discourse_id
stringlengths
12
12
essay_id
stringlengths
12
12
discourse_text
stringlengths
4
4.1k
discourse_type
stringclasses
7 values
discourse_effectiveness
stringclasses
3 values
202691953ec7
95EE2E824EB6
our county administrators might fail to see the real outcome of this decision.
Rebuttal
Adequate
b7890d945801
9604D30A25AB
In German suburb's, life goes on without cars. There is a new experimental district, that allows people to see how much you don't need a car for. The new district without any cars, has stores and malls in walking distance. so there is no need for a car. Which can save a person lots of money. People have sold there cars to live in this new district. But if you moved with a car, when you buy a house. And a 40,000 dollar large garage on the edge of the development. The residents also say that not having a car is a lot less to worry about. And the Unite States is promoting car reduced communities. Paris bands driving due to smog, Paris was forced to enforce a partial driving Ban. When days of near record pollution was getting higher. If u were cought breaking the band you would be fined. They lifted the band when the smog cleard enough. Paris has more smog than any other European Capital. But diesel fuel was blamed, cause they have a tax policy that goes for diesel over regular gasoline. Although Beijing, China is the most polluted citie in the worlde. Car-Free day is spinning into a big hit in Bogota. Car free day, is when no cars are allowed on the road except buss's and taxis's. People walked, biked and, road bikes. Other Colombian cities are joining the year around event. People from different countrys came to see this event, and were enthusiastic about it. The end of car culture, people have been buying and driving less in the past years. The amount people drive now is what it was in 1995. Also there as been a large drop in people geting there permintas and licenses, from 16 years old to 39 years old. And people have been taking public tranporstion and car-pooling more.
Evidence
Ineffective
6b6c36505696
9615F113FAA1
My principal has decided that all students must participate in at least one extracurricular activity. I disagree with my principal
Position
Adequate
c4f111f999cc
9615F113FAA1
you cant force anyone,
Claim
Adequate
257f02ddee51
9615F113FAA1
they can do whatever they want
Claim
Adequate
bd3a5f1debf8
9615F113FAA1
some people are not best doing extracurricular activity.
Claim
Adequate
dadcac97b9bb
9615F113FAA1
Forcing someone is not good because you cant tell someone do things that they couldnt do.
Claim
Adequate
637480db4229
9615F113FAA1
Some people dont like playing sports, working the yearbook, or serve on the student council. Not everyone have the same opinion, but many people have different opinion. Forcing an students to do something probably make them feel that they have no rights.
Evidence
Adequate
1cde35909319
9615F113FAA1
The students should decide what they should do, not the principal because students should get their own opinions
Claim
Adequate
5d432e48d713
9615F113FAA1
Letting the principal decide the students what to do, make me feel not very good because it make me feel like he is telling me what to do and i dont like that.
Evidence
Ineffective
460094620bce
9615F113FAA1
Some other people are not good at doing sports or working the year. Some people are different from others.
Claim
Adequate
c5da428af3fa
9615F113FAA1
Some students are best other things and some are not. Many students have their own taste on something.
Evidence
Ineffective
f3e4c0510e82
9615F113FAA1
I disagree what is the principal is saying because they cant forcing any the student, the students should decided they own, and some people are not best doing extracurricular activity. The students should be able to choose what they ever want.   
Concluding Statement
Adequate
7e8d10d187e3
9631D2A1BB2C
Im going to tell you if the facial action coding system is a good or bad idea
Position
Ineffective
009ed46f9c44
9631D2A1BB2C
First the process begins when the computer constructs a 3-D computer model of the face; all 44 major muscles in the model must move like human muscles. Movement of one or more muscles is called an “action unit. Then Dr. Huang relies on the work of psychologists, such as Dr. Paul Eckman, creator of FACS (Facial Action Coding System). Eckman has classified six basic emotions— happiness, surprise, anger, disgust, fear, and sadness— and then associated each with characteristic movements of the facial muscles.
Evidence
Ineffective
3c1f2aba24a2
9631D2A1BB2C
The facial expressions for each emotion are universal,” observes Dr. Huang, “even though individuals often show varying degrees of expression” (like not smiling as broadly). Using video imagery, the new emotion-recognition software tracks these facial movements— in a real face or in the painted face of Mona Lisa. By weighting the different units, the software can even identify mixed emotions (as in da Vinci’s masterpiece). Each expression is compared against a neutral face (showing no emotion).
Evidence
Ineffective
3b6beac5430d
9631D2A1BB2C
In fact, we humans perform this same impressive “calculation” every day. For instance, you can probably tell how a friend is feeling simply by the look on her face. Of course, most of us would have trouble actually describing each facial trait that conveys happy, worried, etc.
Evidence
Ineffective
0602c3ff39ef
9631D2A1BB2C
Yet Dr. Huang observes that artists such as da Vinci studied human anatomy to help them paint facial muscles precisely enough to convey specific emotions. His new computer software stores similar anatomical information as electronic code.
Evidence
Ineffective
8879a7e628ae
9631D2A1BB2C
The Mona Lisa demonstration is really intended to bring a smile to your face, while it shows just how much this computer can do. Imagine a computer that knows when you’re happy or sad. For example, if you smile when a Web ad appears on your screen, a similar ad might follow. But if you frown, the next ad will be different. “A classroom computer could recognize when a student is becoming confused or bored,” Dr. Huang predicts. “Then it could modify the lesson, like an effective human instructor.” The same technology can make computer-animated faces more expressive— for video games or video surgery. “Most human communication is nonverbal, including emotional communication,” notes Dr. Huang. “So computers need to understand that, too.”
Evidence
Ineffective
b1186e1bf4a5
9631D2A1BB2C
In conclusion the technology to read peoples facial expressions is a great idea because the computer could help students out if they dont understand the work just by reading there faces.
Concluding Statement
Adequate
014ec9039407
963859B3739B
I belive the advantages of limitng a car usage.
Position
Ineffective
cd20a400a57c
963859B3739B
we have most of the people who are not driving with the right responsible license
Claim
Ineffective
ca0ea63288a7
963859B3739B
we have some who are getting in severe car accidents
Claim
Adequate
f46a613775a1
963859B3739B
there are pollution in the air.
Claim
Adequate
e41788e6886f
963859B3739B
you dont have to pay for any car ticket or parking garage fees
Claim
Adequate
84695dc58660
963859B3739B
As a result half of the families don't own cars about 50% of them sold there cars
Evidence
Adequate
adea749a9759
963859B3739B
It somehow made them feel a whole lot better
Claim
Adequate
6b5015f73d98
963859B3739B
In Vauban you have there reseidents walking. Even we we people taking the suburbs, as a public transportation with less space for parking as if your where driving your car. They are increasing numbers are pravite car owned by burgeoning middle class cities to help out in another way of transportation. Most of the public transport serving surburbs play a much larger role. Even number license plates were ordered to leave their cars at home for odd- number plates. Drivers were fine according to Reuters. 27% of peole impounded for their reaction to fine. Beijing,China known as the most polluted cities in the world. Freezing nights caused the warmer layer of air to trap car emissions. The gas was blamed since France ha sa tax policy that has favors diesel engines In my own way there are alot of advantgaes of limiting car. But as of some people its a hard way. Colombias hiked,biked skated ot took buses to work. During a car-free day yesterday leaving the streets of this capital city eerrily devoid of traffic jams. Recent studies say that Americans are buying fewer cars, driving less and also getting fewer licenses as each year passes by. In America the number of miles driven dropped steadily. All the diffrent changes and diffrent counties and cites people who stopped car commuting as a result of recession. inconclusion based on the passage information displayed
Evidence
Adequate
8d167d8c9bcc
963859B3739B
I believe them are advantages of limiting a car.    
Concluding Statement
Adequate
165a14c3f159
964639CCF90C
How the author support his suggests that studying venus is a worthy pursuit despite the danger it presents is
Position
Ineffective
7befa0c4fb1b
964639CCF90C
venus is one of the brightest point of light in the night sky, making it simple for even an amateur stargazer to sopt. Venus is the secoynd planet from our sun. Venus is also referred to as Earth's twin, Venus is also the clostest planet in distance. Venus is sometimes right around the coner in space terms, humas have sent numerous spacecraft to land in the cloud-draped world and no spacecraft survived the landing for more than a few hours. Venus has not been touch by any spaceship for more than three decades. The article also said, "on the planet's surface, temperatures averge over 8-- degrees fahrenheit, and the atmospheric pressure is 90 times greater than what we experience on our own planet. These conditions are far more extreme than anything humans encounter on earth; such an environment would crush even a submarine accustomed to diving in the deepest part of our oceans and would liquefy many metals." At thirty-plus miles above the surface, temperatures would still be toasty at around 170 degrees Fahrenheit, but the air pressure would be close to that of sea level on Earth. Solar power would be plentiful and radiation would not ecceed Earth levels. Not easy conditions, but survivable for humans.
Evidence
Ineffective
269118c30520
964639CCF90C
These are the reasons why the author suggested that studying Venus is a worthy pursuit despite the dangers it present.
Concluding Statement
Adequate
0970d86af6c2
96B312BD472F
It is said that, over summer break students tend to forget the majority of what they learned during the school year. Once the year begins, their teachers advise them to use the information given from the classes taken prior to assist them. It should be out of the question, that students need to do school work during their 2 month-long summer vacation. The question at hand is, who should be in charge of creating these summer assignments, the teachers or the students?
Lead
Effective
d222e91d9f7d
96B312BD472F
The apparent solution is that the teachers should be assigning these projects
Position
Adequate
17aec0ac4a86
96B312BD472F
they have credibility in their subject
Claim
Adequate
670d27c7fbc8
96B312BD472F
a knowledge of how students work based off of experience.
Claim
Adequate
461b30bd8859
96B312BD472F
Firstly, a teacher has a certain credibility that students do not
Claim
Effective
2841d742ec46
96B312BD472F
The goal of these assignments is to help the students fortify their knowledge over summer so that it is not lost. These teachers go through years of university studying the subject that they teach, so why should a student who has taken the class for one year have authority over summer assignments. For example, AP BC Calculus is an immense subject with a variety of different units of math. If a student tried to make a summer study guide, they would only have a year of experience under their belt. On the other hand, teachers, who have been teaching/studying this subject for years, have a strong understanding of each unit and how to teach it in a unique way. The credibility of the creator of the assignment must be strong, so the student can have an easier time understanding the subject. Thus, teachers should be assigning summer assignments.
Evidence
Effective
0ef61368dc3e
96B312BD472F
Following my previous statement, teachers who have been working with students for years know the best strategies for getting students to absorb the subject.
Claim
Effective
aa73fbf2e8fa
96B312BD472F
Many students have a hard time grasping a topic. If students decide to ask a colleague before a teacher, they have the chance of getting incorrect information or no help at all. For example, many students in the AP Computer Science course have to figure out problems of which have many different solution. Students who don't want to give away their specific answer will try to help students figure out a secondary solution. Unfortunately, most students will not be able to figure out a second solution, because they don't have enough experience. Once the student asks the teacher for help, the teacher will be able to help the student find a solution because of their expertise. Therefore, teachers can offer a more valuable source of knowledge that will stick with the student.
Evidence
Effective
730bbfcf23de
96B312BD472F
Although the student designing the assignment knows how other students' brain works, they don't have the experience that teachers have. Students designing assignments don't know exactly how to get through to students who do not know how to do the work
Counterclaim
Effective
545c70d25209
96B312BD472F
. On the other hand, Teachers who have been working with students for years will know how to get a student to grasp the topics. Therefore, teachers designing assignments will know how to mold the assignment into a more enjoyable experience.
Rebuttal
Effective
c6e650e2e2b3
96B312BD472F
the efforts that teachers put into their own education provides strong evidence that teachers should be creating and assigning summer assignments. The years teachers spend in school give them the required credibility that is nessasary for students to trust teachers' judgement. Also, the effort teachers put into their work, to make sure their students are able to understand the topic, comes from their experience as teachers. Use these points to figure out that teacher-designed assignments are more beneficial than student-based assignments.
Concluding Statement
Effective
64c49a687b4d
96C077AC2014
Why would there be a face on mars?
Lead
Adequate
f8ec8f2e6c52
96C077AC2014
It could be a computer image hicup
Claim
Adequate
89dee8b1be9c
96C077AC2014
The land erodes.
Claim
Adequate
8da936f114b9
96C077AC2014
There are a lot of things that are natural and look like faces.
Claim
Adequate
a1e9a57f12f9
96C077AC2014
But, it still might not be natural
Claim
Adequate
3f899f74c939
96C077AC2014
No the rock formation is natural.
Position
Adequate
02f5e9b1f88b
96C077AC2014
First off, it could be a computer image hicup
Claim
Adequate
b6be255ee871
96C077AC2014
What I mean is That the camera that is moving takes different pictures of one area as its moving. I can relate to another "alien" sighting. A comet passing earth was thought to be a triangular UFO but the telescope took three different pictures at once and gave it that UFO shape.
Evidence
Adequate
08c0983ca42e
96C077AC2014
Secondly, The land erodes over time
Claim
Adequate
1d69d0bb4002
96C077AC2014
The land could have eroded land could cause a "face" to appear. This "face" is nothing more than a simple act of nature and its way. In the top picture over time you can see it erode away, especialy the 1998 photgraph.
Evidence
Adequate
b053a872630b
96C077AC2014
Thirdly, We see things that look like faces everyday, wether its clouds or land formations.
Claim
Adequate
bba18b03e58e
96C077AC2014
We see our faces everyday, so its easy to compare. In the top picture you can see a land formation, but scince we know what a face looks like its easy to compare to. In the picture, yes we can see some definition but its still just a land form. For example the man in the moon, it looked like a face but wasn't.
Evidence
Adequate
24bca233767e
96C077AC2014
On the other hand, it might be.
Claim
Adequate
5c8bf5810e20
96C077AC2014
Most theorists claim it appears to be an Egyptian Pharoh. The theorists also claim that the martians built the pyramids. It's a theory but it might be possible.
Counterclaim
Adequate
a031b662b177
96C077AC2014
In conclusion, No it is a natural landform. It could be a computer image hicup. The land erodes. There are a lot of things that are natural and look like faces. But, it still might not be natural. If it is unnatural then there could be other life out there.
Concluding Statement
Ineffective
11057d62414d
9706F8E7D534
Luke Bomberger was just an ordanery small town boy untill his friend ofered a jod as a seagoing cowboy. When he was thinking about it he said to him self that it would be a wonderfull oprtunet and just couldn't say no. He told his friend that he would take the jod. When Luke truned 18 thay could have drafted him over to the army but they didn't. Luke claims in the article that he was ment for the job becues he was rased on his aunt's farm. Yet he was not ready for the sea. Luke said he saw some pritty cool stuff. Thay also had some fun on the ship when the anamals were out. When Luke came home his aunt was probuly rilly thankfull that he came back ok. He probuly was thankfull that he got to come home becoues the other seagoing cowboys didn't do as much seagoing as him. Luke said going over seas let him be more aware for people and there needs, thats what lead him to latter on hosting international students in his home for many years.
Evidence
Ineffective
2d540a9d24b2
97249F8DF48F
Technology is always improving. From a simple toaster to a toaster that can make several pieces at once. This facial recognition is a new way of detecting the true emotions of someone.
Lead
Adequate
bb8c5ef61602
97249F8DF48F
I think the use of this technology is useful to all students, parents, governement workers, and etc.
Position
Adequate
ab50a9da4da0
97249F8DF48F
Facial expression does not have a set of rules you have to follow. For example, when someone is very angry, they might cry instead. In result, the computer might take it as sadness.
Claim
Ineffective
a97dd225ca1d
97249F8DF48F
Most of the time, facial expressions are easy to recognize. In paragraph 2 of "Making Mona Lisa Smile," it says, "Each expression is compared against a neutral face" (D'Alto 2). Everyone has different neutral faces. Most people have a good way of keeping in their emotions, making their face look blank.
Evidence
Ineffective
e1a566a60044
97249F8DF48F
When expressing emotions, certain muscles are tied to certain emotions.
Claim
Adequate
c17f0d94760d
97249F8DF48F
In paragraph 3 of the article, the author says, "... your frontalis pars lateralis muscle (above your eyes raises your eyebrows when you're surpised; your orbicularis oris (around your mouth) tightens your lips to show anger" (3). Most of the time when you are surprised, you raise your brows. Also, when you are mad, you make a face, and tighten your lips.
Evidence
Adequate
9b01d7e50fdd
97249F8DF48F
When in school, you can use your facial expressions to show how you are feeling. In paragraph 6, the author goes on to explain that, "'A classroom computer could recognize when a student is becoming confused or bored,' Dr. Huange predicts. "Then it could modify the lesson, like an effective human instructor." Several teens do not speak up when they do not understand something that was taught during class because they do not want to be embarrassed
Evidence
Adequate
7fc2e505649d
97249F8DF48F
So if you are at home, on a computer, you will not have to speak up you can just act the same, and the computer will change it to help you understand more efficiantly.
Claim
Adequate
315bfb7ad4a6
97249F8DF48F
In conclusion, facial recognition is a great way to get students on the right track in school. It can help the teachers decide if their teacher techniques are effective or not.
Concluding Statement
Adequate
13a9c2bb34c1
97249F8DF48F
Also, facial recognition can help people understand how others are feeling in certain pictures
Claim
Adequate
e0ad7a31c654
97249F8DF48F
If someone throws on a fake smile for a photo, the computer will recognize that
Evidence
Adequate
de9aff9e1a0b
97249F8DF48F
Many different emotions, have different ways it can be shown.
Claim
Adequate
b99a6dd7e07c
97249F8DF48F
The computers detect multiple emotions including: happiness, surprise, anger, disgust, fear, and sadness (3).
Evidence
Adequate
053f2e8bb4d5
974383195606
Our principle has recently stated to all the students of SCHOOL_NAME that all students have to participate in one extracurricular activity. Some students agree with this new idea and some do not.
Lead
Adequate
84dd96b29f8a
974383195606
I agree with our principle that it should be mandatory to take at least one extracurricular activity.
Position
Adequate
c98079526736
974383195606
There are many activities to chose from but in my opinion, the best activities are doing the school musical,
Claim
Adequate
1f46e95d97ef
974383195606
participating in a sport
Claim
Adequate
d62908aec516
974383195606
helping teachers during your spare time.
Claim
Adequate
a06e38a0ecc1
974383195606
Participating in musical gives students a chance to make friends and to get to know others. When I first moved here I did not have many friends or kids to hang out with but when I joined musical I began to meet so many people and they are considered to be my friends. Musical allows students to get to know others and to make friends.
Evidence
Adequate
d0daccd97f67
974383195606
During your time in musical you have to memorize so many things like songs, lines, and dances. When you memorize these things it allows me to memorize things in school much better. I can memorize how to perform a math equation as well as learning a song. Musical allows students to memorize things better in school just like in musical.
Evidence
Adequate
d9c63b0d694f
974383195606
musical also gives you a great sense of confidence. When you perform a scene in front of a audience you need confidence and when practice the scene enough you get confident about it and you perform it perfectly. You can use that kind of confidence when you are taking a test/quiz cause if you studied it enough you get the confidence to do well on it. Musical can teach you how confidence works and how to gain it.
Evidence
Adequate
245609f19662
974383195606
One of the main perks of playing sports is that they keep you in shape and keep you physically active. In our world today we see teens with there heads down looking at there phones but when you are playing a sport you become way more physically active. Sports allow students to be more proactive.
Evidence
Adequate
edd91aba8e5e
974383195606
sports also allow students to think quick on there feet. When you play sports your has to think quickly which allows the brain to think faster. When I play baseball I have to think of the play quickly because if I do not think about it what will I do if the ball comes to me. So when you play sports your mind begins to think quicker which can be very helpful in school. If you need to think of a homework plan or if you need to think on if you have quizzes or tests that week use your quick thinking.
Evidence
Adequate
75488c5da1d6
974383195606
sports can also teach you on how to be a great leader. When you are playing a game of baseball and you are the captain and you are leading the team; you learn on what is the best play or who should go where. So sports allow you to learn how to be a good leader
Evidence
Adequate
35538e639467
974383195606
Being a TA allows students to assist others in need. When I was a TA for Spanish I got help kids who were struggling on a worksheet or who did not word meant. Being a TA allows students to assist others who need help.
Evidence
Adequate
8a4e26c9e910
974383195606
you also get to learn what being a teacher is like and what the perks of it are. When I was a TA I learned how my teacher taught the class and what she did with students who were not doing what they were suppost to. Being a TA allows students to learn what being a teacher is like.
Evidence
Adequate
563053e63c8a
974383195606
when being a TA you get to meet more students and get to know what they are like. When I walked into the class I would be helping in, I saw so many kids and got to meet so many of them and they all were cool. Being a TA is good for meeting others
Evidence
Ineffective
cb9b1a88924a
974383195606
I stated in the beginning that I agree with our principle that all students should participate in a extracurricular activity. I said that due to the fact that extracurricular activitys are fun and there are many benefits. My top three activities were musical, sports, and being a TA(teachers assitant). I say that every single student in SCHOOL_NAME should do an extracurricular activity. 
Concluding Statement
Adequate
938148f682f9
974C176869EC
Luke was offered a trip to Europe on a boat by a friend and of course he couldn't say no. So Luke took the offer but World War II was going in Europe and many countries were left in ruins. A group called UNRRA (the United Nations Relief and Rehabilitation Administration) hired "Seagoing Cowboys" to take care of the animals that were shipped over seas. According to the text in August 1945, they received their orders to report to New Orleans. They arrived August 14 the day the Pacific war was over. Luke turned 18 the day before arriving in Greece, which meant he could be drafted for military service. He was discharged in 1947 but Luke had already made nine trips the most any Seagoing Cowbody had ever done.
Evidence
Ineffective
75adecb3ab42
974C176869EC
Luke had a great experience doing something he loved and also helping out others. He went to Europe to have a fun vacation but ended up helping fourty-four countries that were in ruins
Evidence
Adequate
d7ed7a274cd3
974C176869EC
I would encourage a lot of people to join the Seagoing Cowboy program
Position
Adequate
43412e8ef338
974C176869EC
you get to travel around and visit a lot of countries but also you get to help out countries that aren't at there finest at the moment.
Claim
Effective
5921262fb8b9
9756E31C449F
Imagine sitting on your fluffy, brown couch, thinking of what you could do if you signed up for the drama club, band, or even strings. You look at all your friends posts about how fun yearbook club was when you weren't even there. How would you feel? After school activities can do a lot for you. I've always enjoyed them even though it's extra hours at school.
Lead
Effective
fb54d2aa9dff
9756E31C449F
In my opinion, you should choose at least one extracurricular activity to do after school.
Position
Effective
23d24f93cce0
9756E31C449F
After school activities will prevent laziness,
Claim
Effective
b15cd7b70a9b
9756E31C449F
bring happiness into going to school,
Claim
Effective
f59ee079b180
9756E31C449F
it may even help you become more social.
Claim
Effective
4db45686a77e
9756E31C449F
When you actually have something to do after school, you are out running about, having fun, and you aren't even thinking about sitting on your phone, eating all the chocolate covered pretzels in the world. Knowing myself, all I want to do when I get home is eat, and of course, sleep. Being lazy leads to weight gain. Many students my age care about how they look to others. You have to be "skinny" to "fit in" or "thick" for boys to like you. It's always good to stay in shape and after school activities may help you with that. Doing what you love makes you more energized. Most clubs have fundraisers you can volunteer for and contribute too. You can stay up at night planning about it, making up cool ideas that'll keep you awake. Overall, no student should just sit at home, doing nothing but eating, if they have a choice to join a club.
Evidence
Effective
d28a8d1d0a60
9756E31C449F
When you might not have classes with a certain friend, it is always a good thing to see them if you have an after school activity with them. The friendship won't fade if you still get to talk to them for even just an hour a day. Sharing what you do after school makes you feel like you are apart of something. I always like sharing my stories about my track meets, practices, and pretty much everything. It's exciting to share stories to your friends instead of saying, "oh, I don't do anything after school." You should be happy about seeing the process you made for the school environment. If you end up in the gardening club or even a Junior Honors Society type club, you help make the front of your schools plants look pretty. People will most likely compliment you daily about how it looks and it'll make you very happy. Don't you want people complimenting your work? Lastly, not being in clubs wont make you happy going to school because you have nothing to look forward too. You could've chose between 100 or more clubs to join, but you didn't so you regret it.
Evidence
Effective
3ceb41a00826
9756E31C449F
You can't enjoy clubs if you don't talk to anyone. Clubs are meant to be fun and meant for everyone to have a good time. If you don't talk to people and socialize even a little bit, they aren't going to speak to you first.
Evidence
Adequate
371c54856dda
9756E31C449F
I see why some students will disagree with my opinion on extracurricular activities because some people do have things going on in their life. I understand that some people are really shy, but its always good to step out of your comfort zone. Overall though, it is hard to talk to people when you aren't the type of person too.
Counterclaim
Adequate