0.2614539563655853,
-0.004068058915436268,
-0.3089480698108673,
0.3707708418369293,
0.20624873042106628,
0.0029370554257184267,
-0.03981023281812668,
-1.1253113746643066,
0.6202029585838318,
1.2694694995880127,
0.8498759269714355,
0.47971904277801514,
-0.15758976340293884,
-0.7961062788963318,
0.519426703453064,
-0.4252190887928009,
0.36087876558303833,
-0.37005195021629333,
-0.29162004590034485,
0.2902519404888153,
0.37002885341644287,
0.31878069043159485,
-0.3194240629673004,
0.5702721476554871,
-0.670881450176239,
-0.479401171207428,
-0.2183264195919037,
-0.23587562143802643,
-0.10123425722122192,
0.6480620503425598,
-0.8799650073051453,
0.24936172366142273,
-0.03594484180212021,
-1.090293526649475,
0.3516952097415924,
-0.6650015711784363,
-0.7258737087249756,
0.2731420695781708,
-0.21983610093593597,
-0.49600082635879517,
0.005473759490996599,
-0.004164708778262138,
0.3352237343788147,
-0.07472144812345505,
0.45152807235717773,
-0.5114001035690308,
-0.5656850934028625,
0.5968199968338013,
-0.32653024792671204,
1.0333845615386963,
0.09948133677244186,
-0.36852264404296875,
0.12252464145421982,
-0.8166019320487976,
-0.25945597887039185,
0.10749390721321106,
-0.04142087325453758,
-0.9877592921257019,
-0.11205989122390747,
0.1629188358783722,
0.0038181014824658632,
0.4331547021865845,
-0.33681222796440125,
-0.17373450100421906,
-0.7217821478843689,
0.9390071034431458,
0.7259906530380249,
0.05309350788593292,
0.5586597919464111,
-0.09147806465625763,
0.1657644510269165,
-0.0861327052116394,
0.1780833750963211,
-0.2458295226097107,
-0.08222218602895737,
-0.24799402058124542,
-0.08187124133110046,
0.5274342894554138,
0.78249591588974,
0.3170810043811798,
0.6871169209480286,
-0.5274816751480103,
-0.005126868840306997,
-0.3077600598335266,
0.3867461681365967,
-0.20591314136981964,
0.26784470677375793,
-0.08899951726198196,
-0.29481419920921326,
-0.6399490237236023,
-0.8034027814865112,
-0.5758363008499146,
-0.17693883180618286,
0.24154511094093323,
0.5915018916130066,
0.6434828639030457,
-0.5979114174842834,
0.980318546295166,
0.038775939494371414,
-0.1780742108821869,
0.10288991779088974,
-0.14330734312534332,
0.275607705116272,
0.690994143486023,
0.1998286247253418,
-1.1688175201416016,
-0.11550291627645493,
0.5904844999313354,
-0.8465498685836792,
0.1734362095594406,
-0.15213057398796082,
-0.21437671780586243,
-0.020565090700984,
0.412942498922348,
-0.702677845954895,
0.5238657593727112,
0.6411117911338806,
-0.4308488667011261,
0.14459002017974854,
-0.3462338447570801,
0.1455054134130478,
-1.0871471166610718,
0.33674174547195435,
-0.16238757967948914,
-0.4800019860267639,
-0.4926709234714508,
-0.0019679937977343798,
0.3743212819099426,
-0.19895964860916138,
-0.2821255028247833,
0.4627527594566345,
-0.13393482565879822,
-0.2859145998954773,
-0.4522312581539154,
0.14611394703388214,
0.043626803904771805,
-0.0670909509062767,
-0.2666397988796234,
0.4568832814693451,
0.49103012681007385,
-0.44608891010284424,
0.29851850867271423,
0.06601152569055557,
-0.2864318788051605,
0.6492199301719666,
-0.660326361656189,
0.001642787829041481,
0.08504378795623779,
0.24334710836410522,
-0.5767109990119934,
-0.448336124420166,
0.46081647276878357,
-0.1973726898431778,
0.2082204520702362,
-0.4837142527103424,
-0.7277631759643555,
0.003057939698919654,
-0.13291247189044952,
0.6294026970863342,
0.21730193495750427,
-0.3642328679561615,
0.7826698422431946,
0.49550661444664,
-0.23378871381282806,
-1.0029239654541016,
-0.8525757193565369,
0.684788703918457,
-0.5759779214859009,
-0.48423293232917786,
0.3605601191520691,
-0.0028012054972350597,
-0.7968000173568726,
0.09712187200784683,
0.005467125214636326,
-0.004221913404762745,
0.5699403882026672,
0.5529034733772278,
0.13690021634101868,
0.32108837366104126,
-0.08972322940826416,
0.04963481053709984,
-0.30156540870666504,
0.2501753866672516,
-0.5575590133666992,
0.3482825756072998,
-0.31196480989456177,
-0.27646496891975403,
-0.46986404061317444,
0.4927974045276642,
0.5436615347862244,
-0.27683353424072266,
0.7114521861076355,
0.050277307629585266,
-0.5985320210456848,
-0.03065316379070282,
-0.49841558933258057,
-0.12123163789510727,
-0.5196548700332642,
0.1242741197347641,
-0.3429523706436157,
-1.206508755683899,
0.7872613072395325,
-0.22553059458732605,
0.33603453636169434,
0.1056889146566391,
0.5890324115753174,
0.1913071721792221,
0.8267514109611511,
0.9241645932197571,
-0.2586206793785095,
0.5151168704032898,
-0.05852792039513588,
0.6977447271347046,
-0.629817008972168,
0.02929173968732357,
-0.34666597843170166,
0.24485759437084198,
-0.9342348575592041,
-0.03987475857138634,
0.1569519340991974,
0.07445980608463287,
-0.3621950149536133,
0.2251376509666443,
0.04776277020573616,
0.49149394035339355,
0.06419974565505981,
0.1613520085811615,
0.46980777382850647,
0.23111304640769958,
0.20397964119911194,
0.2814411520957947,
-0.3468030095100403,
-0.870273232460022,
1.2570959329605103,
0.45702770352363586,
0.7635930180549622,
0.12774671614170074,
0.7446234226226807,
0.477782279253006,
0.2902314364910126,
-0.6159595847129822,
0.24295109510421753,
-0.047962870448827744,
-0.6890537142753601,
-0.13623416423797607,
-0.41571661829948425,
-1.082796573638916,
0.09141387790441513,
-0.19515685737133026,
-0.753537118434906,
0.1207406297326088,
0.20416691899299622,
-0.497312992811203,
0.19016534090042114,
-0.1684119552373886,
1.095736026763916,
-0.22279910743236542,
-1.0601089000701904,
-0.025393417105078697,
-0.7499797344207764,
0.5859843492507935,
-0.2489907145500183,
0.7431821823120117,
0.20024943351745605,
0.0528838187456131,
0.38639387488365173,
-0.6349584460258484,
0.9161356091499329,
0.2587321698665619,
-0.579426109790802,
0.2861986458301544,
0.15985752642154694,
0.6749348640441895,
0.6409805417060852,
0.16975310444831848,
0.27727755904197693,
0.0012689828872680664,
-0.3236929178237915,
-0.49790453910827637,
1.1556695699691772,
-0.5497384667396545,
-0.34776991605758667,
-0.41216930747032166,
-0.7023890614509583,
-0.08477140218019485,
0.2598710060119629,
-0.16918547451496124,
0.34866586327552795,
-0.134665384888649,
0.14129021763801575,
0.7822748422622681,
0.09717686474323273,
0.22429516911506653,
0.30662596225738525,
0.3087257146835327,
-0.5611186623573303,
0.6615346074104309,
0.147765651345253,
-0.2448914349079132,
0.20381520688533783,
0.12020658701658249,
-0.27644604444503784,
-0.24760930240154266,
-0.10079437494277954,
0.4840715229511261,
-0.9802175164222717,
0.009037293493747711,
-0.7847568392753601,
0.03848692402243614,
-0.6121363639831543,
-0.3715018630027771,
-0.3584865629673004,
-0.05879518762230873,
-0.02250225469470024,
-0.2925518751144409,
0.34925898909568787,
0.1280784159898758,
-0.2522898018360138,
-0.08787021040916443,
-0.7039504051208496,
0.2461906373500824,
0.5049772262573242,
0.4355602264404297,
-0.33588552474975586,
-0.2933950126171112,
-0.1571487933397293,
-0.06777545064687729,
0.201008141040802,
-0.5245340466499329,
0.1141357496380806,
-0.2048330307006836,
0.24765494465827942,
0.5984994173049927,
0.09409619122743607,
1.077062964439392,
-0.6447422504425049,
0.6137587428092957,
0.06248067319393158,
-1.1777317523956299,
0.5910639762878418,
-0.20160961151123047,
-0.3627685606479645,
0.7379189729690552,
-0.1260630488395691,
-0.6640774011611938,
-0.2727552056312561,
-0.9762616753578186,
-1.2024974822998047,
0.16567659378051758,
0.28330501914024353,
0.5440558195114136,
-0.04984898492693901,
0.8066374063491821,
0.09590017050504684,
0.5069942474365234,
-1.1266911029815674,
0.03896459937095642,
-0.1202293410897255,
-0.21730439364910126,
-0.18016089498996735,
-0.3685431480407715,
-0.8031156659126282,
0.029976438730955124,
0.3594215512275696,
-0.1303899884223938,
-0.03515820577740669,
-0.006472824141383171,
-0.27666333317756653,
-0.1394774615764618,
0.35784462094306946,
0.6336012482643127,
0.8949843645095825,
-0.21120138466358185,
0.39332908391952515,
0.009580966085195541,
-0.37656375765800476,
0.0347561351954937,
0.03536070138216019,
-0.31932783126831055,
-0.3489123284816742,
0.41462942957878113,
0.5468894243240356,
0.27247875928878784,
-0.9359871745109558,
0.6963229179382324,
0.0034275799989700317,
-0.2833573520183563,
-0.8702274560928345,
-0.1511523723602295,
-0.07956547290086746,
0.2596683204174042,
0.08921420574188232,
-0.12137427926063538,
0.34369632601737976,
-0.8021327257156372,
0.30046600103378296,
0.5150778889656067,
-0.42107629776000977,
-0.17029373347759247,
0.5574210286140442,
-0.05037667229771614,
-0.34798210859298706,
0.315267413854599,
0.22501708567142487,
-0.2872558534145355,
0.4214385747909546,
0.5945785641670227,
0.8242457509040833,
0.15559130907058716,
-0.21764616668224335,
0.1760130077600479,
0.5425706505775452,
-0.3594290614128113,
0.11599576473236084,
-0.3276669681072235,
-0.5579705834388733,
-0.3144714832305908,
-0.2808980643749237,
-0.2984524965286255,
0.22235363721847534,
-0.587173342704773,
0.025031641125679016,
-0.6374608278274536,
-0.3259759247303009,
-0.4405755400657654,
0.11958587169647217,
-0.27675047516822815,
0.10509244352579117,
0.21385745704174042,
0.42651718854904175,
-0.9931044578552246,
0.5153279900550842,
0.7088162302970886,
0.05191643908619881,
-0.3230477273464203,
0.09661237895488739,
-0.0328124538064003,
-0.36589622497558594,
0.488709032535553,
0.3821214437484741,
-0.17636464536190033,
-0.33126917481422424,
-0.7673839926719666,
-0.39866572618484497,
1.046329140663147,
0.46749448776245117,
-0.8119156956672668,
0.3116038739681244,
0.1941099464893341,
0.33669430017471313,
-0.44195327162742615,
-0.4036501348018646,
0.5853437781333923,
0.4919459819793701,
-0.2530084550380707,
-0.5744780898094177,
0.13878367841243744,
-0.28456494212150574,
0.04776052013039589,
0.11017633229494095,
-0.5247029662132263,
0.9470093846321106,
-0.05035398527979851,
0.05249414220452309,
-0.16157937049865723,
0.579712450504303,
0.4789993166923523,
0.5190738439559937,
0.5801486372947693,
0.5311642289161682,
0.9323873519897461,
0.1255791187286377,
1.0836567878723145,
-0.698028564453125,
0.48713645339012146,
0.7657645344734192,
-0.5474556684494019,
0.6228189468383789,
0.6775248646736145,
0.1593259572982788,
0.6735900640487671,
0.4965308606624603,
0.15766321122646332,
0.5004343390464783,
0.2835187017917633,
-0.38039639592170715,
-0.43249979615211487,
-0.12442000210285187,
-0.12141311168670654,
0.2973300814628601,
0.38505950570106506,
-0.44107338786125183,
0.14147083461284637,
-0.015656940639019012,
0.12441899627447128,
0.3043240010738373,
-0.4312480092048645,
0.5882207751274109,
0.1374085545539856,
-0.2518061697483063,
0.23894846439361572,
0.2514627277851105,
0.3577774465084076,
-0.6147297620773315,
-0.04353286325931549,
0.01857064478099346,
0.30304646492004395,
-0.3256393373012543,
-0.32413244247436523,
0.11894897371530533,
0.06075969338417053,
-0.020237848162651062,
0.017516842111945152,
0.6803781986236572,
-0.24913544952869415,
-0.3503965735435486,
0.15821225941181183,
-0.09291943162679672,
0.03812873363494873,
-0.16676022112369537,
-0.7519136667251587,
0.31303295493125916,
-0.5968510508537292,
-0.15288789570331573,
0.45311570167541504,
0.7177314758300781,
-0.23760104179382324,
0.5222870111465454,
0.7889952659606934,
0.09940842539072037,
-0.42597973346710205,
0.1929832547903061,
0.6978775858879089,
-0.8265405893325806,
-1.0627721548080444,
-1.2161641120910645,
0.5416064858436584,
-0.35590147972106934,
0.09032096713781357,
0.757627010345459,
0.524990975856781,
0.705761730670929,
0.4027433395385742,
0.8856298923492432,
0.08362464606761932,
0.1267118901014328,
-0.5898047089576721,
0.5877541303634644,
-0.49643179774284363,
0.5206996202468872,
-0.4827386140823364,
-0.6791198253631592,
-0.6321983337402344,
1.0163521766662598,
-0.2714736759662628,
-0.042740289121866226,
0.4561796486377716,
0.6984673142433167,
-0.11513391137123108,
-0.12449387460947037,
0.21312721073627472,
-0.027648217976093292,
0.420746773481369,
0.463226318359375,
0.5449422597885132,
-0.7043383121490479,
0.40297049283981323,
-0.30174535512924194,
-0.21924768388271332,
-0.46197712421417236,
-1.0468260049819946,
-1.056698203086853,
-0.23820048570632935,
-0.31216150522232056,
-0.6493557691574097,
-0.017823437228798866,
0.8255088925361633,
0.6425409317016602,
-0.6731417775154114,
-0.530336856842041,
-0.2847454845905304,
-0.08405697345733643,
-0.38723406195640564,
-0.16355252265930176,
0.45638442039489746,
-0.023960519582033157,
-0.4382908344268799,
0.18631711602210999,
0.5914652347564697,
0.12381797283887863,
-0.21195583045482635,
-0.11639732867479324,
0.06239474192261696,
0.057937998324632645,
0.6750441193580627,
0.41640037298202515,
-0.7442272901535034,
-0.3104902505874634,
-0.40195828676223755,
-0.24470773339271545,
-0.04187439754605293,
1.2166337966918945,
-0.40261539816856384,
0.4053102135658264,
0.14764472842216492,
0.8084505200386047,
0.2229549139738083,
0.39120814204216003,
0.2589821219444275,
-0.3748873472213745,
0.4140956997871399,
0.18033279478549957,
0.4098275303840637,
0.46239709854125977,
-0.6583870053291321,
0.07542375475168228,
0.24484555423259735,
-0.48791128396987915,
-0.9881394505500793,
0.14961901307106018,
-1.1146059036254883,
-0.3804844617843628,
0.8734400868415833,
-0.17845191061496735,
-0.7184063196182251,
-0.22385193407535553,
-0.003206504276022315,
-0.004902737680822611,
-0.1477774828672409,
1.0995545387268066,
0.7200568914413452,
0.5113121867179871,
-0.13682910799980164,
-0.8672375082969666,
0.3344298303127289,
0.1945776641368866,
-0.6608685255050659,
0.6065364480018616,
0.40562883019447327,
0.4492427706718445,
0.16029313206672668,
0.7781074643135071,
-0.4863676428794861,
0.3458032011985779,
-0.14560000598430634,
-0.22298169136047363,
-0.17865104973316193,
-0.2577996253967285,
-0.5562630295753479,
0.566352367401123,
-0.0438549630343914,
0.21471938490867615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11139v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11139v1 | Breaking Boundaries: Investigating the Effects of Model Editing on Cross-linguistic Performance | 2024-06-17T01:54:27 | 2024-06-17T01:54:27 | Somnath Banerjee, Avik Halder, Rajarshi Mandal, Sayan Layek, Ian Soboroff, Rima Hazra, Animesh Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL | The integration of pretrained language models (PLMs) like BERT and GPT has
revolutionized NLP, particularly for English, but it has also created
linguistic imbalances. This paper strategically identifies the need for
linguistic equity by examining several knowledge editing techniques in
multilingual contexts. We evaluate the performance of models such as Mistral,
TowerInstruct, OpenHathi, Tamil-Llama, and Kan-Llama across languages including
English, German, French, Italian, Spanish, Hindi, Tamil, and Kannada. Our
research identifies significant discrepancies in normal and merged models
concerning cross-lingual consistency. We employ strategies like 'each language
for itself' (ELFI) and 'each language for others' (ELFO) to stress-test these
models. Our findings demonstrate the potential for LLMs to overcome linguistic
barriers, laying the groundwork for future research in achieving linguistic
inclusivity in AI technologies. | [
-0.4654182493686676,
-0.6901240944862366,
0.28551265597343445,
0.30387741327285767,
0.11822158843278885,
0.37489423155784607,
-0.34651896357536316,
-0.7415733933448792,
-0.05154616758227348,
0.47164154052734375,
-0.3414512574672699,
-0.34334155917167664,
-0.857880175113678,
0.24094942212104797,
-0.3395707905292511,
0.7849946022033691,
-0.4017788767814636,
0.2474258989095688,
-0.2919023334980011,
-0.4123810827732086,
-0.6356357932090759,
-0.6227707862854004,
-0.3743117153644562,
-0.4606383740901947,
0.3291783332824707,
0.019046679139137268,
1.0261881351470947,
0.5137808918952942,
0.218268021941185,
0.34230589866638184,
-0.3156091868877411,
0.1797397881746292,
-0.2901332676410675,
-0.07617275416851044,
-0.43952465057373047,
-0.5116917490959167,
-0.45138174295425415,
0.009101624600589275,
0.9992577433586121,
0.7324239015579224,
0.10374274104833603,
-0.16663968563079834,
0.3235241770744324,
0.3904680013656616,
-0.44977128505706787,
-0.14711374044418335,
-0.669686496257782,
0.14491428434848785,
-0.2861584722995758,
0.09069152921438217,
-0.17335861921310425,
-0.13582247495651245,
0.08233547955751419,
-0.6800873875617981,
-0.04371629282832146,
-0.16859671473503113,
1.0712435245513916,
0.324390709400177,
-0.29273638129234314,
-0.18276122212409973,
-0.6154953837394714,
0.8010595440864563,
-0.826829195022583,
0.7599230408668518,
0.24912211298942566,
-0.23344118893146515,
0.0343238040804863,
-0.5415709614753723,
-0.5167892575263977,
0.03864924982190132,
-0.11226226389408112,
-0.06048949435353279,
-0.24001336097717285,
0.15700849890708923,
0.11892320215702057,
0.22524061799049377,
-0.38499513268470764,
0.5806185603141785,
-0.5282043814659119,
-0.03538145497441292,
0.598778247833252,
-0.08167295902967453,
0.8649336695671082,
0.008456772193312645,
-0.0485687181353569,
0.04107346013188362,
-0.8427087068557739,
0.08046920597553253,
0.6614255309104919,
0.2963746190071106,
-0.005658347625285387,
0.78074711561203,
0.1752023845911026,
0.730925977230072,
-0.27503564953804016,
-0.09347263723611832,
0.15860344469547272,
-0.3976982533931732,
-0.247475728392601,
-0.033073779195547104,
0.6795718669891357,
0.3450094163417816,
0.4861167371273041,
-0.21120813488960266,
-0.0063246432691812515,
-0.17545484006404877,
0.08202843368053436,
-0.16054612398147583,
0.02235576882958412,
-0.014342550188302994,
-0.16324785351753235,
0.08796988427639008,
-0.352911114692688,
-0.6265538334846497,
-0.4162474274635315,
-0.4596590995788574,
0.4671684503555298,
-0.6305423974990845,
-0.4345929026603699,
0.0692019909620285,
-0.0826219990849495,
0.12026680260896683,
0.2695806920528412,
-0.8973174095153809,
0.1309821903705597,
0.6833788156509399,
0.7670010328292847,
-0.030862992629408836,
-0.8871326446533203,
0.060109153389930725,
0.03254145011305809,
-0.3748435378074646,
0.47617051005363464,
-0.7050730586051941,
-0.5632686614990234,
0.06931298226118088,
-0.15727172791957855,
-0.30817288160324097,
-0.5916957259178162,
0.25700125098228455,
-0.507458508014679,
0.09750336408615112,
-0.31356674432754517,
-0.6929641962051392,
-0.0665716901421547,
0.1794384866952896,
-0.7029429078102112,
1.0433626174926758,
-0.12512408196926117,
-0.611913800239563,
0.42586275935173035,
-0.7354166507720947,
-0.4950830638408661,
-0.17475520074367523,
-0.07867122441530228,
-0.24377937614917755,
0.08562199026346207,
0.4196906089782715,
0.10936328768730164,
-0.01781638152897358,
0.41385623812675476,
0.027242835611104965,
-0.14170202612876892,
0.016023406758904457,
-0.17503537237644196,
0.9216070771217346,
0.03557879850268364,
-0.3559051752090454,
0.20394380390644073,
-0.5876963138580322,
0.050315383821725845,
-0.020341666415333748,
-0.12469931691884995,
-0.5571854114532471,
-0.13482369482517242,
-0.012619228102266788,
0.45784756541252136,
0.17537415027618408,
-0.432055801153183,
0.07876459509134293,
-0.25668245553970337,
0.359476774930954,
0.8577258586883545,
-0.38733014464378357,
0.40011197328567505,
-0.3284136652946472,
0.7205734848976135,
-0.02623330056667328,
0.14526516199111938,
0.04855859652161598,
-0.7129406929016113,
-0.8512143492698669,
-0.1873708963394165,
0.5841636061668396,
0.6544755101203918,
-0.7726079225540161,
0.23919637501239777,
-0.11087755858898163,
-0.43212276697158813,
-1.1497373580932617,
0.5423364639282227,
0.21405746042728424,
0.2287580668926239,
0.4175702929496765,
-0.1706821471452713,
-0.5311956405639648,
-0.8578968048095703,
-0.7951999306678772,
-0.028167132288217545,
0.27955907583236694,
0.14449580013751984,
0.3482770025730133,
-0.27006304264068604,
0.978287398815155,
0.1670822650194168,
-0.2206277698278427,
-0.32633957266807556,
0.19795829057693481,
-0.1770343780517578,
0.6248357892036438,
0.4646885395050049,
-0.6038311123847961,
-0.6289818286895752,
0.1248643770813942,
-0.7445920705795288,
-0.4835740625858307,
-0.13580335676670074,
-0.15020836889743805,
0.31842267513275146,
0.5002923011779785,
-0.5275887250900269,
0.49666330218315125,
0.9173018932342529,
-0.2050672173500061,
0.37280672788619995,
-0.2492041289806366,
0.382207453250885,
-0.7201562523841858,
-0.21994535624980927,
-0.08135338872671127,
0.04961070790886879,
-0.6836344003677368,
0.12624959647655487,
-0.08670173585414886,
-0.11768821626901627,
-0.5604209303855896,
0.7887194752693176,
-0.5742775797843933,
-0.10401927679777145,
-0.05888257548213005,
0.22904133796691895,
-0.02974974922835827,
0.22266197204589844,
0.1184830442070961,
0.7363716959953308,
0.389365553855896,
-0.3430609703063965,
-0.11764240264892578,
0.24079596996307373,
-0.4046865701675415,
0.3805468678474426,
-0.6251843571662903,
0.15024204552173615,
-0.1159481555223465,
-0.13218443095684052,
-0.8149577975273132,
0.20188942551612854,
-0.12518583238124847,
-0.1843426525592804,
0.32230329513549805,
-0.1067838966846466,
-0.5790649056434631,
0.11894871294498444,
-0.17655394971370697,
0.6304364204406738,
0.2823580503463745,
-0.5354011058807373,
0.7301678657531738,
0.5107356905937195,
-0.43462198972702026,
-0.8061909079551697,
-0.8118926882743835,
0.40039578080177307,
-0.020269401371479034,
-0.9241564869880676,
0.22377334535121918,
0.02311653457581997,
-0.6506264209747314,
0.0737929418683052,
0.27383166551589966,
-0.16678880155086517,
0.1342247873544693,
0.015073856338858604,
0.15345285832881927,
-0.03603602945804596,
0.014658218249678612,
0.37373751401901245,
0.3288978636264801,
-0.22339555621147156,
-0.12726503610610962,
0.44887498021125793,
-0.0868462398648262,
-0.45993572473526,
-0.3294462561607361,
0.4493699073791504,
0.42589396238327026,
-0.5783299803733826,
0.8379834294319153,
0.5656139850616455,
-0.316488653421402,
-0.2697819471359253,
-0.6738388538360596,
0.24900564551353455,
-0.41671809554100037,
0.3971062898635864,
-0.5243166089057922,
-1.3595210313796997,
0.6696472764015198,
0.008998009376227856,
0.09421098232269287,
0.4650193452835083,
0.4259740710258484,
0.09066472202539444,
0.9427367448806763,
1.0240278244018555,
-0.026543065905570984,
0.4530467092990875,
-0.08366167545318604,
0.37948453426361084,
-0.7090749144554138,
-0.09820181876420975,
-0.47615522146224976,
-0.2390257567167282,
-0.7729257345199585,
-0.5769351720809937,
0.38043466210365295,
0.31655001640319824,
0.03380357474088669,
0.16522568464279175,
-0.2658265233039856,
0.5901956558227539,
0.5831655263900757,
-0.18250462412834167,
0.5371336936950684,
-0.12532030045986176,
-0.33025074005126953,
-0.5590988993644714,
-1.0388667583465576,
-0.4129696488380432,
1.0155210494995117,
0.44527697563171387,
0.6692153811454773,
0.042192235589027405,
0.5548737049102783,
0.2166021466255188,
0.4622444212436676,
-0.31166666746139526,
0.30995044112205505,
-0.3015539050102234,
-0.7367210984230042,
-0.42844462394714355,
-0.19034309685230255,
-0.744803249835968,
0.44967374205589294,
-0.18195828795433044,
-0.6165241003036499,
0.3775298595428467,
-0.05493419989943504,
-0.12416128814220428,
0.7908423542976379,
-0.6881631016731262,
0.9537357687950134,
-0.48747187852859497,
-0.4006333649158478,
-0.2300192415714264,
-0.5072178244590759,
0.5549440383911133,
-0.24544303119182587,
0.5309589505195618,
-0.11399725824594498,
-0.005200594197958708,
0.7182904481887817,
-0.31859350204467773,
0.8984903693199158,
-0.05796699970960617,
-0.3574592173099518,
0.1529286801815033,
0.03555385023355484,
0.20673422515392303,
-0.1513320803642273,
-0.055412810295820236,
0.7531681060791016,
-0.12153322994709015,
-0.44041529297828674,
-0.36066561937332153,
0.6113472580909729,
-1.061729073524475,
-0.5927962064743042,
-0.202818363904953,
-0.9151632785797119,
-0.39115768671035767,
0.22528421878814697,
0.1611279845237732,
-0.06002971902489662,
-0.2193077951669693,
-0.16568759083747864,
0.5201718211174011,
-0.5892871618270874,
0.37437009811401367,
0.38557571172714233,
-0.3427116572856903,
-0.36268430948257446,
0.5543767213821411,
0.5036212801933289,
0.36923736333847046,
0.09486782550811768,
-0.07350669056177139,
-0.1643761396408081,
-0.5038994550704956,
-0.4019235074520111,
0.34908491373062134,
-0.6926026344299316,
0.20004531741142273,
-0.802643358707428,
-0.31238695979118347,
-0.604897141456604,
-0.46439501643180847,
-0.4739565849304199,
-0.3010520339012146,
0.021708481013774872,
-0.14188550412654877,
0.0803656354546547,
1.0239832401275635,
-0.4855983257293701,
0.3215426206588745,
-0.7989587783813477,
0.13352255523204803,
0.09473363310098648,
0.4052625894546509,
-0.0671166405081749,
-0.4852742552757263,
-0.3428487181663513,
0.03651116043329239,
-0.15653984248638153,
-0.6906782984733582,
0.4020572304725647,
0.15535150468349457,
0.7349680662155151,
-0.24904704093933105,
-0.325762540102005,
0.8596566319465637,
-0.617668867111206,
0.7992079854011536,
0.049323514103889465,
-1.4791699647903442,
0.4092761278152466,
-0.2255306988954544,
0.36611661314964294,
0.31405380368232727,
0.5131286382675171,
-0.8036091923713684,
-0.8274550437927246,
-0.5571312308311462,
-0.9689633846282959,
0.5624560117721558,
0.01945377141237259,
0.09244124591350555,
0.28776276111602783,
0.09009083360433578,
0.26513728499412537,
0.2562507092952728,
-0.9018979072570801,
-0.11463793367147446,
-0.13815009593963623,
-0.012791210785508156,
-0.17416641116142273,
-0.3741983473300934,
-0.14682263135910034,
-0.4851095676422119,
0.6743490099906921,
0.18633264303207397,
-0.18810808658599854,
0.3168037533760071,
-0.479969322681427,
-0.08915316313505173,
0.37686482071876526,
0.6053684949874878,
1.0814436674118042,
0.08759352564811707,
-0.10261816531419754,
0.2947986125946045,
-0.1326959878206253,
0.1207311600446701,
0.13997426629066467,
-0.19049005210399628,
0.1753811538219452,
0.6075721383094788,
0.8803312182426453,
0.08932769298553467,
-0.6011462211608887,
0.06797582656145096,
0.12735171616077423,
-0.17089666426181793,
0.18500328063964844,
-0.13203725218772888,
0.029236622154712677,
0.22128932178020477,
0.014685176312923431,
0.06345676630735397,
-0.31895604729652405,
-0.5418354272842407,
0.22150740027427673,
0.32868704199790955,
-0.1752869188785553,
-0.17914468050003052,
0.812044620513916,
0.2189694046974182,
-0.2240518033504486,
0.48907971382141113,
0.11488807946443558,
-0.7020914554595947,
0.39945998787879944,
0.398223876953125,
0.7093307971954346,
-0.5624322295188904,
0.1228165552020073,
0.004244110081344843,
1.0466599464416504,
0.06241285428404808,
0.12456916272640228,
0.12726758420467377,
-1.1320387125015259,
-0.7999498844146729,
-0.39609384536743164,
-0.506001353263855,
0.0765254870057106,
-0.4534992575645447,
0.23607614636421204,
-0.37797418236732483,
-0.15165935456752777,
-0.07632512599229813,
-0.23412564396858215,
-0.6898004412651062,
0.15178512036800385,
0.25080427527427673,
0.889883816242218,
-1.0379477739334106,
0.8946216106414795,
0.7571896910667419,
-0.2721526622772217,
-0.6782843470573425,
-0.1550918072462082,
0.011765772476792336,
-0.7053613066673279,
0.6601824760437012,
-0.20427080988883972,
0.04768145829439163,
-0.021387092769145966,
-0.3733599781990051,
-0.7609969973564148,
0.7172216176986694,
0.5200341939926147,
-0.4486941993236542,
-0.04370066151022911,
0.5775014758110046,
0.6401491165161133,
-0.23801346123218536,
0.20014691352844238,
0.781123697757721,
0.7020373940467834,
-0.5271965861320496,
-1.5146340131759644,
-0.35770952701568604,
-0.24828782677650452,
0.09584662318229675,
0.047078631818294525,
-0.6361884474754333,
1.0836902856826782,
0.03854699060320854,
0.09943272173404694,
-0.023809071630239487,
0.5024550557136536,
0.09213738143444061,
0.04779357835650444,
0.4044345021247864,
0.8249890804290771,
0.7163856029510498,
-0.14173467457294464,
0.9048087000846863,
-0.4233357310295105,
0.14242635667324066,
1.0485517978668213,
-0.5055941343307495,
0.5711464285850525,
0.5192815065383911,
-0.15888236463069916,
0.413433700799942,
0.42994704842567444,
0.24867068231105804,
0.2229854315519333,
0.11170286685228348,
-0.10871509462594986,
-0.010334392078220844,
-0.40418025851249695,
-0.44580554962158203,
0.49799230694770813,
0.2637671232223511,
-0.1892227977514267,
-0.22657793760299683,
0.24779990315437317,
0.4410310387611389,
0.3383837342262268,
-0.3363727331161499,
0.4617970883846283,
0.016516046598553658,
-0.6207706332206726,
0.5521442294120789,
0.20083115994930267,
0.8787099719047546,
-0.6495583057403564,
0.07183192670345306,
-0.28071796894073486,
0.03141098842024803,
-0.22344841063022614,
-0.7965884804725647,
0.4266279339790344,
0.20637299120426178,
-0.009649061597883701,
-0.540219783782959,
0.6853066086769104,
-0.8376678824424744,
-0.4924050569534302,
0.8194300532341003,
0.8371681571006775,
-0.008525623008608818,
0.1346975415945053,
-0.8447878956794739,
0.39766451716423035,
-0.010765176266431808,
0.008711385540664196,
0.3646673858165741,
0.3758605718612671,
-0.1279873549938202,
0.5169141292572021,
0.5084483623504639,
0.3186279833316803,
0.5355806946754456,
0.05074450746178627,
0.594574511051178,
-0.5377375483512878,
-0.39513272047042847,
-0.7594248056411743,
0.7460998892784119,
-0.02649669535458088,
-0.5535456538200378,
0.9487921595573425,
0.4472842514514923,
1.325557827949524,
0.16169123351573944,
0.9319750666618347,
0.002099217614158988,
0.2403407096862793,
-0.5914174318313599,
0.7952794432640076,
-0.6918615698814392,
0.14071008563041687,
-0.3962368667125702,
-0.7721613645553589,
-0.4085518419742584,
0.2420952469110489,
-0.42194995284080505,
0.12109000235795975,
0.6323537230491638,
0.6549038290977478,
0.15984754264354706,
-0.21626195311546326,
0.5420546531677246,
0.41176363825798035,
0.2918085753917694,
0.3456870913505554,
0.9984037280082703,
-0.3813444972038269,
0.16701863706111908,
-0.4316881000995636,
-0.14767973124980927,
0.3443211317062378,
-0.8435652852058411,
-0.8730441331863403,
-0.3729347288608551,
-0.19857902824878693,
-0.2274974137544632,
0.43397486209869385,
0.6158424019813538,
0.5289425253868103,
-0.6302450895309448,
-0.6600891947746277,
0.24122796952724457,
0.43087393045425415,
-0.049926526844501495,
-0.20766755938529968,
0.15656669437885284,
-0.5239417552947998,
-1.009789228439331,
0.5050939917564392,
0.3474891185760498,
-0.04871392995119095,
-0.2951982021331787,
-0.07130881398916245,
-0.647425651550293,
0.15576881170272827,
0.5032001733779907,
0.2783950865268707,
-0.8036706447601318,
-0.0496797114610672,
-0.14012181758880615,
0.011156683787703514,
0.05857555568218231,
0.8350383639335632,
-0.387169748544693,
0.6531676650047302,
0.4458296000957489,
0.8879556655883789,
0.11998549848794937,
-0.058613475412130356,
0.9575576186180115,
-0.8493267297744751,
0.3701319396495819,
0.16872060298919678,
0.4413924217224121,
0.6486287713050842,
-0.1713690459728241,
0.5554717183113098,
0.3688490390777588,
-0.5868211984634399,
-0.9176533818244934,
-0.1149609386920929,
-0.32857564091682434,
-0.37224453687667847,
1.0041340589523315,
-0.16085389256477356,
-0.08280043303966522,
-0.05273886024951935,
0.03266811743378639,
0.30377545952796936,
0.14665375649929047,
0.5129022002220154,
1.1995127201080322,
-0.1708277016878128,
-0.17725594341754913,
-0.6878687143325806,
0.5906215310096741,
0.8610904216766357,
-0.6641431450843811,
-0.12674252688884735,
0.35636794567108154,
0.1656290739774704,
0.10119330883026123,
0.5537931323051453,
-0.2620718777179718,
0.1316949725151062,
-0.07479117810726166,
0.4729486405849457,
0.06540225446224213,
-0.3784753978252411,
-0.6090503931045532,
-0.1129099652171135,
0.1366836130619049,
0.2436663806438446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11132v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11132v1 | RePrompt: Planning by Automatic Prompt Engineering for Large Language Models Agents | 2024-06-17T01:23:11 | 2024-06-17T01:23:11 | Weizhe Chen, Sven Koenig, Bistra Dilkina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this past year, large language models (LLMs) have had remarkable success
in domains outside the traditional natural language processing, and people are
starting to explore the usage of LLMs in more general and close to application
domains like code generation, travel planning, and robot controls. Connecting
these LLMs with great capacity and external tools, people are building the
so-called LLM agents, which are supposed to help people do all kinds of work in
everyday life. In all these domains, the prompt to the LLMs has been shown to
make a big difference in what the LLM would generate and thus affect the
performance of the LLM agents. Therefore, automatic prompt engineering has
become an important question for many researchers and users of LLMs. In this
paper, we propose a novel method, \textsc{RePrompt}, which does "gradient
descent" to optimize the step-by-step instructions in the prompt of the LLM
agents based on the chat history obtained from interactions with LLM agents. By
optimizing the prompt, the LLM will learn how to plan in specific domains. We
have used experiments in PDDL generation and travel planning to show that our
method could generally improve the performance for different reasoning tasks
when using the updated prompt as the initial prompt. | [
-0.6240977048873901,
-0.5807255506515503,
0.6326479315757751,
0.32849302887916565,
-0.08751987665891647,
0.1515529900789261,
-0.3144366145133972,
-0.06034290790557861,
0.1417725682258606,
0.5820301175117493,
-1.1376523971557617,
-0.5493443012237549,
-0.09033551067113876,
0.25038155913352966,
0.10337953269481659,
0.596255362033844,
-0.25130695104599,
0.16456285119056702,
-0.02343877963721752,
0.02858424186706543,
-0.6067704558372498,
-0.4326101541519165,
-0.922081470489502,
-0.3697583079338074,
0.6826022863388062,
0.5169645547866821,
0.34605011343955994,
0.5001488924026489,
0.24724449217319489,
0.33307525515556335,
0.09870732575654984,
0.36372238397598267,
-0.43354952335357666,
0.48666679859161377,
-0.2877911925315857,
-0.48678699135780334,
-0.32436132431030273,
-0.06719571352005005,
0.6323441863059998,
0.5152900815010071,
-0.028446603566408157,
0.13156263530254364,
0.032142944633960724,
0.7469658851623535,
-0.44025200605392456,
0.21699674427509308,
-0.3946467638015747,
0.048177607357501984,
0.34362927079200745,
-0.7646549940109253,
-0.5971167087554932,
-0.31633827090263367,
-0.02409299463033676,
-0.47349488735198975,
0.14076170325279236,
0.26678088307380676,
0.41312769055366516,
0.3018129765987396,
-0.17873038351535797,
-0.14481577277183533,
-0.5876184105873108,
0.9273064136505127,
-0.5174725651741028,
0.33448901772499084,
0.07932936400175095,
0.5460518002510071,
-0.7319115400314331,
-0.7100334167480469,
-0.4770992696285248,
-0.5153135657310486,
0.03184380382299423,
-0.2258181869983673,
-0.012231863103806973,
0.26577243208885193,
0.4697645306587219,
-0.2581419050693512,
-0.7192299365997314,
0.3661758005619049,
0.03897006809711456,
-0.38507258892059326,
0.5303620100021362,
0.40533486008644104,
0.3773016631603241,
0.02278946526348591,
-0.5075811743736267,
-0.24400940537452698,
-0.8712581992149353,
0.029743239283561707,
0.3833480477333069,
0.5845679640769958,
0.03442259132862091,
0.6770143508911133,
-0.3643013834953308,
0.7801868915557861,
-0.02482028678059578,
-0.11877890676259995,
-0.08330169320106506,
-0.19658593833446503,
-0.15379945933818817,
-0.07577882707118988,
0.6358708739280701,
0.4442066252231598,
0.6008495092391968,
0.13359756767749786,
-0.3866342604160309,
-0.2562899887561798,
0.04219463840126991,
-0.9349132776260376,
-0.18993449211120605,
0.26604554057121277,
-0.3806033432483673,
-0.12360698729753494,
-0.42704635858535767,
-0.8797807693481445,
-0.6282406449317932,
-0.5365409255027771,
0.08467324078083038,
-0.4590998888015747,
0.0799279659986496,
-0.03392375260591507,
0.016097266227006912,
0.2508038580417633,
0.451874315738678,
-0.7110592126846313,
0.09117965400218964,
0.7389923334121704,
0.7533105611801147,
-0.047349393367767334,
-0.4596129357814789,
-0.931376039981842,
-0.2133622020483017,
-0.2737639248371124,
1.025882601737976,
-0.5938028693199158,
-0.5839739441871643,
0.2928778827190399,
-0.13029345870018005,
-0.02411065809428692,
-0.05954673886299133,
0.4708966910839081,
-0.8216061592102051,
0.36460691690444946,
-0.27999788522720337,
-0.44498834013938904,
-0.13896167278289795,
0.4444212317466736,
-0.49912095069885254,
0.4975242614746094,
0.14657559990882874,
-0.6030066013336182,
0.14870591461658478,
-0.6297486424446106,
-0.5038309693336487,
0.022076910361647606,
-0.2185782492160797,
-0.07853026688098907,
-0.33232855796813965,
0.4624241292476654,
0.41191500425338745,
-0.3830307424068451,
0.13131770491600037,
0.11174726486206055,
-0.12105634808540344,
0.29584938287734985,
-0.13805532455444336,
0.9088783264160156,
0.199221670627594,
-0.18471767008304596,
0.42447227239608765,
-0.6374326348304749,
0.09138356149196625,
-0.0742378681898117,
-0.41806164383888245,
-0.05788915231823921,
-0.012194625101983547,
-0.19392690062522888,
0.2617630958557129,
0.4351106882095337,
-0.31018173694610596,
0.5623356103897095,
-0.5516256093978882,
0.29118791222572327,
0.9630892276763916,
0.1233072578907013,
0.8642310500144958,
-0.4835667908191681,
0.9900351166725159,
-0.5059375762939453,
0.07121539860963821,
-0.56415194272995,
-0.42643240094184875,
-0.6005892753601074,
-0.28212490677833557,
0.15625114738941193,
0.6113869547843933,
-1.0020393133163452,
0.4920228123664856,
-0.027398157864809036,
-0.3729293942451477,
-0.010713358409702778,
-0.16015338897705078,
0.19823111593723297,
0.6713637113571167,
0.26667076349258423,
0.06195151433348656,
-0.606427788734436,
-0.7407028675079346,
-0.3442522883415222,
-0.3092852830886841,
-0.11661456525325775,
0.31803494691848755,
0.13467402756214142,
-0.24623212218284607,
1.0689412355422974,
-0.6508107781410217,
-0.169713094830513,
-0.6124318242073059,
0.265171617269516,
0.2877848446369171,
0.4254743754863739,
0.49326854944229126,
-0.5237409472465515,
-0.48858126997947693,
-0.1880313754081726,
-0.17192627489566803,
-0.5528249144554138,
-0.40956297516822815,
-0.3667333126068115,
0.4931783378124237,
0.540139377117157,
-0.8014848232269287,
0.17170283198356628,
0.44092652201652527,
-0.33324718475341797,
0.8772172927856445,
-0.27999362349510193,
0.1402669996023178,
-0.9631272554397583,
0.06579890847206116,
0.12131009250879288,
-0.2577124238014221,
-0.5279197096824646,
0.085607148706913,
0.06392883509397507,
-0.24307283759117126,
-0.3543776869773865,
0.8867175579071045,
-0.6178379058837891,
-0.04483899474143982,
-0.47971129417419434,
0.22005809843540192,
-0.11495576053857803,
0.7629337310791016,
-0.11392256617546082,
0.8941352963447571,
0.40959906578063965,
-0.7507847547531128,
0.4889897406101227,
0.24376501142978668,
-0.1583544760942459,
0.48731911182403564,
-0.3527560532093048,
0.13075049221515656,
-0.12134118378162384,
0.5370653867721558,
-1.3107147216796875,
-0.11882586032152176,
0.45207613706588745,
-0.5362630486488342,
0.44589605927467346,
-0.2709381580352783,
-0.4002514183521271,
-0.3853243291378021,
-0.28222203254699707,
0.18593443930149078,
0.5128219723701477,
-0.686819851398468,
0.9635506272315979,
0.2966752350330353,
-0.43090519309043884,
-0.5763043165206909,
-0.4203021824359894,
0.11422999948263168,
-0.17845484614372253,
-0.6938334703445435,
0.23854026198387146,
-0.1590328961610794,
-0.2489999681711197,
-0.38147059082984924,
0.13775408267974854,
0.10890287905931473,
-0.078569196164608,
0.16990293562412262,
0.3160507082939148,
0.0007684092852286994,
0.1338665634393692,
-0.01031455397605896,
-0.44052836298942566,
0.16946867108345032,
-0.37856921553611755,
1.2439333200454712,
0.2791781723499298,
-0.24965260922908783,
-0.7113381028175354,
0.18430496752262115,
0.4158014953136444,
-0.23167377710342407,
0.5087282657623291,
0.1916033774614334,
0.020294729620218277,
-0.7075821161270142,
-0.4891413152217865,
-0.4273996651172638,
-0.5517565608024597,
0.28452277183532715,
-0.32344958186149597,
-0.7312179803848267,
0.6230393648147583,
-0.425611287355423,
0.36507999897003174,
0.16386358439922333,
0.5173280835151672,
0.10414839535951614,
0.9818298816680908,
0.7557267546653748,
-0.12521564960479736,
0.7856032848358154,
-0.24120686948299408,
0.0369839072227478,
-0.7571540474891663,
-0.027037302032113075,
-0.6895726323127747,
-0.609283447265625,
-0.5937517285346985,
-0.6085825562477112,
0.07882574945688248,
-0.3110977113246918,
-0.4906170666217804,
0.48956966400146484,
-0.49629831314086914,
0.39001011848449707,
0.6342669129371643,
-0.23352134227752686,
0.25953391194343567,
0.1317443549633026,
-0.3365973234176636,
0.019976967945694923,
-0.6963739395141602,
-0.5973163843154907,
0.8433942794799805,
0.2822507321834564,
0.9402472376823425,
-0.41720885038375854,
0.8192048668861389,
0.15580208599567413,
0.3102547228336334,
-0.7798494100570679,
1.0018324851989746,
0.3742470145225525,
-0.09848112612962723,
-0.5435295701026917,
-0.5557262301445007,
-1.1446317434310913,
0.15314804017543793,
0.10724042356014252,
-0.6778620481491089,
0.38283640146255493,
0.10231221467256546,
-0.26056087017059326,
0.0882977545261383,
-0.567267894744873,
0.5220611095428467,
-0.21634069085121155,
0.0016291270731016994,
-0.28342440724372864,
-0.6113952994346619,
0.11770693212747574,
0.014078006148338318,
0.09434182941913605,
-0.14380790293216705,
-0.2671200931072235,
0.6695044636726379,
-0.35341203212738037,
0.737430214881897,
-0.4235399067401886,
-0.22363637387752533,
0.2807672321796417,
0.5220711827278137,
1.032760500907898,
-0.07021389156579971,
-0.20821185410022736,
-0.09306162595748901,
-0.44192269444465637,
-0.03994220122694969,
-0.7225300073623657,
0.8097912073135376,
-0.4896754324436188,
-0.6872450709342957,
-0.12381786108016968,
-0.6296297311782837,
-0.2625266909599304,
0.29929760098457336,
0.06463974714279175,
0.511488676071167,
-0.08866456896066666,
-0.4929954409599304,
0.19817249476909637,
-0.6671856045722961,
0.7298212647438049,
0.7751724720001221,
-0.4692271649837494,
-0.5267040729522705,
0.668148398399353,
-0.013122845441102982,
0.194524884223938,
0.6090022921562195,
0.12409745156764984,
-0.4206750988960266,
-0.510444164276123,
-0.26925691962242126,
0.3806462287902832,
-0.8476684093475342,
-0.27682799100875854,
-0.5124030113220215,
-0.09728821367025375,
-0.368279367685318,
-0.4243604242801666,
-0.2543163597583771,
-0.6033039093017578,
-0.24920988082885742,
-0.025653788819909096,
0.23170042037963867,
0.2698301076889038,
-0.14985883235931396,
0.38988080620765686,
-0.646696150302887,
0.2637615203857422,
0.19611267745494843,
0.06178034096956253,
-0.08758556842803955,
-0.4749881327152252,
-0.001261914148926735,
0.10082642734050751,
-0.3170176148414612,
-0.5717429518699646,
0.815579891204834,
-0.22199104726314545,
0.7645764946937561,
0.19704866409301758,
0.36022868752479553,
0.40029072761535645,
-0.7258699536323547,
0.6437720656394958,
0.0584377758204937,
-0.5452293753623962,
0.5741211175918579,
-0.3607163429260254,
0.13954490423202515,
0.4355756640434265,
0.3180225193500519,
-0.5806423425674438,
-0.28152158856391907,
-0.4506329298019409,
-0.8202152252197266,
0.6312239766120911,
0.10824114829301834,
0.0072523485869169235,
0.06331820040941238,
0.37525516748428345,
0.0889681950211525,
0.2461978793144226,
-0.37628307938575745,
-0.24451440572738647,
0.30209076404571533,
-0.08183159679174423,
-0.09385740756988525,
-0.2513551115989685,
-0.2406141310930252,
-0.02781551145017147,
0.5217986702919006,
-0.24102921783924103,
0.3945956826210022,
0.2681056261062622,
0.0007383640040643513,
-0.3121064603328705,
0.07770440727472305,
0.8579379916191101,
0.9198954701423645,
0.010515622794628143,
0.008643941953778267,
-0.000799493514932692,
-0.24183599650859833,
0.29243946075439453,
0.19529402256011963,
-0.07921503484249115,
-0.11419855058193207,
0.3518674671649933,
0.5017808079719543,
-0.06354918330907822,
-0.7895111441612244,
0.2971276044845581,
-0.19486385583877563,
-0.043417900800704956,
-0.3310699164867401,
0.1747179925441742,
-0.12957437336444855,
0.5963371396064758,
0.3683418035507202,
0.014898004941642284,
-0.11583581566810608,
-0.28910860419273376,
0.14510971307754517,
0.3495040535926819,
-0.11060590296983719,
-0.08831774443387985,
0.43626928329467773,
0.454863578081131,
-0.933648943901062,
0.6611874103546143,
-0.07550611346960068,
-0.6568514108657837,
0.6790875196456909,
0.45844992995262146,
1.1421679258346558,
-0.3422785699367523,
0.3691721558570862,
0.4262082278728485,
0.23444540798664093,
-0.09664489328861237,
0.26096972823143005,
-0.04247544705867767,
-0.791661262512207,
-0.8038479089736938,
-0.45639824867248535,
-0.4504186511039734,
-0.21624453365802765,
-0.11809935420751572,
0.3922196328639984,
-0.45029711723327637,
-0.14135494828224182,
-0.5218760967254639,
0.13694870471954346,
-0.5674030184745789,
-0.07681366801261902,
0.061006586998701096,
1.1047157049179077,
-0.37694382667541504,
0.5285527110099792,
0.6938887238502502,
-0.14775952696800232,
-0.7458881735801697,
0.17489410936832428,
-0.27948805689811707,
-1.1179635524749756,
0.9041534066200256,
0.2586158215999603,
-0.12412853538990021,
0.3169315457344055,
-0.6762070655822754,
-0.7598463296890259,
1.012177586555481,
0.483268141746521,
-0.9408379197120667,
-0.09567893296480179,
0.07639801502227783,
0.42510369420051575,
-0.5464791059494019,
0.03588800132274628,
0.4887552261352539,
0.5763832330703735,
0.28907865285873413,
-0.7271173596382141,
0.33818650245666504,
0.001047248370014131,
-0.008058625273406506,
0.2896080017089844,
-0.5574227571487427,
0.8111065030097961,
-0.4243297576904297,
-0.4583926498889923,
0.28334906697273254,
0.5038071274757385,
0.7185518741607666,
0.2218133956193924,
0.5618833899497986,
0.22040414810180664,
0.8185541033744812,
0.16489316523075104,
1.2155247926712036,
-0.621157705783844,
0.2435915619134903,
1.1220533847808838,
-0.2843748927116394,
0.5774455070495605,
0.46699053049087524,
-0.10677160322666168,
0.4129088521003723,
0.720490038394928,
0.13253521919250488,
0.6275117993354797,
0.46550342440605164,
-0.20445583760738373,
-0.29426315426826477,
0.0766778290271759,
-0.11994382739067078,
-0.06259028613567352,
0.20812039077281952,
-0.32336071133613586,
-0.3500062823295593,
0.19062542915344238,
-0.03453081473708153,
0.03340112045407295,
-0.32270097732543945,
0.5416571497917175,
0.17440932989120483,
-0.8781245946884155,
0.5467836856842041,
-0.01861693151295185,
0.3777090013027191,
-0.38172081112861633,
0.048895906656980515,
-0.40888261795043945,
0.04791557788848877,
0.10515838861465454,
-0.8344048857688904,
-0.17397946119308472,
-0.22236496210098267,
0.15108689665794373,
-0.4560239613056183,
0.7778688669204712,
-0.25349387526512146,
-0.206810861825943,
0.28544557094573975,
0.4553193747997284,
0.052709393203258514,
-0.2566872239112854,
-0.6267687082290649,
-0.06249367073178291,
0.013958769850432873,
-0.5354864001274109,
0.196391761302948,
0.5852271914482117,
0.11085276305675507,
1.2666468620300293,
0.7228005528450012,
0.17374083399772644,
-0.09709479659795761,
0.13336895406246185,
1.155398964881897,
-0.8920527100563049,
-0.713136613368988,
-1.0861822366714478,
0.5604832172393799,
-0.0942964032292366,
-0.07126691937446594,
0.6250449419021606,
0.4152999520301819,
0.42021238803863525,
0.02944176457822323,
0.7304071187973022,
0.18802860379219055,
0.5824882388114929,
-0.6056811809539795,
0.4499998986721039,
-0.2784489691257477,
0.5100012421607971,
-0.13519057631492615,
-1.148432731628418,
-0.35583391785621643,
0.7051131725311279,
-0.5019141435623169,
0.012876717373728752,
0.7308867573738098,
1.00184166431427,
0.4582228362560272,
-0.22429268062114716,
0.17055408656597137,
0.04769906401634216,
0.7224689722061157,
0.49267643690109253,
1.1515302658081055,
0.09438037127256393,
0.5020478367805481,
-0.11577510088682175,
-0.24416887760162354,
-0.36766523122787476,
-0.831071674823761,
-1.2376312017440796,
-0.4836955964565277,
-0.15573342144489288,
-0.21250705420970917,
-0.09228131175041199,
1.2058634757995605,
0.3496059477329254,
-0.49304983019828796,
-0.2896116375923157,
-0.46553853154182434,
0.3393055498600006,
0.10836444050073624,
-0.2258409559726715,
0.33995792269706726,
-0.7556320428848267,
-0.6738612651824951,
0.5959583520889282,
0.2802056670188904,
0.1741185486316681,
-0.5392928719520569,
-0.2984302043914795,
-0.03505616635084152,
0.05363229289650917,
0.4575268030166626,
0.3951387107372284,
-0.34367623925209045,
-0.20691139996051788,
-0.059632688760757446,
-0.2512125074863434,
0.12308961153030396,
1.1166753768920898,
-0.8797701597213745,
0.30930095911026,
0.9040866494178772,
0.43489640951156616,
0.2255505621433258,
0.2067154347896576,
1.1029493808746338,
-0.6038526296615601,
0.2456936538219452,
0.4767664074897766,
0.40078961849212646,
0.1417182981967926,
-0.31372684240341187,
0.4440201222896576,
-0.034141905605793,
-0.9582147002220154,
-0.8254197239875793,
0.3135581612586975,
-0.8956214785575867,
-0.329215943813324,
1.4261345863342285,
0.061056315898895264,
-0.3368779122829437,
-0.08848830312490463,
-0.8456574082374573,
0.20853282511234283,
-0.6393581628799438,
0.7714038491249084,
0.3600301444530487,
-0.37898388504981995,
-0.3104148209095001,
-0.39840489625930786,
0.5913169980049133,
0.027994707226753235,
-0.6774579286575317,
0.38376790285110474,
0.5430638790130615,
0.1533392071723938,
0.15304288268089294,
0.7681729793548584,
0.29284927248954773,
0.06384734064340591,
-0.2868819236755371,
0.2426299750804901,
-0.19754505157470703,
-0.41885432600975037,
-0.1689445674419403,
0.2456021010875702,
0.07073909044265747,
-0.23908938467502594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11131v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11131v2 | Are Large Language Models a Good Replacement of Taxonomies? | 2024-06-17T01:21:50 | 2024-06-20T08:01:14 | Yushi Sun, Hao Xin, Kai Sun, Yifan Ethan Xu, Xiao Yang, Xin Luna Dong, Nan Tang, Lei Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB | Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate an impressive ability to internalize
knowledge and answer natural language questions. Although previous studies
validate that LLMs perform well on general knowledge while presenting poor
performance on long-tail nuanced knowledge, the community is still doubtful
about whether the traditional knowledge graphs should be replaced by LLMs. In
this paper, we ask if the schema of knowledge graph (i.e., taxonomy) is made
obsolete by LLMs. Intuitively, LLMs should perform well on common taxonomies
and at taxonomy levels that are common to people. Unfortunately, there lacks a
comprehensive benchmark that evaluates the LLMs over a wide range of taxonomies
from common to specialized domains and at levels from root to leaf so that we
can draw a confident conclusion. To narrow the research gap, we constructed a
novel taxonomy hierarchical structure discovery benchmark named TaxoGlimpse to
evaluate the performance of LLMs over taxonomies. TaxoGlimpse covers ten
representative taxonomies from common to specialized domains with in-depth
experiments of different levels of entities in this taxonomy from root to leaf.
Our comprehensive experiments of eighteen state-of-the-art LLMs under three
prompting settings validate that LLMs can still not well capture the knowledge
of specialized taxonomies and leaf-level entities. | [
-0.30979496240615845,
-0.6377136707305908,
0.5380215644836426,
-0.16648122668266296,
-0.393323689699173,
0.3787720799446106,
-0.3736402690410614,
-0.6182376742362976,
0.2841249108314514,
0.4167537987232208,
-0.10975636541843414,
-0.5202377438545227,
-0.6486044526100159,
0.19229327142238617,
-0.423951119184494,
0.48792433738708496,
-0.03789417818188667,
-0.002205488970503211,
-0.6159541010856628,
-0.24035201966762543,
-0.26241886615753174,
-0.5484803318977356,
-0.5783135294914246,
-0.570048451423645,
0.6509415507316589,
-0.0018003028817474842,
0.5735726952552795,
0.7904552221298218,
0.38419994711875916,
0.2661057114601135,
-0.5648878216743469,
0.11730912327766418,
-0.535119891166687,
0.047609034925699234,
-0.2232612520456314,
-0.2949591875076294,
-0.5208700895309448,
-0.23363029956817627,
0.7687799334526062,
1.1625546216964722,
-0.42031538486480713,
0.10643123835325241,
0.23648589849472046,
0.4915490746498108,
-0.4792569577693939,
0.48926103115081787,
-0.9274914264678955,
-0.3101980984210968,
-0.4034823179244995,
-0.27390146255493164,
-0.4862339198589325,
-0.40200188755989075,
0.22989551723003387,
-0.6416719555854797,
0.06907804310321808,
0.1812712848186493,
0.6408822536468506,
0.2582155764102936,
-0.6460090279579163,
-0.38408607244491577,
-0.6922476887702942,
0.6628144979476929,
-0.8849663734436035,
0.4494868814945221,
0.2071664035320282,
0.23149819672107697,
-0.2710834741592407,
-0.6803853511810303,
-0.23563240468502045,
0.01538311317563057,
-0.24563509225845337,
-0.12245669960975647,
-0.616162121295929,
0.07308295369148254,
0.23772704601287842,
0.32452914118766785,
-0.46759358048439026,
0.5315940976142883,
-0.07883796840906143,
-0.25384971499443054,
0.2341112345457077,
0.3115030825138092,
0.40717166662216187,
-0.48088252544403076,
-0.3313346803188324,
0.0985426977276802,
-1.1323697566986084,
-0.06341423839330673,
0.2547948956489563,
0.42076924443244934,
0.3502095937728882,
0.38955122232437134,
-0.12322801351547241,
0.9136302471160889,
-0.5138437747955322,
-0.5223750472068787,
0.48736464977264404,
-0.05309506505727768,
-0.40458959341049194,
-0.059563830494880676,
0.5707464218139648,
0.4208502173423767,
0.43527939915657043,
-0.3379175662994385,
-0.27516889572143555,
0.02070559561252594,
-0.03417107090353966,
-0.5877496004104614,
0.0014292600098997355,
0.07671023905277252,
-0.2077694535255432,
0.10820364207029343,
-0.4456622302532196,
-0.6356555223464966,
-0.39208200573921204,
-0.28966763615608215,
0.13757744431495667,
-0.43678760528564453,
-0.5034696459770203,
0.2862370014190674,
-0.11921067535877228,
0.12262760102748871,
0.6242521405220032,
-0.7860016822814941,
0.5314987897872925,
1.04628586769104,
0.8079957962036133,
-0.18592144548892975,
-0.27161693572998047,
-0.09638173878192902,
0.2598789930343628,
-0.48731955885887146,
0.7954586148262024,
-0.6724318265914917,
-0.27554750442504883,
0.05317787453532219,
-0.06861083954572678,
-0.037877149879932404,
-0.9348294138908386,
0.22050362825393677,
-0.740451455116272,
0.02289016917347908,
-0.3265960216522217,
-0.9214012622833252,
-0.20788095891475677,
0.38087326288223267,
-0.6515512466430664,
0.6735586524009705,
0.24840836226940155,
-0.7413861751556396,
0.5296236872673035,
-0.17304043471813202,
-0.30368754267692566,
0.47179996967315674,
0.038562092930078506,
-0.12944862246513367,
-0.1957215517759323,
-0.12475886940956116,
0.40916943550109863,
-0.6073214411735535,
0.7199656963348389,
-0.3825428783893585,
-0.4461769163608551,
-0.24515560269355774,
-0.05658192187547684,
0.8773120641708374,
0.06880349665880203,
0.02751409076154232,
-0.2595871388912201,
-0.6371929049491882,
0.06153077632188797,
-0.03481096401810646,
-0.2572648227214813,
-0.81175696849823,
0.23982906341552734,
-0.35147330164909363,
-0.09561006724834442,
0.09591442346572876,
-0.42722734808921814,
0.5714823603630066,
-0.4733645021915436,
0.8106585144996643,
0.6942955255508423,
0.09490756690502167,
0.5432295203208923,
-0.16488797962665558,
0.6030452847480774,
-0.1833585649728775,
-0.07868535071611404,
0.1654636710882187,
-0.5622188448905945,
-0.4777309000492096,
-0.37594008445739746,
0.38726237416267395,
0.18613219261169434,
-0.6500017046928406,
0.2752712368965149,
-0.6572169065475464,
-0.6068112850189209,
-0.04890359938144684,
0.0691186860203743,
0.09887787699699402,
0.4343653917312622,
0.21673189103603363,
-0.40321436524391174,
-0.45994436740875244,
-0.8768381476402283,
-0.2447853535413742,
-0.3577236235141754,
-0.1312703639268875,
0.3722175657749176,
0.6061614751815796,
-0.22439569234848022,
0.8832040429115295,
-0.48800399899482727,
-0.17156273126602173,
-0.15172527730464935,
-0.005037388298660517,
0.1743210256099701,
0.0004005211521871388,
0.5611470341682434,
-0.28930410742759705,
-0.18603764474391937,
-0.11932853609323502,
-0.4688006043434143,
-0.08718511462211609,
0.2961811125278473,
0.2175600677728653,
0.13876408338546753,
0.2872934639453888,
-0.8774323463439941,
0.047289036214351654,
0.44257086515426636,
-0.05977629870176315,
0.4454832375049591,
0.0822308212518692,
-0.2079576849937439,
-0.8081973791122437,
0.1717752069234848,
-0.04141134396195412,
-0.1192522794008255,
-0.6537370681762695,
0.23749245703220367,
0.11149287968873978,
0.11835239082574844,
-0.3896000385284424,
0.8227713108062744,
-0.39935845136642456,
-0.43494075536727905,
0.13212738931179047,
0.19021888077259064,
-0.05043283477425575,
0.2707419693470001,
-0.07422178238630295,
0.7613857984542847,
0.8408681154251099,
-0.7150236964225769,
0.27312201261520386,
0.22383953630924225,
-0.7452274560928345,
0.38143280148506165,
-0.5112767219543457,
-0.11906596273183823,
-0.3026945888996124,
0.5071609020233154,
-0.7827571630477905,
-0.3682844638824463,
0.17578406631946564,
-0.18014675378799438,
0.2858399748802185,
-0.2656608521938324,
-0.7969082593917847,
-0.4671037793159485,
-0.07372141629457474,
0.249845489859581,
0.5555903315544128,
-0.4540170431137085,
0.5983749628067017,
0.44680362939834595,
-0.09655069559812546,
-0.42957067489624023,
-0.47385725378990173,
0.39798465371131897,
-0.41867661476135254,
-0.533871054649353,
0.07798217236995697,
0.20635922253131866,
-0.4357629418373108,
0.03026494011282921,
-0.19232633709907532,
0.10292072594165802,
0.3785228431224823,
-0.035680871456861496,
0.1664944440126419,
-0.29869571328163147,
0.7107017636299133,
-0.4219716787338257,
0.12387695908546448,
0.14793573319911957,
-0.18837521970272064,
0.8846714496612549,
0.06723486632108688,
-0.18413236737251282,
0.026491718366742134,
-0.05821961909532547,
0.6624680757522583,
-0.3986371159553528,
0.567184567451477,
-0.11343067139387131,
-0.6308945417404175,
-0.2519008219242096,
-0.555722713470459,
0.10993596166372299,
-0.4118751287460327,
0.298843652009964,
-0.3312017619609833,
-1.0402008295059204,
0.5732088088989258,
-0.26262474060058594,
-0.06775771826505661,
0.5549523830413818,
0.28467363119125366,
0.06792306154966354,
0.7159250378608704,
0.3295215964317322,
-0.08474848419427872,
0.14824044704437256,
-0.3074803650379181,
0.42461612820625305,
-0.9219201803207397,
-0.3247092664241791,
-0.6544771790504456,
0.01949029229581356,
-0.6542890667915344,
-0.31546860933303833,
0.3996671140193939,
0.16327698528766632,
-0.38192346692085266,
0.2986542284488678,
-0.27262166142463684,
0.3221157491207123,
0.4163780212402344,
-0.1278514415025711,
0.5183228254318237,
-0.06905259191989899,
0.25248411297798157,
0.1559305638074875,
-0.8293633460998535,
-0.6552901864051819,
0.9684884548187256,
0.26553985476493835,
0.9005828499794006,
0.09062663465738297,
0.7851095795631409,
0.006063368171453476,
0.4955146908760071,
-1.0132880210876465,
0.6799545288085938,
-0.2790847718715668,
-0.5078622102737427,
-0.48647627234458923,
-0.6734457612037659,
-1.1157712936401367,
0.2889131009578705,
0.21865563094615936,
-0.9136191010475159,
0.01392589882016182,
0.07222403585910797,
-0.18737073242664337,
0.6089457869529724,
-0.5382073521614075,
0.7002910375595093,
-0.12932457029819489,
-0.020013747736811638,
-0.10933685302734375,
-0.3347749710083008,
0.6194473505020142,
-0.3045125901699066,
0.3855414092540741,
-0.18337757885456085,
-0.03783949837088585,
0.9675859808921814,
-0.5216381549835205,
0.8443588614463806,
-0.04821551963686943,
-0.3634916841983795,
0.31267616152763367,
0.3082953095436096,
0.4255671501159668,
-0.37320268154144287,
-0.12140735983848572,
0.08495033532381058,
0.0012730775633826852,
-0.1215071752667427,
-0.7164804339408875,
0.6646707653999329,
-0.6327219605445862,
-0.997231125831604,
-0.4634269177913666,
-0.3455866873264313,
-0.6103084087371826,
0.22591911256313324,
-0.1864812672138214,
0.5466918349266052,
-0.09726375341415405,
0.37463217973709106,
0.4503517150878906,
-0.07835055887699127,
0.0667995810508728,
0.29760968685150146,
-0.2612876892089844,
-0.19788819551467896,
0.768524169921875,
0.27432724833488464,
0.5046846270561218,
0.2728610932826996,
0.3661097288131714,
-0.3599536716938019,
-0.6141750812530518,
-0.29676634073257446,
0.34771648049354553,
-0.8220317363739014,
-0.5810315608978271,
-0.8218088150024414,
-0.23988230526447296,
-0.34578990936279297,
0.11605960130691528,
-0.029016390442848206,
-0.21894781291484833,
-0.2958225607872009,
-0.04904501885175705,
0.38337692618370056,
0.8920367360115051,
0.2529313266277313,
0.2056066393852234,
-0.6580456495285034,
0.0470024012029171,
0.4112539291381836,
0.4853755235671997,
0.44478046894073486,
-0.46635839343070984,
-0.030301300808787346,
0.05378812178969383,
0.09386473149061203,
-0.5138015151023865,
0.19669167697429657,
0.14697213470935822,
0.7375428080558777,
0.23001565039157867,
-0.1597013622522354,
0.7341635823249817,
-0.561214804649353,
0.7619210481643677,
0.2892349064350128,
-1.0047156810760498,
0.12241861969232559,
-0.41240161657333374,
0.4486747682094574,
0.17228111624717712,
0.4653213918209076,
-0.7890803217887878,
-0.5935235023498535,
-0.6407955288887024,
-0.7818717956542969,
0.3883965015411377,
-0.17214854061603546,
0.1411515772342682,
0.02020290307700634,
0.2877434492111206,
0.13996794819831848,
0.48279377818107605,
-0.57645583152771,
-0.1918255090713501,
-0.006696109659969807,
0.15927742421627045,
-0.21729256212711334,
-0.3030613362789154,
-0.006509517785161734,
-0.2764515280723572,
0.42442458868026733,
-0.05666433274745941,
-0.06979596614837646,
-0.2407405823469162,
0.13829579949378967,
-0.3441149592399597,
0.49092888832092285,
0.10888317972421646,
1.2193701267242432,
-0.2642042934894562,
0.42746737599372864,
0.07577162235975266,
-0.07597128301858902,
0.10186883807182312,
-0.24651455879211426,
-0.3222978115081787,
-0.08115863054990768,
0.7064679265022278,
0.6606316566467285,
0.4349006712436676,
-0.6168822050094604,
0.33272916078567505,
0.4425755441188812,
-0.28541409969329834,
-0.09099064767360687,
0.14165732264518738,
0.5545199513435364,
0.08517621457576752,
0.40865951776504517,
-0.0011935335351154208,
-0.04172298684716225,
-1.1233433485031128,
0.08723904937505722,
0.6938996315002441,
0.15039639174938202,
-0.06849522143602371,
0.44226428866386414,
0.0036849924363195896,
-0.3487868309020996,
0.4655681252479553,
-0.15190833806991577,
-0.819855272769928,
0.5188895463943481,
0.4956977367401123,
0.3983631730079651,
-0.16718749701976776,
0.44254550337791443,
0.42182204127311707,
0.3917851150035858,
-0.27092400193214417,
-0.11970475316047668,
0.2625473737716675,
-0.8185818195343018,
-0.492753267288208,
-0.6791011691093445,
-0.41337716579437256,
0.26401302218437195,
-0.4922918677330017,
0.16384488344192505,
-0.3499554693698883,
-0.04906533658504486,
0.021282250061631203,
-0.0840916857123375,
-0.6653439402580261,
0.34309694170951843,
0.12468396127223969,
1.2569530010223389,
-0.6505399346351624,
0.7822215557098389,
0.39244386553764343,
-0.2497461885213852,
-0.9038001894950867,
-0.17124222218990326,
-0.052187636494636536,
-0.9488241672515869,
0.6826417446136475,
-0.059593986719846725,
-0.20118533074855804,
-0.035623978823423386,
-0.6751149892807007,
-1.1607047319412231,
1.2370822429656982,
0.18762220442295074,
-0.7445984482765198,
-0.3245353400707245,
0.22883307933807373,
0.9350134134292603,
-0.34607139229774475,
0.05289827287197113,
0.4782162010669708,
0.4341927468776703,
0.43842813372612,
-0.9271435737609863,
0.08935818076133728,
0.24005775153636932,
0.12245001643896103,
0.43420061469078064,
-0.6248214840888977,
1.015467643737793,
0.045987568795681,
-0.452300488948822,
0.14621224999427795,
0.1774548441171646,
0.10858839750289917,
0.18203923106193542,
0.6875449419021606,
0.7250241637229919,
0.9743682742118835,
-0.10777492821216583,
0.7858989834785461,
-0.21471597254276276,
0.5735809206962585,
1.136422872543335,
-0.7115066051483154,
0.9320845007896423,
0.44030141830444336,
-0.3487340211868286,
0.38889551162719727,
0.6709322333335876,
-0.03275584802031517,
0.3315017521381378,
0.5954970717430115,
0.007643148303031921,
-0.5862461924552917,
-0.13728724420070648,
-0.48492056131362915,
0.4479651153087616,
0.5010265707969666,
-0.051819272339344025,
-0.6022819876670837,
-0.24594439566135406,
0.1631735861301422,
-0.09431786090135574,
-0.36148399114608765,
0.6555055975914001,
0.08954766392707825,
-0.6348414421081543,
0.8996462821960449,
-0.18641255795955658,
0.4237114191055298,
-0.8538069128990173,
0.05546946823596954,
-0.412863552570343,
-0.19409134984016418,
-0.14553409814834595,
-0.9405941367149353,
0.06663325428962708,
-0.09103696048259735,
0.3652784824371338,
-0.4305087924003601,
0.7474542260169983,
-0.25971391797065735,
-0.31359732151031494,
0.5205828547477722,
0.8853445649147034,
0.09445595741271973,
0.033006519079208374,
-0.2102021425962448,
0.044059086591005325,
-0.21255673468112946,
-0.21441833674907684,
0.24542807042598724,
0.5455169081687927,
0.052629049867391586,
1.052108645439148,
0.3934074640274048,
0.20485439896583557,
-0.15879051387310028,
0.17880479991436005,
1.0019183158874512,
-0.49133962392807007,
-0.15016096830368042,
-0.686549723148346,
0.0723949745297432,
0.02219461090862751,
-0.18885236978530884,
0.8560585379600525,
0.7632067203521729,
0.9719246029853821,
0.13189727067947388,
0.6206119656562805,
0.0226607583463192,
0.6282400488853455,
-0.629996657371521,
0.4505867660045624,
-0.899749755859375,
0.42028123140335083,
-0.3921187222003937,
-1.1609114408493042,
-0.5016909241676331,
0.11311366409063339,
-0.42020127177238464,
-0.02196401171386242,
0.7996708154678345,
0.6702325940132141,
-0.10515674948692322,
0.021177340298891068,
0.5278355479240417,
0.4635712504386902,
0.3251107931137085,
0.45181193947792053,
0.9804040193557739,
0.08048849552869797,
0.5201008915901184,
0.1142396330833435,
-0.12912620604038239,
-0.10798105597496033,
-0.6873236298561096,
-0.6332874298095703,
-0.677200198173523,
-0.16099533438682556,
-0.2559483051300049,
0.14343467354774475,
0.7292515635490417,
0.29998496174812317,
-0.4982067346572876,
-0.3566015064716339,
-0.007406881079077721,
0.22502602636814117,
0.07515475898981094,
-0.23336276412010193,
0.3517944812774658,
-0.1497933268547058,
-0.49750635027885437,
0.10351649671792984,
0.3085271418094635,
0.004020154010504484,
-0.45891281962394714,
0.09903142601251602,
-0.1083693578839302,
-0.1352204829454422,
0.7221470475196838,
0.12790550291538239,
-1.0369515419006348,
-0.632773756980896,
0.024821989238262177,
-0.093403160572052,
0.2346068173646927,
0.9529415965080261,
-0.8124452829360962,
0.18859438598155975,
0.32582271099090576,
0.4237113893032074,
0.32243189215660095,
-0.19363921880722046,
0.2610276937484741,
-0.3374342620372772,
-0.2511279284954071,
0.293720543384552,
0.7264885306358337,
0.4156067371368408,
0.054956041276454926,
0.5765396952629089,
0.3932932913303375,
-0.3908067047595978,
-0.870872974395752,
0.22943666577339172,
-0.9263865947723389,
-0.3699270486831665,
1.4945883750915527,
-0.027447951957583427,
-0.4234004616737366,
-0.07623220980167389,
0.10500973463058472,
-0.06424831598997116,
-0.2607190012931824,
0.6706076264381409,
0.8568559288978577,
0.1359649896621704,
-0.13733017444610596,
-0.35364213585853577,
0.44805416464805603,
0.08430787175893784,
-0.8171786665916443,
0.3670569062232971,
0.6474417448043823,
0.5614206194877625,
0.2813810408115387,
0.8139365911483765,
0.09751538932323456,
-0.15777356922626495,
-0.22348301112651825,
-0.03523356840014458,
0.22920115292072296,
-0.2515793442726135,
-0.0380031019449234,
0.13051918148994446,
0.3795349597930908,
0.2850135862827301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11130v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11130v1 | Dynamic Order Template Prediction for Generative Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis | 2024-06-17T01:21:28 | 2024-06-17T01:21:28 | Yonghyun Jun, Hwanhee Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect-based sentiment analysis (ABSA) assesses sentiments towards specific
aspects within texts, resulting in detailed sentiment tuples. Previous ABSA
models often use static templates to predict all of the elements in the tuples,
and these models often fail to accurately capture dependencies between
elements. Multi-view prompting method improves the performance of ABSA by
predicting tuples with various templates and then ensembling the results.
However, this method suffers from inefficiencies and out-of-distribution
errors. In this paper, we propose a Dynamic Order Template (DOT) method for
ABSA, which dynamically generates necessary views for each instance based on
instance-level entropy. Ensuring the diverse and relevant view generation, our
proposed method improves F1-scores on ASQP and ACOS datasets while
significantly reducing inference time. | [
-0.5499736070632935,
-0.6795811653137207,
0.5886235237121582,
0.2694815695285797,
-0.6415035128593445,
0.2216533124446869,
0.3557232618331909,
-0.3471335470676422,
0.5630437731742859,
0.08911234140396118,
-0.5044990181922913,
-0.572191059589386,
-0.4583452343940735,
0.09574506431818008,
-0.2511918544769287,
0.5414573550224304,
0.14703425765037537,
-0.02184244804084301,
-0.26564234495162964,
-0.1228211522102356,
-0.3065349757671356,
-0.5088200569152832,
-0.39041203260421753,
0.04018788784742355,
0.4884980618953705,
0.47529932856559753,
0.3484190106391907,
0.5129150748252869,
0.2094413936138153,
0.38210198283195496,
-0.3783426284790039,
0.2821672558784485,
-0.003302879398688674,
0.6759937405586243,
-0.052756715565919876,
-0.47888657450675964,
-0.7795916199684143,
-0.02498413436114788,
0.3334730863571167,
0.43327784538269043,
-0.2544172406196594,
0.026675451546907425,
0.21135757863521576,
0.7703990340232849,
-0.6923646330833435,
0.36841094493865967,
-0.6795921325683594,
0.14811350405216217,
-0.01650851033627987,
-0.058451589196920395,
-0.28773343563079834,
-0.40125221014022827,
0.3033549189567566,
-0.4297158718109131,
0.1414642184972763,
0.1139126569032669,
0.6476883888244629,
0.0817032903432846,
-0.37585896253585815,
-0.10833543539047241,
-0.47041088342666626,
0.7851877808570862,
-0.6086398959159851,
0.2908758819103241,
0.028289183974266052,
0.09792904555797577,
0.10383524745702744,
-0.5436113476753235,
-0.6203033328056335,
0.2587136924266815,
0.16507908701896667,
0.5134696960449219,
0.03521948307752609,
0.01609230972826481,
-0.16094502806663513,
0.7066110372543335,
-0.20324194431304932,
0.07040264457464218,
-0.08368698507547379,
0.3137695789337158,
0.570165753364563,
0.33143162727355957,
-0.21442925930023193,
-0.6882591843605042,
-0.23221248388290405,
-0.3366125822067261,
-0.6323364973068237,
0.2191573828458786,
0.4243623912334442,
0.2578714191913605,
-0.32011085748672485,
0.3247080147266388,
-0.28676867485046387,
0.6027377247810364,
0.615359365940094,
0.03623577952384949,
0.5807262659072876,
-0.02396104298532009,
-0.40365952253341675,
0.07795877754688263,
0.8370949029922485,
0.454218327999115,
-0.3568354547023773,
0.45678120851516724,
-0.16008061170578003,
-0.14562401175498962,
0.5426939129829407,
-0.7089385986328125,
-0.17747996747493744,
0.6323192715644836,
-0.4926007390022278,
-0.730095386505127,
0.42962202429771423,
-1.3936687707901,
-0.6719686388969421,
-0.20998084545135498,
-0.12951862812042236,
-0.7144152522087097,
-0.22025147080421448,
-0.25137072801589966,
0.14303240180015564,
-0.05238911509513855,
0.7124764919281006,
-0.675577700138092,
-0.3276718854904175,
0.60129314661026,
0.6640854477882385,
-0.10652585327625275,
-0.06852012127637863,
-0.6069960594177246,
0.03308827057480812,
-0.4905519485473633,
1.1927911043167114,
-0.8842735290527344,
-0.451689749956131,
0.21135620772838593,
-0.4039405882358551,
0.07037068158388138,
-0.38722047209739685,
0.2448456585407257,
-0.4214397370815277,
0.45732298493385315,
-0.3035726547241211,
-0.4667888283729553,
-0.5965580344200134,
0.4730466902256012,
-0.5185322761535645,
0.9337828159332275,
0.11315584182739258,
-0.8313653469085693,
0.5950719714164734,
-0.4368393123149872,
-0.4355921447277069,
-0.15225337445735931,
-0.3731285035610199,
-0.656179666519165,
0.5815165638923645,
0.7008974552154541,
0.7991663217544556,
-0.1847437173128128,
0.11209259182214737,
-0.4635465443134308,
0.22478336095809937,
0.28930652141571045,
-0.3001517951488495,
0.12426155805587769,
0.3122895359992981,
-0.3118647038936615,
0.35671234130859375,
-0.8503409624099731,
0.09337282180786133,
-0.19025130569934845,
-0.39488810300827026,
-0.5318422913551331,
0.3690128028392792,
-0.14718925952911377,
0.2638610899448395,
-0.051707252860069275,
-0.31707170605659485,
0.3057558238506317,
-0.6475397944450378,
0.00956112053245306,
1.0417135953903198,
0.41315725445747375,
0.3071659207344055,
0.0884116142988205,
0.8631793260574341,
0.4454043507575989,
0.22627270221710205,
-0.29232677817344666,
-0.6173588633537292,
-0.847617506980896,
-0.27148449420928955,
0.14050011336803436,
0.5075391530990601,
-0.9934535622596741,
0.7765454649925232,
-0.1361272782087326,
-0.6954816579818726,
-0.24277396500110626,
-0.02790890634059906,
0.6051793694496155,
0.17160148918628693,
0.19205878674983978,
-0.7833256721496582,
-0.2397903949022293,
-0.5965164303779602,
-0.08295455574989319,
-0.44428256154060364,
0.01719556376338005,
0.16541370749473572,
0.12015847861766815,
0.30415698885917664,
0.6823318600654602,
-0.7058819532394409,
-0.3362622559070587,
-0.5646300315856934,
0.5968158841133118,
0.26765403151512146,
0.24968180060386658,
0.8204823136329651,
-0.7020134329795837,
-0.6187387108802795,
-0.08200394362211227,
-0.7028765678405762,
0.04969107732176781,
-0.1306128352880478,
0.05124952644109726,
0.19117669761180878,
0.3706713914871216,
-0.22152411937713623,
0.482631653547287,
0.5952166318893433,
-0.49732640385627747,
0.3463667333126068,
0.05423840135335922,
0.1604875773191452,
-1.606709361076355,
-0.24786880612373352,
0.24534045159816742,
-0.035190608352422714,
-0.42194628715515137,
-0.21042193472385406,
-0.08534570038318634,
-0.0715813934803009,
-0.4968377947807312,
0.2817527949810028,
-0.5948016047477722,
0.0953042060136795,
-0.09549522399902344,
-0.4590478837490082,
0.14007708430290222,
0.49772557616233826,
0.09397328644990921,
0.512261688709259,
0.6488525867462158,
-0.583997368812561,
0.33457833528518677,
0.16784876585006714,
-0.6195428967475891,
0.9742265939712524,
-0.28245577216148376,
0.1404155194759369,
-0.17736391723155975,
0.08851809799671173,
-0.781867504119873,
-0.08357323706150055,
0.25640997290611267,
-0.4112774431705475,
0.5036817193031311,
-0.20134766399860382,
-0.3868669867515564,
-0.13789387047290802,
-0.594822883605957,
0.35316264629364014,
0.07199857383966446,
-0.2174362987279892,
0.9002369046211243,
0.25266334414482117,
-0.33360961079597473,
-0.5858899354934692,
-0.03086150251328945,
-0.13512645661830902,
-0.2714143395423889,
-0.25067535042762756,
0.19962669909000397,
0.03765256330370903,
-0.41979873180389404,
-0.08967987447977066,
-0.04901650547981262,
0.12650592625141144,
-0.10329508781433105,
0.36731091141700745,
0.05399809032678604,
-0.18616729974746704,
-0.13689808547496796,
0.37566566467285156,
-0.03954121470451355,
-0.06235125660896301,
-0.05206184461712837,
0.7108688950538635,
-0.30884528160095215,
-0.4229341149330139,
-0.6398003697395325,
0.5347053408622742,
0.8742580413818359,
-0.34653496742248535,
0.724428117275238,
0.03141658380627632,
-0.11777621507644653,
-0.24489164352416992,
-0.4873308539390564,
-0.039627328515052795,
-0.504172146320343,
0.3940162658691406,
-0.39119377732276917,
-0.08381647616624832,
0.5562771558761597,
0.20502953231334686,
0.07718978822231293,
0.3465512692928314,
0.6313969492912292,
-0.1636495143175125,
0.9330736994743347,
0.6901209950447083,
-0.19639164209365845,
1.032485008239746,
-0.5228270888328552,
0.20275656878948212,
-0.7430758476257324,
-0.36730149388313293,
-0.2967693507671356,
-0.285864919424057,
-0.31093069911003113,
-0.362173467874527,
0.825517475605011,
0.009836805984377861,
-0.11080355942249298,
-0.19426192343235016,
-0.5882233381271362,
0.1228409856557846,
0.6867003440856934,
-0.10062159597873688,
0.2347918450832367,
0.37433531880378723,
-0.2577113211154938,
0.07249536365270615,
-0.5187063217163086,
-0.22666937112808228,
0.8809826970100403,
0.18627886474132538,
0.7145498394966125,
0.10377664864063263,
0.5684553980827332,
0.23659686744213104,
0.4168505072593689,
-0.9718775749206543,
0.44066229462623596,
-0.2636086344718933,
-0.1655677855014801,
-0.053924888372421265,
-0.12499547004699707,
-0.7599008083343506,
0.32009005546569824,
-0.37336158752441406,
-0.5833281874656677,
0.7380258440971375,
0.2066124826669693,
-0.5914913415908813,
0.3805820643901825,
-0.4811735153198242,
0.37312328815460205,
-0.12084618955850601,
-0.2811506390571594,
-0.28263959288597107,
-0.252961665391922,
0.18989154696464539,
-0.092340387403965,
0.08836813271045685,
-0.12035215646028519,
0.15167377889156342,
0.6194987297058105,
-0.6999356746673584,
0.9738418459892273,
-0.3269781172275543,
-0.07523093372583389,
0.31699156761169434,
0.19593974947929382,
0.42262497544288635,
0.33466416597366333,
-0.502092719078064,
0.07009683549404144,
-0.35640019178390503,
-0.07315885275602341,
-0.6201875805854797,
0.457975834608078,
-0.6571775078773499,
-0.5946534276008606,
-0.9214497208595276,
-0.24501922726631165,
-0.4008791446685791,
0.15512016415596008,
0.5846918821334839,
0.6325786113739014,
0.06946767121553421,
0.18444009125232697,
0.46957358717918396,
-0.34412550926208496,
0.502473771572113,
0.4581383764743805,
0.03069206513464451,
-0.7830541729927063,
0.5831157565116882,
0.10863611847162247,
-0.08690690249204636,
0.5782877206802368,
0.21134565770626068,
-0.27242156863212585,
-0.8261250257492065,
-0.6698806881904602,
-0.014358204789459705,
-0.5416564345359802,
-0.6914087533950806,
-0.3902416229248047,
0.034935589879751205,
-0.542795717716217,
-0.40180039405822754,
-0.6834841370582581,
-0.2217179536819458,
-0.3134513199329376,
-0.3140760064125061,
0.5984904170036316,
0.8463352918624878,
0.06481220573186874,
0.2591923475265503,
-0.8530360460281372,
0.25778722763061523,
0.2642503082752228,
0.44423699378967285,
0.202875554561615,
-0.18901567161083221,
-0.0012161312624812126,
-0.27597206830978394,
-0.7011750936508179,
-1.0126793384552002,
0.7879189252853394,
0.08187995105981827,
0.36723747849464417,
0.9982368350028992,
0.36786898970603943,
0.7459918260574341,
-0.36042118072509766,
0.8937569260597229,
0.5559868812561035,
-0.9558408856391907,
0.8085945844650269,
-0.3201688528060913,
0.06620489805936813,
0.39811867475509644,
-0.07249484956264496,
-0.32807451486587524,
-0.7154242396354675,
-0.5404786467552185,
-1.2642474174499512,
0.7739925980567932,
0.17819614708423615,
0.10770057886838913,
-0.01731741987168789,
0.44617927074432373,
0.35020899772644043,
0.3868636190891266,
-0.2709788382053375,
-0.41999551653862,
-0.6318838596343994,
-0.3065883219242096,
0.17051969468593597,
-0.5052136778831482,
0.07343965768814087,
-0.3066936135292053,
0.6539928317070007,
-0.29824119806289673,
0.4459111988544464,
0.13816988468170166,
0.4394994378089905,
-0.19222301244735718,
0.24381254613399506,
0.3470577299594879,
0.8134884238243103,
-0.26626142859458923,
-0.12696154415607452,
-0.06072729453444481,
-0.4820806384086609,
0.07751253992319107,
0.04691847041249275,
-0.24508191645145416,
0.02175685577094555,
0.19607725739479065,
0.8155844211578369,
-0.21449629962444305,
-0.24500201642513275,
0.5070952773094177,
-0.09361531585454941,
0.10429023951292038,
-0.7099708914756775,
-0.03487814590334892,
-0.29400911927223206,
0.3148931860923767,
0.4529232382774353,
0.024857083335518837,
-0.002159944735467434,
-0.6366280317306519,
0.08612366765737534,
0.24780452251434326,
-0.613619863986969,
-0.527406632900238,
0.6884880661964417,
0.41392168402671814,
0.04495213180780411,
0.6513035297393799,
-0.22497552633285522,
-0.4696570336818695,
0.6283726692199707,
-0.09174768626689911,
1.1608728170394897,
-0.5696027874946594,
0.2828229069709778,
0.11386369913816452,
-0.07218217104673386,
0.13131116330623627,
0.6026700139045715,
0.30286046862602234,
-0.7759450674057007,
-0.233728289604187,
-0.818138599395752,
-0.4869122803211212,
0.24944745004177094,
-0.9767777919769287,
0.2590830326080322,
-0.599660336971283,
-0.08602375537157059,
0.05376341938972473,
-0.05389556661248207,
-0.4845396876335144,
0.49994608759880066,
0.10554271936416626,
0.6382249593734741,
-0.7887263894081116,
0.937839925289154,
1.091496229171753,
-0.56855309009552,
-0.7074554562568665,
0.4177873134613037,
0.34310173988342285,
-0.5822369456291199,
0.21412546932697296,
0.19791142642498016,
-0.18624497950077057,
-0.494810551404953,
-0.2336350679397583,
-0.7802766561508179,
0.874342143535614,
0.016768837347626686,
-0.1296156346797943,
0.22153769433498383,
-0.09808926284313202,
0.610954999923706,
-0.5487975478172302,
0.034548450261354446,
-0.03840921074151993,
0.2682622969150543,
0.1773604452610016,
-0.5118143558502197,
-0.022516924887895584,
-0.5189142227172852,
0.052059661597013474,
0.018901413306593895,
-0.7308589220046997,
0.8637453317642212,
0.021314427256584167,
0.1256312131881714,
-0.03862535580992699,
1.2608895301818848,
0.25827720761299133,
0.396454393863678,
0.8136846423149109,
0.399279922246933,
0.5921697020530701,
0.02901809848845005,
1.0233778953552246,
-0.4240354597568512,
0.23558759689331055,
0.8740876913070679,
-0.2801586389541626,
0.9678574204444885,
0.40658634901046753,
-0.07770755141973495,
1.0130369663238525,
0.804739236831665,
0.014713363721966743,
0.6755176186561584,
-0.25437960028648376,
-0.12993492186069489,
-0.19358445703983307,
0.18367315828800201,
-0.42274272441864014,
0.6872789263725281,
0.6724938750267029,
-0.49607914686203003,
0.16805878281593323,
-0.2092680037021637,
0.10248950123786926,
0.041617512702941895,
-0.377549409866333,
0.8649016618728638,
0.1521563082933426,
-0.743446409702301,
0.3621961772441864,
0.03303741291165352,
0.687279999256134,
-0.32176637649536133,
0.1698046177625656,
-0.650510847568512,
0.30124932527542114,
-0.01177219208329916,
-0.7621380090713501,
0.4050692319869995,
-0.05223872885107994,
-0.40112823247909546,
-0.3852841854095459,
0.17572465538978577,
-0.11511426419019699,
-0.9607213735580444,
0.1438179612159729,
0.6635066866874695,
-0.18739430606365204,
-0.3409687280654907,
-0.7593181729316711,
-0.2832564115524292,
-0.004092017654329538,
-0.7540482878684998,
0.4124944806098938,
0.6308868527412415,
-0.0859626829624176,
0.546705961227417,
0.36108702421188354,
0.034511417150497437,
-0.23684807121753693,
-0.13532714545726776,
0.931372344493866,
-0.7050775289535522,
-0.9238646030426025,
-0.6111289858818054,
0.5176472067832947,
-0.3296276032924652,
-0.2438715398311615,
0.48733508586883545,
0.5541722774505615,
0.37321892380714417,
-0.12280893325805664,
0.8865730166435242,
-0.25929850339889526,
0.6861408948898315,
-0.6847801208496094,
0.8052550554275513,
-0.9036008715629578,
0.5066348910331726,
-0.49626797437667847,
-0.9072998762130737,
-0.33063775300979614,
0.4900931417942047,
-0.25472110509872437,
-0.0997578576207161,
0.8510208129882812,
0.5310661792755127,
-0.24920515716075897,
-0.0036762175150215626,
0.10488178580999374,
0.32470494508743286,
0.46217823028564453,
0.18581317365169525,
0.6509040594100952,
-0.05867627263069153,
0.33470654487609863,
-0.5560894012451172,
-0.11009637266397476,
-0.22458188235759735,
-1.0122220516204834,
-0.6790812611579895,
-0.7125968933105469,
-0.47429370880126953,
-0.5261939764022827,
-0.21676483750343323,
0.716946005821228,
0.6164074540138245,
-1.0065497159957886,
-0.028467727825045586,
0.07434991002082825,
0.3577054440975189,
-0.75033038854599,
-0.3246690034866333,
0.7351953983306885,
-0.2071872353553772,
-1.1464868783950806,
0.34147074818611145,
0.33273762464523315,
-0.04305664822459221,
-0.17489922046661377,
0.43915241956710815,
0.1508464515209198,
0.23424874246120453,
0.8727758526802063,
-0.03542722389101982,
-0.69914710521698,
-0.4762062430381775,
-0.28881463408470154,
0.3339647352695465,
0.4025413691997528,
0.7804704904556274,
-0.749946653842926,
0.4861316680908203,
0.8389232754707336,
0.08698339015245438,
0.13598908483982086,
0.29151055216789246,
1.0292859077453613,
-0.967490017414093,
0.21805895864963531,
0.2059701383113861,
0.5393913984298706,
0.24340936541557312,
-0.4221058189868927,
0.1635812669992447,
0.3491613268852234,
0.030161941424012184,
-0.6481577157974243,
0.409646213054657,
-1.1210606098175049,
-0.472817987203598,
1.208203911781311,
-0.3394368886947632,
-0.09796614199876785,
-0.33993038535118103,
0.07277273386716843,
0.040682803839445114,
-0.9747231602668762,
1.2012406587600708,
0.2713187336921692,
-0.46019673347473145,
-0.24433693289756775,
-0.0026986326556652784,
0.524828314781189,
0.35414260625839233,
-0.9329884648323059,
0.023135799914598465,
0.6512159109115601,
0.2106277048587799,
0.2218191772699356,
0.48227784037590027,
-0.09373803436756134,
-0.08905840665102005,
-0.21324406564235687,
0.05791649594902992,
-0.055496569722890854,
-0.40016862750053406,
-0.2098628133535385,
0.7425507307052612,
-0.09244860708713531,
-0.4154854118824005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11116v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11116v1 | Grammaticality Representation in ChatGPT as Compared to Linguists and Laypeople | 2024-06-17T00:23:16 | 2024-06-17T00:23:16 | Zhuang Qiu, Xufeng Duan, Zhenguang G. Cai | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional performance across
various linguistic tasks. However, it remains uncertain whether LLMs have
developed human-like fine-grained grammatical intuition. This preregistered
study (https://osf.io/t5nes) presents the first large-scale investigation of
ChatGPT's grammatical intuition, building upon a previous study that collected
laypeople's grammatical judgments on 148 linguistic phenomena that linguists
judged to be grammatical, ungrammatical, or marginally grammatical (Sprouse,
Schutze, & Almeida, 2013). Our primary focus was to compare ChatGPT with both
laypeople and linguists in the judgement of these linguistic constructions. In
Experiment 1, ChatGPT assigned ratings to sentences based on a given reference
sentence. Experiment 2 involved rating sentences on a 7-point scale, and
Experiment 3 asked ChatGPT to choose the more grammatical sentence from a pair.
Overall, our findings demonstrate convergence rates ranging from 73% to 95%
between ChatGPT and linguists, with an overall point-estimate of 89%.
Significant correlations were also found between ChatGPT and laypeople across
all tasks, though the correlation strength varied by task. We attribute these
results to the psychometric nature of the judgment tasks and the differences in
language processing styles between humans and LLMs. | [
-0.2648615539073944,
-0.706726610660553,
0.778511106967926,
0.5225030779838562,
-0.24779397249221802,
-0.1477438360452652,
-0.7435861229896545,
-0.3475809693336487,
0.2715747356414795,
0.007874050177633762,
-0.3025260269641876,
-0.4745599031448364,
-0.7638945579528809,
0.09102453291416168,
-0.25406211614608765,
0.8860139846801758,
0.42029210925102234,
0.22930985689163208,
-0.3367243707180023,
0.1952599734067917,
-0.19789740443229675,
-1.0357483625411987,
-0.45549145340919495,
-0.42694082856178284,
0.4580782949924469,
0.19521275162696838,
0.8319445252418518,
0.1729545146226883,
0.6028088331222534,
0.2842918932437897,
-0.2116209715604782,
-0.11738479882478714,
-0.5035969614982605,
-0.03260147571563721,
-0.2667161226272583,
-0.6434922218322754,
-0.32003161311149597,
0.14366938173770905,
0.44356971979141235,
1.0217832326889038,
-0.33777347207069397,
0.05233757570385933,
0.1880904883146286,
0.6709012985229492,
-0.48644834756851196,
0.5095991492271423,
-0.5300063490867615,
0.22150620818138123,
-0.38793620467185974,
-0.2107916921377182,
-0.6684830784797668,
-0.18344901502132416,
0.23297874629497528,
-0.41272321343421936,
0.20739638805389404,
0.045218534767627716,
0.8395666480064392,
-0.028292464092373848,
-0.6303538084030151,
-0.171282559633255,
-0.5903546214103699,
0.42781513929367065,
-0.6790112853050232,
0.5541172027587891,
0.38474225997924805,
-0.04981086403131485,
-0.3506069481372833,
-0.5848245024681091,
-0.5252127647399902,
-0.6810162663459778,
-0.15743717551231384,
0.3080272674560547,
-0.17999814450740814,
0.3069300055503845,
0.3275327980518341,
0.5074663758277893,
-0.7117823362350464,
0.2051640748977661,
-0.23824995756149292,
0.0483994334936142,
0.5112395882606506,
-0.06919608265161514,
0.06382107734680176,
-0.6147341132164001,
-0.3152269124984741,
0.03186491131782532,
-0.5478965044021606,
0.033273350447416306,
0.31443706154823303,
0.19353125989437103,
-0.05794680491089821,
0.9136317372322083,
-0.28826913237571716,
0.42261403799057007,
-0.035448458045721054,
0.19046957790851593,
0.15054509043693542,
-0.16609659790992737,
-0.2774023413658142,
-0.30394288897514343,
1.2118077278137207,
0.511893630027771,
0.7943120002746582,
-0.10295998305082321,
-0.02150817960500717,
0.39149972796440125,
0.3099828064441681,
-0.52782142162323,
-0.438137412071228,
-0.26688477396965027,
-0.4409361183643341,
-0.11265642195940018,
0.24278223514556885,
-0.4864775240421295,
-0.6143544316291809,
-0.39797908067703247,
0.04075693339109421,
-0.4626753628253937,
-0.30168190598487854,
0.2678830027580261,
0.097730353474617,
0.40440917015075684,
0.338686466217041,
-1.0213172435760498,
0.4064335525035858,
0.9262202382087708,
0.5616268515586853,
-0.15674251317977905,
-0.5274283289909363,
-0.12331509590148926,
-0.3798615038394928,
-0.3754642903804779,
0.9828813672065735,
-0.4288177490234375,
-0.2980254888534546,
-0.02215580828487873,
-0.15314878523349762,
-0.380484938621521,
-0.39002496004104614,
0.6401695609092712,
-0.2828499674797058,
0.3059602379798889,
-0.24689963459968567,
-0.673603892326355,
-0.17004816234111786,
0.20223315060138702,
-0.3053501844406128,
0.981054425239563,
-0.06555210053920746,
-0.6146146059036255,
0.666842520236969,
-0.39857807755470276,
-0.29036644101142883,
0.24797207117080688,
-0.48960742354393005,
-0.09692800790071487,
0.39929449558258057,
-0.006192807573825121,
0.702482283115387,
-0.28894609212875366,
0.5229862332344055,
-0.20925694704055786,
-0.3013736307621002,
0.5628041625022888,
-0.42200925946235657,
0.5025718808174133,
-0.016086561605334282,
-0.23418110609054565,
-0.030118072405457497,
-0.5244811773300171,
0.09219110757112503,
0.035501934587955475,
-0.5209082961082458,
-0.10712626576423645,
0.26804351806640625,
0.17134328186511993,
0.22791768610477448,
0.06803322583436966,
-0.40855005383491516,
0.26053938269615173,
-0.4663999378681183,
0.5080953240394592,
0.6060158014297485,
-0.21117573976516724,
0.28861114382743835,
-0.2303110510110855,
0.4373742341995239,
-0.27104029059410095,
-0.040671613067388535,
0.06917056441307068,
-0.6801081895828247,
-0.8141857385635376,
-0.12678495049476624,
0.0873209536075592,
0.46668702363967896,
-0.04586723819375038,
0.4846382141113281,
-0.5685978531837463,
-0.4126562476158142,
-0.10930142551660538,
0.18834008276462555,
0.5587695240974426,
-0.131498783826828,
0.032442010939121246,
-0.3884774148464203,
-0.5133717656135559,
-1.0049270391464233,
-0.4830782115459442,
-0.5595574975013733,
-0.13810475170612335,
0.29673582315444946,
0.42828986048698425,
0.04733768105506897,
0.930743396282196,
-0.36574381589889526,
-0.08466722816228867,
-0.41969695687294006,
0.1164168268442154,
0.331989586353302,
0.29849866032600403,
0.5276733636856079,
-0.6343061327934265,
-0.3865237832069397,
0.18765497207641602,
-0.6328275799751282,
-0.16539201140403748,
0.09155411273241043,
-0.03432893380522728,
0.23232492804527283,
0.7151654362678528,
-0.936188280582428,
0.4113563895225525,
0.5100886225700378,
-0.8027440905570984,
0.6414082646369934,
-0.1129690632224083,
0.06645181030035019,
-1.0358507633209229,
0.02671065740287304,
-0.0068291411735117435,
-0.2518617808818817,
-0.495783269405365,
0.15542028844356537,
-0.15245115756988525,
0.06838171929121017,
-0.17902861535549164,
0.1923847645521164,
-0.36242473125457764,
-0.23657546937465668,
0.22666321694850922,
0.23063282668590546,
-0.27686530351638794,
0.6059492826461792,
0.06794130802154541,
0.6768612861633301,
0.2999809980392456,
-0.28604182600975037,
0.2744520604610443,
0.07664873450994492,
-0.3730100393295288,
0.5601108074188232,
-0.7402176260948181,
0.13914166390895844,
-0.2910596430301666,
0.12940077483654022,
-1.2572699785232544,
-0.48270121216773987,
0.13716965913772583,
-0.5905990600585938,
0.009285124950110912,
-0.3094951808452606,
-0.6385384798049927,
-0.18763257563114166,
0.04403231292963028,
0.294259250164032,
0.5952766537666321,
-0.06103826314210892,
0.4815790355205536,
0.1439855396747589,
-0.323775053024292,
-0.1108173131942749,
-0.7021119594573975,
0.2296425700187683,
-0.143435537815094,
-0.7173992991447449,
-0.09851828217506409,
0.16707365214824677,
-0.6828265190124512,
-0.3658643364906311,
-0.010487966239452362,
0.05536706745624542,
0.04674570634961128,
0.4165053069591522,
0.2561240792274475,
-0.3765931725502014,
0.3237358033657074,
-0.5514944791793823,
0.09970153123140335,
0.2830828130245209,
-0.2247595489025116,
0.7889387607574463,
-0.37718361616134644,
-0.5653060078620911,
-0.27939373254776,
0.09229756891727448,
0.5267475843429565,
-0.12581266462802887,
0.670312762260437,
0.3634134531021118,
-0.10988295823335648,
0.1652987003326416,
-0.8386695384979248,
0.13457104563713074,
-0.36164841055870056,
0.3889656364917755,
-0.35408806800842285,
-0.8275465369224548,
0.5092955231666565,
0.23746728897094727,
-0.22321026027202606,
0.4537593424320221,
0.6180366277694702,
-0.229075089097023,
0.6357147097587585,
0.3285081088542938,
0.020967140793800354,
0.58762526512146,
-0.02881835773587227,
0.2053440511226654,
-0.6168060898780823,
-0.31765103340148926,
-0.4879160225391388,
-0.17504319548606873,
-0.8228599429130554,
-0.42628318071365356,
0.15097272396087646,
0.055164214223623276,
-0.26198306679725647,
0.12078087776899338,
-0.06027655676007271,
0.468296080827713,
0.47746938467025757,
0.25281983613967896,
0.3161328434944153,
-0.06194586679339409,
-0.2135428935289383,
-0.18344296514987946,
-0.5716203451156616,
-0.6742896437644958,
1.0184247493743896,
0.21798793971538544,
0.6808634400367737,
0.3274993896484375,
0.5360258221626282,
0.2189158946275711,
-0.08076246827840805,
-1.1552708148956299,
0.7945479154586792,
-0.32748380303382874,
-0.26104670763015747,
-0.07963543385267258,
-0.3998428285121918,
-1.102830171585083,
0.43844538927078247,
-0.2577867805957794,
-0.9930529594421387,
0.11056852340698242,
-0.0404108427464962,
-0.3141922354698181,
-0.11843486875295639,
-1.0677049160003662,
0.8512853980064392,
0.07157585769891739,
-0.2537338435649872,
-0.14276109635829926,
-0.6031022667884827,
0.17039692401885986,
0.22169345617294312,
0.18780450522899628,
-0.23235341906547546,
0.11570244282484055,
0.6722752451896667,
-0.36706987023353577,
1.033906102180481,
0.07980825752019882,
-0.16814638674259186,
0.08370950073003769,
0.24140599370002747,
0.31336259841918945,
0.13958227634429932,
0.05642621964216232,
0.08226413279771805,
-0.10953841358423233,
-0.43548384308815,
-0.6273400783538818,
0.5268466472625732,
-0.6447403430938721,
-0.6622664928436279,
-0.5737784504890442,
-0.426254540681839,
-0.29834291338920593,
0.1713515669107437,
0.3374481797218323,
0.45006275177001953,
-0.5270512104034424,
0.17616860568523407,
0.2893927991390228,
0.02918962948024273,
0.3012103736400604,
0.4711489677429199,
-0.3924677073955536,
-0.09395518153905869,
0.3723589777946472,
-0.08029737323522568,
0.586460530757904,
0.4047224521636963,
0.2086416631937027,
-0.13937988877296448,
-0.4028097689151764,
-0.045298393815755844,
0.3593537211418152,
-0.6997978687286377,
0.22155268490314484,
-0.5022786259651184,
-0.14386890828609467,
-0.2398432195186615,
-0.02724733017385006,
-0.32620957493782043,
-0.48949718475341797,
-0.014782211743295193,
-0.09329386055469513,
0.3152216672897339,
0.9711697101593018,
0.21210211515426636,
0.4538966119289398,
-0.44737669825553894,
-0.029572390019893646,
0.23642447590827942,
0.198655366897583,
-0.25632235407829285,
-0.535459578037262,
0.12311117351055145,
0.12805011868476868,
-0.10256883502006531,
-0.5327057838439941,
0.18493665754795074,
0.3298075497150421,
0.2989172637462616,
0.5141499638557434,
-0.39481204748153687,
0.7281823754310608,
-0.40181097388267517,
1.0487772226333618,
0.10357118397951126,
-0.8798918724060059,
0.3537537455558777,
-0.6406335830688477,
0.2596491277217865,
0.45007678866386414,
0.09226739406585693,
-0.8796094655990601,
-0.48366662859916687,
-0.6246749758720398,
-0.7351299524307251,
0.5492636561393738,
0.42608097195625305,
0.2217041403055191,
-0.24434760212898254,
0.367496132850647,
0.001549854059703648,
0.1000332310795784,
-0.8492183685302734,
0.03161958232522011,
0.049151528626680374,
-0.023393267765641212,
-0.48813292384147644,
-0.4301762580871582,
0.08264990895986557,
-0.16198065876960754,
0.08687934279441833,
-0.09261982887983322,
0.5928929448127747,
0.15823544561862946,
-0.14579768478870392,
0.18901275098323822,
0.6210017204284668,
0.6658554077148438,
0.8317925333976746,
-0.0850781500339508,
0.3923614025115967,
-0.036581188440322876,
-0.5882201194763184,
-0.09125672280788422,
0.12902595102787018,
0.18641676008701324,
-0.059131018817424774,
0.8465418815612793,
0.863318681716919,
0.6036252379417419,
-0.5230939984321594,
0.9000353217124939,
-0.026435814797878265,
-0.15627524256706238,
-0.49181821942329407,
-0.08318864554166794,
0.13918904960155487,
0.254895955324173,
0.18494772911071777,
0.3794550895690918,
0.026914404705166817,
-0.7570181488990784,
-0.11561769247055054,
0.4820230007171631,
-0.14516788721084595,
-0.5225091576576233,
0.3456498384475708,
-0.014419249258935452,
-0.22572799026966095,
0.6996237635612488,
-0.33706849813461304,
-0.6771280765533447,
0.3996278941631317,
0.36381950974464417,
0.8048447370529175,
-0.08863698691129684,
0.14038272202014923,
0.2964097261428833,
0.22398915886878967,
-0.3121373951435089,
0.3187265992164612,
-0.0317651592195034,
-0.9126960039138794,
-0.5303770899772644,
-0.5653282403945923,
-0.17545436322689056,
-0.207012340426445,
-0.7187075018882751,
0.27324536442756653,
-0.31399545073509216,
-0.29751870036125183,
-0.03512852266430855,
-0.24903957545757294,
-0.6442110538482666,
0.011130938306450844,
0.3150443732738495,
0.6220744848251343,
-0.8365791440010071,
0.4329279065132141,
0.8898531198501587,
-0.31874850392341614,
-0.8492358922958374,
0.18813678622245789,
-0.002116402378305793,
-0.9365653395652771,
0.7884960770606995,
0.05256281793117523,
-0.004431383218616247,
-0.09418071061372757,
-0.24390460550785065,
-0.6708710789680481,
0.6797856092453003,
0.4709417223930359,
-0.6431690454483032,
-0.3359559178352356,
0.3993041515350342,
0.7803993225097656,
0.032502055168151855,
0.4716959297657013,
0.6146311163902283,
0.23026083409786224,
0.08764873445034027,
-1.546278476715088,
-0.08464320003986359,
-0.36317646503448486,
0.1471625119447708,
0.3570825457572937,
-0.5748713612556458,
0.9198686480522156,
-0.1807963252067566,
-0.2783108949661255,
0.05333350598812103,
0.35667893290519714,
0.10089704394340515,
0.003225150750949979,
0.30142003297805786,
0.4982008934020996,
0.7320801019668579,
-0.2530636787414551,
1.120111107826233,
-0.12313876301050186,
0.5120611190795898,
1.0754687786102295,
0.009074294939637184,
0.9781545400619507,
0.5876320004463196,
-0.6550856828689575,
0.4920811057090759,
0.44456082582473755,
0.21145696938037872,
0.2180931717157364,
0.3145579695701599,
-0.3326340615749359,
-0.4120795726776123,
-0.023104744032025337,
-0.2274627983570099,
0.8342157006263733,
0.4433058500289917,
-0.5427669286727905,
-0.08688077330589294,
-0.08788254857063293,
0.38313785195350647,
0.13960294425487518,
-0.2771229147911072,
0.8510468006134033,
0.2787104547023773,
-0.9055414199829102,
0.613915205001831,
-0.30503904819488525,
0.6586794257164001,
-0.6065937876701355,
0.13658350706100464,
-0.17585058510303497,
0.23062708973884583,
-0.42716068029403687,
-1.0637937784194946,
0.042205579578876495,
0.017914555966854095,
0.022011324763298035,
-0.18296277523040771,
0.5072336196899414,
-0.22183720767498016,
-0.3583794832229614,
0.17719729244709015,
0.7463914155960083,
0.38184693455696106,
-0.22891579568386078,
-0.13068071007728577,
-0.08900491148233414,
-0.08859506994485855,
-0.26742228865623474,
0.17277196049690247,
0.6845253109931946,
-0.16984118521213531,
0.6595363616943359,
0.5163266658782959,
0.21089133620262146,
0.32826751470565796,
0.28000810742378235,
0.7757494449615479,
-0.7365990877151489,
-0.43939125537872314,
-1.1333978176116943,
0.2805876135826111,
0.05753633379936218,
-0.5380851626396179,
0.7637869715690613,
0.5480260848999023,
0.8168755173683167,
-0.16768838465213776,
0.5816203355789185,
-0.3036745488643646,
0.09540382027626038,
-0.7135199904441833,
0.5092296004295349,
-0.07232938706874847,
0.1369292140007019,
-0.4527202546596527,
-0.8471606373786926,
-0.3258169889450073,
0.883691668510437,
-0.6411072015762329,
0.1720980405807495,
0.9862961769104004,
0.624075710773468,
-0.10438859462738037,
0.14515773952007294,
0.2967774569988251,
0.3157569169998169,
0.20262715220451355,
0.5961701273918152,
1.0671513080596924,
-0.12263623625040054,
0.2999502420425415,
0.009765884838998318,
-0.14724376797676086,
-0.1834213137626648,
-0.8030426502227783,
-1.0423134565353394,
-0.5364536046981812,
-0.007347482722252607,
-0.18672344088554382,
-0.06574290245771408,
1.2617727518081665,
0.6217307448387146,
-0.4916525185108185,
-0.43089526891708374,
-0.4041326642036438,
-0.4760046601295471,
-0.08835618197917938,
-0.27032744884490967,
0.21104435622692108,
-0.4417418837547302,
-0.540232241153717,
0.25799718499183655,
0.10027854144573212,
-0.131977841258049,
-0.16115836799144745,
0.05898227170109749,
-0.16034217178821564,
-0.12239633500576019,
0.8563457727432251,
0.013478709384799004,
-0.936561644077301,
-0.325444757938385,
-0.05561685934662819,
-0.21941666305065155,
0.24053063988685608,
0.8600588440895081,
-0.6282838582992554,
0.23195165395736694,
0.4833156168460846,
0.25126516819000244,
0.3915390074253082,
0.11346570402383804,
0.7289445996284485,
-0.6950264573097229,
0.2560822665691376,
0.10911879688501358,
0.5601598024368286,
0.27445918321609497,
-0.2924726903438568,
0.5924972891807556,
0.40222305059432983,
-0.7231268882751465,
-0.44917041063308716,
0.22027793526649475,
-1.2333641052246094,
0.2748161554336548,
1.489173173904419,
-0.23680678009986877,
0.028152231127023697,
0.04673837497830391,
-0.4963071644306183,
-0.07888760417699814,
-0.5963699221611023,
0.683870792388916,
1.0369232892990112,
-0.28907510638237,
-0.11462827771902084,
-0.6803364753723145,
0.3246375620365143,
0.6134413480758667,
-0.7349572777748108,
0.12883107364177704,
0.5543708205223083,
0.24805045127868652,
0.124562568962574,
0.7174926996231079,
0.010300434194505215,
0.1954774409532547,
-0.15445983409881592,
-0.013168581761419773,
0.3168018162250519,
0.16903716325759888,
-0.21257777512073517,
0.015130910091102123,
0.49983394145965576,
0.04804835468530655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11115v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11115v1 | Text Grafting: Near-Distribution Weak Supervision for Minority Classes in Text Classification | 2024-06-17T00:23:08 | 2024-06-17T00:23:08 | Letian Peng, Yi Gu, Chengyu Dong, Zihan Wang, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL | For extremely weak-supervised text classification, pioneer research generates
pseudo labels by mining texts similar to the class names from the raw corpus,
which may end up with very limited or even no samples for the minority classes.
Recent works have started to generate the relevant texts by prompting LLMs
using the class names or definitions; however, there is a high risk that LLMs
cannot generate in-distribution (i.e., similar to the corpus where the text
classifier will be applied) data, leading to ungeneralizable classifiers. In
this paper, we combine the advantages of these two approaches and propose to
bridge the gap via a novel framework, \emph{text grafting}, which aims to
obtain clean and near-distribution weak supervision for minority classes.
Specifically, we first use LLM-based logits to mine masked templates from the
raw corpus, which have a high potential for data synthesis into the target
minority class. Then, the templates are filled by state-of-the-art LLMs to
synthesize near-distribution texts falling into minority classes. Text grafting
shows significant improvement over direct mining or synthesis on minority
classes. We also use analysis and case studies to comprehend the property of
text grafting. | [
-0.049086082726716995,
-0.588282585144043,
0.3081726133823395,
0.12518936395645142,
-0.34741032123565674,
0.37434449791908264,
-0.08040142059326172,
-0.6181840300559998,
0.3345661461353302,
0.5878238081932068,
-0.3324766159057617,
-0.5917807221412659,
-0.4037584960460663,
0.1025555357336998,
-0.6698817610740662,
1.403469204902649,
-0.10187053680419922,
-0.20722530782222748,
-0.20308464765548706,
0.006581539288163185,
-0.21798297762870789,
-0.8305240869522095,
-0.2000885307788849,
-0.05244133248925209,
0.2803131639957428,
0.4944849908351898,
0.38733938336372375,
0.6300546526908875,
0.46381691098213196,
0.2645084857940674,
-0.18388527631759644,
-0.0963495671749115,
-0.5451881289482117,
-0.02959418296813965,
-0.097064308822155,
-0.7221733331680298,
-0.5009198784828186,
0.02550749108195305,
0.7057797908782959,
0.7675270438194275,
0.21132361888885498,
0.013071306981146336,
0.2723250687122345,
0.46776270866394043,
-0.7961691617965698,
-0.23863911628723145,
-0.8580273985862732,
0.2982133626937866,
-0.7544901967048645,
-0.16930969059467316,
-0.4555472135543823,
-0.4468837082386017,
0.014359711669385433,
-0.20385490357875824,
0.6076797842979431,
-0.002013510325923562,
0.6217467784881592,
-0.055303916335105896,
-0.509662926197052,
-0.16199246048927307,
-0.7138587832450867,
0.8839439153671265,
-0.5733762383460999,
0.11458957195281982,
0.44533470273017883,
0.15415869653224945,
0.14585722982883453,
-0.9617992639541626,
-0.26693183183670044,
0.168354332447052,
-0.1732959747314453,
0.19700171053409576,
0.021026672795414925,
0.051981959491968155,
0.043764300644397736,
0.7543250918388367,
-0.15263840556144714,
0.2066597044467926,
-0.587354838848114,
-0.3445728123188019,
0.4671400487422943,
0.16985099017620087,
0.19591481983661652,
-0.04891526326537132,
-0.7569115161895752,
-0.0673588216304779,
-0.6638164520263672,
-0.3309440016746521,
0.6366984248161316,
0.4308379590511322,
0.03653210774064064,
0.6741926074028015,
0.1395171731710434,
0.7392712831497192,
-0.125122532248497,
-0.2682730257511139,
0.404704213142395,
-0.5076668858528137,
-0.2810937464237213,
0.20318929851055145,
0.692468523979187,
0.3754918575286865,
0.0031765492167323828,
-0.10125035792589188,
-0.3656265139579773,
0.06133311241865158,
0.1864621788263321,
-0.8571884632110596,
-0.1976032257080078,
-0.19579967856407166,
-0.7223643064498901,
-0.7952852845191956,
0.09312405437231064,
-1.0301843881607056,
-0.3460882604122162,
0.016542620956897736,
0.17798691987991333,
-0.047526922076940536,
-0.19308921694755554,
-0.11184442043304443,
-0.21477335691452026,
-0.021567460149526596,
0.2007591724395752,
-1.1629223823547363,
0.26072973012924194,
0.32621821761131287,
0.9995387196540833,
-0.5223528742790222,
0.036946918815374374,
-0.23628076910972595,
0.4991365373134613,
-0.22947043180465698,
0.7863785028457642,
-0.371158242225647,
-0.27460789680480957,
0.21419592201709747,
-0.13850826025009155,
0.06269283592700958,
-0.6839491724967957,
0.7054183483123779,
-0.2383769154548645,
0.21564076840877533,
0.25651833415031433,
-0.6457080245018005,
0.2145366221666336,
0.1957351416349411,
-0.48555782437324524,
1.13319730758667,
0.3781660199165344,
-1.1124452352523804,
0.4677734971046448,
-0.20653969049453735,
-0.5540019869804382,
0.08410319685935974,
0.09303032606840134,
-0.8275452256202698,
-0.09493677318096161,
-0.07617493718862534,
0.7398709654808044,
0.11103059351444244,
0.24834828078746796,
-0.6562401056289673,
-0.525364875793457,
0.11860723048448563,
-0.408383309841156,
0.7321919798851013,
0.17559406161308289,
-0.324817419052124,
-0.13068139553070068,
-0.519374668598175,
-0.26426589488983154,
-0.05954517796635628,
-0.28239622712135315,
-0.6445648074150085,
-0.18421617150306702,
0.4896466135978699,
0.039418987929821014,
0.13713958859443665,
-0.4553898870944977,
0.3588048815727234,
-0.5216461420059204,
0.22127944231033325,
1.0018669366836548,
-0.12461230158805847,
0.8645485639572144,
-0.4046614468097687,
0.414726585149765,
-0.15219666063785553,
0.09823022037744522,
-0.2160223126411438,
-0.4297427535057068,
-0.7012572288513184,
-0.4808136224746704,
0.4859105348587036,
0.7169219851493835,
-0.7032297849655151,
0.47702309489250183,
0.055329740047454834,
-0.510822057723999,
-0.4392727017402649,
0.4764254093170166,
0.42221570014953613,
0.4305212199687958,
0.4062716066837311,
-0.34249404072761536,
-0.6634277105331421,
-0.819808840751648,
-0.3789941668510437,
-0.23310580849647522,
0.030523505061864853,
-0.03790202736854553,
0.3435153663158417,
-0.3901936411857605,
0.8088220357894897,
-0.651431143283844,
-1.0497034788131714,
-0.33779045939445496,
-0.13126660883426666,
-0.03952869400382042,
0.5052538514137268,
0.6613141298294067,
-0.8945949077606201,
-0.6606112122535706,
-0.22152067720890045,
-0.7335102558135986,
-0.18406683206558228,
-0.18469254672527313,
-0.08415975421667099,
0.09876317530870438,
1.0834484100341797,
-0.12048980593681335,
0.49036705493927,
0.3789225220680237,
-0.15874002873897552,
0.43000856041908264,
0.11773177981376648,
-0.18716351687908173,
-1.2016700506210327,
-0.09731843322515488,
-0.07854434847831726,
-0.340181440114975,
-0.6378621459007263,
-0.20513224601745605,
-0.0069631170481443405,
-0.06929779052734375,
-0.6143061518669128,
0.6812893748283386,
-0.5375173687934875,
0.20394542813301086,
-0.39149564504623413,
-0.0737529769539833,
-0.37187808752059937,
0.3120885491371155,
-0.1646634340286255,
0.3167504370212555,
0.5786924958229065,
-0.4691716432571411,
0.2898287773132324,
0.21460393071174622,
-0.24230772256851196,
0.6211516261100769,
-0.286180704832077,
-0.029796132817864418,
-0.0723523274064064,
0.5305983424186707,
-0.6881716847419739,
-0.09290952980518341,
0.3415903151035309,
-0.1743815839290619,
0.48869001865386963,
-0.46775978803634644,
-0.5554607510566711,
-0.260416179895401,
-0.5214435458183289,
0.6681929230690002,
0.6575824618339539,
-0.601852297782898,
0.3696814179420471,
0.4831008017063141,
-0.21061775088310242,
-0.5493459105491638,
-1.0253946781158447,
0.08184440433979034,
-0.46291738748550415,
-0.18400147557258606,
0.5722559094429016,
-0.10475821793079376,
-0.16167166829109192,
0.23172339797019958,
-0.053479764610528946,
-0.15464092791080475,
0.13150137662887573,
0.23306268453598022,
0.31170955300331116,
0.009037131443619728,
0.20265524089336395,
0.4813113212585449,
-0.033867474645376205,
-0.22931373119354248,
-0.4113506078720093,
0.09330831468105316,
0.13420195877552032,
-0.39489278197288513,
-0.25404635071754456,
0.2599267065525055,
0.1172950491309166,
0.19293589890003204,
0.6625979542732239,
0.5157734751701355,
-0.28691694140434265,
-0.5708758234977722,
-0.3270339071750641,
-0.2827419638633728,
-0.48616936802864075,
0.21606631577014923,
-0.14902682602405548,
-0.9739951491355896,
0.00968975480645895,
-0.24149680137634277,
0.2850937247276306,
0.35383257269859314,
0.6817922592163086,
-0.3699648976325989,
0.6546919941902161,
0.8987059593200684,
-0.21309135854244232,
0.7851232290267944,
-0.0912066176533699,
-0.09393583238124847,
-0.3502900004386902,
-0.2600954473018646,
-0.5163549780845642,
-0.39032459259033203,
-0.5514023303985596,
-0.5333880186080933,
0.0923072099685669,
0.061696309596300125,
0.4426387548446655,
0.1932583749294281,
-0.593447208404541,
0.5357452630996704,
0.5733357071876526,
0.08154855668544769,
0.3381476402282715,
0.37333372235298157,
-0.08151553571224213,
-0.12320412695407867,
-0.5058773756027222,
-0.6894694566726685,
1.3469868898391724,
0.18861031532287598,
0.7348748445510864,
-0.07105846703052521,
1.1112420558929443,
0.5345718264579773,
0.8847485780715942,
-0.6836048364639282,
0.4774142801761627,
-0.39818671345710754,
-0.7425394058227539,
-0.013738010078668594,
-0.587414026260376,
-0.911037266254425,
0.35430431365966797,
-0.5661861300468445,
-0.5377731919288635,
0.11247504502534866,
0.4156508445739746,
0.4565232992172241,
0.8460347652435303,
-0.8752703070640564,
0.6553717851638794,
0.17751529812812805,
-0.19301263988018036,
0.13469447195529938,
-0.6389036178588867,
0.5853515267372131,
-0.4747127592563629,
0.31173673272132874,
0.10441502928733826,
-0.05658707767724991,
0.8854438066482544,
-0.33875077962875366,
1.2816323041915894,
-0.10123448073863983,
-0.16104018688201904,
0.41189253330230713,
-0.0505964420735836,
0.4134315550327301,
-0.15148480236530304,
0.010134279727935791,
-0.05643982067704201,
-0.32621267437934875,
-0.6763644814491272,
-0.365836501121521,
0.6438711285591125,
-0.3996633291244507,
-0.4035234749317169,
-0.480165034532547,
-0.21987897157669067,
-0.1584828644990921,
0.38811641931533813,
0.45071083307266235,
0.24822445213794708,
-0.41806986927986145,
-0.00024880885030142963,
0.7240922451019287,
0.11186717450618744,
0.40853843092918396,
0.107626773416996,
-0.05468393489718437,
-0.35608550906181335,
1.2298344373703003,
-0.12446542084217072,
0.2648927569389343,
0.6409895420074463,
-0.013180217705667019,
-0.246015265583992,
-0.786022424697876,
-0.3644089102745056,
0.16742771863937378,
-0.7442795038223267,
-0.4027402997016907,
-0.6932393312454224,
-0.1905837506055832,
-0.23473361134529114,
-0.5239771008491516,
-0.20049065351486206,
-0.48006004095077515,
-0.6490362882614136,
-0.3018267750740051,
0.042157404124736786,
0.7149916887283325,
-0.04393581300973892,
0.33823972940444946,
-0.8077871203422546,
0.3344345688819885,
0.32857266068458557,
0.40295153856277466,
0.005849551875144243,
-0.37901005148887634,
-0.24045208096504211,
-0.17241989076137543,
-0.4888004958629608,
-1.061978816986084,
0.18611682951450348,
-0.0013794713886454701,
0.4040619730949402,
0.3703804910182953,
0.3015640676021576,
0.3543148636817932,
-0.4457172155380249,
0.44318991899490356,
0.49485069513320923,
-0.9206274747848511,
0.4151391386985779,
-0.1561627835035324,
-0.15243659913539886,
0.7480409145355225,
0.21447929739952087,
-0.24644294381141663,
-1.1373189687728882,
-0.6950101852416992,
-1.029115080833435,
0.7820002436637878,
0.49469026923179626,
0.37130430340766907,
0.11601974070072174,
0.16523568332195282,
0.2073879837989807,
0.026548899710178375,
-1.0344785451889038,
-0.4222659170627594,
-0.40317094326019287,
-0.6154776811599731,
-0.1608196496963501,
-0.28996485471725464,
-0.06810050457715988,
-0.04201747104525566,
0.6606103777885437,
-0.14115439355373383,
0.07402189075946808,
0.057673074305057526,
-0.35602644085884094,
0.07862631231546402,
0.3014727830886841,
0.35886362195014954,
0.19637593626976013,
-0.2720184028148651,
0.49748870730400085,
0.24943411350250244,
-0.6254897713661194,
0.28103315830230713,
0.050340697169303894,
-0.5140284299850464,
0.09520427882671356,
0.5093116760253906,
0.503591001033783,
-0.02911040559411049,
-0.5108477473258972,
0.7483359575271606,
0.09553685039281845,
-0.3495974838733673,
-0.08250265568494797,
0.028865300118923187,
-0.02407979406416416,
-0.010688330046832561,
0.5203087329864502,
0.3368631899356842,
0.12430596351623535,
-0.5530024766921997,
0.26296019554138184,
0.3696441352367401,
-0.7340908050537109,
-0.39539724588394165,
0.5983144044876099,
0.37525561451911926,
-0.08979415148496628,
0.38638779520988464,
-0.19103661179542542,
-0.4445289671421051,
0.5104199051856995,
0.6991814970970154,
0.7324246764183044,
-0.034168414771556854,
0.19528445601463318,
0.1395895779132843,
0.3815169036388397,
-0.16950179636478424,
-0.1797475665807724,
-0.14073927700519562,
-0.4513600468635559,
-0.3102587163448334,
-0.6205248236656189,
-0.3307020664215088,
-0.1202884241938591,
-0.4207518994808197,
0.48248082399368286,
-0.4142330586910248,
-0.08418256044387817,
-0.23939065635204315,
-0.3511837422847748,
-0.2073899656534195,
0.24023641645908356,
-0.014909520745277405,
0.6403778791427612,
-1.1858699321746826,
0.6421734690666199,
0.9119484424591064,
-0.09195318818092346,
-0.30771976709365845,
0.21642525494098663,
-0.06358575075864792,
-0.49137255549430847,
0.36525896191596985,
0.2286481261253357,
0.21878528594970703,
-0.10937947779893875,
-0.5125304460525513,
-0.2653111517429352,
0.8072668313980103,
0.406402051448822,
-0.48781827092170715,
0.062134698033332825,
0.061535775661468506,
0.5660129189491272,
0.03227521851658821,
0.08364175260066986,
0.05043649673461914,
0.331192284822464,
0.0775381326675415,
-0.624336302280426,
0.1870902180671692,
-0.17263320088386536,
-0.2189992517232895,
0.47497326135635376,
-0.6272422075271606,
0.5238174200057983,
-0.20431898534297943,
-0.2737121284008026,
0.08040482550859451,
0.8167097568511963,
0.156956747174263,
0.6799163818359375,
0.5519200563430786,
0.5354596376419067,
0.746558427810669,
0.05751410499215126,
0.8253385424613953,
0.3133896291255951,
0.3289423882961273,
0.8783353567123413,
0.012046614661812782,
0.5157581567764282,
0.4408896863460541,
-0.2728768289089203,
0.6141955256462097,
0.5449525117874146,
-0.23593731224536896,
0.5641237497329712,
0.3276920020580292,
-0.5006961226463318,
-0.012913160026073456,
-0.1971013993024826,
-0.4857768714427948,
0.14493174850940704,
0.09221246838569641,
-0.45826223492622375,
-0.13902446627616882,
0.021061543375253677,
0.012175234965980053,
0.2564102113246918,
-0.33680248260498047,
0.7783336043357849,
0.39051389694213867,
-0.13248984515666962,
0.2956234812736511,
0.3014468252658844,
1.0956389904022217,
-0.408182829618454,
0.0007753102690912783,
-0.3616955578327179,
0.24822275340557098,
-0.4721244275569916,
-0.6620931625366211,
0.4462641179561615,
0.08775880187749863,
-0.34805828332901,
-0.6645048260688782,
1.0517704486846924,
-0.49068304896354675,
-0.545289933681488,
0.2548036575317383,
0.4687005579471588,
0.2730356454849243,
0.2555876076221466,
-0.5126237869262695,
-0.30837783217430115,
0.16464978456497192,
0.012724007479846478,
0.7640697956085205,
0.46055302023887634,
-0.38767296075820923,
0.4675918221473694,
0.721892774105072,
0.24716120958328247,
0.1175706759095192,
-0.09529726952314377,
0.9293371438980103,
-0.7579795718193054,
-0.4628514051437378,
-1.014533281326294,
0.11875106394290924,
-0.07438180595636368,
-0.22177989780902863,
0.7709463834762573,
0.761435866355896,
0.8863614797592163,
-0.11101191490888596,
0.8878482580184937,
-0.0023211264051496983,
0.3597950339317322,
-0.44377055764198303,
0.6772944927215576,
-0.6403860449790955,
0.14605021476745605,
-0.7662737369537354,
-1.151141881942749,
-0.4386717975139618,
0.28080227971076965,
0.22636081278324127,
-0.11192850768566132,
0.6245683431625366,
0.5130301117897034,
-0.41953402757644653,
-0.2518901824951172,
0.14310476183891296,
0.021055161952972412,
0.17387495934963226,
0.5448442101478577,
0.887181282043457,
-0.18174849450588226,
1.09489905834198,
-0.2307228296995163,
-0.264748752117157,
-0.19853712618350983,
-0.8226398825645447,
-1.2733080387115479,
-0.42933976650238037,
-0.2576238214969635,
-0.36306360363960266,
-0.06962047517299652,
0.30903947353363037,
0.6876559853553772,
-0.6505347490310669,
-0.05664389207959175,
-0.21165333688259125,
0.5758369565010071,
-0.010469942353665829,
-0.33967113494873047,
0.4826548993587494,
-0.2229584902524948,
-0.9392926692962646,
0.19487588107585907,
0.13217921555042267,
0.6471166610717773,
-0.0756983757019043,
0.1929764449596405,
0.06988142430782318,
-0.2108079195022583,
0.4153856039047241,
0.16839377582073212,
-0.1170772984623909,
0.32965826988220215,
-0.3959493041038513,
-0.3200933039188385,
-0.12532170116901398,
1.0397228002548218,
-0.7296814918518066,
0.277029812335968,
0.36191606521606445,
0.6544060111045837,
0.812868595123291,
-0.030315065756440163,
0.40217843651771545,
-1.159277319908142,
0.39664068818092346,
0.517250657081604,
0.0577523410320282,
0.5260922312736511,
-0.17412926256656647,
0.3455222249031067,
0.8179352283477783,
-0.010157405398786068,
-1.2799129486083984,
0.28724896907806396,
-0.8616829514503479,
-0.5029415488243103,
1.1070919036865234,
-0.10566063225269318,
-0.032671041786670685,
-0.4334174692630768,
-0.2630532383918762,
0.30923986434936523,
-0.34364351630210876,
0.5746176242828369,
0.35642537474632263,
0.2725526690483093,
0.11593957990407944,
-0.21007859706878662,
0.5694560408592224,
0.5538961887359619,
-0.9470590353012085,
-0.0855417549610138,
0.21300958096981049,
0.25416722893714905,
-0.037384312599897385,
0.9579304456710815,
-0.20274190604686737,
-0.14517536759376526,
-0.22744834423065186,
-0.028363538905978203,
0.13166970014572144,
-0.12739050388336182,
0.020266959443688393,
0.42019933462142944,
-0.15996651351451874,
0.05149059370160103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11109v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11109v2 | Investigating Annotator Bias in Large Language Models for Hate Speech Detection | 2024-06-17T00:18:31 | 2024-06-18T06:21:16 | Amit Das, Zheng Zhang, Fatemeh Jamshidi, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha, Nilanjana Raychawdhary, Mary Sandage, Lauramarie Pope, Gerry Dozier, Cheryl Seals | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Data annotation, the practice of assigning descriptive labels to raw data, is
pivotal in optimizing the performance of machine learning models. However, it
is a resource-intensive process susceptible to biases introduced by annotators.
The emergence of sophisticated Large Language Models (LLMs), like ChatGPT
presents a unique opportunity to modernize and streamline this complex
procedure. While existing research extensively evaluates the efficacy of LLMs,
as annotators, this paper delves into the biases present in LLMs, specifically
GPT 3.5 and GPT 4o when annotating hate speech data. Our research contributes
to understanding biases in four key categories: gender, race, religion, and
disability. Specifically targeting highly vulnerable groups within these
categories, we analyze annotator biases. Furthermore, we conduct a
comprehensive examination of potential factors contributing to these biases by
scrutinizing the annotated data. We introduce our custom hate speech detection
dataset, HateSpeechCorpus, to conduct this research. Additionally, we perform
the same experiments on the ETHOS (Mollas et al., 2022) dataset also for
comparative analysis. This paper serves as a crucial resource, guiding
researchers and practitioners in harnessing the potential of LLMs for
dataannotation, thereby fostering advancements in this critical field. The
HateSpeechCorpus dataset is available here:
https://github.com/AmitDasRup123/HateSpeechCorpus | [
-0.5684788227081299,
-0.8388491272926331,
0.1359139233827591,
-0.06758614629507065,
-0.16343462467193604,
0.15627282857894897,
-0.29257088899612427,
-0.6949971914291382,
0.144029438495636,
0.5964358448982239,
-0.3343837261199951,
-0.3324962258338928,
-0.9046737551689148,
0.003226564032956958,
-0.33982518315315247,
1.541418194770813,
0.08232592046260834,
0.09134510159492493,
0.14008182287216187,
-0.2893303632736206,
-0.3145509958267212,
-0.8934127688407898,
-0.6795822978019714,
-0.33462807536125183,
0.6680654287338257,
-0.014819847419857979,
0.7938590049743652,
0.48476871848106384,
0.2859809696674347,
0.18731284141540527,
-0.3284516930580139,
-0.20029670000076294,
-0.5939471125602722,
0.3271920084953308,
0.07466347515583038,
-0.31882646679878235,
-0.1897391378879547,
0.09571206569671631,
0.3518727421760559,
0.3696877062320709,
0.15118005871772766,
0.25648871064186096,
-0.043522559106349945,
0.09669867157936096,
-0.5706022381782532,
0.23581083118915558,
-0.9849829077720642,
0.2201329618692398,
-0.642245352268219,
-0.024421142414212227,
-0.25064876675605774,
-0.4643109440803528,
0.1414089798927307,
-0.4676377475261688,
0.4366743862628937,
0.09746986627578735,
0.47731879353523254,
0.3953301012516022,
-0.26484355330467224,
-0.3568572402000427,
-0.6119616627693176,
0.6949661374092102,
-0.5573330521583557,
0.34083420038223267,
0.4601425528526306,
0.19095809757709503,
-0.0464768148958683,
-0.1700577586889267,
-0.7136488556861877,
-0.3337087333202362,
0.10589557141065598,
-0.15853214263916016,
-0.31231755018234253,
0.06791635602712631,
0.6250857710838318,
0.3267931342124939,
-0.3511715829372406,
0.6097807288169861,
-0.43811583518981934,
-0.436799019575119,
0.6063236594200134,
-0.04836561158299446,
0.300583153963089,
-0.2060890942811966,
-0.27285036444664,
0.19914385676383972,
-0.6424345374107361,
-0.4234885573387146,
0.7217473983764648,
0.4427166283130646,
0.014217344112694263,
0.5669857263565063,
0.008730607107281685,
0.5031382441520691,
-0.25963592529296875,
0.12598982453346252,
0.47044411301612854,
0.19318757951259613,
-0.04126673564314842,
0.19754397869110107,
0.8701147437095642,
0.42850956320762634,
0.792356550693512,
-0.15813048183918,
-0.16010649502277374,
0.21386070549488068,
0.30041375756263733,
-0.6346941590309143,
-0.2724868357181549,
0.034278951585292816,
-0.09955470263957977,
-0.46157950162887573,
-0.5992214679718018,
-0.9227649569511414,
-0.9742063879966736,
-0.24116066098213196,
0.1874188780784607,
-0.3735111355781555,
-0.29368630051612854,
-0.45622509717941284,
-0.09187185019254684,
0.07133425027132034,
0.24356795847415924,
-0.9576399326324463,
0.1835804283618927,
0.666262686252594,
0.816451370716095,
-0.4009462594985962,
-0.16302534937858582,
-0.6421614289283752,
0.035427525639534,
-0.150553360581398,
0.6792368292808533,
-0.7516860961914062,
-0.2611161172389984,
0.216446653008461,
-0.3813815414905548,
0.12347882241010666,
-0.7094680666923523,
0.7937260866165161,
-0.5704395174980164,
0.018889958038926125,
-0.2324565052986145,
-0.5322323441505432,
-0.142791748046875,
0.27614983916282654,
-0.6272813081741333,
1.0179667472839355,
0.09099185466766357,
-1.0312379598617554,
0.6275191903114319,
-0.8208060264587402,
-0.22588960826396942,
0.2524685859680176,
-0.36888593435287476,
-0.7111436128616333,
-0.03753386065363884,
0.2264707386493683,
0.37227511405944824,
-0.15268531441688538,
0.2722269594669342,
-0.5776094198226929,
-0.19398239254951477,
0.36524999141693115,
-0.37420693039894104,
0.7195791006088257,
0.23870857059955597,
-0.541227400302887,
0.24120867252349854,
-0.5735065340995789,
-0.5780980587005615,
0.311447411775589,
-0.009040160104632378,
-0.43306460976600647,
-0.05103069543838501,
0.38918930292129517,
0.3054409921169281,
-0.27579838037490845,
-0.7910032868385315,
-0.09539814293384552,
-0.05182300880551338,
0.4096887409687042,
1.07562255859375,
-0.21763348579406738,
0.06276720762252808,
-0.10929565131664276,
0.6753525733947754,
0.026827458292245865,
0.18073873221874237,
0.0911596417427063,
-0.4869518578052521,
-0.49787425994873047,
-0.36930471658706665,
0.13407176733016968,
0.3814222514629364,
-0.45695847272872925,
-0.0897052064538002,
-0.05147583410143852,
-0.40551993250846863,
-0.5132887959480286,
-0.01577574573457241,
0.21403208374977112,
0.468666136264801,
0.4192383289337158,
-0.06665495038032532,
-0.773949384689331,
-1.1924906969070435,
-0.4212345480918884,
-0.11737954616546631,
0.025105716660618782,
0.27312394976615906,
0.5803154110908508,
-0.07723170518875122,
0.8825051784515381,
-0.2866653501987457,
-0.438228577375412,
-0.23550434410572052,
0.11731112748384476,
-0.19070826470851898,
0.2389962077140808,
0.5326622128486633,
-0.8986063003540039,
-0.39013436436653137,
-0.21355648338794708,
-0.33018696308135986,
-0.5206382870674133,
0.13516072928905487,
0.0866439938545227,
0.3372645378112793,
0.31332412362098694,
-0.28130823373794556,
0.4284360110759735,
0.6314221024513245,
-0.2538312077522278,
0.6709147691726685,
0.6181582808494568,
0.07266969233751297,
-0.7360938191413879,
-0.13415485620498657,
0.2244204729795456,
-0.1260215938091278,
-0.7763784527778625,
-0.22561043500900269,
-0.4051326811313629,
0.06057120859622955,
-0.4279997646808624,
0.2694951295852661,
-0.08424241095781326,
-0.0071067288517951965,
-0.28605929017066956,
0.233623206615448,
-0.5515942573547363,
0.27601030468940735,
0.08115987479686737,
0.745190441608429,
0.2404295802116394,
-0.28623566031455994,
0.229050412774086,
0.2833924889564514,
-0.18268325924873352,
0.5497897267341614,
-0.4463198482990265,
0.18155011534690857,
-0.08672135323286057,
0.3660130202770233,
-0.9635213613510132,
-0.1480778455734253,
0.5813259482383728,
-0.4458565413951874,
0.0040199244394898415,
-0.5810784697532654,
-0.6807150840759277,
-0.35209357738494873,
-0.2885048985481262,
0.42133575677871704,
0.2752479314804077,
-0.4500272870063782,
0.35183846950531006,
0.9244557023048401,
-0.1823192685842514,
-0.4720389246940613,
-0.8441560864448547,
0.08521753549575806,
-0.6227729916572571,
-0.21214492619037628,
0.005049249157309532,
0.0780750960111618,
-0.42247655987739563,
-0.3081373870372772,
0.08389781415462494,
-0.11420534551143646,
0.04450837895274162,
0.5104190111160278,
0.24910324811935425,
0.08603569120168686,
0.11902987211942673,
-0.29298171401023865,
-0.038495615124702454,
0.3022972643375397,
-0.024885106831789017,
0.6617297530174255,
0.17043757438659668,
-0.22584128379821777,
-0.04909811541438103,
0.10991537570953369,
0.4293075203895569,
-0.1282115876674652,
0.6615736484527588,
0.8567146062850952,
-0.3317793011665344,
-0.03701815754175186,
-0.8344404697418213,
0.04654451087117195,
-0.3627692461013794,
0.5110130310058594,
-0.1278681606054306,
-1.3325445652008057,
0.6504532098770142,
0.41218072175979614,
0.15886190533638,
0.39748048782348633,
0.7756946086883545,
0.32184261083602905,
0.829193115234375,
0.2590583264827728,
-0.36481326818466187,
0.5499856472015381,
0.038634467869997025,
0.2941642105579376,
-0.8990022540092468,
-0.11386854946613312,
-0.585218071937561,
-0.06420904397964478,
-0.8344746232032776,
-0.5099349617958069,
0.2801631987094879,
-0.44980186223983765,
-0.29988402128219604,
-0.04359300062060356,
-0.5919087529182434,
0.45725059509277344,
0.3432645797729492,
-0.22833603620529175,
0.13540025055408478,
0.1453891545534134,
0.22317130863666534,
-0.39822307229042053,
-0.47579291462898254,
-0.5551117658615112,
1.2201956510543823,
0.6472712755203247,
0.3394116759300232,
0.0013637510128319263,
0.47229117155075073,
0.38729506731033325,
0.6595168113708496,
-0.7355806231498718,
0.36365336179733276,
0.03263905644416809,
-0.9659632444381714,
-0.12030324339866638,
-0.4173141121864319,
-0.6238335967063904,
0.4620794653892517,
-0.10188539326190948,
-1.02016019821167,
0.09927263110876083,
0.33586791157722473,
-0.2331729233264923,
0.6868297457695007,
-0.5927855372428894,
0.8246616125106812,
0.022644151002168655,
-0.4122943878173828,
0.018112802878022194,
-0.2057599425315857,
0.5398203730583191,
-0.3642210364341736,
0.4058501720428467,
-0.4561866819858551,
0.02131984755396843,
1.0786172151565552,
-0.23695823550224304,
1.0730254650115967,
-0.42912283539772034,
-0.3245534300804138,
0.1837538480758667,
0.06005008518695831,
0.5338872671127319,
-0.2565072476863861,
-0.26917871832847595,
0.517380952835083,
-0.35546547174453735,
-0.2397039383649826,
-0.12679049372673035,
0.624963641166687,
-0.6270515322685242,
-0.40369725227355957,
-0.552513062953949,
-0.6197251677513123,
-0.29063016176223755,
0.043227411806583405,
0.15723563730716705,
0.0854765921831131,
-0.1464010328054428,
-0.17063719034194946,
0.5538154244422913,
-0.3463509678840637,
0.18473581969738007,
0.4166451692581177,
-0.351433664560318,
-0.29381898045539856,
0.8625284433364868,
0.5007554292678833,
0.26357078552246094,
-0.08124233782291412,
0.10609780251979828,
-0.1316341757774353,
-0.8096796274185181,
-0.37773165106773376,
0.0776592493057251,
-0.5125665664672852,
-0.0852101743221283,
-0.8612477779388428,
-0.23420219123363495,
-0.3882855474948883,
0.09812972694635391,
-0.34526339173316956,
-0.3051441013813019,
-0.06261160224676132,
-0.20738756656646729,
0.5820382237434387,
0.7571752667427063,
-0.07234454900026321,
0.48194605112075806,
-0.06756655126810074,
0.23924775421619415,
0.05253678187727928,
0.43866434693336487,
-0.004220681730657816,
-0.7257505655288696,
-0.2316998839378357,
-0.060292087495326996,
-0.3015792965888977,
-0.8033027648925781,
0.2564542293548584,
-0.32542890310287476,
0.3234914243221283,
0.12027287483215332,
0.021184280514717102,
0.4717617928981781,
-0.5244770646095276,
0.8408927917480469,
-0.09303013980388641,
-0.7637777924537659,
0.40721607208251953,
-0.5900236964225769,
-0.077082559466362,
0.4221403896808624,
0.5503972768783569,
-0.7334563732147217,
-0.6308718323707581,
-0.6102977395057678,
-0.929695725440979,
0.7845432758331299,
0.3942899703979492,
0.1282580941915512,
-0.12220636755228043,
0.12515054643154144,
0.3035881817340851,
0.14115683734416962,
-0.8961067199707031,
-0.5451160073280334,
-0.14766615629196167,
0.031207581982016563,
0.02009444497525692,
-0.6286715865135193,
-0.16423362493515015,
-0.0537443682551384,
0.806343674659729,
0.030098089948296547,
0.08716752380132675,
-0.12912487983703613,
-0.18091915547847748,
0.038293808698654175,
0.3784608244895935,
0.5090683698654175,
0.5725469589233398,
-0.09310586750507355,
0.05281241983175278,
0.38153180480003357,
-0.6142885684967041,
-0.06462427228689194,
0.4516142010688782,
-0.33334365487098694,
0.06303215771913528,
0.3085477352142334,
0.9240310788154602,
-0.07905812561511993,
-0.5297117233276367,
0.5162842273712158,
0.17542442679405212,
-0.08726775646209717,
-0.6534756422042847,
-0.02133289724588394,
-0.2665368318557739,
0.20745159685611725,
0.3395195007324219,
-0.19235020875930786,
0.23516899347305298,
-0.05558865889906883,
0.1367262303829193,
0.43182963132858276,
-0.4689040780067444,
-0.3090636730194092,
0.6890981793403625,
0.1312588006258011,
-0.172006756067276,
0.35929974913597107,
-0.029542721807956696,
-0.8252646923065186,
0.34195128083229065,
0.43917545676231384,
0.8677105903625488,
-0.4546528458595276,
0.20154674351215363,
0.22718913853168488,
0.44259148836135864,
0.3862484395503998,
-0.15459096431732178,
-0.0894056111574173,
-0.743332028388977,
-0.517112672328949,
-0.6807823181152344,
-0.5146851539611816,
0.5422240495681763,
-0.4575219750404358,
0.12983918190002441,
-0.3900465667247772,
-0.10317958891391754,
0.3359847068786621,
-0.1476624608039856,
-0.6063570976257324,
0.07797443866729736,
0.7489659786224365,
0.607327401638031,
-1.045400619506836,
0.5222162008285522,
0.3785431683063507,
-0.3380219042301178,
-0.4883935749530792,
0.09178749471902847,
0.4571300446987152,
-1.049149751663208,
0.7983739376068115,
0.18454457819461823,
0.08244871348142624,
-0.25271883606910706,
-0.4279235303401947,
-0.5351362824440002,
0.33505308628082275,
0.3277701139450073,
-0.7104637026786804,
0.3225324749946594,
0.6414425373077393,
0.6306552290916443,
-0.2597455084323883,
0.44178852438926697,
0.7667340040206909,
0.41835373640060425,
-0.1270834356546402,
-0.9525796175003052,
0.031892385333776474,
0.02062378078699112,
0.038804277777671814,
0.27213481068611145,
-0.5877480506896973,
0.5490049719810486,
0.05792924389243126,
0.19711142778396606,
-0.47042393684387207,
0.33654463291168213,
0.2632664442062378,
0.2585172951221466,
0.6422091126441956,
0.5202680826187134,
0.6002349257469177,
-0.07869857549667358,
0.941108763217926,
0.22395266592502594,
0.22333011031150818,
1.313339352607727,
-0.24500758945941925,
0.5325654149055481,
0.4676373302936554,
-0.2811255156993866,
0.1481163054704666,
0.5479416847229004,
-0.1339869499206543,
0.03435477614402771,
0.7165299654006958,
-0.4422558844089508,
0.009312313981354237,
-0.46361106634140015,
-0.21784833073616028,
0.5255714654922485,
0.3819148540496826,
-0.5811191201210022,
-0.16584818065166473,
0.15248167514801025,
0.47892919182777405,
-0.12690582871437073,
-0.22610989212989807,
0.6909360289573669,
-0.1046828180551529,
-0.22896723449230194,
0.43204933404922485,
-0.28769028186798096,
0.8315987586975098,
-0.46762996912002563,
0.14539338648319244,
-0.07192139327526093,
-0.03135944530367851,
-0.33907952904701233,
-0.8317288160324097,
0.43342047929763794,
0.4871689975261688,
-0.0992777869105339,
-0.027594828978180885,
0.4059636890888214,
-0.3536086082458496,
-0.22702091932296753,
0.3396710157394409,
0.0636233314871788,
0.28860709071159363,
-0.41406068205833435,
-0.7428768873214722,
0.6893858909606934,
0.23747318983078003,
-0.35747194290161133,
0.3097917139530182,
0.3545854389667511,
-0.21540631353855133,
0.6144486665725708,
0.5819541811943054,
0.31981512904167175,
0.23739904165267944,
0.3048858344554901,
0.9144944548606873,
-0.552769124507904,
-0.245231494307518,
-1.1525602340698242,
0.1840936839580536,
-0.1540585309267044,
-0.4234902858734131,
0.8657369017601013,
0.8761847615242004,
1.0226633548736572,
0.2770703434944153,
1.1840064525604248,
0.024752750992774963,
0.8237736225128174,
-0.17318305373191833,
0.6311671733856201,
-0.06648877263069153,
0.2406018078327179,
-0.5386218428611755,
-0.8267202377319336,
-0.5385681390762329,
0.4798113703727722,
-0.8452131748199463,
0.11493393033742905,
0.19741719961166382,
0.8112382292747498,
-0.07146686315536499,
0.3193511366844177,
0.24620945751667023,
0.5516053438186646,
0.7112339735031128,
0.1450808048248291,
0.9098379611968994,
-0.251120388507843,
0.624415397644043,
-0.291445255279541,
-0.1270182579755783,
-0.1905783861875534,
-0.6696110963821411,
-0.9178748726844788,
-0.4437378942966461,
-0.590700089931488,
-0.3856760263442993,
0.1780998855829239,
0.9969897866249084,
0.5417196750640869,
-0.9125864505767822,
-0.06613314896821976,
0.21586866676807404,
0.03355097770690918,
0.3642885088920593,
-0.2867596447467804,
0.2902732193470001,
-0.19703646004199982,
-0.7761402130126953,
-0.12561096251010895,
0.09426116198301315,
-0.08642854541540146,
-0.22732457518577576,
0.06602957844734192,
-0.06725655496120453,
-0.1687277853488922,
0.6519209742546082,
0.2516809105873108,
-0.8655098080635071,
-0.42611604928970337,
-0.7354568243026733,
0.1729835569858551,
0.045565277338027954,
0.8131213188171387,
-0.6815229058265686,
0.33867788314819336,
-0.05988309532403946,
0.7159643173217773,
0.49324673414230347,
-0.2591962218284607,
0.330859899520874,
-0.5160168409347534,
0.1637962907552719,
0.3875817060470581,
0.23210206627845764,
0.6070401072502136,
-0.2327338308095932,
0.5682553052902222,
0.28550994396209717,
-0.6646254062652588,
-1.0708343982696533,
0.2171674221754074,
-0.722802460193634,
0.10407952219247818,
1.3456369638442993,
0.15400874614715576,
-0.10271156579256058,
-0.278510719537735,
-0.46327340602874756,
0.3306716978549957,
-0.6394548416137695,
0.8036445379257202,
0.7558562159538269,
-0.17137962579727173,
-0.19700036942958832,
-0.9158899188041687,
0.7500953674316406,
0.32795411348342896,
-0.5392930507659912,
0.579849362373352,
0.6853824257850647,
0.38009944558143616,
0.06756848841905594,
0.5449778437614441,
-0.12243381887674332,
-0.026770323514938354,
-0.1399565488100052,
0.27321380376815796,
-0.055832937359809875,
0.23552273213863373,
-0.4278012216091156,
0.11138202250003815,
0.07013218849897385,
-0.13641996681690216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11107v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11107v1 | Exploring Safety-Utility Trade-Offs in Personalized Language Models | 2024-06-17T00:17:11 | 2024-06-17T00:17:11 | Anvesh Rao Vijjini, Somnath Basu Roy Chowdhury, Snigdha Chaturvedi | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) become increasingly integrated into daily
applications, it is essential to ensure they operate fairly across diverse user
demographics. In this work, we show that LLMs suffer from personalization bias,
where their performance is impacted when they are personalized to a user's
identity. We quantify personalization bias by evaluating the performance of
LLMs along two axes - safety and utility. We measure safety by examining how
benign LLM responses are to unsafe prompts with and without personalization. We
measure utility by evaluating the LLM's performance on various tasks, including
general knowledge, mathematical abilities, programming, and reasoning skills.
We find that various LLMs, ranging from open-source models like Llama (Touvron
et al., 2023) and Mistral (Jiang et al., 2023) to API-based ones like GPT-3.5
and GPT-4o (Ouyang et al., 2022), exhibit significant variance in performance
in terms of safety-utility trade-offs depending on the user's identity.
Finally, we discuss several strategies to mitigate personalization bias using
preference tuning and prompt-based defenses. | [
-0.2061571627855301,
-0.6045252084732056,
0.7141956090927124,
0.0816085934638977,
0.06289374828338623,
0.14981213212013245,
-0.18850134313106537,
-0.44389548897743225,
-0.2125658392906189,
0.7500206232070923,
-0.3118106424808502,
-0.573261559009552,
-0.5827793478965759,
0.0037584626115858555,
-0.03591223433613777,
1.0739229917526245,
0.23872099816799164,
-0.16757383942604065,
-0.1893661767244339,
0.13017547130584717,
-0.6492262482643127,
-0.858279824256897,
-0.6358006000518799,
-0.2480737268924713,
0.6119163632392883,
0.2341124713420868,
0.8752426505088806,
0.637278139591217,
0.2971740663051605,
0.318804532289505,
-0.245977520942688,
-0.4678579270839691,
-0.3757477402687073,
0.3389519155025482,
-0.22973889112472534,
-0.3766741156578064,
-0.6009912490844727,
0.010103760287165642,
0.3965047299861908,
0.6364313364028931,
0.13354921340942383,
0.07314451783895493,
0.1263362169265747,
0.4667224586009979,
-0.6585640907287598,
0.10042533278465271,
-0.711273193359375,
-0.1314721405506134,
-0.31001585721969604,
-0.18193800747394562,
-0.5400223135948181,
-0.701850414276123,
0.2787063717842102,
-0.44415318965911865,
-0.05442003160715103,
0.11668190360069275,
0.4765738546848297,
0.2591198980808258,
-0.6289359331130981,
-0.2255893051624298,
-0.6772014498710632,
0.9732329845428467,
-0.7129977941513062,
0.23770660161972046,
0.5799106359481812,
0.31216713786125183,
-0.1489909589290619,
-0.28806057572364807,
-0.18361476063728333,
-0.4936596155166626,
0.03811915963888168,
-0.17013926804065704,
-0.2062825858592987,
0.25562652945518494,
0.32624831795692444,
0.023744432255625725,
-0.5161876082420349,
0.5209625959396362,
-0.06326600909233093,
-0.39492782950401306,
0.6772814989089966,
0.31567880511283875,
0.363787442445755,
0.01934342086315155,
-0.29546260833740234,
-0.05529206991195679,
-0.8872286081314087,
0.5137932896614075,
0.8220219612121582,
0.23907603323459625,
-0.2218470722436905,
0.46354228258132935,
-0.213009312748909,
0.6459081768989563,
-0.05658102035522461,
-0.3280467689037323,
0.23875755071640015,
-0.12109334021806717,
-0.12393457442522049,
-0.005026975646615028,
0.8205227255821228,
0.46960848569869995,
0.6242388486862183,
-0.3429756462574005,
-0.044539157301187515,
-0.2054918259382248,
0.06079798936843872,
-0.6497533321380615,
-0.09959213435649872,
0.18870872259140015,
-0.49486681818962097,
-0.5670065879821777,
-0.35118380188941956,
-0.6246744990348816,
-0.6669420003890991,
-0.18585669994354248,
0.20124991238117218,
-0.22865727543830872,
-0.011463860981166363,
0.05735151469707489,
0.15148116648197174,
-0.17010445892810822,
0.21317225694656372,
-1.1508561372756958,
0.2753843665122986,
0.5902587175369263,
0.6393667459487915,
-0.44255203008651733,
-0.1347874402999878,
-0.6040796041488647,
0.3269696831703186,
-0.08220012485980988,
0.613828182220459,
-0.6194173693656921,
-0.6564116477966309,
0.19239582121372223,
-0.2562730312347412,
0.0658874660730362,
-0.44602999091148376,
0.6819866895675659,
-0.5611554980278015,
-0.0033875894732773304,
-0.5888103246688843,
-0.3694743812084198,
0.01787218078970909,
-0.0413333922624588,
-0.4752567708492279,
0.4492340087890625,
-0.21226075291633606,
-0.9861090183258057,
0.4254034757614136,
-0.5484923720359802,
-0.5220782160758972,
-0.023106049746274948,
-0.046248361468315125,
-0.18929354846477509,
0.08579061180353165,
-0.11434301733970642,
0.5316764116287231,
-0.27017197012901306,
0.2343100607395172,
-0.7150782942771912,
-0.3556763231754303,
0.6240049004554749,
-0.5373793840408325,
0.7340076565742493,
0.36657074093818665,
-0.2682745158672333,
0.2701111435890198,
-0.7832956314086914,
-0.055127859115600586,
0.08368084579706192,
-0.5669472217559814,
-0.7721198201179504,
0.053766392171382904,
0.17106108367443085,
0.20727132260799408,
0.49178895354270935,
-0.5298436284065247,
-0.04884852468967438,
-0.5012292861938477,
0.1938941478729248,
1.2387745380401611,
-0.28213101625442505,
0.45576760172843933,
-0.23588964343070984,
0.4796302318572998,
-0.05063490569591522,
0.18951553106307983,
-0.037960946559906006,
-0.5690784454345703,
-0.4831241965293884,
-0.17095054686069489,
0.09540437906980515,
0.6930976510047913,
-0.38683226704597473,
0.5175471901893616,
-0.03339293226599693,
-0.02674928307533264,
-0.061738383024930954,
0.22306573390960693,
0.5128775835037231,
0.45441746711730957,
0.025677524507045746,
-0.17567844688892365,
-0.2136421650648117,
-1.0978189706802368,
-0.8135809898376465,
-0.32220837473869324,
-0.2542518675327301,
0.4544790983200073,
-0.0030671926215291023,
-0.3282662332057953,
1.0645780563354492,
-0.6675151586532593,
0.03397606313228607,
-0.2335929423570633,
-0.20663700997829437,
0.07777031511068344,
0.30172857642173767,
0.692366898059845,
-0.5081047415733337,
-0.5289842486381531,
0.16382041573524475,
-0.5216490626335144,
-0.5120540261268616,
-0.06937859207391739,
-0.055314768105745316,
0.2433629333972931,
0.168631911277771,
-0.47186577320098877,
0.1900595873594284,
0.590433657169342,
-0.6324015855789185,
0.4194382131099701,
-0.17029039561748505,
-0.11367854475975037,
-1.054547905921936,
0.11198970675468445,
0.2549864947795868,
-0.18742431700229645,
-0.9411982297897339,
-0.05598659813404083,
-0.08357971161603928,
0.2522585988044739,
-0.5463975667953491,
0.7887883186340332,
-0.1346185803413391,
-0.0011978186666965485,
-0.2827053368091583,
-0.09257935732603073,
-0.3386469781398773,
0.1606595814228058,
-0.10539332032203674,
0.9536176323890686,
0.4630742073059082,
-0.5456300377845764,
-0.16562670469284058,
0.07049828767776489,
-0.1568877100944519,
0.2984106242656708,
-0.8183780908584595,
0.31306615471839905,
0.0653548389673233,
-0.05761396884918213,
-0.7424173951148987,
-0.3847898542881012,
0.3525836765766144,
-0.13976268470287323,
0.17762336134910583,
-0.22248013317584991,
-0.3435077965259552,
0.016942916437983513,
-0.5589084625244141,
0.32535845041275024,
0.5808047652244568,
-0.41435426473617554,
0.4138046205043793,
0.6129050254821777,
-0.5846481323242188,
-0.6172230839729309,
-0.3791593909263611,
0.12050896137952805,
-0.4960116446018219,
-0.6352964639663696,
0.09835278242826462,
-0.45869165658950806,
-0.5683331489562988,
-0.2637028694152832,
0.062367986887693405,
0.02327764593064785,
0.4942522644996643,
0.4410993754863739,
0.3131115436553955,
0.27465736865997314,
-0.03073621541261673,
0.3192310929298401,
-0.23938357830047607,
0.2636328935623169,
0.04914393275976181,
0.5380897521972656,
-0.23316419124603271,
-0.3470514714717865,
-0.23361338675022125,
0.27981171011924744,
0.4776967763900757,
-0.029753025621175766,
0.7623012661933899,
0.2392864227294922,
-0.1657087653875351,
0.19491243362426758,
-0.6949443221092224,
0.024508295580744743,
-0.5871612429618835,
0.16555146872997284,
-0.3020678162574768,
-1.2736854553222656,
0.6184163689613342,
0.004968288354575634,
0.3194331228733063,
0.05581777170300484,
0.8764543533325195,
-0.042384304106235504,
1.1490352153778076,
0.5645102262496948,
-0.1918931007385254,
0.526934027671814,
0.27756792306900024,
0.2938556373119354,
-0.5953442454338074,
-0.21724717319011688,
-0.5414797067642212,
0.026264123618602753,
-0.7692798972129822,
-0.0006502494215965271,
0.3902018964290619,
-0.2561453878879547,
-0.5090887546539307,
0.08784251660108566,
-0.19764447212219238,
0.5256762504577637,
0.5553037524223328,
-0.10590086877346039,
0.48901888728141785,
0.010917581617832184,
-0.07088034600019455,
-0.1298520863056183,
-0.3634960949420929,
-0.7947385311126709,
1.3571480512619019,
0.7310676574707031,
1.1529178619384766,
0.27551910281181335,
0.7287513017654419,
0.29580336809158325,
0.30819013714790344,
-0.4716324806213379,
0.5224360823631287,
-0.1795726716518402,
-0.5443041920661926,
-0.21767601370811462,
-0.5782362222671509,
-1.0821906328201294,
0.29743698239326477,
-0.11708466708660126,
-1.0438592433929443,
-0.06938404589891434,
0.4666323661804199,
-0.4856368899345398,
0.1461697369813919,
-0.9389706254005432,
0.6179197430610657,
-0.5469929575920105,
-0.45161867141723633,
-0.0561494417488575,
-0.5750287175178528,
0.6958070993423462,
-0.27992528676986694,
0.3858512341976166,
-0.26835769414901733,
-0.09873753786087036,
0.4798206090927124,
0.026181593537330627,
1.0767323970794678,
-0.13407805562019348,
-0.17445813119411469,
-0.18951137363910675,
0.18857818841934204,
0.5656411051750183,
0.1499982625246048,
-0.03409920260310173,
0.3590225279331207,
0.00827634334564209,
-0.25404655933380127,
-0.26109424233436584,
1.1860969066619873,
-0.8198763132095337,
-0.9292405247688293,
-0.45709720253944397,
-0.6387947797775269,
-0.4252961277961731,
0.28767675161361694,
0.3080143332481384,
-0.01516240369528532,
-0.3396104574203491,
0.05669127777218819,
0.8404548764228821,
-0.6676313877105713,
0.5480322241783142,
0.448648065328598,
-0.10560505837202072,
-0.24221104383468628,
0.7416415214538574,
0.021351687610149384,
0.37555891275405884,
0.1984926462173462,
0.5026236176490784,
-0.4232001006603241,
-0.6035059690475464,
-0.2779614329338074,
0.07930684089660645,
-0.7428398728370667,
-0.011786997318267822,
-0.9080340266227722,
0.04639808461070061,
-0.33911818265914917,
-0.18803122639656067,
-0.16129696369171143,
-0.27732565999031067,
-0.3144354820251465,
-0.1012413427233696,
0.20863372087478638,
0.6509381532669067,
0.1667693853378296,
0.1925312876701355,
-0.7543622851371765,
0.04011537879705429,
0.41601818799972534,
0.5553594827651978,
-0.058424826711416245,
-0.3050367832183838,
-0.1492457538843155,
-0.27203938364982605,
-0.28623273968696594,
-0.7537916898727417,
0.2102266401052475,
-0.2466384619474411,
0.7836658954620361,
0.4634966254234314,
0.173453226685524,
-0.02943740226328373,
-0.5509725213050842,
0.7206117510795593,
0.3337765038013458,
-1.0163668394088745,
0.3575817346572876,
-0.47474247217178345,
0.1444091945886612,
0.46852946281433105,
0.23848497867584229,
-0.5134007930755615,
-0.30567532777786255,
-0.17902952432632446,
-0.822933554649353,
0.4901609420776367,
0.27369484305381775,
0.3980380892753601,
0.06299926340579987,
0.1698300689458847,
0.36003997921943665,
0.2071579098701477,
-0.9195175766944885,
-0.30899763107299805,
0.04383034631609917,
-0.044633835554122925,
-0.03194157034158707,
-0.47169560194015503,
-0.2571406662464142,
0.023492980748414993,
0.3257454037666321,
-0.22727695107460022,
-0.050211142748594284,
-0.4077915549278259,
0.006278356537222862,
0.03464744985103607,
0.7262596487998962,
0.7499427795410156,
0.42302924394607544,
-0.2159297913312912,
0.18568874895572662,
0.22011344134807587,
-0.40978315472602844,
0.32650890946388245,
-0.015498874709010124,
-0.43391117453575134,
-0.2946624457836151,
0.1973009556531906,
0.7675926685333252,
0.31089767813682556,
-0.7654821872711182,
0.3903287649154663,
-0.20620562136173248,
0.22565044462680817,
-0.1474822461605072,
0.3697375953197479,
0.09910561144351959,
0.07916553318500519,
0.07299346476793289,
0.2105090618133545,
0.3625829517841339,
-0.3011467158794403,
-0.1974928081035614,
0.6296773552894592,
0.02504871040582657,
-0.4736056625843048,
0.796907901763916,
0.3935621678829193,
-0.4408235549926758,
-0.10254573822021484,
0.14488056302070618,
-0.22788500785827637,
0.3936242461204529,
0.38108059763908386,
1.213645100593567,
-0.33563870191574097,
0.04715561121702194,
0.018749123439192772,
0.3132669925689697,
0.1341104954481125,
0.024463357403874397,
0.1643851101398468,
-0.6492298245429993,
-0.21443220973014832,
-0.4111311435699463,
-0.44645243883132935,
0.22190219163894653,
-0.42195019125938416,
0.09943592548370361,
-0.7030869126319885,
-0.478038489818573,
-0.24929307401180267,
-0.3006778657436371,
-0.7445034980773926,
-0.08920510113239288,
0.16593998670578003,
0.7181875705718994,
-0.7228074073791504,
0.7381818890571594,
0.6736879944801331,
-0.04945505037903786,
-0.4101138710975647,
0.3284234404563904,
0.14992082118988037,
-0.576301097869873,
0.6996307969093323,
-0.012173580005764961,
-0.2641277611255646,
-0.39431488513946533,
-0.1876971572637558,
-0.8470662236213684,
0.8957775831222534,
0.6983180642127991,
-0.7724040150642395,
0.017315741628408432,
0.3518332242965698,
0.5024381875991821,
-0.1488468050956726,
0.1717132031917572,
0.7223121523857117,
0.3710901737213135,
-0.2780032753944397,
-0.9917720556259155,
0.07493547350168228,
-0.02953753061592579,
0.3917669355869293,
-0.16965194046497345,
-0.6623387336730957,
0.737493097782135,
-0.26016664505004883,
-0.057416882365942,
-0.04646275192499161,
0.1748284548521042,
0.4659389853477478,
0.5400148630142212,
0.5735898017883301,
0.24179525673389435,
0.6036062240600586,
0.10416528582572937,
1.3798919916152954,
-0.40886634588241577,
0.14094381034374237,
0.9070292115211487,
-0.5305649638175964,
0.5773785710334778,
0.4485156238079071,
-0.2038796991109848,
0.16158196330070496,
0.5384641289710999,
0.5494948029518127,
0.7045848965644836,
0.11633653938770294,
-0.3995192348957062,
-0.37328779697418213,
-0.05046181380748749,
-0.4673903286457062,
0.16400781273841858,
0.020679164677858353,
-0.4293532371520996,
-0.02640978991985321,
-0.08659955859184265,
0.3598858714103699,
-0.01746371202170849,
-0.0007175309583544731,
0.7650576233863831,
0.20307254791259766,
-0.5237100124359131,
0.3645007610321045,
0.16854801774024963,
0.8615327477455139,
-0.5660803318023682,
0.3115762174129486,
-0.28312385082244873,
0.10077930986881256,
-0.08332497626543045,
-0.9822853803634644,
0.08871972560882568,
0.23032519221305847,
-0.2492050975561142,
-0.31110110878944397,
0.9122697114944458,
-0.07035411894321442,
-0.260076642036438,
0.41911593079566956,
0.3366592824459076,
-0.11374612152576447,
0.12736088037490845,
-0.493621826171875,
0.30201733112335205,
-0.03007759153842926,
-0.5241029262542725,
0.9249829649925232,
-0.05962558835744858,
-0.2076226770877838,
0.9816977977752686,
0.8929088711738586,
-0.023793723434209824,
0.12858399748802185,
0.09438923001289368,
0.9379347562789917,
-0.4059534966945648,
-0.637597918510437,
-1.0583120584487915,
0.42837581038475037,
-0.05701635777950287,
-0.3560604751110077,
0.8286930918693542,
0.4686669707298279,
0.7906880974769592,
-0.2644940912723541,
1.1805713176727295,
0.31494197249412537,
0.49913010001182556,
-0.6128773093223572,
0.9644824862480164,
-0.24107086658477783,
0.6992037892341614,
-0.4279155731201172,
-0.7769020199775696,
-0.21248014271259308,
0.3461304008960724,
-0.606238603591919,
0.2464364469051361,
0.18586698174476624,
0.6288121938705444,
0.15427163243293762,
-0.2326045036315918,
0.5678730010986328,
0.03736063838005066,
0.6497553586959839,
0.5559690594673157,
0.8431786894798279,
0.09892094880342484,
0.3310634195804596,
-0.18240785598754883,
-0.42888087034225464,
-0.2677362859249115,
-1.0111384391784668,
-1.2513197660446167,
-0.29115426540374756,
-0.1131276860833168,
-0.24866874516010284,
0.0796954557299614,
1.0767031908035278,
0.6488890647888184,
-0.8651056289672852,
-0.29740110039711,
0.21811272203922272,
0.2673792541027069,
0.2782937288284302,
-0.17587976157665253,
0.026633070781826973,
-0.23803748190402985,
-0.6080105900764465,
0.3250887989997864,
0.3526318073272705,
0.10655532777309418,
-0.22891318798065186,
-0.38066598773002625,
0.3811827301979065,
0.3040362596511841,
0.749919056892395,
0.3226557672023773,
-0.9789865016937256,
-0.48819541931152344,
0.09778150171041489,
-0.08277111500501633,
-0.11982441693544388,
0.9597413539886475,
-0.42751210927963257,
0.36310064792633057,
0.5236762166023254,
0.6665471792221069,
-0.02528424561023712,
-0.012033067643642426,
0.6693861484527588,
-0.5485170483589172,
0.06934741139411926,
0.07215509563684464,
0.350065141916275,
0.31171715259552,
-0.7606412768363953,
0.17517590522766113,
0.0399281308054924,
-0.7263004779815674,
-0.8254955410957336,
0.4461216628551483,
-0.936617374420166,
-0.1953737437725067,
1.336920142173767,
-0.27662551403045654,
0.32459890842437744,
-0.39873895049095154,
-0.3183099627494812,
-0.18190902471542358,
-0.6907217502593994,
0.9591460227966309,
0.5803866982460022,
-0.2079555094242096,
-0.20066246390342712,
-0.5756020545959473,
0.6907733082771301,
0.3324718177318573,
-1.0097118616104126,
0.15295766294002533,
0.4653051793575287,
0.7432512044906616,
-0.05805680528283119,
0.5923138856887817,
0.050440721213817596,
0.17453348636627197,
-0.5473191142082214,
-0.05562268942594528,
-0.12017624080181122,
-0.154250830411911,
-0.5419299006462097,
0.1634664088487625,
0.4523695111274719,
-0.002513042651116848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11106v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11106v1 | From Intentions to Techniques: A Comprehensive Taxonomy and Challenges in Text Watermarking for Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T00:09:31 | 2024-06-17T00:09:31 | Harsh Nishant Lalai, Aashish Anantha Ramakrishnan, Raj Sanjay Shah, Dongwon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the rapid growth of Large Language Models (LLMs), safeguarding textual
content against unauthorized use is crucial. Text watermarking offers a vital
solution, protecting both - LLM-generated and plain text sources. This paper
presents a unified overview of different perspectives behind designing
watermarking techniques, through a comprehensive survey of the research
literature. Our work has two key advantages, (1) we analyze research based on
the specific intentions behind different watermarking techniques, evaluation
datasets used, watermarking addition, and removal methods to construct a
cohesive taxonomy. (2) We highlight the gaps and open challenges in text
watermarking to promote research in protecting text authorship. This extensive
coverage and detailed analysis sets our work apart, offering valuable insights
into the evolving landscape of text watermarking in language models. | [
-0.024179955944418907,
-0.7426499128341675,
0.7868236899375916,
0.030229002237319946,
-0.49437040090560913,
0.16226518154144287,
-0.011721236631274223,
-0.5226589441299438,
0.06086676940321922,
1.0943944454193115,
-0.36412182450294495,
-0.3844341039657593,
-0.9670153260231018,
0.17720729112625122,
-0.6465370655059814,
0.9696794748306274,
-0.27161163091659546,
-0.1812199056148529,
-0.3392718732357025,
-0.12320391088724136,
-0.29885733127593994,
-0.7560019493103027,
-0.5467700362205505,
-0.1521819531917572,
0.5901216864585876,
0.12691864371299744,
0.4932882487773895,
0.7110159397125244,
0.6721440553665161,
0.24804234504699707,
-0.3534212112426758,
0.07538017630577087,
-0.3779308795928955,
0.5312792658805847,
-0.11348923295736313,
-0.3267139196395874,
-0.15541628003120422,
0.028078556060791016,
0.5621201395988464,
0.28272122144699097,
0.10415314882993698,
0.05881420150399208,
0.2832796275615692,
0.33826908469200134,
-0.9300603866577148,
-0.13027463853359222,
-0.5927983522415161,
-0.07414323836565018,
-0.5774350762367249,
-0.3081986606121063,
-0.6512092351913452,
-0.09532465040683746,
-0.015805194154381752,
-0.5203741788864136,
-0.2559226453304291,
0.1281469762325287,
0.7375940084457397,
0.01456095464527607,
-0.3959621489048004,
-0.6928718090057373,
-0.7946409583091736,
1.1253305673599243,
-0.7291847467422485,
0.07871358841657639,
0.2624090015888214,
-0.08039268851280212,
-0.059689074754714966,
-0.881624162197113,
-0.2421838939189911,
0.3199142515659332,
0.017488820478320122,
-0.0004966857959516346,
-0.3123077154159546,
-0.021187182515859604,
0.2287828028202057,
0.409771203994751,
-0.29749682545661926,
0.11428277939558029,
0.11913327872753143,
-0.19775764644145966,
0.9071788191795349,
0.08202768862247467,
0.6558451652526855,
-0.06997742503881454,
-0.5728277564048767,
0.01624447852373123,
-1.0112274885177612,
-0.031220676377415657,
0.5081239342689514,
0.28719428181648254,
0.10238979011774063,
0.5720968842506409,
0.11388308554887772,
0.5193037390708923,
-0.5133095979690552,
-0.1477358192205429,
-0.3770920932292938,
-0.16687758266925812,
-0.13151933252811432,
-0.08632204681634903,
1.0181045532226562,
0.0647253692150116,
0.45937472581863403,
-0.25816625356674194,
-0.3318471908569336,
-0.3748376965522766,
0.32734256982803345,
-0.7073975205421448,
0.095809705555439,
0.10919560492038727,
-0.47856855392456055,
-0.3222476840019226,
0.24296186864376068,
-0.6551618576049805,
-0.6326530575752258,
-0.4715765416622162,
0.4858807623386383,
-0.21114687621593475,
-0.4520939290523529,
0.09007029980421066,
-0.4489707350730896,
0.33300480246543884,
0.28047752380371094,
-0.8659125566482544,
0.3407394587993622,
1.0187265872955322,
0.6610738039016724,
-0.5528073906898499,
-0.05939080938696861,
-0.20660017430782318,
0.48325738310813904,
-0.38650476932525635,
0.6247880458831787,
-0.7157803177833557,
-0.3370071351528168,
0.1701517254114151,
-0.10506361722946167,
0.19912847876548767,
-0.13780838251113892,
0.4035356044769287,
-0.8215621113777161,
0.23230233788490295,
-0.5051575303077698,
-0.8882622718811035,
-0.10817651450634003,
0.04711182788014412,
-0.6161827445030212,
0.8376292586326599,
-0.30172690749168396,
-0.8062236309051514,
0.3229507803916931,
-0.4193404018878937,
-0.35726258158683777,
0.26251211762428284,
-0.054662175476551056,
-0.5084401965141296,
0.2507180869579315,
-0.08005519956350327,
0.5410950779914856,
-0.28486523032188416,
0.5221681594848633,
-0.06734707951545715,
0.003435505321249366,
0.44190075993537903,
-0.43540239334106445,
0.842622697353363,
0.11300761997699738,
-0.3365437686443329,
0.10393070429563522,
-0.5227682590484619,
0.02216392196714878,
0.24349886178970337,
-0.0834863930940628,
-0.904614269733429,
0.13171114027500153,
0.19992828369140625,
-0.23309941589832306,
0.4879707992076874,
-0.36343804001808167,
-0.03041665256023407,
0.07133567333221436,
0.5038028955459595,
0.760524332523346,
0.36174461245536804,
0.4541427195072174,
-0.28707650303840637,
0.6644275784492493,
-0.40314239263534546,
0.3603115379810333,
-0.4173854887485504,
-0.7278744578361511,
-0.3342188596725464,
-0.4834063649177551,
0.3324071168899536,
0.17970401048660278,
-0.5214968919754028,
0.3914828300476074,
-0.20473435521125793,
-0.47545766830444336,
-0.2597651779651642,
0.4001297950744629,
0.6824240684509277,
-0.0642484501004219,
0.20302577316761017,
-0.3170147240161896,
-0.2389024943113327,
-0.9924624562263489,
-0.7602412700653076,
-0.09263543784618378,
0.11175728589296341,
0.27024075388908386,
0.643413782119751,
0.019851334393024445,
1.088454008102417,
-0.553401529788971,
-0.1787547618150711,
-0.3791111409664154,
0.20987841486930847,
-0.21476224064826965,
0.46896734833717346,
0.6177634000778198,
-1.110203742980957,
-0.6369880437850952,
-0.10939574986696243,
-0.7003746628761292,
-0.359662264585495,
0.003049740567803383,
-0.13953359425067902,
0.2651977241039276,
0.6851180195808411,
-0.5220178365707397,
0.5525784492492676,
0.7115231156349182,
-0.33254167437553406,
0.3955428898334503,
0.1823848932981491,
0.16287514567375183,
-1.0986181497573853,
0.15031498670578003,
-0.06228630989789963,
0.08214662224054337,
-0.86199951171875,
0.5237926840782166,
-0.02896023355424404,
0.06549078226089478,
-0.3090440034866333,
0.7458929419517517,
-0.6649007201194763,
0.3586450219154358,
-0.4589483141899109,
-0.2938951849937439,
0.27556607127189636,
0.023805735632777214,
0.20315806567668915,
0.5007638931274414,
0.44996511936187744,
-0.5127730369567871,
0.07594209909439087,
0.24574381113052368,
-0.31014785170555115,
0.5383372902870178,
-0.7580097913742065,
0.33624956011772156,
-0.15746748447418213,
-0.169031023979187,
-1.0633021593093872,
-0.0622689351439476,
0.37522265315055847,
-0.2761949300765991,
0.5477489233016968,
-0.46583521366119385,
-0.6505394577980042,
0.28364986181259155,
-0.43304771184921265,
0.27339622378349304,
0.36458685994148254,
-0.394707053899765,
0.7154821157455444,
0.5614967346191406,
-0.5113958120346069,
-0.5172775983810425,
-0.7094611525535583,
0.6515684723854065,
-0.4887847900390625,
-0.36777251958847046,
0.6793840527534485,
-0.01164016593247652,
-0.5726506114006042,
-0.030223993584513664,
-0.005372494924813509,
-0.44023796916007996,
0.39149025082588196,
0.1479133814573288,
0.18747778236865997,
0.21770621836185455,
0.03529428690671921,
0.06829927116632462,
-0.2333664745092392,
0.09822651743888855,
-0.06876108795404434,
0.28115135431289673,
0.518507182598114,
-0.28207218647003174,
-0.32114723324775696,
0.7051502466201782,
0.23044010996818542,
-0.25215598940849304,
0.7315736413002014,
0.1957360804080963,
-0.3467811942100525,
-0.20321772992610931,
-0.5802488327026367,
-0.0912783220410347,
-0.4756970703601837,
0.042328864336013794,
-0.012354923412203789,
-1.0266958475112915,
0.3056117594242096,
0.12273365259170532,
0.4135251045227051,
0.2671150267124176,
0.22719232738018036,
-0.01004236750304699,
0.4377523362636566,
0.8730105757713318,
-0.16295331716537476,
0.5862953662872314,
0.09983894228935242,
0.3070933222770691,
-0.8237700462341309,
-0.18820376694202423,
-0.7101940512657166,
0.038160618394613266,
-0.3685799241065979,
-0.2640562355518341,
-0.08046828955411911,
0.004082621540874243,
-0.003347134217619896,
0.4550367593765259,
-0.8054651021957397,
0.42793363332748413,
0.4226537346839905,
-0.10685115307569504,
0.41771408915519714,
0.12547951936721802,
0.26452937722206116,
-0.25109976530075073,
-0.28546199202537537,
-0.9624041318893433,
1.0746010541915894,
0.0688026025891304,
0.6908244490623474,
0.12762920558452606,
0.8276635408401489,
0.2810737192630768,
0.3746448755264282,
-0.6520385146141052,
0.6990005373954773,
0.14695455133914948,
-1.0499476194381714,
-0.45705923438072205,
-0.3901006877422333,
-1.1403814554214478,
0.27820712327957153,
-0.08329499512910843,
-0.8053507208824158,
-0.1256047785282135,
-0.06832272559404373,
0.044622424989938736,
0.4729935824871063,
-0.3715730607509613,
0.7394838929176331,
-0.3126824200153351,
-0.6520296931266785,
-0.019271720200777054,
-0.4831143021583557,
0.046517081558704376,
-0.3343649208545685,
0.4747523367404938,
-0.10593237727880478,
-0.42929452657699585,
0.9646722078323364,
-0.16370990872383118,
0.8524755835533142,
-0.2227867990732193,
-0.6760480999946594,
0.4289589524269104,
0.1931271106004715,
0.48699697852134705,
-0.16974973678588867,
-0.07067451626062393,
0.1479606330394745,
0.013267885893583298,
-0.17852893471717834,
-0.1792212277650833,
0.4183073043823242,
-0.2234584540128708,
-0.660753071308136,
-0.49316394329071045,
-0.25500309467315674,
-0.10364340990781784,
0.5020490884780884,
0.19467106461524963,
0.4633864164352417,
-0.37100639939308167,
0.41692957282066345,
0.8086977005004883,
-0.3816092610359192,
0.6854957938194275,
0.2998405396938324,
-0.15031103789806366,
-0.42007049918174744,
0.7247360348701477,
0.018675925210118294,
0.2894558906555176,
0.6514768600463867,
0.2885655164718628,
-0.19702672958374023,
-0.929811418056488,
0.008705489337444305,
0.18927468359470367,
-0.6999063491821289,
-0.18211495876312256,
-0.6488548517227173,
-0.10669424384832382,
-0.2716757655143738,
-0.2494974136352539,
-0.18577474355697632,
-0.15653695166110992,
-0.3565210700035095,
0.19740068912506104,
0.47426837682724,
0.8236485719680786,
0.3840571939945221,
0.41650718450546265,
-0.6635205745697021,
0.34299933910369873,
0.33285829424858093,
0.25259244441986084,
0.11983844637870789,
-0.3871636986732483,
-0.0932428315281868,
-0.042119961231946945,
-0.2715970277786255,
-0.6196650862693787,
0.3071715533733368,
-0.016146475449204445,
0.5146746039390564,
0.3650476038455963,
0.12888719141483307,
0.26498207449913025,
-0.44819799065589905,
0.9242632985115051,
0.20874996483325958,
-0.9912474155426025,
0.456505686044693,
-0.42086437344551086,
0.02995121292769909,
0.37887337803840637,
0.42949220538139343,
-0.656782329082489,
-0.41584259271621704,
-0.4815889298915863,
-1.0882292985916138,
0.44407010078430176,
0.4870038330554962,
0.47658771276474,
0.22436125576496124,
0.4920710623264313,
0.2899644672870636,
0.3306799829006195,
-0.9299691915512085,
-0.09652173519134521,
0.2590477168560028,
-0.23986980319023132,
-0.0798189714550972,
-0.5501568913459778,
-0.31499192118644714,
-0.03031293861567974,
0.7627464532852173,
-0.06284996122121811,
0.06105247139930725,
0.13052375614643097,
-0.19285708665847778,
0.23724175989627838,
0.48739826679229736,
0.3778483271598816,
0.36056289076805115,
0.3147309124469757,
0.048323649913072586,
-0.3003612160682678,
-0.427956759929657,
0.26178041100502014,
-0.3187655806541443,
-0.46758902072906494,
-0.028749944642186165,
0.8025335669517517,
0.534965455532074,
0.2946842312812805,
-0.4251481294631958,
0.6367107629776001,
0.03970063105225563,
-0.3327993154525757,
-0.22019439935684204,
0.06439409404993057,
0.3034207820892334,
-0.21406012773513794,
0.4757794439792633,
-0.30807486176490784,
0.06481153517961502,
-0.4112367331981659,
-0.1860785186290741,
0.6929206848144531,
-0.2800786793231964,
-0.4989078640937805,
0.5842856764793396,
0.006970243528485298,
-0.22840328514575958,
0.07240302860736847,
0.2841978371143341,
-0.4679042398929596,
0.5307185053825378,
0.23890343308448792,
1.0996804237365723,
-0.21579720079898834,
0.08994986116886139,
-0.01299983635544777,
0.35041987895965576,
-0.27116823196411133,
0.23373135924339294,
-0.18812809884548187,
-0.8095172047615051,
-0.19495868682861328,
-0.5418780446052551,
-0.69770348072052,
0.06727287173271179,
-0.66647869348526,
0.008355827070772648,
-0.38795650005340576,
-0.16298183798789978,
0.3324390649795532,
-0.19497768580913544,
-0.20889730751514435,
-0.014583628624677658,
0.06079508364200592,
0.5576083064079285,
-0.6697977185249329,
0.48904356360435486,
0.657401978969574,
0.17170096933841705,
-0.4274553656578064,
0.07531968504190445,
0.3277035355567932,
-0.5638971328735352,
0.24347804486751556,
0.052421651780605316,
-0.16178220510482788,
0.07160509377717972,
-0.9774823784828186,
-0.756870687007904,
0.7233853340148926,
0.2925526201725006,
-0.3363429307937622,
0.21337120234966278,
0.33505699038505554,
0.4433915913105011,
-0.30631622672080994,
-0.3468643128871918,
0.35283365845680237,
0.6582785844802856,
-0.18958568572998047,
-0.29888758063316345,
0.18610331416130066,
-0.24076882004737854,
0.08675859868526459,
0.37268319725990295,
-0.525300145149231,
0.5539343357086182,
0.30176475644111633,
-0.32330459356307983,
0.29672566056251526,
0.06747683882713318,
0.2068893164396286,
0.29650405049324036,
0.2672502398490906,
0.3552838861942291,
0.3304429352283478,
-0.2200332134962082,
1.0012134313583374,
-0.15140080451965332,
0.2766065001487732,
0.6881423592567444,
-0.45318716764450073,
0.5906180143356323,
0.7877102494239807,
-0.13741415739059448,
0.23872797191143036,
0.24109098315238953,
-0.07776863127946854,
0.5373791456222534,
0.27168741822242737,
-0.39067211747169495,
-0.2387208640575409,
-0.30652880668640137,
-0.2885001301765442,
0.29794585704803467,
0.3344522714614868,
-0.4370059669017792,
0.10329554229974747,
-0.12816676497459412,
0.29502201080322266,
0.2631266117095947,
-0.09679195284843445,
1.0461997985839844,
0.46946439146995544,
-0.5354744791984558,
-0.15237228572368622,
-0.06058403104543686,
0.812341034412384,
-0.7347633838653564,
0.19946281611919403,
0.07067512720823288,
-0.05641837790608406,
-0.16327565908432007,
-0.9112833738327026,
0.23152242600917816,
0.1251876950263977,
-0.04806786775588989,
-0.9691075086593628,
0.97285395860672,
-0.23432259261608124,
-0.16127073764801025,
0.48968055844306946,
0.41400977969169617,
0.07360117882490158,
-0.15481817722320557,
-0.36160850524902344,
0.3870202898979187,
-0.1717669814825058,
-0.42137929797172546,
0.28647807240486145,
0.6138910055160522,
-0.002657173201441765,
0.5819538235664368,
0.5990438461303711,
0.19589371979236603,
-0.2160840928554535,
0.057836588472127914,
0.4277525842189789,
-0.725974977016449,
-0.3257577419281006,
-1.328571081161499,
0.30311185121536255,
-0.236785888671875,
-0.3248926103115082,
0.99948650598526,
0.5087225437164307,
0.49037832021713257,
-0.031023217365145683,
0.9281390309333801,
-0.059354737401008606,
0.21626237034797668,
-0.5457780361175537,
1.0003385543823242,
-0.604461669921875,
0.12748323380947113,
-0.9089775085449219,
-0.8290718793869019,
-0.5367411375045776,
0.1738111525774002,
-0.023462459444999695,
0.09234121441841125,
0.533786952495575,
0.5440621376037598,
0.17568963766098022,
0.14108696579933167,
0.310732364654541,
-0.27311065793037415,
0.6562787294387817,
0.1239779070019722,
1.0153529644012451,
-0.3723694384098053,
0.4099996089935303,
-0.12345411628484726,
-0.0820421651005745,
-0.09198328852653503,
-1.1592806577682495,
-0.8368081450462341,
-0.8188751339912415,
-0.6583787798881531,
-0.022176748141646385,
-0.0284932442009449,
0.44752395153045654,
0.6207769513130188,
-0.7828161120414734,
-0.19816209375858307,
-0.11265715211629868,
0.20425498485565186,
-0.16404952108860016,
-0.2045479267835617,
0.28322896361351013,
-0.02447899989783764,
-0.5651364326477051,
-0.01678260788321495,
0.5313060879707336,
0.5015497207641602,
-0.17297351360321045,
-0.0006757853552699089,
-0.02194189466536045,
0.39294734597206116,
0.568321168422699,
0.14277170598506927,
-0.451020210981369,
-0.23498699069023132,
-0.13531459867954254,
-0.27502602338790894,
-0.17424631118774414,
1.0573846101760864,
-0.06777812540531158,
0.2418982833623886,
0.4736856520175934,
0.6173375844955444,
0.2606446444988251,
-0.1557854562997818,
0.5210869908332825,
-0.6073620915412903,
-0.056127067655324936,
0.31013724207878113,
0.3588145077228546,
0.4300081431865692,
-0.3893158733844757,
0.4327946603298187,
0.1984836310148239,
-0.3839004933834076,
-1.046906590461731,
0.24381770193576813,
-0.8918718099594116,
-0.43823516368865967,
1.305240273475647,
-0.27037832140922546,
-0.1417170614004135,
-0.38307005167007446,
-0.19516803324222565,
0.009280306287109852,
-0.1892675757408142,
0.6699369549751282,
1.1257212162017822,
0.43565189838409424,
-0.22025127708911896,
-0.48648926615715027,
0.5760999321937561,
0.18051010370254517,
-0.930693507194519,
0.4542411267757416,
0.23228885233402252,
0.27936121821403503,
0.07319881021976471,
0.5809452533721924,
-0.5269384980201721,
-0.014757297933101654,
-0.2941757142543793,
0.3664090931415558,
0.12027637660503387,
-0.35139286518096924,
-0.1987394243478775,
0.26908451318740845,
0.19655536115169525,
0.22568665444850922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11102v1 | Grading Massive Open Online Courses Using Large Language Models | 2024-06-16T23:42:11 | 2024-06-16T23:42:11 | Shahriar Golchin, Nikhil Garuda, Christopher Impey, Matthew Wenger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Massive open online courses (MOOCs) offer free education globally to anyone
with a computer and internet access. Despite this democratization of learning,
the massive enrollment in these courses makes it impractical for one instructor
to assess every student's writing assignment. As a result, peer grading, often
guided by a straightforward rubric, is the method of choice. While convenient,
peer grading often falls short in terms of reliability and validity. In this
study, we explore the feasibility of using large language models (LLMs) to
replace peer grading in MOOCs. Specifically, we use two LLMs, GPT-4 and
GPT-3.5, across three MOOCs: Introductory Astronomy, Astrobiology, and the
History and Philosophy of Astronomy. To instruct LLMs, we use three different
prompts based on the zero-shot chain-of-thought (ZCoT) prompting technique: (1)
ZCoT with instructor-provided correct answers, (2) ZCoT with both
instructor-provided correct answers and rubrics, and (3) ZCoT with
instructor-provided correct answers and LLM-generated rubrics. Tested on 18
settings, our results show that ZCoT, when augmented with instructor-provided
correct answers and rubrics, produces grades that are more aligned with those
assigned by instructors compared to peer grading. Finally, our findings
indicate a promising potential for automated grading systems in MOOCs,
especially in subjects with well-defined rubrics, to improve the learning
experience for millions of online learners worldwide. | [
-0.18649467825889587,
-0.8954110145568848,
0.8903315663337708,
-0.1547543853521347,
-0.15555870532989502,
0.12467966228723526,
-0.6258293986320496,
-0.44669297337532043,
0.062429457902908325,
0.3944583535194397,
-0.34528109431266785,
-0.683804452419281,
-0.42714792490005493,
-0.02783653512597084,
-0.21644370257854462,
1.5098602771759033,
-0.27432578802108765,
0.351828008890152,
-0.3690688908100128,
0.024798933416604996,
-0.24995599687099457,
-0.5437133312225342,
-0.5311848521232605,
-0.4168277382850647,
0.6454780101776123,
0.5336741209030151,
0.6344242095947266,
0.5643810033798218,
0.6896664500236511,
0.24464048445224762,
-0.19143757224082947,
0.22196631133556366,
-0.5084007382392883,
-0.08406535536050797,
-0.3257136046886444,
-0.2887172996997833,
-0.7201114296913147,
0.1912672370672226,
0.6447840332984924,
0.8265364170074463,
-0.23251669108867645,
0.3955431878566742,
0.034445181488990784,
0.37200483679771423,
-0.480337917804718,
0.1508098989725113,
-0.5133393406867981,
0.12362172454595566,
-0.0813465416431427,
-0.06324981898069382,
-0.6779946684837341,
-0.5993812680244446,
0.11455927044153214,
-0.691635012626648,
0.09774251282215118,
-0.16311563551425934,
0.7813146710395813,
-0.10713445395231247,
-0.2698338031768799,
-0.6198890805244446,
-0.7139468789100647,
0.7999303936958313,
-0.542863130569458,
0.07973960041999817,
0.4740545153617859,
0.37226641178131104,
0.13542313873767853,
-0.5960776209831238,
-0.5827932357788086,
-0.4871644973754883,
0.18587331473827362,
0.252702921628952,
0.4590359032154083,
0.2543349862098694,
0.3716665208339691,
0.8609365224838257,
-0.34595075249671936,
0.500797688961029,
-0.3706822395324707,
-0.20382843911647797,
0.2898407578468323,
0.35845696926116943,
0.10744603723287582,
0.06799373030662537,
-0.351311594247818,
-0.12206513434648514,
-0.8821474313735962,
-0.017731821164488792,
0.7151707410812378,
0.49753692746162415,
0.0625588670372963,
0.6293362975120544,
-0.12372306734323502,
0.562960684299469,
0.002871215809136629,
-0.27594175934791565,
0.007327910978347063,
-0.2667338252067566,
-0.08368844538927078,
-0.21331411600112915,
0.7656334638595581,
0.5668649673461914,
0.37897494435310364,
0.11425963044166565,
-0.1216510459780693,
-0.006312149576842785,
0.15082517266273499,
-0.7937537431716919,
-0.20488843321800232,
0.20614567399024963,
-0.14315594732761383,
-0.3495427966117859,
0.010940317995846272,
-0.776578962802887,
-0.3380860388278961,
-0.2546972334384918,
0.7606602311134338,
-0.11738555878400803,
0.2915554344654083,
0.0057843346148729324,
0.0932079628109932,
0.06605096906423569,
0.9870541095733643,
-0.6713877320289612,
0.26632389426231384,
0.6142730116844177,
1.2226749658584595,
-0.016020817682147026,
-0.2492232322692871,
-0.6024377942085266,
0.002315102843567729,
-0.29931849241256714,
0.5631764531135559,
-0.5644746422767639,
-0.14939439296722412,
0.2132224440574646,
-0.34569641947746277,
0.2679336965084076,
-0.24405056238174438,
0.4187179207801819,
-0.4842819571495056,
0.7969152331352234,
-0.19861723482608795,
-0.8461787104606628,
-0.15508733689785004,
0.5181734561920166,
-0.3908258378505707,
0.8967552781105042,
0.04702405259013176,
-0.31120455265045166,
0.1302526891231537,
-0.730431079864502,
-0.05739356204867363,
0.2743579149246216,
0.07999617606401443,
-0.2328508049249649,
-0.19835300743579865,
0.07351171225309372,
0.5978460907936096,
-0.342427521944046,
0.29871538281440735,
-0.1787152737379074,
-0.4485836625099182,
0.19824260473251343,
-0.14305584132671356,
0.5323004126548767,
0.12633559107780457,
-0.47128114104270935,
0.1086404100060463,
-0.5215975046157837,
0.25097623467445374,
-0.07610465586185455,
-0.43055665493011475,
-0.2942306101322174,
0.024110861122608185,
-0.15337702631950378,
0.251359760761261,
0.14790405333042145,
-0.7406522631645203,
0.561308741569519,
-0.0831834226846695,
0.3364139795303345,
1.219869613647461,
-0.13855546712875366,
0.28358498215675354,
-0.3632841110229492,
0.47381591796875,
-0.2773411273956299,
0.19831088185310364,
-0.23360858857631683,
-0.7122611403465271,
-0.9867395758628845,
-0.23309306800365448,
0.16322177648544312,
0.28756222128868103,
-0.645853579044342,
0.23296606540679932,
-0.3432912230491638,
-0.753990650177002,
-0.2685890793800354,
0.38891875743865967,
0.6201344132423401,
0.31789126992225647,
0.4410341680049896,
-0.33591753244400024,
0.04102766886353493,
-0.27822357416152954,
-0.10612773895263672,
-0.26677945256233215,
-0.2640951871871948,
0.3176155984401703,
0.5196269154548645,
-0.021919775754213333,
0.5627667903900146,
-0.7018418312072754,
-0.4995209574699402,
-0.09555305540561676,
0.128684863448143,
0.16039209067821503,
0.30877143144607544,
0.13882867991924286,
-0.14514102041721344,
-0.5755495429039001,
0.24123868346214294,
-0.5313956141471863,
-0.2930794358253479,
0.028142986819148064,
-0.11775989085435867,
0.012447225861251354,
0.2678649425506592,
-0.2867026925086975,
0.0801110491156578,
0.5888262987136841,
-0.28343862295150757,
0.6639837026596069,
-0.2086244821548462,
0.21844516694545746,
-0.7557013034820557,
-0.06270760297775269,
0.026035070419311523,
-0.2984606623649597,
-0.6184958815574646,
0.5438486933708191,
0.16206499934196472,
-0.20066313445568085,
-0.4756159484386444,
0.5762287378311157,
-0.4054983854293823,
0.10294416546821594,
-0.240062415599823,
0.36513224244117737,
-0.03083190880715847,
0.5553284287452698,
-0.05685540288686752,
0.60272616147995,
0.46896323561668396,
-0.5483096837997437,
0.26654377579689026,
0.1263337880373001,
-0.5920673608779907,
0.6264214515686035,
-0.44666072726249695,
0.27876216173171997,
-0.1236473023891449,
0.6108043789863586,
-0.9637078046798706,
-0.15368525683879852,
0.13935492932796478,
-0.29545944929122925,
-0.0033596400171518326,
-0.20644976198673248,
-0.3416309058666229,
-0.2245774120092392,
-0.3138652443885803,
0.33979639410972595,
0.4811297357082367,
-0.6400884985923767,
0.3754430115222931,
-0.1299857199192047,
-0.0697498619556427,
-0.40312135219573975,
-0.4698304235935211,
-0.08981356769800186,
0.10330410301685333,
-0.31902876496315,
0.036945778876543045,
-0.30801111459732056,
-0.24112951755523682,
-0.19805416464805603,
0.18405170738697052,
-0.018282534554600716,
-0.04912373051047325,
0.4325351417064667,
0.4991292357444763,
-0.2400842159986496,
0.2557790279388428,
-0.21569609642028809,
0.061901044100522995,
-0.04288247227668762,
-0.6488760709762573,
0.5595735907554626,
-0.18837042152881622,
-0.5246049165725708,
-0.3296247124671936,
0.24185815453529358,
0.9640116691589355,
-0.26411551237106323,
0.8061023950576782,
0.3726789653301239,
-0.27683025598526,
-0.2466069459915161,
-0.7540189623832703,
-0.11528462916612625,
-0.47005754709243774,
0.08595395088195801,
0.11812873929738998,
-1.172027349472046,
0.5491088032722473,
0.21703779697418213,
0.4380539357662201,
0.10036911815404892,
0.8091029524803162,
0.03800119087100029,
0.7192648649215698,
0.39837703108787537,
0.28647640347480774,
0.4970070421695709,
-0.24991586804389954,
0.3162299692630768,
-0.7986794710159302,
-0.3193831145763397,
-0.5998786091804504,
-0.2020706981420517,
-0.387523353099823,
-0.7353549599647522,
0.30246639251708984,
-0.15205304324626923,
-0.22533388435840607,
0.12026825547218323,
-0.14199593663215637,
0.8712567687034607,
0.5046243667602539,
0.2556317448616028,
0.5168119072914124,
0.20256657898426056,
-0.23634395003318787,
0.10542072355747223,
-0.22345714271068573,
-0.702766478061676,
1.2282570600509644,
0.2618439793586731,
0.7659801840782166,
0.19697241485118866,
0.37489038705825806,
0.23059101402759552,
0.7398844361305237,
-0.9495255947113037,
0.7093163132667542,
-0.022949259728193283,
-0.7414059638977051,
-0.3592661917209625,
-0.7728569507598877,
-0.28791114687919617,
0.2922375798225403,
-0.21537038683891296,
-0.6235023736953735,
-0.37042009830474854,
0.2020106464624405,
-0.3368142247200012,
0.779395341873169,
-0.634242057800293,
0.7323207259178162,
-0.13075920939445496,
-0.6166725158691406,
-0.2616172730922699,
-0.3336668312549591,
0.3238752782344818,
-0.28802910447120667,
0.3248699903488159,
-0.08647098392248154,
-0.025163615122437477,
0.7215660810470581,
-0.60527503490448,
0.6732150912284851,
-0.02464081533253193,
-0.34766703844070435,
0.492485910654068,
0.2569992244243622,
0.4306643307209015,
-0.20529095828533173,
-0.21325643360614777,
0.284499853849411,
-0.34048327803611755,
-0.40918999910354614,
-0.6243469715118408,
0.9722179770469666,
-0.9646777510643005,
-0.5725720524787903,
-0.5185519456863403,
-0.42196768522262573,
-0.03597209230065346,
0.07436619699001312,
0.11157577484846115,
0.5921677350997925,
0.08322370052337646,
0.04670868068933487,
0.39039167761802673,
-0.33520036935806274,
0.23117569088935852,
0.7038198113441467,
-0.4929673373699188,
-0.5730748772621155,
0.9565026760101318,
0.2820587456226349,
0.9068722128868103,
0.40091195702552795,
0.4782768487930298,
-0.16609793901443481,
-0.39387115836143494,
-0.5102751851081848,
0.27639102935791016,
-1.0663601160049438,
-0.2582917809486389,
-0.638239860534668,
0.05464736372232437,
-0.3096790909767151,
-0.4814712703227997,
-0.07251463830471039,
-0.495291531085968,
-0.08780550956726074,
-0.29200342297554016,
0.26412421464920044,
0.9527854919433594,
0.10955919325351715,
0.49918437004089355,
-0.6557357311248779,
-0.1566949337720871,
0.47768011689186096,
0.6192027926445007,
0.2046683132648468,
-0.8088040947914124,
-0.1690220683813095,
0.06813991069793701,
-0.5147334337234497,
-0.4987034797668457,
-0.07922393083572388,
0.3315459191799164,
0.11577558517456055,
0.5162357687950134,
-0.11110777407884598,
0.7721483111381531,
-0.6743345260620117,
1.0244662761688232,
0.3664575517177582,
-1.1832714080810547,
0.35823675990104675,
-0.5027590990066528,
0.13777945935726166,
0.42560771107673645,
0.5602266192436218,
-0.7928498387336731,
-0.879414975643158,
-0.21272897720336914,
-0.6677125692367554,
0.775204598903656,
0.0949576273560524,
0.32473525404930115,
-0.08960419148206711,
0.29484477639198303,
0.3129170536994934,
0.09818527847528458,
-1.1313902139663696,
-0.11882691085338593,
-0.07200171053409576,
-0.11834263801574707,
-0.3037559688091278,
-0.23029141128063202,
0.06475580483675003,
-0.1603766828775406,
0.7853747010231018,
-0.1509917676448822,
-0.07913327217102051,
0.07294490188360214,
-0.028647897765040398,
-0.4332585334777832,
0.5108633041381836,
0.8789882063865662,
0.8387011885643005,
-0.2937808334827423,
-0.0016894128639250994,
0.1711048036813736,
-0.5717191100120544,
0.2948152422904968,
-0.5952979326248169,
-0.3278568387031555,
-0.11228287220001221,
0.2924153804779053,
0.4464592933654785,
-0.05005093291401863,
-0.8338782787322998,
0.6394399404525757,
-0.0038846114184707403,
-0.24337133765220642,
-0.16089510917663574,
0.013739443384110928,
-0.22611863911151886,
-0.09806530922651291,
0.27929922938346863,
-0.17076575756072998,
-0.1699138581752777,
-0.6371387243270874,
-0.2964305281639099,
0.2999831736087799,
-0.3869139552116394,
-0.14491236209869385,
0.40738987922668457,
0.5020753145217896,
-0.2478729635477066,
0.6395115852355957,
0.04587046802043915,
-0.6382789015769958,
0.31154003739356995,
0.47234752774238586,
0.7912158370018005,
-0.16037936508655548,
0.46823790669441223,
0.5129912495613098,
0.3365303575992584,
-0.3019530773162842,
-0.1613810658454895,
-0.17039461433887482,
-0.32505229115486145,
-0.69703209400177,
-0.8219545483589172,
-1.1024274826049805,
0.0017948092427104712,
-0.5015039443969727,
0.344230055809021,
-0.9705625772476196,
-0.11427012830972672,
-0.22268927097320557,
-0.01708618924021721,
-0.4394431412220001,
0.14957889914512634,
0.27640247344970703,
0.5012760162353516,
-0.8998448252677917,
0.5191304683685303,
0.9380726218223572,
-0.3619852364063263,
-0.8409872055053711,
-0.18839131295681,
0.18269452452659607,
-0.5260394215583801,
0.441428005695343,
0.4167059063911438,
-0.071275494992733,
-0.1189950630068779,
-0.46706169843673706,
-0.6213482618331909,
0.9480463862419128,
0.04135436192154884,
-0.5360161066055298,
-0.10152128338813782,
0.06317206472158432,
0.6668410897254944,
-0.020112648606300354,
0.8623937964439392,
-0.19146913290023804,
0.33441635966300964,
0.04784509912133217,
-1.0893728733062744,
-0.14708784222602844,
-0.10538174957036972,
-0.22091811895370483,
0.5007933378219604,
-0.6934095621109009,
1.035592794418335,
-0.2693966031074524,
-0.12193265557289124,
0.15853579342365265,
0.4619210660457611,
-0.06009869650006294,
0.2177601456642151,
0.29261937737464905,
0.7917172312736511,
0.7897275686264038,
-0.2882838249206543,
0.9067119359970093,
-0.0698099285364151,
0.6876641511917114,
0.8293283581733704,
-0.398404598236084,
0.8785523772239685,
0.34546026587486267,
-0.2977963984012604,
0.9140231013298035,
0.2640638053417206,
0.08145634084939957,
-0.0670548677444458,
0.2908059358596802,
-0.2905789911746979,
-0.44920456409454346,
-0.22272692620754242,
-0.41853201389312744,
0.3527953624725342,
0.25790077447891235,
-0.21646039187908173,
-0.3604635000228882,
0.2376636117696762,
0.09778334200382233,
0.27474507689476013,
-0.8285280466079712,
0.5328088998794556,
-0.06141824647784233,
-0.8608691692352295,
0.24191053211688995,
0.16611000895500183,
0.6115991473197937,
-0.7457494139671326,
0.0020360362250357866,
-0.3942280411720276,
0.45570653676986694,
-0.2624496817588806,
-0.8899083733558655,
-0.3580394983291626,
0.6146692633628845,
-0.048527467995882034,
-0.5875493884086609,
0.05103055760264397,
-0.46168866753578186,
-0.6218591928482056,
0.08669424802064896,
0.22413252294063568,
0.2342679500579834,
0.09874473512172699,
-0.0740588828921318,
-0.10928785800933838,
-0.1587316244840622,
0.06180131062865257,
0.43421071767807007,
0.3053591549396515,
0.010746492072939873,
0.8882421851158142,
0.8567517995834351,
0.07777908444404602,
0.15057605504989624,
0.03867815434932709,
0.7201891541481018,
-0.4955350160598755,
-0.5746250748634338,
-0.8544920086860657,
0.2766507565975189,
0.061380013823509216,
-0.38170892000198364,
1.0650041103363037,
0.306500643491745,
1.2563676834106445,
-0.08624956756830215,
0.43147799372673035,
-0.09184931218624115,
0.42552146315574646,
-0.700480043888092,
0.5077894926071167,
-0.4688691794872284,
0.18280106782913208,
-0.600060224533081,
-1.1190139055252075,
-0.37005531787872314,
0.5349998474121094,
-0.5265461206436157,
0.0785774365067482,
0.9459571242332458,
0.5550026893615723,
0.2635595202445984,
-0.06487865000963211,
0.3620211184024811,
-0.13491396605968475,
0.5816870331764221,
0.704158365726471,
1.106143832206726,
-0.25605320930480957,
0.7931716442108154,
-0.3046981394290924,
-0.2473531812429428,
-0.2933597266674042,
-0.7742088437080383,
-1.1747292280197144,
-0.20870542526245117,
-0.5023550987243652,
-0.50300532579422,
0.08742476254701614,
1.224797010421753,
0.2255481332540512,
-0.7441653609275818,
-0.3717358410358429,
0.19945105910301208,
0.07248830050230026,
-0.06235354766249657,
-0.24136632680892944,
0.12364322692155838,
-0.15701520442962646,
-0.7676274180412292,
-0.10135937482118607,
0.3589264452457428,
0.11865972727537155,
-0.3584578037261963,
-0.07020720839500427,
-0.051886964589357376,
-0.14074812829494476,
0.6929885149002075,
0.07338127493858337,
-0.9424044489860535,
-0.5243902206420898,
0.0004572124744299799,
-0.3426002562046051,
-0.02222728356719017,
0.9491823315620422,
-0.5023130774497986,
0.5071483850479126,
0.49176934361457825,
0.3955233097076416,
0.10466918349266052,
0.16072775423526764,
0.3130347430706024,
-0.4668612778186798,
-0.16597364842891693,
0.2618894875049591,
0.22460496425628662,
0.4321456253528595,
-0.10964652895927429,
0.24487093091011047,
0.21543706953525543,
-0.7880597114562988,
-0.839877188205719,
0.04148830473423004,
-0.9060356020927429,
-0.022946106269955635,
1.2073577642440796,
-0.44341787695884705,
-0.025000303983688354,
0.10022582858800888,
-0.19986513257026672,
-0.08620904386043549,
-0.1701340228319168,
0.7963919639587402,
1.1843172311782837,
0.35118621587753296,
0.1473231017589569,
-0.3706301152706146,
-0.062284160405397415,
0.41869819164276123,
-0.8059484362602234,
0.11756554991006851,
0.7196164131164551,
0.23790188133716583,
0.32904326915740967,
0.4907808005809784,
-0.017002655193209648,
0.3337833881378174,
-0.35720375180244446,
0.11793281137943268,
-0.2095431685447693,
-0.5541970133781433,
-0.32859915494918823,
0.2520160377025604,
0.12615400552749634,
0.10746600478887558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15477v1 | CrisisSense-LLM: Instruction Fine-Tuned Large Language Model for Multi-label Social Media Text Classification in Disaster Informatics | 2024-06-16T23:01:10 | 2024-06-16T23:01:10 | Kai Yin, Chengkai Liu, Ali Mostafavi, Xia Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the field of crisis/disaster informatics, social media is increasingly
being used for improving situational awareness to inform response and relief
efforts. Efficient and accurate text classification tools have been a focal
area of investigation in crisis informatics. However, current methods mostly
rely on single-label text classification models, which fails to capture
different insights embedded in dynamic and multifaceted disaster-related social
media data. This study introduces a novel approach to disaster text
classification by enhancing a pre-trained Large Language Model (LLM) through
instruction fine-tuning targeted for multi-label classification of
disaster-related tweets. Our methodology involves creating a comprehensive
instruction dataset from disaster-related tweets, which is then used to
fine-tune an open-source LLM, thereby embedding it with disaster-specific
knowledge. This fine-tuned model can classify multiple aspects of
disaster-related information simultaneously, such as the type of event,
informativeness, and involvement of human aid, significantly improving the
utility of social media data for situational awareness in disasters. The
results demonstrate that this approach enhances the categorization of critical
information from social media posts, thereby facilitating a more effective
deployment for situational awareness during emergencies. This research paves
the way for more advanced, adaptable, and robust disaster management tools,
leveraging the capabilities of LLMs to improve real-time situational awareness
and response strategies in disaster scenarios. | [
-0.23916929960250854,
-0.7201589941978455,
0.363044410943985,
0.5491185188293457,
-0.23292206227779388,
0.6581006646156311,
-0.35308581590652466,
-0.22764553129673004,
0.26508858799934387,
0.3307884931564331,
-0.5671026706695557,
-0.8747934103012085,
-0.6567046642303467,
0.028012868016958237,
-0.4437769651412964,
1.087443470954895,
0.005850606132298708,
-0.06984326243400574,
0.35020214319229126,
0.11127499490976334,
-0.19123642146587372,
-0.3067513704299927,
-0.7367061376571655,
0.13894540071487427,
0.6585676670074463,
0.8219152688980103,
0.36670947074890137,
0.28112101554870605,
0.7083179354667664,
0.29891958832740784,
0.06572162359952927,
0.27219444513320923,
-0.8679655194282532,
-0.06115207076072693,
-0.17912137508392334,
-0.11267214268445969,
-0.25903064012527466,
-0.2030937522649765,
0.4415069818496704,
0.13134582340717316,
-0.38210543990135193,
0.36020544171333313,
0.3412575423717499,
0.23785322904586792,
-0.8089534044265747,
0.15166862308979034,
-0.5651369094848633,
-0.1413029134273529,
0.060413021594285965,
-0.6311686038970947,
-0.3822249472141266,
-0.6648876667022705,
0.1619778573513031,
-0.39376023411750793,
0.4062095284461975,
-0.07374707609415054,
0.4318743348121643,
0.38777822256088257,
-0.4289714992046356,
-0.24781058728694916,
-0.9282825589179993,
0.6509056091308594,
-0.35858154296875,
0.3140218257904053,
0.1324169784784317,
0.4086968004703522,
0.016973568126559258,
-0.7463092803955078,
-0.3362700939178467,
0.39803841710090637,
0.4693315625190735,
0.11038412153720856,
0.2258806824684143,
0.3107105493545532,
-0.05055173859000206,
0.0630088746547699,
-0.4147888422012329,
0.3655398488044739,
-0.2899573743343353,
-0.18510545790195465,
0.7338303327560425,
0.3234078586101532,
0.35138043761253357,
-0.44652435183525085,
-0.46608033776283264,
-0.11650319397449493,
-0.6124805212020874,
-0.1998419165611267,
-0.22870506346225739,
0.5597410798072815,
-0.5080869197845459,
0.2623823881149292,
-0.11479293555021286,
0.26832571625709534,
-0.23703712224960327,
-0.5297951102256775,
0.13851824402809143,
-0.09831386059522629,
-0.28386905789375305,
0.5616800785064697,
0.9128989577293396,
0.6404913663864136,
0.12989892065525055,
0.0870017409324646,
-0.13902153074741364,
-0.16406744718551636,
0.43578338623046875,
-1.0778934955596924,
-0.148933544754982,
-0.06351637840270996,
-0.4006675183773041,
-0.582801342010498,
0.009485969319939613,
-0.9129483103752136,
-0.9906569719314575,
-0.14826330542564392,
0.44473132491111755,
-0.2940659523010254,
-0.18531128764152527,
0.269901841878891,
0.2581407427787781,
-0.06654467433691025,
0.6290025115013123,
-0.5097560882568359,
-0.16651888191699982,
0.6515177488327026,
1.041720986366272,
0.3377414643764496,
-0.06525454670190811,
-0.2826194167137146,
0.3205982744693756,
-0.031085606664419174,
0.9287474155426025,
-0.5300780534744263,
-0.2671760320663452,
0.44791561365127563,
0.07708041369915009,
-0.10090069472789764,
-0.1420610100030899,
0.8779081702232361,
-0.4951210618019104,
-0.2177443653345108,
-0.15083982050418854,
-0.4844587445259094,
-0.25647780299186707,
0.38663995265960693,
-0.48767557740211487,
0.7695125937461853,
-0.08190735429525375,
-1.01100492477417,
0.2194526493549347,
-0.4810667335987091,
-0.48939672112464905,
0.06322891265153885,
0.013276333920657635,
-0.553622841835022,
0.07070187479257584,
0.1686318814754486,
0.9919394850730896,
-0.5513361096382141,
0.40828293561935425,
-0.7401919364929199,
-0.26600342988967896,
0.08361586183309555,
-0.5583125948905945,
0.3749694228172302,
0.044863540679216385,
-0.026899244636297226,
0.12111710757017136,
-0.8274101614952087,
0.001791926915757358,
0.16720978915691376,
-0.6823266744613647,
-0.5122681260108948,
0.20933687686920166,
0.32312119007110596,
0.20176298916339874,
0.25643855333328247,
-0.3765212297439575,
0.1818799525499344,
-0.24599167704582214,
0.2164965569972992,
0.6276735663414001,
0.3492981195449829,
0.3350953459739685,
-0.26719775795936584,
0.1681339144706726,
-0.034526363015174866,
0.4257417917251587,
-0.18597538769245148,
-0.271442711353302,
-0.7718129754066467,
-0.10203676670789719,
0.05239606648683548,
1.0743242502212524,
-0.7727962136268616,
0.3551858961582184,
-0.33715662360191345,
-0.5775086879730225,
-0.6453700661659241,
0.09239121526479721,
0.10699284076690674,
0.5006673336029053,
0.6138927340507507,
0.4093915820121765,
-0.9540984630584717,
-0.6723034977912903,
0.002144553931429982,
-0.019070329144597054,
0.06634083390235901,
0.18938672542572021,
0.20196259021759033,
-0.42569395899772644,
0.4181547462940216,
-0.6897664070129395,
-0.07522112876176834,
-0.5619418025016785,
0.33709001541137695,
-0.005110705271363258,
0.0733853355050087,
0.34199872612953186,
-0.8578051924705505,
-0.4475443959236145,
0.05762774497270584,
-0.7324259281158447,
-0.24985231459140778,
-0.21319207549095154,
0.0638459250330925,
-0.07550319284200668,
0.511592447757721,
-0.21266330778598785,
0.3653918504714966,
0.19200727343559265,
-0.14607496559619904,
0.4011022746562958,
-0.05279430001974106,
0.4466326832771301,
-1.5995991230010986,
-0.42024144530296326,
0.18383601307868958,
0.019579026848077774,
-0.8225281238555908,
-0.2315463274717331,
0.38892826437950134,
-0.07855941355228424,
-0.5225664973258972,
0.44372278451919556,
-0.38592395186424255,
0.3566384017467499,
-0.3380194902420044,
0.16536381840705872,
-0.2802540361881256,
-0.06506527215242386,
-0.10955335944890976,
0.3760964870452881,
0.7163901925086975,
-0.6447989344596863,
0.4439082145690918,
0.1584181934595108,
-0.4233802556991577,
0.5340958833694458,
-0.213341623544693,
-0.0452747605741024,
-0.3288578987121582,
0.1665789932012558,
-1.0292415618896484,
-0.5881321430206299,
0.23576219379901886,
-0.15366999804973602,
0.5351282954216003,
-0.17406868934631348,
-0.6032979488372803,
-0.5604444146156311,
-0.36717015504837036,
0.007251872215420008,
0.17995578050613403,
-0.48024260997772217,
0.5310395359992981,
0.411814421415329,
-0.33106622099876404,
-0.4973914325237274,
-0.5293134450912476,
0.16328048706054688,
-0.5951671600341797,
-0.3645469546318054,
0.1477394849061966,
-0.13205622136592865,
0.04354369640350342,
-0.14145444333553314,
-0.1716112345457077,
-0.27080291509628296,
0.36646100878715515,
0.32342079281806946,
0.17543484270572662,
-0.23750148713588715,
0.4698715806007385,
0.3220151960849762,
0.07353869825601578,
-0.09507005661725998,
0.05390090122818947,
0.5785633325576782,
-0.025397058576345444,
-0.09048566967248917,
-0.6720907688140869,
0.28897717595100403,
0.5631349086761475,
-0.03743380308151245,
1.0839424133300781,
0.7635821104049683,
-0.5493623614311218,
-0.209848091006279,
-0.7352377772331238,
-0.19191797077655792,
-0.4828575849533081,
0.4282781481742859,
0.06009828671813011,
-1.096028447151184,
0.37439411878585815,
-0.5683895349502563,
0.06634615361690521,
0.27130651473999023,
0.30199387669563293,
-0.2658632695674896,
0.7232544422149658,
0.6900725364685059,
-0.5422556400299072,
0.526952862739563,
-0.3168247640132904,
0.2162177413702011,
-0.40944918990135193,
-0.26760777831077576,
-0.5530136823654175,
-0.3081054091453552,
-0.3532003164291382,
-0.43187400698661804,
0.4110413193702698,
0.17545194923877716,
-0.4651825428009033,
-0.0019142305245622993,
-0.4139874577522278,
0.5651809573173523,
-0.021944839507341385,
0.3881121873855591,
0.0809280201792717,
0.06388578563928604,
0.5988647937774658,
0.049613870680332184,
-0.6786357164382935,
-0.6503099799156189,
0.7797753214836121,
0.37606680393218994,
0.957282543182373,
0.09984967112541199,
1.1497117280960083,
0.32793790102005005,
0.7809574604034424,
-0.7018263339996338,
0.4543406665325165,
-0.12870001792907715,
-0.38829898834228516,
-0.3081028461456299,
-0.4143046736717224,
-0.6827502250671387,
-0.09382642060518265,
-0.49891072511672974,
-0.6762101650238037,
0.01640179194509983,
0.07537484169006348,
-0.6580880284309387,
0.23315183818340302,
-0.8706237077713013,
0.7358981966972351,
-0.296290785074234,
0.1909256875514984,
-0.4071682393550873,
-0.5389530062675476,
0.3387279808521271,
-0.40178966522216797,
0.577380895614624,
-0.11310695856809616,
-0.32918453216552734,
0.6327943205833435,
-0.06475581228733063,
1.4124119281768799,
-0.034946419298648834,
-0.25083574652671814,
0.47940802574157715,
-0.02735801972448826,
0.5250885486602783,
0.2936408519744873,
0.1362265944480896,
-0.11973293870687485,
-0.34954968094825745,
0.0009476323612034321,
-0.4782499074935913,
0.8255656957626343,
-0.742072582244873,
-0.462970495223999,
0.10282276570796967,
-0.4201885163784027,
-0.17516952753067017,
0.25328314304351807,
0.3166438937187195,
0.5120912194252014,
-0.3451925218105316,
0.20285403728485107,
0.982956051826477,
-0.4480968415737152,
0.502639889717102,
0.6578909754753113,
0.11633715033531189,
-0.5318061113357544,
1.0335447788238525,
0.28912627696990967,
-0.03849295526742935,
0.82933509349823,
0.2712351679801941,
-0.056464437395334244,
-0.4829402267932892,
-0.05905403196811676,
0.222799614071846,
-0.7872849702835083,
-0.7943243980407715,
-0.8709520697593689,
-0.4612533450126648,
-0.26208755373954773,
-0.3772543668746948,
-0.303102046251297,
-0.19859722256660461,
-0.6289360523223877,
-0.23244608938694,
0.48793938755989075,
0.655321478843689,
0.022359950467944145,
0.5530424118041992,
-1.1708546876907349,
0.31986531615257263,
-0.029075223952531815,
0.4375607371330261,
-0.055495668202638626,
-0.5345298647880554,
-0.3741881549358368,
0.06754538416862488,
-0.36654311418533325,
-1.2184947729110718,
0.05822738632559776,
0.5032152533531189,
0.2562277019023895,
0.7696278691291809,
0.4775814712047577,
0.6330109238624573,
-0.6447393298149109,
0.325554221868515,
0.2749362289905548,
-0.5700063109397888,
0.8012926578521729,
-0.46676528453826904,
0.1164967268705368,
0.5624353289604187,
0.7169824838638306,
-0.5340512990951538,
-0.43750256299972534,
-0.49453821778297424,
-0.799500584602356,
0.763522207736969,
-0.05147793889045715,
0.21213243901729584,
-0.06806342303752899,
0.16464680433273315,
-0.27417266368865967,
0.08959340304136276,
-0.400663822889328,
-0.20584207773208618,
-0.23101919889450073,
-0.4940929710865021,
-0.1424451619386673,
-0.705742597579956,
-0.06424567848443985,
-0.17864543199539185,
0.5592224597930908,
0.035132087767124176,
-0.03972132131457329,
-0.15935760736465454,
0.02473682351410389,
0.0842643678188324,
0.41911160945892334,
0.6673397421836853,
0.19711530208587646,
-0.11462800949811935,
0.2842566668987274,
0.4851166009902954,
-0.7407675385475159,
0.31307554244995117,
0.3201531171798706,
0.018715528771281242,
-0.15599870681762695,
0.5643128156661987,
0.7254075407981873,
0.8161718845367432,
-0.539104163646698,
0.4538087546825409,
-0.19954372942447662,
-0.015160530805587769,
-0.15328232944011688,
0.19081845879554749,
0.3178386390209198,
0.6125331521034241,
0.4102778434753418,
-0.11927488446235657,
0.39598575234413147,
-0.2840532660484314,
0.07245243340730667,
-0.049911607056856155,
0.007113981060683727,
-0.35093954205513,
0.23043543100357056,
0.32471713423728943,
-0.4812847971916199,
0.1744828075170517,
-0.2195039838552475,
-0.44232892990112305,
0.4610196352005005,
0.44401174783706665,
1.0388965606689453,
-1.2222546339035034,
0.5151675343513489,
0.5465533137321472,
0.4983104169368744,
-0.3866048753261566,
0.5957723259925842,
0.08416757732629776,
-0.8184043765068054,
-0.23746070265769958,
-0.84127277135849,
-0.02638310380280018,
0.5766792297363281,
-0.45007991790771484,
0.4072739779949188,
-0.7040324211120605,
-0.1821790486574173,
0.0046378751285374165,
-0.48189911246299744,
-0.6102483868598938,
0.2891121804714203,
0.2173500806093216,
0.9284998178482056,
-0.9446403384208679,
0.35924574732780457,
0.903862476348877,
0.0826025977730751,
-0.8383166193962097,
0.3028673231601715,
0.0346294529736042,
-0.3956637680530548,
0.30132490396499634,
0.47929084300994873,
0.12086167186498642,
0.10290270298719406,
-0.7283604145050049,
-1.0869511365890503,
0.7856019139289856,
0.3919590711593628,
-0.7553069591522217,
0.012425296008586884,
0.29470187425613403,
0.554455578327179,
-0.2767895460128784,
-0.10265669971704483,
0.2987995147705078,
0.4103844165802002,
0.0865907222032547,
-0.850168764591217,
-0.018730809912085533,
0.06328697502613068,
-0.05778292939066887,
0.4911128282546997,
-0.5799189209938049,
0.034083884209394455,
-0.4351509213447571,
-0.4538196623325348,
-0.45952802896499634,
0.7897788882255554,
0.03530195727944374,
0.6507368683815002,
0.3703286349773407,
0.4111492335796356,
0.8561502695083618,
-0.07891291379928589,
0.8039798736572266,
-0.2877688407897949,
0.5259131193161011,
1.1099179983139038,
0.08095861226320267,
0.8009380102157593,
-0.06751125305891037,
0.08184195309877396,
0.20287209749221802,
0.8219354152679443,
0.2685295343399048,
0.6151988506317139,
-0.014466983266174793,
-0.5513281226158142,
-0.472898930311203,
-0.1790134757757187,
-0.1438676416873932,
0.40912923216819763,
0.8864704370498657,
-0.43471434712409973,
-0.5286073088645935,
0.36083829402923584,
0.012906587682664394,
-0.25690895318984985,
-0.5555004477500916,
0.7743297815322876,
0.2569332718849182,
0.04945677891373634,
0.7777842879295349,
0.0036596045829355717,
0.39990514516830444,
-0.19124285876750946,
0.14350758492946625,
0.06455502659082413,
0.1075127050280571,
-0.36328691244125366,
-0.9279499053955078,
0.45516064763069153,
0.1948857605457306,
-0.29868102073669434,
0.11616764962673187,
0.7880892157554626,
-0.44114693999290466,
-0.6935661435127258,
0.26570457220077515,
0.19732880592346191,
-0.016249287873506546,
-0.10626766085624695,
-0.6637149453163147,
0.2831665277481079,
-0.1048891693353653,
-0.3244503438472748,
0.07221750915050507,
0.8813855051994324,
-0.08779928088188171,
0.9064253568649292,
0.16407474875450134,
-0.1435350775718689,
-0.03781672567129135,
0.46315354108810425,
0.969231128692627,
-0.6472212076187134,
-0.5125074982643127,
-0.9802817106246948,
0.5062112212181091,
-0.32726967334747314,
-0.11260463297367096,
0.5453563928604126,
0.4861869215965271,
0.42459338903427124,
-0.128906711935997,
0.9681509733200073,
0.004081673454493284,
0.6515968441963196,
-0.34853318333625793,
0.6763800978660583,
-0.558887243270874,
0.20919667184352875,
-0.49355030059814453,
-0.7893162965774536,
-0.47672319412231445,
0.32241544127464294,
-0.2953311800956726,
-0.1441154032945633,
0.38218453526496887,
0.6565537452697754,
-0.21594074368476868,
0.04525236040353775,
0.053847331553697586,
0.36143410205841064,
0.21083851158618927,
0.39763563871383667,
0.8939979672431946,
-0.11119207739830017,
0.6489973068237305,
-0.06777332723140717,
-0.49782446026802063,
-0.5138110518455505,
-0.7478048801422119,
-1.2159706354141235,
-0.7395303845405579,
-0.2874518036842346,
-0.20868812501430511,
0.01381014846265316,
0.9329158067703247,
0.2893683612346649,
-0.674179196357727,
0.18410354852676392,
0.19361981749534607,
0.20706339180469513,
0.3146325945854187,
-0.2470245361328125,
0.4032055139541626,
-0.24175800383090973,
-0.2854762375354767,
0.4946601390838623,
0.5134316682815552,
0.2608661949634552,
-0.05230347067117691,
0.12154296785593033,
0.001347921323031187,
0.12933386862277985,
0.7882733345031738,
0.050689395517110825,
-0.42480048537254333,
-0.31322264671325684,
-0.19098711013793945,
-0.18360355496406555,
-0.2503768801689148,
0.634384274482727,
-0.23916921019554138,
0.03830357640981674,
0.40799978375434875,
0.8983608484268188,
-0.010713991709053516,
0.07711010426282883,
-0.015877390280365944,
-0.8689797520637512,
0.025244208052754402,
0.08720359206199646,
0.1851653754711151,
0.6407198309898376,
-0.7675724625587463,
0.3005390763282776,
0.11473895609378815,
-0.45440220832824707,
-0.9465058445930481,
0.1772005558013916,
-0.7950836420059204,
-0.21716776490211487,
1.340798258781433,
0.18368807435035706,
-0.03442666679620743,
-0.22040395438671112,
-0.3156889081001282,
0.6212946772575378,
-0.5777916312217712,
1.24541437625885,
0.4566328823566437,
0.3728245198726654,
-0.5183612704277039,
-0.4980725646018982,
0.3841242492198944,
-0.32665154337882996,
-1.0035779476165771,
0.08763221651315689,
0.2717806100845337,
0.30787041783332825,
0.2564544081687927,
0.3899664878845215,
0.43214523792266846,
0.11762745678424835,
-0.5920126438140869,
0.0834217295050621,
0.12352797389030457,
-0.6984021067619324,
-0.07779917865991592,
0.3013901114463806,
-0.4222899377346039,
-0.06598851084709167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11097v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11097v2 | InstructCMP: Length Control in Sentence Compression through Instruction-based Large Language Models | 2024-06-16T23:00:47 | 2024-06-18T18:35:52 | Juseon-Do, Jingun Kwon, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Manabu Okumura | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Extractive summarization can produce faithful summaries but often requires
additional constraints such as a desired summary length. Traditional sentence
compression models do not typically consider the constraints because of their
restricted model abilities, which require model modifications for coping with
them. To bridge this gap, we propose Instruction-based Compression
(InstructCMP), an approach to the sentence compression task that can consider
the length constraint through instructions by leveraging the zero-shot
task-solving abilities of Large Language Models (LLMs). For this purpose, we
created new evaluation datasets by transforming traditional sentence
compression datasets into an instruction format. By using the datasets, we
first reveal that the current LLMs still face challenges in accurately
controlling the length for a compressed text. To address this issue, we propose
an approach named "length priming," that incorporates additional length
information into the instructions without external resources. While the length
priming effectively works in a zero-shot setting, a training dataset with the
instructions would further improve the ability of length control. Thus, we
additionally created a training dataset in an instruction format to fine-tune
the model on it. Experimental results and analysis show that applying the
length priming significantly improves performances of InstructCMP in both
zero-shot and fine-tuning settings without the need of any model modifications. | [
-0.13609842956066132,
-0.6258542537689209,
0.6078841686248779,
0.19895149767398834,
-0.4630029499530792,
0.011944741010665894,
-0.5567322373390198,
-0.23125681281089783,
0.11752849072217941,
0.6530662178993225,
-0.544940173625946,
-0.431241899728775,
-0.9285263419151306,
0.17172951996326447,
-0.272625595331192,
0.9967312812805176,
-0.10782822221517563,
-0.04198092594742775,
-0.4716854691505432,
0.3445090055465698,
-0.8022923469543457,
-0.41743871569633484,
-0.05715591087937355,
-0.1343444287776947,
0.08559591323137283,
1.030792474746704,
0.64467853307724,
0.9979293346405029,
0.5196508169174194,
0.18630659580230713,
-0.05265652760863304,
0.36843574047088623,
-0.42472368478775024,
0.13114193081855774,
0.17711567878723145,
-0.5779000520706177,
-0.14853988587856293,
-0.06329597532749176,
0.7350051999092102,
0.7515134215354919,
-0.07680419832468033,
0.26052868366241455,
0.3249202370643616,
0.7535483241081238,
-1.0014888048171997,
0.3803955018520355,
-0.3455715477466583,
0.15431474149227142,
0.13823874294757843,
-0.7088183164596558,
-0.6546609401702881,
-0.13864947855472565,
-0.24768328666687012,
-0.10879901051521301,
0.08473265171051025,
0.10450132936239243,
0.6875205039978027,
0.2757771611213684,
-0.2887093126773834,
-0.2470434457063675,
-0.8253580927848816,
0.7655368447303772,
-1.0410739183425903,
0.022126851603388786,
0.26535555720329285,
-0.0003263286780565977,
-0.06262347102165222,
-0.3637021481990814,
-0.3408620357513428,
-0.20571370422840118,
-0.12273071706295013,
0.141546830534935,
0.04522588849067688,
0.3613570034503937,
0.4537416994571686,
0.46351712942123413,
-0.765001118183136,
0.34286463260650635,
-0.6121631860733032,
0.09838169813156128,
0.5361225605010986,
0.3716742992401123,
0.2961329221725464,
-0.2621592581272125,
-0.29441747069358826,
-0.02448386512696743,
-0.8607619404792786,
0.005058462265878916,
0.44703730940818787,
0.29477277398109436,
-0.12400566041469574,
1.0195039510726929,
-0.46818768978118896,
0.8806084990501404,
-0.05658126622438431,
-0.16655218601226807,
-0.024869240820407867,
0.06073266640305519,
-0.4828629195690155,
0.4424656629562378,
0.6715620756149292,
0.5756343007087708,
0.18377499282360077,
-0.3158072829246521,
-0.26761871576309204,
-0.10886260867118835,
0.09620972722768784,
-1.2637206315994263,
0.10053441673517227,
0.3070203363895416,
-0.5528662800788879,
-0.26688152551651,
0.2566468119621277,
-0.614211916923523,
0.07850652188062668,
-0.5537211894989014,
0.5187895894050598,
-0.47953203320503235,
0.4161979556083679,
0.6157203912734985,
-0.2093309611082077,
0.19818666577339172,
-0.18501776456832886,
-1.228033185005188,
0.5891262292861938,
0.798123836517334,
1.1488255262374878,
-0.04353015497326851,
-0.11121152341365814,
-0.7288463115692139,
0.3706904947757721,
-0.16099174320697784,
0.5704177618026733,
-0.6860565543174744,
-0.5186831951141357,
-0.06141357123851776,
0.08870703727006912,
-0.016926156356930733,
-0.36925560235977173,
0.40374556183815,
-0.17697031795978546,
0.3827700614929199,
0.23697292804718018,
-1.118402361869812,
0.0043151238933205605,
0.1919136643409729,
-0.3214253783226013,
0.44347894191741943,
0.05601061135530472,
-0.6105420589447021,
-0.08689434826374054,
-0.5999068021774292,
-0.6225854158401489,
0.12041181325912476,
-0.04643445461988449,
-0.3389841616153717,
0.32986927032470703,
0.6502297520637512,
0.784679114818573,
-0.17952772974967957,
0.07301870733499527,
0.015961473807692528,
-0.6603078842163086,
0.005023977719247341,
-0.5560989379882812,
0.5734876990318298,
-0.00021504044707398862,
-0.04326992109417915,
0.19391748309135437,
-0.697619616985321,
0.32567647099494934,
-0.031089434400200844,
-0.33343765139579773,
-0.03762373700737953,
-0.0857071802020073,
-0.4844607412815094,
0.017829162999987602,
0.3261795938014984,
-0.5963189005851746,
0.5616061687469482,
-0.6748197674751282,
0.41078078746795654,
0.5691814422607422,
0.4390065371990204,
0.6060613393783569,
-0.5441726446151733,
0.7755516171455383,
-0.4371674656867981,
0.38705262541770935,
-0.643211841583252,
-0.08740130811929703,
-0.7081221342086792,
-0.13335561752319336,
0.418420672416687,
0.8339853286743164,
-0.7949507832527161,
0.6699601411819458,
-0.5986286997795105,
-0.39930784702301025,
-0.24140502512454987,
-0.031314536929130554,
0.46509093046188354,
0.5051907896995544,
0.5951944589614868,
-0.35369083285331726,
-0.36181071400642395,
-0.8137367367744446,
0.0068550012074410915,
0.14668917655944824,
-0.46641838550567627,
0.09418323636054993,
0.3671340346336365,
0.4253584146499634,
0.7101498246192932,
-0.9581069350242615,
-0.24660377204418182,
-0.5680510401725769,
0.3883204460144043,
0.2110256403684616,
0.6215620636940002,
0.1947842687368393,
-0.43204376101493835,
-0.3476871848106384,
-0.5597817301750183,
-0.5552445650100708,
-0.29504919052124023,
-0.20680129528045654,
0.24118438363075256,
-0.11034902185201645,
0.42351624369621277,
-0.6072872281074524,
0.5256736874580383,
0.6430144906044006,
-0.09682291001081467,
0.8858613967895508,
-0.5369768142700195,
0.18714118003845215,
-0.9191206693649292,
-0.34189024567604065,
-0.2307571917772293,
-0.21337944269180298,
-0.26206013560295105,
-0.037820007652044296,
0.21270279586315155,
-0.37881070375442505,
-0.5140477418899536,
0.007776146288961172,
-0.7210878729820251,
0.056785374879837036,
-0.6045351028442383,
-0.22348898649215698,
0.18911893665790558,
0.7341626882553101,
0.09610255062580109,
0.7188006043434143,
0.30728596448898315,
-0.6465854048728943,
0.31541693210601807,
0.37094685435295105,
-0.5900257229804993,
0.24289920926094055,
-0.7772842645645142,
0.15466944873332977,
-0.25327545404434204,
0.13519319891929626,
-0.44664379954338074,
-0.3232868015766144,
0.2278033345937729,
-0.36950281262397766,
0.6545597910881042,
-0.3359060287475586,
-0.735493540763855,
-0.12780490517616272,
-0.4006672501564026,
-0.008945857174694538,
0.7176504731178284,
-0.2625105679035187,
0.18596994876861572,
0.05971021205186844,
-0.3965914249420166,
-0.6470316052436829,
-0.6896214485168457,
0.34654727578163147,
-0.19181691110134125,
-0.40037229657173157,
0.7488106489181519,
-0.34831464290618896,
0.09951493889093399,
-0.04006374627351761,
-0.0976681187748909,
-0.1300005316734314,
-0.1224784329533577,
0.34609782695770264,
0.30744287371635437,
-0.03541700541973114,
0.2517954409122467,
0.44135621190071106,
-0.028893055394291878,
0.1384941041469574,
-0.27759021520614624,
0.6179603934288025,
0.3153549134731293,
-0.11510399729013443,
-0.7147663831710815,
0.589414656162262,
0.3175405263900757,
-0.35441121459007263,
0.8591639995574951,
-0.02853585034608841,
-0.13143189251422882,
-0.4403262734413147,
-0.27629342675209045,
-0.4581662714481354,
-0.40446189045906067,
0.2548232078552246,
0.008683481253683567,
-0.9081135392189026,
-0.11587437987327576,
-0.19973768293857574,
0.013975328765809536,
0.04288214072585106,
0.2938840091228485,
0.06750207394361496,
0.8872746825218201,
1.0178511142730713,
-0.07449366897344589,
0.5451048612594604,
-0.32453835010528564,
-0.011021334677934647,
-0.7832329869270325,
-0.13907846808433533,
-0.483993262052536,
-0.4109291732311249,
0.08395563066005707,
-0.4000716507434845,
0.3398197591304779,
0.12250189483165741,
-0.09674093872308731,
0.4639204740524292,
-0.703123927116394,
0.9572322964668274,
0.369437575340271,
0.3733939826488495,
0.09090117365121841,
-0.18531210720539093,
0.3674199879169464,
-0.08186686038970947,
-0.8423276543617249,
-0.5213918685913086,
0.9721895456314087,
0.1260710507631302,
0.7406484484672546,
-0.16006477177143097,
0.6263904571533203,
0.25594374537467957,
-0.10570051521062851,
-0.9934232831001282,
0.6208319664001465,
-0.2412787675857544,
0.08713754266500473,
-0.3847317397594452,
-0.6182081699371338,
-0.7749529480934143,
-0.14026421308517456,
-0.15252037346363068,
-0.7051964998245239,
-0.07864778488874435,
0.044117748737335205,
-0.46087226271629333,
0.23474682867527008,
-0.6640582084655762,
0.6634231805801392,
-0.47050711512565613,
-0.023478500545024872,
-0.10280153900384903,
-0.7645460367202759,
0.2913832664489746,
0.4357476830482483,
-0.07272335886955261,
-0.04598313570022583,
-0.10391184687614441,
0.8047370910644531,
-0.7553730010986328,
0.9478044509887695,
0.07131624221801758,
0.18464522063732147,
0.2757185399532318,
0.096106618642807,
0.521877646446228,
-0.2262452393770218,
0.2567422688007355,
-0.07012812048196793,
0.0345834381878376,
-0.30030345916748047,
-1.0002509355545044,
0.4899551570415497,
-0.2671980857849121,
-0.6048282980918884,
-0.09238845109939575,
-0.8284116387367249,
-0.30472034215927124,
0.042441241443157196,
0.3887966275215149,
0.7398853898048401,
-0.04379269853234291,
0.5103329420089722,
0.6832438111305237,
-0.26029300689697266,
0.704685389995575,
0.5013667345046997,
0.13763175904750824,
-0.35136598348617554,
0.6359314918518066,
0.2776801288127899,
0.467122346162796,
0.9087161421775818,
0.21733275055885315,
-0.09970120340585709,
-0.6529427170753479,
-0.46423009037971497,
-0.05710916966199875,
-0.485821008682251,
-0.5545907020568848,
-0.4079821705818176,
-0.33885449171066284,
-0.4757869243621826,
-0.26003462076187134,
-0.1610981523990631,
-0.6398072838783264,
-0.3416152894496918,
-0.22070634365081787,
0.11555404961109161,
0.48525771498680115,
0.09186570346355438,
0.5924150943756104,
-1.0830979347229004,
0.18231995403766632,
0.04988399147987366,
0.22369971871376038,
-0.17330101132392883,
-0.8613231778144836,
-0.500984787940979,
-0.15686367452144623,
-0.3253038227558136,
-1.0626981258392334,
0.5857009291648865,
0.2824379503726959,
-0.08865789324045181,
0.47632870078086853,
0.2715202569961548,
0.6493052840232849,
-0.7376999855041504,
0.8046859502792358,
0.09191618859767914,
-0.9946403503417969,
0.5952398180961609,
0.0880378782749176,
0.7407673001289368,
0.22610321640968323,
0.46000587940216064,
-0.4402889609336853,
-0.3908478915691376,
-0.46273791790008545,
-0.8832636475563049,
0.5321632027626038,
0.22960086166858673,
0.4083836078643799,
-0.0029464447870850563,
0.4362284541130066,
0.07941514998674393,
0.2431289106607437,
-0.3667658865451813,
0.030484160408377647,
0.11133803427219391,
-0.3477923274040222,
0.0013544682879000902,
-0.7251761555671692,
-0.00007339625881286338,
0.051496922969818115,
0.7691155672073364,
-0.1340855211019516,
0.0905260294675827,
0.13465836644172668,
-0.21893030405044556,
0.12554201483726501,
0.7251946926116943,
0.5349392294883728,
0.6561950445175171,
-0.2795701026916504,
0.09070169180631638,
0.0528116375207901,
-0.3604503273963928,
0.14486831426620483,
0.153335303068161,
-0.20818570256233215,
-0.03494375944137573,
0.6225065588951111,
0.6598100662231445,
0.3414173722267151,
-0.9466135501861572,
0.7716494202613831,
0.024890122935175896,
-0.03667280822992325,
-0.2545381486415863,
0.28582173585891724,
-0.30762559175491333,
-0.06889787316322327,
-0.026562470942735672,
-0.19052137434482574,
0.24398861825466156,
-0.2651218771934509,
0.0848352462053299,
0.23031453788280487,
-0.42314720153808594,
-0.03704775869846344,
0.5221036076545715,
-0.009049933403730392,
-0.21268826723098755,
0.9037743806838989,
-0.044933006167411804,
-0.25133809447288513,
0.7299782037734985,
0.5821620225906372,
0.6619895696640015,
-0.10864683985710144,
0.17427146434783936,
0.3142986297607422,
0.48757991194725037,
-0.21701060235500336,
0.2010626643896103,
-0.1653636395931244,
-0.4376141130924225,
-0.901655375957489,
-0.3851734399795532,
-0.41724681854248047,
0.2376980036497116,
-0.8376433253288269,
0.35540473461151123,
-0.5000691413879395,
0.3415479063987732,
-0.24235938489437103,
-0.08661019057035446,
-0.25295424461364746,
0.1687796413898468,
0.12143372744321823,
1.1267794370651245,
-0.700002133846283,
0.5494293570518494,
-0.08913476765155792,
-0.4955453872680664,
-0.8114168643951416,
-0.05235712602734566,
-0.14155684411525726,
-0.22837331891059875,
0.4035288095474243,
0.6456983089447021,
0.003151331562548876,
-0.14123034477233887,
-0.9766685366630554,
-0.40299490094184875,
1.0499895811080933,
0.5856688618659973,
-0.7189823985099792,
-0.1457432508468628,
0.18794581294059753,
0.2521217167377472,
-0.524324893951416,
-0.1339970976114273,
0.35064148902893066,
0.1613112837076187,
-0.006299630273133516,
-0.748069167137146,
-0.02505399100482464,
0.02371746115386486,
-0.03853415697813034,
0.30545762181282043,
-0.3704011142253876,
0.5301757454872131,
-0.3858877718448639,
-0.3104129433631897,
0.2958943545818329,
0.8967581987380981,
-0.24531058967113495,
-0.0224519744515419,
0.24426817893981934,
0.5734891295433044,
0.45583051443099976,
0.20233599841594696,
1.1535053253173828,
-0.553364098072052,
0.16693150997161865,
1.5786534547805786,
-0.1534247100353241,
0.8975604772567749,
0.29601043462753296,
0.17798902094364166,
0.4793132245540619,
0.203007310628891,
-0.23745019733905792,
0.38446474075317383,
0.3074518144130707,
-0.2434522807598114,
-0.12237711250782013,
-0.21681708097457886,
-0.052784863859415054,
0.6170133948326111,
0.3094973564147949,
-0.5754254460334778,
0.019956249743700027,
0.10895077884197235,
0.30819517374038696,
0.2176389992237091,
-0.4851420223712921,
0.6341511011123657,
-0.031938184052705765,
-0.6636294722557068,
0.38085469603538513,
0.2774973213672638,
0.5513630509376526,
-0.9169336557388306,
-0.2168407440185547,
0.1089128851890564,
-0.1110570952296257,
-0.06109173595905304,
-0.8284263014793396,
0.40331295132637024,
0.13299421966075897,
-0.38384750485420227,
-0.48665282130241394,
0.6064459681510925,
-0.6073235869407654,
-0.46074914932250977,
-0.23531045019626617,
0.257463276386261,
0.31619247794151306,
-0.25490298867225647,
-0.2773972451686859,
-0.1631411463022232,
-0.13220584392547607,
-0.1100403442978859,
0.28437843918800354,
0.22492735087871552,
0.16005375981330872,
0.6306200623512268,
0.45422935485839844,
0.3001348078250885,
-0.27946335077285767,
-0.12062033265829086,
0.7388693690299988,
-0.5131095051765442,
-0.4949969947338104,
-1.0193169116973877,
0.25602036714553833,
-0.18523702025413513,
-0.06578201055526733,
0.538816511631012,
0.8262932896614075,
0.7272982001304626,
-0.3247937560081482,
0.6485992670059204,
-0.12961497902870178,
0.2849443852901459,
-1.0181480646133423,
0.42891594767570496,
-0.2786862552165985,
0.28441914916038513,
0.09288345277309418,
-0.6606541275978088,
-0.3656896948814392,
0.03352012485265732,
-0.36460211873054504,
-0.2296496480703354,
0.7127674221992493,
0.738878071308136,
-0.0025342730805277824,
-0.17762915790081024,
0.44707465171813965,
0.1439107060432434,
0.13433919847011566,
0.77252197265625,
0.53254634141922,
-0.036592572927474976,
0.7994859218597412,
-0.7072983384132385,
-0.3480822443962097,
0.04953595623373985,
-1.1001710891723633,
-0.9225941896438599,
-0.3508705198764801,
-0.326350599527359,
-0.06090385839343071,
0.0455881729722023,
0.9616138339042664,
0.7722958326339722,
-0.4539618194103241,
-0.1741904765367508,
0.04929310455918312,
-0.14539885520935059,
-0.47087740898132324,
-0.27235546708106995,
0.5034967660903931,
-0.4193996787071228,
-0.7654535174369812,
0.665446937084198,
0.658726155757904,
0.25150585174560547,
-0.1528196632862091,
0.17495089769363403,
0.09724877029657364,
0.20802289247512817,
0.585452139377594,
0.3012561798095703,
-0.2507126033306122,
-0.24824243783950806,
-0.1772213578224182,
0.21558256447315216,
0.05217365175485611,
1.0869024991989136,
-0.6782004833221436,
0.3383842408657074,
0.4796862006187439,
0.5380539894104004,
0.29182466864585876,
0.09879998117685318,
0.727214515209198,
-1.1982970237731934,
0.3778015971183777,
0.3715302646160126,
0.500123143196106,
0.3638055622577667,
-0.6833654642105103,
0.4566831886768341,
-0.11480361223220825,
-0.7279630899429321,
-0.5851256847381592,
0.3392230272293091,
-0.9122259020805359,
-0.6149342060089111,
0.9857362508773804,
-0.2735540270805359,
-0.22267015278339386,
0.36040961742401123,
-0.3863774836063385,
0.2778197228908539,
-0.23619221150875092,
0.9642715454101562,
0.626853346824646,
-0.22849082946777344,
-0.44226232171058655,
-0.46281012892723083,
0.28697195649147034,
0.296875536441803,
-0.9701823592185974,
0.17546400427818298,
0.6159247756004333,
0.05176278203725815,
-0.12536559998989105,
0.19725053012371063,
-0.04590355604887009,
0.1501610428094864,
-0.22725200653076172,
0.13192228972911835,
-0.5898720622062683,
-0.5879162549972534,
-0.36807772517204285,
0.38731423020362854,
-0.2797616720199585,
-0.34491896629333496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11096v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11096v2 | The Potential and Challenges of Evaluating Attitudes, Opinions, and Values in Large Language Models | 2024-06-16T22:59:18 | 2024-07-01T10:04:09 | Bolei Ma, Xinpeng Wang, Tiancheng Hu, Anna-Carolina Haensch, Michael A. Hedderich, Barbara Plank, Frauke Kreuter | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have sparked wide interest in
validating and comprehending the human-like cognitive-behavioral traits LLMs
may have. These cognitive-behavioral traits include typically Attitudes,
Opinions, Values (AOV). However, measuring AOV embedded within LLMs remains
opaque, and different evaluation methods may yield different results. This has
led to a lack of clarity on how different studies are related to each other and
how they can be interpreted. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing an
overview of recent works on the evaluation of AOV in LLMs. Moreover, we survey
related approaches in different stages of the evaluation pipeline in these
works. By doing so, we address the potential and challenges with respect to
understanding the model, human-AI alignment, and downstream application in
social sciences. Finally, we provide practical insights into evaluation
methods, model enhancement, and interdisciplinary collaboration, thereby
contributing to the evolving landscape of evaluating AOV in LLMs. | [
-0.3942784368991852,
-0.7712156176567078,
0.86918705701828,
0.075576551258564,
-0.025983864441514015,
0.23972973227500916,
-0.5205268859863281,
-0.42246612906455994,
-0.11974775046110153,
0.3297605514526367,
-0.49707284569740295,
-0.37611979246139526,
-0.782267153263092,
-0.0879189521074295,
-0.10192888230085373,
0.8568722605705261,
-0.06503905355930328,
0.3083544969558716,
-0.44973257184028625,
-0.4461170732975006,
-0.35380250215530396,
-0.7124173045158386,
-0.7205130457878113,
-0.6190832257270813,
0.36844050884246826,
0.1519831120967865,
0.8072196245193481,
0.3131970465183258,
0.4869372248649597,
0.3175121247768402,
-0.3733721673488617,
-0.03603365272283554,
-0.5247864127159119,
0.0827571302652359,
-0.19397182762622833,
-0.3595302402973175,
-0.6262396574020386,
0.29939958453178406,
0.8262409567832947,
0.8819242715835571,
-0.16111503541469574,
0.3260791301727295,
0.20249652862548828,
0.9631252288818359,
-0.6737557053565979,
0.37691566348075867,
-0.36537209153175354,
-0.1524229645729065,
-0.0929609164595604,
0.24695086479187012,
-0.2600122094154358,
-0.48777803778648376,
0.39169177412986755,
-0.16421714425086975,
-0.4376237094402313,
0.013218803331255913,
0.6711679697036743,
-0.004838420078158379,
-0.7286964654922485,
-0.5612375140190125,
-0.6418073773384094,
1.1431756019592285,
-0.7715370059013367,
0.3492281436920166,
0.08958027511835098,
0.13037677109241486,
-0.14424088597297668,
-0.2393277883529663,
-0.7422894835472107,
-0.18235689401626587,
0.23932935297489166,
0.012956677936017513,
-0.19570371508598328,
0.0297681987285614,
-0.2548291087150574,
0.4967886209487915,
-0.11695796251296997,
0.2663017809391022,
-0.13665787875652313,
0.04805687442421913,
0.9257881045341492,
0.43478259444236755,
0.16470591723918915,
-0.35753852128982544,
-0.1930738240480423,
-0.0830322727560997,
-0.6385634541511536,
0.3704427182674408,
0.6421805620193481,
-0.012483353726565838,
-0.17100702226161957,
0.6229386925697327,
-0.15060307085514069,
0.5668140649795532,
0.02623271942138672,
0.07598095387220383,
0.45779740810394287,
-0.22291719913482666,
-0.13751235604286194,
-0.3269984722137451,
0.9652314782142639,
0.36414456367492676,
0.3869681656360626,
0.023591313511133194,
-0.18641412258148193,
0.11535019427537918,
0.23537129163742065,
-0.41532692313194275,
0.1833663433790207,
0.44053447246551514,
-0.6345463395118713,
-0.5556407570838928,
-0.010569131001830101,
-0.6598649621009827,
-0.692566990852356,
-0.5806582570075989,
0.30016258358955383,
-0.2383822202682495,
-0.4773624539375305,
0.048455044627189636,
-0.011276233941316605,
0.5500221252441406,
0.6207769513130188,
-0.6798031330108643,
0.2630361318588257,
1.066335916519165,
0.7193664312362671,
-0.5295566916465759,
-0.3089097738265991,
-0.13374212384223938,
-0.1856750100851059,
-0.47871050238609314,
0.677016019821167,
-0.8039323091506958,
-0.4121456444263458,
-0.0005923348944634199,
-0.19209586083889008,
0.1670610010623932,
-0.37793731689453125,
0.48165854811668396,
-0.534753680229187,
-0.02633066475391388,
-0.5768922567367554,
-0.5518673062324524,
-0.1226642057299614,
0.5208847522735596,
-0.47327685356140137,
0.984683096408844,
-0.03788631781935692,
-0.6202517747879028,
0.19338934123516083,
-0.7529693841934204,
-0.27251115441322327,
-0.2201119363307953,
-0.20477387309074402,
-0.2171977162361145,
0.3559320569038391,
-0.005007264204323292,
0.4324674606323242,
-0.5801450610160828,
0.2577826976776123,
-0.5192458629608154,
-0.10808878391981125,
0.6392614841461182,
-0.4133298993110657,
1.0149997472763062,
0.25198543071746826,
-0.006820653099566698,
0.4233952462673187,
-0.5191299319267273,
0.011014771647751331,
0.13174226880073547,
-0.2285403460264206,
-0.488637238740921,
0.2050272524356842,
-0.1408282369375229,
0.17994458973407745,
0.4652402698993683,
-0.569945216178894,
0.206330344080925,
-0.37126433849334717,
0.74214106798172,
1.0693327188491821,
0.0691072940826416,
0.6130656599998474,
-0.10480597615242004,
0.6244359016418457,
-0.17981559038162231,
0.44105592370033264,
0.1553892195224762,
-0.3908407390117645,
-0.6802608966827393,
-0.16306589543819427,
0.050860702991485596,
0.21212653815746307,
-0.32907867431640625,
0.3570517599582672,
-0.2859821617603302,
-0.8749917149543762,
-0.8683029413223267,
0.1532364934682846,
0.37441304326057434,
0.23525993525981903,
0.10448669642210007,
-0.46797001361846924,
-0.18348300457000732,
-0.8299431204795837,
-0.500684916973114,
-0.583757758140564,
0.1191997230052948,
0.5257397890090942,
0.5597320795059204,
-0.09655231237411499,
0.9925578832626343,
-0.3718615174293518,
0.018864920362830162,
-0.13690833747386932,
0.32078126072883606,
0.16713209450244904,
0.13872914016246796,
0.20231658220291138,
-0.5979568958282471,
-0.24073871970176697,
0.08252903819084167,
-0.7239485383033752,
-0.15761104226112366,
0.44326460361480713,
0.06136889010667801,
0.08761334419250488,
0.3146072328090668,
-0.5518486499786377,
0.21453797817230225,
0.8798749446868896,
-0.25207459926605225,
0.583306610584259,
0.1054607629776001,
0.5215965509414673,
-0.6289002299308777,
-0.1835969090461731,
0.23635011911392212,
-0.02644878625869751,
-0.5267560482025146,
0.157614067196846,
-0.1882389485836029,
0.12779755890369415,
-0.6127694845199585,
0.6874189972877502,
-0.5615012645721436,
-0.286888062953949,
-0.1493101269006729,
0.2342674285173416,
0.05814989656209946,
0.19035236537456512,
0.08847443014383316,
0.46206849813461304,
0.47215917706489563,
-0.4089919924736023,
0.6405125856399536,
0.11119508743286133,
-0.6644435524940491,
0.7467729449272156,
-0.734724760055542,
0.4165571928024292,
-0.3193463385105133,
0.2641882002353668,
-0.9266350269317627,
0.13661186397075653,
0.10088711977005005,
-0.42508187890052795,
0.021889621391892433,
-0.25849080085754395,
-0.315479040145874,
-0.06087568402290344,
-0.5202156901359558,
0.4714687168598175,
0.4687974154949188,
-0.18866059184074402,
0.6681618690490723,
0.8234587907791138,
-0.38674867153167725,
-0.5394147634506226,
-0.2848985493183136,
0.10032538324594498,
-0.3300633728504181,
-0.5757714509963989,
0.04843168333172798,
0.021546801552176476,
-0.9445986747741699,
0.06475108116865158,
0.028561513870954514,
0.09361926466226578,
0.0755138248205185,
0.20126429200172424,
0.37707123160362244,
-0.22776667773723602,
0.08083516359329224,
-0.21109993755817413,
0.12844282388687134,
0.21173296868801117,
-0.11029545217752457,
0.3184514343738556,
-0.7064583897590637,
-0.5619325041770935,
-0.021099135279655457,
0.20303267240524292,
0.7170323133468628,
-0.4251703917980194,
0.6748600006103516,
0.29790884256362915,
-0.2683427929878235,
0.0355282761156559,
-0.6002278327941895,
0.023878274485468864,
-0.37878549098968506,
0.61190265417099,
-0.09910545498132706,
-0.9294938445091248,
0.3375687599182129,
-0.03168294578790665,
0.11494505405426025,
0.3819003999233246,
0.9356299638748169,
-0.25321903824806213,
0.9066615104675293,
0.5028542280197144,
-0.014563746750354767,
0.3373752534389496,
0.002022208645939827,
0.40454772114753723,
-1.3881076574325562,
-0.2749488353729248,
-0.4864509105682373,
-0.08019670099020004,
-0.33510756492614746,
-0.5014039278030396,
0.48596104979515076,
-0.028994083404541016,
-0.24857357144355774,
-0.14285945892333984,
-0.16372013092041016,
0.254625141620636,
-0.17728854715824127,
-0.01824365183711052,
0.47202759981155396,
-0.4294743239879608,
0.24831724166870117,
-0.13715426623821259,
-0.3387167751789093,
-1.012222409248352,
1.1815826892852783,
0.8037277460098267,
0.694145679473877,
0.2582482099533081,
0.19719082117080688,
0.43020644783973694,
0.749372661113739,
-1.222355842590332,
0.5626435875892639,
0.05218309536576271,
-0.8036637306213379,
-0.7631065249443054,
-0.20629103481769562,
-0.8262413144111633,
0.49960625171661377,
-0.38613516092300415,
-1.0901905298233032,
0.1770317107439041,
0.02991511858999729,
-0.10097498446702957,
0.2011364996433258,
-0.67453932762146,
0.8795009851455688,
-0.4283117949962616,
-0.35429003834724426,
-0.481301486492157,
-0.37813806533813477,
0.4360768795013428,
-0.11693999171257019,
0.4980475902557373,
-0.3920827805995941,
0.00692960387095809,
0.7525712847709656,
-0.3262659013271332,
0.7304668426513672,
-0.05799144506454468,
-0.4870525896549225,
0.450707346200943,
-0.13271981477737427,
0.34528201818466187,
-0.08926890045404434,
-0.4905860126018524,
0.5423302054405212,
0.10301651060581207,
-0.28942394256591797,
-0.6953603625297546,
0.8191096782684326,
-0.9153426289558411,
-0.8187013268470764,
-0.5403412580490112,
-0.4864611327648163,
-0.5063189268112183,
-0.12241945415735245,
-0.27968305349349976,
0.11905661970376968,
-0.6693126559257507,
0.17389072477817535,
0.6599582433700562,
-0.4393399953842163,
0.30528688430786133,
0.4652377963066101,
-0.32125356793403625,
-0.056927211582660675,
0.6768006682395935,
-0.016596263274550438,
0.47363540530204773,
0.16951370239257812,
0.30521804094314575,
-0.3093603551387787,
-0.5874909162521362,
-0.29875847697257996,
0.2668965458869934,
-0.9541083574295044,
0.2547537386417389,
-0.5136823058128357,
0.04801100865006447,
-0.4290900230407715,
-0.08610218018293381,
-0.6956332921981812,
-0.009482858702540398,
-0.04679426550865173,
0.0409875325858593,
0.3672037422657013,
1.1844536066055298,
0.3176102042198181,
0.05940800905227661,
-0.5850080847740173,
0.06487419456243515,
0.32396039366722107,
0.412384957075119,
0.4963189363479614,
-0.41569647192955017,
-0.07327616214752197,
0.15720224380493164,
-0.17254120111465454,
-0.931126058101654,
0.19201065599918365,
-0.234366774559021,
0.4759511947631836,
0.3330939710140228,
-0.032766975462436676,
0.6199955344200134,
-0.4311571717262268,
0.9613575339317322,
0.06282707303762436,
-1.233486294746399,
0.22400407493114471,
-0.2019326090812683,
0.007566608022898436,
0.45240598917007446,
0.37728217244148254,
-0.6233721375465393,
-0.16170527040958405,
-0.3942195773124695,
-0.9380760192871094,
0.5644349455833435,
0.14299125969409943,
0.17565827071666718,
0.16364791989326477,
0.18610073626041412,
0.0373428650200367,
0.34686166048049927,
-0.6377297043800354,
-0.257882684469223,
-0.011565896682441235,
-0.2063625007867813,
-0.18224625289440155,
-0.14125707745552063,
-0.07031290233135223,
-0.21708588302135468,
0.6388624310493469,
0.049584802240133286,
-0.008685063570737839,
-0.04285271838307381,
-0.22034816443920135,
0.01091915275901556,
0.7375909090042114,
0.14329007267951965,
0.7734352350234985,
-0.16694104671478271,
-0.028119364753365517,
0.32541388273239136,
-0.22204025089740753,
0.279583603143692,
-0.3387879729270935,
0.15559232234954834,
-0.4269033968448639,
0.3357696831226349,
0.7228139638900757,
0.0594952329993248,
-0.6783592104911804,
0.768713116645813,
-0.003171722637489438,
0.20352190732955933,
-0.46384739875793457,
-0.19130373001098633,
0.2453279048204422,
0.19084547460079193,
0.20887349545955658,
-0.13666322827339172,
0.0016205066349357367,
-1.128440022468567,
-0.40426546335220337,
0.639078676700592,
-0.8332430124282837,
-0.3661350607872009,
0.1689252406358719,
0.3226667046546936,
-0.18088705837726593,
0.5455936789512634,
0.003947429824620485,
-0.4382942318916321,
0.6404887437820435,
0.04066795855760574,
0.8288689255714417,
-0.18445822596549988,
0.007562967017292976,
-0.1666879802942276,
0.4269258677959442,
0.12374353408813477,
0.09462746232748032,
0.1799692064523697,
-0.9930285811424255,
-0.5444543361663818,
-0.7268509864807129,
-0.5248618721961975,
0.22316019237041473,
-0.8221308588981628,
0.3427589237689972,
-0.1856711059808731,
-0.33765777945518494,
0.1806718111038208,
-0.0793616771697998,
-0.7526915669441223,
0.08940257877111435,
0.24586939811706543,
0.5393117666244507,
-1.0179286003112793,
0.7966984510421753,
1.1341534852981567,
-0.11247380077838898,
-0.4757689833641052,
0.14378871023654938,
0.28832346200942993,
-0.9398508667945862,
0.7011009454727173,
-0.25443777441978455,
-0.38556110858917236,
-0.23653264343738556,
-0.40231844782829285,
-0.767310619354248,
0.8459867238998413,
0.12789057195186615,
-0.38452965021133423,
0.041890546679496765,
-0.07498989254236221,
0.67865389585495,
-0.5066720247268677,
0.48897287249565125,
0.8154553771018982,
0.7857404351234436,
-0.18787367641925812,
-0.8310921788215637,
-0.13132594525814056,
-0.30608931183815,
0.18807655572891235,
0.06007979065179825,
-0.9390108585357666,
0.7043187618255615,
-0.12875992059707642,
0.027131306007504463,
-0.22375313937664032,
0.8553048968315125,
0.3165477216243744,
0.1430685818195343,
0.6487358808517456,
0.2403741180896759,
0.5892823338508606,
-0.030569564551115036,
1.1044602394104004,
-0.034108612686395645,
0.3688432276248932,
0.7824607491493225,
-0.61393803358078,
0.9150148034095764,
0.556118369102478,
-0.4988979995250702,
0.45750296115875244,
0.5593906044960022,
0.15532760322093964,
0.1408742219209671,
0.436653196811676,
-0.1232379749417305,
-0.1906038522720337,
-0.27302244305610657,
-0.03709597885608673,
0.5824545621871948,
0.6318778395652771,
-0.09350483864545822,
0.15694938600063324,
-0.24608637392520905,
0.08507206290960312,
0.17039434611797333,
-0.5593544840812683,
0.6915388107299805,
0.23421023786067963,
-0.8330258131027222,
0.13882802426815033,
0.1489972174167633,
0.6653396487236023,
-0.48712846636772156,
-0.05526913329958916,
0.19203010201454163,
-0.0582784004509449,
-0.2845132648944855,
-1.2576614618301392,
0.3033588230609894,
0.27995744347572327,
-0.1250908076763153,
-0.1790180653333664,
0.5120535492897034,
-0.059626832604408264,
-0.26225319504737854,
0.28359606862068176,
0.4740445017814636,
0.18501470983028412,
0.041661448776721954,
-0.5839259624481201,
0.4678601920604706,
-0.13358017802238464,
-0.5674489736557007,
0.3089432716369629,
0.4822194576263428,
-0.19153518974781036,
0.7472566962242126,
0.43496841192245483,
0.26713883876800537,
-0.22836627066135406,
0.05029321834445,
0.6050002574920654,
-0.6723431348800659,
-0.1237359344959259,
-1.0761417150497437,
0.42925095558166504,
0.11455010622739792,
-0.46883952617645264,
0.7539352178573608,
0.2671573758125305,
0.6866222023963928,
0.11563132703304291,
1.0923808813095093,
-0.057972878217697144,
0.1573641151189804,
-0.538506805896759,
0.6222399473190308,
-0.35543879866600037,
0.4682621657848358,
-0.6763216257095337,
-0.799470067024231,
0.196365624666214,
0.6179901957511902,
-0.6478159427642822,
0.2100338488817215,
0.6187900900840759,
0.33503851294517517,
0.34248822927474976,
-0.06033379212021828,
0.10371778905391693,
0.3470618426799774,
0.2834441363811493,
0.4362366199493408,
1.275443196296692,
-0.24632637202739716,
0.23608404397964478,
0.0777660608291626,
-0.4659155309200287,
-0.12999354302883148,
-1.230194091796875,
-0.7953319549560547,
-0.573401927947998,
-0.4645327627658844,
-0.39588773250579834,
0.07896598428487778,
1.081735610961914,
0.5030890703201294,
-0.6534416675567627,
-0.5529173612594604,
0.24615870416164398,
0.3222302794456482,
-0.11129159480333328,
-0.24284835159778595,
0.3343859016895294,
0.10059314966201782,
-0.837804913520813,
0.09229931235313416,
0.5913811326026917,
-0.16666944324970245,
-0.8663795590400696,
-0.2586013674736023,
-0.1019812747836113,
0.4331582486629486,
0.7940061092376709,
0.20313940942287445,
-0.9188380241394043,
-0.3338761031627655,
-0.12306181341409683,
-0.07932727038860321,
0.07755567133426666,
0.7090418338775635,
-0.5790194272994995,
0.387831449508667,
0.44261229038238525,
0.5350764989852905,
0.2566912770271301,
-0.011191596277058125,
0.8360188603401184,
-0.2890748381614685,
-0.12450232356786728,
0.3809756636619568,
0.4732484221458435,
0.5315964221954346,
-0.1592193841934204,
0.25561726093292236,
-0.2110578566789627,
-0.5718486905097961,
-0.8882321119308472,
0.4595254957675934,
-0.8878769874572754,
-0.23390713334083557,
1.4005725383758545,
-0.23815497756004333,
-0.28459152579307556,
-0.20104509592056274,
-0.024697022512555122,
0.12773387134075165,
-0.38062092661857605,
0.8037320971488953,
1.141054391860962,
-0.29065003991127014,
-0.0658668726682663,
-0.682064950466156,
0.27300480008125305,
0.3907324969768524,
-0.8636255860328674,
0.31109732389450073,
0.4245154559612274,
0.20286160707473755,
0.0410110168159008,
0.6001728177070618,
-0.6159095764160156,
-0.15512079000473022,
-0.5004283785820007,
0.2502691447734833,
0.2936360538005829,
0.07695581018924713,
-0.6546339988708496,
-0.027830520644783974,
0.6040220856666565,
0.2601623237133026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11093v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11093v1 | RAEmoLLM: Retrieval Augmented LLMs for Cross-Domain Misinformation Detection Using In-Context Learning based on Emotional Information | 2024-06-16T22:49:11 | 2024-06-16T22:49:11 | Zhiwei Liu, Kailai Yang, Qianqian Xie, Christine de Kock, Sophia Ananiadou, Eduard Hovy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Misinformation is prevalent in various fields such as education, politics,
health, etc., causing significant harm to society. However, current methods for
cross-domain misinformation detection rely on time and resources consuming
fine-tuning and complex model structures. With the outstanding performance of
LLMs, many studies have employed them for misinformation detection.
Unfortunately, they focus on in-domain tasks and do not incorporate significant
sentiment and emotion features (which we jointly call affect). In this paper,
we propose RAEmoLLM, the first retrieval augmented (RAG) LLMs framework to
address cross-domain misinformation detection using in-context learning based
on affective information. It accomplishes this by applying an emotion-aware LLM
to construct a retrieval database of affective embeddings. This database is
used by our retrieval module to obtain source-domain samples, which are
subsequently used for the inference module's in-context few-shot learning to
detect target domain misinformation. We evaluate our framework on three
misinformation benchmarks. Results show that RAEmoLLM achieves significant
improvements compared to the zero-shot method on three datasets, with the
highest increases of 20.69%, 23.94%, and 39.11% respectively. This work will be
released on https://github.com/lzw108/RAEmoLLM. | [
-0.3247257471084595,
-0.8317123651504517,
0.3420357406139374,
0.32384589314460754,
-0.13912560045719147,
0.18217049539089203,
-0.07453293353319168,
-0.690511167049408,
0.5959324836730957,
0.1690749228000641,
-0.49555322527885437,
-0.6642531156539917,
-0.8015474081039429,
0.21134528517723083,
-0.25169500708580017,
0.765219509601593,
-0.14245177805423737,
-0.02093752846121788,
-0.42023965716362,
-0.250783234834671,
-0.24110020697116852,
-0.3163376450538635,
-0.22998055815696716,
-0.4375852644443512,
0.43859782814979553,
0.7676534652709961,
0.37523382902145386,
0.050564780831336975,
0.5283645391464233,
0.08487247675657272,
-0.1312149167060852,
0.4333384037017822,
-0.6576352715492249,
0.46136248111724854,
-0.2990325689315796,
-0.5652370452880859,
-0.15473809838294983,
0.07024189829826355,
0.4429738521575928,
-0.05371459946036339,
0.028771188110113144,
0.03141823783516884,
-0.18723297119140625,
0.8388437628746033,
-0.9556387066841125,
-0.11283963918685913,
-0.6596164703369141,
0.24698767066001892,
-0.225627601146698,
-0.6216037273406982,
-0.43625473976135254,
-0.33845779299736023,
-0.07296111434698105,
-0.39163851737976074,
-0.08140280097723007,
0.49972525238990784,
0.7368738651275635,
0.21233965456485748,
-0.4920618534088135,
-0.448722779750824,
-0.12719424068927765,
1.0249199867248535,
-0.6603339314460754,
0.5625292062759399,
0.46313783526420593,
-0.060667604207992554,
-0.016855118796229362,
-0.3369116187095642,
-0.5487864017486572,
0.1908629983663559,
0.028468100354075432,
0.4002106487751007,
-0.5083969831466675,
-0.19904650747776031,
0.09042181074619293,
0.298644095659256,
-0.6603052020072937,
-0.04239759221673012,
0.05467142164707184,
-0.027656495571136475,
0.49958521127700806,
0.027490640059113503,
0.3699081242084503,
-0.5490210652351379,
-0.7277947664260864,
0.020322255790233612,
-0.7864539623260498,
-0.3966420590877533,
0.19615031778812408,
0.18442998826503754,
-0.1756918877363205,
0.6765417456626892,
-0.16004543006420135,
0.42083868384361267,
0.34780648350715637,
-0.18932078778743744,
0.44731050729751587,
0.21553975343704224,
-0.34765729308128357,
0.3562203645706177,
0.5271522402763367,
0.4393664002418518,
-0.022262781858444214,
-0.07528884708881378,
-0.2669312655925751,
0.17547397315502167,
0.11023227125406265,
-0.8815333843231201,
0.26745590567588806,
0.19912296533584595,
-0.4903610348701477,
-0.11358083039522171,
-0.07844365388154984,
-0.9576210975646973,
-0.659911572933197,
-0.2539260685443878,
0.5258840322494507,
-0.7000824809074402,
-0.27072498202323914,
0.16263830661773682,
0.10054538398981094,
-0.002742999466136098,
0.4660260081291199,
-0.4143766462802887,
-0.05696408823132515,
0.6169057488441467,
0.7932115793228149,
-0.5495871305465698,
0.08682230859994888,
-0.5387793779373169,
0.004113950300961733,
0.0031477659940719604,
1.0285933017730713,
-0.7458401322364807,
-0.4470689594745636,
0.07920155674219131,
-0.11633401364088058,
-0.09814193099737167,
-0.8567943572998047,
0.6586581468582153,
-0.7456691265106201,
0.2198590487241745,
-0.16390500962734222,
-0.7635895609855652,
-0.3393360674381256,
0.6983320116996765,
-0.49222424626350403,
1.1571029424667358,
0.18417242169380188,
-1.095088243484497,
0.10289731621742249,
-0.44744834303855896,
-0.4920697808265686,
-0.09718024730682373,
0.047478582710027695,
-0.5266087055206299,
0.05252863094210625,
0.11068782210350037,
0.5737167000770569,
-0.41502314805984497,
-0.017697617411613464,
-0.30107542872428894,
-0.2924748659133911,
0.32038119435310364,
-0.31724727153778076,
0.3184603154659271,
0.20885583758354187,
-0.3703596889972687,
-0.1111336350440979,
-0.3846032917499542,
0.014977649785578251,
-0.2246302366256714,
-0.3633722960948944,
-0.6637693047523499,
-0.44701242446899414,
0.06038645654916763,
0.40116915106773376,
0.008844573050737381,
-0.651375949382782,
-0.07794441282749176,
-0.10522279143333435,
-0.5218695402145386,
0.4563254714012146,
0.23746438324451447,
0.5091705322265625,
-0.4603756070137024,
0.7825311422348022,
0.47944745421409607,
0.08173643797636032,
-0.06571463495492935,
-0.3833407461643219,
-0.572684645652771,
-0.22796760499477386,
-0.053520623594522476,
0.7139416337013245,
-0.9262330532073975,
-0.0052267699502408504,
0.09523829817771912,
-0.24573597311973572,
-0.6008764505386353,
0.22059234976768494,
0.5698766708374023,
0.6725661158561707,
0.6409870386123657,
-0.0664294958114624,
-0.6463944315910339,
-0.6540184617042542,
-0.9097562432289124,
0.045192476361989975,
0.35979223251342773,
0.5261972546577454,
0.41476988792419434,
-0.7282078266143799,
0.892428457736969,
-0.2492683380842209,
-0.5789008140563965,
-0.186293825507164,
0.4674373269081116,
0.10740824788808823,
0.12068171799182892,
0.5000132322311401,
-1.034420371055603,
-0.6913689970970154,
-0.028471074998378754,
-0.8076145648956299,
-0.3884657919406891,
0.19366790354251862,
-0.20133067667484283,
0.5065862536430359,
-0.04776058346033096,
-0.5957245230674744,
0.5574125647544861,
0.4811765253543854,
-0.2639266550540924,
0.47390076518058777,
0.3303453028202057,
0.5549465417861938,
-1.217946171760559,
-0.26616179943084717,
0.45787155628204346,
-0.3859242796897888,
-0.4337633550167084,
-0.4146643877029419,
0.34271717071533203,
0.27928948402404785,
-0.6913884878158569,
0.7774778008460999,
-0.6127154231071472,
0.07527119666337967,
-0.38528215885162354,
0.5655677318572998,
0.04888883978128433,
0.18926654756069183,
-0.052043478935956955,
0.49495553970336914,
0.3145124316215515,
-0.48025110363960266,
0.2837250530719757,
0.3059638440608978,
-0.1251031905412674,
1.233441948890686,
0.0020925148855894804,
0.024167878553271294,
-0.33524078130722046,
0.12491294741630554,
-0.40535569190979004,
-0.2912460267543793,
0.5350162386894226,
-0.6347071528434753,
0.40286773443222046,
-0.30181992053985596,
-0.3815895915031433,
0.10418447107076645,
-0.4260403513908386,
0.2235812246799469,
0.18341916799545288,
-0.7365666627883911,
0.9088501334190369,
0.5295179486274719,
0.04835055023431778,
-0.6915110945701599,
-0.8471643924713135,
0.014120402745902538,
-0.36312469840049744,
-0.5313250422477722,
0.2431587427854538,
-0.12348661571741104,
-0.47476890683174133,
0.19985561072826385,
-0.46738341450691223,
-0.01746392995119095,
-0.2600722908973694,
0.5371819734573364,
0.15344741940498352,
-0.04857280105352402,
0.5213143825531006,
0.10989559441804886,
-0.013546187430620193,
0.030002078041434288,
-0.013190951198339462,
0.07010667771100998,
-0.18567557632923126,
-0.39129048585891724,
-0.32241013646125793,
0.40713226795196533,
0.19182291626930237,
-0.05110939219594002,
0.6927944421768188,
0.6501820683479309,
-0.5882321000099182,
-0.6450873017311096,
-0.6473023295402527,
-0.18628542125225067,
-0.36957108974456787,
0.24272765219211578,
-0.04395676776766777,
-1.058566689491272,
0.2567131221294403,
-0.5214745998382568,
-0.5265148282051086,
0.4196687638759613,
0.3337990343570709,
-0.1860504001379013,
0.6063178181648254,
0.4623583257198334,
-0.31075331568717957,
0.5678108334541321,
-0.3300110995769501,
0.12236131727695465,
-0.8032370209693909,
-0.47114256024360657,
-0.25002336502075195,
-0.4680314064025879,
0.00894138216972351,
-0.7098749876022339,
0.38364866375923157,
0.12854115664958954,
0.048020172864198685,
-0.19874164462089539,
-0.1904485523700714,
0.49766865372657776,
0.14263223111629486,
0.29311612248420715,
0.3610706329345703,
0.17315039038658142,
0.10608021169900894,
-0.25196772813796997,
-0.6747663617134094,
-0.18006116151809692,
0.7688601016998291,
0.14962300658226013,
1.25983726978302,
0.20859752595424652,
0.7415164113044739,
0.6511734127998352,
0.8746225237846375,
-1.0003445148468018,
0.29901930689811707,
0.014602327719330788,
-0.46635469794273376,
0.25085124373435974,
-0.5985186100006104,
-0.5427271127700806,
0.2642672657966614,
-0.5267594456672668,
-0.4270114004611969,
0.41503244638442993,
0.034346193075180054,
0.0726577565073967,
0.5461871027946472,
-0.37245702743530273,
0.5086726546287537,
-0.4446612298488617,
-0.44441717863082886,
-0.3939335346221924,
-0.6250295639038086,
0.416221022605896,
-0.19419682025909424,
0.26691898703575134,
-0.29315435886383057,
-0.022898409515619278,
0.6132317185401917,
-0.012417306192219257,
0.8385035991668701,
-0.2929079830646515,
0.06789866834878922,
0.2382567822933197,
0.2922306954860687,
0.5569995641708374,
0.2726411521434784,
-0.3385944068431854,
0.024818161502480507,
-0.36764490604400635,
0.05687322840094566,
-0.577981173992157,
0.8709156513214111,
-0.47915399074554443,
-0.19708506762981415,
-0.7043895125389099,
-0.66608726978302,
-0.37585169076919556,
0.08356086909770966,
0.16427409648895264,
0.2373592108488083,
-0.17947620153427124,
0.32660043239593506,
1.1664466857910156,
-0.18886660039424896,
0.1280951201915741,
0.833828866481781,
-0.4033273160457611,
-0.27308955788612366,
0.6923190951347351,
-0.20876143872737885,
0.0943726897239685,
0.5011143088340759,
-0.024454306811094284,
-0.29224562644958496,
-0.08511639386415482,
-0.045860011130571365,
0.4556739628314972,
-0.9261209964752197,
-0.9141384363174438,
-0.7627917528152466,
-0.011195643804967403,
-0.13801327347755432,
0.0046818978153169155,
-0.3017197251319885,
-0.094453826546669,
-0.7789100408554077,
-0.08809321373701096,
0.7823547720909119,
0.7747005224227905,
-0.23412396013736725,
0.22773541510105133,
-0.8692594766616821,
0.5991403460502625,
-0.09457136690616608,
0.42966505885124207,
-0.22917836904525757,
-0.7586942315101624,
-0.5666295289993286,
0.21630620956420898,
-0.3953686058521271,
-0.9778673052787781,
0.7995737791061401,
0.40916451811790466,
0.4079294204711914,
0.4334436058998108,
0.3092060983181,
0.6310734748840332,
-0.002261810004711151,
0.3456253111362457,
0.12085621058940887,
-0.897982656955719,
0.49251285195350647,
0.19748854637145996,
0.03287743404507637,
0.4260452389717102,
0.8971458673477173,
-0.8903930187225342,
-0.2088783234357834,
-0.5472401976585388,
-0.8021453619003296,
0.8343883752822876,
-0.1606924682855606,
-0.07814929634332657,
-0.2497829794883728,
0.36740177869796753,
0.17148415744304657,
0.10390446335077286,
-0.49384886026382446,
-0.41737785935401917,
0.10569217801094055,
-0.3813549876213074,
0.28535205125808716,
-0.5624620914459229,
-0.0268255528062582,
0.08578342944383621,
0.9896485805511475,
-0.13849784433841705,
0.17794029414653778,
0.4235660433769226,
-0.7187309861183167,
-0.43566080927848816,
0.3153148591518402,
0.23047806322574615,
0.31504133343696594,
-0.36032751202583313,
0.20304518938064575,
0.09384364634752274,
-0.47234615683555603,
0.06309743970632553,
0.0582868866622448,
0.05125182867050171,
0.37498196959495544,
0.09651905298233032,
0.7861158847808838,
0.5595000386238098,
-0.5820554494857788,
0.6231111884117126,
-0.03368164598941803,
-0.05152610316872597,
-0.19272202253341675,
-0.1991085410118103,
-0.002566494047641754,
0.6969600915908813,
0.5617926120758057,
0.15834105014801025,
0.2040470987558365,
-0.3960059583187103,
0.3409115672111511,
0.43489179015159607,
-0.46538791060447693,
-0.27649644017219543,
0.49974408745765686,
0.13003653287887573,
-0.04842422902584076,
0.25138360261917114,
-0.13570304214954376,
-0.6290925145149231,
0.2797028720378876,
0.652675211429596,
0.9711291193962097,
-0.4286669194698334,
0.39105644822120667,
0.07141759246587753,
0.20486538112163544,
-0.1926567554473877,
0.6170973777770996,
0.004681962076574564,
-0.7880578637123108,
-0.023454569280147552,
-0.5035558342933655,
-0.6991652846336365,
-0.36118513345718384,
-0.5457630157470703,
0.13449089229106903,
-0.1299692839384079,
-0.36704087257385254,
-0.5126619338989258,
-0.0008667866350151598,
-0.5181161165237427,
0.44970452785491943,
0.009660765528678894,
1.039294958114624,
-0.741568922996521,
0.5769084692001343,
0.7273364067077637,
-0.20522430539131165,
-0.4411065876483917,
0.12735392153263092,
0.43734145164489746,
-0.43383514881134033,
0.9503606557846069,
0.19617776572704315,
-0.4739505648612976,
-0.08173773437738419,
-0.5550338625907898,
-0.7648633122444153,
1.1857880353927612,
0.43659213185310364,
-0.4842749834060669,
0.4912324845790863,
0.024193456396460533,
0.2867377698421478,
-0.7132284641265869,
0.330791711807251,
0.10863690823316574,
0.4862872064113617,
0.22104232013225555,
-0.348806232213974,
-0.19124822318553925,
-0.27022936940193176,
-0.18773779273033142,
0.07123219966888428,
-0.5425263047218323,
0.6436330080032349,
-0.02677038498222828,
-0.33393657207489014,
-0.47823566198349,
0.7175963521003723,
0.26103225350379944,
0.7088460326194763,
0.37766700983047485,
0.7896795868873596,
0.8216871023178101,
-0.03012729249894619,
1.0609571933746338,
-0.33762404322624207,
0.5208255648612976,
1.0482394695281982,
-0.399041086435318,
0.9563608169555664,
0.4822517931461334,
0.13188700377941132,
0.5192833542823792,
0.6470556855201721,
0.5111059546470642,
0.38865771889686584,
0.023446036502718925,
-0.6953942775726318,
-0.15019340813159943,
-0.255788117647171,
-0.3638526499271393,
0.03683248907327652,
0.6244463920593262,
-0.3476329743862152,
-0.149373397231102,
0.2793678641319275,
0.13758431375026703,
-0.029237307608127594,
-0.45505213737487793,
0.5378650426864624,
0.45214369893074036,
-0.01337653398513794,
0.554057240486145,
-0.01738893985748291,
1.1781363487243652,
-0.5112510919570923,
-0.033321354538202286,
-0.5707663893699646,
0.1620703786611557,
-0.7110351324081421,
-0.784429132938385,
0.30152392387390137,
0.2048143744468689,
-0.45170721411705017,
-0.2913474440574646,
1.2056703567504883,
-0.7955464720726013,
-0.18551373481750488,
0.6692988872528076,
0.5119712948799133,
0.1249781996011734,
-0.29544633626937866,
-0.6808212995529175,
0.29896068572998047,
-0.11668392270803452,
-0.49822568893432617,
0.29889410734176636,
0.6884349584579468,
0.0075755370780825615,
0.7807859778404236,
0.32634568214416504,
0.019984155893325806,
0.12680232524871826,
0.06994738429784775,
0.9084451794624329,
-0.673283040523529,
-0.17357608675956726,
-0.5994123816490173,
0.44502151012420654,
-0.026798177510499954,
-0.11600524187088013,
0.944119930267334,
0.6066062450408936,
0.6466563940048218,
-0.09559163451194763,
0.8066131472587585,
0.0626470223069191,
0.8653845191001892,
-0.5207859873771667,
0.7590216398239136,
-0.901321530342102,
0.27408015727996826,
-0.5211299061775208,
-0.9360566735267639,
-0.6412830352783203,
0.44979050755500793,
-0.24496866762638092,
0.01662011444568634,
0.6311098337173462,
0.9462666511535645,
-0.21246112883090973,
0.10457407683134079,
0.3823975622653961,
0.44043341279029846,
-0.09026294201612473,
0.46020475029945374,
0.7438406348228455,
-0.3999041020870209,
0.09446978569030762,
-0.1263451725244522,
-0.1670394092798233,
-0.7222225069999695,
-0.9157471060752869,
-0.6284390091896057,
-0.2715674936771393,
-0.3177523910999298,
-0.4546019434928894,
0.2240384966135025,
1.0497148036956787,
0.39125239849090576,
-0.6486711502075195,
0.05820872634649277,
0.5808312296867371,
0.367314875125885,
0.2921391427516937,
-0.31245121359825134,
0.19581176340579987,
-0.2473967969417572,
-0.4994853436946869,
0.637120246887207,
0.6296757459640503,
-0.15788684785366058,
0.10235995799303055,
-0.3873147666454315,
-0.5955255031585693,
0.2669507563114166,
0.6690732836723328,
0.4064366817474365,
-0.42060932517051697,
-0.13289467990398407,
-0.10754713416099548,
-0.2606505751609802,
0.23814217746257782,
0.5543228983879089,
-0.9215493202209473,
0.6182371377944946,
0.3079838454723358,
0.9531886577606201,
0.5420748591423035,
0.24389542639255524,
0.014977230690419674,
-0.9039910435676575,
0.04954250156879425,
0.4010319709777832,
0.31642526388168335,
0.6064247488975525,
-0.5896161198616028,
0.3194769620895386,
0.38246670365333557,
-0.5645003914833069,
-0.5471507906913757,
0.04007803648710251,
-1.0053225755691528,
0.020123261958360672,
1.1870334148406982,
-0.1038687527179718,
-0.4139384329319,
0.11394280940294266,
-0.34170499444007874,
0.25577718019485474,
-0.5533758997917175,
0.8297544121742249,
0.29168692231178284,
-0.24869957566261292,
-0.3281591236591339,
-0.29454755783081055,
0.46075740456581116,
0.4506206810474396,
-1.0500221252441406,
-0.23461543023586273,
0.6109545826911926,
0.3070627450942993,
-0.11561199277639389,
0.3626517951488495,
-0.21872477233409882,
0.24865400791168213,
-0.44718408584594727,
0.3407408893108368,
-0.03522821143269539,
-0.25393813848495483,
-0.45476987957954407,
-0.10486509650945663,
-0.38606634736061096,
0.11834627389907837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11087v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11087v2 | MemDPT: Differential Privacy for Memory Efficient Language Models | 2024-06-16T22:11:41 | 2024-06-20T05:43:50 | Yanming Liu, Xinyue Peng, Jiannan Cao, Yuwei Zhang, Chen Ma, Songhang Deng, Mengchen Fu, Xuhong Zhang, Sheng Cheng, Xun Wang, Jianwei Yin, Tianyu Du | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models have consistently demonstrated remarkable performance
across a wide spectrum of applications. Nonetheless, the deployment of these
models can inadvertently expose user privacy to potential risks. The
substantial memory demands of these models during training represent a
significant resource consumption challenge. The sheer size of these models
imposes a considerable burden on memory resources, which is a matter of
significant concern in practice. In this paper, we present an innovative
training framework MemDPT that not only reduces the memory cost of large
language models but also places a strong emphasis on safeguarding user data
privacy. MemDPT provides edge network and reverse network designs to
accommodate various differential privacy memory-efficient fine-tuning schemes.
Our approach not only achieves $2 \sim 3 \times$ memory optimization but also
provides robust privacy protection, ensuring that user data remains secure and
confidential. Extensive experiments have demonstrated that MemDPT can
effectively provide differential privacy efficient fine-tuning across various
task scenarios. | [
-0.4388592839241028,
-0.5826796293258667,
0.20350852608680725,
0.05483813211321831,
-0.232498437166214,
0.06144542992115021,
-0.06207837536931038,
-0.19638293981552124,
-0.0827161967754364,
0.5419728755950928,
-0.7084448933601379,
-0.42138516902923584,
-0.4126569628715515,
-0.18075793981552124,
-0.06543423980474472,
0.524394154548645,
0.00828992947936058,
0.09317690134048462,
0.26960015296936035,
-0.090018130838871,
-0.14633043110370636,
-0.8526575565338135,
-0.7346708178520203,
-0.1710527390241623,
0.3465994596481323,
0.40916866064071655,
0.6861639618873596,
0.9378888607025146,
0.15586015582084656,
0.30593106150627136,
0.12413772940635681,
0.0748826339840889,
-0.6196673512458801,
0.21843929588794708,
-0.4742242693901062,
-0.10602787882089615,
-0.5790278315544128,
-0.016021544113755226,
0.5801159143447876,
0.6464762091636658,
-0.1068514734506607,
0.14314833283424377,
0.03659477084875107,
0.8417530059814453,
-1.0212624073028564,
-0.21055257320404053,
-0.6135759949684143,
0.03796432539820671,
-0.2774605453014374,
-0.28141316771507263,
-0.2321503460407257,
-0.22277934849262238,
0.14514030516147614,
-0.09005937725305557,
0.03469974175095558,
-0.15153923630714417,
0.43122443556785583,
0.14286360144615173,
-0.3816569447517395,
0.3878939151763916,
-0.6135849356651306,
0.8637738823890686,
-0.5652605891227722,
0.7257623076438904,
0.5979530215263367,
0.36183276772499084,
-0.04793570935726166,
-0.42528924345970154,
-0.48172974586486816,
0.12517790496349335,
0.432585209608078,
-0.06125890091061592,
-0.3268902897834778,
0.3272639214992523,
0.2323904037475586,
0.3515584468841553,
-0.6706463694572449,
0.5187257528305054,
-0.14577767252922058,
-0.4507773220539093,
0.39222830533981323,
0.36055445671081543,
0.18572010099887848,
0.36860066652297974,
-0.37590259313583374,
-0.22575612366199493,
-0.7673190832138062,
-0.0962444394826889,
0.9083456993103027,
0.24148355424404144,
-0.16862159967422485,
0.5381389856338501,
-0.5691927075386047,
0.7165579199790955,
-0.3329203128814697,
-0.25501829385757446,
0.05644013732671738,
0.06293609738349915,
-0.15774650871753693,
0.004308274015784264,
0.5584756731987,
0.5596809983253479,
0.3176442086696625,
-0.2161809206008911,
-0.09152166545391083,
0.08787321299314499,
0.11732877045869827,
-1.173447847366333,
-0.4341808259487152,
0.20282137393951416,
-0.49569493532180786,
-0.33105769753456116,
-0.14968927204608917,
-0.8336573839187622,
-0.2936359643936157,
-0.3372947573661804,
0.21054506301879883,
-0.4871252477169037,
-0.6779352426528931,
0.3121177852153778,
-0.05305631086230278,
-0.08998222649097443,
0.007684359326958656,
-1.4557801485061646,
0.822990894317627,
0.9330368638038635,
0.7971945405006409,
-0.15973567962646484,
-0.3994978964328766,
-0.5154335498809814,
0.4938746690750122,
0.014465587213635445,
0.26645976305007935,
-0.7380937337875366,
-0.31561172008514404,
-0.20842503011226654,
-0.19462022185325623,
-0.17695222795009613,
-0.3224536180496216,
-0.03938622772693634,
-0.4805428385734558,
0.03298380598425865,
0.01654929108917713,
-0.42883992195129395,
-0.2555209696292877,
0.3698354661464691,
-0.46471893787384033,
0.42344868183135986,
0.24570874869823456,
-0.8940225839614868,
0.05162438750267029,
-0.5024830102920532,
-0.35744065046310425,
-0.26117485761642456,
-0.24407634139060974,
-0.5247170329093933,
0.17129941284656525,
0.18737532198429108,
0.7085282802581787,
-0.17851239442825317,
-0.02822290174663067,
-0.43098917603492737,
-0.3332746922969818,
0.17565646767616272,
-0.5530932545661926,
0.8318271636962891,
0.41978538036346436,
-0.3739352524280548,
-0.1643945574760437,
-0.9858987331390381,
0.015313880518078804,
0.05721089988946915,
-0.35791823267936707,
-0.7824193835258484,
-0.4101243317127228,
-0.08940846472978592,
0.07228071987628937,
0.36194705963134766,
-0.7066953182220459,
0.10014080256223679,
-0.4348205626010895,
0.5129055976867676,
0.9519426226615906,
-0.12393402308225632,
0.6376132369041443,
-0.008652332238852978,
0.5720186829566956,
0.09399117529392242,
0.41755741834640503,
0.15430547297000885,
-0.39951038360595703,
-0.02118355594575405,
-0.4378950893878937,
0.37732619047164917,
0.4708765745162964,
-0.48879632353782654,
0.331216961145401,
-0.2510317265987396,
-0.3096773028373718,
-0.09805632382631302,
0.0036749851424247026,
0.47826796770095825,
0.6651973724365234,
0.22877579927444458,
-0.28830134868621826,
-0.2800491154193878,
-1.1082124710083008,
-0.41768527030944824,
0.024507256224751472,
-0.10249212384223938,
0.6759575605392456,
0.06382283568382263,
-0.4489739239215851,
0.6290876269340515,
-0.560786247253418,
-0.24508827924728394,
-0.1826658397912979,
-0.14772216975688934,
-0.0018697029445320368,
0.9723992943763733,
0.49054020643234253,
-0.7542206645011902,
-0.25298070907592773,
-0.31980839371681213,
-0.1738157421350479,
-0.10008174180984497,
-0.03786230459809303,
-0.07126595824956894,
0.34121444821357727,
0.36121392250061035,
-0.3179464638233185,
0.213728129863739,
1.0566296577453613,
-0.3540938198566437,
0.342819482088089,
-0.5303481817245483,
-0.06979028880596161,
-1.173636794090271,
0.03936143219470978,
-0.3601124584674835,
-0.4137625992298126,
-0.47887927293777466,
-0.16003869473934174,
0.36608046293258667,
-0.33904269337654114,
-0.5809752941131592,
0.602924644947052,
-0.5205074548721313,
0.13016225397586823,
-0.24519777297973633,
-0.37086647748947144,
-0.19025906920433044,
0.4029863476753235,
-0.052074313163757324,
0.763306736946106,
0.8014690279960632,
-0.8623515367507935,
0.07458960264921188,
-0.02252579666674137,
0.2135397344827652,
0.5795961618423462,
-0.2098785936832428,
0.4286825656890869,
0.20493723452091217,
-0.1776820719242096,
-0.8531082272529602,
-0.14904926717281342,
0.23521675169467926,
-0.20866215229034424,
0.72141432762146,
-0.3096502423286438,
-0.6350419521331787,
-0.1759350448846817,
-0.6772488355636597,
0.5119030475616455,
0.47638633847236633,
-0.7574203014373779,
0.557681143283844,
0.8864373564720154,
0.10086052119731903,
-0.9129840135574341,
-0.6828095316886902,
0.18686771392822266,
-0.3758420944213867,
-0.4997727572917938,
0.28594258427619934,
0.16244658827781677,
-0.08880849182605743,
-0.17923499643802643,
-0.39788490533828735,
-0.36022958159446716,
0.43359455466270447,
0.31323492527008057,
-0.30057457089424133,
0.004041685257107019,
-0.058460578322410583,
0.5320085883140564,
-0.6335567235946655,
-0.12143560498952866,
-0.5380721092224121,
0.9655059576034546,
0.024239258840680122,
-0.14828413724899292,
-0.5446938872337341,
0.42443153262138367,
0.1348341405391693,
-0.20668597519397736,
0.770738959312439,
0.3391987681388855,
-0.4299979507923126,
-0.3302032947540283,
-0.6537821888923645,
-0.4892526865005493,
-0.5861206650733948,
0.46451735496520996,
-0.5578305125236511,
-1.0167534351348877,
0.38143035769462585,
-0.5652813911437988,
0.024752993136644363,
0.002853183774277568,
0.6263431310653687,
0.26406174898147583,
1.0629706382751465,
0.8268683552742004,
-0.32401221990585327,
0.6434095501899719,
-0.1478874534368515,
0.08045319467782974,
-0.8964077234268188,
0.1318298876285553,
-0.21392613649368286,
-0.539086639881134,
-0.7108040452003479,
-0.1394852250814438,
0.09789418429136276,
-0.19325481355190277,
-0.33888545632362366,
0.5335792899131775,
-0.6078495979309082,
0.7149406671524048,
0.6845130920410156,
0.25966688990592957,
0.17187710106372833,
0.00726998969912529,
-0.18850187957286835,
-0.11824203282594681,
-0.33057311177253723,
-0.49609458446502686,
1.3564422130584717,
0.5497612357139587,
1.1417824029922485,
0.16365022957324982,
0.9398025274276733,
-0.16456285119056702,
-0.3637975752353668,
-0.1993524134159088,
0.7536985278129578,
-0.35039475560188293,
-0.638713538646698,
-0.3305918872356415,
-0.7995333075523376,
-0.9333393573760986,
0.04949481785297394,
0.14709624648094177,
-1.1311454772949219,
0.18003349006175995,
0.2704336941242218,
-0.21932798624038696,
0.5276467204093933,
-0.6910708546638489,
0.8548471331596375,
-0.16989801824092865,
-0.6330030560493469,
-0.6014275550842285,
-0.8750526309013367,
0.2822891175746918,
0.04779810085892677,
-0.23947592079639435,
-0.33413463830947876,
-0.25738656520843506,
0.729646623134613,
-0.37322333455085754,
0.887885332107544,
-0.6598470211029053,
0.11286582052707672,
-0.24138809740543365,
0.47526538372039795,
0.38246360421180725,
0.4380866289138794,
-0.08664659410715103,
0.37789326906204224,
-0.026545116677880287,
-0.17375457286834717,
-0.20654159784317017,
0.971017599105835,
-0.6767181158065796,
-0.5120017528533936,
-0.11608229577541351,
-0.816664457321167,
-0.24223171174526215,
0.47800570726394653,
0.076044961810112,
0.515393853187561,
-0.15515539050102234,
0.07643284648656845,
0.7978746294975281,
-0.5262816548347473,
0.3604065775871277,
0.6857207417488098,
0.09801901876926422,
-0.23301446437835693,
0.9802963137626648,
0.1514667570590973,
0.2936463952064514,
0.5980751514434814,
0.4149821400642395,
-0.629101037979126,
-0.7058745622634888,
-0.34731265902519226,
0.18609648942947388,
-0.5118139982223511,
-0.2144177109003067,
-0.9654752612113953,
-0.05867266654968262,
-0.38776135444641113,
0.03507140651345253,
-0.9162458181381226,
-1.0858855247497559,
-0.21541915833950043,
-0.20838157832622528,
0.40662747621536255,
0.05132614076137543,
-0.5414223074913025,
0.5635265707969666,
-0.4192237854003906,
0.3691285252571106,
0.380951851606369,
0.8224307894706726,
-0.24494600296020508,
-0.3340896666049957,
0.09676262736320496,
-0.013376260176301003,
-0.4210669696331024,
-0.48778149485588074,
0.3201442062854767,
0.23963820934295654,
0.4270997643470764,
0.5411075353622437,
0.21928666532039642,
0.43767982721328735,
-0.6803992390632629,
0.4843555688858032,
0.11611247807741165,
-0.8445905447006226,
0.31711527705192566,
-0.2833396792411804,
0.011609707027673721,
0.8719743490219116,
0.26529595255851746,
-0.16643334925174713,
-0.377095103263855,
-0.730894923210144,
-0.823893666267395,
0.45102065801620483,
-0.029545946046710014,
0.6368730068206787,
0.21598388254642487,
0.5579720139503479,
0.43495428562164307,
0.20679332315921783,
-0.46456244587898254,
-0.293916791677475,
-0.1311720460653305,
-0.07768453657627106,
0.09253339469432831,
-0.46870672702789307,
-0.1709546595811844,
-0.3360614478588104,
0.47139862179756165,
-0.038203734904527664,
0.11285775154829025,
-0.1557048112154007,
0.06820175051689148,
0.17968159914016724,
0.15651266276836395,
0.6415096521377563,
0.7291516065597534,
-0.3612724244594574,
0.6561009883880615,
0.11035147309303284,
-0.7886606454849243,
0.33862796425819397,
0.1718481034040451,
-0.11921916157007217,
-0.21302717924118042,
-0.4674716889858246,
0.28823959827423096,
0.05063856765627861,
-0.40269404649734497,
0.5200740694999695,
-0.3762551546096802,
-0.3010150194168091,
-0.12287832051515579,
0.37693968415260315,
0.19539648294448853,
0.32766106724739075,
-0.16654253005981445,
0.021229276433587074,
0.37145888805389404,
-0.0976782888174057,
0.46834075450897217,
0.4407031238079071,
-0.341129332780838,
-0.42178139090538025,
1.0152477025985718,
0.022121617570519447,
-0.2138933688402176,
0.4966776371002197,
-0.003738078521564603,
-0.4147816002368927,
0.13730180263519287,
0.7166404724121094,
1.0082429647445679,
-0.6447705626487732,
-0.04616314917802811,
0.09742866456508636,
0.14234745502471924,
-0.20570677518844604,
0.5265775322914124,
-0.1915656328201294,
-0.48271310329437256,
0.09231746941804886,
-0.36428946256637573,
-0.6548495292663574,
0.2947041094303131,
-0.3635384440422058,
0.20926903188228607,
-0.858633279800415,
-0.11347653716802597,
-0.3389929533004761,
-0.090507872402668,
-0.4057437777519226,
0.2486414760351181,
0.2642916738986969,
0.818320631980896,
-0.5409142971038818,
1.2317062616348267,
0.4586404860019684,
0.1029181033372879,
-0.5809382796287537,
-0.16834469139575958,
0.13488319516181946,
-0.9333316683769226,
0.24300836026668549,
0.5121167898178101,
-0.2760985791683197,
0.24668708443641663,
-0.35481926798820496,
-0.5250006318092346,
0.913583517074585,
0.762001097202301,
-0.6534091234207153,
0.4260256290435791,
0.36657580733299255,
0.33621731400489807,
-0.12456907331943512,
-0.2866259217262268,
0.4356535077095032,
0.11804047226905823,
-0.18337690830230713,
-0.6971659660339355,
0.35336124897003174,
0.04423264414072037,
0.03817714378237724,
0.07847984880208969,
-0.6217862963676453,
1.042647361755371,
-0.04987752065062523,
-0.2991681396961212,
-0.24289098381996155,
0.30917873978614807,
0.2441312074661255,
0.12791161239147186,
0.5697882175445557,
0.522492527961731,
0.8266320824623108,
0.2071683555841446,
0.9660089015960693,
-0.49398213624954224,
0.0420004278421402,
1.027873158454895,
-0.10459515452384949,
0.6254839897155762,
0.579454779624939,
0.15163011848926544,
-0.12177568674087524,
0.6183808445930481,
0.22090408205986023,
1.0056371688842773,
0.5742852091789246,
-0.2336038202047348,
-0.0376126691699028,
-0.014854800887405872,
-0.5571421980857849,
0.2760484516620636,
0.08312204480171204,
-0.37048763036727905,
-0.3563779890537262,
-0.09452429413795471,
0.29916873574256897,
0.04083876311779022,
-0.2453320473432541,
0.7735872864723206,
0.31912124156951904,
-0.024250607937574387,
0.5559713840484619,
0.15655487775802612,
0.6665807962417603,
-0.4591846764087677,
0.2387104630470276,
-0.14613275229930878,
0.8049845695495605,
-0.004475073888897896,
-0.5218903422355652,
0.489511102437973,
-0.18626300990581512,
0.1077393889427185,
-0.3181602358818054,
0.5896867513656616,
-0.250777006149292,
-0.05393027886748314,
0.4254216253757477,
0.38017377257347107,
0.26173996925354004,
-0.4287909269332886,
-0.8075240850448608,
-0.10859629511833191,
-0.2279513031244278,
-0.4835447072982788,
0.7453750371932983,
0.4701193571090698,
0.09411412477493286,
0.6465585231781006,
0.5619106888771057,
0.23160095512866974,
-0.006205318961292505,
0.35246551036834717,
1.1559467315673828,
-0.5856097340583801,
-0.9108496308326721,
-1.475894570350647,
0.2144007533788681,
-0.14646436274051666,
-0.2756965160369873,
0.7477055191993713,
0.8436208963394165,
0.685312807559967,
-0.03424076735973358,
0.6858764886856079,
0.29511189460754395,
0.6992678046226501,
-0.5180593729019165,
0.9524367451667786,
-0.36376526951789856,
0.39906424283981323,
-0.28705573081970215,
-0.9479423761367798,
-0.5223779678344727,
0.6057929992675781,
-0.2878151535987854,
-0.27549993991851807,
0.23979221284389496,
0.8295657634735107,
-0.5655834674835205,
-0.06744284927845001,
0.3775953948497772,
-0.04096748307347298,
0.5807555317878723,
0.7103769779205322,
0.8036832213401794,
-0.2991986870765686,
0.21510683000087738,
-0.7060990929603577,
-0.5289540886878967,
-0.04488416761159897,
-0.960233747959137,
-1.273887276649475,
-0.47947990894317627,
-0.27306872606277466,
-0.13177043199539185,
0.03361010551452637,
0.7173144817352295,
0.8685183525085449,
-0.7519018650054932,
-0.21542495489120483,
-0.25808411836624146,
0.013722866773605347,
-0.17298874258995056,
-0.09899704903364182,
0.5021503567695618,
0.03931800276041031,
-0.5447418093681335,
0.3464798033237457,
0.5591170787811279,
0.38710540533065796,
-0.2438964694738388,
-0.012947342358529568,
0.094397634267807,
-0.012117649428546429,
0.15215156972408295,
0.354765385389328,
-0.1222505196928978,
-0.19018308818340302,
-0.19672834873199463,
-0.13412782549858093,
-0.02525300532579422,
0.6804705858230591,
-0.4519665837287903,
0.5334979891777039,
0.4063475728034973,
0.820014476776123,
0.6224717497825623,
0.15854781866073608,
0.9269059896469116,
-0.8481819033622742,
0.6811714768409729,
0.36335131525993347,
0.1554412990808487,
0.2990877628326416,
-0.550855278968811,
0.5989369750022888,
0.024136822670698166,
-0.47024375200271606,
-1.042587161064148,
0.3237099051475525,
-0.9186747670173645,
-0.34702059626579285,
0.9129189252853394,
-0.2090032696723938,
-0.24916064739227295,
-0.3864343762397766,
-0.10457151383161545,
0.12124432623386383,
-0.450052410364151,
0.9639476537704468,
0.1052044928073883,
-0.013728304766118526,
-0.19388335943222046,
-0.5760210156440735,
0.6686632037162781,
0.28024277091026306,
-0.39805683493614197,
0.5709133744239807,
-0.006192097440361977,
0.35113319754600525,
-0.1982673704624176,
0.7773830890655518,
-0.2815328538417816,
-0.01371059101074934,
0.015292630530893803,
-0.15306635200977325,
-0.5162964463233948,
-0.40837228298187256,
-0.3478845953941345,
0.014211178757250309,
-0.1460014283657074,
-0.6353865265846252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11085v1 | Multiple Sources are Better Than One: Incorporating External Knowledge in Low-Resource Glossing | 2024-06-16T22:01:15 | 2024-06-16T22:01:15 | Changbing Yang, Garrett Nicolai, Miikka Silfverberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we address the data scarcity problem in automatic data-driven
glossing for low-resource languages by coordinating multiple sources of
linguistic expertise. We supplement models with translations at both the token
and sentence level as well as leverage the extensive linguistic capability of
modern LLMs. Our enhancements lead to an average absolute improvement of
5%-points in word-level accuracy over the previous state of the art on a
typologically diverse dataset spanning six low-resource languages. The
improvements are particularly noticeable for the lowest-resourced language
Gitksan, where we achieve a 10%-point improvement. Furthermore, in a simulated
ultra-low resource setting for the same six languages, training on fewer than
100 glossed sentences, we establish an average 10%-point improvement in
word-level accuracy over the previous state-of-the-art system. | [
-0.3775055706501007,
-0.41703471541404724,
0.6922374367713928,
0.1854875087738037,
-0.07525394856929779,
0.26208794116973877,
-0.6509305834770203,
-0.5729329586029053,
0.2780020236968994,
0.38535767793655396,
-0.2592114210128784,
-0.3936474621295929,
-0.7568492889404297,
0.19587023556232452,
-0.1698153167963028,
0.8078330755233765,
-0.15271447598934174,
0.2208271324634552,
-0.06961676478385925,
-0.4459511637687683,
-0.14832094311714172,
-0.3836475610733032,
-0.6505408883094788,
-0.07445624470710754,
0.5822510123252869,
0.8454515337944031,
1.0097029209136963,
0.541760265827179,
0.6774397492408752,
0.310373455286026,
-0.04189979285001755,
0.6869379281997681,
-0.5252320170402527,
0.13102495670318604,
-0.3388853371143341,
-0.45761317014694214,
-0.43452757596969604,
-0.05459780618548393,
0.4632161855697632,
0.6413431763648987,
-0.27142810821533203,
0.001675163279287517,
0.11142085492610931,
1.0028870105743408,
-0.8292924165725708,
0.19689923524856567,
-0.7779877781867981,
-0.29680436849594116,
-0.3072845935821533,
0.10840646177530289,
-0.08886994421482086,
-0.3387201130390167,
0.16119810938835144,
-1.013670802116394,
0.1108902096748352,
-0.11985372751951218,
0.8801870346069336,
0.5653187036514282,
-0.20999126136302948,
-0.5536112189292908,
-0.7121176719665527,
0.7916131615638733,
-0.7288618683815002,
0.34252607822418213,
0.6265935301780701,
0.2200390100479126,
0.30437788367271423,
-0.4248271882534027,
-0.45884737372398376,
-0.18084992468357086,
-0.17935682833194733,
0.12236288189888,
0.07208335399627686,
0.0967649593949318,
0.13460780680179596,
0.35426589846611023,
0.026855982840061188,
0.09877045452594757,
-0.4229879379272461,
-0.064918652176857,
0.6035885810852051,
-0.005927523598074913,
0.050609041005373,
-0.22815968096256256,
-0.06140628084540367,
-0.10082464665174484,
-0.5549758672714233,
-0.26098230481147766,
0.09757713973522186,
0.7968659996986389,
-0.18027915060520172,
0.6144500970840454,
-0.49720287322998047,
0.5560194849967957,
-0.00008203188917832449,
-0.42180630564689636,
0.3117044270038605,
-0.9500065445899963,
-0.14945712685585022,
-0.3735533058643341,
0.7427122592926025,
0.23342709243297577,
0.2730695307254791,
-0.32530662417411804,
-0.19185136258602142,
-0.35481324791908264,
0.08054439723491669,
-0.26697617769241333,
-0.2777615189552307,
-0.011652453802525997,
-0.06797929108142853,
-0.019867196679115295,
0.0042514558881521225,
-0.7030657529830933,
-0.581939160823822,
-0.4814576804637909,
0.09414543956518173,
-0.5619805455207825,
-0.028867268934845924,
-0.22482450306415558,
-0.0028802906163036823,
-0.2029966562986374,
0.33450591564178467,
-0.944850504398346,
0.2556741237640381,
0.2704308331012726,
1.2724672555923462,
-0.18450185656547546,
-0.22189263999462128,
-0.6637201309204102,
0.4355640113353729,
-0.5088903903961182,
0.8850498795509338,
-0.40079399943351746,
-0.22723357379436493,
0.07661423087120056,
-0.2528485357761383,
0.09384721517562866,
-0.8399121165275574,
0.39992210268974304,
-0.4249536395072937,
0.07547501474618912,
-0.47728100419044495,
-0.4260997772216797,
0.009032100439071655,
-0.14158563315868378,
-0.7462934255599976,
1.219995379447937,
0.40020790696144104,
-0.3577824831008911,
0.6877360939979553,
-0.7263346314430237,
-0.33418577909469604,
0.24058103561401367,
-0.08745477348566055,
-0.07536350935697556,
0.3748595714569092,
0.4433618485927582,
0.13083194196224213,
-0.326560914516449,
0.40445467829704285,
-0.23399077355861664,
-0.03820252791047096,
0.13240370154380798,
-0.1794768124818802,
0.45043259859085083,
0.3156113922595978,
-0.045545611530542374,
0.17296364903450012,
-0.8963513374328613,
0.14887548983097076,
-0.15279313921928406,
-0.709042489528656,
-0.5252329707145691,
-0.2419183999300003,
0.05870499834418297,
0.4391922652721405,
0.36161118745803833,
-0.22663146257400513,
0.28146296739578247,
-0.687860906124115,
0.1220473051071167,
0.7812319993972778,
-0.17119383811950684,
0.870830774307251,
-0.4860358238220215,
0.4362128674983978,
0.015431580133736134,
0.11693604290485382,
0.16231133043766022,
-0.45344364643096924,
-1.133917212486267,
-0.27636221051216125,
0.21416711807250977,
0.6490368843078613,
-1.3765888214111328,
0.23633721470832825,
-0.4912307858467102,
-0.3031856119632721,
-0.8279328346252441,
0.7500668168067932,
0.3589048385620117,
0.2960972189903259,
0.6601762175559998,
-0.2179574966430664,
-0.3038974404335022,
-1.0594935417175293,
-0.06464949995279312,
-0.06667390465736389,
-0.0030960985459387302,
0.3365800976753235,
0.19950346648693085,
0.0019956508185714483,
0.9285737872123718,
-0.385188490152359,
-0.5220451354980469,
-0.22459430992603302,
-0.003807101398706436,
0.22975541651248932,
0.31966087222099304,
0.4228265583515167,
-0.42163050174713135,
-0.9845056533813477,
0.005946076940745115,
-0.6485716104507446,
-0.2592298686504364,
0.008799292147159576,
-0.4033873975276947,
0.5707752704620361,
0.26661455631256104,
-0.4048713147640228,
0.042216453701257706,
0.5493324995040894,
0.029907748103141785,
0.25840267539024353,
-0.5270571708679199,
-0.03986804559826851,
-0.9848789572715759,
0.002395917195826769,
0.22073788940906525,
0.051412492990493774,
-0.8728044033050537,
0.08064993470907211,
0.08641480654478073,
0.19107745587825775,
-0.44104939699172974,
0.6270926594734192,
-0.6693248748779297,
0.0003005109610967338,
-0.40546563267707825,
0.46098431944847107,
-0.19322502613067627,
0.46419790387153625,
-0.07422863692045212,
1.0717556476593018,
0.7424245476722717,
-0.6976602673530579,
0.6091466546058655,
0.3151538670063019,
-0.4766201674938202,
0.6441035270690918,
-0.14998401701450348,
0.08337090164422989,
-0.1069720908999443,
-0.22387227416038513,
-0.7103023529052734,
-0.46126165986061096,
0.30297157168388367,
0.013848901726305485,
0.2948639988899231,
-0.2059301733970642,
-0.7699649333953857,
-0.19553934037685394,
-0.3408769965171814,
-0.018589811399579048,
0.32671815156936646,
-0.6388102769851685,
0.3866014778614044,
0.5958025455474854,
-0.4190647602081299,
-0.554675817489624,
-0.8750259876251221,
0.25938332080841064,
-0.10874591767787933,
-0.7391679286956787,
0.21192008256912231,
-0.14086750149726868,
-0.5356663465499878,
-0.09994437545537949,
-0.15591315925121307,
-0.2511749565601349,
-0.006184996571391821,
-0.10694050788879395,
0.08293171226978302,
-0.05987562611699104,
0.4926460087299347,
-0.1996062844991684,
-0.16495026648044586,
-0.37848854064941406,
-0.5312759280204773,
0.13657337427139282,
0.013518774881958961,
-0.19828706979751587,
-0.3052438497543335,
0.4461953938007355,
0.3255579173564911,
0.2205224186182022,
0.9010612368583679,
0.4335600733757019,
-0.22866828739643097,
-0.3179357051849365,
-0.5891255736351013,
0.09819009155035019,
-0.5349898338317871,
0.09821408241987228,
-0.5347461700439453,
-0.6030784249305725,
0.5166329741477966,
0.09979945421218872,
-0.11675109714269638,
0.5356113910675049,
0.3330487012863159,
-0.11183231323957443,
0.7391158938407898,
1.0538136959075928,
-0.32144442200660706,
0.6053483486175537,
-0.25302642583847046,
-0.15391801297664642,
-0.5814042091369629,
-0.004773312248289585,
-0.18493938446044922,
-0.1006111353635788,
-0.7858930826187134,
-0.668998658657074,
0.44020918011665344,
0.31531068682670593,
-0.08682355284690857,
0.13281294703483582,
-0.43245404958724976,
0.4792982339859009,
0.9334295988082886,
0.24200981855392456,
0.6367536783218384,
0.36800143122673035,
-0.03816480562090874,
0.010630473494529724,
-0.9782856702804565,
-0.4436335265636444,
1.1565287113189697,
0.020699840039014816,
0.9398391246795654,
0.36611753702163696,
0.537597119808197,
0.06919276714324951,
0.4980071187019348,
-0.880750834941864,
0.3655570447444916,
-0.5222584009170532,
-0.5148377418518066,
-0.5791950225830078,
-0.6094234585762024,
-0.48219063878059387,
0.28790172934532166,
-0.24568551778793335,
-0.4489506781101227,
0.23980693519115448,
0.07234074920415878,
-0.42615824937820435,
0.27687501907348633,
-0.8177255988121033,
0.41524747014045715,
-0.3937489688396454,
-0.4299261271953583,
-0.21193519234657288,
-0.4335428774356842,
0.2480735331773758,
-0.4041000306606293,
0.5082448720932007,
-0.2728607952594757,
-0.5602927803993225,
0.7315376400947571,
-0.6395491361618042,
0.6159138083457947,
-0.1336933970451355,
-0.48493173718452454,
0.23696044087409973,
-0.2947988212108612,
0.6886957287788391,
0.007906682789325714,
-0.2735605239868164,
0.15469717979431152,
-0.44509097933769226,
-0.5976549386978149,
-0.5496807098388672,
0.7026695013046265,
-0.7025048136711121,
-0.6198737621307373,
-0.36707040667533875,
-0.6611420512199402,
-0.554171621799469,
0.09487135708332062,
0.1714097261428833,
0.20970867574214935,
0.15747947990894318,
-0.2595692574977875,
0.3242049813270569,
-0.1885906159877777,
0.44941046833992004,
0.7101513743400574,
0.038057878613471985,
-0.6595063805580139,
1.0389214754104614,
0.37294822931289673,
0.5979170799255371,
0.1725480556488037,
0.02195047214627266,
-0.23254060745239258,
-0.8306828141212463,
-0.533751904964447,
0.534915566444397,
-1.0611109733581543,
-0.30218586325645447,
-0.4253690540790558,
-0.0845334380865097,
-0.36892983317375183,
-0.17650258541107178,
-0.4218186140060425,
-0.5195118188858032,
-0.18764382600784302,
-0.016234111040830612,
0.5191805958747864,
0.9101777672767639,
-0.44377097487449646,
0.6156076788902283,
-0.8242982029914856,
0.46974703669548035,
0.13924553990364075,
0.7084277272224426,
-0.314303994178772,
-0.5820019245147705,
-0.7426312565803528,
0.06645721942186356,
-0.009316572919487953,
-0.691837728023529,
0.5196273922920227,
0.4890080392360687,
0.6387307047843933,
0.13060115277767181,
-0.15063363313674927,
0.7788171768188477,
-0.3242351710796356,
0.6186885833740234,
0.15645182132720947,
-0.9048606157302856,
0.5066913962364197,
-0.19716250896453857,
0.6635432839393616,
1.0225929021835327,
0.43225520849227905,
-0.6091251969337463,
-0.9397823810577393,
-0.5372754335403442,
-1.050871729850769,
1.1634495258331299,
0.1894136220216751,
-0.141188845038414,
0.16195008158683777,
0.3120688498020172,
0.14208060503005981,
0.10173530876636505,
-0.5854085087776184,
-0.5447105765342712,
0.050484780222177505,
-0.30260106921195984,
-0.30694282054901123,
-0.2169191986322403,
-0.19106756150722504,
-0.07876624912023544,
1.0735613107681274,
-0.39928171038627625,
-0.040228404104709625,
-0.15294429659843445,
-0.3462899327278137,
-0.2036401629447937,
0.32545754313468933,
0.4380771815776825,
0.9117603302001953,
-0.03144002705812454,
0.2806888818740845,
0.5120552182197571,
-0.45637550950050354,
0.09644198417663574,
0.17146968841552734,
-0.28751087188720703,
0.19621412456035614,
0.3533925712108612,
0.6788355112075806,
0.06944997608661652,
-0.3712972104549408,
0.18636232614517212,
0.24866627156734467,
0.06340884417295456,
-0.07135085761547089,
-0.029298266395926476,
0.05129878222942352,
0.10383137315511703,
0.5925922393798828,
0.3347819447517395,
-0.10017535090446472,
-0.2949725091457367,
0.24050992727279663,
0.3398290276527405,
-0.12496025115251541,
0.02314714714884758,
0.4032285511493683,
0.3758443593978882,
0.18350908160209656,
0.45354345440864563,
-0.44612935185432434,
-0.2198193520307541,
0.33918866515159607,
-0.07798969000577927,
0.44241881370544434,
-0.11992263793945312,
0.2475629299879074,
0.5843368768692017,
0.3560628890991211,
-0.37480753660202026,
0.31072574853897095,
0.02985290437936783,
-0.7275153398513794,
-0.678523063659668,
-0.4876266419887543,
-0.5970087051391602,
0.26078638434410095,
-0.3782041072845459,
0.3367108404636383,
-0.27858787775039673,
-0.22372528910636902,
0.07963285595178604,
0.14080968499183655,
-0.6085962653160095,
-0.05670640245079994,
0.247577965259552,
0.7208036780357361,
-0.5653946399688721,
0.9228672981262207,
0.5726742744445801,
-0.7603940367698669,
-0.46389883756637573,
0.18431271612644196,
0.02963220700621605,
-0.849845826625824,
0.8692543506622314,
-0.22387926280498505,
-0.16123414039611816,
-0.08152331411838531,
-0.4916287064552307,
-1.614540457725525,
0.8695536255836487,
0.4415157735347748,
-0.5951904654502869,
-0.06876075267791748,
0.25488513708114624,
0.5828078389167786,
-0.19169574975967407,
0.23000884056091309,
0.6367980241775513,
0.6520662307739258,
-0.1171313151717186,
-1.3593393564224243,
0.06511826813220978,
-0.02476496808230877,
0.12468431144952774,
0.1788032352924347,
-0.503450870513916,
0.5729591846466064,
-0.2401089072227478,
-0.7843052744865417,
-0.02818233333528042,
0.7209472060203552,
-0.04570002481341362,
-0.005881564226001501,
0.4054793417453766,
0.38737910985946655,
1.0075639486312866,
-0.03464415669441223,
0.9572111964225769,
-0.6918964385986328,
0.17535942792892456,
1.3521703481674194,
-0.029043957591056824,
0.6132117509841919,
0.48244065046310425,
-0.2962273955345154,
0.3001757562160492,
0.39141541719436646,
0.09923847764730453,
0.7447117567062378,
0.12570367753505707,
-0.4505935609340668,
-0.14070136845111847,
-0.3054318428039551,
-0.15595409274101257,
0.21551725268363953,
0.47557777166366577,
-0.08242896944284439,
-0.30573543906211853,
0.2889164388179779,
-0.15825578570365906,
0.125690758228302,
-0.3382086455821991,
1.0697842836380005,
0.09806513041257858,
-0.5655856728553772,
0.8302072286605835,
0.08783434331417084,
1.1486189365386963,
-0.5248520970344543,
0.29193100333213806,
-0.5150087475776672,
0.06001589447259903,
-0.28651300072669983,
-0.738842248916626,
0.3495367169380188,
0.0921868085861206,
-0.18206679821014404,
-0.41262927651405334,
0.5699940919876099,
-0.7468366026878357,
-0.4907245635986328,
0.4539456069469452,
1.0911158323287964,
0.15123461186885834,
0.010403028689324856,
-0.6451021432876587,
-0.24139748513698578,
-0.2622714936733246,
0.04480333626270294,
0.1477494090795517,
0.5023807883262634,
0.11510929465293884,
0.8811370730400085,
0.5166400074958801,
0.5013638734817505,
0.17314781248569489,
0.43500593304634094,
0.9903504848480225,
-0.6491802334785461,
-0.4182761609554291,
-0.5997018218040466,
0.13368858397006989,
-0.32138535380363464,
-0.21702945232391357,
0.8239248394966125,
0.6095730662345886,
1.0272778272628784,
-0.00701462896540761,
1.1066005229949951,
-0.10636604577302933,
0.49908095598220825,
-0.6566237211227417,
0.4448547065258026,
-0.5187380313873291,
0.43074148893356323,
0.013038047589361668,
-0.8693979382514954,
-0.2969684302806854,
0.40850627422332764,
-0.31919318437576294,
-0.058647964149713516,
0.9182369709014893,
0.7824748754501343,
-0.07069467008113861,
-0.4158047139644623,
0.32037004828453064,
0.11621963232755661,
0.060506291687488556,
0.6087096333503723,
0.8537106513977051,
-0.191887766122818,
0.853424072265625,
-0.6293164491653442,
-0.17885571718215942,
0.029300620779395103,
-0.5106169581413269,
-0.5485469102859497,
-0.6797299981117249,
-0.31677743792533875,
-0.16973857581615448,
0.07566072791814804,
0.925967812538147,
0.7717295289039612,
-1.0413825511932373,
-0.30889707803726196,
-0.10379067808389664,
0.23417526483535767,
-0.17878146469593048,
-0.22437046468257904,
0.17969539761543274,
-0.9080007672309875,
-0.7301979064941406,
0.7059928178787231,
0.19918987154960632,
0.05418397858738899,
-0.2942008972167969,
-0.10696804523468018,
-0.30514687299728394,
0.03804297745227814,
0.596731424331665,
0.05344221740961075,
-0.7653473019599915,
-0.3213047981262207,
-0.17598247528076172,
-0.5963398218154907,
0.3657433092594147,
0.7475494146347046,
-0.5886736512184143,
0.3501105308532715,
0.4164195954799652,
0.3288097381591797,
0.43175220489501953,
0.08296925574541092,
0.4945595860481262,
-0.993182361125946,
0.09733325242996216,
-0.06598009914159775,
0.28826355934143066,
0.6658472418785095,
-0.24989283084869385,
0.8795142769813538,
0.37398040294647217,
-0.2549588978290558,
-0.40536612272262573,
0.17426276206970215,
-0.8577608466148376,
-0.36588066816329956,
1.355686902999878,
-0.025685716420412064,
0.04458526149392128,
-0.38675886392593384,
-0.06316584348678589,
0.3106083869934082,
-0.7143241167068481,
0.8718817830085754,
0.9972933530807495,
-0.19495578110218048,
-0.0586407408118248,
-0.7657331228256226,
0.9401940107345581,
0.2785530388355255,
-1.1631686687469482,
0.24951870739459991,
0.7376301288604736,
0.09353956580162048,
0.47329771518707275,
0.9376893639564514,
0.31382909417152405,
-0.11472553014755249,
-0.10356155037879944,
-0.04809553176164627,
0.05069193243980408,
-0.3025030195713043,
-0.485568642616272,
0.053796060383319855,
0.1931471973657608,
0.221886545419693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15476v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15476v1 | Self-Regulated Data-Free Knowledge Amalgamation for Text Classification | 2024-06-16T21:13:30 | 2024-06-16T21:13:30 | Prashanth Vijayaraghavan, Hongzhi Wang, Luyao Shi, Tyler Baldwin, David Beymer, Ehsan Degan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, there has been a growing availability of pre-trained text models on
various model repositories. These models greatly reduce the cost of training
new models from scratch as they can be fine-tuned for specific tasks or trained
on large datasets. However, these datasets may not be publicly accessible due
to the privacy, security, or intellectual property issues. In this paper, we
aim to develop a lightweight student network that can learn from multiple
teacher models without accessing their original training data. Hence, we
investigate Data-Free Knowledge Amalgamation (DFKA), a knowledge-transfer task
that combines insights from multiple pre-trained teacher models and transfers
them effectively to a compact student network. To accomplish this, we propose
STRATANET, a modeling framework comprising: (a) a steerable data generator that
produces text data tailored to each teacher and (b) an amalgamation module that
implements a self-regulative strategy using confidence estimates from the
teachers' different layers to selectively integrate their knowledge and train a
versatile student. We evaluate our method on three benchmark text
classification datasets with varying labels or domains. Empirically, we
demonstrate that the student model learned using our STRATANET outperforms
several baselines significantly under data-driven and data-free constraints. | [
0.06450091302394867,
-0.018481075763702393,
0.45121514797210693,
-0.032853156328201294,
-0.25686022639274597,
0.007819043472409248,
0.02873220667243004,
-0.4234844446182251,
0.13205289840698242,
0.7645103335380554,
-0.28447774052619934,
-0.5546979904174805,
-0.5983179807662964,
0.05283355712890625,
-0.8638299703598022,
1.048723816871643,
-0.1308726966381073,
-0.24054402112960815,
-0.46935561299324036,
0.005863097961992025,
-0.3477429151535034,
-0.5779708623886108,
-0.23414525389671326,
-0.31062522530555725,
0.5345100164413452,
0.56260746717453,
0.31275618076324463,
0.7387762069702148,
0.43425115942955017,
0.3663420081138611,
0.19185900688171387,
0.0979294702410698,
-0.30839067697525024,
-0.013041384518146515,
-0.4081769287586212,
-0.4753963351249695,
-0.20788472890853882,
0.20670996606349945,
0.7538622617721558,
0.5225597023963928,
-0.1657649427652359,
0.18841971457004547,
0.31799134612083435,
0.6379523277282715,
-0.8422252535820007,
0.18966057896614075,
-0.545698344707489,
0.09137971699237823,
-0.19626681506633759,
0.15030896663665771,
-0.4775034487247467,
-0.3090069890022278,
0.16595818102359772,
-0.7743401527404785,
0.24365700781345367,
-0.36726027727127075,
0.554979681968689,
0.48068076372146606,
-0.7591758370399475,
-0.35730957984924316,
-0.7597683668136597,
0.5606376528739929,
-0.2894987165927887,
0.31073781847953796,
0.33043670654296875,
0.35514748096466064,
0.13586193323135376,
-1.1188470125198364,
-0.6562815308570862,
0.36236825585365295,
-0.3608909547328949,
0.4643782377243042,
-0.12528599798679352,
0.028446028009057045,
-0.3208553194999695,
0.24168387055397034,
-0.26542961597442627,
0.29212579131126404,
-0.6100702285766602,
0.044053610414266586,
0.6504431366920471,
0.16585512459278107,
0.23928961157798767,
-0.7353448867797852,
-0.9166513085365295,
-0.15197832882404327,
-0.12280343472957611,
0.06831566989421844,
0.4359993040561676,
0.5844898223876953,
-0.01760329119861126,
0.4498271942138672,
-0.2404850572347641,
0.7140300869941711,
-0.16046664118766785,
-0.050339747220277786,
0.06652117520570755,
-0.261709988117218,
-0.24419550597667694,
0.29039233922958374,
1.0397632122039795,
-0.04701891914010048,
-0.022048411890864372,
-0.3489994704723358,
-0.14870350062847137,
0.04811703413724899,
0.33014822006225586,
-0.8061639666557312,
-0.5718896985054016,
0.21751996874809265,
-0.3778235912322998,
-0.5340606570243835,
-0.018387306481599808,
-0.5646153688430786,
-0.25637245178222656,
-0.3763204514980316,
0.7052056193351746,
-0.3047269880771637,
-0.27676719427108765,
0.2217486947774887,
-0.20353852212429047,
-0.48296022415161133,
0.26643672585487366,
-0.8568568229675293,
0.5276150107383728,
0.6039566397666931,
0.8069925904273987,
-0.21711008250713348,
-0.49510473012924194,
0.10153023898601532,
0.37587231397628784,
-0.185995414853096,
0.45270928740501404,
-0.3287528157234192,
-0.2957996129989624,
-0.1583983600139618,
-0.1906808465719223,
-0.38868293166160583,
-0.20663005113601685,
0.32775914669036865,
-0.5624272227287292,
0.390438437461853,
0.09673812240362167,
-0.9232667088508606,
-0.3009830713272095,
0.019085314124822617,
-0.8116207718849182,
1.114748239517212,
0.1949702352285385,
-1.0775891542434692,
0.4436025619506836,
-0.2708933353424072,
-0.16678282618522644,
0.3490873873233795,
-0.3172062039375305,
-0.18824419379234314,
-0.37742385268211365,
0.07976679503917694,
0.8270029425621033,
0.009359455667436123,
0.6219927668571472,
-0.17402519285678864,
-0.30198782682418823,
0.02009378746151924,
-0.19634726643562317,
1.057183861732483,
0.22853583097457886,
-0.2215709686279297,
-0.059811148792505264,
-0.9303274154663086,
0.04432440549135208,
-0.19475528597831726,
-0.3696131408214569,
-0.9409326314926147,
-0.1838541477918625,
-0.11259418725967407,
0.2309872806072235,
0.18322502076625824,
-0.47799649834632874,
0.467720627784729,
-0.08951523900032043,
0.3855929672718048,
0.7896966934204102,
0.07774937897920609,
0.7092105746269226,
-0.4148639738559723,
0.18135102093219757,
0.29944002628326416,
0.12152519077062607,
0.08819681406021118,
-0.2613842189311981,
-0.6245232820510864,
-0.5253722071647644,
0.6132138967514038,
0.4811229109764099,
-1.068755030632019,
0.372812956571579,
-0.689252495765686,
-0.858293890953064,
-0.5071101188659668,
0.470496267080307,
0.08276934176683426,
0.6091862916946411,
0.43685147166252136,
-0.24713291227817535,
-0.3319547772407532,
-0.604213297367096,
-0.11247260868549347,
-0.23919840157032013,
0.05879624933004379,
0.3284953236579895,
0.5086933970451355,
-0.15528951585292816,
1.1012014150619507,
-0.4514762759208679,
-0.7236422896385193,
-0.08272696286439896,
0.07539405673742294,
-0.14290297031402588,
0.7736003994941711,
0.5115529298782349,
-0.7397160530090332,
-0.46041008830070496,
-0.19782434403896332,
-0.8108864426612854,
0.2037339061498642,
-0.44204723834991455,
-0.30182990431785583,
-0.2952013909816742,
0.24909698963165283,
-0.5395247340202332,
0.4002624452114105,
0.5782061815261841,
-0.20329639315605164,
0.32391107082366943,
-0.027173664420843124,
-0.21018142998218536,
-1.4779573678970337,
-0.005803000647574663,
-0.27945324778556824,
-0.16333474218845367,
-0.6264961361885071,
-0.005012802314013243,
0.3504296839237213,
-0.19948069751262665,
-0.3170628547668457,
0.6854686141014099,
-0.21071916818618774,
0.16619911789894104,
-0.10691633075475693,
0.30820879340171814,
-0.0030380552634596825,
0.337441623210907,
0.12083721160888672,
0.46472832560539246,
0.6790328025817871,
-0.842121422290802,
0.24178627133369446,
0.5936319828033447,
-0.42097461223602295,
0.1952214539051056,
-0.24213674664497375,
0.10747960209846497,
-0.1223696768283844,
0.35976797342300415,
-0.9997882843017578,
-0.23691944777965546,
0.347173810005188,
-0.13212323188781738,
0.07625604420900345,
-0.35163751244544983,
-0.24640677869319916,
-0.3328304588794708,
0.1359001249074936,
0.3896288275718689,
0.22155717015266418,
-0.9377250671386719,
0.9613237380981445,
0.022988388314843178,
0.02597067505121231,
-0.8220780491828918,
-0.793286919593811,
-0.09054597467184067,
-0.05231745168566704,
-0.3837588429450989,
0.45880424976348877,
0.08502613753080368,
0.18344059586524963,
0.49222204089164734,
-0.09315375983715057,
-0.5951201319694519,
0.16442857682704926,
0.4103533923625946,
0.1262046843767166,
0.09060287475585938,
0.4820186495780945,
0.3875610828399658,
0.12181352823972702,
-0.1721988171339035,
-0.6163792610168457,
0.06414946168661118,
0.418393075466156,
-0.1767691820859909,
-0.5982609391212463,
0.022428547963500023,
0.47956064343452454,
-0.21465803682804108,
0.7700608968734741,
0.47444382309913635,
-0.2821195721626282,
-0.7676960825920105,
-0.28093045949935913,
-0.24989551305770874,
-0.5155885815620422,
-0.06313134729862213,
-0.2179233431816101,
-0.9386147260665894,
0.3948511779308319,
-0.11701313406229019,
0.1178421601653099,
0.2993493974208832,
-0.05747971311211586,
0.059063684195280075,
0.2678782641887665,
0.8092196583747864,
-0.029218673706054688,
0.5422762632369995,
-0.34709736704826355,
-0.1861778199672699,
-0.5173482298851013,
-0.3967263400554657,
-0.5371713638305664,
-0.37091583013534546,
-0.44081440567970276,
-0.18661147356033325,
-0.0035703331232070923,
0.02994563989341259,
-0.10730437189340591,
0.3602178990840912,
-0.60707688331604,
0.5145292282104492,
0.682550311088562,
0.34564289450645447,
0.39894935488700867,
-0.009612291119992733,
-0.10184089094400406,
0.2288641780614853,
-0.9606602787971497,
-0.2653062343597412,
1.221168041229248,
0.08928688615560532,
0.6777688264846802,
0.15152744948863983,
1.238889217376709,
0.24380040168762207,
0.4844214618206024,
-0.7410539984703064,
0.5760313868522644,
-0.6037070751190186,
-0.7949567437171936,
-0.3120734393596649,
-1.1497173309326172,
-0.8611564040184021,
0.2923741638660431,
-0.35532769560813904,
-0.556017279624939,
0.5011855363845825,
-0.0006695284973829985,
-0.38676536083221436,
0.6579078435897827,
-0.7372595071792603,
0.5128543376922607,
-0.22786417603492737,
-0.28949862718582153,
0.1609114408493042,
-0.5105778574943542,
0.5491904020309448,
-0.4829771816730499,
0.17536036670207977,
0.014352427795529366,
0.0913454070687294,
1.0752623081207275,
-0.38267263770103455,
1.152464509010315,
-0.19528622925281525,
0.09041000157594681,
0.5793613791465759,
0.23175698518753052,
0.208152174949646,
-0.13341231644153595,
0.0023525599390268326,
0.2275363653898239,
0.08985526859760284,
-0.34209832549095154,
-0.5602147579193115,
0.395873486995697,
-1.2209012508392334,
-0.32517942786216736,
-0.24792145192623138,
-0.4020358622074127,
-0.11234340816736221,
0.6478786468505859,
0.13559532165527344,
0.44794926047325134,
0.15233281254768372,
0.38354483246803284,
0.30124926567077637,
0.27817031741142273,
0.5067852139472961,
0.5500380992889404,
-0.10712658613920212,
-0.40369805693626404,
0.9399309158325195,
0.5908210277557373,
0.13268297910690308,
0.4301913380622864,
0.37762898206710815,
-0.37758004665374756,
-0.3843066990375519,
-0.381748765707016,
-0.10943522304296494,
-0.8516330122947693,
-0.4389790892601013,
-0.7607681751251221,
-0.3330531716346741,
-0.620367169380188,
-0.0317278616130352,
-0.41814538836479187,
-0.7251909375190735,
-0.5669835209846497,
-0.35002651810646057,
0.20632076263427734,
1.0661356449127197,
0.016824163496494293,
0.8374142646789551,
-0.9986389875411987,
-0.043359994888305664,
0.6188703179359436,
0.630201518535614,
0.247978076338768,
-0.38210901618003845,
-0.14960947632789612,
-0.3316916823387146,
-0.0780847817659378,
-0.8641746640205383,
0.22248932719230652,
0.23235052824020386,
0.425523042678833,
0.4169706106185913,
0.46196362376213074,
0.24143950641155243,
-0.22432388365268707,
0.6175709366798401,
0.32005977630615234,
-1.0152689218521118,
0.17374847829341888,
-0.28412145376205444,
-0.1069461926817894,
0.7493717670440674,
0.7993666529655457,
-0.389647513628006,
-0.20114867389202118,
-0.663266658782959,
-0.7548366189002991,
0.6778969168663025,
0.09370506554841995,
0.28854984045028687,
0.4031848907470703,
0.8265065550804138,
0.20097070932388306,
0.2806988060474396,
-0.7256824970245361,
-0.17606742680072784,
-0.5602987408638,
-0.6611358523368835,
-0.10652405023574829,
-0.12603667378425598,
-0.22041790187358856,
-0.1667185127735138,
0.5235421061515808,
-0.13768307864665985,
-0.19945213198661804,
0.24126875400543213,
-0.04272784665226936,
0.2655143439769745,
0.15958450734615326,
-0.10561929643154144,
0.39235392212867737,
-0.026697957888245583,
0.43933534622192383,
-0.05616084858775139,
-0.8183004856109619,
0.4293963611125946,
0.1886511743068695,
-0.5948047041893005,
-0.11601285636425018,
0.26731547713279724,
0.49254050850868225,
0.38046354055404663,
-0.03783638775348663,
0.6048099994659424,
-0.2720803916454315,
-0.5990047454833984,
-0.004970525857061148,
0.2496308833360672,
-0.08680306375026703,
0.13586865365505219,
0.3467821180820465,
0.26934686303138733,
0.16821366548538208,
0.06446512788534164,
0.5377809405326843,
-0.1968381702899933,
-0.43346354365348816,
-0.17524439096450806,
0.5570573806762695,
0.2909812927246094,
0.26290163397789,
0.7462297081947327,
0.11023136228322983,
-0.45108285546302795,
0.32490432262420654,
0.5258614420890808,
0.6847579479217529,
-0.4424594044685364,
0.681568443775177,
0.27443090081214905,
0.3757026493549347,
-0.20819999277591705,
0.06392060965299606,
-0.12000022828578949,
-0.9777873158454895,
-0.18197260797023773,
-0.4314459562301636,
-0.39089539647102356,
-0.11729844659566879,
-0.7633178234100342,
0.07056781649589539,
-0.7117457389831543,
-0.19405773282051086,
-0.06366457790136337,
0.1120423674583435,
-0.6678401231765747,
0.5254300236701965,
-0.14158442616462708,
0.9632797241210938,
-1.1109009981155396,
0.8557692170143127,
0.6929023265838623,
-0.33848369121551514,
-1.2766969203948975,
-0.3119908571243286,
-0.2539816200733185,
-0.40895920991897583,
0.6090810298919678,
0.08747463673353195,
0.04616628587245941,
0.2091698795557022,
-0.5472643375396729,
-0.7665216326713562,
1.2158292531967163,
0.2532956004142761,
-0.391750305891037,
-0.12062527239322662,
0.15507791936397552,
0.3337894380092621,
-0.21343880891799927,
-0.046335961669683456,
-0.02146070823073387,
0.11715006083250046,
0.2043006271123886,
-0.5352501273155212,
0.02622947096824646,
0.015783291310071945,
-0.3281104266643524,
-0.05716782063245773,
-0.9998128414154053,
1.0821123123168945,
0.24151192605495453,
-0.38117024302482605,
-0.2985919713973999,
0.8553313612937927,
-0.3723142147064209,
0.32168126106262207,
0.5675159096717834,
0.6950253844261169,
1.2461057901382446,
0.10940735042095184,
0.6913788318634033,
-0.40677934885025024,
0.450820654630661,
1.3349640369415283,
-0.12849028408527374,
0.8791657090187073,
0.08447928726673126,
0.0992266833782196,
0.7025375366210938,
0.5231198668479919,
0.10329518467187881,
0.5019868612289429,
-0.08976440876722336,
-0.34757199883461,
-0.499096542596817,
-0.03252030909061432,
-0.21851831674575806,
0.858191728591919,
0.022460680454969406,
-0.26112523674964905,
-0.19443173706531525,
-0.09044988453388214,
-0.14116886258125305,
0.03806860372424126,
-0.44549673795700073,
0.8394977450370789,
0.06587015837430954,
-0.2715487778186798,
0.00539362384006381,
-0.04739329218864441,
0.5294292569160461,
-0.6505815982818604,
0.28077736496925354,
-0.1728295534849167,
0.298420786857605,
-0.4849974811077118,
-0.5765082836151123,
-0.031822625547647476,
-0.2530941665172577,
-0.1574254333972931,
-0.16910883784294128,
1.0768585205078125,
-0.6473820209503174,
-0.5317712426185608,
0.1784990280866623,
0.6449732780456543,
0.05958838760852814,
0.1902572512626648,
-0.4956069886684418,
-0.40580451488494873,
-0.1557139903306961,
-0.033878982067108154,
0.33059218525886536,
0.5862110257148743,
0.07614479959011078,
0.7798964381217957,
0.6042278409004211,
0.05224624648690224,
0.16470371186733246,
-0.19168081879615784,
1.034309983253479,
-0.3469323217868805,
-0.8247921466827393,
-0.5340769290924072,
0.29221752285957336,
0.043770868331193924,
-0.30518773198127747,
0.9013102054595947,
0.5231162309646606,
0.9877955317497253,
0.163881316781044,
0.9372966885566711,
0.20042793452739716,
0.5031947493553162,
-0.3402346074581146,
1.057572364807129,
-0.5795906782150269,
-0.10175234824419022,
-0.2605220079421997,
-0.5616110563278198,
-0.07360217720270157,
0.31736746430397034,
-0.19252710044384003,
0.05760366469621658,
0.34892547130584717,
0.2204202264547348,
-0.22088590264320374,
0.3969084322452545,
0.06141124665737152,
-0.11856827884912491,
0.2278750240802765,
0.27219727635383606,
0.6591009497642517,
-0.3806692957878113,
0.5959137678146362,
-0.6653163433074951,
-0.237227663397789,
0.08676056563854218,
-0.7392111420631409,
-0.9796971082687378,
-0.687454879283905,
-0.22092284262180328,
-0.17518524825572968,
-0.20983973145484924,
0.6424574851989746,
0.8805062174797058,
-0.5007733702659607,
-0.16522780060768127,
0.07867257297039032,
0.30886417627334595,
-0.24884578585624695,
-0.21016909182071686,
0.5855259895324707,
-0.20443138480186462,
-0.4292334020137787,
0.3164626359939575,
-0.34358543157577515,
0.44346562027931213,
-0.20443299412727356,
0.37742936611175537,
-0.048573389649391174,
0.06230662390589714,
0.17936071753501892,
-0.0290398970246315,
0.06045389547944069,
-0.23733191192150116,
-0.1484197974205017,
-0.2452416568994522,
-0.3708397150039673,
0.8404210805892944,
-0.7313235402107239,
0.5994613766670227,
0.3586539924144745,
0.9528296589851379,
0.39055708050727844,
0.2578900158405304,
0.11829133331775665,
-1.1651101112365723,
0.07541266828775406,
0.18471300601959229,
0.047743018716573715,
0.26580801606178284,
-0.6423176527023315,
0.3759021759033203,
0.3218371272087097,
-0.5211845636367798,
-0.6596874594688416,
0.04305388778448105,
-0.7333703637123108,
-0.4827893078327179,
0.7304847240447998,
-0.40372684597969055,
-0.37548986077308655,
-0.08717506378889084,
0.28172922134399414,
0.33356428146362305,
-0.2747230529785156,
0.8758622407913208,
0.5495816469192505,
0.09821221977472305,
0.009203909896314144,
-0.2869705557823181,
0.5489295721054077,
0.25613871216773987,
-0.7664771676063538,
0.09936347603797913,
0.34715428948402405,
0.4208518862724304,
0.24288074672222137,
0.714494526386261,
0.1447889357805252,
-0.204717218875885,
0.2445998638868332,
0.14586851000785828,
-0.3769318759441376,
-0.9159051775932312,
-0.07436628639698029,
0.46785104274749756,
-0.5216339826583862,
-0.22265011072158813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11073v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11073v1 | Exploring the Limitations of Detecting Machine-Generated Text | 2024-06-16T21:02:02 | 2024-06-16T21:02:02 | Jad Doughman, Osama Mohammed Afzal, Hawau Olamide Toyin, Shady Shehata, Preslav Nakov, Zeerak Talat | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent improvements in the quality of the generations by large language
models have spurred research into identifying machine-generated text. Systems
proposed for the task often achieve high performance. However, humans and
machines can produce text in different styles and in different domains, and it
remains unclear whether machine generated-text detection models favour
particular styles or domains. In this paper, we critically examine the
classification performance for detecting machine-generated text by evaluating
on texts with varying writing styles. We find that classifiers are highly
sensitive to stylistic changes and differences in text complexity, and in some
cases degrade entirely to random classifiers. We further find that detection
systems are particularly susceptible to misclassify easy-to-read texts while
they have high performance for complex texts. | [
-0.3277280032634735,
-0.7192647457122803,
0.6610376834869385,
0.10048991441726685,
-0.014845617115497589,
0.17251834273338318,
-0.3293476402759552,
-0.9330392479896545,
-0.33485910296440125,
0.6485029458999634,
-0.41123858094215393,
-0.39012661576271057,
-0.979587197303772,
0.7104828357696533,
-0.35315772891044617,
1.052701711654663,
-0.26001667976379395,
-0.3901311159133911,
-0.2169961929321289,
-0.0904243066906929,
-0.44937795400619507,
-0.9357327818870544,
-0.36606431007385254,
-0.34245043992996216,
0.35437139868736267,
0.3002432882785797,
0.5486067533493042,
0.45112916827201843,
0.6911112070083618,
0.37644878029823303,
0.04377639293670654,
0.5050094127655029,
-0.4412398338317871,
0.5295352935791016,
-0.03452438861131668,
-0.5907713770866394,
-0.04668840393424034,
0.011372106149792671,
0.6207793354988098,
0.16709372401237488,
0.5348432064056396,
-0.008348019793629646,
0.18390865623950958,
0.5838618278503418,
-0.851970374584198,
-0.14332181215286255,
-0.8029065132141113,
0.04092514142394066,
-0.4946760833263397,
-0.4510486423969269,
-0.9829504489898682,
-0.08911070227622986,
0.06293373554944992,
-0.47019195556640625,
0.5256326794624329,
0.2984733283519745,
0.782319962978363,
0.11947987973690033,
-0.3031446039676666,
-0.8348300457000732,
-1.017897367477417,
0.8962317705154419,
-0.2771730422973633,
0.15341171622276306,
0.23571191728115082,
0.33753135800361633,
0.028716495260596275,
-0.5734741687774658,
-0.690211296081543,
-0.1261962503194809,
-0.13801932334899902,
0.034583818167448044,
-0.3186523914337158,
-0.19866284728050232,
0.4567774534225464,
0.19249476492404938,
-0.70725417137146,
0.276571661233902,
-0.05248824879527092,
-0.4231317937374115,
0.6930521726608276,
0.3231334388256073,
0.5242430567741394,
-0.42048919200897217,
-0.1337910145521164,
-0.1484133005142212,
-0.2790066599845886,
0.07245702296495438,
0.7471933960914612,
0.330250084400177,
0.3174205422401428,
0.5887928605079651,
-0.19425305724143982,
0.6341962218284607,
-0.1760317087173462,
-0.29506245255470276,
0.06173443794250488,
-0.22226350009441376,
-0.21496960520744324,
-0.06468567997217178,
0.926537275314331,
0.30458617210388184,
0.3880719840526581,
0.009824185632169247,
-0.6043915152549744,
0.09096100926399231,
0.39785102009773254,
-0.6866518259048462,
-0.2251003235578537,
-0.18665125966072083,
-0.5937164425849915,
-0.5379683971405029,
0.09319540858268738,
-0.24804545938968658,
-0.5893679857254028,
-0.009831302799284458,
0.5955998301506042,
-0.4185977578163147,
-0.020410241559147835,
0.18506093323230743,
-0.6159758567810059,
-0.02317594364285469,
0.43674278259277344,
-0.7963297367095947,
-0.06427554786205292,
0.5646950006484985,
0.5623252391815186,
-0.3167571723461151,
-0.3430638015270233,
-0.3579161465167999,
-0.15845562517642975,
-0.2839992344379425,
0.9588929414749146,
-0.5359001755714417,
-0.3211653232574463,
-0.1552269607782364,
0.06036004051566124,
-0.1491556465625763,
-0.7096662521362305,
0.7878459692001343,
-0.4289787709712982,
0.23748145997524261,
-0.050031181424856186,
-0.43324893712997437,
0.11818388104438782,
-0.08030124008655548,
-0.6714168787002563,
0.8310545682907104,
0.2512357831001282,
-1.0462383031845093,
0.8751416206359863,
-0.28647470474243164,
-0.7668672204017639,
0.060447290539741516,
0.13759323954582214,
-0.8824418783187866,
0.11096317321062088,
-0.2302180379629135,
0.7025795578956604,
-0.06502686440944672,
0.18885467946529388,
-0.24343526363372803,
-0.5930774807929993,
0.6057302355766296,
-0.6529608964920044,
0.5356168746948242,
0.5506613850593567,
-0.44990232586860657,
-0.02898145467042923,
-1.0192041397094727,
-0.08874107152223587,
0.20114341378211975,
-0.6742631196975708,
-0.5399742126464844,
0.11578097939491272,
0.5009697079658508,
0.032281626015901566,
0.1992141753435135,
-0.38738787174224854,
0.07969024777412415,
0.15157221257686615,
0.3798450827598572,
0.7361719012260437,
-0.292005330324173,
0.2366824597120285,
-0.608661413192749,
0.4851365387439728,
-0.04320905730128288,
-0.29504990577697754,
-0.22288945317268372,
-0.5072268843650818,
-0.7959475517272949,
-0.2666589915752411,
0.31481921672821045,
0.643943190574646,
-0.8292627930641174,
0.47035399079322815,
0.10145671665668488,
-0.508322536945343,
-0.32759249210357666,
0.05289106443524361,
0.48988649249076843,
-0.08065486699342728,
0.1775292158126831,
-0.2468308061361313,
-0.5136738419532776,
-0.78248131275177,
-0.8059192299842834,
-0.08227408677339554,
-0.19127342104911804,
0.38603875041007996,
0.5498983860015869,
-0.3945460915565491,
0.5930287837982178,
-0.5045322179794312,
0.1396549642086029,
-0.33123546838760376,
0.4730382561683655,
-0.38208743929862976,
0.4473683536052704,
0.6960169672966003,
-0.6148627996444702,
-0.4707047939300537,
0.09051574766635895,
-0.7657102942466736,
-0.37228167057037354,
-0.3717171251773834,
0.07634299248456955,
0.420732319355011,
0.4601902365684509,
-0.23549558222293854,
0.4730284512042999,
0.3102049231529236,
-0.3457692861557007,
0.6554493308067322,
-0.13029387593269348,
0.23401924967765808,
-0.6441285610198975,
0.06295424699783325,
0.2718347907066345,
-0.21210314333438873,
-0.7676602005958557,
-0.011696655303239822,
0.17211033403873444,
-0.1302030384540558,
-0.17254826426506042,
0.20725344121456146,
-0.2790820300579071,
0.08743125200271606,
-0.3843699097633362,
-0.051719628274440765,
0.2199404537677765,
0.2000129222869873,
-0.03826311230659485,
0.6540343165397644,
0.049304693937301636,
-0.7180269360542297,
-0.0242325346916914,
-0.19605912268161774,
-0.5410575270652771,
0.79714035987854,
-0.5170047879219055,
0.20389847457408905,
-0.3268653452396393,
0.22369368374347687,
-1.0661371946334839,
-0.5298827886581421,
0.06256978213787079,
-0.49646255373954773,
0.5449195504188538,
0.10552927851676941,
-0.5798457860946655,
-0.31260424852371216,
-0.2583458721637726,
0.308501660823822,
0.19315558671951294,
-0.4402708113193512,
0.35467132925987244,
0.039985258132219315,
0.08616672456264496,
-0.48289433121681213,
-0.6068200469017029,
-0.015745660290122032,
-0.2969304323196411,
-0.6168289184570312,
0.21990393102169037,
0.053348686546087265,
-0.29461297392845154,
-0.14786681532859802,
0.07266217470169067,
-0.11997263878583908,
0.5694460868835449,
0.2540827691555023,
0.014933276921510696,
-0.27939507365226746,
0.2872771918773651,
0.2375275045633316,
0.10915227234363556,
-0.08418118208646774,
-0.0374358631670475,
0.5007765889167786,
0.1163867712020874,
-0.2576712965965271,
-0.5885263085365295,
0.37840190529823303,
0.9305874109268188,
-0.13514651358127594,
0.602802038192749,
0.827338457107544,
-0.3159264326095581,
-0.5634260773658752,
-0.3752884566783905,
0.1226753368973732,
-0.4776417911052704,
0.3261352479457855,
-0.6828845739364624,
-1.0007274150848389,
0.23526881635189056,
0.25044646859169006,
-0.25692710280418396,
0.9222432374954224,
0.3954128623008728,
-0.059434518218040466,
1.1563137769699097,
0.7333908677101135,
0.17060336470603943,
0.3637221157550812,
0.2017218917608261,
0.2619364261627197,
-0.5840744376182556,
-0.23656204342842102,
-1.1370769739151,
-0.16543513536453247,
-1.125927209854126,
0.04580308869481087,
-0.054332222789525986,
0.013856273144483566,
-0.20809626579284668,
0.4764935076236725,
-1.0363330841064453,
0.5529995560646057,
0.6555486917495728,
0.12313060462474823,
0.5078163146972656,
-0.1025606170296669,
0.16243121027946472,
0.018103551119565964,
-0.36683279275894165,
-0.9598236083984375,
1.2619929313659668,
0.3651517927646637,
0.6024868488311768,
0.013936369679868221,
0.6263527870178223,
0.6631788611412048,
0.30168429017066956,
-0.6694715023040771,
0.22144468128681183,
-0.5442297458648682,
-0.5915944576263428,
-0.1528734713792801,
-0.5119785070419312,
-0.9864939451217651,
0.12356056272983551,
-0.4625644385814667,
-0.5026329159736633,
0.07759696990251541,
-0.14693231880664825,
-0.01771668717265129,
0.4198038876056671,
-0.9332701563835144,
0.7639198303222656,
-0.04004443436861038,
-0.09333627671003342,
0.16864071786403656,
-0.31826096773147583,
0.27144473791122437,
-0.33382272720336914,
0.014691940508782864,
-0.10257790237665176,
0.27405044436454773,
0.7722954154014587,
-0.12714585661888123,
0.6993308663368225,
0.10535454750061035,
-0.125857412815094,
0.5892625451087952,
0.3314867317676544,
0.2623150050640106,
-0.26805514097213745,
-0.0919068455696106,
-0.08295226842164993,
-0.21216446161270142,
-0.4115019142627716,
-0.3223321735858917,
0.47695693373680115,
-0.798558235168457,
-0.4476129412651062,
-0.45813891291618347,
-0.38710102438926697,
0.004973075818270445,
0.3216330111026764,
0.9113824963569641,
0.3713790476322174,
-0.24947421252727509,
0.09517703205347061,
0.5904254913330078,
-0.4616037607192993,
0.29128509759902954,
0.14502760767936707,
-0.2250511795282364,
0.034276217222213745,
1.2101719379425049,
0.2615498900413513,
0.35071897506713867,
0.32851505279541016,
0.10787391662597656,
-0.07761168479919434,
-0.7013910412788391,
-0.765155553817749,
-0.12943311035633087,
-0.6424327492713928,
0.009441399946808815,
-0.7741360664367676,
-0.22014814615249634,
-0.21436578035354614,
-0.31087562441825867,
0.14042143523693085,
-0.4994896352291107,
-0.6566978693008423,
0.20069251954555511,
0.13255974650382996,
1.0999501943588257,
0.25265756249427795,
0.2439459264278412,
-0.45539015531539917,
0.1373475342988968,
0.36938250064849854,
0.2873162627220154,
-0.12269611656665802,
-0.4724377691745758,
0.11346295475959778,
-0.4115068316459656,
-0.5717050433158875,
-0.6502189040184021,
0.20582516491413116,
-0.06100601330399513,
0.20847119390964508,
0.29835277795791626,
0.05547038093209267,
-0.049215879291296005,
-0.2681750953197479,
0.7058185338973999,
0.023203762248158455,
-1.0166733264923096,
0.4928099513053894,
-0.3941490948200226,
0.34704601764678955,
0.4372527003288269,
0.5090185403823853,
-0.4884634017944336,
-0.6948004961013794,
-0.40349844098091125,
-0.36319229006767273,
0.6770793795585632,
0.281031996011734,
0.17070285975933075,
0.056822799146175385,
0.33038410544395447,
0.44196781516075134,
0.130085289478302,
-0.6954241394996643,
-0.011907225474715233,
-0.29976341128349304,
-0.2226429581642151,
-0.033331695944070816,
-0.2177492082118988,
0.2913472056388855,
0.17780978977680206,
0.35671138763427734,
0.02290998585522175,
0.42315027117729187,
0.174886554479599,
-0.20153571665287018,
-0.08100944012403488,
0.4154764413833618,
0.8789042234420776,
0.2296866625547409,
-0.0063255419954657555,
0.25033098459243774,
-0.10316136479377747,
-0.4934126138687134,
0.1617792248725891,
-0.1874891072511673,
-0.42207783460617065,
0.17608964443206787,
0.7833910584449768,
0.8189459443092346,
-0.20617987215518951,
-0.6371710300445557,
0.4244147837162018,
-0.18288439512252808,
-0.19832547008991241,
0.11834891885519028,
0.5434903502464294,
-0.40071481466293335,
-0.053973786532878876,
0.2636937201023102,
0.5724771618843079,
0.31710219383239746,
-0.7934120893478394,
0.0648699477314949,
0.40293586254119873,
-0.4076693654060364,
-0.23107752203941345,
0.5266415476799011,
0.1709170639514923,
-0.6015209555625916,
0.3329162299633026,
-0.5478573441505432,
-0.8757554292678833,
0.7823235988616943,
0.6980578303337097,
0.9565812349319458,
-0.0004748308565467596,
0.07191324234008789,
0.14820219576358795,
0.3323017656803131,
0.03647994250059128,
0.1538756638765335,
-0.10997329652309418,
-0.8029119372367859,
-0.19273847341537476,
-0.6916537284851074,
-0.4372432827949524,
0.22306104004383087,
-0.36994022130966187,
0.27187153697013855,
-0.5956545472145081,
-0.45555317401885986,
0.4099659323692322,
-0.14862807095050812,
-0.6222621202468872,
0.2362866848707199,
0.00641262624412775,
0.34503984451293945,
-0.8804558515548706,
0.21747593581676483,
0.635145366191864,
-0.06761699169874191,
-0.3507879674434662,
0.3179728090763092,
0.10351096838712692,
-0.5327281355857849,
0.7120139002799988,
0.6051414012908936,
-0.48409324884414673,
-0.2699914574623108,
-0.5971816182136536,
-0.21148976683616638,
0.5779053568840027,
-0.13732285797595978,
-0.43279722332954407,
0.12405452877283096,
0.1284608542919159,
0.7959792613983154,
-0.2001136988401413,
0.12474199384450912,
0.5464459657669067,
0.4360254108905792,
-0.4625852108001709,
-1.101636528968811,
0.010973908938467503,
-0.15570469200611115,
0.039900485426187515,
0.29767608642578125,
-0.6115139126777649,
0.9902024269104004,
0.023886261507868767,
-0.5981848239898682,
0.16682901978492737,
0.3223744332790375,
-0.06246370077133179,
0.9182924628257751,
0.28852054476737976,
0.4389343857765198,
0.9281597137451172,
-0.3482222855091095,
1.0194158554077148,
0.10980276018381119,
0.3460181951522827,
0.5397408604621887,
-0.2642650902271271,
0.6132619380950928,
-0.2016020268201828,
-0.16245537996292114,
0.623067319393158,
0.49184244871139526,
0.004436257295310497,
0.10719690471887589,
0.4638928174972534,
-0.44756048917770386,
-0.2961333096027374,
-0.1453457921743393,
-0.2331772744655609,
0.7522444128990173,
0.12673403322696686,
-0.5637134313583374,
0.30586865544319153,
0.16616731882095337,
0.11241259425878525,
0.3993132412433624,
-0.108443982899189,
0.6538819074630737,
-0.20891842246055603,
-0.7729271650314331,
0.5451648831367493,
0.35854506492614746,
1.0536102056503296,
-0.0752146765589714,
0.2934599220752716,
0.26524618268013,
0.2077106237411499,
-0.41163986921310425,
-0.8542078137397766,
0.27544280886650085,
0.255715548992157,
-0.4228628873825073,
-0.037279363721609116,
1.2382794618606567,
0.05394987761974335,
-0.3623630404472351,
-0.002702258760109544,
0.44278252124786377,
0.04211612045764923,
-0.06432512402534485,
-0.2445092350244522,
0.3853926658630371,
-0.07836724817752838,
-0.2261361926794052,
0.33947426080703735,
0.9293654561042786,
-0.043963655829429626,
0.6251352429389954,
0.5978603363037109,
-0.4803735613822937,
-0.0462799072265625,
-0.08458210527896881,
0.41668757796287537,
-0.5551198720932007,
-0.11320999264717102,
-0.9016737341880798,
0.08833981305360794,
-0.04125891253352165,
-0.6581942439079285,
0.6715657711029053,
0.5663672685623169,
1.0087494850158691,
-0.26786330342292786,
1.0674854516983032,
0.0655127689242363,
0.40629130601882935,
-0.5612149238586426,
0.891761839389801,
-0.523315966129303,
0.11489462852478027,
-0.5621636509895325,
-0.6556753516197205,
-0.37330275774002075,
0.4928646385669708,
-0.11982652544975281,
0.13875052332878113,
0.7170317769050598,
0.42188388109207153,
0.14331451058387756,
0.22889608144760132,
0.38165339827537537,
-0.1869155764579773,
0.28105488419532776,
0.5504541993141174,
1.1259891986846924,
-0.3245719373226166,
0.5735804438591003,
-0.15695030987262726,
-0.12977541983127594,
-0.5106484293937683,
-0.6780139803886414,
-1.0674057006835938,
-0.7291826009750366,
-0.17947660386562347,
-0.5516865849494934,
-0.11997052282094955,
0.3421184718608856,
0.44679781794548035,
-0.6666490435600281,
0.04027716442942619,
0.00796190183609724,
0.2966412603855133,
0.023204300552606583,
-0.32802486419677734,
0.09561379253864288,
-0.36085203289985657,
-0.8218458890914917,
0.0835832729935646,
0.35539498925209045,
0.2412947416305542,
-0.21503157913684845,
0.1486475020647049,
0.43674081563949585,
0.2900739312171936,
0.8883221745491028,
0.16205090284347534,
-0.4932919442653656,
-0.5965963006019592,
0.1467009037733078,
-0.6254191994667053,
-0.015799425542354584,
1.0956950187683105,
-0.42446377873420715,
0.44445154070854187,
0.7795373797416687,
0.6723054051399231,
0.37408000230789185,
-0.11069247126579285,
0.14720456302165985,
-0.5017235279083252,
-0.33710312843322754,
0.2673009932041168,
0.15689365565776825,
0.34265217185020447,
-0.5874071717262268,
0.2388363480567932,
0.551668107509613,
-0.7689630389213562,
-0.8356735706329346,
0.4619017243385315,
-0.6837779879570007,
-0.6440082788467407,
0.965249240398407,
0.03793366625905037,
0.06163402646780014,
-0.36928558349609375,
-0.3912729322910309,
0.2397296130657196,
-0.27395689487457275,
0.6685101389884949,
0.960404098033905,
-0.2347089946269989,
0.4021680951118469,
-0.47022154927253723,
0.5189881920814514,
0.23124875128269196,
-0.72410649061203,
-0.001660080044530332,
0.518576443195343,
0.27372947335243225,
0.4166766107082367,
0.44462263584136963,
0.0652751550078392,
0.3985196650028229,
0.01311518531292677,
-0.16153433918952942,
0.26461321115493774,
-0.5654497742652893,
-0.20830422639846802,
0.48079797625541687,
0.29209092259407043,
0.18190549314022064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11069v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11069v1 | WildVision: Evaluating Vision-Language Models in the Wild with Human Preferences | 2024-06-16T20:53:25 | 2024-06-16T20:53:25 | Yujie Lu, Dongfu Jiang, Wenhu Chen, William Yang Wang, Yejin Choi, Bill Yuchen Lin | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent breakthroughs in vision-language models (VLMs) emphasize the necessity
of benchmarking human preferences in real-world multimodal interactions. To
address this gap, we launched WildVision-Arena (WV-Arena), an online platform
that collects human preferences to evaluate VLMs. We curated WV-Bench by
selecting 500 high-quality samples from 8,000 user submissions in WV-Arena.
WV-Bench uses GPT-4 as the judge to compare each VLM with Claude-3-Sonnet,
achieving a Spearman correlation of 0.94 with the WV-Arena Elo. This
significantly outperforms other benchmarks like MMVet, MMMU, and MMStar.
Our comprehensive analysis of 20K real-world interactions reveals important
insights into the failure cases of top-performing VLMs. For example, we find
that although GPT-4V surpasses many other models like Reka-Flash, Opus, and
Yi-VL-Plus in simple visual recognition and reasoning tasks, it still faces
challenges with subtle contextual cues, spatial reasoning, visual imagination,
and expert domain knowledge. Additionally, current VLMs exhibit issues with
hallucinations and safety when intentionally provoked. We are releasing our
chat and feedback data to further advance research in the field of VLMs. | [
-0.4689779281616211,
-0.455770343542099,
0.6050415635108948,
0.24485163390636444,
-0.2967831790447235,
-0.20121540129184723,
-0.17972013354301453,
-0.857414186000824,
-0.044523872435092926,
0.5911562442779541,
-0.39645013213157654,
-0.46088916063308716,
-0.3162149488925934,
-0.10799416899681091,
-0.32281383872032166,
0.6212417483329773,
-0.002289103576913476,
0.12925246357917786,
-0.227556049823761,
-0.3344327211380005,
-0.5170145630836487,
-0.6375501155853271,
-0.20613525807857513,
-0.10201238095760345,
0.6218118667602539,
0.07901032269001007,
0.5925831198692322,
0.41552770137786865,
0.568595826625824,
0.3513728976249695,
0.06295284628868103,
0.19585177302360535,
-0.5767440795898438,
0.11516518890857697,
-0.03159506991505623,
-0.24031509459018707,
-0.5478994250297546,
0.23050551116466522,
0.21056927740573883,
0.583040714263916,
-0.258685827255249,
-0.023735780268907547,
-0.07657811790704727,
0.488757461309433,
-0.7045975923538208,
0.14009667932987213,
-0.7173919081687927,
0.38567396998405457,
-0.2856501638889313,
-0.143332377076149,
-0.44675973057746887,
-0.11321082711219788,
0.6117594838142395,
-0.6520867347717285,
0.2721885144710541,
0.268500417470932,
1.0872511863708496,
0.14465726912021637,
-0.44495609402656555,
0.4203917384147644,
-0.86418616771698,
0.7633267641067505,
-0.3901802599430084,
0.5912272930145264,
0.2954505980014801,
0.6698082089424133,
0.04195626825094223,
-0.7350382208824158,
-0.727077066898346,
-0.18149542808532715,
0.1891174167394638,
0.2876521944999695,
-0.4800088405609131,
0.17016150057315826,
0.26683691143989563,
0.00633249431848526,
-0.6955769062042236,
0.07405764609575272,
-0.5802575349807739,
-0.2713758051395416,
0.63345867395401,
0.3926059603691101,
-0.0868343859910965,
-0.026568762958049774,
-0.45778584480285645,
-0.3714223802089691,
-0.4281218945980072,
-0.07953624427318573,
0.15932396054267883,
-0.034210413694381714,
0.16690003871917725,
0.5544852018356323,
-0.3198850750923157,
1.0955089330673218,
-0.28733229637145996,
0.12499994784593582,
0.46959546208381653,
-0.26018884778022766,
-0.5366761088371277,
-0.5727463364601135,
0.7435799241065979,
1.0659610033035278,
0.27176645398139954,
-0.19902795553207397,
-0.24254663288593292,
0.33272773027420044,
0.598291277885437,
-0.44454970955848694,
-0.1404423862695694,
-0.026794089004397392,
-0.4546959102153778,
-0.37167826294898987,
-0.13330520689487457,
-0.8451856970787048,
-0.7346203923225403,
-0.41057878732681274,
0.5821502804756165,
-0.1494477093219757,
-0.12260407954454422,
0.05672789737582207,
-0.31085872650146484,
0.43649375438690186,
0.7386168837547302,
-0.901197612285614,
0.25861072540283203,
0.47871825098991394,
0.6229172348976135,
-0.5285170078277588,
-0.6259225010871887,
-0.5074410438537598,
-0.19810572266578674,
-0.33456751704216003,
0.9402123093605042,
-0.4203391373157501,
-0.28575819730758667,
0.08953826129436493,
-0.17965815961360931,
-0.009303738363087177,
-0.7196125984191895,
0.5432471036911011,
-0.35766226053237915,
-0.018367011100053787,
-0.3484196960926056,
-0.22262293100357056,
-0.08108936250209808,
0.5608605742454529,
-0.6265731453895569,
0.6497560143470764,
-0.26472702622413635,
-0.5548281073570251,
0.9422594904899597,
-0.3782161474227905,
0.016968274489045143,
0.4501045346260071,
-0.3875647783279419,
-0.2221173644065857,
0.2657588720321655,
0.1097460612654686,
0.4720442295074463,
-0.09955011308193207,
0.23468898236751556,
-0.46861040592193604,
-0.33481648564338684,
0.26882362365722656,
-0.588396430015564,
0.2607879638671875,
0.27680668234825134,
-0.30377787351608276,
0.5107226371765137,
-0.8351966142654419,
0.08461201190948486,
0.1380750685930252,
-0.04201241955161095,
-0.4606592655181885,
0.1909027099609375,
0.3856591582298279,
0.276123583316803,
-0.0299857035279274,
-0.45500776171684265,
0.12081311643123627,
-0.34177568554878235,
0.295803427696228,
0.8722809553146362,
-0.22813384234905243,
0.2549189329147339,
-0.08451066166162491,
0.28707581758499146,
0.0958864763379097,
0.866466224193573,
0.2320915013551712,
-0.7370601296424866,
-0.7776610255241394,
-0.09707159548997879,
-0.2717236280441284,
0.34577882289886475,
-0.7649516463279724,
-0.07716722041368484,
-0.10190016776323318,
-0.4912882149219513,
-0.41322773694992065,
-0.051481474190950394,
0.33416882157325745,
0.35806459188461304,
0.2569007873535156,
-0.49503225088119507,
-0.5376209616661072,
-1.1461595296859741,
-0.3106805086135864,
-0.21335433423519135,
-0.024162041023373604,
0.815833568572998,
0.37817785143852234,
-0.5143527984619141,
1.0742082595825195,
-0.5264737010002136,
-0.3937626779079437,
-0.21098023653030396,
0.02483495883643627,
0.07532721757888794,
0.07963673025369644,
0.755350649356842,
-1.27777898311615,
-0.4681502878665924,
-0.05042221024632454,
-0.8935153484344482,
0.07465028017759323,
0.3560754954814911,
-0.030894571915268898,
0.1978463977575302,
-0.02048465795814991,
-0.4277290999889374,
0.6453348994255066,
0.7250933647155762,
-0.44469544291496277,
0.494218111038208,
-0.24075976014137268,
0.2856387495994568,
-0.5497691035270691,
0.07958485931158066,
-0.021756669506430626,
-0.015386555343866348,
-0.7591096758842468,
0.07666941732168198,
-0.032205600291490555,
0.08756929636001587,
-0.7135653495788574,
0.4672889709472656,
-0.1699143797159195,
-0.277738094329834,
0.028072228655219078,
0.3506005108356476,
0.036382097750902176,
0.5388764142990112,
0.23109708726406097,
0.5336405634880066,
0.6646229028701782,
-0.30438950657844543,
0.7560075521469116,
0.35581016540527344,
-0.26454609632492065,
0.3651200532913208,
-0.5786495208740234,
0.17128346860408783,
-0.05608728900551796,
0.1327708661556244,
-0.7422605752944946,
-0.2773057520389557,
0.1408310979604721,
-0.2650386393070221,
0.024724546819925308,
-0.22637394070625305,
-0.3144837021827698,
-0.4852388799190521,
-0.4232102632522583,
0.21940383315086365,
0.3623877763748169,
-0.41981980204582214,
0.527827799320221,
0.5457102060317993,
0.3181719183921814,
-0.7159553170204163,
-0.6753147840499878,
0.5522974729537964,
-0.1277424395084381,
-0.5679270029067993,
0.044679801911115646,
-0.21233467757701874,
-0.5635103583335876,
-0.10059010237455368,
0.02186700887978077,
0.02581941708922386,
-0.004524615127593279,
0.4443327486515045,
0.5555803179740906,
0.0005347523838281631,
-0.28085678815841675,
-0.49354276061058044,
-0.15693069994449615,
-0.13760906457901,
-0.5724126696586609,
0.2867262065410614,
-0.5777878761291504,
-0.29351818561553955,
0.05443509295582771,
0.23498083651065826,
0.6910422444343567,
-0.37885206937789917,
0.58149653673172,
0.3785111904144287,
-0.3582538664340973,
-0.11100137233734131,
-0.6638915538787842,
-0.09817899763584137,
-0.40979379415512085,
0.21935680508613586,
-0.34719204902648926,
-0.8560352921485901,
0.2656697630882263,
0.19999752938747406,
0.10844830423593521,
0.282052218914032,
0.6037012338638306,
-0.05511119216680527,
1.1571890115737915,
0.7116702795028687,
0.30092763900756836,
0.42147815227508545,
-0.2701062560081482,
0.06506596505641937,
-0.6391382217407227,
-0.470355749130249,
-0.12858667969703674,
-0.223457470536232,
-0.4971287250518799,
-0.42557576298713684,
0.506948709487915,
-0.3720429241657257,
0.3009045124053955,
0.3047662377357483,
-0.4701399803161621,
0.43602627515792847,
0.37659183144569397,
-0.0388282835483551,
0.32527151703834534,
-0.16854368150234222,
-0.446287602186203,
-0.439778596162796,
-0.4917163550853729,
-0.5310784578323364,
1.0919638872146606,
0.1561189442873001,
0.7097560167312622,
0.13660892844200134,
0.4281761050224304,
0.2723786532878876,
0.3889304995536804,
-0.6878630518913269,
0.6464886665344238,
-0.025728769600391388,
-0.7759406566619873,
-0.34593886137008667,
-0.2606171667575836,
-0.8647207617759705,
0.7232832312583923,
-0.5324704051017761,
-1.0086777210235596,
0.2779202461242676,
0.36515969038009644,
-0.38901248574256897,
0.19647172093391418,
-0.6602253913879395,
1.1792784929275513,
-0.290195107460022,
-0.7935954332351685,
-0.15973272919654846,
-0.7537753582000732,
0.5402384996414185,
-0.0879204124212265,
0.21761512756347656,
0.02881583943963051,
0.1413293182849884,
0.6007429361343384,
-0.2378191351890564,
0.7762818336486816,
-0.12218046933412552,
0.06021483987569809,
0.049070220440626144,
-0.07597682625055313,
0.2502014636993408,
-0.07952472567558289,
0.28344693779945374,
0.27273157238960266,
-0.15024468302726746,
-0.12000124156475067,
-0.4357217252254486,
0.7621042132377625,
-0.8914968967437744,
-0.4364262521266937,
-0.7080042362213135,
-0.2789210379123688,
-0.4935731589794159,
0.18462218344211578,
0.3138100504875183,
0.6253019571304321,
-0.431402325630188,
0.15036267042160034,
0.7409247756004333,
-0.3271801471710205,
0.323418527841568,
0.6591138243675232,
-0.5990862846374512,
-0.3535190224647522,
0.7407464385032654,
0.046171434223651886,
0.2019759714603424,
0.32290783524513245,
0.15698643028736115,
-0.17011934518814087,
-0.7599672675132751,
-0.6177316308021545,
-0.07028521597385406,
-0.7794291973114014,
0.07816831767559052,
-0.8735280632972717,
-0.016007401049137115,
-0.1931598037481308,
-0.05897945538163185,
-0.4676671028137207,
-0.06450823694467545,
0.21074159443378448,
-0.12270081043243408,
0.18713711202144623,
0.8384851813316345,
-0.09137260168790817,
-0.17226581275463104,
-0.6613882184028625,
0.3152780532836914,
0.8326482772827148,
0.49783629179000854,
-0.123745396733284,
-0.2515043020248413,
-0.0888114646077156,
-0.24181866645812988,
-0.15026259422302246,
-0.692350447177887,
0.6169101595878601,
-0.012701863422989845,
0.5892369747161865,
0.4584697186946869,
0.0030533047392964363,
0.739837110042572,
-0.707987904548645,
0.881310224533081,
0.14616908133029938,
-0.6849098205566406,
0.5169605612754822,
-0.2937536835670471,
-0.015021455474197865,
0.5077560544013977,
0.06064562499523163,
-0.5356730818748474,
-0.3575250804424286,
-0.511601448059082,
-0.877888023853302,
0.7123233675956726,
0.29702839255332947,
0.03085019811987877,
0.25778234004974365,
-0.028348444029688835,
0.11498938500881195,
0.25890496373176575,
-0.5877277255058289,
-0.1601220816373825,
-0.47632500529289246,
0.2122606337070465,
-0.1975279599428177,
-0.08711284399032593,
-0.24401047825813293,
-0.2579696476459503,
0.09378694742918015,
-0.26081374287605286,
0.17472371459007263,
0.03800187632441521,
0.028251782059669495,
-0.26838991045951843,
0.20674388110637665,
0.8747153878211975,
0.8444919586181641,
-0.46297022700309753,
0.33637046813964844,
0.4047677218914032,
-0.7077575922012329,
-0.2696314752101898,
0.07904621958732605,
-0.13821902871131897,
-0.1556386798620224,
0.4141545593738556,
1.0845041275024414,
0.2213163673877716,
-0.9815915822982788,
0.8700821399688721,
-0.666179358959198,
-0.2953086197376251,
-0.24664872884750366,
0.10211018472909927,
-0.22514018416404724,
0.246007040143013,
0.49135902523994446,
0.605457603931427,
0.3926508128643036,
-0.5926321148872375,
0.17507147789001465,
0.26045799255371094,
-0.6509839296340942,
-0.36395666003227234,
0.9202042818069458,
0.2915065288543701,
0.00974483136087656,
0.3921578526496887,
0.046783462166786194,
-0.6582803726196289,
0.30166640877723694,
0.12662343680858612,
0.9923965334892273,
0.27228033542633057,
0.15010346472263336,
0.10700443387031555,
0.27860382199287415,
-0.01432252861559391,
0.11282804608345032,
-0.1417490839958191,
-0.7972787618637085,
-0.33434242010116577,
-0.7329276204109192,
-0.7221964001655579,
0.09343661367893219,
-0.5966519713401794,
0.14988821744918823,
-0.23372359573841095,
-0.22043617069721222,
0.11510372161865234,
-0.06787749379873276,
-0.8872709274291992,
0.24819296598434448,
0.41261768341064453,
0.6788612008094788,
-0.8401709794998169,
0.9098738431930542,
0.804190456867218,
-0.2930937707424164,
-0.608625590801239,
-0.1419627070426941,
0.3191659450531006,
-0.7555272579193115,
0.640018880367279,
0.08273874223232269,
-0.15664426982402802,
-0.16801775991916656,
-0.8478730320930481,
-0.42459967732429504,
1.0993255376815796,
0.04712215065956116,
-0.7568433284759521,
0.24569988250732422,
-0.20600944757461548,
0.721833348274231,
-0.1539829969406128,
0.15222898125648499,
0.34876060485839844,
0.560820460319519,
0.36513420939445496,
-1.1046878099441528,
-0.31944939494132996,
-0.340169221162796,
-0.021138250827789307,
0.043980665504932404,
-0.65581214427948,
0.5960596203804016,
-0.30259567499160767,
-0.00752252247184515,
-0.19094271957874298,
0.4191056191921234,
0.3727760314941406,
0.5587141513824463,
0.6481673717498779,
0.4167898893356323,
0.4300127327442169,
-0.16539974510669708,
1.08085298538208,
0.06259810924530029,
0.22686418890953064,
0.608437716960907,
-0.6348065733909607,
1.0260859727859497,
0.5052381157875061,
-0.12746991217136383,
-0.04087228327989578,
0.3357585370540619,
-0.16266480088233948,
0.7230120897293091,
0.060092173516750336,
-0.06058738753199577,
-0.4976768493652344,
-0.0961855947971344,
-0.13822713494300842,
0.5400779843330383,
0.1681046038866043,
0.14139612019062042,
0.08433831483125687,
0.32620882987976074,
-0.25425368547439575,
-0.05240296199917793,
0.04291895031929016,
0.7612470388412476,
0.11635905504226685,
-0.8424894213676453,
0.5047223567962646,
-0.1734948754310608,
0.6258745193481445,
-0.6872467398643494,
-0.0756436437368393,
-0.3496044874191284,
0.42022690176963806,
-0.08316773921251297,
-0.7824209928512573,
0.11857518553733826,
0.2477162480354309,
0.02556266076862812,
-0.35267528891563416,
0.6562156081199646,
-0.21783365309238434,
-0.0239421334117651,
0.4576641023159027,
0.44238054752349854,
0.21291764080524445,
-0.05978451296687126,
-0.4358054995536804,
0.5165668725967407,
-0.15296657383441925,
-0.3205946683883667,
0.4397263526916504,
0.3267422318458557,
-0.2285194844007492,
0.7497742176055908,
0.638367772102356,
0.07468267530202866,
0.12550775706768036,
0.38490813970565796,
0.9799558520317078,
-0.6549826264381409,
-0.29502958059310913,
-0.7913508415222168,
0.3550257384777069,
-0.3240186870098114,
-0.6592212915420532,
0.8008462190628052,
0.49853459000587463,
0.7252805829048157,
-0.10499125719070435,
0.7932907342910767,
-0.04428085684776306,
0.0269525907933712,
-0.21068252623081207,
0.7826962471008301,
-0.756613552570343,
0.12078037112951279,
-0.5448082089424133,
-0.9158379435539246,
-0.5988903641700745,
0.5887770652770996,
-0.21122947335243225,
-0.21562981605529785,
0.49105870723724365,
0.5535062551498413,
0.025712311267852783,
-0.1360025554895401,
0.9568015933036804,
0.3403335213661194,
0.38892775774002075,
0.6128339767456055,
1.084972858428955,
-0.254978209733963,
0.7362790703773499,
-0.04804614931344986,
-0.5732713341712952,
-0.49019765853881836,
-0.8206905722618103,
-0.9084255695343018,
-0.6691593527793884,
-0.0724349170923233,
-0.05684687942266464,
0.1527605950832367,
0.815125584602356,
0.8459392786026001,
-0.594732940196991,
-0.06681317836046219,
0.05152976140379906,
-0.24248266220092773,
-0.27529093623161316,
-0.14269794523715973,
0.04004361853003502,
0.09920766949653625,
-0.5155341029167175,
0.4567984938621521,
0.6941894888877869,
0.07804926484823227,
-0.57618647813797,
-0.3444758951663971,
0.1408877819776535,
0.06564042717218399,
0.8181771039962769,
0.1361563801765442,
-0.9961209297180176,
-0.3239966928958893,
0.34792667627334595,
-0.37706369161605835,
-0.1799015998840332,
0.48649653792381287,
-0.8569226264953613,
0.8035550713539124,
0.44704514741897583,
0.20743823051452637,
0.8675630688667297,
-0.405129998922348,
0.7765697836875916,
-0.38265901803970337,
0.006449452135711908,
0.27906057238578796,
0.40532729029655457,
0.3651059865951538,
0.1738051176071167,
0.5638659000396729,
0.6846135854721069,
-0.4662359654903412,
-0.8450419902801514,
0.12937036156654358,
-1.205146074295044,
0.04145893454551697,
1.053621530532837,
0.07428448647260666,
-0.24985931813716888,
-0.1748236119747162,
-0.4846550524234772,
-0.29746013879776,
-0.2179127186536789,
0.7266318202018738,
0.47472479939460754,
-0.1729370355606079,
-0.1787264198064804,
-1.053778052330017,
0.6465452909469604,
0.07804633677005768,
-0.547631025314331,
0.1017138734459877,
0.6321114301681519,
-0.01567675545811653,
0.1129951998591423,
0.49540138244628906,
0.045674365013837814,
0.32580143213272095,
0.16757577657699585,
0.17314285039901733,
-0.05105581507086754,
-0.34886595606803894,
-0.21148446202278137,
0.18378309905529022,
0.07313409447669983,
-0.13893850147724152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11065v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11065v1 | Can LLMs Understand the Implication of Emphasized Sentences in Dialogue? | 2024-06-16T20:41:44 | 2024-06-16T20:41:44 | Guan-Ting Lin, Hung-yi Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emphasis is a crucial component in human communication, which indicates the
speaker's intention and implication beyond pure text in dialogue. While Large
Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized natural language processing, their
ability to understand emphasis in dialogue remains unclear. This paper
introduces Emphasized-Talk, a benchmark with emphasis-annotated dialogue
samples capturing the implications of emphasis. We evaluate various LLMs, both
open-source and commercial, to measure their performance in understanding
emphasis. Additionally, we propose an automatic evaluation pipeline using
GPT-4, which achieves a high correlation with human rating. Our findings reveal
that although commercial LLMs generally perform better, there is still
significant room for improvement in comprehending emphasized sentences. | [
-0.3796222507953644,
-0.9975177645683289,
0.9999472498893738,
0.36818650364875793,
-0.5086568593978882,
-0.1762268990278244,
-0.5543016195297241,
-0.799142599105835,
-0.007312582805752754,
0.42522984743118286,
-0.4218038320541382,
-0.4441879391670227,
-0.7611021399497986,
0.3322782516479492,
-0.3276629149913788,
0.7308627963066101,
0.062148209661245346,
0.006664891727268696,
-0.051863040775060654,
-0.06755117326974869,
-0.4310685992240906,
-0.3029276430606842,
-0.40974074602127075,
-0.5190508365631104,
0.1640668511390686,
0.26998016238212585,
0.7817689776420593,
0.5768545866012573,
0.6154772639274597,
0.33623790740966797,
-0.4070700705051422,
0.099616639316082,
-0.40160781145095825,
0.11610274016857147,
-0.12594561278820038,
-0.4718436300754547,
-0.5371319055557251,
0.09502068907022476,
0.8249809145927429,
0.9150211215019226,
0.18622858822345734,
-0.0679820105433464,
0.24849116802215576,
0.34627053141593933,
-0.5045335292816162,
0.3238815367221832,
-0.7434963583946228,
-0.18196910619735718,
0.09734959155321121,
-0.290798544883728,
-0.4877117872238159,
-0.17129993438720703,
0.48575302958488464,
-0.43969935178756714,
-0.19864444434642792,
0.2338991016149521,
1.0340465307235718,
0.5591824650764465,
-0.48389583826065063,
-0.15980352461338043,
-0.6186294555664062,
0.925588846206665,
-0.6636696457862854,
0.18617898225784302,
0.19658790528774261,
0.05787920206785202,
-0.3592422306537628,
-0.6751172542572021,
-0.284514456987381,
-0.2660694420337677,
-0.18416011333465576,
0.10450322180986404,
-0.013273263350129128,
0.6800181865692139,
0.4302770793437958,
0.784831166267395,
-0.21193405985832214,
0.05448944494128227,
-0.05788582190871239,
0.05790874734520912,
0.4601321220397949,
0.021405622363090515,
0.24684739112854004,
-0.26776066422462463,
-0.4791673719882965,
0.32460397481918335,
-0.5950453877449036,
-0.0031670506577938795,
0.2257714867591858,
0.08837896585464478,
0.09604514390230179,
0.35944047570228577,
-0.38610872626304626,
0.5882903337478638,
0.06922498345375061,
-0.04395578056573868,
0.0654320940375328,
-0.29651203751564026,
-0.5192951560020447,
-0.013949904590845108,
0.6238481402397156,
0.6144907474517822,
0.5231838226318359,
-0.0008469140739180148,
0.10233775526285172,
-0.1481366902589798,
0.1336325705051422,
-0.8519119024276733,
0.028457680717110634,
0.26896777749061584,
-0.3501696288585663,
-0.04178071767091751,
-0.15216855704784393,
-0.3460404574871063,
-0.34977588057518005,
-0.36659812927246094,
0.09978818148374557,
-0.05554936081171036,
-0.023595944046974182,
0.18308262526988983,
-0.20794400572776794,
0.3559730350971222,
0.5066161155700684,
-0.7848372459411621,
0.5611453056335449,
0.8854541778564453,
0.5992732048034668,
-0.3457462787628174,
0.018739843741059303,
-0.3738589286804199,
-0.0005424384726211429,
-0.17316584289073944,
0.8858512043952942,
-0.6444770693778992,
-0.4787706732749939,
0.010879991576075554,
-0.05533398687839508,
-0.054148100316524506,
-0.5077131986618042,
1.4696441888809204,
-0.1250779926776886,
-0.1480991244316101,
-0.05302806943655014,
-0.8888676166534424,
-0.2553677260875702,
0.26877257227897644,
-0.34701865911483765,
0.9979788661003113,
-0.03766646236181259,
-0.7103537321090698,
0.3194894790649414,
-0.4825960397720337,
-0.36638331413269043,
0.2754296362400055,
-0.30560752749443054,
-0.2586895823478699,
0.31905463337898254,
0.29280874133110046,
0.31181028485298157,
-0.46533724665641785,
0.4664733409881592,
-0.3036721348762512,
-0.6272043585777283,
0.7213945388793945,
-0.4869731068611145,
0.3918484151363373,
-0.15951617062091827,
-0.5741062164306641,
-0.04270477965474129,
-0.5799131989479065,
0.23431852459907532,
-0.2735937833786011,
-0.20686878263950348,
-0.19674211740493774,
0.18182796239852905,
-0.11821824312210083,
0.019781922921538353,
0.2039661407470703,
-0.36642175912857056,
0.03614043444395065,
-0.4244896173477173,
0.5435599684715271,
0.660534143447876,
0.12029774487018585,
0.32061266899108887,
0.09004451334476471,
0.4388551414012909,
-0.36721381545066833,
0.015167280100286007,
-0.6071726679801941,
-0.7044425010681152,
-0.9121283888816833,
-0.44541916251182556,
0.0584828145802021,
0.4027392268180847,
0.21258611977100372,
0.5241580009460449,
-0.2745949625968933,
-0.0960584431886673,
-0.49320507049560547,
0.1113218441605568,
0.44004637002944946,
0.43861910700798035,
0.3087413012981415,
-0.34997591376304626,
-0.5138317346572876,
-1.3058046102523804,
-0.6270692348480225,
-0.19423475861549377,
-0.09460768103599548,
0.668351411819458,
0.18540292978286743,
-0.10451624542474747,
0.9578135013580322,
-0.7095363140106201,
-0.0030637329909950495,
-0.44219207763671875,
0.42841637134552,
0.2740531265735626,
0.1314338743686676,
-0.00689147412776947,
-0.8023474216461182,
-0.4713985025882721,
-0.1812683641910553,
-0.3213947117328644,
-0.5360676050186157,
-0.040663622319698334,
-0.1998896598815918,
-0.3562779128551483,
0.5071096420288086,
-0.738806426525116,
0.5061039328575134,
0.3455458879470825,
-0.061298612505197525,
0.5749104619026184,
-0.0326944924890995,
0.17695477604866028,
-0.6152003407478333,
-0.03149249404668808,
0.20016592741012573,
-0.2718102037906647,
-0.6673958897590637,
-0.24002638459205627,
0.026694469153881073,
0.07648549228906631,
-0.24823647737503052,
0.5049628019332886,
-0.4178762435913086,
-0.4589383602142334,
-0.3419741690158844,
0.4168523848056793,
0.2206076681613922,
0.42568010091781616,
0.2674722671508789,
0.8238637447357178,
0.24611088633537292,
-0.35062652826309204,
-0.06621358543634415,
0.20032203197479248,
-0.5400012135505676,
0.4992341697216034,
-0.7963050603866577,
0.23209595680236816,
0.10517165064811707,
0.5386539697647095,
-1.187739372253418,
-0.3367516100406647,
0.049225375056266785,
-0.22096186876296997,
0.2935267984867096,
-0.5057684779167175,
-0.3545268177986145,
-0.33543887734413147,
-0.053284574300050735,
0.08889278024435043,
0.3846747577190399,
-0.1972123086452484,
0.4549561142921448,
0.32490473985671997,
-0.2819782793521881,
-0.6283823251724243,
-0.5181534886360168,
0.1554204672574997,
-0.310812383890152,
-0.655250072479248,
0.28931641578674316,
-0.027501286938786507,
-0.5408088564872742,
-0.3780045211315155,
-0.033785682171583176,
-0.3068159222602844,
0.43780821561813354,
0.5532658696174622,
0.14000074565410614,
-0.21657142043113708,
0.20538677275180817,
-0.22321373224258423,
-0.09080731123685837,
0.11229143291711807,
-0.3460199236869812,
0.21905896067619324,
-0.3736046850681305,
-0.3915514051914215,
-0.5490251779556274,
0.12587864696979523,
0.5373220443725586,
0.046161457896232605,
0.3028024137020111,
0.3296279311180115,
-0.07191310822963715,
0.0233615655452013,
-0.6554147601127625,
-0.28053969144821167,
-0.48694050312042236,
0.4088887572288513,
-0.22335578501224518,
-0.8609099388122559,
0.11768851429224014,
-0.35354235768318176,
-0.003951012156903744,
0.3480868637561798,
0.47166550159454346,
-0.10374598950147629,
1.1564249992370605,
0.4763944149017334,
-0.07056073844432831,
0.34794434905052185,
0.1861685961484909,
0.35081321001052856,
-0.9427657127380371,
0.37680554389953613,
-0.3559707701206207,
-0.29830214381217957,
-0.5078640580177307,
-0.4628489017486572,
0.26216423511505127,
0.1188112124800682,
0.1513136327266693,
0.14001047611236572,
-0.4525637924671173,
0.6184679865837097,
0.17702771723270416,
-0.13598063588142395,
0.5053691267967224,
-0.2137938141822815,
0.0035028578713536263,
-0.16468796133995056,
0.051104944199323654,
-0.9366833567619324,
0.8818289637565613,
0.6906835436820984,
0.6229802370071411,
-0.2863537669181824,
0.2896326184272766,
0.07419255375862122,
0.40705445408821106,
-0.975521445274353,
0.6402602195739746,
0.10769201815128326,
-0.8037367463111877,
-0.30428844690322876,
-0.05064509063959122,
-0.7095849514007568,
0.5215990543365479,
0.1554345190525055,
-1.1024457216262817,
-0.13025596737861633,
0.2314789891242981,
-0.30887371301651,
-0.14625602960586548,
-0.8886883854866028,
0.839028537273407,
-0.2880333662033081,
-0.3411378562450409,
-0.3566429615020752,
-0.6004114151000977,
0.4103817939758301,
0.24052979052066803,
0.20809905230998993,
-0.5871163606643677,
-0.06717142462730408,
0.41738465428352356,
-0.0892452746629715,
0.8870103359222412,
0.0357755646109581,
-0.02112291194498539,
0.3958156406879425,
-0.40650978684425354,
0.5601451992988586,
0.02595716528594494,
-0.14625553786754608,
-0.13441206514835358,
-0.6815342903137207,
-0.248125359416008,
-0.66959148645401,
0.4048103988170624,
-0.46278154850006104,
-0.8707162141799927,
-0.04730607196688652,
-0.6197633147239685,
-0.30119356513023376,
-0.0699157565832138,
-0.03702639788389206,
0.45684006810188293,
-0.5721924901008606,
0.1113433688879013,
0.630620539188385,
0.0041497801430523396,
0.09637878835201263,
0.5393484830856323,
0.01745498552918434,
-0.08153170347213745,
0.2845725417137146,
-0.10672523081302643,
0.4731927216053009,
0.41558653116226196,
0.21494150161743164,
-0.32695525884628296,
-0.7301919460296631,
-0.3275701105594635,
0.21928487718105316,
-0.92915278673172,
0.3399524986743927,
-1.1032156944274902,
0.020473530516028404,
-0.1579940915107727,
-0.3224807381629944,
-0.1116330698132515,
-0.5357620716094971,
-0.024009689688682556,
-0.42358073592185974,
0.29824578762054443,
0.6250680088996887,
0.2735571265220642,
0.4584721326828003,
-0.45243656635284424,
0.04614469036459923,
0.39455679059028625,
0.10135924816131592,
-0.32043302059173584,
-0.5309195518493652,
-0.19845367968082428,
-0.17981623113155365,
-0.48212945461273193,
-0.7118772268295288,
0.2022215873003006,
0.2296774685382843,
0.568095326423645,
0.8004642128944397,
-0.12311756610870361,
0.5138159394264221,
-0.5315836668014526,
0.8342724442481995,
-0.1264609694480896,
-1.0244084596633911,
0.43746280670166016,
-0.36188390851020813,
0.4112674295902252,
0.7209397554397583,
0.2108738124370575,
-0.5603931546211243,
-0.7653183937072754,
-0.7218958139419556,
-0.8692465424537659,
0.5918437838554382,
0.39930567145347595,
-0.004562661051750183,
-0.15050922334194183,
0.11850466579198837,
-0.13307315111160278,
0.3172277510166168,
-0.5625996589660645,
-0.16739708185195923,
0.25385960936546326,
-0.15933485329151154,
-0.15565693378448486,
-0.5093429684638977,
-0.12159750610589981,
0.007940788753330708,
0.3705933690071106,
-0.1347566545009613,
0.2601202428340912,
0.23201927542686462,
-0.4205678701400757,
-0.11118614673614502,
0.8076087236404419,
0.5931527614593506,
0.6381779313087463,
-0.4674829840660095,
0.20959267020225525,
0.4208873212337494,
-0.39319437742233276,
-0.03256208822131157,
0.2780899405479431,
-0.054863132536411285,
0.1200142502784729,
0.3075215816497803,
0.8417428731918335,
0.8335638046264648,
-0.7650933861732483,
0.6048430800437927,
0.022879505529999733,
0.04196746274828911,
-0.250301331281662,
-0.04615793004631996,
0.25145766139030457,
0.008335146121680737,
0.4397815763950348,
-0.34718093276023865,
0.6594010591506958,
-0.5900831818580627,
0.17283140122890472,
0.2880437970161438,
-0.611296534538269,
-0.36067017912864685,
0.37970128655433655,
0.63405442237854,
-0.03588341176509857,
0.324323832988739,
-0.0058675589971244335,
-1.0505614280700684,
0.7678386569023132,
0.31606951355934143,
1.2267711162567139,
-0.0497441366314888,
-0.12985578179359436,
0.39339718222618103,
0.32331669330596924,
0.006256793159991503,
0.20191644132137299,
-0.35623082518577576,
-0.6058369874954224,
-0.6744235157966614,
-0.41609930992126465,
-0.9539852738380432,
-0.06076034530997276,
-0.5809882283210754,
0.3212503492832184,
-0.2091355323791504,
-0.3663867115974426,
0.16728980839252472,
0.09855767339468002,
-0.5993959903717041,
0.14917722344398499,
0.40295448899269104,
0.7218005061149597,
-0.8780630826950073,
0.5519971251487732,
0.5514391660690308,
-0.09108642488718033,
-0.7677727937698364,
0.17398011684417725,
0.06230873242020607,
-0.7381606698036194,
0.858394205570221,
0.7495203614234924,
-0.29666852951049805,
-0.0628381073474884,
-0.526640772819519,
-0.5655896067619324,
0.6756188869476318,
0.07431557774543762,
-0.3495301306247711,
0.01847982034087181,
0.19461458921432495,
0.5373253226280212,
-0.4457012116909027,
1.000935673713684,
0.9283874034881592,
0.7662264108657837,
-0.19562628865242004,
-1.0407402515411377,
-0.1184135377407074,
0.019658181816339493,
-0.16049602627754211,
0.2567850649356842,
-0.5909788608551025,
0.710935115814209,
0.04729558899998665,
-0.33023348450660706,
0.031187713146209717,
0.6147416830062866,
-0.00019117996271234006,
0.20971578359603882,
0.5188044905662537,
0.4412311613559723,
0.71604984998703,
-0.26059529185295105,
1.1624560356140137,
-0.42893344163894653,
0.05188761651515961,
1.2416083812713623,
-0.3479793667793274,
0.6993348598480225,
0.27847614884376526,
-0.19924074411392212,
0.36594563722610474,
0.46495553851127625,
0.3341538608074188,
0.11156539618968964,
0.37839195132255554,
-0.40477895736694336,
-0.3855260908603668,
-0.4426248371601105,
-0.11589132249355316,
0.3526149392127991,
0.8874242305755615,
-0.6405546069145203,
-0.07287150621414185,
-0.4390201270580292,
0.0069915661588311195,
-0.026732750236988068,
-0.23386810719966888,
0.768108069896698,
0.5091975927352905,
-0.9813847541809082,
0.4957607686519623,
-0.25107741355895996,
0.4109644889831543,
-0.38653799891471863,
0.06475553661584854,
0.02608967199921608,
0.2853766083717346,
-0.14836588501930237,
-0.9010725617408752,
-0.05925668030977249,
0.02780737541615963,
-0.019119590520858765,
-0.2760990560054779,
0.8503496050834656,
-0.46303093433380127,
0.025090808048844337,
0.3486210107803345,
0.19362425804138184,
0.477825790643692,
-0.15484873950481415,
-0.5274359583854675,
0.21035102009773254,
-0.08999180048704147,
-0.23450356721878052,
0.07332731038331985,
0.45233526825904846,
0.02983909659087658,
0.5972588658332825,
0.2597813308238983,
-0.1417868733406067,
0.015027513727545738,
0.2306879311800003,
0.6849668622016907,
-0.4709782302379608,
-0.34735938906669617,
-0.827761709690094,
0.4201129078865051,
-0.4372229278087616,
-0.46553871035575867,
0.6835510730743408,
0.4315818250179291,
0.296953022480011,
0.34789371490478516,
0.8484076261520386,
0.3205527663230896,
0.6450731158256531,
-0.35439231991767883,
0.10453813523054123,
-0.12079285085201263,
0.059917449951171875,
-0.44285640120506287,
-0.9379996657371521,
-0.09583952277898788,
0.5405648946762085,
-0.7891321182250977,
-0.24699710309505463,
0.8025032877922058,
0.5698350667953491,
0.029736975207924843,
0.3266473710536957,
0.37284934520721436,
0.2716006934642792,
0.25905752182006836,
0.3532542586326599,
1.1929517984390259,
-0.07540365308523178,
0.7556042075157166,
0.03259783610701561,
-0.1505611687898636,
-0.6237012147903442,
-0.9780681133270264,
-0.9351266622543335,
0.004886248614639044,
-0.3503875732421875,
0.058857422322034836,
0.1293986737728119,
0.9535274505615234,
0.6452743411064148,
-0.563597559928894,
-0.1965905725955963,
-0.13927705585956573,
0.15104258060455322,
-0.10254406929016113,
-0.17843569815158844,
0.2049834281206131,
-0.5943594574928284,
-1.0870847702026367,
0.5502294898033142,
0.6511332988739014,
0.03170834109187126,
-0.06292669475078583,
0.08613890409469604,
0.0026746776420623064,
0.26703545451164246,
0.352486252784729,
0.19620026648044586,
-0.9792701601982117,
-0.35300055146217346,
-0.14256849884986877,
-0.2724265158176422,
0.39933672547340393,
1.0134005546569824,
-0.37039539217948914,
0.5467039942741394,
0.3381885588169098,
0.6223062872886658,
0.4912155866622925,
0.4141673743724823,
0.932925283908844,
-0.6460384726524353,
0.29974639415740967,
0.22154438495635986,
0.541649341583252,
0.44352462887763977,
-0.27365511655807495,
0.5908011198043823,
-0.14557161927223206,
-0.8666159510612488,
-0.5851843357086182,
0.2724086046218872,
-1.031611442565918,
0.0643359050154686,
1.4091532230377197,
-0.41319647431373596,
-0.0785999745130539,
-0.4857540428638458,
-0.4216298460960388,
0.08277354389429092,
-0.5946420431137085,
0.411151647567749,
0.9902515411376953,
0.028888722881674767,
-0.14365032315254211,
-0.8470788598060608,
0.6099358797073364,
0.7876604795455933,
-0.7620354890823364,
0.24414822459220886,
0.42088013887405396,
-0.16628074645996094,
0.07849325239658356,
0.7176234722137451,
0.04192912206053734,
0.1717076599597931,
-0.3780187666416168,
-0.07190202176570892,
0.6153869032859802,
0.09418173879384995,
-0.31606972217559814,
-0.10107245296239853,
0.5175262689590454,
-0.008129348047077656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11050v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11050v1 | A Peek into Token Bias: Large Language Models Are Not Yet Genuine Reasoners | 2024-06-16T19:22:53 | 2024-06-16T19:22:53 | Bowen Jiang, Yangxinyu Xie, Zhuoqun Hao, Xiaomeng Wang, Tanwi Mallick, Weijie J. Su, Camillo J. Taylor, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study introduces a hypothesis-testing framework to assess whether large
language models (LLMs) possess genuine reasoning abilities or primarily depend
on token bias. We go beyond evaluating LLMs on accuracy; rather, we aim to
investigate their token bias in solving logical reasoning tasks. Specifically,
we develop carefully controlled synthetic datasets, featuring conjunction
fallacy and syllogistic problems. Our framework outlines a list of hypotheses
where token biases are readily identifiable, with all null hypotheses assuming
genuine reasoning capabilities of LLMs. The findings in this study suggest,
with statistical guarantee, that most LLMs still struggle with logical
reasoning. While they may perform well on classic problems, their success
largely depends on recognizing superficial patterns with strong token bias,
thereby raising concerns about their actual reasoning and generalization
abilities. | [
-0.21891139447689056,
-0.8572227358818054,
1.004382610321045,
0.1830829381942749,
-0.13106034696102142,
0.056087926030159,
-0.13004624843597412,
-0.15841491520404816,
0.19198490679264069,
0.5241864919662476,
-0.58230060338974,
-0.21882323920726776,
-0.6717129349708557,
0.2370416224002838,
-0.5674058198928833,
0.7065302133560181,
0.0794890746474266,
0.4392487406730652,
-0.3736976981163025,
-0.16469739377498627,
-0.6713786125183105,
-0.7081078886985779,
-0.6760289072990417,
-0.44204598665237427,
0.37551435828208923,
0.21353061497211456,
0.5680174231529236,
0.3820815682411194,
0.30638715624809265,
0.2645902931690216,
-0.2747483253479004,
0.017299264669418335,
-0.29549548029899597,
0.031060652807354927,
-0.5479097366333008,
-0.8938031196594238,
-0.17348438501358032,
0.22729839384555817,
0.4397863745689392,
0.8081352114677429,
0.0984901413321495,
0.23304839432239532,
-0.3332669734954834,
0.40650421380996704,
-0.5025292038917542,
0.12119057029485703,
-0.9615100622177124,
0.01854032278060913,
-0.3135684132575989,
0.02424263209104538,
-0.8117668032646179,
-0.16115280985832214,
0.048535700887441635,
-0.3594164252281189,
0.3151552975177765,
0.5017103552818298,
0.6287999749183655,
0.33803460001945496,
-0.6407613754272461,
-0.1654156744480133,
-0.28996849060058594,
1.0251480340957642,
-1.0426490306854248,
0.4400395452976227,
0.3741089701652527,
0.19966711103916168,
-0.43038368225097656,
-0.4989475607872009,
-0.8793569207191467,
-0.4195672869682312,
-0.09248314797878265,
-0.23204712569713593,
-0.01111319474875927,
0.08730679005384445,
0.722670316696167,
0.27960404753685,
-0.38816073536872864,
0.08534155040979385,
-0.21114522218704224,
-0.6013725996017456,
0.2187487781047821,
0.1363152414560318,
0.34989866614341736,
-0.31247231364250183,
-0.3901822566986084,
0.20772990584373474,
-0.7762216925621033,
-0.06436800956726074,
0.36145496368408203,
0.1696491837501526,
-0.04272768273949623,
0.8811505436897278,
0.15125852823257446,
0.7883177995681763,
0.01631402224302292,
-0.31408464908599854,
0.05421463027596474,
-0.3692186772823334,
-0.2873866558074951,
0.11552564799785614,
0.5197364091873169,
0.2569310665130615,
0.36693307757377625,
-0.019922470673918724,
-0.41798409819602966,
0.35071584582328796,
-0.040346745401620865,
-0.5368677973747253,
-0.048644572496414185,
0.35202556848526,
-0.5945664644241333,
-0.13123869895935059,
0.12846730649471283,
-0.5300185680389404,
-0.488894522190094,
-0.4853793680667877,
0.3227136433124542,
-0.2602628171443939,
-0.28236016631126404,
0.22545678913593292,
-0.5952087044715881,
0.3314661979675293,
0.20541726052761078,
-0.7164636850357056,
0.16958443820476532,
1.0482932329177856,
0.7817776799201965,
-0.46522778272628784,
-0.12415026873350143,
-0.7344474196434021,
-0.22997303307056427,
-0.5872476696968079,
0.8088637590408325,
-0.596381664276123,
-0.27737724781036377,
-0.01904716156423092,
0.08026266098022461,
-0.2178589254617691,
-0.5980277061462402,
0.8217973113059998,
-0.40614941716194153,
0.2737085223197937,
-0.7445570826530457,
-0.6526780128479004,
0.19351929426193237,
0.45186543464660645,
-0.6124757528305054,
0.7529296278953552,
0.1693042367696762,
-1.1304271221160889,
0.7555914521217346,
-0.4117407500743866,
-0.4675762951374054,
-0.2724997103214264,
-0.5030384659767151,
-0.07491135597229004,
0.2375517338514328,
0.10997289419174194,
0.11612332612276077,
-0.5340591669082642,
0.48863857984542847,
-0.5201314687728882,
-0.4504987299442291,
0.6503317952156067,
-0.50636887550354,
0.9608488082885742,
0.03075491078197956,
-0.6381857991218567,
0.18901567161083221,
-0.6397240161895752,
-0.2425634264945984,
0.09207715094089508,
-0.2107364982366562,
-0.27215903997421265,
0.225397527217865,
-0.08737444877624512,
0.38390669226646423,
0.05922422185540199,
-0.6622011065483093,
0.3599780201911926,
-0.42746785283088684,
0.5649883151054382,
1.1985501050949097,
-0.2918927073478699,
0.2548571527004242,
-0.25633808970451355,
0.5085113048553467,
0.351148396730423,
0.08509615063667297,
-0.029454305768013,
-0.5632066130638123,
-1.1746898889541626,
-0.37500298023223877,
0.41001057624816895,
0.27893707156181335,
-0.7901564836502075,
0.4444568157196045,
-0.12404762208461761,
-0.06074925512075424,
-0.25440752506256104,
0.048711977899074554,
0.4051186442375183,
0.661871075630188,
0.07004685699939728,
-0.1958152949810028,
-0.5063609480857849,
-1.2025151252746582,
-0.46296191215515137,
-0.373640239238739,
0.026177043095231056,
0.17997434735298157,
0.7404492497444153,
-0.2666758596897125,
1.0995066165924072,
-0.20829738676548004,
-0.08342291414737701,
-0.38973137736320496,
-0.232216477394104,
0.48160696029663086,
0.2753030061721802,
0.42075207829475403,
-0.713472843170166,
0.11808103322982788,
-0.2687465250492096,
-0.6760045886039734,
-0.19652411341667175,
-0.01638992317020893,
0.01584473066031933,
0.4569164216518402,
0.5482076406478882,
-1.030982255935669,
0.4298570454120636,
0.4325011074542999,
-0.8549943566322327,
0.8432579040527344,
0.19829243421554565,
-0.19227512180805206,
-0.7675658464431763,
0.09846705198287964,
0.09614069014787674,
-0.01700829714536667,
-0.32124441862106323,
-0.14938294887542725,
-0.09505023062229156,
0.23627878725528717,
-0.24485458433628082,
0.9086529016494751,
-0.27232590317726135,
-0.19803732633590698,
-0.18368284404277802,
-0.06614307314157486,
0.08547753840684891,
0.09364601224660873,
-0.09930171072483063,
0.7750799655914307,
0.5382720232009888,
-0.3999910354614258,
0.30517104268074036,
0.05485789105296135,
-0.34646111726760864,
0.6194164752960205,
-0.7155012488365173,
0.08339670300483704,
-0.15109017491340637,
0.46112582087516785,
-1.0253775119781494,
-0.318114310503006,
0.18929600715637207,
-0.3674878180027008,
0.05165587365627289,
-0.19940347969532013,
-0.7020479440689087,
-0.5789093375205994,
-0.15760362148284912,
0.32282623648643494,
0.48378482460975647,
-0.6379799842834473,
0.6162654757499695,
0.2162727415561676,
0.165914848446846,
-0.7806978225708008,
-0.7826922535896301,
-0.023827042430639267,
-0.3610025942325592,
-0.4940776228904724,
-0.08623701333999634,
0.06961514055728912,
-0.767716109752655,
-0.19811077415943146,
-0.4040040969848633,
0.15067297220230103,
-0.04207532852888107,
0.09605562686920166,
0.4088926315307617,
-0.21027719974517822,
0.20843331515789032,
-0.1606995314359665,
-0.18030685186386108,
0.4676333963871002,
-0.6722302436828613,
0.5839825868606567,
0.1152782216668129,
-0.750334620475769,
-0.22334593534469604,
-0.06669497489929199,
0.7735567688941956,
-0.12956121563911438,
0.7008838057518005,
0.3110661208629608,
-0.2642972469329834,
-0.4037799835205078,
-0.9929827451705933,
-0.4063340127468109,
-0.43604448437690735,
0.17079539597034454,
-0.4659062922000885,
-1.0259848833084106,
0.707958996295929,
0.18110091984272003,
-0.12686768174171448,
0.42138853669166565,
0.6352283358573914,
0.3491278290748596,
1.1770931482315063,
0.2650754451751709,
-0.180540531873703,
0.04866699129343033,
0.011556126177310944,
0.5100047588348389,
-0.5983179211616516,
-0.27504783868789673,
-0.5395129919052124,
-0.07422439754009247,
-0.5867319703102112,
-0.5807771682739258,
0.07860121876001358,
-0.15849848091602325,
-0.348567932844162,
-0.07373209297657013,
-0.23939162492752075,
0.5119361877441406,
0.5137794613838196,
-0.12163811177015305,
0.22574569284915924,
-0.260702520608902,
-0.39723461866378784,
0.018286464735865593,
-0.7326509952545166,
-0.5350757241249084,
1.1219381093978882,
0.39718616008758545,
0.5805079340934753,
-0.06946247816085815,
0.09649785608053207,
0.2201477438211441,
0.27505820989608765,
-0.8619637489318848,
0.6068958044052124,
0.1538822054862976,
-0.9881640672683716,
-0.16931280493736267,
-0.5638827085494995,
-0.6800481677055359,
0.29708075523376465,
0.07054122537374496,
-0.7351723909378052,
0.23552320897579193,
0.2708888351917267,
0.1758030354976654,
0.4346311092376709,
-0.6476567983627319,
0.8563491106033325,
-0.17485184967517853,
-0.3195505440235138,
0.057345110923051834,
-0.5881627798080444,
0.6727709174156189,
-0.17958469688892365,
0.41793709993362427,
-0.1991964727640152,
0.05623726174235344,
0.7946655750274658,
-0.5671118497848511,
0.8231716156005859,
-0.20054784417152405,
-0.22684361040592194,
0.33546367287635803,
0.2594563961029053,
0.38154664635658264,
0.10831326991319656,
-0.3315129280090332,
0.1085890531539917,
0.1073354110121727,
-0.8424072265625,
-0.6402776837348938,
0.6054246425628662,
-0.5185864567756653,
-0.9068886637687683,
-0.580765962600708,
-0.3220422565937042,
-0.4408082067966461,
0.34140250086784363,
0.10866464674472809,
0.36699190735816956,
-0.04262307286262512,
0.10926146805286407,
0.578257143497467,
-0.06566966325044632,
0.15800140798091888,
0.2749191224575043,
-0.44932281970977783,
-0.1711306869983673,
0.690935492515564,
0.036992721259593964,
0.40198972821235657,
0.0396050326526165,
0.44869598746299744,
-0.434513121843338,
-0.6249504685401917,
-0.4260367751121521,
0.2956749498844147,
-0.8817276954650879,
0.023736922070384026,
-0.24459588527679443,
-0.04642585664987564,
-0.3694227337837219,
0.08244234323501587,
-0.15970373153686523,
-0.34715795516967773,
0.025925008580088615,
-0.2942551076412201,
0.019842084497213364,
0.6524145603179932,
0.20936934649944305,
0.017578527331352234,
-0.2517985999584198,
0.210387721657753,
0.3371606469154358,
0.16304658353328705,
0.01903117075562477,
-0.6457656621932983,
0.17343299090862274,
-0.17534497380256653,
0.09080825001001358,
-0.6707687377929688,
0.12375220656394958,
-0.28386354446411133,
0.5783807635307312,
0.6757794618606567,
-0.09982534497976303,
0.36206570267677307,
-0.4296322762966156,
0.9245835542678833,
0.22900083661079407,
-1.1166325807571411,
0.4392727315425873,
-0.4835461676120758,
0.03212464973330498,
0.4320797920227051,
0.2016819715499878,
-0.2548653483390808,
-0.22513611614704132,
-0.6311063766479492,
-0.4303770065307617,
0.5038757920265198,
0.07894979417324066,
0.1771482676267624,
-0.38875719904899597,
0.4564893841743469,
0.1323591023683548,
0.33048221468925476,
-0.706719160079956,
-0.21707449853420258,
-0.09701769798994064,
-0.11857052892446518,
-0.08034618943929672,
-0.36479124426841736,
-0.21234145760536194,
-0.3738766610622406,
0.35626640915870667,
-0.3882856070995331,
0.025057902559638023,
0.2661280333995819,
0.07281048595905304,
-0.02711944468319416,
0.2915615737438202,
0.5105351805686951,
1.107359528541565,
-0.012023087590932846,
0.5176509022712708,
0.15917283296585083,
-0.30670684576034546,
0.2429584115743637,
-0.16260407865047455,
-0.2240075320005417,
0.05221157521009445,
0.720785915851593,
0.7764589190483093,
0.023739656433463097,
-1.0558675527572632,
0.8156864643096924,
0.02769971825182438,
-0.26067543029785156,
-0.4342704117298126,
0.012396288104355335,
0.1027102991938591,
0.005469185765832663,
0.43344825506210327,
0.06676571071147919,
0.06469079107046127,
-0.8382344841957092,
0.05955604836344719,
0.7217219471931458,
-0.3324642777442932,
-0.38409700989723206,
0.5191279649734497,
0.04664144292473793,
-0.2458503544330597,
0.7025076746940613,
-0.1300271451473236,
-0.7547631859779358,
0.6893566250801086,
0.7736462354660034,
0.4854598045349121,
0.17671772837638855,
-0.04365667700767517,
0.03900354355573654,
0.4756680428981781,
-0.22652322053909302,
0.1665986180305481,
0.25968673825263977,
-0.9842840433120728,
-0.6913902163505554,
-0.5548004508018494,
-0.38729149103164673,
0.14678381383419037,
-0.37492871284484863,
0.3743683099746704,
-0.5405365228652954,
-0.37097686529159546,
-0.08046288788318634,
-0.215000718832016,
-0.5584506392478943,
0.27982524037361145,
-0.0012316809734329581,
1.2231389284133911,
-0.879871666431427,
0.6499714255332947,
0.5558328032493591,
-0.29196467995643616,
-0.7466180324554443,
0.11901235580444336,
0.11084747314453125,
-0.9022490978240967,
0.9562695026397705,
0.36489319801330566,
0.09952918440103531,
-0.3248405456542969,
-0.6770341992378235,
-0.668635368347168,
0.7414919137954712,
0.6975680589675903,
-0.5141128301620483,
-0.23843593895435333,
0.18617528676986694,
0.331307977437973,
-0.2276572734117508,
0.2898796796798706,
0.844489336013794,
0.6972358822822571,
0.2063545137643814,
-1.0174247026443481,
0.11456339061260223,
-0.1177426427602768,
-0.21187886595726013,
0.09785054624080658,
-0.7604151964187622,
0.9340304136276245,
-0.15482866764068604,
0.13259084522724152,
-0.2038063406944275,
0.4427517354488373,
0.6529640555381775,
0.4933817386627197,
0.7330561876296997,
0.7976679801940918,
0.7273845076560974,
-0.25040388107299805,
1.0474984645843506,
-0.15315799415111542,
0.13284462690353394,
0.782258152961731,
-0.5772517323493958,
0.6573147177696228,
0.9302424788475037,
-0.18615518510341644,
0.49952828884124756,
0.5538305640220642,
0.08045893907546997,
0.0832095667719841,
0.639326810836792,
-0.12912489473819733,
-0.6849260926246643,
-0.20926716923713684,
-0.09624502062797546,
0.5186611413955688,
0.3336560130119324,
-0.3730451464653015,
0.23154836893081665,
-0.09711422771215439,
0.17080676555633545,
-0.06681078672409058,
-0.22172202169895172,
0.3781554400920868,
0.310452938079834,
-0.862556517124176,
0.21795955300331116,
-0.007993083447217941,
0.7361646890640259,
-0.35302942991256714,
-0.008349829353392124,
-0.27417683601379395,
0.1812705546617508,
-0.21277835965156555,
-0.47933799028396606,
0.13152045011520386,
-0.10001008957624435,
-0.058744024485349655,
0.15182992815971375,
0.9191888570785522,
0.17551976442337036,
-0.5584179759025574,
0.1898828148841858,
0.6768462061882019,
0.016783127561211586,
0.030810309574007988,
-0.5530340671539307,
0.3657379150390625,
0.037977829575538635,
-0.33139705657958984,
0.278621643781662,
0.5832776427268982,
-0.25905996561050415,
0.8410619497299194,
0.9127325415611267,
0.2346174269914627,
0.08554454147815704,
0.2242959439754486,
0.9024175405502319,
-0.6251546740531921,
-0.24921467900276184,
-1.2444401979446411,
0.35183432698249817,
-0.23575109243392944,
-0.3150000274181366,
0.937422513961792,
0.7189018130302429,
0.6594131588935852,
-0.03477667272090912,
0.770609974861145,
0.18838535249233246,
0.47058168053627014,
-0.7579858899116516,
0.4744258522987366,
-0.3618204891681671,
0.20963767170906067,
-0.12401722371578217,
-0.9041721820831299,
-0.1985902339220047,
0.7113059163093567,
-0.5865132212638855,
0.14362256228923798,
0.8044974207878113,
0.708311140537262,
-0.1658366173505783,
-0.043597158044576645,
0.2183527797460556,
0.33586493134498596,
0.3804992735385895,
0.4076913595199585,
1.178931474685669,
-0.13274389505386353,
0.09824980795383453,
0.2111893892288208,
-0.16615714132785797,
-0.14026814699172974,
-0.9582590460777283,
-1.4982637166976929,
-0.2695142328739166,
-0.07323120534420013,
-0.6236292123794556,
0.04465557262301445,
0.9640317559242249,
0.6597942113876343,
-0.8861954808235168,
0.024676844477653503,
-0.33520030975341797,
0.46704915165901184,
0.37761110067367554,
-0.2736453413963318,
0.3436765968799591,
-0.43544983863830566,
-0.5761733651161194,
0.27991876006126404,
0.15897497534751892,
-0.1625324934720993,
-0.542210042476654,
0.09221827238798141,
0.15582770109176636,
0.43470802903175354,
0.5405576229095459,
-0.050991449505090714,
-1.115735650062561,
-0.5205416679382324,
0.2126636803150177,
0.02414853498339653,
-0.10380040854215622,
1.0862157344818115,
-0.723542332649231,
0.31654730439186096,
0.4963635206222534,
0.5612710118293762,
0.13210687041282654,
-0.08499240130186081,
0.5484463572502136,
-0.3083975911140442,
0.4078991413116455,
0.21031107008457184,
0.6805249452590942,
0.25843390822410583,
0.03478173166513443,
0.3831476867198944,
0.6509143710136414,
-0.5167936682701111,
-1.138559103012085,
0.31693610548973083,
-0.9555006623268127,
-0.28944897651672363,
1.3598084449768066,
-0.026287948712706566,
-0.31692561507225037,
-0.13824956119060516,
-0.36207112669944763,
-0.08878352493047714,
-0.08419095724821091,
0.6789518594741821,
0.9311188459396362,
-0.0317256934940815,
0.11207933723926544,
-0.6420352458953857,
0.4656780958175659,
0.6762523055076599,
-0.5498590469360352,
0.01911301724612713,
0.5935110449790955,
0.47705087065696716,
0.10255134850740433,
0.6631768345832825,
-0.11268562823534012,
0.13308089971542358,
0.1287301778793335,
-0.38792330026626587,
0.1971299797296524,
-0.14790621399879456,
-0.16263176500797272,
-0.05741743743419647,
0.47771769762039185,
0.3467433750629425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11049v1 | Reconsidering Sentence-Level Sign Language Translation | 2024-06-16T19:19:54 | 2024-06-16T19:19:54 | Garrett Tanzer, Maximus Shengelia, Ken Harrenstien, David Uthus | cs.CL | cs.CL | Historically, sign language machine translation has been posed as a
sentence-level task: datasets consisting of continuous narratives are chopped
up and presented to the model as isolated clips. In this work, we explore the
limitations of this task framing. First, we survey a number of linguistic
phenomena in sign languages that depend on discourse-level context. Then as a
case study, we perform the first human baseline for sign language translation
that actually substitutes a human into the machine learning task framing,
rather than provide the human with the entire document as context. This human
baseline -- for ASL to English translation on the How2Sign dataset -- shows
that for 33% of sentences in our sample, our fluent Deaf signer annotators were
only able to understand key parts of the clip in light of additional
discourse-level context. These results underscore the importance of
understanding and sanity checking examples when adapting machine learning to
new domains. | [
0.12635621428489685,
-0.3493473529815674,
0.40678903460502625,
0.11109180003404617,
-0.3569332957267761,
-0.028862928971648216,
0.08642826974391937,
-0.5110617280006409,
-0.27169913053512573,
0.7049849629402161,
-0.5581212043762207,
-0.5769226551055908,
-1.0795477628707886,
0.42277467250823975,
-0.4375251531600952,
1.1103477478027344,
-0.3261675536632538,
-0.14386630058288574,
0.016772901639342308,
-0.2712310254573822,
-0.6296245455741882,
-0.41413626074790955,
-0.7077429294586182,
-0.15375065803527832,
-0.22863879799842834,
0.41625601053237915,
0.7498471140861511,
0.5834575891494751,
0.3463008403778076,
0.22267629206180573,
-0.015394939109683037,
-0.10228433459997177,
-0.26455873250961304,
0.08159304410219193,
0.15055470168590546,
-0.3909847140312195,
-0.44756293296813965,
0.2569829225540161,
0.7010489106178284,
1.0552325248718262,
0.4791165590286255,
0.0528658889234066,
0.06604280322790146,
0.42486992478370667,
-0.366240918636322,
0.3452930450439453,
-0.5110454559326172,
0.30908650159835815,
-0.24590913951396942,
0.10175412893295288,
-0.5988883376121521,
0.10084688663482666,
0.05877052992582321,
-0.6292605400085449,
0.290747731924057,
0.228113055229187,
0.8759222626686096,
0.6407026052474976,
-1.00663161277771,
-0.29477864503860474,
-0.5299462676048279,
0.6434165239334106,
-0.8042154908180237,
0.2759152948856354,
0.4967363774776459,
0.07777400314807892,
-0.052188679575920105,
-0.4977114498615265,
-0.32765042781829834,
-0.13242918252944946,
-0.33937281370162964,
-0.06833112984895706,
-0.3008050322532654,
0.13636061549186707,
0.5795252919197083,
0.12622083723545074,
-0.480639785528183,
0.07547487318515778,
-0.6466889381408691,
-0.35537153482437134,
0.5308674573898315,
0.18440650403499603,
0.5205230712890625,
-0.5651220679283142,
-0.5793628096580505,
-0.012486978434026241,
-0.5378028154373169,
0.2187262922525406,
-0.0789455845952034,
0.43774276971817017,
-0.048746608197689056,
0.5906433463096619,
-0.0188922006636858,
0.9138475060462952,
0.004437151364982128,
-0.06210890784859657,
0.19790376722812653,
-0.3635328412055969,
-0.081688791513443,
-0.06980444490909576,
0.7102823853492737,
0.3857256770133972,
0.23298892378807068,
0.11604663729667664,
-0.26667946577072144,
-0.09744567424058914,
0.10937836021184921,
-0.5501956939697266,
0.01064133271574974,
0.09860162436962128,
-0.19441568851470947,
0.24518688023090363,
-0.0017962099518626928,
0.031168315559625626,
-0.29912683367729187,
-0.19881555438041687,
0.25290945172309875,
-0.40404611825942993,
-0.00448565324768424,
0.21656328439712524,
-0.09544995427131653,
0.15221330523490906,
0.27319929003715515,
-0.5519087910652161,
0.3792244791984558,
0.7215539216995239,
0.730981171131134,
-0.2559203803539276,
-0.34592241048812866,
-0.649451732635498,
0.042838793247938156,
-0.2676727771759033,
0.3556271493434906,
-0.3278941810131073,
-0.35799604654312134,
-0.10719916969537735,
0.10342065244913101,
-0.18020261824131012,
-0.3655868470668793,
0.5424813628196716,
-0.3171180188655853,
0.4644777178764343,
-0.11358862370252609,
-0.6270987391471863,
0.03249456733465195,
-0.17163382470607758,
-0.3829633891582489,
0.6626800894737244,
0.24443094432353973,
-0.3488384783267975,
0.6898158192634583,
-0.5034657716751099,
-1.09661066532135,
0.023538071662187576,
-0.0854683667421341,
-0.4640202820301056,
0.09380083531141281,
0.26878148317337036,
0.490673691034317,
0.13272038102149963,
0.2033286839723587,
0.2440444976091385,
-0.32565420866012573,
0.3444421589374542,
-0.1002674400806427,
1.11959707736969,
0.3086414635181427,
-0.5260223746299744,
-0.02209356240928173,
-0.5810837745666504,
-0.2817825376987457,
-0.226297527551651,
-0.15400834381580353,
-0.2576465308666229,
-0.1712796837091446,
0.13698476552963257,
0.4339253306388855,
-0.0534072145819664,
-0.6032953858375549,
-0.1567145437002182,
-0.28932031989097595,
0.7173461318016052,
0.3859586715698242,
0.0872679278254509,
0.3897048830986023,
0.050693579018116,
0.6842992901802063,
0.10258841514587402,
-0.04907246306538582,
-0.4314166009426117,
-0.6931247711181641,
-0.612569272518158,
-0.21929261088371277,
0.10248247534036636,
0.5215508341789246,
-0.5288387537002563,
0.4086240231990814,
-0.15536057949066162,
0.2805156111717224,
-0.7773638963699341,
0.008942965418100357,
0.8237627148628235,
0.5877081751823425,
0.45743119716644287,
-0.4475308358669281,
-0.546499490737915,
-0.8407998085021973,
-0.43091732263565063,
-0.3256976008415222,
-0.24914930760860443,
-0.12013353407382965,
0.5609152317047119,
0.32631227374076843,
0.8560003638267517,
-0.3040045499801636,
-0.6089152097702026,
-0.1489114761352539,
0.15692874789237976,
0.10651474446058273,
0.6556562781333923,
0.23309123516082764,
-0.8603068590164185,
-0.424866646528244,
-0.147671639919281,
-0.7878947854042053,
-0.15228135883808136,
-0.6513028740882874,
0.2854153513908386,
0.1176287978887558,
0.8414206504821777,
-0.584659218788147,
0.6017147898674011,
0.6284244656562805,
-0.8177170157432556,
0.1951606720685959,
-0.20738524198532104,
0.32831907272338867,
-1.1045855283737183,
0.13188683986663818,
-0.016678791493177414,
-0.5997036695480347,
-0.7018987536430359,
0.028255818411707878,
0.11982591450214386,
-0.5465176105499268,
-0.46844053268432617,
0.415973424911499,
-0.7538629770278931,
-0.5148879289627075,
-0.4970094561576843,
0.4702550768852234,
0.10965801775455475,
0.36155205965042114,
-0.11340270936489105,
0.7640962600708008,
0.3713795244693756,
-0.41994693875312805,
-0.14982813596725464,
0.7467407584190369,
-0.282916784286499,
0.8531744480133057,
-0.6345726251602173,
0.19697722792625427,
-0.13459761440753937,
0.42637699842453003,
-1.0073601007461548,
-0.38895905017852783,
0.525215208530426,
-0.5851879119873047,
0.36660319566726685,
-0.09029503911733627,
-0.1988402009010315,
-0.31352534890174866,
0.1309603899717331,
0.4093019962310791,
0.6895781755447388,
-0.08322746306657791,
0.2150977998971939,
0.5031622052192688,
0.13619199395179749,
-0.26382359862327576,
-0.9467043280601501,
0.6241490244865417,
-0.19799615442752838,
-0.5632818937301636,
0.1332063525915146,
0.29197806119918823,
-0.28363266587257385,
-0.09025973081588745,
-0.339866042137146,
-0.1113574281334877,
0.41503721475601196,
0.3656957447528839,
-0.011140324175357819,
-0.2921421229839325,
-0.14204448461532593,
0.20925970375537872,
-0.3986646831035614,
0.020324552431702614,
-0.45240136981010437,
-0.2171030193567276,
-0.03229011222720146,
-0.5925447940826416,
-0.8640073537826538,
0.41963517665863037,
0.4709658920764923,
0.019882868975400925,
0.6220130920410156,
0.29202067852020264,
-0.4525516629219055,
0.04961578920483589,
-0.004271115642040968,
0.006735103204846382,
-0.38266947865486145,
0.3816181421279907,
-0.6880847811698914,
-1.1953617334365845,
0.22304241359233856,
0.22086814045906067,
0.30788061022758484,
0.4752219021320343,
0.31141358613967896,
-0.30252352356910706,
0.8139155507087708,
0.41640669107437134,
0.17844289541244507,
0.30907461047172546,
0.18540778756141663,
0.3483220338821411,
-0.9303185939788818,
0.023092452436685562,
-0.4200039505958557,
-0.4478442072868347,
-0.2345343381166458,
-0.5005030632019043,
0.5468788146972656,
0.3412312865257263,
0.10170502215623856,
1.126149296760559,
-0.3370993435382843,
0.2933819890022278,
0.12331279367208481,
0.10551736503839493,
0.6078588366508484,
-0.3891627788543701,
0.32924216985702515,
-0.23939161002635956,
-0.5140135884284973,
-0.6457560658454895,
0.8637791872024536,
0.30267852544784546,
0.12103424221277237,
-0.0461953729391098,
0.49498143792152405,
0.4587463438510895,
0.23112426698207855,
-0.5205937027931213,
0.6776877641677856,
-0.21340714395046234,
-0.7815296649932861,
-0.5909491181373596,
-0.296968936920166,
-1.187833547592163,
0.4647596478462219,
0.04260356351733208,
-0.641967236995697,
-0.005627263803035021,
0.36320292949676514,
-0.14226722717285156,
0.051101215183734894,
-0.8445466160774231,
1.200145959854126,
-0.25077420473098755,
0.16304700076580048,
0.031017154455184937,
-0.9980977177619934,
0.27518412470817566,
-0.04856153205037117,
0.4263799786567688,
-0.3068796396255493,
-0.23127032816410065,
0.574098527431488,
-0.48112255334854126,
1.2731971740722656,
-0.08825792372226715,
-0.2185308188199997,
0.19823187589645386,
0.13426950573921204,
0.39720025658607483,
-0.19488772749900818,
-0.12667691707611084,
-0.08133414387702942,
-0.08019804954528809,
-0.8648762106895447,
-0.4109137952327728,
0.04268040508031845,
-0.5619295239448547,
-0.8751463890075684,
-0.2847725749015808,
-0.6369696259498596,
-0.3578854203224182,
0.1472434550523758,
0.34192347526550293,
0.3255191147327423,
-0.22140765190124512,
-0.0122196851298213,
0.3275262117385864,
0.13032953441143036,
0.17215611040592194,
0.36966681480407715,
-0.004663332365453243,
-0.027653764933347702,
0.7140386700630188,
-0.18613004684448242,
0.5806519389152527,
0.3618791401386261,
-0.013359148986637592,
-0.049292370676994324,
-0.8542923331260681,
-0.8079404234886169,
0.06391306966543198,
-0.7730302214622498,
0.17678618431091309,
-0.4733971059322357,
0.07520337402820587,
-0.5349330902099609,
-0.2239362597465515,
-0.07856716215610504,
-0.5846138596534729,
-0.5166276097297668,
-0.22163309156894684,
0.09522715955972672,
0.5940386056900024,
0.07709881663322449,
0.10481282323598862,
-0.5928925275802612,
0.29156941175460815,
-0.029932362958788872,
-0.22970950603485107,
-0.4138582646846771,
-0.8432749509811401,
-0.1605650633573532,
-0.056540247052907944,
0.014620069414377213,
-0.7559106945991516,
-0.14119189977645874,
0.4183492660522461,
0.21323223412036896,
0.31166961789131165,
0.3400859236717224,
0.6707566380500793,
-0.5842515230178833,
0.9948385953903198,
0.4649026691913605,
-1.116646409034729,
0.5052671432495117,
-0.3228490948677063,
0.6707203388214111,
0.4642467200756073,
0.40075382590293884,
-0.9129058718681335,
-0.8661746978759766,
-0.3308546543121338,
-0.8121172189712524,
0.7098882794380188,
0.5198419094085693,
0.30402982234954834,
0.017138496041297913,
0.35923460125923157,
0.2685055732727051,
0.1488059163093567,
-0.7749245166778564,
-0.11317294090986252,
-0.17706771194934845,
-0.21621261537075043,
-0.24500375986099243,
0.0753159373998642,
-0.010690897703170776,
-0.17452289164066315,
0.3359188735485077,
-0.23478636145591736,
-0.05821163207292557,
0.04350317642092705,
-0.6542729735374451,
-0.07491970807313919,
0.28779640793800354,
0.6249026656150818,
0.537855863571167,
0.3260592520236969,
0.2177634984254837,
0.2966477572917938,
-0.18282195925712585,
0.16948728263378143,
-0.08615655452013016,
-0.5916778445243835,
0.10815709829330444,
0.8696330189704895,
1.2452446222305298,
0.7107189893722534,
-0.6571435332298279,
0.5272859334945679,
0.47202160954475403,
-0.2991901934146881,
-0.053205665200948715,
-0.0641799122095108,
0.031076159328222275,
0.07132662087678909,
0.2093232423067093,
0.20834816992282867,
0.00548143032938242,
-0.666344165802002,
0.47014370560646057,
0.20878295600414276,
-0.7565279603004456,
-0.494854599237442,
0.9139419198036194,
0.28929170966148376,
-0.6788551807403564,
0.4241373538970947,
-0.094492606818676,
-0.7060754299163818,
0.4002946615219116,
0.5329799056053162,
0.8488039374351501,
0.018914468586444855,
0.4040314853191376,
0.2338525950908661,
0.43434321880340576,
-0.023753687739372253,
-0.10617362707853317,
-0.2590365409851074,
-0.4235931932926178,
-0.5702749490737915,
-0.27340489625930786,
-0.4291488528251648,
-0.2862418293952942,
-0.6645168662071228,
0.11263812333345413,
-0.1720276027917862,
-0.24982082843780518,
-0.10549606382846832,
-0.44236189126968384,
-0.46165549755096436,
0.1952592134475708,
0.2822578549385071,
0.7097336649894714,
-1.086991548538208,
0.6589377522468567,
0.6279308199882507,
-0.43004289269447327,
-0.4123082756996155,
0.28395652770996094,
0.09027989953756332,
-0.6914930939674377,
0.5917404890060425,
0.05463062971830368,
-0.18412022292613983,
0.08424393832683563,
-0.1976763755083084,
-0.7394338846206665,
0.6849130392074585,
0.3444846272468567,
-0.06913738697767258,
-0.13443586230278015,
0.40839511156082153,
0.7169322371482849,
-0.423617422580719,
-0.39250847697257996,
0.6547194123268127,
0.40089529752731323,
0.027063747867941856,
-1.0649394989013672,
0.36319512128829956,
0.03690203279256821,
0.183088481426239,
0.09980356693267822,
-0.4369259774684906,
0.6395885944366455,
-0.26518675684928894,
-0.5728530287742615,
0.052137795835733414,
0.9554663300514221,
-0.1614198237657547,
0.39257413148880005,
0.49178123474121094,
0.18826335668563843,
0.6093606352806091,
0.07591215521097183,
0.9952986240386963,
-0.011155176907777786,
0.1534203737974167,
1.1164988279342651,
-0.3184373676776886,
0.7694958448410034,
0.5968413352966309,
-0.24595393240451813,
0.3309963345527649,
0.490581214427948,
0.11163254082202911,
0.09103135764598846,
0.1557154357433319,
-0.08192874491214752,
-0.3659696877002716,
0.10784149169921875,
-0.015763510018587112,
0.3378048837184906,
0.09080395102500916,
-0.24217069149017334,
-0.20947176218032837,
0.4249385893344879,
0.22573699057102203,
0.5152233839035034,
-0.0587334930896759,
0.5630703568458557,
0.46149495244026184,
-0.8037932515144348,
0.6095595359802246,
0.061605054885149,
0.31212276220321655,
-0.2715587913990021,
0.23593227565288544,
-0.14913016557693481,
0.03380800783634186,
-0.14805008471012115,
-0.8635925054550171,
0.6277398467063904,
0.1788972169160843,
0.023073993623256683,
-0.9179700613021851,
0.4517020881175995,
-0.40962252020835876,
-0.37990641593933105,
-0.07398978620767593,
0.4331957995891571,
0.5387741923332214,
0.15368898212909698,
-0.7509538531303406,
0.13974899053573608,
0.062186673283576965,
-0.2371288686990738,
0.3418081998825073,
0.6248344779014587,
-0.19075970351696014,
0.6027860045433044,
0.3171507716178894,
-0.3054632544517517,
0.08076547086238861,
-0.199773907661438,
0.4632844626903534,
-0.6338990926742554,
-0.6131496429443359,
-0.544871985912323,
0.6577672362327576,
-0.045672956854104996,
-0.8130363821983337,
0.9267264604568481,
0.5114786624908447,
0.9497507810592651,
-0.07865437120199203,
0.668415367603302,
-0.1392536461353302,
0.20183789730072021,
-0.6690934300422668,
0.5169184803962708,
-0.5462325811386108,
0.06119534373283386,
-0.26317474246025085,
-0.4376964569091797,
-0.5058169364929199,
0.5021843314170837,
-0.3281247615814209,
-0.29385873675346375,
1.0092962980270386,
0.3927270770072937,
0.07804083824157715,
0.024423817172646523,
0.5906378030776978,
0.027760246768593788,
0.08524756878614426,
0.7800518274307251,
0.4392896890640259,
-0.7731487154960632,
0.7947604656219482,
0.3602694869041443,
-0.14658936858177185,
-0.1655733287334442,
-0.7743521928787231,
-0.9899875521659851,
-1.0592023134231567,
-0.7684289216995239,
-0.4578499495983124,
-0.033986132591962814,
0.6967979669570923,
0.7115218043327332,
-1.1244477033615112,
-0.36678218841552734,
0.060927633196115494,
0.20518290996551514,
-0.3961019814014435,
-0.12167816609144211,
0.28368324041366577,
-0.36072877049446106,
-0.6839826107025146,
0.6588027477264404,
0.26716890931129456,
-0.02548440545797348,
-0.11877425014972687,
-0.13123708963394165,
0.01696869172155857,
-0.28731581568717957,
0.5556711554527283,
0.5822353959083557,
-0.8931515216827393,
-0.647445023059845,
-0.11174294352531433,
-0.3932729661464691,
0.24247340857982635,
1.2101242542266846,
-0.599463939666748,
0.22309963405132294,
0.0589604452252388,
0.6983810067176819,
0.6038329601287842,
-0.06031182035803795,
0.750451922416687,
-0.8802685141563416,
0.18725548684597015,
0.22363102436065674,
0.26793918013572693,
0.4824540615081787,
-0.2193334549665451,
0.3333321809768677,
0.4108140170574188,
-0.030535949394106865,
-0.7613509297370911,
0.703044056892395,
-0.9318147897720337,
-0.41330206394195557,
0.9774636030197144,
-0.39740604162216187,
-0.31765076518058777,
-0.5995878577232361,
-0.16727745532989502,
0.2713346481323242,
-0.13437406718730927,
0.6358095407485962,
0.6703415513038635,
-0.29864630103111267,
-0.2696978449821472,
-0.5393353700637817,
0.5982940196990967,
0.5696602463722229,
-0.5239638686180115,
0.1810218244791031,
0.6235488057136536,
0.16935992240905762,
0.03395143523812294,
0.8394286036491394,
0.1070927232503891,
0.33878612518310547,
0.050195466727018356,
-0.19939693808555603,
-0.23200726509094238,
-0.07223508507013321,
-0.30533963441848755,
0.27289578318595886,
0.08499659597873688,
-0.329534113407135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11044v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11044v1 | Evaluating the Performance of Large Language Models via Debates | 2024-06-16T19:02:31 | 2024-06-16T19:02:31 | Behrad Moniri, Hamed Hassani, Edgar Dobriban | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) are rapidly evolving and impacting various
fields, necessitating the development of effective methods to evaluate and
compare their performance. Most current approaches for performance evaluation
are either based on fixed, domain-specific questions that lack the flexibility
required in many real-world applications where tasks are not always from a
single domain, or rely on human input, making them unscalable. We propose an
automated benchmarking framework based on debates between LLMs, judged by
another LLM. This method assesses not only domain knowledge, but also skills
such as problem definition and inconsistency recognition. We evaluate the
performance of various state-of-the-art LLMs using the debate framework and
achieve rankings that align closely with popular rankings based on human input,
eliminating the need for costly human crowdsourcing. | [
-0.5943882465362549,
-0.903565526008606,
0.5185980796813965,
0.1503966748714447,
0.031045500189065933,
0.2518404424190521,
-0.5878496170043945,
-0.47559624910354614,
-0.036062728613615036,
0.614107072353363,
-0.27991783618927,
-0.37395524978637695,
-0.7579020857810974,
0.16506224870681763,
-0.3670046627521515,
0.41359269618988037,
-0.0844329223036766,
0.10806211084127426,
-0.539494514465332,
-0.4247947335243225,
-0.2499636560678482,
-0.5747051239013672,
-0.5850685834884644,
-0.5487869381904602,
0.3936805725097656,
0.2710364758968353,
0.7256803512573242,
0.4934181272983551,
0.5818595290184021,
0.5423223972320557,
-0.25311195850372314,
0.3166202902793884,
-0.5071461796760559,
0.35008519887924194,
-0.5838564038276672,
-0.1892441362142563,
-0.35230207443237305,
0.04535187780857086,
0.7992957830429077,
0.7023400664329529,
-0.24492914974689484,
0.20082509517669678,
0.030152779072523117,
0.48122313618659973,
-0.5186188220977783,
0.024177897721529007,
-1.0423635244369507,
0.009498393163084984,
-0.3582340180873871,
-0.22133375704288483,
-0.33705171942710876,
-0.6590012907981873,
0.26354119181632996,
-0.1681927740573883,
-0.004730226006358862,
0.11678266525268555,
0.9054074883460999,
0.205714613199234,
-0.28029865026474,
-0.3593553304672241,
-0.5268272161483765,
0.5626251697540283,
-0.9166886806488037,
0.3963984549045563,
0.051441267132759094,
0.3877162039279938,
-0.35021138191223145,
-0.5774126052856445,
-0.578216016292572,
-0.4681372344493866,
0.12175953388214111,
-0.1589532047510147,
-0.28957730531692505,
-0.09739574790000916,
0.2525639832019806,
0.3469611406326294,
-0.5928806662559509,
0.49676594138145447,
-0.017838049679994583,
-0.045510344207286835,
0.8146019577980042,
0.31399253010749817,
0.0024467308539897203,
0.030092177912592888,
-0.17581094801425934,
-0.11775621771812439,
-0.6202396750450134,
-0.2463427633047104,
0.5043399930000305,
0.21166706085205078,
0.21733854711055756,
0.5472848415374756,
-0.3296385109424591,
0.7091172337532043,
0.06717957556247711,
-0.0362786129117012,
0.25051048398017883,
0.03621729835867882,
-0.2908652126789093,
-0.456644743680954,
1.03087317943573,
0.3734058737754822,
0.14685358107089996,
-0.2853243052959442,
-0.3563321828842163,
-0.1088217943906784,
0.2591060400009155,
-0.7733762264251709,
-0.10444645583629608,
0.15455099940299988,
-0.1827012151479721,
-0.13092970848083496,
-0.26066094636917114,
-0.9226463437080383,
-0.6838993430137634,
-0.382196843624115,
0.6405284404754639,
0.14914478361606598,
-0.27332717180252075,
0.04273947328329086,
0.020344030112028122,
-0.07487773150205612,
0.4706488251686096,
-0.7340520024299622,
0.4641982614994049,
0.9821118712425232,
0.5949805378913879,
-0.5539147853851318,
-0.26448357105255127,
-0.4133245646953583,
-0.07730325311422348,
-0.3586176633834839,
1.0473508834838867,
-0.6750238537788391,
-0.3699522316455841,
0.16542062163352966,
-0.08142389357089996,
-0.23280967772006989,
-1.223833441734314,
0.5517081618309021,
-0.7533702254295349,
0.04587383195757866,
-0.15863651037216187,
-1.0255234241485596,
0.15335234999656677,
0.6000466346740723,
-0.7302885055541992,
1.1542553901672363,
-0.12407032400369644,
-0.7176337242126465,
0.33650368452072144,
-0.6117278337478638,
-0.25022590160369873,
0.3864092230796814,
-0.3132565915584564,
-0.37743842601776123,
-0.1561661809682846,
0.11904651671648026,
0.43354636430740356,
-0.6809357404708862,
0.45576217770576477,
-0.4078141152858734,
-0.24964836239814758,
0.33334285020828247,
-0.44560953974723816,
0.5029124617576599,
0.09589428454637527,
-0.5211345553398132,
0.3470599353313446,
-0.7348136305809021,
0.21619918942451477,
0.12569642066955566,
-0.48306605219841003,
-0.17362560331821442,
0.1583407074213028,
-0.0893174409866333,
0.10557668656110764,
0.15243679285049438,
-0.4219819903373718,
0.33092471957206726,
-0.4608790874481201,
0.4700778126716614,
0.7153027653694153,
-0.11041347682476044,
0.12138063460588455,
-0.2898666262626648,
0.5524094700813293,
-0.21190883219242096,
-0.03274518623948097,
0.24639275670051575,
-0.38603895902633667,
-0.9313653111457825,
0.015160896815359592,
0.5190985202789307,
0.42787861824035645,
-0.5608556866645813,
0.33126869797706604,
-0.3988690972328186,
-0.6133153438568115,
-0.580912709236145,
0.37640097737312317,
0.3851557970046997,
0.28538867831230164,
0.23194384574890137,
-0.40439632534980774,
-0.2814936935901642,
-0.968180775642395,
-0.45094209909439087,
-0.2934475243091583,
-0.015085854567587376,
0.6475788354873657,
0.3926841616630554,
-0.054693803191185,
0.8262982964515686,
-0.40367910265922546,
0.09245046973228455,
-0.20337265729904175,
0.5618211030960083,
-0.11472061276435852,
0.2830202579498291,
0.08726820349693298,
-0.4573763906955719,
-0.2776987850666046,
0.15311242640018463,
-0.6835794448852539,
-0.356772243976593,
0.22854402661323547,
-0.15921641886234283,
0.4649517834186554,
0.5192678570747375,
-0.5430576205253601,
0.08589281141757965,
0.564507782459259,
-0.20456162095069885,
0.5532926917076111,
-0.05119405686855316,
0.4623124897480011,
-0.6440824866294861,
0.1966007649898529,
-0.012086021713912487,
-0.2591525614261627,
-0.31095704436302185,
0.27630457282066345,
0.057880062609910965,
-0.033968158066272736,
-0.34664657711982727,
0.9141164422035217,
-0.32689717411994934,
-0.23738574981689453,
-0.1817077398300171,
0.48596420884132385,
-0.007476092781871557,
0.28435319662094116,
0.1873343586921692,
0.8238969445228577,
0.1706744283437729,
-0.3844278156757355,
0.4847422242164612,
-0.03704961761832237,
-0.8455452919006348,
0.6140389442443848,
-0.6391732692718506,
0.3793541491031647,
0.28311780095100403,
0.15920908749103546,
-1.0963380336761475,
0.0016029844991862774,
-0.14246729016304016,
-0.17502206563949585,
0.20567917823791504,
-0.33425119519233704,
-0.6416494846343994,
-0.4455077648162842,
-0.12378215044736862,
0.3967060446739197,
0.14779460430145264,
-0.4482351839542389,
0.29686057567596436,
0.7473378777503967,
-0.5142989158630371,
-0.5152866244316101,
-0.1244085431098938,
0.39884498715400696,
-0.3185509741306305,
-0.7386187314987183,
0.11149122565984726,
-0.1332668513059616,
-0.6400792598724365,
-0.17798173427581787,
0.1635301560163498,
-0.19218941032886505,
0.1588873267173767,
0.01540695782750845,
0.0860970988869667,
-0.41215673089027405,
0.2528516948223114,
-0.1888565868139267,
0.08584357053041458,
0.12948022782802582,
-0.045323148369789124,
0.4457218647003174,
-0.12740914523601532,
-0.5865947008132935,
-0.15081243216991425,
0.19613495469093323,
0.6284935474395752,
-0.2865508496761322,
0.43805721402168274,
0.2106591910123825,
-0.31369712948799133,
-0.39438116550445557,
-1.220663070678711,
0.02268725261092186,
-0.5047906041145325,
0.49441149830818176,
-0.3156511187553406,
-1.2067291736602783,
0.32488298416137695,
-0.5261983871459961,
0.16301289200782776,
0.44130438566207886,
0.964932918548584,
0.17051225900650024,
0.9401213526725769,
0.3773484230041504,
-0.14213289320468903,
0.1386074721813202,
0.018177973106503487,
0.023938139900565147,
-0.5966225862503052,
-0.25558915734291077,
-0.76457679271698,
-0.26508185267448425,
-0.29691872000694275,
-0.7208935022354126,
0.23439162969589233,
-0.058487217873334885,
-0.3476102352142334,
0.3320057988166809,
-0.3123950660228729,
0.6423280835151672,
0.10618879646062851,
-0.45927610993385315,
0.5202859044075012,
-0.07679831236600876,
-0.43326514959335327,
-0.08274964243173599,
-0.5625187158584595,
-0.7985298037528992,
0.9252164363861084,
0.3868919014930725,
0.6808983087539673,
0.19139012694358826,
0.3526042401790619,
0.4466812014579773,
0.696952760219574,
-0.7317140102386475,
0.6798375248908997,
0.07776503264904022,
-0.6379634737968445,
-0.5564118027687073,
-0.6597869992256165,
-0.9128332138061523,
0.8261933922767639,
-0.2559148669242859,
-0.8508514165878296,
-0.09845392405986786,
-0.0361124612390995,
-0.21801766753196716,
0.5431416630744934,
-0.5676791667938232,
1.0616717338562012,
-0.19198046624660492,
-0.5328325033187866,
-0.35680443048477173,
-0.22733908891677856,
0.34100261330604553,
-0.029379863291978836,
0.29750487208366394,
-0.2829304337501526,
0.03828096017241478,
0.8622944951057434,
-0.41279906034469604,
0.43186837434768677,
-0.038760848343372345,
-0.3790574371814728,
0.18119731545448303,
0.12809348106384277,
0.3097822964191437,
0.05606742575764656,
-0.3880651295185089,
0.1721571832895279,
0.06605031341314316,
-0.04468448460102081,
-0.5938988327980042,
0.8882938623428345,
-0.7786149978637695,
-0.8580533266067505,
-0.25455382466316223,
-0.45721063017845154,
-0.6869111061096191,
0.057945091277360916,
-0.08315690606832504,
0.3205696940422058,
-0.6310560703277588,
0.035490211099386215,
0.5903812646865845,
-0.29626262187957764,
0.28673017024993896,
0.8135401606559753,
-0.32269585132598877,
-0.33138754963874817,
0.6686338782310486,
0.18256746232509613,
0.25006330013275146,
0.3513398766517639,
0.25684335827827454,
-0.4966590404510498,
-0.5338242650032043,
-0.6716868281364441,
0.17533475160598755,
-0.7273919582366943,
-0.23437434434890747,
-0.7043219804763794,
-0.14619283378124237,
-0.22323960065841675,
0.11186590045690536,
-0.6199127435684204,
-0.37824684381484985,
0.22739765048027039,
0.10455917567014694,
0.16343945264816284,
0.9895750284194946,
0.2549118995666504,
-0.08018434047698975,
-0.5559594035148621,
0.027187693864107132,
0.5363852381706238,
0.4759305715560913,
0.34451329708099365,
-0.7582421898841858,
-0.1310189962387085,
-0.310512900352478,
-0.6109564304351807,
-0.3900235593318939,
0.207276850938797,
-0.063910111784935,
0.686455249786377,
0.26693663001060486,
-0.10134709626436234,
0.7731194496154785,
-0.6508197784423828,
0.6324426531791687,
-0.09379465132951736,
-1.1100926399230957,
0.20349229872226715,
-0.1760943979024887,
0.07712413370609283,
0.7119550108909607,
0.2720741629600525,
-0.5243915319442749,
-0.43088483810424805,
-0.44448769092559814,
-0.8132139444351196,
0.5523198843002319,
0.09012553840875626,
-0.03489193692803383,
-0.03474936634302139,
0.0697694793343544,
-0.009560052305459976,
0.2965949475765228,
-0.4284917116165161,
-0.050262823700904846,
0.4140971004962921,
0.1876065731048584,
0.021200431510806084,
-0.1199457049369812,
-0.32092389464378357,
-0.42047783732414246,
0.5793672204017639,
-0.034699223935604095,
-0.08818797767162323,
-0.13646748661994934,
-0.2129787653684616,
-0.2883349657058716,
0.43483078479766846,
0.5631444454193115,
1.0805119276046753,
0.021207164973020554,
0.13580118119716644,
0.49586769938468933,
0.005897813942283392,
0.24283811450004578,
0.1237412840127945,
-0.008100887760519981,
0.0026058489456772804,
0.3723609149456024,
0.6879977583885193,
0.48363956809043884,
-1.0306810140609741,
0.5239970684051514,
-0.10815379023551941,
-0.40688061714172363,
0.0441647432744503,
0.003123361151665449,
0.5956004858016968,
0.3979586362838745,
0.1239759549498558,
-0.2934790849685669,
0.041584357619285583,
-0.5310012102127075,
0.2251000553369522,
0.5376256704330444,
-0.1603926420211792,
0.04804764688014984,
0.45368969440460205,
0.32090431451797485,
-0.48445308208465576,
0.2776978313922882,
-0.09261370450258255,
-0.5713863968849182,
0.724634051322937,
0.23506410419940948,
0.5949157476425171,
-0.2349512130022049,
0.10705636441707611,
0.21114932000637054,
0.22739450633525848,
-0.23268349468708038,
0.06311167776584625,
0.14383193850517273,
-0.7086271643638611,
-0.3597863018512726,
-0.5014340877532959,
-0.9137215614318848,
0.4629809558391571,
-0.4701855480670929,
0.13713522255420685,
-0.48847517371177673,
-0.3147203326225281,
0.27438655495643616,
0.31973305344581604,
-0.6419849991798401,
0.08328493684530258,
0.21643652021884918,
1.000590205192566,
-0.6131005883216858,
0.7097676396369934,
0.7573245763778687,
0.04631469398736954,
-0.5172118544578552,
0.0080454396083951,
-0.004548958502709866,
-0.6696273684501648,
0.6142367720603943,
-0.05561380833387375,
-0.36820974946022034,
-0.3412388563156128,
-0.410441130399704,
-0.8093408346176147,
0.8083475828170776,
0.5413627624511719,
-0.694561779499054,
0.45153796672821045,
0.1750860959291458,
0.7206922173500061,
-0.2820868492126465,
0.6140686273574829,
0.5700061321258545,
0.5544108748435974,
0.16977731883525848,
-1.2546405792236328,
-0.16789844632148743,
-0.4123278260231018,
-0.06281300634145737,
0.11177366226911545,
-0.9129540920257568,
0.7565168738365173,
0.1144191175699234,
-0.20788489282131195,
0.15530474483966827,
0.5606619715690613,
0.19726933538913727,
0.2527594566345215,
0.5380306839942932,
0.5562812089920044,
0.9329888224601746,
-0.06515434384346008,
0.6894181370735168,
-0.33800527453422546,
0.4497360587120056,
1.1066627502441406,
-0.9633682370185852,
1.2573691606521606,
0.15475139021873474,
-0.530773401260376,
0.24005663394927979,
0.4690685272216797,
-0.03888622298836708,
0.08128941059112549,
0.850939929485321,
-0.2024201899766922,
-0.48780378699302673,
-0.029811430722475052,
-0.2988143563270569,
0.45577573776245117,
0.29134315252304077,
-0.028367944061756134,
-0.3572465777397156,
-0.35671502351760864,
0.08877439796924591,
0.3459901213645935,
-0.059318237006664276,
0.875078558921814,
-0.052126962691545486,
-1.0035609006881714,
0.811982274055481,
0.4105205833911896,
0.7112380266189575,
-0.46927693486213684,
0.009836776182055473,
-0.25801870226860046,
0.3410991132259369,
-0.0034298745449632406,
-0.7945791482925415,
0.11697186529636383,
0.32037827372550964,
0.039666108787059784,
0.03247915208339691,
0.4209388196468353,
-0.48066964745521545,
-0.48016977310180664,
0.550846517086029,
0.5699450969696045,
0.2675819993019104,
0.12933582067489624,
-0.9308740496635437,
0.5142344236373901,
-0.49693000316619873,
-0.30776917934417725,
0.6166947484016418,
0.4421483278274536,
-0.16573597490787506,
0.8859608173370361,
0.2606920301914215,
0.007958684116601944,
-0.14999771118164062,
0.35789406299591064,
1.0462621450424194,
-0.374952495098114,
-0.23660704493522644,
-0.8988741636276245,
-0.0077186403796076775,
-0.28411245346069336,
-0.4678487479686737,
0.6815431118011475,
0.6965576410293579,
0.8424929976463318,
0.21357451379299164,
0.698885977268219,
0.24504049122333527,
0.7303778529167175,
-0.39538756012916565,
0.9582167863845825,
-0.5658343434333801,
0.4522039294242859,
-0.46566805243492126,
-0.8083962202072144,
-0.12040366977453232,
0.666862428188324,
-0.4581432640552521,
0.05748043954372406,
0.5234372615814209,
0.8734496235847473,
-0.01255618967115879,
0.13600821793079376,
0.38596242666244507,
0.29645416140556335,
0.3296244442462921,
0.5279653072357178,
0.9911824464797974,
-0.05021326243877411,
0.27436068654060364,
0.17097468674182892,
-0.22646285593509674,
-0.1862800121307373,
-1.0784282684326172,
-1.0746409893035889,
-0.3669533133506775,
-0.4142177104949951,
-0.13281778991222382,
0.2910197079181671,
1.130794644355774,
0.678333044052124,
-0.9365414977073669,
-0.7793728113174438,
0.48600324988365173,
0.34286537766456604,
0.06665754318237305,
-0.1896906942129135,
0.3994312584400177,
-0.11944635957479477,
-0.8149323463439941,
0.5691944360733032,
0.27769848704338074,
-0.46417585015296936,
-0.5386579632759094,
-0.009592530317604542,
-0.2594904601573944,
0.4219444990158081,
0.6955985426902771,
0.3242371380329132,
-0.9246860146522522,
-0.167947456240654,
-0.37356626987457275,
-0.2192932814359665,
0.054430581629276276,
0.8517405390739441,
-0.7110280990600586,
0.3516833484172821,
0.38453781604766846,
0.9807068109512329,
0.3019295036792755,
0.10513089597225189,
0.47936680912971497,
-0.45075878500938416,
-0.14301928877830505,
0.15857301652431488,
0.2448595017194748,
0.4964987337589264,
0.08586204051971436,
0.45618167519569397,
0.19498015940189362,
-0.7806238532066345,
-0.9981826543807983,
-0.008020922541618347,
-0.6684197783470154,
-0.20530210435390472,
1.188338279724121,
-0.386966735124588,
0.24778376519680023,
-0.2602877616882324,
-0.046815793961286545,
-0.07087913900613785,
-0.2463923543691635,
0.8312047123908997,
0.9639863967895508,
0.0949283167719841,
0.16564005613327026,
-0.6309551000595093,
0.4154169261455536,
0.41180849075317383,
-0.8584893941879272,
0.4629307687282562,
0.26452237367630005,
0.47023311257362366,
-0.10083110630512238,
0.6515726447105408,
-0.2162039875984192,
-0.16577337682247162,
-0.2707100212574005,
-0.020340466871857643,
0.17310062050819397,
-0.20714588463306427,
-0.249470055103302,
0.44460535049438477,
0.30800145864486694,
0.4427855610847473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11036v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11036v1 | garak: A Framework for Security Probing Large Language Models | 2024-06-16T18:18:43 | 2024-06-16T18:18:43 | Leon Derczynski, Erick Galinkin, Jeffrey Martin, Subho Majumdar, Nanna Inie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | As Large Language Models (LLMs) are deployed and integrated into thousands of
applications, the need for scalable evaluation of how models respond to
adversarial attacks grows rapidly. However, LLM security is a moving target:
models produce unpredictable output, are constantly updated, and the potential
adversary is highly diverse: anyone with access to the internet and a decent
command of natural language. Further, what constitutes a security weak in one
context may not be an issue in a different context; one-fits-all guardrails
remain theoretical. In this paper, we argue that it is time to rethink what
constitutes ``LLM security'', and pursue a holistic approach to LLM security
evaluation, where exploration and discovery of issues are central. To this end,
this paper introduces garak (Generative AI Red-teaming and Assessment Kit), a
framework which can be used to discover and identify vulnerabilities in a
target LLM or dialog system. garak probes an LLM in a structured fashion to
discover potential vulnerabilities. The outputs of the framework describe a
target model's weaknesses, contribute to an informed discussion of what
composes vulnerabilities in unique contexts, and can inform alignment and
policy discussions for LLM deployment. | [
-0.6145966053009033,
-1.222672700881958,
0.3891802728176117,
-0.06771601736545563,
-0.014169171452522278,
0.4089110791683197,
-0.11005059629678726,
-0.44330844283103943,
0.13782742619514465,
0.7057034373283386,
-0.5244704484939575,
-0.5187656283378601,
-0.7245426774024963,
-0.23669151961803436,
-0.5393669605255127,
1.284291386604309,
-0.027958346530795097,
-0.364041805267334,
-0.022773124277591705,
-0.3304057717323303,
-0.748532772064209,
-0.7636536359786987,
-0.7599841952323914,
-0.3158959448337555,
0.5319405198097229,
0.2055281400680542,
0.7741842865943909,
0.2580815553665161,
0.709790825843811,
0.3613814115524292,
-0.22687658667564392,
-0.011708219535648823,
-0.5236328840255737,
0.48845964670181274,
-0.25832071900367737,
-0.6441129446029663,
-0.5591562390327454,
-0.13390564918518066,
0.3844372034072876,
0.29232168197631836,
-0.06256137043237686,
0.417197585105896,
-0.04865659028291702,
0.4877370297908783,
-0.533624529838562,
-0.19224601984024048,
-0.6834102272987366,
0.11903847754001617,
-0.40844112634658813,
-0.21709372103214264,
-0.3863578140735626,
0.17431403696537018,
0.1970292329788208,
-0.3886120915412903,
0.17663347721099854,
0.35990193486213684,
0.7579613327980042,
0.1697016805410385,
-0.5264931917190552,
-0.35004574060440063,
-0.7202547192573547,
0.7933797836303711,
-0.501311719417572,
0.12968741357326508,
0.3127260208129883,
0.7548368573188782,
-0.4406587779521942,
-0.6083034873008728,
-0.4153265357017517,
-0.4699844419956207,
0.10630280524492264,
-0.2580820918083191,
-0.5369006991386414,
0.03770871087908745,
-0.09968002140522003,
0.38905030488967896,
-0.7837303280830383,
0.11940864473581314,
-0.23387275636196136,
-0.37636300921440125,
0.6821067333221436,
0.3844892084598541,
0.6891464591026306,
0.3050520718097687,
-0.36105093359947205,
-0.18930287659168243,
-0.7963140606880188,
-0.19429552555084229,
0.7137762904167175,
0.390606552362442,
-0.45346799492836,
0.42159247398376465,
0.22515472769737244,
0.5704427361488342,
-0.13563063740730286,
0.05860133841633797,
-0.12339624762535095,
-0.33719003200531006,
-0.31724563241004944,
-0.0532953180372715,
0.7875494956970215,
0.2196669727563858,
-0.11134283244609833,
-0.06363499909639359,
-0.2303696572780609,
0.09710494428873062,
0.7799985408782959,
-0.38584885001182556,
-0.2986536920070648,
0.39318493008613586,
-0.18314984440803528,
-0.8284258842468262,
-0.10476168245077133,
-1.1798555850982666,
-0.7033295631408691,
0.23495061695575714,
0.15644828975200653,
0.0013069413835182786,
-0.24434949457645416,
-0.03296087682247162,
-0.034069452434778214,
0.24568119645118713,
0.1455494612455368,
-1.0271607637405396,
0.35972481966018677,
0.9585345387458801,
0.8259533643722534,
0.09766121208667755,
-0.16728368401527405,
-0.6204737424850464,
0.14404769241809845,
-0.4795951545238495,
0.5702141523361206,
-0.5118571519851685,
-0.45589572191238403,
0.05886242166161537,
-0.19017887115478516,
0.20802338421344757,
-0.10180528461933136,
0.4635043740272522,
-0.7675943374633789,
0.05610595643520355,
-0.07340972870588303,
-0.20570702850818634,
-0.2752038240432739,
0.8839691877365112,
-0.7574616074562073,
0.8791778683662415,
-0.09588868916034698,
-0.8733201622962952,
0.2267116904258728,
-0.8871132135391235,
-0.21367812156677246,
0.31738099455833435,
-0.30716198682785034,
-0.5002867579460144,
-0.04284444451332092,
0.3473985493183136,
0.3780956268310547,
-0.4878428280353546,
0.13668319582939148,
-0.4368719458580017,
-0.2629360556602478,
0.25064557790756226,
-0.41551801562309265,
0.5977751612663269,
0.2398211508989334,
-0.4291880428791046,
0.35164207220077515,
-0.21127478778362274,
-0.011907479725778103,
0.27369970083236694,
-0.32144564390182495,
-0.34452155232429504,
0.12820403277873993,
-0.17751166224479675,
-0.20346860587596893,
0.2346285581588745,
-0.40166914463043213,
0.18831367790699005,
-0.6902815699577332,
0.6421905159950256,
0.9259758591651917,
0.18230488896369934,
0.6381759643554688,
-0.2294393628835678,
0.9693443775177002,
-0.2657129466533661,
0.39643874764442444,
0.039602283388376236,
-0.40719956159591675,
-0.6672123074531555,
-0.30142921209335327,
0.043543945997953415,
0.506093442440033,
-0.3790958523750305,
0.05686333030462265,
-0.16839565336704254,
-0.6125847697257996,
-0.4335617125034332,
0.24717821180820465,
0.33030274510383606,
0.19023312628269196,
0.1440185159444809,
-0.15334254503250122,
-0.6419640183448792,
-0.8417247533798218,
-0.2734745442867279,
-0.5457722544670105,
0.23640544712543488,
0.38934096693992615,
0.8036587238311768,
-0.6469686031341553,
0.6866889595985413,
-0.23550079762935638,
-0.18204206228256226,
-0.5955705642700195,
0.04841933771967888,
0.10747762024402618,
0.24221178889274597,
0.6035771369934082,
-0.8574742674827576,
-0.350686639547348,
0.5995592474937439,
-0.8048446774482727,
0.0928352028131485,
0.061045531183481216,
-0.13257727026939392,
-0.05882673338055611,
0.6454358696937561,
-0.44337713718414307,
0.3631437420845032,
0.795925498008728,
-0.2373584359884262,
0.5762948393821716,
-0.16158831119537354,
-0.15575659275054932,
-0.8618749976158142,
0.17356207966804504,
-0.22689618170261383,
-0.11849332600831985,
-0.9865975379943848,
0.6795495748519897,
-0.17598462104797363,
-0.2845199704170227,
-0.21241864562034607,
0.9997313618659973,
-0.30097073316574097,
-0.26305943727493286,
-0.21062256395816803,
-0.029354210942983627,
0.06740429252386093,
0.17871789634227753,
-0.8411419987678528,
0.9372015595436096,
0.4244193434715271,
-0.5396996140480042,
0.5097385048866272,
0.11250496655702591,
-0.44600969552993774,
0.46673646569252014,
-0.7639127969741821,
0.4515850841999054,
0.09242410957813263,
0.31360018253326416,
-0.9875849485397339,
-0.2816544473171234,
0.5507051348686218,
-0.4439026117324829,
0.36470159888267517,
-0.3542633354663849,
-0.31527581810951233,
-0.31576740741729736,
-0.3353915810585022,
0.6274159550666809,
0.0826118066906929,
-0.42179521918296814,
0.8037118911743164,
0.7276064157485962,
-0.44273841381073,
-0.9764679074287415,
-0.48059239983558655,
0.5553564429283142,
-0.5963979363441467,
-0.6766253709793091,
0.017888767644762993,
0.19566401839256287,
-0.6988686919212341,
-0.2568889260292053,
-0.0027245297096669674,
-0.004928655456751585,
0.7590354681015015,
0.3619489371776581,
0.3407471477985382,
-0.08557020872831345,
-0.016711650416254997,
-0.3701750934123993,
-0.11908804625272751,
0.1855527013540268,
-0.3158963918685913,
0.6948248744010925,
-0.4500054121017456,
-0.6207001805305481,
0.019444413483142853,
0.4867309033870697,
0.6747984886169434,
-0.46047812700271606,
0.36574673652648926,
0.4945262372493744,
-0.0912461057305336,
-0.4391573667526245,
-0.4776763319969177,
0.015156155452132225,
-0.5247775316238403,
0.5650419592857361,
-0.18030613660812378,
-1.1700278520584106,
0.73393315076828,
0.08513157069683075,
0.2626107931137085,
0.30359333753585815,
0.8468084931373596,
-0.124487966299057,
0.9023828506469727,
1.0972946882247925,
-0.5625975131988525,
0.2836426794528961,
-0.1355590671300888,
0.601720929145813,
-0.7691673040390015,
-0.1586662232875824,
-0.3176479637622833,
-0.36348432302474976,
-0.3441706895828247,
-0.24383439123630524,
0.45387083292007446,
-0.21861709654331207,
-0.21439796686172485,
0.16914448142051697,
-0.46037352085113525,
0.4123426377773285,
0.1569921374320984,
-0.3434731960296631,
-0.009846467524766922,
-0.1447935700416565,
-0.4438689053058624,
0.4248511791229248,
-0.47254031896591187,
-0.7892190217971802,
1.3066529035568237,
0.7225098609924316,
0.7392618656158447,
0.36527615785598755,
0.5918962955474854,
0.665075421333313,
0.4964354932308197,
-0.6097366809844971,
0.6558070182800293,
0.3422199785709381,
-0.9895415306091309,
-0.3828120827674866,
-0.24274875223636627,
-1.0244417190551758,
0.38479721546173096,
0.0430213063955307,
-0.8677113652229309,
-0.09323073923587799,
0.05367610231041908,
-0.4077765941619873,
0.3980976343154907,
-0.33281952142715454,
0.8276781439781189,
-0.35305535793304443,
-0.08013671636581421,
-0.19923703372478485,
-0.50436931848526,
0.4867323935031891,
-0.10925542563199997,
0.35860538482666016,
-0.10940543562173843,
0.14448866248130798,
0.6210545301437378,
-0.34857481718063354,
1.0768682956695557,
-0.049092646688222885,
-0.3433038592338562,
0.2580935060977936,
0.24883714318275452,
0.547808051109314,
0.08458733558654785,
0.20157156884670258,
0.11670498549938202,
-0.2091967910528183,
-0.37289661169052124,
-0.6301097273826599,
0.6403087973594666,
-0.6933419704437256,
-0.7564588785171509,
-0.46955960988998413,
-0.6208920478820801,
-0.10275521129369736,
-0.024685433134436607,
0.04728104919195175,
0.2814578711986542,
-0.6675841212272644,
-0.06939921528100967,
0.6615904569625854,
-0.3286106288433075,
0.11595480889081955,
0.2866823971271515,
-0.38415470719337463,
-0.4631211757659912,
0.7721344828605652,
-0.12336820363998413,
0.29969343543052673,
0.25418755412101746,
-0.06079603359103203,
-0.08947577327489853,
-0.7025435566902161,
-0.4733526110649109,
0.06547535955905914,
-0.7946463227272034,
-0.23642759025096893,
-0.3151344358921051,
-0.07787381857633591,
-0.06913544237613678,
-0.38664987683296204,
-0.16937394440174103,
0.1094907745718956,
0.05874623358249664,
-0.3931397795677185,
0.39834851026535034,
0.8899656534194946,
0.12978443503379822,
0.2702125906944275,
-0.544597327709198,
-0.024522952735424042,
0.40584585070610046,
-0.13376298546791077,
0.1658356785774231,
-0.48844003677368164,
-0.2842477262020111,
0.064531609416008,
-0.28389614820480347,
-0.7364858388900757,
0.5625264644622803,
0.020226869732141495,
0.7509836554527283,
0.3725124001502991,
-0.1357056051492691,
0.3324969410896301,
-0.47902095317840576,
0.7886222004890442,
-0.03327462449669838,
-0.7237237691879272,
0.47707879543304443,
-0.43204522132873535,
-0.10537590831518173,
0.5129815340042114,
0.08197461813688278,
-0.5988103747367859,
-0.5838415026664734,
-0.47113049030303955,
-0.9065735340118408,
0.13417193293571472,
0.0015191752463579178,
0.409921795129776,
-0.061118729412555695,
0.24037499725818634,
-0.12226012349128723,
0.25294753909111023,
-0.5911936163902283,
-0.18188413977622986,
-0.03196714073419571,
0.08814030140638351,
-0.24987585842609406,
-0.43485018610954285,
-0.709311842918396,
0.15393617749214172,
0.3875719904899597,
-0.18828456103801727,
0.4455855190753937,
-0.03961944952607155,
-0.13926051557064056,
0.025371506810188293,
0.5514336824417114,
0.7350370287895203,
0.2568525969982147,
-0.024703439325094223,
0.3391016721725464,
0.4628289043903351,
-0.4576961398124695,
0.5408208966255188,
-0.24018485844135284,
-0.049180593341588974,
-0.1930479258298874,
0.621427059173584,
0.6896770596504211,
0.18969179689884186,
-0.6189668774604797,
0.6512911915779114,
0.014813542366027832,
-0.2970067262649536,
-0.2981351613998413,
0.07229731976985931,
-0.10109920054674149,
0.49132826924324036,
0.2843180298805237,
-0.18712961673736572,
-0.14169718325138092,
-0.6901840567588806,
0.14851237833499908,
0.763311505317688,
-0.4025125801563263,
-0.4159012734889984,
0.5244287848472595,
0.08301428705453873,
-0.39520397782325745,
0.4152551591396332,
-0.1790113002061844,
-0.9538508057594299,
0.6937173008918762,
0.3792570233345032,
1.0152734518051147,
-0.1969590187072754,
0.24047940969467163,
-0.19580498337745667,
0.7487565279006958,
0.11606553941965103,
0.11767179518938065,
0.026807745918631554,
-0.8039258122444153,
-0.39253297448158264,
-0.4490411579608917,
-0.6795386672019958,
0.2124885767698288,
-0.6143965125083923,
-0.08081084489822388,
-0.8429260849952698,
-0.42366623878479004,
-0.2340630143880844,
0.1315697431564331,
-0.5196455717086792,
-0.15897142887115479,
0.2574939429759979,
0.6669275164604187,
-0.8550732731819153,
0.5025444626808167,
0.6873214840888977,
-0.16110876202583313,
-0.5294578671455383,
-0.16490277647972107,
0.30965766310691833,
-0.867541491985321,
0.8649400472640991,
0.107989102602005,
-0.099875807762146,
-0.4430549144744873,
-0.6312914490699768,
-0.7021557092666626,
1.1096597909927368,
0.41530483961105347,
-0.4088723361492157,
-0.015838757157325745,
0.26792460680007935,
0.5368101596832275,
-0.30007314682006836,
0.026931943371891975,
0.49158820509910583,
0.5724371075630188,
-0.32869186997413635,
-0.8247113823890686,
0.04369477555155754,
-0.3871093988418579,
-0.07835574448108673,
0.432437002658844,
-0.5479832291603088,
0.8376410603523254,
-0.11958954483270645,
-0.4066544771194458,
0.005982218775898218,
0.5225344896316528,
0.15594345331192017,
0.21925054490566254,
0.34809088706970215,
0.6776925921440125,
0.9591139554977417,
0.18653139472007751,
1.2835726737976074,
-0.08788763731718063,
0.19815057516098022,
0.9431161284446716,
-0.44563883543014526,
0.7818479537963867,
0.47935646772384644,
-0.13276885449886322,
0.4247560203075409,
0.2502172291278839,
-0.20207928121089935,
0.5317270159721375,
0.44209569692611694,
-0.4335915744304657,
-0.014298402704298496,
0.16315321624279022,
-0.18205948173999786,
0.4573046565055847,
0.5013017654418945,
-0.22933992743492126,
-0.4970306158065796,
0.08380450308322906,
0.1898736208677292,
-0.18587419390678406,
-0.27931585907936096,
0.6826921105384827,
0.21080118417739868,
-0.3021124005317688,
0.4313567876815796,
0.3386058211326599,
0.4297233521938324,
-0.6915755271911621,
0.14118796586990356,
-0.14800700545310974,
0.10257839411497116,
0.026347216218709946,
-0.5585094690322876,
0.3257859945297241,
0.1397167444229126,
0.009649123065173626,
-0.0015249610878527164,
0.8214111328125,
0.0913534015417099,
-0.23054851591587067,
0.4316028952598572,
0.30841901898384094,
-0.0010354903060942888,
0.061091769486665726,
-0.7372650504112244,
0.38950294256210327,
-0.040376242250204086,
-0.22298181056976318,
0.7302861213684082,
0.2756483852863312,
-0.1768394112586975,
1.1345574855804443,
0.9462383985519409,
0.03791634365916252,
-0.005657827015966177,
-0.11611589789390564,
0.9627761840820312,
-0.3047109842300415,
-0.5566037893295288,
-1.2752604484558105,
0.35210511088371277,
-0.10430050641298294,
-0.35505855083465576,
0.8977070450782776,
0.1102127656340599,
0.5315434336662292,
0.44365617632865906,
1.0026228427886963,
0.33687371015548706,
0.17418861389160156,
-0.376690149307251,
0.9657818675041199,
-0.203177347779274,
0.6147089004516602,
-0.20580828189849854,
-0.7238738536834717,
-0.3237183690071106,
0.7532662153244019,
-0.5903962850570679,
-0.3098422884941101,
0.24223542213439941,
1.0455635786056519,
0.022812267765402794,
-0.07828323543071747,
0.28258785605430603,
0.17517559230327606,
0.8512930274009705,
0.3775910437107086,
1.0699883699417114,
-0.36792105436325073,
0.5140774250030518,
0.2615402340888977,
0.0425410158932209,
-0.47807854413986206,
-0.8470732569694519,
-1.1019200086593628,
-0.33306872844696045,
-0.04639218747615814,
-0.06328134983778,
0.36489203572273254,
0.5258569121360779,
0.4419727921485901,
-0.6224782466888428,
-0.2035353183746338,
-0.11771096289157867,
0.08458571881055832,
-0.11445299535989761,
-0.1820986121892929,
0.052097368985414505,
-0.26896241307258606,
-0.07004238665103912,
0.8293902277946472,
0.5075165629386902,
-0.020173851400613785,
-0.7261432409286499,
-0.14469262957572937,
0.017181003466248512,
0.24173197150230408,
0.21761827170848846,
0.5600894689559937,
-0.70542311668396,
-0.5913278460502625,
-0.18109436333179474,
-0.2218247801065445,
-0.29134610295295715,
0.5441780090332031,
-0.36804965138435364,
0.4387587904930115,
0.16804558038711548,
1.086168885231018,
0.17631326615810394,
-0.29013592004776,
1.0107544660568237,
-0.6924592852592468,
0.09296756237745285,
0.3086700439453125,
0.3527795672416687,
0.1610976755619049,
-0.37390074133872986,
0.4090597331523895,
-0.30522191524505615,
-0.6972488164901733,
-1.292950987815857,
0.42065703868865967,
-0.6076095700263977,
-0.07288122177124023,
0.9338831901550293,
-0.23364056646823883,
-0.17674702405929565,
-0.4449031949043274,
-0.19094769656658173,
-0.2933184504508972,
-0.044978395104408264,
0.6697707176208496,
0.8040774464607239,
0.5177081227302551,
0.08346130698919296,
-0.9458135366439819,
0.3435773253440857,
0.48263347148895264,
-0.5822955965995789,
0.1854216605424881,
0.0671161487698555,
0.20725631713867188,
0.24028244614601135,
0.5266549587249756,
-0.07985242456197739,
0.19946570694446564,
0.061345070600509644,
-0.11786594241857529,
-0.20214806497097015,
-0.45785394310951233,
-0.4951896667480469,
0.35667651891708374,
0.14025071263313293,
-0.020393693819642067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11035v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11035v1 | Scaling Synthetic Logical Reasoning Datasets with Context-Sensitive Declarative Grammars | 2024-06-16T18:10:49 | 2024-06-16T18:10:49 | Damien Sileo | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Logical reasoning remains a challenge for natural language processing, but it
can be improved by training language models to mimic theorem provers on
procedurally generated problems. Previous work used domain-specific proof
generation algorithms, which biases reasoning toward specific proof traces and
limits auditability and extensibility. We present a simpler and more general
declarative framework with flexible context-sensitive rules binding multiple
languages (specifically, simplified English and the TPTP theorem-proving
language). We construct first-order logic problems by selecting up to 32
premises and one hypothesis. We demonstrate that using semantic constraints
during generation and careful English verbalization of predicates enhances
logical reasoning without hurting natural English tasks. We use relatively
small DeBERTa-v3 models to achieve state-of-the-art accuracy on the FOLIO
human-authored logic dataset, surpassing GPT-4 in accuracy with or without an
external solver by 12%. | [
-0.09598526358604431,
-0.7009066343307495,
0.7707439064979553,
0.08836391568183899,
-0.12216763943433762,
-0.29835590720176697,
-0.39451852440834045,
-0.36108919978141785,
-0.2547340989112854,
0.42698293924331665,
-0.6068211197853088,
-0.4518432021141052,
-0.4798329770565033,
0.4294717311859131,
-0.065784752368927,
0.5673807859420776,
0.02379142865538597,
0.02036086656153202,
-0.2059224545955658,
-0.284823477268219,
-0.4793006479740143,
-0.6989398002624512,
-0.35494381189346313,
-0.09631764888763428,
-0.08341679722070694,
0.2697179913520813,
0.5565943121910095,
0.5975855588912964,
0.4439297616481781,
0.3283914029598236,
0.16380533576011658,
0.4403451979160309,
-0.10603395849466324,
0.26425930857658386,
-0.706188976764679,
-0.4732518196105957,
-0.25886303186416626,
-0.2272026091814041,
0.4184694290161133,
0.7476791739463806,
0.022719934582710266,
-0.040150921791791916,
-0.37906521558761597,
0.47717031836509705,
-0.485306054353714,
0.5846918821334839,
-0.935441255569458,
-0.14642810821533203,
-0.035509150475263596,
-0.09194249659776688,
-0.6108759641647339,
-0.38614925742149353,
0.14127060770988464,
-0.9002674221992493,
0.18169958889484406,
-0.16744858026504517,
0.7752242088317871,
0.3700654208660126,
-0.5843425989151001,
-0.19892631471157074,
-0.6363154053688049,
0.9773551225662231,
-0.5618792772293091,
0.547214925289154,
0.18765519559383392,
0.4745177924633026,
-0.12583652138710022,
-0.7681145668029785,
-0.40778806805610657,
0.09229351580142975,
-0.08698593080043793,
-0.3913853168487549,
-0.23549599945545197,
-0.06183500960469246,
0.47513607144355774,
0.015317020937800407,
-0.453070729970932,
-0.25642818212509155,
-0.36571621894836426,
-0.28951340913772583,
0.586295485496521,
-0.0130997309461236,
0.1960408091545105,
0.06108061224222183,
0.04169260337948799,
-0.04865964129567146,
-0.7800159454345703,
-0.032690346240997314,
-0.10144118964672089,
0.5580034255981445,
0.3272954821586609,
0.5260832905769348,
-0.2305375188589096,
0.9820141196250916,
0.18438151478767395,
-0.1405406892299652,
0.14425677061080933,
-0.6625227928161621,
-0.1617974042892456,
-0.07118040323257446,
0.320348858833313,
0.2824089825153351,
0.5242313146591187,
0.04984091967344284,
-0.10428974777460098,
0.5356438755989075,
0.1185181736946106,
-1.0351881980895996,
-0.1332753747701645,
0.1982279121875763,
0.030210046097636223,
-0.15545018017292023,
-0.030105140060186386,
-0.1603677123785019,
-0.18607786297798157,
-0.7467032670974731,
0.3082271218299866,
-0.6184681057929993,
-0.10647228360176086,
0.6857993602752686,
0.00694554578512907,
0.250953733921051,
0.3782535791397095,
-0.8990851640701294,
0.4815129041671753,
0.8620462417602539,
0.2757476568222046,
0.13000233471393585,
-0.05791362375020981,
-0.6449196934700012,
0.21697580814361572,
-0.3294422924518585,
0.6383928656578064,
-0.6769673824310303,
0.17029716074466705,
0.06328020989894867,
-0.08023965358734131,
-0.17654180526733398,
-0.5966536998748779,
0.8042303323745728,
-0.49026554822921753,
0.3682917654514313,
-0.43438902497291565,
-0.6083879470825195,
-0.014115442521870136,
0.49783483147621155,
-0.3061600923538208,
0.42831143736839294,
0.08001670241355896,
-0.671983540058136,
0.7202157378196716,
-0.40825703740119934,
-0.805773913860321,
0.06362628191709518,
-0.42398372292518616,
-0.003668811172246933,
0.008274727500975132,
0.5042107701301575,
0.29173359274864197,
-0.2670224606990814,
0.4505751430988312,
0.027203332632780075,
0.139665424823761,
-0.12471692264080048,
-0.13111329078674316,
0.9310479760169983,
0.04357300326228142,
-0.3987458646297455,
0.10281332582235336,
-1.009135365486145,
0.4552178978919983,
0.16147713363170624,
-0.3043772578239441,
-0.23216292262077332,
0.09522143751382828,
-0.4037095606327057,
0.3594900071620941,
0.08968691527843475,
-0.6451958417892456,
0.16352419555187225,
-0.5018701553344727,
0.7693198323249817,
0.4292758107185364,
0.09244172275066376,
0.2839168608188629,
-0.3118288815021515,
0.2940577268600464,
0.14999505877494812,
-0.06975240260362625,
-0.15301217138767242,
-0.47428426146507263,
-0.6215450167655945,
-0.46733519434928894,
0.12383202463388443,
0.5554729104042053,
-0.6160255074501038,
0.5567757487297058,
-0.4941553771495819,
-0.19751779735088348,
-0.13554950058460236,
0.0746222585439682,
0.18400442600250244,
0.764500617980957,
0.5552244782447815,
0.1316971480846405,
-0.5877816677093506,
-0.9217889308929443,
-0.32628732919692993,
-0.19661223888397217,
-0.4064509868621826,
0.10528899729251862,
0.32830968499183655,
-0.26468831300735474,
1.218134880065918,
-0.4719370901584625,
-0.32904329895973206,
-0.3561670184135437,
-0.12034180015325546,
0.23114736378192902,
0.4041821360588074,
0.37276583909988403,
-0.7452210187911987,
-0.25961312651634216,
-0.1187778040766716,
-0.6564774513244629,
-0.43488267064094543,
-0.1777619868516922,
-0.15102384984493256,
0.33724886178970337,
0.23794302344322205,
-0.7863089442253113,
0.15596991777420044,
-0.018392188474535942,
-0.5866514444351196,
0.40390676259994507,
-0.2217940390110016,
-0.13951824605464935,
-0.8583400845527649,
-0.36738720536231995,
-0.05354415625333786,
-0.5004891157150269,
-0.839128315448761,
0.11683277040719986,
0.1473151445388794,
-0.05577758327126503,
-0.30142369866371155,
0.3043346703052521,
-0.08238787204027176,
0.45444753766059875,
-0.006515829358249903,
0.17917749285697937,
0.4378501772880554,
0.25036802887916565,
0.41792577505111694,
0.2586590051651001,
0.4145536720752716,
-0.5717744827270508,
0.16673949360847473,
0.3018510341644287,
-0.06574734300374985,
0.7565374970436096,
-0.7088897228240967,
-0.06400179117918015,
-0.14307023584842682,
0.3463323712348938,
-0.5230839252471924,
-0.2566604018211365,
-0.12161127477884293,
-0.10226354002952576,
0.12009692937135696,
-0.08944395929574966,
-0.43920618295669556,
-0.0437861792743206,
-0.19245201349258423,
0.5201212167739868,
0.4991031289100647,
-0.7456666231155396,
0.5664323568344116,
0.13633905351161957,
0.0953328087925911,
-0.153831347823143,
-0.6710814237594604,
-0.05940603092312813,
-0.1572115421295166,
-1.0981696844100952,
0.42331910133361816,
0.08665560185909271,
-0.7832318544387817,
-0.18409569561481476,
-0.39402851462364197,
-0.2512831687927246,
-0.03267605975270271,
-0.04903502017259598,
-0.029864609241485596,
-0.1454804241657257,
0.15093614161014557,
0.038275040686130524,
0.048897139728069305,
0.32790911197662354,
-0.707504391670227,
0.22227396070957184,
-0.577697217464447,
-0.33724942803382874,
-0.24062950909137726,
0.24558697640895844,
0.4936758279800415,
-0.27341726422309875,
0.4738147556781769,
-0.07136988639831543,
-0.6384174227714539,
-0.7102469205856323,
-0.2575284242630005,
-0.37034669518470764,
-0.4635480046272278,
-0.0059609562158584595,
-0.7681978344917297,
-0.718062162399292,
0.23019419610500336,
0.060794126242399216,
0.18177849054336548,
0.5622572898864746,
0.5856087803840637,
0.5332947969436646,
0.8846381306648254,
0.24587468802928925,
0.4218461811542511,
-0.1660280078649521,
0.02760837785899639,
0.34768736362457275,
-0.05891669914126396,
-0.004514529835432768,
-0.33006617426872253,
0.22334052622318268,
-0.6799083948135376,
-0.6195723414421082,
0.1567295789718628,
-0.0263232309371233,
-0.3886092007160187,
0.5718249678611755,
-0.5286589860916138,
0.768617570400238,
0.5176708698272705,
-0.016109926626086235,
0.47522661089897156,
-0.07488253712654114,
-0.24623312056064606,
-0.1993861198425293,
-0.6090089082717896,
-0.5186083912849426,
0.9586056470870972,
0.12851224839687347,
0.4446859359741211,
0.3894016742706299,
0.5569342970848083,
0.07423917204141617,
0.0027036701794713736,
-0.6247095465660095,
0.6262640953063965,
-0.1683083474636078,
-0.8137975931167603,
-0.2734760046005249,
-0.48787403106689453,
-0.6317517757415771,
0.42110657691955566,
-0.007702745497226715,
-0.5630364418029785,
0.07660643011331558,
0.024998489767313004,
-0.24816325306892395,
0.05659982189536095,
-0.8575273752212524,
0.7910953164100647,
-0.10717535763978958,
-0.622772753238678,
-0.04974661394953728,
-0.5687960386276245,
0.3623487949371338,
-0.15074686706066132,
0.24392758309841156,
-0.17427365481853485,
0.18957379460334778,
0.25367864966392517,
-0.9903146624565125,
0.7735401391983032,
-0.30031818151474,
-0.2772153615951538,
0.51316237449646,
0.423577219247818,
0.45053210854530334,
0.23419710993766785,
-0.052770983427762985,
-0.1926739364862442,
0.2804659903049469,
-0.40714678168296814,
-0.7237444519996643,
0.5095569491386414,
-0.33913442492485046,
-0.8803061842918396,
-0.42568692564964294,
-0.5925862789154053,
-0.512365460395813,
0.40182968974113464,
0.0405832938849926,
0.49827834963798523,
-0.09542544931173325,
0.12188751995563507,
0.5230103135108948,
0.21942558884620667,
0.05505462363362312,
0.42067766189575195,
-0.006345445290207863,
-0.190463125705719,
0.881518542766571,
0.07113239914178848,
0.355865478515625,
0.47550615668296814,
0.35309872031211853,
-0.41648146510124207,
-0.286074161529541,
-0.3829185962677002,
0.16288121044635773,
-0.8882705569267273,
-0.12767869234085083,
-0.39718082547187805,
-0.005268361885100603,
-0.5720038414001465,
-0.4149431884288788,
-0.2569183111190796,
-1.1437560319900513,
0.08855076134204865,
-0.25895458459854126,
0.09713539481163025,
0.39389094710350037,
-0.06714881211519241,
-0.3189396560192108,
-0.5583982467651367,
0.47734150290489197,
0.620773196220398,
0.08811669051647186,
-0.7024127840995789,
-0.5457561612129211,
0.3181290924549103,
-0.009515280835330486,
-0.1448560208082199,
-0.5356466770172119,
0.3417900502681732,
0.39855101704597473,
0.17364369332790375,
0.44533783197402954,
0.31805577874183655,
0.4319005012512207,
-0.6748056411743164,
0.5591706037521362,
-0.08532959967851639,
-1.0263445377349854,
0.8082190752029419,
-0.4886256456375122,
0.3293800950050354,
0.8187453150749207,
0.16552148759365082,
-0.09587984532117844,
-0.2547067701816559,
-0.5713419318199158,
-0.6364258527755737,
0.4460214078426361,
0.3856242299079895,
-0.11015462130308151,
-0.167992502450943,
0.2656819522380829,
0.08889952301979065,
0.06611388921737671,
-0.6499660611152649,
0.3011508285999298,
-0.36159321665763855,
-0.4415978491306305,
0.3365807831287384,
-0.0031610296573489904,
-0.3497258424758911,
-0.5159250497817993,
0.6172245740890503,
-0.37964826822280884,
-0.18600188195705414,
0.34288129210472107,
-0.35291606187820435,
0.2514963746070862,
0.5214546918869019,
0.5638770461082458,
0.9012462496757507,
-0.1914513111114502,
0.5330327153205872,
0.025936774909496307,
-0.2446778267621994,
0.4081234931945801,
0.348690390586853,
-0.4634602665901184,
-0.15026448667049408,
0.5033081769943237,
0.3845495283603668,
-0.16278977692127228,
-0.939845621585846,
0.44925081729888916,
-0.18712371587753296,
-0.49522554874420166,
-0.24047735333442688,
0.14067904651165009,
0.006478714756667614,
0.178498774766922,
0.03429356589913368,
-0.058984801173210144,
-0.07419958710670471,
-0.29719164967536926,
0.3311227560043335,
0.29531481862068176,
0.11642269045114517,
-0.4234398305416107,
0.835165798664093,
0.3010966181755066,
-0.003921661991626024,
0.5127965211868286,
-0.4823435842990875,
-0.5661895275115967,
0.5404254198074341,
0.8393661975860596,
0.740425169467926,
0.08753296732902527,
0.08643054217100143,
0.508283793926239,
0.4326750338077545,
-0.06906908750534058,
0.42630496621131897,
-0.2690272033214569,
-1.0580060482025146,
-0.4343412518501282,
-0.5028623342514038,
-0.5965562462806702,
-0.05551568418741226,
-0.262170672416687,
0.2734363377094269,
-0.8126813173294067,
0.05661396682262421,
0.16401784121990204,
0.13479533791542053,
-0.5626131296157837,
0.2929352819919586,
0.006497623864561319,
0.8646464943885803,
-0.7876170873641968,
0.7586163878440857,
0.6904116272926331,
-0.19128158688545227,
-0.6388532519340515,
-0.1267206370830536,
0.061830680817365646,
-0.43767037987709045,
0.6895158886909485,
0.5170682668685913,
-0.21217778325080872,
-0.19624100625514984,
-0.27857229113578796,
-0.6259201765060425,
0.8335494995117188,
0.5637766122817993,
-0.46225759387016296,
0.20867283642292023,
0.5468184351921082,
0.6679034233093262,
-0.5096278786659241,
-0.14830756187438965,
0.9299971461296082,
0.5367907285690308,
0.1258709877729416,
-0.5735515356063843,
0.41951873898506165,
-0.18536195158958435,
-0.20431126654148102,
0.012515489012002945,
-0.3525906205177307,
0.5711629986763,
-0.2988273501396179,
-0.30094578862190247,
-0.39262863993644714,
0.5447196364402771,
0.6243378520011902,
0.17437517642974854,
0.6283538937568665,
0.7501584887504578,
1.045363187789917,
-0.2290641963481903,
0.9795295000076294,
-0.295987069606781,
-0.18591070175170898,
1.2354379892349243,
-0.6232001781463623,
0.5299409031867981,
0.4418858587741852,
-0.07511880248785019,
0.5818991661071777,
0.2647972106933594,
0.1482986956834793,
0.34403616189956665,
0.5526809692382812,
-0.5094398856163025,
-0.5672690868377686,
-0.418287992477417,
-0.06495242565870285,
0.4021807909011841,
0.36856698989868164,
-0.1786498725414276,
-0.20847877860069275,
-0.23183569312095642,
0.14282424747943878,
0.37720125913619995,
-0.053034160286188126,
0.42369136214256287,
-0.07166432589292526,
-0.7458346486091614,
0.8076859712600708,
0.08839520066976547,
0.27812308073043823,
-0.46085047721862793,
-0.002417846117168665,
-0.13914762437343597,
0.48286861181259155,
-0.23267762362957,
-0.377718061208725,
0.426540732383728,
0.22732482850551605,
-0.2899029552936554,
-0.5368932485580444,
0.8410926461219788,
-0.3136754333972931,
-0.672464907169342,
-0.03360176086425781,
0.4834049642086029,
-0.25568461418151855,
-0.05529281124472618,
-0.12018385529518127,
-0.151349276304245,
0.002895024139434099,
-0.3831191062927246,
0.04615268483757973,
0.7077156901359558,
-0.4360351264476776,
0.5657519102096558,
0.5138921737670898,
-0.08517482131719589,
0.10957389324903488,
0.26767438650131226,
0.9154688715934753,
-0.51557856798172,
-0.3043232262134552,
-0.6733118295669556,
0.28665846586227417,
-0.1167936623096466,
0.009353642351925373,
0.6275454163551331,
0.4339017868041992,
0.882804811000824,
0.037924639880657196,
0.7592214941978455,
-0.19670121371746063,
0.3699648678302765,
-0.31030046939849854,
0.017363136634230614,
-0.11775508522987366,
0.34195658564567566,
0.2807655334472656,
-0.7061306238174438,
-0.825461745262146,
0.7031834721565247,
-0.3834502100944519,
-0.21076110005378723,
0.7710787653923035,
0.6568642854690552,
-0.14068354666233063,
0.015679193660616875,
0.17414605617523193,
0.2073708474636078,
0.6454629302024841,
0.8198410272598267,
0.49095582962036133,
-0.20773634314537048,
0.42755481600761414,
-0.4103848338127136,
-0.14038515090942383,
0.29992684721946716,
-1.0441662073135376,
-0.9596365690231323,
-0.30354243516921997,
-0.4596518874168396,
-0.3906915485858917,
-0.22123487293720245,
1.0572565793991089,
0.6981220245361328,
-0.9461191892623901,
0.17471598088741302,
-0.6660382151603699,
0.16727080941200256,
-0.19814318418502808,
-0.24404150247573853,
0.3388749957084656,
-0.6676706075668335,
-0.6346101760864258,
0.8243975639343262,
0.07292395830154419,
-0.16555315256118774,
-0.023682575672864914,
0.011604474857449532,
-0.05549655854701996,
0.5123648643493652,
0.8016625642776489,
0.39332064986228943,
-0.47302958369255066,
-0.5882174372673035,
-0.07281626015901566,
-0.00006018737985868938,
-0.022243989631533623,
0.7005528807640076,
-0.8218762278556824,
0.4160745143890381,
0.7765613794326782,
0.598835825920105,
0.29882189631462097,
0.29070204496383667,
0.6887158155441284,
-0.8644654154777527,
0.2893214225769043,
0.29030412435531616,
0.4276828467845917,
0.3608594834804535,
-0.12026520073413849,
0.7124862670898438,
0.44470885396003723,
-0.37200504541397095,
-0.724515974521637,
0.4811861217021942,
-0.7957065105438232,
-0.3726792633533478,
1.1484508514404297,
-0.06902239471673965,
-0.06525914371013641,
-0.04227716103196144,
-0.002650244627147913,
-0.22785386443138123,
-0.07845920324325562,
0.48067769408226013,
0.6439705491065979,
-0.26670849323272705,
0.247440367937088,
-0.28301095962524414,
0.6344392895698547,
0.5363200902938843,
-0.9510229825973511,
0.24948708713054657,
0.9076945185661316,
0.3384280204772949,
0.2420107126235962,
0.5225022435188293,
-0.15434935688972473,
0.08085811883211136,
-0.003501875326037407,
-0.3150131106376648,
-0.22916771471500397,
-0.47878286242485046,
-0.32066670060157776,
0.39455392956733704,
0.033978160470724106,
0.02247161976993084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11030v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11030v1 | FoodieQA: A Multimodal Dataset for Fine-Grained Understanding of Chinese Food Culture | 2024-06-16T17:59:32 | 2024-06-16T17:59:32 | Wenyan Li, Xinyu Zhang, Jiaang Li, Qiwei Peng, Raphael Tang, Li Zhou, Weijia Zhang, Guimin Hu, Yifei Yuan, Anders Søgaard, Daniel Hershcovich, Desmond Elliott | cs.CL | cs.CL | Food is a rich and varied dimension of cultural heritage, crucial to both
individuals and social groups. To bridge the gap in the literature on the
often-overlooked regional diversity in this domain, we introduce FoodieQA, a
manually curated, fine-grained image-text dataset capturing the intricate
features of food cultures across various regions in China. We evaluate
vision-language Models (VLMs) and large language models (LLMs) on newly
collected, unseen food images and corresponding questions. FoodieQA comprises
three multiple-choice question-answering tasks where models need to answer
questions based on multiple images, a single image, and text-only descriptions,
respectively. While LLMs excel at text-based question answering, surpassing
human accuracy, the open-sourced VLMs still fall short by 41\% on multi-image
and 21\% on single-image VQA tasks, although closed-weights models perform
closer to human levels (within 10\%). Our findings highlight that understanding
food and its cultural implications remains a challenging and under-explored
direction. | [
-0.36323362588882446,
-0.5674923062324524,
0.3247353136539459,
-0.1287642866373062,
0.1304502636194229,
0.0004472927830647677,
-0.21252644062042236,
-0.6502765417098999,
0.08787170052528381,
0.49287593364715576,
-0.6175937652587891,
-0.3590790927410126,
-0.49621760845184326,
-0.06295467913150787,
-0.21307872235774994,
0.7208913564682007,
-0.15810152888298035,
0.3609744608402252,
0.024210913106799126,
-0.44134315848350525,
-0.32617858052253723,
-0.20295648276805878,
-0.3930250406265259,
-0.09238243103027344,
0.5347744822502136,
0.4774097204208374,
0.7662822604179382,
0.6857839822769165,
0.439139187335968,
0.1980016827583313,
-0.21922622621059418,
0.5072007179260254,
-0.3047654628753662,
-0.12394797056913376,
-0.1646999716758728,
-0.5845469832420349,
-0.0870862752199173,
-0.015716012567281723,
0.21099445223808289,
0.7092715501785278,
0.04503009840846062,
0.6355658769607544,
0.025857945904135704,
0.6189708113670349,
-0.669349730014801,
0.08408675342798233,
-0.5344169735908508,
0.2216852307319641,
-0.26707977056503296,
-0.04047601297497749,
-0.1413925737142563,
-0.24177992343902588,
0.007383726071566343,
-0.7605498433113098,
-0.04519445449113846,
-0.0885118618607521,
1.1440831422805786,
0.3127919137477875,
-0.9165178537368774,
-0.23489655554294586,
-0.8802101016044617,
0.790576696395874,
-0.2358274757862091,
0.19549857079982758,
0.5215197205543518,
0.44846445322036743,
-0.1292993724346161,
-0.8071897029876709,
-0.7558245658874512,
0.16752831637859344,
-0.07068195194005966,
0.2938653230667114,
0.001074991305358708,
-0.32888439297676086,
-0.12821009755134583,
0.789903461933136,
-0.7086173892021179,
-0.1741655468940735,
-0.2521171271800995,
-0.07940749078989029,
0.5105811357498169,
0.4485916197299957,
0.8368449211120605,
-0.3409274220466614,
-0.66758131980896,
-0.3030293583869934,
-0.34431788325309753,
0.7099887728691101,
-0.21676146984100342,
0.2628782093524933,
0.023590898141264915,
0.5866585373878479,
-0.45668095350265503,
0.6426310539245605,
-0.2749440670013428,
-0.21410809457302094,
0.29255303740501404,
-0.7945321202278137,
-0.12168756127357483,
-0.5148283243179321,
0.5086994171142578,
0.8772119283676147,
0.26658129692077637,
0.38710132241249084,
-0.24369867146015167,
-0.15674448013305664,
-0.18021260201931,
-0.5678756237030029,
-0.5334829092025757,
0.33513954281806946,
-0.6001622676849365,
0.2066194713115692,
0.2849465310573578,
-0.456439733505249,
-0.5484520196914673,
0.05812285095453262,
0.37742534279823303,
-0.21676385402679443,
-0.3013097643852234,
0.11977428197860718,
-0.6556084156036377,
0.7015002369880676,
0.42359864711761475,
-0.9227729439735413,
0.034894827753305435,
0.47216716408729553,
0.6125815510749817,
0.12250876426696777,
-0.31625646352767944,
-0.256658136844635,
0.29260337352752686,
-0.5105762481689453,
0.7098802924156189,
-0.7760338187217712,
0.01184757798910141,
-0.38567590713500977,
0.5499919652938843,
0.17298133671283722,
-0.7898249626159668,
0.5790315270423889,
-0.3111124038696289,
-0.13374502956867218,
-1.053459882736206,
-0.1556008756160736,
-0.5017597079277039,
0.6114367246627808,
-0.7325854301452637,
0.8263134956359863,
0.199477881193161,
-0.570422351360321,
0.7569538950920105,
-0.13570906221866608,
-0.40188342332839966,
0.5508010983467102,
-0.40590786933898926,
0.33683425188064575,
-0.16138695180416107,
0.6241711974143982,
0.4614819884300232,
-0.33162248134613037,
0.2376735657453537,
-0.37965530157089233,
-0.4619830250740051,
0.23786313831806183,
-0.6919100284576416,
0.47693899273872375,
0.4508378505706787,
-0.07476180046796799,
0.0739087387919426,
-0.38701632618904114,
-0.002906010951846838,
0.40533024072647095,
-0.41534551978111267,
-0.666109025478363,
0.13340651988983154,
0.5245133638381958,
-0.027612967416644096,
0.3226853013038635,
-0.34571126103401184,
0.2941651940345764,
-0.1310943216085434,
0.6238914728164673,
0.5953953266143799,
-0.3408792018890381,
0.40202245116233826,
-0.5050613880157471,
0.16639935970306396,
0.20053426921367645,
0.5163360834121704,
-0.607015073299408,
-0.5256386399269104,
-0.44249051809310913,
-0.19488884508609772,
0.2494186908006668,
0.7213679552078247,
-1.259572148323059,
-0.1490224003791809,
-0.1294783353805542,
-0.6332108974456787,
-0.5309593081474304,
-0.004716301802545786,
-0.051560185849666595,
0.2663719058036804,
0.3657824993133545,
-0.543724000453949,
0.05316843464970589,
-1.0766427516937256,
-0.09812620282173157,
-0.1149662658572197,
-0.3647519052028656,
0.5711454749107361,
0.34930580854415894,
-0.08671028167009354,
0.4915115535259247,
-0.682900607585907,
-0.25783953070640564,
-0.4323607087135315,
-0.015439522452652454,
0.1361410915851593,
0.45397576689720154,
0.7360427975654602,
-1.217973232269287,
-0.5016722083091736,
0.4575325548648834,
-0.5892581343650818,
0.3846265375614166,
-0.1347629427909851,
-0.2610001862049103,
-0.1241055279970169,
-0.18155169486999512,
-0.33029690384864807,
0.38626721501350403,
0.6062431931495667,
-0.4026564061641693,
0.3275515139102936,
0.23674964904785156,
0.6296966671943665,
-1.2414021492004395,
-0.13555312156677246,
0.2297043353319168,
0.23340675234794617,
-0.558340847492218,
0.42146530747413635,
0.2358315885066986,
-0.04427172616124153,
-0.5919892191886902,
0.8872048258781433,
-0.2811497747898102,
-0.015294776298105717,
-0.11248867958784103,
-0.24929454922676086,
0.3640272617340088,
0.5831344127655029,
0.3035489022731781,
0.7371418476104736,
0.500903308391571,
-0.37195390462875366,
0.47420087456703186,
0.13886508345603943,
-0.5556783080101013,
0.3915043771266937,
-0.33596011996269226,
-0.3208896517753601,
-0.24670113623142242,
0.3846626579761505,
-1.0902220010757446,
-0.6202689409255981,
0.6027487516403198,
-0.29125434160232544,
-0.22035257518291473,
-0.16706407070159912,
-0.46448227763175964,
-0.5193350911140442,
-0.17172926664352417,
0.7785637974739075,
0.009622622281312943,
-0.6074593663215637,
0.8963541388511658,
0.46635252237319946,
0.08499989658594131,
-0.5887795686721802,
-0.9950339198112488,
0.05918867513537407,
-0.019596371799707413,
-0.6713816523551941,
-0.10067099332809448,
-0.2008376568555832,
-0.17326143383979797,
-0.004447678569704294,
-0.30658528208732605,
-0.5714521408081055,
0.20148220658302307,
0.1491519957780838,
0.16907493770122528,
-0.35538148880004883,
0.17447243630886078,
-0.19250549376010895,
0.692415177822113,
-0.1789698749780655,
-0.34761548042297363,
0.5337350368499756,
-0.32587918639183044,
0.0016073760343715549,
-0.3989328145980835,
0.39854350686073303,
0.4630626142024994,
-0.38167697191238403,
0.4009901285171509,
1.030632734298706,
-0.49152475595474243,
0.03708900883793831,
-0.12216683477163315,
-0.06057282164692879,
-0.4411492347717285,
0.35731327533721924,
-0.4508039057254791,
-0.6275742650032043,
0.5990433692932129,
0.217845156788826,
0.1175999790430069,
0.281520813703537,
0.2813641130924225,
-0.3027378022670746,
0.5118158459663391,
0.39871451258659363,
-0.03892988711595535,
0.31408390402793884,
-0.09818393737077713,
-0.32611578702926636,
-0.32030096650123596,
-0.4997822642326355,
-0.3819374740123749,
-0.23829346895217896,
-0.6723182797431946,
-0.817982017993927,
0.28704705834388733,
-0.4674080014228821,
-0.19298122823238373,
-0.05984257161617279,
-0.4568101167678833,
0.8417484760284424,
0.49537476897239685,
0.502228319644928,
0.2729322910308838,
-0.23363493382930756,
0.12549136579036713,
0.16789598762989044,
-0.7466659545898438,
-0.4765782356262207,
0.5007262229919434,
0.35734421014785767,
1.132185935974121,
0.12572017312049866,
0.34203726053237915,
0.1280563473701477,
-0.048971883952617645,
-0.9486299157142639,
0.27704498171806335,
-0.9044649600982666,
-0.7360119223594666,
-0.4232077896595001,
-0.4484460949897766,
-0.5235770344734192,
0.308322548866272,
-0.057744234800338745,
-0.47835904359817505,
0.08927938342094421,
0.29522135853767395,
-0.5632601380348206,
0.5158258676528931,
-1.02558171749115,
0.9718136191368103,
-0.5166583061218262,
-0.37140071392059326,
0.5823414325714111,
-0.5784612894058228,
0.5287296175956726,
0.2701217532157898,
0.4712182283401489,
-0.12451101839542389,
0.2864166498184204,
0.47570422291755676,
0.09149428457021713,
0.7919742465019226,
-0.04954078048467636,
-0.13193044066429138,
0.3204595446586609,
0.2564624845981598,
0.04840729385614395,
0.1509564369916916,
0.22499459981918335,
0.18045738339424133,
0.5484831929206848,
-0.6077849864959717,
-0.7516471147537231,
0.6073335409164429,
-0.6031148433685303,
-0.4565280079841614,
-0.1998109221458435,
-0.6672552227973938,
0.020670095458626747,
0.1994512677192688,
-0.12519100308418274,
0.35623446106910706,
0.11476705968379974,
0.20312614738941193,
0.6762901544570923,
-0.5703436732292175,
0.18010744452476501,
0.1190980076789856,
-0.3221038281917572,
-0.1949290633201599,
0.9920130968093872,
0.18142256140708923,
0.0557137094438076,
0.47993379831314087,
0.29103928804397583,
-0.057385124266147614,
0.10476543754339218,
-0.513264536857605,
-0.1813070923089981,
-0.9037871360778809,
0.09836145490407944,
-0.5084789991378784,
-0.25551125407218933,
-0.11849581450223923,
-0.01282108761370182,
-0.4558655917644501,
-0.1388729214668274,
-0.24037794768810272,
0.08040039241313934,
-0.02593282423913479,
0.80690997838974,
0.029507184401154518,
-0.08954859524965286,
-0.9532791376113892,
0.5261529684066772,
0.526508092880249,
0.22492098808288574,
0.28879445791244507,
-0.27909907698631287,
-0.20130431652069092,
0.14274896681308746,
-0.11869741976261139,
-0.7939854264259338,
0.366036981344223,
0.16173532605171204,
0.4670480787754059,
0.517885684967041,
0.11950913071632385,
0.7679579854011536,
-0.1328480839729309,
1.2197227478027344,
0.03984018787741661,
-0.7200531363487244,
0.46383538842201233,
-0.20505477488040924,
0.8291066288948059,
0.4390261471271515,
0.6261940598487854,
-1.0125406980514526,
-0.3276183009147644,
0.20506839454174042,
-1.0250967741012573,
0.3727276027202606,
-0.19167235493659973,
0.2711540460586548,
0.01955442689359188,
0.07381840795278549,
0.517874538898468,
0.008806397207081318,
-1.1000925302505493,
-0.19387339055538177,
-0.6087817549705505,
-0.05194658413529396,
0.12991783022880554,
-0.04073470085859299,
-0.24201655387878418,
-0.4779473841190338,
0.20366090536117554,
-0.218256875872612,
-0.2875567078590393,
0.09292685240507126,
0.18505236506462097,
-0.09820039570331573,
0.48754286766052246,
0.27500292658805847,
0.5380923748016357,
-0.10228367894887924,
0.2364816814661026,
0.026432514190673828,
-0.5542299151420593,
-0.12133270502090454,
-0.3098226487636566,
-0.06331482529640198,
-0.3776329755783081,
0.28391093015670776,
0.6110963821411133,
-0.3312961161136627,
-0.7094317674636841,
0.2837989926338196,
-0.586234986782074,
-0.1832461953163147,
-0.3356115221977234,
0.06619563698768616,
0.004509388469159603,
0.5731589794158936,
0.6955650448799133,
-0.06485384702682495,
0.4246387779712677,
-0.8618251085281372,
0.2585090100765228,
0.3228021264076233,
-0.26834797859191895,
-0.14730492234230042,
0.4448179602622986,
0.25758519768714905,
0.46736884117126465,
0.7468931078910828,
-0.07672832161188126,
-0.465244323015213,
0.8347830772399902,
0.13238723576068878,
0.3891386091709137,
0.1119966208934784,
0.5034565925598145,
0.36474233865737915,
0.5800006985664368,
-0.00776940630748868,
0.6596908569335938,
-0.13788539171218872,
-0.9423126578330994,
-0.20211805403232574,
-0.7034374475479126,
-0.278311550617218,
0.3548683822154999,
-0.7061774730682373,
-0.08875495940446854,
-0.23985609412193298,
-0.04916165769100189,
0.046111296862363815,
-0.28944337368011475,
-0.7630198001861572,
0.5243636965751648,
0.523500919342041,
1.0659890174865723,
-1.0122004747390747,
0.6706525683403015,
0.9919846057891846,
-0.2968764007091522,
-1.147972583770752,
0.573365330696106,
-0.030558522790670395,
-0.7491238117218018,
0.7829821705818176,
0.13290336728096008,
0.056462667882442474,
-0.5622134208679199,
-0.953940749168396,
-0.7901292443275452,
1.0136584043502808,
-0.12224645912647247,
-0.31606990098953247,
-0.0029653897508978844,
0.060100045055150986,
0.38689684867858887,
-0.07713303714990616,
0.30412253737449646,
0.3430064618587494,
0.5808578729629517,
0.35264086723327637,
-0.7543023228645325,
-0.18065664172172546,
-0.26983094215393066,
0.04455637186765671,
0.01976606249809265,
-1.0353940725326538,
1.074049472808838,
-0.26433002948760986,
-0.45795580744743347,
0.09028678387403488,
0.5836647748947144,
0.029975779354572296,
0.5861341953277588,
0.4173513650894165,
0.20981648564338684,
0.6811832189559937,
-0.3448910415172577,
0.8749290108680725,
-0.10172572731971741,
0.24990272521972656,
1.112516164779663,
-0.3082270622253418,
0.6981201171875,
0.48762747645378113,
0.10473472625017166,
0.1199490875005722,
1.4174107313156128,
-0.28970202803611755,
0.6079168319702148,
0.061198197305202484,
-0.09962587058544159,
-0.6264743208885193,
-0.785261869430542,
-0.2766881585121155,
0.9965092539787292,
0.13652992248535156,
-0.28725090622901917,
-0.21249085664749146,
-0.031542252749204636,
-0.34682247042655945,
0.01028489787131548,
-0.4302956163883209,
0.6608004570007324,
-0.036708440631628036,
-0.33031657338142395,
0.3224104940891266,
-0.13237375020980835,
0.5675152540206909,
-0.3461027443408966,
-0.4191882312297821,
-0.4410870373249054,
-0.3972751796245575,
-0.09562940895557404,
-1.2625240087509155,
-0.11258358508348465,
-0.3321046829223633,
-0.32222244143486023,
0.13614392280578613,
0.4850693643093109,
-0.39336082339286804,
-0.3139908015727997,
0.1612769514322281,
0.45158469676971436,
0.002280716085806489,
0.18916785717010498,
-0.5622511506080627,
0.027735799551010132,
0.05695951730012894,
-0.055628206580877304,
-0.0018109424272552133,
0.6906034350395203,
-0.05019339174032211,
0.6575537919998169,
0.28429102897644043,
-0.27609747648239136,
-0.1080407127737999,
-0.10892602056264877,
0.8773087859153748,
-0.6527734994888306,
-0.5534330606460571,
-0.6990559101104736,
0.34424954652786255,
0.3737316429615021,
-0.19919751584529877,
0.4657083749771118,
0.24031908810138702,
1.3769545555114746,
-0.2867579758167267,
0.8707734942436218,
-0.16699010133743286,
-0.0823371633887291,
-0.7339656949043274,
0.6922097206115723,
-1.3013522624969482,
-0.01353378500789404,
-0.024478815495967865,
-0.3404993712902069,
0.07421621680259705,
0.23452059924602509,
-0.1913149654865265,
-0.027685631066560745,
0.4217451214790344,
0.7082348465919495,
-0.04286095127463341,
0.07741323858499527,
0.5289381742477417,
0.089935302734375,
-0.10579047352075577,
0.7032114267349243,
1.3194795846939087,
-0.2027173489332199,
0.4705510139465332,
-0.18820202350616455,
-0.3211665749549866,
0.28185874223709106,
-0.3473409116268158,
-0.4998023808002472,
-0.915029764175415,
0.1544792801141739,
0.14563441276550293,
0.004212620668113232,
0.926943838596344,
0.7807490825653076,
-0.6476545333862305,
-0.24223917722702026,
0.8091639876365662,
0.092012919485569,
-0.32704511284828186,
-0.2041882574558258,
0.06140998750925064,
0.08235257118940353,
-0.8692024946212769,
0.2114039808511734,
0.2835683524608612,
0.0680655762553215,
-0.22706203162670135,
0.13085633516311646,
-0.15244072675704956,
0.14214850962162018,
0.6648111939430237,
0.3303927779197693,
-0.9635536074638367,
-0.17489811778068542,
0.08852039277553558,
-0.11543653905391693,
0.1853737086057663,
0.4459771513938904,
-0.20768648386001587,
0.5293965935707092,
0.23980237543582916,
0.7904070019721985,
0.0779147520661354,
0.10600263625383377,
0.27986764907836914,
-0.7287219762802124,
-0.05930287018418312,
-0.09666621685028076,
0.38184642791748047,
0.3831764757633209,
-0.528715193271637,
0.27087992429733276,
0.10502414405345917,
-0.4550168216228485,
-0.3713507354259491,
0.37701675295829773,
-1.0413236618041992,
-0.848006010055542,
1.1732814311981201,
-0.183796226978302,
-0.7586312890052795,
0.11457086354494095,
-0.17956487834453583,
0.22444486618041992,
-0.31139838695526123,
0.7142512202262878,
0.7105187773704529,
0.21142242848873138,
-0.40011945366859436,
-0.651087760925293,
0.3006749153137207,
0.24385686218738556,
-0.8312731981277466,
0.09105446934700012,
0.671556830406189,
0.38756063580513,
0.17839673161506653,
0.42830005288124084,
0.19708089530467987,
0.3222632110118866,
-0.11402163654565811,
0.2679697871208191,
0.32341688871383667,
-0.6698766350746155,
0.06198146194219589,
0.4101087749004364,
0.048291485756635666,
-0.42244404554367065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11029v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11029v1 | Curating Stopwords in Marathi: A TF-IDF Approach for Improved Text Analysis and Information Retrieval | 2024-06-16T17:59:05 | 2024-06-16T17:59:05 | Rohan Chavan, Gaurav Patil, Vishal Madle, Raviraj Joshi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Stopwords are commonly used words in a language that are often considered to
be of little value in determining the meaning or significance of a document.
These words occur frequently in most texts and don't provide much useful
information for tasks like sentiment analysis and text classification. English,
which is a high-resource language, takes advantage of the availability of
stopwords, whereas low-resource Indian languages like Marathi are very limited,
standardized, and can be used in available packages, but the number of
available words in those packages is low. Our work targets the curation of
stopwords in the Marathi language using the MahaCorpus, with 24.8 million
sentences. We make use of the TF-IDF approach coupled with human evaluation to
curate a strong stopword list of 400 words. We apply the stop word removal to
the text classification task and show its efficacy. The work also presents a
simple recipe for stopword curation in a low-resource language. The stopwords
are integrated into the mahaNLP library and publicly available on
https://github.com/l3cube-pune/MarathiNLP . | [
-0.5963806509971619,
-1.0155158042907715,
0.24688665568828583,
0.3682011365890503,
-0.7325467467308044,
0.33622273802757263,
-0.2950863838195801,
-0.48823365569114685,
0.412975549697876,
0.7536652684211731,
-0.3268665373325348,
-0.495572030544281,
-0.8700169324874878,
0.3857385814189911,
-0.44977056980133057,
0.8982644081115723,
-0.16555044054985046,
-0.2493750900030136,
-0.049604158848524094,
-0.6098194122314453,
-0.6824145913124084,
-0.35644546151161194,
-0.8619377613067627,
-0.183547243475914,
0.25413572788238525,
0.5455655455589294,
0.592900276184082,
0.25458773970603943,
0.648480236530304,
0.2534888684749603,
-0.20671533048152924,
0.34732452034950256,
-0.49706029891967773,
0.4624578356742859,
-0.5548560619354248,
-0.25898703932762146,
-0.05544023588299751,
-0.05047544464468956,
0.3716556429862976,
0.5733461380004883,
-0.22677931189537048,
-0.005995552521198988,
-0.13880933821201324,
0.8243488669395447,
-1.078025460243225,
0.20628656446933746,
-0.3138101398944855,
0.27705663442611694,
-0.8431516885757446,
-0.1578514575958252,
-0.3757922053337097,
-0.4794439971446991,
-0.2703128755092621,
-0.34328433871269226,
0.017551833763718605,
0.20053835213184357,
0.8555851578712463,
0.33530041575431824,
0.01645650528371334,
-0.6091066002845764,
-0.9608454704284668,
0.9725868105888367,
-0.41344836354255676,
0.2518603503704071,
0.6417091488838196,
0.18508945405483246,
0.017541395500302315,
-0.6189125180244446,
-0.5331546664237976,
-0.12575607001781464,
-0.007081781513988972,
0.20916910469532013,
-0.23931469023227692,
0.008559036068618298,
0.4009000360965729,
0.6087753772735596,
-0.28096064925193787,
-0.07019294053316116,
-0.45206812024116516,
-0.22714871168136597,
0.44300881028175354,
0.2628266215324402,
0.5478463172912598,
-0.4477885365486145,
-0.39140960574150085,
0.09196441620588303,
-0.5270525217056274,
-0.13257147371768951,
0.036297012120485306,
-0.005283552687615156,
0.19745208323001862,
0.8629796504974365,
-0.4312465786933899,
0.7347621321678162,
-0.14378298819065094,
-0.10965731739997864,
0.17896272242069244,
-0.7969276905059814,
-0.21969278156757355,
0.2135877162218094,
0.8454049229621887,
0.05131542310118675,
0.3033958375453949,
-0.2445119023323059,
-0.3080641031265259,
0.42503252625465393,
0.3745753765106201,
-0.8912992477416992,
0.016073785722255707,
0.18106934428215027,
-0.4157453179359436,
-0.4994021952152252,
-0.03132758289575577,
-0.9777112007141113,
-0.0755251944065094,
0.09582965075969696,
0.2671371400356293,
-0.5667105913162231,
-0.20229461789131165,
0.10267426818609238,
-0.405726820230484,
0.48424604535102844,
-0.18616104125976562,
-0.6775633096694946,
0.40995752811431885,
0.44589853286743164,
0.9060587882995605,
-0.3560850918292999,
0.08440092206001282,
-0.7541099190711975,
0.09064539521932602,
-0.5759767889976501,
0.750139594078064,
-1.0193101167678833,
-0.9504457712173462,
0.16586649417877197,
-0.1564330756664276,
0.02250315435230732,
-0.7499115467071533,
1.0389236211776733,
-0.6905122399330139,
0.16786617040634155,
-0.12134068459272385,
-0.5753067135810852,
-0.1727723926305771,
0.29090532660484314,
-0.7634560465812683,
1.4007014036178589,
0.09295553714036942,
-0.7934988737106323,
0.4027232825756073,
-1.0037399530410767,
-0.788701057434082,
0.5572845339775085,
-0.1772998571395874,
-0.2629273533821106,
0.3120381236076355,
0.24265336990356445,
0.33289554715156555,
-0.1353076994419098,
0.15280704200267792,
0.10400865226984024,
-0.2510075271129608,
0.26348426938056946,
-0.1461111456155777,
0.8273807168006897,
0.6004302501678467,
-0.29099616408348083,
0.009089717641472816,
-0.5668275952339172,
-0.0833747461438179,
-0.004924798384308815,
-0.31080636382102966,
-0.7029640674591064,
0.13890491425991058,
0.4404262602329254,
0.2075304538011551,
0.1271677166223526,
-0.9651268124580383,
0.07068983465433121,
-0.6034216284751892,
0.49610427021980286,
0.33608245849609375,
0.3756966292858124,
0.3110111951828003,
-0.3388349711894989,
0.9081856608390808,
0.11640311777591705,
0.17907586693763733,
0.06773501634597778,
-0.7574635744094849,
-0.6047078967094421,
-0.24250498414039612,
0.2782127857208252,
0.5500002503395081,
-1.1257646083831787,
0.16080786287784576,
-0.18721701204776764,
-0.6372902393341064,
-0.5729053020477295,
0.33651790022850037,
0.4086197316646576,
0.394223690032959,
0.5165437459945679,
-0.5601552128791809,
-0.4869532585144043,
-0.7584158182144165,
-0.15535499155521393,
0.25036168098449707,
0.272895872592926,
0.07543133199214935,
0.5695327520370483,
-0.2877804636955261,
1.1595901250839233,
-0.8339345455169678,
-0.6341283917427063,
-0.305049866437912,
0.3608454465866089,
-0.13312436640262604,
0.08365805447101593,
0.3765698969364166,
-1.1184275150299072,
-0.3405435085296631,
-0.4884122312068939,
-0.6104097366333008,
-0.15565533936023712,
0.36928048729896545,
-0.4249468445777893,
0.3835162818431854,
0.6091070175170898,
-0.583244264125824,
0.45001670718193054,
0.3017948269844055,
-0.26941192150115967,
0.4594095051288605,
-0.041851893067359924,
0.0842176228761673,
-1.363783597946167,
0.054325226694345474,
-0.12830810248851776,
-0.13668042421340942,
-0.35120585560798645,
0.22396023571491241,
-0.18739734590053558,
-0.3272608816623688,
-0.3885457217693329,
0.7191168069839478,
-0.2520730793476105,
0.2110404223203659,
-0.4596562385559082,
0.5217871069908142,
0.011883449740707874,
0.06581912189722061,
0.12040133774280548,
0.9374723434448242,
0.08907506614923477,
-0.6567906737327576,
0.4634689688682556,
0.4985215961933136,
-0.37341323494911194,
0.6766806244850159,
-0.47041192650794983,
-0.14398981630802155,
-0.0006330814212560654,
-0.06453435122966766,
-0.8132661581039429,
-0.09941335022449493,
0.4772372543811798,
-0.3895810544490814,
0.28727877140045166,
0.16785061359405518,
-0.6283566355705261,
-0.09283317625522614,
-0.4427587687969208,
0.3415290415287018,
0.4767567217350006,
-0.25244656205177307,
0.3266846239566803,
0.8075649738311768,
-0.17586369812488556,
-0.49082621932029724,
-0.8502175211906433,
0.4346168041229248,
-0.06999588012695312,
-0.30749252438545227,
0.47171303629875183,
-0.09704675525426865,
-0.49474266171455383,
0.42256635427474976,
0.08614742010831833,
-0.2083282619714737,
-0.021349797025322914,
0.2732778787612915,
0.15135011076927185,
0.15319187939167023,
0.4250757396221161,
-0.0319838672876358,
-0.25263330340385437,
-0.14543987810611725,
-0.270488440990448,
0.4995144009590149,
0.01539173349738121,
0.028468022122979164,
0.12229887396097183,
0.47347772121429443,
0.44722333550453186,
-0.6987388730049133,
0.7627220749855042,
0.999038815498352,
-0.5684672594070435,
-0.23695024847984314,
-0.5160280466079712,
0.15664143860340118,
-0.3930111229419708,
-0.0008715882431715727,
-0.2461957484483719,
-0.7202154397964478,
0.011415821500122547,
-0.0007119987276382744,
0.0244813933968544,
0.729550302028656,
0.5905427932739258,
0.08292035758495331,
0.5742120146751404,
0.697015643119812,
-0.25457999110221863,
0.42339736223220825,
-0.09156426042318344,
0.5881964564323425,
-0.7539102435112,
-0.20345816016197205,
-0.8271494507789612,
0.07572577148675919,
-0.8404232859611511,
-0.5154732465744019,
-0.020782142877578735,
-0.02183181792497635,
0.3654034733772278,
0.3976127505302429,
-0.7890017628669739,
0.05247563496232033,
0.27074962854385376,
-0.005025042220950127,
0.4338432848453522,
0.11492554843425751,
-0.21128453314304352,
-0.1985011249780655,
-0.3958766758441925,
-0.5589553713798523,
0.7499269247055054,
-0.3438192307949066,
0.5959150791168213,
0.15560513734817505,
0.8584333062171936,
0.7315281629562378,
0.31560203433036804,
-1.132371187210083,
0.74260413646698,
-0.32233548164367676,
-0.7486337423324585,
-0.30600428581237793,
-0.17962221801280975,
-0.9618509411811829,
-0.11772672086954117,
-0.3264962136745453,
-0.24852560460567474,
-0.21220248937606812,
-0.3686574399471283,
-0.10492326319217682,
0.22536183893680573,
-0.47209858894348145,
0.6607323884963989,
-0.04115307703614235,
-0.27950140833854675,
-0.5725531578063965,
-0.00518778245896101,
0.16907432675361633,
-0.27231019735336304,
0.5272538065910339,
-0.10506579279899597,
-0.431000679731369,
1.1147516965866089,
-0.7240656018257141,
0.36392366886138916,
0.05508241802453995,
0.19188319146633148,
0.5008459091186523,
-0.06052601337432861,
0.17526255548000336,
-0.33521193265914917,
-0.18385592103004456,
0.18514640629291534,
0.0005666876095347106,
-0.5871283411979675,
-0.2067306786775589,
0.6100254058837891,
-0.28079625964164734,
-0.11557751148939133,
-0.49322155117988586,
-0.01809011772274971,
-0.05516058951616287,
0.3539591133594513,
0.46248432993888855,
0.6332997679710388,
-0.3306860327720642,
0.2747141420841217,
0.6704352498054504,
-0.27998086810112,
0.6150913834571838,
0.2055891454219818,
-0.25439000129699707,
-0.21314939856529236,
0.9740536212921143,
0.3311731219291687,
-0.20449276268482208,
0.6226465106010437,
0.15579810738563538,
-0.34672054648399353,
-0.4972374737262726,
-0.4492608606815338,
0.14042051136493683,
-0.5453836917877197,
0.02288096584379673,
-0.5618084669113159,
-0.2566533386707306,
0.008430303074419498,
-0.25144797563552856,
-0.03516685962677002,
-0.34903714060783386,
0.07923538237810135,
0.021259577944874763,
0.5609943866729736,
0.7821676135063171,
0.13645553588867188,
-0.01956258900463581,
-1.038223385810852,
0.3955475389957428,
-0.06958842277526855,
0.5454207062721252,
-0.25156599283218384,
-0.2999430000782013,
-0.34999212622642517,
-0.36093950271606445,
-0.2829206883907318,
-0.9175201654434204,
0.32565605640411377,
0.1443895697593689,
0.4119131863117218,
0.46652236580848694,
0.369637668132782,
0.3883760869503021,
-0.24068443477153778,
0.9020113348960876,
0.06970711797475815,
-0.8614323139190674,
0.8605691194534302,
-0.09944329410791397,
0.433470755815506,
0.7865673899650574,
0.542773425579071,
-0.5568967461585999,
-0.7436767816543579,
-0.6829215884208679,
-0.9515194892883301,
0.3501408100128174,
0.40493032336235046,
0.26911625266075134,
-0.6079339981079102,
0.20233923196792603,
-0.15606608986854553,
0.3730866611003876,
-0.13138489425182343,
-0.0788002461194992,
0.1061558946967125,
-0.4257153570652008,
0.004504882264882326,
-0.6368181705474854,
0.07691142708063126,
0.12857219576835632,
0.8408669233322144,
0.3656150698661804,
-0.04307040944695473,
0.06833891570568085,
-0.47192975878715515,
0.03290553390979767,
0.5819908976554871,
0.44732940196990967,
0.5763581991195679,
-0.16824327409267426,
-0.07852215319871902,
0.1265891194343567,
-1.036306619644165,
0.06759141385555267,
-0.09456957876682281,
-0.45407047867774963,
0.3957374393939972,
0.24682414531707764,
0.366671085357666,
0.5282963514328003,
-0.7853765487670898,
0.36722803115844727,
-0.11054550856351852,
0.13107159733772278,
-0.6472555994987488,
-0.009472823701798916,
0.08773636817932129,
-0.2240629345178604,
0.17040997743606567,
0.026977455243468285,
0.10831284523010254,
-0.5374299883842468,
0.22213411331176758,
0.2604564428329468,
-0.6358774304389954,
0.1679985374212265,
0.5352169275283813,
0.371256023645401,
-0.515800952911377,
0.872602105140686,
-0.5223515033721924,
-0.3786693215370178,
0.30923178791999817,
0.016561998054385185,
0.9995572566986084,
-0.04183560982346535,
0.21170978248119354,
0.4454096853733063,
0.3519396483898163,
-0.08410267531871796,
0.22261491417884827,
-0.3381390869617462,
-0.7904564738273621,
-0.6381098031997681,
-1.2182376384735107,
-0.5624210834503174,
0.037075866013765335,
-0.6687806248664856,
0.2772842049598694,
-0.46848776936531067,
-0.4396480917930603,
0.12117010354995728,
0.3735581636428833,
-0.5387160181999207,
0.21328133344650269,
0.021087633445858955,
0.9519097208976746,
-0.780869722366333,
0.7640492916107178,
0.8842208385467529,
-0.9551711082458496,
-0.5641303062438965,
-0.07660873979330063,
-0.18819895386695862,
-0.29878655076026917,
0.7196189761161804,
0.2842784821987152,
-0.34459418058395386,
-0.03816287964582443,
-0.38114893436431885,
-0.38752949237823486,
0.7527887225151062,
-0.5039283633232117,
-0.4956784248352051,
0.14375969767570496,
0.03748885169625282,
0.5584416389465332,
-0.21353989839553833,
0.08607412129640579,
0.5510355234146118,
0.5176263451576233,
0.15582996606826782,
-0.48578548431396484,
0.18480761349201202,
-0.24534419178962708,
0.217405766248703,
0.6296488642692566,
-0.3229193687438965,
0.3032085597515106,
0.06522668153047562,
-0.3030433654785156,
-0.14459368586540222,
0.3125782310962677,
0.09021493792533875,
0.291288822889328,
0.4670305848121643,
0.8063018918037415,
0.5357860326766968,
-0.12231366336345673,
1.0457816123962402,
-0.4533844292163849,
0.37151002883911133,
0.6955239176750183,
-0.10536424070596695,
1.120423436164856,
0.3651614189147949,
-0.2548837661743164,
0.4940871596336365,
0.5197256207466125,
-0.00980649795383215,
0.33333471417427063,
0.03387376666069031,
-0.5026465654373169,
-0.19542603194713593,
-0.4363992512226105,
0.2530680000782013,
0.7370955944061279,
0.5889385342597961,
-0.15041571855545044,
-0.4471050798892975,
0.4585969150066376,
0.20831398665905,
0.21025651693344116,
-0.33041200041770935,
0.6582179665565491,
0.40789586305618286,
-0.8751319646835327,
0.21366555988788605,
0.2709680199623108,
0.6841626763343811,
-0.5038202404975891,
-0.09267476946115494,
-0.2460448145866394,
0.16338784992694855,
-0.29598677158355713,
-0.8753358125686646,
1.0349597930908203,
0.25642725825309753,
-0.2576490640640259,
-0.21965520083904266,
1.0573663711547852,
-0.29110997915267944,
-0.42899540066719055,
0.5289134383201599,
0.4167134463787079,
0.4010455906391144,
-0.11504650115966797,
-0.6025936603546143,
0.09068965166807175,
-0.23035985231399536,
-0.16341423988342285,
0.13917146623134613,
0.15928064286708832,
-0.21466359496116638,
0.4982130527496338,
0.5649164319038391,
0.35522735118865967,
-0.1547635793685913,
-0.03292826563119888,
0.48320019245147705,
-0.8726365566253662,
-0.4505797028541565,
-0.8888674378395081,
0.023167073726654053,
-0.2246534675359726,
-0.17673899233341217,
0.6836776733398438,
0.5234617590904236,
0.9241544008255005,
0.14469166100025177,
0.857304573059082,
-0.36566221714019775,
0.36016035079956055,
-0.5579001307487488,
0.7463623881340027,
-0.5788090825080872,
0.08670693635940552,
-0.18920214474201202,
-1.0225082635879517,
-0.10343533754348755,
0.46875274181365967,
-0.39958855509757996,
-0.09212387353181839,
0.7589343786239624,
0.7399911284446716,
0.12988655269145966,
0.11562702804803848,
0.47635409235954285,
0.21053887903690338,
0.10525597631931305,
0.13915260136127472,
0.5010883212089539,
-0.365165114402771,
0.9159233570098877,
-0.1638966053724289,
-0.24211643636226654,
-0.5538524389266968,
-0.6587122678756714,
-0.5131406784057617,
-0.6656979918479919,
-0.281929612159729,
-0.44647955894470215,
-0.14035861194133759,
0.699009358882904,
0.36383745074272156,
-0.8148627877235413,
0.0203639455139637,
0.07421489804983139,
0.24941247701644897,
-0.11544851213693619,
-0.299587219953537,
0.2681046724319458,
-0.572726845741272,
-0.6700605750083923,
0.13919757306575775,
0.6145110726356506,
-0.5675338506698608,
-0.26695406436920166,
0.1858372986316681,
-0.39886555075645447,
0.3750467896461487,
1.0249192714691162,
0.2358095645904541,
-0.29678040742874146,
-0.12331979721784592,
-0.16323885321617126,
-0.41840264201164246,
-0.001117914798669517,
0.6607034802436829,
-0.7214527130126953,
0.8388212323188782,
0.6073093414306641,
0.6949131488800049,
0.6703633666038513,
-0.006843160837888718,
0.14121805131435394,
-0.5776183605194092,
0.17420819401741028,
0.27842894196510315,
0.23396946489810944,
0.5329222679138184,
-0.13250280916690826,
0.7336544394493103,
0.4493362307548523,
-0.25346311926841736,
-0.36423227190971375,
0.3690436780452728,
-0.9405362606048584,
-0.18668758869171143,
1.0831269025802612,
0.07095295935869217,
-0.32139360904693604,
-0.45948633551597595,
-0.2728290855884552,
0.3649877905845642,
-0.3799773156642914,
0.7525247931480408,
1.1196110248565674,
0.09582015872001648,
0.04888176545500755,
-0.9534816145896912,
0.5271363258361816,
0.3140930235385895,
-0.6893588304519653,
-0.5093833804130554,
0.3347543776035309,
0.42545023560523987,
0.4447501003742218,
1.1331549882888794,
-0.41683468222618103,
-0.018543310463428497,
-0.045734703540802,
-0.017111675813794136,
-0.13380402326583862,
0.05345305800437927,
-0.263019859790802,
0.3352033793926239,
0.20301078259944916,
-0.4820210933685303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11028v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11028v1 | Universal Cross-Lingual Text Classification | 2024-06-16T17:58:29 | 2024-06-16T17:58:29 | Riya Savant, Anushka Shelke, Sakshi Todmal, Sanskruti Kanphade, Ananya Joshi, Raviraj Joshi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Text classification, an integral task in natural language processing,
involves the automatic categorization of text into predefined classes. Creating
supervised labeled datasets for low-resource languages poses a considerable
challenge. Unlocking the language potential of low-resource languages requires
robust datasets with supervised labels. However, such datasets are scarce, and
the label space is often limited. In our pursuit to address this gap, we aim to
optimize existing labels/datasets in different languages. This research
proposes a novel perspective on Universal Cross-Lingual Text Classification,
leveraging a unified model across languages. Our approach involves blending
supervised data from different languages during training to create a universal
model. The supervised data for a target classification task might come from
different languages covering different labels. The primary goal is to enhance
label and language coverage, aiming for a label set that represents a union of
labels from various languages. We propose the usage of a strong multilingual
SBERT as our base model, making our novel training strategy feasible. This
strategy contributes to the adaptability and effectiveness of the model in
cross-lingual language transfer scenarios, where it can categorize text in
languages not encountered during training. Thus, the paper delves into the
intricacies of cross-lingual text classification, with a particular focus on
its application for low-resource languages, exploring methodologies and
implications for the development of a robust and adaptable universal
cross-lingual model. | [
-0.2671375870704651,
-0.3211480975151062,
0.009981769137084484,
0.21829387545585632,
-0.17866043746471405,
0.1713947206735611,
-0.2700284421443939,
-0.8708395957946777,
-0.06636524200439453,
0.6096050143241882,
-0.3039417564868927,
-0.46643438935279846,
-0.5027256608009338,
0.22035180032253265,
-0.20633110404014587,
1.3534915447235107,
-0.16678600013256073,
0.16526758670806885,
0.11307764053344727,
-0.434683233499527,
-0.4930575489997864,
-0.7243502736091614,
-0.27398741245269775,
-0.6045830845832825,
0.40305548906326294,
0.4947759807109833,
0.3974340856075287,
0.24883054196834564,
0.14123453199863434,
0.2752494215965271,
-0.065243199467659,
0.09181167185306549,
-0.3942509591579437,
-0.0322653129696846,
-0.3833483159542084,
-0.35813698172569275,
-0.048094894737005234,
-0.10010304301977158,
0.6520152688026428,
0.9316126704216003,
0.10443838685750961,
-0.01815883442759514,
0.13683347404003143,
0.23520760238170624,
-0.4891054332256317,
-0.058784980326890945,
-0.6321861147880554,
0.35723862051963806,
-0.3276103436946869,
0.034632597118616104,
-0.5246692895889282,
0.006483312696218491,
0.1802791953086853,
-0.5764200687408447,
0.18908482789993286,
0.1625647246837616,
0.6558034420013428,
-0.07583489269018173,
-0.6668805480003357,
-0.2529944181442261,
-0.6946971416473389,
0.8457785844802856,
-0.25245124101638794,
0.7985435724258423,
0.1483343094587326,
0.3450927734375,
0.3549760580062866,
-0.47460290789604187,
-0.28849753737449646,
0.07942327111959457,
-0.08953940123319626,
-0.017580939456820488,
-0.10892261564731598,
-0.20862874388694763,
-0.22875425219535828,
0.32009437680244446,
-0.7013661861419678,
0.4410828948020935,
-0.2157248854637146,
-0.33680328726768494,
0.5410851240158081,
-0.010772288776934147,
0.7618469595909119,
-0.10516110062599182,
-0.7112239599227905,
-0.02134302631020546,
-0.5562165379524231,
0.11760944128036499,
0.12258963286876678,
0.6612532734870911,
-0.07780817151069641,
0.3118972182273865,
-0.094515860080719,
0.791455864906311,
-0.1616266667842865,
-0.16330775618553162,
0.051003895699977875,
-0.5323800444602966,
-0.3245256543159485,
0.36199042201042175,
0.8077657222747803,
-0.029541857540607452,
0.2951847314834595,
-0.4720035493373871,
-0.07760793715715408,
-0.08542511612176895,
0.10236258059740067,
-0.7619720697402954,
-0.1322321593761444,
-0.3520722985267639,
-0.18754731118679047,
-0.28043439984321594,
-0.0385744571685791,
-0.6089009046554565,
-0.15313652157783508,
-0.23297014832496643,
0.2663005292415619,
-0.19646327197551727,
-0.23863112926483154,
0.10465912520885468,
0.20103880763053894,
-0.09668741375207901,
0.18845954537391663,
-1.139646053314209,
0.2638521194458008,
0.4189130961894989,
0.5135620832443237,
-0.2681927978992462,
-0.5338000059127808,
-0.3994617760181427,
0.4107230007648468,
-0.2989819049835205,
0.7976065278053284,
-0.4953424036502838,
-0.39919158816337585,
0.005993235856294632,
0.22341085970401764,
-0.09728410094976425,
-0.1737985610961914,
0.5208250880241394,
-0.3795541524887085,
0.5455228686332703,
0.03209010139107704,
-0.29691261053085327,
-0.45621782541275024,
0.30243119597435,
-0.6544525623321533,
1.1265130043029785,
0.12598583102226257,
-0.9555420279502869,
0.4592632055282593,
-0.35609620809555054,
-0.7066964507102966,
0.2662743330001831,
-0.038970690220594406,
-0.19000869989395142,
-0.11934394389390945,
0.2261078655719757,
0.6063875555992126,
-0.593936562538147,
0.20033276081085205,
0.002905499190092087,
-0.28446200489997864,
0.2792162001132965,
-0.5114049911499023,
1.1019951105117798,
0.0418596975505352,
-0.2007976770401001,
-0.11841744929552078,
-0.6515163779258728,
0.22300761938095093,
-0.19816675782203674,
-0.44165247678756714,
-0.9180293679237366,
-0.5840961337089539,
0.715309739112854,
0.2265741527080536,
0.1964416652917862,
-0.5368267297744751,
0.13068445026874542,
-0.31267714500427246,
-0.011297971941530704,
0.3717404007911682,
-0.25140655040740967,
0.8562381267547607,
0.0030664263758808374,
0.5866073369979858,
-0.13572187721729279,
-0.03830540552735329,
-0.14120344817638397,
-0.47042855620384216,
-0.4406270682811737,
-0.36846229434013367,
0.7983080148696899,
0.9617644548416138,
-0.8118955492973328,
0.3796520531177521,
-0.3564103841781616,
-0.45226702094078064,
-0.5693836808204651,
0.5013989806175232,
0.7069522738456726,
0.385696679353714,
0.3130391240119934,
-0.2623981237411499,
-0.45769616961479187,
-0.7708966732025146,
-0.1799546778202057,
0.0004863739013671875,
0.04792290925979614,
0.04160961136221886,
0.22790805995464325,
-0.7167558073997498,
0.6456554532051086,
-0.2497718632221222,
-0.3787076473236084,
-0.6573988199234009,
0.2724355459213257,
-0.07321464270353317,
0.4035228192806244,
0.5714439153671265,
-1.0968456268310547,
-0.9386230111122131,
0.7268637418746948,
-0.8141406178474426,
-0.3470690846443176,
-0.1688918173313141,
-0.2420189380645752,
0.4672929048538208,
0.48964589834213257,
-0.15705284476280212,
0.28971245884895325,
0.5906535387039185,
-0.2677675485610962,
0.2969152629375458,
-0.24040758609771729,
0.11223075538873672,
-0.9651793241500854,
-0.012128257192671299,
0.1748242974281311,
-0.14490346610546112,
-0.9005056619644165,
0.04763398319482803,
0.06885252147912979,
-0.08705519139766693,
-0.536029040813446,
1.0181282758712769,
-0.4736286997795105,
0.10148098319768906,
-0.24260585010051727,
-0.07377583533525467,
0.031364209949970245,
0.5013247728347778,
0.24157953262329102,
0.48200610280036926,
0.6192444562911987,
-0.5256462693214417,
0.25364410877227783,
0.30446359515190125,
-0.16198468208312988,
0.9116429686546326,
-0.2510722279548645,
-0.21637971699237823,
-0.07593178749084473,
0.1328696757555008,
-0.9611257910728455,
-0.062140099704265594,
0.3560400903224945,
-0.2567943334579468,
0.5545521974563599,
-0.08315539360046387,
-0.36509305238723755,
-0.04534508287906647,
0.06454925239086151,
0.5952594876289368,
0.19531700015068054,
-0.7745298743247986,
0.5803008079528809,
0.5723893642425537,
-0.27397727966308594,
-0.48492804169654846,
-0.9899598956108093,
-0.015814512968063354,
-0.17056907713413239,
-0.47900331020355225,
0.3574866056442261,
-0.04670187830924988,
-0.028784556314349174,
0.08223258703947067,
-0.16229601204395294,
-0.4756840467453003,
-0.12996503710746765,
0.05686480551958084,
0.2858037054538727,
-0.14081774652004242,
0.24965593218803406,
0.3488183617591858,
-0.18568864464759827,
-0.49022671580314636,
-0.425126850605011,
0.1823505312204361,
-0.17787203192710876,
-0.14689233899116516,
-0.214217871427536,
0.6805035471916199,
0.3535834550857544,
-0.15378440916538239,
0.44017738103866577,
0.8100385665893555,
-0.35298654437065125,
-0.45442259311676025,
-0.2072838395833969,
0.38831576704978943,
-0.39982283115386963,
0.3149849474430084,
-0.5411320328712463,
-0.935948371887207,
0.3086652457714081,
0.07678045332431793,
0.0061748879961669445,
0.2626083195209503,
0.5219193696975708,
0.10710716992616653,
0.7712128758430481,
1.150027871131897,
-0.42255470156669617,
0.33592385053634644,
0.09553351998329163,
0.0717245563864708,
-0.4719158709049225,
-0.21007801592350006,
-0.635252833366394,
-0.027003632858395576,
-0.6228680610656738,
-0.4335346519947052,
0.0829799696803093,
-0.012190969660878181,
-0.07859960198402405,
0.5555444359779358,
-0.6258467435836792,
0.588524341583252,
0.44637981057167053,
-0.18486624956130981,
0.4103863537311554,
0.2582942247390747,
-0.2882094383239746,
-0.2279428243637085,
-0.9520785808563232,
-0.3120765686035156,
0.8347806930541992,
0.11596740782260895,
0.8091068863868713,
-0.1752341389656067,
0.55768883228302,
0.29558929800987244,
0.5574525594711304,
-0.5661273002624512,
0.40257859230041504,
-0.5470210909843445,
-0.7497071623802185,
-0.40830686688423157,
-0.6303248405456543,
-1.0192887783050537,
0.7526170611381531,
-0.15280364453792572,
-0.699262261390686,
0.018479418009519577,
-0.25832369923591614,
0.23300866782665253,
0.46540719270706177,
-0.6656331419944763,
1.200657606124878,
-0.6697801947593689,
0.02239830046892166,
0.19921894371509552,
-0.7230699062347412,
0.32498031854629517,
-0.4451276659965515,
0.4194318950176239,
0.06695039570331573,
0.010790538042783737,
0.6210170388221741,
0.025148870423436165,
0.9445876479148865,
0.2391054779291153,
-0.3751061260700226,
0.23571272194385529,
0.016399482265114784,
-0.030578281730413437,
-0.10004324465990067,
0.2581246495246887,
0.4226369857788086,
-0.11583562940359116,
-0.3795086145401001,
-0.23168815672397614,
0.5240018963813782,
-0.5766639113426208,
0.04607938230037689,
-0.5246105790138245,
-0.6762024164199829,
-0.341966837644577,
0.40736475586891174,
0.42740872502326965,
0.32640233635902405,
-0.5198883414268494,
-0.07053615897893906,
0.716783881187439,
-0.3328944444656372,
0.2077183872461319,
0.6626530885696411,
-0.32731860876083374,
-0.37506401538848877,
1.1747092008590698,
0.044465914368629456,
0.16741296648979187,
0.8391366004943848,
0.13920247554779053,
-0.31634581089019775,
-0.16269047558307648,
-0.6150965690612793,
0.16605393588542938,
-0.7578554153442383,
-0.2118588238954544,
-0.46749937534332275,
-0.1930871456861496,
-0.42388448119163513,
-0.39673173427581787,
-0.1389700472354889,
-0.3233858048915863,
-0.26706188917160034,
0.055929284542798996,
0.1516750156879425,
0.614782452583313,
-0.22158142924308777,
0.38214075565338135,
-0.9579594731330872,
0.4282872676849365,
0.3469736874103546,
0.3796003758907318,
-0.18374565243721008,
-0.37325015664100647,
-0.42355942726135254,
0.02627749554812908,
-0.09075058251619339,
-0.8535585403442383,
0.5269915461540222,
0.3259488344192505,
0.9988328814506531,
0.13108372688293457,
0.014891582541167736,
0.2427898496389389,
-0.5099740624427795,
0.2778567969799042,
0.43176397681236267,
-0.8816094994544983,
0.2870394289493561,
-0.24371042847633362,
0.4081668555736542,
0.5327861905097961,
0.7654524445533752,
-0.9929476380348206,
-0.3685474991798401,
-0.3886834979057312,
-0.759386420249939,
0.8269355893135071,
-0.04843522235751152,
-0.08311755955219269,
0.42665860056877136,
-0.11866994947195053,
0.4113471210002899,
0.006424122489988804,
-1.084975004196167,
0.04705113172531128,
-0.16726578772068024,
-0.43515846133232117,
-0.20646938681602478,
0.0701555609703064,
0.019022272899746895,
-0.2513922154903412,
0.6111446619033813,
-0.2184695303440094,
-0.1363462209701538,
-0.16415521502494812,
-0.4994739592075348,
-0.0629289373755455,
0.5121818780899048,
0.08182407915592194,
0.18850260972976685,
0.07582398504018784,
0.12780117988586426,
0.3206196129322052,
-0.45108264684677124,
0.364384263753891,
0.27407529950141907,
-0.44104719161987305,
0.18445555865764618,
0.21719367802143097,
0.7456396222114563,
0.5852488875389099,
-0.705469012260437,
0.20933309197425842,
-0.020957643166184425,
-0.03759346157312393,
0.33294761180877686,
-0.1973874270915985,
-0.06177150458097458,
0.16291096806526184,
0.25785741209983826,
-0.04883836209774017,
0.18779434263706207,
-0.5996605753898621,
0.16828565299510956,
0.32374799251556396,
-0.5273961424827576,
-0.3366723358631134,
0.48863935470581055,
0.23652435839176178,
-0.20617687702178955,
0.36673209071159363,
-0.18540795147418976,
-0.9071300625801086,
0.3771939277648926,
0.6870785355567932,
0.832267165184021,
-0.4151204526424408,
0.5499502420425415,
0.08319533616304398,
0.39283570647239685,
-0.16187384724617004,
-0.22122512757778168,
-0.2391083538532257,
-0.7591938972473145,
-0.2982015311717987,
-0.7445555925369263,
-0.6115809082984924,
-0.20840728282928467,
-0.5408120155334473,
0.08210097998380661,
-0.12486687302589417,
0.19831033051013947,
-0.0362430065870285,
-0.028992293402552605,
-0.5678679347038269,
0.4694453477859497,
0.41096439957618713,
0.715693473815918,
-1.218808889389038,
0.917258620262146,
0.9764366745948792,
-0.15806342661380768,
-0.3848041594028473,
-0.08925829082727432,
-0.09494210034608841,
-0.5392332077026367,
0.8563295006752014,
0.3329474925994873,
-0.13505227863788605,
-0.3285627067089081,
-0.262867271900177,
-0.6406201720237732,
0.48852598667144775,
0.12196366488933563,
-0.21625056862831116,
0.01846405118703842,
0.45967474579811096,
0.8270132541656494,
-0.38576391339302063,
-0.25648176670074463,
0.28403013944625854,
0.48972102999687195,
0.040810726583004,
-1.0472511053085327,
-0.039875179529190063,
-0.3725571930408478,
0.19065946340560913,
0.3491445779800415,
-0.3902758061885834,
0.7326174974441528,
0.012177509255707264,
-0.1549382358789444,
-0.06860201060771942,
0.6104142665863037,
0.11914079636335373,
0.38336771726608276,
0.39759060740470886,
0.5216638445854187,
0.6789168119430542,
-0.00837432686239481,
0.8649906516075134,
0.03196544945240021,
0.18312379717826843,
0.8237632513046265,
-0.40638598799705505,
0.6038191318511963,
0.16250135004520416,
-0.008638156577944756,
0.32317468523979187,
0.5907546877861023,
0.015877893194556236,
0.568036675453186,
0.026176011189818382,
-0.3230065405368805,
-0.30285289883613586,
-0.23877552151679993,
-0.30867519974708557,
0.4841367304325104,
0.24689967930316925,
0.08621900528669357,
-0.43311452865600586,
0.44310349225997925,
0.0013859699247404933,
0.07806965708732605,
-0.43814796209335327,
0.5352509617805481,
0.016034908592700958,
-0.3870847523212433,
0.5277358293533325,
0.10185376554727554,
0.9604963660240173,
-0.536143958568573,
0.2832474410533905,
-0.11960728466510773,
0.3750503361225128,
0.07346721738576889,
-0.7446205019950867,
0.12886568903923035,
0.11983813345432281,
-0.2035321742296219,
-0.5201857089996338,
0.8979462385177612,
-0.8959289193153381,
-0.7866894602775574,
0.5499712228775024,
0.3996540307998657,
0.09776199609041214,
0.17375575006008148,
-0.6744868159294128,
-0.08736389130353928,
0.13767582178115845,
0.007463863585144281,
0.6207394003868103,
0.960025429725647,
-0.369670033454895,
0.5730571150779724,
0.51141756772995,
0.09387572109699249,
0.06905370950698853,
-0.13280238211154938,
0.5328885316848755,
-0.6574889421463013,
-0.8203862905502319,
-0.3710625469684601,
0.3060990273952484,
0.11594375967979431,
-0.5114575028419495,
0.8419622778892517,
0.5529084801673889,
1.1786950826644897,
-0.07634252309799194,
0.9917688965797424,
0.06568903475999832,
0.6159576773643494,
-0.2962752878665924,
0.8148776888847351,
-0.9458341002464294,
-0.042633410543203354,
-0.3427775800228119,
-0.8177981972694397,
-0.46270373463630676,
0.4562944173812866,
0.07691140472888947,
-0.16436666250228882,
0.5000516772270203,
0.29859429597854614,
-0.2549315094947815,
0.02014579437673092,
0.28014254570007324,
-0.13430002331733704,
0.012787993997335434,
0.7136589288711548,
0.6164208650588989,
-0.36798274517059326,
0.953599750995636,
-0.20388992130756378,
-0.14363273978233337,
-0.27232858538627625,
-0.7086730599403381,
-1.0470824241638184,
-0.6281601190567017,
-0.13521350920200348,
-0.03345103561878204,
0.04360898584127426,
0.5003984570503235,
0.6331436634063721,
-0.9193692803382874,
-0.48051750659942627,
0.1592237800359726,
0.23462724685668945,
-0.13694408535957336,
-0.19012969732284546,
0.1066514179110527,
-0.3470747768878937,
-0.8009620904922485,
0.2089565396308899,
0.19742874801158905,
0.42264145612716675,
-0.16683971881866455,
-0.09160798043012619,
-0.317871630191803,
-0.162929967045784,
0.6335597038269043,
0.684862494468689,
-0.37334373593330383,
0.09704817086458206,
0.049187298864126205,
-0.5211912989616394,
-0.13425350189208984,
0.7054044604301453,
-0.5766274333000183,
0.4018946588039398,
0.5372148156166077,
1.0435285568237305,
0.48464563488960266,
-0.34465816617012024,
0.49529120326042175,
-0.958906352519989,
0.3673557937145233,
0.19868630170822144,
0.24341456592082977,
0.5240835547447205,
-0.29744014143943787,
0.6626133322715759,
0.18125873804092407,
-0.3869289457798004,
-0.9514710903167725,
0.21491216123104095,
-1.0213271379470825,
-0.7014081478118896,
1.0682730674743652,
-0.004783020354807377,
-0.09392665326595306,
-0.1800442636013031,
-0.35057148337364197,
0.28588247299194336,
-0.0583479180932045,
0.5195478200912476,
0.6905902624130249,
0.10430346429347992,
-0.0706140324473381,
-0.23501721024513245,
0.18033252656459808,
0.21977174282073975,
-1.0227183103561401,
0.056358207017183304,
0.37675902247428894,
0.22368326783180237,
0.3627936840057373,
0.6180577874183655,
0.12054480612277985,
0.1503305286169052,
-0.05833357572555542,
0.2179950326681137,
0.2526988983154297,
-0.6886283159255981,
-0.26630935072898865,
0.1580667942762375,
-0.5728256702423096,
0.006102732848376036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11025v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11025v1 | Large Language Models for Dysfluency Detection in Stuttered Speech | 2024-06-16T17:51:22 | 2024-06-16T17:51:22 | Dominik Wagner, Sebastian P. Bayerl, Ilja Baumann, Korbinian Riedhammer, Elmar Nöth, Tobias Bocklet | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Accurately detecting dysfluencies in spoken language can help to improve the
performance of automatic speech and language processing components and support
the development of more inclusive speech and language technologies. Inspired by
the recent trend towards the deployment of large language models (LLMs) as
universal learners and processors of non-lexical inputs, such as audio and
video, we approach the task of multi-label dysfluency detection as a language
modeling problem. We present hypotheses candidates generated with an automatic
speech recognition system and acoustic representations extracted from an audio
encoder model to an LLM, and finetune the system to predict dysfluency labels
on three datasets containing English and German stuttered speech. The
experimental results show that our system effectively combines acoustic and
lexical information and achieves competitive results on the multi-label
stuttering detection task. | [
-0.3555166721343994,
-1.0059796571731567,
0.5284239053726196,
0.2409139722585678,
0.019101060926914215,
0.23995362222194672,
-0.15508152544498444,
-0.6672912240028381,
0.21454107761383057,
0.5124942064285278,
-0.27031925320625305,
-0.10914213210344315,
-0.7793136239051819,
0.27406707406044006,
-0.6951096653938293,
0.7424120306968689,
0.09909394383430481,
0.21267665922641754,
-0.009254650212824345,
0.07817200571298599,
-0.5045099258422852,
-0.6987698078155518,
-0.7024884819984436,
-0.5071378350257874,
0.4777827560901642,
0.38880887627601624,
0.8376321196556091,
0.3119072914123535,
0.20264595746994019,
0.4279839098453522,
-0.29741546511650085,
-0.016586674377322197,
-0.27508535981178284,
0.5882018208503723,
0.28227531909942627,
-0.15504349768161774,
-0.5701634287834167,
-0.3673221170902252,
1.036353588104248,
0.736976683139801,
-0.10430037975311279,
-0.16471339762210846,
0.14199711382389069,
0.3222062587738037,
-0.2934131324291229,
0.18890447914600372,
-0.47556185722351074,
-0.02803342230618,
-0.41871750354766846,
0.031163597479462624,
-0.43333277106285095,
0.0720292404294014,
-0.33579185605049133,
-0.2498292177915573,
0.14194606244564056,
-0.06864654272794724,
0.3971148431301117,
0.3583123981952667,
-0.3703310787677765,
-0.5139186978340149,
-0.7721381783485413,
0.4682452380657196,
-0.5792654752731323,
1.0885326862335205,
0.48912739753723145,
0.0442141629755497,
-0.47963547706604004,
-0.5800268054008484,
-0.6934424042701721,
-0.5183262228965759,
0.14790691435337067,
-0.2558686435222626,
-0.3270243704319,
0.1369045525789261,
0.30898386240005493,
0.2630539536476135,
-0.832822322845459,
0.7679300308227539,
-0.1133420467376709,
-0.5366791486740112,
0.657990038394928,
-0.13813801109790802,
0.29126694798469543,
0.11633022874593735,
-0.06566596031188965,
0.05850643292069435,
-0.16978727281093597,
-0.276568740606308,
0.44616493582725525,
0.45139726996421814,
-0.00666871527209878,
0.3363780081272125,
-0.1921188235282898,
0.8366397023200989,
-0.306941956281662,
-0.546735405921936,
0.3629452884197235,
0.15366218984127045,
0.02886679209768772,
0.4433400630950928,
0.4660640060901642,
-0.1977936178445816,
0.49667492508888245,
-0.08104407042264938,
-0.6326870322227478,
0.022179557010531425,
-0.33270949125289917,
-0.5667122006416321,
-0.3965194523334503,
0.16214537620544434,
0.012055613100528717,
-0.03152022138237953,
-0.1667320877313614,
-0.7493112683296204,
-0.5678182244300842,
-0.20064429938793182,
0.33203282952308655,
-0.2816377282142639,
-0.47959277033805847,
0.11376571655273438,
-0.14111964404582977,
-0.4220128059387207,
0.05119984224438667,
-0.8778253197669983,
0.0491148941218853,
0.5630239844322205,
0.7222197651863098,
0.06605470925569534,
-0.2946286201477051,
-0.9577419757843018,
0.17552383244037628,
-0.22285668551921844,
0.673698902130127,
-0.6252856254577637,
-0.1844610571861267,
0.19183796644210815,
0.07411997765302658,
0.09617307037115097,
-0.4404521882534027,
0.6651327610015869,
-0.49111148715019226,
-0.29851165413856506,
0.16276635229587555,
-0.6517983078956604,
0.04176587238907814,
-0.07879176735877991,
-0.9310309886932373,
0.9462056756019592,
-0.06681721657514572,
-0.4713771343231201,
0.5199064612388611,
-0.4163069725036621,
-0.4926658570766449,
0.568474292755127,
0.13282260298728943,
-0.521314799785614,
0.2662563621997833,
0.2584128677845001,
0.6759936213493347,
0.058614134788513184,
0.7072277069091797,
-0.4372565448284149,
-0.3578323423862457,
0.6657293438911438,
-0.9925753474235535,
0.5322579741477966,
0.1358538419008255,
-0.04858052730560303,
-0.1328304409980774,
-0.8318920135498047,
-0.11901617050170898,
0.12319157272577286,
-0.5839596390724182,
-0.4328553378582001,
-0.1324835568666458,
0.3804565370082855,
0.0445953793823719,
0.05485149100422859,
-0.532685399055481,
0.16135267913341522,
-0.13997358083724976,
0.569657564163208,
0.3959421217441559,
-0.17499573528766632,
-0.09579259157180786,
0.03965374827384949,
0.36547112464904785,
0.1942686289548874,
-0.19800181686878204,
-0.2575583755970001,
-0.5294926762580872,
-0.6123363375663757,
-0.5578973889350891,
0.5437716841697693,
0.36312147974967957,
-0.83658367395401,
0.3749004602432251,
-0.1435355544090271,
-0.2112979292869568,
-0.4342549741268158,
0.30837830901145935,
0.30706337094306946,
0.5243716239929199,
0.3127516806125641,
0.06283841282129288,
-0.47502896189689636,
-0.8992542624473572,
-0.1759643703699112,
-0.2114870697259903,
-0.1261485517024994,
-0.1256069540977478,
0.513032853603363,
-0.319267600774765,
0.5313650965690613,
-0.405783087015152,
-0.48609599471092224,
-0.21925924718379974,
0.15350711345672607,
-0.19871313869953156,
0.29393109679222107,
0.4345240890979767,
-0.9555070996284485,
-0.3163376748561859,
-0.1810772866010666,
-0.35444530844688416,
-0.3660968840122223,
0.20708389580249786,
0.5643537044525146,
0.5042237043380737,
0.7351207733154297,
-0.07027396559715271,
0.15917588770389557,
0.8832535147666931,
-0.3830837905406952,
0.4631859064102173,
-0.20883353054523468,
0.16178357601165771,
-0.6506500840187073,
-0.2935493588447571,
0.37452569603919983,
-0.41470813751220703,
-0.9840836524963379,
-0.33781957626342773,
0.11437162756919861,
-0.16764019429683685,
-0.30520758032798767,
0.4193096458911896,
-0.316982239484787,
-0.040485430508852005,
-0.22460544109344482,
0.2640565037727356,
0.022006308659911156,
0.022376151755452156,
0.10887490957975388,
0.6234859824180603,
0.7760120034217834,
-0.5071690678596497,
0.6400032043457031,
-0.06996867805719376,
-0.33512023091316223,
0.6332087516784668,
-0.4355616569519043,
-0.01548007968813181,
-0.23040026426315308,
0.2535393536090851,
-1.4183331727981567,
-0.6749164462089539,
-0.05237196385860443,
-0.31221288442611694,
0.6485796570777893,
-0.1078115776181221,
-0.7288482785224915,
-0.6932333111763,
0.39279890060424805,
0.3189829885959625,
0.2843577563762665,
-0.6656278967857361,
0.17605985701084137,
0.7352330684661865,
-0.3628556430339813,
-0.28221070766448975,
-0.8815383911132812,
0.2568036615848541,
-0.19200818240642548,
-0.6240887641906738,
0.18073301017284393,
0.14168545603752136,
-0.133589506149292,
-0.1008974015712738,
0.05603073537349701,
-0.4741328954696655,
0.13226038217544556,
0.037493761628866196,
0.06481816619634628,
-0.12180303782224655,
0.6838967800140381,
-0.11247238516807556,
0.046729397028684616,
-0.13632744550704956,
-0.2019384503364563,
0.5824140906333923,
-0.24185700714588165,
-0.42939838767051697,
-0.5322523713111877,
0.5172620415687561,
0.6077591180801392,
-0.040033888071775436,
0.4647311866283417,
0.6907281279563904,
-0.6649981737136841,
-0.2341284602880478,
-0.8745666146278381,
-0.261928528547287,
-0.4757898151874542,
0.7754185795783997,
-0.4581475555896759,
-0.9371830821037292,
0.4461701810359955,
0.10339915007352829,
-0.3052613437175751,
0.11986162513494492,
0.4831210672855377,
-0.021695926785469055,
1.2131320238113403,
0.710780143737793,
-0.24006535112857819,
0.44795167446136475,
0.22086286544799805,
0.09002456814050674,
-0.33151426911354065,
-0.32826516032218933,
-0.6758029460906982,
-0.20633943378925323,
-0.3557340204715729,
-0.3157711923122406,
0.36594459414482117,
0.010162602178752422,
0.008535736240446568,
0.008608686737716198,
-0.42874717712402344,
0.5049458742141724,
0.2799707353115082,
-0.12626416981220245,
0.5673478245735168,
0.29948338866233826,
-0.1268816888332367,
-0.1751936823129654,
-0.8776147961616516,
-0.37653040885925293,
0.45693957805633545,
0.6816145777702332,
0.5719636082649231,
0.0316547267138958,
0.6418216228485107,
0.39986085891723633,
0.2410416454076767,
-0.8915755152702332,
0.297983855009079,
-0.32985150814056396,
-0.6361116766929626,
-0.545274019241333,
-0.45748838782310486,
-0.8400173187255859,
0.06647542864084244,
-0.28184759616851807,
-0.7260907292366028,
0.23275770246982574,
0.26470234990119934,
-0.1383141726255417,
0.37692520022392273,
-0.63560551404953,
0.5431253910064697,
-0.38828375935554504,
-0.2634143531322479,
-0.009553007781505585,
-0.0160268172621727,
0.4738881587982178,
-0.4345322847366333,
0.6133681535720825,
-0.11468666046857834,
0.11428803205490112,
0.9029197692871094,
-0.06852900236845016,
0.8609010577201843,
-0.2556299865245819,
-0.46226298809051514,
0.2557291090488434,
0.021792149171233177,
0.23849184811115265,
-0.04446934163570404,
-0.28666046261787415,
0.47185182571411133,
-0.10065446048974991,
-0.1382468342781067,
-0.29409030079841614,
0.8434684872627258,
-0.3816487789154053,
-0.5613517761230469,
-0.4969233572483063,
-0.5876771211624146,
-0.3674299716949463,
0.11170364171266556,
-0.00616060197353363,
0.5428597331047058,
-0.30494964122772217,
0.24883747100830078,
0.5870988965034485,
-0.024226287379860878,
0.6692286133766174,
0.5223894119262695,
-0.23116755485534668,
-0.336049348115921,
0.863000214099884,
0.4733964502811432,
0.14695240557193756,
-0.04946145787835121,
0.1178654208779335,
-0.5849206447601318,
-0.46411728858947754,
-0.4199371337890625,
0.3175278604030609,
-0.7594100832939148,
-0.24478183686733246,
-0.5541496872901917,
-0.2847338616847992,
-0.6000871658325195,
0.12742893397808075,
-0.34841862320899963,
-0.17777526378631592,
-0.35000190138816833,
0.09325561672449112,
0.5208654999732971,
0.8798861503601074,
-0.23532114923000336,
0.4108189344406128,
-0.8518419861793518,
0.3111160397529602,
0.3550960123538971,
0.5977430939674377,
0.02816423773765564,
-0.7923187613487244,
-0.28313592076301575,
0.09730445593595505,
-0.27557000517845154,
-1.1027523279190063,
0.6399455666542053,
0.45024099946022034,
0.6346834301948547,
0.3732586205005646,
-0.11548642069101334,
0.8034215569496155,
-0.32535889744758606,
0.47681376338005066,
0.3062913119792938,
-0.9990021586418152,
0.38576531410217285,
-0.10140789300203323,
0.15167655050754547,
0.09690311551094055,
0.6451135277748108,
-0.7308652400970459,
-0.43254968523979187,
-0.3607847988605499,
-0.7621002793312073,
0.5159023404121399,
0.04108961671590805,
-0.045080121606588364,
0.009374787099659443,
0.22878871858119965,
-0.07043685764074326,
0.03295443207025528,
-0.7902087569236755,
0.048664674162864685,
0.006891282740980387,
-0.08549988269805908,
-0.3529779016971588,
-0.45935431122779846,
-0.10598152875900269,
-0.15399520099163055,
0.6088575124740601,
-0.09695416688919067,
-0.13283656537532806,
0.2639916241168976,
-0.18605124950408936,
-0.14021514356136322,
0.4427471160888672,
0.41936469078063965,
0.18842077255249023,
0.155939981341362,
0.21775583922863007,
0.19681839644908905,
-0.619137704372406,
0.4904153048992157,
0.37458112835884094,
0.09707342833280563,
0.11387845873832703,
0.5109330415725708,
0.8601735234260559,
0.3084438741207123,
-0.8026981949806213,
0.27052149176597595,
0.10862202197313309,
-0.3596709668636322,
-0.3883053958415985,
0.003172449069097638,
0.1918814331293106,
0.3829059302806854,
0.5349643230438232,
-0.3346153795719147,
0.14018778502941132,
-0.5616318583488464,
0.43094125390052795,
0.47154033184051514,
-0.46774575114250183,
-0.07677682489156723,
0.6567226052284241,
0.20670761168003082,
-0.5943530201911926,
0.6098031401634216,
-0.28774306178092957,
-0.5786882638931274,
0.6035434603691101,
0.7589588165283203,
0.5719541311264038,
-0.6793303489685059,
0.08312755078077316,
0.01209201943129301,
0.23585809767246246,
-0.3206619918346405,
0.11382308602333069,
0.271382212638855,
-0.749186098575592,
-0.47239136695861816,
-0.7190468311309814,
-0.15614835917949677,
0.49401238560676575,
-0.48701491951942444,
0.4242132902145386,
0.0074384487234056,
-0.3207501471042633,
0.346547394990921,
-0.20761273801326752,
-0.5728680491447449,
0.04218132793903351,
0.7843939661979675,
0.45635369420051575,
-1.2499700784683228,
0.9968538880348206,
0.4939051568508148,
-0.11698678880929947,
-0.7037758827209473,
0.08617281913757324,
0.07363838702440262,
-0.639474630355835,
0.8190255761146545,
0.2350708395242691,
-0.02531488798558712,
0.044252652674913406,
-0.17544718086719513,
-0.9954255223274231,
0.6015446782112122,
0.4541027843952179,
-1.1125199794769287,
0.24328821897506714,
0.22592784464359283,
0.5943670868873596,
-0.2661644518375397,
0.019285017624497414,
0.8043569922447205,
0.6664968132972717,
0.22069090604782104,
-1.2365738153457642,
-0.22761976718902588,
0.2553924024105072,
-0.25448086857795715,
0.1658628135919571,
-0.4471108913421631,
0.7237891554832458,
-0.07591155916452408,
-0.17672540247440338,
-0.26991745829582214,
0.5662344098091125,
0.4320099353790283,
0.48854076862335205,
0.7789285182952881,
0.38635358214378357,
1.0874959230422974,
-0.2569446563720703,
0.5852647423744202,
-0.15383704006671906,
0.0032830771524459124,
0.719205915927887,
-0.30822470784187317,
0.8342161178588867,
0.3015262186527252,
-0.028102606534957886,
0.1652134209871292,
0.47909092903137207,
-0.11746096611022949,
0.07407117635011673,
0.2448197454214096,
-0.33071503043174744,
-0.4507105052471161,
-0.21121501922607422,
-0.3613705337047577,
0.8252784609794617,
0.773174524307251,
-0.18328581750392914,
-0.1250775307416916,
0.4651198387145996,
-0.05213114991784096,
0.03341740369796753,
-0.5233516097068787,
0.6594153046607971,
0.035603296011686325,
-0.5741420984268188,
1.0107916593551636,
-0.07120972126722336,
0.8157539367675781,
-0.30114784836769104,
0.016466336324810982,
0.0056155347265303135,
0.22864681482315063,
-0.25539401173591614,
-0.6959969401359558,
0.21955353021621704,
-0.025027811527252197,
0.01971443183720112,
-0.23239408433437347,
0.8866400718688965,
-0.8698310256004333,
-0.7581567764282227,
0.4409962594509125,
0.34131407737731934,
0.4029808044433594,
-0.08383112400770187,
-0.5368039011955261,
0.49616801738739014,
-0.09247495979070663,
-0.20114372670650482,
0.31849271059036255,
0.4459109604358673,
-0.11155209690332413,
0.7753434777259827,
0.41497135162353516,
0.2668188810348511,
0.02161986194550991,
0.3366994857788086,
0.8251617550849915,
-0.3409505784511566,
-0.5098482966423035,
-0.7527840733528137,
0.31214895844459534,
-0.05688384175300598,
-0.006656465586274862,
0.5318592190742493,
0.34805846214294434,
0.601992666721344,
0.04427996650338173,
0.7622389197349548,
0.2226531058549881,
0.28187036514282227,
-0.5197892785072327,
0.6895641684532166,
-0.7228873372077942,
0.13599736988544464,
-0.3914085924625397,
-0.8380997776985168,
-0.5270694494247437,
0.5399789214134216,
-0.03045564331114292,
0.07674821466207504,
0.30135926604270935,
0.8719587922096252,
0.0013280212879180908,
-0.018914945423603058,
0.7159035801887512,
0.37678542733192444,
0.3702426254749298,
0.3849482238292694,
0.7565552592277527,
-0.18525679409503937,
0.6535456776618958,
-0.07505462318658829,
-0.4688678979873657,
-0.5119919180870056,
-0.9647621512413025,
-0.7286556363105774,
-0.8055102229118347,
-0.5018178820610046,
-0.31232380867004395,
0.1203097328543663,
0.6525301933288574,
0.6582451462745667,
-0.6800580024719238,
-0.2224423885345459,
0.22677062451839447,
0.28927668929100037,
-0.1651575118303299,
-0.22725695371627808,
-0.05345897004008293,
-0.23591561615467072,
-0.9826247692108154,
0.75692218542099,
0.17992562055587769,
0.5495225787162781,
-0.5591864585876465,
0.08173526078462601,
-0.018772857263684273,
-0.09360500425100327,
0.6028016209602356,
0.23504376411437988,
-0.7083816528320312,
-0.21489167213439941,
-0.21158526837825775,
0.14836004376411438,
-0.18805921077728271,
0.6414315104484558,
-0.6499666571617126,
0.39086636900901794,
0.330007940530777,
0.31064915657043457,
0.3701074421405792,
-0.29472434520721436,
0.24729563295841217,
-0.9369425177574158,
0.601995587348938,
0.46209073066711426,
0.48242664337158203,
0.49014341831207275,
-0.41810834407806396,
-0.02045002020895481,
0.18550480902194977,
-0.6821772456169128,
-1.2950001955032349,
0.3292151093482971,
-0.5079560875892639,
-0.3792409598827362,
1.170941710472107,
0.040255188941955566,
0.06520328670740128,
-0.5580945611000061,
0.0768558457493782,
0.334456205368042,
-0.5763466954231262,
0.6382703185081482,
0.93719482421875,
-0.1443759649991989,
-0.14547045528888702,
-0.7116677761077881,
0.4317445755004883,
0.26002198457717896,
-0.2125626653432846,
0.3006978929042816,
0.7984598278999329,
0.3078818619251251,
0.22981847822666168,
0.37775683403015137,
0.1346462368965149,
-0.041813816875219345,
0.23397772014141083,
0.014559662900865078,
-0.35729801654815674,
-0.5895377993583679,
-0.69149249792099,
0.37684205174446106,
0.05369199439883232,
0.13895553350448608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11020v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11020v1 | RUPBench: Benchmarking Reasoning Under Perturbations for Robustness Evaluation in Large Language Models | 2024-06-16T17:26:44 | 2024-06-16T17:26:44 | Yuqing Wang, Yun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the increasing use of large language models (LLMs), ensuring reliable
performance in diverse, real-world environments is essential. Despite their
remarkable achievements, LLMs often struggle with adversarial inputs,
significantly impacting their effectiveness in practical applications. To
systematically understand the robustness of LLMs, we present RUPBench, a
comprehensive benchmark designed to evaluate LLM robustness across diverse
reasoning tasks. Our benchmark incorporates 15 reasoning datasets, categorized
into commonsense, arithmetic, logical, and knowledge-intensive reasoning, and
introduces nine types of textual perturbations at lexical, syntactic, and
semantic levels. By examining the performance of state-of-the-art LLMs such as
GPT-4o, Llama3, Phi-3, and Gemma on both original and perturbed datasets, we
provide a detailed analysis of their robustness and error patterns. Our
findings highlight that larger models tend to exhibit greater robustness to
perturbations. Additionally, common error types are identified through manual
inspection, revealing specific challenges faced by LLMs in different reasoning
contexts. This work provides insights into areas where LLMs need further
improvement to handle diverse and noisy inputs effectively. | [
-0.2397344708442688,
-1.0102754831314087,
0.6822835206985474,
0.2241908460855484,
-0.018500827252864838,
-0.06365431100130081,
-0.31002748012542725,
-0.2006951868534088,
-0.40726861357688904,
0.44068968296051025,
-0.4311668872833252,
-0.6275099515914917,
-0.7996466755867004,
0.1229180246591568,
-0.4404577314853668,
0.6568222045898438,
-0.012715577147901058,
0.2812667787075043,
-0.3937661051750183,
-0.2612271010875702,
-0.44243910908699036,
-0.5754162669181824,
-0.06090984493494034,
-0.5408808588981628,
0.5003277063369751,
0.35157763957977295,
0.8107815384864807,
0.5115751624107361,
0.6682672500610352,
0.34218326210975647,
-0.15688380599021912,
-0.014997478574514389,
-0.43829345703125,
0.6642509698867798,
-0.33598682284355164,
-0.5360935926437378,
-0.30010494589805603,
-0.1720932275056839,
0.7929590344429016,
0.6934425234794617,
-0.23902370035648346,
0.1468464881181717,
0.16129471361637115,
0.34873390197753906,
-0.8894538879394531,
0.03613967448472977,
-0.8474293351173401,
-0.09384910017251968,
-0.4096524119377136,
0.056199733167886734,
-0.47788190841674805,
-0.17209742963314056,
-0.14892889559268951,
-0.3443054258823395,
-0.03497656062245369,
-0.17579519748687744,
0.9695530533790588,
0.6528233885765076,
-0.1854054182767868,
0.02166125923395157,
-0.5456583499908447,
0.9588090777397156,
-0.7895448803901672,
0.5448082685470581,
0.30130836367607117,
0.4083436131477356,
-0.6705101132392883,
-0.9086746573448181,
-0.3800587058067322,
-0.368948370218277,
-0.04088621959090233,
-0.030675601214170456,
-0.34554052352905273,
-0.05434393510222435,
0.5746305584907532,
0.19676263630390167,
-0.6503997445106506,
0.24193483591079712,
0.3929922878742218,
-0.2344851940870285,
0.2653942406177521,
0.2587282657623291,
0.22107669711112976,
-0.04090683534741402,
-0.20582972466945648,
-0.4569934010505676,
-0.6930396556854248,
-0.11816030740737915,
0.5238549709320068,
0.11587876081466675,
0.03203950077295303,
0.5269730687141418,
-0.24282722175121307,
0.8509490489959717,
-0.26968541741371155,
-0.24249793589115143,
-0.012932365760207176,
-0.25101467967033386,
-0.21779093146324158,
-0.5181075930595398,
0.7877570390701294,
0.15407702326774597,
0.2114909291267395,
-0.08702243864536285,
-0.29230254888534546,
0.18680612742900848,
0.03230825066566467,
-0.6112266778945923,
-0.30803635716438293,
0.13503439724445343,
-0.18344056606292725,
-0.3170658051967621,
-0.07381942123174667,
-1.0707893371582031,
-0.6464279294013977,
-0.022942349314689636,
0.16463133692741394,
-0.2924945652484894,
-0.031007738783955574,
0.20726709067821503,
0.0498826690018177,
0.13532672822475433,
0.3681303560733795,
-0.7141648530960083,
0.3673161268234253,
0.798011302947998,
0.3507477641105652,
-0.13883458077907562,
-0.47254082560539246,
-0.8680121898651123,
-0.008579357527196407,
-0.15260514616966248,
0.9814740419387817,
-0.7923768162727356,
-0.21045218408107758,
-0.1334899514913559,
-0.2784433662891388,
-0.11147350072860718,
-0.6027854681015015,
0.9075063467025757,
-0.43779051303863525,
0.003339327871799469,
-0.29939162731170654,
-0.37510934472084045,
0.03432634472846985,
0.5230724811553955,
-0.6627615094184875,
1.0816830396652222,
0.03144775703549385,
-0.9412040114402771,
0.41247808933258057,
-0.25549113750457764,
-0.4642845094203949,
-0.02978823333978653,
-0.33645856380462646,
-0.42301878333091736,
0.105901800096035,
0.3246113359928131,
0.2914452850818634,
-0.6331602931022644,
0.2077682465314865,
-0.77535480260849,
-0.32444068789482117,
0.6752640604972839,
-0.5877748727798462,
0.7860114574432373,
0.09970927238464355,
-0.359370619058609,
0.36265769600868225,
-0.8965421319007874,
0.18295128643512726,
0.1825224757194519,
-0.3604564666748047,
-0.12259401381015778,
0.23804406821727753,
-0.11843249946832657,
0.08313071727752686,
0.037172164767980576,
-0.20329821109771729,
0.07342900335788727,
-0.13463732600212097,
0.5113970041275024,
0.7313953042030334,
-0.15567918121814728,
-0.0794946551322937,
-0.23813503980636597,
0.6869232058525085,
-0.16574226319789886,
-0.06986857205629349,
-0.11718665063381195,
-0.24468781054019928,
-0.7025023102760315,
-0.3467349112033844,
0.6003831624984741,
0.718603253364563,
-0.2556414306163788,
0.38963407278060913,
-0.2757508456707001,
-0.3968243896961212,
-0.1644594520330429,
0.27843567728996277,
0.2539333999156952,
0.47966864705085754,
0.25044766068458557,
-0.03679497167468071,
-0.43360766768455505,
-0.8696692585945129,
-0.6406954526901245,
-0.13967616856098175,
-0.03621575981378555,
0.12889525294303894,
0.5192487239837646,
-0.2582441568374634,
0.47906532883644104,
-0.15994477272033691,
0.055502668023109436,
-0.33025628328323364,
0.12029635161161423,
0.07058130204677582,
0.22826220095157623,
0.26763272285461426,
-0.39929670095443726,
-0.179192915558815,
-0.08576091378927231,
-0.6010406017303467,
-0.4284427762031555,
-0.12216781824827194,
0.016819603741168976,
0.335453063249588,
0.48433375358581543,
-0.6084741950035095,
0.43024829030036926,
0.7732293605804443,
-0.2954767048358917,
0.677291989326477,
0.01257463451474905,
-0.016348538920283318,
-0.6601351499557495,
0.16459709405899048,
-0.06735483556985855,
-0.26097190380096436,
-0.14193306863307953,
0.3945437967777252,
-0.07704627513885498,
0.04930499568581581,
-0.03701816499233246,
0.25925108790397644,
-0.35911571979522705,
-0.1905432939529419,
-0.00623534619808197,
0.29325491189956665,
0.008813214488327503,
0.05205667391419411,
-0.16576260328292847,
0.6737003922462463,
0.5655853152275085,
-0.2967131435871124,
0.5684282779693604,
0.014986904338002205,
-0.437813937664032,
0.40413743257522583,
-0.6618043184280396,
0.21832376718521118,
0.1542680710554123,
0.42975422739982605,
-0.9323230981826782,
-0.3965330719947815,
0.0035520142409950495,
-0.4009902775287628,
0.19757921993732452,
-0.28522205352783203,
-0.8545899391174316,
0.031194372102618217,
-0.17313992977142334,
0.2397715300321579,
0.25433051586151123,
-0.5329480767250061,
0.811880886554718,
0.25683826208114624,
-0.0964781865477562,
-0.8376766443252563,
-0.6409198641777039,
0.2016099989414215,
-0.36560216546058655,
-0.7989698052406311,
-0.12391170859336853,
0.07041548192501068,
-0.5847179293632507,
-0.08896470814943314,
-0.2811443507671356,
0.07764337211847305,
0.38068071007728577,
0.14637701213359833,
0.16800320148468018,
-0.09748079627752304,
-0.13412164151668549,
-0.2623080611228943,
-0.22337029874324799,
0.16348858177661896,
0.021301960572600365,
0.7044883370399475,
-0.41982701420783997,
-0.6264452934265137,
-0.1803382933139801,
0.08666514605283737,
0.6485439538955688,
-0.2809165120124817,
0.4779217541217804,
0.49806684255599976,
-0.30896326899528503,
-0.535193920135498,
-0.6669893860816956,
-0.25718167424201965,
-0.4405994415283203,
0.42717888951301575,
-0.5569812059402466,
-0.8225950598716736,
0.707664966583252,
-0.10796615481376648,
-0.02234828844666481,
0.2685242295265198,
0.6381915211677551,
0.038306497037410736,
0.8908029794692993,
0.20355618000030518,
-0.014232135377824306,
0.19396014511585236,
0.1538771241903305,
0.0501474067568779,
-0.44085946679115295,
-0.05587351322174072,
-0.7872219681739807,
-0.19819375872612,
-0.5741909146308899,
-0.5533244609832764,
0.1585615873336792,
0.11949510872364044,
-0.2400592565536499,
0.20546957850456238,
-0.13465267419815063,
0.527070164680481,
0.4218136966228485,
-0.32737141847610474,
0.48910561203956604,
0.05362050235271454,
-0.46396204829216003,
-0.14963172376155853,
-0.7393202185630798,
-0.7100462913513184,
1.0223479270935059,
0.40137457847595215,
1.104810118675232,
0.17461173236370087,
0.37001535296440125,
-0.06914043426513672,
0.2019282430410385,
-0.5645513534545898,
0.6978276968002319,
-0.13932277262210846,
-0.5817644596099854,
-0.14996396005153656,
-0.639632523059845,
-0.8615548014640808,
0.471986323595047,
-0.39865630865097046,
-0.990686297416687,
0.09394045174121857,
0.13373246788978577,
-0.06097180023789406,
0.36343103647232056,
-0.4623786509037018,
1.0251480340957642,
-0.3619967997074127,
-0.6571295857429504,
-0.3275120258331299,
-0.5161839723587036,
0.3710739314556122,
0.06985840946435928,
0.16108782589435577,
-0.10523024946451187,
-0.0702047124505043,
0.181326761841774,
-0.2044134885072708,
0.6503763198852539,
0.17691640555858612,
-0.15378019213676453,
0.1048727035522461,
0.4504375457763672,
0.6726722717285156,
0.17709608376026154,
-0.13713721930980682,
0.28912994265556335,
0.1499469131231308,
-0.37733325362205505,
-0.5947638154029846,
0.8836077451705933,
-0.6035667061805725,
-0.617543637752533,
-0.6258814334869385,
-0.6883208155632019,
-0.6702163219451904,
0.273061603307724,
0.327759712934494,
0.4207177460193634,
-0.18099425733089447,
0.4281034469604492,
0.6921833157539368,
-0.24911364912986755,
0.21415121853351593,
0.46564674377441406,
-0.21733303368091583,
-0.40386396646499634,
0.588940441608429,
0.014601757749915123,
0.3282215893268585,
0.34099388122558594,
0.21830891072750092,
-0.23906277120113373,
-0.819231390953064,
-0.3653815984725952,
0.016356678679585457,
-0.9630352854728699,
-0.1376478523015976,
-0.3726195693016052,
0.1316070556640625,
-0.2918492555618286,
0.18537653982639313,
-0.34130001068115234,
-0.37707072496414185,
0.0019922414794564247,
-0.010561131872236729,
-0.05626097321510315,
0.6238084435462952,
0.05493133142590523,
-0.05499015375971794,
-0.628711462020874,
0.17845779657363892,
0.28604915738105774,
0.6419563889503479,
-0.20052912831306458,
-0.45415687561035156,
0.17236445844173431,
-0.2926504909992218,
-0.26544106006622314,
-0.8083353638648987,
-0.07013428211212158,
-0.05518344044685364,
0.7695776224136353,
0.26302334666252136,
0.03450283780694008,
0.6028281450271606,
-0.15045513212680817,
0.5470494031906128,
-0.1418917328119278,
-0.9346681237220764,
0.4230404794216156,
-0.6063038110733032,
0.38603198528289795,
0.60960853099823,
-0.01311931200325489,
-0.26275938749313354,
-0.34354516863822937,
-0.5355600118637085,
-0.8618891835212708,
0.4189946949481964,
0.025973454117774963,
-0.19275178015232086,
0.20043465495109558,
0.16799521446228027,
0.0415344312787056,
-0.09554092586040497,
-0.87675940990448,
0.004556025378406048,
-0.10518061369657516,
-0.04603986814618111,
0.19266384840011597,
-0.3102891743183136,
-0.3378746807575226,
-0.07776396721601486,
0.6054822206497192,
-0.1208096444606781,
-0.23911048471927643,
-0.056406810879707336,
-0.22773365676403046,
-0.1724400818347931,
0.4944465756416321,
0.5273399353027344,
0.8479971885681152,
0.00721137598156929,
0.2772631049156189,
0.48517125844955444,
-0.2540076673030853,
-0.07523172348737717,
0.32418936491012573,
-0.16011404991149902,
-0.29583877325057983,
0.623149037361145,
0.573529839515686,
0.20138993859291077,
-1.069819688796997,
0.3481515645980835,
-0.2736571133136749,
-0.044305212795734406,
-0.264009028673172,
0.183041051030159,
0.13053499162197113,
0.11207691580057144,
0.0001800811296561733,
0.03310394287109375,
0.04636198654770851,
-0.4340508282184601,
0.07944180071353912,
0.5552155375480652,
-0.06996385008096695,
-0.09854119271039963,
0.5442231297492981,
-0.0175258070230484,
0.006509996019303799,
0.5921517014503479,
0.06746140867471695,
-0.3935096263885498,
0.274632066488266,
0.48662787675857544,
0.7196192145347595,
0.019822049885988235,
-0.24344328045845032,
0.23594515025615692,
0.5396262407302856,
-0.1256519854068756,
0.15188026428222656,
0.15810438990592957,
-0.7842016816139221,
-0.728905439376831,
-0.465246319770813,
-0.6715612411499023,
0.4633239507675171,
-0.6327613592147827,
0.25183841586112976,
-0.752500593662262,
-0.2040349692106247,
-0.05911700800061226,
-0.08299476653337479,
-0.4244453012943268,
0.03845984488725662,
0.0903904139995575,
0.937934935092926,
-0.631648063659668,
0.6833924055099487,
1.0118149518966675,
-0.17442825436592102,
-0.8595947623252869,
0.22411251068115234,
0.2906140983104706,
-0.5695851445198059,
0.32500511407852173,
-0.06984186917543411,
-0.43375831842422485,
-0.3927391469478607,
-0.5409714579582214,
-0.801871657371521,
0.7980358004570007,
0.8309780359268188,
-0.715448260307312,
0.4239049255847931,
0.18782354891300201,
0.5111908316612244,
-0.05263981968164444,
0.20621061325073242,
0.8826127052307129,
0.7275769114494324,
0.014677458442747593,
-0.7482286691665649,
0.12872180342674255,
-0.1858234405517578,
-0.1568809598684311,
0.14747081696987152,
-0.636682391166687,
0.5957792401313782,
-0.04849296808242798,
-0.18634068965911865,
0.2747347056865692,
0.4629630148410797,
0.558242917060852,
-0.10339387506246567,
0.5758833289146423,
0.9792703986167908,
0.7699642181396484,
-0.5011681318283081,
1.1475287675857544,
-0.27055245637893677,
0.14769800007343292,
1.2706818580627441,
-0.45459163188934326,
0.9184242486953735,
0.3071329593658447,
-0.3277817964553833,
0.6319160461425781,
0.38658085465431213,
-0.1393989473581314,
-0.014573263935744762,
0.40056899189949036,
-0.15338847041130066,
-0.6725287437438965,
0.19297632575035095,
-0.230599507689476,
0.5206597447395325,
0.3833391070365906,
0.013417874462902546,
-0.34789571166038513,
-0.4827116131782532,
0.0499698780477047,
0.32584694027900696,
0.15743914246559143,
0.5969775915145874,
-0.016586270183324814,
-0.7737625241279602,
0.59339839220047,
0.0511542484164238,
0.4233633875846863,
-0.705755352973938,
-0.05438172444701195,
-0.20327328145503998,
0.596219003200531,
-0.320056289434433,
-0.7983899116516113,
0.11753297597169876,
0.07138539105653763,
0.03402365744113922,
-0.07455527782440186,
0.8923873901367188,
-0.061924804002046585,
-0.4217263162136078,
0.4804224669933319,
0.35673972964286804,
-0.005028229672461748,
0.10671817511320114,
-0.7293127179145813,
0.6366742849349976,
-0.10117751359939575,
-0.3143911063671112,
0.5591425895690918,
0.4695233404636383,
-0.06882286071777344,
0.9347877502441406,
0.5654609799385071,
0.198396697640419,
-0.0031958369072526693,
0.3024575412273407,
0.8367342948913574,
-0.555565357208252,
-0.09630884230136871,
-0.9077419638633728,
0.4291675388813019,
-0.033581722527742386,
-0.47844693064689636,
0.9731366038322449,
0.3396645486354828,
0.733497679233551,
0.22604401409626007,
0.7424870729446411,
0.1191459372639656,
0.495155930519104,
-0.4275371730327606,
0.43196728825569153,
-0.28041183948516846,
0.6674144864082336,
-0.4247371256351471,
-1.0058674812316895,
-0.5530298352241516,
0.8422467112541199,
-0.3568113446235657,
0.13677817583084106,
0.6389372944831848,
0.7951817512512207,
0.03916436433792114,
0.1011415347456932,
0.2816416323184967,
0.40980881452560425,
0.31857940554618835,
0.3219597637653351,
1.0803980827331543,
-0.07875896990299225,
0.8340592980384827,
-0.17514678835868835,
-0.22137507796287537,
-0.03175196051597595,
-1.2300870418548584,
-0.8464695811271667,
-0.1704459935426712,
-0.2811988890171051,
-0.6478398442268372,
0.12351509183645248,
0.5741477608680725,
0.5552229285240173,
-0.9204158782958984,
-0.2894706726074219,
-0.24197952449321747,
0.2886635661125183,
-0.18594588339328766,
-0.21060588955879211,
0.10084334760904312,
-0.47414082288742065,
-0.532180666923523,
0.5952996611595154,
0.17042356729507446,
-0.23412151634693146,
-0.43533575534820557,
0.15659599006175995,
-0.01626262255012989,
0.05527060106396675,
0.29484695196151733,
0.19572409987449646,
-0.7761574387550354,
-0.30743107199668884,
-0.1701490879058838,
-0.009571085684001446,
-0.05557917430996895,
0.7519105076789856,
-0.6782211065292358,
0.31423622369766235,
0.7020901441574097,
0.707951009273529,
0.4070271849632263,
0.07653404772281647,
0.5744280219078064,
-0.4114534854888916,
0.07724738121032715,
0.3303467631340027,
0.6337140202522278,
0.4787959158420563,
0.06096719577908516,
0.5668039321899414,
0.1615365445613861,
-0.7414190173149109,
-1.0843676328659058,
0.4023713171482086,
-0.9163437485694885,
-0.3336697816848755,
1.2626373767852783,
-0.3196582496166229,
0.00013868276437278837,
-0.07970011979341507,
0.05734211951494217,
-0.18978941440582275,
-0.21289728581905365,
0.6182669997215271,
1.1109572649002075,
-0.07356119900941849,
-0.28644970059394836,
-0.5545439720153809,
0.19065697491168976,
0.7615998387336731,
-0.7772969603538513,
0.41759854555130005,
0.8113523721694946,
0.6359314322471619,
-0.030916189774870872,
0.08803888410329819,
-0.4128105342388153,
0.26267075538635254,
0.2691338360309601,
-0.23049364984035492,
-0.01563742570579052,
-0.24823951721191406,
-0.4397396743297577,
0.37654900550842285,
0.4522867500782013,
0.32376736402511597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11016v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11016v1 | Optimized Speculative Sampling for GPU Hardware Accelerators | 2024-06-16T17:19:23 | 2024-06-16T17:19:23 | Dominik Wagner, Seanie Lee, Ilja Baumann, Philipp Seeberger, Korbinian Riedhammer, Tobias Bocklet | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In this work, we optimize speculative sampling for parallel hardware
accelerators to improve sampling speed. We notice that substantial portions of
the intermediate matrices necessary for speculative sampling can be computed
concurrently. This allows us to distribute the workload across multiple GPU
threads, enabling simultaneous operations on matrix segments within thread
blocks. Additionally, we use fast on-chip memory to store intermediate results,
thereby minimizing the frequency of slow read and write operations across
different types of memory. This results in profiling time improvements ranging
from 6% to 13% relative to the baseline implementation, without compromising
accuracy. To further accelerate speculative sampling, probability distributions
parameterized by softmax are approximated by sigmoid. This approximation
approach results in significantly greater relative improvements in profiling
time, ranging from 37% to 94%, with a slight decline in accuracy. We conduct
extensive experiments on both automatic speech recognition and summarization
tasks to validate the effectiveness of our optimization methods. | [
-0.6984533667564392,
-1.0324512720108032,
0.7315137386322021,
0.11983738094568253,
-0.26308923959732056,
0.3857550621032715,
-0.2118844985961914,
-0.38595497608184814,
0.28400522470474243,
-0.07190591841936111,
-0.37406590580940247,
-0.12798957526683807,
-0.42450952529907227,
-0.24808503687381744,
-0.22115124762058258,
0.7299087643623352,
-0.04392791539430618,
-0.26699185371398926,
-0.15031291544437408,
-0.0022296099923551083,
-0.15899258852005005,
-0.2316531240940094,
-0.7467434406280518,
-0.05214401334524155,
0.3157086968421936,
0.3887563943862915,
0.395832896232605,
0.7703948020935059,
0.481685608625412,
0.3120719790458679,
-0.11141713708639145,
0.08886967599391937,
-0.5647437572479248,
0.08469315618276596,
0.3293372392654419,
-0.3275206983089447,
-0.5419871211051941,
0.09225166589021683,
0.9378509521484375,
0.4583636224269867,
-0.45943114161491394,
0.6766465902328491,
-0.04865613952279091,
0.20643675327301025,
-0.9842656254768372,
0.06583151966333389,
-0.348970890045166,
0.2720913290977478,
-0.6954118013381958,
-0.6014497876167297,
-0.36829039454460144,
-0.5671002268791199,
-0.2755689322948456,
-0.8481423258781433,
0.8277949690818787,
0.18664075434207916,
0.24076783657073975,
0.30411937832832336,
0.2919764220714569,
0.32856932282447815,
-1.0411320924758911,
0.785647988319397,
-0.39292457699775696,
0.02260354347527027,
0.2010311782360077,
0.4332091510295868,
0.10952594131231308,
-0.8166701197624207,
-0.39318445324897766,
-0.0727493017911911,
0.21972382068634033,
0.11255813390016556,
-0.2046327143907547,
0.2055070847272873,
0.6395121216773987,
0.35104095935821533,
-0.707207202911377,
0.012802665121853352,
-0.7268195152282715,
-0.35592156648635864,
0.5250512361526489,
0.3353407084941864,
-0.07930339127779007,
0.4353620111942291,
-0.282462477684021,
-0.23468057811260223,
-0.6729223132133484,
0.02892359159886837,
0.6314370632171631,
0.06615250557661057,
0.01106396596878767,
0.2573045790195465,
-0.10517700016498566,
0.6079838871955872,
0.1015036553144455,
-0.11076314747333527,
0.32248231768608093,
-0.43509647250175476,
-0.21798409521579742,
0.19698870182037354,
0.6956223845481873,
0.1834312081336975,
-0.21329449117183685,
-0.13190336525440216,
-0.12093372642993927,
0.1531044840812683,
0.41543856263160706,
-1.1107027530670166,
-0.10973234474658966,
0.43791842460632324,
-0.36064907908439636,
-0.04277976602315903,
-0.1843726634979248,
-1.1859004497528076,
-0.0987926721572876,
-0.10833040624856949,
0.025761689990758896,
-0.1759488880634308,
0.00577985355630517,
-0.030326278880238533,
-0.5277342796325684,
-0.14854393899440765,
0.09615964442491531,
-1.0720596313476562,
0.7640548944473267,
0.77602618932724,
0.8148981332778931,
-0.35746288299560547,
-0.009872036054730415,
-0.9348224401473999,
0.2444303035736084,
-0.341190367937088,
0.9802641868591309,
-0.774995744228363,
-0.7914981842041016,
-0.36866527795791626,
-0.3886156976222992,
-0.11297688633203506,
-0.5580228567123413,
0.7466182708740234,
-0.17875578999519348,
-0.38199523091316223,
-0.3103385865688324,
-0.3625323474407196,
0.12983837723731995,
-0.09613481909036636,
-0.6138529181480408,
1.2597365379333496,
-0.05178749933838844,
-0.6963562369346619,
0.418703556060791,
-0.393081396818161,
-0.389212042093277,
0.2112700492143631,
-0.4181106984615326,
-0.3030134439468384,
0.5620343685150146,
0.36424529552459717,
0.3027591109275818,
-0.25530698895454407,
-0.048526450991630554,
-0.4213844835758209,
-1.1109997034072876,
0.04936295747756958,
-0.3284907639026642,
0.2981204688549042,
0.48226892948150635,
-0.3534024655818939,
0.3030071258544922,
-0.3981080651283264,
0.008280321955680847,
-0.16614927351474762,
-0.06008411571383476,
-0.035063426941633224,
-0.08303564786911011,
0.10479290038347244,
-0.2589660882949829,
0.08337344229221344,
-0.8281739950180054,
0.14532488584518433,
-0.14001674950122833,
0.28608840703964233,
1.011224627494812,
-0.19958630204200745,
0.2726270854473114,
-0.24736528098583221,
0.7804107069969177,
-0.25260430574417114,
0.42436859011650085,
0.08434920012950897,
-0.7208895683288574,
-0.2720426023006439,
-0.29562512040138245,
0.13233044743537903,
0.6572300791740417,
-0.7648741006851196,
-0.16680534183979034,
0.08023311197757721,
-0.5182567834854126,
-0.5482879281044006,
0.14422006905078888,
0.6315733790397644,
0.6693277359008789,
0.31915083527565,
-0.4053996801376343,
-0.43142446875572205,
-0.9077739715576172,
-0.2186514139175415,
-0.19635334610939026,
0.05984595790505409,
0.5940232872962952,
-0.017966024577617645,
0.11068442463874817,
0.5077003836631775,
-0.870653510093689,
0.15496926009655,
-0.14535988867282867,
0.38490772247314453,
0.498708039522171,
0.5730648636817932,
0.728121280670166,
-0.4560937285423279,
-0.303559809923172,
-0.27317187190055847,
-0.43357229232788086,
0.09609223157167435,
0.1564265489578247,
-0.09988050162792206,
-0.18608473241329193,
0.7237756252288818,
-0.5731616616249084,
0.4883328080177307,
0.18317542970180511,
0.19115829467773438,
0.5892956852912903,
-0.5488302707672119,
0.331205278635025,
-0.7967495918273926,
0.18088124692440033,
0.16960527002811432,
-0.052145786583423615,
-0.5608474612236023,
0.16694918274879456,
-0.0980038121342659,
-0.04065828397870064,
-0.4839930236339569,
0.3790781497955322,
-0.28045573830604553,
-0.19854487478733063,
-0.4796513617038727,
-0.06497159600257874,
-0.3302686810493469,
0.28924205899238586,
-0.19385746121406555,
1.4010584354400635,
0.6606916785240173,
-0.5860796570777893,
0.2400045096874237,
-0.22791914641857147,
-0.1816851794719696,
0.2052033692598343,
-0.789527952671051,
0.5172371864318848,
-0.45516660809516907,
0.25563815236091614,
-0.9271734952926636,
0.07310609519481659,
0.1570943146944046,
-0.37295812368392944,
0.4832516014575958,
-0.09169760346412659,
-0.6039573550224304,
-0.5847352147102356,
-0.5304268002510071,
0.8311523795127869,
0.7460636496543884,
-0.2539929449558258,
0.717181384563446,
0.8853256106376648,
-0.4587666988372803,
-0.8802160620689392,
-0.6715486645698547,
-0.3773134648799896,
-0.06503374129533768,
-0.2959647476673126,
0.5623828768730164,
-0.21446149051189423,
-0.3398003578186035,
-0.13525107502937317,
0.17495088279247284,
0.06395784020423889,
0.018050184473395348,
0.27187904715538025,
0.5779728293418884,
-0.34000134468078613,
-0.20163828134536743,
0.26488643884658813,
-0.3362645208835602,
-0.1353192925453186,
-0.4545789361000061,
0.7471722364425659,
-0.16651688516139984,
-0.011514334008097649,
-0.40054821968078613,
0.3443772792816162,
0.06335867196321487,
0.22785846889019012,
0.17502695322036743,
1.2270708084106445,
-0.4382919371128082,
-0.009545991197228432,
-0.7168614268302917,
-0.38135698437690735,
-0.5609554648399353,
0.2430635392665863,
-0.4177212119102478,
-0.7820973992347717,
0.48454174399375916,
0.2941345274448395,
0.3013503849506378,
0.4290396571159363,
0.7815839052200317,
0.03609166294336319,
1.0239176750183105,
0.5130478143692017,
-0.5031656622886658,
0.2951800227165222,
-0.1458553671836853,
0.036960575729608536,
-0.8257442712783813,
0.010883770883083344,
-0.5690175890922546,
-0.6543818712234497,
-0.5294074416160583,
-0.8389092087745667,
0.3737994432449341,
-0.41402682662010193,
0.3221243917942047,
0.056474581360816956,
-0.5573834180831909,
0.5596055388450623,
0.7252458930015564,
0.07867932319641113,
-0.06902949512004852,
0.29326239228248596,
-0.31380870938301086,
-0.06427332013845444,
-0.6330689787864685,
-0.05121854320168495,
1.153792381286621,
-0.08892140537500381,
0.8075826168060303,
-0.4541837275028229,
0.4618830978870392,
0.21303924918174744,
0.5049661993980408,
-0.27467286586761475,
0.6701769232749939,
-0.2457035779953003,
-0.6635330319404602,
0.0036441092379391193,
-0.44599276781082153,
-0.5671439170837402,
0.10919605195522308,
0.1177377849817276,
-0.9151423573493958,
0.30880290269851685,
0.49703845381736755,
-0.9080672860145569,
0.6028245091438293,
-0.6129687428474426,
0.4553413987159729,
0.31289389729499817,
-0.5825691223144531,
-0.591502845287323,
-0.35033950209617615,
0.37425073981285095,
0.08605913817882538,
-0.14905662834644318,
-0.15816552937030792,
0.020038548856973648,
0.7810138463973999,
-0.2406446635723114,
0.4571789801120758,
-0.29390135407447815,
0.41945573687553406,
0.5031100511550903,
-0.17124298214912415,
0.2725694179534912,
0.2780297100543976,
-0.19597266614437103,
-0.09642530232667923,
-0.23304226994514465,
-0.6155993938446045,
-0.17423678934574127,
0.8274081349372864,
-0.6259822845458984,
-0.4720310866832733,
-0.4688759446144104,
-0.8487502932548523,
-0.39487048983573914,
-0.2649042308330536,
0.2887256145477295,
0.5525368452072144,
-0.15403148531913757,
-0.02654695138335228,
0.6167339086532593,
-0.08854229003190994,
0.6910706758499146,
0.09660942852497101,
0.13010916113853455,
-0.11803179979324341,
1.0363693237304688,
-0.22119303047657013,
0.06156010925769806,
0.0848611444234848,
-0.008824781514704227,
-0.2291792333126068,
-0.8077696561813354,
-0.5702939033508301,
0.25696778297424316,
-0.26557934284210205,
0.09622931480407715,
-0.7040336728096008,
0.020053204149007797,
-0.643243670463562,
-0.05344223976135254,
-0.44226211309432983,
-0.5136980414390564,
-0.29126355051994324,
-0.14547207951545715,
0.2848031520843506,
0.1289515346288681,
-0.24249626696109772,
0.5101045370101929,
-0.60688716173172,
0.47571849822998047,
0.023502178490161896,
0.054659441113471985,
-0.14339835941791534,
-0.6060103178024292,
0.007761694025248289,
-0.2949640452861786,
-0.28239068388938904,
-0.2503116726875305,
0.39697638154029846,
0.18439117074012756,
0.859752357006073,
0.5931342840194702,
-0.3798917829990387,
1.1330901384353638,
-0.4880109131336212,
0.4607008397579193,
-0.1269187331199646,
-0.5593164563179016,
0.48582297563552856,
-0.08670544624328613,
0.2993045747280121,
1.0523781776428223,
0.5635085701942444,
-0.1443195939064026,
-0.4886491596698761,
-0.6596133708953857,
-0.7200972437858582,
0.7211374640464783,
0.244122713804245,
0.02436249330639839,
0.20971329510211945,
0.4927060306072235,
0.051220934838056564,
0.19134776294231415,
0.4255822002887726,
-0.560762882232666,
0.2623966634273529,
-0.016139153391122818,
-0.4745147228240967,
-0.3009423315525055,
-0.4269406199455261,
-0.43684151768684387,
0.6380267143249512,
-0.20591114461421967,
0.6176914572715759,
0.023555397987365723,
0.12247519195079803,
-0.04721851274371147,
0.030818400904536247,
0.7577003240585327,
0.8329795002937317,
-0.6525015830993652,
0.09134577214717865,
0.13340018689632416,
-1.2236716747283936,
-0.24037568271160126,
0.7208929657936096,
-0.3276440501213074,
0.07068557292222977,
-0.49024927616119385,
0.882732093334198,
-0.01821209117770195,
-0.7544231414794922,
0.19107167422771454,
-0.6644394993782043,
-0.09636849164962769,
-0.16654998064041138,
0.1862419992685318,
-0.05212247371673584,
0.1569262146949768,
0.5081045627593994,
0.4422381818294525,
0.5993331670761108,
-0.33940014243125916,
0.3332926034927368,
0.3537527322769165,
-0.21732737123966217,
-0.3604055643081665,
0.9481337666511536,
-0.3170095980167389,
0.05310789868235588,
0.8861903548240662,
-0.3048543632030487,
-0.10240712016820908,
0.6988820433616638,
0.42512112855911255,
0.8611928820610046,
-0.34933552145957947,
-0.017508620396256447,
0.5688996911048889,
0.21501043438911438,
-0.10286521166563034,
0.6227261424064636,
-0.43616512417793274,
-0.502997875213623,
-0.5104517936706543,
-0.8380395770072937,
-0.7467566728591919,
-0.3077366352081299,
-0.7154349088668823,
0.04479150101542473,
-0.7955365180969238,
-0.5007821321487427,
0.11970075964927673,
-0.048058588057756424,
-0.5467720031738281,
-0.024917839094996452,
0.33878907561302185,
0.768875241279602,
-0.6767756342887878,
0.9800084829330444,
0.1970963180065155,
0.06401848047971725,
-0.7726266980171204,
-0.5168610215187073,
0.13152150809764862,
-0.7256162166595459,
0.2844892740249634,
0.025987112894654274,
-0.00844451691955328,
-0.0672997534275055,
-0.10499028116464615,
-0.64236980676651,
1.0422776937484741,
0.39837023615837097,
-0.6299756169319153,
0.21261338889598846,
-0.0980261042714119,
0.235166996717453,
-0.02606801874935627,
0.6985507607460022,
0.9072205424308777,
0.3357911705970764,
0.30526232719421387,
-0.6865392923355103,
0.059886910021305084,
-0.6825931668281555,
-0.10697334259748459,
0.27886539697647095,
-0.5043896436691284,
1.1064443588256836,
-0.3338741064071655,
-0.022478697821497917,
0.14158840477466583,
0.8614044785499573,
0.8069632649421692,
0.3578842878341675,
0.5381346344947815,
0.6243136525154114,
0.9637492299079895,
-0.23709797859191895,
1.4363235235214233,
-0.62436842918396,
0.06092333048582077,
0.9521757960319519,
-0.23977386951446533,
0.7646961808204651,
0.505739688873291,
-0.21443778276443481,
-0.016075609251856804,
0.6668762564659119,
-0.11037428677082062,
0.24524883925914764,
0.17511789500713348,
-0.6844439506530762,
0.04201348498463631,
-0.10232070088386536,
-0.5129790902137756,
0.09647812694311142,
0.49960121512413025,
-0.31734561920166016,
-0.041220102459192276,
-0.08356448262929916,
0.006660932675004005,
-0.6500542759895325,
-0.5435645580291748,
0.19022737443447113,
-0.0312206894159317,
-0.8068274259567261,
0.28376486897468567,
0.09219882637262344,
0.8298162221908569,
-0.3255808353424072,
0.176752507686615,
-0.1331826150417328,
0.45573365688323975,
-0.013173510320484638,
-0.49845725297927856,
0.26420459151268005,
-0.08202255517244339,
0.08556581288576126,
-0.3131997585296631,
0.9031495451927185,
-0.07469314336776733,
-0.8053560256958008,
-0.17096573114395142,
0.20100286602973938,
0.4667738676071167,
-0.15009362995624542,
-0.41131392121315,
0.35599905252456665,
-0.41677212715148926,
-0.08605494350194931,
0.4289441704750061,
-0.25892919301986694,
0.09482333064079285,
0.2916671931743622,
0.8461620807647705,
0.377789705991745,
0.5010614991188049,
0.2146281898021698,
1.0015674829483032,
-0.45758238434791565,
-0.5691015124320984,
-0.775357186794281,
-0.03823021799325943,
-0.2847157418727875,
-0.547399640083313,
0.7503385543823242,
1.1439859867095947,
0.5614160299301147,
-0.04349946230649948,
0.5498045086860657,
0.08343455940485,
0.3197328746318817,
-0.4243800938129425,
0.5019538402557373,
-0.23425492644309998,
0.03043561987578869,
-0.27692216634750366,
-0.8390656113624573,
-0.1073925793170929,
0.2656075954437256,
-0.2574365735054016,
0.05857430398464203,
0.5578424334526062,
0.9684587717056274,
-0.2729177474975586,
0.367958128452301,
0.05740736424922943,
0.18350769579410553,
0.28214648365974426,
0.6582202911376953,
0.45755550265312195,
-0.39429157972335815,
0.3683357834815979,
-0.5973735451698303,
-0.3428391218185425,
-0.15933872759342194,
-0.543260395526886,
-0.417682409286499,
-0.18430155515670776,
-0.3709484338760376,
-0.3126576244831085,
0.2633780837059021,
0.37364324927330017,
0.9169800877571106,
-0.6952658891677856,
-0.4936656057834625,
0.11823954433202744,
-0.3829317092895508,
-0.35128575563430786,
-0.17913411557674408,
0.28116264939308167,
-0.3450115919113159,
-0.9712747931480408,
0.6502312421798706,
0.523269534111023,
-0.20385967195034027,
-0.2125336080789566,
0.1499156653881073,
0.09721757471561432,
0.15384681522846222,
0.3064614236354828,
0.6608736515045166,
-0.21753978729248047,
0.06094151735305786,
0.06261812150478363,
0.06427350640296936,
0.19625645875930786,
1.3288161754608154,
-1.1129742860794067,
0.4244508743286133,
0.8639141321182251,
0.7491039037704468,
1.34089994430542,
0.22387583553791046,
0.44503840804100037,
-0.5982756018638611,
0.6243996024131775,
0.45615094900131226,
0.42898452281951904,
-0.02510695904493332,
-0.35879161953926086,
0.25209540128707886,
0.4411340653896332,
-0.4655371308326721,
-0.8326528072357178,
-0.3684749901294708,
-1.3866220712661743,
-0.05225431174039841,
0.8777914047241211,
-0.022970089688897133,
-0.6317155361175537,
-0.028233453631401062,
0.036583416163921356,
0.18480217456817627,
-0.5530592203140259,
0.5863142013549805,
0.1424742341041565,
-0.5147335529327393,
0.026708204299211502,
-0.9446386098861694,
0.5626463294029236,
0.41218164563179016,
-0.8065319657325745,
-0.24000826478004456,
0.33970218896865845,
0.14206109941005707,
0.13348466157913208,
1.0887579917907715,
-0.21321173012256622,
0.6402704119682312,
0.2425716072320938,
-0.15954457223415375,
0.06637372076511383,
-0.30609801411628723,
-0.016801122575998306,
0.6083108186721802,
-0.41368114948272705,
-0.23020769655704498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11012v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11012v3 | Connecting the Dots: Evaluating Abstract Reasoning Capabilities of LLMs Using the New York Times Connections Word Game | 2024-06-16T17:10:32 | 2024-06-22T15:40:14 | Prisha Samadarshi, Mariam Mustafa, Anushka Kulkarni, Raven Rothkopf, Tuhin Chakrabarty, Smaranda Muresan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The New York Times Connections game has emerged as a popular and challenging
pursuit for word puzzle enthusiasts. We collect 200 Connections games to
evaluate the performance of state-of-the-art large language models (LLMs)
against expert and novice human players. Our results show that even the
best-performing LLM, GPT-4o, which has otherwise shown impressive reasoning
abilities on a wide variety of benchmarks, can only fully solve 8% of the
games. Compared to GPT-4o, novice and expert players perform better, with
expert human players significantly outperforming GPT-4o. To deepen our
understanding we create a taxonomy of the knowledge types required to
successfully categorize words in the Connections game, revealing that LLMs
struggle with associative, encyclopedic, and linguistic knowledge. Our findings
establish the New York Times Connections game as a challenging benchmark for
evaluating abstract reasoning capabilities in humans and AI systems. | [
-0.3957362771034241,
-0.9535320401191711,
1.0459668636322021,
0.01457483321428299,
-0.21525819599628448,
0.4644645154476166,
-0.03640952333807945,
-0.7716234922409058,
0.04275868833065033,
0.3504735827445984,
-0.43659746646881104,
-0.4895688593387604,
-0.6086264848709106,
0.4937179684638977,
-0.33559349179267883,
0.6229935884475708,
-0.053311094641685486,
-0.1995045393705368,
-0.7408689856529236,
0.0163633543998003,
-0.5120258331298828,
-0.33960074186325073,
-0.9014163613319397,
-0.5492671728134155,
0.5357796549797058,
0.33577850461006165,
0.6400683522224426,
0.6727735996246338,
0.6208730340003967,
0.4650014340877533,
-0.3302234709262848,
0.41905176639556885,
-0.5537092685699463,
-0.021780600771307945,
-0.3569536805152893,
-0.7179893851280212,
-0.3466470539569855,
0.01618182845413685,
0.2086249738931656,
0.8396490812301636,
0.1814892590045929,
0.3027893006801605,
-0.27679723501205444,
0.9076476693153381,
-0.2775558531284332,
0.20291930437088013,
-0.8316570520401001,
0.02250727079808712,
-0.23917147517204285,
-0.4283139407634735,
-0.3019704818725586,
-0.592958390712738,
0.529075026512146,
-1.0479178428649902,
0.15352962911128998,
0.2182314246892929,
0.9805853366851807,
0.18883942067623138,
-0.7232592701911926,
-0.45899173617362976,
-0.6982787847518921,
0.26773929595947266,
-0.46722909808158875,
-0.07376256585121155,
0.4376330077648163,
0.5287459492683411,
-0.3692938983440399,
-0.5459901094436646,
-0.6738237738609314,
-0.3151185214519501,
0.3313753604888916,
0.002500851871445775,
-0.42526423931121826,
0.111002616584301,
0.39212852716445923,
0.25502511858940125,
-0.3538755774497986,
-0.07090436667203903,
-0.6078628897666931,
-0.07340694963932037,
0.800420343875885,
0.3141676187515259,
0.17658179998397827,
0.1522189974784851,
-0.3281770348548889,
0.3342280685901642,
-0.7945087552070618,
0.4589300751686096,
0.43959516286849976,
-0.2154383361339569,
-0.06324339658021927,
0.8029788732528687,
-0.15116336941719055,
0.9357354640960693,
0.23671844601631165,
-0.12402401864528656,
-0.02538210339844227,
-0.21573865413665771,
0.2233285903930664,
-0.11437536031007767,
0.5800610184669495,
0.5784478783607483,
0.5107481479644775,
-0.4207923710346222,
0.01770664192736149,
0.18046079576015472,
0.07770519703626633,
-0.2848612666130066,
-0.43056559562683105,
0.013442229479551315,
-0.3255527913570404,
0.12299990653991699,
-0.3870319128036499,
-0.3911249339580536,
-0.6648443937301636,
-0.29573163390159607,
0.740720808506012,
-0.6263323426246643,
-0.09034436196088791,
0.3093414902687073,
-0.2632826566696167,
0.1259506642818451,
0.3615299165248871,
-0.8690487742424011,
0.23787228763103485,
0.6550373435020447,
0.78266441822052,
-0.22149668633937836,
-0.22306987643241882,
-0.16609114408493042,
0.1350071132183075,
-0.4834587574005127,
1.227618932723999,
-0.5068138241767883,
-0.28316017985343933,
-0.08820055425167084,
-0.34917017817497253,
0.021588943898677826,
-0.3450636565685272,
0.5080642700195312,
-0.791873037815094,
-0.018438929691910744,
-0.5449167490005493,
-1.1260243654251099,
-0.15462256968021393,
0.5361884832382202,
-0.5571234822273254,
0.5159249901771545,
-0.15747587382793427,
-0.7368211150169373,
0.16886968910694122,
-0.591033399105072,
-0.39287853240966797,
0.1718737632036209,
-0.20751924812793732,
0.25421735644340515,
0.23270846903324127,
-0.0036413418129086494,
0.14718705415725708,
-0.37677064538002014,
-0.14310038089752197,
-0.3718677759170532,
-0.562758207321167,
0.477843314409256,
-0.00907323881983757,
0.6366786956787109,
0.020149173215031624,
-0.04410090669989586,
0.09818864613771439,
-0.5954898595809937,
-0.15623131394386292,
0.09489437937736511,
-0.37847763299942017,
-0.42728936672210693,
0.28885725140571594,
-0.811480700969696,
0.2865573465824127,
0.19683656096458435,
-0.5981075763702393,
0.12557347118854523,
-0.39135125279426575,
0.68505859375,
0.7787426114082336,
-0.014264794066548347,
0.2402733564376831,
-0.2322605699300766,
0.491996169090271,
-0.002674849471077323,
0.07541364431381226,
-0.2657035291194916,
-0.8677520751953125,
-0.807761013507843,
0.22301529347896576,
0.3110373020172119,
0.610728919506073,
-1.3353453874588013,
0.5066951513290405,
-0.4768984317779541,
-0.6359898447990417,
-0.3749401569366455,
-0.24506951868534088,
0.26062825322151184,
0.713080108165741,
0.2614124119281769,
-0.07067178189754486,
-0.031239071860909462,
-0.9014557600021362,
-0.5384427309036255,
-0.4017449617385864,
-0.07838000357151031,
0.697778582572937,
0.5359144806861877,
0.1389341652393341,
1.09871506690979,
-0.47593629360198975,
-0.07178690284490585,
0.11775599420070648,
0.11003107577562332,
0.06589070707559586,
0.008848737925291061,
0.261410117149353,
-0.2913079559803009,
-0.3583536744117737,
-0.007014330476522446,
-0.9127741456031799,
0.018471291288733482,
0.19935378432273865,
0.06413614004850388,
0.0015538467559963465,
0.6822523474693298,
-0.7206753492355347,
0.0906243771314621,
0.6600625514984131,
-1.093027949333191,
0.665271520614624,
-0.3563252091407776,
0.33187252283096313,
-0.835511326789856,
0.07099605351686478,
0.12697990238666534,
0.08402221649885178,
-0.4278125464916229,
-0.1169520914554596,
-0.2444763332605362,
-0.17025215923786163,
-0.20558054745197296,
0.3653002083301544,
-0.7890191078186035,
-0.25187212228775024,
-0.020192287862300873,
0.5396441221237183,
0.08409308642148972,
0.17795497179031372,
-0.23913341760635376,
0.9037253856658936,
0.6695444583892822,
-0.5579816699028015,
0.6515142917633057,
0.25137075781822205,
-0.745606541633606,
0.3058304190635681,
-0.8259068727493286,
0.172862708568573,
0.0014383384259417653,
0.16958656907081604,
-1.1810648441314697,
0.08073920756578445,
-0.3227573335170746,
-0.47510093450546265,
-0.15778400003910065,
0.16775977611541748,
-0.46191444993019104,
-0.39265525341033936,
0.0324038490653038,
0.6471863389015198,
0.3055145740509033,
-0.22861754894256592,
0.44538307189941406,
0.5724045634269714,
-0.04129866883158684,
-0.33702218532562256,
-0.6142449975013733,
0.4804781675338745,
-0.17663151025772095,
-0.8846084475517273,
0.24774430692195892,
-0.035860683768987656,
-0.1998385787010193,
0.08877956122159958,
-0.0419437550008297,
-0.10711360722780228,
0.12845686078071594,
-0.21425838768482208,
0.09199152886867523,
-0.1500379890203476,
0.10852842032909393,
-0.13075944781303406,
-0.25280994176864624,
0.42758962512016296,
0.06894582509994507,
0.21090584993362427,
-0.1047426164150238,
-0.6183149814605713,
-0.16926151514053345,
0.2701389193534851,
0.4705145061016083,
-0.14716647565364838,
0.30948078632354736,
0.1891203671693802,
-0.1364421546459198,
-0.020985819399356842,
-0.7962108254432678,
-0.1779465526342392,
-0.45686790347099304,
0.424599826335907,
-0.6115631461143494,
-1.4337797164916992,
0.710398256778717,
-0.30180105566978455,
-0.13649605214595795,
0.28429290652275085,
-0.015235341154038906,
0.011670958250761032,
1.061722755432129,
0.5002108812332153,
-0.044214680790901184,
-0.10609234124422073,
0.15210478007793427,
0.3855861723423004,
-0.542538583278656,
-0.3383968472480774,
-0.40403950214385986,
-0.3951326608657837,
-0.5081999897956848,
-0.6061263084411621,
0.5164843797683716,
0.237418070435524,
-0.26845699548721313,
0.25806793570518494,
-0.4101029932498932,
0.8239074349403381,
0.45813697576522827,
0.1098528802394867,
0.7721458673477173,
0.000956278177909553,
-0.2420867532491684,
-0.10600917786359787,
-0.7217904329299927,
-0.41038188338279724,
1.0622776746749878,
0.36394113302230835,
0.3952336013317108,
0.324248731136322,
0.2671264410018921,
0.3449731171131134,
0.003078568261116743,
-0.8095534443855286,
0.8667930960655212,
0.022747907787561417,
-0.5877737402915955,
-0.2529136538505554,
-0.6892357468605042,
-1.1013203859329224,
-0.16225536167621613,
-0.5418387651443481,
-0.7208572030067444,
0.0030064505990594625,
-0.09559028595685959,
-0.4582923650741577,
0.4860856235027313,
-0.7584041357040405,
0.548414945602417,
0.010346191003918648,
-0.17707227170467377,
-0.4238390326499939,
-0.5067750215530396,
0.7903249263763428,
0.12701649963855743,
0.12967364490032196,
-0.32790592312812805,
-0.35348641872406006,
0.6059231758117676,
-0.09893340617418289,
0.46959999203681946,
0.22387702763080597,
-0.18237923085689545,
0.37909451127052307,
0.2132808119058609,
0.25660717487335205,
-0.09788619726896286,
0.06443168222904205,
0.46903517842292786,
-0.1367923468351364,
-0.3191107511520386,
-0.6085087656974792,
0.5947695970535278,
-0.7493175268173218,
-0.7671467065811157,
-0.4711235761642456,
-0.5875779390335083,
-0.5056771039962769,
0.25639331340789795,
0.24033263325691223,
0.3020145297050476,
-0.15440796315670013,
-0.0011745755327865481,
0.6921959519386292,
-0.23056533932685852,
0.4435092806816101,
0.6654805541038513,
0.021152397617697716,
-0.36095696687698364,
0.8711636066436768,
0.13103951513767242,
0.17971529066562653,
0.3233712911605835,
0.047519780695438385,
-0.4636065661907196,
-0.8677971959114075,
-0.32285553216934204,
0.27383288741111755,
-0.6173940300941467,
-0.15451611578464508,
-0.3182743787765503,
-0.17401081323623657,
-0.00620236387476325,
0.1608199179172516,
-0.09953264147043228,
-0.3297070860862732,
0.12831537425518036,
-0.04996035620570183,
0.3510456383228302,
0.9742348790168762,
0.16402310132980347,
0.04428546130657196,
-0.8819940090179443,
0.08974070847034454,
0.7698789238929749,
0.6755139231681824,
-0.0977470800280571,
-0.24003340303897858,
-0.3369996249675751,
-0.27135851979255676,
-0.2291668802499771,
-1.0014874935150146,
-0.24325072765350342,
-0.03618989512324333,
0.5162217617034912,
0.6373695135116577,
-0.016846463084220886,
0.7387875914573669,
-0.7656050324440002,
1.0614471435546875,
0.31368955969810486,
-1.0458558797836304,
0.24363578855991364,
-0.6834092736244202,
0.23687130212783813,
0.4554651975631714,
0.23717886209487915,
-0.38513028621673584,
-0.233191579580307,
-0.5966679453849792,
-0.5558163523674011,
0.6323477625846863,
0.313747763633728,
-0.2575204074382782,
-0.3625152111053467,
0.5401282906532288,
-0.19027680158615112,
0.23089498281478882,
-0.5289347767829895,
-0.5435581207275391,
0.35330691933631897,
0.13224580883979797,
-0.12553629279136658,
-0.4241299033164978,
-0.14658223092556,
-0.3428557813167572,
0.2811211347579956,
0.014407481998205185,
0.33757761120796204,
0.17156898975372314,
0.1725572943687439,
-0.06294993311166763,
-0.06498759984970093,
0.761375904083252,
1.0959255695343018,
0.1614471673965454,
0.34144824743270874,
0.149909108877182,
-0.43265366554260254,
0.1816825568675995,
0.22859878838062286,
-0.2249213606119156,
-0.013703814707696438,
0.714450478553772,
0.6416996121406555,
0.17555059492588043,
-0.7071342468261719,
0.39579060673713684,
-0.20234200358390808,
-0.45488229393959045,
-0.11612658202648163,
0.19402147829532623,
0.5099454522132874,
0.40256160497665405,
0.5049845576286316,
0.18504701554775238,
0.12028226256370544,
-0.4030728042125702,
0.05068140849471092,
0.4869306683540344,
-0.21690146625041962,
-0.41603273153305054,
0.49397316575050354,
0.6082106828689575,
-0.5374432802200317,
0.3129481077194214,
-0.40190061926841736,
-0.31659311056137085,
0.5300910472869873,
0.44083431363105774,
0.5454176068305969,
-0.10311289876699448,
0.08332815021276474,
0.35477468371391296,
0.4212309420108795,
-0.09652162343263626,
0.0959954634308815,
-0.006742311641573906,
-0.9446908235549927,
-0.9139728546142578,
-0.08146049082279205,
-0.3565233051776886,
0.14526167511940002,
-0.21246682107448578,
0.030963370576500893,
-0.30352282524108887,
-0.3832067549228668,
-0.13487450778484344,
0.3137442171573639,
-0.46892333030700684,
-0.30574092268943787,
0.2054823786020279,
1.2974867820739746,
-0.9489981532096863,
0.44293197989463806,
0.9807100892066956,
-0.34442365169525146,
-0.7095986008644104,
-0.15398748219013214,
0.014995338395237923,
-0.6724361181259155,
0.4856669008731842,
-0.010972612537443638,
-0.04857485368847847,
0.20533296465873718,
-0.35768142342567444,
-1.057582974433899,
1.268989086151123,
0.525424063205719,
-0.4169601798057556,
-0.03568553552031517,
0.2620849907398224,
0.4767242968082428,
-0.2959911525249481,
0.5316256284713745,
0.6638874411582947,
0.34168699383735657,
0.11842981725931168,
-0.9267858862876892,
-0.031553179025650024,
-0.31190288066864014,
-0.06856875121593475,
0.04194223880767822,
-0.5163846015930176,
0.8201032280921936,
-0.2133065015077591,
-0.40457683801651,
-0.09402108937501907,
0.8105300068855286,
0.6706696152687073,
0.34449514746665955,
0.8176066875457764,
0.763430655002594,
0.768365740776062,
-0.21953171491622925,
0.6771312952041626,
-0.45373228192329407,
0.018559655174613,
0.8042386174201965,
-0.240960031747818,
0.6862345337867737,
0.4328186511993408,
-0.4973878562450409,
0.5925745368003845,
0.7447623014450073,
0.1339045763015747,
0.27101704478263855,
0.49901214241981506,
-0.39244598150253296,
-0.39396339654922485,
-0.06112953647971153,
-0.3502718210220337,
0.4001174867153168,
0.38430264592170715,
0.20052005350589752,
-0.5055583119392395,
-0.4156053066253662,
-0.09647847712039948,
0.410190612077713,
-0.31250014901161194,
0.7923389673233032,
0.05781212076544762,
-0.8592261672019958,
0.34330135583877563,
-0.2130238264799118,
0.6335453391075134,
-0.5291780233383179,
-0.2528877556324005,
-0.2753128409385681,
0.11806302517652512,
-0.04056427255272865,
-1.01677405834198,
0.1383800059556961,
-0.004334981087595224,
-0.15776163339614868,
0.358786940574646,
0.6548279523849487,
-0.4347115159034729,
-0.35941022634506226,
0.35171788930892944,
0.7247241139411926,
0.37024885416030884,
0.0174589604139328,
-0.809973418712616,
-0.0752878338098526,
-0.10685831308364868,
-0.14308491349220276,
0.3169669806957245,
1.091976523399353,
0.04654945433139801,
1.0320374965667725,
0.7176473140716553,
0.3656180799007416,
0.05780385062098503,
-0.13555122911930084,
0.794741690158844,
-0.7409863471984863,
-0.5762007236480713,
-0.8490946292877197,
0.4482032060623169,
-0.43659210205078125,
-0.6499615907669067,
1.097264289855957,
0.6116206049919128,
0.5136486291885376,
0.05877058580517769,
0.5475744605064392,
0.23139126598834991,
0.4888288974761963,
-0.3435685932636261,
0.6102243065834045,
-0.22857758402824402,
0.4400882422924042,
-0.09964204579591751,
-0.7545006275177002,
-0.057027604430913925,
0.2229764759540558,
-0.3184814453125,
-0.14779826998710632,
0.8627509474754333,
0.5255469083786011,
-0.048795606940984726,
0.07812751084566116,
0.3447229862213135,
0.23490801453590393,
0.2760116755962372,
0.8943718671798706,
1.015092372894287,
-0.2713644504547119,
0.7297536134719849,
0.13917261362075806,
-0.4465794265270233,
0.044963445514440536,
-1.0184062719345093,
-1.2817718982696533,
-0.5942010283470154,
-0.1833873987197876,
-0.2690529525279999,
0.06301473826169968,
0.5489020347595215,
0.41651055216789246,
-0.31420639157295227,
-0.3307342529296875,
-0.3877899944782257,
0.3007110357284546,
-0.20908223092556,
-0.2584514319896698,
0.4036167562007904,
-0.4228362739086151,
-0.43437913060188293,
0.5748129487037659,
0.10790685564279556,
-0.3355576694011688,
-0.40865421295166016,
0.03746204078197479,
-0.3496967852115631,
0.16886132955551147,
0.9780570864677429,
0.17942802608013153,
-0.742577850818634,
-0.3345714509487152,
0.10148299485445023,
0.037255968898534775,
-0.3350968062877655,
0.8954793214797974,
-0.8811725974082947,
0.5431897044181824,
0.7319183349609375,
0.8037894368171692,
0.3550460636615753,
0.06176154688000679,
0.6831415891647339,
-0.30465757846832275,
-0.14763708412647247,
0.16461555659770966,
0.3250371217727661,
0.2629220485687256,
-0.03605775535106659,
0.5138381123542786,
0.4122602045536041,
-0.7915652394294739,
-0.5468440651893616,
0.24466915428638458,
-0.7564682364463806,
-0.3380470871925354,
1.1264811754226685,
-0.2801714241504669,
-0.2393994927406311,
-0.6009959578514099,
0.18717023730278015,
0.08004070073366165,
-0.30244171619415283,
1.1274051666259766,
0.8254641890525818,
-0.5046254396438599,
-0.1385946422815323,
-0.5995602607727051,
0.7897889018058777,
0.20502306520938873,
-0.6758816838264465,
-0.19210244715213776,
0.6535874605178833,
0.12705248594284058,
0.44606253504753113,
0.7355991005897522,
0.01822701469063759,
0.08224192261695862,
-0.027535224333405495,
0.0168396458029747,
-0.4428956210613251,
-0.06205035746097565,
-0.1418572962284088,
0.16887246072292328,
0.06368105858564377,
-0.16013288497924805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11011v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11011v2 | Data Shapley in One Training Run | 2024-06-16T17:09:24 | 2024-06-29T23:05:32 | Jiachen T. Wang, Prateek Mittal, Dawn Song, Ruoxi Jia | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Data Shapley provides a principled framework for attributing data's
contribution within machine learning contexts. However, existing approaches
require re-training models on different data subsets, which is computationally
intensive, foreclosing their application to large-scale models. Furthermore,
they produce the same attribution score for any models produced by running the
learning algorithm, meaning they cannot perform targeted attribution towards a
specific model obtained from a single run of the algorithm. This paper
introduces In-Run Data Shapley, which addresses these limitations by offering
scalable data attribution for a target model of interest. In its most efficient
implementation, our technique incurs negligible additional runtime compared to
standard model training. This dramatic efficiency improvement makes it possible
to perform data attribution for the foundation model pretraining stage for the
first time. We present several case studies that offer fresh insights into
pretraining data's contribution and discuss their implications for copyright in
generative AI and pretraining data curation. | [
0.07895658910274506,
-0.457411527633667,
0.3813569247722626,
0.15362510085105896,
-0.20957820117473602,
-0.10274220257997513,
0.13992872834205627,
-0.13208524882793427,
0.14536917209625244,
0.830582857131958,
-0.6032731533050537,
0.06892549991607666,
-0.5019673109054565,
-0.37529993057250977,
-0.8100120425224304,
1.0774028301239014,
-0.10248930007219315,
0.05202890560030937,
-0.9481379985809326,
-0.07533640414476395,
-0.13169601559638977,
-0.9363315105438232,
-0.6113091707229614,
-0.5461283326148987,
0.3592447340488434,
0.46169203519821167,
0.4953581988811493,
0.955034613609314,
0.5269373059272766,
0.258757621049881,
0.5844711065292358,
-0.16264185309410095,
-0.6547048687934875,
0.19081920385360718,
0.011144873686134815,
-0.7236269116401672,
-0.04703853651881218,
0.4108297824859619,
0.7519268989562988,
0.7646406888961792,
-0.14002718031406403,
0.28269246220588684,
-0.07218325883150101,
0.8016756772994995,
-0.9572048783302307,
-0.15066075325012207,
-0.4968482553958893,
0.1155627965927124,
-0.423887699842453,
-0.1356980949640274,
-0.23975308239459991,
-0.4085419476032257,
0.04767480865120888,
-0.8101022243499756,
0.44796010851860046,
-0.03044774755835533,
0.8037099838256836,
0.6012665033340454,
-0.1637202352285385,
-0.16893543303012848,
-0.5227254033088684,
1.1353110074996948,
-0.332436203956604,
0.35619446635246277,
0.4538819193840027,
0.24086031317710876,
0.2194792479276657,
-0.9615670442581177,
-0.35317033529281616,
-0.2090635448694229,
0.22154086828231812,
-0.11716925352811813,
-0.06763069331645966,
-0.3513123393058777,
0.27092835307121277,
0.5630276203155518,
-0.11528479307889938,
0.06754346936941147,
-0.40252745151519775,
-0.029215652495622635,
0.7371422648429871,
0.21988098323345184,
-0.33704715967178345,
0.06923844665288925,
-0.5220962762832642,
-0.3038843274116516,
-0.6462880373001099,
0.08835338056087494,
0.5211649537086487,
0.35760027170181274,
-0.11906783282756805,
0.17339013516902924,
-0.11922173202037811,
0.6628494262695312,
0.1598813682794571,
0.2669440805912018,
0.22786074876785278,
-0.1861571967601776,
-0.0827053040266037,
0.12388025969266891,
0.7172626256942749,
-0.24037161469459534,
0.31361812353134155,
-0.37616515159606934,
-0.12739509344100952,
-0.3464518189430237,
0.5867098569869995,
-1.1442757844924927,
-0.7651951909065247,
0.21948164701461792,
-0.40514424443244934,
-0.8474990129470825,
0.3500414192676544,
-0.19455738365650177,
-0.6325858235359192,
-0.4845483899116516,
0.45728063583374023,
-0.4828396439552307,
-0.0650750920176506,
-0.0007782637840136886,
0.09439874440431595,
0.1977187991142273,
0.050853434950113297,
-0.7970098257064819,
0.22479148209095,
0.7078989148139954,
0.8268010020256042,
-0.34451353549957275,
-0.44837942719459534,
-0.7051773071289062,
0.35951849818229675,
-0.49401625990867615,
0.5461289286613464,
-0.5740417838096619,
-0.031943291425704956,
-0.23773670196533203,
-0.28872454166412354,
-0.05199316516518593,
-0.6177030801773071,
0.31168442964553833,
-0.4335314631462097,
0.07727236300706863,
-0.5000718832015991,
-0.6557540893554688,
-0.09105709940195084,
0.01099006924778223,
-0.7654224038124084,
0.7450352907180786,
0.34291982650756836,
-0.7375087141990662,
0.8534401655197144,
-0.788338840007782,
-0.7198030352592468,
-0.0019766546320170164,
-0.1181376650929451,
-0.8994017839431763,
0.3349211812019348,
0.16552476584911346,
0.6777670383453369,
-0.1449005901813507,
0.2108486294746399,
-0.5001106858253479,
-0.3191451132297516,
0.2881535589694977,
-0.33652767539024353,
1.0582022666931152,
0.12443868815898895,
-0.12614993751049042,
0.01915661431849003,
-0.9769086241722107,
0.4125845432281494,
0.352709025144577,
-0.19307075440883636,
-0.2279416024684906,
-0.06622137874364853,
0.2145473062992096,
-0.0009578921599313617,
0.17306309938430786,
-0.3831237852573395,
0.12535007297992706,
0.03551774099469185,
0.4958595633506775,
0.7902339100837708,
-0.1444830596446991,
0.23172463476657867,
-0.4830549657344818,
0.7070255875587463,
0.0043022045865654945,
0.1600806713104248,
-0.15896448493003845,
0.0008833173778839409,
-0.471591055393219,
-0.44353023171424866,
0.46164390444755554,
0.3940994143486023,
-0.39066997170448303,
0.09741180390119553,
-0.2780613899230957,
-0.5005934834480286,
-0.43727341294288635,
0.20844747126102448,
0.42009976506233215,
0.3364735245704651,
0.26119598746299744,
-0.44870835542678833,
-0.6316477060317993,
-0.8447683453559875,
-0.13866721093654633,
0.032818544656038284,
-0.10820288956165314,
0.5343295335769653,
0.5889742970466614,
0.14601100981235504,
1.003039002418518,
-0.47313693165779114,
-0.16258947551250458,
-0.012473954819142818,
0.12746131420135498,
-0.0487426221370697,
0.892250120639801,
0.5382072925567627,
-0.8505727052688599,
-0.4276665151119232,
-0.2984824478626251,
-0.864292323589325,
-0.026419747620821,
-0.1179569661617279,
-0.2196999490261078,
-0.4393523037433624,
0.4224894046783447,
-0.08723326772451401,
0.286941260099411,
0.5263839364051819,
0.007045774254947901,
0.5601292252540588,
-0.10806380957365036,
0.49833664298057556,
-1.124708652496338,
0.21761587262153625,
-0.5915645956993103,
-0.3441426753997803,
-0.46209123730659485,
-0.05321523919701576,
-0.1525983065366745,
-0.44694098830223083,
-0.45320752263069153,
0.23839335143566132,
-0.03539500758051872,
-0.2851789593696594,
-0.13939163088798523,
-0.4584076404571533,
0.07504245638847351,
0.1728801429271698,
-0.07929843664169312,
0.6818873882293701,
0.7591267228126526,
-0.75453782081604,
0.7558876872062683,
0.4887421429157257,
-0.40328601002693176,
0.8011735677719116,
-0.832370400428772,
0.4513520896434784,
-0.03516304865479469,
0.2625381350517273,
-0.5508250594139099,
-0.4144952893257141,
0.060546282678842545,
-0.3521864414215088,
0.23710858821868896,
-0.31965115666389465,
-0.3496418297290802,
-0.0505739226937294,
-0.34554219245910645,
0.8771233558654785,
0.17104403674602509,
-0.7406755685806274,
0.4659680724143982,
0.2710111141204834,
0.23869284987449646,
-0.4099997580051422,
-0.9156840443611145,
-0.1339007467031479,
-0.6981855630874634,
-0.6940253973007202,
0.48795318603515625,
0.28502359986305237,
-0.08743550628423691,
-0.1379324346780777,
0.20453904569149017,
-0.4525775611400604,
0.3727894723415375,
0.4537675976753235,
-0.06334513425827026,
-0.047984007745981216,
0.012464714236557484,
-0.36844077706336975,
-0.30906394124031067,
0.281109482049942,
-0.35779792070388794,
0.5106874108314514,
0.2523033618927002,
-0.6405906081199646,
-0.4946728050708771,
0.3576134145259857,
0.17656682431697845,
-0.30872753262519836,
0.769209623336792,
0.5073691606521606,
-0.4100291430950165,
-0.25193682312965393,
-0.31114065647125244,
-0.1641945093870163,
-0.4240438938140869,
0.40014463663101196,
-0.26345714926719666,
-0.32750195264816284,
0.4081379771232605,
0.10852719843387604,
0.21709591150283813,
0.3449939489364624,
0.292034387588501,
-0.3420089781284332,
0.557896614074707,
0.7355692982673645,
-0.465677410364151,
0.899738609790802,
-0.5129098296165466,
0.013556660152971745,
-0.49869635701179504,
-0.18383494019508362,
-0.5321353077888489,
-0.23581640422344208,
-0.029958883300423622,
-0.0939234048128128,
0.222551628947258,
0.28604909777641296,
-0.33332741260528564,
0.15287400782108307,
-0.38999512791633606,
0.501344621181488,
0.6864809989929199,
0.4164920151233673,
0.10659132897853851,
0.2114933878183365,
0.8262964487075806,
0.10932540148496628,
-0.8924713730812073,
-0.22632092237472534,
1.7287187576293945,
0.062316980212926865,
0.7043572664260864,
-0.15949131548404694,
1.0735992193222046,
0.5519331097602844,
0.4366076588630676,
-0.44100967049598694,
0.09942969679832458,
-0.39371195435523987,
-0.6719874739646912,
-0.3678874373435974,
-0.5126439929008484,
-0.8319175839424133,
-0.3412790596485138,
-0.19084741175174713,
-0.45157772302627563,
-0.1703917235136032,
0.5757738947868347,
-0.43523094058036804,
0.36732059717178345,
-0.642720639705658,
1.0839183330535889,
-0.4350709617137909,
-0.5641107559204102,
-0.3626759648323059,
-0.38357770442962646,
0.43039047718048096,
-0.30769628286361694,
-0.10457862168550491,
0.15137851238250732,
0.19038519263267517,
1.3950738906860352,
-0.7294247150421143,
0.5981559753417969,
-0.4995347559452057,
0.20103541016578674,
0.43596649169921875,
-0.17321047186851501,
0.561081051826477,
-0.16503693163394928,
0.14287787675857544,
0.11934254318475723,
0.07020040601491928,
-0.8073728680610657,
-0.48872777819633484,
0.49164101481437683,
-0.5235349535942078,
-0.0766175389289856,
-0.22494567930698395,
-0.5813168883323669,
-0.36207616329193115,
0.05485621839761734,
0.4768354892730713,
0.5487538576126099,
-0.1884537637233734,
0.5259945392608643,
0.8236924409866333,
0.19754059612751007,
0.04622379317879677,
-0.0295158252120018,
-0.0408640131354332,
-0.22252991795539856,
1.1267658472061157,
-0.2061460018157959,
0.3007534444332123,
0.08498472720384598,
0.2637220621109009,
-0.18784503638744354,
-0.7865592837333679,
-0.44213345646858215,
-0.14207297563552856,
-0.5749847292900085,
-0.1955956071615219,
-0.3338002860546112,
0.011117343790829182,
-0.22167202830314636,
-0.608943521976471,
-0.760511577129364,
-0.24880163371562958,
-0.24293959140777588,
0.22187647223472595,
0.3791626989841461,
0.5377355813980103,
-0.029708966612815857,
0.5794600248336792,
-0.4510122835636139,
0.13923871517181396,
0.4688754975795746,
0.34733861684799194,
-0.0710325613617897,
-0.675129234790802,
-0.5826203227043152,
0.26030099391937256,
-0.29618123173713684,
-0.3749343156814575,
-0.20177938044071198,
0.4523896276950836,
0.4495920240879059,
0.47804510593414307,
-0.2130594551563263,
0.8013781309127808,
-0.04126329347491264,
0.6984628438949585,
0.10114207863807678,
-0.9375377297401428,
0.6551322937011719,
-0.21236515045166016,
-0.05191997066140175,
0.9602083563804626,
0.48897549510002136,
0.0482902005314827,
0.2693638503551483,
-0.7556526064872742,
-0.5616007447242737,
0.719417929649353,
0.009802932851016521,
0.12366066128015518,
0.5762364864349365,
0.6119953989982605,
0.22799383103847504,
0.34132975339889526,
-0.4462781250476837,
-0.15760180354118347,
-0.4542982280254364,
-0.10427745431661606,
-0.20784880220890045,
0.08674347400665283,
-0.16659221053123474,
-0.2720310091972351,
0.9491559267044067,
-0.13271166384220123,
0.02808905579149723,
-0.36014771461486816,
-0.39240431785583496,
0.04457523301243782,
-0.26685911417007446,
-0.07630710303783417,
0.772975742816925,
-0.0546070821583271,
-0.29289478063583374,
-0.08426278829574585,
-0.5531865358352661,
0.15830397605895996,
0.34197908639907837,
-0.2690594494342804,
-0.43183863162994385,
0.660417914390564,
0.637165367603302,
0.3358970582485199,
-0.50190669298172,
0.7844177484512329,
0.4401582181453705,
-0.3649221956729889,
-0.2882597744464874,
0.20111709833145142,
-0.24442999064922333,
0.37989524006843567,
0.2137133628129959,
-0.1549081802368164,
0.0955124944448471,
-0.5363024473190308,
0.6028929948806763,
0.549859881401062,
-0.3702259361743927,
-0.1777643859386444,
0.9287866353988647,
-0.1979794204235077,
0.14596815407276154,
0.8917512893676758,
0.052393827587366104,
-0.5784907341003418,
0.6326083540916443,
0.2730084955692291,
0.9085128307342529,
-0.3047960698604584,
0.1968606412410736,
0.1546475738286972,
-0.3587566018104553,
-0.11370090395212173,
0.07646892219781876,
-0.3064436912536621,
-0.8530689477920532,
-0.24071134626865387,
-0.6458021402359009,
-0.33400827646255493,
0.10140271484851837,
-0.8366709351539612,
0.1303471177816391,
-0.6275557279586792,
0.07999073714017868,
0.27887606620788574,
0.09946532547473907,
-0.8209306001663208,
0.36245086789131165,
0.1185227558016777,
0.2424492985010147,
-1.0308400392532349,
0.7372927665710449,
0.6866823434829712,
-0.44623643159866333,
-0.6526068449020386,
-0.23196889460086823,
-0.23878754675388336,
-0.951496422290802,
0.3730483651161194,
0.10499989986419678,
0.10447806119918823,
0.06782390922307968,
-1.018619418144226,
-0.7764401435852051,
1.0724276304244995,
0.5670768618583679,
-0.056331176310777664,
0.27161431312561035,
0.2499578446149826,
-0.04716857895255089,
-0.5128138661384583,
-0.2439194768667221,
0.6428623795509338,
0.19361092150211334,
0.2195124477148056,
-0.46383652091026306,
-0.10716148465871811,
0.19437910616397858,
-0.3602975904941559,
0.0523526631295681,
-0.43398934602737427,
1.072211503982544,
-0.30172690749168396,
-0.008218956179916859,
-0.3043787181377411,
0.6841810941696167,
0.4087764620780945,
0.282088965177536,
0.5616461038589478,
0.5503949522972107,
0.9079194664955139,
-0.019349675625562668,
1.1172727346420288,
-0.1917014867067337,
0.30723807215690613,
1.0322853326797485,
0.15686306357383728,
0.4247521758079529,
0.36257144808769226,
-0.7770575881004333,
0.4185127913951874,
0.5481311678886414,
-0.1766989827156067,
0.6632173657417297,
0.49577775597572327,
-0.1864190697669983,
-0.25770944356918335,
-0.16912707686424255,
-0.2396436333656311,
0.5027483105659485,
-0.17223934829235077,
-0.45281174778938293,
0.04384469985961914,
0.010631851851940155,
-0.024567898362874985,
-0.021481525152921677,
-0.537040114402771,
0.40111497044563293,
-0.09462718665599823,
-0.14088982343673706,
0.4451669156551361,
-0.21187640726566315,
0.5877364873886108,
-0.8576583862304688,
0.013709788210690022,
-0.06519602984189987,
0.2048197239637375,
-0.6397892236709595,
-0.2949211001396179,
0.37857529520988464,
-0.10337057709693909,
-0.4833492338657379,
-0.3757067918777466,
0.5607692003250122,
-0.21751847863197327,
-0.5202671885490417,
-0.5520342588424683,
0.29220280051231384,
0.48292285203933716,
-0.7356681227684021,
-0.687780499458313,
-0.15423773229122162,
0.17068205773830414,
-0.4529096782207489,
0.27433931827545166,
0.371847003698349,
-0.23186136782169342,
0.8028769493103027,
0.7081318497657776,
-0.09770635515451431,
0.2731214165687561,
-0.11537296324968338,
0.8761062622070312,
-0.5701358914375305,
-0.7328416705131531,
-0.5321160554885864,
0.3286033570766449,
-0.03919079527258873,
-0.4209121763706207,
0.545872688293457,
0.9516134262084961,
0.7571912407875061,
0.17099303007125854,
0.9802592396736145,
-0.3111876845359802,
0.13924236595630646,
-0.5673006176948547,
0.6216541528701782,
-0.4494701623916626,
-0.11416859924793243,
-0.16723372042179108,
-0.853110671043396,
0.1019502580165863,
0.6828968524932861,
-0.2272062599658966,
0.2800872027873993,
0.43256300687789917,
0.3735302686691284,
-0.3365548551082611,
0.1462678611278534,
0.011052360758185387,
-0.3058066964149475,
0.4572746157646179,
0.7880085110664368,
0.5648943781852722,
-0.5137671828269958,
0.17287908494472504,
-0.5469847321510315,
-0.3087020814418793,
0.0788707360625267,
-0.9041537046432495,
-0.6073435544967651,
-0.7967860102653503,
-0.3583754599094391,
-0.25272712111473083,
-0.1377735435962677,
0.5038694143295288,
1.0569508075714111,
-0.954239010810852,
0.1106814369559288,
-0.08976003527641296,
-0.2658744752407074,
-0.40324267745018005,
-0.23805265128612518,
0.6196864247322083,
-0.17756305634975433,
-0.2971101701259613,
0.3230421841144562,
-0.3525882363319397,
-0.03926089033484459,
-0.5055837631225586,
-0.08880293369293213,
0.07504601776599884,
-0.15298528969287872,
0.20760178565979004,
0.34680500626564026,
0.039919670671224594,
-0.31447097659111023,
-0.6936377882957458,
0.1279374361038208,
0.03462384268641472,
1.3875625133514404,
-0.984486997127533,
0.14916889369487762,
0.12150789052248001,
0.988659679889679,
1.0664399862289429,
0.40378621220588684,
0.4809975326061249,
-0.7748034596443176,
0.1993347704410553,
0.38607221841812134,
-0.04348106309771538,
0.5582528114318848,
-0.4508141577243805,
0.44891783595085144,
0.37111616134643555,
-0.4051970839500427,
-0.7476034164428711,
0.21973103284835815,
-0.7650663256645203,
0.004253487102687359,
0.7354072332382202,
-0.25912773609161377,
-0.034899380058050156,
-0.003092705737799406,
0.4733380079269409,
0.09044460207223892,
-0.0483844019472599,
0.7192611694335938,
0.745925784111023,
-0.30066996812820435,
0.17773932218551636,
-0.6028832793235779,
0.655214250087738,
0.4694627821445465,
-0.9350820183753967,
0.3919264078140259,
0.5632055997848511,
0.480014443397522,
-0.16176316142082214,
0.697069525718689,
0.0908169373869896,
0.08344835042953491,
0.4789499342441559,
-0.05730925872921944,
-0.8179473876953125,
-0.4079842269420624,
-0.23509395122528076,
0.2368965446949005,
-0.22915881872177124,
-0.541512668132782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11911v1 | A Notion of Complexity for Theory of Mind via Discrete World Models | 2024-06-16T16:46:55 | 2024-06-16T16:46:55 | X. Angelo Huang, Emanuele La Malfa, Samuele Marro, Andrea Asperti, Anthony Cohn, Michael Wooldridge | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Theory of Mind (ToM) can be used to assess the capabilities of Large Language
Models (LLMs) in complex scenarios where social reasoning is required. While
the research community has proposed many ToM benchmarks, their hardness varies
greatly, and their complexity is not well defined. This work proposes a
framework to measure the complexity of ToM tasks. We quantify a problem's
complexity as the number of states necessary to solve it correctly. Our
complexity measure also accounts for spurious states of a ToM problem designed
to make it apparently harder. We use our method to assess the complexity of
five widely adopted ToM benchmarks. On top of this framework, we design a
prompting technique that augments the information available to a model with a
description of how the environment changes with the agents' interactions. We
name this technique Discrete World Models (DWM) and show how it elicits
superior performance on ToM tasks. | [
-0.6688781380653381,
-0.9313620924949646,
1.1467982530593872,
0.22714915871620178,
-0.19865824282169342,
0.026220351457595825,
-0.387123703956604,
-0.4795283079147339,
-0.1647302806377411,
0.006497299298644066,
-0.7680087089538574,
0.0347476489841938,
-0.6415764093399048,
0.1293286681175232,
-0.09568719565868378,
0.6072154641151428,
-0.07861950993537903,
-0.05504691228270531,
-0.3464924097061157,
-0.06964048743247986,
-0.2687576711177826,
-0.12306708842515945,
-0.7565714716911316,
-0.8195998668670654,
0.6761986613273621,
0.0009234824101440609,
0.6583173871040344,
0.3966492712497711,
0.7468442916870117,
0.40323641896247864,
-0.3676108419895172,
0.34234631061553955,
-0.49183809757232666,
0.21594631671905518,
-0.5272552967071533,
-0.6898934245109558,
-0.6537119746208191,
0.01672700047492981,
0.2896556556224823,
0.8963841199874878,
-0.06659846007823944,
0.08417323976755142,
0.08921894431114197,
0.46223780512809753,
-0.34584131836891174,
0.37899255752563477,
-0.59282386302948,
-0.016888711601495743,
-0.040441256016492844,
-0.31254005432128906,
-0.2517063617706299,
-0.2585769295692444,
0.5215490460395813,
-0.5016718506813049,
0.06576377898454666,
0.17896994948387146,
0.3116133511066437,
0.3058392405509949,
-0.5634137988090515,
-0.17464154958724976,
-1.1530307531356812,
0.9576542973518372,
-0.3614468574523926,
0.003736436367034912,
0.3903772830963135,
0.378573477268219,
-0.5405927896499634,
-0.3584713935852051,
-0.9593971967697144,
-0.1828271746635437,
0.20943419635295868,
-0.15601180493831635,
-0.12952390313148499,
0.42917928099632263,
0.5927871465682983,
0.6810315847396851,
-0.32642585039138794,
-0.3755474388599396,
0.015427807345986366,
0.2561892569065094,
0.7596076726913452,
0.579517126083374,
0.3034627437591553,
-0.07748936861753464,
-0.25885626673698425,
-0.2752740681171417,
-0.25358638167381287,
-0.10377315431833267,
0.05728325992822647,
0.06506550312042236,
-0.09615573287010193,
0.12070169299840927,
-0.24385035037994385,
0.7438812255859375,
0.12265970557928085,
-0.4144112765789032,
-0.3004864752292633,
0.16103745996952057,
-0.34621521830558777,
-0.5023995041847229,
0.3149149715900421,
0.19030000269412994,
0.3504994809627533,
0.032904624938964844,
-0.2783195376396179,
0.07099500298500061,
0.3787009119987488,
-0.4179357886314392,
-0.16549116373062134,
0.5209407210350037,
-0.24084776639938354,
-0.03197246044874191,
-0.08684290945529938,
-0.42842039465904236,
-0.6433987617492676,
-0.16278086602687836,
0.5415101051330566,
-0.6764817237854004,
-0.6600894331932068,
0.288907527923584,
-0.21108989417552948,
0.177188441157341,
0.4814871549606323,
-0.6596990823745728,
0.5183734893798828,
0.7853906750679016,
0.7997101545333862,
-0.09233205020427704,
-0.36690574884414673,
0.2918761968612671,
0.26222243905067444,
-0.47683680057525635,
0.7970886826515198,
-0.4000944495201111,
-0.46536460518836975,
-0.24697159230709076,
-0.3125077188014984,
0.17222587764263153,
-0.22565637528896332,
0.12188108265399933,
-0.4104626178741455,
0.07507598400115967,
-0.7593352794647217,
-0.8001025319099426,
-0.5560963153839111,
0.5046626329421997,
-0.554908812046051,
0.9076517224311829,
0.21436479687690735,
-0.6053206324577332,
0.26153624057769775,
-0.7996538281440735,
-0.3810962438583374,
0.574398398399353,
-0.26472336053848267,
0.13448429107666016,
0.47522225975990295,
-0.12094884365797043,
0.6184560060501099,
-0.7018816471099854,
0.7370635271072388,
-0.5672265291213989,
-0.44334426522254944,
0.4028441309928894,
-0.3668467402458191,
0.7414502501487732,
0.26617732644081116,
-0.40281209349632263,
-0.05976879969239235,
-0.8049269914627075,
0.21433500945568085,
0.4121653437614441,
-0.19816766679286957,
-0.6032808423042297,
0.24372538924217224,
-0.2294483780860901,
-0.04753052815794945,
0.20200836658477783,
-0.3264847695827484,
0.2301049530506134,
-0.30927661061286926,
0.5454223155975342,
0.9442128539085388,
0.09641426801681519,
0.24171803891658783,
-0.9409390687942505,
0.4415702521800995,
-0.28443098068237305,
0.16299064457416534,
0.07037249952554703,
-0.5669335126876831,
-0.8072731494903564,
-0.27663305401802063,
0.019267264753580093,
0.26269105076789856,
-0.7105961441993713,
0.396098792552948,
-0.5247012376785278,
-0.7570055723190308,
-0.029541125521063805,
-0.2799171209335327,
0.4967959523200989,
-0.01036881934851408,
0.11884085088968277,
-0.39932623505592346,
-0.21120205521583557,
-0.7146011590957642,
-0.21100059151649475,
-0.44780784845352173,
-0.14615420997142792,
0.3966679573059082,
0.7092897891998291,
0.026799656450748444,
0.8148343563079834,
-0.5084232687950134,
0.1876949965953827,
-0.2163778841495514,
0.18850569427013397,
0.1488649547100067,
0.40901389718055725,
0.20073063671588898,
-0.7811999320983887,
-0.05617896839976311,
-0.10841716825962067,
-0.9002317190170288,
0.240334615111351,
0.06060272827744484,
0.003306585829705,
-0.1704961657524109,
0.1005764976143837,
-0.8701815009117126,
0.3391985595226288,
0.10142412036657333,
0.019988464191555977,
0.18503163754940033,
-0.3051103949546814,
0.28988152742385864,
-0.6969938278198242,
0.08053592592477798,
0.07665880769491196,
-0.0054171159863471985,
-0.6345440149307251,
0.4927096366882324,
-0.20083172619342804,
0.04073000326752663,
-0.2597934901714325,
0.5958775877952576,
-0.5110316872596741,
-0.0902380421757698,
-0.10933617502450943,
0.015631167218089104,
-0.20579278469085693,
0.889838457107544,
-0.2042841762304306,
0.3948531150817871,
0.15916584432125092,
-1.0849394798278809,
0.6956398487091064,
-0.1047237291932106,
-0.49696919322013855,
1.1423850059509277,
-0.602952241897583,
0.36230847239494324,
-0.1722692996263504,
0.3891737461090088,
-1.3707515001296997,
-0.3631708323955536,
-0.05072179436683655,
-0.13331638276576996,
-0.07859589904546738,
0.22473861277103424,
-0.4636574685573578,
-0.5631637573242188,
-0.09572739154100418,
0.39946451783180237,
0.39883458614349365,
-0.3063333034515381,
0.7060292959213257,
0.25069496035575867,
0.07974027842283249,
0.024185702204704285,
-0.6531424522399902,
0.0003357201348990202,
-0.3665477931499481,
-0.6834602952003479,
0.6246974468231201,
-0.5327752828598022,
-0.7227689623832703,
-0.17683418095111847,
-0.24015764892101288,
-0.24644328653812408,
0.2255527377128601,
0.3705328702926636,
-0.19387002289295197,
0.0997699648141861,
0.3747115135192871,
-0.10244794934988022,
0.07055426388978958,
0.41024258732795715,
-0.2913103401660919,
0.4942564368247986,
-0.07972337305545807,
-0.3742995262145996,
-0.18948020040988922,
0.272519052028656,
0.7823728322982788,
0.0057890103198587894,
0.29223132133483887,
-0.023005889728665352,
-0.8492118716239929,
-0.5993437767028809,
-0.5129480957984924,
-0.20530661940574646,
-0.49149516224861145,
0.2193998545408249,
-0.8383274674415588,
-0.6408441066741943,
0.6110126376152039,
-0.3033732771873474,
-0.01770666614174843,
0.11930690705776215,
0.5607215762138367,
0.06449086219072342,
1.026818871498108,
0.7325681447982788,
0.10490618646144867,
0.27098405361175537,
-0.2355804443359375,
0.1994466334581375,
-0.5627942085266113,
-0.1560627520084381,
-0.13517163693904877,
-0.53635174036026,
-0.35131603479385376,
-0.5648799538612366,
0.414431095123291,
-0.11990986764431,
-0.3909178078174591,
0.14420336484909058,
-0.4085564613342285,
0.4637084901332855,
0.40791943669319153,
0.3800417482852936,
0.43731269240379333,
-0.07888626307249069,
-0.2774355411529541,
0.07714013010263443,
-0.6041512489318848,
-0.47392675280570984,
0.8732039928436279,
0.2641691267490387,
0.7039522528648376,
0.4485779106616974,
0.5004396438598633,
0.4242243468761444,
0.04156959801912308,
-0.7546338438987732,
1.0141210556030273,
0.3315088748931885,
-0.9403676986694336,
-0.7024925947189331,
-0.2237592488527298,
-0.9129170179367065,
0.13381196558475494,
-0.07536162436008453,
-0.6981773376464844,
0.031196292489767075,
-0.01565481536090374,
-0.5622172951698303,
0.31176963448524475,
-0.12362950295209885,
0.16774989664554596,
0.02171982266008854,
-0.3023306727409363,
-0.6625391244888306,
-0.41809046268463135,
0.49388977885246277,
0.11535260081291199,
0.06193617731332779,
-0.19575195014476776,
0.01841580681502819,
0.6548018455505371,
-0.4142071604728699,
0.6961467266082764,
-0.06608489900827408,
-0.5563158392906189,
0.29916027188301086,
0.3616253137588501,
0.4918154776096344,
-0.07083357870578766,
-0.0017430715961381793,
-0.22672392427921295,
-0.027439769357442856,
-0.40441858768463135,
-0.9037018418312073,
0.5868566036224365,
-0.4993845820426941,
-0.7823600172996521,
-0.5276327133178711,
-0.8109163045883179,
-0.46839094161987305,
0.0742340162396431,
0.19564852118492126,
0.3600107729434967,
-0.2628389000892639,
-0.0725003182888031,
0.9760348796844482,
-0.0792645514011383,
0.3561500906944275,
0.6262692809104919,
-0.09723055362701416,
-0.04120102524757385,
0.7737103700637817,
0.5513398051261902,
0.17917874455451965,
0.34240737557411194,
0.19381801784038544,
-0.06452800333499908,
-0.4740619361400604,
-0.03983359783887863,
-0.06325222551822662,
-0.7775678634643555,
0.027576850727200508,
-0.3994220495223999,
-0.09142141044139862,
0.00042898207902908325,
-0.010118055157363415,
-0.09424838423728943,
-0.20377109944820404,
0.2543081045150757,
-0.16410300135612488,
0.5877106189727783,
1.1369643211364746,
-0.0019469419494271278,
0.1676771640777588,
-0.16228096187114716,
0.32276028394699097,
0.8384162187576294,
0.6211444139480591,
0.476442813873291,
-0.21830534934997559,
-0.1460302621126175,
-0.022786298766732216,
-0.2283778041601181,
-0.9154170155525208,
-0.00531008280813694,
-0.16909649968147278,
0.550474226474762,
0.3036564290523529,
0.18306110799312592,
0.8475537300109863,
-0.2973252534866333,
0.5774798393249512,
-0.10125046223402023,
-1.1141574382781982,
0.6046748161315918,
-0.7073914408683777,
0.28205448389053345,
0.12824253737926483,
0.3931652307510376,
-0.32375338673591614,
-0.3987736999988556,
-0.8979142904281616,
-0.4744527339935303,
0.3290528357028961,
-0.04213492199778557,
0.0833696722984314,
-0.2521013021469116,
0.597167432308197,
-0.1797325611114502,
0.1484430581331253,
-0.5460629463195801,
-0.23167987167835236,
0.4801868200302124,
-0.2421608567237854,
-0.021488221362233162,
-0.34196901321411133,
-0.3110385835170746,
-0.18138816952705383,
0.42071494460105896,
-0.0705333724617958,
0.40068623423576355,
0.4716625213623047,
-0.01199922151863575,
-0.4340325891971588,
0.2146998643875122,
0.5232247114181519,
1.0364760160446167,
-0.2482728809118271,
0.271783709526062,
0.3541085124015808,
-0.15772251784801483,
0.5332522392272949,
-0.2827914357185364,
0.06688589602708817,
-0.4288303256034851,
0.5351769924163818,
0.4693174958229065,
0.14042535424232483,
-0.5402254462242126,
0.3244970142841339,
-0.050413794815540314,
-0.3750474154949188,
-0.32326003909111023,
0.4684698283672333,
-0.07118493318557739,
0.4333557188510895,
0.5633972883224487,
-0.23757049441337585,
0.24243022501468658,
-0.5227892398834229,
-0.03391857445240021,
0.39938947558403015,
-0.45220300555229187,
-0.26528382301330566,
0.4019604027271271,
0.32362696528434753,
-0.5313186645507812,
0.3285771608352661,
-0.47845450043678284,
-0.36935678124427795,
0.8419400453567505,
0.3880366384983063,
0.7591415047645569,
-0.22384107112884521,
0.0003971286350861192,
0.12780331075191498,
0.504671037197113,
-0.48755350708961487,
0.6931381225585938,
-0.09471524506807327,
-0.7562662363052368,
-0.4552597105503082,
-0.2954423427581787,
-0.6790738105773926,
0.5112378597259521,
-0.7673612833023071,
-0.05493035539984703,
-0.8988156914710999,
-0.4448390603065491,
0.013888117857277393,
0.37602895498275757,
-0.7575160264968872,
0.5691406726837158,
0.10307520627975464,
0.6853466629981995,
-0.5727902054786682,
0.6150270700454712,
0.8268883228302002,
0.007146748248487711,
-0.6349560618400574,
0.02264861762523651,
0.21287117898464203,
-0.6597446799278259,
0.4884283244609833,
0.05991687998175621,
-0.33396127820014954,
0.0923215001821518,
-0.6859387159347534,
-0.737273633480072,
1.0688320398330688,
0.29111436009407043,
-0.5430350303649902,
0.207894429564476,
-0.2814520597457886,
0.6894183158874512,
-0.31060001254081726,
0.21079322695732117,
0.5301110148429871,
0.5973327159881592,
-0.29215505719184875,
-0.8568850755691528,
0.4019410312175751,
-0.3175070285797119,
0.460730642080307,
0.11936873197555542,
-0.7665934562683105,
1.1095715761184692,
-0.2753223180770874,
-0.4826020896434784,
0.06511963903903961,
0.6706776022911072,
0.29503247141838074,
0.3293100893497467,
0.9050530195236206,
0.44870737195014954,
1.0465829372406006,
-0.016316767781972885,
0.9609098434448242,
-0.22937119007110596,
0.3938117027282715,
0.8980202078819275,
-0.4309643805027008,
0.5586375594139099,
0.27316322922706604,
-0.8171728253364563,
0.5236210823059082,
0.610975980758667,
0.2387980818748474,
0.21162287890911102,
0.9022687673568726,
-0.27314919233322144,
-0.42922380566596985,
-0.04908648133277893,
-0.1704426258802414,
0.43273621797561646,
0.5265318751335144,
0.13149240612983704,
0.1698550581932068,
0.07332143187522888,
-0.11675668507814407,
0.3836432993412018,
-0.19484740495681763,
0.6738680601119995,
0.14317819476127625,
-0.8672864437103271,
0.5909001231193542,
0.01767646335065365,
0.531717836856842,
-0.5024781823158264,
-0.10877169668674469,
-0.2827903628349304,
0.20400865375995636,
0.1657944768667221,
-0.676616907119751,
0.10201864689588547,
-0.3281528949737549,
-0.5139843821525574,
-0.006108422763645649,
0.48860234022140503,
-0.23921126127243042,
-0.3849432170391083,
0.5157486796379089,
0.7917152643203735,
0.23702043294906616,
-0.07446259260177612,
-0.5059816837310791,
0.09425871074199677,
-0.23822322487831116,
-0.45467835664749146,
0.20874083042144775,
0.7809832096099854,
-0.20150521397590637,
1.211214542388916,
0.31697243452072144,
0.030247973278164864,
-0.2575100064277649,
-0.20856620371341705,
0.4625484049320221,
-0.9783656001091003,
-0.6132453680038452,
-1.1167412996292114,
0.037066858261823654,
-0.07796306163072586,
-0.3201964199542999,
0.5838590860366821,
-0.1599266231060028,
0.7129002809524536,
0.12579092383384705,
0.9603525996208191,
-0.3100827634334564,
0.45572754740715027,
-0.3022676706314087,
0.4396047294139862,
-0.5922119617462158,
0.4477047026157379,
-0.4892781972885132,
-0.8473231196403503,
-0.0689043328166008,
0.7231881022453308,
-0.14392806589603424,
0.22379520535469055,
0.8428425788879395,
0.5946958065032959,
0.15336111187934875,
0.24999454617500305,
0.47466954588890076,
0.2060054987668991,
0.21902789175510406,
1.0233899354934692,
0.9558573365211487,
-0.11502200365066528,
0.39626795053482056,
-0.22960254549980164,
-0.4529654085636139,
-0.00529062282294035,
-0.9191882014274597,
-1.0708976984024048,
-0.8735756874084473,
-0.3214905560016632,
-0.24108651280403137,
0.07697811722755432,
0.9228227734565735,
0.8586956858634949,
-0.35721319913864136,
-0.44117245078086853,
-0.2030107080936432,
0.40072235465049744,
-0.6716150641441345,
-0.15927545726299286,
-0.02839837782084942,
-0.06471767276525497,
-0.82773357629776,
0.27013301849365234,
0.4513102173805237,
0.269437700510025,
-0.8109712600708008,
0.0996541753411293,
-0.0406193844974041,
0.5508468151092529,
0.6287614107131958,
-0.058813441544771194,
-1.0377583503723145,
-0.6741577386856079,
-0.359021931886673,
-0.18409590423107147,
-0.3093219995498657,
0.91838538646698,
-0.5041576027870178,
0.44609934091567993,
0.49356070160865784,
0.36720889806747437,
0.33062681555747986,
-0.3379253149032593,
0.8573759198188782,
-0.512474536895752,
0.005404599942266941,
0.04729771986603737,
0.23374763131141663,
0.27476564049720764,
-0.39426571130752563,
0.741461992263794,
0.21348732709884644,
-0.3921618163585663,
-0.8760824203491211,
0.46401447057724,
-0.7759785056114197,
-0.554977297782898,
0.8209177851676941,
-0.26907458901405334,
-0.3547070026397705,
-0.3288903534412384,
-0.004721235483884811,
0.03878607600927353,
-0.16370269656181335,
1.001595377922058,
1.184037685394287,
-0.11897502839565277,
-0.11724720150232315,
-0.4116213023662567,
0.6955642104148865,
0.38539162278175354,
-0.535887598991394,
0.019746238365769386,
0.19189561903476715,
0.14570391178131104,
0.423522025346756,
1.037756323814392,
0.22456219792366028,
0.02094324491918087,
0.12508247792720795,
0.033337995409965515,
0.19904017448425293,
-0.3547908365726471,
-0.3050340414047241,
0.21258018910884857,
0.1716589778661728,
0.3032882809638977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10999v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10999v1 | Not All Bias is Bad: Balancing Rational Deviations and Cognitive Biases in Large Language Model Reasoning | 2024-06-16T16:25:22 | 2024-06-16T16:25:22 | Liman Wang, Hanyang Zhong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper investigates the nuanced role of biases in the decision-making
processes of large language models (LLMs). While conventional research
typically aims to eliminate all biases, our study reveals that not all biases
are detrimental. By examining rational deviations, involving heuristic
shortcuts that enhance decision-making efficiency, we highlight their potential
benefits when properly balanced. We introduce the concepts of heuristic
moderation and an abstention option, allowing LLMs to abstain from answering
when uncertain, thereby reducing error rates and improving decision accuracy.
Using our newly developed BRD (Balance Rational Deviations) dataset, our
findings demonstrate that appropriately scaled bias inspection enhances model
performance and aligns LLM decision-making more closely with human reasoning.
This balance improves the reliability and trustworthiness of LLMs and suggests
new strategies for future enhancements. Our work offers a fresh perspective on
leveraging biases constructively to enhance the practical applications of LLMs,
from conversational agents to decision support systems and beyond. | [
-0.5140387415885925,
-0.7370124459266663,
0.7604279518127441,
0.13711583614349365,
-0.12962648272514343,
-0.05836109444499016,
-0.525820791721344,
-0.38760286569595337,
-0.0825936421751976,
0.6565510630607605,
-0.43805888295173645,
-0.22484391927719116,
-0.5842164754867554,
-0.11831589043140411,
-0.03538959473371506,
0.86796635389328,
-0.020858008414506912,
0.31913307309150696,
-0.34633374214172363,
-0.254758358001709,
-0.5523573756217957,
-0.34698396921157837,
-0.7167550325393677,
-0.8524674773216248,
0.3547288179397583,
0.29370415210723877,
1.0166552066802979,
0.640606164932251,
0.25702235102653503,
0.20187772810459137,
-0.16802917420864105,
0.2954842746257782,
-0.42418211698532104,
0.2741568684577942,
-0.560043215751648,
-0.5989391207695007,
-0.2944910526275635,
0.1169697567820549,
0.5362898111343384,
0.8893263339996338,
-0.14681962132453918,
-0.03763190656900406,
0.06313996762037277,
0.7987977862358093,
-0.7321305274963379,
0.16383355855941772,
-0.5999988913536072,
-0.12146218121051788,
-0.29958921670913696,
-0.023526109755039215,
-0.5051512718200684,
-0.3487204313278198,
0.32550084590911865,
-0.3650110065937042,
-0.16555465757846832,
0.1603943556547165,
0.7006208300590515,
0.5242326855659485,
-0.4726821780204773,
-0.1034855768084526,
-0.7029733657836914,
1.201215386390686,
-0.8234454393386841,
0.501201868057251,
0.43018487095832825,
0.2762291431427002,
-0.1884324997663498,
-0.015929579734802246,
-0.3663857579231262,
0.06445854902267456,
0.059282802045345306,
-0.209594264626503,
-0.1460941880941391,
0.1908016949892044,
0.30770325660705566,
0.058822475373744965,
-0.06330698728561401,
0.27547788619995117,
-0.255014032125473,
-0.37647104263305664,
0.6559058427810669,
0.13959838449954987,
0.1991782933473587,
-0.022426877170801163,
-0.1005200520157814,
0.004426711704581976,
-0.7190961241722107,
-0.06374409794807434,
0.2885189354419708,
0.23226989805698395,
0.01971946284174919,
0.6430230736732483,
-0.22449523210525513,
0.5850610733032227,
0.0633532777428627,
-0.15296724438667297,
0.023299401625990868,
-0.25777584314346313,
-0.3796185255050659,
-0.02302633225917816,
0.6167980432510376,
0.6501209735870361,
0.7118349671363831,
-0.12815876305103302,
-0.3220042884349823,
0.24338550865650177,
0.22430159151554108,
-0.543438196182251,
-0.046278294175863266,
0.18286177515983582,
-0.3594490885734558,
-0.3175944685935974,
-0.19262248277664185,
-0.7598697543144226,
-0.5435787439346313,
-0.5361445546150208,
0.11484913527965546,
-0.27029988169670105,
-0.1985173523426056,
0.45936018228530884,
-0.16406680643558502,
0.12481007725000381,
0.6140928268432617,
-0.6885954737663269,
0.16994202136993408,
0.7002465128898621,
0.4088125228881836,
-0.20036327838897705,
-0.08891858160495758,
-0.369350403547287,
0.11184819787740707,
-0.5519233345985413,
0.6197122931480408,
-0.43569669127464294,
-0.41848689317703247,
-0.06728146970272064,
-0.24570132791996002,
0.17303575575351715,
-0.8055704236030579,
1.0432026386260986,
-0.4267701506614685,
0.14821915328502655,
-0.7272160649299622,
-0.5481456518173218,
-0.29925382137298584,
0.27606359124183655,
-0.5845487117767334,
0.6623463034629822,
-0.02242349646985531,
-0.6416109204292297,
0.6169659495353699,
-0.33779364824295044,
-0.5446471571922302,
-0.18824978172779083,
-0.2950621545314789,
-0.460191547870636,
0.07666436582803726,
0.305006742477417,
0.11783330887556076,
-0.5701289772987366,
0.3166201710700989,
-0.5754639506340027,
0.017674533650279045,
0.46928322315216064,
-0.6811913847923279,
0.9310594797134399,
0.3612237274646759,
-0.3755585849285126,
0.3198474049568176,
-0.17031294107437134,
0.25925412774086,
-0.0829853042960167,
-0.42149409651756287,
-0.5130088925361633,
0.30013519525527954,
-0.10688614100217819,
0.22130708396434784,
-0.06934944540262222,
-0.15921859443187714,
0.1269431859254837,
-0.3333951234817505,
0.3737798035144806,
1.0190798044204712,
-0.21230734884738922,
0.9079136252403259,
-0.7306297421455383,
0.2549651861190796,
0.11753031611442566,
0.2677694261074066,
0.08478019386529922,
-0.33422157168388367,
-0.8889531493186951,
-0.4433826208114624,
0.2859540283679962,
0.5762009024620056,
-0.5209634900093079,
0.5338585376739502,
-0.04362805187702179,
-0.24295774102210999,
-0.5863017439842224,
0.40082231163978577,
0.2682097256183624,
0.4273398816585541,
0.16515344381332397,
-0.15787898004055023,
-0.6251269578933716,
-0.971733033657074,
-0.49251171946525574,
-0.18630161881446838,
0.07412277162075043,
0.1733749657869339,
0.22699305415153503,
-0.305815726518631,
0.9356095194816589,
-0.34401798248291016,
-0.17013554275035858,
-0.18622693419456482,
-0.20218655467033386,
-0.0848751962184906,
0.33885470032691956,
0.461700439453125,
-0.4331705868244171,
-0.24568814039230347,
-0.17796045541763306,
-0.6864448189735413,
-0.4995509684085846,
-0.21325264871120453,
-0.532657265663147,
0.42650285363197327,
0.4146389365196228,
-1.0120048522949219,
0.158331498503685,
0.214493066072464,
-0.43026888370513916,
0.4518152177333832,
0.1496286690235138,
-0.02282024174928665,
-0.5933841466903687,
-0.3206416666507721,
0.3798266351222992,
-0.3291550874710083,
-0.34273916482925415,
-0.006044220644980669,
0.038765136152505875,
0.7507361173629761,
-0.22976547479629517,
0.5761871933937073,
-0.3843405246734619,
-0.08354423195123672,
-0.25714701414108276,
0.15810434520244598,
0.17145101726055145,
-0.08802694082260132,
-0.027685603126883507,
0.6524649858474731,
0.3324902057647705,
-0.5043830275535583,
0.12848247587680817,
0.022830141708254814,
-0.3914772868156433,
0.7083079814910889,
-0.34177762269973755,
-0.2982901632785797,
-0.20919962227344513,
0.2744750678539276,
-0.6452405452728271,
0.016631701961159706,
0.1081404834985733,
-0.35035189986228943,
0.15038488805294037,
0.1045617088675499,
-0.34585443139076233,
-0.2518743872642517,
-0.5217078924179077,
0.25398680567741394,
0.5311372876167297,
-0.4699437618255615,
0.5440502762794495,
0.4364333748817444,
-0.07711146771907806,
-0.6208921670913696,
-0.6426848769187927,
-0.08145240694284439,
-0.3544459044933319,
-0.6835185885429382,
0.021971533074975014,
-0.11188586801290512,
-1.0477466583251953,
-0.20521846413612366,
-0.2918332815170288,
0.18811017274856567,
0.21117892861366272,
-0.022295663133263588,
0.557288646697998,
-0.11656156182289124,
-0.06080574542284012,
-0.026345113292336464,
0.07772832363843918,
0.22683370113372803,
-0.39756399393081665,
0.5985045433044434,
0.02217002585530281,
-0.4618207812309265,
-0.3447728157043457,
0.07700840383768082,
0.9062241315841675,
-0.1195530816912651,
0.5112369060516357,
0.18685382604599,
-0.37503060698509216,
-0.27236342430114746,
-0.9650928974151611,
-0.3466918170452118,
-0.45710548758506775,
0.09011545777320862,
0.0013122919481247663,
-0.8150915503501892,
0.45996907353401184,
0.06877285987138748,
0.24939484894275665,
0.20015674829483032,
0.6837910413742065,
-0.10242729634046555,
1.2117609977722168,
0.3363892734050751,
-0.3883320093154907,
0.4997793436050415,
0.090884268283844,
0.39789512753486633,
-0.776412844657898,
0.019219130277633667,
-0.5533946752548218,
-0.15942400693893433,
-0.5130576491355896,
-0.636542022228241,
0.21324124932289124,
0.19190378487110138,
-0.4397430121898651,
-0.47192710638046265,
-0.31055113673210144,
0.572915256023407,
0.4019708037376404,
0.05775275453925133,
0.2953945994377136,
-0.15064837038516998,
0.036096978932619095,
-0.24197500944137573,
-0.47355642914772034,
-0.7957591414451599,
0.9977644085884094,
0.4721902310848236,
1.0361809730529785,
0.0992446020245552,
0.3200397491455078,
0.2876749634742737,
0.34620511531829834,
-0.834130585193634,
0.3736373782157898,
0.2483542114496231,
-0.7945883870124817,
-0.5051325559616089,
-0.46250098943710327,
-0.5267481803894043,
0.624925971031189,
-0.2738945186138153,
-0.5225575566291809,
0.11975979804992676,
0.10523603111505508,
-0.3261682391166687,
0.4114222228527069,
-0.8099989295005798,
0.49303367733955383,
-0.48568660020828247,
-0.7544171214103699,
-0.23304595053195953,
-0.3757393956184387,
0.5704030990600586,
-0.03015810251235962,
0.355251669883728,
-0.08167397230863571,
0.02177043817937374,
0.5621196031570435,
-0.22136171162128448,
0.8462865948677063,
0.017466871067881584,
-0.2678878605365753,
0.35643795132637024,
0.2838509976863861,
0.5533625483512878,
0.15600305795669556,
-0.33048245310783386,
0.1777261197566986,
-0.013048599474132061,
-0.498565137386322,
-0.3823493421077728,
0.5671349167823792,
-0.7894600033760071,
-0.8562840819358826,
-0.3669165372848511,
-0.6539255380630493,
-0.33873462677001953,
0.355537474155426,
0.0011423738906159997,
-0.2488529533147812,
-0.1512264609336853,
0.14727845788002014,
0.9379469752311707,
-0.1623830646276474,
0.3553309142589569,
0.4293304979801178,
-0.29378241300582886,
-0.3310195505619049,
0.38425663113594055,
0.12480279058218002,
0.6634486317634583,
0.0029833270236849785,
0.19631610810756683,
-0.29571107029914856,
-0.5151048898696899,
-0.5023540258407593,
0.23066899180412292,
-0.8163390755653381,
-0.08334509283304214,
-0.5127749443054199,
0.01951598934829235,
-0.4445962905883789,
-0.3911796808242798,
-0.4898126423358917,
-0.2269401252269745,
-0.09920714795589447,
-0.4059649407863617,
0.08086259663105011,
0.3700604736804962,
-0.013772477395832539,
0.2299228012561798,
-0.4277627468109131,
-0.00004733744208351709,
0.2661353647708893,
0.18108953535556793,
0.10409089177846909,
-0.26253363490104675,
-0.029394203796982765,
0.2563880383968353,
-0.5057297945022583,
-0.5185834765434265,
0.36812591552734375,
-0.3812403678894043,
0.8530706167221069,
0.5302155017852783,
0.15041442215442657,
0.4050111174583435,
-0.259054034948349,
0.6746721267700195,
0.16490116715431213,
-1.0008457899093628,
0.15485769510269165,
-0.6368492245674133,
0.32220831513404846,
0.5646585822105408,
0.05840124934911728,
-0.5131502151489258,
-0.27433767914772034,
-0.26283565163612366,
-0.675888180732727,
0.6693442463874817,
0.02296815626323223,
-0.0749443843960762,
0.02441572956740856,
0.21628022193908691,
-0.045487284660339355,
0.2901800572872162,
-0.6905054450035095,
-0.05176333710551262,
0.03662383556365967,
-0.18689985573291779,
-0.057318948209285736,
-0.3438112735748291,
-0.4467203617095947,
-0.3948012590408325,
0.8215412497520447,
-0.191571444272995,
-0.17460951209068298,
-0.03957228735089302,
-0.17949971556663513,
-0.3900551497936249,
0.5354102253913879,
0.6204922795295715,
0.6510701179504395,
0.024461353197693825,
0.18211986124515533,
0.39881956577301025,
-0.11851295828819275,
-0.08938798308372498,
-0.35050055384635925,
-0.3596671521663666,
-0.33809471130371094,
0.33435001969337463,
0.6351059675216675,
-0.1002325564622879,
-0.8049274682998657,
0.38041484355926514,
0.1438203603029251,
-0.09904017299413681,
-0.0879640281200409,
0.012346997857093811,
0.20960833132266998,
0.36421316862106323,
0.041034843772649765,
0.21488440036773682,
-0.09857896715402603,
-0.6095142960548401,
0.0946727767586708,
0.8090109825134277,
-0.22826644778251648,
-0.006341667380183935,
0.4510791301727295,
0.233189195394516,
-0.12411973625421524,
0.7044402956962585,
-0.018968237563967705,
-0.566318929195404,
0.6078923344612122,
0.35988569259643555,
0.6526588797569275,
-0.1741718202829361,
0.06406226009130478,
-0.10022565722465515,
0.7863298058509827,
-0.4753650724887848,
0.12287010997533798,
0.10583753138780594,
-1.148950219154358,
-0.4676238000392914,
-0.46505048871040344,
-0.43029987812042236,
-0.052536360919475555,
-0.5084434747695923,
0.4674564003944397,
-0.6342974305152893,
-0.24383489787578583,
-0.019857151433825493,
-0.17244525253772736,
-0.465789258480072,
0.12304374575614929,
0.22429823875427246,
0.8396127820014954,
-0.8249216675758362,
0.6352533102035522,
0.3307190537452698,
-0.28207358717918396,
-0.6372855305671692,
0.020834047347307205,
0.3587782680988312,
-0.6363618969917297,
0.5437913537025452,
-0.039912767708301544,
-0.09706723690032959,
-0.41980868577957153,
-0.5458036065101624,
-0.7213807702064514,
0.7321903109550476,
0.461071252822876,
-0.5445271134376526,
0.02598767727613449,
0.015276138670742512,
0.4076116681098938,
-0.19125455617904663,
0.3752496838569641,
0.8962748050689697,
0.7928575873374939,
-0.05322084203362465,
-1.0294498205184937,
0.05191738158464432,
0.24023349583148956,
-0.17851470410823822,
0.3536147475242615,
-0.7037649154663086,
0.9223495125770569,
-0.23334503173828125,
0.07599658519029617,
-0.2938126027584076,
0.26102763414382935,
0.410376638174057,
0.30792877078056335,
0.6033229231834412,
0.6784879565238953,
0.8561109900474548,
-0.26573604345321655,
0.8916477560997009,
-0.024874737486243248,
0.020197441801428795,
0.9442561268806458,
-0.8000653386116028,
0.3772553503513336,
0.7178947925567627,
-0.16172921657562256,
0.18718808889389038,
0.5506207942962646,
0.23893392086029053,
0.4447365701198578,
0.19706131517887115,
-0.3946499228477478,
-0.6461613774299622,
-0.16520445048809052,
0.0571061447262764,
0.2972941994667053,
0.5728820562362671,
-0.3035537600517273,
-0.269500195980072,
-0.14129647612571716,
0.3276657462120056,
0.3153036832809448,
-0.16326434910297394,
0.6414151787757874,
0.18470312654972076,
-0.9279235005378723,
0.38857409358024597,
0.07900523394346237,
0.9398345351219177,
-0.3082595467567444,
0.182272270321846,
0.018433047458529472,
0.4017859399318695,
-0.37694448232650757,
-0.8488008379936218,
0.4000824987888336,
-0.19685763120651245,
-0.5824155807495117,
-0.45616406202316284,
0.6290937066078186,
-0.18049292266368866,
-0.2881481647491455,
0.4201774001121521,
0.6757842302322388,
-0.2892225384712219,
-0.06457848846912384,
-0.6294050216674805,
0.3867953419685364,
0.3329727351665497,
-0.1396288424730301,
0.2529445290565491,
0.4770609140396118,
-0.6528381109237671,
0.8269317746162415,
0.6311016082763672,
0.19172756373882294,
-0.05059994012117386,
0.2769944369792938,
0.7108538150787354,
-0.58774334192276,
-0.35004496574401855,
-1.1000328063964844,
0.30188751220703125,
-0.2762720584869385,
0.02642039954662323,
0.7320170998573303,
0.5212094783782959,
0.9182848930358887,
0.29379063844680786,
1.225259780883789,
0.4261265993118286,
0.46942684054374695,
-0.5032489895820618,
0.5391936302185059,
-0.1705603450536728,
0.6667494773864746,
-0.20901794731616974,
-0.7574414610862732,
-0.23401093482971191,
0.8434237241744995,
-0.7663744688034058,
0.25778308510780334,
0.5341629385948181,
0.7847900986671448,
0.13244228065013885,
0.27538371086120605,
0.24523358047008514,
0.17756444215774536,
0.6555790901184082,
0.2629005014896393,
0.9244722723960876,
-0.015236013568937778,
0.13955266773700714,
-0.0904143825173378,
-0.22626446187496185,
-0.2650665044784546,
-0.7569912075996399,
-1.0176931619644165,
0.021141208708286285,
-0.19572857022285461,
-0.4234126806259155,
0.05129149183630943,
1.1573964357376099,
0.7121700644493103,
-0.6274286508560181,
-0.35020557045936584,
0.03115149401128292,
0.6736037731170654,
-0.059491753578186035,
-0.2550414502620697,
-0.16781790554523468,
-0.4653688967227936,
-0.6459253430366516,
0.06942006200551987,
0.2699737250804901,
0.012597372755408287,
-0.3851708769798279,
-0.17422887682914734,
-0.22479839622974396,
0.5683383941650391,
0.6815327405929565,
0.0275399349629879,
-0.8416114449501038,
-0.3461126387119293,
0.02342204377055168,
-0.29956358671188354,
-0.03552054986357689,
0.7580059766769409,
-0.4355156719684601,
0.22091780602931976,
0.6766783595085144,
0.6312775611877441,
0.1496228277683258,
-0.057569719851017,
0.8358412384986877,
-0.26532086730003357,
0.1268233060836792,
0.237516388297081,
0.5612828135490417,
0.5198729634284973,
-0.3095947802066803,
0.4104960262775421,
0.057820506393909454,
-0.6027067303657532,
-0.9005503058433533,
0.32849568128585815,
-0.8803542256355286,
-0.4589632749557495,
1.394626498222351,
0.39108118414878845,
-0.21611197292804718,
-0.20021001994609833,
-0.4238213896751404,
0.15361447632312775,
-0.4686439335346222,
0.7901896238327026,
1.1550986766815186,
-0.15772148966789246,
-0.15328195691108704,
-0.7865990400314331,
0.4730806350708008,
0.833331286907196,
-0.8042627573013306,
0.37421202659606934,
0.9115644097328186,
0.4657435119152069,
0.0822376236319542,
0.517870306968689,
-0.23520450294017792,
0.035142380744218826,
-0.35211727023124695,
0.14244595170021057,
0.3188055157661438,
-0.00342865870334208,
-0.30086204409599304,
-0.21784621477127075,
0.43717703223228455,
0.20504647493362427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10996v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10996v1 | THEANINE: Revisiting Memory Management in Long-term Conversations with Timeline-augmented Response Generation | 2024-06-16T16:17:46 | 2024-06-16T16:17:46 | Seo Hyun Kim, Kai Tzu-iunn Ong, Taeyoon Kwon, Namyoung Kim, Keummin Ka, SeongHyeon Bae, Yohan Jo, Seung-won Hwang, Dongha Lee, Jinyoung Yeo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are capable of processing lengthy dialogue
histories during prolonged interaction with users without additional memory
modules; however, their responses tend to overlook or incorrectly recall
information from the past. In this paper, we revisit memory-augmented response
generation in the era of LLMs. While prior work focuses on getting rid of
outdated memories, we argue that such memories can provide contextual cues that
help dialogue systems understand the development of past events and, therefore,
benefit response generation. We present Theanine, a framework that augments
LLMs' response generation with memory timelines -- series of memories that
demonstrate the development and causality of relevant past events. Along with
Theanine, we introduce TeaFarm, a counterfactual-driven question-answering
pipeline addressing the limitation of G-Eval in long-term conversations.
Supplementary videos of our methods and the TeaBag dataset for TeaFarm
evaluation are in https://theanine-693b0.web.app/. | [
-0.3484935462474823,
-1.1728731393814087,
0.5873211622238159,
-0.28388145565986633,
-0.10938898473978043,
0.08343450725078583,
-0.11953607946634293,
-0.3436456024646759,
0.5191600918769836,
0.7483798861503601,
-0.8087126612663269,
0.00901117455214262,
-0.18433313071727753,
-0.29850250482559204,
-0.39967799186706543,
0.9334493279457092,
0.031792864203453064,
-0.1300593614578247,
-0.30811139941215515,
-0.20234544575214386,
-0.7154824137687683,
-0.848179817199707,
-1.108643651008606,
-0.6677298545837402,
0.927400529384613,
0.34364718198776245,
0.5296177268028259,
0.4223092794418335,
0.1657869964838028,
0.3007696866989136,
-0.16477558016777039,
-0.045864224433898926,
-0.6725632548332214,
0.42331770062446594,
-0.3313199579715729,
-0.4402317404747009,
-0.5336751937866211,
-0.42034679651260376,
0.35704267024993896,
0.7169834971427917,
-0.23731496930122375,
0.12410201877355576,
-0.05232289060950279,
0.5119286179542542,
-0.5812988877296448,
-0.03724810108542442,
-0.6476171612739563,
0.1288747936487198,
-0.006168579217046499,
-0.4861326217651367,
-0.3379769027233124,
-0.05672908201813698,
0.30071067810058594,
-0.31650301814079285,
0.051155976951122284,
0.03504260256886482,
0.5379422307014465,
0.125154048204422,
-0.4012066125869751,
-0.3408803641796112,
-0.9764858484268188,
0.8746427297592163,
-0.577442467212677,
0.023978840559720993,
0.42378291487693787,
0.24504892528057098,
-0.3052603304386139,
-0.8327400088310242,
-0.5316721796989441,
-0.07036586105823517,
-0.05319945141673088,
0.11175613850355148,
-0.19606329500675201,
0.0882987380027771,
0.2882983386516571,
0.3705771267414093,
-0.6486585736274719,
0.05414359271526337,
-0.3526154160499573,
-0.44374939799308777,
0.17459164559841156,
0.3301873803138733,
0.2274613380432129,
-0.21375888586044312,
-0.5584571361541748,
0.1949046403169632,
-0.7180067896842957,
-0.21416865289211273,
-0.025948354974389076,
-0.0537174753844738,
0.25133824348449707,
0.46570321917533875,
0.04767590016126633,
0.5244825482368469,
-0.09957887977361679,
0.060016367584466934,
-0.30761241912841797,
-0.24372053146362305,
-0.43515563011169434,
0.3720334470272064,
0.53354811668396,
0.2877304255962372,
0.5902448892593384,
-0.23540937900543213,
0.45387470722198486,
-0.023528533056378365,
0.3448481559753418,
-1.0150333642959595,
-0.306543231010437,
0.4039279818534851,
-0.280138224363327,
0.008867749944329262,
-0.5642749667167664,
-0.879658579826355,
-0.31393808126449585,
0.08309171348810196,
0.2841040790081024,
-0.16359244287014008,
-0.4767495393753052,
-0.03662796691060066,
-0.17821814119815826,
0.25020745396614075,
0.21818220615386963,
-0.7074361443519592,
0.3623124063014984,
0.5123624801635742,
0.5097975134849548,
-0.010459460318088531,
-0.0944078266620636,
-0.7626587748527527,
0.5232142806053162,
-0.2000342160463333,
0.813416063785553,
-0.5653612613677979,
-0.7443708181381226,
-0.016203580424189568,
-0.17961865663528442,
0.09632694721221924,
-0.5833807587623596,
0.19702009856700897,
-0.7151890993118286,
0.3363634943962097,
-0.2597125172615051,
-0.5987321138381958,
-0.11786916851997375,
0.520200252532959,
-0.5703953504562378,
0.7090224623680115,
0.06097119674086571,
-0.40932485461235046,
0.057584747672080994,
-0.4971170425415039,
-0.36812785267829895,
-0.14362575113773346,
-0.20276518166065216,
-0.4413946568965912,
-0.012317737564444542,
0.08847007155418396,
0.09790994226932526,
-0.490811288356781,
0.6280705332756042,
-0.3979952037334442,
-0.22582606971263885,
0.38711944222450256,
-0.8222965002059937,
0.6166554689407349,
0.11274778842926025,
-0.08123172074556351,
0.06540097296237946,
-0.6675014495849609,
0.04305277392268181,
0.12649552524089813,
-0.05822254717350006,
-0.10505414754152298,
0.09025207161903381,
-0.5298766493797302,
0.19872713088989258,
-0.07288111001253128,
-0.2814497947692871,
-0.15297168493270874,
-0.27571266889572144,
0.6585618257522583,
0.7652474045753479,
0.4086531400680542,
0.4787807762622833,
-0.37294477224349976,
0.2762954831123352,
0.3051503300666809,
-0.0013734643580392003,
-0.9092231392860413,
-0.13537907600402832,
-1.1228225231170654,
0.2254023551940918,
-0.08067865669727325,
0.6052536368370056,
-0.7625802159309387,
0.25025638937950134,
-0.29195746779441833,
-0.03989990055561066,
0.12404457479715347,
0.3039500117301941,
0.1147708147764206,
0.8864762783050537,
0.5766507983207703,
-0.33677390217781067,
-0.7079244256019592,
-0.8849840760231018,
-0.24033883213996887,
-0.7961233854293823,
-0.07148239016532898,
0.6261065602302551,
0.21747814118862152,
0.026751309633255005,
0.9854714274406433,
-0.4383247196674347,
0.11294310539960861,
-0.10945253074169159,
0.23910841345787048,
-0.09727215766906738,
0.45720502734184265,
0.2432657927274704,
-0.650251567363739,
0.12410739064216614,
-0.3380538523197174,
-0.4611104130744934,
-0.1278788149356842,
-0.4808705747127533,
-0.18181203305721283,
0.35523736476898193,
0.4963386058807373,
-0.8746019005775452,
0.5068265795707703,
0.2663624882698059,
-0.15245525538921356,
0.29180455207824707,
0.018485410138964653,
0.1445210725069046,
-1.147207498550415,
0.14998801052570343,
-0.41343384981155396,
-0.2876688241958618,
-0.5526690483093262,
-0.6016915440559387,
-0.279344379901886,
-0.27973389625549316,
-0.5587568283081055,
0.8221556544303894,
-0.4064098298549652,
0.06719114631414413,
-0.2999860942363739,
0.22035229206085205,
0.042017862200737,
0.6800488829612732,
0.23746399581432343,
0.759325385093689,
0.11319663375616074,
-0.5826370716094971,
0.5925189852714539,
0.1515512615442276,
-0.07017847895622253,
0.6910059452056885,
-0.44407591223716736,
0.36161261796951294,
-0.07462114840745926,
0.3774741590023041,
-1.3411649465560913,
-0.2605981230735779,
0.5283578038215637,
-0.20725718140602112,
0.41378289461135864,
0.017227478325366974,
-0.206248477101326,
-0.6911700963973999,
-0.19701366126537323,
0.4088650047779083,
0.454994797706604,
-0.6105608344078064,
0.8183339238166809,
0.053246788680553436,
-0.39889436960220337,
-0.4022616147994995,
-0.7268491387367249,
0.560259997844696,
-0.5206495523452759,
-0.4063529074192047,
0.006515200715512037,
-0.366681307554245,
-0.2591433525085449,
-0.06259963661432266,
-0.41264671087265015,
-0.009496507234871387,
0.10114527493715286,
-0.0009557437151670456,
0.16194018721580505,
-0.1089009940624237,
0.4285258650779724,
-0.19465649127960205,
-0.06409739702939987,
0.24733325839042664,
-0.16910171508789062,
0.833560585975647,
0.44125914573669434,
-0.17305652797222137,
-0.07966390997171402,
0.5366452932357788,
0.2634625732898712,
-0.10531533509492874,
0.6865046620368958,
0.34737324714660645,
-0.2543026804924011,
-0.09650075435638428,
-0.6740831136703491,
-0.3264428675174713,
-0.4683021008968353,
0.36386728286743164,
-0.26647427678108215,
-1.0035637617111206,
0.59487384557724,
-0.3157424330711365,
-0.2606526017189026,
0.2721262276172638,
0.5699959993362427,
-0.2389063835144043,
0.6483247876167297,
0.15291403234004974,
-0.1345815807580948,
0.7809098362922668,
0.08880395442247391,
0.28552284836769104,
-0.7838605642318726,
-0.12177453935146332,
-0.21905362606048584,
-0.3588511347770691,
-0.23193766176700592,
-0.2554965019226074,
0.22624993324279785,
0.15127840638160706,
-0.6492500305175781,
0.007805878762155771,
0.2015986144542694,
0.470736563205719,
0.13135914504528046,
0.2465648502111435,
0.12936560809612274,
-0.01300691720098257,
0.25566092133522034,
0.125734344124794,
-0.7343124747276306,
-0.35525521636009216,
0.7865059971809387,
0.2558004558086395,
0.689771831035614,
0.06440747529268265,
0.3152848184108734,
0.1171720027923584,
0.39622315764427185,
-0.668911874294281,
0.8455524444580078,
0.21845529973506927,
-0.581344723701477,
0.0126569839194417,
-0.504748523235321,
-0.9157190918922424,
0.0025619075167924166,
-0.0200809258967638,
-1.0363625288009644,
-0.08307602256536484,
0.3478630483150482,
-0.6556373834609985,
0.44488462805747986,
-0.5978551506996155,
0.7230352163314819,
-0.49895402789115906,
-0.7267372608184814,
-0.3021603226661682,
-0.7657367587089539,
0.33055126667022705,
0.09564691036939621,
-0.1791834980249405,
0.029544129967689514,
0.08846917748451233,
0.48194846510887146,
-0.6352143883705139,
1.1060361862182617,
0.0743955671787262,
-0.10336349159479141,
0.6523483991622925,
0.20293577015399933,
0.41899096965789795,
0.29627373814582825,
0.038354720920324326,
-0.06876905262470245,
-0.1842406988143921,
-0.43255361914634705,
-0.6207572817802429,
0.9782694578170776,
-0.28403979539871216,
-1.034170150756836,
-0.2682381868362427,
-0.6077228784561157,
-0.23298980295658112,
0.11389968544244766,
-0.14641234278678894,
0.6213300228118896,
-0.571104109287262,
0.08275480568408966,
0.9242842793464661,
-0.47856149077415466,
0.8269948959350586,
0.2852831184864044,
-0.4225509464740753,
-0.3732645511627197,
0.4513609707355499,
0.13364633917808533,
0.43170809745788574,
0.29281800985336304,
0.09410189092159271,
-0.11143571883440018,
-0.15713216364383698,
-0.5883519053459167,
-0.08357978612184525,
-0.437503457069397,
-0.37792056798934937,
-0.6202042102813721,
-0.21060170233249664,
-0.10862791538238525,
0.13225378096103668,
-0.1652347445487976,
-0.5189491510391235,
-0.4189698100090027,
-0.14042618870735168,
0.47680148482322693,
0.22977375984191895,
0.03519846871495247,
0.5636903643608093,
-0.7877171039581299,
0.3048397898674011,
0.4499332904815674,
0.3683053255081177,
0.32782474160194397,
-0.1709374636411667,
-0.2989555597305298,
0.27028223872184753,
-0.4032168984413147,
-0.9357707500457764,
0.26588037610054016,
0.09686358273029327,
0.34619009494781494,
0.26360994577407837,
-0.26996853947639465,
0.8245135545730591,
-0.6178296804428101,
1.2574080228805542,
0.10654738545417786,
-0.6354485750198364,
0.5115308165550232,
-0.4042295515537262,
0.5623934268951416,
0.104192815721035,
0.09623313695192337,
-0.7052074074745178,
-0.10807892680168152,
-0.7091537117958069,
-1.0038070678710938,
0.30865055322647095,
-0.012215128168463707,
0.3209438621997833,
-0.2599999010562897,
0.5549647212028503,
-0.1628669798374176,
0.3847954571247101,
-0.28241321444511414,
-0.17310002446174622,
-0.06012532487511635,
0.04509575292468071,
-0.11930972337722778,
-0.41168758273124695,
-0.23865115642547607,
0.0303813349455595,
0.36738502979278564,
0.1131347194314003,
0.44840192794799805,
0.1878911256790161,
-0.24018743634223938,
-0.2101333886384964,
0.6001536250114441,
0.47310003638267517,
0.7968254685401917,
-0.2625632882118225,
0.18028812110424042,
0.33940520882606506,
-0.136630117893219,
-0.04861800745129585,
-0.13688147068023682,
0.12420433014631271,
-0.18975260853767395,
0.2012089490890503,
0.7451825737953186,
0.22031475603580475,
-0.6976664066314697,
0.08254935592412949,
-0.1054348573088646,
0.14546506106853485,
-0.705845296382904,
0.3208981454372406,
0.13239315152168274,
0.22985996305942535,
0.46146467328071594,
-0.17868240177631378,
0.14759725332260132,
-0.8879973292350769,
0.26532313227653503,
0.40414607524871826,
-0.2139483392238617,
-0.19812358915805817,
0.6484653353691101,
0.1568823903799057,
-0.4778519570827484,
0.6750448942184448,
0.34738731384277344,
-0.4898812770843506,
0.6189038157463074,
0.7707741260528564,
0.9595968127250671,
-0.3316797614097595,
0.1508496105670929,
0.38403233885765076,
-0.14888057112693787,
-0.03633280098438263,
0.1366828978061676,
-0.3682487905025482,
-0.6365844011306763,
-0.5479825139045715,
-0.2379685640335083,
-0.39194750785827637,
0.38252994418144226,
-0.6599737405776978,
-0.3018282949924469,
-0.5418502688407898,
-0.39520761370658875,
-0.3202975392341614,
-0.11655069887638092,
-0.6433546543121338,
0.3200973868370056,
0.19601210951805115,
0.8864520192146301,
-0.4408554136753082,
0.7237791419029236,
0.23631680011749268,
-0.3006308376789093,
-0.41806158423423767,
-0.011034740135073662,
0.08326121419668198,
-0.544940710067749,
0.365756630897522,
-0.0023589739575982094,
-0.18562382459640503,
-0.0013066896935924888,
-0.6941583752632141,
-0.6312136054039001,
1.1093056201934814,
0.25426241755485535,
-0.5394609570503235,
0.002005817601457238,
0.24847303330898285,
0.6498525142669678,
-0.2696758508682251,
0.4864950180053711,
0.8154348134994507,
0.27706050872802734,
0.3896265923976898,
-0.6933826208114624,
-0.1738804131746292,
-0.1677134931087494,
0.17286722362041473,
0.46648356318473816,
-0.8555229902267456,
0.4656248092651367,
-0.07763168960809708,
-0.33816903829574585,
0.6153446435928345,
0.7102500796318054,
-0.02862614393234253,
0.2299564778804779,
0.15032601356506348,
0.48872143030166626,
0.7695849537849426,
-0.2070007175207138,
1.0578185319900513,
0.05752406269311905,
-0.16343921422958374,
1.4261760711669922,
-0.26851263642311096,
0.8954663872718811,
0.9529482126235962,
0.12908224761486053,
0.5216202139854431,
0.5018839836120605,
0.37392330169677734,
0.3019730746746063,
0.35664790868759155,
-0.5300803184509277,
-0.33542299270629883,
-0.2955187261104584,
-0.20358459651470184,
0.2452763020992279,
0.5815290808677673,
-0.2833206355571747,
-0.3856264352798462,
-0.09031336009502411,
0.1432247906923294,
-0.08361988514661789,
-0.5945742130279541,
0.9426925182342529,
0.3325275480747223,
-0.6253235340118408,
0.5246021747589111,
-0.5017257332801819,
0.31957361102104187,
-0.579034149646759,
-0.05743169039487839,
-0.576279878616333,
0.2332535684108734,
0.1646270900964737,
-0.7658068537712097,
0.4433823525905609,
-0.08573738485574722,
-0.3656958043575287,
-0.18162372708320618,
0.8312845230102539,
-0.7727007269859314,
-0.18317954242229462,
0.38238945603370667,
0.6721271872520447,
-0.055820249021053314,
0.3221305310726166,
-0.47168606519699097,
0.20201075077056885,
-0.3047649562358856,
-0.47838661074638367,
0.1644826978445053,
0.2932429015636444,
-0.1872159093618393,
0.6733792424201965,
0.3147471845149994,
0.02999122254550457,
-0.22144298255443573,
0.003501198487356305,
0.8506470918655396,
-0.7528114914894104,
-0.24570795893669128,
-1.175686001777649,
0.404908150434494,
-0.2410469502210617,
-0.10898305475711823,
0.6351073980331421,
0.43101197481155396,
0.6763337850570679,
0.2178480476140976,
0.577037513256073,
0.2778034210205078,
0.6314148306846619,
-0.5866414904594421,
0.3885084092617035,
-0.3564603626728058,
0.5129278302192688,
-0.07108458131551743,
-0.7818669080734253,
-0.2843838930130005,
0.29892393946647644,
-0.41331472992897034,
0.30083614587783813,
0.4906581938266754,
0.8065239191055298,
0.062105629593133926,
0.13960735499858856,
0.17573373019695282,
0.5469651222229004,
0.5118149518966675,
1.0452919006347656,
0.9991695284843445,
-0.42643028497695923,
0.7297396063804626,
0.4019804894924164,
0.20910291373729706,
0.16649200022220612,
-0.9893633723258972,
-0.9529464244842529,
-0.14912311732769012,
-0.11702486872673035,
-0.4835617244243622,
0.45745018124580383,
0.8419070839881897,
0.20387142896652222,
-0.8686431646347046,
-0.332396000623703,
0.0695062056183815,
0.04168736934661865,
0.2123553603887558,
-0.16603659093379974,
0.2561783492565155,
-0.15926478803157806,
-0.48674947023391724,
0.2792762219905853,
0.5874598622322083,
0.16016952693462372,
-0.28258734941482544,
-0.006846222095191479,
-0.21556377410888672,
0.4610549211502075,
0.6185314655303955,
0.6302692294120789,
-0.393082857131958,
-0.5295464992523193,
-0.1060931459069252,
0.10994677990674973,
0.3405126929283142,
0.9050877690315247,
-1.021831750869751,
0.4997689723968506,
0.3432439863681793,
0.7172631621360779,
0.7524511814117432,
-0.04459552839398384,
0.9440321326255798,
-0.5375086665153503,
0.14340414106845856,
-0.007725321222096682,
0.1934768110513687,
0.3785349726676941,
-0.15920214354991913,
0.2750154733657837,
-0.036156393587589264,
-0.5639092922210693,
-0.6832415461540222,
0.48108771443367004,
-0.7418919801712036,
-0.3016101121902466,
1.060899019241333,
0.13502536714076996,
-0.40532436966896057,
-0.07499285042285919,
-0.3485027849674225,
0.18666262924671173,
-0.24986737966537476,
0.6329103708267212,
0.8685256242752075,
-0.18903902173042297,
-0.5322163701057434,
-0.5053743124008179,
0.5200725793838501,
0.6671324968338013,
-0.8014528751373291,
0.10048078745603561,
0.8705620169639587,
0.16065242886543274,
0.14155340194702148,
0.869806170463562,
-0.003983605187386274,
0.2732711136341095,
-0.19899050891399384,
-0.37710779905319214,
0.10465395450592041,
-0.3695822060108185,
-0.18651491403579712,
0.07035316526889801,
-0.08692777901887894,
0.12492341548204422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10993v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10993v1 | CoSTA: Code-Switched Speech Translation using Aligned Speech-Text Interleaving | 2024-06-16T16:10:51 | 2024-06-16T16:10:51 | Bhavani Shankar, Preethi Jyothi, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Code-switching is a widely prevalent linguistic phenomenon in multilingual
societies like India. Building speech-to-text models for code-switched speech
is challenging due to limited availability of datasets. In this work, we focus
on the problem of spoken translation (ST) of code-switched speech in Indian
languages to English text. We present a new end-to-end model architecture COSTA
that scaffolds on pretrained automatic speech recognition (ASR) and machine
translation (MT) modules (that are more widely available for many languages).
Speech and ASR text representations are fused using an aligned interleaving
scheme and are fed further as input to a pretrained MT module; the whole
pipeline is then trained end-to-end for spoken translation using synthetically
created ST data. We also release a new evaluation benchmark for code-switched
Bengali-English, Hindi-English, Marathi-English and Telugu- English speech to
English text. COSTA significantly outperforms many competitive cascaded and
end-to-end multimodal baselines by up to 3.5 BLEU points. | [
-0.010645374655723572,
-0.5246782898902893,
0.017745928838849068,
0.7263354063034058,
-0.6042084693908691,
0.5082618594169617,
-0.4544944763183594,
-0.5145125389099121,
-0.030099844560027122,
0.3637063503265381,
-0.3402118980884552,
-0.23423832654953003,
-0.5898004174232483,
0.18472091853618622,
-0.6641736626625061,
1.1021983623504639,
-0.1799039989709854,
0.5190836191177368,
-0.09841828793287277,
-0.07717542350292206,
-0.6578917503356934,
-0.44209590554237366,
-0.4699636399745941,
-0.2672879695892334,
0.2739338278770447,
0.35436031222343445,
0.607943058013916,
0.4660542905330658,
0.3559338450431824,
0.2349216639995575,
0.10222325474023819,
0.18378332257270813,
-0.23806194961071014,
-0.14401085674762726,
-0.29234904050827026,
-0.48702001571655273,
-0.4255019426345825,
-0.2118554562330246,
0.671841561794281,
0.4184116721153259,
-0.18991534411907196,
0.15447571873664856,
0.25961631536483765,
0.4662134349346161,
-0.3250725567340851,
0.3863353431224823,
-0.8994588851928711,
-0.28369584679603577,
-0.5530472993850708,
-0.2906634211540222,
-0.6608299612998962,
-0.3509516716003418,
-0.14334051311016083,
-0.2998276650905609,
-0.08068640530109406,
-0.18981513381004333,
0.869708240032196,
0.40303218364715576,
-0.350966215133667,
-0.5352100133895874,
-0.8386811017990112,
0.5414191484451294,
-0.7062497138977051,
0.6971697807312012,
0.317556768655777,
0.43132874369621277,
0.32632166147232056,
-0.6121338605880737,
-0.6827990412712097,
0.007418360095471144,
0.06870239228010178,
0.3233025372028351,
-0.13397635519504547,
-0.0939556136727333,
-0.18311408162117004,
0.1924947053194046,
-0.5215422511100769,
-0.012084079906344414,
-0.6390479803085327,
-0.017135951668024063,
0.7307506799697876,
-0.13464388251304626,
0.3804710805416107,
0.023364275693893433,
-0.5032668113708496,
-0.12702657282352448,
-0.6637598276138306,
0.0927213579416275,
0.6462438106536865,
0.554395318031311,
-0.3968655467033386,
0.3162505328655243,
0.02960578165948391,
0.9395431876182556,
-0.08311814069747925,
-0.056489042937755585,
0.3080880045890808,
-0.21638832986354828,
-0.21866293251514435,
0.4113471806049347,
0.5835912227630615,
0.18870386481285095,
0.22383461892604828,
-0.013293316587805748,
-0.18728411197662354,
0.4542849063873291,
0.17692019045352936,
-0.21553024649620056,
0.03756943717598915,
-0.020646505057811737,
-0.2953477203845978,
-0.02887551672756672,
-0.3123672604560852,
-0.719555139541626,
0.19470760226249695,
-0.3265729546546936,
0.3702543079853058,
-0.4383963346481323,
-0.3530927002429962,
0.23882734775543213,
0.32028141617774963,
0.7513384222984314,
0.21196819841861725,
-0.6937688589096069,
0.3544473350048065,
0.5278935432434082,
0.8504284620285034,
-0.46510666608810425,
-0.275455504655838,
-0.33017587661743164,
0.29193034768104553,
-0.293427050113678,
0.7815113663673401,
-0.7558936476707458,
-0.5352838635444641,
0.3540409207344055,
-0.1016680896282196,
-0.2859511971473694,
-0.22215218842029572,
0.7551329731941223,
-0.6359912753105164,
0.17579489946365356,
0.16925309598445892,
-0.17633602023124695,
0.05992771312594414,
0.041673243045806885,
-0.3042975664138794,
0.8722202777862549,
-0.303431898355484,
-0.3604433536529541,
0.06336688995361328,
-0.34748610854148865,
-0.8239113092422485,
0.1535547971725464,
-0.3120379149913788,
-0.3807411789894104,
-0.04503859579563141,
0.1753624826669693,
0.09666240215301514,
-0.44136685132980347,
0.36049601435661316,
0.14222651720046997,
-0.3045651912689209,
0.31705161929130554,
-0.6304608583450317,
0.7110319137573242,
0.6435779333114624,
-0.06182214990258217,
0.07109785079956055,
-0.7013275027275085,
0.18389160931110382,
-0.15134848654270172,
-0.3668634593486786,
-0.22973009943962097,
0.0500979907810688,
0.3635399639606476,
0.4487510621547699,
0.4175836145877838,
-0.6645638346672058,
0.10414337366819382,
-0.15643063187599182,
0.6028103828430176,
0.4401240050792694,
-0.3609869182109833,
0.32745230197906494,
-0.2580418288707733,
0.5771991014480591,
0.08249542862176895,
0.09920088201761246,
-0.18422208726406097,
-0.6725016236305237,
-0.7060642838478088,
-0.13134361803531647,
0.25591403245925903,
0.8116805553436279,
-0.78587806224823,
0.09770312160253525,
-0.4503878951072693,
-0.3832036554813385,
-1.0566767454147339,
-0.24947431683540344,
0.9386726021766663,
0.37585535645484924,
0.496496319770813,
-0.078153595328331,
-0.40595170855522156,
-0.998650848865509,
-0.5094018578529358,
-0.04562823474407196,
0.3084114193916321,
-0.07826010882854462,
0.09727268666028976,
-0.34076616168022156,
0.7418720722198486,
-0.3547729551792145,
-0.3566533327102661,
-0.3593180477619171,
-0.011379682458937168,
0.2927999198436737,
0.6755872368812561,
-0.05600760132074356,
-0.9278696179389954,
-0.816058337688446,
0.2224254310131073,
-0.07892627269029617,
-0.4677722752094269,
-0.33596140146255493,
0.0058869593776762486,
0.4018232822418213,
0.8481050729751587,
-0.15743543207645416,
0.49297410249710083,
0.9848766922950745,
0.09555783867835999,
0.28710004687309265,
-0.4020136892795563,
0.411466121673584,
-1.2602980136871338,
0.15806758403778076,
-0.35616570711135864,
-0.2515906095504761,
-0.6349464058876038,
0.012655257247388363,
0.43054211139678955,
-0.3463207483291626,
-0.7139892578125,
0.2284129112958908,
-0.5148851871490479,
-0.3170488476753235,
-0.18620575964450836,
0.16480891406536102,
-0.1561148315668106,
0.702698826789856,
0.11741886287927628,
1.1356074810028076,
0.23566129803657532,
-0.5985094308853149,
-0.09697893261909485,
0.6754757165908813,
-0.2774694561958313,
0.6725776791572571,
-0.5645765662193298,
0.24337267875671387,
0.03467579185962677,
0.18780162930488586,
-1.3326350450515747,
0.1597028523683548,
-0.054572951048612595,
-0.7454806566238403,
0.41012078523635864,
-0.32210633158683777,
-0.24924226105213165,
-0.034785714000463486,
0.2019864022731781,
0.7569536566734314,
0.39245566725730896,
-0.5898906588554382,
0.09660173952579498,
0.6914952993392944,
-0.3128587305545807,
-0.3393007218837738,
-0.9226109385490417,
0.244866281747818,
0.08990208059549332,
-0.5198553800582886,
0.4974310100078583,
-0.11651328206062317,
0.13967981934547424,
-0.15688365697860718,
-0.13656459748744965,
-0.39584365487098694,
-0.5440055131912231,
0.06846149265766144,
0.31976866722106934,
-0.06121600791811943,
-0.10550748556852341,
0.37111297249794006,
-0.3683992922306061,
-0.21218463778495789,
-0.29506435990333557,
0.8678401708602905,
-0.1259135603904724,
-0.5225661396980286,
-0.2418283224105835,
0.5999696850776672,
0.39653149247169495,
-0.6682919859886169,
0.3148125112056732,
0.2399044930934906,
-0.40801918506622314,
-0.07530893385410309,
-0.2601989805698395,
0.5296342372894287,
-0.41845640540122986,
0.43554791808128357,
-0.7009186148643494,
-0.5374326109886169,
0.5642217993736267,
-0.10022509843111038,
0.23466907441616058,
0.2436579167842865,
0.6457586884498596,
-0.06210304796695709,
1.1090524196624756,
0.5058528780937195,
0.06513136625289917,
0.529966413974762,
-0.005453616846352816,
0.5698789358139038,
-0.7999812960624695,
-0.2688528001308441,
-0.6745975017547607,
-0.14363867044448853,
-0.5897420644760132,
-0.7401986122131348,
0.46822816133499146,
-0.07718506455421448,
0.2816038727760315,
0.7115375399589539,
-0.5400769114494324,
0.43304306268692017,
0.16958986222743988,
0.04317061975598335,
0.5049523115158081,
-0.1959763467311859,
0.06794429570436478,
-0.1798580288887024,
-0.5455591082572937,
-0.343662291765213,
0.8916980624198914,
0.079038105905056,
0.8742467164993286,
0.17720633745193481,
0.3479946553707123,
0.4947037994861603,
0.09674776345491409,
-0.4074127674102783,
0.5994569063186646,
-0.5436483025550842,
-0.4437533915042877,
0.054828327149152756,
-0.10343284159898758,
-0.8475708365440369,
0.2942655384540558,
-0.10969046503305435,
-0.2194393128156662,
0.09834080934524536,
0.13860881328582764,
-0.00372000178322196,
0.1926395744085312,
-0.7470115423202515,
0.5058032274246216,
-0.41814759373664856,
-0.2763734757900238,
-0.5780335068702698,
-0.8451285362243652,
0.26722028851509094,
-0.06329215317964554,
0.2844507694244385,
0.08797257393598557,
-0.03409447520971298,
0.5252647399902344,
-0.34974780678749084,
0.5180883407592773,
0.13490615785121918,
-0.2654434144496918,
0.13438285887241364,
-0.13774751126766205,
0.3518506586551666,
-0.08057314902544022,
-0.10217598080635071,
0.5536829829216003,
0.028425974771380424,
-0.38614147901535034,
-0.20029838383197784,
0.6276189684867859,
-0.7887239456176758,
-0.29913169145584106,
-0.5970543622970581,
-0.6127896904945374,
-0.4400995075702667,
0.1569068431854248,
0.47964465618133545,
0.6293594241142273,
-0.16732844710350037,
-0.07104910165071487,
0.6556259989738464,
-0.38521528244018555,
0.5354061722755432,
0.6365223526954651,
-0.23807939887046814,
-0.660459041595459,
0.9337921738624573,
0.14700686931610107,
0.6892995834350586,
0.6669294238090515,
-0.29272764921188354,
-0.49852293729782104,
-0.5657776594161987,
-0.8394830226898193,
0.22224146127700806,
-0.4163687229156494,
-0.27622565627098083,
-0.6125138998031616,
-0.4568871259689331,
-0.4905470907688141,
-0.5945176482200623,
-0.5298322439193726,
-0.16240645945072174,
0.14508219063282013,
0.17067374289035797,
0.09001140296459198,
0.6102629899978638,
0.010941781103610992,
0.6229591965675354,
-0.7239819169044495,
0.20454207062721252,
0.10182781517505646,
0.44881588220596313,
-0.5222913026809692,
-0.7456158399581909,
-0.4581330120563507,
0.1611391305923462,
0.11928150802850723,
-1.0163544416427612,
0.6317231059074402,
0.2246795892715454,
0.37357011437416077,
0.12899520993232727,
-0.09175454080104828,
1.101348638534546,
-0.7843136191368103,
0.3945586085319519,
0.24483157694339752,
-1.1615556478500366,
0.47864940762519836,
-0.5431938767433167,
0.39926955103874207,
0.7427003979682922,
0.12524452805519104,
-0.7658812999725342,
-0.3085157871246338,
-0.2847568988800049,
-0.858403742313385,
0.6469921469688416,
0.05621567368507385,
-0.019454041495919228,
0.03412366658449173,
-0.028640344738960266,
0.21234749257564545,
0.32991155982017517,
-0.6494924426078796,
0.026164859533309937,
-0.058756954967975616,
-0.31067782640457153,
-0.18835149705410004,
0.12623964250087738,
0.10035941749811172,
-0.3489629924297333,
0.6618068814277649,
0.00014653362450189888,
0.32350167632102966,
0.22665469348430634,
-0.5792983174324036,
-0.06830845773220062,
0.3992197811603546,
0.6909068822860718,
0.4133974313735962,
0.005496289115399122,
-0.09014298021793365,
0.2001236528158188,
-0.4438479244709015,
-0.05666853114962578,
0.20692749321460724,
-0.1756889373064041,
0.11575552821159363,
0.13321956992149353,
0.7957432866096497,
0.585795521736145,
-0.6309023499488831,
0.3985460698604584,
0.026321204379200935,
0.1882970780134201,
-0.3779178559780121,
-0.26338011026382446,
0.011959859170019627,
-0.031206458806991577,
0.09763205796480179,
0.41199567914009094,
-0.10145551711320877,
-0.5618140697479248,
0.293418824672699,
0.27670812606811523,
-0.5535077452659607,
-0.35855481028556824,
0.9177142977714539,
0.6519465446472168,
-0.7536796927452087,
0.2710227370262146,
0.0021708691492676735,
-0.47549962997436523,
0.20708873867988586,
1.042375922203064,
0.9053637385368347,
-0.543339729309082,
0.12410976737737656,
0.17247514426708221,
0.3860023021697998,
0.04703189805150032,
0.3674870729446411,
-0.1730102002620697,
-0.4375365078449249,
-0.3109683692455292,
-0.6007867455482483,
-0.5134180188179016,
-0.21663758158683777,
-0.866525411605835,
0.6870200634002686,
-0.16313238441944122,
0.1596207171678543,
-0.5339452624320984,
-0.2480391412973404,
-0.46021026372909546,
0.2152133584022522,
0.12864316999912262,
0.8993288278579712,
-1.042262315750122,
1.3241549730300903,
0.7218154668807983,
-0.45169249176979065,
-0.462039977312088,
0.0021773672197014093,
-0.22787176072597504,
-1.1349369287490845,
0.19650106132030487,
-0.03264209255576134,
-0.3497697710990906,
0.2969346046447754,
-0.3558429479598999,
-0.8827166557312012,
0.8462926149368286,
0.301256000995636,
-0.6218534708023071,
0.1815083622932434,
0.5482326149940491,
0.5205017924308777,
-0.4119560420513153,
0.19196073710918427,
0.49639758467674255,
-0.028972558677196503,
0.08498935401439667,
-1.1275670528411865,
-0.500524640083313,
-0.5463075041770935,
0.08040197193622589,
0.4316108822822571,
-0.912635326385498,
0.9422838687896729,
0.08361876010894775,
-0.28350043296813965,
-0.1232338696718216,
0.661974310874939,
0.12837393581867218,
0.2780294120311737,
0.6030727624893188,
0.46424543857574463,
0.3142249882221222,
0.03391152247786522,
0.6173596382141113,
-0.5605506300926208,
-0.04259446635842323,
1.2093185186386108,
-0.5107854008674622,
1.2404115200042725,
0.46758201718330383,
-0.216588094830513,
0.4063500761985779,
0.4370983839035034,
0.5870099663734436,
0.7083908915519714,
0.03702007979154587,
-0.30594587326049805,
-0.05419960990548134,
-0.018353931605815887,
-0.6784720420837402,
0.6586061716079712,
0.5867916941642761,
0.02991061471402645,
-0.28993716835975647,
0.0828472301363945,
0.16104069352149963,
0.4461436867713928,
-0.22235722839832306,
0.6405813694000244,
-0.023970454931259155,
-0.8826606273651123,
0.5236456990242004,
0.019305678084492683,
0.8950712084770203,
-1.0546998977661133,
-0.08664373308420181,
-0.18055066466331482,
0.23939573764801025,
-0.11314617097377777,
-0.6940690279006958,
0.5724921822547913,
0.31013375520706177,
-0.012859753333032131,
-0.8343698382377625,
0.5869351029396057,
-0.9401166439056396,
-0.31058764457702637,
0.3362860083580017,
0.18263712525367737,
0.23626083135604858,
0.30517300963401794,
-0.6239129304885864,
0.36395928263664246,
0.2365376502275467,
0.4521012604236603,
0.3232881426811218,
0.04250844940543175,
-0.3356996476650238,
0.46892186999320984,
0.898003101348877,
0.26673415303230286,
0.40351998805999756,
0.06777051091194153,
0.6221057772636414,
-0.422364205121994,
-1.0190571546554565,
-0.5597599744796753,
0.6567385196685791,
-0.09530619531869888,
-0.699345588684082,
0.6356290578842163,
0.8228326439857483,
0.9874539971351624,
-0.10983487963676453,
0.7893955707550049,
-0.05266329273581505,
0.4985044598579407,
-0.4487628936767578,
0.8568641543388367,
-0.2749860882759094,
0.2501266896724701,
-0.31335920095443726,
-0.7125323414802551,
-0.13195794820785522,
0.5487825870513916,
-0.29042160511016846,
-0.5202854871749878,
0.5444574952125549,
0.7881840467453003,
-0.11627687513828278,
-0.012625270523130894,
0.4036272168159485,
0.10993342846632004,
0.4457625150680542,
0.6081985235214233,
0.5372850298881531,
-0.6997374296188354,
0.8001821637153625,
0.23816734552383423,
-0.4528796970844269,
-0.2243727445602417,
-0.7076945900917053,
-0.38119369745254517,
-1.101306676864624,
-0.21494516730308533,
-0.38307300209999084,
0.24495315551757812,
0.7783762812614441,
0.47729137539863586,
-0.759850025177002,
-0.665676474571228,
-0.024257300421595573,
-0.051687899976968765,
-0.17344534397125244,
-0.10991223901510239,
0.06785546243190765,
-0.37611323595046997,
-0.9600851535797119,
0.5689318180084229,
0.541157066822052,
-0.34320366382598877,
-0.13714534044265747,
-0.17407318949699402,
-0.6206493973731995,
0.3614118993282318,
0.5613009333610535,
0.497269868850708,
-0.474535197019577,
-0.0823531299829483,
-0.13409756124019623,
-0.3246729075908661,
0.11245882511138916,
0.8966118693351746,
-0.6398736834526062,
0.5476455092430115,
0.6349235773086548,
0.9557515382766724,
0.5435012578964233,
-0.0984763503074646,
0.7693597078323364,
-0.7067850232124329,
0.39190036058425903,
0.1268281638622284,
0.30013394355773926,
0.2904509902000427,
-0.03497672453522682,
0.41454970836639404,
0.09236778318881989,
-0.5915359854698181,
-0.9486664533615112,
0.3562370240688324,
-1.1560492515563965,
0.1494903713464737,
1.1826186180114746,
0.08123387396335602,
-0.1490183174610138,
-0.2593819499015808,
-0.43003785610198975,
0.5457852482795715,
-0.27981463074684143,
0.5664269924163818,
0.3687755763530731,
-0.09449174255132675,
0.0594814196228981,
-0.4192708432674408,
0.42702338099479675,
0.6591489315032959,
-0.9528367519378662,
-0.006432546768337488,
0.2404574453830719,
0.0744682028889656,
0.029741650447249413,
0.9480135440826416,
-0.3893446922302246,
0.14402395486831665,
-0.11825000494718552,
0.19875596463680267,
0.1065436527132988,
-0.2950197458267212,
-0.5913095474243164,
-0.34367844462394714,
-0.33618950843811035,
-0.8257128000259399
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10991v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10991v1 | Adaptive Query Rewriting: Aligning Rewriters through Marginal Probability of Conversational Answers | 2024-06-16T16:09:05 | 2024-06-16T16:09:05 | Tianhua Zhang, Kun Li, Hongyin Luo, Xixin Wu, James Glass, Helen Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Query rewriting is a crucial technique for passage retrieval in open-domain
conversational question answering (CQA). It decontexualizes conversational
queries into self-contained questions suitable for off-the-shelf retrievers.
Existing methods attempt to incorporate retriever's preference during the
training of rewriting models. However, these approaches typically rely on
extensive annotations such as in-domain rewrites and/or relevant passage
labels, limiting the models' generalization and adaptation capabilities. In
this paper, we introduce AdaQR ($\textbf{Ada}$ptive $\textbf{Q}$uery
$\textbf{R}$ewriting), a framework for training query rewriting models with
limited rewrite annotations from seed datasets and completely no passage label.
Our approach begins by fine-tuning compact large language models using only
~$10\%$ of rewrite annotations from the seed dataset training split. The models
are then utilized to generate rewrite candidates for each query instance. A
novel approach is then proposed to assess retriever's preference for these
candidates by the probability of answers conditioned on the conversational
query by marginalizing the Top-$K$ passages. This serves as the reward for
optimizing the rewriter further using Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), a
process free of rewrite and retrieval annotations. Experimental results on four
open-domain CQA datasets demonstrate that AdaQR not only enhances the in-domain
capabilities of the rewriter with limited annotation requirement, but also
adapts effectively to out-of-domain datasets. | [
-0.04589904844760895,
-0.9910897016525269,
0.4111124873161316,
-0.1682383418083191,
-0.23136912286281586,
-0.04706062376499176,
-0.016127463430166245,
0.0012025280157104135,
0.1875,
0.8518298268318176,
-0.6178565621376038,
-0.4077301323413849,
-0.06167494133114815,
0.03806515038013458,
-0.07003914564847946,
0.9399645328521729,
-0.07311508804559708,
-0.0432850643992424,
-0.5030108690261841,
-0.3048931658267975,
-0.4414711594581604,
-0.6801499128341675,
-0.8940021395683289,
0.1003335639834404,
0.6306286454200745,
0.39215853810310364,
0.7636398673057556,
0.7767555117607117,
0.4256136417388916,
0.2216031849384308,
-0.015222222544252872,
0.09677088260650635,
-0.49019187688827515,
0.5346062779426575,
-0.13259820640087128,
-0.7621861100196838,
-0.4087187647819519,
-0.3280763030052185,
0.8198055028915405,
0.8483982682228088,
-0.6608988046646118,
0.018893660977482796,
-0.04305822774767876,
0.9228877425193787,
-0.6929289102554321,
-0.2521688640117645,
-1.209751009941101,
-0.06880006939172745,
0.11376097798347473,
-0.49622592329978943,
-0.5038275122642517,
-0.7317082285881042,
0.19348835945129395,
-0.8541519641876221,
0.6249410510063171,
0.4972243905067444,
0.5452100038528442,
0.429835706949234,
-0.7106480002403259,
-0.3108709454536438,
-0.4970580041408539,
0.7729905247688293,
-0.46199461817741394,
0.46593406796455383,
0.2579221725463867,
0.563448429107666,
-0.44231852889060974,
-0.6061152815818787,
-0.5046895146369934,
0.019075684249401093,
0.12657597661018372,
0.08577361702919006,
-0.23939818143844604,
0.07510624825954437,
-0.09616455435752869,
0.48869457840919495,
-0.36675670742988586,
-0.10960976034402847,
-0.38178324699401855,
-0.2106124758720398,
0.6671843528747559,
0.3821816146373749,
0.10808080434799194,
0.1728721410036087,
-0.27434539794921875,
-0.1133456602692604,
-0.7814306020736694,
0.1649494171142578,
0.25862959027290344,
0.2854721248149872,
0.5542486310005188,
0.4203285574913025,
-0.3709897994995117,
0.7440171241760254,
0.5080509781837463,
0.14890871942043304,
0.0035211024805903435,
-0.3246304392814636,
-0.33699604868888855,
0.06356597691774368,
0.5395263433456421,
0.3314901292324066,
0.06975043565034866,
-0.062035344541072845,
-0.013170499354600906,
-0.5135111808776855,
0.4198593199253082,
-0.7617000341415405,
-0.29547956585884094,
0.2591610848903656,
-0.36214205622673035,
-0.19068197906017303,
-0.4766075611114502,
-0.5284320712089539,
-0.26410481333732605,
-0.17026522755622864,
0.4086015522480011,
-0.4820116460323334,
-0.016980528831481934,
0.2015353888273239,
-0.03310132771730423,
0.45538368821144104,
0.36036232113838196,
-0.8485947847366333,
0.3813377022743225,
0.7268865704536438,
0.458359956741333,
-0.11899619549512863,
-0.08060382306575775,
-0.6718880534172058,
0.15350256860256195,
-0.31628039479255676,
0.7875627279281616,
-0.7469711899757385,
-0.4304145276546478,
0.16228222846984863,
0.220495343208313,
-0.5485233664512634,
-0.5394310355186462,
0.9207565784454346,
-1.171492576599121,
0.08556073158979416,
-0.21118928492069244,
-0.6615588665008545,
-0.1782263070344925,
0.10091768205165863,
-0.6605041027069092,
0.6444061398506165,
-0.14078831672668457,
-0.5874508023262024,
0.4261928200721741,
-0.3347397744655609,
-0.3946986794471741,
-0.2783229351043701,
0.046389468014240265,
-0.6462401151657104,
0.27600929141044617,
0.45080649852752686,
-0.19265778362751007,
-0.0969376340508461,
0.19326020777225494,
-0.12293662875890732,
-0.2564992308616638,
0.5707903504371643,
-0.48954927921295166,
0.6351674795150757,
0.10742714256048203,
0.028619812801480293,
0.23385757207870483,
-0.6116713285446167,
0.22838611900806427,
-0.05035687983036041,
-0.5204349160194397,
-0.4145927131175995,
0.18078474700450897,
-0.3003169596195221,
-0.11404528468847275,
0.022185426205396652,
-0.6431305408477783,
0.3020651340484619,
-0.6596222519874573,
0.3094926178455353,
0.7695900797843933,
0.4531373083591461,
0.6249056458473206,
-0.48483672738075256,
0.7927242517471313,
-0.10883636772632599,
0.12130600214004517,
-0.07728826254606247,
-0.31188976764678955,
-1.011418342590332,
-0.10490109026432037,
0.4159107208251953,
0.3997989594936371,
-0.7655041217803955,
-0.01853039860725403,
-0.32179298996925354,
-0.3409162759780884,
-1.0337947607040405,
0.056469354778528214,
0.6258337497711182,
0.5690762996673584,
0.4219616651535034,
-0.1645413637161255,
-0.2958356440067291,
-0.9699609279632568,
-0.541534423828125,
-0.1110224649310112,
0.14425817131996155,
0.5573417544364929,
0.10789410769939423,
0.37906304001808167,
0.733420193195343,
-0.8296807408332825,
-0.3227306604385376,
0.07422243058681488,
-0.22779734432697296,
0.20906713604927063,
0.42649605870246887,
0.17251557111740112,
-0.9762857556343079,
-0.6092262268066406,
-0.2410251349210739,
-0.4138663411140442,
-0.044607020914554596,
-0.14971141517162323,
-0.5665572285652161,
0.23969623446464539,
0.573323130607605,
-0.30304646492004395,
0.39886465668678284,
0.021533789113163948,
-0.21403326094150543,
0.3424801528453827,
-0.3224610686302185,
0.24403929710388184,
-0.8904587626457214,
-0.15311472117900848,
-0.31028205156326294,
-0.029809754341840744,
-0.5038831233978271,
0.1707078516483307,
-0.004871173296123743,
0.0005660004098899662,
-0.39822471141815186,
0.4885772466659546,
-0.6573169231414795,
0.19702717661857605,
-0.33879122138023376,
0.08292271941900253,
0.2060915231704712,
0.5732133388519287,
0.1405647248029709,
0.762652575969696,
0.41271480917930603,
-0.7425061464309692,
0.18063805997371674,
0.7193453311920166,
0.006205290090292692,
0.6220188736915588,
-0.7386705875396729,
0.5691120028495789,
-0.25528907775878906,
0.42537590861320496,
-1.1204243898391724,
-0.09576814621686935,
0.28027915954589844,
-0.5579351186752319,
0.13318327069282532,
-0.6213234663009644,
0.03164055943489075,
0.036552559584379196,
-0.35157161951065063,
0.5578307509422302,
0.2516748011112213,
-0.45994046330451965,
0.7090016007423401,
0.1805579662322998,
-0.29776355624198914,
-0.6792166829109192,
-0.3425115942955017,
-0.06635197252035141,
-0.2503527104854584,
-0.5915330052375793,
0.47286632657051086,
-0.08281829208135605,
0.023432008922100067,
-0.1112629696726799,
-0.2505415081977844,
-0.16239744424819946,
-0.04981552064418793,
0.1926567703485489,
0.10328435897827148,
-0.4074091613292694,
0.11326627433300018,
0.442763090133667,
0.06953733414411545,
0.13464008271694183,
-0.35623201727867126,
0.16636785864830017,
0.14033593237400055,
-0.48946139216423035,
-0.3603231608867645,
0.5360325574874878,
0.2339162677526474,
-0.37880685925483704,
0.8548982739448547,
0.14265578985214233,
-0.051603980362415314,
-0.12844690680503845,
-0.4951975643634796,
-0.0792989656329155,
-0.4793432354927063,
0.23641006648540497,
-0.78586745262146,
-0.9382145404815674,
0.36607760190963745,
0.3619532287120819,
0.25927823781967163,
0.38179340958595276,
0.5504854321479797,
0.14907489717006683,
0.9048811197280884,
0.5908330082893372,
0.20577092468738556,
0.5432157516479492,
0.11772838979959488,
0.09916602820158005,
-1.0982211828231812,
-0.1752108335494995,
-0.49985799193382263,
-0.15610329806804657,
-0.7123417854309082,
-0.4190787076950073,
0.37803077697753906,
-0.019890552386641502,
-0.2943437397480011,
-0.030074475333094597,
-0.5924307107925415,
0.500357449054718,
0.8329862356185913,
0.21991156041622162,
0.46022167801856995,
0.1558472067117691,
-0.11923260986804962,
-0.0788043886423111,
-0.6314482092857361,
-0.4093327522277832,
1.501408576965332,
0.012412558309733868,
0.8137778639793396,
0.41953620314598083,
0.6533234119415283,
0.19178074598312378,
0.2146356701850891,
-0.7403852939605713,
0.4083883762359619,
0.06759170442819595,
-0.7719861268997192,
-0.5032714605331421,
-0.36181363463401794,
-1.1671310663223267,
0.5518490076065063,
-0.10463281720876694,
-0.41669198870658875,
0.5499528646469116,
0.3292253911495209,
-0.5613516569137573,
0.010498704388737679,
-0.6918556094169617,
0.7778100371360779,
-0.09821779280900955,
-0.47885242104530334,
-0.10634079575538635,
-0.615269124507904,
0.09604436159133911,
-0.021464835852384567,
-0.11712159961462021,
0.019662098959088326,
-0.18255753815174103,
0.6827457547187805,
-0.29078158736228943,
0.6892789006233215,
-0.3986254036426544,
-0.05203627049922943,
0.4915846586227417,
0.3473894000053406,
0.41337472200393677,
0.05600319057703018,
-0.4679839015007019,
-0.5189850330352783,
0.27907559275627136,
-0.501151978969574,
-0.6410638689994812,
0.5085235238075256,
-0.524418294429779,
-1.0732088088989258,
-0.4479943811893463,
-0.33536699414253235,
-0.38614168763160706,
0.16184474527835846,
-0.03610454872250557,
0.35219699144363403,
-0.5320517420768738,
0.23712828755378723,
0.6497292518615723,
-0.29964739084243774,
0.033428408205509186,
0.7630149126052856,
-0.024969585239887238,
-0.5098963379859924,
0.6839829087257385,
-0.24144530296325684,
0.4396474361419678,
0.5988409519195557,
0.0227544866502285,
-0.5715969204902649,
-0.8796706199645996,
-0.5805205702781677,
0.058608949184417725,
-0.8155857920646667,
-0.2765132188796997,
-0.8580143451690674,
-0.11684492230415344,
-0.4840517044067383,
-0.05811140313744545,
0.14918702840805054,
-0.6018484830856323,
-0.038985129445791245,
0.07709993422031403,
0.3973883390426636,
0.07036112248897552,
0.24633312225341797,
0.34848466515541077,
-0.5181077718734741,
0.26789966225624084,
0.3791099190711975,
0.1584581732749939,
0.06109070032835007,
-0.9096137881278992,
-0.05722151696681976,
0.17440423369407654,
-0.5512173771858215,
-0.5806915163993835,
0.372592031955719,
0.7195475697517395,
0.5294951796531677,
0.018189940601587296,
0.5546940565109253,
0.6289834976196289,
-0.7057884335517883,
0.4354763627052307,
-0.2694037854671478,
-0.48724058270454407,
0.6728696227073669,
-0.339032381772995,
-0.13353769481182098,
0.9519219398498535,
0.3383153975009918,
-0.41935330629348755,
-0.24460993707180023,
-0.47214195132255554,
-0.9564856290817261,
0.5691356062889099,
0.13969457149505615,
0.27708014845848083,
-0.09927763044834137,
0.6304484009742737,
0.126380056142807,
0.18784956634044647,
-0.2678653299808502,
-0.0689108595252037,
-0.14577847719192505,
-0.2193937599658966,
0.0917493999004364,
-0.3417893350124359,
-0.1517774611711502,
-0.010146601125597954,
0.7547491192817688,
-0.24257594347000122,
0.1422450691461563,
0.3657357096672058,
-0.13015392422676086,
-0.07535870373249054,
0.5398911237716675,
0.08199138194322586,
0.4891590178012848,
-0.5056447386741638,
-0.16165512800216675,
0.01833813451230526,
-0.4360162615776062,
0.3014833331108093,
0.1551845669746399,
-0.3189941346645355,
-0.24204756319522858,
0.02915511280298233,
0.5043727159500122,
0.023680487647652626,
-0.4829097390174866,
0.4392423629760742,
-0.3699170649051666,
-0.1787116527557373,
-0.2791905999183655,
0.32784655690193176,
0.04270798712968826,
0.06420771032571793,
0.3904016315937042,
-0.3409614861011505,
0.3797507882118225,
-0.48944002389907837,
0.27620044350624084,
0.4855274260044098,
-0.5118457674980164,
-0.20883327722549438,
0.9130721092224121,
0.27642911672592163,
-0.27317309379577637,
0.6713677644729614,
0.04750122129917145,
-0.2632060647010803,
0.32911109924316406,
0.7461997270584106,
0.8389754295349121,
-0.27038145065307617,
0.004739521536976099,
0.39159637689590454,
0.03324497118592262,
0.24976879358291626,
0.1640784591436386,
-0.062421057373285294,
-0.7035603523254395,
-0.17275768518447876,
-0.8107177019119263,
-0.6681008338928223,
-0.2900002896785736,
-0.857397198677063,
-0.05849010869860649,
-0.20652109384536743,
0.07021510601043701,
0.4028225839138031,
0.00539191672578454,
-0.38956573605537415,
0.3059752583503723,
-0.4816320836544037,
0.780890941619873,
-0.5616441965103149,
0.6548413038253784,
0.8087127208709717,
-0.5592975616455078,
-0.5196807384490967,
0.20782232284545898,
-0.052705805748701096,
-0.9484679698944092,
0.3176238238811493,
-0.32490167021751404,
-0.15015341341495514,
0.18885537981987,
-0.28779417276382446,
-0.8396522402763367,
1.0080692768096924,
0.3666912019252777,
-0.3551649749279022,
-0.058083392679691315,
0.059323906898498535,
0.5448136925697327,
-0.5279020071029663,
0.13376475870609283,
0.47847801446914673,
-0.028313731774687767,
0.3395722210407257,
-0.7212182879447937,
0.3320724666118622,
-0.15484796464443207,
-0.02765064872801304,
0.2120114266872406,
-0.7148551344871521,
0.523626983165741,
-0.21931487321853638,
-0.20221343636512756,
0.30206066370010376,
0.6563299298286438,
0.21727588772773743,
0.37305402755737305,
0.46151936054229736,
0.26729199290275574,
0.6833146214485168,
0.06342114508152008,
0.9225931167602539,
-0.04858561232686043,
0.019441338256001472,
1.3232558965682983,
-0.32713228464126587,
1.0407196283340454,
0.4775979816913605,
-0.2098921686410904,
0.4977450668811798,
0.5208116173744202,
0.34772616624832153,
0.6268616318702698,
0.5068277716636658,
-0.36572930216789246,
-0.3545694947242737,
-0.17347916960716248,
-0.2104438841342926,
0.45181789994239807,
0.10320381075143814,
-0.3137863874435425,
0.06048398092389107,
-0.2719418406486511,
0.024492153897881508,
0.31956568360328674,
-0.1807921677827835,
1.0366326570510864,
0.06179884448647499,
-1.0291885137557983,
0.9598753452301025,
-0.059442393481731415,
0.31352823972702026,
-0.16178904473781586,
0.0023973581846803427,
-0.4994371831417084,
0.4347406029701233,
-0.07672905176877975,
-0.7019720077514648,
0.3329145014286041,
-0.16907085478305817,
-0.2649243474006653,
0.016529647633433342,
0.6055553555488586,
-0.3943544626235962,
-0.5111967325210571,
-0.23262085020542145,
0.5003435611724854,
0.07618633657693863,
-0.3808723986148834,
-0.6469810605049133,
-0.3320554196834564,
0.2929114103317261,
-0.18501313030719757,
0.4660719931125641,
0.7054886221885681,
-0.22773116827011108,
0.7723671197891235,
0.6913732290267944,
-0.22041599452495575,
0.04161280393600464,
0.15650956332683563,
0.9986962676048279,
-0.805410623550415,
-0.45102232694625854,
-0.5381640195846558,
0.22134645283222198,
0.029749400913715363,
-0.17184853553771973,
0.8010648488998413,
0.8689658045768738,
0.5541121363639832,
0.1395263522863388,
0.6748412847518921,
0.22032378613948822,
0.7240150570869446,
-0.5618469715118408,
0.4654616117477417,
-0.5325211882591248,
0.24303938448429108,
-0.09397898614406586,
-0.8583117723464966,
-0.13713638484477997,
0.25425752997398376,
-0.48778918385505676,
-0.13620245456695557,
0.36757567524909973,
1.0387005805969238,
0.027805734425783157,
-0.0757107213139534,
0.12444185465574265,
-0.07926396280527115,
0.3305763900279999,
0.893613338470459,
0.908211886882782,
-0.494320273399353,
0.943467378616333,
0.1674809753894806,
-0.24197377264499664,
-0.33559277653694153,
-0.6097187995910645,
-0.7531904578208923,
-0.47332528233528137,
-0.46638649702072144,
-0.4853493273258209,
0.3747304379940033,
0.5460215210914612,
0.2607140839099884,
-0.7554392218589783,
-0.0020852272864431143,
0.1369369477033615,
0.2603449821472168,
-0.21866390109062195,
-0.20443247258663177,
0.7216522097587585,
-0.3061414659023285,
-0.6062943935394287,
0.34665927290916443,
-0.05314657837152481,
-0.14143002033233643,
0.2606922388076782,
0.11646448075771332,
-0.2509394586086273,
0.2899061143398285,
0.20753441751003265,
0.3478527069091797,
-0.6046037673950195,
-0.191327765583992,
0.39492830634117126,
0.18712158501148224,
0.31061816215515137,
0.7324262857437134,
-0.6976690888404846,
0.5695971250534058,
0.1953454464673996,
0.7550864815711975,
0.49648186564445496,
0.4297946095466614,
0.7157301902770996,
-0.703106701374054,
-0.2177387923002243,
0.31287187337875366,
0.03390040993690491,
0.3846263885498047,
-0.37614357471466064,
0.3554341495037079,
-0.058140918612480164,
-0.7652595639228821,
-0.7745909094810486,
0.2677995562553406,
-0.9001242518424988,
-0.06165703013539314,
1.1833428144454956,
-0.1577850580215454,
-0.41505709290504456,
-0.2452417016029358,
-0.43090879917144775,
0.15620100498199463,
-0.46531787514686584,
0.6704325079917908,
0.2926045358181,
-0.25871720910072327,
-0.03383859246969223,
-0.3726660907268524,
0.5160024762153625,
0.46268606185913086,
-0.37417930364608765,
0.5132873058319092,
0.651665210723877,
0.5916829109191895,
-0.22835427522659302,
1.1027761697769165,
-0.04484938457608223,
0.3398439288139343,
0.06942977756261826,
-0.198650062084198,
0.02142811380326748,
0.1307099312543869,
-0.4100038409233093,
0.10447239875793457,
0.3826461732387543,
-0.5317465662956238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15474v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15474v1 | WundtGPT: Shaping Large Language Models To Be An Empathetic, Proactive Psychologist | 2024-06-16T16:06:38 | 2024-06-16T16:06:38 | Chenyu Ren, Yazhou Zhang, Daihai He, Jing Qin | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | Large language models (LLMs) are raging over the medical domain, and their
momentum has carried over into the mental health domain, leading to the
emergence of few mental health LLMs. Although such mental health LLMs could
provide reasonable suggestions for psychological counseling, how to develop an
authentic and effective doctor-patient relationship (DPR) through LLMs is still
an important problem. To fill this gap, we dissect DPR into two key attributes,
i.e., the psychologist's empathy and proactive guidance. We thus present
WundtGPT, an empathetic and proactive mental health large language model that
is acquired by fine-tuning it with instruction and real conversation between
psychologists and patients. It is designed to assist psychologists in diagnosis
and help patients who are reluctant to communicate face-to-face understand
their psychological conditions. Its uniqueness lies in that it could not only
pose purposeful questions to guide patients in detailing their symptoms but
also offer warm emotional reassurance. In particular, WundtGPT incorporates
Collection of Questions, Chain of Psychodiagnosis, and Empathy Constraints into
a comprehensive prompt for eliciting LLMs' questions and diagnoses.
Additionally, WundtGPT proposes a reward model to promote alignment with
empathetic mental health professionals, which encompasses two key factors:
cognitive empathy and emotional empathy. We offer a comprehensive evaluation of
our proposed model. Based on these outcomes, we further conduct the manual
evaluation based on proactivity, effectiveness, professionalism and coherence.
We notice that WundtGPT can offer professional and effective consultation. The
model is available at huggingface. | [
-0.4962884783744812,
-0.7555294036865234,
1.028295636177063,
0.31041285395622253,
-0.2860237956047058,
-0.13516837358474731,
-0.5478987097740173,
-0.36292311549186707,
0.18387573957443237,
0.3229129910469055,
-0.6377246975898743,
-0.13868539035320282,
-0.7978482842445374,
-0.1546562761068344,
-0.038537830114364624,
0.8402402997016907,
0.005416395142674446,
0.2790873348712921,
0.18448911607265472,
0.013393751345574856,
-0.1247013509273529,
-0.434187114238739,
-0.9766485691070557,
-0.6912885904312134,
0.7013843655586243,
0.1921844631433487,
0.929671049118042,
0.299769788980484,
0.5074371695518494,
0.21759356558322906,
-0.19291114807128906,
-0.11171294003725052,
-0.32341745495796204,
0.11915183812379837,
-0.28844138979911804,
0.08258116990327835,
-0.7421547174453735,
0.08563104271888733,
0.3291507661342621,
0.8697417974472046,
-0.7919082641601562,
0.02552950568497181,
0.17338183522224426,
0.4469054937362671,
-0.040073223412036896,
0.142874613404274,
-0.037634119391441345,
0.123575858771801,
0.04799584299325943,
0.15207529067993164,
-0.24915313720703125,
-0.29503026604652405,
0.03905996307730675,
-0.40278759598731995,
-0.1314685344696045,
-0.19763346016407013,
0.5041751265525818,
0.11057785153388977,
-0.6970428824424744,
-0.04866141453385353,
-0.6600375175476074,
0.4255939722061157,
-0.6465988159179688,
0.4059632420539856,
0.4622642397880554,
0.2040511667728424,
-0.3025955855846405,
-0.8994355797767639,
-0.5980433821678162,
-0.3657536208629608,
-0.021084792912006378,
0.17256975173950195,
-0.44608137011528015,
0.2301620990037918,
0.2697294056415558,
0.35591480135917664,
-0.3761835992336273,
0.2301570475101471,
0.047781895846128464,
0.023020988330245018,
0.5685098767280579,
0.4080740809440613,
0.18951869010925293,
0.06117653846740723,
-0.08962246775627136,
0.16970296204090118,
-0.4034231901168823,
-0.07286012917757034,
0.0002751946449279785,
0.008666950277984142,
-0.18507623672485352,
0.45998620986938477,
0.2182408720254898,
0.6004227995872498,
0.4065060615539551,
-0.24913644790649414,
-0.4305882751941681,
0.33035871386528015,
-0.054361261427402496,
0.027093244716525078,
0.8223615288734436,
0.5562993884086609,
0.6079925894737244,
-0.22091397643089294,
0.05370607227087021,
0.15056747198104858,
0.673827052116394,
-1.0625178813934326,
-0.5597636699676514,
0.43852779269218445,
-0.6002301573753357,
-0.32781732082366943,
-0.17218533158302307,
-0.6410443782806396,
-0.6246109008789062,
-0.6270187497138977,
0.1125251054763794,
-0.5042845010757446,
-0.831295371055603,
0.031322963535785675,
0.20931757986545563,
0.10549226403236389,
0.22391076385974884,
-0.9934706091880798,
0.428856760263443,
0.6750382781028748,
0.5967873334884644,
0.2050381749868393,
-0.2709626853466034,
-0.5861036777496338,
0.2311089187860489,
-0.3047431707382202,
0.5856006741523743,
-0.7265259027481079,
-0.40457677841186523,
-0.0807059109210968,
-0.022232241928577423,
0.2728106677532196,
-0.09320047497749329,
0.4797845184803009,
-0.07919742166996002,
0.21591366827487946,
-0.6372458934783936,
-0.6477212905883789,
0.11071603000164032,
0.5306209921836853,
-0.2486189901828766,
0.6841935515403748,
0.7352253198623657,
-0.7846022248268127,
0.15390118956565857,
-0.8392783999443054,
-0.2762485444545746,
0.32172855734825134,
-0.06705177575349808,
0.09839048981666565,
0.4051916003227234,
0.0952601507306099,
0.5587322115898132,
-0.4324740171432495,
0.37110137939453125,
-0.3653945028781891,
-0.17199644446372986,
0.19929195940494537,
-0.016441889107227325,
0.6484975814819336,
-0.03726550191640854,
-0.12941597402095795,
0.19666963815689087,
-0.5833603739738464,
0.21603165566921234,
0.25254714488983154,
-0.20265120267868042,
-0.31733620166778564,
-0.26098668575286865,
0.45943164825439453,
0.35728415846824646,
-0.11035288125276566,
-0.5345903635025024,
0.2947358191013336,
-0.22146645188331604,
0.46758201718330383,
0.8348886966705322,
0.17300842702388763,
0.2332625836133957,
-0.16844765841960907,
0.7412819266319275,
-0.17523367702960968,
0.4508989453315735,
0.14262181520462036,
-0.5791404247283936,
-0.12529897689819336,
-0.6325643062591553,
-0.004789038095623255,
0.3822246789932251,
-0.24221953749656677,
0.5137487649917603,
-0.007671883329749107,
-0.8989580273628235,
-0.5346923470497131,
0.04592921584844589,
0.2395922988653183,
0.762422502040863,
0.24571871757507324,
-0.5554900765419006,
-0.2611776888370514,
-0.6938449740409851,
-0.4050982594490051,
0.07432122528553009,
0.07064788043498993,
0.1770492047071457,
0.06956691294908524,
-0.5774927735328674,
0.5430837869644165,
-0.470725417137146,
-0.33921316266059875,
-0.42815858125686646,
-0.013416591100394726,
0.15004712343215942,
0.23548294603824615,
0.31617793440818787,
-0.6064147353172302,
-0.8018140196800232,
-0.0521942600607872,
-0.7205492854118347,
-0.042705241590738297,
0.21372723579406738,
-0.09985291212797165,
-0.31893184781074524,
0.2644256055355072,
-0.8595725893974304,
0.15469945967197418,
0.6768913865089417,
-0.834699809551239,
0.4975126087665558,
-0.4130687713623047,
0.024954942986369133,
-1.1483126878738403,
0.04163828119635582,
0.18983756005764008,
-0.18848900496959686,
-0.7207410931587219,
0.056642912328243256,
-0.035219088196754456,
-0.11984937638044357,
-0.21533098816871643,
0.6204183101654053,
-0.3767625689506531,
0.41392266750335693,
-0.22259178757667542,
0.0984063670039177,
-0.35547468066215515,
0.24932314455509186,
0.13137102127075195,
0.2829904854297638,
0.705301821231842,
-0.3693305253982544,
0.71450275182724,
0.39237359166145325,
-0.02534145675599575,
1.349211573600769,
-0.5900140404701233,
0.25406089425086975,
0.09325828403234482,
0.259194016456604,
-0.431627482175827,
-0.443787544965744,
0.12344849854707718,
-0.15471729636192322,
0.5286371111869812,
-0.19390374422073364,
-0.5955139398574829,
-0.37101489305496216,
0.14571839570999146,
0.24939435720443726,
0.8445588946342468,
-0.457253098487854,
0.5820971131324768,
0.2749187648296356,
-0.5223119854927063,
-0.11665675044059753,
-0.3424256145954132,
0.4022639989852905,
-0.18313202261924744,
-0.5015624165534973,
0.22377370297908783,
-0.043173108249902725,
-0.5382667183876038,
-0.01341027021408081,
0.22299489378929138,
-0.09110567718744278,
-0.018484976142644882,
0.22315987944602966,
0.00788671150803566,
0.03827878460288048,
0.22925478219985962,
0.06314759701490402,
-0.4683435559272766,
0.2556406855583191,
-0.05862300470471382,
0.7090354561805725,
-0.39169740676879883,
-0.4078965187072754,
-0.49325820803642273,
0.5881174206733704,
0.6085431575775146,
-0.24923042953014374,
0.8640455007553101,
1.0545529127120972,
-0.4489203691482544,
0.08653371781110764,
-0.506259024143219,
-0.6919848918914795,
-0.42834585905075073,
0.3892817795276642,
-0.32447123527526855,
-0.796291708946228,
0.26473626494407654,
-0.2661058306694031,
-0.26270821690559387,
-0.016040612012147903,
0.8079240918159485,
-0.28943049907684326,
1.2031655311584473,
0.7792494297027588,
0.08441624045372009,
0.21649378538131714,
0.0637928694486618,
0.5468828082084656,
-1.0131434202194214,
-0.09201624989509583,
0.15733376145362854,
-0.18908478319644928,
-0.6484116911888123,
0.06318985670804977,
0.4248104989528656,
0.03331782668828964,
-0.6429851651191711,
0.033216286450624466,
-0.7460136413574219,
0.10438849776983261,
0.32289645075798035,
0.43765366077423096,
0.052181098610162735,
-0.2320404052734375,
-0.09539050608873367,
-0.6807050108909607,
-0.377527117729187,
-0.6125317215919495,
0.8431780338287354,
0.525701642036438,
0.838606595993042,
0.46030551195144653,
0.7030842304229736,
0.2638363540172577,
0.6504262685775757,
-0.8812418580055237,
0.420392781496048,
0.2422177940607071,
-0.2830883264541626,
-0.14693033695220947,
-0.31976425647735596,
-0.9091672897338867,
0.16470731794834137,
0.09839803725481033,
-1.0888997316360474,
-0.019587993621826172,
0.3735784590244293,
-0.09559888392686844,
0.31159448623657227,
-0.6939059495925903,
0.9589586853981018,
-0.39806386828422546,
-0.4712950885295868,
-0.2817293703556061,
-0.6444886922836304,
0.38506290316581726,
-0.16278387606143951,
-0.01684250868856907,
-0.09553133696317673,
0.010044548660516739,
0.5400876402854919,
-0.24574559926986694,
0.8630607724189758,
-0.49239206314086914,
-0.349575012922287,
-0.2643294930458069,
0.5479177832603455,
0.570188581943512,
0.12413472682237625,
0.006178994197398424,
-0.23304429650306702,
0.30844852328300476,
-0.44674670696258545,
-0.651624858379364,
0.5563365817070007,
-0.5253615379333496,
-0.6842908263206482,
-0.37087032198905945,
-0.6465129256248474,
-0.7644157409667969,
0.3988419771194458,
0.014345095492899418,
0.4179750680923462,
-0.6269295811653137,
-0.21497100591659546,
0.567949652671814,
-0.08298756927251816,
0.026798980310559273,
0.7224473357200623,
-0.36727026104927063,
-0.05614000931382179,
0.4753488302230835,
-0.25596892833709717,
0.20677031576633453,
-0.09396328777074814,
0.6412649750709534,
-0.3474273681640625,
-0.024026870727539062,
-0.047501709312200546,
0.6691256165504456,
-0.6686240434646606,
0.052848611027002335,
-0.5699521899223328,
-0.08074426651000977,
-0.40945807099342346,
-0.3783155381679535,
-0.40816566348075867,
-0.036042626947164536,
0.009364084340631962,
-0.18213233351707458,
0.7516505718231201,
0.9218469262123108,
-0.3845186233520508,
0.3396945297718048,
-0.8446224331855774,
0.17232385277748108,
0.30998051166534424,
0.44795024394989014,
0.2745004892349243,
-0.5617676377296448,
-0.11781246215105057,
-0.07200393080711365,
-0.4851301312446594,
-1.0151535272598267,
0.5018662810325623,
-0.03109857253730297,
0.3922215700149536,
0.8502991199493408,
0.06657400727272034,
0.3567318022251129,
-0.5037243962287903,
0.4951338768005371,
0.5423861145973206,
-0.9189196228981018,
0.44997328519821167,
-0.6410899758338928,
0.0932108461856842,
0.1531698852777481,
0.45694538950920105,
-0.9768868088722229,
-0.2690921127796173,
-0.8666010499000549,
-0.4569096863269806,
0.4422154724597931,
-0.1648755818605423,
0.34039780497550964,
-0.07688767462968826,
0.38267195224761963,
-0.16509471833705902,
0.0008094785152934492,
-0.5792974233627319,
0.05289016664028168,
-0.08247240632772446,
-0.5430597066879272,
-0.1779412031173706,
-0.4603024423122406,
-0.7793731689453125,
-0.44756871461868286,
0.22857967019081116,
-0.12685023248195648,
0.6098785400390625,
0.32442930340766907,
0.2466803938150406,
-0.31999456882476807,
0.49084270000457764,
0.28458258509635925,
0.6691995859146118,
-0.14681781828403473,
0.18170173466205597,
-0.10584252327680588,
-0.5782455801963806,
0.27218732237815857,
0.3160191476345062,
0.569342851638794,
-0.3181051015853882,
0.3460805118083954,
0.38613712787628174,
0.030281443148851395,
-0.5308941006660461,
0.6488962769508362,
0.011785363778471947,
-0.12625345587730408,
-0.18339070677757263,
-0.07596534490585327,
0.565773069858551,
0.5124099254608154,
-0.0029666477348655462,
-0.3888634741306305,
-0.1313493549823761,
-0.6493024826049805,
0.1440935581922531,
0.31080836057662964,
-0.6169414520263672,
-0.5018754601478577,
0.5192067623138428,
0.05963418632745743,
-0.7691959738731384,
0.9321983456611633,
-0.25945374369621277,
-0.7771255373954773,
0.233696848154068,
0.755890429019928,
0.7011101245880127,
-0.4366086721420288,
0.31432515382766724,
0.044074758887290955,
0.24683313071727753,
-0.2984866797924042,
0.42741870880126953,
-0.058135736733675,
-0.6494918465614319,
-0.14572584629058838,
-0.268764853477478,
-0.7051234841346741,
-0.06265805661678314,
-1.1060364246368408,
-0.14844833314418793,
-0.498533695936203,
-0.4551573097705841,
-0.30790072679519653,
0.0566522590816021,
-0.8474188446998596,
0.2397329956293106,
-0.09894260764122009,
0.8925237655639648,
-0.7708424925804138,
0.9661611914634705,
0.8482785820960999,
-0.42708492279052734,
-1.0360479354858398,
0.12336265295743942,
0.004433378577232361,
-0.8971405029296875,
0.4069781005382538,
-0.02134602703154087,
0.17020514607429504,
0.311632364988327,
-0.24055299162864685,
-0.3683789372444153,
1.003085732460022,
0.5136246681213379,
-0.5698587894439697,
-0.08953535556793213,
-0.19061361253261566,
0.7788605093955994,
-0.26414087414741516,
0.20954546332359314,
0.6839627623558044,
0.7552028894424438,
-0.3975968658924103,
-1.126218318939209,
0.43736761808395386,
-0.1581224501132965,
-0.15198475122451782,
0.2331879734992981,
-0.6717889904975891,
0.5613508224487305,
-0.6355600357055664,
0.2651955783367157,
0.06771361082792282,
-0.025395339354872704,
0.19634371995925903,
0.0023624084424227476,
0.40747079253196716,
0.6441147327423096,
0.8949983716011047,
-0.08345340937376022,
1.3086979389190674,
-0.23206974565982819,
0.23016396164894104,
0.9951152205467224,
-0.5565457940101624,
0.8211873769760132,
0.7688697576522827,
-0.25604578852653503,
0.45046481490135193,
0.6724622249603271,
-0.24406610429286957,
0.5240960717201233,
0.10155970603227615,
-0.5563562512397766,
-0.29438045620918274,
-0.2474377304315567,
-0.3942466676235199,
0.44441378116607666,
0.3878394067287445,
-0.49301525950431824,
-0.05071515962481499,
0.08862919360399246,
0.3260505199432373,
0.20501938462257385,
-0.22816196084022522,
0.5641936659812927,
0.4906318783760071,
-0.5572081208229065,
0.18429812788963318,
0.021357940509915352,
0.2157447338104248,
-0.7666081786155701,
0.12023043632507324,
-0.24797417223453522,
0.4764235317707062,
-0.18897967040538788,
-0.9596340656280518,
0.11546412110328674,
0.12359721958637238,
-0.22815270721912384,
-0.32649704813957214,
0.6234654784202576,
-0.3577757179737091,
-0.5557544827461243,
0.4594753384590149,
0.7304573059082031,
0.14795751869678497,
-0.3682194948196411,
-0.7407459020614624,
-0.0970165804028511,
-0.2917885184288025,
-0.512820303440094,
0.6503039598464966,
0.5395302772521973,
0.023324904963374138,
0.7595699429512024,
0.5383633971214294,
0.41678085923194885,
-0.5982859134674072,
0.3592369258403778,
0.8094230890274048,
-0.7295218110084534,
-0.4262489974498749,
-0.7360769510269165,
0.506162703037262,
-0.11775043606758118,
-0.08080685883760452,
0.5898948311805725,
-0.0876212865114212,
0.06210271269083023,
-0.05386458709836006,
0.615658700466156,
-0.11999679356813431,
0.4595806896686554,
-0.14633166790008545,
0.8459321856498718,
-0.47461241483688354,
-0.17239242792129517,
-0.33672475814819336,
-0.8315441012382507,
-0.18930095434188843,
0.8549250960350037,
-0.21434272825717926,
0.3422519862651825,
0.682323157787323,
0.6278557181358337,
-0.02568378858268261,
-0.028977209702134132,
0.4337785840034485,
0.32635006308555603,
0.5758156776428223,
0.6353617310523987,
0.9377981424331665,
-0.027442704886198044,
0.18844933807849884,
-0.2778718173503876,
-0.5169293880462646,
0.16180437803268433,
-0.9991348385810852,
-0.847757875919342,
-0.31000348925590515,
-0.27508509159088135,
-0.45090028643608093,
-0.2399841845035553,
1.072171926498413,
0.7683147192001343,
-0.2536951005458832,
0.03630784898996353,
-0.04068597033619881,
-0.36864468455314636,
-0.4809979498386383,
-0.2383851408958435,
0.4595104157924652,
0.07644056528806686,
-0.35289695858955383,
0.07128193229436874,
0.4081984758377075,
0.09177812933921814,
-0.40416401624679565,
-0.2711337208747864,
0.3353603482246399,
0.00032843786175362766,
0.742981493473053,
0.17457716166973114,
-0.6891201138496399,
-0.0621846467256546,
0.007457833271473646,
-0.08070816844701767,
-0.10382030159235,
0.9023120403289795,
-0.3422291576862335,
0.3535139262676239,
-0.44644707441329956,
0.43677443265914917,
0.37267959117889404,
-0.009866085834801197,
0.8061090707778931,
-0.14197926223278046,
0.2205820530653,
0.45799046754837036,
0.3680579960346222,
0.40607309341430664,
-0.6488481760025024,
0.4612176716327667,
0.048065185546875,
-0.681531548500061,
-0.9476854205131531,
0.396506667137146,
-1.0490422248840332,
-0.10365505516529083,
1.2966395616531372,
-0.27855202555656433,
0.252882182598114,
-0.18716183304786682,
-0.6243290901184082,
0.14184555411338806,
-0.2802560031414032,
0.9552261829376221,
0.5836471915245056,
-0.5271047949790955,
-0.6689111590385437,
-0.2606574296951294,
0.5420199036598206,
0.29132017493247986,
-0.6421012878417969,
0.1917387992143631,
0.1758430451154709,
0.565213143825531,
-0.3488922119140625,
0.8726939558982849,
-0.09576864540576935,
0.32824456691741943,
0.08695002645254135,
0.26971980929374695,
-0.1594935804605484,
0.2723880112171173,
-0.01132475771009922,
-0.07383102178573608,
0.5958801507949829,
0.29217055439949036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10985v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10985v1 | Taking a Deep Breath: Enhancing Language Modeling of Large Language Models with Sentinel Tokens | 2024-06-16T15:50:10 | 2024-06-16T15:50:10 | Weiyao Luo, Suncong Zheng, Heming Xia, Weikang Wang, Yan Lei, Tianyu Liu, Shuang Chen, Zhifang Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown promising efficacy across various
tasks, becoming powerful tools in numerous aspects of human life. However,
Transformer-based LLMs suffer a performance degradation when modeling long-term
contexts due to they discard some information to reduce computational overhead.
In this work, we propose a simple yet effective method to enable LLMs to take a
deep breath, encouraging them to summarize information contained within
discrete text chunks. Specifically, we segment the text into multiple chunks
and insert special token <SR> at the end of each chunk. We then modify the
attention mask to integrate the chunk's information into the corresponding <SR>
token. This facilitates LLMs to interpret information not only from historical
individual tokens but also from the <SR> token, aggregating the chunk's
semantic information. Experiments on language modeling and out-of-domain
downstream tasks validate the superiority of our approach. | [
-0.11140652000904083,
-0.7211719751358032,
0.712308943271637,
0.05906187742948532,
-0.7570327520370483,
0.43318551778793335,
-0.4402519166469574,
-0.2602035105228424,
0.3418979048728943,
0.6327492594718933,
-0.3013274669647217,
-0.507906436920166,
-0.804686963558197,
-0.17596504092216492,
-0.6531371474266052,
0.8145049810409546,
0.1817949414253235,
-0.3254668712615967,
-0.026946863159537315,
0.07276681065559387,
-0.4275331199169159,
-0.43952494859695435,
-0.7245420813560486,
-0.24529774487018585,
0.5128665566444397,
0.16130207479000092,
0.6221083998680115,
0.5657739043235779,
0.5335268974304199,
0.268903523683548,
-0.5663621425628662,
0.0949878990650177,
-0.4720630943775177,
0.30779555439949036,
-0.29780858755111694,
-0.3888890743255615,
-0.21263282001018524,
-0.3539566099643707,
0.9470987915992737,
0.7769784927368164,
0.021439626812934875,
0.06454682350158691,
0.052522435784339905,
0.4575551748275757,
-0.5343261361122131,
0.18469534814357758,
-0.8073626160621643,
-0.0645289421081543,
-0.3426525294780731,
-0.015084819868206978,
-0.5441527366638184,
0.16684690117835999,
0.25335147976875305,
-0.2151031494140625,
0.021408308297395706,
-0.11007416993379593,
0.5536368489265442,
0.4835456609725952,
-0.3845883905887604,
-0.08140753209590912,
-0.658096969127655,
0.7094141244888306,
-0.9909502267837524,
0.33575084805488586,
0.07338481396436691,
0.11252880841493607,
0.07902763038873672,
-1.024599313735962,
-0.6706111431121826,
0.09267780929803848,
-0.1283523440361023,
0.06547366827726364,
-0.35799798369407654,
0.120585598051548,
-0.16323286294937134,
0.49907854199409485,
-0.3861100375652313,
0.27849897742271423,
-0.3088163733482361,
-0.12493745982646942,
0.37339991331100464,
0.3522631824016571,
0.20210720598697662,
-0.12197998911142349,
-0.4677114486694336,
0.06085589900612831,
-0.5580394864082336,
-0.18748676776885986,
-0.26907333731651306,
0.5926918387413025,
-0.19763408601284027,
0.5848133563995361,
-0.12803445756435394,
0.6206013560295105,
-0.29960760474205017,
-0.20820489525794983,
0.1619592308998108,
-0.14337942004203796,
-0.6054543256759644,
-0.1620544046163559,
0.6536701321601868,
0.15476767718791962,
-0.015244143083691597,
-0.1643144190311432,
-0.1916934847831726,
0.04913308098912239,
0.3562595546245575,
-1.0093719959259033,
0.1291903555393219,
0.5141798853874207,
-0.5051677227020264,
-0.26396849751472473,
-0.2339097410440445,
-0.7220039367675781,
-0.5723787546157837,
-0.45036381483078003,
0.24257205426692963,
-0.3403536081314087,
-0.2909977436065674,
0.40730926394462585,
-0.24790766835212708,
0.09883434325456619,
0.2506261169910431,
-0.6579551100730896,
0.4242633581161499,
1.0297553539276123,
1.0545284748077393,
-0.3644947409629822,
-0.18254061043262482,
-0.5640466213226318,
0.13426172733306885,
-0.2413330376148224,
0.7432061433792114,
-0.749113142490387,
-0.47308549284935,
0.14599528908729553,
-0.2181004285812378,
-0.2027311772108078,
-0.6349169611930847,
0.41623374819755554,
-0.6687151193618774,
0.09713272750377655,
0.26117751002311707,
-0.8677518367767334,
-0.15775947272777557,
0.20102936029434204,
-0.5457547903060913,
0.9812130928039551,
0.05362796410918236,
-0.6836113333702087,
-0.04434224218130112,
-0.6865059733390808,
-0.5544238686561584,
0.2590687870979309,
-0.16448715329170227,
-0.2961830794811249,
0.5579409003257751,
0.2985875904560089,
0.6855091452598572,
-0.24122744798660278,
0.28291937708854675,
-0.05382775515317917,
-0.258698970079422,
0.5004929900169373,
-0.40293970704078674,
0.5375452637672424,
0.3027971684932709,
-0.2680478096008301,
0.3262401819229126,
-0.35474199056625366,
-0.24965044856071472,
-0.05497553199529648,
-0.20330917835235596,
-0.31124594807624817,
0.0032805942464619875,
0.07407263666391373,
0.16613605618476868,
0.013520431704819202,
-0.3144005239009857,
0.21294307708740234,
-0.40189656615257263,
0.6954076886177063,
0.690639317035675,
0.1630094051361084,
0.3666200637817383,
-0.23376233875751495,
0.669420063495636,
0.19896234571933746,
0.12770681083202362,
-0.6635071039199829,
-0.3743017315864563,
-0.8744621276855469,
-0.8414251804351807,
0.26953840255737305,
0.14531011879444122,
-0.5136272311210632,
0.5313851833343506,
-0.7250145673751831,
-0.5138112306594849,
-0.5645878314971924,
0.007859287783503532,
0.19686181843280792,
0.4582902491092682,
0.41957396268844604,
-0.3535339832305908,
-0.360000878572464,
-0.590156614780426,
-0.3873870074748993,
-0.16822820901870728,
-0.09194795787334442,
0.20261968672275543,
0.4789654314517975,
-0.5089040398597717,
1.0604369640350342,
-0.7422390580177307,
-0.4733085334300995,
-0.47596073150634766,
0.12500636279582977,
0.11630943417549133,
0.250778466463089,
0.10501819103956223,
-0.6503421664237976,
-0.11126753687858582,
-0.1554347276687622,
-0.4209693372249603,
0.08374317735433578,
-0.32219812273979187,
-0.13927443325519562,
0.04712093994021416,
0.8222724199295044,
-0.8475052118301392,
0.4322951138019562,
0.5467532873153687,
-0.43311044573783875,
0.354471892118454,
0.1216660588979721,
-0.40728864073753357,
-1.232548475265503,
0.20035453140735626,
-0.32317861914634705,
-0.3225336968898773,
-0.7095825672149658,
0.3696839213371277,
0.022488145157694817,
-0.2506175637245178,
-0.7720262408256531,
1.0890100002288818,
-0.3109712302684784,
-0.0074058398604393005,
-0.536669135093689,
0.19356165826320648,
0.1617240309715271,
0.3299711048603058,
0.19709299504756927,
0.5275511145591736,
0.5833733677864075,
-0.5279110670089722,
-0.006791086867451668,
0.1606103777885437,
-0.5401290655136108,
0.22728951275348663,
-0.5858275890350342,
0.23933054506778717,
-0.28570929169654846,
0.6271792054176331,
-1.0499809980392456,
-0.31548258662223816,
-0.09920722246170044,
-0.4466584622859955,
0.411192387342453,
-0.06393076479434967,
-0.5007320046424866,
-0.14435231685638428,
-0.22968903183937073,
0.44916442036628723,
0.5516214370727539,
-0.4400485157966614,
1.045243501663208,
0.6357266902923584,
-0.4224018454551697,
-0.2586769461631775,
-0.8739611506462097,
0.5213564038276672,
-0.5112572908401489,
-0.39521077275276184,
0.6128693222999573,
0.1430722177028656,
-0.31655773520469666,
0.055181410163640976,
-0.08611936867237091,
-0.04406197369098663,
0.18046949803829193,
0.1490734964609146,
0.1060013622045517,
-0.1041143462061882,
0.5740072727203369,
0.03234134241938591,
-0.13424085080623627,
-0.09422732889652252,
-0.5985766649246216,
0.7394701242446899,
-0.03977217152714729,
-0.22741930186748505,
-0.5392395853996277,
0.4908308684825897,
0.9038194417953491,
-0.5844111442565918,
0.8708169460296631,
0.506783664226532,
-0.682418704032898,
-0.15345844626426697,
-0.6682077646255493,
-0.23984619975090027,
-0.4275766611099243,
0.3095356523990631,
-0.24606475234031677,
-1.3018685579299927,
0.5602306127548218,
-0.2753998935222626,
0.0003182783257216215,
0.3257806897163391,
0.7314751744270325,
-0.04417707026004791,
0.5172653794288635,
0.7400342226028442,
-0.5474468469619751,
0.6652140021324158,
-0.3143591582775116,
0.3425596058368683,
-1.104496717453003,
-0.09127479046583176,
-0.501891553401947,
-0.3048103153705597,
-0.08791051805019379,
-0.9946149587631226,
0.32977503538131714,
0.02182598039507866,
-0.13784494996070862,
0.04242189601063728,
-0.27997905015945435,
0.47916004061698914,
0.23112273216247559,
0.09636591374874115,
0.24168363213539124,
-0.11594720929861069,
-0.18120801448822021,
0.09123139083385468,
-0.4691682755947113,
-0.5060180425643921,
0.738976240158081,
0.575179398059845,
0.8644787073135376,
0.05684294179081917,
0.7695911526679993,
0.014901784248650074,
0.3829670548439026,
-0.9182891845703125,
0.42807629704475403,
-0.23322713375091553,
-0.5995988845825195,
-0.4096898138523102,
-0.2603634297847748,
-0.9322124719619751,
0.45436742901802063,
0.3423527777194977,
-0.7703777551651001,
-0.0866650640964508,
-0.07398353517055511,
-0.556890606880188,
0.19019916653633118,
-0.48927369713783264,
0.8177594542503357,
-0.017283858731389046,
-0.053175706416368484,
-0.4494532644748688,
-0.7176783084869385,
0.2735694944858551,
-0.19231781363487244,
0.4612526595592499,
-0.10945289582014084,
-0.36512213945388794,
0.6809699535369873,
-0.510503888130188,
1.2816401720046997,
-0.08816572278738022,
-0.11490891873836517,
0.5691028833389282,
0.0685749426484108,
0.5897835493087769,
-0.09020638465881348,
0.0002911660703830421,
0.04703948274254799,
-0.5569463968276978,
-0.3297017812728882,
-0.6474001407623291,
0.45835721492767334,
-0.481757253408432,
-0.2903088331222534,
-0.2417389154434204,
-0.406606525182724,
-0.11279484629631042,
0.3065585494041443,
-0.03769060596823692,
0.5351378321647644,
0.11791288107633591,
0.3848094344139099,
0.5688214302062988,
-0.204553484916687,
0.6040117144584656,
0.5208063721656799,
-0.32372409105300903,
-0.4999079406261444,
0.6302571892738342,
-0.06568284332752228,
0.27740177512168884,
0.6869995594024658,
0.4750734269618988,
-0.6893883943557739,
-0.5021226406097412,
-0.13880960643291473,
0.37646180391311646,
-0.7303165197372437,
-0.3717724680900574,
-0.8081799745559692,
-0.20493562519550323,
-0.39459240436553955,
-0.10491084307432175,
-0.32755768299102783,
-0.3849107623100281,
-0.40931811928749084,
-0.31755420565605164,
0.4086953103542328,
0.4714546799659729,
0.23424433171749115,
0.5718811750411987,
-0.9905412793159485,
0.23271283507347107,
0.24385222792625427,
0.2597021460533142,
0.19594834744930267,
-0.8817422986030579,
-0.3828979730606079,
-0.22111168503761292,
-0.041984573006629944,
-0.5350649356842041,
0.4574698507785797,
0.21523937582969666,
0.2520688772201538,
0.30685320496559143,
0.016461409628391266,
0.9603254199028015,
-0.5166223645210266,
0.997185468673706,
0.004121776670217514,
-1.2969857454299927,
0.42753031849861145,
-0.34600400924682617,
0.7178415656089783,
0.4420677125453949,
0.0447385236620903,
-0.8587600588798523,
-0.6986592411994934,
-0.522148072719574,
-1.1176440715789795,
0.2874174118041992,
0.20149949193000793,
0.4794647991657257,
-0.20128528773784637,
0.1938716471195221,
-0.06636276841163635,
0.17923077940940857,
-0.4655747711658478,
0.17261464893817902,
0.1616409868001938,
-0.42627012729644775,
-0.12159931659698486,
-0.3267529308795929,
0.06669621914625168,
-0.10812161862850189,
0.4867278039455414,
-0.36095860600471497,
0.2385995239019394,
0.18043044209480286,
-0.2964533865451813,
0.271056592464447,
0.2149421125650406,
0.7562471628189087,
0.44412437081336975,
0.19117675721645355,
0.5922549962997437,
0.2014855146408081,
-0.4162198603153229,
-0.08533629775047302,
-0.0676564872264862,
0.11447680741548538,
0.1013670563697815,
0.5824642777442932,
0.7500222325325012,
0.4539427161216736,
-0.8681496977806091,
0.41590526700019836,
-0.1496591567993164,
0.23771362006664276,
-0.10239005088806152,
-0.2620258033275604,
0.518706738948822,
0.2368120700120926,
0.41809484362602234,
-0.24653306603431702,
0.008356096222996712,
-0.4995018243789673,
0.2589508295059204,
0.3012811839580536,
-0.40685486793518066,
-0.13081420958042145,
0.5771844387054443,
0.31686854362487793,
-0.1720864623785019,
0.6058531403541565,
0.1717265099287033,
-0.674004077911377,
0.2238921970129013,
0.484621524810791,
1.1459743976593018,
-0.16730819642543793,
-0.08490652590990067,
-0.026946039870381355,
0.16199222207069397,
0.09067357331514359,
0.034950606524944305,
-0.18220160901546478,
-0.5289979577064514,
-0.8638091087341309,
-0.7706986665725708,
-0.3336295187473297,
0.3122830390930176,
-0.5405339002609253,
0.019579576328396797,
-0.12804104387760162,
-0.25978901982307434,
0.04182557761669159,
-0.2304365634918213,
-0.6821340918540955,
0.41789618134498596,
0.34679368138313293,
1.1054311990737915,
-0.7926043272018433,
0.8039577603340149,
0.380138635635376,
-0.1649176925420761,
-0.5992333889007568,
0.1883298009634018,
-0.004776256624609232,
-0.7813398241996765,
0.5304002165794373,
0.35484495759010315,
-0.1595585197210312,
-0.034405019134283066,
-0.20171870291233063,
-0.9323236346244812,
0.8682169914245605,
0.20255416631698608,
-0.5918777585029602,
0.03617388755083084,
0.2739892601966858,
0.6762847900390625,
-0.2945777475833893,
0.1824066936969757,
0.6456685662269592,
0.281864732503891,
0.1201145276427269,
-0.7132534980773926,
0.06586102396249771,
-0.07471582293510437,
0.16508783400058746,
0.15566569566726685,
-0.8125341534614563,
0.6648990511894226,
-0.0390821173787117,
-0.25440770387649536,
-0.037952978163957596,
0.7504875659942627,
-0.016683772206306458,
0.003991979639977217,
0.4739725589752197,
0.6489191651344299,
0.9797554016113281,
0.17251929640769958,
1.1052719354629517,
-0.4159838855266571,
0.2944613993167877,
1.3844873905181885,
-0.45637091994285583,
1.1628373861312866,
0.5654515624046326,
0.002009007381275296,
0.385286808013916,
0.42049023509025574,
0.45907410979270935,
0.47188207507133484,
0.3403380215167999,
-0.6554027795791626,
-0.13687501847743988,
-0.315725177526474,
-0.02382948063313961,
0.6035016179084778,
0.5908289551734924,
-0.46672457456588745,
-0.12828367948532104,
0.09018990397453308,
0.3237289488315582,
-0.1354438215494156,
-0.17209619283676147,
0.9805285334587097,
0.3193776309490204,
-0.7784423828125,
0.3930831551551819,
0.12730634212493896,
0.491156667470932,
-0.34561586380004883,
0.32743173837661743,
-0.3867124319076538,
0.3481055796146393,
-0.03404434397816658,
-0.6905163526535034,
0.674998939037323,
0.3334362506866455,
-0.02016008272767067,
-0.38757872581481934,
0.7661445140838623,
-0.46485409140586853,
-0.5663995742797852,
0.21577538549900055,
0.3732893466949463,
0.27494409680366516,
-0.49499499797821045,
-0.359177827835083,
0.6502622961997986,
-0.24114087224006653,
-0.2894630432128906,
0.28118664026260376,
0.46013912558555603,
0.08942727744579315,
0.7665873169898987,
0.6083057522773743,
-0.06228743866086006,
0.11441776156425476,
0.25639608502388,
1.1142115592956543,
-0.8338332772254944,
-0.5504574775695801,
-1.2295610904693604,
0.8961785435676575,
-0.03188121318817139,
-0.3111042380332947,
0.584316074848175,
0.7540243864059448,
0.5311993360519409,
0.00038666347973048687,
0.9011561870574951,
0.3135858178138733,
0.5664929747581482,
-0.6108267903327942,
0.7542945146560669,
-0.36485347151756287,
0.033812180161476135,
-0.08888933062553406,
-0.5680331587791443,
-0.6421655416488647,
0.3973885774612427,
0.01319779921323061,
-0.25881290435791016,
0.7670171856880188,
0.6495490670204163,
0.0694551020860672,
-0.14824125170707703,
0.1712818741798401,
0.3085000813007355,
0.7251462340354919,
0.31597572565078735,
0.7952331304550171,
-0.2123822271823883,
0.34067851305007935,
-0.008766049519181252,
-0.10003238171339035,
-0.4687066376209259,
-0.9784268736839294,
-1.0109226703643799,
-0.4776538610458374,
-0.3775913417339325,
-0.06280623376369476,
-0.26881924271583557,
0.704923152923584,
0.9325181841850281,
-0.5200976729393005,
-0.03607204183936119,
-0.1677592247724533,
0.06597717106342316,
-0.08735790848731995,
-0.22084465622901917,
0.48830071091651917,
-0.6219490766525269,
-0.6425527930259705,
0.5801557898521423,
0.4584403932094574,
0.16318726539611816,
-0.35033920407295227,
0.17905446887016296,
0.2190503031015396,
0.34591206908226013,
0.8838031888008118,
-0.13668839633464813,
-0.9238980412483215,
-0.31117865443229675,
0.01673634722828865,
-0.07568138092756271,
-0.12440711259841919,
0.9416954517364502,
-1.0362169742584229,
0.5158081650733948,
0.410067081451416,
0.9707367420196533,
0.6808596849441528,
0.00047822462511248887,
0.3891213834285736,
-0.9258226156234741,
0.1116228923201561,
0.5487261414527893,
0.37216395139694214,
0.38302257657051086,
-0.08330115675926208,
0.3819129765033722,
-0.06484537571668625,
-0.31321412324905396,
-0.9954224824905396,
0.1591685563325882,
-0.9681634902954102,
-0.4095756411552429,
1.213110327720642,
-0.2033848613500595,
-0.2755317986011505,
0.058630477637052536,
-0.27570292353630066,
0.22399179637432098,
-0.24082183837890625,
0.6877001523971558,
0.6246455311775208,
0.06668804585933685,
-0.0005280663608573377,
-0.1657910943031311,
0.21693195402622223,
0.4097171425819397,
-1.0180363655090332,
0.41470322012901306,
0.17280374467372894,
0.23261551558971405,
0.12102677673101425,
0.7489141225814819,
-0.2030225247144699,
-0.19021062552928925,
-0.07037225365638733,
-0.15056683123111725,
0.1294706165790558,
-0.4212944507598877,
-0.7030567526817322,
-0.03758201748132706,
-0.01939578168094158,
-0.206513449549675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10984v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10984v1 | Revisiting Cosine Similarity via Normalized ICA-transformed Embeddings | 2024-06-16T15:44:37 | 2024-06-16T15:44:37 | Hiroaki Yamagiwa, Momose Oyama, Hidetoshi Shimodaira | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cosine similarity is widely used to measure the similarity between two
embeddings, while interpretations based on angle and correlation coefficient
are common. In this study, we focus on the interpretable axes of embeddings
transformed by Independent Component Analysis (ICA), and propose a novel
interpretation of cosine similarity as the sum of semantic similarities over
axes. To investigate this, we first show experimentally that unnormalized
embeddings contain norm-derived artifacts. We then demonstrate that normalized
ICA-transformed embeddings exhibit sparsity, with a few large values in each
axis and across embeddings, thereby enhancing interpretability by delineating
clear semantic contributions. Finally, to validate our interpretation, we
perform retrieval experiments using ideal embeddings with and without specific
semantic components. | [
-0.6836594939231873,
-0.607610821723938,
0.47060564160346985,
-0.07828308641910553,
-0.5745902061462402,
-0.422372967004776,
0.000128170067910105,
-0.41829752922058105,
0.7759128212928772,
0.518937349319458,
-0.5275753736495972,
-0.7137629389762878,
-0.5795174241065979,
0.1203378364443779,
-0.6527693271636963,
0.7906799912452698,
0.06683040410280228,
0.20623786747455597,
-0.31905806064605713,
-0.591250479221344,
-0.6661465167999268,
-0.1215028166770935,
-0.15692855417728424,
-0.08357588201761246,
0.25791576504707336,
0.3903578221797943,
1.0935931205749512,
0.62242591381073,
0.704558253288269,
0.22096401453018188,
0.29128023982048035,
-0.22407439351081848,
-0.725619375705719,
-0.22624965012073517,
-0.17513178288936615,
-0.48502033948898315,
-0.3720499277114868,
0.11585752665996552,
0.44136568903923035,
0.9743832349777222,
0.24076992273330688,
0.17128713428974152,
0.41836631298065186,
0.6346784234046936,
-0.5110796093940735,
0.38268905878067017,
-0.7576730847358704,
0.0007196991355158389,
0.03588113933801651,
-0.3147543966770172,
-0.24531854689121246,
-0.19902805984020233,
0.3828944265842438,
-0.9652537107467651,
0.565858006477356,
0.14226801693439484,
1.003920555114746,
0.18365156650543213,
-0.24326932430267334,
-0.6451722383499146,
-0.3316376805305481,
0.9594597220420837,
-0.5688524842262268,
0.6327599883079529,
0.037544723600149155,
0.2800443470478058,
-0.3827744722366333,
-0.6599593162536621,
-0.712252676486969,
-0.2074267566204071,
-0.29626399278640747,
-0.07540400326251984,
-0.49894019961357117,
-0.25313135981559753,
-0.26632219552993774,
0.3461986780166626,
-0.3698825538158417,
-0.04737398773431778,
-0.2526611387729645,
-0.23207704722881317,
0.695220947265625,
-0.014954946003854275,
0.7267863154411316,
-0.10767968744039536,
-0.8700425624847412,
-0.41150954365730286,
-0.815254271030426,
0.22682228684425354,
0.2506480813026428,
0.246271550655365,
-0.3041895627975464,
0.7645295858383179,
-0.2075718194246292,
0.35743317008018494,
-0.035689111799001694,
0.058541517704725266,
0.11391394585371017,
-0.027374057099223137,
-0.14917820692062378,
0.06404295563697815,
0.302674800157547,
0.7544032335281372,
0.24298489093780518,
-0.5653639435768127,
0.14316301047801971,
0.08119536191225052,
0.2936420142650604,
-0.49295738339424133,
-0.16438275575637817,
-0.3383362889289856,
-0.7731630802154541,
-0.02403501234948635,
0.4032428562641144,
-0.8258052468299866,
0.08273081481456757,
-0.8290134072303772,
0.4964560270309448,
-0.6126411557197571,
0.09700693190097809,
0.32784661650657654,
-0.2735098600387573,
0.6119475364685059,
0.26383814215660095,
-0.41410911083221436,
0.6987066864967346,
1.2026537656784058,
0.704047679901123,
-0.556952178478241,
-0.2893882691860199,
-0.2352086901664734,
-0.11396150290966034,
-0.48783761262893677,
0.834099531173706,
-0.506951093673706,
-0.16475598514080048,
-0.2091667801141739,
0.19423601031303406,
0.23849008977413177,
-0.5712493658065796,
0.4060629606246948,
-0.8468779921531677,
-0.16326023638248444,
-0.2549467384815216,
-0.505629301071167,
-0.6751399636268616,
0.1996036171913147,
-0.9066162109375,
0.7316792607307434,
0.020932931452989578,
-0.6281006336212158,
0.5813354253768921,
-0.21356919407844543,
0.1956104040145874,
-0.08142807334661484,
-0.5060573220252991,
-0.556935727596283,
0.39469829201698303,
0.16190659999847412,
0.5189759135246277,
-0.3399263024330139,
0.09076441824436188,
-0.872074544429779,
-0.3886215090751648,
0.5215281248092651,
-0.43849366903305054,
0.7744285464286804,
-0.05827675014734268,
-0.3519591987133026,
-0.2904316484928131,
-0.9289864897727966,
-0.048651061952114105,
-0.3054831922054291,
0.3422408401966095,
-1.0145364999771118,
-0.2237420529127121,
-0.09994173794984818,
-0.05190856382250786,
0.1397121101617813,
-0.6881922483444214,
-0.05666380003094673,
-0.28864482045173645,
-0.19495970010757446,
0.6171716451644897,
0.2575626075267792,
0.6839310526847839,
-0.22732232511043549,
-0.027479585260152817,
0.17539918422698975,
-0.2157406210899353,
0.593252420425415,
-0.49103623628616333,
-0.5231444835662842,
-0.6439470052719116,
-0.0858188346028328,
0.04517560079693794,
-0.5640271902084351,
0.46587324142456055,
-0.7922897934913635,
-0.469608336687088,
-0.6789740920066833,
-0.05500571429729462,
0.16872984170913696,
0.2768736183643341,
0.7866132855415344,
-0.8776857256889343,
-0.3200908899307251,
-1.2187856435775757,
-0.4900273084640503,
0.16655783355236053,
-0.2514673173427582,
0.1723664551973343,
0.35022327303886414,
-0.148808553814888,
0.9645212292671204,
-0.6341245770454407,
-0.5469593405723572,
0.3308418393135071,
0.21041929721832275,
0.005827529821544886,
0.5593682527542114,
0.7104039192199707,
-0.5274453163146973,
-0.6310268044471741,
0.05819964036345482,
-0.6409059762954712,
0.026813844218850136,
-0.3804767429828644,
-0.46540623903274536,
-0.40707314014434814,
0.6131696105003357,
-0.37152165174484253,
1.1077499389648438,
0.26328879594802856,
-0.6533346772193909,
0.11431445926427841,
-0.10258984565734863,
0.23781372606754303,
-0.9987390041351318,
-0.05291031301021576,
-0.18356925249099731,
0.002974989591166377,
-0.41377678513526917,
0.12403299659490585,
-0.15438437461853027,
0.014802643097937107,
-0.20558537542819977,
0.36495232582092285,
-0.495199054479599,
-0.5894933342933655,
-0.3241325318813324,
0.48567700386047363,
0.1702372133731842,
0.4041841924190521,
-0.2385052889585495,
0.6170536279678345,
0.38550692796707153,
-0.6894503235816956,
0.1061442419886589,
0.2952324151992798,
-0.29907768964767456,
0.9475163221359253,
-0.4950742721557617,
0.10370267927646637,
-0.33988094329833984,
0.10064907371997833,
-0.9315149188041687,
0.2342039793729782,
0.041485220193862915,
-0.5448188185691833,
0.10173574090003967,
0.07849880307912827,
0.024258064106106758,
0.5283385515213013,
-0.6603710055351257,
0.5972132682800293,
0.2054298222064972,
-0.6715763211250305,
0.4982852339744568,
0.21771234273910522,
-0.03572867810726166,
-0.5893229246139526,
-0.401603102684021,
0.006314304191619158,
-0.216308131814003,
-0.5352662205696106,
0.6449037790298462,
0.13341288268566132,
-0.6335256695747375,
0.5925130844116211,
0.07503253221511841,
-0.1211676150560379,
0.11004353314638138,
0.306789368391037,
0.32248178124427795,
-0.5455747842788696,
0.06647685170173645,
0.3268319070339203,
-0.268790602684021,
0.06363924592733383,
0.08340910077095032,
0.46323466300964355,
-0.12506097555160522,
-0.5338784456253052,
-0.7877805233001709,
0.4736952483654022,
0.5115994215011597,
0.0063822283409535885,
0.6403176784515381,
0.6461366415023804,
-0.46640172600746155,
0.15078991651535034,
-0.46735358238220215,
-0.3031720519065857,
-0.3162933886051178,
0.48088082671165466,
-0.5852437615394592,
-0.6485854983329773,
0.6028441786766052,
0.25999635457992554,
-0.15178601443767548,
0.8646388053894043,
0.33157312870025635,
-0.12944072484970093,
0.6195666790008545,
0.7319390773773193,
-0.07968088239431381,
0.13920335471630096,
-0.44242924451828003,
0.19567173719406128,
-0.8521474599838257,
-0.5037976503372192,
-0.6810827255249023,
-0.4945148229598999,
-0.9312050938606262,
-0.6016765236854553,
0.40336188673973083,
0.043503355234861374,
-0.13381832838058472,
0.16986337304115295,
-0.18502824008464813,
0.4430960714817047,
0.14681613445281982,
0.10962268710136414,
0.3616909980773926,
0.3157646059989929,
0.19754032790660858,
-0.33451923727989197,
-0.18314221501350403,
-0.5116682648658752,
0.8565000891685486,
0.29976558685302734,
0.8652163743972778,
0.06832247227430344,
0.5799669623374939,
0.1960023194551468,
0.35705438256263733,
-0.8932878375053406,
0.2901851236820221,
-0.43277856707572937,
-0.2613693177700043,
-0.30536454916000366,
-0.1191725879907608,
-1.127543330192566,
0.48949891328811646,
-0.280592679977417,
-0.6194421052932739,
0.8671275973320007,
-0.46562838554382324,
0.006518160458654165,
0.4162769019603729,
-0.5195150375366211,
0.546464204788208,
0.1415574848651886,
0.14677783846855164,
-0.7976866364479065,
-0.31717610359191895,
-0.02984820120036602,
0.3563966453075409,
0.21391452848911285,
-0.30108049511909485,
-0.28014931082725525,
0.7901065349578857,
-0.3403347134590149,
0.9125930070877075,
-0.05281911790370941,
0.23329834640026093,
0.588223934173584,
0.3893625736236572,
0.14811153709888458,
0.4139663279056549,
0.02801060490310192,
0.5449877977371216,
0.34211465716362,
-0.8213463425636292,
-0.9588109850883484,
1.001589298248291,
-1.1691937446594238,
-0.4467048943042755,
-0.39327964186668396,
-0.7643753290176392,
0.11282403022050858,
0.2796131670475006,
-0.017081178724765778,
0.6232495903968811,
-0.5356289148330688,
0.5742360949516296,
0.46075114607810974,
-0.06311669945716858,
0.058246660977602005,
0.3334134817123413,
0.10705433785915375,
-0.19779129326343536,
0.6975966691970825,
0.17874644696712494,
0.11988545209169388,
0.4397517442703247,
0.015902860090136528,
-0.14256730675697327,
-0.45646271109580994,
-0.1997356414794922,
0.301445335149765,
-0.7678862810134888,
-0.210496723651886,
-0.4023287296295166,
0.11415108293294907,
-0.4508886933326721,
-0.43348264694213867,
-0.614970326423645,
-0.5000897645950317,
-0.5890108346939087,
0.006667152047157288,
0.29848599433898926,
0.9491069316864014,
-0.05405479297041893,
-0.11775097250938416,
-0.7087572813034058,
0.16901668906211853,
0.21073447167873383,
0.32908546924591064,
0.17448002099990845,
-0.5150039196014404,
-0.20429466664791107,
0.16478946805000305,
-0.12439638376235962,
-0.7179815769195557,
0.5441570281982422,
0.25194597244262695,
0.4772785007953644,
0.27440348267555237,
0.16926932334899902,
0.9636243581771851,
-0.2289140820503235,
0.5788674354553223,
0.184799924492836,
-0.9196978211402893,
-0.2586763799190521,
0.4137592911720276,
-0.016449403017759323,
0.645315945148468,
0.636201024055481,
-0.38245660066604614,
-0.08359095454216003,
-0.6918084621429443,
-0.5927553772926331,
0.23970183730125427,
0.1140529066324234,
0.37713533639907837,
0.12399433553218842,
0.5823357105255127,
0.750024676322937,
-0.4578979015350342,
-0.2647240161895752,
-0.17700733244419098,
-0.1863904893398285,
-0.43429484963417053,
-0.05031759291887283,
-0.28667327761650085,
-0.188947394490242,
0.21459320187568665,
0.4510611593723297,
-0.16878947615623474,
0.6285334229469299,
0.4380708932876587,
-0.3044334352016449,
0.13488607108592987,
0.4077363610267639,
0.08774641156196594,
0.47482946515083313,
-0.05525241792201996,
0.5978826284408569,
0.37702319025993347,
-0.6410969495773315,
-0.023817013949155807,
-0.11701873689889908,
-0.2007187306880951,
0.19110478460788727,
0.6394920945167542,
0.572074294090271,
0.46916186809539795,
-0.17534440755844116,
0.620236337184906,
-0.4411698877811432,
0.31072428822517395,
-0.32143497467041016,
-0.42932936549186707,
-0.13279494643211365,
0.28439074754714966,
0.2897496819496155,
0.21641935408115387,
0.42994263768196106,
-0.5703955888748169,
0.539732813835144,
0.5583623647689819,
-0.991852343082428,
-0.8488339185714722,
-0.20699508488178253,
-0.3056880831718445,
0.00008971565694082528,
0.5543774366378784,
-0.12496934831142426,
-0.1412951797246933,
0.48513999581336975,
0.4066277742385864,
0.9592271447181702,
0.22322994470596313,
0.09731348603963852,
0.2813529372215271,
0.1030905693769455,
0.39219793677330017,
0.012834993191063404,
-0.03795395419001579,
-0.6953677535057068,
-0.16563472151756287,
-0.24979326128959656,
-0.09494633972644806,
-0.2305407077074051,
-1.3176662921905518,
0.5023752450942993,
0.027057038620114326,
0.2802762985229492,
0.0006416560499928892,
-0.24589432775974274,
-1.063238501548767,
0.2154332995414734,
-0.2645793855190277,
0.6751573085784912,
-0.9344591498374939,
0.6383285522460938,
0.6073814034461975,
-0.37711113691329956,
-0.9397895932197571,
0.17533552646636963,
-0.195503830909729,
-0.9274981617927551,
0.5096518397331238,
-0.030334029346704483,
-0.25528857111930847,
-0.28416699171066284,
-0.4721948206424713,
-1.1365177631378174,
1.3858600854873657,
0.1856847107410431,
-0.1391160637140274,
0.10344837605953217,
0.5129275918006897,
0.7851201891899109,
-0.686633288860321,
0.10209982842206955,
0.45701494812965393,
-0.2325447052717209,
-0.12380856275558472,
-0.7653024196624756,
0.26766732335090637,
0.17187431454658508,
0.16073673963546753,
-0.15109358727931976,
-0.41893747448921204,
0.8161415457725525,
0.16897721588611603,
-0.46573591232299805,
0.04805359989404678,
1.0132163763046265,
-0.2577146291732788,
0.6691845655441284,
0.3587503135204315,
0.6555596590042114,
0.3762342035770416,
0.24298009276390076,
0.8094787001609802,
-0.2999245822429657,
0.7020249962806702,
0.8862305283546448,
0.133326455950737,
0.9766151905059814,
0.882885754108429,
-0.09986219555139542,
0.6655023694038391,
0.08021734654903412,
0.4753064513206482,
0.5986910462379456,
-0.10466992110013962,
-0.028771717101335526,
-0.0890183299779892,
-0.20104609429836273,
-0.34859222173690796,
0.6867315769195557,
0.3950689136981964,
-0.17655932903289795,
-0.6791397333145142,
-0.028119273483753204,
0.07892876863479614,
0.2792961597442627,
-0.3053722381591797,
0.8848196864128113,
0.45979544520378113,
-0.50291907787323,
0.5441219806671143,
-0.0995134562253952,
0.5190370082855225,
-0.2116185575723648,
-0.3752717971801758,
-0.07829272747039795,
0.44882315397262573,
-0.15675589442253113,
-0.7962974905967712,
0.8609753847122192,
-0.38700851798057556,
0.08136823028326035,
0.23751011490821838,
0.7991480231285095,
-0.32967689633369446,
-0.3066532611846924,
0.4895165264606476,
0.2849731147289276,
0.118039071559906,
0.16528606414794922,
-0.5113081336021423,
-0.08325280994176865,
0.08626911789178848,
0.010555801913142204,
0.5362086892127991,
0.8342977166175842,
-0.3986957371234894,
0.41869574785232544,
0.48293110728263855,
-0.18802671134471893,
0.287447988986969,
-0.47124436497688293,
0.9586253762245178,
-0.525264322757721,
-0.47020792961120605,
-0.5987941026687622,
0.20991884171962738,
0.1423734873533249,
-0.30509868264198303,
0.7518269419670105,
0.6103690266609192,
1.07823646068573,
-0.24252967536449432,
0.23202161490917206,
0.048441220074892044,
0.4303223192691803,
-0.6223850250244141,
0.6045506000518799,
-0.3773292601108551,
0.19308805465698242,
-0.1209825798869133,
-0.9795196652412415,
-0.474044531583786,
0.6332385540008545,
-0.43955013155937195,
-0.5172684788703918,
0.7264145612716675,
1.0317497253417969,
-0.36948439478874207,
0.17705616354942322,
0.4445702135562897,
0.14833156764507294,
0.48237645626068115,
0.10811999440193176,
0.4654180407524109,
-0.6548479795455933,
0.34707674384117126,
-0.368289977312088,
-0.31983059644699097,
-0.15406359732151031,
-0.6394109129905701,
-0.6135933995246887,
-0.8372380137443542,
-0.18059907853603363,
-0.46953245997428894,
-0.16976217925548553,
1.0725780725479126,
0.09372220933437347,
-1.0256377458572388,
-0.3169330358505249,
0.11409095674753189,
0.023455971851944923,
-0.33185145258903503,
-0.225374236702919,
0.9012961387634277,
-0.2245396077632904,
-0.6445149779319763,
0.05600203946232796,
0.33514660596847534,
0.08637496829032898,
-0.4031633138656616,
-0.0042368099093437195,
-0.03509404882788658,
0.13979656994342804,
0.5102939605712891,
0.002766223857179284,
-0.6718918085098267,
-0.9163150787353516,
-0.024647517129778862,
-0.0772506520152092,
0.2596021890640259,
1.0379358530044556,
-0.5284116864204407,
0.6255588531494141,
0.920809805393219,
0.7710955739021301,
0.44768670201301575,
-0.12596923112869263,
0.4024621546268463,
-0.41146478056907654,
0.3019300103187561,
0.22400175034999847,
0.22992099821567535,
0.24178510904312134,
-0.30982232093811035,
0.20173366367816925,
0.22717265784740448,
-0.29183632135391235,
-0.535795271396637,
0.21542969346046448,
-1.3312644958496094,
0.10300549119710922,
0.8652722835540771,
-0.5881814360618591,
-0.5137633681297302,
-0.3604090213775635,
-0.15375664830207825,
0.4427894651889801,
-0.16530154645442963,
1.0612990856170654,
0.5398421287536621,
-0.26514142751693726,
0.3194619119167328,
0.016913797706365585,
0.2548326253890991,
0.36403143405914307,
-0.48403680324554443,
-0.360302209854126,
0.1439296454191208,
0.5792538523674011,
0.45730939507484436,
0.16456620395183563,
-0.5856651067733765,
0.31779035925865173,
0.09834548830986023,
0.12999160587787628,
0.23698414862155914,
-0.05347750335931778,
-0.26407590508461,
0.1046256348490715,
0.20414382219314575,
-0.323014497756958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10977v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10977v1 | Toward Optimal LLM Alignments Using Two-Player Games | 2024-06-16T15:24:50 | 2024-06-16T15:24:50 | Rui Zheng, Hongyi Guo, Zhihan Liu, Xiaoying Zhang, Yuanshun Yao, Xiaojun Xu, Zhaoran Wang, Zhiheng Xi, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang, Hang Li, Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68 | The standard Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) framework
primarily focuses on optimizing the performance of large language models using
pre-collected prompts. However, collecting prompts that provide comprehensive
coverage is both tedious and challenging, and often fails to include scenarios
that LLMs need to improve on the most. In this paper, we investigate alignment
through the lens of two-agent games, involving iterative interactions between
an adversarial and a defensive agent. The adversarial agent's task at each step
is to generate prompts that expose the weakness of the defensive agent. In
return, the defensive agent seeks to improve its responses to these newly
identified prompts it struggled with, based on feedback from the reward model.
We theoretically demonstrate that this iterative reinforcement learning
optimization converges to a Nash Equilibrium for the game induced by the
agents. Experimental results in safety scenarios demonstrate that learning in
such a competitive environment not only fully trains agents but also leads to
policies with enhanced generalization capabilities for both adversarial and
defensive agents. | [
-0.11346837878227234,
-0.5881925821304321,
0.6380167007446289,
-0.08519299328327179,
0.010635658167302608,
0.35120198130607605,
-0.36790576577186584,
-0.17195956408977509,
-0.16641314327716827,
0.44540125131607056,
-0.8587934374809265,
-0.502244770526886,
-0.4554438889026642,
-0.14427058398723602,
0.2944785952568054,
1.237760066986084,
-0.09448952227830887,
0.08316117525100708,
-0.2823777198791504,
-0.158418670296669,
-0.4387977421283722,
-0.021598713472485542,
-0.8624166250228882,
-0.7461473345756531,
0.6417881846427917,
0.4751223921775818,
0.8524022102355957,
0.8723258376121521,
0.46134722232818604,
0.3537732660770416,
0.1722746193408966,
0.320393443107605,
-0.8057898283004761,
0.5581896901130676,
-0.3636777400970459,
-0.43331286311149597,
0.09436194598674774,
0.1367306411266327,
0.6572396159172058,
0.22085583209991455,
-0.40815305709838867,
-0.2953040599822998,
0.052244529128074646,
0.697445273399353,
-0.4877931773662567,
-0.03733542189002037,
-0.3569091558456421,
0.2900674641132355,
0.11419239640235901,
-0.4233494997024536,
-0.3796112537384033,
-0.2888934314250946,
0.35445308685302734,
-0.939738929271698,
-0.20716768503189087,
-0.027484070509672165,
1.1414519548416138,
0.5953105688095093,
-0.4742548167705536,
-0.32642310857772827,
-0.701010525226593,
0.7068790197372437,
-0.2964412569999695,
0.02522001415491104,
0.07895540446043015,
0.5531840920448303,
-0.535578727722168,
-0.18060268461704254,
-0.22884376347064972,
-0.2765789330005646,
0.09075997769832611,
0.43129679560661316,
-0.2777116894721985,
0.2080853432416916,
0.020883794873952866,
-0.3252319097518921,
-0.5853734016418457,
0.5147488117218018,
-0.08430157601833344,
-0.08654842525720596,
0.9118162393569946,
0.4167834520339966,
0.3228229284286499,
0.43143776059150696,
-0.8603513836860657,
-0.4089534878730774,
-0.7295594811439514,
0.6034547090530396,
0.5782063603401184,
0.34087902307510376,
-0.11118060350418091,
0.43757736682891846,
0.2830081582069397,
0.542327344417572,
0.26141273975372314,
-0.42507490515708923,
-0.1655547022819519,
-0.21884919703006744,
0.2568543255329132,
0.07330290228128433,
0.7663604021072388,
0.5962506532669067,
0.355882853269577,
-0.49786874651908875,
-0.43126702308654785,
0.25250646471977234,
0.6651118397712708,
-0.4001169502735138,
-0.039496105164289474,
0.18278726935386658,
-0.014843002893030643,
-0.5088492035865784,
0.12409967929124832,
-0.6498706340789795,
-0.7591714262962341,
-0.3567541241645813,
0.47724342346191406,
-0.08146687597036362,
-0.060293469578027725,
-0.19448959827423096,
-0.21981343626976013,
0.5065165162086487,
0.25968673825263977,
-0.9500186443328857,
0.24616973102092743,
0.8748447895050049,
0.45661431550979614,
-0.3325093388557434,
-0.40751367807388306,
-0.7568897008895874,
0.14310596883296967,
-0.6613610982894897,
0.7612947821617126,
-0.05556408688426018,
-0.4087632894515991,
0.17720463871955872,
-0.22644901275634766,
-0.03605096787214279,
-0.47073906660079956,
0.2710478603839874,
-0.6778379678726196,
0.1956258863210678,
-0.45941340923309326,
-0.6212725639343262,
0.10487563908100128,
0.6340742707252502,
-0.4062650799751282,
0.7624974846839905,
0.015052800066769123,
-0.5316193699836731,
0.3808022439479828,
-0.39181432127952576,
-0.49303123354911804,
-0.08649405092000961,
-0.4477255642414093,
-0.7053197622299194,
-0.1673852801322937,
0.04976225271821022,
-0.013496150262653828,
-0.40425240993499756,
0.1692369431257248,
-0.2750430703163147,
-0.5803655982017517,
0.42264774441719055,
0.07638535648584366,
0.5350816249847412,
0.15188489854335785,
-0.4738391637802124,
0.6124840378761292,
-0.20652587711811066,
-0.017131146043539047,
0.23756945133209229,
-0.6748327016830444,
0.04824225977063179,
0.1935148686170578,
-0.43125057220458984,
0.14024411141872406,
0.035796236246824265,
-0.15711729228496552,
0.3078133463859558,
-0.43097928166389465,
0.148428812623024,
1.1040058135986328,
-0.02410442754626274,
0.8359570503234863,
-0.6686563491821289,
0.8404189348220825,
-0.10597576946020126,
0.09202715754508972,
0.23646879196166992,
-0.0886964350938797,
-0.3846297860145569,
-0.2495134323835373,
0.1292760670185089,
0.6657034158706665,
-0.9110416173934937,
0.3210905194282532,
-0.15503060817718506,
-0.034939270466566086,
-0.63567054271698,
0.15692415833473206,
0.6352659463882446,
0.5958958864212036,
0.1867946982383728,
-0.18130573630332947,
-0.4544956684112549,
-0.6799027323722839,
-0.1973579376935959,
-0.36206623911857605,
0.2837978005409241,
0.46641623973846436,
0.13433536887168884,
-0.19124871492385864,
0.7332141399383545,
-0.12527436017990112,
-0.3395971953868866,
-0.31602001190185547,
0.09235251694917679,
-0.14086778461933136,
0.30849164724349976,
0.3769272565841675,
-0.4172976613044739,
-0.5209059715270996,
0.022125476971268654,
-0.7530284523963928,
-0.05804872140288353,
-0.2747081518173218,
-0.277219295501709,
0.4117271304130554,
0.30654728412628174,
-0.3585982024669647,
0.20154641568660736,
0.31554171442985535,
-0.364055871963501,
0.42954233288764954,
-0.34004247188568115,
0.07026569545269012,
-0.7772530913352966,
-0.1526348739862442,
-0.24782168865203857,
-0.46103376150131226,
-0.5915820002555847,
0.2623859941959381,
-0.14014504849910736,
0.2017965167760849,
-0.14930124580860138,
0.6217871904373169,
-0.516060471534729,
-0.427791029214859,
-0.509028434753418,
0.6770849823951721,
-0.1884307563304901,
0.6201989650726318,
0.1316065937280655,
0.8915637731552124,
0.4363816976547241,
-0.6002891659736633,
0.4451960623264313,
0.1594066172838211,
-0.03549395129084587,
0.6782938838005066,
-0.475718230009079,
0.20681937038898468,
-0.27376481890678406,
0.21655768156051636,
-0.9864665269851685,
-0.09088428318500519,
0.4902329742908478,
-0.42374688386917114,
0.5148541331291199,
0.2335873246192932,
0.03765777498483658,
-0.1982431560754776,
-0.6161662340164185,
0.28302204608917236,
0.6604740619659424,
-0.7247681021690369,
0.5105658173561096,
0.6006373167037964,
0.24759924411773682,
-1.1120952367782593,
-0.3479406535625458,
-0.06548049300909042,
-0.3370632529258728,
-0.5077327489852905,
0.27754825353622437,
0.07400314509868622,
-0.36321720480918884,
0.06158241257071495,
-0.051705505698919296,
0.23546957969665527,
0.3760201334953308,
0.25396332144737244,
0.4521169662475586,
-0.1107916384935379,
0.046464595943689346,
-0.24756132066249847,
-0.256193071603775,
0.062467414885759354,
-0.41827908158302307,
0.33491837978363037,
0.01746124029159546,
-0.20754754543304443,
-0.4389619529247284,
0.27222391963005066,
0.020328115671873093,
0.10988941788673401,
0.49078452587127686,
0.4388177692890167,
-0.016619309782981873,
-0.2603071630001068,
-0.24898819625377655,
-0.2558252215385437,
-0.4201391041278839,
0.4508000314235687,
-0.30327340960502625,
-0.9428899884223938,
0.4066629409790039,
0.042016927152872086,
0.29665303230285645,
0.26277798414230347,
0.5856379270553589,
-0.3246331512928009,
1.2020576000213623,
0.47346606850624084,
-0.0967310443520546,
0.2790543735027313,
-0.10574795305728912,
-0.20165252685546875,
-0.5325506329536438,
-0.44440266489982605,
-0.36381715536117554,
-0.5221593976020813,
-0.5479220747947693,
-0.23476552963256836,
0.2449682354927063,
0.05270782858133316,
-0.5468184947967529,
0.2653246521949768,
-0.3588836193084717,
0.7513925433158875,
0.6569778919219971,
0.4273594319820404,
-0.061208948493003845,
-0.027675284072756767,
-0.3792813718318939,
-0.12233539670705795,
-0.7349050641059875,
-0.2508767545223236,
0.9438202977180481,
0.5036848783493042,
0.7424665093421936,
0.5337608456611633,
1.0491052865982056,
0.19385381042957306,
0.2655971646308899,
-0.8953849077224731,
0.26923665404319763,
0.18502211570739746,
-0.29732125997543335,
-0.4849289655685425,
-0.4729011356830597,
-1.163371205329895,
0.12304715067148209,
-0.3878633677959442,
-0.6539568305015564,
-0.05617361143231392,
0.24736692011356354,
-0.5805227160453796,
0.001700747525319457,
-0.12313121557235718,
0.8418506979942322,
-0.44009625911712646,
-0.6183830499649048,
-0.2599051892757416,
-1.0016310214996338,
0.4421520233154297,
0.32584336400032043,
0.10261086374521255,
0.05215659365057945,
-0.25789764523506165,
0.5845325589179993,
-0.2891633212566376,
0.5952191352844238,
-0.2921590209007263,
-0.35465818643569946,
0.3337603211402893,
-0.0608428530395031,
0.7535690665245056,
-0.0738542377948761,
0.3334505259990692,
-0.5418010950088501,
-0.3025479316711426,
-0.5655773282051086,
-0.5814638137817383,
0.4437568783760071,
-1.235107421875,
-0.6997007131576538,
-0.6371608376502991,
-0.7621456980705261,
-0.2749521732330322,
-0.1277868002653122,
0.237430140376091,
-0.06928770989179611,
-0.44485893845558167,
-0.3231525719165802,
0.8481445908546448,
-0.20499315857887268,
0.3224034309387207,
0.5785422325134277,
-0.05608903244137764,
-0.47337186336517334,
0.845565140247345,
-0.3054300844669342,
0.31406816840171814,
0.35143226385116577,
0.13449469208717346,
-0.5616705417633057,
-0.48701080679893494,
-0.47313937544822693,
0.21311770379543304,
-0.7090157270431519,
-0.2833622395992279,
-0.12283720821142197,
-0.02707812190055847,
-0.29183319211006165,
-0.22966568171977997,
-0.09967950731515884,
-0.07914654165506363,
-0.29137179255485535,
-0.08598411828279495,
-0.13225829601287842,
0.8729331493377686,
-0.48279428482055664,
0.3771427273750305,
-0.47877275943756104,
0.05587933212518692,
0.44495689868927,
-0.16639424860477448,
-0.1684086173772812,
-0.5476483106613159,
-0.07123364508152008,
-0.04376091808080673,
-0.436776340007782,
-1.034347414970398,
-0.009557305835187435,
0.02778690867125988,
0.6101568341255188,
0.5676544904708862,
0.033078279346227646,
0.5584002137184143,
-0.3440852761268616,
0.4925892949104309,
0.4193410277366638,
-0.5109864473342896,
0.19147980213165283,
-0.33068183064460754,
0.12223432958126068,
0.6684038639068604,
0.20259344577789307,
-0.5007772445678711,
-0.059626687318086624,
-0.3516991436481476,
-0.6518998146057129,
0.9973029494285583,
-0.17875413596630096,
-0.24634027481079102,
-0.010176850482821465,
0.3848206400871277,
-0.19071748852729797,
-0.05529365316033363,
-0.49097785353660583,
-0.15696337819099426,
0.18440119922161102,
-0.3283573389053345,
-0.1265103816986084,
-0.17410151660442352,
-0.7275226712226868,
0.22746430337429047,
0.892894983291626,
-0.16718032956123352,
0.16685864329338074,
-0.09659858047962189,
-0.25516873598098755,
-0.5494272708892822,
0.1491924375295639,
0.8889333605766296,
0.266296923160553,
0.10672954469919205,
0.24195680022239685,
0.07236875593662262,
0.06784956157207489,
0.5937284827232361,
0.14625735580921173,
-0.1886826455593109,
-0.56864994764328,
0.5023863911628723,
0.903540849685669,
0.25638875365257263,
-0.7968343496322632,
0.7292176485061646,
-0.13910940289497375,
-0.3848321735858917,
-0.050758086144924164,
0.24605131149291992,
0.04747084528207779,
0.8272915482521057,
-0.023379702121019363,
-0.17074058949947357,
-0.1598205715417862,
-0.6039623618125916,
0.4491577446460724,
0.8792404532432556,
-0.5637774467468262,
-0.09480419009923935,
0.6024268269538879,
0.050780393183231354,
-0.600045382976532,
0.5320072174072266,
-0.402822881937027,
-0.8592044711112976,
0.6956843137741089,
0.6512786149978638,
0.6886234879493713,
-0.09360365569591522,
0.46398767828941345,
0.3519207835197449,
0.08511859178543091,
-0.3341628313064575,
0.1741972267627716,
-0.1653454452753067,
-0.8541308045387268,
-0.1736425757408142,
-0.22311028838157654,
-0.44119659066200256,
-0.39677533507347107,
-0.594961941242218,
0.05064353346824646,
-0.5885620713233948,
-0.10817644745111465,
-0.2983754277229309,
0.30633315443992615,
-0.42572101950645447,
-0.20163308084011078,
0.11641772836446762,
0.23127232491970062,
-0.4890751540660858,
0.4718609154224396,
0.6122314929962158,
-0.5305419564247131,
-1.0086476802825928,
-0.12476067990064621,
0.4600708782672882,
-1.1929643154144287,
0.5155787467956543,
0.02312219701707363,
-0.18625549972057343,
-0.007652005646377802,
-0.5440471768379211,
-0.6044353246688843,
1.2689127922058105,
0.3828098177909851,
-0.6848253607749939,
-0.12282641977071762,
-0.0163174569606781,
0.43577784299850464,
-0.46657803654670715,
0.13515907526016235,
0.7478746771812439,
0.4657653868198395,
0.17521578073501587,
-0.5031638741493225,
0.05119127780199051,
0.09221605956554413,
-0.15905719995498657,
0.34698328375816345,
-0.5907840132713318,
0.6001141667366028,
-0.692328691482544,
-0.4078890085220337,
0.23631422221660614,
0.6552144885063171,
0.5888612866401672,
0.17530880868434906,
0.6217240691184998,
0.8378445506095886,
0.767663836479187,
-0.11646426469087601,
0.8738277554512024,
-0.08255501836538315,
0.33515459299087524,
1.1623607873916626,
-0.33282190561294556,
0.4058258533477783,
0.42241474986076355,
-0.24690473079681396,
0.39529526233673096,
0.8833341598510742,
0.043247465044260025,
0.6517267823219299,
0.5718079805374146,
-0.32675254344940186,
-0.35084807872772217,
-0.2551025152206421,
-0.08840824663639069,
0.16233199834823608,
-0.02357294224202633,
-0.06004530191421509,
-0.4477373957633972,
-0.3449886441230774,
0.06888965517282486,
0.5320178866386414,
-0.04990871250629425,
1.255232810974121,
-0.06950662285089493,
-1.1720601320266724,
0.3608570992946625,
-0.12648552656173706,
0.5765265226364136,
-0.49108943343162537,
0.06443003565073013,
-0.22620999813079834,
0.3905383348464966,
-0.011419719085097313,
-0.5738199949264526,
-0.09512221068143845,
-0.1558438241481781,
0.05373398959636688,
-0.03202807530760765,
0.4858654737472534,
-0.783304750919342,
0.2270849496126175,
0.5221575498580933,
0.3349897265434265,
-0.00869617611169815,
0.3762492835521698,
-0.8871299028396606,
-0.14333921670913696,
0.0028939431067556143,
-0.12398618459701538,
0.6194527745246887,
0.10243242979049683,
0.044102903455495834,
0.5054904818534851,
0.3632137179374695,
0.12330105900764465,
-0.0992431715130806,
-0.03109343722462654,
0.5842660665512085,
-0.49240365624427795,
-0.5921752452850342,
-0.9433169364929199,
0.3321273624897003,
-0.05203765258193016,
-0.1996924877166748,
0.32105496525764465,
0.17089037597179413,
0.5973585247993469,
0.35432830452919006,
0.6222261190414429,
0.330549418926239,
0.19197745621204376,
-0.5311243534088135,
0.32268059253692627,
-0.5732558369636536,
0.327798068523407,
0.14883525669574738,
-0.6686481237411499,
-0.1602737158536911,
0.6196734309196472,
-0.032182395458221436,
-0.16432493925094604,
0.4912469685077667,
0.8063161373138428,
0.41590872406959534,
-0.27281105518341064,
0.24394011497497559,
-0.18283820152282715,
0.3463241159915924,
1.0651556253433228,
1.0504093170166016,
-0.25856396555900574,
0.6263554692268372,
-0.11677874624729156,
-0.3180044889450073,
-0.07548432052135468,
-0.7201361060142517,
-1.0328162908554077,
-0.27330130338668823,
-0.15518973767757416,
-0.7461075186729431,
0.5551243424415588,
1.392290711402893,
0.31018203496932983,
-0.6707698702812195,
-0.4190693795681,
-0.16853836178779602,
0.4092079997062683,
-0.3441310226917267,
-0.20649296045303345,
0.2542846202850342,
-0.7766457200050354,
-0.42736631631851196,
0.5138460397720337,
0.14128899574279785,
0.16498781740665436,
-0.25400495529174805,
-0.8758671879768372,
-0.28747960925102234,
0.12892208993434906,
0.04476301744580269,
0.6689615845680237,
-0.7453269362449646,
-0.2611304819583893,
0.0845063328742981,
-0.4845980107784271,
0.03368845582008362,
0.7818148732185364,
-0.512532651424408,
0.3965955078601837,
0.33009427785873413,
1.1481266021728516,
0.24493415653705597,
0.37210750579833984,
0.8296559453010559,
-0.7643657922744751,
0.005557486787438393,
0.20325325429439545,
0.07626434415578842,
0.2485627979040146,
-0.4142126441001892,
0.60075843334198,
0.11280297487974167,
-0.8118402361869812,
-0.8406907916069031,
0.3673704266548157,
-0.6401592493057251,
-0.3474678099155426,
1.1118476390838623,
-0.40878424048423767,
-0.16785810887813568,
0.17116136848926544,
-0.12716752290725708,
0.4927537143230438,
-0.49384748935699463,
0.8596833944320679,
0.598888635635376,
-0.23013827204704285,
-0.11742949485778809,
0.06858037412166595,
0.8648854494094849,
0.6464232206344604,
-0.718546986579895,
-0.08194655179977417,
0.4476392865180969,
0.053549207746982574,
0.025783084332942963,
0.7161040306091309,
0.21475224196910858,
0.5707646012306213,
-0.09735191613435745,
-0.19578398764133453,
-0.007364238612353802,
-0.6047243475914001,
-0.7037575840950012,
-0.0031250198371708393,
0.24367786943912506,
-0.19219426810741425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10976v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10976v1 | Promoting Data and Model Privacy in Federated Learning through Quantized LoRA | 2024-06-16T15:23:07 | 2024-06-16T15:23:07 | JianHao Zhu, Changze Lv, Xiaohua Wang, Muling Wu, Wenhao Liu, Tianlong Li, Zixuan Ling, Cenyuan Zhang, Xiaoqing Zheng, Xuanjing Huang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | Conventional federated learning primarily aims to secure the privacy of data
distributed across multiple edge devices, with the global model dispatched to
edge devices for parameter updates during the learning process. However, the
development of large language models (LLMs) requires substantial data and
computational resources, rendering them valuable intellectual properties for
their developers and owners. To establish a mechanism that protects both data
and model privacy in a federated learning context, we introduce a method that
just needs to distribute a quantized version of the model's parameters during
training. This method enables accurate gradient estimations for parameter
updates while preventing clients from accessing a model whose performance is
comparable to the centrally hosted one. Moreover, we combine this quantization
strategy with LoRA, a popular and parameter-efficient fine-tuning method, to
significantly reduce communication costs in federated learning. The proposed
framework, named \textsc{FedLPP}, successfully ensures both data and model
privacy in the federated learning context. Additionally, the learned central
model exhibits good generalization and can be trained in a resource-efficient
manner. | [
-0.31305110454559326,
-0.7702237367630005,
0.1491866111755371,
0.16366693377494812,
-0.1423777937889099,
-0.04755617678165436,
-0.09699152410030365,
-0.45741406083106995,
-0.03194945305585861,
0.7054264545440674,
-0.5473938584327698,
-0.8849936723709106,
-0.13687340915203094,
-0.31901562213897705,
-0.44137802720069885,
1.1149520874023438,
0.18519732356071472,
-0.02084043063223362,
-0.36666765809059143,
-0.27516308426856995,
0.303871750831604,
-0.642016589641571,
-0.6770911812782288,
-0.4721246063709259,
0.7231488823890686,
0.15599270164966583,
0.6680969595909119,
0.7882870435714722,
0.47416332364082336,
0.25713053345680237,
-0.018162602558732033,
0.07474751770496368,
-0.4744105637073517,
0.18314732611179352,
-0.18117116391658783,
-0.8331813216209412,
-0.7738797664642334,
0.03703700378537178,
0.7716278433799744,
0.7181168794631958,
-0.49316272139549255,
0.24940510094165802,
0.014829810708761215,
0.9940809607505798,
-1.056226372718811,
0.2749313414096832,
-0.11844459176063538,
0.44048455357551575,
-0.08551549911499023,
-0.053796686232089996,
-0.4624435603618622,
-0.5681895613670349,
0.09966810792684555,
-0.5347785353660583,
0.09897918254137039,
-0.2640816271305084,
0.617610514163971,
0.27600327134132385,
-0.2918451428413391,
0.26434436440467834,
-0.7464163303375244,
0.5773284435272217,
-0.39565524458885193,
0.513607919216156,
0.5918271541595459,
0.3870907723903656,
0.07830782234668732,
-0.8281521201133728,
-0.12455105036497116,
0.2174733579158783,
0.01512092538177967,
-0.3522178828716278,
-0.5334323048591614,
0.20365607738494873,
0.29909834265708923,
0.5214836597442627,
-0.3410176932811737,
0.5317381620407104,
-0.05766706541180611,
-0.15706320106983185,
0.8003469705581665,
0.06822971999645233,
-0.2480422854423523,
0.39377981424331665,
-0.4943351447582245,
-0.32512491941452026,
-0.836367130279541,
0.13030290603637695,
0.5461540222167969,
0.5356031060218811,
-0.27182674407958984,
0.30645015835762024,
-0.7388126850128174,
0.6011636853218079,
0.23269663751125336,
-0.22083821892738342,
0.20091675221920013,
-0.0184781551361084,
-0.5777865052223206,
-0.2199421375989914,
0.8746361136436462,
-0.03747430443763733,
-0.108372263610363,
-0.3553519546985626,
-0.35848355293273926,
-0.15138526260852814,
-0.13069041073322296,
-1.0564452409744263,
0.06991992145776749,
0.17613163590431213,
-0.3061010539531708,
-0.43456268310546875,
-0.08772125095129013,
-0.7130903601646423,
-0.23773261904716492,
-0.17237570881843567,
0.3893122971057892,
-0.0348307266831398,
-0.10021050274372101,
0.20092931389808655,
0.35143977403640747,
0.09729690104722977,
0.08793656527996063,
-1.3687409162521362,
0.6395493745803833,
1.0556968450546265,
0.7148716449737549,
0.3019716143608093,
-0.17031562328338623,
-0.8615524172782898,
0.18478789925575256,
0.018295738846063614,
0.4267948269844055,
-0.3287198543548584,
-0.22763390839099884,
0.23842450976371765,
-0.14815407991409302,
0.09030797332525253,
-0.2057272046804428,
0.015394224785268307,
-0.8107149004936218,
0.403516560792923,
-0.1359448879957199,
-0.5981549024581909,
-0.11665242910385132,
0.09261298179626465,
-0.678316593170166,
0.42295876145362854,
0.17066901922225952,
-0.9201472997665405,
0.04824533313512802,
-0.7376055717468262,
-0.19133113324642181,
0.031510621309280396,
-0.22208012640476227,
-0.7775129079818726,
-0.015363681130111217,
0.4011669456958771,
0.7213249206542969,
-0.08696640282869339,
0.2600347697734833,
-0.36890125274658203,
-0.3453117609024048,
0.2341117411851883,
-0.31645438075065613,
0.9610751867294312,
0.21525123715400696,
-0.27636048197746277,
0.1396036297082901,
-0.6676443815231323,
0.23014210164546967,
0.04645923897624016,
-0.4793912172317505,
-0.49968504905700684,
-0.23303955793380737,
-0.3110564053058624,
-0.16477468609809875,
0.459026962518692,
-0.4097647964954376,
0.2521283030509949,
-0.5401282906532288,
0.4875633120536804,
0.8399118185043335,
-0.13702169060707092,
0.8446362018585205,
-0.30961543321609497,
0.5598840117454529,
-0.08170022815465927,
0.5989207029342651,
0.016862353309988976,
-0.13973809778690338,
-0.519943118095398,
-0.45507240295410156,
0.49393951892852783,
0.15564225614070892,
-0.5085209012031555,
0.3056662678718567,
-0.3078543543815613,
-0.4564337432384491,
-0.4374660551548004,
0.12468510866165161,
0.4668598175048828,
0.3461063504219055,
-0.061251673847436905,
0.07250689715147018,
-0.0980205237865448,
-0.7643744945526123,
0.08268015831708908,
0.0348363034427166,
-0.12956075370311737,
0.2957741916179657,
0.30252623558044434,
-0.3861866295337677,
1.0974996089935303,
-0.6290166974067688,
-0.47327759861946106,
0.12923307716846466,
-0.02684401161968708,
-0.12888240814208984,
0.6653059720993042,
0.602027952671051,
-0.9164758324623108,
-0.36682742834091187,
0.1082666888833046,
-0.7396382689476013,
0.0791793018579483,
0.38616466522216797,
-0.29006487131118774,
0.3697783052921295,
0.25384387373924255,
-0.41371312737464905,
0.38948506116867065,
0.9022415280342102,
-0.36411410570144653,
0.11003110557794571,
-0.19031894207000732,
-0.3216050863265991,
-1.0879006385803223,
0.08851662278175354,
-0.1749524474143982,
-0.5968579649925232,
-0.38425368070602417,
0.666251003742218,
-0.06274384260177612,
-0.4418671429157257,
-0.36960145831108093,
0.4764837622642517,
-0.11418715119361877,
-0.18289990723133087,
-0.1826673150062561,
0.05898259952664375,
0.09940911084413528,
0.5621991753578186,
0.019112512469291687,
0.6656811833381653,
0.7707429528236389,
-0.35610780119895935,
0.3657836318016052,
0.4060363173484802,
-0.035713884979486465,
0.8245404958724976,
-0.5197842717170715,
0.26095467805862427,
0.18160103261470795,
0.33410704135894775,
-0.10966785997152328,
-0.38191840052604675,
0.25769102573394775,
-0.22853140532970428,
-0.015517364256083965,
-0.11818014085292816,
-0.7144641876220703,
0.08963679522275925,
-0.21666055917739868,
0.25827866792678833,
0.4464191198348999,
-0.8443528413772583,
0.6384239792823792,
0.48204556107521057,
0.18127761781215668,
-0.8028378486633301,
-0.6627217531204224,
-0.3980931043624878,
-0.3485209047794342,
-0.7170894145965576,
0.21635468304157257,
-0.05158894136548042,
-0.2517552673816681,
-0.16927149891853333,
-0.06611872464418411,
-0.4488510489463806,
0.49972420930862427,
0.5158771276473999,
-0.09524133056402206,
-0.283009797334671,
0.18328262865543365,
0.18295727670192719,
-0.24054883420467377,
0.3240712285041809,
-0.5264297127723694,
0.500360906124115,
-0.3544788062572479,
-0.3467734158039093,
-0.5591909885406494,
0.3534284830093384,
0.17994903028011322,
-0.3824271559715271,
1.0688350200653076,
0.6551985144615173,
-0.506269633769989,
-0.6294789910316467,
-0.2688232660293579,
-0.4784199595451355,
-0.5514744520187378,
-0.11494231224060059,
-0.01935700885951519,
-1.2298753261566162,
0.6840277910232544,
-0.03150412067770958,
0.2308170348405838,
-0.0974007323384285,
0.31830233335494995,
0.011893325485289097,
0.7998968958854675,
1.3101938962936401,
-0.2793176770210266,
0.7345816493034363,
-0.38543498516082764,
0.07669021934270859,
-0.523802638053894,
-0.20936931669712067,
-0.4072634279727936,
-0.319083034992218,
-0.7672620415687561,
-0.18106555938720703,
0.32168006896972656,
0.026144031435251236,
-0.4005051553249359,
0.06773573160171509,
-0.3517225980758667,
0.6516960859298706,
0.9310221672058105,
0.5742775201797485,
0.5767025351524353,
0.2885836660861969,
0.12195184081792831,
0.20966432988643646,
-0.6165257096290588,
-0.09362024813890457,
1.2018945217132568,
0.5855289697647095,
0.9075734615325928,
0.1447295844554901,
1.097693681716919,
0.2754475474357605,
0.1172465831041336,
-0.5081585049629211,
0.6811078190803528,
-0.05304820463061333,
-0.4218817949295044,
-0.33255308866500854,
-0.8270182609558105,
-0.7075459957122803,
0.2840445041656494,
-0.14180053770542145,
-0.7536581754684448,
0.39963820576667786,
0.11862573772668839,
-0.6443561315536499,
0.3493260443210602,
-0.31499534845352173,
0.5479295253753662,
0.15517915785312653,
-0.5813127756118774,
-0.274610310792923,
-0.7038058638572693,
0.3567686080932617,
-0.23504813015460968,
-0.0942872166633606,
0.024789772927761078,
0.03814804553985596,
0.7938355803489685,
-0.7074486017227173,
1.0416381359100342,
-0.3250877857208252,
-0.33299458026885986,
0.04607674106955528,
-0.09292170405387878,
0.5306186676025391,
0.4036460816860199,
0.07163490355014801,
0.2855817675590515,
-0.29416048526763916,
-0.4812227487564087,
-0.48144012689590454,
0.8209894895553589,
-0.7544585466384888,
-0.6076735258102417,
-0.24978721141815186,
-0.6284772157669067,
-0.24106211960315704,
0.19544248282909393,
0.058092985302209854,
0.23783668875694275,
-0.027050765231251717,
0.41331061720848083,
0.9414993524551392,
-0.016792332753539085,
0.47207629680633545,
0.8667787313461304,
-0.29290860891342163,
-0.35134729743003845,
0.7286688089370728,
-0.16258087754249573,
0.5070027709007263,
0.4969165325164795,
0.3329910337924957,
-0.07134483009576797,
-0.359533429145813,
0.18025124073028564,
0.38791632652282715,
-0.8206977844238281,
-0.47532328963279724,
-0.47349345684051514,
-0.3916700482368469,
-0.21052980422973633,
-0.3108236491680145,
-0.5933090448379517,
-0.440234899520874,
-0.5093328952789307,
-0.26145288348197937,
0.5818870663642883,
0.09235461056232452,
-0.584472119808197,
0.8153745532035828,
-0.5226761102676392,
-0.02984010800719261,
0.5122214555740356,
0.5979640483856201,
-0.11323907971382141,
-0.10108226537704468,
-0.4509798586368561,
0.3587455153465271,
-0.09210050851106644,
-0.053598083555698395,
0.2605874836444855,
0.27546679973602295,
0.032375894486904144,
0.7166262269020081,
0.31230300664901733,
0.37788769602775574,
-0.22562779486179352,
0.36593201756477356,
-0.05013946816325188,
-1.0032004117965698,
0.538613498210907,
-0.42476239800453186,
0.11328937113285065,
0.4170151352882385,
0.18860067427158356,
-0.21709883213043213,
-0.32954683899879456,
-0.7743715643882751,
-0.5393664240837097,
0.6681612730026245,
-0.0569821372628212,
0.3038235902786255,
0.45009443163871765,
0.2325831800699234,
0.00686310650780797,
0.3818913698196411,
-0.9083071947097778,
-0.24789629876613617,
0.02351977862417698,
0.0663035586476326,
0.26597556471824646,
-0.0025696672964841127,
-0.651078999042511,
0.0879676416516304,
0.4880676865577698,
-0.3063959777355194,
0.21145087480545044,
-0.27351921796798706,
0.2885873019695282,
-0.2017446756362915,
0.09154631197452545,
0.37535881996154785,
0.5403192639350891,
-0.1801372915506363,
-0.14153717458248138,
-0.3163416385650635,
-0.46938541531562805,
0.0704726129770279,
0.5275818109512329,
-0.4901520311832428,
-0.15569661557674408,
0.13624510169029236,
0.7998613715171814,
0.29043179750442505,
-0.4537964463233948,
0.6415178775787354,
-0.14412705600261688,
-0.30855998396873474,
-0.21160383522510529,
0.3902145326137543,
0.011888335458934307,
0.6835609674453735,
0.18721596896648407,
-0.09970265626907349,
-0.09597493708133698,
-0.1555047631263733,
0.21577028930187225,
0.5284353494644165,
-0.2074708491563797,
-0.44272366166114807,
0.8261471390724182,
0.34900811314582825,
-0.21028508245944977,
0.6049425601959229,
0.15367867052555084,
-0.11731192469596863,
0.3034800589084625,
0.34495317935943604,
0.7680948376655579,
-0.4593870937824249,
0.6484790444374084,
-0.05069044604897499,
-0.0323018915951252,
-0.2708560824394226,
0.20073682069778442,
-0.4940519630908966,
-0.5156578421592712,
-0.06123435124754906,
-0.5913272500038147,
-0.5338415503501892,
0.004163621459156275,
-1.0819613933563232,
-0.05921374261379242,
-0.8841190934181213,
-0.18448969721794128,
-0.17932681739330292,
0.15654073655605316,
-0.48357436060905457,
-0.023047031834721565,
0.30243706703186035,
0.7773171663284302,
-0.8246033191680908,
1.0164587497711182,
0.10949172079563141,
-0.3745183050632477,
-0.6132107973098755,
-0.2900550961494446,
-0.2845908999443054,
-0.6920278668403625,
0.6396262645721436,
-0.128769651055336,
0.04849083721637726,
0.16126251220703125,
-0.7642858028411865,
-0.6774725317955017,
1.2625237703323364,
0.6142167448997498,
-0.7844395041465759,
-0.18913154304027557,
0.5040828585624695,
0.6230429410934448,
-0.24615325033664703,
-0.4014495015144348,
0.23669831454753876,
0.06586655974388123,
-0.09901247173547745,
-0.591516375541687,
-0.0939728170633316,
0.3744746148586273,
-0.35446348786354065,
0.2814415693283081,
-0.8076049089431763,
0.984134316444397,
-0.2384474128484726,
-0.40413698554039,
-0.13995113968849182,
0.8820542097091675,
0.1282084733247757,
0.44717493653297424,
0.23091214895248413,
0.5478555560112,
1.1113022565841675,
-0.017992936074733734,
0.8528178930282593,
-0.16559763252735138,
0.6801236867904663,
1.1739486455917358,
-0.3039857745170593,
0.967359721660614,
0.4570370316505432,
-0.04029122740030289,
0.2488444447517395,
0.4328155517578125,
0.08856304734945297,
0.8501401543617249,
0.04305462911725044,
-0.6906914114952087,
0.013514909893274307,
-0.20179319381713867,
-0.3357914984226227,
0.4055343270301819,
0.2301987260580063,
-0.6020617485046387,
-0.3907896876335144,
0.30170947313308716,
0.2920006513595581,
0.13424520194530487,
-0.47045546770095825,
0.7621718645095825,
0.2384253740310669,
-0.001904125907458365,
0.6241503357887268,
0.046896930783987045,
0.4142725169658661,
-0.6893726587295532,
0.3042336702346802,
-0.5821728706359863,
0.3718070685863495,
-0.27370625734329224,
-0.31115588545799255,
0.2258191704750061,
0.07482678443193436,
-0.20131923258304596,
-0.22046223282814026,
0.13571348786354065,
-0.4609473943710327,
-0.3095855712890625,
0.28894591331481934,
0.42694661021232605,
-0.3152945637702942,
-0.1096336841583252,
-0.5455840229988098,
-0.004328847862780094,
-0.21097517013549805,
-0.26471030712127686,
0.7551262974739075,
0.3152730464935303,
-0.0811108946800232,
0.9463812112808228,
0.6079033017158508,
-0.12444152683019638,
-0.21784661710262299,
0.02013656124472618,
1.1126298904418945,
-0.15455833077430725,
-0.8129133582115173,
-0.8670496940612793,
0.1414465606212616,
0.07336072623729706,
-0.07749271392822266,
0.7553188800811768,
0.28599491715431213,
0.99555903673172,
0.10525231063365936,
0.47685593366622925,
0.23303870856761932,
0.2072272002696991,
-0.612952709197998,
1.0183957815170288,
-0.28130796551704407,
0.40833890438079834,
0.05791835859417915,
-0.8752729296684265,
-0.35440292954444885,
0.5622139573097229,
-0.22078686952590942,
-0.3192193806171417,
0.4010324776172638,
0.6753589510917664,
-0.17136313021183014,
0.167000874876976,
0.313996821641922,
0.07685694098472595,
0.30661705136299133,
0.6011890769004822,
0.3523954153060913,
-0.5461961030960083,
0.08179578185081482,
-0.7567482590675354,
-0.07352828979492188,
-0.13920524716377258,
-0.7732459306716919,
-1.094649314880371,
-0.5138909220695496,
-0.544479489326477,
-0.11346616595983505,
0.18238382041454315,
0.7011712193489075,
0.8861401677131653,
-0.5039608478546143,
-0.1468372493982315,
-0.1000339686870575,
0.21214744448661804,
-0.2865212857723236,
-0.16388723254203796,
0.44648686051368713,
0.06633199751377106,
-0.6517001986503601,
0.27648016810417175,
0.0500025674700737,
0.1780567467212677,
-0.734775185585022,
0.03885463997721672,
0.0781969204545021,
-0.1270935982465744,
0.28583139181137085,
0.4031849801540375,
-0.35997435450553894,
-0.051427315920591354,
-0.20044751465320587,
-0.19452670216560364,
0.011521474458277225,
0.5752993226051331,
-0.891508162021637,
0.15760326385498047,
0.2537913918495178,
0.7493367195129395,
0.28147947788238525,
0.2029171586036682,
0.5805111527442932,
-1.0539329051971436,
0.41405442357063293,
0.2316056787967682,
0.12215772271156311,
0.3829607665538788,
-0.6414786577224731,
0.649883508682251,
-0.05300269275903702,
-0.7322307229042053,
-1.1227442026138306,
0.04233688488602638,
-0.6966527104377747,
0.02095792256295681,
0.7680767178535461,
-0.684201717376709,
-0.4297561049461365,
0.5039069652557373,
0.3917549252510071,
-0.023303277790546417,
-0.4131796360015869,
0.8099365830421448,
0.19124194979667664,
0.2643115222454071,
-0.06445050239562988,
-0.3266620934009552,
0.6314606666564941,
-0.049352556467056274,
-0.9534965753555298,
0.3201977014541626,
0.4149051606655121,
0.14581061899662018,
-0.07733254134654999,
0.3993678689002991,
0.15883615612983704,
0.19484256207942963,
-0.1327688843011856,
-0.11417707800865173,
-0.2869517207145691,
-0.3425319790840149,
-0.7023102045059204,
0.272123783826828,
-0.2915101945400238,
-0.4080393612384796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10974v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10974v1 | Towards Supporting Legal Argumentation with NLP: Is More Data Really All You Need? | 2024-06-16T15:15:44 | 2024-06-16T15:15:44 | T. Y. S. S Santosh, Kevin D. Ashley, Katie Atkinson, Matthias Grabmair | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Modeling legal reasoning and argumentation justifying decisions in cases has
always been central to AI & Law, yet contemporary developments in legal NLP
have increasingly focused on statistically classifying legal conclusions from
text. While conceptually simpler, these approaches often fall short in
providing usable justifications connecting to appropriate legal concepts. This
paper reviews both traditional symbolic works in AI & Law and recent advances
in legal NLP, and distills possibilities of integrating expert-informed
knowledge to strike a balance between scalability and explanation in symbolic
vs. data-driven approaches. We identify open challenges and discuss the
potential of modern NLP models and methods that integrate | [
-0.20317009091377258,
-0.6967304944992065,
0.789912223815918,
0.1254424750804901,
-0.3067464828491211,
-0.32328277826309204,
-0.04342925548553467,
-0.6915355920791626,
0.02806083858013153,
0.42890384793281555,
-0.2245146930217743,
-0.19976700842380524,
-0.6186044216156006,
-0.02482449635863304,
-0.39086979627609253,
1.0071214437484741,
0.14506582915782928,
0.5101785659790039,
-0.756895124912262,
-0.6058239936828613,
-0.7673169374465942,
-0.9971221685409546,
-0.9922569990158081,
-0.2903721332550049,
0.4512137770652771,
0.13606101274490356,
0.8624520301818848,
0.825567364692688,
0.3707684576511383,
0.2701827883720398,
-0.0929856151342392,
-0.0885743796825409,
0.13348864018917084,
0.4121803641319275,
-0.21109285950660706,
-0.6262362003326416,
-0.229856938123703,
-0.06991808861494064,
0.3062017858028412,
0.5631427764892578,
-0.2867186963558197,
0.027147658169269562,
-0.6546755433082581,
0.631940484046936,
-0.4798111617565155,
0.14395292103290558,
-0.5441320538520813,
0.3931117653846741,
-0.02924477495253086,
0.06744913756847382,
-0.5224365592002869,
-0.22984106838703156,
0.22954969108104706,
-0.5741124749183655,
-0.23678244650363922,
0.14787040650844574,
0.8331177234649658,
0.6604493856430054,
-0.5557228326797485,
-0.5426363945007324,
-0.7063201069831848,
0.6007217168807983,
-0.998227059841156,
0.38258811831474304,
0.13100174069404602,
0.5779158473014832,
0.07191344350576401,
-0.9518361687660217,
-0.6078944206237793,
-0.5586278438568115,
0.019432255998253822,
0.17705249786376953,
-0.5027949810028076,
-0.007907940074801445,
0.5076345801353455,
-0.24377770721912384,
-0.3193626403808594,
0.34874120354652405,
-0.15945811569690704,
0.02163565717637539,
0.9471436738967896,
-0.044223885983228683,
0.2481943964958191,
-0.12724409997463226,
0.029392177239060402,
-0.06352309882640839,
-0.553716242313385,
-0.0655239149928093,
0.4189870357513428,
0.1087924912571907,
0.010961147956550121,
0.7579312324523926,
0.28714004158973694,
0.6228451132774353,
0.09823738038539886,
0.26149240136146545,
-0.20799194276332855,
-0.1623045653104782,
-0.19845803081989288,
0.465821772813797,
0.9753194451332092,
0.19763244688510895,
0.4811614155769348,
0.1191776841878891,
0.034953873604536057,
-0.14024297893047333,
0.5081955790519714,
-0.4378822147846222,
0.046524375677108765,
0.6554401516914368,
-0.6679002046585083,
-0.0503254197537899,
0.08696717768907547,
-0.6705211400985718,
-0.8088926076889038,
-0.6306442618370056,
-0.1982099711894989,
-0.3080636262893677,
-0.23528234660625458,
0.5873385667800903,
-0.5828589797019958,
0.31531772017478943,
0.5346221923828125,
-0.778010904788971,
0.26527056097984314,
0.9160045385360718,
0.6647148728370667,
0.3061361610889435,
0.17888867855072021,
-0.4194074869155884,
0.27483442425727844,
-0.6400009393692017,
1.037545919418335,
-0.5931258201599121,
0.025941679254174232,
0.08778943866491318,
-0.2538452744483948,
0.08655137568712234,
-0.5286970138549805,
1.0567500591278076,
-0.48014047741889954,
0.09877120703458786,
-0.347771018743515,
-0.5815646648406982,
-0.514343798160553,
0.09600400924682617,
-0.8683094382286072,
0.669456422328949,
-0.21971428394317627,
-0.5881490111351013,
1.0411179065704346,
-1.0235031843185425,
-0.6876717209815979,
0.4147728383541107,
-0.5943790078163147,
-0.6030677556991577,
0.2913013994693756,
0.1875961571931839,
0.4919513463973999,
-0.28985974192619324,
0.827915370464325,
-0.5765324234962463,
0.27635496854782104,
0.009766336530447006,
-0.326614111661911,
1.2770397663116455,
0.41323164105415344,
-0.3486814498901367,
0.1617189347743988,
-0.608012855052948,
-0.17322711646556854,
0.1132594496011734,
-0.10540267825126648,
-0.2593025267124176,
0.703650176525116,
-0.12178561091423035,
0.32821962237358093,
0.047357071191072464,
-0.3301561772823334,
0.07603210210800171,
-0.2938331663608551,
0.48708102107048035,
0.4866819977760315,
-0.3455235958099365,
0.389495849609375,
-0.2351245880126953,
0.638280987739563,
-0.17506185173988342,
-0.06039642170071602,
0.2777673006057739,
-0.743966281414032,
-0.5096897482872009,
-0.024192338809370995,
0.4404372572898865,
0.5782567262649536,
-0.3105361759662628,
0.44622233510017395,
-0.24145923554897308,
-0.21644046902656555,
-0.6234756112098694,
-0.18534041941165924,
-0.23166990280151367,
0.25128495693206787,
0.33441847562789917,
0.19374606013298035,
-0.9959772229194641,
-0.860727846622467,
-0.4277564287185669,
-0.6131843328475952,
-0.14170272648334503,
0.500900387763977,
0.5175742506980896,
0.05421047657728195,
1.2769830226898193,
0.08173204213380814,
-0.08919783681631088,
-0.7170249223709106,
0.07059090584516525,
0.31069257855415344,
0.3203023076057434,
0.8958666324615479,
-0.8906019926071167,
-0.28391262888908386,
0.48155954480171204,
-1.150300145149231,
-0.32207411527633667,
-0.6821261644363403,
-0.036054402589797974,
-0.0029242602176964283,
0.5484684705734253,
-1.0334675312042236,
0.30737441778182983,
-0.252371609210968,
-0.5254842042922974,
0.5898600816726685,
-0.13769271969795227,
-0.24165582656860352,
-0.8562101125717163,
-0.17855294048786163,
0.4740707278251648,
-0.49985262751579285,
-0.7068015933036804,
0.2969917953014374,
-0.2579827904701233,
0.11229926347732544,
-0.4119657576084137,
0.44775301218032837,
-0.13934028148651123,
0.14958514273166656,
-0.2831595838069916,
0.018322721123695374,
-0.05706499516963959,
-0.12143587321043015,
0.21173131465911865,
0.15381577610969543,
0.5323087573051453,
-0.368116170167923,
0.785682201385498,
0.00905173271894455,
0.08436216413974762,
0.8941059708595276,
-0.8000969290733337,
-0.26596707105636597,
-0.23002436757087708,
0.4694380462169647,
-0.3338710069656372,
-0.317531019449234,
0.3575846552848816,
-0.17379051446914673,
0.16963672637939453,
-0.7375501394271851,
-0.5048878192901611,
-0.4572811424732208,
-0.129142627120018,
0.2948412299156189,
0.2557453215122223,
-0.35660696029663086,
0.9289201498031616,
0.5946006178855896,
-0.1478462815284729,
-0.5873657464981079,
-0.5931140780448914,
0.5403813123703003,
-0.7106224894523621,
-0.5365937352180481,
0.11994079500436783,
0.35546186566352844,
-0.9718117117881775,
-0.021063825115561485,
0.1176702007651329,
-0.23215140402317047,
0.14322306215763092,
0.2220294326543808,
-0.12164416164159775,
-0.4810742437839508,
0.44054141640663147,
0.1898103803396225,
-0.23509715497493744,
0.706085205078125,
-0.41124704480171204,
0.19857251644134521,
-0.12979231774806976,
-0.614154577255249,
-0.5638887882232666,
0.7504311203956604,
0.45170822739601135,
0.19200685620307922,
0.43731048703193665,
0.13100586831569672,
-0.47289949655532837,
-0.045185819268226624,
-0.5975504517555237,
0.13708966970443726,
-0.37667834758758545,
0.31381264328956604,
-0.11150731146335602,
-0.6350004076957703,
0.19343671202659607,
-0.10101765394210815,
0.7225080132484436,
0.8286848068237305,
0.6794835329055786,
-0.29746711254119873,
1.182937502861023,
0.38878071308135986,
-0.0917171761393547,
0.17572981119155884,
0.13099461793899536,
0.5591451525688171,
-0.12677493691444397,
-0.08140221238136292,
-0.8135359287261963,
-0.04062788560986519,
-0.4462426006793976,
-0.0968744233250618,
-0.1961885243654251,
0.1250615119934082,
-0.27715134620666504,
0.2670471668243408,
-0.4699259102344513,
0.4891366958618164,
0.39134153723716736,
-0.1584651619195938,
0.22777806222438812,
-0.26696115732192993,
0.176469624042511,
0.13775427639484406,
-0.901787519454956,
-0.7666429877281189,
0.8752583861351013,
0.610823929309845,
0.3510497212409973,
0.10747148841619492,
0.33055242896080017,
0.4342232644557953,
0.03360214829444885,
-1.0208855867385864,
0.57969731092453,
-0.24334625899791718,
-0.7609509229660034,
-0.16679778695106506,
-0.26755571365356445,
-0.8538627624511719,
0.2854006886482239,
-0.4426227807998657,
-0.5223496556282043,
0.10576731711626053,
-0.024183297529816628,
-0.6292974352836609,
0.21203117072582245,
-0.6043069958686829,
0.7380259037017822,
-0.36710453033447266,
-0.11782320588827133,
-0.2527184784412384,
-0.5991695523262024,
0.18824957311153412,
0.05763181298971176,
0.3425624668598175,
-0.18588513135910034,
0.1897086501121521,
1.1164230108261108,
-0.8716557025909424,
0.6556478142738342,
-0.18150779604911804,
-0.12609419226646423,
0.5406051278114319,
-0.4368775188922882,
0.2571031451225281,
0.25195664167404175,
-0.21991591155529022,
-0.04896170273423195,
0.4041140079498291,
-0.2756870985031128,
-0.7693690061569214,
0.29417189955711365,
-0.35604628920555115,
-0.856452226638794,
-0.35383203625679016,
-0.5654377937316895,
0.04658782482147217,
0.023770775645971298,
-0.19807937741279602,
-0.025006700307130814,
0.3716370463371277,
0.3212219178676605,
0.4451439082622528,
0.1354907751083374,
0.4883701503276825,
0.2082415521144867,
0.20332825183868408,
-0.25510692596435547,
0.7648440599441528,
0.2051001638174057,
-0.47633668780326843,
-0.023324402049183846,
0.5843274593353271,
-0.694786548614502,
-0.6940457224845886,
-0.5743117332458496,
0.24836678802967072,
-1.0238924026489258,
-0.029965201392769814,
-0.7264757752418518,
0.03227727860212326,
-0.38251441717147827,
-0.3034062385559082,
-0.25380992889404297,
-0.7883589267730713,
-0.17196394503116608,
-0.3628655672073364,
0.6447115540504456,
0.8971608877182007,
-0.061626747250556946,
0.035150427371263504,
-0.5913974642753601,
0.16944211721420288,
0.2517894208431244,
0.1597079038619995,
-0.2060495913028717,
-0.3507378399372101,
0.02236921153962612,
0.007077143527567387,
-0.09523957222700119,
-0.9639298915863037,
0.04597723111510277,
-0.02547927014529705,
0.6603655219078064,
0.5697249174118042,
-0.012557893991470337,
0.8318297266960144,
-0.6306267380714417,
0.9295896887779236,
0.20903673768043518,
-0.701360285282135,
0.5748578906059265,
-0.08363371342420578,
-0.24608466029167175,
0.5563855767250061,
0.4339219033718109,
-0.3811797499656677,
-0.16923277080059052,
-0.5531832575798035,
-0.7630081176757812,
0.3720897138118744,
-0.06497452408075333,
0.2792607545852661,
0.09783938527107239,
0.6833798289299011,
0.10774455219507217,
-0.04761742800474167,
-1.0385894775390625,
0.15714935958385468,
-0.1675483137369156,
-0.45762452483177185,
0.4130733907222748,
0.09168389439582825,
-0.31132006645202637,
-0.5772941708564758,
0.37496417760849,
-0.16964465379714966,
-0.014418533071875572,
-0.11526384949684143,
-0.03864222392439842,
0.31230682134628296,
0.12285376340150833,
0.442340224981308,
0.6504104733467102,
0.3201211094856262,
-0.05331074073910713,
0.24335910379886627,
-0.2269812524318695,
0.14884133636951447,
0.07817929983139038,
-0.06994765996932983,
0.3780631124973297,
0.7223397493362427,
0.6986376047134399,
-0.3243313133716583,
-0.7392616271972656,
0.5299480557441711,
-0.06970258057117462,
-0.6987797617912292,
-0.5055371522903442,
0.04034965857863426,
0.19794872403144836,
0.5923997759819031,
0.18493622541427612,
-0.12190450727939606,
0.035895850509405136,
-0.4551447629928589,
0.33771032094955444,
0.6169130206108093,
-0.2835688591003418,
0.17684771120548248,
0.9130975604057312,
-0.055544931441545486,
-0.2263210564851761,
0.33863651752471924,
0.2609453499317169,
-0.25794246792793274,
0.8703773021697998,
0.2383517622947693,
0.8458411693572998,
0.33798959851264954,
0.09951870143413544,
0.18707837164402008,
0.033876288682222366,
-0.3828643262386322,
0.18558867275714874,
-0.34961146116256714,
-0.5067209005355835,
-0.5925180912017822,
-0.24482356011867523,
-0.48618435859680176,
-0.03144808113574982,
-0.37210625410079956,
0.276899516582489,
-0.5847695469856262,
-0.23869191110134125,
0.1900383085012436,
-0.17315784096717834,
-0.31770455837249756,
0.1148877739906311,
0.01908109523355961,
0.8884873986244202,
-0.8552577495574951,
0.5701941251754761,
0.7555003762245178,
-0.5811967849731445,
-0.48037442564964294,
-0.20449614524841309,
0.03338330611586571,
-0.3352884352207184,
0.5926217436790466,
0.011237617582082748,
-0.026053955778479576,
-0.34922632575035095,
-0.8975606560707092,
-0.3172442317008972,
0.6453903913497925,
0.5711225867271423,
-0.27626118063926697,
-0.058999910950660706,
0.33265379071235657,
0.7770564556121826,
-0.4000657796859741,
0.47348085045814514,
0.591496467590332,
0.7987204194068909,
0.20747709274291992,
-0.21740299463272095,
0.014933809638023376,
-0.413888156414032,
-0.2414456009864807,
-0.17117609083652496,
0.04133071377873421,
0.42023494839668274,
-0.19869375228881836,
-0.32920747995376587,
-0.30931970477104187,
0.751792848110199,
0.16154316067695618,
0.5106642246246338,
0.45760664343833923,
0.7298047542572021,
0.6790485382080078,
-0.2227417379617691,
1.1544054746627808,
-0.0344257690012455,
-0.059355344623327255,
1.072019100189209,
-0.38280123472213745,
0.6944183707237244,
0.5302592515945435,
-0.28893259167671204,
0.4834483563899994,
0.8210553526878357,
-0.34414196014404297,
-0.13922137022018433,
0.3633476793766022,
-0.1386764943599701,
-0.5264686942100525,
-0.30253124237060547,
-0.06888365745544434,
0.30706751346588135,
0.37577104568481445,
-0.14508067071437836,
-0.22442686557769775,
-0.3124906122684479,
0.16996882855892181,
0.15158022940158844,
-0.05629914999008179,
1.0686776638031006,
0.08722575753927231,
-0.6794003248214722,
0.1998036950826645,
0.0014328756369650364,
0.2317766398191452,
-0.3331100642681122,
-0.16665290296077728,
0.14132387936115265,
-0.33360230922698975,
-0.48383665084838867,
-1.0707511901855469,
0.5916165709495544,
0.35612866282463074,
-0.10496380925178528,
-0.35923048853874207,
0.5093239545822144,
0.10381226986646652,
-0.3720984160900116,
0.18861545622348785,
0.4049941897392273,
0.2711906135082245,
0.0302626620978117,
-0.9382091164588928,
-0.30112743377685547,
-0.2876444458961487,
-0.2366422563791275,
0.1377345472574234,
0.6499192714691162,
-0.40055328607559204,
0.8068276643753052,
0.7537460327148438,
0.23307910561561584,
0.24796925485134125,
0.45643922686576843,
0.590624213218689,
-0.6185583472251892,
-0.3300628960132599,
-1.2006090879440308,
0.5717947483062744,
-0.5065418481826782,
-0.09132536500692368,
0.39718201756477356,
0.29569312930107117,
0.4048481285572052,
0.19725625216960907,
0.8783168792724609,
-0.24644969403743744,
0.11521577090024948,
-0.6710106134414673,
0.6163150072097778,
-0.4183903634548187,
0.1408853828907013,
-0.031190643087029457,
-0.4965573251247406,
-0.6897194385528564,
0.8201679587364197,
-0.20697006583213806,
-0.05794886499643326,
0.4480673372745514,
0.12215342372655869,
-0.04049024358391762,
0.33124107122421265,
0.18547497689723969,
-0.130595400929451,
0.643004298210144,
0.4199085533618927,
0.9202155470848083,
-0.18328353762626648,
0.42443251609802246,
0.11871086061000824,
0.05390167236328125,
-0.15993142127990723,
-1.08495032787323,
-0.7176318168640137,
-0.3054417669773102,
-0.4451707899570465,
-0.0006199536146596074,
-0.20752210915088654,
0.8327198624610901,
0.8031758069992065,
-0.8475627303123474,
-0.30132243037223816,
-0.670574963092804,
0.34487828612327576,
-0.3085211217403412,
-0.19868724048137665,
0.18219076097011566,
-0.6507045030593872,
-0.447833389043808,
0.3351902365684509,
0.23662744462490082,
-0.05561262369155884,
0.03983408212661743,
-0.03204786777496338,
-0.3471880853176117,
0.4373181462287903,
0.7144668102264404,
0.5423198938369751,
-0.8237287998199463,
-0.15330971777439117,
-0.717606246471405,
0.21627874672412872,
0.33164072036743164,
0.9995297193527222,
-0.47552725672721863,
0.30688363313674927,
0.5854233503341675,
0.9258811473846436,
0.04254787415266037,
0.0729135125875473,
0.8963720202445984,
-0.2813918888568878,
0.11152096092700958,
0.5442149043083191,
0.834886372089386,
-0.17873334884643555,
-0.2752888798713684,
0.5803169012069702,
0.06412513554096222,
-0.31420189142227173,
-0.7689501643180847,
0.30431604385375977,
-0.8513255715370178,
-0.5038489103317261,
0.9372662305831909,
-0.2513682246208191,
-0.04895582050085068,
-0.5280885696411133,
-0.17658036947250366,
0.07388090342283249,
-0.3273369073867798,
0.7328273057937622,
1.008963704109192,
-0.25247451663017273,
-0.3413785994052887,
-0.9680498838424683,
0.5820509791374207,
0.508213460445404,
-1.2133127450942993,
0.2363705039024353,
0.6759493350982666,
-0.3419439494609833,
0.3643622100353241,
0.22905994951725006,
-0.13849560916423798,
0.40794721245765686,
0.11779072135686874,
-0.28655654191970825,
0.18420594930648804,
-0.32300636172294617,
-0.46027353405952454,
0.4074263572692871,
0.02635510452091694,
0.2993885278701782
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.