question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
int64
0
74.5k
sentence_embeddings
sequencelengths
1.02k
1.02k
<p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/IBHdy.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>This is an excerpt from "Modern mathematical statistics with applications" by Devore et al. What puzzles me is that the estimator cannot help being dependent on $\theta$, since the sample depends on the parameter.</p>
73,384
[ -0.03154265135526657, -0.0033498024567961693, 0.0071097384206950665, 0.0004639640392269939, 0.04898902773857117, 0.019556058570742607, -0.027698885649442673, 0.0207839272916317, 0.013052034191787243, -0.05280311778187752, 0.04065847396850586, 0.038831926882267, 0.07227423042058945, 0.008955988101661205, -0.0023924517445266247, 0.028546767309308052, -0.047151774168014526, 0.04585262015461922, -0.006921439431607723, 0.008987592533230782, 0.0031609938014298677, 0.08306464552879333, -0.010242622345685959, -0.015470455400645733, -0.01879202388226986, 0.018377769738435745, 0.038768600672483444, -0.00377951143309474, -0.006259015761315823, 0.09569017589092255, -0.04859725758433342, -0.04067053645849228, 0.011809476651251316, 0.048698168247938156, 0.012263997457921505, -0.0325021855533123, -0.04020696133375168, 0.0017198349814862013, 0.019122235476970673, 0.048722825944423676, -0.05451245233416557, -0.05024993419647217, -0.020301269367337227, 0.035830240696668625, -0.03767215833067894, 0.02718370594084263, -0.02287627011537552, -0.07731395214796066, 0.040994368493556976, -0.01964312046766281, 0.07512760907411575, 0.001531083369627595, 0.01121857576072216, 0.051747582852840424, -0.02424156293272972, 0.00241577485576272, 0.05404180660843849, 0.08893503993749619, -0.04063519835472107, -0.034962248057127, -0.035721853375434875, -0.03317975252866745, 0.00008239659655373544, -0.004183166194707155, -0.04429293051362038, -0.017567791044712067, 0.004899689927697182, -0.019260896369814873, 0.03462626039981842, -0.016996512189507484, 0.030445164069533348, 0.02477377839386463, 0.018056798726320267, 0.024198144674301147, -0.020133716985583305, -0.013779031112790108, -0.0044230809435248375, 0.045450013130903244, 0.0367085263133049, 0.0075988974422216415, 0.02291625179350376, 0.017387209460139275, 0.03996538370847702, 0.04385152831673622, 0.006839343812316656, 0.0036659217439591885, 0.06171819940209389, -0.019477061927318573, 0.03156888112425804, 0.028134915977716446, -0.019385404884815216, 0.015662651509046555, 0.010639011859893799, -0.03902871906757355, -0.032837800681591034, 0.037098053842782974, -0.036357223987579346, 0.03356711566448212, 0.0047739772126078606, -0.001078728586435318, 0.02583128958940506, -0.04644137620925903, 0.005134876351803541, 0.05005243048071861, -0.021906813606619835, 0.005822278093546629, 0.0013647095765918493, 0.0003180211060680449, 0.011422205716371536, -0.04998089373111725, 0.0022552763111889362, 0.03317536786198616, 0.00247215642593801, -0.005071426276117563, 0.012842564843595028, 0.005760582629591227, -0.009399808943271637, -0.0002541262365411967, 0.029426876455545425, 0.04651067033410072, 0.02933059073984623, -0.014000430703163147, 0.017117539420723915, -0.0351128950715065, -0.04086533561348915, 0.034635771065950394, 0.02576928399503231, -0.04340803623199463, -0.031719308346509933, 0.018344983458518982, 0.0008355373283848166, 0.0057035041972994804, 0.0413682647049427, 0.02234506979584694, 0.02693082205951214, 0.0002430093300063163, -0.07044940441846848, -0.049223046749830246, 0.03298983722925186, -0.011207577772438526, -0.004378139972686768, -0.07011987268924713, 0.018267938867211342, 0.03192144259810448, 0.04041586071252823, -0.013458081521093845, 0.05195316672325134, 0.016000008210539818, 0.02689424529671669, 0.03099161759018898, -0.023076843470335007, -0.011986767873167992, -0.02285255864262581, -0.04311571270227432, 0.005993111990392208, -0.08203045278787613, 0.01837947964668274, -0.004167966544628143, 0.010932191275060177, -0.03181758522987366, 0.03543597459793091, 0.010873351246118546, -0.01460930798202753, -0.0064132860861718655, 0.002145099686458707, -0.03505793958902359, 0.0794617310166359, -0.0005399464280344546, 0.02985820360481739, 0.009294966235756874, 0.024749021977186203, 0.02410285361111164, 0.022132936865091324, 0.0226959977298975, 0.0501721128821373, -0.05260342359542847, -0.026320483535528183, -0.04219731688499451, 0.025047553703188896, 0.005151176359504461, -0.045729443430900574, -0.03650759905576706, 0.026254508644342422, 0.008839084766805172, 0.03120504319667816, 0.0668744444847107, 0.02482038550078869, -0.01735629141330719, 0.014138269238173962, -0.02176082693040371, -0.009831851348280907, -0.05433326214551926, 0.0035954536870121956, -0.015634434297680855, -0.015159457921981812, 0.03323722630739212, 0.002533752704039216, 0.02121567726135254, -0.024609409272670746, 0.0009666078258305788, -0.007851125672459602, -0.026718102395534515, 0.027088336646556854, -0.014934086240828037, 0.028231706470251083, 0.040547993034124374, 0.06254442781209946, 0.02494749054312706, 0.024792687967419624, -0.03938726335763931, -0.04694008827209473, 0.017087459564208984, -0.044913243502378464, 0.02159888856112957, 0.009332195855677128, -0.016489511355757713, 0.005980254616588354, -0.023211954161524773, -0.03336823731660843, 0.06361385434865952, -0.05002126097679138, 0.06423518061637878, 0.010924162343144417, -0.003128096926957369, -0.005205546505749226, 0.0142039330676198, 0.05807754769921303, 0.0007067275582812726, -0.007960125803947449, -0.0212688148021698, -0.05541376397013664, 0.021493544802069664, 0.06714723259210587, -0.01251775212585926, -0.0384364128112793, 0.01821933686733246, 0.06709634512662888, 0.009908577427268028, 0.014478813856840134, 0.019942859187722206, -0.012005103752017021, 0.00948658399283886, 0.0208638533949852, 0.010051819495856762, 0.007334767375141382, 0.009202132001519203, 0.011597005650401115, -0.0012274684850126505, 0.007212527561932802, -0.02475525252521038, 0.026262721046805382, 0.055171720683574677, -0.01915723644196987, -0.011256208643317223, 0.009173312224447727, 0.02115202322602272, 0.03413517028093338, -0.06256549060344696, 0.014219009317457676, 0.03118194080889225, 0.023220092058181763, -0.0019534146413207054, -0.028853224590420723, -0.021043511107563972, 0.03965536504983902, 0.0023687828797847033, -0.04956979304552078, 0.023617224767804146, 0.03870105370879173, -0.021906735375523567, -0.007184100802987814, -0.047596946358680725, -0.03601084649562836, 0.026484454050660133, -0.012735431082546711, 0.057873379439115524, 0.03525475785136223, -0.010695075616240501, 0.008326033130288124, -0.04065325856208801, -0.015575913712382317, -0.02543996088206768, 0.012465671636164188, 0.040843114256858826, -0.04670662805438042, -0.005740109831094742, -0.012306321412324905, -0.029759598895907402, 0.017321009188890457, 0.02346457727253437, 0.021275002509355545, -0.0035640692804008722, -0.016185147687792778, -0.051139503717422485, -0.028850577771663666, -0.00715924147516489, 0.008794520050287247, -0.058265551924705505, -0.05336276441812515, 0.04152074083685875, 0.011796860955655575, 0.01435042917728424, 0.020697299391031265, -0.04896230250597, -0.03493146970868111, -0.027634600177407265, 0.023524345830082893, 0.0339646153151989, -0.02439194731414318, 0.03766445070505142, 0.03940415009856224, -0.023725034669041634, -0.02483612857758999, -0.06005100533366203, -0.07740780711174011, -0.00744895962998271, -0.003906192723661661, 0.0178939551115036, -0.005316152237355709, -0.04583015665411949, 0.09589487314224243, 0.01825619675219059, -0.019476020708680153, -0.016223423182964325, -0.02512797899544239, -0.047457028180360794, -0.07568307220935822, 0.00010795220441650599, 0.0194250475615263, 0.002458159113302827, 0.0354645773768425, 0.02545267343521118, 0.004581213463097811, 0.009050377644598484, 0.04770403727889061, -0.02001153863966465, 0.030844004824757576, 0.03661618009209633, -0.01592058129608631, 0.02526128850877285, 0.041895780712366104, -0.0014670424861833453, -0.009841532446444035, 0.009346314705908298, 0.05270005017518997, -0.0007896088063716888, -0.044595684856176376, 0.020505854859948158, -0.0332031324505806, 0.017456168308854103, -0.038896214216947556, 0.0504133477807045, 0.03700190410017967, -0.006117313168942928, 0.0055792988277971745, 0.005786057561635971, 0.03143775463104248, -0.039223991334438324, -0.018945198506116867, 0.041297294199466705, -0.006568143144249916, -0.04161452874541283, -0.03419238328933716, -0.014732052572071552, -0.010796725749969482, 0.027342859655618668, -0.005257736891508102, -0.044566892087459564, 0.00608433224260807, 0.028377532958984375, -0.015738951042294502, -0.010452346876263618, -0.032555531710386276, 0.009378401562571526, -0.06439773738384247, 0.024949567392468452, 0.01633971370756626, 0.028991369530558586, 0.01078387163579464, 0.03305291756987572, 0.026236455887556076, 0.008554456755518913, 0.004075555596500635, 0.044123575091362, -0.07772227376699448, 0.019623130559921265, -0.005990740843117237, -0.03694376349449158, 0.013667336665093899, -0.029095027595758438, 0.049128491431474686, -0.014926331117749214, 0.007646257523447275, -0.04258834198117256, -0.0008536519017070532, -0.05045408383011818, 0.028310449793934822, 0.0013282636646181345, 0.0025305929593741894, -0.00715296808630228, 0.013260334730148315, 0.04325716197490692, -0.020982299000024796, 0.05357435345649719, 0.05835358425974846, -0.011655129492282867, -0.0019648647867143154, -0.05199751257896423, 0.01650909148156643, 0.010584520176053047, 0.03046562895178795, 0.022999059408903122, 0.013416139408946037, -0.03262338042259216, 0.015021614730358124, 0.0036801223177462816, 0.07038094848394394, 0.07386601716279984, 0.012527050450444221, -0.0413023866713047, -0.03015575371682644, -0.02565905638039112, 0.014962583780288696, 0.03517879545688629, 0.00638278154656291, -0.017052551731467247, 0.09125589579343796, 0.006860165391117334, -0.03597818687558174, -0.009533941745758057, 0.030222071334719658, 0.018735846504569054, -0.007590737193822861, -0.029657013714313507, 0.006643850822001696, -0.004692441318184137, 0.002606392139568925, 0.0139077827334404, 0.01335953176021576, 0.0027173124253749847, -0.00982359703630209, 0.016587721183896065, -0.026300525292754173, -0.0072396243922412395, 0.008008807897567749, 0.018382318317890167, 0.036271385848522186, -0.010590871796011925, -0.03177841380238533, 0.03328165411949158, 0.028677767142653465, 0.035522155463695526, 0.011287866160273552, -0.0002868632145691663, -0.07591602951288223, -0.012163165956735611, 0.05249377712607384, 0.02242007665336132, -0.03202557936310768, 0.0013749090721830726, -0.048225823789834976, 0.005064185708761215, 0.03094811923801899, -0.03852412477135658, 0.03404843062162399, -0.02521481364965439, -0.017374303191900253, -0.026281971484422684, -0.04853128641843796, -0.044956378638744354, 0.0040005650371313095, -0.014689664356410503, 0.0023051402531564236, -0.018395204097032547, -0.03901147469878197, -0.008834694512188435, -0.0038640291895717382, 0.011292641051113605, 0.07228574901819229, 0.051499415189027786, -0.011926005594432354, 0.011725646443665028, 0.04564220458269119, -0.014475282281637192, -0.05656127631664276, 0.038620151579380035, -0.009524495340883732, 0.018546195700764656, 0.020569229498505592, -0.04365558922290802, -0.060966987162828445, 0.024958861991763115, -0.012507649138569832, -0.02342015691101551, 0.0033804404083639383, -0.006828771438449621, 0.034604430198669434, 0.051896072924137115, 0.011809701099991798, 0.07202456891536713, 0.009593878872692585, 0.035099513828754425, -0.0016728831687942147, -0.01897263340651989, 0.012237741611897945, -0.05154004320502281, -0.027726903557777405, -0.03711998835206032, 0.0028401054441928864, -0.02463598921895027, 0.004291352815926075, 0.011461063288152218, 0.02311543934047222, -0.02478824555873871, -0.03277571126818657, 0.008958415128290653, -0.01820240169763565, 0.01791752129793167, 0.008068890310823917, -0.0029972558841109276, 0.012021893635392189, -0.02198503166437149, 0.004231721628457308, 0.018012449145317078, -0.07359404861927032, 0.00008897035149857402, 0.013236548751592636, -0.03139403834939003, -0.027215203270316124, -0.06111884489655495, -0.04233340546488762, -0.0009291489841416478, -0.022494187578558922, 0.04256685823202133, -0.021420137956738472, 0.05712543800473213, 0.005727250594645739, -0.04280716925859451, -0.026680991053581238, -0.005007701925933361, -0.009647647850215435, 0.03227623552083969, -0.032231222838163376, -0.005400591064244509, 0.0024898317642509937, 0.032568566501140594, -0.07015147060155869, -0.011946757324039936, 0.035354312509298325, 0.009256473742425442, -0.010770303197205067, 0.0065831029787659645, -0.023274196311831474, -0.014704191125929356, -0.06802051514387131, -0.004096703138202429, 0.042549099773168564, 0.006115675438195467, -0.01541618537157774, -0.032483506947755814, 0.04708949849009514, 0.09165778756141663, -0.0115113016217947, 0.02165350317955017, 0.043109603226184845, -0.05729520693421364, -0.012934917584061623, 0.015246634371578693, 0.01910962350666523, -0.052125897258520126, 0.007664917036890984, -0.015538523904979229, 0.0021558606531471014, -0.0050646462477743626, -0.010013792663812637, -0.055843185633420944, 0.027338502928614616, 0.018040083348751068, 0.009811777621507645, -0.0006113028503023088, -0.005046337842941284, 0.015221389010548592, 0.03355185687541962, -0.010392460972070694, 0.010664486326277256, -0.015644315630197525, -0.03280926123261452, 0.05975332111120224, -0.011142401956021786, -0.01870313659310341, 0.018989909440279007, 0.08394081890583038, -0.02771807461977005, -0.011823232285678387, 0.002319489838555455, -0.014078316278755665, 0.01835509203374386, 0.019620340317487717, 0.003357130568474531, 0.01965979114174843, 0.022065261378884315, -0.0685902014374733, 0.0035895113833248615, -0.0360344797372818, 0.011560211889445782, 0.04534270241856575, -0.01272853184491396, 0.03208238258957863, 0.017106030136346817, -0.0310893002897501, -0.026077503338456154, -0.04046527296304703, -0.022694263607263565, -0.017945870757102966, -0.020199190825223923, 0.021962817758321762, 0.028813660144805908, -0.005946432705968618, 0.03418879210948944, 0.006948960479348898, 0.0102304145693779, 0.006295513827353716, 0.0210906770080328, 0.03255600482225418, 0.004375842399895191, 0.014628955163061619, -0.05129377171397209, 0.030814731493592262, -0.041043996810913086, 0.013344056904315948, -0.039526332169771194, 0.009265863336622715, 0.050233058631420135, 0.005070451181381941, 0.046834323555231094, -0.02395530417561531, -0.007516923826187849, -0.045921582728624344, 0.019886253401637077, 0.02991621010005474, 0.013265752233564854, 0.045718543231487274, -0.0016185111599043012, 0.02632523886859417, 0.025133751332759857, 0.016453145071864128, -0.04560347646474838, -0.0796976312994957, -0.032181501388549805, -0.010625964030623436, -0.003530690213665366, 0.061162710189819336, -0.02796867862343788, -0.019594108685851097, 0.03344065696001053, -0.035069484263658524, 0.02026856690645218, 0.012677800841629505, 0.03343229740858078, -0.021708529442548752, 0.0773596316576004, 0.012780562974512577, 0.01152034942060709, 0.005396479275077581, -0.01953367330133915, 0.10377173870801926, 0.05103839933872223, 0.03791198879480362, -0.055397190153598785, 0.019261237233877182, -0.012075484730303288, -0.001227736589498818, -0.021674860268831253, 0.013594867661595345, 0.007560061756521463, -0.02810012176632881, 0.008339784108102322, 0.015290298499166965, 0.01747281476855278, 0.0015268881106749177, 0.06000761315226555, -0.032182708382606506, -0.0459599643945694, -0.01610025018453598, 0.005142288748174906, 0.00046538104652427137, -0.011941483244299889, -0.03878375142812729, 0.030486367642879486, 0.0010518641211092472, -0.017004668712615967, -0.03144114464521408, -0.02592414617538452, 0.0001743851025821641, -0.024223459884524345, -0.02747577242553234, -0.031061332672834396, 0.040867552161216736, 0.01802227646112442, -0.03717852383852005, 0.012596607208251953, -0.02323623187839985, 0.001720368629321456, 0.03136305883526802, 0.024927647784352303, 0.0010082643711939454, -0.003313853405416012, 0.032271526753902435, -0.007789040450006723, -0.033963706344366074, -0.01812208816409111, -0.032741982489824295, 0.03486162796616554, 0.030444970354437828, 0.00832169596105814, -0.008201675489544868, 0.007286212407052517, -0.014292240142822266, -0.057565804570913315, 0.007853791117668152, 0.00415149237960577, 0.003986821044236422, -0.03132655471563339, -0.008689919486641884, -0.01013146247714758, 0.014847036451101303, 0.00395378191024065, 0.03366260230541229, 0.040888089686632156, -0.05802735686302185, -0.015294336713850498, -0.0038641581777483225, 0.04918242618441582, 0.01010211557149887, -0.026016611605882645, -0.0040143933147192, -0.015713829547166824, -0.02585197426378727, 0.0164770670235157, -0.0017905314452946186, -0.025274956598877907, 0.03514319285750389, -0.009298847056925297, 0.01791188307106495, -0.004599620122462511, -0.026069123297929764, 0.0063821859657764435, -0.024458492174744606, 0.006845302879810333, -0.047327738255262375, 0.017564913257956505, 0.020585767924785614, 0.04359579086303711, 0.01020411029458046, -0.021676503121852875, 0.0032464538235217333, 0.02760227955877781, 0.02447320520877838, -0.04625466465950012, -0.036120545119047165, 0.0165452491492033, -0.020542291924357414, -0.009044663049280643, -0.0012084526242688298, 0.03717860206961632, 0.009003357961773872, 0.028010547161102295, -0.03180447965860367, 0.013052175752818584, -0.005338325630873442, 0.02962600253522396, 0.008655390702188015, -0.03885708376765251, 0.02139156498014927, 0.004605493973940611, 0.003534230636432767, 0.0021243025548756123, -0.019775303080677986, -0.04575938731431961, 0.004220684990286827, 0.009418072178959846, -0.035715486854314804, -0.0467565581202507, 0.0015759876696392894, 0.00850843545049429, 0.017475320026278496, 0.00926593504846096, -0.011108066886663437, -0.01854534074664116, -0.027211269363760948, -0.01758076623082161, -0.014076252467930317, -0.004211347550153732, 0.004450381267815828, -0.024138441309332848, -0.019511623308062553, 0.0316411592066288, -0.0019579583313316107, 0.025298938155174255, -0.028721380978822708, 0.018910834565758705, 0.008314134553074837, 0.056223493069410324, -0.0453413762152195, -0.018672732636332512, 0.03547866642475128, -0.03661626577377319, -0.004582234658300877, 0.018925126641988754, -0.015000530518591404, 0.04437787085771561, 0.01842879131436348, -0.02401863783597946, -0.002144633326679468, 0.005064697936177254, -0.03290122374892235, 0.008701611310243607, 0.03232604265213013, -0.002972327871248126, 0.024593548849225044, -0.023183029145002365, 0.014234042726457119, 0.019630463793873787, 0.019834615290164948, 0.05133090913295746, 0.0380772165954113, 0.01226668432354927, -0.028736570850014687, 0.02960570715367794, 0.012714885175228119, 0.04925430938601494, -0.007308941800147295, 0.02248290367424488, 0.034603044390678406, 0.05052316561341286, -0.03342457860708237, 0.04636552557349205, -0.03169182687997818, 0.015187193639576435, -0.13220855593681335, -0.022447938099503517, 0.01884240098297596, 0.018879935145378113, 0.0610465481877327, -0.053389810025691986, 0.003722491441294551, 0.01623530685901642, -0.053986869752407074, -0.002949570305645466, -0.01248918380588293, -0.015859361737966537, -0.0454665906727314, -0.010099362581968307, -0.04738762602210045, 0.03249970078468323, 0.024266745895147324, 0.007098049856722355, 0.041677325963974, 0.01723003201186657, -0.0009921604068949819, -0.02751537412405014, -0.00797449704259634, 0.011632420122623444, 0.00399068184196949, -0.01713787391781807, 0.02046387270092964, -0.018681643530726433, -0.03897155076265335, 0.02678433433175087, 0.015475403517484665, 0.028521282598376274, 0.006789871025830507, 0.005718612112104893, 0.01210540346801281, 0.03949704393744469, 0.03508780524134636, -0.017184296622872353, -0.0060883695259690285, -0.005315294489264488, 0.012567320838570595, 0.03227685019373894, -0.011846757493913174, -0.02731824479997158, -0.005782975349575281, -0.016379043459892273, -0.04964955151081085, -0.0038488623686134815, -0.027633177116513252, -0.04337140545248985, 0.010074544697999954, -0.022653212770819664, -0.008244010619819164, -0.0253383070230484, 0.01638024114072323, -0.03553367033600807, -0.018898628652095795, 0.02952433004975319, 0.00833121407777071, 0.021801652386784554, -0.009301808662712574, -0.045931801199913025, -0.0470583476126194, 0.01778477616608143, 0.0036687611136585474, -0.04391174018383026, -0.040832020342350006, 0.022696644067764282, -0.0008153764065355062, -0.015546975657343864, -0.008333438076078892, 0.0117432726547122, -0.04168345406651497, 0.03811383992433548, -0.012349730357527733, -0.0014476636424660683, 0.0017841729568317533, -0.02771853469312191, -0.025532299652695656, -0.09912234544754028, 0.08740201592445374, -0.002362866187468171, -0.004637145437300205, -0.02050432749092579, -0.03261994943022728, -0.0115147540345788, -0.0005984080489724874, 0.0545843280851841, 0.017648203298449516, 0.004796415567398071, 0.033011969178915024, 0.010913753882050514, -0.017290694639086723, -0.03449484705924988, 0.03922590985894203, -0.029007449746131897, -0.010327541269361973, -0.008177650161087513, -0.023198021575808525, 0.03388793766498566, 0.016558418050408363, -0.03291601687669754, 0.002891854615882039, 0.02960706315934658, 0.024333881214261055, 0.031666938215494156, 0.055416230112314224, -0.0005170341464690864, 0.0012203427031636238, 0.0638631135225296, -0.017924636602401733, 0.05049630627036095, 0.002412697533145547, -0.006036445498466492, -0.08222470432519913, 0.024531224742531776, -0.06486459076404572, -0.0306085254997015, -0.011685020290315151, 0.007684577722102404, 0.011038379743695259, -0.013404130935668945, -0.04344287887215614, 0.019059013575315475, -0.03476332500576973, 0.023254187777638435, 0.03944885730743408, 0.020725153386592865, 0.04538009688258171, -0.013761933892965317, -0.02043943852186203, 0.009885751642286777, 0.017592964693903923, 0.004801346454769373, 0.023805640637874603, 0.02538340352475643, 0.00749023025855422, 0.0002973961236421019, 0.0423584021627903, 0.0034440457820892334, 0.0010195012437179685, -0.007422166410833597, 0.018537990748882294, -0.031847063452005386, -0.05652790516614914, -0.02933872491121292, 0.005498800426721573, -0.009981808252632618, -0.0072675058618187904, 0.0002306572423549369, 0.04597695916891098, -0.002659713616594672, 0.0009086952777579427, -0.03296152874827385, -0.0064651635475456715, -0.03682428598403931, 0.00022510462440550327, 0.040589336305856705, -0.018716590479016304, -0.014214827679097652, -0.030367126688361168, 0.036290306597948074, -0.0006726377760060132, 0.009661463089287281, -0.0186080913990736, 0.00403236597776413, 0.019086942076683044, -0.0047104693949222565, -0.03259588032960892, -0.01809203065931797, -0.05272046476602554, -0.03116704896092415, 0.031786032021045685, 0.02563757263123989, 0.04981075972318649, -0.006608724128454924, -0.03714689239859581, -0.027508335188031197, 0.08777429163455963, -0.08163157850503922, -0.018447270616889, -0.007729825098067522, 0.016865326091647148, 0.029512448236346245, -0.03587031364440918 ]
<p>I have a mixed model built using Data A below, and now I want to validate the model using Data B. What should I do to actually "validate" the model?</p> <pre><code>model &lt;- lme(Y~1+X1+X3, random=~1|School, method="ML", data=A) </code></pre> <p>I know how to use "predict(model,B) - B$Y" to get residuals, but what else should I also perform in this validation process?</p> <p>(I will not apply the cross-validation technique since my data are hierarchical structured.)</p>
35,718
[ -0.0067083146423101425, -0.007669028360396624, -0.031057534739375114, -0.024149911478161812, 0.011728012003004551, 0.019282611086964607, -0.0249804500490427, -0.0021926292683929205, 0.08135847002267838, 0.0015678787603974342, 0.06404178589582443, 0.04689296334981918, 0.06531214714050293, 0.01238013431429863, 0.04859715700149536, 0.008381271734833717, 0.01767645590007305, -0.025438737124204636, 0.025248568505048752, -0.014855289831757545, -0.00461675925180316, -0.019802577793598175, 0.017134036868810654, -0.028639383614063263, 0.009814450517296791, 0.036600347608327866, 0.06793183833360672, 0.003881955286487937, 0.027658548206090927, 0.03092903643846512, -0.022260237485170364, -0.047895122319459915, 0.005468251649290323, 0.02137642912566662, -0.0006074814009480178, 0.005837646313011646, -0.00555868074297905, -0.016730690374970436, 0.002573332516476512, 0.01286002155393362, -0.013377171009778976, -0.019811710342764854, 0.029992980882525444, 0.055699385702610016, -0.009074344299733639, 0.01630818471312523, -0.022645771503448486, -0.01895909570157528, 0.04615567997097969, -0.04082083702087402, 0.0632481649518013, -0.0071649085730314255, 0.032661568373441696, 0.06337587535381317, -0.02692417986690998, -0.007260223384946585, 0.08865317702293396, 0.07414132356643677, -0.0000642622253508307, -0.04526016488671303, -0.033341024070978165, -0.044773805886507034, 0.00046072411350905895, 0.0029456145130097866, -0.05858658254146576, 0.0048693446442484856, -0.00925269816070795, -0.009810210205614567, 0.03817863389849663, -0.03647049143910408, 0.023106997832655907, 0.02124503068625927, 0.03884554281830788, -0.030867846682667732, 0.056435223668813705, -0.016988592222332954, 0.009434840641915798, 0.016410863026976585, 0.032924652099609375, 0.030539730563759804, -0.02434488944709301, 0.015581158921122551, 0.002397987525910139, 0.03798741474747658, -0.003048775950446725, -0.030147027224302292, 0.035338014364242554, 0.0192320067435503, 0.010162259452044964, -0.009713447652757168, -0.018468765541911125, 0.008581586182117462, 0.035401515662670135, 0.022587627172470093, -0.02832832559943199, 0.05181187763810158, -0.004250869154930115, 0.045716460794210434, 0.033349089324474335, -0.02172241173684597, 0.011567514389753342, -0.032350536435842514, 0.03294629976153374, 0.05151974409818649, -0.03413858264684677, 0.004498857539147139, -0.006429684814065695, -0.000940607744269073, -0.0025426438078284264, -0.00756408367305994, -0.01653905399143696, 0.05348415672779083, -0.016936587169766426, -0.004964996129274368, 0.040733955800533295, -0.04089267924427986, -0.004398820456117392, -0.008115340955555439, 0.05109842121601105, 0.0350923016667366, 0.053377989679574966, -0.008609844371676445, 0.03209158405661583, 0.01492005493491888, -0.057091984897851944, -0.019694190472364426, 0.0034298754762858152, -0.0029198150150477886, -0.04381589591503143, 0.06351576000452042, -0.026085959747433662, -0.02333591692149639, 0.010235491208732128, -0.025406967848539352, 0.04046732187271118, 0.011411819607019424, -0.09660165011882782, -0.07563166320323944, 0.02193734422326088, -0.019553637132048607, 0.001457946258597076, -0.03865321725606918, -0.00359920971095562, 0.03201839700341225, 0.06058621406555176, 0.025466252118349075, 0.010457596741616726, 0.03478080406785011, 0.02284133806824684, -0.011048798449337482, -0.05084553733468056, -0.029963195323944092, -0.00517270527780056, -0.022199200466275215, -0.03717368096113205, -0.0717858076095581, -0.000862781482283026, 0.024538792669773102, -0.0501260906457901, -0.012311801314353943, 0.029503317549824715, -0.01257230993360281, -0.007357139140367508, 0.0012207000982016325, 0.008954470977187157, -0.007704638410359621, 0.05643244832754135, 0.0027888640761375427, 0.038047973066568375, 0.036718934774398804, -0.023313019424676895, 0.03233100473880768, 0.00296196062117815, 0.02266502007842064, 0.039257682859897614, 0.021968139335513115, 0.022646406665444374, 0.011628121137619019, 0.023456010967493057, 0.016487104818224907, -0.05715562775731087, 0.001336399232968688, -0.011325196363031864, 0.019665734842419624, -0.016720455139875412, 0.03490278124809265, 0.02482989989221096, -0.0024398346431553364, 0.05743337422609329, -0.03132668882608414, -0.029451927170157433, -0.07981304824352264, 0.00727780070155859, 0.0028429562225937843, -0.031212393194437027, 0.0071538034826517105, -0.01621728576719761, 0.008733228780329227, -0.037323176860809326, -0.002290567383170128, -0.042985353618860245, -0.004310645628720522, 0.015406039543449879, -0.01160765066742897, -0.0023818698246032, 0.013933751732110977, 0.05946974828839302, -0.03150561824440956, 0.04920593649148941, -0.008153875358402729, 0.0019735575187951326, -0.0038442020304501057, -0.03569960594177246, -0.02956300787627697, -0.02978324703872204, -0.03399325907230377, 0.023252326995134354, 0.00439309561625123, 0.003657401306554675, 0.03335660323500633, -0.07725498080253601, 0.06874804943799973, 0.049293402582407, 0.015945235267281532, 0.002586293499916792, -0.017160650342702866, 0.0077834222465753555, 0.031484562903642654, -0.027634482830762863, -0.007264974992722273, -0.054371003061532974, -0.036265335977077484, 0.045099612325429916, -0.0046078176237642765, -0.021470775827765465, 0.017363769933581352, 0.053988490253686905, -0.03369086980819702, 0.023576751351356506, 0.02832549437880516, -0.03344811126589775, 0.006810463964939117, 0.011904427781701088, 0.0033128424547612667, -0.014948053285479546, 0.02860339917242527, 0.014307491481304169, 0.013844792731106281, 0.011609284207224846, 0.006541245151311159, -0.0020127964671701193, 0.05925528705120087, 0.0077937631867825985, 0.004219265654683113, -0.008435534313321114, -0.033769384026527405, 0.05347982421517372, -0.0015401325654238462, 0.015042223036289215, 0.04397578537464142, -0.002712239744141698, -0.03336377441883087, -0.010146006010472775, -0.008797865360975266, 0.004348372109234333, 0.049377407878637314, -0.02349681593477726, 0.010574880056083202, 0.018554067239165306, -0.032401904463768005, -0.008382134139537811, -0.04031672701239586, -0.024896757677197456, -0.07014261931180954, 0.0168245118111372, 0.018054625019431114, -0.009835856966674328, 0.03386769816279411, -0.037754446268081665, -0.03973294422030449, -0.012768169865012169, -0.03080069087445736, 0.031007837504148483, -0.045082539319992065, -0.03398110345005989, 0.011708329431712627, -0.021288087591528893, -0.012758825905621052, 0.03300672769546509, -0.030087405815720558, -0.014260157942771912, 0.018106451258063316, -0.013108144514262676, -0.042002297937870026, -0.041957952082157135, -0.01044556312263012, -0.01473380345851183, 0.021354669705033302, -0.02563362754881382, 0.031078871339559555, 0.010612040758132935, -0.032559216022491455, 0.01031105313450098, -0.03340640291571617, -0.005308591760694981, -0.03236876055598259, -0.021225130185484886, 0.01621415838599205, 0.005709103308618069, 0.05057680979371071, -0.0002858600055333227, -0.03168659284710884, 0.0062567805871367455, -0.03542183339595795, -0.04768582060933113, 0.019226444885134697, 0.023257752880454063, -0.000014487930457107723, -0.010426257736980915, -0.027066662907600403, 0.06267404556274414, 0.03102938085794449, -0.054272543638944626, -0.057041410356760025, 0.0016650165198370814, -0.015271943993866444, -0.030190013349056244, 0.014912177808582783, 0.016638077795505524, 0.00017523103451821953, 0.026891177520155907, 0.02271266095340252, -0.015278364531695843, 0.03524031490087509, 0.017231734469532967, -0.026630230247974396, -0.023250175639986992, 0.008971898816525936, -0.013793517835438251, 0.0220080204308033, 0.012429852038621902, -0.030003350228071213, 0.022704293951392174, -0.023921219632029533, 0.013540895655751228, -0.006958120968192816, -0.051288820803165436, -0.015195949003100395, -0.043352119624614716, 0.01507549174129963, -0.02382778748869896, 0.04080183058977127, -0.008279710076749325, -0.029410336166620255, 0.030849523842334747, 0.01036838162690401, 0.0125624043866992, 0.0015515980776399374, 0.012082328088581562, 0.03145435079932213, 0.03385873883962631, -0.025798652321100235, 0.00403230544179678, 0.0064474171958863735, 0.001482413150370121, 0.017856629565358162, -0.015879934653639793, -0.008004623465240002, 0.05056009441614151, 0.0037522867787629366, 0.008332840166985989, 0.014573357068002224, -0.03253444656729698, 0.004255570005625486, -0.09007233381271362, 0.02365739829838276, -0.025254471227526665, 0.05773446336388588, -0.00515767652541399, 0.03711728751659393, -0.0012459616409614682, -0.04916534200310707, 0.04482659697532654, 0.004365907050669193, -0.04155856370925903, 0.06356651335954666, 0.0004789842350874096, -0.023156510666012764, -0.006061404012143612, -0.012430110946297646, 0.022468363866209984, -0.042330142110586166, -0.0013271014904603362, -0.004856238141655922, 0.013722777366638184, -0.01557980477809906, 0.0037043902557343245, -0.061237893998622894, -0.010054751299321651, -0.0266391783952713, 0.018687311559915543, 0.016719691455364227, -0.019553564488887787, -0.010042701847851276, 0.058314427733421326, -0.018086016178131104, -0.025146203115582466, -0.045657023787498474, -0.023807022720575333, 0.02109977975487709, 0.05838310718536377, 0.0446939654648304, 0.026595482602715492, -0.026245666667819023, 0.02961973287165165, 0.004115327261388302, 0.0445273295044899, 0.06526542454957962, 0.013399580493569374, -0.03497884050011635, -0.025826377794146538, -0.003718787571415305, -0.00784345157444477, 0.017285510897636414, -0.017707765102386475, -0.01903533935546875, 0.046183571219444275, 0.03826282173395157, -0.058285538107156754, 0.03590584918856621, 0.10199052095413208, 0.023406678810715675, 0.007004181854426861, -0.02126915194094181, 0.0012659271014854312, -0.011275509372353554, -0.014133494347333908, 0.06132444366812706, -0.005873972550034523, 0.01648348569869995, 0.01386824157088995, 0.021505778655409813, -0.025251837447285652, -0.02435859851539135, 0.036727119237184525, 0.05162392184138298, 0.04175615310668945, 0.006368822883814573, -0.0678114965558052, -0.01274616364389658, 0.06435050815343857, 0.05339260399341583, 0.006850221194326878, -0.012494654394686222, -0.09801314026117325, 0.0030206989031285048, 0.05686197057366371, 0.04465063288807869, -0.03378457948565483, -0.030484933406114578, -0.04815475270152092, -0.011734707280993462, 0.031614355742931366, -0.0241229385137558, 0.02806842513382435, -0.027266645804047585, 0.03293305262923241, -0.02897021546959877, -0.002587652765214443, -0.04878317564725876, 0.025731466710567474, -0.009680857881903648, 0.035233333706855774, -0.0022945536766201258, -0.02864192984998226, -0.021387772634625435, 0.0034085670486092567, 0.0032847141847014427, 0.03014610894024372, -0.02752736769616604, -0.03719973564147949, 0.004628093913197517, 0.010646157898008823, 0.006944610737264156, -0.0344390869140625, 0.015811098739504814, 0.00791745912283659, -0.009439115412533283, 0.03615928441286087, -0.006592645309865475, -0.029203960672020912, 0.024311067536473274, 0.04273199662566185, -0.027154041454195976, -0.00028868834488093853, -0.02887365221977234, 0.02665562927722931, 0.015125620178878307, 0.024558259174227715, 0.030706100165843964, -0.006821039132773876, 0.030133763328194618, -0.04789448529481888, -0.04011199623346329, -0.00799555890262127, -0.01152162067592144, -0.05192093178629875, -0.06850411742925644, -0.006100806407630444, -0.015356423333287239, 0.03897790238261223, 0.004856153391301632, 0.006188222207129002, -0.05881418660283089, -0.0534355454146862, -0.006273382343351841, 0.0455571711063385, -0.044518984854221344, -0.011794481426477432, 0.00432167574763298, -0.0023172174114733934, -0.02946930192410946, -0.006486379075795412, 0.028286952525377274, -0.000039840084355091676, -0.012544315308332443, 0.003273110603913665, -0.022816127166152, 0.039342429488897324, 0.01308641117066145, -0.015452180989086628, 0.014353072270751, -0.013070695102214813, 0.017602263018488884, 0.006273849867284298, 0.05571943521499634, -0.029168738052248955, -0.051242075860500336, 0.0022553487215191126, 0.03869161009788513, -0.009835483506321907, 0.028825748711824417, -0.022826191037893295, 0.030690733343362808, -0.02680196426808834, -0.013125903904438019, -0.06396844238042831, -0.05373549833893776, 0.005292781628668308, -0.002223048359155655, -0.014255588874220848, -0.03825916349887848, -0.033466119319200516, -0.041640475392341614, -0.014957535080611706, -0.016340183094143867, 0.05840654671192169, -0.04579680785536766, 0.01223600935190916, 0.014025446027517319, -0.006376533769071102, 0.07471262663602829, 0.027038464322686195, 0.011556878685951233, 0.00903440173715353, -0.021655136719346046, -0.022749366238713264, 0.03213464841246605, 0.010681829415261745, -0.03878510743379593, 0.006275515537708998, -0.06397885829210281, 0.028607187792658806, 0.06337068974971771, -0.02956576831638813, -0.029447700828313828, 0.00116059766151011, 0.005034810397773981, 0.012301619164645672, -0.05951463803648949, 0.026716135442256927, -0.03507343679666519, 0.0012479431461542845, -0.012134457007050514, 0.015712229534983635, -0.011732022278010845, -0.0006295278435572982, 0.05850064009428024, -0.027808615937829018, 0.0020118490792810917, 0.0012516188435256481, 0.08661918342113495, -0.004808878526091576, 0.001939141540788114, -0.007652326952666044, -0.009795352816581726, 0.051822543144226074, -0.011620144359767437, 0.011602283455431461, 0.028211338445544243, 0.04500478133559227, -0.057323701679706573, -0.03043975867331028, -0.0011102947173640132, -0.019565630704164505, 0.040906380861997604, -0.03407856822013855, 0.045864831656217575, 0.03456372395157814, -0.00011324373190291226, -0.01702169142663479, -0.029683029279112816, -0.027208177372813225, -0.00760304182767868, -0.005188414826989174, 0.07768965512514114, -0.0044850236736238, -0.008952072821557522, 0.012427239678800106, -0.013227317482233047, 0.04329777881503105, 0.013150523416697979, 0.03182156756520271, 0.004084447864443064, 0.01150794792920351, 0.00589812221005559, -0.043728236109018326, 0.03256892040371895, -0.03704565018415451, -0.005472098011523485, -0.019018346443772316, -0.020710431039333344, 0.022507062181830406, 0.04133305698633194, 0.0074275522492825985, -0.03461987152695656, -0.020373636856675148, -0.07342279702425003, 0.03741889446973801, 0.023004842922091484, 0.0051443008705973625, 0.040049366652965546, 0.015403768047690392, 0.029870182275772095, 0.006528643891215324, 0.03498506546020508, -0.05388486385345459, -0.09255422651767731, -0.041012804955244064, -0.02796543389558792, -0.0034442241303622723, 0.028201986104249954, 0.02500900812447071, -0.004941537044942379, 0.026876548305153847, -0.029517171904444695, 0.03606625273823738, -0.02196316421031952, 0.03923424333333969, -0.012202335521578789, 0.045247647911310196, -0.006264070048928261, 0.010283279232680798, 0.006182799115777016, 0.008812416344881058, 0.10529731959104538, 0.07198727130889893, 0.05343806371092796, -0.10470101237297058, 0.05764418840408325, 0.01218313816934824, -0.014296474866569042, -0.028037898242473602, -0.0020520044490695, 0.028680799528956413, -0.006678038742393255, 0.02875402756035328, 0.031875018030405045, 0.003109130309894681, 0.010168185457587242, 0.05134836584329605, -0.035559918731451035, -0.0278831347823143, 0.011095601134002209, -0.0009265403496101499, -0.02899584174156189, -0.024742677807807922, -0.047525908797979355, -0.007667989935725927, 0.004713950678706169, -0.027489423751831055, -0.020753655582666397, -0.023811303079128265, 0.026472311466932297, 0.02447553351521492, 0.0019810397643595934, 0.010086588561534882, -0.013848906382918358, 0.0423319935798645, -0.005334282293915749, -0.04745946452021599, 0.0029932688921689987, -0.011017180979251862, 0.03685333952307701, 0.03805360198020935, -0.023355595767498016, -0.01577318273484707, -0.018576931208372116, 0.008703019469976425, -0.02652687020599842, -0.03671972453594208, -0.042345330119132996, 0.04380498826503754, 0.011133536696434021, -0.02401787042617798, 0.017577124759554863, 0.013539263047277927, 0.010823646560311317, -0.014495554380118847, -0.04554077610373497, 0.028852226212620735, 0.0003702212998177856, -0.04887143895030022, -0.021757418289780617, -0.027190402150154114, 0.03671550750732422, -0.028792941942811012, 0.005432106088846922, 0.012469861656427383, -0.018296152353286743, 0.001356156775727868, -0.04728041961789131, 0.03308871388435364, 0.00022393405379261822, 0.015830986201763153, 0.0028549563139677048, -0.027653342112898827, -0.009956397116184235, 0.012898930348455906, 0.04753383994102478, 0.03440369665622711, -0.010846083983778954, -0.019207391887903214, -0.0006457956042140722, -0.010155758820474148, -0.01741705648601055, 0.01473104115575552, -0.012566096149384975, -0.002118215663358569, -0.012903242371976376, -0.010481725446879864, 0.03148466721177101, 0.052124764770269394, 0.01567808724939823, -0.03384977579116821, -0.011362419463694096, 0.018351033329963684, -0.00735852774232626, -0.04011166840791702, -0.03679344430565834, 0.015352658927440643, -0.0525512732565403, 0.008481692522764206, -0.013622722588479519, 0.06205584481358528, 0.02754492498934269, 0.016368472948670387, -0.025314433500170708, 0.0586857832968235, -0.007329199928790331, 0.015886923298239708, 0.001333924476057291, -0.00741351256147027, -0.020139669999480247, -0.009184184484183788, -0.008035700768232346, 0.008986077271401882, -0.011803479865193367, -0.05002041533589363, -0.0403301939368248, 0.044652875512838364, -0.021258948370814323, -0.03614391013979912, 0.03623054921627045, -0.007114409934729338, -0.0020517795346677303, -0.04528473690152168, 0.029859015718102455, -0.016263850033283234, -0.03912460803985596, 0.011783083900809288, -0.060582492500543594, -0.014936035498976707, -0.00894306693226099, -0.013847130350768566, -0.020649313926696777, 0.0184156633913517, 0.001653687097132206, 0.02281920798122883, -0.03583948314189911, -0.00044965188135392964, 0.018358560279011726, 0.062457211315631866, -0.030161168426275253, -0.0019529166165739298, 0.028863433748483658, -0.04660918563604355, -0.024361710995435715, 0.005402503535151482, -0.03565791994333267, 0.036334168165922165, 0.01223845686763525, 0.005861994810402393, -0.007933815009891987, 0.0578814372420311, -0.009973260574042797, -0.014533977024257183, -0.003868842264637351, -0.006564093288034201, 0.025436900556087494, 0.00776499742642045, 0.029237668961286545, 0.011145922355353832, -0.018206099048256874, 0.02544821985065937, 0.03690849617123604, -0.0027611865662038326, -0.012711478397250175, 0.0016902206698432565, -0.00045891653280705214, 0.052672527730464935, 0.03383777663111687, 0.01330462284386158, 0.024845091626048088, 0.04548680782318115, -0.017294710502028465, 0.029449179768562317, -0.004853691905736923, 0.012404150329530239, -0.10715710371732712, -0.03229048103094101, 0.021134529262781143, 0.03899533674120903, 0.016625655815005302, -0.044416457414627075, -0.012505268678069115, 0.05632585659623146, -0.015192430466413498, 0.007501928135752678, 0.005337554961442947, 0.004558965098112822, -0.009252890944480896, 0.020345836877822876, -0.021741576492786407, -0.002507261699065566, 0.010135981254279613, 0.014195399358868599, -0.01166454516351223, 0.0026747032534331083, 0.015608858317136765, -0.012815603986382484, -0.026089457795023918, -0.0058320388197898865, 0.033839549869298935, -0.0619627982378006, 0.02472775988280773, -0.016817772760987282, -0.0331655815243721, 0.024848587810993195, 0.021139342337846756, 0.03707720711827278, 0.01813582144677639, 0.004297314211726189, 0.027753673493862152, 0.038151856511831284, 0.024150120094418526, 0.0029673187527805567, 0.013329282402992249, 0.0160387996584177, 0.02975379303097725, 0.036171335726976395, -0.036695417016744614, 0.0030420906841754913, 0.00033425490255467594, -0.0016164870467036963, -0.04878852888941765, 0.07232809066772461, -0.013356640003621578, -0.02134150266647339, -0.009172609075903893, 0.01346213836222887, 0.01815747655928135, -0.04526832327246666, -0.025862256065011024, -0.014389369636774063, 0.020160071551799774, 0.06153688579797745, 0.049679361283779144, -0.03202914819121361, 0.01084988284856081, -0.03438219055533409, -0.023181216791272163, 0.006573474500328302, -0.004825211130082607, -0.031658321619033813, -0.05065236613154411, 0.006608859170228243, 0.010477838106453419, -0.02233242429792881, -0.04745323956012726, -0.0068647731095552444, -0.03760306164622307, 0.044930294156074524, -0.01077253371477127, 0.016791870817542076, 0.014953285455703735, -0.004493432119488716, -0.008029825985431671, -0.08019107580184937, 0.04609466344118118, 0.032441962510347366, -0.022742684930562973, -0.05196310207247734, 0.03081534430384636, -0.02381773665547371, -0.0019507560646161437, 0.06031012162566185, 0.03612670302391052, 0.00786495115607977, -0.0024806023575365543, 0.01401632558554411, -0.02047089859843254, -0.06551950424909592, 0.03564300388097763, -0.0009372499771416187, -0.017032204195857048, -0.014302515424787998, -0.019338494166731834, -0.011068123392760754, 0.029682524502277374, 0.000634242023807019, 0.019361326470971107, 0.018901653587818146, 0.027142025530338287, -0.017567699775099754, 0.020559603348374367, -0.013652237132191658, 0.001855675014667213, 0.04367195814847946, -0.004393368028104305, 0.006719713564962149, 0.03959396481513977, 0.012703480198979378, -0.04915301874279976, 0.03315342590212822, -0.060231491923332214, 0.014705401845276356, -0.011388719081878662, 0.02180618979036808, -0.009225135669112206, -0.0656074807047844, 0.02475421503186226, 0.013640650548040867, -0.004780903924256563, 0.006275479216128588, 0.03014945611357689, 0.018137654289603233, 0.0490962415933609, -0.030397355556488037, -0.007438495755195618, 0.010136325843632221, -0.033593907952308655, -0.009900333359837532, 0.011795468628406525, 0.06698443740606308, -0.014521530829370022, 0.01400867011398077, 0.05630434677004814, 0.006719284690916538, 0.00645456463098526, -0.015418549999594688, 0.07015510648488998, -0.02775404043495655, 0.003863199846819043, 0.008925764821469784, -0.015978021547198296, 0.04422350972890854, -0.0004665151936933398, -0.007913827896118164, 0.05476147308945656, -0.0745796412229538, -0.0025690272450447083, -0.07252278923988342, -0.027575548738241196, -0.009302477352321148, 0.027458207681775093, 0.02380695939064026, 0.033520519733428955, 0.015676574781537056, 0.01270010694861412, -0.01793542504310608, -0.02766096591949463, 0.0031011009123176336, 0.02131851762533188, 0.00554297398775816, -0.03259507939219475, -0.0028721776325255632, -0.012781290337443352, -0.018087223172187805, -0.027847273275256157, -0.013259788043797016, 0.01619015820324421, 0.08510368317365646, 0.030545439571142197, -0.032518841326236725, -0.018905580043792725, -0.0058599803596735, 0.017156237736344337, -0.07395622879266739, -0.0089963898062706, -0.040575604885816574, 0.006180521100759506, 0.0050634159706532955, -0.024764539673924446 ]
<p>I have some project categories $(PC_1, ... ,PC_n)$ and some institutions $(I_1, ..., I_n)$ and would like to determine how fairly projects are assigned to institutions and their project categories by some external sources.</p> <p>I was thinking about using some chi square based measure for this. Basically I have a two dimensional contingency table where one dimension corresponds to the project categories and the other to the institutions. Each cell of the contingency table counts the number of projects that each institution ‘runs’ for a particular project category.</p> <p>I could determine $(O – E)\cdot|O-E|/E$ for each cell. Here:</p> <ul> <li>$O$ is the observer number of projects</li> <li>$E$ is the expected number of projects</li> </ul> <p>IMHO this would give me a value for each cell which indicates how much the observed value differs from the expected value and thus how fairly the resources were assigned for an institution and project category. In other words a negative value indicates ‘unfairness’, a positive value indicates ‘favouritism’ and a value close to zero indicates ‘fairness’. What do you think?</p>
35,719
[ -0.024160651490092278, 0.005256539210677147, -0.03625136986374855, -0.017987141385674477, 0.05878331884741783, 0.009797939099371433, 0.0071746548637747765, 0.0017378763295710087, 0.01475563459098339, 0.012177083641290665, 0.05059690773487091, 0.030356550589203835, 0.04822452738881111, 0.027626371011137962, 0.011486806906759739, -0.007223246619105339, -0.01747618056833744, 0.018448546528816223, -0.0370003841817379, -0.005187292583286762, 0.04071752727031708, 0.025685688480734825, 0.012502838857471943, 0.01642448455095291, -0.06449717283248901, 0.06754518300294876, -0.00004622845153789967, -0.015154397115111351, -0.03663058951497078, 0.055565692484378815, -0.0027542971074581146, -0.008220730349421501, 0.01940944604575634, 0.0007413489511236548, 0.00004692085713031702, -0.010449669323861599, -0.0136646693572402, -0.03045377880334854, -0.005060912575572729, 0.02396523393690586, -0.021328583359718323, -0.00592647073790431, 0.008713953197002411, 0.01842811331152916, 0.018240543082356453, 0.009192022494971752, 0.001610361272469163, -0.023274226114153862, 0.003155316924676299, -0.03542365878820419, 0.047815218567848206, 0.004879474174231291, 0.0206769946962595, -0.010585814714431763, -0.0061547099612653255, -0.030100993812084198, -0.0001631724735489115, 0.056916460394859314, -0.010795453563332558, -0.021050522103905678, 0.025539688766002655, 0.0044066584669053555, 0.008442087098956108, -0.014089638367295265, -0.018615195527672768, 0.020879307761788368, 0.009510012343525887, -0.04560559615492821, 0.04068101942539215, -0.00980545487254858, 0.004939874168485403, 0.020679302513599396, 0.0139590660110116, -0.021025070920586586, 0.018829334527254105, -0.043174996972084045, 0.0035647337790578604, 0.0009829062037169933, 0.003399400506168604, 0.03190420940518379, -0.03622917830944061, 0.014849823899567127, -0.016068128868937492, 0.052773237228393555, 0.03491610661149025, -0.03970916196703911, 0.04709164798259735, -0.07795126736164093, 0.0206956434994936, 0.011373358778655529, -0.006762471981346607, -0.017097707837820053, 0.033770374953746796, 0.000813925638794899, -0.058331508189439774, 0.024437222629785538, -0.016748476773500443, 0.038040775805711746, 0.0025511456187814474, -0.004724238533526659, -0.004074690863490105, -0.035849954932928085, 0.025898216292262077, 0.036197807639837265, -0.04942796006798744, 0.0013004124630242586, -0.027928223833441734, 0.027558762580156326, -0.01257372461259365, -0.006736119743436575, 0.0006055222474969923, 0.027612818405032158, 0.06249338015913963, 0.04861217364668846, 0.013383529148995876, -0.027002552524209023, 0.00008742790669202805, -0.02936670556664467, 0.031597886234521866, 0.050625164061784744, 0.031030649319291115, -0.03882189840078354, 0.03828878700733185, 0.0011436017230153084, -0.06330180913209915, 0.02677781693637371, 0.04908176511526108, -0.010780151933431625, -0.0426621176302433, 0.05811058357357979, 0.04176035523414612, 0.01458258181810379, 0.021338380873203278, 0.016404008492827415, 0.02606099098920822, 0.008013730868697166, -0.09845470637083054, -0.0872889831662178, 0.023756299167871475, 0.010416141711175442, -0.007088252808898687, -0.06199684739112854, -0.05699063464999199, -0.007161092013120651, 0.08806471526622772, -0.01960858330130577, 0.02478993684053421, 0.00045230722753331065, 0.03155355527997017, 0.03094707429409027, -0.017569245770573616, 0.012122660875320435, -0.026174258440732956, -0.04082315415143967, -0.003949948586523533, -0.05933263525366783, 0.0318172313272953, 0.022680247202515602, -0.011940189637243748, 0.0015738316578790545, 0.013491721823811531, 0.022576551884412766, -0.01582430675625801, -0.013184203766286373, 0.011131049133837223, -0.021006926894187927, 0.07962401956319809, -0.018127882853150368, 0.011465683579444885, -0.0013377964496612549, 0.025668082758784294, 0.02372664399445057, 0.0435536727309227, 0.021143805235624313, 0.05670560151338577, -0.032676827162504196, 0.02475184202194214, -0.017468128353357315, -0.0006604563095606863, -0.014334178529679775, -0.03820352256298065, -0.02515852265059948, -0.00497956108301878, -0.002638021716848016, 0.03622857853770256, 0.04903833940625191, 0.006535809952765703, -0.010446631349623203, 0.0641852468252182, -0.06257537007331848, -0.05114378780126572, -0.0777854397892952, 0.00273546832613647, 0.007542084902524948, -0.041607193648815155, 0.01975417695939541, -0.019183481112122536, -0.02596133016049862, -0.0037459596060216427, 0.0013064895756542683, -0.0002227527293143794, 0.00555769307538867, 0.018581636250019073, -0.06016124412417412, -0.014733516611158848, 0.052207350730895996, 0.017002306878566742, 0.011716492474079132, 0.05800771340727806, -0.054021451622247696, -0.08612442761659622, -0.00036285401438362896, -0.03768393397331238, 0.03604986146092415, -0.008087331429123878, 0.015834221616387367, -0.014739727601408958, 0.006331195589154959, -0.018654562532901764, 0.03916745260357857, -0.04182109236717224, 0.0633447915315628, 0.06973259150981903, 0.017218120396137238, 0.025727827101945877, 0.017118874937295914, 0.005789499264210463, 0.02538103424012661, -0.009711532853543758, -0.014839459210634232, -0.04765665531158447, 0.0174330435693264, 0.005540890619158745, 0.008907195180654526, -0.041825536638498306, 0.02521774172782898, 0.00810396857559681, -0.004461543168872595, 0.0035147094167768955, -0.00203114515170455, -0.021037623286247253, 0.015089410357177258, 0.004677364602684975, 0.017117401584982872, -0.012702957727015018, 0.03739234432578087, 0.013273773714900017, -0.0008072728523984551, 0.003940091002732515, -0.021534258499741554, -0.02555333636701107, 0.040121786296367645, -0.011224254965782166, 0.016467178240418434, -0.017822738736867905, -0.01939387060701847, 0.05503867566585541, 0.004664476495236158, 0.0008077232050709426, 0.0409519225358963, -0.007689300924539566, -0.005730293691158295, 0.023981858044862747, -0.028821444138884544, 0.01598137803375721, -0.0033868649043142796, -0.06349163502454758, 0.007058123126626015, 0.03411133587360382, 0.01108649279922247, 0.04774351790547371, -0.004883300978690386, -0.001144322333857417, -0.07446636259555817, 0.010967884212732315, 0.02934740111231804, -0.00011431158782215789, -0.016428722068667412, -0.00484138960018754, -0.02260671742260456, -0.02819555066525936, -0.010302315466105938, 0.01812669076025486, 0.03537268191576004, -0.0010590020101517439, -0.008754602633416653, -0.026406588032841682, -0.026053154841065407, 0.03332914412021637, -0.012008474208414555, -0.013214712031185627, 0.06037192419171333, 0.011004075407981873, -0.010774459689855576, 0.005923909600824118, -0.006180528551340103, -0.024567805230617523, -0.03530557453632355, -0.06684090942144394, 0.009436334483325481, 0.019926033914089203, -0.030654989182949066, 0.0437505766749382, -0.047060560435056686, -0.020616518333554268, 0.020504573360085487, 0.024007713422179222, 0.019042568281292915, 0.01317740697413683, 0.022072676569223404, 0.03180777654051781, 0.019238878041505814, -0.042353078722953796, -0.0744723528623581, -0.054989006370306015, 0.0019486350938677788, -0.011929932981729507, 0.024456895887851715, 0.0271266121417284, -0.028951264917850494, 0.06269524246454239, 0.0644657090306282, -0.023633325472474098, -0.062009476125240326, -0.03590134531259537, -0.031902093440294266, -0.004400584846735001, -0.0010226648300886154, 0.039586391299963, -0.010949550196528435, 0.013587393797934055, 0.018473373726010323, 0.03402546048164368, 0.03959400951862335, -0.0052277809008955956, -0.0033996261190623045, -0.005803436506539583, -0.012969265691936016, -0.029518431052565575, 0.03151107579469681, 0.02403366006910801, -0.030002932995557785, 0.01179893221706152, 0.018583904951810837, 0.030209286138415337, 0.0070488532073795795, -0.029728874564170837, -0.03159224987030029, -0.034362565726041794, 0.016022376716136932, -0.001427765586413443, 0.04889792203903198, 0.03726464509963989, 0.019264671951532364, -0.005308995954692364, 0.014152729883790016, -0.00684778206050396, -0.052645713090896606, 0.004321059212088585, 0.08856834471225739, 0.010932516306638718, 0.015617053024470806, 0.0048591746017336845, -0.05429030954837799, 0.01948905922472477, 0.02742762863636017, -0.058364517986774445, -0.02040979452431202, 0.02191515825688839, 0.03676730394363403, 0.02637692540884018, -0.02180604822933674, -0.017484091222286224, 0.0007938669295981526, -0.05803419649600983, -0.015114586800336838, -0.03993534296751022, 0.07986617833375931, 0.0046358839608728886, 0.017348507419228554, -0.02021053619682789, -0.010852615348994732, -0.020778337493538857, -0.009213382378220558, -0.0429723896086216, 0.005103160627186298, -0.036328721791505814, 0.030854584649205208, -0.01017745304852724, -0.001404368318617344, 0.020778387784957886, -0.0055701881647109985, 0.014071560464799404, -0.0020831706933677197, 0.021776555106043816, -0.005499690305441618, 0.0342964269220829, -0.042346350848674774, -0.008952692151069641, -0.0006339821266010404, -0.017346445471048355, 0.02629109099507332, -0.0030573164112865925, 0.06254325062036514, -0.0268368199467659, -0.016513751819729805, -0.013184580020606518, -0.015878841280937195, -0.015172535553574562, 0.03009556233882904, 0.007045740727335215, -0.021222997456789017, 0.010176829062402248, -0.025102965533733368, 0.03335504233837128, -0.045230455696582794, 0.04780780151486397, 0.03923942148685455, -0.000405716709792614, 0.011938482522964478, -0.0037859485018998384, -0.03273271769285202, -0.0014964269939810038, 0.04136763513088226, 0.04111359268426895, -0.004900888539850712, 0.04739506542682648, 0.049037523567676544, -0.03150549530982971, -0.006454499904066324, 0.06873992085456848, 0.05082876980304718, -0.01081043854355812, -0.008836308494210243, -0.006897048093378544, -0.01182802114635706, -0.0366281196475029, -0.01085899118334055, 0.009148415178060532, 0.033420003950595856, 0.003806209657341242, 0.028698893263936043, 0.0052582076750695705, -0.031016802415251732, 0.011613704264163971, -0.010122230276465416, 0.031919367611408234, 0.00663911085575819, -0.02342892438173294, 0.015306506305932999, 0.037913233041763306, 0.016237545758485794, 0.047171611338853836, 0.005334766581654549, -0.0930190458893776, 0.004000378306955099, 0.03676572069525719, 0.024713201448321342, -0.024782592430710793, -0.058023601770401, -0.02409052848815918, -0.009484418667852879, 0.0223249364644289, -0.02562265656888485, 0.015473423525691032, -0.01530641783028841, 0.014536050148308277, -0.05582387372851372, 0.011953890323638916, -0.02877373807132244, 0.01694762147963047, 0.01118032168596983, 0.022618211805820465, -0.025311725214123726, -0.045282378792762756, -0.038084276020526886, 0.0009892885573208332, 0.05724106729030609, 0.0016858094604685903, -0.013949362561106682, -0.041517164558172226, 0.01785670407116413, 0.07215876132249832, -0.03635702282190323, -0.04270002245903015, 0.016502579674124718, 0.03625209629535675, 0.02446816675364971, 0.05887327715754509, -0.003480165731161833, -0.021329445764422417, -0.014983557164669037, -0.02578083798289299, -0.03930589184165001, 0.00862962193787098, -0.04352208226919174, 0.06697740405797958, 0.02197110839188099, -0.01758633367717266, 0.0531255342066288, 0.05560846999287605, -0.05753154307603836, -0.013372989371418953, -0.0299749244004488, 0.028582878410816193, -0.0023192879743874073, 0.02705855295062065, -0.006697255186736584, 0.0027016063686460257, -0.03808806091547012, 0.00022491466370411217, 0.011189034208655357, 0.07881635427474976, -0.01783817447721958, -0.01859586127102375, 0.00460467766970396, 0.012623091228306293, -0.027545087039470673, -0.004994450137019157, 0.01894373632967472, 0.013443773612380028, 0.031502094119787216, -0.035090893507003784, 0.007039302494376898, -0.011375799775123596, 0.039930492639541626, 0.002863159403204918, -0.033090416342020035, 0.027427317574620247, -0.06383202224969864, -0.0019303126027807593, 0.01614909991621971, 0.00293111614882946, 0.040805425494909286, -0.026076121255755424, 0.0497468039393425, 0.015816425904631615, 0.02224830538034439, -0.02546229213476181, 0.06073172762989998, 0.007630154490470886, 0.02588268555700779, -0.023271989077329636, 0.005442512687295675, 0.01978525146842003, -0.001218383084051311, -0.07591041922569275, -0.0299206655472517, -0.010219171643257141, -0.01493037585169077, -0.023147117346525192, -0.011652633547782898, -0.03866150975227356, 0.026406828314065933, -0.042299460619688034, -0.02492433227598667, 0.07419054955244064, -0.008055740967392921, -0.009046908468008041, -0.004141660872846842, -0.015443168580532074, 0.08095889538526535, -0.021916724741458893, -0.027842171490192413, -0.012757984921336174, -0.026231132447719574, -0.01400599256157875, -0.011212700977921486, 0.010276439599692822, -0.048998020589351654, -0.013541342690587044, 0.0002621221065055579, 0.013406479731202126, 0.03325500339269638, 0.016001706942915916, -0.010711360722780228, -0.00535002863034606, -0.049668874591588974, -0.010722730308771133, 0.004526255186647177, -0.006828833371400833, 0.014010821469128132, -0.015619311481714249, -0.02864072658121586, -0.011658365838229656, -0.031346049159765244, -0.0016407521907240152, -0.013490025885403156, 0.03195450082421303, -0.023308662697672844, 0.010279462672770023, 0.03276985511183739, 0.014353988692164421, -0.04627399891614914, 0.014046277850866318, 0.008502280339598656, 0.04280664026737213, 0.00564843975007534, -0.017106637358665466, 0.004102752078324556, 0.03145484998822212, -0.020695680752396584, -0.005449358373880386, -0.03465200960636139, -0.014451039023697376, 0.050572723150253296, -0.012517556548118591, 0.05780312418937683, 0.03767860308289528, 0.021086785942316055, -0.03315688669681549, -0.018254071474075317, 0.0011616786941885948, 0.011922087520360947, 0.036714594811201096, 0.018099060282111168, -0.0464269183576107, -0.0011013501789420843, 0.02089044451713562, 0.009633354842662811, 0.004021947737783194, 0.04070026054978371, 0.005330903455615044, 0.013449272140860558, 0.0444030687212944, -0.028515195474028587, -0.02875712513923645, 0.059539929032325745, -0.034216299653053284, -0.008336317725479603, -0.03507096320390701, -0.06302487850189209, 0.028554189950227737, 0.05603272095322609, -0.04100561887025833, -0.047696422785520554, -0.021775877103209496, -0.06165265664458275, -0.008351996541023254, 0.010624300688505173, 0.0023052121978253126, -0.0050216480158269405, -0.016993440687656403, 0.019067607820034027, 0.0013011092087253928, 0.016907138749957085, -0.06076188012957573, -0.0410262756049633, -0.0045840018428862095, -0.01002482045441866, -0.04304414987564087, -0.0075567360036075115, 0.012344718910753727, 0.00824282318353653, 0.012239480391144753, -0.036840956658124924, 0.0017131281783804297, -0.008150280453264713, 0.017707958817481995, -0.012006754986941814, 0.053905703127384186, -0.004111031070351601, -0.010722354054450989, 0.0005730044795200229, -0.010654976591467857, 0.1266585886478424, 0.061212632805109024, 0.05543310567736626, -0.050087593495845795, 0.034173447638750076, 0.025562753900885582, -0.016033872961997986, -0.03997384011745453, 0.038208868354558945, -0.019657881930470467, 0.017235346138477325, 0.03031439334154129, 0.06529258191585541, 0.06445460766553879, -0.0034536405000835657, 0.07444658130407333, -0.006775213405489922, -0.02487604133784771, 0.007550064008682966, 0.0005555665120482445, -0.009369747713208199, -0.02887413091957569, -0.02997598610818386, 0.052248936146497726, 0.05916466936469078, 0.02333892323076725, -0.017430927604436874, 0.003760650986805558, -0.0020285635255277157, -0.04927065595984459, -0.016756244003772736, 0.03149786964058876, 0.029718484729528427, 0.0034627974964678288, -0.024925781413912773, -0.008465022780001163, -0.008402345702052116, -0.02832331694662571, 0.015869971364736557, 0.043356552720069885, 0.025376178324222565, -0.024621764197945595, 0.03861801698803902, 0.01567678339779377, -0.029483141377568245, -0.015277926810085773, -0.050218939781188965, 0.0376293919980526, 0.013674480840563774, -0.03439139574766159, -0.031066259369254112, -0.011994744651019573, 0.007580135483294725, -0.022733760997653008, -0.038657233119010925, 0.0021519684232771397, 0.021208709105849266, -0.019677089527249336, -0.006782636512070894, 0.017272982746362686, 0.015301261097192764, -0.020137900486588478, 0.013124716468155384, 0.018226521089673042, -0.028414087370038033, -0.0422314777970314, -0.02838776633143425, 0.0970405787229538, 0.006838125642389059, -0.023210128769278526, 0.0064133545383811, -0.027441125363111496, -0.03549438342452049, -0.01798969693481922, -0.04332705959677696, -0.0017904373817145824, 0.04944753274321556, 0.002492963569238782, -0.043326493352651596, 0.008503892458975315, -0.023160625249147415, 0.02267128974199295, -0.0287043247371912, -0.003361821174621582, -0.03923613205552101, -0.0102755231782794, 0.029006043449044228, -0.010902924463152885, 0.021611252799630165, 0.033744119107723236, 0.032883141189813614, 0.08320263028144836, 0.013476194813847542, -0.03244037926197052, -0.020911697298288345, -0.05128953605890274, -0.05305980518460274, 0.021045148372650146, 0.009100770577788353, 0.05969514325261116, -0.009026830084621906, 0.0042849513702094555, -0.021553155034780502, 0.08104296028614044, 0.010849262587726116, 0.015902839601039886, 0.021090533584356308, -0.07912193238735199, -0.015484458766877651, -0.010308317840099335, -0.005515451543033123, -0.025507714599370956, 0.0007297371630556881, -0.02894231677055359, -0.0447993203997612, 0.015662655234336853, -0.030138714239001274, -0.027312494814395905, -0.016599271446466446, -0.06227871775627136, 0.0476226806640625, -0.004097719676792622, -0.013067846186459064, -0.04012126103043556, -0.02268691547214985, 0.008087134920060635, -0.01640278659760952, -0.005127664655447006, 0.022360166534781456, 0.008361537009477615, 0.0023061903193593025, 0.008943680673837662, -0.006335197947919369, 0.0139992143958807, 0.010867241770029068, 0.01283499225974083, 0.022118056192994118, 0.04965299367904663, -0.022516373544931412, -0.01952369138598442, 0.03941154479980469, -0.011829488910734653, -0.027396826073527336, 0.026781899854540825, -0.02232491597533226, 0.04915643110871315, 0.008536378853023052, -0.01469456311315298, -0.03219236433506012, -0.0006677005439996719, -0.03821408003568649, -0.03556610643863678, -0.030179690569639206, -0.007090695668011904, -0.021527636796236038, -0.036644645035266876, 0.002827404299750924, -0.008002275601029396, -0.017210310325026512, -0.0015652735019102693, 0.05452051758766174, -0.009821091778576374, -0.0026182583533227444, -0.05065646395087242, -0.00815752986818552, 0.010336044244468212, 0.010125342756509781, -0.004715482238680124, -0.021815946325659752, 0.0463012158870697, -0.04309818148612976, -0.0018834637012332678, -0.015344623476266861, 0.02348952181637287, -0.0593649260699749, -0.026411034166812897, 0.018448127433657646, -0.007644168101251125, 0.006618240848183632, -0.04683306813240051, 0.02727060206234455, 0.02141292206943035, -0.04243665933609009, 0.042252931743860245, -0.002085776999592781, -0.031349506229162216, -0.05048219487071037, 0.0407862663269043, -0.04189272224903107, -0.0023278684820979834, 0.007533293683081865, 0.009115437977015972, 0.01284149382263422, 0.024545008316636086, 0.01825469546020031, -0.011501636356115341, 0.010365416295826435, -0.008241233415901661, 0.017974810674786568, -0.04813341796398163, 0.04325277358293533, -0.0061224098317325115, -0.05114259198307991, 0.04933323711156845, 0.0007548951543867588, -0.0018518833676353097, 0.006253437139093876, 0.02413833700120449, 0.04367170110344887, 0.07029615342617035, 0.04595603421330452, -0.007035695947706699, -0.041600681841373444, -0.0002675470896065235, 0.03136184811592102, 0.027917493134737015, -0.0027727067936211824, 0.05360211431980133, 0.06307999044656754, 0.025257542729377747, -0.008545046672224998, 0.007986648939549923, 0.0018593176500871778, -0.03225595876574516, 0.004489043261855841, -0.06797760725021362, 0.029952941462397575, -0.0012700783554464579, 0.04282610863447189, -0.05951336398720741, 0.02660784311592579, -0.010994154028594494, 0.013466674834489822, -0.0018834394868463278, 0.0004466479877009988, 0.0032571519259363413, -0.03600691258907318, 0.011814119294285774, 0.013158881105482578, 0.007196186576038599, -0.06318605691194534, -0.03579419478774071, -0.03639230504631996, -0.016327885910868645, -0.007154127582907677, -0.026529181748628616, -0.01726471073925495, 0.03419679030776024, -0.033562395721673965, -0.0008837625500746071, 0.05261775106191635, 0.006887009367346764, 0.04918733984231949, -0.06241399422287941, 0.024070385843515396, 0.0013777439016848803, 0.010592320002615452, 0.003680068301036954, -0.01187179796397686, -0.07790815085172653, 0.019879771396517754, 0.07534940540790558, 0.0063014947809278965, -0.010956834070384502, -0.0060391779989004135, 0.033432308584451675, 0.009589032270014286, -0.04705248400568962, 0.03324444591999054, -0.0325840525329113, -0.0006459244177676737, -0.022985972464084625, -0.025448879227042198, 0.02009694278240204, -0.014866442419588566, 0.02530418150126934, -0.008391893468797207, -0.017503906041383743, -0.007795695215463638, -0.015368529595434666, 0.03189351409673691, -0.0018136902945116162, 0.0020029854495078325, 0.04280876740813255, 0.02420045994222164, 0.007320931181311607, -0.017942283302545547, -0.00041436805622652173, -0.053722038865089417, 0.08032001554965973, -0.026258835569024086, -0.02684970386326313, 0.00837025698274374, 0.017034096643328667, 0.021700456738471985, -0.07095734775066376, -0.03033551014959812, 0.0223576370626688, -0.04355253279209137, 0.006928741000592709, 0.030358564108610153, 0.00967740174382925, 0.0002500496048014611, 0.014789620414376259, 0.026458431035280228, -0.03744541108608246, -0.02122255600988865, 0.014564614742994308, 0.038189735263586044, 0.03347688540816307, 0.02279597893357277, 0.0073686633259058, 0.027263350784778595, -0.009201700799167156, 0.014623051509261131, 0.030655885115265846, 0.0009732078178785741, 0.02901645004749298, -0.0017095596995204687, 0.04012254625558853, 0.015082700178027153, 0.014595710672438145, -0.027286723256111145, -0.023664748296141624, 0.050750184804201126, 0.005895543377846479, 0.02524961717426777, -0.07378063350915909, 0.0019566600676625967, -0.02286713942885399, 0.0095497015863657, -0.0074069201946258545, 0.04156595841050148, -0.022351816296577454, 0.0017890657763928175, -0.00954833161085844, 0.014274816028773785, 0.007111689075827599, -0.032355546951293945, 0.03496856614947319, -0.029149848967790604, -0.0016377177089452744, 0.014379937201738358, -0.02129569835960865, -0.007095250766724348, -0.028451310470700264, 0.05264311283826828, 0.03516269475221634, 0.02730984054505825, -0.00473235547542572, -0.031076261773705482, 0.04665322229266167, 0.053146082907915115, -0.04386284947395325, -0.045987412333488464, -0.03835645318031311, 0.026161981746554375, 0.013942860066890717, -0.026501381769776344 ]
<p>I'm playing with support vector machines (SVM) using the e1071::svm() function in R, and I encountered a scenario where I asked it for a leave-one-out cross-validated classification of a 2-category response and obtained a total accuracy of 38% (35/90), which, given 90 samples, ends up with a 95% confidence interval that is <strong>below</strong> chance. Should I consider this a fluke, and if not, how is it possible for an SVM to become anti-predictive?</p> <p>In case it matters, I used default values for the cost and gamma parameters, and the data predicting the response was a 8192 item vector representing 500 milliseconds of electroencephalogram data collected across 64 electrodes. </p>
35,721
[ -0.020517498254776, -0.041681233793497086, -0.0023488153237849474, -0.02019122801721096, 0.01414512936025858, -0.049646247178316116, -0.019411148503422737, 0.033964674919843674, 0.051955293864011765, -0.013571933843195438, 0.034576017409563065, 0.015949858352541924, 0.05608542636036873, 0.059646476060152054, -0.017212936654686928, 0.014259451068937778, 0.01860998384654522, 0.009021516889333725, 0.02102155238389969, -0.005794551223516464, -0.02208499237895012, 0.0024951633531600237, -0.029417095705866814, -0.023514188826084137, -0.011367293074727058, 0.05492805689573288, 0.0268048457801342, -0.011060148477554321, -0.0008272831328213215, 0.07069382816553116, -0.06092802807688713, -0.052539288997650146, 0.01634129136800766, 0.021607350558042526, 0.02106470800936222, 0.00000779848596721422, -0.024478623643517494, -0.03114323318004608, 0.0004517927300184965, 0.05873921141028404, 0.022124117240309715, 0.00798838771879673, -0.009485366754233837, 0.08187593519687653, -0.03199027478694916, 0.019036568701267242, -0.04134271666407585, -0.034270044416189194, 0.038092974573373795, -0.006293607410043478, 0.05721702426671982, -0.015883654356002808, 0.0495012141764164, 0.022862296551465988, -0.022227004170417786, 0.01475736778229475, 0.08327730745077133, 0.05519658327102661, -0.009830367751419544, -0.062493063509464264, -0.02755536139011383, -0.025317711755633354, -0.009083750657737255, -0.019992195069789886, -0.006542854011058807, 0.04016541317105293, 0.02738375961780548, -0.023600339889526367, 0.04169490188360214, -0.010412520729005337, 0.013556036166846752, 0.020988833159208298, -0.013695674017071724, 0.006846346892416477, 0.03610469773411751, -0.023719100281596184, 0.008515306748449802, 0.015565062873065472, 0.013205236755311489, 0.03893443942070007, 0.012075306847691536, 0.009316345676779747, 0.024266233667731285, 0.03809472918510437, 0.022765761241316795, -0.007566266227513552, 0.028419461101293564, -0.024301493540406227, -0.006032553501427174, 0.023342974483966827, -0.03518557921051979, 0.05943267419934273, 0.029689690098166466, 0.00816700141876936, -0.06058220565319061, 0.043481115251779556, -0.012833656743168831, 0.029640791937708855, 0.03480656445026398, -0.015530452132225037, -0.016682947054505348, 0.0031398057471960783, 0.03625746816396713, 0.028245968744158745, -0.05911971628665924, -0.010981877334415913, -0.023488609120249748, -0.011486262083053589, -0.013207241892814636, -0.0325196199119091, 0.015084343031048775, 0.026120837777853012, 0.0185023732483387, 0.013125238008797169, 0.019776124507188797, -0.008030532859265804, -0.04872424900531769, -0.031024623662233353, 0.021050691604614258, 0.024762079119682312, 0.025166910141706467, -0.003757328959181905, -0.010105172172188759, -0.03373377025127411, -0.01097625121474266, 0.002468134043738246, 0.04750186949968338, -0.017827875912189484, -0.05581236630678177, 0.05097390338778496, 0.006703042425215244, -0.04573853686451912, 0.04117919132113457, -0.03673326224088669, 0.010843894444406033, -0.02360421046614647, -0.10217072814702988, -0.06110658869147301, 0.018537994474172592, -0.009310895577073097, -0.016740653663873672, -0.04037351906299591, -0.019941503182053566, 0.012790998443961143, 0.0483325757086277, 0.01470367331057787, 0.05202878639101982, 0.0014886801363900304, 0.0389547161757946, 0.02533157914876938, -0.06285076588392258, 0.012391160242259502, -0.038499265909194946, 0.004399019759148359, -0.04529640078544617, -0.025196289643645287, 0.024189643561840057, -0.004977515432983637, 0.009695623070001602, 0.013640156015753746, -0.03708779439330101, -0.0190053042024374, -0.013254155404865742, -0.032677795737981796, -0.006200916133821011, -0.047052331268787384, 0.053833745419979095, 0.022932741791009903, 0.00292963907122612, 0.001035381923429668, -0.03909800946712494, 0.01187719777226448, 0.053427353501319885, 0.025382474064826965, 0.03843562677502632, 0.03020813874900341, 0.020630870014429092, -0.04206804558634758, 0.05046563968062401, 0.001457294332794845, -0.015241919085383415, -0.010003033094108105, -0.019089389592409134, 0.01795763149857521, -0.0046366360038518906, 0.06128614395856857, -0.03208804875612259, -0.039787497371435165, 0.0409076027572155, -0.006461771670728922, -0.03418567404150963, -0.035551849752664566, 0.015231683850288391, 0.004114849958568811, -0.02729443646967411, 0.060731422156095505, 0.013770248740911484, 0.016255635768175125, 0.014471122995018959, -0.0030440352857112885, -0.03955445811152458, 0.00952682550996542, 0.0428105853497982, -0.05677470564842224, -0.01651737093925476, 0.04490126669406891, -0.003148469841107726, -0.035007722675800323, 0.021235009655356407, -0.022393865510821342, -0.10453213006258011, 0.00015255494508892298, -0.01781223900616169, 0.02750403620302677, -0.00653478316962719, -0.03762590512633324, 0.011342435143887997, -0.014389044605195522, -0.028373515233397484, 0.048006024211645126, -0.047915372997522354, 0.046268392354249954, 0.042347148060798645, -0.015662550926208496, -0.019327031448483467, -0.008526424877345562, 0.01080966368317604, 0.006195989437401295, -0.007199276238679886, -0.004283166490495205, -0.027295000851154327, 0.00158183672465384, 0.03544037416577339, 0.02477537840604782, 0.016753479838371277, -0.014107161201536655, -0.003610647516325116, 0.00560024892911315, 0.012998820282518864, 0.018288740888237953, 0.004662372171878815, -0.01998504437506199, 0.022738803178071976, 0.0230756513774395, 0.0027085738256573677, -0.015605073422193527, 0.02424319088459015, -0.0029094526544213295, -0.021448355168104172, 0.011508258059620857, -0.006411516573280096, 0.043137021362781525, 0.01027337834239006, 0.010223268531262875, 0.020828472450375557, -0.013753790408372879, 0.04790642485022545, -0.01744299754500389, 0.01910628378391266, 0.03566707298159599, 0.02591828815639019, 0.014782052487134933, -0.004726982209831476, -0.021654682233929634, 0.06134011223912239, 0.07691125571727753, -0.03127528354525566, 0.003852949244901538, 0.03433673456311226, -0.05055902525782585, -0.00019989866996183991, -0.017427751794457436, -0.018052613362669945, -0.03715120628476143, 0.03418750688433647, 0.03330056741833687, 0.006000007968395948, 0.018626928329467773, -0.0181272029876709, -0.024656105786561966, 0.0226910300552845, -0.03494565561413765, 0.03772193565964699, 0.015881991013884544, -0.04164401441812515, -0.0067811994813382626, -0.041117895394563675, -0.01491085160523653, 0.016448795795440674, -0.0007868187967687845, -0.02892172895371914, 0.03788438439369202, -0.024482864886522293, -0.04123593866825104, 0.0005739983171224594, -0.0361497662961483, -0.007764098234474659, 0.005045375786721706, -0.03708091750741005, 0.03799710422754288, -0.01090332679450512, -0.05475441738963127, 0.025372715666890144, -0.010401799343526363, -0.013775409199297428, -0.012270987033843994, -0.03826374188065529, 0.006852060090750456, -0.023577898740768433, 0.000036156656278762966, 0.035593483597040176, -0.008090723305940628, -0.0008655780111439526, -0.07717209309339523, -0.0716557502746582, -0.0028271020855754614, -0.014880774542689323, -0.01338565070182085, 0.014188419096171856, 0.008939427323639393, 0.10533598810434341, 0.04591764509677887, -0.02948649600148201, -0.0295167975127697, -0.00973321869969368, -0.05299817770719528, -0.03022894449532032, 0.008677245117723942, 0.035380154848098755, 0.01257724966853857, 0.039843011647462845, -0.023049578070640564, 0.02368907444179058, 0.04435281082987785, -0.0003532560949679464, -0.0500691682100296, 0.036951061338186264, -0.01417352631688118, 0.006737003102898598, 0.03239388018846512, 0.026801269501447678, -0.03700179234147072, 0.01852809265255928, 0.013543634675443172, 0.037152595818042755, 0.008759967051446438, -0.018724244087934494, 0.01702474057674408, -0.050648242235183716, 0.06267190724611282, -0.034931886941194534, 0.0142073854804039, 0.00834980234503746, -0.04911024495959282, -0.02027054689824581, 0.012611628510057926, 0.05415080860257149, -0.04429275915026665, 0.015406811609864235, 0.03520714491605759, 0.055552635341882706, -0.0033323480747640133, -0.012819608673453331, -0.01618782803416252, 0.0356048159301281, -0.0007343195611611009, -0.027439726516604424, -0.02728433907032013, 0.040700264275074005, 0.04000856354832649, 0.010341021232306957, 0.004205797333270311, -0.023131923750042915, 0.0023747067898511887, -0.05555381998419762, -0.03507488965988159, -0.050072431564331055, 0.032239917665719986, 0.013777206651866436, 0.020932549610733986, 0.01809368096292019, -0.0374513640999794, -0.004564250353723764, 0.02436154894530773, -0.019093390554189682, 0.019079318270087242, -0.029774989932775497, -0.016911640763282776, -0.015199780464172363, -0.04200168699026108, 0.03545146808028221, -0.016169195994734764, -0.015810087323188782, -0.0320233553647995, 0.031861718744039536, -0.06189572438597679, -0.003603834193199873, -0.0007390041719190776, 0.03946607932448387, -0.037848036736249924, -0.018601899966597557, 0.010973856784403324, -0.014268745668232441, 0.03528011590242386, 0.023566391319036484, -0.03573786839842796, 0.0002594605030026287, -0.036861125379800797, -0.0015630580019205809, 0.01684894785284996, 0.026933252811431885, 0.01276096049696207, 0.007605083752423525, -0.06005188450217247, 0.0006316493381746113, 0.023715190589427948, 0.0480811782181263, 0.04650029540061951, -0.017291080206632614, -0.03472183272242546, -0.03546854481101036, -0.040537215769290924, 0.02884821780025959, 0.011049320921301842, 0.05420893058180809, 0.04082388058304787, 0.04494288191199303, 0.032301876693964005, -0.05147116258740425, -0.009961878880858421, 0.05360841751098633, 0.014419048093259335, -0.004187212325632572, -0.05404113978147507, -0.01489128265529871, 0.01734796352684498, -0.008301314897835255, -0.005576541181653738, -0.00669478764757514, -0.011637379415333271, -0.025328511372208595, 0.02080524154007435, -0.03826344013214111, -0.04237869754433632, -0.01161455363035202, 0.009322802536189556, 0.00569182587787509, -0.02086474560201168, -0.00023839018831495196, 0.008518708869814873, 0.024314656853675842, 0.06887735426425934, -0.013133058324456215, 0.020283138379454613, -0.0894932821393013, 0.013696882873773575, 0.04875194653868675, 0.022369178012013435, -0.02542116865515709, -0.03437875211238861, -0.06790141016244888, 0.0051950677298009396, 0.03176260367035866, -0.034468743950128555, 0.016631530597805977, -0.004708734806627035, -0.006258184555917978, -0.04954821616411209, -0.00943201594054699, -0.044262807816267014, 0.004852863494306803, -0.03594525530934334, 0.07318311929702759, -0.017874926328659058, -0.03672093152999878, -0.028303438797593117, -0.032385505735874176, 0.03676186129450798, 0.05826874077320099, -0.007176434155553579, -0.039182648062705994, -0.022169139236211777, 0.0026436648331582546, -0.005451202858239412, -0.06317784637212753, -0.017117854207754135, -0.0216694213449955, -0.025075694546103477, 0.05862440541386604, -0.01376370806246996, -0.045460037887096405, 0.050874754786491394, 0.026163224130868912, 0.005059760995209217, -0.04366166517138481, -0.041821520775556564, 0.020373808220028877, 0.033083438873291016, 0.015775397419929504, 0.04171289503574371, 0.023194964975118637, 0.013184121809899807, 0.006908794399350882, -0.06267981231212616, -0.002587872790172696, -0.04113181680440903, 0.007192668039351702, -0.0032185509335249662, -0.03131849318742752, -0.033012524247169495, 0.026519106701016426, 0.022329704836010933, 0.03412051871418953, -0.025061683729290962, 0.004573552869260311, -0.009172097779810429, 0.01072003785520792, -0.02762412466108799, -0.004127980209887028, -0.009899701923131943, 0.034688159823417664, -0.05880061909556389, -0.004540340509265661, -0.00342014548368752, -0.019450897350907326, 0.022578394040465355, 0.0508124940097332, -0.06722516566514969, 0.007069552782922983, 0.0058189816772937775, -0.005792679265141487, 0.02981574833393097, -0.004628477618098259, 0.013769419863820076, -0.0250588059425354, 0.015464781783521175, -0.0023626405745744705, -0.037949636578559875, -0.01789383590221405, 0.006578285247087479, -0.0062936581671237946, 0.04244717210531235, -0.0020843318197876215, 0.012366076000034809, 0.03673475980758667, -0.000053176045184955, -0.0654713362455368, -0.034576889127492905, 0.01938534900546074, -0.01123395748436451, -0.02225939743220806, -0.04097837582230568, 0.0016312540974467993, -0.026110708713531494, -0.03922823816537857, -0.010498902760446072, 0.018259583041071892, 0.011984055861830711, -0.007127027027308941, 0.021810542792081833, -0.021026620641350746, 0.07754648476839066, -0.00044679827988147736, 0.037930574268102646, 0.023237304762005806, -0.02637329511344433, -0.013412934727966785, 0.013812117278575897, 0.005087230820208788, -0.028844868764281273, 0.005486881360411644, -0.002653110306710005, 0.011811413802206516, -0.010191471315920353, 0.01810178905725479, -0.01615922339260578, 0.028522880747914314, -0.023764370009303093, 0.058705829083919525, -0.00993567518889904, 0.017779232934117317, 0.01577342115342617, -0.005188302136957645, 0.016805963590741158, -0.018856221809983253, -0.026167524978518486, 0.00228446489199996, 0.0400538295507431, 0.026280948892235756, 0.0020053137559443712, 0.00938924215734005, 0.051040634512901306, -0.03403255343437195, 0.016362324357032776, -0.017495082691311836, -0.018627455458045006, 0.031765166670084, 0.021505078300833702, 0.003501121886074543, -0.002999788848683238, 0.03607438504695892, -0.0510532408952713, -0.016819000244140625, -0.01518706139177084, 0.021788043901324272, 0.047434691339731216, 0.009179290384054184, 0.0295440461486578, -0.002313363365828991, -0.009011431597173214, -0.028115876019001007, -0.07351375371217728, -0.024543192237615585, 0.006326055619865656, 0.003380679525434971, 0.016707727685570717, -0.006865178234875202, 0.01763688586652279, 0.03500087186694145, 0.002356152515858412, 0.0013001497136428952, 0.01276874728500843, 0.02049718052148819, 0.037140194326639175, 0.044656310230493546, 0.0019592444878071547, -0.027481311932206154, 0.016280891373753548, -0.00878019817173481, -0.0136030288413167, 0.0052338289096951485, 0.015558217652142048, 0.016237173229455948, -0.01096994150429964, 0.008435769937932491, -0.03938112407922745, -0.03182478994131088, -0.01695014163851738, -0.006461832206696272, 0.048008162528276443, -0.033215999603271484, 0.02258758433163166, 0.005368626210838556, 0.015300312079489231, 0.028107384219765663, 0.03391297534108162, -0.04395909234881401, -0.0832086056470871, -0.04890000820159912, -0.046120405197143555, -0.03809274360537529, 0.0789504423737526, 0.014527028426527977, -0.014347093179821968, -0.008636211045086384, -0.012489783577620983, 0.06439346075057983, -0.019271183758974075, 0.03056390956044197, -0.01584613509476185, 0.03655388206243515, -0.002338842721655965, 0.01053862739354372, -0.009417769499123096, -0.005553719587624073, 0.13239435851573944, 0.03664664179086685, 0.029947908595204353, -0.04855591431260109, -0.0020837329793721437, -0.012229550629854202, -0.03388066962361336, -0.006500779651105404, 0.0043987734243273735, 0.016553254798054695, -0.017347147688269615, 0.03492550179362297, 0.012864705175161362, 0.05253280699253082, 0.0015332056209445, 0.050767309963703156, -0.006248062942177057, 0.027570899575948715, 0.011901505291461945, 0.00026790646370500326, 0.0031506726518273354, -0.058503974229097366, -0.011751663871109486, 0.01948261633515358, -0.020868895575404167, -0.045808542519807816, 0.006421353202313185, -0.017731929197907448, 0.014771530404686928, 0.026791933923959732, -0.0009923375910148025, -0.0104578398168087, 0.021077916026115417, 0.029977936297655106, -0.007932382635772228, -0.0005190365482121706, 0.03219281882047653, 0.023155776783823967, 0.0015920874429866672, 0.04245004430413246, 0.013153093867003918, -0.014488414861261845, 0.021810393780469894, 0.01560014858841896, -0.04110674560070038, 0.0011944514699280262, -0.049204036593437195, 0.04382890462875366, 0.03739120066165924, -0.0040016015991568565, -0.013562307693064213, -0.018029149621725082, 0.0025759630370885134, -0.0273661557585001, -0.01434844359755516, -0.016221608966588974, -0.02183132991194725, -0.0317198671400547, -0.03664571791887283, -0.011244281195104122, 0.025020260363817215, -0.007154409307986498, 0.03846742957830429, 0.032962679862976074, -0.04337301477789879, -0.013031354174017906, 0.002387737389653921, -0.01712477020919323, 0.016252426430583, -0.01170797273516655, 0.046450287103652954, -0.030378686264157295, -0.033300526440143585, -0.02757410518825054, 0.0386103056371212, 0.0011467720614746213, 0.013406342826783657, -0.02790764532983303, -0.017842017114162445, -0.023837806656956673, -0.046421460807323456, -0.019833149388432503, -0.021609311923384666, 0.03612367808818817, -0.011906804516911507, 0.0016164083499461412, -0.00997183471918106, 0.014939086511731148, 0.007544255815446377, 0.0010923707159236073, 0.01803172193467617, 0.036370307207107544, 0.014327064156532288, -0.04023604094982147, -0.04968483746051788, -0.02280338853597641, -0.04970047250390053, 0.02600654400885105, 0.023601152002811432, 0.06621202826499939, -0.0029268907383084297, 0.04178847372531891, 0.012057866901159286, 0.011756685562431812, 0.03569506108760834, -0.05430024489760399, 0.01003852766007185, -0.024691762402653694, -0.02412836253643036, 0.009199075400829315, 0.011384252458810806, -0.03382942080497742, -0.02651354670524597, -0.045789435505867004, -0.015903953462839127, -0.0002018377126660198, 0.01692451722919941, -0.04153040423989296, 0.014593872241675854, 0.008078917860984802, 0.03277859836816788, -0.0007532290765084326, 0.006003879476338625, -0.01912390999495983, 0.010839981026947498, -0.0457431860268116, -0.047374751418828964, 0.04492051899433136, -0.0166392233222723, -0.015183503739535809, 0.011797763407230377, 0.03125988692045212, 0.0042776321060955524, -0.0008839815272949636, -0.012607929296791553, 0.030939236283302307, -0.011205214075744152, 0.030381321907043457, -0.028481995686888695, -0.005036677233874798, 0.05487675592303276, -0.052199073135852814, -0.05077122896909714, 0.015281198546290398, -0.055542245507240295, 0.01961018703877926, 0.017094852402806282, 0.012398592196404934, 0.013195306062698364, 0.03810036554932594, -0.02195965312421322, -0.014655916020274162, 0.05755773186683655, 0.02298700623214245, -0.0050826300866901875, 0.054147422313690186, -0.0014293852727860212, 0.03333755210042, 0.021997828036546707, -0.003121671499684453, 0.032365307211875916, 0.024276668205857277, -0.03299184888601303, 0.015311749652028084, -0.0019331498770043254, 0.0475568026304245, -0.008361371234059334, -0.01793564483523369, 0.003979135304689407, 0.037030693143606186, 0.003102038288488984, 0.0275009423494339, -0.01417925301939249, 0.0001034931920003146, -0.08357518911361694, -0.010405907407402992, -0.011718581430613995, 0.018052326515316963, 0.03170032054185867, -0.043205417692661285, 0.02309529297053814, 0.06219445541501045, -0.07224909216165543, 0.01836646907031536, -0.003973883111029863, -0.020852064713835716, -0.03879457712173462, 0.011700538918375969, -0.01902044378221035, -0.026344578713178635, 0.048172496259212494, -0.0026417917106300592, 0.01598174311220646, 0.018236897885799408, -0.023685071617364883, -0.042396098375320435, -0.027271412312984467, 0.07911447435617447, -0.021537309512495995, -0.052001845091581345, 0.013545408844947815, -0.05087302625179291, -0.03754579648375511, 0.02331221103668213, 0.006455807480961084, 0.00010895000741584226, 0.06475859135389328, 0.02257377654314041, 0.003628367092460394, 0.04002656787633896, 0.03621351718902588, -0.040670979768037796, -0.0007610337343066931, 0.017407776787877083, 0.022265121340751648, 0.041969142854213715, -0.010798539035022259, 0.021831465885043144, 0.00519907521083951, -0.007358550559729338, -0.02991073951125145, 0.02977096289396286, -0.0027230004779994488, -0.01925554871559143, 0.01782037690281868, 0.04634757712483406, -0.024952055886387825, -0.05367812514305115, 0.013554981909692287, -0.026081997901201248, -0.011505166999995708, 0.0511450357735157, 0.027423853054642677, 0.012882382608950138, -0.006637256126850843, -0.0404638946056366, -0.057718656957149506, 0.0056871091946959496, 0.0012338929809629917, -0.01217492576688528, -0.06650862842798233, -0.0003972831182181835, -0.0021697613410651684, -0.01919974386692047, -0.012267445214092731, -0.0035838813055306673, -0.029460258781909943, 0.06783981621265411, -0.0030078289564698935, 0.04519672691822052, 0.05961000546813011, -0.010501117445528507, 0.024362891912460327, -0.09673142433166504, 0.06971204280853271, -0.01729726605117321, -0.015494260005652905, -0.010619382373988628, 0.0028258515521883965, -0.011606586165726185, -0.002910326700657606, 0.050133559852838516, -0.006365668028593063, -0.004338657017797232, 0.015223179943859577, -0.0034771766513586044, -0.02092989720404148, -0.03012087382376194, 0.06046869978308678, -0.022906294092535973, -0.020274922251701355, 0.01612311229109764, 0.007076028268784285, 0.01091952994465828, 0.006260850001126528, -0.0002511156490072608, 0.006283019669353962, -0.0016758784186095, 0.011463806964457035, -0.023769386112689972, 0.035108327865600586, 0.027315357699990273, 0.028271274641156197, 0.05053316056728363, 0.006768971215933561, 0.016053179278969765, -0.009076996706426144, -0.004240456968545914, -0.0610978901386261, 0.01979191228747368, 0.014007838442921638, -0.014130859635770321, -0.011675338260829449, 0.06290307641029358, 0.02664950117468834, -0.046367090195417404, -0.04535665363073349, 0.04942742735147476, -0.0006939313607290387, 0.012661388143897057, 0.071041040122509, 0.01553533598780632, 0.027928488329052925, -0.010783103294670582, 0.020572036504745483, 0.013348473235964775, 0.01635689102113247, 0.0004640421539079398, 0.03987856209278107, 0.030924413353204727, 0.0063721188344061375, 0.03447907418012619, 0.04899459704756737, -0.03223896026611328, 0.005040209274739027, 0.008967418223619461, 0.08367185294628143, -0.026294758543372154, -0.0151256388053298, -0.010921475477516651, 0.013106217607855797, -0.01434087473899126, -0.04513724148273468, -0.03562381491065025, 0.04774947836995125, -0.0668831616640091, -0.006543595343828201, -0.06322809308767319, -0.022011615335941315, -0.0001669346384005621, 0.0013560756342485547, 0.045871034264564514, 0.04931558296084404, 0.03144070878624916, 0.015705635771155357, -0.021795175969600677, 0.033093422651290894, 0.023279068991541862, -0.005234300158917904, 0.0031808591447770596, -0.00649377703666687, 0.009928128682076931, -0.0029139830730855465, 0.015889672562479973, -0.0001092053935281001, -0.035614825785160065, -0.000881410320289433, 0.041250452399253845, 0.015584343113005161, -0.031533412635326385, -0.0471000075340271, -0.00553126260638237, 0.0409822016954422, -0.07209741324186325, 0.0010649757459759712, -0.04728073254227638, 0.07374143600463867, -0.02023887075483799, -0.011266167275607586 ]
<p>I am trying to compare 2 ideas to see which one is better/more effective - I am looking to see if a significant difference. (2 conditions)</p> <p>We used a questionnaire to gather feedback from hundreds of people. (Questions include: how likely would you buy it, how likely would you tell your friends and family, I want to learn more about this product...etc. An swers are multiple choice: strongly agree,somewhat agree, neutral, somewhat disagree, strongly disagree &amp; no advantage, some advantage, slight advantage, a great advantage)</p> <p><strong>WHAT SHOULD I DO? AND IS THIS THE RIGHT WAY OF DOING IT? (using SPSS)</strong></p> <ol> <li>t-test: by combining the data (would I just give each answer a value like 1-4, add values up for total score for each participant)</li> <li>Run cross tabs and then do something?</li> <li>Other suggestions?</li> </ol> <p>THANKS! :) </p>
73,385
[ -0.04718226566910744, 0.012841918505728245, 0.01227891631424427, 0.03221452608704567, 0.029468154534697533, 0.0065454114228487015, 0.02511748857796192, -0.026814792305231094, 0.05244545638561249, 0.025910979136824608, 0.03382866829633713, 0.049399394541978836, 0.01971280202269554, 0.03824037313461304, -0.015790339559316635, 0.028405793011188507, 0.010017582215368748, -0.009099149145185947, 0.0018275304464623332, 0.030073247849941254, -0.0392254963517189, 0.010577167384326458, -0.011876341886818409, 0.0027987200301140547, -0.03185734897851944, 0.04883826896548271, 0.03951936960220337, -0.056117940694093704, 0.007048927713185549, 0.04839853569865227, -0.0476628802716732, -0.0450863242149353, -0.004448580555617809, 0.0017310562543570995, 0.0014407513663172722, -0.03790588676929474, -0.01718156598508358, -0.012840029783546925, -0.006471777800470591, 0.019815025851130486, 0.008012193255126476, -0.0009864377789199352, -0.024336300790309906, 0.01650843396782875, -0.002988889580592513, 0.008908843621611595, -0.046603452414274216, -0.02352234348654747, -0.01304639969021082, -0.08220414817333221, 0.029758457094430923, -0.005775513127446175, 0.006796387489885092, 0.06363522261381149, 0.006982481572777033, -0.018462657928466797, 0.05494183301925659, 0.06669528782367706, -0.006470388732850552, -0.040568508207798004, 0.012164442799985409, 0.0036087341140955687, -0.00024330704763997346, -0.030352730304002762, -0.052582114934921265, 0.009445970878005028, -0.007828986272215843, 0.013696021400392056, 0.049141738563776016, -0.005164894741028547, 0.04879654571413994, 0.03554137423634529, 0.02605297975242138, -0.005667132791131735, -0.005407377146184444, -0.04559166356921196, -0.008568685501813889, 0.022164369001984596, 0.07715750485658646, 0.06065582111477852, 0.029967177659273148, 0.012434625066816807, 0.0054404898546636105, 0.05606786534190178, 0.016046786680817604, -0.03232883661985397, 0.07230395823717117, -0.022941771894693375, -0.024422286078333855, 0.030750367790460587, 0.02262081764638424, -0.018922733142971992, 0.06489819288253784, 0.038832779973745346, -0.028830941766500473, 0.011669151484966278, -0.007286658510565758, 0.02885904721915722, 0.002830356592312455, 0.025614921003580093, -0.0002781924558803439, -0.02939329482614994, 0.009395135566592216, 0.018639881163835526, 0.010580210015177727, -0.015048046596348286, 0.004788180813193321, 0.018160246312618256, -0.0006789422477595508, -0.0024346860591322184, -0.00795728899538517, 0.027423547580838203, -0.003204597858712077, -0.01069888286292553, -0.007456858642399311, -0.043511684983968735, -0.020931553095579147, -0.023073207587003708, 0.06499764323234558, 0.05712595954537392, 0.049727652221918106, -0.04101107642054558, 0.014542187564074993, -0.00967336818575859, -0.05315312743186951, -0.009209266863763332, 0.006157335825264454, 0.006086396519094706, -0.04162609577178955, 0.06360048055648804, 0.000057467841543257236, 0.010321083478629589, 0.04920082911849022, -0.005739480257034302, 0.011877846904098988, 0.022404909133911133, -0.09743818640708923, -0.03540891036391258, 0.05304524302482605, -0.03058556653559208, 0.003167135175317526, -0.034208785742521286, -0.005994412116706371, -0.00011346623068675399, 0.022586187347769737, 0.006376172881573439, 0.029193419963121414, 0.026726996526122093, 0.028136037290096283, -0.003359151305630803, -0.026546496897935867, -0.00973600335419178, -0.010847068391740322, -0.03471910208463669, -0.0202347245067358, -0.06883584707975388, 0.00956634059548378, 0.029529402032494545, 0.00035222104634158313, 0.007724923547357321, -0.007929063402116299, -0.0013292666990309954, -0.006567684002220631, -0.011900071054697037, 0.017654692754149437, -0.03562450036406517, 0.03884020447731018, -0.024450799450278282, 0.013614104129374027, 0.004033057484775782, -0.036222927272319794, -0.0016886998200789094, 0.012405548244714737, -0.013727128505706787, 0.023015951737761497, 0.0018856466049328446, 0.0203696321696043, -0.01929764449596405, -0.01367846317589283, 0.009991475380957127, -0.03766288608312607, -0.045594651252031326, -0.04964339733123779, 0.005660131573677063, 0.030755063518881798, 0.06276050209999084, -0.007988493889570236, 0.0006228065467439592, 0.028594044968485832, -0.04997919499874115, -0.09209220111370087, -0.09864111244678497, 0.0017130596097558737, 0.024052327498793602, -0.044904906302690506, 0.022356677800416946, 0.01735980622470379, 0.030021078884601593, -0.028905587270855904, -0.0058259679935872555, -0.02623705193400383, 0.04377158358693123, 0.024877021089196205, -0.020724846050143242, 0.029524071142077446, 0.07489465177059174, 0.016477089375257492, -0.05767863243818283, 0.03366643935441971, -0.030337488278746605, -0.0524958036839962, -0.0017025283304974437, -0.03378460183739662, 0.013308859430253506, 0.0038437542971223593, -0.01983661763370037, 0.03827595338225365, 0.043434638530015945, -0.018146468326449394, 0.010193907655775547, -0.046503156423568726, 0.1282605677843094, 0.06722971796989441, -0.016296377405524254, 0.010605759918689728, 0.0011433410691097379, 0.02794751338660717, 0.030828025192022324, -0.006294773425906897, 0.015162084251642227, -0.04783813655376434, 0.025439048185944557, 0.04360060766339302, -0.004344967659562826, -0.05323006957769394, 0.027030114084482193, 0.038703642785549164, -0.035939183086156845, 0.006637538317590952, 0.03820331394672394, -0.005175644066184759, -0.019319912418723106, 0.013755164109170437, 0.03417463228106499, 0.017513426020741463, 0.022835515439510345, -0.00004752241511596367, 0.018054204061627388, 0.027570350095629692, 0.01782885193824768, 0.027704307809472084, 0.038905613124370575, 0.050642866641283035, 0.01233790535479784, -0.01041855476796627, -0.007543094456195831, 0.05164971575140953, 0.0029270134400576353, -0.023822009563446045, 0.015930460765957832, -0.00645685289055109, -0.0020181038416922092, 0.004784524440765381, -0.02430015243589878, 0.02391805313527584, 0.030439253896474838, -0.021546194329857826, 0.008255407214164734, 0.03137979656457901, -0.029405010864138603, -0.0025372228119522333, 0.004793423227965832, 0.015376975759863853, -0.04999015852808952, 0.002210241975262761, 0.0275022741407156, -0.013634433969855309, 0.023955129086971283, -0.020471831783652306, -0.022920429706573486, -0.00683927396312356, 0.007246873807162046, 0.02039889246225357, -0.028099311515688896, -0.06715235859155655, -0.01982465572655201, -0.03974326699972153, -0.01909121312201023, 0.04439127445220947, 0.006545670330524445, -0.030495954677462578, 0.03459545969963074, 0.0346154049038887, -0.06592220813035965, -0.03747144341468811, -0.022475751116871834, 0.0537898950278759, -0.005161327309906483, -0.04722152277827263, 0.023857075721025467, -0.01141246035695076, -0.03999609500169754, 0.03346046805381775, -0.029629947617650032, -0.017167193815112114, -0.013351887464523315, 0.016071742400527, -0.003679802641272545, 0.0017013093456625938, -0.02593040093779564, 0.0004146930587012321, -0.004259890411049128, 0.0025951985735446215, -0.09211412817239761, -0.02487420290708542, 0.036960069090127945, -0.003582598175853491, 0.05823430046439171, -0.005272513255476952, -0.009579939767718315, 0.08797449618577957, 0.011115188710391521, -0.026866048574447632, -0.06354352086782455, -0.0008606004994362593, -0.043320368975400925, 0.0022328344639390707, 0.01570313610136509, 0.0258681271225214, -0.0031450591050088406, 0.015234083868563175, 0.006264062598347664, 0.007275518495589495, 0.04168754816055298, 0.009750169701874256, -0.013196001760661602, 0.012399592436850071, -0.0011853001778945327, -0.014968464151024818, 0.04120762273669243, 0.03134912997484207, -0.050338298082351685, -0.0007300767465494573, 0.007645339239388704, 0.010867857374250889, 0.008647864684462547, -0.030928993597626686, 0.015161748975515366, -0.010811403393745422, -0.01911388896405697, -0.02324925921857357, 0.03658783435821533, 0.01705232448875904, -0.02284540794789791, -0.024752376601099968, 0.020028237253427505, 0.0461445152759552, -0.01854315958917141, -0.004790633916854858, 0.0780235305428505, 0.02718360722064972, -0.030768005177378654, -0.035053495317697525, -0.035851143300533295, 0.007814498618245125, -0.016677075996994972, 0.022624315693974495, -0.013406350277364254, 0.02285659871995449, 0.08126796036958694, 0.03920146822929382, 0.01836860366165638, -0.0375862680375576, 0.00415502255782485, -0.08287565410137177, -0.00002302781467733439, -0.04041394218802452, 0.08894512057304382, 0.011022205464541912, 0.05481170117855072, 0.033690303564071655, -0.0110015869140625, 0.019141322001814842, 0.0016982079250738025, -0.03556631878018379, 0.05521447956562042, -0.012919020839035511, 0.012500825338065624, 0.031785860657691956, 0.0009380263509228826, 0.008623525500297546, -0.01602000743150711, -0.005738066043704748, -0.02059255726635456, 0.04410085082054138, -0.011464731767773628, -0.01247936487197876, 0.002645098837092519, 0.018655532971024513, 0.0011256362777203321, 0.021656174212694168, -0.03125211223959923, 0.0005265420186333358, 0.032696109265089035, 0.023563440889120102, -0.02513391710817814, 0.03251541778445244, -0.01627587340772152, -0.01925666630268097, 0.004461833741515875, 0.040490780025720596, 0.012133603915572166, 0.013843490742146969, -0.020596768707036972, 0.018980685621500015, 0.031939320266246796, 0.034683361649513245, 0.00934750959277153, 0.006368814501911402, -0.03719102218747139, -0.03153787553310394, -0.004945805296301842, 0.011827261187136173, -0.005476765800267458, -0.01614992693066597, -0.024587156251072884, 0.006286934483796358, 0.014933655969798565, -0.02693799138069153, -0.0012381421402096748, 0.035255227237939835, 0.02046511508524418, 0.009357616305351257, -0.024607980623841286, -0.05352664366364479, -0.009498801082372665, -0.031490884721279144, 0.033292051404714584, 0.03199362754821777, -0.0008422104292549193, -0.0010013722348958254, 0.027189034968614578, -0.002689845161512494, -0.07556574046611786, 0.021430963650345802, -0.02585749700665474, 0.02958562597632408, 0.015384115278720856, -0.04008929803967476, 0.013713101856410503, 0.04817374423146248, 0.024427827447652817, 0.005767097696661949, 0.006101243197917938, -0.07823358476161957, -0.014999674633145332, 0.06372048705816269, 0.06704186648130417, -0.053126972168684006, -0.009191708639264107, -0.027630390599370003, -0.02441798895597458, 0.04052595794200897, -0.07108907401561737, 0.016565125435590744, -0.012504156678915024, 0.009816826321184635, -0.0438581183552742, 0.007236421573907137, -0.0241981353610754, 0.01488368771970272, -0.018452346324920654, 0.02715284936130047, 0.005859866738319397, -0.017986638471484184, -0.0023580973502248526, -0.010515323840081692, 0.036046188324689865, 0.05790982022881508, -0.0665760189294815, -0.024421440437436104, -0.001253120368346572, 0.0006688887951895595, -0.0169440358877182, -0.07912453263998032, 0.006992073263972998, 0.005616195499897003, -0.02103264257311821, 0.0680331140756607, 0.01640271209180355, -0.01565045677125454, 0.024153074249625206, 0.008949527516961098, -0.0134357875213027, 0.0003088516532443464, -0.027757173404097557, 0.01360015943646431, 0.04217655211687088, 0.02603778801858425, 0.025343427434563637, 0.040980614721775055, -0.02035023644566536, 0.033916302025318146, -0.013075449503958225, -0.030247163027524948, -0.0062461975030601025, -0.03563898801803589, -0.06630839407444, -0.008419865742325783, -0.05501428246498108, 0.00502636656165123, 0.004084646236151457, 0.011610033921897411, -0.04743005335330963, -0.03787199407815933, 0.02142416313290596, 0.031979821622371674, 0.023336928337812424, 0.00095541583141312, 0.0023296677973121405, 0.0006172267021611333, 0.0037154420278966427, -0.020861538127064705, 0.00763341598212719, -0.015557974576950073, -0.0041746399365365505, 0.014351861551404, -0.06081044673919678, -0.011240048334002495, -0.019968662410974503, -0.022403893992304802, -0.012335145846009254, -0.00676294881850481, 0.058070674538612366, -0.013618400320410728, 0.029864300042390823, 0.006608827970921993, -0.03284621238708496, -0.01229061558842659, 0.07790601253509521, 0.014419333077967167, 0.017842672765254974, -0.05091320723295212, 0.06834253668785095, -0.01345093548297882, -0.03309117630124092, -0.041490163654088974, -0.027875619009137154, 0.021333927288651466, 0.016637707129120827, -0.027914267033338547, -0.0306991133838892, -0.0004519251815509051, 0.0035867481492459774, -0.0312383770942688, -0.018124490976333618, -0.0036447884049266577, -0.0002359719801461324, -0.003748869290575385, 0.015605207532644272, -0.00877317413687706, 0.05371863767504692, -0.009787137620151043, -0.016767315566539764, -0.011135080829262733, 0.015271990559995174, -0.01530102826654911, -0.02061581052839756, -0.035712942481040955, -0.0517803393304348, -0.05685834214091301, -0.05480631813406944, 0.010420123115181923, 0.04663022235035896, -0.0231560617685318, 0.00007078996713971719, -0.00854309368878603, -0.022455701604485512, -0.04232136160135269, -0.034291986376047134, 0.005810035392642021, -0.022730644792318344, -0.00997987575829029, -0.04380076751112938, 0.022507626563310623, -0.030845215544104576, -0.030168205499649048, 0.003990534693002701, 0.011965434066951275, -0.05750532075762749, 0.0023338592145591974, 0.05874164402484894, -0.02194436825811863, 0.023421473801136017, -0.013438770547509193, -0.008660437539219856, 0.04232705011963844, 0.013385845348238945, 0.021525269374251366, -0.0028834128752350807, 0.04270683601498604, -0.014771079644560814, -0.029594795778393745, 0.014231993816792965, -0.013554910197854042, 0.05513041839003563, -0.005795107688754797, 0.014013523235917091, 0.08210726827383041, -0.014069310389459133, 0.004232837352901697, 0.009226777590811253, -0.0003031616797670722, -0.01674807444214821, 0.02469450607895851, 0.038820214569568634, 0.019302185624837875, 0.009807078167796135, 0.05271292105317116, -0.00748770497739315, 0.040285833179950714, 0.0213888268917799, 0.04911741241812706, 0.02991737797856331, 0.013967861421406269, -0.058125630021095276, -0.027023272588849068, 0.009424460120499134, -0.06487895548343658, 0.03972217068076134, -0.04173047095537186, -0.018786456435918808, 0.03747156262397766, 0.04697687178850174, -0.04371226206421852, -0.050590574741363525, 0.015603359788656235, -0.059689346700906754, -0.027971457690000534, 0.014561139047145844, -0.03316912055015564, 0.01907273568212986, -0.0030801002867519855, 0.05949001759290695, 0.0067443810403347015, 0.007810254581272602, -0.05633198842406273, -0.08078180253505707, -0.027529120445251465, 0.013232659548521042, -0.021629413589835167, 0.04363475367426872, -0.0005082289571873844, -0.014843001961708069, 0.031012849882245064, -0.022356264293193817, 0.011432670056819916, 0.03772168606519699, 0.01916438899934292, -0.014842928387224674, 0.04565086215734482, 0.018633928149938583, 0.03895338624715805, 0.01922825165092945, -0.025917228311300278, 0.10245656222105026, 0.07241112738847733, 0.027424486353993416, -0.06924891471862793, 0.05493297055363655, 0.017268402501940727, 0.015465437434613705, 0.018613465130329132, 0.029883000999689102, -0.004841109737753868, 0.026241563260555267, 0.04260393977165222, 0.05980802699923515, 0.028394049033522606, 0.0038779943715780973, 0.04481200501322746, -0.037763871252536774, -0.03494016081094742, 0.026877837255597115, -0.022719047963619232, -0.005680218804627657, -0.05356285348534584, -0.04385276138782501, 0.014011739753186703, 0.0012384000001475215, -0.010427569039165974, 0.012583710253238678, -0.035584818571805954, 0.016967684030532837, 0.0018975570565089583, 0.0015612011775374413, 0.01629152148962021, -0.001604305929504335, 0.029408399015665054, -0.03830024227499962, -0.018042881041765213, 0.04547392576932907, -0.04545116797089577, 0.01653837412595749, 0.056383632123470306, 0.011191516183316708, -0.03471241146326065, 0.01906558871269226, 0.0363762229681015, -0.07463829964399338, 0.0018753466429188848, -0.04600762948393822, 0.008782324381172657, -0.0020715382415801287, -0.04708978533744812, -0.031084861606359482, 0.009750230237841606, 0.0008097783429548144, -0.030412519350647926, -0.04043956845998764, 0.03493576869368553, 0.032109085470438004, 0.0014777862234041095, -0.04376000538468361, -0.05140954628586769, 0.014403024688363075, -0.021100809797644615, -0.006407753098756075, 0.02849913388490677, -0.014598451554775238, -0.027027500793337822, -0.007265440188348293, 0.019905833527445793, 0.04304700717329979, 0.013516499660909176, -0.0020735531579703093, -0.012110416777431965, -0.020658083260059357, 0.03490065783262253, -0.027224378660321236, 0.025702200829982758, -0.006430148147046566, -0.0009183435468003154, 0.0329802967607975, -0.057448841631412506, -0.024274397641420364, 0.010591547004878521, 0.007212746422737837, 0.00007951132283778861, -0.03952076658606529, 0.029239242896437645, 0.03630645200610161, -0.020666880533099174, 0.025278765708208084, 0.030069975182414055, 0.032064344733953476, 0.06570101529359818, 0.019490664824843407, -0.07257819920778275, -0.03783027455210686, -0.0036909610498696566, -0.027706535533070564, -0.013546047732234001, -0.007070556282997131, 0.07303783297538757, 0.010346727445721626, 0.00970459170639515, 0.014960451051592827, -0.01840358041226864, -0.013842049054801464, 0.0007641298579983413, -0.00706310011446476, -0.07235800474882126, -0.04756012558937073, 0.016959965229034424, -0.00042049121111631393, -0.02014048397541046, 0.021540898829698563, -0.02774553745985031, -0.030664190649986267, 0.013891094364225864, -0.03007074072957039, -0.00015208209515549242, -0.0021002867724746466, -0.02141422964632511, 0.05209393426775932, -0.036360688507556915, -0.0032668402418494225, -0.028336411342024803, -0.03560558333992958, 0.015031665563583374, 0.028449339792132378, 0.012920684181153774, 0.02178812026977539, 0.00988058466464281, 0.013711226172745228, 0.04252665489912033, -0.004121182952076197, -0.0028071473352611065, 0.005736366380006075, 0.005215957295149565, 0.002658300334587693, 0.008393222466111183, -0.0059590465389192104, -0.015411012805998325, 0.03561241179704666, 0.007446698844432831, -0.0030682163778692484, -0.0015942128375172615, -0.013633428141474724, 0.056447818875312805, 0.0032515593338757753, -0.038964029401540756, 0.012296258471906185, 0.07212978601455688, -0.02904587797820568, -0.030242571607232094, -0.01636453904211521, 0.017095360904932022, 0.024332482367753983, -0.0062479241751134396, 0.003988883923739195, 0.002785734599456191, -0.02431516721844673, 0.042604777961969376, 0.010923256166279316, -0.013289063237607479, -0.032136138528585434, -0.029323216527700424, -0.0164338406175375, -0.015722259879112244, 0.007360963616520166, -0.04941986873745918, 0.021828731521964073, 0.01040075533092022, -0.031053179875016212, 0.022280847653746605, -0.00004348923175712116, 0.009571751579642296, -0.0676354318857193, -0.00572282075881958, -0.003650722559541464, -0.02177557721734047, 0.028269052505493164, -0.03941811993718147, 0.028550976887345314, 0.03840106353163719, -0.04535120353102684, -0.0014859737129881978, -0.007524007000029087, 0.016518130898475647, -0.03457581251859665, 0.03258512169122696, -0.037605758756399155, 0.02553497813642025, -0.013620690442621708, 0.04467128962278366, 0.013217332772910595, 0.04386795684695244, -0.005045709665864706, 0.02137899585068226, -0.02466532401740551, 0.02236776426434517, 0.012104840949177742, -0.05780371278524399, 0.029480312019586563, -0.04120294749736786, -0.04438076540827751, 0.03308969736099243, 0.0031327183824032545, 0.048159725964069366, 0.022514991462230682, 0.03711792454123497, -0.028073936700820923, 0.009657255373895168, -0.0009297234937548637, 0.015688840299844742, -0.005070938728749752, 0.0008518265676684678, 0.02178536169230938, 0.015737449750304222, 0.02364220842719078, 0.019540464505553246, 0.05035869777202606, 0.0033611461985856295, 0.005889453925192356, 0.018292484804987907, -0.04978952556848526, -0.02171904779970646, -0.0209363903850317, 0.015895633026957512, 0.02369828149676323, -0.0379408560693264, -0.0047177160158753395, -0.025237543508410454, 0.016155073419213295, 0.043054502457380295, -0.031660910695791245, -0.022980976849794388, -0.01878419704735279, -0.0159530621021986, -0.028040943667292595, 0.017477773129940033, -0.007665795274078846, 0.025600232183933258, -0.03219207003712654, 0.012958915904164314, -0.010942353866994381, 0.012807279825210571, -0.020397618412971497, 0.025205044075846672, -0.016972875222563744, 0.07146204262971878, -0.022412138059735298, -0.011726278811693192, 0.04439399391412735, -0.00885965395718813, 0.0020617065019905567, -0.08146742731332779, 0.05662224441766739, 0.020419618114829063, -0.048099368810653687, -0.042270589619874954, -0.018674423918128014, -0.04072980955243111, 0.02060832642018795, 0.04391995817422867, -0.005514490883797407, -0.004862281959503889, 0.001379574416205287, 0.040868163108825684, 0.0027835459914058447, -0.026502888649702072, 0.06862837821245193, -0.005893443711102009, -0.018334150314331055, -0.010910811834037304, -0.0023767079692333937, 0.008567129261791706, -0.009729544632136822, 0.04433540627360344, -0.03748442232608795, 0.021298954263329506, -0.02617419697344303, 0.007723359856754541, 0.01778700388967991, 0.0019930852577090263, -0.03477414324879646, 0.051378391683101654, -0.008291272446513176, 0.018531525507569313, 0.0007725433679297566, -0.024880006909370422, -0.01392799336463213, 0.044840842485427856, -0.01919754594564438, 0.007607049774378538, -0.023317508399486542, -0.015643369406461716, -0.03548889234662056, -0.06390337646007538, -0.013571802526712418, 0.005344917997717857, -0.029923345893621445, 0.00708273658528924, 0.030278118327260017, 0.034897781908512115, 0.01428673043847084, -0.013302741572260857, 0.04059096798300743, -0.03044675849378109, -0.013840585015714169, -0.002077021636068821, 0.0037844942416995764, 0.03439030423760414, 0.015215657651424408, 0.017105335369706154, 0.05283171683549881, 0.015267197042703629, 0.03241027891635895, -0.034328147768974304, 0.029263870790600777, -0.023930585011839867, -0.006068646442145109, 0.045964501798152924, -0.007088225334882736, -0.0012018863344565034, 0.04540707543492317, -0.004994628485292196, 0.0515412911772728, -0.04579746723175049, 0.02102995663881302, -0.04145913943648338, -0.010094549506902695, -0.041323352605104446, -0.01616424135863781, 0.018479498103260994, 0.017568103969097137, 0.009867903776466846, 0.012622044421732426, -0.02067851833999157, -0.011458678171038628, 0.016449205577373505, 0.016955366358160973, 0.026721833273768425, -0.040434133261442184, -0.02293042466044426, 0.005311875604093075, -0.03142380341887474, -0.018669642508029938, 0.000687793071847409, 0.019098956137895584, 0.0008294624858535826, 0.010433534160256386, -0.0067934300750494, -0.04330040514469147, 0.029161879792809486, 0.04315601661801338, -0.04715602472424507, 0.0016891672275960445, -0.045933231711387634, -0.004185961093753576, -0.019306378439068794, -0.022875741124153137 ]
<p>When you are trying to fit models to a large dataset, the common advice is to partition the data into three parts: the training, validation, and test dataset.</p> <p>This is because the models usually have three "levels" of parameters: the first "parameter" is the model class (e.g. SVM, neural network, random forest), the second set of parameters are the "regularization" parameters or "hyperparameters" (e.g. lasso penalty coefficient, choice of kernel, neural network structure) and the third set are what are usually considered the "parameters" (e.g. coefficients for the covariates.)</p> <p>Given a model class and a choice of hyperparameters, one selects the parameters by choosing the parameters which minimize error on the training set. Given a model class, one tunes the hyperparameters by minimizing error on the validation set. One selects the model class by performance on the test set.</p> <p>But why not more partitions? Often one can split the hyperparameters into two groups, and use a "validation 1" to fit the first and "validation 2" to fit the second. Or one could even treat the size of the training data/validation data split as a hyperparameter to be tuned.</p> <p>Is this already a common practice in some applications? Is there any theoretical work on the optimal partitioning of data?</p>
73,386
[ -0.013410987332463264, 0.054759860038757324, -0.029205895960330963, -0.013983532786369324, 0.02669581212103367, 0.001492199837230146, -0.026027031242847443, -0.03787899762392044, 0.053790345788002014, 0.0006253075553104281, 0.02577168680727482, 0.02562509849667549, 0.051730141043663025, -0.044256582856178284, 0.00233378354460001, -0.01382300816476345, -0.0012420245911926031, -0.009440608322620392, -0.008593187667429447, 0.008379417471587658, -0.011267080903053284, 0.015868403017520905, 0.01278879027813673, -0.03909187763929367, -0.018172476440668106, 0.020717790350317955, 0.03038797900080681, -0.0013702778378501534, 0.017335735261440277, 0.023840652778744698, -0.024129444733262062, -0.018812283873558044, 0.007712711580097675, 0.06966015696525574, 0.004849608987569809, -0.02550439164042473, -0.0035631090868264437, -0.05514037609100342, -0.022588586434721947, 0.033954594284296036, -0.032072968780994415, 0.00657258415594697, -0.012198771350085735, 0.020109672099351883, 0.015456999652087688, 0.038658495992422104, -0.007267208304256201, -0.05302692949771881, -0.00003236471093259752, -0.051848381757736206, 0.06105220317840576, -0.0009455587714910507, 0.04982476308941841, 0.05614442005753517, -0.01581249199807644, -0.024125557392835617, 0.06867548078298569, 0.08634203672409058, -0.010930709540843964, -0.019828446209430695, -0.03886532410979271, -0.036568447947502136, 0.02572699636220932, 0.018225528299808502, -0.02965066023170948, 0.043441884219646454, 0.02916858345270157, -0.01473713107407093, 0.002397169591858983, -0.004078995902091265, 0.0199003703892231, 0.002497827634215355, 0.05446090176701546, -0.035372957587242126, 0.013083279132843018, 0.020322127267718315, 0.00998767465353012, 0.04498365521430969, 0.06100211292505264, 0.007065658923238516, 0.030840914696455002, 0.018653737381100655, 0.014578557573258877, 0.012739225290715694, -0.005264120642095804, 0.0017405017279088497, 0.08312547206878662, -0.011479126289486885, -0.00728303287178278, -0.007778317667543888, -0.006041723769158125, 0.019856669008731842, 0.07118816673755646, -0.006434584967792034, -0.02167758159339428, 0.025466127321124077, -0.00026623893063515425, 0.01786910369992256, 0.01633823662996292, 0.006464929785579443, -0.02072100341320038, -0.01258661225438118, -0.009464893490076065, 0.040612947195768356, -0.012654473073780537, 0.003470631083473563, -0.006877067033201456, -0.007136819418519735, 0.0026018021162599325, -0.011914285831153393, -0.023865846917033195, 0.0372699573636055, -0.010589745827019215, 0.01924050599336624, 0.01695559173822403, 0.011144465766847134, 0.01729632541537285, -0.044194545596838, 0.035270724445581436, 0.06879378855228424, 0.037176910787820816, -0.03926275297999382, 0.030003516003489494, -0.001488714711740613, -0.05912008881568909, 0.02034670300781727, 0.01150646060705185, -0.025522487238049507, -0.045115675777196884, 0.040939755737781525, -0.02068718895316124, -0.02610674686729908, 0.03526832535862923, -0.020213263109326363, -0.0022198655642569065, 0.02598033845424652, -0.07902068644762039, -0.039070963859558105, 0.0006450233049690723, 0.0013314048992469907, 0.014982867985963821, -0.018688956275582314, -0.012823112308979034, 0.00936464685946703, 0.060339685529470444, -0.016113612800836563, 0.031327441334724426, 0.008308152668178082, 0.026762081310153008, -0.01978130266070366, -0.02457226812839508, -0.03678383678197861, -0.028676172718405724, 0.01589539460837841, -0.04039302095770836, -0.07762721925973892, 0.0016854392597451806, 0.05709336698055267, -0.0043741860426962376, 0.019558828324079514, 0.010582180693745613, -0.0069728814996778965, -0.01683168113231659, -0.01961176097393036, 0.018216440454125404, -0.00798592995852232, 0.05407048016786575, 0.0027872950304299593, 0.07716064900159836, 0.03572482615709305, -0.012960324995219707, 0.021837370470166206, 0.025915317237377167, 0.02737308293581009, 0.016331637278199196, 0.029930703341960907, 0.00315461540594697, 0.00038177528767846525, 0.03177112340927124, 0.003740619169548154, -0.031184161081910133, -0.05487081781029701, 0.025828853249549866, 0.02249765209853649, 0.0129784494638443, 0.022387918084859848, 0.020903103053569794, -0.04298333451151848, 0.0267960112541914, -0.05151127278804779, -0.04582845792174339, -0.05572478473186493, 0.010477723553776741, -0.05267668515443802, -0.011949438601732254, 0.052168361842632294, -0.009373839013278484, -0.005448331590741873, 0.0024208317045122385, -0.03872673586010933, -0.014194709248840809, 0.009688657708466053, 0.047238774597644806, -0.011655431240797043, 0.020299790427088737, 0.07063380628824234, -0.007914233021438122, -0.024117646738886833, 0.06281010806560516, -0.02952062524855137, -0.075990229845047, 0.005461819935590029, -0.060331717133522034, 0.008766966871917248, -0.037728775292634964, -0.024889664724469185, -0.013134678825736046, 0.016935275867581367, -0.036507442593574524, 0.03672314062714577, -0.041268911212682724, 0.06856294721364975, 0.05751684308052063, -0.0002210861857747659, -0.0034408208448439837, 0.001491681905463338, -0.023509101942181587, 0.021801047027111053, -0.0009750754688866436, 0.003594029461964965, -0.06951044499874115, -0.01129264198243618, 0.05955301970243454, 0.012312396429479122, -0.03106018714606762, -0.0014495484065264463, 0.05859009921550751, 0.025516023859381676, 0.025485780090093613, 0.015176234766840935, -0.016468564048409462, -0.008246514946222305, 0.034954946488142014, 0.00622076028957963, 0.01802319660782814, -0.009377009235322475, -0.005643465556204319, -0.004883036948740482, 0.017432188615202904, 0.0007707984768785536, 0.003203138243407011, 0.06419852375984192, 0.015363269485533237, -0.0002443820412736386, -0.0007954943575896323, -0.027533089742064476, 0.021229013800621033, -0.026507427915930748, 0.03642769157886505, -0.00046257497160695493, 0.024682020768523216, -0.0005018250085413456, -0.019357740879058838, -0.014996089041233063, 0.009311625733971596, 0.011729511432349682, -0.019079767167568207, 0.02629387006163597, 0.025496868416666985, -0.043398723006248474, 0.00001669111406954471, -0.048282165080308914, -0.03410980477929115, -0.07211202383041382, -0.01088443398475647, 0.02888544648885727, -0.012520910240709782, 0.05650658160448074, -0.04334308207035065, -0.005709437187761068, -0.0009985934011638165, -0.01827077753841877, 0.03092966414988041, -0.027057595551013947, -0.03052976354956627, -0.0004131337336730212, -0.034909702837467194, -0.024500105530023575, 0.0166611485183239, -0.011883484199643135, 0.02279438078403473, -0.013503477908670902, 0.0023061682004481554, -0.05062725022435188, -0.059942279011011124, -0.012686180882155895, -0.0063110594637691975, -0.010722143575549126, -0.05067138373851776, 0.047853756695985794, 0.03592376783490181, -0.032326627522706985, 0.023709874600172043, 0.008578573353588581, 0.008833607658743858, -0.022728195413947105, -0.04682552069425583, 0.0012802903074771166, -0.005825462285429239, 0.02439669519662857, 0.05794316902756691, -0.03749328851699829, -0.017709415405988693, -0.06490609049797058, -0.055923350155353546, -0.00780544662848115, -0.0032162703573703766, 0.050252750515937805, 0.0015027843182906508, -0.006942960433661938, 0.0805225521326065, 0.020866453647613525, -0.014690259471535683, -0.03171171993017197, 0.03483082354068756, -0.007229293696582317, -0.013882112689316273, 0.019449669867753983, 0.043711911886930466, 0.026877842843532562, 0.005629961844533682, -0.01303042285144329, 0.032502658665180206, 0.03891848027706146, 0.003593707224354148, -0.023311711847782135, 0.006340248975902796, 0.02872474305331707, -0.024855516850948334, 0.0008784233359619975, 0.02224317193031311, -0.0029981324914842844, 0.036321282386779785, -0.03773391619324684, 0.01939946785569191, 0.016225438565015793, -0.03938356414437294, 0.017936166375875473, -0.0411154143512249, 0.0179890263825655, -0.017277251929044724, 0.019562970846891403, 0.025266947224736214, -0.06955423206090927, 0.005459320265799761, 0.08018044382333755, 0.014319460839033127, -0.021042924374341965, -0.012921549379825592, 0.030948512256145477, 0.037980787456035614, -0.03156203031539917, -0.030160512775182724, -0.03169960528612137, 0.0005679283640347421, 0.004081118386238813, -0.002134254202246666, -0.020751357078552246, 0.060079243034124374, 0.01281912624835968, 0.016400715336203575, -0.04025910049676895, -0.05245387554168701, 0.009509853087365627, -0.09230424463748932, 0.010417339392006397, -0.016781410202383995, 0.0514286644756794, -0.012881480157375336, 0.019292643293738365, 0.017546873539686203, -0.010080904699862003, 0.036689355969429016, 0.03836866095662117, -0.07410982996225357, 0.0049337539821863174, 0.007606512866914272, 0.008687236346304417, -0.014959807507693768, -0.011396955698728561, 0.024703074246644974, -0.033281873911619186, 0.01576894521713257, -0.01627335138618946, 0.021436696872115135, -0.021721959114074707, 0.013230480253696442, -0.0008985560853034258, -0.009033246897161007, 0.010259482078254223, 0.008625591173768044, 0.04653802141547203, 0.03140365704894066, -0.006223836913704872, 0.03792094439268112, -0.007935632951557636, -0.0149741405621171, -0.011544523760676384, 0.011029433459043503, 0.014776439405977726, 0.05809541791677475, -0.005040805321186781, 0.045716457068920135, -0.0242807287722826, 0.01797744818031788, -0.02604527212679386, 0.02932082675397396, 0.035482898354530334, -0.031963691115379333, -0.004944668151438236, -0.04720425233244896, -0.023076577112078667, -0.014389362186193466, 0.020482731983065605, 0.014529990963637829, -0.02392495423555374, 0.04267474636435509, 0.027945732697844505, -0.03545209765434265, 0.0023154369555413723, 0.06434521079063416, 0.014285767450928688, -0.03301263228058815, -0.04999937117099762, -0.017198678106069565, 0.010938928462564945, 0.013931903056800365, -0.003766830312088132, -0.0008084905566647649, -0.018282148987054825, 0.03346763178706169, 0.020379461348056793, -0.02985282801091671, 0.0006836270913481712, -0.0020065640565007925, 0.05814013630151749, 0.0573560930788517, 0.0013153881300240755, -0.0022397234570235014, 0.005577113479375839, 0.06252675503492355, 0.04701215773820877, 0.03585829958319664, -0.039122696965932846, -0.0865480899810791, 0.018946941941976547, 0.04332362487912178, 0.016954638063907623, -0.024598363786935806, -0.005220408085733652, -0.01928417943418026, -0.033148348331451416, 0.03213384374976158, -0.02813880518078804, 0.008664926514029503, -0.007336936425417662, -0.011491919867694378, -0.051117561757564545, -0.006053832359611988, -0.03428715839982033, 0.010721787810325623, -0.02688024565577507, 0.040800243616104126, -0.029020534828305244, -0.02397102117538452, -0.031081385910511017, 0.045664526522159576, 0.0075190989300608635, 0.0666276067495346, -0.02241656742990017, -0.019110703840851784, -0.007559804245829582, -0.006033098325133324, -0.044996168464422226, -0.06278818100690842, -0.03892698884010315, 0.030556902289390564, -0.01832752116024494, -0.008400361984968185, 0.0037986983079463243, -0.06703241169452667, 0.01950516737997532, 0.00298200361430645, -0.04134446755051613, -0.0013917029136791825, -0.026645634323358536, 0.051790203899145126, 0.013701679185032845, 0.0026567073073238134, 0.06978817284107208, 0.0035652839578688145, 0.014154484495520592, -0.009084227494895458, -0.031836021691560745, 0.005358035676181316, -0.007557789329439402, -0.04893011972308159, -0.03864819183945656, -0.023405995219945908, 0.0002615263219922781, 0.02757040411233902, -0.019989272579550743, 0.04887869209051132, -0.030759869143366814, -0.046177059412002563, -0.008129293099045753, 0.038470055907964706, 0.016401242464780807, -0.028875838965177536, 0.0223682951182127, 0.05607469379901886, 0.02433781512081623, 0.019696103408932686, -0.01051446795463562, -0.03151603415608406, 0.04976479336619377, 0.04117334261536598, -0.027256984263658524, 0.01203794777393341, -0.05768877640366554, -0.013729896396398544, 0.02381533570587635, 0.006128091365098953, 0.026729997247457504, -0.009861492551863194, 0.030366789549589157, -0.01200221199542284, -0.03811797499656677, -0.00034428140497766435, 0.014522626996040344, -0.00042501025018282235, 0.04708203300833702, -0.04353443533182144, 0.027763914316892624, -0.038121048361063004, -0.0008871006430126727, -0.0723004937171936, -0.030731432139873505, 0.028531569987535477, -0.0237966850399971, -0.016662847250699997, -0.04086022078990936, 0.020994821563363075, -0.03528157249093056, -0.05451233685016632, 0.007675673346966505, 0.06519454717636108, -0.02581426315009594, -0.019310707226395607, -0.03768116235733032, 0.0273748766630888, 0.055592313408851624, 0.02263701520860195, 0.017227619886398315, -0.009153859689831734, 0.0006012146477587521, -0.014282400719821453, 0.02723008394241333, -0.004517268389463425, -0.029784128069877625, 0.004162119701504707, -0.03432488813996315, 0.0030357821378856897, 0.05021108314394951, -0.004806322976946831, -0.020118407905101776, -0.014649340882897377, -0.038105208426713943, 0.008554850704967976, -0.025426965206861496, 0.013479910790920258, 0.028059309348464012, -0.00999212171882391, -0.005770788993686438, 0.02587939240038395, -0.016326146200299263, -0.017886610701680183, 0.028964173048734665, -0.002740793861448765, -0.008189871907234192, 0.02459751069545746, 0.061890922486782074, 0.003681040834635496, -0.007035547401756048, -0.018189765512943268, -0.02604812942445278, 0.05932985246181488, 0.004388004541397095, -0.014805455692112446, 0.013598506338894367, 0.048448916524648666, -0.04846259579062462, -0.01579897478222847, -0.014862807467579842, -0.04631486535072327, 0.03215779364109039, -0.043051671236753464, 0.03935081139206886, 0.054985642433166504, -0.009093206375837326, 0.0005580652505159378, -0.0603145956993103, 0.00761055713519454, -0.022296937182545662, 0.018371136859059334, 0.054265767335891724, 0.005988998804241419, -0.012438789010047913, 0.040772464126348495, -0.0031502689234912395, 0.005416617263108492, 0.04452360048890114, -0.011766989715397358, 0.041333846747875214, 0.008387797512114048, -0.05611219257116318, -0.06376413255929947, 0.0442904569208622, -0.05107368156313896, -0.017683418467640877, -0.010204751044511795, -0.018243413418531418, 0.02894715964794159, 0.023060953244566917, 0.003773896023631096, -0.02404281310737133, 0.020299749448895454, -0.046313319355249405, 0.027838535606861115, 0.03450264781713486, -0.006292750593274832, 0.039892569184303284, -0.0019557643681764603, 0.05555169656872749, 0.0116463927552104, 0.019511790946125984, 0.0015247320989146829, -0.05949285998940468, -0.054430488497018814, -0.016078192740678787, -0.02457978017628193, 0.017337990924715996, 0.007427884731441736, -0.033803269267082214, 0.0028526298701763153, -0.005751464050263166, 0.026321016252040863, -0.009263144806027412, 0.0562557689845562, -0.041890453547239304, 0.035800836980342865, -0.01518659945577383, -0.019048497080802917, 0.0032436498440802097, 0.0015947440406307578, 0.1293632984161377, 0.11632833629846573, 0.053278081119060516, -0.034226253628730774, 0.03295983746647835, -0.010273262858390808, -0.01821054145693779, -0.004328293725848198, -0.007058748044073582, 0.023090442642569542, 0.002624458633363247, 0.024790192022919655, 0.0369889996945858, 0.01397885661572218, 0.016014713793992996, 0.047191742807626724, -0.025964507833123207, -0.0015626808162778616, 0.02420923113822937, 0.023315541446208954, -0.009267013520002365, -0.01146214734762907, -0.028059091418981552, 0.0022964461240917444, 0.005031257402151823, -0.01937262713909149, -0.009626622311770916, -0.027800245210528374, 0.02756471000611782, -0.014365720562636852, -0.019179753959178925, -0.00525554409250617, -0.0032151935156434774, 0.01475490815937519, -0.01472416426986456, 0.01066064927726984, -0.014711015857756138, -0.027767712250351906, -0.012649217620491982, 0.022413885220885277, 0.013540892861783504, 0.007541408762335777, -0.02998378314077854, 0.017622599378228188, -0.049824755638837814, -0.05008849874138832, -0.030669305473566055, 0.04531025514006615, -0.007924983277916908, -0.019931690767407417, -0.0012040083529427648, 0.01162397675216198, 0.01648259349167347, -0.014873368665575981, -0.034922536462545395, 0.03751019760966301, 0.02008570358157158, -0.020089752972126007, -0.029067065566778183, -0.04201817512512207, 0.006571995560079813, -0.011777023784816265, 0.019623123109340668, 0.007137253414839506, -0.012564283795654774, -0.02387353964149952, -0.005483546294271946, 0.043413400650024414, 0.014215300790965557, 0.015731697902083397, 0.00921397190541029, -0.022891394793987274, -0.022014888003468513, -0.0244993194937706, 0.03955534100532532, 0.0167837031185627, -0.005725710652768612, -0.01397431269288063, -0.0075684599578380585, -0.041643474251031876, -0.021667305380105972, -0.0015255585312843323, -0.03368620201945305, 0.009086523205041885, -0.03367204964160919, -0.022763926535844803, 0.008442741818726063, 0.04114217683672905, 0.019600117579102516, -0.003388406243175268, 0.008187423460185528, 0.01802895963191986, 0.004221061710268259, -0.0527220219373703, -0.028492767363786697, -0.008990113623440266, -0.03083207830786705, 0.04080218821763992, 0.014204657636582851, 0.11169946938753128, -0.0217958502471447, 0.006674680858850479, -0.0146870082244277, 0.032565731555223465, 0.002599709201604128, 0.02092023752629757, 0.005193849094212055, -0.06640889495611191, 0.010297168046236038, 0.011034674011170864, -0.006102186162024736, -0.04069337248802185, -0.00909249298274517, -0.01934404857456684, -0.02924380637705326, 0.023667097091674805, -0.025010425597429276, -0.018697459250688553, 0.032533202320337296, -0.026509908959269524, 0.05785069614648819, -0.04028593376278877, 0.000411985965911299, -0.024812204763293266, 0.001969984034076333, -0.06368754804134369, -0.0698523074388504, 0.009415160864591599, -0.008525805547833443, -0.02845088206231594, 0.004649399779736996, 0.04920356348156929, 0.0010062886867672205, 0.016872169449925423, -0.013164786621928215, 0.014249080792069435, 0.004526129923760891, 0.043213844299316406, -0.052356455475091934, -0.015519725158810616, 0.0581708662211895, -0.05958632752299309, -0.06573265045881271, 0.012630400247871876, -0.030479250475764275, 0.044385749846696854, 0.031316209584474564, -0.007019509095698595, -0.018926169723272324, 0.028157809749245644, -0.035076044499874115, -0.026308836415410042, 0.004611168522387743, 0.03254909813404083, 0.02388615719974041, -0.012787128798663616, 0.04151305556297302, -0.00443009240552783, -0.02076941914856434, 0.03244369104504585, 0.00316334399394691, 0.009321850724518299, -0.009483782574534416, 0.030398711562156677, 0.014097507111728191, 0.055805809795856476, -0.004270133096724749, 0.0019323829328641295, 0.031453125178813934, 0.043879423290491104, -0.04595564678311348, 0.05318514630198479, -0.013276800513267517, 0.0358455628156662, -0.08676460385322571, -0.03019464761018753, -0.026515832170844078, 0.0020362031646072865, 0.005262008868157864, -0.053704019635915756, -0.005227755289524794, 0.021929513663053513, -0.03864056617021561, 0.05542135238647461, -0.030894877389073372, 0.008519881404936314, -0.01336020790040493, -0.016482625156641006, -0.004900814034044743, 0.011566422879695892, 0.03086199425160885, -0.008101338520646095, -0.006376917939633131, 0.005132521968334913, 0.012964817695319653, -0.02540642023086548, -0.021287865936756134, 0.03196952864527702, -0.016337569802999496, -0.05069715902209282, 0.03299262002110481, 0.005922915879637003, -0.05000115931034088, 0.01882166601717472, -0.009404243901371956, 0.011514787562191486, 0.043947577476501465, 0.0014046321157366037, 0.001308840117417276, 0.04404231905937195, 0.0450015664100647, 0.0006881622830405831, 0.0010185010032728314, -0.005314005073159933, -0.002180870622396469, 0.027227161452174187, 0.009451817721128464, 0.012192418798804283, 0.042864859104156494, -0.0024564298801124096, -0.011587127111852169, 0.019107230007648468, 0.004259698558598757, -0.02553842030465603, 0.015499047003686428, 0.008656752295792103, -0.0054750144481658936, -0.03261156752705574, -0.0005547741311602294, -0.022805124521255493, 0.008414785377681255, 0.012905013747513294, 0.01716926321387291, -0.0156440157443285, 0.01953238993883133, -0.011481163091957569, -0.02121901325881481, -0.02009473741054535, 0.024407852441072464, -0.01673332042992115, -0.05096755921840668, -0.004813562147319317, -0.004046766087412834, -0.023376449942588806, -0.06483140587806702, -0.003214475465938449, 0.02561725489795208, 0.05289674550294876, -0.02638157084584236, 0.030367393046617508, 0.02836555428802967, -0.03747500106692314, -0.010829171165823936, -0.08717510104179382, 0.07878090441226959, 0.0027420620899647474, -0.004618237726390362, -0.031117640435695648, 0.003168240888044238, -0.04066552221775055, -0.006615424994379282, 0.06045866757631302, 0.053750015795230865, 0.02783200517296791, -0.0455404631793499, 0.012828407809138298, 0.010412529110908508, -0.0538121797144413, 0.02553052455186844, -0.0093641746789217, -0.021416708827018738, -0.010738243348896503, 0.0036731332074850798, 0.004885590169578791, -0.019872643053531647, 0.007750749588012695, 0.0033885962329804897, 0.021513961255550385, 0.013352534733712673, 0.020978640764951706, 0.009997415356338024, 0.027150504291057587, 0.006886634044349194, 0.031068164855241776, -0.002721265656873584, 0.01075491402298212, 0.011982026509940624, -0.010459746234118938, -0.07072685658931732, -0.025422215461730957, -0.050778940320014954, -0.03981969505548477, -0.004468343686312437, 0.02837669663131237, 0.006696123629808426, -0.03726641833782196, 0.017423944547772408, 0.010427468456327915, -0.035100057721138, 0.016556909307837486, 0.048547517508268356, 0.04736444726586342, 0.037135545164346695, 0.012008043006062508, 0.015665212646126747, 0.04750184342265129, -0.015368655323982239, 0.0032485227566212416, 0.02433134987950325, 0.03690316900610924, 0.02740619331598282, 0.009511347860097885, 0.02094378136098385, -0.011065274477005005, 0.015586827881634235, 0.004736424423754215, 0.05751277878880501, -0.04038763791322708, -0.019903670996427536, 0.00453256256878376, -0.025378568097949028, -0.010842197574675083, -0.030791576951742172, -0.009607368148863316, 0.0631902888417244, -0.03162451833486557, -0.03896080330014229, -0.05694114416837692, -0.007362544536590576, 0.02467295713722706, 0.052577074617147446, -0.0015805265866219997, 0.06092219427227974, -0.009633045643568039, -0.005895520560443401, -0.03048853762447834, 0.005523297004401684, 0.04106983169913292, -0.00702998461201787, 0.04419657588005066, -0.012552797794342041, -0.00412329938262701, -0.017504902556538582, -0.013171058148145676, -0.023107582703232765, -0.031676359474658966, 0.01175321452319622, 0.0660499706864357, 0.05098782479763031, 0.005247598979622126, -0.03537488356232643, -0.018097519874572754, 0.036905523389577866, -0.0726841539144516, -0.03287801519036293, -0.037844717502593994, 0.02224094420671463, -0.0025953128933906555, -0.008685560896992683 ]
<p>I was thinking of this problem.</p> <p><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two_envelopes_problem" rel="nofollow">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two_envelopes_problem</a></p> <p>I believe the solution and I think I understand it, but if I take the following approach I'm completely confused.</p> <p>Problem 1:</p> <blockquote> <p>I will offer you the following game. You pay me \$10 and I will flip a fair coin. Heads I give you \$5 and Tails I give you \$20.</p> <p>The expectation is \$12.5 so you will always play the game.</p> </blockquote> <p>Problem 2:</p> <blockquote> <p>I will give you an envelope with \$10, the envelope is open and you can check. I then show you another envelope, closed this time and tell you: This envelope either has \$5 or $20 in it with equal probability. Do you want to swap?</p> <p>I feel this is exactly the same as problem 1, you forgo \$10 for a \$5 or a \$20, so again you will always switch.</p> </blockquote> <p>Problem 3:</p> <blockquote> <p>I do the same as above but close the envelopes. So you don't know there are $10 but some amount X. I tell you the other envelope has double or half. Now if you follow the same logic you want to switch. This is the envelope paradox.</p> </blockquote> <p>What changed when I closed the envelope??</p> <p>EDIT:</p> <p>Some have argued that problem 3 is not the envelope problem and I'm going to try and provide below why I think it is by analysing how each views the game. Also, it gives a better set up for the game.</p> <p>Providing some clarification for Problem 3:</p> <p>From the perspective of the person organising the game:</p> <blockquote> <p>I hold 2 envelopes. In one I put \$10 close it and give it to the player. I then tell him, I have one more envelope that has either double or half the amount of the envelope I just gave you. Do you want to switch? I then proceed to flip a fair coin and Heads I put \$5 in and Tails I put \$20. And hand him the envelope. I then ask him. The envelope you just gave me has twice or half the amount of the envelope you are holding. Do you want to switch?</p> </blockquote> <p>From the perspective of the player:</p> <blockquote> <p>I am given an envelope and told there is another envelope that has double or half the amount with equal probability. Do I want to switch. I think sure I have $X$, hence $\frac{1}{2}(\frac{1}{2}X + 2X) &gt; X$ so I want to switch. I get the envelope and all of a sudden I am facing the exact same situation. I want to switch again as the other envelope has either double or half the amount.</p> </blockquote>
73,387
[ -0.0454801507294178, -0.02853136882185936, 0.03758235275745392, -0.029210006818175316, 0.008569221012294292, -0.009508674964308739, 0.004279579035937786, -0.012505356222391129, 0.009586356580257416, 0.018942365422844887, 0.03945228084921837, 0.037474531680345535, 0.014265852980315685, 0.036402370780706406, -0.0012109564850106835, 0.05169505625963211, 0.046755824238061905, -0.008330865763127804, 0.019510235637426376, -0.00856770295649767, -0.016654539853334427, 0.024126334115862846, 0.008301779627799988, -0.0014052584301680326, -0.0502571202814579, 0.0372534841299057, 0.04175593703985214, -0.03478862717747688, 0.027708683162927628, 0.05319305881857872, -0.0389600470662117, 0.00145696010440588, 0.01736469194293022, -0.015066257677972317, 0.03479210287332535, 0.0084996921941638, 0.007368265185505152, -0.0005323906661942601, 0.020753754302859306, -0.005784183274954557, -0.05310036987066269, 0.04864136129617691, 0.019729889929294586, 0.04239535704255104, -0.009536992758512497, 0.013562639243900776, -0.01377780083566904, 0.005348382983356714, 0.01636960357427597, -0.05698004737496376, 0.06405412405729294, -0.021620091050863266, 0.010395917110145092, 0.036754071712493896, 0.009173628874123096, -0.013686149381101131, 0.05229196324944496, 0.08511655777692795, -0.006726959720253944, -0.04167477414011955, -0.004050788469612598, -0.005121726542711258, -0.009952623397111893, -0.008892352692782879, -0.03543000668287277, 0.025168344378471375, 0.010141685605049133, 0.00979714933782816, -0.01352120004594326, -0.029277373105287552, 0.012495476752519608, 0.01353785116225481, 0.03895595297217369, -0.014951533637940884, 0.02589220181107521, 0.0006829748162999749, 0.00016982821398414671, 0.04787229001522064, 0.044900186359882355, 0.07972334325313568, 0.023486454039812088, -0.026380043476819992, 0.021710021421313286, 0.011973539367318153, 0.03893782198429108, -0.03218597173690796, 0.043176840990781784, -0.004515796899795532, 0.050457753241062164, 0.02049507386982441, 0.02484925091266632, -0.009964851662516594, 0.05820070952177048, -0.029449257999658585, -0.026758641004562378, 0.06110452860593796, -0.02788630686700344, 0.01961968094110489, -0.006969226524233818, -0.029725132510066032, -0.01476787868887186, -0.034200720489025116, -0.009861054830253124, 0.06410377472639084, -0.01057871337980032, 0.006836443208158016, -0.01321562472730875, 0.013446980156004429, 0.013575699180364609, -0.017395328730344772, -0.04263252764940262, 0.07775890082120895, -0.03343256562948227, 0.025618206709623337, -0.033593274652957916, -0.04143214970827103, -0.01816817931830883, -0.0023532595951110125, 0.04088203236460686, 0.05514220520853996, 0.01408205647021532, -0.026656122878193855, 0.011837744154036045, -0.04231729730963707, -0.05568079650402069, -0.046190205961465836, 0.02269044518470764, 0.019983911886811256, -0.023747935891151428, 0.05437193438410759, 0.022917089983820915, -0.03353710472583771, -0.0008993339142762125, 0.02463243529200554, 0.012619071640074253, -0.0284414142370224, -0.09286954998970032, -0.06888317316770554, 0.03412865102291107, -0.025467274710536003, -0.028534600511193275, -0.0397537499666214, 0.0009490038501098752, 0.045698147267103195, 0.03558548539876938, -0.0020640678703784943, 0.025358982384204865, 0.0027736637275666, 0.03898027166724205, 0.04750983417034149, -0.005862460937350988, 0.027079332619905472, -0.02473352663218975, 0.01974167302250862, -0.016043003648519516, -0.051372624933719635, -0.023899182677268982, 0.03225398808717728, -0.019209550693631172, -0.030798783525824547, -0.007968931458890438, 0.008293027989566326, -0.05640941113233566, -0.024575674906373024, -0.027705930173397064, -0.04492131620645523, 0.10736621171236038, 0.03686438873410225, 0.04142149165272713, 0.023964527994394302, -0.0015021796571090817, 0.019007215276360512, -0.02960270829498768, -0.002971230074763298, 0.015231127850711346, -0.05982786417007446, 0.01069075521081686, -0.029915189370512962, -0.01010869350284338, 0.008772536180913448, -0.030203726142644882, 0.022893410176038742, -0.029285136610269547, -0.011408694088459015, 0.011578431352972984, -0.026530032977461815, 0.025810418650507927, 0.0256886575371027, -0.021542692556977272, -0.04338742047548294, -0.06262166798114777, -0.08337176591157913, 0.012539952993392944, -0.0033543927129358053, 0.027312733232975006, 0.025519950315356255, -0.031217342242598534, -0.02040492184460163, -0.017674770206212997, 0.0040684957057237625, -0.02415124699473381, 0.062382154166698456, 0.031554073095321655, -0.049321845173835754, -0.01850394532084465, 0.07091008871793747, 0.027474962174892426, -0.02672542817890644, 0.02200973406434059, -0.05449412763118744, -0.009493594989180565, 0.02400965988636017, -0.029534652829170227, 0.032271359115839005, -0.0016455685254186392, 0.001472773845307529, 0.0464298352599144, 0.010704782791435719, 0.0035003290977329016, 0.028396431356668472, -0.05530888959765434, 0.06242622435092926, 0.06313096731901169, 0.02294333465397358, 0.013521532528102398, 0.014696800149977207, 0.0037977967876940966, 0.04396776854991913, 0.00840908195823431, -0.04286196082830429, -0.04068474471569061, -0.03292466327548027, 0.01738821528851986, 0.01662086509168148, -0.00338661577552557, 0.030763395130634308, 0.07836596667766571, 0.018118401989340782, -0.021936533972620964, 0.013106975704431534, -0.004224043805152178, 0.0270839836448431, 0.01887986995279789, 0.0010617109946906567, 0.02777777798473835, 0.0989607498049736, 0.011747857555747032, -0.025092655792832375, -0.005211313255131245, 0.03427138179540634, -0.060030460357666016, 0.03619430586695671, 0.016595592722296715, 0.018525073304772377, -0.020178036764264107, -0.021393844857811928, 0.03191420063376427, -0.04334644973278046, -0.012234367430210114, 0.019538281485438347, 0.02249196171760559, -0.04647117108106613, -0.006943426560610533, -0.025700556114315987, -0.01051219180226326, -0.025129862129688263, -0.032195936888456345, 0.020536646246910095, 0.01616125926375389, 0.0010176440700888634, 0.010393465869128704, -0.002848129952326417, 0.0025506571400910616, 0.02278456650674343, 0.008503017015755177, 0.002584102563560009, -0.013585606589913368, -0.02569473162293434, -0.043811049312353134, -0.0016000267351046205, 0.0009685723925940692, 0.012366145849227905, 0.00021526709315367043, -0.004359210841357708, -0.06787551939487457, 0.04705338552594185, -0.022763047367334366, -0.07675814628601074, 0.026529492810368538, 0.017227061092853546, 0.03934086114168167, 0.02982792630791664, 0.01631094701588154, -0.013302961364388466, 0.007706869393587112, -0.02515464648604393, 0.004352850839495659, -0.02705858275294304, -0.008679965510964394, 0.0919196829199791, 0.019187914207577705, -0.0671858862042427, 0.02659371681511402, -0.023066261783242226, -0.06283208727836609, -0.02945123426616192, -0.02569006010890007, -0.008510855957865715, -0.011061256751418114, -0.006620394065976143, -0.022653676569461823, 0.018719691783189774, -0.02973887138068676, -0.06300918012857437, -0.07832971960306168, -0.008569413796067238, -0.019872654229402542, 0.0022953832522034645, 0.010131647810339928, -0.010419987142086029, 0.07101466506719589, 0.03547966852784157, 0.0030314491596072912, -0.03243669867515564, 0.006388090550899506, -0.011352410539984703, -0.017420727759599686, -0.022608136758208275, 0.022930599749088287, -0.021578900516033173, -0.014476312324404716, -0.0018777564400807023, 0.03665127605199814, 0.017216740176081657, -0.018592050299048424, -0.0016434426652267575, -0.004756361711770296, 0.0182732455432415, -0.014313850551843643, 0.046360284090042114, 0.004277945030480623, -0.008492819964885712, -0.021483680233359337, 0.01911921612918377, -0.0005148418713361025, -0.004481503274291754, -0.024144137278199196, 0.029162131249904633, -0.01577584445476532, 0.018340202048420906, 0.0049161845818161964, 0.053883012384176254, -0.0064072017557919025, 0.005130949895828962, -0.0018010587664321065, 0.000035277676943223923, 0.06985414773225784, -0.03990747407078743, -0.004884503781795502, 0.06954043358564377, 0.044744823127985, -0.01725625805556774, -0.06229018792510033, -0.03393898531794548, 0.0251197200268507, 0.017241274937987328, -0.015525189228355885, -0.03489607572555542, 0.035789135843515396, 0.057032108306884766, 0.014832733199000359, 0.014843253418803215, -0.04685980826616287, 0.0027553269173949957, -0.08284014463424683, 0.007632109802216291, -0.016068264842033386, 0.0503111258149147, 0.011252796277403831, 0.0451226644217968, 0.007411499507725239, 0.004158905707299709, -0.03714881092309952, 0.027327291667461395, -0.07850231230258942, 0.03695211932063103, 0.022880056872963905, 0.017494842410087585, -0.013124148361384869, 0.0005127133917994797, 0.016983849927783012, -0.021542148664593697, -0.010285534895956516, -0.03792977333068848, 0.01631217636168003, -0.03340565040707588, 0.031721096485853195, -0.0025996845215559006, -0.03251686319708824, 0.0110755180940032, 0.012169009074568748, 0.013008719310164452, 0.011109450832009315, 0.07036706060171127, 0.0007446020608767867, -0.02898074872791767, -0.004051888827234507, 0.012073082849383354, 0.03141250088810921, 0.05550039932131767, 0.045801471918821335, 0.014108440838754177, 0.028805699199438095, -0.02207009866833687, -0.012869498692452908, 0.0014452202012762427, 0.04257930815219879, 0.006546270567923784, -0.03959909826517105, -0.009886386804282665, -0.05595577508211136, -0.007826839573681355, 0.0027935090474784374, 0.015523571521043777, -0.017536817118525505, 0.032300543040037155, 0.05290403962135315, -0.023095186799764633, -0.007949638180434704, 0.004686837084591389, 0.04242893308401108, 0.005865939427167177, -0.026704566553235054, -0.023102905601263046, -0.02327161468565464, -0.028691638261079788, 0.03973395377397537, -0.0007993968320079148, -0.010801712982356548, 0.013247964903712273, -0.0032833581790328026, 0.03491652011871338, 0.000580453546717763, -0.005038936156779528, 0.02531803958117962, -0.01652853935956955, 0.04235393553972244, -0.008730762638151646, -0.026253221556544304, 0.0064697242341935635, 0.003068687627092004, -0.0006963810883462429, 0.024196123704314232, 0.00011915898357983679, -0.007015238981693983, -0.013709578663110733, 0.01668696478009224, 0.052352938801050186, -0.03249369189143181, 0.016626417636871338, -0.049294035881757736, -0.027204234153032303, -0.003549461252987385, -0.04477144777774811, 0.014740679413080215, -0.04576963186264038, -0.005200396757572889, -0.029034119099378586, -0.015480468049645424, -0.020748009905219078, -0.0024445506278425455, -0.032162051647901535, 0.053550515323877335, -0.02631278522312641, -0.01611454226076603, -0.017282631248235703, 0.01859932206571102, 0.0661398321390152, 0.04792766645550728, -0.05880967527627945, 0.03557967022061348, 0.026106273755431175, 0.0001112349855247885, -0.02558020129799843, -0.0951341912150383, 0.003670151112601161, -0.01811252534389496, -0.0012031063670292497, 0.013646514154970646, -0.0054238177835941315, -0.08510191738605499, 0.014017101377248764, -0.03414304926991463, -0.002753029577434063, 0.055867794901132584, -0.016716279089450836, 0.05243217200040817, 0.05062548443675041, 0.01149542536586523, 0.04471562057733536, 0.05966551601886749, -0.008613774552941322, 0.0388098880648613, -0.0004831865953747183, -0.00023245972988661379, -0.03024071455001831, 0.00829377956688404, -0.03777733072638512, 0.030012346804142, -0.04207950830459595, 0.04928096756339073, 0.02280660904943943, 0.03325997292995453, -0.0130333062261343, -0.04050644487142563, -0.01879776641726494, 0.004773168358951807, 0.008081947453320026, 0.016092030331492424, -0.035527292639017105, -0.04261809587478638, -0.004076269920915365, -0.005683660972863436, 0.030875833705067635, 0.0032990030013024807, 0.007742675952613354, -0.0004571835452225059, -0.03025934100151062, 0.00489804008975625, -0.05656052008271217, 0.00843611266463995, -0.03155524656176567, -0.050682734698057175, 0.028003131970763206, -0.00544592784717679, 0.015373560599982738, 0.015007768757641315, -0.007723386865109205, -0.03401487320661545, 0.03716380149126053, 0.009904422797262669, -0.025167416781187057, -0.05273626372218132, 0.03432789444923401, 0.024272747337818146, -0.0044870320707559586, -0.043790094554424286, 0.012729845009744167, 0.02068491093814373, -0.008873571641743183, -0.03780193626880646, -0.0050880503840744495, -0.020922422409057617, 0.013784872367978096, -0.03252531215548515, -0.05762183293700218, -0.0045325011014938354, 0.00205276464112103, 0.001644361182115972, 0.0033812467008829117, -0.010509432293474674, 0.03502730652689934, 0.004249433521181345, -0.012698281556367874, -0.017532797530293465, -0.03490392491221428, -0.015890179201960564, -0.017957348376512527, 0.008257831446826458, -0.02024884708225727, -0.049188435077667236, -0.022316455841064453, -0.007383578922599554, 0.022815106436610222, -0.009795963764190674, -0.02438531257212162, -0.01458017434924841, -0.023495836183428764, -0.022687794640660286, -0.006456541828811169, 0.002775771776214242, 0.012287233024835587, -0.0025081364437937737, 0.011221406050026417, 0.022200068458914757, 0.008951330557465553, -0.03339822217822075, 0.006880536675453186, -0.00963106844574213, 0.002256625099107623, 0.009410381317138672, 0.09244014322757721, -0.044800858944654465, -0.005282475613057613, -0.006482396740466356, -0.022973651066422462, 0.021582836285233498, -0.05716527998447418, 0.0036149942316114902, 0.01577926240861416, 0.03303695097565651, -0.028565842658281326, -0.046123482286930084, -0.05192257836461067, 0.04042007774114609, 0.02169734798371792, 0.013105807825922966, 0.03497307375073433, 0.03788972273468971, -0.0072732362896203995, 0.016967186704277992, -0.009164955466985703, 0.018691347911953926, -0.048986587673425674, 0.03334600850939751, 0.03450562059879303, -0.02922440506517887, 0.010264544747769833, 0.058569833636283875, 0.03645150363445282, 0.05807243287563324, -0.004853983875364065, 0.005311302840709686, 0.01503141038119793, 0.021840432658791542, -0.06415686011314392, -0.039007607847452164, 0.021442251279950142, -0.049788761883974075, 0.030414627864956856, 0.004133566748350859, -0.026104185730218887, 0.032385602593421936, -0.0007636344525963068, -0.015006281435489655, -0.02247968502342701, -0.014896099455654621, -0.046793133020401, 0.014610152691602707, -0.008558060973882675, 0.01884889230132103, 0.01697121374309063, 0.004082777071744204, 0.04239428788423538, -0.01565377041697502, 0.024288151413202286, -0.07430588454008102, -0.07012723386287689, -0.006478163413703442, -0.02826475352048874, -0.014734795317053795, 0.049530476331710815, 0.003778125625103712, 0.015228033997118473, 0.0067473179660737514, -0.047611165791749954, -0.0367932952940464, 0.03839963674545288, 0.00222021690569818, -0.029218260198831558, 0.05414154380559921, -0.010340210050344467, 0.042865049093961716, -0.04127845540642738, -0.01304053794592619, 0.12517103552818298, 0.051214978098869324, 0.029279781505465508, -0.06392809748649597, 0.04353119432926178, -0.019859757274389267, 0.0250005554407835, -0.013977466151118279, 0.03791973367333412, -0.01688825711607933, 0.014319621957838535, 0.01012110710144043, 0.06357701122760773, 0.011693992651998997, -0.025843126699328423, 0.029342859983444214, -0.06902284175157547, -0.03693518787622452, -0.0024011428467929363, 0.005175765138119459, 0.006065829657018185, -0.026545114815235138, -0.024985117837786674, 0.025422722101211548, -0.023203736171126366, 0.007245364133268595, -0.010696488432586193, -0.019200440496206284, 0.03775639086961746, -0.0032344022765755653, 0.015843097120523453, 0.0026253981050103903, 0.006685419473797083, -0.01872394047677517, 0.01775578409433365, 0.05863532796502113, 0.020917784422636032, -0.05336056649684906, 0.017402399331331253, 0.02543274499475956, 0.01406456995755434, 0.0029293992556631565, 0.037796955555677414, 0.02534903585910797, -0.05789733678102493, -0.015384609811007977, -0.036606863141059875, 0.009879937395453453, -0.01054591778665781, -0.03603183850646019, -0.017496725544333458, 0.00685759587213397, -0.006862655282020569, -0.03960125148296356, -0.016699446365237236, 0.019546378403902054, 0.0033397721126675606, -0.022926723584532738, -0.013333470560610294, -0.026060422882437706, 0.044354185461997986, -0.008227305486798286, 0.04232177138328552, 0.018658721819519997, -0.026854339987039566, -0.046824075281620026, -0.02921336703002453, 0.035684701055288315, 0.013208854012191296, 0.00724736787378788, -0.01913529820740223, -0.0036426556762307882, -0.07204215228557587, -0.012088713236153126, -0.011769639328122139, 0.011680523864924908, 0.02507651410996914, 0.009603621438145638, 0.0023350187111645937, 0.010605105198919773, -0.033336345106363297, 0.021585017442703247, -0.022392576560378075, 0.01818900555372238, -0.02704063057899475, 0.005275540053844452, -0.01144212856888771, -0.01455960888415575, 0.024503417313098907, 0.0014516875380650163, 0.039809972047805786, 0.0394304022192955, -0.007127146702259779, -0.013651277869939804, -0.05292313173413277, -0.02019367553293705, -0.03233911842107773, -0.015507112257182598, -0.029659932479262352, 0.04805787652730942, 0.008677637204527855, 0.012603670358657837, -0.028748279437422752, -0.007786725647747517, -0.06236719340085983, -0.007607981562614441, 0.018845554441213608, -0.02717904932796955, 0.000594796147197485, 0.0697561576962471, 0.038441672921180725, -0.029941760003566742, -0.00539378309622407, -0.005046193487942219, -0.006170931737869978, 0.052648600190877914, 0.0003154782752972096, -0.02154000848531723, 0.007856442593038082, -0.020084870979189873, 0.06879658997058868, -0.03916526958346367, -0.03407524153590202, -0.044300105422735214, 0.009091819636523724, 0.015081778168678284, -0.004148825071752071, -0.01467935647815466, -0.006285601761192083, 0.035294439643621445, -0.01837846264243126, 0.034555889666080475, 0.0013356260024011135, -0.030651938170194626, -0.012776082381606102, 0.018778400495648384, 0.053998932242393494, 0.03807114064693451, -0.038304056972265244, -0.04530046880245209, 0.019743168726563454, -0.02834293432533741, -0.011674484238028526, -0.019499700516462326, 0.04805292934179306, 0.04342895746231079, 0.02882755920290947, -0.009984361939132214, 0.016546284779906273, 0.05737101286649704, -0.032872606068849564, -0.028761984780430794, 0.00276513141579926, -0.01624882034957409, 0.04011939465999603, -0.013896482065320015, -0.009853694587945938, 0.0034775573294609785, -0.004201504401862621, 0.023631282150745392, 0.0019112990703433752, 0.0005823177052661777, -0.036536600440740585, 0.0030160495080053806, -0.00980162899941206, 0.0033920849673449993, -0.028544003143906593, 0.006341156084090471, -0.028808729723095894, -0.008376557379961014, -0.0027446832973510027, 0.032793838530778885, -0.0037456259597092867, 0.00878302101045847, -0.07082272320985794, 0.015419332310557365, 0.03167213127017021, 0.01881970278918743, 0.03308052197098732, -0.03575487062335014, 0.0073498827405273914, 0.03790174797177315, -0.027423938736319542, 0.02888692170381546, 0.010727436281740665, -0.02047152817249298, -0.04536473751068115, 0.0521947406232357, -0.06374002248048782, 0.03039451502263546, 0.02605617232620716, 0.01351949479430914, 0.025304580107331276, 0.008544753305613995, -0.004666062071919441, -0.03931483253836632, 0.0010664872825145721, 0.04046415537595749, -0.02790009044110775, -0.007337695453315973, 0.04529159516096115, -0.024240918457508087, 0.007627333980053663, 0.06182059273123741, 0.031337372958660126, 0.007795567158609629, -0.02585756406188011, 0.022565005347132683, -0.009026638232171535, 0.052753958851099014, 0.03058193251490593, 0.04102142155170441, 0.04808048531413078, -0.0027360536623746157, -0.004983674734830856, 0.0017361883074045181, 0.020341655239462852, 0.009910907596349716, 0.05024820938706398, 0.00040842077578417957, -0.006586118601262569, 0.009361141361296177, -0.003561731893569231, -0.02351776883006096, 0.008475820533931255, -0.013003772124648094, 0.024941038340330124, -0.000017373025912093, -0.012821909971535206, 0.025817887857556343, -0.0291758943349123, 0.014037058688700199, -0.006287865340709686, -0.028357360512018204, 0.006204446777701378, -0.04013177379965782, -0.018115077167749405, 0.044610340148210526, 0.023161251097917557, 0.00849660113453865, -0.03757156804203987, 0.01707315258681774, -0.007584861945360899, 0.01801922731101513, 0.04536115378141403, -0.038862504065036774, -0.041969094425439835, 0.0010368982329964638, 0.003955792170017958, 0.035123925656080246, -0.032834574580192566, 0.003958649002015591, -0.018008524551987648, -0.07741332799196243, 0.028960198163986206, -0.025312799960374832, -0.0007581561803817749, -0.03461538255214691, -0.027190443128347397, -0.03201887011528015, 0.013453397899866104, 0.057076774537563324, 0.0009346434380859137, -0.02968788519501686, -0.030100110918283463, 0.01893884316086769, 0.036306511610746384, -0.061020348221063614, 0.032163456082344055, 0.006672602146863937, 0.01867603324353695, 0.011586818844079971, -0.01612669602036476, 0.013485025614500046, 0.019448159262537956, 0.05284862965345383, -0.017117610201239586, -0.01032130979001522, -0.0027610184624791145, 0.004467516206204891, -0.0030527394264936447, 0.041953857988119125, -0.00496679125353694, 0.016831818968057632, -0.01914454624056816, 0.028734585270285606, -0.021617120131850243, -0.0037697216030210257, -0.05416775867342949, 0.002171299885958433, -0.05322419852018356, -0.01937379688024521, 0.0027070885989814997, 0.028660355135798454, 0.02865133062005043, -0.05992778018116951, -0.033686764538288116, 0.032197244465351105, -0.023234082385897636, -0.04699643701314926, 0.02818732149899006, 0.005604580510407686, 0.016705026850104332, 0.016362907364964485, 0.06484459340572357, -0.0689038410782814, -0.0249741580337286, 0.012918327935039997, -0.04551219940185547, 0.05067979171872139, -0.006947146262973547, 0.05877078324556351, 0.04004252701997757, 0.0019261681009083986, 0.034915100783109665, -0.022064905613660812, 0.019015461206436157, -0.0042093414813280106, -0.00827833078801632, 0.030814727768301964, -0.002532570157200098, -0.05289047211408615, 0.0030586516950279474, 0.010161338374018669, 0.06244011968374252, -0.010539962910115719, 0.025807129219174385, -0.007560159545391798, 0.03256315365433693, -0.040755514055490494, 0.0010449058609083295, 0.0035058006178587675, -0.020740823820233345, -0.014320340007543564, 0.005312266759574413, -0.023428894579410553, 0.023344343528151512, 0.055242929607629776, -0.01959368772804737, 0.01031984481960535, 0.03251158818602562, -0.03149139881134033, -0.04741301387548447, -0.0008775875903666019, 0.0007034422596916556, 0.0015661675715819001, 0.00895739533007145, 0.014667493291199207, 0.021707898005843163, -0.02085365355014801, -0.01609901525080204, -0.008802647702395916, 0.06499826163053513, -0.043604183942079544, 0.011108332313597202, -0.012546720914542675, 0.005700492300093174, 0.039449580013751984, -0.010257069952785969 ]
<p>We are measuring data with a high sample rate (20 kHz) and calculated a big standard error due to our system setup. Currently we are only interested in slow signals (in the order of Hz's) is it valid to use averaging (once per 20.000 samples) and thus lower our standard error with an order 20.000?</p>
41,569
[ -0.01862935721874237, -0.025190608575940132, -0.02736695297062397, -0.021773487329483032, 0.059549763798713684, 0.004666769877076149, -0.03398978337645531, -0.015764573588967323, -0.017467079684138298, -0.009941252879798412, 0.023563850671052933, 0.035983093082904816, 0.0822153091430664, 0.024724498391151428, 0.026247547939419746, -0.011147056706249714, -0.037436842918395996, 0.028769798576831818, -0.01576707512140274, -0.05819803103804588, 0.02002403885126114, 0.03408096358180046, -0.0023120539262890816, -0.017983578145503998, -0.032353226095438004, 0.009961599484086037, 0.05791384354233742, -0.01457177847623825, 0.00768471322953701, 0.01435864344239235, -0.043922338634729385, 0.005164770409464836, 0.016975710168480873, 0.03867427259683609, 0.060434721410274506, -0.02749684639275074, -0.04079277068376541, -0.047236423939466476, 0.00525077898055315, 0.049784693866968155, -0.03334134444594383, 0.03230470418930054, 0.02359699085354805, -0.014215993694961071, -0.00018972023099195212, -0.0004991429159417748, 0.03488648310303688, -0.027387630194425583, 0.020102856680750847, -0.04676314443349838, 0.06302203983068466, -0.003094902727752924, 0.012668692506849766, 0.024853965267539024, 0.006308634765446186, 0.03461882844567299, 0.06187449395656586, 0.03767174482345581, -0.031627874821424484, -0.016209129244089127, 0.01788248121738434, -0.03619978204369545, -0.01473523210734129, -0.007326058112084866, 0.019381621852517128, 0.008461015298962593, -0.046492718160152435, -0.010088633745908737, 0.015772467479109764, -0.024392466992139816, 0.017029497772455215, 0.016602594405412674, 0.03633662685751915, -0.012238897383213043, -0.0005408958531916142, -0.03319054841995239, 0.04101291298866272, 0.01570589281618595, 0.008704731240868568, 0.060952428728342056, -0.0020260163582861423, 0.004877222701907158, 0.040271468460559845, 0.03585536405444145, 0.024107273668050766, -0.027057485654950142, 0.05806479975581169, -0.042194873094558716, 0.01025147084146738, 0.017077362164855003, 0.022182103246450424, 0.01607002317905426, 0.031380198895931244, 0.00018097041174769402, -0.019676199182868004, -0.006715327501296997, -0.02487964741885662, 0.07526584714651108, -0.004117772914469242, -0.03159749135375023, 0.016937406733632088, -0.029180601239204407, 0.04141805320978165, 0.042981263250112534, -0.022557199001312256, 0.0234982967376709, -0.01471544336527586, -0.006592721212655306, -0.017645059153437614, -0.024001026526093483, -0.01236983947455883, -0.03393956273794174, -0.006355178542435169, 0.030966052785515785, 0.01523782778531313, 0.018694374710321426, -0.001046082703396678, 0.0010442481143400073, 0.058480553328990936, 0.07455399632453918, 0.047399990260601044, -0.03939015790820122, 0.002914096461609006, -0.006045673508197069, -0.04093313589692116, 0.0761246383190155, -0.03544694557785988, -0.03979021683335304, -0.06286502629518509, 0.04513843357563019, 0.02387816272675991, -0.016876181587576866, 0.039420995861291885, -0.027441512793302536, 0.07209152728319168, -0.02783784829080105, -0.09875898063182831, -0.07014100253582001, 0.04954466596245766, -0.018814271315932274, -0.002774671418592334, -0.10347405076026917, 0.024996714666485786, 0.02694457769393921, 0.030449047684669495, 0.07390067726373672, 0.04445263370871544, 0.01517997495830059, 0.016043702140450478, 0.02031274512410164, -0.028278019279241562, -0.05028574913740158, 0.0014509102329611778, -0.004675474017858505, -0.002951196627691388, -0.052819617092609406, 0.014149838127195835, -0.016474401578307152, -0.007172253914177418, -0.013960831798613071, -0.02931295335292816, -0.0029759861063212156, -0.016335561871528625, 0.015333817340433598, -0.008128652349114418, -0.04679436236619949, 0.0628092885017395, 0.005808492656797171, 0.04023980349302292, -0.022049540653824806, 0.01993451453745365, 0.017176970839500427, 0.005042288918048143, -0.016177451238036156, 0.039220768958330154, -0.023609444499015808, 0.033090636134147644, -0.0026541338302195072, 0.017056312412023544, 0.019713571295142174, -0.035738710314035416, -0.02011793665587902, -0.02734791673719883, 0.009847109206020832, 0.008630169555544853, 0.037747614085674286, 0.017110643908381462, -0.009968291036784649, -0.03804461285471916, -0.05746830254793167, -0.06035573408007622, -0.053298357874155045, 0.014241809025406837, 0.0016409988747909665, 0.003927415702491999, 0.020902305841445923, 0.0036349475849419832, 0.06125766783952713, -0.017303787171840668, -0.005695007275789976, -0.03262688219547272, -0.0005747067625634372, 0.03679097071290016, -0.05463000386953354, 0.01424243114888668, 0.010933117009699345, 0.0034409919753670692, -0.027633117511868477, 0.021623505279421806, -0.0040315985679626465, -0.04268336296081543, 0.0037792623043060303, -0.036444470286369324, 0.027295419946312904, 0.03716512396931648, -0.026772307232022285, 0.046129122376441956, -0.018501952290534973, -0.00005436954234028235, 0.048049040138721466, -0.014190451242029667, 0.09890604764223099, 0.04542425647377968, 0.012786440551280975, -0.008202719502151012, 0.05160984769463539, 0.01902247592806816, -0.00024132423277478665, 0.01653132401406765, -0.04577067494392395, -0.05191827565431595, 0.04201376810669899, 0.023038718849420547, 0.031697120517492294, -0.07514196634292603, -0.031337201595306396, 0.07408936321735382, -0.021890202537178993, 0.03722387179732323, 0.004745930433273315, 0.024604521691799164, -0.019402215257287025, 0.015764649957418442, 0.04039204865694046, 0.01971936784684658, 0.022667374461889267, -0.012313143350183964, -0.003153490833938122, 0.012879899702966213, 0.025531241670250893, 0.04421050474047661, 0.003247826127335429, -0.024848295375704765, 0.023596266284585, 0.008162124082446098, -0.03024972416460514, 0.0023277581203728914, -0.022210869938135147, 0.06380167603492737, 0.022610055282711983, -0.009389189071953297, 0.03276938572525978, 0.03824474290013313, 0.003254594514146447, 0.0028079068288207054, -0.02805059589445591, -0.027083680033683777, -0.02887289598584175, 0.05411364883184433, -0.04128722473978996, 0.011265694163739681, -0.057705558836460114, -0.01847299002110958, -0.029101235792040825, -0.035122599452733994, 0.046673089265823364, -0.015205775387585163, 0.033692676573991776, -0.031815044581890106, -0.004346584901213646, -0.050094056874513626, -0.008188462816178799, -0.0023913446348160505, 0.025850247591733932, -0.02115379460155964, 0.005382892210036516, 0.027189821004867554, -0.08372247964143753, 0.04066832363605499, -0.00865982286632061, 0.00990410428494215, 0.05411462113261223, 0.006901353597640991, -0.07541844993829727, 0.002678824122995138, -0.0022794739343225956, 0.020239200443029404, -0.016630589962005615, -0.00817371066659689, 0.05600526183843613, 0.016798604279756546, -0.02647050842642784, 0.03669881820678711, -0.039751697331666946, -0.0317770391702652, -0.03437507152557373, -0.015085509046912193, -0.00022153256577439606, -0.029949501156806946, -0.007052958477288485, 0.015969770029187202, -0.045347943902015686, -0.06691454350948334, -0.012581070885062218, -0.06637059897184372, 0.010581271722912788, -0.01579408161342144, 0.059936437755823135, 0.01622956618666649, -0.02196681872010231, 0.06543636322021484, 0.04531458020210266, -0.03112214244902134, -0.026030339300632477, -0.02773815393447876, 0.003054349683225155, -0.0622495636343956, 0.027244484052062035, 0.03385249152779579, -0.02311711572110653, 0.008675987832248211, -0.005283741280436516, 0.011185995303094387, 0.05755624175071716, 0.010878200642764568, -0.0036529323551803827, -0.014036799781024456, -0.015743212774395943, -0.009043815545737743, 0.038064274936914444, 0.027897506952285767, -0.041912373155355453, -0.016945267096161842, 0.004992264322936535, 0.08223480731248856, 0.02881428226828575, -0.04391893744468689, 0.03340383991599083, -0.0004285761096980423, -0.009173929691314697, -0.014956671744585037, -0.006676068529486656, 0.029347356408834457, 0.009031226858496666, -0.013487797230482101, 0.0543595589697361, -0.018560394644737244, 0.0035844319500029087, 0.013428062200546265, 0.05243869870901108, 0.03961028531193733, -0.014826982282102108, -0.03479615971446037, -0.020802300423383713, -0.017811186611652374, 0.024442069232463837, -0.014044566079974174, -0.046123962849378586, 0.044546764343976974, 0.03598611801862717, -0.0013059912016615272, -0.009776468388736248, -0.021805783733725548, 0.045401785522699356, -0.059435468167066574, 0.00025642025866545737, -0.03542573004961014, 0.018479276448488235, 0.032020606100559235, 0.04631591588258743, 0.00023980735568329692, -0.008984159678220749, 0.027354473248124123, -0.01608651876449585, -0.025087879970669746, 0.044366106390953064, -0.0366850309073925, -0.0190159622579813, 0.008500540629029274, -0.023532317951321602, 0.01824549026787281, -0.02336142212152481, 0.05111623555421829, -0.04281165078282356, 0.025259165093302727, -0.042572569102048874, -0.003420917084440589, 0.0453677624464035, 0.02577902190387249, -0.060921330004930496, 0.028328554704785347, 0.0343875028192997, -0.009718109853565693, 0.0015924081671983004, 0.003674647770822048, -0.008946772664785385, -0.01223823893815279, -0.02125854790210724, 0.046073075383901596, -0.03364969417452812, 0.037440259009599686, -0.0007001889171078801, 0.026150623336434364, -0.04630230739712715, 0.010985332541167736, 0.018768861889839172, 0.057673972100019455, 0.004184158518910408, -0.019897064194083214, -0.02525494620203972, -0.030733635649085045, -0.03746611252427101, 0.014914450235664845, 0.04724680632352829, 0.03214729204773903, -0.022171897813677788, -0.009047930128872395, -0.012490486726164818, -0.045877404510974884, 0.01182857807725668, 0.057675816118717194, -0.027651460841298103, 0.026340648531913757, -0.0637284368276596, -0.049833741039037704, -0.005281869787722826, -0.0008199634030461311, 0.03362410143017769, 0.012516124173998833, -0.0019382451428100467, 0.006499337498098612, 0.017191262915730476, 0.009644124656915665, -0.01421023067086935, 0.02906271629035473, 0.039893560111522675, 0.024109451100230217, 0.004327800124883652, -0.0348152332007885, 0.010513265617191792, 0.027138298377394676, 0.031663838773965836, 0.03973941504955292, -0.005451307166367769, -0.09931051731109619, -0.017941059544682503, -0.008314680308103561, 0.02049228735268116, -0.022366715595126152, 0.022161684930324554, -0.05725380405783653, -0.000871857802849263, 0.05596376210451126, -0.01771700382232666, 0.018789341673254967, -0.027958720922470093, 0.003317013382911682, -0.04942253232002258, 0.022358404472470284, -0.009824174456298351, 0.028552910313010216, -0.016567882150411606, 0.028863465413451195, -0.01452990435063839, -0.039247360080480576, -0.011936393566429615, 0.005239720456302166, 0.036059193313121796, 0.046124253422021866, -0.014502860605716705, 0.004324598703533411, 0.014707481488585472, 0.03714866191148758, -0.02827022224664688, -0.0628015398979187, 0.015186896547675133, -0.017849765717983246, 0.006906479597091675, -0.003731250064447522, -0.005669003818184137, -0.029159264639019966, 0.0399453341960907, 0.03587767481803894, -0.01213936135172844, -0.013314387761056423, -0.012865377590060234, 0.043239716440439224, 0.015403980389237404, 0.03353694826364517, 0.0510304719209671, 0.017404379323124886, 0.003814161755144596, 0.0431923009455204, 0.005756638012826443, 0.023052804172039032, -0.07519159466028214, 0.02724747359752655, -0.014278633520007133, -0.030105257406830788, -0.017378559336066246, 0.04634914919734001, 0.008111398667097092, 0.06384549289941788, 0.014002346433699131, -0.003809299785643816, 0.0293749812990427, 0.015062619931995869, -0.0007886433159001172, -0.012126811780035496, -0.0007920051575638354, 0.02904026210308075, -0.03388301283121109, -0.022077545523643494, -0.0002068991307169199, -0.004834081046283245, -0.008752596564590931, 0.030560292303562164, -0.026406336575746536, -0.0046652983874082565, -0.05069264397025108, -0.02213585004210472, 0.016332479193806648, -0.032157763838768005, 0.063711978495121, -0.016175176948308945, 0.028387781232595444, -0.005675497930496931, -0.012884246185421944, -0.0036914723459631205, 0.01241269614547491, -0.023274069651961327, 0.05736855790019035, -0.08604956418275833, 0.06303531676530838, -0.023047616705298424, 0.029210301116108894, -0.05992578715085983, -0.0631754919886589, 0.026423370465636253, 0.00658414326608181, -0.006395398173481226, -0.02896716631948948, -0.013901433907449245, -0.03197392076253891, -0.02030731737613678, -0.005896396469324827, 0.02597319334745407, 0.012447603978216648, -0.05055432394146919, 0.017852334305644035, -0.013001910410821438, 0.08742792159318924, -0.02335328236222267, -0.0022620405070483685, 0.010290813632309437, -0.01789112389087677, -0.018421869724988937, -0.07832897454500198, 0.0427047498524189, -0.05151199921965599, 0.009331908077001572, -0.02762177400290966, -0.019470365718007088, -0.00550308870151639, -0.006401850376278162, -0.005513095296919346, 0.021882183849811554, 0.0014081881381571293, 0.015403793193399906, -0.03197465464472771, 0.04480702802538872, -0.017129186540842056, -0.012011988088488579, -0.008383064530789852, -0.018250998109579086, -0.04938984662294388, -0.01643652468919754, 0.026542427018284798, 0.04957729950547218, -0.02864007093012333, 0.005374044645577669, 0.05390426516532898, 0.0055533177219331264, -0.0017452508909627795, 0.014536580070853233, -0.029484333470463753, 0.027117738500237465, -0.014214441180229187, 0.0164694394916296, 0.028292112052440643, -0.018451344221830368, -0.008988572284579277, -0.05512530729174614, -0.02800799533724785, -0.02540615014731884, 0.07523523271083832, 0.03155926614999771, 0.05275443568825722, 0.018839897587895393, 0.011426321230828762, -0.01196537259966135, -0.04813747853040695, -0.02591690607368946, -0.0251139048486948, 0.005486063193529844, 0.03653404489159584, 0.012918515130877495, -0.006936101242899895, -0.030996182933449745, -0.0020430719014257193, 0.02441621758043766, 0.026313938200473785, 0.01434293482452631, 0.03654336556792259, -0.007044062949717045, 0.017665861174464226, -0.027633456513285637, 0.011342821642756462, -0.052526142448186874, 0.02865036204457283, -0.033881429582834244, -0.026394745334982872, 0.02090713381767273, 0.01203459408134222, 0.010487194173038006, -0.07229622453451157, 0.0024189490359276533, -0.02912907302379608, 0.0030754837207496166, -0.017080126330256462, -0.023184971883893013, 0.031212275847792625, 0.007029431406408548, 0.01667768321931362, 0.00880526751279831, 0.03183417022228241, -0.026023639366030693, -0.05698872730135918, -0.013660725206136703, -0.03268871083855629, -0.03424226492643356, 0.0635705441236496, 0.019844012334942818, -0.014936148189008236, 0.029984332621097565, -0.00430457666516304, 0.025008639320731163, -0.007240330334752798, 0.02902495115995407, -0.028459757566452026, 0.04965514689683914, 0.029956132173538208, 0.0019231484038755298, 0.0037371187936514616, 0.00999643187969923, 0.11803991347551346, 0.06201574206352234, 0.006301905959844589, -0.03884318843483925, 0.033597879111766815, 0.006702797021716833, 0.014859970659017563, -0.04088672995567322, 0.0033808890730142593, -0.012543470598757267, -0.02264169417321682, 0.032800380140542984, 0.03578256815671921, -0.00040239832014776766, -0.022056054323911667, 0.07085821032524109, -0.001508143381215632, 0.011782925575971603, 0.011646142229437828, 0.04239390417933464, 0.01832433044910431, 0.012190155684947968, 0.015009700320661068, 0.03171982988715172, -0.035675641149282455, -0.025514280423521996, -0.004994660150259733, -0.0018107291543856263, -0.01503554917871952, -0.005029706750065088, 0.004904355388134718, 0.017990028485655785, 0.04108140617609024, -0.012573092244565487, -0.059713464230298996, -0.016204888001084328, -0.02063923515379429, -0.011873736046254635, 0.00849605817347765, 0.001278932555578649, 0.012790695764124393, 0.013486268930137157, 0.01400117389857769, 0.0327281728386879, -0.02016955427825451, -0.015471032820641994, -0.027110902592539787, 0.012246442027390003, 0.02467440254986286, -0.01756550744175911, -0.009956822730600834, 0.02387349121272564, 0.010242077521979809, -0.055163074284791946, 0.01325948629528284, -0.01730763353407383, 0.011405916884541512, -0.014385776594281197, -0.02970210835337639, -0.04767018184065819, 0.03304459527134895, 0.0022376880515366793, 0.00021865704911760986, 0.019094208255410194, -0.011973056010901928, -0.0032408072147518396, 0.04334601014852524, 0.03128240630030632, -0.010201169177889824, -0.02018864080309868, -0.024737020954489708, 0.03351692482829094, -0.05252953618764877, 0.015480794943869114, 0.02016373537480831, -0.022941067814826965, 0.0447961799800396, -0.005317649804055691, -0.006336220074445009, -0.024783974513411522, -0.07823885977268219, 0.06279289722442627, 0.025022432208061218, -0.03238077089190483, -0.03371506184339523, 0.006554902996867895, -0.027554374188184738, 0.0449117049574852, -0.015489020384848118, 0.003533684415742755, 0.0028992081061005592, 0.04718853533267975, 0.029281992465257645, -0.0229931753128767, -0.0007996948552317917, -0.01709205098450184, -0.012626524083316326, 0.02408222109079361, 0.022842997685074806, 0.05269823595881462, 0.009762413799762726, 0.03191257268190384, 0.004382633604109287, 0.034195009618997574, -0.024142006412148476, 0.0075698490254580975, -0.011161098256707191, -0.048800989985466, 0.019464772194623947, -0.015173659659922123, 0.00004211657142150216, -0.031106511130928993, 0.00193207326810807, -0.06475138664245605, -0.00034118921030312777, -0.01969016343355179, 0.010969158262014389, 0.010711927898228168, 0.03277689218521118, -0.0396730974316597, -0.017791319638490677, -0.004222034011036158, 0.03526466339826584, -0.006697946228086948, -0.0008804846438579261, -0.006176693830639124, -0.008168050087988377, 0.00017315502918791026, 0.0076684788800776005, -0.02913418598473072, -0.002719183685258031, 0.05665859952569008, 0.0055717541836202145, -0.007499413099139929, 0.008963648229837418, -0.005890198051929474, 0.03437430411577225, -0.008907615207135677, -0.058907512575387955, -0.018255766481161118, 0.040890686213970184, -0.061998385936021805, -0.02312629483640194, 0.05170803144574165, -0.0004145429120399058, -0.006916047539561987, 0.02017972059547901, -0.02442070282995701, 0.0026826930698007345, 0.030514637008309364, -0.012284591794013977, -0.05131923779845238, 0.012458101846277714, -0.014249536208808422, 0.0005884061101824045, 0.03809766098856926, 0.044692154973745346, 0.0398726612329483, 0.03297910839319229, 0.03549888730049133, 0.037890851497650146, -0.014761785976588726, -0.0017032496398314834, -0.00296407425776124, -0.023406291380524635, 0.024290598928928375, -0.013839338906109333, 0.002697261981666088, 0.03422217071056366, 0.044511087238788605, -0.02813829481601715, -0.01064218394458294, -0.025258919224143028, -0.011519821360707283, -0.08077790588140488, -0.014861653558909893, 0.0068092942237854, -0.00005985700408928096, -0.003006918588653207, -0.03686898946762085, 0.0009104351047426462, 0.019232865422964096, -0.05908235162496567, 0.0009008787455968559, -0.036491911858320236, -0.0382242277264595, -0.04223571717739105, -0.007158549036830664, 0.00575438654050231, -0.007526845205575228, 0.02470490336418152, 0.029110360890626907, 0.024254916235804558, -0.0036100444849580526, 0.016263622790575027, -0.031033921986818314, -0.02553970366716385, 0.007101514842361212, 0.02060887962579727, -0.013785691931843758, 0.04000537097454071, -0.04696104675531387, -0.04450349509716034, 0.032720282673835754, -0.017853500321507454, 0.016537586227059364, -0.015202222391963005, 0.028758835047483444, -0.020722515881061554, 0.028571641072630882, 0.04732886701822281, -0.053337935358285904, 0.013220558874309063, 0.00898500345647335, -0.005219270940870047, 0.02211451716721058, -0.027949709445238113, 0.006275087594985962, 0.04755963012576103, -0.03703315183520317, -0.04847344011068344, 0.016774388030171394, 0.031818687915802, -0.019857781007885933, 0.004220200702548027, -0.007750475779175758, 0.01212058775126934, -0.02771463617682457, 0.03077603504061699, 0.0025483539793640375, 0.002546329516917467, 0.03816996514797211, 0.005000322125852108, -0.05386490002274513, 0.023077040910720825, -0.0053070103749632835, -0.008110523223876953, -0.0008939530234783888, 0.01683347299695015, -0.04723642021417618, -0.08166652917861938, -0.024841703474521637, 0.0064190165139734745, -0.015532763674855232, -0.024294106289744377, -0.009028108790516853, 0.010397616773843765, 0.06189605966210365, -0.0050819977186620235, 0.037651773542165756, 0.017586901783943176, -0.0163089819252491, -0.019086159765720367, -0.05536404252052307, 0.05394132807850838, 0.01380875613540411, 0.03245389461517334, -0.03229648619890213, -0.05030512064695358, -0.01107585895806551, 0.023413360118865967, 0.04715107008814812, 0.023031532764434814, 0.006651957053691149, 0.008106010966002941, -0.003349149599671364, 0.00019800057634711266, -0.04358689486980438, 0.018779927864670753, -0.019107483327388763, 0.0036535260733217, -0.021612435579299927, -0.025261132046580315, -0.005163026507943869, -0.02992798015475273, -0.005721192806959152, 0.01312454417347908, 0.013213587924838066, -0.00690437899902463, -0.029984470456838608, 0.03662267327308655, 0.03187815099954605, -0.015782233327627182, 0.05585923045873642, -0.017519056797027588, 0.017574556171894073, 0.01743442378938198, -0.019475026056170464, -0.054365795105695724, 0.01978801190853119, -0.04078448936343193, 0.02199152112007141, -0.011955732479691505, 0.04785626381635666, -0.015842026099562645, -0.07184276729822159, -0.007308905012905598, 0.023162459954619408, -0.07761132717132568, 0.013388704508543015, 0.038684338331222534, 0.002225950127467513, 0.008469498716294765, -0.011661172844469547, 0.028895702213048935, -0.0016039015026763082, 0.0016402527689933777, 0.0008865658310241997, 0.026289623230695724, -0.007262319792062044, -0.01906762085855007, 0.01635635830461979, 0.004543879069387913, -0.00948815606534481, 0.030062235891819, 0.031417347490787506, 0.026157526299357414, 0.001988916890695691, -0.029509838670492172, 0.0009972640546038747, -0.01317825447767973, -0.01047444250434637, 0.03340883180499077, -0.0010356230195611715, 0.054902222007513046, -0.02864120341837406, -0.02427959255874157, -0.01765422523021698, -0.026302296668291092, -0.014294992201030254, -0.01036140602082014, -0.010618623346090317, 0.049910277128219604, -0.0024610545951873064, -0.010235275141894817, 0.010944816283881664, 0.015330749563872814, 0.014941392466425896, -0.07875458896160126, 0.03470622003078461, -0.016820507124066353, 0.023207463324069977, 0.029970036819577217, 0.009543347172439098, -0.026839395985007286, 0.014655755832791328, 0.0015261565567925572, 0.01581544429063797, 0.005437641870230436, 0.003910447470843792, -0.016233501955866814, 0.004648255649954081, -0.004155928269028664, -0.0617789588868618, 0.0048271785490214825, -0.009379364550113678, 0.011471898294985294, -0.0007989494479261339, -0.04126233235001564 ]
<p>I have four numeric variables. All of them are measures of soil quality. Higher the variable, higher the quality. The range for all of them is different:</p> <p>Var1 from 1 to 10</p> <p>Var2 from 1000 to 2000</p> <p>Var3 from 150 to 300</p> <p>Var4 from 0 to 5</p> <p>I need to combine four variables into single soil quality score which will successfully rank order.</p> <p>My idea is very simple. Standardize all four variables, sum them up and whatever you get is the score which should rank-order. Do you see any problem with applying this approach. Is there any other (better) approach that you would recommend?</p> <p>Thanks</p> <p><strong>Edit:</strong></p> <p>Thanks guys. A lot of discussion went into "domain expertise"... Agriculture stuff... Whereas I expected more stats-talk. In terms of technique that I will be using... It will probably be simple z-score summation + logistic regression as an experiment. Because vast majority of samples has poor quality 90% I'm going to combine 3 quality categories into one and basically have binary problem (somequality vs no-quality). I kill two birds with one stone. I increase my sample in terms of event rate and I make a use of experts by getting them to clasify my samples. Expert classified samples will then be used to fit log-reg model to maximize level of concordance / discordance with the experts.... How does that sound to you?</p>
49,470
[ -0.030080847442150116, -0.027529822662472725, 0.0011161164147779346, 0.024492451921105385, 0.015445691533386707, 0.00948253832757473, 0.03632039204239845, 0.005473432596772909, 0.027012355625629425, -0.015886425971984863, 0.00952102430164814, 0.023588305339217186, 0.03711378201842308, 0.03429374098777771, 0.012977657839655876, -0.014428769238293171, 0.03135906532406807, 0.01624068059027195, -0.0013941120123490691, -0.010682191699743271, -0.0013649415923282504, -0.02236940898001194, 0.004896991886198521, 0.00931492168456316, -0.012067991308867931, 0.06673051416873932, 0.0046170256100595, 0.010291729122400284, -0.014101970940828323, 0.036042794585227966, -0.017305150628089905, -0.035814519971609116, 0.037249606102705, 0.05707044154405594, 0.030781913548707962, -0.0017266805516555905, -0.019526107236742973, 0.027427250519394875, -0.010486863553524017, 0.04480433091521263, -0.018638722598552704, -0.04166477546095848, 0.000300849846098572, -0.02816072478890419, -0.011735881678760052, 0.009678973816335201, 0.014465076848864555, -0.019926469773054123, 0.048837028443813324, -0.037731025367975235, 0.035709165036678314, 0.0006614731391891837, 0.025477303192019463, 0.02204544097185135, -0.005168497562408447, -0.015794912353157997, 0.049554597586393356, 0.05708169564604759, -0.016442373394966125, -0.03359987586736679, -0.009913789108395576, -0.036500267684459686, 0.019331414252519608, -0.011630193330347538, -0.022249167785048485, 0.031343016773462296, -0.015438715927302837, -0.002291594399139285, 0.03399591147899628, 0.010804124176502228, 0.02500854805111885, 0.021918542683124542, 0.054173920303583145, -0.01796911656856537, 0.015565403737127781, -0.01227691862732172, 0.02012724243104458, 0.006148326210677624, 0.05720309168100357, -0.003371630562469363, -0.025624750182032585, 0.01775793917477131, 0.0013283423613756895, 0.04641705006361008, 0.013950590044260025, -0.012865003198385239, 0.06421057134866714, -0.06433334946632385, 0.02433609776198864, 0.022247767075896263, -0.019309213384985924, 0.0056973532773554325, 0.034258827567100525, 0.012979064136743546, -0.029898330569267273, -0.007451335899531841, -0.033187322318553925, 0.028154414147138596, -0.018305236473679543, 0.03984133526682854, -0.005621068645268679, -0.03527567535638809, 0.030008837580680847, 0.04814170300960541, -0.020444801077246666, -0.012745807878673077, -0.029027514159679413, -0.020281827077269554, -0.003139684209600091, -0.057374224066734314, -0.0026306225918233395, 0.0010250029154121876, 0.011445404961705208, -0.009236619807779789, 0.007563743740320206, -0.014214807190001011, -0.020108260214328766, -0.019983313977718353, 0.0712977722287178, 0.013448663987219334, 0.042147520929574966, -0.04786023497581482, 0.020339926704764366, -0.04080267995595932, -0.0600830502808094, 0.0115613779053092, 0.038691721856594086, -0.00474923150613904, -0.04303473234176636, 0.053000353276729584, 0.01005086861550808, 0.0252362247556448, 0.02536938525736332, 0.011615212075412273, 0.006814293097704649, -0.034566719084978104, -0.05834265798330307, -0.026847468689084053, 0.0387190580368042, -0.010898408479988575, 0.016652127727866173, -0.07115203142166138, -0.014459050260484219, 0.020914355292916298, 0.038551751524209976, 0.027753496542572975, 0.0453212596476078, 0.02572210505604744, 0.0347437858581543, 0.045980099588632584, -0.01210376713424921, -0.0034290598705410957, -0.005414904560893774, -0.03251217305660248, -0.020851755514740944, -0.07608122378587723, 0.009790990501642227, -0.023545850068330765, -0.043764080852270126, -0.01409669779241085, 0.01994074136018753, 0.015476285479962826, 0.0010188388405367732, -0.03896697610616684, 0.026793785393238068, -0.001905188662931323, 0.037028249353170395, -0.011963989585638046, 0.02323143742978573, -0.0011677599977701902, 0.007391400169581175, -0.014998828992247581, 0.018379775807261467, 0.05251326784491539, 0.05411192774772644, -0.02137627638876438, 0.02892298437654972, -0.04954993724822998, 0.01188204437494278, -0.01830221712589264, -0.02007940784096718, -0.033610351383686066, -0.007971799932420254, 0.03864727169275284, -0.00957490038126707, 0.015693310648202896, -0.022992325946688652, -0.011769507080316544, 0.07282230257987976, -0.028303977102041245, -0.0621783547103405, -0.04377872124314308, -0.012976047582924366, 0.020872004330158234, -0.013396537862718105, 0.005924776662141085, -0.04875260964035988, 0.037832796573638916, 0.0194172915071249, 0.01719457283616066, -0.03987031802535057, 0.006222479976713657, 0.07435768842697144, -0.01300649531185627, 0.004719231277704239, 0.03588298335671425, 0.011908662505447865, -0.042814597487449646, 0.039323776960372925, 0.006111022550612688, -0.07515475898981094, 0.015403114259243011, -0.00401744619011879, 0.008874794468283653, -0.020195946097373962, -0.03522733226418495, 0.07117228955030441, -0.006597574800252914, -0.0434374064207077, 0.004433047957718372, -0.08347535878419876, 0.06577335298061371, 0.0712805911898613, -0.02613026462495327, -0.025659708306193352, 0.015146245248615742, -0.007171521428972483, 0.026230303570628166, -0.051541026681661606, -0.003933575935661793, -0.05225398391485214, -0.006696260068565607, 0.030348336324095726, 0.04145233705639839, -0.051925674080848694, 0.006425903178751469, 0.03954898193478584, 0.014326507225632668, 0.03551912307739258, 0.03694629296660423, 0.024209143593907356, 0.005572955589741468, 0.02232714742422104, 0.04112633317708969, 0.026506341993808746, 0.007822268642485142, -0.019962985068559647, 0.010253789834678173, 0.036336541175842285, -0.03103967010974884, 0.013786540366709232, 0.014839272014796734, 0.011063746176660061, 0.010644507594406605, 0.014668295159935951, 0.01300344243645668, 0.017523258924484253, -0.04358619078993797, -0.005515797063708305, 0.047954659909009933, 0.04247956722974777, 0.00753178633749485, 0.010524377226829529, -0.0014642621390521526, 0.06010612100362778, 0.07106490433216095, -0.03549332171678543, 0.018864937126636505, 0.023042181506752968, -0.025567393749952316, -0.011263849213719368, 0.005544578190892935, -0.04310052841901779, -0.053367190062999725, 0.002393493428826332, 0.04532288759946823, -0.016586795449256897, 0.024853214621543884, 0.03129996731877327, -0.029481755569577217, -0.014075784012675285, 0.009182194247841835, 0.005063114687800407, 0.011324807070195675, -0.023086780682206154, -0.041223328560590744, 0.0266304612159729, -0.0037123814690858126, 0.046130456030368805, 0.01104030106216669, -0.02767331153154373, 0.012672767043113708, -0.013042410835623741, -0.05341557040810585, -0.03246714174747467, -0.029910597950220108, 0.014311658218502998, -0.012642784975469112, -0.018584169447422028, 0.02117505483329296, -0.0036651412956416607, -0.06176120787858963, -0.0028264906723052263, -0.03745286166667938, -0.012160057201981544, -0.04647809639573097, 0.0022526492830365896, -0.010852411389350891, 0.0462106429040432, -0.018558170646429062, 0.013744846917688847, 0.011090000160038471, -0.006044346839189529, -0.04364872723817825, -0.0929507315158844, 0.037457361817359924, -0.014475738629698753, 0.03154272958636284, -0.011545198038220406, -0.0124839898198843, 0.08405694365501404, 0.07158590853214264, -0.04283212125301361, -0.05893073230981827, -0.029756728559732437, -0.026291897520422935, 0.010252880863845348, 0.044028155505657196, -0.004665670916438103, 0.012625488452613354, 0.031165488064289093, -0.003951703198254108, 0.03107503056526184, 0.028070300817489624, 0.01149925496429205, 0.0206050556153059, 0.030091499909758568, 0.01184010785073042, -0.020667990669608116, -0.0004286355688236654, 0.03234675154089928, -0.05773104727268219, 0.021344978362321854, 0.012149711139500141, 0.007577456999570131, 0.02830931916832924, -0.054090991616249084, 0.0014826699625700712, 0.024060161784291267, 0.012715032324194908, -0.001915790606290102, -0.014748013578355312, 0.029575087130069733, -0.06113206967711449, -0.005454047117382288, 0.0038073656614869833, 0.012894541025161743, 0.02371966280043125, -0.004389799665659666, 0.04097452014684677, 0.07096610963344574, -0.022046193480491638, -0.010723713785409927, 0.020748598501086235, -0.02310210093855858, 0.01688852533698082, -0.025253208354115486, -0.009579678066074848, 0.009623993188142776, 0.04086067155003548, -0.009314638562500477, -0.02539329044520855, -0.0689515545964241, 0.025798359885811806, -0.0662303939461708, 0.009468810632824898, -0.04827198013663292, 0.07541245967149734, 0.00460554426535964, 0.03372678533196449, 0.01107635349035263, -0.031526532024145126, 0.020572302863001823, 0.007770319934934378, -0.05902310460805893, 0.03297030180692673, 0.024655479937791824, -0.0013379359152168036, 0.008956708945333958, 0.005517615936696529, 0.011562036350369453, -0.04488476738333702, 0.01950872130692005, -0.012363011948764324, 0.04951827973127365, -0.039991267025470734, 0.012834593653678894, -0.02788418158888817, -0.01481409277766943, 0.0199138130992651, 0.0096391336992383, -0.007554244715720415, -0.01740948110818863, 0.06055213883519173, 0.040938735008239746, -0.017126331105828285, 0.025277720764279366, -0.03528469428420067, 0.007484906818717718, 0.00005285984661895782, 0.052426137030124664, -0.0024276485200971365, 0.04562126845121384, -0.03827023133635521, 0.06298558413982391, -0.027842815965414047, 0.047718118876218796, 0.010185793973505497, -0.03265770524740219, -0.03929084166884422, -0.008213321678340435, -0.03671923279762268, 0.03016786091029644, 0.026458580046892166, 0.01899394765496254, -0.017042070627212524, 0.029414573684334755, 0.016222264617681503, -0.07622059434652328, 0.0194076057523489, 0.03232812136411667, -0.012608322314918041, -0.02135651372373104, 0.0030481668654829264, -0.017360422760248184, 0.04274049773812294, -0.022493992000818253, 0.03828103467822075, 0.047661226242780685, -0.03067637048661709, -0.04506952315568924, 0.05900048464536667, -0.027952149510383606, -0.02454829029738903, 0.00032883352832868695, 0.025601239874958992, 0.0211279708892107, -0.016752855852246284, -0.08268281817436218, -0.01113850437104702, 0.030847085639834404, 0.03403933718800545, 0.043404605239629745, -0.03190118819475174, -0.09977668523788452, 0.011078416369855404, 0.022993776947259903, 0.0641918033361435, -0.06827680766582489, -0.006345351226627827, -0.005002634599804878, -0.052301064133644104, 0.018158935010433197, -0.07937037199735641, 0.029156852513551712, -0.019118554890155792, 0.030026018619537354, -0.013598884455859661, -0.03671526536345482, -0.05385076627135277, 0.024318773299455643, -0.0010598450899124146, 0.04702376201748848, 0.02122334949672222, -0.033225588500499725, -0.04703659936785698, 0.04383426904678345, 0.0055842325091362, 0.01725934073328972, -0.010987549088895321, -0.015204629860818386, -0.019354628399014473, 0.010779840871691704, -0.03686026483774185, -0.03215426579117775, 0.03032803349196911, -0.017367450520396233, 0.0017460881499573588, 0.02627677470445633, 0.027634186670184135, -0.005692626815289259, -0.012744617648422718, 0.0403323769569397, -0.01775667630136013, -0.007154420949518681, 0.030524050816893578, 0.034204766154289246, 0.025076154619455338, 0.010312090627849102, 0.02168155461549759, 0.024747218936681747, -0.0022869990207254887, 0.022494371980428696, -0.022873949259519577, 0.016359539702534676, -0.021533170714974403, -0.026156429201364517, -0.026519540697336197, 0.01329423114657402, -0.039671339094638824, 0.014985598623752594, -0.013245680369436741, 0.06831836700439453, -0.037550147622823715, -0.004278183449059725, -0.007783402688801289, -0.030091043561697006, -0.013041170313954353, -0.0292135551571846, -0.012173877097666264, 0.023604577407240868, 0.02195575088262558, -0.007861630991101265, 0.008321656845510006, 0.019829459488391876, -0.01584835909307003, 0.00046948756789788604, -0.03700161352753639, 0.022179296240210533, -0.049738809466362, -0.0041986857540905476, -0.008532680571079254, -0.014895654283463955, 0.06531919538974762, 0.03468994051218033, 0.052435994148254395, 0.009935688227415085, -0.013510774821043015, -0.021340273320674896, 0.026800818741321564, 0.02348191849887371, 0.032042887061834335, -0.06442885845899582, 0.029515186324715614, -0.013785297982394695, -0.005015301983803511, -0.058386512100696564, -0.05628719553351402, 0.01648101955652237, 0.013937004841864109, -0.024182191118597984, -0.058386772871017456, 0.01652323640882969, -0.014888527803122997, -0.008842147886753082, -0.024584941565990448, 0.07290628552436829, -0.02524792030453682, -0.016839027404785156, 0.002559944987297058, 0.03255171328783035, 0.05822943150997162, 0.025854485109448433, -0.005575892515480518, 0.006538636051118374, -0.019271478056907654, -0.006318771746009588, -0.023042898625135422, -0.02265378087759018, -0.039106596261262894, -0.009728529490530491, -0.010294413194060326, 0.01623564213514328, 0.03086516633629799, 0.014465427957475185, 0.027519717812538147, -0.0016750871436670423, 0.019516218453645706, 0.0012352555058896542, -0.010677493177354336, 0.00015336694195866585, -0.00939965806901455, 0.010386993177235126, -0.05063430592417717, 0.005089671351015568, -0.027803825214505196, -0.04769594594836235, -0.01113662589341402, 0.0031013910192996264, 0.03246745467185974, 0.007564571686089039, 0.051371850073337555, 0.02322642132639885, -0.0028110118582844734, -0.00355156441219151, -0.012576699256896973, 0.035885926336050034, 0.0028344960883259773, -0.017639050260186195, -0.012295019812881947, 0.03619775548577309, -0.0028237004298716784, 0.0023988992907106876, -0.012388383038341999, -0.05054158717393875, 0.07120711356401443, -0.03579123690724373, 0.03620065003633499, 0.061123576015233994, 0.015255284495651722, -0.01889994740486145, -0.04218081012368202, 0.008364221081137657, 0.0009423269075341523, -0.007241302169859409, 0.047469835728406906, 0.007499018218368292, 0.013547282665967941, 0.01035874243825674, 0.02788764424622059, -0.01901690848171711, 0.03632833808660507, -0.036353155970573425, 0.042985908687114716, 0.011864210478961468, -0.05681602656841278, -0.03033623844385147, 0.041930925101041794, -0.051583170890808105, -0.027839967980980873, 0.0030298540368676186, -0.045556314289569855, 0.03288077190518379, 0.03464866057038307, -0.01385434903204441, -0.019257621839642525, -0.04648395627737045, -0.08182277530431747, 0.025117596611380577, -0.013257665559649467, -0.06844615936279297, 0.03098122403025627, -0.005756897386163473, -0.01315414160490036, 0.027040937915444374, 0.021970568224787712, -0.07197941839694977, -0.06564030796289444, -0.006804025731980801, 0.018462330102920532, -0.07092463970184326, -0.013644995167851448, -0.00739206001162529, -0.06338810920715332, 0.029250141233205795, -0.02428552135825157, 0.03869035467505455, -0.0022717376705259085, 0.022750353440642357, -0.001159660634584725, 0.0533626526594162, 0.027872055768966675, 0.0169198177754879, 0.0018729508155956864, -0.003527830122038722, 0.14379994571208954, 0.06237498298287392, 0.024098429828882217, -0.07049477100372314, 0.02326512150466442, 0.044092681258916855, 0.03872859477996826, 0.014275097288191319, -0.011739778332412243, 0.018974540755152702, 0.008822149597108364, 0.039688631892204285, 0.04862743616104126, 0.03610226884484291, 0.018566811457276344, 0.08409827202558517, -0.01277940534055233, -0.009090103209018707, -0.02989700250327587, 0.04859679192304611, -0.0001307410711888224, -0.021574918180704117, -0.04785175248980522, 0.0192238911986351, 0.012371480464935303, -0.017636725679039955, -0.01284271851181984, -0.017377836629748344, -0.02651875652372837, -0.0236199963837862, 0.02688644453883171, 0.01489525567740202, 0.007515985053032637, 0.009360757656395435, -0.031035825610160828, 0.011886714957654476, 0.002646104199811816, -0.015038798563182354, 0.008554316125810146, 0.010854912921786308, 0.02300916612148285, 0.015345992520451546, 0.02102132886648178, 0.005326693877577782, -0.05427749082446098, -0.021617325022816658, -0.07005792111158371, 0.008851388469338417, -0.014067497104406357, 0.002979346551001072, -0.03405553475022316, -0.011136885732412338, 0.032747454941272736, -0.014326184056699276, -0.04908297583460808, 0.018370751291513443, 0.015736714005470276, 0.0036732705775648355, -0.055905621498823166, -0.0006934404955245554, 0.028384020552039146, -0.0003871290246024728, 0.012474951334297657, -0.0038114534690976143, -0.054614678025245667, -0.044748805463314056, -0.044344883412122726, 0.06263581663370132, 0.010669412091374397, -0.002639882965013385, -0.035630516707897186, -0.02781703695654869, 0.0035872908774763346, 0.01433784794062376, -0.01759491115808487, 0.002475614659488201, 0.0429946705698967, -0.018193842843174934, -0.004889121279120445, -0.007220045663416386, -0.0296091940253973, -0.005706123076379299, -0.02469806931912899, 0.008183980360627174, -0.03809520602226257, 0.002119993092492223, -0.03172164410352707, 0.03389088809490204, 0.021139957010746002, -0.00703654857352376, 0.014909281395375729, 0.021999428048729897, -0.022444354370236397, -0.047084543853998184, 0.0033867359161376953, -0.01720101572573185, -0.031724963337183, 0.013196045532822609, 0.005231817718595266, 0.09329402446746826, 0.013859627768397331, 0.004463633056730032, 0.012492522597312927, 0.04039401561021805, 0.008435629308223724, 0.034018561244010925, 0.031118744984269142, -0.047670356929302216, -0.009661708027124405, 0.03316858038306236, -0.006747972685843706, -0.018496107310056686, -0.034030329436063766, -0.04567565768957138, -0.04358378052711487, 0.002945277141407132, -0.05754378065466881, -0.0442294105887413, -0.009959954768419266, -0.0347086563706398, 0.02627970278263092, -0.03005271404981613, 0.021447354927659035, -0.01292200107127428, 0.010381640866398811, -0.021707965061068535, 0.010628136806190014, -0.010815677233040333, -0.004810902755707502, -0.016840685158967972, 0.008093718439340591, 0.022205933928489685, 0.01953449472784996, 0.02161192148923874, -0.018771979957818985, -0.0053198328241705894, 0.0047635603696107864, 0.049837663769721985, -0.005218342877924442, 0.0069736395962536335, 0.0023063188418745995, -0.04624725505709648, -0.0256645530462265, 0.03547465801239014, 0.00926885474473238, 0.0069722081534564495, 0.013711849227547646, 0.004620152059942484, -0.03178757056593895, 0.046787358820438385, -0.018366878852248192, 0.008689879439771175, 0.003846228588372469, 0.04049854353070259, -0.0007162461406551301, 0.02405400574207306, 0.020460104569792747, 0.009797656908631325, -0.016050469130277634, -0.0022739048581570387, 0.019364632666110992, 0.01627447083592415, -0.0019921560306102037, 0.021864239126443863, -0.022253192961215973, 0.01030777022242546, -0.019365299493074417, -0.028739280998706818, 0.017499545589089394, 0.07513447105884552, -0.03142537176609039, -0.01995464786887169, 0.014610769227147102, 0.015456132590770721, -0.038386501371860504, -0.01595683954656124, 0.005756956059485674, 0.0176509041339159, -0.0017178029520437121, -0.0498255155980587, 0.018606944009661674, 0.03245074674487114, -0.0428062342107296, 0.001096753403544426, 0.009584611281752586, 0.0040895999409258366, -0.053585484623909, 0.004377241246402264, -0.027181871235370636, -0.0018068203935399652, 0.009563719853758812, 0.03007289208471775, 0.01914208196103573, 0.010784262791275978, -0.009897854179143906, -0.002875447506085038, -0.03617231547832489, 0.010860402137041092, 0.02245390973985195, -0.02416718192398548, 0.07703140377998352, -0.04923815652728081, -0.03971586376428604, 0.04596231132745743, -0.01016936358064413, 0.03684477135539055, 0.033354632556438446, 0.05361273139715195, 0.00942240934818983, 0.07632895559072495, 0.03270707651972771, -0.03886636346578598, 0.01795194484293461, -0.0007918235496617854, 0.01294419914484024, 0.00408371165394783, -0.01765599101781845, 0.01936487853527069, 0.043188195675611496, 0.018259627744555473, -0.02855580486357212, 0.007459878455847502, -0.025062870234251022, -0.025616195052862167, 0.005859592463821173, 0.03813488408923149, 0.012494487687945366, -0.005858092103153467, 0.01473287120461464, -0.0315098911523819, 0.005614427849650383, 0.027064258232712746, 0.003176826750859618, -0.00020157580729573965, -0.018706342205405235, -0.012258299626410007, -0.055354632437229156, -0.023555919528007507, 0.012092414312064648, -0.021031904965639114, -0.041482195258140564, 0.009973122738301754, 0.004708613734692335, -0.009697655215859413, -0.03525388985872269, -0.006052082870155573, -0.06628969311714172, 0.08569137006998062, -0.04956944286823273, 0.03200071305036545, 0.021165546029806137, -0.012845329940319061, 0.06169191002845764, -0.07052523642778397, 0.06651884317398071, 0.007072539068758488, 0.018894316628575325, -0.016296425834298134, -0.014667194336652756, -0.01838841289281845, 0.0008144791354425251, 0.04349267855286598, 0.013265601359307766, 0.004920582752674818, -0.00910690426826477, 0.0033134908881038427, 0.017440613359212875, -0.019059866666793823, 0.018200207501649857, -0.015716267749667168, 0.0009456921834498644, -0.0333990640938282, 0.017320431768894196, 0.01769101992249489, -0.028402572497725487, 0.00495736300945282, -0.04421687498688698, -0.027921395376324654, -0.003580549731850624, 0.023398539051413536, -0.0016602854011580348, -0.037289321422576904, -0.009459649212658405, 0.043884363025426865, -0.02660515159368515, -0.008285848423838615, 0.015216050669550896, 0.015256929211318493, -0.013827352784574032, 0.028992632403969765, 0.0071800812147557735, -0.008033736608922482, 0.013649245724081993, 0.03705659508705139, 0.012502833269536495, -0.06872463971376419, -0.006656373385339975, 0.004922389052808285, -0.050169460475444794, 0.0029642428271472454, 0.02319011092185974, 0.01670559123158455, 0.0351102352142334, -0.010112538933753967, 0.019526051357388496, -0.009788653813302517, -0.003985084127634764, -0.0209281574934721, 0.016165906563401222, 0.013712750747799873, 0.030347861349582672, 0.008874820545315742, 0.010255959816277027, 0.004812873434275389, 0.054179348051548004, 0.007101049646735191, 0.03391631692647934, 0.031780458986759186, -0.011253680102527142, 0.026286151260137558, 0.0044194492511451244, 0.022423500195145607, 0.004181876312941313, 0.013397838920354843, 0.013308996334671974, -0.015201062895357609, -0.03627483546733856, -0.04698751121759415, -0.013987780548632145, -0.058291543275117874, -0.024153979495167732, -0.009483515284955502, 0.008329582400619984, 0.0017327197128906846, 0.01408747211098671, -0.026004284620285034, -0.014469189569354057, 0.021631445735692978, -0.020996516570448875, 0.011247267946600914, -0.03241778165102005, 0.010083043947815895, 0.045889779925346375, -0.03808751329779625, -0.034625135362148285, -0.015724414959549904, 0.006806123070418835, 0.016165371984243393, 0.03133386746048927, -0.046955656260252, -0.039398495107889175, -0.0030343460384756327, 0.03177114203572273, -0.03750350698828697, -0.0495198518037796, -0.06305841356515884, 0.008929820731282234, -0.008100580424070358, -0.024668650701642036 ]
<p><strong>INTRO</strong></p> <p>I have trained a SVM model based on 300 training cases in order to build a filter that should help me extract a bigger and evenly balanced training set, that is to be validated by human judges.</p> <p><strong>DATA</strong></p> <p>My training set is:</p> <pre><code>288 negative cases 12 positive cases </code></pre> <p>My model performance is:</p> <pre><code>True positives = 6 False positives = 0 True negatives = 288 False negative = 6 </code></pre> <p>I have used this model on a 440000 cases data set and I am given confidence values for zeroes and ones (confidence.1. = 95% -> confidence.0. = 5% and confidence.1. = 50% -> confidence.0. = 50%)</p> <p>When the model is applied to the 440000 cased it predicts 1499 of the cases to be positive.</p> <p><strong>PROBLEM</strong></p> <p>As explained I am about to take a random sample of 3000 cases that will hopefully be balanced in order to train a better model. Thus my formal problem becomes:</p> <p><em>"How can one extract a random sample of 3000 and approximate the balance of the dataset given the information I have stated?"</em></p> <p><strong>OWN THOUGHTS</strong></p> <p>I am fairly good with R but I simply do not have the knowledge or the skills to figure this out. I dont even know if it is possible. The only thing I do know is that it seems a bit doll to just put a finger in the air and guess on which cases to extract. The easy way would be to take the top 3000 sorted on confidence.1. which is nothing more that a qualified guess. Happy new year Kasper </p>
47,744
[ -0.03630399703979492, -0.020504359155893326, -0.014972621574997902, 0.004322798456996679, -0.01709028333425522, -0.026159459725022316, -0.023200437426567078, -0.0007934338063932955, 0.0213296040892601, 0.012103128246963024, 0.0033796397037804127, 0.06640646606683731, 0.039885565638542175, 0.04293418303132057, -0.020269842818379402, 0.008608642965555191, 0.018371934071183205, 0.003578606992959976, -0.00960179977118969, 0.009118689224123955, -0.0386386401951313, 0.029480475932359695, 0.010248505510389805, -0.013424132950603962, -0.056655026972293854, 0.006367709022015333, 0.047494594007730484, -0.01786961778998375, 0.00654600840061903, 0.03714136406779289, -0.04635758697986603, -0.028537463396787643, 0.04524541646242142, 0.015648838132619858, 0.03750152513384819, 0.013036543503403664, -0.01472293771803379, -0.02139357663691044, -0.004597013350576162, 0.01703503169119358, -0.02495042234659195, -0.0016243759309872985, 0.0105076739564538, 0.09368181228637695, -0.01921048015356064, 0.004712425637990236, 0.0019869229290634394, -0.027696197852492332, 0.007538334466516972, -0.06562311202287674, 0.0626724362373352, 0.0020365810487419367, 0.03748883679509163, 0.042125701904296875, 0.022693190723657608, -0.030606627464294434, 0.02304949425160885, 0.07115855813026428, 0.00010121083323610947, -0.030703112483024597, 0.014330248348414898, -0.02993459813296795, -0.03371395915746689, -0.012777297757565975, -0.01757636107504368, 0.02997400611639023, -0.004585168790072203, -0.01843750849366188, 0.05532857030630112, 0.0035896014887839556, 0.013356057927012444, -0.0003588850668165833, 0.03393002599477768, 0.003498473670333624, -0.0010746525367721915, -0.06448563933372498, 0.008429137989878654, 0.008648230694234371, 0.04327400401234627, 0.004486325662583113, 0.0193119328469038, 0.02528955042362213, -0.018832577392458916, 0.06592609733343124, 0.03183829039335251, -0.02537616342306137, 0.06240970641374588, -0.026653962209820747, 0.013893050141632557, 0.034717150032520294, -0.007642768789082766, 0.004387419205158949, 0.038681890815496445, 0.0023845438845455647, -0.06335507333278656, 0.025003736838698387, -0.0030513564124703407, 0.02001829817891121, 0.012845221906900406, 0.009749216958880424, -0.00741531141102314, -0.045652929693460464, 0.03861663490533829, 0.08840454369783401, -0.06126744672656059, -0.0025205917190760374, -0.011417297646403313, -0.014100102707743645, 0.009584883227944374, -0.027643689885735512, -0.025840168818831444, -0.004064634442329407, 0.01435172837227583, -0.0050376420840620995, 0.002629148541018367, -0.013975286856293678, -0.0224580317735672, -0.04788358882069588, 0.024716701358556747, 0.040394220501184464, 0.023103119805455208, -0.010452331975102425, 0.012327871285378933, -0.036423005163669586, -0.04368399456143379, 0.022097600623965263, 0.019346600398421288, 0.000761483795940876, -0.050505299121141434, 0.05574221909046173, -0.01642506942152977, -0.031721826642751694, 0.03525162488222122, -0.01725742407143116, 0.07627081125974655, -0.05950383096933365, -0.10532581806182861, -0.03742998465895653, 0.01742113009095192, -0.030388087034225464, 0.01800120808184147, -0.03512684628367424, 0.0008765928796492517, 0.05594046413898468, 0.05411094054579735, 0.032278645783662796, 0.05546712875366211, 0.020325137302279472, 0.018267568200826645, 0.025380482897162437, -0.028435397893190384, -0.015627730637788773, -0.035181254148483276, 0.021026814356446266, -0.06540389358997345, -0.04800911620259285, 0.04240036383271217, 0.005932417698204517, -0.011242815293371677, -0.01139142643660307, -0.03802996128797531, 0.013985749334096909, -0.00044065751717425883, -0.03235187754034996, 0.007082998752593994, 0.0011117327958345413, 0.05589858815073967, 0.03149877116084099, 0.0159517340362072, 0.009882977232336998, -0.014095521531999111, 0.01745125837624073, 0.07400088757276535, 0.0025288572069257498, 0.027081742882728577, 0.0041585746221244335, 0.039831098169088364, -0.05026784539222717, 0.04440443962812424, 0.020747492089867592, -0.009106718003749847, -0.024120435118675232, -0.015003050677478313, 0.005718789994716644, 0.03570474684238434, 0.032463278621435165, -0.015828754752874374, -0.029130807146430016, 0.009161176159977913, -0.03792986646294594, -0.06517188251018524, -0.06428076326847076, -0.030263716354966164, -0.0023524833377450705, -0.015776194632053375, -0.005236754193902016, -0.004382870625704527, 0.026102816686034203, -0.022887317463755608, -0.0037742804270237684, -0.03522856906056404, -0.01221543364226818, 0.09508660435676575, -0.019748257473111153, 0.016526348888874054, 0.053023021668195724, 0.03336845710873604, -0.03591054677963257, 0.046458736062049866, -0.030382616445422173, -0.050113704055547714, 0.018963729962706566, -0.013101429678499699, 0.0023786970414221287, 0.02121005579829216, -0.006632186006754637, 0.03653203696012497, -0.016665317118167877, 0.0030651220586150885, -0.0037752517964690924, -0.021615110337734222, 0.06947517395019531, 0.078506238758564, 0.009583454579114914, -0.003147179028019309, -0.00793506670743227, 0.010550860315561295, 0.021705856546759605, -0.003524663858115673, -0.0018297542119398713, -0.050041571259498596, -0.007291794754564762, 0.01781735010445118, 0.0063960617408156395, -0.03904977813363075, 0.01057283766567707, 0.03884062543511391, -0.01125246100127697, 0.023670867085456848, 0.016941580921411514, -0.007183845620602369, 0.017717823386192322, 0.035207923501729965, 0.015461825765669346, 0.043556373566389084, -0.011791040189564228, 0.001590188592672348, 0.00000837738025438739, 0.02789394184947014, -0.0006700661615468562, -0.02106545679271221, 0.032476309686899185, 0.03220394253730774, 0.024116775020956993, -0.03370507061481476, -0.032957229763269424, 0.03662782534956932, -0.021756118163466454, -0.030124353244900703, 0.04379817470908165, -0.01665360853075981, 0.008902331814169884, -0.0028893519192934036, 0.003565598279237747, 0.029940206557512283, 0.05349172279238701, -0.038654785603284836, 0.014283818192780018, 0.012985172681510448, -0.05072961747646332, -0.005986845586448908, -0.011321257799863815, -0.02103152498602867, -0.059888649731874466, 0.027991583570837975, 0.027422206476330757, -0.005656459368765354, 0.011829645372927189, -0.01124665793031454, 0.003990994766354561, -0.0016277329996228218, -0.0016927528195083141, 0.01563793607056141, 0.02526000700891018, -0.08175528794527054, 0.008533726446330547, 0.0051934970542788506, -0.05094138905405998, 0.02102302573621273, 0.010124952532351017, -0.035414230078458786, 0.010153580456972122, -0.015247381292283535, -0.04566727578639984, -0.023725109174847603, -0.03766898065805435, -0.0037960095796734095, -0.02196328155696392, -0.04206893593072891, 0.034203119575977325, 0.03798447921872139, -0.0340275876224041, 0.010981118306517601, -0.014233016408979893, -0.03282834589481354, -0.01844923198223114, 0.01135703269392252, -0.016455931589007378, -0.0012937417486682534, -0.022510692477226257, 0.008966362103819847, 0.046060990542173386, -0.01291448250412941, -0.05633219704031944, -0.021532030776143074, 0.01656883768737316, 0.022315384820103645, 0.044011108577251434, 0.0249469093978405, -0.005462401546537876, 0.1210232600569725, 0.06066692993044853, -0.07813047617673874, -0.026146957650780678, -0.02440103329718113, -0.053616590797901154, 0.004596506245434284, 0.020931879058480263, 0.019242800772190094, 0.010431916452944279, 0.035441383719444275, -0.0015242195222526789, 0.007980755530297756, 0.02968137152493, 0.00029802523204125464, -0.04591967910528183, 0.026449033990502357, -0.04032564535737038, 0.008952024392783642, 0.03683655709028244, 0.018632542341947556, -0.04582149162888527, -0.004484982695430517, -0.0032510559540241957, 0.011801770888268948, 0.012987873516976833, -0.08581706136465073, 0.027438312768936157, 0.00304531492292881, 0.025684058666229248, -0.020110758021473885, 0.01885666511952877, 0.04337659105658531, -0.024587713181972504, -0.005527036730200052, -0.002552272751927376, 0.023773854598402977, -0.01959570124745369, -0.014541341923177242, 0.03351852297782898, 0.04403643682599068, -0.016725029796361923, 0.009230316616594791, -0.046557165682315826, -0.010600018315017223, 0.002370355650782585, -0.00336261629126966, -0.0031604012474417686, 0.016621431335806847, 0.05322971194982529, 0.009099157527089119, 0.00009597966709407046, 0.0021091895177960396, -0.005365552846342325, -0.048261359333992004, -0.02667219191789627, -0.027925485745072365, 0.062076032161712646, 0.01950914040207863, 0.06267593055963516, 0.037343740463256836, -0.04587627202272415, 0.010988999158143997, 0.03599509969353676, -0.015328940935432911, 0.030619429424405098, 0.040742482990026474, -0.008854889310896397, -0.010070305317640305, -0.035744842141866684, 0.03487229719758034, -0.016261909157037735, -0.013885349966585636, -0.02642810344696045, 0.021770860999822617, -0.04791568964719772, 0.011416684836149216, 0.010321064852178097, 0.0033173549454659224, 0.006828412879258394, 0.03739791736006737, 0.02394483983516693, -0.02386176586151123, 0.00032208123593591154, 0.020359862595796585, -0.02450760081410408, 0.013552766293287277, -0.025230610743165016, 0.03988826274871826, 0.022489475086331367, 0.017466962337493896, 0.00961559172719717, 0.03274908289313316, -0.05505593866109848, 0.007026836276054382, -0.06324990093708038, 0.008329272270202637, 0.050585173070430756, 0.01850534975528717, -0.0024276140611618757, -0.04774067550897598, -0.005110375117510557, 0.03498801216483116, 0.0054893651977181435, -0.013934179209172726, 0.01593329943716526, 0.07841047644615173, 0.016855085268616676, -0.0880448967218399, -0.014356609433889389, 0.06960050761699677, -0.012326697818934917, 0.009583068080246449, -0.05393286421895027, 0.00015580763283651322, -0.008743462152779102, 0.0002539425913710147, 0.03922022506594658, 0.008178767748177052, -0.004554084036499262, -0.026556283235549927, 0.03869905695319176, -0.014102552086114883, -0.049668293446302414, 0.04554220288991928, 0.03100397065281868, 0.08434611558914185, -0.007201673462986946, -0.00899608712643385, 0.0159183070063591, 0.028541453182697296, 0.03639659658074379, -0.010774602182209492, -0.0031646438874304295, -0.1144343912601471, -0.02369476854801178, 0.0625598281621933, 0.050364427268505096, -0.05005078762769699, -0.006814180873334408, -0.0602836012840271, -0.016644125804305077, 0.04157951846718788, -0.05821278318762779, -0.008334572426974773, -0.03609444200992584, 0.007101577240973711, -0.020423876121640205, -0.02745763026177883, -0.04082619026303291, 0.008627182804048061, -0.020061422139406204, 0.032330237329006195, -0.009197434410452843, -0.013075126335024834, -0.041965167969465256, 0.002561261411756277, 0.02791975438594818, 0.060850586742162704, -0.005708825774490833, -0.03090832196176052, 0.005748000927269459, 0.004102235194295645, -0.02588934265077114, -0.0542173758149147, -0.005347989499568939, 0.005758199375122786, -0.010507065802812576, 0.026556657627224922, -0.04082728177309036, -0.038155000656843185, -0.003057030728086829, 0.027768250554800034, -0.023809412494301796, -0.009387030266225338, -0.05865515395998955, 0.04148951545357704, 0.025020591914653778, 0.011449447833001614, 0.008618034422397614, 0.02965647727251053, 0.020414654165506363, 0.002224740106612444, -0.023993629962205887, -0.008045474998652935, -0.025154398754239082, -0.027362050488591194, -0.054042473435401917, 0.004439848940819502, -0.016995850950479507, -0.00019569775031413883, 0.030270278453826904, 0.07174495607614517, -0.00004615195211954415, -0.004283092450350523, 0.011591439135372639, -0.007969914004206657, -0.036454327404499054, -0.01972014084458351, -0.02962544746696949, 0.0255418810993433, 0.0004781085008289665, 0.004477542359381914, 0.00547073595225811, -0.01775985397398472, 0.027561232447624207, 0.03136695548892021, -0.07451317459344864, 0.03788267448544502, -0.030999569222331047, 0.005715955980122089, -0.003050070023164153, -0.02167622372508049, 0.04535537213087082, -0.032451290637254715, 0.05283790081739426, 0.024598391726613045, -0.023291783407330513, 0.0018277574563398957, 0.007347250357270241, 0.00808711163699627, 0.031132210046052933, -0.012919320724904537, 0.045101381838321686, 0.03194763511419296, 0.005327142309397459, -0.06394211947917938, -0.06825856119394302, 0.04325583577156067, 0.0035439704079180956, -0.011532670818269253, -0.043418556451797485, -0.020338406786322594, 0.03789432719349861, 0.021596582606434822, -0.0037012756802141666, 0.06603279709815979, 0.006374774035066366, -0.0037727043963968754, -0.010250379331409931, 0.0035150116309523582, 0.0764785185456276, -0.026550309732556343, 0.02652781456708908, 0.011396043002605438, 0.009016850963234901, -0.047384560108184814, 0.020157629624009132, -0.003631043713539839, -0.024599600583314896, -0.031416624784469604, -0.014032461680471897, 0.025970393791794777, 0.07894523441791534, 0.015442159958183765, 0.01930864341557026, -0.0023452157620340586, -0.017581863328814507, 0.012827371247112751, -0.033834610134363174, -0.000558317406103015, -0.006588324438780546, 0.0071696205995976925, -0.03188453987240791, 0.0143616683781147, -0.02757713943719864, -0.022002073004841805, 0.03411545604467392, -0.0066003454849123955, -0.00007539484795415774, 0.008229335770010948, 0.060077957808971405, -0.015909206122159958, 0.014987995848059654, -0.021431859582662582, -0.01075668353587389, 0.008014285936951637, 0.009675633162260056, 0.029845157638192177, -0.007522875908762217, 0.025369862094521523, -0.020961519330739975, -0.01809593476355076, -0.06627927720546722, -0.00935433804988861, 0.07317928224802017, 0.011063549667596817, 0.03882865235209465, 0.008058333769440651, 0.01385907270014286, 0.009504441171884537, -0.03575478866696358, 0.006029476877301931, -0.01074244175106287, 0.010869674384593964, 0.03485604003071785, 0.03896746039390564, 0.0003177002363372594, 0.005322575103491545, 0.01079664658755064, 0.031672440469264984, 0.0365753173828125, -0.006528620608150959, 0.00406349403783679, 0.028742928057909012, -0.023237230256199837, 0.0009925621561706066, 0.019506890326738358, -0.029318463057279587, 0.004918117541819811, 0.002072839066386223, -0.023461924865841866, 0.03249516710639, 0.0030711861327290535, -0.009140177629888058, -0.03490069881081581, -0.04185331612825394, -0.057222288101911545, 0.0600176602602005, 0.018045220524072647, -0.019046107307076454, 0.03976137936115265, -0.004353757482022047, -0.007009926252067089, 0.0334993451833725, 0.020944517105817795, -0.017953742295503616, -0.06590564548969269, -0.017469145357608795, -0.07140295952558517, -0.07567531615495682, 0.006700587458908558, 0.015227974392473698, -0.022265339270234108, 0.0052937171421945095, -0.014548609033226967, 0.0339631624519825, 0.002670420566573739, 0.06832225620746613, -0.0012406744062900543, 0.04737117514014244, 0.00968276895582676, 0.0347709134221077, 0.008701213635504246, 0.004664630629122257, 0.1448754370212555, 0.0624358169734478, 0.03760740906000137, -0.07373073697090149, -0.021130433306097984, 0.0219004824757576, -0.03820133954286575, -0.010660015046596527, 0.019408857449889183, -0.020259510725736618, -0.009924285113811493, 0.014637215062975883, 0.02320001646876335, 0.009904243983328342, 0.0024971538223326206, 0.028440559282898903, -0.03426367789506912, -0.006585866212844849, -0.019984139129519463, 0.02872554399073124, -0.011591395363211632, -0.04698649048805237, -0.05064557120203972, 0.07589889317750931, 0.032883480191230774, -0.04075990617275238, -0.04098426178097725, -0.010325413197278976, -0.022186337038874626, -0.027077512815594673, 0.03828362375497818, 0.008101915009319782, -0.009602820500731468, -0.003826353931799531, 0.02363394759595394, -0.019509345293045044, 0.0018486721673980355, -0.033895380795001984, 0.003697973908856511, 0.03111676126718521, 0.0018652286380529404, 0.0014672402758151293, -0.014577294699847698, 0.015282846055924892, -0.031327515840530396, -0.045734703540802, -0.04353436082601547, 0.009701761417090893, -0.020010560750961304, -0.04170878976583481, 0.008320373483002186, -0.009343991987407207, -0.01928342692553997, -0.0425683818757534, -0.0029247375205159187, 0.007419435307383537, 0.03159080818295479, -0.0026825645472854376, -0.04151402413845062, -0.009961718693375587, 0.04037551209330559, -0.010695025324821472, 0.023221490904688835, 0.009706963784992695, -0.01468098908662796, -0.05584699660539627, -0.01974351517856121, 0.016213487833738327, -0.0011965475277975202, 0.028291795402765274, -0.0002624301996547729, -0.05148690193891525, -0.017514590173959732, -0.007424496579915285, 0.00501140346750617, 0.008030823431909084, 0.0007438462343998253, -0.023445110768079758, -0.026766084134578705, -0.023562481626868248, 0.005747773218899965, -0.022370021790266037, -0.008084379136562347, 0.016480257734656334, 0.006627646274864674, 0.015193265862762928, -0.03997720032930374, 0.04702586680650711, 0.016635293141007423, 0.020685575902462006, 0.04365173354744911, 0.06744900345802307, -0.011867749504745007, -0.04839107021689415, -0.029933279380202293, -0.010569371283054352, -0.05484766885638237, 0.047914471477270126, 0.03125965967774391, 0.07918719947338104, 0.043732065707445145, 0.01357104629278183, 0.00906983483582735, 0.04365813732147217, 0.008100242353975773, 0.00989280641078949, 0.012288757599890232, -0.0572308748960495, 0.0012117710430175066, -0.011645826511085033, -0.038600411266088486, -0.03870271146297455, -0.03777957335114479, -0.005905175115913153, -0.00012595635780598968, -0.01664312370121479, -0.011438755318522453, -0.018624456599354744, 0.03932708501815796, 0.01072950754314661, 0.007924379780888557, -0.013791486620903015, 0.012493775226175785, -0.01056706067174673, 0.019728414714336395, -0.031682852655649185, 0.0008958710823208094, -0.0012156646698713303, 0.01368711981922388, 0.005802965257316828, 0.016157399863004684, 0.02187967486679554, -0.012427153997123241, 0.007024333346635103, -0.02859603986144066, 0.022243715822696686, -0.004683504346758127, 0.021900756284594536, -0.04544243961572647, -0.015946928411722183, 0.03129421919584274, -0.038953445851802826, -0.023798376321792603, -0.004202317912131548, 0.016727034002542496, 0.04522018879652023, 0.015757977962493896, -0.021319914609193802, -0.0026193244848400354, 0.034357573837041855, -0.016379190608859062, -0.03167770430445671, -0.005829915404319763, 0.02746630646288395, -0.003563154488801956, 0.013668888248503208, 0.03280118852853775, 0.011869003996253014, -0.015119361691176891, 0.017514998093247414, 0.015413181856274605, 0.013696253299713135, -0.03393487632274628, 0.002071911469101906, -0.01846311427652836, 0.023573659360408783, -0.0032360851764678955, 0.0039959498681128025, 0.030095869675278664, 0.019234631210565567, -0.029864002019166946, 0.010588068515062332, -0.013564164750277996, 0.02610633336007595, -0.11846034973859787, -0.03501282259821892, 0.01238508615642786, -0.0033793114125728607, 0.02009759657084942, -0.08049334585666656, 0.025562047958374023, 0.03448726609349251, -0.029498575255274773, 0.016728820279240608, 0.0020913456100970507, 0.01336919516324997, 0.0032169825863093138, 0.043090350925922394, -0.03231922164559364, -0.034502558410167694, 0.03808287903666496, 0.013642062433063984, 0.0514349602162838, 0.02846365235745907, 0.01420880202203989, -0.0212906114757061, -0.023063553497195244, 0.034668248146772385, -0.007588821928948164, -0.02585717663168907, 0.03366059064865112, -0.03781118243932724, -0.022591279819607735, 0.044531844556331635, -0.010882556438446045, 0.015003728680312634, 0.058497268706560135, 0.08686371147632599, 0.0003948236699216068, 0.04809204116463661, 0.023293277248740196, 0.02029925212264061, 0.009960117749869823, 0.004558765795081854, 0.03408551216125488, -0.013665738515555859, 0.0076575507409870625, 0.016563380137085915, 0.04562624916434288, -0.026180006563663483, -0.013137651607394218, 0.0367698073387146, -0.013495407998561859, -0.019405893981456757, 0.0037544225342571735, -0.007213533390313387, -0.008122630417346954, -0.03891327977180481, 0.010169490240514278, -0.02349531464278698, 0.02080664038658142, -0.0004654406802728772, 0.022083066403865814, -0.025842446833848953, 0.016339117661118507, -0.010022604838013649, -0.04897085204720497, -0.002683778991922736, 0.004004090558737516, -0.02159150503575802, -0.042027056217193604, -0.0007485076785087585, 0.011895456351339817, -0.036165256053209305, -0.057604849338531494, -0.01697348989546299, -0.02846486307680607, 0.0555730015039444, -0.009785423055291176, 0.014919805340468884, 0.03770742565393448, 0.009115349501371384, 0.023952776566147804, -0.11772425472736359, 0.04885602742433548, 0.0007839277386665344, -0.023573050275444984, -0.022533558309078217, -0.016548823565244675, 0.0093406792730093, 0.011831494979560375, 0.014302612282335758, 0.014865203760564327, 0.0037139272317290306, -0.014204311184585094, 0.0014990682248026133, 0.010020178742706776, -0.05186700075864792, 0.02915876731276512, -0.022353315725922585, -0.014744900166988373, -0.015952538698911667, -0.005187089089304209, -0.0021650553680956364, 0.019926020875573158, 0.009092707186937332, 0.005460009444504976, -0.015870874747633934, -0.012880325317382812, 0.004458426497876644, 0.004663986153900623, 0.04213976860046387, -0.01310357078909874, 0.04720459505915642, -0.010841515846550465, -0.005350932013243437, 0.04501240327954292, -0.02415386587381363, -0.027759728953242302, 0.045088984072208405, -0.009076348505914211, -0.02994132786989212, 0.006213974207639694, 0.010366689413785934, 0.024230819195508957, -0.04490170255303383, 0.004592410754412413, 0.024471165612339973, -0.01753075420856476, 0.019840480759739876, 0.01179831475019455, -0.004179410170763731, 0.03696827590465546, 0.017668820917606354, 0.006654629483819008, -0.0014973508659750223, -0.028687354177236557, 0.00488080782815814, -0.01647382602095604, -0.014170878566801548, -0.014038548804819584, 0.008124057203531265, 0.01874975860118866, -0.004054237622767687, 0.02296125516295433, 0.020884688943624496, 0.01181149110198021, -0.017345799133181572, -0.008170563727617264, -0.021618595346808434, 0.006315498147159815, -0.029734810814261436, -0.01826281100511551, -0.02095913328230381, 0.06935452669858932, -0.03315144032239914, 0.018015166744589806, -0.02349114790558815, 0.005948846228420734, 0.01075361855328083, 0.0030403081327676773, 0.006255416199564934, 0.014028497971594334, 0.002184133045375347, -0.03013015352189541, 0.0056280395947396755, 0.011686048470437527, 0.017791716381907463, -0.02479398623108864, 0.04279160499572754, -0.029978714883327484, 0.02300793118774891, 0.0017248851945623755, -0.02863520383834839, -0.014949976466596127, -0.0029046600684523582, 0.006879988592118025, 0.011219969019293785, 0.01887085847556591, 0.0013599282829090953, -0.031172076240181923, -0.03136875107884407, 0.03330417349934578, -0.024598438292741776, 0.01779867708683014, -0.06900058686733246, -0.016328690573573112, -0.0406082347035408, -0.0518803596496582 ]
<p>I am doing cross-validation using the leave-one-out cross-validation method (total 10 runs). I have predicted $\hat{y}$ and observed $y$ from all the runs. I have applied the following equation to calculate $R^2$. Can anyone please confirm whether I am doing right? I am confused because the $R^2$ value appeared negative. \begin{align} SSE&amp;=∑(y-\hat{y})^2 \\ SST&amp;=∑(y–\bar{y})^2 \\ R^2&amp;=1-(SSE/SST) \end{align} (N.b., $\bar{y}=$ is the average of $y$.)</p>
27,748
[ -0.033767830580472946, -0.026519667357206345, -0.04851937294006348, 0.013382448814809322, 0.013806693255901337, -0.013980627991259098, -0.008533980697393417, -0.01172054186463356, 0.03388980031013489, -0.011026116088032722, 0.058124322444200516, 0.02307605743408203, 0.08876577019691467, -0.004542037378996611, 0.004699224606156349, 0.029029663652181625, -0.022987527772784233, 0.0022255931980907917, 0.022056246176362038, -0.013132398948073387, 0.014869768172502518, 0.02755781263113022, 0.01721734181046486, -0.023296311497688293, -0.032086893916130066, 0.049038179218769073, 0.06341630220413208, -0.00739336758852005, -0.005561185535043478, 0.033416785299777985, -0.038632914423942566, -0.04559772461652756, -0.006923884619027376, 0.06741435080766678, 0.011342170648276806, -0.011449840851128101, -0.015586208552122116, -0.059791769832372665, -0.008920546621084213, 0.02439388446509838, 0.006789519917219877, -0.012802847661077976, -0.007967285811901093, 0.04516913369297981, 0.011930926702916622, -0.030505230650305748, -0.01579209417104721, -0.008044308982789516, 0.04755832254886627, -0.031126471236348152, 0.08403056859970093, 0.000762377108912915, 0.03284135460853577, 0.03624430671334267, -0.03697333484888077, 0.010313726030290127, 0.023799922317266464, 0.038933683186769485, -0.013621500693261623, -0.031534746289253235, -0.007325027137994766, -0.048003874719142914, 0.0008152525988407433, 0.02995448186993599, -0.04175705090165138, -0.012663550674915314, 0.006034421268850565, 0.012624658644199371, -0.006458932533860207, -0.026403069496154785, 0.07301530241966248, 0.006328564137220383, 0.026386631652712822, -0.011760737746953964, 0.03241748735308647, -0.004802764393389225, 0.01193145290017128, 0.05855662003159523, 0.027561118826270103, 0.04399054870009422, -0.0006792553467676044, -0.012293791398406029, 0.026986291632056236, 0.05678993836045265, 0.0014817790361121297, 0.011712653562426567, 0.08006814122200012, -0.002241729525849223, 0.046417102217674255, 0.030119996517896652, 0.015384468249976635, 0.0004974166513420641, 0.05973118171095848, -0.0002119614655384794, -0.049383774399757385, 0.05273735895752907, -0.004063160624355078, 0.04610433802008629, 0.013552500866353512, -0.024571705609560013, 0.01431698352098465, -0.05199569836258888, 0.017764071002602577, 0.07769738882780075, -0.03941040113568306, -0.022540710866451263, -0.03955526649951935, 0.006106968969106674, 0.013461988419294357, -0.04325227439403534, -0.031366653740406036, 0.021869152784347534, -0.025658611208200455, -0.03851146250963211, 0.04015042632818222, -0.011685595847666264, 0.013339094817638397, 0.015508154407143593, -0.000788428180385381, 0.005170048214495182, 0.04066986218094826, -0.009327669627964497, 0.0036341461818665266, 0.007563465740531683, -0.00552962115034461, 0.02579438127577305, 0.020111657679080963, -0.025115469470620155, -0.02669723890721798, 0.027921225875616074, 0.01650986447930336, -0.04715937748551369, 0.022898035123944283, -0.006064934190362692, 0.01587548851966858, 0.01378495991230011, -0.09183821082115173, -0.05576316639780998, 0.004877577070146799, -0.03782258555293083, 0.053197845816612244, -0.03131759911775589, -0.03435341641306877, 0.012210112996399403, 0.05549938231706619, 0.01709257811307907, 0.03162764012813568, 0.022723110392689705, 0.017875421792268753, -0.003918694797903299, -0.010440163314342499, -0.03182796761393547, -0.04673418775200844, -0.01603543944656849, -0.06076531857252121, -0.054584044963121414, 0.009026147425174713, 0.004240772686898708, -0.01769149862229824, 0.016419442370533943, 0.01756731979548931, -0.00886390171945095, 0.024267949163913727, 0.03828892111778259, 0.018161680549383163, -0.03736304119229317, 0.05295726656913757, 0.002630864968523383, 0.023677963763475418, 0.030271334573626518, 0.01505851000547409, 0.016320329159498215, 0.030292993411421776, 0.03953802213072777, 0.037623003125190735, -0.009044905193150043, -0.02004559524357319, -0.04671674594283104, 0.015758421272039413, 0.0057670860551297665, -0.06206049397587776, -0.0320291668176651, -0.02885764092206955, -0.015054622665047646, 0.008110311813652515, 0.06224960833787918, -0.014574514701962471, -0.04317384585738182, 0.0610746331512928, -0.0570375993847847, -0.017420828342437744, -0.05178297683596611, -0.0042767939157783985, 0.01590104214847088, -0.0032749539241194725, 0.0013391909888014197, 0.030270736664533615, 0.025676995515823364, -0.009316510520875454, -0.011586165055632591, -0.016960173845291138, 0.03130485489964485, 0.01579904556274414, -0.007497662212699652, 0.015652397647500038, 0.04120757803320885, 0.012047416530549526, 0.01738106645643711, 0.03242751955986023, -0.05978613719344139, -0.034678734838962555, -0.022901251912117004, 0.006518777925521135, -0.025866471230983734, 0.0024294473696500063, -0.04742532595992088, 0.028342703357338905, -0.028498368337750435, -0.014844122342765331, 0.013010051101446152, -0.05090121179819107, 0.05605442449450493, 0.055964089930057526, 0.0060815270990133286, 0.01181622315198183, 0.006551358848810196, 0.0209914892911911, 0.029619745910167694, -0.03233584761619568, -0.013082734309136868, -0.026428813114762306, -0.03364110738039017, 0.04581755772233009, 0.0033718282356858253, -0.04216211661696434, 0.007510481867939234, 0.07447709143161774, 0.0008670992683619261, -0.0006051931413821876, 0.005655617918819189, 0.01001627929508686, -0.023896319791674614, 0.024635035544633865, 0.03079906851053238, -0.007287765387445688, -0.02462089993059635, -0.01538271177560091, 0.0035235732793807983, 0.01864861510694027, 0.039743781089782715, 0.004466714337468147, 0.03006851300597191, 0.011583777144551277, -0.00018905413162428886, -0.0015724420081824064, -0.006573295220732689, 0.056701451539993286, -0.005338698159903288, -0.005896532442420721, 0.05662698298692703, 0.03606833890080452, -0.012928529642522335, -0.016059452667832375, 0.005726612638682127, 0.04143177717924118, 0.04566163569688797, -0.02074521966278553, 0.011423202231526375, 0.011722434312105179, -0.0348268523812294, 0.004418535623699427, -0.0192247461527586, -0.04192805290222168, -0.052927806973457336, 0.00660400977358222, 0.04513290524482727, 0.05804334953427315, 0.026409393176436424, -0.05089866369962692, 0.00021041081345174462, -0.03959071263670921, 0.005013776943087578, 0.018243638798594475, -0.012823204509913921, -0.04440508782863617, -0.00886612944304943, -0.060039665549993515, -0.00008841259841574356, 0.03359336778521538, -0.005915180779993534, -0.044625576585531235, 0.0030014440417289734, -0.013446840457618237, -0.05183598771691322, -0.04051872715353966, -0.05921498313546181, 0.02702183835208416, -0.03559728339314461, -0.02459467202425003, 0.05549541115760803, 0.02100963145494461, -0.031452275812625885, 0.07020936906337738, -0.01873018965125084, -0.02952639013528824, -0.0022450806573033333, 0.004980580881237984, 0.04847721755504608, -0.0026462359819561243, 0.04115305095911026, 0.01883082278072834, 0.021656498312950134, 0.002592101925984025, -0.05625259503722191, -0.08593884110450745, 0.028533125296235085, 0.030862919986248016, 0.00046215171460062265, 0.03263954073190689, -0.009354782290756702, 0.07880823314189911, 0.023191360756754875, -0.033079005777835846, -0.0017303327331319451, 0.051354482769966125, -0.027776796370744705, -0.031424347311258316, -0.012767644599080086, -0.025363318622112274, 0.025424333289265633, 0.03537900373339653, 0.010308682918548584, 0.04208768159151077, 0.031630273908376694, 0.003413805039599538, -0.03610094264149666, -0.010123577900230885, -0.00721637113019824, -0.0014220229350030422, 0.04284633323550224, -0.010649303905665874, 0.008765796199440956, -0.016212189570069313, 0.009878415614366531, 0.052490558475255966, 0.00408210838213563, -0.06708435714244843, 0.015191390179097652, -0.07417069375514984, 0.022330982610583305, -0.008455414324998856, 0.04087826609611511, -0.009213529527187347, -0.023719366639852524, -0.029565906152129173, 0.0008514289511367679, 0.045750461518764496, -0.005460827145725489, 0.013292628340423107, 0.03469749912619591, 0.010601229965686798, 0.0018076957203447819, -0.0010276084067299962, -0.0029739970341324806, -0.01230206061154604, 0.03874961659312248, 0.022252291440963745, -0.023179668933153152, 0.03968146815896034, 0.038921140134334564, 0.01372494176030159, -0.011280771344900131, -0.03552388399839401, -0.0007871977868489921, -0.049712151288986206, -0.0015474992105737329, -0.07769545912742615, 0.05203305184841156, 0.012292370200157166, 0.027556423097848892, 0.01567128486931324, -0.011476177722215652, 0.03205675631761551, 0.007530047558248043, -0.030014505609869957, 0.008435612544417381, -0.03008875995874405, -0.008500258438289165, -0.01739690825343132, 0.0002566646144259721, 0.023711059242486954, -0.06494100391864777, 0.049308352172374725, 0.009995227679610252, 0.005874318536370993, -0.02891130931675434, -0.031161770224571228, -0.005320011172443628, 0.020442428067326546, -0.03009834885597229, 0.02962861955165863, 0.0375424325466156, -0.017759554088115692, 0.025273125618696213, 0.04617425426840782, -0.013197408989071846, -0.005216533318161964, -0.058554016053676605, 0.0064491285011172295, 0.03232892230153084, 0.0287203136831522, 0.031988341361284256, -0.00909025315195322, -0.036321211606264114, 0.001843458623625338, -0.005659662652760744, 0.008012606762349606, 0.0373123399913311, -0.01630895584821701, -0.043598588556051254, -0.058491840958595276, -0.013022561557590961, -0.00712917186319828, -0.012206542305648327, 0.04074384644627571, 0.019810503348708153, 0.045890502631664276, 0.009934994392096996, -0.03369448706507683, -0.004778627306222916, 0.07819201052188873, -0.005381646100431681, 0.024702664464712143, -0.047197531908750534, 0.03833604231476784, -0.0063046300783753395, -0.010125439614057541, 0.022477611899375916, -0.016442421823740005, -0.022107195109128952, -0.03380555659532547, 0.040635399520397186, 0.015723934397101402, 0.01003002654761076, 0.007445113733410835, 0.030068693682551384, 0.059518635272979736, -0.041800037026405334, -0.040370676666498184, 0.0156861562281847, 0.06370200961828232, 0.03692936897277832, 0.0013127109268680215, -0.03318523243069649, -0.028631243854761124, 0.001928970799781382, 0.0006237845518626273, 0.018203001469373703, -0.03862646967172623, -0.009514383971691132, -0.044196706265211105, -0.020416921004652977, 0.018425608053803444, -0.02372048795223236, -0.007551964372396469, -0.0014247543876990676, -0.009579703211784363, 0.007743819151073694, -0.0036446251906454563, -0.06893062591552734, -0.009583134204149246, -0.024080270901322365, 0.01928451657295227, -0.022383853793144226, -0.02821684069931507, -0.0364917553961277, -0.003861555829644203, 0.012132618576288223, 0.03382543846964836, -0.04171176254749298, -0.004473193548619747, -0.02734730765223503, 0.023119613528251648, 0.01764540746808052, -0.075703464448452, -0.02680944837629795, 0.009421790018677711, 0.012888064607977867, 0.06298316270112991, -0.018026407808065414, -0.03265250846743584, 0.033079762011766434, 0.05433175340294838, 0.013858075253665447, -0.0321444496512413, -0.04064718261361122, 0.04126591235399246, 0.034704625606536865, 0.0012110269162803888, 0.07622949779033661, -0.001619006390683353, 0.011597474105656147, -0.023586686700582504, 0.0031769576016813517, -0.006082803942263126, 0.0038280971348285675, -0.007416998967528343, -0.003796523669734597, -0.03651053085923195, 0.012376859784126282, -0.002888127462938428, -0.03942592442035675, 0.056388478726148605, -0.07280722260475159, -0.02929835394024849, 0.02726501226425171, 0.02677665837109089, -0.00007151124009396881, -0.005939437076449394, -0.0059455689042806625, 0.03484690934419632, -0.00764098996296525, -0.021693093702197075, -0.028858458623290062, -0.03448941558599472, -0.014615464955568314, 0.03215044364333153, -0.03235673904418945, 0.05828923359513283, -0.036035120487213135, -0.04395357891917229, 0.0045921350829303265, -0.052156638354063034, 0.014988203532993793, -0.029410867020487785, 0.01574842818081379, -0.005729514639824629, -0.001479294733144343, -0.01413720566779375, 0.027988294139504433, 0.01813751645386219, 0.01441996730864048, -0.010473509319126606, -0.0022076547611504793, -0.008016315288841724, 0.010283430106937885, -0.0727696344256401, -0.028282074257731438, -0.015173518098890781, -0.006522209383547306, -0.019591189920902252, -0.011891305446624756, -0.024667108431458473, -0.037579409778118134, -0.0215858556330204, -0.011858540587127209, 0.04302077367901802, -0.028851330280303955, -0.010338222607970238, 0.01230968814343214, -0.00889005046337843, 0.07353953272104263, -0.02212211862206459, 0.008034823462367058, 0.012862267903983593, 0.03425190597772598, -0.028556980192661285, 0.043640848249197006, 0.05735672265291214, -0.04635124281048775, -0.006380995735526085, -0.04005517065525055, -0.007025215774774551, 0.04641593247652054, -0.009956753812730312, -0.02688007429242134, 0.0012203393271192908, 0.002567617455497384, 0.015412851236760616, -0.012219260446727276, 0.004584548529237509, -0.025619370862841606, -0.011453859508037567, -0.004256345331668854, -0.046330779790878296, -0.03627149015665054, 0.01101861521601677, 0.03641360625624657, -0.006779321003705263, -0.015514210797846317, 0.0005530606140382588, 0.09320235997438431, 0.013101300224661827, -0.005256297066807747, -0.004209969192743301, -0.05478077754378319, 0.017844945192337036, 0.020053045824170113, -0.005982378963381052, 0.02999366819858551, 0.004014729056507349, -0.0655071884393692, -0.021758636459708214, -0.025639062747359276, 0.002207823796197772, 0.08848851919174194, -0.03798414021730423, 0.04883742704987526, -0.0009033178794197738, 0.0016046109376475215, -0.01775892823934555, -0.08663120865821838, -0.0034415984991937876, 0.0044149053283035755, 0.01999909244477749, 0.04783608764410019, 0.062027715146541595, 0.011905502527952194, -0.011013752780854702, 0.009602953679859638, 0.04612894728779793, 0.03274460509419441, 0.019520238041877747, 0.03448100760579109, -0.0011230806121602654, -0.007054127752780914, -0.04402869939804077, 0.0204558614641428, -0.028870420530438423, -0.008046944625675678, -0.02103886939585209, 0.016218554228544235, -0.003453783690929413, 0.023986592888832092, 0.00042062363354489207, -0.046173080801963806, -0.025219133123755455, -0.025883328169584274, 0.0076658716425299644, 0.0037152329459786415, 0.000897020217962563, 0.00459517166018486, 0.04384484514594078, -0.0038381568156182766, 0.03103584051132202, 0.03997461125254631, -0.03137095645070076, -0.05955464392900467, -0.01691039837896824, -0.02854137495160103, -0.01102636568248272, 0.03147576004266739, 0.027816753834486008, -0.017057932913303375, -0.0069363596849143505, -0.044644951820373535, 0.03910097852349281, 0.031044665724039078, 0.029423877596855164, -0.006445871666073799, 0.06727902591228485, -0.0022367609199136496, 0.017729412764310837, 0.002968010725453496, 0.02700546756386757, 0.12065567076206207, 0.1010543704032898, 0.03270043805241585, -0.042122915387153625, 0.01911606453359127, -0.03619491681456566, -0.01760207675397396, -0.02062825858592987, -0.004408146720379591, -0.035245537757873535, -0.008468914777040482, 0.031926680356264114, 0.030624782666563988, 0.013116192072629929, -0.004385156556963921, 0.012957176193594933, -0.0319245345890522, -0.009736803360283375, -0.003814631374552846, -0.0055832089856266975, -0.005157677922397852, -0.021634984761476517, -0.01706419698894024, 0.013184786774218082, -0.030469456687569618, -0.03278638422489166, -0.03254161402583122, -0.013197286985814571, -0.0010765781626105309, -0.0013941237702965736, -0.00824037566781044, 0.054933108389377594, -0.019603798165917397, 0.014538545161485672, -0.043951332569122314, -0.009591768495738506, 0.016264349222183228, -0.02737489342689514, 0.03547908365726471, 0.018255839124321938, -0.0023115205112844706, -0.014386984519660473, 0.02047804743051529, -0.006163445301353931, -0.051891326904296875, 0.0013736016117036343, -0.04132745787501335, 0.07228885591030121, -0.02217147871851921, -0.03594287484884262, -0.01138344407081604, -0.019029751420021057, 0.009340854361653328, -0.03975774347782135, -0.005857117008417845, 0.014693347737193108, 0.012281887233257294, -0.030456138774752617, -0.02400156483054161, -0.07278710603713989, 0.044062014669179916, 0.031849492341279984, -0.02056240290403366, 0.021351484581828117, 0.020729171112179756, -0.028643079102039337, 0.027552643790841103, 0.05900375917553902, 0.009778723120689392, 0.008270448073744774, -0.000125943188322708, -0.0032087669242173433, -0.011184539645910263, -0.033722762018442154, 0.04559337720274925, 0.010062845423817635, 0.04780708998441696, -0.014628578908741474, -0.008744643069803715, -0.03950333967804909, -0.05397239699959755, 0.0021256643813103437, -0.011982858180999756, -0.0037647199351340532, -0.00575422216206789, -0.03355799987912178, -0.019291071221232414, 0.024248342961072922, -0.010758000425994396, -0.0010243527358397841, 0.005082578398287296, 0.06580657511949539, 0.009355340152978897, -0.031681716442108154, -0.020646557211875916, 0.0400739423930645, -0.030311254784464836, 0.03163204342126846, -0.01429380290210247, 0.03180889040231705, 0.023918334394693375, 0.043294258415699005, -0.021910717710852623, 0.025234585627913475, -0.029413780197501183, -0.00003883934914483689, -0.0042833904735744, -0.03636227175593376, 0.008634543046355247, -0.01972101256251335, -0.013474156148731709, -0.01565123349428177, 0.0029526303987950087, -0.01979791186749935, -0.036123719066381454, 0.014721100218594074, 0.007946301251649857, -0.022505488246679306, 0.01359538733959198, -0.0011566031025722623, -0.025444652885198593, -0.043805379420518875, -0.009583688341081142, -0.049704279750585556, 0.01022113673388958, -0.01085609383881092, -0.030387744307518005, -0.020733844488859177, -0.008315949700772762, 0.006001739297062159, 0.01728147827088833, 0.04593998193740845, 0.01832873560488224, 0.04003101959824562, -0.006961534731090069, -0.01730869524180889, -0.018062595278024673, 0.057220298796892166, -0.039843615144491196, -0.026706891134381294, 0.036022964864969254, -0.028629284352064133, -0.023812633007764816, 0.04320291057229042, 0.0328708179295063, 0.048034559935331345, 0.022487005218863487, -0.007491096388548613, 0.0008093969081528485, 0.032875653356313705, -0.019943661987781525, -0.014460885897278786, 0.007828913629055023, 0.00875036884099245, 0.034754421561956406, -0.01704745553433895, 0.009504987858235836, -0.013335473835468292, 0.022898316383361816, 0.046158429235219955, 0.03209390491247177, -0.0256781205534935, -0.022162076085805893, -0.004030843731015921, -0.006904821842908859, 0.017340080812573433, 0.012517214752733707, 0.026391705498099327, 0.011842812411487103, 0.003479677950963378, -0.03992091119289398, 0.04114579036831856, -0.02715359628200531, -0.015965135768055916, -0.06109025701880455, -0.026927629485726357, 0.028145048767328262, 0.023212172091007233, -0.00643526203930378, -0.07023848593235016, 0.00207162881270051, 0.03584393858909607, -0.017871204763650894, 0.03376326337456703, -0.041653599590063095, -0.006599417421966791, -0.049818165600299835, 0.011903790757060051, -0.021018510684370995, -0.022099943831562996, 0.02342476136982441, 0.03627907484769821, 0.03525698557496071, 0.03605026379227638, -0.007282794453203678, -0.024852944537997246, -0.03091210126876831, 0.04781128466129303, 0.02562086284160614, -0.054442405700683594, 0.02272348664700985, -0.0113754877820611, -0.021812887862324715, 0.05339112505316734, -0.02396196685731411, 0.004415624774992466, -0.007680172100663185, 0.040840454399585724, -0.02073734812438488, 0.03668302297592163, 0.03612641245126724, -0.016430579125881195, 0.017998330295085907, 0.0149137694388628, 0.017068475484848022, 0.02240539714694023, -0.017517322674393654, 0.0133134126663208, -0.016895677894353867, -0.021364988759160042, -0.04080722853541374, 0.034610237926244736, -0.027369285002350807, -0.021036913618445396, 0.02368917129933834, 0.02250671200454235, -0.021994851529598236, -0.06669201701879501, -0.010365553200244904, -0.014516891911625862, 0.01245406735688448, 0.04213152080774307, 0.021116701886057854, -0.0361306257545948, 0.002600024687126279, -0.004228414036333561, -0.07842599600553513, 0.01743197627365589, 0.020637601613998413, -0.026763804256916046, -0.05543430894613266, -0.004929846618324518, 0.019482934847474098, -0.0342511311173439, -0.006579775828868151, -0.02162010781466961, -0.027437305077910423, 0.0011373994639143348, -0.008553744293749332, -0.011488603428006172, 0.027034198865294456, -0.003931468352675438, -0.0040496038272976875, -0.09170153737068176, 0.059487178921699524, 0.026858195662498474, -0.049462612718343735, -0.010213693603873253, 0.01702854596078396, -0.038530491292476654, -0.036985475569963455, 0.062429361045360565, -0.002721471479162574, 0.007847812958061695, -0.0034236665815114975, 0.0209178626537323, -0.009720145724713802, -0.06728968024253845, 0.046657878905534744, -0.0049797589890658855, 0.020194850862026215, -0.01891058310866356, -0.050089914351701736, 0.012102068401873112, 0.01573018915951252, 0.01168141234666109, 0.0010938256746158004, 0.03925304487347603, 0.00818574894219637, -0.020258121192455292, 0.04582834243774414, 0.007973291911184788, -0.015604906715452671, 0.06874217838048935, 0.026230216026306152, 0.009219489991664886, 0.0362936370074749, -0.024207865819334984, -0.01816222257912159, 0.03973864018917084, 0.011446135118603706, -0.03570375218987465, -0.006576674524694681, 0.04561088979244232, 0.009220863692462444, -0.041527360677719116, -0.04114324226975441, 0.05946000665426254, 0.003800460370257497, -0.0006795220542699099, 0.0445517972111702, 0.021819183602929115, 0.0028263316489756107, 0.022545576095581055, 0.023819297552108765, 0.02849024534225464, 0.030253572389483452, 0.04206809401512146, 0.0216288510710001, -0.01116028893738985, 0.021964114159345627, -0.01767868734896183, 0.02983301505446434, -0.019423920661211014, 0.023076113313436508, 0.02094237320125103, 0.05567497760057449, -0.03732690215110779, -0.016980288550257683, 0.025309544056653976, -0.023647457361221313, -0.013391218148171902, -0.03994998335838318, -0.03269204497337341, 0.05013865604996681, -0.05552060902118683, 0.017456814646720886, -0.02250046096742153, -0.029324006289243698, -0.006440394092351198, 0.012728116475045681, -0.016323914751410484, 0.031518276780843735, 0.03060043975710869, -0.028942763805389404, -0.02191774919629097, -0.005736729130148888, 0.0263922568410635, -0.02875586971640587, 0.024694785475730896, -0.009683501906692982, -0.021892134100198746, 0.00010120619117515162, -0.014323526993393898, 0.015139964409172535, 0.0029160117264837027, 0.02316192165017128, 0.061612531542778015, 0.013242426328361034, -0.021907439455389977, -0.01601295918226242, 0.027826914563775063, 0.039679206907749176, -0.055247705429792404, -0.058223798871040344, -0.002470447914674878, 0.04221698269248009, 0.0025380642618983984, -0.03757641464471817 ]
<p>I understand supervised and unsupervised learning well, and would be able to identify some 'basic' examples of, for example, supervised classifcation as:</p> <ul> <li>SVMs</li> <li>Random Forests</li> <li>Logistic Regression</li> </ul> <p>These are key works in the field which have lots of code and publications available.</p> <p>I am now starting to look at domain adaptation in supervised learning, where the distribution over the data at learning and testing time are known to be different. Despite reading some of the literature, I haven't spotted any similar 'basic' methods which come up time and time again. In contrast, there seem to be a wild array of completely different methods for achieving the goal, many of which have only been in the literature for a few years.</p> <p>Are there such key, established methods for domain adaptation? What are the most popular methods currently used?</p>
35,729
[ -0.005091939587146044, 0.013276800513267517, -0.004625815432518721, -0.003927372395992279, 0.012273753061890602, 0.0033684223890304565, -0.03068438731133938, 0.0075272754766047, 0.05887054651975632, -0.052050910890102386, 0.03981003165245056, 0.043498169630765915, 0.04101477190852165, 0.037515342235565186, 0.009910251945257187, -0.006951043847948313, 0.013798346742987633, -0.03836490586400032, -0.012183231301605701, 0.008389212191104889, 0.040825728327035904, 0.0232964139431715, 0.021307066082954407, 0.00897434912621975, -0.011661343276500702, 0.033767059445381165, -0.009681903757154942, -0.026841310784220695, 0.02737140655517578, 0.04199482873082161, -0.05684766545891762, 0.0033717001788318157, -0.014715242199599743, 0.032178621739149094, -0.000978246214799583, 0.0008265014039352536, -0.029599741101264954, -0.04774192348122597, -0.012462981976568699, 0.01645011082291603, -0.06879264116287231, 0.0003664923715405166, -0.027229301631450653, 0.03463790565729141, 0.007071473635733128, 0.006402082275599241, -0.0425633043050766, -0.007755405269563198, -0.0010315401013940573, -0.03759855031967163, 0.055105920881032944, -0.02127833291888237, 0.016398632898926735, 0.030644558370113373, -0.0038536833599209785, -0.012462115846574306, 0.07077110558748245, 0.05126116797327995, 0.00705628702417016, -0.0484703965485096, -0.0015144178178161383, -0.00982365757226944, -0.0036074586678296328, -0.01998143643140793, -0.02498944289982319, 0.020523205399513245, 0.01302413735538721, -0.015504647977650166, 0.029751049354672432, -0.003976904321461916, 0.008226856589317322, 0.00885552167892456, 0.06680673360824585, 0.02024458907544613, -0.002533462131395936, -0.007479044143110514, 0.008567949756979942, 0.03334400802850723, 0.03652935475111008, 0.04345540329813957, 0.025205211713910103, 0.01160405296832323, 0.0029668426141142845, 0.008126573637127876, 0.009253095835447311, 0.00745466910302639, 0.09134943038225174, -0.006234796717762947, -0.007585790473967791, 0.0260179340839386, -0.0016333903186023235, -0.002551701618358493, 0.04483756050467491, -0.004646697081625462, -0.048595987260341644, 0.05310351774096489, 0.028072182089090347, 0.034898243844509125, 0.04782018065452576, -0.007289656437933445, 0.017070665955543518, -0.039597008377313614, -0.025315558537840843, 0.05887829139828682, -0.043583862483501434, -0.00929922517389059, -0.05664309859275818, -0.007139578461647034, -0.01129206083714962, -0.01199311949312687, -0.034681446850299835, 0.05284298211336136, -0.0012643091613426805, 0.007491302210837603, -0.009691785089671612, 0.011653120629489422, -0.004004342015832663, -0.02748778462409973, 0.008978132158517838, 0.07120541483163834, 0.017847325652837753, -0.050472550094127655, 0.011995752342045307, -0.016095038503408432, -0.04491248354315758, 0.01303957775235176, 0.005156048573553562, -0.029868246987462044, -0.05195264145731926, 0.016353262588381767, -0.018443353474140167, -0.06388170272111893, 0.03984382748603821, 0.030598245561122894, -0.005167257972061634, 0.004482549149543047, -0.09008804708719254, -0.06634607911109924, -0.01574723795056343, 0.000955400406382978, 0.012367334216833115, -0.02161722257733345, -0.019615745171904564, 0.027657734230160713, 0.023062335327267647, 0.02277580089867115, 0.02179598994553089, 0.03613763675093651, 0.009529526345431805, 0.007670004386454821, -0.004750129301100969, 0.01727609522640705, -0.025440778583288193, 0.0018188217654824257, -0.002060725586488843, -0.08515563607215881, 0.01860174909234047, -0.0023849373683333397, 0.0029590274207293987, 0.012330385856330395, 0.027619706466794014, -0.011055557057261467, -0.016793303191661835, -0.047055549919605255, 0.014834124594926834, 0.0019617853686213493, 0.0759575292468071, 0.004827114753425121, 0.062026455998420715, 0.012758362106978893, -0.02384883351624012, -0.014252164401113987, 0.049689557403326035, 0.04453364014625549, 0.033885352313518524, -0.010411886498332024, -0.014391627162694931, -0.003184250555932522, 0.027351945638656616, 0.009590143337845802, -0.011810505762696266, -0.004220103845000267, 0.012196090072393417, 0.026472199708223343, -0.008009359240531921, 0.04929269105195999, 0.020304188132286072, -0.018995041027665138, 0.04106537625193596, -0.06377489119768143, -0.02423035353422165, -0.01851062849164009, 0.021098310127854347, -0.05865456908941269, 0.0017170666251331568, 0.03609234094619751, -0.005370780825614929, 0.02139310911297798, -0.014887865632772446, -0.041673459112644196, -0.01879112794995308, -0.02576747164130211, 0.04534493759274483, -0.05139245465397835, 0.004860209301114082, 0.05441019684076309, 0.012245286256074905, -0.044888317584991455, 0.03307567909359932, -0.04588482156395912, -0.08099240809679031, 0.0006416820106096566, -0.027125338092446327, 0.014927756041288376, -0.019843943417072296, -0.02085234969854355, 0.03192443400621414, -0.01962534710764885, -0.04698685556650162, 0.00254933163523674, -0.05504465848207474, 0.05652330443263054, 0.056617848575115204, -0.01431528851389885, -0.004157687537372112, 0.029879271984100342, -0.008236251771450043, 0.02980322390794754, -0.0012073734542354941, -0.024626273661851883, -0.0996197983622551, -0.05682727321982384, 0.06326339393854141, 0.03475387394428253, -0.030033569782972336, 0.012637751176953316, 0.009856234304606915, 0.03700488805770874, 0.025294048711657524, 0.005141462665051222, -0.0260130874812603, -0.013812828809022903, -0.015492413192987442, 0.040661536157131195, 0.01541162934154272, 0.00015421646821778268, 0.013913502916693687, 0.004255547653883696, 0.033954646438360214, -0.010394943878054619, -0.013663535937666893, 0.04325740039348602, 0.015810994431376457, 0.0025284718722105026, -0.018747316673398018, -0.032316215336322784, 0.020351756364107132, -0.0350327305495739, -0.012359386309981346, 0.027634432539343834, 0.02338309958577156, 0.01796206831932068, 0.012853825464844704, -0.015826497226953506, 0.036651212722063065, 0.01608836092054844, 0.006249257363379002, 0.007274150382727385, 0.009158930741250515, -0.02974126487970352, -0.010535536333918571, -0.00859823264181614, -0.04895862564444542, -0.02792196534574032, 0.027596978470683098, 0.016063811257481575, -0.000451848580269143, 0.0069525889120996, -0.012360832653939724, -0.01086714118719101, 0.012555545195937157, -0.002720674965530634, 0.0426594540476799, 0.016066264361143112, 0.012554679065942764, 0.03280847147107124, -0.01288516167551279, -0.042734503746032715, 0.04450080171227455, -0.002741825534030795, -0.014673925004899502, 0.0072435420006513596, 0.012356569059193134, -0.047974590212106705, -0.006831243168562651, -0.04479346424341202, 0.04972568154335022, -0.02521611750125885, 0.00500778341665864, 0.05651487410068512, -0.01946588233113289, -0.022873111069202423, 0.027238745242357254, -0.0028818845748901367, -0.054120566695928574, -0.047211967408657074, -0.01177956722676754, -0.004734788555651903, -0.020347826182842255, 0.006231235805898905, 0.052013080567121506, -0.013267314061522484, 0.005520029459148645, -0.05389149487018585, -0.045786142349243164, 0.041342008858919144, 0.029080014675855637, 0.04670477285981178, 0.042129188776016235, 0.02871324121952057, 0.10431256890296936, 0.0197401475161314, -0.028629830107092857, -0.008009371347725391, 0.006541286129504442, -0.009123115800321102, -0.02432921901345253, 0.017413562163710594, 0.023296989500522614, -0.011436346918344498, -0.0065596625208854675, -0.01569923758506775, 0.02998814359307289, 0.03311765566468239, 0.0048149386420845985, 0.00353858876042068, 0.051030319184064865, 0.02492353320121765, -0.010383103042840958, 0.025219399482011795, 0.024171732366085052, -0.014547541737556458, -0.007509313058108091, -0.0024275497999042273, -0.002239770023152232, 0.0236718337982893, -0.04096418619155884, 0.02811872586607933, -0.03865635395050049, -0.00914920587092638, -0.03181477263569832, 0.019215267151594162, 0.00577585119754076, -0.04861989617347717, 0.015945637598633766, 0.03950418159365654, 0.01879124902188778, 0.0027723340317606926, -0.004016736522316933, 0.04047666862607002, 0.039110612124204636, -0.022810835391283035, -0.01583794876933098, -0.012757819145917892, 0.0006637853221036494, 0.04483354464173317, -0.03208240866661072, 0.013296126388013363, 0.03842777758836746, 0.0531100332736969, 0.01632673665881157, 0.010765038430690765, -0.05475296452641487, 0.02753855101764202, -0.07351525872945786, 0.018671220168471336, -0.03289923444390297, 0.07790069282054901, 0.029917173087596893, 0.024794217199087143, 0.03620683401823044, -0.000647355685941875, 0.013153424486517906, 0.02078954130411148, -0.06838610768318176, 0.007858000695705414, -0.021723449230194092, 0.0013778975699096918, -0.031513988971710205, -0.0182716753333807, 0.03146211802959442, -0.033150143921375275, -0.014789417386054993, -0.052293561398983, 0.01644592173397541, -0.022903820499777794, 0.006247640121728182, 0.009732993319630623, -0.04457235708832741, -0.015244383364915848, 0.014993544667959213, -0.010394494980573654, 0.011576244607567787, -0.001741228741593659, -0.003953240811824799, 0.010212019085884094, -0.04947382211685181, -0.031078997999429703, -0.00778305483981967, -0.008252246305346489, 0.056414950639009476, 0.011695313267409801, 0.024579398334026337, -0.06987261772155762, 0.0552237294614315, -0.021272078156471252, 0.043072011321783066, 0.008668707683682442, -0.03942440450191498, -0.0018150811083614826, -0.08503339439630508, -0.03692646697163582, 0.03467664122581482, 0.010152901522815228, 0.01911764219403267, 0.0021546795032918453, 0.023832881823182106, 0.017168274149298668, -0.06564667075872421, -0.022702760994434357, 0.06839674711227417, 0.00010746817133622244, -0.004311484284698963, -0.018769148737192154, -0.0015839876141399145, -0.020028207451105118, 0.00003317041773698293, 0.027638858184218407, -0.0094760125502944, -0.020330915227532387, -0.015608505345880985, 0.030659392476081848, -0.019506866112351418, -0.008336154744029045, -0.03646179661154747, 0.04401266202330589, 0.0733085423707962, 0.015067150816321373, -0.016895612701773643, -0.0024889048654586077, 0.02682551182806492, 0.08733748644590378, -0.0026617685798555613, -0.0015299979131668806, -0.08398507535457611, 0.015950622037053108, 0.040340449661016464, 0.01358597818762064, -0.03657960519194603, -0.0012893954990431666, -0.02984822914004326, -0.0024515590630471706, 0.025683673098683357, -0.02802666835486889, -0.004839340224862099, -0.010715204291045666, -0.03895409032702446, -0.009704961441457272, -0.05925361439585686, -0.025662286207079887, 0.014777788892388344, -0.02644832246005535, 0.04347381368279457, -0.035112302750349045, -0.02733403444290161, -0.05038704723119736, 0.009076789021492004, -0.008791238069534302, 0.058290619403123856, -0.010406729765236378, -0.004065479151904583, -0.008506523445248604, 0.024541011080145836, -0.02100077085196972, -0.06896238029003143, -0.012886098586022854, 0.03970445320010185, -0.01410695444792509, 0.00026895501650869846, -0.017624318599700928, -0.0561363659799099, 0.0006662555388174951, 0.0031696471851319075, -0.0684553012251854, -0.004050508141517639, 0.02569016069173813, 0.007153993472456932, 0.037579819560050964, 0.012528321705758572, 0.04631407558917999, 0.016441144049167633, 0.02151607908308506, -0.011036185547709465, -0.024314608424901962, 0.03612656146287918, -0.05406631529331207, -0.007750629913061857, -0.016688724979758263, -0.010763704776763916, -0.005774117074906826, 0.04463104158639908, 0.002326234010979533, 0.04889155924320221, -0.006951428018510342, -0.02399243414402008, -0.01463479083031416, 0.005885507445782423, -0.027976524084806442, -0.02985161915421486, 0.05871111899614334, 0.03516374155879021, 0.009311330504715443, 0.009336899034678936, 0.00384337455034256, 0.02552005834877491, 0.005111502483487129, 0.002752682426944375, -0.06468278169631958, -0.00468506058678031, -0.06516475230455399, -0.02551741525530815, 0.022692274302244186, -0.025761671364307404, 0.06989281624555588, 0.022157803177833557, 0.043349023908376694, 0.008853862062096596, -0.027917176485061646, -0.0052259196527302265, -0.0073914965614676476, -0.004037266131490469, 0.03250998631119728, -0.033426132053136826, 0.017368419095873833, -0.01413570437580347, 0.0033924959134310484, -0.06138284131884575, -0.05092589557170868, 0.04254896193742752, 0.005815271288156509, -0.03190382942557335, -0.060532499104738235, 0.03993495553731918, -0.019058236852288246, -0.020711787045001984, -0.0004093587049283087, 0.06882847845554352, -0.015538562089204788, -0.0018355570500716567, -0.009464144706726074, 0.03237512335181236, 0.05153530091047287, -0.05187400430440903, 0.021540110930800438, -0.010974576696753502, 0.013205217197537422, 0.010597696527838707, 0.005998516455292702, 0.024385379627346992, -0.0401933416724205, -0.0037811091169714928, -0.041227374225854874, 0.04124993085861206, 0.030479291453957558, -0.02048240788280964, 0.010975094512104988, 0.0389682836830616, -0.04648387059569359, -0.015615705400705338, -0.03320974111557007, 0.009848225861787796, 0.028079736977815628, -0.003378599649295211, -0.03282636031508446, 0.018994564190506935, 0.004691978916525841, 0.007058955729007721, 0.03328729420900345, 0.013751976191997528, 0.04697171598672867, 0.023459583520889282, 0.04078930616378784, -0.02830358035862446, 0.0216654185205698, 0.02131093293428421, -0.05481352284550667, 0.03711327910423279, 0.01337498240172863, 0.028467632830142975, 0.022202113643288612, 0.008854296989738941, -0.042681436985731125, -0.011286057531833649, -0.04301106557250023, -0.01819467358291149, 0.030267024412751198, 0.02168205939233303, 0.05747482553124428, 0.07638736814260483, 0.02018290013074875, -0.00145521922968328, -0.07330084592103958, -0.0504726767539978, -0.013186641037464142, 0.012177035212516785, 0.025433585047721863, 0.02555392123758793, 0.03020114079117775, 0.04168451949954033, 0.0016065031522884965, 0.02402927540242672, 0.03157447651028633, -0.005689132027328014, 0.03360152989625931, 0.026449281722307205, -0.09173326194286346, -0.05090843141078949, 0.007558143697679043, -0.034548770636320114, 0.016939053311944008, 0.0034034480340778828, 0.0010536195477470756, 0.06362742185592651, 0.010525623336434364, 0.009396671317517757, -0.05230153724551201, -0.00022830413945484906, -0.042543213814496994, 0.036612942814826965, 0.020166469737887383, -0.0013087866827845573, 0.016689948737621307, -0.007754309102892876, 0.028840024024248123, -0.03451640531420708, 0.007306886836886406, -0.001634943182580173, -0.0823478177189827, -0.03453778848052025, -0.027455974370241165, -0.031969454139471054, 0.046803612262010574, 0.025775056332349777, -0.05138789117336273, -0.008483397774398327, -0.03900865837931633, 0.03655064105987549, 0.03318507969379425, 0.05035400390625, -0.019605381414294243, 0.05205824226140976, -0.010468840599060059, 0.008829385042190552, 0.0034163142554461956, -0.010020919144153595, 0.13067765533924103, 0.05454915389418602, 0.06408379971981049, -0.06564554572105408, 0.006221003830432892, -0.03658813238143921, -0.00009925764607032761, 0.0042381202802062035, -0.01910366676747799, -0.007149178069084883, 0.004803348798304796, 0.013165267184376717, 0.023552190512418747, 0.03390256687998772, -0.027967577800154686, 0.04907531663775444, -0.02609805390238762, 0.013235077261924744, 0.010313805192708969, 0.01163325272500515, 0.004125550389289856, -0.007181012537330389, -0.044369809329509735, 0.025233019143342972, 0.01710856333374977, 0.008750232867896557, -0.005333786830306053, -0.020282242447137833, 0.015085809864103794, -0.035910896956920624, 0.014204936102032661, -0.0037629215512424707, 0.0010190606117248535, -0.03182053193449974, -0.0006356077501550317, 0.01666438579559326, 0.013456479646265507, -0.037853341549634933, -0.011472774669528008, 0.017799243330955505, 0.002602159045636654, -0.016945917159318924, -0.007246461696922779, 0.006879589986056089, -0.03234900161623955, -0.0515834242105484, -0.06229153648018837, 0.029297027736902237, -0.048410385847091675, 0.00576358288526535, 0.01813036948442459, 0.009141404181718826, 0.0008263146737590432, -0.029780780896544456, -0.021302979439496994, 0.021072549745440483, 0.04361497610807419, 0.001972659956663847, 0.008797179907560349, -0.018745267763733864, 0.05448183789849281, -0.0016659102402627468, 0.0028636043425649405, -0.0014419277431443334, -0.010915825143456459, -0.01947609893977642, -0.019551100209355354, 0.030884645879268646, 0.009132909588515759, 0.010659311898052692, 0.01261274516582489, 0.00935123860836029, -0.01331073697656393, 0.008612999692559242, 0.006310849450528622, 0.010403383523225784, 0.0266254972666502, -0.01547055784612894, -0.023500995710492134, -0.05383702740073204, -0.040245238691568375, -0.014615993946790695, -0.03600860387086868, 0.026653608307242393, -0.04203645884990692, 0.011889384128153324, 0.04553062841296196, 0.006254060659557581, 0.04946918413043022, 0.02791544422507286, 0.002356907119974494, 0.005631130188703537, 0.005417560692876577, -0.027080457657575607, -0.013510150834918022, -0.006882438436150551, -0.03294268995523453, -0.005234542768448591, 0.020917603746056557, 0.05509709194302559, 0.05709837004542351, -0.009952744469046593, -0.009426094591617584, 0.019076436758041382, 0.0017089411849156022, 0.04306167736649513, -0.003597743809223175, -0.03723610192537308, -0.012138262391090393, -0.04725762456655502, 0.012662200257182121, -0.07371252030134201, 0.0014107954921200871, -0.0357927642762661, -0.025274725630879402, 0.003842244390398264, 0.0012637543259188533, -0.009267965331673622, 0.030435392633080482, -0.02079404890537262, 0.050038933753967285, -0.02934110537171364, -0.01570737548172474, -0.033097609877586365, -0.035671595484018326, -0.03430965542793274, -0.03161613643169403, -0.008989627473056316, -0.004005854949355125, 0.00042517221299931407, -0.004731235560029745, 0.034731607884168625, 0.020579123869538307, -0.01782982237637043, 0.029273610562086105, 0.005065164063125849, -0.0555267296731472, 0.022556627169251442, -0.04094128683209419, -0.045307934284210205, 0.018904291093349457, -0.023937910795211792, 0.014660930261015892, 0.03905651345849037, -0.0075245085172355175, 0.02218213677406311, 0.006058960221707821, -0.007181941065937281, -0.02496681548655033, 0.02305171638727188, 0.004719666205346584, -0.03169906884431839, -0.014876207336783409, 0.03712749853730202, 0.027984613552689552, 0.03142223507165909, 0.06742590665817261, 0.008493664674460888, -0.005012050736695528, 0.008955482393503189, 0.0006946137873455882, 0.03115902468562126, -0.008093463256955147, 0.02814018353819847, -0.028695544227957726, 0.012126578949391842, 0.006370679009705782, 0.01414506882429123, 0.048375193029642105, 0.038361094892024994, -0.03626377508044243, 0.04948900267481804, -0.009382732212543488, 0.0049447123892605305, -0.09601671993732452, -0.02044459991157055, 0.053935419768095016, -0.003429899225011468, 0.01644173450767994, -0.09233424812555313, -0.003733416087925434, 0.01045258529484272, -0.07675324380397797, 0.03639627993106842, 0.010461433790624142, -0.036824148148298264, -0.013142145238816738, 0.025262754410505295, -0.025138113647699356, 0.011369043961167336, 0.001633829204365611, 0.018264783546328545, 0.0036851405166089535, 0.0251922644674778, -0.016206489875912666, 0.004353554453700781, -0.031218593940138817, 0.016759946942329407, 0.0036150554660707712, -0.04286659508943558, 0.015783635899424553, -0.04397841542959213, -0.04771967977285385, 0.03791160508990288, 0.017199192196130753, 0.0387270450592041, 0.03805191442370415, 0.005413752980530262, 0.013255191966891289, 0.006570279132574797, 0.04069329425692558, -0.017043741419911385, -0.011956647969782352, 0.02343498170375824, 0.026094840839505196, 0.02370019629597664, -0.014461340382695198, 0.024654893204569817, 0.00584048219025135, -0.023051731288433075, -0.026896391063928604, 0.016574295237660408, -0.030948445200920105, -0.044098950922489166, -0.0012965787900611758, 0.008391516283154488, -0.023468662053346634, 0.004438256379216909, -0.012984220869839191, -0.04567800462245941, -0.029548633843660355, 0.03799358010292053, -0.0027398583479225636, -0.00548730231821537, 0.04095768555998802, -0.01251913234591484, -0.03712557256221771, 0.015638690441846848, -0.018122728914022446, -0.011371167376637459, -0.01872638612985611, 0.021523281931877136, 0.0054350560531020164, 0.0074236104264855385, -0.022229967638850212, -0.01757398061454296, -0.004914355929940939, 0.029047762975096703, -0.005515063647180796, 0.03709446266293526, 0.001335592707619071, -0.026288775727152824, 0.0049668424762785435, -0.06601490825414658, 0.05390727519989014, -0.011283334344625473, -0.050187673419713974, -0.007818922400474548, 0.006338577717542648, -0.028763340786099434, -0.03469479829072952, 0.06561583280563354, -0.01759093627333641, 0.039921440184116364, -0.05682274326682091, 0.02335732989013195, -0.0049976566806435585, -0.03818505257368088, 0.02563622035086155, -0.014551554806530476, -0.04255182668566704, -0.005473956000059843, -0.01136002317070961, -0.00791563093662262, -0.02325921319425106, 0.010067494586110115, -0.02475670911371708, 0.02538098208606243, 0.003017963143065572, -0.0021568622905761003, 0.04322623088955879, 0.0012466242769733071, 0.040727898478507996, 0.03783334419131279, -0.002806834178045392, 0.01922881416976452, -0.014490500092506409, 0.015630682930350304, -0.0032621363643556833, 0.01763596013188362, -0.04139511287212372, -0.025343982502818108, -0.00987209752202034, 0.008591915480792522, 0.03649241849780083, -0.051960136741399765, 0.006788249127566814, 0.021295970305800438, 0.0026269720401614904, 0.019037259742617607, 0.029902298003435135, 0.020776860415935516, 0.02727627009153366, 0.021977007389068604, 0.001440293388441205, -0.011427436955273151, -0.016598260030150414, -0.0029860257636755705, 0.01623550057411194, 0.036684151738882065, -0.014360452070832253, 0.04159969836473465, 0.009863793849945068, -0.02935655415058136, 0.04343956336379051, -0.007710149511694908, 0.047416314482688904, -0.05120440199971199, 0.012858320958912373, 0.02136007696390152, 0.0071221101097762585, -0.014693628065288067, 0.02910996414721012, -0.04528123885393143, 0.06191127747297287, -0.02719493955373764, 0.00008732916467124596, -0.03744957968592644, -0.015976758673787117, -0.011180045083165169, 0.0052214511670172215, -0.05409039929509163, 0.06244071573019028, 0.011274058371782303, 0.03266537934541702, 0.0186653733253479, 0.011327790096402168, 0.027662677690386772, 0.03505973890423775, 0.02935992367565632, -0.010945932008326054, -0.009160292334854603, 0.024643640965223312, -0.016783632338047028, -0.019086772575974464, -0.02955603040754795, -0.021188581362366676, 0.07435688376426697, 0.035921186208724976, 0.0021588425152003765, -0.03514552861452103, 0.002195450011640787, 0.035855554044246674, -0.09071304649114609, -0.01126838382333517, -0.04507558047771454, 0.01010782178491354, -0.007618322968482971, -0.024470850825309753 ]
<p>I have a data table T1, that contains nearly a thousand variables (V1) and around 200 million data points. The data is sparse and most of the entries are NA. Each datapoints have a unique id and date pair to distinguish from another.</p> <p>I have another table T2, which contains a separate set of variables (V2). This table also has id and date pair that uniquely identify entries in T2. </p> <p>We suspect that the data in T1 can be used to predict values of variables in T2. </p> <p>To prove this, I thought to apply 'glm' model in R and check if we can really find some variable in T2 that is dependent on variables in T1. </p> <p>For each variable in T2, I started pulling out all data in T1 having same id and date pair which resulted in much smaller ~50K data points for some of test variables. </p> <p>The problems that I am facing now with application of glm is as follows. </p> <ol> <li><p>In some cases, it shows me an error 'fit not found' and warning 'glm.fit: algorithm did not converge '. I am not sure why is it shown? </p></li> <li><p>How the NAs are treated in glm? Does it remove all records involving 'NA' first and then perform fitting?</p></li> <li><p>Is it a good strategy to remove all NAs first and then call 'glm'. I fear that this may reduce the datapoints significantly as most of them are NAs. </p></li> <li><p>Which method is used to calculate the coefficients. I couldnot find any website or paper or book that discuss how the output is calculated.</p></li> </ol> <p>I tested glm with and without 'NAs' and found difft answers which points that NAs are considered while fitting the data:</p> <p>Example 1:</p> <pre><code>&gt; tmpData x1 x2 x3 Y 1 1 1 1 3 2 1 0 4 5 3 1 2 3 6 4 0 3 1 4 Call: glm(formula = as.formula(paste(dep, " ~ ", paste(xn, collapse = "+"))), na.action = na.exclude) Coefficients: (Intercept) as.numeric(unlist(tmpData["x1"])) as.numeric(unlist(tmpData["x2"])) 5.551e-16 1.000e+00 1.000e+00 as.numeric(unlist(tmpData["x3"])) 1.000e+00 Degrees of Freedom: 3 Total (i.e. Null); 0 Residual Null Deviance: 5 Residual Deviance: 9.861e-31 AIC: -260.6 </code></pre> <p>Example 2:</p> <pre><code>'x1' 'x2' 'x3' 'Y' 100000 1 NA 2 1 1 1 3 1 NA -1124 2 1 0 4 5 1 2 3 6 0 3 1 4 Coefficients: (Intercept) as.numeric(unlist(tmpData["x1"])) as.numeric(unlist(tmpData["x2"])) as.numeric(unlist(tmpData["x3"])) -2.3749044 -0.0000625 0.6249899 1.8749937 Degrees of Freedom: 5 Total (i.e. Null); 2 Residual Null Deviance: 13.33 Residual Deviance: 1.875 AIC: 20.05 </code></pre>
73,388
[ -0.023019447922706604, 0.04705878719687462, 0.022448554635047913, -0.0035344534553587437, 0.04739803075790405, 0.014953594654798508, -0.01356644369661808, -0.04772266373038292, 0.014959010295569897, -0.0037175228353589773, 0.015518644824624062, 0.04582252725958824, 0.028456876054406166, -0.005807268898934126, 0.022294210270047188, 0.01862979494035244, -0.010454398579895496, 0.006785116624087095, 0.002419210271909833, -0.012193500064313412, -0.004819607827812433, 0.031208962202072144, -0.02101866528391838, -0.029371803626418114, -0.028903568163514137, 0.054628778249025345, -0.009649168699979782, -0.016090190038084984, 0.0004501245857682079, 0.07353344559669495, -0.042761776596307755, -0.045558325946331024, -0.005428614094853401, 0.01873636059463024, -0.02650076150894165, 0.0006293805781751871, 0.015370385721325874, -0.0373399555683136, -0.002187900710850954, 0.049622438848018646, 0.005404483526945114, -0.008868212811648846, -0.030601125210523605, 0.05953265354037285, 0.01333738025277853, 0.028729824349284172, 0.02896151691675186, 0.00696089630946517, 0.02781057171523571, -0.029543336480855942, 0.03784371167421341, -0.025764605030417442, 0.05471579357981682, 0.020058682188391685, -0.006896667182445526, -0.004881714005023241, 0.04243522509932518, 0.05417913571000099, -0.010631018318235874, -0.038603588938713074, -0.011394495144486427, -0.033624254167079926, 0.016699783504009247, -0.022059373557567596, -0.006885509006679058, 0.03199639543890953, 0.011165366508066654, -0.002472764579579234, 0.005912536755204201, -0.04247777536511421, 0.027489615604281425, -0.005559437442570925, 0.01934981532394886, 0.00974410679191351, 0.004539203830063343, -0.010644293390214443, -0.004148733802139759, -0.025733251124620438, 0.06087839603424072, 0.009370817802846432, -0.00011658319272100925, 0.019670428708195686, 0.02959701605141163, 0.03468547388911247, 0.022331025451421738, -0.017623817548155785, 0.04555901512503624, -0.042519234120845795, 0.014860362745821476, 0.0006000440334901214, -0.020734624937176704, 0.042751286178827286, 0.04345657303929329, 0.03761548921465874, -0.02898152731359005, 0.056520089507102966, -0.005508599802851677, 0.014719031751155853, 0.02397824451327324, -0.0019418381853029132, -0.048551321029663086, -0.03845909982919693, 0.0037690221797674894, 0.03709124028682709, -0.021344443783164024, -0.024767311289906502, -0.019608428701758385, -0.0031207117717713118, -0.02396097220480442, -0.034145236015319824, -0.004736994858831167, 0.030626371502876282, 0.03481348603963852, -0.039107099175453186, 0.008145039901137352, -0.03214285522699356, 0.014776937663555145, -0.018818756565451622, 0.051633745431900024, 0.07896541804075241, 0.037569042295217514, -0.016947446390986443, -0.0061637465842068195, -0.024187592789530754, -0.032417841255664825, -0.0061171893030405045, -0.0010319161228835583, 0.004404611885547638, -0.04026840999722481, 0.03399195894598961, 0.0031734704971313477, -0.017774831503629684, 0.06183309853076935, -0.0227194931358099, 0.030439913272857666, 0.01519002579152584, -0.05576396360993385, -0.05867292732000351, 0.04182395339012146, -0.07086487859487534, 0.0473710335791111, -0.016019059345126152, 0.017455903813242912, -0.0204012468457222, 0.05057162791490555, 0.006860050372779369, 0.03333605080842972, 0.03934565186500549, 0.008952639065682888, -0.004808251745998859, -0.03162422031164169, -0.025145122781395912, -0.02427370846271515, -0.00003753730925382115, -0.028531016781926155, -0.06195222958922386, 0.02831513248383999, 0.03583265095949173, -0.02668907679617405, 0.006876446306705475, 0.00708002271130681, 0.05523072928190231, -0.03432163968682289, 0.019999034702777863, 0.02964356355369091, -0.03789592161774635, 0.0653868243098259, -0.0035313591361045837, 0.01586207002401352, 0.06458680331707001, -0.03626503422856331, 0.06301161646842957, 0.03575041890144348, 0.04252384603023529, 0.04018818959593773, 0.008916552178561687, 0.0011753892758861184, -0.010691183619201183, 0.01657160185277462, 0.016185671091079712, -0.021235216408967972, -0.0203277375549078, -0.028484823182225227, -0.021898368373513222, 0.045544110238552094, 0.04844723269343376, 0.006986456923186779, -0.0016658732201904058, 0.0661364197731018, -0.058199651539325714, -0.0392913781106472, -0.032873161137104034, -0.0137457475066185, -0.005561157129704952, -0.008804277516901493, -0.015528308227658272, -0.007166360039263964, 0.032709695398807526, 0.03702586516737938, -0.04279200732707977, -0.031835488975048065, -0.021577587351202965, 0.038371726870536804, -0.025005701929330826, 0.0004990918678231537, 0.04636388644576073, 0.05512415990233421, -0.03593481332063675, 0.03742986544966698, -0.04031545668840408, -0.039422448724508286, 0.04159824550151825, -0.05104568973183632, 0.007480963598936796, -0.029795225709676743, -0.021000249311327934, 0.011742210946977139, 0.02573770470917225, -0.04018021374940872, 0.03981367498636246, -0.06602801382541656, 0.02817094512283802, 0.048428189009428024, 0.004723315127193928, 0.018257038667798042, 0.014464756473898888, -0.011902389116585255, 0.009495878592133522, -0.005069540813565254, 0.021877799183130264, -0.07886071503162384, -0.06009630486369133, 0.04657043144106865, 0.055534232407808304, -0.008035100996494293, 0.0014203868340700865, 0.03858484327793121, -0.007934543304145336, 0.021598761901259422, 0.01384698785841465, -0.004390427377074957, -0.025620238855481148, 0.012100339867174625, -0.0021101017482578754, 0.001023947959765792, 0.018857317045331, 0.01763222925364971, 0.004491664934903383, 0.0325276255607605, -0.018050706014037132, 0.0023563296999782324, 0.07076417654752731, 0.03608587384223938, -0.037461649626493454, -0.007266441360116005, -0.028928518295288086, 0.05261027067899704, -0.010628143325448036, -0.0027335803024470806, 0.0297755915671587, 0.018527090549468994, -0.009648111648857594, -0.015971766784787178, 0.014999507926404476, 0.008280587382614613, 0.028644507750868797, -0.029665427282452583, -0.008962581865489483, 0.02662067674100399, -0.061436306685209274, 0.0327751450240612, -0.026088692247867584, -0.0637989193201065, -0.06902974843978882, 0.03206460922956467, 0.0028312569484114647, -0.009757187217473984, 0.0060774190351367, -0.03513757139444351, 0.01518311258405447, -0.020216993987560272, -0.026577701792120934, -0.0023574403021484613, 0.006804535631090403, -0.026220407336950302, -0.0005928787286393344, -0.03770509362220764, -0.01734398677945137, 0.01930658146739006, -0.03037280961871147, -0.016050158068537712, 0.04573596641421318, -0.0176556333899498, -0.0529480054974556, -0.03737901523709297, -0.02251480519771576, -0.0033344076946377754, -0.040635351091623306, -0.06327766925096512, 0.009533361531794071, 0.029298340901732445, -0.03373730927705765, -0.028255539014935493, -0.04325123131275177, -0.024888409301638603, -0.01585441082715988, 0.011337492614984512, 0.04740201309323311, 0.0067528230138123035, -0.013001478277146816, 0.024839069694280624, -0.031161578372120857, 0.011453721672296524, -0.05536332353949547, -0.019127119332551956, 0.04408806189894676, 0.0002985969476867467, 0.03627020865678787, -0.002846142975613475, -0.023923853412270546, 0.05419245734810829, 0.04587557539343834, -0.02022101916372776, -0.02158466726541519, -0.007670655380934477, -0.029932299628853798, -0.042186904698610306, 0.04497596621513367, -0.0069974251091480255, 0.049519896507263184, 0.018430808559060097, -0.03705241531133652, 0.007513049989938736, 0.0533878318965435, 0.006544069852679968, 0.02359987050294876, 0.016675038263201714, -0.0017637483542785048, -0.024278899654746056, 0.011714075691998005, 0.002100634854286909, -0.021707525476813316, 0.04175904393196106, -0.012211251072585583, 0.02770201303064823, -0.00696454057469964, -0.05993706360459328, 0.0033267142716795206, -0.015776747837662697, 0.07532474398612976, -0.035915400832891464, 0.005590131040662527, -0.006153050810098648, -0.021971259266138077, 0.01408963743597269, 0.01765928603708744, 0.03910484537482262, -0.015066134743392467, 0.02228797785937786, 0.05765032023191452, -0.00993120577186346, -0.014742404222488403, 0.03442317619919777, -0.01588558591902256, -0.010800198651850224, -0.005129254423081875, -0.06215610355138779, -0.00897897407412529, 0.02970404177904129, 0.05181249603629112, -0.0026310612447559834, -0.03034786321222782, -0.026720363646745682, 0.001217978773638606, -0.05054429918527603, 0.005758353043347597, -0.018252741545438766, 0.05473388358950615, 0.007521956227719784, 0.03772151842713356, 0.021296242251992226, 0.029603518545627594, 0.013422503136098385, -0.02054179459810257, -0.07324615865945816, -0.006645429413765669, -0.014673387631773949, -0.03250620514154434, 0.026166893541812897, -0.04388446360826492, 0.045198772102594376, -0.005017186515033245, -0.0002994830720126629, -0.007380696479231119, 0.039174292236566544, -0.029296686872839928, 0.023431669920682907, -0.02657967060804367, -0.0099593885242939, -0.05489802733063698, 0.02240697294473648, 0.029345912858843803, -0.009113353677093983, 0.023988027125597, 0.054152101278305054, 0.015724647790193558, -0.009041447192430496, -0.04963715746998787, 0.009689888916909695, 0.02877945639193058, 0.04493186995387077, 0.024755768477916718, 0.030108990147709846, -0.04638773575425148, 0.009983992204070091, 0.03152039274573326, 0.013810459524393082, 0.02940860204398632, 0.002049599541351199, -0.04025566205382347, -0.025728201493620872, -0.0027293956372886896, 0.0082192188128829, 0.017990387976169586, 0.021374475210905075, 0.00029622321017086506, 0.07194135338068008, 0.029886282980442047, -0.019719410687685013, 0.0018734022742137313, 0.05165564641356468, 0.023336637765169144, 0.01792089082300663, -0.0013258105609565973, -0.01498541608452797, -0.012238210067152977, 0.022286634892225266, 0.032138098031282425, -0.028384169563651085, -0.0021630199626088142, -0.027668792754411697, 0.036015890538692474, -0.01580396108329296, -0.020087871700525284, 0.016104066744446754, 0.05657767504453659, 0.056986041367053986, 0.0014376383041962981, -0.03618493303656578, 0.023955773562192917, 0.055915795266628265, 0.018480544909834862, 0.003236685646697879, 0.025530720129609108, -0.10089854151010513, -0.01550122257322073, 0.03960747271776199, 0.04901381582021713, -0.03906802833080292, -0.0029933496844023466, -0.035430580377578735, -0.010981922969222069, 0.006720250938087702, 0.006737081333994865, 0.032694313675165176, -0.016152136027812958, 0.01603328064084053, -0.0410877950489521, -0.024725066497921944, -0.047415316104888916, 0.0013534296303987503, -0.05352948233485222, 0.03198784589767456, -0.006099484860897064, -0.03425011411309242, -0.020978428423404694, 0.003405757248401642, -0.006235175766050816, 0.027712861075997353, -0.00968906469643116, -0.0295264832675457, 0.05669450759887695, 0.04809283837676048, -0.025754351168870926, -0.015210497193038464, 0.0014567316975444555, -0.03770420327782631, -0.03355398774147034, 0.011818207800388336, -0.012986090034246445, -0.029880866408348083, 0.006366008426994085, 0.021952897310256958, 0.01657560095191002, -0.0013776394771412015, -0.024189479649066925, 0.0075231390073895454, 0.016547152772545815, -0.030507247895002365, 0.056599706411361694, 0.02714274451136589, 0.007693442050367594, 0.0223613940179348, -0.03852182999253273, -0.03333626314997673, -0.05409408360719681, -0.05272146686911583, -0.04171187803149223, 0.0035103855188935995, -0.01039851550012827, 0.021612562239170074, -0.022995922714471817, 0.02240188606083393, -0.004438693169504404, 0.018212366849184036, 0.021349970251321793, 0.06155549734830856, -0.018567431718111038, -0.0026446429546922445, -0.014721190556883812, 0.025583509355783463, -0.0023689144290983677, -0.015188375487923622, 0.011172663420438766, -0.007386739831417799, -0.010552779771387577, -0.01945563033223152, -0.00850893184542656, 0.01526368223130703, -0.0409393347799778, 0.013244740664958954, 0.008505593053996563, 0.012977922335267067, 0.005460700020194054, 0.014056210406124592, 0.028774132952094078, 0.002174954628571868, -0.046747397631406784, -0.026240339502692223, 0.028651965782046318, -0.0007554951007477939, 0.008862145245075226, -0.007158498279750347, 0.04685140773653984, -0.04112149029970169, -0.017475003376603127, -0.037326354533433914, -0.019650422036647797, 0.009786292910575867, -0.03351099416613579, -0.043431807309389114, -0.04028574377298355, -0.00018400409317109734, -0.029424967244267464, 0.01737375371158123, -0.012239889241755009, 0.05921487137675285, -0.02218623086810112, -0.004557994659990072, 0.0018465898465365171, 0.03479713946580887, 0.05307486280798912, -0.020652033388614655, -0.009191394783556461, -0.0051006777212023735, -0.0012163878418505192, -0.016766732558608055, -0.0031632548198103905, 0.0009341953555122018, -0.025734392926096916, -0.011477252468466759, -0.045214347541332245, -0.015819642692804337, 0.04625122249126434, 0.001869618776254356, -0.015410134568810463, -0.005354052875190973, 0.004016687627881765, -0.013965814374387264, -0.03459286317229271, 0.01601104810833931, -0.0008100706618279219, 0.010444000363349915, -0.008833244442939758, 0.005147480871528387, 0.0023801932111382484, -0.03827577084302902, 0.04132379591464996, -0.023659598082304, 0.006780247204005718, 0.015526136383414268, 0.037386201322078705, -0.012484780512750149, 0.02622441202402115, -0.023629458621144295, -0.023424893617630005, 0.07902512699365616, 0.015575920231640339, 0.017245370894670486, -0.0056959111243486404, 0.06868673861026764, -0.04687333106994629, -0.025049326941370964, -0.02443111501634121, 0.00914206262677908, 0.04170471057295799, 0.01619686745107174, 0.029975421726703644, 0.05639014393091202, 0.004410129971802235, 0.0006968319648876786, -0.06851746141910553, 0.020688127726316452, 0.003484665183350444, 0.0018986420473083854, 0.04887812212109566, 0.008030042052268982, -0.04072975739836693, 0.02905181236565113, -0.03236645832657814, 0.03981195390224457, 0.030392710119485855, -0.024817829951643944, -0.01740778610110283, -0.005865186452865601, -0.03945690765976906, -0.030834602192044258, 0.013335616327822208, -0.030960015952587128, -0.003686058335006237, -0.015838049352169037, -0.03745574504137039, 0.017719928175210953, 0.01301987748593092, 0.046382348984479904, -0.050798796117305756, -0.03680501878261566, -0.07883333414793015, 0.0047953869216144085, 0.04497838392853737, -0.008471191860735416, 0.03379395231604576, 0.04291030764579773, 0.02981715463101864, -0.01659587025642395, 0.01862289570271969, -0.029624460265040398, -0.06684119999408722, -0.034339237958192825, -0.02292327769100666, -0.01662093959748745, 0.04837661236524582, -0.028217097744345665, -0.024775534868240356, 0.010499532334506512, -0.05320006236433983, -0.02629845216870308, 0.01377454400062561, 0.04709840565919876, 0.0032662739977240562, 0.06845664232969284, -0.011875397525727749, -0.0048008933663368225, -0.005884802900254726, -0.0038151175249367952, 0.1511271446943283, 0.09142592549324036, 0.021810349076986313, -0.04907521605491638, -0.0035426681861281395, 0.020797019824385643, -0.03180430456995964, -0.04908980056643486, -0.00024219129409175366, 0.009623698890209198, -0.009231535717844963, 0.06787661463022232, 0.025296002626419067, 0.012460140511393547, -0.04050321877002716, 0.029988978058099747, -0.02926022559404373, -0.03667093813419342, 0.010719808749854565, -0.0018009712221100926, -0.003640533657744527, -0.00667050015181303, -0.017989300191402435, 0.010905031114816666, 0.020693650469183922, -0.026049964129924774, 0.008069626055657864, 0.022785475477576256, -0.014191020280122757, -0.019010484218597412, -0.038559865206480026, 0.01173266489058733, 0.008038162253797054, 0.03777037933468819, -0.006685230880975723, 0.01931879110634327, -0.002211306942626834, -0.05296234041452408, 0.004335691686719656, 0.05130167677998543, 0.0005910488544031978, 0.0000436438167525921, -0.008293019607663155, -0.004853882361203432, -0.034941416233778, -0.01720810867846012, -0.03655892238020897, 0.053919486701488495, 0.014609226956963539, -0.04038282856345177, -0.0013834370765835047, -0.0137493796646595, 0.023366892710328102, -0.026618266478180885, 0.001069815014488995, 0.04646190628409386, 0.02648228034377098, -0.007925513200461864, -0.012892592698335648, -0.03320655599236488, 0.0037370827049016953, -0.0034454085398465395, 0.012462751939892769, 0.02992197498679161, -0.00534571660682559, 0.011141421273350716, -0.000705718994140625, 0.08240152150392532, 0.009882031939923763, 0.05153479799628258, -0.016295725479722023, 0.018083777278661728, -0.0086800716817379, -0.049261413514614105, 0.01813427358865738, 0.01830720156431198, -0.00012911010708194226, -0.015566693618893623, 0.019200453534722328, -0.036840055137872696, -0.04732263833284378, 0.02095009759068489, -0.0030197459273040295, 0.009978639893233776, -0.07048394531011581, 0.0016472490970045328, 0.020779699087142944, 0.03212627023458481, 0.04886937513947487, 0.013754548504948616, -0.02792753465473652, 0.05744636803865433, -0.006310807541012764, -0.03179053217172623, -0.04036474972963333, -0.02763008512556553, -0.019541161134839058, 0.0046686031855642796, 0.0010473825968801975, 0.05836359038949013, 0.04311687871813774, 0.0227874256670475, -0.016954142600297928, 0.006883857771754265, -0.012849608436226845, 0.0025605896953493357, 0.02097426727414131, -0.05510295182466507, 0.04368289187550545, -0.005825936794281006, 0.017266076058149338, -0.008446436375379562, 0.006616056896746159, -0.018423300236463547, -0.02239040657877922, -0.0035162209533154964, -0.012948385439813137, -0.025190649554133415, 0.01714148558676243, -0.013907541520893574, 0.01750103011727333, -0.04971402883529663, -0.018581004813313484, -0.04047679901123047, -0.006473795976489782, -0.014809783548116684, -0.044053152203559875, 0.020924026146531105, -0.008284972049295902, -0.010889284312725067, 0.004165361635386944, 0.056453242897987366, -0.004113003611564636, -0.012678807601332664, -0.01884596422314644, 0.04544756934046745, -0.016647063195705414, 0.05317769572138786, -0.016857296228408813, -0.015039102174341679, 0.03976359963417053, -0.028542498126626015, -0.01937483623623848, 0.009066836908459663, -0.019667398184537888, 0.02251785807311535, -0.021631157025694847, 0.0007581737008877099, -0.053217511624097824, 0.04267822578549385, -0.04434686899185181, 0.010456550866365433, -0.03965606540441513, 0.025944305583834648, 0.012515912763774395, 0.000010147758075618185, 0.002379628596827388, 0.030479345470666885, -0.012929501943290234, 0.04208413511514664, 0.04538971558213234, 0.009228283539414406, -0.0012388344621285796, 0.009211699478328228, -0.02720908634364605, 0.000014628743883804418, 0.03499072790145874, -0.010255767963826656, 0.021661454811692238, 0.060846295207738876, -0.013006175868213177, 0.054534848779439926, -0.011201852932572365, 0.03199860081076622, -0.09272851794958115, -0.033211130648851395, -0.006914718542248011, 0.06103697046637535, 0.03261663392186165, -0.03998970240354538, -0.0018590642139315605, -0.0026646992191672325, -0.035396452993154526, 0.022777754813432693, 0.017894450575113297, 0.011990963481366634, -0.028246372938156128, 0.02050265669822693, 0.0023441039957106113, 0.001811397960409522, 0.035992030054330826, 0.0028231169562786818, 0.02772081084549427, 0.04493795335292816, 0.029563073068857193, -0.03864159807562828, -0.01763925515115261, -0.010344780050218105, -0.009683985263109207, -0.05876736715435982, 0.02377660945057869, -0.025447651743888855, -0.005451613571494818, 0.000491179118398577, -0.035024456679821014, 0.04687820374965668, 0.01929783634841442, 0.02155137062072754, -0.016697373241186142, 0.044843703508377075, 0.05057675018906593, 0.03083355724811554, 0.02824840135872364, 0.002328210975974798, -0.008171961642801762, 0.02117118239402771, -0.00260065495967865, 0.044819094240665436, 0.025607138872146606, -0.04082491993904114, 0.004680697340518236, -0.005366222932934761, 0.0036129869986325502, -0.005674448795616627, -0.01316811516880989, 0.01716482639312744, -0.03433498367667198, -0.014761792495846748, 0.00997698213905096, -0.003341343719512224, 0.026772907003760338, 0.04226011410355568, 0.04084319248795509, -0.03631558641791344, 0.026001108810305595, -0.0025416561402380466, -0.029648471623659134, 0.021188395097851753, 0.004240474198013544, 0.03984498977661133, -0.06893576681613922, 0.0048004635609686375, -0.010298681445419788, -0.015464933589100838, -0.03622295707464218, 0.018316732719540596, -0.08305323868989944, 0.05561438202857971, -0.031056063249707222, -0.003155746264383197, 0.060271866619586945, -0.03637728840112686, 0.03368936851620674, -0.12326651811599731, 0.06886383146047592, -0.02969544194638729, -0.007084071170538664, -0.05424438789486885, -0.025784865021705627, -0.0582607127726078, 0.0035357025917619467, 0.04101886600255966, 0.025915032252669334, 0.026613611727952957, -0.01646246761083603, 0.03432633727788925, 0.010637855157256126, -0.02510257624089718, 0.0591103620827198, 0.022300798445940018, -0.007483282592147589, 0.004208953119814396, -0.0362868458032608, -0.0007159633678384125, 0.004180088173598051, 0.0092643853276968, -0.023086095228791237, 0.012758058495819569, 0.04011979326605797, -0.005454614758491516, 0.051558542996644974, -0.002187522826716304, -0.0021090623922646046, 0.026034751906991005, -0.018844429403543472, 0.000887917063664645, 0.06370892375707626, -0.014582592062652111, -0.07187119871377945, 0.022598398849368095, -0.04095948114991188, -0.009211559779942036, 0.03211163729429245, 0.005271767266094685, -0.002567257033661008, -0.07895292341709137, 0.02177235670387745, -0.005338273011147976, -0.005042163655161858, 0.002610425930470228, 0.01578415371477604, -0.0046710544265806675, -0.003041026880964637, -0.030608290806412697, 0.016834888607263565, 0.011884340085089207, 0.00141133985016495, 0.035547785460948944, 0.03098004125058651, 0.011029127985239029, -0.02875833585858345, -0.012656847946345806, 0.0474948026239872, 0.0034051844850182533, 0.014469743706285954, -0.014122577384114265, 0.04872375726699829, -0.028528623282909393, -0.01447170041501522, 0.011879808269441128, 0.019034504890441895, 0.013561327010393143, 0.01666841469705105, -0.03509918227791786, 0.060678254812955856, -0.0813908651471138, -0.02936294674873352, 0.0006141476333141327, -0.04175007343292236, -0.03255975991487503, 0.008823741227388382, -0.017978787422180176, 0.028694646432995796, -0.010580364614725113, 0.01887674070894718, 0.01352508831769228, -0.02486354112625122, -0.0390743687748909, -0.012714824639260769, -0.0018392535857856274, 0.009660139679908752, 0.01304509025067091, -0.026897653937339783, -0.009650994092226028, -0.021256720647215843, -0.03822871670126915, 0.01112797949463129, 0.0457732155919075, 0.019587544724345207, -0.04820990562438965, -0.008955031633377075, -0.020533591508865356, 0.017972838133573532, -0.04789081588387489, -0.024886051192879677, -0.015224223025143147, 0.018377887085080147, -0.03190463408827782, -0.04782707244157791 ]
<p>There are several packages that can apply the Durbin-Watson test for serial correlation. However, I do not see a package that supports the calculation in the case that once has a GLS weighted regression.</p> <p>For example, CRAN package <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/lmtest/index.html" rel="nofollow">lmtest</a> notes in their <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/lmtest/NEWS" rel="nofollow">changelog</a> that they explicitly do not support weighted regressions (yet). Before the recent release, lmtest would not throw an error when passing weighted regressions. </p> <p>My concern is that the other dwtest packages may also not be explicitly dealing with this scenario.</p>
1,008
[ -0.050671301782131195, 0.001465587061829865, 0.009125001728534698, -0.002693049842491746, 0.05752664804458618, -0.003561154706403613, -0.046659812331199646, -0.024539727717638016, 0.036895424127578735, -0.012805555015802383, 0.020156214013695717, 0.07517272233963013, 0.07181483507156372, 0.07144378870725632, -0.002955071162432432, -0.0037254018243402243, -0.007705676835030317, 0.044380173087120056, -0.024176372215151787, 0.0006409540073946118, -0.017563004046678543, 0.013348073698580265, 0.00832084659487009, -0.009673258289694786, 0.007247732486575842, 0.005142820533365011, 0.01754254847764969, -0.0596943162381649, -0.02321241796016693, 0.028426751494407654, -0.053691163659095764, 0.00909495260566473, -0.008591069839894772, 0.051573991775512695, -0.013453496620059013, 0.03359152004122734, -0.012582925148308277, -0.009354150854051113, -0.02103440649807453, 0.013273653574287891, -0.03988543525338173, 0.013994774781167507, -0.007762440480291843, 0.07444173842668533, -0.009189634583890438, 0.019278131425380707, -0.006075655575841665, 0.03488766774535179, 0.0331999696791172, -0.01290430873632431, 0.05773262679576874, -0.00821654498577118, 0.021732890978455544, -0.0045898593962192535, -0.025432884693145752, 0.017561085522174835, 0.04664161056280136, 0.04975612461566925, -0.022001050412654877, -0.03225275129079819, -0.016130022704601288, -0.004379420541226864, 0.04291979968547821, 0.0053056636825203896, -0.03187396004796028, 0.006394797470420599, -0.0012119874591007829, -0.021474922075867653, 0.03663633391261101, -0.032866742461919785, 0.005241821985691786, 0.035270366817712784, 0.05715122073888779, -0.004909674171358347, -0.006020783446729183, -0.033868204802274704, -0.032576557248830795, -0.010957191698253155, 0.02090071141719818, 0.023678597062826157, -0.01771017722785473, 0.005762419197708368, 0.018789982423186302, 0.018313517794013023, 0.05491085350513458, -0.018988780677318573, 0.0634397342801094, -0.018858598545193672, 0.041943229734897614, 0.06717181950807571, 0.010846702381968498, -0.0127937076613307, 0.023981725797057152, 0.022321896627545357, -0.03332128748297691, 0.030783161520957947, -0.003898950759321451, -0.000419546413468197, -0.003919759299606085, -0.012989570386707783, -0.017674066126346588, -0.044006846845149994, 0.032859183847904205, 0.06433554738759995, 0.009124156087636948, -0.03476334363222122, -0.0014431200688704848, -0.05169481784105301, -0.01299840584397316, -0.030728613957762718, -0.004575319122523069, -0.017600305378437042, -0.002462416421622038, -0.042301613837480545, 0.0079621821641922, -0.014089350588619709, -0.021130859851837158, 0.02081611379981041, 0.057096872478723526, 0.07035300135612488, 0.07725287228822708, -0.0028872881084680557, 0.03140738606452942, -0.044830240309238434, -0.03413339704275131, 0.05619027093052864, 0.03466304391622543, -0.04771964251995087, -0.03009382076561451, 0.07370420545339584, 0.01863667741417885, -0.019609250128269196, 0.01661328785121441, -0.02835671231150627, 0.04281120374798775, 0.006075520068407059, -0.04941051825881004, -0.07108849287033081, 0.047691021114587784, -0.03533513471484184, -0.005210497882217169, -0.018275069072842598, -0.034069038927555084, 0.01599549874663353, 0.0783771425485611, 0.02837757021188736, 0.056265659630298615, -0.007172332610934973, 0.05015718191862106, 0.007875413633883, 0.0022952882573008537, 0.0006763375131413341, -0.028339533135294914, -0.033246465027332306, -0.014922207221388817, -0.06218944862484932, 0.009634220041334629, 0.010810069739818573, -0.047782156616449356, 0.020893724635243416, 0.018064996227622032, 0.03200632333755493, -0.016704820096492767, -0.009353820234537125, 0.0025465746875852346, -0.03283621370792389, 0.046017132699489594, -0.015000252984464169, 0.02447333373129368, -0.006275660824030638, -0.010948533192276955, 0.012680461630225182, 0.0017644715262576938, 0.06279803067445755, 0.0017591435462236404, -0.027087392285466194, 0.006683481857180595, -0.019845085218548775, -0.002744037192314863, -0.010045114904642105, -0.015065557323396206, -0.027106402441859245, -0.022391116246581078, -0.03985528275370598, 0.03889975696802139, 0.028059083968400955, -0.002280604559928179, -0.02599647454917431, 0.04276633262634277, -0.05495896190404892, -0.021280577406287193, -0.02764701470732689, 0.0011519866529852152, -0.00020695016428362578, -0.029198691248893738, 0.0023683388717472553, -0.020116489380598068, 0.041505567729473114, -0.0008827289566397667, -0.03591722995042801, 0.008483818732202053, 0.021739814430475235, 0.05721437931060791, -0.02439494989812374, -0.01575303077697754, 0.018986620008945465, 0.054509926587343216, -0.0327904038131237, 0.002342148218303919, -0.020228339359164238, -0.03905926272273064, 0.03719864413142204, -0.02035723626613617, 0.0138162299990654, -0.014576805755496025, -0.0019754054956138134, 0.007579348050057888, -0.00997217744588852, -0.021125448867678642, 0.05006709322333336, -0.061965834349393845, 0.01594029925763607, 0.07345210760831833, 0.0005996546824462712, 0.011885457672178745, -0.017923645675182343, -0.008553799241781235, 0.004782821051776409, -0.02344854548573494, -0.03565763682126999, -0.027598747983574867, 0.023894624784588814, 0.026227690279483795, 0.01168794371187687, -0.013665147125720978, 0.02471519634127617, 0.06305692344903946, 0.00967478472739458, -0.02487342059612274, 0.03780382499098778, -0.0018064918695017695, -0.04434889182448387, -0.004223222844302654, 0.005255857948213816, 0.03052263893187046, -0.014978651888668537, 0.01132189016789198, 0.015499518252909184, 0.033859193325042725, 0.02778436802327633, -0.03992895409464836, 0.06899114698171616, 0.003408348886296153, 0.003842616453766823, -0.036298006772994995, -0.027161315083503723, 0.07169739902019501, -0.012322419323027134, 0.02373090572655201, 0.018699070438742638, -0.005591278895735741, -0.0013802986359223723, 0.037622082978487015, 0.00007655481749679893, 0.011642667464911938, 0.017860697582364082, -0.017523663118481636, -0.04370107874274254, 0.029059018939733505, -0.04490761086344719, 0.024528473615646362, -0.019341062754392624, 0.00587108451873064, -0.009482420980930328, 0.007751575671136379, -0.002977019175887108, 0.0078055402263998985, 0.006636433769017458, -0.027661003172397614, -0.0018817766103893518, -0.019160935655236244, 0.00035236464464105666, -0.02020903117954731, 0.02047278732061386, -0.04899361729621887, -0.020019780844449997, -0.00243106996640563, 0.004495742730796337, 0.01796610653400421, 0.005362403579056263, -0.027514789253473282, 0.04912728816270828, 0.02404644899070263, -0.05172507464885712, -0.048639968037605286, -0.016222205013036728, -0.011955056339502335, -0.032059669494628906, -0.0339137502014637, 0.039698526263237, 0.011617236770689487, -0.06093255430459976, 0.0001225639134645462, -0.03894281014800072, 0.029915090650320053, 0.007644675672054291, -0.006719109136611223, -0.012428096495568752, -0.007788567803800106, -0.012913710437715054, 0.015277130529284477, -0.05594208091497421, -0.015553407371044159, -0.05841697007417679, -0.06520002335309982, 0.03871669992804527, -0.001196174300275743, 0.025455646216869354, 0.04339491203427315, -0.03881289064884186, 0.05460164323449135, 0.028691422194242477, -0.003398687345907092, -0.0524028018116951, -0.029813650995492935, -0.024084018543362617, -0.03177669644355774, 0.0382230281829834, -0.006857255473732948, 0.01294208038598299, 0.02978513576090336, 0.005443528760224581, -0.02139589563012123, 0.04565585404634476, 0.014723440632224083, 0.020817888900637627, 0.031054958701133728, -0.025316203013062477, 0.01912032440304756, 0.015804531052708626, 0.011752097867429256, -0.004566539544612169, -0.01031419262290001, 0.011389856226742268, -0.002491940511390567, -0.030855096876621246, -0.05116027221083641, 0.0023901849053800106, -0.02233191579580307, 0.004830632824450731, -0.026583949103951454, 0.03530796989798546, -0.00474242027848959, -0.012742741964757442, -0.048706550151109695, 0.03277849406003952, 0.02047756128013134, -0.01109201181679964, 0.012070306576788425, -0.008757000789046288, 0.041171759366989136, -0.006749263498932123, -0.016896424815058708, -0.008218774572014809, -0.04890914261341095, 0.05403762310743332, -0.031229937449097633, -0.024639002978801727, 0.04469257593154907, 0.019030645489692688, -0.009128550067543983, -0.012367761693894863, -0.05126171186566353, -0.0039432779885828495, -0.05326984077692032, 0.03719178959727287, -0.052731432020664215, 0.043717753142118454, 0.025405071675777435, 0.030472407117486, 0.07247309386730194, -0.021021857857704163, -0.011100656352937222, -0.024472137913107872, -0.08387138694524765, 0.033000487834215164, 0.02556752972304821, -0.015091591514647007, 0.059519317001104355, -0.018138915300369263, -0.03380664810538292, -0.029848789796233177, 0.007680295035243034, -0.009646961465477943, 0.03631709888577461, -0.038666728883981705, 0.012270249426364899, -0.008476356975734234, -0.021746573969721794, 0.008722975850105286, 0.01830061338841915, 0.03787285089492798, -0.044490549713373184, 0.026000237092375755, 0.028055446222424507, -0.008171221241354942, -0.0024064870085567236, -0.038709696382284164, 0.02569466270506382, 0.007292113266885281, 0.0451744869351387, 0.05808049812912941, 0.004307313822209835, -0.05563231557607651, 0.011283011175692081, -0.0074788909405469894, 0.010847571305930614, 0.049127716571092606, -0.05628682300448418, -0.05270320549607277, -0.025796912610530853, -0.02305646240711212, 0.023546185344457626, 0.010778933763504028, 0.00011029182496713474, 0.02910827472805977, 0.08051078766584396, 0.03373553603887558, 0.0062423208728432655, 0.008714031428098679, 0.06067731976509094, 0.02298479527235031, 0.005870053544640541, 0.021536007523536682, -0.010676885023713112, -0.0015678702620789409, -0.013728921301662922, 0.07605942338705063, -0.004101692233234644, 0.03144481033086777, 0.029645277187228203, -0.01778947003185749, 0.010246683843433857, -0.019431080669164658, 0.027189059183001518, 0.04690863564610481, 0.04698524624109268, -0.020164793357253075, -0.033126138150691986, 0.038727015256881714, 0.049781739711761475, 0.010850481688976288, 0.04170558974146843, 0.01594032719731331, -0.06235592067241669, 0.011679958552122116, 0.024247581139206886, 0.05313175171613693, -0.04437989741563797, 0.000009073871297005098, -0.006459979806095362, 0.011764620430767536, 0.024029942229390144, -0.019642069935798645, 0.023404009640216827, -0.007855991832911968, 0.017848452553153038, -0.029567867517471313, -0.04715781658887863, -0.035026635974645615, 0.042502421885728836, -0.041107919067144394, 0.0021728796418756247, 0.006281373091042042, -0.028355246409773827, -0.008684482425451279, 0.018255481496453285, -0.005896392278373241, 0.02447645366191864, 0.002731666900217533, 0.0023315094877034426, 0.016625938937067986, 0.026862243190407753, -0.011098960414528847, -0.033476222306489944, -0.044713180512189865, -0.03988742455840111, 0.0021746004931628704, 0.05125509947538376, -0.0081863421946764, -0.017909817397594452, 0.028187345713377, 0.022843020036816597, 0.0051750559359788895, -0.020944643765687943, 0.01475674007087946, 0.023994790390133858, 0.03448564559221268, -0.001594524597749114, 0.03679366037249565, -0.0003332619380671531, -0.014900357462465763, 0.017997032031416893, -0.004323859233409166, 0.02170383371412754, -0.03048640862107277, -0.012009995058178902, -0.02810191735625267, -0.010550240986049175, -0.011514672078192234, 0.004441187717020512, -0.009113220497965813, 0.005929021164774895, -0.0038121012039482594, 0.04248814284801483, -0.007795316632837057, 0.021022241562604904, -0.031192099675536156, -0.005168992560356855, 0.0025903957430273294, 0.01129740197211504, -0.006077352445572615, 0.010038640350103378, 0.009039688855409622, -0.017038460820913315, 0.007004220504313707, -0.0020940834656357765, -0.040995243936777115, -0.0019110377179458737, 0.010711295530200005, 0.0030633879359811544, 0.004402669612318277, -0.030612189322710037, 0.023155799135565758, 0.012220253236591816, 0.04360992833971977, 0.004967087414115667, -0.014397671446204185, 0.006458571646362543, 0.007962128147482872, 0.006185230799019337, -0.014690975658595562, -0.03240189328789711, 0.03189239650964737, -0.01964721456170082, 0.01677851192653179, -0.05958119034767151, -0.012063747271895409, 0.024593858048319817, 0.020183438435196877, -0.02576286718249321, -0.004097486846148968, -0.02281971462070942, -0.02692931890487671, -0.015744393691420555, -0.02260836958885193, 0.0838899314403534, 0.008856991305947304, -0.007815025746822357, -0.03399994596838951, 0.02279116027057171, 0.08244382590055466, -0.008327219635248184, -0.00532509945333004, 0.0132835004478693, -0.03524377942085266, -0.002835589461028576, -0.0014514765935018659, 0.002290517557412386, -0.045209676027297974, -0.031225169077515602, -0.020611684769392014, -0.003702086629346013, 0.033154867589473724, -0.02006334438920021, -0.04815838113427162, -0.0033601068425923586, -0.011777223087847233, 0.00847606174647808, -0.04758366942405701, 0.019909312948584557, -0.01956190913915634, 0.01348645705729723, -0.04808792844414711, -0.0320967361330986, 0.028941404074430466, -0.005414360202848911, 0.005056146997958422, 0.011737177148461342, -0.045259904116392136, 0.0002159098075935617, 0.06576916575431824, 0.03756777197122574, 0.015304441563785076, -0.003969416953623295, -0.01905277743935585, 0.05110640451312065, -0.0462157279253006, 0.01824473962187767, -0.001054709660820663, 0.038224220275878906, -0.044378723949193954, -0.036306098103523254, -0.027700766921043396, 0.03979901969432831, 0.04392130300402641, -0.012450141832232475, 0.0682053342461586, 0.058272507041692734, -0.023641707375645638, -0.002879366045817733, -0.04034947231411934, -0.007446335628628731, -0.015449069440364838, 0.005532239563763142, 0.03019150346517563, 0.03617534413933754, -0.010551166720688343, 0.00807073526084423, 0.015990372747182846, 0.02557988651096821, 0.04732225090265274, -0.00525219552218914, -0.019016936421394348, 0.012499241158366203, -0.017105817794799805, -0.03493402898311615, 0.03853868693113327, -0.06178361177444458, 0.003252460155636072, -0.018584199249744415, -0.0004287831543479115, 0.03389441594481468, 0.008664369583129883, 0.0096574192866683, -0.03710317611694336, -0.06693082302808762, -0.0764555111527443, 0.019259341061115265, 0.027846751734614372, -0.025010336190462112, 0.018703436478972435, 0.037867140024900436, 0.01785009354352951, 0.03296641260385513, 0.029514849185943604, -0.029738890007138252, -0.08478444814682007, 0.007275858428329229, 0.017411284148693085, -0.03153429180383682, 0.03244103863835335, 0.013290940783917904, 0.0011514521902427077, 0.011706525459885597, -0.023006746545433998, -0.013437893241643906, 0.017048032954335213, 0.017819667235016823, -0.007314433343708515, 0.0938330888748169, -0.018727559596300125, 0.00617896718904376, -0.028100229799747467, -0.00581327686086297, 0.16296952962875366, 0.025448450818657875, 0.08091779053211212, -0.06319404393434525, 0.014410517178475857, 0.021339599043130875, 0.02156844176352024, -0.03015175275504589, -0.00812346301972866, -0.028969690203666687, -0.01121814176440239, 0.01589575782418251, 0.0409604087471962, 0.008364788256585598, -0.016460340470075607, 0.03846229240298271, -0.02983338199555874, 0.018653668463230133, 0.01860114187002182, -0.009500022977590561, 0.005220136139541864, 0.012505360879004002, -0.03246595337986946, 0.001050325226970017, 0.01625397801399231, -0.01522731315344572, -0.022578615695238113, -0.011109668761491776, -0.023141298443078995, -0.02058500424027443, -0.0032030935399234295, 0.010248119942843914, 0.03903675451874733, 0.04901069402694702, -0.007694737054407597, -0.01618507131934166, 0.040301088243722916, -0.03165534883737564, 0.05086175724864006, 0.031844474375247955, -0.03785272315144539, -0.0016577846836298704, 0.0033186031505465508, 0.01920921355485916, -0.016204658895730972, -0.025456609204411507, -0.0252886600792408, 0.034945301711559296, -0.019136734306812286, -0.0414767861366272, 0.008390095084905624, -0.00694989413022995, 0.022996531799435616, -0.039026517421007156, -0.00934967678040266, 0.033288050442934036, 0.03312709927558899, 0.011168002150952816, -0.011945800855755806, -0.05083201453089714, 0.0018713560421019793, 0.016100144013762474, 0.08968367427587509, 0.03930113837122917, -0.04961371794342995, -0.00395519332960248, -0.025071226060390472, 0.048695072531700134, -0.014859356917440891, 0.007114402949810028, -0.00349294301122427, -0.01797359809279442, -0.032784730195999146, -0.05110381916165352, 0.00023875245824456215, 0.010780440643429756, 0.04000399634242058, 0.02397141419351101, -0.0064110057428479195, -0.020493635907769203, -0.07330325245857239, 0.004073863383382559, -0.04475557804107666, -0.01274887379258871, -0.03188907355070114, 0.026959870010614395, 0.03778674453496933, 0.030520357191562653, -0.013301494531333447, 0.006540804635733366, -0.02033209428191185, 0.02931944653391838, 0.03522495552897453, -0.046632204204797745, 0.014320556074380875, -0.01616193726658821, -0.03058522567152977, 0.00539232324808836, -0.05479653179645538, 0.04926498234272003, 0.016864249482750893, 0.023080114275217056, -0.03662331774830818, 0.027828631922602654, -0.010620237328112125, 0.0073903934098780155, 0.02570394240319729, 0.012162648141384125, 0.003041145158931613, 0.03426632285118103, -0.008401958271861076, -0.009646272286772728, -0.020281972363591194, -0.07438689470291138, -0.02256433106958866, 0.0001806869258871302, -0.025871751829981804, -0.09561703354120255, -0.0019692175555974245, 0.024959255009889603, -0.014809389598667622, -0.03127951920032501, 0.005919510964304209, -0.036132048815488815, -0.013504751026630402, -0.031187819316983223, -0.012140374630689621, 0.020401932299137115, 0.014064807444810867, -0.040240272879600525, 0.022955672815442085, 0.06092143803834915, 0.006222250871360302, 0.013403553515672684, 0.005456117447465658, 0.010029010474681854, 0.009743327274918556, 0.060695912688970566, 0.0037402648013085127, -0.03943873569369316, 0.023414095863699913, 0.015578326769173145, 0.0016731844516471028, 0.006805241107940674, -0.044978853315114975, 0.01782400533556938, 0.009847402572631836, 0.027052463963627815, -0.020254431292414665, 0.0520479679107666, -0.0015523479087278247, 0.00104648491833359, -0.04782606661319733, 0.00697993952780962, 0.04752976819872856, -0.000015692243323428556, -0.02986723743379116, 0.019451677799224854, 0.0058755455538630486, -0.007471935823559761, 0.05226758122444153, 0.007161710411310196, 0.019532497972249985, -0.02961719036102295, -0.02881399355828762, 0.043401267379522324, 0.01905057206749916, -0.028059866279363632, 0.032567162066698074, 0.015371466986835003, -0.022418610751628876, 0.010283175855875015, 0.01315742451697588, 0.00032089356682263315, -0.10004372894763947, 0.007098938804119825, 0.021128082647919655, 0.01143170241266489, -0.005089983809739351, -0.0552428774535656, 0.01851803809404373, 0.0023307506926357746, -0.021026259288191795, 0.015359126031398773, 0.02154180034995079, -0.02304479293525219, -0.028078146278858185, -0.010225964710116386, -0.025990601629018784, 0.01646425761282444, 0.028910212218761444, 0.004984968341886997, 0.022244490683078766, 0.02982684224843979, 0.048196468502283096, -0.030744917690753937, -0.00026515513309277594, -0.02303343266248703, 0.00918595027178526, -0.01683180406689644, 0.0436028428375721, -0.04067607223987579, -0.03281083703041077, 0.012667481787502766, -0.036675725132226944, 0.023584997281432152, 0.012208611704409122, 0.07343654334545135, 0.0036874301731586456, 0.049687858670949936, 0.04334750398993492, 0.009529572911560535, 0.0240493044257164, 0.0007964876713231206, -0.011285080574452877, 0.040155861526727676, -0.05687056854367256, 0.003841105382889509, -0.03761443868279457, -0.025228707119822502, -0.023579590022563934, 0.027728024870157242, -0.03523880988359451, -0.028362827375531197, -0.0022496075835078955, -0.020240258425474167, 0.01861627772450447, -0.00031888653757050633, -0.012606524862349033, -0.036286402493715286, 0.007089361548423767, 0.03259219974279404, 0.02667407877743244, -0.01924714632332325, -0.013548409566283226, -0.0041114697232842445, -0.03145594522356987, 0.012254341505467892, -0.05242032930254936, 0.006668892223387957, -0.08055935055017471, -0.027179254218935966, 0.0014511108165606856, 0.012337258085608482, -0.04634029418230057, 0.030520420521497726, 0.0016662055859342217, 0.061176665127277374, -0.023845840245485306, 0.040374644100666046, 0.0010559825459495187, 0.015695150941610336, 0.06112007424235344, -0.1311899572610855, 0.028712110593914986, -0.018295759335160255, -0.03555154800415039, -0.02147732302546501, 0.0025099243503063917, 0.003017182694748044, -0.02673518843948841, 0.0160305704921484, -0.003258738899603486, 0.025109248235821724, 0.016690043732523918, 0.050030943006277084, -0.02128531038761139, -0.04281901940703392, 0.023579319939017296, -0.012467773631215096, -0.03494667634367943, -0.02088724635541439, -0.027843723073601723, -0.01611407846212387, 0.04341329634189606, 0.012820800766348839, -0.00943088997155428, -0.003967692609876394, -0.018516935408115387, 0.014821240678429604, 0.03636253997683525, 0.0029324297793209553, -0.005496975965797901, 0.04881145805120468, -0.02108158729970455, 0.03429798036813736, -0.007822179235517979, -0.006492009852081537, -0.06425932049751282, 0.04433426633477211, -0.05036279931664467, -0.04608682170510292, 0.028853490948677063, 0.05410370975732803, -0.023474782705307007, -0.016936205327510834, 0.00995841808617115, -0.015153290703892708, 0.011809567920863628, -0.030156362801790237, 0.028212767094373703, -0.0090607525780797, 0.052999693900346756, 0.032338738441467285, -0.008826774545013905, 0.023034311830997467, -0.014916974119842052, -0.014825443737208843, 0.014718202874064445, 0.020129740238189697, 0.018398279324173927, -0.047400351613759995, -0.0051885610446333885, -0.009027968160808086, 0.010700439102947712, -0.021800654008984566, 0.007578400894999504, -0.018035445362329483, -0.01842677965760231, 0.017877576872706413, -0.004539782181382179, 0.039797343313694, 0.006332457531243563, 0.010167785920202732, 0.03693247213959694, -0.01711489073932171, 0.022610262036323547, -0.029191963374614716, -0.04211818799376488, -0.001286478596739471, 0.026944266632199287, 0.019498970359563828, 0.018032412976026535, -0.0047293915413320065, 0.0003884417237713933, 0.017063794657588005, -0.049248307943344116, 0.006712493486702442, -0.018559874966740608, 0.006863106973469257, -0.02154473401606083, 0.011598440818488598, -0.0023982729762792587, -0.03528216481208801, -0.05749033764004707, -0.010518663562834263, 0.01709001138806343, 0.016115525737404823, -0.025424083694815636, -0.09318806231021881, 0.02031468227505684, 0.02598160319030285, 0.05866900458931923, -0.06418716162443161, -0.0065974160097539425, -0.0440392941236496, 0.017458880320191383, -0.009793306700885296, -0.01681479439139366 ]
<p>I have <strong>6</strong> masses as input data which they are expressed as m+/- delta m. Via a complicated processes I calculate <strong>decay width</strong> as a final result. It takes a long time for the code to compute decay width for example for <strong>m</strong> values. Let's call it <strong>(decay width)_central</strong>. Let's call <strong>m + delta m= m_max</strong> and <strong>m- delta m =m_min</strong>. (For 6 masses: For example m_max means I substitute all 6 masses with their maximum value). Then decay width for m_max is <strong>(decay width)_max</strong> and decay width for m_min is <strong>(decay width)_min</strong>. Can I have an estimate for error bar with only these 3 values of decay widths? (It is very time consuming to find more than these 3 results.) Or may be you suggest a better way? Thanks a lot.</p> <p>My problem is how to calculate error bars for decay width. Errors originate from 6 experimental data which I used as inputs. The question is that how should I find error bars for decay width? I can't use the usual methods such as deviation for errors, because it is so time consuming to calculate decay width for the masses in experimental range and then find mean value. Can I find an estimate for error bars only with 3 values of decay width? The decay width which I found by substituting all the masses with m + delta m, The one by substituting all the masses with m - delta m and the one which I found by substituting the mean values for m? </p>
35,730
[ -0.03772663325071335, -0.010316519998013973, -0.0008308448595926166, 0.010994642041623592, 0.019696956500411034, 0.03859923779964447, -0.018799006938934326, -0.03608473762869835, 0.05119048431515694, -0.023406486958265305, 0.0029424510430544615, -0.006958503741770983, 0.062105581164360046, 0.007272900547832251, 0.02296281047165394, -0.0007160438108257949, -0.007867258042097092, -0.023920947685837746, -0.021347861737012863, -0.07735065370798111, 0.018469782546162605, 0.023276429623365402, -0.009644674137234688, 0.018950967118144035, -0.036151789128780365, 0.04229738190770149, 0.030928470194339752, 0.03262203931808472, 0.01201036386191845, 0.046586811542510986, -0.03719622269272804, -0.06392406672239304, 0.03555581718683243, 0.02865113690495491, 0.012524222955107689, 0.010802242904901505, -0.026158835738897324, -0.03389516472816467, -0.01925566792488098, 0.031718675047159195, -0.04764898493885994, -0.004812038503587246, 0.008056722581386566, 0.0026927520520985126, -0.008248057216405869, -0.010421277955174446, -0.006795715074986219, -0.008407069370150566, 0.024004366248846054, -0.03601778671145439, 0.08926642686128616, -0.009346586652100086, 0.05509475618600845, 0.008865592069923878, -0.021319692954421043, 0.003514697775244713, 0.03256074711680412, 0.06841403245925903, 0.01581226848065853, -0.029665663838386536, -0.013213622383773327, -0.038834284991025925, 0.025071537122130394, 0.008979431353509426, -0.016787031665444374, 0.03829579800367355, -0.0027542472817003727, 0.011620507575571537, 0.03465978056192398, 0.024171561002731323, 0.017775239422917366, -0.012109210714697838, 0.04271067678928375, 0.00016896758461371064, 0.016528554260730743, -0.031320780515670776, -0.0015659850323572755, 0.03017180971801281, 0.04492238163948059, 0.04358675330877304, -0.000745937752071768, 0.01625392772257328, 0.012444553896784782, 0.004177062772214413, -0.018316369503736496, -0.009719688445329666, 0.06828675419092178, -0.02776564471423626, 0.01664847694337368, 0.019482214003801346, -0.008921951055526733, 0.01741187460720539, 0.013397971168160439, 0.011391576379537582, -0.03889397159218788, -0.006894569378346205, 0.014892015606164932, 0.03218936547636986, -0.010001437738537788, 0.010114106349647045, -0.02576218917965889, -0.04919639602303505, 0.008089370094239712, 0.0699802115559578, -0.02214859239757061, 0.023833390325307846, -0.0029224574100226164, -0.027250023558735847, -0.03427566587924957, -0.01649220660328865, -0.015580198727548122, -0.03949488326907158, 0.009106671437621117, -0.01870623230934143, -0.012288174591958523, -0.027104588225483894, -0.04530133306980133, -0.02886192686855793, 0.04085301235318184, 0.07755881547927856, 0.03125641867518425, -0.04622461274266243, 0.02497512847185135, -0.01383287739008665, -0.0809001699090004, 0.04146409034729004, 0.05320744216442108, 0.019712530076503754, -0.058835163712501526, 0.04749983176589012, 0.028820360079407692, -0.0070008146576583385, 0.04147003963589668, -0.01151947770267725, 0.034039970487356186, -0.009007579647004604, -0.0899115651845932, -0.0893600806593895, -0.00298464042134583, -0.000647454580757767, -0.024306172505021095, -0.0625392496585846, -0.0026955963112413883, 0.05932675302028656, 0.02917342074215412, 0.05557015910744667, 0.009359131567180157, 0.022999411448836327, 0.00015264817920979112, 0.010165897198021412, -0.027798181399703026, -0.009485728107392788, -0.00506225973367691, 0.015310992486774921, -0.036584626883268356, -0.06362250447273254, -0.024307817220687866, 0.005911590065807104, -0.027291040867567062, -0.002248281380161643, 0.05279339477419853, 0.0185270793735981, 0.014304589480161667, -0.005791482515633106, 0.028000865131616592, -0.03672714903950691, 0.05351666733622551, -0.0075845252722501755, -0.002522264374420047, -0.0004172275948803872, -0.00046846873010508716, -0.01684044860303402, -0.00023111121845431626, -0.006170856300741434, 0.07718972116708755, -0.031174758449196815, -0.0034462586045265198, -0.019997041672468185, 0.017306597903370857, 0.0569218210875988, -0.03101440519094467, -0.023597054183483124, -0.012503945268690586, 0.0071972329169511795, 0.020448539406061172, 0.07914187759160995, 0.02286555990576744, -0.004292570985853672, 0.03891603276133537, -0.045965880155563354, -0.03410756587982178, -0.03629215434193611, 0.007127938326448202, -0.028131848201155663, -0.021499566733837128, -0.03007483296096325, 0.003871876746416092, -0.013086971826851368, 0.023432625457644463, -0.036617498844861984, 0.00629542488604784, -0.00969524122774601, 0.005559099372476339, -0.0088013531640172, 0.021354064345359802, 0.05538131296634674, 0.01584579236805439, -0.045444779098033905, 0.030400263145565987, -0.025871602818369865, 0.002621869556605816, 0.03735685721039772, -0.03861906751990318, -0.010697145015001297, 0.012927086092531681, -0.04464246705174446, 0.005967999342828989, -0.0278428066521883, 0.000013741570001002401, -0.0012392880162224174, -0.02449301816523075, 0.07749751210212708, 0.05859734117984772, 0.015801744535565376, 0.027855416759848595, 0.00576612027361989, 0.013874196447432041, 0.0315767340362072, -0.06056554242968559, -0.033202920109033585, -0.0418347492814064, -0.021624628454446793, -0.0010424895444884896, -0.01009306963533163, -0.08276646584272385, 0.03454522415995598, 0.022507736459374428, -0.02710309624671936, 0.022562459111213684, 0.01940583437681198, -0.017733987420797348, 0.0003305288264527917, 0.02325192093849182, 0.043175626546144485, -0.004686486441642046, 0.036002304404973984, -0.0012115752324461937, 0.04133124276995659, 0.013981243595480919, -0.016707276925444603, 0.038588233292102814, 0.029518505558371544, -0.025172384455800056, 0.01661129668354988, -0.01711595430970192, -0.04289790987968445, 0.03171999379992485, -0.012826336547732353, 0.049622587859630585, 0.05090544745326042, -0.038525138050317764, 0.027209021151065826, 0.03482000157237053, -0.02438589558005333, 0.029056694358587265, 0.03834361582994461, 0.012866973876953125, 0.009449505247175694, 0.007051561959087849, -0.03342704474925995, -0.006405671592801809, -0.04118213802576065, -0.014804829843342304, -0.01349260937422514, -0.002557890024036169, 0.0343453586101532, 0.016422376036643982, 0.01932898350059986, -0.010469869710505009, 0.006462926510721445, -0.01947634480893612, 0.002111579990014434, -0.01233675517141819, 0.0015197483589872718, -0.018440892919898033, 0.0031604983378201723, 0.006692742928862572, -0.08015601336956024, 0.03685259819030762, -0.005037330556660891, -0.046489156782627106, 0.02724923938512802, 0.017005780711770058, -0.06079694256186485, -0.016546670347452164, -0.002165101235732436, -0.015350138768553734, 0.02596927247941494, 0.007113661151379347, 0.03545945882797241, 0.003951032646000385, -0.043037526309490204, 0.0581059455871582, -0.04325525462627411, -0.030786676332354546, -0.028120271861553192, 0.01294576097279787, 0.02454107254743576, -0.011633885093033314, 0.05208500847220421, 0.030923398211598396, 0.0004903897061012685, -0.019903935492038727, -0.05779634788632393, -0.05108420550823212, 0.0008217322756536305, -0.007166252471506596, 0.01991363614797592, 0.044901829212903976, -0.019071541726589203, 0.10191822052001953, 0.021871035918593407, -0.039560846984386444, -0.014711884781718254, -0.009694489650428295, -0.023933634161949158, -0.02850036509335041, 0.02091648057103157, -0.028430869802832603, 0.009489770047366619, -0.014759759418666363, -0.004393043927848339, 0.03258543834090233, 0.014715762808918953, -0.005817787256091833, -0.010260030627250671, 0.015562356449663639, 0.0023830991704016924, -0.020872434601187706, 0.04679730907082558, 0.03177765756845474, 0.009416830725967884, -0.006691124755889177, -0.03025772236287594, 0.049259334802627563, -0.007391748484224081, -0.05397523567080498, 0.026102421805262566, -0.03524843975901604, 0.016752757132053375, -0.00579649955034256, -0.013462250120937824, 0.0027747759595513344, -0.029794903472065926, 0.0005026573198847473, 0.017971692606806755, 0.029477763921022415, 0.0023874556645751, 0.010323063470423222, 0.038976673036813736, 0.06434202939271927, -0.0021389175672084093, -0.04266364499926567, -0.01193367037922144, -0.013208095915615559, 0.008860396221280098, -0.026241160929203033, -0.05836822837591171, 0.03799251466989517, 0.0324358269572258, 0.005424177274107933, 0.0012679484207183123, -0.015557272359728813, 0.004620869178324938, -0.06063460186123848, -0.001909930375404656, -0.008516787551343441, 0.07556100189685822, 0.01477915607392788, 0.048473138362169266, 0.05971313640475273, -0.04736098647117615, 0.01578354649245739, -0.03313380107283592, -0.08216971904039383, 0.03904210403561592, -0.01641434244811535, -0.048152025789022446, 0.021456828340888023, -0.022133752703666687, 0.01700909249484539, -0.026086580008268356, 0.015909703448414803, -0.003240011166781187, 0.01365586742758751, -0.06749673187732697, -0.01733117550611496, -0.02484111115336418, 0.014527596533298492, -0.0488748736679554, 0.05291953682899475, 0.06019757688045502, 0.0026802236679941416, 0.020370453596115112, -0.0037420582957565784, -0.05236394330859184, -0.0364946648478508, -0.05072464793920517, 0.0026823803782463074, -0.005394873674958944, 0.056656062602996826, 0.045366011559963226, 0.06677758693695068, -0.05758995935320854, -0.0004531214653979987, 0.008711895905435085, 0.0625930055975914, 0.011609237641096115, -0.006756510119885206, 0.004075809847563505, -0.0077678789384663105, 0.016744881868362427, 0.05190932750701904, 0.018480820581316948, 0.01668197475373745, 0.012952277436852455, 0.05227634310722351, -0.016153905540704727, -0.09345202147960663, 0.04020686447620392, 0.06287862360477448, -0.006534706801176071, 0.0249418243765831, -0.07445744425058365, 0.013323534280061722, 0.003335560904815793, -0.05211460217833519, -0.008331174030900002, 0.04430612549185753, -0.010366391390562057, 0.00429373187944293, 0.04461708664894104, 0.02762671746313572, -0.02292577736079693, 0.01351831667125225, 0.0394434817135334, 0.015411296859383583, -0.02643735520541668, -0.018177300691604614, 0.01695145294070244, 0.04799214377999306, 0.048292726278305054, -0.029441040009260178, 0.00539603503420949, -0.0815373957157135, 0.0162812452763319, 0.032786671072244644, 0.07931573688983917, -0.001601288910023868, -0.022442445158958435, 0.001526809181086719, -0.019036147743463516, 0.025847839191555977, -0.06587833911180496, 0.017954997718334198, -0.022975163534283638, 0.014926213771104813, -0.0017274448182433844, -0.01706032082438469, -0.03222529962658882, 0.029896507039666176, -0.023713786154985428, -0.00815894827246666, -0.04609077796339989, 0.03768940269947052, 0.009128165431320667, 0.014584161341190338, 0.008145949803292751, 0.08098827302455902, 0.0037171931471675634, -0.027678897604346275, -0.01819511502981186, 0.018657295033335686, -0.036112528294324875, -0.06556478887796402, 0.02846229262650013, -0.04538774490356445, 0.002582618035376072, 0.055284760892391205, -0.021958446130156517, -0.05132927745580673, 0.032471634447574615, 0.07292897254228592, -0.0077838352881371975, -0.035242959856987, -0.033728573471307755, 0.01584199257194996, 0.04028715193271637, 0.01538011059165001, 0.09090950340032578, 0.03795163705945015, -0.009866977110505104, -0.011818157508969307, 0.016863370314240456, 0.0023488346487283707, -0.04323023185133934, -0.014757360331714153, -0.03473048284649849, 0.026226064190268517, -0.0017598561244085431, 0.01272781565785408, -0.010021216236054897, 0.051623620092868805, -0.021680785343050957, -0.002171008614823222, -0.00020661584858316928, 0.027057262137532234, -0.006750575266778469, -0.02260253019630909, 0.002828948898240924, 0.022013304755091667, 0.02102712355554104, -0.005387532990425825, -0.006504782009869814, -0.02424454875290394, -0.006451795343309641, 0.024317419156432152, -0.05493069812655449, -0.011658037081360817, -0.0451161190867424, -0.0316237136721611, -0.0020416700281202793, -0.018217673525214195, 0.018056433647871017, -0.008733878843486309, 0.018792562186717987, 0.020503802224993706, -0.037545088678598404, -0.00043749864562414587, 0.02485404722392559, -0.00277789612300694, 0.027965394780039787, -0.05463022366166115, 0.011960848234593868, -0.013904408551752567, 0.06721441447734833, -0.08188163489103317, -0.008039440028369427, 0.003858629148453474, 0.03021351806819439, -0.011186077259480953, -0.007472868077456951, -0.03210658207535744, -0.015242458321154118, -0.011652113869786263, -0.04886108636856079, 0.025319909676909447, 0.01666712574660778, 0.010421480983495712, 0.02396622858941555, 0.0361647754907608, 0.08121398836374283, 0.023665213957428932, 0.044332362711429596, -0.00042580539593473077, 0.024141820147633553, -0.03190150484442711, 0.016658231616020203, 0.009462600573897362, 0.004034898709505796, -0.047456443309783936, -0.01496316958218813, 0.026628129184246063, 0.056974828243255615, -0.005622263997793198, 0.007832246832549572, 0.0077662281692028046, 0.004869739059358835, 0.01291597355157137, -0.043391719460487366, 0.02049119956791401, -0.025610003620386124, 0.0036600229796022177, 0.015528175048530102, -0.018487976863980293, -0.01600206457078457, 0.005842834245413542, 0.026374442502856255, 0.005834951996803284, -0.04229319095611572, 0.03511771559715271, 0.03971312195062637, 0.008915456011891365, 0.0012384351575747132, 0.0010075056925415993, -0.020204028114676476, 0.02852703630924225, -0.004234823863953352, 0.022288134321570396, 0.008216450922191143, 0.014419594779610634, 0.009359111078083515, -0.013788573443889618, -0.05015834793448448, 0.017256636172533035, 0.07183168828487396, -0.009958953596651554, 0.05521031841635704, 0.011577025055885315, 0.015392793342471123, -0.03814779222011566, -0.03786828741431236, -0.03172102943062782, 0.021867452189326286, -0.012702896259725094, 0.07300126552581787, -0.009975763037800789, -0.011600453406572342, 0.0099983224645257, 0.021965382620692253, -0.01447282824665308, 0.029672415927052498, -0.0229428019374609, 0.010433492250740528, -0.008391566574573517, 0.011362428776919842, 0.0009299050434492528, 0.03441005200147629, -0.049004927277565, 0.03350213170051575, -0.00723266089335084, -0.004939674399793148, 0.01373680867254734, 0.009520611725747585, -0.005031822249293327, -0.039949093014001846, -0.013056094758212566, -0.05499282479286194, 0.03274824097752571, 0.022001899778842926, -0.043267376720905304, 0.013354403898119926, 0.05909647420048714, 0.03268519788980484, 0.005705568473786116, 0.03416094928979874, -0.029026588425040245, -0.06629422307014465, -0.020035499706864357, -0.0374615341424942, -0.04157377779483795, 0.0454401895403862, -0.0000034611302908160724, -0.030859116464853287, 0.008779045194387436, 0.01442793570458889, 0.04745395481586456, 0.004036270547658205, 0.01791314035654068, -0.013764632865786552, 0.043215617537498474, -0.0012876628898084164, -0.012214930728077888, 0.04599642753601074, 0.01344627607613802, 0.12227988243103027, 0.0703442320227623, 0.0266703013330698, -0.06667513400316238, -0.012832406908273697, 0.0017689054366201162, -0.0089320819824934, 0.022508271038532257, 0.018007298931479454, 0.025412730872631073, 0.003722972236573696, 0.011542662046849728, 0.024704616516828537, 0.010902753099799156, 0.03988317400217056, 0.06310229003429413, -0.017782898619771004, -0.036218564957380295, 0.04880271106958389, 0.0345526859164238, -0.0029481390956789255, -0.025590496137738228, -0.025184690952301025, 0.0598582848906517, -0.007599875330924988, -0.014744574204087257, 0.00033696129685267806, 0.00005783311280538328, 0.02170277014374733, -0.007828964851796627, -0.019549686461687088, -0.00423767976462841, -0.002636389574036002, 0.02320188283920288, -0.037157077342271805, -0.020254911854863167, 0.01757325977087021, -0.0035640811547636986, 0.029725341126322746, 0.04363982751965523, 0.011426583863794804, -0.008214634843170643, 0.0036859784740954638, 0.01926501840353012, -0.021897513419389725, -0.05390043184161186, -0.03669034689664841, 0.03701967000961304, -0.00688643753528595, -0.004027524497359991, 0.0314934141933918, 0.008573981001973152, -0.0032312788534909487, -0.04558894410729408, 0.02255835570394993, 0.014284800738096237, -0.0013695803936570883, -0.06994768232107162, 0.010259951464831829, -0.0039748274721205235, 0.009072400629520416, 0.003713772865012288, -0.020700903609395027, -0.010205783881247044, -0.037308380007743835, -0.015593163669109344, -0.030834726989269257, 0.024854116141796112, -0.004532597027719021, -0.001309077488258481, -0.02052406221628189, -0.015175692737102509, -0.011201709508895874, 0.022524196654558182, 0.015158492140471935, -0.015936700627207756, 0.010837707668542862, 0.02450679987668991, -0.008181584998965263, 0.010724235326051712, -0.056499700993299484, 0.021936215460300446, -0.003157177707180381, -0.0071358815766870975, -0.040928591042757034, 0.011052911169826984, 0.03244087100028992, 0.021029820665717125, 0.012949945405125618, -0.0037151046562939882, -0.0009531156392768025, 0.02699652686715126, 0.003351552877575159, -0.05927269905805588, 0.01760900393128395, -0.020596742630004883, -0.03235575184226036, -0.009644493460655212, -0.024463703855872154, 0.024368610233068466, -0.01682528853416443, 0.01972619630396366, -0.0019993905443698168, 0.03737861290574074, 0.027763763442635536, 0.0041186753660440445, 0.012236882001161575, -0.03162430226802826, -0.008452176116406918, -0.019982662051916122, 0.0006469982326962054, -0.002687872853130102, -0.0024432663340121508, -0.038924284279346466, -0.015470144338905811, 0.0358232818543911, 0.014584268443286419, -0.01942933164536953, 0.04621333256363869, -0.03435708209872246, -0.01173963863402605, -0.018956521525979042, 0.05435352772474289, -0.024586329236626625, -0.014952494762837887, -0.00781475193798542, -0.022552184760570526, -0.024518059566617012, -0.014120473526418209, -0.0005195979028940201, -0.0066831232979893684, 0.0002561332075856626, 0.034021973609924316, 0.010133451782166958, -0.04547913372516632, 0.0014793847221881151, 0.01142913568764925, 0.04443374276161194, -0.023351717740297318, 0.010975886136293411, 0.036866605281829834, -0.0721556544303894, -0.0181184820830822, -0.003329899162054062, 0.002321765525266528, 0.023332765325903893, 0.04354377090930939, -0.022693321108818054, -0.002732733031734824, 0.05564688518643379, -0.02489054575562477, -0.027368862181901932, -0.02608056552708149, -0.0052180238999426365, -0.019526122137904167, 0.00758141465485096, 0.025788187980651855, -0.008057009428739548, 0.014840732328593731, 0.007899216376245022, 0.00968112237751484, -0.010340957902371883, 0.009273726493120193, -0.0038852973375469446, 0.016915448009967804, 0.019494669511914253, -0.008297516964375973, 0.009383720345795155, 0.021587740629911423, 0.056772030889987946, -0.008302140980958939, -0.018826492130756378, -0.005962808150798082, 0.002281127031892538, -0.088545061647892, -0.018618986010551453, -0.01967141218483448, 0.017245767638087273, 0.010428637266159058, -0.09166642278432846, 0.05025387182831764, 0.03339753672480583, -0.036889176815748215, -0.0003900898154824972, -0.049864448606967926, -0.001094420556910336, -0.02276778221130371, -0.0304883886128664, -0.01634453795850277, 0.012266808189451694, 0.029368381947278976, -0.006002841517329216, 0.0560498982667923, 0.01219108048826456, -0.030027242377400398, -0.05512692406773567, -0.02682364545762539, 0.020987320691347122, 0.036900825798511505, -0.06690540909767151, 0.0400208905339241, -0.041225820779800415, -0.06490010768175125, 0.036105625331401825, -0.011190238408744335, 0.007867144420742989, -0.026343170553445816, 0.01795969530940056, -0.0027900319546461105, 0.035852573812007904, 0.03239906206727028, -0.008576499298214912, 0.012373169884085655, -0.009324860759079456, 0.0027469845954328775, 0.011495359241962433, -0.01988361030817032, 0.05742564797401428, 0.01837148331105709, -0.024801727384328842, -0.0735929012298584, 0.012884057126939297, -0.006681588478386402, -0.029071172699332237, -0.018916931003332138, 0.00782620906829834, 0.021615497767925262, -0.07991809397935867, 0.024432597681879997, -0.03165052831172943, 0.012630532495677471, 0.03284022957086563, 0.047304634004831314, -0.01837388426065445, 0.006578667555004358, -0.00840888824313879, -0.015634967014193535, -0.0029414754826575518, 0.026647744700312614, -0.026494348421692848, -0.003272632835432887, -0.010142439976334572, 0.0029987862799316645, 0.026477620005607605, -0.04220449924468994, -0.019091682508587837, -0.05401020869612694, 0.025990307331085205, -0.02427828125655651, 0.005250582937151194, -0.03590238094329834, 0.0010328555945307016, 0.03365860506892204, -0.09045159816741943, 0.021436356008052826, 0.0093560004606843, 0.003457671031355858, -0.04462726414203644, -0.01694771833717823, -0.02453100122511387, -0.014466424472630024, 0.03764049708843231, 0.032088253647089005, -0.03498931974172592, 0.02826523222029209, 0.016226230189204216, -0.007210276089608669, -0.05162904039025307, 0.0058440943248569965, -0.0074426112696528435, -0.021235452964901924, -0.005811974406242371, 0.0045058829709887505, 0.02693207375705242, 0.03992956876754761, 0.009379453025758266, 0.0019021197222173214, -0.0229655671864748, 0.053965967148542404, 0.0011671168031170964, -0.0049549308605492115, -0.03539719805121422, -0.016126787289977074, 0.04900241643190384, 0.0039059689734131098, 0.0214148610830307, 0.031708575785160065, 0.004632672760635614, -0.030645636841654778, 0.030858248472213745, 0.004917752929031849, -0.00323122157715261, -0.014860372990369797, -0.0007798675214871764, -0.010673322714865208, -0.018051492050290108, -0.021602462977170944, 0.023157719522714615, -0.0648593083024025, -0.019983747974038124, 0.027981344610452652, 0.02699149213731289, 0.0534442737698555, 0.016639940440654755, 0.0318012461066246, 0.012802550569176674, -0.016241276636719704, 0.0018352506449446082, 0.02551325410604477, -0.0049174875020980835, 0.04801928251981735, 0.034902576357126236, -0.013467621989548206, -0.04889407008886337, 0.005927645601332188, -0.00042956287506967783, 0.024570617824792862, 0.0036665452644228935, -0.018463997170329094, 0.014876083470880985, -0.014573439955711365, -0.03455366939306259, -0.020711146295070648, -0.033674456179142, 0.04597899317741394, 0.0033027350436896086, 0.020086323842406273, -0.032065246254205704, -0.021774061024188995, -0.023279491811990738, 0.024130109697580338, -0.03872513398528099, -0.00014735863078385592, 0.02481997199356556, 0.03037286177277565, -0.0029246110934764147, -0.009737164713442326, 0.012628160417079926, -0.03964272513985634, 0.012827939353883266, -0.004740686155855656, -0.004731017164885998, -0.00785017665475607, 0.01807662658393383, -0.05059835687279701, -0.019215969368815422, 0.02779258042573929, 0.027230942621827126, 0.051465146243572235, -0.05085192993283272, -0.03743311017751694, 0.015529238618910313, 0.0020063738338649273, -0.023838143795728683, -0.020675187930464745, -0.0288747139275074, -0.021889086812734604, -0.014712532050907612, -0.01167262438684702 ]
<p>Given a data matrix like this:</p> <pre><code> [,1] [,2] [,3] [,4] [,5] [,6] [,7] [1,] 9.520 11.137 16.576 18.225 20.576 25.861 NA [2,] 9.005 9.491 11.106 16.530 18.184 20.495 25.773 [3,] 9.437 11.050 20.393 25.711 NA NA NA [4,] 9.442 11.058 20.411 25.711 NA NA NA [5,] 9.431 11.045 20.421 25.707 NA NA NA [6,] 9.461 11.052 20.319 25.657 NA NA NA [7,] 9.245 10.819 20.253 25.628 NA NA NA [8,] 9.229 10.801 20.216 25.594 NA NA NA [9,] 9.234 10.805 20.258 25.619 NA NA NA [10,] 9.241 10.814 20.264 25.626 NA NA NA [11,] 9.248 10.819 20.281 25.649 NA NA NA [12,] 9.231 10.800 20.219 25.567 NA NA NA </code></pre> <p>How do I get a data frame like this?:</p> <pre><code> S p1 p2 p3 p4 p5 p6 p7 1 NA 9.520 11.137 16.576 18.225 20.576 25.861 2 9.005 9.491 11.106 16.530 18.184 20.495 25.773 3 NA 9.437 11.050 NA NA 20.393 25.711 4 NA 9.442 11.058 NA NA 20.411 25.711 5 NA 9.431 11.045 NA NA 20.421 25.707 6 NA 9.461 11.052 NA NA 20.319 25.657 7 NA 9.245 10.819 NA NA 20.253 25.628 8 NA 9.229 10.801 NA NA 20.216 25.594 9 NA 9.234 10.805 NA NA 20.258 25.619 10 NA 9.241 10.814 NA NA 20.264 25.626 11 NA 9.248 10.819 NA NA 20.281 25.649 12 NA 9.231 10.800 NA NA 20.219 25.567 </code></pre> <p>In the matrix, each row represent the timepoints from 1 sample. The matrix is balanced with an arbitrary number of NAs as needed. In the dataframe, each column represents all the timepoints that are functionally equivalent. Timepoints in a single sample cannot be functionally equivalent. </p> <p>I think I should be able to solve this with some form of kmeans clustering that restricts each cluster from having more than one member from each sample. Any ideas?</p>
73,389
[ -0.029948977753520012, 0.046240705996751785, -0.014091363176703453, -0.019803980365395546, 0.017281560227274895, 0.011187775991857052, 0.004591829609125853, -0.03448420390486717, 0.02369263581931591, -0.033582329750061035, 0.05809980630874634, 0.08915283530950546, 0.0517975352704525, 0.01692529208958149, 0.036133117973804474, 0.002840597415342927, -0.010732323862612247, 0.014176944270730019, -0.014456134289503098, -0.018882514908909798, 0.009873028844594955, -0.00259420252405107, -0.0057033877819776535, -0.013760020956397057, -0.011165599338710308, 0.0257888063788414, 0.03232039883732796, -0.0015179705806076527, -0.012966598384082317, 0.051996681839227676, -0.03929869085550308, -0.02912341244518757, 0.0711035281419754, 0.009893672540783882, 0.02236049249768257, -0.014368372969329357, -0.013093416579067707, -0.0004350499075371772, -0.012600884772837162, 0.019750850275158882, -0.011444668285548687, -0.012915858067572117, 0.014128400012850761, 0.007752192672342062, -0.012742430903017521, 0.04618605598807335, -0.012179454788565636, 0.02902081608772278, 0.01841628924012184, -0.007577425800263882, 0.08307743817567825, 0.01425187848508358, 0.022548099979758263, 0.0075737489387393, -0.046395476907491684, 0.01647143065929413, 0.013394583016633987, 0.047811109572649, 0.0143499244004488, -0.061095915734767914, -0.012037006206810474, -0.005857172887772322, 0.008584574796259403, -0.025411436334252357, -0.02246122993528843, 0.009182590991258621, -0.04507351666688919, 0.014149175025522709, 0.017764955759048462, -0.07764363288879395, -0.024479683488607407, 0.005796986166387796, 0.04198303818702698, -0.02669403702020645, 0.0014933018246665597, -0.01037678774446249, 0.019011961296200752, -0.0037067593075335026, 0.049432482570409775, 0.010068024508655071, 0.02530723251402378, 0.05118386074900627, 0.034471478313207626, 0.014062155038118362, 0.03451630845665932, -0.016645612195134163, 0.05537939444184303, -0.03834086284041405, 0.032547056674957275, 0.027017543092370033, 0.031697485595941544, 0.0330362468957901, 0.03552580624818802, 0.057462871074676514, -0.012647602707147598, 0.028414517641067505, 0.024403952062129974, 0.011154092848300934, 0.004755693022161722, -0.033892784267663956, -0.02399958297610283, -0.04967610910534859, -0.01070035807788372, 0.022088149562478065, -0.024937598034739494, -0.01622455008327961, -0.03314158320426941, -0.011771388351917267, -0.04213380441069603, 0.002186959609389305, -0.004020805936306715, 0.0373103953897953, 0.009038462303578854, -0.016492577269673347, 0.031455136835575104, -0.08099288493394852, 0.006007040850818157, 0.009021490812301636, 0.04099864512681961, 0.07371019572019577, 0.0015006023459136486, -0.020355576649308205, 0.02296835370361805, -0.03329920023679733, -0.04562326893210411, -0.013369535095989704, -0.016057994216680527, -0.015937797725200653, 0.0019670468755066395, 0.006070556119084358, -0.07085438817739487, -0.03179054334759712, 0.06412958353757858, -0.02527470327913761, 0.03193537890911102, 0.005283401347696781, -0.08603621274232864, -0.045351993292570114, 0.04745916649699211, -0.046086110174655914, 0.004823222290724516, -0.049705080687999725, 0.04376491904258728, -0.006054708268493414, 0.04538928344845772, 0.01130998320877552, 0.008000791072845459, 0.05097755044698715, 0.01720689795911312, 0.00007817850564606488, -0.007426699157804251, 0.0024025398306548595, -0.021360784769058228, -0.017999833449721336, -0.014741955325007439, -0.056650325655937195, -0.023536257445812225, -0.004501477815210819, -0.009161979891359806, 0.019189702346920967, -0.0030531876254826784, -0.010649029165506363, 0.0027389887254685163, -0.03643021732568741, -0.0672413632273674, -0.0283367857336998, 0.02675495482981205, 0.02386801317334175, -0.015336292795836926, 0.03423098102211952, -0.0588945597410202, -0.001898968475870788, -0.013485491275787354, 0.033609434962272644, 0.04251868277788162, -0.0006325429421849549, 0.03149851784110069, 0.017756130546331406, 0.006191737949848175, 0.04572024941444397, -0.010813385248184204, -0.006457061506807804, 0.014290004037320614, -0.026039142161607742, 0.06826384365558624, 0.025645747780799866, 0.052714753895998, -0.02969401702284813, 0.028305374085903168, -0.05080872401595116, -0.015464029274880886, -0.05613211914896965, 0.0022913157008588314, 0.02177998051047325, -0.034048259258270264, -0.02405770868062973, 0.019890353083610535, 0.010070023126900196, 0.045887306332588196, -0.03449413180351257, -0.033010561019182205, -0.012505418621003628, 0.04451044276356697, -0.02991051971912384, -0.015405192039906979, 0.05011727660894394, 0.05760828033089638, -0.021386386826634407, 0.06285402923822403, -0.004828320350497961, 0.030584463849663734, 0.02784375660121441, -0.01715707965195179, -0.0037530246190726757, -0.01776309125125408, -0.022423842921853065, 0.011391893029212952, 0.012401778250932693, -0.03265487030148506, 0.04128461331129074, -0.06823059171438217, 0.019690878689289093, 0.04662662744522095, 0.05225498601794243, -0.010114595293998718, -0.05387762933969498, 0.01158000249415636, 0.05925390496850014, -0.03917250409722328, 0.0050420500338077545, -0.021839246153831482, 0.011830031871795654, 0.03140139952301979, 0.03179969638586044, -0.0630992129445076, 0.011235145851969719, 0.05603485926985741, 0.016254542395472527, 0.021739719435572624, 0.07211805880069733, -0.0166215468198061, -0.021899007260799408, 0.013905253261327744, -0.023901915177702904, 0.03229872137308121, -0.0016068235272541642, 0.003306032856926322, 0.037229157984256744, 0.047301921993494034, 0.0034628345165401697, -0.00692864740267396, 0.0008676667930558324, -0.0324983224272728, -0.03724982962012291, -0.0034253448247909546, -0.01171805988997221, 0.037188295274972916, 0.010756827890872955, -0.038561541587114334, 0.026831356808543205, 0.01868072897195816, -0.033987145870923996, -0.015341740101575851, -0.0008878895896486938, -0.029518084600567818, 0.06273004412651062, -0.02943379245698452, 0.013020194135606289, 0.031508952379226685, -0.008963251486420631, 0.04590721055865288, -0.027761828154325485, 0.013348878361284733, -0.05719204246997833, 0.012532314285635948, 0.05572041869163513, 0.010255631059408188, -0.011413617059588432, -0.015355617739260197, -0.010992542840540409, 0.038040272891521454, -0.02164047583937645, 0.045726314187049866, 0.000820500252302736, -0.05483909696340561, -0.012148186564445496, 0.02078477293252945, -0.027203300967812538, 0.08233112841844559, 0.024173278361558914, -0.05088881030678749, 0.025220515206456184, -0.006186253856867552, -0.014457693323493004, 0.0017173333326354623, -0.039243124425411224, 0.04353833198547363, -0.01922892965376377, 0.01572999358177185, 0.051067207008600235, -0.012269322760403156, -0.08138536661863327, -0.03279176726937294, -0.048139575868844986, -0.010970143601298332, -0.024414030835032463, 0.005731379147619009, 0.04569266363978386, 0.0003681602538563311, -0.005523380823433399, 0.036377161741256714, 0.000632811221294105, 0.0034761542920023203, -0.029393261298537254, -0.006470666266977787, -0.022695254534482956, 0.013836522586643696, -0.026301568374037743, 0.055827587842941284, 0.0010156190255656838, 0.0640021339058876, 0.005726408213376999, -0.042115017771720886, -0.03503607586026192, 0.0009118144516833127, -0.03549880534410477, -0.03129645437002182, 0.03944100812077522, 0.010770292021334171, 0.014457255601882935, -0.01773221790790558, -0.005902462173253298, 0.048834409564733505, 0.0602756142616272, -0.03923451900482178, 0.025979606434702873, 0.020148321986198425, -0.02458619698882103, -0.04537956044077873, 0.008662121370434761, 0.0023839501664042473, -0.008030862547457218, 0.025632888078689575, 0.005377324763685465, 0.015163564123213291, 0.0039980062283575535, -0.02835012786090374, -0.017255732789635658, -0.0005670478567481041, 0.041051872074604034, -0.03708087280392647, -0.002385461702942848, 0.0058455378748476505, -0.02739892527461052, 0.008400073274970055, 0.02773912064731121, 0.033845555037260056, -0.0175685603171587, -0.009375105611979961, 0.05740376561880112, 0.043347932398319244, -0.053254224359989166, 0.03824080899357796, 0.00777409877628088, -0.02078094147145748, -0.013913247734308243, -0.057864293456077576, -0.022882476449012756, 0.034363869577646255, 0.02214239165186882, 0.029161319136619568, 0.02505890466272831, -0.03032679483294487, 0.05202021822333336, -0.03607835993170738, 0.02103881537914276, -0.021498413756489754, 0.04611892253160477, 0.010297173634171486, 0.06403803080320358, -0.0010071484139189124, 0.0331055223941803, 0.027177419513463974, -0.004066485445946455, -0.04138108715415001, 0.020469458773732185, 0.035559579730033875, -0.004103683400899172, -0.0016669923206791282, -0.04038470238447189, 0.00923240277916193, -0.00662611098960042, 0.013557418249547482, 0.03404746204614639, -0.010976137593388557, -0.04504945129156113, 0.04138556495308876, -0.005585432983934879, 0.03063090518116951, -0.044366855174303055, 0.01914428360760212, 0.07060971856117249, -0.018326101824641228, 0.015446626581251621, 0.007442422676831484, -0.021753141656517982, 0.002233145758509636, -0.0004404025967232883, 0.035088472068309784, 0.028672926127910614, 0.00919868890196085, 0.027711309492588043, 0.022305458784103394, -0.02088877744972706, 0.0031602822709828615, -0.04544474929571152, 0.008198205381631851, 0.05289816856384277, -0.011948645114898682, -0.008906260132789612, -0.029649930074810982, 0.022825604304671288, -0.005101493094116449, 0.013913675211369991, -0.019548628479242325, 0.001631631050258875, 0.008668577298521996, 0.028529683127999306, -0.02672431245446205, 0.08323521167039871, 0.06695178151130676, 0.04918437451124191, 0.017267540097236633, -0.04554097354412079, -0.007630341220647097, -0.017230698838829994, -0.0014550879132002592, 0.010220433585345745, -0.004700543824583292, 0.023170745000243187, 0.015873808413743973, 0.009116563946008682, -0.046171579509973526, -0.007924219593405724, 0.008205005899071693, 0.006600141525268555, 0.04669952392578125, -0.02933347225189209, -0.03831101581454277, -0.017255036160349846, 0.043463513255119324, 0.031234290450811386, 0.01666593737900257, -0.011843911372125149, -0.11054551601409912, -0.0022492411080747843, 0.032602470368146896, 0.03136719390749931, -0.04152384027838707, -0.02749224565923214, -0.05960586667060852, 0.008378172293305397, 0.031234821304678917, -0.027480371296405792, 0.05205830931663513, -0.027157563716173172, -0.02335638552904129, -0.009212201461195946, 0.006434448063373566, -0.03445591405034065, 0.008390660397708416, -0.054545123130083084, 0.011127116158604622, -0.031282130628824234, -0.07026024162769318, -0.028618060052394867, 0.03028281405568123, -0.015221396461129189, 0.053983770310878754, -0.027454029768705368, -0.047576598823070526, 0.021428102627396584, -0.0011949874460697174, -0.005554159637540579, -0.017958298325538635, 0.024767372757196426, 0.02897684834897518, -0.027756989002227783, 0.06046132370829582, -0.022081270813941956, 0.008913367055356503, 0.016643619164824486, 0.0077977352775633335, 0.040960121899843216, 0.008246077224612236, 0.009905035607516766, 0.04039912298321724, 0.018692318350076675, 0.0028904294595122337, 0.03271203860640526, 0.017672915011644363, -0.04688486456871033, -0.0007168634911067784, -0.10928084701299667, -0.015438678674399853, -0.006343170069158077, -0.030491257086396217, -0.0805051252245903, 0.02284945361316204, 0.008327780291438103, 0.0402432419359684, 0.004400232806801796, 0.020135952159762383, -0.022968316450715065, 0.018632391467690468, 0.012454431504011154, 0.05006541311740875, -0.016086837276816368, -0.052395015954971313, 0.01680608280003071, 0.00044668695772998035, -0.014630389399826527, -0.03158676251769066, 0.03166227415204048, 0.002046366920694709, 0.0033716934267431498, 0.00882845651358366, -0.028260594233870506, 0.008918531239032745, -0.01589871011674404, -0.010609629563987255, -0.005265404004603624, -0.05967281386256218, 0.008445019833743572, 0.0024495553225278854, 0.04389198496937752, 0.043763644993305206, -0.03402171656489372, 0.013799170032143593, 0.04297483712434769, -0.013896279968321323, -0.008701205253601074, -0.048562563955783844, 0.04766826331615448, 0.00013342974125407636, -0.010763523168861866, -0.06387011706829071, -0.0600406751036644, 0.05459165945649147, 0.025644920766353607, -0.047142576426267624, -0.056904204189777374, -0.048569854348897934, -0.006826218217611313, -0.008704422041773796, -0.015524552203714848, -0.014869093894958496, -0.04803161323070526, -0.005986191798001528, -0.0002687963133212179, 0.0015398422256112099, 0.07097240537405014, 0.029334012418985367, 0.00618214625865221, 0.03213643282651901, -0.03437869995832443, -0.007241110783070326, 0.0008176419651135802, -0.023926518857479095, -0.031024636700749397, -0.013096408918499947, -0.03793104365468025, -0.009389199316501617, 0.05878303200006485, 0.01168488897383213, 0.003574071917682886, -0.01922019198536873, 0.0014517210656777024, 0.04162753000855446, -0.04526304081082344, -0.0075699035078287125, -0.05572844669222832, -0.0014692216645926237, -0.05018242821097374, 0.028046373277902603, -0.017557300627231598, 0.011777137406170368, 0.01875426433980465, -0.0068738884292542934, -0.008072775788605213, 0.038567882031202316, 0.04599188640713692, -0.02326861023902893, 0.009683428332209587, -0.022204337641596794, 0.013597648590803146, 0.0363425612449646, 0.0270994883030653, 0.026167428120970726, 0.009711568243801594, 0.015898719429969788, -0.030490504577755928, -0.04250824451446533, -0.035998355597257614, 0.025508057326078415, 0.01054726168513298, -0.01796012930572033, 0.012511667795479298, 0.054786812514066696, 0.015504329465329647, 0.006606992334127426, -0.019326983019709587, -0.00025057108723558486, -0.021837536245584488, 0.05254071578383446, 0.09140079468488693, -0.0021210392005741596, -0.028842110186815262, 0.05511782690882683, -0.008255673572421074, 0.030842090025544167, 0.02887149341404438, -0.02447388879954815, -0.053533535450696945, 0.015842176973819733, 0.013390174135565758, -0.017596358433365822, -0.027373112738132477, -0.015554656274616718, 0.015361601486802101, -0.02833864465355873, -0.0326855406165123, 0.018759049475193024, 0.009918761439621449, -0.0013530137948691845, -0.009129873476922512, -0.014425693079829216, -0.03331179544329643, -0.008548024110496044, 0.05119382217526436, -0.029942939057946205, 0.01656939461827278, 0.016771314665675163, 0.030322549864649773, -0.0272599458694458, 0.03567768633365631, -0.0434156209230423, -0.04297343268990517, -0.04194195568561554, -0.032430123537778854, -0.018769187852740288, 0.06411737948656082, 0.02160237543284893, -0.002457705559208989, 0.009747575968503952, -0.05668812617659569, 0.0014769722474738955, 0.024107418954372406, 0.010715355165302753, -0.03532278910279274, 0.06555595993995667, 0.0024997645523399115, 0.012458917684853077, 0.007316962815821171, -0.054612379521131516, 0.13066673278808594, 0.0735635757446289, 0.04046805202960968, -0.03566214069724083, 0.011910454370081425, 0.036080095916986465, -0.05687171593308449, -0.023740138858556747, -0.011395490728318691, 0.0329534076154232, 0.005695583764463663, 0.04927784949541092, 0.03996914625167847, 0.03368436172604561, 0.041960377246141434, 0.006515102926641703, -0.05683092400431633, 0.011506431736052036, -0.007518277037888765, -0.003967274911701679, -0.03877945616841316, -0.011884823441505432, -0.07145582139492035, -0.007706866599619389, 0.02216740883886814, 0.0008543947478756309, -0.05979272350668907, -0.0010323866736143827, -0.03202363848686218, 0.030273666605353355, -0.01114125456660986, 0.00227526668459177, -0.005508649628609419, 0.013258194550871849, 0.005333219654858112, 0.002412905218079686, 0.02156446874141693, -0.01118481531739235, -0.008932680822908878, 0.020115310326218605, 0.005480294581502676, 0.019655533134937286, -0.07104410231113434, 0.021088076755404472, -0.02554141730070114, 0.0038264605682343245, -0.02573378011584282, 0.02598739229142666, -0.01482231542468071, -0.023611435666680336, 0.009274539537727833, 0.034104663878679276, 0.018128734081983566, -0.03622082993388176, -0.002730349777266383, 0.030262600630521774, 0.02394450455904007, -0.008178317919373512, 0.012756770476698875, 0.02706870809197426, 0.012949643656611443, -0.014773090369999409, 0.02839137241244316, -0.0057855104096233845, 0.00794883444905281, -0.02639167755842209, -0.009259369224309921, 0.043252941220998764, 0.007889938540756702, 0.048051632940769196, 0.009257392957806587, -0.020490726456046104, -0.03888975828886032, -0.0379062220454216, 0.03589390963315964, 0.013992061838507652, -0.006493649911135435, 0.012257488444447517, -0.007453493773937225, 0.01006165612488985, 0.00386626529507339, 0.044258248060941696, -0.03330065310001373, -0.024141259491443634, -0.024730464443564415, 0.03041830286383629, 0.027775265276432037, 0.045865025371313095, 0.013198410160839558, 0.014925788156688213, 0.0032912245951592922, 0.05870501697063446, -0.012704310938715935, -0.042033616453409195, -0.03108643926680088, 0.010478299111127853, -0.012525414116680622, 0.02531025931239128, 0.013760927133262157, 0.04596193879842758, 0.04424779862165451, 0.0036777553614228964, -0.020699433982372284, 0.020983710885047913, -0.0009295889758504927, -0.027372078970074654, 0.0029795148875564337, -0.014164839871227741, 0.02574933134019375, 0.02132847160100937, -0.004043196327984333, -0.04312429949641228, 0.024872949346899986, -0.0216120146214962, -0.03855137899518013, -0.01129206269979477, 0.01711948774755001, -0.035297736525535583, 0.03158283233642578, 0.00410862872377038, -0.02101052738726139, -0.02190316468477249, -0.0016099826898425817, -0.03463580086827278, 0.0034664024133235216, -0.04880432412028313, -0.02395504340529442, -0.03877608850598335, 0.014926454983651638, -0.053023599088191986, -0.019219283014535904, 0.03432432934641838, -0.0028349084313958883, 0.008727817796170712, -0.015056760981678963, 0.0062645310536026955, 0.022936183959245682, 0.030076581984758377, 0.006252010818570852, -0.03838852792978287, -0.006964037660509348, -0.06426995247602463, -0.037412695586681366, -0.0081115011125803, -0.026290489360690117, 0.0510462187230587, -0.008762218989431858, 0.009066115133464336, -0.004410737659782171, 0.05101960152387619, -0.009702763520181179, -0.011041118763387203, -0.03728857636451721, -0.0011654339032247663, 0.0016988154966384172, 0.013251923955976963, 0.02141938917338848, -0.012504959478974342, -0.011172281578183174, 0.013608192093670368, 0.04871295392513275, -0.006438523065298796, -0.01444316003471613, 0.006344859953969717, -0.029116405174136162, 0.017747852951288223, 0.008354092948138714, 0.0035602860152721405, 0.02830648049712181, 0.007650912739336491, -0.00671108765527606, 0.013377683237195015, -0.014418133534491062, 0.0075786905363202095, -0.10143136233091354, -0.03808250650763512, 0.005818121135234833, -0.02426094003021717, 0.023841379210352898, -0.029014380648732185, 0.015491029247641563, -0.0034951239358633757, -0.03828291967511177, 0.030496681109070778, 0.001252601039595902, 0.018165282905101776, 0.0004030750715173781, 0.041312042623758316, -0.041536346077919006, 0.03102368861436844, 0.044973570853471756, 0.0503540076315403, 0.05248855799436569, 0.0208438690751791, 0.02814863808453083, -0.02384241484105587, -0.02253386192023754, 0.0008083253633230925, 0.015663931146264076, -0.052839238196611404, -0.03554201498627663, -0.024424497038125992, 0.009326465427875519, -0.002530009252950549, -0.0069883037358522415, -0.010707369074225426, -0.011595066636800766, 0.02095663920044899, -0.0025799672584980726, 0.052645713090896606, -0.00041777570731937885, 0.02903720736503601, -0.034240346401929855, -0.015970323234796524, -0.0020324070937931538, -0.023423349484801292, 0.00180909619666636, 0.03222624957561493, 0.010577240958809853, 0.013146668672561646, -0.003403122304007411, 0.0035395200829952955, -0.04476683959364891, 0.019886180758476257, -0.04778965562582016, 0.015112950466573238, 0.008447516709566116, -0.047403402626514435, 0.000622496590949595, -0.018653225153684616, 0.015292171388864517, 0.00992001686245203, 0.013091273605823517, -0.016052938997745514, 0.04885971546173096, 0.008509736508131027, -0.03953437879681587, -0.012273100204765797, 0.030792251229286194, 0.015616373158991337, -0.04432130232453346, -0.06690245121717453, 0.03868051990866661, -0.03273812308907509, 0.0050810216926038265, 0.015383933670818806, -0.04051673412322998, 0.023561011999845505, 0.011404271237552166, 0.007258690893650055, 0.036989204585552216, 0.02388135902583599, 0.03333738073706627, -0.06199885159730911, 0.020046282559633255, 0.012141714803874493, 0.00649484945461154, -0.05921054258942604, -0.012952744029462337, -0.03781038150191307, 0.0721389651298523, 0.04018009081482887, 0.01881217584013939, 0.015364027582108974, -0.0285597275942564, 0.04769450053572655, 0.0298902690410614, -0.0482441671192646, 0.03810929134488106, 0.019673915579915047, -0.03226452320814133, -0.01563517190515995, -0.02031691186130047, 0.02055407129228115, 0.001707143266685307, -0.010441337712109089, 0.0012829744955524802, -0.04479227587580681, -0.0029127972666174173, -0.047927625477313995, -0.021645305678248405, 0.013501063920557499, -0.02131207101047039, 0.03214777261018753, 0.018101278692483902, 0.027043888345360756, 0.06739409267902374, 0.001961668487638235, -0.01634461246430874, -0.0042701661586761475, -0.077371746301651, 0.016976328566670418, -0.011129654943943024, -0.03177866339683533, 0.008867407217621803, -0.0639871284365654, 0.02405003271996975, 0.004630302544683218, -0.023539219051599503, -0.032822154462337494, 0.02142021246254444, -0.006518573500216007, 0.010777732357382774, -0.011345011182129383, 0.018278520554304123, -0.028529342263936996, -0.025133920833468437, 0.02696649357676506, 0.018093910068273544, 0.019270282238721848, -0.044724833220243454, 0.026202954351902008, 0.0023056750651448965, -0.017789309844374657, 0.0036852313205599785, -0.027656758204102516, 0.07741782069206238, -0.012390268966555595, 0.01891852170228958, 0.037750255316495895, -0.0220747459679842, 0.011707568541169167, -0.012077700346708298, -0.015539134852588177, -0.002636329038068652, -0.00741913728415966, 0.017719615250825882, -0.022507071495056152, -0.002580818487331271, -0.014580006711184978, -0.0165142510086298, -0.04131560027599335, 0.02021821215748787, -0.017203375697135925, 0.014640076085925102, 0.03431030735373497, -0.01794457621872425, -0.007960102520883083, 0.008776471018791199, 0.0011589318746700883, -0.029163172468543053, 0.047677669674158096, -0.026111997663974762, 0.007974358275532722, -0.006239376962184906, -0.013517388142645359, 0.015367822721600533, -0.030231740325689316, -0.023108983412384987, -0.05209943652153015, 0.015202135778963566, -0.0004249128687661141, 0.005298052914440632, -0.02105233073234558, -0.03560547158122063, -0.02998078614473343, 0.017810123041272163, 0.009213886223733425, -0.02258221246302128 ]
<p>I am trying to fit a model investigating the amount of the loan (or a transformation of it) as a function of the the variables <code>income</code>, <code>gender</code>, <code>customer</code> and <code>age</code>.</p> <p>Fitting a standard linear regression gives poor results (R-squared of only 0.27). Besides, the relationship between income and loan seems quite weird. It has a sort of left-rotated Z-shape</p> <p>Would be appropriate to use a semiparametric model here? And so yes, how would you model it?</p> <p>I tried this: </p> <pre><code>model &lt;- spm(loan~f(income, basis="trunc.poly")+age+factor(gender)+factor(customer)) </code></pre> <p>But this gave poor results (no significant variables).</p> <p>Anyone has suggestions?</p> <p>Many thanks in advance.</p>
73,390
[ -0.005802972707897425, -0.024013638496398926, -0.011076156981289387, 0.00786341167986393, 0.0470263697206974, -0.03495294600725174, -0.007190869655460119, -0.001840326120145619, 0.013214271515607834, 0.005989109165966511, 0.03496799245476723, 0.05967568978667259, 0.06012372300028801, 0.0054848468862473965, 0.019421275705099106, 0.00969651434570551, -0.015641773119568825, -0.020763639360666275, -0.004396818112581968, 0.011281381361186504, 0.00441074650734663, 0.00444587180390954, 0.002978286938741803, -0.00431698327884078, 0.00036111942608840764, 0.017505157738924026, 0.010762078687548637, -0.03424529731273651, -0.009348124265670776, 0.01669164001941681, -0.010327782481908798, -0.03854556009173393, 0.009382139891386032, 0.03598858043551445, 0.018705984577536583, 0.024240611121058464, -0.0261326152831316, -0.02600526064634323, -0.002168945036828518, 0.023838048800826073, 0.007640576921403408, 0.01989789493381977, 0.01584986411035061, 0.03385939821600914, 0.0002231254184152931, 0.03628963604569435, 0.0015326892025768757, 0.026054788380861282, 0.07030361890792847, -0.03919096663594246, 0.07206454128026962, 0.00554220424965024, 0.012710317969322205, 0.011863859370350838, -0.00811679381877184, -0.04111195728182793, 0.06326824426651001, 0.07094074785709381, -0.014437181875109673, -0.05145041272044182, -0.01015391107648611, -0.036022063344717026, 0.009674383327364922, -0.03799265995621681, -0.039885152131319046, -0.015227308496832848, -0.007219268940389156, -0.016580143943428993, 0.024543816223740578, -0.04399236664175987, 0.04113562032580376, -0.013592805713415146, 0.01636037603020668, -0.0006720344536006451, -0.021997904404997826, -0.051358167082071304, -0.004857433028519154, 0.032730840146541595, 0.04272616654634476, -0.012795621529221535, -0.008729040622711182, 0.009289011359214783, -0.007703643292188644, 0.031369127333164215, -0.001493410556577146, -0.04893268644809723, 0.07150392234325409, 0.012444697320461273, 0.021244848147034645, 0.02146208845078945, 0.0017463016556575894, 0.013714615255594254, 0.043025389313697815, -0.00006386741006281227, -0.041967011988162994, 0.035869523882865906, -0.010844321921467781, 0.02901574969291687, 0.027821259573101997, -0.02042216993868351, -0.0193387009203434, -0.03229420259594917, -0.013862659223377705, 0.03274745121598244, -0.021177005022764206, 0.011028699576854706, 0.0037885173223912716, -0.00474932324141264, -0.011670681647956371, -0.043969783931970596, -0.03388094902038574, 0.04827188327908516, 0.0025426517240703106, -0.017909297719597816, 0.006700539495795965, -0.026649832725524902, -0.029909498989582062, -0.01099453680217266, 0.021969644352793694, 0.05801502615213394, 0.027750251814723015, -0.03192133083939552, 0.014465945772826672, -0.0034554468002170324, -0.03966327756643295, 0.03380170091986656, -0.0009742066613398492, -0.03144675865769386, -0.025170709937810898, 0.039522815495729446, 0.010319155640900135, -0.026847030967473984, 0.02664240077137947, 0.029902085661888123, -0.0002341800427529961, -0.0077577573247253895, -0.06736207008361816, -0.05957351252436638, -0.002804152201861143, 0.008446754887700081, 0.06494700908660889, -0.053693987429142, 0.005431637167930603, 0.021980538964271545, 0.0778699666261673, -0.00028168983408249915, 0.028856193646788597, -0.0097741624340415, 0.021065104752779007, -0.005517840851098299, -0.04490264132618904, -0.01699204370379448, -0.04640553519129753, -0.01481140498071909, 0.006833416875451803, -0.020869655534625053, 0.01332723256200552, 0.021513093262910843, 0.012396243400871754, -0.01862282305955887, 0.04565254598855972, 0.012954230420291424, -0.041215457022190094, -0.025174250826239586, -0.03922824561595917, -0.011748874559998512, 0.03851507231593132, -0.026788832619786263, 0.026106426492333412, 0.006399767939001322, -0.023731453344225883, 0.02658017724752426, 0.02903185412287712, 0.05080505087971687, 0.05116024613380432, -0.024224678054451942, -0.001036158879287541, -0.007300783414393663, 0.030709825456142426, 0.028005696833133698, -0.06717441231012344, -0.03072129562497139, -0.031483087688684464, -0.01780318282544613, -0.0028065359219908714, 0.02654060162603855, -0.01427492406219244, -0.0530499666929245, 0.018110856413841248, -0.039734501391649246, -0.07891024649143219, -0.04796439781785011, 0.005966667551547289, -0.025153739377856255, -0.0026244125328958035, 0.004386070650070906, -0.0009390197810716927, 0.059707120060920715, -0.018038729205727577, 0.00315815769135952, -0.04880711808800697, -0.0028434202540665865, 0.026080399751663208, -0.03446954861283302, 0.0159685667604208, 0.02895279787480831, 0.024042263627052307, -0.022173529490828514, 0.028633732348680496, -0.033754538744688034, -0.027633491903543472, 0.008191450498998165, -0.042853519320487976, 0.012641552835702896, -0.03531545028090477, -0.014134624972939491, 0.014161846600472927, 0.00745887728407979, 0.02248738706111908, 0.06762980669736862, -0.03696684166789055, 0.023163652047514915, 0.10864600539207458, 0.02568059042096138, -0.00025359136634506285, -0.0038784241769462824, -0.000720291631296277, 0.0626460462808609, -0.034771427512168884, -0.018568627536296844, -0.02710689790546894, -0.019306104630231857, 0.06398595124483109, -0.003923495300114155, -0.025015195831656456, -0.019194811582565308, 0.06318698823451996, 0.022395318374037743, 0.005094326101243496, 0.009652710519731045, -0.01658542826771736, -0.00043381284922361374, 0.000966050720307976, -0.001265568076632917, 0.0320560447871685, 0.01013015303760767, 0.0172562412917614, -0.0010877948952838778, 0.016752293333411217, -0.02387041226029396, 0.014645597897469997, 0.06548800319433212, -0.006221795454621315, 0.028715556487441063, -0.014789162203669548, -0.002469004364684224, 0.04673410579562187, -0.041370972990989685, -0.01773895137012005, 0.036333393305540085, -0.020274460315704346, -0.009984915144741535, 0.011423371732234955, -0.011327924206852913, -0.011172985658049583, 0.02433706447482109, -0.002116184215992689, -0.00046323766582645476, 0.007667750120162964, -0.03444075956940651, -0.010208254680037498, -0.00436702836304903, -0.03729838877916336, -0.04496658965945244, 0.0072562298737466335, 0.01511403452605009, 0.0002933623909484595, 0.04030492901802063, -0.003973361104726791, -0.016234496608376503, 0.025577740743756294, -0.005434844642877579, 0.004998303018510342, -0.00430923281237483, -0.07091616094112396, -0.0015076575800776482, 0.01847400888800621, -0.013815763406455517, 0.03445203974843025, 0.012280437164008617, 0.0016141593223437667, 0.018498700112104416, -0.009789166040718555, -0.015581054612994194, -0.026996487751603127, -0.027530880644917488, -0.0004673290532082319, -0.033076368272304535, -0.02843349613249302, 0.021407457068562508, 0.007702406030148268, -0.02337406389415264, 0.014030247926712036, -0.04232718423008919, -0.040253106504678726, 0.007721900474280119, -0.015064763836562634, 0.00009247030538972467, 0.03234409540891647, 0.011845752596855164, 0.02932344190776348, -0.010593396611511707, 0.01061563566327095, -0.061468712985515594, -0.04015865549445152, 0.02709973230957985, 0.010980425402522087, 0.03507627919316292, 0.01073713880032301, 0.0050238254480063915, 0.05028366297483444, 0.030764006078243256, -0.010255170054733753, -0.09197405725717545, -0.019182417541742325, -0.020715074613690376, -0.03266945853829384, 0.06503311544656754, 0.057077955454587936, 0.004234661348164082, 0.04078331217169762, -0.007082030177116394, 0.025507016107439995, 0.020526330918073654, -0.0036907109897583723, 0.010539685375988483, 0.01011591125279665, -0.037236496806144714, -0.016588004305958748, 0.01529880240559578, 0.015463159419596195, -0.030760591849684715, 0.014912828803062439, -0.017407655715942383, 0.005509363021701574, -0.006933222990483046, -0.05011942982673645, -0.020477764308452606, -0.014877105131745338, -0.021219005808234215, -0.021953541785478592, 0.026140844449400902, 0.014135411940515041, -0.04493462294340134, 0.02641509287059307, 0.006899520754814148, 0.0542900525033474, 0.0032482268288731575, 0.019088275730609894, 0.08680412173271179, 0.02388540469110012, 0.0020924988202750683, 0.034402329474687576, -0.024249032139778137, 0.023683935403823853, 0.027045227587223053, -0.007337851915508509, -0.02426855079829693, 0.03158510848879814, 0.07382034510374069, 0.012074146419763565, -0.009412368759512901, -0.026431716978549957, 0.0397113673388958, -0.09715443104505539, 0.02888353355228901, -0.021388929337263107, 0.06197333335876465, 0.042046550661325455, 0.03760097548365593, 0.028245849534869194, 0.01433567050844431, 0.013775741681456566, 0.013124480843544006, -0.06469691544771194, 0.03883453458547592, -0.0026527284644544125, 0.02874685451388359, -0.02172010950744152, 0.02423815056681633, 0.03431703895330429, -0.019722066819667816, 0.04053620249032974, 0.010926803573966026, 0.03938210383057594, 0.005359018687158823, 0.019007856026291847, 0.0031880191527307034, 0.018999282270669937, 0.03036431036889553, -0.014521013014018536, 0.03976576402783394, -0.03280936926603317, -0.0062867081724107265, 0.04735806956887245, -0.006242077797651291, -0.031930018216371536, -0.03354525566101074, 0.005135350860655308, 0.005021901801228523, 0.05771557241678238, 0.0062219854444265366, 0.0020196738187223673, -0.027859775349497795, 0.019505934789776802, -0.007725899573415518, -0.017813127487897873, 0.012058025225996971, -0.017568498849868774, -0.027851073071360588, -0.024078017100691795, -0.01111991424113512, -0.010021718218922615, -0.015016971156001091, 0.012431897222995758, -0.011037844233214855, 0.08853505551815033, 0.04607252776622772, -0.03362440690398216, 0.014985164627432823, 0.08197037130594254, 0.0410105399787426, 0.0032151949126273394, -0.05473105609416962, 0.006368089001625776, -0.03583696112036705, 0.010229285806417465, 0.053480397909879684, 0.0224081389605999, 0.012206326238811016, 0.010957968421280384, 0.027124572545289993, -0.042527928948402405, -0.012940901331603527, 0.027401423081755638, 0.0237779188901186, 0.07241766899824142, 0.03140079602599144, -0.03393232449889183, -0.0010083401575684547, 0.05376268923282623, 0.026971042156219482, 0.02260373719036579, -0.047668568789958954, -0.12672506272792816, -0.0017127086175605655, 0.043130479753017426, 0.012975876219570637, -0.0478871688246727, -0.0545983612537384, -0.03078898787498474, -0.008979995734989643, 0.01581132784485817, -0.027215298265218735, -0.006129495333880186, 0.00749622005969286, -0.00041161509579978883, -0.022672448307275772, -0.039585817605257034, -0.04632261022925377, 0.023380449041724205, -0.03500622883439064, -0.002042762003839016, -0.03545904532074928, -0.0583045668900013, -0.04527368023991585, 0.023180080577731133, 0.04431597888469696, 0.040800418704748154, -0.010672338306903839, -0.020945794880390167, 0.0176256000995636, 0.027735669165849686, -0.03581913933157921, -0.06752980500459671, 0.005824163090437651, -0.009114638902246952, -0.0029572637286037207, 0.0427449494600296, 0.005772673059254885, -0.0370451956987381, 0.014287449419498444, 0.023307574912905693, -0.00629442697390914, -0.012164187617599964, -0.0368293821811676, 0.00700696324929595, 0.039265070110559464, 0.020506631582975388, 0.046354468911886215, 0.022473854944109917, -0.02289026416838169, 0.0026599273551255465, -0.031228497624397278, -0.031681206077337265, -0.004289568401873112, 0.0037122927606105804, -0.0667252242565155, 0.025472106412053108, -0.007720775902271271, 0.019209524616599083, -0.012656813487410545, 0.04781602323055267, -0.0651581659913063, 0.012403666041791439, 0.026125764474272728, 0.03129172325134277, -0.004688538610935211, -0.005460728425532579, 0.014538098126649857, -0.019639484584331512, -0.0034050403628498316, -0.04122798889875412, -0.011574492789804935, -0.017646770924329758, 0.010954746976494789, -0.02362923137843609, -0.02516758441925049, 0.013221602886915207, 0.00824862439185381, -0.03537570312619209, 0.02515585348010063, -0.04287349805235863, 0.018730314448475838, -0.030203744769096375, 0.05613863840699196, 0.030549442395567894, -0.04601330682635307, 0.0426463857293129, 0.037898916751146317, 0.03036859631538391, -0.004457028117030859, -0.02355215698480606, 0.03794366121292114, 0.008543399162590504, -0.025065675377845764, -0.028309106826782227, -0.06694809347391129, 0.03149453550577164, -0.018915077671408653, -0.013695408590137959, -0.026228969916701317, -0.002038161037489772, -0.020107241347432137, -0.0020509909372776747, 0.009916181676089764, 0.013193815015256405, -0.023334987461566925, 0.0007400522008538246, -0.03286747261881828, 0.013661776669323444, 0.03784938529133797, -0.0028129792772233486, 0.01512011606246233, 0.00873873196542263, -0.01793821156024933, -0.03705118969082832, 0.01389867253601551, -0.012841783463954926, -0.03995897248387337, -0.004268282558768988, -0.045867111533880234, -0.008118939585983753, 0.06802377849817276, -0.021871626377105713, 0.006076458841562271, -0.024768618866801262, -0.019925303757190704, 0.0017736011650413275, -0.016205502673983574, -0.003032451029866934, 0.007170822471380234, -0.0030804460402578115, -0.029067400842905045, 0.002167448401451111, -0.05287708714604378, 0.01394116971641779, 0.0044195824302732944, 0.031446609646081924, -0.017543409019708633, 0.03468841686844826, 0.07540489733219147, 0.015897611156105995, 0.018215371295809746, -0.0037591075524687767, 0.008286813274025917, 0.04754263162612915, 0.04765259847044945, 0.01743282563984394, 0.009458906017243862, 0.048918481916189194, -0.06779664009809494, -0.03418277949094772, -0.05066347494721413, -0.017635663971304893, 0.05276206135749817, -0.01359536126255989, 0.04002901539206505, 0.04101363196969032, 0.0006082472973503172, -0.020448248833417892, 0.002652876079082489, 0.005961079150438309, -0.007148815784603357, 0.030841238796710968, 0.04393303394317627, -0.03161197528243065, 0.02376529388129711, 0.02731149084866047, 0.007649289444088936, 0.039896003901958466, 0.06674923002719879, 0.014211855828762054, -0.019550828263163567, 0.036251407116651535, -0.0205733310431242, -0.05987260118126869, 0.04578058421611786, 0.002116878516972065, 0.018101222813129425, -0.04846887290477753, -0.00696708494797349, 0.057579778134822845, 0.05290753021836281, 0.031217264011502266, -0.04982943460345268, -0.002788315061479807, -0.037734296172857285, -0.028086721897125244, 0.030077729374170303, -0.029647601768374443, 0.04749653860926628, 0.009168722666800022, 0.04735451191663742, -0.008765500970184803, 0.04644430801272392, -0.046530526131391525, -0.09271950274705887, -0.005075096618384123, -0.02729342319071293, -0.019762761890888214, 0.013009520247578621, -0.004798405338078737, -0.0023119503166526556, 0.011748229153454304, -0.05074385926127434, 0.005510719493031502, 0.006221211515367031, -0.0021893340162932873, 0.008368655107915401, 0.05000019446015358, -0.011012531816959381, -0.0034801482688635588, -0.03648585453629494, -0.004856951534748077, 0.11215677857398987, 0.07812878489494324, 0.02130071073770523, -0.04396086931228638, -0.014502270147204399, -0.007383372168987989, -0.029018012806773186, 0.014798224903643131, -0.0024276478216052055, 0.011786374263465405, -0.007487516384571791, 0.04757373780012131, 0.07438556104898453, 0.016875052824616432, 0.010166541673243046, 0.014335370622575283, -0.052780166268348694, -0.00678057037293911, 0.03176972642540932, -0.03393591195344925, -0.001444814377464354, -0.04174097999930382, -0.06013757362961769, 0.019124018028378487, 0.016864212229847908, -0.04937417060136795, -0.038729459047317505, 0.003309290623292327, 0.008952186442911625, -0.020289504900574684, -0.023726407438516617, 0.016493620350956917, -0.005992920137941837, 0.02604304999113083, 0.003858250565826893, 0.003955472726374865, 0.008385888300836086, -0.04181543365120888, -0.004483840428292751, 0.06313338875770569, -0.017101997509598732, 0.00016749055066611618, 0.005460813175886869, -0.024597397074103355, -0.05867008492350578, -0.03933972120285034, -0.028408342972397804, 0.010093988850712776, 0.0009939769515767694, -0.007895550690591335, -0.028910860419273376, 0.0542575903236866, 0.024040713906288147, -0.042917586863040924, -0.040851984173059464, 0.06049136444926262, 0.005242472980171442, 0.0014710744144394994, 0.00784504134207964, 0.016083955764770508, -0.00889635644853115, -0.0072377524338662624, 0.00018239894416183233, 0.060715556144714355, 0.0022297934629023075, -0.013584163971245289, -0.07285439223051071, 0.04187729209661484, -0.03802712261676788, -0.010873612016439438, 0.04632691293954849, 0.0012823462020605803, -0.017820799723267555, 0.005797394551336765, 0.04464706778526306, 0.02231633849442005, -0.002089555375277996, -0.062443654984235764, 0.027170846238732338, -0.053300078958272934, -0.02412424609065056, 0.042784303426742554, -0.0024730947334319353, 0.0011757342144846916, -0.015939362347126007, 0.029426543042063713, 0.008976686745882034, 0.01932472363114357, 0.008442988619208336, -0.011356879025697708, -0.015025458298623562, 0.03374110907316208, 0.020915845409035683, -0.04459824040532112, -0.019345123320817947, -0.020724613219499588, -0.025130150839686394, -0.012551144696772099, -0.024546166881918907, 0.07978389412164688, 0.028961917385458946, 0.02494145929813385, -0.006103327963501215, 0.010463648475706577, -0.0175040103495121, -0.006277210544794798, 0.04039672762155533, -0.0707811489701271, 0.022210892289876938, -0.03907587379217148, 0.0013016846496611834, -0.0183818731456995, 0.025906600058078766, -0.006967667955905199, -0.05620984733104706, 0.03546451777219772, -0.0028805809561163187, -0.018330402672290802, 0.042029138654470444, -0.02424553968012333, 0.014464824460446835, -0.0337432362139225, 0.005604009609669447, -0.052362050861120224, -0.009511115029454231, 0.020739974454045296, 0.009310686960816383, 0.010490071959793568, 0.02782067283987999, -0.023020543158054352, 0.020240938290953636, 0.014578200876712799, -0.0037712398916482925, 0.018704291433095932, -0.014849793165922165, 0.016591735184192657, 0.012648927047848701, 0.020495682954788208, -0.016109636053442955, -0.031032582744956017, 0.005634428467601538, -0.03673682361841202, -0.002838095650076866, -0.01716485060751438, 0.008707542903721333, 0.039914023131132126, -0.007686251308768988, 0.0032700004521757364, -0.015403548255562782, 0.01825008913874626, -0.011050005443394184, -0.026203535497188568, -0.016954002901911736, 0.007026832550764084, 0.018677514046430588, -0.017940685153007507, -0.011288375593721867, -0.02883903868496418, 0.0003982892376370728, 0.02172176167368889, 0.0707315132021904, 0.0073392647318542, -0.0018344834679737687, 0.0028264119755476713, 0.0014762236969545484, -0.013694937340915203, 0.004895832389593124, 0.0014022960094735026, 0.05153157189488411, 0.004667417146265507, -0.03611728176474571, 0.03125490993261337, -0.01880238950252533, 0.026568090543150902, -0.10368816554546356, -0.049584176391363144, -0.004379417281597853, 0.00009358661918668076, 0.013760250061750412, -0.07244186848402023, 0.00542919896543026, -0.010393365286290646, -0.04673710837960243, 0.0055458517745137215, -0.012069489806890488, 0.016820820048451424, -0.027907878160476685, -0.005652685649693012, 0.0026629685889929533, 0.019706154242157936, 0.0315830372273922, 0.06806257367134094, 0.0631602331995964, -0.0018524391343817115, 0.0007603281410411, -0.0036502487491816282, -0.008203755132853985, 0.007902070879936218, -0.00220177648589015, -0.050664857029914856, -0.0041992501355707645, -0.014559938572347164, -0.01590987667441368, 0.029040636494755745, 0.027260225266218185, 0.05220174416899681, 0.015974223613739014, 0.0375046543776989, 0.04866335541009903, 0.07303696125745773, 0.06898081302642822, -0.003086227923631668, -0.03388417884707451, -0.0035736190620809793, -0.008721482940018177, 0.028117584064602852, -0.027356188744306564, 0.023611411452293396, 0.0024668783880770206, 0.008847800083458424, -0.005884760059416294, -0.03939337655901909, -0.012601340189576149, 0.002993824193254113, -0.005208681337535381, -0.054629381746053696, 0.002612003358080983, -0.04235649108886719, 0.024851668626070023, -0.012338091619312763, -0.025950705632567406, 0.03546485677361488, 0.05485639348626137, -0.01563318818807602, 0.02656668797135353, -0.0035356618463993073, -0.06290144473314285, -0.01913013868033886, -0.008231204003095627, -0.0173946525901556, -0.04348355531692505, -0.0037724622525274754, -0.0060623628087341785, -0.013912475667893887, -0.03993131220340729, 0.012422102503478527, -0.009478901512920856, 0.04716978222131729, -0.03701300546526909, 0.008529653772711754, 0.06063801422715187, -0.04199981316924095, 0.04434902220964432, -0.06251210719347, 0.06553792953491211, 0.005404513329267502, 0.0061400532722473145, 0.007127917837351561, -0.008138098753988743, -0.01461117621511221, -0.013185556046664715, 0.07748346030712128, -0.014984391629695892, 0.014621350914239883, -0.05483982339501381, 0.01403376366943121, 0.009939534589648247, -0.02606646716594696, 0.03932257369160652, 0.02771693281829357, -0.017997445538640022, -0.010656740516424179, -0.014935413375496864, 0.008003251627087593, -0.008701685816049576, 0.025106944143772125, -0.00857316143810749, 0.008375954814255238, -0.00815587304532528, -0.033534176647663116, -0.015210489742457867, 0.004446330014616251, -0.029059352353215218, 0.05041651427745819, 0.015997543931007385, -0.012019267305731773, 0.015922510996460915, 0.004440862685441971, -0.06963497400283813, 0.02522781305015087, -0.026783568784594536, 0.026374835520982742, 0.01088146772235632, -0.006051891017705202, 0.018060768023133278, -0.04566548764705658, 0.030105343088507652, 0.04732561483979225, -0.053482815623283386, -0.011659127660095692, 0.01880943588912487, 0.021108578890562057, 0.009090536274015903, -0.030356954783201218, 0.0029992598574608564, -0.0039522890001535416, -0.03843424469232559, 0.013202553614974022, 0.015367994084954262, 0.01749933324754238, -0.013479520566761494, 0.014300056733191013, 0.03335365280508995, 0.0002948651381302625, 0.001460418337956071, 0.013169398531317711, 0.044457338750362396, -0.024143729358911514, 0.004602852743119001, 0.006910391617566347, -0.006658127997070551, 0.032606180757284164, -0.018468620255589485, -0.033998604863882065, 0.05990631505846977, -0.006334762088954449, -0.0057709417305886745, -0.047796621918678284, 0.013261080719530582, -0.07067174464464188, 0.005376176908612251, 0.014701769687235355, 0.027386916801333427, 0.020459318533539772, -0.0007241159910336137, 0.011844929307699203, -0.020127728581428528, 0.021496882662177086, 0.010506839491426945, 0.0010986090637743473, -0.026687396690249443, -0.015923144295811653, -0.006616194732487202, -0.011060520075261593, -0.017234088853001595, -0.044534627348184586, 0.07366751879453659, 0.0385211780667305, 0.016631729900836945, -0.029943574219942093, -0.002263139234855771, 0.007197519764304161, 0.059918247163295746, -0.07248551398515701, -0.0386887788772583, -0.04918981343507767, -0.02350033074617386, 0.010784310288727283, -0.011835448443889618 ]
<p>I am an anthropology student. I am researching the inter-relatedness of most if not all humans as part of my studies. I personally have an interest in statistics and probability theory and I have used it in regards to this topic. Before I explain my theory, I received the following from a computer scientist that I wish to share to better give a background idea of what I’m trying to put forward:<br> If there were random intermixing, then we would each have ~1 million ancestors living in 1500 AD, out of a world population of ~500 million. So the fractional overlap between two people would be about 1/500th.</p> <p>But the probability that two people share at least one common ancestor would be essentially 100%. Basically, you are choosing a random number between 1 and 500 a million times and you're asking whether you ever choose number 500. In a million trials, we expect this to happen 2000 times. So that it happens at least once is guaranteed.</p> <p>If we get rid of the random intermixing, the fractional overlap will drop to much less than 1/500th. But I suspect that the probability of at least one overlap will remain very high. If the population in 1500 was 500 million, and it is 6 billion today (12x larger). If the average generation length is 30 years, there are 17 generations in 500 years. So the average number of surviving children per mother is $\exp((\log 12)/17) = 1.157$ Since a child has two parent, the average number of surviving children per person is 2 * 1.157 = 2.315 So this is the average growth rate per generation for the descendants of a person in 1500. $2.315^{17}$ = 1.575 million. So an average person in 1500 has about 1.5 million offspring alive today. Sampling from the whole world, the probability that a random person from 1500 is an ancestor of a random person in 2000 would be 1.5 million / 6 billion = 0.025%. If you were only considering people in a region like Europe, it would probably be something like 1.4 million / 700 million = 0.2%.</p> <p>As I have said above, this is from a computer scientist. Next, is my own theory. From a probabilistic standpoint, due to the Law of Large Numbers, me, you or *almost anyone alive today had an ancestor in like say feudal Japan in 1500 CE. I chose Japan because of its remoteness yet it still had contact with the rest of the world at that time and I chose the year 1500 because of each person had in theory about a million ancestors- lower than that because of inbreeding but still a sizable number nonetheless. I have shared this theory with several of my colleagues and they are intrigued by it yet I have not yet shared it with an actual statistician. I know it seems unlikely, but from a strictly statistical standpoint, what do you think of it?</p> <p>*please note, this excludes populations that have not have had contact. </p>
73,391
[ -0.033626776188611984, -0.03857141733169556, 0.039054032415151596, -0.03353821113705635, 0.03371109813451767, -0.013867730274796486, -0.023790759965777397, -0.04909465089440346, 0.005587685387581587, -0.02660032920539379, 0.05242890864610672, 0.02598855271935463, 0.01879759505391121, 0.009340459480881691, 0.02804558351635933, 0.02555307373404503, -0.014224682934582233, -0.0037013974506407976, -0.013005574233829975, -0.007538212928920984, 0.041009675711393356, 0.023354748263955116, 0.014425772242248058, -0.01082981750369072, -0.06124560534954071, 0.031554173678159714, 0.0326535739004612, -0.049916669726371765, -0.0180701594799757, 0.0821743905544281, -0.03923330456018448, -0.043102625757455826, 0.05749577656388283, 0.06327377259731293, 0.04034014046192169, 0.02176690846681595, -0.04307694733142853, -0.026776520535349846, -0.010350325144827366, 0.029957955703139305, -0.043123986572027206, -0.021034561097621918, -0.021754933521151543, 0.0394333116710186, -0.0031108222901821136, 0.02832130342721939, 0.025073004886507988, -0.060332536697387695, 0.027665311470627785, -0.03903227671980858, 0.05013376101851463, -0.025153761729598045, 0.05120514705777168, -0.019345587119460106, 0.013905692845582962, 0.0035722600296139717, 0.051518142223358154, 0.021217551082372665, 0.02932136505842209, -0.03387279808521271, -0.016542891040444374, -0.021467022597789764, -0.011903430335223675, 0.006757302675396204, -0.028101224452257156, 0.037941284477710724, -0.007761809974908829, -0.012826544232666492, 0.03721687197685242, -0.029476851224899292, 0.03267807140946388, 0.011454394087195396, 0.07180941104888916, 0.015456223860383034, 0.01752263493835926, -0.0017815164756029844, 0.020365672186017036, 0.0006691282032988966, 0.029206132516264915, 0.030454883351922035, -0.015098757110536098, -0.0028354376554489136, 0.02403987944126129, 0.00836599338799715, 0.018539810553193092, -0.022770393639802933, 0.03876242786645889, -0.035132188349962234, 0.006167723331600428, 0.013708055019378662, -0.02126133441925049, -0.01990918256342411, 0.035596318542957306, 0.00454708794131875, -0.044426023960113525, 0.046048853546381, 0.00966922752559185, -0.01767076924443245, 0.010105540044605732, 0.006096892990171909, -0.029401183128356934, -0.04218153655529022, 0.03467559814453125, 0.08184409141540527, 0.014049862511456013, -0.021535729989409447, -0.04928591474890709, -0.030052917078137398, -0.023845572024583817, -0.018639883026480675, 0.030861571431159973, 0.015952834859490395, 0.022678932175040245, 0.01572364754974842, 0.014543507248163223, 0.018902922049164772, 0.03021116554737091, -0.028742503374814987, 0.1144200935959816, 0.056210748851299286, 0.004094994161278009, -0.006143467966467142, 0.009587361477315426, -0.016201136633753777, -0.03455078974366188, 0.017614562064409256, -0.011014079675078392, 0.0009330266038887203, -0.023868989199399948, 0.06876346468925476, 0.008743677288293839, -0.02108026295900345, 0.043030306696891785, -0.0038217268884181976, 0.07294820994138718, -0.00917776208370924, -0.0816553384065628, -0.02880718745291233, 0.05229954421520233, -0.03841564431786537, 0.007357532158493996, -0.08014392852783203, 0.03005894087255001, -0.011141323484480381, 0.07147959619760513, -0.0020151962526142597, 0.03676152601838112, -0.005344876553863287, 0.0156509131193161, 0.0544687919318676, -0.017074527218937874, -0.01787065900862217, 0.010856777429580688, -0.014627617783844471, -0.0195911955088377, -0.08173740655183792, 0.04108933359384537, 0.030841367319226265, -0.0341712050139904, -0.025946034118533134, 0.03492511436343193, 0.02658800408244133, -0.018583090975880623, -0.017385907471179962, 0.0010013333521783352, -0.029526429250836372, 0.07201221585273743, 0.03071405552327633, 0.030281800776720047, 0.033001773059368134, 0.017588771879673004, 0.044555582106113434, 0.006348105613142252, 0.023778920993208885, 0.004317709244787693, -0.014130081050097942, 0.04963161051273346, 0.007101880386471748, -0.01658051647245884, -0.00814876239746809, -0.03928143158555031, -0.027613354846835136, -0.018315332010388374, 0.005479421466588974, 0.05746438354253769, 0.005067605525255203, -0.022672170773148537, -0.03131522238254547, -0.004655069671571255, -0.02519775927066803, -0.06137457489967346, -0.03864838927984238, -0.02843557484447956, 0.04719076305627823, -0.021310757845640182, -0.006068952847272158, -0.010966637171804905, -0.021606169641017914, -0.050223201513290405, 0.00505561800673604, -0.031947020441293716, -0.012016789987683296, 0.024801457300782204, -0.014774812385439873, 0.006910041905939579, 0.04777165874838829, 0.013526433147490025, -0.0040259212255477905, 0.04859837144613266, -0.017902709543704987, -0.02878345362842083, -0.023223180323839188, -0.03127303719520569, 0.026257550343871117, -0.004514874424785376, 0.04725903272628784, 0.01724785752594471, -0.027593383565545082, 0.020404906943440437, -0.01292412169277668, -0.024800270795822144, 0.04879451543092728, 0.008666427806019783, 0.009689616039395332, -0.03795887157320976, -0.002503305906429887, 0.004092726390808821, -0.024967605248093605, 0.011104579083621502, -0.07683666050434113, -0.0952044129371643, -0.01205327920615673, 0.0022810688242316246, 0.01293441653251648, -0.04745902493596077, 0.013681489042937756, 0.01647770404815674, 0.047242678701877594, 0.005639566108584404, -0.022815125063061714, -0.00925524439662695, -0.02535085752606392, 0.003975288942456245, 0.014840537682175636, 0.0038225899916142225, 0.036106716841459274, 0.017389431595802307, -0.04337628558278084, 0.02898288704454899, -0.05953528732061386, -0.031668148934841156, 0.028032639995217323, 0.03132069483399391, 0.04295550659298897, -0.012974832206964493, 0.003433370729908347, -0.007674149237573147, 0.011325683444738388, -0.010972995311021805, 0.03010634332895279, 0.0037758385296911, -0.020990686491131783, -0.037644773721694946, -0.023245077580213547, 0.014171899296343327, 0.013674644753336906, -0.05422734469175339, -0.013532829470932484, 0.016439594328403473, -0.010326438583433628, 0.028506554663181305, -0.009256972931325436, -0.028665879741311073, -0.008585301227867603, -0.00900847278535366, 0.01312551461160183, 0.00642723822966218, 0.02310844510793686, -0.04839338734745979, -0.02774966135621071, -0.0023555688094347715, 0.012192154303193092, 0.012691647745668888, -0.013374172151088715, -0.09259258210659027, -0.04251619428396225, -0.0067529743537306786, -0.00014914431085344404, 0.045530181378126144, -0.009999900124967098, -0.0025148801505565643, 0.028750715777277946, 0.012660279870033264, -0.07454431802034378, -0.025545306503772736, -0.033268798142671585, -0.00017013192700687796, -0.03561997041106224, 0.005349163897335529, 0.04217343404889107, 0.021744217723608017, -0.05391334369778633, 0.026411084458231926, -0.02858930267393589, -0.014382196590304375, -0.02196591906249523, -0.010308615863323212, -0.008070823736488819, -0.0056535168550908566, -0.016064586117863655, 0.012708800844848156, 0.02047581598162651, -0.015753123909235, -0.06830616295337677, -0.06583825498819351, 0.020584018900990486, 0.005711935460567474, 0.05522909760475159, 0.0193476565182209, -0.010565599426627159, 0.056340787559747696, 0.043584126979112625, -0.019701633602380753, -0.005528242327272892, 0.02737719751894474, 0.00660952553153038, 0.004927305970340967, 0.059483252465724945, 0.022554799914360046, -0.039551299065351486, 0.021666210144758224, 0.01879763789474964, 0.007458631414920092, 0.025417985394597054, -0.016570035368204117, 0.029473355039954185, 0.038463443517684937, -0.015288575552403927, 0.0009942810283973813, 0.03296171501278877, 0.019253313541412354, -0.019153770059347153, 0.03717517480254173, -0.004811976570636034, 0.012985286302864552, -0.017738305032253265, -0.06081497669219971, 0.03022761084139347, -0.0053620957769453526, -0.008273173123598099, -0.015313882380723953, 0.006877812556922436, 0.023137208074331284, -0.03538574278354645, 0.042987413704395294, -0.006921830587089062, 0.05831451714038849, 0.008265271782875061, -0.0023161694407463074, 0.0375697948038578, 0.07182413339614868, -0.011882607825100422, 0.013460349291563034, -0.015671804547309875, 0.023544805124402046, -0.012646974064409733, -0.007607807405292988, -0.004898883402347565, -0.007834100164473057, 0.050731293857097626, -0.014048857614398003, -0.04951179400086403, -0.00999305211007595, -0.03940165415406227, -0.03494059294462204, 0.015273182652890682, -0.04201021045446396, 0.036958906799554825, 0.013217799365520477, 0.04912246763706207, 0.012251298874616623, -0.02255985327064991, -0.00813236366957426, 0.027069007977843285, -0.04255971685051918, -0.00628611771389842, -0.04215740039944649, -0.0273732952773571, -0.027170395478606224, -0.04564952105283737, 0.02776540070772171, 0.019366173073649406, -0.04819975793361664, -0.035194795578718185, 0.019493160769343376, -0.02599399723112583, 0.002061696257442236, -0.016385963186621666, -0.040170930325984955, -0.0073400577530264854, 0.04597529396414757, -0.008563348092138767, 0.04352158308029175, 0.026521077379584312, 0.022731851786375046, 0.0026308081578463316, -0.02704756148159504, -0.040378328412771225, -0.00032195099629461765, 0.043765489012002945, 0.040794048458337784, 0.01965036243200302, 0.007176933344453573, -0.03799938037991524, -0.03137896955013275, -0.01084856502711773, 0.0032597268000245094, 0.0711946114897728, 0.02331077866256237, 0.02475360594689846, -0.012607763521373272, -0.0095203947275877, -0.014562755823135376, 0.022402359172701836, -0.047387976199388504, 0.010858378373086452, 0.04901235178112984, 0.04639259725809097, -0.03167930245399475, 0.00806772243231535, 0.03221853822469711, -0.02460135519504547, 0.011221303604543209, 0.0003088956873398274, -0.04214920476078987, -0.0202154703438282, 0.01471975352615118, 0.0004388537781778723, -0.0024313987232744694, -0.03767908364534378, -0.0394173189997673, 0.0026774019934237003, 0.022544194012880325, -0.030419262126088142, 0.023488275706768036, -0.005766738671809435, 0.04554473236203194, -0.015214060433208942, -0.05167735368013382, -0.011155273765325546, -0.009250267408788204, 0.0024433229118585587, 0.05257445201277733, -0.0003880282456520945, -0.011594397015869617, -0.01344359666109085, 0.007632667198777199, 0.05785927549004555, -0.06565338373184204, 0.04736405983567238, -0.04334238916635513, -0.03684631362557411, 0.03614036366343498, -0.009285037405788898, 0.015101870521903038, -0.023128703236579895, -0.01332441158592701, -0.01911899261176586, -0.041605059057474136, -0.006151183508336544, -0.013697158545255661, -0.023750321939587593, 0.0035122763365507126, -0.0078948475420475, 0.014047296717762947, 0.011569411493837833, 0.032206229865550995, 0.02780681848526001, 0.03329212963581085, -0.01506003737449646, 0.01464841514825821, 0.013740453869104385, -0.008763277903199196, -0.0019598589278757572, -0.03629933297634125, 0.049940939992666245, -0.028992336243391037, -0.012383267283439636, 0.01977548561990261, -0.02757720649242401, -0.06500309705734253, 0.039653439074754715, 0.019020119681954384, 0.00824748259037733, 0.02493506669998169, -0.007727774791419506, 0.041960589587688446, -0.006232275161892176, -0.0076461248099803925, 0.03677532821893692, 0.03551613166928291, -0.037848252803087234, 0.023525074124336243, -0.008479648269712925, -0.018008651211857796, -0.045479074120521545, -0.028738413006067276, -0.017224162817001343, -0.009612854570150375, -0.03909660875797272, 0.010328137315809727, -0.034862782806158066, 0.013678002171218395, 0.0014579591806977987, -0.026831235736608505, -0.018426869064569473, 0.013089013285934925, -0.02208893746137619, 0.040007442235946655, -0.030175242573022842, 0.03630460798740387, 0.01732729747891426, -0.0063770366832613945, 0.05151002109050751, -0.012260076589882374, -0.004842087626457214, -0.060793668031692505, -0.0012892656959593296, 0.00966714508831501, -0.053367309272289276, -0.019647739827632904, 0.04241048917174339, -0.0013804695336148143, 0.024715717881917953, -0.0002142943412763998, 0.05609791353344917, 0.019101010635495186, -0.04791061207652092, -0.04158719629049301, 0.035968467593193054, -0.0020627067424356937, 0.05124861001968384, -0.009585109539330006, 0.028439944609999657, -0.0063056908547878265, -0.02902567759156227, -0.06367958337068558, -0.02509336546063423, 0.05105254799127579, -0.017295457422733307, 0.005456241313368082, -0.03840113803744316, -0.027153247967362404, -0.017420196905732155, 0.012601153925061226, 0.0005092891515232623, 0.08022788166999817, 0.005145523697137833, -0.01833031326532364, -0.022241530939936638, 0.032303743064403534, 0.03546552360057831, 0.001953288447111845, -0.02921900898218155, 0.0111283790320158, -0.022593850269913673, 0.02124033495783806, -0.056528542190790176, 0.05416794866323471, -0.03478744626045227, -0.01463792659342289, -0.017063988372683525, -0.013292222283780575, 0.027856210246682167, -0.04449193552136421, -0.04475901648402214, 0.03946007415652275, -0.022800859063863754, 0.035695988684892654, 0.014919193461537361, -0.004555108025670052, -0.0019281028071418405, 0.018575940281152725, -0.003815920790657401, 0.015472430735826492, 0.04417696222662926, -0.04710850864648819, 0.011832491494715214, -0.010968849994242191, -0.03380497917532921, -0.00639828247949481, 0.02850966900587082, -0.039695173501968384, -0.014633224345743656, -0.015234699472784996, -0.04457080736756325, 0.03326069191098213, -0.03131595253944397, -0.01310252957046032, 0.017150690779089928, 0.0000687236970406957, -0.03209236264228821, -0.0072569772601127625, -0.04363645240664482, 0.01710508018732071, 0.019656646996736526, -0.024664003401994705, -0.015779081732034683, 0.025363121181726456, 0.010520892217755318, 0.010112824849784374, -0.00806401390582323, 0.010383273474872112, 0.007011396810412407, -0.018130522221326828, 0.04590017348527908, -0.06035955622792244, -0.024260709062218666, 0.04369470104575157, 0.0561092235147953, 0.03792337700724602, 0.021875033155083656, -0.0023483086843043566, 0.006151346489787102, 0.023048337548971176, -0.02804456651210785, -0.004826760850846767, 0.04735172539949417, -0.04393814504146576, 0.010608094744384289, 0.01787486858665943, -0.026394013315439224, 0.060087721794843674, 0.043180253356695175, -0.010422774590551853, -0.021465465426445007, -0.03528168424963951, -0.0210262518376112, 0.00010222896526101977, 0.02967756800353527, 0.017560722306370735, 0.043132878839969635, -0.04574905335903168, 0.005338556598871946, 0.011915575712919235, -0.0007555540069006383, -0.028676055371761322, -0.06354598701000214, -0.0065447986125946045, -0.050995003432035446, -0.06769715994596481, 0.04200342670083046, 0.013269182294607162, -0.03251272439956665, 0.004965176340192556, 0.007898854091763496, -0.027332957834005356, 0.028692491352558136, 0.04456185922026634, -0.06207602843642235, 0.09084726125001907, 0.02897050976753235, 0.042140647768974304, -0.024145910516381264, 0.016802305355668068, 0.14800338447093964, 0.027880270034074783, 0.029193010181188583, -0.022740190848708153, 0.03715301677584648, -0.014579512178897858, -0.0021304204128682613, -0.029578810557723045, 0.0051762196235358715, 0.005876404698938131, -0.001656995969824493, 0.05692226067185402, 0.04560995474457741, 0.013467404060065746, -0.0220223069190979, 0.05730552598834038, -0.03332339972257614, -0.028696240857243538, -0.0432065948843956, 0.02721104398369789, -0.02963128313422203, -0.015460062772035599, 0.028530403971672058, 0.0024536675773561, -0.014760715886950493, 0.02057260274887085, -0.020152537152171135, -0.010102411732077599, 0.005578820127993822, -0.02551611326634884, -0.02787928842008114, -0.00807902216911316, 0.04806850850582123, -0.02373550273478031, 0.00019435054855421185, -0.04746651649475098, -0.018443340435624123, -0.010559272952377796, 0.023711703717708588, 0.022754952311515808, 0.018801914528012276, 0.035800524055957794, 0.029169773682951927, 0.008680079132318497, -0.03907271847128868, -0.04043183475732803, -0.03230370581150055, 0.01635167934000492, -0.002309445757418871, -0.028483930975198746, -0.02000007964670658, 0.023909253999590874, 0.03100711852312088, -0.022463036701083183, -0.01190344337373972, 0.023012790828943253, 0.01864941231906414, 0.0025473155546933413, -0.005682504735887051, 0.018244260922074318, 0.0350491888821125, -0.005539822392165661, 0.02069433219730854, 0.02550816349685192, -0.03169599175453186, -0.015987636521458626, 0.006553654093295336, 0.040263306349515915, 0.008566339500248432, -0.005076452158391476, -0.06646834313869476, -0.01650640182197094, -0.052202872931957245, -0.003647110192105174, -0.017293816432356834, 0.016359688714146614, 0.057354219257831573, -0.002722712466493249, -0.02090776152908802, -0.026187129318714142, 0.023303203284740448, 0.022930867969989777, 0.01651776023209095, -0.01858905702829361, -0.009855413809418678, 0.011244002729654312, 0.020558979362249374, 0.01119782030582428, -0.045023027807474136, 0.026557093486189842, -0.03826563432812691, 0.05941145494580269, -0.015107943676412106, -0.0014339783228933811, 0.007394681219011545, -0.006929511670023203, -0.03657236322760582, -0.010428407229483128, -0.01717148721218109, 0.027802033349871635, -0.01367176789790392, 0.03959968686103821, 0.01572495885193348, 0.014917210675776005, 0.009094768203794956, 0.03587557002902031, 0.00849034171551466, -0.08055148273706436, -0.010572966188192368, 0.0129757234826684, -0.002112654270604253, -0.01170468982309103, -0.012314452789723873, 0.004961799830198288, 0.00950388703495264, -0.022872626781463623, -0.0017588482005521655, -0.023743601515889168, 0.002875731559470296, -0.045658618211746216, 0.00985748041421175, -0.008873458951711655, -0.05488390102982521, -0.011606198735535145, -0.018947066739201546, -0.012404941953718662, -0.008572329767048359, -0.0153408944606781, -0.00027591967955231667, 0.05554141476750374, -0.008936755359172821, 0.019010744988918304, 0.02143360674381256, -0.025744901970028877, -0.00835047010332346, 0.02688155509531498, 0.005535395350307226, 0.0031950869597494602, -0.046088237315416336, -0.032903850078582764, 0.055300869047641754, -0.017021840438246727, -0.07021772116422653, 0.0667044147849083, -0.007965829223394394, 0.03476230055093765, 0.006160730961710215, -0.014570104889571667, 0.007670634891837835, 0.06998683512210846, -0.03204287216067314, -0.006842729169875383, -0.02795039862394333, 0.03976578265428543, 0.031225956976413727, -0.0007514805183745921, -0.012875014916062355, 0.04325246438384056, -0.009731207974255085, 0.04494190216064453, 0.032942336052656174, -0.04548771679401398, 0.009279887191951275, -0.006574426311999559, -0.04130509868264198, 0.03350676968693733, 0.0004575425700750202, -0.03330399468541145, 0.048901405185461044, 0.048651162534952164, -0.0000895465345820412, 0.022807808592915535, -0.013355490751564503, -0.007629542611539364, -0.04365789517760277, -0.014334691688418388, 0.013113681226968765, 0.01493319682776928, 0.04869137704372406, -0.022153805941343307, -0.05589527264237404, 0.010148240253329277, -0.03914135321974754, 0.02935096062719822, 0.015726454555988312, 0.0046974183060228825, -0.05555441230535507, 0.008237972855567932, -0.030323056504130363, 0.027788827195763588, 0.013256192207336426, 0.04847820848226547, 0.035912223160266876, 0.049629922956228256, -0.016922375187277794, -0.05887389928102493, -0.007087587378919125, 0.019231947138905525, -0.07436908036470413, -0.006045086774975061, 0.02500993385910988, 0.021106930449604988, -0.016071321442723274, 0.029045911505818367, -0.03560584783554077, 0.017433954402804375, 0.011978596448898315, 0.04838993027806282, 0.016235537827014923, 0.0005427075084298849, -0.007519836537539959, 0.026124661788344383, 0.009872667491436005, 0.0408208854496479, 0.025466740131378174, 0.05613286420702934, -0.03149758279323578, 0.006906780879944563, 0.02105468139052391, -0.023478170856833458, -0.0003022875462193042, 0.021535631269216537, 0.025300655514001846, -0.016786737367510796, 0.01381301786750555, 0.009260064922273159, -0.010979055427014828, 0.01624174416065216, -0.011453217826783657, 0.013148423284292221, 0.0269533209502697, 0.03261435776948929, 0.037430427968502045, 0.036840103566646576, 0.02974722720682621, -0.03300123289227486, -0.015032750554382801, 0.020172694697976112, 0.024563288316130638, -0.009397618472576141, -0.017956703901290894, -0.04201993718743324, -0.020608047023415565, 0.02543841302394867, 0.03707875311374664, -0.027185479179024696, -0.03581580892205238, 0.015900660306215286, -0.014092684723436832, 0.007208476774394512, 0.011906524188816547, -0.027747025713324547, -0.010425466112792492, -0.057912785559892654, 0.08742913603782654, -0.023815542459487915, 0.042624298483133316, -0.07873467355966568, -0.038022588938474655, 0.01481179241091013, 0.030023718252778053, 0.03454087674617767, -0.008028467185795307, 0.01917942240834236, -0.03141673654317856, 0.045454058796167374, 0.017160942777991295, -0.023286476731300354, 0.0038850971031934023, -0.0135757215321064, -0.02720995433628559, -0.032615505158901215, 0.021489465609192848, -0.0008632017998024821, -0.004300433211028576, -0.0020725869107991457, -0.05283862352371216, 0.009820927865803242, 0.052038293331861496, -0.013199541717767715, 0.010324141941964626, 0.029174594208598137, -0.046482447534799576, 0.008975055068731308, 0.010237899608910084, -0.019835250452160835, 0.02220817655324936, -0.01209991704672575, -0.053722772747278214, 0.03588886559009552, -0.05107009410858154, -0.011592562310397625, 0.02202461287379265, -0.002852682489901781, 0.019330598413944244, -0.032523274421691895, 0.018573997542262077, 0.023527605459094048, -0.040482137352228165, -0.022242046892642975, 0.014441401697695255, 0.01469100546091795, 0.01916767843067646, -0.009158389642834663, 0.06745386123657227, 0.002968487562611699, -0.04459434002637863, 0.006616528145968914, -0.04181673750281334, -0.011741000227630138, -0.04097135737538338, 0.013093830086290836, 0.00938416551798582, 0.015095751732587814, 0.02694578282535076, -0.00016735093959141523, 0.026418736204504967, -0.032199520617723465, -0.0040817358531057835, 0.031129304319620132, 0.016887111589312553, -0.0055502625182271, 0.042370621114969254, 0.013109731487929821, 0.10475856065750122, 0.0174711961299181, 0.027616338804364204, 0.0005933114443905652, -0.03473389893770218, -0.02910563163459301, -0.010509190149605274, 0.0031141317449510098, -0.007321063429117203, -0.011688923463225365, 0.0072028618305921555, 0.01214530412107706, 0.03637033700942993, 0.07421878725290298, -0.051820192486047745, 0.05030452087521553, 0.006289578974246979, -0.02277599461376667, -0.03548593819141388, 0.009032875299453735, -0.028869327157735825, -0.026705916970968246, 0.04085052013397217, 0.032250504940748215, 0.03703436627984047, 0.018531953915953636, -0.010933822020888329, 0.02257738821208477, 0.028672246262431145, -0.016569754108786583, -0.021676557138562202, -0.042080383747816086, 0.028189988806843758, -0.011762924492359161, -0.024324826896190643 ]
<p>I trained a few different models, (Perceptron, Stochastic Gradient Descent and Naive Bayes), each with different parameters. I then scored their accuracy on a cross validation set.</p> <p>The scores on the best parameter Perceptron, SGD and NB models were 93%, 91% and 94% respectively. </p> <p>I didn't expect such similar results and I'm at a bit confused because I feel that the possibility of variance makes choosing the NB as the best model questionable.</p> <p>Am I supposed to test all 3 on the test set and use the model with the best unbiased error? Or is that implicitly cherry picking the best model ?</p>
35,733
[ -0.03252766653895378, -0.02831673063337803, -0.02116769552230835, -0.030638612806797028, 0.04531340301036835, -0.005341466516256332, 0.003069428028538823, -0.009275281801819801, 0.04931801185011864, 0.01499068085104227, 0.03321591764688492, 0.020633002743124962, 0.05679726600646973, 0.03769665211439133, -0.023487146943807602, 0.0019259349210187793, 0.0036074696108698845, 0.014560804702341557, -0.015193315222859383, -0.005175159778445959, -0.005444458220154047, 0.013133917935192585, 0.006277145817875862, -0.01496639009565115, -0.04906287416815758, 0.017521152272820473, 0.03183729201555252, -0.029234761372208595, 0.0021622921340167522, 0.033934324979782104, -0.06002674251794815, -0.0019520039204508066, -0.006993399932980537, 0.0650453269481659, 0.02748122438788414, 0.03626846522092819, -0.013488822616636753, -0.027324656024575233, -0.05536485090851784, 0.03561011701822281, 0.011845693923532963, -0.0035127270966768265, -0.007974795065820217, 0.00941727589815855, -0.021244479343295097, 0.011071242392063141, -0.025475256145000458, -0.003953677602112293, 0.009857757948338985, -0.03673724830150604, 0.06313718110322952, 0.0028795236721634865, 0.029158635064959526, 0.05089348927140236, -0.022047122940421104, -0.029115134850144386, 0.08253905177116394, 0.04902743548154831, -0.030023101717233658, -0.06044429913163185, 0.007410928141325712, -0.00573304807767272, 0.017106827348470688, -0.01632193848490715, -0.03663357347249985, 0.04104912281036377, 0.025230232626199722, -0.023879902437329292, 0.03748391196131706, 0.018424849957227707, 0.033987388014793396, -0.019792424514889717, 0.02665756456553936, -0.015242977999150753, 0.031018275767564774, 0.00046499408199451864, 0.0009821944404393435, 0.06253025680780411, 0.026513151824474335, 0.027300329878926277, 0.000773250067140907, 0.03224105015397072, 0.021769702434539795, 0.03658793494105339, 0.02441456727683544, -0.009937811642885208, 0.061146266758441925, 0.03349323943257332, -0.003281116019934416, 0.008573624305427074, -0.0212745051831007, -0.00236501800827682, 0.05145256221294403, -0.007527326699346304, -0.04120095446705818, 0.026651496067643166, -0.01326292846351862, 0.016904937103390694, 0.025065746158361435, -0.016163337975740433, -0.023715859279036522, -0.04310855641961098, -0.00563374487683177, 0.065957210958004, -0.043674834072589874, -0.01277942955493927, -0.006914173252880573, -0.002007357543334365, -0.029570095241069794, -0.01779850944876671, -0.038823071867227554, 0.03680726885795593, -0.013404613360762596, -0.0054442500695586205, 0.03682941198348999, 0.00933474488556385, 0.0034675314091145992, -0.03276434540748596, 0.04504917934536934, 0.036179132759571075, 0.06361836940050125, -0.02989029698073864, 0.02515779249370098, -0.037821780890226364, -0.018324054777622223, -0.01648961752653122, 0.024603145197033882, 0.005968434736132622, -0.04663371294736862, 0.03785407170653343, -0.007134548854082823, -0.01988740637898445, 0.031660426408052444, -0.011918686330318451, 0.010149949230253696, 0.007159148808568716, -0.10381166636943817, -0.06517818570137024, 0.018166420981287956, -0.030801992863416672, 0.03901979699730873, -0.05083180591464043, -0.02700294926762581, 0.029202178120613098, 0.031289391219615936, -0.03252596780657768, 0.047320932149887085, -0.008859948255121708, 0.02816491760313511, -0.020442673936486244, -0.026928147301077843, -0.021182410418987274, 0.0021131420508027077, 0.027565689757466316, -0.046514227986335754, -0.09155727177858353, 0.0006232922314666212, 0.008428424596786499, 0.007723364047706127, -0.018595745787024498, 0.016279583796858788, -0.00973458681255579, 0.014747710898518562, -0.01618369296193123, 0.02558320201933384, -0.017006343230605125, 0.0468316450715065, 0.02718771994113922, 0.03388025239109993, 0.031726110726594925, -0.017790069803595543, 0.012617085129022598, 0.03026818297803402, 0.017299216240644455, 0.033983565866947174, 0.003051481209695339, 0.018120823428034782, -0.030917968600988388, 0.014630666933953762, 0.024207213893532753, -0.0335649698972702, 0.0029356880113482475, 0.007426093332469463, 0.003788086585700512, -0.011685427278280258, 0.04022688418626785, 0.0012978154700249434, -0.04633978754281998, 0.04167617857456207, -0.023749947547912598, -0.026565367355942726, -0.06557245552539825, 0.0070528131909668446, -0.004099928308278322, -0.029219437390565872, 0.04626207426190376, -0.011447139084339142, 0.02279154770076275, -0.015140621922910213, -0.020973512902855873, -0.03311838582158089, 0.006891847588121891, 0.03237754851579666, -0.018306858837604523, 0.00024054838286247104, 0.08456479012966156, -0.04581572860479355, -0.04140636697411537, 0.024586152285337448, -0.009565415792167187, -0.0930459052324295, 0.03162466734647751, -0.04540315270423889, 0.017741316929459572, -0.022055665031075478, -0.05600234493613243, 0.02206030674278736, 0.005700856912881136, -0.023705245926976204, 0.026040516793727875, -0.05164219066500664, 0.07742993533611298, 0.024687057361006737, -0.026501154527068138, 0.008715781383216381, -0.004738923627883196, 0.011852969415485859, 0.08525952696800232, -0.031312428414821625, 0.03172091022133827, -0.0458308681845665, -0.03590105473995209, 0.03229688107967377, 0.018018409609794617, -0.029287856072187424, 0.0014038679655641317, 0.041226569563150406, -0.001578645664267242, 0.01615813933312893, -0.004022584762424231, 0.042417801916599274, -0.0457686148583889, 0.013039038516581059, 0.051282722502946854, 0.010355832986533642, 0.039289865642786026, 0.0213933065533638, -0.025801802054047585, 0.0305288415402174, 0.002337548416107893, -0.021347776055336, 0.06969530880451202, 0.008140523917973042, 0.012151030823588371, 0.010965202935039997, -0.046038661152124405, 0.009684058837592602, -0.011748021468520164, -0.00859149731695652, 0.010816109366714954, -0.0011762139620259404, -0.033089715987443924, 0.021357085555791855, 0.0001950984151335433, 0.04412958398461342, 0.028340743854641914, -0.002021855441853404, -0.015312730334699154, 0.057496774941682816, -0.060280557721853256, -0.0024459962733089924, 0.0037370892241597176, -0.025223227217793465, -0.05386211350560188, 0.007714961189776659, 0.0008870895835570991, -0.004430518951267004, 0.030351432040333748, -0.0089806467294693, -0.03420640528202057, 0.01200092677026987, 0.006339999847114086, 0.023252956569194794, -0.012759464792907238, -0.07264415919780731, -0.005027852486819029, -0.03409713879227638, 0.004137176088988781, 0.05076010897755623, -0.024559659883379936, -0.019996922463178635, 0.020602548494935036, -0.0005500405095517635, -0.03506380692124367, -0.04204440861940384, -0.05201341211795807, 0.019008973613381386, 0.0025271684862673283, -0.021669581532478333, 0.03952580317854881, -0.02026602253317833, -0.040121469646692276, 0.05347035825252533, -0.012627891264855862, -0.005323489662259817, 0.03183910623192787, 0.022130068391561508, -0.017587197944521904, 0.015519014559686184, -0.01657256670296192, 0.056412115693092346, -0.02481054700911045, -0.015282968059182167, -0.07273777574300766, -0.03946249932050705, 0.025907570496201515, -0.00632022600620985, 0.02361289970576763, -0.0013293040683493018, 0.009500674903392792, 0.09615112096071243, 0.008696782402694225, -0.031402990221977234, -0.029945669695734978, 0.006907814182341099, -0.04662768915295601, -0.044191379100084305, 0.026479370892047882, 0.03781349956989288, -0.017095958814024925, 0.020393265411257744, -0.03549908474087715, 0.040201336145401, 0.04095819219946861, -0.016224712133407593, 0.0033229792024940252, 0.0015513329999521375, 0.023437540978193283, -0.05160063877701759, 0.043826907873153687, 0.027520526200532913, 0.0026533796917647123, 0.011204262264072895, 0.008446158841252327, -0.0015550036914646626, 0.0071511538699269295, -0.026373201981186867, 0.07053937762975693, -0.020021092146635056, 0.015633221715688705, -0.03952717408537865, 0.033759020268917084, -0.0016780068399384618, -0.019229084253311157, -0.030330684036016464, 0.02168242819607258, 0.01662427745759487, 0.007496706210076809, 0.020295802503824234, 0.050553347915410995, 0.050418976694345474, -0.020747171714901924, -0.053446631878614426, -0.014464317820966244, -0.006281072739511728, 0.0007103728130459785, 0.04249373823404312, 0.011347239837050438, 0.04297082871198654, 0.034009430557489395, 0.02438037469983101, 0.013543966226279736, -0.0745047777891159, -0.027500273659825325, -0.08550869673490524, 0.022884579375386238, -0.02923276647925377, 0.02362278662621975, 0.022788573056459427, 0.029782133176922798, 0.01208268478512764, -0.023367546498775482, 0.019237423315644264, -0.011580083519220352, -0.042676810175180435, 0.04317786544561386, 0.02773704193532467, -0.019410358741879463, -0.0017081941477954388, -0.05343259125947952, -0.0003506873908918351, -0.06578151881694794, 0.029341408982872963, 0.04245077446103096, 0.005966567434370518, -0.02839466743171215, 0.0085170092061162, -0.0547444149851799, -0.030893465504050255, 0.024724852293729782, 0.036474645137786865, -0.03287215158343315, -0.03316936269402504, -0.01783713884651661, 0.032917071133852005, -0.026818400248885155, -0.02114780619740486, -0.010607232339680195, 0.001974186860024929, -0.01952969841659069, 0.038032885640859604, -0.008545124903321266, 0.028772737830877304, -0.05883154645562172, 0.06638587266206741, 0.018983570858836174, 0.008308524265885353, 0.03270057961344719, -0.009631606750190258, -0.03391898795962334, -0.04940366372466087, -0.004458549432456493, 0.030338285490870476, 0.004646912682801485, 0.03339427709579468, -0.02569418027997017, 0.060384608805179596, 0.04163910821080208, -0.03276931494474411, -0.013101316057145596, 0.022419489920139313, 0.0012205274542793632, 0.012627544812858105, -0.017448790371418, -0.03569650650024414, 0.002275285543873906, -0.028611425310373306, 0.017830923199653625, -0.00013744707393925637, -0.043053045868873596, -0.0130153838545084, 0.028981124982237816, -0.039792682975530624, -0.04723041132092476, -0.005618056282401085, 0.012784590944647789, 0.03378337621688843, -0.008978125639259815, -0.005227462388575077, 0.014163191430270672, 0.05256512761116028, 0.06267666071653366, 0.016178417950868607, -0.01253692526370287, -0.06813567876815796, -0.004434515722095966, 0.055785711854696274, 0.021421125158667564, -0.06520837545394897, -0.014904310926795006, -0.03567908704280853, -0.030486300587654114, -0.010913856327533722, -0.020975610241293907, 0.030635669827461243, 0.027622496709227562, -0.014323803596198559, -0.03362494334578514, -0.01343008503317833, -0.014066261239349842, -0.0026303811464458704, -0.02157280407845974, 0.03378187119960785, -0.03085070103406906, -0.012108334340155125, 0.005718820262700319, 0.0023067391011863947, 0.00031599897192791104, 0.06158275157213211, -0.041210852563381195, 0.006404887419193983, 0.001870639156550169, 0.030587732791900635, -0.013501569628715515, -0.09432435780763626, -0.029174117371439934, -0.007180065382272005, -0.004242657218128443, 0.04905864968895912, -0.005747943185269833, -0.06787914782762527, -0.00540876854211092, -0.008913076482713223, -0.028100155293941498, -0.006584702059626579, -0.011376160196959972, 0.02551240101456642, 0.031144896522164345, 0.033307816833257675, 0.05783456191420555, -0.007040305994451046, 0.03987458720803261, -0.007464813068509102, -0.0391598716378212, 0.008555053733289242, -0.039808936417102814, -0.011385709047317505, -0.03620913624763489, -0.03324834257364273, -0.012477370910346508, 0.03415623679757118, 0.025603163987398148, 0.051574159413576126, -0.031198350712656975, -0.010456942953169346, -0.0075759729370474815, 0.0034510400146245956, 0.017836881801486015, -0.021649738773703575, 0.0211851354688406, 0.007236327975988388, 0.012438066303730011, 0.016818273812532425, -0.002405088860541582, -0.024583129212260246, 0.03555559739470482, 0.05235225707292557, -0.03518491983413696, 0.018139271065592766, -0.025631148368120193, -0.010653429664671421, 0.005554536357522011, -0.007564911153167486, 0.01261194795370102, 0.028916077688336372, 0.0312955267727375, 0.009459977969527245, -0.02817193605005741, -0.044865984469652176, 0.004664375446736813, 0.013925331644713879, 0.0416962131857872, -0.03444833680987358, 0.01179676316678524, -0.013848187401890755, -0.004368586000055075, -0.07875365763902664, -0.0364794097840786, 0.012584914453327656, 0.005075445864349604, -0.05119447782635689, 0.005864206701517105, 0.026269456371665, 0.01381706167012453, -0.0181434266269207, -0.022653691470623016, 0.0648479089140892, -0.021318161860108376, 0.0013765908079221845, 0.02978937141597271, 0.020585739985108376, 0.08507127314805984, -0.014223056845366955, 0.04142388701438904, 0.012396272271871567, -0.01885388419032097, -0.007744931150227785, 0.03153448924422264, 0.022427547723054886, -0.0199736375361681, 0.007716475520282984, -0.0034224630799144506, 0.04077509790658951, 0.06673989444971085, -0.016154879704117775, 0.00008974856609711424, 0.045895349234342575, -0.012666722759604454, -0.02254137583076954, 0.014209036715328693, 0.0008253509877249599, 0.009046451188623905, -0.0184475127607584, -0.012435434386134148, 0.03336234390735626, -0.009829954244196415, -0.01233827043324709, 0.04903005063533783, 0.009834145195782185, 0.00013584976841229945, 0.014274007640779018, 0.09862010180950165, 0.0031378602143377066, -0.025447994470596313, -0.00962352566421032, -0.045159708708524704, 0.06281302869319916, 0.014893178828060627, 0.03515257686376572, -0.014408599585294724, 0.024974368512630463, -0.03460155427455902, -0.03512117266654968, -0.00879200454801321, 0.011657260358333588, 0.058480311185121536, 0.028309155255556107, 0.04775984212756157, 0.04593654349446297, 0.00788070447742939, -0.011764795519411564, -0.08477555960416794, -0.01247552502900362, -0.028075726702809334, 0.01615283079445362, 0.04495939984917641, 0.034008096903562546, 0.00034186866832897067, 0.048489391803741455, 0.005878904368728399, 0.024399688467383385, 0.026769639924168587, 0.03561917692422867, 0.005404001101851463, -0.003974255174398422, 0.002420909935608506, -0.04683484882116318, 0.0596105232834816, -0.06595173478126526, 0.0158244501799345, -0.03313259035348892, -0.01639343611896038, 0.03142375126481056, 0.03397562727332115, 0.018437620252370834, -0.008627007715404034, -0.0016073879087343812, -0.05481484904885292, 0.015848202630877495, 0.02925960160791874, 0.00404365872964263, 0.0051947482861578465, 0.008485396392643452, 0.06160407513380051, -0.000747176178265363, 0.0265827439725399, -0.038230542093515396, -0.10511995851993561, -0.009642605669796467, 0.024941356852650642, -0.005447338335216045, 0.012463422492146492, -0.023620903491973877, -0.031108511611819267, 0.010369139723479748, -0.01746242865920067, 0.04831467941403389, -0.011285667307674885, 0.010746663436293602, -0.03705437481403351, 0.03054155223071575, -0.015107894316315651, -0.011959335766732693, 0.012486142106354237, -0.00924285501241684, 0.12322215735912323, 0.053603507578372955, 0.04535029083490372, -0.04312137886881828, 0.0052519552409648895, -0.03922967612743378, -0.013733851723372936, 0.01649511232972145, 0.0011042176047340035, 0.03910288214683533, 0.030750345438718796, 0.0036008451133966446, -0.02096758410334587, 0.014673484489321709, -0.05944550037384033, 0.040007710456848145, 0.010026715695858002, -0.025444788858294487, 0.046080149710178375, 0.003154369769617915, 0.03315894678235054, -0.03065292350947857, -0.0030847808811813593, 0.016840796917676926, -0.0017326996894553304, -0.026394544169306755, -0.018740177154541016, -0.02771773934364319, 0.00577883142977953, 0.011051750741899014, 0.0008426716667599976, 0.01528854388743639, -0.03677503764629364, 0.015599368140101433, -0.032701071351766586, -0.016817817464470863, -0.011957828886806965, -0.02552521601319313, 0.04516052454710007, 0.03193718194961548, 0.024283666163682938, -0.018443332985043526, -0.0215308777987957, 0.00624773558229208, -0.05199509486556053, -0.015996692702174187, -0.04697161912918091, 0.03321555256843567, 0.002124078804627061, -0.01749003864824772, 0.001972774276509881, 0.025141486898064613, 0.0032911100424826145, -0.040416982024908066, -0.011942755430936813, 0.03145476058125496, 0.00008230822277255356, -0.048121482133865356, -0.054714594036340714, -0.027418099343776703, 0.02513330988585949, -0.013946904800832272, 0.018286434933543205, 0.0009796195663511753, -0.016222327947616577, -0.019642196595668793, -0.03429204598069191, 0.03327752649784088, 0.010549894534051418, 0.04394334927201271, 0.013875596225261688, -0.029887309297919273, -0.05339260399341583, -0.0030703239608556032, 0.029061108827590942, 0.014865241013467312, 0.034002285450696945, -0.01759020797908306, -0.005435208790004253, -0.016607845202088356, -0.050668865442276, -0.010854685679078102, -0.03143557533621788, 0.03280550613999367, -0.03145467862486839, -0.00044437285396270454, 0.014570629224181175, -0.007245402783155441, 0.06020819768309593, 0.04386960342526436, 0.03333365544676781, 0.02557184174656868, 0.003934724722057581, -0.055958520621061325, -0.026858441531658173, 0.007086046040058136, -0.0413641631603241, 0.04405977204442024, 0.010888099670410156, 0.06030702590942383, 0.003439919091761112, 0.041735660284757614, -0.030244603753089905, 0.022147957235574722, 0.023871194571256638, -0.0038601586129516363, -0.010645684786140919, -0.039941925555467606, 0.004143776837736368, 0.0140920951962471, 0.014025690034031868, -0.033213283866643906, 0.011561050079762936, -0.03525041043758392, -0.013955394737422466, 0.040633391588926315, -0.024297451600432396, -0.03019372560083866, -0.00348225561901927, 0.02130037732422352, 0.04388292506337166, -0.027059504762291908, 0.01854695938527584, -0.011029457673430443, 0.018107859417796135, -0.02666627988219261, -0.011974850669503212, -0.00756802735850215, 0.008225400000810623, -0.028616465628147125, -0.03173017129302025, 0.04283933714032173, -0.02943362481892109, 0.0074082775972783566, -0.028642693534493446, 0.014268641360104084, 0.017242882400751114, 0.04961053654551506, -0.01035524532198906, -0.0048002516850829124, 0.03270069882273674, -0.04571707919239998, -0.04069703072309494, -0.008777924813330173, 0.0016005903016775846, 0.013157384470105171, 0.018543390557169914, -0.018332764506340027, -0.023399967700242996, 0.011087137274444103, -0.03211701661348343, -0.01199309527873993, -0.011024695821106434, 0.03313036262989044, 0.011171379126608372, -0.006734635215252638, 0.02875773049890995, 0.01683388464152813, -0.0052041951566934586, 0.011115740984678268, -0.004686370026320219, 0.0014490834437310696, 0.026503320783376694, 0.02328033372759819, -0.03151801973581314, -0.02626500092446804, -0.006605467293411493, -0.006498660426586866, -0.032295480370521545, 0.048975586891174316, -0.029089970514178276, 0.044523581862449646, -0.011544928885996342, 0.021052690222859383, -0.05465201660990715, -0.04662369191646576, 0.01789472997188568, -0.015848783776164055, 0.032037414610385895, -0.07598649710416794, 0.037213027477264404, 0.05185238644480705, -0.06592243164777756, 0.0343211330473423, -0.004972358699887991, 0.007689271122217178, -0.050881993025541306, 0.008662297390401363, -0.011198426596820354, 0.0007376137073151767, 0.003676898777484894, -0.0021512017119675875, 0.016911104321479797, 0.035688161849975586, -0.004184895195066929, -0.020025085657835007, -0.0338582769036293, 0.04513022303581238, -0.007727242074906826, -0.040667105466127396, -0.006012987811118364, -0.040881987661123276, -0.04497004300355911, 0.03959282860159874, -0.004745125770568848, -0.011396177113056183, 0.009434551000595093, 0.05639789626002312, 0.018271099776029587, 0.023094579577445984, 0.040304072201251984, -0.029892396181821823, -0.03081435337662697, 0.010008983314037323, 0.02065138891339302, 0.04125954210758209, 0.0037508916575461626, 0.009451727382838726, -0.0016067156102508307, -0.010902565903961658, -0.029319453984498978, -0.008547116070985794, -0.023981716483831406, -0.011845255270600319, 0.027940208092331886, -0.007358118891716003, -0.012299112975597382, -0.03844928368926048, -0.0076625291258096695, -0.04624534770846367, 0.030633889138698578, 0.027916185557842255, 0.01782630942761898, -0.036104410886764526, -0.001224264851771295, -0.02022147737443447, -0.004834289196878672, -0.011295159347355366, -0.006918887607753277, -0.011489974334836006, -0.013979923911392689, 0.009161415509879589, 0.022960884496569633, 0.014091094955801964, -0.035643771290779114, -0.03935568779706955, -0.0044786264188587666, 0.044395167380571365, -0.020457573235034943, 0.024328919127583504, 0.018402623012661934, -0.03519951552152634, -0.027639560401439667, -0.06621761620044708, 0.07710891216993332, 0.007829112000763416, -0.02852812595665455, -0.06688923388719559, 0.010584545321762562, -0.043901748955249786, -0.017031291499733925, 0.05413137376308441, -0.004767973907291889, 0.027026614174246788, -0.011001834645867348, -0.0024665703531354666, -0.007290889509022236, -0.04099202901124954, 0.06595645099878311, -0.005430169403553009, -0.026736965402960777, -0.031976956874132156, 0.012112895958125591, 0.02041693776845932, 0.031807851046323776, 0.01570381037890911, -0.00576631398871541, 0.02512231282889843, 0.014709941111505032, -0.01656162180006504, 0.03182801231741905, -0.011534317396581173, -0.012103335000574589, 0.037405673414468765, 0.00613510562106967, -0.01760130561888218, -0.006544065196067095, -0.008375324308872223, -0.05635173246264458, 0.02116672322154045, 0.0098557248711586, -0.009630038402974606, -0.007002140395343304, 0.05664079263806343, 0.02835754305124283, -0.03246769309043884, -0.006122928578406572, 0.04458846524357796, -0.04855507239699364, 0.02336479350924492, 0.03632603958249092, 0.014133721590042114, 0.00698912562802434, -0.022610975429415703, 0.04335543140769005, 0.012985133565962315, -0.02837410941720009, -0.003380724461749196, 0.017370114102959633, 0.007726555690169334, 0.03295811265707016, 0.02816985733807087, 0.048462703824043274, -0.04270179569721222, 0.027402592822909355, 0.009679507464170456, 0.012343723326921463, -0.03645851090550423, -0.012731507420539856, 0.024817844852805138, -0.0009998318273574114, -0.019447699189186096, -0.014550585299730301, -0.01807057112455368, 0.07955323904752731, -0.050411783158779144, -0.038022514432668686, -0.024092698469758034, -0.013119005598127842, 0.016217675060033798, -0.013326362706720829, 0.004425444640219212, 0.0024704611860215664, 0.036676984280347824, 0.00922578014433384, -0.03979170322418213, 0.027626337483525276, 0.04910949617624283, -0.01655995100736618, 0.019278861582279205, -0.014383186586201191, 0.018646230921149254, -0.04534982144832611, -0.00891528557986021, -0.030550742521882057, 0.004152077715843916, 0.015625471249222755, 0.04209856688976288, 0.00672460300847888, -0.027154218405485153, -0.026483112946152687, -0.0007268192712217569, 0.03256417065858841, -0.0534670352935791, -0.02587352693080902, -0.034786153584718704, 0.02754666656255722, 0.004593317396938801, 0.0023101945407688618 ]
<p>This is in reference to the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Girsanov_theorem" rel="nofollow">Girsanov theorem</a> however question is general. If $X$ is a standard normal variable $N(0,1)$, why is expectation of $e^{-\mu X - \mu^2/2}$ equal to 1?</p> <p>Shouldn't it be $e^{-\mu^2/2}$?</p>
47,133
[ -0.011088480241596699, -0.04566693305969238, -0.00991423986852169, -0.0377679280936718, 0.005872546229511499, 0.014180738478899002, -0.02689538709819317, -0.028067145496606827, -0.023273617029190063, -0.04843353480100632, 0.051964666694402695, 0.041652850806713104, 0.0860220342874527, 0.021475542336702347, 0.03185717388987541, 0.043894264847040176, -0.047930121421813965, 0.004042462911456823, -0.04273080825805664, -0.007930377498269081, -0.020303022116422653, 0.04101274162530899, 0.033077023923397064, 0.0025026104412972927, -0.019964028149843216, 0.03151090815663338, 0.02347254753112793, -0.012609748169779778, 0.034365177154541016, 0.08724348247051239, -0.037254296243190765, -0.025222212076187134, 0.014554450288414955, 0.02342432737350464, -0.01292694266885519, 0.006894377991557121, -0.022260582074522972, -0.025953182950615883, -0.002796761691570282, 0.02109907567501068, -0.03494516760110855, -0.010635246522724628, 0.01225903257727623, 0.019527722150087357, -0.05246804282069206, 0.012920218519866467, 0.017059097066521645, -0.04072262719273567, 0.032738763839006424, -0.048983972519636154, 0.07816233485937119, -0.012634232640266418, 0.02845304273068905, 0.02906377799808979, 0.006098750978708267, -0.00950030330568552, 0.03516653552651405, 0.03559799864888191, -0.002466522855684161, -0.05783313512802124, 0.009580740705132484, -0.04457120969891548, -0.006971183232963085, 0.010182824917137623, 0.020944658666849136, -0.02637345902621746, 0.002548885066062212, -0.015882404521107674, 0.03191978856921196, 0.01564818248152733, -0.005658145993947983, 0.04538155719637871, 0.0030981514137238264, -0.029658865183591843, 0.02753327041864395, -0.030719175934791565, 0.018604176118969917, -0.007392657920718193, 0.0369873009622097, 0.026740089058876038, 0.008236183784902096, 0.00493247713893652, 0.05072624981403351, 0.03186697140336037, 0.006633535958826542, 0.0153324780985713, 0.07413747906684875, -0.010246003046631813, 0.05031050369143486, 0.015178986825048923, 0.002382880775257945, 0.02652251534163952, 0.03523356094956398, -0.07125617563724518, -0.03147554770112038, 0.04835691303014755, -0.014481164515018463, 0.01055987924337387, 0.007925922982394695, 0.0012495771516114473, -0.014513776637613773, -0.037260375916957855, 0.03488908335566521, 0.03913044184446335, -0.006560879293829203, -0.011414182372391224, -0.03326075151562691, 0.0076458691619336605, -0.013328107073903084, -0.036697935312986374, -0.0003466129710432142, 0.044287845492362976, -0.0034389409702271223, -0.013975930400192738, 0.01084880530834198, -0.013244172558188438, 0.0232972614467144, -0.010375844314694405, 0.016992973163723946, 0.030022036284208298, 0.0470263846218586, 0.003325756872072816, 0.03425462916493416, -0.01766766980290413, -0.09313283115625381, 0.03314187005162239, 0.03169358894228935, 0.012373420409858227, -0.08246636390686035, 0.03558247536420822, 0.02925657108426094, 0.012312975712120533, 0.00456773117184639, 0.046043310314416885, 0.03920299559831619, -0.02188311144709587, -0.08266369253396988, -0.06839058548212051, 0.058793969452381134, -0.0378376841545105, 0.013683820143342018, -0.09385252743959427, 0.00783313438296318, 0.043363992124795914, 0.06454607099294662, -0.009314988739788532, 0.03754721209406853, -0.017979709431529045, 0.01866348274052143, -0.0007359511218965054, 0.01226890366524458, -0.025774035602808, -0.021313266828656197, -0.026581041514873505, -0.005627763457596302, -0.04222285374999046, 0.028359560295939445, 0.025695234537124634, -0.008032292127609253, -0.011168509721755981, 0.0354049988090992, -0.022945649921894073, 0.008898770436644554, -0.0061242892406880856, -0.014099250547587872, -0.0195628572255373, 0.08528520911931992, 0.027465665712952614, 0.006273455917835236, 0.02707294560968876, 0.007057573646306992, 0.060066740959882736, -0.01321213785558939, 0.061821043491363525, 0.03540920093655586, -0.04913098365068436, -0.020197739824652672, -0.04281095787882805, 0.0536528043448925, -0.005797970108687878, -0.00911665614694357, 0.023771140724420547, -0.019052429124712944, 0.012833916582167149, -0.022852573543787003, 0.012160533107817173, 0.009221438318490982, 0.010013389401137829, 0.009845390915870667, -0.0642586499452591, -0.018527425825595856, -0.046654827892780304, 0.00553936418145895, 0.0252287108451128, -0.04823080077767372, 0.007625698111951351, 0.01691167615354061, 0.04558933153748512, -0.012869312427937984, -0.006702649872750044, -0.01380460150539875, -0.019282259047031403, 0.004082790110260248, -0.03373853117227554, 0.008458966389298439, 0.07980534434318542, 0.03845340758562088, -0.014144901186227798, 0.021602289751172066, -0.0491006076335907, -0.03888503462076187, 0.009139006957411766, -0.03912017494440079, 0.011461819522082806, 0.0034561262000352144, -0.009055739268660545, 0.01390322856605053, -0.013316529802978039, -0.00300771975889802, 0.03292189911007881, -0.06692681461572647, 0.026644714176654816, 0.057352833449840546, 0.014853044413030148, 0.010179045610129833, 0.02132195234298706, 0.02077578194439411, -0.0037667627912014723, -0.017661405727267265, -0.03806342929601669, -0.04523632675409317, -0.0019846924114972353, 0.03556515648961067, 0.05563337728381157, -0.035743847489356995, -0.0033706265967339277, 0.04371898993849754, 0.017082322388887405, 0.037816476076841354, 0.04982622712850571, 0.027494510635733604, -0.07731810957193375, -0.012225243262946606, 0.04117327183485031, 0.006792145781219006, 0.009506306611001492, 0.01524092722684145, 0.011716450564563274, 0.00935621652752161, 0.0011920504039153457, -0.033090345561504364, 0.047900065779685974, -0.026984790340065956, 0.012026680633425713, -0.030442725867033005, 0.02657703123986721, 0.02503686398267746, -0.0361638180911541, 0.030247915536165237, -0.0014792396686971188, 0.0006189641426317394, -0.0075173694640398026, -0.01982232928276062, -0.01881970837712288, 0.042663272470235825, 0.003346577985212207, -0.014317650347948074, -0.030894190073013306, 0.03364348039031029, 0.009407113306224346, 0.0005784171517007053, 0.02598579227924347, -0.024998966604471207, -0.012624369002878666, 0.012894032523036003, 0.016028812155127525, -0.027622420340776443, 0.005263573490083218, -0.00458000460639596, -0.03386228159070015, 0.008864461444318295, -0.0074612731114029884, 0.016570845618844032, 0.01852690801024437, -0.040233757346868515, 0.00415570056065917, -0.00838035624474287, 0.010057108476758003, 0.026507198810577393, 0.0023769319523125887, 0.003291501197963953, 0.024631476029753685, -0.0047479672357439995, -0.039577025920152664, -0.011690073646605015, -0.032459743320941925, -0.011212158016860485, -0.012163685634732246, -0.026971643790602684, 0.07058120518922806, -0.0073898546397686005, -0.01813538745045662, 0.027919653803110123, -0.046044159680604935, -0.05870030075311661, -0.06291230022907257, 0.005077906884253025, 0.06705065816640854, -0.030755693092942238, 0.03672011196613312, 0.01640789583325386, -0.04208555817604065, -0.007800127845257521, -0.047017838805913925, -0.05931289866566658, 0.008929991163313389, -0.04500754550099373, 0.015297885052859783, 0.015554305166006088, -0.010780713520944118, 0.0855652466416359, 0.01239483430981636, -0.0032192145008593798, -0.01001841388642788, -0.01847117394208908, -0.014923485927283764, -0.08225922286510468, 0.0037076822482049465, 0.03325371816754341, -0.036865971982479095, 0.06463861465454102, -0.01848967745900154, 0.02103845588862896, 0.026030084118247032, 0.004880439955741167, -0.016780219972133636, -0.015355315059423447, -0.03811558336019516, -0.02072845585644245, 0.0534781813621521, 0.021280037239193916, 0.018747370690107346, -0.015449214726686478, 0.0510566309094429, 0.0550185963511467, 0.03097051940858364, -0.021253501996397972, 0.06915397942066193, -0.07204540818929672, 0.022147350013256073, -0.061870425939559937, 0.050066303461790085, -0.015744203701615334, -0.0301580261439085, -0.003347475081682205, -0.024743642657995224, 0.03215697407722473, -0.03700553998351097, 0.014873193576931953, 0.049534790217876434, 0.002497245091944933, -0.024235591292381287, 0.01111037377268076, -0.019211208447813988, 0.009163878858089447, 0.017330113798379898, -0.04008020460605621, -0.01842256635427475, 0.04392223060131073, 0.07053924351930618, -0.00013824331108480692, -0.0032241824083030224, -0.013680161908268929, -0.016776174306869507, -0.04418036714196205, -0.0007948686252348125, -0.01693834364414215, -0.0007768218056298792, 0.0021639838814735413, 0.029022905975580215, -0.005125271622091532, -0.0015543561894446611, 0.013125616125762463, 0.004321069922298193, -0.10429506003856659, -0.003508463269099593, -0.06401552259922028, -0.031492143869400024, -0.005889514926820993, -0.009726195596158504, 0.02376732975244522, 0.008610040880739689, 0.002790740691125393, -0.01596515066921711, 0.03643050044775009, -0.051692988723516464, 0.000984327751211822, -0.020338911563158035, -0.04842660203576088, -0.04620015248656273, 0.027008239179849625, 0.031642913818359375, -0.02281227521598339, 0.018002234399318695, 0.009038766846060753, -0.04038523510098457, -0.012764530256390572, -0.022052809596061707, 0.010410763323307037, 0.026157626882195473, 0.0366656668484211, 0.030936742201447487, -0.004988576285541058, -0.008840901777148247, 0.017680699005723, 0.019003259018063545, 0.07957600802183151, 0.028594298288226128, 0.009422831237316132, -0.0007274898234754801, -0.06239058077335358, -0.027543408796191216, -0.0018476129043847322, 0.022853447124361992, 0.021363748237490654, 0.017466504126787186, 0.028781311586499214, -0.011111070401966572, 0.011101770214736462, 0.017342587932944298, 0.07473520189523697, -0.014940222725272179, 0.002034032717347145, -0.02921289950609207, -0.0187054630368948, -0.04548415169119835, 0.01963026262819767, 0.005032673943787813, -0.052206795662641525, -0.04902603104710579, -0.014437620528042316, 0.025944605469703674, 0.004050721414387226, 0.018962789326906204, -0.030998561531305313, 0.01797783561050892, 0.04238171875476837, 0.04545590654015541, -0.042083583772182465, 0.004540428053587675, 0.01044600922614336, 0.04220493137836456, 0.014545774087309837, -0.01230640523135662, -0.052203767001628876, -0.00045935195521451533, 0.023523330688476562, 0.012793323956429958, 0.001126598916016519, -0.010085060261189938, -0.05740441381931305, 0.024763720110058784, 0.025166897103190422, -0.011286073364317417, 0.023242473602294922, -0.018470529466867447, 0.02986682765185833, 0.0009161828202195466, -0.0301576629281044, -0.033440001308918, -0.0014038161607459188, 0.012885932810604572, 0.05491619184613228, -0.014904453419148922, -0.01857413351535797, -0.045250046998262405, -0.025369903072714806, 0.014576210640370846, 0.05390886589884758, 0.011506753973662853, 0.014518790878355503, 0.010955024510622025, 0.039616748690605164, 0.010315969586372375, -0.0743035152554512, 0.005718480329960585, -0.02001378685235977, 0.021678244695067406, -0.0027164884377270937, -0.018548622727394104, -0.04574062302708626, 0.014057543128728867, -0.006797711364924908, -0.021251339465379715, 0.00848628580570221, 0.012522601522505283, 0.03738153725862503, 0.0371352918446064, -0.00974204484373331, 0.06850943714380264, 0.008902331814169884, 0.03185668960213661, 0.0070234681479632854, -0.06547999382019043, 0.010059678927063942, -0.05582432821393013, -0.04464837908744812, -0.03511761501431465, -0.007784961257129908, -0.009126780554652214, 0.03813263401389122, 0.023334460332989693, 0.04738485813140869, 0.004293967969715595, -0.019010478630661964, 0.010655430145561695, 0.014645679853856564, 0.032912902534008026, -0.008489252999424934, -0.0051646847277879715, 0.014731618575751781, -0.020505009219050407, -0.020409859716892242, 0.04282660782337189, -0.015875190496444702, -0.00019969770801253617, 0.03282465785741806, -0.01398145966231823, 0.026914862915873528, -0.025407947599887848, -0.03284938260912895, 0.001596016576513648, -0.03881412744522095, 0.01860124245285988, 0.013040121644735336, 0.017592674121260643, 0.0397539846599102, -0.010520742274820805, -0.02523687481880188, 0.028511827811598778, 0.009098726324737072, -0.004197284113615751, -0.03720620274543762, 0.01601417362689972, 0.05027667433023453, 0.0017749593826010823, -0.09383000433444977, -0.02968173660337925, 0.005247855093330145, -0.06506436318159103, 0.00706041743978858, -0.025183608755469322, -0.012666178867220879, -0.011356150731444359, -0.005325099918991327, -0.0027068466879427433, 0.01805638149380684, 0.0396152064204216, -0.016167020425200462, 0.0039021873380988836, -0.011854988522827625, 0.05746544897556305, 0.002078926656395197, -0.026999302208423615, 0.025712858885526657, 0.004641364794224501, -0.022669147700071335, 0.00891993660479784, 0.07221125066280365, 0.004330510273575783, -0.005944077391177416, -0.0012896106345579028, -0.05011285841464996, -0.0008810212020762265, 0.0020404052920639515, -0.03412341699004173, 0.052019622176885605, 0.0273833516985178, 0.023447010666131973, -0.0050801304168999195, -0.032215315848588943, -0.001824417500756681, 0.03302103653550148, 0.026189375668764114, -0.04176710173487663, -0.018285581842064857, -0.005770701915025711, 0.025771578773856163, 0.0077728689648211, 0.04192895069718361, 0.01656259223818779, 0.07704086601734161, -0.013320572674274445, -0.021006247028708458, 0.0009897308191284537, -0.009866775013506413, 0.031727731227874756, 0.0010224044090136886, -0.010657167993485928, -0.010532796382904053, 0.0005678677116520703, -0.035227227956056595, -0.028275934979319572, -0.025846119970083237, 0.04278748109936714, 0.05695677176117897, 0.01756533980369568, 0.05706718564033508, 0.02592703141272068, 0.008255565539002419, -0.012510315515100956, -0.03369579091668129, 0.007014136295765638, -0.03136510029435158, -0.0072889747098088264, 0.03246549144387245, -0.046879835426807404, 0.05429927259683609, 0.008442006073892117, 0.01834670454263687, 0.0028598320204764605, 0.029515400528907776, 0.008227929472923279, 0.029685119166970253, 0.018001122400164604, 0.003689507022500038, -0.018434159457683563, 0.050343770533800125, -0.03155559301376343, 0.027575701475143433, -0.006161992438137531, 0.017110202461481094, 0.039062049239873886, -0.016537686809897423, -0.006052914075553417, -0.04135558754205704, -0.0028407182544469833, -0.0339127779006958, -0.006400658283382654, 0.004797950852662325, -0.029529135674238205, 0.009101487696170807, 0.028640197589993477, 0.020518187433481216, -0.027887940406799316, 0.028767865151166916, -0.034444939345121384, -0.0648324191570282, -0.01002622302621603, -0.008980289101600647, -0.036512140184640884, 0.01955494098365307, -0.012697948142886162, 0.006431153044104576, 0.02070951834321022, -0.06161610037088394, -0.0022397972643375397, 0.010278510861098766, -0.001169027527794242, -0.001417111256159842, 0.07506595551967621, 0.03530389815568924, 0.029324745759367943, -0.03684205189347267, 0.02926058880984783, 0.11488428711891174, 0.06016426533460617, 0.026782860979437828, -0.06150539591908455, -0.01773357205092907, -0.04236753657460213, 0.00582630792632699, -0.0440119132399559, -0.005087452940642834, 0.008221053518354893, -0.017110683023929596, 0.034671682864427567, 0.041535452008247375, 0.017224501818418503, -0.05072489008307457, 0.03129630535840988, -0.007672554813325405, -0.07354532927274704, -0.022080644965171814, -0.009208262898027897, -0.023029210045933723, 0.010669466108083725, -0.0136244622990489, 0.056607406586408615, -0.05109516903758049, 0.01817699894309044, 0.01628045178949833, -0.012656671926379204, -0.007181101478636265, -0.01336110383272171, -0.017042389139533043, 0.011907018721103668, 0.031919218599796295, -0.019816778600215912, -0.05206938460469246, 0.004198048263788223, 0.019823512062430382, -0.014105663634836674, 0.025819286704063416, -0.005510029383003712, 0.007705858908593655, 0.020026175305247307, 0.021161070093512535, 0.00437393831089139, -0.041464824229478836, 0.00545100774616003, -0.013833165168762207, 0.046113643795251846, 0.006637642625719309, -0.004500080365687609, 0.0011639413423836231, -0.01598941907286644, 0.015587260946631432, -0.03852128982543945, -0.030612070113420486, 0.002479097805917263, 0.02138080634176731, -0.02582711912691593, -0.0068474882282316685, -0.02638377994298935, 0.008608379401266575, -0.0028495381120592356, 0.013371176086366177, -0.001184362918138504, -0.045636892318725586, -0.012935378588736057, -0.017169926315546036, 0.027243344113230705, -0.007754546124488115, -0.023686116561293602, -0.002058790298178792, -0.03753079101443291, -0.06896936893463135, -0.005898063071072102, -0.0003383174480404705, -0.024730637669563293, 0.0402381531894207, 0.015612841583788395, 0.037899404764175415, 0.01135067455470562, -0.027115676552057266, 0.028569761663675308, -0.03306160867214203, 0.02210102789103985, -0.041795846074819565, -0.013332073576748371, 0.032752275466918945, 0.02209106832742691, -0.005797064863145351, -0.015397749841213226, 0.03988456726074219, 0.04056702181696892, 0.021783413365483284, -0.014358336105942726, -0.033526454120874405, -0.0021964311599731445, -0.03506181761622429, -0.0030195482540875673, -0.00627050269395113, 0.045601736754179, -0.009798331186175346, 0.043155670166015625, -0.030073683708906174, 0.02004348114132881, -0.028515731915831566, -0.005142565816640854, -0.003664596239104867, -0.036386456340551376, 0.03635215759277344, 0.05153582617640495, 0.016613133251667023, -0.009924547746777534, -0.0107010742649436, -0.006526588927954435, 0.013087492436170578, 0.02754039317369461, 0.022142885252833366, -0.044540345668792725, -0.013359569013118744, -0.02635328844189644, 0.04585955664515495, -0.013028117828071117, -0.02790377289056778, -0.03464054316282272, 0.02041701413691044, 0.010913927108049393, -0.02776241861283779, 0.0008249521488323808, 0.011127248406410217, 0.013109631836414337, -0.026583872735500336, 0.04102063924074173, 0.01670517586171627, -0.01290111429989338, -0.0002176442212658003, 0.035760119557380676, -0.014760838821530342, 0.059977322816848755, -0.010203581303358078, 0.006027012597769499, 0.05619977042078972, -0.042042870074510574, -0.013934011571109295, 0.021120870485901833, 0.027513904497027397, 0.025727184489369392, 0.002362186787649989, -0.037476565688848495, -0.043744321912527084, 0.046826206147670746, -0.06221951171755791, 0.01586960442364216, -0.005769315641373396, -0.042813509702682495, 0.0026322253979742527, -0.01781025342643261, -0.013716313056647778, -0.01261336263269186, -0.0014737070305272937, 0.04249141365289688, 0.02900860831141472, -0.015195341780781746, -0.04047013074159622, 0.006584003567695618, 0.005461662542074919, 0.0041428059339523315, 0.01957550272345543, 0.010772556997835636, 0.027045799419283867, 0.03330542892217636, -0.039006754755973816, 0.03804558515548706, -0.06320293247699738, -0.02199074998497963, -0.06631555408239365, -0.031921904534101486, 0.037226010113954544, 0.022255977615714073, 0.0414561927318573, -0.014269761741161346, -0.013481006026268005, 0.019158197566866875, -0.04997318238019943, -0.044454142451286316, -0.015124848112463951, -0.04715409129858017, -0.018568824976682663, -0.013226590119302273, -0.015553075820207596, 0.02304929308593273, 0.02585824765264988, 0.02570408582687378, 0.023654745891690254, 0.0055208755657076836, -0.026654407382011414, -0.015722496435046196, 0.0071416618302464485, 0.031928952783346176, -0.019722474738955498, -0.03885382413864136, 0.029092365875840187, -0.024238932877779007, 0.01911713182926178, 0.04419911652803421, -0.0043735927902162075, -0.01106454897671938, 0.027458636090159416, 0.01545986719429493, -0.002440967131406069, 0.045690588653087616, 0.017867563292384148, -0.0024724637623876333, 0.039414748549461365, -0.0029815032612532377, 0.02566980943083763, 0.02295602113008499, -0.019674982875585556, -0.018101422116160393, 0.004257288761436939, -0.024157708510756493, -0.048747848719358444, 0.002490348881110549, -0.005544149316847324, -0.06315526366233826, -0.017426086589694023, 0.017106126993894577, -0.01573874242603779, -0.032365135848522186, 0.06375640630722046, 0.003434434300288558, 0.001738211722113192, 0.004248303361237049, 0.027629321441054344, -0.019873423501849174, 0.020086433738470078, 0.0353744737803936, -0.07391861826181412, 0.0356893427670002, 0.03432169184088707, -0.0008371988078579307, -0.06908105313777924, -0.013840153813362122, -0.002195065375417471, 0.005515439435839653, 0.03359655663371086, -0.039866600185632706, -0.061956632882356644, 0.010699284262955189, -0.003409671364352107, 0.019309338182210922, -0.003165537491440773, -0.017404047772288322, -0.008803450502455235, -0.08301955461502075, 0.03686967119574547, -0.014147106558084488, 0.002327013062313199, -0.04267730563879013, 0.006865296512842178, -0.0340188629925251, -0.027901174500584602, 0.026655955240130424, 0.045011743903160095, -0.015409767627716064, 0.011982512660324574, 0.03689145669341087, 0.031338393688201904, -0.03920876234769821, 0.03651273250579834, -0.018587365746498108, -0.03710654377937317, -0.03276729956269264, -0.015022202394902706, 0.021651631221175194, 0.04481570050120354, 0.009998342953622341, -0.012040036730468273, 0.01922871172428131, -0.01675596833229065, 0.012577270157635212, 0.049256332218647, 0.02750827930867672, -0.007966697216033936, 0.08776427060365677, -0.015457380563020706, 0.010504684410989285, -0.01277120877057314, -0.016481688246130943, -0.023202210664749146, 0.03691437840461731, -0.031698718667030334, -0.02446126379072666, -0.020653011277318, 0.04273872449994087, 0.06270315498113632, -0.06399949640035629, -0.03876834362745285, 0.037940528243780136, -0.044265422970056534, -0.015822459012269974, 0.06131591275334358, 0.040216922760009766, 0.04656950384378433, 0.02212229184806347, 0.010853253304958344, 0.007898680865764618, 0.020435789600014687, 0.04468939080834389, 0.023957496508955956, 0.04629950597882271, -0.024243444204330444, -0.0021224510855972767, 0.004739363212138414, -0.0669366866350174, 0.029773816466331482, -0.0038770227693021297, 0.04152442887425423, -0.031223511323332787, -0.03659844025969505, 0.015761150047183037, 0.016200078651309013, 0.008712824434041977, -0.022146053612232208, -0.038505494594573975, 0.06130853295326233, -0.01880546845495701, 0.004704305436462164, -0.014846946112811565, -0.00024844869039952755, -0.022824155166745186, -0.0020099610555917025, 0.01674911007285118, -0.006017846055328846, 0.012966006994247437, 0.008791157975792885, 0.0026524465065449476, -0.00331871653907001, 0.0127367889508605, -0.029345925897359848, 0.01644229143857956, 0.007731019519269466, -0.008244577795267105, -0.038390111178159714, -0.017334721982479095, 0.005858217366039753, -0.039165329188108444, 0.0037555673625320196, 0.04714955762028694, 0.0027216493617743254, -0.001082928036339581, -0.03413761779665947, 0.0021773953922092915, 0.0696231946349144, -0.04662309214472771, -0.014034830033779144, -0.012948302552103996, -0.008755462244153023, -0.01392744667828083, -0.01065080612897873 ]
<p>I have data on commute times over a specified route over different days during different conditions. Some of the conditions are categorical (e.g., weather, traffic), and some of them are numeric (e.g., time departing from origin). I'd like to find out which of these conditions most strongly correlate with the shortest commute times on any given day of the week (M-F).</p> <p>Is there a decision tree-like algorithm that would discover the conditions most strongly correlated with the shortest commute times?</p>
73,392
[ -0.04181147739291191, -0.03234472498297691, 0.029299702495336533, 0.018744058907032013, 0.06076454743742943, 0.015303079970180988, 0.04299057275056839, -0.006405087187886238, 0.028897197917103767, -0.010282834060490131, 0.03295811265707016, 0.0607709139585495, 0.040053654462099075, 0.07260309159755707, -0.006695175543427467, 0.0033651203848421574, 0.01195136085152626, 0.006727383006364107, -0.028404224663972855, -0.026191797107458115, -0.028400158509612083, 0.009616876021027565, 0.026815861463546753, 0.010273999534547329, -0.04775875806808472, 0.03703024610877037, 0.01364403311163187, -0.015008945018053055, -0.0024955475237220526, 0.017434796318411827, -0.0515606589615345, -0.012837053276598454, 0.0027749838773161173, 0.07318135350942612, 0.021776648238301277, 0.01949967071413994, 0.003793751122429967, -0.017361516132950783, -0.040507104247808456, -0.013752155937254429, 0.03147450461983681, -0.04233777895569801, -0.013015102595090866, 0.013416748493909836, -0.016382554545998573, 0.032954830676317215, 0.029622819274663925, 0.015803806483745575, 0.020819520577788353, -0.042379602789878845, 0.09616905450820923, -0.04337037354707718, -0.009306646883487701, 0.011937475763261318, -0.026577481999993324, -0.02362392097711563, 0.02163848839700222, 0.04772142693400383, 0.01514954399317503, -0.034796092659235, -0.013443668372929096, -0.021724184975028038, -0.011802627705037594, -0.009968594647943974, -0.07751395553350449, 0.02104989066720009, 0.007855896838009357, -0.029534311965107918, 0.03283024579286575, 0.012344238348305225, -0.006013724487274885, -0.013755994848906994, 0.052552420645952225, 0.006323294248431921, 0.009377265349030495, -0.014650706201791763, -0.0005966995959170163, 0.01884373091161251, 0.06491139531135559, 0.006576112005859613, 0.00730817811563611, -0.008160727098584175, -0.004938419442623854, 0.01303433533757925, -0.0023016768973320723, -0.0020932303741574287, 0.061945922672748566, -0.04481790214776993, -0.028945662081241608, 0.05256826430559158, 0.012384224683046341, -0.03615768626332283, 0.013157148845493793, -0.004439676646143198, -0.005980303511023521, 0.02335038036108017, -0.022550802677869797, -0.028386425226926804, 0.00456977728754282, 0.04037611931562424, -0.012884880416095257, -0.04071075841784477, 0.009091413579881191, 0.02028476633131504, -0.021524103358387947, 0.0077035026624798775, -0.030212463811039925, 0.0190883856266737, -0.008630944415926933, 0.028899334371089935, -0.03836832568049431, -0.021329956129193306, 0.003879332449287176, 0.016116729006171227, 0.006824768614023924, -0.041845325380563736, -0.009369807317852974, -0.011211995035409927, 0.027259912341833115, 0.08184469491243362, 0.021845724433660507, -0.05177047848701477, -0.018983269110322, -0.029236655682325363, -0.05299214646220207, -0.0004149212036281824, -0.009292560629546642, -0.00616737175732851, 0.02034365013241768, 0.06610077619552612, -0.016844017431139946, -0.00870851706713438, 0.014455734752118587, 0.002729107392951846, 0.01602647826075554, 0.0037390447687357664, -0.09150993824005127, -0.02585068717598915, 0.00003189858762198128, 0.029725637286901474, -0.017975475639104843, -0.025309991091489792, 0.009075951762497425, 0.010636679828166962, 0.05096890777349472, 0.019581813365221024, 0.05425713211297989, 0.003641175338998437, -0.006787369027733803, 0.008019146509468555, 0.0031879767775535583, -0.02345031499862671, -0.01122917328029871, -0.009501263499259949, -0.01141111459583044, -0.050371214747428894, 0.008683309890329838, 0.03751492500305176, 0.00869651511311531, 0.0021212121937423944, 0.05858933925628662, 0.016924861818552017, -0.04618862271308899, -0.006224668584764004, 0.015068117529153824, -0.006719502154737711, 0.04889952018857002, 0.027665073052048683, 0.01919092983007431, -0.01681848242878914, -0.002367812441661954, 0.0017012503230944276, 0.02119981124997139, 0.024662263691425323, 0.0290323868393898, -0.005098517052829266, -0.054216984659433365, 0.0029554669745266438, 0.002220416907221079, -0.006413400638848543, 0.014822904951870441, -0.04244605079293251, -0.050639357417821884, -0.01306967530399561, 0.011324673891067505, 0.07429873198270798, -0.015917044132947922, -0.013813406229019165, 0.05700623616576195, -0.06609176099300385, -0.006485703866928816, -0.021602284163236618, -0.014626918360590935, -0.02172720432281494, -0.040806014090776443, 0.01430060900747776, -0.004553681705147028, 0.01478972751647234, -0.022378265857696533, -0.03939727693796158, -0.011035660281777382, 0.0036488757468760014, 0.055078718811273575, -0.010771561414003372, 0.005013908259570599, 0.04720514640212059, 0.02736395038664341, -0.02892376482486725, 0.0033849028404802084, -0.04942581430077553, -0.07110629230737686, 0.009721104055643082, -0.04318515211343765, 0.021975325420498848, -0.0003811764472629875, 0.0292976014316082, 0.058559760451316833, 0.015665274113416672, -0.061459556221961975, -0.0011585542233660817, -0.044365569949150085, 0.047054991126060486, 0.0618303045630455, 0.004854059778153896, 0.04636872559785843, 0.02284468524158001, 0.007766099646687508, 0.024090860038995743, 0.005213701631873846, -0.00952799990773201, -0.012590115889906883, -0.023617655038833618, 0.0371016263961792, 0.012499417178332806, -0.03066815808415413, 0.027227558195590973, 0.05443928390741348, 0.03557503968477249, 0.006346655543893576, 0.05305926874279976, 0.00747899804264307, 0.017404474318027496, 0.025297321379184723, 0.03307675942778587, 0.020404057577252388, -0.006942616775631905, 0.03210827335715294, -0.01761029288172722, 0.0001648515317356214, -0.03861567750573158, -0.04156646132469177, 0.04411858320236206, 0.04670955613255501, 0.008882029913365841, -0.0123237743973732, -0.05686138570308685, 0.05421619117259979, -0.026274405419826508, -0.01268546748906374, 0.04962464049458504, 0.02223169431090355, 0.034111056476831436, 0.030637571588158607, -0.05481945350766182, 0.02336410991847515, 0.0696396604180336, -0.02872912399470806, 0.007953383028507233, 0.0263515654951334, -0.027793513610959053, 0.03667820617556572, -0.01834152452647686, -0.04870250076055527, -0.012837979011237621, 0.026112450286746025, 0.044180430471897125, -0.0038216360844671726, 0.00836752075701952, 0.0021081878803670406, 0.008964997716248035, -0.034099411219358444, -0.03383474797010422, 0.01966562680900097, 0.0015923605533316731, -0.04538089036941528, -0.025534633547067642, -0.0038095698691904545, -0.04812393710017204, 0.03939179703593254, -0.018027031794190407, -0.008338145911693573, 0.049433913081884384, 0.044725652784109116, -0.042903751134872437, -0.00447841128334403, -0.04112773388624191, 0.023542923852801323, -0.05842648446559906, -0.012678937055170536, 0.009212690405547619, 0.007210500072687864, -0.06848379224538803, -0.011432347819209099, -0.04459885507822037, 0.006010982673615217, 0.0018821272533386946, -0.06359890103340149, 0.013926719315350056, -0.01637273095548153, 0.012402494437992573, 0.046286098659038544, 0.013266919180750847, 0.005417804233729839, -0.05399971455335617, -0.05413935333490372, 0.03110339306294918, -0.023327382281422615, 0.04819720238447189, 0.027279818430542946, -0.017865203320980072, 0.07181651145219803, 0.03355109691619873, -0.054267700761556625, -0.04549863934516907, -0.0043915496207773685, -0.02037326619029045, -0.013039853423833847, 0.00805942714214325, 0.040582478046417236, 0.009870529174804688, -0.008035167120397091, 0.02324065938591957, 0.032236553728580475, 0.062244050204753876, 0.010850585997104645, -0.025442712008953094, 0.04672596976161003, -0.009243707172572613, 0.00046381785068660975, 0.03806285560131073, 0.04303283244371414, -0.0447450689971447, 0.01238152664154768, -0.04794524237513542, -0.0005927244783379138, 0.019342903047800064, -0.06326823681592941, 0.016842544078826904, -0.005022395867854357, 0.0232221782207489, -0.0668940395116806, 0.01776082254946232, -0.032175738364458084, -0.054211053997278214, -0.022555449977517128, 0.013553457334637642, 0.024577215313911438, -0.017352158203721046, 0.006809059996157885, 0.05942726880311966, 0.06759089231491089, -0.035320982336997986, -0.019624443724751472, -0.007399635389447212, -0.02039584331214428, 0.056170061230659485, -0.05784819275140762, -0.017629317939281464, 0.044038642197847366, 0.014433592557907104, 0.036270640790462494, 0.03517524525523186, -0.05077880248427391, 0.01731429062783718, -0.04872294142842293, -0.020468104630708694, -0.01920267567038536, 0.0833369717001915, 0.009646588936448097, 0.04427028074860573, -0.006638435646891594, -0.004396043252199888, -0.0008993372321128845, 0.019470466300845146, -0.08998642861843109, 0.0037544688675552607, -0.0017670626984909177, -0.012696207500994205, 0.0016176641220226884, -0.07606229186058044, -0.02221987582743168, -0.0387481190264225, 0.013116988353431225, -0.0013453884748741984, 0.05730411410331726, -0.02816985547542572, 0.013132928870618343, -0.025777101516723633, -0.01031051017343998, -0.024762168526649475, -0.014253182336688042, 0.054397813975811005, 0.018133046105504036, 0.029553331434726715, 0.013671446591615677, -0.020652586594223976, -0.027652904391288757, 0.010752218775451183, 0.013461860828101635, -0.002787587698549032, 0.03139322251081467, -0.05377960205078125, 0.0009169596596620977, -0.004093566909432411, 0.010370178148150444, -0.008050190284848213, 0.01782068982720375, 0.017884623259305954, -0.01188338827341795, -0.019959205761551857, 0.006831382401287556, -0.023572586476802826, 0.009826784953474998, 0.01340955775231123, 0.0016220425022765994, -0.005234842654317617, 0.039757903665304184, 0.011442705057561398, -0.06683705747127533, -0.008088505826890469, 0.055455148220062256, 0.0141150476410985, -0.017904693260788918, -0.015644798055291176, -0.020463554188609123, 0.006960245780646801, -0.0016346467891708016, 0.02590334787964821, 0.04078098013997078, 0.02296404354274273, 0.01910768263041973, 0.018876897171139717, 0.009862041100859642, -0.036273401230573654, 0.028728604316711426, -0.004702433943748474, 0.023250194266438484, 0.020840713754296303, -0.026196332648396492, 0.025502899661660194, 0.011309821158647537, 0.02962181530892849, 0.0386328361928463, 0.02848186157643795, -0.0932297632098198, 0.004195625893771648, 0.027420077472925186, 0.04234788939356804, 0.01115206815302372, -0.00007854290015529841, -0.055768273770809174, 0.010949450545012951, 0.04619317874312401, -0.00818184856325388, 0.028874007984995842, 0.016545604914426804, 0.009210611693561077, -0.04827990010380745, -0.038661323487758636, -0.04079647362232208, 0.007733766920864582, -0.020327426493167877, 0.0646386593580246, 0.028154538944363594, -0.04670245945453644, -0.04626841098070145, 0.0007406295044347644, 0.015214633196592331, 0.011250955983996391, 0.013766327872872353, -0.018774336203932762, 0.0019151302985846996, -0.006413978990167379, -0.05888392776250839, -0.0767713114619255, -0.046043604612350464, 0.03800402954220772, 0.0004410988767631352, 0.053073376417160034, -0.02401755005121231, -0.0018996914150193334, -0.001549775362946093, -0.018246935680508614, -0.02592177875339985, 0.024337725713849068, -0.06104870140552521, 0.04062637314200401, -0.008928599767386913, 0.01053161546587944, 0.028315745294094086, 0.01727680303156376, -0.03280779719352722, 0.004365410655736923, -0.030276086181402206, 0.01548837311565876, 0.01678556017577648, -0.010170342400670052, -0.008069182746112347, -0.05666636303067207, -0.016294220462441444, -0.019612377509474754, -0.014752116985619068, 0.03424463048577309, -0.00884627178311348, -0.028690004721283913, -0.05451466515660286, 0.011720034293830395, -0.015498622320592403, -0.017753776162862778, -0.015404422767460346, 0.008181543089449406, -0.022075548768043518, -0.00597405806183815, 0.057042550295591354, -0.02026038058102131, 0.031986236572265625, 0.011616740375757217, -0.0241549089550972, -0.007850142195820808, -0.012690686620771885, -0.008636546321213245, -0.013238443993031979, 0.0135265551507473, 0.04152783378958702, 0.003372585168108344, 0.019344512373209, 0.038319408893585205, -0.023044142872095108, -0.022908471524715424, 0.04643784090876579, 0.017191430553793907, 0.02844971977174282, 0.004790480248630047, 0.02753089927136898, -0.003910809755325317, -0.033084139227867126, -0.04756489768624306, -0.03519914299249649, 0.022312048822641373, 0.02732165902853012, -0.07103975117206573, -0.054703254252672195, 0.033016856759786606, -0.035410962998867035, -0.03179924190044403, -0.03736479952931404, 0.04837232455611229, -0.02212860994040966, -0.0005304988590069115, -0.004762412514537573, 0.0062128403224051, 0.05253256857395172, 0.024620240554213524, 0.01545228622853756, 0.02482203021645546, -0.02624622732400894, -0.000027431608032202348, -0.0010454303119331598, 0.01636960357427597, -0.005474898032844067, -0.027632994577288628, -0.009226106107234955, 0.0286856722086668, 0.02343354932963848, -0.0030099176801741123, -0.006206468679010868, 0.032444532960653305, -0.01682109199464321, -0.014976922422647476, -0.01746116764843464, 0.039639804512262344, 0.02282777801156044, -0.002063646912574768, -0.021535880863666534, 0.007072231732308865, -0.012350816279649734, -0.006911029573529959, -0.022200781852006912, -0.017590468749403954, -0.00930891465395689, 0.023702314123511314, 0.045438315719366074, -0.013019858859479427, 0.01234282273799181, 0.032831285148859024, 0.00014724205539096147, -0.004039617255330086, 0.0005568997003138065, -0.02871173992753029, 0.015399274416267872, 0.0183810293674469, -0.014476860873401165, -0.008868474513292313, -0.00496467063203454, -0.0063750226981937885, 0.045220695436000824, 0.00844595581293106, 0.07095064967870712, 0.07584600895643234, 0.010343359783291817, 0.02300366386771202, -0.02522924542427063, -0.012729816138744354, -0.003841595258563757, 0.0204051174223423, 0.04344172030687332, 0.032150235027074814, -0.0013793775578960776, 0.04423022270202637, 0.012831518426537514, -0.031925711780786514, -0.006747359409928322, 0.023324932903051376, 0.0029365785885602236, 0.022896599024534225, -0.02693461999297142, -0.10080690681934357, -0.03600029647350311, -0.05674300715327263, 0.005021224729716778, -0.010559792630374432, -0.011540775187313557, 0.031239092350006104, 0.021961254999041557, -0.0070352316834032536, -0.02996719814836979, 0.011684763245284557, -0.047130681574344635, 0.015849245712161064, 0.016352331265807152, -0.05017530918121338, 0.022639410570263863, 0.056264810264110565, 0.06700503826141357, -0.007935411296784878, -0.015081246383488178, 0.01417047530412674, -0.037892553955316544, 0.004950021393597126, 0.0017057042568922043, -0.04317712411284447, 0.05299080163240433, -0.010999738238751888, -0.04264073073863983, 0.03164594992995262, -0.027619823813438416, 0.008552629500627518, 0.004582538269460201, 0.036096181720495224, 0.013032160699367523, 0.035895947366952896, 0.00149276084266603, -0.02375209331512451, -0.005228101275861263, -0.00646918686106801, 0.13532009720802307, 0.06295990198850632, 0.055748313665390015, -0.0666048601269722, 0.007310997229069471, 0.027668481692671776, -0.011370532214641571, -0.04131566733121872, 0.02218620292842388, 0.010031609795987606, 0.004391232505440712, 0.08310572803020477, -0.03542732074856758, -0.010186957195401192, -0.04595309495925903, 0.03826204314827919, -0.030456900596618652, -0.04435926675796509, 0.016468096524477005, 0.014070902019739151, 0.0036129907239228487, -0.01835193671286106, -0.031197719275951385, 0.039903488010168076, -0.022255975753068924, -0.024335861206054688, -0.0008361091604456306, -0.039822451770305634, 0.03365500643849373, -0.0417739562690258, -0.01954287476837635, 0.042863331735134125, 0.04396611824631691, 0.004442726261913776, -0.03405068442225456, 0.03098360076546669, 0.012739056721329689, -0.013072493486106396, -0.006053595338016748, 0.010052507743239403, -0.009162078611552715, -0.007396239321678877, -0.02785225212574005, 0.012168947607278824, -0.053762760013341904, 0.027125991880893707, -0.0565854087471962, 0.047828558832407, 0.008879093453288078, 0.01508419867604971, 0.006264067254960537, 0.0250494834035635, 0.03678836673498154, -0.020127583295106888, 0.010536697693169117, 0.0027944270987063646, 0.05310346186161041, -0.03886716440320015, -0.02040106989443302, -0.030111903324723244, 0.019140344113111496, -0.010961456224322319, -0.0005573272937908769, 0.022128667682409286, -0.012577460147440434, -0.011693594977259636, -0.020377952605485916, 0.023813994601368904, 0.019157057628035545, 0.00024612690322101116, -0.022157952189445496, -0.02672586590051651, 0.010276653803884983, -0.0007239492260850966, 0.036579679697752, 0.0005979844136163592, 0.022562898695468903, 0.028821291401982307, -0.032368335872888565, -0.02163631282746792, -0.03069179132580757, -0.008621479384601116, -0.03466593474149704, -0.024403028190135956, -0.047690439969301224, -0.014008824713528156, 0.039085157215595245, 0.04860229045152664, 0.052876412868499756, 0.030866609886288643, -0.002318599494174123, 0.03689545392990112, -0.019150273874402046, -0.01087226253002882, -0.01240585744380951, -0.034909721463918686, -0.02226324751973152, 0.0685402974486351, 0.03625636547803879, 0.04400365799665451, 0.022437697276473045, 0.00012631167192012072, 0.010147263295948505, 0.014649111777544022, 0.02643497660756111, 0.02003408968448639, 0.009849052876234055, -0.06024415045976639, 0.004272886086255312, 0.01217824500054121, 0.0037284432910382748, -0.026079846546053886, -0.040235091000795364, -0.015685439109802246, -0.028674177825450897, 0.011287000961601734, -0.060134660452604294, -0.006482185795903206, 0.02826138399541378, 0.011365514248609543, 0.029427262023091316, -0.018405381590127945, 0.011498111300170422, -0.036626044660806656, -0.019568108022212982, -0.06396497786045074, -0.027810879051685333, -0.010795381851494312, 0.007829495705664158, -0.02114907093346119, 0.02980850450694561, 0.03447560593485832, 0.013918465934693813, -0.00692861108109355, -0.008226518519222736, 0.011643418110907078, -0.0005509378970600665, 0.08215193450450897, -0.002126141218468547, -0.000607475929427892, 0.012041187845170498, -0.05684269964694977, -0.02910195104777813, 0.028415001928806305, -0.009449709206819534, 0.013410773128271103, 0.007700984366238117, -0.021195348352193832, -0.006463086698204279, 0.05493725836277008, -0.042819056659936905, -0.03323548659682274, -0.024505432695150375, 0.03038518689572811, 0.013241996988654137, 0.009820678271353245, -0.02232597954571247, -0.02195057086646557, -0.050144754350185394, -0.017329270020127296, 0.037490908056497574, 0.009469667449593544, 0.015070063062012196, 0.008840342052280903, -0.0007384106866084039, -0.01005268469452858, 0.010240588337182999, -0.02538430131971836, 0.014467467553913593, 0.014850950799882412, -0.018303213641047478, 0.04684455692768097, 0.011091778986155987, 0.012403327971696854, -0.08904308080673218, -0.028440436348319054, 0.050716299563646317, 0.0314989797770977, 0.0730057954788208, -0.046870529651641846, 0.004944105166941881, 0.028513623401522636, -0.0355064794421196, 0.04508117213845253, 0.03192555904388428, 0.020582925528287888, -0.02980179153382778, -0.00022928779071662575, -0.022354794666171074, 0.03804341331124306, 0.02051495388150215, 0.026892369613051414, 0.024364257231354713, 0.05000482127070427, -0.004904483910650015, -0.030085943639278412, -0.004684568382799625, -0.00871674157679081, 0.03759238123893738, -0.04594976827502251, 0.023919198662042618, -0.04865662381052971, -0.02645612135529518, 0.02741086296737194, -0.025178318843245506, 0.0002905465953517705, 0.0016545419348403811, -0.010259908623993397, 0.02184603363275528, 0.03762805089354515, 0.04943558946251869, -0.02760385535657406, -0.01812852919101715, -0.011814485304057598, 0.0023386660031974316, 0.04873748496174812, 0.030548276379704475, 0.008669542148709297, 0.0043054320849478245, -0.016027938574552536, -0.0612020269036293, 0.047314148396253586, 0.0020243527833372355, -0.003029236802831292, 0.007303646299988031, 0.0003546137595549226, -0.0164946336299181, 0.01721128262579441, -0.012680314481258392, -0.03188025578856468, -0.0060499198734760284, 0.03133970499038696, 0.020658258348703384, -0.038474880158901215, 0.024731725454330444, -0.015956154093146324, -0.05227392911911011, 0.004829959012567997, 0.029671603813767433, 0.015937695279717445, -0.010496879927814007, -0.015006930567324162, -0.021982159465551376, 0.030874738469719887, -0.03771545737981796, 0.01876037009060383, 0.025672024115920067, 0.0422041229903698, 0.01278980914503336, 0.003619794500991702, 0.012629992328584194, -0.013580219820141792, 0.009769611991941929, -0.08868732303380966, 0.04446505382657051, 0.028638126328587532, 0.015677424147725105, -0.019385650753974915, -0.03955809026956558, -0.0790695995092392, -0.0012316856300458312, 0.03752469643950462, -0.022228188812732697, -0.004393597133457661, -0.015485955402255058, 0.0014934322098270059, 0.0013754202518612146, -0.05063210055232048, 0.025769535452127457, 0.0009359038667753339, -0.034319695085287094, 0.005408200901001692, -0.026688644662499428, 0.03325521573424339, -0.04027577489614487, -0.02159903571009636, 0.0023380520287901163, -0.016205139458179474, -0.016307806596159935, -0.002755420748144388, 0.04472426697611809, 0.008095460943877697, 0.010408559814095497, 0.014503567479550838, 0.02785220555961132, 0.012764138169586658, 0.03417403623461723, -0.036602385342121124, -0.045717012137174606, 0.06395317614078522, -0.05320413038134575, -0.028018565848469734, 0.025747615844011307, 0.010843791998922825, -0.0014393194578588009, -0.03214898332953453, 0.018412763252854347, 0.02387710101902485, -0.033590249717235565, 0.01628938503563404, 0.04781143739819527, 0.00739607959985733, 0.03260980546474457, -0.018007328733801842, 0.021040422841906548, 0.0046495068818330765, -0.039906468242406845, 0.03571237623691559, 0.02303525246679783, -0.022276706993579865, -0.024695806205272675, -0.0186756644397974, 0.004824349656701088, 0.006513549946248531, 0.04494670405983925, -0.02271169424057007, -0.0051398188807070255, -0.02418450638651848, -0.032683733850717545, 0.05125671997666359, -0.00496938219293952, 0.03160799294710159, 0.02526300773024559, -0.030998602509498596, 0.035854533314704895, -0.043514493852853775, -0.020828017964959145, -0.03997037187218666, -0.013733281753957272, -0.027873344719409943, 0.02211892232298851, 0.005913583096116781, 0.023870771750807762, -0.01820303313434124, 0.037990789860486984, 0.03761616721749306, 0.013316898606717587, -0.012335581704974174, -0.024444710463285446, 0.013422518968582153, 0.0090722581371665, -0.01185520552098751, 0.005591789726167917, -0.015072401612997055, -0.06927981972694397, -0.0445011630654335, -0.0060537331737577915, 0.050387103110551834, -0.019389325752854347, -0.0006086089415475726, 0.01511282566934824, -0.017226755619049072, -0.00418580649420619, -0.061479657888412476, -0.008642829954624176, -0.046121541410684586, 0.0325925350189209, -0.019863372668623924, -0.0006967310328036547 ]
<p>I would like to compare two linear regression models which represent degradation rates of a mRNA over time under two different conditions. The data for each model collected independently. </p> <p>Here is the dataset.</p> <pre> Time (hours) log(Treatment A) log(treatment B) 0 2.02 1.97 0 2.04 2.06 0 1.93 1.96 2 2.02 1.91 2 2.00 1.95 2 2.07 1.82 4 1.96 1.97 4 2.02 1.99 4 2.02 1.99 6 1.94 1.90 6 1.94 1.97 6 1.86 1.88 8 1.93 1.97 8 2.12 1.99 8 2.06 1.93 12 1.71 1.70 12 1.96 1.73 12 1.71 1.76 24 1.70 1.46 24 1.83 1.41 24 1.62 1.42 </pre> <p>These are my models:</p> <pre><code>Exp1.A.lm&lt;-lm(Exp1$Time~Exp1$(Treatment A)) Exp1.B.lm&lt;-lm(Exp1$Time~Exp1$(Treatment B)) </code></pre> <pre> Call: lm(formula = Exp1$Time ~ Exp1$(Treatment A)) Residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max -6.8950 -1.2322 0.2862 1.2494 5.2494 Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|) (Intercept) 74.68 6.27 11.91 2.94e-10 *** Exp1$(Treatment A) -36.14 3.38 -10.69 1.77e-09 *** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 Residual standard error: 2.97 on 19 degrees of freedom Multiple R-squared: 0.8575, Adjusted R-squared: 0.85 F-statistic: 114.3 on 1 and 19 DF, p-value: 1.772e-09 Call: lm(formula = Exp1$Time ~ Exp1$(Treatment B)) Residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max -7.861 -3.278 -1.444 3.222 11.972 Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|) (Intercept) 88.281 16.114 5.478 2.76e-05 *** Exp1$(Treatment B) -41.668 8.343 -4.994 8.05e-05 *** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 Residual standard error: 5.173 on 19 degrees of freedom Multiple R-squared: 0.5676, Adjusted R-squared: 0.5449 F-statistic: 24.94 on 1 and 19 DF, p-value: 8.052e-05 </pre> <p>To compare these two models, I used this following code. </p> <pre><code>anova(Exp1.A.lm,Exp1.B.lm) </code></pre> <pre> Analysis of Variance Table Model 1: Exp1$Time ~ Exp1$Exp1$(Treatment A) Model 2: Exp1$Time ~ Exp1$Exp1$(Treatment B) Res.Df RSS Df Sum of Sq F Pr(>F) 1 19 167.60 2 19 508.48 0 -340.88</pre> <p>My question is why the ANOVA analysis doesn't show an F statistics and a p.val. My apologies if this is a naive question. </p> <p>Based on different slopes, the rate of degradation is different in these two models, but I would like to know how statistically significant this difference is. I hope that this makes sense. </p> <p>Thank you-</p>
37,528
[ -0.017786981537938118, 0.055262241512537, -0.031015591695904732, 0.007620225660502911, -0.009217620827257633, 0.021764812991023064, 0.001693356898613274, -0.018774451687932014, 0.04581916704773903, -0.00949468370527029, 0.03113505244255066, 0.04425068572163582, 0.04370089992880821, -0.002608734415844083, 0.05755741521716118, 0.003158931154757738, 0.006188937928527594, 0.018035361543297768, 0.028692780062556267, -0.00982543732970953, 0.018604667857289314, -0.015183805488049984, 0.04873427376151085, 0.019692938774824142, -0.0025766240432858467, 0.06687597930431366, 0.0472693033516407, -0.014594003558158875, -0.039585888385772705, 0.05850056931376457, -0.025137197226285934, -0.03529166802763939, -0.006204155273735523, 0.00579068623483181, -0.00577280530706048, 0.02572314813733101, -0.009747803211212158, -0.03347911685705185, -0.004169170279055834, 0.028702573850750923, -0.010923645459115505, -0.01444417517632246, 0.015420123934745789, 0.026065215468406677, 0.03583056107163429, 0.009187974967062473, 0.00011142473522340879, 0.018058905377984047, 0.033762041479349136, 0.0005829868605360389, 0.06173814460635185, -0.015799419954419136, 0.02528461068868637, 0.003989778459072113, -0.04551142826676369, -0.01473513524979353, 0.0355590395629406, 0.08352742344141006, 0.021627362817525864, -0.06972870975732803, -0.0375879630446434, -0.019547205418348312, 0.012517833150923252, -0.018233641982078552, -0.03269031643867493, -0.004718191921710968, 0.003120308043435216, 0.0054142358712852, 0.04367729276418686, -0.03222458064556122, -0.005520619451999664, 0.00792604312300682, 0.03374822810292244, -0.015827633440494537, 0.009037033654749393, 0.004747806116938591, 0.009798360988497734, -0.004781286232173443, 0.029706234112381935, 0.04003557562828064, -0.01992703787982464, 0.017809735611081123, 0.04988045245409012, 0.046169016510248184, -0.007066197227686644, 0.023504070937633514, 0.05634419620037079, -0.047237977385520935, 0.03039039857685566, 0.05108565837144852, -0.016078118234872818, 0.027968935668468475, 0.0569416768848896, 0.027451127767562866, -0.006367950700223446, 0.024776391685009003, 0.01006395649164915, 0.021799834445118904, 0.02476000040769577, -0.006818633060902357, -0.021957844495773315, -0.08547402173280716, 0.01550251804292202, 0.02612212486565113, 0.011736830696463585, -0.015491479076445103, -0.011126115918159485, 0.005287813488394022, -0.021873541176319122, -0.041032832115888596, -0.03515887260437012, 0.02800280787050724, -0.006278279237449169, 0.02443462237715721, -0.009602567180991173, -0.04214077070355415, -0.023048121482133865, -0.014594078063964844, 0.06322400271892548, 0.030375970527529716, 0.08618444204330444, -0.03905705735087395, -0.015301944687962532, -0.0037301306147128344, -0.01636192575097084, -0.04406936094164848, 0.00618594279512763, -0.001554393908008933, -0.015875978395342827, 0.02982422336935997, -0.015272705815732479, -0.05120148882269859, 0.05674094334244728, 0.009080690331757069, 0.04093479365110397, 0.030875304713845253, -0.07354948669672012, -0.059273913502693176, 0.04576042667031288, -0.010504933074116707, 0.03760802745819092, -0.032185036689043045, -0.004063244443386793, 0.0217667818069458, 0.04843359813094139, 0.04681801423430443, 0.020162031054496765, 0.048230886459350586, -0.005204302258789539, 0.03196367621421814, 0.010917783714830875, 0.035175878554582596, 0.0004964640829712152, -0.00908731296658516, -0.011058351956307888, -0.06733526289463043, -0.025899942964315414, 0.009659931994974613, -0.020784880965948105, 0.009744804352521896, 0.03206121176481247, -0.0035737319849431515, -0.013828759081661701, 0.0012880121357738972, -0.010441537946462631, -0.023822998628020287, 0.059326499700546265, -0.0016530784778296947, 0.04726289212703705, 0.01741947792470455, -0.01091894879937172, -0.010815142653882504, 0.007872301153838634, 0.030607786029577255, 0.027114281430840492, -0.012429842725396156, 0.010018914006650448, -0.007151711266487837, 0.023283306509256363, 0.05909213423728943, -0.06636565178632736, -0.03155612200498581, -0.03211439773440361, -0.022584468126296997, 0.03853507339954376, 0.03809093311429024, 0.0016397516010329127, 0.005582984071224928, 0.0519544743001461, -0.033197373151779175, -0.028055846691131592, -0.05450258031487465, -0.024793116375803947, 0.02550864778459072, -0.03845060616731644, 0.00009980156028177589, 0.011560280807316303, -0.002945853630080819, 0.004808253142982721, 0.0031605702824890614, -0.030080700293183327, -0.006667516194283962, 0.039730336517095566, -0.024487847462296486, -0.004807911813259125, 0.04627768695354462, 0.07196240872144699, -0.011859167367219925, 0.041862860321998596, -0.010209478437900543, -0.0002246082731289789, 0.03966919332742691, -0.035696469247341156, -0.008347217924892902, -0.0031131035648286343, -0.012477711774408817, 0.006255616899579763, -0.006654866971075535, -0.027254870161414146, 0.027424661442637444, -0.03884859010577202, 0.024683432653546333, 0.07021775841712952, 0.05247054621577263, 0.0017923576524481177, -0.03064349852502346, -0.029772548004984856, 0.0798785537481308, -0.02932089753448963, 0.02663794718682766, -0.02294531837105751, -0.03890715911984444, 0.03403572365641594, 0.017071086913347244, -0.02209835685789585, 0.019563598558306694, 0.03938461095094681, -0.03739602863788605, 0.03323628380894661, 0.059810299426317215, -0.01567818410694599, -0.05846508592367172, 0.01635894738137722, 0.014859567396342754, 0.014826593920588493, -0.003980065695941448, 0.03296620026230812, -0.023838097229599953, 0.04131888598203659, -0.011377625167369843, 0.011379372328519821, 0.043160270899534225, 0.00822556670755148, -0.012608948163688183, -0.0015237706247717142, -0.03830619156360626, 0.03831479698419571, -0.005464568734169006, -0.012827718630433083, 0.017997177317738533, -0.02036142721772194, -0.005815762560814619, -0.01165236160159111, -0.006016972009092569, 0.027387287467718124, 0.03102029860019684, -0.0055490462109446526, -0.026309290900826454, 0.0001204504951601848, -0.00986708514392376, 0.02458963170647621, -0.05786995589733124, -0.04273573309183121, -0.023359237238764763, -0.021068371832370758, 0.04116960987448692, -0.00873497687280178, 0.006552465260028839, -0.02673608623445034, 0.00322848092764616, -0.00043431727681308985, -0.03451848775148392, 0.05986172333359718, -0.0035634285304695368, -0.01255422830581665, -0.008659579791128635, -0.00599753437563777, -0.005539796780794859, 0.04128789156675339, -0.015098212286829948, -0.028285419568419456, 0.029675405472517014, 0.010594626888632774, -0.01782820373773575, -0.038173794746398926, -0.022325124591588974, -0.00766539154574275, 0.017835231497883797, -0.025411143898963928, 0.06172147020697594, -0.027109647169709206, -0.05717364698648453, 0.027314580976963043, -0.07788178324699402, 0.01656658947467804, -0.01959610916674137, 0.01965404488146305, -0.023007575422525406, 0.01567855104804039, -0.022254236042499542, 0.02426438219845295, 0.01854756847023964, -0.03537881746888161, -0.09341255575418472, -0.020864402875304222, 0.0024488649796694517, 0.022758586332201958, 0.01062166690826416, -0.020009847357869148, -0.02284122444689274, 0.0655113086104393, 0.050583936274051666, -0.04791779816150665, -0.03224680572748184, 0.009094287641346455, -0.029559316113591194, -0.0012821875279769301, 0.008917953819036484, -0.01662301830947399, 0.010358141735196114, 0.015622735023498535, 0.002297205850481987, 0.03005053475499153, 0.04141853004693985, -0.008007267490029335, 0.03438177332282066, -0.00225283345207572, 0.03943255543708801, -0.024245716631412506, 0.039627086371183395, 0.03637494146823883, 0.008417265489697456, 0.04423174634575844, 0.007893511094152927, 0.03612205386161804, -0.017096005380153656, -0.06186801195144653, 0.013969263061881065, -0.0019349490758031607, 0.011202888563275337, -0.029220139607787132, 0.000416091235820204, 0.01985158957540989, -0.012050002813339233, 0.0012581907212734222, 0.011082219891250134, 0.042001206427812576, -0.03211310878396034, 0.014744219370186329, 0.05454133078455925, 0.05053902044892311, -0.008714611642062664, 0.02121220901608467, -0.01287571806460619, -0.031427282840013504, 0.037726011127233505, -0.05499429255723953, -0.012981227599084377, 0.051353853195905685, 0.0080278804525733, 0.013474220409989357, -0.015420129522681236, -0.04089741408824921, -0.0029008626006543636, -0.04883240908384323, 0.014180813916027546, 0.003936546389013529, 0.057463180273771286, 0.035092487931251526, 0.04347359389066696, -0.03292305767536163, -0.030599534511566162, -0.012003964744508266, -0.03190029039978981, -0.06234457343816757, 0.06455885618925095, -0.004797032568603754, -0.022896965965628624, 0.021880563348531723, -0.026852965354919434, 0.021475665271282196, -0.048272375017404556, 0.01524963416159153, 0.01672556810081005, -0.0008380156359635293, 0.005404969211667776, 0.02384050004184246, -0.024380939081311226, 0.034155718982219696, -0.045967649668455124, 0.029121095314621925, -0.015919797122478485, -0.0026071127504110336, 0.019850727170705795, 0.0361972413957119, -0.033243149518966675, 0.013313227333128452, -0.011403042823076248, 0.009542673826217651, 0.051411014050245285, 0.033980097621679306, 0.04278538003563881, 0.036858875304460526, -0.02435935288667679, 0.010069080628454685, 0.008232218213379383, -0.005856723058968782, 0.03688787296414375, -0.012026435695588589, -0.05043117702007294, -0.04483193904161453, -0.01586686260998249, -0.0017915008356794715, -0.0008844148251228034, 0.015683868899941444, -0.03344174847006798, 0.02630515955388546, 0.04237516596913338, -0.026742907240986824, 0.03683403134346008, 0.07028589397668839, -0.009241987951099873, -0.0018135961145162582, -0.02265424095094204, -0.027230774983763695, 0.0006108231609687209, -0.010162526741623878, 0.02501038834452629, 0.01807212643325329, 0.031676843762397766, -0.014411096461117268, 0.031290967017412186, -0.025864247232675552, -0.034521084278821945, 0.003449348732829094, 0.04221602529287338, 0.0356760136783123, 0.010834021493792534, -0.03080986626446247, -0.03181419521570206, 0.04071440547704697, 0.01789139397442341, -0.002937739947810769, 0.04515470936894417, -0.07105035334825516, -0.008325740694999695, 0.01792816072702408, 0.03945164754986763, -0.011675607413053513, -0.04637259617447853, -0.04396906495094299, -0.050593163818120956, 0.003271023742854595, -0.026856839656829834, 0.03197130560874939, 0.019939273595809937, 0.02729608863592148, -0.019576892256736755, -0.032116975635290146, -0.06084590032696724, 0.028638383373618126, -0.02258140780031681, 0.008791926316916943, -0.025005055591464043, -0.03103555180132389, -0.042815472930669785, -0.010315407998859882, -0.0027113885153084993, 0.03405596315860748, -0.07045815885066986, -0.03566884249448776, 0.04283613711595535, 0.008736667223274708, 0.011857589706778526, -0.020228078588843346, 0.029013577848672867, -0.002867588773369789, -0.010823133401572704, 0.022802302613854408, -0.01405368372797966, -0.0239358339458704, 0.03190988302230835, 0.010846458375453949, 0.001330554485321045, -0.004094442818313837, -0.0019400048768147826, 0.02579127997159958, 0.03790685161948204, -0.028448618948459625, 0.05939633026719093, 0.016896190121769905, -0.026141854003071785, 0.006853608880192041, -0.06808745115995407, -0.005910939536988735, -0.005011103581637144, -0.022810528054833412, -0.06942420452833176, -0.01466416846960783, -0.0011089243926107883, 0.03113885410130024, -0.0006037461571395397, -0.009824243374168873, -0.008009476587176323, 0.028536824509501457, 0.023823436349630356, 0.020619740709662437, -0.026604635640978813, -0.036679450422525406, 0.019979873672127724, -0.0008433932671323419, -0.06221112608909607, -0.020845703780651093, 0.01101480983197689, -0.02786456048488617, -0.03188241645693779, 0.01739237830042839, -0.07524950802326202, -0.011860166676342487, 0.007070046849548817, -0.011441061273217201, -0.014229507185518742, 0.0023413558956235647, -0.010549136437475681, 0.012671118602156639, 0.02765461429953575, -0.0022977779153734446, -0.0321073941886425, -0.006974289193749428, 0.030402904376387596, -0.0012381644919514656, 0.0038645982276648283, -0.03769609332084656, 0.03298678249120712, -0.004657507874071598, -0.04742790013551712, -0.05461699888110161, -0.007964985445141792, 0.019346026703715324, -0.006106408778578043, -0.03475615754723549, -0.03965526819229126, -0.034911319613456726, -0.0018854790832847357, 0.017069343477487564, -0.02652348205447197, 0.05298089608550072, -0.04265196621417999, -0.017741551622748375, -0.007351644337177277, 0.026687704026699066, 0.07200063765048981, -0.030371634289622307, 0.014715440571308136, 0.008837936446070671, -0.029704803600907326, -0.03254019096493721, 0.01829061098396778, -0.0035192444920539856, -0.00668389443308115, -0.001786920358426869, -0.02686236798763275, -0.004362565465271473, 0.07514475286006927, -0.004345367196947336, -0.05624575540423393, -0.004467697814106941, -0.0020132241770625114, 0.05347321182489395, -0.03156221657991409, 0.01804814673960209, -0.04322325438261032, 0.02058311365544796, -0.031318023800849915, 0.019390452653169632, -0.006576872896403074, 0.007938562892377377, 0.010496923699975014, -0.023246178403496742, -0.011166993528604507, 0.013782531954348087, 0.06620270013809204, -0.008380915969610214, -0.01636977680027485, -0.0090927230194211, -0.030456868931651115, 0.03904474154114723, -0.0413961298763752, 0.015160677954554558, 0.0129135362803936, 0.0032654087990522385, -0.04449706897139549, 0.00898650474846363, -0.0377291776239872, -0.004081667400896549, 0.0357629731297493, 0.013214961625635624, 0.05013864487409592, 0.06360729783773422, 0.008686617948114872, 0.020084323361516, -0.07710065692663193, -0.009766269475221634, 0.010438765399158001, 0.022764023393392563, 0.060077693313360214, -0.018229007720947266, -0.02734123356640339, 0.06658819317817688, -0.002451232634484768, 0.012491654604673386, 0.026344921439886093, -0.02515466697514057, -0.019396385177969933, 0.0005277181044220924, -0.028697149828076363, 0.004338457249104977, 0.03588945418596268, -0.04712655767798424, 0.027993276715278625, -0.043844353407621384, -0.028003200888633728, 0.029192257672548294, 0.06162435561418533, -0.025272304192185402, -0.05827008932828903, -0.03965647891163826, -0.09086348861455917, 0.01714230701327324, 0.007430147845298052, -0.014665027149021626, 0.04786129668354988, 0.03139243274927139, 0.05506100878119469, -0.014698611572384834, 0.07078246027231216, -0.04632076993584633, -0.04937917739152908, -0.022746920585632324, -0.004280430730432272, -0.013723534531891346, 0.09507392346858978, -0.008098529651761055, -0.009729665704071522, 0.01298454124480486, -0.04652097448706627, 0.036164458841085434, 0.0035109047312289476, 0.04676656052470207, -0.0049307746812701225, 0.06501951813697815, -0.017721615731716156, 0.011917633935809135, -0.019007597118616104, -0.021179819479584694, 0.12814241647720337, 0.07102952152490616, 0.03039410524070263, -0.050756532698869705, 0.02615104615688324, 0.03873901814222336, 0.008361874148249626, 0.005583606660366058, -0.04413866996765137, 0.045435257256031036, -0.021286271512508392, 0.07321774214506149, 0.015244899317622185, 0.02937629260122776, -0.0341021828353405, 0.03251597285270691, -0.006596943363547325, -0.005865017417818308, -0.02045241743326187, 0.015530267730355263, 0.02539040893316269, -0.021858546882867813, -0.029933897778391838, -0.009516940452158451, 0.01781373843550682, -0.033653222024440765, -0.03668705374002457, -0.009385337121784687, 0.004530093166977167, -0.028916487470269203, -0.01915929652750492, 0.02781669609248638, -0.003211447037756443, 0.010491165332496166, -0.029211105778813362, 0.022841263562440872, -0.0016347559867426753, -0.03261621668934822, 0.02030048333108425, 0.042761772871017456, 0.03126997873187065, 0.027975885197520256, 0.008986677043139935, 0.03584959730505943, -0.04327994957566261, -0.010374420322477818, -0.05572919175028801, 0.05255349352955818, 0.00701826112344861, -0.03166615217924118, 0.003680307185277343, -0.02543335221707821, 0.0006364612490870059, -0.014033451676368713, -0.012179190292954445, 0.03206950053572655, -0.012675256468355656, -0.006929612718522549, 0.025009753182530403, -0.01486529316753149, 0.034500930458307266, -0.01145046204328537, 0.006669726688414812, 0.04296208545565605, -0.037843622267246246, 0.002144131576642394, -0.05022389441728592, 0.03482488915324211, -0.03638068214058876, 0.022097120061516762, 0.011772966012358665, -0.004034916404634714, 0.0031278033275157213, 0.0023301015608012676, 0.035148005932569504, 0.019229495897889137, 0.025886649265885353, -0.0074326032772660255, 0.00016128888819366693, -0.039092570543289185, -0.021766958758234978, 0.03043743595480919, -0.0027746595442295074, -0.003620306495577097, -0.025732828304171562, -0.02916938066482544, 0.05427166819572449, 0.007052975706756115, 0.0014028400182724, 0.018860701471567154, -0.0008633782272227108, 0.038708724081516266, -0.0053523085080087185, -0.07212485373020172, 0.008832879364490509, 0.02917793020606041, -0.009897692129015923, 0.012189293280243874, -0.06187831237912178, 0.059874437749385834, 0.019168078899383545, 0.013244465924799442, -0.014001680538058281, 0.020712418481707573, -0.007056943140923977, -0.027400946244597435, 0.024414649233222008, 0.001094941166229546, 0.010934289544820786, 0.032864611595869064, -0.002687617903575301, 0.0071107991971075535, 0.028513530269265175, -0.06757771223783493, -0.05438929796218872, 0.020600542426109314, -0.015595093369483948, -0.026998812332749367, 0.021646158769726753, -0.02163856290280819, -0.0029601436108350754, -0.02659345418214798, -0.01689709536731243, -0.051048967987298965, -0.005817367695271969, -0.025401150807738304, -0.029086865484714508, -0.033105749636888504, 0.03581919148564339, -0.012400025501847267, -0.028276124969124794, 0.03564108535647392, 0.008230641484260559, 0.023969551548361778, -0.018141472712159157, 0.022208314388990402, 0.022003497928380966, 0.03604934737086296, 0.023624135181307793, -0.02843051590025425, 0.0030655174050480127, -0.02626395784318447, -0.03098190389573574, -0.011543517000973225, -0.008776634931564331, 0.03069891408085823, 0.014712408185005188, 0.0024595276918262243, -0.022469060495495796, 0.05824003368616104, 0.0027030757628381252, -0.02040856145322323, -0.020899470895528793, -0.032953765243291855, 0.012590802274644375, -0.030958957970142365, 0.016223182901740074, -0.006197981536388397, -0.005611599422991276, -0.01283140480518341, 0.06441626697778702, -0.03957459703087807, 0.01287925522774458, -0.003179907565936446, 0.015317353419959545, 0.02291969582438469, 0.010443741455674171, -0.028306690976023674, 0.011811782605946064, 0.038473255932331085, -0.02688531205058098, 0.016410943120718002, -0.025992682203650475, 0.014029247686266899, -0.086138516664505, -0.018290458247065544, -0.006913082208484411, 0.040222831070423126, 0.015494597144424915, -0.02783142402768135, -0.013765803538262844, 0.039104968309402466, -0.00920198392122984, 0.0017256966093555093, -0.010082053020596504, 0.03218088671565056, -0.02444305829703808, 0.028263920918107033, -0.01991376280784607, 0.0053819576278328896, 0.009049326181411743, 0.03140907734632492, 0.0649304986000061, 0.0010493554873391986, 0.00045425823191180825, -0.03606034442782402, -0.02839563973248005, 0.0021581894252449274, 0.013789083808660507, -0.049096547067165375, 0.0041746655479073524, -0.02604740485548973, 0.02523944526910782, 0.024543892592191696, -0.004607901908457279, 0.03176899999380112, 0.004676314070820808, 0.018151745200157166, 0.03029090352356434, 0.023417983204126358, 0.0209262203425169, 0.02003490924835205, -0.03230490908026695, -0.016046782955527306, 0.006326228380203247, -0.027028148993849754, -0.051412809640169144, 0.04890703409910202, 0.010634764097630978, 0.0243106409907341, -0.014458791352808475, 0.007325017359107733, 0.0015293324831873178, -0.009178596548736095, -0.050429217517375946, 0.012715499848127365, 0.017535103484988213, -0.02885323017835617, -0.03341538831591606, -0.041519731283187866, 0.027869611978530884, 0.015848301351070404, 0.042371027171611786, -0.031979575753211975, 0.01860598288476467, -0.01112458761781454, 0.0052855354733765125, -0.007521586026996374, 0.012704689987003803, 0.017912840470671654, -0.0488867424428463, -0.018621953204274178, -0.03192184865474701, -0.008186954073607922, -0.06616261601448059, -0.011373325251042843, -0.047117020934820175, 0.04109298810362816, -0.02962423302233219, 0.010860400274395943, 0.00999384094029665, 0.025567518547177315, 0.044868431985378265, -0.1068563163280487, 0.030819499865174294, 0.01381862536072731, -0.0022987157572060823, -0.06906219571828842, -0.008654661476612091, -0.0683809146285057, 0.05989157408475876, 0.05112804099917412, 0.0297261830419302, -0.009144041687250137, 0.014868133701384068, 0.028824882581830025, -0.020965198054909706, -0.049052644520998, 0.06418269127607346, -0.024420268833637238, 0.0070623490028083324, -0.03669518232345581, 0.012323394417762756, -0.0024349410086870193, 0.028538748621940613, 0.010903260670602322, -0.0026448112912476063, -0.027641024440526962, 0.0023928028531372547, -0.03783448040485382, 0.02471349760890007, -0.03907719999551773, -0.0435037687420845, 0.026571333408355713, -0.00345126842148602, 0.0425168015062809, 0.06188473477959633, 0.0341552272439003, -0.04358242079615593, 0.04395977780222893, -0.03585237264633179, 0.006650974974036217, 0.0017357609467580914, -0.03579140827059746, -0.012829437851905823, -0.05734395980834961, 0.015072501264512539, -0.005795136094093323, -0.05173987150192261, 0.007139564026147127, -0.031302593648433685, 0.013133242726325989, 0.03442619368433952, -0.005415021907538176, 0.037705421447753906, -0.01304534450173378, -0.015375301241874695, 0.013447898440063, -0.005838355515152216, 0.012691260315477848, -0.004992459435015917, 0.00948955025523901, 0.028786582872271538, -0.03381512686610222, 0.02690841257572174, -0.0057113198563456535, 0.0632115975022316, -0.008164414204657078, -0.00858528446406126, 0.01208342146128416, -0.0025520306080579758, -0.04571094736456871, 0.0007536321063525975, -0.011935426853597164, 0.004871083423495293, -0.07527704536914825, 0.030154598876833916, -0.0023182318545877934, 0.006598261184990406, 0.008802486583590508, 0.009010398760437965, 0.021924329921603203, -0.021388528868556023, 0.011056570336222649, 0.02393588423728943, 0.014613447710871696, -0.01629727892577648, -0.013090288266539574, -0.007064945064485073, 0.022675499320030212, -0.014076325111091137, -0.021855764091014862, -0.036782264709472656, -0.03136783838272095, -0.03922563046216965, -0.053446024656295776, 0.01487712562084198, 0.02276100404560566, 0.016389936208724976, -0.07174374163150787, -0.022484390065073967, -0.005739228799939156, 0.033799100667238235, -0.03594443202018738, -0.01926398277282715, -0.009709572419524193, 0.02737276814877987, 0.003262026235461235, -0.002321941079571843 ]
<p>I am confused between what types of problems these three models capture, and their applications:</p> <ul> <li><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latent_Dirichlet_allocation" rel="nofollow">Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA)</a></li> <li><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirichlet_process" rel="nofollow">Dirichlet Processes</a> and <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pitman%E2%80%93Yor_process" rel="nofollow">Pitman-Yor processes</a></li> <li><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hierarchical_Dirichlet_process" rel="nofollow">Hierarchical Dirichlet Process</a> (HDP) &amp; Hierarhical Pitman-Yor Processes</li> </ul> <p>More than formal definitions (which I can find on Wikipedia), I am looking for the <strong>intuition</strong> behind each of them ( how they build on each other).</p> <p>Perhaps, more specifically:</p> <ul> <li>Is the difference between LDA and HDP that LDA is parameteric (i.e. I need to pre-specify the number of topics) whereas HDP is non-parametric? (and therefore I don't need to know how many topics I have)</li> <li>What is the difference between a Dirichlet Processes and Pitman-Yor Processes? </li> <li>What is the difference between a non-parametric process (e.g. DP) and a hierarhical non-parametric process (e.g. HDP)?</li> </ul>
73,393
[ -0.04332451894879341, -0.04584262892603874, 0.010662217624485493, -0.02033008076250553, 0.05214031785726547, -0.02496396377682686, -0.016044186428189278, -0.04397592693567276, 0.05012480542063713, -0.023308929055929184, 0.03252824768424034, -0.01859728805720806, 0.048584867268800735, 0.004154419060796499, 0.01907903142273426, 0.04086309298872948, 0.004149054177105427, 0.006907034199684858, -0.016737112775444984, -0.005632298067212105, 0.005294193979352713, -0.0069946651346981525, 0.022140568122267723, -0.001433574128895998, -0.02330508641898632, 0.016076529398560524, 0.007757502608001232, -0.0017986595630645752, -0.0027215145528316498, 0.05130719766020775, -0.022432681173086166, -0.007705755066126585, -0.039460960775613785, 0.026148509234189987, -0.007761064916849136, -0.010456012561917305, -0.030849529430270195, -0.02427433803677559, -0.02618774026632309, 0.007191861979663372, -0.03932205215096474, -0.029478657990694046, -0.007197770290076733, 0.027100449427962303, -0.04554465040564537, 0.027606988325715065, 0.00010001908958656713, -0.03176378086209297, 0.01987324468791485, -0.04183861240744591, 0.03124896064400673, -0.002394447335973382, 0.042951829731464386, 0.035361818969249725, -0.0011871601454913616, -0.020177975296974182, 0.013777695596218109, 0.10547562688589096, -0.00042455579387024045, -0.03748645633459091, -0.03364860266447067, 0.006858144421130419, 0.005679405760020018, -0.034047067165374756, -0.0581776462495327, 0.051683757454156876, 0.009159478358924389, -0.02870091423392296, 0.0286409892141819, 0.01927482895553112, 0.02686144970357418, 0.013508079573512077, 0.05327637121081352, -0.021573835983872414, 0.034485090523958206, -0.03444545343518257, -0.01858670823276043, 0.013878127560019493, 0.03797952085733414, 0.031742408871650696, 0.015316658653318882, 0.019154250621795654, -0.009841430000960827, 0.015409775078296661, -0.005592597648501396, -0.004812208935618401, 0.08948250114917755, -0.011138116009533405, 0.010175238363444805, -0.02097116969525814, -0.04266679286956787, -0.0067970422096550465, 0.034813471138477325, 0.01293947920203209, -0.03329979255795479, 0.01590745709836483, 0.009834983386099339, 0.030239179730415344, 0.010497603565454483, 0.0010275207459926605, -0.026059886440634727, -0.05051102861762047, 0.008402078412473202, 0.04886684939265251, 0.002413316862657666, -0.015545657835900784, -0.01757292076945305, 0.020025411620736122, -0.05339159816503525, 0.006034000776708126, -0.03345796838402748, 0.0693928599357605, -0.0008554331725463271, -0.00010006052616517991, -0.001595006207935512, 0.00883095059543848, -0.001175113720819354, -0.02792736515402794, 0.0480794832110405, 0.08967239409685135, 0.04316472262144089, -0.05280596390366554, 0.03575414791703224, -0.033728454262018204, -0.07258273661136627, 0.003487519221380353, 0.03165120258927345, -0.014188508503139019, -0.057372111827135086, 0.050993192940950394, 0.01752125844359398, -0.013901210390031338, 0.05249493941664696, 0.03782022371888161, 0.022929534316062927, -0.0016479275655001402, -0.06090009957551956, -0.0631881132721901, 0.02107970602810383, 0.034743234515190125, 0.02335435152053833, -0.06080007925629616, -0.00014603340241592377, 0.023751022294163704, 0.03161008656024933, -0.01688227243721485, 0.006118978373706341, 0.03598005697131157, 0.04604402184486389, 0.01162648107856512, -0.0691218227148056, 0.042618442326784134, -0.004021647851914167, 0.012276655063033104, 0.007121625822037458, -0.09700777381658554, 0.01733347587287426, 0.0232472475618124, -0.02321067452430725, -0.02017953433096409, 0.04282405599951744, 0.004987331107258797, 0.00962330773472786, -0.017801258713006973, 0.02550354227423668, 0.0011757287429645658, 0.06532168388366699, -0.01540266815572977, 0.026834353804588318, 0.05352885276079178, 0.02973836101591587, 0.02464412897825241, 0.0024047631304711103, 0.05538605526089668, 0.03110383450984955, -0.01379680447280407, 0.0171272661536932, -0.0028123059310019016, 0.010112611576914787, 0.019684668630361557, -0.048416804522275925, -0.03153808414936066, -0.013398047536611557, 0.014078164473176003, 0.00194434798322618, 0.019450170919299126, 0.011420398019254208, -0.005826065316796303, 0.032469313591718674, -0.027840591967105865, -0.05654324218630791, -0.049248553812503815, 0.011031272821128368, -0.05560183897614479, 0.004520866554230452, 0.07893962413072586, -0.012498758733272552, -0.024791264906525612, -0.026964403688907623, 0.014387753792107105, 0.006991250440478325, 0.004628044553101063, 0.013488915748894215, -0.03633211925625801, -0.0047478280030190945, 0.05434350296854973, 0.01602141372859478, -0.03137991204857826, 0.045635782182216644, -0.05955727770924568, -0.027521828189492226, -0.02100490778684616, -0.02011835016310215, 0.023218119516968727, -0.01529671810567379, -0.013406798243522644, -0.0028170680161565542, -0.0054077222011983395, -0.024250565096735954, 0.035752732306718826, -0.07134491205215454, 0.0948484018445015, 0.04755399748682976, -0.0055465493351221085, 0.00013586986460722983, 0.0352126844227314, -0.01343023031949997, 0.03809291496872902, -0.028369545936584473, -0.001527279382571578, -0.05452355742454529, -0.004660708364099264, 0.03477179631590843, 0.013845052570104599, -0.022066570818424225, 0.007772278040647507, 0.0303978119045496, 0.029241934418678284, 0.013740593567490578, 0.02811056561768055, -0.035032592713832855, -0.025008881464600563, 0.01804501935839653, 0.03319546580314636, -0.025773582980036736, 0.01098297256976366, -0.010645371861755848, -0.03569808602333069, 0.04910122603178024, -0.02841312624514103, -0.008975791744887829, 0.09070653468370438, -0.010066668502986431, -0.0013077912153676152, -0.01417878083884716, 0.01583627425134182, 0.042346082627773285, -0.013346895575523376, -0.015475007705390453, 0.06162131205201149, 0.0065346467308700085, -0.037903934717178345, 0.0014296817826107144, -0.03384581580758095, 0.010281168855726719, 0.02180267870426178, -0.030259327962994576, 0.007779882289469242, 0.027701353654265404, -0.007520805578678846, 0.04899746924638748, -0.0046918513253331184, -0.004683576989918947, -0.040699493139982224, 0.0032256552949547768, 0.020349429920315742, -0.017216186970472336, 0.009871446527540684, -0.028530476614832878, -0.02462102100253105, 0.02426748536527157, -0.03578519821166992, 0.002979824785143137, -0.004033749923110008, -0.07023672014474869, 0.012962322682142258, -0.03833162412047386, -0.006367434747517109, 0.02691262774169445, 0.0004521344671957195, 0.002728874096646905, 0.0032092160545289516, -0.018360696732997894, -0.0525980219244957, -0.041819531470537186, 0.0033252439461648464, 0.05246394872665405, -0.022161299362778664, -0.013380421325564384, 0.0663268193602562, 0.01237475872039795, -0.03435497730970383, 0.03198176622390747, -0.025249402970075607, -0.0376434251666069, -0.07131468504667282, 0.00961936917155981, 0.002861974062398076, 0.0019706832244992256, -0.010371942073106766, 0.04319140315055847, -0.0515289306640625, -0.0005012289038859308, -0.062160033732652664, -0.058422524482011795, 0.009788468480110168, -0.006673512980341911, 0.03463325649499893, 0.011911343783140182, -0.02560286596417427, 0.02266121655702591, 0.026668118312954903, -0.04290873557329178, -0.0531252957880497, 0.00345582771115005, -0.0620509497821331, -0.0011450742604210973, 0.010291018523275852, 0.010825753211975098, -0.017823345959186554, 0.00027148137451149523, 0.036259304732084274, 0.036212008446455, 0.027304144576191902, 0.02602490782737732, 0.007605078164488077, 0.0024615852162241936, 0.02243334986269474, -0.036000806838274, 0.021197332069277763, -0.003251198912039399, -0.02930372580885887, -0.010661661624908447, -0.047096118330955505, 0.009394479915499687, -0.0018104355549439788, -0.03471589833498001, -0.0007656413363292813, -0.011378111317753792, -0.056400470435619354, -0.019572759047150612, -0.010948613286018372, 0.02486729435622692, -0.05975111573934555, 0.001777605852112174, 0.029389729723334312, 0.03196919336915016, -0.03445911034941673, 0.008800644427537918, 0.029605688527226448, 0.0471452921628952, -0.04951866343617439, 0.024859044700860977, -0.06082192808389664, 0.0126638263463974, 0.0072572920471429825, 0.007422523573040962, 0.016531459987163544, 0.07550525665283203, 0.042456332594156265, 0.005339037626981735, -0.002724127611145377, -0.021789779886603355, -0.011893723160028458, -0.08844558894634247, 0.03132311627268791, -0.03140750899910927, 0.06539841741323471, -0.004317212384194136, 0.022997455671429634, -0.007468864321708679, 0.021103329956531525, 0.03633558005094528, 0.014858338050544262, -0.05278540030121803, 0.007357264868915081, -0.02843662165105343, 0.007455045823007822, -0.0024436379317194223, 0.0012806302402168512, 0.04140859097242355, -0.018941842019557953, -0.0024060735013335943, -0.0012166221858933568, 0.03546780347824097, -0.04419845715165138, 0.026936668902635574, -0.04418924078345299, -0.02053133212029934, -0.010450727306306362, -0.009939897805452347, 0.017910398542881012, -0.025913875550031662, 0.03863261640071869, 0.03687799721956253, 0.0017349637346342206, -0.021408144384622574, -0.01556678768247366, 0.013398291543126106, 0.04158252850174904, 0.01881434954702854, 0.018286338075995445, 0.03045240230858326, -0.01479581743478775, 0.042054977267980576, 0.013517447747290134, 0.04664938151836395, 0.02640802599489689, -0.018355680629611015, -0.019697654992341995, -0.07858304679393768, -0.022616088390350342, -0.002867414616048336, 0.051329635083675385, 0.025380779057741165, -0.0035481834784150124, 0.010808393359184265, -0.001119646243751049, -0.002861246233806014, 0.020199384540319443, 0.019674263894557953, -0.019171737134456635, 0.0007907021208666265, -0.023308226838707924, 0.009006594307720661, 0.01287232618778944, -0.005909394472837448, 0.04420569911599159, -0.0036242366768419743, -0.011572121642529964, 0.0007217164966277778, 0.0060911173932254314, -0.03684613108634949, -0.04705289751291275, -0.009750662371516228, 0.03614470735192299, 0.020795904099941254, -0.010087191127240658, -0.06849553436040878, -0.012359519489109516, 0.0716736763715744, 0.048748988658189774, 0.013292558491230011, 0.024659622460603714, -0.06845875084400177, -0.02024742215871811, 0.032239895313978195, 0.007582776248455048, -0.04059521108865738, -0.00047516083577647805, -0.029322922229766846, -0.05591914430260658, 0.017587846145033836, -0.0053715272806584835, 0.005477136000990868, 0.016979975625872612, -0.008591379970312119, 0.015585516579449177, -0.018447689712047577, -0.018246913328766823, 0.00014800897042732686, 0.023365750908851624, 0.03137149289250374, -0.043044086545705795, -0.0055328430607914925, -0.04649430513381958, -0.0027960322331637144, 0.004729045554995537, 0.04458241164684296, -0.027363663539290428, -0.0022654759231954813, 0.0006618964252993464, 0.02287541702389717, -0.029566721990704536, -0.07009069621562958, 0.004648066125810146, 0.03233921527862549, -0.016906656324863434, 0.056269463151693344, -0.03563755005598068, -0.07130323350429535, 0.005448693409562111, 0.006028556264936924, -0.04307772219181061, 0.018698597326874733, -0.01862882450222969, 0.034067507833242416, 0.03322704881429672, 0.004916943609714508, 0.06946969032287598, 0.06012990325689316, -0.034029096364974976, -0.00016863943892531097, -0.01499094720929861, 0.020451927557587624, -0.03379763290286064, -0.007115334738045931, -0.05764206498861313, 0.0022655280772596598, -0.05476479232311249, 0.03147723153233528, -0.00022363108291756362, -0.004303939640522003, -0.03288096562027931, -0.025165611878037453, -0.01483894046396017, 0.039593297988176346, 0.015540898777544498, 0.009668780490756035, -0.014275191351771355, 0.05462707206606865, 0.032635681331157684, -0.012927740812301636, 0.03532913327217102, -0.019076932221651077, 0.00261123338714242, 0.014469964429736137, -0.009995332919061184, -0.016567286103963852, -0.030555782839655876, -0.00864509679377079, 0.056170474737882614, 0.010568914003670216, 0.016311435028910637, 0.012365342117846012, 0.06555783003568649, 0.006226422265172005, -0.0841602236032486, 0.001955487998202443, -0.007433256600052118, -0.0037064843345433474, 0.010866133496165276, -0.025242267176508904, 0.035194337368011475, -0.021564071998000145, -0.04062566161155701, -0.028213368728756905, -0.04002344235777855, 0.027143774554133415, 0.012767020612955093, -0.05483373999595642, -0.0446220301091671, 0.004801249597221613, -0.011973106302320957, -0.026204807683825493, -0.0263108778744936, 0.09371893107891083, -0.05058388039469719, 0.015585669316351414, 0.04865533486008644, 0.03281965106725693, 0.05964022874832153, 0.01600942388176918, 0.02898072637617588, -0.006062321364879608, 0.023381158709526062, -0.004297868814319372, -0.024964215233922005, 0.04322410374879837, -0.05052221938967705, 0.012716447003185749, -0.0015095125418156385, -0.0004048356495331973, 0.046987276524305344, -0.04422355443239212, 0.0026115006767213345, -0.002365734428167343, -0.012788481079041958, -0.0017372859874740243, -0.04087012633681297, -0.02041495591402054, 0.010385685600340366, -0.0062507083639502525, -0.004931567702442408, 0.030532855540513992, 0.030798308551311493, -0.02424461767077446, 0.01614311896264553, -0.0210297629237175, 0.014951147139072418, 0.023330654948949814, 0.014173302799463272, -0.02080407179892063, 0.05071595683693886, 0.003339623799547553, -0.022155821323394775, 0.06833086907863617, -0.05068797618150711, 0.010780173353850842, 0.037266556173563004, -0.005615680478513241, -0.029339168220758438, -0.05723384767770767, -0.047623924911022186, 0.032333068549633026, 0.03537362813949585, 0.016745518893003464, 0.03873310983181, 0.010519154369831085, -0.02594328299164772, 0.035090092569589615, -0.0578126385807991, 0.004295183811336756, -0.008180638775229454, -0.010005985386669636, 0.05268936604261398, -0.00009843937732512131, -0.019075628370046616, 0.0728992372751236, 0.008836477063596249, 0.052260227501392365, 0.016092641279101372, 0.028583552688360214, 0.015229308046400547, 0.007126822602003813, -0.03866518661379814, -0.018698420375585556, 0.024760864675045013, -0.014343158341944218, 0.019069615751504898, -0.008618703112006187, -0.04413018003106117, 0.08799175173044205, 0.04893256351351738, -0.004495831206440926, -0.061905890703201294, 0.0015637149335816503, -0.07750282436609268, 0.011162196286022663, 0.029005354270339012, 0.02981184981763363, -0.0245341919362545, -0.009777897968888283, 0.035569705069065094, -0.0010101799853146076, 0.005135434679687023, 0.017522146925330162, -0.06779918819665909, -0.025904005393385887, -0.016435794532299042, -0.04239945486187935, 0.000547242583706975, 0.001992596546187997, -0.04402585327625275, 0.01816956140100956, -0.004209734965115786, -0.00931780505925417, 0.014074509963393211, 0.03358256816864014, -0.014690441079437733, 0.04881303012371063, 0.016556046903133392, 0.03371407091617584, -0.00766099663451314, -0.015502022579312325, 0.10218126326799393, 0.08481809496879578, 0.050494950264692307, -0.051139600574970245, 0.04810207709670067, 0.000009640251846576575, 0.012647579424083233, -0.006103485357016325, 0.014332488179206848, 0.016849059611558914, 0.004907486494630575, 0.03958373889327049, 0.025457749143242836, -0.001724696485325694, 0.011587847024202347, 0.06848736852407455, -0.0552532821893692, -0.014909747987985611, 0.010279438458383083, -0.03984454274177551, -0.01157169695943594, -0.015923216938972473, -0.02876567654311657, 0.036657556891441345, 0.02640792913734913, 0.0024189844261854887, -0.023447787389159203, -0.017939617857336998, 0.020967410877346992, -0.016622725874185562, -0.025293296203017235, -0.02212602086365223, 0.006568925455212593, 0.017466945573687553, 0.008094248361885548, 0.025735827162861824, -0.001792229013517499, -0.04392138868570328, 0.022181542590260506, 0.034846268594264984, 0.00897815078496933, -0.01681780070066452, -0.009040712378919125, 0.016244346275925636, -0.019166236743330956, -0.03418457880616188, -0.045425429940223694, 0.013808042742311954, -0.018372811377048492, 0.00773488637059927, -0.014074251055717468, -0.01542701292783022, 0.01935124769806862, -0.014692164026200771, -0.007866659201681614, 0.013119684532284737, 0.02501343935728073, 0.005914997775107622, -0.016267482191324234, -0.0502840094268322, 0.024916570633649826, -0.023370884358882904, 0.0333474837243557, -0.007616925984621048, -0.025641823187470436, -0.023807119578123093, -0.04373634234070778, 0.05098312348127365, 0.004343521781265736, 0.0034203955437988043, -0.004325754474848509, 0.01697162352502346, -0.03773510828614235, -0.007132700644433498, -0.004669179208576679, -0.00013705871242564172, 0.06308620423078537, 0.00997551716864109, -0.013423513621091843, -0.018270818516612053, -0.034190695732831955, 0.006931418087333441, 0.01092644315212965, -0.04279179126024246, -0.0398029126226902, -0.008106283843517303, 0.019909881055355072, 0.03394150361418724, 0.02079128287732601, 0.04012315347790718, -0.033292006701231, 0.03836236521601677, -0.010922819375991821, -0.068924181163311, -0.00430421344935894, -0.03030223399400711, -0.013804890215396881, -0.03190683200955391, -0.010359523817896843, 0.05453164502978325, 0.01776229962706566, 0.003624414559453726, -0.03558971732854843, 0.03461867570877075, 0.005098741035908461, 0.01245167851448059, -0.011265840381383896, -0.02217148244380951, 0.02957928366959095, 0.05670135095715523, 0.036972612142562866, -0.03619121015071869, 0.005582422949373722, -0.019249197095632553, -0.027694402262568474, 0.017690185457468033, -0.027788007631897926, -0.03473731875419617, -0.029300879687070847, -0.03116854839026928, 0.06038779392838478, -0.020779576152563095, 0.01837039552628994, -0.02781243436038494, 0.02213643677532673, 0.025919701904058456, -0.009385364130139351, 0.010705375112593174, 0.02145090326666832, -0.0010555151384323835, -0.026476142928004265, 0.026191480457782745, -0.0025188717991113663, -0.02299969643354416, -0.009555038996040821, 0.012574320659041405, -0.011962140910327435, 0.017890838906168938, -0.0044863405637443066, -0.03996196761727333, 0.054045528173446655, -0.040959279984235764, -0.06608981639146805, 0.016758577898144722, 0.005561545491218567, 0.012594038620591164, 0.026855094358325005, 0.0012335561914369464, -0.018101312220096588, 0.023020626977086067, -0.01105397380888462, -0.013796049170196056, 0.011736282147467136, -0.021245766431093216, -0.02100413851439953, -0.03487247973680496, 0.015319658443331718, 0.025392459705471992, -0.007318392861634493, 0.0274644885212183, 0.011218542233109474, -0.005231298506259918, -0.015501990914344788, 0.012986386194825172, -0.023930303752422333, 0.02476189285516739, -0.023596059530973434, -0.0018509079236537218, 0.03610002249479294, 0.05473962053656578, -0.030199334025382996, 0.031637437641620636, 0.006457563955336809, 0.011313650757074356, -0.08350490033626556, 0.001991389086470008, -0.021945251151919365, -0.03572416678071022, 0.018692292273044586, -0.04680359363555908, -0.009672267362475395, 0.029622113332152367, -0.017749639227986336, 0.02763289213180542, 0.030463730916380882, 0.02702033333480358, -0.026435568928718567, 0.011725540272891521, -0.04147045686841011, 0.04695293307304382, 0.010800091549754143, 0.03239315003156662, 0.03781742602586746, -0.0026738226879388094, 0.00423321733251214, -0.003084503347054124, -0.030734218657016754, -0.01508228201419115, -0.015390862710773945, -0.04845599830150604, 0.05684581398963928, -0.0185285322368145, -0.05208561569452286, 0.035498183220624924, 0.015155293978750706, -0.0061662164516747, 0.02752234786748886, -0.01442661788314581, 0.013141541741788387, 0.004779120907187462, 0.011507144197821617, -0.005864781327545643, 0.005136855412274599, 0.03685176745057106, 0.008748788386583328, 0.02810824103653431, 0.02338402345776558, 0.008692735806107521, 0.03486425057053566, -0.021296050399541855, 0.02075166441500187, 0.04138752073049545, -0.0010683932341635227, -0.02318057231605053, 0.005219686310738325, -0.043364644050598145, 0.02194744162261486, -0.012619514018297195, 0.02546035125851631, -0.029314182698726654, 0.016419392079114914, 0.02969767153263092, -0.009021940641105175, -0.03216368705034256, 0.017573803663253784, 0.0017854234902188182, -0.034660857170820236, 0.007804590277373791, -0.0011328253895044327, 0.0004432333225850016, -0.015679961070418358, 0.01118867751210928, 0.019010448828339577, -0.011305493302643299, -0.053715530782938004, -0.020059537142515182, -0.06142590939998627, 0.03915594145655632, -0.07960155606269836, 0.009988456964492798, 0.027641216292977333, -0.017992446199059486, 0.0087530966848135, -0.06718000769615173, 0.0721624344587326, -0.010562359355390072, -0.009408588521182537, -0.04881126806139946, 0.03130942955613136, -0.014966997317969799, 0.005524241831153631, 0.0758635550737381, -0.0037303371354937553, 0.011960264295339584, 0.02099774032831192, -0.015311835333704948, 0.025462957099080086, -0.008430940099060535, 0.03541811555624008, -0.02836991474032402, 0.02506234496831894, 0.005818669218569994, -0.016819946467876434, 0.011896266601979733, 0.03391190618276596, 0.03131162002682686, -0.009210378862917423, -0.008157439529895782, 0.0269430223852396, -0.0220653023570776, 0.00014088534226175398, 0.015102789737284184, -0.003525095758959651, 0.052461277693510056, -0.012114198878407478, 0.011020500212907791, -0.013810629025101662, 0.00498595554381609, -0.010573945008218288, 0.031612616032361984, -0.027809113264083862, -0.047322582453489304, 0.0041106510907411575, 0.005380976479500532, 0.001259868498891592, -0.05173657089471817, -0.03331799432635307, 0.031618569046258926, -0.0338677242398262, -0.015579920262098312, 0.025324495509266853, 0.052901044487953186, 0.033990487456321716, 0.0025780710857361555, 0.009728475473821163, 0.025807535275816917, -0.02062041684985161, -0.005438660271465778, 0.01023803185671568, 0.04756647348403931, -0.0036862168926745653, 0.014542261138558388, 0.0033509170170873404, -0.022128308191895485, 0.029911251738667488, -0.014862331561744213, 0.059808265417814255, -0.0020334923174232244, -0.027978505939245224, 0.012341262772679329, 0.01390900369733572, -0.02466808632016182, 0.020887643098831177, 0.01965516246855259, 0.08185888081789017, 0.005124089308083057, -0.0008874196792021394, -0.01712667942047119, 0.01313692331314087, -0.01811377704143524, 0.005130266770720482, -0.019216176122426987, 0.046673428267240524, 0.020681925117969513, -0.004422164522111416, -0.03781983628869057, -0.004863415379077196, 0.03419330716133118, -0.02683686465024948, 0.0327439121901989, 0.00005643007534672506, -0.01331996824592352, -0.03411213681101799, -0.04921922832727432, 0.010104954242706299, -0.0010532395681366324, 0.022325320169329643, 0.038408927619457245, 0.041901055723428726, 0.021287286654114723, -0.03284066915512085, -0.03400499373674393, 0.022850437089800835, -0.08521046489477158, -0.012809226289391518, -0.047433771193027496, -0.008181490004062653, -0.0006988958921283484, 0.0017016901401802897 ]
<p>I have been trying to use <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/sspir/index.html" rel="nofollow">sspir</a> R package to estimate the following Poisson model:</p> <p>$Y_{t}\sim Po(\exp(\lambda_{t}));$ such that $\lambda_{t}=X_{t}\beta +\gamma_{t}$ and $\gamma_{t}=\theta\gamma_{t-1}+u_{t},u_{t}\sim NID(0,\sigma ^{2}).$</p> <p>In State-space form, we have $\lambda_{t}=Z_{t}F_{t},$ $Z_{t}=\left[ X_{t}\: 1\right] ,$ $F_{t}=\left[ \beta^{\prime}\: \gamma_{t}\right] $</p> <p>Then, $F_{t}=\left( \begin{array} [c]{ll}% 1 &amp; 0\\ 0 &amp; \theta \end{array} \right) F_{t-1}+\left( \begin{array} [c]{l}% 0\\ u_{t}% \end{array} \right) $. Standard initial conditions are also set.</p> <p>I have been trying to use <code>sspir</code> package in R to estimate this model, but I was not able to. If I let $\gamma_{t}$ to be a random walk, then it is standard.</p> <p>Any suggestion? I am kind of new with this models so any help is very much appreciated.</p>
35,735
[ 0.019011618569493294, -0.034569643437862396, 0.018221188336610794, 0.025350533425807953, 0.00015245578833855689, -0.020363785326480865, -0.011202271096408367, -0.020177587866783142, 0.0390554815530777, -0.031110838055610657, 0.047192350029945374, 0.02907683700323105, 0.05942600965499878, 0.029484672471880913, 0.04083487391471863, 0.007655233610421419, -0.002461932599544525, -0.0024669712875038385, -0.04496825113892555, 0.01426402572542429, -0.03641923516988754, 0.010716041550040245, -0.028350312262773514, -0.03732055798172951, -0.021491074934601784, 0.05161077156662941, 0.026229610666632652, -0.009435554966330528, -0.019672710448503494, 0.05068086087703705, -0.049783412367105484, 0.009382380172610283, -0.0217919759452343, 0.03916013985872269, -0.0007992770406417549, 0.04858012869954109, -0.0412682369351387, -0.02751252055168152, -0.011388644576072693, -0.0028081124182790518, -0.03009691834449768, 0.0013848262606188655, 0.00039272979483939707, 0.021472452208399773, -0.022690951824188232, 0.008931885473430157, -0.011730783618986607, 0.03030010126531124, 0.06221196427941322, 0.01596640981733799, 0.02847837284207344, 0.010809891857206821, 0.01727260649204254, 0.029553750529885292, 0.004251871723681688, -0.024482665583491325, 0.0430278517305851, 0.03082963451743126, -0.005120942369103432, -0.05806984752416611, -0.049797847867012024, -0.04521189257502556, 0.005557107273489237, -0.048565641045570374, -0.03104563243687153, 0.0027893120422959328, -0.000009169242730422411, -0.021799173206090927, 0.02860238403081894, 0.014199051074683666, 0.021608853712677956, -0.012833495624363422, 0.03571772947907448, 0.03878556564450264, -0.001226452412083745, -0.025481678545475006, -0.01322108693420887, 0.018717363476753235, 0.030386898666620255, 0.0239750687032938, -0.016829749569296837, 0.007204686291515827, 0.008349813520908356, 0.0027724981773644686, -0.006220581941306591, 0.012509283609688282, 0.09465532749891281, 0.02411589026451111, 0.005146562587469816, 0.03279624879360199, -0.041168082505464554, -0.0005145465838722885, 0.06826546043157578, -0.012516766786575317, -0.03316127508878708, 0.04649599269032478, 0.01225463580340147, 0.026065301150083542, 0.009367384016513824, -0.009267659857869148, -0.008433223702013493, -0.069401316344738, 0.015109464526176453, 0.07207925617694855, -0.03043888881802559, -0.016057515516877174, -0.016963539645075798, -0.015886440873146057, -0.029832035303115845, -0.04423678666353226, -0.06346476823091507, 0.014307386241853237, -0.031249884516000748, -0.011045040562748909, -0.009514108300209045, -0.019726015627384186, -0.029719697311520576, 0.0002516757231205702, 0.0307153332978487, 0.03294422850012779, 0.034762680530548096, -0.005822672508656979, 0.03216216713190079, -0.02372804284095764, -0.07991381734609604, 0.012070422992110252, 0.009183001704514027, -0.02412206307053566, -0.056365612894296646, 0.05149146541953087, -0.004619454964995384, -0.027953583747148514, 0.0594664067029953, 0.02553202584385872, 0.06194727122783661, 0.006388596724718809, -0.07442168891429901, -0.02605637162923813, 0.04100858420133591, -0.007282500620931387, 0.07671552151441574, -0.06286615878343582, -0.016973286867141724, -0.010289348661899567, 0.05597345903515816, -0.011734305880963802, 0.027458328753709793, 0.016185566782951355, 0.004090405069291592, -0.003071448765695095, -0.04039629176259041, -0.021036509424448013, -0.0030626473017036915, -0.03481173515319824, -0.019943954423069954, -0.0694262683391571, 0.04603113606572151, 0.01463220827281475, -0.015031356364488602, -0.004964387509971857, 0.02827017568051815, -0.002832495141774416, 0.03337724134325981, -0.03569735214114189, -0.010104135610163212, -0.04515058547258377, 0.03694135323166847, -0.02300679311156273, 0.006605588365346193, 0.009227714501321316, -0.02494928613305092, -0.019369183108210564, -0.020755771547555923, 0.05228646099567413, 0.03615391626954079, -0.023055152967572212, -0.006649870425462723, -0.03871578350663185, -0.020518077537417412, 0.03703735023736954, -0.0413435623049736, -0.03319801390171051, -0.022141259163618088, -0.0306589063256979, -0.01670626364648342, 0.030276283621788025, 0.0012760106474161148, 0.047648146748542786, 0.007104267366230488, -0.03115866333246231, -0.06234206631779671, -0.03696637600660324, -0.023408737033605576, -0.01053033210337162, -0.0006822108989581466, 0.048235610127449036, 0.0035844917874783278, 0.033286113291978836, 0.023587722331285477, -0.045866865664720535, -0.007532251533120871, 0.00594080425798893, 0.028664037585258484, -0.001543876132927835, -0.0061338599771261215, 0.0611022487282753, 0.06723693013191223, -0.006303130183368921, 0.005373024847358465, -0.013721504248678684, -0.017290161922574043, -0.029586225748062134, -0.029579738155007362, 0.0396394357085228, 0.016948742792010307, 0.011649608612060547, 0.05831599608063698, 0.012669514864683151, 0.010555444285273552, 0.01540996041148901, 0.004575922153890133, 0.030770855024456978, 0.0526820607483387, 0.04269324988126755, 0.00040703179547563195, 0.02725256234407425, 0.019411085173487663, 0.04403363913297653, -0.023005619645118713, -0.0033067120239138603, -0.028688112273812294, -0.005458602216094732, 0.0358748622238636, 0.010358620434999466, -0.01453673280775547, -0.020223824307322502, 0.05957702919840813, -0.004128638654947281, 0.02248864620923996, 0.06115163862705231, -0.029521364718675613, -0.032793983817100525, 0.03750520944595337, 0.03661023825407028, 0.019294239580631256, 0.004612354561686516, 0.025352008640766144, -0.031153298914432526, 0.033527765423059464, -0.021904276683926582, -0.014080357737839222, 0.03483150154352188, 0.029290786013007164, -0.007595463190227747, -0.03074675053358078, 0.009619239717721939, 0.07133235782384872, 0.024645108729600906, 0.051791928708553314, 0.03366408497095108, -0.0044616274535655975, -0.02126690186560154, -0.012792079709470272, -0.002009760355576873, 0.021626876667141914, 0.04183204844594002, -0.03746974840760231, -0.0020040911622345448, 0.028024856001138687, -0.049937862902879715, 0.03204667195677757, -0.03026217222213745, -0.05610426515340805, -0.05268111079931259, 0.01668659597635269, 0.0335136353969574, 0.025965889915823936, -0.00892875250428915, -0.037354640662670135, -0.04870189353823662, -0.009981481358408928, -0.01599574275314808, 0.060343675315380096, -0.003201237879693508, -0.038707636296749115, -0.0015452466905117035, 0.002523364033550024, -0.020437082275748253, 0.019326012581586838, 0.02850101701915264, -0.0015413699438795447, 0.005947865545749664, 0.006550776772201061, -0.01859590783715248, -0.008121499791741371, -0.0163184255361557, 0.015784408897161484, -0.04450441524386406, -0.014697453938424587, 0.02143697999417782, 0.0013595749624073505, -0.02766481414437294, 0.022009775042533875, -0.05995455011725426, -0.004436416085809469, -0.015076600015163422, 0.014804558828473091, 0.017230359837412834, -0.016111861914396286, 0.05017213895916939, 0.051810041069984436, -0.007851106114685535, 0.011865850538015366, -0.10724534094333649, -0.06880944967269897, -0.0020007796119898558, -0.01854277402162552, 0.016689278185367584, 0.008602839894592762, 0.0015447130426764488, 0.06349768489599228, 0.033071715384721756, -0.014130481518805027, -0.0346963070333004, 0.04257216304540634, -0.03556721284985542, -0.06754840910434723, 0.007476427126675844, 0.011118186637759209, -0.0003310100582893938, 0.02342846803367138, -0.02109954133629799, 0.026690959930419922, 0.040525440126657486, 0.0191279798746109, 0.006097744684666395, 0.019977889955043793, -0.03718732297420502, -0.020757712423801422, 0.03151986002922058, 0.003235961077734828, 0.03205581381917, -0.01732623390853405, -0.007054911460727453, 0.03139428794384003, 0.00026541086845099926, -0.05535382404923439, 0.03084380179643631, 0.004312776494771242, -0.006038166582584381, -0.030359763652086258, 0.017864281311631203, -0.034215107560157776, -0.05368095263838768, -0.016106221824884415, 0.026580898091197014, 0.040388476103544235, -0.00501683633774519, 0.014826823957264423, 0.05859406664967537, 0.023195335641503334, -0.027270939201116562, -0.002107183448970318, -0.004501902498304844, -0.03867456689476967, -0.0027582200709730387, -0.004834081511944532, -0.012376348488032818, 0.002144274767488241, 0.0498574860394001, 0.015817582607269287, -0.0057520754635334015, 0.019597595557570457, -0.010558459907770157, -0.023459047079086304, 0.01775212585926056, -0.008756333962082863, 0.05951632931828499, 0.05403962358832359, 0.02423369139432907, -0.006756567396223545, -0.011655103415250778, 0.007940806448459625, -0.01671372912824154, -0.11825334280729294, 0.02052237093448639, 0.006407433655112982, -0.03800143301486969, 0.003394166938960552, -0.025830578058958054, 0.05278340354561806, 0.012773491442203522, 0.01891360431909561, 0.013642688281834126, -0.02381337620317936, -0.028865259140729904, -0.01416871976107359, -0.019988959655165672, 0.016352063044905663, -0.04114118218421936, -0.00741842994466424, 0.02562800608575344, -0.00926713366061449, -0.022865336388349533, 0.046420417726039886, 0.004555561579763889, 0.01403331384062767, -0.06763647496700287, 0.03828399255871773, 0.009081658907234669, 0.0208327267318964, 0.02391892485320568, -0.012532642111182213, -0.032253388315439224, 0.020328767597675323, -0.006234141066670418, 0.026149310171604156, 0.04575198143720627, -0.001632622443139553, -0.034835513681173325, -0.06925325095653534, -0.021593419834971428, 0.03408252075314522, -0.0021725897677242756, 0.01733904331922531, 0.010044077411293983, 0.07075350731611252, 0.01635962724685669, -0.005681918002665043, 0.013244538567960262, 0.060091495513916016, 0.0031096250750124454, 0.023771952837705612, -0.0008511494961567223, -0.005172935780137777, -0.010345610789954662, 0.019922006875276566, 0.036367759108543396, 0.0009993009734898806, -0.028213677927851677, 0.013677127659320831, 0.020318344235420227, 0.002932524075731635, -0.003870925400406122, 0.008916530758142471, 0.026165185496211052, 0.05658327415585518, -0.009135863743722439, -0.05321360379457474, 0.013878993690013885, 0.0058846622705459595, 0.025575459003448486, 0.011053962633013725, -0.00948747992515564, -0.07348743081092834, -0.04508104920387268, 0.008474182337522507, 0.014619531109929085, 0.005941609386354685, -0.021106913685798645, -0.0685478001832962, 0.0019267076859250665, 0.033644530922174454, -0.013875207863748074, 0.03781260922551155, -0.010044528171420097, -0.015840759500861168, 0.03432313725352287, -0.04905279725790024, -0.03834255412220955, -0.00357788591645658, -0.032785672694444656, 0.016148190945386887, 0.01739613711833954, -0.04571527615189552, -0.004679531790316105, -0.0035983214620500803, -0.02216329611837864, 0.05492093414068222, -0.007815875113010406, -0.01974528096616268, 0.04859793186187744, 0.006907708942890167, -0.020997704938054085, -0.0913914367556572, 0.0033259023912250996, -0.015167799778282642, 0.023570885881781578, -0.0006127716624177992, -0.00896101351827383, -0.058847978711128235, 0.049362663179636, 0.03918548673391342, -0.0135962450876832, -0.024089390411973, -0.014144075103104115, 0.02713874541223049, 0.02431945502758026, 0.0023861422669142485, 0.041993044316768646, 0.04974929615855217, -0.0031267646700143814, 0.005058520473539829, -0.04532352089881897, -0.032671213150024414, -0.0311944130808115, 0.042905185371637344, -0.05320267751812935, 0.018820026889443398, -0.011617416515946388, 0.04901512712240219, -0.009350908920168877, 0.006308862939476967, -0.04696907103061676, 0.01812499202787876, -0.019735021516680717, 0.009541352279484272, -0.006863637827336788, -0.008644334971904755, -0.013415179215371609, 0.00456157186999917, 0.0032876278273761272, -0.010358043946325779, 0.005309956148266792, -0.058816827833652496, -0.01177658699452877, 0.004118619952350855, -0.049063779413700104, 0.002042478183284402, 0.009919621050357819, -0.009545897133648396, 0.014955163933336735, -0.0272083580493927, 0.04300510883331299, 0.009848092682659626, 0.022061271592974663, 0.01683073863387108, -0.03568127751350403, 0.002051630523055792, 0.02096705324947834, 0.0000924312844290398, -0.008332440629601479, -0.05058175325393677, 0.04731113836169243, -0.014009361155331135, -0.02574423886835575, -0.05721907317638397, -0.07780356705188751, 0.04408038780093193, -0.05857235938310623, -0.04456384479999542, -0.04115291312336922, 0.0026727847289294004, -0.01922711171209812, -0.05064800754189491, 0.008601127192378044, 0.021239111199975014, -0.006190970074385405, 0.006501188036054373, 0.0007374816341325641, 0.03818226605653763, 0.08039459586143494, 0.038731638342142105, 0.0129161411896348, 0.052743326872587204, -0.020681636407971382, -0.039774902164936066, -0.0029769924003630877, 0.043196700513362885, -0.027268337085843086, 0.011034447699785233, -0.013936423696577549, -0.04948010295629501, 0.011867771856486797, 0.0034040457103401423, -0.013414719142019749, 0.02425849437713623, -0.009305145591497421, 0.06999704986810684, -0.050622839480638504, -0.009082243777811527, -0.01927589438855648, 0.02517055533826351, -0.034335847944021225, -0.005246641114354134, 0.006373144686222076, -0.0030102331656962633, 0.055896516889333725, -0.019239094108343124, 0.0011649200459942222, 0.02645537070930004, 0.07851951569318771, 0.001872721710242331, -0.024891385808587074, 0.0048392522148787975, 0.0074907769449055195, 0.04924498125910759, 0.022724736481904984, 0.020534640178084373, 0.03252929076552391, 0.0196429081261158, -0.059468384832143784, -0.02387208864092827, -0.018617603927850723, 0.0032743075862526894, 0.05100029706954956, -0.02832699939608574, 0.03355938941240311, 0.040004801005125046, -0.054916832596063614, 0.03259512782096863, -0.016303272917866707, -0.020682545378804207, 0.004142929799854755, 0.017089417204260826, 0.048366427421569824, 0.02501886896789074, -0.015334276482462883, 0.0552959144115448, 0.017358548939228058, 0.020482614636421204, 0.06945132464170456, 0.012384673580527306, -0.018818020820617676, 0.01952236145734787, 0.00021312141325324774, -0.02336634323000908, 0.03943618759512901, -0.006129693705588579, 0.0534173920750618, -0.02812638320028782, -0.05010703206062317, 0.03503181040287018, 0.03619973361492157, 0.023456424474716187, -0.007829846814274788, -0.013012997806072235, -0.06611460447311401, -0.009533537551760674, 0.03484015539288521, -0.024162910878658295, 0.03396954387426376, 0.01077836100012064, 0.03695477545261383, 0.015473966486752033, 0.049684979021549225, -0.0217509176582098, -0.07127945870161057, 0.00012050136137986556, -0.028983281925320625, -0.0010349659714847803, 0.07771526277065277, 0.008637843653559685, -0.007946313358843327, 0.021245235577225685, -0.03787563368678093, 0.013468360528349876, -0.007649062667042017, 0.02055780030786991, -0.014674600213766098, 0.09260536730289459, -0.02239144966006279, -0.00871574878692627, -0.04902999848127365, 0.001029068836942315, 0.15428131818771362, 0.06776324659585953, 0.04330306127667427, -0.06262128055095673, 0.006377038080245256, 0.015467154793441296, -0.011708538047969341, -0.017351847141981125, 0.005016926676034927, 0.003682993585243821, -0.013826047070324421, 0.024967091158032417, 0.04932785406708717, -0.003521283157169819, -0.0016144785331562161, 0.008173682726919651, -0.09032289683818817, -0.009287737309932709, 0.013096677139401436, -0.020987922325730324, 0.013216238468885422, -0.022865522652864456, -0.045375462621450424, 0.019793836399912834, 0.0036430025938898325, -0.024956105276942253, -0.021522898226976395, 0.010871133767068386, -0.013691626489162445, -0.01620275340974331, 0.009236427024006844, -0.0020276226568967104, 0.01426905021071434, -0.021160151809453964, 0.012772314250469208, 0.019853809848427773, -0.00996036920696497, -0.032683856785297394, 0.06860494613647461, 0.049367766827344894, 0.024131258949637413, -0.007238324731588364, 0.0348837710916996, 0.0051500010304152966, -0.006507443264126778, -0.020186137408018112, -0.02344597689807415, 0.09929729253053665, -0.030118418857455254, -0.019749127328395844, 0.023470519110560417, -0.014388585463166237, 0.028935275971889496, -0.013903554528951645, 0.007705820724368095, -0.01767544075846672, 0.05163766071200371, -0.018053922802209854, 0.002318050479516387, -0.03766809403896332, -0.02424829825758934, -0.0012168885441496968, 0.01245024148374796, 0.03512502834200859, -0.025491317734122276, -0.02063157968223095, -0.050660982728004456, 0.0566767081618309, -0.0032659429125487804, 0.01272865291684866, 0.013944286853075027, -0.03698116913437843, -0.05000003054738045, -0.01342345867305994, -0.00648002652451396, 0.010492704808712006, 0.03259044140577316, -0.016542386263608932, -0.015146571211516857, -0.00762253999710083, -0.05188249796628952, 0.010074677877128124, -0.00969269871711731, -0.024559497833251953, -0.033835865557193756, -0.04244732856750488, 0.04625357687473297, -0.0037586132530122995, -0.05187055841088295, 0.01317626889795065, -0.00203477474860847, 0.08326329290866852, 0.002639462472870946, -0.027760203927755356, -0.025011442601680756, -0.0018018430564552546, 0.00849025510251522, 0.0020662201568484306, -0.02908828854560852, -0.005240451078861952, -0.015325416810810566, 0.004289534408599138, -0.017498956993222237, 0.01864873431622982, -0.0039320518262684345, 0.020033543929457664, 0.012890947982668877, -0.036608122289180756, 0.0030705956742167473, -0.0035019780043512583, 0.01060459017753601, -0.020505646243691444, 0.0017291943076997995, -0.025840068235993385, -0.02978331595659256, -0.010008861310780048, -0.025946246460080147, -0.03606320545077324, 0.01662445068359375, -0.0535917691886425, 0.009072328917682171, -0.019876398146152496, 0.005045090802013874, 0.019007865339517593, 0.0358109287917614, -0.036086857318878174, 0.017504345625638962, -0.04620310291647911, 0.033722005784511566, -0.013430011458694935, 0.0017922610277310014, -0.0038810635451227427, 0.000985967111773789, 0.002566535724326968, 0.007241717539727688, 0.004950038157403469, 0.016818948090076447, 0.025729266926646233, -0.025428062304854393, -0.022876743227243423, 0.04962821677327156, -0.044758331030607224, -0.030500246211886406, 0.01894061639904976, -0.0038312887772917747, 0.024358531460165977, 0.014180636964738369, 0.0005368333659134805, 0.02229253388941288, 0.0333077572286129, -0.02010509930551052, 0.00498657301068306, 0.007707911543548107, -0.0021773912012577057, 0.007403401657938957, 0.003938733134418726, -0.021711885929107666, 0.02949097566306591, 0.017251214012503624, 0.000022141330191516317, 0.007383852265775204, -0.02729509025812149, -0.009026293642818928, -0.018404221162199974, -0.021006671711802483, -0.0016547060804441571, 0.010516902431845665, -0.01665882021188736, 0.0422348752617836, 0.020405875518918037, 0.0001523325772723183, 0.0008176287519745529, -0.05931917577981949, -0.02626778371632099, -0.0899195447564125, -0.00968475453555584, 0.008891016244888306, 0.010093459859490395, 0.03481407091021538, -0.03353779390454292, 0.006119438447058201, -0.003670566016808152, -0.0012648914707824588, -0.031804513186216354, -0.001226171851158142, 0.014555107802152634, -0.042488012462854385, -0.019712083041667938, -0.03384922444820404, 0.035306427627801895, 0.04018669202923775, 0.043410588055849075, 0.02830778993666172, 0.012121882289648056, -0.017152130603790283, -0.025468790903687477, -0.008739069104194641, -0.014040072448551655, 0.03445630520582199, -0.06914985179901123, 0.047660067677497864, -0.020251763984560966, 0.022524219006299973, 0.016506411135196686, 0.013233608566224575, 0.0048645902425050735, -0.003664919640868902, 0.03621223568916321, -0.03396790102124214, 0.0730443075299263, 0.03862496837973595, 0.01530385110527277, 0.037349242717027664, -0.021786604076623917, 0.0029809155967086554, 0.027651207521557808, -0.03771224245429039, -0.020912375301122665, 0.014528563246130943, -0.010819613933563232, -0.06085718050599098, 0.023877855390310287, -0.01676466129720211, 0.011913429014384747, 0.0012845676392316818, -0.019295787438750267, -0.021928222849965096, -0.03140673041343689, 0.029876871034502983, -0.04211513325572014, 0.007627551909536123, 0.03750316798686981, 0.03412403538823128, -0.005187885835766792, 0.023324253037571907, -0.026876989752054214, -0.02054719254374504, 0.008281432092189789, -0.009812572039663792, -0.014104961417615414, -0.04450438544154167, 0.00021402386482805014, -0.014652470126748085, -0.017121663317084312, -0.06099560111761093, 0.025234565138816833, -0.026889823377132416, 0.04365625977516174, -0.003883479628711939, 0.0007972034509293735, 0.023863982409238815, 0.004502045921981335, 0.05029192939400673, -0.0687214583158493, 0.054943427443504333, 0.01072230376303196, -0.016261767596006393, -0.008152879774570465, 0.02329396829009056, -0.005553163588047028, 0.012460306286811829, 0.03735823184251785, -0.022433623671531677, -0.016323458403348923, 0.06685248762369156, 0.036617130041122437, 0.023595457896590233, -0.026762207970023155, 0.03599920496344566, -0.043012585490942, -0.006542589515447617, -0.022359108552336693, -0.027382172644138336, 0.012598886154592037, 0.007258624769747257, -0.00633264658972621, -0.012859786860644817, -0.01959736831486225, 0.005173792131245136, -0.05241497606039047, -0.011875125579535961, 0.010951030999422073, -0.01052867155522108, 0.03240227326750755, -0.0006987398373894393, 0.026716308668255806, 0.035333190113306046, -0.02609977312386036, -0.030713288113474846, 0.06480583548545837, -0.013938143849372864, -0.03767944499850273, 0.00873996876180172, -0.015435312874615192, -0.015082739293575287, -0.07877684384584427, 0.011812249198555946, 0.044786445796489716, 0.009775673039257526, 0.014936528168618679, 0.04392154887318611, 0.02755741961300373, 0.04351469874382019, 0.02933730185031891, -0.012681516818702221, 0.0030403395649045706, 0.019296208396553993, 0.019435852766036987, 0.019775696098804474, 0.004802098032087088, -0.03554324805736542, -0.015940960496664047, 0.02432401478290558, 0.007752374280244112, 0.027072811499238014, -0.0009882592130452394, 0.06080807372927666, -0.006962777581065893, -0.03953417018055916, 0.049742016941308975, -0.009692435152828693, 0.003099143272265792, -0.005211218725889921, -0.03787865489721298, 0.030265776440501213, -0.017090754583477974, 0.027385402470827103, 0.032840367406606674, 0.013431807979941368, -0.02598157525062561, -0.0015009106136858463, 0.012680224142968655, 0.019621212035417557, -0.020007409155368805, 0.010429794900119305, -0.012090158648788929, -0.02553846873342991, -0.012585013173520565, -0.022579964250326157, 0.010766646824777126, 0.032451774924993515, 0.004703514743596315, -0.011043335311114788, -0.03198300674557686, -0.008935505524277687, -0.019481297582387924, 0.008896010927855968, 0.028538398444652557, -0.016479386016726494, -0.03155191242694855, -0.0034492763224989176, 0.02812175638973713, 0.05276273190975189, -0.06392794102430344, -0.010982116684317589, 0.0059823403134942055, -0.022209446877241135, -0.010620120912790298, -0.004893068689852953 ]
<p>I'm trying to plot forecast and real data on the same plot. But there is always gap between them on the image :</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/ni7FR.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I use for the forecasting following code: y=boardings[,1] ## Simple Exponential smoothing #predict existing values results=HoltWinters(y,beta=FALSE, gamma=FALSE) #print data print(cbind(y,results$fitted)) #draw the plot with fitted values plot(results) #predict future values results2=forecast.HoltWinters(results,h=12) print(results2)</p> <pre><code>#draw the plot with prediction plot.forecast(results2,lwd=1,xlab='time',ylab='log.boardings',main='12-month prediction by Exponential Smoothing') </code></pre> <p>The data is taken from the <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/timeSeries/index.html" rel="nofollow">timeSeries</a> package with name <code>boardings</code>.</p> <p>I would really appreciate any help.</p>
73,394
[ -0.022471493110060692, -0.016553128138184547, -0.004045369569212198, 0.03301427885890007, -0.006955491378903389, -0.0004245525342412293, -0.04827887564897537, 0.002563278656452894, 0.025396551936864853, -0.011419528163969517, 0.05947725847363472, 0.04061770811676979, 0.041022710502147675, 0.05283452570438385, 0.03308117017149925, 0.004366944544017315, 0.008179807104170322, -0.014704259112477303, 0.00433618389070034, 0.006323057692497969, -0.01632736437022686, 0.008326031267642975, 0.020585743710398674, 0.0021202177740633488, 0.010859345085918903, 0.04366762936115265, 0.047997087240219116, 0.011483798734843731, 0.015260999090969563, 0.067432701587677, -0.05669431760907173, -0.06397119164466858, -0.0012314266059547663, 0.03249146416783333, 0.03924316540360451, 0.041588567197322845, -0.013971799984574318, -0.04768285155296326, 0.010407721623778343, 0.007223126478493214, -0.01708441786468029, 0.019328279420733452, 0.03707138076424599, 0.054184440523386, -0.003159750485792756, 0.010834543965756893, 0.009910915978252888, 0.038178157061338425, 0.05518506094813347, -0.0010367779759690166, 0.06242219731211662, -0.05222417041659355, 0.024298956617712975, 0.018876289948821068, -0.054149333387613297, 0.00723465858027339, 0.06575092673301697, 0.05015530809760094, 0.004870811011642218, -0.04485169053077698, -0.011899377219378948, -0.05342886969447136, -0.027640702202916145, -0.010887112468481064, -0.035789985209703445, 0.018732717260718346, -0.03943818435072899, -0.03702103719115257, 0.0072455452755093575, -0.04962257295846939, 0.009445236064493656, 0.02141338773071766, 0.03318050131201744, -0.06290768831968307, 0.035697635263204575, -0.05222039297223091, 0.028659231960773468, 0.024447478353977203, 0.061591263860464096, 0.010122671723365784, 0.019039373844861984, 0.027742264792323112, 0.03796829283237457, 0.014314317144453526, 0.03298916667699814, -0.003265023697167635, 0.04870033636689186, -0.022594090551137924, 0.016016792505979538, 0.042988456785678864, -0.0015829144977033138, 0.03483569994568825, 0.07367020845413208, 0.010992353782057762, 0.006752061191946268, 0.038080018013715744, 0.006728426553308964, 0.04428749531507492, 0.013927179388701916, -0.051012072712183, -0.002965716179460287, -0.03473109379410744, 0.021855376660823822, 0.022514376789331436, -0.0010951540898531675, -0.02950434945523739, -0.020140167325735092, -0.045561112463474274, -0.013907114043831825, -0.010268030688166618, -0.03140288591384888, 0.023395279422402382, -0.016039418056607246, -0.008962906897068024, -0.0044760690070688725, -0.03163241967558861, 0.0073040747083723545, 0.04632473364472389, 0.04135975241661072, 0.06811599433422089, 0.047051507979631424, 0.006411151494830847, 0.019357752054929733, 0.006141046993434429, -0.07338615506887436, 0.036567434668540955, 0.026405246928334236, -0.016902444884181023, -0.012482956983149052, 0.01745523139834404, -0.066301628947258, -0.03232391178607941, 0.052255868911743164, 0.027433287352323532, 0.0362941175699234, -0.0016696690581738949, -0.07682537287473679, -0.03843473643064499, 0.0237873625010252, -0.0036727318074554205, 0.016090184450149536, -0.0352102592587471, 0.005928540602326393, -0.013703706674277782, 0.03403226286172867, -0.0046175699681043625, 0.01671331562101841, 0.006900315638631582, 0.01094889733940363, 0.003181152744218707, -0.013804486021399498, 0.009725229814648628, 0.008841656148433685, -0.01796034350991249, -0.03147926926612854, -0.04665643721818924, -0.018580887466669083, 0.0400390550494194, -0.0032385678496211767, -0.024771222844719887, 0.055783044546842575, 0.007516967598348856, -0.0014174728421494365, -0.04717440903186798, -0.009018704295158386, -0.039915360510349274, 0.08042914420366287, 0.03825521096587181, -0.0037276274524629116, 0.02251068875193596, -0.0364343486726284, 0.0034939402248710394, -0.02059645764529705, -0.0004101698868907988, 0.041073497384786606, 0.012719935737550259, 0.007496758364140987, -0.013127468526363373, 0.011034214869141579, 0.018230821937322617, -0.014561576768755913, -0.07080478221178055, -0.030175015330314636, -0.021828750148415565, 0.01816338300704956, 0.03082982823252678, 0.02143244817852974, -0.024106986820697784, 0.043864015489816666, -0.07752954959869385, -0.05234130471944809, -0.06477954238653183, 0.0032810047268867493, -0.032740212976932526, -0.025191636756062508, -0.015582535415887833, -0.003250143490731716, 0.020068366080522537, -0.004621740430593491, 0.002726081060245633, -0.005092510487884283, -0.011346598155796528, 0.056479427963495255, 0.0026198106352239847, -0.006287963129580021, 0.03530518338084221, 0.05463840812444687, -0.0026785838417708874, 0.020361678674817085, -0.013051445595920086, -0.02769743837416172, 0.032298460602760315, -0.04124082997441292, 0.003487741807475686, -0.011791255325078964, -0.0017465638229623437, 0.02298741787672043, 0.03575487434864044, -0.00795472040772438, 0.019942590966820717, -0.026030799373984337, 0.044809769839048386, 0.057780832052230835, 0.001243567792698741, -0.004550628364086151, -0.02409227006137371, 0.042894039303064346, 0.06630611419677734, -0.03706042096018791, -0.03322258219122887, -0.029079262167215347, -0.0329049713909626, 0.0359828807413578, 0.011609762907028198, -0.004351114854216576, 0.007045876234769821, 0.06478829681873322, -0.0009892763337120414, -0.0046042874455451965, 0.04889440909028053, -0.008997577242553234, 0.003208489390090108, 0.018969187512993813, -0.004207464400678873, 0.02275080978870392, -0.008895233273506165, 0.020123513415455818, -0.007148780860006809, 0.03888215124607086, -0.019900035113096237, -0.013172238133847713, 0.042885493487119675, -0.013114798814058304, 0.0013715745881199837, -0.049130409955978394, -0.033472493290901184, 0.07237046211957932, -0.022240927442908287, -0.03011416643857956, 0.022953083738684654, 0.03561810776591301, -0.012323134578764439, 0.004031563177704811, -0.016464540734887123, -0.013052421621978283, 0.055533114820718765, -0.005892745219171047, -0.008908750489354134, 0.01077563688158989, -0.058346763253211975, 0.025028720498085022, -0.033391281962394714, -0.04575033113360405, -0.046860985457897186, 0.03941783308982849, 0.03840125724673271, 0.03631847724318504, 0.051786430180072784, -0.010596717707812786, -0.052405547350645065, 0.024349389597773552, -0.04002577066421509, 0.013743876479566097, -0.027099311351776123, -0.04787883907556534, 0.03511146456003189, -0.03302944451570511, -0.01363428495824337, 0.015653999522328377, 0.007498255930840969, -0.013213900849223137, 0.002095002681016922, -0.04693680629134178, -0.01744316704571247, -0.048625506460666656, -0.05328499525785446, 0.011368597857654095, 0.009988578036427498, -0.03250323608517647, 0.06519728899002075, -0.0067740571685135365, -0.053528234362602234, 0.019190603867173195, -0.047245148569345474, 0.003470191964879632, -0.028808142989873886, -0.0035095452331006527, 0.019720137119293213, -0.01006176508963108, 0.022216200828552246, 0.006799038033932447, -0.0030739756766706705, -0.005728103686124086, -0.045259375125169754, -0.06122899055480957, 0.008515090681612492, -0.010214176960289478, -0.009490802884101868, -0.022001270204782486, 0.010729997418820858, 0.03753773495554924, -0.0011706606019288301, 0.00963194016367197, -0.06779514253139496, -0.004324485082179308, -0.03563467785716057, -0.039872411638498306, 0.005547535140067339, 0.01938672363758087, 0.04978841543197632, -0.013650566339492798, 0.00226815277710557, 0.037262506783008575, 0.022929774597287178, -0.029365915805101395, 0.00792967714369297, -0.03522413223981857, 0.012137980200350285, 0.00818216148763895, 0.01629684492945671, 0.017089122906327248, -0.017588507384061813, 0.005662229377776384, 0.00097090401686728, 0.027888387441635132, -0.01184489019215107, -0.051058534532785416, -0.03666023910045624, -0.014094655402004719, 0.053330063819885254, -0.049170851707458496, 0.01575375907123089, 0.001956355758011341, -0.06482889503240585, -0.03674447163939476, -0.00594743387773633, 0.07583359628915787, -0.0246697049587965, -0.005624454468488693, 0.05476827919483185, 0.0055755688808858395, -0.028093356639146805, 0.00022150982113089412, -0.01635395921766758, 0.011638405732810497, 0.017676590010523796, -0.06642182171344757, -0.039597611874341965, 0.033070195466279984, 0.02437777630984783, 0.011347309686243534, 0.009822885505855083, -0.03722231462597847, 0.025804631412029266, -0.055991288274526596, -0.020745601505041122, -0.00595183577388525, 0.08410657942295074, 0.003430592827498913, 0.026203593239188194, 0.01951652579009533, 0.004665801767259836, 0.0496472604572773, 0.020802518352866173, -0.05918757990002632, 0.027674537152051926, 0.05334562435746193, -0.012151837348937988, -0.002323990920558572, -0.018010510131716728, 0.022405877709388733, -0.02004110813140869, 0.038757212460041046, 0.0278848297894001, 0.008563421666622162, -0.041098568588495255, -0.0030789244920015335, -0.003416522638872266, 0.038274411112070084, -0.05596373230218887, -0.021307706832885742, 0.04565020278096199, 0.007547938264906406, 0.05307898297905922, 0.04547210782766342, -0.0006793811917304993, -0.0251231100410223, -0.008373982273042202, 0.01849832944571972, 0.02372116409242153, 0.04781061038374901, 0.03473234176635742, 0.00008804818207863718, -0.019889820367097855, -0.006065927911549807, -0.017662646248936653, 0.020274022594094276, 0.03974299132823944, 0.03436807170510292, 0.022294480353593826, 0.014362933114171028, 0.0010631205514073372, 0.004744354635477066, 0.014387037605047226, -0.0188014917075634, -0.03610244765877724, 0.0106965908780694, 0.05254258215427399, 0.008809893392026424, 0.017902618274092674, 0.07304009795188904, -0.0002160011645173654, 0.021400567144155502, -0.011284051463007927, -0.008441494777798653, -0.03789316862821579, -0.0061662024818360806, 0.025193870067596436, 0.013683447614312172, -0.010349277406930923, 0.0049616447649896145, 0.04575721174478531, -0.03173866122961044, -0.02492779865860939, 0.01157044805586338, 0.025007709860801697, 0.044239599257707596, 0.0037784723099321127, -0.04220569506287575, 0.005513377953320742, 0.032689183950424194, 0.03948542848229408, -0.022312764078378677, -0.0038473475724458694, -0.10490825027227402, -0.032344188541173935, 0.04123854637145996, 0.03035162016749382, -0.0182320699095726, -0.07828784734010696, -0.05971391871571541, 0.009299060329794884, 0.028085092082619667, -0.036104392260313034, -0.009751477278769016, -0.01385551318526268, -0.00006235911132534966, -0.022386109456419945, -0.023877281695604324, -0.042963895946741104, 0.01072094775736332, -0.014908681623637676, 0.034891728311777115, -0.0032586592715233564, -0.030207550153136253, -0.005009954795241356, 0.029842285439372063, 0.01750163361430168, 0.04445653781294823, -0.020398670807480812, -0.03180641680955887, 0.01670294813811779, -0.028247816488146782, -0.026826590299606323, -0.04995124414563179, 0.03717867285013199, -0.01639988087117672, -0.02822943404316902, 0.05021742731332779, -0.003131549572572112, 0.018422573804855347, -0.014839882962405682, 0.015412313863635063, -0.012460621073842049, -0.006164915394037962, -0.04395708441734314, 0.019616592675447464, 0.043318673968315125, 0.026751866564154625, 0.03921767324209213, 0.048911865800619125, 0.01765230856835842, -0.008165252394974232, -0.07166916131973267, 0.002732402179390192, -0.0019687090534716845, -0.015352687798440456, -0.06472360342741013, -0.04944821074604988, -0.03738017752766609, -0.012273351661860943, -0.013748805038630962, 0.016739899292588234, -0.05994800105690956, 0.0066137658432126045, 0.009138468652963638, 0.03732199966907501, -0.025986192747950554, -0.021067559719085693, 0.008601712994277477, -0.006591586396098137, -0.025075793266296387, 0.018726877868175507, 0.008215606212615967, -0.035700444132089615, -0.01287040300667286, 0.007389969192445278, -0.030157038941979408, 0.024576175957918167, 0.010716419667005539, -0.006378454621881247, 0.019344529137015343, -0.021915310993790627, -0.01902901940047741, 0.01302389521151781, 0.04098954424262047, 0.00008212788816308603, -0.027903689071536064, -0.020225150510668755, 0.01475891750305891, -0.011824938468635082, -0.005505864508450031, -0.07071452587842941, 0.04645729809999466, 0.019454635679721832, -0.02287498116493225, -0.04085058346390724, -0.05806867405772209, 0.057483650743961334, -0.017951076850295067, -0.04584621638059616, -0.04579697176814079, -0.02409905008971691, -0.01772221550345421, 0.027643434703350067, -0.013062510639429092, -0.029060259461402893, -0.04208603873848915, -0.01479864027351141, -0.01910351775586605, -0.0005068897153250873, 0.08557497709989548, 0.009439550340175629, 0.008652362041175365, 0.0142021793872118, 0.005827725864946842, -0.02650337666273117, -0.01948627270758152, 0.003319280920550227, -0.008113348856568336, 0.0015514232218265533, -0.032855577766895294, 0.03715437278151512, 0.04910159483551979, -0.010569046251475811, 0.020101388916373253, 0.004264876712113619, 0.03248795494437218, 0.06318057328462601, -0.08214616775512695, -0.012716683559119701, -0.011246566660702229, -0.0032632139045745134, -0.06094367057085037, -0.007982241921126842, 0.01758919656276703, -0.05098759010434151, -0.016740979626774788, -0.014657187275588512, -0.039715949445962906, 0.013924297876656055, 0.03963979706168175, 0.003978990484029055, -0.009295327588915825, -0.006480345502495766, -0.0038549716118723154, 0.026097098365426064, 0.03132816404104233, 0.009359109215438366, 0.003993150778114796, 0.013442620635032654, -0.03424306586384773, -0.03942832350730896, 0.006439639255404472, 0.0063081723637878895, 0.06865797191858292, -0.03179735690355301, 0.05313001200556755, 0.022980598732829094, 0.019390663132071495, 0.014759568497538567, -0.016220472753047943, -0.0361003614962101, -0.006417765747755766, 0.016673840582370758, 0.05482051894068718, -0.005152516532689333, -0.008842209354043007, 0.023068172857165337, 0.021180499345064163, 0.06388074159622192, 0.02151133492588997, 0.0016932974103838205, -0.021764880046248436, -0.009443105198442936, 0.0014663418987765908, 0.007984427735209465, -0.00020505247812252492, 0.010108270682394505, 0.029204020276665688, -0.0037902770563960075, 0.012500843033194542, 0.041951488703489304, 0.08593492954969406, -0.011099490337073803, -0.0006338107050396502, -0.016269782558083534, -0.049376048147678375, -0.026196205988526344, 0.027353409677743912, -0.011739150620996952, 0.02305585704743862, 0.0005730827106162906, 0.03783853352069855, 0.00023964889987837523, 0.04249946400523186, -0.03936536982655525, -0.041945938020944595, -0.025967445224523544, -0.07349492609500885, 0.029821103438735008, 0.061167050153017044, -0.0149640291929245, -0.020479263737797737, 0.011388445273041725, -0.02536155842244625, 0.04693705961108208, 0.005212333519011736, 0.02853134647011757, 0.015109333209693432, 0.03785507008433342, -0.007597101852297783, 0.02091103605926037, -0.02232564054429531, -0.007388461846858263, 0.1359071284532547, 0.04299762099981308, 0.056319594383239746, -0.045381203293800354, 0.009572116658091545, 0.005748888477683067, -0.009426621720194817, -0.020246095955371857, -0.0002545476017985493, 0.03358528017997742, -0.023448128253221512, 0.05971561744809151, 0.04409804567694664, 0.0336131826043129, 0.012285629287362099, 0.029502838850021362, -0.04692260921001434, -0.0022131293080747128, -0.024347838014364243, 0.01496939081698656, 0.02504006214439869, -0.0035743890330195427, -0.09988702088594437, 0.005259240046143532, -0.0030043632723391056, -0.005321305710822344, -0.02284945175051689, -0.04556706175208092, -0.0005107213510200381, 0.029134176671504974, -0.01412147656083107, 0.01585349254310131, 0.021376753225922585, 0.022807693108916283, 0.027786634862422943, -0.032098859548568726, 0.01827673614025116, -0.03027420863509178, 0.019894715398550034, 0.008690032176673412, 0.03346986323595047, 0.005998595617711544, -0.017504049465060234, 0.014169234782457352, -0.04213012382388115, -0.020453358069062233, -0.00737296836450696, 0.04213857278227806, 0.02074088715016842, -0.048673760145902634, 0.018972933292388916, 0.02239696867763996, -0.013806281611323357, -0.023989057168364525, -0.019947558641433716, 0.008260402828454971, -0.0057759671472013, -0.025690989568829536, -0.002972194692119956, -0.019337601959705353, 0.011146929115056992, -0.00568199809640646, 0.01979723945260048, 0.05214047431945801, -0.0036732996813952923, 0.0003551777917891741, -0.06023924797773361, 0.06253760308027267, -0.0022785908076912165, 0.010540146380662918, 0.014634431339800358, -0.01020060759037733, -0.021771717816591263, -0.03553493320941925, 0.009597777388989925, 0.028753548860549927, 0.023714395239949226, 0.012622926384210587, -0.03588428720831871, 0.01285572163760662, -0.028294330462813377, -0.0060041798278689384, -0.014246135018765926, -0.032677531242370605, -0.027634454891085625, -0.0030630426481366158, 0.03909042477607727, 0.023488465696573257, 0.02844587340950966, 0.009223728440701962, -0.002362887840718031, 0.048837315291166306, 0.02158479206264019, -0.05271679535508156, -0.034742724150419235, -0.025778811424970627, -0.04054933786392212, -0.033033668994903564, -0.01377966906875372, 0.08643640577793121, 0.043868109583854675, 0.00959066767245531, 0.007728114724159241, 0.00969065260142088, -0.01845487579703331, -0.00518219918012619, 0.026624949648976326, -0.013277867808938026, 0.03913260996341705, 0.01426586601883173, -0.00355480145663023, -0.03978809714317322, 0.011495404876768589, -0.0186260137706995, -0.038772255182266235, -0.01336970366537571, -0.00888295192271471, -0.02037787437438965, 0.04090964049100876, 0.0049368287436664104, -0.006280926056206226, -0.04824240505695343, 0.0004502551455516368, -0.058255672454833984, -0.010275812819600105, -0.02503424510359764, -0.04902779310941696, -0.058899182826280594, 0.013935599476099014, -0.060330335050821304, -0.018370339646935463, 0.0355151891708374, 0.012161865830421448, 0.020649338141083717, -0.00713277468457818, 0.02846769616007805, -0.003242270555347204, 0.024029254913330078, -0.01572638563811779, -0.03336653113365173, 0.025509139522910118, -0.012967577204108238, -0.07477640360593796, -0.01578579656779766, -0.003979152999818325, 0.010440032929182053, 0.012101289816200733, -0.009191461838781834, -0.022058112546801567, 0.0870743989944458, -0.0024349000304937363, 0.009983045049011707, -0.02263021096587181, 0.00018688305863179266, 0.019984504207968712, 0.006734567694365978, 0.015976885333657265, -0.02333242818713188, -0.001664519775658846, 0.028077272698283195, 0.040233731269836426, 0.028438778594136238, -0.013255307450890541, -0.023573877289891243, -0.019617728888988495, 0.02076650969684124, 0.0006026268820278347, -0.022556019946932793, 0.03810415789484978, 0.03886709734797478, -0.01340488065034151, 0.0093370471149683, -0.0019166127312928438, 0.020454317331314087, -0.060111239552497864, -0.009721999056637287, -0.01525874249637127, 0.0030439558904618025, 0.005871607456356287, -0.05329761281609535, -0.023164259269833565, 0.028525464236736298, -0.02947864681482315, -0.008312474004924297, 0.011246499605476856, -0.0053831408731639385, -0.04456585645675659, 0.018676823005080223, -0.01845451071858406, -0.011228762567043304, 0.06797966361045837, 0.0358894020318985, 0.0042773084715008736, 0.011961073614656925, 0.042177703231573105, -0.00526625569909811, -0.031924061477184296, 0.029221683740615845, 0.0034795310348272324, -0.04121118783950806, 0.03043140284717083, -0.0040073394775390625, -0.009767206385731697, 0.005005815997719765, -0.03209139406681061, -0.01107602659612894, 0.008623459376394749, -0.02360294759273529, 0.03290696442127228, 0.05319792777299881, 0.0018154960125684738, 0.011273162439465523, 0.00421723211184144, -0.010488439351320267, 0.04359855502843857, -0.010187736712396145, 0.002589329844340682, 0.030355185270309448, 0.02707582712173462, -0.015219523571431637, -0.023819316178560257, 0.03088982217013836, 0.0051640477031469345, -0.005719594191759825, -0.03132021054625511, 0.04916777461767197, 0.024339871481060982, -0.03935592994093895, -0.01825767010450363, -0.021873336285352707, 0.0010871816193684936, 0.0394846573472023, -0.0023162984289228916, -0.008233180269598961, 0.011546535417437553, -0.015907229855656624, -0.04956705868244171, 0.003377427812665701, -0.007631504442542791, -0.005594068672508001, -0.017323629930615425, -0.014524102210998535, -0.00013471953570842743, -0.026677792891860008, -0.010156587697565556, 0.026095125824213028, -0.004090195056051016, 0.03157838433980942, 0.005342172458767891, -0.014859114773571491, 0.03165089339017868, -0.012197126634418964, 0.013844691216945648, -0.06904187798500061, 0.04274476692080498, -0.0028853558469563723, -0.0005820541409775615, -0.03737060725688934, 0.008757980540394783, -0.06771444529294968, 0.06281518191099167, 0.035989824682474136, 0.020096736028790474, 0.021576927974820137, -0.010838852263987064, -0.00015295155753847212, 0.01509411446750164, -0.03029392473399639, 0.03446583449840546, -0.01938302256166935, -0.03314555436372757, 0.046776097267866135, 0.00618676096200943, -0.0013120875228196383, 0.053641289472579956, 0.005782534368336201, -0.05165819078683853, 0.05117738991975784, 0.05207742005586624, -0.04278434440493584, 0.010609278455376625, 0.00530906580388546, -0.01897258125245571, 0.03314422816038132, 0.022136379033327103, -0.029658855870366096, 0.025323932990431786, -0.005326427053660154, -0.061768099665641785, 0.024512706324458122, -0.024336598813533783, -0.02218721993267536, 0.02236773818731308, -0.02316856011748314, -0.009333542548120022, -0.04617069661617279, 0.01204849686473608, 0.03546798601746559, 0.015297360718250275, 0.026097971946001053, 0.04584183171391487, 0.04649718850851059, -0.0016140606021508574, -0.06387365609407425, -0.003540054662153125, 0.01601899415254593, -0.029137343168258667, 0.029996557161211967, -0.011540835723280907, 0.02151312120258808, 0.017974454909563065, 0.03151719272136688, 0.010454966686666012, -0.020966334268450737, 0.022934474050998688, -0.03154857084155083, 0.08048316836357117, -0.005046653561294079, 0.015871694311499596, -0.017778003588318825, -0.007282161619514227, 0.003928790334612131, -0.002453697146847844, 0.0041645243763923645, 0.012380456551909447, -0.037988945841789246, 0.02844627946615219, -0.0001007042737910524, -0.02002216875553131, -0.010551763698458672, 0.016937891021370888, 0.021081989631056786, 0.008510999381542206, -0.002938629128038883, -0.0009739674278534949, 0.02148069255053997, -0.017167208716273308, -0.0010440319310873747, -0.0033181507606059313, 0.0060524847358465195, -0.006606776732951403, -0.00735837547108531, -0.019988104701042175, 0.025877272710204124, -0.012597206048667431, -0.05130656063556671, 0.0389094315469265, 0.026864632964134216, -0.012709131464362144, -0.07355547696352005, -0.04020190238952637, -0.018404891714453697, 0.03765169531106949, -0.08144360780715942, -0.024074062705039978, -0.010250811465084553, 0.008905824273824692, 0.02692570723593235, -0.037706635892391205 ]
<p>Assume the model $ \ y = X\beta + u \ $ with $\ W \ $ is a $ \ n\times l \ $ so called matrix of instruments. </p> <p>The following assumptions hold. There is a law of large numbers (LLN) for 1.,2.,3. and 4. such that</p> <ol> <li><p>$\text{plim}_{n\to\infty} \ \left(\frac{X^TX}{n}\right) = m_{X^TX}$</p> <p>holds where $m_{X^TX}$, a finite, non stochastic matrix with full column rank, exsists.</p></li> <li><p>$\text{plim}_{n\to\infty} \ \left(\frac{W^TW}{n}\right) = \text{lim}_{n\to\infty} \left(\frac{{\mathbb E}\left(W^TW\right)}{n}\right)$</p> <p>where we assume, that the RHS exists and is finite as well as positive definite.</p></li> <li><p>$\text{plim}_{n\to\infty} \ \left(\frac{W^TX}{n}\right)$</p> <p>where we assume, that the limit $W^TX$ exists, is finite and $W^TX$ has full column rank i.e. $\text{rk}\left(W^TX\right)=k$.</p></li> <li><p>$\text{plim}_{n\to\infty} \ \left(\frac{W^Tu}{n}\right) = \text{lim}_{n\to\infty} \left(\frac{{\mathbb E}\left(W^Tu\right)}{n}\right) = 0$</p> <p>where we assume that $\text{lim}_{n\to\infty} \left(\frac{{\mathbb E}\left(W^Tu\right)}{n}\right)$ is equal to $0$.</p></li> </ol> <p>The asymptotic variance for OLS will, under the assumption of homoscedastic errors $u$ i.e. that ${\mathbb E}\left(uu^T|X\right) = \sigma^2_0 I_n$ and that the model is actually correctly specified , be</p> <p>$\text{plim}_{n\to\infty} \text{Var}\left[ n^{\frac{1}{2}}\left(\boldsymbol{\widehat{\beta}}_{\text{KQ}} - \boldsymbol{\beta_0}\right)\big| X\right] = \sigma_0^2 \ m_{X^TX}^{-1}$</p> <p>The corresponding asymptotic variance for the 2SLS case will look like</p> <p>$\text{plim}_{n\to\infty} \text{Var}\left[ n^{\frac{1}{2}}\left(\boldsymbol{\widetilde{\beta}_{\text{2SLS}}} - \boldsymbol{\beta_0}\right)\big| X\right] = \sigma_0^2 \ \text{plim}_{n\to\infty} \left(\frac{X^TP_W X}{n}\right)^{-1}$</p> <p>If I now consider the precision matrix rather then the variance matrix and take their difference I'll get </p> <p>$\text{plim}_{n\to\infty} \ \left(\frac{X^TM_WX}{n}\right) = \left(\text{plim}_{n\to\infty} \ \frac{X^TX}{n}\right) - \left(\text{plim}_{n\to\infty} \ \frac{X^TP_WX}{n}\right)$</p> <p>which is a positive semidefinite matrix.</p> <p><strong>My question: When are both asymptotic variances of OLS and 2SLS equal</strong></p> <p>My guess is that we need to set $X^TX = X^T P_W X$. The only possibility for such a thing is when $P_WX=X$. So all the columns of $X$ must be in the image of $P_W$. This means that all the columns of $X$ are actually viable instruments. By that I conclude that there are (at least asymptotically) no endogenous regressor within $X$ if their asymptotic variances are equal. But this seems to good to be true. There are downfalls of using a 2SLS-approach if theres no endogeneity involved. Again, this would mean that if the variances of the 2SLS and OLS estimator are equal asymptotically it does not matter if we choose 2SLS or OLS since both estimators are consistent for $\beta$.</p> <p>Any thoughts about this proble would be very much appreciated Druss</p>
73,395
[ -0.026345588266849518, -0.022825026884675026, 0.038565777242183685, -0.021289121359586716, 0.03211168199777603, 0.009340129792690277, -0.007673206739127636, -0.002583130029961467, 0.02987084537744522, -0.045400261878967285, 0.01282922737300396, -0.007297635078430176, 0.07447320222854614, 0.06422756612300873, -0.004827391356229782, 0.02894177846610546, -0.016876088455319405, 0.007522710599005222, -0.022819150239229202, -0.023423755541443825, 0.010995161719620228, 0.04959220811724663, -0.024631429463624954, -0.023533394560217857, -0.020548125728964806, 0.02382703684270382, 0.006699028890579939, -0.0013660745462402701, -0.01928628794848919, 0.05929238349199295, 0.0012970350217074156, 0.01815170608460903, 0.0035340460017323494, 0.007552313152700663, 0.030764712020754814, 0.05835171043872833, 0.004108648281544447, -0.04957441985607147, 0.03404868394136429, -0.004870594944804907, 0.0008089084294624627, 0.0286715105175972, -0.004250142257660627, 0.009080133400857449, 0.0030368142761290073, 0.028090985491871834, 0.032488979399204254, -0.03244839608669281, 0.033691078424453735, -0.014126581139862537, 0.05119785666465759, 0.014978600665926933, 0.006171443499624729, 0.001825470244511962, -0.042376454919576645, -0.03550252318382263, 0.03756161034107208, 0.09167502820491791, 0.02230709232389927, -0.03367459774017334, 0.01879597268998623, -0.01858440414071083, 0.038874752819538116, -0.03476829454302788, -0.004415235482156277, 0.061736222356557846, 0.024379095062613487, -0.030497374013066292, 0.012913590297102928, -0.007760363630950451, 0.00990549847483635, 0.002528195269405842, 0.03488340973854065, 0.009687277488410473, -0.004179027397185564, 0.023526759818196297, -0.001453868579119444, 0.017835168167948723, 0.02615628018975258, 0.02463187463581562, 0.005377092398703098, 0.02870631404221058, 0.015757234767079353, 0.021476712077856064, 0.01692008227109909, 0.00558945257216692, 0.07152040302753448, 0.010375631041824818, 0.0410846583545208, 0.047467805445194244, -0.012979291379451752, -0.005063939373940229, 0.04303835704922676, -0.01567169278860092, -0.04105919227004051, 0.05477993190288544, -0.02375219017267227, 0.00649601873010397, 0.005226778797805309, 0.000055396463721990585, 0.004863487556576729, -0.05503115430474281, -0.03553782403469086, 0.013336703181266785, 0.007773163728415966, -0.03705253452062607, 0.007005320396274328, 0.0035386900417506695, -0.04431120678782463, -0.03516774624586105, -0.019133562222123146, 0.02093045599758625, -0.020828301087021828, 0.013185519725084305, -0.025757011026144028, 0.007705517578870058, 0.01663128286600113, -0.016270475462079048, 0.03907470032572746, 0.07584773749113083, 0.03706934675574303, -0.02074320800602436, -0.00009167501411866397, -0.014614489860832691, -0.0653194859623909, 0.022324174642562866, -0.0013764419127255678, -0.012130950577557087, -0.08051585406064987, 0.016688650473952293, 0.0210665762424469, -0.03119824081659317, 0.07161556929349899, 0.00783056952059269, 0.0586419552564621, -0.006081260275095701, -0.06637817621231079, -0.03597556799650192, 0.06879587471485138, 0.010234293527901173, 0.009351503103971481, -0.04196573793888092, 0.005016463343054056, 0.056243155151605606, 0.0757821574807167, -0.009352308697998524, 0.05127813294529915, 0.021737875416874886, 0.00190361135173589, -0.01575354114174843, -0.04684121534228325, -0.028912054374814034, -0.02891460806131363, 0.0011433673789724708, 0.011968415230512619, -0.05410533398389816, 0.025705058127641678, 0.03723336011171341, -0.03176601976156235, 0.023890946060419083, 0.028678828850388527, -0.0013318185228854418, -0.029883334413170815, -0.021796004846692085, -0.0295287873595953, -0.050149496644735336, 0.04648778215050697, -0.005917378701269627, 0.0272383913397789, 0.018923988565802574, 0.015104771591722965, 0.01948198303580284, -0.008835738524794579, 0.03932978957891464, 0.010388403199613094, -0.031634893268346786, -0.018031468614935875, -0.032820332795381546, 0.001247493433766067, 0.038805652409791946, -0.06245250254869461, -0.013599622063338757, -0.05925839766860008, 0.016384173184633255, 0.038487885147333145, -0.0203394778072834, -0.006718162912875414, 0.00361929670907557, 0.009188071824610233, -0.026361608877778053, -0.04427217319607735, -0.06630071252584457, 0.018005546182394028, 0.03655656427145004, -0.017342479899525642, 0.03643941134214401, -0.023514071479439735, -0.029541335999965668, 0.010519585572183132, -0.00564273726195097, -0.023079071193933487, 0.007117771077901125, 0.030687935650348663, -0.03628205507993698, -0.014185826294124126, 0.052452608942985535, 0.049949854612350464, 0.02141042985022068, 0.03763667866587639, -0.040685396641492844, -0.043716590851545334, -0.005895697977393866, -0.017410576343536377, 0.03888879343867302, 0.017297273501753807, -0.005105046555399895, 0.033404331654310226, -0.06528737396001816, 0.0031669747550040483, 0.009113648906350136, -0.04080108553171158, -0.009799987077713013, 0.11330051720142365, 0.015131332911550999, -0.027343161404132843, 0.0007425780058838427, 0.0037889215163886547, 0.050868578255176544, -0.050570130348205566, -0.026685385033488274, -0.046288419514894485, -0.015200887806713581, 0.002701382152736187, 0.04968168959021568, -0.014817364513874054, 0.019901223480701447, 0.038565948605537415, 0.032672055065631866, 0.008157995529472828, 0.014286752790212631, 0.008106648921966553, -0.02850652113556862, -0.01136578619480133, -0.0007231025374494493, 0.0032553221099078655, -0.02425084263086319, -0.03583727031946182, -0.03552907705307007, 0.020255176350474358, -0.005481243599206209, 0.007788786198943853, 0.003143700771033764, 0.015046232379972935, -0.0012662936933338642, -0.0009407069883309305, -0.03767407312989235, 0.039537813514471054, 0.007843200117349625, -0.019809812307357788, -0.009584719315171242, 0.013108283281326294, -0.001513495808467269, 0.014123129658401012, -0.01669470965862274, 0.004101804457604885, 0.019218290224671364, -0.027863623574376106, -0.03993811830878258, 0.02262585610151291, -0.049497202038764954, 0.004814048297703266, -0.027160238474607468, -0.04669298976659775, -0.016565049067139626, 0.028721708804368973, 0.04639095067977905, 0.02145477943122387, 0.015034562908113003, 0.0032935640774667263, -0.007987144403159618, 0.016870295628905296, -0.019386257976293564, 0.01695357635617256, -0.034080870449543, -0.06487203389406204, 0.027401605620980263, -0.00954943336546421, 0.002594489837065339, 0.014109335839748383, 0.010236862115561962, 0.004086254630237818, 0.055911142379045486, 0.006799384020268917, -0.046808212995529175, -0.050441041588783264, -0.030632026493549347, -0.02594643644988537, -0.012229020707309246, -0.009420867078006268, 0.0630323737859726, 0.04182378575205803, -0.04446545988321304, -0.013700789771974087, -0.04872145131230354, -0.017822392284870148, -0.019555486738681793, -0.005468796472996473, -0.013854709453880787, 0.016211116686463356, 0.06653697043657303, -0.022605344653129578, -0.010974959470331669, -0.014272012747824192, -0.08804203569889069, 0.0037940156180411577, 0.019886456429958344, 0.00934944674372673, 0.061484143137931824, 0.03775038197636604, -0.02173696830868721, 0.055299948900938034, 0.04145640507340431, 0.01051662303507328, -0.025542080402374268, 0.023153528571128845, -0.028444819152355194, -0.04892633855342865, 0.01315916795283556, -0.034806497395038605, -0.009091364219784737, 0.018621930852532387, 0.031087461858987808, 0.007117095403373241, 0.029253404587507248, 0.011705871671438217, 0.05752149596810341, 0.009614847600460052, -0.02500210702419281, -0.009480204433202744, 0.0060919965617358685, 0.03868179768323898, 0.014011617749929428, -0.010607250966131687, -0.013136920519173145, 0.01687745191156864, 0.04894537478685379, -0.07309246063232422, 0.016250379383563995, -0.018703393638134003, -0.008342940360307693, -0.03639591112732887, 0.04662713408470154, 0.011703046038746834, -0.01855170540511608, -0.04985617846250534, 0.005271833389997482, -0.0031465194188058376, 0.018328553065657616, 0.04610371217131615, 0.022036850452423096, 0.005752571392804384, 0.010243640281260014, -0.021521247923374176, -0.012694131582975388, -0.04303295910358429, 0.000880792154930532, -0.03614741191267967, 0.010683990083634853, 0.014618541114032269, 0.04342425614595413, -0.022164227440953255, -0.04573017358779907, -0.011115475557744503, -0.04726255685091019, -0.056563250720500946, 0.014406557194888592, -0.05518725886940956, 0.0369827076792717, 0.03415542095899582, 0.05554014444351196, -0.02910563535988331, 0.007867646403610706, 0.0413692332804203, -0.0045401169918477535, -0.07780714333057404, 0.0028424165211617947, -0.0022772180382162333, 0.0038997670635581017, 0.010983828455209732, 0.01334489043802023, 0.009980841539800167, -0.0030915553215891123, -0.023970531299710274, -0.03829870745539665, 0.009333235211670399, -0.045624494552612305, 0.05655049532651901, -0.04791482910513878, -0.0701562762260437, -0.004586624912917614, -0.02271583117544651, 0.0095383794978261, -0.011004231870174408, -0.006951088551431894, 0.020800931379199028, -0.021379129961133003, -0.01489543542265892, -0.00040301488479599357, 0.03689248487353325, 0.05912116542458534, 0.005129235330969095, -0.005393091589212418, -0.03104761429131031, -0.021851781755685806, 0.06566523015499115, 0.020312920212745667, 0.03002178482711315, 0.04334963485598564, 0.023065835237503052, -0.035251665860414505, -0.04126310348510742, 0.0007308091153390706, 0.00880889967083931, 0.025923123583197594, 0.03277415409684181, -0.035935260355472565, 0.05565914511680603, 0.008224187418818474, 0.006688738241791725, 0.01793346181511879, 0.024427874013781548, 0.023071587085723877, 0.021582722663879395, 0.01665063388645649, 0.0020210484508424997, 0.026119228452444077, -0.006570665631443262, 0.007692944258451462, -0.00015675790200475603, 0.021296922117471695, 0.01341695711016655, 0.029549850150942802, 0.010843346826732159, -0.02823408879339695, 0.044688329100608826, 0.03046022541821003, 0.021984577178955078, -0.02061416395008564, -0.052196599543094635, 0.027155598625540733, 0.026053907349705696, 0.03379572927951813, 0.044486116617918015, 0.028962405398488045, -0.05041947588324547, 0.008921864442527294, 0.01932462491095066, 0.03795987740159035, -0.034766845405101776, 0.0009474424878135324, -0.044392265379428864, -0.024978285655379295, 0.019265178591012955, 0.0041325329802930355, 0.021310079842805862, -0.01174208428710699, 0.0054026274010539055, -0.007099986542016268, -0.04093114286661148, -0.0343015193939209, -0.0337330661714077, 0.021038221195340157, 0.012801999226212502, -0.004528878256678581, -0.03982770815491676, -0.038410332053899765, -0.00508816447108984, 0.03042846918106079, 0.014733835123479366, -0.011686522513628006, 0.0168234221637249, 0.024340596050024033, 0.029699720442295074, -0.009148371405899525, -0.08007000386714935, 0.02806084230542183, 0.024577848613262177, -0.035687752068042755, 0.008289114572107792, -0.016209857538342476, -0.07660496234893799, 0.03134097158908844, 0.010233513079583645, 0.026870889589190483, 0.02256367914378643, -0.016944993287324905, 0.05847829207777977, 0.022489935159683228, 0.024114489555358887, 0.06543153524398804, 0.04188276827335358, 0.008804111741483212, -0.0067746820859611034, -0.011392932385206223, -0.018881332129240036, -0.04599441587924957, 0.03378092125058174, -0.05388779938220978, -0.010925009846687317, -0.022705508396029472, 0.02532198838889599, -0.019743463024497032, 0.03250780329108238, -0.026853378862142563, -0.029897945001721382, -0.004937625490128994, 0.032094795256853104, 0.002398551907390356, -0.03169933706521988, -0.008684380911290646, 0.04926665127277374, 0.005757070612162352, -0.04611973464488983, 0.050544336438179016, -0.020246172323822975, 0.02305968664586544, 0.029952123761177063, -0.014631640166044235, -0.015399490483105183, 0.012120207771658897, -0.002457152819260955, -0.00928961206227541, 0.01792757399380207, 0.045667603611946106, -0.005801491439342499, 0.03473513573408127, -0.006209930405020714, 0.03504454344511032, -0.020916007459163666, 0.01255875639617443, 0.008088105358183384, 0.00004197101225145161, 0.0019146590493619442, 0.006382293999195099, 0.02448636293411255, -0.03583521023392677, -0.05252273753285408, -0.048130493611097336, 0.023073391988873482, 0.0035805096849799156, -0.02365131489932537, -0.016284838318824768, -0.023690903559327126, -0.02489507384598255, -0.06152817979454994, -0.009846420958638191, 0.013852954842150211, -0.024292035028338432, 0.007417874876409769, -0.010052896104753017, 0.0286567285656929, 0.08993164449930191, 0.0026416569016873837, -0.022026391699910164, 0.011760981753468513, -0.05239201709628105, -0.000026944559067487717, -0.024563437327742577, 0.013054248876869678, -0.004664014559239149, -0.01855158619582653, -0.013063139282166958, -0.03281671181321144, 0.04699145630002022, -0.019387317821383476, -0.015410942025482655, 0.030117224901914597, 0.01909344084560871, 0.0007572353351861238, -0.012632658705115318, -0.01906072534620762, -0.005777739454060793, 0.018120385706424713, 0.009205690585076809, -0.024369079619646072, 0.00970384944230318, -0.014177576638758183, 0.008650003932416439, -0.03239668905735016, 0.007759204134345055, -0.031067367643117905, 0.042285505682229996, -0.016450177878141403, -0.0027423922438174486, -0.00579485297203064, -0.018441053107380867, 0.009144866839051247, 0.003668517805635929, 0.023917181417346, 0.012544838711619377, 0.013908617198467255, -0.04517316818237305, -0.08706066012382507, -0.0550626702606678, 0.04469844326376915, 0.028160106390714645, 0.03857554867863655, 0.005543266888707876, 0.038560304790735245, -0.04970002546906471, -0.02790983021259308, -0.021036693826317787, -0.015081213787198067, -0.037070080637931824, 0.007448500953614712, 0.049902427941560745, -0.025870278477668762, -0.03837479278445244, 0.04230067506432533, 0.02582450397312641, 0.03626534715294838, 0.02832421474158764, 0.014609665609896183, -0.013452819548547268, 0.0017430990701541305, -0.02028556354343891, -0.07257451862096786, 0.043611668050289154, -0.052070148289203644, 0.03676088899374008, -0.03929585590958595, -0.01568618230521679, 0.00902594719082117, 0.06164368987083435, -0.005048777442425489, -0.04852644354104996, 0.0033113867975771427, -0.05860345438122749, -0.011890738271176815, 0.022655660286545753, 0.02393731102347374, 0.016926031559705734, -0.0017430944135412574, 0.04081219807267189, 0.000020904493794660084, 0.05522960424423218, -0.004311314783990383, -0.0445810928940773, -0.014488928951323032, -0.029635580256581306, -0.022549407556653023, 0.02660490572452545, -0.0014404825633391738, 0.001839785953052342, -0.0000011672989330691053, -0.05766330286860466, 0.012877266854047775, 0.0014182578306645155, 0.041970815509557724, 0.006375112105160952, 0.015934297814965248, 0.00041590401087887585, 0.04006565362215042, -0.02850431762635708, -0.0012433803640305996, 0.17322149872779846, 0.08194463700056076, 0.006700040772557259, -0.04055286943912506, 0.005678405519574881, 0.013877305202186108, 0.0005511572817340493, -0.02754973992705345, -0.0004725875915028155, -0.021649569272994995, -0.032186638563871384, 0.042275797575712204, 0.031255416572093964, -0.02507171966135502, 0.022330597043037415, 0.02392539568245411, -0.044796254485845566, -0.03223717585206032, -0.000738760398235172, 0.012292703613638878, -0.05137203261256218, -0.001854997593909502, 0.0071266815066337585, 0.005939133930951357, 0.02059316448867321, -0.029079709202051163, 0.008845821022987366, -0.0003186315589118749, 0.0071456534788012505, -0.005861811339855194, -0.03779012709856033, -0.010762335732579231, 0.00048097167746163905, -0.010699241422116756, 0.01844549924135208, -0.02076682634651661, 0.014296155422925949, -0.02999393455684185, -0.001661763177253306, 0.07384417206048965, -0.027126220986247063, 0.019143888726830482, 0.0015162198105826974, 0.01972033642232418, -0.02642250806093216, -0.012394379824399948, -0.037448540329933167, 0.02008281648159027, -0.007127057295292616, -0.033914532512426376, -0.021746117621660233, 0.00021909632778260857, 0.01624130830168724, -0.010676837526261806, -0.021392416208982468, 0.04300830513238907, 0.03716559708118439, -0.04612596705555916, 0.004324625246226788, 0.013016492128372192, -0.019861776381731033, 0.005458906292915344, 0.02833697199821472, 0.024469198659062386, -0.07227126508951187, -0.017902972176671028, -0.022034641355276108, 0.0508379228413105, -0.03750253841280937, 0.04619346931576729, -0.019861949607729912, 0.0021972591057419777, 0.009047020226716995, -0.03289458900690079, 0.02217709645628929, 0.019130971282720566, 0.005440870299935341, -0.011296730488538742, 0.020017428323626518, -0.017643919214606285, -0.05233168974518776, 0.024369288235902786, -0.01428033784031868, -0.02028317004442215, -0.05742431432008743, 0.02333265356719494, -0.015705199912190437, 0.017436392605304718, -0.03477242961525917, -0.009945465251803398, -0.019629456102848053, 0.08363783359527588, 0.009003779850900173, -0.0364515520632267, -0.014421360567212105, -0.013327456079423428, -0.012344993650913239, 0.014316504821181297, 0.03373688831925392, 0.03592348471283913, 0.063571035861969, 0.025077521800994873, 0.0023689409717917442, 0.035825587809085846, -0.013211484998464584, -0.016325557604432106, 0.0218158308416605, -0.05443676933646202, 0.028940606862306595, 0.0723959282040596, 0.018042081966996193, -0.004623661749064922, 0.00003764353459700942, -0.02950429543852806, 0.0032471604645252228, -0.01028511207550764, 0.005653817672282457, -0.04334663599729538, 0.006778302136808634, 0.010761653073132038, 0.036548495292663574, -0.020987514406442642, -0.002261342480778694, -0.004700521472841501, 0.03767216578125954, 0.02737717516720295, -0.014058598317205906, 0.01440842542797327, 0.00035470392322167754, -0.025239767506718636, -0.02726590447127819, -0.004837753251194954, 0.00195678835734725, -0.02131175808608532, -0.01289514172822237, -0.002479957416653633, -0.003015832742676139, 0.014261688105762005, -0.004942994099110365, -0.012354645878076553, -0.002117299009114504, -0.05611587315797806, -0.027954787015914917, 0.022075574845075607, 0.012371205724775791, 0.0877372995018959, 0.029281631112098694, 0.0022373527754098177, -0.030691316351294518, 0.002891921205446124, -0.01845245249569416, -0.0027397095691412687, -0.009885254316031933, -0.02099718526005745, 0.0439797043800354, -0.007614579983055592, 0.023798000067472458, 0.020997440442442894, -0.003540651872754097, 0.012860724702477455, 0.0438443161547184, -0.011458213441073895, -0.019284745678305626, 0.04536176472902298, -0.03283214196562767, 0.0026868844870477915, -0.019559677690267563, -0.00041970686288550496, 0.023130109533667564, 0.03450581058859825, -0.010471395216882229, -0.002612838987261057, -0.02661970630288124, 0.0042320736683905125, -0.08032289892435074, -0.05336955562233925, -0.0008668765076436102, 0.03121309168636799, 0.05832837522029877, -0.033097561448812485, 0.008233350701630116, 0.03544329106807709, -0.06001781299710274, 0.022708075121045113, 0.012985031120479107, 0.04746270924806595, -0.05036774277687073, -0.004853353835642338, -0.019367920234799385, 0.04509292542934418, 0.026511870324611664, 0.020199274644255638, 0.01684887520968914, 0.05446048080921173, 0.012653631158173084, -0.037568118423223495, -0.022296462208032608, 0.005121144931763411, -0.029074497520923615, -0.03024017997086048, 0.036580462008714676, -0.05647603049874306, 0.03152812644839287, 0.007145371288061142, -0.002084579085931182, 0.031525250524282455, -0.017855562269687653, 0.04304879531264305, 0.029514838010072708, 0.03269171342253685, 0.03613603487610817, 0.022806432098150253, 0.019359158352017403, -0.04079962894320488, 0.01352697517722845, -0.016876939684152603, -0.007887291721999645, -0.006933725904673338, 0.05677841976284981, -0.02462974190711975, -0.005115830339491367, 0.0011927512241527438, -0.009494406171143055, 0.003339095739647746, 0.007318730931729078, -0.013332899659872055, -0.048243921250104904, -0.03247494995594025, 0.009083425626158714, -0.005547582171857357, -0.046263255178928375, 0.001461380859836936, 0.05221047252416611, -0.012531761080026627, -0.022351182997226715, 0.018083995208144188, -0.024824192747473717, 0.04047028347849846, 0.005233676638454199, 0.030704397708177567, -0.03385927900671959, -0.022952692583203316, 0.003684447379782796, -0.008710461668670177, -0.022227460518479347, 0.020617926493287086, -0.04733908921480179, 0.04388314113020897, -0.03422079607844353, 0.009539635851979256, -0.02705075591802597, 0.007947876118123531, -0.0008319794433191419, -0.06209098547697067, 0.02291109599173069, -0.00869689043611288, -0.029508525505661964, -0.015280789695680141, -0.03221379593014717, -0.0011710604885593057, -0.01652423106133938, 0.07097318768501282, 0.03312132507562637, -0.04354936257004738, 0.021041208878159523, 0.034861572086811066, 0.007728611119091511, -0.06562367081642151, 0.027330517768859863, -0.01818874478340149, 0.02003374509513378, -0.010677346028387547, -0.026394715532660484, 0.005222586449235678, 0.02663537859916687, 0.01895199343562126, -0.01443093828856945, -0.01073217112571001, 0.0157568771392107, -0.020686926320195198, 0.033090539276599884, 0.01232806034386158, -0.01710612326860428, 0.06129143759608269, -0.01671290397644043, 0.005501380190253258, 0.0024449750781059265, -0.0315205454826355, -0.08743133395910263, 0.006005546543747187, -0.04021099582314491, 0.021547583863139153, -0.058581702411174774, -0.01847255416214466, -0.017051761969923973, -0.03408736735582352, -0.014790737070143223, 0.03947319835424423, -0.04692637920379639, -0.008358331397175789, 0.036629147827625275, 0.010855014435946941, 0.044553566724061966, 0.023307839408516884, -0.00964199285954237, 0.043344058096408844, -0.007802341133356094, 0.0013003017520532012, -0.0007148389122448862, 0.07520192861557007, -0.0473015196621418, 0.016210095956921577, 0.02230565808713436, -0.023556554690003395, 0.03941738232970238, 0.014254175126552582, -0.01509309746325016, -0.07065644860267639, -0.02482721395790577, 0.03995909169316292, -0.052656207233667374, 0.01218115072697401, 0.021068887785077095, -0.03916766867041588, 0.08644982427358627, -0.02514728717505932, 0.026289621368050575, 0.03434336930513382, 0.05614845082163811, -0.0034388841595500708, 0.01605028659105301, -0.03560302034020424, 0.006832558196038008, -0.02560090646147728, -0.008003449067473412, -0.024903301149606705, -0.019038774073123932, -0.0015924707986414433, -0.04422770440578461, -0.04384024813771248, 0.02223377488553524, -0.00619121827185154, 0.00735818687826395, -0.05847172439098358, -0.02226562798023224, -0.014250416308641434, 0.028384726494550705, 0.01203799806535244, 0.012339688837528229, 0.01430729404091835, -0.002610627794638276, -0.0017758540343493223, 0.04738619178533554, -0.033430036157369614, 0.02868993766605854, -0.01485816203057766, -0.01900537870824337, 0.009670881554484367, -0.01278472039848566 ]
<p>From what I read the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theil%E2%80%93Sen_estimator" rel="nofollow">Theil-Sen estimator</a> seems to be a really cool estimator; robust and easy to understand. <strong>Would it be possible to device (or does it already exists) a Bayesian "version" of the Theil-Sen estimator so that you provide a prior for the slope and get a probability density back instead of just a point estimate? How would such an estimator look/work?</strong></p>
73,396
[ -0.016032008454203606, 0.01848611980676651, 0.04635704681277275, -0.019124167039990425, 0.04155515134334564, 0.04113887622952461, 0.005807661917060614, -0.0036025643348693848, 0.019100261852145195, -0.04435277730226517, -0.014449634589254856, 0.03676526993513107, 0.06859691441059113, 0.03454281762242317, 0.044236231595277786, 0.0030338545329868793, -0.019224241375923157, 0.023987382650375366, -0.026396924629807472, -0.04550159350037575, 0.010525674559175968, 0.018282726407051086, -0.00912466924637556, -0.007072558160871267, -0.010575990192592144, 0.01987495645880699, 0.02322383224964142, -0.019044354557991028, -0.01139550656080246, 0.11314942687749863, -0.01936403475701809, -0.04104023426771164, 0.014569088816642761, 0.04422793164849281, 0.017470408231019974, -0.028060585260391235, -0.006630799267441034, -0.02266446128487587, -0.0278195608407259, 0.05009022727608681, -0.015515548177063465, -0.01155861746519804, 0.008850370533764362, 0.03751162812113762, -0.06775616109371185, -0.010011234320700169, 0.009035399183630943, -0.06309699267148972, 0.054177768528461456, -0.06074730306863785, 0.05211617052555084, 0.023637156933546066, 0.02008475922048092, 0.07002880424261093, -0.025482498109340668, -0.034717656672000885, 0.03455757349729538, 0.04502562806010246, -0.011441828683018684, -0.06584379076957703, -0.02375158481299877, -0.0012717032805085182, -0.019359057769179344, -0.041808247566223145, -0.011576193384826183, 0.021175066009163857, -0.029315102845430374, -0.02147829905152321, 0.021332615986466408, -0.025344546884298325, -0.018485063686966896, 0.010246279649436474, 0.02204230986535549, 0.008863934315741062, 0.026863468810915947, -0.04637118801474571, 0.006961396895349026, 0.03078349493443966, 0.019290581345558167, 0.009427952580153942, 0.03322383761405945, -0.011527097783982754, 0.04257386177778244, 0.058598842471838, 0.011159132234752178, -0.018539197742938995, 0.06334668397903442, -0.04886767640709877, 0.03750200569629669, -0.004472183063626289, -0.03498438373208046, 0.007095342967659235, 0.012707104906439781, 0.011597718112170696, -0.06619191914796829, 0.029129108414053917, 0.001533340779133141, 0.06421352177858353, 0.010169644840061665, -0.0006776507361792028, 0.02956673875451088, -0.000218732631765306, -0.011811085045337677, 0.052005618810653687, -0.013670859858393669, -0.028445158153772354, 0.009608539752662182, 0.0037425204645842314, -0.04727783799171448, -0.012751540169119835, -0.046252887696027756, 0.00249630119651556, 0.011512457393109798, -0.04113435000181198, 0.02243191935122013, -0.02464519627392292, -0.0038617420941591263, -0.01089082844555378, 0.0460096150636673, 0.0635482668876648, 0.02703646756708622, 0.01577005535364151, 0.024324892088770866, -0.04255777597427368, -0.05058065056800842, -0.010558315552771091, -0.003454781137406826, -0.019721537828445435, 0.017147155478596687, 0.028524262830615044, -0.020158659666776657, 0.04594747722148895, 0.07445228099822998, 0.012649253010749817, 0.022778918966650963, -0.0054330830462276936, -0.0590800940990448, -0.04793129116296768, 0.03033016249537468, 0.008692268282175064, 0.011255419813096523, -0.05854419991374016, 0.010561314411461353, 0.029475009068846703, 0.030770698562264442, 0.028827521950006485, 0.01718280278146267, 0.004230756778270006, 0.016472822055220604, -0.015748484060168266, -0.035469599068164825, -0.028709689155220985, -0.013334325514733791, -0.05150149017572403, -0.02784356102347374, -0.09374535828828812, 0.03632260486483574, -0.005824131891131401, -0.019171584397554398, -0.048455655574798584, 0.04849810153245926, 0.03721275553107262, -0.005872812122106552, 0.007568292319774628, -0.03009185753762722, -0.030247701331973076, 0.10628931224346161, 0.008915704675018787, -0.00022897767485119402, 0.015768839046359062, 0.0034663998521864414, 0.010084099136292934, 0.01528420951217413, 0.00492593040689826, 0.0282188318669796, -0.08495057374238968, 0.0002791087026707828, -0.012246588245034218, 0.029470905661582947, 0.011676306836307049, 0.012078380212187767, -0.01450233906507492, 0.0009243566892109811, -0.02223755046725273, -0.013068052008748055, 0.02105017565190792, 0.014445427805185318, -0.009509749710559845, 0.015883632004261017, -0.05005134642124176, -0.009439080022275448, -0.040903497487306595, 0.007864436134696007, 0.002343888860195875, -0.012968527153134346, -0.004472463857382536, 0.022395532578229904, 0.0017286846414208412, -0.026712791994214058, -0.031005915254354477, -0.012441630475223064, -0.012682531028985977, 0.01916860230267048, -0.01774057373404503, 0.03749886155128479, 0.048640891909599304, 0.03556463494896889, 0.008300693705677986, 0.03839438036084175, -0.03908693417906761, -0.06333529204130173, -0.02857312001287937, -0.027683062478899956, 0.026848001405596733, -0.008588001132011414, -0.018246611580252647, 0.0015402259305119514, -0.02206452190876007, -0.0040212590247392654, 0.0016122349770739675, -0.04628724232316017, 0.05750394985079765, 0.05146074667572975, 0.025543950498104095, 0.0026456171181052923, 0.0026265080086886883, -0.002194963162764907, 0.012656141072511673, -0.010242811404168606, -0.015388095751404762, -0.044383227825164795, 0.04308057948946953, 0.060584768652915955, 0.04589652642607689, -0.03320470079779625, 0.037716783583164215, 0.060153111815452576, -0.009830981492996216, 0.044037580490112305, 0.008395296521484852, 0.0011083013378083706, -0.019632896408438683, 0.010723174549639225, 0.013434498570859432, 0.0044316784478724, -0.004206114914268255, 0.048323675990104675, 0.028386348858475685, 0.037943802773952484, -0.026557018980383873, -0.012718834914267063, -0.00836961343884468, -0.022640926763415337, 0.027060745283961296, -0.00886176060885191, 0.011730181984603405, 0.032718949019908905, -0.03983670100569725, 0.0158404354006052, 0.014466408640146255, -0.011873007752001286, -0.004336922895163298, 0.01589752547442913, -0.04212474822998047, 0.04489635303616524, 0.04857071861624718, -0.059679288417100906, 0.010077187791466713, 0.026997819542884827, -0.024836167693138123, 0.02474183961749077, -0.00942291785031557, -0.002044789493083954, -0.025794709101319313, 0.019013503566384315, 0.026330532506108284, -0.01577024720609188, -0.015170533210039139, -0.017963875085115433, -0.036707211285829544, -0.0002950473572127521, 0.011943826451897621, -0.013134363107383251, 0.04235799238085747, -0.054663922637701035, 0.008155999705195427, 0.002369296969845891, -0.012451106682419777, 0.027633750811219215, 0.022758955135941505, -0.028527773916721344, 0.013318960554897785, -0.027883168309926987, -0.05344809591770172, -0.018104655668139458, -0.04699273779988289, 0.02501969411969185, -0.019050586968660355, -0.02092807926237583, 0.01528540812432766, -0.0071808830834925175, 0.023221170529723167, 0.051815588027238846, -0.04471055418252945, -0.05730157345533371, -0.07471060007810593, 0.02104051783680916, 0.008272928185760975, 0.033523716032505035, 0.0569649338722229, 0.025241341441869736, -0.04502386599779129, -0.003051200183108449, -0.05046272650361061, -0.06489977240562439, 0.022637812420725822, 0.03480745851993561, 0.027020858600735664, -0.0019424542551860213, -0.0028168323915451765, 0.0924636498093605, 0.015851017087697983, -0.05085824429988861, -0.004912862554192543, 0.004268533084541559, -0.01946166902780533, -0.0005980677669867873, -0.010211019776761532, -0.02537316083908081, -0.004740726202726364, 0.0015469923382624984, -0.03817104548215866, 0.0070589035749435425, 0.08460919559001923, 0.015057655051350594, -0.00801870971918106, 0.004072265233844519, -0.014192338101565838, 0.018356435000896454, 0.031128883361816406, 0.016668571159243584, -0.02140485681593418, -0.0031614815816283226, -0.044818222522735596, 0.047871217131614685, 0.0029726135544478893, -0.04252758249640465, 0.02613196335732937, -0.0016770849470049143, -0.021240586414933205, -0.03890550136566162, -0.0007911440916359425, -0.0025770466309040785, 0.00010069292329717427, 0.005916634574532509, 0.027213720604777336, 0.05813604220747948, -0.0028344672173261642, 0.015149524435400963, 0.04523896425962448, 0.02479042112827301, -0.04870118573307991, -0.025201847776770592, 0.014637586660683155, -0.013696633279323578, -0.036979760974645615, 0.0005079659749753773, -0.008845321834087372, 0.02235559932887554, 0.03003707528114319, 0.002379871439188719, 0.014762451872229576, -0.022891119122505188, 0.016712015494704247, -0.05950753018260002, 0.02267870120704174, 0.017810845747590065, 0.05419047549366951, 0.04536842182278633, 0.03171810135245323, -0.022039176896214485, 0.03682396188378334, 0.0045333970338106155, 0.004603623878210783, -0.07570270448923111, -0.006095081102102995, -0.029099155217409134, -0.036879733204841614, -0.008678058162331581, -0.01620267890393734, 0.04964142292737961, -0.04698306694626808, 0.0017962036654353142, 0.0022206860594451427, 0.017738832160830498, -0.027324751019477844, 0.0014915810897946358, -0.04435114935040474, -0.04506075754761696, 0.013354399241507053, -0.014013904146850109, 0.03167387470602989, -0.0374508835375309, 0.025357913225889206, 0.006596568506211042, 0.008937714621424675, -0.011570648290216923, -0.002409766661003232, 0.0053152358159422874, -0.018809577450156212, 0.005213909316807985, 0.020674820989370346, 0.04383635148406029, -0.050452299416065216, 0.0021927000489085913, 0.008796592243015766, 0.06113246828317642, 0.04680841416120529, -0.01772349327802658, -0.0014764060033485293, 0.003448956413194537, -0.03378729522228241, 0.03097037598490715, 0.025276649743318558, -0.03375450149178505, 0.006466472055763006, 0.013366970233619213, 0.01691480726003647, -0.04807280749082565, 0.016917027533054352, 0.07667917013168335, 0.01595497317612171, 0.012782138772308826, -0.07217328250408173, -0.009492439217865467, 0.013949810527265072, 0.014543542638421059, 0.016710547730326653, -0.005601875949651003, -0.0037611599545925856, 0.019640885293483734, 0.03783417493104935, 0.017688540741801262, 0.01605190709233284, -0.013630741275846958, 0.003422041889280081, 0.0293375663459301, 0.018881363794207573, -0.030212191864848137, 0.0024197218008339405, 0.03412662073969841, 0.03385022282600403, -0.00963982567191124, 0.015113737434148788, -0.11470102518796921, -0.016448015347123146, 0.0015016638208180666, 0.02163219451904297, -0.01948700286448002, 0.03266976773738861, -0.09620340168476105, -0.030450962483882904, 0.06465674191713333, -0.026857981458306313, 0.01617448776960373, -0.057688191533088684, 0.043820928782224655, 0.01797199621796608, -0.018853208050131798, -0.027354992926120758, 0.01820540241897106, -0.017543654888868332, -0.004398282617330551, -0.005566505249589682, -0.019701341167092323, -0.050838980823755264, 0.00919314380735159, 0.016102604568004608, 0.07001586258411407, -0.0016491141868755221, -0.011240873485803604, -0.01680312305688858, 0.008789991028606892, -0.011013071984052658, -0.08621414005756378, 0.013812331482768059, 0.005683291237801313, 0.007120653986930847, 0.02356787584722042, -0.019527625292539597, -0.041514672338962555, 0.03712064400315285, 0.00862137135118246, -0.027102984488010406, 0.0027419901452958584, -0.03050314262509346, 0.026184163987636566, 0.04292186349630356, 0.021853553131222725, 0.017025809735059738, 0.005495094228535891, 0.0077377683483064175, 0.031135134398937225, -0.02574463188648224, 0.006638620980083942, -0.0595058836042881, -0.02133987471461296, -0.03554792329668999, -0.0012106134090572596, -0.02288738451898098, 0.025930045172572136, -0.004143207333981991, 0.03969347104430199, -0.013285464607179165, -0.03624176234006882, 0.023914111778140068, 0.04488559067249298, 0.016100743785500526, 0.003157418454065919, -0.02138325572013855, 0.0032623636070638895, -0.020627738907933235, -0.02567712962627411, 0.021650440990924835, 0.020075000822544098, 0.00046961914631538093, -0.03023565001785755, -0.01910007931292057, 0.02083483524620533, -0.018001385033130646, -0.043111179023981094, 0.05189604312181473, -0.0465891994535923, 0.05048629641532898, -0.005913676228374243, 0.043111156672239304, 0.012828914448618889, -0.03040320798754692, 0.0016223578713834286, -0.008321667090058327, -0.022654438391327858, 0.024403253570199013, -0.042762476950883865, 0.011287383735179901, -0.016355523839592934, 0.01462768204510212, -0.06615950167179108, -0.030026186257600784, 0.013179941102862358, -0.0012671749573200941, -0.05751871317625046, -0.030986063182353973, 0.01771918311715126, -0.01162128709256649, -0.01340196467936039, 0.024013105779886246, 0.038112442940473557, 0.013190505094826221, 0.00533042149618268, 0.0031344962771981955, 0.03865615278482437, 0.06077855825424194, 0.005495215766131878, -0.019628850743174553, 0.0417998768389225, -0.03430543467402458, -0.013570287264883518, -0.01874454692006111, 0.017122875899076462, -0.044402264058589935, 0.02268098294734955, -0.004380706697702408, 0.026646848767995834, 0.04772515967488289, 0.00017549759650137275, -0.008100992999970913, 0.017535382881760597, 0.04066997393965721, -0.0098916906863451, -0.05262875556945801, -0.013516681268811226, -0.04918276146054268, -0.009486662223935127, -0.04332764074206352, -0.0034198961220681667, 0.014843787997961044, -0.010258284397423267, 0.046995870769023895, 0.009530281648039818, 0.0038455540779978037, -0.015736572444438934, 0.030834482982754707, -0.010940710082650185, 0.006845650728791952, 0.03242943808436394, -0.025983870029449463, 0.059704892337322235, 0.007462063804268837, -0.003105480456724763, 0.020629193633794785, 0.006879416294395924, -0.03225605562329292, -0.01784132793545723, -0.05663848668336868, 0.00027210963889956474, 0.07745946943759918, -0.020766330882906914, 0.03573732078075409, 0.022169295698404312, -0.0204023327678442, -0.016978930681943893, 0.001795281539671123, -0.011411670595407486, -0.024589620530605316, 0.007042807526886463, 0.043991878628730774, -0.03750243037939072, -0.0017559294356033206, 0.031403083354234695, -0.007786584552377462, 0.02539161406457424, 0.057240065187215805, 0.0015897752018645406, 0.06823474913835526, 0.06572927534580231, 0.00574348121881485, -0.030375860631465912, 0.06573217362165451, -0.010106818750500679, -0.0005572349764406681, -0.03792029991745949, -0.051638226956129074, 0.03614281117916107, 0.010662181302905083, 0.00026238366262987256, -0.03795281797647476, -0.045537032186985016, -0.025377344340085983, 0.039332423359155655, 0.00013527923147194088, -0.0031590047292411327, 0.019965143874287605, 0.012750983238220215, -0.008496956899762154, -0.00452111242339015, 0.015888525173068047, -0.04467969015240669, -0.11078241467475891, -0.012243080884218216, -0.019072076305747032, -0.01693633385002613, -0.002314874902367592, 0.03725424408912659, -0.038787201046943665, 0.034436874091625214, -0.02995813824236393, 0.003170693526044488, 0.02179945819079876, 0.027438713237643242, 0.006416620220988989, 0.07341980934143066, 0.00022871170949656516, 0.054147444665431976, -0.01902601681649685, -0.01061027217656374, 0.11100874841213226, 0.09970884770154953, 0.042842961847782135, -0.03436875343322754, 0.018719684332609177, -0.005446585360914469, 0.03028138540685177, -0.00033865042496472597, 0.019454171881079674, 0.04063938558101654, -0.03885446861386299, -0.005440632812678814, 0.05635477602481842, 0.008051933720707893, -0.013818196952342987, 0.04448110610246658, -0.0073777311481535435, -0.023717954754829407, -0.008678686805069447, 0.02566029690206051, -0.01391506940126419, -0.010082234628498554, -0.053952887654304504, 0.014579055830836296, 0.01626865193247795, -0.04258400574326515, -0.004328585229814053, -0.02541802078485489, -0.02823762036859989, 0.020781097933650017, -0.016836494207382202, -0.031855396926403046, 0.028978899121284485, -0.034420404583215714, 0.0015353115741163492, -0.020990919321775436, 0.0008060116088017821, -0.012786846607923508, 0.0065232436172664165, 0.01757592149078846, 0.01804340071976185, -0.003730167867615819, -0.011030299589037895, -0.00029727595392614603, -0.019144531339406967, -0.005852401256561279, -0.017152776941657066, 0.01342068798840046, -0.017754964530467987, 0.004178772214800119, -0.009572777897119522, -0.01560231577605009, 0.05281927436590195, -0.02095903642475605, -0.012206465937197208, 0.01999632827937603, 0.010185832157731056, 0.007557766046375036, -0.011443467810750008, 0.020299233496189117, 0.00878455676138401, 0.005980059038847685, 0.01710355281829834, 0.06293096393346786, -0.03465507552027702, -0.053331468254327774, -0.012080682441592216, 0.05123240500688553, 0.00399445928633213, -0.021841056644916534, -0.020114442333579063, -0.04515745863318443, -0.03335694968700409, -0.042365845292806625, 0.016289982944726944, -0.023343130946159363, -0.00480769295245409, -0.005778525490313768, -0.00947224348783493, -0.0013062843354418874, -0.004124825820326805, 0.026569921523332596, -0.05765990540385246, 0.008459151722490788, -0.023912163451313972, 0.02783920057117939, 0.09985280781984329, 0.042169757187366486, 0.010921191424131393, 0.0335848405957222, -0.044001832604408264, -0.005468180403113365, 0.004714170470833778, -0.07156063616275787, 0.011215420439839363, 0.012197919189929962, -0.025084996595978737, -0.014797758311033249, -0.007480914704501629, 0.03039821796119213, 0.003539685858413577, 0.05665292590856552, -0.0368022695183754, 0.014479444362223148, -0.04103750362992287, 0.024591311812400818, -0.017066676169633865, -0.06947527080774307, -0.014359473250806332, -0.00822490081191063, -0.0035661461297422647, -0.011440359987318516, -0.0004948535934090614, -0.012160131707787514, -0.013686737045645714, -0.0068259527906775475, 0.005046979058533907, -0.05879273638129234, -0.0001196637749671936, 0.004274868872016668, 0.024831708520650864, -0.0018267289269715548, 0.026046760380268097, 0.004896373953670263, -0.03712178021669388, -0.03818086162209511, 0.016944758594036102, -0.03225007653236389, 0.02566826343536377, -0.022588390856981277, -0.05331341549754143, 0.003054044209420681, 0.01430260855704546, 0.02241496555507183, -0.019246108829975128, 0.02255939692258835, 0.0424642376601696, 0.04677736759185791, -0.026346448808908463, -0.02597176283597946, 0.030503978952765465, -0.042929474264383316, -0.008690038695931435, 0.03414115309715271, 0.01694757491350174, 0.01839650236070156, 0.020117733627557755, -0.0016848244704306126, -0.025314683094620705, 0.023711513727903366, -0.025509241968393326, 0.01837472803890705, -0.00520262960344553, 0.003450216958299279, -0.0020103196147829294, -0.03142212703824043, 0.00442156009376049, 0.01769437827169895, 0.005755975376814604, 0.022214751690626144, 0.009154935367405415, -0.013222762383520603, -0.0022032377310097218, 0.0126260444521904, -0.01224222220480442, -0.010994763113558292, -0.018268095329403877, -0.007958181202411652, 0.018838893622159958, 0.009119871072471142, -0.03043382614850998, -0.0026523720007389784, -0.020664984360337257, 0.03461983799934387, -0.11174745112657547, -0.013429934158921242, 0.010250028222799301, -0.018409794196486473, 0.038109190762043, -0.05004297196865082, -0.0066549768671393394, 0.006366225425153971, -0.03097951039671898, 0.03151990845799446, 0.015594365075230598, -0.0007018284522928298, -0.05573691427707672, 0.005963274743407965, -0.007600774988532066, 0.07212666422128677, -0.018000591546297073, 0.04212862253189087, 0.03862651064991951, 0.005599332973361015, 0.015976741909980774, -0.01013464666903019, -0.009170586243271828, 0.022232331335544586, 0.033994439989328384, -0.05846352502703667, 0.05178453028202057, -0.05652565881609917, -0.023255597800016403, 0.04890121519565582, 0.026816703379154205, 0.051368072628974915, -0.01273565087467432, 0.022818630561232567, 0.013915586285293102, 0.026633860543370247, 0.03860427811741829, 0.010010004974901676, 0.003222676692530513, 0.022445833310484886, -0.01073329709470272, 0.025980567559599876, 0.0002442855329718441, -0.003974568098783493, 0.03228706866502762, 0.0017276688013225794, -0.027499569579958916, 0.031742509454488754, 0.0018401927081868052, -0.016556058079004288, 0.043089110404253006, -0.01371140219271183, 0.016477596014738083, -0.024750906974077225, 0.01453159935772419, -0.05762573331594467, 0.011655972339212894, 0.04540656879544258, -0.03251585364341736, -0.000727368809748441, 0.024044860154390335, 0.0008412037277594209, -0.06311430782079697, 0.053742289543151855, -0.0430331788957119, -0.006430190522223711, -0.06341681629419327, 0.0361953005194664, 0.01982375793159008, -0.008338764309883118, 0.0015201537171378732, -0.0013764428440481424, -0.009756584651768208, 0.040401965379714966, -0.02087870053946972, 0.01966228149831295, 0.029010256752371788, -0.0007586238789372146, 0.010728118009865284, -0.06003695726394653, 0.09091927111148834, -0.010871494188904762, -0.028566475957632065, -0.01606603153049946, -0.020891590043902397, -0.010798285715281963, -0.03486185148358345, 0.04508953541517258, 0.005986868403851986, 0.012494955211877823, 0.0053298636339604855, 0.03987530618906021, 0.010933063924312592, -0.03402513638138771, 0.008205999620258808, 0.03087140992283821, -0.027452850714325905, -0.02606199122965336, -0.0009775238577276468, -0.006665339693427086, 0.01993306539952755, 0.0617021769285202, -0.029426125809550285, 0.001922805793583393, 0.0009741453686729074, -0.0006847036420367658, -0.007914766669273376, 0.006772549822926521, -0.004175137262791395, 0.034155551344156265, -0.018643781542778015, -0.013874777592718601, -0.013003364205360413, -0.009616418741643429, -0.05609879270195961, 0.00725540891289711, -0.03089485689997673, -0.01474031526595354, -0.016161227598786354, -0.003402584232389927, -0.016823282465338707, -0.05736914649605751, -0.03032139502465725, 0.001053448999300599, -0.04859679937362671, 0.0029508701991289854, 0.04198215901851654, -0.014956291764974594, 0.04848084971308708, -0.02420368418097496, 0.019888585433363914, 0.01175130344927311, 0.0032130684703588486, -0.0006037357961758971, 0.014885312877595425, 0.058762989938259125, -0.0015943500911816955, 0.024435801431536674, 0.03414148837327957, -0.00201037316583097, 0.04071923345327377, -0.019596414640545845, 0.046020034700632095, -0.02079200930893421, 0.0017945298459380865, 0.02194979414343834, -0.004273362923413515, -0.013430442661046982, 0.005617649760097265, -0.020674096420407295, 0.07510747015476227, -0.005442631896585226, -0.0017256010323762894, -0.0032827353570610285, -0.011914437636733055, -0.02965327724814415, 0.00539856031537056, -0.015107874758541584, 0.011423579417169094, 0.019792666658759117, -0.00011627242929534987, 0.016136659309267998, -0.0007898839539848268, 0.028196215629577637, -0.02682824432849884, 0.03434455767273903, -0.0003196273173671216, -0.021024303510785103, 0.028718437999486923, -0.01556595042347908, -0.029714811593294144, -0.02353941649198532, -0.01110516395419836, 0.01353083923459053, 0.055908411741256714, -0.0024774731136858463, -0.04503553360700607, -0.008081099949777126, 0.03834158927202225, -0.06207521632313728, 0.0371670164167881, -0.031197449192404747, 0.034684356302022934, -0.014291411265730858, -0.03109772317111492 ]
<p>I've been using a Metropolis/Gibbs sampler combination to generate a joint density for some parameters(it is a hierarchical model, with $y_i\sim Poisson(\lambda_i)$, $\lambda_i\sim Gamma(\alpha,\beta)$). What techniques can I use to lower autocorrelation(it is present in $\alpha$ and $\beta$)? I have been using thinning, but even when I use huge lags(4950, which is reaching the memory limit on my computer to use) there is still significant autocorrelation. Is there something I could do with my step size distribution to help with this? I have been drawing the new values of $\alpha$ and $\beta$ from a normal distribution, with mean the current parameter value, and standard deviation 1. Thanks!</p>
47,141
[ -0.005382679868489504, -0.0028332951478660107, 0.05745823681354523, 0.004398732911795378, 0.032872941344976425, -0.004047607071697712, -0.013368966057896614, -0.035452693700790405, 0.033773746341466904, -0.052393876016139984, 0.03704512491822243, 0.031238291412591934, 0.040375929325819016, 0.04879213124513626, 0.04922439157962799, -0.060819111764431, -0.015964386984705925, -0.01636519283056259, -0.00451612239703536, -0.02903457172214985, -0.01610737107694149, -0.027484150603413582, 0.029839472845196724, -0.01915430836379528, -0.007306567393243313, 0.04938613250851631, 0.01900601014494896, -0.0000538764288648963, -0.017941799014806747, 0.03686709329485893, -0.041626811027526855, -0.01184998918324709, 0.01960589364171028, 0.013858893886208534, -0.025990230962634087, -0.014052853919565678, -0.03722672164440155, -0.04676496610045433, -0.021265635266900063, 0.03048287332057953, -0.07135709375143051, 0.027767937630414963, -0.03865079581737518, 0.013311185874044895, 0.0005347682163119316, 0.00951424054801464, -0.0026619660202413797, -0.03493460267782211, 0.04128332808613777, 0.0028890769463032484, 0.04323580861091614, 0.018924852833151817, -0.011559379287064075, 0.052452441304922104, 0.014155321754515171, -0.019754929468035698, 0.04111161082983017, 0.09440317749977112, 0.0005556414253078401, -0.012814238667488098, -0.005125085823237896, -0.06020871922373772, 0.002842687303200364, -0.050798751413822174, -0.02856014110147953, 0.02553091198205948, -0.030245337635278702, -0.03103215992450714, 0.014695880934596062, -0.0066422875970602036, 0.014162474311888218, 0.02295685186982155, 0.03352148085832596, -0.004919246304780245, 0.019929571077227592, -0.05987769365310669, 0.020047063007950783, 0.04042552784085274, 0.05644058436155319, 0.024978365749120712, 0.03763747587800026, 0.0011917947558686137, 0.010642769746482372, 0.029736675322055817, -0.044177014380693436, -0.006353855133056641, 0.08192655444145203, -0.033643197268247604, -0.010509341023862362, 0.005322251934558153, -0.04912956804037094, 0.014339426532387733, 0.09675151854753494, 0.02225705236196518, -0.05608160048723221, 0.0316617451608181, -0.018578695133328438, 0.016015157103538513, 0.01455578301101923, 0.01967768743634224, -0.0516342967748642, -0.05611523240804672, 0.03262931853532791, 0.054325539618730545, 0.0007396491128019989, 0.0062661487609148026, -0.013846691697835922, -0.01755610480904579, -0.03635474666953087, -0.054472360759973526, -0.04953959956765175, -0.040809981524944305, 0.010254795663058758, -0.0072321416810154915, 0.04932922497391701, 0.0016610606107860804, -0.0067459531128406525, -0.026869967579841614, 0.05188285931944847, 0.08695605397224426, 0.014996790327131748, -0.013473531231284142, 0.02213931828737259, -0.028102662414312363, -0.07919979840517044, 0.015255349688231945, 0.011398008093237877, -0.06687774509191513, -0.06959152221679688, 0.057163406163454056, 0.001220397767610848, -0.01555081270635128, 0.051201727241277695, -0.04161969572305679, 0.05111662670969963, 0.047712020576000214, -0.07804706692695618, -0.023542370647192, 0.0366988480091095, -0.017524585127830505, 0.01418368797749281, -0.06320108473300934, 0.01685643009841442, 0.02030104212462902, 0.048670027405023575, 0.029815232381224632, 0.003540175501257181, -0.011254070326685905, 0.056980084627866745, 0.0023481633979827166, -0.021476207301020622, -0.02163384109735489, -0.014626124873757362, 0.01813354343175888, -0.011875675059854984, -0.09271173924207687, 0.02847285568714142, 0.01999758556485176, -0.03920359909534454, -0.014677111990749836, 0.03350120782852173, 0.013762270100414753, -0.03351730853319168, -0.015965968370437622, 0.019400402903556824, -0.07427387684583664, 0.042224980890750885, -0.023396175354719162, 0.00926760770380497, -0.04266552999615669, -0.007436604239046574, 0.01964091695845127, 0.007176493294537067, 0.03834109753370285, 0.044994138181209564, -0.0002848562435247004, 0.004268651828169823, 0.01667376235127449, -0.002723823767155409, 0.024592900648713112, 0.010917717590928078, -0.033085666596889496, -0.022136855870485306, -0.0041041141375899315, 0.022784877568483353, 0.011668420396745205, 0.009843181818723679, -0.002680224133655429, 0.018792368471622467, -0.04349846392869949, -0.047017015516757965, -0.09373236447572708, -0.01310810074210167, 0.008360451087355614, 0.005808028858155012, 0.07721169292926788, -0.006324945017695427, 0.014617803506553173, -0.011773253791034222, -0.03796239569783211, -0.02704904042184353, -0.013599504716694355, 0.01938728056848049, -0.04591483622789383, 0.039490293711423874, 0.013439211063086987, 0.04673308879137039, -0.008726324886083603, 0.05237036198377609, -0.01292836107313633, -0.005654142703860998, -0.012915249913930893, -0.029785070568323135, 0.0030378056690096855, -0.038092292845249176, -0.00008124962187139317, 0.01403988990932703, -0.03043539822101593, -0.0010473543079569936, 0.009294731542468071, -0.03207888454198837, 0.038605570793151855, 0.06615561991930008, 0.02305397391319275, 0.02406558208167553, 0.042274683713912964, 0.011049831286072731, -0.0021916497498750687, -0.021213887259364128, -0.030152710154652596, -0.03052503988146782, 0.01781497336924076, 0.06839516758918762, -0.02170100435614586, -0.06711500883102417, 0.028981663286685944, 0.05243590474128723, 0.02366848848760128, 0.04703717306256294, 0.01799491047859192, -0.01255558617413044, 0.01132010854780674, 0.012490309774875641, 0.01995830237865448, 0.022030366584658623, -0.008344890549778938, 0.01527076680213213, -0.0014100180706009269, 0.03361695632338524, -0.05304889380931854, -0.038103774189949036, -0.013461397960782051, 0.03137294203042984, 0.02282780408859253, -0.02776704542338848, -0.04891055077314377, 0.03570464998483658, -0.007955276407301426, 0.007135608699172735, 0.0371970571577549, -0.0110349515452981, -0.010417682118713856, 0.003288817824795842, -0.027786320075392723, 0.02579534240067005, 0.05662884563207626, -0.02764536254107952, 0.018423030152916908, 0.02275284007191658, -0.033400073647499084, 0.023929215967655182, -0.022680319845676422, -0.02436770312488079, -0.04324370250105858, -0.0061166551895439625, 0.01933116652071476, 0.008120954036712646, 0.018898552283644676, -0.02781573496758938, -0.0015688911080360413, 0.01001814380288124, -0.01256162766367197, 0.04147617146372795, -0.003318122122436762, -0.05506134778261185, -0.00765361450612545, -0.013524765148758888, -0.0009440470603294671, 0.003808296751230955, -0.002944635460153222, 0.018928730860352516, -0.016499172896146774, -0.012457083910703659, -0.04810977354645729, -0.042562201619148254, -0.0027531320229172707, -0.007823492400348186, -0.01735689491033554, -0.027854520827531815, 0.028096674010157585, 0.020572001114487648, -0.02454015240073204, 0.024828465655446053, -0.013188125565648079, 0.020776188001036644, -0.036696720868349075, -0.003382146591320634, 0.017074445262551308, 0.004299602936953306, 0.0060501606203615665, 0.050293706357479095, -0.019808856770396233, 0.01846352219581604, -0.025370026007294655, -0.035963818430900574, 0.03872019797563553, -0.0006409681518562138, 0.04516468569636345, 0.0008862895774655044, -0.046222034841775894, 0.06415778398513794, 0.051243532449007034, 0.009563746862113476, -0.028495464473962784, -0.006013296544551849, -0.03440999239683151, -0.0552770160138607, 0.029116898775100708, 0.01819590851664543, 0.007661504205316305, 0.012100235559046268, 0.0006726246792823076, 0.0392959825694561, 0.04292808473110199, 0.020255276933312416, 0.014198573306202888, 0.02425042912364006, -0.03028906136751175, 0.0010384024353697896, 0.03407132998108864, -0.015941133722662926, -0.037236250936985016, 0.011966729536652565, -0.010954214259982109, 0.019686885178089142, -0.017213761806488037, -0.02361948974430561, 0.0013780149165540934, 0.003782292129471898, -0.0007416642038151622, -0.048595719039440155, 0.02405020408332348, 0.04895791783928871, -0.04050466790795326, -0.014171783812344074, 0.024669092148542404, -0.00893061701208353, -0.014519643038511276, 0.03218887746334076, 0.03142125532031059, 0.02074555866420269, -0.024696294218301773, -0.025302091613411903, -0.03103824146091938, -0.04103543236851692, 0.032941292971372604, -0.019192662090063095, -0.05778250843286514, 0.021958857774734497, 0.024587364867329597, 0.018926141783595085, -0.011762569658458233, -0.06458035111427307, -0.013927849009633064, -0.07707586139440536, -0.014110843650996685, -0.0387924499809742, 0.07685770094394684, 0.016646960750222206, 0.03073783405125141, 0.01933945342898369, 0.01564965397119522, 0.02602366730570793, 0.006955007091164589, -0.04455423727631569, 0.020929865539073944, -0.02306634560227394, -0.020906006917357445, 0.01649363711476326, -0.041389305144548416, 0.02314687892794609, -0.02663087099790573, 0.008495306596159935, 0.003119579516351223, 0.05604390799999237, -0.012386878952383995, -0.000350233749486506, -0.025774605572223663, -0.013159145601093769, -0.03601214662194252, 0.01579233817756176, -0.027448059991002083, -0.01093385275453329, 0.0024544226471334696, 0.04323187470436096, 0.008919529616832733, -0.006856037303805351, -0.05580301210284233, 0.0473155602812767, 0.0026936200447380543, 0.010224130004644394, 0.04595465213060379, 0.004911897704005241, -0.04533110931515694, 0.01182382833212614, 0.03215673193335533, 0.06002150848507881, 0.02213018573820591, -0.011096262373030186, 0.02477969415485859, -0.03254013508558273, -0.03654106706380844, 0.03914273902773857, 0.003262503072619438, -0.02564801089465618, 0.0013481221394613385, 0.05279599875211716, 0.0420781709253788, -0.0417993888258934, 0.03527127578854561, 0.05867993086576462, 0.001771870767697692, -0.018576160073280334, -0.029052734375, -0.01077920850366354, -0.000011065158105338924, -0.014779970981180668, 0.01656806655228138, 0.004593227989971638, -0.0335783027112484, 0.0029558236710727215, -0.005725617986172438, -0.009323842823505402, -0.01802273839712143, 0.02218746207654476, 0.05028980225324631, 0.046862952411174774, 0.017798200249671936, -0.011135440319776535, -0.0003767168091144413, 0.003256566124036908, 0.010767164640128613, 0.01421278715133667, 0.021047407761216164, -0.06538565456867218, -0.03467041626572609, 0.018328288570046425, 0.03728426992893219, -0.03471938893198967, 0.06792569160461426, -0.04495915398001671, -0.031847115606069565, 0.04125891625881195, -0.008015228435397148, 0.026691991835832596, -0.008580268360674381, -0.013557166792452335, 0.0063962978310883045, -0.006790675222873688, -0.05028685927391052, 0.03190693259239197, -0.0027297160122543573, 0.022384226322174072, -0.02613738551735878, -0.015071181580424309, -0.024021463468670845, -0.0007702736766077578, -0.03018794022500515, 0.08424023538827896, -0.022562764585018158, -0.003487661248072982, -0.0024863206781446934, 0.008366566151380539, 0.022136446088552475, -0.07957809418439865, -0.003694926155731082, -0.021811770275235176, -0.05527462810277939, 0.0408632829785347, -0.006134072318673134, -0.01756172627210617, 0.03523160144686699, 0.014196881093084812, -0.0011177243432030082, -0.0037961637135595083, -0.0039384132251143456, 0.06255663931369781, 0.023879431188106537, 0.000988344894722104, 0.05727555975317955, 0.0488082617521286, -0.03907376155257225, 0.007016660179942846, 0.003445554757490754, 0.030525807291269302, -0.02974546141922474, 0.040970928966999054, -0.0565466471016407, -0.01929728128015995, -0.0483829565346241, 0.052581045776605606, -0.02244040183722973, 0.02865603193640709, -0.005499149207025766, -0.03355714678764343, 0.03568420559167862, 0.06666634231805801, -0.004220730159431696, -0.0009799550753086805, 0.03246061131358147, 0.016134800389409065, -0.0253705233335495, -0.017672333866357803, 0.018426183611154556, -0.0018467638874426484, 0.001818095101043582, 0.004252409562468529, -0.043287020176649094, 0.01439847331494093, -0.030161069706082344, 0.028728581964969635, 0.02429421804845333, -0.0043950011022388935, 0.0326676219701767, 0.01996973156929016, 0.03482872620224953, -0.0038086052518337965, -0.016269447281956673, 0.02271079830825329, 0.016076387837529182, -0.046106137335300446, 0.044436264783144, -0.032167717814445496, 0.05732700601220131, -0.04579450190067291, 0.028712676838040352, -0.053840380162000656, -0.04136199504137039, 0.0142876161262393, 0.01631561666727066, 0.008912119083106518, -0.04899986460804939, 0.0054691326804459095, 0.0011162047740072012, -0.028245294466614723, 0.009134581312537193, 0.01910294219851494, 0.015289783477783203, 0.013994152657687664, -0.000744886405300349, 0.042995527386665344, 0.0615851990878582, 0.02070315182209015, 0.01553625613451004, -0.011463879607617855, -0.004533690866082907, -0.004877450410276651, 0.0029625038150697947, 0.030621077865362167, -0.03278791904449463, -0.010295050218701363, 0.009562334045767784, -0.01326410099864006, 0.04917958006262779, -0.08690325170755386, -0.04946199432015419, -0.0062809474766254425, 0.04744390398263931, 0.05006130412220955, -0.0011472745100036263, 0.014856968075037003, -0.018294723704457283, 0.02887222357094288, -0.022349629551172256, 0.011785679496824741, 0.010359097272157669, -0.04732309654355049, 0.015758482739329338, 0.015035022050142288, -0.016544612124562263, -0.0035808058455586433, 0.08597470819950104, -0.04530544951558113, -0.018408779054880142, 0.02193918079137802, -0.02648492529988289, 0.05980593338608742, 0.029205255210399628, 0.019435478374361992, 0.0333298034965992, 0.0009913909016177058, -0.02561398223042488, -0.020066194236278534, -0.019877485930919647, -0.02391103282570839, 0.05888202041387558, -0.018792731687426567, 0.04244855418801308, 0.0078305434435606, -0.02639860473573208, 0.0061322362162172794, -0.013609918765723705, -0.037927307188510895, -0.026715988293290138, -0.02885802648961544, 0.05379611253738403, -0.030727259814739227, -0.00044028149568475783, 0.027977216988801956, 0.0015820659464225173, -0.013993789441883564, 0.06678754091262817, -0.009327837266027927, 0.04826607182621956, -0.0018273834139108658, -0.03567403927445412, -0.015411285683512688, 0.03311093524098396, -0.05739631876349449, 0.03075544349849224, -0.02139340154826641, -0.015124170109629631, 0.05338270589709282, 0.05357998609542847, 0.005296975839883089, -0.015734123066067696, 0.005646569188684225, -0.05340574309229851, 0.03238799795508385, 0.02430386282503605, -0.013023371808230877, 0.03635365143418312, 0.019451804459095, 0.04966093972325325, -0.008337731473147869, 0.04029165953397751, -0.027298446744680405, -0.032285887748003006, -0.028525933623313904, -0.0152401989325881, -0.012122128158807755, 0.031996943056583405, -0.00931941531598568, -0.02933122217655182, -0.0013003203785046935, -0.012950681149959564, 0.036401595920324326, -0.03366318717598915, 0.005348664242774248, -0.008385241962969303, 0.07055597007274628, 0.01289835013449192, 0.027378620579838753, -0.0005413313629105687, 0.014650809578597546, 0.12113284319639206, 0.03445281833410263, 0.034757278859615326, -0.06208248808979988, 0.02296769991517067, -0.03882657736539841, -0.010340474545955658, -0.027108769863843918, 0.020565001294016838, 0.02688920497894287, -0.02506529539823532, 0.04377090185880661, 0.07116323709487915, -0.020721478387713432, 0.01935570500791073, 0.06709254533052444, -0.036895547062158585, -0.020815104246139526, 0.0177217498421669, 0.030802516266703606, -0.002620273269712925, 0.004591687116771936, -0.041370999068021774, 0.005128118675202131, -0.002856598235666752, -0.03016565926373005, -0.04564598575234413, -0.03069796785712242, -0.0031029530800879, 0.011275237426161766, 0.0009749634191393852, 0.0061115301214158535, 0.03510642051696777, 0.02659209817647934, 0.05846472084522247, -0.021988756954669952, 0.00434616906568408, -0.04487339034676552, -0.01849837228655815, 0.03912513703107834, 0.007580092642456293, 0.0024268634151667356, -0.02817671000957489, -0.022077733650803566, -0.010892090387642384, -0.059857554733753204, -0.03999168053269386, 0.01983393356204033, -0.02516578696668148, -0.007935626432299614, -0.0029069699812680483, 0.026276791468262672, 0.026476137340068817, -0.04181455075740814, 0.006282282993197441, 0.005198274739086628, 0.021958129480481148, -0.02119242399930954, 0.007921240292489529, -0.02101755142211914, 0.03300164267420769, 0.020786549896001816, 0.017535096034407616, 0.02708338014781475, -0.024706920608878136, -0.04032598063349724, -0.024385418742895126, 0.038632288575172424, 0.03128815069794655, -0.06536466628313065, 0.0004125946434214711, 0.023943299427628517, -0.018201803788542747, -0.006248281337320805, -0.016561562195420265, 0.005610041785985231, 0.003120419569313526, 0.014873229898512363, -0.02482028119266033, -0.0018406423041597009, -0.034630682319402695, 0.0024187720846384764, -0.006614780984818935, 0.005991783458739519, -0.03656899556517601, -0.042387813329696655, 0.01863357052206993, 0.026858223602175713, -0.001928430632688105, -0.03630944341421127, -0.005139590706676245, 0.07836546003818512, 0.02499816194176674, -0.045470211654901505, -0.012687419541180134, 0.014094439335167408, -0.03555630147457123, 0.02267024852335453, -0.00022283416183199733, 0.07571840286254883, 0.0024970821104943752, -0.001332941697910428, 0.023359712213277817, 0.009537083096802235, 0.015307851135730743, 0.017512604594230652, 0.0008301418856717646, -0.029306594282388687, -0.007963157258927822, -0.016498615965247154, -0.019954312592744827, -0.019919032230973244, -0.0025286246091127396, -0.0038944350089877844, 0.003472629003226757, -0.01496296375989914, 0.00993240624666214, 0.015258640050888062, 0.01180354505777359, -0.034210413694381714, 0.001382222049869597, -0.03355034440755844, 0.04248641058802605, -0.004955850075930357, -0.006823623087257147, 0.00013832925469614565, 0.008479819633066654, 0.04126162827014923, 0.003547420958057046, -0.022908376529812813, 0.004037823528051376, 0.04469094052910805, 0.03635656088590622, 0.05662060156464577, 0.014328119345009327, 0.03666617348790169, 0.034954193979501724, 0.01727057807147503, -0.05388615280389786, -0.011896546930074692, 0.015124957077205181, -0.03384485840797424, -0.07832135260105133, 0.0022985052783042192, -0.021325359120965004, 0.01959586888551712, 0.0104512395337224, -0.0030884176958352327, -0.04069320484995842, 0.04389447346329689, -0.02174227684736252, -0.004100936930626631, -0.013663711957633495, -0.0002677465963643044, -0.00032607544562779367, 0.03152161091566086, -0.011371674947440624, 0.02252350188791752, 0.02982722781598568, 0.018629521131515503, 0.011245861649513245, -0.008079219609498978, -0.011245755478739738, -0.00959811545908451, -0.01712396740913391, -0.0015966449864208698, -0.010241986252367496, -0.009624744765460491, 0.022474106401205063, 0.06164270639419556, 0.002308264374732971, 0.024259796366095543, 0.0073281703516840935, -0.013566900044679642, -0.08530989289283752, -0.029503462836146355, 0.007010677829384804, -0.008914534002542496, 0.03020239993929863, -0.06801928579807281, -0.006531211547553539, 0.0022653311025351286, -0.04749766364693642, 0.025204965844750404, -0.016465909779071808, 0.009809155948460102, -0.010547461919486523, -0.05027095228433609, -0.01658231019973755, -0.01733637973666191, 0.0185309536755085, 0.041249871253967285, 0.018217749893665314, 0.01686677895486355, 0.023649228736758232, -0.043061766773462296, -0.020339258015155792, -0.009481607005000114, 0.004592255689203739, -0.03635609894990921, -0.001365005155093968, -0.03257068246603012, -0.04282156378030777, 0.04107142239809036, -0.0149940000846982, 0.017367679625749588, -0.019927142187952995, 0.05262017250061035, -0.007488874718546867, 0.032497745007276535, 0.052414070814847946, 0.017012853175401688, 0.04170858487486839, 0.0001882498327177018, 0.0014151560608297586, 0.001222729799337685, -0.009935436770319939, 0.007267296779900789, 0.046182941645383835, 0.002759945811703801, 0.010473343543708324, 0.02377781830728054, -0.009733929298818111, -0.0074541871435940266, -0.009176652878522873, 0.007088673301041126, 0.03027825988829136, -0.01950276829302311, 0.04056093841791153, -0.0023683253675699234, -0.013845977373421192, 0.021620094776153564, 0.03677146136760712, -0.016451135277748108, -0.019756121560931206, -0.04442877694964409, -0.030747778713703156, -0.009383387863636017, -0.00452060392126441, -0.06989940255880356, -0.04421253129839897, -0.004093256779015064, -0.033257607370615005, -0.017065230756998062, -0.017412321642041206, 0.0017135664820671082, -0.023602642118930817, 0.056456319987773895, -0.024191228672862053, 0.042134497314691544, -0.025994230061769485, 0.001119812368415296, -0.006359874736517668, -0.04405025765299797, 0.042019881308078766, -0.003219595644623041, -0.051405079662799835, -0.020963285118341446, 0.018531350418925285, -0.027664242312312126, 0.007522151339799166, 0.06962817907333374, 0.0019275962840765715, 0.03073217160999775, 0.014152921736240387, 0.03099706768989563, 0.011214286088943481, -0.02357199415564537, 0.022014131769537926, -0.01631278730928898, -0.025176074355840683, 0.014298684895038605, -0.024743912741541862, 0.039432208985090256, 0.03344157710671425, -0.03699777275323868, -0.01255148183554411, -0.009578966535627842, 0.036907654255628586, -0.0008874850464053452, -0.004794684704393148, -0.02979002334177494, -0.03222205117344856, 0.016631949692964554, -0.0041997358202934265, -0.008727307431399822, 0.0029845417011529207, -0.024068592116236687, -0.06878567487001419, 0.004008457530289888, -0.01752648502588272, -0.04788782447576523, -0.00952885951846838, 0.026115382090210915, -0.007581844460219145, -0.025490332394838333, 0.01631762646138668, 0.00044205598533153534, -0.0384976901113987, 0.022106463089585304, 0.036364082247018814, 0.0036768661811947823, 0.019165774807333946, 0.0027860242407768965, 0.012441199272871017, 0.031379472464323044, 0.013603316619992256, 0.028826134279370308, 0.022592421621084213, 0.005622436758130789, -0.015757247805595398, 0.034535963088274, 0.018538186326622963, 0.004022807348519564, 0.024658353999257088, -0.026934223249554634, 0.028460800647735596, 0.025985265150666237, -0.05687021091580391, -0.004552766215056181, -0.0324861966073513, -0.017256490886211395, -0.022798778489232063, 0.01396486721932888, 0.06523333489894867, -0.008163714781403542, -0.002598579740151763, -0.02208249270915985, -0.016830213367938995, 0.00003849452696158551, -0.024920612573623657, -0.021961402148008347, 0.041185542941093445, -0.014848452992737293, -0.03874054178595543, -0.017333853989839554, -0.0011833193711936474, 0.017947982996702194, -0.025088362395763397, 0.013259774073958397, -0.030341381207108498, -0.0022565603721886873, 0.020860182121396065, -0.014424633234739304, -0.06864641606807709, -0.03934364765882492, 0.04492003470659256, 0.029464125633239746, 0.013405941426753998, 0.017660727724432945, -0.05110146477818489, 0.02439127489924431, 0.07516413182020187, -0.037823185324668884, -0.030658412724733353, -0.029255911707878113, -0.0031447161454707384, -0.02021625265479088, 0.0268910713493824 ]
<p>I'm familiar with very basic plotting in R, but I'm not sure how best to create the reasonably-complicated plot described below.</p> <p>I have developed a density estimation method that essentially fits an empirical distribution to multiple univariate samples, under distinct conditions. To be clear, let $\mathbf{x}_i^\mathrm{j}$ be a vector of univariate values for the $i^\mathrm{th}$ sample under condition $j$. My method allows me to approximate the distribution from which the values in $\mathbf{x}_i^\mathrm{j}$ were drawn. Although in principle, $j$ could take on many values, in practice I am interested in just two conditions (e.g., $j$ specifies whether the sample is for a pre- or post-intervention condition).</p> <p>In particular, the method I have developed attempts to establish correspondences between common features of the fitted density estimates (e.g., modes). I want to be able to plot curves for all the density estimates in such a way as to allow comparison between the two conditions, and between corresponding features of the distributions.</p> <p>I would like to create a grid of subplots (e.g., <em>m</em> × <em>n</em> if there are a total of 2 × <em>m</em> × <em>n</em> samples; note that <em>m</em> and <em>n</em> are only specified so that the overall plot has a convenient aspect ratio, they do not relate to the design of the experiment etc.). Each subplot would show two curves: one for the distribution underlying $\mathbf{x}_i^\mathrm{pre}$ and the other for $\mathbf{x}_i^\mathrm{post}$. Further, to allow the correspondences to be compared, I would like to color the line used to draw the curves using a “rainbow” (or other color map), so that one could, for example, look at the red regions of two curves and visually determine whether they do in fact correspond. To this end, I can provide vectors (<em>x</em>, p(<em>x</em>), <em>c</em>), where <em>x</em> is an arbitrary value on the horizontal axis of the density estimate plot, p(<em>x</em>) is the density estimate for <em>x</em>, and <em>c</em> is a value in (0, 1), such that a particular value of <em>c</em> should correspond across all density estimates, and should, therefore, be plotted in the same color (e.g., a value of 0.2 might sit at the peak of the mode of the distributions).</p> <p>Lastly, in order to allow the two curves in each subplot to be distinguished, I'd like to be able to style each differently, for example by using a thin line for the pre condition and a thick line for the post condition.</p> <p>Thanks.</p>
31,078
[ -0.034968845546245575, 0.010456942021846771, 0.02055888995528221, -0.02084660902619362, 0.031521204859018326, 0.017708376049995422, 0.01222180388867855, 0.00102138239890337, 0.028311926871538162, -0.05644272267818451, 0.048477668315172195, 0.050075240433216095, 0.08480630069971085, 0.040789686143398285, 0.0023886291310191154, -0.021960748359560966, -0.01212708093225956, 0.019456109032034874, -0.018937913700938225, -0.04765651002526283, 0.05467313528060913, -0.006794131826609373, 0.021895838901400566, -0.013558978214859962, -0.02717401459813118, 0.06940489262342453, 0.01854853332042694, -0.019674129784107208, -0.017819790169596672, 0.08448906987905502, -0.03443429246544838, -0.025187039747834206, 0.0005314919981174171, 0.04711742326617241, 0.0126494774594903, 0.01499470416456461, 0.02768654190003872, -0.031478263437747955, 0.007687595207244158, 0.020708326250314713, -0.05937545374035835, -0.006606387440115213, 0.0024503895547240973, 0.02700970135629177, 0.008846631273627281, 0.027930816635489464, -0.020114334300160408, -0.019729096442461014, 0.04625164717435837, -0.007879534736275673, 0.07858211547136307, 0.057958826422691345, 0.020055774599313736, 0.05444392189383507, -0.06957218050956726, -0.011272299103438854, 0.05386282131075859, 0.0863213762640953, 0.029030075296759605, -0.07366647571325302, -0.00042263060458935797, -0.03298846259713173, -0.0021957154385745525, -0.038347095251083374, -0.044041361659765244, 0.02994482032954693, 0.016569834202528, 0.008764578960835934, -0.0008791782893240452, -0.04850681871175766, -0.0013432863634079695, 0.019383620470762253, 0.03232119232416153, -0.023306038230657578, -0.013798612169921398, -0.024782896041870117, 0.02638390101492405, 0.01331297867000103, 0.032487429678440094, 0.007235102355480194, 0.02027914486825466, 0.030969219282269478, -0.016294924542307854, 0.026125086471438408, 0.01526256650686264, -0.002994300564751029, 0.07583346962928772, -0.00282355397939682, 0.03385462239384651, -0.01657005026936531, -0.029868267476558685, 0.014635511673986912, 0.058914631605148315, 0.007714456878602505, -0.028951570391654968, -0.012201562523841858, -0.014877887442708015, 0.0077594066970050335, -0.03615950047969818, -0.04027413949370384, -0.027958469465374947, -0.05671098455786705, -0.006016253959387541, 0.02561684139072895, 0.0011921083787456155, -0.005614245776087046, 0.0046764095313847065, -0.04049824923276901, -0.006391302682459354, 0.006834793370217085, -0.0111250514164567, 0.04162511229515076, 0.03144274652004242, -0.007868994027376175, 0.001799052464775741, -0.027868257835507393, 0.0004954052856191993, 0.004777475725859404, 0.045246656984090805, 0.06331461668014526, 0.0464090071618557, -0.029385749250650406, 0.02264723740518093, -0.050859563052654266, -0.07674562931060791, -0.003914534579962492, 0.03336721286177635, 0.019802972674369812, -0.02442000061273575, 0.005416442174464464, 0.0000630622380413115, -0.021541103720664978, 0.04004354029893875, 0.015098151750862598, 0.012669187970459461, 0.028846118599176407, -0.07624942064285278, -0.08780278265476227, 0.0083532789722085, -0.011602099984884262, 0.005404147785156965, -0.05374254286289215, -0.003090124810114503, 0.04049206152558327, 0.03341192007064819, 0.00008549945778213441, 0.01954643428325653, -0.0007002738420851529, 0.047582123428583145, 0.03142402693629265, -0.020022347569465637, 0.006929344963282347, -0.021711187437176704, -0.007595445495098829, -0.03837664797902107, -0.03672213479876518, 0.03678637370467186, 0.014788102358579636, -0.02581075020134449, 0.01571718230843544, 0.07078088819980621, 0.011435703374445438, -0.010999434627592564, -0.011534249410033226, -0.008984255604445934, -0.008406076580286026, 0.058797065168619156, -0.01677798107266426, 0.015991713851690292, 0.009460977278649807, -0.05457553267478943, 0.03306901082396507, 0.00783807784318924, 0.030024442821741104, 0.06310095638036728, -0.039760738611221313, 0.012927519157528877, -0.013399100862443447, -0.027052875608205795, 0.04927487298846245, 0.0008332125726155937, -0.038622528314590454, -0.030314965173602104, -0.03359620273113251, 0.04288746416568756, 0.010771839879453182, 0.024273764342069626, -0.026470210403203964, 0.05649684742093086, -0.04850687086582184, -0.027570785954594612, -0.036477770656347275, 0.013175182975828648, -0.02445444092154503, -0.07737798243761063, 0.024219000712037086, 0.012163023464381695, 0.013546349480748177, 0.022772861644625664, -0.03855704888701439, -0.0146326944231987, 0.014919809065759182, 0.04680680111050606, -0.02727608010172844, -0.033962927758693695, 0.03183837980031967, 0.031084256246685982, 0.015035079792141914, 0.04313897714018822, -0.032602231949567795, -0.037427254021167755, -0.01480016764253378, -0.031900692731142044, 0.018165893852710724, -0.003436656668782234, 0.00030327707645483315, 0.01689775288105011, -0.004180239513516426, -0.005659917369484901, 0.044751476496458054, -0.04994524270296097, 0.03327902406454086, 0.08064242452383041, -0.01483190804719925, 0.012577475979924202, -0.012269522063434124, -0.011790139600634575, 0.047315601259469986, -0.03312412649393082, 0.002010233933106065, -0.021606775000691414, -0.004896161146461964, 0.05833892896771431, 0.03573719412088394, -0.04804760217666626, 0.02336931973695755, 0.040824491530656815, 0.015775339677929878, -0.008606335148215294, 0.028516622260212898, -0.020777063444256783, -0.04547354206442833, -0.007966790348291397, 0.03477153554558754, 0.013479192741215229, -0.04074105620384216, 0.01772613823413849, -0.003941514529287815, 0.029140911996364594, -0.03481265529990196, -0.0064024971798062325, 0.025773020461201668, -0.05215277522802353, -0.0060740988701581955, -0.023235704749822617, 0.023508548736572266, 0.05284642055630684, 0.006817980203777552, -0.012927185744047165, 0.023389767855405807, -0.01895076222717762, -0.0013745622709393501, 0.04451243579387665, -0.013716616667807102, 0.00864623486995697, 0.03594854101538658, -0.03786291182041168, -0.019656339660286903, 0.011782411485910416, -0.026823224499821663, 0.023824525997042656, -0.029568156227469444, -0.05447093024849892, -0.013594493269920349, 0.025123989209532738, 0.031620170921087265, 0.02489786222577095, -0.004056924022734165, -0.033223122358322144, -0.006866236217319965, 0.03565977141261101, 0.031328264623880386, 0.060786519199609756, 0.0003729633754119277, -0.030913153663277626, 0.007062127348035574, -0.05121977999806404, -0.019067740067839622, 0.016929544508457184, 0.019666606560349464, -0.05430135875940323, 0.019212592393159866, 0.005958842113614082, -0.061645135283470154, -0.01825265772640705, -0.014146489091217518, -0.018343642354011536, -0.03308819606900215, -0.02737705036997795, 0.06538716703653336, -0.0015724832192063332, -0.06960676610469818, 0.03198648616671562, -0.019917327910661697, -0.0016982718370854855, -0.03178859502077103, 0.01632731780409813, 0.03426355868577957, 0.009101295843720436, 0.03320847079157829, 0.049614232033491135, -0.00043814454693347216, -0.01998061127960682, -0.06319611519575119, -0.039973050355911255, -0.026272520422935486, 0.03047303296625614, 0.07807794213294983, 0.0457434356212616, 0.02566467970609665, 0.03404174745082855, 0.008577495813369751, -0.021557044237852097, -0.05502140894532204, -0.005510931368917227, -0.031147856265306473, -0.00982241053134203, 0.02472219616174698, 0.0003041871532332152, 0.0077883112244307995, 0.02498776465654373, 0.014492228627204895, -0.002632737159729004, 0.05888906121253967, 0.02140873298048973, 0.008739537559449673, 0.06110655516386032, 0.010911975055932999, 0.0015693285968154669, 0.02647475153207779, 0.015850823372602463, -0.022626345977187157, -0.005137952975928783, 0.010940620675683022, -0.028487542644143105, 0.011863638646900654, -0.04652567207813263, 0.02761669084429741, 0.017714722082018852, 0.030105995014309883, -0.014789299108088017, 0.006318450905382633, 0.009890414774417877, -0.028796400874853134, -0.008905114606022835, 0.05477166548371315, 0.05211334303021431, -0.019032707437872887, -0.026766624301671982, 0.07508031278848648, 0.033731766045093536, -0.047593969851732254, 0.003976814914494753, -0.0026686780620366335, -0.0008438499644398689, 0.01564273238182068, -0.0614292286336422, -0.030087675899267197, 0.016614142805337906, 0.039968401193618774, 0.02203601785004139, -0.0008032801561057568, -0.011472532525658607, 0.040421128273010254, -0.01642114669084549, -0.03302634134888649, -0.03101287968456745, 0.0574045330286026, 0.004696632735431194, 0.06505218148231506, -0.014951108023524284, -0.015117441304028034, 0.00814605038613081, -0.009040634147822857, -0.060983918607234955, 0.030904652550816536, 0.02801981195807457, 0.02528255060315132, -0.02258986607193947, -0.014646991156041622, 0.03312602639198303, -0.0067198812030255795, 0.021885208785533905, -0.011076315306127071, 0.03366823494434357, -0.01887037418782711, -0.008174923248589039, -0.02856157347559929, -0.029738016426563263, -0.024658584967255592, 0.03732916712760925, 0.024525059387087822, -0.007935364730656147, 0.046699974685907364, -0.0070530627854168415, -0.0003072042600251734, -0.019395532086491585, 0.006651587784290314, 0.023733310401439667, 0.017881643027067184, 0.02790830470621586, -0.0074544185772538185, 0.02118518389761448, -0.029431898146867752, -0.009087511338293552, -0.007169312797486782, 0.0676250085234642, 0.04862473905086517, -0.0445912666618824, 0.012233637273311615, 0.022318847477436066, -0.015763845294713974, -0.006401668768376112, 0.06653130799531937, -0.026386184617877007, -0.008544244803488255, 0.01576138101518154, 0.031857091933488846, -0.022172430530190468, 0.024696316570043564, 0.033946406096220016, 0.046467460691928864, 0.0003313907654955983, -0.04447920620441437, -0.004491592291742563, 0.0033674149308353662, 0.04282436519861221, 0.003949654754251242, 0.03248588740825653, 0.026815375313162804, 0.003602370386943221, 0.03151058033108711, 0.03913039714097977, -0.04453067108988762, -0.016600018367171288, 0.020205240696668625, 0.04339689761400223, -0.008982639759778976, -0.010505118407309055, 0.014759218320250511, 0.033291324973106384, 0.044483572244644165, -0.01460396870970726, 0.024116212502121925, -0.1114107295870781, 0.01075185276567936, 0.04217073321342468, 0.018598616123199463, 0.00038512604078277946, 0.0016455521108582616, -0.07663065195083618, -0.015824351459741592, 0.023541145026683807, -0.02326703630387783, -0.004805766511708498, -0.037232931703329086, 0.0073383222334086895, -0.018622873350977898, -0.0271769929677248, -0.04803014174103737, 0.012143690139055252, -0.01477192435413599, 0.015852399170398712, -0.010530531406402588, -0.01705787517130375, -0.039364978671073914, 0.012204301543533802, 0.02794034592807293, 0.049117978662252426, 0.0002792680752463639, -0.009058376774191856, -0.024673843756318092, -0.023785805329680443, 0.007202484179288149, -0.06276264041662216, 0.02287774160504341, 0.00619695195928216, -0.011513933539390564, 0.06358605623245239, -0.013971536420285702, -0.010786756873130798, 0.02149094268679619, -0.023738449439406395, 0.024899976328015327, 0.0397019200026989, -0.01855262741446495, 0.06276948004961014, 0.0450652651488781, 0.03052515722811222, 0.022817978635430336, 0.032330214977264404, 0.012913462705910206, -0.005778122693300247, -0.017143944278359413, 0.015212418511509895, -0.010185722261667252, -0.039240941405296326, -0.03249798342585564, -0.036242976784706116, 0.005345234181731939, 0.0306482445448637, -0.020730620250105858, 0.007770176511257887, -0.0025361720472574234, -0.03159814327955246, 0.03585487976670265, 0.03120659850537777, -0.008910473436117172, -0.004604739136993885, -0.01154626626521349, 0.026539791375398636, 0.012276814319193363, 0.0062175532802939415, 0.038992855697870255, -0.025863664224743843, -0.011435980908572674, 0.016294250264763832, -0.06420491635799408, 0.003093116683885455, -0.047153037041425705, 0.010693935677409172, -0.01496997382491827, -0.004827002063393593, 0.03945109620690346, 0.0013394106645137072, 0.06611593812704086, 0.005717434920370579, -0.028120988979935646, -0.011536824516952038, 0.040694840252399445, 0.010306764394044876, 0.010671649128198624, -0.0023717370349913836, 0.008636748418211937, 0.004893056116998196, -0.01094303373247385, -0.06170075386762619, -0.002298373496159911, -0.022556664422154427, 0.005263384897261858, -0.034133028239011765, -0.03525108844041824, -0.029749324545264244, 0.022715793922543526, -0.00534778693690896, 0.0033142189495265484, 0.0011124972952529788, 0.004536069929599762, -0.020236283540725708, -0.025714561343193054, 0.04018083214759827, 0.031481169164180756, -0.04732144623994827, 0.013300570659339428, 0.00861500296741724, -0.027809573337435722, -0.016457580029964447, 0.010124236345291138, -0.04095994308590889, -0.03577633947134018, 0.0012244958197697997, -0.0644179955124855, 0.035419296473264694, 0.023944659158587456, -0.025982003659009933, -0.03538651391863823, -0.015965620055794716, -0.03181184455752373, -0.02139216661453247, -0.06003231555223465, -0.039917510002851486, -0.042764049023389816, 0.00306184240616858, -0.0327906608581543, -0.01925041526556015, 0.010505883023142815, -0.005189687013626099, -0.0014361580833792686, -0.005594403017312288, -0.019767457619309425, 0.014522889629006386, 0.07686642557382584, -0.013017931953072548, -0.014691234566271305, 0.03239756077528, -0.001017197733744979, 0.026917042210698128, -0.027028178796172142, 0.01367679052054882, 0.014095593243837357, 0.025478873401880264, -0.004448958206921816, -0.033536724746227264, -0.03925146162509918, -0.007217673119157553, 0.0465298630297184, 0.017451055347919464, 0.057279910892248154, 0.046319082379341125, -0.03694499656558037, 0.02169862762093544, -0.028791924938559532, -0.009656480513513088, -0.024974947795271873, 0.010969778522849083, 0.06394017487764359, -0.03227011114358902, -0.0367254801094532, 0.030222386121749878, 0.029412418603897095, 0.0010902403155341744, 0.034897200763225555, -0.020602449774742126, 0.034735746681690216, 0.03564877808094025, -0.031088130548596382, -0.036330509930849075, 0.011095225811004639, -0.05155684053897858, 0.023528221994638443, -0.0569588728249073, -0.04065178334712982, 0.004634201060980558, 0.07275652885437012, -0.03311217203736305, -0.02190070040524006, -0.0091325081884861, -0.017694706097245216, 0.034535571932792664, 0.012801072560250759, -0.015400051139295101, 0.006322988774627447, -0.000004313253612053813, 0.027826694771647453, -0.05050015449523926, 0.0211845263838768, -0.006083390675485134, -0.05633504316210747, -0.026091700419783592, -0.021840432658791542, -0.02688809297978878, 0.06036187335848808, -0.008417205885052681, -0.019759204238653183, 0.022330746054649353, 0.006864696275442839, 0.04487287625670433, -0.01763315685093403, -0.013260133564472198, -0.014298687689006329, 0.05527542904019356, -0.010077285580337048, 0.02171682007610798, -0.005103485193103552, -0.03495924174785614, 0.13944806158542633, 0.0573185458779335, 0.048328518867492676, -0.0440148189663887, 0.018265048041939735, 0.010327516123652458, -0.014360037632286549, 0.004927709698677063, 0.015927299857139587, 0.03866082802414894, -0.04663638398051262, 0.004994163289666176, 0.028905602172017097, 0.005555262323468924, 0.029225798323750496, 0.05025498941540718, -0.0017602589214220643, -0.00020029430743306875, -0.03612108156085014, 0.012019909918308258, 0.0006501184543594718, 0.023449258878827095, -0.03406548127532005, 0.00579894008114934, 0.024176860228180885, -0.009990014135837555, -0.04750548303127289, -0.04943530261516571, 0.02694607339799404, 0.033518992364406586, -0.02054554596543312, -0.007323542144149542, 0.04347766190767288, 0.01648958958685398, 0.021518215537071228, -0.0025517605245113373, 0.02168775349855423, -0.04674872010946274, 0.03201748803257942, 0.027498507872223854, 0.019243543967604637, 0.03230781480669975, -0.034430041909217834, -0.01030724961310625, -0.027004467323422432, -0.024705564603209496, -0.06621810793876648, 0.03171829879283905, 0.024779176339507103, -0.060713957995176315, -0.025638332590460777, 0.03683789074420929, 0.029131459072232246, -0.035552117973566055, -0.05528002604842186, 0.007767312694340944, 0.04369818791747093, -0.02327750064432621, -0.0012893647653982043, -0.028205523267388344, 0.004393746145069599, 0.01701001264154911, 0.044191841036081314, 0.025864003226161003, -0.05781959742307663, -0.024579429998993874, -0.0033364740666002035, 0.04121054336428642, 0.016902990639209747, -0.0033023471478372812, -0.04292166605591774, -0.007961779832839966, -0.025618957355618477, -0.034373845905065536, 0.009860742837190628, 0.03482722491025925, 0.019702346995472908, 0.04523854702711105, -0.06269963085651398, 0.005208429414778948, -0.04694833979010582, -0.006015968509018421, -0.013675798662006855, -0.0065514929592609406, -0.025103891268372536, -0.012595990672707558, 0.053238775581121445, 0.026518061757087708, 0.032037463039159775, -0.014187666587531567, 0.013464641757309437, 0.06572500616312027, 0.03789164125919342, -0.021689504384994507, -0.010982670821249485, 0.020022911950945854, 0.00046576838940382004, 0.00041707680793479085, -0.029006266966462135, 0.016093648970127106, -0.0005679427995346487, 0.017827467992901802, 0.023999111726880074, 0.04830273985862732, 0.005890225991606712, -0.017748940736055374, -0.01558928657323122, -0.05503704771399498, 0.022936426103115082, -0.014565318822860718, 0.008977625519037247, -0.017980843782424927, 0.004084071610122919, -0.03235854580998421, -0.024823924526572227, 0.005403840448707342, -0.05164455622434616, -0.0158003531396389, -0.03947736695408821, 0.014374595135450363, -0.022804223001003265, -0.0058789304457604885, -0.0279846154153347, -0.029614150524139404, -0.013132571242749691, -0.0379982627928257, 0.014259302988648415, 0.002017037710174918, 0.007000785320997238, -0.03912520781159401, -0.0012982150074094534, 0.029112569987773895, 0.027504008263349533, 0.010641766712069511, -0.0035164046566933393, 0.036630913615226746, 0.04148472100496292, 0.013734403997659683, 0.01151284296065569, -0.012142425402998924, -0.008712745271623135, -0.03786623850464821, -0.029967285692691803, 0.0019560230430215597, -0.02042277902364731, 0.03399503231048584, 0.009711867198348045, 0.007354080211371183, -0.031025100499391556, 0.02442360855638981, -0.02688627876341343, -0.015903351828455925, -0.012709524482488632, 0.0015334293711930513, 0.0015369531465694308, -0.016643641516566277, 0.016148032620549202, -0.02183287963271141, 0.00306115229614079, 0.02021331526339054, 0.02005234733223915, 0.002319413935765624, -0.033378735184669495, 0.008108874782919884, -0.03724677488207817, 0.018016984686255455, -0.00603336188942194, -0.0063872202299535275, 0.02447965368628502, 0.05991143733263016, -0.03599599376320839, 0.03536618500947952, -0.004553799517452717, 0.006791076622903347, -0.08644527941942215, -0.004404633771628141, 0.025742877274751663, -0.013925319537520409, 0.014113345183432102, -0.05264545977115631, -0.006269414909183979, 0.01605723425745964, -0.023899948224425316, 0.0434977225959301, -0.0017529340693727136, -0.018234096467494965, -0.018916012719273567, 0.023653555661439896, -0.038164734840393066, 0.011450715363025665, 0.013545721769332886, 0.003806810360401869, 0.059875838458538055, 0.03160926327109337, -0.023707063868641853, -0.031056463718414307, -0.04605354741215706, 0.015020076185464859, 0.01436189841479063, -0.07145632058382034, 0.031015748158097267, -0.019035179167985916, -0.01418476365506649, 0.018923435360193253, -0.0014710943214595318, 0.028639432042837143, -0.01500417198985815, -0.0014084429712966084, 0.01361811626702547, 0.046822238713502884, 0.024534715339541435, -0.024992138147354126, -0.01937553845345974, -0.02309512160718441, 0.032962750643491745, -0.019517848268151283, -0.04087556153535843, 0.03633136302232742, 0.0724322572350502, 0.011185204610228539, -0.05143135040998459, 0.0025288378819823265, 0.005530878901481628, -0.028307698667049408, -0.0018929059151560068, 0.013361655175685883, 0.014450599439442158, -0.0032016318291425705, 0.04460008814930916, -0.060196734964847565, -0.005579485557973385, -0.008024371229112148, 0.0055303508415818214, 0.0029233377426862717, 0.03742942214012146, -0.024495897814631462, -0.05086301267147064, -0.00011310439003864303, -0.032415349036455154, -0.01474752277135849, -0.05049678310751915, 0.01443452388048172, -0.03747563809156418, 0.01716919057071209, -0.02840770035982132, -0.004721896722912788, -0.03119944967329502, 0.017464328557252884, -0.015246134251356125, -0.012482847087085247, -0.006017736159265041, -0.0034805312752723694, 0.013187341392040253, -0.05018998309969902, 0.036904122680425644, 0.016552221029996872, -0.03450224548578262, -0.02246159315109253, -0.023214438930153847, -0.022160449996590614, 0.014143818989396095, 0.048325154930353165, 0.02020907960832119, 0.007941996678709984, -0.014309692196547985, 0.04259252920746803, 0.05117613077163696, -0.07015448808670044, 0.034314628690481186, -0.0072214966639876366, -0.016216717660427094, 0.01006276160478592, 0.027871372178196907, -0.009303328581154346, 0.020551146939396858, 0.03824125602841377, -0.010999985039234161, 0.0013124427059665322, 0.026782937347888947, -0.026361441239714622, 0.014512325637042522, -0.07904636859893799, -0.03335125744342804, 0.0123064573854208, 0.021195610985159874, 0.0029620670247823, 0.01363214012235403, -0.008101397193968296, -0.09183777868747711, 0.0156856756657362, -0.044046103954315186, -0.04807742312550545, 0.010289019905030727, -0.011672778986394405, -0.010583700612187386, -0.04979445040225983, 0.009495657868683338, -0.026746084913611412, -0.014366691000759602, -0.012994425371289253, 0.02921733818948269, 0.034857381135225296, 0.024682315066456795, 0.0002777049958240241, 0.014302045106887817, -0.024784589186310768, -0.014386335387825966, 0.021644294261932373, -0.026770826429128647, 0.041969817131757736, 0.012419704347848892, 0.017092738300561905, 0.0024327293504029512, -0.037059977650642395, 0.006066778674721718, -0.0021632215939462185, 0.010956629179418087, -0.005989227909594774, -0.018261022865772247, 0.04387883096933365, -0.01516787800937891, 0.011159476824104786, -0.004466875456273556, -0.024259157478809357, 0.020723482593894005, -0.031617529690265656, 0.009494876489043236, -0.036020427942276, -0.032955996692180634, -0.04090135544538498, 0.014013220556080341, -0.01991831324994564, 0.03165571019053459, -0.012516755610704422, 0.07096473127603531, 0.022471079602837563, -0.028535787016153336, 0.02500213123857975, 0.025717047974467278, 0.05062606558203697, 0.019433407112956047, 0.010833820328116417, 0.04589509591460228, -0.0039881146512925625, 0.014207884669303894, -0.04931379482150078, 0.013204080052673817, -0.002706751460209489, 0.017282139509916306, -0.02053471840918064, 0.005036306567490101, 0.0032428705599159002, 0.04974918067455292, -0.05123620107769966, -0.06078261137008667, -0.016004366800189018, 0.000294008816126734, 0.05149948596954346, 0.007161117624491453 ]
<blockquote> <p><strong>Possible Duplicate:</strong><br> <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/26970/validation-techniques-for-hierarchical-model">Validation techniques for hierarchical model</a> </p> </blockquote> <p>I already posted <a href="http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/135641/validation-techniques-for-hierarchical-model">this to Math.SE</a>, but I realized this would probably be a better place to post to. </p> <p>I have a hierarchical model that I need to validate. My model is as follows: we have a collection of $λ_i$ that we draw from ${\rm Gamma}(α,β)$. Then, we draw our data point yi from ${\rm Poisson}(λ_i)$. I get a joint distribution of $α,β,λ_i$ via a Gibbs sampler combined with a Metropolis step. This part is fine, no problems with implementation. My question is how do I validate such a model? I have my set of data, each one corresponding to one particular $λ_i$. I'm not sure what statistical tests/ other steps I should take to check are. Thanks!</p>
49,336
[ -0.03709207475185394, -0.0099651413038373, 0.025001157075166702, -0.037011921405792236, 0.03901054710149765, -0.031184040009975433, -0.008150364272296429, -0.037887558341026306, 0.0592859722673893, -0.036306675523519516, 0.08623556792736053, 0.02676638588309288, 0.08297859132289886, 0.030889885500073433, 0.02492593228816986, -0.007731735240668058, -0.010547776706516743, -0.014582470059394836, -0.0054404172115027905, -0.012892581522464752, 0.003044865094125271, -0.0037167579866945744, 0.0072608343325555325, -0.025582248345017433, -0.013466271571815014, 0.0060756090097129345, 0.03126966208219528, 0.002853082725778222, -0.009581550024449825, 0.04987046867609024, -0.05654650554060936, -0.02600172907114029, 0.003981995861977339, 0.04374295473098755, -0.00235455809161067, 0.021060174331068993, -0.011393717490136623, -0.02742493525147438, -0.017495620995759964, 0.016744576394557953, -0.04264363273978233, -0.00549970893189311, 0.010436346754431725, 0.04800871014595032, -0.015582265332341194, 0.018269749358296394, -0.03527660295367241, 0.011757719330489635, 0.05549003183841705, -0.028356797993183136, 0.03941631317138672, 0.007368003483861685, 0.024247433990240097, 0.07812237739562988, 0.0022503421641886234, -0.054734084755182266, 0.04139512777328491, 0.07654433697462082, 0.004571287427097559, -0.04635145887732506, -0.03867725655436516, -0.04770801216363907, -0.015081425197422504, -0.05870728939771652, -0.046014636754989624, 0.02397826686501503, 0.001555358525365591, -0.005314752925187349, 0.027312295511364937, -0.0230006892234087, 0.03188618645071983, 0.01242739800363779, 0.02160124108195305, -0.03435942530632019, 0.005878629628568888, 0.012798353098332882, 0.009323138743638992, 0.0534377284348011, 0.04440585523843765, 0.030332792550325394, 0.0013080358039587736, 0.004177436698228121, 0.00400654599070549, 0.020874442532658577, -0.009463377296924591, -0.04239660128951073, 0.07131744921207428, 0.0050811925902962685, -0.023109422996640205, -0.03328511118888855, -0.03276330605149269, -0.018102489411830902, 0.04699457436800003, 0.0060091507621109486, -0.03265177458524704, 0.02878454700112343, -0.019902219995856285, 0.023910749703645706, -0.0035811651032418013, 0.024458499625325203, 0.013408844359219074, -0.03974352777004242, 0.028195997700095177, 0.057594332844018936, -0.008214726112782955, 0.011692533269524574, -0.005781247746199369, -0.007833169773221016, -0.029776733368635178, -0.023423735052347183, -0.05022267624735832, 0.043353915214538574, 0.0051012602634727955, 0.00620929105207324, 0.02782285213470459, -0.02170311100780964, -0.008640679530799389, -0.04715221747756004, 0.05742337182164192, 0.03247860446572304, 0.006543348077684641, -0.022047366946935654, 0.026122581213712692, -0.03120996244251728, -0.05325773358345032, -0.003572494722902775, 0.02124633640050888, -0.009309773333370686, -0.04658173769712448, 0.03303518518805504, -0.00015943852486088872, -0.019859660416841507, 0.0366271436214447, 0.012180529534816742, 0.05194023251533508, 0.00029261986492201686, -0.09806197881698608, -0.0762905403971672, 0.019333096221089363, 0.01500684767961502, 0.003946458455175161, -0.031184732913970947, -0.001200330094434321, 0.027423985302448273, 0.030314333736896515, 0.0020792607683688402, 0.008820967748761177, 0.009637605398893356, 0.05341139808297157, 0.00313542946241796, -0.04204903542995453, -0.03666472062468529, -0.014575347304344177, 0.0060089887119829655, -0.023590117692947388, -0.09133096784353256, 0.047190744429826736, -0.007743213325738907, -0.011534013785421848, 0.0010806563077494502, 0.02843754179775715, 0.009179850108921528, 0.02108205109834671, -0.025551868602633476, 0.021150201559066772, -0.04110211879014969, 0.045403335243463516, -0.012111435644328594, 0.02714088372886181, -0.0012580632464960217, -0.051092855632305145, 0.011193974874913692, -0.02054271288216114, 0.003447894938290119, 0.03932751715183258, -0.0010983293177559972, -0.012372097931802273, 0.0045128329657018185, 0.02188965305685997, 0.00021762200049124658, -0.04129240661859512, -0.020414266735315323, -0.024783441796898842, -0.013041462749242783, 0.0006320954998955131, 0.003336841706186533, 0.01066463440656662, -0.0016921170754358172, 0.016271278262138367, -0.06758885830640793, -0.06888077408075333, -0.05573144927620888, 0.014258443377912045, -0.04121093824505806, -0.02592688798904419, 0.0588071271777153, -0.009374663233757019, -0.016137653961777687, -0.03892916813492775, -0.016272570937871933, -0.035539817065000534, -0.02541092224419117, 0.013012196868658066, -0.011788120493292809, 0.005915423389524221, 0.023716626688838005, 0.06808733195066452, -0.006391479633748531, 0.0653994232416153, -0.013183278031647205, -0.026797425001859665, -0.01722361333668232, -0.037551168352365494, -0.02871110662817955, 0.009079962968826294, 0.004220751579850912, 0.034755922853946686, 0.017609480768442154, -0.0008371097501367331, 0.02735992893576622, -0.036457452923059464, 0.06085388734936714, 0.04293252155184746, 0.019292032346129417, 0.027291109785437584, 0.01953280344605446, -0.012197407893836498, 0.009213513694703579, 0.002605677582323551, -0.028734106570482254, -0.06758636981248856, -0.015415131114423275, 0.05002140626311302, -0.002130788518115878, -0.041655801236629486, 0.024954799562692642, 0.04212985187768936, -0.00276894005946815, 0.008298554457724094, 0.0002954467199742794, -0.027833271771669388, -0.03789602965116501, 0.02311798557639122, -0.0016435072757303715, 0.018890444189310074, 0.02985800988972187, -0.007374996785074472, -0.013489156030118465, 0.055046092718839645, -0.03186773881316185, 0.009234316647052765, 0.032967522740364075, -0.017772965133190155, -0.011026459746062756, -0.005298430100083351, -0.01986735872924328, 0.042543161660432816, 0.02419891208410263, 0.006041729357093573, 0.05479351803660393, -0.02390931360423565, 0.0028998597990721464, -0.020304711535573006, 0.003115242114290595, 0.04276300594210625, 0.05911557748913765, -0.048046816140413284, 0.0013574943877756596, 0.01848970353603363, -0.037393562495708466, 0.008485807105898857, -0.044549137353897095, -0.033009227365255356, -0.035325005650520325, -0.0029602432623505592, 0.011631551198661327, 0.0015639346092939377, -0.0017524623544886708, -0.03833650052547455, -0.02700546756386757, -0.009578255005180836, -0.019825035706162453, 0.04586881399154663, -0.00794654805213213, -0.030564390122890472, -0.01821822114288807, -0.01658775843679905, 0.0018774146446958184, 0.02822551690042019, -0.004118668381124735, -0.005108787678182125, -0.009055898524820805, 0.031292933970689774, -0.03448227792978287, -0.04740413650870323, -0.007986635901033878, 0.013671759516000748, -0.039105627685785294, -0.03838095813989639, 0.01902944967150688, 0.034628868103027344, -0.03860127553343773, 0.01951630786061287, 0.011308206245303154, -0.03136887028813362, -0.0362580381333828, -0.004231870640069246, 0.027635402977466583, 0.003346923738718033, 0.03670750930905342, 0.03268292173743248, -0.019164174795150757, 0.0053415363654494286, -0.05257111415266991, -0.0741124302148819, 0.007640316616743803, -0.015735013410449028, 0.04300984740257263, 0.003273564390838146, -0.028498388826847076, 0.05453821271657944, 0.061518050730228424, -0.021291742101311684, -0.03676379844546318, 0.024365058168768883, -0.04067257046699524, -0.010837271809577942, 0.026726016774773598, 0.002002313733100891, -0.009627270512282848, 0.027768641710281372, 0.024585820734500885, 0.02192857302725315, 0.015348469838500023, -0.011383975856006145, -0.003655386157333851, 0.023061981424689293, 0.011285258457064629, -0.02191142737865448, 0.026463709771633148, -0.011182139627635479, -0.026041025295853615, 0.004443400073796511, -0.04236043244600296, 0.022043941542506218, 0.004278519656509161, -0.04619915783405304, -0.009812915697693825, -0.010562526062130928, -0.0163431316614151, -0.0513438917696476, 0.03224657475948334, 0.033328257501125336, -0.06313466280698776, 0.02625287137925625, 0.030212735757231712, 0.01507062092423439, -0.0019045487279072404, 0.018941350281238556, 0.06559960544109344, 0.04857851192355156, -0.03510339558124542, -0.016796719282865524, -0.02109989896416664, -0.006117825862020254, 0.024623295292258263, 0.0010086802067235112, -0.03088003396987915, 0.05663387104868889, 0.043846286833286285, 0.017121201381087303, -0.008412323892116547, -0.053378403186798096, -0.022382637485861778, -0.05849149450659752, 0.03874784708023071, -0.05421796813607216, 0.07459618151187897, -0.0005068606697022915, 0.044526487588882446, 0.01142016239464283, -0.012767466716468334, 0.017485298216342926, 0.018412385135889053, -0.06019889935851097, 0.020816965028643608, -0.0016550746513530612, 0.01806032471358776, -0.0029867799021303654, -0.051059551537036896, 0.03963370621204376, -0.02777824178338051, -0.005714257713407278, -0.007982934825122356, 0.051781486719846725, -0.012827026657760143, 0.007849350571632385, -0.059829194098711014, -0.03409148380160332, -0.0035523257683962584, 0.01975085772573948, 0.009754396043717861, -0.00854829978197813, -0.02354338765144348, 0.05396812781691551, -0.0009516443242318928, 0.006279115565121174, -0.05112968012690544, 0.029861997812986374, 0.011350520886480808, 0.04332622140645981, 0.028959374874830246, 0.018351607024669647, -0.00865239929407835, 0.0026183039881289005, 0.01866880990564823, 0.03873409330844879, 0.07090741395950317, -0.0013345503248274326, 0.007372105959802866, -0.039890024811029434, -0.0243704691529274, 0.009452258236706257, 0.019745979458093643, -0.0043696146458387375, -0.0081841591745615, 0.0474407933652401, 0.05124955251812935, -0.05770111083984375, 0.05092160403728485, 0.07039724290370941, 0.004886788781732321, -0.007541396655142307, -0.019825529307127, -0.036248449236154556, -0.006158335600048304, 0.004500996321439743, 0.020010648295283318, -0.006806492805480957, -0.028801530599594116, 0.015024479478597641, 0.0005092441570013762, -0.02269170619547367, -0.05052817612886429, 0.028978314250707626, 0.036799024790525436, 0.040060292929410934, 0.0035277316346764565, -0.03355182707309723, -0.018184145912528038, 0.008258341811597347, 0.0549120157957077, 0.01466373074799776, -0.020647011697292328, -0.0740133598446846, -0.0340452678501606, 0.05612333491444588, 0.011371715925633907, -0.031967997550964355, 0.03026583045721054, -0.04174739494919777, -0.02871638350188732, 0.05807263031601906, -0.005209641996771097, 0.05352545529603958, 0.009632471017539501, 0.0023589429911226034, 0.011113129556179047, -0.037221603095531464, -0.025621837005019188, 0.005908152554184198, 0.010097780264914036, 0.0011858469806611538, -0.009865134954452515, 0.0005753793520852923, -0.03584486246109009, -0.0161819476634264, -0.023511124774813652, 0.07761719822883606, -0.009599238634109497, 0.0009605434024706483, -0.009559700265526772, -0.024844355881214142, -0.011413447558879852, -0.0928039401769638, 0.018309080973267555, 0.021929264068603516, -0.019950663670897484, 0.021910522133111954, -0.022134006023406982, -0.05535225570201874, 0.027824074029922485, 0.04343785345554352, -0.023173682391643524, 0.0209491029381752, -0.015294302254915237, 0.06970910727977753, 0.014848263002932072, 0.019581934437155724, 0.04639197513461113, 0.0522216372191906, -0.025373460724949837, -0.008874939754605293, -0.025630753487348557, -0.0030096215195953846, 0.0006584466900676489, -0.0024782386608421803, -0.055744320154190063, 0.03019130416214466, -0.047101251780986786, 0.03539790213108063, -0.01806463673710823, 0.014277017675340176, -0.019951490685343742, -0.049956511706113815, 0.014589282684028149, 0.04019514098763466, -0.008464337326586246, 0.003446730086579919, -0.03349528834223747, 0.008397743105888367, -0.004834942519664764, -0.024558115750551224, 0.036263659596443176, -0.006887070368975401, 0.0025225335266441107, -0.025933364406228065, -0.038736432790756226, 0.007849334739148617, -0.011579741723835468, 0.00592431053519249, 0.02092178352177143, -0.0224897563457489, 0.05571778118610382, -0.009463530965149403, 0.03789179027080536, -0.0022071434650570154, -0.03173346072435379, -0.0055996691808104515, 0.023392634466290474, -0.015034317970275879, 0.03352127596735954, 0.00912274606525898, 0.02148662880063057, -0.04718354716897011, 0.005058743990957737, -0.0531710609793663, -0.028895797207951546, 0.022115902975201607, -0.0006805915618315339, -0.02590465173125267, -0.04499609395861626, 0.002617736579850316, -0.010935576632618904, -0.01832984760403633, -0.00807785801589489, 0.037570659071207047, -0.013605373911559582, -0.0034436422865837812, 0.015761418268084526, 0.010663758963346481, 0.05823520943522453, 0.025823060423135757, 0.021448444575071335, -0.016284704208374023, -0.00924103707075119, 0.027642156928777695, 0.04759287089109421, 0.009076309390366077, -0.034746553748846054, -0.02947584167122841, -0.01431015320122242, 0.033246658742427826, 0.009366510435938835, -0.023611437529325485, -0.042190492153167725, -0.018702197819948196, -0.008747564628720284, 0.021633705124258995, -0.027889875695109367, 0.024631991982460022, -0.007840466685593128, 0.004149078857153654, -0.038504693657159805, 0.016001805663108826, 0.01626746915280819, -0.031435783952474594, 0.0621853731572628, -0.029696328565478325, 0.0031948827672749758, 0.03732505813241005, 0.07948397845029831, -0.022815298289060593, 0.011685613542795181, 0.01956588588654995, -0.011023957282304764, 0.04408150166273117, -0.004798440262675285, -0.004724801052361727, 0.040905654430389404, 0.003443245543166995, -0.02712489292025566, -0.0437048003077507, -0.02653803490102291, -0.007262662053108215, 0.045045144855976105, -0.006298532709479332, 0.0351467989385128, 0.018951818346977234, -0.016348673030734062, 0.008722768165171146, -0.02282770909368992, -0.008386757224798203, -0.02316340245306492, 0.02599314972758293, 0.05391433835029602, -0.013697322458028793, 0.01147183682769537, 0.05367529019713402, -0.004210254177451134, -0.00027691692230291665, 0.03479021415114403, -0.0021677983459085226, 0.0175478495657444, 0.007067267782986164, -0.05726915970444679, -0.022835439071059227, 0.05743488296866417, -0.07943904399871826, 0.016865741461515427, -0.00897267460823059, -0.04922036454081535, 0.02901851013302803, 0.04977244511246681, 0.015713931992650032, -0.007918787188827991, 0.005989901255816221, -0.05509038642048836, 0.05855102464556694, 0.03627461940050125, 0.022146161645650864, 0.01577627845108509, 0.031332481652498245, 0.040357556194067, -0.015277067199349403, 0.01947573944926262, -0.05528722703456879, -0.0550803504884243, -0.00571523467078805, -0.017729975283145905, -0.0351107120513916, 0.04471608251333237, 0.03248688578605652, -0.011522924527525902, -0.013004526495933533, -0.011182022280991077, 0.0024557991418987513, 0.009831315837800503, 0.01462258119136095, -0.03946051374077797, 0.05064055696129799, -0.023077018558979034, 0.031309474259614944, 0.015081202611327171, 0.01642969809472561, 0.10936255007982254, 0.06747563183307648, 0.030447250232100487, -0.07551473379135132, 0.05364685878157616, 0.0066010900773108006, -0.013757963664829731, -0.030617358162999153, 0.0049597835168242455, 0.01841113343834877, -0.04982537403702736, 0.000016169060472748242, 0.07398171722888947, -0.012130815535783768, 0.018441801890730858, 0.09030275791883469, -0.05223822966217995, -0.03225113824009895, -0.0032588299363851547, -0.0033600861206650734, -0.029883693903684616, -0.0009106129291467369, -0.009904416278004646, 0.005216056946665049, -0.009101908653974533, -0.021775424480438232, -0.01477639190852642, -0.01857115514576435, 0.0006414889357984066, 0.02604287676513195, 0.025369614362716675, -0.030212873592972755, 0.009968314319849014, -0.00009240041981684044, 0.022480670362710953, -0.03885604813694954, -0.010051456280052662, -0.045611243695020676, 0.04628130421042442, 0.059811536222696304, 0.0017409082502126694, 0.007542022969573736, -0.0030816872604191303, 0.0032854119781404734, -0.026104534044861794, -0.040099646896123886, -0.07804764807224274, 0.030820243060588837, -0.011625549755990505, -0.023850092664361, -0.009929409250617027, 0.007767071947455406, 0.03155415877699852, -0.012906640768051147, 0.011765334755182266, 0.011616766452789307, 0.06032118946313858, -0.0162858497351408, -0.04744035005569458, -0.03120269812643528, 0.040001459419727325, -0.01712469942867756, 0.02354270964860916, -0.015071839094161987, -0.053125083446502686, -0.05932723730802536, -0.052336715161800385, 0.014103036373853683, 0.018053729087114334, -0.000059986105043208227, -0.006967632565647364, -0.025725070387125015, -0.01637178100645542, 0.005800455808639526, 0.01774371601641178, 0.003335369285196066, 0.03626575320959091, 0.01903667487204075, -0.014264794066548347, 0.008199012838304043, -0.05800054222345352, -0.0038101589307188988, -0.027232447639107704, -0.003078350331634283, -0.019332099705934525, -0.024708503857254982, 0.0341142937541008, 0.04120620712637901, 0.02908245474100113, -0.006018688902258873, -0.019408581778407097, 0.04657683148980141, 0.015951380133628845, -0.05644644424319267, -0.04340285062789917, -0.029374200850725174, -0.060810744762420654, -0.01073390431702137, -0.021720144897699356, 0.040126629173755646, 0.008495280519127846, -0.0023938892409205437, 0.028915107250213623, 0.02865166962146759, -0.0007861796184442937, 0.009312170557677746, -0.00037359027191996574, -0.039245907217264175, 0.008084762841463089, 0.010353981517255306, -0.0027448066975921392, -0.0062196278013288975, -0.01592763513326645, 0.0027153189294040203, -0.011924943886697292, 0.04441177472472191, -0.03033601865172386, -0.03751443699002266, 0.00902671180665493, -0.012090293690562248, -0.0075491261668503284, -0.040407609194517136, 0.011775519698858261, 0.020484494045376778, -0.0240250825881958, 0.011137177236378193, -0.010286703705787659, 0.029445165768265724, 0.0058116670697927475, 0.013347653672099113, 0.009393598884344101, 0.04055824875831604, 0.045737266540527344, 0.031162258237600327, 0.011647503823041916, 0.011986104771494865, 0.03691430017352104, 0.03518548235297203, -0.029077857732772827, -0.011329913511872292, 0.04511234164237976, -0.010006367228925228, -0.046258628368377686, 0.02584211342036724, -0.016723163425922394, 0.022407984361052513, 0.020424313843250275, 0.009434378705918789, -0.007469105534255505, 0.03115401230752468, -0.027703547850251198, -0.009142161346971989, 0.00560761708766222, 0.0028666972648352385, 0.0013747981283813715, 0.02050124481320381, 0.007211660500615835, 0.04855549708008766, 0.018808353692293167, 0.020182156935334206, 0.03318902105093002, -0.011924556456506252, -0.027302663773298264, -0.014936037361621857, -0.02931210957467556, 0.030925294384360313, 0.02613864839076996, -0.008521306328475475, 0.038227591663599014, 0.07650016993284225, -0.03609110042452812, 0.031579580157995224, -0.01354995183646679, -0.01150115393102169, -0.09605632722377777, -0.04452921822667122, 0.01000363938510418, 0.0364329032599926, -0.004446895327419043, -0.0328952930867672, 0.0031525418162345886, 0.03817587345838547, -0.0198026355355978, 0.031033087521791458, 0.020163916051387787, 0.026740625500679016, -0.021970553323626518, -0.02473321557044983, -0.02389908768236637, 0.015001648105680943, -0.005938653368502855, 0.04602959752082825, 0.01160038635134697, 0.04556387662887573, 0.017217451706528664, -0.03903798386454582, -0.029430193826556206, 0.02669132873415947, 0.011179208755493164, -0.05948912352323532, 0.01635071635246277, -0.007601537741720676, -0.03282769024372101, 0.008805433288216591, 0.03625190258026123, 0.0047484152019023895, 0.002531404374167323, 0.009947101585566998, 0.003079594811424613, 0.04430804401636124, 0.045537710189819336, 0.03927238658070564, 0.02121901884675026, 0.000174127213540487, 0.014393972232937813, 0.032108746469020844, -0.02678005024790764, -0.011416214518249035, 0.049791473895311356, 0.00473283976316452, -0.010732446797192097, 0.0841488167643547, 0.006137283053249121, -0.012235000729560852, 0.0032163311261683702, -0.0011245320783928037, -0.0019714338704943657, -0.021649904549121857, 0.01874147541821003, -0.02577236294746399, 0.02731599472463131, 0.06286303699016571, 0.05540729686617851, -0.02070307917892933, -0.020646536722779274, -0.02905171923339367, -0.04146358370780945, -0.001291878055781126, -0.022244583815336227, -0.04790392145514488, -0.06158693879842758, -0.00872629601508379, -0.02384699136018753, -0.00013774157559964806, -0.01675417274236679, 0.0017550975317135453, -0.04780922457575798, 0.04733625799417496, -0.0271979458630085, 0.01615111343562603, 0.0006989811663515866, -0.036410827189683914, -0.014444618485867977, -0.06725519150495529, 0.06028616055846214, 0.013400635682046413, -0.03591110557317734, -0.039148688316345215, 0.01714818924665451, -0.017405489459633827, -0.024955449625849724, 0.056473035365343094, 0.004492962267249823, 0.007386481389403343, 0.030802687630057335, 0.01877593994140625, 0.006019112188369036, -0.044554904103279114, 0.020568767562508583, -0.034799881279468536, -0.0036787085700780153, -0.024446427822113037, -0.018725698813796043, 0.02444251999258995, 0.00888100080192089, 0.02884708158671856, -0.007195320911705494, 0.005891961976885796, 0.016030101105570793, -0.020792163908481598, -0.019185949116945267, -0.022853100672364235, -0.0002956463140435517, 0.028736712411046028, -0.019041821360588074, -0.013047167100012302, 0.03070772998034954, -0.014365054666996002, -0.055880479514598846, -0.012674065306782722, -0.0356157086789608, -0.04086603596806526, -0.004416599404066801, 0.0428030788898468, -0.012672881595790386, -0.044190868735313416, 0.0112643176689744, 0.019727330654859543, -0.017140056937932968, 0.0049640522338449955, 0.04407872259616852, 0.045429397374391556, 0.0479692704975605, -0.0034145202953368425, -0.021157007664442062, 0.05231256037950516, -0.03365393728017807, 0.018548903986811638, 0.021410688757896423, 0.054987795650959015, -0.015111930668354034, 0.036544933915138245, 0.03046967089176178, 0.028899917379021645, 0.024694956839084625, 0.00008901952969608828, 0.05714097619056702, -0.022218549624085426, -0.01383532676845789, 0.03079741820693016, -0.018577057868242264, 0.011046011932194233, 0.00853536743670702, 0.013831451535224915, 0.07865848392248154, -0.014532497152686119, -0.017599884420633316, -0.002626970410346985, -0.012580284848809242, -0.0320771187543869, 0.03824656084179878, 0.011106391437351704, 0.04857087507843971, -0.020741146057844162, 0.011808812618255615, -0.027640366926789284, -0.0017076688818633556, 0.010234912857413292, -0.01509618479758501, 0.025984695181250572, 0.025326648727059364, 0.026472901925444603, -0.012884796597063541, -0.027002323418855667, -0.033106304705142975, -0.024404015392065048, 0.022486336529254913, 0.03530385345220566, -0.00441709766164422, 0.012941152788698673, -0.01053222268819809, -0.02444702945649624, 0.03656771406531334, -0.05684889853000641, -0.021170035004615784, -0.05432264134287834, 0.0010192255722358823, -0.031486738473176956, -0.01910722255706787 ]
<p>I've been searching for a way to combine two hazard ratios from the same study for a meta-analysis, but found nothing. Does anyone know how to do this?</p> <p>Any thoughts would be great.</p> <p>Good Day,</p> <p>Simon</p>
73,397
[ -0.029346898198127747, 0.006832472048699856, 0.017352137714624405, 0.02740265242755413, 0.008067980408668518, 0.0011779294582083821, -0.008158640004694462, -0.025388704612851143, 0.06427168101072311, -0.02789662592113018, 0.033415697515010834, 0.04933735728263855, 0.02678324468433857, -0.004114051349461079, 0.002417703391984105, 0.020724210888147354, 0.024402964860200882, 0.021151289343833923, 0.03086136281490326, -0.029995393007993698, 0.007477508392184973, -0.005048029124736786, -0.008811946026980877, 0.01322989258915186, 0.003301406279206276, 0.04264817014336586, 0.055770061910152435, -0.03716569393873215, -0.01858164556324482, 0.06211988255381584, -0.03847464546561241, -0.04851822927594185, 0.02395840734243393, 0.05647915601730347, 0.004731054417788982, -0.0025888984091579914, -0.0009360615513287485, -0.0033620367757976055, -0.011679564602673054, 0.03332873061299324, 0.005171551834791899, -0.0070106834173202515, -0.018275078386068344, 0.05274033918976784, -0.026353521272540092, 0.006877131760120392, -0.04530614987015724, -0.044020794332027435, 0.012295451015233994, -0.042556438595056534, 0.06058536842465401, -0.032776013016700745, 0.05453190580010414, 0.03424675390124321, -0.017160190269351006, 0.032559897750616074, 0.06024739146232605, 0.08396010845899582, 0.04813474416732788, -0.06698063760995865, -0.0327012799680233, -0.042033012956380844, -0.008813745342195034, -0.01152164675295353, -0.033605653792619705, -0.008041179738938808, 0.004754117224365473, -0.04876268655061722, 0.015509291552007198, -0.018448641523718834, 0.017256073653697968, -0.00848497822880745, 0.03343513235449791, -0.0347239151597023, 0.0039886548183858395, -0.017919059842824936, -0.0004709219210781157, 0.01820342428982258, 0.04156037047505379, 0.006079426966607571, 0.00023383396910503507, 0.002628779038786888, 0.0754050612449646, 0.019864046946167946, -0.0031638883519917727, 0.019340727478265762, 0.08073063939809799, -0.01253356970846653, 0.024240192025899887, 0.021143851801753044, 0.0027856857050210238, -0.004020696971565485, 0.0602860152721405, 0.0008299936889670789, -0.02579837664961815, 0.0027814374770969152, 0.003959673922508955, 0.045160628855228424, -0.022223548963665962, 0.01773986779153347, -0.006876650732010603, -0.028174597769975662, 0.003647386794909835, 0.024761436507105827, 0.005587365943938494, -0.02385154739022255, -0.006690837908536196, 0.0012095727724954486, 0.024027086794376373, -0.018035752698779106, -0.015986260026693344, 0.023157469928264618, -0.010197664611041546, -0.013540585525333881, -0.035094086080789566, -0.01697230525314808, -0.0196971632540226, -0.016622543334960938, 0.06533055007457733, 0.04877231642603874, 0.05624768137931824, -0.033943213522434235, 0.019930711016058922, -0.027288665995001793, -0.04757748916745186, -0.022447912022471428, 0.02081138640642166, -0.002634734380990267, -0.01139544602483511, 0.06411583721637726, 0.02693251706659794, -0.016172241419553757, 0.059153828769922256, 0.01826968416571617, 0.03096507117152214, -0.0012336870422586799, -0.06178542971611023, -0.027518557384610176, 0.03484131768345833, -0.00525136012583971, -0.02123243734240532, -0.05635055899620056, -0.005131692625582218, 0.013204395771026611, 0.07412774860858917, 0.04413657262921333, 0.045933108776807785, -0.0001893066510092467, 0.023712685331702232, 0.04074912890791893, 0.04001498222351074, -0.0014073846396058798, 0.00003287127037765458, 0.01952693983912468, -0.016688071191310883, -0.11577559262514114, 0.03471047803759575, 0.0015440593706443906, 0.0026112725026905537, 0.026632236316800117, 0.045439910143613815, -0.014989872463047504, -0.015369032509624958, -0.00573923671618104, 0.035979364067316055, -0.020496608689427376, 0.06652083247900009, 0.002470875158905983, -0.02550889551639557, 0.010621895082294941, -0.006833199877291918, -0.010819010436534882, 0.018336622044444084, 0.054243359714746475, 0.010194175876677036, -0.012567746452987194, -0.0017581400461494923, -0.033041492104530334, 0.004996721167117357, 0.017547620460391045, -0.021376801654696465, -0.018998704850673676, -0.01456750649958849, 0.003444751026108861, 0.01603785529732704, 0.018766863271594048, -0.011850924231112003, 0.0016950992867350578, 0.030384579673409462, -0.024943064898252487, -0.035054050385951996, -0.09655007719993591, -0.05055444315075874, 0.0007153740734793246, -0.029048213735222816, 0.011345515958964825, 0.02196037583053112, 0.059334345161914825, -0.05409489572048187, -0.02126263454556465, -0.008779622614383698, -0.029217515140771866, 0.017345674335956573, -0.015033694915473461, -0.01420176774263382, 0.0486455038189888, 0.04900066554546356, -0.02718561328947544, 0.025819748640060425, -0.04030018672347069, -0.03167391195893288, 0.005203606560826302, -0.034229230135679245, 0.007927491329610348, -0.005231819581240416, -0.046364959329366684, -0.010078719817101955, -0.009309873916208744, 0.0030286454129964113, -0.007909323088824749, -0.05428596958518028, 0.0898410975933075, 0.06557715684175491, 0.005327742081135511, 0.0059309774078428745, 0.0032141944393515587, 0.04886848106980324, -0.009851302020251751, -0.04172593355178833, -0.008991824463009834, -0.011986182071268559, 0.01352452952414751, 0.05219263210892677, -0.00894126482307911, -0.055522121489048004, 0.04353721812367439, 0.04200877621769905, 0.022152263671159744, -0.007853053510189056, 0.07300177216529846, -0.00845289882272482, -0.041781000792980194, -0.0031338443513959646, 0.0036540564615279436, 0.03318377956748009, -0.003004230558872223, 0.0021857707761228085, 0.014833826571702957, 0.02292737551033497, 0.004629050847142935, -0.04375094175338745, 0.034021563827991486, -0.018289530649781227, 0.010607601143419743, 0.038959432393312454, -0.013767709955573082, 0.029785415157675743, -0.024196267127990723, 0.03990297392010689, 0.018751099705696106, 0.014788178727030754, 0.0012327239383012056, 0.029247557744383812, -0.018038906157016754, 0.028117462992668152, 0.005975351203233004, -0.05066319927573204, 0.053625598549842834, 0.02228964865207672, -0.03262628614902496, -0.03316575661301613, -0.012167094275355339, -0.026524556800723076, -0.01358058862388134, -0.005400747526437044, -0.016609864309430122, -0.010355627164244652, 0.0590476356446743, -0.008102862164378166, -0.020961685106158257, 0.009588267654180527, -0.020264990627765656, 0.010636548511683941, -0.008288438431918621, -0.036647289991378784, 0.026947524398565292, -0.027594005689024925, -0.011946181766688824, 0.033106978982686996, -0.0004600636020768434, 0.0005333645967766643, 0.0194063913077116, 0.020222680643200874, -0.04292217269539833, -0.03475991263985634, -0.014210980385541916, 0.02398703619837761, -0.02012535184621811, -0.02148956060409546, 0.009872572496533394, 0.03158211708068848, -0.0880873054265976, 0.02159886248409748, -0.0036682328209280968, 0.010431548580527306, -0.01153694000095129, 0.03884109854698181, 0.028303030878305435, -0.006699337158352137, -0.006934851873666048, 0.019001668319106102, -0.002489961450919509, -0.003376905806362629, -0.056338466703891754, -0.039292097091674805, 0.021561939269304276, 0.03488113358616829, 0.027713095769286156, 0.010024316608905792, 0.006165197119116783, 0.08485757559537888, 0.010398232378065586, 0.01631353422999382, -0.03617630526423454, 0.008142094127833843, -0.012209637090563774, -0.03422858566045761, -0.004217378329485655, -0.003955000080168247, 0.01586425118148327, 0.033146925270557404, -0.020499451085925102, 0.021035434678196907, 0.060286108404397964, 0.016554784029722214, 0.0042373016476631165, 0.010726289823651314, 0.03748050332069397, -0.005059481598436832, 0.0019779044669121504, 0.0041161454282701015, -0.0016537373885512352, -0.012255772016942501, 0.008139951154589653, 0.042796459048986435, -0.04449419304728508, -0.06351295858621597, 0.005307076498866081, 0.008848806843161583, -0.02274376153945923, -0.043230991810560226, 0.013616546988487244, 0.019552698358893394, 0.0008259436581283808, -0.006029169075191021, 0.026484446600079536, 0.059094350785017014, -0.03664935380220413, 0.019753126427531242, 0.041225552558898926, 0.042553238570690155, -0.008193478919565678, -0.0350661501288414, 0.0036048858892172575, 0.0011089729377999902, 0.0223012026399374, 0.001806855434551835, 0.008853110484778881, 0.01818983443081379, 0.029903575778007507, 0.04043809697031975, 0.00345424422994256, -0.04299962893128395, 0.05125493183732033, -0.06701501458883286, 0.006249514874070883, -0.02595873922109604, 0.033224813640117645, 0.005226788576692343, 0.046614937484264374, 0.006300262175500393, -0.03905387222766876, 0.010935519821941853, 0.0021533844992518425, -0.07582246512174606, 0.03736420348286629, -0.009753216989338398, -0.01371544599533081, 0.016745734959840775, -0.023150376975536346, 0.023915698751807213, -0.02766251564025879, -0.03269902244210243, -0.0005932832136750221, 0.037889789789915085, -0.03326910734176636, 0.022773245349526405, -0.02309975028038025, -0.022557644173502922, 0.00029857479967176914, 0.002156483242288232, 0.0047606839798390865, 0.00785129051655531, -0.0012087291106581688, 0.022267784923315048, 0.012612894177436829, -0.019586248323321342, -0.028325004503130913, 0.02899925969541073, 0.02177126705646515, 0.04274234548211098, 0.019022969529032707, 0.043292924761772156, -0.03608297184109688, 0.011940853670239449, -0.024933544918894768, 0.017343996092677116, 0.05095764994621277, -0.0075821648351848125, -0.027554577216506004, -0.009783045388758183, -0.009122916497290134, 0.0025985916145145893, 0.011723410338163376, 0.0021491635125130415, 0.005851571913808584, 0.04637620598077774, 0.032244086265563965, -0.050086285918951035, 0.01780514046549797, 0.03984532877802849, 0.013539745472371578, -0.00199970044195652, -0.01636018045246601, -0.018507836386561394, 0.009844250045716763, -0.03270250931382179, 0.010808708146214485, 0.034886885434389114, -0.024035682901740074, -0.024324778467416763, 0.056081779301166534, -0.012989710085093975, -0.023188112303614616, -0.005791677627712488, 0.01910186931490898, 0.039234764873981476, 0.036694690585136414, -0.03435864672064781, -0.012471800670027733, 0.04876873642206192, 0.03369636833667755, 0.04384465143084526, 0.020226992666721344, -0.07772528380155563, 0.00965730007737875, 0.0456964336335659, 0.05205349624156952, -0.0372418537735939, -0.008898410014808178, -0.02724692039191723, -0.021116899326443672, 0.04152539372444153, -0.04455246776342392, 0.0027714313473552465, -0.004641662817448378, 0.013583223335444927, -0.009695552289485931, -0.05102132633328438, -0.03411119058728218, 0.034829117357730865, -0.005658318288624287, 0.0030143975745886564, 0.034005921334028244, -0.0031954944133758545, -0.046606991440057755, 0.006993248593062162, 0.014196601696312428, 0.07149487733840942, -0.028983067721128464, -0.022515367716550827, -0.008450900204479694, 0.02474505454301834, -0.04211226850748062, -0.08255186676979065, 0.008232902735471725, -0.029203491285443306, -0.0072524952702224255, 0.05821716785430908, -0.011382479220628738, 0.013794531114399433, 0.05609825253486633, -0.000584288383834064, -0.03437576815485954, -0.0026337658055126667, -0.015462618321180344, 0.004672445822507143, 0.04259439557790756, 0.005835267249494791, 0.08057743310928345, -0.006183099001646042, -0.0027409938629716635, -0.014605732634663582, -0.041469357907772064, 0.03979400172829628, -0.03799540176987648, -0.014166115783154964, -0.02112829126417637, -0.01653231494128704, -0.01912783272564411, -0.024089736863970757, -0.0033703830558806658, 0.014189297333359718, 0.023093122988939285, -0.01294031459838152, 0.01085044164210558, -0.026371633633971214, 0.01883135549724102, -0.03366171196103096, 0.04122023284435272, 0.0009680464281700552, -0.0006570169352926314, -0.03040662594139576, 0.03789034113287926, -0.024051271378993988, -0.027539199218153954, -0.0007754977559670806, -0.09007047116756439, 0.012041512876749039, -0.04088818281888962, -0.03982490673661232, -0.0021194377914071083, -0.020392417907714844, 0.0571650005877018, -0.035598024725914, 0.020225415006279945, -0.0016237484524026513, -0.02828352525830269, -0.0036241463385522366, 0.04427507147192955, 0.008877537213265896, 0.017647389322519302, -0.06728959828615189, 0.07664642482995987, 0.004050322342664003, -0.008423988707363605, -0.06937935948371887, -0.012329893186688423, 0.049514029175043106, 0.013845193199813366, -0.03186799958348274, -0.05749611184000969, 0.005114040803164244, -0.01268340926617384, -0.048820242285728455, 0.002085524844005704, 0.054544758051633835, -0.03596605360507965, -0.013225588947534561, -0.01947926916182041, 0.011226873844861984, 0.04200025275349617, 0.0020110816694796085, -0.015424699522554874, 0.03196530044078827, -0.06627937406301498, 0.0012027788907289505, -0.020152470096945763, -0.008284623734652996, -0.03740759193897247, 0.0009430509526282549, -0.038594938814640045, -0.01724955625832081, 0.0447821319103241, -0.007059200666844845, -0.0054736752063035965, 0.02142147906124592, -0.01188165694475174, 0.043787017464637756, -0.04687155410647392, 0.005642571486532688, 0.0014678684528917074, 0.046099137514829636, -0.038340453058481216, 0.05829702690243721, -0.01366403978317976, 0.0032069808803498745, -0.00979525875300169, 0.005878969561308622, -0.03582511842250824, 0.023908566683530807, 0.04309413209557533, -0.026957403868436813, -0.005842301063239574, -0.01142862718552351, -0.026069048792123795, -0.0016503907972946763, 0.03161158040165901, 0.009561429731547832, 0.04528840258717537, -0.010960354469716549, -0.0592300109565258, -0.04106986150145531, -0.019233860075473785, -0.008085217326879501, 0.03502453863620758, -0.05132875591516495, 0.0516682043671608, 0.04128216952085495, 0.0018747348804026842, 0.010000529699027538, -0.003725949674844742, -0.0030397428199648857, -0.0033304120879620314, -0.006594597361981869, 0.06261851638555527, -0.006217476911842823, -0.03194892406463623, 0.05122855678200722, 0.04540960490703583, 0.0179570522159338, 0.034400824457407, -0.009926523081958294, 0.0012541566975414753, 0.006455907132476568, -0.009114379063248634, -0.01237665954977274, 0.05497731268405914, -0.05759399011731148, 0.025803174823522568, -0.06601173430681229, -0.014448384754359722, 0.06051056087017059, 0.007860809564590454, -0.011099952273070812, -0.04173438996076584, -0.04080388322472572, -0.04635041579604149, 0.016785115003585815, 0.004030120559036732, -0.03260150924324989, 0.04600633680820465, 0.008347941562533379, 0.05594202131032944, -0.00033143896143883467, 0.026010314002633095, -0.03670495003461838, -0.08467169106006622, -0.014945182017982006, -0.014154516160488129, -0.034141551703214645, -0.0004668435431085527, -0.01625024527311325, -0.02692296914756298, 0.03015860542654991, -0.022978948429226875, 0.0008735947194509208, -0.019771086052060127, 0.03128756210207939, 0.025268279016017914, 0.0634375587105751, 0.04605528712272644, 0.01242576353251934, 0.022649068385362625, -0.020844770595431328, 0.12863463163375854, 0.0764586552977562, 0.059156954288482666, -0.07406839728355408, 0.046735748648643494, 0.00509675731882453, 0.030335059389472008, -0.005427541211247444, 0.004992007743567228, 0.021715989336371422, -0.022405603900551796, 0.04847894608974457, 0.07762718200683594, -0.011303368024528027, -0.038275931030511856, 0.057358238846063614, -0.012451892718672752, -0.007948064245283604, -0.03168345242738724, 0.02241857908666134, -0.013789945282042027, -0.03115076944231987, -0.002580885076895356, 0.007683387957513332, -0.011290932074189186, -0.019183499738574028, -0.021709805354475975, -0.0316711887717247, -0.0074742501601576805, 0.00976318959146738, -0.006611232180148363, -0.04754263907670975, 0.03335532173514366, 0.006846999749541283, 0.016812732443213463, -0.01300464291125536, 0.003680686466395855, -0.004974954761564732, -0.016882216557860374, 0.012595642358064651, 0.004071456380188465, 0.02039884217083454, 0.011093427427113056, 0.029695868492126465, -0.03570271655917168, -0.01223105750977993, -0.006074327975511551, 0.017793484032154083, -0.0061865076422691345, -0.007051293738186359, -0.03834383562207222, -0.016925282776355743, 0.017887214198708534, -0.01467174757272005, -0.03483850508928299, 0.008261757902801037, 0.027803217992186546, -0.04091963917016983, 0.008868228644132614, -0.041707247495651245, 0.026745745912194252, -0.013882783241569996, 0.05816977471113205, 0.04643085598945618, -0.021439675241708755, -0.03255655989050865, -0.06457387655973434, 0.03275402635335922, 0.008969787508249283, -0.0045731463469564915, -0.008205673657357693, 0.001205473905429244, -0.03119676001369953, -0.00699211098253727, -0.002543400274589658, 0.0056037153117358685, 0.04768431931734085, 0.019375460222363472, -0.02386787347495556, -0.029600413516163826, -0.040309660136699677, 0.02696927636861801, -0.014726339839398861, -0.018084801733493805, -0.04900931939482689, -0.00483590317890048, 0.03696538507938385, 0.03830207511782646, -0.023557333275675774, 0.04275107756257057, -0.02497127465903759, 0.04201075807213783, 0.034521304070949554, -0.054266370832920074, -0.02326287515461445, 0.004152971785515547, -0.011183278635144234, -0.018061337992548943, -0.022770870476961136, 0.0639004036784172, -0.006428814493119717, 0.008017444051802158, 0.03160511702299118, 0.013282681815326214, 0.0005434901104308665, -0.02597902901470661, -0.0011558582773432136, -0.05260523781180382, -0.012579445727169514, 0.020463332533836365, 0.03481249138712883, 0.018484225496649742, -0.0067431312054395676, -0.011012637987732887, -0.038233380764722824, 0.02591559663414955, -0.018594933673739433, -0.016794877126812935, 0.010006913915276527, -0.04166034609079361, 0.036617521196603775, -0.010896165855228901, -0.016855044290423393, -0.053907543420791626, -0.0156398918479681, -0.012567318044602871, -0.021416254341602325, -0.03090777061879635, 0.012804444879293442, 0.023083221167325974, 0.020338023081421852, 0.03521940857172012, 0.03689102083444595, -0.001983378315344453, -0.0065893023274838924, 0.024232791736721992, -0.0006172980065457523, 0.03487676754593849, 0.0061530363745987415, -0.007254209369421005, 0.02869292162358761, -0.05470244958996773, -0.0051630460657179356, 0.02320520579814911, 0.0005441898247227073, 0.036986224353313446, 0.014646299183368683, -0.030478715896606445, -0.019221989437937737, 0.07574456930160522, -0.03806212171912193, -0.055103693157434464, -0.03448105975985527, -0.0038901716470718384, -0.003718743799254298, 0.003049839986488223, -0.018134504556655884, -0.0012908950448036194, -0.02590278349816799, 0.0048704794608056545, 0.043886445462703705, 0.004757832735776901, 0.0061720372177660465, 0.0012459785211831331, 0.017877930775284767, 0.05438961461186409, -0.01558076310902834, -0.013323253020644188, 0.034690696746110916, 0.04338621720671654, -0.019670531153678894, 0.023595266044139862, -0.013197703287005424, 0.009304355829954147, -0.07746913284063339, -0.027141615748405457, -0.03504566848278046, -0.01815471425652504, 0.0386270135641098, -0.03579602763056755, 0.04170855134725571, -0.01529119536280632, -0.04276422783732414, -0.007218281272798777, 0.01891596056520939, -0.021829385310411453, -0.05822157487273216, 0.0027149550151079893, -0.011813945136964321, 0.03162723779678345, 0.015125474892556667, 0.03988996893167496, 0.0191651601344347, 0.03145674988627434, -0.029883973300457, -0.020793898031115532, -0.03558611869812012, -0.01121589820832014, 0.02521245740354061, -0.04950449615716934, 0.026863712817430496, -0.042301468551158905, -0.05541973188519478, 0.02654586173593998, 0.0051757595501840115, 0.04461286962032318, 0.045460838824510574, 0.03287505730986595, 0.0108921118080616, 0.029756009578704834, -0.006605364847928286, 0.02341386489570141, -0.038118407130241394, -0.02225324884057045, 0.03288089111447334, 0.007768925279378891, -0.05622076243162155, 0.04045960679650307, 0.03302169218659401, 0.0010568237630650401, -0.03619099035859108, 0.02797912247478962, -0.030264083296060562, -0.026796266436576843, -0.017365481704473495, -0.006764658726751804, 0.057325512170791626, -0.031435877084732056, 0.013305053114891052, -0.03144640102982521, 0.0036889570765197277, 0.07963170856237411, -0.009836075827479362, 0.024078911170363426, 0.03545257821679115, -0.017970137298107147, -0.02428731881082058, -0.005198965780436993, 0.002589058829471469, -0.0333474725484848, -0.007697541266679764, 0.010171427391469479, 0.0020332077983766794, 0.00820987205952406, -0.05044563487172127, -0.013074045069515705, -0.021317554637789726, 0.03726356104016304, -0.03329059109091759, 0.02533477544784546, 0.021737778559327126, 0.0000867191847646609, 0.02170126885175705, -0.04145956039428711, 0.03023052215576172, 0.028103094547986984, -0.022838842123746872, -0.054361939430236816, -0.053690630942583084, 0.007961614057421684, -0.0036271510180085897, 0.06029258668422699, -0.03327484056353569, 0.026391370221972466, -0.028730273246765137, 0.07189258188009262, 0.0027291139122098684, -0.02235184796154499, 0.043767206370830536, -0.004892351105809212, -0.050935983657836914, -0.03127185255289078, 0.003096464090049267, 0.010922583751380444, -0.0084170401096344, -0.016268804669380188, -0.03909672796726227, 0.014264418743550777, 0.024254323914647102, 0.02766890451312065, 0.03433328866958618, -0.025209538638591766, -0.03207370638847351, 0.05121097341179848, -0.03446273133158684, 0.01261206716299057, 0.05904287472367287, 0.007238709833472967, -0.04280620440840721, 0.034461818635463715, -0.026489371433854103, -0.03492062911391258, -0.01595238596200943, -0.019023355096578598, -0.02101471833884716, -0.029844222590327263, 0.003992175683379173, -0.0006333375931717455, -0.04078191518783569, 0.006780889350920916, 0.0339626669883728, 0.008315362967550755, 0.01866995356976986, -0.018450813367962837, 0.010696466080844402, -0.015300736762583256, -0.03745199739933014, 0.005182458553463221, -0.0351971760392189, 0.017744842916727066, -0.012433757074177265, -0.002653165953233838, 0.030163442716002464, -0.016158603131771088, 0.018110979348421097, -0.017394257709383965, 0.010174144059419632, -0.02998548373579979, -0.007716380059719086, -0.008967415429651737, -0.026127180084586143, 0.0002075915690511465, 0.008880057372152805, -0.015704454854130745, 0.05059187486767769, -0.019202763214707375, 0.006995655596256256, -0.003828370710834861, -0.027845587581396103, -0.0360664501786232, -0.014812043868005276, 0.03276679664850235, 0.022809302434325218, -0.014594879932701588, -0.014597431756556034, 0.0065925647504627705, -0.030469730496406555, 0.00915635284036398, -0.01646334119141102, 0.04220026731491089, -0.022538401186466217, -0.014676854945719242, -0.032675232738256454, -0.02922450192272663, -0.01620767079293728, -0.03686436638236046, -0.0009993414860218763, 0.05619280785322189, 0.01088257972151041, -0.0318463034927845, -0.019633527845144272, 0.01946946792304516, 0.03222976252436638, -0.05467170476913452, -0.03967336192727089, -0.021501725539565086, 0.03087470307946205, -0.005287336651235819, 0.010823385789990425 ]
<p>I have spent a fair amount of time trying to solve this problem but I can't find the solution. More specifically, I have the following matrix:</p> <pre><code>P(D|E&amp;F) = [ 0.5 0.3 0.5 0.2 ; 0.5 0.7 0.5 0.8 ] </code></pre> <p>All the variables are binary (two states) D, E and F are nodes of a Bayesian network. E and F are the parents of D and they are independent. </p> <p>Now, new evidence comes in and we know that D and E are independent as well (the link between D and F remains but the arc from E to D is removed). How do I go about finding P(D|F) from P(D|E&amp;F) ?</p>
35,743
[ -0.018145151436328888, 0.019470691680908203, -0.034504484385252, 0.011964760720729828, 0.025234300643205643, -0.025124473497271538, -0.003972434904426336, 0.0028064644429832697, 0.04306110367178917, 0.0039535160176455975, 0.03558468446135521, 0.049521882086992264, 0.04592501372098923, 0.03052074834704399, 0.06599107384681702, 0.0349852591753006, 0.0038418229669332504, -0.009746122173964977, 0.01722477376461029, -0.03911524638533592, -0.0037064682692289352, 0.005376387853175402, 0.03474495932459831, -0.021845882758498192, 0.009472868405282497, 0.07710228860378265, 0.043746162205934525, -0.023002970963716507, 0.021762529388070107, 0.04660898819565773, -0.010060323402285576, -0.05338072031736374, 0.022357556968927383, 0.014530565589666367, 0.017776500433683395, 0.0005050660111010075, -0.013992086984217167, -0.0075971102342009544, -0.013416713103652, 0.03384175896644592, -0.02219710685312748, -0.03815826401114464, -0.027376821264624596, 0.041021764278411865, -0.03364082798361778, -0.005328943952918053, 0.049461085349321365, -0.02477344311773777, 0.0757875069975853, -0.024831267073750496, 0.09659555554389954, -0.05413316562771797, 0.0314943827688694, 0.03650113567709923, -0.033138345927000046, -0.03336639702320099, 0.045217134058475494, 0.055124033242464066, 0.033304959535598755, -0.04508640617132187, -0.045296717435121536, -0.04676037281751633, -0.014731064438819885, -0.033813536167144775, -0.035925038158893585, 0.025478485971689224, -0.017976364120841026, -0.029828589409589767, 0.0080542778596282, -0.012529030442237854, -0.03819803521037102, 0.018089672550559044, 0.05740837752819061, -0.00499772559851408, -0.002147446386516094, -0.02377992682158947, -0.00016758128185756505, 0.04237990453839302, 0.021312318742275238, 0.02710939757525921, -0.030496718361973763, 0.0021731460001319647, 0.006654203869402409, 0.0486103780567646, -0.009279832243919373, -0.04033198207616806, 0.03273787721991539, -0.04007692262530327, -0.0027392255142331123, -0.0007745836628600955, -0.05289687216281891, -0.01724076084792614, 0.07336721569299698, 0.01074259914457798, -0.0450323149561882, 0.028323419392108917, -0.027014102786779404, 0.039752308279275894, 0.00386590464040637, -0.015092894434928894, -0.026241762563586235, -0.04958290979266167, 0.023757625371217728, 0.05304256081581116, -0.01020236499607563, 0.022925131022930145, -0.02481171302497387, 0.02602752298116684, -0.020552996546030045, -0.03594176843762398, -0.01377900317311287, 0.02436932921409607, 0.02694893814623356, 0.031030526384711266, -0.017570508643984795, -0.025736892595887184, -0.0284933652728796, -0.01399596780538559, 0.059034090489149094, 0.05450465902686119, 0.007209030445665121, -0.011498086154460907, 0.02816019207239151, -0.025880856439471245, -0.061314888298511505, -0.02342149056494236, 0.00007187940354924649, -0.022063041105866432, -0.001427343930117786, 0.04038407653570175, -0.012372635304927826, -0.017275918275117874, 0.017465414479374886, -0.0004538515640888363, -0.005075907800346613, 0.0019953942392021418, -0.07143481820821762, -0.04315493628382683, 0.024572500959038734, -0.00021072635718155652, -0.023330161347985268, -0.06307917088270187, 0.035437632352113724, 0.06918217986822128, 0.06517335027456284, -0.0028171769808977842, 0.01796920783817768, -0.009315377101302147, 0.012737341225147247, 0.011384398676455021, -0.01661784015595913, -0.034328050911426544, -0.03649556636810303, -0.006513128522783518, -0.02516455203294754, -0.06573804467916489, 0.016352739185094833, -0.012136210687458515, -0.044378671795129776, -0.01807769387960434, 0.039994094520807266, 0.0090959332883358, -0.03401334583759308, -0.015251211822032928, -0.036445651203393936, -0.028181128203868866, 0.08672638982534409, -0.004135260358452797, -0.004271127749234438, 0.03627469018101692, -0.017331238836050034, 0.03405935317277908, -0.003382445778697729, 0.04686587676405907, 0.02942114882171154, -0.019403813406825066, -0.04696173220872879, 0.0017688915831968188, 0.031600311398506165, 0.0007625576108694077, -0.010274644941091537, -0.02948085591197014, -0.015989847481250763, -0.010869442485272884, 0.013818798586726189, 0.026827607303857803, 0.00818257499486208, -0.039086222648620605, 0.021114874631166458, -0.026445822790265083, -0.01497640460729599, -0.06015404686331749, 0.020668216049671173, 0.004811830818653107, -0.009917935356497765, 0.010157445445656776, 0.013834084384143353, 0.018128037452697754, -0.028334930539131165, -0.028872452676296234, -0.0472123883664608, -0.005380616988986731, 0.03297635540366173, -0.05259834602475166, 0.014997857622802258, 0.040488604456186295, 0.06916005164384842, -0.01570560410618782, 0.04489268362522125, -0.035865914076566696, -0.0017591711366549134, -0.01941387727856636, -0.015700604766607285, -0.035882942378520966, -0.01110657025128603, -0.0026560858823359013, 0.02194642834365368, 0.015423770062625408, 0.01851930469274521, -0.008571797050535679, -0.0518677644431591, 0.07784601300954819, 0.04183268919587135, 0.03656765818595886, 0.004285020753741264, 0.01321395207196474, 0.004883454646915197, 0.03533387556672096, 0.00597338704392314, -0.02942654676735401, -0.04111572355031967, 0.0014228515792638063, 0.014236178249120712, 0.00048434341442771256, -0.024288639426231384, 0.012766776606440544, 0.04861624911427498, -0.011433301493525505, -0.0012152227573096752, 0.04394898936152458, -0.009077213704586029, -0.0012912192614749074, 0.03682711720466614, 0.019910937175154686, 0.004476908594369888, -0.0035026248078793287, 0.012799904681742191, 0.034336306154727936, 0.03786527365446091, -0.02296801656484604, -0.03540970757603645, -0.0030030841007828712, 0.00024307276180479676, 0.0035109706223011017, -0.033018868416547775, -0.007943443953990936, 0.03325328230857849, 0.01732090674340725, -0.004541307687759399, 0.037227410823106766, -0.005266193300485611, -0.02272004820406437, -0.009578006342053413, -0.03694441169500351, 0.02400060184299946, 0.01350784208625555, -0.06623352319002151, 0.008445322513580322, 0.03198033198714256, 0.01950662024319172, 0.06929215788841248, -0.02278539165854454, -0.01113004982471466, -0.02640421688556671, 0.045605216175317764, 0.005731502547860146, -0.03258958458900452, 0.016834350302815437, -0.002039227867498994, -0.038029927760362625, -0.020812610164284706, -0.01673109643161297, 0.017492178827524185, -0.001545937149785459, -0.08399330079555511, -0.03911256417632103, -0.004245875868946314, -0.0186109971255064, 0.008718316443264484, 0.0001312403182964772, -0.04202893003821373, -0.009504090063273907, 0.000440587435150519, -0.021372878924012184, -0.035743292421102524, -0.021135929971933365, -0.0034437004942446947, -0.037511248141527176, -0.0005538933910429478, 0.021422984078526497, 0.022337153553962708, 0.00896980706602335, 0.02812219224870205, -0.05507766455411911, 0.002702950267121196, 0.0010419331956654787, -0.02557874470949173, 0.001247745007276535, 0.042990803718566895, 0.043670330196619034, 0.005263343919068575, 0.006925190333276987, 0.015460148453712463, -0.05895354226231575, -0.07715146988630295, 0.015412824228405952, 0.04830263927578926, -0.007741312030702829, 0.02386000193655491, -0.021267838776111603, 0.04546074569225311, 0.03873973339796066, -0.030459782108664513, -0.01056741178035736, 0.003158883424475789, -0.013794015161693096, -0.04109976068139076, 0.011332238093018532, 0.044853001832962036, 0.013240475207567215, 0.014112227596342564, -0.016703402623534203, 0.004992074333131313, 0.05793686956167221, 0.01799749583005905, 0.012027495540678501, 0.04085885360836983, 0.015776541084051132, -0.03105904534459114, 0.03711971268057823, 0.02677861973643303, -0.028450962156057358, 0.0262818094342947, 0.02465548738837242, 0.022782377898693085, -0.017360670492053032, -0.03819897398352623, -0.04796544462442398, 0.0007336366106756032, 0.014216937124729156, -0.02715465985238552, 0.024732312187552452, 0.0019443753408268094, -0.010620085522532463, 0.03662934899330139, 0.025243282318115234, 0.04110341519117355, -0.02225661836564541, 0.02272530272603035, 0.06595480442047119, -0.008614873513579369, -0.0170340146869421, -0.01391329150646925, -0.025010189041495323, -0.008601073175668716, 0.009870159439742565, -0.005342327058315277, -0.020844873040914536, 0.040789369493722916, 0.0009365386213175952, 0.02741486020386219, -0.0027577884029597044, -0.014536297880113125, -0.016124948859214783, -0.02774454653263092, 0.026829931885004044, -0.002029597060754895, 0.01723332703113556, -0.020972896367311478, 0.0403168611228466, 0.003949387464672327, 0.02169153280556202, 0.014232227578759193, -0.002039797604084015, -0.06590402126312256, 0.005401965696364641, -0.007285078521817923, -0.0451965369284153, -0.023344002664089203, -0.014105444774031639, 0.03675343468785286, -0.04743701592087746, 0.026675447821617126, -0.007794433739036322, 0.013871816918253899, -0.04965405911207199, 0.0004170799511484802, -0.03407585993409157, -0.013297254219651222, 0.012187681160867214, 0.004026991780847311, 0.029965266585350037, -0.004912437871098518, 0.016554875299334526, 0.04942483827471733, -0.03905876353383064, -0.01827765628695488, -0.02562861330807209, 0.008530838415026665, 0.006606084760278463, 0.02187349647283554, 0.053929999470710754, 0.07391061633825302, 0.005461202468723059, 0.018263280391693115, 0.005130089819431305, 0.03459252417087555, 0.07055939733982086, -0.050616420805454254, 0.01087244600057602, -0.04569299891591072, 0.0038012301083654165, -0.031057873740792274, 0.033936310559511185, -0.012317739427089691, 0.025788836181163788, 0.043842460960149765, 0.03966148570179939, -0.042508773505687714, -0.00676801847293973, 0.08685281872749329, 0.00500496244058013, -0.02777850069105625, -0.030495433136820793, -0.01417422853410244, -0.05274426192045212, 0.003692867700010538, 0.015754831954836845, 0.011726250872015953, -0.015673426911234856, -0.022341938689351082, 0.008295316249132156, -0.028104398399591446, 0.024804580956697464, -0.018690578639507294, -0.022346191108226776, 0.009484647773206234, 0.0075841727666556835, -0.03341224417090416, -0.009990161284804344, 0.028981000185012817, -0.033692676573991776, 0.06273198872804642, 0.010303227230906487, -0.05346293747425079, 0.023414205759763718, 0.05924680083990097, 0.0549728199839592, -0.04511340335011482, -0.004978272132575512, -0.056479547172784805, -0.03629704564809799, 0.05410817638039589, -0.017582247033715248, 0.050000544637441635, 0.0010932505829259753, 0.022763190791010857, 0.013653810136020184, -0.015530631877481937, -0.04267674311995506, -0.011529522947967052, -0.02937931753695011, 0.03176914155483246, -0.015850476920604706, -0.06083839386701584, -0.013593638315796852, -0.018240420147776604, 0.051720645278692245, 0.07153580337762833, -0.022429391741752625, -0.04622277617454529, -0.0043546343222260475, 0.01758914813399315, -0.0071771699003875256, -0.05927085503935814, 0.020786872133612633, -0.018212689086794853, -0.03188886493444443, 0.039697155356407166, -0.036408234387636185, -0.06973810493946075, 0.044641073793172836, -0.014956548810005188, -0.031960420310497284, 0.026919489726424217, 0.010651370510458946, 0.048418913036584854, 0.008657226338982582, -0.010901103727519512, 0.019917387515306473, 0.03516879677772522, -0.029141051694750786, -0.000530192453879863, -0.0592825710773468, 0.028897324576973915, -0.022999223321676254, 0.03774268180131912, -0.038004301488399506, 0.02674379199743271, -0.020862296223640442, 0.03215847909450531, 0.048831693828105927, 0.03769869729876518, -0.0022139959037303925, -0.025264428928494453, 0.010356477461755276, 0.03372811898589134, -0.04270142689347267, 0.013531431555747986, -0.016461914405226707, 0.022810278460383415, -0.009389190003275871, -0.02083970047533512, 0.022782035171985626, -0.033278271555900574, 0.022193940356373787, -0.00629982678219676, -0.04955412447452545, 0.027242058888077736, -0.035451654344797134, -0.05064111948013306, 0.0182704608887434, -0.04850514978170395, 0.011792773380875587, -0.0041651311330497265, 0.04082082211971283, -0.00024078688875306398, -0.027416113764047623, -0.015752369537949562, 0.011861713603138924, 0.01816808059811592, 0.02222830429673195, -0.046515367925167084, 0.0151047483086586, -0.050723232328891754, -0.015615053474903107, -0.05923975631594658, -0.041130583733320236, -0.0012542653130367398, -0.007428201846778393, -0.04155569151043892, -0.04563768953084946, 0.030117040500044823, -0.005892232526093721, 5.507102400770236e-7, -0.017580237239599228, 0.04930121824145317, -0.008909904398024082, 0.008376401849091053, 0.04913274198770523, -0.002881390741094947, 0.03686213120818138, 0.005067991558462381, -0.015158670954406261, 0.0027876931708306074, -0.020523376762866974, -0.00012622329813893884, 0.000582127773668617, 0.007568588946014643, -0.03016398847103119, -0.01892484910786152, -0.047733504325151443, 0.04830726981163025, 0.06015300378203392, -0.033466923981904984, 0.00243694637902081, -0.04101257398724556, 0.017038710415363312, 0.009833370335400105, -0.021045444533228874, -0.009789733216166496, 0.010162049904465675, 0.006504083517938852, 0.028737235814332962, 0.023681452497839928, 0.0021491842344403267, -0.029552944004535675, 0.004392292816191912, -0.042428724467754364, -0.010682313703000546, -0.00024522742023691535, 0.07948004454374313, -0.018514536321163177, 0.016594648361206055, 0.0014687031507492065, 0.02251589111983776, 0.04539790004491806, 0.002206136006861925, -0.014603149145841599, 0.02701181173324585, 0.030842430889606476, -0.045346103608608246, -0.02412341721355915, -0.05150221288204193, 0.00016448913083877414, 0.046710144728422165, -0.001428168616257608, 0.04429563879966736, 0.015156005509197712, 0.04499407857656479, -0.000843001005705446, -0.016360661014914513, 0.0008202838944271207, 0.0031996590550988913, -0.005791871342808008, 0.04156878590583801, -0.01521463692188263, 0.0062521533109247684, 0.06100213900208473, 0.014979143626987934, 0.012069289572536945, -0.005320897325873375, 0.01751124858856201, 0.005500021390616894, 0.07851626724004745, -0.02084132842719555, 0.01422159094363451, 0.024666678160429, -0.02859687991440296, 0.02461336739361286, -0.007059071678668261, -0.031254593282938004, 0.08493632078170776, 0.040747519582509995, -0.030885057523846626, -0.033699166029691696, -0.027346154674887657, -0.030885718762874603, 0.00871361419558525, 0.014358178712427616, -0.000981334364041686, 0.036339107900857925, 0.015250607393682003, 0.01335185393691063, 0.008374393917620182, 0.01454105693846941, -0.024631444364786148, -0.04886705428361893, -0.058704227209091187, -0.033916108310222626, 0.0026232965756207705, 0.025088626891374588, 0.014301585033535957, -0.010065846145153046, 0.03571499139070511, -0.004131299443542957, -0.018430551514029503, 0.015097412280738354, 0.04742623120546341, -0.027639565989375114, 0.0710054337978363, 0.008861580863595009, 0.025457117706537247, 0.02103974111378193, -0.017040016129612923, 0.09325100481510162, 0.06591898202896118, 0.023404717445373535, -0.04442698881030083, 0.0541640967130661, 0.033503204584121704, -0.01690395548939705, -0.05824292451143265, 0.03642028570175171, 0.02684735506772995, 0.0005945927696302533, 0.032746799290180206, 0.031303901225328445, 0.03668930009007454, 0.0012422543950378895, 0.02681799978017807, -0.050140630453825, -0.025224175304174423, 0.0065668304450809956, 0.0454227589070797, -0.03839312493801117, -0.057488828897476196, -0.044594790786504745, 0.010276418179273605, -0.008844371885061264, -0.030430860817432404, -0.05197205767035484, -0.008527050726115704, 0.025426246225833893, -0.02838650904595852, 0.02705325372517109, -0.008985141292214394, -0.003803048748522997, 0.0023350496776401997, 0.011901198886334896, 0.027003327384591103, 0.020764760673046112, -0.014501024037599564, 0.013022352010011673, 0.019771967083215714, 0.01171075738966465, 0.00012456435069907457, -0.0056280652061104774, -0.01202482357621193, -0.01524462178349495, -0.054289449006319046, -0.011033306829631329, 0.0680520310997963, 0.0013220903929322958, -0.025386931374669075, -0.006836351007223129, -0.020082786679267883, -0.009246937930583954, -0.08331847935914993, 0.006042872089892626, 0.02817085199058056, 0.03290925547480583, 0.008870507590472698, -0.0028831481467932463, 0.00663980096578598, 0.044947147369384766, -0.003621116280555725, 0.025589941069483757, 0.03006531111896038, 0.022433411329984665, -0.00324618280865252, -0.03584975004196167, 0.07142817229032516, 0.04688102379441261, -0.016955599188804626, 0.002330468501895666, -0.0444628931581974, -0.0071185315027832985, -0.0014310721307992935, 0.032445382326841354, -0.012361720204353333, -0.022561028599739075, -0.017381610348820686, -0.0014287984231486917, 0.0006763591663911939, -0.025226900354027748, 0.005470342468470335, -0.03293342515826225, -0.010933320969343185, -0.01657252386212349, -0.0021871805656701326, 0.028287416324019432, 0.03908122330904007, 0.006291890982538462, -0.003141651162877679, 0.012296458706259727, 0.03087502159178257, 0.0127834752202034, -0.05755774304270744, -0.012739862315356731, -0.023138929158449173, 0.003512824885547161, 0.028381086885929108, -0.01298961229622364, 0.06082460656762123, 0.011093134060502052, 0.01824234053492546, -0.0009008566266857088, 0.0332377627491951, -0.015136419795453548, 0.0210207961499691, -0.04296804964542389, -0.052296653389930725, 0.00023237925779540092, -0.0011743324575945735, -0.048268817365169525, -0.012685975059866905, 0.004236292093992233, -0.026028834283351898, -0.021702684462070465, 0.04311222583055496, 0.011010486632585526, -0.05751863494515419, -0.0039045982994139194, 0.012883931398391724, 0.02949688583612442, -0.027483511716127396, 0.005582717247307301, -0.014490549452602863, -0.03073335625231266, 0.0018063177121803164, -0.011012418195605278, -0.04611939936876297, 0.05817711725831032, 0.005854667630046606, -0.013689426705241203, 0.029087400063872337, 0.026461010798811913, 0.011666500940918922, -0.05277056246995926, 0.03628992661833763, 0.020715951919555664, 0.05013842135667801, -0.05332548916339874, -0.013026133179664612, 0.031089743599295616, -0.045575037598609924, 0.010339475236833096, 0.028812404721975327, 0.04280218854546547, 0.05269736424088478, -0.018779246136546135, -0.016776282340288162, 0.015947440639138222, 0.035738274455070496, -0.03176267817616463, -0.019383704289793968, 0.014402220025658607, 0.040623974055051804, -0.015487593598663807, 0.024055810645222664, -0.024762505665421486, 0.005740342196077108, -0.007445789407938719, 0.016028454527258873, 0.031219858676195145, 0.004029621835798025, -0.019441768527030945, 0.027718596160411835, 0.018762387335300446, 0.0034841024316847324, 0.025573264807462692, -0.006965726148337126, 0.016195200383663177, 0.042541515082120895, 0.022028807550668716, 0.025124171748757362, -0.012952674180269241, 0.04121580719947815, -0.0905567929148674, 0.006187260150909424, -0.008148528635501862, 0.005417224485427141, 0.08436934649944305, -0.050519250333309174, 0.03429548442363739, 0.03616352751851082, -0.0425868034362793, -0.0014270301908254623, 0.004696177784353495, 0.029254741966724396, -0.02613123320043087, 0.024003131315112114, -0.04442860186100006, 0.04548557102680206, 0.0218107420951128, 0.042493268847465515, 0.06518661230802536, -0.000483336130855605, -0.03707060590386391, -0.05329745262861252, -0.053085941821336746, 0.01720549538731575, 0.01458641979843378, -0.04215507209300995, 0.0077783530578017235, -0.05607068911194801, -0.02270490489900112, 0.034880172461271286, 0.03333521634340286, -0.024300143122673035, -0.011564383283257484, 0.02994670160114765, 0.05153219774365425, 0.02700016275048256, -0.006266095209866762, 0.003174776444211602, 0.021752312779426575, -0.019611377269029617, -0.014986247755587101, 0.007150460500270128, -0.01090910378843546, 0.0032550760079175234, 0.012641973793506622, -0.015842506662011147, -0.041679587215185165, -0.004058717284351587, -0.01559174433350563, 0.029156237840652466, 0.010859222151339054, -0.008685408160090446, -0.020656315609812737, -0.02618519961833954, -0.006217935122549534, -0.07849452644586563, 0.01851882040500641, 0.05586417019367218, 0.024114226922392845, -0.001022339565679431, -0.001267269835807383, -0.03806409612298012, -0.03445430472493172, 0.010704107582569122, -0.02681085094809532, -0.0009145555086433887, -0.069584921002388, -0.005214259028434753, -0.002099923323839903, 0.0035450421273708344, 0.010427732951939106, -0.04092440381646156, -0.04628390818834305, 0.030200090259313583, -0.03138969466090202, -0.007557414472103119, 0.011167810298502445, -0.011299347504973412, 0.029672592878341675, -0.07346930354833603, 0.05732424184679985, 0.005045642144978046, -0.05379244685173035, -0.04685937613248825, 0.023900315165519714, -0.019726181402802467, -0.002983640180900693, 0.024522559717297554, -0.026641223579645157, 0.026947475969791412, -0.029392775148153305, 0.0006554915453307331, 0.02469944767653942, -0.04184096306562424, 0.05391497164964676, -0.0441252775490284, -0.0021860322449356318, -0.030507802963256836, -0.016944829374551773, 0.028411759063601494, 0.011739957146346569, -0.030571479350328445, 0.0024786824360489845, -0.02101833000779152, -0.0048918635584414005, -0.00834010262042284, -0.010274465195834637, -0.04875645041465759, 0.012185263447463512, 0.04267195239663124, -0.034227848052978516, 0.018078096210956573, 0.02628031186759472, 0.013453821651637554, -0.07272116094827652, 0.05136281996965408, -0.034759845584630966, -0.03873796761035919, -0.023613661527633667, 0.0007710285135544837, -0.0025590911973267794, -0.0944305807352066, 0.006530506070703268, 0.02227715216577053, -0.0688406452536583, -0.002833303064107895, 0.02041611447930336, -0.0004685161111410707, 0.05062827840447426, 0.014523131772875786, 0.02275332808494568, -0.012569926679134369, -0.033081214874982834, 0.01199245359748602, 0.025129759684205055, 0.039485059678554535, -0.004018721170723438, 0.05966789275407791, 0.03404294326901436, -0.030324123799800873, 0.042307525873184204, -0.010448296554386616, 0.03183336555957794, 0.005173607263714075, -0.0077069224789738655, 0.013483884744346142, 0.001252552610822022, 0.012024632655084133, 0.02525760419666767, -0.018113814294338226, 0.022117940708994865, -0.014745407737791538, 0.02743840217590332, -0.01518517080694437, -0.0032007715199142694, -0.02879943512380123, 0.048410672694444656, 0.02287551388144493, 0.05091182887554169, -0.006092032417654991, 0.014491830952465534, 0.01928086392581463, -0.0009128855890594423, 0.010407188907265663, -0.01803256943821907, -0.0022063255310058594, -0.013494381681084633, 0.00725313276052475, 0.02255355753004551, 0.011467383243143559, -0.05459935963153839, -0.01660342700779438, -0.0025856459978967905, 0.016485076397657394, 0.008862496353685856, -0.02027823217213154, -0.026620279997587204, -0.006140983197838068, 0.014715619385242462, -0.02337091602385044, -0.009580147452652454, -0.036671631038188934, 0.04671120271086693, -0.001219031517393887, -0.013114809058606625 ]
<p>I used the MATLAB interface of libsvm for doing binary classification of 997-dimensional training data. I am trying to understand how the resulting model is used to compute the predicted output (which we get by calling <code>svmpredict</code>)</p> <p>The model contains fields (it has linear kernel):</p> <pre><code>nSV = [546; 246]; totalSV=792; rho = 0.093 and svCoeff [792x1 double] and SVs [792x997 double] </code></pre> <p>I thought that we must be simply multiplying svCoeff with SVs to get a [997x1] matrix which we then multiply with the actual feature, before shareholding by rho. But that's not the case. Can someone illustrate with a simple equation how these parameters are used to do classification?</p>
73,398
[ -0.0012614422012120485, -0.016604628413915634, 0.010904589667916298, -0.026978719979524612, 0.0019153556786477566, -0.011694167740643024, -0.030185634270310402, 0.004321145359426737, 0.036503199487924576, -0.008610179647803307, 0.03210978955030441, 0.015238814055919647, 0.04305429384112358, 0.008597251027822495, 0.011824235320091248, 0.0032371769193559885, 0.004164441954344511, 0.007338972762227058, -0.003629254875704646, -0.003939295653253794, -0.005709894001483917, 0.020853959023952484, 0.015836285427212715, -0.012827672995626926, 0.0021834855433553457, 0.07505688071250916, 0.027481455355882645, -0.016409078612923622, 0.021565526723861694, 0.030427860096096992, -0.018257424235343933, -0.04370410367846489, 0.012711375951766968, 0.015280503779649734, 0.01023602019995451, 0.02256094664335251, -0.01468969788402319, -0.039010822772979736, 0.022577030584216118, 0.02218208648264408, 0.005340582225471735, 0.0017979906406253576, -0.019496599212288857, 0.05802660435438156, -0.02104644477367401, 0.019421741366386414, 0.0048465910367667675, -0.025784064084291458, 0.04816131293773651, -0.02294272743165493, 0.06352686136960983, 0.035816632211208344, 0.04104876518249512, 0.0029087630100548267, -0.009121243841946125, 0.03841928765177727, 0.01687674969434738, 0.05206965655088425, 0.025555888190865517, -0.03641372546553612, 0.012692547403275967, -0.0006694909534417093, -0.03443658724427223, -0.0272109042853117, 0.010943268425762653, 0.03437458351254463, -0.03169899061322212, -0.03281942009925842, 0.048595886677503586, -0.0016865422949194908, 0.03288785740733147, 0.016557488590478897, 0.002935068216174841, -0.05229761078953743, 0.028626592829823494, -0.047970958054065704, 0.004133226349949837, 0.01606888510286808, 0.01415154431015253, -0.009772323071956635, 0.010212812572717667, 0.05104022100567818, -0.031280048191547394, 0.05258762463927269, -0.0008319643675349653, -0.013990277424454689, 0.04237673059105873, 0.0012078884756192565, 0.055998578667640686, 0.015394174493849277, -0.026817554607987404, 0.04281379282474518, 0.007802813779562712, -0.010226706974208355, -0.05355197936296463, 0.042198799550533295, -0.010384468361735344, 0.04023570939898491, 0.04356122016906738, -0.04264521226286888, -0.01893363520503044, -0.0043809800408780575, -0.013377783820033073, 0.042166754603385925, -0.04262971505522728, -0.01344934944063425, -0.028263485059142113, 0.010544114746153355, -0.02299315482378006, -0.02561664767563343, -0.006766702979803085, 0.014207984320819378, 0.026517679914832115, -0.0229633916169405, 0.009269816800951958, -0.03651463985443115, 0.006513729691505432, -0.014051666483283043, 0.007214927114546299, 0.04353206604719162, 0.00816560722887516, -0.0322105698287487, 0.018229560926556587, -0.020311782136559486, -0.05793140083551407, 0.011306452564895153, 0.02572077512741089, -0.004610759671777487, -0.06586246192455292, 0.042501918971538544, 0.017700280994176865, -0.06867071986198425, 0.04051430523395538, -0.00955137424170971, 0.011759561486542225, -0.02694682963192463, -0.06257891654968262, -0.06880216300487518, 0.05021320655941963, -0.010478547774255276, 0.03778921440243721, -0.03082411363720894, 0.03753738850355148, 0.03309749811887741, 0.05764329433441162, -0.008251754567027092, 0.05280977860093117, 0.023815691471099854, 0.01778491400182247, 0.006760118994861841, -0.024330509826540947, -0.0011709699174389243, -0.006968564819544554, -0.00929243490099907, -0.02161400392651558, -0.025507096201181412, 0.00002077637327602133, 0.009318813681602478, -0.022708334028720856, -0.00018065969925373793, -0.01484637800604105, 0.018019679933786392, -0.006268247030675411, 0.005676655564457178, -0.05103158578276634, -0.04249078035354614, 0.03477161377668381, -0.007457214407622814, 0.04981549084186554, 0.04462246224284172, -0.014124376699328423, 0.008555572479963303, 0.021245645359158516, 0.0752510130405426, 0.03732265904545784, 0.06145092472434044, 0.00431028613820672, -0.04534192383289337, 0.05771607905626297, -0.007173525635153055, -0.07352891564369202, -0.05782588571310043, -0.00805710069835186, 0.040357571095228195, 0.03038434311747551, 0.04580358788371086, 0.00794946402311325, -0.011412741616368294, 0.0202499870210886, -0.0036341985687613487, -0.04371482878923416, -0.024775510653853416, 0.011587025597691536, -0.02545715682208538, -0.02880607545375824, 0.0015173478750512004, 0.0053811753168702126, 0.007246227469295263, 0.026399487629532814, -0.00727201160043478, -0.07378043234348297, -0.004042717628180981, 0.06108205020427704, -0.049361519515514374, 0.004177745431661606, 0.01854133978486061, 0.043279215693473816, -0.016391174867749214, 0.03841737285256386, -0.02452835440635681, -0.02363757975399494, 0.02185088023543358, -0.0060182358138263226, 0.011782181449234486, -0.02673248201608658, -0.025782331824302673, 0.0025368710048496723, 0.033191557973623276, 0.01454296987503767, -0.010666469112038612, -0.032584261149168015, 0.049536995589733124, 0.08068819344043732, 0.013319754041731358, 0.00948200561106205, 0.030358608812093735, -0.0022255827207118273, 0.00616555567830801, -0.006130573805421591, -0.012686398811638355, -0.012773893773555756, -0.03451363742351532, 0.030457988381385803, 0.013006065972149372, -0.02016499452292919, 0.010516907088458538, 0.017102908343076706, 0.009964561089873314, 0.043219517916440964, 0.03972639888525009, -0.02060004696249962, 0.030776284635066986, 0.008908366784453392, 0.015507680363953114, -0.012103237211704254, -0.03001851588487625, 0.016333581879734993, 0.019806131720542908, 0.033670973032712936, 0.008171353489160538, -0.03247394785284996, 0.05362222343683243, -0.0244571715593338, -0.013029512017965317, -0.007038257084786892, 0.006553380750119686, 0.04864368960261345, 0.0033032000064849854, -0.009034724906086922, 0.05040285736322403, -0.019609645009040833, 0.004663304425776005, -0.03235854208469391, -0.02221626415848732, 0.029209638014435768, 0.05701383948326111, -0.03617226332426071, -0.0036939717829227448, 0.01763978600502014, -0.08334039151668549, 0.03516879305243492, -0.013109857216477394, -0.00473622465506196, -0.052025213837623596, 0.08203092217445374, 0.05307187885046005, -0.006973715033382177, 0.023497479036450386, -0.026021793484687805, -0.04286722093820572, -0.012554884888231754, -0.03380904346704483, 0.04234444722533226, 0.01777184009552002, -0.07946835458278656, 0.019563697278499603, -0.04830120503902435, -0.04589049890637398, 0.016789371147751808, 0.02417362481355667, -0.04468768462538719, 0.0068138362839818, -0.04742132127285004, -0.041254911571741104, -0.04219212010502815, 0.0005123951705172658, 0.0019350299844518304, 0.01784796454012394, 0.02436724677681923, 0.03010961413383484, -0.01500669401139021, -0.02502855472266674, 0.014369816519320011, -0.048059962689876556, -0.03165728971362114, -0.0281542856246233, -0.01467042788863182, -0.0006953691481612623, -0.022791273891925812, 0.014179762452840805, 0.019012274220585823, -0.018125522881746292, -0.0010488486150279641, -0.04669046401977539, -0.05969583988189697, 0.012292706407606602, 0.004997940268367529, 0.01678951270878315, 0.03808945417404175, 0.010361708700656891, 0.07779934257268906, 0.02243296056985855, -0.027162862941622734, -0.02471417933702469, 0.03484204411506653, -0.04033871367573738, 0.002486682031303644, 0.02814825065433979, 0.01311345212161541, -0.0019330201903358102, 0.0176170002669096, 0.0076245274394750595, 0.023599866777658463, 0.0751078650355339, -0.0005607101484201849, -0.02037125825881958, 0.01327157486230135, -0.011777072213590145, -0.032142724841833115, 0.03681258484721184, -0.014787742868065834, 0.003987461794167757, 0.00485899718478322, 0.007677743211388588, -0.0015905678737908602, -0.004136866424232721, -0.03139628469944, 0.003017985727638006, -0.012474080547690392, 0.02307918481528759, -0.047554027289152145, -0.011936252936720848, -0.006557561457157135, -0.03637341409921646, 0.027392026036977768, -0.0008889138116501272, 0.04796263575553894, -0.03745238110423088, 0.004493405111134052, -0.0066314879804849625, 0.030564410611987114, -0.012703865766525269, -0.01050377357751131, -0.008595790714025497, 0.001594930188730359, 0.019432494416832924, -0.03206077590584755, 0.0008157335687428713, 0.054697051644325256, 0.028772864490747452, -0.0077370936051011086, -0.006640556734055281, -0.03297429904341698, 0.009640495292842388, -0.0636046975851059, -0.016041185706853867, -0.023960020393133163, 0.026556434109807014, -0.0028416169807314873, 0.049488745629787445, 0.0392945259809494, -0.009572463110089302, 0.05553579330444336, -0.00783596932888031, -0.04939157888293266, 0.02475738152861595, 0.026325495913624763, -0.03120221011340618, -0.007808594964444637, -0.05391010269522667, 0.05206519737839699, -0.031248344108462334, -0.01735980622470379, 0.023313302546739578, 0.009929614141583443, -0.08947800099849701, 0.004572810605168343, -0.002339262282475829, 0.0020306785590946674, -0.04537275806069374, -0.0065840003080666065, 0.024575624614953995, -0.03971400856971741, -0.005448505748063326, 0.02402050793170929, -0.012247275561094284, -0.006237727124243975, -0.015091908164322376, -0.002120943507179618, -0.02156434766948223, 0.031779225915670395, -0.004604052286595106, 0.043588582426309586, -0.06247923895716667, 0.006007559597492218, -0.004075940232723951, 0.07294919341802597, 0.05137969180941582, 0.01108538918197155, 0.010459164157509804, -0.06423844397068024, 0.003654876258224249, -0.008938719518482685, 0.01715880259871483, 0.0008037424413487315, 0.01586880162358284, 0.06671468913555145, 0.017995303496718407, -0.06115920469164848, -0.0012538268929347396, 0.09184769541025162, -0.005202686879783869, -0.019692160189151764, -0.03666001930832863, 0.027498304843902588, -0.01923191547393799, -0.0013303111772984266, 0.040891557931900024, 0.0317416675388813, -0.03079686127603054, -0.03774695843458176, 0.03939112275838852, -0.042863380163908005, -0.018444418907165527, 0.025490684434771538, 0.03250329941511154, 0.07655283063650131, -0.013659599237143993, 0.003866876708343625, 0.00867727492004633, 0.05583738163113594, 0.047947682440280914, 0.013919290155172348, -0.007798046804964542, -0.09298434108495712, -0.05208360031247139, 0.02726033516228199, 0.007307153195142746, -0.0431913286447525, -0.01677769050002098, -0.03378371521830559, -0.007255423814058304, -0.009371667169034481, -0.029692988842725754, 0.049081988632678986, 0.015208140946924686, 0.01438503060489893, -0.02101038210093975, 0.006963537074625492, -0.05886587128043175, 0.02088482305407524, -0.034295547753572464, 0.02632959559559822, -0.03930014744400978, -0.02337558940052986, -0.03234109655022621, 0.037448275834321976, 0.034940917044878006, 0.013653593137860298, -0.01749844290316105, -0.02574906498193741, 0.013633300550282001, 0.01814747042953968, -0.03507179394364357, -0.026815209537744522, 0.009524594992399216, 0.027058184146881104, -0.011433592066168785, 0.07148398458957672, -0.01594712771475315, -0.05501852184534073, 0.05810049921274185, 0.045229338109493256, -0.017790701240301132, -0.02155326120555401, -0.035952128469944, 0.008153432048857212, 0.03408646211028099, -0.017113571986556053, 0.05904562026262283, 0.012857671827077866, 0.0016375663690268993, 0.001908305799588561, -0.046704087406396866, 0.013267571106553078, 0.029636738821864128, -0.023047717288136482, -0.05138828605413437, 0.006742417346686125, -0.022373046725988388, 0.02852335385978222, 0.04610252380371094, 0.03975042328238487, -0.027981020510196686, 0.0015081173041835427, -0.04223429784178734, 0.005980955436825752, -0.027422171086072922, -0.022563615813851357, -0.0061359042301774025, 0.04287481680512428, 0.011508508585393429, -0.009728013537824154, -0.033988840878009796, -0.018992571160197258, -0.0027727107517421246, -0.00760267348960042, -0.031057603657245636, -0.0177385825663805, -0.0001964096154551953, 0.008562945760786533, 0.04205959662795067, -0.02115878276526928, 0.045748550444841385, -0.01516712550073862, -0.0076332371681928635, 0.020261704921722412, -0.06370260566473007, -0.006941702216863632, -0.026606962084770203, -0.02382548525929451, 0.029116440564393997, -0.017205897718667984, 0.0345611646771431, 0.011153115890920162, -0.005138722714036703, -0.056846100836992264, -0.050125546753406525, 0.033586639910936356, -0.03366122394800186, -0.0015093249967321754, -0.03836353123188019, 0.001969922101125121, -0.020924529060721397, -0.03766297921538353, 0.01553608849644661, 0.031067127361893654, -0.054667115211486816, -0.005575940478593111, 0.03136071190237999, 0.006550027057528496, 0.03120398335158825, -0.04330732300877571, 0.01238873228430748, 0.039366599172353745, 0.019310124218463898, -0.024838674813508987, 0.0625297874212265, -0.000888035399839282, -0.010815877467393875, -0.004686716478317976, -0.053455207496881485, -0.008330443874001503, 0.0682583898305893, 0.0004373710253275931, 0.011782429181039333, -0.011291127651929855, -0.006358138285577297, 0.015015858225524426, -0.018073396757245064, -0.031092632561922073, 0.02106228470802307, 0.005960347130894661, 0.002578180283308029, -0.025712911039590836, -0.0011665745405480266, 0.018354196101427078, 0.012480897828936577, 0.004788413178175688, 0.0032478957436978817, -0.0024545055348426104, 0.06112084910273552, -0.02685723453760147, 0.03328341990709305, -0.007913006469607353, -0.01974746212363243, 0.03984154388308525, 0.003511278424412012, 0.029944337904453278, 0.015651065856218338, 0.027651796117424965, -0.021453384310007095, 0.008615393191576004, -0.09410658478736877, 0.003284321166574955, 0.06113191694021225, -0.031479865312576294, 0.05589430406689644, 0.0326085165143013, -0.022053034976124763, -0.002315401565283537, -0.06452999264001846, -0.03447878733277321, -0.002547929063439369, -0.01934509538114071, 0.04310275614261627, 0.010474630631506443, -0.02767108380794525, 0.06532508134841919, 0.02558871917426586, -0.003997521474957466, 0.06690680235624313, 0.019055405631661415, -0.0026848786510527134, 0.023494744673371315, 0.0002711052948143333, -0.001994919264689088, 0.06222081184387207, 0.006576386280357838, -0.0018904001917690039, 0.004618061240762472, -0.010393187403678894, 0.05238790810108185, 0.01656060852110386, 0.027304543182253838, -0.07845718413591385, -0.01714467629790306, -0.04533234238624573, 0.0022433099802583456, -0.009381948038935661, -0.021210970357060432, 0.02402135543525219, -0.010523560456931591, 0.02588639222085476, 0.02665651962161064, 0.04393091797828674, -0.009509885683655739, -0.04347736015915871, -0.029664956033229828, -0.05890476703643799, -0.048903632909059525, 0.056199219077825546, 0.014192892238497734, -0.02482518181204796, 0.031698670238256454, -0.05622175335884094, 0.038366515189409256, -0.010131186805665493, 0.05517774447798729, -0.006394179072231054, 0.07283255457878113, -0.006931931246072054, 0.005514122545719147, 0.018467361107468605, 0.0043851882219314575, 0.11568178981542587, 0.04682566225528717, 0.04404356703162193, -0.04260227829217911, -0.00572223961353302, -0.0032069708686321974, -0.020317263901233673, -0.04354732483625412, -0.0073649464175105095, -0.009683744050562382, 0.018632199615240097, 0.030057227239012718, 0.00731125520542264, -0.0030346724670380354, 0.02462124079465866, 0.010699688456952572, -0.014277962036430836, -0.01255954522639513, 0.034379612654447556, -0.00728781521320343, 0.018658578395843506, -0.013777293264865875, -0.04090436175465584, 0.03659547492861748, 0.011476035229861736, -0.05672222003340721, -0.047781601548194885, -0.02217002399265766, 0.01889643631875515, 0.008016789332032204, 0.012645348906517029, 0.022260915488004684, 0.01763259619474411, 0.04287676140666008, 0.008656885474920273, 0.009303608909249306, 0.03875938057899475, -0.0028361172880977392, 0.010758517310023308, 0.030324943363666534, 0.012459949590265751, -0.01672534830868244, 0.0012672793818637729, -0.000499035872053355, -0.05312139913439751, -0.011317024938762188, -0.0402831956744194, 0.057286620140075684, 0.038858432322740555, -0.05716119334101677, -0.018259849399328232, -0.004853245336562395, -0.005732712801545858, -0.03282829746603966, -0.010212603956460953, 0.0026098955422639847, 0.009613003581762314, -0.014084246940910816, -0.021770840510725975, -0.028688253834843636, -0.017750149592757225, -0.03478823974728584, 0.026025980710983276, 0.02635100670158863, -0.058065250515937805, -0.01581718772649765, -0.040363047271966934, 0.04072977602481842, 0.00047777482541278005, -0.01185149047523737, 0.002919120015576482, 0.00648009916767478, -0.003954877145588398, -0.029469646513462067, 0.0034026452340185642, 0.024225959554314613, 0.007093447260558605, -0.04195311665534973, -0.023364324122667313, -0.003803335828706622, -0.05399029701948166, -0.016548024490475655, -0.0038091696333140135, 0.006991022266447544, -0.03906070441007614, 0.015086960047483444, -0.011664971709251404, 0.03081202693283558, -0.020606931298971176, -0.020456498488783836, 0.01953251101076603, 0.027352506294846535, 0.010860980488359928, -0.06163930892944336, -0.038329463452100754, 0.0171799473464489, -0.016246823593974113, 0.029478022828698158, 0.0007639374816790223, 0.04930553585290909, 0.03573436290025711, 0.002441238844767213, -0.02231695130467415, 0.03493428975343704, -0.02871345914900303, 0.02694464847445488, -0.00616107415407896, -0.02495991438627243, 0.0032042840030044317, -0.035966720432043076, -0.007729745469987392, -0.04544658958911896, -0.0004573181795421988, 0.006770165637135506, -0.00621921569108963, -0.011698438785970211, 0.025786254554986954, -0.05894837528467178, -0.01897411048412323, -0.02579820714890957, 0.03164033591747284, -0.021734902635216713, -0.028587644919753075, -0.017132604494690895, 0.060374580323696136, -0.012477333657443523, -0.015258891507983208, -0.029829252511262894, -0.011040220968425274, -0.015020781196653843, -0.008402601815760136, 0.023510044440627098, 0.014268673956394196, 0.04200780764222145, -0.0171110350638628, 0.026744363829493523, -0.009980508126318455, 0.038763243705034256, -0.0064115868881344795, 0.008327055722475052, 0.04142582044005394, -0.05626775696873665, -0.02073616534471512, -0.0014984599547460675, 0.004012225661426783, 0.028733860701322556, 0.009311244823038578, 0.016704099252820015, -0.013465841300785542, 0.07335050404071808, -0.03739158436655998, -0.007664141245186329, 0.004566943738609552, -0.029026711359620094, -0.011891762726008892, 0.029859714210033417, 0.016885096207261086, 0.00522166583687067, 0.0006257143104448915, 0.03668535500764847, -0.00632119458168745, -0.03982638940215111, -0.006044911686331034, 0.019376909360289574, -0.004809918813407421, 0.01254995632916689, 0.011010282672941685, -0.01830957643687725, 0.04458117485046387, 0.025447258725762367, -0.01841392181813717, 0.033210575580596924, -0.002570738550275564, 0.032227709889411926, -0.051353223621845245, -0.030927957966923714, -0.02862132154405117, 0.005560971796512604, 0.017975766211748123, -0.04588242992758751, 0.015223894268274307, 0.023863133043050766, -0.05808936804533005, 0.003289344720542431, 0.010340972803533077, -0.0017023050459101796, -0.041008513420820236, 0.019467689096927643, -0.032542821019887924, -0.011965872719883919, 0.04245388135313988, -0.02948518842458725, 0.049489568918943405, 0.005518923047930002, 0.002633783733472228, -0.037653420120477676, -0.014879792928695679, 0.014473918825387955, -0.022710701450705528, -0.03752868250012398, 0.02382201887667179, -0.027813298627734184, -0.02573038451373577, 0.0362052284181118, -0.023823332041502, -0.0022256288211792707, 0.07452155649662018, 0.02826439030468464, -0.0014899508096277714, 0.06315172463655472, 0.009067723527550697, -0.005721048917621374, 0.023646889254450798, 0.01688203029334545, 0.06115470454096794, -0.003332226537168026, 0.01654072105884552, 0.03505459055304527, 0.028837770223617554, -0.009030910208821297, -0.007892018184065819, 0.02266012877225876, -0.02790670096874237, -0.02873140014708042, -0.025523405522108078, -0.010198001749813557, 0.013082246296107769, -0.044795792549848557, 0.01989745907485485, -0.027105024084448814, -0.01183138508349657, -0.005963947158306837, -0.0227165799587965, -0.029648972675204277, 0.018579943105578423, -0.02066579833626747, -0.02235492318868637, -0.003946960438042879, 0.030922120437026024, -0.02585616707801819, -0.04863375797867775, -0.012037105858325958, 0.0657305121421814, -0.02544960007071495, -0.004800628405064344, -0.010480414144694805, -0.022121043875813484, 0.0754803717136383, -0.006733125075697899, 0.04605702683329582, 0.01770566776394844, -0.05431186035275459, 0.026755211874842644, -0.08733322471380234, 0.03736061975359917, 0.03721163049340248, -0.05538126826286316, -0.029570316895842552, -0.002988351508975029, -0.0031692874617874622, 0.006428791210055351, 0.025075586512684822, 0.017814014106988907, -0.0156119205057621, -0.0190822035074234, -0.003918015398085117, 0.03562944009900093, -0.05434117466211319, 0.030427956953644753, -0.010211066342890263, -0.025436757132411003, -0.017222652211785316, 0.004446443170309067, -0.009172208607196808, 0.018207382410764694, 0.004523030482232571, -0.013139404356479645, -0.032835058867931366, 0.006324879825115204, -0.03670249879360199, -0.011547201313078403, 0.05124272406101227, 0.007077671121805906, 0.04949124902486801, -0.006396715994924307, -0.0019332137890160084, 0.023179082199931145, -0.007429561112076044, -0.07163708657026291, -0.022497031837701797, -0.019284488633275032, -0.030641207471489906, -0.0030010754708200693, 0.024351486936211586, 0.03253604844212532, -0.08029209077358246, -0.009684529155492783, 0.031891003251075745, -0.047168225049972534, -0.015205593779683113, 0.06682799756526947, 0.02542448788881302, 0.03879455104470253, 0.013934146612882614, 0.05053113400936127, -0.014165041036903858, -0.02253255620598793, 0.006700738798826933, 0.047745898365974426, 0.04601367190480232, 0.019437581300735474, 0.023441724479198456, 0.041677892208099365, -0.02097156271338463, 0.016761470586061478, -0.032101914286613464, 0.01710496097803116, -0.030972251668572426, 0.0037107872776687145, -0.022270597517490387, -0.022862058132886887, 0.028047891333699226, 0.01001361571252346, -0.01617521606385708, 0.10664283484220505, -0.04726819321513176, -0.031484976410865784, -0.04549446702003479, 0.001583623350597918, -0.016869457438588142, -0.0033949059434235096, 0.04088344797492027, 0.03338225930929184, 0.010114692151546478, 0.017582718282938004, 0.017031148076057434, -0.025125019252300262, 0.07915721833705902, -0.01066972129046917, 0.006677302531898022, 0.022156009450554848, 0.002965044928714633, 0.018217654898762703, 0.004634136334061623, 0.0018246544059365988, -0.01883513107895851, 0.03128582611680031, 0.029512904584407806, 0.00447318609803915, 0.0002767571131698787, -0.0016326106851920485, -0.011523283086717129, -0.008111890405416489, -0.06959512084722519, -0.015782764181494713, -0.028984827920794487, 0.011450603604316711, -0.011144662275910378, -0.009657762944698334 ]
<p>How can I measure separability between different number of instance of one feature vector? For example the main vector is <code>V=[1 1 2 3 4 5 7 8 10 100 1000 99 999 54]</code> and three sub-vector with different sample lengths are <code>t1=[1 1 2 3 99 1000]</code> or <code>t2=[1 10 1000]</code> or <code>t3=[2 3 4 10 100 99 999 54]</code>.</p> <p>Which one is more separable and more informative? I mean I am looking for a sub-vector with minimum length and maximum separability power.</p> <p>If I put it in GMM, the sub-vector with less samples has better probability which is not fairly approach.</p> <pre><code>train=[1 2 1 2 1 2 100 101 102 99 100 101 1000 1001 999 1003]; No_of_Iterations=10; No_of_Clusters=3; [mm,vv,ww]=gaussmix(train,[],No_of_Iterations,No_of_Clusters); test1=[1 1 1 2 2 2 100 100 100 101 1000 1000 1000]; test2=[1 1 2 2 100 99 1000 999]; test3=[1 100 1000]; [lp,rp,kh,kp]=gaussmixp(test1,mm,vv,ww); sum(lp) [lp,rp,kh,kp]=gaussmixp(test2,mm,vv,ww); sum(lp) [lp,rp,kh,kp]=gaussmixp(test3,mm,vv,ww); sum(lp) </code></pre> <p>The results are as follow :</p> <pre><code>ans = -8.0912e+05 ans = -8.1782e+05 ans = -5.0381e+05 </code></pre> <p>I will really appreciate, if you could help me.</p>
73,399
[ -0.020041899755597115, 0.008241426199674606, -0.013829205185174942, -0.029764456674456596, 0.04242229089140892, 0.0009805104928091168, -0.036436449736356735, -0.07075900584459305, 0.026180019602179527, -0.0016016531735658646, 0.04815944656729698, 0.06595767289400101, 0.036755941808223724, 0.018120426684617996, 0.01809961348772049, 0.0025792522355914116, -0.007671027909964323, -0.0049489219672977924, 0.028323335573077202, -0.02465352788567543, -0.034231189638376236, 0.01041919831186533, 0.04861465469002724, -0.04140862450003624, -0.052404534071683884, 0.04243117570877075, 0.031813740730285645, -0.020990950986742973, 0.018049493432044983, 0.029893748462200165, -0.04918582737445831, -0.060463279485702515, 0.01876331865787506, 0.050193000584840775, 0.006321266293525696, 0.011106008663773537, -0.035869792103767395, -0.02388872392475605, -0.011458445340394974, 0.013260407373309135, -0.029772337526082993, -0.015965664759278297, -0.007473430130630732, 0.02707855775952339, -0.00936130154877901, 0.034783974289894104, 0.03556369990110397, -0.035527706146240234, 0.03236052393913269, -0.04879118129611015, 0.02872086502611637, 0.021798942238092422, 0.019629046320915222, 0.00452458905056119, 0.011463472619652748, 0.011950998567044735, 0.016775278374552727, 0.07507944107055664, -0.032300710678100586, -0.03369181975722313, 0.008309757336974144, -0.019452666863799095, 0.03716201335191727, 0.004499536938965321, -0.006927618756890297, 0.037761181592941284, -0.022423632442951202, -0.03528406098484993, 0.05733519047498703, -0.03667702525854111, 0.031014440581202507, 0.007746952585875988, 0.03783773258328438, -0.059016335755586624, 0.024926109239459038, -0.019641088321805, -0.01544768363237381, 0.04566030204296112, 0.02985316701233387, -0.0005432544276118279, 0.041099678725004196, -0.01772606000304222, -0.009264876134693623, 0.04597892612218857, 0.04856822267174721, -0.02789744734764099, 0.06688053160905838, -0.02435774728655815, -0.0020594759844243526, 0.03781928867101669, -0.026437170803546906, 0.012333777733147144, 0.01879383996129036, 0.057451460510492325, -0.03287858888506889, 0.05004638805985451, -0.007191664073616266, 0.009139815345406532, 0.014286256395280361, 0.006462334655225277, -0.04272410646080971, -0.05237627774477005, -0.00275740516372025, 0.06264880299568176, -0.03294769674539566, 0.0003516855067573488, -0.0264941044151783, -0.005728049203753471, -0.008883431553840637, 0.00030454472289420664, 0.0012738131918013096, 0.03187514841556549, 0.02679886855185032, -0.028062153607606888, 0.04459201171994209, -0.01794307306408882, 0.018690407276153564, 0.0111998924985528, 0.02496437542140484, 0.10257276147603989, 0.037364859133958817, -0.041908226907253265, 0.01629454456269741, -0.03978152573108673, -0.044039350003004074, 0.011717597022652626, -0.0072060851380229, 0.0027679100167006254, -0.028437776491045952, 0.030394110828638077, -0.010690063238143921, -0.0126163549721241, 0.034696727991104126, -0.039131373167037964, 0.009814443998038769, -0.01830972731113434, -0.05116773769259453, -0.021357521414756775, 0.05054706335067749, -0.011478627100586891, 0.024000627920031548, -0.01970021240413189, 0.018272574990987778, -0.0038035360630601645, 0.022264262661337852, 0.027562187984585762, 0.08809961378574371, 0.01728815957903862, 0.019988417625427246, -0.016542157158255577, -0.03502311930060387, -0.005786063149571419, -0.034249160438776016, -0.005649436730891466, -0.005776670295745134, -0.06779906898736954, -0.03607155382633209, 0.024878956377506256, -0.031573306769132614, 0.01876816153526306, -0.010173515416681767, 0.022128324955701828, 0.027797695249319077, -0.016538769006729126, -0.01629018411040306, -0.013794942758977413, 0.06478893011808395, 0.004904859699308872, 0.0548543706536293, 0.02619221992790699, -0.01421722024679184, -0.016225503757596016, 0.0195739958435297, -0.017926229164004326, 0.04353410005569458, -0.02617921307682991, 0.003322485601529479, -0.005816155578941107, 0.04011331498622894, 0.019186818972229958, -0.01792437769472599, -0.03668868914246559, 0.010385522618889809, -0.00009581985796103254, 0.03709936887025833, 0.022464454174041748, 0.036856137216091156, 0.011771413497626781, 0.033777400851249695, -0.020371977239847183, -0.03225545212626457, -0.029162416234612465, 0.01003215741366148, 0.004843407776206732, -0.03892005980014801, 0.055906105786561966, -0.03492152690887451, 0.011078514158725739, 0.014567370526492596, -0.03300097957253456, -0.05666607618331909, -0.009223878383636475, 0.020112885162234306, -0.04941905662417412, -0.028417306020855904, 0.05309011787176132, 0.007683969102799892, -0.040252868086099625, 0.06469356268644333, -0.0018575243884697556, -0.01269365195184946, 0.027527861297130585, -0.004460243508219719, -0.00767764775082469, 0.0005510797491297126, -0.04451293125748634, 0.02577831596136093, 0.03862438723444939, -0.029388008639216423, 0.05132085829973221, -0.07698013633489609, 0.07001347839832306, 0.05774776637554169, 0.025730298832058907, -0.009974582120776176, -0.02655867673456669, -0.02931189350783825, 0.026589516550302505, -0.008320922031998634, 0.0202769935131073, -0.049544937908649445, -0.019386837258934975, 0.04887713864445686, 0.03586054593324661, -0.03496280312538147, 0.017931252717971802, 0.05102258175611496, -0.017728354781866074, -0.009312840178608894, 0.03786170110106468, 0.007773685734719038, -0.03531875088810921, 0.018757469952106476, 0.01202123798429966, -0.003110966645181179, -0.017198709771037102, 0.011446052230894566, 0.01836150512099266, 0.03177627548575401, 0.002746549667790532, -0.021869543939828873, 0.05478999763727188, -0.01548414770513773, -0.012653576210141182, -0.03185398504137993, -0.01305131334811449, -0.009155169129371643, -0.011383474804461002, 0.0047950344160199165, 0.04367659613490105, 0.000543667352758348, -0.007782394997775555, -0.031125161796808243, -0.04219089448451996, 0.01013959851115942, 0.013487753458321095, -0.03505369648337364, -0.0018555782735347748, 0.02373412996530533, -0.034845542162656784, 0.0015216284664347768, -0.009949504397809505, 0.01280204951763153, -0.06564754247665405, 0.06773881614208221, 0.07239586114883423, -0.03765358030796051, 0.0029077252838760614, -0.020183011889457703, -0.03542680665850639, 0.035457491874694824, -0.0011130387429147959, 0.04144749790430069, -0.03098710998892784, -0.06423608958721161, 0.022179333493113518, 0.002929041860625148, -0.007346160709857941, 0.03044065646827221, -0.0033134648110717535, -0.02960674650967121, 0.012297358363866806, -0.017711402848362923, -0.06495670974254608, -0.013888980261981487, -0.025433093309402466, 0.03217756375670433, 0.006393736694008112, -0.032695796340703964, 0.03924265503883362, 0.006340739317238331, -0.06257032603025436, 0.025444716215133667, -0.039768073707818985, -0.039558615535497665, -0.016755353659391403, -0.015276473946869373, 0.0042808204889297485, 0.016280971467494965, 0.005294385831803083, 0.053234975785017014, -0.03330172970890999, -0.001962971640750766, -0.05597855895757675, -0.06364775449037552, 0.0030272796284407377, -0.009171119891107082, 0.03195788338780403, -0.02589578926563263, -0.012998935766518116, 0.04085984826087952, 0.05530553311109543, -0.046153854578733444, -0.03110651858150959, 0.022672099992632866, -0.02668789029121399, 0.006052298471331596, 0.01469338033348322, 0.015291743911802769, 0.040713440626859665, -0.0012209564447402954, 0.014008364640176296, 0.04119056835770607, 0.038562994450330734, -0.02750306762754917, -0.0008844922413118184, 0.005463739857077599, -0.0034825371112674475, -0.02665860392153263, 0.024935081601142883, 0.012380904518067837, -0.06349882483482361, 0.01486127357929945, 0.016376595944166183, 0.009236050769686699, 0.017615454271435738, -0.0254545696079731, 0.002070231596007943, -0.011433164589107037, 0.04407015070319176, -0.012893116101622581, -0.0010877494933083653, 0.009174852631986141, -0.014251461252570152, 0.01947149820625782, 0.04585134983062744, 0.03174792602658272, -0.035299256443977356, -0.015863921493291855, 0.050343167036771774, 0.03342697024345398, -0.023082463070750237, 0.02557765319943428, 0.000857678591273725, 0.008292866870760918, 0.01145023014396429, -0.02109311893582344, -0.04648582264780998, 0.023259708657860756, 0.034851495176553726, 0.02240706980228424, 0.043389949947595596, -0.026680374518036842, 0.016122736036777496, -0.056399449706077576, -0.007032681256532669, -0.023225992918014526, 0.05339447408914566, 0.006586691830307245, -0.01128355786204338, 0.05459892749786377, -0.013914346694946289, -0.002052437514066696, 0.003380767535418272, -0.05469882860779762, 0.01531024370342493, 0.009153439663350582, -0.03911401331424713, 0.014333076775074005, -0.015048438683152199, -0.01112438179552555, -0.04074539616703987, 0.016187196597456932, 0.020425915718078613, 0.022686947137117386, -0.0809575617313385, 0.03297169879078865, -0.016785776242613792, 0.028454575687646866, -0.0188850499689579, 0.02089349739253521, 0.024361884221434593, 0.043124280869960785, 0.005367424339056015, 0.00894753448665142, -0.011725776828825474, 0.01287793181836605, 0.011921929195523262, 0.018090780824422836, -0.02083692140877247, 0.05508066341280937, 0.027416018769145012, 0.07832656800746918, -0.013546614907681942, 0.0018436621176078916, 0.024220945313572884, 0.01503404788672924, 0.03817952051758766, -0.03213644027709961, 0.01178969256579876, -0.04635469987988472, -0.02126474864780903, 0.00015736420755274594, 0.022357413545250893, 0.03446853905916214, -0.021198125556111336, 0.024456212297081947, 0.02518816851079464, -0.05388256907463074, 0.016997862607240677, 0.08472044765949249, -0.018556034192442894, -0.03148344159126282, -0.05936933308839798, -0.01702672243118286, 0.004171034321188927, -0.01523453090339899, 0.03507329151034355, 0.027371486648917198, -0.029854876920580864, 0.0027192654088139534, 0.021295009180903435, -0.03961458057165146, -0.0002908820169977844, -0.012811901979148388, 0.035782281309366226, 0.03769378364086151, 0.0010143204126507044, -0.04898012802004814, -0.01707426644861698, 0.07007697969675064, 0.01789097487926483, 0.04089127853512764, -0.01564803160727024, -0.05898822844028473, 0.005831277463585138, 0.07088559120893478, 0.017556192353367805, -0.031768251210451126, 0.0020922974217683077, -0.012274307198822498, 0.013269013725221157, 0.029124276712536812, -0.041047994047403336, 0.056580957025289536, -0.0025112938601523638, 0.01812560297548771, -0.043071575462818146, 0.022558892145752907, -0.04777548089623451, 0.025966709479689598, -0.02167639695107937, 0.010853096842765808, -0.05396053194999695, -0.02124277502298355, -0.007607310079038143, 0.015961354598402977, 0.010240203700959682, 0.05117180570960045, -0.04255224019289017, -0.02649756334722042, 0.02198103442788124, 0.014159412123262882, -0.012394404970109463, -0.03891001641750336, 0.01695810817182064, 0.02660452388226986, -0.0182880200445652, 0.04990800470113754, -0.05493185296654701, -0.0300619937479496, 0.01712057925760746, 0.038080230355262756, -0.010125502943992615, -0.010231382213532925, 0.0069321077316999435, 0.05083998292684555, 0.007475043646991253, 0.01915876753628254, 0.046985968947410583, 0.013033907860517502, 0.019153643399477005, 0.009076344780623913, -0.045556098222732544, 0.011871244758367538, -0.04048123210668564, -0.01555668655782938, -0.03103863261640072, 0.0209183469414711, -0.0232098288834095, 0.05412454530596733, -0.001062549650669098, 0.04032357037067413, -0.027576351538300514, 0.0019787237979471684, -0.01005598995834589, 0.016331564635038376, -0.03577207773923874, -0.014034027233719826, -0.01852765865623951, 0.03166941553354263, -0.0011074839858338237, 0.012289282865822315, 0.017199033871293068, -0.033332765102386475, -0.00019007826631423086, 0.019480859860777855, -0.04650994390249252, 0.0014084542635828257, -0.045401960611343384, -0.018704459071159363, 0.017773492261767387, -0.002571876859292388, 0.02815413475036621, -0.0011774011654779315, 0.048709992319345474, 0.04604528471827507, -0.04492800682783127, 0.023491444066166878, 0.006528244819492102, -0.008994954638183117, 0.04314371570944786, -0.05567851662635803, 0.03238091617822647, -0.01596743054687977, -0.021632051095366478, -0.05742790177464485, -0.022361772134900093, 0.026677438989281654, -0.0017039930680766702, -0.009274333715438843, -0.04904670640826225, -0.01936778984963894, -0.03258666396141052, 0.014327667653560638, -0.0358910895884037, 0.059647586196660995, 0.023543164134025574, -0.015263097360730171, 0.013630956411361694, -0.005169749725610018, 0.0501098670065403, -0.00104517734143883, 0.02338632196187973, 0.012168032117187977, 0.03586385399103165, 0.01174493320286274, 0.04747425764799118, -0.0035474819596856833, -0.016469866037368774, -0.012663839384913445, -0.013799465261399746, -0.005988250020891428, 0.06943609565496445, -0.029180798679590225, -0.027496041730046272, -0.01756574772298336, 0.0012640421045944095, 0.011945917271077633, -0.037313953042030334, -0.004770603030920029, -0.00783692579716444, -0.02604369819164276, -0.032352592796087265, 0.021730244159698486, 0.0017302593914791942, -0.02760530263185501, 0.02115403302013874, 0.00752322468906641, -0.021745802834630013, 0.0073357922956347466, 0.06064576283097267, -0.0047594597563147545, 0.011510106734931469, -0.0017298187594860792, -0.0035140502732247114, 0.02457214891910553, 0.0029730412643402815, 0.016311736777424812, -0.00024851015768945217, 0.05020192265510559, 0.002376473043113947, 0.00017699720046948642, -0.04540247842669487, 0.003029261250048876, 0.07113741338253021, 0.018614578992128372, 0.036237817257642746, 0.05715111643075943, 0.03428354486823082, -0.00011176801490364596, -0.044739630073308945, -0.0038552971091121435, 0.0024548128712922335, 0.002035950543358922, 0.04544596001505852, 0.012681924737989902, -0.03444509208202362, 0.027226699516177177, 0.01577390544116497, 0.021030360832810402, 0.026958085596561432, -0.0288686603307724, 0.030498452484607697, 0.010326740331947803, -0.040398187935352325, -0.04192254692316055, 0.058965716511011124, -0.004783444572240114, 0.011553657241165638, -0.03599252924323082, -0.0124274380505085, 0.028928231447935104, 0.03436523675918579, 0.006905025336891413, -0.057441070675849915, -0.010847173631191254, -0.05761619284749031, 0.013170978985726833, 0.04109179228544235, -0.06326820701360703, 0.0005207557696849108, 0.012886852957308292, 0.02912619151175022, 0.04929405823349953, 0.010668848641216755, -0.005462478846311569, -0.06738343089818954, -0.06518816202878952, -0.033931657671928406, -0.03901391103863716, 0.025292515754699707, 0.012646675109863281, -0.061879005283117294, 0.015014438889920712, 0.004443403799086809, 0.025668423622846603, 0.016716517508029938, 0.03694406896829605, 0.019167480990290642, 0.05521045997738838, 0.016846375539898872, 0.067942313849926, 0.01055473554879427, 0.004330412019044161, 0.1269734650850296, 0.08295202255249023, 0.05919992923736572, -0.045909956097602844, 0.04555804654955864, 0.0427488274872303, -0.03850552812218666, -0.04182853177189827, 0.02023754082620144, 0.010631958954036236, -0.01932402513921261, 0.020150456577539444, 0.01216936856508255, 0.009279372170567513, -0.021391527727246284, 0.02957172505557537, -0.031937118619680405, 0.009223943576216698, 0.023897673934698105, 0.011123238131403923, 0.0005714694852940738, -0.021334480494260788, -0.06174178048968315, 0.012643329799175262, 0.026401914656162262, -0.012805742211639881, -0.02058541215956211, 0.008513093926012516, 0.02650333009660244, 0.021335337311029434, 0.013415047898888588, 0.0063198404386639595, -0.008236914873123169, 0.016856536269187927, -0.007130751386284828, 0.019193628802895546, 0.015516798011958599, -0.03171761706471443, 0.007897105067968369, 0.004187331534922123, 0.030020585283637047, -0.012534653767943382, -0.02250061184167862, 0.01907738298177719, -0.04427933320403099, -0.04441569745540619, -0.03991309553384781, 0.028410209342837334, -0.018191616982221603, -0.01178968045860529, 0.01787995919585228, 0.022733554244041443, 0.033990807831287384, -0.07087869197130203, 0.0030478942207992077, -0.011015353724360466, 0.025135278701782227, 0.011223147623240948, -0.031173910945653915, -0.03925072401762009, 0.0524619035422802, -0.02702948823571205, 0.024486985057592392, -0.031533319503068924, -0.020933911204338074, -0.010518893599510193, -0.0002690334804356098, 0.0365898571908474, -0.008002222515642643, -0.009018013253808022, 0.006240283604711294, -0.03957902640104294, -0.03353291377425194, -0.03216015547513962, 0.00046945505891926587, -0.027716781944036484, -0.011810614727437496, -0.005992478225380182, -0.05685848742723465, 0.01639145240187645, -0.0064026121981441975, 0.02013542130589485, 0.011978126130998135, 0.02678796835243702, 0.016327274963259697, -0.007060109172016382, 0.023015053942799568, 0.020970435813069344, 0.004398598801344633, 0.006001524161547422, 0.007418706547468901, 0.03472352400422096, 0.0002890545583795756, -0.022276360541582108, -0.01499455887824297, -0.009816679172217846, -0.043179914355278015, 0.021079815924167633, -0.02199987880885601, 0.040391743183135986, -0.013356825336813927, -0.0068549481220543385, -0.009744889102876186, 0.023625032976269722, -0.03411198407411575, -0.01362585462629795, -0.00820558425039053, -0.01597319170832634, -0.03369106724858284, 0.0012149823596701026, -0.027781084179878235, -0.020821498706936836, 0.011463773436844349, -0.0356890931725502, -0.012217793613672256, 0.0324258916079998, -0.008496682159602642, -0.059374623000621796, 0.011216080747544765, -0.0034628291614353657, 0.009074550122022629, -0.03694698214530945, -0.009036180563271046, -0.010533617809414864, 0.028801079839468002, -0.02625013142824173, -0.025996008887887, -0.024712922051548958, 0.002049101982265711, -0.019640477374196053, -0.0021004648879170418, 0.027761287987232208, 0.02952488884329796, 0.023629769682884216, -0.011494380421936512, 0.014164755120873451, -0.001170167583040893, 0.047087162733078, -0.018980367109179497, 0.0016826788196340203, 0.05328059941530228, -0.061918798834085464, -0.01974007673561573, -0.0037264428101480007, -0.01436910405755043, 0.02530115284025669, -0.001622101292014122, -0.000784282514359802, -0.038715094327926636, 0.05797547847032547, 0.0022683574352413416, -0.003914793021976948, 0.0002710199623834342, -0.014028734527528286, -0.009814510121941566, -0.019514452666044235, -0.004476327449083328, 0.003706319723278284, -0.026353834196925163, 0.005511762108653784, 0.027614563703536987, -0.028673188760876656, -0.026224849745631218, 0.002805961761623621, -0.03235787898302078, 0.0037861536256968975, 0.031155982986092567, -0.05305418744683266, 0.050018176436424255, 0.06114479526877403, -0.003128512529656291, 0.020679151639342308, -0.03774197772145271, 0.026431867852807045, -0.08418368548154831, -0.039789218455553055, -0.014616178348660469, -0.021574776619672775, 0.05536418780684471, -0.025953056290745735, 0.010367531329393387, 0.025505762547254562, -0.07687968760728836, 0.05118205025792122, -0.018372787162661552, -0.0002801034424919635, -0.05786358192563057, 0.03560265898704529, -0.0425923690199852, 0.002190876752138138, 0.008787301369011402, -0.019711699336767197, 0.050693050026893616, 0.028003709390759468, -0.005078282207250595, -0.02087032049894333, -0.04817671701312065, -0.000011052752597606741, -0.011090829968452454, -0.04983536899089813, 0.01660817302763462, -0.025308379903435707, -0.043042052537202835, 0.011910858564078808, -0.032207075506448746, 0.015616715885698795, 0.012414401397109032, 0.04386000335216522, -0.003998551517724991, 0.04480316489934921, 0.01810297556221485, 0.004538645502179861, 0.01961715705692768, -0.009053405374288559, 0.0011430722661316395, 0.003275468247011304, 0.011540831997990608, 0.01805082894861698, 0.01733817532658577, 0.02072669006884098, -0.03102841228246689, 0.010707599110901356, -0.02110736072063446, -0.01428256556391716, -0.02133636362850666, 0.012879520654678345, 0.014019782654941082, -0.043980006128549576, -0.016376156359910965, -0.034721411764621735, 0.03283163160085678, -0.0022374289110302925, 0.02829516865313053, -0.02401285618543625, -0.0021591472905129194, -0.06303216516971588, -0.05704702436923981, -0.02266126498579979, 0.0010583552066236734, 0.015652207657694817, -0.03530455008149147, -0.020009486004710197, 0.016119934618473053, 0.01727069541811943, 0.0013308641500771046, -0.045456092804670334, 0.008110987022519112, 0.08319440484046936, -0.01544228382408619, -0.0005449456511996686, -0.021317018195986748, 0.03520379588007927, 0.05591689422726631, -0.0947631299495697, 0.03863280266523361, -0.007020945660769939, -0.022047482430934906, -0.028691565617918968, -0.05175688490271568, -0.03350343182682991, 0.041217140853405, 0.062378983944654465, 0.02690289355814457, 0.002004133304581046, -0.011146696284413338, -0.01059329230338335, 0.01489002164453268, -0.029225116595625877, 0.021174566820263863, -0.013044225983321667, -0.007515990640968084, -0.005780358798801899, -0.03385365381836891, 0.022438134998083115, -0.004881068132817745, 0.02552201598882675, 0.01344238594174385, -0.017410436645150185, -0.023845355957746506, -0.02479694038629532, 0.009032373316586018, 0.019322527572512627, -0.018300339579582214, 0.04659178853034973, -0.04007633775472641, 0.04066945239901543, 0.03284304961562157, -0.014844809658825397, -0.04832430183887482, -0.010795283131301403, -0.033105626702308655, -0.019283819943666458, -0.0008798344642855227, 0.012759258970618248, 0.06559698283672333, -0.06757306307554245, 0.005701011978089809, -0.004136038478463888, -0.05424300581216812, 0.0003298246010672301, 0.054374903440475464, 0.05013137310743332, 0.0540158748626709, 0.005074045155197382, 0.03338107094168663, -0.009025724604725838, -0.006424273829907179, -0.0017703346675261855, 0.038204360753297806, 0.0016177144134417176, 0.03487934544682503, -0.0014869986334815621, 0.02905438281595707, -0.025471549481153488, 0.00654452433809638, -0.0035615703091025352, 0.020356005057692528, 0.010662541724741459, -0.00552997924387455, 0.020107131451368332, -0.03222081810235977, -0.02854677475988865, 0.02474762685596943, 0.00852295383810997, 0.03229740262031555, -0.06797871738672256, -0.026382112875580788, -0.03460957109928131, -0.016364051029086113, -0.0765932947397232, 0.005115475971251726, -0.001568649779073894, 0.02565167285501957, 0.03222430869936943, 0.019635822623968124, 0.012874575331807137, -0.00679455790668726, 0.03644724562764168, -0.01877729408442974, 0.040728699415922165, -0.035758595913648605, 0.019443130120635033, 0.009638260118663311, 0.008494573645293713, -0.045704618096351624, 0.008137709461152554, 0.006495409645140171, 0.02285810373723507, 0.03248226270079613, -0.03326611593365669, -0.056735843420028687, -0.01245038490742445, 0.02002386562526226, -0.05607982724905014, -0.004389425739645958, -0.08134641498327255, 0.014956426806747913, 0.00017771196144167334, -0.02367326244711876 ]
<p>What are the most significant annual conferences focusing on quantitative methods in psychology?</p> <p>This could include but is not limited to psychometrics, mathematical psychology, and statistical methods in psychology.</p> <p>Rules:</p> <ul> <li>One conference per answer</li> <li>Include a link to the conference</li> </ul>
35,748
[ -0.010966235771775246, -0.06539148092269897, -0.04846726357936859, -0.030486397445201874, 0.04444160684943199, 0.020287681370973587, -0.027362797409296036, -0.01251840777695179, 0.004097634460777044, -0.003885297803208232, 0.029802406206727028, 0.04575434327125549, 0.017755500972270966, 0.016824183985590935, 0.005340761039406061, -0.001094676787033677, -0.011459916830062866, 0.021069562062621117, -0.006319640204310417, 0.03575609251856804, 0.007570979185402393, 0.03239917382597923, 0.009598196484148502, 0.006944619119167328, -0.0305495448410511, 0.03692103549838066, -0.009080144576728344, 0.010283142328262329, -0.03576093167066574, 0.04417379945516586, -0.03751586750149727, -0.005640290677547455, 0.009058543480932713, 0.03117983788251877, 0.008924358524382114, -0.012206153944134712, 0.013779103755950928, 0.022923290729522705, -0.0033706719987094402, 0.0242932066321373, -0.0474783293902874, -0.049221187829971313, -0.015249423682689667, 0.003031513188034296, -0.03893624246120453, 0.004396469797939062, -0.03753973916172981, -0.03865966945886612, 0.01192868035286665, -0.041958849877119064, 0.046503182500600815, 0.031094558537006378, 0.004962616134434938, 0.00638285418972373, -0.004682293627411127, -0.00359700177796185, 0.007767436560243368, 0.037482429295778275, -0.0010288557969033718, -0.05636978521943092, 0.013377935625612736, -0.007152826990932226, 0.007457399275153875, -0.017138777300715446, -0.020385723561048508, 0.05430237203836441, 0.03825461119413376, -0.016870087012648582, 0.031041590496897697, -0.01699378713965416, -0.05428137257695198, 0.022078897804021835, 0.055786021053791046, -0.008614957332611084, -0.0135849229991436, -0.012093596160411835, -0.02186729945242405, 0.0029557321686297655, 0.009619622491300106, 0.07471451163291931, -0.0008782289223745465, 0.001712915487587452, -0.028053488582372665, 0.02454509399831295, 0.026918374001979828, -0.037892088294029236, 0.07408982515335083, -0.032294031232595444, -0.04560831934213638, -0.003411839948967099, -0.029899993911385536, -0.020445793867111206, 0.017560549080371857, 0.02155608870089054, -0.05104215815663338, 0.03000437095761299, 0.004813643638044596, 0.05926433578133583, 0.01195431500673294, -0.016733547672629356, -0.016075603663921356, -0.05590830370783806, -0.006258897017687559, 0.06369967013597488, -0.007271258160471916, -0.008422637358307838, -0.01566460356116295, 0.02681771107017994, -0.035606563091278076, 0.006728605832904577, -0.0019067720277234912, 0.039434172213077545, 0.017089594155550003, 0.00648517906665802, 0.05167221277952194, 0.011877095326781273, -0.018760930746793747, -0.012989227660000324, 0.04026906564831734, 0.05516718700528145, 0.02045195922255516, -0.034270741045475006, 0.025146089494228363, -0.023688672110438347, -0.05883896350860596, 0.013772599399089813, 0.01515968982130289, -0.03650110214948654, 0.0037406454794108868, 0.011058795265853405, 0.015949536114931107, -0.004072625655680895, 0.01592823676764965, -0.02449594996869564, 0.015350284986197948, 0.0574084110558033, -0.06718466430902481, -0.06717962771654129, 0.029618963599205017, 0.014290430583059788, 0.013504071161150932, -0.007358154281973839, 0.026815639808773994, 0.026177065446972847, 0.052270594984292984, -0.0017682164907455444, 0.037272483110427856, 0.006457043346017599, 0.03908133506774902, 0.002193448832258582, -0.040766242891550064, -0.013557776808738708, 0.009161682799458504, -0.0014718989841639996, 0.002781514311209321, -0.0918332114815712, 0.03593778237700462, 0.017929088324308395, 0.009683679789304733, -0.007461153902113438, 0.06376399099826813, 0.01673993282020092, -0.038817111402750015, 0.026713021099567413, 0.042770832777023315, 0.009223626926541328, 0.05571805313229561, -0.003402509493753314, -0.016414286568760872, 0.026696033775806427, 0.0000774633081164211, 0.0336955264210701, 0.038618121296167374, 0.006168969441205263, 0.022558391094207764, -0.04551447555422783, -0.00166823819745332, 0.02499924600124359, -0.028779316693544388, 0.03862044960260391, -0.03315340355038643, -0.04286617785692215, -0.007234332151710987, -0.006187000311911106, 0.017525440081954002, 0.047613970935344696, -0.028775544837117195, -0.015862783417105675, 0.02694973349571228, 0.0038005716633051634, -0.015333392657339573, -0.05741747468709946, 0.06526529788970947, 0.010356883518397808, -0.009140927344560623, 0.07506667077541351, -0.016512755304574966, 0.03114735521376133, -0.020532676950097084, -0.04280351102352142, -0.02737945131957531, 0.04663054272532463, 0.01587011106312275, -0.00841284915804863, -0.0076707457192242146, 0.07764314115047455, 0.03300625458359718, -0.010497260838747025, -0.003602356184273958, -0.05316493660211563, -0.04586747661232948, -0.006918547209352255, -0.02009918913245201, 0.03171389177441597, -0.045543819665908813, -0.053023334592580795, 0.007587381638586521, 0.009158877655863762, -0.043054256588220596, 0.06901198625564575, -0.032058145850896835, 0.034586936235427856, 0.014371187426149845, -0.012750907801091671, 0.04620363935828209, 0.01883750781416893, 0.01475844532251358, 0.008571742102503777, 0.005520375911146402, 0.005788652691990137, -0.05277511477470398, -0.008849564008414745, 0.04446117952466011, 0.031358566135168076, -0.009764855727553368, 0.03692173957824707, 0.03118273988366127, 0.06734804809093475, -0.009821365587413311, 0.04884283244609833, -0.02970004640519619, -0.047084741294384, -0.0014841050142422318, 0.00029418859048746526, 0.011354918591678143, 0.00024738197680562735, -0.0005522762658074498, 0.00283130188472569, 0.012728909961879253, 0.02870277315378189, -0.026930509135127068, 0.05605245754122734, -0.013347822241485119, -0.04274294152855873, -0.02049480937421322, -0.015306596644222736, 0.042872000485658646, -0.04922693967819214, -0.004292805679142475, 0.023057566955685616, 0.021302981302142143, 0.018699822947382927, 0.02003883570432663, -0.046588506549596786, -0.0023212602827697992, 0.0099704060703516, -0.03274954482913017, 0.022082140669226646, 0.025418855249881744, -0.021257486194372177, 0.02851487696170807, -0.03155728057026863, 0.0061043729074299335, -0.010394947603344917, -0.01031484268605709, 0.04439124837517738, 0.02604072540998459, 0.013981915079057217, -0.018907716497778893, -0.009738603606820107, 0.01474230270832777, -0.05404249206185341, 0.034974489361047745, -0.035841263830661774, -0.03202293440699577, 0.019235022366046906, -0.05196136608719826, 0.018925094977021217, 0.014767841435968876, -0.034832049161195755, -0.02139698714017868, 0.04479557275772095, 0.028757592663168907, -0.07434584945440292, -0.013546549715101719, -0.0027341670356690884, 0.029188023880124092, -0.025110647082328796, 0.015813259407877922, 0.015980180352926254, 0.0208467785269022, -0.01253207866102457, -0.034358371049165726, -0.021291233599185944, -0.007258937228471041, 0.019262880086898804, -0.05469066649675369, 0.016080185770988464, -0.02187504433095455, -0.012298882007598877, 0.027049943804740906, -0.0485050342977047, 0.006153350695967674, -0.037210430949926376, -0.042421743273735046, 0.025920754298567772, -0.013723896816372871, 0.0420028418302536, 0.004740163218230009, 0.005498431622982025, 0.031926583498716354, 0.04419222101569176, -0.019073674455285072, -0.061103109270334244, -0.005761970300227404, -0.003494387259706855, -0.01855272613465786, 0.03903714194893837, -0.024682363495230675, 0.02299926057457924, 0.041552506387233734, 0.009331030771136284, -0.01264832355082035, 0.038657296448946, 0.02602343261241913, 0.005094745196402073, -0.02137773483991623, -0.00833749771118164, 0.0013474082807078958, 0.010791633278131485, 0.011388136073946953, -0.07738403230905533, 0.025138448923826218, 0.002115590963512659, -0.020140398293733597, 0.008940289728343487, -0.015612494200468063, 0.0009989433456212282, -0.023333799093961716, -0.0010435482254251838, -0.007516488432884216, 0.0071834661066532135, 0.022829126566648483, -0.0014437430072575808, -0.04735499247908592, 0.015667477622628212, -0.007451762445271015, -0.016974249854683876, -0.008341929875314236, -0.02364143170416355, -0.005205250345170498, -0.04834480956196785, 0.011869838461279869, -0.019054902717471123, -0.028321076184511185, 0.03391343355178833, -0.031473200768232346, -0.0004615430370904505, 0.06311964988708496, 0.027539052069187164, 0.051478445529937744, 0.001855929964222014, -0.006205190904438496, -0.031976379454135895, -0.05388660356402397, 0.00697322329506278, -0.0693085789680481, 0.05534777790307999, -0.009879845194518566, 0.05208895727992058, -0.004149651620537043, 0.038946956396102905, -0.012472504749894142, 0.033201057463884354, -0.0899101048707962, 0.0035860135685652494, -0.03711962327361107, 0.01464156061410904, 0.014570512808859348, 0.014202218502759933, 0.05838821455836296, 0.025156360119581223, 0.010497817769646645, -0.03470345586538315, 0.028054725378751755, -0.02652859501540661, -0.004581185057759285, -0.026633234694600105, -0.0286369901150465, 0.010706265456974506, 0.002442817436531186, 0.023969046771526337, -0.03561132773756981, 0.036721471697092056, 0.03150630369782448, -0.0010085147805511951, -0.022079916670918465, 0.00936339981853962, 0.05376500263810158, 0.04406827315688133, 0.059317026287317276, 0.017757141962647438, 0.01629020646214485, -0.049879323691129684, 0.032810088247060776, 0.0016993065364658833, 0.011899459175765514, 0.00959403533488512, -0.018065256997942924, -0.03682214394211769, -0.07783103734254837, -0.00982656143605709, 0.02010628953576088, 0.005473109427839518, 0.021601086482405663, 0.013140717521309853, 0.03140074014663696, 0.012992197647690773, -0.016541484743356705, 0.01607483997941017, 0.04638855531811714, 0.0162937194108963, -0.03389335796236992, 0.008933431468904018, -0.0062101478688418865, 0.032491736114025116, -0.003067557467147708, 0.03326886519789696, 0.019895415753126144, 0.034355875104665756, 0.022315796464681625, 0.017744192853569984, 0.007104202173650265, -0.045528605580329895, -0.016959700733423233, 0.03501361235976219, 0.03915632516145706, -0.0014093639329075813, -0.007616179063916206, -0.023215925320982933, 0.05719912797212601, 0.05835985392332077, -0.007431178819388151, 0.00512473750859499, -0.07004866003990173, 0.025457395240664482, 0.0434364452958107, 0.0335109569132328, -0.06767553836107254, 0.00812668539583683, -0.02077375538647175, -0.01620171032845974, 0.048415765166282654, 0.0023479138035327196, 0.009075148031115532, -0.017358025535941124, -0.0028003216721117496, -0.002910190960392356, 0.012250734493136406, -0.031431812793016434, 0.008456501178443432, 0.04993671923875809, 0.005370897240936756, -0.009915204718708992, -0.0015535963466390967, -0.033223941922187805, -0.017865747213363647, 0.029838385060429573, 0.030892588198184967, 0.008588949218392372, 0.012905513867735863, -0.006898340303450823, 0.026649663224816322, -0.0513174906373024, -0.04985744506120682, 0.02553272247314453, 0.05773986130952835, -0.009743175469338894, 0.043936196714639664, -0.03712254762649536, -0.0471918098628521, 0.01640251651406288, -0.025865649804472923, -0.00515536405146122, 0.0037118203472346067, 0.023824790492653847, 0.04285930469632149, 0.032192863523960114, -0.01814947836101055, 0.06369182467460632, 0.0466841459274292, -0.04095623642206192, -0.011537629179656506, -0.02932445891201496, -0.011413692496716976, 0.0025383010506629944, -0.03534374386072159, -0.01622948795557022, -0.010233510285615921, -0.050372567027807236, 0.022102104499936104, -0.050398848950862885, -0.01385196577757597, -0.039103537797927856, -0.004158367402851582, -0.0009223314700648189, 0.01743481494486332, -0.027299700304865837, 0.006303702015429735, 0.04226227477192879, 0.008035168051719666, 0.01956319250166416, -0.01428527757525444, 0.008500734344124794, -0.005237208679318428, 0.00821587536484003, 0.022634340450167656, -0.015424782410264015, -0.01863083429634571, -0.011842015199363232, -0.012693014927208424, 0.02651388570666313, -0.005177751183509827, 0.03234224021434784, -0.03501797839999199, -0.0036672442220151424, 0.014512893743813038, -0.046272922307252884, -0.0175242368131876, -0.011766240000724792, -0.0012086033821105957, 0.03823849558830261, -0.02707039751112461, 0.009220415726304054, 0.009390858002007008, -0.008538282476365566, -0.0604989118874073, -0.039054930210113525, 0.04288896173238754, 0.020644308999180794, -0.04987673833966255, -0.029025917872786522, 0.038847021758556366, -0.02036704123020172, 0.02101512812077999, -0.028353724628686905, 0.09627002477645874, -0.020066842436790466, -0.025011645630002022, -0.00950763188302517, 0.004219043534249067, 0.015525586903095245, 0.011618200689554214, 0.00834448542445898, -0.02936781942844391, 0.016397472470998764, 0.0025954057928174734, 0.016694383695721626, 0.01575038954615593, -0.02327115274965763, -0.007674279157072306, -0.0001488385023549199, -0.038827016949653625, 0.018920935690402985, -0.024578092619776726, -0.04346905276179314, 0.0413425974547863, -0.024646500125527382, -0.021607516333460808, -0.05846522003412247, 0.0024842831771820784, -0.03776741772890091, 0.027367904782295227, -0.014752283692359924, -0.011047952808439732, -0.04276610538363457, 0.008710996247828007, -0.01033808570355177, 0.01908787339925766, -0.05590731278061867, 0.004945406224578619, 0.04440496489405632, -0.020076584070920944, 0.020160531625151634, 0.0053045740351080894, -0.016324196010828018, 0.03603244572877884, -0.028767872601747513, 0.0236813947558403, -0.006426049862056971, -0.0008232379332184792, -0.016582762822508812, -0.025871915742754936, -0.02264825813472271, -0.0012289686128497124, 0.04337097704410553, 0.027268817648291588, 0.038014233112335205, 0.09151460975408554, -0.03157750889658928, 0.010003389790654182, -0.036894895136356354, 0.013150679878890514, 0.006400329992175102, 0.029356300830841064, 0.04841092973947525, -0.027944421395659447, -0.03672508895397186, 0.017116565257310867, 0.01960412785410881, -0.0038691400550305843, 0.04016074538230896, -0.01554576400667429, 0.06025625392794609, 0.017932699993252754, -0.10421707481145859, -0.027094639837741852, 0.030648184940218925, -0.05470510572195053, 0.0130348801612854, -0.01763281412422657, -0.06440968811511993, 0.04009898379445076, 0.0136225875467062, 0.00793770793825388, -0.016072051599621773, -0.024279363453388214, -0.0569380484521389, 0.03296896815299988, -0.01765894889831543, 0.02812127023935318, -0.01690729707479477, -0.008950983174145222, -0.011807918548583984, -0.015742862597107887, 0.016238389536738396, 0.0031540561467409134, -0.06341598182916641, -0.04126059636473656, -0.029894430190324783, -0.04785124212503433, -0.007206984795629978, 0.0034181158989667892, -0.005232269875705242, -0.0023731915280222893, -0.0005294349393807352, 0.014881611801683903, 0.04174351319670677, 0.048975277692079544, -0.001914365915581584, 0.04848547279834747, -0.014648563228547573, -0.006548787001520395, -0.019292064011096954, -0.034419670701026917, 0.09768147021532059, 0.07248688489198685, 0.05618222430348396, -0.07495854794979095, 0.04425425827503204, 0.00913354754447937, 0.01382257230579853, -0.030733121559023857, 0.009096737019717693, -0.019743680953979492, -0.020773213356733322, 0.07773956656455994, 0.0847957655787468, 0.03608529642224312, -0.022414900362491608, 0.048361536115407944, -0.008310306817293167, -0.038016460835933685, -0.014622206799685955, -0.040841445326805115, 0.025882354006171227, 0.01230663899332285, -0.012917893007397652, 0.0015388216124847531, 0.018482686951756477, -0.019198084250092506, -0.06592239439487457, -0.04896611347794533, 0.005157162435352802, -0.0053507862612605095, -0.02123003453016281, -0.006095812655985355, 0.028317738324403763, 0.03244040533900261, -0.07875687628984451, -0.023388061672449112, 0.012989641167223454, -0.05241924896836281, 0.022423194721341133, 0.021404242143034935, 0.01343215350061655, -0.01827099919319153, -0.0043259793892502785, 0.03644929826259613, -0.022319436073303223, -0.00754087558016181, -0.01645352877676487, -0.001693263533525169, -0.03896705061197281, -0.010983535088598728, -0.0392889641225338, -0.04111720249056816, 0.010052151046693325, 0.02167542837560177, -0.013011655770242214, 0.030677268281579018, 0.04318387061357498, -0.04677467420697212, -0.013863774947822094, -0.05072740465402603, -0.011974658817052841, 0.012853788211941719, 0.05643332749605179, 0.023694349452853203, -0.01889382116496563, -0.03648821637034416, -0.03040037676692009, 0.013634627684950829, 0.002718413481488824, 0.009585712105035782, 0.03061729669570923, 0.004323834553360939, -0.05057147517800331, -0.042569976300001144, -0.0012483014725148678, -0.03132505342364311, 0.05063868314027786, 0.024564871564507484, -0.008570286445319653, -0.023034458979964256, -0.0458243303000927, 0.009418115019798279, -0.01146161649376154, -0.011746160686016083, -0.04256628826260567, 0.018013570457696915, 0.05017184093594551, 0.004438098520040512, 0.019578993320465088, -0.0008617130224592984, -0.014568186365067959, 0.006529849488288164, 0.021239986643195152, -0.03584647923707962, -0.01832888461649418, -0.05011580139398575, -0.0077423821203410625, -0.017365505918860435, -0.014513842761516571, 0.0209087822586298, 0.046333327889442444, 0.002764578443020582, 0.0018202082719653845, 0.021150771528482437, -0.030866442248225212, -0.028219835832715034, 0.0008543168078176677, -0.03781107813119888, -0.003037060610949993, 0.004324031062424183, 0.01966840773820877, -0.054779719561338425, -0.03831253945827484, -0.05371220409870148, 0.011396972462534904, -0.005722687114030123, -0.05158489942550659, -0.04640629142522812, -0.007974578067660332, 0.03401455655694008, 0.04584602639079094, -0.02942906878888607, -0.03172547370195389, -0.02166534774005413, -0.008295167237520218, 0.012966160662472248, 0.008600165136158466, 0.03066605143249035, -0.022072486579418182, -0.003950514364987612, -0.03691927716135979, 0.050435665994882584, 0.01053321547806263, 0.01670818030834198, 0.016061749309301376, -0.014391261152923107, 0.03157596290111542, 0.02680784836411476, 0.0072066159918904305, -0.04588056728243828, 0.035998258739709854, -0.0720963329076767, -0.025316480547189713, 0.03115992434322834, -0.030950596556067467, -0.0014153519878163934, 0.044515252113342285, 0.04400136321783066, 0.001250813016667962, -0.01559770479798317, -0.00672976253554225, -0.005346126854419708, 0.00034994707675650716, -0.012540096417069435, 0.029813028872013092, -0.018710318952798843, 0.009445622563362122, 0.021449754014611244, -0.051798488944768906, 0.036443017423152924, 0.06792471557855606, -0.019708560779690742, 0.013879451900720596, 0.032400984317064285, -0.013479807414114475, -0.005190907046198845, 0.01615312322974205, -0.004604750778526068, 0.055300403386354446, 0.04864975064992905, -0.04280993714928627, 0.048427388072013855, -0.006862212438136339, -0.005747706163674593, -0.10111119598150253, 0.027179772034287453, -0.008103410713374615, 0.021707337349653244, 0.03287259861826897, -0.06077420338988304, 0.04160955920815468, 0.04458419978618622, -0.025661470368504524, 0.022353265434503555, -0.024966420605778694, -0.029718466103076935, -0.0025707255117595196, -0.010731075890362263, 0.002360650571063161, -0.004928045440465212, -0.015068938955664635, -0.01498052105307579, 0.025780420750379562, 0.019340170547366142, 0.01052761822938919, -0.05085749179124832, -0.010003656148910522, -0.0033071287907660007, -0.003137048799544573, -0.05364362895488739, 0.02697153203189373, -0.03498723730444908, -0.017075417563319206, 0.019306883215904236, -0.018892802298069, 0.012876175343990326, 0.052238449454307556, -0.008838449604809284, -0.02477317303419113, 0.05812202766537666, 0.03708929941058159, -0.02005629800260067, 0.013870922848582268, 0.01726064831018448, -0.0030713146552443504, 0.04673613980412483, -0.01827985793352127, 0.020209182053804398, 0.0011752472491934896, -0.02270517870783806, -0.047455620020627975, 0.019215865060687065, 0.003416987368836999, 0.021252015605568886, -0.00413828669115901, -0.03435787931084633, -0.002942448016256094, 0.010910116136074066, 0.019130123779177666, -0.04998485743999481, -0.005664669908583164, 0.01581108756363392, 0.023255834355950356, 0.012610447593033314, 0.01823537051677704, 0.007816953584551811, -0.03488486260175705, 0.014825548976659775, -0.045528482645750046, 0.02387164533138275, -0.06072679162025452, 0.010080172680318356, 0.056129127740859985, 0.009436745196580887, -0.0013368234504014254, -0.0014918888919055462, -0.027301885187625885, 0.03831233084201813, -0.03971602022647858, 0.012661031447350979, -0.011827302165329456, -0.00849518645554781, 0.026222040876746178, -0.07889498770236969, 0.044852692633867264, -0.0016168539877980947, -0.0074165924452245235, -0.029845112934708595, -0.004198530688881874, -0.014110149815678596, -0.002875150414183736, 0.059332020580768585, -0.008766468614339828, -0.011682162061333656, 0.005278232041746378, -0.01100787054747343, -0.004728200379759073, -0.03568873181939125, 0.004979921039193869, -0.053054843097925186, 0.0074993763118982315, -0.05826586112380028, -0.00632838997989893, 0.006667118053883314, 0.008518439717590809, 0.014192444272339344, 0.031409863382577896, 0.025025224313139915, -0.012943741865456104, 0.004775413777679205, 0.06566710770130157, 0.033084459602832794, -0.020626522600650787, 0.036406807601451874, 0.004936013370752335, 0.04391847923398018, 0.004139439202845097, 0.0006326707662083209, -0.040605537593364716, 0.01386064663529396, -0.024638500064611435, -0.05521329492330551, -0.004259289242327213, 0.019540008157491684, -0.01692473515868187, -0.057953447103500366, 0.016748754307627678, 0.03171421214938164, -0.013477093540132046, 0.013782772235572338, 0.03343561291694641, 0.027350114658474922, 0.0236278735101223, 0.034607041627168655, 0.04552415758371353, 0.06368312984704971, 0.005142730660736561, 0.0001754441182129085, 0.04510406032204628, 0.053570687770843506, 0.05405476316809654, 0.017373956739902496, -0.006199136842042208, 0.02543758973479271, 0.08037836849689484, 0.002168005332350731, 0.021071679890155792, 0.011936675757169724, 0.0019015326397493482, 0.05061078071594238, -0.0242537222802639, 0.04363927245140076, -0.004650128539651632, -0.008984903804957867, 0.07630062103271484, -0.03553855046629906, 0.006644430570304394, -0.00432012090459466, 0.015141170471906662, -0.05127372592687607, -0.0004344152985140681, -0.014277497306466103, 0.05405082926154137, -0.03644344583153725, 0.008360379375517368, 0.00597938010469079, 0.00668019475415349, 0.018704723566770554, 0.0014789089327678084, 0.04387577250599861, 0.00975590106099844, -0.010994508862495422, -0.02795165590941906, -0.02961074374616146, -0.050199445337057114, -0.023850729689002037, 0.02550063654780388, 0.043590690940618515, 0.033894579857587814, 0.0028950024861842394, 0.00867619551718235, -0.020951204001903534, 0.05834083631634712, -0.03176305443048477, -0.009527190588414669, -0.019434260204434395, -0.0023900866508483887, -0.010918772779405117, -0.008910860866308212 ]
<p>I have two samples, one with $n_1 = 41,000$ and the other with $n_2 = 881$; the larger sample has a standard deviation of $13.74$, and the smaller has an $SD=10.75$. The means are different, and when I run a Welch's t-test, I get a $p &lt; .001$. I'm not sure if that's the appropriate test. I checked the skew for both samples; it was $29$ for the large sample and $9$ for the small one. Should I use a Mann-Whitney U test, or do I have enough data to assume normally distributed samples? In the end I need to know if the means of the samples are statistically different and be able to say one mean is $X$ times larger than the other. </p>
73,400
[ -0.032705046236515045, -0.028823012486100197, -0.021259445697069168, 0.0035394050646573305, 0.045321300625801086, 0.024744397029280663, 0.016498908400535583, -0.010964356362819672, 0.005180910229682922, -0.03903632238507271, 0.08972444385290146, 0.02259420044720173, 0.054143112152814865, 0.019224341958761215, 0.03109043464064598, 0.010055499151349068, -0.03772241994738579, 0.02484731934964657, 0.0007225528825074434, -0.04635528475046158, 0.0020406506955623627, 0.021421661600470543, 0.024894673377275467, -0.03637125343084335, -0.03682928532361984, 0.03890962526202202, 0.006975919008255005, -0.028010226786136627, -0.0032834112644195557, 0.06587320566177368, -0.027960507199168205, -0.03794071078300476, 0.017882883548736572, 0.041356731206178665, 0.023813467472791672, -0.004433599300682545, -0.022707315161824226, -0.025547029450535774, 0.012607711367309093, 0.027008244767785072, -0.05456719547510147, 0.008968782611191273, 0.00954979658126831, -0.0015373645583167672, 0.00356522249057889, 0.00786304660141468, -0.01999264769256115, -0.05861853063106537, 0.018168926239013672, -0.031020671129226685, 0.061237040907144547, 0.02903531678020954, 0.021181782707571983, 0.0131479287520051, -0.03205142915248871, -0.025093277916312218, 0.0270832646638155, 0.0424724742770195, -0.01921260356903076, -0.027949653565883636, -0.0020838845521211624, -0.005231326445937157, -0.03959769755601883, -0.025229042395949364, -0.03014998324215412, 0.019154364243149757, -0.04701020196080208, -0.025835644453763962, 0.007700610440224409, -0.012556924484670162, 0.021044649183750153, 0.035552311688661575, 0.017074713483452797, -0.016645876690745354, 0.01803583838045597, -0.04406507685780525, 0.021167397499084473, 0.027575194835662842, 0.043401818722486496, 0.026551181450486183, 0.01897413097321987, 0.015612662769854069, 0.053059618920087814, 0.026244746521115303, 0.0206593107432127, -0.062020208686590195, 0.058201856911182404, -0.0002738509501796216, -0.005367313511669636, 0.043313104659318924, -0.022900769487023354, -0.01443902775645256, 0.0872543603181839, -0.004857351537793875, -0.0038331167306751013, 0.007246263325214386, -0.048914916813373566, 0.015053216367959976, -0.017590612173080444, -0.02005951479077339, -0.02350308932363987, -0.08074834197759628, 0.047883350402116776, 0.04215862229466438, -0.006099537946283817, -0.03801830857992172, -0.00046076232683844864, 0.013806494884192944, -0.028429444879293442, 0.0026391050778329372, -0.017979517579078674, 0.00675287377089262, 0.00039265575469471514, 0.002565233502537012, 0.03471199795603752, 0.01483501773327589, -0.0035525381099432707, -0.02822326496243477, 0.029992951080203056, 0.04711635410785675, 0.08008381724357605, -0.0053568254224956036, 0.02823140285909176, -0.023334965109825134, -0.04931601509451866, 0.04560835286974907, 0.016208907589316368, -0.00935861375182867, -0.05883694067597389, 0.06494389474391937, -0.006170310080051422, -0.0009117706795223057, 0.002904251916334033, -0.015969466418027878, 0.034064166247844696, 0.015844523906707764, -0.06709155440330505, -0.07631264626979828, 0.07022376358509064, -0.011709487065672874, 0.007589160464704037, -0.06941338628530502, -0.010330602526664734, 0.034701868891716, 0.024190396070480347, 0.024231528863310814, 0.03295130282640457, -0.021438991650938988, 0.024107376113533974, 0.021740105003118515, -0.027652421966195107, 0.013734938576817513, -0.020833076909184456, -0.017499487847089767, 0.0042426008731126785, -0.0679657980799675, 0.0005266026128083467, 0.0005454025231301785, -0.0029151071794331074, 0.003995557781308889, 0.011494341306388378, 0.04011831060051918, 0.032542884349823, -0.027366824448108673, 0.028617799282073975, -0.009427180513739586, 0.07097803801298141, 0.02645818516612053, 0.036874473094940186, -0.008432014845311642, -0.010649113915860653, 0.004757891409099102, 0.057556819170713425, 0.03387109190225601, 0.04628507047891617, 0.018859738484025, 0.026163270696997643, -0.009984700009226799, 0.020709173753857613, 0.023057889193296432, -0.008720390498638153, 0.01884349249303341, -0.020740725100040436, -0.015629515051841736, -0.0027727880515158176, 0.044930268079042435, -0.007711176760494709, -0.006616824772208929, 0.019942179322242737, -0.03927388787269592, -0.0381697379052639, -0.04710806906223297, -0.02149846963584423, -0.008914926089346409, -0.04687933996319771, 0.052456170320510864, -0.01687062531709671, 0.019580142572522163, -0.03061164915561676, -0.011134733445942402, 0.00534939207136631, -0.0003423777234274894, 0.032221123576164246, -0.06483041495084763, -0.013822177425026894, 0.0495859757065773, 0.06753809005022049, -0.02928769960999489, 0.031893592327833176, -0.03511550650000572, -0.04522059112787247, 0.03428785875439644, -0.038753386586904526, 0.01782011240720749, 0.010992196388542652, -0.008000209927558899, -0.0005916116060689092, 0.01243163924664259, 0.012652918696403503, 0.04588852450251579, -0.028376372531056404, 0.0753815621137619, 0.028920801356434822, 0.004892341326922178, 0.0035588573664426804, -0.012109442614018917, 0.030324216932058334, 0.006291534751653671, -0.044046007096767426, -0.04143952578306198, -0.0665137767791748, 0.017972620204091072, 0.007730585988610983, 0.00731436163187027, -0.05009026080369949, 0.004922916181385517, 0.0520559698343277, 0.0082728685811162, 0.021079106256365776, 0.021310416981577873, 0.004639795050024986, -0.05994671210646629, -0.009712640196084976, 0.030423277989029884, 0.02046297676861286, 0.031549129635095596, -0.005750824697315693, 0.01107010804116726, 0.05009368434548378, 0.014059723354876041, -0.031306102871894836, 0.030944285914301872, -0.02350999414920807, 0.020014086738228798, -0.029147209599614143, -0.00423355121165514, 0.033820778131484985, -0.008466308005154133, -0.01001708209514618, 0.07571230083703995, 0.012158595025539398, -0.02994026057422161, -0.0074931723065674305, -0.009825735352933407, 0.048617079854011536, 0.009199107997119427, 0.0013704287121072412, 0.0032102426048368216, 0.020935604348778725, -0.03097619116306305, 0.03463703393936157, -0.03658461198210716, -0.017807528376579285, -0.021130437031388283, -0.006565877236425877, -0.012807374820113182, 0.030512358993291855, 0.028075089678168297, -0.026819126680493355, -0.008479450829327106, 0.0030212742276489735, -0.03891401365399361, -0.01744476519525051, -0.02242596447467804, -0.07420401275157928, 0.03909224271774292, 0.0074286372400820255, 0.004039620980620384, 0.02317468263208866, 0.02674337662756443, 0.017421826720237732, 0.023008231073617935, 0.009609752334654331, -0.025350285694003105, -0.02758457511663437, -0.03983146324753761, 0.003994648810476065, 0.01957506127655506, -0.03230676427483559, 0.049133509397506714, -0.010581588372588158, -0.03566518798470497, 0.05259000509977341, -0.029422476887702942, -0.062090057879686356, -0.03940717503428459, 0.021867243573069572, -0.007316284347325563, 0.0013834120472893119, 0.006154095288366079, 0.0095065888017416, -0.012293945997953415, -0.03179562836885452, -0.03830624744296074, -0.07264190912246704, 0.005882078781723976, -0.012875747866928577, 0.05120205506682396, 0.003995997365564108, -0.03883886709809303, 0.03815701603889465, 0.020688878372311592, 0.026165781542658806, -0.028111405670642853, 0.04036690667271614, -0.01876794919371605, -0.0019441527547314763, 0.0018179082544520497, 0.020504742860794067, 0.004362701438367367, 0.021527964621782303, 0.012476477771997452, 0.004130512475967407, 0.03867137059569359, -0.02380206435918808, -0.050869688391685486, 0.027829451486468315, -0.0028738288674503565, 0.0014578023692592978, 0.02608981542289257, 0.013186013326048851, -0.018517421558499336, 0.00945800356566906, 0.017746828496456146, 0.043601296842098236, 0.008681640960276127, -0.025603055953979492, 0.026240212842822075, 0.011030331254005432, 0.0162782184779644, -0.044933151453733444, 0.00443591084331274, 0.009924616664648056, -0.044950976967811584, -0.014704272150993347, 0.04342639073729515, 0.019349949434399605, -0.0255723986774683, 0.03560686483979225, 0.050629790872335434, 0.015839021652936935, -0.00816495530307293, -0.01036732830107212, -0.008598239161074162, 0.002355702454224229, 0.02563941664993763, -0.026533981785178185, -0.01319336611777544, 0.030989328399300575, 0.04820600152015686, 0.04693031311035156, -0.016691194847226143, -0.023082442581653595, 0.023806676268577576, -0.05665704235434532, 0.019280897453427315, -0.005332620814442635, 0.018426386639475822, -0.0037133742589503527, -0.0023772523272782564, 0.038485489785671234, 0.00971295963972807, 0.03133876994252205, -0.0200234055519104, -0.042183127254247665, 0.07022231072187424, -0.01560258399695158, -0.023219646885991096, 0.0011459843954071403, -0.030445683747529984, 0.015519310720264912, 0.0034938857425004244, 0.06617161631584167, 0.022845884785056114, 0.03763352707028389, -0.016435695812106133, 0.016945786774158478, -0.04233354330062866, -0.019429704174399376, 0.026428939774632454, 0.025068111717700958, -0.03595014661550522, -0.06525380164384842, 0.01741390861570835, 0.024380318820476532, -0.0559103898704052, -0.0015412018401548266, 0.008228913880884647, 0.05506376177072525, -0.011756407096982002, 0.01584726944565773, -0.013741141185164452, 0.025955844670534134, -0.05071314051747322, 0.007447920739650726, -0.0033401018008589745, 0.04636039957404137, 0.04791933670639992, 0.018487274646759033, -0.029485275968909264, -0.03684641048312187, -0.03736533969640732, 0.0016790657537057996, 0.016335448250174522, 0.003073479048907757, 0.004372832830995321, 0.03307482227683067, 0.01505617517977953, -0.03468169644474983, 0.04369126632809639, 0.06281792372465134, -0.0025855181738734245, -0.010539153590798378, -0.018460597842931747, -0.023253925144672394, 0.0009117249865084887, 0.004614506848156452, 0.023543164134025574, 0.032463911920785904, 0.005033118650317192, -0.05913873761892319, 0.0438365712761879, -0.01770944893360138, -0.02387675642967224, -0.0004961766535416245, -0.0020870950538665056, 0.034121815115213394, -0.014492073096334934, -0.03284046798944473, 0.012738194316625595, 0.00200401758775115, 0.03567517176270485, -0.00910784862935543, 0.01865798979997635, -0.06486727297306061, -0.004802333656698465, 0.04866606742143631, 0.04206569492816925, -0.03551225736737251, 0.02929689548909664, -0.050738539546728134, 0.017617281526327133, 0.013357039541006088, -0.021607698872685432, 0.028106799349188805, 0.022227328270673752, 0.0032823141664266586, -0.011810039170086384, 0.006939185317605734, -0.04507642984390259, 0.0017828979762271047, -0.005101002752780914, 0.010409393347799778, -0.03296075761318207, -0.027849791571497917, -0.06335259228944778, 0.004081735387444496, 0.05996980518102646, 0.06668467074632645, -0.025436922907829285, -0.04512842744588852, 0.04410231485962868, 0.03382668271660805, -0.01212032325565815, -0.05706636235117912, 0.007151748053729534, 0.005050043575465679, -0.03003886714577675, 0.04293762892484665, 0.009351772256195545, -0.05404305085539818, 0.06567651033401489, -0.03168414533138275, -0.01728757657110691, -0.006835213862359524, 0.03035622648894787, 0.06167095899581909, 0.046935636550188065, 0.03915278613567352, 0.025384699925780296, -0.01697453297674656, 0.020392924547195435, -0.014036191627383232, -0.008910474367439747, 0.0018582427874207497, -0.04746553674340248, -0.00714466255158186, -0.055146362632513046, -0.0015302925603464246, -0.013953540474176407, 0.05231252685189247, -0.024400057271122932, 0.04908669367432594, -0.04478781670331955, -0.0026272039394825697, 0.023936577141284943, 0.019132062792778015, 0.05211317911744118, 0.02937052771449089, -0.006917403545230627, 0.019685007631778717, -0.021928399801254272, -0.016889868304133415, 0.017574824392795563, -0.04299786686897278, -0.003672992577776313, 0.02471986413002014, -0.03649018704891205, 0.015005309134721756, -0.026209650561213493, -0.030866993591189384, 0.0017983111320063472, -0.014592454768717289, 0.06209433823823929, 0.007239531259983778, 0.047917164862155914, 0.019965140148997307, -0.017210863530635834, -0.003950403071939945, 0.04558146372437477, 0.0006216512410901487, 0.07605165243148804, -0.0418943427503109, 0.04949793964624405, 0.023812517523765564, -0.009747592732310295, -0.05452393367886543, -0.014985870569944382, 0.00855785608291626, 0.03327567130327225, 0.019548751413822174, -0.03347385302186012, -0.0034956689924001694, -0.005473415367305279, -0.025092383846640587, -0.033693987876176834, 0.04618416354060173, -0.03503980115056038, -0.07901524007320404, -0.026562975719571114, 0.049384620040655136, 0.11440316587686539, -0.03808998689055443, 0.01853344403207302, -0.006521694827824831, -0.01405947282910347, -0.02959856204688549, 0.013656871393322945, -0.005864486563950777, -0.012674380093812943, -0.01462139468640089, -0.01062120869755745, -0.006376368924975395, 0.04238856956362724, -0.07125205546617508, -0.01784674823284149, 0.025005660951137543, 0.005182493012398481, 0.018093518912792206, -0.0064630513079464436, -0.016934966668486595, -0.021902205422520638, 0.010838180780410767, -0.03979384899139404, 0.011255532503128052, 0.03812270984053612, -0.019419165328145027, 0.023820267990231514, 0.03308800980448723, -0.0123826265335083, 0.023850686848163605, 0.05761508643627167, -0.010942201130092144, 0.01955677568912506, -0.024766677990555763, -0.016026264056563377, 0.022723274305462837, -0.00506398594006896, -0.04286086931824684, 0.006773604545742273, 0.015386518090963364, -0.032743699848651886, -0.04567192494869232, 0.0010796200949698687, 0.005342954304069281, 0.040997400879859924, -0.0092617217451334, 0.04976566880941391, 0.04307911545038223, 0.007432917132973671, 0.015010807663202286, -0.010612508282065392, 0.009566991589963436, -0.007472948636859655, 0.010470063425600529, 0.050412509590387344, 0.010324125178158283, -0.014023760333657265, 0.059668708592653275, -0.011776252649724483, 0.016473250463604927, 0.02470747008919716, 0.013354698196053505, 0.02832235023379326, 0.005500510800629854, -0.03807411715388298, -0.04289469122886658, 0.022565776482224464, -0.04316768795251846, 0.02775506116449833, -0.05423396825790405, 0.03421515226364136, 0.05007662624120712, 0.056574635207653046, 0.02878425270318985, -0.037179987877607346, -0.045626670122146606, -0.06711023300886154, -0.05135205760598183, 0.036097750067710876, -0.0027273641899228096, -0.0005244845524430275, -0.009948772378265858, 0.04601167514920235, -0.003539094002917409, 0.017604149878025055, -0.04179461672902107, -0.07293396443128586, -0.018886994570493698, -0.005396327003836632, -0.04573165625333786, 0.013808272778987885, -0.030849305912852287, -0.007737273816019297, 0.04176566004753113, -0.056709252297878265, 0.041901860386133194, -0.01124937366694212, 0.004708270542323589, -0.02269100770354271, 0.033072032034397125, 0.0012996284058317542, 0.03419328108429909, -0.0035806060768663883, -0.011303896084427834, 0.10186504572629929, 0.025615664198994637, 0.03887353464961052, -0.019046401605010033, -0.019079897552728653, -0.02756231650710106, -0.001386143616400659, -0.011517209000885487, 0.018117565661668777, 0.01797511987388134, -0.006426754407584667, 0.03915119171142578, 0.03529662638902664, 0.026960045099258423, -0.01808467134833336, 0.05587230250239372, -0.013459743931889534, -0.006406500935554504, 0.019263723865151405, 0.003403723705559969, 0.00215116236358881, -0.04734186455607414, -0.020562022924423218, 0.013499920256435871, -0.0025421895552426577, -0.03102175146341324, -0.06324178725481033, 0.014910499565303326, -0.0004036934988107532, 0.021846886724233627, 0.0003581558703444898, -0.0014757146127521992, 0.006816515699028969, -0.005274946801364422, -0.036784008145332336, 0.014268969185650349, 0.011197658255696297, -0.057665444910526276, 0.02420976012945175, 0.03992908447980881, -0.015595506876707077, -0.011336284689605236, 0.017703430727124214, 0.03264642879366875, -0.04187620058655739, -0.012559610418975353, 0.00751876924186945, 0.01770295947790146, 0.018019676208496094, -0.01938939467072487, -0.010736816562712193, 0.004865740891546011, -0.030836215242743492, -0.031204024329781532, -0.013551539741456509, 0.04368932545185089, 0.001761970459483564, -0.03307579085230827, -0.004088044166564941, -0.018813088536262512, 0.05808286368846893, 0.023516319692134857, 0.034421052783727646, 0.012122767977416515, 0.008474443107843399, -0.007236962206661701, 0.011940261349081993, 0.03413403034210205, 0.004592906218022108, -0.017375284805893898, -0.012010394595563412, -0.0021920225117355585, -0.025277791544795036, 0.01669500395655632, 0.010056601837277412, -0.01153144333511591, 0.0269435066729784, 0.028010442852973938, -0.021136123687028885, -0.011492167599499226, -0.05749938637018204, 0.015156444162130356, -0.01235349290072918, 0.037552934139966965, -0.033750858157873154, -0.036943309009075165, 0.031000060960650444, 0.007544951047748327, 0.038381610065698624, -0.016179054975509644, 0.0401528961956501, 0.05784241482615471, 0.06517785042524338, -0.03221329674124718, -0.008865206502377987, -0.010970942676067352, -0.025542939081788063, -0.0013707233592867851, -0.04591914266347885, 0.054494474083185196, 0.013554944656789303, -0.006237063556909561, -0.0039021905977278948, 0.010052373632788658, -0.033586855977773666, 0.015097536146640778, 0.007400063332170248, -0.05804149806499481, -0.00033003310090862215, 0.007456348743289709, 0.007000322453677654, -0.009942416101694107, -0.0072509972378611565, -0.020790306851267815, -0.031124213710427284, 0.031155286356806755, -0.02446375973522663, -0.008743057027459145, -0.0321437269449234, -0.02785848081111908, 0.015318762511014938, 0.010535701178014278, -0.023338550701737404, 0.007155077066272497, 0.007661599200218916, 0.04666242003440857, -0.0012457657139748335, -0.03621423989534378, 0.01746404729783535, -0.00779741583392024, -0.030445532873272896, 0.05528433620929718, -0.0010397828882560134, 0.013331715017557144, 0.00897172186523676, -0.00547665124759078, -0.021195242181420326, 0.015954051166772842, -0.0301965419203043, -0.009466003626585007, 0.09243815392255783, -0.04232899099588394, 0.007813701406121254, 0.03999638557434082, -0.012518476694822311, 0.021892117336392403, -0.008579644374549389, -0.03173045441508293, -0.022401846945285797, 0.028798745945096016, -0.05769876018166542, -0.03551439940929413, -0.008715159259736538, -0.022353151813149452, -0.004178518895059824, -0.03486979380249977, 0.02663901448249817, 0.01286749355494976, -0.0015234402380883694, 0.052732065320014954, 0.023880485445261, -0.02309320867061615, 0.01358719076961279, -0.0023071730975061655, -0.01446856465190649, 0.0451224111020565, -0.0006387056782841682, -0.010839154943823814, 0.04667887091636658, 0.07034599781036377, -0.04256098344922066, 0.03717480227351189, -0.03768506646156311, -0.00099377881269902, -0.09006866812705994, -0.039593618363142014, 0.047426268458366394, -0.025444163009524345, 0.03529823198914528, -0.06820904463529587, -0.005502673331648111, 0.012488065287470818, -0.03244370222091675, -0.01750815659761429, -0.021967358887195587, -0.04308353736996651, -0.059005096554756165, -0.014817408286035061, -0.009264043532311916, 0.006155552342534065, -0.033519573509693146, 0.05696948245167732, -0.0038175550289452076, 0.04620738327503204, -0.03000836819410324, 0.01603439450263977, -0.013410809449851513, -0.002509060315787792, -0.006844270508736372, -0.09471969306468964, -0.018638117238879204, -0.032185148447752, -0.027536358684301376, 0.049985822290182114, -0.007423941511660814, 0.031171899288892746, -0.014993776567280293, 0.003870160784572363, -0.012129870243370533, 0.03910021111369133, 0.05321243032813072, -0.018023625016212463, 0.0025587265845388174, -0.013584819622337818, -0.02128281071782112, 0.034577466547489166, 0.017531733959913254, -0.02867508865892887, 0.056447114795446396, -0.026767672970891, 0.010401162318885326, 0.031287044286727905, -0.006327230948954821, -0.015759343281388283, 0.0037251177709549665, 0.03247413411736488, 0.019842328503727913, -0.016980763524770737, 0.0015357735101133585, -0.022729521617293358, -0.0073948809877038, 0.016875363886356354, 0.042520616203546524, -0.045478351414203644, 0.02249644137918949, -0.028410283848643303, -0.02120439149439335, 0.0078014894388616085, -0.0049172332510352135, 0.012473953887820244, -0.045580025762319565, -0.028535369783639908, -0.01748390682041645, 0.009047862142324448, -0.029242921620607376, -0.018874818459153175, -0.04432281479239464, 0.022569214925169945, -0.022403426468372345, 0.04615714028477669, 0.010541630908846855, -0.0008296547457575798, -0.014025743119418621, -0.0490926094353199, 0.01715288683772087, 0.0038905192632228136, 0.025844639167189598, -0.03882307559251785, -0.01685214787721634, -0.04963349178433418, -0.018360933288931847, 0.062492549419403076, 0.0568428710103035, 0.008715098723769188, -0.002214952604845166, -0.01332901231944561, 0.021255649626255035, -0.08329669386148453, 0.039133790880441666, -0.04027051851153374, -0.024113427847623825, -0.015178042463958263, -0.01954832673072815, 0.05080639198422432, -0.00042433146154507995, 0.012976250611245632, -0.03759796917438507, -0.025849856436252594, 0.01848633587360382, 0.025127481669187546, 0.04247564449906349, -0.0007053547305986285, 0.0035527958534657955, 0.05681844428181648, -0.01856268383562565, 0.02329840138554573, -0.010591136291623116, -0.006450831890106201, -0.07285690307617188, 0.038845036178827286, -0.021710515022277832, -0.04790731146931648, 0.0007377925212495029, 0.0136767802760005, 0.017521141096949577, -0.03682219237089157, -0.024898257106542587, 0.009151516482234001, -0.03246248885989189, -0.0042200409807264805, 0.013535919599235058, 0.03691786155104637, -0.007601351942867041, -0.023755144327878952, 0.026007715612649918, 0.03322269022464752, -0.011173033155500889, 0.004294049460440874, 0.0020943349227309227, 0.019672663882374763, -0.0018147373339161277, -0.007502246648073196, 0.04630390927195549, -0.055043961852788925, 0.021052446216344833, -0.032908763736486435, 0.048110052943229675, 0.0037619711365550756, -0.04503798112273216, 0.011513720266520977, 0.003066081553697586, 0.021094027906656265, 0.016761042177677155, -0.023952538147568703, 0.04568026587367058, -0.004163152538239956, -0.00969728548079729, -0.029300333932042122, -0.014160607010126114, -0.00908831600099802, -0.010871397331357002, 0.01533601712435484, -0.02571183629333973, -0.014663856476545334, -0.008943479508161545, 0.010007052682340145, -0.012431525625288486, 0.028599178418517113, -0.02675062231719494, -0.021663213148713112, -0.011348742991685867, 0.02108127251267433, -0.04532575607299805, -0.020997434854507446, -0.0004956653574481606, -0.04025968536734581, 0.026329634711146355, 0.04120001941919327, -0.00012964785855729133, 0.005244102329015732, -0.02143123932182789, 0.0027016540989279747, 0.050201792269945145, -0.05590120330452919, -0.013389077968895435, -0.06436854600906372, 0.004088345915079117, 0.0120217464864254, -0.043559812009334564 ]
<p>This may be a stupid question but... is there a specific name for normalizing some data so that it has mean=0 and sd=1? </p> <p>Or do I just say "data was normalized to have mean=0 and sd=1"?</p> <p>thanks nico</p>
47,158
[ -0.03775286301970482, -0.008114021271467209, -0.032355744391679764, 0.0002865751157514751, -0.004204418510198593, 0.015488719567656517, -0.014581478200852871, -0.012463820166885853, -0.006104622967541218, -0.010423176921904087, 0.03171154856681824, -0.0032479672227054834, 0.03712471202015877, -0.006024844944477081, 0.04285970330238342, 0.009155086241662502, -0.015026799403131008, -0.0032993510831147432, -0.027392227202653885, -0.03457899019122124, 0.015384379774332047, -0.01773012988269329, -0.00284016621299088, 0.0158905778080225, -0.017275461927056313, 0.04265066608786583, 0.010013693943619728, -0.020467370748519897, -0.05508444830775261, 0.045839160680770874, -0.04675372689962387, -0.016087573021650314, -0.002783182542771101, 0.014092369936406612, 0.007439667824655771, -0.011304829269647598, -0.014545896090567112, -0.007923704572021961, -0.027174152433872223, 0.037690527737140656, -0.0010861444752663374, -0.018121393397450447, 0.014964012429118156, 0.040530845522880554, -0.018130915239453316, 0.017253026366233826, 0.01348052266985178, -0.02344978041946888, -0.0037319078110158443, -0.05931980535387993, 0.08778266608715057, -0.03264089301228523, 0.06504226475954056, 0.04293832182884216, 0.016689341515302658, 0.015624254941940308, 0.04584844410419464, 0.02069185860455036, 0.015696367248892784, -0.05998179689049721, -0.03111080639064312, -0.018089070916175842, -0.0026927199214696884, 0.015149989165365696, -0.008025480434298515, 0.026629704982042313, 0.010654891841113567, -0.03552651032805443, 0.045629456639289856, 0.0014035176718607545, -0.02218444086611271, 0.01930873841047287, 0.035400014370679855, -0.03541294112801552, 0.010142849758267403, -0.030800238251686096, 0.008518662303686142, -0.01821126602590084, 0.022234059870243073, 0.040918733924627304, 0.029780928045511246, 0.006769126746803522, 0.018060578033328056, -0.0075247264467179775, 0.005136645399034023, 0.0012982719345018268, 0.08906178921461105, -0.026190325617790222, 0.012752077542245388, 0.0764147937297821, -0.01311071403324604, -0.003979504108428955, 0.0368184857070446, -0.010899069719016552, -0.054471295326948166, 0.054126568138599396, 0.011978057213127613, 0.04705232381820679, -0.009070469997823238, -0.035191960632801056, 0.014451835304498672, -0.04575653746724129, 0.008102336898446083, 0.023807823657989502, -0.03640362620353699, 0.014642569236457348, -0.056083351373672485, 0.02986304648220539, -0.02254939079284668, 0.002769466722384095, -0.028701774775981903, 0.003470400348305702, 0.03440069034695625, -0.012821231037378311, 0.012819564901292324, -0.008180164732038975, -0.006189793348312378, 0.04804110899567604, 0.05281471833586693, 0.05458679422736168, 0.03720029816031456, -0.04396061226725578, 0.03439982235431671, 0.036607954651117325, -0.07614507526159286, 0.021754693239927292, 0.007542121224105358, -0.019006889313459396, -0.05677112936973572, 0.05732747167348862, -0.011267888359725475, -0.02097240835428238, 0.050612810999155045, -0.027508368715643883, 0.031685907393693924, -0.0029434259049594402, -0.03849908709526062, -0.05076703801751137, 0.03933968022465706, -0.016709383577108383, 0.029587989673018456, -0.04282005503773689, -0.013650906272232533, 0.014434607699513435, 0.019339224323630333, 0.05713804438710213, 0.04213818535208702, 0.02346203289926052, -0.011408579535782337, -0.00960681214928627, 0.013683506287634373, -0.051137860864400864, 0.01761237159371376, -0.05162344127893448, -0.02757774479687214, -0.03672762215137482, 0.023352762684226036, 0.040853872895240784, 0.01155902910977602, 0.01227659173309803, 0.031559791415929794, -0.03735567629337311, -0.00334091205149889, 0.04971785470843315, 0.010279681533575058, -0.030949333682656288, 0.063115693628788, 0.024234125390648842, 0.039261043071746826, 0.009898572228848934, 0.02745894342660904, 0.03134828805923462, -0.01894432120025158, 0.0690499022603035, 0.06472552567720413, -0.012852414511144161, -0.039441801607608795, -0.0024153105914592743, 0.046133723109960556, 0.031132275238633156, -0.016842413693666458, 0.004457017872482538, -0.0019114421447739005, 0.023196952417492867, 0.014823433011770248, 0.05539848282933235, -0.008596681989729404, -0.03005976788699627, 0.009992486797273159, -0.056983936578035355, 0.0037119684275239706, -0.04989675059914589, -0.031194355338811874, -0.04689960181713104, -0.006647863425314426, 0.0036138249561190605, 0.0021906874608248472, 0.030769241973757744, -0.043687332421541214, -0.011190696619451046, -0.026455122977495193, -0.011482727713882923, 0.04577288031578064, -0.08783154934644699, -0.015436984598636627, 0.03392636403441429, 0.03427720442414284, -0.044073089957237244, 0.04198487848043442, -0.023516030982136726, -0.006028981413692236, -0.04632630944252014, -0.005220833700150251, 0.029839232563972473, -0.02854066528379917, -0.009287851862609386, 0.03518608212471008, 0.015933848917484283, -0.014129984192550182, 0.01481049507856369, -0.055827777832746506, 0.0343233160674572, 0.053153734654188156, -0.016078464686870575, -0.017527492716908455, -0.020945962518453598, 0.03489021956920624, 0.002992818132042885, 0.003524415660649538, -0.026887286454439163, -0.03889619559049606, 0.0064193857833743095, 0.04732923582196236, 0.01535562053322792, -0.01731482893228531, -0.022634197026491165, 0.07569313049316406, 0.03588574752211571, 0.016305051743984222, 0.03241901099681854, -0.021928077563643456, 0.010479575023055077, -0.006448073778301477, -0.018471525982022285, 0.0302208811044693, -0.0014407598646357656, 0.02499683015048504, -0.008172407746315002, 0.039373043924570084, 0.04126359149813652, -0.004479161463677883, 0.051400069147348404, 0.02942168340086937, 0.013800127431750298, -0.009119360707700253, -0.03695845231413841, 0.03266125172376633, -0.050005797296762466, 0.03304344415664673, 0.022899655625224113, 0.0076507204212248325, -0.025668416172266006, 0.004820271395146847, 0.025215337052941322, 0.015912439674139023, 0.03286059945821762, -0.010131597518920898, 0.026219312101602554, 0.025919973850250244, -0.017789557576179504, 0.02083250693976879, -0.007684843614697456, -0.03195183724164963, -0.04322022944688797, -0.01129736565053463, 0.05237261950969696, 0.008230584673583508, 0.051767781376838684, -0.035309817641973495, -0.00022082870418671519, -0.029947122558951378, -0.01923637092113495, 0.029454205185174942, 0.03234391659498215, -0.028530756011605263, -0.005242334213107824, -0.015050123445689678, -0.03007897175848484, 0.027904121205210686, -0.00599801866337657, -0.006256531924009323, 0.038500819355249405, -0.008015959523618221, -0.04435698688030243, -0.02164972759783268, -0.051063213497400284, 0.02850126475095749, 0.00964469276368618, -0.011124233715236187, 0.04388807341456413, 0.015396581962704659, -0.05546880140900612, 0.009179015643894672, -0.06600971519947052, -0.05233852192759514, -0.05385952070355415, -0.03470909595489502, 0.02475149556994438, -0.021565865725278854, 0.040531225502491, 0.024419452995061874, -0.05818209797143936, 0.00006231129373190925, -0.040406327694654465, -0.020570138469338417, 0.020146675407886505, -0.011705891229212284, 0.03697039932012558, 0.013991426676511765, -0.011777828447520733, 0.07222764939069748, 0.0012826327001675963, -0.013062532059848309, -0.04689687490463257, 0.031685035675764084, -0.02544121816754341, -0.028450116515159607, 0.0065749166533350945, 0.009372329339385033, 0.007200423162430525, -0.010396307334303856, -0.012586410157382488, 0.03890855237841606, 0.05285509675741196, 0.011866378597915173, -0.028326842933893204, 0.020877879112958908, -0.008205740712583065, -0.0073997159488499165, 0.02196488529443741, 0.056388940662145615, -0.020097196102142334, 0.01207487378269434, -0.0073166340589523315, 0.05038094148039818, 0.029382167384028435, -0.04149894788861275, 0.014810945838689804, 0.016496649011969566, 0.00872437097132206, -0.020729875192046165, 0.02166704647243023, 0.031919606029987335, -0.027616256847977638, -0.024010686203837395, 0.026862438768148422, -0.014981006272137165, -0.030333420261740685, -0.006236000452190638, 0.049978822469711304, 0.03353463113307953, -0.03467797860503197, -0.02472004108130932, 0.007341024465858936, 0.0060136388055980206, 0.012727613560855389, -0.043109145015478134, -0.021366629749536514, 0.0326063372194767, 0.037852007895708084, 0.029645800590515137, 0.02568950690329075, -0.05667072907090187, 0.03200669214129448, -0.10361751914024353, 0.019967813044786453, 0.001793049625121057, 0.03207791969180107, 0.004464041441679001, 0.024093179032206535, 0.027020163834095, 0.02821705862879753, 0.03680882602930069, -0.0050303759053349495, -0.05212801322340965, 0.022346843034029007, -0.03787858039140701, -0.025326693430542946, -0.007664583157747984, -0.018618397414684296, 0.018605481833219528, -0.04599440470337868, 0.007428280543535948, 0.00926738977432251, 0.015599314123392105, -0.04816284030675888, -0.02148108184337616, 0.018207021057605743, -0.025161733850836754, -0.012943082489073277, -0.012594485655426979, 0.016336411237716675, 0.0359361357986927, 0.021992716938257217, 0.025775302201509476, 0.044302016496658325, -0.015583595260977745, -0.036157671362161636, -0.0089228181168437, 0.019364090636372566, 0.04668601229786873, -0.01442683581262827, 0.032970964908599854, -0.05262751132249832, 0.040165871381759644, 0.01043214462697506, 0.04956704005599022, 0.009142623282968998, -0.0016816563438624144, -0.019922615960240364, -0.04353916272521019, -0.018077144399285316, -0.00895820651203394, 0.0009521213942207396, 0.011120805516839027, -0.01596709154546261, -0.008932686410844326, 0.0565953403711319, -0.0392286442220211, 0.012329893186688423, 0.10300920158624649, 0.016742661595344543, -0.017106300219893456, -0.03245234861969948, -0.000895422650501132, -0.008129013702273369, 0.007048687431961298, 0.020408663898706436, 0.041638679802417755, -0.004946371540427208, 0.017822671681642532, 0.0022089877165853977, -0.0035591195337474346, -0.010641183704137802, -0.016317099332809448, -0.007918729446828365, 0.03382434323430061, 0.0071581522934138775, -0.013812001794576645, 0.021702995523810387, 0.04659678414463997, 0.019629569724202156, 0.03833311051130295, -0.014059762470424175, -0.06775715947151184, 0.029128454625606537, 0.025645066052675247, 0.03727922588586807, -0.014768623746931553, 0.0020724858622998, -0.01798539236187935, -0.016911428421735764, 0.02914680913090706, -0.032936517149209976, -0.006764763966202736, -0.05153535678982735, -0.0051012528128921986, 0.006777098868042231, 0.009729448705911636, -0.04272487387061119, 0.026427246630191803, -0.0028373796958476305, 0.04576025530695915, 0.015432436019182205, -0.0020876447670161724, -0.07447966188192368, -0.013036251068115234, -0.018473923206329346, 0.03652069345116615, -0.03758571669459343, -0.014448372647166252, 0.00991570670157671, 0.06235381215810776, -0.02519369125366211, -0.08414090424776077, 0.0002845472772605717, 0.034223999828100204, 0.020646076649427414, 0.012604259885847569, 0.0029043492395430803, -0.04383353516459465, 0.02683056890964508, -0.00035580762778408825, -0.035210441797971725, 0.02135458029806614, -0.010667109861969948, 0.05599096044898033, 0.037012673914432526, 0.004992637317627668, 0.04284132272005081, 0.038504183292388916, 0.02036886289715767, -0.01717895083129406, -0.06575324386358261, 0.02770404890179634, -0.05352713167667389, -0.015919603407382965, -0.07130719721317291, 0.0111647117882967, -0.04731694236397743, 0.012327736243605614, 0.007546484004706144, 0.05104003846645355, -0.0006798201939091086, -0.032951582223176956, 0.019958920776844025, 0.009353172034025192, 0.0014089326141402125, -0.03394532948732376, 0.0022197372745722532, -0.015468710102140903, -0.007198710925877094, -0.03826936334371567, -0.011577623896300793, -0.03537276014685631, -0.02016471140086651, 0.03576597198843956, -0.019548848271369934, 0.030790075659751892, -0.02416958287358284, -0.036529041826725006, 0.036855489015579224, -0.051555681973695755, 0.03407123684883118, -0.023025833070278168, 0.016958199441432953, -0.012951246462762356, -0.04133987054228783, -0.008039065636694431, 0.01171055156737566, -0.015820635482668877, 0.009771195240318775, -0.08717530220746994, 0.025625471025705338, 0.00835783313959837, 0.006926402915269136, -0.04897042363882065, -0.04698885604739189, 0.03419104218482971, -0.016614330932497978, 0.004002195782959461, -0.04497850313782692, 0.027406923472881317, 0.0061691515147686005, -0.03967023640871048, -0.0032126291189342737, 0.04230216145515442, -0.00941820815205574, -0.02278316579759121, -0.019920729100704193, 0.004593802150338888, 0.06379427760839462, -0.00962661299854517, -0.019174421206116676, -0.013730288483202457, 0.009553709998726845, -0.01764494925737381, 0.01810109242796898, 0.04400826618075371, -0.04116405174136162, 0.016694163903594017, -0.06916531175374985, -0.04986469820141792, 0.013176840730011463, 0.010823220014572144, 0.027215611189603806, -0.012639617547392845, -0.0014891097089275718, 0.00533702177926898, -0.02272496372461319, 0.018405096605420113, -0.018950842320919037, -0.012233000248670578, -0.00839743111282587, -0.006671621929854155, -0.03540439158678055, -0.0001510527217760682, 0.020414546132087708, 0.010106674395501614, -0.012409775517880917, -0.009856504388153553, 0.05346180871129036, 0.025613892823457718, 0.004481141455471516, -0.00817824061959982, -0.01726052723824978, 0.029933294281363487, 0.027151402086019516, -0.005563700571656227, 0.005912799388170242, 0.003145914990454912, -0.031824324280023575, -0.014911863952875137, 0.0004851695557590574, -0.04204438999295235, 0.04224485903978348, -0.01713806390762329, 0.0708814412355423, 0.053933847695589066, -0.0033267296385020018, 0.004886181093752384, -0.05066368728876114, -0.00307258777320385, -0.0036653857678174973, 0.0032690633088350296, 0.056954581290483475, -0.0007017108146101236, 0.02970901131629944, 0.002368405694141984, 0.036401715129613876, -0.005243971943855286, 0.06515812128782272, 0.029463695362210274, 0.0009784783469513059, 0.019838424399495125, -0.027095608413219452, -0.06286076456308365, 0.06023736670613289, -0.02554398402571678, 0.011429567821323872, -0.004167760256677866, -0.02796250395476818, 0.04905691742897034, 0.013413872569799423, 0.011376886628568172, -0.053600408136844635, -0.00016815173148643225, -0.047768473625183105, 0.022804036736488342, 0.022364847362041473, -0.0529811792075634, 0.03510848060250282, -0.05456283316016197, 0.02721167355775833, -0.03594203665852547, -0.007306709885597229, -0.007943029515445232, -0.060508910566568375, -0.0019922114443033934, -0.03387872502207756, -0.0008116941316984594, 0.008765828795731068, -0.01828715391457081, -0.002400454832240939, -0.014270799234509468, -0.035350218415260315, 0.00921287015080452, 0.02075713686645031, 0.014258161187171936, -0.031387876719236374, 0.02940518595278263, 0.03566848859190941, 0.022548804059624672, -0.007888512685894966, -0.013248758390545845, 0.1352604180574417, 0.065859854221344, 0.02848503366112709, -0.058321576565504074, -0.01531748566776514, 0.01680585741996765, 0.01179755199700594, -0.011351843364536762, 0.017770584672689438, -0.02794836089015007, 0.029782051220536232, 0.03192957863211632, 0.046842142939567566, 0.007733082864433527, 0.018416430801153183, 0.05692194402217865, -0.005765806417912245, -0.035108234733343124, 0.027869831770658493, 0.00391422538086772, -0.01832776516675949, -0.013692199252545834, -0.10643929988145828, 0.034930307418107986, 0.02954168990254402, -0.012180216610431671, -0.00677872821688652, 0.009962087497115135, 0.017215179279446602, 0.04013485461473465, -0.0038310368545353413, 0.014764423482120037, 0.05135112628340721, 0.02784106321632862, -0.011471075937151909, -0.046795446425676346, 0.037584442645311356, -0.026167122647166252, -0.009390916675329208, 0.03225407749414444, 0.009333926253020763, 0.009477945975959301, 0.0072905016131699085, -0.02656560391187668, -0.04083220660686493, -0.0185577180236578, 0.011526819318532944, 0.04055489972233772, -0.020007483661174774, -0.014044721610844135, -0.004925653338432312, 0.02579990215599537, -0.029813826084136963, -0.03356155380606651, 0.00698369974270463, 0.007921617478132248, 0.02002594619989395, 0.0026620831340551376, -0.006020102649927139, -0.02228846773505211, 0.0027623686473816633, -0.02324785105884075, 0.013540465384721756, 0.029118768870830536, 0.013891798444092274, 0.018986718729138374, -0.023864014074206352, 0.04603167250752449, -0.022389333695173264, 0.003474404802545905, 0.03762444481253624, -0.017437465488910675, -0.03670535609126091, 0.009053503163158894, -0.0029365725349634886, -0.002458837116137147, 0.05291745066642761, -0.016520200297236443, -0.00006197416951181367, -0.0548732653260231, -0.028212565928697586, 0.044159892946481705, -0.01283351331949234, 0.0058579170145094395, -0.03361507132649422, -0.01236946601420641, 0.015276131220161915, 0.0641053318977356, -0.012676818296313286, 0.009141243994235992, 0.019551897421479225, 0.06602859497070312, 0.053123049437999725, -0.033831410109996796, -0.022745288908481598, 0.019209200516343117, -0.039999108761548996, 0.01570604369044304, -0.031251221895217896, 0.048247333616018295, 0.034414246678352356, 0.008629515767097473, -0.032191112637519836, 0.04312930628657341, -0.008228220045566559, 0.02497253753244877, -0.028516488149762154, -0.03445492684841156, 0.022713283076882362, -0.010710119269788265, 0.03554466739296913, -0.004296738654375076, -0.019899673759937286, 0.007902642711997032, 0.011350009590387344, -0.0065977973863482475, 0.019767003133893013, -0.015215120278298855, 0.0209822840988636, -0.039077091962099075, 0.007427182048559189, 0.006354806944727898, -0.03228114917874336, -0.06180867552757263, -0.039517369121313095, 0.02424508146941662, -0.028970878571271896, -0.011463850736618042, 0.002298147650435567, 0.02132326550781727, 0.042352452874183655, 0.03794558346271515, 0.003778312122449279, 0.000617913668975234, 0.0035463753156363964, 0.009443972259759903, -0.011844138614833355, 0.014891344122588634, -0.011950639076530933, 0.02708338387310505, 0.03464923053979874, -0.030592113733291626, -0.033192455768585205, 0.012888471595942974, 0.030869100242853165, 0.03412683308124542, 0.003431644756346941, -0.02063676156103611, -0.03333152458071709, 0.04463065415620804, -0.021853018552064896, -0.05826643109321594, -0.031971875578165054, -0.03010445646941662, -0.0037434266414493322, 0.038298171013593674, -0.020481429994106293, 0.02107163332402706, -0.025525100529193878, -0.016899460926651955, 0.0065151541493833065, 0.008962889201939106, -0.020428404211997986, 0.010751998983323574, 0.060281023383140564, 0.012883341871201992, 0.0049558947794139385, 0.007300615776330233, 0.021370070055127144, 0.04046235978603363, -0.05805451050400734, -0.005522625986486673, -0.00843404233455658, -0.0054493374191224575, -0.06537841260433197, -0.02271638624370098, 0.025836778804659843, -0.015155920758843422, 0.00595458596944809, -0.04401637613773346, 0.014806819148361683, -0.017946947365999222, -0.04506475850939751, -0.006771942134946585, 0.01529629249125719, -0.047135960310697556, -0.016788501292467117, 0.025462161749601364, 0.012624576687812805, 0.02471183054149151, 0.03266659006476402, 0.03027164749801159, -0.03829606994986534, 0.02145107463002205, -0.0076471902430057526, 0.015451488085091114, -0.01588905043900013, 0.01644141972064972, 0.014641550369560719, -0.06881133466959, -0.018149521201848984, -0.07523556053638458, -0.026737665757536888, 0.05999565124511719, 0.009700855240225792, -0.012297539040446281, 0.04883124679327011, 0.053850192576646805, -0.0021694041788578033, -0.0017660760786384344, 0.0009430682403035462, -0.015437186695635319, -0.06843806803226471, 0.023445870727300644, 0.01742447167634964, 0.050118859857320786, -0.004223814699798822, -0.031314101070165634, 0.028993209823966026, -0.056019436568021774, -0.03992004692554474, 0.011257776990532875, -0.038547005504369736, -0.03641103580594063, -0.029009617865085602, -0.04823944717645645, 0.011079052463173866, -0.0029526036232709885, -0.010236726142466068, -0.025200344622135162, 0.03189890459179878, 0.01839711144566536, -0.01346291322261095, -0.03128879517316818, 0.01977377012372017, 0.012325655668973923, -0.025791583582758904, 0.02801932953298092, 0.007761660497635603, -0.04403030127286911, -0.047913603484630585, -0.03058917447924614, -0.010259130969643593, -0.01993286795914173, -0.015074804425239563, -0.020594626665115356, -0.019458329305052757, 0.039143502712249756, 0.0030210858676582575, 0.0012785017024725676, 0.03455505892634392, -0.045644793659448624, -0.003659522393718362, -0.06148945167660713, 0.07176825404167175, 0.04864739626646042, 0.0030473920051008463, -0.005094899330288172, 0.017761634662747383, -0.051278647035360336, 0.005520858336240053, 0.07264435291290283, 0.015769071877002716, 0.02844221703708172, -0.025269625708460808, 0.03285420686006546, 0.03930220380425453, -0.04921611398458481, 0.0363733172416687, 0.02736176922917366, -0.047212131321430206, -0.002286942210048437, 0.00039049272891134024, 0.008872018195688725, -0.03740265592932701, -0.010738762095570564, 0.019554970785975456, -0.009961806237697601, -0.03618950769305229, -0.009933405555784702, 0.0404854379594326, 0.026387618854641914, -0.03155853971838951, 0.04364354908466339, -0.019493767991662025, -0.03299720585346222, 0.018721697852015495, -0.00372681999579072, -0.0493851937353611, 0.020073270425200462, -0.044309310615062714, -0.015573935583233833, -0.020928479731082916, 0.020209312438964844, 0.01966381072998047, -0.04862789809703827, -0.0011919417884200811, -0.00747707299888134, -0.024536872282624245, 0.01080771442502737, 0.033495042473077774, 0.023240402340888977, 0.06341222673654556, -0.020715218037366867, -0.0023513894993811846, -0.0155573058873415, 0.0010680616833269596, 0.058080729097127914, 0.029052790254354477, 0.019634025171399117, 0.01828123815357685, 0.004438341129571199, 0.000029275077395141125, -0.007420441601425409, 0.032002273947000504, -0.002667227992787957, 0.02460041455924511, -0.042241305112838745, -0.018703149631619453, 0.015807218849658966, -0.014361709356307983, 0.0331261083483696, 0.015956006944179535, 0.017442088574171066, 0.05092604458332062, -0.026867633685469627, -0.00850667804479599, -0.05522438883781433, -0.02446715533733368, -0.041424643248319626, -0.022821050137281418, 0.0009224206442013383, 0.06465836614370346, -0.015808016061782837, -0.021504221484065056, -0.010761135257780552, -0.004155004862695932, 0.04565049335360527, -0.048419807106256485, 0.04665563628077507, -0.027662066742777824, 0.009961861185729504, 0.009634735994040966, 0.023075107485055923, -0.015457360073924065, 0.00892424676567316, 0.02897271327674389, 0.016489651054143906, 0.05075858160853386, 0.001758033991791308, 0.00962843932211399, 0.01707828789949417, 0.017535552382469177, -0.07442377507686615, -0.038266174495220184, -0.037152986973524094, 0.006791728548705578, -0.019284430891275406, -0.011874423362314701 ]
<p>Lately, I have been interested in phenomenons related to omission of variables. For example, it can be shown that the expected value of the sample variance under the inclusion of one variable $x_1$ but omission of one variable $x_2$ is $\mathbb{E}(s^2|x_1,x_2)= \sigma^2 + \frac{\sigma^2}{n-1} RSS_{x_1, \beta_2 x_2}$ where $\beta_2$ is the true coefficient of $x_2$ and $RSS_{x_1, \beta_2 x_2}$ is the residual sum of squares when running a regression with $x_1$ as predictor and $\beta_2x_2$ as outcome. Now, I am interested in getting a better expression for this when we have an $AR(2)$ process.</p> <p>Let an $AR(2)$-process be given by $x_t = ax_{t-1}+bx_{t-2} + \epsilon_t$ (with the $\epsilon_i$ being independent and normal with standard deviation $\sigma$).</p> <p>If we run a regression with $(x_2,\ldots, x_T)$ as the response vector and $(x_1,\ldots, x_{T-1})$ as the predicting variable, what can be said about the residual sum of squares? That is, if we (falsely) think that the process is an $AR(1)$-process, what can be said about the expected residual sum of squares?</p> <p>Since I am quite unschooled in statistics (my only academic background is in mathematics), I would be interested in references (articles and books) as well as answers, even if they are only tangentially related to this question.</p>
35,751
[ 0.011615319177508354, -0.010530658066272736, -0.019190292805433273, 0.0056464411318302155, 0.016185861080884933, 0.016141755506396294, 0.0020472388714551926, -0.015991857275366783, 0.035957466810941696, -0.0604521706700325, -0.012480787001550198, 0.00948213692754507, 0.0807327926158905, -0.017803726717829704, 0.02265232428908348, 0.008355558849871159, -0.018244829028844833, -0.0047719040885567665, 0.027930213138461113, -0.0040809838101267815, -0.00324689201079309, 0.015518170781433582, 0.010482516139745712, -0.01690690778195858, -0.024870652705430984, 0.07298865169286728, 0.02290375903248787, -0.0026863422244787216, 0.0021082928869873285, 0.054240308701992035, -0.0142064169049263, -0.007030943874269724, -0.03526405990123749, 0.03810836002230644, -0.004612996708601713, 0.0027182037010788918, -0.011097734794020653, -0.023537402972579002, 0.03487249091267586, 0.05462869256734848, -0.019321730360388756, -0.026908298954367638, -0.01658453978598118, 0.0025083862710744143, -0.03246774524450302, -0.016054220497608185, -0.008830503560602665, -0.03959420323371887, 0.007373206317424774, -0.037963803857564926, 0.07159784436225891, -0.00219679344445467, 0.02537887915968895, 0.012129398062825203, 0.004553424194455147, 0.03769805282354355, 0.024075837805867195, 0.004315264988690615, 0.0033782701939344406, -0.06285480409860611, -0.014099979773163795, 0.004383050370961428, 0.0027052736841142178, 0.01662752963602543, -0.05348764359951019, 0.0028822647873312235, -0.007246905937790871, -0.04653638228774071, 0.021565286442637444, -0.003865741891786456, 0.013640002347528934, 0.003833782859146595, 0.029969066381454468, 0.0039705801755189896, 0.0067832511849701405, 0.007197667378932238, 0.012699187733232975, 0.006129066925495863, 0.022498441860079765, 0.008845997974276543, 0.019759846851229668, -0.014578533358871937, 0.05073728784918785, 0.04187528043985367, 0.013677962124347687, 0.015225180424749851, 0.043541211634874344, -0.025908024981617928, 0.028462937101721764, 0.0007961092633195221, 0.012122049927711487, 0.01065689604729414, 0.05221658572554588, 0.007066314108669758, -0.04848184064030647, 0.03348131105303764, -0.013843713328242302, 0.041118670254945755, 0.013156487606465816, -0.009403670206665993, -0.026005402207374573, -0.024207288399338722, 0.01923285610973835, 0.049448296427726746, 0.0055651175789535046, -0.03299817070364952, -0.0014700621832162142, 0.020846586674451828, -0.020584814250469208, -0.029534919187426567, -0.02014152705669403, 0.025627736002206802, -0.004302546847611666, -0.015374862588942051, 0.029391808435320854, 0.00804855301976204, 0.007476717233657837, 0.010057477280497551, 0.04411015287041664, 0.08073627948760986, 0.04494616389274597, -0.02488553524017334, 0.011224862188100815, 0.009030412882566452, -0.0581519789993763, 0.008183937519788742, 0.03699212893843651, -0.052507445216178894, -0.04705522209405899, 0.06118394806981087, 0.02937646023929119, -0.01820729672908783, 0.009966029785573483, 0.025119882076978683, 0.008455730974674225, 0.02731410413980484, -0.07916095107793808, -0.0626436322927475, 0.025601547211408615, -0.04371977970004082, 0.01638745702803135, -0.03724132478237152, -0.002010512864217162, 0.027091655880212784, 0.06714340299367905, 0.004328260198235512, 0.03887695446610451, 0.010603748261928558, 0.04085658863186836, 0.0410928837954998, -0.028116319328546524, -0.027606965973973274, 0.016882766038179398, -0.052535530179739, -0.02692292630672455, -0.0610368475317955, 0.017667541280388832, 0.06806395202875137, -0.007248283829540014, -0.012471873313188553, 0.03642604500055313, 0.01405109278857708, -0.029694505035877228, 0.008246786892414093, 0.014082653447985649, -0.030582336708903313, 0.08026464283466339, -0.01189460325986147, 0.01793457381427288, 0.020184820517897606, 0.0031531911808997393, -0.00892877671867609, 0.023288754746317863, 0.0742826983332634, 0.04262780398130417, 0.010532328858971596, -0.02245875634253025, 0.012727595865726471, -0.026843063533306122, 0.028124121949076653, -0.07586841285228729, -0.005583975464105606, -0.04180438816547394, 0.019264554604887962, -0.012365635484457016, 0.04517754539847374, -0.03033723309636116, -0.007305487059056759, 0.03631545230746269, -0.03227679431438446, -0.00838761031627655, -0.062329329550266266, 0.0024971277453005314, 0.004523568321019411, -0.02721162512898445, 0.03616441786289215, 0.013104477897286415, 0.014564123004674911, 0.020910188555717468, -0.024115340784192085, -0.013747603632509708, 0.036161985248327255, 0.06342394649982452, -0.03540729358792305, 0.01524871215224266, 0.01596515066921711, 0.04897967725992203, 0.009015432558953762, 0.034929536283016205, -0.032347194850444794, -0.08048857748508453, -0.018078003078699112, -0.03839323669672012, 0.011484534479677677, -0.024862831458449364, -0.024830814450979233, 0.013565252535045147, -0.025174666196107864, -0.010350270196795464, 0.026913492009043694, -0.061160266399383545, 0.044854383915662766, 0.04426819458603859, 0.01831314153969288, -0.020279619842767715, 0.02436443604528904, 0.04917674884200096, 0.0007175466744229198, -0.051998626440763474, -0.00826987437903881, 0.022509809583425522, -0.018986962735652924, 0.04194154590368271, 0.05092499032616615, -0.035430289804935455, 0.00112731265835464, 0.04942455515265465, 0.003192247822880745, 0.002551140496507287, 0.04261316731572151, 0.004642006941139698, -0.01402168907225132, 0.023720823228359222, -0.01943955197930336, 0.027819309383630753, -0.0006932368851266801, -0.012591143138706684, 0.015023048035800457, 0.029253477230668068, 0.013227802701294422, 0.01837499439716339, 0.04770946502685547, 0.01166895404458046, 0.005509358365088701, -0.03493083640933037, 0.012961754575371742, 0.0593549944460392, -0.01816440373659134, 0.016658024862408638, 0.051305048167705536, 0.030657809227705002, -0.004946751054376364, 0.01565939001739025, 0.014343039132654667, 0.026923200115561485, -0.017916124314069748, -0.03496753051877022, -0.00459781801328063, 0.01043928973376751, -0.05156634375452995, 0.03245353698730469, -0.04092400148510933, -0.027088431641459465, -0.02101302146911621, -0.010309640318155289, 0.003740915795788169, 0.017042111605405807, 0.03156808391213417, -0.0011365715181455016, -0.0062872180715203285, -0.03247646614909172, 0.0009290952002629638, 0.017621764913201332, 0.0190524160861969, -0.03773247450590134, 0.006552862469106913, -0.058150555938482285, -0.006445598788559437, 0.037365250289440155, -0.015180377289652824, -0.0263227391988039, 0.04975792393088341, -0.01653016172349453, -0.07420312613248825, -0.048577118664979935, -0.0471806526184082, -0.029659375548362732, -0.020393328741192818, -0.05254864692687988, 0.027084998786449432, -0.0006070929230190814, -0.033148542046546936, 0.030633963644504547, -0.04592003673315048, 0.007727712858468294, -0.032031409442424774, -0.010939010418951511, 0.010258259251713753, -0.015285145491361618, 0.016569674015045166, 0.03370082005858421, -0.019509416073560715, -0.01105494424700737, -0.05301976576447487, -0.07988125085830688, 0.010529760271310806, -0.004304495174437761, 0.034812960773706436, 0.0008751671994104981, -0.047885533422231674, 0.08747486770153046, -0.009044771082699299, 0.006947396323084831, 0.006051995791494846, 0.02543186955153942, 0.021685948595404625, -0.02032804861664772, 0.019438521936535835, 0.013807709328830242, 0.00533104594796896, 0.047320302575826645, -0.03976089879870415, 0.012600445188581944, 0.04494200274348259, -0.0007935120956972241, 0.009118406102061272, 0.00575615419074893, -0.011452806182205677, 0.01842190884053707, 0.010923963971436024, 0.02140110358595848, 0.007230246905237436, 0.010202339850366116, 0.026243148371577263, 0.04382016137242317, 0.027510806918144226, -0.058374468237161636, -0.0004007913521490991, -0.024713873863220215, -0.008748780004680157, 0.027401434257626534, 0.017502322793006897, 0.016614113003015518, -0.017349334433674812, -0.02929762192070484, 0.021995728835463524, 0.025643566623330116, -0.016048897057771683, 0.01913493499159813, 0.04140155017375946, 0.05583230033516884, 0.022993752732872963, -0.026057669892907143, -0.0334022119641304, -0.00817354116588831, 0.04152858629822731, -0.00890392903238535, -0.01941651664674282, 0.026489295065402985, 0.021178903058171272, -0.00015977431030478328, -0.02611338533461094, -0.02274101972579956, 0.014799477532505989, -0.07963661104440689, 0.02664291486144066, -0.032509271055459976, 0.04257261008024216, -0.014423699118196964, 0.0019641134422272444, -0.026868795976042747, -0.018604056909680367, 0.010803977958858013, 0.00781270582228899, -0.05548286810517311, 0.010895864106714725, 0.011445412412285805, -0.01956363022327423, 0.001836688257753849, 0.008611812256276608, 0.08298708498477936, -0.03310157358646393, 0.040896784514188766, -0.0035222526639699936, 0.014825581572949886, -0.05108419433236122, -0.01007911842316389, -0.046053290367126465, -0.026774266734719276, 0.0036123073659837246, 0.0377243347465992, -0.008857563138008118, -0.0616266205906868, -0.0004385924548842013, 0.042190175503492355, -0.03000715561211109, 0.016842132434248924, -0.04814155027270317, 0.012724378146231174, 0.012196069583296776, 0.04272966831922531, 0.07782099395990372, 0.03342094272375107, -0.023685995489358902, 0.02367476187646389, 0.025101253762841225, 0.04596244543790817, 0.015056964941322803, 0.027068860828876495, -0.017986176535487175, -0.021844999864697456, -0.04132703319191933, -0.016090089455246925, 0.02219139225780964, 0.00936705619096756, -0.002740353113040328, 0.07802041620016098, 0.00887826457619667, -0.018453888595104218, 0.004606447648257017, 0.04237985983490944, 0.009979577735066414, 0.021520040929317474, -0.010575750842690468, 0.022485556080937386, 0.01279955729842186, 0.011052695102989674, 0.028469417244195938, 0.016949161887168884, 0.00452257227152586, -0.04730737581849098, 0.02865166775882244, 0.01092698983848095, -0.005066474433988333, -0.003792469622567296, 0.027487747371196747, 0.0383572094142437, 0.033082228153944016, -0.052828118205070496, 0.012340832501649857, 0.045657407492399216, 0.04177926480770111, 0.03036990389227867, 0.014460449106991291, -0.06839864701032639, -0.00163909955881536, 0.024827348068356514, 0.028271788731217384, -0.039158593863248825, -0.024321595206856728, -0.014130422845482826, 0.0016417423030361533, 0.03832199051976204, 0.008429923094809055, 0.010234290733933449, -0.01655270718038082, -0.01636100560426712, -0.005206802394241095, 0.002877843799069524, -0.03796128183603287, 0.006646791007369757, -0.005883598234504461, 0.028957249596714973, -0.01529734954237938, -0.02195587567985058, -0.03254037722945213, -0.04147591441869736, 0.01719573885202408, 0.0437028743326664, 0.006942238658666611, -0.03224054351449013, -0.0028950581327080727, 0.07341517508029938, 0.00030987494392320514, -0.033065441995859146, 0.0220342930406332, 0.006675345823168755, -0.040910035371780396, 0.06433270871639252, -0.009088602848351002, -0.057423580437898636, 0.02455030009150505, 0.03148946911096573, -0.004973402712494135, -0.003710877150297165, -0.017475740984082222, 0.04140669107437134, 0.046486277133226395, -0.010863889008760452, 0.07085829973220825, 0.039248958230018616, 0.008905853144824505, -0.020733769983053207, -0.007413641083985567, 0.00540173938497901, -0.028843490406870842, -0.04569642245769501, -0.04294145479798317, -0.02229875512421131, -0.02014237642288208, 0.03233795240521431, -0.014372692443430424, 0.03628621995449066, -0.021085049957036972, -0.041180118918418884, 0.008313207887113094, 0.04620375856757164, -0.005986467469483614, -0.005668828263878822, -0.0030373670160770416, 0.014144952408969402, -0.02609364315867424, -0.025739872828125954, -0.0039021086413413286, -0.011453509330749512, 0.03219076618552208, 0.030625546351075172, -0.00612457562237978, 0.030685126781463623, -0.013285031542181969, -0.019952166825532913, 0.006457910407334566, -0.002290715230628848, 0.027551358565688133, -0.009625143371522427, 0.040686968713998795, -0.03269675374031067, -0.023576905950903893, -0.013898654840886593, 0.021375324577093124, 0.005180651787668467, 0.0231837946921587, -0.05142572149634361, 0.02388116531074047, -0.004007391631603241, -0.003935925662517548, -0.08041157573461533, -0.04511350020766258, 0.0019258069805800915, -0.014780040830373764, -0.03167713060975075, -0.015199167653918266, 0.024820806458592415, -0.046481795608997345, -0.03581899404525757, -0.014042128808796406, 0.06580060720443726, -0.03007632866501808, -0.047230031341314316, -0.010144377127289772, 0.07441651076078415, 0.059552986174821854, -0.021859250962734222, -0.023210633546113968, 0.05425644665956497, -0.05147593095898628, -0.014231833629310131, -0.017177030444145203, 0.0513506717979908, -0.03169655054807663, -0.0008630200754851103, -0.04973316565155983, -0.03703610599040985, 0.020819522440433502, -0.037339139729738235, -0.02460937201976776, 0.01825464703142643, 0.012550759129226208, 0.01729263924062252, -0.020008279010653496, -0.02903212420642376, -0.013138078153133392, 0.05465344712138176, 0.023089459165930748, -0.03008059598505497, -0.01501375436782837, -0.014246615581214428, -0.005306093953549862, 0.0014256038703024387, -0.02174891158938408, 0.018633801490068436, 0.05646372213959694, 0.011427421122789383, -0.008517938666045666, -0.005083153489977121, 0.002780362730845809, 0.072524793446064, 0.027073128148913383, 0.021572081372141838, 0.01830173470079899, 0.040848325937986374, -0.05042415112257004, -0.05353943258523941, -0.04209599271416664, 0.010442136786878109, 0.07281807065010071, -0.08200287818908691, 0.014922242611646652, 0.03475521504878998, -0.02358180284500122, -0.016037823632359505, -0.028481964021921158, 0.0025365909095853567, -0.02766565792262554, -0.003202189691364765, 0.04921837896108627, -0.020758284255862236, -0.021754223853349686, 0.023413177579641342, 0.017247183248400688, -0.006235812325030565, 0.01742575317621231, -0.020411405712366104, 0.027295008301734924, 0.015337685123085976, -0.040411125868558884, -0.05502840131521225, 0.029858089983463287, -0.020740503445267677, -0.01754741184413433, 0.004585163667798042, -0.000788455770816654, 0.04564680531620979, 0.028358157724142075, 0.01412425097078085, -0.06378687173128128, -0.04992321506142616, -0.03556457534432411, -0.008734033443033695, -0.004499603994190693, -0.05018509924411774, 0.03162098675966263, -0.01975441724061966, 0.018205426633358, 0.005042003467679024, 0.043661344796419144, -0.015930935740470886, -0.09438259154558182, -0.0012997841695323586, -0.025698021054267883, -0.029475433751940727, 0.032742034643888474, -0.01338405441492796, -0.015511082485318184, -0.004163457080721855, -0.03777022659778595, 0.047665923833847046, 0.014235844835639, 0.03928305208683014, -0.005327234510332346, 0.0815199464559555, 0.0003719963424373418, 0.009265772067010403, -0.031117144972085953, 0.010876460932195187, 0.10138321667909622, 0.0792020931839943, 0.037292174994945526, -0.06012614443898201, 0.0036517770495265722, -0.013604264706373215, 0.0027858216781169176, -0.0066286781802773476, 0.004228795878589153, 0.0008836495107971132, 0.002177260350435972, 0.045415882021188736, 0.06219256669282913, 0.001935591222718358, -0.049312226474285126, -0.005190716125071049, -0.04571252316236496, -0.011259892955422401, -0.017039896920323372, 0.00897509790956974, 0.019806141033768654, -0.027466097846627235, -0.04808390513062477, -0.007572908885776997, -0.020336244255304337, -0.0029175125528126955, -0.014547150582075119, 0.012765615247189999, -0.01423339731991291, 0.0009641749202273786, -0.04601685702800751, -0.003078585723415017, 0.009630885906517506, 0.04300956055521965, -0.03213769569993019, 0.007908937521278858, 0.015736522153019905, -0.04381931945681572, 0.019772659987211227, 0.03814294934272766, -0.009092113003134727, 0.01854665018618107, 0.056769873946905136, 0.027457822114229202, -0.054305776953697205, -0.00007777146674925461, 0.0025163402315229177, 0.06889283657073975, -0.03300660848617554, -0.014448960311710835, -0.04427539184689522, -0.036492861807346344, 0.04357973113656044, 0.00036051421193405986, -0.02127424255013466, 0.028261099010705948, 0.007245795801281929, -0.040484536439180374, 0.026902802288532257, -0.0133451446890831, 0.036697663366794586, 0.017252936959266663, 0.0411406047642231, 0.02411423809826374, -0.08410815894603729, -0.03285645321011543, -0.005130128003656864, 0.06611240655183792, -0.010158339515328407, -0.008359001018106937, -0.00384892406873405, 0.02271261066198349, -0.010563149116933346, -0.006364533212035894, 0.0353071428835392, -0.007999995723366737, 0.03165042772889137, -0.03683191165328026, -0.006334713660180569, -0.02427026629447937, -0.046115171164274216, 0.020407745614647865, -0.0597301609814167, 0.027536310255527496, -0.05617198348045349, -0.02939852513372898, 0.03136293217539787, 0.022574948146939278, -0.011488440446555614, -0.03677168861031532, 0.009059983305633068, 0.06766466051340103, 0.025676021352410316, -0.04963866248726845, -0.025318536907434464, 0.0006289971061050892, -0.008630553260445595, -0.016233833506703377, -0.020054776221513748, 0.06553066521883011, 0.018091056495904922, 0.0680084079504013, -0.040629807859659195, 0.0500553622841835, -0.017625553533434868, -0.014480859972536564, 0.009076306596398354, -0.06703982502222061, 0.02118345908820629, 0.042164675891399384, 0.04248219355940819, -0.022311178967356682, -0.002841479377821088, -0.00746300769969821, -0.031040426343679428, -0.02197781391441822, -0.012036286294460297, -0.04026195779442787, 0.028504692018032074, -0.02461984008550644, 0.022487984970211983, -0.03959397226572037, -0.024270260706543922, -0.011981170624494553, -0.03017345257103443, 0.013650081120431423, 0.002733161672949791, -0.01900622434914112, 0.01808963157236576, -0.014862265437841415, -0.013656273484230042, 0.013296539895236492, 0.03006311133503914, 0.013075760565698147, -0.005041333846747875, -0.019331561401486397, -0.031226487830281258, 0.03645755723118782, -0.017327018082141876, -0.026045572012662888, 0.026039380580186844, -0.04067610204219818, -0.022219132632017136, 0.03688451275229454, 0.0009544152999296784, 0.04784012585878372, -0.007304950151592493, -0.005809508264064789, -0.06289453059434891, 0.0458451472222805, -0.00788747239857912, 0.012915419414639473, -0.014597979374229908, 0.026111602783203125, -0.01374486181885004, -0.047794703394174576, 0.022397927939891815, -0.007336992770433426, -0.013509245589375496, -0.00536893866956234, 0.04637978971004486, -0.018327223137021065, -0.015021350234746933, 0.024544699117541313, 0.028701037168502808, -0.01899300515651703, 0.008849715813994408, -0.0017191792139783502, 0.01970738172531128, 0.030189726501703262, -0.02156955748796463, 0.0489194393157959, -0.00923890620470047, 0.016682446002960205, -0.07111699879169464, -0.012418192811310291, 0.02778041735291481, 0.05303199216723442, 0.017437364906072617, -0.009260988794267178, 0.007548496127128601, 0.008118191733956337, -0.05874183028936386, -0.013319314457476139, -0.0042443000711500645, -0.02653064951300621, -0.037119973450899124, -0.025712935253977776, -0.03464166447520256, 0.01751846633851528, 0.04093397781252861, 0.0013881833292543888, 0.021439306437969208, 0.015858320519328117, -0.00823803897947073, -0.03525685891509056, -0.013807695358991623, -0.0012686713598668575, 0.013202846050262451, -0.06923887878656387, 0.013350363820791245, -0.019235672429203987, -0.009466324932873249, 0.015533982776105404, 0.011438969522714615, 0.006795800756663084, -0.016024021431803703, 0.00923684611916542, -0.005443568341434002, 0.03472252935171127, -0.007541794795542955, -0.00994838960468769, 0.01669243723154068, -0.019433602690696716, 0.005502790678292513, 0.01347174122929573, -0.032520100474357605, 0.02127963863313198, 0.026912251487374306, -0.011449899524450302, -0.03231402486562729, 0.007479315157979727, 0.0013769044307991862, -0.050231948494911194, -0.0038854777812957764, 0.017194464802742004, 0.02797059156000614, -0.050703492015600204, 0.04499011114239693, -0.051559366285800934, -0.011970611289143562, 0.04697505384683609, 0.014814093708992004, -0.0162437092512846, 0.03875831142067909, -0.012630852870643139, -0.0613618828356266, 0.018790122121572495, -0.006888792850077152, 0.015094340778887272, -0.030217869207262993, -0.06739331781864166, 0.018436379730701447, 0.010222113691270351, -0.03051888383924961, -0.040278516709804535, -0.02767445147037506, 0.041168034076690674, -0.021005170419812202, 0.011431890539824963, -0.010538383387029171, -0.024497583508491516, 0.013694346882402897, -0.05989699438214302, 0.07684990018606186, 0.019674910232424736, -0.014315585605800152, 0.01364404521882534, 0.023710332810878754, -0.020331887528300285, -0.01206895336508751, 0.05350597947835922, -0.002970905974507332, 0.005741579923778772, -0.002429130021482706, 0.053936976939439774, 0.010989690199494362, -0.024666910991072655, 0.08081857115030289, 0.012712888419628143, 0.0006397453835234046, -0.050297364592552185, 0.0075850416906178, 0.030848678201436996, 0.01540360413491726, 0.016422057524323463, 0.014690803363919258, 0.002547177718952298, -0.014484979212284088, -0.0036737716291099787, 0.04338952898979187, 0.013164912350475788, -0.002849442418664694, 0.07454220205545425, -0.0187111534178257, 0.00809995736926794, 0.03959427401423454, -0.01197812519967556, -0.04402952641248703, 0.005958297289907932, -0.006760615389794111, -0.034541066735982895, -0.03326503187417984, 0.009534155018627644, 0.008489275351166725, -0.052873145788908005, 0.013026868924498558, 0.02419811300933361, -0.008836064487695694, -0.023395629599690437, 0.046098742634058, 0.01633218303322792, 0.022855645045638084, -0.007808309514075518, 0.015036935918033123, 0.02825630083680153, -0.0005610408843494952, 0.00005898404560866766, 0.0020981961861252785, 0.03138965740799904, 0.037866294384002686, -0.01846647821366787, 0.014309748075902462, -0.0235629640519619, 0.031175531446933746, -0.027297381311655045, 0.02962154895067215, -0.03672018647193909, -0.03567500039935112, 0.004517646972090006, -0.011743534356355667, 0.015189389698207378, -0.03129754960536957, -0.002775456290692091, 0.05099019408226013, -0.03257586061954498, -0.0018869361374527216, -0.05361397936940193, 0.01258721575140953, -0.008907564915716648, -0.02542058378458023, -0.010580034926533699, 0.01166307833045721, -0.007761857006698847, -0.0025826282799243927, 0.003635613014921546, -0.00702828960493207, 0.0070508262142539024, -0.0020183122251182795, -0.0011469052406027913, -0.018114715814590454, -0.012196382507681847, -0.02795383147895336, -0.0600874125957489, -0.004299642983824015, -0.015592196024954319, 0.032014597207307816, 0.07655518501996994, 0.013501787558197975, -0.03907937929034233, -0.02525291033089161, 0.010199984535574913, 0.07033582031726837, -0.06744075566530228, 0.012628520838916302, 0.019738707691431046, -0.00020712839614134282, -0.03215469792485237, -0.01941756159067154 ]
<p>Am I correct to understand that the order in which variables are specified in a multifactorial ANOVA makes a difference but that the order does not matter when doing a multiple linear regression?</p> <p>So assuming an outcome such as <strong>measured blood loss, y</strong> and two categorical variables</p> <ol> <li><strong>adenoidectomy method, a</strong></li> <li><strong>tonsillectomy method, b</strong></li> </ol> <p>The model <em>y~a+b</em> is different to the model <em>y~b+a</em> (or so my implementation in R seems to indicate).</p> <p>Am I correct to understand that the term here is that ANOVA is a <strong>hierarchical</strong> model since it first attributes as much variance as it can to the first factor before trying to attribute residual variance to the second factor?</p> <p>In the example above the hierarchy makes sense because I always do the adenoidectomy first before doing the tonsillectomy but what would happen if one had two variables with no inherent order?</p>
47,159
[ -0.04657712206244469, -0.02012641541659832, -0.008987381123006344, -0.00038892970769666135, 0.07577278465032578, 0.01409815438091755, 0.00851388368755579, 0.0061180321499705315, 0.050024908035993576, -0.034407153725624084, 0.02943948097527027, -0.007683350704610348, 0.06739427149295807, 0.00526866689324379, 0.037948139011859894, 0.01934046298265457, 0.004625501111149788, 0.009398884139955044, 0.031878769397735596, -0.004473733250051737, -0.04185929521918297, 0.028950076550245285, 0.0013492924626916647, -0.011127159930765629, -0.04448600485920906, 0.06917119771242142, 0.03614117577672005, -0.019432589411735535, 0.0035972464829683304, 0.01592700555920601, -0.031420912593603134, -0.02502244897186756, -0.01907089725136757, 0.032838124781847, 0.013389520347118378, -0.00723638292402029, -0.022747298702597618, -0.021711790934205055, 0.014848303981125355, 0.018655071035027504, -0.013868145644664764, -0.006701740436255932, -0.02357800491154194, 0.036937206983566284, 0.027191368862986565, 0.007626598235219717, -0.03232955187559128, 0.016301488503813744, 0.008480628952383995, -0.03370867669582367, 0.03735758736729622, 0.007736292202025652, 0.035231053829193115, 0.07000111788511276, -0.05393238365650177, -0.012391239404678345, 0.030395716428756714, 0.043505001813173294, -0.002359002362936735, -0.046776656061410904, -0.014536133967339993, -0.02997138723731041, 0.01541224867105484, -0.008709804154932499, -0.03369099274277687, -0.009643590077757835, -0.005146571900695562, -0.015398984774947166, 0.04725402593612671, -0.02163655310869217, 0.028111452236771584, -0.011881625279784203, 0.035285916179418564, -0.03794189915060997, 0.029151706025004387, -0.01723880134522915, 0.022312285378575325, -0.002784966491162777, 0.05277447775006294, 0.025854315608739853, 0.008672061376273632, 0.01813451200723648, 0.0017766996752470732, 0.023402532562613487, -0.007197321392595768, -0.004957993980497122, 0.07166049629449844, -0.0092782499268651, 0.023066341876983643, 0.012612785212695599, -0.029215969145298004, 0.009935262612998486, 0.02244546078145504, 0.03922208026051521, -0.04101158678531647, 0.008137918077409267, -0.012175663374364376, 0.03214681148529053, 0.0068239569664001465, 0.0035675696562975645, -0.005387882702052593, -0.029708102345466614, 0.024394232779741287, 0.05760670825839043, -0.020853262394666672, -0.01772173121571541, -0.03193611651659012, 0.04128265753388405, -0.0280692670494318, -0.03856748715043068, -0.0149126797914505, 0.010967780835926533, -0.02665557898581028, -0.02269812673330307, -0.0034701970871537924, -0.041727203875780106, 0.013114586472511292, -0.003389463061466813, 0.08475971221923828, 0.07095421105623245, 0.054137393832206726, -0.04043904319405556, 0.001495705801062286, 0.003746703499928117, -0.03944919630885124, -0.01364685408771038, 0.009592304937541485, -0.015543981455266476, -0.04892085865139961, 0.05448469519615173, 0.007341492455452681, -0.034350983798503876, 0.009916788898408413, -0.019398638978600502, 0.003877324517816305, 0.008845316246151924, -0.1312675029039383, -0.08004210144281387, 0.03655610606074333, -0.009687118232250214, 0.009371669963002205, -0.03296877443790436, -0.03024226613342762, 0.024656124413013458, 0.06939934194087982, -0.014859533868730068, 0.03566119074821472, 0.017919249832630157, 0.00945289433002472, 0.00839056447148323, -0.02440548501908779, 0.026821047067642212, 0.001524878665804863, -0.035411857068538666, -0.027777357026934624, -0.11604475975036621, 0.0038654536474496126, 0.025387022644281387, 0.011921790428459644, 0.01170499250292778, 0.02938026934862137, -0.013805827125906944, 0.0037786918692290783, 0.008008887059986591, 0.01035214215517044, -0.012725149281322956, 0.04517829790711403, -0.016919594258069992, 0.04847327992320061, 0.0250102411955595, 0.001708869356662035, 0.005689865909516811, -0.006112069357186556, 0.0591009184718132, 0.03816859796643257, 0.019580679014325142, -0.005416609346866608, -0.018236180767416954, 0.015178466215729713, 0.040536992251873016, -0.0422363206744194, -0.026348209008574486, -0.032361842691898346, -0.025934215635061264, 0.00046942036715336144, 0.03172001987695694, -0.015166101977229118, -0.010254844091832638, 0.05850347504019737, -0.0464758537709713, -0.054378677159547806, -0.07304833829402924, 0.008002487942576408, 0.005625492427498102, -0.016646800562739372, 0.028209682554006577, -0.029053090140223503, 0.025822345167398453, 0.0032626294996589422, -0.0016954527236521244, -0.010930623859167099, -0.02535787783563137, 0.022130217403173447, -0.003729512682184577, 0.010080277919769287, 0.048978790640830994, 0.03351496160030365, -0.024425959214568138, 0.01311462465673685, -0.017074132338166237, -0.02944210171699524, 0.014876547269523144, -0.044496819376945496, -0.010147050954401493, -0.02316446788609028, -0.02248470112681389, 0.01570398546755314, -0.009974025189876556, -0.013627591542899609, 0.06559362262487411, -0.07726150006055832, 0.06630245596170425, 0.05818420276045799, 0.01434732973575592, 0.01735689491033554, 0.05105980485677719, 0.0053556086495518684, 0.00848996639251709, -0.028261631727218628, -0.016683191061019897, -0.04009757190942764, -0.025156913325190544, 0.006869380362331867, 0.02272166684269905, -0.02946666069328785, 0.059292297810316086, 0.0037948349490761757, 0.032796889543533325, 0.018232321366667747, 0.03574717044830322, 0.03541731834411621, -0.00908433087170124, -0.02893928810954094, 0.013158837333321571, 0.013534453697502613, 0.032029975205659866, -0.011942097917199135, -0.023539921268820763, 0.05864284187555313, 0.004638465587049723, 0.011273762211203575, 0.061079807579517365, 0.013029702939093113, -0.004125574603676796, -0.023487534373998642, -0.038864217698574066, 0.03920118883252144, -0.028954604640603065, 0.055194590240716934, 0.03262796252965927, 0.02474287711083889, -0.04472094401717186, 0.006354284938424826, 0.004763060249388218, 0.009861540980637074, 0.022433511912822723, -0.04443523660302162, 0.006629759445786476, 0.008612556383013725, -0.007295485120266676, -0.002086666878312826, -0.07521682977676392, -0.006260239519178867, -0.04864263907074928, -0.018867135047912598, 0.006619596853852272, 0.028422396630048752, 0.011084171012043953, -0.0339057594537735, -0.016673514619469643, -0.022812578827142715, -0.04907291382551193, 0.039348967373371124, 0.005306370556354523, -0.04690384864807129, -0.021413806825876236, -0.03570886328816414, 0.03221713379025459, 0.031102633103728294, -0.005983470939099789, -0.03153594583272934, 0.0230153389275074, -0.010331567376852036, -0.04550366848707199, -0.046415891498327255, -0.020092392340302467, 0.0007565075065940619, 0.028992213308811188, -0.0237481240183115, 0.027550434693694115, -0.019320381805300713, -0.0050996714271605015, 0.014681421220302582, -0.0247515682131052, -0.007812703028321266, 0.030222706496715546, 0.011852264404296875, -0.01663409359753132, 0.021715639159083366, 0.01985759288072586, 0.041010838001966476, -0.029827948659658432, -0.04818841814994812, -0.07578863203525543, -0.08087918162345886, 0.041689418256282806, -0.0025214403867721558, 0.037937335669994354, -0.02357977256178856, -0.015471117570996284, 0.0650392696261406, 0.060530997812747955, -0.02327554300427437, -0.046246908605098724, -0.0207495279610157, -0.018972912803292274, -0.028464611619710922, 0.04235624149441719, 0.026549438014626503, -0.0058289337903261185, 0.04648398235440254, -0.030785730108618736, 0.040875423699617386, 0.04949535056948662, 0.013334930874407291, 0.012056182138621807, -0.006804010830819607, 0.04044299200177193, -0.015040135011076927, 0.011180869303643703, 0.00875769928097725, 0.018622249364852905, 0.00008442809485131875, -0.009592095389962196, 0.028019629418849945, 0.025273224338889122, -0.048173654824495316, 0.03925590589642525, -0.050510503351688385, -0.028771061450242996, -0.04250628501176834, -0.0007696411339566112, 0.039345208555459976, -0.0018604000797495246, -0.0026093902997672558, 0.0345829501748085, 0.02414243295788765, -0.009197195991873741, 0.002161250216886401, 0.04299035295844078, 0.050627805292606354, -0.0015675416216254234, 0.004936994519084692, -0.014771386981010437, -0.016885584220290184, 0.059964366257190704, 0.0008129209745675325, 0.010945707559585571, 0.01695060171186924, 0.04060288518667221, -0.009727037511765957, -0.010126466862857342, -0.07517872005701065, 0.030103985220193863, -0.03754877299070358, 0.032845936715602875, -0.013209669850766659, 0.03246698155999184, -0.008123422041535378, 0.04495667666196823, -0.020942553877830505, -0.010000519454479218, -0.011770477518439293, -0.02902187965810299, -0.04390783607959747, 0.013723871670663357, 0.01903420314192772, 0.0028813371900469065, 0.02086355723440647, -0.01749182865023613, 0.02002723142504692, -0.019534163177013397, 0.013123609125614166, -0.01098546665161848, 0.03231462091207504, 0.014542232267558575, 0.009771749377250671, -0.0312817320227623, -0.016231514513492584, 0.010643876157701015, -0.0030762278474867344, 0.004880535416305065, -0.01663120836019516, 0.044712889939546585, 0.004344568122178316, -0.008290422149002552, -0.010727472603321075, -0.023581381887197495, 0.007972970604896545, 0.030695589259266853, 0.03982961177825928, 0.026159724220633507, 0.006004184018820524, -0.04342440888285637, 0.013362472876906395, 0.009409967809915543, 0.02749374322593212, 0.01597105897963047, -0.002095109550282359, -0.007324480917304754, -0.017712688073515892, -0.059364888817071915, -0.012098396196961403, 0.0028074230067431927, 0.01783037930727005, -0.017172913998365402, 0.031509824097156525, 0.03340409696102142, -0.06244552135467529, 0.02281877025961876, 0.027110349386930466, 0.006688252557069063, -0.01043765526264906, -0.016916612163186073, 0.019028030335903168, -0.01099136471748352, -0.01588534750044346, 0.04515104368329048, -0.0017855638870969415, -0.03055960312485695, -0.02037518098950386, 0.027874546125531197, -0.0018801286350935698, 0.01688331551849842, 0.021565694361925125, 0.022248608991503716, 0.030050287023186684, 0.02437773160636425, -0.027952319011092186, -0.019142087548971176, 0.037896476686000824, 0.01710471883416176, 0.04167066141963005, -0.010515647940337658, -0.06356462836265564, -0.01851443573832512, 0.015228718519210815, 0.03201794996857643, -0.04530417174100876, 0.03615734353661537, -0.0006877811974845827, -0.030783144757151604, 0.011390317231416702, -0.004323235712945461, 0.040686432272195816, -0.03085341677069664, 0.012304254807531834, -0.016627170145511627, -0.05910342559218407, -0.060413677245378494, 0.028542686253786087, 0.01250790897756815, 0.00964811909943819, 0.014751303941011429, -0.0003666517441160977, -0.047606442123651505, -0.02668331377208233, 0.019747991114854813, 0.017018208280205727, -0.05667788162827492, -0.011985237710177898, 0.020166488364338875, 0.021787861362099648, -0.003386572701856494, -0.05276937037706375, 0.03319554775953293, 0.007768940646201372, -0.01805723085999489, 0.07142101973295212, -0.0005982803995721042, -0.032786037772893906, 0.01675247773528099, 0.025512775406241417, -0.013642527163028717, 0.021305471658706665, 0.015185239724814892, 0.07526155561208725, 0.013828943483531475, 0.012682393193244934, 0.05316547676920891, 0.020734643563628197, 0.00044166063889861107, -0.022372113540768623, -0.04261640086770058, 0.026059232652187347, -0.009779298678040504, -0.023583274334669113, -0.04663670435547829, -0.026392903178930283, 0.009138548746705055, 0.050934772938489914, 0.03204546123743057, 0.019028566777706146, -0.02245466038584709, -0.01408110186457634, 0.03414873033761978, 0.02365574613213539, 0.003048317739740014, -0.00480624008923769, -0.0031469129025936127, 0.027007203549146652, -0.021074587479233742, -0.023104215040802956, 0.007324984762817621, 0.01087979320436716, 0.005109487567096949, 0.04250809922814369, -0.04298176243901253, 0.01931202970445156, -0.0038531729951500893, -0.03857215866446495, 0.006128419656306505, -0.030416339635849, 0.009682085365056992, -0.01369175873696804, 0.02032407931983471, -0.02704269252717495, -0.06032513454556465, -0.004433901980519295, 0.025965388864278793, -0.01953159272670746, 0.006335041020065546, -0.034759145230054855, 0.023729246109724045, 0.0033592761028558016, 0.0057748365215957165, -0.040192410349845886, -0.034446556121110916, -0.015235946513712406, 0.02657996118068695, -0.005697384476661682, 0.0023239157162606716, -0.009749582037329674, -0.053437136113643646, -0.028084129095077515, -0.015351143665611744, 0.043334223330020905, -0.04445774480700493, 0.005332359112799168, 0.0267623420804739, 0.02138311043381691, 0.09824369102716446, 0.023831434547901154, -0.00897397194057703, -0.010071635246276855, -0.04055260121822357, 0.00016149491420947015, 0.016530770808458328, 0.02110876888036728, -0.009838446043431759, 0.01224694587290287, 0.0026897029019892216, 0.027195962145924568, 0.06518646329641342, 0.009915648028254509, -0.011039890348911285, 0.013491196557879448, -0.026767631992697716, -0.006163957994431257, -0.04843765124678612, 0.00665769400075078, -0.014465173706412315, 0.023650197312235832, -0.00023400707868859172, -0.00025441913749091327, -0.009992537088692188, -0.005675903055816889, 0.013715783134102821, -0.019765863195061684, -0.0076871635392308235, 0.015254971571266651, 0.0776221752166748, -0.031530167907476425, 0.035279855132102966, -0.003437499748542905, -0.04009158909320831, 0.060543399304151535, 0.028985558077692986, 0.01173208374530077, -0.006717273499816656, 0.029887516051530838, -0.006129814311861992, -0.03235125169157982, -0.025926312431693077, 0.035630352795124054, 0.07198132574558258, -0.025251951068639755, 0.031671155244112015, 0.06754124164581299, 0.0006797108799219131, -0.0018958617001771927, -0.061129987239837646, -0.024642065167427063, -0.02491745911538601, 0.025158194825053215, 0.059507619589567184, 0.004480075091123581, 0.010598127730190754, 0.0411565825343132, 0.010144192725419998, 0.022337650880217552, 0.01802971214056015, 0.024826446548104286, -0.013582659885287285, -0.0005874115158803761, 0.0052958265878260136, -0.06311755627393723, 0.024098312482237816, -0.04843081161379814, 0.022239787504076958, -0.0380057655274868, -0.01091077271848917, 0.059770617634058, 0.034906625747680664, 0.004665527027100325, -0.07234835624694824, -0.03914804756641388, -0.04032284766435623, 0.01582913100719452, 0.014232298359274864, -0.0010152386967092752, 0.017619730904698372, -0.027399355545639992, 0.03711247816681862, -0.021797021850943565, 0.014125119894742966, -0.025523532181978226, -0.06265522539615631, -0.045861393213272095, 0.011414372362196445, -0.02034333348274231, 0.028844740241765976, -0.024038121104240417, -0.02072848193347454, -0.009740089997649193, -0.04737621545791626, -0.0035896089393645525, 0.01920551247894764, 0.021144745871424675, 0.023133015260100365, 0.05837418511509895, 0.03207537159323692, -0.008735369890928268, 0.019708899781107903, 0.022059433162212372, 0.11619643121957779, 0.08537766337394714, 0.039154741913080215, -0.0646548792719841, 0.033962432295084, -0.01342295203357935, 0.029570313170552254, 0.010853167623281479, 0.002320358296856284, -0.010256164707243443, -0.005246486980468035, 0.05876132473349571, 0.038847558200359344, 0.03989825397729874, 0.00891150999814272, 0.05269331857562065, -0.08401895314455032, -0.021597804501652718, 0.0017601035069674253, 0.016226064413785934, 0.004613216035068035, -0.0034977244213223457, -0.04570911452174187, -0.019551483914256096, 0.03326283395290375, 0.005876230541616678, -0.011847039684653282, 0.0005078306421637535, -0.007619200274348259, -0.03306887671351433, -0.027349328622221947, 0.030804628506302834, 0.022678757086396217, 0.007743534166365862, -0.04848693311214447, 0.009082836098968983, 0.04273337125778198, -0.06187670677900314, 0.024429896846413612, 0.0008056856459006667, -0.0005060851108282804, -0.009595240466296673, 0.015697401016950607, 0.015848999843001366, -0.07224752753973007, -0.03214940056204796, -0.005335470661520958, 0.02471574954688549, -0.013699796982109547, -0.002834872342646122, -0.05305471271276474, -0.027353961020708084, -0.0021149632520973682, -0.058818839490413666, 0.0017611004877835512, 0.035054463893175125, 0.053849801421165466, -0.008807938545942307, -0.04024778679013252, -0.025852587074041367, -0.007384284865111113, -0.02106364443898201, 0.004808398429304361, 0.01760600320994854, -0.018024403601884842, -0.024652719497680664, -0.06350100040435791, 0.05388829857110977, -0.01828998699784279, 0.012178563512861729, -0.010044049471616745, -0.019452406093478203, -0.008239122107625008, 0.01824398897588253, 0.01906537264585495, -0.010266697965562344, 0.04809626191854477, 0.005178895778954029, -0.02941630221903324, -0.0008540738490410149, -0.05494305118918419, -0.014351876452565193, -0.03321348503232002, 0.005444942973554134, -0.026142098009586334, -0.003355380380526185, 0.025020800530910492, 0.057972222566604614, -0.006669464521110058, -0.025702018290758133, 0.0008346310933120549, 0.047019150108098984, -0.0010607371805235744, -0.04729430004954338, -0.003094986081123352, 0.032612450420856476, -0.0026409742422401905, -0.01577821932733059, -0.026081789284944534, 0.06280782073736191, 0.025883134454488754, 0.047811359167099, -0.02882516011595726, 0.0652468279004097, 0.020804084837436676, 0.0032171516213566065, 0.027333077043294907, -0.051203351467847824, 0.022581638768315315, 0.03331347182393074, 0.020445331931114197, -0.02607085183262825, -0.049884360283613205, -0.03274684399366379, -0.03879471868276596, 0.002998460317030549, -0.03421091288328171, 0.00480593042448163, 0.004916906822472811, -0.009421378374099731, 0.029643043875694275, -0.07025310397148132, -0.005259924102574587, -0.05869453772902489, 0.016646092757582664, 0.020013295114040375, -0.05474526807665825, -0.022336497902870178, 0.022110536694526672, -0.014613132923841476, -0.014650089666247368, 0.012830850668251514, 0.024731449782848358, 0.028547625988721848, 0.003928906749933958, -0.013033714145421982, -0.007754574064165354, 0.051335837692022324, 0.010737789794802666, -0.016894908621907234, -0.007600946351885796, -0.03425208851695061, -0.02038607932627201, 0.012044775299727917, 0.000814208819065243, 0.03095605969429016, 0.016448093578219414, 0.02774365432560444, -0.025303173810243607, 0.05007152259349823, -0.016258856281638145, 0.009186084382236004, 0.0055346121080219746, -0.02544393762946129, 0.010143894702196121, -0.02867632359266281, -0.009221051819622517, 0.03047102876007557, -0.02249336428940296, 0.04940798506140709, 0.038998838514089584, 0.007437555585056543, -0.045940712094306946, 0.019764471799135208, -0.003446851624175906, 0.0577012337744236, -0.014059375040233135, 0.004878893494606018, 0.02454684115946293, 0.054080426692962646, -0.03285934031009674, 0.061285339295864105, -0.025318531319499016, 0.01852523721754551, -0.09218654036521912, -0.028526924550533295, -0.0017872843891382217, 0.04228473827242851, 0.023287076503038406, -0.022268852218985558, -0.004941957071423531, 0.029308436438441277, -0.0525222085416317, -0.01569788157939911, 0.02443794719874859, -0.005606769118458033, -0.009417631663382053, 0.012000132352113724, -0.03568712994456291, 0.020504962652921677, -0.009550093673169613, 0.022440230473876, 0.028249386698007584, 0.02364410273730755, 0.01855541206896305, -0.04090317338705063, -0.01797914132475853, 0.02117077447474003, -0.0004601610417012125, -0.07715754210948944, 0.04005119949579239, 0.013944782316684723, -0.03515278548002243, 0.01483465638011694, -0.023985857143998146, 0.016531281173229218, 0.05006507784128189, 0.036209121346473694, 0.018123401328921318, 0.03038070537149906, -0.015030452981591225, -0.000885489396750927, -0.0230695977807045, 0.012115216813981533, 0.025128455832600594, 0.01763669028878212, -0.021532705053687096, 0.013655613176524639, 0.04920775815844536, -0.0011801416985690594, -0.008837330155074596, -0.0263142678886652, -0.025485681369900703, -0.020294586196541786, 0.01478748768568039, 0.0007275342359207571, -0.02001924440264702, -0.0057860384695231915, -0.007307726889848709, -0.02297126315534115, 0.011415500193834305, 0.06952723860740662, 0.044306252151727676, -0.04086010530591011, -0.017129989340901375, 0.010634167119860649, -0.03252119943499565, 0.02351653389632702, -0.029123054817318916, -0.023340674117207527, -0.04274017736315727, 0.00981824193149805, -0.029196210205554962, -0.05021575838327408, -0.01649663597345352, -0.028469661250710487, -0.030128521844744682, 0.015222493559122086, -0.014994907192885876, -0.0062825907953083515, 0.0029730945825576782, -0.025003526359796524, 0.02729341946542263, -0.10002899169921875, 0.06953661143779755, 0.004698214586824179, -0.03767357021570206, -0.0414293147623539, 0.01103455200791359, -0.01566988229751587, 0.030709510669112206, 0.05629546195268631, 0.03107134811580181, 0.017171639949083328, 0.00923014897853136, 0.04476367309689522, -0.019549669697880745, -0.02929801307618618, 0.032914962619543076, -0.01682800054550171, -0.013014079071581364, -0.024283016100525856, 0.009423124603927135, -0.010851923376321793, 0.03156893327832222, -0.008563321083784103, -0.01840387098491192, 0.01673341542482376, -0.023703651502728462, 0.03764162212610245, 0.005744417198002338, -0.030166760087013245, -0.0568012073636055, 0.04242091625928879, 0.008549991995096207, -0.04004381597042084, 0.021580658853054047, 0.0011986198369413614, -0.06931746006011963, 0.003067433601245284, 0.008190752938389778, -0.0012660182546824217, -0.019326208159327507, 0.008957514539361, 0.005709820427000523, -0.02915356494486332, -0.011369162239134312, -0.007348077837377787, -0.03784537315368652, -0.027966031804680824, 0.04315952584147453, 0.03595691919326782, 0.026799598708748817, 0.0240451842546463, -0.023348281159996986, 0.025271659716963768, -0.035021767020225525, 0.005013948772102594, 0.03554667532444, 0.03046826831996441, 0.027795063331723213, -0.01717175729572773, 0.0393105112016201, -0.024466613307595253, -0.009183505550026894, 0.003241406287997961, 0.056779831647872925, -0.00783766433596611, -0.005586763843894005, -0.008842134848237038, -0.014687009155750275, 0.017376651987433434, -0.027522623538970947, -0.00880513433367014, 0.04259001463651657, -0.02107004076242447, 0.019179729744791985, -0.02118012309074402, 0.016444392502307892, -0.02370554208755493, -0.0294526144862175, -0.009401421993970871, 0.039767470210790634, 0.016451915726065636, -0.005717065185308456, -0.01623505726456642, -0.016101518645882607, 0.015229505486786366, -0.007364585530012846, 0.008687324821949005, -0.012326960451900959, -0.026201434433460236, 0.00978052243590355, -0.051774218678474426, -0.02896857261657715, -0.050564032047986984, 0.04420478641986847, 0.04714525118470192, 0.027234625071287155, -0.024250509217381477, -0.019890883937478065, -0.0011273700511083007, 0.03969179838895798, -0.09129483997821808, -0.020487679168581963, -0.04160759970545769, 0.008305756375193596, 0.004862916190177202, -0.019556891173124313 ]
<p>I have numerous road segments that belong to a city. Each road segment as a weight that is given to it due to its level of 'connectivity' (‘impact’from a small side street to a motorway). So, small neighbourhood road networks won’t have much weight at the regional level. These are calculated at different radii from each segment going from 400 meters at 400 meter intervals to 20,000 m. So each line segment will have a ‘measure’ at each radius (400, 800, 1200m) that indicate its level of impact on the total network. </p> <p>Now here’s my question: </p> <p>I want to be able to 'cluster' these so I can say that these segments 'cluster' around the R400 (400m) radius and therefore are local BUT also have activity around 800m and 1000m so could be local and a little peripheral activity. So below are 6 records just showing the activity at 400, 800 and 1200 meters - in reality it'll go up to 20,000m at 400m intevals.</p> <pre><code> 400m 800m 1200m </code></pre> <p>1 1.2982806 1.3231481 1.3453017 2 1.2048655 1.2961186 1.3369008 3 1.2557751 1.3028713 1.341819 4 1.3692737 1.367762 1.3970656 5 1.3519189 1.3815914 1.3904856 6 1.3940601 1.3942301 1.4031725</p> <p>So the higher the score the greater the 'connectivity' at that level of radius. So 400m radius of the 2nd record start at 1.20 then at 1200m is 1.33 - so it has a higher connectivity at 1200m.</p> <p>Therefore, I think the 'shape' of the 'line' and how it clusters with similar lines is important. But I want the data to dictate this and not me starting to create 'categories' by forcing the data to do things that I want to see - this is my concern.</p> <p>I was thinking using the K Mean measure (But this asks for number of categories...which I think dictates to the data what I want to see) or comparing areas under the curves Or shapes of the curves once of plotted them out – basically grouping the once that look similar, but I know that there are issues where because they could be same areas and shapes but inverted. </p> <p>thanks for your patience, clearly, I am rather lost... would be grateful for any advice! with kindest regards, Atakan</p>
73,401
[ -0.049646832048892975, 0.012004424817860126, 0.004354074597358704, 0.01455302257090807, 0.05762758478522301, 0.027308568358421326, 0.009573237039148808, -0.05020640045404434, 0.046682775020599365, -0.047902658581733704, 0.0342424139380455, 0.03599128499627113, 0.02320837415754795, 0.04576120898127556, -0.018728556111454964, 0.03269248083233833, -0.03056000918149948, 0.030887572094798088, -0.01565040834248066, -0.09105630964040756, -0.029011279344558716, -0.003509847680106759, 0.03968935087323189, 0.00391581654548645, -0.04050205275416374, 0.06661020219326019, 0.010255410335958004, -0.04071798175573349, -0.022963127121329308, 0.006403443869203329, -0.005015084985643625, -0.03231620416045189, 0.013727383688092232, 0.009665515273809433, -0.001508517423644662, 0.01952098123729229, -0.05779307708144188, -0.023654097691178322, -0.02795601636171341, 0.007207375485450029, -0.020887095481157303, -0.009847487322986126, 0.02464548870921135, 0.0371769517660141, -0.02048058807849884, 0.03497592359781265, 0.010733559727668762, 0.006289074197411537, 0.0108818169683218, -0.036638397723436356, 0.0675995871424675, 0.0009747836156748235, 0.023419175297021866, 0.03348275274038315, -0.027941210195422173, -0.019992761313915253, 0.045496683567762375, 0.04038288816809654, -0.002106353174895048, -0.011213211342692375, -0.011327303946018219, -0.03119935467839241, 0.0014535004738718271, -0.05428822338581085, -0.03791584447026253, 0.008452672511339188, -0.014808651059865952, 0.01294537354260683, 0.0766981691122055, 0.018793214112520218, 0.007977691479027271, -0.010474376380443573, 0.015385527163743973, -0.015659276396036148, -0.020280295982956886, 0.0003365384181961417, -0.006186299491673708, -0.00296152220107615, 0.08735249191522598, -0.0025114919990301132, 0.004056558012962341, 0.013927052728831768, -0.014470374211668968, 0.011080502532422543, 0.03345639258623123, -0.01369992084801197, 0.07399313151836395, -0.037058115005493164, -0.002980793360620737, 0.018176838755607605, 0.006949067581444979, -0.04562786966562271, 0.0463397242128849, 0.010563195683062077, 0.004132939036935568, 0.030258281156420708, -0.003244952531531453, -0.015470768325030804, 0.011377669870853424, 0.05017219856381416, -0.01771598868072033, -0.06066541001200676, -0.010106095112860203, 0.0027755447663366795, -0.027260711416602135, 0.01675553061068058, -0.032411497086286545, -0.04278909042477608, -0.00538416625931859, 0.0141694825142622, -0.013436706736683846, -0.05294764041900635, 0.02585129253566265, -0.00006315697828540578, 0.00859382189810276, -0.05928398296236992, 0.0006232979358173907, 0.017599521204829216, 0.015905408188700676, 0.059995222836732864, 0.0270650964230299, -0.03158744052052498, -0.0038909621071070433, -0.04165997356176376, -0.06428604573011398, 0.018460314720869064, 0.0019446213264018297, 0.011278445832431316, 0.02288879081606865, 0.029554447159171104, -0.004697796888649464, -0.002270854776725173, 0.04217924550175667, -0.03202497214078903, 0.03453053906559944, 0.009638582356274128, -0.08286026120185852, -0.014333073049783707, 0.03940217196941376, 0.035555578768253326, 0.04528099298477173, -0.000825081137008965, 0.007710803300142288, 0.02516544982790947, 0.06096275523304939, 0.028908535838127136, 0.038059741258621216, 0.06230640411376953, -0.001069233170710504, 0.0241240244358778, -0.03297222778201103, -0.058207008987665176, -0.054695844650268555, 0.0024373414926230907, -0.010024448856711388, -0.06540892273187637, -0.0011138428235426545, 0.01906626857817173, -0.021001942455768585, -0.0023177489638328552, 0.022634556517004967, 0.02263893000781536, -0.0012505677295848727, 0.010802427306771278, -0.019750988110899925, 0.014479458332061768, 0.062289249151945114, 0.04619797691702843, 0.007902462966740131, 0.006532338447868824, 0.02439168468117714, 0.005718389991670847, 0.020117638632655144, 0.03217069059610367, 0.011878788471221924, 0.006718566175550222, 0.004312717355787754, -0.018043644726276398, 0.010610603727400303, 0.020826024934649467, -0.034065697342157364, -0.07050938904285431, -0.04782230406999588, 0.020013652741909027, 0.02493012323975563, 0.03870343416929245, -0.013070983812212944, -0.03003612719476223, 0.06512445956468582, -0.03634558618068695, -0.03338420018553734, -0.018577713519334793, 0.017018428072333336, -0.01420342456549406, -0.012556564062833786, -0.04245951771736145, -0.028964662924408913, -0.009493573568761349, 0.004538912326097488, -0.00679968623444438, -0.02179832197725773, -0.009267838671803474, 0.05897355452179909, -0.03841762989759445, -0.010242591612040997, 0.05101272091269493, 0.002498642075806856, 0.005785386543720961, 0.03541775047779083, -0.023210329934954643, 0.008670519106090069, 0.004362375475466251, -0.017684604972600937, 0.0013374369591474533, -0.01727285236120224, -0.008357739076018333, -0.013410121202468872, 0.019408149644732475, -0.042593713849782944, 0.0061499932780861855, -0.0685691237449646, 0.08483961224555969, 0.06608092039823532, 0.02028125710785389, 0.017940038815140724, 0.023252302780747414, -0.03439891338348389, 0.026740312576293945, -0.027615496888756752, -0.00559330265969038, -0.06900954991579056, 0.01061622891575098, 0.04306962713599205, -0.0029884111136198044, -0.0476616770029068, -0.03522222489118576, 0.07496357709169388, 0.02849622629582882, 0.0020880610682070255, -0.0072907619178295135, 0.006961206439882517, -0.0008542317664250731, 0.0727187916636467, 0.034984078258275986, 0.037221189588308334, -0.03802002593874931, 0.013380534015595913, 0.00838649645447731, 0.03059762716293335, -0.04258628189563751, -0.002599202562123537, 0.015265324153006077, -0.019417433068156242, 0.00035913760075345635, -0.03276680037379265, -0.001767454668879509, 0.06783100217580795, -0.01841173693537712, 0.0004029492265544832, 0.048083145171403885, 0.010746725834906101, -0.018123876303434372, -0.027356022968888283, -0.022657308727502823, 0.019626501947641373, 0.03360283002257347, -0.03057955764234066, -0.029034461826086044, -0.0003043088654521853, -0.03789624571800232, 0.057537078857421875, 0.002732903230935335, -0.022510087117552757, -0.06630333513021469, 0.015962479636073112, 0.07810879498720169, 0.010486952029168606, -0.02308274805545807, -0.022817015647888184, -0.010642850771546364, -0.017929617315530777, 0.05108959972858429, 0.016982870176434517, 0.021610667929053307, -0.06149852275848389, -0.022930841892957687, 0.02247878909111023, -0.007070903666317463, 0.03300727158784866, 0.0019161957316100597, -0.07914727926254272, 0.024917980656027794, 0.022804593667387962, -0.04098408296704292, -0.015278764069080353, -0.04272208362817764, 0.012683073058724403, -0.021938644349575043, -0.014659980311989784, 0.041788455098867416, 0.013057738542556763, -0.07582585513591766, 0.021752869710326195, -0.028311988338828087, 0.0007493032608181238, -0.046227727085351944, -0.022698920220136642, -0.01556455995887518, 0.017154261469841003, 0.04132230579853058, 0.027875486761331558, -0.022442324087023735, 0.015982724726200104, -0.0568360798060894, 0.0004047269467264414, 0.03379657119512558, -0.03296118602156639, 0.07893585413694382, 0.008098157122731209, 0.004723828751593828, 0.08442893624305725, -0.002649837639182806, -0.05042017623782158, -0.08154652267694473, 0.000219504174310714, -0.01130268257111311, -0.010918236337602139, 0.011187853291630745, 0.029302217066287994, 0.017598412930965424, -0.0378107987344265, 0.016446715220808983, 0.05568433180451393, 0.05122552439570427, -0.016610650345683098, 0.005283998791128397, 0.03164646774530411, -0.019624361768364906, -0.009785005822777748, 0.034679144620895386, 0.09383571147918701, -0.028971800580620766, 0.008952083997428417, -0.01479068398475647, -0.0034815981052815914, 0.013758460991084576, -0.07154504209756851, -0.00018351992184761912, -0.0025307140313088894, 0.042353637516498566, -0.0618421770632267, 0.010292844846844673, 0.03313300386071205, -0.024968000128865242, -0.014803091995418072, 0.017380617558956146, 0.048733171075582504, -0.014813471585512161, -0.016289154067635536, 0.07414177060127258, 0.0464116707444191, 0.00946080032736063, 0.007631861139088869, 0.0003920971357729286, -0.003698596265166998, 0.014185326173901558, -0.030347323045134544, -0.029948638752102852, -0.013022573664784431, 0.032489024102687836, -0.006727317348122597, 0.013796312734484673, -0.034293707460165024, 0.01896260492503643, -0.031304631382226944, 0.01730070635676384, -0.04790463671088219, 0.04379654675722122, 0.026608649641275406, 0.030349310487508774, 0.005408252589404583, -0.058735668659210205, -0.022326165810227394, -0.003025810932740569, -0.02684950642287731, -0.014904559589922428, -0.02831747569143772, -0.037983838468790054, 0.046190109103918076, -0.03983438387513161, -0.013550731353461742, -0.029166430234909058, 0.023274488747119904, 0.01687793806195259, 0.008884374983608723, -0.035271573811769485, -0.01855168305337429, 0.005737259052693844, 0.006170838605612516, -0.02440195344388485, 0.01683966815471649, 0.07570678740739822, 0.027954868972301483, 0.0482269749045372, 0.0033057720866054296, 0.024863511323928833, -0.014065167866647243, -0.03199905529618263, -0.012549382634460926, 0.009126896969974041, 0.012088875286281109, -0.023372700437903404, -0.0077742342837154865, -0.0163206048309803, -0.002460421761497855, 0.031075017526745796, -0.0010241218842566013, 0.02625388465821743, -0.012953503057360649, 0.008715116418898106, -0.010755038820207119, -0.006742903497070074, 0.0012589655816555023, 0.055654995143413544, 0.01994323544204235, -0.006233572959899902, 0.0006192554719746113, -0.01020248793065548, -0.06445623934268951, 0.013344560749828815, 0.04054239019751549, 0.019574936479330063, -0.02068185992538929, -0.050502438098192215, -0.03321579098701477, 0.017500847578048706, -0.010417593643069267, 0.04712346941232681, -0.00976147036999464, 0.005655099172145128, 0.016148434951901436, 0.036029525101184845, -0.006157780531793833, -0.04938442260026932, 0.01633661612868309, 0.008369415998458862, 0.007794459816068411, -0.03881734609603882, -0.04889075085520744, 0.037979017943143845, -0.0032239037100225687, 0.032368507236242294, 0.03487879037857056, -0.016284124925732613, -0.14750656485557556, -0.03687196224927902, 0.025993110612034798, 0.025691546499729156, 0.018339218571782112, -0.04467855021357536, -0.025023359805345535, -0.0103341955691576, 0.047274649143218994, -0.03968363255262375, 0.02761908248066902, -0.02486049383878708, 0.02745099738240242, 0.004881764762103558, -0.02595692314207554, -0.029171722009778023, 0.0328291617333889, 0.0024510440416634083, 0.057588156312704086, -0.015307419933378696, -0.006120397709310055, -0.035964325070381165, 0.018259186297655106, 0.014291479252278805, 0.037428632378578186, -0.0283314511179924, -0.03474204242229462, 0.005270345602184534, 0.00759136863052845, -0.011856522411108017, -0.04690352827310562, 0.036891914904117584, 0.0529383048415184, 0.036897990852594376, 0.07853882759809494, 0.015178018249571323, 0.005492659751325846, 0.025893865153193474, -0.005035774782299995, -0.011363446712493896, 0.01991899684071541, -0.005062447395175695, 0.09856628626585007, 0.02770582027733326, -0.022102106362581253, 0.0558570921421051, 0.0413699634373188, -0.014306127093732357, 0.0447688065469265, -0.02080686390399933, 0.019055411219596863, -0.000340953265549615, -0.03388543054461479, -0.015989547595381737, 0.001604704768396914, -0.0033896327950060368, 0.0022014989517629147, -0.0046948534436523914, 0.005452627316117287, -0.024837888777256012, -0.00922136940062046, 0.00035592252970673144, 0.03584156557917595, -0.024443533271551132, -0.003835313720628619, -0.0228341706097126, 0.033275056630373, 0.04293614625930786, -0.018776429817080498, 0.015895985066890717, -0.02489267662167549, -0.009611289016902447, -0.006494598463177681, -0.01791776530444622, -0.011216605082154274, -0.014941847883164883, 0.0202544704079628, 0.02570921555161476, -0.007705631200224161, 0.01970953308045864, 0.01852344162762165, 0.017203325405716896, 0.028476648032665253, -0.02236616425216198, -0.01727769523859024, -0.0006394314696080983, -0.0015078852884471416, 0.006672865245491266, 0.00032102930708788335, 0.04157974198460579, 0.0011607668129727244, -0.010694875381886959, -0.04985673725605011, -0.0187746100127697, 0.0464499332010746, -0.009124500676989555, -0.00847049243748188, -0.02912871167063713, -0.027178777381777763, 0.013684113509953022, -0.0058386363089084625, -0.011165069416165352, 0.03433533385396004, -0.02334064245223999, 0.00024996549473144114, 0.019070124253630638, 0.01595809869468212, 0.0756617933511734, -0.022683225572109222, 0.01780123822391033, 0.026759125292301178, 0.004757608287036419, -0.024059029296040535, 0.0028109035920351744, -0.006082945037633181, -0.04152088239789009, -0.013014673255383968, -0.052711065858602524, 0.004744863137602806, 0.03661434352397919, -0.027052177116274834, 0.01037658005952835, -0.040578678250312805, 0.013488748110830784, -0.01863108016550541, 0.0011569951893761754, -0.015223031863570213, -0.03390121832489967, -0.021718384698033333, -0.012433372437953949, 0.0437610000371933, -0.04788351058959961, 0.015205464325845242, 0.007027942221611738, -0.01512905117124319, -0.011097571812570095, 0.011065809987485409, 0.025578584522008896, 0.005597797688096762, -0.004513119347393513, -0.022751551121473312, -0.017860546708106995, 0.04282156750559807, -0.008918967097997665, -0.03488156944513321, 0.006082095205783844, -0.0037173994351178408, -0.02794366516172886, 0.011268540285527706, -0.008805348537862301, -0.025187810882925987, 0.055509235709905624, 0.014761916361749172, 0.04755329340696335, 0.01813651993870735, -0.02592391148209572, 0.026237796992063522, -0.03899369016289711, 0.005387034732848406, 0.022490626201033592, 0.013902264647185802, 0.04605836793780327, -0.00970474537461996, -0.0236990787088871, -0.011175756342709064, -0.004605473019182682, -0.006023874972015619, -0.0045317308977246284, 0.012822729535400867, 0.04357149824500084, -0.02602287195622921, -0.03548416867852211, -0.009258363395929337, 0.010059477761387825, -0.01303165778517723, -0.03087485022842884, 0.006941377650946379, 0.0007846661028452218, 0.0415143184363842, 0.03494821488857269, -0.0034404925536364317, -0.039383575320243835, 0.0018547255313023925, -0.05102050304412842, 0.012584968470036983, 0.01049594022333622, -0.059894219040870667, 0.0005698244785889983, 0.025694625452160835, 0.040049780160188675, -0.005225176457315683, 0.008901174180209637, -0.027679547667503357, -0.02218976989388466, -0.012087476439774036, -0.0382629856467247, -0.07906795293092728, 0.026605624705553055, 0.004172046203166246, -0.04285508766770363, 0.08421014249324799, -0.025617945939302444, 0.026112500578165054, 0.01919708028435707, 0.015057988464832306, 0.033732637763023376, 0.03861193731427193, 0.031208230182528496, 0.010516978800296783, -0.006762802600860596, -0.047704067081213, 0.1497146189212799, 0.06755166500806808, 0.019357522949576378, -0.046211451292037964, -0.0038528426084667444, 0.03298157453536987, -0.001814745250158012, -0.05328361317515373, -0.005084960721433163, 0.03934323787689209, -0.030066246166825294, 0.04450805112719536, 0.023920893669128418, 0.03129805624485016, 0.0009366626618430018, 0.06257732957601547, -0.016893792897462845, -0.02494705282151699, 0.018501687794923782, 0.010043363086879253, -0.006954843178391457, -0.0024108365178108215, -0.05560745671391487, 0.04051893576979637, 0.030594289302825928, -0.02170444466173649, -0.04884198680520058, 0.015002665109932423, 0.02092771790921688, 0.00568276597186923, -0.012212562374770641, 0.008544516749680042, 0.034741587936878204, -0.03701818734407425, -0.00040886865463107824, -0.04283380135893822, 0.028059974312782288, -0.02092212624847889, -0.006160077638924122, -0.01629497855901718, -0.029744958505034447, -0.017213501036167145, -0.03450165316462517, 0.026029037311673164, -0.07947678864002228, -0.013761356472969055, -0.05602920427918434, 0.05296734720468521, 0.004310998134315014, 0.013806784525513649, 0.029060998931527138, 0.048835638910532, 0.005924605298787355, -0.047265514731407166, -0.0017542019486427307, -0.018825292587280273, 0.01920556277036667, 0.023919949308037758, -0.02523311972618103, -0.03443647548556328, 0.012741342186927795, 0.01625923626124859, 0.007926082238554955, 0.03620801493525505, 0.004965477157384157, -0.024402529001235962, -0.043000634759664536, 0.05119987577199936, 0.0031970429699867964, 0.018454154953360558, 0.010672162286937237, -0.030201414600014687, -0.01714889146387577, -0.004227861296385527, -0.017194688320159912, -0.012852910906076431, -0.027510447427630424, 0.00960942730307579, 0.0009870773646980524, -0.0025891740806400776, 0.00034052389673888683, -0.021327463909983635, -0.04231560230255127, -0.0367870032787323, -0.020036447793245316, 0.007070673163980246, 0.03121940605342388, 0.043996378779411316, 0.01026199758052826, 0.015725478529930115, -0.03046824038028717, 0.049007564783096313, 0.01074008084833622, -0.01778406649827957, -0.021494928747415543, 0.0004873148864135146, -0.026515796780586243, 0.03964756801724434, 0.016520719975233078, 0.028691107407212257, 0.010942062363028526, -0.030338624492287636, 0.0049006263725459576, 0.04837622866034508, 0.02160954475402832, 0.009430070407688618, 0.0014094647485762835, -0.06499015539884567, 0.03339814767241478, 0.000945793988648802, 0.015132213942706585, -0.05642352253198624, -0.00646943598985672, -0.017281359061598778, -0.04157590493559837, -0.0076113357208669186, -0.01580526866018772, -0.02822183258831501, 0.0022967131808400154, -0.035317182540893555, 0.022923460230231285, -0.02964797616004944, -0.020437346771359444, -0.050954341888427734, -0.003470828291028738, -0.08258551359176636, -0.01703602820634842, -0.000027481612050905824, 0.026895808055996895, 0.02158975787460804, 0.05125860869884491, 0.022162124514579773, 0.004784422926604748, -0.012889554724097252, 0.017477987334132195, 0.002804428106173873, -0.021906863898038864, 0.039017897099256516, -0.00931136216968298, -0.03558780625462532, 0.008988289162516594, -0.0344262421131134, -0.058457501232624054, -0.00521973567083478, -0.026670219376683235, 0.05605972558259964, 0.0028988602571189404, 0.014357286505401134, 0.0014505741419270635, 0.029220741242170334, -0.001961073139682412, -0.027744745835661888, -0.013177668675780296, 0.016740459948778152, 0.04413328319787979, -0.007038952317088842, -0.019940534606575966, -0.01896870881319046, -0.022541586309671402, -0.004454850219190121, 0.03624168783426285, -0.011373871937394142, -0.003296608105301857, 0.0050107636488974094, -0.038769129663705826, 0.01090709213167429, -0.009817481972277164, 0.011660846881568432, 0.0445953868329525, 0.017357153818011284, -0.05134223401546478, -0.0395645909011364, -0.005943456199020147, 0.012803589925169945, -0.030965641140937805, -0.030383089557290077, 0.00016094278544187546, -0.03422984480857849, 0.05771230533719063, -0.05409913510084152, 0.0307740680873394, -0.006284293718636036, -0.05047285556793213, 0.01815340295433998, 0.022704748436808586, 0.04037993773818016, -0.04501279443502426, 0.019705047830939293, -0.026370765641331673, 0.0012612047139555216, 0.01378694549202919, 0.060320042073726654, 0.016176555305719376, 0.0476529598236084, 0.0050075361505150795, -0.022201919928193092, -0.016300974413752556, -0.020349400117993355, 0.0034290996845811605, -0.057431358844041824, 0.020062128081917763, -0.036402393132448196, 0.02790316939353943, 0.01490685623139143, -0.09545912593603134, -0.010691317729651928, 0.01776152104139328, 0.022703073918819427, 0.005945540964603424, 0.03914462774991989, 0.00977420900017023, -0.010557142086327076, -0.0004308764182496816, -0.021567251533269882, -0.010651662014424801, -0.016812948510050774, 0.0048015364445745945, 0.0033680780325084925, 0.04980309680104256, -0.01248975470662117, 0.006231170147657394, 0.02378012053668499, 0.005911641754209995, 0.008312731049954891, -0.021098272874951363, 0.030419666320085526, 0.009011910296976566, -0.03504587337374687, -0.015804383903741837, 0.0009400869021192193, 0.021520737558603287, 0.018943794071674347, 0.007619142532348633, -0.012127324938774109, 0.00010705777094699442, -0.014194285497069359, -0.04469679668545723, -0.00747612863779068, 0.0061327447183430195, -0.02199462056159973, -0.04553886130452156, -0.0119640426710248, 0.005247992463409901, 0.00931771844625473, 0.0007703742012381554, -0.005815400276333094, 0.006778015289455652, 0.01967320218682289, 0.014835283160209656, 0.019947823137044907, 0.03562145680189133, 0.012109518051147461, 0.041987136006355286, -0.1096019521355629, 0.026321832090616226, 0.0281634870916605, 0.012281200848519802, 0.004535365384072065, -0.019863467663526535, -0.028606826439499855, 0.008830884471535683, 0.03798139840364456, 0.01939433068037033, -0.0259943138808012, -0.03628561645746231, 0.04923254996538162, 0.013851268216967583, -0.0196843184530735, 0.025902194902300835, -0.003853717353194952, -0.007982592098414898, -0.019918574020266533, -0.012648630887269974, 0.0066053494811058044, 0.0198883768171072, 0.036647528409957886, 0.017794819548726082, -0.021963929757475853, -0.03046390600502491, -0.015921758487820625, -0.003340670373290777, -0.03085957281291485, -0.023305797949433327, 0.0298592709004879, 0.025787075981497765, -0.013180547393858433, 0.05374835431575775, -0.005938193295150995, -0.01987018808722496, 0.04290817305445671, -0.03259732946753502, -0.009655763395130634, 0.04440316930413246, 0.013201985508203506, 0.045591533184051514, -0.04884481057524681, -0.013763552531599998, 0.0038452271837741137, -0.023868853226304054, 0.013567822985351086, 0.045530155301094055, 0.029873179271817207, 0.04262001812458038, -0.006465318147093058, 0.03206869214773178, -0.02146264724433422, -0.03068355843424797, 0.04364854842424393, 0.01425833348184824, 0.019419126212596893, 0.011308317072689533, -0.005714457016438246, 0.04837946593761444, -0.004698307253420353, 0.011148996651172638, -0.056099966168403625, 0.04471215605735779, 0.015521544963121414, -0.01626097969710827, 0.022394612431526184, 0.006492419168353081, 0.023569727316498756, 0.05379142984747887, -0.004799708724021912, 0.04130705073475838, -0.049044765532016754, 0.0005914201610721648, -0.01995108462870121, -0.04833590239286423, -0.04538557678461075, 0.05987582355737686, 0.005095636937767267, 0.02223878726363182, 0.02777869813144207, 0.02421391010284424, 0.01811457797884941, -0.030725006014108658, -0.007712242659181356, -0.002966566476970911, 0.04265501722693443, -0.006963552441447973, 0.014262727461755276, 0.02475077286362648, 0.0057553984224796295, -0.01503116823732853, -0.007187228184193373, -0.0019161326345056295, 0.037410616874694824, 0.015009574592113495, -0.03204123303294182, -0.005588526837527752, -0.013338379561901093, 0.01843986287713051, -0.05349486321210861, -0.03681790083646774, -0.04296605661511421, -0.014737019315361977, 0.009570013731718063, -0.01622152328491211 ]
<p>I have two bacterial markers, I'll just call them <em>X</em> and <em>Y</em>. <em>X</em> codes for virulence, whereas <em>Y</em> just indicates the bacteria is present. Consequently, <em>X</em> will not show up without <em>Y</em> although not all bacteria have <em>X</em>. Both also have a detection limit, although I only care about the detection limit for <em>X</em> because I want to know the probability distribution for the ratio of <em>X</em> / <em>Y</em> (pathogenic to normal bacteria if present).</p> <p>Because the data are censored and a ratio, I was considering fitting a censored beta distribution. However I realized that the ratio itself is not censored - for example, <em>X</em> could be below detection limit but still some large % of <em>Y</em> if <em>Y</em> is also fairly low. </p> <p>Does anyone have any suggestions for how to address this problem? I am assuming using a ratio distribution won't work because <em>X</em> and <em>Y</em> are obviously not independent. </p>
73,402
[ -0.018843555822968483, 0.009360023774206638, 0.023214317858219147, 0.028882745653390884, 0.017181722447276115, 0.0006917429273016751, 0.0011074249632656574, -0.024866580963134766, 0.0299261212348938, -0.009485604241490364, 0.03584756702184677, 0.06000755354762077, 0.045182034373283386, 0.048188041895627975, 0.02506326697766781, -0.00872398167848587, -0.01551048643887043, -0.005943899974226952, -0.011327826417982578, -0.018551252782344818, 0.015173012390732765, -0.013458087109029293, 0.02376713789999485, -0.005852243397384882, -0.03372211381793022, 0.039403870701789856, 0.04091178998351097, -0.028960276395082474, 0.018668221309781075, 0.04251532256603241, -0.030154012143611908, -0.05784713849425316, 0.007397699169814587, 0.025893189013004303, 0.008288569748401642, -0.03404272720217705, -0.011811614036560059, -0.0314309224486351, -0.038676146417856216, 0.046266213059425354, -0.04012281820178032, 0.016853859648108482, 0.006623308639973402, 0.02410537376999855, -0.002785966731607914, 0.00983518362045288, -0.011937395669519901, -0.030839111655950546, 0.03218289837241173, -0.06870648264884949, 0.07722681760787964, 0.006282938178628683, 0.07182275503873825, 0.02102448046207428, -0.00025388060021214187, 0.004986480809748173, 0.03972427546977997, 0.08432776480913162, -0.0005334337474778295, -0.04363090917468071, -0.009437104687094688, -0.020814377814531326, -0.03163837268948555, -0.004197332542389631, -0.015985984355211258, 0.0013967794366180897, -0.02847178839147091, -0.027705928310751915, 0.018727147951722145, 0.007468062452971935, 0.03421909362077713, 0.03311631456017494, 0.031570859253406525, -0.025875944644212723, 0.017061498016119003, 0.0002604233450256288, -0.00625641830265522, 0.021888958290219307, 0.02831442840397358, -0.0029697201680392027, -0.016444580629467964, -0.0015811530174687505, 0.018679922446608543, 0.032338082790374756, 0.018573015928268433, -0.03603844344615936, 0.04628952220082283, -0.06989263743162155, 0.01953156292438507, 0.02850056067109108, -0.024053944274783134, 0.01243348978459835, 0.061379674822092056, 0.01917596347630024, -0.060007404536008835, 0.03488527238368988, -0.02899773046374321, 0.030960319563746452, -0.022671755403280258, 0.0007034345762804151, -0.01905515044927597, -0.059761032462120056, 0.004774187691509724, 0.062147267162799835, -0.03103570267558098, 0.0027428639587014914, -0.038043856620788574, -0.003060919465497136, 0.008810590952634811, -0.02276945486664772, -0.02173610031604767, 0.020148517563939095, 0.012317720800638199, 0.026493260636925697, 0.01716754212975502, -0.00560791464522481, -0.008256599307060242, -0.04023132100701332, 0.059150584042072296, 0.047928664833307266, 0.041803471744060516, -0.013111390173435211, 0.014303626492619514, 0.011216778308153152, -0.038650065660476685, 0.01202674861997366, -0.003077747765928507, -0.013088100589811802, -0.036930762231349945, 0.056085653603076935, -0.006445381790399551, 0.0120007349178195, 0.05858364328742027, -0.0021673403680324554, 0.020728699862957, -0.0023321262560784817, -0.03329302370548248, -0.049754928797483444, 0.037068501114845276, 0.008279209956526756, 0.000366642780136317, -0.05685051158070564, -0.01999252289533615, 0.08256566524505615, 0.06807927042245865, 0.02589685469865799, 0.02977251634001732, -0.0385764017701149, 0.00697896396741271, 0.019471658393740654, -0.016970785334706306, -0.029038600623607635, -0.00990276224911213, -0.027469925582408905, -0.0002808859571814537, -0.0617053359746933, -0.00453144172206521, 0.009103963151574135, -0.02162868157029152, -0.01233353279531002, 0.023122860118746758, 0.0023017365019768476, 0.00034929916728287935, 0.00032895043841563165, 0.03359087184071541, -0.05668535828590393, 0.07817603647708893, -0.022341378033161163, 0.04049777612090111, 0.03056144341826439, -0.0014146094908937812, 0.01855994202196598, 0.03477189689874649, 0.022968841716647148, 0.04155586659908295, -0.025975365191698074, -0.004162671510130167, 0.00924281682819128, 0.03095899522304535, 0.058050643652677536, 0.002350129187107086, -0.014705324545502663, -0.04828760027885437, 0.01994621939957142, 0.019034668803215027, 0.017963744699954987, -0.011526727117598057, -0.05441596731543541, 0.0672837570309639, -0.04693903774023056, -0.07335660606622696, -0.05419789254665375, -0.046816837042570114, -0.001318891067057848, -0.031053518876433372, 0.030682949349284172, -0.00020730579853989184, -0.005004319362342358, -0.036224279552698135, -0.01505322102457285, -0.034496959298849106, -0.01467505656182766, 0.05159984156489372, -0.05757314711809158, -0.01339311059564352, 0.024567188695073128, 0.029609235003590584, -0.028620578348636627, 0.0567907877266407, -0.04271875321865082, -0.041115012019872665, -0.003201812971383333, -0.04602452367544174, 0.013845168054103851, 0.005848773289471865, -0.009656415320932865, -0.024116002023220062, -0.012018384411931038, -0.029031604528427124, -0.004675223026424646, -0.06833744049072266, 0.0756477639079094, 0.05023513361811638, 0.03152789548039436, -0.034920014441013336, -0.0034009639639407396, 0.030697552487254143, 0.011319918558001518, -0.05063464865088463, -0.02924366667866707, -0.05243596434593201, 0.017004968598484993, 0.015025340020656586, 0.004471848718822002, -0.013943946920335293, 0.04205408692359924, 0.030944600701332092, -0.02973935753107071, -0.0316803976893425, 0.00646214047446847, 0.03799459710717201, 0.036646898835897446, -0.0007897645118646324, 0.02527608349919319, 0.03218766674399376, -0.012963834218680859, 0.016694605350494385, 0.01079542189836502, 0.05688692629337311, -0.031621068716049194, -0.0029042467940598726, 0.018602386116981506, 0.013686035759747028, -0.009544736705720425, 0.006527920253574848, 0.012263459153473377, 0.041132137179374695, -0.0023758693132549524, 0.001329799764789641, 0.04302143305540085, -0.001220978214405477, -0.0005171799566596746, 0.057348351925611496, -0.004472058266401291, 0.015014498494565487, 0.05274643003940582, -0.06982339918613434, 0.0046735187061131, 0.008382037281990051, -0.0328984409570694, 0.010455463081598282, -0.01651025004684925, -0.036328427493572235, -0.004772804211825132, 0.007250748109072447, 0.01541554369032383, 0.01725928485393524, 0.028225425630807877, -0.038477689027786255, -0.05351801961660385, 0.00022614850604441017, -0.03222096711397171, -0.0008119196281768382, 0.0007233969517983496, -0.03949004039168358, 0.004554090090095997, -0.00784975290298462, 0.0028485029470175505, -0.009882184676826, 0.0025257994420826435, -0.023636313155293465, -0.0619313009083271, -0.029712935909628868, -0.03167833760380745, -0.07290196418762207, -0.016039596870541573, 0.007391118910163641, 0.0013249608455225825, 0.0004174846690148115, 0.03943445906043053, 0.02442200668156147, -0.034928757697343826, 0.02571079693734646, -0.019131239503622055, -0.017510006204247475, -0.04915245249867439, 0.01689114421606064, 0.03083481453359127, 0.01541629433631897, -0.002744748955592513, 0.030575182288885117, -0.012308585457503796, -0.015933802351355553, -0.039931442588567734, -0.07399815320968628, 0.020679233595728874, 0.019196199253201485, 0.033545367419719696, 0.05887937173247337, 0.01354670338332653, 0.057063981890678406, 0.041341379284858704, 0.04743191972374916, -0.007851891219615936, 0.004249923396855593, -0.03718479350209236, -0.011267689056694508, -0.012907677330076694, 0.0311521515250206, 0.02542003244161606, 0.027880726382136345, 0.010340088047087193, 0.013589413836598396, 0.03810306638479233, 0.012458235956728458, -0.021325556561350822, 0.024529455229640007, 0.05328715592622757, -0.018825678154826164, 0.03161075338721275, 0.06049900874495506, 0.009765972383320332, -0.00567268393933773, 0.004723753314465284, 0.04233406111598015, 0.016113698482513428, -0.04662764072418213, -0.04415498673915863, -0.029042178764939308, -0.004039732739329338, -0.002485864795744419, -0.005951009690761566, 0.06402359157800674, -0.006010006181895733, -0.0017278178129345179, -0.006847920827567577, 0.05099852383136749, 0.0022004905622452497, -0.005328769329935312, 0.07257676124572754, 0.04469999670982361, 0.005051151849329472, -0.01379846129566431, 0.003070610109716654, -0.02455075830221176, 0.01462930254638195, -0.028357038274407387, -0.023134535178542137, 0.012488454580307007, 0.01377772819250822, -0.0013664498692378402, -0.02633942849934101, -0.028150172904133797, -0.030462143942713737, -0.06213689595460892, 0.007088193204253912, -0.009309888817369938, 0.04782678559422493, 0.03228775039315224, 0.009716975502669811, 0.003789263078942895, -0.03987840563058853, 0.011554894037544727, 0.010124493390321732, -0.05978236719965935, 0.03341563418507576, -0.016550134867429733, 0.004013602156192064, 0.0010703917359933257, -0.01808270439505577, 0.04762018844485283, -0.0364607535302639, 0.0018712672172114253, 0.011217562481760979, 0.04734669625759125, -0.06347183138132095, 0.0066953422501683235, -0.05014661327004433, -0.03126915916800499, -0.009556015022099018, 0.02015257067978382, -0.03722120821475983, 0.008921095170080662, 0.01831471547484398, 0.03649192675948143, -0.021276503801345825, -0.018203526735305786, -0.017450673505663872, 0.018568657338619232, 0.0259097833186388, 0.04431065544486046, 0.009464398957788944, 0.0595790259540081, -0.07097020745277405, -0.029875623062253, 0.01180448941886425, 0.041138313710689545, 0.02725442312657833, -0.007293056696653366, -0.023547694087028503, -0.029627155512571335, -0.040562111884355545, 0.00023125746520236135, 0.032583218067884445, -0.0065994528122246265, -0.005199735052883625, 0.041100483387708664, -0.004620009567588568, -0.06977919489145279, 0.0091328714042902, 0.04194945469498634, 0.0544327013194561, 0.006680157035589218, 0.013257662765681744, -0.018202804028987885, 0.021502269431948662, 0.00342632457613945, -0.024594616144895554, 0.02058102749288082, 0.003472641808912158, -0.0222498569637537, 0.011035369709134102, -0.018912237137556076, 0.0000855247417348437, 0.003783463966101408, 0.003732062177732587, 0.018683116883039474, 0.0043737078085541725, -0.04319196194410324, 0.021457264199852943, 0.0073110805824398994, 0.020343909040093422, 0.039224691689014435, -0.004197119269520044, -0.06653942167758942, -0.0008441769750788808, 0.06481000781059265, 0.03080180287361145, -0.011823245324194431, -0.05619826167821884, -0.030301403254270554, -0.01914294622838497, 0.06965598464012146, -0.0534391775727272, 0.008580829948186874, -0.021541912108659744, -0.04621095955371857, 0.0040589855052530766, -0.04477763921022415, -0.03778788074851036, 0.023022999987006187, -0.00980929471552372, -0.01434717420488596, -0.0019333056407049298, -0.049862708896398544, -0.04141942039132118, -0.0019586074631661177, 0.005419518332928419, 0.058965954929590225, -0.012009616009891033, -0.04903664067387581, 0.03596443682909012, 0.021351847797632217, -0.009895156137645245, -0.067317433655262, 0.013048389926552773, 0.017280617728829384, 0.022763295099139214, 0.055969350039958954, 0.01089804619550705, -0.025268342345952988, 0.05167517438530922, 0.017010418698191643, -0.021103428676724434, 0.029493730515241623, 0.02281424216926098, 0.039131730794906616, 0.04305490106344223, 0.0410921610891819, 0.02712106704711914, 0.03441798314452171, 0.025797391310334206, -0.019363725557923317, -0.04617202654480934, -0.0010064265225082636, -0.06124240159988403, -0.00010483535152161494, -0.052604544907808304, 0.009324525482952595, -0.03445661813020706, 0.013245795853435993, 0.027126286178827286, 0.022746508941054344, -0.01641414687037468, -0.03350592404603958, 0.023492487147450447, -0.0013690468622371554, -0.009268482215702534, 0.000011325213563395664, 0.00842295028269291, 0.02480657584965229, -0.027425624430179596, -0.0023967213928699493, 0.02259436994791031, -0.05317588523030281, -0.03344744071364403, -0.001438454957678914, -0.05644787847995758, 0.018161742016673088, -0.007015099283307791, -0.0012487603817135096, 0.011268985457718372, -0.01508007850497961, 0.03506485000252724, -0.002931273775175214, 0.012258489616215229, 0.005268617533147335, -0.02009604126214981, -0.014066139236092567, 0.02933785878121853, 0.027565045282244682, 0.05143512412905693, -0.033381544053554535, 0.07559458166360855, -0.02844042330980301, 0.016797948628664017, -0.07228436321020126, -0.03697923198342323, 0.0025392298121005297, 0.03380283713340759, -0.023755090311169624, -0.06626124680042267, 0.012634890154004097, -0.0026089875027537346, -0.030569711700081825, -0.011070664040744305, 0.03961202874779701, 0.0035659230779856443, -0.028991248458623886, -0.023771950975060463, 0.04217974841594696, 0.07754118740558624, -0.032039351761341095, 0.004055514466017485, 0.015530805103480816, -0.0015233111334964633, 0.041052933782339096, -0.003926943521946669, 0.022884834557771683, -0.0502624548971653, -0.009152211248874664, -0.020990602672100067, 0.01390629168599844, 0.0500444732606411, -0.025611277669668198, -0.04266003146767616, -0.011746472679078579, 0.04115903377532959, -0.011112160049378872, 0.014494131319224834, 0.014504902064800262, -0.01684211567044258, -0.02151496894657612, -0.005980554036796093, 0.005560676101595163, -0.030738528817892075, 0.003314174944534898, 0.021947456523776054, 0.015184886753559113, -0.018352238461375237, -0.007983502000570297, 0.06567822396755219, -0.029646720737218857, -0.02651376463472843, -0.016226544976234436, -0.005465373396873474, 0.036168020218610764, 0.0027891499921679497, -0.026352401822805405, 0.02392062172293663, 0.02937675639986992, -0.050581999123096466, -0.03396717831492424, -0.0563458614051342, -0.0209066029638052, 0.03368989750742912, -0.02047884650528431, 0.0009399907430633903, 0.026801472529768944, 0.011359469965100288, 0.03238807991147041, -0.018907636404037476, -0.0360165573656559, 0.003006983082741499, -0.012356873601675034, 0.049044977873563766, -0.010984787717461586, -0.01351717859506607, 0.03800711780786514, 0.010669137351214886, 0.019306907430291176, 0.015732917934656143, 0.018073825165629387, 0.037369851022958755, 0.020006034523248672, -0.0022946686949580908, -0.02804376929998398, 0.016744717955589294, -0.06179019808769226, 0.01668902300298214, -0.04841432720422745, -0.027485068887472153, 0.07708501815795898, 0.03943176940083504, -0.045874737203121185, -0.051834236830472946, -0.020616469904780388, -0.05537489429116249, 0.012579629197716713, 0.03585229441523552, 0.01432191114872694, 0.05243249237537384, -0.00152881711255759, 0.06474068015813828, 0.00007551201997557655, 0.010731331072747707, -0.05069144442677498, -0.08385299891233444, -0.00999509822577238, -0.01778903231024742, -0.04421316459774971, 0.025823701173067093, -0.0004743073077406734, -0.012652043253183365, 0.025901302695274353, -0.030952835455536842, 0.0315413661301136, 0.008083993569016457, 0.05719739571213722, -0.018918458372354507, 0.03392914682626724, 0.03749064356088638, 0.020391123369336128, 0.012500724755227566, 0.009475105442106724, 0.12899945676326752, 0.08189210295677185, 0.031543225049972534, -0.05936530977487564, 0.04000984877347946, -0.007123067043721676, 0.020598310977220535, -0.027829477563500404, 0.0020326944068074226, 0.02685404382646084, -0.005828686524182558, 0.05165191739797592, 0.044938672333955765, -0.006675243377685547, -0.007236847188323736, 0.0844181701540947, -0.024110862985253334, -0.010708941146731377, 0.021198706701397896, 0.013203131966292858, -0.02272900938987732, 0.0143878273665905, -0.023840876296162605, 0.012954682111740112, 0.03133341670036316, -0.01780620962381363, -0.03261708840727806, -0.022035444155335426, -0.02443578653037548, 0.016187647357583046, 0.0025471337139606476, -0.015345803461968899, 0.0293236393481493, 0.020049680024385452, 0.0189119353890419, -0.008024445734918118, -0.01804948039352894, -0.012620268389582634, 0.003582531353458762, 0.028813960030674934, 0.0023354121949523687, -0.01323440857231617, 0.007867272943258286, 0.028669193387031555, -0.02999091148376465, -0.009138385765254498, -0.010912054218351841, 0.04217683523893356, 0.01340580265969038, 0.00508232694119215, -0.025880180299282074, -0.01981230080127716, -0.013792116194963455, -0.027313577011227608, -0.02894991636276245, 0.009934705682098866, 0.019464341923594475, -0.005363625939935446, 0.006469240412116051, -0.002348258625715971, 0.057771436870098114, -0.009922764264047146, 0.039069272577762604, 0.058031585067510605, -0.03647922724485397, -0.03234405815601349, 0.011327357031404972, 0.06448037177324295, 0.005975192412734032, 0.002214467618614435, 0.024687690660357475, -0.02476072683930397, -0.0010111035080626607, -0.004239389207214117, 0.008594333194196224, 0.0007196386577561498, 0.005449871066957712, -0.024332497268915176, -0.03470759466290474, -0.001087136915884912, -0.04466843232512474, 0.016624167561531067, -0.01585703343153, -0.02614750899374485, -0.04111144691705704, -0.011363033205270767, 0.020401034504175186, 0.03911153972148895, 0.003381700487807393, 0.023946613073349, -0.004425697959959507, 0.05081992223858833, 0.004590792581439018, -0.02635122649371624, -0.041172269731760025, 0.015325275249779224, -0.02732936292886734, -0.017832282930612564, -0.011516832746565342, 0.03458699211478233, 0.022674966603517532, 0.05889752507209778, 0.03415262699127197, -0.01946684718132019, -0.030711639672517776, -0.0009027985506691039, -0.03692317008972168, -0.08503049612045288, -0.03415543958544731, 0.03703652322292328, 0.03422149270772934, -0.017237495630979538, -0.033359672874212265, -0.04413536563515663, -0.04226820170879364, 0.031004376709461212, -0.006570921279489994, -0.02096017822623253, -0.042308174073696136, -0.030158216133713722, 0.008905346505343914, 0.007514121010899544, -0.0008085797308012843, -0.006673772819340229, -0.04760973900556564, 0.007615693844854832, -0.03686075657606125, -0.021081114187836647, -0.00806792639195919, -0.0013822269393131137, 0.006828213110566139, 0.015027903020381927, 0.03247932717204094, 0.009187053889036179, 0.029613550752401352, 0.014464939013123512, 0.022151317447423935, 0.0011977091198787093, -0.029372328892350197, -0.003440944477915764, 0.01849006488919258, -0.03307587653398514, -0.020422179251909256, 0.011148253455758095, -0.004343741107732058, 0.031742651015520096, 0.015520988963544369, 0.007479073014110327, 0.003241226077079773, 0.022608188912272453, -0.009699941612780094, -0.011455502361059189, -0.019109103828668594, 0.010259409435093403, -0.025562334805727005, 0.01360282115638256, 0.00025314284721389413, 0.0024099438451230526, -0.014145218767225742, 0.0281798355281353, 0.020354140549898148, 0.01805732399225235, -0.001987182768061757, 0.01519761048257351, 0.011184842325747013, 0.04760204255580902, -0.007737047038972378, -0.011038349941372871, 0.029964955523610115, 0.04094899073243141, -0.017486296594142914, 0.00289986003190279, -0.016820736229419708, -0.003510765265673399, -0.09358903020620346, 0.008379291743040085, 0.019254149869084358, -0.03117472119629383, 0.03796960785984993, -0.019261980429291725, 0.003145296825096011, 0.024447569623589516, -0.04934605956077576, -0.023057235404849052, -0.017479579895734787, -0.00046065286733210087, -0.025552276521921158, 0.014605006203055382, -0.03797272965312004, 0.030603766441345215, 0.025243595242500305, 0.025360992178320885, 0.06152215972542763, 0.05711791291832924, -0.026699451729655266, -0.051456861197948456, -0.01424291729927063, 0.014969433657824993, 0.0008789057028479874, -0.07114951312541962, 0.0388539619743824, -0.028819607570767403, 0.00043911783723160625, 0.025913933292031288, 0.003791658440604806, 0.02932550199329853, 0.03966081142425537, 0.023908961564302444, -0.007581401150673628, 0.05029944330453873, 0.044310130178928375, -0.033572178333997726, 0.012568001635372639, 0.009064487181603909, 0.004943655803799629, 0.0028663177508860826, -0.05460173636674881, -0.0001640635309740901, 0.04822676628828049, -0.016720902174711227, 0.003134262515231967, -0.02969597466289997, -0.016160203143954277, -0.01871662028133869, 0.006790570914745331, -0.0016463366337120533, 0.028820985928177834, -0.03625548258423805, 0.03488897159695625, -0.03821799159049988, 0.019706550985574722, 0.060474101454019547, 0.04013144597411156, -0.002260890556499362, -0.0020556917879730463, -0.02610466629266739, -0.058699868619441986, -0.02892914228141308, -0.005648592486977577, -0.007642386481165886, -0.025127992033958435, 0.003408285556361079, -0.048528820276260376, 0.018399136140942574, -0.0033584542106837034, 0.0044503104873001575, -0.047317810356616974, 0.04776033014059067, -0.05366542190313339, 0.020242221653461456, 0.045262519270181656, 0.03333595022559166, 0.0029465609695762396, -0.06280723214149475, 0.039861779659986496, 0.01785466820001602, 0.004794859793037176, -0.03312435373663902, -0.01642034389078617, -0.01823117583990097, -0.004485824145376682, 0.05632675066590309, 0.02949058823287487, 0.015891170129179955, -0.009375507943332195, 0.058449991047382355, -0.020559655502438545, -0.0690995305776596, 0.033612221479415894, -0.016260769218206406, -0.024530066177248955, -0.017988009378314018, 0.016381537541747093, 0.03423348814249039, -0.026418672874569893, 0.020368894562125206, -0.005907575599849224, -0.05167202651500702, -0.008525589480996132, -0.005977089051157236, 0.0064194281585514545, -0.024390699341893196, -0.021229134872555733, 0.04640017822384834, 0.014675011858344078, 0.026840707287192345, 0.011081986129283905, 0.034264665096998215, -0.06062901020050049, 0.028821570798754692, -0.01859503798186779, -0.03144463896751404, 0.03791354224085808, 0.01427362859249115, -0.02505279891192913, -0.05459020286798477, -0.01921498216688633, 0.015060484409332275, -0.052780330181121826, -0.011083049699664116, -0.001370557933114469, -0.013932024128735065, 0.06518539041280746, -0.029804935678839684, 0.031719423830509186, -0.0029457274358719587, 0.030397679656744003, 0.007635647896677256, -0.026234235614538193, -0.014314558357000351, -0.010269727557897568, 0.006416863761842251, 0.008179846219718456, -0.020836936309933662, 0.04708733782172203, -0.02552642673254013, 0.016674188897013664, 0.0017830126453191042, 0.008740575984120369, 0.0006917048594914377, -0.04942219704389572, -0.0009951696265488863, -0.008307545445859432, -0.005140322260558605, 0.05471368506550789, 0.004846222698688507, 0.014487016946077347, -0.032565031200647354, -0.04911557212471962, -0.010804517194628716, 0.0076906136237084866, 0.011233607307076454, 0.026244185864925385, 0.0074897650629282, 0.02492722123861313, -0.006357360631227493, -0.012683798559010029, 0.01257015485316515, -0.03644980490207672, 0.030001692473888397, -0.005763117223978043, 0.012869968079030514, 0.00913076288998127, -0.017590828239917755, 0.010962803848087788, -0.005909076426178217, 0.02567078359425068, 0.01635153964161873, 0.012840664014220238, -0.0059511903673410416, -0.05568989738821983, 0.019145185127854347, 0.036037515848875046, -0.06680819392204285, -0.03191404044628143, -0.038506343960762024, -0.03712444379925728, 0.03176061809062958, -0.060826435685157776 ]
<p>I perform prequential evaluation like this: start with a training set, classify a number of examples, then add the correctly classified examples in the training set and continue to classifying the next number of unseen examples. Is this supposed to increase performance as examples are added to the training set or this doesn't apply to every case? By increasing performance I mean if the average F1, not only accuracy, of the second piece of unseen examples must be higher than that of the first or is it possible for a latter piece to have worse average F1 than a former? And if it has worse, what does this could be possibly mean? Could it mean a problem with training data?</p> <p>This paper <a href="http://www.cs.waikato.ac.nz/~eibe/pubs/Twitter-crc.pdf" rel="nofollow">Sentiment Knowledge Discovery in Twitter Streaming Data</a> describes prequential evaluation. It experiments with Naive Bayes and not SVMs, probably for the reasons mentioned in comments below.</p> <p>Thanks a lot in advance! </p>
73,403
[ -0.025345172733068466, -0.04576481133699417, -0.038312505930662155, 0.011943858116865158, 0.03661970794200897, 0.024747174233198166, -0.009998852387070656, -0.008305716328322887, 0.037749629467725754, -0.015538339503109455, 0.02057817205786705, 0.024125179275870323, 0.04085333272814751, 0.02915075048804283, 0.012972350232303143, -0.00459433626383543, -0.024274621158838272, 0.007906715385615826, -0.0157169196754694, 0.04867061227560043, -0.03585894778370857, 0.057472191751003265, 0.03907839208841324, -0.03366351127624512, 0.010669795796275139, 0.036445681005716324, -0.009322660975158215, -0.011291217990219593, 0.05025220289826393, 0.01834854483604431, -0.0027603290509432554, -0.0024438377004116774, 0.013394174166023731, 0.03284826874732971, 0.011173485778272152, 0.009871965274214745, -0.037126608192920685, -0.01937507651746273, -0.005432415287941694, 0.020669935271143913, -0.012041188776493073, -0.03504747524857521, -0.017711538821458817, 0.07174207270145416, -0.0371544286608696, -0.016373150050640106, -0.02797665260732174, -0.03137321397662163, 0.034701280295848846, -0.021860582754015923, 0.04369300231337547, 0.02591763623058796, 0.006468178238719702, 0.03356942534446716, 0.01823529787361622, -0.014298157766461372, 0.05657627061009407, 0.09487096965312958, 0.010487181134521961, -0.04238755255937576, -0.013132242485880852, -0.05481746047735214, 0.0016174506163224578, 0.000902514555491507, -0.025736985728144646, 0.05149892717599869, 0.019737567752599716, -0.04066672921180725, 0.047950588166713715, 0.005874102469533682, 0.020637759938836098, -0.003808535635471344, 0.03007272630929947, 0.015546557493507862, 0.025636816397309303, -0.014560135081410408, 0.0026947667356580496, 0.04548577964305878, 0.014721163548529148, 0.004469797946512699, 0.01862383261322975, 0.020023997873067856, 0.04044633358716965, 0.059881970286369324, -0.010661295615136623, -0.013164723291993141, 0.06381741166114807, -0.04880741238594055, 0.02773985080420971, 0.026374151930212975, -0.014211254194378853, 0.0008422292303293943, 0.01269271969795227, -0.0038462914526462555, -0.03303446248173714, 0.03274396434426308, -0.030743878334760666, 0.015443643555045128, 0.027262991294264793, -0.042133528739213943, -0.025081312283873558, -0.038781650364398956, 0.006967172957956791, 0.046752676367759705, -0.03166902810335159, -0.026347389444708824, -0.03171567991375923, -0.028080077841877937, -0.02951483614742756, -0.01795249432325363, -0.030761059373617172, -0.01152262557297945, -0.0035200505517423153, -0.007469413802027702, -0.02018095925450325, -0.028580646961927414, -0.025693098083138466, 0.008852547034621239, 0.03668107092380524, 0.03508257120847702, 0.047250568866729736, -0.016387078911066055, 0.05193944647908211, -0.02246304228901863, -0.040288910269737244, -0.009352877736091614, 0.015710562467575073, -0.03733232244849205, -0.030166983604431152, 0.032799821346998215, -0.000429005129262805, -0.00460542319342494, 0.04659454897046089, -0.006112461443990469, 0.020705219358205795, 0.00893200933933258, -0.03743579983711243, -0.030417462810873985, 0.03834240883588791, -0.0002951027709059417, 0.021152731031179428, -0.04777134954929352, -0.006291856057941914, 0.05170781910419464, 0.01700296625494957, 0.03982391580939293, 0.046779926866292953, 0.01893041282892227, 0.02522245980799198, 0.0014640998560935259, -0.0229431614279747, -0.04566315561532974, -0.017548833042383194, 0.005658113397657871, -0.07170094549655914, -0.07384304702281952, 0.036558061838150024, -0.0202218946069479, 0.00777799729257822, -0.00453751627355814, 0.03339316323399544, 0.02317693643271923, 0.028179215267300606, -0.013496226631104946, 0.013423681259155273, -0.0075693256221711636, 0.02769268862903118, 0.026067672297358513, 0.06299906969070435, 0.012630349956452847, 0.0201248936355114, -0.021912099793553352, 0.015018283389508724, 0.019240187481045723, 0.05003100261092186, 0.00733936158940196, -0.0044660139828920364, -0.042348600924015045, 0.04718763381242752, -0.00611841632053256, -0.030061431229114532, -0.0013468193355947733, -0.08517065644264221, 0.02845221385359764, -0.005087351892143488, 0.026823658496141434, 0.004103186074644327, -0.011900273151695728, 0.0352761335670948, -0.05666299909353256, -0.0687965527176857, -0.09107092022895813, -0.011656740680336952, -0.0233798548579216, -0.025718485936522484, 0.04328840598464012, 0.005605712067335844, 0.02711513265967369, -0.04359154775738716, 0.016210410743951797, -0.04197155311703682, -0.0016603830736130476, 0.034257013350725174, -0.03620521351695061, -0.002695848001167178, 0.0523105263710022, 0.0011131775099784136, 0.0027621332556009293, 0.03283284232020378, -0.006710936315357685, -0.08014373481273651, -0.005974425468593836, -0.003693981794640422, 0.02474994771182537, -0.013680174015462399, -0.028154704719781876, 0.032607000321149826, -0.0009728012373670936, -0.052869994193315506, 0.026227472350001335, -0.09515854716300964, 0.06103772297501564, 0.09420715272426605, 0.016856567934155464, 0.0102406470105052, 0.017506130039691925, -0.002033512108027935, 0.008898700587451458, -0.02337232045829296, 0.0006475308327935636, -0.06679800152778625, -0.024437448009848595, 0.057975832372903824, 0.029817037284374237, -0.021619684994220734, 0.0015901668230071664, 0.036832958459854126, 0.024490075185894966, -0.028288090601563454, 0.024050166830420494, 0.0015579273458570242, -0.02874329499900341, 0.03494691848754883, 0.03638390079140663, 0.03561089560389519, 0.012704774737358093, 0.0335586816072464, -0.035253074020147324, 0.012193105183541775, -0.00590567896142602, 0.024924343451857567, 0.03812171891331673, -0.013874455355107784, 0.009318957105278969, -0.028344381600618362, 0.012053089216351509, 0.021103978157043457, -0.026839084923267365, -0.026485750451683998, 0.009867466986179352, -0.0002623136679176241, -0.008156131953001022, -0.00034541377681307495, 0.022575629875063896, 0.031317856162786484, 0.03166837990283966, 0.0003571378474589437, -0.0033333904575556517, 0.05081348866224289, -0.05647784471511841, 0.006833033636212349, -0.005819758865982294, -0.013668203726410866, -0.04373285546898842, 0.04031252861022949, 0.029560942202806473, -0.014068864285945892, 0.02093425765633583, -0.05280976742506027, -0.0027308918070048094, -0.0008124851738102734, 0.015837732702493668, 0.03259074687957764, 0.01426029670983553, -0.057021599262952805, 0.004305036272853613, -0.015840495005249977, -0.028449391946196556, 0.03911199793219566, -0.02668287232518196, -0.04450575262308121, -0.005283990874886513, -0.009866548702120781, -0.020892340689897537, -0.032740067690610886, -0.05558004602789879, -0.0034479619935154915, -0.043569039553403854, -0.007531624287366867, 0.03240788355469704, 0.014713183976709843, -0.04412374272942543, 0.037123531103134155, -0.04241836816072464, -0.013475407846271992, -0.00831656251102686, -0.010549815371632576, 0.019716380164027214, -0.015102067030966282, 0.021495860069990158, 0.03224008157849312, 0.021150309592485428, -0.01764594577252865, -0.09272988140583038, -0.04548421502113342, 0.01488890778273344, -0.020187553018331528, 0.043079495429992676, 0.014420801773667336, -0.013824641704559326, 0.07913823425769806, 0.030808761715888977, -0.05942799150943756, -0.021734369918704033, 0.0016363451723009348, -0.0037687448784708977, -0.01555723324418068, 0.0024864794686436653, 0.01599101722240448, -0.011984927579760551, 0.006700089666992426, 0.002055745106190443, 0.04796460270881653, 0.06322083622217178, 0.014750927686691284, -0.02756679244339466, 0.024388983845710754, 0.008780152536928654, 0.0030994194094091654, 0.03239114582538605, 0.06404592096805573, -0.01820221170783043, 0.005360252223908901, 0.015797479078173637, 0.032083660364151, 0.025070039555430412, -0.011798035353422165, 0.04296315088868141, 0.003973388113081455, 0.016244450584053993, -0.003563317470252514, 0.052518051117658615, -0.01774238795042038, -0.04370402172207832, -0.02581646293401718, -0.005379451904445887, 0.03029841184616089, -0.047159213572740555, 0.032470978796482086, 0.04295240715146065, 0.019722364842891693, 0.0004898534389212728, -0.03164026513695717, -0.039412591606378555, -0.015787608921527863, 0.009121520444750786, -0.027293866500258446, 0.00875174067914486, 0.01918770931661129, 0.061766237020492554, -0.020081384107470512, 0.04031791165471077, -0.039457812905311584, -0.013096638023853302, -0.04080274701118469, -0.01756918989121914, -0.04460568353533745, 0.05497882142663002, -0.002887582639232278, 0.004564484115689993, 0.0013348005013540387, -0.006785182747989893, 0.02090277522802353, 0.017841992899775505, -0.06231963634490967, 0.009943284094333649, 0.01681685261428356, -0.01036887988448143, -0.0213543102145195, -0.052294179797172546, 0.02156541682779789, -0.03689021244645119, -0.00016300761490128934, -0.020522238686680794, 0.02303876169025898, -0.022852648049592972, 0.00739568704739213, -0.004433659370988607, 0.0258718803524971, -0.036821380257606506, 0.005976867862045765, 0.026767849922180176, -0.014198582619428635, 0.044536568224430084, 0.010850956663489342, -0.03839396312832832, -0.010731318034231663, -0.03953273221850395, 0.037362243980169296, -0.004477569833397865, 0.0125405453145504, 0.019386209547519684, 0.032937247306108475, -0.05335026979446411, 0.03489059954881668, -0.011454875580966473, 0.06623152643442154, 0.04637949541211128, -0.039551518857479095, -0.011284119449555874, -0.043452754616737366, -0.04817841947078705, 0.04022751748561859, 0.04191850498318672, 0.00463513657450676, 0.0003490492235869169, 0.00532052805647254, 0.008066143840551376, -0.03654975816607475, -0.009219071827828884, 0.05512053519487381, -0.004254329949617386, -0.008103534579277039, -0.04737469553947449, 0.0038978371303528547, 0.003934995271265507, -0.006443392485380173, 0.0305434949696064, 0.023041637614369392, -0.02279951423406601, -0.018194440752267838, 0.0071546598337590694, -0.04646443948149681, -0.06828393042087555, 0.038188498467206955, 0.007137781474739313, -0.020502952858805656, 0.017558332532644272, -0.024528449401259422, 0.019492296501994133, 0.04776998609304428, 0.042602311819791794, -0.00861668586730957, -0.00012034364772262052, -0.12024276703596115, -0.023541351780295372, 0.0569692999124527, 0.0754946693778038, -0.02473267912864685, -0.015404781326651573, -0.05032994598150253, 0.014041848480701447, 0.004704211838543415, -0.023101143538951874, 0.02372964471578598, -0.007964253425598145, 0.008985822089016438, -0.02759678289294243, -0.038279853761196136, -0.02377990633249283, 0.010488448664546013, -0.04313964396715164, 0.05279761925339699, 0.006229941733181477, -0.0093036238104105, -0.07510539889335632, 0.002700334880501032, -0.02006402611732483, 0.04171670973300934, -0.015919610857963562, -0.003988376818597317, -0.007490441668778658, 0.010641763918101788, -0.03334519639611244, -0.04521610215306282, 0.012721924111247063, -0.02357523888349533, -0.017764165997505188, 0.018394511193037033, -0.04634184017777443, -0.06255294382572174, 0.019317898899316788, 0.02813231199979782, -0.026715949177742004, 0.0008192184614017606, -0.050102755427360535, 0.05878628417849541, 0.027288351207971573, 0.00876695103943348, 0.05924887955188751, 0.0405791737139225, -0.005189517978578806, 0.035321999341249466, 0.019164295867085457, 0.0002420030941721052, -0.035124510526657104, 0.0034452835097908974, -0.02531994879245758, -0.019939642399549484, 0.015204815194010735, 0.021827708929777145, 0.026592576876282692, 0.04980575293302536, -0.009267249144613743, -0.014232439920306206, 0.013292795047163963, -0.003337445668876171, 0.011431851424276829, -0.051540058106184006, -0.020677387714385986, 0.031072409823536873, -0.006305157206952572, 0.03066209703683853, 0.0257379412651062, -0.031437020748853683, 0.03977961838245392, 0.04420088976621628, -0.04257247969508171, 0.025484489277005196, -0.009217717684805393, 0.010212508961558342, 0.013811609707772732, -0.0005263783386908472, 0.030871646478772163, 0.02156320959329605, 0.005713270045816898, 0.014706024900078773, -0.009991464205086231, -0.014903705567121506, -0.0091860955581069, 0.0020390597637742758, 0.023620665073394775, 0.001213130890391767, 0.012766147032380104, 0.0057851774618029594, -0.01570301130414009, -0.054563771933317184, 0.0010837707668542862, 0.04789610952138901, -0.02307347021996975, -0.016046885401010513, -0.013677212409675121, 0.012678263708949089, 0.03914330154657364, -0.014604669995605946, 0.01951506733894348, 0.06753778457641602, -0.037428293377161026, -0.029253965243697166, 0.01639360748231411, 0.0025997720658779144, 0.08035910874605179, -0.018177133053541183, 0.013866011053323746, 0.0121549591422081, -0.02540370635688305, -0.021752087399363518, -0.006883184891194105, 0.01585025154054165, -0.05079055577516556, -0.011319576762616634, -0.03597831726074219, 0.014816522598266602, 0.01594417169690132, -0.0009646166581660509, -0.0020325686782598495, 0.0038723298348486423, -0.013007060624659061, 0.01831139624118805, -0.028477074578404427, 0.00454398849979043, 0.016868136823177338, -0.027023185044527054, -0.03560079634189606, 0.020834458991885185, 0.02233821712434292, -0.034791622310876846, -0.002422206336632371, -0.0006245634867809713, -0.01669505424797535, -0.006863606162369251, 0.046045877039432526, -0.05135027691721916, 0.0327904112637043, 0.023613255470991135, -0.03695262223482132, 0.021694365888834, 0.009654764086008072, -0.012089104391634464, -0.005441487301141024, 0.02520153298974037, -0.03964480012655258, 0.04620976001024246, -0.022960904985666275, -0.007246108725667, 0.06990592926740646, 0.017998741939663887, 0.041143015027046204, 0.03224563226103783, -0.01687457598745823, -0.01669803448021412, -0.029043642804026604, -0.010767705738544464, -0.01191986445337534, -0.019459515810012817, 0.01376525778323412, 0.004145132377743721, 0.0066308192908763885, 0.03346972167491913, -0.01130556408315897, 0.002485366305336356, 0.03612618148326874, 0.0085592120885849, 0.00843201857060194, 0.018319180235266685, -0.04333942383527756, -0.00023716915166005492, 0.01737220771610737, -0.029024317860603333, 0.0077648041769862175, -0.03277698904275894, -0.02694079652428627, 0.02938256226480007, 0.03489724546670914, 0.02880117855966091, -0.05823995918035507, -0.010608410462737083, -0.053812988102436066, 0.006514286622405052, 0.007348103914409876, -0.04216194897890091, 0.02799050696194172, -0.0007431121193803847, 0.04255017265677452, 0.04232419654726982, 0.03903120011091232, 0.007257586345076561, -0.05502162128686905, -0.04996268451213837, -0.01167620625346899, -0.016185032203793526, -0.0014098695246502757, 0.0023803815711289644, -0.04471021518111229, 0.020799588412046432, -0.03314922749996185, 0.06042487546801567, 0.0009789782343432307, 0.03450788930058479, -0.0016453092684969306, 0.033068522810935974, -0.02516426518559456, 0.07346799969673157, 0.031851284205913544, 0.0004147982399445027, 0.12400195002555847, 0.07251036912202835, 0.04378432407975197, -0.036643385887145996, 0.040027275681495667, 0.04694591462612152, -0.0034267380833625793, -0.014836189337074757, 0.012177271768450737, 0.02857965975999832, -0.022913500666618347, -0.0036795358173549175, 0.02115674503147602, -0.015861621126532555, -0.03045143000781536, 0.038426537066698074, -0.030641324818134308, -0.006059024948626757, -0.0005114720552228391, 0.028581375256180763, 0.022502534091472626, 0.01314446423202753, -0.06316310912370682, -0.003185700625181198, 0.0008160372963175178, 0.00047464127419516444, -0.0035792035050690174, -0.0031983840744942427, -0.014998877421021461, -0.002348529174923897, 0.0025813160464167595, 0.03314487263560295, 0.004834064748138189, -0.005866931285709143, 0.00020511574984993786, 0.02035275101661682, 0.010731987655162811, -0.0136577058583498, 0.024579593911767006, 0.06063157320022583, -0.0023513962514698505, -0.013034573756158352, 0.007629154250025749, 0.014032487757503986, -0.04398828372359276, -0.04164012521505356, -0.02668706327676773, 0.0749727189540863, -0.007664013188332319, -0.02923138439655304, -0.018943624570965767, -0.016166238114237785, 0.0003949952661059797, -0.060736265033483505, -0.006316160783171654, 0.04042792692780495, 0.02940819412469864, 0.004160608164966106, -0.030296513810753822, -0.011535979807376862, 0.024042563512921333, -0.027398258447647095, 0.012899854220449924, 0.02074681967496872, -0.04061862826347351, -0.05937845632433891, -0.015189423225820065, 0.008481992408633232, 0.017871851101517677, 0.008293493650853634, -0.011034044437110424, -0.02428685501217842, -0.02722354047000408, -0.026496319100260735, -0.02728467807173729, 0.011606727726757526, 0.025218505412340164, -0.02855224907398224, -0.03675181046128273, -0.04656987264752388, -0.011651087552309036, -0.008641754277050495, -0.0365108922123909, -0.012481920421123505, -0.0229585412889719, 0.004202424082905054, -0.020833976566791534, 0.008752093650400639, 0.008745686151087284, 0.035874247550964355, 0.026075327768921852, 0.06301983445882797, 0.01408173143863678, -0.03762104734778404, -0.01897677592933178, -0.0142184067517519, -0.06352080404758453, 0.013786641880869865, 0.015086700208485126, 0.048364024609327316, 0.011403725482523441, -0.007325255777686834, 0.016472788527607918, 0.00972704030573368, 0.009839971549808979, 0.03859592229127884, 0.004719241987913847, -0.0235204566270113, -0.00013064972881693393, 0.00753839872777462, 0.0025333554949611425, -0.0237390398979187, -0.0257007647305727, -0.005816358141601086, -0.0032931589521467686, 0.025953108444809914, -0.015840794891119003, -0.028957301750779152, 0.012496483512222767, 0.002896412741392851, 0.0735308825969696, -0.004351903218775988, 0.0007918470073491335, -0.018860314041376114, -0.002602790482342243, -0.056396786123514175, -0.00943914707750082, -0.016629470512270927, 0.05179698392748833, -0.012295728549361229, -0.0000736811343813315, 0.0019864283967763186, -0.011622809804975986, -0.014740299433469772, -0.07117850333452225, 0.0668870210647583, -0.02507149800658226, 0.020461242645978928, -0.013877826742827892, -0.03073888272047043, 0.03745365887880325, -0.05198797583580017, -0.019956806674599648, 0.01432187668979168, 0.018760474398732185, 0.04515228047966957, -0.02834445610642433, -0.021815748885273933, -0.03168785199522972, 0.055152568966150284, -0.010830356739461422, -0.02357172593474388, 0.01720934361219406, 0.015334072522819042, 0.011035204865038395, 0.018787728622555733, 0.01323897298425436, 0.004990140907466412, 0.029350221157073975, -0.005976191721856594, 0.005725049413740635, 0.02171606756746769, -0.0314391627907753, -0.0033478010445833206, -0.030227461829781532, 0.04058730602264404, 0.01304951123893261, 0.017695283517241478, 0.01893497258424759, 0.02083403430879116, -0.044607020914554596, 0.044075723737478256, -0.029974985867738724, 0.03049866482615471, -0.06887056678533554, -0.009514267556369305, 0.0238764937967062, -0.004065036773681641, 0.03308601677417755, -0.052476584911346436, 0.01739315129816532, 0.018898090347647667, -0.024247681722044945, 0.04760435223579407, 0.02256086841225624, 0.04433218762278557, -0.035779356956481934, -0.02088797837495804, -0.057645611464977264, -0.010133501142263412, 0.0416145846247673, 0.05623935908079147, 0.04816894233226776, 0.027827883139252663, -0.007959479466080666, -0.009318098425865173, -0.05846128612756729, 0.04888450726866722, -0.005561771336942911, -0.015772851184010506, 0.07334364950656891, -0.0422327034175396, -0.009656467474997044, -0.008302059955894947, 0.027443690225481987, -0.0013968739658594131, 0.040200572460889816, 0.04010414332151413, 0.03301037847995758, 0.026858966797590256, 0.019028523936867714, -0.0020028750877827406, 0.029444213956594467, 0.04497600346803665, 0.014960100874304771, -0.018006810918450356, -0.002230365527793765, 0.02303691767156124, 0.012609141878783703, -0.012990833260118961, -0.017641587182879448, -0.01628692075610161, -0.024103207513689995, -0.03038354218006134, -0.009277205914258957, -0.016422443091869354, 0.032544273883104324, -0.0369751863181591, 0.005541257094591856, -0.0334036611020565, 0.02253243885934353, 0.01743055135011673, 0.027104729786515236, -0.011023085564374924, 0.012377509847283363, -0.020229868590831757, -0.01927938684821129, 0.01651776395738125, -0.012003149837255478, -0.004796565975993872, -0.0688706785440445, -0.00920009147375822, 0.006752440705895424, -0.009312826208770275, -0.051707152277231216, -0.00880576204508543, -0.03481093794107437, 0.05750409513711929, -0.03275272995233536, 0.05101478844881058, 0.02823079377412796, 0.005581825505942106, -0.03067808225750923, -0.10938730090856552, 0.08077391237020493, 0.017080722376704216, -0.029308360069990158, -0.02153978869318962, 0.006216792389750481, -0.03112618438899517, 0.018533483147621155, 0.03771192580461502, 0.009120171889662743, -0.013123121112585068, -0.019302595406770706, -0.00016748762573115528, -0.0005989982164464891, -0.03944515809416771, 0.03499286249279976, -0.027689790353178978, -0.03596461936831474, 0.008291048929095268, -0.03788338229060173, 0.007583240512758493, 0.016195036470890045, 0.022342396900057793, -0.024941015988588333, 0.014261651784181595, -0.0005098232650198042, -0.012484285049140453, 0.0252495389431715, 0.0451979786157608, 0.032488930970430374, 0.0452517569065094, 0.014359396882355213, 0.010535451583564281, 0.006116598378866911, -0.0011956270318478346, -0.07361633330583572, 0.033120278269052505, -0.021314281970262527, 0.006712198257446289, -0.02885565720498562, -0.010650331154465675, -0.028206028044223785, -0.03693896532058716, -0.038834135979413986, 0.04832179471850395, -0.039680927991867065, 0.03786308318376541, 0.036732375621795654, -0.003821178339421749, 0.04091595858335495, 0.009524994529783726, 0.04600295051932335, -0.030482102185487747, -0.02143125608563423, 0.011470221914350986, 0.021508635953068733, 0.03205687925219536, 0.0006553403218276799, 0.0339713990688324, 0.04102928563952446, -0.04433233290910721, 0.02173113077878952, -0.0009349720785394311, 0.04670952260494232, -0.011013206094503403, 0.0015899322461336851, -0.011410855688154697, -0.005077909678220749, -0.03215578570961952, 0.0026618402916938066, 0.005666709970682859, 0.03977740928530693, -0.039929334074258804, 0.01848626881837845, -0.05020145699381828, -0.02747221849858761, -0.003861676901578903, 0.011835119687020779, 0.003403843380510807, 0.05399112030863762, 0.0013763101305812597, -0.004523657727986574, -0.007765498943626881, -0.002752867992967367, 0.03587399050593376, -0.009708021767437458, 0.011543532833456993, -0.011860647238790989, 0.009932780638337135, 0.01917022094130516, -0.0539984256029129, 0.020658958703279495, -0.03323426842689514, -0.006575185805559158, 0.011941191740334034, 0.0028016793075948954, -0.03635569289326668, -0.06224049627780914, -0.035191264003515244, 0.020208584144711494, -0.05345139652490616, 0.039853598922491074, -0.071686752140522, 0.03304540738463402, -0.02948400191962719, -0.03945177420973778 ]
<p>I have a set of observations. When I do an OLS I get a $\beta$. After I remove some values I also get a $\beta$. Now I want to test if the properties of two betas are the same? Please give me a hint how to do that?</p>
35,760
[ -0.06047182157635689, 0.0602828674018383, -0.016052784398198128, 0.038883570581674576, 0.011622927151620388, 0.0533028207719326, -0.02004448138177395, 0.002775980159640312, 0.048695676028728485, -0.02407248504459858, 0.04059587046504021, 0.023979760706424713, 0.061404984444379807, 0.007773682475090027, 0.012916428968310356, -0.032585509121418, -0.04426492750644684, 0.0148998461663723, -0.03753821179270744, 0.019624443724751472, 0.016439609229564667, -0.0037036859430372715, 0.03379475697875023, -0.00009055739792529494, -0.012336364947259426, 0.04902903363108635, 0.010627208277583122, -0.03734670579433441, 0.014430907554924488, 0.05858867987990379, -0.02274901047348976, -0.04911143705248833, 0.00362714403308928, 0.014846812933683395, 0.0030242453794926405, -0.012531505897641182, -0.0374581404030323, -0.03856872394680977, -0.010256580077111721, 0.047383978962898254, -0.023354528471827507, -0.030048031359910965, -0.02793411910533905, 0.0492297001183033, 0.0008499851683154702, -0.026543136686086655, 0.017823070287704468, -0.015396542847156525, 0.013083132915198803, -0.03218333050608635, 0.0747249573469162, -0.021075010299682617, 0.05626353248953819, 0.05909053236246109, -0.01157789584249258, -0.008676961995661259, 0.029549382627010345, 0.07036547362804413, -0.0023891201708465815, -0.029050346463918686, -0.02751307003200054, -0.025639614090323448, 0.03246724605560303, -0.0033905697055161, -0.05607140064239502, 0.02838263288140297, 0.0009057914139702916, 0.007161356043070555, 0.026729615405201912, -0.013384382240474224, 0.01034630462527275, 0.02267865464091301, 0.027238426730036736, 0.012768407352268696, -0.015535170212388039, -0.04429898038506508, 0.02475225366652012, 0.030534744262695312, 0.06578277796506882, 0.02608390524983406, 0.007026544772088528, 0.025211112573742867, 0.02321513742208481, 0.02867150492966175, 0.0047543724067509174, -0.03260430321097374, 0.046634335070848465, -0.03423408418893814, 0.02002720721065998, 0.027142928913235664, 0.007308015134185553, -0.0185028538107872, 0.05286863073706627, -0.0007902535726316273, -0.03267112374305725, 0.026976220309734344, -0.017381461337208748, 0.03928174078464508, -0.0158325657248497, 0.016338607296347618, 0.022011293098330498, -0.058076679706573486, 0.006777873728424311, 0.03006752021610737, -0.010277328081429005, -0.04700297862291336, -0.011998772621154785, 0.015274524688720703, 0.0054551647044718266, -0.04103943333029747, 0.007462115492671728, 0.03713404759764671, 0.008662758395075798, 0.008626447059214115, 0.04471002146601677, -0.009881542064249516, -0.03009432554244995, -0.02366618812084198, 0.05077036842703819, 0.04219963029026985, 0.030084112659096718, -0.008386529982089996, -0.009513764642179012, -0.004701833240687847, -0.013356243260204792, 0.023493334650993347, 0.03399232402443886, -0.008409435860812664, -0.04948090761899948, 0.03572362661361694, 0.0062787337228655815, -0.054529327899217606, 0.03379755839705467, -0.012981712818145752, 0.03513418138027191, 0.02173009142279625, -0.07645613700151443, -0.04761531949043274, 0.011749912984669209, -0.022052841261029243, 0.0011454509804025292, -0.03719821199774742, -0.012650581076741219, 0.024261556565761566, 0.05208222195506096, 0.02472745068371296, 0.02574063092470169, 0.021278010681271553, 0.016954751685261726, 0.032999854534864426, 0.0011292612180113792, -0.0489036962389946, -0.02765222080051899, -0.006511439569294453, -0.021847762167453766, -0.04114656150341034, -0.010998141951858997, 0.00467834435403347, -0.024242570623755455, -0.029194870963692665, 0.0271165668964386, 0.005612506996840239, -0.018823180347681046, -0.002533384133130312, 0.0512135848402977, -0.03972415253520012, 0.06473243236541748, -0.030268065631389618, -0.0032845409587025642, 0.027379322797060013, -0.02840186469256878, 0.024408390745520592, -0.005890661850571632, 0.06057734414935112, 0.05557854846119881, 0.000945859239436686, -0.036323707550764084, -0.03401967138051987, 0.029606541618704796, 0.023848427459597588, -0.036121122539043427, -0.022924326360225677, -0.03974580392241478, 0.008549513295292854, -0.009092443622648716, 0.03961494565010071, 0.0112240519374609, -0.011559456586837769, 0.061665184795856476, -0.07213997840881348, -0.032352957874536514, -0.08839303255081177, 0.014896261505782604, 0.001469388953410089, -0.021890897303819656, 0.037795938551425934, 0.03307114914059639, -0.0094712283462286, -0.017690831795334816, -0.015729624778032303, -0.01474115252494812, 0.0015337328659370542, 0.051816675812006, -0.05263320356607437, 0.02789973095059395, 0.04171208292245865, 0.07186269015073776, -0.033703409135341644, 0.056108541786670685, -0.03187715634703636, -0.0010015368461608887, 0.03575703129172325, -0.02415868081152439, -0.021625785157084465, -0.019390350207686424, 0.0047041974030435085, 0.010765837505459785, -0.003326502861455083, -0.01037990115582943, 0.02932361513376236, -0.05638771504163742, 0.04782881215214729, 0.0910431519150734, 0.011585235595703125, 0.03557095676660538, -0.015177782624959946, 0.017163235694169998, 0.039726048707962036, -0.034340061247348785, -0.013768710196018219, -0.0337943509221077, 0.001409095828421414, 0.02227277122437954, 0.03190303593873978, -0.03129034489393234, 0.028076838701963425, 0.039703547954559326, 0.011792981997132301, 0.004113401751965284, 0.023317325860261917, 0.00816145446151495, -0.0014226214261725545, -0.015268014743924141, -0.014310562051832676, 0.0366835743188858, 0.022444577887654305, 0.0019172878237441182, 0.017107732594013214, 0.043154504150152206, -0.04593780264258385, 0.03809095546603203, 0.03155701979994774, 0.006537468172609806, -0.014281760901212692, -0.02745921164751053, -0.03575796261429787, 0.04139363393187523, -0.0008902233676053584, 0.00005369905920815654, 0.03648841008543968, 0.0355168953537941, -0.012354619801044464, -0.0010762392776086926, 0.00475331349298358, 0.035452716052532196, 0.008799745701253414, -0.04913894832134247, -0.023875584825873375, 0.01961664669215679, -0.04362809658050537, 0.030485451221466064, 0.021139800548553467, -0.009956257417798042, -0.023410828784108162, 0.03691679239273071, 0.030276281759142876, -0.003096257569268346, 0.009220199659466743, -0.02042585425078869, -0.041585881263017654, -0.0025827535428106785, -0.040076278150081635, 0.01709289662539959, 0.008213086985051632, -0.04853319376707077, 0.015103072859346867, -0.04187401384115219, 0.0008721263729967177, 0.0011334903538227081, 0.008357113227248192, -0.004105236381292343, 0.0341658741235733, 0.00398834515362978, -0.05533166602253914, -0.04349847882986069, -0.04758516699075699, 0.013460930436849594, -0.011085590347647667, -0.02230948954820633, 0.04216432571411133, 0.013395563699305058, -0.041100431233644485, 0.010524284094572067, -0.017072614282369614, -0.0075286864303052425, -0.01436504814773798, -0.03322407230734825, 0.019836459308862686, -0.00732162082567811, 0.03041497990489006, 0.03782769665122032, -0.032166361808776855, -0.0027326801791787148, -0.08691783994436264, -0.07248217612504959, -0.0037624784745275974, 0.024967877194285393, 0.023391766473650932, 0.0038611190393567085, -0.04112131521105766, 0.07229090481996536, 0.04159240052103996, -0.02379707805812359, -0.0320744588971138, 0.036392465233802795, -0.043338045477867126, -0.0520985871553421, 0.0064939954318106174, -0.02237866073846817, 0.018751313909888268, 0.037589870393276215, 0.03909020498394966, 0.026734190061688423, 0.0548713356256485, 0.017845815047621727, 0.007860515266656876, 0.00026287793298251927, 0.029078608378767967, 0.008032592013478279, 0.04032132029533386, 0.006984014995396137, -0.014550636522471905, 0.043329495936632156, 0.033241771161556244, 0.03011154569685459, 0.01845168136060238, -0.03550007566809654, 0.039387136697769165, 0.006601749919354916, 0.021136315539479256, 0.0008906680159270763, 0.04841102287173271, 0.03318021446466446, -0.006243146024644375, -0.0034417076967656612, 0.021449994295835495, 0.02416123077273369, -0.03439587727189064, 0.0027340909000486135, 0.06694706529378891, -0.0030399435199797153, -0.007282968144863844, -0.021492978557944298, -0.0338469035923481, -0.033898916095495224, 0.016353175044059753, -0.0353618785738945, -0.03563086315989494, 0.05321924760937691, 0.016575412824749947, 0.03552306815981865, 0.00216679647564888, -0.06937260925769806, -0.012735904194414616, -0.06845694780349731, -0.0014573067892342806, 0.00018209124391432852, 0.03009304404258728, 0.007882900536060333, 0.029172176495194435, 0.03461435064673424, -0.0018674173625186086, 0.021192656829953194, -0.00756643433123827, -0.050481364130973816, 0.03640317544341087, -0.00999890360981226, -0.01818018965423107, 0.017904961481690407, -0.006347386632114649, 0.038544800132513046, -0.030808713287115097, 0.014995218254625797, -0.007137687876820564, 0.0036031256895512342, -0.06372688710689545, 0.0038166367448866367, -0.054707109928131104, -0.025743000209331512, -0.00047617199015803635, 0.048062995076179504, -0.02126946486532688, -0.04384193941950798, -0.01323440670967102, 0.03245628997683525, -0.007251086179167032, 0.022208699956536293, -0.050170451402664185, 0.021764598786830902, 0.0006129938992671669, 0.03309199586510658, 0.0218011774122715, 0.02240045927464962, -0.018401088193058968, 0.03732747212052345, 0.00949864275753498, 0.04876847192645073, 0.06575509160757065, 0.01608867757022381, -0.054795753210783005, -0.021087946370244026, 0.006294943392276764, -0.018746985122561455, 0.05375263839960098, 0.01948563940823078, -0.018423590809106827, 0.03308076784014702, 0.048715703189373016, -0.048964984714984894, 0.03192995488643646, 0.07770932465791702, 0.03476019203662872, -0.010389966890215874, -0.004342623054981232, -0.007207099348306656, -0.005967350676655769, -0.04022699221968651, -0.004364995751529932, -0.0054633538238704205, -0.02023938111960888, -0.015309213660657406, 0.030305294319987297, -0.024905027821660042, -0.011987808160483837, 0.010190838947892189, 0.012864958494901657, 0.0419195219874382, -0.0038932436145842075, -0.06288903951644897, 0.012424972839653492, 0.04951609671115875, 0.03762497380375862, 0.03565550968050957, 0.013795408420264721, -0.0601230226457119, 0.03835511952638626, 0.0319785512983799, -0.001417657476849854, -0.028406066820025444, 0.0007183162379078567, -0.014033089391887188, -0.024576732888817787, 0.04662448167800903, -0.03426545485854149, 0.02972349151968956, -0.00644695432856679, 0.009507638402283192, -0.03888939321041107, 0.020747488364577293, -0.026360832154750824, 0.02150353416800499, 0.013473124243319035, 0.046840935945510864, -0.028582625091075897, -0.013431316241621971, -0.03461266681551933, -0.02024998888373375, 0.015841152518987656, 0.07590402662754059, -0.013407616876065731, -0.015595617704093456, 0.017596160992980003, 0.02349545620381832, -0.04976295679807663, -0.04405839741230011, 0.03725374490022659, 0.011718842200934887, -0.02411321923136711, 0.010089038871228695, 0.000004185238594800467, -0.055455323308706284, 0.0046637714840471745, -0.0111558111384511, -0.012135183438658714, 0.01614224910736084, -0.01976693421602249, 0.03298727422952652, 0.06224142387509346, -0.0003398990083951503, 0.06942819803953171, 0.016152886673808098, 0.02127893641591072, -0.006570758298039436, -0.016837839037179947, 0.012550235725939274, -0.06454355269670486, -0.03885906562209129, -0.05241090804338455, 0.013011861592531204, -0.0382816307246685, 0.03255562111735344, -0.03710660710930824, 0.018512725830078125, -0.00569196417927742, -0.019419481977820396, 0.008267889730632305, 0.025295646861195564, -0.015324162319302559, -0.013851199299097061, -0.0011729913530871272, 0.021024370566010475, -0.032779477536678314, -0.013709801249206066, 0.02809028886258602, -0.020934956148266792, 0.003211624687537551, 0.0012061550514772534, -0.04354459047317505, 0.03808647021651268, -0.04764694720506668, -0.006172626279294491, -0.037305738776922226, -0.025089802220463753, -0.011381545104086399, -0.005213235039263964, 0.006626978516578674, 0.012385576963424683, -0.025497041642665863, -0.028426650911569595, 0.05085200443863869, -0.007601918186992407, -0.004820330999791622, -0.08021698147058487, 0.05652567744255066, 0.004629143048077822, -0.018267424777150154, -0.08229614794254303, -0.05407194420695305, 0.027155250310897827, 0.02596195600926876, 0.0005460000829771161, -0.029264133423566818, 0.004763804841786623, -0.0025154808536171913, -0.012331359088420868, -0.07015537470579147, 0.047010328620672226, -0.009412422776222229, 0.0031314000952988863, 0.010392090305685997, 0.031976550817489624, 0.08950715512037277, 0.002661254722625017, 0.015472795814275742, -0.012710463255643845, -0.008963963948190212, -0.024784905835986137, -0.0014472914626821876, 0.012280451133847237, -0.020643919706344604, -0.01275727991014719, -0.0468139573931694, 0.0035882932133972645, 0.02088714763522148, -0.02582882158458233, -0.027356332167983055, 0.004185939207673073, 0.000462407449958846, -0.0005881391698494554, -0.030185438692569733, -0.01272911112755537, -0.004928812384605408, 0.0024202666245400906, 0.014704380184412003, 0.011319711804389954, 0.007846281863749027, -0.03095703013241291, 0.003810173599049449, 0.011848066933453083, -0.020707931369543076, 0.020348481833934784, 0.08106627315282822, -0.016933942213654518, -0.00004544490730040707, -0.006700572557747364, -0.025020720437169075, 0.017409315332770348, 0.00037559171323664486, -0.009925415739417076, -0.014803722500801086, 0.029748812317848206, -0.0798252522945404, -0.01930978149175644, -0.03521714359521866, 0.0040151504799723625, 0.0743233785033226, -0.005960309412330389, 0.026515349745750427, 0.08421001583337784, 0.015541224740445614, 0.004352402873337269, -0.03171957656741142, 0.0040535712614655495, 0.0002477889065630734, -0.020061451941728592, 0.06260127574205399, 0.008623478934168816, -0.004573645535856485, 0.026295945048332214, 0.04091789200901985, 0.018458746373653412, 0.022708240896463394, -0.011364448815584183, 0.04197387769818306, 0.025956125929951668, -0.03642110526561737, -0.038559045642614365, 0.007632348220795393, -0.02884085290133953, 0.0029812315478920937, -0.03617135435342789, -0.01744634099304676, 0.049382489174604416, 0.05315933749079704, 0.030120309442281723, -0.07547395676374435, -0.03944661468267441, -0.0628858208656311, 0.023128783330321312, 0.014887605793774128, 0.013869773596525192, 0.038791678845882416, 0.04026731103658676, 0.056939829140901566, 0.010880333371460438, 0.025301367044448853, -0.05164393410086632, -0.048533856868743896, 0.0009792771888896823, -0.025953955948352814, -0.011700035072863102, 0.0259013082832098, -0.01572646200656891, -0.051959328353405, 0.006669633090496063, -0.015395048074424267, 0.014427782967686653, 0.004377489909529686, 0.03136485815048218, 0.011235874146223068, 0.04420517757534981, -0.0034526214003562927, 0.03588052839040756, 0.01678289845585823, -0.007848580367863178, 0.09193046391010284, 0.09452655166387558, 0.037286560982465744, -0.08261795341968536, 0.02822861261665821, 0.030786877498030663, -0.01796821318566799, -0.033374179154634476, 0.0131907993927598, 0.006603292189538479, 0.018418418243527412, 0.021687086671590805, 0.08041570335626602, 0.019652290269732475, -0.022041605785489082, 0.05079912394285202, -0.01705041155219078, 0.006107903551310301, 0.009269099682569504, 0.010103067383170128, -0.02177145518362522, -0.041548825800418854, -0.04486938938498497, 0.015970010310411453, 0.013624226674437523, -0.012497276067733765, -0.005380490329116583, 0.0005704763461835682, 0.019741106778383255, 0.014354528859257698, 0.011774459853768349, 0.022375164553523064, 0.01933654397726059, 0.027683373540639877, -0.027262074872851372, 0.013195051811635494, 0.016268018633127213, -0.009865138679742813, 0.030094482004642487, 0.0380537174642086, 0.016680777072906494, 0.00449439836665988, 0.02774578519165516, 0.01218840666115284, -0.04502217471599579, -0.018409324809908867, -0.03709586337208748, 0.04829688370227814, -0.009234094060957432, -0.032699041068553925, -0.004155992530286312, 0.0012098829029127955, -0.03210072964429855, -0.07273178547620773, -0.015175484120845795, 0.007484490517526865, -0.013700621202588081, -0.044381070882081985, 0.025475945323705673, -0.042861223220825195, 0.023869475349783897, -0.011699819937348366, 0.04079799726605415, -0.007012984715402126, -0.05088815465569496, 0.005921578500419855, 0.012747720815241337, 0.039069097489118576, 0.01641520857810974, -0.015715043991804123, 0.007566521409898996, -0.028588904067873955, 0.013771110214293003, -0.008920934051275253, -0.015482788905501366, 0.004037162754684687, 0.024905532598495483, -0.023088671267032623, -0.009569663554430008, -0.01980212703347206, -0.030104948207736015, 0.0011213155230507255, -0.007247165311127901, 0.00600192416459322, -0.06322019547224045, -0.01683703064918518, 0.03971094265580177, 0.03886374458670616, 0.020072605460882187, 0.015320627018809319, -0.02455829828977585, 0.03820890933275223, 0.0027754297479987144, -0.09260157495737076, 0.00975758396089077, 0.022172801196575165, -0.05370014160871506, 0.000574867648538202, -0.06011926010251045, 0.07270980626344681, 0.03777315095067024, 0.02932649664580822, -0.02162753976881504, 0.014994410797953606, -0.03419123589992523, 0.015173816122114658, -0.019498422741889954, -0.039025645703077316, 0.00804299395531416, 0.03361716866493225, 0.008719979785382748, -0.015938935801386833, -0.011470859870314598, -0.042912185192108154, -0.019741803407669067, 0.038208670914173126, -0.023182256147265434, -0.025865068659186363, -0.0009143843781203032, -0.007076741196215153, 0.01602596789598465, -0.05775243043899536, -0.0061416965909302235, -0.0327518954873085, -0.006951431278139353, 0.04106670245528221, 0.00027631729608401656, -0.005331107415258884, 0.011625039391219616, 0.015252440236508846, -0.032179925590753555, 0.04693644493818283, 0.043430719524621964, 0.033144231885671616, 0.0072850435972213745, 0.0017086691223084927, -0.012956886552274227, 0.06701456010341644, -0.007327697705477476, -0.015408415347337723, 0.03647742047905922, -0.02185841090977192, -0.008563518524169922, 0.02414461225271225, -0.01029796339571476, 0.045107677578926086, 0.017592161893844604, 0.006564275361597538, -0.02394268848001957, 0.035817500203847885, -0.015556705184280872, 0.0025327603798359632, -0.022924168035387993, -0.0029173879884183407, -0.017930710688233376, 0.011266401968896389, 0.015177376568317413, 0.0349746011197567, -0.014956380240619183, 0.014283822849392891, 0.023910334333777428, -0.009217328391969204, -0.012342228554189205, -0.006421681493520737, 0.024591734632849693, -0.0072273146361112595, 0.011519287712872028, 0.0033963518217206, -0.0014713454293087125, 0.0585133321583271, -0.043440189212560654, 0.016850855201482773, -0.008051699958741665, -0.006152705289423466, -0.08812560886144638, -0.007228509988635778, 0.02154167741537094, -0.006534363608807325, 0.04464299976825714, -0.056982457637786865, 0.061974912881851196, 0.014581680297851562, -0.028858978301286697, -0.010081024840474129, -0.028229979798197746, 0.029981939122080803, -0.036019906401634216, -0.003742869710549712, -0.02341131493449211, 0.030179305002093315, 0.021844202652573586, 0.0320565365254879, 0.03255734592676163, 0.040292493999004364, -0.018641823902726173, -0.008702564053237438, -0.003812653012573719, -0.01045242603868246, 0.007635287940502167, -0.10302150249481201, 0.011732133105397224, -0.030793221667408943, -0.03297608345746994, 0.04242584481835365, -0.055739834904670715, -0.009874287992715836, 0.008276894688606262, 0.020363500341773033, 0.01722600683569908, 0.027387090027332306, 0.023619484156370163, -0.005288952961564064, -0.038834862411022186, -0.00931905210018158, -0.003947777207940817, 0.024001294746994972, -0.02125668153166771, 0.003397048218175769, 0.04687456414103508, -0.0005894001224078238, -0.025526588782668114, -0.023354345932602882, 0.003731334814801812, -0.01932530105113983, -0.020249061286449432, -0.011295544914901257, 0.005679829977452755, -0.03161889687180519, -0.004414652939885855, -0.01784583367407322, -0.007576034404337406, 0.057659223675727844, -0.011408708989620209, -0.010784221813082695, -0.005788773763924837, -0.03725658729672432, -0.06850048154592514, 0.023890390992164612, 0.003772594965994358, 0.007928199134767056, -0.07842960208654404, -0.011861974373459816, -0.0012086902279406786, -0.041837580502033234, -0.029043488204479218, -0.051034364849328995, -0.006948183290660381, 0.06697976589202881, -0.013761147856712341, -0.028788287192583084, -0.007304680533707142, -0.012666005641222, 0.0001764703047228977, -0.070489801466465, 0.02522546797990799, -0.010695206001400948, -0.0187003705650568, -0.01281778048723936, 0.04464026913046837, -0.05648178234696388, -0.006617238745093346, 0.03808207809925079, 0.006657406687736511, 0.0064242989756166935, 0.010001110844314098, 0.026650112122297287, -0.0008299211622215807, -0.053000058978796005, 0.05093904957175255, -0.001840142416767776, -0.007198747247457504, 0.006045992951840162, -0.03114326298236847, 0.017244113609194756, 0.007970422506332397, -0.007812428288161755, -0.011312467977404594, -0.007960202172398567, 0.04289533197879791, -0.0034224092960357666, 0.01798054575920105, -0.0067555964924395084, 0.01722002401947975, 0.025535056367516518, -0.0017559017287567258, 0.025850987061858177, 0.022715965285897255, -0.003036183537915349, -0.03274127468466759, 0.04664414003491402, -0.022701676934957504, -0.043220072984695435, -0.00528413662686944, -0.007586443331092596, -0.04041672497987747, -0.025288481265306473, -0.02405942976474762, -0.012692200019955635, -0.013422408141195774, -0.010362016968429089, -0.0012703113025054336, -0.021905366331338882, 0.020732929930090904, -0.009708927012979984, 0.0063958424143493176, 0.015022828243672848, -0.022374752908945084, 0.02134130895137787, 0.021499788388609886, 0.01615915074944496, 0.005090771708637476, -0.015007425099611282, 0.03264162689447403, 0.020076727494597435, 0.02485658787190914, -0.007524013519287109, 0.04509129747748375, -0.0008200810989364982, -0.006175672635436058, 0.016329923644661903, -0.006127137690782547, 0.015369073487818241, -0.027202675119042397, -0.000534393941052258, 0.054489973932504654, -0.10083268582820892, 0.009937464259564877, -0.025832287967205048, -0.0026663304306566715, -0.02975396253168583, 0.0025519700720906258, 0.017607470974326134, -0.028291793540120125, 0.016470782458782196, 0.012846382334828377, -0.01262163557112217, -0.00607565650716424, 0.01668890379369259, -0.023144764825701714, 0.00121124682482332, -0.009133701212704182, -0.03171345591545105, -0.008416286669671535, 0.004809776321053505, -0.03559610992670059, -0.023176977410912514, 0.040703460574150085, 0.024375921115279198, 0.01887386664748192, -0.004931299481540918, -0.047680001705884933, -0.023020150139927864, 0.030436674132943153, -0.06395653635263443, -0.03096664696931839, -0.019317464902997017, 0.01651366800069809, -0.0020619621500372887, -0.018677257001399994 ]
<p>I am looking at the spatial patterns of turnover in aquatic assemblages using gradient forest and generalized dissimilarity models in R. I have species and environmental data for more than 400 sites sampled from streams across the country. However, I also have many missing values in my predictor (environmental) variables, up to 30% for some variables, so removing the cases with incomplete data sets or replacing them by the mean will result in bias and loss of information. About the missingness pattern, my data is really an assembly of data collected by different county administrations, and the decisions about which variables to sample are made at the county level. For example, some counties have monitored total and dissolved nutrients but others have only routinely monitored total nutrients. The missingness pattern is thus affected by those decisions. The next matrix is an example of how my data would look like:</p> <pre><code> County V1 V2 V3 V4 V5 V6 [1,] 10 52 6 35 294 48 25 [2,] 10 22 7 41 53 42 NA [3,] 10 118 NA 55 82 59 NA [4,] 10 150 8 13 91 63 15 [5,] 10 500 NA NA NA 102 9 [6,] 9 58 7 NA 22 73 7 [7,] 9 9 6.5 NA 38 152 17 [8,] 9 9 7 NA 14 224 11 [9,] 9 142 5.5 NA 57 64 11 [10,] 9 90 6 NA 102 66 NA [11,] 6 30 7 9 NA NA 11 [12,] 6 420 4.5 8 NA NA NA [13,] 6 43 4.5 3.5 NA NA NA [14,] 6 50 6.5 116 NA NA 14 [15,] 6 10 NA 13 NA NA 8 &gt; </code></pre> <p>where "County" is the different county administrations that have provided data, and "V1 to V6" are the environmental variables. In county 10 all variables are sampled but some are missing at random. In county 9 variable V3 is not routinely monitored. In county 6 variables V4, and V5 are not monitored, in addition there are missing values in the routinely measured variables due to, e.g. failure in the sampling device.</p> <p>I cannot forget to mention that my data are also spatially autocorrelated at small spatial scales (&lt;10 to 100km). I would like to estimate those missing values but I don’t know which method is the most appropriate to do so, and which R packages are recommended. </p>
35,761
[ -0.03545152023434639, 0.0067220465280115604, 0.010349102318286896, 0.032403044402599335, 0.019276749342679977, -0.012020811438560486, -0.012630648910999298, -0.03662713244557381, 0.01816791296005249, -0.041894037276506424, 0.02932664006948471, 0.04352070763707161, 0.030588896945118904, 0.02474263682961464, 0.028452124446630478, 0.043683603405952454, -0.00600729463621974, 0.028340568765997887, 0.004268518649041653, -0.02501656301319599, -0.002390740904957056, 0.008663341403007507, 0.02018381655216217, -0.021343493834137917, -0.020555349066853523, 0.04742101952433586, 0.020841537043452263, -0.011055254377424717, -0.0185039434581995, 0.023935232311487198, -0.03623324632644653, -0.03778091073036194, 0.014217753894627094, -0.00419256929308176, 0.008546930737793446, 0.010979371145367622, -0.008860375732183456, -0.03623895347118378, 0.02710861526429653, 0.04800192639231682, -0.04560593515634537, -0.02639603056013584, -0.006646164692938328, 0.03226501867175102, 0.010969175025820732, 0.021711835637688637, 0.010595530271530151, 0.02103981375694275, 0.032725267112255096, 0.030446425080299377, 0.07372733950614929, 0.009627235122025013, 0.04850301519036293, 0.001149816787801683, -0.04677915945649147, -0.023133475333452225, 0.03833460807800293, 0.059478968381881714, -0.0008700905600562692, -0.058395884931087494, 0.0010147542925551534, -0.038764338940382004, 0.0026885783299803734, -0.029974600300192833, -0.03628618270158768, 0.003137708641588688, -0.017859185114502907, -0.030110016465187073, 0.03283297270536423, -0.034110989421606064, 0.005179148633033037, -0.010975103825330734, 0.003806681139394641, -0.01681545376777649, -0.009437698870897293, -0.025291116908192635, -0.009210345335304737, 0.018982069566845894, 0.04054452106356621, -0.015560172498226166, 0.004203530494123697, 0.0032942257821559906, 0.02858750708401203, 0.01636539399623871, 0.03511926159262657, -0.0025319012347608805, 0.05032157152891159, -0.062097396701574326, 0.017370257526636124, -0.004142333287745714, 0.006558561231940985, 0.026166176423430443, 0.08317183703184128, 0.02027154713869095, -0.0427682027220726, 0.02941642887890339, -0.0002391951420577243, 0.03528684377670288, -0.014984111301600933, 0.007240470964461565, -0.04893529415130615, -0.04721647500991821, 0.00814051367342472, 0.02852582186460495, -0.02928036078810692, -0.04463407024741173, -0.03219367191195488, -0.01192267332226038, -0.027090834453701973, -0.005594225134700537, -0.0051376838237047195, 0.017730548977851868, 0.0059267254546284676, -0.0014400547370314598, 0.00836773682385683, -0.031018786132335663, 0.014466347172856331, 0.016459880396723747, 0.03400741517543793, 0.07569752633571625, 0.07965218275785446, -0.032342880964279175, -0.00655147572979331, -0.019060838967561722, -0.07124828547239304, 0.02317299135029316, -0.004396260250359774, -0.023188713937997818, -0.03793148323893547, 0.010444970801472664, -0.03020823933184147, -0.019640101119875908, 0.05204794183373451, -0.03613678738474846, 0.0382162407040596, 0.005551641341298819, -0.087669238448143, -0.03481264412403107, 0.028389252722263336, -0.04263458028435707, 0.015576745383441448, -0.049407802522182465, -0.0010507795959711075, 0.005306367762386799, 0.018196741119027138, 0.019978944212198257, 0.011706570163369179, 0.04841959848999977, 0.022771896794438362, 0.00025881873443722725, -0.02145630121231079, 0.0011116357054561377, -0.02087823487818241, -0.03303283452987671, -0.043291978538036346, -0.056465987116098404, 0.020992416888475418, 0.029103605076670647, 0.0014790889108553529, 0.02018691413104534, 0.015526298433542252, 0.001652059145271778, 0.00869804248213768, -0.019969353452324867, 0.010384555906057358, 0.006977584678679705, 0.045672208070755005, -0.015607979148626328, 0.04270324110984802, 0.008212681859731674, -0.03567579761147499, 0.0026354447472840548, 0.012150296010077, 0.07314947247505188, 0.056828562170267105, 0.01514371670782566, 0.030168022960424423, -0.01297824177891016, -0.011285088025033474, 0.01685403101146221, -0.037657491862773895, -0.03171972930431366, -0.007627879269421101, -0.012323006987571716, 0.03936866298317909, 0.025728615000844002, 0.0016623855335637927, -0.023417901247739792, 0.052475444972515106, -0.05661694332957268, -0.034611571580171585, -0.0440119244158268, -0.001825591898523271, -0.0031215380877256393, -0.01484924741089344, 0.029717281460762024, -0.017191030085086823, 0.009701569564640522, 0.03683406487107277, -0.023833798244595528, -0.03310507535934448, -0.012827524915337563, 0.06348873674869537, -0.038175322115421295, -0.008105774410068989, 0.0020179245620965958, 0.05188030004501343, 0.0075386217795312405, 0.0634133368730545, -0.01764504425227642, -0.02777641825377941, 0.028608785942196846, -0.02024015784263611, -0.01142382062971592, -0.010268083773553371, -0.009142238646745682, -0.010804325342178345, 0.0016458967002108693, -0.06628628075122833, 0.0362393781542778, -0.06589280068874359, 0.039432499557733536, 0.06008068099617958, -0.0004244865267537534, 0.002126026898622513, 0.0027309409342706203, -0.029335971921682358, 0.03302089497447014, -0.07649010419845581, -0.03776702284812927, -0.08415044844150543, 0.007873334921896458, 0.016608726233243942, 0.028370434418320656, 0.005048452410846949, 0.03574682027101517, 0.0017803000519052148, 0.026251474395394325, 0.01127328909933567, 0.03492894768714905, 0.001408864976838231, -0.009720037691295147, 0.052427783608436584, 0.014341486617922783, 0.016330638900399208, 0.02349778078496456, 0.0226244255900383, -0.0024920420255512, 0.049532245844602585, -0.015634121373295784, 0.007771547418087721, 0.023948250338435173, 0.004948146175593138, -0.013854427263140678, -0.026238182559609413, 0.00798271968960762, 0.0602683499455452, -0.015720488503575325, -0.018539035692811012, 0.058108460158109665, 0.014591740444302559, 0.004997205920517445, -0.01220838725566864, -0.0035351980477571487, 0.03307545185089111, 0.08827518671751022, -0.04099855571985245, 0.011121438816189766, 0.0035261015873402357, -0.023721061646938324, 0.024810420349240303, -0.07567523419857025, -0.02565135806798935, -0.04407216235995293, 0.005469656549394131, 0.03304960951209068, -0.000022187656213645823, 0.030110318213701248, -0.029679013416171074, 0.018779339268803596, -0.011765535920858383, -0.0007188486633822322, 0.01960778422653675, 0.04959527403116226, -0.01691405288875103, -0.0024236373137682676, -0.002027286449447274, -0.0015788880409672856, 0.015957826748490334, -0.026333367452025414, -0.03763139247894287, 0.05136054754257202, 0.036568183451890945, -0.04514376074075699, -0.041253361850976944, 0.00385983195155859, 0.018913084641098976, -0.021491505205631256, -0.031873926520347595, 0.011154349893331528, -0.006420114077627659, -0.050706032663583755, 0.012174752540886402, -0.05544580519199371, -0.011249394156038761, -0.03772243484854698, -0.004772992338985205, -0.005673629697412252, 0.002734628040343523, -0.013839278370141983, 0.030101537704467773, -0.020323680713772774, 0.005375497508794069, -0.042666587978601456, -0.0640709325671196, 0.004525789525359869, 0.009881074540317059, 0.025147126987576485, -0.0047359406016767025, -0.012444054707884789, 0.06634380668401718, 0.05512388050556183, -0.03962497413158417, -0.02962702512741089, -0.001945819123648107, -0.04927966371178627, -0.04173702746629715, 0.009875116869807243, 0.014316597953438759, 0.04603508487343788, 0.01315324753522873, -0.02823580615222454, 0.05596204102039337, 0.022057434543967247, 0.007692950777709484, 0.004170714411884546, 0.05012209713459015, -0.007132420781999826, -0.014791269786655903, 0.02266169711947441, 0.022204404696822166, -0.023571455851197243, -0.0011200805893167853, -0.02612180821597576, 0.015225752256810665, 0.0076789334416389465, -0.06227729842066765, -0.010049312375485897, -0.016366343945264816, 0.035203125327825546, -0.030876491218805313, 0.00624946691095829, 0.03045816160738468, -0.03314417600631714, 0.01760326325893402, -0.02796163596212864, 0.0795462429523468, -0.020627537742257118, -0.026087546721100807, 0.0558822937309742, 0.03066175989806652, -0.009201091714203358, 0.057175591588020325, -0.020285656675696373, 0.04556094482541084, 0.019034821540117264, -0.05046258121728897, -0.023147176951169968, 0.044924717396497726, 0.052782315760850906, 0.010019725188612938, -0.02476412244141102, -0.03671468794345856, 0.047011952847242355, -0.038870733231306076, 0.005992127116769552, -0.01551914494484663, 0.022752629593014717, 0.004805953707545996, -0.0019295262172818184, 0.0028763674199581146, 0.012648255564272404, 0.00837793666869402, -0.007333350367844105, -0.02969968691468239, 0.004762798082083464, 0.01437460258603096, 0.014915013685822487, -0.011787138879299164, -0.06663310527801514, 0.049353986978530884, 0.005800922401249409, 0.019487129524350166, -0.0005540281999856234, 0.0313800647854805, -0.041669346392154694, 0.03046369180083275, 0.013928658328950405, 0.0051702032797038555, -0.014189439825713634, -0.004009856842458248, 0.036093827337026596, -0.032007262110710144, 0.05042906850576401, 0.032020095735788345, 0.0028025819920003414, -0.022908087819814682, -0.04195905104279518, -0.0002852795587386936, 0.05371982231736183, 0.04143236204981804, 0.032011087983846664, 0.01563425362110138, -0.01231521274894476, -0.021167129278182983, 0.014841866679489613, 0.049591679126024246, 0.01939452812075615, 0.047446031123399734, -0.017855539917945862, -0.012434839271008968, 0.0026931380853056908, 0.01908607967197895, 0.018382254987955093, 0.015234679915010929, 0.009302422404289246, 0.04040641337633133, 0.05568424612283707, -0.05490068346261978, 0.045207805931568146, -0.022131837904453278, 0.025919562205672264, 0.008143976330757141, -0.004191861022263765, -0.013690917752683163, 0.018483076244592667, -0.009572884067893028, 0.043137744069099426, 0.009906302206218243, -0.002691936446353793, -0.021355172619223595, 0.03426935523748398, -0.022147508338093758, -0.032447732985019684, -0.018854806199669838, 0.00955156795680523, 0.02906862646341324, -0.029824335128068924, -0.041733842343091965, 0.010165437124669552, 0.015061436221003532, 0.0287475548684597, 0.019647903740406036, 0.036005664616823196, -0.11905112862586975, -0.025038592517375946, 0.0603158101439476, 0.020419953390955925, -0.0014063991839066148, -0.01316680759191513, -0.06808135658502579, -0.02064628154039383, -0.0011389350984245539, -0.0038967663422226906, 0.007745840586721897, 0.0025042325723916292, 0.025517797097563744, -0.014062325470149517, -0.07185191661119461, -0.018049512058496475, -0.008199012838304043, -0.027388552203774452, 0.042714979499578476, -0.032660167664289474, -0.053464047610759735, -0.014364983886480331, 0.015918022021651268, 0.006965263746678829, 0.05834800377488136, -0.03541610762476921, -0.03762677311897278, 0.037230562418699265, 0.016618186607956886, 0.0029092116747051477, -0.04119164124131203, 0.04378707706928253, -0.00021306776034180075, 0.021901315078139305, 0.05729348585009575, 0.008798982948064804, -0.022683007642626762, 0.04054627940058708, 0.024308685213327408, -0.009178324602544308, -0.018154138699173927, -0.005849627312272787, 0.053793203085660934, 0.002979136072099209, -0.006005410570651293, 0.06046313792467117, 0.021220257505774498, -0.023811738938093185, -0.0028897682204842567, -0.07989322394132614, -0.004244895186275244, -0.0350780263543129, -0.04108573496341705, -0.06109868362545967, -0.05144702270627022, 0.008475324138998985, 0.026152195408940315, -0.0015948567306622863, 0.0020202198065817356, -0.02833392657339573, -0.011500263586640358, 0.027975700795650482, 0.012895642779767513, -0.031061673536896706, 0.013051810674369335, -0.0060354797169566154, 0.004350149538367987, -0.009671117179095745, -0.007732521742582321, 0.021691206842660904, -0.007927537895739079, 0.0055196769535541534, -0.014997413381934166, -0.04020775482058525, -0.009370686486363411, -0.04073287919163704, 0.02694648504257202, 0.018198112025856972, -0.023310814052820206, 0.00021268794080242515, 0.032068997621536255, 0.07425811886787415, 0.01411730982363224, -0.02747104875743389, -0.022410333156585693, 0.02802594006061554, -0.039582159370183945, -0.0028073275461792946, 0.020560603588819504, 0.04386185109615326, -0.01186260487884283, 0.027010351419448853, -0.06264900416135788, -0.03178352490067482, 0.01527867466211319, 0.00700397789478302, -0.05451033636927605, -0.025446387007832527, -0.05883371829986572, -0.010512133128941059, 0.009622445330023766, -0.012303591705858707, 0.026312395930290222, -0.03928465023636818, -0.012529962696135044, -0.012596264481544495, 0.01748887076973915, 0.07590142637491226, -0.04199671000242233, -0.007852494716644287, 0.01168700959533453, -0.04837314784526825, -0.008443938568234444, 0.0030664841178804636, -0.025686483830213547, -0.039535753428936005, -0.003703775815665722, -0.04606174677610397, 0.030503476038575172, 0.03968626260757446, 0.00016716944810468704, -0.04159989207983017, -0.005939793772995472, 0.0015125200152397156, 0.031526289880275726, -0.0349629707634449, 0.011096450500190258, -0.03796654939651489, -0.005952427629381418, -0.01464586891233921, 0.027502013370394707, 0.017525415867567062, -0.03032727912068367, 0.012999972328543663, -0.006536219734698534, -0.01398081798106432, 0.04222158342599869, 0.028773827478289604, -0.03511705622076988, 0.05372683331370354, 0.0062313624657690525, 0.004038634244352579, 0.06285001337528229, 0.010200537741184235, 0.01941405050456524, 0.000649338704533875, 0.04794737324118614, -0.04246427118778229, -0.05355944111943245, -0.05312693491578102, 0.024223238229751587, 0.02143845334649086, 0.0031827648635953665, 0.023003635928034782, 0.05819958075881004, -0.002223328221589327, 0.03677584230899811, -0.059035707265138626, -0.009868238121271133, 0.012817498296499252, 0.011445931158959866, 0.07387594878673553, -0.004589735064655542, -0.007620394229888916, 0.03686126694083214, 0.014364060945808887, 0.03559624403715134, 0.04699999466538429, -0.0018284255638718605, 0.0010200736578553915, 0.0037435826379805803, -0.05005350708961487, -0.04593805968761444, -0.0009702325914986432, -0.022501369938254356, 0.004980191588401794, -0.0113604087382555, -0.034002356231212616, 0.05990034341812134, 0.03200587257742882, 0.013998947106301785, -0.028174905106425285, -0.03667803108692169, -0.052206311374902725, 0.03407397121191025, 0.010349485091865063, -0.0015599216567352414, 0.03723563998937607, 0.04484240710735321, 0.03086802549660206, -0.01316130068153143, 0.03356723114848137, -0.040608927607536316, -0.06619544327259064, -0.03737097606062889, -0.045659422874450684, -0.02010505646467209, 0.038634829223155975, -0.01362746674567461, -0.02624468319118023, 0.01352197490632534, -0.02533709444105625, 0.009979584254324436, 0.016203459352254868, 0.00601918762549758, -0.027879098430275917, 0.01804797723889351, 0.012502236291766167, 0.013275484554469585, -0.017684217542409897, -0.029123937711119652, 0.15514850616455078, 0.03423801809549332, 0.039294321089982986, -0.008331065066158772, 0.000004618908860720694, 0.027613896876573563, 0.008740559220314026, -0.012829342857003212, -0.04463104531168938, 0.029900865629315376, -0.01333365123718977, 0.03996073082089424, 0.001387295313179493, 0.02255980484187603, 0.007384658791124821, 0.04377738758921623, -0.03867927938699722, -0.0040664575062692165, 0.0016839917516335845, 0.01113603264093399, 0.011344397440552711, -0.0054642618633806705, -0.04646003246307373, 0.009448934346437454, 0.05959150195121765, -0.02267656847834587, -0.028442032635211945, 0.009463759139180183, 0.0101895397529006, 0.034196887165308, -0.026380890980362892, 0.001451497315429151, -0.008788473904132843, 0.026784375309944153, -0.0012625728268176317, 0.014345546253025532, 0.009620841592550278, -0.07063448429107666, 0.009437855333089828, 0.0072016227059066296, -0.02583502233028412, -0.0008593059028498828, -0.01124743651598692, -0.0023828342091292143, -0.018729686737060547, -0.012128284201025963, -0.03996100649237633, 0.06986897438764572, -0.0030856903176754713, -0.02913096733391285, 0.0018835016526281834, -0.0017753740539774299, 0.004830744117498398, -0.04828142374753952, -0.00949260126799345, -0.006068298127502203, 0.01619770936667919, -0.007777808234095573, 0.012280113063752651, 0.027794519439339638, 0.012005356140434742, 0.02749255672097206, -0.01752043329179287, 0.03868002071976662, -0.012203986756503582, -0.04705683887004852, -0.008610079064965248, 0.028379321098327637, 0.00041447216062806547, 0.04402617737650871, 0.024848513305187225, 0.022389715537428856, -0.01176065020263195, -0.025794364511966705, 0.007722342852503061, 0.007723634131252766, 0.04101007804274559, -0.002280172659084201, 0.0012063932372257113, 0.03126463294029236, -0.07888802886009216, -0.02638847939670086, -0.03538306802511215, -0.027970613911747932, -0.03450094163417816, 0.007896684110164642, -0.016246933490037918, 0.054178718477487564, 0.052424702793359756, 0.015028241090476513, 0.013874305412173271, 0.07301110774278641, -0.004235872067511082, -0.019077176228165627, -0.030111845582723618, -0.05449545010924339, -0.0436025895178318, 0.015301729552447796, -0.0017697106814011931, 0.06368739902973175, 0.025834474712610245, -0.007234761957079172, 0.005199591629207134, 0.03386031463742256, 0.0166719201952219, -0.00004826787699130364, 0.000283428787952289, -0.02749629132449627, 0.013145443052053452, 0.0036371194291859865, -0.011510387994349003, -0.06527353823184967, 0.021641135215759277, -0.03360456973314285, -0.01886136271059513, 0.02329414151608944, -0.024218348786234856, -0.034768249839544296, 0.00651351036503911, -0.013871116563677788, 0.02686198055744171, 0.0030526467598974705, -0.054617807269096375, -0.058496277779340744, -0.04297265782952309, -0.03995301201939583, -0.039987578988075256, 0.0010035159066319466, -0.0005662563489750028, -0.03513176739215851, -0.011885713785886765, 0.03680841624736786, -0.017762107774615288, 0.017752842977643013, 0.010433931834995747, 0.016628682613372803, 0.0239794310182333, 0.06092115864157677, -0.0007516197510994971, -0.029788047075271606, 0.013940492644906044, -0.037521038204431534, -0.022083090618252754, -0.0019742916338145733, -0.00044090274604968727, 0.04247692599892616, -0.028087936341762543, 0.0015322859399020672, -0.06294569373130798, 0.06590615212917328, -0.04871044680476189, 0.045430317521095276, -0.02018783986568451, 0.023311080411076546, 0.0018507911590859294, -0.0297133456915617, -0.008363733068108559, 0.04585869982838631, -0.017568103969097137, -0.011969818733632565, 0.045355554670095444, 0.007996141910552979, -0.0026807833928614855, 0.008153296075761318, -0.029578758403658867, 0.01381733175367117, -0.011622725054621696, 0.0057319034822285175, -0.03922026976943016, 0.0467413067817688, -0.008821538649499416, 0.005212488584220409, 0.016992881894111633, 0.02567397430539131, -0.08757466077804565, -0.01244540885090828, 0.012252516113221645, 0.058834508061409, -0.005218688398599625, -0.018836595118045807, 0.02013111487030983, 0.015758691355586052, -0.04524430260062218, 0.012317902408540249, 0.022258300334215164, 0.015294363722205162, -0.03930514305830002, 0.03164968267083168, -0.04429027438163757, -0.014654923230409622, 0.056211840361356735, 0.0021518117282539606, 0.01027789618819952, 0.0232208464294672, 0.033656999468803406, -0.05354698747396469, -0.03938162699341774, 0.013023674488067627, -0.001778814592398703, -0.057481423020362854, -0.016495436429977417, -0.02191111072897911, 0.014925765804946423, -0.010184545069932938, -0.04223039373755455, 0.008748098276555538, 0.035523273050785065, 0.037897925823926926, -0.007530178874731064, 0.05756048113107681, 0.0005307710380293429, 0.04281995818018913, -0.030522659420967102, -0.037910331040620804, 0.003591300221160054, -0.014116613194346428, -0.02880012057721615, 0.05166422203183174, 0.030125712975859642, -0.018706049770116806, -0.01480646338313818, -0.02328881062567234, -0.008926313370466232, -0.015307314693927765, 0.017720144242048264, 0.008127900771796703, -0.005048014223575592, -0.00942560750991106, -0.020441293716430664, -0.012751433998346329, 0.01602434553205967, 0.06325702369213104, 0.03548070415854454, -0.033927224576473236, 0.01243515033274889, -0.013373314402997494, -0.05323662981390953, -0.00546120572835207, -0.0055632092989981174, -0.018110016360878944, -0.058940738439559937, -0.018550962209701538, -0.015806714072823524, -0.0039014816284179688, -0.005645043216645718, 0.019789615646004677, -0.04763716459274292, 0.05439610034227371, 0.01795101910829544, -0.00989976990967989, 0.005154157988727093, -0.01206195168197155, 0.03355615958571434, -0.06411577016115189, 0.062007371336221695, -0.0028556780889630318, 0.014362320303916931, -0.0449238196015358, -0.00907815434038639, -0.02564479038119316, 0.058321088552474976, 0.03314831852912903, -0.007038279436528683, 0.016562050208449364, -0.0011738769244402647, 0.020095430314540863, 0.00339511432684958, -0.005022916477173567, 0.05822443589568138, 0.0012201020726934075, -0.012718248181045055, 0.03916332125663757, -0.009136449545621872, 0.04165269061923027, 0.011913818307220936, -0.018166227266192436, 0.0020388734992593527, -0.0427529476583004, 0.021817391738295555, 0.02111656963825226, 0.027861667796969414, -0.03599366545677185, -0.016693836078047752, 0.030903229489922523, -0.037661466747522354, 0.02135731466114521, 0.020268885418772697, 0.009310517460107803, -0.04513407126069069, 0.02627493254840374, -0.038058891892433167, -0.012029979377985, 0.04963051900267601, -0.008872047998011112, 0.03475584089756012, -0.07264614850282669, 0.004642311483621597, -0.01719551719725132, -0.029328681528568268, -0.0012972125550732017, 0.05288925766944885, -0.00422893650829792, 0.0368601456284523, -0.0037786844186484814, 0.0007960257353261113, -0.0026991209015250206, 0.005164142698049545, 0.01714872196316719, 0.040436387062072754, 0.02367899939417839, -0.00745102483779192, -0.0037936472799628973, 0.023502610623836517, -0.027591539546847343, 0.01024867594242096, -0.017302505671977997, 0.03944532573223114, 0.013710333034396172, 0.004728126805275679, 0.03770674765110016, 0.030186839401721954, 0.005911600310355425, 0.017132161185145378, 0.008189964108169079, 0.03193465620279312, -0.022108661010861397, -0.029682094231247902, -0.06463830173015594, -0.05016498640179634, 0.02232983149588108, 0.022524643689393997, -0.05416436120867729, 0.022469371557235718, -0.0007770843803882599, 0.0646197721362114, -0.003586773294955492, 0.0004727620689664036, 0.01227013859897852, -0.0412663035094738, 0.02378961257636547, -0.00779540091753006, 0.02362005040049553, 0.02265823818743229, 0.02798941358923912, -0.004438639152795076, -0.02837158925831318, -0.015493970364332199, 0.02464458718895912, 0.020712589845061302, -0.03009502962231636, -0.011301534250378609, 0.004043646156787872, 0.025847328826785088, -0.016339587047696114, -0.04255089908838272, -0.025706687942147255, 0.012433044612407684, -0.009254307486116886, -0.02917923964560032 ]
<p>I'm writing a proposal for a restrospective cohort study using registry data. Am I right to think of the registry data as the whole population?</p> <p>If it is the population, then am I right in thinking there is no need to calculate required sample size (as is required for other cohort studies) or confidence intervals?</p> <p>If it is a sample, what would be the study population, and how would I go about calculating sample size?</p> <p>Additionally, with this in mind, how do I treat missing data? If there are 1000 heart transplant patients in a registry but only 500 of them have complete data (i.e. all the variables have values), do I treat these 500 patients as a sample? Furthermore, if it is a sample, it isn't random. Therefore is it worth calculating the confidence intervals from this actual sample size?</p>
73,404
[ -0.037867967039346695, -0.015947984531521797, -0.011033492162823677, 0.007130007725208998, 0.034908466041088104, 0.00914252083748579, -0.011213278397917747, -0.04316622018814087, 0.005680156406015158, -0.0006304655107669532, 0.04115577042102814, 0.025696849450469017, 0.039785873144865036, 0.004006661009043455, -0.02228289656341076, 0.026330197229981422, -0.0455997996032238, 0.003855586750432849, -0.014893434010446072, -0.0007067471160553396, 0.015904635190963745, -0.0202789269387722, 0.01190263032913208, -0.02602451853454113, -0.02097378857433796, 0.037477899342775345, 0.03961684927344322, -0.04927663505077362, 0.030836379155516624, 0.039528343826532364, -0.06510674953460693, -0.028041137382388115, 0.031054450199007988, 0.04003334045410156, 0.008143124170601368, 0.02243710309267044, -0.05379336327314377, -0.017573758959770203, 0.04476131498813629, 0.033960822969675064, -0.035929158329963684, -0.013519203290343285, 0.008112422190606594, 0.003702957648783922, 0.015496651642024517, 0.019476579502224922, -0.02178085967898369, -0.029614385217428207, -0.00850482564419508, -0.031221121549606323, 0.036569155752658844, -0.0012628426775336266, 0.0332871749997139, 0.002258202526718378, 0.014393781311810017, -0.0032628532499074936, 0.027873028069734573, 0.0247833039611578, -0.0048490832559764385, -0.02588752657175064, -0.03330770879983902, -0.022055909037590027, -0.003341940464451909, -0.024867655709385872, -0.005293507128953934, 0.00703600887209177, -0.006147002335637808, 0.004380521364510059, 0.04148295149207115, -0.004293100442737341, 0.001662379945628345, 0.013089318759739399, 0.0030751752201467752, -0.014487067237496376, 0.04215163365006447, -0.022904707118868828, 0.016657311469316483, 0.022197231650352478, 0.04531071335077286, 0.023218512535095215, -0.01670152321457863, 0.006107634399086237, 0.032624565064907074, 0.038184039294719696, 0.017504749819636345, -0.005868489388376474, 0.04492490366101265, -0.029028166085481644, 0.06862707436084747, -0.011770942248404026, 0.01054907962679863, -0.0023177149705588818, 0.007964733056724072, -0.011387882754206657, -0.06395894289016724, 0.02542605809867382, -0.02883746288716793, 0.060337334871292114, -0.03831513598561287, -0.00019812727987300605, -0.02279144711792469, -0.042168159037828445, 0.0388975590467453, 0.03204723447561264, -0.046212971210479736, 0.0023659721482545137, -0.008235695771872997, -0.024311376735568047, 0.0016095523023977876, -0.022569872438907623, -0.02659430354833603, 0.022857408970594406, 0.039438117295503616, 0.01759880594909191, 0.04136337712407112, 0.020589271560311317, 0.002821867587044835, -0.015760019421577454, 0.06362289935350418, 0.04916277155280113, 0.06462185829877853, -0.009861735627055168, 0.029858900234103203, -0.023734094575047493, -0.048970796167850494, 0.03062378242611885, -0.01589507795870304, -0.015204879455268383, -0.0613359771668911, 0.05376754328608513, 0.0031347095500677824, -0.0006672819727100432, 0.049244266003370285, 0.02075657807290554, 0.045498576015233994, -0.007626678328961134, -0.08121675997972488, -0.035454161465168, 0.011097494512796402, 0.00858059711754322, -0.017548413947224617, -0.06540007889270782, 0.02911456674337387, -0.02445685863494873, 0.04381658509373665, 0.012023166753351688, 0.03719349950551987, 0.02759024128317833, 0.025423849001526833, 0.02168651856482029, -0.02253779023885727, -0.002806168282404542, -0.02094193920493126, -0.012441635131835938, -0.02749834768474102, -0.09914198517799377, 0.01895166002213955, 0.020956993103027344, -0.010545887984335423, -0.01988554187119007, -0.004632565658539534, -0.02463773638010025, -0.04133697226643562, -0.025866620242595673, 0.022912565618753433, -0.01894989050924778, 0.06146971508860588, -0.04026429355144501, 0.03374628722667694, 0.02972915954887867, 0.014040891081094742, 0.018974266946315765, 0.029168618842959404, 0.05098084732890129, 0.034277621656656265, 0.003343579126521945, 0.011673983186483383, -0.005127458833158016, 0.012794421054422855, 0.010936195962131023, -0.03323446959257126, -0.040044646710157394, 0.02869982272386551, 0.01679369807243347, 0.03792677819728851, 0.038889821618795395, 0.027567626908421516, -0.013714673928916454, 0.06684918701648712, -0.03980030491948128, -0.04473753646016121, -0.07372388988733292, -0.01199272833764553, -0.0047905463725328445, -0.048542194068431854, -0.015750600025057793, -0.0010238352697342634, 0.013947964645922184, 0.02426404133439064, 0.004877583589404821, 0.0018009990453720093, -0.022529227659106255, 0.01848784275352955, -0.03536704555153847, 0.014343883842229843, 0.052396226674318314, 0.04300330951809883, -0.02500172145664692, 0.05786113440990448, -0.021994367241859436, -0.06571555137634277, -0.03496631979942322, -0.035783279687166214, 0.026257986202836037, -0.014338585548102856, -0.025817593559622765, -0.01139041967689991, -0.01302102766931057, -0.017968179658055305, 0.054962772876024246, -0.01877707801759243, 0.08367573469877243, 0.03675219044089317, -0.03113924153149128, 0.004448626656085253, 0.01536211185157299, 0.025077590718865395, 0.00042021501576527953, -0.0022384794428944588, -0.014114033430814743, -0.060591500252485275, 0.02666424959897995, 0.04747181758284569, -0.048035912215709686, -0.03172709420323372, -0.03154502809047699, 0.06441070884466171, 0.006821761839091778, 0.025333957746624947, -0.006573856342583895, -0.02594427764415741, -0.030555646866559982, 0.019931653514504433, 0.03588110953569412, 0.008585087954998016, 0.012813938781619072, -0.012824094854295254, -0.011549318209290504, 0.029030252248048782, 0.005238308571279049, 0.019441615790128708, 0.06316249072551727, -0.004814582876861095, 0.012825031764805317, -0.01952924206852913, -0.041759077459573746, 0.03172799572348595, -0.02384086325764656, 0.01311006210744381, 0.021349245682358742, -0.01916147582232952, 0.011544546112418175, 0.02140575647354126, -0.019602829590439796, 0.014956267550587654, 0.04540862888097763, -0.029159754514694214, -0.003628646256402135, 0.0009111713734455407, -0.05417477339506149, -0.0020710935350507498, -0.02602967619895935, -0.06478100270032883, -0.04478054121136665, -0.004858570173382759, 0.05046073719859123, -0.01748383417725563, 0.06940633058547974, -0.03330620750784874, -0.043201297521591187, 0.013279820792376995, -0.02257264219224453, 0.013674869202077389, 0.02554415352642536, -0.06228842958807945, 0.007639789022505283, 0.002321066102012992, -0.02459784969687462, 0.009175860323011875, -0.0009720272500999272, 0.014201721176505089, 0.0192366112023592, -0.007305143401026726, -0.048997342586517334, -0.04062063619494438, 0.01670951582491398, 0.030375303700566292, -0.019192352890968323, -0.0058827525936067104, 0.05846838280558586, 0.017091946676373482, -0.010990532115101814, -0.008656392805278301, -0.024140682071447372, -0.031693581491708755, -0.03177889436483383, -0.0011474430793896317, 0.029819190502166748, -0.022106962278485298, -0.0008611876983195543, 0.012181863188743591, 0.012956180609762669, -0.011281845159828663, -0.048448558896780014, -0.06280963867902756, 0.05644398555159569, -0.02111457847058773, 0.04149859398603439, 0.01792374812066555, -0.01632346585392952, 0.07433880120515823, 0.022098137065768242, 0.014413065277040005, -0.0019465143559500575, -0.008968527428805828, 0.0221864040941, 0.009980494156479836, 0.015122991055250168, 0.021614814177155495, -0.042140427976846695, -0.016313940286636353, -0.006442421115934849, 0.023783082142472267, 0.020461201667785645, 0.020933931693434715, 0.025459174066781998, -0.010410400107502937, 0.0015664295060560107, 0.011301892809569836, 0.03314737603068352, 0.004999171011149883, -0.036898449063301086, 0.004397497978061438, -0.047910843044519424, 0.04819595813751221, 0.036019209772348404, -0.10955661535263062, -0.02133893594145775, -0.0390377901494503, -0.006358050275593996, -0.012226518243551254, 0.0026428094133734703, 0.036688778549432755, -0.04320969060063362, 0.009711593389511108, 0.033815689384937286, 0.032924722880125046, -0.009374287910759449, -0.03549269959330559, 0.04105726629495621, 0.028755659237504005, -0.023492107167840004, 0.005162355024367571, -0.024640310555696487, -0.02687075361609459, 0.007452946621924639, -0.010800843127071857, 0.0045493901707232, 0.035471443086862564, 0.08021865785121918, 0.043527062982320786, -0.04866700619459152, -0.03308138996362686, 0.009147240780293941, -0.06818873435258865, -0.0067789009772241116, -0.001276781433261931, 0.04600534588098526, -0.02851817011833191, 0.03798896446824074, 0.006395015399903059, -0.03344704210758209, 0.013169640675187111, 0.029862351715564728, -0.03950314596295357, 0.003845911007374525, -0.03440321981906891, -0.02430390939116478, 0.00886791106313467, -0.015832822769880295, 0.05871151387691498, 0.042587317526340485, -0.0036900017876178026, -0.024392157793045044, 0.019577324390411377, -0.03739583119750023, 0.013869560323655605, -0.019055528566241264, -0.012646839953958988, 0.02986556477844715, -0.005038129165768623, -0.005164699628949165, -0.004262263420969248, 0.017495421692728996, 0.045649122446775436, 0.046912722289562225, -0.019152561202645302, -0.030736062675714493, 0.024286899715662003, 0.01654249057173729, 0.05796828493475914, 0.04790601134300232, 0.033426571637392044, -0.05532286688685417, 0.0376867912709713, -0.02008765935897827, 0.038497451692819595, 0.002336207078769803, -0.001840329496189952, -0.0025219267699867487, -0.02588975988328457, 0.0108097018674016, -0.009789961390197277, 0.01392007153481245, 0.022689657285809517, -0.0357830673456192, 0.07927022129297256, 0.002897213911637664, -0.0418417863547802, 0.0034083123318850994, 0.07594352960586548, 0.0006037261919118464, 0.01117126177996397, -0.03806869685649872, 0.014796932227909565, -0.020757688209414482, -0.0036490806378424168, 0.049377162009477615, 0.025429507717490196, 0.0032805949449539185, 0.012450193986296654, 0.02482137270271778, -0.02797151729464531, -0.04955613240599632, -0.01795964688062668, 0.038345497101545334, 0.04754757881164551, 0.015801038593053818, -0.031073272228240967, 0.05179438367486, 0.017310122027993202, 0.03163731098175049, 0.04932548850774765, 0.017702840268611908, -0.11261343955993652, 0.014909305609762669, 0.04653181880712509, 0.0455910749733448, -0.04859885573387146, -0.026350151747465134, -0.046816349029541016, 0.003186665242537856, 0.03014329820871353, -0.027448900043964386, -0.02335716411471367, -0.008106342516839504, 0.019499722868204117, -0.012097391299903393, -0.02449174039065838, -0.000856131489854306, -0.0006298942025750875, -0.02631787769496441, 0.002888764487579465, -0.006736460141837597, 0.004813844803720713, -0.009275760501623154, 0.0005503891152329743, 0.022267259657382965, 0.06500402092933655, -0.04254365339875221, -0.01109043974429369, 0.025610096752643585, 0.0340142548084259, -0.027477972209453583, -0.06337721645832062, 0.0043456582352519035, -0.0073199342004954815, 0.015794958919286728, 0.045091044157743454, 0.011506203562021255, -0.03917169198393822, 0.002349578309804201, 0.045669060200452805, -0.028086815029382706, 0.00110350688919425, -0.02577780745923519, 0.027553709223866463, 0.000009079919436771888, 0.018820801749825478, 0.04982991889119148, 0.025896668434143066, 0.018353736028075218, -0.0073508620262146, -0.029780445620417595, 0.024022288620471954, -0.04824701324105263, -0.024194998666644096, -0.06951645761728287, -0.011412410996854305, -0.011187766678631306, 0.0024757906794548035, -0.004826246295124292, 0.02162362076342106, -0.03253693878650665, -0.029751760885119438, 0.019331414252519608, 0.017096469178795815, -0.011858559213578701, 0.007407901808619499, -0.022330068051815033, 0.011727657169103622, -0.012309332378208637, -0.01421989407390356, -0.0005502908024936914, -0.0039070299826562405, 0.009039807133376598, 0.018254509195685387, -0.04733866825699806, -0.006826343014836311, -0.06195893883705139, -0.05556907132267952, 0.02641911432147026, -0.015055042691528797, 0.022653967142105103, -0.002014457480981946, 0.044034454971551895, -0.018245013430714607, -0.04260553792119026, 0.009568393230438232, 0.007813085801899433, 0.009359823539853096, 0.024184711277484894, -0.03718699887394905, 0.02286789007484913, 0.005947676487267017, 0.02251777984201908, -0.08129038661718369, -0.07548005878925323, 0.04400629922747612, 0.005347051192075014, -0.03922165185213089, -0.007367081008851528, 0.004884004592895508, -0.019900701940059662, -0.025959044694900513, -0.01595999300479889, 0.04085179790854454, 0.00873585231602192, -0.00883640255779028, -0.011564196087419987, -0.007960150018334389, 0.07546266168355942, -0.012086882255971432, -0.006640078034251928, 0.037375859916210175, -0.036098379641771317, 0.00041645963210612535, -0.003056106623262167, 0.025009553879499435, -0.019952839240431786, -0.003527552355080843, -0.04857983440160751, 0.012969126924872398, 0.04564250633120537, -0.007307287771254778, 0.009479058906435966, 0.01967635378241539, -0.028288522735238075, 0.019189510494470596, -0.052909888327121735, -0.025865893810987473, 0.006572634447365999, 0.048560842871665955, 0.005407681223005056, 0.028288723900914192, 0.02447734773159027, 0.012032095342874527, 0.020427517592906952, 0.007848765701055527, -0.010057348757982254, 0.0511709488928318, 0.03369501233100891, -0.025013402104377747, 0.021012455224990845, -0.017902206629514694, -0.016051780432462692, 0.01647227443754673, 0.01863127201795578, -0.026357034221291542, 0.01208270899951458, -0.0032952381297945976, -0.04512690007686615, -0.03490312024950981, -0.038579218089580536, 0.005272914655506611, 0.061490848660469055, -0.02193494141101837, 0.025089513510465622, 0.023393508046865463, -0.011401912197470665, -0.00220188545063138, 0.00220078369602561, -0.01687472127377987, -0.0009778294479474425, 0.016789764165878296, 0.011323712766170502, -0.015581809915602207, -0.0361628420650959, 0.05197245255112648, 0.00276884064078331, 0.012266327627003193, 0.021289145573973656, 0.015635734423995018, 0.04439537972211838, -0.017803309485316277, -0.02486165054142475, -0.021899832412600517, 0.017477335408329964, -0.022183096036314964, -0.004810204729437828, -0.026407582685351372, -0.016741279512643814, 0.06412924826145172, 0.013274522498250008, 0.04434569552540779, -0.0024161669425666332, -0.01027711946517229, -0.040276773273944855, 0.004417875315994024, 0.04483551159501076, 0.02861233986914158, 0.040917541831731796, -0.04331373795866966, 0.03620884194970131, 0.009189684875309467, 0.009576509706676006, -0.044742561876773834, -0.08106538653373718, -0.03329279273748398, -0.011005228385329247, -0.04700065404176712, 0.04095970094203949, 0.04742954298853874, -0.014433580450713634, -0.009228333830833435, -0.02102084271609783, 0.005434712395071983, 0.017897432669997215, 0.05691203474998474, -0.02255024015903473, 0.07902351766824722, 0.04665374383330345, 0.014601284638047218, 0.0041407812386751175, 0.03045487403869629, 0.11615610122680664, 0.06728312373161316, 0.011637339368462563, -0.05236060917377472, 0.005051476880908012, 0.009079878218472004, 0.005536626558750868, 0.017212724313139915, 0.036413129419088364, 0.004559837747365236, -0.04342886433005333, 0.08093234151601791, 0.025824135169386864, -0.02033807709813118, -0.007255273405462503, 0.055558010935783386, 0.012921013869345188, -0.0410640574991703, -0.010336085222661495, -0.019426871091127396, -0.001455041579902172, -0.022158462554216385, -0.036673516035079956, 0.023455815389752388, 0.026699481531977654, -0.03142701834440231, -0.016561046242713928, -0.0034176826011389494, -0.021434301510453224, 0.041987475007772446, -0.00632411427795887, 0.031992457807064056, 0.01664840057492256, 0.03513118252158165, -0.04095529392361641, -0.020058264955878258, -0.014340040273964405, -0.035819292068481445, -0.008820717222988605, 0.03548145666718483, -0.055684514343738556, 0.00004678684854297899, -0.012384668923914433, 0.01864137127995491, -0.06240610405802727, -0.03538236394524574, -0.008991784416139126, 0.018150432035326958, 0.007332239765673876, 0.04407556354999542, -0.05426626279950142, -0.012930751778185368, -0.005600213073194027, -0.03837587311863899, -0.007576932664960623, 0.014000671915709972, 0.002728709252551198, -0.010595368221402168, -0.02495628409087658, -0.028958631679415703, 0.02997244894504547, -0.044150952249765396, 0.017260421067476273, 0.041976235806941986, -0.028957026079297066, -0.017670759931206703, -0.032578837126493454, 0.003208692418411374, 0.004787779413163662, 0.019809866324067116, 0.002440432319417596, 0.032225705683231354, -0.0318773090839386, -0.0024624646175652742, 0.0260726660490036, 0.018580950796604156, 0.03698727488517761, -0.018139511346817017, 0.005864008795469999, -0.0042685880325734615, -0.051021695137023926, 0.029469000175595284, -0.0008082929416559637, -0.0326475091278553, -0.02313089556992054, -0.012905560433864594, -0.0011038758093491197, 0.03984900563955307, -0.03151300176978111, 0.005088722333312035, 0.014400594867765903, 0.036364100873470306, -0.02321866899728775, -0.020542675629258156, -0.0303654745221138, 0.013389809988439083, -0.02009022794663906, 0.0020949835889041424, -0.01788952201604843, 0.030286403372883797, 0.006224282085895538, 0.03379124775528908, 0.016056355088949203, 0.02794668637216091, 0.027723902836441994, 0.03530152142047882, -0.0002927681489381939, -0.0682656466960907, 0.00999944657087326, -0.019609881564974785, 0.015054558403789997, -0.05314356088638306, -0.023456841707229614, -0.012748531065881252, -0.0357612743973732, 0.018723631277680397, -0.005371791310608387, -0.018417298793792725, 0.02030734159052372, -0.027969935908913612, -0.008253215812146664, -0.012016314081847668, -0.005792143288999796, -0.038761816918849945, -0.023423533886671066, 0.017673630267381668, -0.006653668358922005, -0.011733220890164375, -0.009347536601126194, -0.005252115428447723, 0.03167014941573143, 0.004853223916143179, -0.018517090007662773, -0.033425480127334595, 0.039045095443725586, -0.01319457683712244, -0.007547431159764528, 0.02960660494863987, -0.04461429640650749, 0.011908089742064476, 0.051490847021341324, -0.055360257625579834, -0.02528638392686844, 0.002863231347873807, -0.00847786758095026, 0.0430767759680748, 0.0339510515332222, -0.022417303174734116, -0.0022317329421639442, 0.02821432612836361, -0.04952560365200043, -0.01964108645915985, -0.038645051419734955, 0.02384508214890957, 0.00924383383244276, 0.005589123349636793, 0.006102248560637236, 0.013809103518724442, 0.015201372094452381, 0.04679317772388458, 0.03496403992176056, -0.00874291080981493, 0.006814248859882355, 0.02276485040783882, 0.06525086611509323, 0.008716044947504997, 0.0014082167763262987, 0.02941424772143364, 0.03164231777191162, 0.06249074265360832, 0.0026928193401545286, 0.05028607323765755, -0.006800017785280943, 0.022825395688414574, -0.08133482933044434, -0.045295290648937225, -0.03008056804537773, 0.026252003386616707, 0.01510065421462059, -0.007615214213728905, -0.03829533979296684, 0.012456397525966167, -0.04719432443380356, 0.022792311385273933, -0.028089402243494987, -0.00010961643420159817, -0.03759782388806343, 0.020566748455166817, -0.004094378557056189, 0.02045634016394615, 0.03195653483271599, 0.030399063602089882, 0.019960522651672363, 0.0197293758392334, 0.047660425305366516, 0.005772687029093504, -0.013232049532234669, 0.0398726761341095, -0.00937629770487547, -0.0840347558259964, -0.012191465124487877, -0.02537224255502224, -0.05281220003962517, 0.0185877475887537, -0.004310326185077429, 0.06274436414241791, 0.03912907466292381, 0.03471671789884567, -0.01659982092678547, 0.04818115755915642, 0.04840192198753357, -0.00891103781759739, -0.01190570555627346, 0.014041107147932053, 0.015819810330867767, 0.04878474399447441, -0.009976672008633614, 0.03163093328475952, 0.06022720783948898, -0.033900078386068344, 0.015598403289914131, 0.016318591311573982, -0.024534273892641068, -0.029567386955022812, 0.009876222349703312, -0.0003911800740752369, -0.029817966744303703, 0.003282018704339862, 0.03126341104507446, -0.04863911494612694, 0.024557117372751236, 0.050557225942611694, -0.0112874461337924, 0.011196442879736423, -0.0016240786062553525, -0.04806416109204292, -0.029507385566830635, 0.009547133930027485, 0.017290165647864342, -0.008667411282658577, -0.04838791862130165, -0.003913399297744036, -0.014802316203713417, -0.025822987779974937, -0.0006991266272962093, 0.017750270664691925, -0.014692231081426144, 0.0547616071999073, -0.013254773803055286, -0.010087613947689533, -0.0015133528504520655, -0.017455123364925385, 0.012022454291582108, -0.05272190645337105, 0.045874014496803284, 0.01812918670475483, -0.034825582057237625, -0.06169396638870239, -0.003633607644587755, -0.01532450970262289, 0.009868997149169445, 0.04305041953921318, 0.03199153020977974, 0.018248964101076126, -0.04636922851204872, 0.014388377778232098, 0.023702464997768402, -0.055347688496112823, 0.04242129996418953, -0.036211464554071426, -0.013322612270712852, 0.0004034833691548556, -0.011192569509148598, -0.023049216717481613, -0.016793273389339447, 0.020831113681197166, -0.017155170440673828, 0.057654909789562225, 0.00960972998291254, 0.01405089907348156, 0.03726267069578171, 0.05703511834144592, -0.022378424182534218, 0.05231228098273277, -0.04321376234292984, 0.01183538231998682, 0.0393456295132637, 0.0015329754678532481, -0.05128193274140358, 0.0038060001097619534, -0.06840436905622482, -0.004389377310872078, 0.0086313895881176, 0.0010644065914675593, 0.002516659442335367, -0.050039876252412796, 0.027176782488822937, 0.053116947412490845, -0.06706716120243073, 0.026670897379517555, 0.05347755551338196, 0.027200959622859955, 0.02475596033036709, -0.05309835821390152, -0.014924122020602226, 0.028703106567263603, -0.04755445197224617, -0.022422362118959427, -0.016781972721219063, -0.018577666953206062, 0.00354585750028491, 0.010825716890394688, 0.0380115807056427, -0.008909802883863449, 0.012574449181556702, 0.01686924137175083, 0.03170878440141678, -0.03678948059678078, -0.048879995942115784, -0.023792104795575142, -0.006749579217284918, 0.016217714175581932, 0.013186035677790642, -0.000223528069909662, 0.06497617810964584, 0.00938112847507, 0.008055482991039753, -0.05664428323507309, -0.027495790272951126, -0.012497739866375923, 0.008745674043893814, 0.003974803723394871, -0.010092837736010551, -0.011142808012664318, 0.005363665986806154, -0.05474505573511124, 0.017461644485592842, 0.04525101184844971, -0.04061047360301018, 0.04960452392697334, -0.01956702023744583, -0.00585420336574316, -0.04089006781578064, -0.022685052827000618, -0.02057350054383278, -0.02284996770322323, -0.0015716520138084888, 0.020371565595269203, 0.04404586926102638, -0.02070648781955242, -0.006593381054699421, -0.018400896340608597, 0.005212361458688974, -0.0560377836227417, -0.030771205201745033, -0.041050318628549576, -0.00048361060908064246, 0.008870519697666168, 0.019754163920879364 ]
<p>What is meant by subscripting the expectation with some distribution, e.g. $\mathrm{E_{f}}[h(X)]$? </p> <p>If it's any help, here's the context:</p> <p>In M.C. Simulation, we wanted </p> <blockquote> <p>$\mathrm{E[h(X)] = \int{h(x)f(x)dx}}$ </p> </blockquote> <p>so we used the law of large numbers and central limit theorem based on samples:</p> <blockquote> <p>$\frac{1}{n} \sum_{i=1}^{n}h(X_i) \longrightarrow E_{f}[h(X)]$, with $X_{1}, \ldots, X_{n} \sim f$</p> </blockquote>
73,405
[ -0.007040239404886961, -0.02342190220952034, 0.003743459703400731, -0.050221092998981476, 0.03729576617479324, 0.00345651526004076, -0.019842566922307014, 0.019278157502412796, 0.027037963271141052, -0.03965448588132858, 0.030063314363360405, 0.0360807441174984, 0.06545553356409073, -0.009288930334150791, 0.03918222337961197, 0.02962551638484001, -0.005422563292086124, 0.0020887102000415325, -0.01552800927311182, -0.04100686311721802, 0.015315218828618526, 0.04438282921910286, 0.028593523427844048, -0.025217760354280472, -0.02778656780719757, 0.05995851382613182, 0.022502558305859566, -0.027105802670121193, 0.05223584547638893, 0.08080678433179855, -0.049744222313165665, -0.020815828815102577, 0.01554450299590826, 0.00838727317750454, -0.018435277044773102, 0.005818827543407679, -0.02561360038816929, -0.052759863436222076, 0.017051490023732185, 0.01932680793106556, -0.06515143811702728, 0.0097579974681139, 0.03438640385866165, 0.029315665364265442, -0.023127565160393715, 0.008706573396921158, -0.032278817147016525, -0.043265193700790405, 0.008100460283458233, -0.03559349104762077, 0.04827488586306572, 0.011730016209185123, 0.05946148931980133, 0.02352426014840603, -0.009395042434334755, 0.014435632154345512, 0.021778417751193047, 0.06277961283922195, 0.01995190978050232, -0.042824629694223404, -0.013446596451103687, -0.03806266933679581, 0.027301762253046036, -0.05321413651108742, -0.021023983135819435, 0.01806391030550003, 0.012960702180862427, -0.03857925906777382, 0.013906454667448997, 0.006618252489715815, 0.0035466980189085007, 0.03068995289504528, 0.024806587025523186, -0.024385791271924973, 0.04206351935863495, -0.019963977858424187, 0.027854233980178833, -0.00019141504890285432, 0.05510079488158226, 0.021358275786042213, 0.023051472380757332, 0.0023469384759664536, 0.041789762675762177, 0.01577446050941944, 0.007138228975236416, 0.015199090354144573, 0.06578316539525986, -0.004464509431272745, 0.05384796857833862, 0.004925267770886421, -0.03055107221007347, 0.0739436000585556, 0.04227430000901222, -0.04887674003839493, -0.02642548643052578, 0.02410738170146942, -0.006025249138474464, 0.038056936115026474, -0.006045661401003599, -0.026710854843258858, -0.05417189747095108, -0.05278133600950241, 0.022384731099009514, 0.0291808620095253, 0.0060806586407125, -0.019704345613718033, -0.02826947346329689, -0.01395132765173912, -0.008578159846365452, -0.01422128640115261, 0.013285099528729916, 0.04326672479510307, 0.0029903443064540625, 0.019416358321905136, 0.0031652022153139114, 0.027342695742845535, 0.03079800307750702, 0.008795702829957008, 0.03266902267932892, 0.035404231399297714, 0.05183850973844528, -0.024129007011651993, 0.04398230463266373, -0.012960489839315414, -0.10545582324266434, 0.023547396063804626, -0.006178766023367643, 0.010972855612635612, -0.06420591473579407, 0.017662914469838142, 0.04946594312787056, -0.03301072493195534, 0.01351980771869421, 0.03510729596018791, -0.002159460913389921, -0.028149669989943504, -0.07122766226530075, -0.06201055273413658, 0.03738408908247948, -0.030708633363246918, -0.008732353337109089, -0.04189946502447128, 0.011628469452261925, 0.025566089898347855, 0.019863901659846306, 0.028919288888573647, 0.04210062325000763, -0.006064539775252342, -0.0030991514213383198, 0.014680439606308937, 0.013111802749335766, -0.03943569213151932, -0.010126080363988876, 0.003037447575479746, -0.001504932763054967, -0.06591328233480453, 0.014619742520153522, 0.03702135011553764, -0.05953322723507881, -0.010604164563119411, 0.06631608307361603, -0.00958456564694643, -0.0027775492053478956, -0.017779329791665077, -0.022802457213401794, -0.058538954704999924, 0.059930913150310516, 0.022732961922883987, 0.037031009793281555, 0.027309151366353035, 0.0010588964214548469, 0.020281057804822922, -0.021878372877836227, 0.04697566479444504, 0.0825096145272255, -0.013183916918933392, 0.0033366794232279062, -0.012326872907578945, 0.03016621619462967, 0.004767212085425854, -0.02428985945880413, -0.028268123045563698, 0.043690137565135956, 0.00988629087805748, 0.02154383808374405, -0.0005937914829701185, 0.02149813622236252, -0.018031680956482887, 0.018355103209614754, -0.04191947728395462, -0.06006575748324394, -0.05726206302642822, -0.0016455487348139286, 0.00034810046781785786, -0.024307403713464737, 0.004160222131758928, -0.032484520226716995, 0.008405333384871483, -0.01409721840173006, -0.013536309823393822, -0.015125221572816372, -0.013551142998039722, 0.032859187573194504, -0.04749105125665665, 0.00712738698348403, 0.030461261048913002, 0.040249716490507126, 0.002969310851767659, 0.04616061970591545, -0.047247882932424545, -0.03576517477631569, 0.008222909644246101, -0.02195655182003975, 0.02866564504802227, -0.008120684884488583, -0.03574645146727562, 0.0009432132355868816, -0.03185690939426422, 0.016896221786737442, 0.04679189994931221, -0.06745059043169022, 0.021540826186537743, 0.07204456627368927, 0.029660478234291077, 0.013023734092712402, 0.03761754184961319, 0.03805939480662346, 0.024953745305538177, -0.009728686884045601, -0.05268867686390877, -0.04305532947182655, -0.014504688791930676, 0.06491782516241074, 0.022105418145656586, -0.029941190034151077, -0.004907445982098579, 0.08283889293670654, -0.005105385556817055, 0.023009954020380974, 0.03515370190143585, 0.0037703390698879957, -0.011325355619192123, 0.014407742768526077, 0.028094952926039696, 0.040477488189935684, -0.019145986065268517, 0.000990293687209487, 0.014508835040032864, 0.061519041657447815, 0.008419318124651909, -0.0014283520868048072, 0.027972744777798653, -0.01990567520260811, 0.045659370720386505, -0.007726305164396763, 0.003308422164991498, -0.005283302627503872, -0.05243123322725296, 0.00890873558819294, -0.020447714254260063, -0.003436424070969224, 0.023077983409166336, 0.010776027105748653, -0.037102408707141876, -0.016497096046805382, 0.03549262881278992, -0.04483042284846306, -0.007203489542007446, 0.030747082084417343, -0.04409858211874962, 0.007500666659325361, -0.020698560401797295, -0.04981064796447754, -0.019693193957209587, -0.002015625825151801, 0.03521741181612015, -0.008623682893812656, 0.0026708717923611403, -0.016741067171096802, -0.022143173962831497, -0.01930149458348751, -0.02197585627436638, 0.0495329275727272, 0.004007216077297926, -0.016932370141148567, 0.017587775364518166, -0.024416595697402954, -0.05396980047225952, 0.020833507180213928, -0.014992869459092617, -0.029153212904930115, 0.01054388377815485, 0.007221714593470097, -0.03779192641377449, -0.026985788717865944, 0.021795345470309258, -0.009449685923755169, 0.016578257083892822, -0.03532165288925171, 0.08396420627832413, 0.006635194644331932, -0.0078496765345335, 0.030311139300465584, -0.04149331524968147, -0.026129448786377907, -0.059067945927381516, -0.02083088643848896, 0.00018007347534876317, 0.005333652254194021, 0.07855591922998428, 0.03793109208345413, -0.019010202959179878, -0.018166882917284966, -0.040373630821704865, -0.04617588222026825, -0.0070062242448329926, -0.016771115362644196, 0.015812240540981293, -0.002089159330353141, -0.008090732619166374, 0.06793692708015442, 0.012253676541149616, 0.002991343615576625, 0.0033594255801290274, -0.024017363786697388, 0.017415005713701248, -0.05177515000104904, 0.029277026653289795, 0.01644628681242466, -0.0028644441626966, 0.031146196648478508, 0.015684008598327637, 0.01945275440812111, 0.016370054334402084, -0.016962135210633278, 0.022108377888798714, 0.014006270095705986, -0.03257784619927406, 0.00856475904583931, 0.052455659955739975, 0.02190832421183586, 0.006316399667412043, 0.012044853530824184, -0.0015239398926496506, 0.02984151430428028, 0.013685275800526142, -0.01685500703752041, 0.053016871213912964, -0.023666685447096825, 0.014496199786663055, -0.04403813183307648, 0.02827552519738674, 0.016093716025352478, -0.059180453419685364, -0.005347835831344128, 0.012038169428706169, -0.014372077770531178, -0.046145010739564896, 0.010550892911851406, 0.028064830228686333, 0.039934489876031876, -0.045404065400362015, -0.02375669963657856, -0.015133543871343136, -0.008091870695352554, 0.009448363445699215, -0.013671820051968098, -0.04490140452980995, 0.035651542246341705, 0.08284617215394974, -0.009466277435421944, -0.002466305159032345, -0.05058653652667999, -0.014984803274273872, -0.05814633145928383, -0.011673490516841412, 0.0006987895467318594, 0.05266867205500603, 0.017216606065630913, 0.04548133537173271, 0.007769847754389048, 0.004243082366883755, 0.005773452110588551, 0.0049904026091098785, -0.06718822568655014, 0.024969469755887985, 0.02149907685816288, -0.02112705446779728, -0.05377154052257538, -0.007273483090102673, 0.06092139333486557, 0.008259761147201061, 0.01544447336345911, -0.02698991633951664, -0.003385217161849141, -0.03898502513766289, 0.014296178705990314, -0.022933021187782288, -0.020746316760778427, -0.05139471963047981, -0.012181215919554234, 0.0348292775452137, -0.0029953753110021353, 0.03336789831519127, 0.009830256924033165, -0.022386202588677406, -0.03890121355652809, -0.015664784237742424, 0.02565518394112587, 0.02423049323260784, 0.02485719881951809, 0.010782020166516304, 0.00019530807912815362, -0.023229554295539856, 0.055208321660757065, 0.057256221771240234, 0.11253343522548676, 0.04035324603319168, -0.03916962444782257, 0.01576780527830124, -0.02277025394141674, -0.018927035853266716, 0.025296177715063095, -0.012050650082528591, 0.006160006858408451, -0.006290155928581953, 0.06866656243801117, 0.01611986942589283, -0.015109622851014137, 0.02973853424191475, 0.05243826285004616, 0.020030811429023743, 0.02441389113664627, -0.03517992049455643, 0.03476278856396675, 0.00020577922987286001, 0.011333871632814407, 0.020462071523070335, -0.0031165960244834423, -0.014014046639204025, 0.009889498353004456, 0.05496861785650253, -0.0037748178001493216, -0.01711764931678772, -0.0041319564916193485, -0.012455824762582779, 0.031205439940094948, 0.008489007130265236, -0.03730129078030586, 0.015349531546235085, 0.01841152273118496, 0.020103158429265022, 0.0604388453066349, -0.017541006207466125, -0.06528165191411972, 0.01712154783308506, 0.018891591578722, 0.034472256898880005, -0.02569618634879589, 0.020155632868409157, -0.049598805606365204, 0.03876825422048569, 0.023700309917330742, -0.026986027136445045, -0.015332694165408611, -0.06298128515481949, 0.03358316421508789, -0.001169076538644731, -0.018034327775239944, -0.043493401259183884, 0.013991033658385277, -0.005544403567910194, 0.021168788895010948, -0.0398503802716732, -0.007474573794752359, -0.033547770231962204, -0.019784042611718178, 0.021542714908719063, 0.07902607321739197, -0.024798337370157242, -0.04232000559568405, -0.007912867702543736, 0.04939698800444603, -0.007303576450794935, -0.07311545312404633, 0.004617512691766024, -0.01584506779909134, 0.021823376417160034, 0.023033004254102707, -0.04903390258550644, -0.06580712646245956, 0.04034149646759033, -0.00017615150136407465, 0.012962311506271362, 0.01301527675241232, -0.010919167660176754, 0.05177832022309303, 0.03494283929467201, 0.007291827350854874, 0.07519825547933578, 0.03367834538221359, 0.019520603120326996, 0.03770589828491211, -0.01921849325299263, 0.012513612397015095, -0.046639129519462585, -0.006508140824735165, -0.04559927433729172, -0.007077811751514673, -0.02504761517047882, -0.010172554291784763, 0.01347346417605877, 0.0571289099752903, -0.0061583137139678, -0.06014260649681091, -0.00560030248016119, 0.015044867992401123, 0.0006031238008290529, -0.02469082921743393, 0.00770663982257247, 0.029576361179351807, 0.027919214218854904, -0.010059881955385208, 0.01179913617670536, -0.009056237526237965, 0.017601028084754944, 0.011214063502848148, -0.01347652543336153, -0.015394136309623718, -0.04336494952440262, -0.049964386969804764, 0.042066484689712524, -0.030616171658039093, 0.02693532221019268, -0.01702236570417881, 0.029034288600087166, -0.025807835161685944, -0.027000166475772858, -0.028017491102218628, -0.019606418907642365, 0.00027239008340984583, 0.010496709495782852, -0.06510782986879349, 0.039458222687244415, 0.010824942030012608, 0.009176627732813358, -0.046744223684072495, -0.03311212733387947, -0.008826582692563534, -0.0038548344746232033, 0.005151497200131416, -0.0364108607172966, -0.0370028018951416, 0.01151073258370161, -0.029296275228261948, -0.015095830895006657, 0.04013980180025101, -0.00919351913034916, -0.01935969851911068, -0.010421794839203358, -0.015047891065478325, 0.08437462896108627, 0.014751747250556946, 0.0035554610658437014, 0.037102364003658295, -0.012079338543117046, -0.03199537843465805, 0.011310710571706295, 0.019280316308140755, -0.00646534189581871, 0.009620830416679382, -0.01507736649364233, 0.010215999558568, 0.0028606420382857323, -0.02388731762766838, -0.002185631077736616, 0.030550114810466766, 0.04015762731432915, 0.015476305037736893, -0.03825462982058525, -0.022231709212064743, 0.003111626021564007, 0.02790432795882225, 0.003341468283906579, 0.018255185335874557, 0.005941665265709162, -0.00831750500947237, 0.01348955649882555, 0.006964553613215685, 0.04565924033522606, -0.011469991877675056, 0.07043324410915375, -0.003195409895852208, 0.01974829100072384, 0.03252388909459114, -0.0049597336910665035, 0.028264842927455902, 0.0011082419659942389, 0.004880813416093588, 0.02150828205049038, 0.04078071564435959, 0.0022954903542995453, -0.029191115871071815, -0.06456034630537033, 0.018000898882746696, -0.004038920160382986, 0.008031453937292099, 0.07132375985383987, -0.00242612580768764, -0.057217102497816086, 0.011399675160646439, -0.04912324622273445, -0.02147524058818817, -0.005402270704507828, -0.016907382756471634, 0.036150023341178894, -0.016145918518304825, 0.000505022588185966, 0.05039548873901367, 0.01014587190002203, 0.016613617539405823, 0.028225380927324295, 0.0023997523821890354, 0.020945994183421135, -0.013983923010528088, -0.018101980909705162, -0.03760217875242233, 0.041916683316230774, -0.054695915430784225, 0.00826821569353342, -0.0611061155796051, -0.019200317561626434, 0.0387529656291008, 0.021451406180858612, 0.004083428997546434, -0.05588668957352638, 0.018944285809993744, -0.018921392038464546, -0.02054116502404213, 0.0319400280714035, -0.035308800637722015, 0.02485327236354351, -0.023225726559758186, 0.04374944046139717, 0.021345335990190506, 0.005275435280054808, -0.0051847463473677635, -0.08565954118967056, -0.03558748960494995, -0.03812229633331299, -0.03636502847075462, 0.03166546672582626, -0.020741386339068413, -0.008743390440940857, 0.01146534364670515, -0.002045979490503669, 0.017937367781996727, -0.02049405872821808, 0.0025718403048813343, -0.020388782024383545, 0.08824967592954636, 0.02591163106262684, 0.034117691218853, -0.0012269282015040517, -0.009377837181091309, 0.11146367341279984, 0.03646552562713623, 0.018219582736492157, -0.032133039087057114, 0.008885153569281101, -0.016421444714069366, 0.008326083421707153, -0.0032010453287512064, -0.007943836972117424, 0.0018546113278716803, 0.00684626679867506, 0.006321116350591183, 0.049125224351882935, 0.004954192787408829, -0.00783193577080965, 0.026761839166283607, -0.03169038146734238, -0.0164171289652586, -0.022793663665652275, 0.01459899079054594, -0.02054676041007042, 0.004448631312698126, -0.09639156609773636, -0.00955360010266304, -0.006141715217381716, 0.012050695717334747, -0.015615328215062618, -0.011608726345002651, 0.008014033548533916, 0.05793657898902893, -0.00535500468686223, -0.0441993810236454, 0.028229327872395515, -0.03880153223872185, -0.00828254222869873, 0.0005046637961640954, 0.031535979360342026, -0.009784595109522343, 0.008667908608913422, 0.01057536993175745, 0.0064804875291883945, -0.019009824842214584, -0.04346679523587227, -0.0033418808598071337, -0.033717624843120575, -0.02045774832367897, -0.0023869886063039303, 0.02712109498679638, -0.03529694676399231, -0.008694601245224476, -0.026623206213116646, -0.029152914881706238, 0.0008281568298116326, -0.04372433200478554, 0.025321872904896736, -0.005026934202760458, 0.01909831166267395, -0.04061037674546242, -0.04587315768003464, -0.04353225976228714, 0.03334732726216316, -0.0158159788697958, 0.015389014035463333, 0.046694066375494, -0.050101615488529205, 0.0004577714134939015, -0.018543897196650505, -0.000019834049453493208, -0.02505515143275261, -0.028283359482884407, 0.029546279460191727, -0.007047588005661964, -0.06391757726669312, -0.03157782182097435, -0.022126803174614906, -0.04707327485084534, 0.05714348331093788, 0.005629074294120073, 0.02854863367974758, -0.03825565427541733, -0.030209021642804146, 0.01764856092631817, -0.042410701513290405, -0.012572775594890118, -0.04800626263022423, -0.026217760518193245, 0.010274901986122131, 0.04169677570462227, 0.021601932123303413, -0.02141650952398777, 0.013293164782226086, 0.04427531734108925, 0.03142789006233215, -0.025428222492337227, -0.014863344840705395, 0.03764691203832626, -0.000693733396474272, -0.014654719270765781, -0.025571303442120552, 0.05610110983252525, 0.013997641392052174, -0.03716306388378143, -0.010779944248497486, 0.008834506385028362, 0.004822510294616222, 0.019914381206035614, -0.026035837829113007, -0.011248773895204067, 0.04298008605837822, -0.00548273092135787, 0.037693753838539124, -0.026834974065423012, 0.003469608025625348, -0.012806643731892109, 0.01432518009096384, 0.006675397511571646, 0.02085784636437893, -0.029636017978191376, 0.0028487720992416143, -0.02706681378185749, 0.03678562864661217, -0.03542701154947281, -0.005492248106747866, -0.0025861519388854504, -0.011298798024654388, 0.015493499115109444, -0.022298255935311317, -0.04124922677874565, -0.0054288264364004135, -0.026621293276548386, -0.010217435657978058, 0.030128050595521927, 0.011960688978433609, -0.023030171170830727, -0.023874877020716667, 0.024185702204704285, -0.04524112120270729, -0.011215116828680038, 0.0005965607706457376, -0.012014959007501602, 0.05445506051182747, -0.04546215385198593, -0.0269843190908432, 0.026623345911502838, 0.030428703874349594, 0.03813730180263519, 0.03922664001584053, -0.017248030751943588, -0.024270540103316307, 0.019236795604228973, -0.056705836206674576, -0.016648419201374054, -0.0014632638776674867, -0.0249175988137722, 0.005095404107123613, -0.0146002983674407, 0.014467793516814709, 0.010936192236840725, 0.00948844663798809, 0.024411004036664963, 0.03224126622080803, 0.010477447882294655, -0.024371352046728134, 0.03963581472635269, 0.022883020341396332, 0.01014514360576868, 0.00317001692019403, -0.0030571925453841686, 0.012763969600200653, 0.03738831356167793, -0.06244420260190964, 0.0339115709066391, -0.02840781770646572, -0.02495010755956173, -0.06603744626045227, -0.05893814191222191, 0.027643823996186256, -0.03738950937986374, 0.055489495396614075, -0.030182376503944397, -0.030897583812475204, 0.01397385448217392, -0.03392864018678665, -0.0037680233363062143, -0.011991580948233604, -0.0025144917890429497, -0.030843667685985565, -0.021115023642778397, 0.006975763011723757, 0.04362933710217476, 0.0012701761443167925, -0.01336301676928997, 0.02000461332499981, 0.006355131510645151, 0.009194137528538704, -0.013593848794698715, -0.024453410878777504, 0.016561731696128845, -0.01650150492787361, -0.03977798670530319, 0.06032935529947281, -0.02338082157075405, -0.020420240238308907, 0.026970678940415382, 0.03400888666510582, -0.01771167665719986, 0.01674308069050312, 0.0009972038678824902, 0.02008260041475296, 0.05657867342233658, 0.03580055013298988, -0.00452312920242548, 0.016556086018681526, 0.03513535112142563, 0.01887814886868, 0.0038245501928031445, 0.04169990122318268, -0.029474135488271713, 0.01116630807518959, -0.012931172735989094, -0.021488577127456665, 0.04485306888818741, 0.007067802827805281, -0.03404517099261284, -0.03459572792053223, -0.00016562410746701062, 0.014816142618656158, -0.02907070890069008, 0.07550224661827087, 0.015265809372067451, 0.0024045524187386036, 0.02867230586707592, -0.014941095374524593, -0.023094359785318375, -0.021199621260166168, 0.004077624063938856, -0.05185932666063309, 0.04352748021483421, 0.019759543240070343, -0.061340779066085815, -0.046064335852861404, -0.03777391463518143, 0.006230596452951431, 0.012011950835585594, -0.008199787698686123, -0.009570290334522724, -0.045787837356328964, 0.02674267627298832, 0.0029528613667935133, 0.014175278134644032, 0.012175709940493107, -0.058691494166851044, 0.014241247437894344, -0.0770486518740654, 0.06907880306243896, -0.0072539509274065495, -0.016761386767029762, -0.04426994547247887, -0.02393644116818905, -0.007148298900574446, -0.03797603026032448, 0.06098903343081474, 0.06436570733785629, -0.02275729551911354, 0.000255483144428581, 0.05487670749425888, 0.026452919468283653, -0.051199622452259064, 0.02218180149793625, 0.0061800493858754635, -0.008127667009830475, -0.001914238091558218, 0.020751863718032837, 0.00008748296386329457, 0.013706924393773079, 0.0021888676565140486, 0.0017333494033664465, 0.015005332417786121, 0.0017182783922180533, -0.004016796592622995, 0.037732433527708054, 0.022944236174225807, 0.0009664504323154688, 0.05944560468196869, -0.02270590513944626, 0.004341613035649061, -0.017767928540706635, -0.005743090063333511, -0.0671115592122078, -0.01477112341672182, -0.04938703775405884, -0.013695856556296349, 0.005413440987467766, 0.012901706621050835, 0.02898387424647808, -0.04201998561620712, -0.009061594493687153, 0.020175723358988762, -0.026543864980340004, -0.0005260431207716465, 0.06547155976295471, 0.0554652065038681, 0.039525315165519714, 0.009246943518519402, 0.020940126851201057, 0.005216261371970177, -0.021099738776683807, -0.0011733814608305693, 0.014063087292015553, 0.015899822115898132, -0.038973256945610046, 0.050913937389850616, 0.010627306066453457, -0.037569742649793625, 0.010383187793195248, 0.02322281524538994, 0.03789900243282318, -0.029620951041579247, -0.02038046345114708, -0.0030296198092401028, -0.018932322040200233, -0.008793383836746216, 0.00795965176075697, -0.039176736027002335, 0.06661425530910492, 0.009325043298304081, 0.0006240463117137551, -0.03435607627034187, 0.03322851285338402, -0.029980085790157318, -0.00881160143762827, 0.008471553213894367, 0.0377628356218338, -0.00004355556666268967, -0.02016010694205761, -0.0046084485948085785, 0.006335774436593056, 0.022356564179062843, -0.03312672674655914, 0.036494310945272446, 0.03881866857409477, -0.014818103052675724, -0.04569104686379433, -0.010411716066300869, 0.007461038418114185, -0.016645580530166626, -0.025571122765541077, 0.01882701925933361, 0.02057570591568947, 0.026073096320033073, -0.03670180216431618, 0.027996337041258812, 0.02333047054708004, -0.047667987644672394, 0.015241830609738827, -0.01706514321267605, 0.0075153689831495285, 0.03503593057394028, -0.02396678552031517 ]
<p>I have a dataset that is clearly increasing as time goes on (exchange rate of a currency, monthly data over 20 years), my question is: Can I detrend the data and then difference it also to make it stationary, if the detrending in itself doesn't achieve this? And if so, would this be considered twice differenced, or just detrended and once differenced? </p>
35,763
[ -0.016342895105481148, 0.0010495848255231977, -0.019498592242598534, 0.03065989725291729, 0.02168823406100273, 0.011227899231016636, -0.04433733597397804, -0.0194469653069973, -0.0098809152841568, -0.028336400166153908, 0.01888931915163994, -0.014178406447172165, 0.02939891628921032, -0.007997863925993443, 0.021963289007544518, -0.0004216890374664217, -0.009120533242821693, 0.02251354791224003, -0.0030102243181318045, -0.014665301889181137, 0.00036722185905091465, 0.03307677432894707, 0.018437782302498817, -0.021567290648818016, -0.04150610417127609, 0.040002819150686264, 0.013356371782720089, -0.008561648428440094, -0.014032429084181786, 0.057073093950748444, -0.049403589218854904, -0.03270212560892105, 0.014698510989546776, 0.04699213057756424, 0.056021615862846375, 0.03590570390224457, -0.0524994395673275, -0.028049247339367867, -0.017987269908189774, 0.05015769973397255, -0.0342206172645092, -0.006823699921369553, -0.01909974403679371, 0.06989733129739761, 0.0032146021258085966, -0.014723081141710281, 0.0014566192403435707, -0.010571046732366085, 0.03661167249083519, 0.006821425631642342, 0.07497682422399521, -0.03706308826804161, 0.025289367884397507, 0.04549512639641762, -0.021879656240344048, 0.007253021467477083, 0.061302922666072845, 0.031076988205313683, -0.0029362314380705357, -0.03491371497511864, -0.037448760122060776, -0.013654058799147606, 0.008701477199792862, 0.026477469131350517, -0.028969891369342804, -0.0009291292517445982, -0.011929076164960861, -0.006656402722001076, 0.049054838716983795, -0.020746631547808647, 0.0319405235350132, 0.008896281942725182, 0.030362119898200035, -0.05150337889790535, -0.009040199220180511, -0.020788028836250305, 0.029618363827466965, 0.0015652349684387445, 0.025198478251695633, 0.026611046865582466, 0.012847334146499634, -0.003029353218153119, 0.05572797358036041, 0.06565158814191818, 0.06360968202352524, -0.014139223843812943, 0.08424054831266403, -0.06069866567850113, 0.044408753514289856, 0.04282723367214203, 0.018117032945156097, -0.014448930509388447, 0.04754260927438736, -0.030895758420228958, -0.029622934758663177, 0.007497877348214388, -0.02002285234630108, 0.053882911801338196, -0.0021242129150778055, -0.016960693523287773, 0.018475908786058426, -0.028093086555600166, 0.028008121997117996, 0.03551384061574936, 0.0015151967527344823, 0.010143636725842953, -0.0040526967495679855, -0.007546810898929834, -0.019233016297221184, -0.014484003186225891, -0.017642827704548836, -0.0006120481411926448, -0.02330184355378151, -0.009686335921287537, 0.04381810501217842, 0.005489905830472708, -0.0023758956231176853, -0.0050272769294679165, 0.025584518909454346, 0.06054298207163811, 0.023006893694400787, -0.01446097157895565, 0.009584938175976276, 0.008245737291872501, -0.055422209203243256, 0.0000359541445504874, 0.005356932524591684, 0.004925640765577555, -0.04564439877867699, 0.04963621124625206, -0.013287906534969807, -0.04108123853802681, 0.018365537747740746, -0.025676164776086807, 0.03746400773525238, 0.012833231128752232, -0.10297408699989319, -0.013381928205490112, 0.03546552360057831, -0.02146458998322487, -0.006057377904653549, -0.06277487426996231, 0.00946042686700821, 0.00458727590739727, 0.03725500404834747, 0.026428986340761185, 0.014814060181379318, -0.00846018735319376, 0.030290033668279648, -0.0017828482668846846, -0.04574313387274742, -0.03615164756774902, 0.01256475131958723, -0.034400127828121185, -0.000016448486348963343, -0.03981463238596916, 0.020153116434812546, 0.03271392360329628, -0.01337440125644207, 0.013977795839309692, 0.04787091165781021, 0.022173073142766953, -0.032930485904216766, 0.03423546999692917, 0.022727228701114655, -0.029726341366767883, 0.09768344461917877, 0.0017223419854417443, 0.002164371544495225, -0.0069763921201229095, 0.04568910971283913, 0.03299279510974884, -0.018111495301127434, 0.06606223434209824, 0.032480061054229736, -0.020664159208536148, -0.010076437145471573, -0.04375745356082916, 0.01584448292851448, 0.022797733545303345, -0.026245323941111565, -0.014424250461161137, -0.01867164485156536, -0.05051911249756813, 0.026128150522708893, 0.02607339806854725, 0.003924323245882988, -0.014339578337967396, 0.04195833578705788, -0.07037711143493652, 0.010752021335065365, -0.0687556266784668, 0.006417074706405401, -0.01084558479487896, -0.0034382599405944347, 0.011776170693337917, 0.020099634304642677, 0.012963715009391308, -0.039008915424346924, -0.020132796838879585, -0.015445764176547527, 0.006793928798288107, 0.010129977017641068, -0.05419330671429634, -0.0022976973559707403, 0.02667931839823723, 0.037636253982782364, 0.02887118048965931, 0.05201287940144539, -0.04796867072582245, -0.024916863068938255, 0.008436285890638828, -0.035196661949157715, 0.0066229067742824554, -0.02014690265059471, -0.015372080728411674, 0.01807236298918724, -0.01435941457748413, -0.022908207029104233, 0.028774047270417213, -0.002513594226911664, 0.07319393754005432, 0.052566222846508026, -0.027563640847802162, -0.018681729212403297, 0.020034480839967728, 0.028127038851380348, 0.0017971359193325043, -0.022287948057055473, -0.05131839960813522, -0.023770099505782127, -0.010207214392721653, 0.044654663652181625, 0.06360607594251633, -0.06310945004224777, 0.043627697974443436, 0.06136732175946236, 0.021906454116106033, 0.028195392340421677, -0.009647917002439499, -0.015291841700673103, -0.02520383521914482, 0.03384412080049515, -0.029733311384916306, 0.043504491448402405, 0.02574222721159458, 0.03942880406975746, -0.00557102682068944, -0.0010301892179995775, 0.014121521264314651, 0.021375400945544243, 0.039945852011442184, 0.025337379425764084, -0.015877511352300644, -0.009626357816159725, -0.022725656628608704, 0.03081563487648964, -0.029647093266248703, 0.012727511115372181, -0.004523454234004021, -0.006911956239491701, -0.013259585946798325, 0.012792857363820076, 0.004241197369992733, 0.014611754566431046, -0.007426454219967127, -0.024309450760483742, 0.0007801314350217581, 0.03974086046218872, -0.04374438151717186, 0.032384373247623444, -0.02585691772401333, -0.0047559430822730064, -0.02080298773944378, -0.027612190693616867, 0.0580560639500618, 0.0068168737925589085, 0.056923139840364456, -0.023867297917604446, -0.005538365803658962, -0.021054217591881752, -0.02944030798971653, 0.01927335560321808, -0.009245564229786396, -0.040757328271865845, 0.027792857959866524, -0.005610975436866283, -0.04839133471250534, 0.05532070994377136, 0.006937181577086449, 0.05548097938299179, 0.0517645925283432, 0.015654265880584717, -0.05498664081096649, -0.023017920553684235, -0.045869454741477966, 0.0025134682655334473, -0.02164507657289505, -0.029767954722046852, 0.06543745845556259, 0.01728244498372078, -0.017214864492416382, -0.005477214232087135, -0.036740172654390335, -0.013152705505490303, -0.05825646221637726, -0.01110604777932167, 0.031045814976096153, -0.006085000466555357, 0.016414573416113853, 0.017622359097003937, -0.016298826783895493, 0.0043242741376161575, -0.061931658536195755, -0.05244889482855797, 0.013474020175635815, -0.031109143048524857, 0.04182730242609978, 0.015640823170542717, -0.026427676901221275, 0.07355238497257233, 0.0414731465280056, -0.01985364779829979, -0.030206497758626938, -0.02772974781692028, -0.009132353588938713, -0.0372612364590168, 0.01229073479771614, -0.016733042895793915, 0.0030560872983187437, 0.04193199798464775, 0.017305660992860794, 0.0464509055018425, 0.05956387147307396, -0.009128582663834095, -0.010903396643698215, 0.0460367277264595, -0.0019068343099206686, 0.03152903541922569, 0.021077241748571396, -0.020837651565670967, -0.04698757827281952, 0.019948262721300125, 0.017974678426980972, 0.03679503872990608, 0.02321026660501957, -0.009876200929284096, 0.05316087231040001, 0.008909541182219982, -0.002841561334207654, -0.018999652937054634, 0.046458568423986435, 0.0019362689927220345, -0.02793269418179989, -0.015951333567500114, -0.0030351351015269756, 0.026746373623609543, -0.007941639050841331, -0.018950266763567924, 0.042044952511787415, 0.017995748668909073, 0.0008317821775563061, 0.0032575272489339113, -0.004299933090806007, -0.01556342002004385, 0.023282160982489586, -0.031225405633449554, -0.07164730131626129, 0.038569219410419464, -0.008572550490498543, 0.009067706763744354, 0.00863952562212944, -0.053864944726228714, -0.011205076240003109, -0.0642060711979866, 0.025287600234150887, 0.03228643909096718, 0.05827966332435608, 0.008959905244410038, 0.026890771463513374, -0.00007857027230784297, 0.013131671585142612, 0.01000605896115303, 0.007233682554215193, -0.04850015044212341, 0.037152137607336044, -0.032332971692085266, -0.02633482590317726, 0.002936417004093528, -0.003183748573064804, 0.010829583741724491, -0.05170126631855965, 0.03899655491113663, -0.024438906461000443, 0.007789953146129847, -0.05344392731785774, -0.01633777655661106, -0.035775892436504364, -0.025369882583618164, -0.01916453242301941, 0.009407924488186836, 0.08558002859354019, -0.057443853467702866, 0.040386490523815155, 0.015813153237104416, 0.010311292484402657, 0.0008763091173022985, -0.03752709925174713, 0.03985372930765152, 0.03955287113785744, 0.031186532229185104, 0.024433603510260582, 0.022004766389727592, -0.009786901995539665, 0.025819355621933937, 0.040026865899562836, 0.024220533668994904, 0.013917814008891582, -0.019250817596912384, -0.06609264016151428, -0.02436075173318386, -0.022813377901911736, 0.009093963541090488, 0.07318669557571411, 0.02993089146912098, 0.03126183897256851, -0.01680915243923664, 0.019757915288209915, -0.015271814540028572, 0.0034210211597383022, 0.0824158564209938, 0.026637936010956764, 0.016768954694271088, -0.018912015482783318, -0.022546323016285896, 0.009918490424752235, -0.03629409521818161, 0.0037093462888151407, 0.009266638197004795, -0.013896114192903042, 0.01625734753906727, -0.00012097768922103569, 0.008505035191774368, 0.0006174836307764053, 0.017328811809420586, 0.0431755967438221, 0.057805728167295456, -0.006919824052602053, 0.006129210349172354, 0.05713658034801483, 0.039702024310827255, 0.051401395350694656, 0.0383918322622776, 0.028980406001210213, -0.11282332986593246, 0.02587125636637211, 0.01796364039182663, 0.022886017337441444, -0.03201926127076149, -0.0013679368421435356, -0.07417116314172745, 0.014312898740172386, 0.07997102290391922, -0.05528601258993149, 0.05136267468333244, 0.0036108363419771194, -0.0016197127988561988, -0.009242672473192215, 0.012828782200813293, -0.006548687815666199, 0.036153849214315414, -0.006911005359143019, 0.04535088315606117, 0.022632943466305733, -0.03031967580318451, -0.03328258916735649, -0.0008365397225134075, -0.0036022886633872986, 0.0268193781375885, -0.002455355366691947, -0.0029724398627877235, -0.011713836342096329, 0.0308015625923872, 0.0020649880170822144, -0.05811920017004013, 0.0031094930600374937, 0.010981332510709763, -0.008018708787858486, 0.04228096455335617, 0.014857287518680096, -0.020634688436985016, -0.016463803127408028, 0.01738516427576542, -0.0016349240904673934, -0.012162317521870136, -0.03543645516037941, 0.08143187314271927, 0.025542065501213074, 0.008723677136003971, 0.051307741552591324, 0.04605701193213463, 0.02262735739350319, 0.03137857839465141, -0.010189304128289223, 0.041667640209198, -0.06063104420900345, -0.015121659263968468, -0.031485315412282944, -0.015452808700501919, -0.055549487471580505, 0.01616489700973034, 0.023168573155999184, 0.018883977085351944, -0.006239581387490034, 0.01112777553498745, 0.029841432347893715, 0.04771716147661209, -0.014161663129925728, -0.008227396756410599, -0.030681787058711052, -0.0014672722900286317, -0.05900289863348007, -0.01616743952035904, 0.0023667148780077696, 0.0025274399667978287, -0.004489532206207514, -0.010779103264212608, -0.022144755348563194, 0.020871562883257866, -0.016321297734975815, -0.010918449610471725, -0.004649312701076269, 0.030372081324458122, 0.0362081304192543, 0.0045637101866304874, 0.05046626180410385, 0.03303104266524315, -0.060289166867733, 0.029363563284277916, 0.0022172967437654734, -0.005283763632178307, 0.0008657849975861609, -0.08610363304615021, 0.06496095657348633, -0.020650815218687057, -0.009493592195212841, -0.06768397986888885, -0.046005718410015106, 0.03273971378803253, 0.006442721001803875, -0.011516077443957329, -0.021732272580266, 0.0005811111186631024, -0.013121530413627625, -0.034683436155319214, -0.04374563694000244, 0.021009346470236778, 0.0034067481756210327, -0.008838614448904991, 0.012950601987540722, 0.01337957102805376, 0.05911722034215927, -0.024778591468930244, 0.025182407349348068, -0.03673041611909866, -0.03833373636007309, -0.005714295897632837, -0.00733000785112381, 0.048861078917980194, -0.03358453884720802, 0.0298338383436203, -0.0465695820748806, -0.0023886295966804028, 0.020480571314692497, -0.05015832558274269, -0.04609088972210884, 0.030043628066778183, -0.02392745204269886, 0.010846256278455257, -0.0029019261710345745, 0.00865466333925724, -0.033259909600019455, -0.006302200723439455, -0.0018615461885929108, 0.027883222326636314, 0.04673924669623375, -0.0787973627448082, 0.011940700002014637, 0.03860709071159363, -0.018572520464658737, 0.018896974623203278, 0.03193076699972153, -0.035042282193899155, 0.005177423357963562, 0.015063410624861717, -0.014509684406220913, -0.012025690637528896, -0.04235326498746872, -0.01645568199455738, -0.012608679011464119, -0.030018353834748268, -0.061791371554136276, -0.017842745408415794, 0.0033131041564047337, -0.0009153000428341329, 0.06506317853927612, 0.010377060621976852, 0.04462640732526779, 0.032820913940668106, 0.019536439329385757, -0.03288666903972626, -0.0288457740098238, -0.001501315040513873, -0.01874779723584652, -0.02084856852889061, 0.04680788144469261, -0.012586927972733974, -0.029409628361463547, 0.011719223111867905, 0.046516913920640945, 0.024711666628718376, 0.057279303669929504, -0.006566945929080248, 0.02133726328611374, 0.005223896820098162, -0.009191244840621948, -0.06587184965610504, -0.002888788003474474, -0.03668767213821411, 0.02934657223522663, -0.008127651177346706, -0.005698219407349825, 0.04187227413058281, 0.03713782876729965, -0.0009624007507227361, -0.06736160069704056, -0.04847988486289978, -0.06900084763765335, -0.007326703984290361, 0.0064032962545752525, 0.030594736337661743, 0.038233932107686996, 0.007934391498565674, 0.018823621794581413, 0.003335517132654786, 0.0007741944282315671, -0.03951193392276764, -0.034395284950733185, -0.006429183762520552, -0.0761241465806961, -0.026003627106547356, 0.04487032815814018, -0.006777087692171335, -0.050021324306726456, -0.010620099492371082, -0.016915975138545036, -0.008601248264312744, 0.030900567770004272, 0.04369010403752327, 0.011949648149311543, 0.09317976981401443, 0.006559106521308422, 0.03398856520652771, -0.013101281598210335, -0.022601356729865074, 0.1200561374425888, 0.09187588095664978, 0.04596160352230072, -0.03959816321730614, 0.026003031060099602, -0.024692993611097336, -0.012817381881177425, -0.02281481958925724, 0.022122979164123535, -0.020695233717560768, -0.00931348092854023, 0.0364372655749321, 0.07523644715547562, -0.004808924160897732, -0.005587022285908461, 0.07775800675153732, -0.0011713065905496478, 0.03619778901338577, -0.0018329181475564837, 0.02175983041524887, 0.006963581778109074, -0.012048156000673771, -0.06531636416912079, -0.012203529477119446, -0.008900371380150318, -0.0028118460904806852, 0.000938660406973213, -0.037580378353595734, 0.017901204526424408, -0.009284565225243568, -0.030902154743671417, -0.02056490071117878, 0.02996739000082016, 0.02082047611474991, -0.05159293860197067, 0.009288999252021313, -0.009367477148771286, -0.01170375943183899, 0.009787487797439098, 0.0139341801404953, 0.016610639169812202, -0.003879360156133771, -0.0033340449444949627, 0.010619320906698704, -0.030036509037017822, -0.03624863922595978, -0.03869853541254997, 0.0078051467426121235, 0.0048952908255159855, -0.03676117956638336, 0.01559274923056364, 0.012566512450575829, 0.031401533633470535, -0.0633104145526886, -0.046056538820266724, -0.005740056745707989, -0.008930233307182789, 0.0049547296948730946, -0.011682316660881042, -0.057941969484090805, 0.041785649955272675, 0.013511864468455315, 0.003771986346691847, 0.003627556376159191, -0.0528242252767086, -0.030489500612020493, -0.011255382560193539, 0.01979142799973488, -0.008689912967383862, -0.017042143270373344, -0.01872360333800316, 0.006673825904726982, -0.017814455553889275, -0.014129690825939178, -0.016892358660697937, 0.01752740703523159, -0.010949727147817612, -0.03569551557302475, 0.0062369233928620815, -0.008824188262224197, -0.04277820512652397, 0.05339236930012703, 0.00023903754481580108, 0.026830613613128662, -0.01903240941464901, 0.007509822025895119, 0.02001761645078659, 0.05411519855260849, -0.00917548593133688, 0.036172669380903244, -0.02316683903336525, 0.053996238857507706, 0.008171729743480682, -0.06921276450157166, 0.00035015156026929617, -0.03003849647939205, -0.03625975549221039, 0.0020891837775707245, -0.042025335133075714, 0.06045185402035713, 0.00795494019985199, 0.0002577975974418223, -0.02845536172389984, 0.03381861746311188, -0.0026458497159183025, 0.04304955154657364, -0.001628524623811245, -0.023868534713983536, -0.0066165621392428875, 0.041617389768362045, 0.0020774088334292173, -0.013989830389618874, -0.04123081639409065, -0.0014642227906733751, -0.008295833133161068, -0.006901802495121956, -0.008202705532312393, -0.01805465668439865, 0.0044794087298214436, -0.015962887555360794, 0.028563763946294785, -0.026828451082110405, 0.001284291036427021, -0.05710337683558464, -0.004762088879942894, 0.004087390843778849, -0.04252023249864578, -0.012040632776916027, -0.006292739883065224, -0.021685849875211716, -0.009057371877133846, 0.010195591486990452, -0.002195746637880802, 0.007391251623630524, -0.024275396019220352, 0.012041804380714893, 0.00827176496386528, 0.014325226657092571, -0.029921049252152443, -0.04515058174729347, 0.00448256591334939, -0.027151145040988922, -0.024783063679933548, 0.014295526780188084, 0.021211273968219757, 0.03652288392186165, 0.00924692489206791, 0.007300451397895813, -0.014077228493988514, 0.06563208252191544, -0.010746357962489128, -0.023173103109002113, -0.004873789381235838, -0.01728864572942257, 0.004266559146344662, 0.019148457795381546, 0.018342798575758934, 0.015769202262163162, -0.024289952591061592, 0.04523331671953201, 0.011893917806446552, 0.019181493669748306, -0.024547453969717026, -0.03055664338171482, -0.0036678046453744173, 0.0012977464357391, 0.019593844190239906, -0.0027980846352875233, 0.052158061414957047, 0.06569982320070267, -0.028534090146422386, -0.024341734126210213, -0.004141375422477722, 0.0067034149542450905, -0.054203104227781296, 0.019910555332899094, 0.015509920194745064, -0.038667093962430954, 0.024167172610759735, -0.048271115869283676, 0.022103307768702507, -0.013276292942464352, -0.0037371565122157335, 0.008176645264029503, -0.06333478540182114, 0.009301375597715378, -0.01499219611287117, -0.003770015900954604, -0.003728321986272931, 0.011115921661257744, 0.06221821531653404, 0.03921281918883324, 0.02837032824754715, 0.011995113454759121, 0.0274751428514719, 0.007417062763124704, -0.022825617343187332, -0.003987218253314495, 0.00915477704256773, -0.029265878722071648, 0.02816152200102806, -0.051455166190862656, -0.035183362662792206, 0.03848185017704964, -0.08639369159936905, 0.0009036505362018943, -0.01258737500756979, 0.009289119392633438, 0.006444649770855904, 0.012824129313230515, 0.011647280305624008, -0.02078029327094555, 0.008197539485991001, 0.020516376942396164, 0.007838909514248371, 0.02968747168779373, -0.042778708040714264, -0.015928201377391815, 0.006719596218317747, -0.058312103152275085, -0.0005445528659038246, -0.016219792887568474, 0.0018076517153531313, -0.002342688851058483, -0.022995945066213608, 0.05574488639831543, 0.030553501099348068, 0.028947077691555023, -0.00615721708163619, -0.0030794264748692513, -0.027009859681129456, 0.003910875413566828, -0.006298190448433161, -0.045093368738889694, 0.01481446623802185, 0.00047223965520970523, -0.037318285554647446, -0.01091074850410223, 0.001126736868172884, -0.014609025791287422, -0.08638546615839005, -0.05609406903386116, 0.009832069277763367, -0.05796045809984207, -0.018174363300204277, -0.005187666974961758, -0.021748783066868782, 0.03652726113796234, -0.01396930031478405, 0.02709205634891987, 0.021283356472849846, -0.02048759162425995, -0.01876765675842762, -0.08599450439214706, 0.050703346729278564, 0.025085024535655975, -0.005461005959659815, -0.03972301632165909, -0.02625557966530323, -0.040682967752218246, 0.002266340423375368, 0.06497931480407715, -0.0019975092727690935, -0.005032157059758902, 0.0036325801629573107, -0.029046816751360893, -0.018438957631587982, -0.028614139184355736, 0.013971906155347824, -0.016849204897880554, -0.012508029118180275, 0.03591211885213852, -0.02777314931154251, -0.007204405497759581, -0.0059110745787620544, 0.012342139147222042, 0.011138896457850933, 0.0009903713362291455, 0.033898115158081055, -0.0016444562934339046, 0.042707573622465134, 0.016385331749916077, -0.026806002482771873, 0.01782093197107315, 0.007982844486832619, -0.00471618864685297, 0.0077916462905704975, -0.005147401709109545, -0.04837062582373619, 0.02054375782608986, -0.018674680963158607, 0.0023840172216296196, -0.02262926660478115, -0.017611324787139893, -0.028115136548876762, -0.020762965083122253, -0.01325384434312582, 0.05135507509112358, 0.01299038901925087, 0.02848137728869915, 0.019282741472125053, -0.006852342281490564, -0.006597702857106924, 0.00669760350137949, -0.00546762440353632, -0.014617618173360825, 0.026774194091558456, 0.04249702766537666, -0.0011944214347749949, -0.016615288332104683, -0.0016318184789270163, 0.0050150081515312195, -0.006324603222310543, -0.005192102398723364, 0.0004406381049193442, 0.0009415401145815849, 0.032075364142656326, -0.00020696940191555768, -0.043006736785173416, -0.010555186308920383, 0.02077873796224594, -0.008410051465034485, 0.03685951977968216, 0.005017463583499193, 0.0017584176966920495, 0.01638801395893097, -0.022119279950857162, 0.008553333580493927, -0.00032097651273943484, -0.030592968687415123, -0.005241729784756899, 0.05227284878492355, 0.0414716973900795, -0.00932865310460329, 0.0018540223827585578, -0.013301062397658825, 0.022804047912359238, 0.008053462021052837, -0.019464289769530296, 0.01710681803524494, -0.0008809891878627241, 0.0041007897816598415, -0.007333031855523586, 0.010044940747320652, -0.05609620735049248, -0.03173576295375824, 0.035046327859163284, 0.03960798308253288, 0.055971477180719376, 0.00325915589928627, -0.013788443058729172, -0.0038441549986600876, 0.03580057621002197, -0.06338474899530411, -0.047346536070108414, -0.03160827234387398, 0.017628995701670647, -0.00688925851136446, -0.03109687939286232 ]
<p>This is similar to question <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/17602/caret-re-sampling-methods">Caret re-sampling methods</a>, although that really never answered this part of the question in an agreed upon way.</p> <p>caret's train function offers <code>cv</code> and <code>repeatedcv</code>. What is the difference in say doing:</p> <pre><code>MyTrainControl=trainControl( method = "cv", number=5, repeats=5 ) </code></pre> <p>vs</p> <pre><code>MyTrainControl=trainControl( method = "repeatedcv", number=5, repeats=5 ) </code></pre> <p>I understand <code>cv</code> breaks the set into k-folds (parameter <code>number</code>), and then starts over and runs it parameters <code>repeats</code> number of times. </p> <p>The only thing I could think of is that maybe regular <code>cv</code> with <code>repeats</code> uses the same exact indexes for the folds each time? essentially running the <code>cv</code> on the same exact folds each time, vs perhaps <code>repeatedcv</code> selects new folds each times?</p> <p>Can someone clarify?</p>
73,406
[ -0.022297097370028496, 0.015341203659772873, 0.0008510822663083673, -0.027667086571455002, 0.026377057656645775, 0.0031074921134859324, 0.0022615257184952497, -0.04692422226071358, 0.045429158955812454, -0.007745630573481321, 0.000161399831995368, 0.03252975642681122, 0.04466864839196205, 0.007999942637979984, 0.021387245506048203, -0.0037905981298536062, -0.03459200635552406, -0.018575381487607956, -0.012959819287061691, -0.012255586683750153, -0.015046482905745506, 0.033811815083026886, 0.014063364826142788, -0.020599866285920143, -0.013770290650427341, 0.04199456050992012, 0.023044807836413383, -0.00880194641649723, 0.027550706639885902, 0.03953736275434494, -0.0713200643658638, -0.00944018829613924, -0.0017611117800697684, 0.043683651834726334, 0.006429268978536129, 0.0040724310092628, -0.025307388976216316, -0.02407681569457054, 0.019583476707339287, 0.029810385778546333, -0.0036220478359609842, -0.010840550996363163, -0.03377999737858772, 0.004280739463865757, 0.005699322558939457, 0.006790210027247667, -0.03390347957611084, -0.0012190876295790076, 0.02875061146914959, -0.018415937200188637, 0.07865897566080093, 0.011086474172770977, 0.01867927983403206, 0.03455188497900963, 0.00414690375328064, 0.00508922478184104, 0.05629223212599754, 0.030213095247745514, -0.020824313163757324, -0.038636401295661926, -0.01824112981557846, -0.0036171949468553066, 0.0032107180450111628, -0.002065746346488595, -0.04698961600661278, 0.03821713849902153, 0.02784930355846882, -0.017970046028494835, 0.03276606649160385, -0.048581574112176895, 0.014674327336251736, 0.018795708194375038, 0.023523075506091118, -0.042387235909700394, 0.026117481291294098, -0.01864759624004364, 0.011581189930438995, 0.035032302141189575, 0.012051480822265148, 0.04986519739031792, -0.0012088436633348465, 0.023740800097584724, -0.0025210657622665167, 0.028370551764965057, 0.021000094711780548, -0.004998873453587294, 0.0667024478316307, -0.021650461480021477, 0.024137133732438087, 0.030825175344944, 0.020712658762931824, -0.00713324174284935, 0.04861428216099739, 0.006003121845424175, -0.055411506444215775, 0.023915667086839676, -0.010562811978161335, 0.04036305472254753, -0.0064189983531832695, 0.014272689819335938, -0.03508396074175835, -0.0526108592748642, 0.0029452659655362368, 0.050999656319618225, -0.01204591616988182, -0.013331683352589607, -0.018889885395765305, -0.024062346667051315, -0.013726518489420414, -0.013041697442531586, 0.00010525812103878707, -0.012371118180453777, -0.014816871844232082, -0.02585367113351822, 0.047793760895729065, 0.03485056385397911, -0.01144443079829216, 0.020830625668168068, 0.050669632852077484, 0.06165212392807007, 0.03135973960161209, -0.031729020178318024, 0.05868097022175789, -0.05263957753777504, -0.04507802426815033, 0.0012672737939283252, 0.011711234226822853, -0.03204119950532913, 0.009426925331354141, 0.03954328969120979, -0.02390488237142563, -0.014266273006796837, 0.019739463925361633, -0.0050421771593391895, 0.016721554100513458, -0.006662657484412193, -0.09076139330863953, -0.05453384295105934, 0.044729508459568024, -0.002883543726056814, 0.004989155102521181, -0.049114860594272614, 0.056649379432201385, -0.015874622389674187, 0.031710732728242874, 0.011548037640750408, 0.04092342033982277, 0.04820121079683304, 0.013045874424278736, 0.02054409869015217, -0.005802756175398827, 0.0008534446242265403, -0.03227243945002556, -0.0005474010249599814, -0.06563497334718704, -0.08678098022937775, 0.024871567264199257, 0.0004122070095036179, 0.006248712074011564, -0.02607671543955803, 0.04277320206165314, -0.02018812857568264, -0.011406195349991322, -0.006054136902093887, 0.00746430829167366, -0.05276273936033249, 0.03775925934314728, 0.01877765730023384, 0.0737062394618988, 0.026594577357172966, -0.015034451149404049, -0.0266276802867651, 0.0068090674467384815, 0.0015687920385971665, 0.062267933040857315, 0.012299507856369019, 0.01681406795978546, -0.03537273779511452, 0.019026903435587883, 0.0443754568696022, -0.005372618790715933, -0.020830698311328888, 0.016060803085565567, 0.00100598088465631, 0.041277170181274414, 0.019592810422182083, 0.008381960913538933, -0.008777158334851265, 0.016748594120144844, -0.061793968081474304, -0.021564383059740067, -0.052780572324991226, 0.007719335146248341, -0.024922167882323265, 0.010518926195800304, -0.0002474031352903694, -0.006037907674908638, 0.014803691767156124, 0.020242758095264435, -0.02438679337501526, -0.009602390229701996, 0.005046997219324112, 0.023946508765220642, -0.0345611646771431, -0.006457281298935413, 0.02829360030591488, 0.013442184776067734, 0.002811383455991745, 0.08979267627000809, -0.024629583582282066, -0.03735708072781563, 0.0064847031608223915, -0.005562609061598778, 0.026851091533899307, -0.007806142792105675, -0.014914307743310928, 0.03038221038877964, 0.010699642822146416, -0.03843585029244423, 0.05921348184347153, -0.0710027664899826, 0.04518763720989227, 0.07580368965864182, -0.0027633276768028736, 0.017867814749479294, 0.004250356927514076, -0.016379464417696, 0.055066101253032684, -0.001548510161228478, -0.026394924148917198, -0.04540560394525528, -0.03006410226225853, 0.04433470591902733, -0.0006395052187144756, -0.011753570288419724, 0.038678351789712906, 0.08277963101863861, 0.023765847086906433, 0.00921613723039627, 0.008128759451210499, 0.0281436275690794, -0.023988166823983192, 0.0033392966724932194, 0.02662440575659275, 0.045401934534311295, -0.005761805456131697, -0.016265414655208588, -0.03216889128088951, 0.04361870139837265, 0.03165309503674507, -0.007422228809446096, 0.050944652408361435, 0.002166417893022299, -0.017545655369758606, -0.003207564353942871, -0.01748529076576233, 0.03816739469766617, -0.0010756815318018198, -0.03495229408144951, 0.03509833291172981, 0.03949405625462532, 0.001313445740379393, -0.016040684655308723, -0.004179425537586212, 0.002105436520650983, 0.05504370480775833, -0.03256816789507866, -0.034968260675668716, 0.008019237779080868, -0.030305594205856323, 0.006376476492732763, -0.036656446754932404, -0.013019664213061333, -0.043894361704587936, 0.0392504557967186, 0.02379702404141426, -0.020525364205241203, 0.04732672870159149, -0.04423969238996506, -0.020249338820576668, -0.008410056121647358, -0.04066308215260506, 0.027191724628210068, -0.022604994475841522, -0.05208756774663925, 0.019159875810146332, -0.011584174819290638, -0.007117219269275665, 0.028253844007849693, -0.0029563314747065306, -0.04789242148399353, 0.02509036473929882, -0.006283025722950697, -0.06331150978803635, -0.018593618646264076, -0.051535580307245255, 0.0441041924059391, 0.013111247681081295, -0.018126284703612328, 0.08686823397874832, 0.027097187936306, -0.07971100509166718, 0.033111389726400375, -0.021575141698122025, -0.018489161506295204, -0.03649446368217468, -0.023347195237874985, -0.003304925747215748, -0.02516981214284897, -0.014995938166975975, 0.06513741612434387, -0.041954465210437775, 0.009898222982883453, -0.04963367059826851, -0.05179689824581146, 0.010339113883674145, -0.01304316520690918, -0.010801971890032291, -0.0025391741655766964, 0.020055735483765602, 0.09535929560661316, 0.0011632603127509356, -0.028898168355226517, -0.05529415234923363, 0.000797320797573775, -0.007669983431696892, -0.0182485468685627, -0.013697485439479351, 0.008016400039196014, -0.007407079450786114, -0.002828160999342799, 0.030026443302631378, 0.027424635365605354, 0.08688925951719284, -0.02515658736228943, 0.014471321366727352, -0.006028927396982908, 0.029859112575650215, -0.027728253975510597, -0.008513099513947964, 0.020077040418982506, 0.004079278092831373, 0.014032847248017788, 0.018082965165376663, -0.008123029954731464, -0.001371675287373364, -0.011346942745149136, 0.027523385360836983, -0.021003397181630135, -0.011093594133853912, -0.004477439448237419, 0.030091335996985435, -0.006549372803419828, -0.051859091967344284, -0.03658388927578926, 0.03328815475106239, 0.03588757663965225, -0.05846568942070007, -0.0138164684176445, 0.0027319276705384254, 0.051953673362731934, -0.006261473521590233, 0.012126236222684383, -0.031301453709602356, -0.015775786712765694, -0.012759159319102764, -0.0004960286896675825, -0.006573790684342384, 0.05161217227578163, 0.042779453098773956, 0.022591739892959595, 0.011714177206158638, -0.047216929495334625, -0.0005510746268555522, -0.07042430341243744, -0.000348578963894397, -0.049736808985471725, 0.04378780350089073, -0.00035911850864067674, 0.047326743602752686, 0.030387815088033676, 0.002620323095470667, -0.008445437066257, 0.041304536163806915, -0.059457965195178986, 0.014274941757321358, 0.010608627460896969, -0.0366690531373024, -0.01939212717115879, -0.030623257160186768, 0.0375191904604435, 0.01639198511838913, -0.023146983236074448, 0.0062978072091937065, -0.0016954559832811356, -0.04992210119962692, 0.011244567111134529, -0.01693185605108738, 0.005909649655222893, -0.00959591194987297, 0.0063193924725055695, 0.059345394372940063, -0.013486082665622234, 0.029637424275279045, 0.0023253897670656443, -0.00238905125297606, -0.008828314021229744, 0.002855891129001975, 0.011731124483048916, 0.0030176013242453337, 0.002588125644251704, 0.013244058936834335, 0.04427915811538696, -0.05020704120397568, 0.01958361826837063, 0.0034012566320598125, 0.04190816357731819, 0.07602375000715256, -0.006164255551993847, -0.03437375649809837, -0.02934599481523037, 0.0002524317824281752, 0.02314281277358532, 0.0025508722756057978, 0.008624741807579994, -0.011339948512613773, 0.0412425734102726, 0.037413474172353745, -0.05574997141957283, 0.008958393707871437, 0.06235942617058754, -0.020379673689603806, -0.03787781670689583, -0.051738083362579346, 0.010934200137853622, 0.019100790843367577, -0.01033006701618433, 0.050824668258428574, 0.012164700776338577, -0.014779403805732727, 0.021050667390227318, 0.013977117836475372, -0.0653110072016716, -0.04962560161948204, 0.005597713403403759, 0.03287702426314354, 0.03348090127110481, -0.02701825648546219, -0.020924037322402, -0.027949213981628418, 0.050500452518463135, 0.04323280602693558, 0.023633519187569618, -0.010413425043225288, -0.06637111306190491, -0.04625324159860611, 0.04716859385371208, 0.0008465123828500509, -0.11332304775714874, 0.010763021185994148, -0.018701467663049698, -0.02088920585811138, 0.002188460435718298, -0.0484752394258976, 0.024721290916204453, -0.053775638341903687, 0.009272951632738113, -0.05304408818483353, -0.005721125286072493, -0.022798284888267517, 0.015210540033876896, -0.03387531638145447, 0.04044895991683006, 0.00004515377804636955, 0.009922516532242298, -0.05901375412940979, 0.016233591362833977, -0.013984725810587406, 0.053859006613492966, -0.05422428622841835, -0.04090815410017967, 0.005876879207789898, -0.0026632912922650576, -0.017728596925735474, -0.06078166514635086, -0.012869875878095627, 0.0110247153788805, 0.024540895596146584, 0.031032046303153038, 0.014184250496327877, -0.025901606306433678, 0.027818994596600533, 0.01554980967193842, 0.0027041290886700153, -0.005039977841079235, -0.03329522907733917, 0.057546358555555344, 0.043438833206892014, 0.01305857952684164, 0.060849204659461975, 0.025663848966360092, 0.0232780110090971, 0.03628417104482651, -0.005974841769784689, 0.015807298943400383, -0.0387987419962883, -0.02655814401805401, -0.03370364010334015, -0.007301271427422762, -0.06319575756788254, 0.031140025705099106, 0.0022706310264766216, 0.030491754412651062, -0.031547535210847855, -0.018459832295775414, 0.005107276141643524, 0.02830648422241211, 0.037597790360450745, -0.03518085554242134, 0.04379218444228172, 0.041752804070711136, 0.004758634138852358, -0.002824337687343359, -0.02780805714428425, -0.02873496152460575, -0.008768416941165924, 0.02402537129819393, -0.010023348964750767, -0.028487302362918854, -0.01799425669014454, -0.022808155044913292, 0.02258104830980301, -0.0181248988956213, 0.014743656851351261, -0.0018607770325616002, 0.025356188416481018, 0.0057207257486879826, -0.03900106996297836, 0.0008853930630721152, 0.014824916608631611, -0.030719870701432228, -0.009429462254047394, -0.0373145192861557, 0.07091353088617325, -0.004903056193143129, -0.02091267518699169, -0.08260087668895721, -0.03239528834819794, 0.05059889703989029, -0.007011708337813616, -0.07035412639379501, -0.01784350909292698, -0.004990799818187952, 0.005707259755581617, -0.004244801588356495, -0.030097421258687973, 0.07271917164325714, -0.05320591852068901, 0.010233280248939991, 0.0033836362417787313, 0.014923356473445892, 0.07369904220104218, 0.011312139220535755, 0.03646443411707878, -0.0010787935461848974, -0.03674649819731712, -0.02038305439054966, 0.034916095435619354, 0.009825048968195915, -0.01828036457300186, -0.010866777040064335, -0.02294175513088703, 0.016792919486761093, 0.05137483775615692, 0.009820712730288506, -0.00898541510105133, 0.021760324016213417, -0.025285672396421432, 0.01684705540537834, -0.03803199902176857, -0.015941942110657692, -0.006257582921534777, 0.03356657922267914, -0.019328605383634567, -0.016515066847205162, -0.0008021538378670812, -0.02736862562596798, 0.002135235583409667, 0.008464127779006958, -0.02231353335082531, 0.026526471599936485, 0.07608533650636673, -0.028193656355142593, 0.04579067602753639, -0.034423597157001495, -0.02215690352022648, 0.04171791300177574, 0.01139680203050375, 0.0037551764398813248, 0.012975875288248062, -0.00011018571240128949, -0.0011877452488988638, 0.021068772301077843, -0.048906199634075165, 0.020138539373874664, 0.047690995037555695, 0.027273226529359818, 0.04661918804049492, 0.05635720118880272, 0.007342406082898378, 0.05360494926571846, -0.03175165131688118, 0.013681056909263134, -0.03395317494869232, 0.03266213834285736, 0.05874888598918915, 0.024607330560684204, -0.019033458083868027, 0.03611031174659729, 0.01124848797917366, 0.053006988018751144, 0.015356926247477531, 0.0111814821138978, 0.028416231274604797, 0.002536613726988435, -0.022020552307367325, -0.022526372224092484, 0.033253785222768784, -0.02438637986779213, 0.0049544814974069595, 0.008821288123726845, -0.04712563753128052, 0.02280053123831749, 0.04281962290406227, 0.018607942387461662, -0.04313475266098976, -0.024495171383023262, -0.05810728296637535, 0.019763924181461334, -0.014454330317676067, -0.02680083177983761, 0.03423615172505379, -0.006677589844912291, 0.011343235149979591, -0.001881021773442626, -0.0022011755499988794, -0.016073184087872505, -0.09443944692611694, -0.025916865095496178, -0.015615927055478096, -0.017297636717557907, 0.038443777710199356, 0.029733365401625633, -0.020511094480752945, 0.0025363080203533173, -0.04988966882228851, 0.04202420637011528, 0.03523610159754753, 0.048007942736148834, -0.007841958664357662, 0.03669817000627518, -0.0033987173810601234, 0.013081577606499195, -0.036127492785453796, -0.030005158856511116, 0.1019909530878067, 0.08567088097333908, 0.023070022463798523, -0.05823304504156113, 0.02594751864671707, 0.03115888126194477, -0.025041839107871056, -0.0000711711254552938, -0.00040249116136692464, 0.04336000978946686, -0.009446593932807446, 0.008753463625907898, 0.03664329648017883, 0.011723494157195091, 0.010113063268363476, 0.01853034272789955, -0.031169068068265915, 0.00036494771484285593, 0.03993604704737663, -0.005220858845859766, 0.023016713559627533, -0.009259836748242378, -0.061572980135679245, -0.008384005166590214, 0.004311254248023033, -0.005317664239555597, -0.007275430019944906, -0.08112823218107224, -0.0040914746932685375, -0.0024120535235852003, 0.005127730313688517, -0.023502498865127563, -0.01727960631251335, -0.03171030431985855, -0.01238277181982994, -0.0057314480654895306, -0.005242874380201101, -0.013346316292881966, 0.025687966495752335, 0.06609004735946655, 0.008280373178422451, -0.02448319084942341, -0.009204586036503315, 0.0169166661798954, -0.014652615413069725, -0.03435356169939041, -0.05578693747520447, 0.021696539595723152, -0.04441140964627266, -0.007941942662000656, 0.007640915457159281, -0.04247951880097389, 0.028700871393084526, -0.05596030876040459, 0.01941031403839588, 0.0018764149863272905, 0.020745204761624336, -0.05365758389234543, -0.023457622155547142, -0.04181594401597977, -0.006073291879147291, -0.013818551786243916, 0.03577588498592377, 0.023281525820493698, -0.018771931529045105, -0.05539587140083313, -0.040879666805267334, 0.02369808219373226, -0.007755917031317949, 0.04106338694691658, 0.04040824621915817, -0.017367437481880188, -0.04773705080151558, -0.023666560649871826, 0.016356874257326126, 0.013611476868391037, 0.02027164213359356, -0.04665502905845642, -0.027375394478440285, -0.02202182076871395, -0.007470700889825821, -0.011275837197899818, 0.0029167027678340673, 0.02648286707699299, -0.03697701543569565, 0.025798939168453217, 0.036765776574611664, 0.0401320680975914, 0.007815937511622906, 0.02511102892458439, 0.0026031993329524994, 0.017023421823978424, 0.023522548377513885, -0.03425595909357071, -0.03293289244174957, 0.023486558347940445, -0.02624300681054592, -0.000604336557444185, -0.03611242398619652, 0.05587281659245491, -0.000059173835325054824, 0.008270292542874813, -0.04438130185008049, 0.03998873010277748, 0.016258087009191513, 0.014768359251320362, 0.00011900713434442878, -0.0508737713098526, 0.0205136276781559, 0.009735440835356712, 0.015671122819185257, -0.04243714362382889, -0.025617452338337898, -0.04959012195467949, -0.030863016843795776, 0.019113609567284584, -0.02813561074435711, -0.07072214782238007, 0.02564873732626438, -0.006072497460991144, 0.029144223779439926, -0.03414011374115944, -0.022418849170207977, -0.059123653918504715, 0.01888134516775608, -0.03747987747192383, 0.0055855815298855305, -0.025752687826752663, 0.01612822338938713, -0.020964205265045166, -0.04007289558649063, -0.004927666392177343, 0.010501101613044739, 0.01981460489332676, -0.03143324330449104, 0.006131387315690517, 0.006801672745496035, 0.030028413981199265, -0.02043091133236885, -0.03306715562939644, 0.04044374078512192, -0.04368288069963455, -0.014547457918524742, 0.005315636284649372, -0.019549774006009102, 0.029571840539574623, 0.048418980091810226, -0.02839420922100544, 0.04577204957604408, 0.04984428361058235, 0.009524459950625896, 0.015844762325286865, -0.013399220071732998, 0.0011740191839635372, 0.013693760149180889, 0.005209215916693211, 0.0024343905970454216, 0.017244739457964897, 0.007630827836692333, 0.01905570551753044, 0.05471425503492355, -0.016032801941037178, -0.02188587561249733, 0.008301198482513428, -0.012715429067611694, 0.011347292922437191, -0.015132647007703781, 0.011000638827681541, 0.018476134166121483, 0.022541657090187073, -0.06938185542821884, 0.026555052027106285, -0.02068278379738331, 0.020076008513569832, -0.08000440895557404, 0.011119999922811985, -0.01657935231924057, -0.010242669843137264, 0.013154562562704086, -0.025507092475891113, 0.006404299288988113, -0.005904027726501226, -0.03170418366789818, 0.029168585315346718, -0.026048095896840096, 0.02975626476109028, -0.045209307223558426, 0.025814900174736977, -0.024350516498088837, -0.0017071053152903914, 0.04824869707226753, -0.02996927499771118, 0.0431022010743618, -0.008715425617992878, 0.023250332102179527, -0.0014732138952240348, 0.001268649473786354, 0.023540301248431206, -0.008792538195848465, -0.03335730358958244, 0.025866543874144554, -0.016287270933389664, -0.035911329090595245, 0.021637331694364548, -0.021222887560725212, 0.011417655274271965, 0.055316388607025146, 0.010812235064804554, 0.02628379687666893, 0.03650030866265297, 0.039062462747097015, 0.007006742060184479, -0.009386928752064705, 0.013440540991723537, 0.006445905193686485, -0.0034702522680163383, 0.03025558963418007, 0.03306029364466667, 0.01013787742704153, 0.015675963833928108, -0.008284017443656921, 0.040196437388658524, -0.014838169328868389, -0.026351701468229294, 0.005022771190851927, -0.03869311884045601, 0.02864082343876362, 0.015084989368915558, 0.009728183969855309, -0.03566484898328781, 0.023323195055127144, -0.0007962404633872211, -0.001226453110575676, 0.0021725771948695183, 0.03534281998872757, -0.02008887380361557, -0.034581735730171204, 0.008048971183598042, 0.01707804948091507, -0.017325691878795624, -0.06289760023355484, 0.020691167563199997, 0.06928093731403351, 0.0011218211147934198, -0.004530823323875666, -0.015223555266857147, -0.003118430729955435, 0.05330152064561844, -0.008251169696450233, 0.03178955987095833, 0.01429187785834074, 0.005658789072185755, -0.014383263885974884, -0.08430087566375732, 0.07484503090381622, 0.015411661006510258, -0.03555247187614441, -0.019402988255023956, 0.0006190990097820759, -0.006741837132722139, 0.04018191248178482, 0.05507376044988632, 0.02323383465409279, -0.005103546194732189, -0.02741927281022072, 0.04819008335471153, 0.0031919924076646566, -0.06756803393363953, 0.01581835187971592, 0.004823154769837856, -0.02227797918021679, -0.017564918845891953, 0.003725233720615506, -0.02436831407248974, 0.021298576146364212, 0.03190665692090988, 0.0034043926279991865, 0.018267536535859108, -0.00739574059844017, -0.01192689873278141, 0.01852862909436226, 0.044591329991817474, -0.0013981142546981573, 0.02783162146806717, -0.0018256059847772121, -0.012303249910473824, 0.02668677642941475, 0.03065410815179348, -0.028329208493232727, 0.024509023874998093, -0.0714900940656662, -0.01662176102399826, -0.021861694753170013, -0.008666499517858028, 0.019793465733528137, -0.05502179637551308, -0.02236746810376644, 0.0062316120602190495, -0.05204921215772629, -0.0193439032882452, 0.03918272256851196, 0.04535793885588646, 0.014147566631436348, 0.008644205518066883, 0.032196205109357834, 0.005057834554463625, 0.0006572514539584517, -0.027437856420874596, 0.020229142159223557, 0.006869204808026552, -0.014624906703829765, 0.015447148121893406, 0.005714531522244215, -0.015304258093237877, 0.045686956495046616, -0.027543578296899796, 0.07401060312986374, -0.03249179571866989, -0.026625091210007668, 0.0021986833307892084, -0.03957417979836464, -0.022123895585536957, 0.0013410181272774935, -0.02831179089844227, 0.06879497319459915, -0.024992728605866432, 0.02498820424079895, 0.0032771422993391752, -0.03921724855899811, -0.01575266569852829, 0.0021381478291004896, 0.027339674532413483, 0.03002704493701458, 0.03447199612855911, -0.004185335710644722, -0.0009350574691779912, 0.00010561047383816913, 0.03550701215863228, -0.03693804144859314, 0.027654195204377174, -0.022111639380455017, -0.019940927624702454, -0.007330823689699173, -0.017169060185551643, -0.038412291556596756, -0.01107445452362299, 0.0025349073112010956, 0.025645805522799492, 0.02787339687347412, -0.009863545186817646, -0.052706167101860046, -0.00076439039548859, 0.021385561674833298, -0.035122111439704895, 0.0037953960709273815, -0.01655595749616623, 0.018186314031481743, 0.007640639320015907, -0.010467639192938805 ]
<p>The biological data is listed as following: </p> <pre><code> V1 V2 V3 V4 V5 V6 0.064 0.014 0.016 0.012 0.013 0.023 0.056 0.000 0.000 0.008 0.010 0.000 0.042 0.014 0.024 0.008 0.017 0.023 0.031 0.014 0.016 0.008 0.013 0.023 0.068 0.000 0.008 0.004 0.020 0.000 0.081 0.000 0.000 0.004 0.010 0.000 0.060 0.014 0.016 0.006 0.010 0.023 </code></pre> <p>or you can download the data from <a href="http://www.mediafire.com/?6yp9l9m47jv433a" rel="nofollow">http://www.mediafire.com/?6yp9l9m47jv433a</a>.</p> <pre><code>A&lt;- dat[,1] B&lt;- dat[,2:6] </code></pre> <p>I want to compare the difference between the first column to other columns of the data.Because only dat[,2] and dat[,6] not subject to normal distribute,I used wilcox.test instead of t.test function to caculate in R. But the warning messages rised up,such as "In wilcox.test.default(A, B[, 1]) : cannot compute exact p-value with ties". Could you give me some suggestions? Thank you.</p> <pre><code>wilcox.test(A,B[,1]) Wilcoxon rank sum test with continuity correction data: A and B[, 1] W = 49, p-value = 0.00184 alternative hypothesis: true location shift is not equal to 0 Warning message: In wilcox.test.default(A, B[, 1]) : cannot compute exact p-value with ties </code></pre>
73,407
[ -0.046871721744537354, 0.004416132811456919, 0.018274551257491112, 0.01224821899086237, -0.015583033673465252, 0.03586681932210922, -0.028671590611338615, 0.011223516426980495, 0.02195475623011589, -0.034470293670892715, 0.061647623777389526, 0.04376371204853058, 0.024202698841691017, 0.0661180317401886, 0.044055286794900894, -0.00015396678645629436, 0.0028196326456964016, -0.008830772712826729, -0.018346397206187248, 0.0009697509813122451, 0.007031070999801159, 0.007463918998837471, 0.003929488826543093, -0.008470705710351467, 0.0014822401572018862, 0.05143078416585922, 0.017929963767528534, 0.00961335189640522, -0.05125990882515907, 0.0344330370426178, -0.05964888259768486, -0.06381124258041382, 0.032456133514642715, -0.013337614014744759, 0.015054011717438698, 0.028994258493185043, 0.012611865065991879, -0.017308784648776054, -0.01146605797111988, 0.035317640751600266, 0.006827355362474918, -0.022791625931859016, -0.0014949673786759377, 0.06467702984809875, 0.013106110505759716, 0.012720473110675812, 0.015150320716202259, 0.03891691192984581, 0.033780232071876526, 0.005481034517288208, 0.06283052265644073, -0.022440316155552864, 0.04124534875154495, -0.013076036237180233, -0.01591813750565052, 0.008842701092362404, 0.019445179030299187, 0.04700438678264618, -0.0005503306165337563, -0.0952611118555069, -0.010350634343922138, -0.04378576949238777, -0.023736242204904556, 0.013379902578890324, -0.029489047825336456, -0.01135102566331625, -0.040322788059711456, -0.0494091622531414, 0.02807721123099327, -0.042977724224328995, -0.0008566596079617739, 0.005777854938060045, -0.005126962438225746, -0.023181360214948654, 0.027119450271129608, -0.009976726956665516, -0.01887318305671215, 0.003484138287603855, 0.04453403875231743, 0.02310372330248356, -0.00002141223376384005, 0.035005100071430206, 0.0020205331966280937, 0.07038483768701553, 0.036926817148923874, -0.00475908862426877, 0.02375883422791958, -0.07516203820705414, 0.02074078470468521, 0.06465545296669006, -0.03473548963665962, 0.032897766679525375, 0.028629068285226822, 0.024625888094305992, -0.027080325409770012, 0.04175206273794174, 0.012041926383972168, 0.007338761352002621, -0.034483492374420166, -0.009001068770885468, -0.031129751354455948, -0.07164269685745239, 0.023032577708363533, 0.0390716977417469, -0.0486164391040802, -0.03880620747804642, -0.02892354130744934, 0.025772327557206154, -0.016181685030460358, -0.025631703436374664, 0.016661720350384712, 0.013010910712182522, 0.010673954151570797, -0.008706548251211643, 0.017763836309313774, -0.03931743651628494, -0.009702736511826515, 0.005914469249546528, 0.07508479803800583, 0.056396082043647766, 0.0901130735874176, 0.015296077355742455, 0.038037389516830444, 0.0010216805385425687, -0.021444061771035194, -0.022094273939728737, 0.02195729687809944, 0.0019092932343482971, 0.0026344694197177887, 0.032965369522571564, 0.00014847029524389654, -0.014553152024745941, 0.0472380705177784, -0.02036125585436821, 0.062157973647117615, 0.02619577944278717, -0.06751459836959839, -0.03209158405661583, 0.05032356455922127, 0.014059252105653286, -0.016099995002150536, -0.030311379581689835, 0.0001253320515388623, 0.03289647400379181, 0.029670435935258865, 0.007499305531382561, 0.029320012778043747, 0.002023940673097968, 0.011365838348865509, 0.0009919480653479695, -0.024844812229275703, -0.028042102232575417, -0.026827659457921982, -0.03215596824884415, -0.043284282088279724, -0.04835392162203789, -0.012732896953821182, 0.014516367577016354, -0.006383680738508701, 0.03461494669318199, 0.02974756434559822, 0.006987782660871744, -0.017981817945837975, -0.050596050918102264, -0.029036061838269234, -0.03395814076066017, 0.031391702592372894, -0.025758275762200356, -0.007325247395783663, 0.02234043926000595, -0.04641171544790268, 0.006135942880064249, -0.027306897565722466, 0.034333646297454834, 0.03992042690515518, -0.03050113096833229, 0.037734679877758026, -0.022032182663679123, 0.03829089179635048, 0.032811131328344345, -0.04733055457472801, 0.014226341620087624, -0.03660109266638756, -0.024723222479224205, 0.050291936844587326, 0.03824722021818161, -0.0006641580839641392, -0.017503933981060982, 0.05801821127533913, -0.045560989528894424, -0.06061352789402008, -0.03024027869105339, -0.02771327644586563, 0.01726660691201687, -0.053343985229730606, 0.004643643274903297, 0.023017525672912598, -0.005018893629312515, -0.005314180627465248, -0.0022807540372014046, -0.015905767679214478, 0.0038116544019430876, 0.040540583431720734, -0.04896219074726105, 0.034425538033246994, 0.04472462460398674, 0.07771860808134079, -0.003044022247195244, 0.023154927417635918, -0.046952024102211, -0.016198329627513885, 0.0185814518481493, -0.04636387899518013, 0.02965409681200981, 0.01673058047890663, -0.005501829087734222, 0.014380010776221752, 0.0013737297849729657, -0.011234891600906849, 0.04927230253815651, -0.06478114426136017, 0.022853704169392586, 0.04372778907418251, 0.02456098422408104, 0.028091954067349434, -0.0477522648870945, -0.00802603829652071, -0.0053585064597427845, -0.02253733202815056, 0.005374997854232788, -0.032622747123241425, 0.016344541683793068, 0.03604118153452873, 0.01761382818222046, -0.03699135780334473, -0.007025276310741901, 0.024455353617668152, -0.00633065402507782, 0.01795423962175846, 0.055159203708171844, 0.01628079265356064, -0.06118528172373772, 0.016226856037974358, 0.011655389331281185, -0.007583968341350555, 0.027121394872665405, 0.029646798968315125, -0.006687890272587538, 0.08054941892623901, -0.026075422763824463, 0.017458174377679825, 0.01300025824457407, -0.003046949626877904, -0.029600519686937332, -0.01139760296791792, -0.008105134591460228, 0.06443057954311371, -0.006107947323471308, 0.034265294671058655, 0.05271494761109352, -0.02716144546866417, -0.01198465097695589, 0.014281799085438251, -0.033181142061948776, 0.02568376436829567, 0.051062602549791336, -0.014031263999640942, 0.03386138752102852, 0.006061953492462635, -0.059027235954999924, -0.0017705709906294942, -0.038367919623851776, -0.007626263424754143, -0.04608537256717682, -0.011815864592790604, 0.027350522577762604, 0.03548921272158623, 0.01993994414806366, -0.032157495617866516, 0.02730661816895008, -0.011047905310988426, -0.018865255638957024, 0.005865131970494986, 0.0037806930486112833, -0.044439274817705154, 0.022409578785300255, 0.008709520101547241, -0.014066207222640514, 0.03642601519823074, 0.012771646492183208, -0.039810337126255035, 0.030311910435557365, 0.011522436514496803, -0.047321829944849014, -0.016078677028417587, -0.024852432310581207, 0.015374814160168171, -0.004301715176552534, -0.03429488465189934, 0.023050613701343536, -0.0017898350488394499, -0.06879943609237671, 0.019601918756961823, -0.053231075406074524, -0.012109990231692791, 0.0030917017720639706, -0.008642054162919521, -0.03318005055189133, 0.010206440463662148, 0.018129507079720497, 0.004559410735964775, -0.016717934980988503, -0.002988432999700308, -0.06188170611858368, -0.040269847959280014, 0.028186611831188202, 0.0065310331992805, 0.034279756247997284, 0.01951955072581768, -0.04442290589213371, 0.053757425397634506, 0.06355724483728409, -0.0005497295060195029, -0.07670924812555313, -0.008599904365837574, -0.05412255972623825, 0.01471812091767788, -0.006295301951467991, 0.03255981579422951, 0.05949768051505089, 0.012513990513980389, 0.0023491522297263145, 0.05667014420032501, 0.03367650508880615, 0.0036150761879980564, -0.008660709485411644, 0.004733104724436998, 0.019087612628936768, -0.047888778150081635, 0.03980962187051773, 0.01740182749927044, -0.0008292710990644991, 0.020772481337189674, 0.011220083571970463, -0.010879389010369778, 0.0011739631881937385, -0.009987764991819859, 0.008446180261671543, 0.015764867886900902, 0.048947639763355255, -0.028813110664486885, 0.014722884632647038, 0.012102076783776283, -0.0147659070789814, -0.003625766607001424, 0.012552259489893913, 0.015285030007362366, -0.008898213505744934, -0.018438709899783134, 0.0817226767539978, 0.04867804795503616, -0.027003269642591476, 0.03117135353386402, -0.000024716749976505525, -0.003054853295907378, 0.0035388809628784657, -0.0688619464635849, -0.031299006193876266, 0.06084541976451874, 0.04952497407793999, 0.011311044916510582, 0.035374950617551804, -0.03207714110612869, 0.0075169941410422325, 0.0035853951703757048, 0.02084752917289734, -0.035667043179273605, 0.046275489032268524, -0.008921943604946136, 0.03299282118678093, 0.03147834911942482, 0.0014471107861027122, -0.006726833060383797, 0.007221321575343609, -0.050894517451524734, 0.01972482167184353, 0.021930783987045288, -0.037981923669576645, 0.013128126040101051, -0.03936682268977165, -0.006277576554566622, 0.01710902713239193, -0.01357530988752842, 0.026811594143509865, 0.0006269838777370751, -0.06747783720493317, 0.006887509487569332, 0.004787036683410406, 0.0037117504980415106, -0.035803988575935364, -0.012212136760354042, 0.05188405513763428, -0.0040313308127224445, 0.03749139606952667, 0.02991892211139202, -0.007191391196101904, 0.032521117478609085, -0.03155799210071564, 0.0031133806332945824, 0.04996347054839134, 0.03927192836999893, 0.07379090040922165, 0.022066157311201096, -0.06412658095359802, -0.03469158336520195, -0.016743253916502, -0.00117907440289855, 0.07004810124635696, -0.019800590351223946, -0.0015061750309541821, 0.008564043790102005, -0.029668550938367844, -0.01645941659808159, 0.0062975105829536915, -0.008509251289069653, -0.0031558757182210684, 0.012274540029466152, 0.030957728624343872, -0.006820196285843849, 0.017416993156075478, 0.06310898065567017, 0.009818540886044502, 0.008851077407598495, -0.02432892471551895, -0.035273972898721695, -0.021546313539147377, -0.02625076100230217, 0.04946405813097954, 0.011653749272227287, 0.0036815409548580647, -0.024497831240296364, 0.027161862701177597, -0.003614772344008088, -0.034218207001686096, -0.01430221926420927, 0.02680976502597332, 0.01338544487953186, -0.013056989759206772, -0.009941711090505123, -0.006748822517693043, 0.040381599217653275, 0.04089335352182388, 0.006106250919401646, 0.030473822727799416, -0.10056059062480927, -0.015786191448569298, 0.02752796560525894, 0.0730382427573204, -0.015344216488301754, -0.017766103148460388, -0.04359200969338417, -0.011315541341900826, 0.03190523758530617, -0.024647053331136703, 0.00476273987442255, 0.0010992579627782106, 0.028299422934651375, -0.023175962269306183, -0.024727635085582733, -0.06555207818746567, -0.006820859387516975, -0.058300603181123734, 0.03764619305729866, -0.025630859658122063, -0.047180015593767166, -0.008234563283622265, 0.01605779118835926, -0.016252964735031128, 0.03655083104968071, -0.0350237675011158, -0.02268529310822487, 0.04120727255940437, 0.0032042013481259346, -0.019527127966284752, -0.04228629171848297, 0.051604896783828735, 0.007123182062059641, 0.007565482519567013, 0.044990383088588715, -0.004387134686112404, 0.017637696117162704, 0.010066760703921318, 0.019546736031770706, -0.009663847275078297, 0.0016967908013612032, 0.0058312625624239445, 0.061636511236429214, 0.007095308043062687, -0.02053801156580448, 0.060084618628025055, -0.0047874185256659985, 0.013609620742499828, -0.029695704579353333, -0.07271253317594528, -0.04033037647604942, -0.007282013539224863, 0.013604159466922283, -0.04787870869040489, -0.028284171596169472, -0.0040748389437794685, 0.01416074763983488, -0.042386580258607864, 0.005164622329175472, -0.010390780866146088, 0.03391014412045479, 0.04562656581401825, 0.017574582248926163, -0.01042054034769535, -0.015273286029696465, -0.012471078895032406, -0.010708792135119438, 0.0027010643389075994, 0.008557947352528572, 0.0329693965613842, -0.045547742396593094, -0.02682509273290634, 0.0018678558990359306, -0.011685763485729694, -0.0010316591942682862, 0.001530362293124199, -0.0301470048725605, -0.0033478732220828533, -0.04006693512201309, 0.006414874456822872, 0.0028007342480123043, 0.04514197260141373, 0.01972382143139839, -0.022837745025753975, -0.007229431997984648, 0.03206246718764305, -0.004146839492022991, 0.004832214675843716, -0.03187853470444679, 0.035282861441373825, -0.016876934096217155, -0.006112948525696993, -0.04624436795711517, -0.0054710628464818, -0.0020598226692527533, 0.020256083458662033, -0.03524922579526901, -0.07103721052408218, -0.03593356907367706, -0.01371676940470934, 0.000821762892883271, -0.00006888020288897678, 0.03387223184108734, -0.012634973041713238, 0.00043902869219891727, 0.020549938082695007, 0.002091667614877224, 0.047928884625434875, -0.023815376684069633, 0.020969323813915253, 0.0014139842242002487, 0.0008489322499372065, 0.010950294323265553, 0.01677212119102478, -0.04600980132818222, -0.030564257875084877, -0.02771274745464325, -0.020890912041068077, 0.009518641047179699, 0.04785275459289551, 0.007414264138787985, -0.023930644616484642, -0.019093871116638184, -0.002077478915452957, 0.022133756428956985, -0.02453492395579815, -0.01374118123203516, -0.025452254340052605, 0.007587804924696684, -0.026894673705101013, 0.02322644554078579, -0.010872798040509224, -0.01777550019323826, -0.01609824411571026, -0.005332434084266424, -0.06914328038692474, 0.03411417827010155, 0.0665258914232254, -0.021383317187428474, 0.03183669596910477, 0.006730512250214815, -0.028418362140655518, 0.03164537623524666, 0.03692501783370972, -0.023373564705252647, -0.039635248482227325, 0.012190373614430428, -0.057612448930740356, 0.017804550006985664, -0.03596431761980057, 0.004604046232998371, 0.03479447960853577, 0.02124224603176117, 0.03495047613978386, 0.04919042810797691, 0.024727292358875275, -0.020170288160443306, -0.01609007641673088, -0.006928547285497189, -0.0034181317314505577, 0.01800972782075405, 0.040137890726327896, -0.0302969291806221, -0.009227655827999115, 0.054678622633218765, 0.06900622695684433, 0.014186827465891838, 0.07206746935844421, -0.015643611550331116, -0.04393628612160683, 0.027900248765945435, -0.015320884063839912, -0.03308816999197006, 0.05058526620268822, -0.025426071137189865, 0.017455121502280235, -0.019919557496905327, -0.037219155579805374, 0.009857636876404285, 0.027362177148461342, -0.021802473813295364, -0.017342280596494675, -0.05801185593008995, -0.08465422689914703, 0.024030787870287895, 0.009266217239201069, -0.04344458132982254, 0.04480819031596184, 0.0004867075476795435, -0.003833064576610923, -0.03520801290869713, 0.06455360352993011, -0.04401097074151039, -0.04716502130031586, -0.042958542704582214, -0.018803423270583153, -0.029470084235072136, 0.051895346492528915, -0.005002095829695463, -0.002594688208773732, 0.02580413594841957, -0.0486493781208992, 0.02847110480070114, 0.018616624176502228, 0.017091922461986542, 0.02503504417836666, 0.04416611045598984, -0.03690449893474579, 0.013912005349993706, -0.00750216469168663, 0.00007929524144856259, 0.15665237605571747, 0.060843683779239655, 0.028760414570569992, -0.053614236414432526, 0.028356418013572693, 0.04624943807721138, 0.012415535748004913, -0.02005799673497677, -0.015262500382959843, 0.019955506548285484, -0.02048991620540619, 0.05549660697579384, 0.04870685189962387, 0.03942585736513138, -0.018751008436083794, 0.02043568715453148, -0.031255125999450684, -0.0333612859249115, -0.01152799278497696, 0.03712920472025871, 0.022564725950360298, -0.04345935583114624, -0.013305369764566422, -0.00406852550804615, 0.04524178057909012, -0.01372660230845213, -0.031523529440164566, 0.0022526318207383156, -0.0029692952521145344, 0.017726868391036987, -0.023172808811068535, 0.029173510149121284, 0.03968663513660431, 0.02047346904873848, -0.010401347652077675, -0.009814837947487831, 0.01587543450295925, -0.0472068190574646, 0.019878875464200974, 0.007263150531798601, 0.016375435516238213, 0.01305010449141264, 0.023041043430566788, 0.045729998499155045, -0.023693310096859932, -0.00492078298702836, -0.02804197184741497, 0.019685378298163414, 0.01074189879000187, -0.017702359706163406, 0.007468267809599638, -0.012526081874966621, 0.00044856526073999703, -0.03692817687988281, -0.039658475667238235, 0.0020728919189423323, 0.00004357401485322043, 0.00913996621966362, 0.011033369228243828, -0.0092230886220932, 0.023713577538728714, -0.011963068507611752, 0.034827593713998795, 0.06291395425796509, -0.004222815856337547, -0.009303240105509758, -0.0359041690826416, 0.06621243059635162, -0.03964819014072418, 0.05891840159893036, -0.004995747469365597, 0.0029129586182534695, 0.005929849576205015, -0.032471563667058945, 0.009685100056231022, 0.012336383573710918, 0.035022005438804626, 0.011062187142670155, -0.01754196360707283, 0.02632891573011875, -0.04085400700569153, 0.006198196206241846, -0.03541062772274017, -0.003961416892707348, -0.028594933450222015, 0.014912126585841179, 0.039896730333566666, 0.005550452508032322, 0.030061103403568268, 0.007848136126995087, 0.011434836313128471, 0.06666327267885208, 0.00913681648671627, -0.02924182079732418, -0.02664649672806263, 0.006883020978420973, 0.0032874459866434336, -0.012524808757007122, -0.00595809007063508, 0.04998141527175903, 0.04926597699522972, 0.0008099665283225477, -0.01752784475684166, 0.005438633728772402, -0.002241414273157716, -0.031702920794487, -0.001861811731941998, -0.027113180607557297, -0.022814184427261353, 0.05451684817671776, -0.03115081787109375, -0.011452315375208855, -0.024777071550488472, -0.04619961231946945, -0.04750354215502739, -0.002059726510196924, -0.03367868810892105, -0.012126198969781399, -0.01898871548473835, 0.0016627771547064185, -0.0338076613843441, -0.005618198774755001, -0.012092373333871365, -0.03100699745118618, -0.017401689663529396, -0.0413360558450222, -0.0008265986107289791, -0.03312867879867554, -0.009747001342475414, -0.0421137660741806, 0.03691389039158821, 0.02833934873342514, 0.009307232685387135, 0.024715421721339226, 0.004190760664641857, -0.021096261218190193, 0.02199636399745941, 0.0468062125146389, 0.016564562916755676, 0.0038134537171572447, 0.02282566763460636, -0.06893257051706314, -0.019396694377064705, 0.015042869374155998, 0.00615322170779109, 0.004063461907207966, 0.00052434898680076, 0.016649765893816948, 0.0077337417751550674, 0.07580335438251495, -0.030516546219587326, 0.0002932559291366488, -0.00955545250326395, -0.012550126761198044, -0.020189007744193077, 0.002974430564790964, -0.011417829431593418, 0.027331329882144928, 0.00738650793209672, -0.006575396750122309, 0.035493239760398865, -0.014334877021610737, -0.026917601004242897, -0.028102392330765724, -0.050571270287036896, -0.019053811207413673, 0.010180988349020481, -0.02694389969110489, -0.000027319250875734724, 0.05415424332022667, -0.017732098698616028, 0.011618747375905514, -0.0191744826734066, 0.02591530792415142, -0.07667314261198044, -0.0157865509390831, 0.02379188872873783, 0.019646301865577698, 0.014150403439998627, -0.040181830525398254, 0.02492976374924183, -0.0002058801765087992, -0.04906304553151131, 0.026860661804676056, 0.027733955532312393, 0.023715782910585403, -0.005178575869649649, 0.01802409626543522, -0.0004755611880682409, 0.031395912170410156, 0.02180909737944603, 0.0188180822879076, 0.050292108207941055, 0.005602406337857246, 0.003643400501459837, -0.049976419657468796, -0.027755210176110268, 0.019649596884846687, 0.02052275463938713, -0.08316908776760101, -0.006726222578436136, -0.004451415501534939, -0.03821799159049988, -0.016915950924158096, -0.05014600604772568, 0.016362639144062996, 0.02501952089369297, 0.04579223692417145, 0.044156789779663086, 0.026154592633247375, 0.03096209093928337, 0.0044876583851873875, -0.023454030975699425, -0.010867667384445667, 0.010981498286128044, -0.011771217919886112, -0.06859324872493744, 0.04131963104009628, 0.014882930554449558, 0.008378828875720501, -0.04071982577443123, -0.0161574799567461, -0.042426977306604385, -0.013128950260579586, -0.022570626810193062, 0.03227407485246658, 0.01879911683499813, -0.02508872002363205, -0.054633092135190964, -0.043413907289505005, 0.00573806231841445, 0.0157766230404377, 0.0601961649954319, 0.004521745257079601, 0.031580518931150436, -0.02467930130660534, -0.012506873346865177, -0.02171619050204754, 0.01775357685983181, 0.009837671183049679, -0.021258756518363953, -0.009053275920450687, -0.008987524546682835, -0.010286279954016209, -0.038971949368715286, 0.012757307849824429, -0.02579239010810852, 0.02525479346513748, -0.006902194116264582, 0.007906398735940456, 0.03188146650791168, 0.00929163210093975, 0.02817183919250965, -0.0691663846373558, 0.04176298528909683, 0.027891097590327263, -0.01611032523214817, 0.013940573669970036, 0.015248121693730354, -0.07038319110870361, 0.09385062754154205, 0.025502488017082214, 0.026604581624269485, -0.00455846032127738, 0.013821516185998917, 0.0063139572739601135, -0.019558127969503403, -0.09179963916540146, 0.022300876677036285, -0.008685723878443241, -0.04469883069396019, 0.010139300487935543, 0.017176654189825058, 0.0084905456751585, 0.023944314569234848, -0.049993231892585754, -0.015565957874059677, 0.011033703573048115, 0.025801338255405426, 0.0045343791134655476, 0.01987568847835064, -0.0010672083590179682, -0.019765248522162437, 0.03963867947459221, -0.03214089572429657, 0.02725699543952942, 0.04211961477994919, 0.009388407692313194, -0.0025559060741215944, 0.05528614670038223, -0.027454804629087448, 0.0026055630296468735, 0.032049618661403656, -0.00005759734631283209, -0.004205376375466585, -0.057598333805799484, 0.013532162643969059, -0.0006527649238705635, 0.00216230028308928, 0.008794907480478287, -0.007895379327237606, -0.020561352372169495, 0.06379643082618713, -0.02035566046833992, 0.035810686647892, -0.021393990144133568, -0.05410342663526535, 0.05515671893954277, -0.012851483188569546, -0.010965568944811821, 0.0015144969802349806, -0.0010528737911954522, 0.040745124220848083, -0.047564711421728134, 0.018643589690327644, -0.052845921367406845, 0.02560930885374546, -0.015374240465462208, -0.018300531432032585, -0.007080378010869026, -0.022505398839712143, -0.00850103609263897, -0.027753105387091637, 0.030376175418496132, 0.038342684507369995, -0.03858460485935211, 0.011791553348302841, 0.0004350020026322454, 0.0022180271334946156, 0.0029987997841089964, 0.005888679530471563, -0.03567589074373245, -0.032427042722702026, -0.02897343412041664, 0.016984404996037483, 0.0044481889344751835, -0.047740720212459564, 0.00925503857433796, 0.01677444949746132, -0.021759798750281334, -0.016465265303850174, 0.01241993810981512, -0.004381534177809954, 0.025050509721040726, -0.03470170497894287, -0.012898474931716919, 0.03178033232688904, 0.020012976601719856, -0.013035044074058533, -0.057523977011442184, -0.0010360411833971739, 0.008946740999817848, 0.02861517295241356, -0.020185915753245354, -0.016987226903438568, -0.016257036477327347, -0.0028998421039432287, -0.006513794418424368, -0.03559749200940132 ]
<p>Dear all, I was encouraged to ask this question here as well as on stackoverflow and would be very appreciative of any answers...</p> <p>Due to hetereoscedasticity I'm doing bootstrapped linear regression (appeals more to me than robust regression). I'd like to create a plot along the lines of what I've done in the script here. However the <code>fill=int</code> is not right since <code>int</code> should (I believe) be calculated using a bivariate normal distribution. </p> <ul> <li>Any idea how I could do that in this setting? </li> <li>Also is there a way for <code>bootcov</code> to return bias-corrected percentiles?</li> </ul> <p>sample script:</p> <pre><code>library(ggplot2) library(Hmisc) library(Design) # for ols() o&lt;-data.frame(value=rnorm(10,20,5), bc=rnorm(1000,60,50), age=rnorm(1000,50,20), ai=as.factor(round(runif(1000,0,4),0)), Gs=as.factor(round(runif(1000,0,6),0))) reg.s&lt;-function(x){ ols(value~as.numeric(bc)+as.numeric(age),data=x,x=T,y=T)-&gt;temp bootcov(temp,B=1000,coef.reps=T)-&gt;t2 return(t2) } dlply(o,.(ai,Gs),function(x) reg.s(x))-&gt;b.list llply(b.list,function(x) x[["boot.Coef"]])-&gt;b2 ks&lt;-llply(names(b2),function(x){ s&lt;-data.frame(b2[[x]]) s$ai&lt;-x return(s) }) ks3&lt;-do.call(rbind,ks) ks3$ai2&lt;-with(ks3,substring(ai,1,1)) ks3$gc2&lt;-sapply(strsplit(as.character(ks3$ai), "\\."), "[[", 2) k&lt;-ks3 j&lt;-dlply(k,.(ai2,gc2),function(x){ i1&lt;-quantile(x$Intercept,probs=c(0.025,0.975))[1] i2&lt;-quantile(x$Intercept,probs=c(0.025,0.975))[2] j1&lt;-quantile(x$bc,probs=c(0.025,0.975))[1] j2&lt;-quantile(x$bc,probs=c(0.025,0.975))[2] o&lt;-x$Intercept&gt;i1 &amp; x$Intercept&lt;i2 p&lt;-x$bc&gt;j1 &amp; x$bc&lt;j2 h&lt;-o &amp; p return(h) }) m&lt;-melt(j) ks3$int&lt;-m[,1] ggplot(ks3,aes(x=bc,y=Intercept,fill=int)) + geom_point(,alpha=0.3,size=1,shape=21) + facet_grid(gc2~ai2,scales = "free_y")+theme_bw()-&gt;plott plott&lt;-plott+opts(panel.grid.minor=theme_blank(),panel.grid.major=theme_blank()) plott&lt;-plott+geom_vline(x=0,color="red") plott+xlab("BC coefficient")+ylab("Intercept") </code></pre>
47,164
[ -0.006678787991404533, 0.028897570446133614, 0.0395367257297039, 0.028894983232021332, 0.035411152988672256, -0.04184198006987572, -0.050155751407146454, -0.04163217172026634, 0.04719042032957077, -0.034071311354637146, 0.04831049218773842, 0.05181599035859108, 0.052160438150167465, 0.04222865030169487, 0.0191195085644722, -0.012928810901939869, -0.013844605535268784, -0.024427538737654686, 0.0037341348361223936, 0.005150682758539915, 0.015913162380456924, 0.004232506733387709, -0.014063703827559948, -0.021982572972774506, 0.002570600714534521, 0.01950684003531933, 0.01847957633435726, -0.041443344205617905, -0.01013377495110035, 0.042201053351163864, -0.06919137388467789, -0.04688240587711334, 0.05748268589377403, 0.0043783714063465595, 0.04761539027094841, 0.011524645611643791, 0.02745085023343563, -0.020030668005347252, -0.01104792021214962, 0.0376986600458622, -0.019025219604372978, 0.03752027824521065, 0.029933622106909752, 0.029286041855812073, 0.029910476878285408, 0.0025017804000526667, -0.028426654636859894, 0.01742372289299965, 0.07591468840837479, -0.031006257981061935, 0.03344820812344551, -0.048015184700489044, 0.021567372605204582, 0.04074547067284584, -0.04721895605325699, -0.03704940900206566, 0.0813792273402214, 0.05269007384777069, 0.026696529239416122, -0.03678038716316223, 0.038078341633081436, -0.06544122099876404, -0.021636614575982094, 0.013735921122133732, 0.0008280515321530402, -0.01694645918905735, 0.0012305369600653648, -0.028086595237255096, 0.005795885808765888, -0.04721076041460037, 0.014595389366149902, 0.009571422822773457, -0.02083420380949974, -0.05917339771986008, 0.025248166173696518, -0.04139084741473198, 0.01856830343604088, -0.007246076595038176, 0.053819216787815094, -0.001732821692712605, -0.0077918898314237595, 0.00799589417874813, -0.0002064464642899111, 0.031973157078027725, 0.008655304089188576, 0.011813882738351822, 0.05278349667787552, -0.04747321084141731, 0.0548715740442276, 0.04352409020066261, -0.005906130652874708, 0.026568664237856865, 0.07696456462144852, 0.023041725158691406, -0.03180038556456566, 0.04328649863600731, -0.0035785746295005083, 0.04561380296945572, 0.0005487895105034113, 0.03556043654680252, -0.036758143454790115, -0.02121286652982235, 0.026704316958785057, 0.061977237462997437, 0.013648039661347866, -0.011999944224953651, -0.018975550308823586, -0.0477132648229599, 0.0009639685740694404, -0.02660955861210823, -0.033482715487480164, 0.019325854256749153, -0.02032453566789627, -0.024017220363020897, 0.026483891531825066, -0.030024653300642967, -0.02891433984041214, -0.005196422338485718, 0.04139029607176781, 0.025150123983621597, 0.009360842406749725, 0.012226900085806847, 0.01269459817558527, -0.012655056081712246, -0.021054454147815704, 0.026283107697963715, 0.013424349017441273, -0.007665483746677637, -0.05524414777755737, 0.021052788943052292, -0.037125688046216965, -0.044157642871141434, 0.04843640327453613, 0.030317841097712517, 0.00910536851733923, -0.06782694160938263, -0.07243309915065765, -0.037965528666973114, -0.0030235250014811754, -0.01731547899544239, 0.019184943288564682, -0.05863838270306587, 0.0015803524293005466, 0.024188563227653503, 0.03235694020986557, 0.011133384890854359, 0.024722155183553696, 0.009612416848540306, 0.0362582765519619, 0.015467694960534573, -0.0319753922522068, 0.007622689940035343, -0.03236622363328934, -0.021556496620178223, -0.014332101680338383, -0.0967208594083786, 0.010283020325005054, 0.005012658424675465, 0.0034695593640208244, 0.014870284125208855, 0.048644308000802994, -0.05370978266000748, -0.034034404903650284, -0.02643570676445961, -0.019153408706188202, -0.04191555455327034, 0.03675255924463272, 0.006219487637281418, 0.04138798639178276, 0.013877536170184612, -0.06994333118200302, -0.011125000193715096, -0.013383428566157818, 0.01656780205667019, 0.028446810320019722, -0.020722145214676857, 0.041468411684036255, -0.029823213815689087, 0.043524373322725296, 0.04068949073553085, -0.04905187711119652, -0.022510724142193794, -0.03763643652200699, -0.03859575837850571, 0.022041598334908485, -0.02284877561032772, 0.001989416778087616, 0.00621537072584033, 0.06467340886592865, -0.06267362833023071, -0.05647283047437668, -0.04552710801362991, -0.01268776599317789, 0.02025700733065605, -0.010829565115272999, 0.010400510393083096, -0.0022828388027846813, 0.04505133628845215, -0.007185065653175116, -0.018396442756056786, 0.018614917993545532, 0.029976313933730125, 0.06484568119049072, -0.05578002333641052, 0.024280549958348274, -0.0030640335753560066, 0.03173820301890373, -0.0015252047451213002, 0.056257300078868866, -0.03964151442050934, -0.031592149287462234, 0.007783264387398958, -0.042194120585918427, 0.013413790613412857, -0.0429515615105629, 0.0024520501028746367, 0.01497234683483839, 0.008405972272157669, -0.005014547612518072, 0.04209698736667633, -0.08609401434659958, 0.033705372363328934, 0.06509307771921158, -0.003294521477073431, -0.008815799839794636, 0.02738732099533081, -0.015692224726080894, 0.021126316860318184, -0.02801688015460968, -0.002948509529232979, -0.024896256625652313, 0.008514396846294403, 0.04416342452168465, 0.004522973671555519, 0.0021093301475048065, 0.011775706894695759, 0.029775986447930336, -0.021183831617236137, 0.019455352798104286, 0.0529743954539299, 0.017509352415800095, -0.012775330804288387, 0.04158249869942665, -0.01881840080022812, 0.032896995544433594, 0.0014363047666847706, 0.020913375541567802, -0.02092495746910572, 0.04128025844693184, 0.002528056502342224, 0.004748185630887747, 0.036054033786058426, 0.013712574727833271, -0.010770518332719803, -0.06077812984585762, -0.012513409368693829, 0.06177176907658577, -0.00199492066167295, -0.019566694274544716, 0.03240124136209488, -0.001344312448054552, -0.05179363116621971, 0.0009949326049536467, 0.011803746223449707, -0.01279317494481802, 0.0725817084312439, -0.029108813032507896, -0.025888532400131226, 0.016051601618528366, 0.014324887655675411, 0.01978924684226513, -0.022818000987172127, -0.00023160013370215893, -0.05058416724205017, 0.02434360422194004, 0.0033069478813558817, 0.019808446988463402, 0.00039051997009664774, 0.005825595464557409, -0.03652755171060562, -0.005634215194731951, 0.03446445241570473, 0.043233465403318405, -0.002659113612025976, -0.03734079375863075, -0.007793944329023361, -0.03867810592055321, -0.022757170721888542, -0.01596148870885372, 0.007075803354382515, -0.04337511956691742, 0.013468526303768158, 0.002807025099173188, -0.03145651891827583, -0.020726311951875687, -0.027382852509617805, -0.026745745912194252, -0.0423213467001915, -0.00942483451217413, 0.06073671579360962, 0.02960946410894394, -0.037611499428749084, 0.010468840599060059, -0.019177371636033058, 0.0026928409934043884, -0.008424792438745499, -0.015929924324154854, 0.01557127758860588, 0.03512256592512131, 0.0372018963098526, 0.025647137314081192, 0.018451470881700516, -0.023452797904610634, -0.06509552896022797, -0.02468126267194748, 0.041006751358509064, 0.018975529819726944, 0.022227484732866287, -0.005395364481955767, 0.013005223125219345, 0.059771936386823654, 0.042906828224658966, 0.015130994841456413, -0.054839279502630234, -0.028613723814487457, -0.01157610584050417, -0.036827195435762405, 0.02025856077671051, 0.0018081937450915575, 0.017363158985972404, -0.007465408183634281, -0.047609079629182816, 0.025483621284365654, 0.06340020895004272, 0.010635631158947945, 0.021382970735430717, 0.015748580917716026, -0.01796596311032772, -0.02564026415348053, 0.034621644765138626, 0.03400527685880661, -0.02654770389199257, 0.01253760140389204, -0.015418009832501411, -0.009812713600695133, -0.0064674555324018, -0.08545476198196411, 0.014794334769248962, -0.01589873991906643, 0.03354956954717636, -0.04570065438747406, 0.0003595134476199746, 0.019074825569987297, -0.056889139115810394, -0.017367135733366013, 0.007607476785778999, 0.04615196958184242, -0.030388733372092247, 0.001490425900556147, 0.013840005733072758, 0.024765554815530777, 0.022088903933763504, 0.00931202620267868, 0.0034113312140107155, -0.030598893761634827, -0.004575573373585939, -0.0689844936132431, -0.013387645594775677, 0.006718225311487913, 0.06664831191301346, -0.005398859735578299, 0.013831106945872307, -0.047823838889598846, 0.03597123548388481, -0.07116598635911942, -0.0097618717700243, -0.04881369695067406, 0.054957084357738495, 0.008231383748352528, 0.012749017216265202, 0.003363342024385929, 0.0018312083557248116, -0.009000731632113457, -0.00750663923099637, -0.07057137787342072, 0.02379048615694046, 0.019116384908556938, -0.00040852295933291316, 0.019867898896336555, -0.032338254153728485, 0.033833906054496765, -0.015725236386060715, 0.0025005158968269825, -0.000009507517461315729, 0.01832488551735878, -0.000990885542705655, 0.00885287206619978, 0.009339964017271996, -0.013534845784306526, -0.008316497318446636, -0.04573187232017517, -0.005002983380109072, -0.0197740588337183, 0.025286870077252388, 0.047039441764354706, 0.004334627650678158, -0.008282270282506943, -0.038338568061590195, 0.004032530821859837, -0.00040344003355130553, 0.03946792334318161, 0.06149031221866608, -0.003620362840592861, -0.08089074492454529, -0.006857420317828655, 0.003833798225969076, 0.063359834253788, 0.07506218552589417, 0.010258177295327187, -0.012262151576578617, -0.01343353372067213, -0.029823023825883865, 0.022903161123394966, 0.009263474494218826, -0.04712003096938133, -0.015037115663290024, 0.06877630949020386, 0.04128822684288025, 0.007783571258187294, -0.009541871026158333, 0.042321156710386276, 0.020825715735554695, 0.008633840829133987, -0.050401605665683746, -0.0027413086500018835, -0.028221653774380684, 0.01239168643951416, 0.021145906299352646, 0.0019193616462871432, -0.0019364452455192804, 0.009141604416072369, 0.061789605766534805, -0.00981197226792574, -0.03808462992310524, 0.01709541492164135, 0.03703461214900017, 0.053847793489694595, 0.016971338540315628, -0.009017296135425568, -0.03297872096300125, 0.03233639523386955, 0.0067815049551427364, 0.005344080273061991, 0.00029554637148976326, -0.08560939878225327, -0.0029062973335385323, 0.052910853177309036, 0.024665558710694313, -0.026932300999760628, -0.05234505236148834, -0.011036333627998829, -0.033510662615299225, 0.02765793725848198, -0.022287337109446526, -0.0010762447491288185, -0.006907473783940077, 0.041820067912340164, -0.0209187138825655, -0.025051867589354515, -0.0458441860973835, 0.02074195258319378, -0.04088618606328964, -0.004074589814990759, 0.0024706015828996897, -0.05588085576891899, 0.0043075717985630035, 0.039057813584804535, -0.0037792641669511795, 0.059283480048179626, -0.03931393474340439, -0.05354003608226776, -0.012773537077009678, 0.028400614857673645, -0.021241214126348495, -0.011699195951223373, 0.0310752522200346, -0.03412676975131035, -0.0024030746426433325, 0.027772746980190277, 0.026827611029148102, -0.021347101777791977, 0.029823653399944305, 0.057787008583545685, -0.0042208400554955006, -0.017090899869799614, -0.005212806630879641, 0.03624996915459633, 0.022111792117357254, -0.010949301533401012, 0.024348804727196693, 0.027893824502825737, -0.011047812178730965, 0.00804013293236494, -0.08642578125, -0.009389976970851421, -0.023048177361488342, -0.031806010752916336, -0.0694396123290062, -0.014382749795913696, -0.021224040538072586, -0.015748191624879837, 0.045084331184625626, 0.017543720081448555, -0.037358786910772324, -0.013517888262867928, 0.04166729748249054, 0.037034422159194946, -0.046127498149871826, -0.021218476817011833, -0.01924820803105831, -0.01467599906027317, 0.007559662684798241, -0.018164774402976036, 0.0074595012702047825, 0.005463038105517626, 0.020199257880449295, 0.01806509867310524, -0.07746440172195435, 0.02253747545182705, -0.02879144996404648, 0.033068686723709106, -0.015044656582176685, 0.002432644832879305, 0.009400829672813416, 0.022008534520864487, 0.041242990642786026, -0.0008188196807168424, -0.012408948503434658, 0.024519462138414383, 0.0365682952105999, -0.017775539308786392, -0.011670416221022606, -0.014409909956157207, 0.05227476358413696, 0.01165083795785904, -0.0013207320589572191, -0.046865809708833694, -0.02732826955616474, -0.017145773395895958, -0.017331374809145927, 0.011334508657455444, -0.0320948027074337, -0.03830172121524811, 0.010145245119929314, -0.024540051817893982, 0.06120781600475311, 0.03499025106430054, -0.021381132304668427, 0.025655623525381088, -0.037259411066770554, -0.003555675968527794, 0.0417325459420681, -0.004960326012223959, -0.009144923649728298, -0.015897860750555992, -0.002135654678568244, 0.0003668938297778368, 0.012116646394133568, -0.0018225499661639333, -0.04868421331048012, 0.023372892290353775, -0.015633972361683846, -0.0066783856600522995, 0.0429467037320137, 0.01852659322321415, -0.027802132070064545, -0.020493099465966225, -0.015131953172385693, 0.04682263359427452, -0.07966062426567078, -0.0326848179101944, -0.019593078643083572, 0.00014377421757671982, -0.028522521257400513, -0.005364331416785717, -0.014747422188520432, 0.0026870479341596365, -0.0028908243402838707, 0.0037968510296195745, -0.01816241256892681, 0.026001881808042526, 0.07085288316011429, -0.014102238230407238, 0.016612745821475983, -0.018264425918459892, -0.028416944667696953, 0.055656999349594116, 0.06979173421859741, -0.0245602335780859, 0.04879901558160782, 0.006797680631279945, -0.02390655130147934, -0.023368343710899353, -0.041067998856306076, -0.013651092536747456, 0.06226762384176254, -0.018320688977837563, 0.030079197138547897, 0.02334390953183174, 0.009807474911212921, 0.00635007256641984, -0.013860592618584633, -0.020770369097590446, 0.019387591630220413, 0.01886657066643238, 0.040198732167482376, -0.014268795028328896, -0.014181242324411869, 0.032249923795461655, 0.010394646786153316, -0.005776418838649988, 0.056232307106256485, 0.007400816772133112, 0.0012103667249903083, 0.018480902537703514, -0.012659119442105293, -0.006051304284483194, 0.03829190135002136, 0.00352568575181067, -0.003315194509923458, -0.03301983326673508, -0.029246626421809196, 0.04390142485499382, 0.028380440548062325, -0.006849184632301331, -0.0025510212872177362, -0.036280520260334015, -0.044399287551641464, -0.0034785261377692223, 0.033510614186525345, -0.06474041938781738, 0.03067060559988022, 0.015027357265353203, 0.023982543498277664, -0.01737591065466404, -0.005320049822330475, -0.055267319083213806, -0.07606444507837296, 0.0018121777102351189, 0.0063747623935341835, -0.03558247536420822, 0.021240606904029846, 0.025906434282660484, -0.021474841982126236, 0.027684856206178665, -0.03045145608484745, 0.006693735718727112, -0.013468929566442966, 0.03502928465604782, 0.023335356265306473, 0.04880700260400772, -0.02957332506775856, 0.0015371559420600533, 0.0071843997575342655, -0.03950023651123047, 0.13331614434719086, 0.04309993237257004, 0.036172643303871155, -0.06335808336734772, -0.016103697940707207, 0.026121405884623528, -0.027508368715643883, -0.006638639140874147, -0.020935749635100365, 0.039866574108600616, -0.02212466113269329, 0.06544950604438782, 0.03784296661615372, 0.0022913734428584576, 0.012780300341546535, 0.040892962366342545, -0.017193742096424103, -0.004153171554207802, -0.01269618608057499, 0.026875685900449753, -0.013167559169232845, -0.001125385519117117, -0.05012981966137886, 0.012619930319488049, -0.013652564026415348, -0.007069643121212721, -0.06001044064760208, -0.018763283267617226, -0.03646009415388107, 0.01609220914542675, -0.003684333758428693, 0.022033363580703735, -0.004664536565542221, -0.006730369757860899, 0.05848065763711929, 0.007141017355024815, -0.002092855516821146, -0.013888990506529808, 0.02554476261138916, 0.012662447988986969, 0.014193885028362274, 0.007414604537189007, -0.0059417118318378925, -0.016652539372444153, -0.007993718609213829, -0.02747129462659359, -0.0758574903011322, 0.0489068329334259, -0.017765730619430542, -0.023896226659417152, -0.014335796236991882, -0.004357366822659969, 0.01253590825945139, -0.013613466173410416, 0.012800569646060467, 0.047857094556093216, 0.029553813859820366, -0.004474373068660498, -0.0115119107067585, -0.013599091209471226, 0.023591218516230583, 0.017718806862831116, 0.053186435252428055, 0.01851014234125614, -0.02105587348341942, -0.02570192702114582, -0.027225375175476074, 0.06081179901957512, -0.017133984714746475, 0.004530461970716715, 0.02724379487335682, 0.009664411656558514, -0.0039054234512150288, -0.03226836770772934, -0.0014429641887545586, 0.009584346786141396, 0.010759980417788029, 0.008980135433375835, -0.04445134103298187, -0.023805247619748116, -0.006451066117733717, 0.01927422545850277, -0.0527007132768631, -0.04188550263643265, -0.007364428136497736, -0.004939728882163763, 0.005840715486556292, 0.02597043663263321, 0.018041575327515602, 0.006022583227604628, 0.0036733406595885754, 0.06857666373252869, 0.00781918317079544, -0.05866953358054161, -0.03733842074871063, 0.022676914930343628, -0.037826038897037506, -0.029910357668995857, -0.015384647995233536, 0.06729374825954437, 0.018827354535460472, 0.024310024455189705, -0.009073586203157902, 0.01751573383808136, 0.02430788055062294, 0.015697075054049492, 0.04259735718369484, -0.03812875226140022, 0.029864942654967308, 0.024794232100248337, 0.007724599447101355, -0.031576015055179596, -0.017860742285847664, -0.034164637327194214, -0.06581132113933563, 0.00783725269138813, -0.032127223908901215, -0.025037016719579697, 0.02394106611609459, -0.02692270837724209, 0.002560675609856844, -0.038164474070072174, -0.009293563663959503, -0.01336502656340599, -0.033383406698703766, 0.023370565846562386, -0.020875627174973488, 0.05228952690958977, 0.031119447201490402, 0.021983014419674873, 0.030598469078540802, 0.038921575993299484, 0.018378257751464844, 0.03131801262497902, 0.009457825683057308, -0.0045135365799069405, 0.00989121850579977, -0.004512896295636892, -0.009037969633936882, 0.01028248481452465, 0.006773266941308975, -0.02711249142885208, -0.034889329224824905, -0.0007917084731161594, 0.0034319793339818716, 0.016968300566077232, 0.009243462234735489, -0.022979499772191048, -0.044704269617795944, 0.050337716937065125, -0.007451849523931742, -0.005496077239513397, -0.021113086491823196, 0.02073846012353897, 0.029628774151206017, 0.006129813846200705, -0.01962505467236042, 0.01213765051215887, 0.03701735660433769, 0.0008512917556799948, 0.04585118964314461, 0.0005227465298958123, -0.0006235938635654747, -0.020144199952483177, -0.0062586101703345776, -0.02301854081451893, -0.023917900398373604, -0.0015042037703096867, 0.011229394003748894, 0.04888772964477539, 0.00916203297674656, 0.041397787630558014, -0.02669757418334484, 0.008040038868784904, -0.0860794261097908, -0.037000689655542374, 0.021567722782492638, -0.0019937751349061728, 0.04247269034385681, -0.007950703613460064, 0.005696162581443787, 0.015098143368959427, -0.048967115581035614, 0.01899542659521103, 0.01339260209351778, -0.00753473537042737, -0.027753954753279686, -0.017856599763035774, -0.04254072532057762, -0.011532009579241276, 0.04233808442950249, 0.005460387095808983, 0.021621445193886757, 0.032858576625585556, 0.039303045719861984, -0.027153193950653076, 0.004881719592958689, -0.006963246967643499, 0.03331464156508446, -0.05417008697986603, 0.009469246491789818, -0.02401406317949295, -0.005880736745893955, 0.013490420766174793, 0.0328817181289196, 0.011883803643286228, -0.02391134947538376, 0.035292334854602814, 0.019144224002957344, 0.05591877922415733, -0.00721616018563509, -0.005927777849137783, 0.026641936972737312, -0.01096896082162857, 0.037083376199007034, 0.02905728667974472, -0.0322786420583725, 0.04427425190806389, 0.048091158270835876, 0.01107069943100214, -0.019363319501280785, 0.03475586324930191, 0.009017943404614925, -0.013301076367497444, -0.033137042075395584, 0.008522494696080685, 0.009669698774814606, -0.038787826895713806, 0.00849951896816492, -0.06892698258161545, 0.0036660777404904366, 0.06012071296572685, 0.019728265702724457, 0.003476626006886363, 0.004900731611996889, -0.020088955760002136, -0.032999902963638306, 0.001404280192218721, -0.0006544067291542888, -0.03443801403045654, -0.04480396583676338, -0.042883653193712234, 0.004478395916521549, -0.009234859608113766, -0.01568550616502762, 0.028683673590421677, -0.03432389721274376, 0.04606366157531738, -0.028426632285118103, 0.021800462156534195, 0.012335262261331081, 0.017288200557231903, 0.008809446357190609, -0.06612542271614075, 0.0683806762099266, -0.01904316619038582, 0.003188885748386383, -0.050071340054273605, 0.009876123629510403, -0.020166520029306412, 0.02762760780751705, 0.016170231625437737, 0.04427045211195946, 0.00874249916523695, -0.010008750483393669, 0.015946494415402412, 0.001030598534271121, -0.033192433416843414, 0.053740669041872025, 0.012036007829010487, -0.006855751387774944, -0.0068623218685388565, 0.02407139167189598, -0.012926800176501274, 0.022256851196289062, 0.028305981308221817, -0.013863162137567997, 0.030393870547413826, 0.01503440085798502, -0.014010402373969555, 0.01590016297996044, -0.016058260574936867, -0.006576842628419399, 0.04865310713648796, 0.008183227851986885, -0.03629806637763977, 0.053445298224687576, -0.005299239885061979, -0.04327530413866043, 0.027408404275774956, -0.01746148243546486, -0.04117366671562195, -0.02348398044705391, -0.007452330086380243, -0.0060860831290483475, -0.04417742043733597, -0.007940827868878841, 0.016573641449213028, -0.03015880100429058, 0.012881027534604073, 0.025956394150853157, -0.014258820563554764, 0.03657136857509613, -0.03558500111103058, 0.01155879721045494, -0.008131565526127815, -0.05521692708134651, 0.026507187634706497, -0.01601215824484825, 0.023174909874796867, -0.018650533631443977, -0.01797228306531906, 0.012699777260422707, -0.019823044538497925, 0.03681951388716698, 0.012753576040267944, 0.06618823856115341, 0.00966077670454979, -0.016450610011816025, 0.0368952676653862, -0.007964052259922028, 0.07086827605962753, -0.02055717632174492, -0.0009131700498983264, 0.03802762180566788, -0.04606178402900696, -0.006729063577950001, -0.02366853691637516, -0.02236815355718136, -0.053539976477622986, -0.0012520765885710716, 0.004867379553616047, 0.039383891969919205, 0.014741016551852226, 0.05341463163495064, 0.031755365431308746, 0.004167445469647646, 0.05122099816799164, -0.004029777832329273, 0.04327370226383209, 0.012881556525826454, -0.024068893864750862, 0.01357657928019762, 0.007831208407878876, -0.0057441131211817265, -0.059036049991846085, 0.012122198939323425, 0.011211810633540154, 0.01437885221093893, -0.04666821286082268, -0.008835487067699432, 0.0034161291550844908, 0.04451150447130203, -0.06348022073507309, -0.016054708510637283, 0.001990195829421282, 0.006962677463889122, 0.024552587419748306, -0.061562974005937576 ]
<p>I conducted a multilevel analysis using repeated measures across four time points. The model contains intercept, linear slope and quadratic slope. I am interested in examining the extent to which variable A interacts with other identified variables in my model, so I added the interaction terms to intercept, linear slope and quadratic slope to estimate the fixed effects of these interactions. I then eliminated the non-significant interactions and retan the model until the interaction terms in the model were all significant. </p> <p>My questions are:</p> <ol> <li><p>When delete non-significant interactions from the model, if the interaction was significant on linear slope but not quadratic slope, should I still keep the non-significant one on quadratic slope? Or should I only keep the significant one on linear slope?</p></li> <li><p>How should I interpret an interaction on linear slope but not quadratic slope (or vice versa)?</p></li> </ol> <p>Thank you for your response in advance! Any advice is appreciated.</p>
73,408
[ -0.02612903155386448, 0.023801013827323914, 0.007562926039099693, 0.02770490199327469, 0.046580616384744644, 0.034241605550050735, -0.005379886366426945, -0.05290558189153671, 0.032589979469776154, -0.02864593081176281, 0.03778136521577835, 0.0009681216324679554, 0.06932078301906586, -0.0371839813888073, 0.02114046923816204, -0.016961578279733658, 0.006456902250647545, -0.00713007478043437, 0.019338760524988174, 0.015002229250967503, -0.07209820300340652, 0.0048441500402987, 0.004045202862471342, 0.003128305310383439, -0.039055246859788895, 0.06792370975017548, 0.06507151573896408, -0.028673291206359863, 0.0316317044198513, 0.03558358922600746, 0.001742956810630858, -0.022478945553302765, 0.008134959265589714, 0.0047739287838339806, 0.013504627160727978, 0.007578246295452118, -0.013585525564849377, -0.01686953380703926, 0.03675754740834236, 0.026076598092913628, -0.01881903037428856, -0.0230192132294178, -0.013439683243632317, 0.05189620703458786, -0.020244479179382324, -0.009842272847890854, -0.016693158075213432, 0.025544114410877228, 0.0713578462600708, -0.003178464015945792, 0.04915705695748329, 0.006347671616822481, 0.03752612695097923, 0.047312214970588684, -0.017697161063551903, -0.028492752462625504, 0.03368781879544258, 0.05720148980617523, 0.010914321057498455, -0.05866223946213722, -0.0337350070476532, -0.012571551837027073, -0.013741079717874527, 0.01133820228278637, -0.03725796565413475, 0.013923785649240017, 0.009451095946133137, -0.005014583934098482, 0.04259853437542915, -0.01460274774581194, 0.0014339324552565813, -0.006187999155372381, 0.044159092009067535, -0.009361094795167446, 0.0025523430667817593, -0.03462190553545952, 0.016754858195781708, 0.021142305806279182, 0.027405664324760437, 0.042393967509269714, -0.016621995717287064, 0.007553418166935444, 0.0011534846853464842, -0.0024462409783154726, 0.02227597124874592, 0.02134769968688488, 0.026734264567494392, -0.017559731379151344, 0.02997746132314205, 0.00448942556977272, -0.016702057793736458, 0.028490060940384865, 0.0539623461663723, 0.00887768529355526, -0.04916181042790413, 0.004239507019519806, -0.02476513758301735, 0.010751341469585896, 0.048286307603120804, 0.02590416744351387, -0.041714251041412354, -0.03245827928185463, 0.01314480323344469, 0.05819273740053177, 0.01018313504755497, 0.026231780648231506, -0.040984585881233215, 0.022421594709157944, 0.021798226982355118, -0.052797336131334305, 0.0011682957410812378, 0.00861415732651949, -0.004662257619202137, -0.0218674223870039, 0.039113160222768784, -0.007715270854532719, -0.015005982480943203, 0.0007593730697408319, 0.10097751766443253, 0.06710856407880783, 0.021657075732946396, -0.036777563393116, 0.030683347955346107, -0.005005070939660072, -0.0021459285635501146, -0.021802006289362907, 0.026432402431964874, -0.012526128441095352, -0.023521730676293373, 0.0711866170167923, 0.0385943166911602, 0.023977145552635193, -0.0012680842773988843, -0.01455648522824049, 0.0378027968108654, 0.016271628439426422, -0.0709628015756607, -0.050645630806684494, 0.02683209627866745, -0.017808780074119568, 0.030255593359470367, -0.03397506847977638, -0.030793190002441406, 0.025081459432840347, 0.08217382431030273, -0.008599556051194668, -0.012487291358411312, 0.03363674879074097, 0.04149187356233597, 0.0017212959937751293, -0.011606317013502121, -0.014283433556556702, -0.014472112990915775, -0.01787608303129673, -0.021607639268040657, -0.1088934987783432, 0.024138327687978745, 0.05060376971960068, 0.0006350810290314257, -0.0006358765531331301, 0.05820000171661377, -0.00867247860878706, -0.010654613375663757, 0.043789926916360855, 0.00912969745695591, -0.021364184096455574, 0.04677629470825195, -0.06583993881940842, 0.040069907903671265, 0.05076327547430992, 0.01693623699247837, 0.048515208065509796, -0.008486528880894184, 0.05888354033231735, 0.030588550493121147, -0.0076015121303498745, 0.014000100083649158, -0.025153985247015953, -0.007801717147231102, -0.0014774890150874853, -0.06263495236635208, -0.046318333595991135, -0.0317753441631794, 0.00961599312722683, 0.023424996063113213, 0.031110040843486786, -0.03430261090397835, -0.014965396374464035, 0.04563532769680023, -0.013323047198355198, -0.03813670203089714, -0.06351576745510101, 0.037602636963129044, -0.020852835848927498, -0.046011388301849365, 0.0014143732842057943, -0.015197907574474812, 0.0062148855067789555, -0.023847954347729683, 0.008867261931300163, -0.0107461828738451, 0.012632057070732117, 0.014752956107258797, -0.04175863415002823, 0.04389077052474022, 0.04450009763240814, 0.053180087357759476, -0.016480188816785812, 0.047368768602609634, -0.05092356353998184, -0.02635502628982067, 0.020304035395383835, -0.032716963440179825, 0.0047745658084750175, -0.037374354898929596, -0.006438002455979586, -0.011327793821692467, -0.0050911749713122845, -0.05530724674463272, 0.037124697118997574, -0.06980311870574951, 0.06570782512426376, 0.037444934248924255, -0.010883328504860401, -0.015294631943106651, 0.03718055412173271, 0.019927524030208588, 0.016327396035194397, -0.01992640644311905, 0.005820952821522951, -0.0493321530520916, -0.03224582597613335, 0.04890161380171776, 0.02040913887321949, -0.031697630882263184, 0.04328310117125511, 0.06573323905467987, 0.010176999494433403, -0.000020151106582488865, 0.02955719456076622, -0.002151952590793371, -0.03495420888066292, 0.020308956503868103, 0.015152791514992714, 0.0065465099178254604, 0.028337471187114716, 0.008160802535712719, 0.0009594307048246264, 0.01374751515686512, -0.004055570345371962, 0.018201082944869995, 0.04603147879242897, 0.023022901266813278, 0.03814256191253662, -0.008998819626867771, 0.0013220268301665783, 0.0388609915971756, -0.008111878298223019, 0.020404532551765442, 0.02882133610546589, -0.011885244399309158, -0.03749585524201393, 0.010441956110298634, -0.015977689996361732, 0.003866876009851694, 0.012464647181332111, -0.047832805663347244, -0.029321465641260147, 0.009637214243412018, -0.013033184222877026, -0.00006296973879216239, -0.03516394644975662, -0.010723898187279701, -0.019617505371570587, -0.0059913345612585545, 0.014501090161502361, -0.010097150690853596, 0.0364048033952713, -0.048618245869874954, -0.001014149165712297, 0.016245190054178238, -0.05102493241429329, -0.004671201109886169, 0.008619824424386024, -0.045129772275686264, -0.01591004617512226, -0.03030186891555786, -0.021712398156523705, 0.020902277901768684, 0.007376379799097776, 0.0009837046964094043, 0.03691357746720314, -0.011185301467776299, -0.029932528734207153, -0.04031790420413017, -0.010557078756392002, 0.01904732920229435, -0.02606535144150257, -0.05787268280982971, 0.042553745210170746, 0.014039956964552402, -0.023646486923098564, 0.011423829942941666, -0.02095455676317215, -0.0031897295266389847, 0.016588564962148666, 0.0038716758135706186, 0.04658179357647896, 0.042438942939043045, 0.01663951948285103, -0.019959451630711555, -0.04764572158455849, 0.026380881667137146, -0.08753130584955215, -0.05359965190291405, 0.022566240280866623, 0.01006738655269146, 0.027949858456850052, -0.010980291292071342, -0.003200270002707839, 0.06919921934604645, 0.03660076484084129, -0.013192986138164997, -0.05742798373103142, -0.012290243990719318, -0.030040688812732697, -0.034461166709661484, 0.009271628223359585, 0.020583495497703552, 0.01298296358436346, -0.004047914408147335, -0.019294925034046173, 0.05079855024814606, 0.02986055426299572, 0.03803863376379013, 0.01173766516149044, 0.010722657665610313, -0.0030124643817543983, -0.004036392085254192, 0.0159903671592474, -0.0030291264411062002, 0.005923790391534567, 0.005729615688323975, 0.017817547544836998, 0.008003403432667255, 0.023399177938699722, -0.05300365760922432, 0.0041280826553702354, -0.03460109233856201, -0.014938742853701115, -0.02330217882990837, 0.013246064074337482, 0.02943495474755764, -0.0030819466337561607, 0.005847908556461334, -0.007436990737915039, 0.04275304824113846, -0.0033304248936474323, 0.0210268534719944, 0.05828472226858139, 0.04030148312449455, -0.025286978110671043, 0.028934285044670105, -0.0020584426820278168, -0.00749298045411706, 0.008550562895834446, -0.01243436150252819, -0.008086210116744041, 0.03581208735704422, 0.023591553792357445, -0.027411069720983505, 0.005274860188364983, -0.0602722242474556, -0.017407115548849106, -0.08150000125169754, 0.0290524885058403, -0.05029027536511421, 0.04224986210465431, -0.014410312287509441, 0.0029922304674983025, 0.01114373654127121, -0.03870979696512222, -0.017574520781636238, 0.02374049834907055, -0.06074545532464981, 0.03350730985403061, -0.024951476603746414, -0.01596970111131668, 0.019679488614201546, -0.009532242082059383, 0.003946264274418354, -0.027216386049985886, -0.006002909503877163, 0.024801883846521378, 0.038437146693468094, 0.0084898816421628, -0.01174420677125454, -0.04128854349255562, -0.03688559681177139, -0.026482360437512398, 0.0015203084331005812, 0.03935046121478081, -0.03376981243491173, 0.013241628184914589, 0.0378093495965004, -0.022857584059238434, -0.007048780098557472, -0.04823724180459976, -0.03586049750447273, 0.05238155275583267, 0.01730531081557274, 0.007083590608090162, 0.005147881340235472, -0.04339165985584259, 0.018719717860221863, 0.006615384481847286, 0.037210267037153244, 0.0170002244412899, 0.018409794196486473, -0.03882317990064621, -0.03308830037713051, -0.0015323833795264363, 0.015598740428686142, 0.03939425200223923, -0.026669273152947426, -0.01594833843410015, 0.04538203403353691, 0.026113666594028473, -0.06313467025756836, 0.06285543739795685, 0.04716872051358223, 0.05359435826539993, 0.005214622709900141, -0.05549003928899765, -0.015187202021479607, 0.009196660481393337, 0.01678595319390297, 0.030806204304099083, -0.003314172150567174, 0.021080853417515755, -0.010014425031840801, 0.039382051676511765, 0.038479581475257874, -0.03329361602663994, 0.018526434898376465, -0.0002949122281279415, 0.04484770447015762, -0.013289379887282848, -0.03262808918952942, 0.01675686612725258, 0.04136165603995323, 0.019165202975273132, -0.0006050458760000765, 0.02465413510799408, -0.11076896637678146, 0.002021301072090864, 0.029667487367987633, 0.045716218650341034, -0.038916755467653275, -0.002283362438902259, -0.01948671042919159, -0.010390940122306347, 0.006625765934586525, -0.015756674110889435, 0.04125611111521721, -0.023464201018214226, 0.04213361442089081, -0.03241422772407532, -0.034719597548246384, -0.03603638708591461, 0.016202185302972794, 0.005861520767211914, 0.027337851002812386, -0.0007850556285120547, -0.03160976618528366, -0.04847064986824989, 0.036519911140203476, 0.025542136281728745, 0.023590166121721268, -0.032894182950258255, 0.0038942047394812107, -0.004892583005130291, -0.0025334202218800783, -0.02930118329823017, -0.06987544894218445, 0.027777398005127907, -0.0021144687198102474, -0.026705699041485786, 0.05472785234451294, 0.00758326705545187, -0.031609561294317245, -0.020421961322426796, 0.016027944162487984, 0.012621477246284485, -0.04361800476908684, -0.01954234205186367, 0.06648349016904831, 0.021427053958177567, -0.005891235079616308, 0.05304717645049095, 0.02323189005255699, -0.022030234336853027, -0.004151454661041498, -0.025039030238986015, 0.01692674309015274, -0.04025745019316673, -0.008676431141793728, -0.03879552707076073, -0.008724977262318134, -0.01723472774028778, 0.04490768909454346, -0.024198947474360466, 0.01645810529589653, -0.051056671887636185, -0.03491135686635971, -0.012530934065580368, 0.030449286103248596, -0.01604469306766987, 0.0053298273123800755, 0.008795464411377907, 0.013158165849745274, -0.02333971858024597, -0.025921184569597244, 0.0017274979036301374, -0.013628662563860416, -0.010801069438457489, 0.00748958857730031, -0.0038778362795710564, 0.0005842236569151282, 0.00004717921183328144, -0.0557909831404686, -0.02905805967748165, -0.03629332408308983, -0.01386262197047472, -0.026209358125925064, 0.01644112728536129, -0.032808028161525726, -0.05374092236161232, 0.004879006650298834, 0.051647257059812546, -0.0010310179786756635, 0.010884538292884827, 0.003879118710756302, 0.0680832713842392, -0.0012441175058484077, 0.011130030266940594, -0.043636057525873184, -0.07436571270227432, 0.007046892773360014, 0.001403170172125101, -0.014001166447997093, -0.006670289672911167, -0.003265144769102335, -0.026750393211841583, 0.0030396818183362484, 0.0097934789955616, 0.05030013620853424, -0.04558044299483299, 0.006529322825372219, 0.008998773992061615, 0.05624201148748398, 0.06253658980131149, -0.025855259969830513, -0.02342585287988186, 0.00508099514991045, -0.021112212911248207, -0.025953056290745735, -0.03196455538272858, 0.005335538182407618, -0.02969488687813282, -0.0030127596110105515, -0.028250206261873245, 0.013345331884920597, 0.05820139870047569, 0.0026012160815298557, -0.030633172020316124, -0.008522159419953823, 0.002311329124495387, 0.00493571488186717, 0.0052446285262703896, -0.005698256194591522, 0.004421809688210487, 0.04307016730308533, 0.031282275915145874, 0.06279624253511429, -0.018935155123472214, -0.021646451205015182, 0.039957787841558456, -0.030553225427865982, -0.04961339011788368, 0.005721778143197298, 0.07031453400850296, 0.006950819864869118, 0.023570314049720764, -0.013267012313008308, -0.0197775736451149, 0.07494353502988815, -0.017671046778559685, -0.0054657431319355965, 0.005317016039043665, 0.010989916510879993, -0.026744350790977478, -0.047678299248218536, -0.021726781502366066, -0.022070785984396935, 0.0535648912191391, -0.010381320491433144, 0.018568167462944984, 0.05197684466838837, -0.021709958091378212, 0.014781367033720016, -0.02671656385064125, 0.014064816758036613, -0.013055325485765934, 0.03476443514227867, 0.06268443167209625, -0.009059052914381027, -0.009378599934279919, 0.03208883851766586, 0.011258686892688274, 0.008690642192959785, 0.005506619811058044, 0.041730765253305435, 0.029967673122882843, 0.0477483794093132, -0.004279909655451775, -0.054978787899017334, 0.03692859038710594, -0.046635355800390244, 0.004598365630954504, -0.04335342347621918, -0.024772752076387405, 0.017738431692123413, 0.07609233260154724, 0.03214649856090546, -0.05596277862787247, 0.0036117120180279016, -0.04215530678629875, -0.004751278553158045, 0.012683050706982613, -0.00954458862543106, 0.005895550362765789, 0.021524548530578613, 0.05529564991593361, -0.01424177922308445, 0.016735533252358437, -0.033766746520996094, -0.07272825390100479, -0.016525745391845703, -0.003325406927615404, -0.020040610805153847, 0.005999621003866196, -0.029193971306085587, -0.04051995277404785, 0.002143456367775798, -0.07133322209119797, -0.016675429418683052, -0.00016187186702154577, 0.0415397472679615, -0.021714763715863228, 0.04481559619307518, -0.02201397344470024, 0.02052329108119011, 0.030477995052933693, -0.0049474043771624565, 0.09393706172704697, 0.09090805798768997, -0.0034260747488588095, -0.0776611939072609, 0.06218085065484047, 0.02024727128446102, 0.004334651865065098, 0.007334754802286625, -0.020119745284318924, -0.029790325090289116, -0.03181518614292145, 0.03308667987585068, 0.049058374017477036, -0.006322861649096012, -0.009646328166127205, 0.042287614196538925, -0.03778985142707825, -0.03636808320879936, 0.015433968976140022, -0.018560942262411118, -0.017832649871706963, 0.01595042273402214, -0.056122131645679474, 0.019107967615127563, -0.0000333093739754986, -0.028482919558882713, -0.027368798851966858, -0.00906442105770111, -0.017357630655169487, -0.0011878369841724634, -0.027130380272865295, 0.02101648412644863, 0.0012509425869211555, 0.018646057695150375, -0.015653271228075027, -0.009111730381846428, 0.006839333102107048, -0.023040443658828735, 0.0007257418474182487, 0.034893449395895004, -0.006394621916115284, -0.022526470944285393, 0.007187305949628353, -0.005591107066720724, -0.06275927275419235, -0.01951601915061474, -0.009478776715695858, 0.03797507286071777, -0.0066750552505254745, -0.026477815583348274, -0.024221358820796013, 0.009991602040827274, 0.011901150457561016, -0.031527020037174225, -0.03565717488527298, 0.028424860909581184, 0.014824764803051949, -0.036333587020635605, -0.013083748519420624, -0.03112715482711792, -0.019718142226338387, 0.011840634047985077, 0.0049005732871592045, 0.038823872804641724, 0.00048392752069048584, -0.00306311110034585, -0.060843512415885925, 0.057966768741607666, 0.00042917835526168346, 0.013061974197626114, 0.014970557764172554, -0.019562583416700363, -0.024140900000929832, -0.027020877227187157, 0.004787791520357132, 0.042810555547475815, 0.04138178378343582, 0.00888749398291111, -0.01598936878144741, -0.05660061538219452, -0.026563795283436775, 0.03199198469519615, -0.00041970214806497097, -0.002578357234597206, -0.02643289603292942, -0.011023218743503094, 0.029129203408956528, 0.02012096345424652, 0.004903716035187244, 0.0307932011783123, 0.00020928421872667968, 0.01665271818637848, 0.013313796371221542, -0.0753760114312172, -0.022228248417377472, 0.011362982913851738, -0.0075624422170221806, -0.030711790546774864, -0.012611567974090576, 0.06297618895769119, 0.02477743662893772, 0.01675204187631607, -0.00943199172616005, 0.05740204453468323, -0.018251148983836174, 0.0015860459534451365, 0.049076661467552185, -0.07093488425016403, 0.011759262531995773, 0.027259333059191704, 0.0355786457657814, 0.0010986722772940993, -0.011457269079983234, -0.01687898486852646, -0.024954117834568024, 0.02450789511203766, -0.008785592392086983, -0.03301861509680748, -0.010347064584493637, -0.03428443893790245, 0.04448198527097702, -0.05057237669825554, -0.03967970237135887, -0.07223767042160034, -0.019640713930130005, 0.02986128441989422, 0.011788075789809227, 0.011075525544583797, 0.015681089833378792, -0.003087899647653103, 0.02894606441259384, -0.0038758576847612858, 0.03091995231807232, -0.007606296334415674, -0.05707354098558426, -0.01667138934135437, -0.010485591366887093, 0.07063240557909012, -0.004793412052094936, -0.04858555644750595, 0.03169189393520355, -0.020037762820720673, -0.009198174811899662, 0.002530648373067379, 0.0023165084421634674, 0.02337438054382801, 0.06950743496417999, 0.0024768314324319363, 0.00263325497508049, 0.013754828833043575, -0.014503132551908493, -0.01136056799441576, -0.04115751385688782, -0.0013933550799265504, -0.006899173837155104, -0.006888398434966803, -0.03995067626237869, 0.02386605739593506, -0.016396285966038704, 0.03843708708882332, 0.05727313831448555, 0.009398614056408405, -0.040610868483781815, 0.019575895741581917, -0.007102465257048607, 0.031717605888843536, -0.005618726834654808, -0.026685314252972603, 0.02471292018890381, 0.05196167156100273, -0.04532019793987274, 0.024675697088241577, 0.017020486295223236, -0.0006425970350392163, -0.0805618017911911, -0.03078647516667843, -0.016462350264191628, 0.04890761151909828, 0.034908343106508255, -0.03721391037106514, -0.0048936279490590096, 0.012150583788752556, -0.032157834619283676, 0.023775706067681313, -0.012619802728295326, 0.02853049710392952, -0.025774002075195312, 0.0030897678807377815, -0.02202543430030346, 0.017862869426608086, 0.014879260212182999, 0.012954385951161385, 0.017908988520503044, 0.007713886443525553, 0.017165159806609154, -0.02175966277718544, 0.03149881213903427, -0.028095567598938942, 0.020088352262973785, -0.07921773195266724, 0.001991553232073784, -0.04361236095428467, -0.009668308310210705, 0.03208572790026665, -0.05095002055168152, 0.033611275255680084, 0.0425693579018116, 0.0082305409014225, 0.02016027830541134, 0.06487371027469635, 0.010556647554039955, 0.0010454142466187477, 0.002562055131420493, 0.0050789653323590755, -0.017769671976566315, 0.05232591554522514, -0.00995217077434063, -0.026146167889237404, -0.008273868821561337, 0.013270550407469273, 0.0016021659830585122, 0.026584496721625328, -0.042076658457517624, -0.005040625110268593, -0.014290266670286655, -0.007160730194300413, -0.023946497589349747, -0.022849662229418755, 0.01912830024957657, 0.009487608447670937, 0.010291395708918571, 0.038837406784296036, 0.0178509633988142, -0.0363713875412941, 0.009217795915901661, 0.004073755815625191, -0.0017225475749000907, 0.002488960511982441, -0.01329102087765932, -0.011179576627910137, -0.04674125835299492, 0.006524541415274143, 0.00015814842481631786, -0.00665557524189353, -0.03290919214487076, -0.0043212417513132095, -0.036035191267728806, 0.028952741995453835, -0.05262692645192146, -0.0077757453545928, -0.027281375601887703, -0.06334234029054642, 0.012918265536427498, -0.09043502807617188, 0.057183172553777695, 0.009164230898022652, -0.01688327267765999, -0.04112720489501953, 0.007890257053077221, -0.04391484707593918, 0.020698366686701775, 0.06993530690670013, 0.0038004752714186907, 0.01671484299004078, 0.004801400471478701, 0.044592831283807755, 0.01529591903090477, -0.029363390058279037, 0.0539950430393219, 0.01550397090613842, 0.015001348219811916, -0.010525601916015148, -0.03553864359855652, 0.0077350204810500145, 0.032630082219839096, 0.025541216135025024, -0.005062170326709747, 0.01655135676264763, 0.020659036934375763, 0.019358864054083824, 0.01856216788291931, 0.008967109955847263, -0.04277016222476959, 0.01233983039855957, 0.02411266416311264, 0.023314479738473892, 0.06591885536909103, -0.010412297211587429, -0.021149542182683945, 0.0034350345376878977, -0.030759980902075768, -0.014416754245758057, 0.008030681870877743, 0.005588904954493046, 0.006191309075802565, -0.04619161784648895, 0.031070029363036156, -0.021566277369856834, -0.021847335621714592, -0.013472335413098335, 0.058270413428545, 0.03319878503680229, 0.04375859349966049, 0.03805380314588547, 0.01406815368682146, 0.023439373821020126, -0.017990339547395706, 0.010328303091228008, 0.03609206900000572, 0.01603204384446144, 0.00587394880130887, -0.02676793746650219, 0.021474136039614677, 0.009426947683095932, 0.01097460649907589, -0.026836857199668884, 0.04202722758054733, -0.025619789958000183, -0.022487681359052658, 0.04799102991819382, -0.000747935613617301, 0.014242934994399548, -0.004984345752745867, 0.012183990329504013, 0.050009019672870636, -0.06824355572462082, 0.0027187305968254805, -0.0249350443482399, -0.007565916515886784, -0.02162308618426323, 0.017064254730939865, 0.020337408408522606, 0.007859189063310623, 0.028142591938376427, -0.010472064837813377, -0.024426832795143127, -0.015833936631679535, 0.019874583929777145, -0.024681176990270615, 0.03918617591261864, -0.016142381355166435, -0.0008745236555114388, -0.030416738241910934, -0.01767614297568798, -0.06022278219461441, -0.05961558222770691, 0.05512871593236923, 0.04054783284664154, 0.015108821913599968, -0.026992207393050194, -0.030564460903406143, -0.015917407348752022, 0.03204626217484474, -0.05740506947040558, -0.033242810517549515, -0.02033313363790512, 0.013801807537674904, 0.002600767882540822, 0.019121089950203896 ]
<p>I am trying to apply a GLM in R. I have a binary response (success vs failure), and 3 categorical explanatory variables : Sex (male or female), Food (present or absent) and Wind (none, low, high). I arranged my data to end up with a count of number of success for each possible combination of explanatory variables. (<em>*</em> Sorry for the pictures instead of codes, but I wasn't able to format it so it could be understandable...)</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/ZZd6m.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I tried to run a GLM on this, taking the Success column as the response variable and treating it as count data : </p> <p><code>model2&lt;-glm(Success~Wind*Sex*Food, data=data, family=poisson)</code></p> <p>But the summary of it gives something unexpected : The residual deviance shows 0 degrees of freedom. <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/8H0ko.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>Why is it the case ? (i.e. is it unusual as I think or I'm just freaking out for nothing) Am I using an inapropriate model or distribution ? Is the trouble coming from the way I managed my dataset ? I don't know if I am using an appropriate technique... Basically, I want to know if any of my explanatory variables or their interaction has an effect on the success of the trial. I don't know how else I could get that info...</p> <p>Thanks</p>
73,409
[ -0.03029535710811615, -0.01334825623780489, 0.002554166130721569, 0.015145239420235157, -0.007842411287128925, -0.001823368133045733, -0.0377853661775589, 0.0085885776206851, 0.03359115123748779, 0.005445662420243025, 0.05616345629096031, 0.04631062597036362, 0.0687379390001297, 0.022355012595653534, 0.0317084901034832, 0.01380626205354929, 0.0066949124448001385, 0.016666213050484657, 0.02601793222129345, 0.002586193848401308, -0.025397468358278275, 0.013754678890109062, 0.0014607403427362442, -0.011445418931543827, -0.008428861387073994, 0.057320062071084976, 0.046233128756284714, -0.013876814395189285, 0.031684380024671555, 0.005385283846408129, -0.06440997123718262, -0.02517831139266491, -0.012328924611210823, -0.004939158912748098, 0.045651692897081375, 0.03581693395972252, -0.057452961802482605, 0.004555044695734978, 0.004397222772240639, 0.015869054943323135, 0.006427980959415436, -0.02341165766119957, -0.025742581114172935, 0.010479921475052834, -0.04142329841852188, -0.0003153942816425115, 0.019822753965854645, -0.007260648068040609, 0.0748525857925415, -0.048639118671417236, 0.06468414515256882, -0.013719679787755013, 0.03985797241330147, 0.04576830565929413, -0.008312772028148174, -0.0028335426468402147, 0.05172104761004448, 0.041851941496133804, -0.0024743189569562674, -0.0374259278178215, -0.017482759431004524, -0.02912200428545475, -0.019843585789203644, -0.03178832679986954, -0.03272812068462372, 0.012250100262463093, 0.03181861713528633, -0.0404401496052742, 0.03421001136302948, -0.005056587979197502, 0.03179486468434334, 0.00852181389927864, 0.024530833587050438, 0.00157697475515306, 0.021729273721575737, 4.1532155137247173e-7, 0.0044889929704368114, -0.0012499947333708405, 0.05205830559134483, 0.023048067465424538, -0.014918594621121883, -0.007590343710035086, -0.005530607420951128, 0.023536885157227516, 0.008518914692103863, -0.03875163197517395, 0.0680171474814415, -0.015406361781060696, -0.008880982175469398, 0.04022257402539253, -0.010861092247068882, 0.008118102326989174, 0.03819481283426285, 0.018503598868846893, -0.05587080493569374, 0.023497097194194794, 0.027234330773353577, 0.028188318014144897, -0.006732000503689051, 0.004671855829656124, -0.031020523980259895, -0.030300764366984367, 0.04757693037390709, 0.05630776286125183, -0.05648820102214813, -0.02885434962809086, -0.02976960688829422, 0.014960595406591892, -0.046942345798015594, -0.05380507931113243, -0.011678661219775677, 0.05034525319933891, 0.024825258180499077, -0.033318739384412766, -0.0004204902797937393, -0.05204625427722931, -0.026629019528627396, 0.005120827350765467, 0.058288127183914185, 0.09012892842292786, 0.019222358241677284, -0.023427249863743782, 0.014996524900197983, -0.030316168442368507, -0.03919956833124161, -0.007809309754520655, 0.030218031257390976, -0.011557156220078468, -0.02663843147456646, 0.04999406263232231, 0.013199174776673317, -0.02359004132449627, 0.027953431010246277, -0.017169807106256485, -0.013805008493363857, -0.027564948424696922, -0.0917675718665123, -0.0041309320367872715, 0.018340108916163445, -0.0367729589343071, 0.03605598956346512, -0.028942812234163284, -0.018865138292312622, 0.036747515201568604, 0.06157488748431206, -0.02607014961540699, 0.034328948706388474, -0.015744198113679886, 0.02653699740767479, 0.0031542552169412374, -0.018692759796977043, 0.008921909146010876, -0.032037895172834396, -0.016866279765963554, -0.03495175763964653, -0.0804799348115921, 0.06571584939956665, 0.0233292318880558, 0.019206125289201736, -0.0046484158374369144, 0.03272823989391327, 0.03388211131095886, -0.002324094995856285, -0.017297936603426933, 0.015417260117828846, 0.005157028790563345, 0.06222677230834961, -0.01340290904045105, 0.02451683022081852, 0.04499367997050285, -0.029372530058026314, 0.021840626373887062, 0.019051915034651756, 0.05224768444895744, 0.045355550944805145, 0.010319070890545845, 0.010171305388212204, -0.057797547429800034, 0.024808289483189583, 0.028771042823791504, -0.03459667041897774, -0.013977976515889168, -0.012397084385156631, -0.02307172119617462, 0.029051801189780235, 0.007392597384750843, -0.02735559083521366, -0.045098789036273956, 0.0503731444478035, -0.014547538943588734, -0.04423977807164192, -0.07813406735658646, -0.021991297602653503, -0.024223679676651955, -0.03709164261817932, -0.005253206938505173, -0.006032708566635847, 0.05399083346128464, -0.004990847781300545, 0.009973252192139626, -0.023685643449425697, -0.02888290397822857, 0.01781739480793476, -0.024103540927171707, -0.023544833064079285, 0.04443361610174179, 0.02906976081430912, -0.013044134713709354, 0.04788932204246521, -0.0353533998131752, -0.05081286281347275, -0.015314611606299877, 0.003270580433309078, -0.02309764176607132, -0.017080338671803474, -0.013275742530822754, 0.013016540557146072, 0.011966867372393608, -0.01976284570991993, 0.014078798703849316, -0.023406654596328735, 0.07069651037454605, 0.07559812813997269, -0.004518765024840832, 0.02510414645075798, 0.0014907857403159142, 0.005170229822397232, 0.004354902543127537, -0.03162091597914696, 0.01644103229045868, -0.04002944752573967, -0.04059290885925293, 0.03895425423979759, -0.005772180389612913, -0.00873938761651516, 0.010964115150272846, 0.040610190480947495, -0.002240704372525215, 0.004459695890545845, 0.044226035475730896, 0.009427019394934177, -0.006329802330583334, 0.010063175112009048, 0.005909475963562727, 0.025253061205148697, 0.004855164792388678, 0.04641097038984299, -0.014108280651271343, 0.030557239428162575, -0.031963326036930084, -0.012777945958077908, 0.07497215270996094, 0.007964282296597958, -0.000393224909203127, -0.02764090523123741, -0.006080016493797302, 0.06595832854509354, -0.007517919410020113, 0.030064718797802925, 0.09002742171287537, 0.041207458823919296, -0.004634391982108355, -0.0027580182068049908, -0.001956204418092966, 0.00930231437087059, 0.028238791972398758, -0.02344694919884205, -0.019050665199756622, 0.018018141388893127, -0.014432718977332115, 0.038291431963443756, -0.013355918228626251, -0.06159944087266922, -0.015749702230095863, 0.013453087769448757, 0.02428041212260723, 0.031958844512701035, 0.040609411895275116, -0.01923396810889244, -0.04972493648529053, -0.009424244053661823, -0.01849069446325302, 0.023394683375954628, 0.026913685724139214, -0.06939064711332321, -0.00933119747787714, -0.022876471281051636, 0.007179770618677139, 0.016196653246879578, 0.004608669318258762, -0.019954167306423187, 0.012638639658689499, 0.012441406026482582, -0.0041621774435043335, -0.03208868205547333, -0.04141702502965927, -0.0100003182888031, -0.01061894092708826, -0.012252451851963997, 0.044085774570703506, 0.01650184951722622, -0.013067486695945263, -0.011553873308002949, -0.05642693489789963, -0.0011835432378575206, 0.018010953441262245, 0.011254070326685905, 0.04136204719543457, 0.019225087016820908, 0.003334794659167528, 0.020120996981859207, -0.029186543077230453, -0.011025642044842243, -0.08137284964323044, -0.0602717399597168, -0.026271793991327286, 0.028740016743540764, 0.03855388984084129, -0.019272349774837494, 0.015128402970731258, 0.053261324763298035, 0.05773954093456268, 0.017832186073064804, -0.0437653549015522, -0.03916540369391441, -0.017738616093993187, -0.003316403366625309, 0.014250186271965504, 0.005091798957437277, 0.03421706706285477, 0.04687388613820076, -0.03867696225643158, 0.05135383456945419, 0.014516324736177921, -0.03689443692564964, -0.025359857827425003, 0.018599146977066994, 0.023995686322450638, -0.04304047301411629, 0.03651267662644386, 0.021471746265888214, -0.013881156221032143, 0.01806490123271942, -0.017820604145526886, 0.035661354660987854, -0.010592566803097725, -0.08047009259462357, -0.01711769960820675, 0.01580246165394783, 0.006011240649968386, -0.03886120766401291, 0.026216495782136917, 0.00907058734446764, -0.04934656247496605, 0.01644907146692276, 0.0033294421155005693, 0.06310723721981049, -0.019912226125597954, 0.0010148599976673722, 0.05125471204519272, 0.044020168483257294, -0.013752344995737076, -0.0000028912618290632963, -0.0012712274910882115, 0.006072599440813065, -0.0009801066480576992, 0.011787794530391693, -0.010131019167602062, 0.01729723997414112, 0.03325851634144783, 0.03510679677128792, -0.02217743918299675, -0.039676543325185776, -0.0009321863180957735, -0.01272883266210556, 0.004070933908224106, -0.03542793542146683, 0.03891145437955856, -0.025450803339481354, 0.04418134316802025, -0.004833589773625135, 0.011327533051371574, 0.009458417072892189, -0.016091611236333847, -0.041084516793489456, 0.03531906381249428, 0.015198883600533009, -0.018130110576748848, 0.038094304502010345, -0.03672054409980774, 0.053861331194639206, -0.00737948389723897, 0.006825675722211599, 0.02965639904141426, 0.010121822357177734, -0.004107372369617224, -0.005362214520573616, -0.038814134895801544, -0.0208602137863636, 0.03530320152640343, 0.0007554266485385597, 0.009185086004436016, 0.007341556251049042, 0.001090495614334941, 0.06714724749326706, 0.0018571993568912148, -0.03521125018596649, -0.06630093604326248, 0.005715057719498873, 0.011964358389377594, 0.044420018792152405, 0.016717594116926193, 0.03750243037939072, -0.03110240399837494, 0.022535264492034912, 0.02969634160399437, 0.022830549627542496, 0.042258117347955704, 0.01914677396416664, 0.0026191463693976402, -0.03340017423033714, -0.020718073472380638, -0.008017536252737045, -0.005134954117238522, 0.006036784034222364, 0.016925716772675514, 0.054549284279346466, 0.04708268493413925, -0.030452994629740715, 0.024020006880164146, 0.004253667779266834, -0.007784644141793251, 0.042553387582302094, -0.02217019535601139, 0.00036070961505174637, -0.02711644023656845, -0.01673165149986744, 0.025521941483020782, -0.0004365374625194818, 0.011360875330865383, -0.03289152681827545, 0.058320302516222, -0.04080023989081383, -0.011180086992681026, 0.02284504845738411, 0.008673452772200108, 0.015919815748929977, 0.0174994058907032, -0.05998891964554787, -0.002088255016133189, 0.025273121893405914, 0.03784515708684921, 0.020998895168304443, -0.017443012446165085, -0.05592602863907814, -0.009289833717048168, 0.03871976211667061, 0.013695226050913334, -0.02537534013390541, -0.02969503402709961, -0.03466222807765007, -0.03269356116652489, -0.012375676073133945, -0.03767104819417, 0.017542680725455284, -0.003986271098256111, 0.025912420824170113, 0.01732800342142582, -0.027373550459742546, -0.07007215172052383, -0.01475043036043644, -0.04210876673460007, -0.007450648583471775, 0.009747966192662716, -0.048803478479385376, -0.029334740713238716, -0.030615879222750664, -0.01945534348487854, 0.0006591682904399931, -0.021203406155109406, -0.020045379176735878, 0.02131849154829979, -0.01229990553110838, -0.043231647461652756, -0.03821102902293205, -0.0011938238749280572, -0.02407495118677616, 0.00989034865051508, 0.058451130986213684, -0.026838183403015137, -0.04611421748995781, 0.003804572392255068, 0.03171853348612785, -0.00222727726213634, -0.019167346879839897, -0.044568710029125214, 0.00989031232893467, 0.015507536008954048, -0.016263658180832863, 0.06021016091108322, 0.0537882037460804, 0.0050531369633972645, 0.010976643301546574, -0.01113863568753004, 0.004080599639564753, -0.029970068484544754, -0.04729003831744194, -0.08376403152942657, 0.01587015576660633, -0.006179345306009054, 0.010334452614188194, 0.023998824879527092, 0.03193800151348114, -0.004717455245554447, -0.02676071971654892, 0.017725778743624687, 0.01705176569521427, 0.008003071881830692, -0.029512962326407433, -0.012426022440195084, 0.0057497527450323105, -0.03824814781546593, -0.02019893005490303, 0.016650104895234108, 0.009073990397155285, -0.02532435767352581, 0.013425527140498161, -0.03002549521625042, 0.008620969951152802, 0.014401320368051529, -0.012459601275622845, 0.0030471952632069588, -0.014267224818468094, -0.012263139709830284, -0.001435296842828393, 0.03817867487668991, -0.011403334327042103, -0.05948007479310036, -0.049254998564720154, 0.00021809342433698475, 0.03167906403541565, 0.005950752645730972, -0.019339468330144882, -0.0017493045888841152, -0.011713230982422829, 0.007532909978181124, -0.06760141253471375, -0.04052503779530525, 0.01431723590940237, -0.014764492399990559, -0.000993220368400216, -0.03915397822856903, -0.0031284037977457047, -0.002487405901774764, -0.01462099514901638, -0.012150198221206665, 0.05251617729663849, -0.012094197794795036, 0.0040707699954509735, 0.006888753268867731, 0.024829933419823647, 0.05111875385046005, 0.010859319940209389, -0.030742347240447998, 0.02453625574707985, -0.03233965113759041, -0.02633257582783699, 0.028762537986040115, -0.013911227695643902, -0.016926074400544167, -0.025912897661328316, -0.012656701728701591, 0.01184301357716322, 0.035120632499456406, -0.023027412593364716, -0.03845406323671341, -0.01390875969082117, 0.0026565969455987215, 0.0424535758793354, -0.041406821459531784, 0.00787628348916769, 0.009194280952215195, 0.012579456903040409, -0.0503455214202404, 0.0009333932539448142, -0.005610854364931583, -0.019199809059500694, 0.05717761069536209, -0.02048838511109352, -0.009638076648116112, 0.03735905513167381, 0.06994231045246124, 0.0066291093826293945, -0.012356949038803577, -0.010854117572307587, 0.0013694000663235784, 0.02437174692749977, 0.028730573132634163, -0.008341208100318909, 0.00543542206287384, 0.03844304010272026, -0.04623215273022652, -0.0010728781344369054, -0.037493523210287094, 0.03980208933353424, 0.06311364471912384, -0.04161116108298302, 0.004263416863977909, 0.03135446459054947, -0.022463001310825348, 0.01712435483932495, -0.021289560943841934, 0.012844492681324482, 0.0030275883618742228, 0.022764744237065315, 0.05277455598115921, 0.005318803712725639, -0.03470320627093315, 0.07206182181835175, 0.04029035568237305, 0.04259710758924484, 0.028196049854159355, 0.03279722109436989, 0.0024843739811331034, 0.014736250974237919, -0.004232403356581926, -0.06262210756540298, 0.03500588983297348, -0.03608778864145279, 0.025764433667063713, -0.017013680189847946, -0.01617405004799366, 0.06144515797495842, 0.06816418468952179, -0.0020684797782450914, -0.038468148559331894, -0.05025336518883705, -0.030100982636213303, 0.006217010784894228, 0.02801629528403282, -0.016590803861618042, 0.01531911175698042, -0.006721900310367346, 0.059403423219919205, -0.003772856667637825, 0.05478784069418907, -0.0016576065681874752, -0.07776187360286713, -0.0011190774384886026, -0.032994065433740616, -0.013346251100301743, 0.03419347479939461, -0.04358867183327675, -0.00038552514160983264, -0.0008087599417194724, -0.022462304681539536, -0.008266166783869267, -0.023065460845828056, 0.03192795068025589, 0.0011200433364138007, 0.06314630806446075, 0.006286434829235077, -0.010964960791170597, -0.003421291708946228, 0.013055034913122654, 0.12269844114780426, 0.027063149958848953, 0.06254804879426956, -0.04929374158382416, -0.016349567100405693, 0.009021392092108727, -0.01013135351240635, 0.010138721205294132, -0.03148673102259636, 0.006017101928591728, -0.019566498696804047, 0.05326592177152634, 0.021867169067263603, 0.039750587195158005, -0.004768501967191696, 0.046305228024721146, -0.00293973577208817, -0.03609984368085861, -0.001568412990309298, -0.011561114341020584, -0.03226777911186218, -0.0018446901813149452, -0.03179801255464554, 0.028465665876865387, 0.03582054004073143, -0.025735201314091682, 0.0019756087567657232, 0.011919490061700344, -0.0194600410759449, 0.013868899084627628, -0.03150969371199608, -0.014713852666318417, 0.011356132104992867, 0.05043049156665802, -0.010036684572696686, -0.035575419664382935, -0.00036793338949792087, -0.0395936593413353, 0.00022571686713490635, 0.031239761039614677, -0.0240015871822834, 0.006029007490724325, 0.023055728524923325, -0.02977188304066658, -0.04705856367945671, -0.04958724603056908, -0.012402131222188473, 0.043441228568553925, 0.020239870995283127, -0.0011086659505963326, -0.01899009570479393, 0.000050230431952513754, 0.005310209468007088, -0.05337771773338318, -0.017726676538586617, 0.017581505700945854, 0.03215496987104416, -0.038693226873874664, -0.06026552990078926, -0.025887204334139824, 0.00870483834296465, -0.0061865695752203465, 0.010967522859573364, 0.045141566544771194, -0.020337510854005814, -0.02759872004389763, -0.036894332617521286, 0.06743350625038147, 0.018488295376300812, -0.005479009822010994, 0.016857165843248367, -0.03906850889325142, -0.0027298876084387302, 0.027890460565686226, 0.00596572645008564, 0.004100584890693426, 0.026560772210359573, -0.020410967990756035, -0.007068361155688763, -0.028061239048838615, -0.03515220806002617, -0.004350955132395029, -0.032159410417079926, 0.030959665775299072, -0.04357688128948212, -0.035801712423563004, -0.024334579706192017, 0.02440750040113926, 0.0094298105686903, -0.009075773879885674, -0.019453085958957672, 0.04188348725438118, -0.01614932157099247, -0.025252478197216988, -0.05525980144739151, 0.019714515656232834, -0.039823226630687714, -0.014443574473261833, -0.02086460404098034, 0.04421337693929672, -0.01540218386799097, 0.0238738264888525, 0.011745470575988293, -0.004254225175827742, -0.004309240262955427, -0.005440498702228069, 0.046939801424741745, -0.030466396361589432, 0.03556251525878906, 0.00006824370211688802, -0.03515201061964035, -0.002529917750507593, -0.03768317401409149, -0.02687956392765045, -0.0379502959549427, -0.013131494633853436, 0.00014611828373745084, -0.02552582323551178, 0.007307650521397591, -0.04109868407249451, 0.03525426238775253, -0.023130269721150398, -0.008991057984530926, -0.06388163566589355, -0.016630088910460472, 0.021454891189932823, -0.010924924165010452, -0.008942659944295883, 0.02311527170240879, -0.028298666700720787, 0.044470567256212234, 0.025925643742084503, 0.029137546196579933, 0.026162199676036835, 0.028357166796922684, 0.05088071897625923, 0.020502140745520592, 0.018786069005727768, 0.009941891767084599, -0.0061901831068098545, 0.07418793439865112, -0.040916986763477325, -0.039633769541978836, 0.016418371349573135, 0.020685823634266853, 0.03991073742508888, 0.0021124854683876038, 0.015206770971417427, -0.03680793568491936, 0.04857832193374634, -0.04487414285540581, -0.0013646528823301196, 0.005179929081350565, 0.02519790269434452, 0.0018213510047644377, -0.021132007241249084, -0.027258995920419693, 0.014583336189389229, -0.019774185493588448, 0.030628543347120285, 0.06630214303731918, 0.03362276777625084, 0.018035929650068283, 0.023324303328990936, -0.02869294211268425, -0.005903119686990976, -0.00584289850667119, -0.0007700977148488164, 0.029427746310830116, 0.09505605697631836, -0.038003262132406235, 0.04550577327609062, -0.029326042160391808, 0.06072070077061653, -0.0878734439611435, -0.045398201793432236, 0.02187407948076725, 0.024802953004837036, 0.027304843068122864, -0.03515351936221123, 0.0045531196519732475, 0.01535490620881319, -0.004768872167915106, -0.021003860980272293, 0.02933538518846035, -0.0030972566455602646, -0.0397518016397953, 0.035941895097494125, -0.014692338183522224, 0.01985504850745201, 0.029907463118433952, -0.001965858740732074, 0.03794661536812782, 0.06159753352403641, 0.001244700513780117, -0.0017336765304207802, -0.015982355922460556, -0.0026278544683009386, 0.007098960690200329, -0.0644448772072792, -0.021519968286156654, -0.008924095891416073, -0.02396874688565731, 0.006048884242773056, -0.0001021470088744536, 0.01739480160176754, 0.016162047162652016, 0.03427153080701828, 0.015658972784876823, 0.05842440202832222, 0.024087170138955116, -0.017636708915233612, -0.01986103504896164, -0.002671473426744342, 0.006847419776022434, 0.03935603052377701, -0.03745417669415474, -0.009874876588582993, 0.013858931139111519, -0.018928058445453644, -0.03134766221046448, 0.012382758781313896, -0.0012414194643497467, -0.0003876039118040353, -0.013183548115193844, 0.029866056516766548, 0.006424229592084885, -0.05523112788796425, 0.03864461928606033, -0.04783206060528755, -0.003816698445007205, 0.0440799817442894, 0.013080866076052189, -0.03030143305659294, -0.009136943146586418, -0.014223430305719376, -0.043169308453798294, -0.040110036730766296, 0.005096257198601961, -0.0014404949033632874, -0.01543582882732153, 0.017903322353959084, -0.019654298201203346, 0.026072703301906586, -0.000999062554910779, -0.011711381375789642, -0.04578999802470207, 0.04083637893199921, -0.037732385098934174, 0.008544540032744408, 0.023747937753796577, 0.004855216946452856, 0.03293365240097046, -0.1181357130408287, 0.07189659029245377, 0.007239955477416515, -0.017472412437200546, -0.049023404717445374, 0.026716137304902077, -0.03389623016119003, 0.044896092265844345, 0.0422428660094738, -0.010319039225578308, -0.0067697009071707726, 0.018736958503723145, 0.047229964286088943, -0.022412123158574104, -0.0264317337423563, 0.05659913271665573, -0.005560130346566439, -0.043896518647670746, -0.025264807045459747, -0.0048055583611130714, 0.008843264542520046, -0.005438670981675386, -0.014153257943689823, -0.017474861815571785, 0.025534337386488914, 0.0024393806234002113, -0.017316214740276337, 0.033270593732595444, 0.013208605349063873, -0.02601294405758381, 0.010887806303799152, -0.02156217396259308, 0.012377195991575718, 0.036701545119285583, 0.0028094814624637365, -0.04659681022167206, 0.07855682820081711, -0.009095041081309319, -0.029888778924942017, 0.014770467765629292, -0.011719267815351486, -0.0041350857354700565, -0.06706927716732025, 0.025533683598041534, -0.0030216106679290533, -0.0472324974834919, 0.03167354315519333, -0.009771245531737804, 0.019284695386886597, 0.05466647446155548, -0.048653166741132736, -0.008856709115207195, -0.0010135543998330832, -0.01752934232354164, 0.04754025861620903, 0.05841255187988281, 0.0132615827023983, 0.010692782700061798, -0.011097647249698639, 0.040719445794820786, -0.01000606082379818, 0.0250119399279356, 0.01322033442556858, 0.03151186183094978, 0.01065426878631115, 0.012916972860693932, 0.017583739012479782, 0.004191951360553503, -0.010156925767660141, 0.008421411737799644, -0.000865028181578964, 0.05030973628163338, -0.015447563491761684, -0.03461535647511482, 0.0038363130297511816, -0.006147111300379038, -0.01765725202858448, -0.005978917703032494, 0.032145872712135315, 0.02625146321952343, 0.03433600068092346, 0.03665544092655182, -0.03013632632791996, -0.02718394435942173, 0.0233673807233572, -0.012033536098897457, 0.010942461900413036, -0.01462667714804411, -0.026976080611348152, -0.00825552735477686, -0.048315759748220444, -0.016410067677497864, -0.05867500603199005, 0.05756520852446556, 0.01503461692482233, -0.01512901484966278, -0.08470797538757324, 0.00007713122613495216, 0.01972171664237976, 0.043989211320877075, -0.06812804937362671, -0.03946976363658905, -0.05227323994040489, 0.04440241679549217, -0.006475991103798151, -0.02566484361886978 ]
<p>$\chi^n_k=\sum_{i=1}^kx_i^n$ where $x_i$ are Gaussian variables and $n>2$?</p>
35,766
[ -0.03728785738348961, -0.02461876906454563, 0.004025210626423359, -0.019825516268610954, 0.08109918236732483, 0.009817567653954029, -0.03156895190477371, -0.04565628245472908, -0.019457753747701645, -0.06379812955856323, 0.05504924803972244, 0.01986505277454853, 0.0295820664614439, 0.0421101376414299, -0.005814376752823591, 0.025011500343680382, -0.042011111974716187, 0.028486471623182297, -0.00894975196570158, 0.009410975500941277, 0.029320022091269493, 0.05857260525226593, 0.024558385834097862, -0.0006451284280046821, -0.06208766996860504, 0.03451356664299965, 0.04294062778353691, -0.044876579195261, 0.008003653027117252, 0.09329172968864441, -0.04389301687479019, 0.01081868540495634, 0.045755088329315186, 0.06168419495224953, 0.00432458333671093, -0.002696317620575428, -0.008422321639955044, -0.03592010214924812, 0.0209406316280365, 0.012056687846779823, -0.03781135380268097, -0.048226505517959595, 0.005954562220722437, 0.00036328998976387084, -0.011691344901919365, 0.0034777901601046324, 0.002385907806456089, -0.06086954101920128, 0.012055085971951485, -0.053562626242637634, 0.08661505579948425, 0.024766964837908745, 0.04851269721984863, -0.013694511726498604, 0.0035981235560029745, -0.018719911575317383, 0.03897033631801605, 0.04046304523944855, 0.009559030644595623, -0.06222296133637428, 0.023353252559900284, -0.02531595341861248, 0.012320493347942829, -0.02744222991168499, -0.04799264669418335, 0.02547905035316944, 0.0024905779864639044, -0.002650381764397025, 0.0023773324210196733, -0.028266368433833122, -0.002708492800593376, 0.051913000643253326, 0.012465513311326504, -0.031227832660079002, -0.004882393404841423, -0.02184349112212658, 0.010333053767681122, 0.011631231755018234, 0.021037515252828598, 0.0017578385304659605, 0.028865834698081017, 0.029473811388015747, 0.011304170824587345, -0.02367076650261879, 0.04459187388420105, 0.011084113270044327, 0.08671534806489944, -0.024734124541282654, 0.019814401865005493, 0.040438827127218246, 0.0038995682261884212, 0.035092320293188095, 0.04231015592813492, -0.04465574398636818, -0.03594137728214264, 0.022856401279568672, -0.04596790671348572, 0.026735536754131317, -0.010525977239012718, -0.020523466169834137, -0.011759236454963684, -0.018788347020745277, 0.025277050212025642, 0.06407493352890015, -0.05436854064464569, -0.0072267064824700356, -0.012639814056456089, 0.027075618505477905, -0.020359192043542862, -0.008287076838314533, -0.03639202564954758, 0.003566187107935548, -0.006276978179812431, 0.017913123592734337, 0.027539582923054695, -0.012734394520521164, -0.03056843765079975, -0.007932779379189014, 0.03729873150587082, 0.09720316529273987, 0.013318865559995174, -0.05062519758939743, 0.022940577939152718, -0.01955864578485489, -0.03571444749832153, 0.03491657227277756, 0.00737221073359251, -0.007596340961754322, -0.06559690088033676, 0.02547784335911274, 0.003192220814526081, -0.022197281941771507, 0.02515936829149723, 0.03616301342844963, -0.01124093122780323, -0.04250602051615715, -0.10743748396635056, -0.03398823365569115, 0.0401063971221447, -0.062068670988082886, 0.0011317089665681124, -0.09075234085321426, 0.03176033869385719, 0.06251025199890137, 0.0694073811173439, 0.0012678890489041805, 0.02835145778954029, 0.020894158631563187, 0.035610415041446686, 0.01912977732717991, -0.021021103486418724, -0.012999732978641987, -0.00955397542566061, -0.019033515825867653, 0.006693441886454821, -0.050455886870622635, 0.030059320852160454, 0.039659954607486725, -0.03855966031551361, -0.024100126698613167, 0.02099587954580784, -0.013159955851733685, -0.0036773979663848877, -0.008606808260083199, 0.015012306161224842, -0.03825334459543228, 0.07665760070085526, 0.044209763407707214, 0.03767469525337219, 0.034986402839422226, -0.009367179125547409, -0.002120252698659897, 0.010498051531612873, 0.04758143797516823, 0.05121616646647453, -0.01395005639642477, 0.00036518642446026206, -0.024594543501734734, 0.01995447836816311, 0.025728458538651466, -0.05405222997069359, -0.02967781201004982, -0.011595123447477818, -0.0006956111756153405, 0.01994866505265236, 0.0524742491543293, 0.02580283209681511, -0.030679622665047646, 0.0437854528427124, -0.04627583920955658, 0.018054623156785965, -0.05592522770166397, 0.01449030451476574, 0.02774365246295929, -0.045709192752838135, -0.00196937401778996, 0.04857378080487251, 0.021017128601670265, 0.01421745028346777, -0.03297821804881096, -0.019672753289341927, 0.005143898539245129, 0.01769096404314041, -0.04701818525791168, -0.007164133712649345, 0.056455474346876144, 0.044944342225790024, -0.007350267376750708, 0.054104167968034744, -0.015218453481793404, -0.03182026371359825, 0.008556582033634186, -0.016060907393693924, 0.034711334854364395, -0.026488201692700386, 0.011449084617197514, 0.02045360393822193, -0.011781837791204453, -0.022883407771587372, 0.06267593801021576, -0.056427985429763794, 0.06017117202281952, 0.05938506871461868, 0.018015339970588684, 0.011429663747549057, -0.020208289846777916, 0.028676096349954605, 0.022908002138137817, -0.03176280856132507, -0.011507809162139893, -0.05033952742815018, -0.004936306271702051, 0.0023922810796648264, 0.06476050615310669, -0.03890399634838104, 0.000508126278873533, 0.022876454517245293, 0.04207915812730789, 0.006366678513586521, 0.0018482864834368229, -0.03945053741335869, -0.019764557480812073, -0.00464695505797863, -0.0070505570620298386, -0.024640386924147606, 0.010301579721271992, 0.022635413333773613, -0.005869561340659857, 0.016664214432239532, 0.005013397894799709, -0.027527840808033943, 0.05417889356613159, -0.038242898881435394, -0.011805231682956219, -0.02129751816391945, -0.03313697129487991, 0.014455308206379414, -0.02140267752110958, -0.004506107419729233, 0.016094062477350235, -0.0056893243454396725, 0.008576877415180206, -0.0073704528622329235, -0.007244914770126343, 0.038996756076812744, -0.04146607592701912, -0.04743582382798195, -0.0017677773721516132, 0.03193347156047821, -0.04650907590985298, 0.011732948943972588, -0.039070624858140945, -0.010905466973781586, -0.005919629242271185, 0.027308423072099686, 0.02621239610016346, -0.025437548756599426, 0.014319650828838348, 0.024191461503505707, -0.03981629014015198, 0.0026801221538335085, -0.021091381087899208, 0.024777673184871674, 0.02854583039879799, -0.03902880847454071, 0.00768762594088912, -0.026287920773029327, -0.004689591005444527, 0.02327335998415947, -0.028813065961003304, 0.002401781501248479, 0.036429211497306824, -0.004095046315342188, -0.0318790078163147, 0.0066244895569980145, -0.02620762027800083, 0.006839854177087545, -0.03424357995390892, -0.0037773465737700462, 0.02770066447556019, -0.0006503477925434709, -0.020606793463230133, 0.04427448287606239, -0.018042229115962982, -0.04222819209098816, -0.04939085617661476, -0.0189591683447361, 0.02221912331879139, -0.034117721021175385, 0.04230067878961563, 0.003208957612514496, -0.007433462422341108, 0.008028781972825527, -0.07257480919361115, -0.02667766623198986, 0.009592065587639809, -0.007963864132761955, 0.03828951343894005, 0.010690280236303806, -0.01893153041601181, 0.06580424308776855, 0.0488588847219944, 0.004224497824907303, -0.020194869488477707, 0.006908081471920013, -0.03706862032413483, -0.05109153687953949, 0.03825194016098976, 0.00908512994647026, -0.01481231115758419, 0.03867875412106514, -0.0024469103664159775, -0.019693298265337944, 0.0875047966837883, 0.00033225867082364857, 0.011382132768630981, 0.017729397863149643, -0.043200552463531494, -0.00517364451661706, 0.01817140355706215, 0.010761862620711327, -0.031681306660175323, -0.01110989972949028, 0.027755847200751305, 0.024192826822400093, 0.0073661962524056435, -0.013453745283186436, 0.029543273150920868, -0.028439350426197052, 0.054948508739471436, -0.031892720609903336, 0.052162472158670425, 0.0453188382089138, 0.005862384103238583, 0.007285929750651121, 0.0184774212539196, -0.0023375058081001043, -0.029889479279518127, 0.02945069409906864, 0.014387324452400208, 0.02215403877198696, 0.0019001438049599528, 0.010502939112484455, -0.015993354842066765, -0.019191140308976173, 0.0337279811501503, -0.029591552913188934, -0.00814781803637743, 0.016306232661008835, 0.05546997860074043, 0.004979580175131559, 0.00020607095211744308, -0.016670826822519302, -0.004409828223288059, -0.042819034308195114, -0.027464639395475388, -0.037471622228622437, 0.038346197456121445, -0.0005810493021272123, 0.07840634882450104, -0.003306875703856349, -0.021746385842561722, -0.005924609489738941, -0.03436371311545372, -0.07775954902172089, 0.009633360430598259, -0.03193870186805725, -0.007532037328928709, 0.018558518961071968, -0.016440633684396744, 0.018285222351551056, 0.01293439045548439, 0.010369502939283848, -0.01273738220334053, 0.020821454003453255, -0.03079673834145069, 0.0322408564388752, 0.0011823149397969246, -0.011415500193834305, 0.0036167388316243887, 0.05368475615978241, 0.04514719918370247, 0.0050032841973006725, 0.04604248329997063, 0.04087773710489273, -0.0070732757449150085, 0.015933824703097343, 0.017069406807422638, 0.012863807380199432, 0.001827784813940525, 0.03381988778710365, 0.010329372249543667, 0.0029847724363207817, -0.027486013248562813, 0.021127725020051003, -0.02101902849972248, 0.023487472906708717, 0.04627464339137077, 0.0069649009965360165, 0.026326444000005722, -0.0694657415151596, -0.03634466603398323, -0.004180244170129299, 0.032577380537986755, 0.019490938633680344, 0.0011640937300398946, 0.048937130719423294, -0.0056278398260474205, -0.0399433970451355, 0.015892021358013153, 0.015688426792621613, 0.03641832247376442, -0.013307373970746994, 0.016415946185588837, 0.015066826716065407, -0.04541366174817085, -0.01242776308208704, 0.002722314093261957, -0.013730313628911972, -0.004107748158276081, 0.00420317193493247, 0.009720117785036564, -0.010269179940223694, -0.006891027558594942, -0.04321157932281494, 0.04247318208217621, 0.032273028045892715, -0.007192475721240044, -0.042021289467811584, 0.0038152567576617002, 0.06925120949745178, 0.0066542429849505424, 0.028330117464065552, -0.01697131060063839, -0.04879376292228699, -0.009751968085765839, 0.00921767856925726, 0.006084558553993702, -0.01904240995645523, 0.004021411295980215, -0.042566850781440735, 0.018972022458910942, 0.012483218684792519, -0.02273106575012207, 0.054876092821359634, -0.015802359208464622, 0.003645367221906781, -0.030260637402534485, -0.009982197545468807, -0.023061828687787056, 0.04374544695019722, -0.009653745219111443, 0.005755169317126274, -0.0569668784737587, 0.002225574105978012, -0.03626275062561035, 0.016902823001146317, 0.019045425578951836, 0.06402011960744858, 0.023208096623420715, 0.007191232871264219, 0.00038703755126334727, 0.04950391501188278, -0.00012159197649452835, -0.06068985536694527, 0.05269819125533104, 0.010323585011065006, -0.0020420916844159365, 0.04834279045462608, -0.045264195650815964, -0.06339835375547409, -0.005442862864583731, 0.023420395329594612, -0.033306628465652466, 0.01722029410302639, -0.0127025805413723, 0.022208966314792633, 0.034237004816532135, 0.013568955473601818, 0.07106074690818787, 0.02350875735282898, -0.029670020565390587, -0.011324310675263405, -0.036638204008340836, 0.007688453886657953, -0.02657226100564003, -0.037870295345783234, -0.013288800604641438, -0.01466104481369257, -0.0020042890682816505, 0.03994946554303169, -0.011284627951681614, 0.05550149083137512, 0.006276067346334457, 0.01928757131099701, -0.018318042159080505, 0.016347374767065048, -0.007522846572101116, 0.004329640883952379, 0.028223250061273575, 0.041723016649484634, 0.04911145195364952, -0.02822253480553627, 0.03914342448115349, 0.01267421804368496, -0.017142072319984436, 0.03166539967060089, -0.016957435756921768, 0.0047526233829557896, -0.04722791537642479, -0.02979436330497265, -0.00354926404543221, -0.020795252174139023, 0.05786774307489395, -0.026618678122758865, 0.03859098255634308, -0.00011424253898439929, -0.06627310067415237, -0.038126055151224136, 0.0163283608853817, 0.0039945440366864204, 0.03284645080566406, -0.008823736570775509, 0.00695741968229413, 0.008368395268917084, -0.011204244568943977, -0.04640466347336769, -0.02062438614666462, -0.004066193010658026, -0.0002870348107535392, 0.020460443571209908, -0.0021530897356569767, -0.0023298244923353195, -0.02238764986395836, -0.053065814077854156, -0.014780956320464611, 0.026178652420639992, -0.0028278781101107597, 0.008701772429049015, 0.007693216670304537, 0.000877158425282687, 0.061256520450115204, -0.009205015376210213, -0.046931616961956024, 0.01824808306992054, -0.02150741033256054, -0.014123549684882164, 0.0056690070778131485, 0.031057463958859444, -0.026967165991663933, -0.002900840947404504, 0.0028213991317898035, -0.026549868285655975, 0.0008397842175327241, 0.0019150376319885254, -0.04902716353535652, -0.013581526465713978, 0.005987273994833231, -0.018361857160925865, -0.025210576131939888, -0.019927600398659706, 0.011166510172188282, 0.023285115137696266, -0.011899118311703205, -0.03547762706875801, -0.023718947544693947, -0.00962027907371521, 0.019269883632659912, 0.01035598386079073, -0.022525247186422348, -0.00024236047465819865, 0.042305584996938705, -0.01883981190621853, -0.0128345787525177, -0.03304658457636833, 0.022802088409662247, 0.0013413458364084363, 0.002633138559758663, 0.0037665932904928923, 0.006736406125128269, 0.03455263003706932, -0.0069627403281629086, -0.0072470298036932945, -0.04690009355545044, 0.020669905468821526, 0.06505504250526428, -0.011710920371115208, 0.05427584424614906, 0.018607808277010918, 0.009198146872222424, 0.0032219896093010902, -0.026645060628652573, -0.006120453588664532, -0.015446254052221775, -0.012708290480077267, -0.0006424156599678099, -0.006325690075755119, -0.0068134889006614685, 0.04188179969787598, 0.01918105222284794, -0.00278482586145401, 0.03165910765528679, 0.0004938927595503628, 0.0199368204921484, -0.006797019857913256, -0.020102642476558685, -0.053312454372644424, 0.06196845322847366, -0.044229425489902496, 0.028623705729842186, -0.016154520213603973, -0.00368178216740489, 0.04181860014796257, 0.012141755782067776, 0.011909322813153267, -0.013740815222263336, -0.00647200969979167, -0.02975131943821907, -0.00032815130543895066, 0.02475973591208458, -0.016224877908825874, 0.022896865382790565, 0.0004091653390787542, 0.020098062232136726, 0.002353685675188899, 0.025252049788832664, -0.0012872604420408607, -0.07085536420345306, -0.010549417696893215, -0.011574991047382355, -0.052429430186748505, 0.013784065842628479, 0.020098155364394188, -0.062076326459646225, -0.00027438788674771786, -0.004338080063462257, 0.005646809004247189, 0.018183231353759766, 0.032119978219270706, -0.0017006408888846636, 0.062297746539115906, 0.029504675418138504, 0.013157518580555916, 0.0038933022879064083, -0.0023746867664158344, 0.11223739385604858, 0.054796651005744934, 0.02259344793856144, -0.0808941051363945, 0.0341765396296978, -0.042021822184324265, -0.004084350541234016, -0.03852543234825134, 0.02129831537604332, -0.02384231798350811, -0.006763691082596779, 0.00915465410798788, 0.04001777991652489, -0.006495293695479631, -0.014721102081239223, 0.051828689873218536, -0.014698886312544346, -0.060078151524066925, -0.024458490312099457, 0.019581370055675507, -0.03670906275510788, 0.023532457649707794, -0.05500461533665657, 0.005842762067914009, -0.03701705113053322, -0.040322527289390564, -0.02378467470407486, -0.010313616134226322, 0.0020773452706635, -0.02487860433757305, -0.06590976566076279, 0.0002699966717045754, 0.02861284837126732, 0.00750032439827919, -0.020380690693855286, 0.02148161269724369, -0.004471041727811098, -0.03601546958088875, -0.0018451459472998977, 0.03830401599407196, -0.0092017138376832, 0.01935547962784767, 0.02965385839343071, -0.014792600646615028, -0.05815644562244415, -0.01991349272429943, -0.05148933455348015, 0.06308847665786743, -0.035462409257888794, 0.0012902498710900545, -0.020316466689109802, 0.0031592785380780697, -0.006531135179102421, -0.05204757675528526, -0.026233026757836342, 0.030514178797602654, 0.011203710921108723, -0.04107952117919922, -0.010341300629079342, -0.03261460363864899, 0.013213356025516987, -0.006283197086304426, 0.06925919651985168, -0.0002997172705363482, -0.04223906248807907, 0.021699773147702217, -0.009729859419167042, 0.057740043848752975, -0.025765947997570038, 0.007846868596971035, -0.00036607353831641376, -0.03026537597179413, -0.024033546447753906, -0.01325936894863844, -0.006524101365357637, -0.0024955568369477987, 0.027907300740480423, -0.00033534722751937807, -0.013402380980551243, -0.008458913303911686, -0.05653686821460724, 0.022705938667058945, -0.007427850738167763, 0.014307825826108456, -0.022367866709828377, -0.03287411853671074, 0.042113810777664185, 0.040140364319086075, -0.003019423456862569, 0.002975212410092354, -0.029448235407471657, 0.06345678120851517, 0.01189887709915638, -0.01108146458864212, 0.0003968882083427161, -0.028725577518343925, -0.007984252646565437, 0.0011433300096541643, -0.019708719104528427, 0.04242760315537453, 0.07188636809587479, 0.02315285988152027, -0.011448081582784653, 0.06692733615636826, -0.012681085616350174, -0.02659582532942295, 0.02118951827287674, -0.02883465774357319, 0.03519394248723984, 0.03439532592892647, 0.03545662760734558, -0.024404553696513176, -0.03793802857398987, -0.015557029284536839, -0.02081052027642727, 0.022169869393110275, -0.02210552804172039, -0.044428303837776184, -0.024351410567760468, -0.02648445963859558, 0.03180274739861488, -0.009164195507764816, 0.002661369042471051, -0.024662842974066734, 0.04144997522234917, -0.009804405272006989, -0.04667440056800842, 0.017945919185876846, -0.0054513500072062016, -0.023873915895819664, 0.010796749964356422, 0.054617248475551605, -0.0031070373952388763, 0.054188184440135956, -0.00452729407697916, -0.01141531951725483, -0.010999912396073341, 0.046721551567316055, 0.001172492397017777, -0.0007956947665661573, 0.04043945297598839, -0.06741838157176971, -0.03081325627863407, 0.00038227575714699924, 0.000740807328838855, 0.040989961475133896, 0.030510161072015762, -0.009699348360300064, -0.018333788961172104, -0.03667539358139038, -0.03255533427000046, -0.0013300480786710978, -0.014006347395479679, -0.0033210443798452616, 0.011588002555072308, -0.01584508642554283, -0.00084728590445593, -0.005601425655186176, -0.018158243969082832, -0.005584743805229664, 0.036605820059776306, 0.019118059426546097, -0.023823276162147522, 0.035043735057115555, -0.006061887368559837, 0.026878274977207184, 0.015604394488036633, -0.016391176730394363, 0.03523075953125954, 0.04955090582370758, -0.029659949243068695, 0.02313297614455223, -0.017635464668273926, 0.03945570066571236, -0.14388926327228546, -0.0469246506690979, -0.000044846903620054945, 0.017415976151823997, 0.026584630832076073, -0.054467231035232544, 0.04316319525241852, 0.03371110185980797, -0.07469697296619415, 0.05521976575255394, -0.009439350105822086, 0.008510365150868893, -0.012601946480572224, 0.03521823137998581, 0.009734446182847023, 0.047679509967565536, 0.03510025143623352, 0.005375046283006668, 0.03485351800918579, 0.03746740147471428, -0.00847556907683611, -0.005709755700081587, -0.011613010428845882, -0.016686858609318733, -0.027832016348838806, -0.05468021333217621, 0.02056949958205223, -0.01837579905986786, -0.0386236310005188, -0.00881466269493103, -0.0013668740866705775, 0.03206361085176468, 0.013789069838821888, 0.008221013471484184, 0.049708228558301926, 0.04648379608988762, 0.05016334354877472, -0.01017073355615139, 0.00930293370038271, 0.003904498415067792, 0.02196715958416462, 0.022294901311397552, -0.0356510728597641, -0.018063977360725403, 0.05053192377090454, -0.005280321463942528, -0.04479110240936279, 0.03714325651526451, 0.0024537474382668734, -0.029272815212607384, -0.01363891176879406, -0.03325386717915535, -0.033351946622133255, -0.013592264614999294, 0.03720376268029213, -0.06182657554745674, -0.01819584332406521, -0.02935652807354927, 0.03784435614943504, -0.046513669192790985, -0.0015122321201488376, 0.02359604835510254, -0.052627742290496826, 0.021310847252607346, 0.019669845700263977, 0.0035354080609977245, -0.04152693599462509, 0.0005139525746926665, 0.021513519808650017, -0.012117131613194942, 0.009206409566104412, -0.01547821331769228, -0.033541928976774216, 0.03290148079395294, 0.007435458712279797, 0.01571485958993435, -0.011486954055726528, -0.020284714177250862, -0.01026207860559225, -0.059673458337783813, 0.019665632396936417, 0.009053708054125309, -0.019291386008262634, -0.02543020062148571, -0.011098186485469341, -0.05910731106996536, -0.03222117945551872, 0.09174007922410965, 0.01734934188425541, -0.017476817592978477, 0.001971460646018386, 0.04396498203277588, 0.013035325333476067, -0.040722209960222244, 0.014007210731506348, -0.02920437976717949, -0.010029556229710579, -0.04317617043852806, -0.0011934010544791818, -0.0013818069128319621, 0.03299970179796219, -0.019511228427290916, -0.01447862759232521, 0.007641143165528774, -0.0167237538844347, -0.006412144750356674, 0.06101125106215477, 0.02016313746571541, -0.035532303154468536, 0.05944686755537987, -0.005915802903473377, 0.009272968396544456, 0.02748262882232666, -0.01701926626265049, -0.06172258034348488, -0.0035564436111599207, -0.04084554687142372, -0.01926358789205551, -0.01483092736452818, 0.021077463403344154, -0.019102631136775017, -0.04777289181947708, 0.00929503608494997, 0.04358641430735588, -0.0365368127822876, -0.01913243532180786, 0.05685228481888771, 0.023219432681798935, 0.01815415360033512, 0.018940672278404236, 0.006058602128177881, 0.026250654831528664, -0.020173294469714165, 0.01419136393815279, 0.033691249787807465, 0.027113845571875572, -0.016069307923316956, 0.0032523886766284704, 0.016123095527291298, -0.0069643426686525345, 0.009486106224358082, 0.00917663425207138, 0.03662174567580223, -0.010967928916215897, -0.0005392431048676372, -0.0025623266119509935, -0.05193006992340088, 0.03226801007986069, 0.014290179125964642, -0.04234814643859863, 0.07469084113836288, -0.03557589277625084, -0.008697401732206345, -0.015243889763951302, -0.013185671530663967, -0.04283951222896576, -0.031441688537597656, 0.013322614133358002, 0.05976204201579094, -0.02496221289038658, -0.02339768595993519, -0.0015146519290283322, 0.002888998482376337, 0.016820549964904785, -0.029989592730998993, 0.025066746398806572, 0.025574754923582077, 0.020500965416431427, -0.01086372323334217, -0.025970948860049248, 0.014710086397826672, 0.00008855917258188128, 0.018704665824770927, 0.04233869910240173, -0.004497013986110687, 0.028456179425120354, -0.010595296509563923, 0.006419657729566097, 0.06032813712954521, -0.04953307658433914, -0.0011448670411482453, -0.05407861992716789, 0.0270382072776556, 0.011712123639881611, -0.00812673568725586 ]
<p>I have a question regarding a small investigation that I have been conducting into the relationship between the length of observation sequence, T, on which two decoders (BCJR and classic Viterbi) decode in a fixed small (2 state, 3 symbol) HMM.</p> <p>When I plot $T$ against the average decoding rate accuracy, I get unsurprising results, the BCJR algorithm moderately outperforms the Viterbi on symbol-by-symbol decoding and the data shows essentially no relationship between $T$ and accuracy rate.</p> <p>However, for the same sequences, I have plotted T against $\log P(O,Q\vert\lambda)$, for both the sequence from the BCJR decoder and the sequence from the Viterbi decoder, where $O$ is the observation sequence. I have also plotted $T$ against $\log P(O\vert Q,\lambda)$. In both cases, for the same set of results, there is a 'perfect' negative linear relationship between $T$ and these log probabilities. This would accord to a 'perfect' relationship: as the length of observation sequence increases, the log probabilities exponentially decrease and the exponential decrease does not vary over $T$, which would be surprising to say the least. </p> <p>Does anyone have any reasons as to how we know these results are wrong? What would be the expected relationship between $T$ and these log probabilities? Any help, no matter how small or trivial - even if just an idea or a thought, would be really appreciated as I just would like to understand this situation further.</p>
73,410
[ -0.006742472294718027, -0.04592393338680267, 0.004360432270914316, 0.013383439742028713, 0.03684854507446289, 0.004884801339358091, 0.037926848977804184, 0.004996498581022024, 0.011135071516036987, -0.017230324447155, 0.040130190551280975, 0.03915625065565109, 0.023464730009436607, 0.01979910023510456, 0.031739477068185806, -0.037472788244485855, -0.02867378108203411, 0.006573726423084736, 0.019622523337602615, 0.011912528425455093, 0.022734282538294792, 0.03954716771841049, 0.018051253631711006, 0.01129494421184063, -0.044761255383491516, 0.04360363632440567, 0.029399165883660316, -0.017093991860747337, 0.021064838394522667, 0.05709526687860489, -0.032821062952280045, -0.0000192159441212425, 0.003597599221393466, 0.059113431721925735, 0.0033263196237385273, -0.02233622781932354, -0.04939023032784462, -0.06665732711553574, -0.019831856712698936, 0.020955465734004974, -0.06569218635559082, -0.02160925604403019, -0.016860991716384888, 0.021787084639072418, -0.008775346912443638, 0.008753788657486439, 0.0007089322316460311, -0.029608972370624542, -0.0026156683452427387, -0.04014790803194046, 0.03320096433162689, 0.006234491243958473, 0.05529654398560524, -0.019295167177915573, 0.00858994945883751, -0.0035188498441129923, 0.060092322528362274, 0.09474692493677139, 0.0189520251005888, -0.03535658121109009, 0.005788660142570734, -0.025433596223592758, 0.007019891869276762, 0.008829028345644474, -0.04093683511018753, 0.010577014647424221, 0.004864348564296961, -0.02824157103896141, 0.037977416068315506, -0.02211575210094452, 0.011437276378273964, 0.025028323754668236, 0.041369374841451645, 0.010295209474861622, 0.015216569416224957, -0.010382027365267277, -0.009661602787673473, 0.038395997136831284, 0.011016884818673134, 0.045152343809604645, 0.015064955689013004, -0.02516181394457817, 0.01447942666709423, 0.055963657796382904, -0.009576528333127499, 0.0008115118253044784, 0.04737647622823715, -0.03618288040161133, -0.01538015529513359, 0.0286659374833107, 0.0028564094100147486, 0.012790502049028873, 0.05071479082107544, -0.02119365893304348, -0.05072741210460663, 0.016042673960328102, -0.02129374071955681, 0.04534095525741577, 0.026742391288280487, -0.0016320820432156324, -0.00837330985814333, -0.0311968345195055, 0.02908632718026638, 0.04981256648898125, -0.0068277535028755665, -0.009190340526401997, -0.016851140186190605, 0.023869263008236885, -0.038353532552719116, -0.033855125308036804, -0.013202819973230362, 0.01121477596461773, 0.008645416237413883, 0.02548619545996189, -0.03957965597510338, -0.06679979711771011, 0.006351622287184, -0.05115774646401405, 0.0500967875123024, 0.04793785884976387, 0.004644005559384823, -0.04184480383992195, 0.0177798829972744, -0.062058910727500916, -0.032465860247612, -0.0030501934234052896, 0.03098633885383606, -0.0387241505086422, -0.06145029515028, 0.03194279596209526, -0.00477190874516964, -0.04150379076600075, 0.05645237863063812, 0.035733554512262344, 0.016385136172175407, -0.0030252516735345125, -0.08434095233678818, -0.01815185882151127, 0.049083318561315536, 0.022319750860333443, -0.004153705667704344, -0.1009019985795021, -0.004717051982879639, 0.07869753241539001, 0.03711222484707832, -0.021669931709766388, 0.052548523992300034, 0.009125344455242157, 0.006258598994463682, 0.025883961468935013, -0.04279186949133873, 0.003685690462589264, -0.029865752905607224, 0.005448893178254366, -0.002387239132076502, -0.05409723520278931, -0.011838477104902267, 0.045095521956682205, 0.01209240686148405, -0.025338072329759598, 0.03689679875969887, 0.009355404414236546, -0.04469575732946396, -0.023801948875188828, -0.0023628149647265673, -0.04992986470460892, 0.06805889308452606, 0.009267141111195087, 0.009492374025285244, -0.011389645747840405, -0.006541564129292965, -0.0038111438043415546, 0.017138008028268814, 0.018421147018671036, 0.04396286606788635, -0.055655304342508316, -0.008163372054696083, -0.01755470223724842, 0.03591255471110344, 0.0025871589314192533, -0.008160974830389023, -0.03476477041840553, -0.020369721576571465, 0.005646159406751394, 0.028376873582601547, 0.023877231404185295, -0.023483959957957268, 0.03937890753149986, 0.04206259176135063, -0.04627327248454094, -0.039482083171606064, -0.005218997597694397, -0.004019356332719326, -0.00361690204590559, -0.022349365055561066, 0.053427115082740784, -0.0006590990233235061, 0.02097739838063717, -0.0035242573358118534, -0.005545109510421753, -0.0432351753115654, -0.023877963423728943, 0.008614100515842438, -0.015228170901536942, 0.00962133426219225, 0.03386872634291649, 0.01596607267856598, -0.010155124589800835, 0.029683703556656837, 0.004099832382053137, -0.06133287400007248, 0.030703220516443253, 0.0009585071820765734, 0.028950022533535957, -0.016037592664361, -0.00824100524187088, -0.010525205172598362, -0.009983699768781662, -0.012151403352618217, 0.01931511051952839, -0.07045383006334305, 0.047434002161026, 0.021941762417554855, 0.03601685166358948, -0.05064105615019798, 0.030360177159309387, 0.016706818714737892, 0.013634043745696545, -0.041698627173900604, 0.016246890649199486, -0.05150033161044121, -0.022888166829943657, 0.040541231632232666, 0.05267588421702385, -0.032703135162591934, -0.0015400886768475175, 0.020012512803077698, 0.003730905707925558, -0.006105920299887657, 0.02075563557446003, 0.00031971861608326435, -0.033569809049367905, 0.004929075948894024, 0.03061342053115368, -0.016842195764183998, -0.006183259189128876, 0.03801563009619713, -0.021736111491918564, 0.006973717361688614, -0.0130933141335845, -0.030180491507053375, -0.004303548485040665, -0.020031340420246124, 0.03944922238588333, -0.04232622683048248, -0.0171431265771389, 0.040504585951566696, -0.028855575248599052, -0.01063445396721363, 0.014742199331521988, -0.0008243995252996683, 0.04690585657954216, -0.012594704516232014, -0.009863742627203465, -0.011743953451514244, 0.0014638998545706272, -0.022028222680091858, -0.010329486802220345, 0.01806187443435192, -0.04176598787307739, 0.014977918937802315, -0.043632615357637405, -0.00870373286306858, -0.01653444953262806, 0.03285748139023781, 0.013032441027462482, -0.024806899949908257, 0.020709775388240814, -0.057215169072151184, -0.07312186807394028, 0.013061153702437878, -0.025786306709051132, 0.03405720740556717, 0.0023688850924372673, -0.04594499245285988, -0.009792217053472996, -0.020024564117193222, -0.023644130676984787, 0.019515734165906906, -0.018361195921897888, 0.031516872346401215, -0.03227980434894562, -0.05193491280078888, -0.033582162111997604, -0.04125766083598137, -0.03293098136782646, 0.0017085763392969966, -0.042517125606536865, 0.0042186095379292965, 0.05540498346090317, 0.015246550552546978, -0.011390097439289093, 0.019286250695586205, -0.05744538456201553, -0.0392838679254055, -0.026189005002379417, -0.011350764892995358, 0.018538180738687515, -0.04728688672184944, 0.042034439742565155, 0.019903456792235374, 0.0028447704389691353, -0.03628360107541084, -0.07860120385885239, -0.07065638899803162, 0.04646939039230347, 0.02064446546137333, 0.04089215397834778, -0.008079576306045055, -0.03678109124302864, 0.07096308469772339, 0.023713408038020134, -0.0133063904941082, -0.0001771097449818626, 0.011249455623328686, -0.021824082359671593, -0.033341437578201294, -0.010793402791023254, 0.03085044026374817, 0.00003908366852556355, 0.07110685110092163, 0.015801573172211647, 0.029944704845547676, 0.058222558349370956, -0.010978044010698795, -0.003946769051253796, 0.03387122228741646, 0.013967541977763176, -0.03596175089478493, 0.03877277672290802, 0.0014969789190217853, -0.014433885924518108, -0.0013492521829903126, 0.020114511251449585, 0.0012057021958753467, 0.0016617672517895699, -0.03314879909157753, 0.028089886531233788, 0.006071807816624641, 0.009697112254798412, -0.01962687447667122, 0.019422244280576706, -0.01125686801970005, -0.009300376288592815, -0.0033658472821116447, 0.045372653752565384, 0.016498923301696777, -0.03310919925570488, 0.020793519914150238, 0.031649310141801834, 0.030348878353834152, 0.004885978065431118, -0.02826060727238655, 0.015606398694217205, -0.02676003985106945, 0.033192552626132965, -0.011270640417933464, -0.019965320825576782, 0.028713541105389595, 0.024313945323228836, -0.004451266489923, -0.024445105344057083, -0.02292872592806816, -0.012030400335788727, -0.060942575335502625, -0.0024663936346769333, 0.005833565257489681, 0.03237177059054375, 0.010104733519256115, 0.02568873204290867, -0.01706906035542488, 0.008241581730544567, 0.02544304169714451, -0.0051121157594025135, -0.061473648995161057, -0.012696153484284878, -0.0193057619035244, -0.04921227693557739, 0.02796388790011406, -0.017366839572787285, 0.04879892244935036, -0.02324923314154148, 0.00017006421694532037, -0.02227369323372841, 0.024346470832824707, -0.04299721494317055, 0.02444012463092804, -0.011057640425860882, -0.0039557600393891335, -0.020773563534021378, -0.000035578930692281574, -0.009123091585934162, 0.004418999422341585, 0.029747648164629936, 0.033335570245981216, -0.007049000356346369, -0.011367653496563435, -0.0075332485139369965, 0.02053460106253624, 0.017410479485988617, 0.010727743618190289, 0.06541766226291656, 0.03519283980131149, -0.04261009767651558, -0.0010373425902798772, 0.0006941464962437749, 0.026186475530266762, 0.019838398322463036, 0.004341484047472477, 0.04216468334197998, -0.029640810564160347, -0.021872002631425858, 0.019546717405319214, 0.029679512605071068, 0.013373035006225109, 0.007752082776278257, 0.06653814762830734, 0.028629163280129433, -0.003411466022953391, 0.021182524040341377, 0.05473686754703522, -0.008822787553071976, 0.010306444019079208, -0.024319840595126152, 0.0012387895258143544, -0.012398689985275269, 0.036973025649785995, 0.006573897786438465, 0.0010974076576530933, -0.0029264185577630997, -0.01465604454278946, 0.04628260061144829, -0.018922852352261543, -0.022490832954645157, -0.01663629338145256, 0.011803113855421543, 0.019903691485524178, 0.019563112407922745, -0.008276996202766895, 0.01351331640034914, 0.01694139465689659, 0.04250488057732582, 0.020415887236595154, -0.010905852541327477, -0.05657403916120529, -0.011012575589120388, 0.025270842015743256, 0.01745755411684513, -0.009634722955524921, 0.002229893347248435, -0.058034032583236694, -0.010181752033531666, 0.015899116173386574, 0.0016038367757573724, 0.06298660486936569, 0.003185140434652567, -0.020502185449004173, -0.04182492941617966, -0.023363377898931503, -0.04198933020234108, 0.004266261123120785, 0.019369862973690033, 0.02656610496342182, -0.0256283488124609, -0.0020950930193066597, -0.02507823146879673, -0.016449658200144768, 0.0334082692861557, 0.08268032968044281, -0.05863460153341293, 0.026669174432754517, 0.009277727454900742, 0.00971005018800497, -0.05605822056531906, -0.04718106985092163, 0.03303825482726097, -0.04143394157290459, -0.020415829494595528, -0.0029039911460131407, -0.01723797619342804, -0.07628403604030609, 0.005373482592403889, 0.03285878896713257, -0.04332810267806053, -0.026041800156235695, 0.011395416222512722, 0.022837216034531593, -0.020180318504571915, -0.008303707465529442, 0.06243453547358513, -0.0003586860839277506, 0.01717204414308071, 0.02905060350894928, -0.03911383077502251, 0.034880511462688446, -0.02569987066090107, 0.024346839636564255, -0.009528038091957569, 0.0005818193312734365, -0.06413990259170532, 0.04959239065647125, 0.01515180617570877, 0.0302714966237545, -0.024292293936014175, 0.003970492165535688, 0.0080894585698843, 0.0043235053308308125, -0.00010373841359978542, 0.02931627444922924, -0.0173653457313776, 0.051346566528081894, -0.031674303114414215, -0.008017614483833313, 0.04809901863336563, -0.02879411354660988, -0.011566950008273125, 0.014250989072024822, -0.01627715304493904, 0.03268517926335335, -0.028987208381295204, 0.014983871020376682, 0.027072111144661903, 0.00871441513299942, 0.027598807588219643, 0.009637836366891861, -0.018202343955636024, 0.012454747222363949, -0.023320654407143593, -0.011296709068119526, -0.014847207814455032, -0.028646813705563545, 0.05835545063018799, -0.040881071239709854, 0.02878759242594242, 0.0018186686793342233, -0.002336399396881461, -0.07103913277387619, -0.06117957457900047, 0.044606443494558334, 0.006184356287121773, -0.03631711006164551, -0.014700028114020824, 0.009613942354917526, 0.011623378843069077, -0.022715970873832703, -0.017558643594384193, 0.055812958627939224, -0.009755345061421394, -0.0040669916197657585, 0.02401738055050373, 0.062045659869909286, 0.028473366051912308, 0.006684953346848488, 0.008790642023086548, -0.001778889331035316, 0.004197410307824612, -0.008972306735813618, 0.013252893462777138, 0.02688819169998169, -0.03821384906768799, -0.03595655411481857, -0.016592543572187424, -0.011520283296704292, 0.03918889909982681, -0.029196342453360558, -0.04202042147517204, -0.006200606934726238, 0.0003637299523688853, 0.01814347133040428, 0.014500396326184273, 0.005137796979397535, 0.0005656357388943434, 0.0005043713608756661, -0.03342370688915253, -0.02953863888978958, -0.00497942790389061, -0.01882103830575943, 0.026099279522895813, 0.007279686164110899, -0.03499661013484001, -0.028213126584887505, 0.05777803063392639, -0.018005860969424248, -0.009214503690600395, 0.01778564043343067, -0.010786592960357666, 0.03491073101758957, -0.01296186912804842, -0.01800665631890297, 0.041195258498191833, 0.0024667608086019754, -0.006373841315507889, -0.04532085731625557, -0.02571866847574711, 0.034145280718803406, 0.07276318967342377, 0.017330022528767586, 0.05504540726542473, -0.008429079316556454, -0.008725455962121487, 0.025929221883416176, -0.010822818614542484, -0.04209984838962555, 0.025597941130399704, 0.011247680522501469, -0.014350621961057186, -0.031457364559173584, -0.025884218513965607, 0.01073435228317976, -0.006068417336791754, 0.01825418323278427, 0.012021423317492008, 0.021346673369407654, -0.007602637633681297, 0.02255973406136036, -0.03498637303709984, -0.019212227314710617, 0.038070227950811386, -0.04206278920173645, 0.02258750982582569, -0.02261112444102764, 0.011172806844115257, 0.06103966385126114, 0.008871321566402912, 0.01951427571475506, -0.03152085840702057, 0.0027866442687809467, -0.04346129298210144, -0.008478197269141674, 0.02979147993028164, -0.008143345825374126, 0.04837624356150627, -0.02782284840941429, 0.039352450519800186, 0.024993980303406715, 0.05036080628633499, -0.035224489867687225, -0.08393526077270508, -0.030797401443123817, 0.016758739948272705, -0.04689114913344383, 0.06651868671178818, 0.005762884858995676, -0.04945874959230423, -0.003907163627445698, 0.006702364422380924, 0.07102606445550919, 0.012294142507016659, 0.03211620822548866, -0.019227083772420883, 0.05988448113203049, 0.02915993332862854, 0.04843484237790108, 0.009252122603356838, -0.025469981133937836, 0.12608253955841064, 0.08857133239507675, 0.000305137422401458, -0.06511972844600677, 0.04242480918765068, 0.0006127351080067456, 0.006428618915379047, -0.02980218082666397, 0.02613244205713272, 0.04398532956838608, -0.020719429478049278, 0.008301183581352234, 0.023953713476657867, -0.015979943796992302, -0.03821692615747452, 0.05101246014237404, -0.045599523931741714, -0.04047005996108055, 0.04178664833307266, -0.00002101949394273106, 0.014109390787780285, -0.04050027206540108, -0.009373731911182404, -0.012527752667665482, -0.015199893154203892, -0.018524138256907463, -0.00402032770216465, -0.027494100853800774, -0.03043733723461628, -0.040372222661972046, -0.004993102513253689, -0.008179017342627048, 0.0354587584733963, 0.00833754800260067, -0.009452743455767632, 0.010937683284282684, -0.033163540065288544, 0.01160982996225357, 0.015729814767837524, 0.060655348002910614, 0.0016008958918973804, -0.005459955427795649, 0.03807276114821434, 0.02008613385260105, -0.05691448226571083, -0.03594626113772392, -0.05023515596985817, 0.05388401448726654, -0.038022998720407486, 0.04798025265336037, -0.014453300274908543, 0.0008800504147075117, -0.028159642592072487, -0.02830647863447666, 0.002275796141475439, 0.032785575836896896, 0.003917214926332235, -0.035109926015138626, -0.032135386019945145, -0.029748687520623207, 0.007694239728152752, 0.008768041618168354, 0.004097760654985905, 0.016209911555051804, -0.011731250211596489, 0.006181907374411821, 0.004625203553587198, 0.043474581092596054, -0.0022487358655780554, 0.004876010585576296, -0.022129371762275696, -0.0016502205980941653, -0.04028395190834999, -0.025606999173760414, 0.017581509426236153, -0.0009338572272099555, 0.04996627941727638, 0.0024486880283802748, -0.034671343863010406, 0.026066312566399574, -0.05790957063436508, 0.035916924476623535, -0.01483477745205164, -0.02786320447921753, -0.056566834449768066, -0.010598941706120968, 0.010870610363781452, -0.005722797475755215, -0.014392051845788956, 0.07118663191795349, 0.02538483403623104, 0.054920684546232224, -0.000011768092008423992, -0.04771706834435463, 0.0020580484997481108, 0.010275942273437977, -0.026050547137856483, -0.017117450013756752, 0.006752662360668182, 0.0596855990588665, 0.01922631822526455, 0.04445762559771538, 0.002877897582948208, 0.023586921393871307, 0.00595895666629076, -0.024569151923060417, -0.031628865748643875, -0.027504896745085716, -0.00352669321000576, 0.024308469146490097, 0.03146672621369362, -0.012242943048477173, -0.028812896460294724, -0.04434535652399063, 0.006956223864108324, 0.015187454409897327, -0.05558518320322037, -0.04376817122101784, 0.0011628424981608987, -0.05036170780658722, -0.021617626771330833, -0.002115933457389474, -0.016014136373996735, 0.011745558120310307, 0.01599177159368992, -0.05086183920502663, 0.009146604686975479, -0.009801743552088737, -0.009438191540539265, -0.0010403272463008761, -0.03325021639466286, 0.048267707228660583, 0.01737302914261818, 0.0024160651955753565, -0.053911034017801285, 0.018970493227243423, -0.008899595588445663, 0.05556679517030716, -0.02129099890589714, -0.0383581779897213, 0.05144442617893219, -0.016483239829540253, -0.03624171018600464, 0.05426143854856491, -0.017744921147823334, -0.0012760331155732274, 0.006445885635912418, 0.011560139246284962, -0.011235500685870647, 0.023198315873742104, -0.007165038958191872, 0.014574702829122543, 0.012190028093755245, -0.014649443328380585, 0.024892210960388184, 0.007406424265354872, 0.000861046020872891, 0.0008445836137980223, -0.0020993619691580534, -0.0022225540596991777, 0.054665759205818176, -0.006130702327936888, 0.0525115504860878, -0.002504711039364338, 0.02536056749522686, 0.0502680242061615, -0.012487338855862617, 0.0022822727914899588, 0.022567033767700195, 0.052166648209095, -0.020430849865078926, 0.025697005912661552, 0.011798356659710407, 0.021740080788731575, -0.06985250860452652, 0.0073083010502159595, -0.018088098615407944, 0.013471788726747036, 0.03744131699204445, -0.06879572570323944, -0.01238742284476757, 0.030364857986569405, -0.039726704359054565, 0.02515517733991146, -0.008580448105931282, 0.029311304911971092, -0.0472557432949543, -0.017924534156918526, -0.049074333161115646, 0.04617776721715927, 0.03732486814260483, 0.015424112789332867, 0.03718775883316994, 0.02910703979432583, -0.0441213920712471, -0.0062442743219435215, -0.05757059529423714, 0.03255553916096687, 0.017181625589728355, -0.0410945750772953, 0.046786949038505554, -0.03698117658495903, -0.022679399698972702, 0.024172507226467133, -0.009897977113723755, 0.03010271117091179, 0.01780318282544613, 0.01879354752600193, 0.013410734944045544, 0.02565140649676323, 0.06004364788532257, -0.060632556676864624, 0.015559661202132702, -0.009402696043252945, 0.01471144612878561, 0.023485593497753143, -0.020762035623192787, 0.0010374835692346096, 0.009550968185067177, -0.011117805726826191, -0.06266876310110092, 0.020247720181941986, -0.009938071481883526, 0.0008893163176253438, -0.017678286880254745, 0.03210579231381416, -0.0039259325712919235, -0.032598819583654404, 0.04828038066625595, -0.03878737613558769, -0.0031400001607835293, 0.013857567682862282, 0.04751792922616005, -0.004005763214081526, -0.013166404329240322, -0.019422410055994987, -0.01856735348701477, 0.007286701817065477, 0.017026592046022415, 0.0010821439791470766, -0.04715919494628906, -0.006105342414230108, -0.018454834818840027, 0.027088120579719543, -0.011303386650979519, -0.016963690519332886, -0.03738074004650116, 0.06581462174654007, -0.02249569445848465, 0.04790392145514488, 0.03826690465211868, -0.007300977129489183, -0.012674039229750633, -0.06978827714920044, 0.08573351800441742, -0.01642136089503765, -0.006473436951637268, -0.03836873918771744, -0.04136979579925537, -0.014399249106645584, -0.010029086843132973, 0.09912298619747162, 0.0065510994754731655, -0.01614243909716606, 0.015588070265948772, 0.055332884192466736, -0.0029528469312936068, -0.018521418794989586, 0.025651246309280396, -0.052056871354579926, 0.010155320167541504, -0.00045937745016999543, -0.04056066274642944, 0.0020753222052007914, 0.0038371344562619925, 0.0038749861996620893, -0.05765555426478386, -0.015329289250075817, -0.0027568202931433916, 0.0005521368584595621, 0.036830008029937744, 0.023121289908885956, 0.013450706377625465, 0.06045229360461235, 0.05446060001850128, 0.03039776347577572, 0.01966424658894539, -0.02959410473704338, -0.07120771706104279, 0.00028383941389620304, 0.02436966821551323, -0.04269908741116524, 0.008915001526474953, 0.023331156000494957, 0.022279685363173485, -0.01032798457890749, -0.03137526661157608, 0.01948726549744606, -0.029864873737096786, 0.028164947405457497, 0.04341742396354675, 0.01754690706729889, 0.04623531550168991, -0.005729380529373884, 0.05188249424099922, 0.02978726290166378, 0.003859161399304867, 0.01713852770626545, 0.03340482711791992, 0.02235858514904976, -0.03081771358847618, 0.023938704282045364, -0.0036093336530029774, -0.04056992754340172, 0.04077570140361786, -0.01784229278564453, 0.05348154902458191, -0.012056665495038033, -0.019476329907774925, 0.032030683010816574, 0.02204768918454647, -0.042881228029727936, 0.0039647966623306274, -0.023711852729320526, 0.07789753377437592, 0.002293420024216175, -0.009906343184411526, -0.03486175090074539, -0.03260450065135956, -0.008000420406460762, -0.02577744610607624, -0.02137729339301586, -0.012044567614793777, 0.003606988349929452, 0.01805838756263256, -0.013779875822365284, -0.0057598683051764965, -0.002325876150280237, -0.0700843408703804, -0.022834189236164093, 0.00645812414586544, 0.003519470104947686, -0.0045705679804086685, -0.047041136771440506, -0.00953725352883339, -0.02082073502242565, 0.03195567801594734, 0.03586648777127266, 0.028035905212163925, -0.024378133937716484, -0.058310285210609436, -0.010324625298380852, 0.049016065895557404, -0.030855771154165268, 0.012352831661701202, -0.06512454152107239, 0.030017616227269173, 0.04240689054131508, -0.01833445020020008 ]
<p>Does anyone know of research which investigates the effectiveness (understandability?) of different visualization techniques? </p> <p>For example, how quickly do people understand one form of visualization over another? Does interactivity with the visualization help people recall the data? Anything along those lines. An example of visualizations might be: scatter plots, graphs, timelines, maps, interactive interfaces (like Parallel Coordinates) etc.</p> <p>I'm particularly interested in research within a lay-person population.</p>
47,168
[ -0.044113241136074066, -0.03237931802868843, -0.020358281210064888, -0.023135391995310783, 0.05780938267707825, -0.0010468346299603581, 0.015519506298005581, -0.02881402149796486, 0.017907315865159035, -0.033488743007183075, 0.01409820094704628, 0.03460858762264252, 0.03822176530957222, -0.006736325565725565, 0.035699162632226944, -0.008925175294280052, -0.027409953996539116, 0.007629866246134043, -0.0006311512552201748, -0.008478446863591671, -0.009726357646286488, -0.03752187266945839, 0.005400875583291054, 0.014475046657025814, -0.01345630269497633, 0.04576047137379646, 0.030659781768918037, -0.03927246853709221, -0.01584169641137123, 0.04419570788741112, -0.020599117502570152, 0.030806375667452812, 0.01264969538897276, 0.06140805780887604, 0.008063454180955887, -0.03242805600166321, -0.021187569946050644, -0.023014675825834274, 0.0071048191748559475, 0.004534391686320305, -0.032328952103853226, -0.02469821646809578, -0.013514336198568344, 0.04741053655743599, -0.03011680208146572, 0.03987982124090195, -0.03026757389307022, -0.04917081817984581, 0.009120084345340729, -0.03962783142924309, 0.061913903802633286, 0.0042154197581112385, 0.021839063614606857, 0.04076603055000305, -0.01522838231176138, 0.01533745788037777, 0.03071342594921589, 0.050066400319337845, 0.0053430465050041676, -0.08512160181999207, 0.04102197289466858, 0.0019043534994125366, 0.0030894940719008446, -0.024883460253477097, -0.03215482831001282, 0.06134143844246864, -0.002203374169766903, -0.011352409608662128, 0.07263914495706558, -0.017136700451374054, -0.029895421117544174, 0.04475793242454529, 0.03952691704034805, 0.02854486182332039, 0.02942311018705368, -0.03130612522363663, 0.01377723179757595, -0.016203563660383224, 0.034425731748342514, 0.03822150453925133, 0.004426831845194101, -0.001284164609387517, 0.0034392147790640593, 0.042570099234580994, -0.006755951792001724, 0.015148906968533993, 0.0998629704117775, -0.039749305695295334, 0.02059781365096569, 0.03998832404613495, -0.014694414101541042, -0.023470107465982437, 0.025930674746632576, 0.010120134800672531, -0.03938515484333038, 0.023801643401384354, -0.01635630615055561, 0.030551256611943245, 0.010767715983092785, -0.04987160861492157, -0.022909415885806084, 0.0009531400282867253, -0.0026389285922050476, 0.03672957047820091, 0.011729972437024117, -0.014649956487119198, -0.04476791247725487, 0.006890447810292244, 0.0035922937095165253, -0.03592948243021965, -0.007870571687817574, -0.00302267842926085, -0.00299342954531312, 0.029604841023683548, 0.010842839255928993, -0.05743439495563507, 0.027501180768013, 0.003092787694185972, 0.06500571966171265, 0.0729268416762352, 0.0018603563075885177, -0.028223266825079918, 0.02569386176764965, -0.024217568337917328, -0.06253081560134888, -0.021585579961538315, 0.005015016067773104, -0.015603527426719666, -0.01838473603129387, 0.047276124358177185, -0.0064069852232933044, 0.003620404051616788, 0.03483046963810921, -0.00561087392270565, 0.024639161303639412, 0.016791202127933502, -0.0665406808257103, -0.042110659182071686, 0.030539395287632942, -0.0009070442174561322, 0.029906321316957474, -0.0192111786454916, 0.01165277510881424, 0.04940180480480194, -0.011946682818233967, 0.006995515897870064, 0.01054846215993166, -0.01784718595445156, 0.04902514070272446, -0.020547769963741302, -0.027651967480778694, 0.015108403749763966, 0.012989711947739124, -0.0191204771399498, 0.0024773250333964825, -0.09448596090078354, 0.016048237681388855, 0.03625906631350517, -0.019220001995563507, -0.04045649617910385, 0.0567069835960865, 0.023750770837068558, 0.005465130787342787, -0.016563300043344498, 0.016161562874913216, -0.01139566209167242, 0.06127062067389488, -0.034314438700675964, 0.06514191627502441, 0.031722623854875565, 0.004939463455229998, 0.023987164720892906, 0.05452455207705498, 0.021696016192436218, 0.028801310807466507, -0.002952049719169736, 0.0033295108005404472, 0.037171002477407455, -0.022408215329051018, -0.021145986393094063, -0.03952652961015701, -0.03772351145744324, -0.06337794661521912, -0.012504467740654945, 0.03693749010562897, 0.057106681168079376, -0.013314252719283104, -0.02711092308163643, 0.041037119925022125, -0.04301156476140022, -0.021470267325639725, -0.06069040670990944, 0.04481073096394539, -0.022505776956677437, 0.01632283441722393, 0.04020977020263672, -0.008413542993366718, 0.01282703597098589, -0.004962703678756952, -0.03608512878417969, -0.01709921658039093, 0.0241555105894804, 0.03327522426843643, -0.041581857949495316, -0.03473782166838646, 0.017910167574882507, 0.004487507976591587, -0.05247369781136513, 0.00042949020280502737, -0.02594958432018757, -0.0550374872982502, -0.03312859684228897, -0.023900240659713745, 0.038802098482847214, -0.009973147884011269, -0.016998933628201485, -0.023239662870764732, 0.034888893365859985, -0.04986751824617386, 0.028996601700782776, -0.050768375396728516, 0.08776424825191498, 0.0211282130330801, 0.004268491640686989, -0.0007534452015534043, 0.03503982722759247, 0.01648022048175335, -0.015334583818912506, 0.03840821981430054, -0.014957640320062637, -0.06496215611696243, -0.009668071754276752, 0.07585346698760986, 0.02185836434364319, -0.031499166041612625, 0.037200938910245895, 0.029211154207587242, 0.033839259296655655, 0.004633408971130848, 0.04196567460894585, -0.02771875634789467, -0.027251720428466797, -0.01881388947367668, 0.032506946474313736, 0.022143591195344925, 0.03129592910408974, 0.02965301088988781, 0.0037148171104490757, 0.006019178312271833, 0.01612464152276516, -0.021157409995794296, 0.03743230551481247, -0.025423383340239525, -0.00001977957072085701, 0.006782163865864277, 0.018446262925863266, 0.04366004839539528, -0.022317223250865936, -0.029961327090859413, -0.005362017545849085, 0.02721354365348816, 0.012730073183774948, 0.014794085174798965, -0.005240955390036106, 0.03053472191095352, 0.039534714072942734, 0.01414054911583662, 0.02638687565922737, 0.017715249210596085, -0.005498843267560005, 0.050806500017642975, -0.06495780497789383, 0.004280822351574898, -0.02161380648612976, 0.0009025489562191069, 0.029170185327529907, 0.0028387797065079212, 0.029968509450554848, -0.038834698498249054, -0.037454430013895035, -0.02007794938981533, -0.009154805913567543, 0.008391274139285088, 0.007983486168086529, -0.030825987458229065, 0.0005880271201021969, -0.02860064059495926, -0.00289432262070477, 0.008360852487385273, -0.06106632575392723, -0.006792778614908457, 0.012040206231176853, -0.011872653849422932, -0.06835263222455978, -0.031268298625946045, -0.02039317600429058, 0.054717861115932465, -0.012327946722507477, -0.008418501354753971, 0.03226389363408089, -0.0050434330478310585, -0.04501727595925331, 0.03487797826528549, 0.006526185665279627, -0.04527847841382027, 0.006717297714203596, 0.0055228606797754765, 0.00728581054136157, -0.024086663499474525, -0.018396880477666855, 0.015504238195717335, -0.07347412407398224, -0.01825304515659809, -0.027273276820778847, -0.055511754006147385, 0.05809500440955162, -0.009748806245625019, 0.046765297651290894, -0.013842000626027584, -0.016884734854102135, 0.03796156495809555, -0.01958855614066124, -0.02074132300913334, -0.06912804394960403, -0.013753843493759632, -0.00961876381188631, -0.006439863238483667, 0.03916400298476219, 0.015106632374227047, -0.023791639134287834, 0.011636216193437576, -0.017459338530898094, 0.042437292635440826, 0.03068162128329277, 0.0015172039857134223, -0.00044996707583777606, 0.011783973313868046, 0.006690511014312506, 0.001996072707697749, -0.002933669136837125, 0.036221954971551895, -0.06752727925777435, 0.01035520900040865, -0.019020739942789078, 0.023202747106552124, 0.033170185983181, -0.02886836789548397, 0.04585445672273636, -0.027546662837266922, 0.013444559648633003, -0.012797092087566853, -0.01541850995272398, -0.015433171764016151, 0.004360734950751066, -0.023365449160337448, 0.0736675038933754, 0.023970581591129303, -0.013353429734706879, -0.014937980100512505, 0.04384671896696091, 0.049425702542066574, -0.037200409919023514, 0.02393021620810032, -0.0007304759928956628, -0.0025257724337279797, 0.024654779583215714, -0.0224283579736948, 0.014521218836307526, 0.03502662852406502, 0.039404451847076416, -0.01469976082444191, 0.0037266805302351713, -0.054499588906764984, 0.028027663007378578, -0.05816730484366417, 0.022053323686122894, -0.05325646698474884, 0.042189791798591614, 0.016470197588205338, 0.026300232857465744, 0.018333660438656807, 0.018085578456521034, -0.008052892982959747, -0.003661739407107234, -0.05540688708424568, 0.025535352528095245, -0.040927063673734665, 0.038441114127635956, 0.006633867509663105, -0.009718567132949829, 0.021502740681171417, 0.006325698457658291, -0.01832636073231697, -0.01346044521778822, 0.0895916223526001, -0.022756339982151985, -0.008162846788764, 0.000803553790319711, -0.02209441550076008, -0.04179847985506058, 0.022956835106015205, -0.025491494685411453, -0.005583918187767267, 0.05271388962864876, 0.02891838178038597, -0.03335651755332947, -0.03334842249751091, -0.010139708407223225, -0.013868404552340508, 0.02628673054277897, 0.0011318597244098783, -0.015886632725596428, 0.007536511402577162, -0.01665404438972473, 0.02459539845585823, -0.015733685344457626, 0.049259357154369354, -0.035263847559690475, -0.011267630383372307, 0.01647171378135681, -0.048110853880643845, -0.004875548183917999, -0.0046544186770915985, 0.045240238308906555, -0.01152513176202774, 0.022389639168977737, 0.01520572043955326, 0.014150978997349739, -0.04115675762295723, 0.011633967980742455, 0.009747960604727268, -0.005473615601658821, -0.002455873414874077, -0.031249186024069786, -0.02897089347243309, 0.007700263522565365, -0.015098238363862038, 0.02029976062476635, 0.028987590223550797, -0.029386045411229134, -0.022465353831648827, 0.023653747513890266, -0.020088419318199158, -0.07025371491909027, -0.012194381095468998, -0.005930892191827297, -0.009236215613782406, 0.027228331193327904, 0.018665237352252007, 0.026685325428843498, 0.007068783510476351, 0.046235255897045135, 0.02263379469513893, -0.033164963126182556, -0.07509170472621918, 0.0038460837677121162, 0.06142887845635414, 0.051865819841623306, -0.0016958550550043583, 0.02073543518781662, -0.036270953714847565, -0.004223149735480547, 0.054337866604328156, -0.002544105751439929, 0.02546202577650547, -0.04654914140701294, 0.025759952142834663, -0.06989237666130066, -0.020945066586136818, -0.001692131394520402, -0.0042395396158099174, -0.014339120127260685, 0.043963633477687836, 0.0017857798375189304, 0.022969702258706093, -0.038679223507642746, -0.01415206864476204, -0.0008434650371782482, 0.04027032107114792, 0.017620911821722984, -0.0034335614182054996, 0.007795562501996756, -0.0007296744734048843, -0.08219071477651596, -0.0430368073284626, 0.02879183553159237, 0.02990010939538479, -0.032988227903842926, 0.04288675636053085, 0.014322198927402496, -0.057951703667640686, 0.0019745181780308485, -0.007991844788193703, 0.0036285347305238247, -0.027867954224348068, -0.003102537477388978, 0.05273027345538139, 0.01869681291282177, 0.008442990481853485, 0.01567069999873638, 0.024867702275514603, -0.012147924862802029, 0.005653075408190489, 0.03340033069252968, 0.013940561562776566, -0.015750033780932426, -0.004951183684170246, 0.005397590342909098, -0.026249293237924576, -0.03468450531363487, 0.002180892275646329, -0.00962025672197342, 0.031642597168684006, -0.030449027195572853, -0.030762644484639168, -0.0068606603890657425, 0.03261658176779747, 0.037014398723840714, -0.014787268824875355, 0.02720814198255539, -0.0030097588896751404, 0.016717424616217613, -0.01982218027114868, 0.023087747395038605, 0.0012264166725799441, -0.02455226704478264, 0.047214217483997345, -0.03794529661536217, 0.0019986173138022423, -0.02287244237959385, -0.0006573786959052086, 0.02066139131784439, -0.02468021772801876, 0.07221464067697525, -0.014459849335253239, 0.015630163252353668, 0.01901961863040924, -0.07245266437530518, -0.010940609499812126, 0.03227343410253525, -0.0028887984808534384, 0.06102187559008598, -0.01552985142916441, 0.02945086732506752, -0.027232449501752853, 0.020043455064296722, -0.03543190658092499, -0.0692792534828186, 0.03348608314990997, 0.04224270209670067, -0.022713549435138702, -0.02105797454714775, 0.017478326335549355, -0.012002792209386826, -0.01716236025094986, 0.016821738332509995, 0.04064708203077316, -0.013881707563996315, -0.012071973644196987, 0.035941775888204575, 0.00033365661511197686, 0.0687851756811142, 0.00464588264003396, -0.02131156623363495, -0.0241339560598135, 0.0027624655049294233, 0.0010957218473777175, -0.001448394381441176, 0.021350761875510216, -0.02094089612364769, -0.036140453070402145, -0.033121198415756226, 0.040381815284490585, 0.019155949354171753, -0.016455315053462982, 0.024184146896004677, 0.047416046261787415, 0.010058539919555187, 0.0034990301355719566, -0.03389952331781387, 0.00004826900840271264, -0.02267945371568203, 0.02639307640492916, -0.059683963656425476, 0.0229488518089056, -0.0006568182725459337, 0.0005097545799799263, 0.030300544574856758, -0.013008205220103264, -0.04966496676206589, 0.0013030415866523981, 0.033138472586870193, 0.0070627182722091675, 0.0255921371281147, 0.03728529065847397, -0.027437327429652214, 0.01428279560059309, -0.022645410150289536, 0.030704371631145477, -0.0008338064071722329, 0.04469652473926544, -0.026301177218556404, -0.05279522016644478, 0.007280268240720034, -0.014210262335836887, 0.056304361671209335, -0.02728385291993618, 0.052570801228284836, 0.04802035167813301, -0.021955186501145363, -0.02875973843038082, -0.015881938859820366, 0.005238238722085953, -0.012326679192483425, -0.0012746368302032351, 0.04410245642066002, -0.0034756651148200035, -0.024067960679531097, 0.00495537742972374, 0.0513765774667263, -0.010745515115559101, 0.03404063358902931, 0.0038042915984988213, -0.013637218624353409, 0.060635268688201904, -0.0890328511595726, -0.0661248043179512, 0.030278347432613373, -0.035716403275728226, 0.02022898569703102, -0.015506082214415073, -0.03879837319254875, 0.04444221779704094, 0.02114269509911537, 0.0016326522454619408, 0.015305963344871998, -0.0023338599130511284, -0.050262581557035446, -0.016236741095781326, -0.0012200875207781792, -0.02230953983962536, -0.014062322676181793, -0.028680866584181786, 0.033658575266599655, -0.022363310679793358, 0.009664777666330338, -0.004341116175055504, -0.0925099104642868, -0.0065796347334980965, -0.0035668567288666964, -0.026538072153925896, 0.04039044305682182, 0.034971337765455246, -0.03803098946809769, 0.010266459546983242, -0.04263416305184364, 0.0008387286798097193, -0.008179421536624432, 0.013696642592549324, -0.024770846590399742, 0.04044146090745926, -0.027401689440011978, 0.02243388444185257, -0.013496484607458115, -0.012262837029993534, 0.10672052949666977, 0.06172595173120499, 0.038589589297771454, -0.05742757022380829, 0.04874657839536667, 0.02089289203286171, 0.0194451455026865, -0.019747497513890266, 0.04111039638519287, 0.007976185530424118, 0.013131740503013134, 0.02606830559670925, 0.07287337630987167, -0.0008783480734564364, -0.008083885535597801, 0.058226194232702255, -0.02881964109838009, -0.03927578032016754, -0.003214059630408883, 0.0027515431866049767, -0.027301987633109093, 0.009763049893081188, -0.08585207164287567, 0.00956693198531866, -0.040431246161460876, -0.025159571319818497, 0.04588786140084267, -0.009288220666348934, 0.015882883220911026, 0.0021987645886838436, -0.027405869215726852, 0.0036834734492003918, 0.018418746069073677, 0.013119849376380444, -0.023371906951069832, -0.0022856376599520445, -0.0008481981349177659, -0.004896378144621849, 0.004124624188989401, 0.04316486790776253, -0.014263019897043705, -0.003876085625961423, -0.023600025102496147, 0.029453027993440628, -0.041866958141326904, -0.01925305835902691, -0.0299071054905653, 0.016695013269782066, -0.03550047427415848, 0.010668930597603321, -0.017188331112265587, -0.021407030522823334, -0.01904970407485962, -0.03181393817067146, -0.040031179785728455, 0.01830316334962845, 0.03426937758922577, 0.01701984740793705, -0.020070763304829597, -0.011683022603392601, 0.024061601608991623, -0.03972109779715538, 0.022254381328821182, 0.015043329447507858, -0.03490795940160751, -0.012860935181379318, -0.013834170997142792, -0.01887795887887478, -0.024138854816555977, 0.0018516929121688008, -0.0019503254443407059, 0.018786044791340828, -0.0378650464117527, -0.024821721017360687, -0.0035799010656774044, 0.02300771325826645, 0.027773132547736168, 0.04131731018424034, -0.00989060290157795, -0.01705216057598591, -0.016297416761517525, 0.03042723797261715, -0.020640410482883453, -0.03309861943125725, -0.022363396361470222, 0.009099130518734455, 0.11304154247045517, 0.015905369073152542, -0.0009676521876826882, 0.004836069419980049, -0.014625299721956253, 0.0013847524533048272, 0.04500966891646385, -0.048327501863241196, -0.02825845032930374, -0.010306439362466335, -0.03316342830657959, -0.010129354894161224, -0.03583685681223869, 0.04006082937121391, 0.021538812667131424, 0.007205452769994736, 0.042396411299705505, 0.03851499781012535, 0.029640881344676018, 0.019560232758522034, -0.01647389866411686, -0.05687882751226425, -0.011483561247587204, -0.02001604437828064, -0.007983292452991009, -0.01771474815905094, 0.0043751560151577, -0.054955508559942245, 0.013863084837794304, -0.03211842104792595, -0.01026145275682211, 0.0008150768699124455, 0.03228256106376648, 0.0011988049373030663, 0.053874365985393524, 0.004755059722810984, -0.01802314817905426, -0.057008519768714905, -0.04846188798546791, -0.023630404844880104, -0.02191058173775673, 0.014641515910625458, 0.006422276608645916, 0.009936422109603882, 0.023676415905356407, 0.007632225751876831, 0.008664470165967941, -0.02442292869091034, -0.0191090926527977, 0.0003875184920616448, 0.014606637880206108, 0.02561161480844021, -0.028820212930440903, -0.03915771469473839, 0.028349654749035835, -0.02427791617810726, -0.03691272810101509, -0.009783333167433739, -0.023344000801444054, 0.015805717557668686, 0.016484474763274193, -0.025675058364868164, -0.002890579868108034, 0.05560355260968208, 0.0035000303760170937, -0.0035576126538217068, 0.004510362632572651, 0.014897352084517479, 0.00043329299660399556, 0.012097705155611038, 0.021399565041065216, -0.04721218720078468, -0.03548293933272362, 0.03220080956816673, 0.009584471583366394, 0.013183283619582653, 0.002398597775027156, -0.015475589781999588, -0.0025353648234158754, 0.02352694422006607, 0.007630085106939077, -0.04986521974205971, 0.06547671556472778, 0.024829182773828506, -0.018521996214985847, 0.03152972459793091, 0.017065424472093582, 0.00043326278682798147, -0.08061239868402481, 0.013305885717272758, 0.007698000408709049, 0.04288273677229881, 0.05884603410959244, -0.07643306255340576, -0.007283595856279135, 0.01763470657169819, -0.05040476843714714, 0.03648093715310097, 0.007901843637228012, -0.038073085248470306, -0.01025086734443903, 0.005211491137742996, 0.02880549244582653, 0.025957323610782623, 0.042016591876745224, 0.03986279293894768, -0.022918760776519775, 0.027724944055080414, -0.007332786917686462, 0.009685180149972439, 0.014120600186288357, 0.03952384367585182, -0.011930152773857117, -0.0493730790913105, 0.007500828243792057, -0.05472157523036003, -0.022039830684661865, 0.04530909284949303, 0.026226911693811417, 0.059158820658922195, 0.0159540306776762, -0.010861297138035297, -0.015026027336716652, 0.04146595299243927, 0.031886614859104156, -0.047401007264852524, -0.04098223149776459, 0.021904047578573227, 0.0075435698963701725, 0.027574973180890083, 0.008097315207123756, 0.04143628105521202, 0.008035820908844471, 0.010877219028770924, -0.028404882177710533, 0.017524467781186104, -0.0025301803834736347, -0.047979071736335754, -0.01366441324353218, -0.017264463007450104, 0.05759191885590553, -0.01223225798457861, 0.04540666937828064, -0.054387886077165604, -0.01396569237112999, 0.022514212876558304, -0.0069052958860993385, -0.019878830760717392, 0.021928204223513603, 0.008160079829394817, -0.03396063297986984, 0.02396620810031891, -0.028206126764416695, 0.03946218639612198, -0.04912884905934334, -0.00979461520910263, -0.005844105035066605, 0.05031958594918251, 0.007161068730056286, -0.0028206228744238615, 0.005249225068837404, 0.06492401659488678, -0.012650324031710625, 0.0010758485877886415, 0.0273829847574234, -0.03387970104813576, 0.002499233465641737, -0.025531141087412834, 0.08135554939508438, 0.006499034818261862, -0.017418352887034416, -0.04173518344759941, -0.013504191301763058, -0.011653569526970387, 0.014906035736203194, 0.0731266662478447, -0.03090229257941246, -0.006586228031665087, -0.026088668033480644, 0.01397500280290842, 0.018329426646232605, -0.04402777925133705, -0.0045670210383832455, -0.02604861557483673, -0.04037264734506607, 0.00551043264567852, -0.020232275128364563, 0.02468821033835411, -0.02476542629301548, 0.015314635820686817, -0.009832887910306454, -0.009164132177829742, -0.02271532453596592, 0.003304068697616458, 0.028715917840600014, 0.04501965269446373, -0.06535834819078445, 0.032443057745695114, 0.0164154265075922, 0.017246412113308907, 0.0138887083157897, -0.04034263268113136, -0.0025614574551582336, 0.023444732651114464, -0.045097485184669495, -0.00782878790050745, -0.0009960585739463568, -0.04750514030456543, -0.012757853604853153, -0.059795551002025604, -0.007724239025264978, -0.006405598483979702, -0.04503459855914116, -0.007381459232419729, 0.04481382295489311, 0.038669291883707047, 0.013962946832180023, -0.027716267853975296, 0.03975054621696472, 0.022299369797110558, -0.007027503103017807, 0.0146925775334239, 0.025687173008918762, 0.0268756952136755, 0.023198023438453674, -0.008784069679677486, 0.04311985522508621, 0.013741380535066128, 0.0313454195857048, 0.00021848762116860598, 0.052573736757040024, -0.017402419820427895, -0.009917771443724632, 0.04788104072213173, 0.004010719712823629, -0.00818372331559658, 0.024351783096790314, 0.004162435885518789, 0.07023497670888901, -0.025133371353149414, 0.007890582084655762, -0.037582095712423325, -0.036971937865018845, -0.05049009993672371, -0.014995303004980087, 0.01032970193773508, 0.05636238306760788, -0.01619451865553856, 0.0073453872464597225, -0.009621099568903446, -0.012938547879457474, 0.0413350947201252, 0.006857415195554495, 0.024417661130428314, -0.05262940004467964, -0.027559837326407433, 0.02991195023059845, -0.02070736698806286, -0.029128795489668846, -0.017701664939522743, 0.029676465317606926, 0.03546233847737312, 0.02253769151866436, 0.0020194381941109896, -0.021281875669956207, -0.017332686111330986, 0.04134709760546684, -0.10303353518247604, -0.0018088531214743853, -0.037452876567840576, 0.02573605626821518, 0.020860377699136734, 0.03409428149461746 ]
<p>This is a soft question: How can the order of a sample univariate data be reversed while preserving the variance?</p>
35,767
[ -0.05098644271492958, -0.005745323374867439, -0.008985406719148159, -0.009555049240589142, 0.025713693350553513, 0.020431937649846077, 0.013774104416370392, 0.024041803553700447, -0.0032311934046447277, -0.018790490925312042, 0.02139410562813282, 0.01788962632417679, 0.05428650975227356, 0.02654816024005413, 0.047282129526138306, -0.0018533255206421018, -0.00807012990117073, 0.03399373218417168, -0.0157867930829525, -0.0014895672211423516, 0.004500567447394133, 0.0014194295508787036, -0.0007295386167243123, -0.0003646252735052258, -0.0285645741969347, 0.029813913628458977, 0.049010418355464935, 0.006477145943790674, 0.012228468433022499, 0.07237371802330017, -0.03790966421365738, -0.03002193756401539, 0.0435563400387764, 0.048187654465436935, 0.029970306903123856, -0.011589325033128262, -0.01674431376159191, -0.04891972988843918, 0.016040951013565063, 0.012494929134845734, -0.05026182532310486, -0.012470890767872334, -0.02959306538105011, 0.030278990045189857, 0.010824494063854218, 0.022548316046595573, -0.02124633826315403, -0.026704397052526474, 0.04536297172307968, -0.03381054475903511, 0.09767645597457886, 0.003135233884677291, 0.002040234161540866, 0.04977114871144295, -0.03720088675618172, 0.04356882721185684, 0.06548020243644714, 0.0494244284927845, -0.00025274851941503584, -0.05549294501543045, 0.00390987005084753, -0.014067670330405235, -0.011176053434610367, 0.012105870991945267, -0.01719246804714203, -0.00117680081166327, -0.011080743744969368, 0.007101609371602535, 0.025489242747426033, -0.018387669697403908, 0.009481295943260193, 0.027501840144395828, 0.05115253105759621, -0.025123313069343567, 0.003890702733770013, -0.022232938557863235, 0.02589413709938526, -0.009574312716722488, 0.04128007963299751, 0.013278338126838207, 0.0207317266613245, 0.022191932424902916, 0.043312352150678635, 0.02388031594455242, -0.017001386731863022, -0.014769084751605988, 0.05965285003185272, -0.025023994967341423, 0.031147856265306473, 0.04411904513835907, -0.02097489684820175, -0.023502793163061142, 0.05054891109466553, -0.01938820630311966, -0.054329149425029755, 0.001108240569010377, -0.00730513921007514, 0.05577576905488968, -0.011320262216031551, -0.017829107120633125, 0.019194362685084343, -0.022879399359226227, 0.01709509640932083, 0.03561931103467941, -0.031585365533828735, -0.02364252507686615, 0.006126866210252047, 0.03678116202354431, -0.0019105836981907487, 0.0035366700030863285, 0.00454598106443882, -0.017023202031850815, 0.021250328049063683, -0.03861568495631218, 0.0556921623647213, 0.005228347610682249, -0.004600915592163801, -0.02806728705763817, 0.043556541204452515, 0.07057605683803558, 0.03440291807055473, -0.035748206079006195, 0.03873083367943764, 0.0037456508725881577, -0.05057234689593315, 0.01138627715408802, 0.021945929154753685, -0.010527411475777626, -0.05683476850390434, 0.026134679093956947, -0.010904680006206036, -0.04035484790802002, 0.054127104580402374, -0.036973737180233, 0.01918925903737545, 0.013963533565402031, -0.12925751507282257, -0.05627403408288956, 0.031248822808265686, -0.039331793785095215, 0.01777268387377262, -0.09713174402713776, 0.018579043447971344, 0.0017869212897494435, 0.043618861585855484, -0.003601977601647377, 0.035560574382543564, 0.01246441900730133, 0.01918499357998371, 0.03221410512924194, 0.01154637522995472, 0.010184464044868946, -0.004945673048496246, -0.004098809324204922, -0.012068177573382854, -0.08081935346126556, -0.0018024275777861476, 0.008849162608385086, -0.014715020544826984, -0.03934730961918831, 0.01864704303443432, -0.033001698553562164, 0.0012733660405501723, -0.03541801869869232, -0.014667708426713943, -0.019871897995471954, 0.07584712654352188, -0.004119287710636854, 0.002455594250932336, -0.002412866335362196, -0.007600091863423586, 0.037557944655418396, -0.01467313151806593, 0.06515979766845703, 0.04662279412150383, -0.0265787485986948, -0.0015488914214074612, -0.007046872284263372, 0.00781937874853611, 0.017582546919584274, -0.032676197588443756, 0.010510836727917194, 0.031909119337797165, 0.011271174065768719, 0.022574087604880333, 0.01472142618149519, -0.033436793833971024, 0.0018061765003949404, 0.026568077504634857, -0.05621977522969246, -0.04800937697291374, -0.09780041873455048, 0.010440289042890072, 0.004077901132404804, -0.0031777131371200085, 0.01738765276968479, 0.01785765215754509, 0.03197478875517845, -0.009019570425152779, -0.036124736070632935, 0.014175423420965672, -0.01941053755581379, 0.04102228581905365, -0.03158167004585266, -0.004598655272275209, 0.06264045834541321, 0.07497065514326096, 0.007515131961554289, 0.04759303480386734, -0.004039584193378687, -0.030701225623488426, -0.00041906494880095124, -0.025980476289987564, 0.019685912877321243, -0.01942048966884613, -0.04073186591267586, 0.025636805221438408, 0.0024435415398329496, -0.009185407310724258, 0.028974955901503563, -0.022234918549656868, 0.04154696315526962, 0.0795787125825882, -0.022520555183291435, -0.007014173083007336, 0.03241048753261566, 0.009556755423545837, 0.0328221395611763, 0.012367629446089268, -0.05020594969391823, -0.03731365129351616, -0.01212700828909874, -0.0014477651566267014, 0.032339949160814285, -0.03405965492129326, 0.025823671370744705, 0.027822818607091904, 0.0379895456135273, 0.01979096047580242, 0.021436892449855804, 0.004126195330172777, -0.02910449169576168, 0.0034119205083698034, -0.006827257107943296, 0.028669461607933044, 0.024028873071074486, -0.007915139198303223, -0.013046195730566978, 0.04628763720393181, -0.0031534978188574314, -0.028408395126461983, 0.014378054067492485, 0.003309103660285473, -0.013668091967701912, 0.010846276767551899, -0.043784670531749725, 0.020794538781046867, -0.027256807312369347, 0.04827842116355896, 0.020845655351877213, 0.014601772651076317, 0.018562374636530876, 0.021795660257339478, 0.020355839282274246, 0.020827315747737885, 0.02007416822016239, -0.03474900871515274, 0.025918247178196907, 0.039645276963710785, -0.027884338051080704, 0.01536994706839323, -0.05180869996547699, -0.028518682345747948, -0.04591327905654907, 0.001757955877110362, 0.05593110993504524, -0.012929313816130161, 0.006142818834632635, 0.002291529905050993, -0.02843421883881092, -0.026111822575330734, -0.016774095594882965, 0.022580042481422424, 0.023173172026872635, -0.04714188352227211, 0.009606755338609219, 0.02271256223320961, -0.01348321232944727, 0.01909167692065239, 0.013495346531271935, 0.01099634449928999, 0.03627542033791542, 0.004354758188128471, -0.053430378437042236, -0.014506692066788673, -0.014891491271555424, 0.020117877051234245, 0.0059808832593262196, -0.02395986206829548, 0.04172427952289581, 0.004935258533805609, -0.020828718319535255, 0.004124539438635111, -0.042685557156801224, -0.027018127962946892, -0.038362812250852585, 0.004300999455153942, 0.03807587921619415, 0.0027356117498129606, 0.020853770896792412, 0.027522459626197815, -0.032714277505874634, -0.011073751375079155, -0.031841885298490524, -0.05527925491333008, -0.006292019039392471, -0.003447819733992219, 0.01465908344835043, 0.015029462054371834, -0.017531270161271095, 0.06026219204068184, 0.02899756468832493, -0.039507921785116196, -0.015838226303458214, -0.02926451526582241, -0.009798243641853333, -0.05202476307749748, 0.037941254675388336, -0.004265797324478626, -0.006753886118531227, 0.03680979087948799, -0.01146500650793314, 0.042868565768003464, 0.04317726567387581, -0.0019216574728488922, -0.04999407380819321, -0.021292472258210182, -0.00443499069660902, 0.007061826530843973, -0.02100309729576111, -0.008146894164383411, -0.006421153899282217, 0.030740495771169662, 0.02471216768026352, 0.04027915745973587, 0.007606907282024622, -0.03772122785449028, 0.04575108364224434, -0.006750454194843769, 0.018991680815815926, -0.05637665465474129, 0.036688435822725296, 0.03924483433365822, -0.007516553625464439, -0.023663287982344627, 0.012551810592412949, 0.04366062954068184, -0.02669862098991871, -0.000695260998327285, 0.05061006546020508, 0.0731801986694336, -0.028945283964276314, -0.0018399945693090558, -0.007989268749952316, -0.0023173540830612183, 0.031224854290485382, -0.02076544426381588, -0.011010612361133099, 0.029319923371076584, 0.05518530681729317, -0.005519753322005272, 0.002138558542355895, -0.047511350363492966, 0.021326841786503792, -0.025352921336889267, 0.02954407036304474, -0.013866037130355835, 0.006626158021390438, -0.005000897217541933, 0.07615555077791214, 0.033958207815885544, 0.03318927809596062, -0.011617681011557579, 0.0049334242939949036, -0.05279042199254036, 0.05951334163546562, -0.021724296733736992, 0.024763617664575577, -0.043833207339048386, 0.0031496193259954453, 0.022832468152046204, -0.009312859736382961, 0.01860138773918152, -0.012571732513606548, -0.007266676984727383, -0.045169197022914886, -0.011315280571579933, -0.02854420430958271, -0.004867848474532366, 0.005219784565269947, 0.02186882309615612, 0.01783536933362484, -0.06089569628238678, 0.026052871719002724, 0.026856351643800735, 0.0044057113118469715, -0.019326776266098022, -0.04167119041085243, 0.036305829882621765, 0.0161619633436203, 0.04585426300764084, 0.002542695961892605, 0.027693014591932297, -0.04025058075785637, 0.019099822267889977, -0.005407629068940878, 0.05279381200671196, 0.02295028232038021, 0.007588970474898815, -0.027722667902708054, -0.010030526667833328, -0.013310329988598824, -0.000026260557206114754, 0.015750110149383545, -0.004673595540225506, 0.002666017273440957, 0.05058453977108002, 0.02483329176902771, -0.05865183472633362, 0.004198563750833273, 0.04661642014980316, 0.037534765899181366, 0.023529862985014915, -0.03534708917140961, -0.0011107348836958408, -0.004503649193793535, -0.012932904995977879, 0.03589757904410362, 0.031466562300920486, -0.033643465489149094, -0.009700881317257881, 0.033081285655498505, -0.0032455921173095703, -0.023231253027915955, -0.0005246925284154713, -0.00017320549522992224, 0.05553487688302994, 0.023407958447933197, -0.013779480941593647, 0.015473131090402603, 0.025830605998635292, 0.06477931141853333, 0.04123898968100548, 0.015322132967412472, -0.09099313616752625, 0.003071120474487543, 0.0036648043897002935, 0.0073065138421952724, -0.048802513629198074, 0.03673586994409561, -0.06131806597113609, -0.023490019142627716, 0.014651097357273102, -0.03940209001302719, 0.02368880622088909, -0.040919192135334015, 0.0012762713013216853, -0.01012155506759882, -0.012699184939265251, -0.03369872272014618, 0.006387130357325077, 0.006999549455940723, 0.015794726088643074, 0.025951284915208817, -0.0081023583188653, -0.08163076639175415, -0.006926599889993668, 0.01054066326469183, 0.050020840018987656, -0.0074793491512537, 0.025346994400024414, 0.0034721053671091795, 0.02770943008363247, -0.06403572857379913, -0.06402688473463058, 0.034782662987709045, 0.029643964022397995, -0.00263353087939322, 0.035117242485284805, -0.031351927667856216, -0.04093480110168457, 0.02266395278275013, -0.0016095010796561837, -0.0011780159547924995, 0.024365447461605072, 0.013027498498558998, 0.029277078807353973, 0.019750326871871948, 0.04126625508069992, 0.07593141496181488, 0.0035321544855833054, 0.007108897902071476, -0.038355402648448944, -0.01897324062883854, 0.03957574442028999, -0.05976786091923714, -0.012155703268945217, -0.04047522321343422, -0.010042557492852211, -0.02300330623984337, 0.02143244631588459, 0.02522463910281658, 0.05482150614261627, 0.022974200546741486, -0.02148372121155262, 0.002394766779616475, 0.028652744367718697, 0.02882268838584423, -0.019868355244398117, -0.0378614217042923, 0.05594445765018463, -0.010616954416036606, -0.04490712285041809, 0.04341894015669823, -0.0013064215891063213, -0.016090285032987595, 0.017070751637220383, -0.030416904017329216, 0.023997871205210686, -0.031353991478681564, -0.03724623844027519, -0.01561362948268652, 0.007447319105267525, 0.009215161204338074, -0.027180248871445656, 0.01338882464915514, 0.017114825546741486, -0.08568049222230911, -0.00041820682235993445, 0.026590101420879364, -0.03493541106581688, -0.002065112581476569, -0.06858622282743454, 0.04325033724308014, 0.022235071286559105, 0.027855917811393738, -0.090795136988163, -0.06545194238424301, -0.0001610536128282547, 0.02624685876071453, -0.01505177840590477, -0.042422886937856674, -0.0067914510145783424, 0.01720372959971428, -0.04402641952037811, -0.030277546495199203, 0.05289702117443085, -0.01001950353384018, -0.010503268800675869, -0.005193592514842749, -0.010000504553318024, 0.08995775133371353, -0.043691486120224, 0.002276327693834901, 0.04113587737083435, -0.0689077228307724, -0.009180266410112381, 0.005820126738399267, 0.028339339420199394, -0.01861567422747612, 0.03762831166386604, -0.007869113236665726, -0.00884691160172224, 0.024940920993685722, 0.00006190853309817612, 0.004239797126501799, 0.00313110975548625, -0.002916737226769328, -0.005329614505171776, -0.03958376124501228, -0.023258844390511513, -0.025926226750016212, 0.020700516179203987, -0.02224517986178398, -0.011501096189022064, 0.001880304072983563, -0.017499633133411407, 0.028796257451176643, 0.022137856110930443, -0.00032343619386665523, -0.0009413041407242417, 0.04766322672367096, -0.056769959628582, -0.040367498993873596, 0.0004887530230917037, -0.03610696271061897, 0.014753032475709915, 0.042892273515462875, 0.011076664552092552, 0.0036151064559817314, -0.0012664563255384564, -0.04031665623188019, -0.02497183345258236, -0.005310545675456524, 0.009645365178585052, 0.08743773400783539, -0.014964182861149311, 0.05598246306180954, 0.046606436371803284, 0.0031121415086090565, 0.0007507970440201461, -0.022836415097117424, -0.003753464203327894, 0.00824432447552681, -0.005098788999021053, 0.04352924972772598, 0.010517256334424019, 0.018568987026810646, 0.009653558023273945, 0.02543131820857525, 0.02046230435371399, 0.02361353673040867, 0.0315883494913578, 0.00927159283310175, -0.004352898802608252, 0.0016035456210374832, -0.03973766416311264, 0.008796581998467445, -0.06180368363857269, 0.013547618873417377, -0.03106677532196045, -0.03275620564818382, 0.03876388445496559, 0.01322645228356123, 0.004494739696383476, -0.05948169156908989, -0.042823661118745804, -0.06627750396728516, 0.00423085642978549, -0.017965596169233322, 0.010674468241631985, 0.012225017882883549, -0.015509403310716152, 0.006074816454201937, -0.006822322495281696, 0.008342061191797256, -0.0315147265791893, -0.06128598377108574, -0.03347671404480934, 0.0020951922051608562, -0.03795529529452324, 0.043221376836299896, 0.017144957557320595, -0.010449283756315708, 0.00499722408130765, -0.007489505223929882, 0.0010795177659019828, -0.007139386609196663, 0.04118051007390022, -0.019780540838837624, 0.06995629519224167, 0.06290361285209656, 0.04019865766167641, 0.004093081224709749, -0.009759103879332542, 0.10198985040187836, 0.054772213101387024, 0.03444097936153412, -0.09508546441793442, 0.037661075592041016, -0.005048321560025215, -0.019324883818626404, 0.011753681115806103, 0.02770397998392582, 0.004821303300559521, 0.03686552122235298, 0.03864406794309616, 0.04444621503353119, 0.025127170607447624, -0.004305114038288593, 0.06882783025503159, -0.05675715580582619, -0.013325272127985954, -0.0254245325922966, 0.007428286597132683, -0.013038689270615578, -0.028612174093723297, -0.0766577422618866, 0.005939430557191372, -0.02208106219768524, -0.010794551111757755, -0.013903919607400894, -0.05322234332561493, -0.006316082552075386, 0.0026650934014469385, -0.01659584604203701, 0.03134290128946304, 0.050184838473796844, 0.0126827172935009, -0.06448888033628464, -0.003036205656826496, 0.04481184110045433, -0.012740270234644413, 0.007456137798726559, 0.00545996380969882, 0.005688606761395931, 0.021515008062124252, -0.015629107132554054, -0.0033027678728103638, -0.01724482700228691, -0.029801296070218086, -0.004131297115236521, 0.011206606402993202, -0.006382022053003311, -0.007875674404203892, -0.036332450807094574, -0.00877476204186678, -0.007274983450770378, -0.05250963941216469, -0.027634847909212112, 0.033167239278554916, 0.011199777014553547, -0.007073095068335533, -0.04708505794405937, -0.031213555485010147, 0.018879441544413567, -0.012858756817877293, 0.03688767924904823, 0.013218458741903305, -0.048791900277137756, -0.018379351124167442, -0.020011261105537415, 0.05225945636630058, -0.0015284201363101602, -0.03416329622268677, -0.005587896332144737, -0.014991537667810917, -0.013692950829863548, 0.0006383688887581229, 0.030777670443058014, 0.018726062029600143, 0.005674732383340597, -0.02610904723405838, -0.005434719379991293, -0.02377942018210888, -0.03614361584186554, 0.02733389474451542, -0.033527471125125885, 0.00963679887354374, -0.032996270805597305, -0.02468651346862316, 0.03257545828819275, 0.06223824992775917, 0.0023876673076301813, 0.021440917626023293, -0.009798144921660423, 0.02749551832675934, 0.011898952536284924, -0.038520198315382004, -0.033388953655958176, 0.02826126292347908, -0.03226624056696892, -0.004859453067183495, 0.00643540546298027, 0.06100032106041908, 0.05105401203036308, 0.021212298423051834, -0.020426107570528984, 0.03508903086185455, -0.02330205775797367, 0.008026696741580963, 0.023264780640602112, -0.057141441851854324, 0.019070008769631386, 0.02147005684673786, -0.02699582464993, -0.011831661686301231, -0.065586619079113, -0.008840649388730526, -0.01750129647552967, -0.0013880063779652119, 0.005045878700911999, 0.024519536644220352, -0.004850654862821102, 0.007922538556158543, 0.0360388457775116, -0.005490866024047136, 0.00018580352480057627, -0.035082604736089706, -0.004974286537617445, -0.010519202798604965, -0.02430587075650692, -0.010837274603545666, 0.01431566197425127, -0.001855483278632164, 0.007916677743196487, 0.04374423995614052, 0.010833649896085262, 0.06035666540265083, -0.010529442690312862, -0.004337225575000048, 0.02085282653570175, 0.030085450038313866, -0.021704211831092834, -0.050953593105077744, 0.019860826432704926, -0.09021420776844025, -0.036011435091495514, 0.02752823941409588, -0.02417938970029354, 0.021139532327651978, -0.0065372409299016, 0.0007130301091820002, -0.033511485904455185, 0.03946763277053833, -0.03064453974366188, -0.0008862139657139778, -0.005546045955270529, 0.0056081912480294704, 0.02022491954267025, -0.022082431241869926, 0.003324223216623068, -0.016442185267806053, -0.019823793321847916, 0.04418779909610748, 0.029388245195150375, 0.01550507266074419, -0.007390913553535938, 0.017180729657411575, 0.004559490829706192, 0.023921692743897438, 0.005494995042681694, 0.00813981331884861, -0.0028017277363687754, 0.06675636768341064, -0.04718198627233505, 0.04573824629187584, -0.007362901698797941, -0.0027623220812529325, -0.09507844597101212, -0.01748383231461048, 0.020485995337367058, -0.048639409244060516, 0.031854718923568726, -0.04419129341840744, 0.011854223906993866, 0.024778064340353012, -0.05176817998290062, 0.039761096239089966, -0.0033501992002129555, -0.023334214463829994, -0.010580932721495628, 0.023314343765378, -0.03071296401321888, 0.02947613224387169, 0.01580139435827732, 0.001568497042171657, 0.03695110231637955, 0.014116817153990269, 0.005387832876294851, 0.006523804739117622, -0.022091757506132126, 0.0062760175205767155, 0.006362952757626772, -0.031698863953351974, 0.018490901216864586, -0.03244312107563019, -0.03466245159506798, 0.03758243843913078, -0.008842166513204575, 0.016737215220928192, 0.010512941516935825, 0.032313860952854156, 0.0003017903654836118, 0.015874268487095833, 0.00515212444588542, -0.006837313063442707, -0.03272439166903496, 0.020272569730877876, 0.03771142289042473, 0.02198227308690548, -0.011953515000641346, 0.03888333588838577, 0.029369639232754707, -0.01633678562939167, -0.003215264296159148, -0.004861125722527504, -0.019086485728621483, -0.015419612638652325, 0.00680380966514349, -0.0019429228268563747, -0.0014616509433835745, -0.027710260823369026, 0.03446924686431885, -0.044039733707904816, -0.025431454181671143, 0.053292080760002136, 0.017622629180550575, -0.011339923366904259, -0.00046719342935830355, -0.024093108251690865, -0.043129436671733856, 0.003224889747798443, -0.0033839039970189333, -0.03879019618034363, -0.061261437833309174, 0.005764844361692667, 0.0231180377304554, -0.019711628556251526, -0.030026914551854134, -0.02991907298564911, -0.008563999086618423, 0.05008169636130333, 0.029620658606290817, -0.00355905550532043, 0.013568231835961342, -0.037782080471515656, 0.006984165403991938, -0.057895317673683167, 0.041801806539297104, -0.005274250637739897, -0.01847153715789318, -0.01809251680970192, -0.011474302038550377, -0.017331471666693687, 0.024948332458734512, 0.05825216695666313, 0.009550339542329311, 0.003106806194409728, 0.008922519162297249, 0.05701690912246704, 0.023065948858857155, -0.043619304895401, 0.03624539449810982, -0.008362647145986557, -0.0025650840252637863, 0.006829490885138512, -0.05004192888736725, -0.008841483853757381, 0.03740920498967171, -0.05427280813455582, -0.017675338312983513, 0.013997277244925499, 0.01409511175006628, 0.00958292093127966, 0.013617596589028835, -0.027327800169587135, -0.022470319643616676, 0.042811423540115356, -0.008181004785001278, -0.023234598338603973, 0.0016827889485284686, -0.006984023842960596, -0.05665520951151848, 0.038861822336912155, -0.049704402685165405, -0.012208154425024986, -0.03974303975701332, 0.04394660145044327, 0.02403871901333332, -0.042491327971220016, 0.0026666787452995777, 0.01655125804245472, -0.04026965796947479, 0.028046144172549248, 0.033308207988739014, 0.027552330866456032, 0.010148950852453709, 0.00253509939648211, -0.02264442853629589, 0.007285015657544136, -0.003008211264386773, 0.04190046712756157, 0.03695268929004669, 0.011578220874071121, -0.002846342511475086, -0.006771612912416458, 0.030141282826662064, -0.020573008805513382, 0.0328805036842823, -0.03115815669298172, 0.03260641172528267, -0.017337795346975327, -0.01893426477909088, 0.02975056692957878, -0.031531646847724915, 0.02547178976237774, -0.04183228313922882, 0.0005186545313335955, 0.05190085619688034, -0.03994692862033844, 0.022703951224684715, -0.03656145557761192, 0.005854691844433546, -0.049439992755651474, -0.03225960209965706, 0.0071035223081707954, 0.01369463000446558, -0.012675940990447998, 0.0038867017719894648, -0.027341647073626518, 0.006059262435883284, 0.049525368958711624, -0.00359424133785069, 0.031316060572862625, -0.006249342579394579, -0.01472568977624178, -0.013452315703034401, -0.030966414138674736, -0.05797918885946274, -0.05118338018655777, 0.006096953991800547, 0.019798627123236656, 0.02430003508925438, 0.04308156296610832, -0.036878153681755066, -0.01237752940505743, 0.047279343008995056, -0.06446092575788498, -0.07107914239168167, -0.04565128684043884, 0.013370903208851814, -0.020597446709871292, -0.0025531018618494272 ]
<p>Hello I'm running anova with R and I am wondering what the differce is between multiway anova and single anova. I know single anova gives a different answer than multiway anova but I dont know how to quantify multiway anova. Could someone explain in words the difference between:</p> <ul> <li>base~col1</li> <li>base~col1+col2</li> <li>base~col1*col2</li> </ul> <p><a href="http://www.gardenersown.co.uk/Education/Lectures/R/anova.htm#anova_1" rel="nofollow">http://www.gardenersown.co.uk/Education/Lectures/R/anova.htm#anova_1</a></p> <p>How do I interpret the results of col1+col2 and col1*col2 because col2 is giving a P(>F) of 0.473 on single anova but P(>F) 4.21e-07 in multiway anova. col2 does correlate well with base having only a 2% coloration for 711 individuals. According to <a href="http://vassarstats.net/rsig.html" rel="nofollow">http://vassarstats.net/rsig.html</a> 2% coloration isn't significant. Thank you</p> <p>edit: i know my col1 and col2 have some interactions is that causing the low multiple anova p value?</p> <p>i am using </p> <pre><code>aov.ex2 &lt;- aov(base~col1+col2,data=data1) summary(aov.ex2) aov.ex2 &lt;- aov(base~col1,data=data1) summary(aov.ex2) aov.ex2 &lt;- aov(base~col1,data=data1) summary(aov.ex2) </code></pre> <p>and the results are not simular</p>
73,411
[ -0.01585223712027073, -0.013064026832580566, 0.0010228506289422512, 0.019936595112085342, 0.009894109331071377, -0.0020906252320855856, 0.0025147730484604836, -0.04378192126750946, 0.0021547512151300907, -0.02461419440805912, 0.04003988206386566, 0.022563859820365906, 0.043182745575904846, 0.037130989134311676, 0.01707492023706436, 0.013663755729794502, 0.018016161397099495, 0.004860749933868647, 0.04226149991154671, 0.007829873822629452, -0.03488687798380852, 0.016235781833529472, -0.003776037599891424, -0.027839120477437973, -0.0030179647728800774, 0.06121263653039932, 0.033431023359298706, -0.03343877196311951, 0.015916429460048676, 0.052209001034498215, -0.02368025854229927, -0.014928719028830528, -0.006540280766785145, 0.030957350507378578, 0.006542187184095383, 0.015113583765923977, -0.0019245537696406245, -0.02332897111773491, 0.012195153161883354, 0.042146649211645126, 0.0026718713343143463, -0.01442735642194748, 0.0051147956401109695, 0.03449363261461258, 0.0022903045173734426, 0.021220693364739418, -0.009764613583683968, -0.012746251188218594, 0.06191902980208397, -0.04391379654407501, 0.04811834916472435, -0.014256726019084454, 0.03383592888712883, 0.048390742391347885, -0.010538446716964245, 0.004880740772932768, 0.021433407440781593, 0.02585836686193943, 0.00660850340500474, -0.060189682990312576, -0.02250109799206257, -0.015148475766181946, -0.007587912026792765, -0.02724534645676613, -0.06367575377225876, -0.011704472824931145, 0.024806814268231392, -0.01389703992754221, 0.06368730962276459, -0.014431457035243511, 0.0355493538081646, -0.00767569849267602, 0.0294381994754076, -0.013973584398627281, 0.02301391400396824, 0.001988086150959134, 0.020266106352210045, -0.007843340747058392, 0.036676857620477676, 0.037994708865880966, -0.003928209189325571, 0.020187649875879288, 0.012708725407719612, 0.044349487870931625, 0.03644806519150734, -0.011962520889937878, 0.032546818256378174, -0.03319751098752022, -0.02826351299881935, -0.004406197462230921, -0.03130464628338814, -0.019410140812397003, 0.06712374836206436, 0.043095555156469345, -0.02154017984867096, 0.043002355843782425, -0.015661491081118584, 0.03888751193881035, -0.003671957878395915, -0.02593001164495945, -0.03218280151486397, -0.01949670910835266, 0.03568914905190468, 0.052371200174093246, -0.0432586595416069, -0.010283275507390499, -0.032598961144685745, 0.012000968679785728, -0.012184436433017254, -0.04033435881137848, -0.0014396895421668887, 0.018112722784280777, -0.015202785842120647, 0.0014971402706578374, -0.008763852529227734, -0.01995413936674595, -0.0014503673883154988, 0.046028006821870804, 0.08278214186429977, 0.054147131741046906, 0.04301055893301964, -0.00920560210943222, -0.018111011013388634, -0.016035299748182297, -0.014373783953487873, 0.024273477494716644, 0.024305427446961403, 0.01624882034957409, -0.03808004781603813, 0.0770239531993866, -0.018696902319788933, -0.006754026748239994, 0.0032574720680713654, 0.001703549176454544, 0.012471787631511688, -0.013560820370912552, -0.1295679658651352, -0.0544520728290081, 0.036309417337179184, -0.03626254200935364, 0.03353646770119667, -0.06685182452201843, -0.010481564328074455, 0.02426593191921711, 0.06447775661945343, -0.0222771018743515, 0.021946405991911888, -0.012921851128339767, 0.013929530046880245, 0.058819014579057693, -0.029393214732408524, 0.0065740966238081455, -0.02856956422328949, -0.034113772213459015, -0.008123690262436867, -0.08337365090847015, 0.024120092391967773, 0.00286282179877162, 0.022835317999124527, 0.030388833954930305, 0.024530431255698204, 0.02778567001223564, -0.02656547538936138, 0.010621970519423485, 0.015819743275642395, -0.02265721559524536, 0.06521092355251312, -0.01721513830125332, 0.03647805005311966, 0.018242668360471725, -0.0336129292845726, 0.026217153295874596, -0.029238855466246605, 0.049094200134277344, 0.031025966629385948, 0.019727235659956932, -0.007651426829397678, -0.02391105145215988, 0.0024372260086238384, 0.0016421437030658126, -0.06367406249046326, -0.012141736224293709, -0.03411312773823738, -0.009239878505468369, 0.020176637917757034, 0.053309179842472076, 0.0028607810381799936, -0.013836266472935677, 0.03672027215361595, -0.040773726999759674, -0.05277727171778679, -0.06190015375614166, -0.0037907275836914778, 0.023049458861351013, -0.05865366756916046, -0.01210794784128666, -0.0010564537951722741, 0.00047805838403292, 0.0185491181910038, 0.004877118393778801, -0.028867360204458237, 0.019565524533391, 0.07539337873458862, -0.0673094391822815, 0.014431647956371307, 0.013146153651177883, 0.04965154454112053, -0.027375943958759308, 0.052855730056762695, -0.05141327902674675, -0.037950750440359116, 0.0047022439539432526, -0.019080163910984993, 0.017890648916363716, 0.014976943843066692, -0.026791399344801903, 0.01694062352180481, 0.03918822854757309, -0.023069478571414948, 0.06223030388355255, -0.07320921868085861, 0.08989883959293365, 0.04541214555501938, 0.0022972412407398224, 0.00392628600820899, 0.006335333455353975, 0.020191533491015434, 0.008192559704184532, -0.034940820187330246, 0.02204638347029686, 0.0007169917807914317, 0.0031037249136716127, 0.04853316396474838, -0.025458546355366707, -0.011962099000811577, 0.0037046424113214016, -0.024704113602638245, 0.007974701933562756, 0.0010604853741824627, 0.04947609826922417, 0.019067877903580666, -0.030982259660959244, 0.028921615332365036, 0.03518904373049736, 0.02985270880162716, -0.0020226757042109966, 0.009858752600848675, -0.010960150510072708, 0.062296029180288315, -0.0005120726418681443, 0.00003076349457842298, 0.045602377504110336, 0.012666163966059685, -0.004765440244227648, -0.042876746505498886, 0.02475028485059738, 0.015978608280420303, -0.036496732383966446, 0.006510658655315638, 0.050771694630384445, 0.015570518560707569, -0.015114462934434414, -0.05341752991080284, -0.038031164556741714, 0.0044078705832362175, 0.029024822637438774, -0.025422679260373116, 0.005127593409270048, -0.008557195775210857, 0.0023237981367856264, 0.011343449354171753, -0.029170773923397064, -0.030827539041638374, -0.0068543292582035065, 0.02718318998813629, 0.041007593274116516, 0.011509731411933899, 0.023383257910609245, -0.03446758911013603, -0.024360191076993942, -0.008299008943140507, -0.03811245411634445, 0.0015707450220361352, -0.010678783990442753, -0.03296157345175743, 0.014205505140125751, -0.028414767235517502, 0.015865983441472054, 0.020480412989854813, -0.002782186958938837, -0.039565056562423706, 0.04091835767030716, 0.020097512751817703, -0.03179299831390381, -0.043716978281736374, -0.005815216340124607, 0.010078002698719501, -0.007008938118815422, -0.026937900111079216, 0.015353825874626637, 0.032445382326841354, -0.02467716485261917, 0.03060343861579895, -0.04408815875649452, -0.014459764584898949, 0.012761559337377548, 0.0182317066937685, 0.03369108587503433, 0.014450330287218094, 0.02483351342380047, 0.02971615083515644, -0.022599032148718834, -0.03139052540063858, -0.04155394807457924, -0.05018085613846779, -0.010289818048477173, 0.012627133168280125, 0.02181277424097061, -0.043780725449323654, -0.01657605729997158, 0.019170839339494705, 0.015761610120534897, -0.04032689705491066, -0.05128660053014755, -0.006352581083774567, -0.03267046809196472, 0.0013536012265831232, 0.017218779772520065, 0.02795575000345707, 0.01193456444889307, 0.01808536797761917, -0.013290124014019966, 0.034681472927331924, 0.05499959737062454, 0.016885174438357353, 0.011725310236215591, 0.009062484838068485, 0.006279999855905771, -0.022203272208571434, 0.024123260751366615, 0.0269011240452528, -0.04758906736969948, -0.011752903461456299, 0.009238427504897118, 0.02467701956629753, 0.0019173420732840896, -0.015031843446195126, 0.024879219010472298, -0.014637792482972145, 0.032587166875600815, -0.04623985290527344, 0.024731989949941635, 0.015486335381865501, -0.02890794910490513, -0.012135053053498268, -0.01767955720424652, 0.03732431307435036, -0.020449258387088776, 0.012396715581417084, 0.0552731491625309, 0.047661300748586655, -0.01498683262616396, 0.021210921928286552, -0.04310561344027519, -0.003754217177629471, 0.00930883176624775, -0.017383836209774017, 0.011764231137931347, 0.04101216048002243, 0.030656689777970314, 0.006954962853342295, -0.005346217658370733, -0.02049116976559162, 0.008241436444222927, -0.030478904023766518, 0.022577159106731415, -0.06152645871043205, 0.030817581340670586, -0.019722916185855865, 0.08137395977973938, -0.017480850219726562, -0.02061644196510315, -0.021474316716194153, -0.023084457963705063, -0.039114657789468765, 0.006173443049192429, 0.030338674783706665, -0.028266075998544693, 0.03051856718957424, -0.06846585124731064, 0.012124860659241676, -0.025801556184887886, 0.0003182055661454797, -0.019533002749085426, 0.02457841858267784, 0.023877890780568123, 0.03240979090332985, -0.027812691405415535, 0.009442419745028019, -0.012625494971871376, 0.025264935567975044, 0.0012741766404360533, 0.01640060357749462, 0.029126273468136787, 0.01259876973927021, -0.022129418328404427, -0.012990894727408886, -0.02631635218858719, 0.013589468784630299, 0.04561547562479973, 0.0401543565094471, 0.04715472459793091, 0.05654068663716316, -0.04419360309839249, 0.023251626640558243, 0.00834242906421423, 0.03867684304714203, 0.011225464753806591, 0.02921096608042717, 0.005006533116102219, -0.025045175105333328, -0.01996230147778988, 0.001652686856687069, 0.02155664935708046, -0.030044887214899063, -0.01584288291633129, 0.012525261379778385, 0.017297111451625824, -0.024310912936925888, 0.015176154673099518, 0.05553284287452698, -0.014492731541395187, -0.005078910384327173, -0.02990550547838211, 0.010625319555401802, -0.03437840938568115, -0.013077698647975922, 0.04492883011698723, 0.0069841016083955765, 0.004150332883000374, -0.0021624229848384857, 0.030929898843169212, -0.012639855965971947, -0.03195982053875923, 0.007588879205286503, 0.005682402290403843, 0.023964591324329376, -0.02325344644486904, -0.04516008496284485, -0.010513235814869404, 0.004698867443948984, 0.018137220293283463, 0.02040732651948929, 0.010347457602620125, -0.06701700389385223, -0.0234181210398674, 0.05077539011836052, 0.05165483430027962, -0.03795093670487404, 0.002078576246276498, 0.005159203894436359, -0.017429232597351074, 0.019357291981577873, -0.005732924211770296, 0.03817067667841911, -0.01717470958828926, 0.016292158514261246, -0.03999505937099457, -0.0005130189820192754, -0.06614422798156738, 0.01645398698747158, -0.040823355317115784, 0.004484768491238356, -0.011052344925701618, -0.01934567652642727, -0.06320372968912125, 0.004869529046118259, -0.0020608657505363226, 0.013396435417234898, -0.04981767013669014, -0.00964683759957552, 0.03450543433427811, 0.028889568522572517, 0.013820149935781956, -0.036368828266859055, 0.05942738801240921, -0.030194805935025215, 0.0047743720933794975, 0.05367320403456688, -0.0050947698764503, 0.005552868824452162, 0.0541081540286541, 0.00434596324339509, -0.005423323251307011, -0.01565694808959961, -0.026730360463261604, 0.0250419769436121, 0.026814213022589684, -0.018522005528211594, 0.05882410332560539, 0.018473194912075996, -0.017787838354706764, 0.01570506952702999, -0.062014371156692505, 0.01983761601150036, -0.01826540194451809, -0.045038823038339615, -0.031890787184238434, -0.014046363532543182, -0.010087301954627037, 0.03345334529876709, 0.01731010153889656, 0.04817492142319679, -0.05245502293109894, -0.024671703577041626, 0.022566087543964386, -0.025564715266227722, 0.0005746025708504021, 0.0030645604711025953, -0.014026880264282227, 0.00572453998029232, -0.024539252743124962, 0.008555212989449501, 0.005179353523999453, -0.03015848621726036, -0.054425936192274094, -0.013346834108233452, -0.03182016685605049, 0.007055672816932201, -0.01829564943909645, -0.03042423538863659, 0.0025411448441445827, -0.009719034656882286, -0.0021904988680034876, -0.009018640033900738, 0.02585003525018692, -0.022311504930257797, -0.08154658228158951, -0.04210126772522926, 0.05429156497120857, -0.011864989064633846, 0.02188054658472538, -0.03426692634820938, 0.05114174634218216, -0.012596245855093002, -0.029774904251098633, -0.04673955962061882, -0.023222429677844048, -0.002286636270582676, -0.007383204996585846, -0.018778137862682343, -0.021307632327079773, -0.045809246599674225, -0.030569156631827354, -0.0063029807060956955, -0.010652040131390095, 0.044400833547115326, -0.019921215251088142, 0.019128039479255676, -0.00990424957126379, -0.0008318288601003587, 0.04343700408935547, 0.0021053135860711336, -0.0007629435858689249, -0.023113494738936424, -0.011902987957000732, -0.02927306853234768, 0.016877301037311554, 0.00922821369022131, -0.016307733952999115, 0.004839695058763027, 0.00639521237462759, 0.003928749822080135, 0.022974852472543716, -0.018430696800351143, 0.0006804882432334125, 0.005728344898670912, -0.007555361371487379, 0.02279006876051426, -0.06200338155031204, 0.013296692632138729, -0.01104858610779047, 0.04957175627350807, -0.035860564559698105, -0.0012405704474076629, -0.011812711134552956, 0.004721121396869421, 0.002246096497401595, -0.016231289133429527, -0.018513265997171402, 0.010658378712832928, 0.0672445222735405, -0.025517821311950684, 0.0328199602663517, -0.009369058534502983, -0.053133122622966766, -0.012569052167236805, -0.004761266987770796, -0.010704642161726952, 0.014286450110375881, 0.02905227057635784, -0.04253532737493515, 0.007975650951266289, -0.032725073397159576, 0.022502046078443527, 0.07015633583068848, -0.02028042823076248, 0.044924281537532806, 0.024901213124394417, 0.026621093973517418, -0.0059540774673223495, -0.0060587553307414055, -0.01623985543847084, -0.0012722464744001627, 0.04353678971529007, 0.06922905147075653, -0.023266226053237915, -0.018020594492554665, 0.016233157366514206, -0.0019014417193830013, 0.005491883493959904, 0.03967374563217163, 0.03715875744819641, 0.008260432630777359, 0.004471985157579184, 0.0015327924629673362, -0.05218944698572159, 0.04018467664718628, -0.026579907163977623, 0.0050833928398787975, -0.04388770833611488, 0.0037783219013363123, 0.06408024579286575, 0.059683170169591904, -0.009763467125594616, -0.08588764071464539, -0.03648202493786812, -0.042144060134887695, -0.020695053040981293, -0.008034714497625828, -0.030195463448762894, -0.0016938615590333939, -0.014407852664589882, 0.036333926022052765, -0.0481499545276165, 0.016379758715629578, -0.05526495724916458, -0.07792214304208755, -0.0023164015728980303, -0.014153940603137016, -0.03160267695784569, 0.0513618104159832, -0.008594629354774952, -0.041591059416532516, 0.02284606359899044, -0.05842256918549538, 0.015155875124037266, -0.017295770347118378, 0.05154726281762123, -0.016829963773489, 0.04228980466723442, 0.007362117059528828, 0.025263052433729172, 0.023972131311893463, 0.014188694767653942, 0.12778490781784058, 0.05443239212036133, 0.01895899884402752, -0.07042388617992401, 0.029393309727311134, -0.0023881022352725267, 0.05185069516301155, -0.03544078767299652, -0.026705434545874596, -0.002829517237842083, 0.011245572939515114, 0.05705669894814491, 0.0529438853263855, 0.018043935298919678, -0.0037154979072511196, -0.0017257591243833303, -0.028051618486642838, -0.04447002708911896, -0.011899035423994064, -0.011563051491975784, -0.006829576566815376, 0.011045357212424278, -0.026216764003038406, -0.03344929963350296, 0.028024381026625633, 0.014311560429632664, -0.02129601500928402, -0.0008889932651072741, 0.003249335801228881, -0.0016267525497823954, 0.003553727874532342, 0.027983009815216064, -0.01723622903227806, 0.022007139399647713, -0.03245307505130768, 0.01262078806757927, 0.06404618173837662, -0.09543479979038239, 0.008519201539456844, 0.0361294150352478, -0.0017991194035857916, -0.02620488964021206, 0.007308133877813816, 0.0462074801325798, -0.048797376453876495, -0.023369286209344864, -0.022340066730976105, 0.04858255758881569, 0.032148875296115875, -0.0049865772016346455, -0.021133149042725563, -0.014477333053946495, -0.02446088008582592, -0.034430257976055145, -0.026521798223257065, 0.0008365928079001606, 0.02800455316901207, -0.026344431564211845, -0.029050834476947784, -0.03344788774847984, -0.006408545654267073, -0.014662453904747963, 0.023656509816646576, 0.05602380260825157, -0.003219026606529951, -0.05704469606280327, -0.035246048122644424, 0.06397370994091034, 0.01916668377816677, -0.006835164036601782, 0.03964804857969284, 0.004265924915671349, 0.0028488736134022474, -0.004425979685038328, -0.016687532886862755, 0.035745490342378616, 0.02244574949145317, -0.028508631512522697, -0.017193568870425224, 0.014140171930193901, -0.033474523574113846, -0.0019423073390498757, -0.011482767760753632, -0.010316526517271996, -0.025134187191724777, 0.016991687938570976, 0.033102698624134064, 0.003826298750936985, 0.01511475071310997, 0.0028253733180463314, -0.016319166868925095, 0.058921486139297485, 0.02488933503627777, -0.020405350252985954, -0.025795890018343925, 0.02591937966644764, -0.04888126254081726, -0.06401316821575165, -0.053004682064056396, 0.04611959308385849, -0.020055511966347694, 0.05303626134991646, -0.024945031851530075, -0.007015514187514782, -0.006150499917566776, -0.004155687056481838, 0.0262583140283823, -0.053920067846775055, 0.021585967391729355, -0.03798503056168556, -0.017446989193558693, -0.041785385459661484, -0.02280140481889248, -0.0198200773447752, -0.052640076726675034, 0.014753150753676891, -0.03524027392268181, -0.03572992980480194, -0.014433752745389938, -0.0265020951628685, -0.0013173023471608758, -0.019047603011131287, -0.026095492765307426, -0.0346188098192215, -0.004717117175459862, -0.01500636525452137, -0.00003843174999929033, 0.006232405547052622, 0.04243612661957741, -0.01213867124170065, 0.012642066925764084, 0.06250675767660141, 0.00599074037745595, 0.036798566579818726, 0.014659020118415356, 0.015845809131860733, 0.023781711235642433, 0.055470120161771774, 0.023771198466420174, -0.029005689546465874, 0.06921952962875366, -0.03625814989209175, -0.06676546484231949, 0.009835353121161461, 0.0029410398565232754, 0.04721057415008545, 0.0032714945264160633, -0.03428082913160324, -0.04334490746259689, 0.08700115233659744, -0.0041931746527552605, -0.010724283754825592, -0.022322053089737892, -0.019073354080319405, 0.03488771617412567, -0.005996854044497013, -0.033328745514154434, 0.01872076652944088, -0.03644028306007385, 0.062416497617959976, 0.027273327112197876, -0.030214350670576096, -0.03416874632239342, -0.02401876449584961, -0.013571394607424736, 0.02071143127977848, -0.00831236969679594, -0.030955825001001358, 0.03901682421565056, 0.06022992730140686, -0.024417374283075333, 0.046031203120946884, -0.060053590685129166, -0.010091166943311691, -0.0746992975473404, 0.007408048026263714, -0.003286034567281604, 0.04596786946058273, 0.019357575103640556, -0.047013744711875916, -0.005055262707173824, 0.03934510797262192, -0.05468980222940445, 0.009952181950211525, 0.02240193635225296, 0.006366504356265068, -0.045468565076589584, -0.014574955217540264, -0.023656275123357773, 0.021964887157082558, 0.013418072834610939, 0.023632057011127472, 0.04008596017956734, 0.01986294984817505, -0.013126667588949203, -0.005102789960801601, -0.02063607983291149, 0.02145741507411003, 0.001471373368985951, -0.06356722116470337, 0.02699935808777809, 0.0020010778680443764, -0.04566817730665207, 0.0181705504655838, -0.036876652389764786, 0.02066635712981224, 0.021763132885098457, 0.034974321722984314, 0.033431295305490494, 0.04586184769868851, -0.013280839659273624, 0.03129689767956734, -0.0219876728951931, -0.000330729759298265, 0.01366809569299221, -0.01666521653532982, -0.01973596401512623, 0.008641290478408337, 0.030276287347078323, 0.010030821897089481, -0.009832417592406273, 0.01609485037624836, -0.015521524474024773, -0.027293531224131584, 0.007193513680249453, 0.0008468470186926425, 0.020030997693538666, 0.0026903704274445772, -0.0009739985689520836, -0.026462335139513016, -0.01080424152314663, 0.03198897838592529, 0.033338405191898346, -0.012069678865373135, 0.022154442965984344, -0.0011632511159405112, -0.027415325865149498, 0.018946059048175812, -0.008354234509170055, 0.023340044543147087, -0.028779873624444008, -0.005916018038988113, 0.003587460145354271, -0.04032008349895477, -0.01504913903772831, 0.0034183491952717304, -0.06615450978279114, -0.01644226722419262, 0.002466538455337286, 0.029705023393034935, 0.0014549994375556707, 0.046297699213027954, 0.018980003893375397, -0.12642385065555573, 0.06770551949739456, 0.039438530802726746, -0.006745585240423679, -0.06764594465494156, 0.019325820729136467, -0.019501330330967903, 0.0571911484003067, 0.06341910362243652, 0.026455959305167198, -0.0005013986956328154, -0.016222290694713593, 0.04616445302963257, 0.009638101793825626, -0.039624616503715515, 0.05541914701461792, 0.022440152242779732, 0.006324314046651125, 0.007936365902423859, -0.002289394848048687, 0.009479339234530926, 0.03777221962809563, 0.004550524055957794, -0.046254321932792664, -0.0033350035082548857, 0.004676140379160643, -0.00528740556910634, 0.046444859355688095, -0.0004078128549735993, -0.03562086820602417, 0.04400316998362541, -0.0230003260076046, -0.014461686834692955, 0.02322261780500412, 0.017697736620903015, -0.027505971491336823, 0.06077193841338158, 0.00045545329339802265, 0.007550036069005728, 0.044157955795526505, -0.02439698949456215, 0.01627635397017002, -0.04512352868914604, 0.02111429162323475, 0.014811993576586246, -0.03709472343325615, -0.007309694308787584, 0.051842473447322845, 0.04907555878162384, 0.012661581858992577, 0.0029016637708991766, 0.046073004603385925, -0.018124090507626534, -0.019629523158073425, -0.005019553937017918, 0.02305562049150467, 0.0018555031856521964, 0.013273472897708416, -0.0006946854409761727, 0.06009330600500107, -0.028568757697939873, 0.0070593757554888725, -0.018396416679024696, 0.038199592381715775, -0.004734593443572521, -0.011699399910867214, 0.002620020182803273, -0.034366071224212646, 0.029775619506835938, 0.012810957618057728, -0.01468318048864603, 0.07460304349660873, -0.04846648499369621, 0.0015472897794097662, 0.020418215543031693, 0.0162662323564291, -0.042184989899396896, -0.0016761455917730927, 0.017484063282608986, -0.0018637499306350946, 0.011706115677952766, 0.010648639872670174, 0.030659491196274757, -0.04021503031253815, 0.027779506519436836, -0.010329840704798698, 0.05379744991660118, -0.01701791025698185, -0.03827732801437378, -0.0017459779046475887, 0.025874417275190353, -0.03355145826935768, -0.014138956554234028, 0.04332011938095093, 0.006532636471092701, 0.010446819476783276, -0.008973997086286545, -0.010201074182987213, 0.013514655642211437, 0.040354691445827484, -0.0525459386408329, -0.04329504817724228, -0.03421175107359886, 0.007618401665240526, -0.00023268522636499256, -0.025405278429389 ]
<p>I am using random forests for a class.</p> <p>I am predicting weight training.</p> <p>In scikit learn I always used a rule of thumb of a depth of 5, the depth x features rounded.</p> <p>I had 53 features, rounded to 50 x 5 and got 250 for number of trees.</p> <p>I picked 250 trees and 5 node depth and got great results.</p> <p>I got 98% accuracy for my test set (100% for training). </p> <p>The data set is for coursera machine learning. The data set is at d396qusza40orc.cloudfront.net/predmachlearn/pml-training.csv I removed seven features that were unrelated. The predictor is classe. </p> <p>Well, it works again, but I have no formal basis. I would appreciate any guidance,</p>
27,350
[ -0.010557192377746105, -0.01364709623157978, -0.002048800466582179, -0.014816264621913433, 0.0475681871175766, 0.033420391380786896, -0.002447918988764286, -0.04757227376103401, 0.015256835147738457, -0.018702657893300056, 0.05171177536249161, 0.028138035908341408, 0.03848559036850929, 0.019578728824853897, -0.015033069998025894, 0.021801738068461418, 0.0018824257422238588, -0.011702843010425568, 0.025446193292737007, -0.029950939118862152, -0.006226084195077419, 0.043188031762838364, 0.03519052639603615, -0.002064084867015481, -0.041698895394802094, 0.03510061651468277, 0.00966184027493, -0.018640363588929176, -0.02965915948152542, 0.027285350486636162, -0.04172222316265106, -0.039654895663261414, 0.005899291485548019, 0.01137247122824192, 0.04310396686196327, -0.0090544568374753, -0.012309842742979527, -0.05092954263091087, -0.013385608792304993, -0.01293257437646389, 0.03320695832371712, 0.009245669469237328, 0.0007361633470281959, 0.025466004386544228, -0.013243298046290874, 0.02956346608698368, -0.010126275941729546, -0.02007548324763775, 0.046836692839860916, -0.020672064274549484, 0.06275194138288498, -0.022341931238770485, 0.053619980812072754, 0.05093009024858475, -0.0027860060799866915, -0.043350476771593094, 0.029771771281957626, 0.07414637506008148, -0.01829436793923378, -0.03936711698770523, -0.029784997925162315, -0.040046095848083496, 0.02245279587805271, 0.03169338032603264, -0.021380983293056488, 0.024153050035238266, 0.0034247736912220716, 0.011524340137839317, 0.03914027661085129, 0.016267387196421623, 0.04050378128886223, -0.002538579050451517, 0.04171501100063324, 0.02902916818857193, 0.019585585221648216, -0.0008843658724799752, 0.028238588944077492, 0.037434082478284836, 0.025126412510871887, 0.021686719730496407, -0.03114170767366886, 0.01949843019247055, -0.007280565798282623, 0.003747654380276799, 0.04231281578540802, -0.012221834622323513, 0.054803553968667984, 0.012178802862763405, -0.014258045703172684, 0.0396297313272953, 0.005724200513213873, 0.005758587270975113, 0.04790785536170006, -0.03551415726542473, -0.00031987729016691446, 0.037696074694395065, -0.02998838946223259, -0.018055323511362076, -0.02316143363714218, 0.0219406858086586, -0.0010508387349545956, -0.014585677534341812, 0.012529928237199783, 0.06572558730840683, -0.041668422520160675, -0.0032031566370278597, -0.06898865848779678, -0.01732836849987507, 0.0002758159826043993, -0.015904651954770088, -0.020845096558332443, 0.0038238903507590294, -0.016944820061326027, -0.029761366546154022, -0.018400369212031364, -0.010350137017667294, -0.039237964898347855, 0.02840668149292469, 0.04023529589176178, 0.03260742872953415, 0.041105493903160095, -0.05502379313111305, 0.04854695871472359, -0.06011594086885452, -0.028031807392835617, -0.008348461240530014, 0.026036495342850685, -0.02525053732097149, -0.008567039854824543, 0.01828162372112274, -0.004262637346982956, 0.000029917078791186213, 0.038289837539196014, -0.004091705195605755, 0.0372999869287014, 0.006598091218620539, -0.09293274581432343, -0.06542422622442245, 0.050718434154987335, -0.012078176252543926, 0.006682483479380608, -0.05688027665019035, -0.013703396543860435, 0.027072781696915627, 0.07658763974905014, 0.017811495810747147, 0.05587076023221016, 0.011997479014098644, -0.008451529778540134, -0.014445383101701736, -0.014043153263628483, -0.006946701090782881, -0.06203426420688629, 0.031906574964523315, -0.02298712357878685, -0.07976925373077393, 0.04237343370914459, 0.010270876809954643, -0.02367071621119976, -0.007952670566737652, 0.012905227951705456, -0.03195711597800255, -0.00023960258113220334, 0.01284968014806509, -0.0077644758857786655, -0.012796412222087383, 0.07670533657073975, 0.025931939482688904, 0.04624427482485771, 0.009340430609881878, 0.010283210314810276, 0.0030213110148906708, 0.04752970486879349, 0.023154959082603455, 0.04186069220304489, 0.026516934856772423, 0.011072482913732529, -0.015347997657954693, 0.04514914005994797, -0.01009018812328577, -0.03614237532019615, -0.03699631616473198, -0.022594507783651352, 0.022384021431207657, 0.00293006026186049, 0.03617091476917267, -0.013087505474686623, -0.02716114930808544, 0.03964109718799591, -0.033841025084257126, -0.012799345888197422, -0.03481605648994446, 0.03825870901346207, -0.03371971473097801, 0.0017066036816686392, -0.017577845603227615, -0.015292307361960411, 0.05004223808646202, -0.01197720505297184, 0.004024230409413576, -0.03225110098719597, -0.00928427092730999, 0.03263522684574127, -0.020078180357813835, -0.018686575815081596, 0.03479210287332535, -0.018931293860077858, 0.010166787542402744, 0.02279767021536827, -0.03431634604930878, -0.06615950912237167, 0.018705107271671295, -0.013961739838123322, -0.0037850586231797934, -0.02849467098712921, 0.00611522700637579, 0.015057430602610111, 0.007852371782064438, 0.01089861337095499, 0.039189185947179794, -0.030941985547542572, 0.048587143421173096, 0.05904299020767212, 0.03151505067944527, 0.03277036175131798, -0.02382027544081211, -0.03160937502980232, 0.021118490025401115, -0.00901506096124649, -0.019882798194885254, -0.03638659417629242, -0.045514918863773346, 0.017646195366978645, -0.01055771391838789, -0.03380025923252106, 0.025483250617980957, 0.07205984741449356, 0.02350357174873352, 0.035115815699100494, 0.04877335950732231, -0.010927896946668625, -0.017988745123147964, 0.06513667106628418, 0.03241680562496185, 0.017559124156832695, -0.01820998080074787, -0.016591601073741913, 0.0035812854766845703, 0.024436403065919876, -0.0038974755443632603, -0.030874017626047134, 0.00904406514018774, 0.022366974502801895, 0.002444862388074398, -0.0049322545528411865, -0.053395628929138184, 0.0006104805506765842, 0.008563741110265255, -0.0036363769322633743, 0.06611090153455734, 0.009877677075564861, -0.009401097893714905, -0.045367684215307236, -0.03383433446288109, 0.026779213920235634, 0.07226530462503433, -0.03425121679902077, -0.008872154168784618, 0.025070149451494217, -0.0384027324616909, -0.00017981280689127743, 0.007614129222929478, -0.038354773074388504, -0.03387819603085518, 0.05653411149978638, 0.05330660939216614, -0.014398370869457722, 0.029156096279621124, -0.01960386335849762, -0.0005842382088303566, -0.005196709651499987, 0.01234207022935152, 0.026271801441907883, -0.0001709446223685518, -0.047127727419137955, -0.019756339490413666, 0.032335858792066574, 0.002338140271604061, 0.04730495437979698, -0.0016992914024740458, -0.03906985744833946, 0.005763326305896044, -0.030393000692129135, -0.01437720749527216, -0.054921794682741165, -0.020475000143051147, 0.025904128327965736, 0.04160785302519798, -0.028089024126529694, 0.034018624573946, 0.004190240520983934, -0.06461471319198608, 0.031111083924770355, 0.010283839888870716, -0.015409617684781551, -0.021434307098388672, 0.020988717675209045, -0.008387505076825619, 0.01025591790676117, -0.015213387086987495, 0.044262148439884186, 0.0044638230465352535, 0.01985885575413704, -0.06983617693185806, -0.07564090937376022, 0.01364772580564022, 0.00009749222226673737, 0.009137386456131935, 0.02568364329636097, 0.019610630348324776, 0.07891829311847687, 0.014620576985180378, -0.029570283368229866, -0.02650746889412403, -0.03801676258444786, -0.011929144151508808, -0.03080657124519348, 0.007571778725832701, -0.0009032046655192971, -0.011374727822840214, 0.022912021726369858, 0.0092084351927042, 0.01633244752883911, 0.06786593049764633, -0.018805045634508133, -0.03287403658032417, 0.04790560528635979, 0.024326365441083908, -0.02254125289618969, 0.06673377007246017, 0.04002238065004349, -0.02772555686533451, 0.014215987175703049, -0.03395387902855873, 0.006753303576260805, 0.007573330774903297, -0.05592610687017441, -0.0024529630318284035, -0.036051761358976364, 0.034898120909929276, -0.022758085280656815, 0.0315566323697567, 0.005264879669994116, -0.0678885281085968, -0.00952123198658228, -0.005353967659175396, 0.05842876434326172, -0.02135379984974861, -0.00670420378446579, 0.021749000996351242, 0.03765306994318962, 0.02883935160934925, 0.002751575782895088, -0.013865717686712742, 0.015605154447257519, 0.008561191149055958, 0.0033779884688556194, 0.029097197577357292, 0.02152552269399166, 0.031240900978446007, 0.0444219745695591, -0.007405225653201342, -0.05864933505654335, -0.00023615604732185602, -0.055375631898641586, 0.010071102529764175, -0.026567058637738228, 0.04923919215798378, 0.008102305233478546, 0.022017821669578552, 0.01878022775053978, -0.01730288378894329, 0.04380330443382263, 0.05631100386381149, -0.0418136827647686, -0.009446291252970695, 0.03565431013703346, -0.010687800124287605, 0.023818794637918472, -0.028850490227341652, -0.02339673973619938, -0.033478669822216034, -0.00045357836643233895, 0.002682152669876814, 0.0020685382187366486, -0.040218401700258255, -0.012960528954863548, -0.015994880348443985, -0.01254316046833992, -0.011981500312685966, -0.0012567343655973673, 0.03376811742782593, -0.003629205049946904, 0.058233004063367844, 0.011778485961258411, 0.013191379606723785, -0.027648355811834335, -0.035175107419490814, -0.01409876812249422, -0.003873851615935564, 0.030296441167593002, 0.07349463552236557, 0.00007573262701043859, -0.0840456560254097, 0.028578568249940872, 0.011979973874986172, 0.05280308425426483, 0.016992898657917976, -0.0197040643543005, 0.0038206172175705433, -0.007982186041772366, -0.02653084695339203, 0.03999550640583038, -0.010131336748600006, 0.01157069206237793, 0.01755680702626705, 0.05659439414739609, -0.0066406563855707645, -0.07975023984909058, 0.0054822941310703754, 0.05809526517987251, -0.011228454299271107, -0.03406088799238205, -0.013716776855289936, -0.00159756513312459, 0.023287098854780197, -0.02298341505229473, 0.07020994275808334, -0.011910025961697102, 0.018682312220335007, -0.017780745401978493, 0.038327597081661224, -0.00313648977316916, -0.05940813198685646, 0.05454230308532715, -0.004277489613741636, 0.06069576367735863, -0.026425177231431007, -0.005750090815126896, 0.017069047316908836, -0.006049939896911383, 0.018114302307367325, 0.020721260458230972, -0.004843968898057938, -0.08473510295152664, -0.007516954094171524, 0.024764711037278175, 0.04215455800294876, -0.025757651776075363, -0.007193369325250387, 0.00012843412696383893, -0.04335206747055054, 0.00233607180416584, -0.04694667086005211, 0.04716610163450241, -0.0021270988509058952, 0.023947957903146744, 0.0015736303757876158, -0.0375855527818203, -0.04746101424098015, 0.017909198999404907, -0.03802615404129028, 0.06384389102458954, 0.009809743613004684, -0.0541670024394989, -0.024942729622125626, 0.019746731966733932, -0.007855494506657124, 0.029986027628183365, -0.012657904997467995, -0.03190353885293007, -0.03674010559916496, -0.004130950663238764, 0.006647429894655943, -0.08235619962215424, -0.024518214166164398, -0.012435730546712875, 0.016673307865858078, 0.021539773792028427, -0.03474624082446098, -0.07766736298799515, 0.02263672649860382, 0.029581179842352867, -0.03352779895067215, -0.03973938524723053, -0.043121982365846634, 0.01876911148428917, 0.012353798374533653, -0.007991466671228409, 0.05125965550541878, 0.038129981607198715, -0.011817951686680317, -0.008951102383434772, -0.025383707135915756, 0.05606403201818466, -0.02484031952917576, 0.0017485079588368535, -0.04537290334701538, -0.017308896407485008, -0.0446113757789135, -0.009443964809179306, 0.01933659426867962, 0.03325073793530464, -0.046366725116968155, -0.025324666872620583, -0.02198038622736931, 0.03211264684796333, -0.008596814237535, 0.014678734354674816, -0.0038683305028826, 0.011250937357544899, -0.01619584672152996, 0.044208407402038574, 0.008303426206111908, 0.01393658947199583, 0.02568775787949562, -0.0035114586353302, -0.0024856990203261375, -0.027480611577630043, -0.037661999464035034, -0.022207127884030342, -0.002193697029724717, -0.026603074744343758, 0.047989826649427414, 0.004075881093740463, 0.01847410760819912, 0.012130141258239746, -0.012017861939966679, -0.013486339710652828, 0.015309076756238937, -0.0005426552961580455, 0.00533071905374527, -0.03482985496520996, -0.0012586023658514023, -0.042992524802684784, 0.026265786960721016, -0.03318055346608162, -0.0075110746547579765, -0.010525296442210674, 0.025225235149264336, -0.021813485771417618, -0.026743458583950996, 0.013467821292579174, -0.010767250321805477, -0.02128153294324875, -0.031224548816680908, 0.07307103276252747, -0.03851285204291344, 0.004997307434678078, 0.017819125205278397, -0.01995995081961155, 0.05630882456898689, 0.031686391681432724, 0.009040731936693192, 0.042968787252902985, 0.02750677987933159, 0.0023783459328114986, -0.0017517799278721213, 0.010238390415906906, -0.02558309957385063, 0.013959762640297413, -0.02239420637488365, 0.03622590750455856, 0.026852736249566078, 0.01937338337302208, 0.01660393364727497, -0.015875015407800674, 0.023571820929646492, 0.010406837798655033, -0.04766199737787247, -0.0054624066688120365, -0.01525532640516758, -0.007870988920331001, 0.006978436838835478, 0.028391841799020767, 0.013775836676359177, -0.016992704942822456, 0.008459877222776413, -0.006925256922841072, -0.0011096085654571652, 0.009657510556280613, 0.09179528802633286, -0.01553766056895256, 0.042099226266145706, -0.006174806971102953, -0.053681571036577225, 0.027456102892756462, 0.01572791486978531, 0.007515146397054195, 0.020408032462000847, 0.04193992167711258, -0.03614051267504692, 0.016777101904153824, -0.05144196376204491, 0.009514093399047852, 0.06963932514190674, -0.011136176064610481, 0.03721320629119873, 0.006450135726481676, -0.010253151878714561, 0.016024501994252205, -0.008515411987900734, -0.007831636816263199, 0.0072109634056687355, 0.015432581305503845, 0.038064293563365936, -0.008357861079275608, 0.04033282399177551, 0.05729616433382034, -0.01019212231040001, 0.024437295272946358, 0.022018497809767723, 0.018756015226244926, 0.0075636962428689, 0.02278132550418377, -0.019212961196899414, -0.017289098352193832, -0.013442536816000938, -0.017659591510891914, 0.0030099754221737385, -0.016168909147381783, -0.02541215904057026, 0.03646736219525337, 0.06681746244430542, -0.0006408970220945776, -0.0255631972104311, -0.0291608776897192, -0.029136307537555695, -0.011657193303108215, 0.024922532960772514, -0.02648860216140747, 0.00034803355811163783, 0.02539961412549019, -0.010214153677225113, 0.0030944033060222864, 0.01442852895706892, -0.03935430571436882, -0.06463944166898727, -0.03608780726790428, -0.016612064093351364, -0.059774722903966904, 0.010867884382605553, -0.005124491173774004, -0.024276411160826683, 0.008051542565226555, -0.007411785889416933, 0.0450509749352932, 0.007950300350785255, 0.0132853789255023, 0.005887066479772329, 0.02505166456103325, 0.03406071290373802, 0.010374032892286777, 0.026524260640144348, 0.00473226560279727, 0.12506429851055145, 0.08348409086465836, 0.05908455699682236, -0.014305487275123596, -0.01645943894982338, 0.02379102259874344, -0.02069038897752762, -0.013067653402686119, 0.009849215857684612, -0.0039889197796583176, -0.024334874004125595, -0.003108642529696226, -0.025478264316916466, 0.02491523139178753, -0.05081397294998169, 0.05616924166679382, -0.01735658012330532, 0.00030636179144494236, -0.0038479166105389595, 0.0025145607069134712, 0.03327571228146553, -0.013041890226304531, -0.060343120247125626, 0.010935642756521702, 0.0036328465212136507, -0.006020636763423681, -0.027396881952881813, -0.005597137380391359, 0.035384759306907654, 0.009052999317646027, -0.0003333255590405315, -0.015486039221286774, -0.0034537953324615955, 0.004589875694364309, 0.019486621022224426, 0.03840572014451027, 0.013368004001677036, -0.012740902602672577, -0.002059127204120159, 0.05919680371880531, 0.03072153404355049, -0.01831098459661007, 0.02430698461830616, 0.013143179938197136, -0.06791798770427704, -0.05124508589506149, -0.049645330756902695, 0.07068628072738647, -0.02565752901136875, -0.0034041821490973234, 0.016708770766854286, -0.006423299200832844, 0.021429050713777542, -0.07244507968425751, -0.002381331752985716, 0.02092783711850643, 0.056434787809848785, -0.01088939793407917, -0.02419707551598549, -0.003653964726254344, 0.033066801726818085, -0.02046489715576172, -0.008379165083169937, 0.00829308945685625, 0.0019178169313818216, -0.012671316042542458, -0.023837793618440628, 0.025259504094719887, 0.008322879672050476, 0.013840176165103912, -0.016835279762744904, 0.0101995337754488, -0.0035630862694233656, -0.016810981556773186, 0.034537628293037415, 0.005391706712543964, -0.018560852855443954, -0.02108468860387802, -0.060423605144023895, -0.03041393682360649, -0.04117603227496147, 0.0030373467598110437, -0.03602270409464836, -0.010787446983158588, -0.05704626068472862, 0.012935986742377281, -0.022125471383333206, 0.04984536021947861, 0.05446135252714157, 0.029622534289956093, -0.0014548870967701077, 0.04169599339365959, 0.0157268475741148, -0.0473870187997818, -0.016094869002699852, -0.008255473338067532, -0.05532363802194595, 0.013177392072975636, 0.026316143572330475, 0.04039626568555832, 0.01795298047363758, 0.03547209873795509, 0.010996024124324322, 0.009744453243911266, 0.002253053244203329, 0.021805519238114357, -0.012137540616095066, -0.04996908828616142, 0.009464037604629993, -0.010523325763642788, -0.016336245462298393, -0.05747136101126671, 0.0020514526404440403, -0.016762807965278625, -0.05643529072403908, 0.0027163918130099773, 0.03035535290837288, -0.052692536264657974, -0.005569105967879295, -0.013033756986260414, 0.010952629148960114, -0.021894950419664383, -0.019974099472165108, -0.06845029443502426, -0.040294043719768524, 0.020900800824165344, -0.057181935757398605, -0.028299717232584953, 0.006464581470936537, -0.01961558498442173, 0.00016144762048497796, 0.04340393841266632, -0.006814025342464447, 0.004125644452869892, -0.021927639842033386, 0.0218217670917511, -0.016614899039268494, 0.002778058871626854, -0.004590604454278946, 0.004223979543894529, 0.023371873423457146, -0.059915874153375626, -0.03447869047522545, 0.019581476226449013, -0.014766125939786434, 0.0570407435297966, 0.001663912902586162, -0.0054139550775289536, -0.01066731009632349, 0.08270251750946045, 0.007013335824012756, -0.02680107392370701, -0.014236200600862503, 0.036656703799963, 0.021013887599110603, 0.03395633026957512, -0.011325696483254433, -0.00981755182147026, -0.015611824579536915, 0.021775970235466957, 0.030215134844183922, 0.04186170548200607, -0.03666222468018532, 0.03262709453701973, -0.04731573909521103, -0.021004704758524895, -0.0026724401395767927, -0.0033943348098546267, 0.024224601686000824, 0.00006269595178309828, -0.0038166064769029617, 0.02943647839128971, -0.017306974157691002, 0.023386791348457336, -0.07208982855081558, -0.04763377457857132, 0.029771113768219948, 0.021214913576841354, 0.03651517629623413, -0.04173443466424942, 0.023863179609179497, 0.01841685175895691, -0.0722903236746788, 0.024505870416760445, -0.0017705518985167146, 0.0012018035631626844, -0.026220520958304405, 0.020073018968105316, -0.03423608839511871, -0.0004308587813284248, 0.01921149343252182, 0.03558085113763809, 0.04104664921760559, 0.011231849901378155, -0.019579080864787102, -0.03858910873532295, 0.002830921672284603, 0.044637396931648254, -0.01895134150981903, -0.060451894998550415, -0.010355045087635517, 0.013460230082273483, -0.04081568866968155, 0.02019144967198372, -0.06590696424245834, 0.02176136150956154, 0.0663452222943306, 0.037825629115104675, 0.03459809720516205, 0.02887164056301117, 0.027820846065878868, -0.019924825057387352, 0.019025564193725586, -0.029571840539574623, -0.036954089999198914, 0.024263693019747734, -0.025126300752162933, 0.036453135311603546, 0.002667822176590562, -0.02852371148765087, -0.0594039149582386, 0.038880523294210434, -0.019556481391191483, -0.0010605327552184463, -0.0200501661747694, -0.02378920465707779, -0.04404078796505928, -0.03719344362616539, -0.005637305788695812, -0.05359574407339096, 0.033430315554142, 0.031586531549692154, 0.002935529686510563, -0.008950302377343178, 0.01192841213196516, -0.007324998266994953, -0.027173062786459923, -0.040576960891485214, 0.02348661981523037, -0.028148183599114418, -0.04716391861438751, 0.014581802301108837, -0.0017995728412643075, -0.03740646690130234, -0.032577965408563614, -0.04197258874773979, 0.0010559045476838946, 0.017300110310316086, 0.0014555805828422308, 0.0045506577007472515, 0.047830186784267426, 0.010276778601109982, 0.013462299481034279, -0.09031835198402405, 0.04711960628628731, 0.004410293884575367, -0.03940391540527344, -0.0542374923825264, 0.012599297799170017, -0.00757324043661356, -0.0029024581890553236, 0.02432001382112503, -0.011630840599536896, 0.052567947655916214, -0.04838227853178978, 0.043616700917482376, -0.0009640360367484391, -0.039747204631567, 0.029038947075605392, -0.004896491765975952, -0.018600909039378166, -0.030686359852552414, -0.052601587027311325, 0.004308976233005524, 0.023541171103715897, 0.04090619832277298, -0.008351068012416363, 0.004967141896486282, 0.02298298478126526, 0.030432187020778656, 0.0336664542555809, -0.013800166547298431, 0.039844948798418045, 0.03678391873836517, 0.009653967805206776, -0.021376213058829308, 0.026859136298298836, -0.023739557713270187, -0.03979165852069855, 0.02086971141397953, -0.01332870777696371, -0.0070955525152385235, -0.031250402331352234, 0.017310384660959244, 0.04265910014510155, -0.07329457998275757, -0.02377171814441681, 0.022775020450353622, -0.0599953755736351, 0.00902703870087862, 0.05202300474047661, -0.009677890688180923, 0.011208372190594673, 0.008018465712666512, 0.03367466479539871, -0.013388453982770443, -0.07057145982980728, 0.0062189484015107155, -0.010230422019958496, 0.029443351551890373, -0.012561638839542866, 0.010704564861953259, 0.040705449879169464, -0.019747409969568253, 0.020783957093954086, -0.014263439923524857, 0.04349798336625099, -0.022890273481607437, 0.023378344252705574, -0.017264414578676224, -0.01881815493106842, 0.037448592483997345, 0.0018410111078992486, -0.014794168062508106, 0.05383443459868431, -0.022897200658917427, -0.021039411425590515, -0.04185428097844124, -0.051883820444345474, 0.0051668258383870125, 0.008915221318602562, 0.03027462400496006, 0.010714844800531864, 0.025634709745645523, 0.006975715979933739, 0.009334921836853027, -0.04506034776568413, 0.034570273011922836, -0.019300395622849464, 0.005962838884443045, -0.0002567294577602297, -0.004261604975908995, 0.007285112980753183, 0.011148268356919289, -0.0201962161809206, -0.022227706387639046, 0.027796272188425064, 0.05904671922326088, 0.029722487553954124, -0.02042737603187561, -0.00294345710426569, 0.006744901183992624, 0.02688652090728283, -0.042388662695884705, 0.010809971019625664, -0.04485813528299332, 0.02651614136993885, 0.033609289675951004, -0.033653754740953445 ]
<p>I want to make a 4 question, multiple choice survey in which each question asks about an analogous range of actions for slightly different scenarios. Each participant would only be administered the survey once. For example: </p> <p>"In situation W how would you behave? (5[very aggressively] -- 1 [not aggressively])." "In situation X how would you behave? (5[very aggressively] -- 1 [not aggressively])." "In situation Y how would you behave? (5[very aggressively] -- 1 [not aggressively])." "In situation Z how would you behave? (5[very aggressively] -- 1 [not aggressively])."</p> <p>I then wanted to sum the responses to the 4 questions, and use that total score as my DV.</p> <p>I plan to have 2 IVs. </p> <p>The first will be relationship status, and consist of 7 levels (e.g. Married, single, divorced, dating, widowed, etc).</p> <p>The second will be, say, partner hair-color preference, and will consist of 3 levels (e.g. blond, brunet, redhead).</p> <p>So, my understanding is that this will be a 3x7 factorial design, with a total number of 21 individual conditions, and an ordinal DV. </p> <p>Ideally, I'd like to do a 3x7 factorial ANOVA to test for main effects and interaction effects, but I don't think my summed, ordinal survey response DV is amenable to this. Is there some other analysis i could use in this situation? Would the Kruskal-Wallis be appropriate? Thanks!</p>
73,412
[ -0.052750442177057266, -0.00413651904091239, 0.018192265182733536, 0.039991553872823715, 0.02592862956225872, 0.011045992374420166, 0.008933980017900467, -0.01832261122763157, 0.0637100338935852, -0.017929477617144585, 0.006339868064969778, 0.02403583750128746, 0.03855388984084129, -0.011854900978505611, 0.03540116921067238, 0.0064611900597810745, 0.01611969619989395, -0.027592439204454422, -0.018378864973783493, 0.007293030619621277, -0.029186639934778214, 0.02338721603155136, -0.0001335198467131704, -0.012963071465492249, 0.0111849969252944, 0.052643656730651855, 0.017207270488142967, -0.06891868263483047, 0.027500692754983902, 0.03912513330578804, -0.0020635707769542933, -0.0328386090695858, -0.014184417203068733, 0.0360134094953537, 0.009294322691857815, 0.027338340878486633, -0.021275892853736877, 0.015465989708900452, 0.009458462707698345, 0.027639398351311684, -0.029234828427433968, -0.010532422922551632, -0.008997568860650063, 0.028017429634928703, -0.03215460479259491, 0.013349772430956364, -0.029109010472893715, -0.02276032231748104, 0.020434830337762833, -0.06987343728542328, 0.06457836925983429, 0.015539882704615593, 0.028005298227071762, 0.05275111645460129, -0.004930535331368446, -0.057375770062208176, 0.05625959485769272, 0.04121798649430275, 0.014972356148064137, -0.02913716435432434, -0.02932329848408699, -0.0307758878916502, 0.004457934759557247, -0.0004998179501853883, -0.03957956284284592, 0.04378094524145126, -0.01582833006978035, -0.03453971445560455, 0.03395022079348564, -0.03106200508773327, 0.008070834912359715, 0.02954656258225441, 0.04233887046575546, 0.009509268216788769, -0.026023980230093002, -0.00805994775146246, 0.00508986646309495, 0.01033849734812975, 0.01894162967801094, 0.04099798575043678, -0.04502815380692482, 0.008728227578103542, -0.011707817204296589, 0.042459454387426376, 0.00031292863423004746, -0.029081344604492188, 0.04325336217880249, -0.04231695085763931, -0.04150274023413658, 0.023210344836115837, -0.019822001457214355, 0.007085493765771389, 0.005602749064564705, 0.041674382984638214, -0.058041490614414215, 0.036885302513837814, -0.022990262135863304, 0.029926348477602005, -0.002900013467296958, 0.05432252585887909, -0.0057875243946909904, 0.01627126894891262, -0.02212398312985897, 0.029918499290943146, -0.02898334711790085, -0.003052315441891551, -0.003903473960235715, 0.0033674121368676424, 0.025397593155503273, -0.03450250253081322, -0.005392396356910467, 0.0013003501808270812, -0.01420719362795353, -0.01490772981196642, -0.0037792969960719347, -0.012070450000464916, -0.05129943788051605, -0.012653701938688755, 0.0950530543923378, 0.07029284536838531, 0.06317281723022461, -0.013052282854914665, 0.012662587687373161, -0.04459373652935028, -0.08528681099414825, -0.006956510711461306, 0.013011407107114792, 0.0006341316038742661, -0.006033227778971195, 0.04578399658203125, 0.012436692602932453, -0.003426044248044491, 0.0526028536260128, 0.0069802128709852695, 0.018758652731776237, 0.002415810711681843, -0.06901707500219345, -0.06900995224714279, 0.022067278623580933, -0.028386438265442848, -0.016528598964214325, -0.06139889732003212, -0.020697781816124916, 0.0347306951880455, 0.03643275424838066, 0.008478187024593353, 0.03888729214668274, 0.021794592961668968, -0.007675790693610907, 0.058969371020793915, -0.04103277623653412, -0.018595896661281586, -0.03759316727519035, -0.04991023615002632, -0.008871086873114109, -0.089848592877388, 0.04031824320554733, -0.0008995757671073079, 0.006652064621448517, 0.022131837904453278, 0.05810181796550751, 0.021294601261615753, -0.03449585288763046, 0.02526090294122696, 0.029876381158828735, 0.027150502428412437, 0.05305063724517822, -0.0415441133081913, 0.024513646960258484, 0.010470570996403694, 0.018978673964738846, 0.016339898109436035, -0.018611744046211243, 0.03347233682870865, 0.057929351925849915, 0.006425340194255114, 0.015565671026706696, 0.0008668929222039878, -0.001669595716521144, -0.007063602562993765, -0.01658078469336033, -0.02756643109023571, -0.016106698662042618, -0.05061103776097298, 0.048129789531230927, 0.02747979760169983, -0.011692208237946033, -0.018496135249733925, 0.02130170166492462, -0.020045660436153412, -0.05921601504087448, -0.061830174177885056, 0.016893545165657997, -0.004305422771722078, -0.04631407558917999, 0.031803566962480545, 0.005652911029756069, 0.048197224736213684, 0.007787954527884722, -0.026689840480685234, -0.01759372092783451, 0.0018219713820144534, 0.06489403545856476, -0.025359397754073143, 0.018873851746320724, 0.011430000886321068, 0.04199901595711708, -0.07288927584886551, 0.0049140132032334805, -0.03254479914903641, -0.010125509463250637, -0.01915273815393448, -0.035335153341293335, 0.029071567580103874, 0.024002831429243088, 0.0229132492095232, 0.003376761684194207, 0.029073618352413177, -0.007579665165394545, 0.048894573003053665, -0.0387079231441021, 0.08674498647451401, 0.08139105141162872, 0.00164189247880131, 0.007786070462316275, 0.03820062801241875, -0.00023603909357916564, 0.002538360422477126, 0.0018279108917340636, 0.0030099842697381973, -0.034186020493507385, -0.006885166745632887, 0.033880289644002914, -0.013460315763950348, -0.041595667600631714, 0.028695732355117798, 0.07001566141843796, 0.027387471869587898, 0.015486111864447594, 0.01882888190448284, 0.03903663903474808, 0.02532426454126835, 0.0010585461277514696, 0.028688790276646614, 0.035893332213163376, 0.01753499172627926, 0.004951059818267822, -0.016353802755475044, 0.0285352636128664, 0.023973556235432625, -0.004590875469148159, 0.019880708307027817, 0.024023275822401047, 0.013527360744774342, -0.040811970829963684, 0.0022829582449048758, 0.044562824070453644, -0.03721106797456741, 0.018891852349042892, 0.0654677227139473, 0.008866976015269756, -0.02087564766407013, 0.0463668629527092, -0.036034777760505676, 0.011102292686700821, 0.03891110420227051, -0.014308221638202667, 0.007184574846178293, 0.02530229464173317, -0.015260223299264908, 0.012411607429385185, -0.04798971861600876, -0.007309035863727331, -0.04957040399312973, 0.006236901972442865, -0.022460704669356346, 0.009537383913993835, 0.015408957377076149, -0.007017071824520826, -0.0007775198901072145, -0.03228795528411865, 0.0089044738560915, 0.011902380734682083, 0.006435651332139969, -0.08109238743782043, 0.0044150701723992825, -0.031170371919870377, -0.01632983796298504, 0.0077325887978076935, -0.0018763680709525943, -0.014482966624200344, 0.06921136379241943, 0.0347108468413353, -0.052215009927749634, -0.024316586554050446, 0.002499140566214919, -0.001509658177383244, -0.000007566133717773482, -0.012574994005262852, 0.02908514067530632, 0.02081657014787197, -0.022824713960289955, -0.021693836897611618, -0.04105681926012039, -0.028282999992370605, -0.005696197971701622, -0.014128209091722965, 0.0255372803658247, 0.016856947913765907, 0.02580626681447029, 0.005415747407823801, -0.04655405879020691, -0.030014531686902046, -0.10178627818822861, -0.039570409804582596, -0.004153780173510313, 0.04773091897368431, 0.03044711984694004, 0.0069439345970749855, -0.0015497644199058414, 0.0410630889236927, 0.02031351998448372, -0.05690624192357063, -0.05389416962862015, -0.028706666082143784, -0.04699430987238884, -0.017198070883750916, 0.032061029225587845, 0.004819962196052074, -0.017607588320970535, 0.039584867656230927, -0.015150722116231918, 0.020896706730127335, 0.023195385932922363, 0.010387075133621693, -0.0046615288592875, 0.018242349848151207, 0.031890735030174255, -0.027922779321670532, 0.055231042206287384, 0.03408912569284439, -0.028241803869605064, 0.002943831030279398, -0.000601076812017709, 0.005301149562001228, 0.02465827390551567, -0.04273814707994461, 0.02643272466957569, -0.018105782568454742, 0.008720746263861656, 0.002455024281516671, -0.009689443744719028, -0.001497394754551351, -0.03165712207555771, -0.03756976127624512, 0.020143426954746246, 0.037313565611839294, -0.05022251978516579, 0.03606647625565529, 0.0751667320728302, 0.054844699800014496, -0.03511951118707657, -0.012667822651565075, 0.011572127230465412, 0.0009339905809611082, 0.007714126259088516, -0.017521746456623077, 0.004504497162997723, 0.035968679934740067, 0.04515455663204193, 0.002405020408332348, -0.0070275659672915936, -0.03224768117070198, 0.03277239203453064, -0.058876100927591324, 0.01728104054927826, -0.05094170570373535, 0.031447552144527435, -0.018015027046203613, 0.052543360739946365, 0.026747167110443115, -0.015586663968861103, -0.013862849213182926, -0.004298586398363113, -0.043869584798812866, 0.01637405902147293, 0.010376493446528912, 0.004556553903967142, 0.010736861266195774, -0.009295474737882614, 0.03485402464866638, 0.003549255197867751, 0.03262363001704216, -0.015558861196041107, -0.0034321548882871866, -0.036601897329092026, -0.001390210003592074, 0.002439576666802168, -0.0059647527523338795, 0.005026261322200298, 0.06274326145648956, 0.03610182926058769, -0.0421815849840641, 0.010389828123152256, -0.009017916396260262, 0.002547925803810358, -0.0004938072524964809, -0.0077364081516861916, -0.0016984038520604372, 0.013859173282980919, 0.05403361842036247, -0.00826424639672041, 0.026242118328809738, -0.024480530992150307, 0.014286911115050316, -0.023453399538993835, 0.044633809477090836, 0.01959921605885029, -0.015211670659482479, -0.018185673281550407, -0.019296877086162567, -0.023340020328760147, -0.008238540962338448, 0.041213590651750565, 0.013435440137982368, 0.007138586603105068, 0.02953498624265194, 0.030907880514860153, -0.06116265058517456, 0.017753347754478455, 0.07708924263715744, -0.018098769709467888, -0.032136235386133194, -0.04363614693284035, 0.00629241531714797, -0.006942295469343662, -0.02630852907896042, 0.037892598658800125, 0.023867640644311905, 0.013658936135470867, -0.000909742433577776, 0.048565395176410675, -0.03585387021303177, -0.03210645541548729, 0.04279539734125137, 0.017586277797818184, 0.023855166509747505, 0.02159813977777958, -0.05953120067715645, -0.005450059659779072, 0.032248351722955704, 0.03846944496035576, -0.004305549431592226, -0.008196149952709675, -0.08194877207279205, 0.0038428998086601496, 0.03806818649172783, 0.08033078163862228, -0.039257995784282684, -0.01660509966313839, 0.010849500074982643, -0.04136878624558449, 0.06474237143993378, -0.07654715329408646, 0.03331119567155838, -0.05723174661397934, -0.001928304904140532, -0.0647628903388977, -0.02545028179883957, -0.04814307764172554, 0.0161958709359169, -0.03793855383992195, -0.0076441471464931965, 0.007933073677122593, -0.0016103952657431364, -0.04750930145382881, 0.037859730422496796, 0.04185853898525238, 0.0385986752808094, -0.005636320449411869, -0.009635512717068195, 0.008285561576485634, -0.010735751129686832, -0.04084518179297447, -0.02339884079992771, 0.017877565696835518, 0.028903720900416374, 0.004873617086559534, 0.07059192657470703, -0.01948986016213894, -0.0274566151201725, -0.003436437575146556, -0.0009190113050863147, 0.01671733893454075, 0.034455738961696625, -0.02259640209376812, 0.05606855824589729, 0.028015989810228348, -0.0005397789063863456, 0.06424178928136826, 0.029242994263768196, -0.011866779997944832, 0.018285827711224556, -0.02449214458465576, -0.0020484321285039186, -0.029360175132751465, -0.04132605344057083, -0.000733698601834476, 0.006058541126549244, 0.013146179728209972, 0.04607878252863884, -0.0032538671512156725, -0.012063310481607914, -0.04478650912642479, -0.026846306398510933, -0.003478368278592825, -0.010726642794907093, 0.0269391480833292, -0.005902185570448637, 0.027205515652894974, -0.007943803444504738, 0.00833952333778143, -0.008393079042434692, -0.001696762628853321, -0.020570795983076096, 0.0011328780092298985, 0.009081593714654446, -0.03613755479454994, 0.010024786926805973, -0.007728626485913992, -0.04444112628698349, 0.007622924167662859, -0.03757578879594803, 0.02842576801776886, -0.034788329154253006, 0.02242252789437771, 0.003849680069833994, -0.029910340905189514, 0.017581593245267868, 0.0023893986362963915, -0.0058730244636535645, 0.04019578546285629, -0.012069025076925755, 0.04824719578027725, -0.049521304666996, -0.01542888768017292, -0.07218071818351746, -0.02878439985215664, 0.013642574660480022, -0.0034650536254048347, -0.010711883194744587, 0.00989551655948162, 0.011297301389276981, -0.01655437797307968, -0.005085896700620651, -0.04187939688563347, 0.06633001565933228, -0.01944633759558201, -0.026716217398643494, -0.017620332539081573, 0.04994862899184227, 0.05501007288694382, 0.02075362578034401, 0.004999929573386908, 0.008846535347402096, -0.05969085171818733, -0.00394612830132246, -0.03226374834775925, -0.03414660319685936, -0.03831394016742706, 0.013251082971692085, -0.01884997822344303, 0.017803968861699104, 0.06998810917139053, -0.0000199311034521088, -0.03139929473400116, -0.025454316288232803, -0.027470214292407036, -0.023354604840278625, -0.0784873440861702, 0.007386507000774145, -0.016523685306310654, 0.01893744245171547, -0.028070982545614243, 0.014572612941265106, -0.02837051823735237, 0.030611470341682434, 0.004912548698484898, 0.01205088384449482, -0.05869091674685478, 0.0257229283452034, 0.05829315260052681, 0.03738958761096001, 0.037979856133461, 0.009094585664570332, -0.007105989381670952, 0.059562742710113525, -0.016016069799661636, -0.02160235308110714, 0.021995577961206436, 0.034660566598176956, -0.03079926036298275, -0.025811122730374336, -0.028229711577296257, 0.029993699863553047, 0.06951485574245453, -0.03667135536670685, 0.04320282116532326, 0.08727646619081497, 0.008944369852542877, -0.020855674520134926, -0.04146604984998703, -0.004719938151538372, -0.020616216585040092, 0.019705859944224358, 0.07018417119979858, 0.0040566097013652325, -0.016420457512140274, 0.014041101559996605, 0.020384179428219795, 0.03579232841730118, 0.03339001163840294, 0.05242914333939552, 0.048980992287397385, 0.04782702401280403, -0.01340323407202959, -0.04402356967329979, 0.025307470932602882, -0.06280358880758286, -0.015645543113350868, -0.012565027922391891, -0.03733238950371742, 0.015372931025922298, 0.04306277260184288, -0.028147559612989426, -0.04934678226709366, -0.0375104695558548, -0.012739389203488827, 0.035400647670030594, 0.009247002191841602, -0.0266086645424366, 0.036257047206163406, -0.00616684602573514, 0.05969559773802757, -0.04187571257352829, -0.009486028924584389, -0.005680687725543976, -0.061254192143678665, -0.025578295812010765, -0.007875881157815456, -0.06286581605672836, 0.05209861323237419, -0.004717739298939705, 0.01638825424015522, -0.008813807740807533, -0.04236204922199249, 0.016278333961963654, -0.021919379010796547, 0.02294994331896305, 0.0048829917795956135, 0.026508575305342674, 0.005432793404906988, 0.01526124682277441, 0.00629806611686945, 0.03060014918446541, 0.10760945081710815, 0.04119415953755379, 0.049235086888074875, -0.0436733216047287, 0.03765418380498886, 0.014709731563925743, -0.007051459513604641, -0.007347746752202511, 0.0048312717117369175, 0.02778836153447628, -0.034062258899211884, 0.03241513669490814, 0.061169520020484924, 0.006895141210407019, 0.011257566511631012, 0.05511904135346413, -0.014284692704677582, -0.03520243614912033, 0.015333317220211029, 0.0012904066825285554, 0.02799960970878601, -0.012349973432719707, -0.027180872857570648, -0.02557600475847721, 0.051718294620513916, 0.007683857344090939, -0.01480947621166706, -0.014094728976488113, 0.012273489497601986, 0.029109571129083633, -0.020467039197683334, 0.029122453182935715, 0.013767671771347523, 0.02145540527999401, -0.03973974660038948, -0.015012530609965324, 0.015558160841464996, -0.0409734882414341, 0.02047116309404373, 0.039871495217084885, -0.006727831903845072, -0.0015483386814594269, 0.005289190914481878, 0.003096851287409663, -0.05276601016521454, -0.032933127135038376, -0.006681045982986689, 0.007726453244686127, 0.023051181808114052, -0.04060138761997223, -0.026598824188113213, 0.021140145137906075, 0.00553116574883461, -0.03463831916451454, -0.04374699667096138, 0.005262400489300489, 0.049872372299432755, -0.04042086750268936, -0.03169015422463417, 0.008227740414440632, -0.02011195942759514, -0.013732959516346455, 0.0035014271270483732, 0.03405799716711044, -0.04482642933726311, -0.025719525292515755, -0.04636334627866745, 0.020252812653779984, 0.02625356800854206, -0.014103420078754425, 0.008604587987065315, -0.010823007673025131, -0.038559604436159134, 0.005771688185632229, -0.0360124409198761, 0.0044959052465856075, 0.01870202273130417, -0.05315272510051727, 0.0009231829317286611, 0.006159327924251556, -0.0350387804210186, -0.005077979061752558, -0.024370336905121803, -0.006184103898704052, -0.03353506699204445, 0.010515349917113781, 0.0075046103447675705, -0.02403264306485653, -0.0055326479487121105, -0.03328453376889229, -0.0120166577398777, 0.09405781328678131, 0.0011916588991880417, -0.00323734013363719, -0.03226859122514725, -0.02327866479754448, -0.01665019430220127, -0.004185428377240896, -0.025217292830348015, 0.051121678203344345, -0.023959532380104065, 0.006818627007305622, -0.00971855316311121, 0.028237061575055122, -0.012612834572792053, 0.020803486928343773, 0.04167063161730766, -0.06113351881504059, -0.004884795285761356, -0.012325800955295563, 0.017075499519705772, -0.0101850014179945, -0.026939280331134796, -0.056443847715854645, -0.023789266124367714, 0.002789389342069626, -0.04183559492230415, -0.027990417554974556, 0.0074180359952151775, -0.037909530103206635, 0.01018906757235527, -0.012524768710136414, -0.020469864830374718, -0.005544594954699278, 0.024645915254950523, -0.0017801978392526507, 0.017057493329048157, 0.015085217542946339, 0.015754029154777527, -0.027839839458465576, -0.002832853002473712, 0.03634786978363991, 0.005665176548063755, -0.0005570175126194954, -0.009023623540997505, -0.019381850957870483, 0.02432440035045147, 0.046780794858932495, 0.02762899175286293, -0.015554513782262802, 0.025702573359012604, -0.06103159114718437, -0.020893873646855354, 0.004471911583095789, 0.00023536350636277348, 0.018054243177175522, 0.06846544146537781, -0.019257668405771255, -0.014689918607473373, 0.05188576877117157, 0.030735794454813004, -0.02518124133348465, 0.0036737630143761635, 0.010609553195536137, 0.024889016523957253, -0.023682141676545143, 0.03107689879834652, 0.008559194393455982, -0.027998186647892, 0.009591503068804741, 0.060968752950429916, -0.006290765944868326, 0.026079995557665825, -0.003271722700446844, 0.00013338003191165626, -0.0002532688667997718, -0.022815706208348274, -0.03061782754957676, 0.006444449536502361, 0.0731293112039566, -0.04389031603932381, 0.022793961688876152, -0.01659110002219677, -0.01423450093716383, -0.0851132720708847, 0.006883337628096342, -0.014320675283670425, 0.008159887976944447, 0.015455390326678753, -0.05933988466858864, 0.01457637082785368, 0.016579002141952515, -0.05136488005518913, -0.0020791252609342337, 0.001249133376404643, 0.01674078404903412, -0.033051665872335434, -0.00667966203764081, -0.028091633692383766, 0.009513323195278645, -0.02276797406375408, 0.016332803294062614, 0.030505655333399773, 0.013349051587283611, 0.005446353927254677, -0.04184824228286743, 0.01862269826233387, 0.04293910786509514, 0.003552893176674843, -0.05272714048624039, 0.023011112585663795, -0.020118381828069687, -0.05151879042387009, 0.020504361018538475, -0.006378288846462965, 0.016336236149072647, 0.026644842699170113, 0.04109387472271919, -0.0025146184489130974, 0.05291267856955528, 0.028230562806129456, 0.01613810658454895, 0.006529885344207287, 0.02284492924809456, 0.011695101857185364, 0.0209362730383873, -0.019839124754071236, 0.04320325702428818, 0.07702569663524628, 0.010079307481646538, -0.0013764420291408896, 0.008063777349889278, -0.011910529807209969, -0.009120876900851727, -0.003371428232640028, -0.007683938834816217, 0.06363703310489655, -0.05311572551727295, -0.0021722852252423763, -0.05492794141173363, 0.0005041213007643819, -0.0005653499392792583, 0.025789719074964523, 0.03739185631275177, 0.014640359207987785, -0.018403854221105576, -0.017108120024204254, -0.012174786068499088, -0.008377416990697384, 0.04342179372906685, -0.04620528221130371, -0.02141673117876053, 0.01007737498730421, -0.003952346742153168, -0.02439987100660801, 0.002447218634188175, -0.0017684242920950055, 0.016170110553503036, -0.04564354941248894, 0.0015084019396454096, -0.010009495541453362, -0.020151246339082718, 0.027039583772420883, -0.09272931516170502, 0.04260019212961197, 0.021352801471948624, -0.012856482528150082, 0.005288601852953434, 0.04686557129025459, -0.002238754415884614, -0.007085404824465513, 0.04008499160408974, -0.008262384682893753, -0.023653125390410423, -0.0061150239780545235, 0.029177984222769737, -0.011114021763205528, -0.004051622003316879, 0.028508566319942474, -0.02330010011792183, 0.026693111285567284, -0.0002736158494371921, 0.012762102298438549, -0.007822028361260891, -0.02150970883667469, 0.032765381038188934, -0.008574686013162136, -0.0032493497710675, -0.02561287209391594, -0.01690574176609516, -0.02766573801636696, 0.014046775177121162, -0.016119949519634247, 0.0257460568100214, -0.029418112710118294, -0.007256053388118744, 0.0026777037419378757, 0.024301182478666306, -0.03241962566971779, 0.028427766636013985, -0.038909342139959335, 0.017873823642730713, -0.027822300791740417, 0.01807725615799427, -0.012666499242186546, -0.07481163740158081, 0.02001621201634407, 0.00501575181260705, -0.04323320463299751, -0.0008729285909794271, 0.03758835047483444, 0.021570108830928802, 0.021283669397234917, 0.010064560920000076, -0.035247061401605606, 0.0069134472869336605, -0.023150674998760223, -0.018855812028050423, 0.012121066451072693, 0.056597087532281876, 0.03564753755927086, -0.03840379789471626, 0.019019993022084236, -0.0408564917743206, 0.041067954152822495, -0.003018783638253808, 0.004243340343236923, 0.04136965051293373, 0.022694997489452362, 0.019788630306720734, 0.026773488149046898, 0.02013850025832653, -0.034002743661403656, 0.031147588044404984, 0.057121917605400085, -0.05014168098568916, -0.006090488284826279, -0.04748421534895897, -0.02429218590259552, -0.06567522138357162, 0.0015018137637525797, 0.0005584132159128785, 0.008125394582748413, -0.00035933853359892964, 0.025709860026836395, -0.015105495229363441, -0.019362062215805054, 0.005188500043004751, -0.008397035300731659, 0.017776954919099808, -0.029480446130037308, -0.022516069933772087, 0.012801947072148323, -0.01471281610429287, -0.04954298585653305, -0.01405535638332367, 0.03155774623155594, 0.01826884225010872, 0.03701016306877136, -0.03881528973579407, -0.018925316631793976, -0.015825284644961357, 0.023298971354961395, -0.010756055824458599, -0.02241378091275692, -0.02776545286178589, -0.012956480495631695, 0.029581831768155098, 0.004394289571791887 ]
<p>Please help! </p> <p>I have developed a logistic regression model for prediction of a binary outcome at a range of different times following a set point. This gave me different models with different variables lists, although many variables overlapped and were seen to be significant at different times. I've then created a combined model to use the same set of variables at all time points and have run this for each of the 6 times in question. This model is therefore not the best-fit for any individual time point, but is the best-fit across all time points. </p> <p>I've been looking at how to internally validate this model within SPSS, and am stuck. I have been able to bootstrap to obtain variable estimates at each of the time points, but am looking for a measure of overall model performance (i.e. a mean AUC to calculate model optimism or similar). However, my attempts at 10-fold cross-validation have failed as I cannot work out how to apply the model created on 9/10th of the dataset to the other 1/10th. Every time I save an .xml file, SPSS tells me it is not recognised and cannot be used. The additional problem is that the model was tested on different population numbers at different time points, due to missing data issues. </p> <p>Is there a simple way to obtain overall model performance data to internally validate a logistic regression model in SPSS, given the problems I have outlined? </p> <p>Thanks</p>
35,771
[ -0.04463895037770271, 0.010542591102421284, -0.03175482526421547, 0.0372757725417614, 0.021921752020716667, -0.009630841203033924, -0.015750540420413017, -0.0194732453674078, 0.044266436249017715, 0.006582092493772507, 0.03264941647648811, 0.05830172076821327, 0.04272159934043884, 0.027043988928198814, -0.013297390192747116, -0.019448887556791306, 0.0006417991826310754, 0.011584345251321793, 0.013819661922752857, -0.0019291519420221448, 0.0033135719131678343, 0.002859033178538084, 0.023265447467565536, -0.00509636290371418, 0.008810699917376041, 0.05334729328751564, 0.04239720478653908, -0.02275356464087963, 0.011235100217163563, 0.04684268683195114, -0.053116731345653534, -0.028760986402630806, -0.007757354993373156, 0.0555410198867321, 0.005125535652041435, 0.005999927408993244, -0.016681212931871414, -0.03277076780796051, -0.030253484845161438, 0.026741942390799522, 0.0015337115619331598, -0.009025756269693375, 0.009992856532335281, 0.03578837960958481, 0.0019634997006505728, 0.009694527834653854, -0.024924492463469505, 0.009817211888730526, 0.04299924522638321, -0.042176149785518646, 0.04766712337732315, -0.024143969640135765, 0.023728230968117714, 0.04814953729510307, 0.001978175714612007, 0.006118939258158207, 0.05635104328393936, 0.07102981954813004, -0.0144174350425601, -0.049426306039094925, -0.0076828207820653915, -0.02238600142300129, -0.010739117860794067, -0.023051738739013672, -0.035425323992967606, 0.02056850865483284, 0.0017005730187520385, 0.006980634294450283, 0.06953627616167068, 0.006918581668287516, 0.0005751496064476669, 0.008844992145895958, 0.04288354888558388, -0.0035044115502387285, 0.03163198009133339, -0.04342695698142052, 0.006521645467728376, 0.019631749019026756, 0.029655588790774345, 0.05639764666557312, -0.006729272194206715, 0.015204758383333683, -0.007093247026205063, 0.020270368084311485, 0.02167586423456669, -0.022650662809610367, 0.0668906569480896, -0.0007443370413966477, 0.024157898500561714, 0.019996576011180878, -0.020155033096671104, 0.019969340413808823, 0.04640021175146103, 0.010614369064569473, 0.003550769528374076, 0.03169556334614754, -0.008451530709862709, 0.04627304896712303, -0.0048766289837658405, 0.02061837539076805, 0.03176209330558777, -0.035795908421278, 0.01384291984140873, 0.03388885408639908, -0.021768584847450256, 0.01947597600519657, -0.01129595935344696, -0.031015589833259583, -0.007077749818563461, -0.06227872520685196, -0.02304273284971714, 0.023715579882264137, 0.04570618271827698, -0.005429895594716072, -0.016912873834371567, -0.017324689775705338, -0.022596171125769615, -0.03528723865747452, 0.014876574277877808, 0.02092031203210354, 0.039488911628723145, -0.028861967846751213, 0.03684542700648308, -0.05588267743587494, -0.046581242233514786, -0.004762821830809116, -0.02480809949338436, -0.0070107909850776196, -0.03249787166714668, 0.07213173061609268, 0.012309498153626919, -0.03024371899664402, 0.04083246737718582, 0.012538119219243526, 0.051991235464811325, 0.013365315273404121, -0.07159396260976791, -0.08996114134788513, -0.015263629145920277, -0.006026712246239185, 0.04340484365820885, -0.037773001939058304, -0.024560105055570602, 0.016182970255613327, 0.03308437764644623, 0.020177550613880157, 0.011685890145599842, 0.025393541902303696, 0.005229334346950054, 0.02227877266705036, -0.006380764301866293, 0.005206143017858267, -0.035846564918756485, -0.03170762211084366, -0.013147308491170406, -0.09896554052829742, 0.002323603257536888, 0.012853875756263733, -0.030334388837218285, -0.026131317019462585, 0.01734982430934906, 0.0013457135064527392, 0.013138586655259132, -0.013257788494229317, 0.003620852716267109, 0.0009822375141084194, 0.04666450619697571, -0.007753106765449047, 0.0013959705829620361, 0.007243515457957983, -0.02506387233734131, -0.019523609429597855, 0.020786326378583908, 0.04807082191109657, 0.01575806550681591, -0.022190842777490616, -0.0060458010993897915, -0.01784733682870865, -0.012405730783939362, 0.029839320108294487, -0.024817775934934616, -0.005987256765365601, -0.03993837907910347, 0.01651810109615326, 0.0031771711073815823, 0.0483410470187664, -0.004292413126677275, -0.019371015951037407, 0.022540085017681122, -0.025293631479144096, -0.052578721195459366, -0.03774523362517357, 0.050619710236787796, 0.023284586146473885, 0.011414293199777603, 0.03306685760617256, -0.004318582825362682, 0.03697056695818901, -0.018668055534362793, -0.016709227114915848, -0.028244419023394585, -0.01631503365933895, 0.05266889929771423, -0.03989562392234802, 0.0018147605005651712, 0.04523393139243126, 0.036271631717681885, -0.056883085519075394, 0.028554409742355347, -0.04411809518933296, -0.02096262201666832, 0.0252502653747797, -0.03293752297759056, -0.003349078120663762, -0.029003985226154327, -0.026095004752278328, 0.023334277793765068, 0.013501649722456932, -0.013656708411872387, 0.03095077909529209, -0.020903155207633972, 0.0714898407459259, 0.07109545171260834, -0.0020841925870627165, -0.011736671440303326, -0.020891889929771423, 0.016369663178920746, 0.020131628960371017, -0.018927140161395073, 0.006062286905944347, -0.04654405638575554, -0.013937219977378845, 0.03284456580877304, -0.029465878382325172, -0.030831733718514442, -0.0026416031178086996, 0.05088678374886513, -0.0021825183648616076, 0.019576434046030045, 0.03481307998299599, -0.03134463354945183, -0.014944241382181644, -0.00021563582413364202, 0.020368589088320732, 0.049965791404247284, 0.013719465583562851, 0.004554225131869316, 0.02004413492977619, 0.04363887012004852, 0.037817925214767456, 0.007231493014842272, 0.04670187085866928, 0.008388753049075603, -0.0037479093298316, -0.026384862139821053, -0.044091302901506424, 0.05668865144252777, -0.005565595347434282, 0.005064125172793865, 0.07178781181573868, -0.005897102411836386, 0.017081916332244873, 0.012045557610690594, -0.007753059267997742, 0.05522546544671059, 0.0632268488407135, -0.029358020052313805, -0.01661452278494835, 0.0008492372580803931, -0.028740467503666878, 0.0006139000179246068, -0.03429130092263222, -0.050527606159448624, -0.06498846411705017, 0.005834346171468496, 0.012274043634533882, 0.008369803428649902, 0.034983184188604355, -0.011857965029776096, -0.022375047206878662, 0.012395559810101986, -0.018826255574822426, 0.030190359801054, -0.043637823313474655, -0.06348424404859543, -0.036299217492341995, 0.010554366745054722, -0.023114819079637527, 0.025530919432640076, -0.03271656483411789, -0.04730871692299843, 0.01720290258526802, -0.005447679664939642, -0.018625877797603607, -0.013615649193525314, -0.028548140078783035, -0.004844512324780226, -0.010314357466995716, -0.0194452665746212, 0.01241737138479948, 0.008933456614613533, -0.05018554627895355, 0.040268417447805405, -0.036596208810806274, 0.01284062024205923, -0.01954844407737255, 0.000014915072824805975, -0.004301665350794792, -0.0013103252276778221, -0.009482434019446373, -0.0056396713480353355, -0.01273431722074747, -0.012749779038131237, -0.05960838869214058, -0.05016382038593292, -0.019128162413835526, 0.015314249321818352, 0.031167708337306976, -0.030320804566144943, -0.01727139577269554, 0.07383490353822708, 0.05115807428956032, -0.025502022355794907, -0.06895165145397186, 0.010226689279079437, -0.026265325024724007, -0.005613846238702536, -0.00025293149519711733, -0.0017811603611335158, 0.0028946653474122286, 0.022573938593268394, -0.020221047103405, -0.01351214200258255, 0.06446509808301926, 0.00085404550191015, -0.011371370404958725, 0.004152842331677675, -0.007544145919382572, -0.041173115372657776, -0.00753755122423172, 0.03852391242980957, -0.025549575686454773, 0.007133813109248877, -0.020404383540153503, 0.03735915943980217, -0.014618704095482826, -0.056065186858177185, 0.005122685804963112, -0.027530677616596222, 0.022271426394581795, -0.03129104897379875, -0.007403882686048746, -0.0004086619010195136, -0.06207172945141792, -0.027092954143881798, 0.038476478308439255, 0.024360686540603638, 0.02883022278547287, 0.0085182199254632, 0.03637097030878067, 0.03539891168475151, 0.009121770039200783, -0.02753029577434063, -0.050635840743780136, -0.003009970998391509, 0.02854551002383232, 0.0023121347185224295, -0.01528190914541483, 0.05035015195608139, 0.03380114585161209, 0.035199642181396484, 0.0017391025321558118, -0.056375134736299515, 0.01239441242069006, -0.07213382422924042, 0.004242877941578627, -0.03635326400399208, 0.05018577352166176, 0.0377044603228569, 0.018454955890774727, 0.016800319775938988, -0.053033627569675446, 0.013859331607818604, 0.034724943339824677, -0.03833385929465294, 0.02897176332771778, -0.022725878283381462, 0.0005902652628719807, 0.03555800020694733, -0.021927159279584885, 0.024741042405366898, -0.06537563353776932, 0.008754045702517033, 0.04216893017292023, 0.0330488421022892, -0.01861269772052765, 0.004829083569347858, -0.009275922551751137, -0.028780998662114143, -0.027176082134246826, 0.01307373121380806, 0.0011627800995483994, 0.011539855971932411, 0.015411355532705784, 0.04444713145494461, 0.0013521688524633646, -0.02309354767203331, -0.0350443460047245, 0.0011840388178825378, 0.005217447876930237, 0.049364835023880005, 0.041424788534641266, 0.023123888298869133, -0.053340815007686615, 0.043276347219944, -0.001588148414157331, 0.03599245101213455, 0.05331737920641899, 0.006237752269953489, -0.05539427325129509, -0.039272334426641464, 0.015587550587952137, 0.029710832983255386, -0.016349291428923607, -0.008920959196984768, 0.005281243938952684, 0.04748077690601349, 0.046817339956760406, -0.07668698579072952, -0.002427577506750822, 0.07753127813339233, 0.0035187348257750273, -0.01298579853028059, -0.008810916915535927, -0.0019395266426727176, -0.022507676854729652, 0.014365224167704582, 0.0011939757969230413, 0.009712417609989643, 0.036742810159921646, 0.009713620878756046, 0.02476336993277073, -0.02512744441628456, -0.024091070517897606, 0.017845045775175095, 0.011341302655637264, 0.0516381561756134, 0.03036654368042946, -0.03843704238533974, 0.0046739052049815655, 0.04144946113228798, 0.026472149416804314, 0.03355303034186363, 0.003859464079141617, -0.09570900350809097, -0.007964516058564186, 0.038090769201517105, 0.04209975525736809, -0.033697910606861115, -0.026148639619350433, -0.022531697526574135, -0.015336837619543076, 0.036954592913389206, -0.030970986932516098, 0.03463878482580185, 0.02053300477564335, 0.023762285709381104, -0.04674232006072998, -0.023746168240904808, -0.04183634743094444, 0.01509827934205532, -0.03531107306480408, 0.019443759694695473, -0.040344737470149994, -0.001818050746805966, -0.05285482108592987, 0.014004024676978588, 0.007566854357719421, 0.05984335020184517, -0.0069694980047643185, -0.01750611886382103, 0.018741590902209282, 0.01961953565478325, -0.013683539815247059, -0.04421578347682953, -0.025673234835267067, 0.02188802696764469, -0.03414026275277138, 0.009634205140173435, 0.02036179229617119, -0.03640962019562721, 0.015116354450583458, 0.03233543038368225, -0.041835639625787735, -0.020711878314614296, -0.06790055334568024, 0.0033176057040691376, 0.002641306957229972, -0.015650147572159767, 0.04692723602056503, 0.042927417904138565, -0.004077112767845392, 0.004593921825289726, -0.026712743565440178, 0.011095896363258362, 0.010238852351903915, -0.03790260851383209, -0.06040741130709648, 0.030541138723492622, -0.012289542704820633, 0.02492247149348259, 0.0014674984849989414, -0.0032181290443986654, -0.004444640129804611, 0.011179975233972073, -0.012622660025954247, 0.0481475293636322, -0.0199748482555151, 0.014337473548948765, 0.016481701284646988, 0.013711909763514996, -0.031357020139694214, -0.018936289474368095, 0.02197045274078846, -0.014414782635867596, -0.03534799441695213, 0.008321743458509445, -0.047978706657886505, 0.018777217715978622, -0.012865648604929447, -0.046733539551496506, 0.01749284379184246, 0.006034585181623697, 0.01186543982475996, -0.009516967460513115, 0.033438026905059814, -0.002404702827334404, -0.046143293380737305, -0.02631174959242344, 0.03845687210559845, 0.05035006254911423, 0.021610984578728676, -0.0037337958347052336, 0.008580232970416546, -0.005896508693695068, -0.0151150431483984, -0.07925255596637726, -0.04905322566628456, 0.03310762718319893, 0.01664801873266697, -0.025175761431455612, -0.027076968923211098, 0.0021441609133034945, -0.00751104112714529, 0.017902921885252, -0.025952178984880447, 0.03414757177233696, -0.020728686824440956, -0.01813293807208538, -0.04017624258995056, -0.0012655872851610184, 0.035251446068286896, 0.008211985230445862, -0.0010199312819167972, -0.015007983893156052, -0.014942442998290062, -0.03689464181661606, 0.011270182207226753, 0.01806584931910038, -0.03754924237728119, -0.033493828028440475, -0.059528104960918427, -0.005300959572196007, 0.02874978817999363, -0.007975653745234013, -0.0096204224973917, -0.00008823180542094633, -0.04038814827799797, 0.0070929680950939655, -0.028163349255919456, 0.02109457366168499, -0.029493968933820724, -0.007826529443264008, -0.02505260519683361, 0.012441720813512802, -0.04038572683930397, -0.004062328953295946, 0.033383771777153015, -0.014654560014605522, -0.031535468995571136, 0.003598366165533662, 0.10685055702924728, 0.018871665000915527, 0.024084776639938354, -0.033961810171604156, -0.023189272731542587, 0.04965812340378761, 0.02830125205218792, -0.000706446182448417, 0.023794488981366158, -0.007679502945393324, -0.0337890200316906, -0.022750653326511383, -0.012226368300616741, -0.010522951371967793, 0.03548939898610115, -0.03887864202260971, 0.01552045252174139, 0.060124993324279785, -0.016781754791736603, -0.02097935974597931, -0.03521163389086723, 0.006187013816088438, 0.014151322655379772, 0.0225059874355793, 0.07193209230899811, 0.029754167422652245, -0.028239823877811432, 0.05457353591918945, 0.013949260115623474, 0.028714967891573906, 0.025798378512263298, -0.0029621245339512825, 0.028904760256409645, 0.01916595920920372, -0.03206459432840347, -0.030203938484191895, 0.04074600711464882, -0.04792875796556473, -0.00462334742769599, -0.007520860061049461, -0.016455329954624176, -0.0019824556075036526, 0.024882588535547256, 0.0005736109451390803, -0.017097264528274536, -0.012209135107696056, -0.058161113411188126, 0.0011207404313609004, -0.00858893059194088, 0.009646310470998287, 0.03160528466105461, -0.003583819605410099, 0.0008059421670623124, 0.01569424197077751, 0.006627324037253857, -0.03694992512464523, -0.08369698375463486, -0.01007852889597416, -0.009901427663862705, -0.037696968764066696, 0.05745875835418701, 0.017199814319610596, -0.013442134484648705, -0.0027918049599975348, -0.01386391744017601, -0.0022367227356880903, -0.02894211933016777, 0.038241755217313766, 0.0270550437271595, 0.08515262603759766, -0.002559674670919776, 0.012919190339744091, 0.007410875055938959, -0.00788839627057314, 0.12652495503425598, 0.08431537449359894, 0.032951414585113525, -0.06700408458709717, 0.009207411669194698, -0.0011917637893930078, 0.011890861205756664, -0.002184028970077634, -0.005284440238028765, 0.010286368429660797, -0.03686310350894928, 0.04670402780175209, 0.04612519592046738, 0.020340081304311752, -0.021153565496206284, 0.06084335595369339, -0.006109595764428377, 0.005671876948326826, 0.007080484181642532, 0.0012528246734291315, 0.005042068660259247, -0.0386306457221508, -0.011431645601987839, 0.0013708744663745165, -0.009193656966090202, -0.04371859133243561, -0.02679893560707569, -0.004386901389807463, 0.016618307679891586, -0.016689429059624672, 0.008494277484714985, -0.0025910111144185066, -0.007019181735813618, 0.02175971306860447, -0.04515841603279114, -0.005385336000472307, 0.0062436130829155445, -0.03828832134604454, 0.034018900245428085, 0.06004112586379051, -0.017879560589790344, 0.02340611256659031, -0.015535927377641201, -0.00007940046634757891, -0.043160609900951385, -0.04523292928934097, -0.061550866812467575, 0.05984099209308624, -0.013262628577649593, -0.026561258360743523, -0.030237220227718353, 0.017658032476902008, 0.008514338172972202, -0.041115280240774155, -0.07239736616611481, 0.009699885733425617, 0.02982325479388237, -0.01830652356147766, -0.014710713177919388, -0.04251464828848839, 0.005455418024212122, 0.018291998654603958, 0.04337116330862045, 0.015118533745408058, -0.022634094581007957, -0.016672737896442413, -0.04385833814740181, 0.04008863866329193, 0.0014307127567008138, 0.013614474795758724, 0.006981926504522562, 0.0014095534570515156, -0.019573071971535683, -0.007985133677721024, 0.05863769352436066, 0.017272593453526497, -0.004386149812489748, -0.026857612654566765, 0.002360318088904023, -0.040426697582006454, -0.055194560438394547, -0.019442513585090637, -0.01857041008770466, 0.0014331459533423185, -0.019658485427498817, -0.01723887398838997, 0.02945181541144848, 0.03385046496987343, 0.02492285892367363, 0.023359283804893494, -0.03216934949159622, 0.039848692715168, -0.005318484269082546, -0.07519055902957916, -0.03153413534164429, 0.00166723458096385, -0.04205463081598282, 0.010391552932560444, -0.01181414257735014, 0.07503124326467514, -0.0025372023228555918, 0.018885301426053047, -0.031228970736265182, 0.06146591156721115, 0.008178340271115303, 0.026414180174469948, 0.007187915034592152, -0.025734154507517815, -0.010795542038977146, 0.011426434852182865, 0.02011810801923275, -0.012039250694215298, -0.009524431079626083, -0.040461208671331406, -0.05410821735858917, 0.05497613176703453, -0.025926388800144196, -0.04232093691825867, 0.02864762768149376, 0.01078302226960659, -0.0015565763460472226, -0.033832669258117676, 0.016921870410442352, -0.022445881739258766, -0.0021532869432121515, -0.015342521481215954, -0.047609083354473114, 0.014430469833314419, 0.005313639994710684, 0.005474905017763376, 0.01464605052024126, 0.07809208333492279, -0.0007568792789243162, 0.008988884277641773, -0.024042317643761635, 0.021432649344205856, 0.030142467468976974, 0.06858153641223907, -0.031247079372406006, -0.003913346212357283, 0.028342101722955704, -0.014305801130831242, -0.01943139359354973, 0.043029434978961945, -0.02910931035876274, 0.04061128944158554, 0.014587982557713985, 0.03796951845288277, -0.011501302011311054, 0.048664893954992294, -0.011681598611176014, -0.03339323028922081, -0.013264669105410576, 0.04205550625920296, 0.00858094822615385, 0.024374481290578842, -0.008958983235061169, 0.0160833727568388, -0.02242906577885151, 0.028675278648734093, 0.060000229626894, 0.022701753303408623, 0.0027604536153376102, 0.006345239467918873, -0.012233010493218899, 0.042753029614686966, 0.04654097929596901, -0.0186358280479908, 0.025885075330734253, 0.05267918109893799, -0.005839712917804718, 0.024893267080187798, 0.009889060631394386, 0.03158647194504738, -0.06884435564279556, -0.013952445238828659, -0.01424470730125904, 0.051474377512931824, -0.009369625709950924, -0.021689681336283684, -0.002836095867678523, 0.054090723395347595, -0.009768359363079071, 0.019253801554441452, 0.035706307739019394, 0.0035772891715168953, -0.009475245140492916, -0.006114194635301828, -0.020673947408795357, 0.0005596757982857525, 0.03144243732094765, 0.020628614351153374, 0.0016202523838728666, 0.020077506080269814, 0.027963463217020035, -0.036783430725336075, -0.0447474867105484, 0.026242027059197426, 0.021801171824336052, -0.04324396327137947, -0.0009467664058320224, -0.04032820463180542, -0.023853391408920288, 0.03208674490451813, 0.009140620939433575, 0.02988363988697529, 0.031192729249596596, 0.007373567204922438, -0.0014327336102724075, 0.049248531460762024, 0.04480883106589317, 0.019128000363707542, 0.014644093811511993, 0.0017340431222692132, 0.026494305580854416, 0.02683047577738762, -0.049333419650793076, 0.04325129836797714, 0.03711385652422905, -0.0008997910772450268, -0.06481777131557465, 0.019231412559747696, -0.02428838051855564, -0.00646540243178606, -0.013102838769555092, -0.024202993139624596, 0.026433300226926804, -0.0251677967607975, -0.026650547981262207, -0.051631152629852295, 0.026016993448138237, 0.04872980713844299, 0.020503591746091843, -0.03882725536823273, 0.014716713689267635, -0.02440699376165867, -0.022527826949954033, -0.008721857331693172, -0.010380135849118233, -0.0016206426080316305, -0.043822456151247025, 0.0005768854171037674, 0.0062322295270860195, -0.03787245228886604, -0.018568605184555054, 0.044545188546180725, -0.016280297189950943, 0.06952549517154694, -0.04792025312781334, 0.020541638135910034, 0.05366242304444313, -0.018905607983469963, 0.006033142562955618, -0.07712895423173904, 0.06906381249427795, 0.007037521339952946, -0.041761286556720734, -0.03694920614361763, -0.013563178479671478, -0.024127427488565445, 0.009488627314567566, 0.03862740844488144, -0.00482894666492939, -0.010467255488038063, 0.00587695837020874, 0.05128674581646919, -0.026680588722229004, -0.043834637850522995, 0.0604928657412529, -0.016743648797273636, -0.03312169760465622, -0.029025238007307053, -0.04304886981844902, -0.04216453433036804, 0.004228230565786362, 0.030848713591694832, -0.02871522307395935, 0.012583826668560505, 0.00994847808033228, -0.02799050696194172, -0.0022657171357423067, -0.02633747085928917, -0.029909586533904076, 0.050348009914159775, -0.009438582696020603, -0.01785615086555481, 0.0535334013402462, 0.031834252178668976, -0.04880860447883606, 0.03241170570254326, -0.019574515521526337, -0.005579902324825525, 0.0054647428914904594, 0.04761451855301857, -0.008037025108933449, -0.06243210285902023, 0.05396652594208717, 0.03004584088921547, -0.01914980262517929, 0.023159358650445938, 0.024526631459593773, 0.006732159294188023, 0.02154277078807354, -0.03866760805249214, 0.016681937500834465, 0.010306913405656815, -0.011987919919192791, 0.005844531115144491, -0.009549658745527267, 0.03879210352897644, 0.004585589282214642, 0.017276406288146973, 0.030092284083366394, -0.003786646295338869, 0.052163977175951004, 0.0019325256580486894, 0.023501984775066376, -0.025493666529655457, -0.01625552959740162, 0.0185786671936512, -0.029758092015981674, 0.028784923255443573, 0.017803415656089783, 0.008004043251276016, 0.04847399517893791, -0.03212305158376694, 0.029204828664660454, -0.07062306255102158, -0.017793210223317146, -0.018051782622933388, 0.012590968050062656, 0.04671338573098183, 0.03330664709210396, 0.0009527098154649138, 0.014108225703239441, 0.006908984389156103, 0.013319575227797031, 0.014778577722609043, 0.030447984114289284, -0.024049699306488037, -0.023111870512366295, 0.007405486423522234, -0.033029865473508835, -0.05128972604870796, -0.023723794147372246, -0.0012932401150465012, 0.013436706736683846, 0.0022939310874789953, 0.030896291136741638, -0.012100180611014366, -0.0493878610432148, 0.013587561435997486, 0.08057054132223129, -0.07050167769193649, -0.0064735873602330685, -0.05383140221238136, 0.0018182727508246899, -0.010910206474363804, -0.02977767214179039 ]
<p>I posted this to mathoverflow and no one's answering:</p> <p><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scheff%C3%A9%27s_method">Scheffé's method</a> for identifying statistically significant contrasts is widely known. A <b>contrast</b> among the means $\mu_i$, $i=1,\ldots,r$ of $r$ populations is a linear combination $\sum_{i=1}^r c_i \mu_i$ in which $\sum_{i=1}^r c_i=0$, and a scalar multiple of a contrast is essentially the same contrast, so one could say the set of contrasts is a projective space. Scheffé's method tests a null hypothesis that says <em>all</em> contrasts among these $r$ populations is $0$, and given a significance level $\alpha$, rejects the null hypothesis with probability $\alpha$ given that the null hypothesis is true. And if the null hypothesis is rejected, Scheffé points out that his test tells us <em>which</em> contrasts differ significantly from $0$ (I'm not sure the Wikipedia article I linked to points that out).</p> <p>I would like to know if one can do something similar in a different sort of situation. Consider a simple linear regression model $Y_i = \alpha + \beta x_i + \varepsilon_i$, where $\varepsilon_i\sim\operatorname{i.i.d.}N(0,\sigma^2)$, $i=1,\ldots,n$.</p> <p>The null hypothesis I want to consider concerns a different sort of contrast. It says there is no subset $A\subseteq\lbrace 1,\ldots,n\rbrace$ such that $E(Y_i) = \alpha_1 + \beta x_i$ for $i\in A$ and $E(Y_i) = \alpha_2 + \beta x_i$ for $i\not\in A$, where $\alpha_1\ne\alpha_2$. If the subset $A$ is specified in advance, then an ordinary two-sample $t$-test does it, but we want something that considers all subsets and holds down the probability of rejecting a true null hypothesis.</p> <p>One could figure this out if efficiency were not a concern: find a test that goes through all $2^{n-1}-1$ possibilities. Even then it's problematic; two contrasts would not be independent. I asked an expert on outlier detection about this and he just said it's a combinatorial nightmare. Then I asked if one could <em>prove</em> that there's no efficient way to do it, perhaps by reducing an NP-hard problem to it. He just said he stays away from NP-hard problems.</p> <p>So: Can one prove either that this problem is "hard" or that it's not?</p>
73,413
[ -0.022593216970562935, 0.029430441558361053, -0.022252634167671204, -0.026336217299103737, 0.005455746781080961, 0.02836013212800026, -0.014481624588370323, 0.03291536122560501, -0.010221008211374283, -0.038000863045454025, 0.04694027081131935, 0.006487852893769741, 0.05749955400824547, 0.01992889866232872, 0.019902586936950684, -0.025171419605612755, -0.014545704238116741, 0.025094984099268913, -0.01305291149765253, -0.0073024192824959755, 0.021652869880199432, 0.03521570563316345, 0.04000774025917053, -0.033225879073143005, -0.05573395639657974, 0.05052633211016655, 0.00900493934750557, 0.005809160880744457, -0.0182481836527586, 0.02307710237801075, -0.040708307176828384, -0.0031289332546293736, -0.00819206889718771, 0.02234550192952156, 0.024952085688710213, 0.011990677565336227, 0.01913554035127163, 0.011193927377462387, 0.027607327327132225, 0.028691250830888748, -0.019251663237810135, -0.05469322204589844, 0.0019194843480363488, 0.02777569368481636, -0.03224010765552521, 0.004135721363127232, -0.01575181819498539, -0.05234886333346367, 0.0332798957824707, -0.028239671140909195, 0.07723642140626907, 0.010127776302397251, -0.006999151781201363, 0.02924908697605133, 0.00005580322613241151, 0.008047042414546013, 0.011486707255244255, 0.02866104245185852, -0.0384804904460907, -0.07642318308353424, -0.03220103308558464, 0.001127806375734508, -0.007515433710068464, 0.010281721130013466, -0.03923949599266052, -0.005538120865821838, 0.039382923394441605, -0.010848253034055233, 0.04683149605989456, -0.02017948031425476, 0.01284629013389349, 0.0007572260801680386, 0.0002454209025017917, 0.005894918460398912, -0.02313660830259323, 0.023349450901150703, 0.010991142131388187, 0.010042659938335419, 0.03237864002585411, 0.018986547365784645, 0.008893460035324097, 0.00975660141557455, 0.022606369107961655, 0.027641812339425087, 0.06995031982660294, 0.011957109905779362, 0.05872878432273865, -0.030179331079125404, 0.0056246137246489525, 0.038134753704071045, -0.0058420621789991856, -0.020447883754968643, 0.07384101301431656, -0.014454234391450882, -0.03773576021194458, 0.0202298853546381, -0.010685416869819164, 0.037713710218667984, 0.01206943765282631, 0.0012972090626135468, -0.01622503623366356, -0.05192992836236954, 0.011089013889431953, 0.04428018629550934, 0.00975851435214281, 0.0027921320870518684, -0.042242273688316345, 0.02848048321902752, -0.013362382538616657, -0.0032561400439590216, -0.03687338903546333, 0.06609497219324112, 0.01035540271550417, 0.03592143952846527, 0.018707377836108208, 0.022257748991250992, -0.015368586406111717, -0.020576922222971916, 0.05259598419070244, 0.0561504140496254, 0.030118321999907494, 0.015014073811471462, 0.004126510117202997, -0.012470916844904423, -0.060114435851573944, -0.011468413285911083, 0.021298576146364212, -0.02329477109014988, -0.020808812230825424, 0.05211564153432846, 0.02364269830286503, -0.009413116611540318, 0.005937275476753712, -0.00981938000768423, 0.025647249072790146, 0.002819378860294819, -0.08808502554893494, -0.04622095450758934, 0.016100434586405754, -0.011912214569747448, -0.03117947094142437, -0.02070384845137596, -0.01285027526319027, 0.03926066681742668, 0.03421533480286598, 0.01047966256737709, 0.0269299503415823, 0.030513040721416473, 0.025454780086874962, 0.025261737406253815, -0.011868606321513653, -0.014359630644321442, -0.03214777261018753, -0.06307104974985123, -0.03381196781992912, -0.05429472401738167, 0.04622255638241768, -0.002323930151760578, 0.0034612605813890696, 0.009808463975787163, 0.026143120601773262, 0.029478594660758972, -0.018049729987978935, 0.009818493388593197, 0.004908132366836071, -0.005693359766155481, 0.06445001810789108, -0.015763267874717712, 0.05061795189976692, -0.013019188307225704, -0.022548945620656013, 0.023008504882454872, -0.0038069651927798986, 0.044834185391664505, 0.035076677799224854, -0.04238540679216385, 0.022164635360240936, -0.02532775327563286, 0.019880803301930428, 0.03194601833820343, -0.04160076007246971, -0.021775012835860252, -0.01956494152545929, -0.01564428023993969, 0.025109943002462387, 0.06426786631345749, 0.000702306570019573, 0.0027413805946707726, 0.05968015640974045, -0.05184141919016838, -0.04161480441689491, -0.0587613508105278, -0.018572157248854637, 0.014364892616868019, -0.024295778945088387, 0.07066737115383148, 0.01490874495357275, -0.02015792950987816, -0.014248613268136978, -0.0007771644159220159, -0.02088358998298645, -0.025745853781700134, 0.028126321732997894, -0.04583278298377991, 0.008653590455651283, 0.006286755669862032, 0.070225290954113, -0.005238891579210758, 0.05423083156347275, -0.008100257255136967, 0.006981872487813234, 0.02441689558327198, -0.03289451077580452, 0.014584079384803772, 0.045538224279880524, -0.01315164566040039, 0.007495332974940538, -0.015376169234514236, -0.028529440984129906, 0.07258996367454529, -0.07115206122398376, 0.014660459943115711, 0.06426858901977539, -0.026874437928199768, -0.0015562053304165602, -0.01628960855305195, 0.006568856071680784, -0.007651899941265583, 0.017677031457424164, -0.020743144676089287, 0.0001511388982180506, -0.018093464896082878, 0.05910903215408325, 0.01827162690460682, -0.056250836700201035, 0.027384916320443153, 0.04150856286287308, 0.03490523248910904, -0.011914663016796112, 0.016897765919566154, 0.0027996746357530355, -0.007180353160947561, -0.02693229727447033, -0.02633088082075119, 0.015676768496632576, 0.03827162832021713, 0.023667244240641594, -0.013798297382891178, 0.009488617070019245, -0.024164995178580284, -0.0016137132188305259, 0.031861528754234314, 0.029627367854118347, -0.024604056030511856, -0.01335203554481268, 0.028599010780453682, 0.023726865649223328, -0.013977997936308384, 0.010174183174967766, 0.05720304697751999, -0.01047652866691351, 0.003752885852009058, 0.015237427316606045, -0.009440899826586246, 0.05114249140024185, 0.006190026644617319, -0.03160608932375908, 0.022548062726855278, 0.04989049956202507, -0.05338772386312485, -0.005305302329361439, -0.037685565650463104, -0.007821616716682911, 0.01250260416418314, -0.03968425840139389, 0.00877603329718113, 0.010164896957576275, 0.016920553520321846, -0.03497577831149101, -0.0010795482667163014, 0.01307129766792059, -0.01924615539610386, 0.06817774474620819, 0.018646804615855217, -0.04607771709561348, 0.006652608513832092, -0.05860084667801857, 0.005573698319494724, 0.018743569031357765, -0.003908440470695496, -0.04069330170750618, 0.03934406116604805, 0.004041773267090321, -0.03610723838210106, -0.020531238988041878, -0.050782132893800735, -0.012015973217785358, -0.04209084436297417, -0.030752358958125114, 0.05714467540383339, 0.0052806236781179905, -0.08940374106168747, 0.02601466327905655, -0.04118587449193001, -0.017876500263810158, -0.03602680191397667, -0.05200313404202461, 0.00836509931832552, 0.006984349340200424, 0.016707411035895348, 0.01882227137684822, -0.011440379545092583, -0.007148421835154295, -0.06332726776599884, -0.06550264358520508, 0.005455919541418552, 0.008947069756686687, 0.010660005733370781, -0.02398443967103958, -0.04484741762280464, 0.09727031737565994, 0.03760555386543274, -0.01985948160290718, -0.03949635848402977, 0.041380688548088074, -0.003227562876418233, 0.008069731295108795, 0.03357025608420372, 0.0030518239364027977, 0.033622585237026215, 0.029141567647457123, -0.009771975688636303, 0.05536558851599693, 0.016677986830472946, 0.019807815551757812, -0.015416049398481846, 0.017020171508193016, -0.022833306342363358, 0.031206335872411728, 0.026413142681121826, 0.020473314449191093, 0.003906571306288242, 0.03704502433538437, -0.01135359425097704, 0.02311398647725582, 0.03967698663473129, -0.04760991781949997, 0.008745062164962292, -0.008992590010166168, 0.03922587260603905, -0.009115323424339294, 0.03260069712996483, -0.014022051356732845, 0.00572969438508153, -0.008171573281288147, -0.006199331022799015, 0.015612737275660038, -0.03835534304380417, -0.019796203821897507, 0.04410534352064133, 0.019597776234149933, -0.02447248063981533, 0.027664272114634514, -0.006086556240916252, -0.002538560191169381, 0.04072755575180054, -0.04023407772183418, -0.04336170852184296, 0.025534246116876602, 0.029340773820877075, -0.0020829499699175358, -0.004231275990605354, -0.020065972581505775, -0.012276461347937584, -0.02183341607451439, 0.04041176289319992, -0.021579673513770103, 0.03943252936005592, -0.028054427355527878, -0.018887730315327644, 0.014977054670453072, -0.030217595398426056, -0.028710035607218742, 0.016798781231045723, -0.07453454285860062, -0.004202953539788723, 0.01877192035317421, -0.03194888308644295, 0.016461249440908432, -0.03414749726653099, 0.02775736153125763, -0.004525423981249332, 0.02700948342680931, -0.025394048541784286, 0.015791041776537895, -0.0355733223259449, 0.021755116060376167, -0.022483032196760178, -0.04099341481924057, -0.0013507211115211248, 0.06926523149013519, 0.04698961228132248, -0.00569287221878767, -0.03405263274908066, -0.0011809119023382664, -0.024994617328047752, -0.017112307250499725, -0.021738234907388687, 0.028727097436785698, 0.038966741412878036, 0.019608953967690468, -0.009344794787466526, 0.004917296115309, -0.018294459208846092, -0.006316524930298328, 0.018639182671904564, 0.04335641860961914, 0.022948559373617172, -0.005049633327871561, -0.008772831410169601, -0.006528472527861595, -0.012478627264499664, -0.02053138241171837, 0.011197873391211033, 0.010269993916153908, -0.02015572413802147, 0.020403794944286346, 0.04976080358028412, -0.017942801117897034, 0.029418937861919403, 0.02780669368803501, 0.025288444012403488, 0.026585016399621964, -0.011377404443919659, 0.004997595679014921, 0.012053444050252438, -0.0028813444077968597, -0.014264765195548534, 0.003930200822651386, -0.0002195950219174847, -0.05822627618908882, 0.0384431891143322, -0.014451460912823677, -0.02870001457631588, -0.012200073339045048, 0.02430874854326248, -0.0025776405818760395, 0.005410351324826479, -0.00405400013551116, 0.03310828283429146, 0.009923188015818596, 0.02190079540014267, 0.017691507935523987, 0.027477696537971497, -0.057769060134887695, -0.014159477315843105, 0.027818983420729637, -0.0018721256637945771, -0.017808007076382637, -0.02294078841805458, -0.012559344992041588, 0.030394231900572777, 0.028968315571546555, -0.024600723758339882, 0.029046539217233658, -0.02703091688454151, 0.03869515284895897, -0.017359280958771706, -0.020742766559123993, -0.06382419914007187, 0.02150196209549904, 0.006549927406013012, 0.004362009931355715, -0.029076460748910904, -0.020459426566958427, -0.06300334632396698, -0.049817729741334915, -0.0029421213548630476, 0.05480942130088806, -0.013473954983055592, 0.0021990658715367317, 0.01084408164024353, 0.027252454310655594, -0.007800353690981865, -0.053457967936992645, 0.061522550880908966, 0.01783844269812107, -0.0213120449334383, 0.014457243494689465, -0.04133760184049606, -0.09108281135559082, 0.028767526149749756, 0.000891109521035105, -0.0359116792678833, 0.012584706768393517, -0.0049158986657857895, 0.058499403297901154, 0.05373046547174454, 0.05528832599520683, 0.06990218162536621, -0.0007915603346191347, 0.0013673362554982305, 0.006049232091754675, -0.014867521822452545, -0.058391135185956955, -0.007472256198525429, -0.04619292542338371, -0.061132341623306274, 0.014298581518232822, -0.022700602188706398, 0.041235875338315964, -0.026637012138962746, 0.04067935422062874, 0.0022762822918593884, -0.03161825239658356, 0.008443067781627178, 0.004615418612957001, -0.02944294549524784, 0.0017899662489071488, -0.02950534038245678, 0.011503876186907291, -0.006186177954077721, -0.008494916372001171, 0.031850796192884445, -0.019754065200686455, 0.0025112098082900047, 0.04868807643651962, -0.003147139446809888, 0.027396203950047493, -0.01585053652524948, -0.008232258260250092, 0.009046753868460655, -0.0383099801838398, 0.035673681646585464, -0.02610786072909832, 0.010747792199254036, -0.003649168647825718, -0.02137996442615986, -0.02205049991607666, 0.03958785533905029, -0.0005726724048145115, 0.020405640825629234, 0.0186547189950943, -0.020678767934441566, 0.016159506514668465, 0.004514188971370459, -0.10412079840898514, -0.017018917948007584, -0.002525260206311941, 0.04226187989115715, -0.0003073748084716499, -0.019905706867575645, -0.024395251646637917, 0.024215534329414368, -0.019644159823656082, 0.010702475905418396, 0.05666502192616463, -0.01441628485918045, -0.021725023165345192, -0.004853036254644394, 0.03595687076449394, 0.058960217982530594, -0.04856126010417938, 0.003497628727927804, 0.0374019555747509, -0.014086267910897732, 0.020589182153344154, -0.014596468769013882, 0.018549412488937378, -0.04627557098865509, 0.0063356258906424046, -0.04645026847720146, -0.04064731299877167, -0.014044802635908127, 0.00007433071004925296, -0.04841907322406769, 0.020809635519981384, -0.017243921756744385, 0.02389148622751236, -0.0243231188505888, -0.051247406750917435, -0.012020778842270374, 0.01931755803525448, -0.036002933979034424, -0.012149198912084103, 0.03737979382276535, 0.005725831724703312, 0.04649798944592476, 0.016067812219262123, -0.05878244712948799, 0.003439415479078889, 0.07631923258304596, -0.01021406427025795, 0.012654873542487621, -0.011651304550468922, -0.020931528881192207, 0.039754338562488556, 0.03283367678523064, -0.004470186773687601, -0.0021478983107954264, 0.026570217683911324, -0.05987553671002388, -0.00759279727935791, -0.0449824258685112, 0.026624200865626335, 0.017886478453874588, 0.020401731133461, 0.020115399733185768, 0.06165900453925133, -0.030823469161987305, -0.014084495604038239, -0.05159609392285347, 0.007132110185921192, -0.0035571474581956863, 0.015000982210040092, 0.03177471458911896, -0.029285481199622154, -0.03271837532520294, 0.08716489374637604, 0.023945963010191917, -0.011010387912392616, 0.0730232447385788, -0.00034374845563434064, 0.04986042156815529, 0.04884662479162216, -0.043248921632766724, -0.07965854555368423, 0.04612147808074951, -0.0628923699259758, 0.010541822761297226, -0.01812005415558815, -0.05044178292155266, -0.0041676852852106094, 0.016076356172561646, 0.02148446813225746, -0.057532377541065216, -0.04871995747089386, -0.07554209232330322, 0.03623243793845177, -0.0025334921665489674, -0.0023710785899311304, 0.04161641001701355, -0.0009246625704690814, 0.009183031506836414, -0.03216160088777542, 0.05410163104534149, -0.02020134963095188, -0.06277723610401154, 0.010003197938203812, -0.0311912652105093, -0.025936830788850784, 0.005132062826305628, 0.01681939698755741, -0.01492550689727068, 0.008232810534536839, -0.04599829763174057, 0.03833269327878952, 0.011227281764149666, 0.016382567584514618, -0.03625599294900894, 0.02331814356148243, -0.02935398556292057, 0.01977481320500374, -0.016521470621228218, -0.05615582689642906, 0.13457702100276947, 0.07446034997701645, 0.03445746749639511, -0.05248907953500748, 0.028439976274967194, -0.0026193824596703053, -0.010650997050106525, -0.03244677931070328, 0.0056213014759123325, 0.010323924012482166, -0.006528516300022602, 0.03142301365733147, 0.10213130712509155, -0.02598329819738865, -0.026031769812107086, 0.030873361974954605, -0.021983139216899872, 0.0014717739541083574, 0.02619810402393341, 0.011204305104911327, -0.02816622331738472, -0.030076472088694572, -0.00790062639862299, 0.029248811304569244, 0.04233693704009056, 0.0001287521590711549, -0.030624162405729294, -0.0015589026734232903, 0.00516974413767457, -0.005469575058668852, -0.0074262917041778564, 0.011651908047497272, 0.0059010060504078865, -0.01032041385769844, -0.003875922178849578, -0.007180573418736458, 0.0338592529296875, -0.058345310389995575, 0.033970754593610764, 0.03831871226429939, -0.01631830260157585, 0.011302138678729534, 0.02671896293759346, 0.014932355843484402, -0.04083504527807236, -0.023493921384215355, -0.024612752720713615, 0.0641394630074501, -0.03721531853079796, -0.03747599944472313, -0.021628065034747124, -0.02522502839565277, 0.0028188435826450586, -0.04342273995280266, -0.031233038753271103, 0.01092896331101656, 0.018368180841207504, -0.037897657603025436, -0.006252690218389034, -0.012710407376289368, -0.003224391723051667, 0.017905285581946373, 0.007887027226388454, 0.019171735271811485, -0.04345254227519035, -0.04965807870030403, -0.009231806732714176, 0.024533547461032867, 0.06408671289682388, -0.010263067670166492, -0.017691582441329956, -0.029354358091950417, 0.001171422773040831, -0.04785684868693352, 0.037882979959249496, 0.022710567340254784, 0.029598837718367577, -0.01218100544065237, -0.04008341580629349, -0.01565295271575451, -0.015442791394889355, -0.03538837656378746, -0.008307602256536484, 0.020748307928442955, -0.012276623398065567, -0.043400879949331284, 0.01861175149679184, 0.06858673691749573, 0.03152923285961151, -0.04139169305562973, 0.017925690859556198, 0.09291298687458038, 0.028628667816519737, -0.05291259288787842, -0.06436417251825333, -0.024425944313406944, -0.02275809831917286, 0.02732917293906212, -0.009487036615610123, 0.028758706524968147, 0.031450942158699036, 0.021058784797787666, 0.029529431834816933, 0.024079931899905205, -0.013813800178468227, -0.02184172347187996, -0.022316675633192062, -0.061124734580516815, -0.013408755883574486, 0.04181969165802002, 0.03762079402804375, -0.026835070922970772, -0.011420703493058681, -0.010379131883382797, -0.00730068190023303, -0.003369048237800598, -0.02045835368335247, -0.002378234174102545, -0.02399119734764099, 0.004922677297145128, 0.01272643357515335, -0.009542648680508137, -0.03523041680455208, -0.002041569910943508, -0.0042333840392529964, 0.010118708945810795, 0.012688862159848213, -0.00815479177981615, -0.02832445316016674, -0.01149079017341137, 0.037793759256601334, 0.027928398922085762, -0.010286876931786537, -0.006779640447348356, 0.0018890781793743372, 0.019980810582637787, 0.03900877758860588, 0.04846984148025513, -0.017207089811563492, 0.00003462185486569069, 0.012492431327700615, -0.03399031609296799, -0.04060113802552223, 0.04588516801595688, 0.010434973053634167, 0.016045859083533287, 0.022197499871253967, 0.008148298598825932, -0.054987963289022446, 0.03807685524225235, -0.018220778554677963, -0.018882794305682182, -0.04302119091153145, 0.045258551836013794, 0.003180001163855195, -0.01620766893029213, 0.019037770107388496, 0.01780933514237404, -0.00906185433268547, 0.026262536644935608, 0.05680380016565323, -0.019518418237566948, -0.0383572056889534, -0.03446699306368828, -0.00168409978505224, -0.004203603137284517, -0.0429757796227932, 0.004181173630058765, 0.0189967043697834, 0.033326923847198486, -0.024338213726878166, 0.02255953848361969, 0.011073625646531582, 0.02148975245654583, -0.04319444298744202, -0.05696476995944977, 0.0362461656332016, 0.02838831953704357, 0.0474415197968483, -0.06452362984418869, 0.03219747915863991, 0.03446190804243088, -0.06891212612390518, 0.007690848782658577, 0.017742488533258438, -0.009275639429688454, -0.06081121787428856, 0.002878752304241061, -0.03810106962919235, -0.03176948428153992, -0.005554491654038429, 0.03764494135975838, -0.007602054625749588, 0.04853587970137596, -0.0025350109208375216, -0.004403598606586456, 0.01034850999712944, 0.003449608338996768, -0.0020587712060660124, -0.055280253291130066, 0.04482833296060562, -0.02574148029088974, -0.024670017883181572, 0.031590670347213745, 0.021238384768366814, 0.0112681295722723, 0.023292111232876778, 0.037787433713674545, 0.022159462794661522, 0.02528126910328865, 0.031379349529743195, -0.0054295421577990055, -0.0394708588719368, 0.017248976975679398, 0.01328274141997099, 0.02122613601386547, -0.0017553947400301695, -0.028891252353787422, -0.005018905736505985, 0.015011744573712349, -0.02902963198721409, -0.015061937272548676, -0.011686556972563267, -0.009535247460007668, 0.03888968005776405, 0.025914844125509262, 0.0035101172979921103, -0.033754535019397736, 0.030294114723801613, -0.06991823017597198, -0.0006324299611151218, 0.014638697728514671, 0.033478327095508575, -0.04200821369886398, 0.012501622550189495, -0.05288558453321457, -0.05300448462367058, 0.03493807092308998, 0.01710413210093975, 0.0070156194269657135, -0.0812685415148735, -0.04132051765918732, -0.030043944716453552, -0.024339810013771057, -0.03046349063515663, -0.021209141239523888, -0.008495435118675232, 0.013903497718274593, 0.012798961251974106, 0.03488386422395706, -0.016497384756803513, -0.011856078170239925, 0.03082404099404812, -0.05807536840438843, 0.05447402596473694, 0.02925020270049572, -0.01567762903869152, -0.035057295113801956, 0.022821566089987755, -0.0549495667219162, 0.005916121881455183, 0.03832414746284485, -0.011444689705967903, 0.04400317743420601, 0.026058916002511978, 0.02213183604180813, 0.006316320039331913, -0.05923980474472046, 0.07548394799232483, 0.0018825038569048047, -0.029850712046027184, -0.014718866907060146, 0.008035104721784592, 0.01628134958446026, -0.02545843832194805, 0.02051866613328457, -0.017251543700695038, -0.01812548004090786, 0.01287421677261591, 0.012345483526587486, 0.03604341670870781, 0.042504359036684036, 0.028339095413684845, -0.01663949154317379, 0.010369769297540188, 0.035841815173625946, 0.01810343563556671, -0.044711507856845856, -0.05594347417354584, 0.012616833671927452, 0.008822607807815075, -0.016734885051846504, 0.025984616950154305, 0.0027659484185278416, -0.016165941953659058, -0.006993159186094999, 0.02543884702026844, 0.0006682425155304372, 0.048360444605350494, -0.01602710224688053, 0.0008334243320859969, -0.01460159383714199, 0.035418570041656494, 0.02005574479699135, 0.04211707413196564, -0.00306233880110085, -0.009108982980251312, 0.005177475046366453, -0.0035977549850940704, 0.017765948548913002, -0.027885649353265762, 0.01596493273973465, 0.03556617349386215, 0.018909720703959465, 0.0013718485133722425, -0.005626507569104433, 0.016884518787264824, -0.0025751336943358183, -0.013404952362179756, 0.03311178833246231, 0.02112826518714428, 0.012154554948210716, -0.03178394213318825, 0.015226547606289387, 0.060409124940633774, -0.027797028422355652, 0.01564452424645424, -0.013976920396089554, 0.025129782035946846, -0.03978433832526207, -0.023457197472453117, 0.032294243574142456, -0.010609341785311699, 0.0002970827044919133, 0.004955239128321409, -0.024684486910700798, -0.014170832931995392, 0.030774779617786407, -0.010328141041100025, 0.0015339147066697478, 0.0019363290630280972, -0.026483586058020592, 0.016681024804711342, 0.01592004857957363, -0.018665922805666924, -0.01038456056267023, 0.012769384309649467, 0.02631251886487007, 0.025786299258470535, -0.025835709646344185, -0.04308151826262474, -0.00644919415935874, 0.05575450509786606, -0.0037892782129347324, -0.05132484808564186, -0.010799375362694263, 0.017058134078979492, -0.005835700314491987, -0.013587964698672295 ]
<blockquote> <p><strong>Possible Duplicate:</strong><br> <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/12386/machine-learning-cookbook-reference-card-cheatsheet">Machine learning cookbook / reference card / cheatsheet?</a> </p> </blockquote> <p>I wonder if there is a good self-learning textbook for machine learning? I am particularly looking for those in application-level, not so much theoretical. I wouldn't mind a math-heavy book, as long as you guys think it is suitable for self-learning. </p> <p>Thanks! </p>
49,363
[ -0.03599616512656212, -0.039642322808504105, 0.00691792881116271, 0.01415430661290884, 0.00992538407444954, -0.001074697938747704, 0.009221913293004036, -0.011803473345935345, -0.006817415822297335, -0.029340039938688278, 0.038216281682252884, 0.042843930423259735, 0.025051012635231018, 0.00892204325646162, -0.0017562274588271976, 0.0010577363427728415, -0.04223134368658066, -0.005206585396081209, -0.005447403993457556, 0.04467392340302467, 0.001992295728996396, 0.012866630218923092, 0.025844277814030647, 0.004084911663085222, -0.034225817769765854, 0.021315598860383034, -0.00847668293863535, -0.013268038630485535, 0.0032061997335404158, 0.034956734627485275, -0.0509200245141983, 0.001235349802300334, 0.017702288925647736, 0.05225704237818718, 0.014568330720067024, -0.002870395313948393, 0.001202738145366311, -0.025418538600206375, -0.02498915046453476, 0.02610662579536438, -0.005088668316602707, -0.045535728335380554, -0.012129870243370533, 0.059371549636125565, -0.02240404486656189, 0.01885775849223137, -0.00987155456095934, -0.02703995257616043, 0.0037293462082743645, -0.03829377517104149, 0.08274492621421814, -0.001860600197687745, 0.019710993394255638, 0.05370478332042694, 0.019265882670879364, -0.008919285610318184, 0.034680213779211044, 0.0628555491566658, -0.012217795476317406, -0.03704608231782913, -0.020129026845097542, -0.04643912613391876, -0.008056779392063618, -0.015400982461869717, -0.04575309529900551, 0.01940598152577877, -0.017144324257969856, 0.002005776623263955, 0.0098149124532938, -0.026962867006659508, 0.016042102128267288, 0.03753754496574402, 0.01309643778949976, 0.008140172809362411, -0.050221577286720276, 0.010054577142000198, -0.02004162222146988, 0.03392144292593002, 0.040144484490156174, 0.022979818284511566, 0.014974365010857582, 0.011041967198252678, -0.009779275394976139, 0.015083321370184422, 0.04061148315668106, -0.019044656306505203, 0.06969186663627625, 0.029575655236840248, -0.01084849052131176, 0.005802009254693985, -0.0037369763012975454, -0.018758216872811317, -0.02593648061156273, -0.03712407499551773, -0.03389772027730942, 0.062005434185266495, -0.02302815206348896, 0.02424142137169838, -0.00009973195847123861, -0.033633679151535034, -0.0038974827621132135, -0.020793823525309563, -0.026734741404652596, 0.0673387348651886, -0.044120702892541885, -0.023643774911761284, -0.015012416988611221, 0.02582523040473461, 0.002472973195835948, -0.002147361868992448, -0.014834485948085785, 0.006730769760906696, 0.0030779573135077953, -0.0145970918238163, 0.03145703673362732, -0.0001660359266679734, 0.010310103185474873, -0.0043448228389024734, 0.016467424109578133, 0.07887296378612518, 0.032098688185214996, -0.04287930205464363, 0.04303470999002457, -0.02303873561322689, -0.06671677529811859, 0.014247056096792221, 0.018456682562828064, -0.017239514738321304, -0.026733247563242912, 0.027230462059378624, -0.040468014776706696, -0.03059670887887478, 0.021880796179175377, 0.03607643395662308, 0.029139209538698196, 0.006580587010830641, -0.053928110748529434, -0.05439905822277069, 0.04924508556723595, -0.06618931889533997, 0.004213100764900446, -0.011163966730237007, 0.04509853199124336, 0.03446356952190399, 0.0283628161996603, 0.04507383704185486, 0.04766460135579109, 0.022212214767932892, 0.021303987130522728, -0.01101052388548851, -0.04992618411779404, -0.006734571419656277, -0.02989385277032852, 0.014530355110764503, -0.0016428522067144513, -0.0430557057261467, 0.06128773093223572, 0.029428351670503616, 0.014077341184020042, -0.0049722082912921906, 0.02748100273311138, 0.0017538972897455096, -0.0059701865538954735, -0.009561574086546898, -0.022633137181401253, -0.024726105853915215, 0.07951893657445908, 0.014687730930745602, 0.060008805245161057, -0.006012704223394394, -0.03447393327951431, -0.01691981963813305, 0.012802437879145145, 0.015415693633258343, 0.057563237845897675, -0.0027511720545589924, -0.02644765004515648, 0.008963051252067089, 0.021647727116942406, 0.013534723781049252, -0.03285520151257515, -0.0610610768198967, -0.012952303513884544, 0.005342253018170595, -0.005474438890814781, 0.04138936102390289, 0.011032155714929104, -0.00929287914186716, 0.03291602060198784, -0.05138510465621948, -0.01978098787367344, -0.07374472171068192, 0.021361542865633965, -0.055832672864198685, 0.0029052156023681164, 0.015287283807992935, 0.002331189811229706, 0.0026080929674208164, -0.020695539191365242, -0.022272922098636627, -0.04049716889858246, 0.009860468097031116, 0.03040655516088009, -0.03653188422322273, -0.007278823759406805, 0.04502025246620178, 0.006766383070498705, -0.032127879559993744, 0.03426697105169296, -0.04701494798064232, -0.04277839884161949, 0.03655148670077324, -0.012730364687740803, 0.02325417287647724, -0.04241508990526199, 0.00566070806235075, 0.027907149866223335, 0.0073151737451553345, -0.039133429527282715, 0.006070271600037813, -0.06362081319093704, 0.04910450428724289, 0.010493420995771885, 0.0424388088285923, 0.03828077018260956, -0.005157741252332926, -0.010139571502804756, 0.028105739504098892, -0.019286412745714188, 0.03222482278943062, -0.04407114535570145, -0.015050726942718029, 0.04984269663691521, 0.01731739565730095, -0.03977426514029503, 0.024737199768424034, 0.040663570165634155, 0.05568283051252365, 0.012003366835415363, -0.012508153915405273, -0.03396276384592056, -0.018519127741456032, 0.011035245843231678, 0.005047672428190708, -0.012088271789252758, 0.02519008331000805, 0.004091466311365366, 0.016118871048092842, 0.01763666234910488, 0.06848868727684021, -0.018209492787718773, 0.015232241712510586, -0.02519860491156578, -0.04826415330171585, 0.015589856542646885, -0.04045923054218292, 0.020811064168810844, -0.017862308770418167, -0.018394049257040024, 0.0077239214442670345, -0.00143377052154392, 0.03698336333036423, -0.020035218447446823, -0.045252714306116104, -0.0031512679997831583, 0.02948945388197899, -0.026298481971025467, 0.01838710531592369, 0.024824563413858414, -0.07941265404224396, 0.03615625947713852, 0.0006944098859094083, 0.00014400220243260264, -0.00609277468174696, -0.0029202071018517017, -0.0211698766797781, -0.04073260724544525, -0.013786548748612404, -0.002275860635563731, 0.014893513172864914, 0.02790629118680954, 0.0031892466358840466, 0.03177141398191452, -0.015212262980639935, -0.049389902502298355, 0.005523512605577707, -0.0043137469328939915, -0.04051085188984871, 0.06199885532259941, 0.03561636060476303, -0.028422027826309204, 0.0023177778348326683, -0.004039707127958536, -0.06820187717676163, -0.013613918796181679, -0.025957413017749786, 0.004481648560613394, -0.01451356615871191, -0.007119244430214167, 0.007913387380540371, -0.009315483272075653, -0.05625944584608078, 0.0020021055825054646, -0.031089002266526222, -0.03783745318651199, -0.027207577601075172, 0.011135823093354702, 0.017408207058906555, -0.004202079027891159, -0.02886008843779564, 0.03164080157876015, -0.02492842823266983, -0.0009611298446543515, -0.06899399310350418, -0.035394128412008286, -0.008228877559304237, 0.004859404172748327, 0.024593252688646317, 0.041883815079927444, -0.004591285716742277, 0.04962347820401192, 0.013342897407710552, -0.05550176650285721, -0.04206160083413124, -0.016111373901367188, 0.00274009071290493, -0.03781669959425926, 0.008934946730732918, -0.005865034181624651, 0.021765580400824547, -0.037593476474285126, -0.001055399072356522, 0.00706253619864583, 0.06625661998987198, -0.0027667111717164516, 0.013924681581556797, 0.03313521295785904, 0.006297822576016188, -0.01869591698050499, 0.02418036200106144, 0.02958790771663189, -0.029842477291822433, 0.004702547565102577, 0.011490306816995144, 0.011573362164199352, 0.024885477498173714, -0.022507518529891968, 0.05626839026808739, -0.03957243636250496, 0.0029615426901727915, -0.06759786605834961, 0.043849289417266846, -0.011865007691085339, 0.0005028654704801738, 0.0113029470667243, 0.00045537587720900774, 0.001999562606215477, -0.019459888339042664, 0.048496972769498825, 0.04613419249653816, 0.0025782629381865263, -0.029482401907444, -0.010895970277488232, -0.018184687942266464, -0.012799757532775402, 0.0018102193716913462, -0.025545218959450722, 0.015745047479867935, 0.06337457150220871, 0.05248340964317322, 0.018336893990635872, 0.026365427300333977, -0.06028677150607109, 0.022700512781739235, -0.08393801003694534, -0.013966680504381657, -0.03515245392918587, 0.06538819521665573, -0.020192740485072136, 0.03598769009113312, 0.01819247379899025, -0.0029602255672216415, 0.026340296491980553, 0.00025839079171419144, -0.102984219789505, 0.010662882588803768, -0.030542833730578423, -0.004849094431847334, 0.01651933789253235, -0.007619157433509827, 0.035331808030605316, -0.004637791775166988, 0.02920992486178875, -0.014177805744111538, 0.017697513103485107, -0.013979420065879822, 0.02661324292421341, -0.029186008498072624, -0.011896498501300812, 0.0008592642261646688, 0.006252413149923086, 0.033327147364616394, -0.019260354340076447, 0.01049071829766035, 0.03728099912405014, -0.01756519265472889, -0.032534606754779816, -0.03263573721051216, 0.0019262975547462702, -0.0188067015260458, 0.02289935201406479, 0.0356372632086277, 0.04661897197365761, -0.014724686741828918, 0.006262120790779591, 0.021425552666187286, 0.0300097968429327, 0.0005294551374390721, -0.03847089782357216, -0.01336727850139141, -0.06123659759759903, -0.03960997983813286, 0.03633866459131241, 0.027895746752619743, 0.006782869808375835, 0.011002207174897194, 0.04393719881772995, 0.02205546386539936, -0.08888527750968933, 0.023765208199620247, 0.034125447273254395, -0.029085103422403336, -0.021198725327849388, -0.01334816962480545, 0.007475270424038172, -0.03414956107735634, 0.013537797145545483, 0.03802027553319931, -0.0008675626595504582, -0.014437476173043251, -0.009330610744655132, -0.02228410355746746, 0.018109118565917015, -0.009249912574887276, -0.016905061900615692, 0.05096862092614174, 0.08028499782085419, -0.01852949522435665, -0.014779092743992805, -0.0068243020214140415, 0.05208517611026764, 0.05924351140856743, 0.001051970524713397, -0.031198350712656975, -0.08739730715751648, -0.00400685565546155, 0.06136079877614975, 0.06576372683048248, -0.06097148358821869, 0.02746627666056156, -0.052667777985334396, -0.05380026251077652, 0.04531656578183174, -0.018804945051670074, 0.04286840185523033, -0.042168114334344864, -0.005020373500883579, -0.01949857920408249, -0.003469783579930663, -0.031807124614715576, 0.007236537057906389, 0.02774467132985592, 0.05138677731156349, -0.034363314509391785, -0.024786509573459625, -0.03438957780599594, -0.015493916347622871, 0.0012345672585070133, 0.07546930015087128, -0.02113913930952549, 0.020053215324878693, 0.005368254613131285, 0.01610913872718811, -0.013123027980327606, -0.0580533929169178, -0.017563581466674805, 0.010289226658642292, -0.006436297204345465, 0.012531728483736515, -0.010312190279364586, -0.09485822170972824, 0.03015005961060524, 0.021967748180031776, -0.05809873715043068, -0.025573955848813057, -0.02696552500128746, -0.017789997160434723, 0.01703372411429882, 0.0008820625371299684, 0.06272217631340027, 0.016985764726996422, -0.005259539932012558, 0.029727671295404434, -0.0012192841386422515, 0.028039632365107536, -0.04111912474036217, -0.04611605778336525, -0.03519885614514351, -0.05167531222105026, -0.06020854413509369, 0.023447463288903236, -0.013321666046977043, 0.019284358248114586, -0.05721868574619293, -0.01765773817896843, 0.005798388738185167, 0.052143871784210205, 0.009954621084034443, 0.0037259934470057487, 0.039425551891326904, 0.028831537812948227, -0.016075102612376213, 0.009033124893903732, 0.030518002808094025, -0.02538396418094635, -0.0071637569926679134, 0.0021783916745334864, -0.03048313967883587, 0.00039319833740592003, -0.07436322420835495, -0.02986302226781845, -0.007420786190778017, -0.017193088307976723, 0.06138446927070618, 0.021669162437319756, 0.028411244973540306, -0.0015275831101462245, -0.07174448668956757, -0.013491651974618435, -0.0014289695536717772, 0.03003871627151966, 0.02111506648361683, -0.02982378751039505, -0.001854010857641697, 0.0014231828972697258, -0.03476311266422272, -0.06190582364797592, -0.03795669972896576, -0.014914961531758308, 0.0029810238629579544, -0.06292176246643066, -0.04185101389884949, 0.0481693409383297, 0.0048746271058917046, -0.037443116307258606, -0.037474147975444794, 0.04804874211549759, 0.0057168640196323395, 0.004814760759472847, 0.0104594761505723, -0.01750122755765915, 0.029055166989564896, 0.03963939845561981, 0.01012159138917923, -0.020114082843065262, -0.025515753775835037, -0.01832534372806549, -0.0109561150893569, 0.018404362723231316, -0.016859423369169235, 0.0005381929222494364, -0.04191390052437782, 0.028791295364499092, 0.06606484204530716, -0.03111734427511692, 0.02059713378548622, 0.012095430865883827, 0.003293282352387905, -0.04944080486893654, -0.028635872527956963, 0.002001183805987239, 0.01976378634572029, 0.01043104287236929, -0.007356587331742048, -0.008622861467301846, -0.008308502845466137, 0.007685230579227209, 0.008669130504131317, 0.004591509699821472, 0.008570583537220955, 0.012148155830800533, 0.06458623707294464, -0.0330975167453289, 0.017961909994482994, -0.004036808852106333, -0.019106535241007805, 0.035334788262844086, -0.009322099387645721, 0.021149571985006332, 0.026814648881554604, -0.006269358564168215, -0.04038528352975845, -0.03397300839424133, -0.03819803148508072, 0.002257579704746604, 0.053912453353405, 0.019648322835564613, 0.03028380312025547, 0.03379497677087784, -0.005730728153139353, 0.012102807871997356, -0.02290314808487892, -0.02245238423347473, 0.013190504163503647, 0.02701588347554207, 0.053710054606199265, -0.002521676477044821, 0.01664656214416027, 0.036359790712594986, 0.014215822331607342, 0.019995996728539467, 0.033827025443315506, 0.017725512385368347, 0.02907642535865307, 0.04719306528568268, -0.06392902880907059, -0.03156881779432297, 0.053057048469781876, -0.06719402968883514, 0.0004341891035437584, -0.025145217776298523, -0.02036955952644348, 0.04412616416811943, 0.024543384090065956, 0.03191402554512024, -0.02906961739063263, -0.015530736185610294, -0.04192844778299332, 0.03242283686995506, 0.009452342987060547, 0.026063097640872, 0.021640926599502563, 0.020328564569354057, -0.0017249315278604627, -0.01886126585304737, 0.025286855176091194, -0.01008343230932951, -0.08742764592170715, -0.031031077727675438, 0.011439495719969273, -0.03797518461942673, 0.018480807542800903, 0.013953479938209057, -0.05327347666025162, 0.02591763809323311, -0.04309092089533806, 0.05142154172062874, 0.03020569495856762, 0.04088886082172394, -0.01805661804974079, 0.03935658931732178, -0.03945865109562874, 0.009439011104404926, -0.003575533628463745, -0.030216442421078682, 0.11293064057826996, 0.0728399008512497, 0.02537422440946102, -0.13150939345359802, 0.014314595609903336, -0.003627221565693617, -0.0136302774772048, -0.05128218233585358, -0.008625454269349575, 0.013763092458248138, 0.008123653940856457, 0.024114735424518585, 0.041975945234298706, -0.004807724617421627, -0.01301583182066679, 0.030597776174545288, 0.00327809969894588, -0.003111894940957427, -0.01361740194261074, 0.0045262291096150875, 0.0028503630310297012, 0.0003087512741331011, -0.05524168536067009, 0.007124247960746288, 0.00884793046861887, -0.01439425628632307, -0.027815327048301697, -0.03103860281407833, 0.024115657433867455, 0.014728954061865807, 0.009103291667997837, -0.037698473781347275, -0.005098547320812941, 0.03440980240702629, 0.024013929069042206, -0.009225782938301563, -0.010389292612671852, -0.003991186618804932, 0.03632402420043945, 0.009915581904351711, 0.04403628781437874, -0.014861762523651123, 0.017800772562623024, 0.0030104322358965874, -0.056947026401758194, -0.03613153472542763, -0.05964191257953644, 0.025776907801628113, -0.032300543040037155, -0.011175062507390976, -0.0031607262790203094, 0.020989613607525826, 0.013440337963402271, -0.022842152044177055, 0.009753976948559284, 0.02186090685427189, 0.05643632262945175, -0.012385397218167782, -0.029290704056620598, -0.03211809694766998, 0.024037033319473267, -0.01688225567340851, 0.009761706925928593, 0.01398357655853033, -0.04137888550758362, -0.014030518010258675, -0.033402711153030396, 0.003531498135998845, 0.0516621395945549, 0.014508250169456005, -0.0005344814853742719, -0.012751269154250622, 0.003973622340708971, -0.019176004454493523, 0.036304593086242676, -0.015957072377204895, 0.043505143374204636, 0.005502892192453146, -0.0010290245991200209, 0.026095803827047348, -0.061157066375017166, 0.025354579091072083, -0.02656356245279312, 0.01674804463982582, -0.026722172275185585, 0.0017536693485453725, 0.012699476443231106, 0.03932745009660721, 0.055715885013341904, 0.018303116783499718, 0.02192818559706211, 0.01522284746170044, -0.004519096575677395, -0.029326800256967545, -0.01230703853070736, -0.019320663064718246, -0.04561007767915726, 0.01815982162952423, 0.00042217844747938216, 0.06071991100907326, 0.056554198265075684, 0.0250942874699831, 0.006031467113643885, -0.0200762040913105, -0.0024084895849227905, 0.01019289530813694, -0.006053331773728132, -0.037813205271959305, -0.02638472057878971, 0.029109837487339973, 0.005981222726404667, -0.0316515676677227, -0.04439385607838631, -0.0042200954630970955, 0.0026791677810251713, -0.001982213230803609, 0.03878961130976677, -0.04296024516224861, 0.026643870398402214, 0.020506519824266434, 0.007447036448866129, -0.006875405553728342, 0.0005618315190076828, -0.034226395189762115, -0.020070480182766914, 0.011816897429525852, -0.039460863918066025, -0.012684253044426441, 0.011578919366002083, -0.0066637336276471615, 0.04149662330746651, 0.019986078143119812, 0.00197666697204113, 0.01226730551570654, 0.026225974783301353, 0.018601302057504654, -0.04563938453793526, 0.05413517728447914, -0.05343876779079437, 0.029981549829244614, 0.05557256564497948, -0.059326302260160446, -0.0516725555062294, 0.017993643879890442, -0.008439759723842144, 0.037749066948890686, 0.01338336430490017, -0.004664015024900436, 0.013456025160849094, 0.04027023911476135, -0.006268757861107588, -0.0010721137514337897, -0.00946025550365448, 0.006668797694146633, 0.0016889461548998952, 0.02746405266225338, 0.02361306920647621, -0.01053618360310793, -0.021914446726441383, -0.0020481206011027098, 0.04872964695096016, 0.06336531043052673, -0.018643351271748543, 0.04133845865726471, -0.004830340854823589, 0.009595494717359543, -0.012415681965649128, 0.018137803301215172, 0.029847748577594757, 0.009275315329432487, 0.004321083426475525, 0.039809852838516235, 0.010740240104496479, -0.006158534903079271, -0.11546783149242401, -0.005323969293385744, 0.029655614867806435, 0.04753006249666214, 0.014300658367574215, -0.057995088398456573, 0.018344949930906296, 0.04133144021034241, -0.05331768840551376, 0.030011199414730072, 0.008977922610938549, -0.02957196533679962, -0.013894758187234402, -0.00005517456156667322, 0.00884597934782505, 0.006394796539098024, 0.028774451464414597, 0.03113057091832161, 0.03890763968229294, 0.023198073729872704, -0.023878563195466995, -0.033213090151548386, -0.028042545542120934, 0.03222627565264702, -0.003397605614736676, -0.06216108053922653, 0.01310604065656662, -0.021393712610006332, -0.05703617259860039, 0.01737418957054615, -0.02758605033159256, 0.042857393622398376, 0.029384709894657135, 0.034846775233745575, -0.01980774663388729, 0.05706790089607239, 0.04635018855333328, -0.008439567871391773, 0.03246421739459038, -0.0019927704706788063, 0.00014897235087119043, 0.01724267192184925, -0.018578125163912773, 0.017727136611938477, 0.004056223668158054, -0.01607537642121315, -0.056225866079330444, 0.0391523502767086, -0.005965137854218483, -0.04731500521302223, -0.0021641873754560947, 0.004647170193493366, 0.009897029027342796, -0.038520678877830505, -0.0003397589025553316, -0.04871061071753502, 0.018216677010059357, 0.030751118436455727, 0.006917033810168505, 0.005391637794673443, 0.005351410713046789, 0.018594974651932716, -0.025215333327651024, 0.028652353212237358, 0.03278714418411255, -0.000525454233866185, -0.035680439323186874, 0.017512746155261993, 0.03962778300046921, 0.0172838494181633, -0.03369072824716568, 0.004423648118972778, 0.006453839596360922, 0.02659860998392105, -0.002635156037285924, 0.029314646497368813, 0.03611917421221733, -0.017501231282949448, 0.0029232827946543694, -0.04728013649582863, 0.037431441247463226, 0.02464323118329048, 0.0028931093402206898, -0.015338647179305553, 0.004036298021674156, -0.00225210003554821, -0.021298060193657875, 0.044880371540784836, -0.01661779172718525, 0.017052482813596725, -0.04007251560688019, 0.028974412009119987, 0.018398171290755272, -0.01712549664080143, 0.04052005335688591, -0.013708512298762798, -0.021295538172125816, -0.012407861649990082, -0.015271473675966263, -0.0005139237619005144, -0.00007514902972616255, 0.00943334773182869, 0.0218304842710495, -0.018805380910634995, 0.01162208616733551, 0.013276170007884502, 0.028613226488232613, 0.0511128231883049, 0.02835865318775177, 0.03369779884815216, -0.009963041171431541, 0.0016124757239595056, 0.05517541244626045, -0.031076133251190186, -0.039273593574762344, -0.009670303203165531, -0.02009953372180462, -0.04214579239487648, -0.004465815145522356, 0.03455715626478195, 0.01656135730445385, -0.05259193480014801, 0.017586590722203255, 0.0548124834895134, -0.0033171188551932573, -0.0033105805050581694, 0.005131857004016638, 0.008511642925441265, 0.06388387084007263, 0.009689053520560265, -0.0013353587128221989, 0.017924435436725616, -0.020773565396666527, -0.008796319365501404, -0.008672378957271576, 0.038149137049913406, -0.0012907839845865965, 0.04440554603934288, 0.035375867038965225, 0.011129163205623627, 0.00012227018305566162, -0.025923240929841995, 0.022566938772797585, -0.015609105117619038, -0.011237130500376225, 0.01293942704796791, -0.011178703978657722, -0.019984688609838486, 0.008126833476126194, -0.0034885676577687263, 0.06969423592090607, -0.035577911883592606, 0.022491304203867912, -0.03364219516515732, -0.0005753947771154344, -0.04233353212475777, -0.001631624181754887, -0.018306370824575424, 0.03327682614326477, 0.009246783331036568, 0.03401739150285721, 0.043875277042388916, -0.010194974951446056, 0.038840293884277344, -0.017429379746317863, 0.04101723060011864, -0.002424143021926284, 0.004775774199515581, -0.037875737994909286, -0.007663256023079157, -0.017060816287994385, -0.00738239660859108, 0.027894752100110054, 0.05024513602256775, 0.026061395183205605, -0.0283720251172781, -0.0001482918596593663, -0.02478802762925625, 0.03969445079565048, -0.08779758960008621, 0.027085574343800545, -0.05755271390080452, -0.015476374886929989, -0.027222832664847374, -0.00108764274045825 ]
<p>I have a database of users with a field of the last time they logged in. Would this kind of data be considered "censored", and if so is there anything I can do with it beyond a histogram/density of how many people logged in within the last month, two months, etc? (To be clear: I only know the last time they logged in, so they could have logged in every day for years, up until a week ago, and all I know is they haven't logged in since last week.)</p> <p>It feels to me that this is censored data, but in a reverse sort of way from the definitions I read online. But perhaps this is just left-censored data? Or is this some kind of logit problem?</p> <p>For now, all I'm able to say is the percentage of users who have logged in during the last month, two months, etc, but I know people will want to hear more than that, and I also fear that it's easy to misinterpret what this data means. (It feels very particular, like explaining a confidence interval.) Ultimately, I may have to (manually) dump the data on a weekly basis to be able to take it any farther.</p> <p>Any references appreciated.</p>
35,775
[ -0.052431076765060425, -0.03915437310934067, 0.03357087820768356, 0.020029155537486076, 0.029749663546681404, 0.011468928307294846, 0.0029001731891185045, -0.019483311101794243, -0.01543383952230215, -0.01818750612437725, 0.023025861009955406, 0.03520263731479645, 0.01196974702179432, 0.04328051581978798, 0.05005502328276634, -0.004668631125241518, -0.019594063982367516, 0.005967732518911362, 0.0024925183970481157, -0.004083414562046528, -0.00814987625926733, 0.0413612462580204, -0.0342821329832077, -0.003906845115125179, -0.056446485221385956, 0.006039976608008146, -0.007714003324508667, -0.014234648086130619, 0.030529707670211792, 0.07707659155130386, -0.009045302867889404, -0.05140257626771927, 0.013604730367660522, 0.01944033056497574, 0.02915251813828945, 0.0032880038488656282, -0.05491607263684273, -0.03602548688650131, -0.0024296899791806936, 0.043151430785655975, -0.042181842029094696, -0.019569039344787598, -0.009825924411416054, 0.03284779563546181, -0.02217271365225315, -0.017394764348864555, -0.016735011711716652, 0.0028675186913460493, 0.03831399232149124, -0.024230822920799255, 0.07488951086997986, -0.03552533686161041, 0.04880737513303757, -0.0028479304164648056, -0.014466045424342155, 0.0196228064596653, 0.04408134147524834, 0.06644823402166367, 0.0015772375045344234, -0.05995224788784981, -0.02286149188876152, -0.018431132659316063, -0.015365490689873695, 0.013074875809252262, -0.008680650033056736, 0.0356934554874897, -0.01795513741672039, -0.020982107147574425, 0.03599705547094345, -0.01377679780125618, 0.01878477819263935, 0.019973790273070335, 0.04044567048549652, 0.012941768392920494, 0.021143194288015366, -0.047989245504140854, 0.016665834933519363, 0.011035832576453686, 0.0285427737981081, 0.0010567994322627783, -0.014872642233967781, 0.008840035647153854, 0.03670499473810196, 0.03203165531158447, 0.001410092692822218, 0.01339326985180378, 0.09669598191976547, -0.07165922224521637, 0.013421781361103058, 0.025687910616397858, -0.04971984773874283, -0.018035419285297394, -0.009045816026628017, 0.02390418015420437, -0.0901789516210556, 0.03486521169543266, -0.004111928399652243, 0.0483044795691967, -0.013125363737344742, -0.003418007865548134, 0.003327859565615654, -0.022178571671247482, 0.012061618268489838, 0.0156815554946661, -0.04793119430541992, -0.007200399413704872, -0.02385660447180271, -0.008183561265468597, -0.022608648985624313, -0.04382017254829407, -0.029459601268172264, 0.010361354798078537, 0.03806367143988609, 0.016832659021019936, 0.025695959106087685, 0.00598863884806633, -0.017769115045666695, -0.029184238985180855, 0.04924611374735832, 0.03192487731575966, 0.03765300288796425, -0.020060621201992035, 0.028077419847249985, -0.03813287243247032, -0.058139290660619736, 0.026695920154452324, 0.011121449060738087, -0.0267972182482481, -0.06844282150268555, 0.0380379781126976, -0.024836784228682518, -0.06148137152194977, 0.06026738882064819, -0.01015622541308403, 0.045045603066682816, 0.0036106903571635485, -0.09086349606513977, -0.05815054848790169, 0.041220106184482574, 0.010993987321853638, -0.009388105943799019, -0.06949708610773087, 0.015301608480513096, 0.014088883996009827, 0.03041585348546505, 0.024654123932123184, 0.022179225459694862, -0.036152053624391556, 0.014120396226644516, 0.011280057951807976, -0.019007880240678787, -0.013194967061281204, -0.0023829075507819653, -0.022204866632819176, -0.040616631507873535, -0.05110330507159233, 0.02562045119702816, 0.045707203447818756, 0.00036563118919730186, -0.01988685503602028, 0.046114787459373474, 0.018898632377386093, -0.027611462399363518, 0.00523925106972456, -0.0070884558372199535, -0.06174702197313309, 0.08703940361738205, 0.002926710294559598, 0.028087107464671135, 0.01616438291966915, 0.011641391552984715, 0.05365363508462906, 0.03434005752205849, 0.034744732081890106, 0.03861118108034134, -0.0290219709277153, -0.009578927420079708, -0.04494785889983177, 0.01879994384944439, 0.011053184978663921, -0.027968639507889748, 0.01476408913731575, -0.02582704834640026, -0.001730760675854981, 0.02905307710170746, 0.0038209320046007633, 0.017876798287034035, -0.07566329091787338, 0.025532452389597893, -0.04764755442738533, -0.022612277418375015, -0.05479586124420166, -0.015688935294747353, -0.01540279295295477, 0.001279944321140647, 0.021424444392323494, 0.01559081207960844, 0.03456384688615799, -0.05109909176826477, -0.050051379948854446, 0.009235748089849949, -0.025019343942403793, 0.04138154163956642, -0.0778360664844513, -0.02137807011604309, 0.025770986452698708, 0.0141452020034194, 0.0036403313279151917, 0.05465376004576683, -0.0466744601726532, -0.061381492763757706, -0.03249184787273407, -0.032972339540719986, 0.03225366771221161, -0.020366983488202095, -0.012057903222739697, 0.014811051078140736, -0.0005190439987927675, -0.02962557040154934, 0.011370924301445484, -0.03660494089126587, 0.039929796010255814, 0.02956140972673893, -0.019187556579709053, -0.02305605076253414, -0.008082814514636993, 0.02186223864555359, -0.008345339447259903, -0.025867467746138573, -0.04756459593772888, -0.05744856968522072, -0.0071572111919522285, 0.06322473287582397, -0.016791684553027153, 0.012190538458526134, 0.006439498625695705, 0.04308668151497841, 0.02879788726568222, 0.017461014911532402, 0.016340715810656548, -0.02686356008052826, 0.02496611326932907, -0.014736516401171684, -0.013209753669798374, 0.012483133003115654, 0.012268233112990856, -0.007753568235784769, 0.003216686425730586, 0.018856815993785858, 0.019344432279467583, 0.00746711203828454, 0.03886779770255089, 0.016613315790891647, -0.001241496647708118, -0.004275111015886068, -0.027292752638459206, 0.061150092631578445, -0.06162713095545769, 0.013011367991566658, -0.023572755977511406, -0.0205784160643816, 0.00851413793861866, 0.009431547485291958, -0.009640734642744064, 0.020467102527618408, 0.0827755406498909, -0.043735913932323456, -0.004797220230102539, 0.023963846266269684, 0.025728600099682808, -0.009627108462154865, -0.021776871755719185, -0.0435820110142231, -0.010538282804191113, -0.009774407371878624, 0.04879990592598915, -0.00001735127079882659, 0.05479962006211281, -0.028499703854322433, -0.03708057850599289, -0.0054563735611736774, -0.033066581934690475, 0.02588668279349804, 0.010601342655718327, -0.04860742390155792, -0.011836257763206959, 0.0551038458943367, -0.011788486503064632, 0.008128030225634575, -0.027996310964226723, -0.005225387401878834, 0.026967840269207954, -0.031093670055270195, -0.02774345874786377, -0.03665006905794144, -0.0267239511013031, 0.0008339445339515805, -0.014160429127514362, -0.030183134600520134, 0.05342016741633415, -0.00586522975936532, -0.01326771080493927, 0.002449949737638235, -0.04546602815389633, -0.036244649440050125, -0.07927806675434113, -0.0005340860225260258, 0.03305569291114807, -0.017953937873244286, -0.01718146912753582, 0.014622705988585949, -0.023117350414395332, -0.012024195864796638, -0.03324902430176735, -0.07170221209526062, 0.047047119587659836, -0.0386463962495327, 0.006496124900877476, 0.019866378977894783, -0.009658231399953365, 0.08966922760009766, 0.034161824733018875, -0.019447047263383865, 0.00003596278838813305, -0.04760374501347542, -0.0005883274716325104, -0.02130853943526745, -0.0005279056495055556, -0.015289903618395329, 0.0065426272340118885, 0.010615714825689793, -0.01204544398933649, 0.03623201698064804, 0.02427726984024048, 0.012042040005326271, -0.008999180980026722, 0.04376255348324776, 0.019670037552714348, -0.001901986077427864, 0.023175330832600594, 0.03395207226276398, -0.03100171685218811, 0.006620319560170174, -0.0221994798630476, 0.06205206736922264, 0.03053373470902443, -0.04470430314540863, 0.03536449000239372, -0.004385723266750574, 0.02112039364874363, 0.014805245213210583, 0.03365809842944145, -0.0024149958044290543, -0.0036022881977260113, 0.0006284398841671646, -0.00762468995526433, -0.0055288043804466724, -0.01616659387946129, 0.02541681006550789, 0.053507786244153976, 0.06580718606710434, -0.013776574283838272, -0.0017313776770606637, 0.015094009228050709, -0.032388824969530106, 0.028106436133384705, -0.020940111950039864, -0.01802666485309601, 0.062038712203502655, 0.03072594664990902, 0.008972090668976307, -0.03346965089440346, -0.03577253222465515, -0.021130895242094994, -0.07286937534809113, 0.044632744044065475, -0.006534417159855366, 0.05045507475733757, -0.01774010621011257, 0.018377352505922318, 0.025823447853326797, -0.003955606836825609, 0.01843118667602539, 0.06247946247458458, -0.02310006134212017, -0.017557183280587196, -0.015502415597438812, 0.0015524574555456638, 0.0013428842648863792, -0.02197960577905178, 0.06960157305002213, -0.01210242323577404, -0.04562573507428169, 0.0012301094830036163, 0.012904269620776176, -0.031388942152261734, -0.009654668159782887, -0.04866735637187958, -0.00039367322460748255, -0.008296553045511246, 0.011967671103775501, 0.01969061978161335, 0.03166884928941727, 0.031693022698163986, 0.03448067605495453, 0.03660731762647629, -0.019379228353500366, -0.009816162288188934, -0.02493607997894287, 0.045404572039842606, 0.030496887862682343, 0.009675445966422558, -0.005553164053708315, -0.038061995059251785, 0.04906759783625603, -0.00708960322663188, 0.03770490735769272, 0.013758908957242966, 0.0069495914503932, -0.0029789127875119448, -0.04575725272297859, -0.02212712913751602, 0.025896016508340836, 0.009370655752718449, 0.00280205300077796, 0.03957071527838707, 0.04553934186697006, 0.021074598655104637, -0.08050228655338287, 0.007419928442686796, 0.0653228908777237, 0.012396304868161678, 0.016371851786971092, -0.008910390548408031, -0.02272328920662403, 0.026813575997948647, 0.005820628721266985, -0.017501797527074814, 0.037781812250614166, 0.02342936582863331, -0.0020248861983418465, 0.012182187288999557, -0.014071783982217312, -0.04156075790524483, 0.025552522391080856, 0.013323112390935421, 0.026646409183740616, -0.024084238335490227, -0.015168216079473495, 0.0658879205584526, 0.007373009342700243, 0.03533823788166046, 0.04984907805919647, 0.049879323691129684, -0.08805285394191742, 0.005772906821221113, 0.052568547427654266, 0.020658688619732857, 0.005158343818038702, -0.017961541190743446, -0.02721196785569191, -0.01140034943819046, 0.022833775728940964, -0.021085157990455627, 0.03408494591712952, -0.0011783253867179155, 0.0059755598194897175, -0.013267885893583298, -0.03234264254570007, -0.002453751163557172, 0.00818751472979784, -0.02104327082633972, 0.033357977867126465, -0.0031508186366409063, -0.03717014566063881, -0.05663890764117241, 0.023561902344226837, 0.0030680738855153322, 0.06932759284973145, 0.026640625670552254, -0.024279503151774406, 0.010343300178647041, 0.01767539046704769, -0.021414654329419136, -0.0662497729063034, -0.009071681648492813, 0.01966630481183529, 0.002901822328567505, 0.04457174614071846, 0.002963655861094594, -0.01280349213629961, -0.003843428334221244, 0.014627053402364254, -0.02172650210559368, 0.014544534496963024, -0.04256575182080269, 0.053311172872781754, 0.004893158562481403, 0.010249175131320953, 0.05831974744796753, 0.06907761842012405, 0.024285046383738518, 0.022448524832725525, -0.03888658806681633, 0.022873658686876297, -0.02586393617093563, 0.02152014896273613, -0.05338560789823532, -0.01657198928296566, -0.05601765960454941, 0.00007024608930805698, 0.01152943167835474, 0.013124200515449047, -0.030282268300652504, -0.02023903839290142, 0.023237211629748344, -0.010777946561574936, -0.0038319979794323444, 0.00443877512589097, 0.00024102204770315439, 0.010950082913041115, -0.01827850565314293, -0.011213690042495728, 0.0021621629130095243, -0.029415838420391083, -0.027464644983410835, -0.003248470602557063, -0.04526001214981079, 0.006103071384131908, 0.014283228665590286, -0.041373614221811295, 0.044041506946086884, -0.0398833230137825, 0.035545267164707184, -0.034074630588293076, -0.007897992618381977, -0.010348447598516941, -0.018760498613119125, 0.028224045410752296, 0.0038882666267454624, -0.012287220917642117, 0.0536629855632782, -0.026590781286358833, 0.04649295657873154, -0.027587464079260826, -0.006004885770380497, -0.0757417231798172, -0.028661580756306648, 0.04398007318377495, 0.00957323145121336, -0.04831928014755249, -0.043799933046102524, 0.0018694319296628237, -0.015539124608039856, -0.018447792157530785, 0.026074308902025223, 0.03292699530720711, -0.008297761902213097, 0.00930248573422432, -0.0015859350096434355, 0.03157907351851463, 0.06996804475784302, -0.008072663098573685, -0.01601307839155197, 0.024654818698763847, 0.011579073034226894, -0.015060009434819221, 0.009364231489598751, 0.001027601072564721, -0.02771603874862194, 0.002473704516887665, -0.025561703369021416, 0.0003036761190742254, 0.02828923799097538, -0.03615490347146988, -0.008683763444423676, 0.018840286880731583, -0.006159499287605286, 0.02836497686803341, 0.00026959064416587353, 0.02967057377099991, -0.020820816978812218, -0.003323871176689863, -0.037855714559555054, -0.0037566146347671747, -0.0044692521914839745, 0.029302915558218956, 0.05539025366306305, 0.0006220117793418467, -0.00882833544164896, 0.011631796136498451, 0.054891739040613174, -0.009673269465565681, -0.004311255645006895, -0.011688568629324436, -0.026788022369146347, 0.027779947966337204, 0.016321182250976562, 0.0006972102564759552, 0.03218648210167885, -0.007077986374497414, -0.07010107487440109, -0.03560888022184372, -0.037836480885744095, -0.03504112362861633, 0.05748002603650093, -0.01536637730896473, 0.03184101730585098, 0.03276469185948372, -0.002131845336407423, 0.023971129208803177, -0.032984115183353424, -0.017392504960298538, -0.005096090957522392, -0.00551627017557621, 0.022768914699554443, -0.03168328478932381, -0.0032144703436642885, -0.005008723586797714, -0.01623871549963951, 0.006459056865423918, 0.07384172827005386, 0.0345124676823616, 0.018191948533058167, 0.023226043209433556, -0.0051514762453734875, -0.03013022243976593, 0.027915790677070618, -0.0472862683236599, 0.003503416432067752, -0.012014715000987053, -0.01931576244533062, 0.021997809410095215, -0.005205471534281969, -0.0002076996461255476, -0.03411085531115532, -0.029915228486061096, -0.054768405854701996, -0.015302516520023346, 0.021632760763168335, 0.0032815085723996162, 0.027192823588848114, -0.0332840196788311, 0.04619145020842552, -0.020850861445069313, -0.008527081459760666, 0.01253250241279602, -0.0450856015086174, 0.00605371780693531, -0.028492208570241928, -0.08120319247245789, 0.006990666966885328, 0.02075813151896, -0.010825805366039276, -0.015323486179113388, -0.04908251017332077, -0.016664758324623108, 0.009790284559130669, 0.06207694858312607, 0.01987910084426403, 0.06323974579572678, 0.033382680267095566, 0.014805389568209648, -0.008957928977906704, -0.014951854944229126, 0.11267302930355072, 0.08696038275957108, 0.0280167069286108, -0.05113315209746361, 0.009092750959098339, 0.009780368767678738, 0.02476409077644348, -0.017053568735718727, -0.01614130660891533, -0.024548647925257683, 0.0024586168583482504, 0.06182922422885895, 0.03272314742207527, -0.003337526461109519, 0.013861512765288353, 0.09503237903118134, -0.011892681941390038, 0.0003419452696107328, 0.01571306772530079, 0.013491441495716572, -0.011609130539000034, -0.020235290750861168, -0.06855648756027222, -0.011595123447477818, 0.060919348150491714, -0.017549950629472733, 0.022324178367853165, -0.008099417202174664, 0.005521019455045462, -0.0008510993211530149, -0.019658202305436134, 0.01619115099310875, 0.008976193144917488, 0.007621369324624538, -0.00729197496548295, -0.04763267561793327, 0.013981024734675884, -0.0014377802144736052, -0.010394781827926636, 0.04273860156536102, 0.0030562749598175287, -0.009984225034713745, -0.004344149958342314, 0.03200870379805565, -0.02358919195830822, -0.04443522170186043, -0.024211371317505836, 0.025429444387555122, -0.010090941563248634, -0.006094682030379772, -0.0028905856888741255, -0.03483298048377037, -0.00852676760405302, 0.0012758030788972974, -0.010601975955069065, 0.02888699807226658, 0.015532959252595901, -0.011674955487251282, -0.005412640981376171, -0.0169307179749012, 0.006976134609431028, -0.04831075668334961, 0.022247690707445145, 0.04891740903258324, -0.03159470111131668, -0.007751053664833307, -0.03261089697480202, 0.016331374645233154, -0.0008745207451283932, 0.005013948772102594, -0.0031717417296022177, -0.024739263579249382, -0.004947198089212179, 0.01429751981049776, 0.003637128509581089, -0.0054827360436320305, 0.02483541890978813, -0.005258331075310707, 0.022988615557551384, -0.027328871190547943, -0.026881439611315727, 0.04836414009332657, 0.003411730518564582, -0.031266093254089355, -0.043945666402578354, 0.011789361014962196, 0.02358769066631794, 0.031578801572322845, -0.0026394014712423086, 0.015097002498805523, -0.007224459666758776, 0.014437374658882618, 0.04400590807199478, -0.04016350209712982, -0.008300947025418282, 0.021733706817030907, -0.0602305643260479, -0.004166807979345322, -0.023418279364705086, 0.06212352216243744, 0.02804630994796753, -0.005871430970728397, 0.019646475091576576, -0.014446171000599861, 0.02357005886733532, 0.004603456240147352, 0.009815710596740246, -0.07891592383384705, -0.027611898258328438, -0.0033491039648652077, 0.012401184998452663, -0.012112101539969444, -0.04737185686826706, -0.05845455080270767, -0.003933447413146496, 0.011742182075977325, 0.013604110106825829, -0.01688527874648571, -0.002964629326015711, 0.012437178753316402, -0.010492623783648014, -0.009910084307193756, -0.014393780380487442, -0.07013871520757675, -0.05399927496910095, -0.006414092145860195, 0.0012615268351510167, -0.011582871899008751, 0.0004605731519404799, 0.030635053291916847, 0.017826056107878685, 0.03820407763123512, -0.014150235801935196, -0.009411116130650043, 0.00936607550829649, 0.04410434141755104, 0.023151328787207603, 0.04681966081261635, -0.0066339983604848385, -0.02764943428337574, 0.06687725335359573, -0.020413704216480255, -0.055294219404459, 0.03409557789564133, 0.016869744285941124, 0.019215242937207222, 0.0037462092004716396, -0.014179697260260582, -0.011961780488491058, 0.05785861983895302, -0.026634082198143005, -0.04803786426782608, -0.044134948402643204, -0.003039567032828927, 0.030533980578184128, 0.012613512575626373, 0.0038394888397306204, 0.0265831109136343, 0.004317270126193762, 0.0024990474339574575, 0.049922484904527664, 0.018316887319087982, 0.0011671873508021235, -0.03272680938243866, 0.04825415089726448, 0.017920101061463356, -0.001652799895964563, -0.010107738897204399, 0.045727431774139404, 0.02984359674155712, -0.030600206926465034, 0.04507061466574669, 0.03348561003804207, -0.0052372366189956665, -0.06606743484735489, -0.0032002204097807407, 0.002558391774073243, 0.036862459033727646, 0.014412885531783104, -0.05785587802529335, -0.020756039768457413, 0.0016927553806453943, -0.028894132003188133, 0.0211101695895195, -0.0016400975873693824, 0.008829248137772083, -0.04029848799109459, 0.013084891252219677, -0.01470994483679533, 0.02049795538187027, 0.0034105342347174883, 0.038931768387556076, -0.0053029609844088554, 0.04176168516278267, -0.009779855608940125, -0.046718042343854904, -0.018658755347132683, 0.028333785012364388, 0.030404066666960716, -0.03479306027293205, 0.06365646421909332, -0.04901792109012604, -0.020723840221762657, 0.06666019558906555, -0.025991709902882576, 0.037151411175727844, 0.031673166900873184, 0.02801929973065853, 0.007825646549463272, 0.03775923699140549, 0.05951753631234169, -0.02362961322069168, -0.041557878255844116, 0.014154392294585705, 0.010540328919887543, 0.05015619471669197, -0.014605612494051456, 0.022176498547196388, 0.009694918058812618, -0.03106900304555893, -0.021610338240861893, 0.012050779536366463, -0.01904594711959362, 0.02589123323559761, -0.004233658779412508, -0.03536824882030487, 0.049797508865594864, -0.011580501683056355, 0.03965085372328758, -0.02024105004966259, -0.0027821494732052088, 0.055416759103536606, 0.01567910797894001, -0.03453919664025307, 0.01990162953734398, 0.013040768913924694, -0.04934747889637947, 0.011231194250285625, 0.027652254328131676, 0.0153475571423769, -0.049207475036382675, 0.009066167287528515, -0.03266434744000435, -0.026889074593782425, -0.011233039200305939, 0.014913453720510006, -0.048823174089193344, 0.037214942276477814, 0.003445673966780305, -0.011773641221225262, 0.03699636459350586, -0.020237455144524574, 0.004427195060998201, -0.06953948736190796, 0.06846819818019867, 0.01834089867770672, 0.02374788373708725, -0.008889741264283657, -0.028266485780477524, -0.027125030755996704, -0.029360521584749222, 0.05460786074399948, 0.0006047997158020735, 0.005986581556499004, 0.002915663179010153, 0.026547836139798164, -0.025853566825389862, -0.07226550579071045, 0.02450699359178543, -0.006888647563755512, -0.017393186688423157, -0.0008446403662674129, -0.026208309456706047, -0.022589916363358498, -0.00926335621625185, 0.030436431989073753, -0.011895098723471165, -0.03495636209845543, 0.01206970401108265, -0.02273794822394848, 0.05223819613456726, 0.024650918319821358, -0.03638104349374771, -0.002585324225947261, 0.004390423651784658, 0.007224991451948881, 0.0544523261487484, -0.005739409942179918, -0.05733208730816841, 0.024640697985887527, -0.010923597030341625, -0.044239144772291183, 0.01063655223697424, -0.0033778324723243713, -0.03663108870387077, -0.018415888771414757, -0.03301774337887764, 0.03573424741625786, -0.03794815018773079, 0.041083868592977524, 0.010874209925532341, 0.003387848613783717, 0.04977666214108467, 0.013685493730008602, 0.04899652302265167, 0.011257643811404705, -0.06070927903056145, 0.012253530323505402, 0.024335641413927078, 0.0054178256541490555, -0.029386598616838455, 0.015510136261582375, 0.031175192445516586, 0.01485580112785101, 0.031317293643951416, 0.01848801039159298, 0.061380818486213684, -0.047990866005420685, -0.0036226999945938587, -0.009376691654324532, -0.0003359908005222678, -0.007566570769995451, 0.014789151027798653, -0.010942308232188225, 0.040460966527462006, 0.00465522613376379, 0.014881948009133339, -0.03317245841026306, -0.027225451543927193, -0.03188806027173996, 0.005319107323884964, 0.04244501516222954, 0.025379100814461708, -0.0017748587997630239, -0.0016447879606857896, 0.014520257711410522, 0.03017282485961914, 0.009960224851965904, -0.017231659963726997, 0.03226502239704132, -0.004772817716002464, -0.0045394389890134335, 0.009445254690945148, -0.06306521594524384, -0.008474333211779594, -0.026873420923948288, 0.011365723796188831, 0.04304840415716171, 0.020582053810358047, 0.004038073588162661, -0.008347011171281338, -0.028270673006772995, 0.030252419412136078, -0.0581793375313282, -0.016198033466935158, -0.0424056276679039, 0.06279385089874268, -0.00020131524070166051, -0.044990405440330505 ]
<p>I have logs for users and posts in a blog platform for 3 years. I can easily find out how many posts each user have made per day/month/year/etc.</p> <p>What I want to find out is if the frequency of posts is growing or not, in other words, if the users are contributing more over time or not. New users could join at any time and old ones could abandon the system (only the first one is logged). Is a trend estimation (<a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trend_estimation" rel="nofollow">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trend_estimation</a>) suitable for this ? </p> <p>More over, is there a python package for this kind of time analyse ? </p>
35,977
[ -0.03256649151444435, -0.024112360551953316, 0.00649819104000926, -0.02051522396504879, 0.02812785655260086, -0.01942426897585392, -0.017522918060421944, -0.02621414326131344, 0.02644968591630459, -0.05044824257493019, 0.018681837245821953, 0.03221176937222481, 0.027420517057180405, 0.031147317960858345, 0.013975689187645912, 0.012554118409752846, 0.00001678142507444136, 0.014994981698691845, 0.00292828306555748, 0.021569957956671715, -0.047946762293577194, 0.02688954956829548, 0.050924863666296005, -0.0006911144009791315, -0.04223238676786423, 0.043118663132190704, 0.024362727999687195, -0.023749787360429764, 0.013575258664786816, 0.04256994649767876, -0.067423976957798, -0.03543326258659363, -0.0059079998172819614, 0.038243167102336884, 0.037615641951560974, 0.012081997469067574, -0.04161478206515312, -0.047413915395736694, -0.02193610928952694, 0.019759876653552055, -0.0058869002386927605, 0.004052150994539261, 0.012424908578395844, -0.007180274464190006, 0.0038371440023183823, 0.02634800784289837, -0.019095024093985558, -0.0025506203528493643, 0.04697174206376076, -0.03122565522789955, 0.07653138041496277, -0.007790987379848957, 0.030895814299583435, 0.0015721049858257174, -0.0072702388279139996, 0.021086251363158226, 0.04323705658316612, 0.017054902389645576, -0.03356006741523743, -0.02634117752313614, -0.030255664139986038, -0.022882163524627686, 0.004207571968436241, -0.022577783092856407, -0.005953725427389145, 0.03415098041296005, -0.045506518334150314, 0.025132810696959496, 0.05592111498117447, 0.012379948049783707, -0.0105710094794631, -0.0049667987041175365, 0.05565837398171425, -0.007124994415789843, -0.017280051484704018, -0.042699217796325684, -0.016441568732261658, 0.03993965685367584, 0.03937369957566261, 0.06939250975847244, -0.006083594635128975, -0.012054184451699257, 0.014686016365885735, -0.024286337196826935, 0.04928481951355934, -0.005123371258378029, 0.06897734105587006, -0.04582922160625458, 0.00037447933573275805, 0.03101174905896187, -0.022496536374092102, -0.016245950013399124, 0.02480444125831127, 0.007263587787747383, -0.004355116281658411, 0.019406769424676895, 0.004057598765939474, 0.025237783789634705, 0.006245918106287718, -0.01669398322701454, 0.0023892889730632305, -0.041882287710905075, -0.0261220782995224, 0.03165411204099655, -0.043156664818525314, -0.0033849941100925207, -0.05572022125124931, -0.04024964198470116, -0.029971500858664513, -0.00562656344845891, -0.047635115683078766, -0.030423225834965706, 0.03062000498175621, -0.0009045201586559415, -0.017804160714149475, 0.0028137683402746916, -0.0008256871369667351, -0.03220485523343086, 0.03312544897198677, 0.06233988702297211, 0.015523127280175686, 0.007971473969519138, 0.013476274907588959, -0.03364478051662445, -0.05925566330552101, 0.032793834805488586, -0.013648350723087788, -0.040008991956710815, -0.05189336836338043, 0.08533865958452225, -0.004114876501262188, -0.043497901409864426, 0.033399470150470734, -0.00860249251127243, 0.04193775728344917, 0.027871549129486084, -0.0685482919216156, -0.055724985897541046, 0.01737389713525772, -0.00872418936342001, 0.03701578080654144, -0.04237418621778488, -0.016475023701786995, 0.02009713649749756, 0.045416176319122314, 0.04711778089404106, 0.026974670588970184, 0.03363289684057236, 0.027791321277618408, 0.002899685176089406, -0.0701540857553482, -0.024493347853422165, -0.004738429095596075, 0.009904292412102222, -0.019311722368001938, -0.05983107164502144, 0.006027337163686752, 0.008280724287033081, -0.025816984474658966, 0.003259925404563546, 0.02319161780178547, 0.045377980917692184, -0.03590529412031174, 0.00689218332991004, 0.026156006380915642, -0.030352717265486717, 0.06606849282979965, -0.0023479280062019825, 0.04672255739569664, -0.014204873703420162, 0.001440098974853754, 0.021335331723093987, 0.016674727201461792, -0.009720821864902973, 0.05384364724159241, -0.024268079549074173, -0.035305771976709366, 0.017986860126256943, -0.00015117216389626265, 0.025219999253749847, -0.018974309787154198, -0.034996990114450455, -0.02117791399359703, -0.0035665216855704784, -0.011903519742190838, 0.05456939712166786, 0.013396562077105045, -0.014817046001553535, 0.012400930747389793, -0.03480793908238411, -0.01683749631047249, -0.08657009154558182, 0.029261870309710503, 0.012530951760709286, 0.04338179901242256, 0.014413952827453613, 0.0037266574800014496, 0.008803412318229675, -0.037418656051158905, -0.015111512504518032, 0.008718584664165974, -0.010143936611711979, 0.02713972143828869, -0.052943889051675797, -0.03695202246308327, 0.010566526092588902, -0.012357348576188087, -0.003701671026647091, 0.021794352680444717, -0.047040823847055435, -0.031060824170708656, -0.0001761160820024088, -0.03335053101181984, 0.0029578206595033407, -0.03219999000430107, -0.028921756893396378, 0.023605013266205788, 0.0004922943189740181, -0.006992971990257502, 0.0034692848566919565, -0.027948791161179543, 0.04843248426914215, 0.010797870345413685, 0.027624616399407387, -0.00020198793208692223, -0.03174532949924469, -0.011106079444289207, 0.02485274337232113, -0.005755526479333639, -0.062021221965551376, -0.09862226247787476, 0.020480815321207047, 0.022798920050263405, 0.05474919080734253, -0.021741122007369995, -0.004681120626628399, 0.06094975396990776, 0.008423125371336937, -0.0013682798016816378, 0.014092206954956055, -0.0203887727111578, 0.0035663836169987917, 0.011820224113762379, 0.056770872324705124, -0.007912004366517067, 0.016963250935077667, 0.02587057091295719, -0.0017633023671805859, 0.03406459838151932, 0.0010885621886700392, -0.030490994453430176, -0.00223028426989913, 0.01689557358622551, 0.008953534997999668, -0.01142189372330904, -0.02324378676712513, 0.007449193391948938, -0.03473202511668205, 0.021648705005645752, 0.016868626698851585, 0.028877468779683113, 0.02246631123125553, 0.025099700316786766, -0.0334150455892086, -0.0017277597216889262, 0.016382064670324326, -0.027525966987013817, -0.0518210344016552, 0.022249402478337288, -0.025834735482931137, 0.02210881933569908, -0.024452080950140953, -0.047148630023002625, -0.03175435587763786, 0.000015513374819420278, 0.01548861339688301, 0.012123148888349533, 0.04916936531662941, -0.021809039637446404, -0.007273406255990267, 0.039922650903463364, -0.02285751886665821, 0.01183384656906128, 0.014021161012351513, -0.041917845606803894, -0.000479693990200758, 0.05796120688319206, -0.024660589173436165, 0.02287394367158413, -0.022787975147366524, 0.023692872375249863, 0.035451486706733704, -0.024245552718639374, -0.0394379161298275, 0.000432377535616979, -0.018426334485411644, 0.006683938670903444, 0.03131438419222832, 0.006973178591579199, 0.037408266216516495, -0.03262611851096153, -0.05111224576830864, 0.042333368211984634, -0.05626525729894638, -0.01671954244375229, -0.03097839467227459, 0.005616722162812948, 0.008164782077074051, -0.020718364045023918, 0.02346585877239704, 0.02297658659517765, -0.012786281295120716, -0.010151351802051067, -0.08946222811937332, -0.04460330307483673, 0.02489265240728855, -0.000504202616866678, 0.03489679843187332, 0.00804141629487276, -0.021198617294430733, 0.03168443962931633, 0.02633840963244438, -0.03547260910272598, -0.023451488465070724, -0.031400296837091446, -0.008072762750089169, -0.034700606018304825, -0.009147120639681816, -0.01365013886243105, 0.00342134153470397, -0.018895665183663368, 0.003307346487417817, 0.019787849858403206, 0.03065326437354088, 0.030521268025040627, 0.002942829392850399, -0.008982534520328045, 0.024046041071414948, 0.029949864372611046, 0.028819357976317406, 0.02775077149271965, 0.0009125432115979493, -0.0007134712650440633, -0.025526762008666992, 0.03650348260998726, 0.021797234192490578, -0.028584683313965797, 0.019880060106515884, -0.017186716198921204, -0.02179091051220894, -0.01021587010473013, -0.004057754762470722, 0.00963142141699791, -0.04161235690116882, -0.01608981564640999, 0.020340414717793465, 0.01685331016778946, -0.011881296522915363, -0.02245551161468029, 0.04935837537050247, 0.0260733962059021, -0.010800432413816452, -0.007079162634909153, -0.046387188136577606, -0.019995924085378647, -0.020094215869903564, -0.031062522903084755, -0.008828670717775822, 0.044889405369758606, 0.020665941759943962, 0.017416730523109436, 0.020282847806811333, -0.04461732134222984, -0.012797458097338676, -0.07118567824363708, 0.002812308259308338, -0.001091320300474763, 0.0539090633392334, 0.0031281374394893646, 0.013903777115046978, 0.023383259773254395, -0.015192064456641674, 0.050274040549993515, -0.011247901245951653, -0.05893395096063614, 0.005372869782149792, -0.02901441976428032, 0.015558312647044659, 0.021273965016007423, -0.01558979693800211, -0.01510617509484291, 0.009942443110048771, 0.007107800804078579, -0.0027583097107708454, 0.03281067684292793, -0.018049119040369987, 0.002615172415971756, -0.028912276029586792, -0.015914076939225197, 0.02105456031858921, -0.0038435703609138727, 0.028706036508083344, -0.01762516424059868, 0.06352394819259644, 0.0397283174097538, 0.05875078961253166, -0.04162777215242386, -0.02859308570623398, -0.008510377258062363, -0.007924910634756088, 0.004568577278405428, 0.013820475898683071, 0.03569996729493141, -0.09649800509214401, 0.05245353654026985, -0.005969068966805935, 0.01307726465165615, 0.0317830890417099, -0.0002996494004037231, -0.00788583792746067, -0.031685374677181244, -0.02014303021132946, 0.059150658547878265, 0.00031891651451587677, 0.0050767264328897, 0.05262782797217369, 0.037025086581707, -0.021220991387963295, -0.0585581436753273, 0.013614079914987087, 0.09603136032819748, 0.004331582225859165, -0.007841183803975582, 0.011982444673776627, 0.011162545531988144, 0.04910846799612045, -0.004446753300726414, 0.010657085105776787, 0.021649369969964027, 0.004978330340236425, -0.006008141674101353, 0.008352477103471756, -0.0049034589901566505, -0.047384679317474365, 0.028656713664531708, 0.03944150358438492, 0.05445597320795059, -0.013334793038666248, -0.01866634003818035, 0.0063409158028662205, 0.061464421451091766, 0.029192689806222916, 0.02420925535261631, 0.0055458564311265945, -0.12624481320381165, -0.009451697580516338, 0.0569891482591629, 0.03558918088674545, -0.038256432861089706, -0.03261316195130348, -0.04907295107841492, -0.010091567412018776, 0.04351285099983215, -0.062041353434324265, -0.004207550548017025, -0.007792808581143618, 0.01942068338394165, -0.0035656525287777185, -0.022628530859947205, -0.016952335834503174, 0.03761126101016998, -0.06128533184528351, 0.01890954002737999, -0.02884405106306076, -0.03148319199681282, -0.01126550231128931, 0.03410874679684639, 0.013581737875938416, 0.06914201378822327, -0.027285508811473846, 0.02705841138958931, 0.021921856328845024, 0.024167047813534737, -0.005722132511436939, -0.04654240235686302, 0.04019874706864357, 0.009055472910404205, -0.006924519315361977, 0.024335073307156563, 0.0032723816111683846, -0.030165743082761765, -0.02670772559940815, -0.022452423349022865, -0.05115330591797829, -0.011227371171116829, -0.033688776195049286, 0.03734845668077469, 0.044719092547893524, -0.00202585244551301, 0.030940702185034752, 0.06673642247915268, 0.0029209593776613474, 0.028719380497932434, 0.008365402929484844, -0.031106775626540184, -0.03072565607726574, 0.029828833416104317, -0.02799994871020317, 0.0018453644588589668, -0.046664733439683914, 0.032035499811172485, -0.00873182900249958, 0.01283443532884121, -0.0321524553000927, 0.03714308142662048, 0.0055994438007473946, 0.01747787743806839, 0.007214196026325226, 0.012393489480018616, 0.053594380617141724, 0.009340289980173111, 0.011835981160402298, -0.031212052330374718, 0.04379163309931755, -0.048914648592472076, -0.01616968773305416, -0.016876528039574623, -0.011075395159423351, 0.018505774438381195, -0.004854423925280571, -0.02942437119781971, 0.00617002509534359, -0.00707069830968976, 0.05082358419895172, -0.012809164822101593, 0.03335084766149521, -0.00331413047388196, -0.0021058903075754642, 0.03165228292346001, 0.0548100620508194, -0.02531798928976059, 0.03919249400496483, -0.044572263956069946, 0.0733676627278328, -0.026459256187081337, -0.006655506789684296, -0.057154156267642975, -0.04352204129099846, 0.08389002829790115, -0.022516746073961258, -0.02962852083146572, -0.05752981826663017, -0.021334992721676826, -0.01882302574813366, 0.02009391598403454, -0.007361745461821556, 0.015134233981370926, -0.027468329295516014, -0.024827556684613228, -0.00960440281778574, 0.026662468910217285, 0.05998494103550911, -0.006715071853250265, 0.0068423449993133545, 0.01157396286725998, 0.034012410789728165, -0.05184647813439369, -0.04740893840789795, 0.012481137178838253, -0.025233475491404533, -0.0015257339691743255, -0.006946492474526167, -0.01148782204836607, 0.07043270021677017, -0.05547051876783371, -0.0047866422683000565, 0.04275522753596306, 0.05011562630534172, 0.021640943363308907, -0.041256990283727646, 0.008002248592674732, -0.003141986206173897, -0.009496111422777176, -0.014707372523844242, -0.027099700644612312, -0.0002918739046435803, -0.001722423592582345, 0.038737766444683075, 0.024348663166165352, -0.03451721742749214, 0.001287179416976869, 0.044582970440387726, 0.013856080360710621, -0.02296854555606842, 0.0341523140668869, -0.018039405345916748, 0.011728353798389435, 0.0023906815331429243, -0.026366660371422768, 0.028547724708914757, -0.026012521237134933, -0.03011499159038067, -0.03604996204376221, -0.016955073922872543, -0.03659651428461075, 0.06198935583233833, 0.0011626055929809809, 0.04348217323422432, 0.030641064047813416, 0.013760673813521862, 0.010701220482587814, 0.0069723231717944145, -0.04384376108646393, -0.018882814794778824, 0.005477139726281166, -0.009778233245015144, -0.028645414859056473, 0.03430046886205673, 0.03380236402153969, 0.023675955832004547, 0.03846408426761627, 0.07124269753694534, -0.000942905549891293, 0.02945726551115513, 0.0268600694835186, -0.018598489463329315, -0.046394072473049164, 0.027595309540629387, -0.0371045358479023, 0.03678610175848007, -0.04684624448418617, -0.03280050307512283, 0.036437224596738815, 0.02553366869688034, -0.009195882827043533, -0.0035683559253811836, -0.004830427002161741, -0.03160062059760094, -0.00471834558993578, 0.025817077606916428, 0.004382845014333725, 0.020375631749629974, 0.034770719707012177, 0.02833111397922039, 0.014484211802482605, 0.03682628273963928, -0.035714831203222275, -0.06399144232273102, -0.018747467547655106, -0.01662927120923996, -0.046574342995882034, 0.0036204925272613764, 0.0016223565908148885, -0.02325708232820034, 0.008987445384263992, 0.01086055301129818, -0.0007239253027364612, 0.01393080409616232, 0.08745916187763214, -0.021156519651412964, 0.07173488289117813, 0.0012440916616469622, -0.012492340989410877, -0.024075262248516083, 0.020879795774817467, 0.12217102944850922, 0.10350450873374939, 0.06608404964208603, -0.0730401948094368, -0.0040724691934883595, -0.024977833032608032, -0.00435969652608037, -0.043957896530628204, 0.0019015175057575107, -0.024609580636024475, -0.024472882971167564, 0.029204724356532097, 0.05036003142595291, -0.012393593788146973, 0.009342397563159466, 0.07356511801481247, 0.020479891449213028, -0.002666100859642029, 0.0021604171488434076, 0.022620586678385735, 0.016507167369127274, -0.0029205854516476393, -0.06909877061843872, 0.02786773256957531, 0.01428059209138155, -0.008435484021902084, 0.00563315162435174, -0.01659017615020275, -0.0009074417757801712, -0.017944302409887314, -0.06022264435887337, 0.03323647007346153, -0.009930215775966644, -0.026485254988074303, -0.006962485611438751, 0.015320003032684326, -0.0024876114912331104, -0.004664193373173475, 0.02521914429962635, 0.033396344631910324, 0.017675109207630157, -0.0182738546282053, -0.01474019419401884, 0.02649409882724285, -0.03407804295420647, -0.008021608926355839, -0.051892224699258804, 0.034711919724941254, -0.00521404854953289, 0.013301489874720573, -0.015678904950618744, -0.013463386334478855, -0.020191803574562073, 0.010592443868517876, -0.02999625913798809, 0.01600411720573902, 0.017852799966931343, 0.013823936693370342, -0.01202371809631586, -0.012269021943211555, -0.019163867458701134, -0.03636445477604866, 0.0005158217390999198, 0.05031424015760422, -0.0616777203977108, -0.03796793520450592, 0.006149751134216785, 0.044892314821481705, 0.0027403358835726976, 0.013424897566437721, 0.0021678151097148657, -0.0074678086675703526, -0.06035160273313522, 0.0035406071692705154, 0.008430782705545425, -0.0029308386147022247, 0.023299159482121468, -0.020955847576260567, 0.002981965895742178, -0.013322447426617146, -0.022756200283765793, 0.03739459067583084, 0.02619664929807186, -0.013373050838708878, -0.031154263764619827, 0.035030297935009, 0.054545123130083084, 0.007552263792604208, 0.02203204110264778, -0.00793108157813549, -0.003350274171680212, -0.004692038055509329, 0.03674981743097305, -0.04764411970973015, -0.002418624237179756, -0.007206483278423548, -0.03771353140473366, -0.0354890301823616, -0.044338081032037735, 0.030656741932034492, 0.005440335720777512, -0.020517732948064804, 0.004553197417408228, 0.0007646483718417585, -0.015693672001361847, 0.03348051384091377, 0.006739350035786629, -0.04139991104602814, 0.0022061578929424286, -0.02081012725830078, -0.011344021186232567, -0.04474674165248871, -0.01723136007785797, -0.02966565452516079, 0.03786215931177139, 0.012055235914885998, -0.01078255195170641, -0.03754333034157753, 0.03234280273318291, -0.02756671793758869, 0.036079466342926025, -0.0031498062890022993, -0.005104998126626015, -0.024137739092111588, -0.026594119146466255, 0.015638479962944984, 0.026783810928463936, -0.015824804082512856, 0.026567691937088966, 0.017668841406702995, 0.008971191011369228, 0.060924090445041656, 0.01287328265607357, -0.003450910560786724, -0.00674840621650219, 0.02330205962061882, -0.036649301648139954, 0.007295018061995506, -0.04537741467356682, -0.08305739611387253, 0.06435231119394302, -0.04272868484258652, -0.026583844795823097, 0.04466291517019272, 0.020204702392220497, 0.014565501362085342, 0.0013104925164952874, -0.03627428412437439, 0.029491711407899857, 0.03542053699493408, -0.011359651573002338, -0.01795630156993866, -0.019994497299194336, 0.03307297080755234, 0.014743943698704243, -0.02450786717236042, -0.01104302890598774, 0.02222863771021366, -0.007122526876628399, 0.017854001373052597, 0.03719098120927811, -0.007968122139573097, -0.004557558801025152, -0.030694743618369102, -0.0047429222613573074, -0.03388790786266327, 0.02147677354514599, -0.0019538530614227057, 0.07071606814861298, 0.053695619106292725, -0.05086087808012962, -0.017965590581297874, -0.01761128380894661, -0.00031209076405502856, -0.049424268305301666, 0.008982637897133827, 0.0035933316685259342, -0.00007047583494568244, 0.009047270752489567, -0.0393943190574646, 0.00349593092687428, 0.04103292152285576, -0.021105067804455757, 0.03288114443421364, 0.015600664541125298, 0.01924486644566059, -0.03664731979370117, 0.04478421434760094, -0.0016345264157280326, 0.029601698741316795, 0.03154697269201279, 0.056318603456020355, 0.02137608453631401, 0.0408073291182518, -0.001138125080615282, -0.08965370804071426, -0.02588542364537716, 0.005810119677335024, -0.0071553755551576614, -0.042639803141355515, 0.03950485214591026, -0.0543086864054203, -0.017617935314774513, 0.05374358966946602, -0.027087749913334846, 0.03698299825191498, 0.03521819785237312, 0.038686320185661316, -0.01076546497642994, 0.048523206263780594, 0.010566814802587032, -0.022451600059866905, 0.003985144197940826, -0.013933515176177025, -0.04407558962702751, 0.042781878262758255, -0.0026268798392266035, 0.0390731617808342, 0.014454329386353493, -0.021957455202937126, 0.006744652055203915, 0.016445962712168694, -0.008574248291552067, -0.005120346322655678, 0.010998406447470188, -0.033579614013433456, 0.024607697501778603, -0.01918257586658001, -0.013254663906991482, -0.011146764270961285, 0.06662449240684509, 0.029653647914528847, 0.019351232796907425, -0.010681219398975372, 0.011057592928409576, -0.014943600632250309, -0.01478361152112484, 0.002944318577647209, -0.021253511309623718, -0.01531593594700098, -0.03922513127326965, 0.015763558447360992, -0.004321502521634102, -0.020302066579461098, -0.01808297261595726, -0.0029401350766420364, -0.03178390860557556, 0.056529004126787186, -0.05141768231987953, -0.017771070823073387, 0.0312933512032032, -0.014161316677927971, 0.003231430659070611, -0.05730607360601425, 0.0722162202000618, 0.026171045377850533, -0.008458726108074188, -0.05452460050582886, -0.0055116345174610615, -0.037121087312698364, -0.010543467476963997, 0.0450013130903244, -0.041793517768383026, 0.0168414618819952, -0.0341036431491375, 0.03820140287280083, 0.04341452941298485, -0.02294280380010605, 0.019236214458942413, -0.03727587312459946, -0.017885722219944, 0.0017013835022225976, -0.05798069015145302, -0.03246420994400978, -0.00849766843020916, 0.033222880214452744, -0.020228981971740723, 0.01830708421766758, 0.02242777682840824, -0.04288787022233009, 0.03291448578238487, 0.029259881004691124, 0.0023983102291822433, 0.05140693485736847, -0.013924652710556984, 0.013501722365617752, 0.02997591905295849, -0.008874875493347645, -0.02433672361075878, 0.05571627989411354, -0.04179023951292038, -0.04356859624385834, 0.012545264326035976, -0.012397510930895805, -0.01812847889959812, -0.02074628882110119, -0.03468457609415054, 0.05176912248134613, -0.00015466481272596866, 0.028987227007746696, 0.023978224024176598, -0.011800747364759445, 0.039459604769945145, -0.027774682268500328, 0.04822199046611786, 0.04307052493095398, 0.0029411346185952425, -0.011016836389899254, 0.014746538363397121, -0.02081574685871601, -0.017339864745736122, 0.0404273197054863, -0.005220290273427963, 0.02022676356136799, 0.012215763330459595, 0.0024234179873019457, -0.0003210587310604751, -0.01632918044924736, 0.011293541640043259, 0.018210073933005333, 0.0010942565277218819, 0.006472151726484299, 0.06146493926644325, -0.010259001515805721, 0.055185869336128235, -0.047525566071271896, 0.021010637283325195, -0.034771181643009186, -0.0374591238796711, -0.016934581100940704, 0.002859636675566435, 0.002463634591549635, -0.007891209796071053, -0.008590278215706348, 0.011382386088371277, 0.05251246318221092, 0.022769421339035034, 0.03802790120244026, -0.04166356101632118, 0.021496087312698364, -0.0002655029820743948, -0.004777795169502497, -0.001202563289552927, -0.02041858807206154, -0.014064759016036987, 0.002169887302443385, 0.031827326864004135, 0.04627837613224983, 0.0031574396416544914, -0.013896692544221878, 0.013350630179047585, -0.010929928161203861, 0.030780449509620667, -0.04113269969820976, 0.007168394513428211, -0.05506692826747894, -0.002373169409111142, 0.016974622383713722, -0.05899440124630928 ]
<p>What is the purpose of the link function as a component of the generalized linear model? Why do we need it?</p> <p>Wikipedia states:</p> <blockquote> <p>It can be convenient to match the domain of the link function to the range of the distribution function's mean</p> </blockquote> <p>What's the advantage of doing this?</p>
73,414
[ -0.036886367946863174, 0.037233348935842514, 0.018892379477620125, -0.021210473030805588, 0.025674650445580482, 0.015128039754927158, -0.030515966936945915, -0.0053675672970712185, 0.02965562418103218, -0.04523158818483353, 0.03442753478884697, 0.04314475506544113, 0.06963527947664261, -0.007013656664639711, 0.027778059244155884, 0.019226154312491417, -0.007275717798620462, -0.010129036381840706, -0.00568851362913847, -0.010740233585238457, 0.010629791766405106, 0.01602615974843502, -0.004707804415374994, -0.01270830538123846, -0.0033108899369835854, 0.06678896397352219, 0.01974909007549286, -0.01634100452065468, 0.054274410009384155, 0.04330415651202202, -0.02347039058804512, -0.024030810222029686, -0.012864959426224232, 0.05382632836699486, -0.0015455452958121896, 0.0072129531763494015, -0.0459660105407238, -0.03047729842364788, -0.010689394548535347, 0.058344241231679916, -0.046560440212488174, -0.003292468609288335, -0.020426113158464432, 0.03220495581626892, 0.0009827316971495748, 0.033438149839639664, -0.023664500564336777, -0.011654914356768131, 0.024010829627513885, -0.0306866355240345, 0.05202309042215347, -0.02686290629208088, 0.017512358725070953, 0.0072081261314451694, -0.008374582044780254, 0.0005064202123321593, 0.05750514939427376, 0.06419799476861954, -0.000838605163153261, -0.025791002437472343, 0.00804300419986248, -0.005295906215906143, 0.015249197371304035, -0.03617309406399727, 0.024359291419386864, 0.016947858035564423, 0.0037393190432339907, -0.02835310809314251, 0.03019646555185318, -0.01841401681303978, -0.03045816533267498, 0.03053959459066391, 0.008359764702618122, 0.006091349758207798, -0.0012322558322921395, -0.0026333315763622522, -0.013018480502068996, 0.02159920148551464, 0.06206337362527847, 0.01986149698495865, 0.0027911534998565912, -0.014486582018435001, -0.01070165541023016, 0.014571796171367168, 0.008609216660261154, 0.02173597738146782, 0.07742909342050552, -0.010555804707109928, 0.018493760377168655, 0.01554149854928255, -0.030711719766259193, 0.0010796894785016775, 0.032785963267087936, 0.016982967033982277, -0.03414973244071007, 0.07174543291330338, 0.0024219213519245386, 0.003632105654105544, 0.046319250017404556, 0.020122172310948372, -0.026349328458309174, -0.06282046437263489, -0.029461270198225975, 0.03126444295048714, -0.011970366351306438, -0.01982826180756092, 0.010183712467551231, -0.01464487798511982, -0.015683893114328384, -0.03277606889605522, -0.040607333183288574, 0.01963006518781185, 0.02006368339061737, -0.0008379026548936963, 0.027677198871970177, -0.028412334620952606, 0.04438762739300728, -0.0028650821186602116, 0.021124843508005142, 0.07090882956981659, 0.02682538889348507, -0.026923619210720062, 0.004355703014880419, 0.0010445649968460202, -0.04583527892827988, 0.01195094920694828, 0.017828138545155525, -0.026268256828188896, -0.0007135368650779128, 0.023885050788521767, 0.01730114407837391, -0.03735225647687912, 0.025644926354289055, 0.009666822850704193, -0.0002149718056898564, -0.008617065846920013, -0.09074317663908005, -0.04615126550197601, 0.06311183422803879, -0.02135995589196682, 0.01341802068054676, -0.052219465374946594, -0.01404951699078083, 0.012440790422260761, 0.049929551780223846, 0.012489697895944118, 0.045689791440963745, -0.014272420667111874, 0.03047969937324524, -0.022409038618206978, -0.031490422785282135, -0.04861338436603546, 0.0031417913269251585, -0.042917877435684204, -0.043275147676467896, -0.08230127394199371, 0.015584303997457027, 0.007362467236816883, -0.015194843523204327, -0.01647588238120079, 0.052498869597911835, -0.008141839876770973, -0.015268955379724503, -0.01139991357922554, -0.009928759187459946, -0.013974294997751713, 0.06658985465765, -0.011018563061952591, 0.06922205537557602, 0.05222678557038307, -0.033321626484394073, 0.03264888375997543, 0.0090612368658185, 0.06101711094379425, -0.005584659054875374, -0.0016683057183399796, -0.001374361221678555, -0.02984127774834633, -0.020224174484610558, 0.0031015551649034023, -0.049183692783117294, 0.008722236379981041, 0.007665508426725864, -0.02138618193566799, 0.022537490352988243, 0.028278717771172523, -0.00760500505566597, 0.005976169370114803, 0.046705253422260284, -0.043833404779434204, -0.03385205939412117, -0.04569150134921074, 0.025930162519216537, -0.023541346192359924, -0.008671681396663189, 0.01042073592543602, -0.0065680681727826595, 0.04199681058526039, 0.01857646368443966, -0.018541166558861732, -0.029220206663012505, -0.018848057836294174, 0.018817570060491562, -0.018434951081871986, -0.00003976359585067257, 0.04035637900233269, 0.09228798747062683, -0.02188149094581604, 0.030732477083802223, -0.05414709076285362, -0.03420770540833473, 0.05025056377053261, -0.034477006644010544, 0.0286692064255476, -0.03572152182459831, 0.009552777744829655, -0.046406812965869904, 0.0072050392627716064, 0.0035020061768591404, 0.029269400984048843, -0.04695049673318863, 0.050959501415491104, 0.1013750433921814, 0.0062829130329191685, 0.0031686844304203987, 0.05110498517751694, 0.00936356745660305, 0.0058736652135849, -0.00958248134702444, -0.010074357502162457, -0.05097552761435509, -0.03241219371557236, 0.03281674161553383, 0.026855969801545143, -0.029510285705327988, 0.02637951634824276, 0.03970523551106453, 0.02293851599097252, -0.018708428367972374, -0.006722395308315754, -0.021060433238744736, -0.011324161663651466, 0.014454051852226257, 0.0005061173578724265, 0.03547409921884537, -0.002131502842530608, -0.015347456559538841, 0.01228291168808937, -0.0069775148294866085, -0.016051746904850006, -0.005086549092084169, 0.0810266062617302, -0.019116194918751717, -0.0324140228331089, -0.003913264721632004, 0.011716310866177082, 0.03445005789399147, -0.03348453342914581, 0.018450230360031128, 0.05058205872774124, -0.025648225098848343, -0.012364186346530914, 0.011780612170696259, -0.04771025478839874, 0.027370881289243698, 0.007436104118824005, -0.02624092996120453, -0.03647308424115181, 0.03319267928600311, -0.052812591195106506, 0.005550413392484188, -0.03651188686490059, -0.033735353499650955, -0.03351874649524689, 0.0023248041979968548, 0.013528264127671719, 0.0007620317628607154, 0.013234134763479233, -0.04629853740334511, -0.04287251830101013, -0.0029440345242619514, -0.005420779809355736, -0.0070757376961410046, 0.0031864973716437817, -0.018779991194605827, -0.019575156271457672, -0.009357592090964317, -0.012811913155019283, 0.01464737020432949, -0.013334657065570354, -0.0037813521921634674, -0.006746741943061352, 0.005202774424105883, -0.03951267898082733, -0.058453746140003204, -0.03395988047122955, 0.025202913209795952, -0.03934529796242714, -0.03485437482595444, 0.007065916433930397, -0.03325306996703148, -0.042832545936107635, 0.013437537476420403, -0.07238372415304184, -0.04222022742033005, -0.023744601756334305, -0.0006147791864350438, 0.0024000199045985937, -0.005582504905760288, 0.029576854780316353, 0.008409756235778332, -0.05570192262530327, -0.014490419998764992, -0.06429657340049744, -0.01200691144913435, 0.037621963769197464, 0.012853964231908321, 0.012297996319830418, 0.0102675287052989, -0.026879148557782173, 0.09190979599952698, 0.046882081776857376, -0.010980769991874695, -0.03261930122971535, -0.01600915752351284, -0.0034650505986064672, -0.06616929918527603, 0.030414940789341927, 0.038305606693029404, 0.02905641309916973, 0.04299617186188698, 0.012535203248262405, 0.003302224213257432, 0.05450998246669769, 0.004681120626628399, 0.017712660133838654, 0.013035246171057224, -0.02490639127790928, -0.03860771656036377, 0.03825618699193001, 0.028805704787373543, -0.03008161671459675, 0.022954121232032776, -0.026540054008364677, 0.02229982241988182, -0.0018870903877541423, -0.03734187036752701, 0.0477251335978508, -0.014343814924359322, -0.005151386838406324, -0.008888171054422855, 0.04464133828878403, 0.011533573269844055, -0.013364673592150211, 0.02693868614733219, -0.012110603973269463, 0.04213627427816391, -0.01824107952415943, 0.01964196190237999, 0.01764693297445774, 0.020604563876986504, -0.02545253187417984, -0.0002795877808239311, -0.050657689571380615, -0.006687626708298922, -0.0032451064325869083, -0.0016048827674239874, -0.030722608789801598, 0.028128698468208313, 0.06544303148984909, -0.023932622745633125, 0.0027699677739292383, -0.034240711480379105, -0.038206759840250015, -0.06346393376588821, 0.003340028692036867, -0.030125068500638008, 0.022735370323061943, 0.02171904593706131, 0.03870997577905655, 0.028406286612153053, 0.018793616443872452, 0.011471442878246307, -0.01831875741481781, -0.09015558660030365, 0.03380969911813736, -0.03821969032287598, 0.015446524135768414, -0.0013243533903732896, -0.02408915013074875, 0.05097343027591705, -0.0016287213657051325, -0.022562526166439056, 0.00787645485252142, 0.0024416691157966852, -0.027135083451867104, 0.023297851905226707, 0.001441317144781351, -0.07063917070627213, -0.0359567329287529, -0.04931822791695595, 0.029104799032211304, -0.011619983240962029, -0.008905465714633465, 0.061210863292217255, -0.009593903087079525, -0.007504072971642017, -0.01227245107293129, 0.01728479377925396, 0.015151137486100197, 0.02771143801510334, 0.01508630346506834, 0.02393113635480404, -0.03858260065317154, 0.04882301017642021, 0.01695515587925911, 0.05406850576400757, 0.068180613219738, -0.014241782948374748, -0.019551552832126617, -0.07231172174215317, -0.02523275651037693, 0.00599105516448617, 0.00830985326319933, -0.011059977114200592, -0.03736541420221329, 0.07490339130163193, 0.024737589061260223, -0.007798445876687765, 0.0026237773708999157, 0.03491410240530968, 0.011487524956464767, -0.013609318993985653, -0.02466498129069805, -0.020361442118883133, -0.02028118260204792, -0.0320153534412384, 0.04790816083550453, -0.029644688591361046, 0.017012858763337135, 0.009365648031234741, 0.03769886866211891, -0.001436496153473854, -0.025214899331331253, -0.06701801717281342, 0.031064018607139587, 0.04083210602402687, 0.04229619354009628, -0.05975606292486191, -0.012460722588002682, 0.029148053377866745, 0.04036374017596245, 0.020391670987010002, -0.0051033226773142815, -0.07196498662233353, 0.014365267008543015, 0.05833214521408081, 0.028366904705762863, -0.051599230617284775, -0.012298019602894783, -0.0328853502869606, -0.0006115909782238305, 0.00005160898217582144, -0.021908743306994438, 0.014696765691041946, -0.024585507810115814, 0.019147949293255806, -0.03469159081578255, -0.049008212983608246, -0.051107730716466904, 0.025249870494008064, -0.006374158896505833, -0.01545600313693285, -0.041937828063964844, -0.008328958414494991, -0.030690127983689308, 0.014422350563108921, 0.0026923285331577063, 0.04978412017226219, -0.0015425734454765916, -0.0007870885892771184, 0.04242972657084465, 0.04739498347043991, -0.023586198687553406, -0.0753236636519432, -0.02849995158612728, 0.006459422875195742, 0.011229236610233784, 0.008259274065494537, -0.022279271855950356, -0.03870479762554169, 0.004521518014371395, 0.01966525986790657, -0.011749600060284138, 0.024129686877131462, 0.03098086081445217, 0.023982442915439606, 0.01582176424562931, -0.00957413762807846, 0.07519905269145966, -0.019342893734574318, -0.012457640841603279, -0.01580357365310192, -0.0373288057744503, 0.016240036115050316, -0.0315626785159111, -0.0484791062772274, -0.018866676837205887, 0.0019235051004216075, -0.011819870211184025, 0.03057076781988144, -0.009504211135208607, 0.002143393037840724, -0.02973535843193531, -0.023157643154263496, 0.004812802653759718, 0.015984509140253067, -0.028451066464185715, -0.030924374237656593, 0.023016449064016342, 0.06171431764960289, 0.027099525555968285, -0.01652297005057335, 0.009216000325977802, -0.01215098425745964, 0.002696111798286438, 0.01943226531147957, 0.008002008311450481, -0.0025997674092650414, -0.012357083149254322, -0.025060303509235382, 0.03309369459748268, -0.012834109365940094, 0.024072932079434395, 0.0021645985543727875, -0.015012157149612904, 0.030320387333631516, -0.057845454663038254, -0.02031753398478031, 0.007982444949448109, -0.01140617299824953, 0.02880830317735672, 0.0010836618021130562, 0.0070556821301579475, -0.04132970795035362, -0.00019053537107538432, -0.06923270970582962, -0.03824489563703537, 0.025981316342949867, -0.017852837219834328, -0.017102928832173347, -0.019804786890745163, -0.009386681951582432, -0.024125834926962852, -0.009576982818543911, -0.008798283524811268, 0.06095610931515694, -0.0024722949601709843, -0.009739714674651623, -0.036417122930288315, 0.015144859440624714, 0.0574064776301384, 0.016942519694566727, -0.013644658029079437, 0.024268463253974915, -0.030219271779060364, 0.011333874426782131, -0.017574969679117203, 0.015644460916519165, -0.051856931298971176, -0.027093997225165367, -0.004237871151417494, -0.0007667778991162777, 0.038196463137865067, -0.013780179433524609, -0.015218719840049744, -0.0024825388099998236, 0.018878426402807236, -0.02247873693704605, -0.015041106380522251, -0.0007460293127223849, -0.03496647626161575, 0.0077039580792188644, 0.011237327009439468, 0.04407301917672157, -0.04008929431438446, -0.01034229900687933, 0.0972752720117569, -0.03594963997602463, -0.020938415080308914, 0.04225771874189377, 0.050134554505348206, -0.030413523316383362, 0.014066429808735847, 0.00960901565849781, -0.02208273485302925, 0.06544006615877151, 0.007870928384363651, 0.01135983970016241, 0.01657554693520069, 0.04145136475563049, -0.009522593580186367, -0.03363008424639702, -0.05394171178340912, -0.007260574027895927, 0.06183043494820595, -0.01894741877913475, 0.04011022672057152, 0.027543222531676292, -0.04167301580309868, 0.005252960603684187, -0.02734656073153019, 0.006896915379911661, -0.020583854988217354, 0.033216144889593124, 0.04200562834739685, -0.040757615119218826, -0.014426766894757748, 0.044670701026916504, -0.0038364273495972157, 0.008962323889136314, -0.001325389021076262, 0.014712881296873093, -0.006056070793420076, 0.016870252788066864, -0.033234842121601105, -0.027700912207365036, 0.07243610173463821, -0.002589193871244788, 0.00808416772633791, -0.00729123642668128, -0.025108577683568, 0.027639608830213547, -0.004378229379653931, 0.009654341265559196, -0.06910379230976105, -0.014486702159047127, -0.02702079340815544, 0.009822317399084568, 0.031907666474580765, -0.013791333884000778, 0.029623286798596382, 0.00803689006716013, 0.011406105011701584, 0.0017143187578767538, 0.026074634864926338, -0.01636478677392006, -0.08857981860637665, -0.0025101313367486, 0.0007019607000984251, -0.042642172425985336, 0.004610327538102865, -0.015498300082981586, -0.051008936017751694, -0.004445833154022694, -0.045692380517721176, 0.0023982597049325705, 0.0316678024828434, 0.050292786210775375, -0.014590469188988209, 0.08768567442893982, -0.00003871667286148295, 0.002542088972404599, 0.018875040113925934, -0.022943047806620598, 0.14583304524421692, 0.03138194978237152, 0.027422765269875526, -0.056368205696344376, -0.015713145956397057, -0.0034265785943716764, -0.005294849630445242, -0.02539019286632538, -0.006521616131067276, 0.010091030970215797, 0.015078970231115818, 0.07128362357616425, 0.043669216334819794, -0.02259696274995804, 0.010060759261250496, 0.05467895418405533, -0.038356851786375046, -0.01526232622563839, 0.0477692112326622, -0.033266857266426086, -0.024023357778787613, 0.030049163848161697, -0.010961302556097507, 0.017730101943016052, 0.032700203359127045, -0.00088526401668787, -0.018365299329161644, -0.02032763883471489, -0.0038610000628978014, 0.008189740590751171, -0.041417088359594345, -0.002172883367165923, 0.0029256045818328857, 0.025007743388414383, 0.027696631848812103, 0.0037105802912265062, 0.005714483559131622, -0.009194131009280682, -0.00739838182926178, 0.04623455926775932, -0.02377433516085148, 0.006462066899985075, -0.005054009146988392, -0.009785886853933334, -0.024599261581897736, -0.021912889555096626, -0.004584093578159809, 0.010710463859140873, -0.048947613686323166, -0.024404272437095642, 0.01246899738907814, -0.016748787835240364, 0.0007192904013209045, -0.03754034265875816, -0.004935084376484156, 0.01264964696019888, 0.0532040037214756, -0.005392894614487886, -0.011377949267625809, -0.031614355742931366, 0.009608995169401169, -0.0277083832770586, 0.036104630678892136, 0.0041174618527293205, -0.03620632737874985, 0.018846843391656876, -0.011410485953092575, 0.057477764785289764, -0.00461365282535553, 0.012507888488471508, 0.00703876418992877, -0.003360130125656724, -0.044152021408081055, -0.027213891968131065, 0.044631291180849075, 0.00025802056188695133, 0.04505537450313568, 0.005195793230086565, 0.03226013481616974, -0.0244356170296669, -0.0674370750784874, 0.00047137049841694534, -0.0038977251388132572, -0.03245888277888298, -0.045607395470142365, 0.022721465677022934, 0.028807122260332108, 0.04082199186086655, 0.03405905142426491, -0.00144398573320359, -0.028028367087244987, 0.027268337085843086, -0.00929494109004736, -0.04605546593666077, 0.020367147400975227, 0.024162618443369865, 0.005929136648774147, -0.012056605890393257, -0.01158080343157053, 0.03695565462112427, 0.05547088012099266, 0.03525650501251221, -0.02884060889482498, 0.04167713224887848, -0.004591408651322126, 0.02019093558192253, 0.02471495047211647, -0.03888503834605217, 0.006786889396607876, 0.013933958485722542, 0.0049181412905454636, -0.027917208150029182, 0.007823311723768711, -0.017982885241508484, -0.033390145748853683, 0.07294140756130219, 0.032272472977638245, -0.03154652193188667, -0.01542865950614214, -0.028288520872592926, 0.03193090856075287, -0.044115882366895676, -0.01052742451429367, -0.008133427239954472, 0.031061721965670586, -0.03421161696314812, -0.04130655154585838, 0.015187300741672516, 0.0005161155131645501, -0.0047808014787733555, 0.012781147845089436, 0.044545963406562805, 0.03384149819612503, -0.02379942126572132, 0.021676544100046158, 0.023313259705901146, -0.02010180614888668, 0.06412806361913681, 0.00015359115786850452, -0.016381654888391495, 0.037194833159446716, -0.03239663317799568, 0.005087448749691248, 0.027346916496753693, 0.003145871451124549, 0.03785073757171631, 0.00408589094877243, 0.00802870374172926, -0.004285329021513462, 0.01992308907210827, -0.020036472007632256, 0.008202404715120792, -0.013757873326539993, -0.0059975869953632355, 0.06207903474569321, 0.007024858146905899, -0.006640886887907982, -0.006084722001105547, 0.005014895927160978, -0.0038519646041095257, 0.040056489408016205, -0.0383065864443779, 0.012827268801629543, 0.0453917495906353, -0.02060708776116371, -0.014000826515257359, -0.015079866163432598, 0.020753802731633186, 0.03749586641788483, 0.056574366986751556, -0.024005912244319916, 0.014830822125077248, 0.009757294319570065, 0.01939614862203598, -0.11077476292848587, -0.024920551106333733, -0.012685299851000309, 0.004560511559247971, 0.03352109342813492, -0.017673831433057785, 0.012438573874533176, 0.008347470313310623, -0.04792565479874611, 0.016218824312090874, 0.01445571519434452, -0.0177617110311985, -0.04209722951054573, -0.025867143645882607, -0.05000929906964302, 0.0589941143989563, 0.004101024940609932, 0.037808120250701904, 0.04223247617483139, -0.00835320446640253, 0.02783638797700405, -0.016607141122221947, -0.025183435529470444, 0.006871582008898258, -0.015275116078555584, -0.022019654512405396, 0.06548192352056503, 0.02329428307712078, -0.02267625741660595, 0.030799761414527893, -0.006011900492012501, 0.05610242113471031, 0.02610958367586136, -0.003940991126000881, 0.01843498833477497, 0.05093937739729881, 0.050191305577754974, -0.004558245185762644, -0.039720043540000916, 0.009269466623663902, 0.008987406268715858, 0.012466308660805225, -0.02730734646320343, 0.03040613979101181, -0.01948617398738861, -0.037718333303928375, -0.041305020451545715, -0.0070544700138270855, -0.018052296712994576, -0.03447817638516426, 0.0032042900566011667, -0.011569011025130749, -0.001038988120853901, -0.0522475466132164, -0.00910655315965414, -0.031362950801849365, -0.03213048726320267, 0.06163695454597473, 0.01344707515090704, -0.025587044656276703, 0.03360835835337639, -0.0063924724236130714, -0.03079499863088131, 0.01867290399968624, -0.009496445767581463, -0.000010436972843308467, -0.05267966538667679, 0.0016879714094102383, -0.0017982319695875049, 0.004666522610932589, 0.004566829185932875, -0.0065005868673324585, -0.03756251558661461, 0.024456311017274857, -0.010069802403450012, 0.03705357387661934, 0.029554756358265877, -0.042923703789711, 0.0038435643073171377, -0.07443712651729584, 0.09252078086137772, 0.03168197721242905, -0.029169246554374695, -0.00673817889764905, -0.005289257969707251, -0.00838605035096407, 0.00940654519945383, 0.06545108556747437, 0.011862238869071007, 0.0021480489522218704, -0.018404880538582802, 0.06763135641813278, -0.021299870684742928, -0.03867564722895622, 0.003306241240352392, -0.012949677184224129, -0.010040665976703167, -0.04546716809272766, 0.008831595070660114, -0.02948860451579094, 0.02862686477601528, -0.008434855379164219, -0.0019417775329202414, 0.02519306167960167, -0.011939672753214836, 0.003342136275023222, 0.02855958603322506, 0.07415720820426941, -0.03130608797073364, 0.05476502329111099, -0.022893592715263367, -0.0030868584290146828, 0.012606763280928135, -0.007844985462725163, -0.05986444652080536, 0.03551826626062393, -0.028992785140872, -0.017910294234752655, 0.007160237990319729, 0.00006272966129472479, 0.013156725093722343, -0.05265248194336891, -0.00028317832038737833, 0.00734974630177021, -0.031767603009939194, 0.005148957017809153, 0.017151793465018272, 0.021161602810025215, 0.05846258997917175, 0.024350645020604134, -0.017691321671009064, -0.01985410787165165, -0.008346115238964558, -0.013905925676226616, 0.025290995836257935, 0.02926580421626568, -0.014710561372339725, 0.005523709114640951, 0.017187736928462982, -0.00024595222203060985, 0.036293722689151764, 0.01053235400468111, 0.05991600826382637, -0.06868857145309448, -0.0134720578789711, 0.03415057063102722, -0.006612837314605713, 0.03537548705935478, 0.03655789792537689, -0.019159017130732536, 0.0706624984741211, -0.04245549067854881, -0.025113394483923912, 0.005344654433429241, -0.010318652726709843, -0.04304635897278786, 0.001822112943045795, 0.0021987317595630884, 0.027864884585142136, 0.02562660165131092, 0.0387401208281517, -0.013135080225765705, -0.022635256871581078, 0.03620724007487297, 0.018917735666036606, 0.014165547676384449, 0.008069789037108421, 0.0005435801576822996, -0.0053267087787389755, -0.011980868875980377, -0.01794346608221531, 0.00352625478990376, 0.025687294080853462, 0.057581160217523575, 0.015592523850500584, -0.02282341942191124, 0.007081786636263132, -0.0005687456578016281, 0.04902322217822075, -0.0741523802280426, -0.015332704409956932, -0.028092265129089355, -0.008933509700000286, -0.0003774954820983112, -0.01486895326524973 ]
<p>I am interested in finding a leading indicator of $Y_t$. Is it sufficient to find a variable $X$ for which its lagged value is correlated with $Y$? Do I have to give consideration to the spurious regression phenomenon? Or is it correct to say that when it comes to forecasting, I can ignore this problem?</p>
35,777
[ -0.01438059937208891, -0.018293676897883415, 0.008685966022312641, -0.002658685203641653, 0.05980395898222923, 0.016870850697159767, -0.027292585000395775, -0.012107186019420624, 0.03480217605829239, -0.03828603774309158, 0.021256359294056892, 0.009521517902612686, 0.058860067278146744, 0.03818884491920471, 0.02426188252866268, 0.03744369000196457, -0.01715322770178318, -0.002784918062388897, 0.024000247940421104, -0.009562131017446518, -0.0029844921082258224, 0.028936011716723442, 0.03734024986624718, -0.016203658655285835, -0.021791161969304085, 0.024486996233463287, 0.022935273125767708, 0.020617874339222908, 0.021730151027441025, 0.06038879603147507, -0.052542105317115784, -0.0056272707879543304, 0.010781713761389256, 0.07672866433858871, 0.017781933769583702, -0.004668230656534433, -0.0005163527093827724, -0.030833633616566658, 0.015035118907690048, 0.045030608773231506, -0.013632703572511673, -0.007539348676800728, 0.025035394355654716, 0.02328711375594139, -0.00027085343026556075, 0.0248696431517601, 0.002175807487219572, -0.04823247715830803, 0.05241156741976738, -0.03019324131309986, 0.08313339203596115, -0.012076573446393013, -0.004861206281930208, 0.0344422273337841, 0.0022123991511762142, -0.004417587071657181, 0.10539720952510834, 0.028782228007912636, -0.020901324227452278, -0.026428822427988052, -0.0034570845309644938, -0.02412484772503376, 0.003588672960177064, 0.010839159600436687, -0.04233286529779434, 0.02832263894379139, -0.03425993770360947, -0.03391630947589874, 0.018604746088385582, -0.0305821243673563, 0.005373230203986168, -0.0035495248157531023, 0.04063081368803978, -0.028864894062280655, 0.019807999953627586, -0.03450948745012283, 0.010228822007775307, 0.04181810840964317, 0.020495835691690445, 0.060436002910137177, 0.018585676327347755, 0.027618136256933212, 0.023548664525151253, 0.05171022564172745, 0.020647818222641945, 0.014597424305975437, 0.016335807740688324, -0.0468587800860405, 0.03523464500904083, 0.040291283279657364, -0.03358864411711693, 0.004236966837197542, 0.05124476179480553, -0.021235501393675804, -0.0038581660483032465, 0.019550878554582596, -0.0289116483181715, 0.034553155303001404, 0.04174525663256645, -0.007666261401027441, -0.007941092364490032, -0.03477107360959053, -0.013365130871534348, 0.07845529168844223, -0.02426835522055626, 0.010537674650549889, -0.010708670131862164, 0.020542088896036148, -0.021290026605129242, -0.03573049232363701, -0.06375835090875626, -0.012953273952007294, -0.013888594694435596, 0.012866953387856483, 0.05010857805609703, 0.03027857095003128, -0.00042487154132686555, -0.022099977359175682, 0.014501665718853474, 0.05189697444438934, 0.027638595551252365, -0.03043552115559578, 0.015784529969096184, -0.0054681855253875256, -0.04391469433903694, 0.02221391163766384, 0.025682097300887108, -0.015175995416939259, -0.030328946188092232, 0.06670321524143219, -0.01424423698335886, -0.036703940480947495, 0.007483218796551228, -0.0032577957026660442, 0.06385435163974762, 0.03724687919020653, -0.0912294015288353, -0.051993172615766525, 0.0430370569229126, -0.021938659250736237, 0.007846245542168617, -0.07607690244913101, 0.0024845032021403313, 0.009940247982740402, 0.05175575241446495, 0.01463895384222269, 0.028988374397158623, 0.011204463429749012, 0.03670548275113106, 0.01728200726211071, -0.05789123475551605, -0.034549884498119354, 0.028140433132648468, -0.03870575875043869, 0.013464391231536865, -0.08168091624975204, -0.02051406353712082, 0.03537413477897644, -0.01389291137456894, -0.03171748295426369, 0.030724260956048965, 0.016406487673521042, -0.019387973472476006, -0.00038973268237896264, 0.022116132080554962, -0.042605914175510406, 0.06783169507980347, -0.015484621748328209, 0.015930280089378357, 0.020879965275526047, 0.009363718330860138, 0.014594780281186104, 0.04334452003240585, 0.048559099435806274, 0.04411940649151802, -0.020365972071886063, -0.02263963595032692, -0.01595332846045494, -0.009003493934869766, 0.004240851383656263, -0.05354772135615349, -0.036129180341959, -0.025939932093024254, 0.009403344243764877, 0.010856264270842075, 0.08259537070989609, 0.02284982055425644, -0.002909287577494979, 0.043920766562223434, -0.071187324821949, -0.03349383920431137, -0.05015947297215462, -0.0337945930659771, 0.012220765464007854, 0.0010541054653003812, 0.03801378607749939, 0.0002425198326818645, 0.029971744865179062, -0.029551666229963303, -0.028136424720287323, -0.008657091297209263, 0.019947683438658714, 0.05348018556833267, -0.04328177869319916, 0.032109182327985764, 0.019789166748523712, 0.02490040846168995, -0.013959027826786041, 0.001876614522188902, -0.05455781891942024, -0.08620405197143555, 0.017897505313158035, -0.028951991349458694, 0.05860736593604088, -0.05293469876050949, -0.017932036891579628, 0.0238031055778265, -0.02290158160030842, -0.015640683472156525, 0.036910515278577805, -0.05074983462691307, 0.05996422842144966, 0.03311175853013992, 0.010634255595505238, -0.01764826662838459, -0.020206471905112267, 0.022886527702212334, 0.012806957587599754, -0.023252470418810844, -0.026774302124977112, -0.02406633272767067, 0.0032362656202167273, 0.033569756895303726, 0.0355931855738163, -0.03944908827543259, 0.027180032804608345, 0.045811742544174194, 0.024523667991161346, -0.00464946124702692, 0.020552678033709526, -0.016376301646232605, 0.006041602231562138, -0.00557493232190609, 0.02155217155814171, 0.015800360590219498, 0.005509179085493088, 0.004985357169061899, 0.0276186466217041, 0.03030329756438732, -0.011943703517317772, 0.0005831553135067225, 0.05732713267207146, -0.007888003252446651, 0.0015044668689370155, 0.02086869440972805, -0.030295275151729584, 0.037364475429058075, -0.0455445721745491, -0.00945117138326168, 0.005511057563126087, 0.03871647268533707, 0.01850036345422268, 0.0160223338752985, -0.011978965252637863, 0.013838793151080608, 0.021659942343831062, -0.05514438822865486, 0.002032054588198662, 0.044938892126083374, -0.024269795045256615, 0.032292045652866364, -0.04514637961983681, -0.04482020437717438, -0.03951098024845123, -0.018490981310606003, 0.041656430810689926, 0.022015923634171486, 0.0090686259791255, -0.020251097157597542, 0.00862547941505909, -0.012461751699447632, -0.013241784647107124, -0.014339943416416645, 0.024699389934539795, -0.02400798164308071, 0.0032597638200968504, -0.03114442341029644, -0.013930571265518665, 0.014223290607333183, -0.032837532460689545, -0.004109252244234085, 0.011358698830008507, -0.025867732241749763, -0.060810498893260956, -0.06279679387807846, -0.03644623979926109, 0.03265533596277237, -0.01515774242579937, -0.042153339833021164, 0.02771121636033058, -0.027127960696816444, -0.03766977787017822, -0.015874609351158142, -0.058854393661022186, -0.008623003959655762, -0.04541977122426033, -0.002356734359636903, -0.014325692318379879, -0.016665799543261528, 0.010956929996609688, 0.023446770384907722, -0.03224113583564758, 0.009521840140223503, -0.034618206322193146, -0.06436877697706223, 0.03903566300868988, -0.00339956465177238, 0.0486840084195137, -0.012698731385171413, -0.04415232688188553, 0.037021979689598083, 0.049149781465530396, 0.005262565333396196, -0.03978094831109047, -0.03180965408682823, -0.017936773598194122, -0.041214969009160995, 0.012983107008039951, 0.01874847337603569, 0.025345100089907646, 0.053474970161914825, 0.01465314906090498, 0.01039499044418335, 0.011724368669092655, 0.032157011330127716, 0.037365831434726715, -0.0066888704895973206, -0.030077427625656128, 0.02635015733540058, -0.00676150806248188, 0.06059795618057251, -0.007490749936550856, -0.023517686873674393, -0.011821369640529156, 0.04840267822146416, 0.02055550180375576, -0.026849204674363136, 0.020993510261178017, -0.03519919887185097, 0.00800300668925047, -0.006078352220356464, 0.02518751285970211, 0.03712654113769531, 0.01734192855656147, -0.04916955903172493, -0.00752212991937995, -0.001719110645353794, 0.021126702427864075, 0.033133089542388916, 0.06206094101071358, -0.005369985941797495, -0.019631443545222282, -0.029807094484567642, -0.024466924369335175, -0.04522469639778137, 0.04040071740746498, -0.00469585694372654, -0.009008664637804031, 0.05002163350582123, 0.014011801220476627, -0.008120561949908733, -0.009156052023172379, -0.034392423927783966, 0.014884207397699356, -0.10253892093896866, -0.021656375378370285, 0.014864944852888584, 0.031052878126502037, 0.005375850945711136, 0.06035924330353737, 0.014192333444952965, 0.00530373165383935, 0.027990512549877167, -0.002547077601775527, -0.07148066908121109, 0.027472546324133873, -0.05960432067513466, 0.006498791743069887, -0.02859380841255188, -0.017274195328354836, 0.033931560814380646, -0.040824469178915024, 0.017954112961888313, -0.014316346496343613, 0.02962680160999298, -0.039343588054180145, 0.008031835779547691, -0.01564756967127323, -0.006841433700174093, -0.009741434827446938, -0.020075758919119835, 0.006254707928746939, -0.03724692016839981, 0.03586551174521446, 0.0464668907225132, 0.001436638180166483, -0.027087949216365814, -0.0396059975028038, 0.02183813601732254, 0.016288353130221367, 0.028468560427427292, 0.02959846891462803, -0.011514308862388134, -0.07900490611791611, 0.01641855388879776, 0.04445008188486099, 0.0382513627409935, 0.014389070682227612, -0.014363850466907024, -0.022353127598762512, -0.0007560974918305874, -0.021464306861162186, 0.018494244664907455, 0.012826296500861645, 0.004106389824301004, 0.006201775744557381, 0.0656399354338646, 0.005304356571286917, -0.04134397208690643, 0.03157929703593254, 0.039133232086896896, 0.022724982351064682, 0.021351074799895287, -0.01764853484928608, -0.0034063702914863825, -0.006198860704898834, 0.013696900568902493, 0.02082284912467003, -0.008007676340639591, 0.010435945354402065, -0.014218796044588089, 0.040780629962682724, -0.0072105019353330135, 0.011676662601530552, 0.014797985553741455, 0.03932242840528488, 0.045018263161182404, 0.016449537128210068, -0.0491802841424942, 0.047032106667757034, 0.033151138573884964, 0.00034219949156977236, 0.05651138350367546, -0.025844477117061615, -0.0869850441813469, -0.0014931339537724853, 0.043412525206804276, 0.02270350605249405, -0.04890294745564461, -0.006446337327361107, -0.05020352452993393, 0.00024635891895741224, 0.04219571128487587, -0.018683940172195435, 0.03542622923851013, -0.009657804854214191, -0.014923898503184319, -0.011378739960491657, -0.05043034255504608, -0.032528106123209, 0.041769906878471375, 0.04251106083393097, 0.037890058010816574, -0.028521187603473663, -0.043787214905023575, -0.02330869436264038, -0.009181926026940346, 0.0009111658437177539, 0.06668942421674728, 0.003308499464765191, 0.004826972261071205, 0.013125108554959297, 0.06258973479270935, 0.02106519229710102, -0.06274831295013428, 0.003817496821284294, 0.011800744570791721, -0.03530454635620117, 0.03914010152220726, -0.006772162858396769, -0.04971407353878021, 0.02773796208202839, -0.005543423350900412, -0.010927832685410976, 0.006957442034035921, -0.0648430585861206, 0.032045260071754456, -0.004491367377340794, 0.038769062608480453, 0.01515952404588461, 0.05245722085237503, 0.011611104011535645, -0.02102692611515522, -0.011271340772509575, -0.006659578066319227, -0.03823050111532211, 0.02597363106906414, 0.004686885513365269, -0.023583993315696716, -0.03642033785581589, 0.0498213991522789, -0.003567909123376012, 0.015114781446754932, -0.022246286273002625, -0.0009966460056602955, -0.014817895367741585, 0.028659628704190254, 0.008060254156589508, -0.018283924087882042, 0.0028252420015633106, -0.005737978965044022, -0.021602729335427284, -0.023236161097884178, 0.009992768056690693, -0.011369411833584309, -0.025230739265680313, 0.04348737373948097, -0.02997004985809326, 0.010850607417523861, -0.009863493964076042, 0.010791881009936333, 0.013617093674838543, -0.004386219661682844, 0.026853857561945915, 0.002772188512608409, 0.027225257828831673, -0.014662647619843483, -0.029329193755984306, 0.007963474839925766, 0.03472787141799927, 0.06227976828813553, 0.03469112142920494, -0.03526962548494339, 0.018077729269862175, -0.02066832408308983, 0.008375735022127628, -0.05429182946681976, -0.038293417543172836, -0.00486127519980073, 0.021287253126502037, -0.03614136949181557, -0.018801374360919, 0.018467679619789124, -0.06189780682325363, -0.053777046501636505, -0.026480428874492645, 0.0638202577829361, -0.0008483996498398483, -0.031052425503730774, -0.016771702095866203, 0.02182380110025406, 0.08087616413831711, -0.028623539954423904, -0.03404374420642853, 0.020485196262598038, -0.009465083479881287, -0.026123953983187675, -0.009710030630230904, 0.033832158893346786, -0.021766118705272675, 0.018516240641474724, -0.02573101967573166, -0.042022526264190674, 0.009150316007435322, -0.015491906553506851, -0.04025552421808243, 0.049313850700855255, 0.018438588827848434, -0.014161655679345131, -0.025767922401428223, 0.013815623708069324, 0.011472310870885849, -0.02386324666440487, 0.014494102448225021, -0.016507264226675034, 0.002561234636232257, -0.03373946622014046, 0.037372320890426636, 0.015485338866710663, -0.0036720188800245523, 0.022890908643603325, 0.04860665276646614, -0.0002833481412380934, -0.011121083050966263, 0.016231421381235123, -0.007879075594246387, 0.025333525612950325, 0.025164982303977013, 0.004411804489791393, -0.0038371835835278034, 0.0005134730017744005, -0.03909538686275482, -0.053142890334129333, -0.011615830473601818, 0.0007216017693281174, 0.0757550522685051, 0.0023404306266456842, 0.030443798750638962, 0.010275163687765598, -0.033774424344301224, -0.006973247975111008, 0.001368977129459381, 0.006242380943149328, -0.024872412905097008, -0.023778755217790604, 0.03489315137267113, -0.012435626238584518, -0.0023502360563725233, 0.0029735553544014692, -0.01572289504110813, 0.010360579006373882, 0.017385652288794518, -0.008613072335720062, -0.004985668696463108, 0.0030307446140795946, -0.001715650549158454, -0.07832033187150955, 0.04140984266996384, -0.030433351173996925, 0.03571811690926552, -0.043120741844177246, -0.013006077148020267, 0.044366542249917984, 0.012194563634693623, 0.0044350954703986645, -0.04939856007695198, -0.01804525777697563, -0.04725978523492813, -0.03177237510681152, 0.028697099536657333, -0.023004774004220963, 0.044879000633955, 0.03003394603729248, 0.020400870591402054, 0.005322475451976061, 0.020615022629499435, -0.02464265003800392, -0.09412163496017456, -0.03781890869140625, -0.02061958611011505, -0.00364341726526618, 0.046624794602394104, -0.006707062944769859, -0.021354837343096733, 0.02431197464466095, -0.03732078894972801, 0.0040545957162976265, -0.02329004369676113, 0.05706577003002167, -0.008983182720839977, 0.0655534565448761, 0.007522541098296642, 0.02356758341193199, -0.013969413004815578, 0.04178595915436745, 0.1036352589726448, 0.08034876734018326, 0.02931951731443405, -0.09371349215507507, 0.03694663196802139, -0.022197509184479713, -0.014374842867255211, -0.03156061843037605, 0.01113620214164257, -0.0012082766043022275, -0.019125113263726234, 0.030058028176426888, 0.026995379477739334, -0.007851682603359222, 0.011450149118900299, 0.04095381870865822, -0.02601386234164238, -0.004261958412826061, 0.004494669381529093, 0.052093151956796646, -0.006488030776381493, -0.032257623970508575, -0.0008957457612268627, 0.019161850214004517, -0.03468506410717964, -0.024200448766350746, 0.010753451846539974, -0.011419075541198254, 0.0003667888231575489, -0.02594459429383278, -0.048903971910476685, -0.017391536384820938, 0.0455617792904377, -0.00875250156968832, -0.033451441675424576, -0.04345747455954552, -0.018309839069843292, -0.03711581975221634, 0.038471341133117676, 0.012472176924347878, -0.002880989108234644, 0.0129136573523283, 0.0011233719997107983, -0.0006388454930856824, -0.02670942060649395, 0.004000012297183275, 0.012086479924619198, 0.030954057350754738, 0.0020210777875036, 0.014136469922959805, -0.023925142362713814, 0.009153640829026699, 0.013256256468594074, -0.003963155671954155, 0.014042962342500687, 0.014820999465882778, 0.04127452149987221, -0.08329521119594574, -0.003367691533640027, -0.034678272902965546, 0.013153846375644207, -0.01942088082432747, 0.04276452586054802, 0.044427964836359024, -0.02699955925345421, 0.012130255810916424, 0.0015754675259813666, 0.050468914210796356, 0.0093876663595438, -0.019179701805114746, -0.019297031685709953, -0.002098638331517577, -0.012760820798575878, 0.015462570823729038, 0.02236395888030529, 0.002532799495384097, 0.008340473286807537, -0.006041292101144791, -0.010675525292754173, -0.03595399856567383, -0.048296138644218445, 0.036774732172489166, -0.03437693789601326, -0.02588232420384884, -0.03879862651228905, 0.02838774211704731, 0.0465579479932785, 0.05551917850971222, 0.010809704661369324, -0.012674150988459587, -0.008952180854976177, 0.037251222878694534, 0.028513142839074135, -0.06071670725941658, -0.002767951227724552, -0.016226427629590034, -0.029825355857610703, 0.04322921484708786, -0.010914412327110767, 0.0189532320946455, 0.014086476527154446, 0.02763870172202587, -0.021097151562571526, 0.010245372541248798, -0.011881155893206596, 0.016509003937244415, 0.028791239485144615, -0.05020754784345627, 0.007978777401149273, 0.009804224595427513, 0.011710667982697487, -0.026009848341345787, -0.041970524936914444, -0.020441774278879166, 0.025742491707205772, 0.0035988762974739075, -0.012023834511637688, -0.036812011152505875, 0.007066333666443825, 0.003845151513814926, -0.0019263677531853318, -0.07256744801998138, -0.008156600408256054, -0.05829697102308273, -0.0369747169315815, 0.009068084880709648, -0.030367661267518997, -0.022947123274207115, -0.007564695086330175, -0.01655104197561741, 0.005943808238953352, 0.0390559583902359, 0.006182832643389702, 0.008787923492491245, -0.030110545456409454, 0.0027228854596614838, -0.036943335086107254, 0.03102823719382286, -0.04113198444247246, -0.026157157495617867, 0.0009236058685928583, -0.008055509999394417, -0.02208334021270275, 0.032467301934957504, -0.01367905829101801, 0.030057374387979507, 0.017418110743165016, 0.02823627181351185, -0.021472569555044174, 0.0035941563546657562, -0.007347090169787407, 0.03408540412783623, 0.03942037373781204, 0.02484486624598503, 0.02710605412721634, 0.010214151814579964, 0.009347544983029366, 0.027965350076556206, -0.003566612023860216, -0.008497088216245174, 0.03163117170333862, 0.0169917531311512, -0.022897133603692055, 0.00540801789611578, 0.020157497376203537, 0.010468955151736736, -0.009809400886297226, -0.006597659084945917, 0.046496592462062836, 0.044494230300188065, -0.0013398336013779044, 0.006878993008285761, 0.007811587769538164, 0.018567726016044617, -0.07439298182725906, -0.007712014485150576, 0.011940591968595982, 0.034306686371564865, 0.032583244144916534, -0.022003501653671265, -0.0020823709201067686, 0.03376009315252304, -0.026602422818541527, 0.03031850792467594, 0.019697969779372215, 0.0020837660413235426, -0.027566269040107727, -0.036602094769477844, -0.013884597457945347, 0.007895848713815212, 0.06313986331224442, 0.04067235812544823, 0.022102635353803635, 0.05365866422653198, 0.024698790162801743, -0.03224974125623703, 0.0060282559134066105, -0.008768794126808643, 0.009603139944374561, -0.046204689890146255, 0.06789971143007278, -0.04147151857614517, -0.05111822858452797, 0.019015008583664894, -0.00510970177128911, 0.053433340042829514, 0.009129181504249573, 0.030123967677354813, -0.032833781093358994, 0.057819630950689316, 0.05406273156404495, -0.00866682082414627, 0.0017430876614525914, 0.010992772877216339, 0.013764637522399426, 0.028627369552850723, -0.006157271098345518, -0.020720116794109344, -0.019476236775517464, -0.030541041865944862, -0.039166584610939026, 0.007447026204317808, 0.004122678656131029, -0.020234402269124985, 0.03250911459326744, -0.009419227950274944, -0.007712772581726313, -0.013036883436143398, 0.033155255019664764, -0.02253069169819355, -0.011695587076246738, 0.04324482008814812, 0.019509200006723404, -0.03982140123844147, 0.005941715091466904, -0.02326611988246441, -0.057420264929533005, 0.04725296422839165, 0.00654012942686677, 0.014242284931242466, -0.07770688831806183, -0.00001464403158024652, -0.015521856024861336, -0.056505195796489716, -0.04390868544578552, 0.021580006927251816, -0.01536780409514904, 0.03723348677158356, -0.02202613651752472, 0.0013196321669965982, 0.03353292495012283, -0.008434326387941837, -0.008095057681202888, -0.04128219559788704, 0.05259783938527107, 0.013911465182900429, 0.01697365567088127, 0.0016402163309976459, -0.007220515515655279, -0.06188042834401131, -0.015526135452091694, 0.05765204876661301, -0.023626739159226418, -0.00852985680103302, 0.020948586985468864, 0.008115106262266636, -0.03496353328227997, -0.04483417421579361, 0.022899756208062172, -0.018641510978341103, 0.009676985442638397, 0.0026084696874022484, -0.038265831768512726, 0.006196414120495319, -0.02046918123960495, 0.02571600116789341, 0.025852764025330544, 0.0019202280091121793, 0.01658017374575138, 0.014844847843050957, 0.03957759588956833, 0.021036667749285698, -0.01657082512974739, 0.07641815394163132, 0.020117713138461113, 0.007157834246754646, 0.03823799267411232, -0.004578383639454842, -0.0987762063741684, 0.01760193146765232, -0.03036843240261078, -0.03865044564008713, 0.0009294746560044587, 0.022488268092274666, -0.00040228100260719657, -0.061155661940574646, -0.009409163147211075, 0.06776406615972519, -0.0026842730585485697, -0.00008066205191425979, 0.0325029194355011, 0.0034578158520162106, 0.010780156590044498, -0.019639572128653526, 0.005079981405287981, 0.04260210692882538, 0.02768181636929512, -0.008354672230780125, 0.000993708148598671, 0.031768400222063065, 0.020701279863715172, 0.01528877206146717, -0.005209615454077721, 0.02014485001564026, 0.02535255067050457, -0.010793931782245636, 0.009188346564769745, -0.05011032149195671, -0.012923594564199448, 0.012690803967416286, -0.006679806392639875, 0.019211972132325172, 0.000696508155670017, 0.006050379015505314, 0.007157013285905123, -0.03348445147275925, -0.015787113457918167, -0.025467664003372192, -0.004845507442951202, -0.023788323625922203, 0.015109067782759666, -0.002634579548612237, -0.011713220737874508, -0.009206795133650303, -0.003608059138059616, 0.03427056223154068, 0.008275586180388927, -0.015738483518362045, -0.02620445378124714, -0.021513381972908974, -0.0281676072627306, -0.021483618766069412, -0.02671145647764206, -0.038799650967121124, -0.048862479627132416, -0.01352376863360405, 0.018845925107598305, 0.04759553074836731, 0.0002472043561283499, -0.02278873883187771, -0.03527718782424927, -0.023027826100587845, 0.061801977455616, -0.08542990684509277, 0.012258741073310375, -0.03490915521979332, -0.01021331362426281, 0.022878898307681084, -0.05751759186387062 ]
<p>Suppose you have $n$ players play a round robin tournament. A win adds 1 to the winning score of a player while a loss adds nothing. After the round robin tournament is finished the players are assigned ranks based on their scores, with ties being broken at random, the top player receiving a rank of $n-1$ and the bottom player receiving a rank of 0. What is the relationship between the expected value of the $\textbf{score}$ of player $i$ and the expected value of the $\textbf{rank}$ of player $i$?</p> <p>Sample result of a tournament with 5 players: $scores=(3,3,2,1,1)$ and $ranks=(3,4,2,1,0)$</p> <p>Addition information: A player $i$ has an attribute $\lambda_i$. The probability that player i beats player $j$ in a game is $\frac{\lambda_i}{\lambda_i+\lambda_j}$.</p> <p>Numerical simulations suggest that taken across players, the two quantities perfectly correlated, but I don't know how to prove this. Any references would be appreciated.</p>
73,415
[ -0.0335029736161232, -0.04971771687269211, -0.018713831901550293, -0.018985092639923096, 0.038017235696315765, 0.04184648394584656, 0.015411392785608768, 0.025212300941348076, 0.029499370604753494, -0.03550875931978226, 0.021822867915034294, 0.043329887092113495, 0.05870277062058449, 0.061500392854213715, 0.002127696294337511, 0.007943985983729362, -0.00934529583901167, 0.010464322753250599, -0.0026798478793352842, 0.011530891992151737, 0.024765674024820328, 0.014384336769580841, 0.026127610355615616, -0.010532019659876823, -0.046280525624752045, 0.04948505759239197, 0.004306488670408726, -0.041354257613420486, 0.02196178026497364, 0.06240202113986015, 0.0004467811086215079, 0.0034360031131654978, 0.006391272880136967, 0.04656434804201126, 0.011202037334442139, -0.011094419285655022, -0.026889484375715256, -0.03457694500684738, 0.011869498528540134, -0.012021545320749283, -0.014428296126425266, -0.04721963033080101, 0.01808025874197483, 0.034877147525548935, -0.01547989621758461, 0.03496043384075165, -0.013260477222502232, -0.021311363205313683, 0.03731696680188179, -0.043343547731637955, 0.061331912875175476, 0.003367153462022543, 0.04667098820209503, 0.02511417493224144, -0.03674957528710365, 0.021268729120492935, 0.03837855905294418, 0.0739172101020813, -0.0017023325199261308, -0.05048799142241478, 0.005545786581933498, -0.0482274554669857, -0.010104121640324593, -0.005236495286226273, -0.04164688661694527, 0.034492213279008865, -0.01592070981860161, -0.017303649336099625, 0.04779606685042381, 0.009117500856518745, -0.03373176231980324, 0.04555927589535713, 0.04115999490022659, -0.019218947738409042, 0.01945856399834156, -0.0268419086933136, 0.05563216283917427, 0.025471394881606102, 0.03916781023144722, 0.019271498546004295, 0.026539435610175133, -0.009678506292402744, 0.03584795072674751, 0.059925541281700134, 0.041741322726011276, -0.013223805464804173, 0.021852806210517883, -0.03188943490386009, 0.0456189289689064, -0.0023867094423621893, -0.025267718359827995, -0.018008947372436523, 0.01579952798783779, -0.04994453862309456, -0.05591685697436333, 0.017114413902163506, -0.036725036799907684, 0.05166865140199661, 0.01538259070366621, 0.0021153062116354704, -0.011397292837500572, -0.050845902413129807, -0.005393866915255785, 0.0417800098657608, 0.004092776216566563, -0.025208858773112297, -0.04268787056207657, 0.010224692523479462, -0.021718259900808334, -0.015237304382026196, -0.012952104210853577, 0.0266143549233675, 0.015458041802048683, -0.015560791827738285, -0.014940908178687096, -0.02240643836557865, 0.00831013172864914, 0.007135460618883371, 0.08230455964803696, 0.04459994286298752, 0.006238075438886881, -0.0377923883497715, -0.00040957648889161646, -0.04026617109775543, -0.03504064679145813, 0.005885083694010973, 0.045161861926317215, -0.031103486195206642, -0.049680739641189575, 0.028182649984955788, -0.021281138062477112, -0.002923134947195649, 0.043743763118982315, 0.007143757771700621, -0.0038349723909050226, -0.005906263366341591, -0.12260819971561432, -0.029918724671006203, 0.03772028535604477, -0.014079057611525059, -0.020317470654845238, -0.05679380148649216, -0.008224149234592915, 0.043219782412052155, 0.07443492114543915, 0.016265571117401123, 0.029194431379437447, -0.0004298969579394907, 0.03471340611577034, 0.05248071998357773, -0.001760872662998736, -0.03469664976000786, -0.023141978308558464, -0.030141035094857216, -0.003037854563444853, -0.0746145248413086, 0.021511556580662727, 0.04809490218758583, -0.019300401210784912, 0.0016243630088865757, 0.043129269033670425, 0.01453628670424223, -0.007947982288897038, -0.03129586577415466, 0.03695834428071976, -0.0286213718354702, 0.030720368027687073, -0.008950420655310154, 0.018434911966323853, 0.006626568268984556, 0.0005600132863037288, -0.022409573197364807, 0.039900731295347214, 0.05900059640407562, 0.04379494488239288, -0.026576999574899673, -0.02630464918911457, -0.024736445397138596, -0.02756132371723652, -0.023022858425974846, -0.06354866921901703, -0.048313431441783905, -0.022228911519050598, 0.023318760097026825, 0.02697083167731762, 0.02507047727704048, 0.012663169763982296, 0.013846402987837791, 0.014566516503691673, -0.03746800869703293, -0.03699467331171036, -0.09347914904356003, 0.01517785806208849, 0.0022956482134759426, -0.02647225558757782, 0.040686868131160736, 0.016029907390475273, 0.030674485489726067, -0.015185031108558178, 0.004149296786636114, -0.014250818639993668, 0.0023262565955519676, 0.04164610803127289, -0.04449628293514252, -0.02498292736709118, 0.06012747809290886, 0.04404908046126366, -0.016729069873690605, 0.045276764780282974, -0.01931857131421566, -0.09077534824609756, 0.014949727803468704, -0.04001966118812561, 0.023525871336460114, -0.00825008749961853, 0.0019007017835974693, 0.03066295199096203, 0.004711893852800131, 0.017916785553097725, 0.02659405581653118, -0.05626203864812851, 0.03168514743447304, 0.026749977841973305, 0.019057925790548325, 0.02787892147898674, 0.006245926022529602, -0.012689877301454544, 0.003778077894821763, -0.014431972056627274, -0.014673424884676933, -0.024337980896234512, -0.004118070472031832, 0.016437705606222153, 0.03855222836136818, -0.03020390309393406, 0.028219852596521378, 0.07796701043844223, 0.012647041119635105, 0.0042133331298828125, 0.03346342593431473, -0.026071209460496902, 0.0013817037688568234, 0.012283614836633205, 0.03784031420946121, 0.01351462583988905, -0.015831459313631058, -0.02069447562098503, -0.011009822599589825, 0.01785167306661606, 0.005122206639498472, -0.0043392302468419075, 0.014737585559487343, 0.03541230782866478, 0.04699285328388214, -0.04835104942321777, -0.0021129376254975796, 0.0655142217874527, -0.0161414947360754, -0.009942276403307915, 0.010929660871624947, 0.02450634352862835, 0.004137389827519655, -0.01150034461170435, -0.012279339134693146, -0.0008663715561851859, 0.007726169656962156, -0.04749823734164238, 0.020472249016165733, 0.0022789170034229755, -0.029516031965613365, 0.011131423525512218, -0.007964740507304668, -0.003469690680503845, -0.025999128818511963, -0.00042831606697291136, 0.031110787764191628, -0.020729638636112213, 0.004487987142056227, -0.03542643040418625, -0.04993309825658798, -0.016119323670864105, -0.012805036269128323, -0.011542441323399544, 0.04271616041660309, -0.06171794608235359, -0.001318776747211814, -0.037314318120479584, -0.010349865071475506, 0.027884632349014282, -0.010336142964661121, -0.008292283862829208, 0.02257302589714527, -0.015821797773241997, -0.03484809771180153, -0.05465935543179512, -0.024195188656449318, 0.011910626664757729, -0.027851123362779617, -0.01706051081418991, 0.04244194179773331, 0.007288768887519836, -0.06757692247629166, 0.0309258121997118, -0.016219953075051308, -0.011885137297213078, -0.026299744844436646, -0.00806050281971693, 0.026430243626236916, -0.013846584595739841, 0.011371866799890995, 0.031057707965373993, 0.037468068301677704, -0.007831229828298092, -0.08229321241378784, -0.07502301782369614, 0.04443869739770889, -0.011381183750927448, 0.06126793473958969, 0.01178030762821436, -0.01804959774017334, 0.037185344845056534, -0.0010259111877530813, -0.007365524768829346, -0.042463287711143494, 0.018490973860025406, -0.00063093047356233, 0.0066607072949409485, 0.0168767087161541, 0.020536744967103004, 0.011708447709679604, 0.09868813306093216, 0.030987760052084923, 0.02693188562989235, 0.029646258801221848, 0.008383031003177166, -0.01390440110117197, 0.011939420364797115, 0.0057912287302315235, -0.019537262618541718, 0.03464740142226219, -0.00978549662977457, -0.03535473346710205, 0.006905387155711651, -0.004127703607082367, -0.011898702010512352, 0.010688104666769505, -0.04730568826198578, 0.04603024199604988, -0.016756238415837288, -0.011308406479656696, -0.034800898283720016, 0.05868024751543999, 0.04069255664944649, -0.0014183897292241454, -0.0008882969850674272, 0.04498464614152908, 0.030300328508019447, -0.018869547173380852, 0.04559999331831932, 0.0695997029542923, -0.0032547391019761562, -0.0478740856051445, -0.02869454398751259, -0.015072999522089958, 0.01678808033466339, 0.01813754253089428, -0.026459287852048874, -0.0013314844109117985, 0.02066800743341446, 0.024910015985369682, -0.005607766564935446, -0.00543812895193696, -0.007964534685015678, -0.012041708454489708, -0.07046914100646973, -0.018243705853819847, -0.04409566521644592, 0.04774269089102745, 0.00689083943143487, 0.0830940380692482, 0.010009166784584522, -0.014455377124249935, 0.026909613981842995, -0.010883329436182976, -0.07084950804710388, -0.01150162611156702, -0.018114766106009483, 0.015376542694866657, 0.001060426002368331, -0.019709840416908264, 0.029334567487239838, -0.02797088772058487, -0.0316665880382061, -0.009703246876597404, 0.04555792361497879, -0.0394112803041935, 0.006725527811795473, -0.04301845654845238, -0.03448721393942833, 0.0441570058465004, 0.017916198819875717, 0.0037269368767738342, -0.040979914367198944, 0.027483463287353516, 0.043381594121456146, 0.008573121391236782, -0.034399788826704025, -0.02377936989068985, 0.029231294989585876, 0.03673996776342392, -0.0012762468541041017, 0.06374634802341461, 0.020885586738586426, -0.030789343640208244, 0.040038030594587326, -0.01998731680214405, 0.044159140437841415, 0.028601255267858505, -0.026378873735666275, 0.03212687373161316, -0.030090300366282463, -0.02691875398159027, 0.009513799101114273, 0.009473378770053387, -0.005457376595586538, -0.0009258468053303659, 0.0004323439206928015, 0.0475069060921669, -0.059883102774620056, 0.020740948617458344, 0.03565037623047829, 0.03462852165102959, 0.015419850125908852, -0.03693564981222153, 0.028145888820290565, -0.0008596290135756135, -0.008776914328336716, 0.03404535353183746, -0.0015048265922814608, 0.013691501691937447, -0.010540907271206379, 0.030556695535779, -0.016141092404723167, -0.003095541847869754, 0.006364544853568077, 0.021859215572476387, 0.054552190005779266, 0.0024249262642115355, -0.014516422525048256, -0.00453238096088171, 0.028412742540240288, 0.029001787304878235, 0.01982695236802101, -0.017215780913829803, -0.053248755633831024, -0.033286202698946, 0.014496068470180035, 0.034833624958992004, -0.03058602102100849, 0.015355528332293034, -0.05056781694293022, -0.01862460747361183, 0.014665644615888596, -0.006117993965744972, 0.03479781374335289, 0.01918460614979267, -0.0085348691791296, 0.0008986316388472915, -0.010210245847702026, -0.02413843758404255, 0.02425418049097061, -0.008406033739447594, 0.05907924100756645, -0.03279346600174904, -0.02531580440700054, -0.018944595009088516, 0.00550934998318553, 0.04947346821427345, 0.03346818685531616, -0.033712297677993774, -0.017206810414791107, -0.015716275200247765, 0.02092624641954899, -0.009823967702686787, -0.08648694306612015, 0.03344181552529335, 0.016137689352035522, 0.013334852643311024, 0.02675686404109001, -0.03001815266907215, -0.011345511302351952, -0.011823094449937344, 0.02870422974228859, -0.02268652804195881, 0.020830335095524788, -0.027385620400309563, 0.05704376474022865, 0.0235479474067688, -0.01628713123500347, 0.02327384240925312, 0.00738943787291646, 0.007182672154158354, -0.013927729800343513, 0.005092823412269354, 0.010732457973062992, -0.006283895578235388, 0.061633702367544174, -0.00795398186892271, -0.010533194057643414, -0.027997033670544624, 0.02831435017287731, 0.02299945428967476, 0.04018713906407356, -0.000312633317662403, -0.029878918081521988, -0.05216912552714348, -0.00900599267333746, -0.025755787268280983, -0.003628065111115575, -0.021734267473220825, 0.006105732172727585, 0.012082238681614399, -0.026700187474489212, 0.050353724509477615, 0.004331733100116253, 0.003150355536490679, -0.018465787172317505, 0.004305259324610233, 0.05284501239657402, -0.016446338966488838, -0.004115093965083361, -0.00034038082230836153, -0.027616392821073532, 0.05738796666264534, -0.01978697068989277, 0.01999402791261673, -0.015289143659174442, -0.003126808675006032, -0.016763143241405487, -0.002751832129433751, 0.014804420061409473, 0.01866075210273266, -0.023351583629846573, 0.012783510610461235, 0.008452173322439194, -0.028608564287424088, -0.04673220217227936, -0.03006673976778984, -0.0045518046244978905, 0.021863438189029694, -0.013675161637365818, -0.01468310784548521, 0.014312331564724445, -0.006469604093581438, -0.041359882801771164, 0.011564712040126324, -0.014426330104470253, -0.033952947705984116, -0.030198989436030388, 0.05762527137994766, -0.0014687145594507456, 0.0493309311568737, 0.012833772227168083, -0.015880383551120758, 0.0003057881840504706, 0.012523368932306767, -0.004769946448504925, -0.035177119076251984, 0.044491663575172424, -0.015824509784579277, -0.0008730255649425089, -0.011305100284516811, 0.03497757390141487, 0.014771304093301296, -0.006609595380723476, -0.02539096400141716, -0.012435048818588257, -0.011439461261034012, -0.002116493182256818, -0.03392975777387619, 0.0057982876896858215, -0.004054068122059107, 0.025625405833125114, 0.004557892680168152, 0.009382517077028751, -0.0317436121404171, -0.0008213449618779123, 0.008612566627562046, -0.005564955994486809, 0.019551411271095276, -0.006539486814290285, 0.07065077126026154, -0.01609906554222107, -0.019994404166936874, 0.011593878269195557, -0.0148997250944376, 0.05951303243637085, 0.028752952814102173, -0.013598683290183544, 0.016088206321001053, 0.02331472933292389, -0.018744727596640587, -0.04322522506117821, -0.06367040425539017, 0.012634165585041046, 0.07365591078996658, -0.013540741987526417, 0.04306183382868767, 0.035088300704956055, 0.022828564047813416, -0.011111501604318619, -0.004723677411675453, 0.009049618616700172, -0.005317480303347111, -0.028506148606538773, 0.04322393611073494, -0.021222703158855438, -0.02880403771996498, 0.027668071910738945, 0.04997504875063896, -0.01207749079912901, 0.03642110526561737, 0.018532032147049904, 0.0016927880933508277, 0.031266793608665466, -0.02356119453907013, -0.04780632257461548, 0.03777103126049042, -0.0643773078918457, 0.025463225319981575, -0.023657893761992455, -0.01187160424888134, 0.08595214784145355, 0.030124057084321976, -0.006238317117094994, -0.04331917688250542, -0.026051141321659088, -0.011565132066607475, -0.008941666223108768, -0.020645003765821457, -0.004193635191768408, 0.022742781788110733, -0.012590611353516579, 0.037722695618867874, -0.014547820203006268, 0.028533054515719414, -0.028436338528990746, -0.06414587050676346, 0.007946941070258617, -0.009420163929462433, -0.05124102905392647, 0.00058013666421175, -0.000653966679237783, -0.012229795567691326, 0.028170611709356308, -0.02750038541853428, 0.030588602647185326, -0.009736987762153149, 0.033133529126644135, -0.028191620483994484, 0.08722389489412308, 0.0007498726481571794, 0.031170250847935677, 0.000283162051346153, -0.0005437993095256388, 0.12157344818115234, 0.05846470594406128, 0.0489845871925354, -0.04863954335451126, 0.014290918596088886, 0.03887258097529411, 0.013382719829678535, -0.030607646331191063, 0.0033975313417613506, 0.005465917754918337, 0.00243183970451355, 0.0494626946747303, 0.056028515100479126, 0.00947586726397276, -0.01784921996295452, 0.02155282348394394, -0.0631621778011322, -0.011923338286578655, -0.02249765768647194, 0.004294074606150389, 0.030785122886300087, -0.008709829300642014, -0.002394874580204487, 0.019383050501346588, 0.023074405267834663, -0.013256118632853031, -0.005025829654186964, 0.0036809034645557404, -0.015343751758337021, 0.011411190964281559, -0.0059263985604047775, -0.001883629709482193, 0.037854745984077454, 0.0022950065322220325, 0.0010053771547973156, 0.029059551656246185, 0.014575053937733173, -0.025493618100881577, 0.008919190615415573, 0.014407356269657612, 0.03727375715970993, -0.005768079776316881, 0.03397807106375694, 0.0267903171479702, -0.07902726531028748, -0.0054186568595469, -0.03970275819301605, 0.018252750858664513, -0.026118306443095207, 0.009180261753499508, -0.038403674960136414, -0.024330008774995804, -0.03313235566020012, -0.024316446855664253, -0.05917704850435257, 0.033838238567113876, 0.0485537089407444, -0.04845011979341507, -0.021874338388442993, -0.02013496123254299, 0.03156084567308426, -0.02447855845093727, 0.017993025481700897, 0.049767978489398956, -0.03938078135251999, -0.05045925825834274, -0.0550755150616169, 0.00812535546720028, 0.020895252004265785, -0.0061778295785188675, -0.046715859323740005, -0.015516958199441433, -0.026638267561793327, -0.014281339943408966, -0.04476458579301834, 0.002533107530325651, 0.03725213557481766, 0.015541746281087399, -0.010434677824378014, 0.023295408114790916, -0.06256864964962006, 0.013288890942931175, -0.05352527275681496, -0.04111989960074425, -0.022970130667090416, 0.009457127191126347, 0.033310361206531525, 0.00435065571218729, -0.02215990051627159, -0.02834666706621647, 0.019306698814034462, 0.04282952472567558, 0.018623976036906242, -0.012570559978485107, -0.0008197465795092285, -0.026540840044617653, -0.05395130068063736, 0.021443059667944908, -0.0181070938706398, 0.05524122342467308, 0.04253631830215454, 0.004476206377148628, 0.022570108994841576, 0.009324473328888416, 0.0005521724815480411, 0.0008865242707543075, 0.02076035551726818, -0.06117742881178856, 0.018194954842329025, 0.005551418289542198, 0.029406685382127762, -0.03262288495898247, -0.01828417368233204, -0.002443118952214718, -0.026081940159201622, 0.017662854865193367, -0.04992106556892395, -0.022709812968969345, -0.03449081629514694, -0.03687427565455437, 0.03134949877858162, -0.024492749944329262, -0.027724605053663254, -0.02535237930715084, -0.01961338520050049, 0.02666940540075302, 0.0208815298974514, -0.009553324431180954, 0.020402900874614716, -0.008348003961145878, -0.0231078639626503, 0.033592868596315384, 0.03373229131102562, 0.005380736198276281, -0.007126528304070234, -0.02560563199222088, -0.031834907829761505, 0.05244661867618561, -0.0019550330471247435, -0.06496588885784149, 0.06115341931581497, -0.03256022185087204, -0.005150943528860807, 0.01791883073747158, 0.012814008630812168, 0.05056312680244446, 0.010306229814887047, -0.019251052290201187, -0.06741100549697876, 0.034555159509181976, -0.02623649872839451, -0.022784942761063576, 0.01587669365108013, 0.013993988744914532, -0.00904237013310194, 0.010824611410498619, -0.03411489352583885, -0.0009147673263214529, -0.014371358789503574, -0.008695274591445923, 0.006321280263364315, -0.0298813134431839, 0.009412623941898346, 0.039068132638931274, 0.0012314397608861327, 0.015310685150325298, -0.011694451794028282, -0.013055996038019657, 0.0044621373526751995, 0.05928982421755791, -0.011130129918456078, 0.04063894599676132, 0.0011330832494422793, -0.0195095706731081, -0.06524945050477982, -0.005778588354587555, 0.03416820615530014, -0.020350879058241844, -0.005903611890971661, -0.04229472950100899, 0.021092787384986877, 0.011887402273714542, -0.060591936111450195, 0.036168672144412994, 0.02672499045729637, -0.009662264958024025, -0.061103928834199905, 0.012506147846579552, -0.02447459101676941, -0.02745143324136734, 0.043153904378414154, 0.030631940811872482, 0.06284403800964355, 0.045864030718803406, -0.0004333663091529161, -0.018370894715189934, -0.07356911897659302, 0.027281254529953003, 0.005557355470955372, -0.05193796753883362, 0.027206337079405785, -0.024108082056045532, -0.043263934552669525, 0.018291277810931206, -0.018718097358942032, -0.013322150334715843, 0.013713015243411064, 0.004783032462000847, -0.016384106129407883, 0.045440904796123505, -0.00947781465947628, -0.02729569748044014, 0.012618374079465866, -0.00842809583991766, 0.010039195418357849, -0.009039731696248055, -0.02863778918981552, 0.04408669099211693, 0.05579804629087448, -0.003234394360333681, -0.0460636131465435, -0.0016222989652305841, 0.023107456043362617, -0.0017367583932355046, 0.035891078412532806, -0.015387539751827717, 0.02431410551071167, -0.04601620137691498, 0.03167123347520828, -0.016557922586798668, -0.0164932943880558, 0.023630287498235703, 0.049373894929885864, -0.005883537698537111, -0.01286532822996378, 0.01805640012025833, -0.04051452875137329, 0.011929287575185299, 0.002637297846376896, 0.019113732501864433, -0.04923820123076439, 0.002228118246421218, -0.01616731844842434, 0.008402632549405098, -0.04678324609994888, -0.06441238522529602, -0.03896787390112877, 0.0278070829808712, -0.012333567254245281, 0.024403557181358337, -0.019673563539981842, -0.01596873253583908, -0.0033603536430746317, -0.08670748025178909, 0.026714658364653587, 0.03199509531259537, 0.01049034669995308, -0.009263373911380768, 0.008570984937250614, -0.021152189001441002, -0.007958960719406605, 0.03791625797748566, -0.01765369437634945, -0.057904958724975586, -0.017770159989595413, 0.026745105162262917, -0.006984949577599764, -0.03748023137450218, 0.030626285821199417, -0.08203879743814468, -0.0032707408536225557, -0.02961285039782524, -0.036782924085855484, 0.02619032748043537, 0.016604578122496605, 0.034565944224596024, -0.05208348110318184, -0.018497606739401817, -0.03946255147457123, -0.0071598379872739315, 0.02989199385046959, -0.014268802478909492, -0.026999233290553093, 0.083919957280159, 0.02593942917883396, 0.01857697404921055, -0.0010029954137280583, -0.01652546413242817, -0.05919261649250984, 0.06247727945446968, -0.030213966965675354, -0.03575818985700607, -0.0060003772377967834, 0.03296462446451187, -0.021774636581540108, -0.04287956655025482, -0.005106254946440458, 0.042139019817113876, -0.03150100260972977, -0.007260696031153202, 0.031120728701353073, 0.040346402674913406, 0.02785668335855007, 0.025278374552726746, 0.02498420886695385, 0.005159236490726471, -0.02055877074599266, 0.006519760936498642, 0.05118963494896889, 0.04729489982128143, 0.031771495938301086, 0.03683752939105034, 0.02063198760151863, 0.012618022970855236, 0.03159584477543831, -0.00009962020703824237, 0.015308305621147156, -0.010067366063594818, -0.01005081832408905, 0.022944800555706024, -0.01782400719821453, 0.032228097319602966, 0.007864573039114475, -0.01273138914257288, 0.037646085023880005, -0.018229946494102478, -0.013209578581154346, -0.030789660289883614, 0.0001529683795524761, -0.026883138343691826, -0.026953216642141342, 0.0015691008884459734, 0.03611622750759125, 0.002901240484789014, 0.004910014569759369, 0.025538558140397072, -0.010546715930104256, 0.005083166994154453, 0.005622702185064554, 0.025566916912794113, -0.003800834296271205, -0.02352024056017399, 0.0068161627277731895, -0.04736392945051193, 0.027921635657548904, -0.02977723814547062, 0.04687066003680229, 0.02469865418970585, 0.007786821108311415, -0.0018539988668635488, -0.025473708286881447, 0.014845124445855618, 0.0654488056898117, -0.06053109094500542, -0.01241753064095974, -0.07385210692882538, 0.041079502552747726, 0.016728408634662628, -0.03867165371775627 ]
<p>Consider a set of observations $ \{ y_i \}$ and assume a Gaussian model for these data: $y_i \sim \mathcal{N}(\mu, \sigma^2)$. Suppose the mean parameter $\mu$ is known, but the variance parameter $\sigma^2$ is not. The conjugate prior for $\sigma^2$ is then the scaled inverse chi-squared distribution; consequently, we have a nice posterior. Now, suppose instead of $\mathcal{N}(\mu, \sigma^2)$ our model is $\mathcal{N}(\mu, \sigma^2 + \sigma_0^2)$ where $\sigma_0^2$ is known. What can we say regarding the prior and posterior distributions of $\sigma^2$ in this case? Thank you.</p> <p>Regards, Ivan</p>
73,416
[ -0.027689194306731224, -0.032648611813783646, 0.017902735620737076, -0.042009539902210236, 0.05995103344321251, 0.032081302255392075, -0.010969946160912514, -0.01606186293065548, 0.0011716861044988036, -0.06361489742994308, 0.03753524646162987, 0.030954506248235703, 0.08451586216688156, 0.01016890536993742, 0.03375793993473053, -0.0037997784093022346, -0.06321679055690765, -0.010766434483230114, -0.031070487573742867, -0.014520691707730293, 0.011871377006173134, 0.03857874125242233, 0.027681976556777954, -0.022678939625620842, -0.05979881435632706, 0.01529290433973074, 0.02831112965941429, -0.0042591579258441925, -0.044488321989774704, 0.07768746465444565, -0.010717613622546196, -0.02219444513320923, 0.021289629861712456, 0.024121828377246857, -0.0023541124537587166, -0.032714683562517166, 0.00923452340066433, -0.0387544222176075, 0.002773935440927744, 0.02678830549120903, -0.0288618803024292, -0.03697787970304489, -0.00798758678138256, 0.025935469195246696, -0.032769735902547836, 0.0054932632483541965, -0.009375045076012611, -0.03833605349063873, 0.040375418961048126, -0.042778272181749344, 0.08546165376901627, -0.00750085199251771, 0.05041298642754555, 0.03818351775407791, -0.0018953499384224415, -0.021230356767773628, 0.0401759147644043, 0.0532914474606514, -0.01153145357966423, -0.06302005797624588, -0.009343995712697506, -0.023002196103334427, 0.017524227499961853, -0.02830895222723484, -0.031114725396037102, -0.004914863035082817, -0.03150011599063873, -0.01518617756664753, -0.008763250894844532, -0.005435574799776077, 0.015346826985478401, 0.024516353383660316, 0.029151804745197296, 0.015519178472459316, 0.026410391554236412, -0.0362439826130867, 0.011534417979419231, 0.037674035876989365, 0.040417928248643875, 0.006533828563988209, 0.00880763866007328, 0.005940386094152927, 0.012654079124331474, 0.017234012484550476, -0.033021230250597, -0.008158695884048939, 0.05832726135849953, -0.0005501938867382705, 0.010396975092589855, 0.0021220864728093147, -0.018996939063072205, 0.0203241053968668, 0.033883366733789444, -0.0575532391667366, -0.037665098905563354, 0.040919240564107895, -0.01844841241836548, 0.03825295716524124, -0.028641892597079277, -0.0055086868815124035, -0.02248982898890972, -0.020603662356734276, -0.000152763954247348, 0.03867585211992264, -0.04538404196500778, -0.04228968918323517, -0.0003672449092846364, 0.027264541015028954, -0.0361168347299099, -0.06556885689496994, -0.036054011434316635, 0.04930476099252701, -0.019861647859215736, 0.039862893521785736, 0.04449428245425224, -0.02011868730187416, -0.03363482654094696, -0.04020761325955391, 0.0635877400636673, 0.08982904255390167, 0.04633493721485138, -0.04093099758028984, 0.0041120401583611965, -0.038547903299331665, -0.027638830244541168, 0.002098350552842021, 0.014768884517252445, -0.029458312317728996, -0.043490998446941376, 0.018790023401379585, -0.004595978185534477, 0.005088400561362505, 0.04003090783953667, -0.006133364979177713, -0.010243275202810764, 0.004225496668368578, -0.08366740494966507, -0.045472677797079086, 0.03148003667593002, -0.015051485039293766, 0.015618556179106236, -0.09495656192302704, -0.0068599446676671505, 0.042726509273052216, 0.025606276467442513, 0.0035081859678030014, 0.01649169810116291, 0.03169995918869972, 0.0326794870197773, -0.019836531952023506, -0.015324185602366924, -0.04484868794679642, 0.0056210896000266075, -0.02052631601691246, -0.027889085933566093, -0.07300910353660583, 0.03187381103634834, -0.002165932906791568, -0.01073366403579712, -0.03352007642388344, 0.052258171141147614, -0.009014271199703217, 0.008829563856124878, 0.0008068735478445888, 0.028485063463449478, -0.03619864210486412, 0.08092103153467178, 0.021501807495951653, 0.028869645670056343, 0.04114774987101555, -0.0019734592642635107, 0.0011781529756262898, 0.016516489908099174, 0.05098641663789749, 0.04603436961770058, -0.017206458374857903, -0.031184392049908638, -0.012399467639625072, 0.014232919551432133, 0.02419932186603546, -0.011174873448908329, -0.013333335518836975, -0.02659641206264496, -0.0110430046916008, 0.033568963408470154, 0.041041050106287, 0.013383789919316769, -0.024518683552742004, 0.04170385003089905, -0.07223394513130188, -0.000408788095228374, -0.08169206231832504, 0.01181256677955389, 0.012472487054765224, -0.021058207377791405, 0.02377745509147644, -0.005961782764643431, 0.02015756629407406, 0.04529517889022827, -0.009635944850742817, -0.01569482684135437, -0.04548409581184387, 0.031723685562610626, -0.00922298338264227, 0.008961441926658154, 0.03819555044174194, 0.04248686507344246, -0.021548094227910042, 0.053300999104976654, -0.003752203891053796, -0.05684271082282066, 0.010454190894961357, -0.03224805369973183, 0.014121191576123238, 0.018256770446896553, -0.034739699214696884, -0.016981074586510658, -0.016238221898674965, -0.03823786601424217, 0.055935777723789215, -0.06640280783176422, 0.02493208646774292, 0.04783940315246582, -0.005929287988692522, 0.0021447185426950455, 0.042347583919763565, -0.003951141610741615, 0.022548288106918335, -0.0023816258180886507, -0.0020133398938924074, -0.036666139960289, -0.01636669412255287, 0.04000914841890335, 0.060204215347766876, -0.040753323584795, 0.01658354327082634, -0.0055241636000573635, 0.028462698683142662, 0.027631569653749466, 0.007659841328859329, 0.0033857235684990883, -0.027377791702747345, 0.010118293575942516, -0.0016966389957815409, 0.011268463917076588, 0.012407563626766205, -0.010662722401320934, 0.022944772616028786, 0.03052580915391445, -0.010842292569577694, 0.00512916361913085, 0.05144646763801575, -0.011714783497154713, -0.010541665367782116, -0.04166129231452942, -0.007890374399721622, 0.007096057757735252, -0.0034515296574681997, 0.01677941530942917, 0.030376093462109566, -0.01309196650981903, -0.010867336764931679, -0.028444966301321983, 0.024164631962776184, 0.05835311487317085, 0.004393850918859243, -0.06329997628927231, -0.010770843364298344, 0.009842677973210812, -0.0264760609716177, -0.0245484858751297, -0.02314109541475773, -0.02169809304177761, -0.035542216151952744, 0.01944647915661335, 0.01236732304096222, -0.036209527403116226, -0.006371533963829279, -0.013431472703814507, -0.08607714623212814, 0.0071907672099769115, 0.009476807899773121, 0.030765531584620476, 0.04443591088056564, -0.034102678298950195, 0.004367129877209663, -0.024778446182608604, 0.02024783194065094, 0.006927459966391325, 0.0012711690505966544, -0.014884545467793941, -0.0016880431212484837, -0.029096633195877075, -0.036133091896772385, -0.009432396851480007, -0.023875953629612923, 0.008227047510445118, 0.004745647311210632, -0.017482275143265724, 0.016565531492233276, 0.02467522583901882, 0.011629166081547737, 0.042947959154844284, -0.03627418354153633, -0.06212606653571129, -0.025168046355247498, -0.010405058972537518, 0.037390824407339096, -0.005496672820299864, 0.0722229853272438, 0.04693911224603653, -0.04041043668985367, 0.008121729828417301, -0.05032498016953468, -0.05805365368723869, 0.02665712498128414, 0.006463926285505295, 0.005182113032788038, -0.004260679706931114, -0.008130484260618687, 0.06007002666592598, 0.01111238170415163, -0.011215933598577976, 0.017859656363725662, 0.049145281314849854, -0.01380105223506689, -0.04280175641179085, 0.014459483325481415, 0.0211616363376379, -0.040962863713502884, 0.030827250331640244, -0.015217308886349201, -0.007931897416710854, 0.04497305676341057, 0.030416244640946388, -0.008590449579060078, 0.002945278538390994, 0.008659828454256058, 0.011883695609867573, 0.007481682114303112, -0.003659455105662346, 0.00046898165601305664, 0.006674386095255613, 0.01644156500697136, 0.03719501569867134, 0.039207812398672104, -0.009656696580350399, 0.006643322296440601, -0.045399658381938934, -0.008926969952881336, -0.0647808313369751, 0.05829715356230736, 0.047559451311826706, -0.02822158671915531, -0.013824942521750927, 0.019326020032167435, 0.003455015830695629, -0.02250640280544758, 0.002939476165920496, 0.05220559611916542, 0.025568563491106033, -0.009677293710410595, -0.00586311100050807, -0.021441223099827766, -0.019498111680150032, 0.024265745654702187, -0.01591777428984642, 0.017915774136781693, 0.028975265100598335, 0.03286755830049515, 0.012003372423350811, -0.015225032344460487, -0.004226657561957836, -0.01003880612552166, -0.06545998156070709, 0.04050728306174278, -0.012124845758080482, 0.0026109174359589815, 0.02169688232243061, 0.0357745885848999, 0.006766694597899914, 0.0176542978733778, -0.017166029661893845, -0.0012581887422129512, -0.056218985468149185, -0.019820086658000946, -0.02477811463177204, 0.004767240956425667, 0.0045583900064229965, -0.0028689904138445854, 0.048847608268260956, -0.020962374284863472, 0.04107881337404251, -0.014208420179784298, 0.018616685643792152, -0.0493202842772007, 0.0016295562963932753, -0.07294081896543503, 0.002464364981278777, 0.025141816586256027, 0.023074472323060036, 0.00989012885838747, -0.02394396997988224, 0.02284260094165802, 0.02755090221762657, -0.002250704215839505, -0.033509720116853714, -0.03433849662542343, 0.017050031572580338, -0.012708170339465141, 0.024623962119221687, 0.02297288179397583, 0.06242968514561653, -0.027984602376818657, 0.04197845980525017, 0.021317390725016594, 0.04658818244934082, 0.053906407207250595, 0.027799544855952263, -0.005453631281852722, -0.03549186512827873, -0.026387609541416168, 0.014089139178395271, 0.04240688681602478, 0.011788785457611084, -0.008113228715956211, 0.057830266654491425, -0.02119506150484085, -0.014032249338924885, 0.03423524275422096, 0.043268922716379166, 0.03935851529240608, 0.008683012798428535, -0.03396114334464073, -0.00501925777643919, -0.007538150530308485, -0.013976254500448704, -0.00009575578587828204, 0.019267285242676735, -0.00808664783835411, -0.02069856785237789, 0.044688452035188675, -0.004726881626993418, -0.00260001327842474, -0.002174146007746458, 0.050884611904621124, 0.04694925993680954, 0.037282150238752365, -0.018190663307905197, 0.0012435289099812508, 0.03917373716831207, 0.03684217110276222, 0.020825199782848358, -0.017500899732112885, -0.08019527792930603, -0.020784802734851837, 0.012442232109606266, -0.006487857550382614, -0.019998500123620033, -0.00922644603997469, -0.03934059664607048, -0.019722312688827515, 0.022732464596629143, -0.009663027711212635, 0.028139600530266762, -0.02398625575006008, -0.018976882100105286, 0.01859362982213497, -0.014087478630244732, -0.028054073452949524, 0.019336888566613197, -0.02529638260602951, -0.026591375470161438, -0.04737677052617073, -0.005522582679986954, -0.04750793054699898, 0.002650771290063858, 0.0024618874303996563, 0.050150394439697266, -0.01506879273802042, -0.017260007560253143, 0.00741747347638011, 0.027103981003165245, 0.003126451512798667, -0.04063154011964798, 0.01356648001819849, 0.021067148074507713, -0.0348413810133934, 0.057524748146533966, -0.01857394352555275, -0.011266130022704601, 0.037019502371549606, 0.028772475197911263, -0.06023569405078888, 0.008434693329036236, -0.0048001729883253574, 0.05316605418920517, 0.03755005821585655, 0.03845309093594551, 0.06133117526769638, -0.028076408430933952, 0.03532716631889343, -0.027597300708293915, -0.03360254317522049, 0.013668209314346313, -0.022601177915930748, 0.002499430440366268, -0.0633954182267189, 0.006500809453427792, 0.014368342235684395, 0.05296081677079201, -0.022922931239008904, 0.056821830570697784, -0.003172881668433547, -0.03580370917916298, 0.011543932370841503, 0.029177626594901085, 0.021867521107196808, 0.012367566116154194, -0.015812082216143608, 0.040697939693927765, 0.009516773745417595, -0.0024505623150616884, 0.0163302980363369, -0.01647951453924179, 0.003555689239874482, 0.0026963315904140472, -0.012042123824357986, 0.03547868877649307, -0.0340249165892601, -0.01918853633105755, 0.03361596167087555, -0.03200141340494156, 0.014060266315937042, -0.01594661921262741, -0.0038661211729049683, 0.022591356188058853, -0.04435673728585243, -0.016012651845812798, 0.0062473067082464695, -0.03666422888636589, 0.007833253592252731, -0.04240020364522934, 0.008501852862536907, 0.03138786554336548, 0.017388442531228065, -0.06629708409309387, -0.026415204629302025, -0.005771598778665066, -0.034597236663103104, -0.0035585907753556967, -0.018556080758571625, 0.015024194493889809, -0.019878273829817772, -0.06128551438450813, -0.017667649313807487, 0.04010932147502899, -0.00780472019687295, -0.012876913882791996, -0.015105796977877617, 0.053532082587480545, 0.034512944519519806, -0.003405860159546137, -0.003492091316729784, 0.05327840521931648, -0.018835630267858505, -0.008984693326056004, 0.03888138011097908, 0.05752537399530411, -0.01807844452559948, 0.020787034183740616, 0.004707641899585724, -0.023820532485842705, 0.043968942016363144, -0.02189149148762226, -0.018146105110645294, 0.04610693082213402, 0.01936720684170723, 0.0028384642209857702, 0.011034330353140831, -0.0329296737909317, -0.025856973603367805, 0.0341806635260582, -0.047209903597831726, -0.02337934635579586, 0.010379249230027199, -0.01207432895898819, 0.038236238062381744, 0.0266244076192379, -0.009533856064081192, 0.002380892401561141, 0.048953827470541, -0.022590715438127518, -0.01586676947772503, 0.0014341670321300626, 0.01574397087097168, 0.0178987979888916, 0.05333634465932846, 0.001190486247651279, 0.03203563764691353, -0.00042717065662145615, -0.04237699136137962, 0.024884289130568504, -0.016282936558127403, 0.0018406157614663243, 0.09081917256116867, -0.036384183913469315, 0.03310655802488327, -0.009862556122243404, 0.03577620908617973, -0.0002470145409461111, -0.07137959450483322, 0.01895943097770214, 0.000526373041793704, -0.0041653611697256565, 0.05750453844666481, -0.032616741955280304, -0.016422688961029053, 0.06020434573292732, -0.0034748606849461794, 0.021985681727528572, 0.02397618629038334, 0.022889262065291405, 0.045377545058727264, 0.006401325110346079, -0.044258709996938705, -0.04140127822756767, 0.04885435104370117, -0.045223526656627655, 0.008523660711944103, -0.05736149474978447, -0.03287959098815918, 0.038093313574790955, 0.015440194867551327, 0.022889139130711555, -0.012177404947578907, -0.02637828327715397, -0.03155646100640297, 0.016376283019781113, 0.04417429864406586, -0.018210941925644875, -0.013832859694957733, -0.0013116882182657719, 0.039853520691394806, -0.022968880832195282, 0.05279780924320221, -0.04349760711193085, -0.12321245670318604, -0.045125022530555725, 0.016378823667764664, -0.0015205137897282839, -0.00810206774622202, -0.013328771106898785, -0.028993191197514534, -0.0032400591298937798, -0.03065158613026142, 0.027340510860085487, 0.0026074114721268415, 0.028240755200386047, -0.04149443656206131, 0.08401114493608475, 0.03093263879418373, 0.03353619948029518, -0.006062055937945843, -0.011848954483866692, 0.09518086165189743, 0.08772619068622589, 0.028065327554941177, -0.03977920114994049, 0.030858419835567474, -0.028592653572559357, 0.0005569717031903565, -0.031234530732035637, 0.004075284115970135, 0.021770713850855827, -0.016000909730792046, -0.008138677105307579, 0.036233942955732346, 0.015451118350028992, -0.018563859164714813, 0.047329869121313095, -0.04974118620157242, -0.05733559653162956, 0.0013259657425805926, 0.0066386628895998, -0.026173433288931847, -0.011923285201191902, -0.024240490049123764, -0.005866471212357283, 0.012956847436726093, -0.00950676016509533, -0.0013784023467451334, -0.010387071408331394, -0.030203144997358322, 0.027014948427677155, 0.005867450498044491, 0.0038609583862125874, 0.016406577080488205, -0.001328208833001554, -0.002020185114815831, 0.006053118966519833, 0.017227953299880028, -0.014950104057788849, 0.012784657999873161, 0.033491410315036774, -0.028836773708462715, 0.030483195558190346, 0.02329566702246666, 0.014325168915092945, -0.044557709246873856, -0.01412644237279892, -0.032021719962358475, 0.048135071992874146, -0.030910853296518326, 0.009210104122757912, -0.005202677566558123, 0.0009165061637759209, -0.022535044699907303, -0.04146934300661087, -0.016591323539614677, 0.051380716264247894, 0.006850870791822672, -0.002137031638994813, -0.000015184068615781143, -0.0019525630632415414, 0.04934051260352135, 0.012344094924628735, 0.04169255122542381, 0.0243547260761261, -0.050203967839479446, -0.056170377880334854, -0.01108457986265421, 0.058205313980579376, 0.028776101768016815, -0.009963395074009895, 0.03144991397857666, -0.029538938775658607, 0.009635725058615208, -0.029111728072166443, 0.02534114383161068, -0.016804005950689316, 0.027499860152602196, -0.0178526584059, 0.010543854907155037, -0.03531765565276146, -0.029236219823360443, 0.014711927622556686, -0.0206059031188488, 0.02798098884522915, -0.02994752861559391, 0.005601197946816683, 0.027510877698659897, 0.016574261710047722, 0.010995532386004925, 0.011374603025615215, 0.0016499693738296628, 0.04334724694490433, 0.03217408433556557, -0.03589445725083351, -0.057341594249010086, 0.017069216817617416, -0.0220277588814497, 0.0022101367358118296, -0.0018885416211560369, 0.058315422385931015, 0.02590642124414444, 0.073512502014637, -0.011067014187574387, 0.06016404926776886, -0.03020542487502098, 0.019681433215737343, -0.010688367299735546, -0.08450888842344284, 0.005854280665516853, -0.007633754517883062, 0.05144462734460831, -0.018600931391119957, -0.03689827397465706, -0.0038104704581201077, -0.023547057062387466, 0.01536966860294342, -0.015247819945216179, -0.03811704367399216, -0.012464550323784351, 0.009025417268276215, 0.019932853057980537, 0.013479177840054035, 0.01924736425280571, 0.0029830955900251865, -0.0017234988044947386, -0.03752072528004646, -0.02587042935192585, 0.0024053966626524925, 0.009614868089556694, -0.07485232502222061, -0.02090628258883953, 0.019464146345853806, 0.014108439907431602, 0.011529098264873028, -0.026086976751685143, -0.027554012835025787, 0.01021502073854208, 0.05890224874019623, -0.030772216618061066, -0.013199557550251484, 0.040908169001340866, -0.03784738853573799, -0.027391217648983, 0.0325523242354393, 0.0006293153273873031, 0.042504001408815384, -0.002041319152340293, -0.00250975601375103, -0.049952052533626556, 0.025146998465061188, -0.06333094835281372, 0.00346784433349967, -0.006685810629278421, -0.0036448074970394373, -0.014674222096800804, -0.028842510655522346, 0.018024049699306488, -0.014488781802356243, 0.024077098816633224, 0.017276592552661896, 0.03687416762113571, 0.01746760495007038, -0.027817502617836, 0.006547213066369295, -0.017842698842287064, 0.01992109976708889, -0.017752543091773987, 0.004063108470290899, 0.012620409019291401, 0.022161155939102173, -0.028401857241988182, 0.030220549553632736, -0.000010376027603342663, 0.015130187384784222, -0.10637438297271729, -0.018086999654769897, 0.05034490302205086, 0.04329358786344528, 0.04069424793124199, -0.021872078999876976, 0.03850386291742325, 0.016473187133669853, -0.05546305701136589, 0.03604086861014366, -0.023889945819973946, -0.00967730488628149, -0.012636643834412098, 0.0056688906624913216, -0.027304915711283684, 0.028184587135910988, 0.017923898994922638, 0.012275931425392628, 0.03737679868936539, 0.019171275198459625, -0.015475451946258545, -0.040834877640008926, 0.01771802455186844, 0.022934619337320328, 0.023497017100453377, -0.04974379390478134, 0.04015406593680382, -0.03533540293574333, -0.024583524093031883, 0.027520356699824333, 0.024618852883577347, 0.033505670726299286, -0.015791231766343117, 0.03765355795621872, 0.03826279938220978, 0.00903147179633379, 0.01587861217558384, 0.028045769780874252, 0.020631348714232445, 0.009619489312171936, 0.018564825877547264, 0.037016965448856354, -0.01650974713265896, -0.01692637987434864, -0.006267594173550606, -0.010539424605667591, -0.010100282728672028, 0.008921529166400433, -0.03210994228720665, -0.03641156107187271, 0.006336260121315718, 0.009387622587382793, -0.005721186753362417, -0.010988610796630383, 0.03748457133769989, -0.04069787636399269, -0.018084142357110977, 0.03869524970650673, 0.039179448038339615, -0.023180996999144554, 0.00851093977689743, 0.0068865022622048855, -0.046014588326215744, 0.009220084175467491, -0.011696659959852695, -0.0038871311116963625, -0.05870780348777771, -0.03615093603730202, 0.007966152392327785, 0.0017547686584293842, 0.0014512509806081653, -0.024284763261675835, -0.04384620115160942, 0.05144115164875984, 0.002366103930398822, 0.0068290806375443935, 0.005957366432994604, 0.00854396540671587, -0.029605107381939888, -0.07817082852125168, 0.022596392780542374, 0.001938173547387123, -0.04985009506344795, 0.013169943355023861, 0.006251898594200611, -0.035661183297634125, -0.01388273760676384, 0.07163634151220322, 0.015253206714987755, 0.03300732001662254, -0.004214071203023195, 0.0512472540140152, -0.006521911360323429, -0.033224500715732574, 0.040864307433366776, 0.02969628944993019, -0.02283279038965702, -0.05388427525758743, -0.007083899807184935, 0.018356218934059143, 0.019207732751965523, 0.01297967229038477, 0.006271189544349909, 0.011442595161497593, 0.009717836044728756, -0.0002404738770565018, 0.0020265928469598293, 0.010049276053905487, -0.007614213041961193, 0.05185648053884506, 0.0007533610914833844, 0.008256016299128532, 0.02518823929131031, 0.01135763805359602, -0.0508575364947319, 0.03324805945158005, -0.010136811062693596, -0.03297910466790199, 0.004465277772396803, -0.018352637067437172, 0.003757860977202654, -0.04040708765387535, -0.020377418026328087, 0.03197391331195831, -0.07551181316375732, -0.006722454447299242, 0.030545465648174286, 0.04438247159123421, 0.057784512639045715, 0.03995097428560257, -0.0010245819576084614, 0.04253509268164635, 0.003333546919748187, 0.03359083831310272, 0.0325222909450531, 0.01142195239663124, -0.014153554104268551, -0.0017350291600450873, 0.04801563546061516, -0.04146105796098709, 0.02152557112276554, -0.027700578793883324, 0.029949957504868507, -0.022712457925081253, -0.010220421478152275, -0.00759669067338109, -0.031155889853835106, 0.019671449437737465, -0.04257061332464218, -0.037579700350761414, 0.07883784919977188, -0.025872712954878807, 0.004152961075305939, -0.024671031162142754, 0.003159885760396719, -0.016303446143865585, 0.011540718376636505, -0.0011241427855566144, 0.004347341600805521, 0.024213990196585655, 0.005375127773731947, -0.019041871652007103, -0.01427446398884058, 0.01565137691795826, -0.056158438324928284, -0.0020425906404852867, -0.03149738907814026, -0.00023727817460894585, 0.016992265358567238, -0.03849946707487106, -0.025561852380633354, -0.024087093770503998, -0.0069353459402918816, 0.013998180627822876, 0.030687477439641953, -0.029276924207806587, -0.0645587295293808, 0.012042404152452946, 0.017118528485298157, -0.06371768563985825, 0.015585767105221748, -0.028290553018450737, 0.004347024019807577, -0.03168417513370514, -0.0610705129802227 ]
<p>I am working on monthly seasonally adjusted data. To the best of my knowledge (maybe I'm wrong), data is seasonally adjusted to take out any form of seasonality. </p> <p>After doing an ACF of the second difference of my data with R, I saw a spike from the lag one point that crosses the horizontal dashed line. This led me to suggest a nonseasonal MA(1) component. I then saw a lag from the 12th point that lies right on the horizontal dashed line. Can this mean there is a seasonal MA(1) component with period 12? And if so, can monthly seasonally adjusted data still exhibit seasonality? </p>
73,417
[ 0.0028544121887534857, -0.004394735209643841, -0.038018904626369476, 0.04135926440358162, 0.04589336737990379, 0.024554355069994926, 0.012164563871920109, 0.0023514714557677507, -0.02261863462626934, -0.044672317802906036, 0.04147467389702797, 0.02016529068350792, 0.057194411754608154, 0.03546285256743431, 0.010583152063190937, -0.030077483505010605, 0.010683506727218628, 0.013212496414780617, 0.03667236119508743, 0.004362940788269043, -0.010806686244904995, 0.018860071897506714, -0.0031363568268716335, -0.0034650303423404694, -0.025243690237402916, 0.04860707372426987, 0.003697301261126995, -0.01898793689906597, 0.0010500382632017136, 0.020248064771294594, -0.03643707185983658, -0.0451291985809803, 0.012287941761314869, 0.013860007748007774, -0.003458714811131358, -0.00002144216159649659, -0.029164955019950867, -0.03537745401263237, -0.024297313764691353, 0.05610603839159012, -0.060187701135873795, -0.03908487409353256, -0.031234299764037132, 0.02056320756673813, -0.08314552903175354, -0.0031158130150288343, 0.039286259561777115, 0.029693935066461563, 0.055441658943891525, -0.022091489285230637, 0.06293118745088577, -0.0010365821653977036, 0.02761368826031685, 0.018876681104302406, -0.016414564102888107, -0.004977192729711533, 0.048544179648160934, 0.045637235045433044, -0.011016834527254105, -0.028679434210062027, -0.032675884664058685, -0.03769872337579727, 0.0018297603819519281, -0.00344166811555624, -0.009003938175737858, 0.029636600986123085, -0.00763132655993104, -0.0002865447604563087, 0.002699204720556736, -0.002617462072521448, 0.0012044513132423162, -0.008807909674942493, 0.02765374258160591, -0.03285853564739227, -0.013657969422638416, -0.07242394983768463, 0.027421673759818077, 0.035217490047216415, 0.032230667769908905, 0.034084588289260864, 0.04123220220208168, 0.025353601202368736, 0.02352897822856903, 0.021359870210289955, 0.043530043214559555, 0.014737305231392384, 0.04635531082749367, -0.041688114404678345, 0.028649186715483665, 0.0245894156396389, -0.010163509286940098, 0.02406339906156063, 0.033595792949199677, 0.0018839288968592882, -0.055521901696920395, 0.023836201056838036, -0.023190457373857498, 0.011374915950000286, -0.02625093422830105, -0.015524940565228462, 0.012039540335536003, 0.002040544990450144, 0.06509838998317719, 0.004976269323378801, -0.008349403738975525, 0.030542880296707153, -0.0189003087580204, 0.005529840011149645, -0.029571494087576866, -0.004539273213595152, -0.0494656041264534, 0.005093165673315525, -0.026465365663170815, -0.00019689372857101262, 0.0546681247651577, -0.02009095437824726, -0.021869925782084465, -0.01277860812842846, 0.056072480976581573, 0.07586649805307388, 0.027990831062197685, -0.00035518777440302074, 0.06062399968504906, -0.009066907688975334, -0.05801180377602577, 0.020862912759184837, -0.037348899990320206, -0.057562731206417084, -0.04643574729561806, 0.030843302607536316, 0.025506775826215744, -0.01350230723619461, 0.06463221460580826, -0.0015402109129354358, 0.03174454718828201, 0.00506471237167716, -0.08428136259317398, -0.075914166867733, 0.06362981349229813, 0.008947349153459072, 0.015413911081850529, -0.0563945397734642, 0.0041913436725735664, 0.024933936074376106, 0.05497129634022713, 0.0007687426987104118, 0.017108792439103127, 0.023629454895853996, 0.02129247784614563, -0.006779729388654232, -0.01675690896809101, -0.0017103649443015456, -0.009599784389138222, -0.07000604271888733, -0.019769705832004547, -0.09591908752918243, 0.04087895527482033, 0.03903811052441597, -0.0006219835486263037, -0.02506348490715027, 0.03679083660244942, 0.02559729851782322, -0.0014420391526073217, 0.023097194731235504, 0.013607976026833057, -0.025096427649259567, 0.07866367697715759, 0.014544512145221233, -0.009047393687069416, 0.012474407441914082, -0.010255307890474796, 0.01253910455852747, -0.019690517336130142, 0.07665251195430756, 0.04938746243715286, -0.026003409177064896, -0.014047829434275627, -0.017112918198108673, 0.03149010241031647, 0.014736219309270382, -0.056005191057920456, -0.007127601653337479, -0.044683635234832764, -0.016949160024523735, 0.039705850183963776, 0.06970617175102234, -0.02028072252869606, -0.007397464010864496, 0.04526489973068237, -0.06403966248035431, -0.03477953374385834, -0.0471140556037426, -0.004292774945497513, -0.025034360587596893, -0.036836352199316025, 0.013946162536740303, 0.0027396520599722862, 0.032926104962825775, -0.04835909232497215, -0.0029885845724493265, 0.0022442766930907965, 0.0040985397063195705, 0.025730248540639877, -0.02796449325978756, 0.00566974887624383, 0.027829930186271667, 0.031890012323856354, 0.017693761736154556, -0.0035784277133643627, -0.06805873662233353, -0.0315743088722229, 0.012536892667412758, -0.051415614783763885, 0.04667246341705322, -0.028631707653403282, -0.01691657118499279, 0.024394776672124863, -0.003000174416229129, -0.04915018752217293, 0.07524287700653076, -0.031512338668107986, 0.03807074576616287, 0.026636779308319092, -0.010772056877613068, -0.007092569954693317, 0.007371324580162764, 0.034913189709186554, 0.001702000037766993, -0.039357688277959824, -0.016621235758066177, -0.040498241782188416, -0.03537237271666527, 0.08871734887361526, 0.0004112556343898177, -0.01863808184862137, 0.01970541477203369, 0.05168554186820984, 0.005835007410496473, 0.04012381657958031, 0.0561332069337368, 0.03762271627783775, -0.010850817896425724, 0.0019702031277120113, 0.005618852097541094, 0.015031320974230766, 0.006613697856664658, 0.07547137886285782, -0.024989692494273186, 0.04359923675656319, 0.04472178965806961, 0.02001723274588585, 0.045242901891469955, -0.029298853129148483, 0.05352206528186798, -0.018230630084872246, -0.012310751713812351, 0.05346944183111191, -0.0477726049721241, -0.004621421918272972, 0.017334748059511185, 0.003637376707047224, -0.034975435584783554, 0.03811099752783775, 0.010968186892569065, -0.002913428470492363, 0.01009550504386425, -0.03200985863804817, -0.03768838196992874, 0.016767581924796104, -0.01787600852549076, 0.036205146461725235, -0.06364218145608902, -0.02142319828271866, 0.0057443794794380665, -0.0028121958021074533, 0.04972078278660774, 0.028057321906089783, 0.03446940705180168, -0.010313338600099087, -0.014746265485882759, 0.0000019360857095307438, -0.029745347797870636, 0.021858712658286095, 0.0056545548141002655, -0.00044946352136321366, -0.022784247994422913, -0.005827728193253279, -0.013207963667809963, 0.034153107553720474, -0.00919159036129713, -0.009429977275431156, 0.02778846025466919, -0.008542723953723907, -0.03993020951747894, -0.008030642755329609, -0.04073943570256233, -0.03505245968699455, -0.06651776283979416, -0.028802625834941864, 0.026993513107299805, -0.0007576081552542746, -0.015086933970451355, -0.010085896588861942, -0.05210646241903305, 0.016312532126903534, -0.05080164223909378, -0.01849578320980072, -0.0021199083421379328, -0.023670095950365067, -0.011952562257647514, 0.009583678096532822, -0.02744862250983715, 0.019190588966012, -0.03530771657824516, -0.05290118232369423, 0.018774373456835747, -0.022453591227531433, 0.011509288102388382, 0.014676179736852646, -0.017561811953783035, 0.052452877163887024, 0.03409140557050705, -0.014952911995351315, 0.0018304364057257771, -0.029401900246739388, -0.029778938740491867, -0.05365975946187973, 0.0331573486328125, 0.039881158620119095, 0.052530333399772644, 0.01673293672502041, -0.026572339236736298, 0.03265973925590515, 0.06089938431978226, 0.023162750527262688, -0.007045252714306116, 0.009391053579747677, -0.01874067261815071, -0.004418089520186186, 0.040555521845817566, 0.009001290425658226, 0.013124271295964718, 0.0021202522329986095, -0.0061254482716321945, 0.015240873210132122, 0.0371549166738987, 0.005413924343883991, 0.05278114974498749, -0.032159727066755295, 0.0043169595301151276, -0.03703697770833969, 0.03528246283531189, 0.0269378162920475, 0.004847563803195953, -0.03345789760351181, -0.024517953395843506, 0.022836700081825256, -0.02368233911693096, -0.03269010782241821, 0.05434216558933258, -0.008645892143249512, -0.0432962067425251, 0.010538477450609207, -0.01920265518128872, 0.0008705596555955708, 0.05511505529284477, -0.035897571593523026, -0.0312288086861372, 0.03757127374410629, -0.009279903024435043, 0.019900435581803322, -0.009280301630496979, -0.07654567807912827, 0.017609428614377975, -0.039706338196992874, 0.00029006172553636134, -0.012480292469263077, 0.04310400038957596, -0.012484710663557053, 0.0293906107544899, 0.0042550228536129, -0.016063589602708817, 0.0036598166916519403, -0.00013842929911334068, -0.05843668058514595, -0.00875617191195488, -0.005424494855105877, -0.011472347192466259, -0.003978086169809103, -0.02418450452387333, -0.008314302191138268, -0.030123921111226082, 0.009633165784180164, 0.0003233127063140273, -0.014589822851121426, -0.013776198029518127, 0.019930046051740646, -0.043585773557424545, -0.0043416693806648254, -0.04531301558017731, -0.013136967085301876, 0.05366086959838867, -0.04413583129644394, 0.016102895140647888, 0.04830602556467056, 0.012477399781346321, -0.018401246517896652, -0.008903083391487598, 0.02293544076383114, 0.026299556717276573, 0.02514084242284298, 0.06798489391803741, 0.0012259043287485838, -0.016732467338442802, 0.04188228026032448, 0.02038881555199623, 0.051139701157808304, 0.015979820862412453, -0.010548951104283333, -0.016790539026260376, -0.050966065376996994, -0.0296607818454504, 0.03971993178129196, 0.018662136048078537, 0.034053124487400055, 0.019362905994057655, 0.03430725261569023, 0.0045731812715530396, -0.03633473441004753, -0.006683501414954662, 0.04436614364385605, 0.017366833984851837, 0.02868509478867054, -0.07138083130121231, -0.008403628133237362, -0.008185370825231075, 0.003952362574636936, 0.06557141989469528, -0.003939339425414801, -0.005980256944894791, 0.011965182609856129, 0.011087874881923199, -0.013312244787812233, -0.023457510396838188, -0.035607073456048965, 0.016418760642409325, 0.07425741851329803, 0.011168957687914371, -0.00587775744497776, 0.050652578473091125, 0.026988226920366287, 0.023532621562480927, -0.007620908319950104, 0.014561653137207031, -0.13115277886390686, -0.0026249538641422987, 0.04715092480182648, 0.03394699469208717, -0.061106763780117035, -0.021524017676711082, -0.07127753645181656, -0.010088234208524227, 0.03244287520647049, -0.03449656814336777, 0.044632937759160995, -0.02670571580529213, 0.03228346258401871, -0.042537618428468704, -0.05532418563961983, -0.02375461906194687, 0.020851291716098785, 0.01724492385983467, 0.016687028110027313, 0.002670198678970337, -0.028711071237921715, -0.030970729887485504, 0.007949220947921276, 0.011168180964887142, 0.04374829679727554, -0.015033039264380932, -0.00454719690605998, -0.02043290250003338, 0.0167730413377285, 0.00821942649781704, -0.04250694066286087, -0.020602745935320854, 0.03114917129278183, -0.010904526337981224, 0.011495484039187431, 0.004851531237363815, -0.008988562040030956, 0.00161364593077451, 0.03755595162510872, -0.014463589526712894, 0.003555963048711419, -0.019156552851200104, 0.019922729581594467, 0.037124134600162506, -0.0007874511065892875, 0.07144908607006073, 0.028935683891177177, -0.0030021341517567635, 0.006245818920433521, -0.032296013087034225, 0.039846159517765045, -0.02084556594491005, -0.030189169570803642, -0.029094399884343147, -0.02049144171178341, -0.029072800651192665, 0.02049947902560234, 0.03133577108383179, 0.02077256515622139, -0.006800118368119001, -0.014666798524558544, 0.018507085740566254, 0.014010141603648663, -0.000681363046169281, -0.0010371609823778272, 0.02789783850312233, -0.007721129339188337, -0.02976456843316555, 0.011569911614060402, 0.0013092407025396824, -0.02170724980533123, -0.03238633647561073, 0.02317492850124836, -0.03909895569086075, 0.022727666422724724, -0.023663220927119255, -0.01047129649668932, -0.006745834369212389, -0.016508793458342552, 0.010298633016645908, -0.027986139059066772, -0.003284948179498315, -0.010653371922671795, -0.04796270653605461, 0.03068813867866993, 0.012996700592339039, -0.015700289979577065, 0.04838959127664566, -0.027910595759749413, 0.04013654962182045, 0.00009115821740124375, 0.009097394533455372, -0.055656492710113525, -0.06130263954401016, 0.0026499617379158735, 0.02296987920999527, -0.05052122101187706, -0.01756519451737404, -0.01024872437119484, -0.006139751058071852, 0.009322622790932655, -0.014987311325967312, 0.019353244453668594, -0.03471860662102699, -0.0659283772110939, 0.04740624874830246, 0.013250324875116348, 0.0692201629281044, -0.00020159268751740456, -0.00591035233810544, 0.012761171907186508, -0.0064367144368588924, -0.024296291172504425, -0.05452624335885048, 0.027525000274181366, -0.02737991325557232, 0.005253403447568417, -0.029841629788279533, -0.0535397082567215, 0.04281845688819885, -0.03135326877236366, -0.03588705137372017, 0.03861996904015541, 0.0015922605525702238, 0.04196266084909439, -0.049903687089681625, 0.03358347713947296, -0.015629084780812263, 0.018939392641186714, -0.027636922895908356, -0.030065061524510384, -0.004353699740022421, -0.024089094251394272, 0.011835775338113308, -0.011352603323757648, -0.01345137506723404, 0.05342625454068184, 0.05647655576467514, -0.0032187465112656355, 0.006416883319616318, 0.024489905685186386, 0.02731132321059704, 0.016451021656394005, 0.01770683191716671, 0.038801174610853195, -0.012987027876079082, -0.0015009865164756775, -0.01653323881328106, -0.002430322812870145, -0.009511037729680538, 0.010899466462433338, 0.0645410493016243, 0.01254163309931755, 0.004550892859697342, -0.0056833671405911446, 0.005931350402534008, 0.016604071483016014, -0.04718046262860298, -0.00600177189335227, -0.006270903162658215, -0.02618967369198799, 0.05015597119927406, -0.03401980549097061, 0.009264628402888775, 0.006659854203462601, -0.005117411259561777, 0.015741830691695213, 0.06430767476558685, 0.026738176122307777, 0.030332455411553383, 0.025826532393693924, 0.036975275725126266, -0.06580235809087753, 0.023637857288122177, -0.012050916440784931, 0.03104957565665245, -0.030337059870362282, 0.006909954361617565, 0.0740174651145935, 0.015185493975877762, 0.0075249760411679745, -0.04057267680764198, -0.016113825142383575, -0.028174223378300667, 0.007283066399395466, 0.015280568972229958, 0.02463076077401638, 0.042838338762521744, 0.004784214310348034, 0.05072420462965965, 0.004840216599404812, 0.000284604582702741, -0.002844619331881404, -0.05561288073658943, 0.017078625038266182, -0.016728848218917847, -0.02147352509200573, 0.04817948117852211, -0.043378785252571106, -0.008369848132133484, -0.024613304063677788, -0.0633738711476326, -0.02377968095242977, -0.01361045427620411, 0.027370695024728775, 0.011467257514595985, 0.09460635483264923, -0.007732853293418884, 0.006318623665720224, -0.002170680556446314, 0.00952758640050888, 0.11684473603963852, 0.09527034312486649, 0.025154242292046547, -0.0588679164648056, 0.017636476084589958, -0.01181216910481453, 0.011814354918897152, -0.04195631295442581, 0.00696456478908658, -0.020673826336860657, -0.03364638239145279, 0.0473882295191288, 0.058421310037374496, -0.010316620580852032, 0.020883511751890182, 0.08259361237287521, -0.013482210226356983, 0.010825537145137787, 0.0010313576785847545, 0.0011188186472281814, 0.03902055695652962, 0.016077788546681404, -0.03581283986568451, 0.01978854462504387, -0.028615856543183327, -0.012880764901638031, -0.013444553129374981, -0.024941710755228996, 0.0015805813018232584, 0.02370714209973812, -0.03730032965540886, 0.008879932574927807, 0.015529269352555275, 0.023198504000902176, -0.005013756919652224, -0.01326678041368723, 0.026089541614055634, -0.026191318407654762, 0.04398610070347786, 0.06602946668863297, 0.021361906081438065, -0.015400426462292671, 0.012057873420417309, -0.009850641712546349, -0.041075319051742554, -0.0234427098184824, -0.045326635241508484, 0.024082908406853676, -0.010255781002342701, 0.0030737665947526693, -0.02421967126429081, 0.0018780477112159133, -0.014855003915727139, -0.045830849558115005, -0.008449021726846695, 0.005333615932613611, 0.021375562995672226, -0.02310066483914852, 0.008415772579610348, -0.0596892349421978, -0.0057316492311656475, 0.013864681124687195, 0.040810439735651016, 0.038751985877752304, -0.03409441560506821, -0.013060619123280048, -0.01038285344839096, 0.05186919867992401, -0.00963224470615387, -0.014100296422839165, -0.013957314193248749, 0.04087061434984207, -0.029697827994823456, 0.005377004388719797, 0.011558234691619873, 0.02237148955464363, -0.009184502065181732, 0.009124810807406902, 0.0022015850991010666, 0.03452947735786438, -0.02342192642390728, 0.027714066207408905, -0.03592270240187645, -0.005324837286025286, -0.005365168210119009, -0.012621893547475338, 0.045780058950185776, 0.023067502304911613, 0.006514217704534531, 0.004940330516546965, -0.007406497839838266, 0.05925991013646126, 0.035984065383672714, -0.05453276261687279, -0.021853119134902954, -0.02966185286641121, -0.0019504278898239136, -0.001500017591752112, -0.059108246117830276, 0.03383062034845352, 0.03877731040120125, 0.012103309854865074, -0.02327953837811947, -0.017936265096068382, 0.01042568776756525, 0.007887324318289757, 0.027502354234457016, -0.03005337528884411, 0.005857835058122873, -0.0018695404287427664, -0.01703990250825882, -0.03910226374864578, -0.04959816113114357, -0.008303340524435043, -0.014564217068254948, -0.025977719575166702, 0.017318304628133774, -0.03695915266871452, -0.007813520729541779, 0.0027969516813755035, -0.004132527392357588, -0.05485000088810921, -0.022443896159529686, -0.02714465744793415, -0.04223628714680672, -0.0003628640261013061, -0.023430701345205307, -0.003933013882488012, 0.01875094324350357, -0.05001257732510567, -0.017236120998859406, 0.04232872277498245, 0.0068333204835653305, 0.018674401566386223, -0.006607519928365946, 0.01200017612427473, -0.005054826382547617, 0.06055900454521179, -0.024289561435580254, -0.0471709780395031, 0.03594429790973663, -0.04688386246562004, -0.025689659640192986, 0.046495042741298676, -0.0054844217374920845, 0.026964839547872543, -0.003381191287189722, 0.022891223430633545, -0.006116749718785286, 0.04768739268183708, -0.004642808809876442, 0.01927405223250389, -0.0239908117800951, 0.024107076227664948, 0.017115388065576553, 0.009824818931519985, -0.050217993557453156, 0.008439764380455017, 0.0016200640238821507, 0.03935449570417404, 0.047576118260622025, -0.0009127598605118692, -0.023699019104242325, -0.002932768315076828, -0.025002459064126015, -0.009048430249094963, -0.01224287785589695, 0.006617644801735878, 0.03761500492691994, 0.04560534283518791, -0.02232094667851925, 0.03990774229168892, -0.017308620736002922, -0.03564479574561119, -0.03717551380395889, -0.026698632165789604, 0.011179722845554352, 0.030940232798457146, -0.0013867190573364496, -0.03440232574939728, 0.011336004361510277, 0.02596142143011093, -0.02445867471396923, 0.012605277821421623, -0.012378258630633354, -0.0187840573489666, -0.059391092509031296, -0.04532583802938461, 0.0004447285027708858, -0.004291445016860962, 0.04893491044640541, 0.020865751430392265, 0.004926973953843117, 0.030430002138018608, 0.004094188567250967, -0.040823061019182205, -0.008908544667065144, 0.010252716951072216, 0.0240341704338789, -0.08312786370515823, 0.07839594036340714, -0.035724908113479614, -0.02506241947412491, 0.01790507882833481, -0.0325704887509346, 0.0030780299566686153, 0.03176242485642433, -0.029049832373857498, -0.022775711491703987, 0.03773965314030647, 0.018407225608825684, -0.011491195298731327, -0.019988415762782097, -0.015412405133247375, 0.02224024571478367, 0.04454074054956436, -0.027063528075814247, 0.0033843722194433212, -0.0058798105455935, -0.04907761514186859, -0.009859838522970676, -0.004684269893914461, -0.0382646769285202, 0.0012251971056684852, -0.00907550286501646, 0.018007900565862656, 0.023368485271930695, -0.014150798320770264, 0.028290066868066788, -0.01837458834052086, -0.0016886253142729402, 0.083250492811203, 0.06127828732132912, -0.013457675464451313, -0.04141964018344879, 0.028514603152871132, -0.012479715049266815, 0.025677263736724854, 0.03181576728820801, -0.017671318724751472, -0.062116023153066635, -0.025004858151078224, -0.03869961202144623, -0.010676423087716103, -0.01668873429298401, 0.0229896679520607, -0.011317349039018154, 0.05498195067048073, 0.005291513167321682, -0.0019099002238363028, 0.01791023276746273, -0.033658936619758606, 0.011444353498518467, -0.06282634288072586, 0.05363663285970688, 0.0028843795880675316, -0.031800590455532074, -0.00932246446609497, -0.02974572964012623, -0.07426556944847107, -0.024623099714517593, 0.008787732571363449, 0.011857209727168083, -0.0047018397599458694, 0.020117487758398056, 0.013785145245492458, -0.01700810343027115, -0.020814651623368263, 0.032650578767061234, -0.03561486676335335, -0.012885607779026031, 0.017156746238470078, -0.025936175137758255, -0.0023082299157977104, 0.011840227991342545, 0.0028034134302288294, -0.021330412477254868, 0.029381366446614265, -0.007879756391048431, 0.005976517219096422, 0.04792173206806183, -0.01799585483968258, -0.008357775397598743, 0.04273735731840134, 0.0338134728372097, 0.0006995261646807194, 0.006776145193725824, -0.015446040779352188, -0.05199676752090454, -0.005041302181780338, -0.014623564667999744, 0.020058250054717064, -0.014004994183778763, 0.006975746713578701, 0.018678102642297745, -0.04006201773881912, 0.0060806008987128735, 0.03593356907367706, 0.03226640075445175, 0.010592971928417683, 0.027817796915769577, -0.004376400262117386, 0.029669778421521187, 0.015029984526336193, 0.03059040941298008, 0.007821161299943924, -0.0020575388334691525, 0.010571255348622799, 0.01827235519886017, -0.009257211349904537, -0.0066887433640658855, -0.023286031559109688, -0.0011239126324653625, -0.0008033398189581931, 0.007507917936891317, 0.007224459201097488, 0.06682253628969193, 0.029466131702065468, -0.061567872762680054, 0.008189376443624496, 0.001035151770338416, 0.04276196286082268, -0.03349902108311653, 0.018498891964554787, 0.001817938289605081, -0.020986031740903854, -0.005064850673079491, -0.00916281621903181, 0.005202163942158222, -0.0344303660094738, 0.008179930038750172, 0.0137533163651824, 0.030197417363524437, -0.005999005399644375, 0.006171662360429764, 0.031868115067481995, 0.009330176748335361, 0.020557381212711334, -0.04503767937421799, 0.030876297503709793, -0.030056485906243324, -0.009431012906134129, 0.00990356970578432, -0.0063545117154717445, -0.032651618123054504, -0.02977622300386429, 0.03714921325445175, 0.03493759036064148, 0.03996006399393082, -0.03205147385597229, -0.026857875287532806, -0.005117024760693312, 0.03446706756949425, -0.06581281125545502, -0.036569174379110336, 0.0020635456312447786, -0.002444337122142315, 0.0018641587812453508, -0.04897690936923027 ]
<p>I am working on a data set. After using some model identification techniques, I came out with an ARIMA(0,2,1) model. </p> <p>I used the <code>detectIO</code> function in the package <code>TSA</code> in R to detect an <em>innovative</em> outlier (IO) at the 48th observation of my original data set. </p> <p>How do I incorporate this outlier into my model so I can use it for forecasting purposes? I don't want to use the ARIMAX model since I might not be able to make any predictions from that in R. Are there any other ways I could do this? </p> <p>Here are my values in order:</p> <pre><code>VALUE &lt;- scan() 4.6 4.5 4.4 4.5 4.4 4.6 4.7 4.6 4.7 4.7 4.7 5.0 5.0 4.9 5.1 5.0 5.4 5.6 5.8 6.1 6.1 6.5 6.8 7.3 7.8 8.3 8.7 9.0 9.4 9.5 9.5 9.6 9.8 10.0 9.9 9.9 9.8 9.8 9.9 9.9 9.6 9.4 9.5 9.5 9.5 9.5 9.8 9.3 9.1 9.0 8.9 9.0 9.0 9.1 9.0 9.0 9.0 8.9 8.6 8.5 8.3 8.3 8.2 8.1 8.2 8.2 8.2 8.1 7.8 7.9 7.8 7.8 </code></pre> <p>That is actually my data. They are unemployment rates over a period of 6 years. There are 72 observations then . Each value is to at most one decimal place</p>
73,418
[ 0.022267844527959824, -0.008366723544895649, 0.02028498612344265, -0.027837032452225685, 0.01323452778160572, -0.0147535540163517, 0.011724957264959812, -0.023756898939609528, 0.025024261325597763, -0.017175830900669098, 0.04894264414906502, 0.03002331219613552, 0.07304131239652634, 0.031251247972249985, 0.032992053776979446, 0.001794012845493853, -0.046438537538051605, 0.007108320482075214, 0.0006833295337855816, -0.013705359771847725, 0.007878084667026997, -0.01967383548617363, 0.006569114979356527, 0.010971036739647388, -0.01842712238430977, 0.04085112363100052, 0.0414712093770504, 0.003927307203412056, -0.0019435329595580697, 0.024345209822058678, -0.027919698506593704, -0.04356140270829201, 0.013048400171101093, 0.047794174402952194, 0.032837897539138794, 0.018470972776412964, -0.0011237324215471745, -0.00031950438278727233, -0.0010768990032374859, -0.0023849366698414087, -0.02503308840095997, -0.015380853787064552, 0.017964811995625496, 0.01735864207148552, -0.003617457114160061, -0.008677730336785316, 0.0010839453898370266, -0.021568970754742622, 0.08789839595556259, -0.0007528719143010676, 0.07125171273946762, -0.05141615867614746, 0.0028847227804362774, 0.04983588308095932, -0.0019464930519461632, -0.025154033675789833, 0.0675547644495964, 0.06570135056972504, -0.019617749378085136, -0.033912330865859985, -0.009572729468345642, -0.026897737756371498, -0.03681628406047821, -0.0244841817766428, -0.03493134304881096, 0.029575582593679428, -0.02966662310063839, -0.01998339779675007, 0.036295682191848755, -0.05911395698785782, 0.008667840622365475, 0.019387243315577507, 0.003100617788732052, -0.01771550066769123, 0.027234027162194252, -0.011716516688466072, -0.000667389715090394, -0.0067982301115989685, 0.03906497359275818, 0.009335685521364212, 0.022577878087759018, 0.015866605564951897, 0.028529951348900795, 0.06117052957415581, 0.01416707132011652, 0.012982442043721676, 0.027053311467170715, -0.050902921706438065, 0.018015317618846893, 0.03333108872175217, -0.018028831109404564, 0.007459125481545925, 0.0703776478767395, 0.01679757423698902, -0.028789671137928963, 0.06359171867370605, -0.024824049323797226, 0.024813804775476456, -0.021028103306889534, 0.0014437754871323705, -0.032054606825113297, -0.04091385379433632, 0.003945487551391125, 0.06888025254011154, -0.010843261145055294, -0.0015416364185512066, -0.037336885929107666, -0.03787511587142944, -0.006902194581925869, -0.0389484167098999, -0.016596438363194466, 0.004675871692597866, -0.009649261832237244, -0.019583813846111298, 0.023581231012940407, 0.015008225105702877, -0.0062231747433543205, -0.017989324405789375, -0.0007876035524532199, 0.04339461773633957, 0.04686550796031952, 0.010673888027668, 0.009176108986139297, -0.03934716060757637, -0.04461321234703064, -0.00983970332890749, -0.016237618401646614, -0.03320502117276192, -0.04538555070757866, 0.02400369942188263, -0.029629793018102646, -0.038933806121349335, 0.05787913128733635, -0.029703892767429352, 0.06514999270439148, 0.012283445335924625, -0.0800028145313263, -0.029199616983532906, 0.04837891086935997, 0.016290057450532913, 0.03463353216648102, -0.06690678745508194, -0.001806338899768889, 0.052870020270347595, 0.05952691286802292, 0.040367014706134796, 0.023901091888546944, 0.02235994301736355, -0.010561706498265266, 0.022515175864100456, -0.05202079191803932, -0.0005051459884271026, 0.0008569736965000629, -0.04415268823504448, 0.0054542915895581245, -0.06875696778297424, -0.010489058680832386, -0.0025977599434554577, -0.02822558954358101, -0.04045781493186951, 0.018454814329743385, 0.0008472329936921597, -0.009946540929377079, -0.05781476944684982, -0.03123961202800274, -0.012307622469961643, 0.08857801556587219, 0.006273420061916113, 0.018988780677318573, 0.021763857454061508, -0.024129431694746017, 0.03503647446632385, -0.004729452542960644, 0.0410052090883255, 0.05127563700079918, -0.015773192048072815, 0.006776129361242056, -0.05625410005450249, -0.0004709538188762963, 0.019250519573688507, -0.06457440555095673, -0.041710834950208664, -0.014024662785232067, -0.014321833848953247, 0.011634474620223045, 0.02452530711889267, -0.018501846119761467, -0.0247742161154747, 0.045081816613674164, -0.05497260019183159, -0.01946135237812996, -0.03972994163632393, -0.0008863991242833436, -0.022897137328982353, -0.010726272128522396, -0.00021810112230014056, 0.007815051823854446, 0.03914082422852516, 0.004955981858074665, 0.0004577722866088152, -0.045163966715335846, -0.030178973451256752, 0.05190085247159004, -0.057101208716630936, -0.022925082594156265, 0.039722297340631485, 0.01512002944946289, -0.008901719935238361, 0.05008963122963905, -0.046057820320129395, 0.04082060232758522, 0.0005915369256399572, -0.0514957569539547, -0.02029646560549736, -0.017336687073111534, -0.013489320874214172, 0.04201923683285713, 0.01623212732374668, 0.01457530353218317, 0.03125534951686859, -0.045332688838243484, 0.05748938396573067, 0.04829116538167, 0.03739611431956291, 0.00901350099593401, -0.017783237621188164, 0.007005041930824518, 0.06521374732255936, -0.04448942095041275, -0.001974427839741111, -0.01777883805334568, -0.010074218735098839, 0.052536338567733765, 0.010986985638737679, -0.05855168402194977, 0.002295941114425659, 0.05862748622894287, -0.018686654046177864, 0.009296627715229988, 0.05611400678753853, -0.01385333202779293, -0.01487972866743803, 0.0060254475101828575, -0.00553701538592577, 0.04192540422081947, -0.0043938965536653996, 0.04728773236274719, 0.022780027240514755, 0.04408635199069977, 0.0402420349419117, 0.030449191108345985, 0.004602436441928148, -0.00034609646536409855, 0.03438469395041466, -0.018864672631025314, 0.019917406141757965, 0.049169864505529404, -0.022833101451396942, -0.012551072053611279, 0.027691073715686798, -0.00336558953858912, -0.015131955035030842, 0.029717903584241867, -0.0002206190547440201, -0.018512777984142303, 0.07100609689950943, -0.024539237841963768, -0.0009632608853280544, 0.020174585282802582, -0.05038361996412277, -0.00807451456785202, -0.001424996880814433, -0.027480613440275192, -0.07996875047683716, 0.0674571692943573, 0.06122046336531639, 0.009630650281906128, -0.010318771004676819, -0.003781232051551342, -0.05327252298593521, -0.03703957051038742, -0.01310105249285698, 0.020189804956316948, 0.016421742737293243, -0.05788811668753624, 0.009678777307271957, -0.006397174205631018, -0.02320665866136551, 0.04494218900799751, -0.0006181268254294991, -0.004328844137489796, -0.0151226706802845, -0.02749672718346119, -0.0324222669005394, 0.017187273129820824, -0.0013291853247210383, 0.03576153144240379, -0.017513660714030266, -0.03926995396614075, 0.04196324944496155, 0.024529602378606796, -0.03839185833930969, 0.002949425717815757, -0.047133415937423706, -0.024918083101511, -0.031956519931554794, 0.03616714105010033, 0.03480077162384987, 0.020796315744519234, 0.012408431619405746, 0.004058313090354204, 0.011635002680122852, -0.00840019341558218, -0.04651080444455147, -0.04065445438027382, -0.024401577189564705, 0.012467611581087112, 0.0001179248938569799, 0.020482389256358147, -0.02016732655465603, 0.061737027019262314, 0.04532814770936966, -0.04600858688354492, -0.022168967872858047, 0.004084112122654915, -0.027658512815833092, -0.045711684972047806, 0.020105594769120216, 0.026912668719887733, 0.016568027436733246, -0.02549196034669876, 0.0006843800656497478, 0.05096747353672981, 0.029959622770547867, -0.009195792488753796, -0.0374702550470829, -0.0015365430153906345, -0.0018516989657655358, -0.005196132697165012, 0.016527891159057617, 0.014265039004385471, -0.041434310376644135, 0.0026892477180808783, -0.011064303107559681, -0.0015135008143261075, 0.030200092121958733, -0.03050239197909832, 0.01566290110349655, 0.007238276768475771, -0.0041325693018734455, -0.032290395349264145, 0.0028075817972421646, -0.00782608613371849, -0.027387255802750587, -0.0257701575756073, 0.020722679793834686, 0.028529679402709007, -0.02556774578988552, 0.023793505504727364, 0.04326603561639786, -0.004706633742898703, 0.002938497345894575, 0.052715152502059937, -0.03823484852910042, 0.016283882781863213, -0.00674942322075367, -0.02307288534939289, 0.014580897055566311, 0.019152143970131874, 0.01470470055937767, 0.018799779936671257, 0.014285656623542309, -0.010024660266935825, 0.03161920979619026, -0.05633518844842911, -0.007505597546696663, -0.006484941113740206, 0.06189173087477684, 0.015004349872469902, 0.015350193716585636, 0.021618837490677834, -0.01567051373422146, 0.006854324135929346, -0.03386548161506653, -0.04937759041786194, 0.04089122638106346, 0.02386820875108242, -0.04418754205107689, 0.00031792453955858946, -0.029846489429473877, 0.0035512472968548536, -0.025613591074943542, 0.045003343373537064, 0.03972719609737396, -0.013608276844024658, -0.03610307350754738, 0.034285932779312134, -0.04221314936876297, 0.016100846230983734, -0.03184082359075546, -0.001867754152044654, 0.03346500173211098, -0.046938709914684296, 0.0045803808607161045, 0.021051863208413124, -0.005548099987208843, -0.03656449541449547, -0.05015626177191734, -0.0267051849514246, 0.020332125946879387, 0.03467363491654396, 0.04027175158262253, 0.016444213688373566, -0.08533694595098495, 0.031186046078801155, 0.006793998647481203, 0.03458467498421669, 0.03381342440843582, 0.004698758013546467, -0.04417804256081581, -0.024463847279548645, -0.006680360529571772, -0.018935035914182663, 0.020282799378037453, 0.013771400786936283, -0.0206126905977726, 0.04135099798440933, 0.031108038499951363, -0.033267632126808167, -0.003728025360032916, 0.06334396451711655, 0.011282265186309814, 0.021446961909532547, -0.01692955009639263, -0.016209861263632774, -0.02251625619828701, 0.01520445104688406, -0.01005307212471962, 0.021509651094675064, -0.004264159128069878, 0.006723419297486544, 0.026644494384527206, -0.020413838326931, -0.02768462337553501, 0.008778455667197704, 0.04632124677300453, 0.07400056719779968, -0.03186725080013275, -0.0368037074804306, 0.008669686503708363, 0.025318587198853493, 0.01570887304842472, 0.05204840004444122, 0.026328470557928085, -0.12699133157730103, 0.03021024726331234, 0.053612783551216125, 0.02616197243332863, -0.03704852610826492, -0.03557450696825981, -0.08106555789709091, -0.0011954496148973703, 0.040572959929704666, -0.04321671277284622, 0.04870036616921425, 0.0029610032215714455, -0.012751051224768162, -0.01870560273528099, -0.022382277995347977, -0.054033681750297546, 0.038655854761600494, -0.016929982230067253, 0.03785240277647972, -0.042907197028398514, -0.09039048850536346, -0.03226814419031143, 0.034337155520915985, -0.01017409935593605, 0.02713535539805889, -0.01873418316245079, -0.012680532410740852, 0.0138419009745121, 0.019632168114185333, -0.04168926551938057, -0.001537988893687725, 0.03242432698607445, -0.014157106168568134, -0.03053954988718033, 0.03128328546881676, -0.012794272974133492, 0.0015267252456396818, 0.017284037545323372, 0.03774169459939003, 0.0320393405854702, 0.009792787954211235, -0.02566572278738022, 0.02360929362475872, 0.027354199439287186, -0.001765008899383247, 0.017820868641138077, 0.01972665823996067, 0.017988966777920723, 0.02269972302019596, -0.0645967647433281, -0.01019676961004734, -0.012551525607705116, -0.027280114591121674, -0.052268244326114655, -0.0015116489958018064, -0.024564800783991814, 0.02644069492816925, 0.041075993329286575, 0.03335471823811531, -0.036397069692611694, 0.013401146046817303, 0.004117107484489679, 0.048450518399477005, -0.022008143365383148, -0.005495951045304537, 0.027341794222593307, 0.022222859784960747, -0.035898081958293915, -0.003854769514873624, 0.002736712107434869, -0.025859815999865532, -0.020995108410716057, 0.03153587505221367, -0.04595682770013809, 0.027478259056806564, -0.047251246869564056, -0.01747136004269123, 0.03062588721513748, 0.015670372173190117, 0.004745190963149071, -0.021532438695430756, 0.04190962016582489, 0.008712170645594597, -0.024567294865846634, -0.02530995011329651, 0.021723272278904915, -0.002311509568244219, 0.026819253340363503, -0.05794035643339157, 0.04554251953959465, -0.009310676716268063, -0.0018896909896284342, -0.0707569271326065, -0.04276043176651001, 0.04247166961431503, 0.018052009865641594, -0.038564614951610565, -0.01584685407578945, -0.04548962786793709, -0.028775693848729134, 0.003427203744649887, -0.033543527126312256, -0.007375798188149929, -0.01449334342032671, 0.0014877172652631998, -0.02096373215317726, -0.00041326729115098715, 0.08992191404104233, 0.015361533500254154, 0.0008419910445809364, 0.05916852876543999, 0.012326176278293133, -0.00783163495361805, 0.020430579781532288, 0.012714660726487637, -0.05386648699641228, 0.00006075766577851027, -0.048251859843730927, -0.03367270901799202, 0.006709678564220667, 0.004767544101923704, 0.00744740292429924, 0.003546359483152628, -0.0017428643768653274, 0.056324783712625504, -0.038727566599845886, -0.012418903410434723, -0.01295614242553711, -0.03554864227771759, -0.04386462643742561, 0.04473095387220383, -0.005396013613790274, 0.011594226583838463, 0.023982740938663483, -0.007744754198938608, -0.0019620382227003574, 0.00008761540811974555, 0.045186903327703476, 0.0053262305445969105, 0.0020046106074005365, -0.019221333786845207, -0.007504784502089024, 0.03755436837673187, 0.010786275379359722, -0.01226862519979477, -0.04073497653007507, 0.014003613032400608, -0.05508478358387947, -0.034390639513731, -0.010764024220407009, 0.0016432816628366709, 0.02932741306722164, 0.004697201773524284, 0.02223559468984604, 0.049001336097717285, 0.017379645258188248, -0.0057127224281430244, -0.005419015418738127, -0.04290055111050606, 0.012807906605303288, 0.02138511836528778, 0.049726102501153946, 0.04825584962964058, -0.006602975074201822, 0.010131529532372952, 0.009772226214408875, 0.027712609618902206, 0.056798193603754044, 0.027968905866146088, 0.04104575514793396, -0.01442880928516388, -0.00038581318221986294, -0.0195777490735054, 0.022182656452059746, -0.0023714762646704912, 0.023546189069747925, -0.017407439649105072, -0.02490224875509739, 0.03368077799677849, 0.0451568104326725, 0.029182633385062218, -0.036640703678131104, -0.01828635483980179, -0.06159224361181259, -0.022314423695206642, 0.03655266389250755, -0.010708536021411419, 0.029168646782636642, 0.007054495625197887, 0.021751489490270615, 0.025865014642477036, 0.025923587381839752, -0.05646936967968941, -0.06418928503990173, -0.0018187399255111814, -0.01859697885811329, -0.033630918711423874, 0.06465035676956177, 0.010292195715010166, -0.008611094206571579, 0.03388839215040207, -0.047158923000097275, 0.018132735043764114, -0.004068958107382059, 0.02465909905731678, 0.0020725291687995195, 0.09005763381719589, -0.010017892345786095, 0.020770292729139328, -0.019482508301734924, -0.005534789990633726, 0.13145476579666138, 0.08263545483350754, 0.02944893017411232, -0.04083433374762535, 0.020937301218509674, 0.021427465602755547, 0.007648039609193802, -0.044651903212070465, -0.016170121729373932, 0.04812154173851013, -0.0008896396029740572, 0.07148787379264832, 0.026692699640989304, -0.005971497856080532, 0.01806083880364895, 0.04565775766968727, -0.04412366449832916, 0.0036272730212658644, 0.014724347740411758, 0.03382868692278862, -0.00476950453594327, -0.020653627812862396, -0.0935937687754631, 0.008524592965841293, -0.013096341863274574, -0.04776713252067566, -0.006118977442383766, -0.006398600060492754, -0.006206251215189695, 0.03708098083734512, 0.031038828194141388, 0.026105212047696114, -0.024368876591324806, 0.004927963018417358, 0.018497345969080925, -0.030049189925193787, 0.004959435667842627, -0.02748480811715126, 0.014207561500370502, 0.02145618386566639, 0.016226762905716896, 0.005172243807464838, -0.016790928319096565, 0.036261167377233505, -0.026900863274931908, -0.02953977696597576, -0.02842746302485466, 0.053581058979034424, -0.009075464680790901, 0.013897957280278206, -0.019350185990333557, 0.019183006137609482, -0.024675333872437477, -0.011425605975091457, -0.04041276499629021, 0.034448664635419846, 0.016164161264896393, -0.02596234157681465, -0.01911202259361744, -0.0010638468666002154, -0.00923630129545927, -0.002217257395386696, 0.01132118422538042, 0.003085239790380001, -0.01359863206744194, -0.006368350237607956, -0.02968072146177292, 0.053011830896139145, -0.01180034689605236, 0.0027190283872187138, 0.004024127498269081, -0.044194288551807404, -0.005715979728847742, 0.004095354117453098, -0.009189745411276817, 0.010540426708757877, -0.020550036802887917, -0.017860082909464836, 0.010981383733451366, -0.019415607675909996, 0.049064185470342636, 0.018339205533266068, -0.013094387948513031, 0.009731526486575603, -0.014648946933448315, -0.0316595733165741, 0.002471474464982748, -0.0015139463357627392, 0.004299301654100418, 0.00547339441254735, -0.025941159576177597, 0.05501183122396469, 0.006893745623528957, -0.06302985548973083, -0.010489310137927532, -0.0151671739295125, -0.0317499153316021, 0.007675496395677328, -0.010456271469593048, 0.06263687461614609, 0.032028816640377045, -0.010157988406717777, -0.004536414053291082, 0.05670091509819031, -0.025284506380558014, -0.009687758982181549, 0.01819775067269802, -0.0297110453248024, 0.00326378527097404, -0.0025383310858160257, -0.002611594507470727, -0.040614187717437744, -0.01701296865940094, -0.008453555405139923, 0.00012238552153576165, 0.017713088542222977, 0.023462334647774696, -0.0769483745098114, 0.03879108652472496, -0.019509531557559967, 0.0019218306988477707, -0.02719399705529213, 0.004849955439567566, -0.016302304342389107, -0.04115943983197212, -0.033835817128419876, -0.01918829418718815, -0.0028301470447331667, 0.011087335646152496, -0.0045944685116410255, 0.012704453431069851, 0.025636497884988785, 0.024174688383936882, 0.020662415772676468, -0.01362652238458395, -0.011230065487325191, 0.00030313225579448044, 0.03309500589966774, -0.021686356514692307, 0.013171800412237644, 0.05755716189742088, -0.004707746207714081, -0.05582575127482414, 0.01931828260421753, -0.025099841877818108, 0.04933483153581619, 0.04094962030649185, -0.0036074798554182053, -0.005385580472648144, 0.03977103903889656, 0.005324045196175575, -0.006491605192422867, 0.005036500282585621, 0.020683016628026962, 0.005347034893929958, -0.005992542486637831, 0.032395437359809875, -0.009020550176501274, -0.00956542044878006, -0.016175854951143265, 0.07325566560029984, 0.04474378004670143, -0.010242542251944542, 0.008219771087169647, 0.039117634296417236, -0.018564047291874886, -0.01929212175309658, -0.02578456699848175, 0.04264087229967117, 0.02310177870094776, -0.02124045416712761, 0.0002186858037021011, -0.045084498822689056, -0.010422964580357075, -0.05214928090572357, -0.015597318299114704, -0.005379918962717056, 0.009656152687966824, 0.04691343754529953, -0.0328877717256546, 0.014427783899009228, 0.03868131712079048, -0.008270016871392727, 0.01463512796908617, -0.0032110337633639574, -0.011388489976525307, -0.00835319422185421, 0.0018301219679415226, -0.04327855259180069, 0.005469972267746925, 0.04253005236387253, 0.02492212876677513, 0.05693162977695465, 0.018154866993427277, 0.0190834179520607, -0.04015357419848442, -0.011601167730987072, 0.026827668771147728, 0.03910127654671669, -0.028401540592312813, 0.01631307788193226, -0.07851030677556992, 0.001886812155134976, 0.03893397003412247, -0.041873615235090256, 0.024232830852270126, -0.0013225993607193232, 0.0017631246009841561, -0.004118152894079685, 0.06833770126104355, 0.02732478827238083, 0.019561955705285072, -0.03793800249695778, -0.02256716601550579, 0.04310773313045502, -0.004101349972188473, -0.007462366484105587, 0.014602510258555412, 0.01573324017226696, 0.02013651840388775, -0.01868053339421749, 0.00774530041962862, -0.022647114470601082, 0.021484343335032463, -0.00659629050642252, -0.005673367530107498, -0.007998651824891567, -0.04914617910981178, -0.022892087697982788, -0.01492027286440134, 0.017477544024586678, 0.010022874921560287, 0.017687000334262848, -0.022719228640198708, -0.0058923568576574326, -0.00993253942579031, -0.05397333204746246, 0.007102820090949535, 0.010346288792788982, -0.006902915425598621, -0.09023119509220123, -0.027730390429496765, 0.01792433299124241, -0.030207239091396332, -0.03996768593788147, 0.031877413392066956, -0.03433690592646599, 0.04767703264951706, -0.0097196064889431, -0.01441734004765749, 0.052593935281038284, -0.03987562283873558, 0.011848308145999908, -0.08980471640825272, 0.08983863145112991, 0.01649039052426815, -0.010563048534095287, -0.039156459271907806, -0.0030212176498025656, -0.03768628463149071, 0.05127508193254471, 0.02998313494026661, 0.01951756700873375, 0.0015206948155537248, 0.006885593291372061, 0.003963939379900694, 0.009852949529886246, -0.019490042701363564, 0.027879834175109863, 0.020734170451760292, -0.02303875796496868, 0.007468968629837036, -0.03534087538719177, 0.01939260959625244, -0.006863127928227186, 0.0169806107878685, 0.005174529273062944, 0.015043182298541069, 0.035944052040576935, -0.05605996772646904, -0.0013658588286489248, -0.012462417595088482, -0.0014895291533321142, 0.00765607925131917, 0.006728806998580694, -0.014323814772069454, 0.0655859187245369, -0.007001100108027458, -0.03959488496184349, 0.03216000646352768, -0.03529976308345795, -0.021267961710691452, -0.0018816005904227495, 0.012958542443811893, 0.0016208450542762876, -0.03834771737456322, -0.036695633083581924, 0.019616182893514633, 0.012510130181908607, -0.00343915238045156, 0.023372596129775047, 0.008655395358800888, 0.036057665944099426, -0.0052565643563866615, 0.0159603264182806, -0.0014884185511618853, -0.012592654675245285, -0.0001795023854356259, -0.011553725227713585, 0.018574031069874763, -0.017811080440878868, 0.0022371180821210146, 0.016917653381824493, 0.002606883179396391, 0.01891656219959259, -0.020044904202222824, 0.02405553311109543, -0.03308458626270294, -0.03434828296303749, 0.022060513496398926, 0.0030827531591057777, 0.04892962425947189, 0.012597359716892242, -0.023451171815395355, 0.04864885285496712, -0.028971726074814796, 0.013768360950052738, -0.032817542552948, 0.02315131388604641, -0.01569060981273651, 0.030498696491122246, -0.0020084630232304335, 0.017688343301415443, -0.022072039544582367, 0.03434271737933159, 0.025453733280301094, 0.015820752829313278, 0.033406272530555725, -0.014176961034536362, 0.003608974162489176, -0.04381515830755234, 0.0077948556281626225, -0.04500870779156685, -0.008299767039716244, -0.0522686243057251, -0.01088056992739439, 0.01310527604073286, 0.03436984494328499, 0.038309745490550995, -0.034923478960990906, -0.04919968917965889, 0.023420289158821106, 0.013278215192258358, -0.06602577865123749, -0.01658923737704754, -0.05325407534837723, 0.0016680610133334994, -0.032498739659786224, -0.04635922238230705 ]
<p>I am using Logistic Regression in a <code>low event rate</code> situation.<br> Overall universe: 46,000<br> Events: 420</p> <p>Conventional logistic regression models divide the data into training and test sets and compute the error rates. The final coefficients and threshold levels are chosen and a model is created.</p> <p>OTH, I'm just trying to prove that so and so coefficient is significant and has positive association with the event in study. I'm not developing a model as of now. I don't focus on error rates (too many true negatives!) and chose my threshold level ~ hit rate. </p> <p>Should I consider dividing my universe into 2 samples, the conventional way? With such a low event rate, I'm worried that doing this to bias my coeff. estimates.</p>
73,419
[ -0.008321462199091911, -0.008830038830637932, -0.02792659029364586, 0.00962414313107729, 0.02772054448723793, 0.003533505368977785, -0.021295862272381783, -0.05151626840233803, 0.06575038284063339, -0.024749496951699257, 0.03599770367145538, 0.0551275908946991, 0.014276723377406597, 0.019532153382897377, 0.04655212536454201, -0.00650403369218111, 0.01914098486304283, 0.01344918180257082, 0.004734466318041086, -0.06079571321606636, 0.006030039396136999, -0.018923860043287277, 0.011002619750797749, 0.0011494641657918692, -0.03081422485411167, 0.03429098054766655, 0.044520843774080276, -0.04061766341328621, 0.006431968882679939, 0.020175093784928322, -0.0031908610835671425, -0.015990370884537697, 0.015939923003315926, 0.04364956542849541, 0.03491980582475662, 0.01630641706287861, -0.006137643940746784, -0.006785623263567686, -0.022219425067305565, 0.0012695143232122064, -0.0174171794205904, -0.0006851901998743415, 0.002303146757185459, 0.02615424431860447, -0.028819963335990906, -0.0050643691793084145, -0.0008495589136146009, -0.062492601573467255, 0.039191171526908875, -0.01886054314672947, 0.001816837815567851, -0.03063838928937912, 0.05557695031166077, 0.020784378051757812, -0.006277273874729872, 0.009932528249919415, 0.060341332107782364, 0.09507250785827637, -0.017544232308864594, -0.012366409413516521, -0.03170067071914673, -0.04478313401341438, -0.01757187768816948, 0.016085593029856682, -0.024307891726493835, 0.036603838205337524, -0.014655575156211853, -0.026908554136753082, 0.008780249394476414, -0.009639338590204716, 0.03702964261174202, -0.010450217872858047, 0.02160157822072506, -0.004655506927520037, 0.01938468962907791, -0.0337185263633728, 0.04213251918554306, 0.02478804811835289, 0.008084265515208244, 0.03132624924182892, 0.011636767536401749, 0.004527915269136429, 0.051577650010585785, 0.045517537742853165, 0.006879656109958887, -0.04728467017412186, 0.08488958328962326, -0.04399413242936134, 0.01988246478140354, -0.013125679455697536, -0.03355086222290993, 0.0032948944717645645, 0.04058244079351425, 0.004580730106681585, -0.035078469663858414, 0.0298140998929739, -0.02291005104780197, 0.06279176473617554, 0.027586277574300766, 0.005093988962471485, -0.05229492485523224, -0.03329893946647644, -0.0008271757396869361, 0.05329954996705055, -0.0216031763702631, -0.0276788417249918, -0.0386924147605896, -0.05087030306458473, -0.01942979358136654, -0.05977584049105644, -0.03621900826692581, -0.0037038095761090517, 0.014593461528420448, -0.0019136246992275119, 0.03619510307908058, 0.02251509763300419, -0.011692636646330357, -0.033813416957855225, 0.0533367320895195, 0.0316728837788105, 0.0691150575876236, -0.03867742791771889, 0.022599855437874794, -0.03662805259227753, 0.000605802284553647, -0.0016561681404709816, 0.03063289262354374, -0.018700066953897476, -0.0717240571975708, 0.020413817837834358, 0.004803600255399942, -0.016025567427277565, 0.010939689353108406, -0.0033785065170377493, 0.026062985882163048, 0.034443482756614685, -0.05834382027387619, -0.054183367639780045, 0.019913187250494957, 0.025977201759815216, -0.006579233333468437, -0.042599309235811234, -0.03736172616481781, 0.019003015011548996, 0.055946458131074905, 0.029457777738571167, 0.02615617960691452, 0.004656642209738493, 0.002740378025919199, 0.02008187770843506, -0.02582605555653572, 0.03950027376413345, -0.04376363754272461, -0.012107394635677338, -0.038862861692905426, -0.10557723045349121, 0.023198889568448067, -0.0001755808771122247, -0.02009083703160286, -0.00538428220897913, 0.01565546914935112, -0.014882945455610752, 0.0037748110480606556, -0.019517581909894943, 0.020970256999135017, -0.010978935286402702, 0.0766230970621109, -0.019969258457422256, 0.04174879938364029, 0.03302662819623947, 0.005789096467196941, 0.025165557861328125, 0.031634844839572906, 0.026491984724998474, 0.0343986339867115, -0.048232000321149826, 0.04490720480680466, -0.022573448717594147, 0.03173724189400673, -0.012032407335937023, -0.045512136071920395, -0.02623613551259041, 0.006031624972820282, -0.012139690108597279, 0.028952836990356445, 0.013497105799615383, 0.013270889408886433, -0.04009130969643593, 0.047698553651571274, -0.014953437261283398, -0.07423944026231766, -0.029021792113780975, -0.030226217582821846, -0.02194877155125141, -0.02821815386414528, 0.006812042091041803, -0.012075023725628853, 0.05918646231293678, -0.010306326672434807, 0.005902966950088739, -0.03490203246474266, -0.016567477956414223, 0.046321213245391846, -0.05503447353839874, 0.013610795140266418, 0.048458073288202286, 0.007647126447409391, -0.010249029844999313, 0.06639125198125839, -0.05671127513051033, -0.05292506888508797, 0.036183517426252365, 0.005788008216768503, -0.01668248139321804, -0.00407211622223258, -0.01952126808464527, 0.038371551781892776, -0.015472359955310822, -0.0312613844871521, 0.02747422084212303, -0.09373100847005844, 0.07716207206249237, 0.039925817400217056, -0.019716337323188782, -0.004522985313087702, -0.01988222450017929, 0.002342867199331522, 0.0011702351039275527, -0.018775800243020058, -0.013216962106525898, -0.06635037064552307, -0.020195281133055687, 0.03624850884079933, -0.02377074398100376, -0.022415144369006157, 0.013024228624999523, 0.04210545867681503, -0.019727448001503944, 0.009125136770308018, -0.012172920629382133, 0.01060958206653595, -0.02127211168408394, -0.0017675397684797645, 0.04078739136457443, 0.0167006254196167, 0.004126146901398897, 0.02365998364984989, -0.003682645270600915, 0.024337496608495712, -0.0309598445892334, 0.00020625987963285297, 0.06018861010670662, -0.009575793519616127, -0.002780344570055604, -0.011900531128048897, 0.01869223080575466, 0.04986419901251793, -0.026683760806918144, 0.007333912421017885, 0.04762784764170647, 0.02429085597395897, -0.004847455304116011, 0.000718572351615876, 0.004233742132782936, 0.01723901368677616, 0.05308709666132927, -0.039559777826070786, 0.02361612394452095, 0.0338062159717083, -0.07205335050821304, -0.026154275983572006, 0.004290559329092503, -0.026860436424613, -0.0328853540122509, 0.0072370111010968685, 0.019656818360090256, 0.027790268883109093, 0.031194273382425308, -0.015359770506620407, -0.036160774528980255, 0.004908023402094841, 0.005199282430112362, -0.0019584379624575377, 0.005405128002166748, -0.06872264295816422, -0.003757090773433447, -0.03511738032102585, -0.02537156082689762, 0.030812736600637436, -0.019720781594514847, -0.007099132519215345, 0.024169286713004112, 0.016650138422846794, -0.059264760464429855, -0.0350639745593071, -0.028115026652812958, -0.0011168151395395398, -0.003624801291152835, -0.056372642517089844, 0.06315196305513382, 0.03472653031349182, -0.04932631179690361, -0.001471380703151226, -0.031017376109957695, -0.008123544044792652, -0.05749484524130821, 0.0029783034697175026, 0.015210592187941074, -0.00488132843747735, -0.01845485530793667, 0.027574526146054268, -0.00036814119084738195, -0.004971999209374189, -0.09663880616426468, -0.04599983990192413, -0.010616746731102467, -0.017830898985266685, 0.021314002573490143, -0.013140620663762093, 0.009178911335766315, 0.04746801033616066, 0.059003908187150955, 0.0007482310174964368, -0.03317946195602417, -0.015827517956495285, -0.051410313695669174, -0.0040633222088217735, 0.011903802864253521, 0.0005421636742539704, 0.026871955022215843, 0.03441385179758072, -0.008110995404422283, 0.04223679006099701, 0.012596052139997482, 0.008253098465502262, 0.005581784527748823, 0.019426248967647552, 0.007069319020956755, -0.029391614720225334, 0.005658035632222891, 0.014065174385905266, -0.02914504148066044, 0.02268749661743641, -0.016714340075850487, 0.035637080669403076, 0.039687152951955795, -0.050378479063510895, 0.0006672111339867115, -0.009113006293773651, -0.0035724120680242777, 0.019660774618387222, -0.04078061878681183, 0.03295545279979706, -0.033328257501125336, -0.018699759617447853, 0.03194807842373848, 0.021826157346367836, -0.03293994441628456, -0.004203516989946365, 0.012106753885746002, 0.04945603013038635, 0.012053411453962326, -0.013554589822888374, -0.019183749333024025, -0.015616816468536854, 0.004844849929213524, 0.002112866146489978, -0.0015176349552348256, 0.03691558539867401, 0.03696839138865471, 0.02048233151435852, -0.03360544517636299, -0.029281621798872948, -0.009648848325014114, -0.0545290932059288, -0.007491333410143852, -0.008753498084843159, 0.04419751092791557, 0.006469563115388155, -0.0037943467032164335, 0.022673606872558594, -0.03040606714785099, 0.014981876127421856, 0.015535113401710987, -0.06365453451871872, 0.022951560094952583, -0.017988599836826324, -0.008324705064296722, 0.020957425236701965, -0.022948719561100006, 0.00018108528456650674, -0.03557687997817993, 0.0032206091564148664, -0.001083827461116016, 0.008480462245643139, 0.0038601141422986984, 0.01477165799587965, -0.007227552589029074, -0.013472164049744606, -0.010210209526121616, -0.0150837367400527, 0.02300678938627243, 0.03178801015019417, -0.0014268814120441675, 0.03775908052921295, 0.03611022233963013, -0.022631250321865082, -0.011402766220271587, -0.00732458708807826, 0.05312991887331009, 0.051113784313201904, -0.003682689508423209, 0.02244761399924755, -0.06735526770353317, 0.01914406009018421, -0.004085778724402189, 0.018200164660811424, 0.03918203338980675, -0.004671746864914894, -0.016659965738654137, -0.031123556196689606, -0.052265189588069916, 0.030761277303099632, 0.026893656700849533, -0.008765093050897121, 0.011253941804170609, 0.05019579455256462, 0.034546881914138794, -0.06421395391225815, -0.0037481007166206837, 0.08698074519634247, -0.015755340456962585, 0.023107826709747314, -0.021403420716524124, -0.002701135817915201, -0.0032702486496418715, -0.02310992032289505, 0.009103112854063511, 0.009737156331539154, -0.023862622678279877, -0.022394126281142235, 0.06072310730814934, 0.02237667702138424, -0.047616031020879745, 0.018710019066929817, 0.031537748873233795, 0.019494323059916496, -0.0003874789399560541, -0.05763337388634682, 0.03743796795606613, 0.05584869533777237, 0.031046217307448387, 0.021303534507751465, 0.01104781124740839, -0.060446977615356445, 0.002735759597271681, 0.028654849156737328, 0.05397820845246315, -0.016532689332962036, -0.030316723510622978, -0.0331488698720932, -0.01873556338250637, 0.015454208478331566, -0.05078482627868652, 0.019310232251882553, 0.027511050924658775, 0.05505555868148804, -0.024127991870045662, -0.023856282234191895, -0.07916302233934402, 0.0471000112593174, -0.022061236202716827, 0.023627998307347298, -0.03727467358112335, -0.027041098102927208, -0.03835885599255562, 0.04077097773551941, 0.006411167327314615, 0.07236290723085403, -0.02686406299471855, -0.0303095243871212, 0.00044562193215824664, -0.00765406247228384, -0.0028402823954820633, -0.019955303519964218, -0.022877749055624008, -0.0058975531719625, -0.017989041283726692, 0.0326203852891922, 0.03717667981982231, -0.01333126425743103, 0.016093939542770386, 0.03140087425708771, -0.009356529451906681, -0.01440805196762085, -0.04424930363893509, 0.043430108577013016, 0.04114355519413948, 0.01658388040959835, 0.08573424816131592, 0.026889147236943245, -0.018380582332611084, 0.03166414424777031, -0.04067065566778183, -0.002264683600515127, -0.013918638229370117, -0.02218647114932537, -0.0030431447084993124, 0.025406645610928535, -0.004848252050578594, 0.003392670303583145, -0.009072170592844486, 0.03324289619922638, 0.002885381691157818, -0.005718003027141094, 0.0200765710324049, -0.0007346495403908193, -0.0038309269584715366, -0.01021998468786478, 0.007077558431774378, 0.024946454912424088, -0.02767762541770935, 0.013396323658525944, -0.0009832773357629776, -0.036287788301706314, 0.006743141915649176, -0.004125027917325497, -0.05621280521154404, -0.003140105400234461, -0.060496583580970764, -0.03472059965133667, 0.014055604115128517, -0.03624476492404938, 0.03315896913409233, 0.01939406991004944, 0.025415562093257904, -0.003499397309496999, -0.028583046048879623, -0.016924994066357613, 0.013536345213651657, 0.0369376502931118, 0.028780505061149597, -0.02764669619500637, 0.05087992176413536, -0.03276246041059494, 0.017786400392651558, -0.08221042156219482, -0.04922071471810341, 0.0163302943110466, -0.020495455712080002, -0.004051598254591227, -0.014545815996825695, -0.011706750839948654, -0.014477953314781189, -0.02753870002925396, -0.030983569100499153, 0.0957833006978035, -0.042688608169555664, -0.026377368718385696, -0.021497609093785286, 0.005756806582212448, 0.05013655126094818, 0.029139989987015724, -0.05671723559498787, 0.01103335153311491, -0.010576008819043636, -0.017620190978050232, -0.00732799107208848, 0.0038144891150295734, -0.03854765370488167, -0.0433526374399662, -0.013703866861760616, -0.005027895327657461, 0.03926384821534157, -0.026903485879302025, -0.014740467071533203, 0.03306151181459427, 0.009507858194410801, 0.03127873316407204, -0.029610872268676758, -0.0002336147299502045, 0.010615216568112373, -0.016521230340003967, -0.01208391971886158, 0.021353503689169884, -0.007253826595842838, 0.008315674029290676, 0.051676489412784576, 0.014721016399562359, -0.007773761171847582, 0.024618791416287422, 0.04574505239725113, 0.025035135447978973, 0.024057146161794662, -0.01852245256304741, -0.030174247920513153, 0.05359089374542236, 0.007540400139987469, -0.02371126413345337, 0.014114733785390854, 0.03605762496590614, -0.0249079167842865, -0.03888712450861931, -0.037482768297195435, 0.02146977186203003, 0.03018895722925663, -0.00380784273147583, 0.0513334795832634, 0.014126617461442947, 0.015930505469441414, 0.0006185990641824901, -0.018187526613473892, -0.011728842742741108, -0.017227841541171074, 0.0008097595418803394, 0.015029486268758774, -0.03650439530611038, -0.025694599375128746, 0.017566382884979248, 0.026939906179904938, 0.00858576875180006, 0.040110040456056595, 0.0052003744058310986, 0.040773846209049225, 0.010268505662679672, -0.016625268384814262, -0.024844003841280937, 0.024909794330596924, -0.07313618808984756, 0.020527195185422897, -0.026076829060912132, 0.012757616117596626, 0.05833825096487999, 0.0016810388769954443, -0.004563744179904461, -0.07431098073720932, -0.0025048446841537952, -0.05437064915895462, -0.007596242241561413, 0.027096275240182877, -0.006082496605813503, 0.0154095608741045, -0.005312643013894558, 0.026669757440686226, -0.0012607687385752797, 0.006055715028196573, -0.005199860781431198, -0.09212281554937363, -0.02385200932621956, 0.0035438532941043377, -0.03559175878763199, 0.012318290770053864, 0.013555909506976604, -0.029260652139782906, 0.035126399248838425, -0.033629078418016434, 0.021889666095376015, 0.03577546030282974, 0.06633513420820236, -0.002498975954949856, 0.03313855826854706, -0.008621915243566036, 0.015627600252628326, 0.008023852482438087, -0.030544284731149673, 0.1556672751903534, 0.08428781479597092, 0.01795242913067341, -0.03842007368803024, 0.031108934432268143, 0.028606567531824112, 0.019831543788313866, 0.008052738383412361, -0.03748180344700813, -0.016752924770116806, -0.003032029839232564, 0.05846783518791199, 0.04489503055810928, 0.02385534718632698, -0.007143637165427208, 0.08022238314151764, -0.034879859536886215, -0.002578109037131071, 0.01290186308324337, 0.03924598544836044, -0.004538323730230331, -0.012029903009533882, -0.0074334354139864445, 0.017667483538389206, 0.002542325993999839, -0.0258160512894392, -0.007087911479175091, -0.01167295966297388, -0.005220099352300167, -0.015917902812361717, 0.0052598267793655396, -0.004022656008601189, 0.02434583753347397, -0.009105447679758072, 0.04340602830052376, -0.009625403210520744, 0.016110548749566078, -0.05795010179281235, 0.00031871622195467353, 0.0037959604524075985, -0.005322359036654234, 0.006868051365017891, 0.0004279064014554024, 0.020826805382966995, -0.03492270037531853, -0.056014858186244965, -0.048291515558958054, 0.04691274091601372, -0.027512788772583008, 0.02146891877055168, -0.009990724734961987, -0.015015779063105583, 0.012770975939929485, -0.021128136664628983, -0.04422476142644882, 0.04186749458312988, 0.01642126403748989, -0.04925191402435303, -0.004579738713800907, -0.026943916454911232, 0.07506197690963745, 0.027887962758541107, 0.028291005641222, 0.0011394479079172015, -0.020999694243073463, -0.023418772965669632, -0.006788956932723522, 0.05159759148955345, -0.004358821082860231, 0.010873804800212383, 0.01569690741598606, 0.01044341828674078, -0.07162099331617355, 0.002553745172917843, 0.0025747979525476694, -0.0026235037948936224, 0.0315101183950901, -0.023953299969434738, -0.038386669009923935, -0.03162550926208496, 0.0024221998173743486, 0.010904082097113132, 0.000986654544249177, -0.0075942138209939, -0.038571543991565704, 0.003961900249123573, -0.023108309134840965, 0.029279908165335655, 0.02876261994242668, 0.02227635309100151, 0.01165000256150961, 0.06095675379037857, 0.008417200297117233, -0.0454506054520607, -0.009775364771485329, -0.007911177352070808, -0.03239757940173149, 0.002470453968271613, -0.017532169818878174, 0.09014346450567245, -0.00403841445222497, 0.005878177937120199, 0.058265671133995056, 0.02294500358402729, -0.024803414940834045, 0.0011784695088863373, 0.028307119384407997, -0.04671652242541313, -0.03316722437739372, -0.006109367124736309, 0.001312129432335496, 0.004882368724793196, -0.032308682799339294, -0.02063664235174656, -0.04828224703669548, 0.020410357043147087, -0.013360463082790375, -0.0615789033472538, 0.03980694338679314, -0.0192126352339983, 0.0315190888941288, -0.027312712743878365, 0.02156820148229599, -0.013816355727612972, -0.006985986139625311, -0.0413602776825428, -0.03975525498390198, -0.00891577173024416, 0.03070509061217308, -0.00483806524425745, 0.01246565766632557, 0.028809919953346252, 0.009449775330722332, 0.01918758824467659, 0.025820927694439888, 0.04256924241781235, -0.012022269889712334, -0.009359225630760193, 0.011819381266832352, -0.009578117169439793, 0.029729679226875305, 0.0015821028500795364, -0.04840216785669327, 0.04067140072584152, -0.020608430728316307, 0.0274642426520586, 0.00962771289050579, 0.00473684910684824, -0.01443631760776043, 0.05735601484775543, -0.03804909437894821, -0.04846688359975815, 0.01172288041561842, 0.024879273027181625, -0.009543855674564838, 0.007530334871262312, 0.01495441421866417, 0.01447184570133686, -0.0004501366929616779, 0.003256694646552205, 0.050040535628795624, 0.03696216642856598, -0.0062371897511184216, -0.026594212278723717, 0.006326727103441954, 0.028621992096304893, -0.00876610167324543, -0.007585068698972464, 0.0030322978273034096, 0.0692620500922203, -0.019022000953555107, 0.05077889934182167, -0.021602844819426537, 0.006203352473676205, -0.09758421778678894, -0.0567655973136425, 0.009461182169616222, 0.008303282782435417, 0.021909363567829132, -0.040767472237348557, 0.006288302596658468, 0.02539813332259655, -0.013816535472869873, 0.0014000149676576257, -0.001849832129664719, -0.026364579796791077, -0.03513108566403389, -0.04131310060620308, -0.03434278070926666, 0.009191211313009262, 0.01618221215903759, 0.0014070076867938042, 0.050443071871995926, 0.02008938603103161, 0.02989768236875534, -0.03524617850780487, -0.026634514331817627, 0.011732268147170544, 0.021040601655840874, -0.006402215454727411, 0.06035514920949936, -0.03473031893372536, -0.03139539062976837, 0.04515659809112549, -0.004275667481124401, 0.0118441516533494, 0.05726682022213936, 0.044627878814935684, 0.0319121815264225, 0.028934800997376442, 0.040199317038059235, -0.016964564099907875, 0.012525837868452072, -0.00539741525426507, 0.03574732318520546, 0.013427255675196648, -0.02992849610745907, -0.0058206962421536446, 0.023104943335056305, 0.0013549099676311016, -0.03913651779294014, 0.029578980058431625, 0.03350450471043587, 0.01030636765062809, -0.014596708118915558, 0.0023400846403092146, 0.011127346195280552, -0.03182479366660118, 0.019232215359807014, -0.03368249908089638, 0.025634773075580597, 0.03455537557601929, 0.008854336105287075, -0.046593356877565384, 0.006323907058686018, -0.015125599689781666, -0.028762541711330414, 0.0017577827675268054, -0.00713924877345562, -0.022528303787112236, -0.03894880414009094, -0.002271880628541112, 0.009334507398307323, -0.030875463038682938, -0.048073675483465195, 0.005239896476268768, -0.054900992661714554, 0.038376081734895706, -0.031939078122377396, 0.02193746343255043, 0.040784452110528946, 0.0053217061795294285, 0.025852367281913757, -0.09576471894979477, 0.06262678653001785, 0.0007864145445637405, 0.02778504602611065, -0.02087973617017269, -0.022626301273703575, -0.020991381257772446, 0.015891898423433304, 0.05702398344874382, 0.027310220524668694, -0.018558725714683533, -0.010568778030574322, 0.03843129053711891, -0.00633523752912879, -0.022181803360581398, 0.0280894972383976, -0.03465776890516281, -0.04955307021737099, -0.014371821656823158, -0.030584242194890976, -0.005110897123813629, 0.011150096543133259, 0.03054027445614338, -0.04159931465983391, 0.027550339698791504, 0.00950908288359642, -0.00949331559240818, 0.019388334825634956, -0.03595703840255737, 0.016181325539946556, 0.04850780963897705, -0.008925671689212322, 0.02780233696103096, 0.024721862748265266, -0.00905760657042265, -0.07614167034626007, 0.038476720452308655, -0.00864557083696127, -0.026326486840844154, 0.030593492090702057, 0.004288333468139172, -0.000852205092087388, -0.0112264109775424, 0.006740370765328407, -0.009799260646104813, -0.002503748517483473, 0.023759525269269943, 0.016418594866991043, -0.00010143934196094051, 0.018277516588568687, -0.02083173394203186, 0.04845472425222397, 0.030281009152531624, -0.01651218719780445, 0.011299822479486465, 0.00858745351433754, 0.007270600646734238, 0.005296654999256134, 0.027072833850979805, 0.0166932325810194, 0.002544129267334938, 0.029696200042963028, 0.029022786766290665, 0.022772295400500298, -0.022508373484015465, 0.01765504851937294, 0.014294917695224285, 0.01597481220960617, 0.018486544489860535, -0.0022173619363456964, 0.0290509220212698, 0.046370070427656174, -0.010889274068176746, -0.011920307762920856, -0.047200459986925125, -0.03524605184793472, -0.04354667291045189, -0.0033419590909034014, 0.0332624688744545, 0.03831439092755318, -0.0017878608778119087, -0.027511917054653168, 0.008061097003519535, 0.015519531443715096, -0.0014029871672391891, -0.012163533829152584, 0.039615124464035034, -0.023601582273840904, 0.00572882778942585, -0.017705153673887253, 0.017000248655676842, -0.012420575134456158, -0.050640303641557693, 0.00424921466037631, 0.0629798173904419, 0.007338550873100758, -0.013883782550692558, -0.03213592991232872, -0.0065596383064985275, 0.02308535948395729, -0.030820271000266075, -0.016705280169844627, -0.057322483509778976, 0.016404107213020325, -0.015624265186488628, -0.04981144145131111 ]
<p>I'm working on a software and need to do some statistics. In my case I'm comparing two different networks that have a certain number of nodes with attributes and want to test with a Fisher's exact test if some of these attributes are enriched in the smaller one.<br> I also have a good math library that is able to calculate hypergeometric distributions and want to use it.</p> <p>So after reading a bit it seemed to me that you need to calculate the probabilities for your obtained data and more extreme cases and then add these.</p> <p>If this is correct and my table looks e.g. like</p> <pre><code>------------------------------------- | |Network1|Network2| ------------------------------------- |has Attribute |a=7 |b=10 | ------------------------------------- |has not Attribute|c=17794 |d=1107 | ------------------------------------- </code></pre> <p>How more extreme tables do I have to calculate for a one-tailed test? I guess until a=0, b=17, c=17801 and d=1100?</p> <p>Thanks a lot!</p>
35,782
[ -0.0247407928109169, -0.026713095605373383, 0.008146143518388271, -0.009240557439625263, 0.05154264345765114, 0.007804904133081436, 0.00012591916311066598, -0.01759510301053524, 0.01703651249408722, -0.0007768064388073981, 0.04400620236992836, 0.052793409675359726, 0.022801106795668602, -0.0007149080047383904, 0.01857353188097477, 0.004349789582192898, -0.00933310016989708, -0.0071703363209962845, -0.01435571163892746, -0.025933297351002693, 0.010608474723994732, 0.0005601080483756959, 0.03447467088699341, -0.021728890016674995, -0.012370177544653416, 0.03381672874093056, 0.03168104588985443, -0.05800269544124603, 0.02459018863737583, 0.03846033290028572, 0.012014600448310375, -0.03125102072954178, 0.044333960860967636, 0.038161445409059525, 0.03711826354265213, 0.008098091930150986, -0.03829193115234375, -0.033882029354572296, -0.008776060305535793, -0.008637784980237484, -0.003939678426831961, -0.010118246078491211, -0.0014950170880183578, 0.04498693346977234, -0.001312742824666202, 0.020943155512213707, -0.0003178358019795269, -0.025798579677939415, 0.03400196507573128, -0.03450985997915268, 0.014638149179518223, -0.0015925202751532197, 0.060281481593847275, 0.002223425777629018, 0.0007941849762573838, 0.005051101092249155, 0.047975994646549225, 0.04984046146273613, 0.00934172235429287, -0.06637132167816162, -0.033731911331415176, -0.036595094949007034, -0.01361218560487032, -0.03579286113381386, -0.013324360363185406, 0.042727746069431305, -0.009453400038182735, -0.04704590514302254, 0.03650588542222977, 0.004537294618785381, 0.008427112363278866, -0.006535167805850506, 0.050106801092624664, -0.0039734188467264175, 0.02385689690709114, -0.00832286849617958, 0.04229249805212021, -0.008077803999185562, 0.03853386640548706, 0.037347499281167984, -0.007711966522037983, 0.013719516806304455, 0.021663466468453407, 0.023984577506780624, 0.04852665588259697, -0.012474210932850838, 0.04224991425871849, -0.010025876574218273, -0.04051190987229347, 0.01982024498283863, -0.028416242450475693, -0.011084333062171936, 0.050311874598264694, 0.01098873745650053, -0.056206997483968735, 0.007380872964859009, -0.025677211582660675, -0.007701866794377565, -0.015505819581449032, 0.007695914711803198, -0.04404250159859657, -0.09051763266324997, 0.021312737837433815, 0.047151219099760056, -0.018614551052451134, 0.015399985946714878, -0.03626856952905655, -0.029151281341910362, -0.038753680884838104, 0.01088368147611618, 0.02568330056965351, -0.00040513736894354224, 0.041947562247514725, -0.008720958605408669, 0.006010815035551786, -0.03349151462316513, -0.014470375142991543, 0.01160337682813406, 0.044698379933834076, 0.038329318165779114, 0.04470963403582573, 0.021115193143486977, 0.016681311652064323, -0.0021261645015329123, -0.02981877699494362, 0.03592008724808693, -0.0068475245498120785, -0.03025391884148121, -0.032647136598825455, 0.03914777934551239, -0.037237443029880524, 0.012812504544854164, 0.0273997001349926, 0.011440049856901169, 0.03855300322175026, -0.0015224209055304527, -0.07097823917865753, -0.05146341398358345, 0.026944100856781006, -0.011875775642693043, 0.023642590269446373, -0.0361742228269577, 0.00828074011951685, 0.06535597145557404, 0.06959917396306992, 0.020453613251447678, 0.04470405727624893, 0.017861969769001007, -0.025145813822746277, 0.005834487266838551, -0.013183088973164558, -0.03256066516041756, -0.04358580708503723, 0.013825378380715847, -0.017857003957033157, -0.09663499891757965, 0.039881542325019836, 0.01009336020797491, -0.031573716551065445, 0.01747776009142399, 0.05910695344209671, -0.002537959022447467, -0.008689486421644688, -0.01172474306076765, -0.014410007745027542, -0.011734217405319214, 0.11087911576032639, 0.021615156903862953, 0.02783716842532158, 0.025518065318465233, -0.00845753401517868, 0.02135947346687317, -0.010576136410236359, 0.014317980036139488, 0.060011450201272964, 0.016086028888821602, 0.013940231874585152, -0.011539009399712086, 0.04018956795334816, 0.008183549158275127, -0.01924113556742668, -0.006310698110610247, -0.004756225738674402, 0.0028723389841616154, 0.014595812186598778, 0.045986779034137726, 0.005519409663975239, -0.03301069512963295, 0.0326361320912838, -0.005411140620708466, -0.0518970862030983, -0.034770943224430084, -0.00812660064548254, -0.0041962298564612865, -0.04343362897634506, -0.01820444129407406, 0.012773792259395123, -0.010638653300702572, -0.010956947691738605, -0.017458869144320488, -0.03281303495168686, -0.00785007793456316, 0.045212265104055405, -0.0281548872590065, -0.028874941170215607, 0.05958181992173195, 0.028038904070854187, -0.009968399070203304, 0.05066677927970886, -0.04805998504161835, -0.041972000151872635, 0.03402137756347656, -0.04759722948074341, -0.006077782716602087, 0.02494264952838421, 0.009627844206988811, 0.02219115011394024, 0.0031516882590949535, 0.01869320683181286, 0.060803983360528946, -0.05413031950592995, 0.07669156044721603, 0.06796730309724808, 0.011784289963543415, 0.012796499766409397, -0.01644882746040821, 0.006597630213946104, 0.010791868902742863, 0.028344137594103813, -0.01652560941874981, -0.10631870478391647, 0.020359456539154053, -0.002007977105677128, -0.016014911234378815, -0.04510576277971268, 0.01512926910072565, 0.07264766842126846, -0.0355725921690464, 0.04008050262928009, 0.01907747983932495, -0.004763183183968067, 0.011938740499317646, 0.01615256257355213, 0.024927960708737373, 0.008669544011354446, -0.009695525281131268, -0.017387252300977707, 0.016723057255148888, 0.031674742698669434, -0.00007486825052183121, -0.021409794688224792, 0.027228087186813354, 0.02862284518778324, 0.013892383314669132, -0.0024353773333132267, -0.014391535893082619, 0.06726150214672089, 0.027331363409757614, -0.0019256696105003357, 0.005306928884238005, 0.010008725337684155, -0.007734161801636219, 0.02659614570438862, -0.03265351057052612, 0.006067993119359016, 0.04973336309194565, -0.06472010910511017, -0.025774750858545303, 0.0012820051051676273, -0.031376246362924576, 0.02985544130206108, -0.021888505667448044, -0.03845878317952156, -0.05992093309760094, 0.030453534796833992, 0.03334100916981697, -0.016721565276384354, 0.04570925980806351, -0.0016222329577431083, -0.02083364687860012, -0.013094191439449787, -0.053286824375391006, -0.022699225693941116, -0.02453281730413437, -0.046394530683755875, 0.0051100850105285645, 0.009702866896986961, -0.006192733068019152, 0.049948688596487045, -0.006293701007962227, -0.01602344401180744, 0.025576269254088402, 0.00432808930054307, -0.02140580676496029, -0.02650262974202633, -0.013675299473106861, 0.0016325950855389237, -0.02562873065471649, -0.05973650887608528, 0.03351827338337898, 0.020606352016329765, -0.04176105931401253, 0.025357641279697418, -0.03283051401376724, -0.004235029220581055, 0.019741671159863472, 0.014624354429543018, -0.02394573763012886, 0.014940613880753517, -0.016037609428167343, 0.00816391222178936, -0.022635919973254204, -0.021066632121801376, -0.0881778746843338, -0.07585695385932922, 0.02225879207253456, -0.010594826191663742, 0.011182131245732307, 0.0089634470641613, -0.009884330444037914, 0.043771110475063324, 0.04298843443393707, -0.049345314502716064, -0.012703387066721916, 0.0033790431916713715, -0.0246737003326416, -0.0014029847225174308, 0.005248181987553835, 0.012529989704489708, 0.0059429858811199665, 0.021096326410770416, 0.01848168671131134, 0.015902958810329437, 0.06389264017343521, -0.019244130700826645, 0.024581335484981537, 0.05410830304026604, 0.035987455397844315, -0.026891235262155533, 0.05465715751051903, 0.04056709632277489, 0.011306379921734333, 0.05332857370376587, -0.009749486111104488, 0.010505086742341518, 0.014824600890278816, -0.030833285301923752, 0.014923063106834888, -0.01257272157818079, 0.011792464181780815, -0.007626755628734827, 0.03253123536705971, 0.04934118315577507, -0.02079915441572666, 0.007069830782711506, 0.03753200173377991, 0.04003315791487694, -0.06029515340924263, -0.01804310455918312, 0.06190275773406029, 0.08231719583272934, -0.0057887183502316475, -0.03209836408495903, 0.012248333543539047, -0.0032915151678025723, -0.01277388446033001, -0.03929226100444794, -0.04320661723613739, 0.03318658843636513, 0.060271043330430984, 0.000046133303840178996, -0.005025612190365791, -0.016159240156412125, 0.00723291328176856, -0.05782996490597725, -0.008154897950589657, -0.04446205869317055, 0.07642542570829391, 0.017106562852859497, 0.030126795172691345, 0.0199733916670084, -0.004124140366911888, -0.022826580330729485, 0.029515095055103302, -0.07222337275743484, 0.011962752789258957, 0.01701357215642929, -0.0034372673835605383, 0.0011328032705932856, -0.06468020379543304, 0.015657374635338783, -0.032099805772304535, 0.017268193885684013, -0.0008865263080224395, 0.022080235183238983, -0.03572830930352211, -0.000803859147708863, -0.02229417860507965, 0.010314207524061203, 0.015678172931075096, 0.045605339109897614, -0.0015658877091482282, 0.005730573087930679, 0.0014636849518865347, 0.04076112434267998, -0.00539062125608325, -0.02949264645576477, -0.018723564222455025, 0.02311534993350506, 0.00823273230344057, 0.04458915814757347, 0.019215118139982224, 0.05688084289431572, -0.03608251363039017, -0.018176846206188202, -0.008356718346476555, 0.03714657947421074, 0.039017558097839355, -0.014791205525398254, -0.009694952517747879, -0.0286103542894125, -0.004935300908982754, -0.04000326618552208, 0.06302055716514587, -0.008521976880729198, -0.005916839465498924, 0.023741915822029114, 0.015965627506375313, -0.05569804832339287, 0.030582888051867485, 0.06468608975410461, 0.0005222196341492236, -0.04976467415690422, 0.0003274817718192935, 0.004562071058899164, -0.011550703085958958, -0.03249441832304001, 0.007804848253726959, 0.03524935245513916, -0.010093895718455315, -0.012777228839695454, 0.034133076667785645, -0.03008972853422165, -0.05587737262248993, 0.03020418807864189, 0.005492431111633778, 0.05067582428455353, -0.004406068939715624, -0.050114262849092484, 0.05716700106859207, 0.040273211896419525, 0.007773129269480705, 0.032445620745420456, -0.004640114959329367, -0.047601018100976944, 0.02495204098522663, 0.046080924570560455, 0.07187574356794357, -0.024232568219304085, -0.00499936006963253, -0.050234321504831314, -0.0015394099755212665, 0.039659880101680756, -0.06184803694486618, 0.01748725399374962, -0.03800061717629433, 0.009277718141674995, -0.027441466227173805, -0.006640258710831404, -0.027963031083345413, 0.017585942521691322, -0.035160407423973083, 0.0479724146425724, -0.009518975391983986, -0.009061322547495365, 0.02970556542277336, 0.012086358852684498, 0.008411020040512085, 0.03513171523809433, -0.04627469554543495, -0.059328045696020126, -0.012572189792990685, 0.028285613283514977, -0.014136172831058502, -0.05996982380747795, 0.01784239150583744, 0.016985543072223663, -0.0038566847797483206, 0.05129832401871681, -0.0433943085372448, 0.015997741371393204, 0.021557509899139404, -0.026936359703540802, -0.04705012962222099, -0.013084134086966515, 0.023143630474805832, 0.041091691702604294, 0.04104922339320183, -0.02060534991323948, 0.049797024577856064, 0.02358442358672619, -0.05139167606830597, 0.000038612539356108755, -0.037020646035671234, -0.021332288160920143, -0.01561169233173132, 0.015873903408646584, -0.03329823911190033, -0.008553040213882923, -0.044954124838113785, 0.02018614299595356, -0.012558838352560997, 0.030736682936549187, -0.007994035258889198, -0.013732513412833214, 0.02951069548726082, 0.008317586965858936, 0.020166026428341866, 0.003574034897610545, -0.024556200951337814, 0.007199288811534643, 0.021942174062132835, 0.011210642755031586, 0.03599541261792183, -0.02261602319777012, 0.011766543611884117, -0.02571304328739643, -0.04114793241024017, 0.0173586867749691, -0.03296327963471413, -0.016094988211989403, 0.00319737964309752, -0.050635840743780136, 0.017122961580753326, -0.012838827446103096, 0.03758327662944794, -0.015475306659936905, 0.019945314154028893, -0.02025093510746956, 0.027588214725255966, 0.01755928061902523, 0.011497464030981064, -0.03766954317688942, 0.03168143704533577, -0.009240665473043919, -0.03773044794797897, -0.05465983226895332, -0.012950773350894451, 0.01780184544622898, 0.0005370007129386067, -0.0354270376265049, -0.020472995936870575, -0.03217092901468277, -0.0025443986523896456, -0.016756776720285416, -0.018502920866012573, 0.032366037368774414, 0.0013720061397179961, -0.024936597794294357, 0.024590665474534035, 0.01078431960195303, 0.08393140137195587, 0.01066680159419775, 0.010091427713632584, 0.028607891872525215, -0.013987541198730469, -0.004834506660699844, 0.0009688303107395768, -0.0007067158003337681, -0.027111206203699112, -0.009601369500160217, -0.018414737656712532, 0.030578503385186195, 0.0315958708524704, -0.006775045767426491, -0.005258294753730297, -0.038605183362960815, 0.0013381114695221186, 0.009271546266973019, -0.011267122812569141, -0.0031331826467067003, -0.01854489929974079, 0.021734759211540222, -0.008634557016193867, 0.049044590443372726, -0.0007814460550434887, -0.013407996855676174, -0.027281535789370537, 0.01006438210606575, 0.018103525042533875, 0.0025233160704374313, 0.10158431529998779, 0.019700033590197563, -0.016606343910098076, 0.005087381694465876, -0.028534099459648132, 0.033242642879486084, -0.011305702850222588, -0.012357024475932121, -0.017909444868564606, 0.042371831834316254, -0.009680804796516895, -0.023770909756422043, -0.03448353707790375, 0.026049232110381126, 0.04077616333961487, 0.008341063745319843, -0.005749321077018976, 0.027385715395212173, 0.006975934840738773, -0.019298452883958817, -0.027283331379294395, -0.040060240775346756, 0.00070348841836676, 0.007524088025093079, 0.045910101383924484, -0.029069840908050537, -0.0316290482878685, 0.0455162413418293, 0.0369274839758873, 0.0331854522228241, 0.06096843257546425, -0.00517816748470068, 0.0006232319283299148, 0.020748864859342575, -0.0003407516924198717, -0.010548909194767475, 0.03167073801159859, -0.03689355030655861, 0.04626057296991348, -0.034944623708724976, -0.019289866089820862, 0.03661876916885376, 0.060252584517002106, -0.014848018996417522, -0.07647638767957687, -0.05832160636782646, -0.021661382168531418, 0.024209873750805855, 0.014264191500842571, -0.02631191723048687, 0.020132027566432953, 0.01774677447974682, 0.015062999911606312, -0.021495187655091286, 0.028632977977395058, -0.022920701652765274, -0.037380117923021317, -0.05622881278395653, -0.002741827629506588, -0.05762594938278198, 0.0018982506589964032, 0.022582776844501495, -0.018521521240472794, 0.02261916548013687, -0.017673995345830917, 0.0714205875992775, -0.020419394597411156, 0.06600360572338104, 0.015615907497704029, 0.08782119303941727, -0.012447557412087917, 0.014881079085171223, 0.009331881068646908, -0.03215651214122772, 0.15484538674354553, 0.07918766885995865, 0.00011355352035025135, -0.05911124870181084, 0.00037577032344415784, 0.029597332701086998, -0.006557906977832317, -0.03285077214241028, -0.019279958680272102, 0.010188151150941849, -0.007564677391201258, 0.05836007371544838, 0.031645480543375015, 0.016184579581022263, 0.017697786912322044, 0.008280284702777863, -0.04438236355781555, -0.011067520827054977, 0.017329521477222443, 0.01644539274275303, 0.011294305324554443, -0.042965117841959, -0.03977234661579132, -0.02970406413078308, 0.04767245054244995, 0.008096076548099518, -0.024689629673957825, 0.0023118809331208467, 0.016148991882801056, 0.03934028372168541, -0.008004041388630867, 0.02556035667657852, 0.057435061782598495, -0.010712342336773872, 0.0031633921898901463, -0.033470652997493744, 0.00874839723110199, -0.00467379204928875, -0.023645984008908272, 0.04165944829583168, 0.03467831388115883, -0.01338308583945036, -0.004990629851818085, 0.019540876150131226, -0.054062604904174805, -0.027230357751250267, -0.032151464372873306, 0.03811138868331909, 0.00043548093526624143, -0.023553475737571716, -0.009620290249586105, -0.014022599905729294, 0.020550018176436424, -0.037215378135442734, -0.02868686057627201, -0.0022237140219658613, 0.003147787181660533, -0.03434153273701668, -0.001755622448399663, -0.010503886267542839, 0.02022371254861355, 0.010354508645832539, 0.0359555184841156, -0.018543384969234467, -0.021923784166574478, -0.034663621336221695, -0.03371588885784149, 0.06082085892558098, 0.010197686031460762, -0.016923222690820694, -0.0217581856995821, -0.02317483350634575, -0.00008089288894552737, 0.002806602045893669, -0.01624525897204876, -0.02337934449315071, 0.00520004378631711, 0.005749196745455265, 0.0006191733991727233, -0.0042570605874061584, 0.03270767629146576, 0.020846281200647354, -0.01504538394510746, -0.019062835723161697, -0.033701904118061066, 0.012848426587879658, 0.019853172823786736, 0.03357991576194763, 0.0048415702767670155, -0.0040160128846764565, -0.012899973429739475, 0.011033028364181519, 0.036780890077352524, 0.0034030056558549404, -0.03644004836678505, -0.031148837879300117, -0.05618730187416077, 0.03427326679229736, -0.015539783053100109, 0.0788300633430481, 0.01598580926656723, -0.035501085221767426, -0.005991395562887192, 0.009679717011749744, 0.010791067965328693, 0.008340585045516491, -0.003170974086970091, -0.08195266872644424, 0.006366868037730455, -0.012122414074838161, -0.005136287305504084, -0.013119284063577652, -0.03839936479926109, -0.03258231282234192, -0.049505945295095444, 0.028971612453460693, -0.005135257728397846, -0.05189383029937744, -0.02677026018500328, -0.044496890157461166, 0.0006321902037598193, -0.007717764936387539, 0.008610752411186695, -0.03218052163720131, -0.02202645130455494, -0.0027914675883948803, 0.026287591084837914, -0.008752241730690002, 0.03862880542874336, -0.017045948654413223, -0.007912528701126575, 0.009054139256477356, 0.03856746107339859, 0.024471022188663483, -0.004263029899448156, -0.01602957583963871, 0.029642539098858833, 0.030743388459086418, -0.029690703377127647, -0.04197495058178902, 0.038610778748989105, -0.0395723357796669, -0.005279215518385172, 0.07526741921901703, 0.004721086006611586, 0.03884251415729523, 0.005343337543308735, 0.0013109368737787008, -0.014488473534584045, 0.02318640612065792, -0.01742785982787609, -0.02428019978106022, -0.02525637485086918, -0.02878430113196373, 0.04481250420212746, 0.0057547371834516525, -0.021990638226270676, 0.017362091690301895, -0.014972029253840446, -0.01804243214428425, 0.029500756412744522, -0.014404398389160633, -0.024894367903470993, -0.0028713014908134937, 0.04107813909649849, 0.02247467078268528, 0.00877983309328556, -0.026219967752695084, 0.008312656544148922, 0.048425957560539246, -0.026187483221292496, -0.012030069716274738, -0.018424058333039284, -0.012678456492722034, -0.05385763943195343, -0.015209917910397053, 0.021663405001163483, 0.0034244696144014597, -0.00455138785764575, -0.039898596704006195, 0.024108409881591797, 0.011859314516186714, -0.03363761305809021, 0.021745122969150543, 0.007477257400751114, 0.0002657529548741877, -0.03793074190616608, 0.026836959645152092, -0.019431617110967636, -0.001994442893192172, 0.009919362142682076, 0.009840243496000767, 0.03635129705071449, -0.028043324127793312, -0.007483062334358692, -0.028662685304880142, -0.008426050655543804, 0.013124438934028149, -0.0025863333139568567, -0.08298702538013458, 0.015275925397872925, -0.019999058917164803, -0.03200849890708923, 0.033469658344984055, -0.05613159015774727, -0.04422007501125336, -0.0007019831682555377, 0.010465032421052456, 0.024905569851398468, 0.04793688654899597, 0.03409777209162712, -0.02665288932621479, -0.023847978562116623, -0.01686037704348564, 0.005318963434547186, 0.009529788978397846, -0.014383376576006413, 0.002373084658756852, 0.012438653968274593, -0.02643069252371788, -0.01050129160284996, 0.05336180701851845, -0.005788139067590237, -0.0030258321203291416, -0.028712475672364235, -0.024244261905550957, 0.039192844182252884, -0.017854705452919006, 0.008252760395407677, -0.0076386574655771255, -0.0012026311596855521, 0.035142142325639725, 0.007826733402907848, 0.024383123964071274, 0.030344752594828606, 0.0005638563889078796, 0.003216172568500042, 0.001497881836257875, 0.047319699078798294, -0.05662107095122337, -0.07402926683425903, -0.010660386644303799, -0.04024513065814972, 0.01138534676283598, -0.0039634727872908115, -0.02384134754538536, -0.08036832511425018, 0.007268501911312342, -0.021083474159240723, 0.04271167516708374, 0.03025875799357891, 0.005408945493400097, 0.03873329237103462, -0.07327000051736832, 0.025284912437200546, -0.002218828769400716, 0.02160305716097355, -0.043756596744060516, -0.004794576670974493, 0.003099435241892934, -0.007746092509478331, 0.044670961797237396, 0.018342450261116028, -0.0019118011696264148, -0.03292492404580116, 0.004790761042386293, -0.019031183794140816, -0.06327856332063675, 0.03725750371813774, -0.03605585917830467, -0.02764534205198288, -0.037278901785612106, -0.030603617429733276, 0.050056345760822296, 0.005267934408038855, -0.009608537890017033, 0.001757830730639398, -0.002175038680434227, 0.018392357975244522, -0.004836187697947025, 0.02749764733016491, -0.04183590039610863, 0.01530536636710167, 0.02391967363655567, 0.003258723998442292, -0.0017297351732850075, -0.014276767149567604, 0.034197140485048294, 0.002407605992630124, 0.08520934730768204, -0.029590696096420288, -0.010451209731400013, -0.0186210498213768, -0.014405396766960621, -0.020787034183740616, -0.06988468766212463, -0.006686542648822069, 0.01638265699148178, -0.011177738197147846, 0.008601429872214794, 0.009724801406264305, -0.03041806071996689, 0.045993655920028687, 0.0016994427423924208, 0.04587177932262421, -0.026136936619877815, -0.054346371442079544, 0.01742706075310707, 0.023129116743803024, -0.03393036872148514, 0.01784234307706356, 0.01821710541844368, 0.04585318639874458, -0.022993316873908043, 0.014143547974526882, -0.00936193112283945, 0.019396569579839706, -0.04139997437596321, -0.028562290593981743, 0.006605543661862612, -0.00463008601218462, 0.009491395205259323, 0.04348613694310188, -0.01722581870853901, 0.047402773052453995, -0.02263992838561535, 0.037083327770233154, 0.0022805167827755213, -0.028363483026623726, 0.015668371692299843, 0.01677895337343216, -0.026205550879240036, 0.016357317566871643, -0.036098893731832504, 0.001216256758198142, 0.03831665962934494, -0.02163943275809288, 0.03921705111861229, -0.0366852730512619, 0.028107669204473495, -0.053963396698236465, -0.007614159025251865, 0.02003457583487034, -0.0001523765386082232, -0.0386924110352993, -0.00823199562728405, 0.05616408586502075, 0.04319722205400467, 0.01651591807603836, -0.010003014467656612, -0.041227735579013824, 0.05436970293521881, 0.03058701567351818, -0.04406027868390083, -0.004142652731388807, -0.03645770996809006, 0.015910372138023376, -0.0355447493493557, -0.043645232915878296 ]
<p>Why are measures of dispersion calculated relative to some central point? Why wouldn't, for instance, all possible non-repeated, pairwise differences in the dataset be a valid measure of spread?</p>
35,784
[ -0.0016373321413993835, 0.016124969348311424, 0.021714583039283752, -0.02413410134613514, 0.032014261931180954, -0.013125981204211712, 0.0037717358209192753, -0.0008360540377907455, 0.00772199546918273, -0.01700126752257347, 0.011713004671037197, 0.01975172944366932, 0.09020291268825531, -0.012841841205954552, 0.01669057458639145, -0.00409995811060071, -0.009964228607714176, 0.04630459100008011, -0.02026805281639099, -0.011004558764398098, -0.0038532335311174393, 0.01813075877726078, -0.0015481224982067943, -0.011269668117165565, -0.01859930343925953, 0.014681834727525711, -0.0027906899340450764, -0.02008660137653351, 0.03784477338194847, 0.039528172463178635, -0.05578385666012764, -0.05008125677704811, 0.024866394698619843, 0.03002209961414337, 0.030437154695391655, 0.005601468496024609, -0.034361839294433594, -0.015590468421578407, -0.019419852644205093, 0.03218931704759598, -0.0471249483525753, -0.048874545842409134, -0.003687635762616992, 0.03992865979671478, -0.05775536596775055, 0.007256556302309036, 0.0120474174618721, -0.03741228207945824, 0.035498619079589844, -0.04526396840810776, 0.08513408154249191, -0.0029846758116036654, 0.02212679386138916, 0.05100775137543678, -0.004766140598803759, 0.04883962124586105, 0.06856443732976913, 0.04055033251643181, -0.02235591970384121, -0.04644353687763214, -0.04395704343914986, 0.0018184351501986384, -0.0007254765368998051, -0.01795808970928192, -0.030020995065569878, 0.0629882663488388, 0.03326060250401497, -0.0013312173541635275, 0.016071803867816925, -0.006841763854026794, 0.0011994094820693135, 0.04155224934220314, 0.02113744243979454, -0.016636742278933525, 0.014841249212622643, -0.009171049110591412, 0.04130345955491066, 0.00301962997764349, 0.04877346381545067, 0.021803593263030052, 0.01666039228439331, -0.006464625708758831, -0.00551960151642561, 0.017370590940117836, 0.02772463858127594, -0.011560158804059029, 0.054547831416130066, -0.051000840961933136, 0.015139316208660603, 0.029997671023011208, -0.02389904484152794, 0.018060529604554176, 0.045749731361866, -0.01008595060557127, -0.0417938195168972, 0.013745315372943878, -0.011585024185478687, 0.002171457279473543, -0.007966502569615841, 0.00009002452134154737, -0.02720182202756405, -0.047725796699523926, 0.018345652148127556, 0.03783198073506355, 0.0045273443683981895, -0.01764681562781334, -0.06083539500832558, 0.023596905171871185, -0.005396412685513496, -0.0177502129226923, 0.01754469983279705, 0.013741477392613888, 0.025805851444602013, 0.011296914890408516, 0.043609146028757095, 0.01545019168406725, 0.0045698899775743484, -0.04461842030286789, 0.03638638183474541, 0.05641680583357811, 0.00800621509552002, -0.017491910606622696, 0.0286281518638134, 0.006816358771175146, -0.030003622174263, 0.039501823484897614, 0.013732577674090862, -0.0043355305679142475, -0.054428696632385254, 0.004621186759322882, 0.012473447248339653, 0.00854422152042389, 0.020589446648955345, 0.006158844102174044, 0.011498413048684597, 0.0005884038400836289, -0.10637630522251129, -0.05469231680035591, 0.037997275590896606, -0.019591381773352623, 0.002199543174356222, -0.0263091791421175, -0.013079510070383549, 0.02795054018497467, 0.03949904441833496, -0.03195858374238014, 0.039385803043842316, -0.0027927111368626356, 0.03060300275683403, 0.022963834926486015, -0.00045149592915549874, -0.033400438725948334, -0.03256287798285484, -0.039242714643478394, -0.002730713225901127, -0.06845666468143463, -0.0026260598096996546, 0.04872429370880127, -0.02085469663143158, 0.00029679934959858656, 0.009204902686178684, -0.01373092271387577, 0.003625711193308234, -0.00002695815419428982, 0.02822272665798664, 0.00023691655951552093, 0.05226680263876915, -0.004555224906653166, 0.017971180379390717, 0.028937844559550285, -0.003677072236314416, -0.0013246792368590832, 0.02129736915230751, 0.06826881319284439, 0.045314375311136246, -0.011912183836102486, 0.007489400915801525, 0.0024667263496667147, 0.02868453972041607, 0.015963060781359673, -0.0679733008146286, -0.007891835644841194, 0.0009280014783143997, 0.013805687427520752, 0.02462604083120823, 0.0738242045044899, -0.05766400694847107, -0.013181568123400211, 0.03765105828642845, -0.02800283208489418, -0.004700660239905119, -0.06917530298233032, 0.040562838315963745, 0.005011245142668486, -0.017769046127796173, 0.026308750733733177, 0.032173093408346176, 0.014048098586499691, -0.013102773576974869, -0.032563261687755585, -0.015455206856131554, -0.005847861059010029, 0.03321561589837074, -0.02530590072274208, 0.021379662677645683, 0.07423844188451767, 0.012482314370572567, -0.008611055091023445, 0.0429757758975029, -0.042864780873060226, -0.07597312331199646, 0.029053596779704094, -0.03503560647368431, 0.03277108818292618, -0.01230529509484768, -0.03177375718951225, -0.009310950525105, 0.007145441137254238, -0.01592830754816532, 0.06571760028600693, -0.05406009033322334, 0.07950406521558762, 0.07223410159349442, -0.011347703635692596, -0.0026206879410892725, 0.028169389814138412, -0.004166904371231794, -0.02924393117427826, 0.0075755552388727665, -0.05021025240421295, -0.05996357649564743, -0.009793429635465145, 0.01665901578962803, 0.01062756683677435, -0.016324691474437714, -0.014179474674165249, 0.04495810344815254, 0.046236976981163025, 0.02006525918841362, 0.019096434116363525, -0.0009610972483642399, -0.03693699091672897, 0.019622523337602615, 0.02213292382657528, 0.023256277665495872, -0.029115235432982445, 0.028057919815182686, 0.03957058861851692, 0.0360926054418087, 0.004314064979553223, -0.0036279892083257437, 0.049748171120882034, 0.04003756120800972, -0.004155147820711136, -0.0002529580087866634, 0.006592283025383949, 0.021081889048218727, -0.03150913864374161, 0.045859791338443756, 0.03536050021648407, 0.017858106642961502, 0.003651481820270419, 0.003224204061552882, -0.05310659483075142, 0.05628267303109169, 0.0355561263859272, -0.02076287940144539, 0.008521638810634613, 0.028789076954126358, -0.028425732627511024, 0.011180730536580086, -0.07198791205883026, -0.042817581444978714, -0.002186953090131283, -0.008532638661563396, 0.06814046949148178, 0.03244897350668907, 0.031303100287914276, -0.024973874911665916, 0.006851147394627333, -0.027871273458003998, -0.014324305579066277, -0.009533035568892956, 0.031094228848814964, -0.050551898777484894, 0.01923491805791855, 0.0001816065632738173, -0.029333965852856636, -0.004552036989480257, -0.018971826881170273, -0.005354087799787521, 0.007911082357168198, -0.010258793830871582, -0.025867914780974388, -0.01493487972766161, -0.037816740572452545, -0.007026622071862221, -0.0250505693256855, -0.027947790920734406, 0.04261254146695137, -0.05081778019666672, -0.05512537062168121, 0.028413675725460052, -0.029310304671525955, -0.03195132315158844, 0.008625744841992855, 0.0044431183487176895, 0.06062477454543114, -0.016318565234541893, -0.003737039165571332, 0.050528332591056824, -0.05506538599729538, -0.03641222417354584, -0.03793719783425331, -0.08178660273551941, 0.013360565528273582, -0.028879592195153236, 0.013794216327369213, 0.00906712282449007, -0.006665722467005253, 0.10259523242712021, 0.04460136592388153, 0.0012568669626489282, -0.013235187157988548, -0.015121773816645145, -0.024532824754714966, -0.01814831979572773, 0.038354963064193726, 0.011287123896181583, -0.0011789870914071798, 0.022262079641222954, 0.02792755886912346, 0.0702480748295784, 0.04877324029803276, -0.021105274558067322, -0.039713308215141296, -0.010686896741390228, 0.022910011932253838, -0.024405796080827713, 0.018561474978923798, 0.01851705275475979, -0.018418990075588226, -0.0064108907245099545, 0.02616744115948677, 0.0475023090839386, 0.011410964652895927, -0.07240042835474014, 0.04502017796039581, -0.007682149764150381, 0.020093247294425964, -0.026774484664201736, 0.057869695127010345, 0.024064017459750175, -0.0412495918571949, -0.0060079158283770084, 0.005121310241520405, 0.05610111355781555, -0.026639968156814575, -0.00988440215587616, 0.06913281232118607, 0.03928610682487488, -0.032249242067337036, 0.013478770852088928, -0.007373827509582043, 0.021925432607531548, -0.011877271346747875, -0.002002772642299533, -0.03243560343980789, 0.02392112836241722, 0.041946232318878174, -0.0017917859368026257, -0.039133865386247635, -0.06105392426252365, -0.01294290367513895, -0.044835757464170456, 0.021430768072605133, 0.0002206393692176789, 0.025215143337845802, 0.004950429778546095, 0.05440732091665268, 0.012086248956620693, -0.027629436925053596, -0.02674986980855465, 0.017412809655070305, -0.04755103215575218, 0.008481517434120178, -0.029095875099301338, -0.03762737661600113, -0.012969710864126682, -0.062117647379636765, 0.02568509802222252, 0.030792975798249245, -0.007009404711425304, -0.016553902998566628, 0.03111879527568817, -0.033688340336084366, -0.007114933338016272, -0.004976585973054171, -0.02932015433907509, -0.016162512823939323, 0.036787014454603195, 0.03628896549344063, -0.04815537482500076, 0.028709236532449722, 0.04312315583229065, 0.01006529200822115, -0.01896025985479355, -0.04968345910310745, 0.023040834814310074, 0.013627558015286922, 0.01444480661302805, 0.005410980898886919, 0.014228127896785736, -0.03511407971382141, 0.02228069305419922, 0.03194088861346245, 0.049406182020902634, 0.007483478169888258, -0.03223467618227005, -0.0221115630120039, -0.0078190378844738, -0.00045183722977526486, 0.011660038493573666, 0.018488068133592606, 0.02467329055070877, 0.041476160287857056, 0.07503897696733475, 0.04261420667171478, -0.0573238842189312, 0.0220447089523077, 0.026784444227814674, 0.006080900318920612, -0.0019275943050161004, -0.043315038084983826, -0.030197683721780777, -0.004304447211325169, -0.0028944648802280426, 0.03955259546637535, -0.007632219232618809, -0.003124857787042856, 0.00276349950581789, 0.027972597628831863, 0.014337119646370411, -0.045372817665338516, -0.02063114568591118, 0.006666227709501982, 0.01880272664129734, -0.028318937867879868, -0.037126678973436356, -0.017457792535424232, -0.0016819963930174708, 0.04704085737466812, 0.02126966044306755, -0.015180988237261772, -0.09467306733131409, 0.008036506362259388, 0.031162701547145844, 0.0043619428761303425, 0.0020422106608748436, -0.008949367329478264, -0.013591074384748936, -0.03133159130811691, 0.04041079059243202, -0.03668515384197235, 0.010721943341195583, -0.02945137396454811, -0.0011091162450611591, -0.023675475269556046, -0.027007803320884705, -0.024281995370984077, 0.03596748784184456, -0.01033183466643095, -0.0026276614516973495, 0.015313106589019299, 0.003675310406833887, -0.04392358288168907, 0.025863749906420708, -0.0059524597600102425, 0.06762567907571793, 0.0008928172755986452, -0.016834910959005356, 0.014217935502529144, 0.030942687764763832, 0.008382810279726982, -0.037073682993650436, -0.005419121123850346, 0.02012515626847744, 0.006175607908517122, 0.05687789246439934, -0.003263561986386776, -0.05412118881940842, 0.006403600797057152, 0.014648279175162315, 0.018290845677256584, 0.023256411775946617, -0.005766501650214195, 0.04837632551789284, 0.044231198728084564, 0.011164936237037182, 0.08868037164211273, 0.00990578904747963, -0.004585574381053448, -0.009771626442670822, -0.044562384486198425, 0.0411636121571064, -0.02495698630809784, -0.007118527311831713, -0.014522712677717209, -0.0002684344653971493, -0.024066077545285225, 0.023720839992165565, 0.015215156599879265, 0.003554542316123843, -0.017341535538434982, -0.027242152020335197, -0.010033935308456421, 0.004902685061097145, 0.01592196710407734, 0.0011048429878428578, 0.025565756484866142, 0.037687476724386215, 0.00482225464656949, 0.00462346663698554, 0.023691175505518913, -0.018673380836844444, -0.004301477689296007, -0.004323250148445368, -0.00381882069632411, -0.005306081846356392, -0.05438624322414398, -0.04012110456824303, 0.023365700617432594, -0.015021499246358871, 0.024386513978242874, -0.02329077199101448, 0.0021911400835961103, 0.016273636370897293, -0.0635865181684494, -0.02157672680914402, -0.0009317246731370687, -0.002140369266271591, 0.06202709674835205, -0.04458990320563316, 0.031086351722478867, -0.032805148512125015, 0.01794580928981304, -0.11103089153766632, -0.00852791778743267, 0.00945975724607706, 0.019821885973215103, 0.004077506717294455, -0.044801123440265656, -0.0038154602516442537, 0.01996094547212124, -0.014402206055819988, -0.026639772579073906, 0.04600602760910988, 0.029574697837233543, -0.04436532035470009, -0.002573417266830802, -0.0025085946545004845, 0.06977453082799911, -0.034993726760149, -0.012870850041508675, 0.025419598445296288, -0.012529268860816956, 0.012428333051502705, 0.014792957343161106, 0.036964498460292816, -0.049546658992767334, -0.019442494958639145, -0.016228321939706802, -0.012305518612265587, 0.04105209931731224, -0.023601995781064034, -0.03834395110607147, -0.013676955364644527, -0.012423550710082054, 0.021296342834830284, -0.017215318977832794, 0.0027566172648221254, -0.018710726872086525, 0.009337523020803928, -0.030747046694159508, 0.007402073126286268, -0.0308244526386261, -0.010371099226176739, 0.054396189749240875, 0.014185951091349125, -0.036301206797361374, 0.028363976627588272, 0.05119166895747185, -0.00013540341751649976, 0.009341452270746231, -0.013186480849981308, -0.013162797316908836, 0.06179214268922806, 0.008707615546882153, -0.009741120971739292, 0.018560897558927536, 0.009863772429525852, -0.018628932535648346, 0.0053996192291378975, -0.03788216412067413, 0.02358383499085903, 0.05579221993684769, -0.024851832538843155, 0.040073927491903305, 0.0428747795522213, -0.03124481812119484, 0.02315111830830574, -0.009140059351921082, 0.02716973051428795, 0.002740357303991914, -0.010134365409612656, 0.05593525618314743, -0.017096467316150665, -0.0016981716034933925, 0.013711024075746536, 0.07214759290218353, 0.03484458476305008, 0.0039057028479874134, 0.0036624500062316656, -0.008014746941626072, 0.020027605816721916, 0.025249341502785683, -0.03632604330778122, 0.03951708972454071, -0.054016049951314926, -0.01801503635942936, -0.020344959571957588, -0.03450801223516464, 0.0375184491276741, -0.035886455327272415, -0.020767686888575554, -0.02517688274383545, -0.015417828224599361, -0.03548142686486244, 0.02075926959514618, -0.02551310881972313, 0.031748391687870026, 0.01925039291381836, -0.0029277813155204058, 0.0031608110293745995, -0.024984080344438553, -0.026626674458384514, 0.010501627810299397, -0.07981222122907639, -0.02898998185992241, -0.03808165341615677, -0.055403731763362885, 0.010105621069669724, 0.009386814199388027, -0.044404201209545135, 0.01876462809741497, -0.04011504724621773, 0.03551538661122322, -0.00174914940726012, -0.003070943523198366, -0.02270083874464035, 0.07115884125232697, 0.029087817296385765, 0.004220287781208754, 0.019095268100500107, -0.01738184690475464, 0.13089242577552795, 0.04229651764035225, 0.035995963960886, -0.07185480743646622, 0.007880115881562233, -0.007263044826686382, -0.04381737485527992, -0.009710718877613544, 0.019124913960695267, 0.005442433059215546, 0.02820681221783161, 0.05560515448451042, 0.031388163566589355, 0.02897483855485916, -0.016087185591459274, 0.067337766289711, -0.04626698046922684, -0.022313538938760757, 0.028305567800998688, -0.014718188904225826, 0.020470207557082176, -0.03453546762466431, -0.060774318873882294, -0.004913275130093098, -0.0035479695070534945, 0.013388745486736298, -0.00051783217350021, -0.03008115664124489, -0.020365580916404724, 0.02023916319012642, -0.042336635291576385, -0.0011406183475628495, 0.017551330849528313, -0.0011172726517543197, -0.056638509035110474, -0.014601408503949642, 0.03551844134926796, -0.04738457873463631, 0.005331869702786207, 0.039102476090192795, -0.034431081265211105, 0.009621373377740383, 0.020696211606264114, 0.015745563432574272, -0.03607739880681038, -0.03159559890627861, -0.03541164472699165, 0.01443406380712986, -0.01168944500386715, -0.020671669393777847, 0.015612631104886532, -0.017279362305998802, -0.03348509222269058, -0.0357137955725193, -0.018708916381001472, 0.00415471475571394, 0.013999829068779945, -0.004778656177222729, -0.011574451811611652, -0.01366973202675581, -0.014500947669148445, -0.015342708677053452, 0.04667383059859276, 0.01874103955924511, 0.007455255836248398, -0.02133028768002987, -0.012075847014784813, 0.06072685867547989, 0.0025381436571478844, 0.017239103093743324, 0.019100671634078026, -0.022007063031196594, -0.04455200210213661, 0.02090487815439701, -0.003718347754329443, 0.005452981684356928, 0.011870733462274075, 0.0030949341598898172, 0.005277697462588549, 0.002295386977493763, -0.026576068252325058, 0.019851775839924812, -0.03149508684873581, 0.020988335832953453, -0.04637490585446358, -0.027580231428146362, 0.016062434762716293, 0.03598834201693535, 0.014306935481727123, 0.013455084525048733, -0.04184919595718384, 0.0356748029589653, 0.0010105291148647666, -0.034187521785497665, -0.018275244161486626, -0.021697720512747765, -0.01695481687784195, -0.016962803900241852, 0.02938099205493927, 0.023173168301582336, 0.006826149299740791, -0.0011715854052454233, -0.025149444118142128, 0.03379068523645401, -0.021808192133903503, 0.0010616781655699015, 0.03577852621674538, -0.05768483132123947, -0.008274759165942669, 0.03674202039837837, -0.023129846900701523, -0.024171246215701103, -0.03214554488658905, -0.03822401911020279, -0.028571484610438347, 0.03235882520675659, 0.03343234583735466, 0.008080653846263885, -0.028425410389900208, -0.015772830694913864, 0.017671819776296616, -0.007128799334168434, -0.015576694160699844, -0.06776800751686096, 0.023296773433685303, -0.02587335929274559, -0.01363181322813034, -0.0074456254951655865, 0.002399529330432415, -0.0028981147333979607, 0.019924575462937355, 0.03914594650268555, 0.02394309639930725, 0.03515826538205147, 0.01984362117946148, 0.02027270942926407, 0.005694242659956217, 0.04786578193306923, -0.01850445568561554, -0.04434267431497574, 0.03786094859242439, -0.021952150389552116, -0.056784916669130325, 0.019501272588968277, -0.025240756571292877, 0.030008617788553238, 0.016645092517137527, 0.01789793372154236, -0.004246470518410206, 0.011615760624408722, -0.025385618209838867, -0.04076436907052994, 0.013439178466796875, -0.004029741045087576, -0.020266449078917503, -0.03094928152859211, 0.004347816109657288, 0.010401658713817596, -0.03171089291572571, 0.02007150463759899, 0.04402001202106476, 0.013547049835324287, 0.02502351626753807, 0.024995742365717888, -0.03200323134660721, 0.020451340824365616, 0.00458792457357049, -0.0013140614610165358, 0.028291745111346245, 0.07428692281246185, -0.06403446197509766, 0.017242249101400375, -0.0008655365672893822, 0.02895566076040268, -0.10147631168365479, 0.003610579762607813, -0.004879939369857311, 0.014092094264924526, -0.004450483247637749, -0.03103124350309372, -0.0000478580295748543, 0.007244614418596029, -0.04226768761873245, 0.06250304728746414, -0.027778519317507744, -0.01227706391364336, -0.01805035211145878, 0.04127030819654465, -0.038199447095394135, 0.06608659029006958, 0.047021109610795975, 0.022452643141150475, 0.011411640793085098, -0.012367346324026585, 0.0031566983088850975, -0.01348189264535904, -0.016948958858847618, -0.01374337263405323, -0.02080675959587097, -0.046053338795900345, 0.010160131379961967, -0.00022250684560276568, -0.03927195072174072, 0.021850766614079475, -0.03362644091248512, -0.00009874407987808809, 0.022247815504670143, -0.019806133583188057, 0.0025305470917373896, 0.013838309794664383, 0.014255881309509277, -0.0005267292144708335, -0.031017085537314415, 0.006350251380354166, 0.012981925159692764, 0.0409611351788044, -0.01926238462328911, 0.003031778149306774, 0.05035773664712906, -0.028742441907525063, -0.03191239386796951, 0.00837431475520134, -0.020898541435599327, -0.04916740208864212, 0.033858876675367355, 0.0206786897033453, 0.03302371874451637, -0.036577530205249786, 0.030203934758901596, -0.03799785301089287, 0.005061340052634478, 0.04332950711250305, 0.03815533220767975, -0.044260431081056595, 0.041961975395679474, -0.028182554990053177, -0.03302489593625069, -0.01308711152523756, 0.03473775088787079, 0.009589815512299538, -0.06008324772119522, -0.019342420622706413, -0.024072062224149704, -0.01821230724453926, -0.007525711320340633, 0.022419007495045662, -0.01604827493429184, 0.007050626445561647, -0.0028274061623960733, -0.0016069194534793496, 0.02751041390001774, -0.021909762173891068, -0.015494260936975479, -0.08359925448894501, 0.08584058284759521, 0.009478175081312656, -0.035036224871873856, -0.06318746507167816, -0.016610583290457726, -0.03614171966910362, 0.038946732878685, 0.05164104700088501, 0.03482726961374283, 0.01528641115874052, -0.015343309380114079, 0.03219280764460564, 0.01790628954768181, -0.02494865655899048, 0.010175875388085842, -0.024959145113825798, -0.024047186598181725, -0.010066010989248753, -0.038309741765260696, -0.03100365586578846, 0.017314240336418152, -0.022163255140185356, -0.005800195038318634, 0.037343040108680725, 0.020017355680465698, 0.007626269478350878, 0.05121544003486633, 0.015978995710611343, -0.06533384323120117, 0.03332783654332161, 0.0059069013223052025, 0.01589677855372429, 0.04394447058439255, -0.02703161910176277, -0.05085242539644241, 0.03208640217781067, -0.02977025881409645, -0.015543625690042973, -0.00626651244238019, 0.052825283259153366, 0.0026096124202013016, -0.055284205824136734, -0.010687561705708504, 0.02176554501056671, -0.026364080607891083, -0.007714255712926388, 0.03568359836935997, 0.017749425023794174, 0.03089030273258686, 0.02331015281379223, -0.01869112439453602, 0.021242039278149605, -0.020724207162857056, 0.009454754181206226, 0.04280700162053108, 0.016222119331359863, 0.010071801953017712, -0.00821542739868164, -0.0007067532860673964, -0.042288217693567276, 0.02444886416196823, -0.004702587611973286, 0.03710545226931572, 0.017663640901446342, 0.018643179908394814, -0.0017622667364776134, -0.016380684450268745, 0.01395553257316351, 0.016984635964035988, -0.006942396983504295, 0.07963519543409348, -0.00766345439478755, 0.012317952699959278, -0.024678397923707962, -0.022664448246359825, -0.00003507473593344912, 0.01280574593693018, 0.020330417901277542, 0.04248369485139847, 0.0035726905334740877, 0.004917141981422901, -0.0189836323261261, -0.019733715802431107, 0.013356080278754234, -0.009980786591768265, 0.029971446841955185, -0.0029834830202162266, -0.019656885415315628, -0.030026253312826157, -0.004774146713316441, -0.0435921885073185, 0.0011477114167064428, 0.0002746749669313431, 0.05095016211271286, 0.020948849618434906, 0.026853585615754128, -0.024528764188289642, -0.015368958003818989, 0.020439397543668747, -0.06964997947216034, -0.045087121427059174, -0.07562728226184845, 0.01990911364555359, -0.0021861232817173004, -0.03662000223994255 ]
<p>I am new to statistics and within the last two days I tried to get my head around PCA plots. Now, I kind of understand what they are showing but I am still not sure about the 95% confidence ellipse that is very often shown in such plots. The 2 dimensional PCA plot displays the two biggest variances (whatever these are) in the data but I don't know what the ellipse is trying to tell me and what it means if a sample/dot (whatever is displayed) is lying outside that ellipse.</p> <p>Help is very much appreciated.</p>
73,420
[ -0.014055617153644562, -0.029224751517176628, 0.01241921354085207, 0.003375640604645014, 0.02786731906235218, 0.005725053139030933, 0.004417066927999258, -0.03255614638328552, 0.0008534562075510621, -0.027887428179383278, 0.05143522471189499, 0.05023393779993057, 0.039783280342817307, 0.03075488656759262, 0.0022070729173719883, 0.025253457948565483, -0.022815274074673653, 0.00670489901676774, -0.002930436283349991, -0.013079163618385792, -0.016348835080862045, -0.003965642768889666, 0.008666141889989376, -0.018332192674279213, -0.04050174355506897, 0.03794596344232559, 0.0345844067633152, -0.03279705345630646, 0.05441039428114891, 0.06271056830883026, -0.07991228997707367, -0.049458879977464676, 0.01184089481830597, 0.026341380551457405, 0.006194460671395063, -0.01266415510326624, 0.00507979653775692, -0.021712487563490868, -0.0039965128526091576, 0.04786476865410805, -0.02734127640724182, -0.006533331237733364, 0.008837107568979263, 0.02495773695409298, 0.0016202193219214678, 0.003469069954007864, 0.008503369055688381, -0.03629995882511139, 0.03612562268972397, -0.03814733028411865, 0.0762721449136734, 0.0018965030321851373, 0.018046945333480835, 0.027945641428232193, 0.016077876091003418, 0.02421145886182785, 0.035826146602630615, 0.05004144832491875, -0.01628786139190197, -0.09377646446228027, -0.010224937461316586, -0.006116617936640978, -0.007318257354199886, -0.008220312185585499, -0.020313581451773643, 0.009810971096158028, -0.020676536485552788, -0.026342976838350296, 0.029498213902115822, -0.005497179459780455, 0.018768182024359703, 0.015465489588677883, 0.013869648799300194, -0.020644301548600197, -0.03107440285384655, -0.013852350413799286, 0.0159723162651062, 0.012259474024176598, 0.027860986068844795, 0.004822674207389355, 0.026971375569701195, 0.023992346599698067, 0.00005045293437433429, 0.011128164827823639, -0.000027388916350901127, 0.03696608170866966, 0.0700414627790451, -0.03896679729223251, 0.03273359313607216, -0.006386651191860437, -0.01928797736763954, 0.01897960528731346, 0.040708668529987335, 0.0014605927281081676, -0.04909317195415497, 0.004081660881638527, 0.004897724837064743, 0.03722705692052841, -0.02090568281710148, -0.02564731054008007, -0.009608089923858643, -0.019606415182352066, 0.018595246598124504, 0.04201274737715721, -0.02138197235763073, -0.023390846326947212, -0.007045846898108721, 0.019626589491963387, 0.0010664020664989948, -0.025430046021938324, -0.01744353026151657, 0.04085575044155121, 0.03714704513549805, 0.038346000015735626, 0.03522263839840889, -0.010748697444796562, 0.008501030504703522, -0.0017432225868105888, 0.014323893934488297, 0.05330094322562218, 0.04575190320611, 0.002349953865632415, 0.01568865217268467, -0.01905600167810917, -0.05286141857504845, 0.04276062548160553, 0.02418859675526619, 0.018196702003479004, -0.030109453946352005, 0.09042256325483322, -0.010605463758111, 0.0007566160638816655, 0.04827309399843216, 0.005839948076754808, 0.03967397287487984, -0.001848499639891088, -0.07784160226583481, -0.033909425139427185, 0.055401403456926346, 0.012862916104495525, -0.005582473240792751, -0.0677327960729599, 0.005003162659704685, 0.05175827071070671, 0.03318636119365692, -0.033023133873939514, 0.003566630184650421, -0.001472414587624371, 0.037406254559755325, 0.010232575237751007, -0.06035894155502319, 0.012463400140404701, -0.0018401345005258918, -0.03712162375450134, -0.000130114407511428, -0.06979921460151672, 0.012895457446575165, 0.03160762041807175, -0.013901966623961926, -0.038616765290498734, 0.004815193824470043, -0.029518574476242065, -0.005884772632271051, -0.03586497902870178, -0.026068704202771187, -0.0004793954431079328, 0.0726967602968216, -0.004032839089632034, -0.003011325839906931, 0.027767347171902657, -0.009358562529087067, 0.04083467274904251, 0.034803882241249084, 0.05437738448381424, 0.060382235795259476, -0.002971068024635315, 0.005725379101932049, -0.03734142333269119, 0.010718557983636856, 0.010638687759637833, -0.062481705099344254, -0.030845025554299355, -0.00024062026932369918, 0.01191580668091774, 0.005140399560332298, 0.042078059166669846, -0.0170269887894392, -0.05462360009551048, 0.010554032400250435, -0.03380338475108147, -0.05274562910199165, -0.05940575152635574, 0.012740163132548332, -0.006857453379780054, -0.04037638008594513, 0.02258402854204178, 0.03404095768928528, -0.017182661220431328, -0.03545565903186798, -0.03612464293837547, -0.04551522806286812, -0.011084173806011677, 0.049496281892061234, -0.05240112543106079, 0.016951296478509903, 0.04882051423192024, 0.03292170539498329, -0.011507399380207062, 0.021666117012500763, -0.052710842341184616, 0.0054205963388085365, -0.015873413532972336, -0.04264413192868233, 0.011381985619664192, 0.0005843719700351357, -0.02608960121870041, -0.010177225805819035, 0.01838846504688263, -0.024222835898399353, 0.0001286587939830497, -0.052681054919958115, 0.04117628559470177, 0.053914863616228104, 0.009576178155839443, -0.01694837585091591, -0.020544404163956642, 0.02580520696938038, 0.01393942255526781, -0.02594635635614395, 0.011070594191551208, -0.012821211479604244, 0.020696869120001793, 0.048809949308633804, 0.009520360268652439, -0.02635892666876316, -0.011966783553361893, 0.07132712751626968, 0.02222343720495701, -0.014091617427766323, 0.038512248545885086, -0.018894542008638382, -0.008208702318370342, -0.03150399029254913, 0.03069784678518772, 0.004717054311186075, 0.02318560890853405, 0.013349462300539017, 0.021153438836336136, 0.034656330943107605, 0.017464490607380867, -0.014760737307369709, 0.05506811663508415, -0.012201329693198204, 0.007346423342823982, -0.007925665937364101, 0.025816259905695915, 0.05311662331223488, -0.014949779026210308, 0.017666883766651154, 0.041889648884534836, -0.014003220945596695, -0.006132891401648521, -0.0009127368684858084, -0.021232273429632187, 0.015939485281705856, 0.06770338863134384, -0.04311290383338928, 0.004416927229613066, 0.006793535314500332, -0.01573753170669079, -0.002587378490716219, -0.017940839752554893, -0.049575623124837875, -0.028643129393458366, -0.004830991383641958, 0.07235181331634521, 0.03641244024038315, 0.03502007946372032, -0.00274843187071383, -0.05018944665789604, -0.013975010253489017, -0.004363200627267361, 0.018470192328095436, 0.007130760699510574, -0.06320617347955704, -0.00036597601138055325, -0.011355427093803883, 0.0004663256695494056, 0.018845073878765106, -0.008262500166893005, 0.0039461455307900906, 0.001227273722179234, -0.008634908124804497, -0.01743861474096775, -0.006985981948673725, -0.007290183566510677, 0.03202157840132713, -0.043334152549505234, -0.032026637345552444, 0.009460698813199997, -0.005169495940208435, -0.008763144724071026, 0.017211735248565674, -0.015283807180821896, -0.0029609196353703737, -0.023876674473285675, 0.007274467032402754, 0.019004328176379204, -0.007407383061945438, -0.004195644054561853, 0.010387461632490158, 0.022817488759756088, -0.012684181332588196, -0.008851364254951477, -0.05431091785430908, -0.015898581594228745, 0.02229434624314308, -0.009248957969248295, -0.023126661777496338, -0.03547779098153114, 0.08581424504518509, 0.01951856166124344, -0.038950756192207336, -0.004004611633718014, -0.010400916449725628, -0.09286907315254211, -0.019430195912718773, 0.013083530589938164, 0.014264235273003578, 0.014341960661113262, 0.013501697219908237, -0.008854213170707226, 0.026267625391483307, 0.04079616069793701, -0.025773005560040474, 0.009294124320149422, 0.015125465579330921, -0.02047167532145977, -0.017556466162204742, 0.027846505865454674, 0.036816373467445374, -0.048565588891506195, -0.014111554250121117, -0.004587338771671057, 0.01992870308458805, 0.03383496403694153, -0.01418160181492567, 0.0034208944998681545, -0.05768293887376785, 0.03071448765695095, -0.04837655648589134, 0.02704937942326069, 0.007005327381193638, 0.010528168641030788, -0.0047678351402282715, 0.024290993809700012, 0.05560098960995674, -0.03464538976550102, -0.01558130793273449, 0.022326132282614708, 0.034630127251148224, -0.008078476414084435, 0.004407759290188551, -0.017894938588142395, 0.023422183468937874, 0.04003068432211876, 0.0018698384519666433, -0.01008545234799385, 0.057312384247779846, 0.05517539009451866, 0.010608621872961521, 0.020247269421815872, -0.05592716857790947, 0.028043221682310104, -0.0755729153752327, 0.013549317605793476, -0.01653958112001419, 0.008983700536191463, -0.03416242450475693, 0.060745805501937866, 0.04511362314224243, -0.005779815372079611, -0.008233058266341686, -0.0029905622359365225, -0.05796470493078232, 0.021654944866895676, -0.035043615847826004, -0.012153679504990578, -0.014058598317205906, 0.0007093778112903237, 0.04449249804019928, 0.00782069843262434, 0.005868291482329369, 0.026047026738524437, 0.03087908960878849, -0.05287809297442436, 0.021165411919355392, -0.021505340933799744, 0.03272828459739685, -0.03327285125851631, 0.01911233738064766, 0.00944303348660469, -0.0022516686003655195, 0.06705838441848755, 0.01462400984019041, -0.03663410246372223, -0.029765907675027847, -0.007719985209405422, 0.0023819433990865946, 0.06315632164478302, 0.029856136068701744, 0.006547030061483383, 0.006207293830811977, -0.009545125998556614, 0.015569589100778103, 0.002297410974279046, 0.0698527917265892, 0.023733913898468018, 0.0030180804897099733, 0.008981981314718723, -0.026670953258872032, -0.03169343248009682, -0.04553021863102913, -0.003079094225540757, 0.016349222511053085, 0.007385989185422659, 0.025131018832325935, 0.004480130970478058, -0.07196507602930069, 0.005567736923694611, 0.052424777299165726, 0.024435944855213165, 0.027969587594270706, -0.0613076388835907, -0.038650911301374435, -0.02132592722773552, -0.009997332468628883, 0.001558756222948432, -0.006996925454586744, -0.004510596860200167, -0.0018364626448601484, 0.07105910032987595, -0.04456838220357895, -0.0602816678583622, -0.011665774509310722, -0.01473069004714489, 0.027121007442474365, -0.027405371889472008, 0.005266995169222355, 0.05488637089729309, 0.006348751951009035, 0.0367998443543911, 0.02945672906935215, -0.0026097004301846027, -0.07322649657726288, -0.00919042807072401, 0.019232356920838356, 0.024051599204540253, -0.011110463179647923, -0.026365328580141068, -0.04466855525970459, -0.008952170610427856, 0.02425975725054741, -0.025642743334174156, 0.01537319179624319, -0.00850972905755043, 0.025673238560557365, -0.06521183997392654, -0.008139404468238354, -0.05846763029694557, -0.041448283940553665, -0.030904021114110947, 0.023323507979512215, -0.023258574306964874, -0.06562057137489319, -0.03796442225575447, -0.0029154785443097353, -0.010743633843958378, 0.07087966054677963, -0.01067841611802578, -0.00011492940393509343, -0.009309308603405952, 0.026696866378188133, -0.02233876660466194, -0.06853475421667099, 0.026955097913742065, 0.0017001035157591105, 0.007076288107782602, 0.08593103289604187, -0.039071861654520035, -0.04726094752550125, 0.0016457285964861512, -0.0061645288951694965, -0.03243743255734444, -0.0028989207930862904, 0.01821741834282875, 0.010432073846459389, 0.02686302736401558, -0.016866102814674377, 0.05938027799129486, -0.012449423782527447, 0.017124690115451813, -0.03489898145198822, -0.04826702922582626, 0.030883420258760452, -0.0226124357432127, 0.011081359349191189, -0.05844193324446678, -0.012273521162569523, -0.04000217840075493, 0.008190006017684937, -0.02385575883090496, 0.03977685794234276, -0.0050966572016477585, -0.013331511989235878, 0.020528629422187805, 0.036388371139764786, 0.01805252954363823, -0.008115963079035282, -0.03583577647805214, 0.014383106492459774, 0.015758609399199486, 0.0007029283442534506, 0.026898805052042007, 0.001184342778287828, 0.028454983606934547, 0.023864852264523506, -0.010757199488580227, -0.0034310738556087017, -0.053885966539382935, -0.03426375240087509, 0.017817554995417595, -0.07008547335863113, 0.018594026565551758, -0.02100745588541031, 0.002653514500707388, 0.040762584656476974, -0.06082814931869507, -0.024309633299708366, 0.02060631290078163, 0.0022348547354340553, 0.07266386598348618, -0.04133276641368866, 0.03006679005920887, -0.0010636908700689673, 0.007284553721547127, -0.05837678909301758, -0.05230829492211342, 0.02651476487517357, 0.019256582483649254, -0.034237537533044815, -0.028322601690888405, -0.046385589987039566, 0.019326146692037582, -0.008991438895463943, 0.024205811321735382, -0.009077562019228935, -0.015386335551738739, -0.03447671979665756, 0.023607635870575905, -0.01056601107120514, 0.08887477219104767, -0.01734093762934208, -0.021701425313949585, 0.028882624581456184, -0.02856973186135292, -0.02854015864431858, 0.01888344995677471, 0.03266340494155884, -0.020772162824869156, 0.005418787710368633, -0.034468650817871094, 0.04507328197360039, 0.024963198229670525, -0.02519296295940876, 0.007193476893007755, 0.002250047866255045, 0.027636604383587837, 0.04265119507908821, -0.040796972811222076, -0.031615715473890305, -0.04489435255527496, 0.018031109124422073, 0.005554954521358013, 0.0022914200089871883, -0.0029973580967634916, -0.02187418006360531, 0.04440310224890709, 0.018207767978310585, 0.01647176407277584, 0.017582988366484642, 0.07951410114765167, -0.025904865935444832, 0.024111581966280937, -0.027120834216475487, -0.03983554616570473, -0.014908942393958569, 0.03156512603163719, 0.0036146119236946106, 0.04413342848420143, 0.014959408901631832, -0.054415397346019745, -0.017563821747899055, -0.046149447560310364, 0.0001596099609741941, 0.0601254478096962, -0.023643989115953445, 0.06148527190089226, 0.041218351572752, 0.003574961330741644, -0.004353505093604326, -0.0645863339304924, 0.013772336766123772, -0.029340291395783424, -0.022378621622920036, 0.03021707944571972, -0.01823548413813114, -0.004147498868405819, 0.03947470709681511, 0.037557829171419144, 0.040821950882673264, 0.04928111657500267, 0.0361001193523407, 0.034708451479673386, 0.01646878384053707, 0.017583636566996574, -0.03683530539274216, 0.020506251603364944, -0.0077039883472025394, -0.003032619832083583, -0.03270704671740532, -0.0009203759836964309, 0.03312743827700615, 0.0169916283339262, 0.0042509096674621105, -0.018709948286414146, -0.016160527244210243, -0.05787927657365799, -0.00019593510660342872, 0.0070614200085401535, -0.004526499193161726, 0.01380214560776949, -0.017921270802617073, 0.029415739700198174, 0.026375913992524147, 0.03649416193366051, -0.022623442113399506, -0.05916804075241089, -0.08841045200824738, 0.0013705008896067739, -0.0326034352183342, 0.0278482586145401, -0.030749130994081497, -0.038789574056863785, 0.05166662484407425, -0.026987668126821518, 0.004454770125448704, 0.0016374136321246624, 0.0341254398226738, -0.013393907807767391, 0.073042131960392, 0.018001174554228783, 0.035332635045051575, -0.018012207001447678, -0.015139228664338589, 0.09858358651399612, 0.055147018283605576, -0.004780371207743883, -0.06904242187738419, 0.026761546730995178, 0.00015677075134590268, 0.026592906564474106, -0.038520585745573044, 0.022598592564463615, 0.011599322780966759, 0.007867223583161831, 0.0703655555844307, 0.028283119201660156, -0.005226156674325466, -0.008300038985908031, 0.04384808987379074, 0.007290682755410671, -0.05299631133675575, -0.001599684590473771, 0.0213190745562315, -0.030933521687984467, -0.011422748677432537, -0.0789957344532013, 0.04454968124628067, 0.002037626225501299, -0.00045623473124578595, -0.016265884041786194, -0.03860366344451904, 0.0039726016111671925, -0.0010091012809425592, -0.012814311310648918, 0.013651974499225616, 0.04803884029388428, 0.01592973619699478, -0.04187450185418129, -0.01277916505932808, 0.025413841009140015, -0.001044289325363934, -0.017911959439516068, 0.012873614206910133, -0.01773885264992714, -0.0010127908317372203, -0.014383766800165176, 0.02157074399292469, -0.0334133580327034, -0.060043815523386, 0.0014128473121672869, 0.050333116203546524, -0.015718458220362663, 0.029818125069141388, -0.048077188432216644, -0.005666187033057213, -0.007092804182320833, -0.051968950778245926, 0.013616686686873436, -0.003630410647019744, 0.005063362419605255, 0.000943488092161715, -0.005849227774888277, -0.0341583713889122, -0.03313439339399338, -0.02213870733976364, 0.02583467587828636, 0.010657785460352898, 0.02611325867474079, 0.017765657976269722, -0.03978653997182846, 0.06649893522262573, -0.01669008657336235, 0.005030965432524681, 0.018502945080399513, 0.026327334344387054, -0.02497255429625511, -0.007754453923553228, 0.026033328846096992, -0.0016681808046996593, 0.01575065590441227, 0.021413002163171768, -0.020822420716285706, 0.010179808363318443, -0.031130069866776466, 0.008225561119616032, -0.04823506996035576, -0.022411542013287544, -0.006691939663141966, 0.01728258840739727, 0.036997124552726746, 0.029659245163202286, 0.019145334139466286, 0.016534483060240746, -0.0022853172849863768, 0.04040716961026192, -0.024565890431404114, -0.052423104643821716, -0.013144416734576225, 0.02269151248037815, -0.014915328472852707, -0.03758769482374191, 0.00031473342096433043, 0.07039112597703934, 0.06795474141836166, -0.00706180464476347, 0.0201430581510067, 0.0090935742482543, -0.0008548656478524208, -0.015527592040598392, 0.022140873596072197, -0.056068576872348785, 0.007914483547210693, -0.02114766277372837, -0.02866700291633606, -0.061593517661094666, 0.00539952190592885, -0.007662761956453323, -0.04498044028878212, -0.007877167314291, 0.030403200536966324, -0.009098352864384651, 0.00808108039200306, 0.013335105031728745, -0.027865994721651077, -0.01905948482453823, -0.00985743012279272, -0.030416099354624748, 0.01464618369936943, 0.02072795107960701, -0.010906971991062164, -0.002310836222022772, 0.002865477930754423, -0.023908553645014763, 0.026421913877129555, 0.03903794288635254, 0.008315673097968102, 0.06195179000496864, -0.0019581227097660303, 0.028381261974573135, -0.003589013824239373, 0.03520754352211952, -0.044960107654333115, -0.013395825400948524, 0.06940512359142303, -0.04945899173617363, -0.056884147226810455, 0.01088105607777834, 0.008517507463693619, 0.03781707584857941, 0.007029978092759848, -0.01306481659412384, -0.05042218789458275, 0.022391734644770622, -0.03829743340611458, -0.04100492224097252, -0.016251809895038605, -0.005778803024441004, 0.008490100502967834, -0.002924870466813445, 0.005922302138060331, -0.0088646886870265, 0.008772344328463078, 0.03332923352718353, 0.05419646576046944, 0.006495968904346228, -0.01691145822405815, 0.01779681071639061, -0.014326539821922779, 0.03235464543104172, 0.009940986521542072, 0.010675628669559956, 0.04767245426774025, 0.03818168863654137, -0.022858113050460815, 0.02749668061733246, -0.024905266240239143, 0.0011128840269520879, -0.07887697219848633, -0.026460886001586914, -0.02594783529639244, 0.025265546515583992, 0.029360178858041763, -0.06631987541913986, 0.006897175684571266, 0.04981542378664017, -0.030643651261925697, 0.03463578596711159, -0.006778887007385492, -0.009226915426552296, -0.049362871795892715, 0.005101574119180441, -0.00848822109401226, 0.0586404912173748, 0.03044772520661354, 0.009106039069592953, 0.0463918074965477, 0.02759244665503502, -0.030715620145201683, -0.023465394973754883, 0.0009611082496121526, 0.05106770619750023, -0.01041983813047409, -0.047829531133174896, 0.03921223431825638, 0.010440179146826267, -0.0250660739839077, 0.016232287511229515, -0.014364899136126041, 0.018020233139395714, 0.05585024878382683, -0.004959007725119591, 0.0030221622437238693, 0.007416051812469959, 0.015316481702029705, 0.005430566146969795, -0.051472947001457214, -0.012004612013697624, 0.04399149864912033, 0.01989787630736828, 0.012924613431096077, 0.02146725356578827, 0.018837830051779747, -0.024191197007894516, -0.023957420140504837, 0.03478771820664406, -0.021091317757964134, 0.0018536831485107541, -0.004762913100421429, -0.01330896932631731, -0.015068914741277695, -0.050513096153736115, 0.05270453542470932, -0.01318000815808773, -0.011331873945891857, 0.03028387390077114, 0.0011426862329244614, -0.016028234735131264, 0.008432597853243351, 0.0010735287796705961, -0.06030081585049629, 0.03365586698055267, 0.0055299741216003895, -0.01353348046541214, -0.05814935639500618, 0.00928151048719883, -0.009822262451052666, -0.010713871568441391, 0.01838899962604046, -0.0197133906185627, -0.032371070235967636, 0.03608952462673187, 0.013759585097432137, -0.03789949044585228, 0.013050254434347153, -0.03284243866801262, -0.015257645398378372, -0.09454098343849182, 0.07485704869031906, -0.03627075254917145, -0.07123009860515594, -0.0496397390961647, -0.0012060323497280478, -0.01915145479142666, 0.04609208181500435, -0.00717280013486743, 0.035754214972257614, 0.02280449867248535, -0.0015132299158722162, 0.018607473000884056, 0.008410974405705929, -0.04359225556254387, 0.035742033272981644, -0.01182419341057539, -0.009102340787649155, -0.03408268839120865, -0.015423335134983063, 0.01174609549343586, 0.03910161182284355, 0.018871238455176353, 0.009438084438443184, 0.05232924595475197, 0.009620958007872105, -0.017421120777726173, 0.010232413187623024, 0.010757923126220703, -0.0058746179565787315, 0.06990513205528259, 0.013427598401904106, -0.020426051691174507, 0.021624889224767685, -0.031131688505411148, -0.032974593341350555, 0.02724192850291729, -0.014258108101785183, -0.010940107516944408, -0.012019958347082138, 0.0029793858993798494, 0.0013913331786170602, -0.05854468792676926, 0.012384031899273396, 0.003979733679443598, -0.04822823405265808, -0.001188378781080246, 0.034023918211460114, 0.045194920152425766, 0.03302440792322159, -0.003959030378609896, 0.026433957740664482, 0.0017459184164181352, -0.04124554991722107, -0.0025650940369814634, 0.004256557673215866, 0.05395255610346794, 0.02288818545639515, 0.006798105780035257, 0.022246653214097023, -0.006115993019193411, 0.013626312837004662, -0.019449446350336075, 0.031921178102493286, -0.042379338294267654, -0.002986558247357607, 0.012487079948186874, -0.02122488245368004, 0.05678754672408104, -0.004125005565583706, -0.012908309698104858, 0.05354620888829231, -0.02769055962562561, 0.014070720411837101, 0.004745868965983391, -0.022434284910559654, 0.007552247494459152, -0.03994385153055191, 0.019373470917344093, -0.0036390770692378283, 0.021412735804915428, 0.0020972404163330793, -0.03670598194003105, 0.013286932371556759, 0.021376052871346474, -0.0018453628290444613, 0.04690038040280342, -0.016540387645363808, 0.023937365040183067, -0.019118526950478554, -0.03129175305366516, -0.03081033192574978, -0.001264905440621078, 0.0015248251147568226, 0.014154362492263317, 0.011265137232840061, 0.01622706465423107, -0.04272957891225815, 0.027572136372327805, 0.04666890576481819, -0.05332126468420029, 0.0008534694206900895, -0.04119515419006348, 0.03915010392665863, 0.04036817327141762, 0.0023408501874655485 ]
<p>I am building a scoring model for rating an individual on trustworthiness. The parameters of the model are not fixed and I have no historical data to test. So to test the validity of the parameters and their weightings, I have built random samples using Monte Carlo simulation. I have now came across the term predictive modeling (logistic regression, etc). So here, does Monte Carlo or any other technique work?<br> Could anyone clarify when to use simulation and when to use predictive modeling?</p>
73,421
[ -0.028725508600473404, -0.0532563216984272, -0.027447910979390144, -0.03620079532265663, 0.03588219732046127, -0.011193441227078438, -0.0040666754357516766, 0.0021430838387459517, 0.05266059190034866, -0.002259130124002695, 0.02821061760187149, 0.047751717269420624, 0.030328745022416115, 0.011246698908507824, 0.014725491404533386, 0.02320566587150097, 0.002272149547934532, 0.01069492008537054, -0.015220137313008308, 0.021411767229437828, -0.012468134053051472, 0.011411924846470356, 0.019365306943655014, -0.037785790860652924, -0.013043755665421486, 0.04158071428537369, 0.030735643580555916, -0.05622675642371178, -0.011885936371982098, 0.033131424337625504, -0.03885801136493683, 0.005058908369392157, 0.04504043236374855, 0.06912501156330109, 0.028678687289357185, -0.012222418561577797, -0.05640297383069992, -0.049249906092882156, -0.019364595413208008, 0.02017074078321457, -0.017652170732617378, -0.02601541019976139, 0.02144816145300865, 0.01273325178772211, 0.0005591233493760228, 0.00348150753416121, -0.02671273984014988, -0.07072319090366364, 0.014889427460730076, -0.02325981855392456, 0.03065376915037632, -0.028576426208019257, 0.028571734204888344, 0.04296749085187912, 0.015172758139669895, -0.03240412473678589, 0.05935479328036308, 0.07845691591501236, -0.014045185409486294, -0.04773364216089249, -0.021529296413064003, -0.010593612678349018, -0.015667753294110298, -0.019063198938965797, -0.012636890634894371, 0.02216743864119053, -0.0019808057695627213, -0.04242461547255516, 0.05720408260822296, -0.00984236691147089, -0.004440199583768845, 0.0372425802052021, 0.03732616826891899, 0.012511404231190681, 0.04434721916913986, 0.008016523905098438, -0.0110929599031806, -0.0049555180594325066, 0.03147244080901146, 0.021008605137467384, -0.004643857479095459, 0.02703847736120224, 0.009382857009768486, 0.0467449352145195, -0.00817782524973154, -0.037716928869485855, 0.026348434388637543, -0.0227819811552763, -0.00409344956278801, 0.008168584667146206, -0.05359816178679466, 0.03523942828178406, 0.010549436323344707, -0.01785074546933174, -0.02756369672715664, 0.013013560324907303, -0.032931145280599594, 0.06349370628595352, 0.02175917662680149, 0.0007689319318160415, -0.012119424529373646, -0.02475089579820633, 0.0016344623873010278, 0.03544586896896362, -0.045846156775951385, -0.01604866050183773, 0.011827437207102776, -0.025696950033307076, 0.007341541349887848, -0.03935358300805092, -0.04207998514175415, 0.014903209172189236, 0.022922636941075325, 0.012654113583266735, 0.06449730694293976, 0.000159859933773987, -0.014858360402286053, -0.03422937169671059, 0.04857610538601875, 0.011130694299936295, 0.013219686225056648, -0.036737725138664246, 0.03186593949794769, -0.034598030149936676, -0.06949972361326218, -0.01913115382194519, 0.0076142847537994385, 0.008770454674959183, -0.050664663314819336, 0.0437859408557415, -0.006898249499499798, -0.04856184497475624, 0.01742800511419773, 0.01824478805065155, 0.007299558725208044, 0.022526049986481667, -0.09251676499843597, -0.03700732812285423, 0.023141609504818916, -0.025180760771036148, 0.06260418146848679, -0.053429704159498215, -0.004660501144826412, 0.011834622360765934, 0.03261667490005493, 0.027689827606081963, 0.03816724196076393, 0.0035959333181381226, 0.02716277353465557, -0.007013658527284861, -0.028807485476136208, -0.013230630196630955, -0.020307909697294235, -0.00598165625706315, -0.030276073142886162, -0.1031184047460556, -0.010428888723254204, 0.04903913289308548, -0.019357701763510704, -0.062027331441640854, -0.005503907334059477, -0.018730660900473595, -0.010416761040687561, -0.018220916390419006, -0.0074628000147640705, -0.032670050859451294, 0.0369686484336853, 0.010444069281220436, 0.033908091485500336, 0.01682615838944912, -0.0010716456454247236, 0.01880669966340065, 0.02505153976380825, 0.04879585653543472, 0.05114596709609032, 0.014827952720224857, 0.020944122225046158, -0.016480684280395508, 0.03313649818301201, -0.027232559397816658, -0.04336658492684364, 0.003720770822837949, 0.0026318032760173082, -0.011594776064157486, -0.013933602720499039, 0.019089382141828537, 0.02735234424471855, -0.01227997150272131, 0.036416225135326385, -0.044437628239393234, -0.0457661971449852, -0.0636315792798996, 0.02089380845427513, -0.015158524736762047, -0.010736312717199326, 0.023067567497491837, -0.0077934530563652515, 0.01841452531516552, -0.025794832035899162, -0.01134243980050087, -0.0434725396335125, -0.0016234932700172067, 0.03848504647612572, -0.059633709490299225, 0.03861422464251518, 0.06070433557033539, 0.013370297849178314, -0.012868156656622887, 0.06450577825307846, -0.06291660666465759, -0.08572665601968765, -0.010630331933498383, -0.05114496126770973, 0.025919076055288315, -0.02209741435945034, -0.04574313759803772, 0.0245413426309824, -0.021212009713053703, -0.027664264664053917, 0.01998775452375412, -0.03402521833777428, 0.07596307247877121, 0.0428193062543869, -0.0009927965002134442, -0.010903329588472843, 0.006974590942263603, -0.009142695926129818, 0.02698730304837227, -0.01600845344364643, -0.042525991797447205, -0.053636334836483, -0.02818252518773079, 0.03697212040424347, -0.011432903818786144, -0.044402386993169785, 0.02505078911781311, 0.041844986379146576, 0.021065732464194298, 0.04656713828444481, 0.018421778455376625, 0.0030552216339856386, -0.014765365980565548, 0.028238195925951004, 0.03260267525911331, 0.005801534280180931, 0.03218260779976845, 0.011262902989983559, 0.029730375856161118, 0.04569925367832184, -0.005896964576095343, 0.011162732727825642, 0.05070848390460014, 0.013718342408537865, -0.00765271345153451, -0.017874911427497864, -0.04401688650250435, 0.03507060930132866, -0.02093595266342163, 0.012491879053413868, 0.0022038195747882128, 0.027631372213363647, -0.015982717275619507, -0.005750307347625494, -0.02205619402229786, 0.024577546864748, 0.08994864672422409, 0.00601084902882576, 0.01803312450647354, 0.025688324123620987, -0.02348100021481514, 0.02125888504087925, 0.0052925655618309975, -0.02949870005249977, -0.024720489978790283, 0.009607083164155483, 0.023980284109711647, -0.007160469889640808, 0.05150375887751579, -0.009662418626248837, -0.06211862340569496, -0.0017238111468032002, -0.016320230439305305, -0.004414028488099575, 0.022230887785553932, -0.07578248530626297, -0.03136950731277466, -0.009196355007588863, -0.033452752977609634, 0.04674515128135681, 0.0008461764664389193, -0.018106812611222267, 0.023938361555337906, -0.029057107865810394, -0.0525943748652935, -0.03216994181275368, 0.010825558565557003, -0.006032339762896299, -0.008725574240088463, -0.030685437843203545, 0.0413052923977375, 0.020845483988523483, -0.008474152535200119, 0.02070160210132599, -0.043879300355911255, -0.01985146291553974, -0.021781597286462784, -0.0013443842763081193, 0.024090193212032318, -0.010147174820303917, 0.0373239740729332, 0.03228064253926277, -0.024325238540768623, 0.013517847284674644, -0.04294830560684204, -0.03721454367041588, 0.04261386767029762, -0.048445578664541245, 0.026917777955532074, -0.002842406276613474, -0.0016439198516309261, 0.0967564582824707, 0.010495389811694622, -0.01699075847864151, -0.006240677088499069, -0.006628846749663353, -0.0431685633957386, -0.004704899154603481, 0.005789066199213266, 0.026092227548360825, -0.008069822564721107, 0.03466822952032089, -0.021737784147262573, -0.008077547885477543, 0.034425392746925354, 0.003970175515860319, 0.0234918724745512, -0.009433209896087646, -0.00010105683031724766, -0.026750897988677025, 0.02175999991595745, -0.012425800785422325, -0.05858162045478821, 0.0019964587409049273, -0.012615839019417763, 0.03929385170340538, 0.02314063347876072, -0.0347602516412735, 0.012630105949938297, -0.014698495157063007, 0.014854933135211468, -0.02055427059531212, 0.011130535043776035, -0.00022604758851230145, -0.06195560470223427, -0.0007889564149081707, 0.015534856356680393, 0.003722147084772587, -0.006615304853767157, 0.011253880336880684, 0.03111150674521923, 0.05462305620312691, -0.006469296291470528, 0.003019554540514946, -0.0042250207625329494, -0.02457466721534729, 0.018558386713266373, -0.016348624601960182, -0.004600719548761845, 0.06592819839715958, 0.01924828812479973, 0.0332995168864727, -0.0067060282453894615, -0.023471856489777565, -0.014072554185986519, -0.043660447001457214, 0.04375435784459114, -0.04231870546936989, 0.08775448799133301, 0.008842012844979763, 0.02823209948837757, 0.023302463814616203, -0.012343577109277248, 0.029931915923953056, 0.017018398270010948, -0.04039958864450455, 0.04626308009028435, -0.014858802780508995, -0.0016783926403149962, 0.004056841600686312, -0.022063497453927994, 0.04031163826584816, -0.025991132482886314, -0.007489912677556276, 0.011594696901738644, 0.020146306604146957, -0.006219017785042524, 0.00411558710038662, -0.07132261246442795, -0.04854738339781761, -0.013506549410521984, -0.0009521289030089974, -0.0206976979970932, -0.02384205535054207, 0.04087464511394501, 0.05761316046118736, 0.004735319409519434, -0.019551942124962807, -0.026956312358379364, 0.00369626865722239, 0.03056250512599945, 0.04033249616622925, 0.048394825309515, 0.04512839391827583, -0.058844830840826035, 0.054926272481679916, 0.0075830561108887196, 0.06525888293981552, 0.03354089334607124, -0.03359254077076912, -0.014694060198962688, -0.04677797108888626, -0.02653505653142929, 0.0033677469473332167, -0.01952139474451542, -0.005973875988274813, -0.008825999684631824, 0.029033439233899117, -0.007467956747859716, -0.038916535675525665, -0.0026922733522951603, 0.07455722242593765, 0.022413665428757668, -0.005811676383018494, -0.009963112883269787, -0.0005359507631510496, 0.01903311163187027, -0.024122709408402443, 0.028955480083823204, 0.029825882986187935, -0.035578250885009766, 0.025479713454842567, 0.017411425709724426, -0.04040869325399399, -0.015239463187754154, -0.01097605749964714, 0.049589674919843674, 0.04547645151615143, 0.031912874430418015, -0.061623383313417435, 0.033425986766815186, 0.020018573850393295, 0.02395486645400524, 0.03395754471421242, 0.02313467487692833, -0.09104233980178833, 0.01613614335656166, 0.05481601133942604, 0.011926461942493916, -0.060067422688007355, -0.0184057354927063, -0.02446325682103634, 0.014575008302927017, 0.032079972326755524, -0.01900847814977169, -0.0009018971468321979, -0.005202482454478741, 0.02914634719491005, -0.037001971155405045, 0.017303461208939552, -0.0587431900203228, 0.004471259657293558, -0.031755369156599045, 0.030997784808278084, -0.02982664853334427, -0.040595706552267075, -0.0479465015232563, 0.024955447763204575, 0.024150965735316277, 0.08206317573785782, -0.021749598905444145, 0.004302334040403366, 0.01081525906920433, 0.0043976930901408195, 0.017013555392622948, -0.05080970376729965, -0.011256208643317223, 0.00837709940969944, -0.04598463326692581, 0.03679736331105232, 0.00010806861246237531, -0.06340941786766052, 0.019325261935591698, -0.007064351812005043, 0.00019666303705889732, -0.015531159937381744, -0.012201374396681786, 0.007053063716739416, -0.011245762929320335, -0.020657401531934738, 0.036696530878543854, 0.042451534420251846, 0.0002388780121691525, 0.002847386756911874, -0.015001348219811916, 0.03748226538300514, -0.007869605906307697, 0.016831129789352417, -0.012000797316432, -0.009186719544231892, -0.015665819868445396, 0.009803935885429382, 0.031054262071847916, 0.03489059954881668, -0.03317893296480179, -0.0315803587436676, 0.0010837269946932793, 0.02250974252820015, 0.0043111639097332954, -0.0043030669912695885, -0.010974187403917313, 0.00021407465101219714, 0.0029388575349003077, -0.02447042614221573, -0.027548372745513916, 0.0008310135453939438, 0.026462111622095108, 0.01051849965006113, -0.050388939678668976, -0.014029406942427158, -0.04492681846022606, -0.023947041481733322, 0.06203221529722214, -0.00906496774405241, 0.043265074491500854, 0.021731821820139885, 0.041157349944114685, -0.0034341742284595966, -0.07505067437887192, -0.02086765319108963, -0.013836579397320747, 0.012478278018534184, 0.06280513107776642, -0.01381966844201088, 0.00011483243724796921, -0.028849657624959946, -0.014034428633749485, -0.0461224764585495, -0.03637209162116051, 0.019752878695726395, -0.0065774861723184586, -0.017686141654849052, -0.027458885684609413, 0.03547149896621704, -0.02323799394071102, -0.04057272523641586, -0.01777667924761772, 0.055855244398117065, 0.006859834771603346, -0.038719866424798965, 0.00454971008002758, -0.010792880319058895, 0.07541469484567642, 0.02595917135477066, -0.016555016860365868, 0.004356218967586756, -0.039011772722005844, -0.018932083621621132, -0.000821666035335511, 0.030739033594727516, -0.04579870030283928, -0.004649403505027294, -0.021991072222590446, -0.007841859944164753, 0.07259155809879303, 0.00016859875177033246, 0.006919648498296738, 0.023960258811712265, 0.033395152539014816, 0.012229685671627522, -0.02904166281223297, 0.010886861942708492, -0.01030945498496294, 0.00870951171964407, -0.014084720984101295, 0.034171752631664276, 0.01317910198122263, 0.01313761156052351, 0.043924275785684586, -0.001475826371461153, 0.023318087682127953, 0.04003444314002991, 0.033596985042095184, -0.01606353186070919, 0.005659186746925116, -0.03500298038125038, -0.03757999837398529, 0.03494163602590561, 0.008601047098636627, 0.005784166511148214, 0.02890392206609249, 0.02939884178340435, -0.017026962712407112, -0.0446239709854126, -0.04104311391711235, -0.024763789027929306, 0.0673174187541008, -0.017288262024521828, 0.0452260822057724, 0.051692698150873184, -0.0006944831693544984, -0.0026095733046531677, -0.03530170023441315, -0.015010944567620754, 0.006479746196419001, -0.00881813932210207, 0.0377328097820282, -0.03887251392006874, 0.01460484229028225, 0.013777446001768112, -0.0330045111477375, 0.034213483333587646, 0.03903038054704666, 0.027700655162334442, 0.04046875983476639, 0.007409416604787111, -0.039658453315496445, -0.00200373656116426, 0.04038554057478905, -0.05637313053011894, 0.0017045321874320507, -0.034761942923069, 0.03778316080570221, 0.03562546521425247, 0.0395025871694088, -0.022461002692580223, -0.05708820000290871, 0.0016141746891662478, -0.050333172082901, -0.0239720456302166, 0.011635085567831993, 0.00917152501642704, 0.021757738664746284, 0.018288908526301384, 0.009143101051449776, 0.0017171265790238976, 0.03408683463931084, -0.013747913762927055, -0.09827009588479996, -0.03126075491309166, 0.017097728326916695, -0.025740057229995728, 0.014937076717615128, 0.04918850213289261, -0.016157707199454308, -0.012919646687805653, -0.03666616976261139, 0.02900625579059124, 0.012471004389226437, 0.02901470847427845, -0.056316815316677094, 0.09202516078948975, -0.014903592877089977, 0.018030427396297455, 0.012195650488138199, 0.018800515681505203, 0.11254287511110306, 0.058894265443086624, 0.034454356878995895, -0.03311486914753914, 0.03821375593543053, -0.004157433286309242, 0.003162102308124304, 0.0011330109555274248, -0.00751134566962719, 0.019119910895824432, 0.010659988969564438, 0.018386002629995346, 0.005706990137696266, -0.008751291781663895, 0.006930386647582054, 0.058801714330911636, -0.04273202270269394, -0.03689379245042801, -0.010859662666916847, -0.021522728726267815, 0.0012688887072727084, -0.005779390688985586, -0.00882020778954029, 0.02941814251244068, -0.0009780512191355228, -0.02379416860640049, -0.0027021458372473717, 0.0022615829948335886, 0.003549380926415324, 0.025918293744325638, -0.008342333137989044, -0.0039634788408875465, 0.026436295360326767, 0.023633314296603203, 0.00003739197563845664, -0.023312930017709732, 0.023579994216561317, -0.018029380589723587, 0.022107280790805817, 0.03363434597849846, -0.02155064046382904, -0.008228140883147717, -0.02504655532538891, 0.0054685682989656925, -0.06276660412549973, -0.04519328102469444, -0.0514434315264225, 0.015289530158042908, -0.01791374199092388, -0.03065781109035015, -0.0025049273390322924, -0.019696203991770744, -0.007450745906680822, -0.02347377873957157, -0.016381269320845604, 0.033317744731903076, 0.025793729349970818, -0.05057032033801079, -0.04519123584032059, -0.043226368725299835, 0.0561220683157444, -0.01743054948747158, 0.04878527671098709, 0.03424614667892456, -0.02385064773261547, 0.01260725874453783, -0.045409195125103, 0.031715698540210724, -0.011954213492572308, 0.00478343153372407, 0.02492627687752247, -0.011021427810192108, -0.047563549131155014, -0.00304992264136672, -0.011260231956839561, 0.009270157665014267, 0.02019909955561161, -0.03858933225274086, 0.01547497883439064, -0.030341241508722305, -0.04395598545670509, 0.00850041676312685, -0.046395543962717056, -0.017042914405465126, -0.05069570615887642, 0.00810542143881321, 0.030312884598970413, 0.03789006173610687, 0.02075868472456932, -0.0026636167895048857, -0.01049692090600729, -0.02297690324485302, 0.012011843733489513, -0.08010274916887283, -0.007345756981521845, 0.016221407800912857, -0.07745636254549026, 0.0046173990704119205, -0.014029582031071186, 0.06100859120488167, 0.014237753115594387, 0.023447925224900246, -0.018230745568871498, 0.016369309276342392, 0.010109635069966316, 0.030015496537089348, 0.028435688465833664, -0.02820773422718048, -0.022653665393590927, -0.009597355499863625, 0.0197294931858778, -0.011789086274802685, -0.0030880498234182596, -0.022732634097337723, -0.01968502439558506, 0.026786455884575844, -0.028169013559818268, -0.007213623728603125, 0.024710578843951225, 0.000296687037916854, 0.037615712732076645, -0.03420714661478996, 0.014839889481663704, -0.014918644912540913, 0.0007058542687445879, 0.005316421389579773, -0.008218030445277691, -0.03233020752668381, 0.022781580686569214, -0.025684267282485962, -0.012191936373710632, 0.04163435846567154, 0.010445770807564259, 0.009382686577737331, -0.016240568831562996, 0.03675401210784912, 0.003130835248157382, 0.028984440490603447, -0.042234987020492554, 0.011001464910805225, 0.022797081619501114, -0.031537700444459915, -0.023980051279067993, 0.021539729088544846, -0.008440302684903145, 0.02975371666252613, -0.005486194510012865, 0.02025407925248146, 0.008930660784244537, 0.01754993572831154, -0.047032248228788376, -0.025267716497182846, -0.00902294460684061, -0.0007989064906723797, -0.00034855701960623264, 0.010194816626608372, 0.007953413762152195, 0.016932234168052673, -0.001000111922621727, 0.01365727186203003, 0.04145124554634094, 0.027007384225726128, 0.004220633301883936, 0.014203445985913277, 0.0217281486839056, 0.01168453972786665, 0.027630265802145004, -0.0032525898423045874, -0.01373213343322277, 0.06876831501722336, 0.017447179183363914, 0.061178311705589294, -0.0066902050748467445, -0.022303104400634766, -0.07483925670385361, -0.04067908972501755, 0.030200786888599396, -0.012399761937558651, 0.04138566926121712, -0.04098738729953766, -0.03681434690952301, 0.02666056714951992, -0.025017956271767616, 0.012706765905022621, 0.022322943434119225, -0.02159036509692669, -0.028916647657752037, -0.015542061068117619, -0.015442791394889355, 0.03536411002278328, 0.03237393498420715, 0.0188019797205925, -0.008632775396108627, 0.013401572592556477, 0.012654881924390793, -0.0009554619318805635, 0.0018001041607931256, 0.029558129608631134, -0.004546180367469788, -0.039346855133771896, 0.022085048258304596, -0.047034963965415955, -0.027973104268312454, 0.03578442707657814, 0.04045672342181206, 0.0403633788228035, 0.02404101751744747, 0.010582257062196732, -0.004000447690486908, 0.04463285207748413, 0.055006321519613266, -0.01384181622415781, 0.006580085027962923, 0.028589501976966858, 0.03869660571217537, 0.036277540028095245, -0.014520718716084957, -0.0018505899934098125, -0.02475178800523281, -0.034606389701366425, -0.02503574639558792, 0.03705152869224548, 0.01585938036441803, -0.04081648960709572, -0.01366698369383812, -0.006493974477052689, -0.01585402712225914, -0.02436010167002678, -0.0023062224499881268, -0.023660937324166298, 0.007120578549802303, 0.06518599390983582, 0.03295106440782547, 0.009651807136833668, 0.02010972425341606, -0.02295289747416973, -0.023395255208015442, 0.03214272856712341, -0.0072051119059324265, -0.016012147068977356, -0.03170180320739746, -0.014963407069444656, 0.023562340065836906, -0.014202142134308815, -0.049448881298303604, 0.019281510263681412, -0.03725166618824005, 0.033667951822280884, -0.027544768527150154, 0.02065061591565609, 0.08097270876169205, -0.035309791564941406, 0.0044145118445158005, -0.06995479762554169, 0.12894122302532196, -0.015172857791185379, -0.03297233581542969, -0.03375821188092232, 0.00429869070649147, -0.01606053113937378, -0.011206496506929398, 0.05002298206090927, 0.009651687927544117, 0.021637851372361183, -0.009355347603559494, 0.0025869267992675304, -0.017363345250487328, -0.04682598635554314, 0.013201175257563591, -0.006641370709985495, -0.00017573269724380225, -0.029221637174487114, 0.013733671978116035, -0.004367480985820293, 0.032077815383672714, 0.02241929993033409, -0.03472830727696419, 0.02114276960492134, 0.02319682575762272, -0.003934741020202637, 0.031086398288607597, 0.012658372521400452, 0.02213115058839321, 0.054690778255462646, -0.007934074848890305, 0.002805240685120225, -0.0024940413422882557, -0.016292870044708252, -0.053557444363832474, 0.031136715784668922, -0.04781540855765343, -0.00869644433259964, 0.0016209526220336556, -0.014672288671135902, -0.030097147449851036, -0.03133310750126839, 0.0017236255807802081, 0.05829595401883125, -0.0026622472796589136, 0.0454682931303978, 0.023278217762708664, 0.02169673517346382, 0.01730821095407009, -0.005342955235391855, -0.004581485874950886, 0.020724641159176826, -0.029030708596110344, -0.03702313080430031, 0.011031273752450943, 0.061652034521102905, -0.017757011577486992, 0.02156267687678337, 0.04553399235010147, -0.004796316381543875, 0.023823769763112068, -0.009946534410119057, 0.060748253017663956, -0.02553490735590458, -0.0019836043938994408, 0.011781970970332623, 0.022362438961863518, 0.03600640594959259, -0.009031976573169231, -0.013677301816642284, 0.07530512660741806, -0.057648587971925735, -0.01640147715806961, -0.06257621943950653, -0.011989722959697247, -0.028900163248181343, -0.02170914225280285, 0.0016896103043109179, 0.027040770277380943, 0.035581354051828384, -0.006683762185275555, -0.009628957137465477, 0.018612006679177284, 0.017924195155501366, -0.01426587626338005, 0.026026709005236626, -0.014652276411652565, 0.01944616623222828, -0.04959946498274803, -0.036461152136325836, 0.00002008461524383165, -0.024540554732084274, 0.022571442648768425, 0.017034735530614853, 0.02205502800643444, 0.0042433892376720905, -0.02725619077682495, -0.009093979373574257, 0.0679171159863472, -0.05556919425725937, 0.01700824685394764, -0.05687437579035759, 0.0019026125082746148, -0.002875466365367174, -0.017431480810046196 ]
<p>I was studying Deep Belief Network (DBN) and have questions. </p> <p>1) According to the definition of DBN, DBN is formed by stacking RBM on top of each other such that the hidden layer in a lower layer becomes the input layer in the above layer. However, when I read the papers by Geoff Hinton (for example, "a fast learning algorithm for deep belief nets"), his DBN doesn't seem to have multiple RBMs. His DBN has only one RBM (i.e., undirected Markov Random Field with two layers) which sits on top while the other layers have only directional edges. I am confused by this difference. </p> <p>Are these two architectures essentially same? When the term, "DBN" is used in literatures, does it refer to Geoff Hinton's DBN? Or does it refer to a general class of multi-layer architectures with one or multiple RBMs.</p> <p>2) Following up the above question, does anybody know why Geoff Hinton's DBN has undirected RBM (called associative memory) on top? What role does it play? What would happen if, instead of undirected edges, directed edges are used on top?</p> <p>Thanks,</p>
451
[ -0.04164332151412964, 0.0015141346957534552, 0.004009754862636328, -0.011967157013714314, 0.024993324652314186, -0.002686877502128482, 0.011782263405621052, -0.016461187973618507, 0.04544255882501602, -0.043716639280319214, 0.01443474180996418, 0.033881090581417084, 0.027345040813088417, 0.017339568585157394, 0.01601037196815014, 0.015306402929127216, 0.02118939347565174, -0.014023764058947563, 0.020747408270835876, -0.023295292630791664, 0.005785967223346233, 0.031426988542079926, 0.010174284689128399, 0.007198254577815533, 0.009285947307944298, 0.037216704338788986, 0.013976570218801498, -0.0024075163528323174, 0.015461409464478493, 0.0563647598028183, -0.015875516459345818, -0.005350049119442701, -0.023498352617025375, 0.014245916157960892, 0.03552718088030815, -0.026807360351085663, -0.006269456353038549, -0.05712875723838806, -0.02960294671356678, 0.0212563406676054, -0.0024568280205130577, -0.030004961416125298, -0.018839368596673012, 0.0633712112903595, -0.05196748673915863, 0.027189137414097786, -0.021653009578585625, -0.02443191036581993, -0.0055079334415495396, -0.03964649513363838, 0.036395344883203506, -0.0435805507004261, 0.0218521561473608, 0.059326544404029846, -0.009967805817723274, 0.031213097274303436, 0.04442457854747772, 0.10347919911146164, -0.009400555863976479, -0.02903066761791706, -0.016274450346827507, -0.03475731983780861, 0.011206691153347492, -0.01200045645236969, -0.025610433891415596, 0.04887395724654198, 0.016632623970508575, -0.041441623121500015, 0.003762240754440427, 0.0018804206047207117, -0.004156618379056454, -0.03449443727731705, 0.032336317002773285, -0.014897627755999565, 0.009554405696690083, 0.015202963724732399, 0.0007415261934511364, -0.004698986653238535, 0.0265783853828907, 0.02033986896276474, 0.01290807779878378, 0.023965777829289436, 0.026168402284383774, 0.005761753302067518, -0.0028844724874943495, -0.0015520078595727682, 0.09381213784217834, -0.009969230741262436, 0.008727243170142174, 0.024441508576273918, -0.02824285998940468, 0.04529043659567833, 0.012398411519825459, -0.013007999397814274, -0.013106306083500385, 0.011169498786330223, -0.004721655044704676, 0.019461870193481445, 0.0011393597815185785, -0.03362585976719856, 0.016861580312252045, -0.009601193480193615, 0.011703846976161003, 0.05481035262346268, 0.012914440594613552, -0.01462892908602953, -0.017703479155898094, 0.036647483706474304, -0.05157720670104027, 0.028409365564584732, -0.05363457649946213, 0.05448349937796593, -0.019701028242707253, 0.009294507093727589, 0.021498220041394234, -0.015793737024068832, 0.004970826208591461, 0.0019554556347429752, 0.021025223657488823, 0.07214781641960144, 0.024056721478700638, -0.02931426465511322, 0.03933677449822426, -0.05379253625869751, -0.08748599141836166, 0.014167793095111847, 0.02652805857360363, 0.0036153087858110666, -0.020439306274056435, 0.04236872121691704, 0.023984575644135475, -0.03880384936928749, 0.02364294044673443, 0.019345959648489952, 0.03499668464064598, 0.003036458743736148, -0.08605284988880157, -0.04401785507798195, 0.03190809115767479, -0.025397375226020813, 0.026961205527186394, -0.04723495990037918, 0.04210419952869415, 0.03087977133691311, 0.06206898018717766, -0.018964121118187904, 0.03739766404032707, 0.024126244708895683, 0.005149815697222948, 0.0008331905701197684, -0.020131397992372513, -0.0035958110820502043, -0.02532804384827614, 0.027682561427354813, -0.061035171151161194, -0.08962784707546234, 0.025581784546375275, -0.006391000002622604, -0.0388529933989048, -0.02993922494351864, 0.03517531976103783, -0.007960858754813671, -0.019236387684941292, 0.004708131775259972, -0.016255853697657585, -0.00726361246779561, 0.055125899612903595, 0.02363782748579979, 0.058125611394643784, 0.041999395936727524, -0.010021152906119823, -0.0059381029568612576, 0.022343425080180168, 0.05480002239346504, 0.04830512776970863, -0.02628183737397194, -0.021723344922065735, -0.01830291375517845, 0.024174174293875694, 0.007997626438736916, -0.024076547473669052, -0.02681398205459118, -0.016683142632246017, 0.022023772820830345, -0.023071996867656708, 0.011007464490830898, 0.012981555424630642, -0.03035225160419941, 0.004024398047477007, -0.03549983724951744, -0.02016559988260269, -0.04986272007226944, 0.04058113321661949, -0.03861838951706886, 0.04810471460223198, 0.0287115927785635, 0.006100052036345005, -0.0036453234497457743, -0.019073806703090668, -0.00003552816269802861, -0.01740392856299877, -0.017822327092289925, 0.005479145795106888, -0.006958435755223036, 0.0074546970427036285, 0.03135175257921219, 0.0019226744771003723, -0.00964114349335432, 0.03415161743760109, -0.04999803751707077, -0.022472301498055458, 0.039146069437265396, -0.012719791382551193, 0.0046373759396374226, -0.03417235240340233, -0.011051398701965809, 0.017115186899900436, -0.009520025923848152, -0.010607068426907063, 0.010091938078403473, -0.07590426504611969, 0.061601750552654266, 0.04943762347102165, -0.002325208857655525, 0.03976713865995407, 0.034770939499139786, 0.03628649190068245, -0.01918494701385498, -0.006187260616570711, 0.011218034662306309, -0.08063838630914688, -0.008752726949751377, 0.03567004203796387, 0.004120555240660906, -0.005811448208987713, 0.03832300752401352, 0.01278909295797348, 0.05947420373558998, 0.007351107429713011, 0.01680002361536026, -0.02910052426159382, -0.0020924669224768877, -0.004164425656199455, 0.009064998477697372, 0.004839777015149593, -0.0035813802387565374, -0.025704503059387207, -0.026108525693416595, 0.036002494394779205, -0.008636868558824062, -0.06007719784975052, 0.048677559942007065, 0.023988036438822746, 0.02507878839969635, -0.014494528993964195, -0.024199986830353737, 0.021229689940810204, -0.0256245955824852, -0.010104545392096043, 0.039412956684827805, 0.009534630924463272, 0.011344699189066887, -0.015959743410348892, -0.06303580850362778, 0.022886518388986588, 0.051078569144010544, -0.03236449509859085, -0.017465297132730484, 0.028496453538537025, -0.053609929978847504, 0.0021521917078644037, -0.036969587206840515, 0.017765892669558525, -0.026702992618083954, 0.027760779485106468, 0.02241462655365467, -0.04051549732685089, 0.05289493128657341, -0.05596740171313286, 0.016263796016573906, 0.002159307710826397, -0.0274793803691864, 0.029691196978092194, -0.014842592179775238, -0.08676522970199585, 0.017170866951346397, -0.0019676319789141417, -0.029853174462914467, 0.059286609292030334, -0.007946406491100788, -0.0354144312441349, -0.0005084533477202058, -0.040335215628147125, -0.054388366639614105, -0.07189860939979553, -0.02552613615989685, 0.04445498436689377, 0.0006260788068175316, -0.05291377380490303, 0.06145322322845459, 0.017419636249542236, 0.010677391663193703, 0.001414487138390541, -0.03012794628739357, 0.00870300829410553, -0.00477389944717288, -0.00581877026706934, 0.004254951141774654, -0.00047469412675127387, -0.008636479265987873, 0.03984997794032097, -0.030172012746334076, 0.00685702171176672, -0.04845714196562767, -0.0799834355711937, 0.055781904608011246, -0.006982586346566677, -0.013501397334039211, 0.0035161259584128857, 0.03360121324658394, 0.05653439462184906, 0.020275793969631195, -0.040496110916137695, -0.003761367406696081, -0.021698860451579094, -0.006680450867861509, -0.023874718695878983, 0.026111550629138947, 0.01964341290295124, 0.01464779581874609, 0.028950924053788185, -0.0011510851327329874, 0.012299877591431141, 0.03129863739013672, -0.009297260083258152, -0.011713598854839802, 0.03504092991352081, 0.012745989486575127, -0.02673039212822914, 0.04424889013171196, 0.04748527333140373, -0.04082949459552765, 0.010962531901896, -0.015003644861280918, -0.010738127864897251, -0.010382073000073433, -0.0021713885944336653, 0.035482797771692276, -0.039842404425144196, -0.0053627099841833115, -0.009310591034591198, 0.02880035527050495, -0.014342655427753925, -0.031041190028190613, 0.010124774649739265, 0.02543487399816513, 0.05547691136598587, -0.026134630665183067, -0.0014177788980305195, 0.012356441468000412, 0.023606186732649803, -0.03457688167691231, 0.013163546100258827, -0.019489413127303123, -0.017048120498657227, -0.013727177865803242, 0.006488317623734474, 0.025159351527690887, 0.034142233431339264, 0.03493993729352951, -0.005872848443686962, 0.05200204253196716, -0.022614557296037674, -0.007874722592532635, -0.04904928058385849, 0.034051563590765, -0.013937108218669891, 0.04893212020397186, -0.011969419196248055, 0.04194575175642967, -0.009331639856100082, 0.003574652597308159, 0.013619441539049149, 0.0034344117157161236, -0.055179040879011154, -0.0178137868642807, -0.02731604129076004, 0.028892818838357925, 0.010554082691669464, -0.004443816374987364, 0.034889038652181625, -0.04259459301829338, -0.05459052324295044, -0.016231536865234375, 0.06098213046789169, -0.07132264226675034, 0.041706424206495285, -0.02469148486852646, -0.0291388351470232, 0.0015734455082565546, -0.003885116660967469, 0.032204098999500275, -0.0012678987113758922, 0.04795784503221512, 0.040690403431653976, 0.015161422081291676, -0.0013018002500757575, -0.02004287950694561, 0.02003861963748932, 0.022541623562574387, 0.03187006339430809, 0.039655957370996475, 0.019076069816946983, -0.021982043981552124, 0.006584562361240387, 0.0366482138633728, 0.05209200829267502, -0.010078508406877518, -0.009006664156913757, -0.008719746954739094, -0.07713137567043304, -0.010267231613397598, -0.03706156462430954, 0.03151597082614899, -0.01306657399982214, 0.02371056005358696, 0.030427169054746628, 0.03730381652712822, -0.05357100069522858, 0.012671015225350857, 0.05039340630173683, -0.018758995458483696, -0.045135747641325, -0.05386224761605263, -0.019790945574641228, -0.03654755279421806, -0.009790086187422276, 0.0648750513792038, -0.012429951690137386, -0.030683692544698715, 0.021746093407273293, 0.03870999813079834, -0.06916287541389465, -0.002779625589028001, -0.02843884564936161, 0.02978503704071045, 0.031042704358696938, -0.007862958125770092, 0.03328968584537506, -0.03519348427653313, 0.027217572554945946, 0.0445101372897625, 0.00874963030219078, 0.018588440492749214, -0.05342656373977661, 0.0030407984741032124, 0.05048484355211258, 0.02372097223997116, -0.04416777566075325, -0.022422725334763527, -0.055774006992578506, -0.028320187702775, 0.020207883790135384, 0.00581761309877038, 0.0311140064150095, -0.008845701813697815, 0.005947263911366463, -0.01693274825811386, -0.01024701539427042, 0.01322873868048191, -0.009960700757801533, -0.005046755075454712, 0.03391484171152115, -0.0028937419410794973, -0.009067234583199024, -0.03362438082695007, -0.020539307966828346, 0.017579102888703346, 0.03762851655483246, -0.023298807442188263, 0.02348555624485016, -0.011585508473217487, 0.04656315967440605, 0.020329559221863747, -0.08608543872833252, 0.003301878459751606, -0.009131067432463169, -0.012826019898056984, 0.04396999254822731, -0.0333612821996212, -0.0396198034286499, 0.020531203597784042, 0.007666970137506723, -0.028494402766227722, 0.010664837434887886, -0.0274454765021801, 0.05387798696756363, 0.053457871079444885, -0.013986101374030113, 0.05809647962450981, -0.019314231351017952, 0.015786776319146156, 0.014662351459264755, -0.005795987322926521, 0.032973192632198334, -0.03263531252741814, 0.01252210047096014, -0.013523215427994728, 0.035414211452007294, -0.011783089488744736, 0.049311261624097824, 0.02333860844373703, 0.031400419771671295, 0.008446535095572472, -0.02347750775516033, -0.007405622862279415, 0.02540728449821472, 0.016304295510053635, -0.03284561634063721, 0.0036378365475684404, 0.011771767400205135, 0.0037885690107941628, -0.006730580702424049, -0.0232384130358696, -0.028625313192605972, 0.029446974396705627, 0.014649518765509129, -0.016981882974505424, -0.016660556197166443, -0.07603290677070618, -0.022236304357647896, 0.030724065378308296, -0.021330121904611588, 0.05675987899303436, 0.027858352288603783, 0.019500913098454475, -0.0008301244815811515, -0.059738416224718094, -0.023133277893066406, -0.00234322645701468, -0.025503287091851234, -0.00696537597104907, -0.043705735355615616, 0.031143793836236, -0.00950352568179369, 0.002791816368699074, -0.052471909672021866, -0.03905908390879631, 0.003398417728021741, 0.0066778226755559444, -0.013311606831848621, -0.0714864432811737, 0.04481253772974014, -0.0019379481673240662, -0.017025090754032135, -0.007642657961696386, 0.08372990787029266, -0.02536061219871044, -0.0018158691236749291, 0.02291439287364483, -0.009303499013185501, 0.03137042000889778, 0.01501175295561552, 0.0034911397378891706, -0.007637071888893843, -0.013776631094515324, -0.011814812198281288, -0.015082859434187412, 0.026698868721723557, -0.013495689257979393, 0.004693979397416115, -0.03857360780239105, 0.020761441439390182, 0.060087062418460846, -0.03554908186197281, 0.033820390701293945, 0.036349818110466, 0.0050115338526666164, -0.03519788384437561, -0.012165476568043232, -0.017053088173270226, -0.02532920241355896, -0.005189924035221338, 0.021296417340636253, 0.01313328929245472, -0.014221911318600178, -0.03466445207595825, 0.026306679472327232, -0.017215749248862267, -0.003170238109305501, -0.00412308145314455, 0.05671754851937294, -0.010982350446283817, 0.01459475327283144, -0.017745845019817352, -0.07615979760885239, 0.06419146806001663, -0.05638502538204193, 0.027379468083381653, 0.023860476911067963, 0.03611559793353081, -0.04635685682296753, -0.007963960990309715, -0.01973639242351055, 0.010880357585847378, 0.06986510753631592, -0.019951632246375084, 0.03713339567184448, 0.014203434810042381, -0.013073505833745003, 0.014799540862441063, -0.0227446798235178, -0.02584131993353367, 0.019512956961989403, -0.034115180373191833, 0.050341613590717316, -0.04064738005399704, -0.014797084964811802, 0.03676389157772064, 0.02070760540664196, 0.035555560141801834, 0.010971881449222565, 0.023160558193922043, 0.03603395074605942, 0.02223782427608967, -0.0011350229615345597, -0.04360175505280495, 0.045627158135175705, -0.04057186469435692, -0.002418961375951767, 0.00977962464094162, -0.04086698591709137, 0.09020455181598663, 0.04244515672326088, 0.01511283591389656, -0.04853738099336624, -0.03197823092341423, -0.03192202374339104, 0.022183718159794807, -0.0073455017991364, 0.04034171625971794, -0.012894179672002792, -0.004840938374400139, 0.033787596970796585, -0.023167835548520088, 0.002864616457372904, 0.0014691444812342525, -0.07902868092060089, -0.06817329674959183, 0.001970916287973523, -0.01893533766269684, 0.031920041888952255, 0.005646770354360342, -0.05757434666156769, 0.017816167324781418, -0.0414852611720562, 0.019375238567590714, 0.005408033728599548, 0.021562371402978897, 0.006462086457759142, 0.03578706458210945, -0.023177022114396095, 0.06291472911834717, 0.01583114080131054, -0.03474567458033562, 0.11194426566362381, 0.06463081389665604, 0.026033304631710052, -0.06411217153072357, -0.02867722697556019, -0.023470768705010414, 0.013496678322553635, -0.011221286840736866, 0.0430716797709465, 0.022397594526410103, 0.008273681625723839, -0.04346142336726189, 0.029938850551843643, 0.02828451804816723, -0.020931458100676537, 0.018266983330249786, -0.0619797520339489, -0.013094523921608925, 0.04101767763495445, 0.005462969187647104, -0.0031863844487816095, -0.008645613677799702, -0.05466802045702934, -0.02118976041674614, 0.0029595824889838696, 0.0017450597370043397, 0.00300067407079041, -0.03562313690781593, 0.03729506582021713, 0.006114970427006483, -0.007385021075606346, -0.027758251875638962, -0.024747978895902634, -0.04017391428351402, 0.022659948095679283, 0.025288457050919533, 0.02163766510784626, -0.014918421395123005, 0.025839848443865776, 0.015003261156380177, 0.034956082701683044, -0.015588670037686825, -0.0016666933661326766, 0.012803861871361732, -0.031132632866501808, -0.006697684060782194, -0.029157385230064392, 0.026141896843910217, -0.024716904386878014, -0.011280003003776073, 0.04429285600781441, -0.024726470932364464, -0.006117918528616428, -0.046308841556310654, -0.0295973252505064, 0.04854857176542282, 0.05585433915257454, 0.012699228711426258, -0.05465563386678696, -0.02384749986231327, 0.04531504586338997, -0.04243089258670807, 0.024564554914832115, -0.005250550340861082, -0.024709884077310562, 0.00043888523941859603, -0.04301853105425835, 0.030102746561169624, 0.004516421351581812, 0.0008351571741513908, -0.04514280706644058, 0.010788966901600361, -0.004333158023655415, 0.00024337302602361888, 0.0302372295409441, -0.026093674823641777, 0.024748941883444786, -0.015324313193559647, -0.025822702795267105, 0.007711209822446108, -0.022811459377408028, -0.003921018913388252, -0.01920800656080246, 0.0031866885256022215, -0.014734646305441856, 0.0258793942630291, 0.06246282532811165, 0.00498401653021574, 0.03555814176797867, 0.018162569031119347, 0.022954856976866722, -0.006735474336892366, 0.00976813118904829, -0.02727924846112728, -0.03776051476597786, 0.011159837245941162, -0.01477565336972475, -0.024367384612560272, -0.0309553574770689, 0.027001895010471344, 0.035923443734645844, 0.018389444798231125, -0.02876121550798416, 0.013844907283782959, -0.011319554410874844, 0.007664678618311882, -0.008026354014873505, -0.024733789265155792, -0.002190126571804285, 0.007694215048104525, 0.013141781091690063, -0.0666021853685379, -0.016689443960785866, -0.02354472316801548, -0.006723132450133562, -0.010755930095911026, 0.006756360176950693, -0.05065986514091492, -0.019896870478987694, 0.028028592467308044, 0.056949108839035034, -0.0034372741356492043, -0.004405738320201635, -0.02623017691075802, 0.03676370531320572, -0.01437154971063137, -0.02280968241393566, -0.028409775346517563, 0.05264458432793617, 0.02134317345917225, -0.038952481001615524, 0.016011320054531097, -0.0005664185155183077, -0.029281361028552055, -0.017243707552552223, 0.003605328034609556, -0.002682259539142251, 0.042168550193309784, -0.02506408840417862, -0.03258289024233818, 0.009925664402544498, -0.01449406798928976, -0.037366870790719986, 0.030508296564221382, 0.0476188026368618, 0.009751085191965103, -0.002119875978678465, -0.03974192962050438, -0.021342681720852852, 0.03599799796938896, -0.04270175099372864, -0.014766012318432331, 0.004828509874641895, -0.010250266641378403, 0.004854029975831509, -0.0018644401570782065, 0.012452775612473488, 0.005887862294912338, -0.020660538226366043, 0.004404427018016577, 0.021065860986709595, 0.01693289540708065, -0.010996556840837002, 0.020198024809360504, -0.01367849763482809, 0.01651088334619999, -0.018460514023900032, 0.006779888644814491, 0.027188604697585106, 0.026053940877318382, -0.04273409768939018, 0.059244222939014435, 0.022029267624020576, 0.005753855686634779, -0.0677967369556427, 0.012090343050658703, 0.011517724022269249, 0.006844199728220701, 0.06783311814069748, -0.059482645243406296, 0.0031879658345133066, 0.017584655433893204, -0.0655074492096901, 0.022371677681803703, 0.00554609764367342, 0.009011351503431797, -0.015227233991026878, -0.0038387475069612265, -0.017870783805847168, 0.05270638316869736, 0.02635531686246395, 0.03894961625337601, 0.03760472685098648, -0.009781306609511375, -0.01690267212688923, -0.016547363251447678, -0.056453507393598557, 0.056897856295108795, 0.0033214539289474487, -0.018285468220710754, 0.062302250415086746, -0.07955922931432724, -0.040774647146463394, 0.038537003099918365, -0.012005473487079144, 0.0011607911437749863, 0.019561486318707466, -0.010074538178741932, 0.019382964819669724, -0.00906800851225853, 0.03702101111412048, -0.03810299187898636, 0.037460796535015106, 0.018715079873800278, 0.013879452832043171, 0.0006144659128040075, -0.0016238557873293757, -0.00044101476669311523, 0.0006871967925690114, 0.014966648072004318, -0.019383329898118973, 0.01868203841149807, -0.010749150067567825, -0.01646316424012184, -0.017829708755016327, -0.0005424549453891814, 0.02131953090429306, -0.020960435271263123, 0.0006019988795742393, -0.020420601591467857, -0.021295173093676567, -0.006382264196872711, 0.027805227786302567, -0.0086330221965909, 0.013585841283202171, 0.024592090398073196, -0.042075805366039276, -0.010229218751192093, 0.0001948415010701865, -0.019967416301369667, -0.0312943309545517, 0.03090292029082775, 0.02732389234006405, -0.05088561400771141, -0.014065940864384174, -0.05028689280152321, -0.03189901262521744, 0.03106064349412918, -0.04022861644625664, 0.05832653120160103, 0.020245905965566635, -0.04974786937236786, 0.008445031940937042, -0.07295569032430649, 0.07066774368286133, 0.01100507378578186, -0.010195860639214516, -0.021906383335590363, 0.011300330981612206, 0.0018256820039823651, -0.048064224421978, 0.08426644653081894, -0.0003534105489961803, 0.028144529089331627, -0.025179462507367134, -0.0017425233963876963, 0.014126424677670002, -0.008350014686584473, -0.012206334620714188, -0.023898355662822723, -0.014958895742893219, -0.025042632594704628, -0.031778499484062195, 0.0032025345135480165, 0.002527574310079217, 0.01612389087677002, -0.019995002076029778, 0.02182895317673683, -0.010530928149819374, 0.03629881516098976, -0.005654643755406141, 0.005125304684042931, 0.005580152850598097, 0.03430750593543053, -0.018203292042016983, -0.015469041652977467, 0.04163074493408203, 0.00938262790441513, -0.06936292350292206, 0.030895095318555832, 0.016931822523474693, -0.027049696072936058, -0.010560563765466213, 0.01720615290105343, 0.059063032269477844, -0.06694892048835754, -0.02618258446455002, 0.005202552769333124, -0.03387506306171417, 0.03155706077814102, 0.08060742169618607, -0.025388270616531372, 0.028198478743433952, -0.0026269243098795414, 0.026462484151124954, 0.014624061994254589, 0.009274709038436413, 0.0026211515069007874, 0.01535481121391058, 0.020402617752552032, -0.003507954301312566, 0.06943001598119736, 0.02735508605837822, -0.030326975509524345, 0.06023208051919937, -0.04106450825929642, 0.029098035767674446, -0.03709065914154053, -0.034540895372629166, 0.022326944395899773, 0.02211470901966095, 0.013500457629561424, 0.008868328295648098, -0.013756163418293, 0.06421638280153275, -0.04283958673477173, 0.021963631734251976, 0.01416024286299944, -0.03544730693101883, -0.006077622529119253, 0.007916077971458435, 0.024962862953543663, 0.03069174475967884, 0.014864595606923103, -0.009980372153222561, 0.002386741805821657, -0.005168656352907419, 0.046444401144981384, -0.01661253534257412, 0.019338706508278847, -0.029131906107068062, 0.0015800361288711429, 0.012075172737240791, -0.016772937029600143, -0.012690878473222256, -0.00009520159801468253, 0.015991749241948128, 0.030005354434251785, 0.03151366114616394, 0.02327197603881359, -0.02398321032524109, -0.006040302570909262, 0.02363406866788864, -0.08263757079839706, -0.02237311564385891, -0.07839798182249069, -0.006484760902822018, 0.0265251025557518, -0.011239331215620041 ]
<p>Is there a standard hypothesis test for differences in the mean of a continuous dependent variable with respect to a single ordered categorical variable. </p> <p>By specifying that the independent variable is ordered, I also mean to impose the assumption that the dependent variable is monotonic in the independent variable.</p>
14,632
[ -0.05762014538049698, 0.006071994546800852, 0.0024494179524481297, 0.01021029893308878, 0.030440500006079674, 0.013628083281219006, 0.020896051079034805, 0.016279952600598335, 0.015307401306927204, -0.031603582203388214, 0.03164045512676239, 0.025273989886045456, 0.07019256055355072, 0.0011166059412062168, 0.038285814225673676, 0.014919633977115154, -0.018371330574154854, 0.016365256160497665, 0.0021484089083969593, 0.012183666229248047, -0.029971277341246605, 0.01309838518500328, 0.026148932054638863, -0.005449950695037842, 0.0022674340289086103, 0.028847159817814827, 0.0087426220998168, -0.010926548391580582, -0.008340309374034405, 0.04639342427253723, -0.035222798585891724, -0.018399393185973167, 0.00838271901011467, 0.052583031356334686, 0.025078458711504936, -0.011867113411426544, 0.0025330735370516777, -0.01904275082051754, -0.03577491268515587, 0.0283807460218668, -0.018183914944529533, -0.016276884824037552, -0.0008951571653597057, 0.04103853181004524, 0.0060346233658492565, 0.022380705922842026, 0.020139263942837715, -0.04234190285205841, 0.02363438718020916, -0.0316624790430069, 0.09205291420221329, -0.05413338541984558, 0.03242959454655647, 0.019351232796907425, -0.03900821506977081, 0.017937447875738144, 0.026717672124505043, 0.03765638545155525, 0.0035151424817740917, -0.03903663158416748, -0.023544492200016975, -0.03717031702399254, 0.0107779735699296, 0.0047943489626049995, -0.04789082705974579, 0.03149159625172615, -0.03281508386135101, -0.0391271710395813, 0.031748004257678986, -0.010064381174743176, -0.014999400824308395, 0.013160250149667263, 0.037431731820106506, 0.010555585846304893, -0.004819873720407486, -0.011702335439622402, 0.006568701937794685, 0.012046042829751968, 0.026989394798874855, 0.03559434041380882, 0.018703632056713104, -0.014114738442003727, 0.0008318155305460095, 0.055474311113357544, 0.005751112475991249, -0.025467291474342346, 0.05807049199938774, -0.02172219567000866, -0.009714623913168907, 0.030945537611842155, -0.037614431232213974, -0.05791584774851799, 0.04480800777673721, 0.011487512849271297, -0.04746032506227493, 0.005323975812643766, -0.05112750828266144, 0.023039560765028, -0.031072789803147316, -0.011388878338038921, 0.019482653588056564, -0.02517041191458702, 0.026065919548273087, 0.03813374415040016, 0.018527807667851448, 0.02457599900662899, -0.020047610625624657, 0.03966144099831581, -0.010982404462993145, -0.013444386422634125, -0.02289266511797905, 0.02655656635761261, 0.021784111857414246, 0.023165708407759666, 0.01198810338973999, -0.009561935439705849, -0.028628766536712646, -0.020190896466374397, 0.03734208270907402, 0.05782613530755043, 0.09947522729635239, -0.03713318333029747, 0.012328702956438065, -0.004623343702405691, -0.04189605265855789, 0.01935182325541973, 0.02351415529847145, 0.009201397188007832, 0.0032197500113397837, 0.053137414157390594, -0.015985099598765373, 0.010832349769771099, 0.04438139498233795, -0.018332235515117645, 0.028411030769348145, 0.009484177455306053, -0.08531450480222702, -0.06212673708796501, 0.022004814818501472, 0.01255430281162262, 0.02736331894993782, -0.05566328018903732, -0.012675139121711254, 0.03408469259738922, 0.008238456211984158, 0.0030792744364589453, 0.023923594504594803, -0.012341611087322235, 0.019565686583518982, 0.03249893710017204, -0.011368502862751484, -0.03755662590265274, 0.016686223447322845, -0.021508891135454178, -0.013528415933251381, -0.09023455530405045, 0.003529042238369584, -0.0050304061733186245, -0.0014614772517234087, 0.019482489675283432, 0.04575285688042641, 0.03407059982419014, -0.01978171244263649, -0.008732637390494347, 0.05444106087088585, -0.02298538014292717, 0.04627533257007599, -0.022286606952548027, 0.021810326725244522, -0.021150637418031693, 0.023644505068659782, 0.03227244317531586, 0.020599009469151497, 0.041488468647003174, 0.05001422017812729, -0.045780956745147705, -0.0007609861786477268, -0.025750543922185898, 0.009135794825851917, 0.01074792817234993, -0.003155537648126483, 0.0033619124442338943, -0.03935858979821205, -0.02624044567346573, -0.017760101705789566, 0.03592963516712189, -0.0011309069814160466, -0.009933607652783394, 0.035223715007305145, -0.06559041142463684, -0.05457350239157677, -0.06382308155298233, -0.005143679212778807, 0.009836734272539616, -0.03555861487984657, 0.04094984382390976, 0.03589565306901932, 0.08254016190767288, -0.026958564296364784, 0.004710323177278042, 0.015018455684185028, -0.028929980471730232, 0.010984756052494049, -0.03307804837822914, 0.03309241309762001, 0.033017825335264206, 0.0718759149312973, -0.020479312166571617, 0.011660192161798477, -0.01499885879456997, -0.061630863696336746, 0.02797568030655384, -0.06367411464452744, 0.019321998581290245, 0.027600808069109917, 0.03226330131292343, 0.013906299136579037, 0.025554925203323364, -0.025604896247386932, 0.04607941582798958, -0.0482340045273304, 0.08060447126626968, 0.04618765786290169, 0.03253538906574249, 0.009133502840995789, 0.009906863793730736, 0.03239927068352699, -0.01577814482152462, -0.014821194112300873, -0.0331464484333992, -0.018928783014416695, 0.0010078179184347391, 0.03199893608689308, 0.015795819461345673, -0.05043511092662811, 0.03267800807952881, 0.054106906056404114, 0.028184164315462112, 0.02552562765777111, 0.023385636508464813, 0.008218091912567616, -0.05434553697705269, 0.02146531641483307, 0.02367529831826687, 0.015248188748955727, 0.019389724358916283, 0.03113815374672413, -0.010801289230585098, 0.057512469589710236, -0.009472629986703396, 0.004438184201717377, 0.0013941845390945673, -0.00943714752793312, 0.010463629849255085, 0.0061981407925486565, -0.031217046082019806, 0.05838235467672348, -0.032699085772037506, 0.0038914026226848364, 0.04094585031270981, -0.012662303633987904, -0.0032554189674556255, 0.02978418953716755, -0.008121914230287075, 0.031870171427726746, 0.03366555646061897, -0.04401259124279022, 0.03941601887345314, 0.0334872305393219, -0.020751064643263817, 0.010173349641263485, -0.05074595659971237, -0.03657057508826256, -0.03905026614665985, -0.01941869780421257, -0.0081528564915061, -0.001798461191356182, 0.02128763683140278, 0.007119324523955584, 0.03901311010122299, 0.00341124483384192, -0.04816479980945587, -0.0004589255549944937, -0.010495183058083057, -0.03921908885240555, -0.020215727388858795, -0.0034789263736456633, -0.02912566438317299, 0.017708338797092438, -0.02876073308289051, -0.012784209102392197, 0.036310870200395584, -0.007030490320175886, -0.062449805438518524, -0.01480086985975504, -0.015881601721048355, -0.009318520314991474, -0.019653305411338806, -0.029131174087524414, 0.012931117787957191, -0.003087566699832678, -0.031204814091324806, 0.017207041382789612, -0.04810135066509247, -0.009890662506222725, -0.012388058006763458, -0.015356307849287987, 0.008587891235947609, 0.006925573572516441, -0.000685833627358079, 0.018806204199790955, -0.035593532025814056, 0.001625241246074438, -0.07157088071107864, -0.08524084836244583, 0.04703228175640106, -0.03462408110499382, 0.0396399162709713, 0.005091061815619469, -0.026589591056108475, 0.046193044632673264, 0.03639751672744751, -0.0154976025223732, -0.06927735358476639, -0.004989455919712782, -0.01923597976565361, 0.0265479888767004, 0.000592898519244045, 0.010967876762151718, 0.02738126553595066, 0.027622463181614876, 0.03916911408305168, 0.02661914937198162, -0.0072013018652796745, 0.02431454509496689, -0.026170985773205757, 0.022909274324774742, 0.015635032206773758, -0.01950213685631752, 0.02626744657754898, 0.01646999828517437, -0.014960039407014847, 0.013603449799120426, 0.017875319346785545, 0.02765578031539917, 0.0043565938249230385, -0.015374459326267242, 0.03530088812112808, -0.004466323181986809, -0.025181608274579048, -0.016823817044496536, 0.036808811128139496, 0.03791981562972069, 0.0035666413605213165, 0.0007827658555470407, 0.025857022032141685, -0.008792632259428501, -0.003938731271773577, 0.03154129534959793, 0.028834331780672073, 0.035362809896469116, -0.020178740844130516, -0.028652312234044075, -0.019156021997332573, -0.04520030692219734, 0.055207349359989166, -0.040683019906282425, -0.04266832768917084, 0.0377676784992218, 0.021497685462236404, 0.026082919910550117, -0.010682147927582264, -0.02131650783121586, 0.04792732000350952, -0.05696887522935867, 0.010033901780843735, -0.000661442696582526, 0.046456653624773026, 0.017505865544080734, 0.04520636424422264, 0.016993815079331398, -0.007095055188983679, 0.0044279457069933414, -0.01746639423072338, -0.05448710545897484, 0.03774561360478401, -0.025345370173454285, 0.03948130086064339, 0.024507027119398117, -0.02742544561624527, 0.018217792734503746, -0.022048914805054665, 0.0209332387894392, -0.007638227194547653, 0.03758558630943298, -0.03686382994055748, 0.0013827397488057613, -0.03550524637103081, -0.04153139144182205, 0.01409120298922062, 0.0000012756150908899144, 0.0007432353449985385, -0.06574298441410065, 0.031980689615011215, 0.014629759825766087, -0.01690167374908924, -0.026612941175699234, -0.04176340997219086, 0.030772732570767403, 0.00906667672097683, 0.028550704941153526, 0.022246036678552628, 0.028236979618668556, -0.03380605950951576, 0.06265329569578171, -0.010361861437559128, 0.040959522128105164, 0.0026058622170239687, -0.012896276079118252, -0.008838157169520855, -0.04193330928683281, -0.017698554322123528, -0.0089344447478652, 0.02602475695312023, 0.016165470704436302, -0.009310364723205566, 0.0545840859413147, 0.017546003684401512, -0.040916115045547485, 0.019408248364925385, 0.04954702407121658, 0.015474606305360794, -0.013858530670404434, -0.013706406578421593, -0.025431500747799873, -0.027078375220298767, -0.0021103525068610907, 0.038733504712581635, 0.010896541178226471, -0.0025303582660853863, 0.037506431341171265, 0.020880574360489845, 0.009233248420059681, -0.03793738782405853, -0.04824279248714447, -0.030107472091913223, 0.0060393414460122585, -0.005653350614011288, -0.04633016139268875, 0.03555958345532417, 0.01431297231465578, 0.020824069157242775, 0.04837945103645325, -0.0032900881487876177, -0.09092387557029724, 0.055344946682453156, 0.053191859275102615, 0.0432908870279789, -0.03151588514447212, -0.011726794764399529, -0.0047746035270392895, 0.023559845983982086, 0.08530014753341675, -0.009892874397337437, -0.0001309883955400437, -0.01959305629134178, 0.02185506373643875, -0.01680949702858925, -0.013788394629955292, -0.04720901697874069, 0.017454326152801514, 0.00042195769492536783, -0.01320604421198368, 0.018652409315109253, -0.01746945083141327, -0.06468699872493744, 0.018876010552048683, 0.018530597910284996, 0.03953021019697189, -0.008598240092396736, 0.00019855721620842814, 0.015057330019772053, -0.02776491641998291, -0.03270586207509041, -0.03999270498752594, 0.031772810965776443, -0.005734400823712349, -0.0025970921851694584, 0.031169630587100983, 0.013247033581137657, -0.008188439533114433, -0.0030615683645009995, -0.012581134214997292, -0.03526805341243744, 0.01801869086921215, 0.006562842987477779, 0.046622175723314285, 0.006158262491226196, -0.0036583596374839544, 0.034933798015117645, 0.013250269927084446, 0.017816876992583275, -0.019351178780198097, -0.00868389755487442, 0.040472403168678284, -0.019771737977862358, -0.02343270182609558, -0.025558920577168465, -0.02027830481529236, -0.005975400563329458, 0.022887224331498146, -0.014660676009953022, 0.02319672517478466, -0.015078859403729439, -0.01693285070359707, -0.0060148159973323345, 0.00953106489032507, 0.014798624441027641, -0.01432698406279087, -0.0007475094171240926, 0.014778323471546173, -0.02131049335002899, -0.027883708477020264, 0.053002700209617615, -0.0311354398727417, -0.0017688579391688108, -0.0268291924148798, -0.041642069816589355, 0.021470677107572556, -0.023341752588748932, -0.03156670182943344, 0.022814394906163216, -0.016521839424967766, 0.039039794355630875, -0.014131632633507252, 0.03474636748433113, -0.014584236778318882, -0.05043346434831619, -0.017287317663431168, 0.037895601242780685, 0.010025129653513432, 0.025727560743689537, -0.06280353665351868, 0.025891685858368874, -0.001013644621707499, -0.01424399483948946, -0.07464339584112167, -0.07905825227499008, 0.008722052909433842, 0.0023064319975674152, -0.008642506785690784, -0.03073558770120144, 0.024441072717308998, -0.009530752897262573, 0.0023557585664093494, -0.03758920729160309, 0.06619733572006226, 0.005551057867705822, -0.026729874312877655, -0.034198567271232605, 0.001225363346748054, 0.05412362143397331, 0.02090323530137539, -0.04249931499361992, 0.006308733019977808, 0.00659733172506094, -0.009541508741676807, -0.01880641095340252, -0.008742496371269226, -0.024655519053339958, 0.017268074676394463, -0.022993408143520355, -0.011597760953009129, 0.009188467636704445, -0.03767996281385422, -0.057343270629644394, 0.029008787125349045, -0.0016011391999199986, 0.006620417349040508, -0.04766717553138733, 0.01188572496175766, -0.039193104952573776, -0.004300656728446484, -0.019002322107553482, 0.003982765134423971, -0.0036265472881495953, -0.0407862663269043, 0.009816685691475868, 0.027058195322752, -0.0640302449464798, 0.03135448694229126, 0.045253120362758636, 0.025048697367310524, -0.003427597228437662, 0.0022810292430222034, -0.011589491739869118, -0.01686895452439785, -0.019957054406404495, -0.027200745418667793, -0.009351778775453568, 0.017023427411913872, -0.038274116814136505, -0.017501095309853554, -0.00894352700561285, -0.014486052095890045, 0.04468606412410736, 0.011348668485879898, 0.05298926308751106, 0.06460975110530853, -0.0034529033582657576, 0.0040978360921144485, 0.00761245796456933, 0.0051812040619552135, 0.011186874471604824, 0.010870764963328838, 0.04333902895450592, 0.0013910367852076888, 0.03409092128276825, 0.05161828547716141, 0.05903865769505501, -0.0010413381969556212, 0.0732957050204277, 0.005632307380437851, 0.0024886459577828646, 0.04346003010869026, -0.05337625741958618, -0.039490148425102234, 0.05508565530180931, -0.07255896925926208, 0.027243180200457573, -0.06482546776533127, -0.00821696873754263, 0.03700563684105873, 0.03181622922420502, 0.004039134364575148, -0.04919665679335594, -0.029395291581749916, -0.050485141575336456, 0.030330654233694077, 0.013618349097669125, 0.02170714922249317, 0.039577022194862366, -0.03055364266037941, 0.024407245218753815, -0.0003331325715407729, 0.015113679692149162, -0.057376474142074585, -0.04349913448095322, -0.03133976459503174, 0.006290421821177006, -0.04045553877949715, 0.01812118850648403, -0.006992029026150703, -0.039211101830005646, 0.02327999658882618, -0.06064750626683235, 0.003713243408128619, 0.043583422899246216, 0.005622012075036764, 0.018870733678340912, 0.06413402408361435, -0.005135352723300457, 0.021247293800115585, -0.0069089350290596485, -0.027856841683387756, 0.11412318795919418, 0.08238030970096588, 0.04809938371181488, -0.06926222890615463, 0.05210522934794426, 0.01935415156185627, 0.018627608194947243, -0.039542388170957565, 0.01785154826939106, -0.01616394706070423, -0.011038132011890411, 0.017219820991158485, 0.0897960215806961, 0.015714867040514946, 0.001537080854177475, 0.06523807346820831, -0.022332603111863136, -0.02013970911502838, 0.012431032955646515, 0.016296707093715668, -0.006771556567400694, -0.027563011273741722, -0.024072034284472466, -0.006500122603029013, 0.0077157276682555676, -0.022093091160058975, -0.007064175326377153, 0.0037801414728164673, -0.019280429929494858, 0.014289584942162037, -0.0273910965770483, 0.004457677714526653, 0.04807468131184578, 0.005736195482313633, -0.041542939841747284, -0.021175893023610115, 0.014052481390535831, -0.029900427907705307, 0.02313181385397911, 0.02466229349374771, 0.010832197964191437, -0.005930980667471886, 0.001101367874071002, -0.004767090547829866, -0.038928963243961334, -0.002198978327214718, -0.024198155850172043, 0.009803255088627338, 0.003216714598238468, -0.00020929044694639742, -0.035575877875089645, -0.006172028370201588, -0.026845121756196022, -0.02320687100291252, -0.04410958290100098, 0.027163267135620117, 0.015957539901137352, -0.01922280713915825, -0.021451741456985474, -0.03409602493047714, 0.02035384066402912, -0.021413559094071388, 0.01704517938196659, 0.0151551878079772, -0.05680425837635994, -0.02416800521314144, -0.015286674723029137, 0.06432811915874481, -0.007444031536579132, -0.056244295090436935, 0.00545667065307498, -0.015833770856261253, -0.0009364841389469802, 0.03157040849328041, -0.020671052858233452, -0.03028678707778454, 0.04249913617968559, 0.003294530790299177, -0.039693914353847504, -0.02329413592815399, -0.007976545952260494, -0.01468402799218893, -0.02061016857624054, -0.007463404443114996, -0.039235856384038925, 0.024443598464131355, 0.04913650080561638, 0.02131110429763794, 0.03239569067955017, 0.0018127522198483348, 0.044771693646907806, 0.06906121224164963, 0.02994396723806858, -0.06464485079050064, -0.032998181879520416, -0.023646393790841103, -0.01982305757701397, -0.027039283886551857, -0.030782394111156464, 0.03612793982028961, 0.03968336805701256, 0.010006102733314037, -0.006616867613047361, 0.0198507159948349, -0.01297071948647499, 0.04168388247489929, 0.0406649112701416, -0.06346507370471954, -0.026712974533438683, 0.013379990123212337, -0.02695862017571926, -0.015625406056642532, -0.0471317395567894, -0.07327914983034134, -0.0077342926524579525, -0.009116746485233307, -0.05079251900315285, -0.02770487777888775, -0.018876459449529648, -0.0020059479866176844, 0.020757710561156273, -0.024362491443753242, -0.012081252411007881, -0.017938314005732536, -0.04075931757688522, -0.005154130049049854, 0.011886323802173138, -0.014880675822496414, 0.04763408750295639, -0.015163961797952652, 0.015528632327914238, 0.01164067629724741, 0.017480362206697464, 0.004175099078565836, 0.050764039158821106, -0.0031424087937921286, 0.04317881911993027, 0.03695708140730858, -0.03375949338078499, -0.006145413499325514, 0.02867555245757103, -0.014433156698942184, 0.017298519611358643, 0.019321169704198837, 0.02294892631471157, 0.015333333984017372, -0.011185781098902225, -0.01484189834445715, -0.007661572191864252, 0.01325029693543911, -0.034143250435590744, -0.0011919785756617785, -0.022843273356556892, -0.027902277186512947, 0.013977710157632828, 0.0028347354382276535, -0.010979469865560532, 0.021755995228886604, -0.03832045570015907, 0.008889447897672653, 0.04429597780108452, -0.0018848379841074347, -0.000719795236364007, 0.022953258827328682, 0.001498256460763514, 0.017863309010863304, 0.029077693819999695, 0.006863536778837442, 0.033560384064912796, 0.03657365217804909, -0.02696830779314041, 0.02426679991185665, -0.0017797842156141996, 0.016961997374892235, -0.09799867868423462, -0.005387478042393923, 0.005873327609151602, 0.02143009938299656, 0.0399601012468338, -0.06192415952682495, 0.03677050769329071, 0.011224894784390926, -0.06541979312896729, -0.011727787554264069, -0.006437103729695082, -0.03984379395842552, -0.05815569683909416, -0.028350183740258217, -0.006135269533842802, 0.055388521403074265, 0.016437696292996407, 0.04278866946697235, 0.04115773364901543, 0.026368191465735435, 0.013416158966720104, -0.027839239686727524, -0.013199100270867348, 0.002084136940538883, 0.0651913583278656, -0.06697966903448105, 0.033533960580825806, -0.016238169744610786, -0.03775349631905556, 0.04816446453332901, 0.005792251322418451, 0.021175455302000046, 0.01611284166574478, 0.0785815566778183, -0.007865657098591328, 0.06300103664398193, 0.004233050625771284, 0.004989498294889927, -0.04471130296587944, 0.002537376247346401, -0.000045532935473602265, 0.026327060535550117, -0.02762541174888611, -0.02274245209991932, 0.046980392187833786, -0.011871150694787502, -0.008868607692420483, -0.011301935650408268, -0.01798800192773342, -0.029937466606497765, -0.018263282254338264, -0.0028245048597455025, 0.006659110076725483, 0.01735064387321472, 0.04687891900539398, -0.03139587864279747, -0.015268374234437943, 0.005485150031745434, 0.00988701730966568, -0.04327364265918732, -0.015111984685063362, 0.01157897338271141, -0.0221876073628664, -0.008839946240186691, -0.0016401056200265884, 0.02746082842350006, -0.06682100147008896, -0.006843469105660915, -0.05309446156024933, -0.007010552566498518, -0.04428279399871826, -0.029710803180933, 0.0172249898314476, 0.02807188779115677, -0.03202185779809952, -0.013680925592780113, 0.011055275797843933, -0.011918292380869389, 0.028794504702091217, -0.06891069561243057, 0.08411382883787155, 0.031814880669116974, 0.014885828830301762, -0.003971396014094353, 0.00179192959330976, -0.04788227379322052, -0.02809309959411621, 0.07552557438611984, -0.005364636890590191, -0.011582178063690662, 0.014396066777408123, 0.028187220916152, -0.018041186034679413, -0.0531429685652256, 0.00817331112921238, -0.032671160995960236, -0.008797083981335163, -0.018129458650946617, -0.02825663797557354, 0.02207285352051258, 0.00026961503317579627, 0.03292464092373848, -0.013872657902538776, 0.013907545246183872, -0.011736174114048481, 0.020070789381861687, 0.018079658970236778, 0.022944161668419838, -0.03633546829223633, 0.05158598721027374, -0.012897884473204613, 0.0098242973908782, -0.016277406364679337, -0.005723725073039532, -0.07815104722976685, 0.03930766507983208, -0.008834325708448887, -0.01035738829523325, -0.02357763610780239, 0.04521447792649269, -0.02516675367951393, -0.02569815330207348, -0.011666376143693924, -0.0022104147356003523, -0.04030700400471687, -0.000018743563487078063, 0.018011843785643578, 0.04855102300643921, 0.03360404074192047, 0.0038111938629299402, -0.01365987304598093, -0.0023352699354290962, -0.015124154277145863, 0.05120416358113289, 0.01628992334008217, 0.028922874480485916, 0.037551168352365494, 0.007167904172092676, 0.009302318096160889, -0.0602576844394207, 0.023005150258541107, -0.0003259494842495769, 0.014883395284414291, 0.036759037524461746, -0.019318552687764168, 0.013652808964252472, 0.021771444007754326, 0.042446963489055634, 0.00842643715441227, 0.019262811169028282, 0.03033742867410183, -0.001347484765574336, 0.010651852935552597, -0.02624404802918434, 0.02457868680357933, -0.02772926539182663, -0.018118934705853462, 0.03450574725866318, -0.02026779018342495, -0.019708136096596718, 0.0030491501092910767, 0.010908709838986397, -0.009331095032393932, 0.024635327979922295, -0.01788364164531231, 0.00458938255906105, -0.006211807485669851, 0.00545981852337718, 0.005838359240442514, -0.037132952362298965, -0.05904718488454819, -0.02505778893828392, 0.04517458379268646, 0.02481182850897312, 0.05156721547245979, 0.003441305598244071, -0.002245715819299221, -0.01765172928571701, 0.06090680509805679, -0.07872501015663147, -0.037424471229314804, -0.06006291136145592, -0.008465363644063473, 0.005384331569075584, -0.020302241668105125 ]
<p>Last week I had an interesting discussion with a good friend of mine. He had been playing some <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_poker">online poker</a> and suggested that there is a relationship between new subscription/additional money transfer and the cards that you're dealt, i.e. you get good cards to get hooked. The sites would probably be risking a lot if this was true but the problem still fascinates me.</p> <p>My first approach to this was to ask my friend to define "good cards" and do a simple <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Binomial_test">binomial test</a>. My friend had though a hard time defining what exactly good cards are. If he gets really bad cards he knows to fold while if he gets good cards he knows to go all in - the bad cards are the ones in between.</p> <p>My other approach would be to calculate the exact probability of each given hand and then to see if it differs from the expected, perhaps using a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wilcoxon_signed-rank_test">Wilcoxon signed-rank test</a> since this should detect a different distribution shape as well as a true shift. I guess the hard part is to calculate the exact probability. </p> <p>The data would consist of the first 0-100 dealt cards compared with 300-400 dealt cards a week later (or a friend that's been on the site for a while).</p> <p><strong>Question</strong>: How would you suggest to approach the issue?</p> <p><strong>How Texas hold'em works</strong></p> <p>I'm no expert gamer (I've only played Texas hold'em 3-4 times) but it's fairly simple, you can find more details on the Wikipedia page <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_hold_%27em">here</a>. </p> <p>The main difference from regular poker is that you only get 2 cards at start. You don't get to switch these cards. On the table are another 5 cards face down. By combining your two with the tables 5 you choose the best possible 5 card-poker hand. </p> <p>For instance if you get 2 aces you have a good start and you will probably go in strong, likewise if you have a 7 and a 2 your chances to win are very slim and you quickly fold. The hard part is perhaps a queen and a 9 where you might end up without anything although your cards are above the "average". You can find a list of the poker hands <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_poker_hands">here</a>.</p>
73,422
[ -0.00859033316373825, -0.026339422911405563, 0.024196216836571693, -0.06705264747142792, 0.03609658405184746, 0.006569963879883289, 0.0437665656208992, -0.01601145975291729, 0.03909730911254883, -0.06110724061727524, 0.021329209208488464, 0.010736238211393356, 0.019743910059332848, 0.05955403670668602, -0.020718997344374657, 0.01697544753551483, -0.002432877430692315, -0.045634061098098755, -0.02885253354907036, 0.013458103872835636, 0.00048732158029451966, 0.008245998993515968, -0.013013207353651524, -0.013657470233738422, -0.045179277658462524, 0.019771356135606766, 0.02207835018634796, -0.024681227281689644, 0.01716417819261551, 0.056501831859350204, -0.07327468693256378, -0.055144745856523514, 0.029236001893877983, 0.03162528946995735, 0.02595827542245388, 0.015849284827709198, 0.005517966579645872, -0.05174638330936432, -0.008061377331614494, 0.014577621594071388, -0.01798376254737377, 0.003997045569121838, 0.010848045349121094, 0.02138487622141838, -0.009025944396853447, 0.023708513006567955, -0.0009962852345779538, -0.03687259182333946, 0.07348484545946121, -0.043523844331502914, 0.06920259445905685, -0.0037140962667763233, -0.0008841087110340595, 0.028678467497229576, -0.0038998981472104788, -0.00891424622386694, 0.013331293128430843, 0.05208780616521835, -0.04121169075369835, -0.030326317995786667, -0.005948164500296116, -0.03291154280304909, -0.03292650729417801, -0.0309431329369545, -0.0062723588198423386, 0.012772466987371445, 0.006990713533014059, -0.04276389628648758, 0.018571509048342705, -0.026418356224894524, 0.0007177028455771506, 0.0206002127379179, 0.020451514050364494, 0.0046224589459598064, 0.005089643876999617, 0.004080303478986025, -0.018619941547513008, 0.036225225776433945, 0.014444062486290932, 0.04286246746778488, -0.008076493628323078, -0.008821985684335232, 0.02386612445116043, 0.0673169493675232, 0.059232790023088455, -0.022865187376737595, 0.06013904884457588, -0.03990595042705536, 0.021254556253552437, 0.025493407621979713, -0.01100981142371893, -0.02342992275953293, 0.03055410273373127, -0.05657210946083069, -0.04440109431743622, 0.019913623109459877, -0.006993480958044529, 0.000548700918443501, 0.0035734358243644238, -0.022876795381307602, -0.016914963722229004, -0.06743306666612625, -0.005737551487982273, 0.05807826668024063, 0.007710185367614031, -0.02644374780356884, -0.010896151885390282, -0.0028548853006213903, -0.018059806898236275, -0.0026651937514543533, -0.02475201152265072, 0.051725879311561584, -0.0038595006335526705, 0.023356933146715164, -0.008308936841785908, 0.013380706310272217, -0.01694539748132229, -0.01857866905629635, 0.05308955907821655, 0.04811418801546097, 0.029643243178725243, -0.025032594799995422, 0.023994948714971542, -0.03955117613077164, -0.03802592307329178, 0.027271693572402, 0.054613690823316574, 0.030793948099017143, -0.059415169060230255, 0.07248935103416443, 0.008195468224585056, 0.004963799379765987, 0.04139524698257446, -0.01253132801502943, 0.04325798153877258, 0.03175739943981171, -0.09114587306976318, -0.031202903017401695, 0.05033236742019653, 0.018202967941761017, -0.023495526984333992, -0.03640211373567581, -0.031404826790094376, 0.05374213680624962, 0.0430392324924469, -0.025130541995167732, 0.05097045749425888, -0.02611847221851349, 0.04247429594397545, 0.010788659565150738, -0.007283700164407492, 0.008590969257056713, -0.07055245339870453, -0.0010587042197585106, -0.01701795868575573, -0.011555624194443226, 0.019695738330483437, 0.03423308581113815, -0.017285775393247604, -0.017740381881594658, 0.021850304678082466, 0.027078701183199883, -0.024429136887192726, -0.03369949012994766, -0.024252312257885933, -0.01411467231810093, 0.05399636924266815, 0.004283636808395386, 0.007972792722284794, -0.03358377516269684, -0.031832773238420486, 0.004652461502701044, 0.02107238583266735, 0.01947200298309326, 0.03369593992829323, -0.08005805313587189, 0.012407943606376648, -0.041437841951847076, -0.0028249933384358883, -0.0061264196410775185, -0.00698948884382844, 0.004894359968602657, -0.035155050456523895, -0.018336549401283264, 0.03788403421640396, 0.01619255356490612, -0.00490264268592, -0.017260754480957985, 0.034493450075387955, -0.06426222622394562, -0.05947273224592209, -0.04505627602338791, 0.006599866785109043, 0.0033936442341655493, -0.004148556850850582, 0.0048567852936685085, 0.0225217342376709, -0.011455131694674492, -0.019323177635669708, -0.0031670881435275078, -0.015225240960717201, -0.00864475592970848, -0.0015206217067316175, -0.0528472363948822, -0.008193349465727806, 0.06759165227413177, 0.018390068784356117, -0.006919814273715019, 0.023557383567094803, -0.07481812685728073, -0.056771498173475266, 0.012699219398200512, -0.03973103687167168, 0.04266825690865517, 0.011350235901772976, 0.03391587734222412, 0.017417816445231438, -0.00725393695756793, 0.01131152268499136, 0.005962214898318052, -0.05392574518918991, 0.015063458122313023, 0.051324065774679184, -0.02030613273382187, 0.03663046285510063, 0.014325041323900223, 0.005979316309094429, -0.008340549655258656, -0.02820207178592682, -0.028117025271058083, -0.06120354309678078, -0.03415247052907944, 0.037132978439331055, -0.012004069983959198, -0.026739640161395073, -0.0018368365708738565, 0.08645370602607727, 0.04037746042013168, -0.007365615107119083, 0.03552298992872238, 0.005032378248870373, -0.011898279190063477, -0.029116475954651833, -0.004726107697933912, -0.001139033236540854, 0.028420928865671158, 0.022633599117398262, -0.0006246931152418256, -0.003034843597561121, 0.03825949877500534, -0.029546603560447693, -0.006835529115051031, 0.019349869340658188, 0.03917643055319786, -0.024386009201407433, -0.01710272766649723, 0.06933838129043579, -0.017110304906964302, -0.011749046854674816, 0.02716103196144104, -0.012598196044564247, -0.004566325340420008, -0.014052581042051315, -0.03639407083392143, 0.03867468237876892, 0.05179480463266373, 0.012527325190603733, 0.03412272408604622, 0.03333436697721481, -0.04241736978292465, -0.002407327527180314, 0.0026713486295193434, -0.024759724736213684, 0.004605503287166357, 0.010071833617985249, 0.007199087180197239, 0.0025664244312793016, -0.016815045848488808, -0.02436886727809906, -0.007751030381768942, -0.02139233984053135, 0.022551557049155235, 0.01113922894001007, -0.008839539252221584, -0.06796199828386307, 0.021007072180509567, -0.007902193814516068, -0.005573784001171589, 0.04480146989226341, 0.032753024250268936, -0.015040830709040165, 0.04270206391811371, 0.0013849412789568305, -0.04558992385864258, -0.003739019390195608, -0.02406989596784115, 0.015038163401186466, -0.015683883801102638, -0.04065489023923874, 0.08507813513278961, 0.010539677925407887, -0.07234244793653488, 0.020633697509765625, -0.028204046189785004, -0.0038922266103327274, -0.018058381974697113, -0.025390153750777245, -0.015112663619220257, 0.014367135241627693, 0.008786596357822418, -0.018372466787695885, 0.04125779867172241, -0.007477873470634222, -0.08928333967924118, -0.07350242137908936, 0.036511246114969254, -0.010096580721437931, 0.019099727272987366, -0.0024009128101170063, -0.030096884816884995, 0.08086218684911728, 0.055706001818180084, 0.02711613103747368, -0.044950224459171295, 0.03547283634543419, -0.03479660674929619, -0.023890387266874313, 0.030453858897089958, 0.012730592861771584, 0.0037600186187773943, 0.04463203623890877, 0.015882888808846474, 0.020770059898495674, 0.03180086240172386, -0.017351876944303513, -0.019721470773220062, 0.059860873967409134, 0.018859602510929108, -0.005373893305659294, 0.041555099189281464, -0.007673679850995541, -0.06309449672698975, -0.056833866983652115, 0.03151186555624008, -0.0019983872771263123, 0.026051944121718407, -0.007219422142952681, 0.03125318884849548, -0.0015001206193119287, -0.006589838303625584, 0.006363094784319401, 0.03901645168662071, 0.010760615579783916, -0.05480881780385971, -0.011841032654047012, 0.019144801422953606, 0.025740038603544235, 0.013583541847765446, 0.08607673645019531, 0.04288257658481598, 0.023920869454741478, -0.03541266545653343, -0.025300417095422745, -0.00968749076128006, -0.03364500775933266, 0.016733568161725998, -0.050992075353860855, -0.029185578227043152, 0.0065078227780759335, 0.00468840729445219, 0.009390223771333694, -0.00926651805639267, -0.026877062395215034, -0.024058854207396507, -0.029436767101287842, 0.01496859360486269, -0.03129753842949867, 0.044097285717725754, -0.00123880454339087, 0.04241116717457771, 0.032415661960840225, -0.0036279577761888504, -0.022126134485006332, 0.03845750540494919, -0.06655796617269516, 0.00546183530241251, -0.010527950711548328, -0.0020485578570514917, -0.008045627735555172, 0.0006424847524613142, 0.020813897252082825, 0.01169933658093214, -0.015928946435451508, -0.011944380588829517, 0.013274536468088627, -0.03624928370118141, 0.010436948388814926, -0.0377056859433651, -0.05676495283842087, 0.02103227563202381, 0.008111432194709778, 0.023264924064278603, -0.005600024946033955, 0.04323391243815422, 0.021817749366164207, -0.002967867534607649, 0.01735318824648857, -0.028828654438257217, 0.03429092466831207, 0.03927213326096535, 0.0264582596719265, 0.004848112817853689, 0.00918082520365715, -0.05262352153658867, 0.020621314644813538, -0.005654623731970787, 0.015018852427601814, 0.03561175987124443, -0.023954376578330994, 0.023565562441945076, -0.06945653259754181, -0.028271682560443878, 0.02145303599536419, -0.014128376729786396, 0.007230375427752733, 0.007563171908259392, 0.045939844101667404, -0.0017130248015746474, -0.03202594071626663, -0.0003633108572103083, 0.047398537397384644, 0.0179204773157835, -0.013611488975584507, -0.02862306870520115, 0.011676312424242496, 0.005678539164364338, -0.0019611052703112364, 0.009148490615189075, 0.031546443700790405, -0.004910843912512064, -0.015920281410217285, 0.06518615782260895, -0.002426146762445569, -0.04471726343035698, 0.03613376244902611, -0.020611140877008438, 0.005899746902287006, -0.0366533100605011, -0.0068711284548044205, 0.032149236649274826, 0.027783123776316643, 0.008200647309422493, -0.020024845376610756, -0.004537691827863455, -0.08049697428941727, -0.03963838517665863, 0.049192287027835846, 0.044161636382341385, -0.006641967222094536, -0.0033385902643203735, -0.00890300702303648, -0.00613004807382822, -0.011316337622702122, -0.012106609530746937, 0.02920086309313774, -0.004412921145558357, 0.0225495845079422, -0.03536054119467735, -0.044217728078365326, -0.056567102670669556, 0.02750697359442711, -0.03597564622759819, 0.026204973459243774, -0.03207538649439812, -0.02324577420949936, -0.025775786489248276, 0.006211009342223406, 0.03744139149785042, 0.05598438158631325, -0.01562430802732706, -0.006008035968989134, 0.014724845066666603, -0.000732655928004533, -0.045114800333976746, -0.07365301996469498, 0.038384005427360535, 0.022934183478355408, 0.004071461968123913, 0.06452543288469315, -0.005162409972399473, -0.021571539342403412, -0.006217505782842636, 0.03554287552833557, 0.0007864810759201646, 0.01636207476258278, -0.023623233661055565, 0.053915344178676605, 0.029394643381237984, 0.04639827087521553, 0.04485860839486122, 0.005967761855572462, -0.02093450538814068, 0.005412767641246319, 0.04039868712425232, -0.012499654665589333, -0.0395873598754406, 0.045778386294841766, -0.05673212558031082, -0.0013209055177867413, -0.056327737867832184, 0.012476195581257343, -0.02938394993543625, 0.04170508310198784, 0.010845668613910675, 0.03190279006958008, -0.020227234810590744, 0.0002750083804130554, 0.0006970469257794321, 0.008899210952222347, -0.01597771793603897, 0.023642145097255707, -0.0012100342428311706, 0.0035108153242617846, 0.0476219579577446, -0.009506596252322197, 0.009678180329501629, -0.005314446985721588, -0.0074905408546328545, 0.001133551704697311, -0.04809480160474777, -0.013000653125345707, -0.019555849954485893, 0.0047965822741389275, 0.1047632098197937, 0.005673618521541357, 0.03452282398939133, 0.0014694923302158713, 0.0025390777736902237, -0.0060722967609763145, 0.02555728144943714, -0.019501248374581337, -0.013925077393651009, 0.004209943115711212, 0.0009450181969441473, 0.031762585043907166, -0.03205244988203049, -0.05409795045852661, -0.03288615494966507, -0.01016431488096714, 0.0004052487784065306, -0.008784562349319458, -0.008240397088229656, 0.005521539598703384, 0.0005433708429336548, 0.00432445527985692, -0.009835029020905495, -0.010468821972608566, -0.010859856382012367, 0.04133874922990799, 0.02398080751299858, -0.019642412662506104, 0.07359546422958374, 0.008193356916308403, -0.02611183375120163, 0.007835390977561474, 0.007487413939088583, -0.016629571095108986, -0.0100388890132308, -0.025944719091057777, -0.044290006160736084, -0.022659899666905403, -0.04031921550631523, 0.004186360631138086, 0.03167347237467766, -0.014287857338786125, 0.012295394204556942, 0.0013765089679509401, -0.00785391591489315, 0.007828962057828903, -0.011762718670070171, 0.000016890706319827586, 0.007626769132912159, -0.015363353304564953, -0.020889848470687866, -0.019717181101441383, 0.00911836139857769, -0.03611937537789345, 0.0005964451702311635, 0.04470716044306755, -0.025911761447787285, 0.025355443358421326, 0.047249939292669296, -0.020138399675488472, -0.05303647369146347, 0.019200997427105904, -0.021537452936172485, 0.05130430683493614, -0.008320227265357971, -0.006632694508880377, 0.001755180419422686, 0.015925271436572075, -0.034722715616226196, -0.026741206645965576, -0.03677671402692795, 0.02121335081756115, 0.059239353984594345, 0.06260278820991516, 0.0468846894800663, 0.024199610576033592, -0.001211899914778769, -0.0019658440724015236, 0.014561966061592102, -0.0039467038586735725, -0.035850439220666885, -0.010981586761772633, 0.006724081933498383, -0.022226860746741295, 0.02044079080224037, 0.03953270986676216, 0.018959807232022285, 0.020806385204195976, 0.06975419819355011, 0.0220062006264925, -0.008187543600797653, 0.08142662048339844, -0.03708115220069885, -0.05239603668451309, 0.02583298273384571, -0.09444404393434525, 0.035292915999889374, -0.03581008315086365, 0.008105076849460602, 0.030256379395723343, 0.023466074839234352, -0.011489727534353733, -0.04856285825371742, -0.028278585523366928, -0.0810270756483078, -0.013123568147420883, -0.007438862230628729, 0.03174736723303795, 0.049284111708402634, -0.004397065378725529, 0.05322268232703209, -0.04002395644783974, 0.0210029948502779, -0.035435549914836884, -0.06499452143907547, -0.029432198032736778, -0.008726979605853558, -0.06148576736450195, 0.016839763149619102, -0.009428733959794044, -0.0008914315258152783, 0.029634574428200722, -0.06263183802366257, -0.005258313845843077, 0.036400437355041504, 0.009358209557831287, -0.016574827954173088, 0.08336159586906433, -0.04343404993414879, 0.044496532529592514, -0.04330212622880936, -0.03464233875274658, 0.1441451758146286, 0.05851897597312927, 0.03162166476249695, -0.03466828912496567, 0.0018660455243662, -0.012199804186820984, 0.0541616789996624, 0.01553321909159422, -0.0018176945159211755, 0.0058564539067447186, 0.0052041285671293736, 0.021012013778090477, 0.041919924318790436, 0.0034418299328535795, -0.025431979447603226, 0.035431426018476486, -0.03387122228741646, 0.00271350028924644, 0.018435431644320488, 0.029693393036723137, -0.0010147953871637583, 0.0023776551242917776, -0.062364812940359116, 0.05270868539810181, -0.0034338675905019045, -0.03939397633075714, 0.009138735011219978, 0.0026316025760024786, -0.005820140242576599, -0.00751930708065629, 0.008574644103646278, 0.0010543898679316044, 0.04307965934276581, -0.04342663288116455, -0.012812416069209576, 0.0225860383361578, 0.03270842880010605, -0.03523603454232216, 0.010806669481098652, 0.05955323949456215, -0.002578513463959098, -0.03876378387212753, 0.002151843858882785, 0.015274634584784508, -0.04501801356673241, -0.03575282543897629, -0.07357724010944366, -0.004295391030609608, 0.0023093647323548794, -0.015948902815580368, -0.024406475946307182, -0.03330950438976288, 0.0027038927655667067, -0.03667311742901802, -0.013766084797680378, 0.02951260656118393, -0.002763299969956279, -0.0037460410967469215, -0.047100234776735306, -0.02150702103972435, 0.0014336125459522009, 0.032854802906513214, 0.004493995103985071, 0.053368788212537766, -0.019073639065027237, -0.061616115272045135, -0.03578907623887062, 0.02050418220460415, 0.021253786981105804, -0.015560731291770935, 0.004816963337361813, 0.009139955043792725, -0.0029665776528418064, -0.0020119058899581432, -0.04264736920595169, -0.005844734143465757, 0.023075494915246964, 0.022488601505756378, 0.0006719222874380648, 0.02984091080725193, -0.05824790149927139, 0.019702795892953873, -0.050377123057842255, -0.0036834110505878925, -0.029115092009305954, -0.00245091924443841, -0.012767537496984005, 0.026529734954237938, 0.04199637472629547, -0.006171935237944126, 0.03239128738641739, 0.08008894324302673, 0.04168584197759628, -0.03633597120642662, -0.024963214993476868, -0.005830773152410984, -0.05713691562414169, -0.03139469400048256, -0.013392333872616291, 0.07641489803791046, 0.02458791807293892, -0.017235899344086647, 0.023180408403277397, -0.014311037957668304, -0.018148334696888924, 0.011606729589402676, 0.00844603218138218, -0.02703600935637951, -0.02639257162809372, 0.012807417660951614, -0.0272188950330019, 0.00326903467066586, -0.02841743268072605, -0.016386469826102257, 0.009509462863206863, -0.011843527667224407, -0.01702578365802765, -0.016787000000476837, 0.003156570252031088, -0.02181350626051426, 0.034274496138095856, 0.008947685360908508, 0.00028568817651830614, 0.006991892587393522, -0.009404825046658516, 0.004642318468540907, 0.03997433930635452, -0.004103254526853561, -0.002210586564615369, 0.0065103741362690926, -0.008453035727143288, 0.0166840311139822, 0.0017211586236953735, -0.0023484232369810343, 0.004505004733800888, 0.017620479688048363, 0.00042380046215839684, -0.0015252927551046014, -0.02619374729692936, -0.01683272235095501, 0.0191109050065279, -0.048510994762182236, 0.03224748745560646, 0.022398170083761215, 0.0033405947033315897, 0.03849543631076813, -0.014517724514007568, -0.022070815786719322, 0.02750287763774395, 0.028651466593146324, -0.02056196890771389, -0.04582584649324417, -0.001711770542897284, -0.0001758717990014702, 0.03189382702112198, 0.015324135310947895, 0.02016315422952175, 0.009242313914000988, -0.0034484341740608215, -0.02003912441432476, 0.017599880695343018, 0.008114301599562168, 0.02287222072482109, -0.004741007462143898, -0.02909606508910656, -0.0003712069883476943, -0.013690276071429253, -0.022010866552591324, 0.0522376224398613, 0.04993157833814621, -0.02781621553003788, 0.05097612366080284, -0.025351285934448242, 0.00175035884603858, -0.05974183231592178, -0.019617820158600807, 0.06883034855127335, -0.001966716255992651, 0.043027009814977646, -0.06114721670746803, -0.0008806651458144188, 0.03563952445983887, -0.05533812940120697, 0.051822539418935776, 0.05442303419113159, 0.01726829633116722, -0.05439385399222374, 0.006985880434513092, -0.020738620311021805, 0.007400243543088436, 0.01803475245833397, 0.03007170371711254, 0.024995118379592896, 0.040498171001672745, -0.0030010854825377464, 0.009466955438256264, 0.005617779679596424, 0.03797636926174164, 0.004099608398973942, -0.051127564162015915, -0.0006511984975077212, -0.018070107325911522, -0.028669914230704308, 0.021084949374198914, -0.03707502409815788, 0.04271118715405464, -0.010705574415624142, 0.03671487048268318, 0.012525509111583233, 0.016224026679992676, 0.011430778540670872, -0.017640994861721992, 0.04806350916624069, -0.0214784387499094, 0.015105905942618847, 0.04879344627261162, -0.0021623040083795786, 0.01920037344098091, 0.03986145183444023, -0.026360103860497475, 0.006346013396978378, -0.015487220138311386, -0.04959306865930557, 0.005299261771142483, 0.0075322482734918594, 0.004776497837156057, 0.04035792872309685, 0.022686263546347618, -0.029874233528971672, -0.006174636073410511, -0.014277681708335876, 0.015379246324300766, 0.00737213809043169, -0.0023779389448463917, -0.00027195291477255523, -0.03329535946249962, -0.052073217928409576, 0.048220694065093994, -0.011383570730686188, -0.015439309179782867, -0.05202425643801689, -0.020895306020975113, 0.0007042661309242249, 0.02607947587966919, 0.011006463319063187, -0.0028504175134003162, -0.010775118134915829, 0.0008840247173793614, -0.015453769825398922, 0.045739077031612396, -0.002129786182194948, -0.004776672925800085, 0.054286468774080276, -0.07547120004892349, 0.05472511053085327, 0.04067247360944748, -0.017145905643701553, -0.011782069690525532, -0.03378748148679733, -0.017193296924233437, -0.03110424429178238, 0.03303062170743942, 0.005751744378358126, -0.022455211728811264, 0.016973979771137238, 0.009983778931200504, -0.016470177099108696, -0.07090797275304794, -0.0006961257895454764, -0.007426154334098101, -0.009758210740983486, 0.041882116347551346, 0.0016828282969072461, 0.006021134555339813, 0.023876303806900978, 0.03253402188420296, -0.02093450538814068, -0.0026115947403013706, 0.0005556901451200247, 0.0065734838135540485, 0.04045125097036362, 0.010788272134959698, -0.041020311415195465, 0.03386461362242699, 0.0025317862164229155, -0.015450590290129185, -0.018974512815475464, -0.040876664221286774, -0.046123355627059937, 0.06503259390592575, -0.0061729843728244305, 0.00931599736213684, 0.031339872628450394, -0.013669515028595924, 0.014409054070711136, -0.035130154341459274, -0.044509224593639374, 0.029452720656991005, 0.014473791234195232, 0.005762543994933367, 0.008892254903912544, 0.008406741544604301, -0.0025086463429033756, 0.003580420045182109, 0.03649669513106346, -0.019574495032429695, -0.05387618765234947, -0.003618838032707572, -0.022015545517206192, 0.029423432424664497, -0.0019754315726459026, 0.048006728291511536, 0.017420748248696327, 0.022953715175390244, 0.0012516452698037028, -0.002216937253251672, 0.03131924569606781, -0.025345195084810257, 0.017074115574359894, 0.004591253586113453, 0.0014784131199121475, -0.023117834702134132, -0.013189592398703098, -0.019110681489109993, 0.049674928188323975, 0.04213080555200577, 0.005715745035558939, -0.0005413313629105687, 0.03563357889652252, -0.029186338186264038, -0.001069229212589562, 0.008844036608934402, 0.01485493779182434, -0.03179129213094711, -0.023262420669198036, 0.005524725653231144, 0.009354248642921448, 0.027554720640182495, -0.013878765515983105, 0.020636793226003647, 0.016751855611801147, 0.018598023802042007, -0.017498191446065903, -0.04068893566727638, 0.023534048348665237, -0.026520956307649612, 0.014600943773984909, 0.01855771616101265, 0.0012122794287279248, -0.0040849051438272, -0.0037845904007554054, 0.020304962992668152, 0.06053297966718674, -0.070834681391716, 0.027021175250411034, -0.07401206344366074, 0.008529962971806526, 0.0404534786939621, -0.017969755455851555 ]
<p>For a linear regression fit for a problem with p variables X_i ranging between 0 and 1, where p>20 (I don't know if that is relevant or not), and the number of samples is about 1000, I wanted to estimate the variance contribution for each of the variables using the regression coefficients. If I understood correctly var(A*X) = A^2*var(X), and therefore I thought that taking the square of the regression coefficients and multiplying that with the variance for each of the variables should give a vector containing all the variance contributions of the different variables. </p> <p>The problem is that I expected the sum of those variance contributions to be equal to the sum of the total regression model variance, but it isn't. The sum of the variances is some times up to 50% larger, then the total variance of the regression model.</p> <p>here some <code>Matlab</code> like pseudo code to explain the problem more in detail. </p> <pre><code>X %sample matrix Y %output sample matrix Linmodel=polyfitn(X,Y) %fit a model for ii=1:nr_colsX VARCONT(ii)=var(Linmodel.COEF(ii)*X(:,ii))) %variance of the contributions VARRC(ii)=(Linmodel.COEF(ii)).^2*var(X(:,ii)) %variance based on Reg. Coef. end SVC=sum(VARCONT(ii)) %sum of the variance contributions SVSRC=sum(VARRC) VY=var(Y) %sum of the variance of the samples VYmod=var(polyvaln(Linmodel,X)) %sum of the variance of the model on the samples XR=rand(100000,nr_colsX) %sum of the variance of the model with large number of samples VYmodR=var(polyvaln(Linmodel,XR)) </code></pre> <p>for one of the models that are supposed to be almost linear, VY is almost equal to VYmod. but SVC is about 50% largen then that. and VYmodR comes more in the direction of SVC. </p> <p>1) Could some body please explain me why the sum of the variance contributions from the Regression coefficients, can be quite a bit larger then the variance of the regression model? </p> <p>2) If this is so as it seems to be the case should there then not be some sort of upper bound for the sum of the square of the regression coefficients, such that the sum of their squares, multiplied by the variances of the input, should not be larger then the total variance of the output? Because it seems strange to me that the output of an interpolation model could result in a larger variance, then the variance of the data output points used for the interpolation. </p> <p>Any help is highly appreciated, but any help that is written in a way, such that also just a silly engineer as me can understand it is appreciated even more. </p>
35,792
[ -0.042907729744911194, 0.03166012465953827, -0.00638597970828414, -0.018422815948724747, 0.04565610736608505, 0.010061719454824924, -0.017116766422986984, -0.02887297421693802, 0.041926026344299316, -0.05039602518081665, 0.061672914773225784, 0.05171538144350052, 0.06722009927034378, 0.012740705162286758, 0.04788439720869064, 0.015884097665548325, 0.004364651162177324, 0.0058563826605677605, 0.012793516740202904, 0.007658709306269884, -0.018975768238306046, 0.029980074614286423, -0.031769465655088425, -0.015843214467167854, -0.02080383710563183, 0.06302022188901901, 0.022453932091593742, -0.02476523444056511, 0.034859154373407364, 0.047007348388433456, -0.02854938432574272, -0.02257451042532921, 0.03253574296832085, 0.013333995826542377, 0.02429293654859066, 0.010616574436426163, 0.01677778922021389, -0.05204296484589577, 0.03252735733985901, 0.04763604328036308, -0.0369260236620903, 0.0023605613969266415, 0.001323582255281508, 0.029448507353663445, 0.004390701651573181, 0.033764008432626724, 0.031362470239400864, -0.01733340509235859, 0.07973325252532959, -0.021014520898461342, 0.0874602422118187, 0.002365688094869256, 0.039799463003873825, 0.00033471008646301925, -0.03644179180264473, -0.0022926158271729946, 0.03573796898126602, 0.019090421497821808, 0.020692413672804832, -0.0373770073056221, 0.01924373209476471, -0.0035991338081657887, -0.003300237702205777, -0.04413412883877754, -0.03489327430725098, -0.001913629937916994, -0.007364855147898197, -0.039274439215660095, 0.02025335282087326, -0.007870800793170929, 0.031823985278606415, 0.022156361490488052, -0.00414614612236619, -0.04116710275411606, -0.007032786961644888, 0.004696073476225138, -0.0066580744460225105, 0.021449796855449677, 0.06186981871724129, -0.010659017600119114, 0.008943453431129456, 0.029430359601974487, 0.021448438987135887, 0.010977866128087044, 0.03303177282214165, -0.0200792346149683, 0.00998582225292921, 0.01295179221779108, 0.0319838672876358, 0.0013311679940670729, -0.0046721938997507095, 0.023437514901161194, 0.06794948875904083, 0.024935252964496613, -0.022008217871189117, 0.010149945504963398, -0.0225649606436491, 0.05310092121362686, 0.02821815386414528, 0.005165532696992159, -0.02737635187804699, -0.027745850384235382, -0.004504554904997349, 0.013317374512553215, -0.01397507544606924, -0.03516685962677002, 0.012386617250740528, 0.004810384940356016, 0.001702062669210136, -0.04479511082172394, -0.01343551930040121, 0.016970036551356316, -0.017604995518922806, 0.009612263180315495, 0.00015147206431720406, -0.0231393501162529, 0.012920529581606388, -0.011886052787303925, 0.010547525249421597, 0.07113425433635712, -0.003536504926159978, -0.021091312170028687, 0.010880121961236, -0.031320590525865555, -0.037899985909461975, 0.027393929660320282, 0.010393280535936356, -0.010732551105320454, -0.05201294273138046, 0.029301464557647705, 0.015392282977700233, -0.0527542345225811, 0.011501221917569637, 0.008116314187645912, 0.009498072788119316, -0.041223470121622086, -0.08481797575950623, -0.07215795665979385, 0.014533951878547668, -0.032874856144189835, 0.022168753668665886, -0.02881142869591713, 0.00941796600818634, 0.023922763764858246, 0.08060994744300842, 0.008263952098786831, 0.0768570527434349, 0.0084046870470047, -0.02719251811504364, -0.009655590169131756, -0.05561636760830879, -0.036557652056217194, -0.019388094544410706, 0.0013869998510926962, 0.002670576795935631, -0.07455386966466904, 0.010501768440008163, -0.013497368432581425, -0.020383192226290703, 0.03742152824997902, -0.023875299841165543, 0.03437820449471474, -0.022302579134702682, -0.012753741815686226, -0.0139053575694561, -0.028818629682064056, 0.0838172510266304, 0.008219336159527302, 0.05288020893931389, 0.021165866404771805, -0.056177202612161636, -0.003066085511818528, 0.0028389717917889357, 0.032185424119234085, 0.03487992286682129, 0.006570660043507814, 0.003850961336866021, -0.008498124778270721, 0.027729734778404236, 0.053568035364151, -0.04845559224486351, -0.05756266042590141, 0.03166145831346512, 0.01630435883998871, 0.031155621632933617, 0.06674203276634216, -0.0055716815404593945, -0.004452510736882687, 0.03825882822275162, -0.02412623167037964, -0.05050385743379593, -0.04348798468708992, -0.005357325542718172, -0.020596696063876152, -0.06463565677404404, -0.01851486600935459, 0.01571454480290413, 0.02906421385705471, 0.048627596348524094, -0.03369797393679619, -0.034296732395887375, -0.002093950053676963, 0.05526159331202507, -0.01865764707326889, -0.0053955623880028725, 0.018962804228067398, 0.05336986854672432, -0.022133836522698402, 0.059520043432712555, -0.025712689384818077, -0.03169824928045273, 0.012063281610608101, -0.03480339050292969, 0.009224002249538898, 0.014460088685154915, -0.06231500953435898, 0.0173475481569767, 0.015443818643689156, -0.021281648427248, 0.030951587483286858, -0.012354078702628613, 0.028997110202908516, 0.06755518913269043, 0.018066754564642906, -0.031443510204553604, 0.03916418179869652, -0.008797215297818184, -0.010362761095166206, -0.043110720813274384, -0.01254491787403822, -0.0050068083219230175, -0.0031250149477273226, 0.03282351419329643, 0.05913352593779564, -0.029860710725188255, -0.029514947906136513, 0.058542970567941666, 0.02596696838736534, 0.02409219928085804, 0.026569517329335213, 0.0013642656849697232, -0.023613886907696724, 0.02481534332036972, -0.014230159111320972, 0.03994710370898247, 0.005442534573376179, -0.028630517423152924, 0.026156354695558548, 0.02931072749197483, 0.01112433709204197, -0.023134075105190277, 0.02458869107067585, 0.004395259078592062, -0.022832417860627174, -0.02098969928920269, 0.00025517871836200356, 0.0014408595161512494, 0.025996778160333633, 0.0025082577485591173, 0.027850082144141197, -0.0020354632288217545, 0.0005619957228191197, -0.029043374583125114, -0.03911276534199715, 0.006970504764467478, 0.011144737713038921, -0.05253206938505173, 0.006255673710256815, 0.007488570176064968, -0.03904908522963524, 0.009002253413200378, -0.015549355186522007, -0.013558443635702133, -0.06448747962713242, 0.030528929084539413, 0.026915283873677254, 0.01060928963124752, 0.004960685037076473, -0.01344545092433691, -0.017120596021413803, -0.035152699798345566, 0.005335528869181871, 0.01348146889358759, -0.008368417620658875, -0.04046662896871567, 0.025698712095618248, 0.005541507620364428, -0.031063979491591454, 0.03466174006462097, 0.021261068060994148, -0.02122868038713932, 0.024716539308428764, -0.01414826512336731, -0.0758909285068512, -0.02180413343012333, -0.03621140867471695, -0.02395261824131012, -0.025316713377833366, -0.01813034527003765, -0.009459896944463253, 0.04166122525930405, -0.04448480159044266, 0.050247132778167725, -0.03527258336544037, -0.016262898221611977, -0.03386930376291275, -0.01417226530611515, -0.011944882571697235, 0.016614597290754318, 0.02275119163095951, 0.015608293935656548, -0.01469432283192873, -0.0315072238445282, -0.05550480633974075, -0.038382042199373245, -0.014505581930279732, 0.011347540654242039, 0.014741374179720879, -0.013543518260121346, -0.007083723787218332, 0.05615446716547012, 0.014937706291675568, -0.0008042351109907031, -0.04554889351129532, 0.01896175742149353, -0.012069237418472767, -0.021467454731464386, 0.04714697599411011, 0.000394138740375638, 0.01242047268897295, 0.05212453380227089, -0.048652391880750656, 0.01414836198091507, 0.05311162769794464, -0.041346628218889236, 0.03701893612742424, 0.01932394877076149, -0.008376589976251125, -0.023267172276973724, 0.05455359071493149, 0.0309956856071949, 0.005619850941002369, 0.01847861334681511, -0.030126430094242096, -0.009473600424826145, 0.0028483422938734293, -0.02626361884176731, -0.0070218853652477264, -0.006333133205771446, 0.021580098196864128, -0.04504673182964325, 0.01722935400903225, 0.014342210255563259, -0.04112851619720459, -0.002051055897027254, -0.0007058329065330327, 0.027750471606850624, -0.005231023300439119, -0.009722201153635979, 0.04227834194898605, 0.030834106728434563, 0.006105959415435791, 0.01983763836324215, -0.028826171532273293, -0.0010549182770773768, -0.005681016482412815, -0.02570885233581066, -0.01411486603319645, 0.0723472610116005, 0.05636681988835335, -0.004512985702604055, -0.016879050061106682, -0.046246934682130814, 0.0016542678931728005, -0.027127157896757126, -0.01044004037976265, -0.051103003323078156, 0.07313733547925949, -0.0023714748676866293, 0.033101245760917664, 0.005418454762548208, 0.01572054624557495, 0.0257929265499115, -0.036272212862968445, -0.06056147441267967, 0.03947945684194565, 0.04288005456328392, -0.029324404895305634, -0.015056679956614971, -0.009001564234495163, 0.02941671945154667, -0.01600697636604309, 0.03430637717247009, 0.016673026606440544, -0.010929754003882408, -0.025834638625383377, 0.03476694971323013, 0.006048260722309351, 0.005215811543166637, -0.017374705523252487, 0.016139661893248558, -0.006182800978422165, -0.025109214708209038, -0.004934822674840689, 0.008362538181245327, -0.015989454463124275, 0.000895584118552506, -0.054359279572963715, 0.005507833324372768, 0.021832965314388275, 0.04126619175076485, 0.018692733719944954, 0.052456267178058624, -0.05403677746653557, 0.032029371708631516, 0.009329872205853462, 0.053983237594366074, 0.060842156410217285, 0.020021874457597733, 0.016509108245372772, -0.03368575498461723, -0.01259669754654169, 0.013073121197521687, -0.015776993706822395, 0.007739714812487364, 0.009230443276464939, 0.027069060131907463, 0.03807666525244713, -0.022552739828824997, -0.0026294738054275513, 0.03153865039348602, 0.027711492031812668, 0.003006420098245144, -0.008219577372074127, 0.025522425770759583, 0.00761739257723093, 0.011288597248494625, -0.013177677057683468, -0.0038270370569080114, 0.004242378287017345, -0.02565169893205166, 0.053450196981430054, -0.048007506877183914, -0.0029497984796762466, 0.004339860286563635, 0.04374578595161438, 0.06029026582837105, 0.0034701768308877945, -0.044281598180532455, -0.007167424540966749, 0.029372965916991234, 0.026278609409928322, 0.05708038806915283, -0.006740342825651169, -0.06511057913303375, -0.039791353046894073, 0.023950617760419846, 0.04406590014696121, -0.04982778802514076, -0.018126806244254112, -0.0001405745279043913, -0.05495123192667961, 0.033576980233192444, -0.019930951297283173, -0.0013797961873933673, -0.01382529828697443, 0.06614401191473007, -0.034454796463251114, -0.04360013082623482, -0.0773189440369606, 0.007779386825859547, -0.05139172822237015, 0.035564593970775604, -0.06683076173067093, -0.045646823942661285, -0.04325950890779495, 0.033323101699352264, 0.01981482468545437, 0.035304583609104156, -0.06014179065823555, -0.007305341772735119, 0.0424240306019783, 0.04849981144070625, -0.02098940685391426, -0.058147549629211426, 0.029186150059103966, 0.01633264124393463, -0.04569806158542633, 0.04947017505764961, -0.02444549649953842, -0.047657184302806854, 0.04022201895713806, 0.0023859639186412096, -0.012301401235163212, 0.006417716853320599, -0.013111175037920475, 0.03927326202392578, 0.029896851629018784, -0.0021471327636390924, 0.06484101712703705, 0.020514944568276405, -0.002095667878165841, 0.007341078016906977, -0.03975199535489082, -0.014961413107812405, -0.012116976082324982, -0.06395751982927322, -0.04730575531721115, -0.0232035331428051, 0.013108908198773861, 0.022704483941197395, 0.011337490752339363, 0.03580937162041664, -0.03280866518616676, 0.030005576089024544, 0.016290701925754547, 0.05231895670294762, 0.01868165098130703, -0.027461279183626175, -0.012440874241292477, 0.042628321796655655, 0.03669806569814682, -0.03695639222860336, 0.019749708473682404, 0.01898937299847603, -0.014570617116987705, 0.022827254608273506, -0.008151198737323284, -0.029342947527766228, -0.021375536918640137, 0.0047121839597821236, -0.029458332806825638, -0.03039756417274475, 0.0029184287413954735, -0.019490446895360947, 0.045903608202934265, 0.0014431205345317721, -0.013562027364969254, -0.006369193084537983, 0.03074016608297825, -0.03142356500029564, -0.015072686597704887, -0.05961662903428078, 0.0012543877819553018, -0.020010637119412422, 0.01187928207218647, -0.042154375463724136, -0.05744538456201553, 0.01968083158135414, -0.013211850076913834, -0.03378590941429138, -0.025994308292865753, -0.05345749109983444, -0.0048792134039103985, -0.02136213891208172, 0.004789553117007017, 0.030657842755317688, -0.043647535145282745, 0.019212964922189713, -0.022288337349891663, 0.01188774686306715, 0.04588421434164047, -0.036711834371089935, 0.0040679569356143475, 0.03849916532635689, -0.025415100157260895, -0.03459402173757553, 0.05137265473604202, -0.02112491801381111, -0.03575953096151352, 0.017556404694914818, -0.0025627627037465572, -0.03476826101541519, 0.05573330074548721, 0.023071009665727615, -0.009563935920596123, 0.007421809248626232, -0.02839735895395279, 0.008395865559577942, -0.02906131185591221, -0.00849055778235197, 0.014838933013379574, 0.01929931528866291, -0.008453558199107647, -0.011991231702268124, -0.0240462739020586, 0.006997846066951752, 0.009064444340765476, 0.023919621482491493, -0.000035560955438995734, -0.002115709939971566, 0.07978092133998871, -0.02154511958360672, 0.015141671523451805, -0.009202199056744576, -0.006565541960299015, 0.01893448643386364, 0.0468161478638649, 0.008988780900835991, 0.013557362370193005, 0.0486946702003479, 0.0008275905274786055, -0.030839692801237106, -0.054624710232019424, 0.004306900314986706, 0.07414567470550537, -0.041193924844264984, 0.03490738943219185, 0.04840115085244179, 0.00754066975787282, 0.008146723732352257, -0.03082512505352497, -0.043326158076524734, 0.023084374144673347, 0.0027196379378437996, 0.05183883011341095, -0.010107133537530899, -0.03436804935336113, 0.06666707247495651, 0.01826830767095089, 0.008513692766427994, 0.04687991365790367, -0.01859648898243904, 0.01016568299382925, -0.007386843673884869, -0.016316404566168785, -0.04924861341714859, 0.009948894381523132, -0.03022903762757778, 0.03478448465466499, -0.025340838357806206, -0.02607082761824131, 0.03716570511460304, 0.05506283789873123, 0.016087107360363007, -0.04853517562150955, -0.040419284254312515, -0.03846130892634392, -0.027048880234360695, 0.00642950925976038, -0.008802383206784725, 0.019876699894666672, -0.005708863493055105, 0.03860685974359512, 0.012700199149549007, 0.04494689777493477, -0.08835310488939285, -0.0659705400466919, -0.028954343870282173, -0.004597929306328297, -0.023144135251641273, 0.013682419434189796, -0.012525759637355804, -0.039102546870708466, 0.030927268788218498, -0.03921811655163765, 0.027828030288219452, -0.01543179526925087, 0.03505111113190651, 0.011561651714146137, 0.022798852995038033, -0.012662594206631184, 0.03431576490402222, -0.018418213352560997, 0.035067662596702576, 0.140260249376297, 0.05716874450445175, 0.0009276719065383077, -0.01383785530924797, 0.00934872031211853, -0.007523530162870884, -0.025683114305138588, -0.0002852425095625222, -0.020725229755043983, -0.007918954826891422, 0.008844861760735512, 0.0667322427034378, 0.025415576994419098, 0.008597370237112045, -0.0003083301708102226, -0.01079213060438633, -0.0386844277381897, -0.028155891224741936, 0.011621699668467045, 0.034295689314603806, 0.007079587783664465, -0.04239204525947571, -0.047701187431812286, 0.009706065058708191, -0.025875722989439964, -0.0019648210145533085, -0.06289452314376831, 0.04444048926234245, -0.022276870906352997, 0.01875203102827072, -0.025430213660001755, 0.04684644937515259, 0.001366201089695096, -0.007199919782578945, -0.012159815989434719, 0.015767669305205345, 0.053712230175733566, -0.0146831925958395, -0.00927785411477089, 0.01504784356802702, -0.00688729714602232, 0.003920429851859808, -0.025547383353114128, 0.0063787056133151054, -0.035136960446834564, -0.0048383669927716255, -0.038321353495121, 0.05309715121984482, 0.01751563884317875, -0.01502691488713026, -0.009517750702798367, 0.017969070002436638, 0.007733888924121857, -0.04009512811899185, 0.014366677030920982, 0.00232091941870749, 0.0037833855021744967, -0.006292089819908142, -0.021826423704624176, -0.0113782724365592, 0.001753348857164383, 0.007064126897603273, 0.00013980276708025485, 0.03356144577264786, -0.05727789178490639, -0.009687399491667747, -0.03378290310502052, 0.05618952214717865, -0.021686803549528122, 0.013128931634128094, 0.03475325554609299, -0.02952447161078453, 0.0031295286025851965, -0.019507549703121185, 0.009773864410817623, -0.016677355393767357, 0.06223028525710106, -0.05180150270462036, -0.009859766811132431, -0.025343937799334526, -0.06427110731601715, -0.004397300537675619, -0.022535163909196854, -0.015594376251101494, -0.05927750840783119, 0.002383016049861908, 0.02733071893453598, 0.012334123253822327, 0.02133350633084774, 0.005869572050869465, 0.0007032258436083794, 0.04921165853738785, -0.004558734130114317, -0.027649765834212303, -0.028531121090054512, -0.005669672507792711, -0.004030982032418251, 0.029887672513723373, 0.00916734617203474, 0.046270404011011124, 0.06977926939725876, 0.025387175381183624, -0.02454197220504284, 0.03721897676587105, -0.016650749370455742, 0.0032133664935827255, 0.026294158771634102, -0.04213964566588402, 0.019852517172694206, -0.0031710246112197638, 0.007785039488226175, -0.05016472935676575, 0.037767574191093445, -0.0546792671084404, -0.07814983278512955, 0.01697978749871254, 0.006297354586422443, -0.024915266782045364, 0.030215676873922348, -0.03586000204086304, 0.026920972391963005, -0.04246138036251068, 0.0014970868360251188, -0.001858557341620326, 0.02165357582271099, -0.02009160816669464, 0.0016254016663879156, -0.043440476059913635, 0.033910151571035385, -0.04407567158341408, 0.013624874874949455, 0.03993343561887741, 0.03264661133289337, 0.03801023215055466, -0.011561891064047813, -0.003040198003873229, 0.007444124203175306, 0.048417869955301285, -0.015885619446635246, -0.013319369405508041, 0.05289937183260918, -0.029000768437981606, -0.059946976602077484, 0.01182282343506813, -0.004898248706012964, 0.04473680630326271, 0.039620786905288696, 0.005439567379653454, -0.035470619797706604, 0.0332004651427269, -0.021231014281511307, 0.017317969352006912, -0.01281388197094202, 0.01804541051387787, 0.03693288564682007, -0.014816531911492348, 0.041063092648983, 0.0005234426353126764, -0.006455652881413698, 0.025466598570346832, 0.05321107059717178, -0.04211089760065079, -0.005053315777331591, 0.007230802904814482, -0.04039887711405754, -0.01610361784696579, 0.013511797413229942, 0.012274724431335926, 0.017760999500751495, 0.0549355074763298, -0.044354286044836044, 0.003243526443839073, -0.0077691758051514626, 0.022560706362128258, -0.0768236517906189, -0.03567809611558914, -0.0448017343878746, 0.009749170392751694, 0.024085206910967827, -0.05222051590681076, -0.005999496206641197, 0.03587507829070091, -0.07645219564437866, -0.029577258974313736, -0.03029942698776722, 0.019112827256321907, -0.033748552203178406, 0.021763885393738747, -0.047989148646593094, 0.011116288602352142, 0.018562374636530876, 0.00955287553369999, 0.03495809808373451, 0.04500557482242584, 0.024016553536057472, -0.05563006177544594, -0.03752731904387474, -0.005530619062483311, -0.013129083439707756, -0.04549015685915947, 0.02585187926888466, -0.014626520685851574, -0.01265171729028225, 0.025424961000680923, -0.04242817312479019, 0.028660990297794342, 0.02574605867266655, 0.03350018337368965, 0.01663867011666298, 0.046453267335891724, -0.0015354461502283812, 0.008027217350900173, 0.017743531614542007, -0.005509866867214441, 0.01349224615842104, -0.0036027124151587486, -0.014183536171913147, 0.021120069548487663, 0.03078552708029747, -0.014704558067023754, 0.004808455239981413, 0.009765533730387688, 0.0012748971348628402, 0.004898999352008104, 0.008467712439596653, 0.012523929588496685, -0.03382659703493118, -0.049191564321517944, 0.0063325949013233185, -0.03327808529138565, -0.041153911501169205, 0.02800331450998783, 0.05402376875281334, -0.016534943133592606, -0.008640841580927372, 0.004215172026306391, -0.012914135120809078, 0.026430990546941757, 0.010236957110464573, -0.024985672906041145, -0.046634793281555176, -0.011914946138858795, 0.015523510985076427, -0.03680426627397537, 0.014664829708635807, -0.0034557741601020098, -0.03178538754582405, 0.03521386533975601, -0.007390715181827545, -0.019101660698652267, 0.009095322340726852, -0.016248565167188644, 0.04886694625020027, -0.0916375145316124, 0.05513107031583786, -0.00439766701310873, -0.022049080580472946, -0.03582221642136574, 0.02775566652417183, -0.022877709940075874, 0.035351935774087906, 0.02306060865521431, 0.002820750931277871, 0.011223774403333664, 0.027266493067145348, 0.01352060679346323, 0.020544761791825294, -0.05577488988637924, 0.06526857614517212, -0.016491128131747246, 0.012181112542748451, 0.0072839888744056225, -0.007612770888954401, 0.02581055276095867, -0.0016073082806542516, 0.04240879788994789, -0.01730404421687126, 0.012927215546369553, -0.0015139331808313727, -0.012730125337839127, 0.022126540541648865, 0.014989263378083706, -0.004586090799421072, 0.031754933297634125, -0.012592446990311146, 0.00257378863170743, 0.05804896727204323, 0.012691114097833633, -0.04798585921525955, -0.032374925911426544, -0.02344173938035965, -0.004605869762599468, 0.04305577278137207, 0.02061212994158268, 0.02303553745150566, -0.032245341688394547, 0.004598984494805336, 0.02771514467895031, -0.0418337807059288, -0.02898428961634636, 0.0590219721198082, 0.013631848618388176, 0.030335446819663048, -0.004929857328534126, 0.01079148892313242, 0.004394603427499533, -0.021905161440372467, -0.014907374046742916, -0.000020510753529379144, 0.05472191050648689, -0.0013188035227358341, -0.011733781546354294, 0.051994066685438156, -0.044341810047626495, 0.049836426973342896, -0.0036422614939510822, 0.013862710446119308, -0.036800697445869446, -0.005408585537225008, 0.015060149133205414, -0.020363787189126015, 0.013672507368028164, -0.010270925238728523, -0.0013473695144057274, 0.06684219837188721, -0.05570916831493378, -0.006306739989668131, 0.003952507395297289, 0.00006054408731870353, 0.001317867310717702, -0.009302402846515179, -0.04646023362874985, 0.030061546713113785, 0.0002461405238136649, -0.002647282090038061, -0.025237811729311943, -0.01117472629994154, 0.04459758847951889, -0.01683664880692959, 0.016093719750642776, -0.011682291515171528, 0.03529534488916397, -0.002127979649230838, -0.025667686015367508, -0.013715769164264202, 0.0017262804321944714, 0.05016763508319855, 0.00974255707114935, 0.01064080186188221, -0.0399976447224617, -0.01967504806816578, 0.00946676917374134, 0.03228548914194107, -0.04886842519044876, 0.012742944061756134, -0.007424087729305029, 0.01090362761169672, -0.01922488957643509, -0.012683942914009094 ]
<p>The <code>chisq.test</code> function in R includes a <code>y =</code> argument, which is to <code>NULL</code> by default. The help page doesn't explain what this argument does, and playing round with numbers doesn't give any clues, for example all these give exactly same results:</p> <pre><code>chisq.test(x=c(20, 10, 5, 3, 2, 1, 0), y = 100:106) chisq.test(x=c(20, 10, 5, 3, 2, 1, 0), y = 0:6) chisq.test(x=c(20, 10, 5, 3, 2, 1, 0), y = 5:11) </code></pre>
18,145
[ -0.041870683431625366, -0.02495325729250908, -0.006577434483915567, -0.03831271827220917, 0.044896215200424194, 0.015201838687062263, -0.0182765144854784, -0.03133232519030571, -0.01941770128905773, -0.02324184961616993, 0.04069983959197998, 0.0697670578956604, 0.023822098970413208, 0.015771595761179924, 0.027127781882882118, 0.030955571681261063, -0.020492225885391235, 0.025493429973721504, -0.009310009889304638, 0.03212575986981392, 0.007482367567718029, 0.01063611451536417, 0.01232216227799654, -0.010291720740497112, -0.006901600398123264, 0.02428273856639862, 0.022110551595687866, -0.014238524250686169, 0.011303458362817764, 0.07489054650068283, -0.058118391782045364, -0.037439510226249695, 0.0013763114111497998, 0.01139204390347004, 0.0035711301025003195, 0.006267067510634661, 0.026486944407224655, -0.027475228533148766, -0.022908879444003105, 0.04698596149682999, -0.02634693868458271, 0.022367997094988823, 0.008656719699501991, 0.03951184079051018, -0.015769103541970253, 0.03610815107822418, 0.0013065459206700325, -0.008210448548197746, 0.014672032557427883, -0.019527876749634743, 0.06532313674688339, -0.018674597144126892, 0.015216025523841381, 0.001509754452854395, 0.002949340268969536, -0.011006231419742107, 0.050810448825359344, 0.02683255635201931, -0.039182424545288086, -0.09473089873790741, -0.018431812524795532, -0.05995028093457222, 0.0004948629066348076, -0.015520259737968445, -0.017012955620884895, 0.014146166853606701, 0.016925709322094917, -0.019976286217570305, 0.004611784126609564, -0.04259556904435158, 0.007159483153373003, 0.05015934631228447, 0.009639252908527851, -0.02563573233783245, 0.03663915395736694, -0.042718417942523956, 0.026997027918696404, -0.017165983095765114, 0.012026628479361534, 0.0483432412147522, 0.009592128917574883, 0.039033886045217514, 0.03319285064935684, 0.002411027206107974, 0.023099593818187714, 0.00043083017226308584, 0.037398576736450195, -0.01125847827643156, 0.015844091773033142, 0.003195680445060134, -0.007445488125085831, 0.014554940164089203, 0.03183620050549507, 0.034462250769138336, -0.035968516021966934, 0.04871957749128342, -0.027891865000128746, 0.05448342114686966, 0.012424089014530182, -0.013955419883131981, -0.006972919218242168, -0.025774294510483742, 0.051877379417419434, 0.0570688396692276, -0.06145639717578888, -0.00818447396159172, 0.01396673172712326, -0.0005790825234726071, -0.016062434762716293, -0.0075025553815066814, -0.01893932744860649, 0.021999651566147804, -0.02343502826988697, 0.03941604867577553, 0.036465972661972046, -0.026280468329787254, -0.028678296133875847, 0.014267217367887497, 0.05450066924095154, 0.019448138773441315, 0.03606859967112541, -0.02245897427201271, 0.009222430177032948, -0.036302193999290466, -0.009684852324426174, -0.00650010397657752, -0.030321616679430008, 0.01383920107036829, -0.048914823681116104, 0.031314149498939514, -0.03294168412685394, -0.028841903433203697, 0.039711616933345795, -0.003846337553113699, 0.05628340691328049, -0.027324143797159195, -0.08254837989807129, -0.06648406386375427, 0.01508688647300005, -0.031334150582551956, -0.031032493337988853, -0.08481554687023163, 0.0067771789617836475, 0.007364721968770027, 0.07132750749588013, -0.004462595097720623, 0.012448413297533989, -0.003272606059908867, -0.017094505950808525, 0.015923738479614258, -0.012147468514740467, -0.023376643657684326, -0.03135997802019119, -0.02611386962234974, 0.019197184592485428, -0.04588262364268303, 0.02789139561355114, -0.006080519873648882, -0.012954536825418472, -0.05328957363963127, 0.007738454267382622, -0.02656957507133484, 0.020224204286932945, -0.014977517537772655, -0.022207429632544518, -0.052291903644800186, 0.06504855304956436, 0.04681970179080963, -0.033213380724191666, 0.04324881359934807, -0.018454084172844887, 0.016071796417236328, -0.006183636374771595, 0.04442382603883743, 0.028504135087132454, -0.009588000364601612, -0.008593250997364521, -0.018474239856004715, 0.03351695463061333, 0.003337845206260681, -0.06029704958200455, -0.025683362036943436, -0.0010612164624035358, -0.012010828591883183, 0.013550502248108387, 0.014436827041208744, -0.002052947646006942, 0.006357062142342329, 0.07407533377408981, -0.07243984937667847, -0.03016000986099243, -0.05606299266219139, -0.01442764326930046, 0.007376837078481913, -0.007973939180374146, -0.014000277034938335, 0.027394132688641548, 0.013608582317829132, 0.012494748458266258, -0.0052565401419997215, -0.01771041937172413, 0.002767092315480113, 0.05493929237127304, -0.019330738112330437, -0.028589976951479912, 0.03938467800617218, 0.0350339375436306, -0.02379409782588482, 0.04427040368318558, -0.022809801623225212, -0.012579398229718208, 0.004997276235371828, -0.01086975447833538, 0.039068251848220825, 0.005952519364655018, -0.01270154770463705, 0.032627277076244354, 0.016094785183668137, -0.023464065045118332, 0.04581071436405182, -0.07635033130645752, 0.03913996368646622, 0.04440658912062645, 0.026423674076795578, -0.01491139829158783, -0.011145509779453278, 0.004826772026717663, 0.05212688446044922, -0.004499371163547039, 0.05440361797809601, -0.05538233369588852, -0.0341082438826561, 0.029547324404120445, -0.005355756729841232, -0.03795357793569565, -0.007446765899658203, 0.013440639711916447, 0.007761286571621895, -0.04421374201774597, 0.03801450505852699, 0.0013581948587670922, -0.022052956745028496, 0.014186582528054714, -0.0037561662029474974, 0.02172992192208767, 0.04750851169228554, 0.07094620913267136, -0.0019284714944660664, 0.023616040125489235, 0.023671254515647888, -0.0277313981205225, 0.045360177755355835, -0.02335958182811737, 0.007647411432117224, 0.001781544997356832, -0.04226695001125336, 0.02446306310594082, -0.004130112938582897, -0.00380130996927619, 0.017011813819408417, 0.012942423112690449, -0.016338136047124863, -0.01756138727068901, -0.007389361038804054, 0.0020105289295315742, 0.017893165349960327, -0.033837851136922836, 0.03659360483288765, 0.018961289897561073, -0.019505059346556664, 0.007765882648527622, -0.017737938091158867, 0.006658098194748163, -0.07852132618427277, 0.0037272556219249964, 0.0529903769493103, 0.035677555948495865, 0.025460345670580864, -0.046922195702791214, -0.06609443575143814, -0.022100530564785004, -0.03106318600475788, 0.037209030240774155, 0.007107642944902182, -0.003955522086471319, 0.00866782944649458, -0.027029208838939667, -0.0071419100277125835, 0.010228365659713745, -0.015138846822082996, -0.031480010598897934, 0.02446575090289116, -0.021064646542072296, -0.001043882337398827, -0.012414827011525631, -0.0361967571079731, 0.016892073675990105, -0.028850499540567398, 0.023788800463080406, 0.06274300813674927, -0.003449523588642478, -0.07351106405258179, 0.05470047518610954, -0.07609578222036362, 0.007812677882611752, -0.03197011351585388, -0.018399549648165703, 0.006291973404586315, -0.000594250624999404, 0.012056373059749603, 0.03247341141104698, -0.03495443984866142, 0.019571755081415176, -0.04587789252400398, -0.041792936623096466, -0.013340613804757595, -0.016400625929236412, -0.011491742916405201, 0.009981129318475723, 0.02247260883450508, 0.066656194627285, 0.032540399581193924, 0.011154192499816418, -0.06314882636070251, 0.030543843284249306, -0.03994808346033096, 0.012472957372665405, 0.03875581547617912, 0.05560939759016037, 0.011398264206945896, 0.014559724368155003, -0.0022396009881049395, 0.07465758174657822, 0.06481959670782089, -0.0032287747599184513, 0.00859401561319828, -0.01779630221426487, -0.000009721036803966854, -0.023528728634119034, 0.02338487096130848, -0.016133517026901245, -0.020638855174183846, 0.018321029841899872, -0.024472396820783615, 0.01872946135699749, -0.04020756855607033, -0.0177536029368639, 0.014642585068941116, -0.006229889113456011, 0.037790168076753616, -0.002269471064209938, 0.07800880819559097, -0.0038437936455011368, -0.024465646594762802, 0.0015201009809970856, -0.004392274189740419, 0.06353408843278885, -0.025167634710669518, -0.0336497463285923, 0.009086760692298412, -0.0031937884632498026, -0.05488809943199158, 0.029325682669878006, 0.003384559415280819, -0.012492609210312366, 0.029074927791953087, -0.05612586811184883, -0.009200990200042725, 0.04640813171863556, 0.04899044707417488, 0.02976185828447342, 0.035724300891160965, -0.06429272145032883, 0.03844304382801056, -0.05034731328487396, -0.0016370299272239208, -0.02613418735563755, 0.02508385293185711, 0.05847715213894844, 0.038469210267066956, 0.030418740585446358, -0.004696650896221399, -0.03318482264876366, -0.024760805070400238, -0.07105149328708649, -0.0018360737012699246, 0.010593567974865437, -0.015115522779524326, -0.023176586255431175, -0.006887251511216164, 0.026484359055757523, -0.000806710624601692, 0.03203940764069557, -0.0014025879791006446, -0.011443518102169037, -0.04122000187635422, 0.020102273672819138, 0.027318164706230164, 0.016712576150894165, 0.0015288711292669177, 0.01832132413983345, 0.03829551115632057, -0.01832856610417366, -0.008883358910679817, 0.007619563024491072, -0.005521534476429224, -0.010487178340554237, 0.0035021654330193996, -0.006405222695320845, 0.010857741348445415, 0.00782036129385233, 0.002104808809235692, 0.04003676399588585, -0.04711295664310455, -0.00921517051756382, -0.00007074409950291738, 0.042291611433029175, 0.07275456190109253, -0.01367105171084404, 0.013098550960421562, -0.0245948676019907, 0.02824835479259491, -0.007824714295566082, 0.008158565498888493, 0.011185606941580772, 0.01604410633444786, 0.06917212903499603, 0.06296941637992859, 0.012469423934817314, 0.016629306599497795, 0.06897677481174469, 0.05299512669444084, -0.0062463292852044106, -0.010213986970484257, 0.008516205474734306, -0.033270303159952164, 0.031849879771471024, -0.005423485767096281, 0.009646870195865631, -0.0021830738987773657, 0.029532447457313538, -0.0020718437153846025, -0.041337303817272186, 0.0006231229053810239, -0.0382530502974987, 0.035872507840394974, 0.04858161881566048, -0.007869420573115349, -0.005545136984437704, 0.015596818178892136, 0.0370057076215744, 0.01639311946928501, 0.03830926865339279, -0.052834849804639816, -0.05973280593752861, -0.01101566944271326, 0.04222136735916138, 0.03268473967909813, -0.027971042320132256, -0.005679712630808353, -0.042899757623672485, 0.007515269797295332, -0.004198163747787476, -0.04738140478730202, 0.03148653358221054, -0.04188353195786476, 0.02082659676671028, -0.028844159096479416, 0.017096543684601784, -0.02525698021054268, 0.037345632910728455, -0.027410557493567467, 0.01801910623908043, -0.0355113223195076, -0.059663619846105576, -0.07972222566604614, 0.02314731664955616, -0.029034897685050964, 0.038218509405851364, -0.07361678034067154, -0.006952994037419558, 0.0061507332138717175, 0.02364778146147728, -0.003054460510611534, -0.039303217083215714, 0.02851768583059311, 0.010231580585241318, 0.043431367725133896, 0.06978616118431091, -0.005475629586726427, -0.004422119818627834, 0.004029659554362297, -0.007653196342289448, -0.03695817291736603, 0.02435235120356083, -0.04733903333544731, -0.004129702690988779, 0.021508634090423584, 0.002356029348447919, 0.02360519953072071, 0.005640984978526831, -0.010610511526465416, -0.0009510759264230728, -0.0918133482336998, -0.012362170964479446, -0.023248014971613884, -0.007952049374580383, -0.06240629032254219, -0.009576769545674324, -0.0006073886179365218, 0.006992070935666561, 0.0039986209012568, 0.018719526007771492, -0.05010678991675377, 0.016863005235791206, -0.00853036716580391, 0.027770213782787323, -0.006914024241268635, -0.02467401698231697, 0.015866594389081, 0.005560737568885088, 0.0018770542228594422, 0.020140167325735092, 0.03436017408967018, -0.029336178675293922, -0.0017576322425156832, 0.03144805133342743, -0.017859164625406265, 0.0036600271705538034, 0.010030291974544525, 0.007666588760912418, 0.0264436062425375, -0.02144918404519558, -0.006744877435266972, -0.036178410053253174, 0.0030860072001814842, -0.000012304849406064022, -0.00803854689002037, -0.023699799552559853, 0.020609114319086075, -0.03894248604774475, -0.010737735778093338, -0.027537137269973755, 0.0806838646531105, 0.016474425792694092, 0.02302658185362816, -0.04806089773774147, -0.030197931453585625, -0.00685020349919796, -0.03159784525632858, -0.031893081963062286, -0.051945921033620834, -0.05051960423588753, 0.013297496363520622, -0.0033778240904212, -0.0034097826573997736, 0.04278150200843811, -0.030403055250644684, 0.018009431660175323, -0.027507314458489418, -0.02232290431857109, 0.06778404861688614, -0.0007387971854768693, -0.03496032580733299, 0.02294994704425335, -0.04163810983300209, 0.015046137385070324, 0.05808502063155174, 0.017364636063575745, -0.038537558168172836, 0.004699105396866798, 0.016150694340467453, -0.019648456946015358, 0.026596544310450554, -0.018929265439510345, -0.026967711746692657, -0.01398790068924427, -0.01120090950280428, 0.0005569986533373594, -0.049953192472457886, -0.006095326039940119, -0.03811466693878174, -0.0033130720257759094, -0.022879673168063164, -0.013322314247488976, -0.029422197490930557, 0.007458217442035675, 0.04666595533490181, 0.002317179227247834, -0.028740044683218002, 0.024755509570240974, 0.08313020318746567, 0.00009127307566814125, -0.03271735832095146, -0.015931399539113045, 0.0084425313398242, 0.03373859077692032, 0.022385867312550545, -0.011567777954041958, -0.014173786155879498, 0.0004065852554049343, -0.012236688286066055, 0.01936623640358448, -0.029655830934643745, 0.020823653787374496, 0.03332424908876419, -0.021624155342578888, 0.05349506065249443, 0.038350652903318405, -0.03138808533549309, 0.009507723152637482, -0.033727820962667465, 0.014730189926922321, -0.02985302545130253, 0.006024814210832119, 0.058279652148485184, 0.02370968647301197, -0.0034787363838404417, 0.0635300725698471, 0.021353352814912796, 0.0064528766088187695, 0.02702755108475685, 0.031313568353652954, -0.005996339023113251, 0.015822172164916992, -0.03949214145541191, -0.01851125992834568, 0.03640129789710045, -0.006837898399680853, 0.032754622399806976, -0.02927282452583313, -0.007558654993772507, 0.03610018268227577, 0.03246045857667923, -0.01324846874922514, -0.005826764740049839, 0.009066062979400158, -0.036014046519994736, -0.014142132364213467, 0.046999238431453705, -0.021625062450766563, 0.03974166139960289, 0.003379028756171465, 0.025271572172641754, 0.017878342419862747, 0.023352624848484993, -0.03669878467917442, -0.052405647933483124, -0.018212758004665375, 0.01050556544214487, -0.029658811166882515, 0.03388263285160065, 0.026366230100393295, -0.020721837878227234, -0.03349611908197403, -0.04227803647518158, 0.021969441324472427, 0.002262224443256855, 0.014675039798021317, -0.03247222676873207, 0.028127655386924744, -0.022766539826989174, -0.0004054909513797611, -0.03970981761813164, -0.04423831030726433, 0.12167028337717056, 0.08206608891487122, 0.04687469080090523, -0.09621533006429672, 0.011647379957139492, 0.009728745557367802, 0.008826649747788906, -0.02223648689687252, -0.03633331134915352, 0.04929761216044426, 0.02834659069776535, 0.054571911692619324, 0.05446132272481918, 0.031087560579180717, -0.02117583155632019, 0.030896546319127083, -0.02766389027237892, -0.032063938677310944, -0.014567206613719463, 0.0068272193893790245, -0.014578159898519516, -0.058084242045879364, -0.07808789610862732, 0.005013139918446541, 0.09138718992471695, -0.0059252167120575905, -0.02421719580888748, -0.011126250959932804, -0.016253825277090073, 0.03238609433174133, -0.04204704239964485, 0.0051985145546495914, 0.004694238770753145, 0.00048013118794187903, 0.00033571181120350957, -0.007663214113563299, 0.0049147214740514755, -0.00032552238553762436, 0.025690646842122078, 0.03984896466135979, 0.016449447721242905, 0.012291336432099342, -0.007738166488707066, 0.045960284769535065, -0.04394776001572609, -0.015563588589429855, -0.007498272228986025, 0.025351611897349358, -0.03357577696442604, -0.044538162648677826, -0.022321563214063644, 0.03694584593176842, -0.015009310096502304, -0.042414214462041855, 0.0012340499088168144, 0.02591392770409584, 0.02350480854511261, -0.0008038810919970274, -0.010300902649760246, -0.008610537275671959, 0.025276342406868935, -0.027984866872429848, 0.03724471479654312, 0.042171090841293335, -0.025989960879087448, -0.02387971617281437, -0.03343462198972702, 0.058055661618709564, -0.03705025836825371, 0.023078683763742447, 0.02601514384150505, -0.015621732920408249, -0.01581420563161373, 0.0008876536157913506, 0.028601914644241333, -0.012699959799647331, 0.024961860850453377, -0.03325938060879707, -0.010904030874371529, 0.0015396689996123314, -0.03894076868891716, 0.035782311111688614, 0.014102349989116192, -0.03948613628745079, -0.02105034328997135, -0.03524916619062424, 0.02429014816880226, 0.04423383250832558, -0.008193864487111568, 0.02475605718791485, -0.03207514062523842, 0.04792296513915062, -0.04860914126038551, -0.019911549985408783, -0.06626171618700027, 0.035673804581165314, -0.026347022503614426, -0.01787191443145275, -0.01244796346873045, 0.02906392142176628, 0.034295883029699326, 0.029862217605113983, -0.010528051294386387, 0.013420556671917439, -0.03961990401148796, -0.008263288997113705, 0.030085889622569084, -0.025896470993757248, -0.000498532026540488, 0.012359995394945145, 0.01752650924026966, -0.051433395594358444, -0.0321391336619854, -0.030855458229780197, -0.04542439058423042, 0.02562939189374447, -0.002970963018015027, -0.07260455191135406, -0.008185851387679577, -0.011168715544044971, -0.006896839011460543, 0.001722173299640417, 0.027416428551077843, -0.02814958244562149, 0.00915569718927145, -0.00615733303129673, -0.06590646505355835, -0.01113193016499281, -0.02608354575932026, -0.028002573177218437, 0.015134411863982677, -0.000883721630088985, -0.02693125046789646, 0.02601819671690464, 0.013530672527849674, -0.005186277907341719, 0.03775005042552948, 0.04320191219449043, -0.007412821054458618, -0.020790595561265945, 0.01007053442299366, -0.07128919661045074, -0.0275309719145298, 0.019323499873280525, -0.028359752148389816, 0.02014130912721157, 0.011585366912186146, 0.01684800162911415, 0.01487521082162857, 0.03280298784375191, -0.019799208268523216, 0.013925044797360897, -0.012525965459644794, 0.018801100552082062, 0.03574543446302414, 0.02500607632100582, -0.02851026877760887, -0.015645332634449005, -0.008096217177808285, 0.023991575464606285, 0.03307678550481796, 0.013335454277694225, -0.012957482598721981, 0.041217025369405746, -0.005072298925369978, 0.03623775765299797, 0.019780078902840614, -0.03204101324081421, -0.023876767605543137, 0.0473325252532959, -0.040988270193338394, 0.045836664736270905, -0.02001633308827877, 0.006885269656777382, -0.12669195234775543, 0.004598802421241999, 0.017974918708205223, 0.009366631507873535, 0.01500933151692152, -0.050538185983896255, 0.045383207499980927, 0.005645148456096649, -0.05317395180463791, 0.014148366637527943, -0.0025213209446519613, -0.002382286824285984, -0.03708506003022194, 0.013197069056332111, -0.01360397133976221, 0.0005827598506584764, 0.0706852376461029, -0.019024889916181564, 0.01759731024503708, -0.025727640837430954, -0.007920917123556137, -0.01053923275321722, 0.029804755002260208, 0.02983279898762703, -0.030562514439225197, -0.05162839591503143, 0.051010292023420334, 0.009949203580617905, -0.009667381644248962, 0.010948401875793934, 0.0016545475227758288, 0.05127718299627304, 0.000432141765486449, 0.0219150111079216, 0.003723597852513194, 0.05576426163315773, 0.028692662715911865, 0.007841315120458603, -0.027541587129235268, 0.00912416074424982, 0.0013595751952379942, 0.0105810035020113, -0.021027658134698868, -0.007120497990399599, 0.042770612984895706, 0.013498873449862003, 0.0046712253242731094, 0.025104185566306114, -0.0341438390314579, -0.01958107016980648, 0.003492876188829541, -0.006825776305049658, 0.02034970000386238, -0.0201837457716465, -0.024918805807828903, -0.03619590029120445, -0.010554233565926552, 0.057326462119817734, 0.037193480879068375, 0.0034511254634708166, 0.018409190699458122, -0.01724797487258911, -0.009227988310158253, 0.03347953408956528, 0.059915341436862946, -0.0006175036542117596, -0.014123265631496906, -0.019880767911672592, -0.005297074094414711, 0.02124791219830513, 0.016728036105632782, 0.01786310225725174, 0.014892449602484703, 0.031007321551442146, 0.020717713981866837, -0.012614701874554157, 0.012002930976450443, -0.003597630187869072, 0.018031643703579903, -0.07393640279769897, 0.03868352994322777, -0.003505072556436062, -0.0051342821680009365, -0.023431863635778427, 0.0023364212829619646, -0.08990350365638733, 0.0016215202631428838, 0.050341084599494934, 0.03663443401455879, -0.023089934140443802, 0.004812364466488361, 0.024915361776947975, 0.00786747969686985, -0.031345199793577194, 0.03615908324718475, 0.0004449396801646799, -0.024592559784650803, -0.03885537013411522, 0.00013309829228091985, 0.003179741557687521, 0.021943138912320137, -0.025372548028826714, -0.02536209672689438, -0.024788768962025642, -0.028910230845212936, -0.025018911808729172, 0.02668108604848385, 0.059753768146038055, 0.007284803315997124, 0.016842495650053024, 0.026817793026566505, -0.010117492638528347, 0.041743163019418716, 0.004808706231415272, -0.06237217038869858, 0.031209753826260567, -0.029194116592407227, 0.009746546857059002, 0.013686852529644966, 0.01250105258077383, 0.0020028194412589073, -0.027471311390399933, 0.004120794590562582, 0.02489568293094635, 0.007148757576942444, -0.0319589264690876, 0.022901728749275208, 0.05320080742239952, 0.046964604407548904, 0.017236080020666122, -0.0020013132598251104, -0.000845125934574753, -0.0016390947857871652, 0.007381377276033163, 0.008720602840185165, -0.004810511600226164, -0.009713619016110897, -0.016470743343234062, 0.03389870375394821, -0.007325556594878435, 0.02082858234643936, -0.026304252445697784, 0.06382833421230316, 0.014063692651689053, 0.011258465237915516, 0.003567146835848689, -0.030349278822541237, 0.01292109489440918, -0.01956036128103733, -0.0156126469373703, 0.04322351515293121, -0.043284013867378235, 0.04777238517999649, -0.03681709244847298, -0.04358809441328049, 0.0025512140709906816, -0.033076751977205276, -0.011711080558598042, -0.0019370261579751968, -0.021851500496268272, 0.017900828272104263, 0.0024824305437505245, -0.018058372661471367, 0.03716627135872841, -0.046650901436805725, 0.009480306878685951, -0.01408447790890932, 0.019473835825920105, 0.016971567645668983, 0.01355668529868126, -0.0038118897937238216, -0.0021341003011912107, 0.03590542450547218, 0.04162051901221275, 0.007405894808471203, -0.06438837945461273, 0.007250433787703514, 0.03303470462560654, 0.033238161355257034, -0.0427047535777092, -0.03194203972816467, -0.008832219056785107, 0.034765470772981644, -0.001730500953271985, -0.026616999879479408 ]
<p>The dependent variable of my problem is highly concentrated around zero. Here is a stemplot</p> <pre><code> The decimal point is 6 digit(s) to the right of the | -2 | 511 -1 | 92221 -0 | 87777666666665555555555555555444444444444444444444444444444433333333+2428 0 | 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000+2113 1 | 00000000000000000000000000000000000011111111111111111111111111111122+110 2 | 0000000000111111233333444444555666666677778889 3 | 00112457778889 4 | 11233456999 5 | 0000389 6 | 01477 7 | 259 8 | 033 9 | 002356 10 | 9 11 | 12 | 13 | 069 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 13 </code></pre> <p>Normally when I have a dependent variable (DV) that looks like this I apply a logarithmic transformation for reasons both economical and mathematical. But obviously this will not work in this case as I have values below zero.</p> <p>Is there another monotonically increasing transformation function that will reduce the peakedness of this distribution?</p>
73,423
[ -0.016928156837821007, -0.005541787948459387, 0.0001577338553033769, -0.012180197983980179, 0.040582284331321716, -0.0236622653901577, -0.024545986205339432, -0.008346746675670147, 0.03996256738901138, -0.06146876513957977, 0.05614779517054558, 0.01689729653298855, 0.02120949886739254, 0.011211811564862728, 0.01868034154176712, 0.024812953546643257, -0.03712598234415054, 0.013112817890942097, 0.001023855758830905, -0.03184448927640915, 0.0016397121362388134, 0.0034462970215827227, 0.011890917085111141, -0.026542263105511665, -0.02193809114396572, 0.031006401404738426, -0.001940108952112496, -0.014888878911733627, -0.02637026645243168, 0.04248737543821335, -0.0318046510219574, -0.0473901703953743, 0.02449665777385235, 0.07989814132452011, 0.004068503621965647, 0.028369169682264328, -0.01753276214003563, -0.02292441390454769, -0.038139231503009796, 0.010892350226640701, -0.02256275899708271, 0.0074255215004086494, -0.03440815582871437, 0.02644372172653675, 0.03807005286216736, 0.019869588315486908, -0.018314393237233162, -0.012029752135276794, 0.004057897720485926, -0.0023544097784906626, 0.07657892256975174, -0.014145717024803162, 0.018602607771754265, -0.024320151656866074, -0.017938710749149323, -0.05801411345601082, 0.0573401004076004, 0.07005847990512848, 0.003620637347921729, -0.06935779750347137, -0.02793579176068306, -0.02730478346347809, 0.005834691692143679, 0.0031428716611117125, -0.014201752841472626, 0.05574004724621773, 0.004954193718731403, -0.016016317531466484, 0.03745609521865845, -0.045745790004730225, 0.009452750906348228, 0.027253657579421997, 0.018870998173952103, -0.011512842029333115, 0.0018397173844277859, -0.019344989210367203, 0.03429761901497841, -0.011363138444721699, 0.03649262338876724, 0.0024830736219882965, 0.012569391168653965, 0.030680427327752113, -0.03099721111357212, 0.04204527661204338, -0.0004975791089236736, 0.0017977120587602258, 0.05550725385546684, -0.006898939143866301, 0.030186409130692482, 0.04760333523154259, -0.01874932460486889, -0.028463920578360558, 0.06825001537799835, -0.006289136130362749, -0.023251459002494812, 0.043490272015333176, 0.005664237774908543, 0.012657207436859608, -0.021600589156150818, 0.006014325190335512, -0.037284016609191895, -0.047070376574993134, -0.014345147646963596, 0.04336680844426155, -0.0035029426217079163, 0.049876946955919266, -0.016165556386113167, -0.03509754687547684, -0.013340913690626621, -0.021438784897327423, -0.03515559434890747, -0.024539602920413017, 0.020377373322844505, 0.0007164322305470705, 0.029397232457995415, -0.028536804020404816, -0.03512274846434593, -0.01755226030945778, 0.0347001887857914, 0.0017059168312698603, 0.03125965595245361, -0.011696330271661282, 0.07023894786834717, -0.021972032263875008, -0.07524929195642471, 0.054685551673173904, 0.023113619536161423, 0.02168159931898117, -0.027859997004270554, 0.0251777246594429, -0.01990007609128952, -0.029138147830963135, 0.10001896321773529, -0.026892974972724915, 0.04211607575416565, 0.03575048968195915, -0.05113430693745613, -0.0672820582985878, 0.016110489144921303, 0.02204740233719349, 0.013041757047176361, -0.05264783278107643, 0.0127369724214077, 0.06404608488082886, 0.037951868027448654, -0.01150465663522482, 0.01312611997127533, 0.012559978291392326, 0.015318707562983036, 0.038533348590135574, 0.01008641254156828, -0.014622741378843784, -0.02421085350215435, -0.05450226366519928, -0.021455025300383568, -0.037188541144132614, 0.015194359235465527, 0.021402345970273018, -0.02884070947766304, -0.018824314698576927, 0.036082543432712555, -0.02248438261449337, -0.010478312149643898, -0.04441971331834793, -0.018939675763249397, -0.013347170315682888, 0.045416396111249924, 0.020676711574196815, 0.019241508096456528, -0.015413717366755009, 0.00032725711935199797, 0.05519559234380722, -0.00759192043915391, 0.038624294102191925, 0.04619510471820831, -0.04789407178759575, 0.0017450375016778708, -0.03888635337352753, 0.012611795216798782, 0.04513205215334892, -0.026938974857330322, -0.034796446561813354, -0.029056457802653313, -0.01671467162668705, 0.00870149303227663, 0.023240691050887108, -0.0015492693055421114, -0.016321126371622086, 0.025362316519021988, -0.049027375876903534, -0.04930996522307396, -0.026903070509433746, 0.005170716904103756, 0.00458461744710803, 0.0006493899854831398, -0.003259242046624422, -0.009000920690596104, 0.01650775596499443, 0.011426951736211777, -0.010260051116347313, 0.04682350531220436, -0.02285955101251602, 0.036480288952589035, -0.043585143983364105, -0.0010367895010858774, 0.0168951153755188, 0.0480751097202301, -0.0125454505905509, 0.05210518464446068, -0.005384529009461403, 0.03140706196427345, -0.0050312839448452, -0.0251249298453331, 0.0171415526419878, -0.03766463324427605, -0.0004413753922563046, 0.058167144656181335, -0.0019757021218538284, -0.0011558884289115667, 0.028025399893522263, -0.05497661605477333, 0.06782970577478409, 0.12590056657791138, 0.018430398777127266, 0.026188408955931664, 0.0052461219020187855, -0.005869628861546516, 0.05564350262284279, -0.03924909979104996, -0.014920382760465145, -0.021448267623782158, 0.01739453710615635, 0.005564337596297264, -0.0005327644175849855, -0.026655105873942375, 0.0011991008650511503, 0.046958863735198975, 0.01193940732628107, 0.018126752227544785, 0.034375857561826706, -0.01104721985757351, 0.017602520063519478, 0.003784658620133996, 0.007877934724092484, 0.02173025719821453, 0.000004014735168311745, 0.023226093500852585, 0.0181704331189394, 0.002524212934076786, 0.0015846401220187545, -0.038287557661533356, 0.006461223587393761, 0.010757296346127987, 0.010906343348324299, -0.032520223408937454, 0.006612129509449005, 0.03828059509396553, -0.03740470111370087, 0.016802318394184113, 0.05331961438059807, -0.036085549741983414, 0.00852782279253006, -0.009204036556184292, -0.037515442818403244, 0.03686487674713135, 0.07434462010860443, 0.008178476244211197, -0.01835521310567856, 0.024303222075104713, -0.013103839941322803, 0.03210068494081497, -0.0324443019926548, -0.043226685374975204, -0.0389726348221302, 0.01334100216627121, 0.033508528023958206, 0.04068329930305481, 0.020086131989955902, -0.02594056911766529, -0.001420039450749755, -0.01930374465882778, -0.0015828653704375029, 0.002353937830775976, 0.0410003587603569, -0.07833491265773773, -0.03511590138077736, 0.0011679608142003417, -0.021537546068429947, 0.03550181910395622, 0.0035056478809565306, -0.013744007796049118, -0.016258718445897102, -0.005041211377829313, -0.058504097163677216, -0.023607058450579643, -0.003502529812976718, -0.01243545114994049, -0.04259468987584114, -0.018114259466528893, 0.05683913454413414, 0.024803023785352707, -0.059948377311229706, -0.00915369763970375, -0.0406390056014061, -0.02131929062306881, -0.043081510812044144, -0.023705443367362022, -0.0029062016401439905, -0.011709815822541714, 0.0008562443545088172, -0.007490280084311962, -0.015207010321319103, 0.003808314446359873, -0.0798151046037674, -0.0741831436753273, 0.0020087093580514193, -0.023553194478154182, 0.04007231071591377, 0.020632466301321983, -0.04187115654349327, 0.052958328276872635, 0.05148913711309433, -0.03634742274880409, -0.061890751123428345, -0.023395152762532234, -0.008843931369483471, 0.006246586330235004, -0.012683073058724403, 0.049977533519268036, 0.017679274082183838, 0.004348175134509802, -0.024724114686250687, 0.03146103397011757, 0.03994537517428398, 0.001190991373732686, -0.035131264477968216, 0.054629772901535034, -0.017010927200317383, -0.017998795956373215, 0.01706787385046482, 0.031240273267030716, -0.030238714069128036, 0.06784314662218094, -0.004428167827427387, -0.003186322282999754, -0.014803069643676281, -0.03658439591526985, 0.025408120825886726, 0.0024457776453346014, 0.020060742273926735, -0.011697775684297085, -0.002096503507345915, 0.04090028628706932, -0.029386034235358238, -0.02182559296488762, 0.03917202726006508, 0.05429789796471596, -0.015954745933413506, 0.005308224819600582, 0.03421713784337044, 0.042724449187517166, -0.020201968029141426, 0.009214605204761028, -0.011188196949660778, -0.014060338959097862, 0.042776595801115036, -0.0005295880837365985, -0.01447389554232359, 0.03194797411561012, 0.01785811223089695, 0.04218755289912224, 0.01110789179801941, -0.012823403812944889, 0.015287413261830807, -0.025920383632183075, 0.0037712266203016043, -0.03322760760784149, 0.07366329431533813, 0.044472984969615936, 0.0424535907804966, 0.049108605831861496, 0.016193602234125137, -0.018553810194134712, 0.01721935160458088, -0.05284903198480606, 0.033804044127464294, -0.014931119047105312, 0.03554844483733177, -0.0017187288030982018, 0.005440026521682739, -0.002681286772713065, -0.03173516318202019, -0.013665207661688328, 0.021838026121258736, 0.04949387162923813, -0.036958422511816025, -0.010704558342695236, 0.006484631914645433, 0.014116049744188786, -0.05129498243331909, 0.024940816685557365, 0.025303352624177933, -0.027942460030317307, 0.06761922687292099, 0.020077228546142578, -0.0024624511133879423, -0.02002420276403427, 0.00011793897283496335, 0.016163432970643044, 0.031824711710214615, 0.031763955950737, 0.03049401380121708, 0.012793200090527534, -0.03830234706401825, -0.0006614064332097769, 0.017824485898017883, 0.024920590221881866, 0.0269367303699255, -0.008620907552540302, 0.013564215041697025, -0.039283156394958496, -0.03868090733885765, -0.004674858413636684, 0.005029021296650171, 0.009853847324848175, 0.013757983222603798, 0.0443870909512043, 0.00996106956154108, -0.020486338064074516, 0.04675595834851265, 0.08648655563592911, -0.00017026621208060533, -0.009446317330002785, -0.018645886331796646, -0.01825140230357647, -0.018271218985319138, 0.020180709660053253, -0.0017191973747685552, 0.02178136445581913, -0.022052934393286705, -0.005818137899041176, 0.05956180766224861, 0.013811810873448849, -0.030473381280899048, 0.008476458489894867, 0.016455071046948433, 0.03723008930683136, -0.016826754435896873, -0.028432847931981087, 0.016580777242779732, -0.016247006133198738, 0.011777111329138279, 0.04017535224556923, 0.0035493229515850544, -0.10064887255430222, -0.004123071674257517, 0.02272896282374859, 0.068659707903862, -0.05577046051621437, 0.019274236634373665, -0.054164160043001175, -0.014062737114727497, 0.03295958787202835, -0.04038531333208084, -0.005028372164815664, 0.034158945083618164, -0.0024757878854870796, -0.01905873604118824, -0.046686768531799316, -0.0573926717042923, 0.007333511486649513, -0.03377590328454971, 0.01681745983660221, -0.04985983669757843, -0.009568441659212112, -0.05571000650525093, 0.019196340814232826, -0.013285484164953232, 0.047343336045742035, 0.022172022610902786, -0.04525274410843849, -0.009684771299362183, 0.015693338587880135, -0.011692878790199757, -0.042356040328741074, 0.014021803624927998, -0.025453360751271248, 0.0011103000724688172, 0.04804956912994385, -0.02198711968958378, -0.04282142594456673, 0.04496145620942116, -0.017289772629737854, 0.00682284589856863, 0.022532351315021515, -0.0043534087017178535, 0.05785951763391495, 0.048160370439291, -0.001790387905202806, 0.021152624860405922, 0.0654802992939949, -0.00791171845048666, -0.001695839804597199, -0.03905932232737541, -0.015361732803285122, -0.03175022453069687, 0.02369821071624756, -0.03790134936571121, -0.0070972926914691925, -0.012440118007361889, 0.011909283697605133, -0.013337031938135624, 0.05232980474829674, 0.00322733330540359, 0.020252078771591187, 0.027368364855647087, 0.008292592130601406, -0.0024966991040855646, -0.020104562863707542, -0.009038131684064865, 0.03195934370160103, 0.026223711669445038, -0.03685840219259262, 0.01632457785308361, -0.00910224113613367, -0.010086563415825367, -0.003641366958618164, -0.02809309773147106, -0.03722362592816353, -0.04184502735733986, -0.016367746517062187, 0.025980262085795403, -0.03471161052584648, 0.034045010805130005, 0.01871485263109207, 0.0075749545358121395, 0.03440861403942108, -0.017051933333277702, -0.004891461227089167, 0.013420592062175274, 0.0010929363779723644, 0.026728618890047073, -0.0442890003323555, 0.013527601957321167, -0.029618896543979645, -0.0014971897471696138, -0.0615948848426342, -0.019823703914880753, 0.010683417320251465, 0.00852846447378397, 0.005379829555749893, -0.016067780554294586, -0.030629081651568413, 0.01735161617398262, 0.009807145223021507, -0.00204707239754498, 0.04200361669063568, -0.0005395442130975425, -0.03808656707406044, -0.0012708058347925544, 0.03048638440668583, 0.0816466361284256, -0.04654794931411743, 0.002450354630127549, 0.03151348978281021, -0.008301991969347, -0.015656784176826477, 0.0060747405514121056, 0.029150133952498436, -0.057398583739995956, -0.009005310013890266, 0.014792891219258308, -0.010939514264464378, 0.024563785642385483, -0.017155878245830536, -0.03186224028468132, -0.019541775807738304, 0.0132147753611207, 0.004161662422120571, -0.00808363314718008, -0.012618115171790123, 0.003088396741077304, -0.007694167084991932, -0.021153803914785385, 0.009678401052951813, -0.046916887164115906, -0.01753360591828823, -0.020688794553279877, 0.01464205700904131, -0.01611008308827877, 0.013299104757606983, 0.04010298475623131, 0.0043754191137850285, -0.006180971395224333, 0.03857811167836189, -0.044106755405664444, 0.014261996373534203, 0.024185199290513992, 0.009486551396548748, -0.011698617599904537, 0.012764115817844868, -0.03154342621564865, 0.000973415735643357, -0.05493650212883949, 0.014076520688831806, 0.05497654154896736, 0.022571664303541183, 0.02769751101732254, -0.018537767231464386, 0.03008531779050827, 0.00769788259640336, -0.005501571111381054, -0.014947998337447643, -0.0009157809545286, -0.007419068831950426, 0.03073503077030182, -0.007073067594319582, 0.009789901785552502, 0.0192713662981987, 0.03996822237968445, 0.01855831779539585, 0.07701248675584793, 0.015167420729994774, -0.03812141343951225, 0.07446589320898056, -0.035102952271699905, 0.02899099700152874, 0.021061746403574944, -0.027035744860768318, 0.05460941791534424, -0.02329261042177677, -0.032269783318042755, 0.032040536403656006, 0.008746775798499584, -0.002197503112256527, -0.06200667470693588, -0.04399031400680542, -0.05176495388150215, -0.012835259549319744, 0.01492201630026102, -0.01642484962940216, 0.03710804507136345, -0.016732964664697647, 0.011066521517932415, -0.004544450901448727, 0.024840114638209343, -0.07436109334230423, -0.029974939301609993, -0.015192452818155289, -0.05584859848022461, -0.05953303351998329, 0.03177918121218681, 0.01071317307651043, -0.00621951837092638, 0.035754721611738205, -0.026849595829844475, 0.024806587025523186, 0.028767498210072517, -0.003195112571120262, 0.03144574910402298, 0.09168899804353714, 0.016647959128022194, 0.03157803416252136, 0.019765978679060936, -0.031644538044929504, 0.13875460624694824, 0.061178434640169144, 0.02687343955039978, -0.05678578093647957, 0.011403716169297695, 0.028872713446617126, 0.03998718783259392, -0.037785500288009644, 0.002255552913993597, 0.01812819577753544, -0.031290456652641296, 0.019580086693167686, 0.05934921279549599, 0.008337782695889473, 0.04698677733540535, 0.05411555990576744, -0.02917521633207798, -0.029942067340016365, 0.0020981549751013517, 0.030185110867023468, 0.016912449151277542, -0.031221473589539528, -0.07553423941135406, -0.0023797086905688047, 0.01220158115029335, -0.029000794515013695, -0.021949363872408867, 0.0027494607493281364, 0.026482123881578445, 0.0034998145420104265, -0.016813097521662712, 0.006145953666418791, 0.05579423904418945, -0.0069359950721263885, 0.022573739290237427, -0.010741106234490871, 0.019476788118481636, -0.023050494492053986, 0.01259875763207674, 0.07442723959684372, -0.006166771985590458, 0.02357259765267372, 0.006230490282177925, -0.005515179131180048, -0.014435874298214912, -0.013863716274499893, -0.05481322854757309, -0.003628755686804652, 0.014328102581202984, -0.011156458407640457, 0.014880884438753128, -0.013726593926548958, -0.005051405169069767, -0.03461498022079468, -0.01705656759440899, 0.027164094150066376, -0.0038238163106143475, 0.01847143843770027, -0.018143901601433754, 0.01820734702050686, 0.01900528557598591, -0.017200306057929993, -0.017204659059643745, 0.020328408107161522, -0.017542697489261627, -0.0263869259506464, -0.009186618030071259, 0.07930508255958557, -0.02010817639529705, -0.004101994447410107, -0.018251854926347733, 0.024282528087496758, -0.008168995380401611, 0.014330568723380566, -0.021806830540299416, -0.0008029218879528344, 0.014307175762951374, -0.0008368912385776639, 0.005652595777064562, -0.013198088854551315, -0.024340219795703888, 0.021419061347842216, -0.03137562796473503, 0.000962875026743859, -0.030390899628400803, 0.03200659155845642, 0.0015963009791448712, 0.037289172410964966, 0.02745097316801548, 0.0033158757723867893, -0.04068047180771828, 0.08278976380825043, 0.028711561113595963, -0.06480870395898819, 0.00553714158013463, -0.005483197048306465, -0.027879798784852028, 0.003900448326021433, -0.019434496760368347, 0.04715753719210625, 0.006951263174414635, -0.00015838963736314327, -0.005852664355188608, 0.0020968809258192778, -0.019129544496536255, 0.001807340420782566, -0.0017567494651302695, -0.05147304758429527, -0.005965162068605423, -0.009305124171078205, -0.037112217396497726, -0.031738217920064926, -0.009878368116915226, -0.025952409952878952, -0.01880226843059063, -0.01458671037107706, 0.016033288091421127, -0.036911845207214355, 0.03049704246222973, -0.027134831994771957, -0.03570890426635742, 0.01238764077425003, 0.016569126397371292, 0.013149633072316647, -0.02752521261572838, -0.046526506543159485, -0.014805984683334827, 0.015617072582244873, 0.04048328846693039, -0.011808407492935658, 0.0374046191573143, 0.03377999737858772, 0.034748341888189316, 0.03670084848999977, -0.014049412682652473, 0.0172970462590456, 0.011509529314935207, 0.032186489552259445, -0.06091025099158287, 0.021707937121391296, 0.027506845071911812, -0.02108749933540821, -0.0024478721898049116, 0.0193609781563282, -0.020055314525961876, 0.03245214745402336, -0.031117958948016167, 0.010938511230051517, -0.016812067478895187, 0.032189711928367615, 0.015829479321837425, 0.0026678775902837515, 0.008810233324766159, -0.024631483480334282, 0.03841777145862579, 0.025537697598338127, -0.006715150084346533, 0.0023081498220562935, 0.0011245700297877192, 0.032626260071992874, 0.07695885747671127, -0.013178065419197083, 0.010884195566177368, -0.0033848420716822147, -0.002851842436939478, 0.03696398437023163, 0.009839609265327454, 0.010460466146469116, 0.03835925832390785, 0.045907340943813324, -0.0003247192653361708, -0.00041310422238893807, -0.04918321967124939, -0.040671732276678085, -0.07977723330259323, -0.010664524510502815, 0.01130914781242609, -0.03302796930074692, 0.025562401860952377, -0.026304399594664574, -0.02442367747426033, 0.010601023212075233, -0.03874814510345459, 0.012361742556095123, -0.012674221768975258, 0.020838843658566475, -0.02084377594292164, -0.04283428192138672, -0.009243490174412727, 0.03279605135321617, 0.029074067249894142, 0.046439703553915024, 0.06051419675350189, -0.008176317438483238, -0.010072308592498302, -0.04473293200135231, 0.014643541537225246, 0.016993120312690735, 0.0006369550246745348, -0.05737956613302231, 0.010703178122639656, -0.0594552680850029, -0.016531165689229965, 0.019533654674887657, -0.03754357993602753, 0.007522645406424999, -0.010118861682713032, 0.022597508504986763, 0.015340269543230534, 0.07531432807445526, 0.027150733396410942, 0.011988911777734756, -0.05479760840535164, 0.008875629864633083, -0.006861172150820494, -0.01554021704941988, -0.04533863440155983, 0.026713479310274124, 0.010444187559187412, -0.0011255333665758371, -0.03378533199429512, -0.001005533616989851, -0.022379066795110703, 0.0194837786257267, -0.02117355726659298, -0.006461475044488907, 0.04262498393654823, -0.03554413095116615, 0.00012699744547717273, -0.066818468272686, -0.029810208827257156, 0.008185265585780144, 0.012003140524029732, 0.02744993008673191, 0.007370756473392248, -0.006213549990206957, -0.03478574752807617, -0.044879667460918427, 0.03526526689529419, -0.025936488062143326, -0.04797450080513954, 0.0015235578175634146, -0.03478201851248741, -0.027299964800477028, -0.015047202818095684, -0.011787716299295425, -0.04033001512289047, 0.021463192999362946, -0.034156523644924164, 0.048254262655973434, 0.029407039284706116, 0.00722483778372407, 0.047172676771879196, -0.09956175088882446, 0.07347530126571655, -0.012743636965751648, 0.030725965276360512, -0.003985152579843998, -0.0335383340716362, -0.027170667424798012, 0.0339849591255188, 0.05534612387418747, 0.025047065690159798, -0.0054455772042274475, 0.01639571227133274, -0.013002406805753708, -0.001873421249911189, -0.07150506973266602, -0.010660482570528984, 0.003708491101861, -0.02085162326693535, -0.00899609737098217, 0.01383606344461441, 0.007654787506908178, 0.009767676703631878, -0.01851167157292366, -0.015797318890690804, -0.034199271351099014, -0.003197810612618923, -0.026801101863384247, -0.05343036353588104, -0.02407483384013176, -0.01791415363550186, 0.04524451866745949, -0.0037341993302106857, -0.007396602537482977, -0.0029793677385896444, 0.003735452191904187, -0.08740122616291046, 0.03408470004796982, -0.04438008368015289, -0.03063184954226017, -0.025246277451515198, 0.019932560622692108, 0.04636723920702934, -0.030684614554047585, 0.03641023486852646, -0.002334324177354574, -0.02101435884833336, -0.051721662282943726, 0.023410024121403694, 0.024376388639211655, 0.024808503687381744, 0.010183728300035, 0.012875981628894806, -0.03437119722366333, 0.01895814947783947, 0.017491258680820465, -0.0022792199160903692, 0.009766986593604088, -0.03189511224627495, 0.015344790183007717, 0.001820761477574706, -0.020869018509984016, -0.003201981307938695, 0.034389011561870575, 0.00293873087503016, 0.007024487946182489, -0.02136298455297947, 0.022552113980054855, 0.004908552393317223, 0.023489419370889664, -0.002339313505217433, 0.0011054003844037652, 0.02867930941283703, 0.06278753280639648, 0.03245437145233154, -0.028167681768536568, -0.014177666045725346, -0.027151059359312057, 0.0008334113517776132, -0.030051112174987793, 0.0000406340004701633, -0.04322751238942146, -0.0013754316605627537, 0.008182036690413952, 0.017945846542716026, 0.021119341254234314, 0.0019021716434508562, 0.006204873789101839, -0.04468237981200218, -0.016985978931188583, 0.013317057862877846, -0.01495718490332365, -0.05421758070588112, -0.057971011847257614, 0.016519695520401, 0.035263702273368835, 0.05502508580684662, 0.008956191129982471, -0.04044326767325401, 0.01952843926846981, 0.06244559586048126, -0.022981608286499977, -0.036518245935440063, -0.029905429109930992, -0.03524240478873253, 0.008105538785457611, -0.022362370043992996 ]
<p>IMDB uses a Bayesian estimate to compute its top 250 films. Let's say I know all the variables needed to compute this Bayesian estimate for these films. I also have the production company associated with each film. How could I fairly rank the production companies based on the weighted rank (and review counts) of their films? I'd be using all films with a more than m reviews. As a refresher, IMDB uses <code>weighted rating (WR) = (v / (v+m)) × R + (m / (v+m)) × C</code>.</p> <p>It probably doesn't matter, but I'm using R to do the analysis in case there are some packages that can help solve this.</p>
73,424
[ -0.02185814082622528, -0.03637673333287239, -0.00824973825365305, -0.0591309629380703, 0.031833913177251816, 0.004518477711826563, 0.008581534028053284, 0.0103328637778759, 0.02043861709535122, -0.021282784640789032, 0.01319003477692604, 0.09673060476779938, 0.06912757456302643, 0.036947283893823624, 0.01677895151078701, 0.005822416394948959, 0.004233696963638067, 0.003592301392927766, -0.012105506844818592, -0.02264903299510479, -0.014164772816002369, 0.050765205174684525, 0.023287910968065262, -0.026880288496613503, -0.05379308760166168, 0.024733873084187508, 0.026193875819444656, -0.020857365801930428, 0.01406532060354948, 0.006213541608303785, -0.03817959129810333, -0.015389990992844105, 0.057046279311180115, 0.026017330586910248, 0.017288800328969955, -0.010507950559258461, -0.031409088522195816, 0.0012096549617126584, -0.0591948926448822, 0.02080477401614189, 0.015203261747956276, -0.017604634165763855, 0.014703143388032913, 0.015208068303763866, -0.0036724575329571962, 0.005558103322982788, -0.008414220996201038, -0.016884395852684975, 0.029685689136385918, -0.03919333219528198, 0.0984768345952034, 0.010036741383373737, 0.010417962446808815, 0.01400595623999834, -0.047870736569166183, -0.009858238510787487, 0.04963831976056099, 0.05138542875647545, -0.01693885400891304, -0.053897425532341, -0.04111858457326889, -0.017005886882543564, -0.0015382780693471432, -0.008035162463784218, -0.013528591021895409, 0.02459459938108921, 0.004822052549570799, -0.00752197066321969, 0.06579139828681946, 0.019524747505784035, -0.015629522502422333, 0.03541164472699165, 0.029527099803090096, -0.02329573594033718, 0.010280661284923553, -0.033794552087783813, 0.033620089292526245, 0.031843651086091995, 0.0525987446308136, 0.024970240890979767, -0.03989868983626366, 0.03234130144119263, 0.012043646536767483, 0.0761314406991005, 0.02372271753847599, -0.03156043589115143, 0.06169179454445839, -0.03873110190033913, 0.019307252019643784, 0.011881519109010696, -0.012670127674937248, 0.0019040750339627266, 0.03808211535215378, 0.013379429467022419, -0.05966963246464729, 0.011630326509475708, -0.0227263905107975, 0.04502682760357857, 0.010868117213249207, -0.025574415922164917, -0.005603545345366001, -0.0460067093372345, 0.011038015596568584, 0.057320721447467804, -0.021211085841059685, -0.017979972064495087, -0.03043033741414547, -0.005543562583625317, -0.017301414161920547, 0.004437902942299843, -0.044468384236097336, 0.007390432991087437, 0.037302225828170776, -0.0441710501909256, 0.0187175665050745, -0.03327341005206108, 0.010972920805215836, -0.006412194576114416, 0.04652394726872444, 0.06390327960252762, 0.026209551841020584, -0.04143718257546425, 0.042849164456129074, -0.028026157990098, -0.047266069799661636, -0.027136467397212982, 0.024563098326325417, -0.018238069489598274, -0.028260421007871628, 0.052764274179935455, -0.017782149836421013, -0.028257358819246292, 0.029105806723237038, -0.02796805277466774, 0.022411689162254333, -0.01122185681015253, -0.0851985365152359, -0.058961715549230576, 0.019158292561769485, -0.03204873204231262, 0.01715678907930851, -0.06745720654726028, 0.01076347567141056, 0.03158174082636833, 0.060493215918540955, 0.03430095314979553, 0.036676518619060516, 0.04679998755455017, 0.026867792010307312, -0.036190956830978394, 0.007057055830955505, -0.07209121435880661, -0.015178890898823738, -0.003796397242695093, -0.021957457065582275, -0.11288988590240479, -0.01340978592634201, -0.022556563839316368, -0.0005566845647990704, 0.029619814828038216, 0.03398173302412033, -0.004389840178191662, -0.040577974170446396, -0.017503898590803146, 0.019010916352272034, -0.017309455201029778, 0.006321300752460957, 0.01053705532103777, 0.03700963407754898, -0.0030824977438896894, -0.016948210075497627, 0.0012122862972319126, 0.03446841239929199, 0.023633265867829323, 0.046150289475917816, -0.019472556188702583, 0.02607632987201214, -0.008266543038189411, 0.05527031049132347, 0.009648638777434826, -0.01446511223912239, -0.04694843292236328, -0.00884760357439518, -0.0010026833042502403, 0.03032699041068554, 0.013893140479922295, 0.0020746549125760794, 0.020505009219050407, 0.06411778926849365, -0.02677340805530548, -0.016458239406347275, -0.047063134610652924, -0.01681322231888771, -0.000689780164975673, -0.02030881866812706, -0.015740586444735527, -0.008268933743238449, 0.005823476240038872, -0.030018014833331108, -0.0033128918148577213, -0.03861726075410843, -0.027264246717095375, 0.048131298273801804, -0.005724174901843071, -0.01992146112024784, 0.01738511584699154, 0.0507698729634285, -0.003704365808516741, 0.03758436068892479, -0.033156853169202805, -0.09232308715581894, 0.023135624825954437, -0.0041795168071985245, 0.010439627803862095, 0.008586909621953964, -0.05197712033987045, 0.03371386602520943, -0.014736678451299667, 0.0016506696119904518, -0.0005414265906438231, -0.05690331012010574, 0.06904866546392441, 0.06605581939220428, 0.037952255457639694, 0.015714135020971298, 0.017017409205436707, 0.004501920659095049, 0.01563326083123684, 0.0024775329511612654, -0.01660057343542576, -0.05498598888516426, -0.017699740827083588, 0.0021691436413675547, -0.019917700439691544, -0.03877057880163193, 0.012975162826478481, 0.03701045364141464, 0.02356773056089878, 0.02658652886748314, 0.022415736690163612, -0.0001761683524819091, -0.029142534360289574, 0.04038732871413231, -0.003249119268730283, 0.011868339031934738, -0.01965313032269478, -0.0036340593360364437, 0.0396217480301857, 0.04982944205403328, -0.033030636608600616, 0.010897384956479073, 0.03456404432654381, -0.00870369654148817, 0.0171994399279356, -0.014980502426624298, -0.037356745451688766, 0.03708793595433235, -0.03829023241996765, 0.007210483308881521, 0.05439315736293793, 0.006006717216223478, 0.016507402062416077, 0.03646652400493622, -0.03674595057964325, 0.0053182318806648254, 0.04118499159812927, -0.03928452357649803, 0.0147317536175251, 0.042615409940481186, -0.01854441687464714, 0.026523839682340622, -0.029245633631944656, -0.01863088086247444, -0.03137456998229027, 0.04767409339547157, 0.053358983248472214, -0.006200232543051243, 0.017965756356716156, -0.013671688735485077, -0.025436818599700928, -0.015682311728596687, -0.04256405681371689, -0.00385243259370327, 0.01073794811964035, -0.04384993761777878, -0.009660682640969753, 0.030196307227015495, -0.015269233845174313, 0.03494581952691078, -0.010340363718569279, -0.05389886349439621, 0.009325483813881874, 0.024386312812566757, -0.047396548092365265, -0.01032992172986269, -0.005707870703190565, 0.02099875546991825, -0.017764832824468613, -0.021369533613324165, 0.02656327374279499, 0.021094147115945816, -0.023973315954208374, 0.02938847616314888, -0.03469529747962952, -0.015590700320899487, 0.008198218420147896, -0.0030803631525486708, -0.0033816960640251637, 0.016697648912668228, -0.00023508879530709237, 0.03217620402574539, -0.02038070186972618, 0.001862366683781147, -0.06308942288160324, -0.06157112866640091, 0.018550479784607887, -0.01711304485797882, 0.015057983808219433, 0.023190567269921303, -0.025482892990112305, 0.051328957080841064, 0.04841519147157669, -0.029374483972787857, -0.01423090510070324, -0.026686305180191994, -0.01864430494606495, 0.006033335346728563, 0.015877965837717056, -0.0007626123842783272, -0.002470445353537798, 0.02295948751270771, 0.034821704030036926, 0.00592693081125617, 0.03714817762374878, -0.038121651858091354, 0.010654888115823269, 0.006356194149702787, -0.002190551022067666, -0.011249078437685966, 0.011651724576950073, 0.03296414017677307, -0.00011155034007970244, 0.04185926169157028, 0.020486455410718918, 0.0025621301028877497, -0.01577654667198658, -0.024724995717406273, -0.02508128620684147, 0.010036522522568703, -0.003114622551947832, -0.04282839968800545, 0.029028646647930145, 0.01665426418185234, -0.007210555952042341, 0.022627541795372963, -0.01751089096069336, 0.048455074429512024, -0.032290540635585785, 0.01946718990802765, 0.04908156767487526, 0.03269580751657486, -0.02742163836956024, -0.029383180662989616, -0.04697871580719948, -0.008142296224832535, -0.01738860458135605, -0.024350633844733238, -0.020814044401049614, 0.012848448939621449, 0.02772553265094757, 0.03211970254778862, -0.04006046801805496, -0.047101691365242004, 0.031213313341140747, -0.04948250576853752, -0.03036092221736908, -0.019576052203774452, 0.05377974361181259, 0.009046457707881927, 0.044324859976768494, 0.020888252183794975, 0.0014486293075606227, 0.018320349976420403, -0.03111099638044834, -0.04266919195652008, 0.020477933809161186, -0.019171321764588356, 0.025635337457060814, -0.005943064112216234, -0.01616043597459793, 0.0182033684104681, -0.007457064930349588, -0.002327804919332266, -0.016638897359371185, 0.028460117056965828, -0.04279507324099541, -0.00830629002302885, -0.053438831120729446, -0.026297418400645256, 0.031240759417414665, 0.02131631225347519, 0.004531817510724068, -0.025270670652389526, 0.04307854175567627, 0.04089679196476936, -0.038544151932001114, -0.009428421966731548, -0.006786658428609371, 0.009482829831540585, 0.003943357151001692, 0.046545449644327164, 0.013059407472610474, 0.044880110770463943, -0.03135786950588226, 0.017340561375021935, -0.02238212339580059, 0.01926967315375805, 0.05808888375759125, -0.038673918694257736, -0.022314617410302162, -0.03321133181452751, -0.01602298952639103, -0.0034136176109313965, 0.010598470456898212, -0.02260213904082775, -0.019914139062166214, 0.050661951303482056, 0.039266105741262436, -0.055791858583688736, 0.02432950586080551, 0.04980715736746788, 0.037158865481615067, 0.00427901279181242, 0.003739007515832782, 0.019019030034542084, -0.009588459506630898, -0.020766081288456917, 0.02390216290950775, 0.01875676028430462, 0.016013823449611664, 0.0053451103158295155, 0.04268427565693855, -0.061166856437921524, -0.09220291674137115, 0.01077759824693203, -0.01802493818104267, 0.028762051835656166, -0.0019498395267874002, -0.037960126996040344, 0.005600318778306246, 0.04957456514239311, 0.048992086201906204, 0.03138691559433937, -0.011252498254179955, -0.10520922392606735, -0.010477256961166859, 0.0532277375459671, 0.03240591660141945, -0.02231597527861595, -0.0166587233543396, -0.054341912269592285, 0.007078326307237148, 0.046299178153276443, -0.0397406741976738, 0.012019307352602482, 0.003590435953810811, 0.04133932292461395, 0.01614629663527012, -0.034372661262750626, -0.011313462629914284, 0.03193394094705582, 0.0013364875921979547, 0.01591918244957924, 0.024514412507414818, -0.04270915314555168, -0.035221293568611145, 0.024442987516522408, 0.019450124353170395, 0.04823997616767883, -0.011731976643204689, -0.03881116956472397, -0.0033303278032690287, 0.012984772212803364, -0.03666548803448677, -0.030420036986470222, 0.011990837752819061, -0.005818729754537344, -0.01251833513379097, 0.07227946817874908, -0.010848618112504482, -0.02339787594974041, 0.022988907992839813, 0.02116544172167778, -0.012560694478452206, 0.0018146298825740814, -0.010288795456290245, 0.015137521550059319, 0.03190501034259796, 0.012631054036319256, 0.018315888941287994, 0.02118312567472458, -0.025423675775527954, 0.02604900486767292, -0.01366641279309988, 0.012684726156294346, -0.04034486413002014, -0.00429451884701848, -0.028005439788103104, -0.012353016994893551, -0.025854390114545822, 0.006372771225869656, 0.0037320032715797424, 0.0314018689095974, -0.04258010908961296, 0.010132544673979282, -0.010409228503704071, -0.018761858344078064, -0.030358707532286644, -0.03536446765065193, 0.005083000753074884, 0.002083416795358062, -0.00954827293753624, 0.004361128434538841, 0.039986561983823776, -0.010046758688986301, 0.02648964524269104, -0.02010773867368698, -0.03692527115345001, 0.02589227631688118, -0.0013047155225649476, 0.02406134456396103, 0.00540141062811017, -0.04690321162343025, 0.07096728682518005, -0.004529165104031563, 0.014634337276220322, -0.004245436750352383, -0.023216381669044495, -0.02234060689806938, -0.000311325304210186, -0.03175169229507446, 0.021036336198449135, -0.027330776676535606, 0.02118825726211071, -0.015869777649641037, -0.017440252006053925, -0.05151280015707016, -0.022631514817476273, -0.003902530064806342, 0.01718507520854473, -0.008008508011698723, -0.0471726655960083, 0.041008539497852325, 0.007321404758840799, 0.007278484757989645, -0.03362211585044861, 0.03277600184082985, 0.0005467029404826462, 0.009578125551342964, 0.008424904197454453, -0.009647100232541561, 0.0796702653169632, 0.011971927247941494, -0.028261631727218628, 0.039954885840415955, 0.002947398694232106, 0.000259116553934291, -0.006007727235555649, 0.026147257536649704, -0.03980096057057381, -0.030348045751452446, -0.00019299554696772248, 0.0046134465374052525, 0.02452458068728447, -0.013606538064777851, 0.04151434451341629, 0.010668057948350906, 0.0074469177052378654, -0.004511041101068258, -0.010351289995014668, -0.01913740672171116, -0.03255545347929001, -0.004053816664963961, -0.06796493381261826, 0.008078199811279774, 0.009141204878687859, -0.016201915219426155, 0.03482583910226822, 0.022994646802544594, 0.0163965355604887, 0.02048923820257187, 0.06566420942544937, 0.025725925341248512, 0.002742467448115349, 0.027229592204093933, -0.011194271966814995, 0.022788111120462418, 0.0007170464377850294, -0.03344180807471275, 0.009349409490823746, 0.03056395798921585, -0.02123568207025528, 0.006545140407979488, -0.059881165623664856, 0.006016762461513281, 0.08068055659532547, 0.0019148424034938216, 0.040110450237989426, 0.018951058387756348, 0.018172480165958405, 0.028471730649471283, -0.026600191369652748, -0.04329615831375122, 0.0027471850626170635, 0.006584540940821171, 0.02760124020278454, -0.00929254014045, 0.04240356758236885, 0.02838677167892456, 0.003125008661299944, 0.01537057664245367, -0.007239885162562132, -0.00787899736315012, 0.03924940153956413, 0.023874154314398766, -0.006056332960724831, -0.0161318089812994, 0.018038876354694366, -0.02050239033997059, -0.0016737710684537888, -0.05130163952708244, -0.04538546875119209, 0.03024502657353878, 0.02366536669433117, 0.0008276295848190784, -0.05968422070145607, -0.057235606014728546, -0.04677371308207512, 0.033171579241752625, 0.009504951536655426, -0.01131719071418047, 0.014670468866825104, 0.0350063256919384, 0.016408441588282585, 0.00018376021762378514, 0.036592382937669754, -0.027435658499598503, -0.0526600256562233, -0.048639941960573196, 0.0026286866050213575, -0.03458006680011749, -0.002324024448171258, -0.007567196618765593, -0.00959780253469944, 0.024993592873215675, -0.03628772124648094, 0.016559908166527748, -0.004656190052628517, 0.02031484805047512, 0.007287139538675547, 0.051195450127124786, -0.010015337727963924, 0.013935055583715439, 0.01854575239121914, -0.0052124084904789925, 0.12839053571224213, 0.09875554591417313, 0.06393032521009445, -0.03573299199342728, 0.0135001540184021, 0.015939118340611458, -0.013335966505110264, -0.05750783905386925, 0.053887203335762024, 0.014568633399903774, -0.0011770850978791714, 0.034612517803907394, 0.024326492100954056, 0.040814824402332306, 0.025234851986169815, 0.05613658204674721, -0.0535736083984375, -0.02083970420062542, -0.013094175606966019, -0.0025021203327924013, 0.03520422428846359, -0.05402201786637306, -0.0667852908372879, 0.05344796180725098, 0.016738643869757652, -0.010236959904432297, -0.034256890416145325, -0.016367526724934578, -0.038318175822496414, 0.029092028737068176, 0.024690229445695877, 0.0016981794033199549, -0.005976737476885319, 0.017415080219507217, 0.023595117032527924, 0.0029406968969851732, 0.042015254497528076, -0.036965806037187576, -0.006031927186995745, 0.024991806596517563, -0.008792263455688953, -0.009473564103245735, -0.03441494330763817, 0.008471189998090267, -0.04641850292682648, -0.003606438636779785, -0.025820745155215263, -0.009877101518213749, 0.0021021096035838127, 0.009304303675889969, -0.007559368386864662, -0.03416739031672478, 0.002419494790956378, -0.044307366013526917, 0.008358020335435867, 0.05665448680520058, 0.03527626022696495, 0.0028554622549563646, -0.046986110508441925, 0.01894277334213257, 0.029514437541365623, 0.002620500745251775, 0.016932806000113487, 0.024509120732545853, -0.006012715864926577, -0.06344752758741379, -0.07433067262172699, 0.03085372969508171, 0.005147330462932587, -0.011153277941048145, -0.01617303304374218, -0.014285153709352016, -0.02068975567817688, -0.02742784656584263, -0.014239925891160965, 0.013963517732918262, -0.0013782060705125332, 0.0069107916206121445, 0.0021802233532071114, -0.024627426639199257, -0.045835185796022415, 0.045496899634599686, -0.019201718270778656, -0.05890326574444771, -0.04322200268507004, -0.00995184388011694, 0.039782825857400894, 0.04989233985543251, 0.02578151598572731, 0.031030695885419846, -0.005315424408763647, 0.040036220103502274, 0.00031955173471942544, -0.05849052220582962, -0.014564840123057365, -0.00025914632715284824, -0.03144477307796478, -0.013597839511930943, 0.022587887942790985, 0.07828265428543091, 0.004023575223982334, -0.01048336923122406, 0.014193219132721424, 0.04069088399410248, -0.03178228810429573, 0.028655892238020897, 0.0044682263396680355, -0.060574352741241455, 0.010390635579824448, -0.002011555479839444, -0.024373456835746765, -0.053650617599487305, -0.011235542595386505, -0.02034349925816059, 0.012670233845710754, 0.01710340566933155, -0.028558406978845596, -0.03395633026957512, -0.01464361697435379, -0.007428174372762442, 0.01705082878470421, 0.0013159498339518905, 0.023752890527248383, 0.011280398815870285, -0.002664078725501895, -0.02534579299390316, 0.022988278418779373, -0.02210880070924759, -0.01924273744225502, -0.050047196447849274, -0.015908438712358475, 0.0038600806146860123, -0.02225779928267002, 0.004615724086761475, -0.015763910487294197, 0.0014739495236426592, 0.0016277878312394023, 0.02792094461619854, 0.012062919326126575, -0.010505041107535362, 0.013742725364863873, -0.05431064963340759, -0.0059369937516748905, -0.0049854363314807415, -0.0038550489116460085, 0.05799512937664986, 0.03314900025725365, 0.008937720209360123, -0.025481754913926125, 0.04167816787958145, -0.03798903897404671, -0.015471233986318111, -0.002280553337186575, -0.011899186298251152, 0.03852491080760956, 0.01805896870791912, 0.032702893018722534, 0.01606578379869461, 0.0012572119012475014, 0.01504658255726099, 0.0800333172082901, 0.005059034563601017, -0.006694528739899397, -0.016990313306450844, 0.004128085914999247, 0.0180944986641407, 0.023394716903567314, -0.010165787301957607, 0.0501127690076828, 0.04679381847381592, -0.03567661717534065, 0.013482916168868542, 0.010952348820865154, -0.003921983763575554, -0.07986876368522644, -0.025063980370759964, 0.0006447440246120095, -0.04191598668694496, 0.06009453907608986, -0.03613824024796486, 0.023127594962716103, 0.01698918640613556, -0.02494359388947487, 0.03158944100141525, 0.037092454731464386, 0.0024959684815257788, -0.029552221298217773, 0.03401082381606102, -0.02328386716544628, 0.029991885647177696, -0.0073150936514139175, 0.006360724102705717, 0.06125178933143616, -0.010495767928659916, 0.003605165285989642, -0.024078983813524246, 0.001417160383425653, 0.04585186764597893, -0.013149121776223183, -0.04787444323301315, 0.059281665831804276, -0.042784858494997025, -0.011339101009070873, 0.05631209909915924, 0.015307203866541386, 0.04631359130144119, 0.010171707719564438, 0.006571382749825716, -0.010158970952033997, 0.0532122477889061, 0.012377897277474403, -0.0002759430790320039, -0.014986855909228325, 0.011239641346037388, 0.04930198937654495, 0.038958001881837845, 0.01729644648730755, 0.04818343743681908, 0.049521781504154205, -0.020537156611680984, 0.004881914705038071, 0.00331086665391922, 0.023861536756157875, 0.005490490235388279, -0.02391328662633896, 0.005257501732558012, -0.006620644126087427, 0.000004140046712564072, -0.004583441652357578, -0.05917254090309143, 0.04212173447012901, 0.026202820241451263, -0.04400404542684555, -0.014588839374482632, 0.025669170543551445, 0.012294959276914597, -0.06285063922405243, -0.014744997024536133, -0.0000023865370621933835, -0.05050206556916237, -0.0250255074352026, 0.030996793881058693, 0.012232303619384766, -0.03387424722313881, -0.07485910505056381, -0.006707265041768551, -0.0396563820540905, 0.05640845000743866, -0.03432447835803032, 0.013217260129749775, 0.029894275590777397, 0.01834935136139393, 0.014181889593601227, -0.06689052283763885, 0.07963328808546066, 0.015115453861653805, -0.010875326581299305, -0.059413086622953415, -0.04115511104464531, 0.004388346802443266, -0.006279837340116501, 0.06740079075098038, 0.01416904479265213, 0.014384187757968903, -0.03708536922931671, -0.0012592354323714972, -0.0057257357984781265, -0.05385144427418709, 0.04242090880870819, 0.01344049908220768, -0.03529665619134903, -0.06888971477746964, 0.014359815046191216, 0.020096777006983757, -0.016740646213293076, -0.014042827300727367, -0.02091371640563011, -0.019375057891011238, -0.011006306856870651, 0.020721375942230225, 0.0026871548034250736, -0.02448265813291073, 0.009161802940070629, 0.04705116152763367, 0.02479737438261509, 0.023425664752721786, 0.03987925499677658, 0.017633140087127686, -0.048758912831544876, 0.06806513667106628, -0.00471836281940341, -0.048567842692136765, 0.007272412534803152, -0.020794441923499107, -0.027651740238070488, -0.08449496328830719, -0.0023735896684229374, 0.04657972604036331, -0.029020993039011955, 0.011573098599910736, -0.0027562242466956377, 0.008837453089654446, 0.03810945525765419, 0.018235644325613976, 0.005034247413277626, 0.011559532023966312, -0.03501511737704277, 0.040485139936208725, 0.012621358036994934, 0.03825012966990471, 0.009696921333670616, 0.04628608003258705, 0.002229818142950535, -0.022250477224588394, 0.029737524688243866, 0.005810210946947336, 0.019391588866710663, -0.043811287730932236, -0.01085736881941557, -0.002996268216520548, 0.0009017831762321293, 0.004229461774230003, -0.02459399774670601, -0.007046594750136137, 0.056075431406497955, -0.02512454241514206, 0.013728363439440727, -0.05175231769680977, 0.007019043434411287, -0.04422156140208244, -0.03266914188861847, -0.013182665221393108, 0.015436598099768162, -0.00019328533380758017, 0.006956558208912611, -0.007308416999876499, -0.025073377415537834, -0.0320168100297451, -0.03909209370613098, 0.04462435096502304, -0.004521127324551344, 0.000765893782954663, -0.02400493621826172, -0.035978030413389206, -0.02076427824795246, 0.0001444004592485726, 0.0009229606948792934, 0.025363663211464882, 0.017131365835666656, -0.006257784552872181, 0.008309001103043556, -0.01827980950474739, 0.03645901754498482, -0.041076723486185074, 0.00674690306186676, -0.0692300945520401, 0.0100135812535882, -0.009794453158974648, -0.01574506051838398 ]
<p>Official stats on how many videos (rather than how many hours or what volume of data) seem quite hard to come by. </p> <p>My current idea is something like this:</p> <p>A youtube URL is like: <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w1sjRD7NSec" rel="nofollow">http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w1sjRD7NSec</a></p> <p>where</p> <pre><code> id = w1sjRD7NSec </code></pre> <p>Assuming that each character in the id can be upper (26) or lower (26) case letter or number (10)</p> <p>the number of combinations should be</p> <pre><code> = (26 + 26 +10 ) ^ 11 = 62^11 = 5.2 x 10 ^19 </code></pre> <p>So if I write a script to try random urls of 100/1000/whatever videos, and Z% are successful, then will </p> <pre><code> Z% x 5.2 x 10 ^19 </code></pre> <p>give me the number of videos that exist (or at least are downloadable), albeit with a very low confidence?</p>
12,795
[ -0.029188022017478943, -0.05201198160648346, 0.0021192266140133142, -0.022254232317209244, 0.04068801924586296, -0.003387455129995942, -0.004584415350109339, -0.03511393070220947, -0.013231998309493065, 0.005000187084078789, -0.0013463929062709212, 0.06656070053577423, 0.028606612235307693, 0.023774515837430954, 0.04313156381249428, -0.0009081034222617745, -0.0014619542052969337, -0.009670797735452652, 0.017011301591992378, 0.023699039593338966, -0.0043944488279521465, 0.03019433282315731, 0.025050561875104904, 0.0006691843154840171, -0.032989371567964554, -0.016897166147828102, 0.02583306096494198, -0.020548265427350998, 0.01791948452591896, 0.018007496371865273, -0.03390362858772278, -0.03696808964014053, 0.044441256672143936, 0.06678718328475952, 0.029997728765010834, 0.013767626136541367, -0.041596248745918274, -0.025007957592606544, -0.041040826588869095, -0.0026713970582932234, -0.009676788933575153, 0.024575617164373398, -0.047612473368644714, 0.02248213440179825, -0.0016371150268241763, 0.0077568041160702705, -0.020244335755705833, -0.006646633613854647, 0.03111577033996582, -0.05085694417357445, 0.09756667166948318, 0.01197410374879837, 0.036989253014326096, 0.013273775577545166, -0.03448650240898132, -0.003401472233235836, 0.06029872968792915, 0.05738203600049019, -0.014249315485358238, -0.04678359627723694, -0.011637957766652107, -0.02613573521375656, -0.008736430667340755, -0.031228750944137573, -0.031682200729846954, 0.02590281143784523, 0.0016975394682958722, 0.015512622892856598, 0.025543471798300743, -0.009091770276427269, 0.011437790468335152, 0.03426843881607056, 0.042698655277490616, 0.004615534096956253, 0.009537740610539913, -0.04001815617084503, 0.039619579911231995, 0.01059382501989603, 0.030811090022325516, 0.0595034696161747, -0.03796776384115219, -0.02697458304464817, 0.004144763574004173, 0.01051631011068821, 0.07143892347812653, 0.0030448068864643574, 0.05576978996396065, -0.02861516736447811, -0.002827433170750737, 0.00654470082372427, -0.013896089047193527, -0.03370512276887894, 0.04269879683852196, 0.04365219548344612, -0.030977485701441765, 0.04544447362422943, -0.03696836531162262, 0.05993175134062767, 0.002940064063295722, -0.030493510887026787, 0.0027358410879969597, -0.014948260970413685, -0.0008864380652084947, 0.07661473006010056, -0.04497223719954491, -0.024010516703128815, -0.03132779151201248, -0.033706605434417725, -0.029675548896193504, -0.009554953314363956, 0.01631457358598709, 0.02886667475104332, 0.013659941963851452, -0.02489881031215191, -0.0036569845397025347, -0.011422482319176197, 0.016651857644319534, 0.00965252798050642, 0.04538875073194504, 0.043765436857938766, 0.04402954876422882, -0.024397091940045357, 0.03453464433550835, -0.07172536849975586, -0.008435233496129513, -0.01892159879207611, -0.003143848618492484, -0.006820407696068287, -0.010129256173968315, 0.043562889099121094, -0.03772253170609474, -0.026333287358283997, 0.02037518471479416, -0.00923143420368433, 0.05801238864660263, -0.017453297972679138, -0.0509200282394886, -0.053445421159267426, 0.0382341593503952, -0.016222845762968063, -0.005820834543555975, -0.03928836062550545, 0.05343034490942955, 0.01155715063214302, 0.018446680158376694, 0.00240546022541821, 0.03941332921385765, 0.022278685122728348, -0.0034733526408672333, 0.020306896418333054, -0.06731769442558289, 0.016038402915000916, 0.00621012644842267, -0.01322546973824501, 0.0034984645899385214, -0.07671718299388885, 0.031239302828907967, 0.007213927805423737, 0.011472804471850395, -0.010597181506454945, 0.001155572128482163, -0.0007355219568125904, -0.031499773263931274, 0.012399345636367798, 0.014552190899848938, -0.04620957002043724, 0.06838840991258621, 0.02791462652385235, 0.07183081656694412, 0.04526503384113312, -0.046052053570747375, -0.008977710269391537, 0.06332606822252274, -0.010987646877765656, 0.06813765317201614, 0.02087029442191124, 0.014087244868278503, -0.0321185402572155, 0.044090453535318375, 0.011061407625675201, -0.016245152801275253, -0.03162868693470955, -0.023541148751974106, 0.002009703777730465, 0.04422842711210251, 0.03849227726459503, 0.012135927565395832, 0.005605834536254406, 0.034099988639354706, -0.04730657488107681, -0.01509189885109663, -0.03478635475039482, 0.012495598755776882, 0.006846656557172537, -0.007161295041441917, 0.010763023048639297, -0.0032735359854996204, 0.03701861947774887, 0.010369808413088322, -0.01661759242415428, -0.03315988928079605, 0.008389444090425968, 0.03991726413369179, -0.01934885047376156, -0.03164297342300415, 0.05731279030442238, 0.017308365553617477, -0.039589621126651764, 0.07742731273174286, -0.057236198335886, -0.06455481052398682, -0.03918619453907013, -0.03764032945036888, 0.017421914264559746, 0.004399470053613186, -0.024228643625974655, 0.0355713777244091, 0.023759352043271065, -0.01602482609450817, 0.014184598810970783, -0.044537946581840515, 0.0589018277823925, 0.06069009378552437, 0.08056473731994629, -0.0047487677074968815, -0.03215295821428299, 0.004477492533624172, -0.005486172158271074, -0.009895458817481995, 0.0031343235168606043, -0.06785088777542114, -0.00728073064237833, 0.052735503762960434, -0.004412464797496796, -0.05865743011236191, -0.004070568829774857, 0.05822288244962692, -0.00003705457129399292, 0.010653184726834297, 0.04764563962817192, -0.021047115325927734, 0.007714219391345978, -0.013384988531470299, 0.03226449340581894, 0.0281638465821743, 0.030809246003627777, -0.024454530328512192, 0.025279520079493523, -0.0025037266314029694, 0.007001424208283424, -0.013149580918252468, -0.02410484105348587, 0.004179474897682667, -0.007914558984339237, -0.028946341946721077, -0.009587710723280907, 0.018078450113534927, 0.009150154888629913, -0.03926874324679375, 0.03671225905418396, 0.026644980534911156, -0.007563353981822729, -0.0188736729323864, -0.04399442300200462, -0.0024389696773141623, 0.015718672424554825, -0.05191526561975479, -0.02958739921450615, 0.026653774082660675, 0.00514448806643486, 0.006900690030306578, -0.03233826905488968, -0.002348268171772361, -0.054803963750600815, 0.04018266126513481, -0.009636519476771355, -0.0018844042206183076, 0.04171345382928848, -0.03703002259135246, -0.0281708762049675, -0.01819019205868244, -0.01525144837796688, 0.013157323934137821, 0.0037083798088133335, -0.04127918928861618, -0.011863794177770615, 0.04588484764099121, -0.03866622596979141, 0.02328314259648323, -0.022452132776379585, -0.01653917320072651, 0.009561263024806976, 0.003841415513306856, -0.021147290244698524, -0.011540595442056656, -0.023832498118281364, 0.05252356827259064, -0.02911164052784443, 0.0030650703702121973, 0.02532835118472576, -0.0016974132740870118, -0.10376477241516113, 0.05184153839945793, -0.034210581332445145, -0.06756661087274551, -0.02973976545035839, 0.01124873012304306, 0.002881149062886834, -0.07823711633682251, 0.004556059837341309, 0.020410826429724693, 0.022600708529353142, 0.019033148884773254, -0.052329570055007935, -0.04318734630942345, 0.008063243702054024, 0.023283572867512703, 0.0413363054394722, 0.019813530147075653, -0.012491602450609207, 0.07271876931190491, -0.007996216416358948, -0.015122667886316776, -0.0313759483397007, -0.026167254894971848, 0.024956444278359413, -0.011459413915872574, 0.033371422439813614, 0.0145779550075531, -0.03308805078268051, 0.00007977056520758197, 0.0179847851395607, 0.0030198106542229652, 0.05846906825900078, -0.005360578186810017, 0.025843212381005287, 0.020835058763623238, 0.024908948689699173, -0.02863895706832409, 0.0323992483317852, 0.06871285289525986, -0.017806267365813255, 0.02416503243148327, -0.0038226956967264414, 0.027035098522901535, -0.010617285966873169, -0.05281967297196388, 0.02617807872593403, 0.0013659207616001368, 0.03273839130997658, -0.007491952273994684, 0.007642886135727167, -0.019791176542639732, -0.03882049024105072, -0.003607182763516903, 0.045295294374227524, 0.05948399752378464, -0.02899111807346344, -0.016653725877404213, 0.02910732850432396, 0.09038858860731125, -0.030594682320952415, -0.015840299427509308, -0.029148703441023827, -0.011089972220361233, -0.025965610519051552, 0.008228226564824581, -0.016200346872210503, 0.05310530588030815, 0.030987922102212906, -0.0007010081899352372, 0.005022766999900341, -0.0034201759845018387, 0.004199600778520107, -0.0770888477563858, -0.027780435979366302, -0.06645546108484268, 0.01755983941257, -0.010827925056219101, 0.05120863392949104, 0.0008130538044497371, 0.007687416858971119, -0.007537372875958681, 0.03239847719669342, -0.08698021620512009, 0.01750490441918373, -0.008672727271914482, -0.012369493953883648, -0.04580847918987274, -0.04149125516414642, 0.02570979855954647, 0.003782328451052308, 0.037068527191877365, 0.012012987397611141, 0.016167547553777695, -0.03155295178294182, 0.017006834968924522, -0.002106494503095746, 0.010987484827637672, -0.006863788701593876, 0.0029868094716221094, 0.011217726394534111, 0.030353659763932228, 0.014633014798164368, -0.008771545253694057, -0.015352078713476658, -0.034310098737478256, -0.004651916213333607, 0.015510091558098793, -0.005293332971632481, 0.002496342873200774, 0.003865049686282873, 0.04607853665947914, -0.01270480640232563, -0.008878268301486969, -0.04133651778101921, 0.009353862144052982, 0.031358830630779266, 0.02352341264486313, -0.0009783994173631072, -0.06695977598428726, 0.010871580801904202, 0.029910216107964516, -0.018212975934147835, -0.021242540329694748, 0.03133782744407654, 0.03828119859099388, -0.008506887592375278, -0.018125610426068306, 0.02448822557926178, 0.089017353951931, -0.02625245228409767, -0.02126469835639, -0.0290392879396677, -0.023698583245277405, 0.001779395155608654, -0.0023702187463641167, -0.02557712234556675, -0.0023758970201015472, 0.020593946799635887, 0.006722106598317623, 0.008577789179980755, -0.03884759917855263, -0.04611656442284584, 0.04300522059202194, -0.02561095543205738, 0.07169097661972046, -0.013457597233355045, -0.014211433008313179, -0.0074203950352966785, 0.026814909651875496, 0.010375600308179855, -0.005230030044913292, -0.021667638793587685, -0.07755453884601593, -0.007334166206419468, 0.07797613739967346, 0.0851401835680008, -0.04160938784480095, -0.01879073865711689, -0.05790704861283302, -0.016563845798373222, 0.020813383162021637, -0.0359775684773922, 0.05228568613529205, -0.0006575020961463451, -0.002614829456433654, -0.023644011467695236, -0.029103366658091545, -0.0015992603730410337, -0.002085093641653657, -0.05022227019071579, 0.011037907563149929, -0.015780912712216377, 0.006448035594075918, -0.039037108421325684, 0.06850603222846985, 0.050591256469488144, 0.058759115636348724, -0.040445830672979355, 0.0015457595000043511, -0.017072340473532677, 0.004353594034910202, -0.01666886918246746, -0.0569329559803009, 0.01553194411098957, -0.0031135715544223785, -0.018250593915581703, 0.039577875286340714, -0.02294827066361904, -0.03256906941533089, 0.04701128229498863, 0.03978656977415085, -0.004768475890159607, 0.005567129235714674, 0.00447143753990531, -0.0068331509828567505, 0.029577286913990974, 0.02493416517972946, 0.03181793540716171, 0.03928004577755928, 0.016821306198835373, 0.021765779703855515, -0.014297427609562874, 0.019857529550790787, 0.004320646170526743, 0.018180234357714653, -0.03828342631459236, 0.0039231195114552975, -0.046950146555900574, 0.024043750017881393, 0.015077703632414341, 0.024405578151345253, -0.040027081966400146, 0.009205320850014687, -0.001561950659379363, 0.05433127284049988, 0.01247680839151144, 0.00574718602001667, 0.04923778772354126, 0.004634209908545017, -0.04353775456547737, 0.021198999136686325, 0.021183012053370476, -0.007205875590443611, 0.01565634086728096, 0.003726223949342966, -0.032320328056812286, -0.014000795781612396, -0.012703374028205872, -0.010092917829751968, 0.054453860968351364, -0.0020051817409694195, 0.03271985799074173, -0.021495439112186432, -0.006942624691873789, 0.021427592262625694, -0.028019195422530174, 0.001790656242519617, 0.007700272835791111, -0.0032594173680990934, 0.032126519829034805, -0.005903302691876888, 0.018424415960907936, -0.012689433060586452, -0.03762325271964073, -0.06639637053012848, -0.060746930539608, 0.05255425348877907, 0.005022185388952494, -0.026621393859386444, -0.0363633893430233, -0.012322659604251385, 0.0072863660752773285, 0.0053428662940859795, -0.014353499747812748, 0.03413459658622742, -0.04497580602765083, -0.003623257391154766, -0.013021443039178848, 0.010686080902814865, 0.056032031774520874, 0.02648039162158966, -0.01974426954984665, 0.0027594631537795067, 0.025974124670028687, -0.0035459822975099087, 0.01763617992401123, -0.010059854947030544, -0.03592918813228607, -0.010526194237172604, -0.019046692177653313, -0.000003115946128673386, 0.04348895326256752, -0.03021099418401718, -0.014941142871975899, -0.019846362993121147, 0.02936670370399952, 0.03281618282198906, -0.06492672115564346, 0.014362569898366928, 0.02456403337419033, -0.017716936767101288, -0.0010194384958595037, 0.009030735120177269, -0.053606681525707245, 0.012721068225800991, 0.006885550916194916, 0.010485412552952766, -0.011261402629315853, -0.0171803068369627, 0.0488334558904171, 0.015545845963060856, 0.0017549635376781225, -0.015619417652487755, -0.01726381480693817, 0.04332743212580681, -0.01941743493080139, 0.008265407755970955, 0.038460031151771545, 0.02808600291609764, -0.01534118503332138, -0.039333950728178024, -0.03997524455189705, -0.01296098344027996, 0.05537865310907364, 0.013504340313374996, 0.0034444122575223446, 0.04446011409163475, 0.0023519464302808046, 0.027665672823786736, 0.02656913548707962, -0.01482928916811943, 0.006835725158452988, 0.05400073155760765, 0.009574657306075096, 0.03247402608394623, -0.0055189551785588264, 0.04044058173894882, -0.020372740924358368, 0.07039076834917068, 0.005607299506664276, 0.06677339226007462, -0.013824284076690674, 0.04230836033821106, -0.08141408115625381, -0.037471238523721695, 0.004474503453820944, -0.04601217433810234, 0.026151439175009727, 0.010143480263650417, -0.017763551324605942, 0.04335266724228859, 0.0081477090716362, -0.008616598322987556, -0.025972476229071617, -0.03931637108325958, -0.032365743070840836, 0.012681576423346996, 0.006999512203037739, 0.02236105129122734, 0.005993332713842392, -0.05569453537464142, 0.036333270370960236, 0.03376706689596176, 0.05847196280956268, -0.0005356187466531992, -0.07673317939043045, 0.002496464876458049, 0.010720372200012207, -0.06799052655696869, 0.05116794630885124, 0.04553557559847832, 0.0035170582123100758, -0.0016261537093669176, -0.03892157971858978, 0.021716676652431488, 0.03651872277259827, 0.06796689331531525, -0.04903135076165199, 0.056850533932447433, 0.010026787407696247, 0.03063044138252735, -0.0067179566249251366, -0.03989633172750473, 0.10519124567508698, 0.07325363904237747, 0.003069296246394515, -0.022740937769412994, -0.005433342885226011, 0.0032389804255217314, -0.003947094082832336, -0.03888917341828346, 0.011385494843125343, 0.015008952468633652, -0.018690085038542747, 0.07446462661027908, -0.006951251067221165, -0.012508044019341469, -0.012301953509449959, 0.03678669035434723, -0.03898797556757927, -0.027855854481458664, 0.013964379206299782, 0.007873396389186382, -0.00969504565000534, -0.027258025482296944, -0.06543852388858795, 0.0020611018408089876, 0.002485748380422592, -0.031102975830435753, -0.03264324739575386, -0.020695719867944717, -0.026591649278998375, 0.01745573803782463, -0.02497432939708233, 0.0025874862913042307, 0.0027953339740633965, -0.013540007174015045, 0.0168113075196743, 0.004715782590210438, -0.007416482083499432, -0.0025949301198124886, 0.008265573531389236, 0.06494400650262833, 0.018539801239967346, -0.0023312147241085768, -0.02867714874446392, -0.00015919531870167702, -0.06335986405611038, -0.0012737773358821869, -0.05786541476845741, 0.01447215024381876, -0.007069115526974201, 0.001211504335515201, -0.038155172020196915, -0.020081287249922752, -0.02623135596513748, -0.03796190768480301, -0.011974404565989971, 0.025930020958185196, 0.043962713330984116, -0.012054580263793468, -0.002301516244187951, -0.004626442212611437, -0.004002907779067755, -0.0041040885262191296, 0.03333505988121033, 0.009670454077422619, -0.014735744334757328, -0.0017086939187720418, -0.022716717794537544, 0.040279533714056015, -0.006736298091709614, -0.0013322943123057485, -0.004973710514605045, -0.030014917254447937, -0.036592405289411545, -0.012258959002792835, 0.01728205941617489, -0.011935887858271599, 0.030893046408891678, 0.006788697559386492, 0.004041884560137987, -0.016185641288757324, 0.010710295289754868, 0.0007556095370091498, -0.021837985143065453, -0.023264525458216667, -0.05506183207035065, 0.03009307198226452, 0.016928192228078842, 0.018688246607780457, -0.012151848524808884, 0.0219161007553339, -0.008678029291331768, 0.043185777962207794, -0.004923617001622915, -0.019865289330482483, -0.037890926003456116, -0.0007195905200205743, -0.013764636591076851, -0.035320449620485306, -0.0007434551371261477, 0.045897845178842545, 0.030566316097974777, -0.0036009284667670727, 0.014313380233943462, -0.018978377804160118, -0.0004864716320298612, 0.02448057383298874, -0.014893983490765095, -0.05890415608882904, -0.025246331468224525, -0.016490355134010315, 0.011401919648051262, -0.02468833513557911, 0.0012260022340342402, -0.008528170175850391, -0.01561184786260128, 0.0465191975235939, -0.014525695703923702, -0.030507920309901237, -0.01956394501030445, -0.023743929341435432, 0.019142096862196922, 0.0028339114505797625, -0.00737288361415267, -0.010528759099543095, 0.018659207969903946, -0.01934627629816532, 0.01635706052184105, -0.009371754713356495, 0.008099991828203201, -0.0032708796206861734, -0.01590709574520588, 0.0211948212236166, 0.027745520696043968, 0.009835101664066315, -0.03117607720196247, 0.01234496384859085, -0.038099177181720734, 0.013624786399304867, -0.03853882849216461, -0.07186605781316757, 0.0342661589384079, -0.04096712917089462, -0.042280424386262894, 0.04351293668150902, -0.015792807564139366, 0.02204711362719536, 0.02915002778172493, -0.014232919551432133, 0.0065183015540242195, 0.05982106551527977, 0.007223160937428474, -0.021405255421996117, 0.026033228263258934, 0.015142276883125305, 0.02429119497537613, 0.011621130630373955, 0.020795034244656563, 0.017773058265447617, 0.0038676909171044827, -0.007788767106831074, 0.054819345474243164, 0.034598808735609055, -0.0026814641896635294, 0.02852059155702591, 0.018646888434886932, 0.032742924988269806, 0.002837748033925891, -0.003963611554354429, 0.008492880500853062, 0.013811769895255566, -0.036804694682359695, 0.04251205548644066, 0.0019279131665825844, 0.014512695372104645, -0.06460355222225189, -0.02206648513674736, 0.016860321164131165, 0.006902738474309444, 0.021394358947873116, -0.04537709802389145, 0.0031262461561709642, 0.013751803897321224, -0.07543310523033142, 0.019376017153263092, 0.006272903177887201, -0.018630456179380417, -0.03684878349304199, 0.05782696604728699, -0.004923741798847914, 0.014977334067225456, 0.031262416392564774, 0.03825320303440094, 0.03887002170085907, 0.010333841666579247, -0.038193266838788986, -0.0014146717730909586, 0.02148221619427204, -0.006911690346896648, 0.0017686726059764624, -0.034971583634614944, 0.04356136918067932, -0.0160687118768692, -0.02250032126903534, 0.006216969806700945, -0.007558399345725775, 0.028027109801769257, 0.010835031047463417, 0.04019344970583916, -0.009764490649104118, 0.05527470260858536, 0.05133195221424103, -0.0022379099391400814, -0.04234686121344566, 0.017432762309908867, 0.012627684511244297, 0.04173194617033005, -0.0005067933234386146, 0.03558254614472389, -0.007618434261530638, -0.00258544716052711, -0.03481505438685417, 0.02092004381120205, 0.016057342290878296, 0.01590537279844284, -0.018262416124343872, -0.01588461920619011, 0.031140316277742386, -0.009199121035635471, 0.00245623174123466, -0.060655154287815094, -0.004340203478932381, 0.03383994102478027, 0.014214565046131611, -0.002557081403210759, 0.017541227862238884, 0.03125401958823204, -0.0014575511449947953, -0.03382359445095062, -0.009414386004209518, -0.012248195707798004, -0.0697363093495369, -0.009417534805834293, 0.005371567327529192, -0.004377408418804407, 0.02072853222489357, -0.01113926898688078, -0.007842717692255974, 0.06268429756164551, 0.03555482625961304, 0.010240674950182438, 0.03767276555299759, 0.004216316621750593, -0.006625669077038765, -0.0580117329955101, 0.05454809591174126, -0.013386420905590057, 0.011645043268799782, -0.07887329161167145, -0.008841587230563164, -0.002102675149217248, 0.007657897192984819, 0.03979168087244034, -0.006686669774353504, -0.0008424754487350583, -0.07124674320220947, 0.026751136407256126, 0.008780352771282196, -0.05807036906480789, 0.029094533994793892, -0.025549648329615593, -0.05016855150461197, -0.019600506871938705, 0.015261884778738022, 0.0202617309987545, -0.03276488929986954, 0.015055261552333832, -0.04510287940502167, -0.04615134373307228, -0.03983684256672859, -0.010367291048169136, 0.03817049041390419, 0.01270840410143137, -0.008361938409507275, 0.032615046948194504, -0.004314041696488857, 0.020706605166196823, 0.026738356798887253, 0.018088679760694504, -0.03089234232902527, 0.04772772267460823, -0.041474878787994385, 0.0010742571903392673, -0.004389221780002117, -0.041248466819524765, 0.02095049060881138, -0.05732470378279686, -0.016241971403360367, 0.031526971608400345, -0.03057781420648098, -0.011492736637592316, 0.009682836011052132, 0.012318813242018223, 0.061546776443719864, -0.016163229942321777, 0.006449851673096418, 0.010355613194406033, -0.0286698117852211, -0.03036249242722988, 0.01145392656326294, -0.007947648875415325, -0.03867113217711449, 0.018083740025758743, 0.007957926951348782, 0.037221815437078476, 0.05003747344017029, 0.04661814123392105, 0.060645587742328644, -0.023585665971040726, -0.006204818841069937, -0.016897160559892654, -0.033893994987010956, -0.01629699021577835, 0.03834860771894455, -0.04185973480343819, 0.04432845488190651, -0.026508545503020287, 0.01778632216155529, -0.049175117164850235, -0.030350783839821815, -0.022875793278217316, -0.008744527585804462, 0.006074715405702591, 0.02158740721642971, -0.045904818922281265, -0.006042682100087404, 0.021536242216825485, 0.02770308405160904, 0.03873931244015694, -0.04984667897224426, 0.025383470579981804, -0.011312943883240223, 0.012418214231729507, -0.003513090079650283, -0.027106501162052155, -0.04787440225481987, 0.0030284461099654436, 0.030110588297247887, 0.0307477954775095, -0.02356884442269802, -0.023951342329382896, -0.02223227173089981, -0.02998599410057068, 0.016443870961666107, -0.00797808263450861, 0.002445053542032838, -0.05880117416381836, 0.023478256538510323, 0.008304750546813011, 0.003267095424234867 ]
<p>I am measuring the evolution of the brain response to a visual stimulation over time. The measures are done every seconds from 1 second to 14 seconds (each measure at time t gives a value summarizing the magnitude of the brain response from time 0 to time t). I have 8 subjects and 2 experimental conditions. For each subject and condition I replicate the measurement 12 times. I obtain therefore for each subject and condition 12 growth curves.</p> <p>My aim is to assess the influence of the experimental condition on the response profile. The responses appear to be fairly linear in time. Additionally, a noticeable aspect of the obtained results is the increase of the response variability over time (for each subject individually as well as between subjects). I am not sure about how to specify properly my random effect for the linear mixed model (using the nlme package).</p> <p>My initial idea was to start with the following model (time being coded as an integer and condition and subject as factors):<code>lm0 &lt;- lme( response ~ time*condition, random = ~time | subject/condition, data = psdData)</code>.</p> <p>Now due to the increase of variability of the response over time, I also get an increase of variability of the residuals over time. I initially wanted to try correcting for this using correlation structures, unfortunately, due to the replications, it seems that I cannot use the correlation option; when trying <code>lm1 &lt;- update(lm0, corr = corCAR1(form = ~time))</code> or <code>lm1 &lt;- update(lm0, corr = corCAR1(form = ~time | subject/condition))</code>, I obtain the error:</p> <pre><code>Error in Initialize.corCAR1(X[[2L]], ...) : covariate must have unique values within groups for "corCAR1" objects </code></pre> <p>and when trying <code>lm1 &lt;- update(lm0, corr = corCAR1(form = ~time | replicate/subject/condition))</code>, I obtain the error:</p> <pre><code>Error in lme.formula(response ~ time * condition, data = psdData, : incompatible formulas for groups in 'random' and 'correlation' </code></pre> <p>As I didn't manage to use correlation structures, I tried to use variance functions to model heteroscedasticity: <code>lm1 &lt;- update(lm0, weights = varPower(form = ~ time))</code></p> <p>But when looking at the residuals, it still displayed an increased variance over time. Same thing happened when using "varExp" or "varConstPower".</p> <p>I tried then another model, this time considering trials as units of measurements (and not subject as previously) and including the trial to trial variability within each subject. I created the factor <code>trialInSub &lt;- condition:replicate</code> which list all 24 trials of each subject (12 per condition) and wrote the model:</p> <pre><code>lm0 &lt;- lme( response ~ time*condition, random = ~time | subject/trialInSub, data = psdData) </code></pre> <p>giving a random intercept and slope for each subject and for each trial within subject.</p> <p>As this model fits a line for each replicate, I don't have anymore the issue about increasing variance over time. However when looking at the autocorrelation of the models residuals, I would suspect something is wrong with the model: from lag 2 to 7, the autocorrelation decreases from 0.5 to -0.5 and from lag 7 to 10 increases back to 0.04. Additionally I have a clear linear trend when plotting residuals against fitted values of the model for time = 1 (it looks fairly normally distributed for all other times) I tried different correlation structures but it didn't change much my results.</p> <p>I am really not sure that I handle the problem in a proper way and that the models I tried really reflect the design of the experiment and the structure of the data. I hope someone can direct me towards a solution that would be statistically sound.</p>
35,796
[ -0.02232467383146286, 0.000436035159509629, 0.016810745000839233, -0.04631412774324417, 0.024019883945584297, -0.023109031841158867, -0.01874491386115551, -0.0198410302400589, 0.0341465100646019, -0.042761705815792084, 0.03573261573910713, 0.0742974653840065, 0.07570287585258484, 0.04614521190524101, 0.0041266088373959064, -0.010585945099592209, 0.015429284423589706, 0.01832057349383831, -0.02996089495718479, -0.013902945443987846, -0.028833404183387756, 0.028401155024766922, 0.004243089351803064, -0.031747180968523026, -0.002864738227799535, 0.04159987345337868, 0.00893776211887598, -0.0452519915997982, 0.010526699014008045, 0.04058445245027542, -0.06107035651803017, -0.0376066230237484, 0.0015506114577874541, -0.004802302923053503, 0.015667883679270744, -0.020583104342222214, 0.000433892389992252, -0.01998283714056015, 0.007684103678911924, 0.006353618111461401, -0.009971808642148972, 0.02371762879192829, -0.0008497911039739847, 0.05054005980491638, 0.012119778431952, 0.01273007970303297, -0.026107879355549812, 0.008564132265746593, 0.07861042022705078, -0.01924523524940014, 0.08839249610900879, -0.002002561232075095, 0.017820363864302635, -0.00008032120240386575, -0.012323793955147266, 0.003006109967827797, 0.05697892978787422, 0.040686219930648804, 0.023297658190131187, -0.03208445757627487, -0.022243766114115715, -0.0305744931101799, 0.024619370698928833, 0.017664195969700813, -0.012108824215829372, -0.01323763933032751, 0.033991578966379166, 0.024786770343780518, 0.028560083359479904, -0.05678443983197212, 0.03832065686583519, 0.008778886869549751, 0.016148939728736877, -0.030938249081373215, 0.012172109447419643, -0.014857697300612926, -0.0004877064493484795, -0.036010999232530594, 0.031143054366111755, 0.05348291993141174, 0.014578456059098244, -0.002314942888915539, -0.02352648600935936, 0.012475041672587395, 0.02272864617407322, -0.0353783555328846, 0.0798250138759613, -0.014727076515555382, 0.021461905911564827, 0.0428897887468338, -0.02233027294278145, 0.04624204710125923, 0.024807104840874672, 0.014021068811416626, -0.03486622869968414, 0.030962688848376274, -0.009733639657497406, 0.03190375491976738, 0.012470814399421215, 0.0005853584152646363, -0.01221069972962141, -0.06007649376988411, 0.022068701684474945, 0.009541592560708523, -0.03662658482789993, -0.0019646715372800827, 0.010829807259142399, -0.0150819206610322, -0.008591008372604847, -0.0345565490424633, 0.0005437907529994845, 0.012810362502932549, -0.002694548573344946, 0.02627710998058319, 0.010894322767853737, -0.0782703310251236, -0.01400490291416645, -0.001795434858649969, 0.038377441465854645, 0.05453765019774437, 0.01657397300004959, -0.0313773937523365, 0.02169533632695675, -0.009730801917612553, -0.01570684090256691, 0.016464445739984512, 0.017548436298966408, -0.002787028905004263, -0.02408478409051895, 0.07560692727565765, 0.028328338637948036, -0.05157836526632309, 0.062429189682006836, -0.012915492057800293, 0.020672982558608055, -0.0006068710936233401, -0.09310857951641083, -0.050330497324466705, 0.024969637393951416, -0.00796628650277853, 0.027194859459996223, -0.05855384096503258, -0.0025745227467268705, 0.0176087636500597, 0.0388515405356884, 0.010822865180671215, 0.02587226964533329, 0.031507447361946106, 0.037700481712818146, 0.02287796139717102, -0.058757007122039795, 0.007809152826666832, -0.028687981888651848, -0.00045834711636416614, -0.04750846326351166, -0.09715189784765244, 0.006734258960932493, 0.01116755697876215, -0.005388564895838499, 0.03114965930581093, 0.006820313166826963, -0.02777162380516529, -0.020626738667488098, -0.01382614765316248, -0.0009697561035864055, -0.013169758021831512, 0.036633577197790146, -0.033504925668239594, 0.0559115968644619, 0.008734787814319134, -0.024065950885415077, -0.001019005780108273, 0.002647084416821599, 0.026693126186728477, 0.007304543163627386, -0.034301966428756714, 0.05061851814389229, 0.03504794463515282, -0.03796781599521637, 0.05549617484211922, -0.045182518661022186, -0.018161989748477936, -0.05129649117588997, -0.016937680542469025, 0.0554090179502964, 0.008391445502638817, -0.022313125431537628, 0.0011469688033685088, 0.01699935458600521, -0.0253608338534832, -0.04759427532553673, -0.07046132534742355, 0.017668263986706734, -0.0004275638493709266, -0.04602598398923874, 0.009048965759575367, -0.04274666681885719, 0.052139393985271454, 0.06962411850690842, -0.008737650699913502, -0.03159065544605255, 0.013190553523600101, 0.06615983694791794, -0.016929809004068375, 0.010161747224628925, -0.005930010695010424, 0.03947144374251366, -0.008474013768136501, 0.029189687222242355, -0.01819148100912571, 0.005711369216442108, 0.01103278435766697, -0.02449362725019455, 0.026174990460276604, -0.015235653147101402, -0.007795469369739294, 0.011985698714852333, 0.024984801188111305, -0.0506720095872879, 0.05768786743283272, -0.04371815547347069, 0.03911839425563812, 0.0922236442565918, -0.022706899791955948, -0.008798826485872269, 0.02353033795952797, -0.0004804358468391001, 0.026437116786837578, -0.055230673402547836, -0.009927515871822834, -0.05236395075917244, -0.005015871021896601, 0.021664690226316452, 0.028154486790299416, 0.008369029499590397, -0.005250686313956976, 0.039695218205451965, 0.026125885546207428, 0.034405358135700226, 0.024989226832985878, -0.001812855596654117, -0.042789191007614136, 0.00964612327516079, 0.03314703330397606, 0.03385983780026436, -0.015625813975930214, 0.012770028784871101, -0.03683455288410187, 0.007983125746250153, 0.017949098721146584, 0.030439456924796104, 0.0213487409055233, -0.009436470456421375, -0.017775481566786766, -0.04701189696788788, -0.024372978135943413, 0.03339536115527153, 0.015479076653718948, 0.021489206701517105, 0.042274583131074905, 0.0278531014919281, -0.03854607418179512, -0.018481435254216194, -0.025745490565896034, -0.018229061737656593, 0.018647342920303345, -0.019601697102189064, -0.04220561310648918, 0.0014429951552301645, 0.009244166314601898, 0.017177803441882133, -0.017237547785043716, -0.030990831553936005, -0.04726402834057808, 0.029336897656321526, 0.007483066525310278, -0.012318827211856842, 0.014397713355720043, -0.07620085775852203, 0.03995053097605705, 0.0001901020877994597, 0.026267103850841522, 0.03941956162452698, -0.021028513088822365, -0.056904371827840805, -0.017365355044603348, -0.009696699678897858, 0.007419205736368895, 0.02851555123925209, 0.004968172870576382, -0.009222825057804585, 0.02672591805458069, -0.0053703198209404945, -0.06677204370498657, -0.015647510066628456, -0.04110227897763252, 0.01287904568016529, 0.00737169710919261, -0.005007901694625616, 0.03994996100664139, 0.02314450778067112, -0.06562026590108871, 0.02533491514623165, -0.02318570390343666, 0.023429306223988533, 0.004728850442916155, -0.02698599360883236, -0.0026741507463157177, 0.0038224535528570414, -0.024980345740914345, 0.03211897239089012, -0.011666092090308666, -0.0448840968310833, -0.06628284603357315, -0.07908475399017334, 0.011619284749031067, 0.02228114940226078, 0.03160887956619263, -0.002208480378612876, 0.024972710758447647, 0.06855171918869019, 0.026335913687944412, -0.021626630797982216, -0.07233726233243942, 0.015684254467487335, 0.0013431379338726401, -0.03810631483793259, 0.04284537583589554, 0.005415407475084066, 0.014481775462627411, 0.015291346237063408, -0.04073823615908623, 0.017159881070256233, 0.05542128160595894, -0.000250363809755072, -0.02115592174232006, 0.03083319216966629, 0.008042698726058006, -0.0072988723404705524, 0.029396751895546913, 0.05703768879175186, -0.013432839885354042, 0.005342068150639534, 0.014076056890189648, 0.010557636618614197, -0.04779137670993805, -0.05907374992966652, 0.0014726286754012108, -0.023266643285751343, 0.00853030290454626, -0.06482037901878357, 0.025234874337911606, -0.008919830434024334, -0.048716068267822266, -0.03557131066918373, 0.014076413586735725, 0.04321826621890068, 0.003677243599668145, -0.005627292208373547, 0.059852421283721924, 0.02476767636835575, -0.02343449555337429, 0.021086111664772034, -0.0313185378909111, 0.008354400284588337, 0.05005090683698654, -0.05725117772817612, 0.017737863585352898, 0.042928602546453476, 0.00533774821087718, 0.03429519012570381, 0.007294256240129471, -0.025744710117578506, 0.021178942173719406, -0.04395582526922226, 0.02642403170466423, -0.04502958059310913, 0.05059155076742172, 0.03908287733793259, 0.03785292059183121, 0.037990134209394455, -0.04397628456354141, 0.02117983065545559, -0.02600874751806259, -0.061493899673223495, 0.026280054822564125, -0.005111146252602339, -0.015924587845802307, 0.030567746609449387, -0.04246676340699196, -0.010339821688830853, -0.0008066883310675621, 0.0018584976205602288, -0.023572871461510658, 0.031777169555425644, -0.011190504767000675, 0.0031967712566256523, -0.007975676096975803, 0.00766178360208869, -0.06316383183002472, 0.016128992661833763, 0.019270217046141624, -0.0003532894770614803, 0.0071756886318326, 0.035909704864025116, 0.037376485764980316, -0.011764158494770527, -0.026562007144093513, -0.0274277925491333, 0.028483953326940536, 0.08810309320688248, -0.027296189218759537, -0.008203194476664066, -0.03716805949807167, 0.0599336177110672, -0.00704135000705719, 0.00967776495963335, 0.08098077028989792, 0.016509266570210457, 0.017263246700167656, -0.021356388926506042, -0.002007383154705167, 0.022981317713856697, 0.0003856676339637488, 0.009455080144107342, -0.012028193101286888, 0.029087433591485023, 0.03607762232422829, -0.017852772027254105, 0.019606895744800568, 0.030879756435751915, -0.018204478546977043, 0.0012112598633393645, -0.05162800848484039, -0.003268796019256115, -0.004968654364347458, 0.01380813680589199, 0.0541873462498188, 0.02736583724617958, 0.02582394890487194, 0.004034774377942085, 0.023751989006996155, -0.04172102361917496, -0.010662349872291088, -0.01611107401549816, 0.0386883020401001, 0.01010944228619337, 0.008206143975257874, 0.0014967272290959954, -0.00022932045976631343, 0.016060199588537216, 0.03041202202439308, 0.03080640360713005, 0.006397389806807041, -0.06262880563735962, -0.021224696189165115, 0.023740239441394806, 0.017440836876630783, -0.009270703420042992, 0.00795596931129694, -0.040128130465745926, -0.03507889062166214, 0.017579277977347374, 0.00938461348414421, 0.033363837748765945, -0.0221248809248209, 0.010152101516723633, -0.013871288858354092, -0.04275619611144066, -0.054094910621643066, 0.020782293751835823, -0.045836687088012695, 0.032759085297584534, -0.02874460443854332, -0.029332205653190613, 0.020845185965299606, 0.020523807033896446, 0.014645803719758987, 0.06908052414655685, -0.045910656452178955, -0.00069486687425524, 0.020379958674311638, -0.0570276714861393, 0.0015950036467984319, -0.027935873717069626, 0.042167287319898605, -0.0030437882523983717, 0.0002487475285306573, 0.04608553647994995, 0.017423521727323532, 0.0012750114547088742, 0.0071112411096692085, 0.014902970753610134, 0.014178957790136337, -0.04963348060846329, -0.017092127352952957, 0.0786261036992073, 0.02762644924223423, 0.008047851733863354, 0.05183866247534752, 0.0030622011981904507, 0.0065377564169466496, 0.015095372684299946, -0.05159587413072586, -0.02540850080549717, -0.008889243006706238, -0.022039417177438736, -0.050861794501543045, 0.00003801967250183225, 0.00768303032964468, 0.06967030465602875, -0.007547257002443075, 0.012037776410579681, -0.02529839053750038, 0.015165864489972591, 0.03462417796254158, 0.033347588032484055, -0.0284330565482378, -0.008120269514620304, 0.022376231849193573, -0.026210300624370575, 0.00041611705091781914, 0.005737622268497944, 0.0022085770033299923, -0.04471597075462341, -0.008907842449843884, 0.035502683371305466, -0.03769180178642273, -0.016927551478147507, 0.01561837550252676, 0.0011749689001590014, -0.01770324632525444, -0.0160283874720335, 0.016582831740379333, 0.02795768901705742, 0.050480324774980545, 0.02021600306034088, -0.026741454377770424, 0.029145827516913414, 0.04790031164884567, -0.021422049030661583, 0.030829887837171555, -0.020639069378376007, 0.009909826330840588, -0.027724776417016983, 0.0004986316780559719, -0.08072695136070251, -0.05123492330312729, 0.01908295974135399, -0.017346154898405075, 0.004834022838622332, -0.02089819684624672, -0.03386871889233589, -0.008105795830488205, 0.011470911093056202, -0.017882512882351875, 0.05228051170706749, -0.013267600908875465, 0.029286248609423637, -0.030582770705223083, 0.009955430403351784, 0.07122015953063965, -0.024249285459518433, -0.01949862763285637, 0.020464090630412102, -0.014809874817728996, -0.034659188240766525, -0.01387649867683649, -0.013773132115602493, -0.06084907427430153, -0.0024523024912923574, -0.05521104112267494, 0.021558577194809914, 0.06050769239664078, -0.013725352473556995, -0.03943478316068649, 0.006097606848925352, -0.02706630900502205, 0.03574090451002121, -0.06308180093765259, -0.004097673576325178, -0.0062323762103915215, -0.0036475621163845062, -0.004577271174639463, 0.009874398820102215, -0.021373070776462555, -0.012818976305425167, 0.00939321331679821, -0.0029335287399590015, -0.023901913315057755, 0.04653584212064743, 0.06852870434522629, 0.002293071709573269, -0.022241804748773575, -0.0018935872940346599, -0.023490548133850098, 0.019615886732935905, 0.0030151328537613153, -0.00034208092256449163, -0.003489199560135603, -0.00021469095372594893, -0.01671372354030609, -0.02189009264111519, -0.002363884821534157, -0.010813686065375805, 0.06483930349349976, 0.00016856375441420823, 0.046506814658641815, 0.06666222214698792, -0.03085501119494438, -0.004905407316982746, -0.03447658196091652, 0.0007317097042687237, -0.006348466034978628, -0.004387843422591686, 0.06468940526247025, -0.04371875151991844, -0.03280416503548622, 0.03077080473303795, 0.03640285134315491, 0.03960297629237175, 0.03991328552365303, -0.012408362701535225, 0.00613816874101758, 0.03321214020252228, -0.018282053992152214, -0.06947237253189087, -0.0023847497068345547, -0.022296784445643425, 0.03713284060359001, -0.0399923250079155, -0.03635294362902641, -0.005982015747576952, 0.05925183743238449, -0.027741780504584312, -0.031092358753085136, -0.030751941725611687, -0.0407382994890213, -0.031158942729234695, 0.035673316568136215, -0.038656529039144516, 0.03459819033741951, 0.0336742140352726, 0.05886846408247948, 0.01563231460750103, 0.006389871705323458, -0.04471564665436745, -0.08727795630693436, -0.008214711211621761, -0.0029420589562505484, -0.004084967542439699, 0.08234982937574387, -0.02214212156832218, -0.027120880782604218, 0.013516219332814217, -0.02371201291680336, 0.027544807642698288, 0.018633142113685608, 0.037395916879177094, 0.008536430075764656, 0.05033868923783302, 0.0049974918365478516, -0.020379401743412018, -0.04974302649497986, 0.005815034732222557, 0.1481008380651474, 0.06188923865556717, 0.03814332187175751, -0.04429197311401367, 0.04412288963794708, 0.027757905423641205, -0.013151248916983604, -0.006563136819750071, -0.00423860689625144, 0.032610852271318436, -0.024839097633957863, 0.027395008131861687, 0.03729936107993126, 0.021251151338219643, -0.01846388354897499, 0.029648104682564735, -0.01867048442363739, -0.0069731250405311584, 0.001531644375063479, 0.015861451625823975, 0.015173585154116154, -0.010219017043709755, -0.0489685982465744, 0.011881666257977486, -0.030937928706407547, -0.0021888981573283672, -0.011861076578497887, -0.011974560096859932, -0.0075492034666240215, -0.014862315729260445, -0.025586459785699844, 0.024907920509576797, -0.003085215575993061, 0.0022246341686695814, 0.009141827002167702, -0.02707037143409252, 0.02111927606165409, -0.01335583720356226, 0.05111662298440933, 0.049505796283483505, -0.007262457627803087, -0.000959533907007426, -0.018373562023043633, 0.009558644145727158, 0.000653401599265635, -0.03282980993390083, -0.012046165764331818, 0.0724140927195549, -0.012354081496596336, -0.016770265996456146, 0.011126190423965454, 0.0049391514621675014, 0.0004228258621878922, -0.044264473021030426, -0.04127349331974983, 0.026925090700387955, -0.012053100392222404, 0.014084377326071262, 0.021435916423797607, -0.012406057678163052, -0.01393989846110344, -0.013131792657077312, 0.04373544454574585, 0.00556387472897768, -0.006917976774275303, -0.004006527364253998, -0.056560222059488297, 0.02436286397278309, 0.04227682575583458, 0.041463714092969894, 0.022497335448861122, -0.038565583527088165, -0.04572093486785889, 0.019330760464072227, 0.03483980521559715, 0.024814583361148834, 0.019758407026529312, -0.007297618314623833, -0.014052698388695717, -0.04350500926375389, -0.0501222163438797, -0.025045175105333328, 0.013335336931049824, -0.015465615317225456, -0.017294375225901604, -0.02447858639061451, 0.02428918145596981, 0.04685279726982117, -0.006762965116649866, -0.023974038660526276, -0.019704146310687065, 0.046618081629276276, 0.008982113562524319, -0.049118202179670334, -0.02624131366610527, 0.017104817554354668, 0.007249756250530481, -0.018487105146050453, -0.00493233697488904, 0.03734205663204193, -0.006620080675929785, -0.00782773643732071, -0.0031275844667106867, 0.027109012007713318, 0.017781991511583328, -0.0017949843313544989, 0.05361941456794739, 0.014133126474916935, -0.001851641689427197, -0.03761513903737068, 0.005615859292447567, 0.00470297085121274, 0.008748969994485378, -0.06222710385918617, -0.049626681953668594, -0.010669886134564877, -0.03315487876534462, 0.016112448647618294, 0.0036976374685764313, -0.017795713618397713, -0.007292659487575293, -0.01621345244348049, 0.018369683995842934, -0.023691289126873016, -0.01984897255897522, -0.017852578312158585, 0.0069082509726285934, -0.002443180186673999, 0.055225830525159836, -0.028905829414725304, 0.01880999654531479, 0.04006711021065712, -0.007198851555585861, 0.016833992674946785, -0.016511019319295883, -0.0053797936998307705, 0.026240598410367966, 0.036507803946733475, 0.023664873093366623, -0.029093772172927856, -0.00693120900541544, -0.05998574569821358, -0.02550528198480606, 0.03133956342935562, -0.0005946727469563484, 0.009548399597406387, 0.033109117299318314, 0.016235927119851112, -0.02444303408265114, 0.032151442021131516, -0.012698945589363575, -0.009782171808183193, -0.014684969559311867, 0.021656740456819534, 0.03097301349043846, 0.0016541038639843464, 0.02330116368830204, 0.021326471120119095, 0.005065580364316702, 0.015470671467483044, 0.048186175525188446, -0.008685275912284851, -0.0016266932943835855, -0.023808758705854416, -0.024757597595453262, 0.017993459478020668, 0.010609280318021774, -0.01431761123239994, 0.05230221524834633, 0.03361034393310547, -0.03360364958643913, 0.03621584549546242, -0.011625193990767002, 0.005757683422416449, -0.08750806003808975, -0.029613573104143143, -0.013329991139471531, 0.018121806904673576, 0.02507583610713482, -0.04149247705936432, -0.039200130850076675, 0.028929101303219795, -0.025294672697782516, 0.004856077488511801, 0.0023999784607440233, 0.004771939944475889, -0.0019357340643182397, 0.0239594466984272, -0.014731707982718945, -0.01300814375281334, 0.03594076633453369, 0.018800944089889526, 0.019977105781435966, 0.021360615268349648, 0.022489264607429504, -0.017922526225447655, -0.013391624204814434, -0.015526738949120045, 0.04505176842212677, -0.05785704031586647, 0.004918698221445084, -0.046620097011327744, -0.0052554006688296795, -0.01309000514447689, 0.017952129244804382, 0.012842618860304356, 0.004678224213421345, 0.04585937410593033, -0.00034896258148364723, 0.047197889536619186, -0.00659678690135479, -0.018717175349593163, 0.03157120943069458, -0.03679371252655983, 0.01563570275902748, 0.010911185294389725, -0.02815784327685833, 0.002198080997914076, -0.010142199695110321, 0.008518118411302567, -0.035773247480392456, 0.029554685577750206, -0.005622382741421461, -0.039565522223711014, -0.003399250563234091, 0.017604559659957886, 0.009795942343771458, -0.056721217930316925, 0.005813138093799353, -0.028539862483739853, 0.0010102002415806055, 0.033989544957876205, 0.030839793384075165, -0.04078340902924538, 0.011048458516597748, -0.03294304385781288, -0.007727507967501879, -0.032307617366313934, 0.014277423731982708, -0.011925683356821537, -0.05244959890842438, -0.015155076049268246, -0.012931608594954014, 0.005726370494812727, -0.007615636568516493, 0.022916674613952637, -0.045888010412454605, 0.034938324242830276, -0.020173795521259308, -0.012629629112780094, -0.024441523477435112, -0.021895620971918106, 0.03245287388563156, -0.08811569213867188, 0.01442231610417366, 0.013778186403214931, -0.03031208924949169, -0.060729801654815674, -0.004119145683944225, -0.06127436086535454, 0.07379763573408127, 0.03040054254233837, 0.006618627812713385, -0.008175037801265717, 0.01747865602374077, 0.024312790483236313, 0.028888603672385216, -0.026490796357393265, 0.08159983158111572, -0.009480524808168411, 0.006408162880688906, -0.010428185574710369, 0.0081504350528121, 0.012040962465107441, -0.02405940368771553, -0.013894681818783283, -0.017528284341096878, 0.01548281591385603, -0.02294035442173481, -0.01967448554933071, 0.04543851315975189, 0.014424283057451248, -0.0396747887134552, 0.0035703100729733706, -0.026530152186751366, 0.010190886445343494, 0.007481500972062349, 0.02060983143746853, -0.06802433729171753, 0.01876906491816044, -0.03397520259022713, -0.00783471018075943, 0.029138466343283653, -0.013405073434114456, -0.007008428685367107, -0.06080344691872597, 0.012002101168036461, 0.025052741169929504, 0.016678664833307266, -0.02468239702284336, 0.05763057991862297, 0.018225032836198807, 0.05100670084357262, -0.004619698040187359, 0.008647852577269077, -0.020560186356306076, 0.0022794678807258606, 0.003953456878662109, 0.0314684621989727, 0.02980855107307434, -0.03153494745492935, -0.020513644441962242, 0.022303089499473572, -0.01900923252105713, 0.041972219944000244, -0.024602197110652924, 0.041761476546525955, -0.005683720111846924, 0.011834358796477318, 0.03287755697965622, -0.020536277443170547, 0.04069748520851135, -0.002833052771165967, 0.00208439864218235, 0.03711596876382828, -0.08630502223968506, 0.009250661358237267, -0.016415342688560486, -0.020300494506955147, -0.01883152686059475, 0.015613782219588757, 0.03849852830171585, 0.047474540770053864, -0.0014785085804760456, 0.003606244456022978, -0.03513872250914574, -0.032811686396598816, 0.009711628779768944, -0.027268007397651672, 0.029135754331946373, 0.010333492420613766, 0.00451894523575902, -0.009080799296498299, -0.01891019195318222, -0.031354013830423355, -0.05042538046836853, 0.0026323962956666946, 0.017261965200304985, 0.023648669943213463, -0.07559873163700104, -0.006960560102015734, 0.0018795335199683905, 0.029552383348345757, -0.034672729671001434, -0.026730354875326157, -0.018267706036567688, 0.024303633719682693, 0.00831337459385395, 0.018710844218730927 ]
<p>I'm very in to Sports analysis and am keen to look at finessing my analysis models that I have worked up (I don't have a great maths background, I've just done a little bit of reading).</p> <p>Standard deviation of Game Results about prediction from a Ratings system (in this case least squares regression with a few tweaks) equals the stochastic element in a normal distribution function where:</p> <p>x = the margin of victory that you are trying to get a % against (e.g. it could be a point spread e.g. % to cover) the mean = the predicted margin of victory derived in this case from my least squares regression to create power ratings for teams sigma = standard deviation of error on the difference between the predicted margin of victory and actual margin of victory based on past results.</p> <p>Based on the above I would treat in Excel terms a win % for team A as:</p> <p>1-NORMDIST(0.5,mean,sigma,true) - with the mean and sigma having values obviously.</p> <p>Based on Stern "The Probability of Winning an American Football Game" American Statistician (August 1991) - the sigma value (stochastic element? - sorry this isn't my usual thing) is approximately 13.86. How would you go about refining this for other sports? - e.g. Australian Rules Football. I said this could be done for any sport (and I believe it can within reason unless the results or the sport doesn't lend itself to this type of analysis).</p> <p>Looking at past AFL results from the end of the season point of view the standard deviations are as follows (have only started looking at these in the last two days):</p> <p>2009: 31.34 (150+ results) 2010: 33.44 (150+ results 2011: 34.91 (150+ results) 2012: 25.62 (only approximately 70 results so far as it is mid season)</p> <p>As you feed more data into the model for 2012 it will build up a more accurate picture but looking at past data I'm putting the sigma value for AFL at around 33.5 (above the 25.62 value). Is there anyway of defining a best fit value? Where I don't have a great background in this kind of thing, if someone could give me some gentle nudges in the right direction in terms of where I should be looking or what I could be applying I would be grateful.</p> <p>I believe this can definitely be applied to other sports as well e.g.:</p> <p>English Premiership:</p> <p>2008/2009: 1.45 (Season with over 300+ results) 2009/2010: 1.52 2010/2011: 1.54 2011/2012: 1.64 (but when looking over the last 100 results around the 1.50 mark)</p> <p>I've also looked at the percentages that this then gives for home wins, away wins and draws and they are virtually identical to the percentages for bookmakers odds (except they work to 105-106% instead of 100% so they have an edge which accounts for the small differences).</p> <p>NBA:</p> <p>2008/2009: 11.30 (Season with 1000+ results) 2009/2010: 11.56 2010/2011: 10.88 2011/2012: 11.36</p> <p>Thanks in advance for any advice,</p>
73,425
[ -0.030853962525725365, -0.018167585134506226, -0.029706913977861404, 0.00963703915476799, 0.07455883920192719, 0.02378494292497635, 0.021283360198140144, -0.02550666220486164, 0.015672340989112854, -0.03157087042927742, 0.011699485592544079, -0.001533369766548276, 0.02341615967452526, 0.032847024500370026, 0.01631809026002884, -0.02496963180601597, 0.008933931589126587, -0.026390524581074715, -0.018421610817313194, 0.003310393076390028, 0.014549892395734787, -0.0014589207712560892, -0.00928741879761219, 0.005466052796691656, -0.03751261904835701, 0.05467210337519646, 0.013516191393136978, -0.02886155992746353, 0.01782592572271824, 0.028312887996435165, -0.010388955473899841, -0.031594179570674896, 0.020305683836340904, 0.024814283475279808, 0.029474560171365738, 0.026580816134810448, 0.010724878869950771, -0.028590604662895203, -0.019177336245775223, 0.024389715865254402, -0.01723191700875759, 0.01695052906870842, 0.016115961596369743, 0.031242046505212784, -0.0199961569160223, 0.042112480849027634, -0.0515146441757679, -0.04683459922671318, 0.033362556248903275, -0.03712411969900131, 0.08392363786697388, 0.007067064289003611, 0.04645800590515137, 0.011602602899074554, -0.021744845435023308, -0.014082860201597214, 0.047215647995471954, 0.06780845671892166, 0.007172157056629658, -0.08262637257575989, 0.019575608894228935, -0.023897739127278328, -0.039531417191028595, 0.01322951354086399, -0.020496681332588196, 0.006929383613169193, -0.01050643902271986, -0.02789759263396263, 0.06820472329854965, 0.002892945194616914, 0.01311725564301014, 0.01481670793145895, 0.03623132407665253, 0.0002694919239729643, -0.00133045413531363, -0.031244758516550064, 0.011367578990757465, -0.002942978637292981, 0.048674143850803375, 0.013764243572950363, 0.0036481928545981646, 0.03950332850217819, 0.030542641878128052, 0.045001450926065445, 0.05703155696392059, 0.020571637898683548, 0.06729293614625931, -0.05390967056155205, 0.018430018797516823, 0.03822595998644829, -0.028430422767996788, -0.0033326868433505297, 0.05339791625738144, -0.03148067370057106, -0.03974257409572601, 0.04129303991794586, -0.032260216772556305, 0.03564934805035591, -0.0031043102499097586, -0.000836607301607728, 0.010318760760128498, -0.05947481840848923, 0.0013324936153367162, 0.053998690098524094, -0.001014236593618989, -0.054983414709568024, -0.0671592727303505, -0.02854991890490055, 0.0016718488186597824, -0.03002542443573475, -0.02664460800588131, 0.04677682742476463, 0.008864822797477245, 0.010875070467591286, -0.015024327673017979, -0.009207542985677719, -0.004100389778614044, -0.01569695584475994, 0.03550412505865097, 0.04603715240955353, 0.008352631703019142, -0.0336187519133091, 0.004695775453001261, -0.03732297569513321, -0.0472942516207695, 0.026909958571195602, -0.000021474455934367143, 0.014975992031395435, -0.031395185738801956, 0.017072098329663277, -0.01767469011247158, -0.004462553653866053, 0.05274750664830208, 0.002318137791007757, 0.019780512899160385, -0.005041069816797972, -0.08746565133333206, -0.02117573469877243, 0.039619140326976776, 0.0003743964771274477, 0.014406134374439716, -0.0827072262763977, -0.032016459852457047, 0.023077702149748802, 0.062741719186306, 0.03938862681388855, 0.04884113743901253, -0.007619940675795078, 0.0488167405128479, 0.0017486867727711797, 0.014926212839782238, -0.0007848999230191112, -0.03428340703248978, -0.043121058493852615, -0.03142048045992851, -0.05965810269117355, 0.006224339362233877, 0.009564151056110859, -0.0022128876298666, 0.001960814232006669, -0.010758153162896633, 0.012242583557963371, -0.011457965709269047, -0.02094721607863903, 0.032526448369026184, -0.019686570391058922, 0.045960474759340286, -0.005491959862411022, 0.03713954612612724, -0.02419261448085308, -0.024195484817028046, -0.015849651768803596, 0.04528523236513138, 0.0031278845854103565, 0.06704948097467422, -0.02455991506576538, 0.013441316783428192, -0.0120928306132555, -0.006542243994772434, -0.043655768036842346, -0.04957229644060135, 0.007877674885094166, -0.03759021684527397, 0.01804591342806816, 0.03853631019592285, 0.0733548253774643, 0.031249618157744408, -0.00013781452435068786, 0.04663965478539467, -0.04761410877108574, -0.051985856145620346, -0.06624636799097061, 0.020442727953195572, -0.008268015459179878, 0.006942262873053551, 0.015039240010082722, -0.022297438234090805, 0.02085897885262966, -0.02057822421193123, 0.006994679104536772, 0.0005726523231714964, 0.026526272296905518, 0.05062682926654816, -0.04150824621319771, 0.010708367452025414, 0.07602579891681671, 0.04137532785534859, -0.0022531168069690466, 0.02443721331655979, -0.039123084396123886, -0.06312686949968338, -0.0052262782119214535, -0.037269096821546555, 0.012238938361406326, -0.009521541185677052, -0.0036624534986913204, 0.006611148826777935, -0.002761583309620619, 0.00212423806078732, -0.010192271322011948, -0.044862598180770874, 0.0499412976205349, 0.0671207383275032, 0.008970413357019424, -0.0008341577486135066, 0.012146084569394588, -0.013718229718506336, 0.011721376329660416, 0.0007931547588668764, -0.024988077580928802, -0.05108427256345749, 0.0079033263027668, 0.0057422020472586155, 0.037083614617586136, -0.04311444237828255, -0.007848449982702732, 0.08957475423812866, -0.0331391915678978, 0.008496008813381195, 0.013697320595383644, -0.00841096043586731, -0.0009104452910833061, -0.028120819479227066, 0.00415329122915864, 0.01425921730697155, -0.022402675822377205, 0.016596371307969093, 0.032575275748968124, -0.0043486496433615685, 0.019867101684212685, -0.012176301330327988, 0.02537095732986927, 0.029451938346028328, -0.0028881835751235485, -0.008206604048609734, -0.02321065030992031, 0.06435921043157578, 0.00608188146725297, -0.007256976328790188, 0.03332475945353508, 0.016539378091692924, -0.023710792884230614, -0.011208179406821728, -0.02058934047818184, 0.0016673053614795208, 0.047577470541000366, 0.011314207687973976, -0.001830210443586111, 0.011033470742404461, -0.018231811001896858, -0.0020828156266361475, -0.015439889393746853, -0.027381516993045807, -0.010902280919253826, -0.025776365771889687, 0.042412884533405304, 0.01689831167459488, 0.021896356716752052, 0.01339221652597189, -0.009368253871798515, -0.001305285026319325, 0.026830270886421204, 0.0033165698405355215, -0.004224557429552078, -0.052935194224119186, -0.030571600422263145, 0.013345117680728436, 0.02004897966980934, -0.011170681565999985, -0.03459230437874794, -0.013230780139565468, 0.05401032418012619, -0.014864993281662464, -0.04024282842874527, -0.035072144120931625, -0.020675458014011383, 0.0005862766411155462, -0.0033146128989756107, -0.014977768063545227, 0.06325141340494156, 0.012631164863705635, -0.027908537536859512, 0.03407899662852287, 0.012961181811988354, -0.006961493752896786, -0.03534530848264694, -0.0013737957924604416, -0.005782249383628368, 0.0021309787407517433, 0.04114452004432678, 0.027776915580034256, -0.017095768824219704, -0.009305065497756004, -0.05442346632480621, -0.03834596276283264, 0.032073669135570526, -0.028520338237285614, 0.021508317440748215, -0.034620512276887894, -0.0387873612344265, 0.08085427433252335, 0.016637444496154785, 0.0034732050262391567, -0.025163089856505394, 0.027423644438385963, -0.023346368223428726, -0.019398456439375877, 0.008571354672312737, 0.005720319226384163, -0.025032738223671913, 0.042221762239933014, -0.05486157163977623, -0.0033566977363079786, 0.018068648874759674, -0.0032355771400034428, -0.028264235705137253, 0.030468525364995003, -0.030930202454328537, -0.0029231917578727007, 0.026729213073849678, -0.0038162011187523603, -0.0351770855486393, 0.03634944558143616, 0.008984403684735298, 0.022886093705892563, 0.005983868148177862, -0.042741455137729645, 0.001458558952435851, -0.020004693418741226, -0.020520830526947975, -0.02732216939330101, 0.026483234018087387, 0.0101619902998209, -0.042997971177101135, -0.009349055588245392, 0.029422739520668983, 0.0186468455940485, 0.030231188982725143, -0.0021996055729687214, 0.07064013183116913, 0.010754728689789772, 0.006590489763766527, -0.02216496504843235, -0.015732016414403915, 0.009298344142735004, -0.014044597744941711, -0.026770442724227905, -0.012345797382295132, 0.04444659873843193, 0.041312262415885925, 0.01918739639222622, 0.0062795295380055904, -0.016869161278009415, -0.03989463299512863, -0.053198061883449554, 0.0057691666297614574, -0.042450789362192154, 0.04145413637161255, 0.019805265590548515, 0.015407562255859375, 0.008223313838243484, -0.0017092970665544271, 0.009104172699153423, 0.0063409581780433655, -0.04070458561182022, 0.041049689054489136, -0.033435940742492676, -0.03571200370788574, -0.010349462740123272, -0.004871956538408995, 0.026567507535219193, -0.0266041848808527, -0.0005547660985030234, 0.011952131986618042, -0.02295065112411976, -0.0331232063472271, -0.03176087886095047, -0.03325623273849487, -0.0422523207962513, 0.03019000217318535, 0.009430660866200924, 0.013920147903263569, -0.020356910303235054, 0.03972238674759865, 0.04230489209294319, -0.006350802723318338, -0.03961402177810669, -0.003508620895445347, 0.04290962964296341, 0.027746453881263733, 0.017749546095728874, 0.02870592474937439, 0.014353143982589245, -0.04765972122550011, 0.05204939842224121, 0.004159874748438597, 0.04615829512476921, 0.03739839047193527, 0.03110942803323269, -0.02759983390569687, -0.06872867047786713, -0.025614658370614052, 0.028104642406105995, -0.01254456490278244, -0.001310775289312005, 0.012091166339814663, 0.026820776984095573, 0.0021371415350586176, -0.07541951537132263, 0.03183574229478836, 0.05192866548895836, 0.003420724533498287, -0.012986580841243267, -0.01598338596522808, -0.018274014815688133, 0.022493677213788033, -0.0005741431377828121, 0.024580806493759155, -0.00031081162160262465, 0.04655180126428604, -0.011291153728961945, 0.05555415153503418, -0.03112468309700489, -0.049804769456386566, 0.033652279525995255, 0.0357406847178936, 0.03751610592007637, 0.005599293392151594, -0.04456988722085953, 0.015828778967261314, 0.05925237759947777, 0.037317611277103424, 0.05309433862566948, 0.06429998576641083, -0.06976597011089325, -0.02996777556836605, 0.00821569561958313, 0.0431259386241436, 0.0016752203227952123, -0.046775564551353455, -0.021091457456350327, -0.033483441919088364, 0.011082344688475132, -0.03475090488791466, 0.044075410813093185, 0.007025819271802902, 0.013773047365248203, -0.03348434343934059, -0.03821033611893654, -0.037610284984111786, 0.020174581557512283, -0.0017619109712541103, 0.026385581120848656, -0.007292040623724461, -0.03197242692112923, -0.03799198940396309, -0.005108915269374847, 0.03464375436306, 0.037792108952999115, 0.004179733339697123, -0.04265179485082626, -0.019606105983257294, 0.016651576384902, 0.005511682480573654, -0.09140392392873764, -0.001504414016380906, 0.001545277307741344, -0.03310181945562363, 0.023108428344130516, 0.022723430767655373, 0.004299903754144907, 0.01179852057248354, 0.027395062148571014, -0.02810806967318058, 0.02152615413069725, -0.061892349272966385, 0.04829036071896553, 0.00007775604899507016, -0.015089252963662148, 0.012594444677233696, 0.032194845378398895, -0.022091414779424667, 0.010609704069793224, -0.02548808790743351, -0.015586012974381447, 0.0011386619880795479, -0.03261646255850792, -0.04566042125225067, -0.02353624999523163, -0.027027659118175507, 0.0018823918653652072, 0.0026815510354936123, 0.05717680975794792, -0.019442494958639145, -0.007455703802406788, -0.03835737705230713, 0.019596334546804428, 0.009819001890718937, -0.003545364597812295, 0.0011837040074169636, 0.01049539539963007, -0.0003924355551134795, 0.034203290939331055, -0.019064193591475487, -0.0320022888481617, -0.011071361601352692, 0.013865683227777481, -0.03740471601486206, 0.015165096148848534, -0.0038392324931919575, -0.023059558123350143, -0.02747165597975254, -0.05396478250622749, 0.047288309782743454, -0.028683487325906754, -0.012580153532326221, 0.01198760699480772, -0.014619572088122368, -0.03761427104473114, 0.05178375542163849, 0.025229448452591896, 0.0383952260017395, 0.012949977070093155, -0.008196834474802017, -0.004793987609446049, -0.026393789798021317, -0.04327148571610451, 0.0023411386646330357, -0.004336279351264238, -0.0012809234904125333, -0.03481529280543327, -0.007949046790599823, 0.007218820508569479, -0.0151542779058218, -0.018894515931606293, 0.0038468020502477884, 0.015877557918429375, -0.06436839699745178, -0.03135688975453377, 0.02430320344865322, 0.02059181220829487, 0.0701141208410263, -0.014106838032603264, -0.013965846039354801, 0.027619827538728714, -0.0018502887105569243, -0.02156743034720421, 0.020039210096001625, 0.03545844182372093, -0.04564554989337921, 0.036540884524583817, 0.021521413698792458, -0.006168999709188938, 0.04744106903672218, 0.000610095274168998, -0.011370211839675903, -0.04576990380883217, 0.006089367438107729, 0.018604470416903496, -0.0017734459834173322, 0.019733555614948273, -0.006815269123762846, 0.00511151785030961, -0.026524711400270462, -0.003498333739116788, -0.03312554210424423, -0.007130831945687532, 0.04473071172833443, 0.03975731506943703, 0.01648985967040062, 0.017892945557832718, 0.036621756851673126, 0.010889064520597458, -0.0423845611512661, -0.010255654342472553, -0.006289320066571236, 0.08231532573699951, 0.025232898071408272, 0.0053699202835559845, 0.028321940451860428, 0.06109776347875595, -0.02548028901219368, -0.021021844819188118, -0.026063796132802963, -0.0021304504480212927, 0.03370271995663643, 0.013169444166123867, 0.025256671011447906, 0.03810088336467743, 0.057750873267650604, -0.010054000653326511, -0.07315592467784882, -0.0009348010644316673, 0.014097216539084911, -0.008789360523223877, 0.03926756605505943, -0.03710230067372322, 0.027450157329440117, 0.03697599843144417, -0.026321930810809135, 0.00592401809990406, 0.04240095615386963, 0.03420931100845337, 0.014168385416269302, 0.03855622932314873, -0.03599220886826515, -0.017455874010920525, 0.014345558360219002, -0.0539768785238266, 0.011088510043919086, -0.04195461794734001, 0.0076808505691587925, 0.016636615619063377, 0.0464126281440258, -0.00773923983797431, -0.06490006297826767, -0.012739123776555061, -0.09397189319133759, 0.002124790335074067, -0.003617585636675358, -0.012529072351753712, 0.0408075712621212, 0.015595829114317894, 0.03507426008582115, -0.04546366259455681, 0.04749252647161484, -0.045371606945991516, -0.05011908710002899, -0.020836452022194862, -0.018804257735610008, -0.0617932565510273, 0.02000727504491806, -0.0207037515938282, 0.007458968553692102, -0.016445254907011986, -0.04117875173687935, 0.003881853073835373, -0.0009849724592640996, 0.0009619590127840638, -0.02807948738336563, 0.08349893242120743, -0.007415172178298235, -0.003877131035551429, 0.028038902208209038, -0.027656543999910355, 0.15001727640628815, 0.08677459508180618, 0.004046522546559572, -0.0160183347761631, 0.0005613446701318026, 0.015538237057626247, -0.004532638471573591, -0.04445180296897888, -0.008953715674579144, 0.017804060131311417, -0.052878256887197495, 0.02381427027285099, 0.025630611926317215, 0.024662405252456665, -0.06009260565042496, 0.06679144501686096, -0.008014530874788761, -0.0016599971568211913, 0.0018074605613946915, 0.008975783362984657, 0.01733969897031784, -0.0055596367456018925, -0.005567221902310848, 0.036956850439310074, 0.010896895080804825, -0.016149891540408134, -0.008058378472924232, -0.01570574939250946, -0.007797498255968094, -0.016827993094921112, -0.03791787847876549, 0.0032363145146518946, 0.01445743441581726, 0.03792104125022888, -0.01231453474611044, -0.0032809849362820387, 0.036483678966760635, -0.06020344793796539, -0.016978280618786812, 0.017983393743634224, -0.001482074148952961, 0.008515384048223495, 0.016192080453038216, 0.01821945235133171, -0.04227631539106369, -0.025401420891284943, -0.07419189065694809, 0.05476869270205498, -0.005825772415846586, 0.009545993991196156, 0.005323689430952072, -0.03573989495635033, -0.024341633543372154, 0.012642748653888702, 0.005165704060345888, 0.000900978862773627, 0.048326484858989716, -0.0431080162525177, -0.03661321476101875, 0.01912226900458336, 0.01088814064860344, -0.005817878060042858, 0.031583983451128006, 0.03627649322152138, 0.02008785866200924, -0.051816780120134354, -0.060851581394672394, 0.054837748408317566, 0.0022737891413271427, -0.009155292995274067, 0.020188335329294205, 0.005007725674659014, -0.052030567079782486, 0.00021991906396578997, -0.0005405917763710022, 0.005302625708281994, -0.003334742272272706, 0.026893846690654755, 0.012378353625535965, -0.053675804287195206, -0.04107139632105827, 0.03873196244239807, -0.05639825388789177, 0.004094356205314398, -0.05301925912499428, -0.009303594008088112, 0.015476192347705364, 0.04511082172393799, 0.02816499024629593, 0.013919545337557793, -0.006386098451912403, 0.06637094169855118, 0.03860243782401085, -0.062407415360212326, -0.03285562992095947, -0.01589328795671463, -0.062350932508707047, -0.006993150804191828, -0.0044901566579937935, 0.07561195641756058, 0.02938207797706127, 0.010134043172001839, 0.004296060651540756, -0.0008131079375743866, -0.021464413031935692, 0.02208385244011879, -0.00955008715391159, -0.0791659876704216, -0.019467219710350037, -0.009728217497467995, -0.026119563728570938, 0.0025540529750287533, -0.008845757693052292, -0.025521064177155495, -0.030911466106772423, -0.0012874898966401815, -0.01927909627556801, -0.03622101992368698, 0.012928168289363384, -0.0019379276782274246, 0.016378775238990784, 0.006171387154608965, 0.01715271919965744, 0.011305248364806175, 0.014664269052445889, -0.01755310595035553, -0.035528670996427536, -0.016504431143403053, 0.008556266315281391, 0.02816765382885933, -0.01366068609058857, 0.05108977481722832, 0.019458916038274765, 0.03776862844824791, -0.04535549134016037, -0.005172520410269499, -0.006536013912409544, 0.03604917228221893, -0.007289194036275148, -0.0018229747656732798, 0.020302310585975647, -0.03563183173537254, -0.03808330371975899, 0.012827477417886257, 0.004065793938934803, 0.05543538182973862, -0.004736569244414568, 0.0006328476592898369, -0.049103230237960815, 0.012877034954726696, 0.02132500894367695, -0.013188434764742851, -0.013805720023810863, 0.027384011074900627, 0.04972570016980171, -0.004651046823710203, 0.036035001277923584, -0.014759297482669353, -0.021131450310349464, 0.0019514025188982487, 0.027079135179519653, -0.0003567975654732436, 0.011527130380272865, 0.01410471461713314, -0.02552168071269989, -0.0015962901525199413, 0.012224134057760239, 0.012854102998971939, 0.054876670241355896, 0.028714671730995178, -0.019039403647184372, 0.004426948726177216, 0.009619159623980522, 0.01619052328169346, -0.0452691912651062, -0.04241856560111046, 0.04370694234967232, 0.014002611860632896, 0.0466107577085495, -0.05594953894615173, 0.01903335191309452, 0.02621227316558361, -0.04190884158015251, 0.018294187262654305, 0.0039235670119524, 0.03388877585530281, -0.03298768773674965, 0.007789095398038626, -0.03478296846151352, 0.009699425660073757, 0.00012425541353877634, 0.022943463176488876, 0.016220714896917343, 0.04129292443394661, -0.0068950713612139225, -0.020684434100985527, -0.0066444785334169865, 0.02395867556333542, 0.003884039120748639, -0.05018119513988495, 0.015915317460894585, -0.05820541828870773, -0.04403066635131836, 0.03283795341849327, -0.015356384217739105, 0.03423844277858734, 0.02359684184193611, 0.00770675390958786, 0.015791581943631172, 0.014484096318483353, 0.021866826340556145, -0.02831674925982952, 0.03336231783032417, 0.003559834323823452, 0.03146369382739067, 0.029379652813076973, 0.0029815996531397104, 0.01966504007577896, 0.050456855446100235, -0.03990614041686058, -0.02456153742969036, -0.03729166090488434, -0.01150408573448658, 0.019626300781965256, 0.006185812409967184, -0.01070624589920044, 0.002412655856460333, -0.02372877486050129, 0.011911171488463879, -0.044079121202230453, 0.020972011610865593, 0.013125551864504814, 0.01848110556602478, -0.0071619004011154175, 0.03421059250831604, -0.007067056372761726, -0.01574646681547165, 0.008869048207998276, -0.03141018748283386, -0.01347681600600481, -0.015818268060684204, 0.016461927443742752, -0.0014214375987648964, -0.011931388638913631, -0.051390230655670166, 0.006938243750482798, -0.0374896265566349, -0.0017500565154477954, 0.03273272514343262, 0.026080872863531113, 0.04660786688327789, 0.022376248612999916, 0.0428093783557415, -0.10333316773176193, 0.044229041785001755, -0.013426904566586018, -0.02694670297205448, -0.0058931694366037846, -0.031982697546482086, -0.02315991185605526, -0.0320039764046669, 0.06718350201845169, -0.018121851608157158, -0.009048809297382832, -0.005144407041370869, 0.039000146090984344, -0.011436308734118938, -0.04118331894278526, 0.036606479436159134, -0.03725142404437065, -0.014494114555418491, -0.02132873795926571, -0.0013491210993379354, 0.014503790996968746, -0.03148728236556053, 0.02311338670551777, -0.05380398780107498, -0.019523004069924355, 0.008373986929655075, -0.04669804871082306, 0.03587848320603371, 0.00310061895288527, -0.06228084862232208, 0.041526470333337784, 0.028116991743445396, -0.01415745634585619, 0.018297312781214714, -0.016724640503525734, -0.0330679714679718, 0.06380833685398102, -0.019871218129992485, -0.03083714097738266, -0.01902281679213047, -0.006364188157021999, -0.0020347118843346834, -0.06526079773902893, -0.004221220035105944, 0.05308754742145538, -0.0039949179627001286, -0.011086561717092991, 0.027948297560214996, 0.02020927518606186, 0.01682233437895775, -0.009521358646452427, 0.042349666357040405, -0.03848022595047951, -0.017855342477560043, -0.005266931839287281, -0.03785116970539093, 0.06695277988910675, 0.04655313491821289, 0.007685577031224966, 0.05412023887038231, -0.012135731987655163, 0.04571912810206413, 0.0027396155055612326, 0.02595573291182518, -0.0468614436686039, 0.015104493126273155, 0.039201706647872925, 0.00595008535310626, 0.04196782410144806, 0.03639356419444084, -0.00182149198371917, 0.04514477401971817, -0.04328366741538048, 0.005171754863113165, -0.058710791170597076, -0.0152922747656703, -0.006818217691034079, -0.013459546491503716, 0.043011803179979324, 0.011711868457496166, 0.002389136701822281, 0.0026783940847963095, 0.02837904915213585, 0.034974776208400726, 0.03209395334124565, -0.007211614865809679, 0.03195265680551529, 0.0036728268023580313, 0.006703480146825314, -0.028814001008868217, -0.024930831044912338, -0.008449357002973557, -0.013284058310091496, 0.021225975826382637, 0.0443037711083889, 0.012424505315721035, -0.008216772228479385, -0.017653726041316986, 0.0003958383167628199, 0.05411872640252113, -0.03672724962234497, -0.04923463985323906, -0.05051948502659798, 0.027279580011963844, 0.006564792711287737, -0.01286037266254425 ]
<p>I have multiple (finitely-many) variables with independent posterior pdfs $f_{x_1}...f_{x_n}$ based on Bayesian updating treating them as independent with independent evidence.</p> <p>If I subsequently discover conditional evidence relating the variables and need a joint prior, is there an analogue to a maximum-entropy prior forming a joint pdf $f_{x_i}(x_1, ...x_n)$ from the individual $f_{x_1}...f_{x_n}$?</p> <p>Sorry if this question is boring, obvious, nonsensical, or underdetermined. If the latter, what extra information is required to make it meaningful?</p>
73,426
[ -0.007242411375045776, 0.033084288239479065, 0.017953531816601753, 0.012401953339576721, 0.02524239756166935, 0.030251866206526756, -0.007158479653298855, -0.008450486697256565, 0.011303667910397053, -0.05946189910173416, 0.026656853035092354, 0.03360369801521301, 0.07020634412765503, -0.00706502515822649, 0.008071284741163254, -0.01049866620451212, -0.028015851974487305, -0.01038597896695137, 0.001141717773862183, -0.03337099775671959, -0.018090838566422462, 0.03237597271800041, 0.02937164343893528, -0.020602405071258545, -0.01770733669400215, 0.06082898750901222, 0.037005431950092316, -0.010415809229016304, 0.01721969060599804, 0.06458860635757446, 0.0014315672451630235, -0.04528707638382912, 0.0035991459153592587, 0.07395947724580765, -0.004027996212244034, -0.04044899716973305, -0.0333138145506382, -0.011675417423248291, 0.0038631341885775328, 0.02943292446434498, -0.06599686294794083, -0.03597251698374748, -0.009842525236308575, 0.02725878544151783, -0.046907924115657806, 0.0029312162660062313, 0.002136422786861658, -0.03020411916077137, 0.020797139033675194, -0.02179514802992344, 0.06938207894563675, 0.01339224074035883, 0.029380854219198227, 0.04611346125602722, -0.037980157881975174, 0.013737564906477928, 0.05460246279835701, 0.10470028221607208, 0.05164601281285286, -0.045355506241321564, -0.027778295800089836, -0.03856301307678223, 0.020144516602158546, -0.0249798484146595, -0.05328194051980972, 0.057588886469602585, -0.023655716329813004, -0.0072556668892502785, 0.0012821261771023273, 0.0002383142418693751, 0.005215217359364033, 0.0027616391889750957, 0.056210990995168686, -0.0026183733716607094, -0.012142285704612732, -0.002889364492148161, 0.021628184244036674, 0.018708141520619392, 0.035292062908411026, 0.0227747093886137, -0.02115797810256481, -0.01715891622006893, 0.030414165928959846, 0.04978392645716667, 0.003027446800842881, -0.013893627561628819, 0.08191748708486557, -0.0180001612752676, 0.010497323237359524, 0.014262096956372261, -0.056746307760477066, -0.013484885916113853, 0.03952194005250931, -0.03502544015645981, -0.07791729271411896, 0.03765816614031792, -0.029653402045369148, 0.025171643123030663, -0.010986880399286747, -0.020930759608745575, 0.0045672147534787655, -0.026242490857839584, -0.013824785128235817, 0.04808735102415085, -0.03321356698870659, -0.007901675999164581, -0.03744533285498619, 0.014680667780339718, -0.020104413852095604, 0.002582019194960594, -0.02504543401300907, 0.031483303755521774, -0.043799687176942825, -0.006008834112435579, 0.02404811792075634, -0.021276669576764107, 0.007084634155035019, -0.024873116984963417, 0.06873959302902222, 0.07345836609601974, 0.05099854618310928, -0.041748080402612686, 0.04126238450407982, -0.0290067121386528, -0.061411913484334946, 0.004353259224444628, 0.007353868335485458, -0.012378078885376453, -0.019422344863414764, 0.05416743457317352, -0.01989324949681759, -0.0022254614159464836, 0.044242724776268005, 0.02646883763372898, -0.024193109944462776, -0.012606932781636715, -0.0811598151922226, -0.015560918487608433, 0.05373023822903633, -0.04217688366770744, -0.02945815771818161, -0.07326839119195938, -0.0016701010754331946, 0.04068503528833389, 0.044449251145124435, -0.02332315593957901, 0.04191417619585991, 0.012990126386284828, 0.03552226722240448, 0.004057496320456266, -0.03471631929278374, -0.02709297090768814, -0.02443241886794567, -0.003744851564988494, -0.029985032975673676, -0.09651452302932739, 0.03029012493789196, 0.0055403257720172405, -0.004934207070618868, -0.00013646503794007003, 0.05905948951840401, -0.011446874588727951, -0.007333462126553059, -0.02759742923080921, 0.013843624852597713, -0.019845781847834587, 0.06787355989217758, -0.00937614869326353, 0.026709087193012238, 0.03801850229501724, 0.0027183271013200283, -0.0021570557728409767, 0.04463057965040207, 0.06621585786342621, 0.052656929939985275, -0.04116231948137283, -0.057405341416597366, 0.016269324347376823, 0.01618998497724533, -0.0026185184251517057, 0.02032761462032795, 0.0033625715877860785, -0.054199784994125366, -0.02576110139489174, 0.023673072457313538, 0.011938344687223434, 0.0168786458671093, -0.030964281409978867, -0.004741881974041462, -0.06797108799219131, -0.0011197435669600964, -0.07146177440881729, -0.008710632100701332, -0.016359029337763786, -0.01788649894297123, 0.054707400500774384, -0.0038183846045285463, 0.05155431479215622, -0.028888365253806114, -0.038806963711977005, -0.0429689846932888, -0.02464989386498928, 0.01419512927532196, -0.035512275993824005, 0.012957198545336723, 0.01674763299524784, 0.06728685647249222, 0.020635249093174934, 0.033444277942180634, -0.036229610443115234, -0.062432099133729935, 0.017456965520977974, -0.016692474484443665, -0.00871429406106472, -0.024218624457716942, 0.0029710724484175444, 0.018247468397021294, -0.026639040559530258, -0.009469609707593918, -0.018618550151586533, -0.04008631780743599, 0.05956161022186279, 0.04608574137091637, 0.030293667688965797, -0.02640930935740471, 0.019093990325927734, 0.02412005327641964, -0.003026877297088504, 0.0005229638773016632, -0.005351061467081308, -0.049695469439029694, -0.0014303933130577207, 0.037096671760082245, 0.040229279547929764, -0.048740264028310776, 0.02830467000603676, 0.01596738211810589, 0.02714078314602375, 0.0005138889537192881, 0.04572439193725586, 0.00784334260970354, -0.012356923893094063, 0.0007022798527032137, 0.008616533130407333, 0.002217227825894952, -0.02198421210050583, 0.023926038295030594, 0.004579651169478893, 0.028563929721713066, -0.0027794779743999243, -0.030520005151629448, 0.008314158767461777, -0.02118866704404354, 0.018877383321523666, -0.016641097143292427, -0.03305036202073097, 0.0055003478191792965, -0.028367631137371063, 0.030093703418970108, 0.008049972355365753, 0.011517706327140331, -0.033769480884075165, 0.002988482592627406, -0.027477391064167023, 0.015169763937592506, 0.023959023877978325, -0.07134978473186493, 0.019004598259925842, 0.015604797750711441, -0.06520255655050278, 0.01653909496963024, -0.019398966804146767, -0.01856527104973793, 0.0022400927264243364, 0.015211855992674828, 0.010815652087330818, -0.03962738439440727, 0.015321063809096813, -0.005094644147902727, -0.03426763787865639, 0.011112554930150509, 0.01160036027431488, 0.03157007694244385, -0.008890987373888493, -0.05043933540582657, 0.010158274322748184, 0.012057164683938026, -0.02113340236246586, 0.027951816096901894, -0.02041950449347496, -0.009132779203355312, -0.027909202501177788, -0.016087232157588005, -0.05080476775765419, -0.008398877456784248, -0.01117849349975586, 0.03681793808937073, -0.03758002072572708, -0.004866078030318022, 0.029119163751602173, -0.007766671013087034, -0.027904605492949486, -0.01904555782675743, -0.031010137870907784, -0.011360805481672287, -0.02961236983537674, -0.015682153403759003, 0.01813879795372486, 0.010561157017946243, 0.03651093691587448, 0.025540189817547798, -0.028381166979670525, 0.004880982916802168, -0.06720507889986038, -0.09318779408931732, 0.05075839161872864, 0.031259190291166306, 0.014740454033017159, -0.015797249972820282, -0.03412161022424698, 0.01904018595814705, 0.012799534015357494, -0.06393877416849136, -0.04337602108716965, 0.013617724180221558, 0.00164960534311831, -0.007905530743300915, -0.008868747390806675, -0.009820529259741306, 0.021638762205839157, 0.06878352165222168, 0.04366783797740936, -0.008579222485423088, 0.028418494388461113, 0.03198555111885071, 0.014418266713619232, 0.02522352710366249, 0.006386096123605967, 0.0041092014871537685, -0.005833799950778484, 0.0294363871216774, -0.03135769069194794, -0.009810580871999264, 0.03090793639421463, 0.025073979049921036, 0.01864786446094513, 0.005539070814847946, 0.03891630098223686, 0.02424057014286518, 0.012988508678972721, -0.049445752054452896, 0.040617942810058594, -0.001747707836329937, -0.014954169280827045, -0.01608317904174328, 0.027653437107801437, 0.019001660868525505, -0.02544439025223255, 0.041533567011356354, 0.06797585636377335, 0.012441743165254593, -0.0363062247633934, -0.006207725964486599, -0.04090970382094383, -0.006500294432044029, 0.0017871937016025186, 0.009409431368112564, -0.007879960350692272, 0.00007514406752306968, 0.012843751348555088, 0.03050578013062477, 0.00026294958661310375, -0.03054155595600605, 0.034817904233932495, -0.04992165043950081, -0.021488623693585396, -0.005283776205033064, 0.008226687088608742, 0.0009180961642414331, 0.07685651630163193, -0.0155982980504632, 0.017142996191978455, -0.0007325625047087669, 0.009877398610115051, -0.08651194721460342, 0.019300514832139015, -0.033920519053936005, 0.00487774983048439, -0.0021516638807952404, -0.02996012382209301, 0.06389433890581131, -0.026663649827241898, 0.00026251215604133904, -0.011316199786961079, 0.027677368372678757, -0.06773609668016434, -0.006516417022794485, -0.04625408351421356, -0.02135438658297062, 0.027169283479452133, 0.029147915542125702, 0.031730715185403824, 0.0013014350552111864, 0.05334694683551788, 0.031161151826381683, -0.001699123065918684, 0.0006126179359853268, -0.0070359716191887856, 0.026455707848072052, -0.013647546991705894, 0.015046126209199429, 0.007973446510732174, 0.04632977768778801, 0.005564468447118998, 0.038713883608579636, 0.007979465648531914, 0.05903610587120056, 0.039441466331481934, -0.03233911469578743, -0.01608303003013134, -0.029743151739239693, -0.006198615301400423, 0.002415112918242812, 0.029758654534816742, -0.002625310095027089, 0.024046050384640694, 0.03544563055038452, 0.02466299757361412, -0.05482027679681778, 0.010835101827979088, 0.05624736100435257, 0.008703730069100857, -0.04203473776578903, -0.004723598249256611, -0.010585791431367397, -0.02655593492090702, -0.012807493098080158, 0.00720087718218565, 0.019616752862930298, -0.03528977185487747, -0.02616056427359581, 0.017609164118766785, -0.03530852124094963, 0.002785127842798829, -0.03135603293776512, 0.008048157207667828, 0.045733675360679626, 0.030791060999035835, -0.014673328958451748, -0.0037006859201937914, 0.014618906192481518, -0.002286213682964444, 0.016029877588152885, 0.008661196567118168, -0.08650888502597809, 0.02311396412551403, 0.035575587302446365, 0.04047549143433571, -0.04692058637738228, 0.019896190613508224, -0.050062187016010284, -0.030069580301642418, 0.06480598449707031, 0.003579167416319251, -0.0074523016810417175, 0.006984722800552845, -0.028014743700623512, 0.04490361735224724, -0.012922391295433044, -0.038716912269592285, 0.034900374710559845, 0.016280172392725945, 0.02478877268731594, 0.011349553242325783, 0.004267820622771978, -0.026513488963246346, 0.01616830751299858, 0.0036336667835712433, 0.0541658028960228, 0.021672705188393593, -0.030763672664761543, 0.0012838965049013495, 0.017094826325774193, 0.03162078559398651, -0.07083038240671158, 0.039720095694065094, -0.004511425271630287, -0.06852119415998459, 0.022890198975801468, -0.025786573067307472, -0.036319486796855927, 0.03260272368788719, 0.013189684599637985, -0.03363381698727608, 0.04939805716276169, 0.02200043573975563, 0.0645674467086792, 0.020988017320632935, 0.013322659768164158, 0.045129138976335526, 0.021857883781194687, 0.0028881116304546595, 0.012322221882641315, -0.018722837790846825, 0.04685673117637634, -0.052576955407857895, 0.008094371296465397, -0.01810133457183838, 0.023495834320783615, 0.0033021357376128435, 0.05325257033109665, -0.02116015926003456, 0.03471493348479271, 0.030433181673288345, -0.027964521199464798, -0.02655836194753647, 0.06253210455179214, 0.027898356318473816, -0.005405148025602102, -0.009119889698922634, 0.016845297068357468, -0.016062036156654358, -0.005887452978640795, 0.02720647118985653, -0.019554095342755318, 0.0065953778102993965, 0.014193976297974586, -0.03245764225721359, 0.01385295856744051, -0.05335909128189087, -0.020521342754364014, 0.01994408667087555, -0.017291253432631493, 0.05729738622903824, 0.006336983293294907, 0.04760920628905296, 0.005868980661034584, -0.03027808852493763, 0.010816040448844433, 0.01719536818563938, -0.017866410315036774, 0.057660166174173355, -0.05288144573569298, 0.031173110008239746, -0.03957965224981308, 0.0010308288037776947, -0.04556117206811905, -0.029133059084415436, -0.0018232772126793861, 0.022527839988470078, -0.029107052832841873, -0.07469334453344345, 0.03404964506626129, -0.027972232550382614, 0.0016042649513110518, -0.024412766098976135, 0.037440888583660126, 0.0043982393108308315, -0.02786715142428875, -0.0022956891916692257, 0.03532135859131813, 0.025475643575191498, -0.005505281034857035, 0.0014612734084948897, 0.04245634004473686, -0.012461114674806595, 0.001980710308998823, 0.008985863998532295, 0.0031005844939500093, -0.023704450577497482, 0.01645243912935257, -0.02475212700664997, -0.00120340206194669, 0.044890791177749634, -0.03974747657775879, 0.01563154347240925, 0.013579551130533218, -0.009928814135491848, 0.0004103981773369014, -0.017268210649490356, -0.026854045689105988, -0.03728405758738518, -0.004024323541671038, -0.019105609506368637, 0.015931257978081703, 0.03258084878325462, -0.04079538583755493, 0.044739995151758194, -0.013946883380413055, -0.028423767536878586, 0.001672875601798296, 0.05905768647789955, -0.007882006466388702, 0.0025861612521111965, 0.020492924377322197, 0.024808526039123535, 0.018784284591674805, -0.014794731512665749, 0.020636307075619698, 0.03244735673069954, -0.0019393290858715773, -0.04143887758255005, -0.03422514349222183, -0.018849510699510574, -0.00014786420797463506, 0.06171606853604317, -0.04063456133008003, 0.036711644381284714, 0.03573936969041824, 0.01024624053388834, -0.007111158687621355, -0.03916597738862038, -0.002337553771212697, 0.0244258064776659, 0.011088329367339611, 0.0427856519818306, -0.026422856375575066, -0.030980492010712624, 0.03690740838646889, 0.004630046896636486, -0.005454963073134422, 0.01619018241763115, 0.0015681294025853276, 0.028761468827724457, 0.0653115063905716, -0.030153345316648483, -0.051339130848646164, 0.03469500690698624, -0.06594476103782654, -0.004879720043390989, -0.02280530519783497, -0.034842777997255325, 0.02567741833627224, 0.033232904970645905, 0.009366912767291069, -0.03474074974656105, -0.031320374459028244, -0.017034677788615227, 0.02657468244433403, 0.008423599414527416, 0.01796131208539009, 0.05113288387656212, -0.03006751276552677, 0.043924205005168915, -0.007006848696619272, 0.005202197935432196, -0.034647807478904724, -0.08974648267030716, -0.05797334015369415, -0.014680745080113411, -0.026860572397708893, 0.020600827410817146, 0.014624211005866528, -0.0178790632635355, 0.02365119755268097, -0.02122189849615097, 0.032353613525629044, -0.028659762814641, 0.03749336674809456, -0.021012797951698303, 0.08954811841249466, 0.013961275108158588, 0.04243854433298111, -0.021612081676721573, 0.0038283641915768385, 0.10616402328014374, 0.04980892315506935, 0.04817913472652435, -0.057653188705444336, 0.012643509544432163, 0.010319968685507774, -0.028779618442058563, -0.035422008484601974, 0.05081180855631828, 0.036324393004179, -0.023255551233887672, 0.021365657448768616, 0.06730378419160843, -0.0018054402898997068, -0.007794671226292849, 0.0546300932765007, -0.0418354831635952, -0.02379811555147171, 0.015839718282222748, 0.016214542090892792, -0.01895064115524292, -0.03616597503423691, -0.04203847795724869, -0.007650483399629593, -0.01452508382499218, -0.003721419256180525, -0.00919106975197792, -0.020799972116947174, 0.019842950627207756, 0.03241952881217003, 0.028544627130031586, -0.031294845044612885, 0.027839818969368935, -0.005771568976342678, 0.004980597645044327, -0.0014885424170643091, 0.01693311147391796, 0.009349930100142956, -0.005924672819674015, 0.009787444025278091, -0.0031107873655855656, 0.019131172448396683, -0.004854719154536724, -0.003620315110310912, -0.008548863232135773, -0.054377853870391846, -0.0229649618268013, 0.035015203058719635, -0.03322187066078186, 0.004432001616805792, -0.046054329723119736, -0.012626206502318382, -0.01145742367953062, -0.02512335777282715, -0.017357537522912025, 0.019669897854328156, 0.052905309945344925, -0.012837973423302174, -0.021281855180859566, -0.00592484837397933, 0.041701462119817734, 0.012275459244847298, 0.025208324193954468, -0.010872011072933674, -0.037256330251693726, -0.01402537152171135, -0.030568845570087433, 0.02896399237215519, 0.04328199848532677, -0.031595803797245026, -0.02311386913061142, -0.013745671138167381, -0.010217655450105667, -0.038889266550540924, 0.002758581889793277, -0.03137419745326042, 0.017742641270160675, 0.007630086503922939, -0.003685423405840993, 0.007513822056353092, -0.015124349854886532, 0.014609776437282562, -0.01107857096940279, -0.022219715639948845, -0.019063422456383705, 0.006121761165559292, 0.032571565359830856, 0.04348623380064964, 0.009221237152814865, 0.002284694230183959, 0.00023191537184175104, 0.04301842302083969, 0.020944911986589432, -0.016817884519696236, -0.004628164693713188, -0.010137410834431648, -0.01341027207672596, 0.008479325100779533, -0.014697911217808723, 0.03873088210821152, 0.02188195288181305, 0.049031905829906464, 0.04052923619747162, 0.025720352306962013, -0.005519308615475893, 0.025631442666053772, -0.005794334691017866, -0.05020410194993019, -0.009429363533854485, 0.003131010802462697, -0.0032198340632021427, -0.014245816506445408, -0.017949990928173065, 0.005501145031303167, 0.013979488052427769, 0.017995094880461693, -0.02599530853331089, -0.044160980731248856, -0.015573726035654545, 0.00486839609220624, 0.04379473254084587, 0.0034157130867242813, 0.013663660734891891, -0.026357922703027725, 0.009726219810545444, -0.0007051549036987126, -0.009545194916427135, 0.007709814701229334, -0.0008983575971797109, -0.01956476829946041, -0.046639006584882736, 0.0265403650701046, 0.018422765657305717, 0.009896286763250828, -0.032171569764614105, 0.004493093583732843, 0.0030643099453300238, 0.060781754553318024, -0.03544614464044571, -0.026357708498835564, 0.03988039121031761, -0.05183781683444977, -0.026029758155345917, 0.018043959513306618, 0.03281574323773384, 0.057557981461286545, 0.03221990168094635, -0.013140090741217136, -0.048512332141399384, 0.030740071088075638, -0.01582472026348114, 0.005942986346781254, 0.014277496375143528, 0.023759935051202774, -0.02627776376903057, -0.01939208246767521, -0.006498880684375763, -0.0006850305362604558, -0.014308365993201733, 0.028803180903196335, 0.04436555877327919, 0.020034251734614372, -0.02636304311454296, 0.042808860540390015, 0.010650129057466984, 0.01753810979425907, -0.005306721199303865, -0.0021938991267234087, 0.06733135879039764, 0.04538795351982117, -0.028714973479509354, 0.01546097919344902, 0.01578139141201973, 0.023257408291101456, -0.1196579709649086, -0.005926245357841253, 0.03126031532883644, 0.021610429510474205, 0.01491157989948988, -0.039301831275224686, 0.03238368034362793, 0.03210756182670593, -0.04531693831086159, 0.013966966420412064, -0.005705211311578751, -0.008913763798773289, -0.025934232398867607, 0.009387847036123276, -0.03971322253346443, 0.03586893901228905, 0.04018761217594147, 0.028515120968222618, 0.030829135328531265, -0.0028565286193042994, -0.01709594950079918, -0.0296002384275198, -0.032708194106817245, 0.013017606921494007, 0.026576749980449677, -0.04971158877015114, 0.04638577625155449, -0.05605851113796234, -0.0679020881652832, 0.007568937726318836, 0.044197291135787964, 0.0021625161170959473, -0.006103562191128731, 0.04158908501267433, 0.02836957946419716, 0.013823064044117928, 0.032884299755096436, -0.00903665367513895, 0.007111380808055401, 0.02354872226715088, -0.009297425858676434, 0.010037548840045929, -0.03689567744731903, -0.00044831601553596556, 0.006552077364176512, 0.0016908388352021575, -0.04398350045084953, 0.0062148249708116055, -0.02770562469959259, -0.03025793842971325, -0.01116621121764183, 0.004840577486902475, 0.016825757920742035, -0.025858813896775246, 0.023692555725574493, -0.055489763617515564, -0.037125665694475174, 0.04172268137335777, 0.014836803078651428, -0.019912663847208023, -0.00044367200462147593, -0.01926097646355629, -0.05676067993044853, 0.00936475396156311, -0.0006837857072241604, -0.013810706324875355, -0.07500520348548889, -0.015914134681224823, 0.005626840516924858, -0.0036690663546323776, -0.029041290283203125, -0.036977559328079224, -0.05017808452248573, 0.012884873896837234, -0.015792082995176315, 0.02249234728515148, -0.0024874189402908087, 0.0014564681332558393, -0.02939698100090027, -0.0516691654920578, 0.038522105664014816, 0.015766145661473274, -0.009879667311906815, -0.021216128021478653, -0.00920234713703394, -0.017216099426150322, -0.039736874401569366, 0.05764402449131012, -0.005854853428900242, 0.0018508958164602518, 0.007681362330913544, 0.029798144474625587, 0.03199131786823273, -0.012734567746520042, 0.01938764378428459, -0.013037493452429771, -0.013095256872475147, -0.038999464362859726, -0.0065567283891141415, 0.03835035488009453, -0.003211056347936392, 0.017023181542754173, -0.03944233059883118, -0.004997606854885817, -0.005956927314400673, 0.046187855303287506, 0.04268788546323776, -0.039928138256073, -0.02876635268330574, 0.013736494816839695, 0.000727073464076966, 0.029092663899064064, 0.028847362846136093, 0.007180037442594767, -0.03778642416000366, 0.02742350846529007, 0.005296401213854551, -0.04833211377263069, 0.016493402421474457, 0.007670975290238857, -0.029165808111429214, -0.05411020666360855, -0.006653083022683859, 0.0235958993434906, -0.07352352887392044, 0.04397277161478996, 0.03803917393088341, 0.021321408450603485, 0.04286593943834305, 0.016514258459210396, 0.003516357159242034, 0.03383146598935127, -0.010725448839366436, -0.0021969815716147423, 0.0193142332136631, 0.05329778045415878, 0.009604847058653831, 0.015426167286932468, 0.014060409739613533, -0.03425363451242447, 0.04305660352110863, -0.0039975689724087715, 0.03461877256631851, -0.03619631007313728, -0.022177135571837425, -0.01122615672647953, -0.014299009926617146, 0.01171083189547062, -0.029582852497696877, -0.005950752180069685, 0.03778986260294914, -0.015185817144811153, -0.0014359544729813933, -0.04415351524949074, 0.039353616535663605, -0.0034819834399968386, -0.006453879177570343, 0.002146603772416711, 0.05130891501903534, 0.02349786087870598, -0.012000390328466892, 0.007706973701715469, -0.027941005304455757, 0.00477787246927619, -0.035303838551044464, 0.03043106198310852, -0.037307221442461014, 0.005737787112593651, 0.02701338566839695, -0.02765447460114956, -0.03795462101697922, -0.03554995357990265, -0.007202521897852421, 0.05103956162929535, 0.03987627476453781, -0.027381982654333115, -0.06439050287008286, -0.020849667489528656, 0.03506707027554512, -0.048050954937934875, 0.013757936656475067, -0.056391164660453796, 0.004453970119357109, 0.030935581773519516, 0.003203198779374361 ]
<p>I'm want to show that a customer who buys paper books is more likely to buy an e-reader than a customer who does not buy paper books. Note that the number of e-readers purchased in the past is small (1,000) compared to the total set of events (1,000,000).</p> <p>Here's the historical data that I have:</p> <pre><code>Customer Name | Month | Purchased Books in Last Month | Purchased Books in Last 12 Months | Purchased Books in Last 3 Years | Purchased Book this Month | Purchased e-Reader this Month Joe Smith | 1/12 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 Joe Smith | 2/12 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 Joe Smith | 3/12 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 ... </code></pre> <p>Using these historical data, I'd like to demonstrate that book-buyers are more likely to buy e-readers, especially if they have recently purchased a book.</p> <ol> <li><p>When I do a linear regression on the binary events for "Purchased Books in Last 12 Months" and "Purchased e-Reader this Month", I get r &lt; 0.1.</p></li> <li><p>However, if I compare P(purchased e-reader) to P(purchased e-reader | purchased books in last 12 months), the probability of a previous-book-buyer purchasing an e-reader is 10x higher than a random customer purchasing an e-reader</p></li> </ol> <p>How do I reconcile these two results? Am I using the right tools to answer this question with confidence?</p>
35,800
[ -0.01997547596693039, -0.05195818468928337, -0.006301757413893938, -0.011810515075922012, 0.012849424034357071, 0.016642777249217033, 0.02934788540005684, 0.03599404916167259, 0.002688351785764098, 0.02716096304357052, 0.043452076613903046, 0.03633856773376465, 0.05641347914934158, -0.0016686600865796208, 0.03718941658735275, 0.04117384925484657, -0.03242231532931328, 0.015046677552163601, 0.014088592492043972, -0.012125912122428417, -0.009588007815182209, 0.01256830245256424, 0.031863097101449966, -0.01818062923848629, -0.01214210782200098, 0.022078609094023705, 0.03410889580845833, -0.03438646346330643, 0.023277726024389267, 0.02641347423195839, -0.015781709924340248, -0.04815572500228882, 0.02417575754225254, 0.04870304465293884, 0.019078241661190987, 0.02487511746585369, -0.008728609420359135, -0.05262236297130585, -0.017485786229372025, 0.006380617618560791, -0.01319167111068964, 0.02218356914818287, -0.005665229167789221, 0.07038860023021698, -0.004843111615628004, 0.025292951613664627, 0.025621194392442703, -0.0035835369490087032, 0.029553838074207306, -0.017749128863215446, 0.05261126905679703, -0.04294551536440849, 0.07271967083215714, 0.03165104240179062, -0.047195181250572205, -0.011572908610105515, 0.037122588604688644, 0.07288207113742828, -0.025517169386148453, -0.033514756709337234, -0.00044995464850217104, -0.04276617616415024, -0.015325181186199188, -0.011394028551876545, -0.013229948468506336, -0.001693910569883883, 0.01452326774597168, -0.012761875987052917, 0.04583149030804634, -0.041900768876075745, 0.01540723443031311, 0.012238061986863613, 0.0449499636888504, 0.026189666241407394, 0.0002492248313501477, -0.04496820643544197, 0.002752721542492509, 0.030738990753889084, 0.06919483095407486, 0.002316942671313882, -0.03194499760866165, -0.0013773392420262098, 0.0282330010086298, 0.07335544377565384, 0.033091042190790176, -0.045355476438999176, 0.05854231119155884, -0.0223176721483469, -0.008729027584195137, 0.02464410662651062, 0.005202106200158596, -0.00020610318460967392, 0.005489409901201725, 0.004968603607267141, -0.07110435515642166, 0.04206375032663345, -0.009713866747915745, 0.00394541397690773, 0.011334139853715897, 0.013647201471030712, -0.0003719006199389696, -0.07721426337957382, 0.018103457987308502, 0.0512196309864521, -0.02537180297076702, -0.041194550693035126, -0.011824795976281166, 0.0018581761978566647, -0.021950041875243187, -0.0068833003751933575, -0.04673253372311592, 0.015220887027680874, 0.001293623587116599, -0.010690804570913315, -0.017120936885476112, -0.020193209871649742, -0.011521978303790092, -0.02382643334567547, 0.06550510227680206, 0.04771195724606514, 0.029901979491114616, -0.02650212123990059, -0.005710024852305651, -0.02960357815027237, -0.02153533324599266, 0.022654321044683456, 0.027117835357785225, -0.04028533399105072, -0.002398513723164797, 0.059226144105196, -0.03532803803682327, 0.009485388174653053, 0.05035737529397011, 0.012843398377299309, 0.022119246423244476, 0.013303309679031372, -0.048677220940589905, -0.03744421899318695, 0.03634548932313919, -0.027835257351398468, 0.01415938325226307, -0.058738596737384796, 0.02145169861614704, 0.03455684706568718, 0.037845198065042496, 0.006893567740917206, 0.04367945343255997, -0.01598832756280899, -0.003676155349239707, 0.032105207443237305, -0.016562167555093765, 0.0026023928076028824, -0.023747887462377548, 0.01822766475379467, -0.03366194665431976, -0.061118338257074356, 0.02419811300933361, -0.010202989913523197, -0.020330965518951416, -0.033199701458215714, 0.05517647787928581, -0.012936926446855068, -0.03515498712658882, -0.01757352612912655, -0.02365691401064396, -0.04325264319777489, 0.08821442723274231, 0.008550489321351051, 0.01362862903624773, -0.0018154766876250505, 0.014680461958050728, 0.027752188965678215, 0.030085701495409012, 0.00917849037796259, 0.04658658057451248, -0.004502180498093367, 0.024069059640169144, 0.00010379318700870499, -0.010645125061273575, 0.03871474787592888, -0.03653085604310036, -0.04434579238295555, -0.06921356171369553, -0.03234598785638809, 0.017867235466837883, -0.0007873630966059864, -0.008123540319502354, -0.02681601792573929, 0.02480592578649521, -0.06111637130379677, -0.05823604762554169, -0.09136446565389633, 0.011358392424881458, 0.009666932746767998, -0.02828800305724144, 0.0035327086225152016, -0.0329834520816803, 0.017167584970593452, 0.0016858781455084682, -0.020860398188233376, -0.03767361491918564, -0.0036886953748762608, 0.006746981758624315, -0.06067624315619469, -0.002338995225727558, 0.05746409296989441, 0.045390352606773376, -0.03728078678250313, 0.0338297039270401, -0.05952360853552818, -0.05679115653038025, 0.03827723488211632, -0.04639115929603577, -0.0037752476055175066, 0.011339457705616951, -0.03469015657901764, 0.025925511494278908, 0.019562533125281334, 0.006593641359359026, 0.03757031634449959, -0.03411932662129402, 0.006661531049758196, 0.08955218642950058, 0.006718214135617018, -0.001966250827535987, -0.017797185108065605, 0.017011212185025215, 0.031075121834874153, -0.003137012477964163, -0.015224939212203026, -0.05300294980406761, 0.012840677984058857, 0.002710076281800866, 0.03230220079421997, -0.009362438693642616, 0.010608812794089317, 0.06479746103286743, 0.008882713504135609, -0.00942717120051384, 0.025842946022748947, -0.0001828573294915259, -0.011227904818952084, 0.02873888984322548, 0.01146908663213253, 0.022901372984051704, 0.014566372148692608, 0.019319381564855576, -0.04534537345170975, 0.032471947371959686, 0.00985564012080431, 0.004970480687916279, 0.005860054865479469, 0.021002501249313354, -0.01555503811687231, -0.021200373768806458, -0.009291620925068855, 0.050697799772024155, -0.02582385018467903, -0.02180630713701248, -0.005530984606593847, -0.007676636800169945, 0.014982607215642929, -0.012960228137671947, -0.035285502672195435, 0.010967828333377838, 0.008373143151402473, -0.0358722098171711, -0.0340055376291275, 0.01397018600255251, -0.022314127534627914, 0.031370099633932114, -0.036853909492492676, -0.02249724231660366, -0.0345727801322937, 0.0272365789860487, 0.037846680730581284, -0.0003306508588138968, 0.03689495474100113, -0.02167605794966221, -0.024482041597366333, -0.014111127704381943, 0.02109510637819767, 0.004794348031282425, -0.05253329500555992, -0.10187774151563644, -0.005748128984123468, -0.003914304077625275, -0.029086751863360405, 0.0037052726838737726, 0.009753836318850517, -0.03052605502307415, 0.00410082470625639, -0.010080204345285892, -0.029398106038570404, -0.03433965519070625, -0.03851846605539322, -0.02641173079609871, -0.009948761202394962, -0.045687370002269745, 0.05018043518066406, -0.011858977377414703, -0.03200944513082504, 0.006809637416154146, -0.03460042178630829, 0.002689134795218706, 0.007695513311773539, -0.05766940489411354, -0.04027682915329933, -0.029992714524269104, 0.008388089016079903, 0.003120959037914872, 0.038384802639484406, -0.008680826984345913, -0.09573427587747574, -0.03504003584384918, -0.01749645173549652, -0.0206595491617918, 0.048155926167964935, -0.007892463356256485, 0.017938414588570595, 0.061242640018463135, 0.050312161445617676, -0.03527239337563515, -0.03361057862639427, -0.001127898576669395, -0.020841950550675392, -0.04984995722770691, -0.00164125207811594, 0.03903713449835777, -0.0049973139539361, 0.02199171856045723, 0.0010984307155013084, 0.00041692479862831533, 0.04391049966216087, -0.011034348979592323, 0.021219829097390175, 0.016642887145280838, -0.006534547079354525, 0.009144678711891174, 0.04013955965638161, 0.04279956966638565, -0.026412129402160645, 0.029132463037967682, -0.04306134209036827, 0.02511213906109333, -0.016554594039916992, -0.0588969849050045, 0.004218702670186758, -0.003610490122810006, 0.004444225691258907, -0.009249590337276459, 0.033852964639663696, -0.009043578989803791, -0.035832617431879044, 0.041116006672382355, -0.02714596316218376, 0.0431491918861866, 0.006103694438934326, 0.014752472750842571, 0.018432490527629852, 0.03759120777249336, -0.012678636237978935, -0.00549249118193984, -0.01968095824122429, 0.01037380751222372, 0.01214370783418417, -0.01786922849714756, 0.0033540180884301662, 0.04469351842999458, 0.04220008850097656, 0.0077154929749667645, -0.017776427790522575, -0.0502377487719059, -0.02934602089226246, -0.01895679160952568, -0.0021203039214015007, -0.009421754628419876, 0.05876801162958145, 0.0011124474694952369, 0.05091661959886551, 0.006774989888072014, -0.06082199141383171, 0.03767668828368187, -0.019493374973535538, -0.08413930982351303, 0.017804324626922607, 0.02179010584950447, -0.007471467833966017, -0.028087858110666275, -0.002443395322188735, 0.0107621094211936, -0.036026887595653534, -0.011242174543440342, -0.005781424231827259, -0.02383117750287056, -0.015707705169916153, 0.005509677808731794, -0.014392142184078693, 0.009787547402083874, 0.0016529334243386984, -0.0057642823085188866, -0.001971394056454301, 0.003646626602858305, 0.048837464302778244, 0.03595275059342384, 0.0187644325196743, 0.01732051372528076, -0.004347555339336395, 0.046882808208465576, 0.024266012012958527, 0.026706228032708168, 0.044213782995939255, -0.007046632934361696, -0.02467375621199608, 0.00704744178801775, 0.03632770851254463, 0.03206830099225044, 0.05055844038724899, 0.005825951229780912, -0.04071664810180664, -0.049168363213539124, 0.0067404271103441715, 0.008480255492031574, 0.00002563203997851815, 0.023100251331925392, -0.0071563441306352615, 0.04415806010365486, 0.05207587778568268, -0.049978408962488174, 0.012506614439189434, 0.07732449471950531, -0.027842357754707336, -0.011640851385891438, -0.017425216734409332, 0.0017875282792374492, -0.0004908285336568952, -0.009647030383348465, 0.03120831400156021, 0.04023164138197899, 0.021759063005447388, -0.0010939195053651929, 0.037566930055618286, 0.02225753851234913, -0.037741780281066895, -0.01925591006875038, -0.016563214361667633, 0.0173955038189888, 0.0020087906159460545, -0.03104502148926258, 0.03774673864245415, 0.028743397444486618, 0.027032222598791122, 0.03461189195513725, -0.0012356846127659082, -0.07780678570270538, 0.017873087897896767, 0.04143845662474632, 0.07052109390497208, -0.06956683099269867, -0.03793197497725487, -0.06125357374548912, -0.017781350761651993, 0.008938555605709553, -0.015652021393179893, -0.005472375545650721, -0.013339529745280743, 0.027830645442008972, -0.021460222080349922, -0.044325489550828934, -0.055345915257930756, 0.023485833778977394, -0.04500451311469078, 0.021045144647359848, -0.03473520278930664, -0.03761143609881401, -0.04261916130781174, 0.02979937382042408, 0.04101860523223877, 0.06345275044441223, -0.06889333575963974, -0.022010060027241707, 0.004118984565138817, 0.007719498127698898, -0.04417763650417328, -0.06334245949983597, 0.004600355867296457, -0.04669508710503578, 0.006362889893352985, 0.02600242756307125, 0.00196798425167799, -0.019168607890605927, 0.005070988088846207, 0.004548759665340185, -0.05399793013930321, -0.029587583616375923, 0.003324430203065276, 0.0015272777527570724, 0.032454557716846466, 0.006680774036794901, 0.07358793914318085, 0.023488862439990044, 0.011443794704973698, 0.012540851719677448, -0.012549292296171188, 0.003954166546463966, -0.02453181892633438, -0.018115099519491196, -0.059575505554676056, 0.024712393060326576, -0.0030077206902205944, 0.009728928096592426, 0.02047864720225334, -0.011349568143486977, 0.01727261207997799, -0.020671872422099113, -0.008313242346048355, 0.02411668188869953, -0.029912082478404045, 0.0023733749985694885, -0.033297307789325714, -0.00007201718108262867, -0.03596390038728714, 0.007219343446195126, -0.004340053535997868, -0.008122715167701244, 0.018331008031964302, 0.0095381960272789, -0.01922505721449852, 0.07307560741901398, -0.03191211819648743, 0.00017825690156314522, -0.015617605298757553, -0.03753114491701126, 0.016091635450720787, 0.012691980227828026, 0.020253317430615425, -0.001706222421489656, 0.008064065128564835, -0.00860716961324215, 0.0015093506081029773, 0.02769361436367035, -0.006959844380617142, -0.032493408769369125, 0.026755403727293015, -0.013122628442943096, -0.03257959336042404, -0.047916289418935776, -0.042491987347602844, 0.03734874352812767, 0.012016882188618183, -0.035443905740976334, -0.02120989002287388, -0.025652259588241577, 0.013966291211545467, 0.01598235033452511, -0.017919814214110374, 0.033771224319934845, -0.030945317819714546, -0.02112027443945408, 0.015533534809947014, 0.009429306723177433, 0.05300995334982872, -0.01082045491784811, -0.057394206523895264, 0.01732882857322693, 0.00903099961578846, -0.04621516913175583, -0.03326907753944397, 0.00020772575226146728, -0.028755951672792435, -0.025276659056544304, -0.024596959352493286, 0.020068330690264702, 0.062059737741947174, -0.05221191421151161, -0.00028751022182404995, -0.006457903888076544, 0.011424936354160309, 0.03741958364844322, -0.01568281464278698, -0.0009961235336959362, -0.009675541892647743, -0.002378916833549738, -0.04863708093762398, 0.003898576833307743, -0.019953474402427673, -0.0026335441507399082, 0.027359867468476295, 0.030061844736337662, -0.04359139874577522, 0.023166226223111153, 0.07861067354679108, -0.024864038452506065, 0.0165842454880476, -0.014345470815896988, -0.021379809826612473, 0.05752602219581604, -0.003617155132815242, -0.002539133420214057, 0.021814916282892227, 0.009290993213653564, -0.040101245045661926, -0.005337562412023544, -0.026153109967708588, 0.000501785078085959, 0.05951451137661934, -0.021503373980522156, 0.061213601380586624, 0.039131730794906616, 0.034682370722293854, 0.0036204499192535877, -0.020586548373103142, -0.010186368599534035, -0.008324902504682541, -0.027860697358846664, 0.02573397383093834, -0.03649980202317238, -0.011299755424261093, 0.046398624777793884, 0.002211679005995393, 0.01529139094054699, 0.0470893420279026, 0.011545197106897831, 0.00915564689785242, 0.05496490001678467, -0.025875769555568695, 0.00015734053158666939, 0.034232042729854584, -0.05793969705700874, 0.0235784649848938, -0.03441629186272621, -0.022956624627113342, 0.01577652059495449, 0.04270531237125397, 0.00153042480815202, -0.037473198026418686, -0.046948280185461044, -0.0768706277012825, 0.005806270055472851, 0.023984935134649277, 0.027293410152196884, 0.05425107479095459, 0.026106979697942734, 0.026031747460365295, 0.01274760253727436, -0.006032394245266914, -0.010232437402009964, -0.06774507462978363, -0.019509747624397278, 0.0034999591298401356, -0.00021312788885552436, 0.026472754776477814, -0.0031194286420941353, -0.01691005565226078, -0.0010031781857833266, -0.009754324331879616, 0.01167739275842905, 0.04937835782766342, 0.033106643706560135, 0.0383138433098793, 0.09764821082353592, 0.02672777883708477, 0.035140663385391235, -0.004870116710662842, -0.016025453805923462, 0.12769073247909546, 0.06937406212091446, 0.033324338495731354, -0.030377371236681938, 0.026042185723781586, 0.04123421385884285, 0.027905821800231934, -0.016512304544448853, 0.016199547797441483, 0.001810606918297708, -0.011974669992923737, 0.06690249592065811, 0.029801372438669205, -0.004871138371527195, -0.02443590760231018, 0.042810577899217606, -0.05028181150555611, -0.007331154774874449, 0.010287485085427761, 0.01549312099814415, 0.03213149681687355, -0.027108781039714813, -0.041908543556928635, 0.002129601314663887, 0.007071519736200571, -0.013383063487708569, -0.02646551840007305, -0.03844054788351059, -0.017289582639932632, 0.011861016973853111, 0.010268839076161385, 0.008645424619317055, 0.046908751130104065, 0.05273021012544632, 0.014608277007937431, -0.01483574416488409, 0.014516128227114677, -0.012610391713678837, 0.03716747835278511, 0.04588853940367699, 0.011859738267958164, -0.004961886443197727, 0.006489512976258993, 0.02860029600560665, -0.06450861692428589, -0.024722442030906677, -0.0600818432867527, 0.05151958763599396, -0.015474916435778141, -0.014548655599355698, -0.017550718039274216, -0.032783083617687225, -0.005684176925569773, -0.0056131319142878056, -0.03843080252408981, 0.06701774895191193, -0.005088805221021175, 0.016307400539517403, -0.004806553944945335, -0.011390607804059982, 0.01921689696609974, -0.021755319088697433, 0.03944924473762512, 0.043778229504823685, -0.012110746465623379, 0.017145371064543724, -0.04577399790287018, 0.03009575605392456, -0.037465374916791916, 0.024628570303320885, 0.007097100839018822, -0.015263473615050316, -0.029269983991980553, -0.02940783090889454, 0.016118647530674934, 0.005395516287535429, -0.007083858363330364, -0.012316872365772724, 0.01306267362087965, 0.031724441796541214, 0.021804403513669968, 0.01922178454697132, -0.018129227682948112, 0.009378578513860703, -0.02735978364944458, 0.002764257835224271, 0.02892768196761608, 0.029486851766705513, 0.026574986055493355, 0.018000403419137, -0.003285665065050125, 0.06449699401855469, 0.003127374453470111, -0.03946799784898758, -0.04573030397295952, -0.05011770501732826, -0.02588801458477974, -0.006097315810620785, -0.0040373364463448524, 0.047139935195446014, 0.03341745585203171, 0.005876386538147926, 0.027968136593699455, -0.0449865460395813, -0.005400063004344702, 0.009141608141362667, 0.0006650500581599772, -0.05380050837993622, 0.016640018671751022, 0.032347675412893295, -0.039821650832891464, -0.023202650249004364, -0.0225762277841568, -0.008205628953874111, -0.011697321198880672, 0.019196055829524994, -0.004581700079143047, -0.0188943799585104, 0.010832307860255241, -0.04294855520129204, 0.009334716945886612, -0.019595477730035782, 0.0015887629706412554, -0.050809346139431, -0.03417092189192772, 0.0031125997193157673, -0.0004128767759539187, -0.00561887351796031, 0.03705679997801781, -0.0014628003118559718, -0.00191882171202451, -0.007291528861969709, 0.01822810061275959, 0.004032961558550596, -0.019224470481276512, 0.05106350779533386, -0.00951425451785326, 0.02096685580909252, -0.06096668168902397, -0.04924369603395462, 0.04897822067141533, -0.03814375400543213, -0.005174683406949043, 0.010865861549973488, 0.014433384872972965, 0.05374976247549057, -0.018775733187794685, -0.004457333590835333, 0.0031863534823060036, 0.02627342939376831, -0.01641716994345188, -0.03318675607442856, -0.0058744982816278934, -0.014598904177546501, 0.03224403038620949, 0.0072934990748763084, 0.004627860616892576, 0.0083996020257473, 0.009491161443293095, 0.032757751643657684, 0.07121579349040985, -0.016128793358802795, -0.0016283199656754732, 0.010895947925746441, 0.02572350576519966, 0.009516245685517788, 0.024289721623063087, 0.006408207584172487, 0.015723079442977905, -0.0039251744747161865, -0.01971033588051796, 0.04223274067044258, 0.013849148526787758, -0.010329632088541985, -0.08754877746105194, -0.04902750998735428, -0.007211113814264536, 0.007403242867439985, 0.015784891322255135, -0.06420215964317322, -0.008302648551762104, 0.004066894296556711, -0.018372684717178345, -0.014795243740081787, 0.00569166149944067, 0.023349640890955925, -0.05407596379518509, 0.01465308666229248, -0.0036364125553518534, 0.0017257153522223234, 0.04142140969634056, 0.0748380646109581, 0.054432980716228485, 0.022529853507876396, 0.04476466402411461, -0.01569320634007454, -0.05255590379238129, -0.011932406574487686, 0.0034754653461277485, -0.04260053113102913, 0.021476464346051216, -0.040425896644592285, -0.03483852744102478, 0.046249326318502426, -0.011112082749605179, 0.02994907833635807, 0.028801171109080315, 0.030091427266597748, 0.02351084165275097, 0.03971312195062637, 0.059447694569826126, 0.009052898734807968, 0.011322162114083767, -0.025566864758729935, 0.01600995473563671, 0.015989618375897408, -0.0025808054488152266, 0.024616843089461327, 0.01563691906630993, -0.028310513123869896, 0.000720081152394414, 0.010125515051186085, -0.021847372874617577, -0.01126753818243742, -0.000277973769698292, 0.04414273798465729, 0.02558913826942444, -0.02248437888920307, 0.023119794204831123, -0.0532962940633297, -0.0205290075391531, 0.016429120674729347, 0.03754061087965965, -0.008797042071819305, 0.0011845227563753724, -0.026727905496954918, -0.04442563280463219, 0.0010323117021471262, 0.02552180178463459, 0.002534188563004136, -0.06485764682292938, 0.008574876934289932, 0.0165620818734169, 0.0041700201109051704, -0.019857922568917274, -0.03173734247684479, -0.07179994136095047, 0.020866764709353447, -0.010894290171563625, -0.005262056365609169, 0.06722240895032883, 0.006501425057649612, 0.036500297486782074, -0.0806843489408493, 0.056630201637744904, 0.01685282401740551, 0.005626700818538666, -0.03415447846055031, -0.026712141931056976, -0.03828682750463486, 0.02294703759253025, 0.0405091866850853, 0.0005884419661015272, -0.008551126345992088, -0.00598657364025712, -0.005903605837374926, 0.014553552493453026, -0.052971113473176956, 0.04707219451665878, -0.046071067452430725, 0.0071706208400428295, 0.006133000832051039, -0.0003184178494848311, 0.004984251689165831, 0.015457123517990112, -0.0016152302268892527, 0.0037012456450611353, -0.021690035238862038, 0.009880759753286839, -0.01800864189863205, 0.03358972445130348, 0.028681814670562744, 0.01705656200647354, 0.03525262326002121, 0.051045168191194534, 0.000528518168721348, -0.015412973240017891, 0.006635668687522411, -0.07392332702875137, 0.07345278561115265, -0.03342481330037117, -0.02757256291806698, 0.001577815506607294, -0.0031915984582155943, -0.0029124864377081394, -0.07365042716264725, 0.0052780527621507645, 0.0016288225306198, -0.03515216335654259, 0.03154130280017853, 0.007611725479364395, 0.003015485592186451, 0.045933905988931656, -0.01122690737247467, 0.014007305726408958, -0.016820626333355904, -0.0157307181507349, -0.01307650376111269, -0.03451002016663551, 0.02387218549847603, -0.0014730867696925998, 0.031538259238004684, 0.047306984663009644, -0.0030498583801090717, 0.0019648494198918343, -0.00874272733926773, 0.05259613320231438, -0.02624615654349327, 0.008787228725850582, 0.04698820039629936, -0.004356354009360075, 0.01224542036652565, 0.03298679739236832, 0.026396818459033966, 0.021508214995265007, -0.03918306902050972, 0.02146146260201931, -0.02165021374821663, 0.004304993432015181, 0.010264950804412365, -0.009924063459038734, 0.05046366527676582, 0.00305127608589828, 0.016164978966116905, 0.02428562194108963, -0.017392462119460106, -0.002983292331919074, 0.01995430327951908, -0.027035750448703766, -0.0008038418018259108, -0.006138812750577927, -0.0708371177315712, -0.004985518287867308, -0.025157134979963303, 0.010006925091147423, -0.019008329138159752, 0.014332771301269531, 0.017871854826807976, 0.03202381357550621, 0.01181161217391491, -0.029866032302379608, -0.008044242858886719, 0.02897104062139988, -0.03751314803957939, -0.0011035287752747536, -0.04970593750476837, 0.030787670984864235, 0.014986134134232998, -0.03613828495144844 ]
<p>I'm hoping someone can explain this bit of R code for me related to <code>glm()</code>. I don't understand the diagnostic plot that has been suggested. It seems a more informative plot would be to plot against the fitted values, but maybe I don't understand something. Here's the code:</p> <pre><code>result &lt;- glm(survive~age, data=donner, family=binomial) # Why is this plotted against the respondent index? plot(residuals(result,type="pearson"), main="pearson residual plot") </code></pre> <p>Data to reproduce the above example:</p> <pre><code>&gt; dput(donner) structure(list(age = c(23L, 40L, 40L, 30L, 28L, 40L, 45L, 62L, 65L, 45L, 25L, 28L, 28L, 23L, 22L, 23L, 28L, 15L, 47L, 57L, 20L, 18L, 25L, 60L, 25L, 20L, 32L, 32L, 24L, 30L, 15L, 50L, 21L, 25L, 46L, 32L, 30L, 25L, 25L, 25L, 30L, 35L, 23L, 24L, 25L), sex = c(1L, 0L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 0L, 1L, 1L, 0L, 0L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 0L, 0L, 1L, 0L, 0L, 1L, 0L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 0L, 0L, 1L, 1L, 0L, 0L, 1L, 1L, 0L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 0L), survive = c(0L, 1L, 1L, 0L, 0L, 0L, 0L, 0L, 0L, 0L, 0L, 1L, 0L, 0L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 0L, 0L, 1L, 1L, 0L, 0L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 0L, 0L, 1L, 0L, 1L, 1L, 0L, 0L, 0L, 0L, 0L, 0L, 1L, 0L, 1L)), .Names = c("age", "sex", "survive"), class = "data.frame", row.names = c(NA, -45L )) </code></pre>
73,427
[ -0.024500994011759758, -0.01799301616847515, -0.009361115284264088, -0.022431012243032455, 0.012677113525569439, -0.026275308802723885, -0.010350329801440239, -0.025435004383325577, 0.038586366921663284, -0.04821160435676575, 0.017325004562735558, 0.03226931393146515, 0.03525586426258087, 0.03423722833395004, 0.05264544486999512, 0.03025694750249386, -0.009793049655854702, 0.014990490861237049, 0.020611325278878212, -0.016330236569046974, -0.01038618665188551, -0.007123561110347509, -0.009727642871439457, -0.014265482313930988, -0.02092803083360195, 0.05232195928692818, 0.01934194006025791, -0.018945982679724693, 0.013629952445626259, 0.042019136250019073, -0.08906958997249603, -0.03980400413274765, -0.005124368704855442, -0.00009705185220809653, 0.042618781328201294, 0.028683248907327652, -0.009578600525856018, -0.015522199682891369, 0.0035629509948194027, 0.04814406484365463, -0.009991750121116638, -0.012179727666079998, 0.01854327879846096, 0.021845713257789612, -0.006947372108697891, 0.02675207145512104, -0.01121976412832737, 0.008943410590291023, 0.05485539138317108, -0.03602033853530884, 0.037759628146886826, -0.016069063916802406, 0.016035061329603195, 0.014571379870176315, -0.046409934759140015, -0.008204509504139423, 0.06718442589044571, 0.040535446256399155, -0.00567574193701148, -0.07251773029565811, -0.01623784750699997, -0.04850342497229576, 0.0024667533580213785, 0.011460427194833755, 0.013396793976426125, 0.0021195600274950266, 0.034940410405397415, -0.039307743310928345, 0.047542329877614975, -0.018180809915065765, -0.009024785831570625, 0.03751611337065697, 0.008038723841309547, -0.05640966817736626, 0.04378121718764305, -0.01874997653067112, 0.012748622335493565, -0.01875002309679985, 0.017970480024814606, 0.008261514827609062, 0.008094662800431252, 0.01139152329415083, 0.006064123008400202, 0.03588873893022537, -0.013447428122162819, -0.007795531302690506, 0.056081950664520264, -0.022342482581734657, 0.041977282613515854, 0.026944786310195923, 0.007331769913434982, 0.05806864798069, 0.03714719042181969, 0.002366089727729559, -0.029630307108163834, 0.04088727757334709, 0.01750793308019638, 0.017833922058343887, 0.007353165186941624, 0.004152087029069662, -0.043972961604595184, -0.04589524865150452, 0.00555520411580801, 0.041353173553943634, -0.03302738443017006, -0.02999582514166832, -0.03925401344895363, -0.013554345816373825, 0.007030384615063667, -0.02841668762266636, -0.01703743264079094, 0.028894532471895218, 0.00297095556743443, 0.011240767315030098, 0.02645016834139824, -0.03272105008363724, -0.022244788706302643, 0.05301997810602188, 0.05949700251221657, 0.03138313814997673, 0.026844333857297897, -0.0012219075579196215, -0.017457664012908936, 0.018800320103764534, -0.07104962319135666, 0.003078124951571226, 0.016040200367569923, -0.007785513531416655, -0.0027613448910415173, 0.03352456912398338, -0.00834811944514513, -0.036084502935409546, 0.06694937497377396, 0.01792929694056511, 0.016510577872395515, -0.027232034131884575, -0.0835423395037651, -0.04914916679263115, 0.03604983538389206, 0.00973474606871605, 0.007843486033380032, -0.06837194412946701, -0.0028287358582019806, 0.016305314376950264, 0.05740848183631897, -0.0005603310419246554, 0.028210170567035675, -0.014128010720014572, 0.0017036182107403874, 0.0048500183038413525, -0.03202051296830177, -0.008821879513561726, -0.005240312777459621, -0.019079411402344704, -0.035875383764505386, -0.0745554268360138, 0.005818463861942291, 0.009038201533257961, -0.027809856459498405, -0.026059916242957115, 0.02813524752855301, -0.027309732511639595, 0.0015370348701253533, -0.012401233427226543, -0.030875207856297493, -0.016181200742721558, 0.05908804386854172, 0.002915657591074705, 0.028006142005324364, 0.07019659131765366, -0.02714700810611248, 0.022906940430402756, -0.007275536190718412, 0.06603074818849564, 0.0468621701002121, -0.005518975667655468, -0.009723441675305367, -0.04314574599266052, 0.008071089163422585, 0.003883983939886093, -0.03842099756002426, -0.04056375101208687, -0.016825616359710693, -0.011752906255424023, 0.05464436858892441, 0.0027283835224807262, -0.01270296424627304, 0.001361703034490347, 0.09360386431217194, -0.04037097841501236, -0.043618619441986084, -0.054677024483680725, -0.034744296222925186, -0.013757404871284962, 0.00033687794348225, -0.010570481419563293, 0.008274677209556103, 0.024179788306355476, 0.004862492438405752, -0.004684009589254856, -0.00813762005418539, -0.006750724744051695, 0.020940812304615974, -0.023410268127918243, -0.02343711256980896, -0.014924770221114159, 0.048825036734342575, -0.0029269845690578222, 0.027995143085718155, -0.030902335420250893, -0.01150942500680685, 0.020377142354846, -0.020575588569045067, 0.017045864835381508, -0.03559919819235802, -0.03238480165600777, -0.0036994353868067265, 0.010721836239099503, 0.009415126405656338, 0.016692256554961205, -0.04755232855677605, 0.027715299278497696, 0.08773395419120789, 0.01803252473473549, -0.015887001529335976, -0.02536783553659916, -0.026055505499243736, 0.019380269572138786, -0.02768743596971035, -0.0019047054229304194, -0.06012575700879097, -0.046873752027750015, 0.03349947929382324, 0.001390280551277101, -0.018794452771544456, -0.0013266631867736578, 0.03794373571872711, 0.011875125579535961, -0.0019855014979839325, 0.03991467505693436, 0.00687268003821373, -0.023769544437527657, 0.00301986001431942, 0.003876402508467436, -0.008871929720044136, -0.0077862064354121685, 0.06212190166115761, 0.004107639193534851, 0.038027551025152206, -0.032942838966846466, 0.02615685760974884, 0.07091907411813736, -0.02041507512331009, -0.0018416022649034858, -0.036194488406181335, -0.020211530849337578, 0.025055861100554466, -0.033462170511484146, 0.0038185622543096542, 0.04731220379471779, 0.012842737138271332, -0.006447818595916033, -0.013406322337687016, 0.0010959251085296273, -0.026576993986964226, 0.0572265163064003, -0.015534156933426857, -0.02449779398739338, 0.0031647661235183477, -0.014525205828249454, 0.02581663429737091, -0.011055645532906055, -0.05936676263809204, -0.03680886700749397, 0.012328123673796654, 0.01577795296907425, 0.013883876614272594, 0.010826333425939083, -0.04320300370454788, -0.03245222941040993, -0.002361539052799344, 0.01086344663053751, 0.04248950257897377, 0.0009123657364398241, -0.05891771242022514, -0.03575493022799492, -0.04773185774683952, -0.011873812414705753, 0.0193976778537035, 0.0021731990855187178, -0.029634641483426094, -0.0014501434052363038, -0.024372974410653114, -0.0265908632427454, -0.03251597285270691, -0.00013276038225740194, 0.010391359217464924, -0.03694571554660797, -0.024545541033148766, 0.07410173863172531, -0.010940155014395714, -0.01837526261806488, -0.0024791874457150698, -0.07708892971277237, -0.0006116734002716839, 0.00936034694314003, -0.024918409064412117, -0.021136827766895294, 0.05407280847430229, -0.005991882644593716, 0.000015146018995437771, -0.025563905015587807, -0.013118001632392406, -0.07596810162067413, -0.04491198807954788, 0.004182401578873396, 0.014906655065715313, 0.007649231236428022, 0.03482943773269653, 0.01883399300277233, 0.03197886794805527, 0.017577823251485825, 0.018086444586515427, -0.06292741000652313, -0.004253983963280916, -0.024485670030117035, -0.04392998665571213, 0.018905868753790855, 0.020852580666542053, 0.04506263881921768, 0.052899450063705444, -0.04847026616334915, 0.02639247290790081, 0.03859679773449898, -0.00805903784930706, -0.00016982357192318887, 0.025915736332535744, -0.029503392055630684, -0.0368727445602417, 0.024505561217665672, 0.027898095548152924, -0.02182179130613804, 0.042860712856054306, 0.025602802634239197, 0.0411100760102272, 0.006005645263940096, -0.03334082290530205, 0.013466788455843925, 0.002460240153595805, 0.0015167173696681857, -0.027522757649421692, 0.02464631013572216, -0.002728989813476801, -0.03513285145163536, -0.02451440505683422, -0.021744754165410995, 0.05152356997132301, -0.048361603170633316, 0.0061501432210206985, 0.025508571416139603, 0.0007042340585030615, -0.025254536420106888, 0.04882378503680229, 0.01431453600525856, -0.030892416834831238, -0.009094665758311749, -0.048202160745859146, 0.002144843339920044, 0.04964345321059227, 0.033832959830760956, 0.013744816184043884, -0.018866486847400665, -0.004418857395648956, 0.022002898156642914, -0.040396369993686676, -0.0025238636881113052, -0.0093986876308918, 0.03224416822195053, -0.01894158124923706, 0.05825556069612503, 0.03901424631476402, 0.03676433116197586, -0.0172269307076931, -0.02660483308136463, -0.06152653321623802, 0.03525800630450249, -0.00487180333584547, -0.03140029311180115, 0.007329707499593496, -0.0336858406662941, 0.06446416676044464, -0.0040870169177651405, -0.0051516457460820675, 0.020916147157549858, 0.026175007224082947, 0.005326172802597284, 0.02757939323782921, 0.012826643884181976, 0.008515738882124424, -0.013851204887032509, 0.006268105935305357, 0.024614563211798668, -0.009158515371382236, 0.03000641241669655, 0.0821937844157219, -0.013378623872995377, 0.011949840933084488, -0.028302809223532677, -0.01433539018034935, 0.0609893836081028, 0.01622302271425724, 0.04296877607703209, 0.011135823093354702, -0.04896289482712746, -0.005255004856735468, 0.007729385979473591, 0.06567808240652084, 0.058055728673934937, -0.03183195739984512, 0.017993154004216194, 0.03287098556756973, -0.013865254819393158, -0.028736811131238937, -0.0015141746262088418, -0.008017282001674175, 0.018911294639110565, 0.0680692046880722, 0.025461731478571892, -0.02452070079743862, -0.009378453716635704, 0.025761114433407784, 0.007334592752158642, 0.006433432921767235, -0.011149107478559017, -0.015878302976489067, -0.018187476322054863, 0.003104948904365301, 0.009720928966999054, 0.02851956896483898, 0.0010170609457418323, 0.0011427915887907147, 0.06569436192512512, -0.026455169543623924, -0.021715430542826653, 0.008407927118241787, 0.03598429635167122, 0.03749467059969902, 0.00475463317707181, -0.035283591598272324, -0.009143240749835968, 0.036514922976493835, 0.009114786051213741, 0.01853817328810692, 0.0038063577376306057, -0.07164879888296127, -0.0036023701541125774, 0.03845490142703056, 0.05719061568379402, -0.049683086574077606, -0.021489908918738365, -0.06846757978200912, 0.007965107448399067, 0.002208883175626397, -0.03874741494655609, 0.01777896285057068, -0.03205185383558273, 0.02845827490091324, -0.026465458795428276, -0.028666706755757332, -0.047454867511987686, 0.020007630810141563, -0.015885237604379654, -0.005973892752081156, -0.009862719103693962, -0.04070943593978882, -0.06741975992918015, -0.02245611511170864, -0.04287965968251228, 0.0360727496445179, -0.05174294486641884, -0.039919231086969376, 0.009284762665629387, 0.02804272435605526, -0.007663934491574764, -0.015960142016410828, -0.0023944834247231483, -0.007939052768051624, 0.013035165145993233, 0.03075568936765194, 0.017020756378769875, -0.0008676672005094588, 0.01759890653192997, 0.05542667582631111, 0.018679898232221603, 0.004371790215373039, -0.020284142345190048, 0.03997054696083069, 0.02978873811662197, -0.024123404175043106, 0.014087717980146408, 0.02470122091472149, -0.03268197923898697, -0.01721811667084694, -0.08132828027009964, -0.02997315488755703, -0.039506666362285614, -0.023457955569028854, -0.045294661074876785, 0.012888817116618156, 0.0003062528558075428, 0.012718296609818935, 0.011071202345192432, -0.006225548684597015, -0.02936350181698799, 0.014997792430222034, 0.021517299115657806, 0.038463979959487915, -0.02065514586865902, 0.004499476402997971, 0.02746623009443283, 0.01946749910712242, 0.030117111280560493, -0.02733583375811577, 0.038504309952259064, 0.0017907643923535943, -0.006652144715189934, 0.024745136499404907, -0.01762549579143524, -0.007664642296731472, 0.0029192320071160793, -0.0065228682942688465, 0.02751515433192253, -0.030663808807730675, -0.004539159592241049, 0.006766574922949076, 0.03684167563915253, 0.004053462762385607, -0.04102389141917229, -0.01645505800843239, 0.019640009850263596, -0.04477851837873459, 0.0006891598459333181, -0.003705540904775262, 0.0504111610352993, -0.007553819101303816, -0.009818131104111671, -0.037214092910289764, -0.008532881736755371, 0.02868928574025631, -0.027724366635084152, -0.041110195219516754, -0.03771433234214783, -0.04389721900224686, -0.01646668091416359, -0.006563125643879175, 0.026977473869919777, 0.04799201712012291, -0.06927435845136642, -0.008829722180962563, -0.03908614069223404, -0.0011948663741350174, 0.058174166828393936, 0.008428150787949562, 0.011620428413152695, 0.009780711494386196, -0.03475623205304146, -0.01630023866891861, 0.02774900756776333, -0.020004412159323692, -0.016612090170383453, -0.0038455119356513023, -0.0344921238720417, 0.04823313280940056, 0.029704967513680458, 0.04966338723897934, -0.0469166524708271, -0.02794036827981472, -0.030214443802833557, 0.024545148015022278, -0.04206329956650734, -0.013816225342452526, -0.020572718232870102, 0.026743561029434204, -0.012807618826627731, -0.024806713685393333, -0.004416962619870901, -0.010366278700530529, 0.03533023223280907, -0.005431869998574257, -0.018836181610822678, 0.05084838718175888, 0.06519457697868347, -0.01455763727426529, -0.0022719053085893393, -0.048243630677461624, 0.006771408021450043, 0.037549905478954315, 0.048394959419965744, -0.01535707525908947, 0.000440313684521243, 0.04220310598611832, -0.03084683232009411, 0.023960964754223824, -0.06315770745277405, 0.01583651639521122, 0.06463083624839783, -0.0072937412187457085, 0.011696170084178448, 0.04487975686788559, 0.0003243828541599214, 0.05016966536641121, -0.03951135277748108, -0.004557312466204166, 0.006241349969059229, -0.008248099125921726, 0.04029598832130432, -0.023673798888921738, -0.01631355844438076, 0.04913317784667015, 0.026707662269473076, 0.007505113258957863, 0.012548059225082397, 0.0012179188197478652, -0.03203752636909485, 0.013430492952466011, -0.003927063662558794, -0.030805863440036774, 0.0428890660405159, -0.006504900753498077, 0.01866549625992775, -0.01669592596590519, -0.012439986690878868, 0.04789439216256142, 0.04924696683883667, -0.010342124849557877, -0.04904510825872421, -0.0088467076420784, -0.043051015585660934, 0.02092907764017582, 0.060694895684719086, -0.06512273848056793, 0.04746956750750542, 0.002162517048418522, 0.025180857628583908, -0.021483637392520905, 0.017621641978621483, -0.0016122953966259956, -0.017693478614091873, -0.030587106943130493, -0.015243464149534702, -0.005252630449831486, 0.018519483506679535, -0.03755906596779823, -0.01603963039815426, -0.01000821590423584, -0.05639497563242912, 0.009992718696594238, 0.008316963911056519, 0.031473781913518906, 0.003326299600303173, 0.05180460959672928, -0.012569725513458252, -0.015571624971926212, -0.007454800419509411, -0.04827206954360008, 0.14911620318889618, 0.05495155602693558, 0.02209639735519886, -0.05107319355010986, -0.02506730891764164, 0.00816281232982874, -0.013827481307089329, 0.012099118903279305, -0.007992114871740341, 0.03846318647265434, 0.009374065324664116, 0.0920068770647049, 0.04107731208205223, 0.03687363117933273, 0.049263663589954376, 0.030803492292761803, -0.03756774216890335, -0.02070664055645466, -0.01684117503464222, -0.0020966450683772564, -0.017160844057798386, 0.010370579548180103, -0.027380406856536865, -0.019256168976426125, 0.06118467450141907, -0.012763193808495998, -0.04832844436168671, -0.019141489639878273, -0.014775021933019161, -0.0053592827171087265, -0.04912334680557251, -0.004963147919625044, 0.0035398327745497227, 0.01157213095575571, 0.004138967487961054, -0.011604374274611473, 0.01920347660779953, -0.01676238887012005, 0.0020876280032098293, 0.0357607863843441, -0.02471110410988331, 0.011977129615843296, -0.01618165150284767, -0.0007023849175311625, -0.013588400557637215, -0.01743961125612259, -0.01718919351696968, 0.036689236760139465, -0.013188977725803852, -0.026111582294106483, -0.013920707628130913, 0.007690540514886379, 0.029491154477000237, -0.04438484460115433, 0.004028538707643747, 0.053563427180051804, 0.021379154175519943, -0.03638032078742981, -0.00042501857387833297, -0.007997207343578339, -0.013260534964501858, 0.0014824590180069208, 0.015615377575159073, 0.030490802600979805, -0.009820847772061825, 0.0027361863758414984, -0.09202928096055984, 0.03170165792107582, -0.0027157259173691273, 0.007517141755670309, 0.05139423906803131, 0.00244308914989233, -0.025112302973866463, 0.004764591809362173, 0.03166975453495979, 0.0200677290558815, 0.02576916292309761, 0.004715257789939642, -0.011555706150829792, -0.03073468804359436, -0.02973601408302784, 0.0629921406507492, -0.04155656322836876, 0.00774930277839303, -0.02858162485063076, -0.00357550079934299, -0.00884060375392437, 0.07768035680055618, 0.02952405996620655, 0.024914562702178955, -0.016017181798815727, 0.07307419180870056, -0.0016076166648417711, -0.047503482550382614, -0.034420501440763474, 0.03923614323139191, -0.04352892190217972, -0.014903704635798931, -0.04555023834109306, 0.0660998672246933, 0.02290906012058258, 0.017983833327889442, -0.003473840421065688, 0.027514439076185226, -0.010765137150883675, -0.02177148126065731, -0.0083972979336977, -0.02451241947710514, 0.05573035404086113, -0.003032738110050559, -0.008140994235873222, -0.013840238563716412, -0.02315712720155716, -0.02381819672882557, -0.06819067895412445, -0.01132011879235506, -0.015365950763225555, 0.000513402686920017, 0.0027720346115529537, -0.0020302145276218653, 0.001502626808360219, -0.026293465867638588, -0.045093730092048645, -0.03282786160707474, -0.016796234995126724, -0.003814061637967825, -0.03834172338247299, -0.02097555249929428, 0.0029230816289782524, -0.021306348964571953, 0.017350859940052032, 0.036166656762361526, 0.043589476495981216, -0.006648800801485777, -0.011926849372684956, 0.023483039811253548, 0.009274659678339958, -0.0004528392164502293, 0.040587976574897766, 0.01732618920505047, 0.031096704304218292, -0.029494212940335274, -0.049942661076784134, 0.029987018555402756, 0.011368981562554836, 0.03333194553852081, -0.02472454309463501, 0.023985963314771652, -0.04253287613391876, 0.05076295882463455, -0.004988075699657202, -0.004388675559312105, -0.016039755195379257, -0.010631483979523182, 0.011864926666021347, 0.002620313549414277, -0.014385558664798737, -0.0030272300355136395, -0.004849534016102552, 0.006219904404133558, 0.0667472630739212, -0.033698152750730515, -0.0048060002736747265, 0.023786351084709167, -0.029736123979091644, 0.004790273495018482, 0.008807782083749771, -0.020348532125353813, 0.04475214332342148, 0.07422839850187302, -0.005837798118591309, 0.040219224989414215, -0.022977694869041443, 0.0137914614751935, -0.0980110839009285, -0.028456175699830055, 0.00028371013468131423, 0.017323192209005356, 0.011077367700636387, -0.0628185048699379, -0.025239363312721252, 0.018063271418213844, 0.00011495409125927836, 0.007421554531902075, 0.0029701567254960537, -0.006859470624476671, -0.02100495994091034, 0.04247833043336868, -0.01678941212594509, 0.04355749487876892, 0.05207955092191696, 0.019150394946336746, 0.05101683735847473, 0.001520163961686194, -0.011759569868445396, -0.02786896377801895, -0.009484590962529182, 0.045368585735559464, -0.0034478059969842434, -0.03217848390340805, 0.029075250029563904, -0.02454414963722229, 0.014015809632837772, -0.006930936127901077, 0.03555883467197418, 0.04386533796787262, 0.0635790005326271, 0.02975696325302124, 0.029627205803990364, 0.033203862607479095, 0.020577797666192055, 0.005055819638073444, -0.02805749513208866, 0.005586591083556414, 0.014839519746601582, 0.010012827813625336, -0.02194621041417122, 0.029688190668821335, -0.0112429428845644, -0.029019545763731003, -0.024723581969738007, 0.015311031602323055, 0.014260861091315746, -0.004837858024984598, -0.007141865324229002, -0.0023619646672159433, -0.01197092980146408, -0.04537701979279518, 0.02586722932755947, -0.06346529722213745, 0.0032479444053024054, 0.015977643430233, 0.028541963547468185, 0.018162304535508156, 0.029255224391818047, -0.05167800188064575, -0.0015130618121474981, -0.008977287448942661, 0.003119439585134387, -0.008248361758887768, -0.04707229882478714, -0.029215555638074875, -0.030926497653126717, 0.027708031237125397, -0.015587396919727325, 0.031158944591879845, -0.025759045034646988, 0.011275903321802616, -0.01460234820842743, -0.003792515955865383, 0.04390154033899307, -0.02502172254025936, 0.019256841391324997, -0.06979092955589294, 0.07823088020086288, 0.01540044043213129, -0.010804358869791031, -0.08410501480102539, -0.017240609973669052, -0.026884252205491066, 0.041135743260383606, 0.0370219349861145, 0.007877607829868793, 0.02325255423784256, 0.004190524108707905, 0.022111842408776283, 0.0013861535117030144, -0.032133013010025024, 0.07587245851755142, 0.029350845143198967, -0.026038624346256256, -0.013759899884462357, 0.048804931342601776, 0.00006195559399202466, 0.02436104416847229, 0.005606111604720354, -0.010586900636553764, -0.01912834495306015, -0.031112974509596825, -0.032704826444387436, -0.010690699331462383, 0.013378073461353779, -0.027685970067977905, 0.013827361166477203, 0.0044609857723116875, 0.011764864437282085, 0.09883083403110504, 0.02274179644882679, -0.052826717495918274, 0.06023920327425003, 0.0030169894453138113, 0.001855057547800243, 0.02313479408621788, -0.030978268012404442, 0.012519421055912971, -0.08766578882932663, 0.020030757412314415, 0.0020276131108403206, -0.02512597292661667, -0.03841599076986313, 0.03232527896761894, 0.019778801128268242, 0.04139973968267441, -0.03170883655548096, -0.02128073200583458, -0.01487690769135952, -0.05897676199674606, 0.02200949750840664, 0.04510272666811943, 0.0027626249939203262, -0.02336614765226841, 0.010099715553224087, 0.004065462853759527, 0.01603829860687256, 0.004897526931017637, -0.001322915661148727, 0.07059672474861145, 0.009899837896227837, 0.017240004613995552, -0.004468034021556377, -0.013798709027469158, 0.023408912122249603, 0.011868159286677837, -0.021471329033374786, 0.01699351891875267, -0.025975359603762627, -0.009972067549824715, 0.006822167430073023, -0.031684715300798416, -0.065895214676857, -0.00986929889768362, 0.04425423964858055, 0.03582322597503662, 0.005420857574790716, 0.044032566249370575, 0.004151440225541592, -0.007478865794837475, 0.019549483433365822, -0.0035231956280767918, 0.05684328451752663, 0.007740703411400318, 0.015553593635559082, -0.01599358394742012, -0.012474852614104748, -0.013996638357639313, -0.03322751820087433, 0.04749661311507225, 0.01613624021410942, -0.011237964034080505, -0.05725500360131264, -0.016686808317899704, 0.02040674164891243, 0.02120617777109146, -0.009873390197753906, -0.030725378543138504, -0.024711577221751213, 0.02609931491315365, 0.020267488434910774, -0.022892499342560768 ]
<p>this is a rather elemental question, but any help would be appreciated anyway.</p> <p>This <a href="http://www.gifted.uconn.edu/siegle/research/Correlation/alphaleve.htm" rel="nofollow">webpage</a> gives a method of finding the p-value of Pearson's correlation coefficient, using a table. However, the methods listed in <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pearson_product-moment_correlation_coefficient" rel="nofollow">Wikipedia's article</a> suggest that <em>using a table</em> is only valid if the variables are special in some sense, or if there is enough data.</p> <p>So, my question is: under no assumptions for the random variables for which Pearson's correlation is calculated, is it correct to use a pre-computed table?</p>
35,803
[ -0.04686097800731659, -0.009665671736001968, -0.004062216728925705, -0.014294161461293697, 0.04823074862360954, 0.03587937727570534, -0.009730799123644829, -0.012709982693195343, 0.02907106839120388, -0.010305792093276978, 0.01241893507540226, 0.037491749972105026, 0.048034343868494034, 0.027140483260154724, 0.041644804179668427, 0.012765604071319103, -0.007060786709189415, 0.01509485486894846, -0.0007623438723385334, -0.024417556822299957, 0.0014921423280611634, 0.019877348095178604, -0.010485694743692875, -0.015001853927969933, -0.03289176523685455, 0.053605642169713974, -0.0035920434165745974, 0.003281232202425599, 0.034647781401872635, 0.051417797803878784, -0.06222117319703102, -0.017529645934700966, 0.04689411073923111, 0.04276372119784355, 0.026795558631420135, 0.01740141212940216, -0.01805705390870571, 0.011660374701023102, -0.011811717413365841, 0.009214034304022789, -0.004014877602458, -0.020747503265738487, 0.03289560601115227, 0.025424860417842865, 0.01004872191697359, 0.023938795551657677, -0.021466214209794998, -0.04035588353872299, 0.029450004920363426, -0.029908524826169014, 0.05439165607094765, 0.015500286594033241, 0.050169847905635834, 0.05983118340373039, -0.04634151980280876, -0.018144506961107254, 0.049856528639793396, 0.03355136141180992, -0.03072199784219265, -0.0736842006444931, 0.022482512518763542, -0.04507824778556824, -0.005801607389003038, -0.01196993887424469, -0.03951957821846008, 0.011103258468210697, -0.005856028757989407, -0.01004902645945549, 0.061577148735523224, -0.024086175486445427, 0.04424552246928215, 0.045508526265621185, 0.06017370522022247, -0.014876611530780792, 0.010517082177102566, -0.02271217107772827, 0.04895910620689392, -0.025527220219373703, 0.03389618173241615, 0.054634734988212585, 0.010707706212997437, 0.01658637449145317, 0.0641631931066513, 0.008363245986402035, 0.026181289926171303, -0.009799192659556866, 0.03519672527909279, -0.02466498874127865, 0.005050016567111015, 0.02245575562119484, -0.047119855880737305, -0.012427756562829018, 0.04051530733704567, 0.0021956597920507193, -0.04886573553085327, 0.031742651015520096, -0.04321133345365524, 0.061322178691625595, 0.027948463335633278, -0.01807984709739685, 0.006782851181924343, -0.022863784804940224, 0.009559198282659054, 0.053769778460264206, -0.043183907866477966, -0.01213541068136692, -0.032209575176239014, 0.0248905997723341, 0.025046400725841522, -0.05397402122616768, 0.012514831498265266, 0.00556376576423645, 0.013720500282943249, 0.007230994291603565, 0.0655626580119133, -0.03034837357699871, -0.001671069534495473, 0.01611325331032276, 0.07831813395023346, 0.05588318035006523, 0.019586840644478798, -0.03703400865197182, 0.005094514228403568, -0.03972327336668968, -0.03155412897467613, 0.05886700749397278, 0.015377150848507881, -0.003184670815244317, -0.029042446985840797, 0.035305675119161606, 0.009742400608956814, -0.00394756393507123, 0.059566423296928406, 0.003215034259483218, 0.033158671110868454, 0.005602905061095953, -0.07981060445308685, -0.042595356702804565, 0.021950354799628258, -0.009583748877048492, -0.02380242757499218, -0.05435037985444069, -0.0008046001894399524, 0.012705681845545769, 0.02895255759358406, -0.012023024260997772, 0.03317935764789581, -0.028060724958777428, 0.06725507229566574, 0.021592622622847557, -0.04840841516852379, -0.010254914872348309, 0.0016019223257899284, -0.0539676696062088, -0.009718104265630245, -0.10221071541309357, 0.023246150463819504, -0.018824858590960503, 0.014851086772978306, -0.011671818792819977, 0.05063463747501373, -0.009026576764881611, -0.02468212880194187, -0.0031077791936695576, 0.0345786027610302, -0.020731644704937935, 0.05922272056341171, -0.0007114786421880126, 0.01592438854277134, 0.03195042163133621, -0.009546923451125622, 0.038299836218357086, -0.010072224773466587, 0.053866513073444366, 0.06437917798757553, -0.013331837020814419, -0.01514813769608736, -0.01606459729373455, 0.04290387034416199, -0.025010306388139725, -0.05730944126844406, 0.0010898361215367913, -0.022596929222345352, 0.008687213994562626, 0.02919909730553627, 0.05204235389828682, 0.014459303580224514, -0.01332753337919712, 0.029811330139636993, -0.05844123661518097, -0.05729634314775467, -0.06629998236894608, 0.02519703097641468, -0.027876589447259903, -0.04005484655499458, 0.03877779096364975, 0.00415607076138258, 0.018614334985613823, -0.0092813391238451, -0.03314906731247902, -0.025111930444836617, -0.004241181071847677, 0.052194993942976, -0.0774315670132637, 0.021627986803650856, 0.0660761371254921, 0.042156148701906204, -0.00047148606972768903, 0.035118862986564636, -0.03960898146033287, -0.050989989191293716, 0.057513050734996796, -0.03683117777109146, 0.005331913474947214, 0.011565177701413631, -0.029486151412129402, 0.01824469119310379, 0.029612556099891663, -0.01574719324707985, 0.032437246292829514, -0.04036903753876686, 0.06372711807489395, 0.06669057905673981, 0.022640647366642952, 0.008931166492402554, 0.0019053724827244878, 0.025876536965370178, 0.0033663150388747454, -0.025210512802004814, -0.007378261536359787, -0.05500109866261482, -0.014710590243339539, 0.02064899168908596, -0.002360552316531539, -0.04398337006568909, 0.02142355591058731, 0.06524156779050827, 0.0304595697671175, 0.010109934955835342, 0.03036731481552124, -0.0011757814791053534, -0.004972736816853285, -0.03491775691509247, 0.0245219636708498, 0.003946423996239901, 0.04501007869839668, 0.00759604386985302, 0.01403654832392931, 0.025732804089784622, 0.005142449401319027, -0.02298448048532009, 0.00546365138143301, 0.003086066571995616, 0.023577220737934113, -0.02788458578288555, -0.018416330218315125, 0.05886361747980118, -0.03525476157665253, 0.01109477411955595, 0.019928978756070137, 0.010710886679589748, -0.00908512994647026, 0.005426321644335985, -0.04040667042136192, -0.009042033925652504, 0.047694526612758636, -0.05074946954846382, -0.009965363889932632, 0.004718380980193615, -0.02489503286778927, 0.012306260876357555, -0.0312584787607193, -0.04137455299496651, -0.02305401861667633, 0.0005313956644386053, 0.012841363437473774, 0.000432683591498062, 0.037142883986234665, -0.022447694092988968, -0.014777456410229206, -0.04431452974677086, -0.02407538890838623, -0.02683885022997856, -0.03233695775270462, -0.09420202672481537, -0.05105289816856384, -0.037406809628009796, -0.013436428271234035, 0.03701351210474968, -0.043434325605630875, -0.007769232150167227, -0.03162768483161926, 0.005472046788781881, -0.01856512390077114, -0.006959140300750732, -0.007556091994047165, -0.002092232694849372, -0.05345326289534569, -0.03423783555626869, 0.008497347123920918, -0.014846866019070148, -0.0626051053404808, 0.003549290122464299, -0.06036427244544029, -0.0341159850358963, -0.008064661175012589, 0.001179417478851974, -0.005053031723946333, -0.01943296566605568, 0.013856515288352966, 0.008001248352229595, -0.04474768787622452, -0.009376965463161469, -0.03231526538729668, -0.03792029246687889, 0.01747867651283741, 0.001025334931910038, 0.052480075508356094, 0.02772287279367447, -0.03991273045539856, 0.04945499822497368, 0.013780714944005013, -0.06156282499432564, -0.03620678558945656, -0.0044153593480587006, -0.0007335893460549414, -0.01161153707653284, 0.02056085504591465, 0.02118193730711937, 0.011000257916748524, 0.029670296236872673, -0.026200655847787857, -0.010034930892288685, 0.040534380823373795, 0.01278343703597784, 0.005007957108318806, -0.004079552832990885, 0.028622085228562355, -0.0071394979022443295, 0.03579626977443695, -0.00877018366008997, -0.029757263138890266, -0.0006992650451138616, 0.005534263327717781, 0.03618093207478523, -0.005790883209556341, -0.020492136478424072, -0.002925655571743846, -0.024763403460383415, 0.014396467246115208, -0.04939285293221474, 0.03255293890833855, -0.00973381195217371, 0.012959764339029789, 0.012671871110796928, 0.02658509835600853, -0.0048677693121135235, -0.018345067277550697, 0.03614918887615204, 0.06630058586597443, 0.0009006055188365281, -0.00522280391305685, -0.004352370277047157, 0.0029226397164165974, -0.02759288065135479, 0.02861044369637966, -0.04479140043258667, -0.04039176553487778, 0.03723464161157608, 0.044212695211172104, 0.02089679054915905, -0.0007386194192804396, -0.04107131063938141, 0.02056947723031044, -0.05769359692931175, 0.024316081777215004, -0.03217807412147522, 0.03407949209213257, -0.013487118296325207, 0.05286504328250885, 0.01815030537545681, -0.03349287062883377, 0.007059958763420582, 0.010260537266731262, -0.07419945299625397, 0.019319606944918633, -0.01130219828337431, -0.02417127788066864, -0.0010551577433943748, -0.06247500702738762, 0.009957652539014816, -0.009315725415945053, 0.013770761899650097, 0.02451571635901928, -0.0054618283174932, -0.0033308295533061028, 0.0031022930052131414, -0.01640705019235611, -0.005145861767232418, -0.0015003547305241227, 0.019602157175540924, 0.027271941304206848, 0.013864378444850445, 0.02738884836435318, 0.02905014157295227, -0.01922050677239895, 0.008272922597825527, -0.011378609575331211, 0.04251912981271744, 0.01503405999392271, 0.03131246939301491, 0.028738958761096, 0.004168374463915825, -0.03996054083108902, 0.011898655444383621, -0.02139473520219326, 0.06521780043840408, 0.056829292327165604, -0.022666210308670998, -0.0331384651362896, 0.012985127978026867, 0.023490097373723984, -0.014557545073330402, 0.006955207325518131, 0.008942033164203167, 0.01957976631820202, 0.05323201045393944, 0.029509130865335464, -0.045519255101680756, 0.02996036224067211, 0.07574567943811417, 0.0240057110786438, -0.018453523516654968, -0.045158036053180695, -0.0008971432689577341, -0.010508262552320957, -0.02333398535847664, 0.025411000475287437, 0.02617255412042141, -0.02034395933151245, 0.008050326257944107, 0.027549877762794495, -0.01452707126736641, -0.030174963176250458, 0.035029374063014984, 0.0099219074472785, 0.030792193487286568, -0.007953681983053684, -0.04508126899600029, 0.04574856534600258, 0.023080045357346535, 0.02592312917113304, 0.016076810657978058, -0.000013955280337540898, -0.05337314307689667, 0.013002242892980576, 0.05662288889288902, 0.06606770306825638, -0.023475926369428635, 0.023741114884614944, -0.036304812878370285, -0.016345558688044548, 0.0477798730134964, -0.01637359894812107, 0.03877045214176178, -0.029832670465111732, -0.0013266257010400295, -0.0019833948463201523, -0.021278662607073784, -0.061452385038137436, 0.0022583920508623123, -0.012620266526937485, 0.018963314592838287, -0.007589919958263636, -0.008433408103883266, -0.056019559502601624, -0.02380705624818802, 0.03418777137994766, 0.0636507049202919, -0.03554018959403038, -0.018336528912186623, -0.0001313390239374712, 0.03300604969263077, -0.0013007967500016093, -0.05231159180402756, -0.0005973759689368308, -0.0058908239006996155, 0.003133108839392662, 0.052670933306217194, -0.021084681153297424, -0.022353461012244225, 0.016111362725496292, 0.004617471247911453, 0.00804910995066166, 0.005887495819479227, 0.019837748259305954, 0.052702467888593674, 0.011468934826552868, -0.00971151702105999, 0.08035437017679214, 0.05775868892669678, -0.03533163294196129, -0.01316958386451006, -0.04013494774699211, -0.0022504604421555996, -0.0008802086813375354, -0.0006852341466583312, -0.03417498990893364, 0.008832830935716629, -0.017170270904898643, 0.014055894687771797, 0.003618774702772498, 0.03868215158581734, -0.0050461264327168465, 0.02117077261209488, 0.002988114021718502, 0.0463203601539135, 0.002415507799014449, 0.016700109466910362, -0.012612045742571354, 0.008459845557808876, 0.018096106126904488, -0.0441397950053215, 0.01816716603934765, -0.014730247668921947, 0.0060054464265704155, 0.004814471118152142, -0.03975492715835571, 0.01171194389462471, -0.03247677534818649, -0.03784472867846489, -0.009326472878456116, -0.02003781870007515, 0.0009646139806136489, 0.007983675226569176, 0.03909812495112419, 0.014402485452592373, -0.058430057018995285, -0.024321189150214195, 0.014624477364122868, 0.015062713995575905, 0.049055397510528564, -0.006905144080519676, 0.023483412340283394, -0.020322900265455246, -0.014886445365846157, -0.08636117726564407, -0.03405168652534485, 0.027189593762159348, 0.007941147312521935, -0.02467169612646103, -0.03576008602976799, -0.0066653164103627205, -0.008416504599153996, -0.005692147649824619, -0.005081482697278261, 0.06692469865083694, -0.016967186704277992, -0.035191893577575684, 0.023694830015301704, -0.01356299128383398, 0.09952846169471741, 0.009208733215928078, -0.045961715281009674, 0.03210487961769104, -0.01913026161491871, -0.027354292571544647, 0.01775660552084446, -0.02102816477417946, -0.026367729529738426, 0.005003457423299551, -0.01862579584121704, 0.018273310735821724, 0.051263634115457535, -0.00005620259980787523, -0.01081564649939537, -0.0033179791644215584, 0.007544386200606823, -0.006374020595103502, -0.026067055761814117, 0.026304414495825768, -0.026057062670588493, 0.011518418788909912, -0.019407380372285843, -0.015811555087566376, -0.04254886135458946, -0.008448531851172447, -0.008997689001262188, -0.022552965208888054, -0.012756242416799068, 0.007633518893271685, 0.07472322881221771, -0.0172047708183527, 0.0054860045202076435, -0.022772960364818573, -0.019909244030714035, 0.03930116444826126, 0.04667433723807335, -0.009756921790540218, -0.01312638632953167, 0.028576252982020378, -0.023013629019260406, -0.03397507220506668, -0.0071219285018742085, 0.006187542341649532, 0.06013832986354828, -0.006528007332235575, 0.05238230898976326, 0.06408432126045227, 0.03098391741514206, -0.02025768719613552, -0.014790458604693413, -0.012166017666459084, -0.00879234354943037, 0.010917514562606812, 0.036268219351768494, -0.01997796632349491, 0.01576528139412403, -0.010360855609178543, 0.009982454590499401, -0.012248096987605095, 0.05060512572526932, 0.03749436140060425, 0.024747740477323532, 0.019529711455106735, -0.004236695822328329, -0.014764155261218548, 0.04660442844033241, -0.05481063947081566, 0.0049282400868833065, -0.06283105909824371, -0.02167295292019844, 0.016066843643784523, 0.026753360405564308, 0.03018549270927906, -0.04826275259256363, -0.03332500532269478, -0.010195531882345676, -0.004040547180920839, -0.007067358121275902, -0.0001483616215409711, 0.015904797241091728, -0.01423476729542017, 0.016859350726008415, -0.006161413621157408, 0.038486823439598083, -0.018824253231287003, -0.08054965734481812, -0.028318628668785095, -0.005381167400628328, -0.024195795878767967, 0.037132155150175095, -0.0015479299472644925, -0.03901967033743858, 0.010565917007625103, -0.038186877965927124, 0.011330177076160908, 0.002833483973518014, 0.04557591676712036, -0.023979775607585907, 0.07998751848936081, -0.00891148578375578, -0.0028736148960888386, 0.011620740406215191, -0.038852788507938385, 0.09129510819911957, 0.0430014468729496, 0.025503892451524734, -0.06565482169389725, 0.032743021845817566, 0.0009983823401853442, 0.004827817901968956, -0.033875055611133575, 0.020146502181887627, -0.02354845218360424, -0.01918962597846985, 0.05364854633808136, 0.07640466839075089, 0.01581323891878128, 0.00999673455953598, 0.0493738017976284, -0.02209424041211605, -0.030305195599794388, 0.0032590602058917284, 0.02276027202606201, -0.008387216366827488, -0.025046732276678085, -0.005450685508549213, -0.007424920331686735, 0.028473298996686935, -0.024206774309277534, -0.038760263472795486, 0.013036578893661499, -0.005052429623901844, 0.0006513028056360781, -0.05019986256957054, -0.007908490486443043, 0.04515312612056732, 0.003913810942322016, -0.02724899910390377, -0.03314928710460663, 0.035390328615903854, -0.024854665622115135, 0.01537418458610773, 0.02969471924006939, -0.028325628489255905, -0.008631207048892975, 0.013870135881006718, -0.007368214428424835, -0.05377490073442459, -0.013359633274376392, -0.015801113098859787, 0.04534438997507095, -0.023230720311403275, -0.03555779531598091, -0.009261034429073334, -0.025417771190404892, -0.02158679999411106, -0.059598159044981, 0.001388708595186472, 0.026524335145950317, 0.017399072647094727, -0.044284071773290634, -0.0029033643659204245, -0.03635431081056595, 0.00041498529026284814, -0.01993018016219139, 0.029669683426618576, 0.0038862992078065872, -0.04619509354233742, 0.0038375952281057835, -0.05018303915858269, 0.0439598485827446, 0.024939827620983124, -0.016813654452562332, -0.0009622214711271226, -0.02011329121887684, -0.055018190294504166, -0.0033036060631275177, 0.02078249119222164, 0.014162967912852764, 0.0391315296292305, -0.00014156174438539892, 0.0024639060720801353, -0.005128183867782354, -0.029237551614642143, 0.015372236259281635, -0.03319517895579338, -0.03543010726571083, -0.025109175592660904, -0.00466705160215497, 0.03257666900753975, 0.06695730984210968, 0.0006097761797718704, 0.0076347580179572105, -0.00811371486634016, 0.024966254830360413, 0.01436309702694416, -0.03829016536474228, -0.02359423041343689, -0.042464885860681534, -0.038510095328092575, 0.023699747398495674, -0.039259254932403564, 0.04402529448270798, 0.020704828202724457, 0.009995320811867714, -0.011019541881978512, -0.003251616144552827, 0.009199103340506554, 0.015981100499629974, -0.0024132300168275833, -0.018870558589696884, 0.026656374335289, -0.003694402752444148, -0.013583453372120857, -0.014213441871106625, 0.00995036493986845, -0.05120232328772545, -0.0031553837470710278, -0.021359751001000404, -0.01740005984902382, -0.01663810759782791, -0.019088465720415115, 0.005219724029302597, -0.00843834038823843, -0.01949898526072502, -0.013231443241238594, -0.041132643818855286, -0.002894389210268855, 0.0206651221960783, 0.016954628750681877, -0.013486504554748535, 0.022577844560146332, -0.013480344787240028, 0.016291117295622826, 0.0420893132686615, 0.028997624292969704, 0.0021652064751833677, -0.027714380994439125, 0.0045097460970282555, 0.018229711800813675, 0.07707460969686508, -0.03172450512647629, -0.0024279719218611717, 0.04067108780145645, -0.02238425798714161, -0.02597680687904358, 0.01600668579339981, -0.009994769468903542, 0.028328420594334602, -0.020660776644945145, 0.044825680553913116, -0.035153891891241074, 0.05673295259475708, -0.06022639200091362, -0.02302788943052292, -0.021984456107020378, 0.006993049290031195, 0.021934619173407555, 0.006607462652027607, -0.02671515755355358, -0.0008044075220823288, -0.010317969135940075, 0.019419629126787186, 0.06392911821603775, 0.01294591836631298, 0.011919242329895496, -0.008955392986536026, 0.010905149392783642, 0.027887990698218346, 0.019367199391126633, -0.030394116416573524, 0.014256728813052177, 0.07375653833150864, -0.03129586949944496, 0.05202367156744003, 0.026910241693258286, 0.007182683330029249, -0.08821102976799011, -0.03781774640083313, 0.015575042925775051, 0.02945493906736374, 0.04170367494225502, -0.06349766999483109, -0.009225054644048214, 0.014497347176074982, -0.06558458507061005, 0.012747668661177158, 0.024534868076443672, -0.0338144525885582, -0.023385463282465935, 0.02743304893374443, 0.007928570732474327, 0.018549583852291107, 0.031887028366327286, 0.03208513557910919, 0.030465127900242805, -0.00387613195925951, 0.022486232221126556, -0.0039850687608122826, -0.01601875014603138, -0.0006478010327555239, -0.006415148731321096, -0.06436452269554138, 0.03882733732461929, -0.04874654859304428, -0.051950640976428986, 0.011867433786392212, -0.01813097856938839, 0.03284767270088196, -0.020373668521642685, 0.018727414309978485, -0.01900324411690235, 0.04234771803021431, 0.05892528221011162, -0.03685857728123665, -0.01208426058292389, 0.0387839674949646, 0.017010271549224854, 0.0362420417368412, -0.040640704333782196, 0.012839511968195438, -0.005961430724710226, 0.0019267953466624022, -0.04560587555170059, 0.021832987666130066, -0.0033601957838982344, -0.014459868893027306, -0.026250066235661507, -0.010746191255748272, 0.015308307483792305, -0.00883165467530489, 0.03146911412477493, -0.07338988035917282, -0.015082544647157192, 0.0192897766828537, 0.05241197347640991, -0.017657091841101646, 0.014457539655268192, -0.011865264736115932, -0.022903043776750565, 0.017824403941631317, -0.015440838411450386, -0.001081337803043425, -0.08910158276557922, -0.025258058682084084, 0.016565822064876556, -0.013070674613118172, -0.0075916931964457035, -0.01973971351981163, -0.052314192056655884, 0.0006464640609920025, 0.0033535927068442106, 0.02692054957151413, 0.02825826406478882, -0.013712257146835327, 0.006750957574695349, -0.05414726212620735, 0.06630868464708328, -0.007253430318087339, -0.028567612171173096, -0.04931659623980522, -0.01288741733878851, -0.03851766511797905, 0.01296556368470192, 0.04608798399567604, -0.01247795857489109, 0.018654366955161095, -0.020872408524155617, 0.003477048594504595, -0.0030863715801388025, -0.03939775004982948, 0.03398413583636284, 0.01535349152982235, -0.02987169846892357, -0.020033493638038635, -0.014814737252891064, 0.04610391706228256, 0.0025274541694670916, -0.0012912893434986472, -0.024445971474051476, 0.02954568713903427, 0.021220451220870018, -0.003232453251257539, 0.05816083401441574, 0.028933735564351082, -0.0037083232309669256, 0.02046935260295868, 0.009884080849587917, 0.01344864722341299, 0.06454075127840042, 0.016277985647320747, -0.04885037615895271, 0.042823079973459244, -0.02306929975748062, -0.016743158921599388, -0.013822343200445175, 0.04462655261158943, -0.058249250054359436, -0.06433332711458206, 0.011308841407299042, 0.03739932179450989, -0.02624324895441532, -0.010694129392504692, 0.004938968922942877, 0.007012137211859226, 0.04736122861504555, -0.0065725394524633884, 0.00794867891818285, 0.0469193160533905, -0.04651165008544922, 0.022385433316230774, 0.019695313647389412, 0.045369952917099, 0.007698607165366411, 0.012001901865005493, 0.037964917719364166, 0.004304996691644192, 0.007140233181416988, -0.0054531521163880825, 0.01791677437722683, -0.028399929404258728, -0.018781514838337898, 0.021634232252836227, -0.0074539328925311565, 0.05525049939751625, 0.022792020812630653, -0.03541390597820282, 0.05647030472755432, -0.03128461167216301, 0.0010045756353065372, -0.029523424804210663, 0.001025983365252614, -0.008973522111773491, -0.015175134874880314, 0.014565194956958294, 0.016810063272714615, -0.0273349117487669, -0.012657164596021175, -0.013632835820317268, -0.013548034243285656, -0.007787664420902729, -0.016176996752619743, 0.03480694070458412, -0.05315285548567772, 0.04673532769083977, -0.011087924242019653, -0.003818420460447669, -0.012692253105342388, -0.016804473474621773, 0.03743297606706619, 0.041022803634405136, 0.007302429061383009, -0.0443558543920517, -0.004906968213617802, -0.0002181753661716357, 0.06852271407842636, -0.02445652149617672, -0.007867024280130863, -0.04014761000871658, 0.0024466929025948048, -0.005688421428203583, 0.02996681071817875 ]
<p>I would like to compute the Wilcoxon rank-sum test in Stata for two countries of my sample with the dummyvalue 3 and 6. </p> <p>Can anyone give the right code for Stata? </p>
73,428
[ -0.03674737736582756, -0.003686585696414113, -0.0299238134175539, 0.010319744236767292, 0.026798484846949577, 0.0042125023901462555, -0.023657813668251038, 0.013064700178802013, 0.060224875807762146, -0.015264245681464672, 0.03623584285378456, 0.047581396996974945, 0.043618153780698776, 0.022135069593787193, 0.002994164824485779, 0.015300052240490913, 0.006108234636485577, 0.03541522100567818, -0.006634026300162077, 0.00011599833669606596, 0.01240842230618, 0.0076802438125014305, -0.011018713936209679, -0.014215747825801373, 0.00303761288523674, 0.04494708403944969, 0.014933492988348007, -0.009896908886730671, 0.006789327599108219, 0.06468977779150009, -0.0663628876209259, -0.04297499358654022, 0.024874065071344376, 0.03034905530512333, 0.017003128305077553, 0.019575411453843117, 0.004112348426133394, -0.0342835895717144, 0.014971000142395496, 0.017549002543091774, -0.013068311847746372, -0.034915316849946976, 0.0027883192524313927, 0.006091408897191286, 0.02504033036530018, 0.057841427624225616, 0.005665688309818506, -0.0262843519449234, -0.005155223421752453, -0.0625467449426651, 0.039485033601522446, 0.01638585515320301, 0.01307632215321064, 0.018175281584262848, -0.019994638860225677, -0.009830025024712086, 0.004463731776922941, 0.052311476320028305, 0.021986233070492744, -0.032651860266923904, -0.016464611515402794, -0.02246834710240364, 0.008041062392294407, -0.04005958139896393, -0.05284542962908745, 0.03070097789168358, -0.006841374095529318, -0.024811282753944397, 0.03012712113559246, -0.020985957235097885, 0.015211167745292187, 0.022829219698905945, 0.027517523616552353, -0.03701314702630043, 0.014707470312714577, 0.01004194188863039, 0.027378369122743607, -0.014322694391012192, 0.02479744143784046, 0.018160779029130936, 0.02558819018304348, 0.01923789270222187, 0.019626494497060776, 0.017510609701275826, 0.02645203284919262, 0.025530735030770302, 0.02466772496700287, -0.0185175109654665, -0.00002176171801693272, 0.03788628429174423, -0.0337638333439827, -0.019733911380171776, 0.030032800510525703, 0.019458280876278877, -0.0073888590559363365, 0.023628871887922287, -0.02283141389489174, 0.03725235536694527, -0.016483673825860023, -0.005722668953239918, -0.01484084315598011, -0.04424910247325897, 0.018197445198893547, 0.044136252254247665, -0.0313032902777195, 0.00019077456090599298, -0.0002820475201588124, -0.008100113831460476, -0.003369285259395838, -0.03772076964378357, -0.01712479442358017, 0.031889788806438446, -0.005199590232223272, -0.025375302881002426, 0.01903369463980198, 0.017404142767190933, -0.024411441758275032, 0.0028013589326292276, 0.005901271477341652, 0.025784283876419067, 0.052516158670186996, 0.012594316154718399, 0.024211576208472252, -0.06135797128081322, -0.037237998098134995, 0.0036486065946519375, -0.0005898954696021974, 0.0048697879537940025, -0.028972914442420006, 0.06919797509908676, -0.0037301883567124605, -0.0526718944311142, 0.023672601208090782, -0.004122042562812567, 0.006539157126098871, 0.01301549468189478, -0.08029892295598984, -0.06285329908132553, 0.02077704668045044, 0.009010442532598972, -0.016735544428229332, -0.060297686606645584, 0.017422836273908615, 0.042301278561353683, 0.02019405923783779, 0.019063156098127365, 0.04425559565424919, 0.038355015218257904, 0.03241817280650139, 0.011976724490523338, -0.03587907925248146, -0.04648644104599953, -0.03875478357076645, -0.016895245760679245, 0.018276825547218323, -0.04002932086586952, 0.002363376785069704, 0.029093913733959198, -0.027283867821097374, -0.011437548324465752, 0.03997386619448662, 0.03496435284614563, -0.018524296581745148, -0.03899873420596123, -0.022926190868020058, -0.024705257266759872, 0.02310912497341633, -0.01306743174791336, -0.015248101204633713, -0.0014647998614236712, -0.03705371543765068, -0.025294722989201546, 0.0020752125419676304, 0.02244991809129715, 0.055376190692186356, -0.02484140545129776, 0.014638034626841545, -0.060426440089941025, 0.006394882220774889, -0.02054457552731037, -0.06044619902968407, -0.036111537367105484, -0.0055097900331020355, 0.009956582449376583, 0.025514615699648857, 0.006069814786314964, 0.015246440656483173, -0.018389880657196045, 0.039441101253032684, -0.027895422652363777, -0.07647088915109634, -0.018433649092912674, -0.009702968411147594, 0.01567937061190605, -0.04320383071899414, -0.015564458444714546, 0.033482909202575684, 0.03125760331749916, -0.009962629526853561, -0.016058538109064102, -0.005668864585459232, -0.013248889707028866, 0.03131670132279396, -0.030564729124307632, -0.012841945514082909, 0.020415479317307472, 0.07652277499437332, -0.026725849136710167, 0.06922236829996109, -0.04735235869884491, -0.052807796746492386, 0.012797270901501179, 0.00664016418159008, 0.05183999612927437, -0.013939275406301022, 0.028311919420957565, -0.012445583939552307, 0.012911349534988403, 0.02733672969043255, 0.019768724218010902, -0.06263349950313568, 0.05420825630426407, 0.07640078663825989, 0.016254324465990067, 0.03419795259833336, -0.05292742699384689, -0.008648396469652653, 0.00318983756005764, -0.020966779440641403, 0.008009873330593109, -0.03999434784054756, 0.007895825430750847, 0.009874558076262474, -0.01022517029196024, -0.061220377683639526, -0.0199104156345129, 0.07877941429615021, 0.02141394466161728, 0.001757712452672422, 0.031352948397397995, -0.026214994490146637, -0.02576535940170288, -0.021517563611268997, 0.00003226816261303611, -0.022647777572274208, 0.044982969760894775, 0.014692693017423153, 0.025019757449626923, 0.035631462931632996, 0.001310107414610684, -0.023953871801495552, 0.05734029784798622, -0.018620504066348076, 0.01798577420413494, -0.024614037945866585, -0.04528086632490158, 0.058644283562898636, -0.026431070640683174, 0.018882887437939644, 0.04788985848426819, -0.0049690078012645245, 0.019968347623944283, 0.0014447023859247565, -0.02648245170712471, 0.011217765510082245, 0.027853867039084435, -0.012454948388040066, -0.00037550050183199346, 0.023764505982398987, -0.03211275115609169, -0.007119206245988607, -0.05136355757713318, 0.009777595289051533, -0.026666931807994843, -0.02721458487212658, 0.06206122785806656, -0.010826432146131992, 0.016771892085671425, -0.017630331218242645, -0.008642303757369518, 0.006507479585707188, -0.03545434772968292, -0.0012139611644670367, 0.003950129263103008, -0.07396195083856583, 0.0003451663360465318, 0.00475712725892663, -0.014787893742322922, 0.0100330151617527, 0.007065212354063988, -0.044196926057338715, 0.04075166583061218, -0.004486498888581991, -0.03807531297206879, -0.012672285549342632, -0.012687870301306248, 0.02600879594683647, -0.034213315695524216, 0.003808418521657586, 0.032737866044044495, -0.007296338677406311, -0.049541786313056946, 0.013556677848100662, -0.03970760107040405, -0.008473115973174572, -0.012589216232299805, 0.013597595505416393, -0.03254785016179085, -0.019086448475718498, -0.03156770393252373, 0.01147419959306717, 0.012068062089383602, -0.00243591982871294, -0.040824662894010544, -0.01708744466304779, 0.023022545501589775, 0.039906468242406845, 0.029996898025274277, -0.009328627027571201, -0.054239995777606964, 0.044591326266527176, 0.005755416117608547, -0.009412696585059166, -0.049727752804756165, -0.021991144865751266, -0.03174895793199539, 0.004905105568468571, 0.05938803777098656, 0.01371128298342228, 0.0041238595731556416, 0.02392197959125042, 0.019270582124590874, 0.017452297732234, 0.0531744621694088, -0.014516358263790607, -0.0027431203052401543, 0.03850182518362999, -0.005875453818589449, -0.02367383800446987, 0.08561268448829651, 0.0027097794227302074, -0.04266203194856644, 0.0008641357417218387, 0.01515682227909565, 0.0067012435756623745, -0.008902857080101967, -0.0017993805231526494, -0.003664619754999876, -0.026603814214468002, 0.023946968838572502, -0.07449846714735031, 0.06628607213497162, 0.018187670037150383, -0.034266240894794464, -0.007320830132812262, -0.01636154018342495, 0.019720623269677162, -0.02669653482735157, 0.02137998305261135, 0.017881348729133606, 0.018936078995466232, -0.0020394527819007635, -0.004803608637303114, 0.0011315072188153863, -0.01408345066010952, 0.01135427039116621, -0.02359001711010933, 0.012142149731516838, 0.03641756623983383, 0.05529763549566269, 0.01967158541083336, -0.0014839265495538712, -0.04632619768381119, 0.004786741454154253, -0.05976671352982521, 0.004905805457383394, -0.047681186348199844, 0.05960555002093315, -0.0010554635664448142, 0.04838016629219055, 0.02391166053712368, -0.004782870877534151, -0.019540222361683846, -0.024357199668884277, -0.03397763520479202, -0.006105974316596985, -0.013342338614165783, -0.008328244090080261, 0.04771767929196358, 0.003001775359734893, -0.013388317078351974, 0.02104153111577034, -0.019658487290143967, -0.001354064792394638, 0.01910446770489216, -0.05743659287691116, 0.016970299184322357, 0.008256703615188599, -0.0038644345477223396, 0.026803642511367798, 0.03255467489361763, -0.009003540500998497, -0.012843870557844639, 0.0268511101603508, 0.059192828834056854, -0.00883807335048914, 0.009389947168529034, -0.01943674311041832, 0.013107020407915115, 0.029763204976916313, 0.02494613267481327, 0.04554089903831482, 0.031137432903051376, -0.07106467336416245, 0.02256683260202408, -0.012678483501076698, 0.04539942368865013, 0.050334587693214417, -0.014826142229139805, -0.010153880342841148, 0.013114595785737038, -0.0077174208126962185, -0.030862176790833473, -0.01969221793115139, 0.008168808184564114, -0.01645420491695404, 0.009789512492716312, 0.04996881261467934, -0.04492126405239105, 0.00646918686106801, 0.11093316972255707, 0.01944710686802864, 0.04628104716539383, -0.02692067250609398, -0.0137528907507658, -0.03264075890183449, -0.011944939382374287, 0.043003350496292114, 0.017308901995420456, -0.01935902051627636, 0.01426455657929182, 0.06953062862157822, -0.03662062808871269, -0.017734616994857788, 0.011995495297014713, 0.05962257832288742, 0.06110027804970741, -0.008291388861835003, -0.0268899817019701, 0.011436118744313717, 0.02064843848347664, 0.018336130306124687, 0.037253379821777344, 0.013312524184584618, -0.08542439341545105, -0.02744346670806408, 0.04551397264003754, 0.011952430941164494, -0.03693867102265358, -0.030015308409929276, -0.046892259269952774, 0.02710980921983719, 0.047451481223106384, -0.044818539172410965, -0.0017111524939537048, 0.015356367453932762, 0.0016504147788509727, -0.014771525748074055, -0.0012558946618810296, -0.04489383101463318, 0.017585834488272667, -0.0020043200347572565, 0.039136577397584915, -0.027427880093455315, -0.03106709197163582, -0.023795271292328835, 0.053769759833812714, -0.010684087872505188, 0.010869769379496574, -0.01753617264330387, 0.0026540972758084536, -0.011425493285059929, 0.039816439151763916, -0.04698643088340759, -0.06753845512866974, 0.004558885004371405, -0.026692865416407585, 0.036340806633234024, 0.04730140045285225, -0.04022396728396416, -0.018871715292334557, -0.02295810356736183, 0.022952640429139137, 0.007490439340472221, -0.0032936653587967157, -0.010476459749042988, 0.03017510287463665, 0.014627577736973763, -0.015950463712215424, 0.03942801430821419, 0.0006968460511416197, 0.008641460910439491, -0.03859468549489975, -0.022907013073563576, -0.020503953099250793, -0.009222588501870632, -0.004091174807399511, -0.03548409789800644, -0.018644429743289948, -0.02630053274333477, -0.004414544440805912, -0.040196627378463745, 0.041055575013160706, -0.03517671674489975, 0.04535503312945366, -0.022362416610121727, 0.02042226307094097, -0.0036106074694544077, -0.010484552010893822, -0.008677965961396694, 0.047967515885829926, 0.003614471759647131, -0.02981049194931984, 0.04946437105536461, -0.011650324799120426, -0.016144733875989914, -0.026501242071390152, 0.002891374984756112, 0.019886035472154617, -0.02018744871020317, -0.026588229462504387, -0.015420041047036648, -0.021931419149041176, 0.06297198683023453, -0.02255997434258461, -0.012186001054942608, -0.000018157201338908635, -0.032352548092603683, -0.016069291159510612, 0.0336090512573719, 0.03412516042590141, 0.025715501978993416, -0.05947938188910484, 0.009946024045348167, 0.0038040257059037685, -0.02404862828552723, -0.06931553781032562, -0.026987217366695404, 0.015370089560747147, 0.00986806582659483, -0.02264917641878128, -0.05354723334312439, -0.025974566116929054, 0.02196134440600872, -0.01832011342048645, -0.0024017798714339733, 0.06449907273054123, -0.03982517123222351, 0.005740022752434015, -0.021335506811738014, 0.019270773977041245, 0.0676487609744072, -0.00555225508287549, 0.01891699992120266, 0.018370676785707474, -0.013684174045920372, -0.004666419234126806, -0.04612114280462265, 0.01995079033076763, -0.024274351075291634, -0.006999440956860781, -0.06298436224460602, -0.013787094503641129, 0.0009698658250272274, 0.021517563611268997, -0.030674565583467484, -0.02004016563296318, 0.00040795421227812767, 0.025879446417093277, -0.0532764308154583, -0.004790422972291708, -0.01490706205368042, 0.013179236091673374, -0.04429921135306358, 0.003962226677685976, -0.04362643510103226, 0.02803356572985649, -0.011556718498468399, 0.005142692942172289, -0.02799837291240692, 0.007074280176311731, 0.07531291991472244, 0.0056939818896353245, 0.023343371227383614, 0.00647418899461627, -0.006173835601657629, 0.022570982575416565, 0.027514178305864334, -0.030979283154010773, -0.008017492480576038, 0.016111496835947037, -0.03498139604926109, -0.015753140673041344, -0.04944051057100296, -0.005888533778488636, 0.07130275666713715, -0.005335847847163677, 0.023179475218057632, 0.0769381895661354, 0.02426135167479515, 0.028301268815994263, -0.005339188501238823, -0.031690411269664764, -0.0012656516628339887, 0.03900841251015663, 0.0520336739718914, 0.022143209353089333, 0.01724776066839695, 0.09006024897098541, 0.0685369223356247, 0.020955244079232216, 0.05193150416016579, 0.03393023461103439, -0.012179500423371792, -0.013078156858682632, -0.010449673980474472, -0.02923164702951908, -0.0018718212377279997, -0.019748765975236893, 0.025135211646556854, 0.0005817649653181434, -0.031147396191954613, 0.009997828863561153, 0.030339786782860756, -0.014751365408301353, -0.019712230190634727, -0.01695767231285572, -0.04683859646320343, 0.01691218465566635, -0.016297223046422005, -0.014729013666510582, 0.03855448588728905, 0.030070481821894646, 0.0037618244532495737, -0.006824437063187361, 0.046933434903621674, -0.03423147648572922, -0.05505595728754997, -0.05365552753210068, -0.0030279592610895634, -0.021735841408371925, 0.04542016237974167, -0.01167816948145628, -0.01707935519516468, 0.059719234704971313, -0.0468350313603878, 0.009781711734831333, 0.002720270538702607, 0.053114406764507294, 0.022387482225894928, 0.08479028940200806, -0.028835628181695938, 0.04253176227211952, -0.014520184136927128, 0.013725610449910164, 0.143462136387825, 0.06191336363554001, 0.04828978329896927, -0.08285265415906906, -0.0012597086606547236, 0.03855319693684578, 0.01329239085316658, -0.005693404003977776, -0.011463664472103119, 0.010268685407936573, -0.01975785754621029, 0.06467381119728088, 0.061528295278549194, 0.0236752200871706, 0.008048225194215775, 0.03483576700091362, -0.022772526368498802, -0.03244001045823097, 0.0024440414272248745, 0.037111811339855194, 0.011162609793245792, -0.007086530327796936, -0.0523487851023674, -0.021801339462399483, 0.017866842448711395, -0.0514109767973423, -0.022923002019524574, 0.02181311883032322, -0.014374658465385437, 0.018157849088311195, -0.0411296971142292, 0.02500210516154766, 0.03398624435067177, 0.02325327880680561, -0.03626510128378868, 0.0076787895523011684, -0.009160436689853668, -0.018676260486245155, -0.00431166123598814, 0.033493850380182266, 0.006216941401362419, -0.003197856480255723, 0.006391695700585842, 0.006531607359647751, -0.05906687304377556, -0.006210543680936098, -0.009952708147466183, 0.016534876078367233, -0.016275614500045776, -0.0011625951156020164, -0.011369063518941402, -0.007554627023637295, -0.0100520309060812, -0.04839253053069115, -0.0362410843372345, -0.0004120556404814124, 0.02034933678805828, -0.02259707823395729, -0.00449243001639843, -0.013623219914734364, 0.007511025294661522, -0.03715775907039642, 0.0417613610625267, 0.007802173960953951, -0.0019562658853828907, 0.025259945541620255, -0.04733799025416374, 0.021452995017170906, -0.007523159962147474, 0.020604491233825684, 0.016696805134415627, -0.02203027345240116, 0.007227850146591663, -0.025845583528280258, 0.013663272373378277, 0.01908046007156372, 0.027179908007383347, -0.01738988421857357, -0.0046360488049685955, -0.028152840211987495, -0.07390914857387543, -0.01700523868203163, -0.06671931594610214, -0.01533687487244606, -0.044452231377363205, -0.006230923347175121, 0.041371241211891174, 0.02496572770178318, -0.012093989178538322, 0.010087019763886929, 0.018681809306144714, 0.06623076647520065, 0.02142142504453659, -0.06797735393047333, 0.02437211573123932, 0.035179246217012405, -0.03166987746953964, -0.04026653617620468, -0.03951061889529228, 0.052012309432029724, 0.06410268694162369, 0.05623452737927437, -0.013233081437647343, 0.023721663281321526, -0.012738637626171112, 0.009313344955444336, 0.009536347351968288, -0.04844779521226883, -0.03822487220168114, 0.017591901123523712, -0.0005367653793655336, -0.032421644777059555, -0.005484767258167267, -0.05411551520228386, -0.024541428312659264, 0.015139218419790268, -0.03552733361721039, -0.05093015730381012, 0.00855418760329485, -0.0015218346379697323, 0.008798623457551003, -0.014954175800085068, 0.016026372089982033, -0.012130304239690304, -0.03971000760793686, -0.0049057817086577415, -0.0008282890194095671, -0.051196515560150146, 0.010758132673799992, -0.02092696540057659, 0.041577357798814774, 0.03717789798974991, 0.013758025132119656, 0.015205012634396553, 0.01042924728244543, 0.004517600405961275, 0.0220269113779068, 0.07978128641843796, -0.011167177930474281, -0.019504183903336525, 0.0320165753364563, -0.05657603219151497, -0.009139050729572773, 0.03117704764008522, 0.0009194297599606216, 0.050749119371175766, 0.031160738319158554, 0.0017557911342009902, -0.0047296565026044846, 0.0325346402823925, -0.017663387581706047, -0.01400262676179409, 0.00447460450232029, -0.010824741795659065, 0.05258503928780556, 0.00867900624871254, -0.024163777008652687, 0.014155911281704903, -0.04560193791985512, 0.027671024203300476, 0.0868794173002243, -0.013402992859482765, 0.011609872803092003, 0.019700249657034874, 0.004950092174112797, 0.056117769330739975, 0.019830765202641487, -0.04019743949174881, 0.02586720697581768, 0.03821166232228279, -0.025597909465432167, 0.02429528348147869, -0.04126628860831261, 0.020863618701696396, -0.06251919269561768, -0.022506214678287506, 0.0018711024895310402, -0.01159677468240261, 0.050219446420669556, -0.03692421317100525, 0.002280217595398426, 0.02830437943339348, -0.0480734258890152, 0.07780464738607407, 0.03933153674006462, -0.013898003846406937, -0.03812998905777931, 0.019970590248703957, 0.0347638875246048, 0.046786919236183167, 0.0019591946620494127, -0.0039314343594014645, 0.06693543493747711, 0.03417857363820076, -0.009736825712025166, -0.03562293201684952, -0.03003043122589588, -0.009055125527083874, 0.022514276206493378, -0.08605045825242996, 0.02274479903280735, -0.030587999150156975, -0.03217869624495506, 0.03508257120847702, -0.06414103507995605, 0.03151434287428856, -0.01171202678233385, 0.012072283774614334, -0.035187508910894394, 0.02949555218219757, 0.04067223146557808, 0.0009773661149665713, -0.020697539672255516, -0.036526184529066086, 0.017296936362981796, 0.005244911648333073, -0.03697793185710907, 0.03629431501030922, 0.02097567915916443, -0.009991375729441643, -0.04895041137933731, -0.007607825566083193, -0.0009626738610677421, -0.008615023456513882, -0.023333828896284103, -0.001953513128682971, 0.002539315726608038, -0.030110551044344902, -0.018949437886476517, -0.02859385311603546, 0.0041272807866334915, 0.016743673011660576, 0.020987849682569504, 0.0277022123336792, 0.011946438811719418, -0.017268525436520576, -0.006373079027980566, 0.009458804503083229, 0.016125785186886787, -0.00348441069945693, -0.05187910050153732, -0.007170164957642555, 0.04720786213874817, 0.0029684347100555897, -0.033609502017498016, -0.008442329242825508, 0.03769831731915474, 0.018020810559391975, -0.02584405057132244, -0.004863988142460585, 0.023722006008028984, -0.02106589637696743, 0.046740010380744934, -0.06977960467338562, 0.039239052683115005, 0.020434081554412842, -0.03211868926882744, -0.005927690304815769, -0.006139948032796383, -0.05518454685807228, 0.00005183433313504793, -0.0032121154945343733, 0.005116316489875317, -0.013732727617025375, -0.03515659272670746, 0.022619348019361496, -0.0045676096342504025, -0.0291972104460001, 0.014287774451076984, -0.013000905513763428, -0.01744053140282631, -0.026219991967082024, 0.0018370195757597685, 0.015792788937687874, -0.000931164831854403, -0.015144707635045052, 0.0008566554170101881, -0.006573275197297335, 0.01840933784842491, -0.03464185819029808, 0.017177801579236984, 0.014858963899314404, -0.02951527014374733, 0.04202921316027641, -0.015859482809901237, 0.006734523922204971, 0.05815712362527847, -0.003114015329629183, -0.03721066564321518, 0.024005023762583733, -0.017196359112858772, -0.05253096669912338, -0.011902084574103355, -0.005580180324614048, 0.0077630034647881985, -0.04833265766501427, 0.010239646770060062, 0.025729412212967873, 0.004234105348587036, 0.02755623124539852, 0.03587435558438301, 0.053140755742788315, 0.06461025029420853, -0.0025630623567849398, 0.02683006227016449, 0.02614879608154297, -0.02548176608979702, 0.048232875764369965, 0.019490540027618408, 0.019057491794228554, -0.01773853227496147, 0.004195486661046743, 0.04056596755981445, -0.025618331506848335, 0.04376426339149475, -0.018010206520557404, 0.0573161281645298, 0.0025310274213552475, -0.033543363213539124, 0.023206165060400963, -0.002190558472648263, 0.03573157638311386, 0.021805647760629654, -0.007291961926966906, 0.04390699416399002, 0.014511335641145706, 0.012076247483491898, -0.03139006718993187, 0.014150104485452175, -0.03781791776418686, -0.04140292853116989, -0.0209023579955101, -0.02876284345984459, -0.04444408789277077, -0.024881945922970772, 0.0196977686136961, -0.04672962427139282, 0.010303037241101265, -0.02238188125193119, -0.00980019848793745, 0.002780800685286522, 0.04304279014468193, -0.03256585821509361, -0.030831288546323776, 0.012865308672189713, 0.004575271159410477, 0.06389539688825607, 0.001189519534818828, 0.021853504702448845, -0.03866631165146828, -0.021804222837090492, -0.011802748776972294, 0.027147352695465088, -0.013444110751152039, -0.03818720206618309, -0.03852279111742973, -0.007806496229022741, 0.016611583530902863, -0.011109907180070877 ]
<p>I have calculated the correlation between A and B for 10 different subjects. For averaging purposes, I've converted the r-values to z-values using Fisher's z-transformation. </p> <pre><code>subj zvalue s1 -0.04 s2 -0.14 s3 -0.29 s4 -0.20 s5 -0.37 s6 -0.01 s7 -0.09 s8 0.20 s9 -0.15 s10 0.09 </code></pre> <p>I want to test if the correlation between A and B is significantly different from zero. Do I use a paired sample t-test against 0 with the z-values, then report the r-value converted from the mean z-value? Or should I convert each subject's z-value back to an r-value before doing the t-test?</p> <p>Edit: Critically, is a paired t-test against 0 appropriate to test if this correlation is significant across subjects?</p>
47,199
[ -0.04038950800895691, -0.020468130707740784, -0.012189876288175583, -0.000936749973334372, 0.050239644944667816, 0.0006632733275182545, 0.0022856914438307285, -0.003999277949333191, 0.02416093647480011, -0.005416871979832649, 0.018472611904144287, 0.017595672979950905, 0.02787318453192711, -0.007124258205294609, 0.049211494624614716, -0.016671547666192055, -0.02677762694656849, -0.016286209225654602, 0.007235396653413773, -0.0004057048063259572, -0.0033135698176920414, -0.004443643614649773, 0.027985207736492157, -0.0016625457210466266, -0.037678465247154236, 0.032547734677791595, 0.004979461897164583, -0.04155251383781433, -0.0002492055355105549, 0.0352439247071743, -0.041120611131191254, -0.034900084137916565, 0.015103922225534916, 0.044042445719242096, 0.01589003950357437, 0.003071691608056426, -0.04439485818147659, -0.03382957726716995, -0.005020391661673784, 0.021283861249685287, -0.003779286751523614, -0.008825323544442654, 0.02608802355825901, 0.03039122372865677, -0.01763521507382393, 0.013593294657766819, -0.014301552437245846, 0.00556579977273941, 0.020139055326581, -0.023642083629965782, 0.06390472501516342, 0.03503207117319107, 0.02835346944630146, -0.008667421527206898, -0.004361766390502453, -0.01999606378376484, 0.05284833908081055, 0.025293869897723198, -0.010564319789409637, -0.05811794102191925, -0.0031921956688165665, -0.06630359590053558, -0.023678861558437347, -0.013472432270646095, -0.02442803792655468, 0.015098029747605324, 0.00027671820134855807, -0.01047470048069954, 0.055301327258348465, -0.03628699854016304, 0.035779934376478195, 0.02980720065534115, 0.01706729084253311, -0.0370621494948864, 0.03303852304816246, -0.04011871665716171, 0.03846381977200508, 0.03246854990720749, 0.045848868787288666, 0.04842395335435867, -0.007639707066118717, -0.019528185948729515, 0.03019450418651104, 0.04599229246377945, 0.053072214126586914, -0.018167652189731598, 0.033837124705314636, -0.0017093652859330177, -0.020342828705906868, 0.029973315075039864, -0.018569154664874077, 0.010304927825927734, 0.028111575171351433, 0.0314030647277832, -0.0525251142680645, 0.029644856229424477, -0.01192863192409277, 0.08229024708271027, -0.034346804022789, -0.023355625569820404, -0.02889690361917019, -0.03366164490580559, 0.029519908130168915, 0.008948498405516148, -0.03689989447593689, 0.008760401047766209, -0.028191858902573586, -0.010070270858705044, 0.009387492202222347, -0.02958810143172741, -0.008847799152135849, 0.00713287154212594, -0.011766703799366951, 0.015796473249793053, 0.047662362456321716, -0.028676722198724747, 0.00791193451732397, -0.0004783791082445532, 0.06580926477909088, 0.04051673039793968, 0.07286027073860168, -0.016375433653593063, -0.026071418076753616, 0.022614136338233948, -0.0018051445949822664, -0.002389987464994192, 0.007186560425907373, -0.016935838386416435, -0.01529502309858799, 0.03966984525322914, -0.000686389859765768, -0.015623793005943298, 0.024329910054802895, -0.0282867681235075, -0.0005336475442163646, 0.006232341285794973, -0.06579121202230453, -0.06717135012149811, 0.029311614111065865, 0.0027193878777325153, -0.021442072466015816, -0.061623502522706985, -0.013369163498282433, 0.02651985175907612, 0.028049683198332787, 0.015391643159091473, 0.04382728040218353, 0.009086192585527897, 0.05970139428973198, 0.02055429294705391, -0.039237719029188156, -0.0395151823759079, -0.05025171861052513, -0.023181285709142685, 0.015125823207199574, -0.03416210040450096, -0.00032029516296461225, 0.009852806106209755, -0.01477731578052044, -0.014293180778622627, 0.03442728891968727, 0.014622651040554047, -0.004864010959863663, 0.010189630091190338, -0.0022998638451099396, 0.00658205384388566, 0.04753110930323601, -0.018946819007396698, 0.026581065729260445, 0.006869536824524403, 0.015313784591853619, -0.003386125899851322, 0.02603628672659397, 0.02478940039873123, 0.029415542259812355, -0.018935712054371834, 0.00020543842401821166, -0.03217954933643341, 0.029752586036920547, -0.007329165935516357, -0.04919499158859253, -0.021554116159677505, -0.0368904210627079, -0.01643790863454342, 0.02486570179462433, 0.07257406413555145, -0.010959705337882042, -0.006582465022802353, 0.04350833222270012, -0.02810390293598175, -0.0639294758439064, -0.03787719085812569, 0.02510201372206211, 0.0049839140847325325, -0.02251499332487583, 0.0047941929660737514, 0.022891676053404808, 0.05991889163851738, -0.0015580905601382256, -0.018837278708815575, -0.025218162685632706, 0.002795198932290077, 0.03711730241775513, -0.04002131149172783, 0.03643341362476349, 0.04441780596971512, 0.05373256653547287, -0.03332938998937607, 0.03354501351714134, -0.018743891268968582, -0.045104701071977615, 0.0009514506673440337, 0.018574323505163193, 0.025644764304161072, 0.005584225989878178, -0.04150937497615814, 0.0184846892952919, -0.0009278705692850053, -0.022347742691636086, 0.04252820089459419, -0.06494584679603577, 0.08236192166805267, 0.06045631319284439, -0.0035605989396572113, -0.0018635432934388518, 0.01647602580487728, 0.04126637801527977, 0.0195624902844429, -0.021619098260998726, 0.0012543601915240288, -0.0887334793806076, -0.020989064127206802, 0.031503889709711075, 0.02457297593355179, -0.0518057644367218, 0.01070386078208685, 0.06298503279685974, -0.0037169225979596376, -0.030226940289139748, 0.04015294462442398, -0.004027226474136114, -0.03897653892636299, 0.02243993617594242, 0.04268822818994522, 0.029385674744844437, -0.01617329567670822, 0.004320502746850252, -0.00339550175704062, 0.029909789562225342, 0.0168539360165596, -0.02312721498310566, 0.03147904574871063, 0.0005220873863436282, 0.029788000509142876, -0.018570994958281517, -0.033949412405490875, 0.021096495911478996, -0.03674977272748947, -0.007652822881937027, 0.018296977505087852, 0.017254572361707687, 0.004773343447595835, 0.02131067030131817, -0.01795702613890171, -0.011687406338751316, 0.048254918307065964, -0.004167723003774881, 0.01069168746471405, 0.004413228947669268, -0.028506727889180183, -0.024736929684877396, -0.0451028011739254, 0.010612202808260918, -0.05175269767642021, -0.00546508003026247, 0.018482539802789688, -0.002836185274645686, 0.013487848453223705, -0.028958873823285103, -0.014568580314517021, -0.010652967728674412, 0.010435043834149837, 0.021804755553603172, 0.009174637496471405, -0.08225379884243011, -0.002621707273647189, 0.0031940226908773184, -0.02993866242468357, 0.01830095611512661, 0.013591193594038486, -0.004507953766733408, 0.02992141991853714, 0.006261159665882587, -0.06839754432439804, -0.037130679935216904, -0.009915683418512344, 0.0028514894656836987, -0.004076763521879911, -0.016681987792253494, 0.07505767047405243, -0.018816577270627022, -0.05908430740237236, 0.022021152079105377, -0.02501673810184002, -0.029437679797410965, 0.020599907264113426, -0.011666304431855679, -0.003651933278888464, 0.0037915187422186136, -0.0021268317941576242, -0.007502350490540266, -0.06544052064418793, -0.004540347494184971, -0.05096700042486191, -0.046603888273239136, 0.032111190259456635, 0.02825736626982689, 0.048958081752061844, 0.008447526022791862, -0.02305762469768524, 0.06435491144657135, 0.011176824569702148, -0.027538396418094635, -0.061936043202877045, -0.005601357668638229, -0.047895610332489014, -0.03746356442570686, 0.03530152887105942, 0.022184021770954132, 0.012930496595799923, 0.023787429556250572, 0.011701105162501335, 0.04193020984530449, 0.03731339052319527, 0.02395317330956459, 0.009388744831085205, 0.015743950381875038, 0.03347586840391159, -0.016730234026908875, 0.029361795634031296, -0.003971562255173922, -0.03395446017384529, 0.00013257464161142707, -0.006289214361459017, 0.01718893274664879, 0.0031916790176182985, -0.025190388783812523, 0.04250599816441536, 0.01018726360052824, 0.020735181868076324, -0.025873390957713127, 0.02989387698471546, 0.0146797439083457, -0.001307399827055633, -0.003984454087913036, 0.016770994290709496, 0.05140183866024017, -0.01331496611237526, 0.006856242660433054, 0.07175241410732269, 0.03133033961057663, -0.011591222137212753, -0.005576801486313343, 0.00999483186751604, -0.0040061804465949535, 0.03381342068314552, -0.03808318078517914, -0.011252026073634624, 0.07246403396129608, 0.0350244902074337, 0.024130938574671745, -0.003744772169739008, -0.06142021715641022, 0.020058225840330124, -0.03956006467342377, 0.009695634245872498, -0.056898731738328934, 0.05016348138451576, -0.011268597096204758, 0.07404160499572754, 0.030230022966861725, -0.0010083926608785987, -0.00731184147298336, -0.00706407381221652, -0.03604390472173691, 0.04700008034706116, -0.009078209288418293, 0.027392003685235977, 0.022288406267762184, 0.00879458524286747, -0.008514989167451859, -0.0012103073531761765, 0.05336502194404602, -0.007179928943514824, 0.025742506608366966, -0.012831112369894981, -0.003346550278365612, -0.0014014681801199913, 0.000001845313022386108, -0.025744089856743813, 0.018179969862103462, -0.016192220151424408, -0.032132867723703384, 0.06220223382115364, 0.04766940325498581, 0.014235134236514568, 0.010437924414873123, -0.03583374246954918, 0.009720654226839542, -0.0109409736469388, 0.03332061320543289, 0.0423002615571022, 0.0256621316075325, -0.052322156727313995, 0.01922486163675785, -0.0004008406540378928, -0.0050657871179282665, 0.022309482097625732, -0.021533941850066185, -0.0032153429929167032, -0.02020573616027832, -0.038081053644418716, -0.01830078661441803, 0.04478096216917038, 0.023348763585090637, -0.004033627919852734, 0.029194572940468788, 0.034878212958574295, -0.021869735792279243, 0.046614911407232285, 0.07823456823825836, 0.014338785782456398, 0.0003233538300264627, -0.019100254401564598, -0.014809534884989262, 0.0016675143269822001, -0.01268254965543747, 0.038031917065382004, 0.058735355734825134, -0.012328755110502243, 0.009517951868474483, 0.03989318758249283, 0.021511048078536987, 0.0042357430793344975, 0.012531314976513386, 0.00545675540342927, 0.0628780946135521, 0.017105557024478912, -0.04321780428290367, -0.002515993779525161, 0.04110357537865639, 0.03402825817465782, 0.03190581500530243, -0.03362805396318436, -0.06759500503540039, 0.013155529275536537, 0.047499727457761765, 0.08070099353790283, -0.035984449088573456, 0.021942729130387306, -0.0544234998524189, -0.015848839655518532, 0.032502252608537674, -0.04591086879372597, 0.0060866111889481544, -0.02986512891948223, -0.015142452903091908, -0.015706738457083702, 0.004600948188453913, -0.061242327094078064, 0.0036423513665795326, -0.016901617869734764, 0.03234311565756798, -0.021132608875632286, -0.04325253516435623, -0.013011801056563854, 0.013322803191840649, 0.023862212896347046, 0.056383244693279266, -0.05522748455405235, -0.010249879211187363, -0.005074790213257074, 0.016025066375732422, 0.005115617997944355, -0.04372267425060272, -0.012548774480819702, -0.006188021507114172, 0.011369490996003151, 0.0750596821308136, -0.008239572867751122, -0.0341530404984951, 0.017965087667107582, -0.007030549459159374, -0.0122838718816638, -0.0025596260093152523, -0.035164933651685715, 0.046730946749448776, 0.047773927450180054, -0.006851040292531252, 0.06866541504859924, -0.0008809663122519851, -0.0016565306577831507, -0.008358742110431194, -0.03427886962890625, -0.028813229873776436, -0.006940721999853849, 0.046854417771101, -0.020423809066414833, 0.0029242897871881723, -0.019707094877958298, 0.02503289468586445, -0.024106455966830254, 0.021606191992759705, -0.01143539696931839, 0.020966123789548874, 0.019799288362264633, 0.012191186659038067, -0.010454139672219753, 0.021316759288311005, 0.02110658958554268, -0.005650169216096401, -0.011703010648488998, -0.030782176181674004, 0.015260342508554459, -0.035202085971832275, -0.01343595515936613, -0.0036459958646446466, -0.05921795219182968, 0.04595591872930527, -0.001267982181161642, -0.0067274123430252075, 0.00932369939982891, -0.06841425597667694, 0.03491900861263275, -0.013746870681643486, 0.026791807264089584, 0.034932613372802734, -0.01714009791612625, 0.00791091751307249, 0.034645769745111465, 0.02261403389275074, 0.03764792159199715, -0.06907103955745697, 0.0441446378827095, -0.011911812238395214, -0.01737648993730545, -0.056176938116550446, -0.010794750414788723, 0.019066378474235535, 0.014308555983006954, 0.013870608992874622, -0.007951739244163036, -0.02015712857246399, -0.005601077806204557, 0.005849443841725588, -0.019004464149475098, 0.08271127194166183, -0.03955022990703583, -0.03291793540120125, 0.008496997877955437, 0.02920716442167759, 0.0744338184595108, -0.006437710486352444, -0.00971972569823265, 0.01567399688065052, -0.0010922977235168219, -0.016816044226288795, 0.011381438933312893, 0.004830208607017994, -0.02732687257230282, -0.02611764334142208, -0.022852955386042595, -0.0002144719910575077, 0.04404895752668381, 0.01824839599430561, -0.014249561354517937, -0.017614208161830902, -0.0341527983546257, -0.01084522157907486, -0.008420192636549473, 0.01385289616882801, -0.03997031971812248, -0.0003986085357610136, -0.048587750643491745, 0.032221924513578415, -0.05078153684735298, 0.008149318397045135, 0.02409304305911064, 0.025727981701493263, -0.054998286068439484, 0.004932595882564783, 0.07056611776351929, 0.028110915794968605, 0.009462529793381691, -0.010569541715085506, -0.02440989576280117, 0.027718091383576393, -0.01186536904424429, 0.0063596428371965885, 0.003264078637585044, 0.03270693123340607, -0.009288259781897068, 0.016262425109744072, -0.004918528720736504, -0.027474764734506607, 0.06166306883096695, 0.02337062731385231, 0.03561246022582054, 0.06267838180065155, 0.03757646307349205, 0.012732201255857944, -0.04973682761192322, 0.028067203238606453, -0.008130690082907677, 0.01159302145242691, 0.023392347618937492, 0.013756398111581802, 0.0018922450253739953, 0.011353012174367905, 0.03300716355443001, 0.003233518684282899, 0.03852034732699394, 0.05341612547636032, -0.014068060554564, 0.028299057856202126, -0.012378447689116001, -0.05820412561297417, 0.04500347003340721, -0.06510322540998459, 0.035546235740184784, -0.04862116277217865, -0.0357481986284256, 0.04054715111851692, 0.021420037373900414, 0.012814696878194809, -0.05972268804907799, -0.01508075650781393, -0.035621438175439835, 0.03358481824398041, -0.01864619180560112, -0.033125393092632294, 0.018964098766446114, -0.001999881584197283, 0.05211430415511131, -0.0342763289809227, 0.04331650212407112, -0.03316451609134674, -0.07870221883058548, -0.052322130650281906, -0.029806755483150482, -0.03497957065701485, 0.053699057549238205, -0.012284659780561924, -0.0015835331287235022, 0.002068555448204279, -0.05368490517139435, 0.052213966846466064, -0.01727636717259884, 0.025488657876849174, -0.046321023255586624, 0.07519331574440002, 0.01040809415280819, 0.021371832117438316, 0.018880769610404968, -0.009737229906022549, 0.10832183808088303, 0.05797092989087105, 0.01602967269718647, -0.059836726635694504, 0.004921592306345701, -0.01326750312000513, 0.011296934448182583, -0.00849169585853815, 0.00586345512419939, 0.009299848228693008, -0.00606154277920723, 0.07003448158502579, 0.05052470043301582, 0.053054071962833405, -0.03579104319214821, 0.06300652772188187, -0.041669342666864395, 0.0009034209651872516, -0.01459443848580122, 0.035402096807956696, 0.014413097873330116, -0.0448085181415081, -0.045773278921842575, -0.030465595424175262, -0.0316450335085392, -0.03137356415390968, -0.036147963255643845, 0.026305830106139183, -0.00976200308650732, -0.025413919240236282, -0.035329077392816544, 0.009212297387421131, 0.00045937098911963403, 0.009128260426223278, -0.012934201397001743, -0.017297690734267235, 0.034176748245954514, -0.05114441365003586, 0.03538646548986435, 0.033494651317596436, -0.016720784828066826, 0.0000703322293702513, 0.01688745990395546, 0.0009299087687395513, -0.07195773720741272, -0.022792676463723183, -0.006808461155742407, 0.04195130243897438, -0.003750353818759322, -0.04999112710356712, -0.0037626849953085184, 0.00943794846534729, 0.004847214091569185, -0.047475192695856094, -0.05020369961857796, 0.00869408342987299, 0.0019633620977401733, -0.011806962080299854, -0.013967814855277538, -0.021845798939466476, 0.002737852046266198, -0.023656882345676422, 0.03280157595872879, 0.05892273038625717, 0.022228818386793137, -0.012591610662639141, -0.030513430014252663, 0.040419548749923706, -0.012167329899966717, 0.024901678785681725, -0.005501095205545425, -0.0066305906511843204, -0.02685585990548134, -0.003850440727546811, 0.00773938512429595, -0.007241610437631607, 0.03170272707939148, 0.0005061819683760405, -0.0020517506636679173, -0.022010864689946175, -0.046305298805236816, 0.027427252382040024, -0.020393233746290207, -0.019344810396432877, -0.055759236216545105, 0.010594895109534264, 0.029683075845241547, 0.010625939816236496, -0.010522361844778061, 0.01941533386707306, -0.0320107564330101, 0.07583893835544586, 0.020382370799779892, -0.05462665483355522, -0.0019291173666715622, -0.013405638746917248, -0.01064416952431202, 0.0014717030571773648, -0.024978987872600555, 0.02351001277565956, 0.06136753037571907, 0.028505627065896988, -0.03881051018834114, 0.004822632297873497, -0.0012710135197266936, -0.007657584734261036, 0.01369958184659481, -0.03676968440413475, -0.039895784109830856, 0.02493186667561531, 0.012758319266140461, -0.010472613386809826, -0.0008674464770592749, -0.05748239532113075, -0.021911688148975372, 0.013664140366017818, -0.02664066106081009, -0.025506213307380676, -0.022740237414836884, -0.03175795450806618, -0.026767520233988762, -0.04887794703245163, -0.012093344703316689, -0.038231175392866135, -0.01748785749077797, 0.016977541148662567, 0.026891352608799934, -0.020764019340276718, 0.05485738813877106, -0.030976800248026848, 0.01662573590874672, 0.04883047193288803, -0.006327245384454727, 0.012163405306637287, 0.010558012872934341, -0.020155305042862892, 0.008167649619281292, 0.04071396589279175, 0.014544516801834106, -0.03300013765692711, 0.032156072556972504, -0.04921090602874756, 0.005664277356117964, 0.03283378481864929, 0.027099447324872017, 0.015218177810311317, -0.011519428342580795, -0.020429477095603943, -0.0216938816010952, 0.011556972749531269, 0.0006296528736129403, -0.01645153947174549, -0.021049201488494873, -0.01470041275024414, -0.03361813351511955, 0.01313998643308878, 0.00403185747563839, 0.033714670687913895, -0.007548458408564329, 0.021912261843681335, 0.04390827938914299, -0.019653426483273506, 0.03725043684244156, 0.0007046859245747328, 0.018713969737291336, -0.014948693104088306, -0.0023727735970169306, -0.009040002711117268, 0.013354470953345299, 0.0730118602514267, -0.005700170528143644, 0.02486903965473175, -0.04003896191716194, 0.013787399977445602, -0.06108931824564934, -0.04100672900676727, 0.011624893173575401, -0.02341541089117527, 0.008692897856235504, -0.07787873595952988, -0.004798763897269964, 0.01639331318438053, -0.047820065170526505, 0.05923910811543465, -0.004847055766731501, -0.06653331220149994, -0.04907248169183731, 0.02061050571501255, 0.0062204995192587376, 0.01249554380774498, 0.007360563613474369, -0.008153626695275307, 0.008644246496260166, 0.004239503759890795, 0.004797658417373896, 0.014503071084618568, -0.035451266914606094, 0.014058004133403301, 0.011827635578811169, -0.06266985833644867, 0.025939563289284706, -0.023332946002483368, -0.06712592393159866, 0.027901198714971542, -0.009062148630619049, 0.030270090326666832, -0.020487908273935318, 0.05334482714533806, 0.008933361619710922, 0.05985959246754646, 0.03912418335676193, 0.0061894855462014675, -0.035580623894929886, -0.0012890652287751436, 0.009141123853623867, 0.02737472392618656, -0.04161335900425911, 0.040719885379076004, 0.006016790866851807, 0.0002827635616995394, -0.024322854354977608, 0.0029138955287635326, -0.021869538351893425, 0.012637943960726261, -0.01704944111406803, 0.010068829171359539, 0.020118998363614082, -0.020856186747550964, -0.009097712114453316, -0.05032140761613846, -0.01819220557808876, 0.049690283834934235, 0.0513596311211586, -0.010408753529191017, 0.00558148929849267, -0.007900146767497063, -0.006568185519427061, 0.02792140282690525, 0.005977386608719826, -0.014351016841828823, -0.07194340974092484, -0.04349721223115921, -0.04062587767839432, 0.03285124897956848, -0.0393337644636631, -0.029440419748425484, -0.014503024518489838, 0.010151317343115807, -0.01634754240512848, 0.02736469730734825, 0.01094752922654152, -0.0015002720756456256, -0.0005951273487880826, -0.059648264199495316, 0.03393556922674179, -0.0009605802479200065, -0.01911308988928795, -0.048484742641448975, -0.022239677608013153, -0.042695023119449615, -0.012566685676574707, 0.058052100241184235, 0.04169890284538269, 0.027546146884560585, -0.020350847393274307, 0.03680092841386795, 0.008949012495577335, -0.08173444867134094, 0.04533135145902634, -0.011723958887159824, -0.005464998539537191, -0.003821838414296508, 0.001906908000819385, -0.0021683829836547375, 0.0034360806457698345, 0.023030590265989304, -0.03387553244829178, 0.005945309996604919, -0.022743139415979385, -0.030098367482423782, 0.03916386514902115, 0.010678112506866455, -0.017288563773036003, 0.026223840191960335, 0.01150352880358696, 0.021390870213508606, 0.04044479876756668, -0.0035011121071875095, -0.047534484416246414, 0.041505228728055954, -0.02831658348441124, -0.00018999971507582814, 0.006644171196967363, 0.02679075114428997, -0.018179869279265404, -0.08425210416316986, 0.02108120545744896, 0.01122919749468565, -0.04473735764622688, 0.009927661158144474, 0.05747516453266144, 0.03540562838315964, 0.024098463356494904, -0.025260763242840767, 0.015574859455227852, 0.00007971753075253218, -0.0154120409861207, 0.015442229807376862, 0.032552607357501984, 0.011206382885575294, -0.01940210536122322, 0.02138778381049633, 0.03655555471777916, -0.0319007970392704, 0.018056737259030342, -0.017154451459646225, 0.03313257545232773, -0.020335359498858452, -0.008124057203531265, 0.040243543684482574, 0.00366682605817914, 0.02894836850464344, 0.0502755232155323, -0.006431465037167072, 0.02559303678572178, -0.0508374385535717, -0.0029026733245700598, -0.03427492827177048, -0.044167231768369675, -0.0634651705622673, 0.024389665573835373, 0.028993118554353714, 0.015063300728797913, -0.0016259890981018543, 0.022602859884500504, 0.015312938019633293, -0.041259538382291794, 0.00661406060680747, -0.023882225155830383, 0.009699070826172829, -0.034891556948423386, -0.007069242652505636, -0.007408516481518745, -0.012240477837622166, -0.04377451166510582, -0.028088653460144997, -0.0036758214700967073, 0.04987822473049164, 0.00523942057043314, -0.06302041560411453, -0.019043928012251854, 0.004813040606677532, 0.008147134445607662, -0.04353886470198631, -0.050689518451690674, -0.025773262605071068, 0.04059562459588051, 0.0011336073512211442, -0.03215648978948593 ]
<p>I am implementing a Fine &amp; Gray competing risk model. The model includes covariates that are static for each person (e.g. location) as well as covariates that change over time (such as local unemployment rates).</p> <p>The issue I have is: how do you generate cumulative incidence curves, assuming covariates that change over time? It is straightforward to use the STATA command "stcurve" and generate a CI curve that assumes fixed values for covariates (e.g. covariate value X for all times), but there is no functionality to generate a CI curve assuming covariate value X in time t, and then covariate value Y in time t + 1. </p> <p>Is there a paper that discusses this, or a package in R/SAS/STATA that lets you generate curves assuming different values of covariates over time? Thanks very much for any help!</p>
35,805
[ -0.02106109820306301, 0.0009591143461875618, 0.03467134013772011, -0.017403120175004005, 0.0327400341629982, -0.004850773140788078, 0.002469775965437293, -0.011210083030164242, 0.05004575476050377, -0.04508545622229576, 0.029822275042533875, 0.06370926648378372, 0.0627870187163353, -0.02996743470430374, 0.03257806971669197, -0.000340716156642884, 0.006183031480759382, 0.019310852512717247, -0.03667115420103073, 0.0011086578015238047, -0.011296968907117844, 0.010087675414979458, 0.023903096094727516, -0.014437982812523842, -0.0165950246155262, 0.0327320471405983, 0.022716091945767403, -0.022716065868735313, -0.012690862640738487, 0.08014900982379913, -0.05129418522119522, -0.025355616584420204, 0.014619539491832256, 0.06039217486977577, -0.00827523972839117, -0.006162452045828104, -0.04763058200478554, -0.05675842612981796, -0.04187489673495293, 0.04458541050553322, -0.048432596027851105, -0.019995205104351044, -0.03415197134017944, 0.06467006355524063, -0.012877661734819412, 0.004080745857208967, -0.026384465396404266, -0.008269749581813812, 0.052344199270009995, -0.026097724214196205, 0.06843716651201248, -0.040419433265924454, 0.07057715952396393, 0.059290673583745956, -0.013882581144571304, -0.0037867191713303328, 0.05941282957792282, 0.02304082363843918, 0.014409898780286312, -0.03980734199285507, -0.046064894646406174, -0.04235704243183136, 0.001244312385097146, -0.04804319143295288, -0.028441959992051125, -0.015370504930615425, -0.011338943615555763, 0.001290319487452507, 0.0276613961905241, -0.089361272752285, 0.011066007427871227, 0.02778383530676365, 0.011247999966144562, -0.009628058411180973, 0.002585381269454956, -0.048929646611213684, 0.003275810508057475, 0.006949851755052805, 0.02710222825407982, -0.005263741593807936, -0.03526942431926727, 0.013731420040130615, -0.007089154329150915, 0.012116006575524807, -0.03419668972492218, -0.002057458506897092, 0.08055741339921951, -0.02289697714149952, 0.04707329720258713, 0.03371259942650795, -0.03494585305452347, -0.005674928892403841, 0.05500428006052971, -0.002958059310913086, -0.03417755663394928, 0.02211625687777996, -0.017738113179802895, 0.04357174411416054, -0.029399072751402855, 0.021012622863054276, -0.001760251703672111, -0.07475781440734863, 0.011819827370345592, 0.04116164147853851, -0.016713822260499, -0.009866583161056042, -0.016146298497915268, -0.02722744829952717, 0.008297460153698921, -0.02170534059405327, -0.05757582187652588, 0.014836521819233894, 0.008512059226632118, -0.01880129985511303, 0.010600213892757893, 0.0014096986269578338, -0.00264775101095438, -0.017081981524825096, 0.049805477261543274, 0.04512985423207283, 0.07307972013950348, -0.0412435308098793, 0.05745933949947357, -0.028881113976240158, -0.03843983635306358, -0.014927866868674755, 0.00965841393917799, -0.012536139227449894, -0.011942864395678043, 0.07465393841266632, 0.004502353258430958, -0.06388480216264725, 0.061029937118291855, -0.0054524969309568405, 0.02522691711783409, -0.010713079012930393, -0.053938690572977066, -0.035277798771858215, -0.02747792936861515, 0.009200341999530792, 0.014075735583901405, -0.0537927970290184, 0.018949462100863457, 0.0068708001635968685, 0.0629761666059494, 0.019192297011613846, 0.028482461348176003, 0.018346142023801804, 0.04457032307982445, 0.022032877430319786, -0.021138383075594902, -0.026108382269740105, 0.0037390789948403835, 0.013801789842545986, -0.06372074782848358, -0.10268287360668182, 0.030163023620843887, 0.005061390344053507, -0.00976250134408474, -0.04189279302954674, 0.061372850090265274, 0.006415776442736387, -0.00618406618013978, -0.003681215224787593, 0.008321292698383331, -0.04201795533299446, 0.0816727951169014, 0.005498915910720825, 0.001759977312758565, 0.024487262591719627, 0.010704508982598782, 0.006771981716156006, -0.00291547947563231, 0.05846364051103592, 0.027020037174224854, -0.02833927795290947, 0.03790230676531792, 0.020336352288722992, -0.019519977271556854, 0.06665973365306854, 0.0008622129680588841, -0.021244367584586143, -0.02379707619547844, -0.061687760055065155, 0.036708321422338486, 0.026358911767601967, -0.02028881572186947, -0.014951297082006931, 0.036109983921051025, -0.031094713136553764, -0.029354741796851158, -0.06424600630998611, 0.01605728454887867, 0.020968057215213776, -0.01073977630585432, 0.024067774415016174, 0.019305258989334106, 0.06201539188623428, 0.005062671843916178, -0.025909239426255226, -0.0370967760682106, -0.01824762299656868, 0.02700357511639595, -0.05660790205001831, -0.025108009576797485, 0.022522134706377983, 0.03650583326816559, -0.024330973625183105, 0.059864506125450134, -0.05579200014472008, -0.0034958068281412125, -0.010364142246544361, -0.03174437955021858, 0.03783303126692772, -0.04455874115228653, -0.02408657968044281, -0.018189765512943268, -0.008817487396299839, -0.007723267190158367, 0.03112344816327095, -0.05018435791134834, 0.050274934619665146, 0.11112106591463089, 0.008987326174974442, -0.0003037452697753906, 0.014570159837603569, 0.007106751669198275, 0.030140317976474762, -0.04131335765123367, -0.042521990835666656, -0.03592493012547493, -0.0029506979044526815, 0.04129423201084137, 0.0005348759586922824, -0.004328938666731119, 0.004444630816578865, 0.03200085461139679, 0.03457395359873772, 0.0016019829781726003, 0.055913183838129044, 0.008595019578933716, 0.009657267481088638, 0.02568531408905983, 0.014457442797720432, 0.038401320576667786, -0.032941482961177826, 0.016791198402643204, -0.005090539343655109, 0.044698622077703476, 0.01679850183427334, -0.010257959365844727, 0.027647031471133232, -0.011612636037170887, -0.004674235824495554, -0.02482922002673149, 0.003434879006817937, 0.04657735675573349, 0.010836770758032799, 0.012619053944945335, 0.04195582866668701, -0.03703194856643677, -0.007173263467848301, 0.016257580369710922, -0.01294825691729784, 0.020071566104888916, 0.046658314764499664, -0.039320819079875946, 0.0038946971762925386, -0.005855812691152096, 0.0014677116414532065, 0.029071753844618797, 0.004435053560882807, -0.055468518286943436, -0.03006770648062229, 0.013534806668758392, 0.028619434684515, 0.02082703821361065, 0.014384487643837929, -0.028377152979373932, -0.02035830356180668, 0.03373795002698898, 0.015002665109932423, 0.04868529736995697, 0.025923626497387886, -0.05540494993329048, 0.0013765627518296242, 0.01387072168290615, -0.03022412583231926, 0.049292825162410736, -0.022666117176413536, -0.028363361954689026, -0.008017156273126602, -0.00536055164411664, -0.05816163495182991, -0.010828064754605293, 0.013198614120483398, 0.0004491407598834485, -0.030945004895329475, -0.01647866703569889, 0.032973889261484146, 0.013634289614856243, -0.039452411234378815, 0.027885593473911285, -0.011733422987163067, -0.024994678795337677, -0.03462808579206467, 0.022094890475273132, 0.022241774946451187, -0.009643588215112686, 0.021063564345240593, 0.026892174035310745, -0.025983382016420364, -0.006319546606391668, -0.07490792870521545, -0.032914165407419205, 0.02434203401207924, -0.0009834211086854339, 0.025890406221151352, -0.00908003281801939, 0.016486411914229393, 0.03568112477660179, 0.005368566140532494, 0.010915304534137249, -0.049237210303545, -0.0018452269723638892, -0.012071385979652405, -0.026342475786805153, -0.005252998787909746, -0.0063319639302790165, -0.032104380428791046, 0.002929115667939186, -0.01351549569517374, 0.012182040140032768, 0.08152909576892853, 0.01634870283305645, 0.015646042302250862, 0.034951094537973404, -0.01972793973982334, 0.0219744760543108, -0.004242391791194677, 0.02582056075334549, 0.011672264896333218, 0.008485696278512478, -0.0050603547133505344, -0.003182891523465514, -0.017880141735076904, -0.03889217600226402, -0.00348601839505136, -0.018436670303344727, -0.009611970745027065, -0.05055825784802437, -0.0030060820281505585, -0.0058838906697928905, -0.02828710526227951, -0.03258238732814789, 0.03833787888288498, 0.016626499593257904, -0.007988236844539642, -0.006905226036906242, 0.02243092656135559, 0.033735256642103195, 0.01669929549098015, 0.03784674406051636, -0.022249052301049232, -0.018093544989824295, 0.014027545228600502, -0.03225446864962578, 0.01196760218590498, 0.022710047662258148, 0.003895227797329426, -0.014300073496997356, -0.0031326753087341785, -0.05034248158335686, 0.007616529706865549, -0.040058284997940063, 0.01003437303006649, 0.014607556164264679, 0.04999982565641403, 0.02730788290500641, 0.0015622113132849336, 0.017056690528988838, -0.03750735521316528, 0.012500625103712082, -0.006106338929384947, -0.0850447341799736, 0.025511588901281357, -0.01611226238310337, 0.017225077375769615, 0.012090008705854416, 0.009585247375071049, 0.03805540129542351, 0.03171762451529503, -0.01698964461684227, -0.014731479808688164, -0.015832914039492607, 0.0005368360434658825, -0.007577132899314165, -0.04693237319588661, -0.02901606261730194, -0.03865475952625275, 0.01770671457052231, 0.001997261540964246, -0.02661941945552826, 0.03680185601115227, 0.013234368525445461, 0.031826313585042953, -0.00302104908041656, -0.0028514256700873375, -0.01099410466849804, 0.04249740391969681, 0.015181205235421658, 0.01969609223306179, 0.04572368413209915, -0.02349941059947014, -0.002182950032874942, 0.0016033551655709743, 0.0460742749273777, 0.05814981088042259, -0.012450212612748146, -0.03270838409662247, -0.04503734037280083, -0.009231221862137318, 0.020673466846346855, 0.003277209121733904, 0.013308307155966759, 0.004645673092454672, 0.05194130539894104, 0.04239853844046593, -0.09529353678226471, 0.019245026633143425, 0.06606166064739227, 0.01812373287975788, -0.014803769998252392, 0.011477984488010406, -0.007290022447705269, -0.009215982630848885, -0.015244059264659882, 0.01990663632750511, 0.0382050983607769, -0.0014167524641379714, 0.034005921334028244, 0.03572416305541992, -0.024408552795648575, 0.011808374896645546, -0.02183406427502632, 0.04201314598321915, 0.036977048963308334, 0.03802378848195076, -0.03905245289206505, 0.05206543207168579, 0.018550481647253036, 0.02264937199652195, 0.03640534356236458, 0.033638350665569305, -0.08926016092300415, 0.013403587974607944, 0.023113364353775978, 0.005667122080922127, -0.025593092665076256, -0.055822864174842834, -0.04013751074671745, -0.028390368446707726, 0.04388915374875069, -0.01815967634320259, 0.00879020243883133, -0.0060551040805876255, -0.012775289826095104, -0.013777541927993298, -0.021771350875496864, -0.0315629281103611, 0.05468745902180672, -0.025226600468158722, 0.027365848422050476, -0.004479280672967434, 0.004705766215920448, -0.02641923353075981, 0.029702162370085716, 0.02297176420688629, 0.06114538013935089, -0.021280106157064438, -0.031090544536709785, 0.01448918879032135, 0.028854086995124817, -0.0025844918563961983, -0.025200918316841125, -0.002871159929782152, -0.0114973783493042, 0.00040909682866185904, 0.05917934700846672, 0.007704809308052063, 0.03336397185921669, 0.01186874695122242, 0.02009575441479683, -0.0011013417970389128, 0.030938005074858665, -0.02139204740524292, 0.042823877185583115, 0.0028312744107097387, -0.0013432629639282823, 0.05239470303058624, 0.023670032620429993, -0.01477886363863945, 0.01471296139061451, -0.01496886182576418, 0.009395379573106766, 0.006473642773926258, -0.026455702260136604, -0.04218432307243347, 0.009206952527165413, 0.007703669369220734, -0.009200481697916985, -0.010183517821133137, -0.014482722617685795, -0.025960849598050117, 0.027035728096961975, 0.017651783302426338, 0.04627642035484314, 0.019499247893691063, -0.0045087579637765884, 0.017017856240272522, 0.01838502287864685, -0.010556025430560112, -0.03722279518842697, 0.029967395588755608, -0.014491554349660873, -0.03675207495689392, -0.032640859484672546, -0.03971400111913681, -0.013860390521585941, -0.045828722417354584, -0.019765758886933327, -0.00740472786128521, -0.01973998360335827, 0.029010754078626633, -0.016013052314519882, 0.05636102706193924, -0.013374785892665386, -0.026238059625029564, 0.004808328114449978, 0.06534112244844437, -0.007893647998571396, 0.015056459233164787, -0.030389107763767242, 0.04375878721475601, -0.014397363178431988, -0.01730191893875599, -0.06900252401828766, -0.04625992476940155, 0.029858876019716263, -0.03451145812869072, -0.042942509055137634, -0.017425600439310074, 0.025860566645860672, -0.006874349433928728, -0.021758390590548515, -0.025433631613850594, 0.04642750695347786, -0.0017128471517935395, 0.012083932757377625, -0.023035312071442604, 0.026021216064691544, 0.04580996558070183, -0.020611630752682686, 0.0172440093010664, 0.022819846868515015, -0.03997453674674034, -0.0278916172683239, -0.009076823480427265, 0.022130344063043594, -0.04543932527303696, 0.008615649305284023, -0.023396531119942665, -0.003957854118198156, 0.03640429675579071, -0.017483064904808998, -0.03624770790338516, 0.0005659438320435584, -0.019894873723387718, 0.019757218658924103, -0.03241565823554993, 0.004609942901879549, -0.034193769097328186, 0.014781077392399311, -0.060465943068265915, 0.019465871155261993, -0.010287219658493996, -0.0068753487430512905, 0.029492150992155075, 0.0005102008581161499, 0.0002592060773167759, 0.014988582581281662, 0.04317682236433029, -0.011713729240000248, 0.007877885363996029, -0.025793539360165596, -0.014927192591130733, 0.034862808883190155, 0.010693932883441448, -0.02649000845849514, -0.008978228084743023, -0.009176261723041534, -0.021465672180056572, 0.00022578667267225683, -0.027299445122480392, 0.02405954897403717, 0.058225445449352264, -0.02649434097111225, 0.054148636758327484, 0.06820463389158249, 0.006837801542133093, 0.00917820818722248, -0.011792413890361786, 0.0004408483218867332, -0.012258131057024002, -0.021990491077303886, 0.05544600635766983, -0.02774173766374588, -0.032383810728788376, 0.03958745300769806, 0.04517639800906181, 0.016519466415047646, 0.07802549004554749, -0.02555324323475361, 0.0014614913379773498, 0.04600627347826958, 0.005504104774445295, -0.02210824191570282, 0.04389086738228798, -0.02041161060333252, 0.01591680385172367, -0.020519621670246124, -0.047908149659633636, 0.01008608192205429, 0.037084925919771194, -0.0022133891470730305, -0.023144619539380074, -0.02660275623202324, -0.06466523557901382, 0.018658697605133057, 0.026235012337565422, -0.03865118324756622, 0.039008863270282745, 0.04633112624287605, 0.006610706448554993, 0.0252684373408556, -0.013238530606031418, -0.047707051038742065, -0.08775867521762848, -0.019246013835072517, -0.04074043408036232, -0.0062347943894565105, -0.00383775238879025, 0.026821915060281754, -0.03557116910815239, 0.02381894923746586, -0.02863551303744316, -0.018029412254691124, 0.011396540328860283, 0.016593601554632187, 0.022251054644584656, 0.10172979533672333, -0.027144096791744232, 0.0060734194703400135, -0.00942662637680769, 0.003325867932289839, 0.09284187108278275, 0.11048410087823868, 0.035807594656944275, -0.06620834022760391, 0.015132625587284565, 0.014017442241311073, -0.012182465754449368, -0.024598658084869385, 0.016824843361973763, 0.029119350016117096, -0.060610149055719376, 0.0384439192712307, 0.048691730946302414, -0.014010945335030556, 0.004299893043935299, 0.07257646322250366, -0.018952975049614906, -0.008917379193007946, -0.02492838352918625, 0.0064830053597688675, 0.003557453164830804, -0.012414565309882164, -0.04429515823721886, 0.014784367755055428, -0.013239556923508644, -0.033579252660274506, -0.025457173585891724, -0.04633113741874695, 0.01178774144500494, 0.018801448866724968, -0.01315615326166153, 0.014400823973119259, 0.025101885199546814, 0.01981770247220993, -0.0017833486199378967, -0.04098431020975113, 0.004657752811908722, -0.028335001319646835, 0.03018522821366787, 0.0265527181327343, 0.010981814935803413, 0.01070492621511221, -0.020160218700766563, 0.00018475405522622168, -0.007120554335415363, -0.03970402106642723, -0.0302304457873106, 0.035667650401592255, -0.023136844858527184, 0.027579059824347496, -0.02041616477072239, 0.009445547126233578, 0.032676663249731064, 0.0007527031702920794, -0.02789522521197796, 0.002727484330534935, 0.04126964882016182, 0.009821541607379913, 0.033052828162908554, -0.052647579461336136, -0.004170694854110479, 0.008914516307413578, 0.017431331798434258, 0.03603116050362587, -0.08580604940652847, 0.003826688276603818, -0.04425975680351257, 0.03935909643769264, 0.0088599668815732, -0.02070315182209015, 0.0204971544444561, -0.028296049684286118, -0.02028764598071575, -0.02203821949660778, -0.01251993142068386, -0.01569027081131935, 0.00925129372626543, -0.023830337449908257, -0.007473919074982405, 0.009101180359721184, -0.03894774615764618, -0.01752043142914772, -0.013694685883820057, 0.0014131596544757485, -0.057256679981946945, -0.004065380431711674, 0.04510261490941048, 0.011665618047118187, -0.007684275507926941, 0.02432197891175747, -0.06083061173558235, 0.03776426240801811, 0.025562424212694168, -0.06278443336486816, 0.008162765763700008, -0.01878088153898716, -0.0016138206701725721, 0.015344896353781223, -0.04588654637336731, 0.04991387575864792, -0.011230598203837872, 0.009148440323770046, 0.004285013768821955, 0.031046394258737564, -0.023755498230457306, 0.022785183042287827, 0.006735306233167648, -0.06184333935379982, 0.011343039572238922, -0.032369114458560944, 0.011361262761056423, -0.013133781962096691, 0.012191275134682655, -0.018222274258732796, -0.015336972661316395, 0.01100233756005764, -0.0075484225526452065, -0.02457929588854313, 0.021944543346762657, -0.00001003555917122867, -0.02153470553457737, -0.018039826303720474, 0.004453599452972412, -0.03916379064321518, -0.00544803636148572, -0.0075090243481099606, -0.013807511888444424, 0.002052469179034233, 0.024009019136428833, -0.010309001430869102, 0.027750156819820404, -0.024102404713630676, 0.013669498264789581, 0.028355980291962624, 0.02339346520602703, 0.03804467245936394, -0.00880853459239006, 0.035503633320331573, -0.018944736570119858, -0.015301217325031757, 0.01977458968758583, -0.0034784418530762196, -0.013881810940802097, -0.010649505071341991, 0.011171082966029644, 0.020917881280183792, 0.004068745765835047, -0.008273263461887836, 0.024687591940164566, 0.030857158824801445, -0.017864210531115532, 0.006619613617658615, -0.029109343886375427, 0.03743089735507965, 0.0000014526486893373658, 0.007302834652364254, -0.008460594341158867, 0.042640626430511475, 0.0003121922491118312, 0.0002460507384967059, 0.04720306769013405, 0.02044042758643627, -0.014421317726373672, 0.012917710468173027, -0.020035238936543465, 0.013260162435472012, 0.027385057881474495, 0.013470481149852276, 0.08274804800748825, 0.05200089514255524, -0.00847108568996191, 0.036185432225465775, -0.00891254935413599, 0.010162138380110264, -0.06002100184559822, -0.007478652521967888, 0.011609396897256374, -0.017243564128875732, 0.05013088509440422, -0.026493646204471588, -0.0170377716422081, 0.0149186160415411, -0.027171995490789413, 0.03677269071340561, -0.02262544445693493, 0.019545769318938255, -0.04722215235233307, -0.0018828172469511628, -0.016732508316636086, 0.03319821506738663, 0.03438003733754158, 0.014151575975120068, 0.027032863348722458, 0.02458811178803444, 0.014676447957754135, -0.020455921068787575, 0.013864009641110897, -0.017002152279019356, 0.021905820816755295, -0.08011539280414581, 0.030586756765842438, -0.030740918591618538, -0.004143845289945602, 0.006931062787771225, -0.027791157364845276, -0.020429175347089767, 0.022972628474235535, 0.038248997181653976, 0.005590086802840233, 0.054783254861831665, 0.02692531794309616, 0.012565870769321918, 0.01944761909544468, -0.025305822491645813, -0.0030817599035799503, 0.009973839856684208, -0.030891643837094307, 0.01992678828537464, 0.03626228868961334, -0.039337411522865295, -0.04714271426200867, 0.008654717355966568, -0.010348349809646606, -0.00873478315770626, -0.021862072870135307, -0.032635003328323364, 0.02244221605360508, -0.007040136959403753, 0.037232134491205215, -0.03278476372361183, 0.007866104133427143, 0.05576048418879509, 0.027645358815789223, 0.006323641631752253, 0.004814759362488985, -0.04771175608038902, -0.062020521610975266, 0.01469963788986206, 0.010229576379060745, 0.0029180997516959906, -0.06522095203399658, 0.003992360085248947, -0.011803662404417992, -0.031879112124443054, -0.03588248789310455, 0.009904082864522934, -0.04068310931324959, 0.030378207564353943, -0.03910958766937256, -0.03221402317285538, 0.05068521201610565, -0.005295277573168278, 0.053000640124082565, -0.05307077616453171, 0.06915131211280823, -0.01310762483626604, -0.02245616726577282, -0.034682583063840866, -0.010494057089090347, -0.024271221831440926, -0.006539902184158564, 0.029551560059189796, -0.03798363357782364, 0.0011976024834439158, -0.01559709757566452, 0.07253699749708176, 0.00471316697075963, -0.02038348838686943, 0.0564044751226902, 0.011954009532928467, -0.02528773993253708, -0.014176838099956512, 0.02295585535466671, 0.007525546941906214, 0.024530308321118355, 0.012387148104608059, -0.036032430827617645, 0.026266159489750862, 0.029124034568667412, -0.03470449522137642, -0.030271967872977257, 0.026687102392315865, -0.04357960820198059, 0.02914552018046379, -0.014513684436678886, 0.018359385430812836, 0.04067635536193848, 0.014421404339373112, -0.034553706645965576, 0.057806313037872314, -0.05035298317670822, -0.033563900738954544, 0.029470106586813927, 0.0018240424105897546, -0.038601625710725784, -0.06886840611696243, 0.0029823128134012222, 0.0004387158842291683, 0.0000035333891901245806, -0.022660737857222557, 0.007968216203153133, 0.003230008529499173, 0.05515911430120468, -0.014561754651367664, -0.03345243260264397, -0.014836742542684078, 0.03194383531808853, 0.004555083345621824, 0.013645258732140064, 0.05453350394964218, -0.03381677716970444, -0.01541006937623024, 0.00555037148296833, -0.02667079120874405, 0.03727000951766968, -0.04062739014625549, 0.028870312497019768, -0.0384918712079525, -0.008883873000741005, -0.0026900700759142637, 0.004633266944438219, 0.033692654222249985, 0.016833316534757614, -0.016386572271585464, 0.0357019267976284, -0.011573713272809982, 0.0363600067794323, 0.005161341279745102, -0.044272590428590775, -0.0572705939412117, -0.010714820586144924, 0.03412885591387749, 0.05045972764492035, 0.0060747237876057625, -0.01593063771724701, 0.03214797377586365, 0.012178060598671436, 0.023301687091588974, -0.014199654571712017, 0.053051095455884933, -0.0033283308148384094, -0.006102722138166428, -0.021662959828972816, -0.04471658542752266, -0.02198251150548458, -0.02155749313533306, 0.023656923323869705, 0.03813013806939125, 0.0514632947742939, -0.0033678847830742598, -0.020412538200616837, -0.015587493777275085, 0.0096370168030262, -0.07457568496465683, -0.0031547127291560173, -0.03388121724128723, 0.00882180966436863, -0.024061476811766624, 0.010761073790490627 ]
<p>I would like to know how to move forward in establishing a baseline on multiple observed years of retrospective data. My intent is to first identify the 10% of a given group to include in a study, and then establish a baseline.</p> <p>One concern of the data is that some observations may have an extremely large score in one year due to "bad luck". To attempt to take this into account, what I had done was look back at three years of data, and ranked each observation from lowest to highest (in a year). I then summed the ranks across three years, which would get me a final "ranking". I then took the highest 10%. My question is, would it be wise to use the mean as baseline given that some observations actually had a lower score in the third year OR should I use the third year score as "baseline"? If neither, what would be a better way of establishing a baseline?</p> <p>I've provided some code to replicate what I have done thus far. </p> <p>Thanks in advance.</p> <p>X1-X3: year 1, year 2, year 3 <br> x1.1 - x3.1: year 1 rank, year 2 rank, year 3 rank <br> total: total sum for year 1, year2 and year 3. <br> mean: mean of year 1, year2 and year 3. rank: final ranking</p> <pre><code>x = c('dplyr', 'ggplot2') lapply(x, require, character.only=T) props = function(ncol, nrow, var.names=NULL){ if (ncol &lt; 2) stop("ncol must be greater than 1") p = function(n){ y = 1 z = sapply(seq_len(n), function(i) { x = sample(seq(0, 10000-y, by = 1), 1) y = y + x return(x) } ) w = c(z) return(w) } DF = data.frame(t(replicate(nrow, p(n = ncol)))) if (!is.null(var.names)) colnames(DF) = var.names return(DF) } set.seed(9213) df = props(ncol = 3, nrow = 100) df$id = rownames(df) df = df[,c(ncol(df),1:(ncol(df)-1))] df.w = data.frame(df, apply(df[2:4], 2, rank, ties.method = 'min')) df.rank = df.w %.% group_by(id, X1, X2, X3, X1.1, X2.1 , X3.1) %.% summarise( total = sum(c(X1, X2 , X3)), mean = mean(c(X1, X2 , X3)), rank = sum(c(X1.1, X2.1 , X3.1))) %.% arrange(id) df.rank$rank = rank(df.rank$rank, ties.method = 'min') df.rank = df.rank[order(df.rank$rank), ] percent.10 = subset(df.rank, rank &gt; quantile(rank, prob = 1 - 10/100)) </code></pre>
73,429
[ -0.02698899805545807, -0.021570945158600807, 0.008057987317442894, -0.0074997879564762115, 0.04094970226287842, 0.006404417101293802, -0.0383552722632885, -0.031029077246785164, 0.027246873825788498, -0.046953100711107254, 0.03648542985320091, 0.06541961431503296, 0.04855135455727577, 0.019541436806321144, 0.038044195622205734, 0.005025947000831366, -0.016773346811532974, 0.0243671927601099, -0.019681815057992935, 0.0050402311608195305, -0.018099995329976082, 0.015058577060699463, -0.008110924623906612, 0.013560484163463116, -0.024893052875995636, 0.019557369872927666, 0.017412245273590088, -0.02732083946466446, -0.0027339316438883543, 0.05532976612448692, -0.06815963238477707, 0.004690864589065313, 0.025381900370121002, -0.008920060470700264, 0.04204859957098961, 0.02447461523115635, -0.019287515431642532, -0.007484888657927513, 0.013377353549003601, 0.034840021282434464, -0.026704227551817894, -0.008224403485655785, -0.008373570628464222, 0.010983598418533802, -0.012033850885927677, 0.02878553979098797, -0.023867689073085785, 0.011127066798508167, 0.0327889509499073, -0.04445115476846695, 0.006333916913717985, 0.01354706659913063, 0.02122015506029129, 0.04296208545565605, -0.062169596552848816, -0.020282015204429626, 0.07013566046953201, 0.043830618262290955, 0.03727865219116211, -0.021852806210517883, 0.04627074673771858, -0.06714660674333572, -0.02641577459871769, 0.018681956455111504, -0.02587858773767948, 0.019007956609129906, 0.008811727166175842, 0.019010907039046288, 0.027307597920298576, -0.025847896933555603, 0.01787702552974224, -0.009335893206298351, 0.004057812038809061, -0.01024281233549118, 0.013107279315590858, 0.0038939679507166147, 0.007853669114410877, -0.03839956969022751, 0.039360836148262024, 0.015025162138044834, -0.021844735369086266, 0.005013434216380119, 0.04567595198750496, 0.057551875710487366, 0.02430928312242031, 0.002781494054943323, 0.058229926973581314, -0.04537958279252052, 0.028803739696741104, 0.05756352096796036, 0.03319234028458595, -0.004123142454773188, 0.04971983656287193, 0.020665409043431282, -0.017309363931417465, -0.009751864708960056, -0.013713053427636623, 0.034519072622060776, 0.007310193497687578, 0.017434408888220787, -0.01926996000111103, -0.045203566551208496, 0.013941300101578236, 0.036063019186258316, -0.04064643010497093, 0.004224768374115229, -0.05663936957716942, -0.01698331907391548, -0.032859932631254196, -0.024079687893390656, -0.0300612673163414, 0.039323385804891586, -0.025520557537674904, -0.04758518189191818, 0.018224336206912994, -0.038923636078834534, 0.00975820142775774, 0.016895044595003128, 0.06080345809459686, 0.03737333044409752, 0.025317320600152016, -0.009608686901628971, 0.009291501715779305, -0.02709505893290043, -0.014705300331115723, 0.0030542761087417603, 0.025739530101418495, -0.005883157253265381, -0.007389593403786421, 0.03873543441295624, 0.001488939975388348, -0.009006435051560402, 0.08024570345878601, 0.00495307520031929, 0.05321674421429634, 0.008798067457973957, -0.0838347002863884, -0.04858273267745972, 0.03851956129074097, -0.03125292807817459, 0.03650052100419998, -0.06427544355392456, -0.0028971335850656033, -0.006684665568172932, 0.022705569863319397, 0.024117620661854744, 0.01574328914284706, 0.03378773108124733, 0.02235058881342411, -0.021180391311645508, -0.0067817759700119495, -0.026301251724362373, -0.01900884509086609, -0.01899939961731434, -0.028664495795965195, -0.07307963073253632, 0.0780215710401535, -0.0288357175886631, -0.0021065548062324524, -0.010601893067359924, 0.04380177706480026, -0.000570334552321583, 0.02504945732653141, -0.00829680822789669, 0.017862435430288315, -0.007499370723962784, 0.02359502762556076, 0.011074483394622803, 0.02944113314151764, 0.024086041375994682, -0.04890359938144684, 0.0007724558236077428, -0.009840131737291813, 0.01571832038462162, 0.022775594145059586, -0.03269213065505028, 0.027062073349952698, -0.03577191010117531, -0.00013636157382279634, 0.022788766771554947, -0.024602361023426056, -0.040378980338573456, -0.004770941566675901, -0.024345319718122482, 0.010787975043058395, -0.009378572925925255, -0.003270480316132307, -0.007725937757641077, 0.058772012591362, -0.02289871871471405, -0.053638212382793427, -0.10604565590620041, -0.017718473449349403, 0.03405873104929924, -0.06498026847839355, -0.030817877501249313, 0.0011675599962472916, 0.061101801693439484, -0.006888184696435928, -0.009680092334747314, -0.01664445735514164, 0.016219964250922203, 0.056756556034088135, -0.03149479627609253, -0.02402466908097267, 0.056816715747117996, 0.05202176049351692, -0.007365834899246693, 0.03407060727477074, -0.05680567026138306, -0.01953667588531971, 0.013737639412283897, -0.0012266201665624976, 0.030613012611865997, 0.018677128478884697, -0.03143514320254326, 0.042031653225421906, -0.004407677333801985, -0.015354039147496223, 0.03741537779569626, -0.06016725301742554, 0.054592330008745193, 0.06863273680210114, 0.0077018034644424915, 0.015652203932404518, -0.04602936655282974, 0.03312595188617706, 0.01652868464589119, -0.014732014387845993, 0.02190227434039116, -0.05447123944759369, -0.04001731425523758, 0.043971553444862366, 0.04625752195715904, -0.016648488119244576, 0.01131066307425499, 0.04684947431087494, -0.05850660428404808, 0.03044254146516323, 0.023947186768054962, 0.025930779054760933, -0.04586941748857498, -0.016413433477282524, 0.03980252891778946, 0.0216140765696764, -0.006165674887597561, 0.02982727438211441, 0.00020572355424519628, 0.05673404783010483, 0.03378906100988388, -0.011565987952053547, 0.030390096828341484, 0.020365098491311073, 0.012486784718930721, 0.013391172513365746, -0.029421953484416008, 0.0489906407892704, -0.0394195020198822, 0.02340935356914997, 0.043966297060251236, 0.014758766628801823, 0.004587436094880104, 0.02400112710893154, -0.01467886846512556, -0.0184903796762228, 0.036378175020217896, -0.06390643864870071, 0.020296642556786537, 0.023572932928800583, 0.01630786620080471, 0.015130642801523209, -0.03178765997290611, -0.050673142075538635, -0.04299132898449898, 0.007799473125487566, 0.01915200613439083, -0.025724930688738823, 0.017226053401827812, -0.027473384514451027, -0.02832830883562565, 0.0021197590976953506, -0.01711941324174404, -0.011533464305102825, 0.05396445840597153, -0.06924927979707718, -0.028758207336068153, 0.009558686055243015, -0.005366029683500528, 0.030469683930277824, 0.0021700907964259386, -0.0405905582010746, 0.051527149975299835, 0.029699044302105904, -0.04985329136252403, -0.03221769258379936, -0.04884229227900505, -0.02143918164074421, -0.005058503244072199, -0.01140339020639658, 0.05531082674860954, 0.02408182993531227, -0.044914018362760544, -0.012338453903794289, -0.04858054220676422, 0.00749578233808279, 0.008083418011665344, -0.0011956895468756557, -0.017908653244376183, 0.016059227287769318, -0.020838061347603798, 0.005538219586014748, 0.002384898252785206, -0.0009109655511565506, -0.03272299841046333, -0.03653709962964058, 0.025872619822621346, 0.004125415347516537, 0.04820069298148155, -0.030389944091439247, 0.020848171785473824, 0.07364536076784134, 0.04551618918776512, -0.007397469133138657, -0.08133489638566971, -0.01752001792192459, 0.01677510142326355, -0.029759665951132774, 0.02153399959206581, 0.02230840176343918, 0.016418607905507088, -0.018998883664608, -0.015811016783118248, 0.009213170036673546, 0.042055923491716385, -0.019673600792884827, 0.0232833418995142, 0.011977926827967167, 0.03667571768164635, -0.02648635022342205, 0.07353203743696213, 0.0342310406267643, -0.014703171327710152, 0.003967741969972849, -0.020883232355117798, 0.021892713382840157, -0.03037096932530403, -0.06500420719385147, 0.0182232316583395, -0.019608236849308014, 0.04873879998922348, -0.010507059283554554, 0.03360080346465111, 0.05095955729484558, -0.05996426194906235, -0.0016758257988840342, -0.0394236259162426, 0.019981088116765022, -0.010808129794895649, 0.014554137364029884, 0.019739925861358643, 0.01247523631900549, -0.03289039060473442, 0.04205150529742241, -0.022423284128308296, -0.03655911609530449, 0.026403794065117836, -0.04310472309589386, 0.026790864765644073, 0.0305581483989954, 0.07342317700386047, -0.007158270105719566, 0.00775171909481287, -0.03171578794717789, 0.012903080321848392, -0.04043116793036461, 0.008409651927649975, -0.03922540694475174, 0.050782546401023865, 0.0178176611661911, 0.018880028277635574, 0.017225876450538635, -0.026114393025636673, 0.013338358141481876, -0.009055736474692822, -0.049647171050310135, 0.0029010858852416277, 0.020089566707611084, 0.014893864281475544, -0.009014534763991833, -0.026246190071105957, 0.0008355543250218034, 0.011803638190031052, 0.024622071534395218, 0.01648937538266182, 0.026540344581007957, -0.02458883263170719, 0.01812911219894886, -0.021612906828522682, 0.021186616271734238, -0.0032317882869392633, 0.01569060981273651, 0.02359713241457939, -0.008825833909213543, 0.044493868947029114, 0.005368806887418032, -0.006442241370677948, 0.001663037808611989, 0.0015415927628055215, 0.009147807024419308, 0.04068344458937645, 0.017046088352799416, -0.004866075702011585, 0.024277344346046448, -0.021236805245280266, 0.004775908775627613, -0.0004953727475367486, 0.021025214344263077, 0.05239763855934143, -0.0012732482282444835, 0.016296524554491043, -0.0034658892545849085, 0.0023470986634492874, 0.043360307812690735, 0.017672725021839142, 0.005968152079731226, -0.026226243004202843, 0.012955992482602596, 0.044221099466085434, -0.018903309479355812, 0.02391209453344345, 0.04159093275666237, 0.024510661140084267, 0.009270219132304192, -0.030606413260102272, -0.002741738222539425, -0.005463356152176857, -0.019970284774899483, 0.04124334082007408, -0.003380934940651059, 0.006888244301080704, -0.002131877699866891, 0.011301529593765736, -0.03350146487355232, -0.040723979473114014, 0.024147726595401764, 0.008809692226350307, 0.08859565854072571, -0.009333890862762928, -0.050454407930374146, -0.008353161625564098, 0.023672712966799736, 0.0504520907998085, 0.0026628298219293356, -0.03348973020911217, -0.09316989779472351, -0.01830943673849106, 0.06596219539642334, 0.05864734947681427, -0.033983953297138214, -0.04088142141699791, -0.05898895487189293, -0.01976032741367817, -0.004972016904503107, -0.04363042488694191, -0.02732125297188759, -0.04737348109483719, -0.00658769067376852, -0.030130192637443542, -0.050308771431446075, -0.055983856320381165, 0.025344964116811752, -0.06160722300410271, 0.02631979063153267, -0.009079720824956894, -0.016101369634270668, -0.02952289953827858, 0.013436452485620975, 0.007825605571269989, 0.014376720413565636, -0.020084351301193237, -0.02689540572464466, 0.023895742371678352, 0.0030451426282525063, -0.02189786173403263, -0.03269997611641884, 0.03903435543179512, 0.001410578261129558, 0.043362658470869064, 0.029117371886968613, 0.003259026212617755, -0.008589629083871841, 0.002971955109387636, 0.012401923537254333, -0.006673114839941263, 0.019611546769738197, 0.02264188975095749, 0.042394768446683884, 0.055444538593292236, -0.022197257727384567, 0.06049909442663193, 0.012134167365729809, -0.0006312048644758761, 0.046824634075164795, -0.01802155189216137, -0.015294564887881279, -0.040757570415735245, -0.014788051135838032, -0.05504186823964119, -0.04607938975095749, -0.011592328548431396, 0.019603880122303963, -0.005927548743784428, 0.03739025816321373, -0.048470787703990936, -0.007866060361266136, 0.08072658628225327, -0.012049242854118347, 0.02388998493552208, -0.026221472769975662, 0.0030443468131124973, -0.013476135209202766, 0.004775847773998976, -0.006013832055032253, 0.04095137119293213, -0.0032192931976169348, -0.0030176870059221983, -0.005184457171708345, -0.06056129187345505, 0.051046811044216156, 0.002742704702541232, -0.008818182162940502, 0.0003784620203077793, -0.01068966370075941, 0.03788929060101509, -0.013184959068894386, 0.03835932910442352, 0.020491039380431175, -0.018267586827278137, -0.02636905014514923, 0.031846784055233, -0.0053554316982626915, -0.020567966625094414, -0.01433044858276844, 0.023607958108186722, 0.006130936089903116, 0.009731194004416466, -0.004033097997307777, -0.015079089440405369, -0.005308380350470543, 0.03519792482256889, -0.01919858157634735, 0.005864559207111597, -0.01409723050892353, 0.0005989946075715125, 0.014699848368763924, -0.02324972301721573, 0.0021711818408221006, -0.036001548171043396, -0.001635941443964839, -0.017128467559814453, 0.008094425313174725, 0.09188612550497055, -0.033966924995183945, -0.012916420586407185, 0.038418080657720566, -0.02682926133275032, -0.02794433757662773, -0.0462399497628212, -0.017310483381152153, -0.03223709762096405, 0.027054185047745705, -0.019437335431575775, 0.003945980221033096, 0.06999993324279785, -0.0003088168741669506, -0.05585864931344986, 0.028240621089935303, -0.029798412695527077, 0.031744007021188736, -0.06418073177337646, -0.002772383624687791, -0.06999952346086502, 0.01974939927458763, -0.03712426871061325, 0.005528977606445551, 0.004036145284771919, -0.008989510126411915, 0.0007268244517035782, -0.010354849509894848, 0.002319341991096735, 0.004221638664603233, 0.04009605199098587, -0.012691960670053959, -0.010107454843819141, -0.033578336238861084, -0.03021583892405033, 0.006223622243851423, 0.02597162127494812, -0.005042007192969322, 0.026122795417904854, -0.0015338059747591615, 0.00044217469985596836, -0.0008604608592577279, -0.026397228240966797, 0.013793949969112873, 0.05749233439564705, 0.012515220791101456, 0.021564416587352753, 0.03524180129170418, -0.013953525573015213, 0.026254894211888313, -0.02402961067855358, -0.004832621198147535, -0.028658956289291382, 0.018648669123649597, 0.0678938776254654, -0.01589297503232956, -0.017184961587190628, 0.04318996146321297, -0.02618701383471489, 0.026631280779838562, 0.05491795018315315, 0.024751946330070496, -0.026316974312067032, 0.00037897744914516807, -0.031698670238256454, -0.027662022039294243, 0.01098089199513197, -0.046928368508815765, 0.002689808141440153, -0.03410502150654793, -0.035700492560863495, -0.018725387752056122, 0.042300038039684296, -0.029574280604720116, -0.03197910636663437, -0.026278985664248466, -0.05791965872049332, -0.019067304208874702, 0.04805658385157585, -0.032866138964891434, 0.02001434937119484, 0.012422014959156513, 0.045543599873781204, 0.01480537187308073, 0.033201366662979126, -0.06142968684434891, -0.04763141646981239, -0.02195458486676216, -0.006792092230170965, -0.06098636984825134, -0.022082917392253876, 0.0016469856491312385, -0.019978031516075134, 0.008645358495414257, -0.0495326928794384, 0.0017745917430147529, -0.01124928891658783, 0.05837520584464073, 0.0018947841599583626, 0.07486636191606522, 0.042001351714134216, 0.026639878749847412, 0.006709942128509283, -0.014031180180609226, 0.1437462866306305, 0.06780407577753067, 0.06144323945045471, -0.060874201357364655, 0.023815330117940903, 0.07125116139650345, 0.01128431037068367, -0.03375106677412987, -0.006677211262285709, -0.0055584535002708435, -0.012378661893308163, 0.06717850267887115, 0.034369394183158875, -0.021767791360616684, 0.002048587193712592, 0.06656011939048767, -0.02290835604071617, -0.011966265738010406, -0.02991592139005661, 0.006995739880949259, -0.005060269497334957, -0.030194828286767006, -0.03261417895555496, 0.0029456992633640766, 0.045280106365680695, -0.010708315297961235, -0.023769157007336617, 0.010320276021957397, -0.013608723878860474, 0.03471210598945618, -0.0065758805721998215, 0.029079843312501907, -0.006336991675198078, -0.0033545808400958776, -0.014421199448406696, -0.04557633772492409, 0.03464004397392273, -0.028168795630335808, 0.03094104863703251, 0.010778019204735756, -0.022998906672000885, 0.012862331233918667, -0.029850881546735764, 0.012043504044413567, -0.05891959369182587, -0.01685796119272709, -0.015138516202569008, 0.037360720336437225, -0.016554800793528557, -0.010194269008934498, -0.022959169000387192, -0.0011032689362764359, -0.0134068438783288, -0.021620484068989754, -0.030194351449608803, 0.03530061990022659, 0.03474266454577446, -0.04239264503121376, -0.003206010442227125, -0.012655237689614296, 0.009140226989984512, -0.014502085745334625, 0.056627023965120316, 0.004325578920543194, -0.0020016785711050034, -0.02937246300280094, -0.05510532855987549, 0.03411370515823364, -0.027408521622419357, 0.014343940652906895, 0.01606524921953678, -0.01742856204509735, -0.05055871605873108, -0.045630235224962234, 0.024312835186719894, -0.002424475736916065, 0.00969978142529726, 0.0096446443349123, 0.027016695588827133, -0.033006731420755386, -0.0270053930580616, 0.019764825701713562, -0.027025796473026276, 0.02442060597240925, -0.017368020489811897, -0.015848957002162933, 0.0203496515750885, 0.00704366248100996, 0.009979410097002983, 0.026034045964479446, -0.005933407694101334, 0.07196732610464096, 0.0306963212788105, -0.007526118773967028, -0.02188165858387947, -0.009211014956235886, -0.04438769072294235, -0.003240742487832904, -0.04373578354716301, 0.057206906378269196, 0.03364574909210205, 0.007385351695120335, 0.014510552398860455, 0.0065949177369475365, 0.0067218514159321785, -0.004481186158955097, 0.030589673668146133, -0.08637047559022903, 0.04722350090742111, -0.006094337906688452, -0.005334535613656044, -0.02664547972381115, -0.03467511758208275, -0.0025912998244166374, -0.019267184659838676, -0.009907008148729801, -0.024753747507929802, -0.002854776568710804, 0.02920663170516491, -0.007520543411374092, 0.01603928580880165, -0.012277132831513882, -0.009464558213949203, -0.040801629424095154, 0.0055268253199756145, -0.03020615689456463, -0.019817156717181206, -0.029749110341072083, 0.022979434579610825, -0.02937428094446659, 0.024632714688777924, 0.04059060662984848, -0.026536211371421814, 0.014270732179284096, -0.006822735071182251, 0.017987944185733795, 0.004624864086508751, 0.06168140098452568, 0.015327677130699158, -0.001003741635940969, 0.01341400295495987, -0.05217257887125015, -0.03975900262594223, -0.007706290110945702, 0.058697089552879333, 0.003958351910114288, 0.01290762610733509, 0.014512705616652966, -0.020352404564619064, 0.020979220047593117, -0.02485649846494198, -0.041019510477781296, -0.03380019590258598, 0.0035544021520763636, 0.05007581040263176, -0.004243738483637571, 0.023450518026947975, 0.011808769777417183, 0.010265709832310677, 0.003406060393899679, 0.04036591202020645, -0.016845766454935074, 0.026605291292071342, -0.010328465141355991, -0.02827126905322075, -0.018986990675330162, -0.010628435760736465, 0.01690681464970112, 0.03231459856033325, 0.048402078449726105, -0.04516132175922394, 0.04771135747432709, -0.002206889446824789, 0.0021916390396654606, -0.056683801114559174, -0.022696731612086296, 0.0020213716197758913, -0.024053173139691353, 0.017070654779672623, -0.047356802970170975, -0.0029186124447733164, 0.025349674746394157, -0.01998063176870346, 0.024118132889270782, 0.016919581219553947, 0.007254462223500013, -0.02297336608171463, 0.04552851617336273, 0.016454221680760384, -0.014636460691690445, -0.001332232728600502, 0.02319163829088211, 0.032793693244457245, 0.06604509055614471, 0.028933662921190262, -0.03155181556940079, -0.03443516045808792, -0.010983933694660664, -0.012566483579576015, -0.07312150299549103, -0.00862396601587534, -0.05225321277976036, -0.013420958071947098, 0.03182464838027954, 0.0001207861423608847, 0.05391580983996391, -0.004724475555121899, 0.01812613196671009, 0.015587642788887024, 0.04059629887342453, 0.0015983430203050375, 0.004397342912852764, -0.00821841973811388, -0.016116227954626083, 0.018978789448738098, 0.0070124720223248005, -0.0007542740786448121, 0.014019191265106201, 0.0349433608353138, -0.009158612228929996, -0.025423891842365265, -0.004496610723435879, -0.0077697765082120895, 0.016312815248966217, 0.013389194384217262, -0.00100146874319762, -0.000832875317428261, -0.008428176864981651, -0.001634064712561667, -0.00994888599961996, -0.013851981610059738, 0.06203673034906387, 0.027019796893000603, -0.01229081116616726, 0.015717191621661186, 0.002825804753229022, -0.03346574679017067, -0.027996394783258438, -0.024883732199668884, 0.009476738050580025, -0.04612961784005165, -0.017509980127215385, 0.010839990340173244, -0.0245955977588892, -0.018191151320934296, -0.019620729610323906, -0.024844741448760033, 0.05829456076025963, -0.03994077444076538, 0.013282089494168758, 0.020519692450761795, 0.029685350134968758, 0.020066838711500168, -0.09418532252311707, 0.047429151833057404, 0.004342931788414717, -0.017462175339460373, -0.020268749445676804, -0.021936869248747826, -0.030655045062303543, 0.01267209928482771, 0.020817063748836517, 0.008286253549158573, 0.0011401093797758222, -0.02906235307455063, 0.03495919704437256, 0.007861376740038395, -0.05956575646996498, 0.055837929248809814, -0.009572598151862621, 0.006182660348713398, -0.0018313812324777246, -0.009319419972598553, 0.0322624146938324, -0.002301823813468218, 0.030813343822956085, -0.028037691488862038, -0.002404151950031519, 0.03716405853629112, -0.002280713291838765, 0.022419435903429985, -0.0002644793421495706, -0.045377157628536224, 0.012489392422139645, 0.011092848144471645, 0.018889181315898895, 0.04077475517988205, -0.010388038121163845, -0.045840464532375336, 0.03826732933521271, -0.045718684792518616, -0.04164816066622734, 0.0006021818844601512, 0.004915454890578985, -0.038334399461746216, -0.06546653807163239, -0.006367035210132599, 0.02213209867477417, -0.02226121351122856, 0.04031549394130707, 0.05961267650127411, -0.00510574271902442, 0.05751218646764755, -0.02381863258779049, 0.02163590118288994, 0.001271015964448452, -0.030921943485736847, 0.008590111508965492, -0.03308380767703056, -0.01625256985425949, -0.002677349140867591, 0.008114981465041637, 0.031531237065792084, 0.007954579778015614, 0.0073536536656320095, 0.0050867171958088875, 0.05406580865383148, -0.04600556194782257, 0.02051268145442009, 0.01655885949730873, 0.013541782274842262, 0.0035410078708082438, 0.006900040898472071, 0.02209317684173584, 0.0299961119890213, -0.03784077242016792, 0.004906969144940376, -0.01812838762998581, -0.03636924549937248, -0.07731232792139053, 0.012933519668877125, -0.03266804292798042, 0.01542090717703104, -0.007208325434476137, 0.007921352051198483, -0.006661614403128624, -0.005446631461381912, 0.03983045369386673, 0.011734457686543465, 0.05755455791950226, -0.02545071206986904, 0.0013967405539005995, 0.02272065356373787, -0.02543061599135399, -0.04040718078613281, -0.022575950250029564, 0.01579110696911812, -0.021331844851374626, 0.02867250330746174, -0.033901818096637726, 0.02294071950018406, 0.022026842460036278, 0.002629673108458519, -0.034294694662094116, -0.022326339036226273, -0.06857883930206299, 0.02172337844967842, 0.024090005084872246, -0.030433062463998795 ]
<p>In maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) a useful result is that the standard errors for some estimated coefficient vector can be computed as the square roots of the diagonal entries of the inverse of the negative expected information matrix. </p> <p>In other words, let the empirical estimate <em>of the expectation</em> of the information matrix be: $$I(\theta) =-\frac{1}{N}\sum_{i=1}^{N}\mathcal{H}(Z_{i}, \theta)$$ for parameter vector $\theta$, and data points $Z_{i}$, where $\mathcal{H}(Z_{i},\theta)$ denotes the Hessian matrix of the log-likelihood function, evaluated at the single datum $Z_{i}$ and the parameter vector estimate $\theta$.</p> <p>Then the matrix given by $I(\theta)^{-1}$ contains the variance/covariance structure of the MLE estimates, and its diagonal entries in particular are the variances of the estimated MLE parameters.</p> <p>In my specific application, the $Z_{i}$ are consumer data about price preferences for different heating options, and the model is a logit probability model. I've done all the work of estimating the MLE and there are standard formulas for the derivative vector and Hessian matrix in this logit scenario. I have about 250 data samples, which is large enough that I expect the MLE estimate to be fairly accurate.</p> <p>However, when I numerically compute the information matrix and the corresponding variances, I am seeing very large numbers. The estimated coefficients range in absolute value from 0.5 to 22, but the smallest standard error is about 7.2, which makes me question what I'm doing.</p> <p>I know that the empirical estimate of the Hessians are correct, as I've used my code on a separate data set to confirm that I'm computing the derivatives and second-derivatives correctly, so I think it's unlikely to be a coding mistake.</p> <p>Does anyone have any advice on what might yield such large standard deviations in practice?</p>
35,807
[ -0.03302156552672386, 0.009646018035709858, -0.004299173131585121, 0.008156046271324158, 0.013462611474096775, 0.035229478031396866, -0.038550570607185364, -0.004875889513641596, 0.026497911661863327, -0.02960243821144104, 0.012766536325216293, 0.041160695254802704, 0.06433626264333725, 0.021407295018434525, 0.0596969835460186, 0.019771846011281013, 0.01838524453341961, 0.013402383774518967, 0.022401180118322372, 0.01212538592517376, 0.006467085797339678, 0.05736720561981201, -0.015099520795047283, -0.03365951031446457, -0.022812647745013237, 0.028981246054172516, 0.0010026703821495175, 0.01148949097841978, -0.003821730148047209, 0.06979596614837646, -0.01161058060824871, -0.024106837809085846, 0.01797843724489212, 0.035069189965724945, 0.033799365162849426, 0.007628551218658686, -0.01728098653256893, -0.03315151482820511, -0.0053284261375665665, 0.024185551330447197, -0.019651371985673904, -0.03827916830778122, -0.025991976261138916, 0.017201419919729233, -0.009920511394739151, 0.0090415570884943, 0.008919578976929188, -0.07864734530448914, 0.047653455287218094, -0.02329983562231064, 0.06684267520904541, 0.03296387195587158, 0.025046922266483307, 0.034030839800834656, -0.039273202419281006, 0.016749730333685875, 0.022385310381650925, 0.07475815713405609, -0.031063411384820938, -0.06286545097827911, 0.0013779120054095984, -0.04054313898086548, -0.013602287508547306, -0.025187157094478607, -0.02425406500697136, 0.013446331024169922, -0.015614045783877373, -0.055358100682497025, 0.04322730749845505, -0.03648034855723381, 0.026131438091397285, 0.03610822930932045, 0.013509904034435749, 0.030328955501317978, 0.020181676372885704, -0.014692596159875393, 0.026391565799713135, 0.02564595267176628, 0.026379883289337158, 0.010773015208542347, 0.02080092951655388, 0.007601215969771147, 0.01127882581204176, 0.041000183671712875, 0.005199364852160215, -0.01095858495682478, 0.0512319840490818, -0.021853100508451462, 0.032222699373960495, 0.00033767291461117566, -0.034150730818510056, 0.008399839513003826, 0.04035266116261482, -0.013612905517220497, -0.03134362772107124, 0.03214455768465996, -0.007080360781401396, 0.014519182033836842, 0.025743279606103897, -0.03410274162888527, -0.02149028331041336, -0.0070579336024820805, -0.018193107098340988, 0.024310212582349777, -0.013389095664024353, -0.00999884307384491, -0.0045066336169838905, -0.04625207930803299, 0.005607846193015575, -0.07340085506439209, 0.0045435670763254166, 0.013687271624803543, -0.008175212889909744, -0.026539396494627, -0.0024389217142015696, -0.017429200932383537, -0.04468219727277756, -0.01887715794146061, 0.019156204536557198, 0.055476196110248566, 0.04220552369952202, 0.0018310693558305502, 0.05413051322102547, -0.06409930437803268, -0.0562681183218956, 0.03031734935939312, 0.0100943548604846, -0.0141607029363513, -0.07277113944292068, 0.02287217602133751, 0.020818131044507027, -0.011630632914602757, 0.03814299777150154, 0.0008389667491428554, -0.0050901249051094055, 0.005595859605818987, -0.05041249468922615, -0.08581622689962387, 0.026222651824355125, 0.0012999054742977023, 0.024217722937464714, -0.09364045411348343, -0.041568536311388016, 0.042610183358192444, 0.0446585975587368, 0.008211980573832989, 0.06029748544096947, 0.011392115615308285, 0.0347934290766716, 0.026142815127968788, -0.052742768079042435, 0.01660303585231304, -0.036012373864650726, -0.0004889070987701416, -0.022295288741588593, -0.044477593153715134, 0.03979849815368652, 0.044441916048526764, -0.019548846408724785, 0.013938989490270615, 0.037411268800497055, 0.06232571229338646, -0.028460726141929626, 0.01798531599342823, -0.02633727341890335, -0.030987046658992767, 0.07942407578229904, -0.006448733154684305, 0.023521743714809418, 0.0168021097779274, 0.0074187591671943665, 0.024411005899310112, -0.017973795533180237, 0.04650487005710602, 0.043792277574539185, -0.015116803348064423, 0.030415553599596024, -0.031248364597558975, 0.02348199300467968, -0.008952026255428791, -0.033410172909498215, -0.026890059933066368, -0.004628217313438654, -0.030585475265979767, 0.018741285428404808, 0.04500817507505417, -0.02367592416703701, -0.03545543923974037, 0.03489568829536438, -0.05894787982106209, -0.06290920078754425, -0.027662087231874466, 0.020396364852786064, -0.015129180625081062, -0.0212154071778059, 0.03568820282816887, -0.015563080087304115, 0.026018936187028885, 0.020886333659291267, 0.0006848954944871366, 0.0081248227506876, 0.0073882099241018295, 0.0548764169216156, -0.025798553600907326, 0.033735696226358414, 0.03735717013478279, 0.04593119025230408, -0.011415872722864151, 0.0247374065220356, -0.012028071098029613, -0.06912656873464584, 0.008865525014698505, -0.04516974464058876, 0.010085049085319042, 0.02938791736960411, -0.02716328576207161, -0.0055449348874390125, -0.02441822551190853, 0.0018530457746237516, 0.03574393317103386, -0.05142549052834511, 0.019913800060749054, 0.029332447797060013, 0.008219236508011818, 0.008661155588924885, 0.03722398728132248, 0.021456226706504822, 0.049355410039424896, -0.013477377593517303, 0.009454946033656597, -0.046465400606393814, -0.008961227722465992, 0.07324379682540894, 0.042563144117593765, -0.035962317138910294, -0.01763882301747799, 0.057138703763484955, 0.03598730266094208, 0.015424809418618679, -0.013283098116517067, -0.022580649703741074, -0.015908867120742798, 0.03576480224728584, -0.00153127231169492, -0.0077436743304133415, 0.027279527857899666, 0.01594521477818489, 0.03112679533660412, 0.023808550089597702, -0.004299413878470659, 0.03975815698504448, 0.043092962354421616, -0.00835796445608139, 0.0045401244424283504, -0.016228534281253815, 0.02724514715373516, 0.05318424850702286, -0.017997248098254204, -0.04128152132034302, 0.036612365394830704, 0.024085627868771553, 0.006110209971666336, -0.009245735593140125, -0.009012197144329548, 0.03355299308896065, 0.01805204339325428, -0.026307355612516403, 0.01524613332003355, 0.03819359093904495, -0.022179124876856804, 0.04593617096543312, -0.045025598257780075, -0.01582154631614685, 0.0411674790084362, 0.007946949452161789, 0.03966052457690239, 0.003575872629880905, 0.005465719848871231, 0.009162098169326782, -0.027988210320472717, -0.0008410434238612652, -0.027763839811086655, 0.03427613526582718, 0.03797183558344841, -0.06734193861484528, -0.018100665882229805, -0.0684191957116127, -0.049368444830179214, 0.042765650898218155, 0.008282933384180069, -0.0011654726695269346, 0.03647614270448685, -0.021010994911193848, -0.03200065717101097, -0.03618632256984711, 0.012449930422008038, -0.011606413871049881, -0.01635127142071724, -0.031220126897096634, 0.03568938001990318, -0.004640347324311733, -0.02032037079334259, 0.03626680746674538, -0.05806877836585045, -0.049129024147987366, -0.014749005436897278, 0.000875374476891011, -0.0026622270233929157, 0.020974256098270416, 0.014836731366813183, 0.021326633170247078, 0.020929209887981415, -0.011351022869348526, -0.09916951507329941, -0.0798274427652359, -0.030932750552892685, 0.012912738136947155, 0.003275904105976224, 0.00024013654910959303, -0.009347223676741123, 0.07217465341091156, 0.02364233322441578, -0.03977382555603981, -0.0032558925449848175, -0.008511933498084545, -0.028146883472800255, -0.03171961382031441, 0.015823153778910637, 0.01665673963725567, 0.007418150082230568, 0.04910833388566971, 0.0036578704603016376, 0.014490238390862942, 0.012761685065925121, -0.03030841052532196, 0.0008596127736382186, 0.051300182938575745, -0.02023947238922119, -0.013174199499189854, 0.03440406918525696, 0.017842166125774384, 0.005574289709329605, 0.03137502446770668, 0.02929229475557804, 0.021286599338054657, 0.00431871647015214, -0.07085615396499634, 0.04283894598484039, -0.036080919206142426, 0.023235846310853958, -0.022497428581118584, 0.012708330526947975, 0.02038205787539482, -0.01245899312198162, -0.024423053488135338, 0.023720959201455116, 0.0044718594290316105, -0.037211596965789795, 0.02560126967728138, 0.029804706573486328, 0.022058991715312004, 0.004508257377892733, -0.0020886848215013742, -0.0380711555480957, 0.01233546994626522, -0.023212414234876633, -0.01951812021434307, -0.03205491602420807, 0.04284394904971123, 0.04039015993475914, 0.01031535305082798, -0.054193589836359024, -0.028536656871438026, 0.04747640714049339, -0.032366763800382614, 0.005191049072891474, -0.014781528152525425, 0.031984928995370865, -0.0029560516122728586, 0.012835181318223476, -0.005330240819603205, 0.006502067670226097, 0.03327992558479309, 0.01736079715192318, -0.07841147482395172, 0.021514790132641792, 0.00846742745488882, -0.01288801059126854, 0.006519020535051823, -0.04033535346388817, 0.05286909267306328, -0.011705078184604645, 0.05423615127801895, 0.04348457232117653, 0.03868443891406059, -0.048473112285137177, 0.0029359785839915276, 0.001181595609523356, 0.004012218210846186, -0.022679565474390984, 0.0011880089296028018, 0.018303927034139633, -0.003380047855898738, 0.003530177054926753, 0.025750773027539253, 0.006233554799109697, -0.006620288826525211, -0.038879089057445526, 0.030257804319262505, 0.030074981972575188, 0.05657992139458656, 0.006064421031624079, -0.00801151804625988, -0.03264962136745453, 0.03705814108252525, -0.0054235211573541164, 0.07908814400434494, 0.04586957395076752, 0.0028482067864388227, -0.009218933060765266, -0.017145708203315735, -0.03038387931883335, 0.047123126685619354, 0.025392139330506325, 0.01991897076368332, 0.024829881265759468, 0.04644109308719635, 0.059339530766010284, -0.008510138839483261, -0.022640354931354523, 0.06389130651950836, -0.005019287578761578, -0.008418749086558819, -0.029055781662464142, -0.0038229660131037235, -0.000007531657047366025, 0.0202078465372324, -0.022583596408367157, 0.026047591120004654, -0.01943201944231987, -0.03537244722247124, 0.04451146721839905, -0.021797237917780876, 0.00792342983186245, 0.016334105283021927, 0.01822740025818348, 0.054397646337747574, 0.017405599355697632, -0.03400389477610588, 0.008741754107177258, 0.02003490924835205, 0.05480928719043732, -0.012428845278918743, 0.03001275844871998, -0.09410546720027924, 0.02235689014196396, 0.013400658965110779, 0.05639797821640968, -0.012804970145225525, 0.009133663028478622, -0.05663444101810455, -0.015578215010464191, 0.07853023707866669, 0.011003157123923302, 0.03876960650086403, -0.054323211312294006, 0.002858542837202549, -0.024952197447419167, 0.015601443126797676, -0.05201471969485283, -0.04139426723122597, -0.00991375744342804, 0.05057321861386299, -0.022628579288721085, -0.014354889281094074, -0.027100231498479843, 0.05453622713685036, 0.04726933315396309, 0.06357713788747787, -0.000592206371948123, -0.03830521181225777, 0.036026742309331894, 0.0007302949670702219, -0.03199191391468048, -0.07098542898893356, 0.007575539406388998, -0.012287469580769539, -0.020715875551104546, 0.047111865133047104, -0.015621482394635677, -0.05293462797999382, 0.0009585092193447053, 0.03245186433196068, 0.02111457847058773, -0.008828016929328442, -0.008713237941265106, 0.008308123797178268, -0.0060568805783987045, 0.030376605689525604, 0.061547886580228806, 0.009898973628878593, -0.007548480294644833, 0.06254987418651581, -0.03389903903007507, 0.0033740741200745106, -0.0032408302649855614, -0.026371462270617485, -0.03164799511432648, -0.010817267931997776, 0.0067729889415204525, 0.006490084808319807, 0.005395896267145872, 0.036916133016347885, -0.07115357369184494, -0.024660170078277588, -0.02286037988960743, 0.03822682797908783, -0.04163777828216553, -0.023693876340985298, 0.0008573231170885265, 0.036824751645326614, -0.046985287219285965, 0.0002791866718325764, 0.01768636703491211, -0.03920513018965721, 0.021343007683753967, -0.0018436507089063525, -0.0647215023636818, 0.0022143861278891563, -0.008685989305377007, -0.04167106747627258, 0.006782735697925091, -0.009325973689556122, 0.021712003275752068, 0.006402545142918825, 0.026455119252204895, 0.023620115593075752, -0.04097960889339447, 0.007848228327929974, -0.010417882353067398, -0.006977342069149017, 0.04635883867740631, -0.029722603037953377, -0.015529321506619453, -0.011177439242601395, -0.0050841327756643295, -0.058923203498125076, 0.001070042490027845, 0.013585902750492096, -0.01789589785039425, -0.04812929406762123, -0.021748322993516922, -0.039943549782037735, -0.01824023947119713, -0.03860042616724968, -0.02657618373632431, 0.04595118761062622, -0.015779519453644753, 0.018014902248978615, -0.0144899170845747, 0.04817056655883789, 0.07635507732629776, -0.004929279442876577, -0.005873396061360836, 0.0451107993721962, -0.02925213612616062, -0.04971829429268837, -0.00929130706936121, 0.02349797636270523, -0.008001849986612797, 0.0008423097897320986, -0.01695774868130684, 0.01664099656045437, 0.030487168580293655, 0.006650243885815144, -0.04998995363712311, 0.03392278403043747, 0.011259243823587894, -0.0012846662430092692, 0.006157729309052229, 0.010006729513406754, -0.02561970055103302, 0.01648232899606228, -0.011026951484382153, -0.000060392998420866206, -0.005077169742435217, 0.03280802071094513, 0.03611267730593681, -0.008720386773347855, -0.001332682790234685, 0.008292829617857933, 0.06075301393866539, -0.003605675185099244, 0.001599174807779491, 0.016047224402427673, -0.002673717448487878, 0.05640781298279762, 0.04008537903428078, 0.013586868532001972, -0.009739958681166172, 0.025567563250660896, -0.03797562047839165, -0.04462450370192528, -0.050391726195812225, 0.021164635196328163, 0.0849698930978775, -0.004348628222942352, -0.008469982072710991, 0.03045607917010784, -0.01748443767428398, -0.029195232316851616, -0.012998365797102451, -0.02607533521950245, 0.040703967213630676, 0.0071158935315907, 0.0188722163438797, -0.01628952845931053, -0.039527181535959244, 0.025243816897273064, -0.0018207377288490534, 0.0062571982853114605, 0.0024803548585623503, -0.013892538845539093, 0.02537686750292778, -0.003024409292265773, -0.026801669970154762, -0.06921166181564331, 0.04258928447961807, -0.04960405454039574, 0.037956602871418, -0.06628909707069397, 0.017831826582551003, 0.004633008502423763, 0.028099114075303078, 0.007931348867714405, -0.01801813393831253, -0.0185628030449152, -0.027227915823459625, 0.02473733015358448, 0.02530808001756668, -0.009815588593482971, 0.03063596971333027, -0.00659007765352726, 0.02251134067773819, -0.013573420234024525, 0.009184894151985645, -0.0011996476678177714, -0.09626366198062897, 0.009673991240561008, 0.012979283928871155, -0.06242203712463379, 0.03738854452967644, 0.02285175211727619, -0.0026152580976486206, 0.01966364122927189, -0.014328486286103725, 0.007978196255862713, 0.0039023300632834435, -0.022661060094833374, 0.01364734023809433, 0.08606182783842087, -0.01858656108379364, -0.0209211278706789, -0.04561024531722069, -0.012395041063427925, 0.11958009004592896, 0.05068492516875267, -0.0263800248503685, -0.019365279003977776, -0.004292110446840525, 0.001373471925035119, -0.02685462310910225, -0.03339901193976402, 0.025322815403342247, -0.011649686843156815, 0.01524582039564848, 0.008065865375101566, 0.022117087617516518, 0.00024768899311311543, -0.01262243464589119, 0.022514844313263893, -0.030812783166766167, -0.020306983962655067, 0.021760424599051476, 0.0008966710302047431, -0.0020711685065180063, -0.03628602251410484, -0.03390129283070564, -0.030330566689372063, -0.005731940735131502, 0.01493982132524252, -0.005116402171552181, 0.003582737175747752, 0.008150948211550713, -0.06557885557413101, -0.04689102992415428, -0.009507149457931519, 0.01285680290311575, 0.048006877303123474, 0.02237762324512005, 0.01632808893918991, -0.01527043990790844, 0.027272818610072136, 0.01141215767711401, 0.017670584842562675, 0.020841943100094795, -0.01104637049138546, 0.017693182453513145, 0.014600959606468678, -0.04849313572049141, -0.04543935880064964, -0.01865112967789173, 0.015475735999643803, -0.02751593105494976, -0.020434711128473282, -0.010452634654939175, 0.0007563199033029377, -0.014195984229445457, -0.027867544442415237, -0.011125877499580383, -0.006843081675469875, 0.016873881220817566, -0.029877010732889175, -0.005288482178002596, -0.0028429762460291386, 0.015676716342568398, 0.01727081649005413, -0.0109550217166543, -0.0011540184495970607, -0.041706591844558716, -0.014001553878188133, 0.0028664241544902325, 0.038913000375032425, 0.009274661540985107, -0.014139393344521523, -0.04354224354028702, -0.051768817007541656, -0.015541499480605125, -0.0429605171084404, -0.0007266894681379199, -0.029965532943606377, 0.034493338316679, -0.016905590891838074, -0.005892232060432434, -0.037153761833906174, -0.02605971321463585, -0.01760849729180336, 0.0076159643940627575, 0.007344311568886042, -0.06061561405658722, 0.00013291966752149165, -0.012550576590001583, -0.004652803298085928, 0.011293643154203892, 0.025007132440805435, 0.006624134257435799, 0.021000584587454796, -0.02368234097957611, -0.02038673684000969, -0.045494336634874344, -0.024928633123636246, -0.045897793024778366, -0.0068473974242806435, -0.001554275630041957, 0.07512194663286209, -0.013004685752093792, 0.05017721280455589, -0.011033372022211552, 0.004603457637131214, 0.007183164823800325, 0.011044030077755451, 0.031068291515111923, -0.009502124972641468, -0.01731739565730095, 0.012169316411018372, -0.009184584952890873, -0.02044646441936493, -0.005946567747741938, -0.05200938135385513, -0.05232313647866249, -0.013253819197416306, 0.01793530397117138, -0.034760959446430206, 0.017161933705210686, 0.013157383538782597, 0.016887066885828972, -0.01659310609102249, 0.0034319867845624685, -0.013212435878813267, 0.02974577434360981, -0.03377407416701317, 0.02618768997490406, -0.021416425704956055, 0.0162922665476799, -0.0320347361266613, -0.007082890719175339, 0.029945500195026398, 0.008814534172415733, 0.013159623369574547, -0.04747593775391579, 0.013245826587080956, 0.029142610728740692, 0.0520322360098362, -0.03829524293541908, -0.028714243322610855, 0.026438139379024506, -0.028908031061291695, -0.034080419689416885, -0.014133705757558346, -0.0014049429446458817, 0.014678020030260086, 0.013758271932601929, -0.03049750253558159, -0.0030309618450701237, 0.022777065634727478, -0.02985396794974804, 0.007835235446691513, -0.0054953694343566895, 0.016954781487584114, -0.0002455670037306845, -0.028713451698422432, 0.045228827744722366, -0.024496477097272873, 0.010034552775323391, 0.021140141412615776, 0.04186021536588669, -0.023433595895767212, -0.012426263652741909, 0.022432146593928337, -0.02722163312137127, 0.011516805738210678, -0.001986079616472125, -0.007337643764913082, 0.02826567366719246, 0.018862785771489143, -0.020004868507385254, 0.035708703100681305, 0.01882888190448284, 0.04615064710378647, -0.06527353078126907, -0.01435296330600977, 0.028884049504995346, 0.005617531482130289, 0.04132795333862305, -0.07228436321020126, -0.024329299107193947, 0.017054349184036255, -0.05376628786325455, 0.008920407854020596, 0.004988014232367277, -0.017849108204245567, -0.01659681834280491, -0.00987735204398632, -0.05198192596435547, 0.029042119160294533, 0.05973921716213226, 0.003239225596189499, 0.04802781343460083, 0.0010577929206192493, -0.031389277428388596, -0.026663895696401596, -0.005367134232074022, 0.04444185271859169, 0.0418049693107605, -0.08417122811079025, 0.01975860632956028, -0.020823746919631958, -0.015150015242397785, 0.023300401866436005, -0.011809124611318111, 0.015662549063563347, 0.005568338092416525, 0.034484609961509705, 0.013421437703073025, 0.07590951770544052, 0.05298317223787308, -0.009207675233483315, 0.01795804873108864, -0.026869259774684906, 0.012017273344099522, 0.029768437147140503, -0.010880439542233944, 0.022922715172171593, -0.00038904629764147103, 0.027187544852495193, -0.0358843095600605, -0.012104159221053123, -0.02555718459188938, 0.003920585382729769, -0.039708878844976425, -0.02656003087759018, 0.025600526481866837, -0.0673309937119484, 0.05237392708659172, -0.01530689001083374, -0.028113557025790215, 0.047861553728580475, 0.038160067051649094, -0.01706453412771225, -0.02017955668270588, -0.005660276394337416, -0.03825731575489044, 0.02002517506480217, 0.013295446522533894, -0.010286575183272362, -0.08522894978523254, -0.013056266121566296, -0.025044796988368034, -0.01455400139093399, -0.011258520185947418, -0.010181481949985027, -0.09737057238817215, 0.05467712879180908, 0.005790005438029766, -0.006014018785208464, 0.020945478230714798, -0.02134910225868225, 0.051793184131383896, -0.08804184943437576, 0.018057802692055702, -0.002660335274413228, 0.007159184664487839, 0.03705478087067604, -0.018000982701778412, -0.011251060292124748, -0.023280069231987, 0.059440720826387405, 0.012062497437000275, -0.007459430489689112, 0.02527175098657608, 0.024684524163603783, 0.03451738879084587, -0.032871510833501816, 0.04688199609518051, -0.016486389562487602, -0.014787865802645683, 0.01147813256829977, 0.008228258229792118, 0.04170414060354233, -0.019925611093640327, 0.016570404171943665, -0.01436915248632431, 0.003615360474213958, -0.018575357273221016, 0.01959162950515747, 0.021132105961441994, -0.0032738770823925734, -0.03101353533565998, 0.04230593517422676, -0.01211492344737053, 0.026543136686086655, 0.015645673498511314, 0.01195757556706667, -0.06834538280963898, -0.028382524847984314, -0.004527231212705374, -0.0067081390880048275, 0.006191522814333439, 0.02029009908437729, 0.015633756294846535, -0.02151835896074772, -0.008180906996130943, 0.02195509523153305, -0.043538451194763184, 0.007524056825786829, 0.016367489472031593, 0.02544926106929779, -0.0012357024243101478, 0.018462199717760086, 0.03804164007306099, 0.030342089012265205, 0.011243337765336037, 0.013446571305394173, 0.03863352909684181, 0.06850625574588776, -0.030030809342861176, -0.007116669788956642, 0.029079291969537735, -0.024661514908075333, 0.045411448925733566, -0.018666183575987816, 0.04629821702837944, -0.016716957092285156, -0.01381455548107624, 0.02799188159406185, 0.026453571394085884, -0.01813705451786518, -0.009453189559280872, -0.01723744161427021, 0.040427811443805695, 0.04068204388022423, -0.012623623944818974, -0.051150236278772354, 0.030359838157892227, -0.0000978773387032561, -0.03706435114145279, 0.01480881217867136, 0.0047350493259727955, 0.01211096253246069, -0.010448510758578777, 0.000019994622562080622, -0.023734310641884804, 0.004186630714684725, -0.04906228557229042, 0.01061965897679329, 0.014626972377300262, 0.013480695895850658, -0.029509197920560837, -0.04394516721367836, -0.017655842006206512, -0.020273320376873016, 0.010978247039020061, 0.029425086453557014, 0.02432839386165142, -0.026248035952448845, -0.040518373250961304, -0.005185778718441725, 0.0650700256228447, -0.0216204971075058, -0.009215829893946648, -0.034770723432302475, -0.02934800274670124, 0.008471932262182236, -0.03193870931863785 ]
<p>I've got a online classification problem where I predict a class label <code>{+1, -1}</code> for an object and then show it to a user to get a real label. My task is to minimize a number of <code>-1</code> objects shown to a user.</p> <p>Obviously, the algorithm will not converge if it learns only on <code>+1 -&gt; -1</code> missclassifications, so a certain ammount of <code>-1</code> objects needs to be shown to users anyway. The problem is to minimize a number of <code>-1</code> objects shown to a user by selecting only the ones most valuable for learning.</p> <p>The above problem is being solved in a field of 'active learning', where a learner gets to decide whether to request a laber for an object from user or not. Searching for a solution that does not imply i.i.d., I've found <a href="http://jmlr.csail.mit.edu/papers/volume7/cesa-bianchi06b/cesa-bianchi06b.pdf" rel="nofollow">this work</a>, where the learner decides on whether to require a label for an object by its margin. This is intuitive: the lesser margin means that we're more likely to make an error, which makes an object more valuable for learning. The probability to require an object depends on a margin and some parameter <code>b</code>, the optimal value for which is given for a linearly separable case, which applies for my problem.</p> <p>The algorithm is simple and goes as follows:</p> <pre><code>initialize weight vector w(t) with zeros for every input vector x(t): calculate margin p(t) = w(t-1) * x(t) predict a class with Hebb's rule y(t) = sgn(p(t)) toss a coin with P(heads) = b / (b + |p(t)|) if Heads: query the label y' of x if y' != y: update weights w(t+1) = w(t) + y'*x else: w(t+1) = w(t) </code></pre> <p>Basically, I need to use this rule for querying user only if object prediction is <code>-1</code>, and if it is <code>+1</code>, I require a label anyway. My question is: would my algorithm converge in that setting? The perceptron algorithm itself and the modified version from the above article are symmetrical in respect to class labels. In my setting there will surely be more errors on <code>+1</code> objects, than on <code>-1</code>'s. <strong>Does it hurt convergence? If it does, what modification to that algorithm can bring it back to 'symmetry' between positive and negative weight updates?</strong></p> <p>The modified algorithm querying <code>+1</code>s in all cases is as follows:</p> <pre><code>initialize weight vector w(t) with zeros for every input vector x(t): calculate margin p(t) = w(t-1) * x(t) predict a class with Hebb's rule y(t) = sgn(p(t)) toss a coin with P(heads) = b / (b + |p(t)|) if Heads or y(t) == +1: query the label y' of x if y' != y: update weights w(t+1) = w(t) + y'*x else: w(t+1) = w(t) </code></pre> <p>Is this algorithm going to converge? If not, what modifications can be made? </p> <p>The first idea was to decrease a learning rate for +1's, but still, I don't know how to prove convergence. Do you have any ideas on how to design an algorithm so that <strong>it will surely find a linear separator in a finite number of iterations</strong>?</p> <p>Thanks.</p> <p><strong>Update</strong>. If don't know how to answer the question, but have any thoughts on where you would look for a solution or any pointers to publications/books/etc, please, let me know!</p>
73,430
[ -0.03403903916478157, -0.059173665940761566, 0.010449757799506187, -0.02585156075656414, -0.018845297396183014, -0.017191672697663307, -0.01464646402746439, 0.019174668937921524, 0.011505463160574436, -0.027081992477178574, 0.036897990852594376, 0.05434608459472656, 0.02870190143585205, 0.06878645718097687, 0.006187151651829481, 0.025470517575740814, -0.0062805949710309505, -0.041556186974048615, -0.030168892815709114, -0.0029717006254941225, 0.0046403976157307625, 0.013027872890233994, 0.04218939691781998, -0.00654252152889967, -0.018461190164089203, -0.01598900556564331, 0.017502298578619957, -0.03349929675459862, 0.012435377575457096, 0.060803208500146866, -0.05411139130592346, -0.011746418662369251, -0.022849934175610542, 0.005342079792171717, 0.03967665508389473, 0.006439473945647478, -0.009287578985095024, -0.012931372039020061, -0.02823617123067379, 0.0021920064464211464, 0.0017598430858924985, 0.01729304902255535, 0.03292962908744812, 0.05610458925366402, 0.035344768315553665, 0.01692473515868187, -0.0191964078694582, 0.006128656677901745, 0.04917485639452934, -0.03483916074037552, 0.04811915382742882, 0.011715457774698734, 0.005964216310530901, -0.002666627988219261, -0.04550334811210632, -0.013539004139602184, 0.038586657494306564, 0.09274865686893463, -0.0006707971333526075, -0.028327247127890587, -0.023919297382235527, -0.016734696924686432, 0.0019152059685438871, -0.016070615500211716, 0.002403074409812689, 0.02371109090745449, 0.01881983131170273, 0.001976483501493931, 0.03829559311270714, -0.03135032579302788, 0.00009511547250440344, -0.005231528077274561, -0.0007835760479792953, -0.02784559689462185, -0.0012224901001900434, 0.022535117343068123, 0.0012857592664659023, 0.06827526539564133, 0.01817445084452629, 0.020168237388134003, 0.006955040618777275, -0.016816480085253716, 0.01716752164065838, 0.05523713305592537, -0.007757735438644886, 0.025962622836232185, 0.0713522732257843, -0.048193663358688354, 0.03162393346428871, 0.022114038467407227, -0.022304587066173553, -0.03910231590270996, 0.048650193959474564, -0.022562336176633835, -0.03244198486208916, 0.03480686992406845, 0.009317646734416485, 0.0037722450215369463, 0.0113593814894557, -0.019676314666867256, -0.033238485455513, -0.048251401633024216, -0.02707005850970745, 0.0529961921274662, -0.04586391523480415, -0.022661609575152397, -0.046480122953653336, -0.01686600036919117, -0.028057536110281944, -0.007821628823876381, -0.00034323669387958944, 0.02240954525768757, 0.002796309534460306, 0.006812987849116325, -0.023085912689566612, -0.038322895765304565, 0.007502928841859102, 0.005936181638389826, 0.0174057949334383, 0.02971968799829483, 0.04859871417284012, 0.0014869080623611808, 0.012644397094845772, -0.03678419440984726, -0.06369313597679138, -0.0240587517619133, -0.001912240288220346, -0.029569320380687714, -0.051065851002931595, 0.05428226664662361, -0.03174673020839691, -0.0018602851778268814, 0.09974820166826248, -0.005023723468184471, -0.020894698798656464, -0.0349331870675087, -0.0487227737903595, -0.030426528304815292, 0.038429729640483856, -0.022838756442070007, 0.01169869489967823, -0.0601905919611454, -0.00890334416180849, 0.06529882550239563, 0.054466936737298965, 0.00900392048060894, 0.03935154527425766, 0.04608670994639397, 0.027817126363515854, 0.0021411003544926643, -0.03611316904425621, 0.028196338564157486, -0.053626205772161484, 0.02715699002146721, -0.046408042311668396, -0.0461462028324604, -0.01133967936038971, 0.05032266676425934, -0.0260283425450325, -0.011049634777009487, 0.042352642863988876, -0.024554183706641197, -0.0061267646960914135, -0.03719765320420265, -0.02545715868473053, -0.031192032620310783, 0.05651012435555458, 0.020245015621185303, 0.06967233121395111, 0.011780458502471447, -0.011470839381217957, 0.011633737944066525, -0.003923310898244381, 0.016889158636331558, 0.07589542865753174, -0.04108603298664093, -0.023931315168738365, -0.048619210720062256, 0.01732618175446987, 0.024797482416033745, -0.003497027326375246, -0.020437687635421753, -0.07404740154743195, 0.03541652485728264, -0.00003266330895712599, -0.0053354245610535145, 0.026454612612724304, 0.011652261018753052, 0.011733193881809711, -0.031464993953704834, -0.05054092779755592, -0.07368472218513489, 0.015834052115678787, 0.008314674720168114, 0.021026726812124252, 0.039521474391222, -0.017288872972130775, -0.010976697318255901, 0.03076360747218132, 0.020252099260687828, -0.03067968413233757, -0.00023151558707468212, 0.04981601610779762, -0.03529840335249901, -0.030633535236120224, 0.04355534911155701, 0.011857828125357628, -0.011096660047769547, 0.055706936866045, -0.047752127051353455, -0.049056410789489746, -0.01744527742266655, 0.028687244281172752, 0.008844898082315922, 0.00040913402335718274, 0.02839869260787964, 0.047762032598257065, -0.009941065683960915, 0.004620506893843412, -0.004268425051122904, -0.049002863466739655, 0.04635617882013321, 0.0768459215760231, -0.0009905124315991998, -0.015934905037283897, 0.022479655221104622, 0.003966770134866238, 0.036645177751779556, -0.017101867124438286, 0.015689369291067123, -0.05721862614154816, -0.027835972607135773, 0.03036203794181347, 0.06413153558969498, -0.03555168956518173, -0.013699999079108238, 0.038243889808654785, -0.004607727285474539, -0.0009377060341648757, 0.017851540818810463, -0.022421831265091896, -0.010930838994681835, 0.04431343451142311, 0.0001911141152959317, 0.02879696525633335, 0.02877954952418804, 0.01763230934739113, 0.017009854316711426, 0.038715001195669174, 0.025520235300064087, -0.010504109784960747, 0.0030004708096385, 0.014020408503711224, 0.0007838031160645187, -0.020837370306253433, -0.007007855921983719, 0.03633555769920349, -0.027024872601032257, 0.007219252176582813, 0.010803740471601486, -0.02249680645763874, -0.013409747742116451, 0.007078378461301327, -0.0324205681681633, 0.030355671420693398, 0.025433428585529327, -0.012633130885660648, 0.01286929938942194, 0.03689206764101982, -0.06928376853466034, 0.01730378158390522, 0.01817145384848118, -0.06598525494337082, -0.02308638021349907, 0.049930378794670105, 0.021315081045031548, 0.014215253293514252, -0.002750337589532137, -0.03441606089472771, -0.00956103764474392, 0.01230001263320446, 0.012255147099494934, 0.054835960268974304, 0.011579297482967377, -0.05459060147404671, -0.002022080821916461, -0.009539410471916199, -0.02053113281726837, 0.013175065629184246, 0.011500641703605652, -0.036376360803842545, 0.06572828441858292, 0.016071461141109467, -0.05618274584412575, -0.029902324080467224, -0.03898145258426666, 0.03861198574304581, -0.024028552696108818, 0.00765798008069396, 0.03734198212623596, 0.04776608198881149, -0.08044689893722534, -0.0023965167347341776, 0.00006915225822012872, -0.049046389758586884, -0.045461591333150864, -0.033683985471725464, -0.019035877659916878, 0.0052719926461577415, -0.029207007959485054, 0.04553644731640816, 0.02688543125987053, -0.0073746247217059135, -0.0897713452577591, -0.06270885467529297, 0.015348304063081741, 0.02318216860294342, 0.01118530984967947, -0.01912054233253002, 0.009235881268978119, 0.12407839298248291, 0.03198225051164627, -0.0027120932936668396, -0.04250384122133255, 0.026080651208758354, 0.000378340802853927, -0.03168307989835739, 0.0019251344492658973, 0.017205556854605675, -0.015886295586824417, 0.01650356501340866, -0.02363276667892933, 0.007928096689283848, 0.03883182629942894, 0.016560031101107597, 0.02191382646560669, 0.03193914145231247, -0.03030974604189396, -0.028437256813049316, 0.00781079288572073, 0.03547423705458641, -0.0033581971656531096, 0.03130866214632988, -0.022008446976542473, 0.03791553154587746, 0.017253557220101357, -0.02477310039103031, 0.04317560791969299, -0.018949510529637337, 0.04870032146573067, 0.0011249631643295288, 0.020986873656511307, 0.004011509008705616, -0.04187832027673721, -0.0220892783254385, -0.005576229654252529, 0.04718872159719467, -0.022781766951084137, -0.016142943874001503, 0.051985275000333786, 0.04231048375368118, -0.01910022459924221, -0.004732820671051741, -0.014213623479008675, -0.003452154342085123, -0.016200102865695953, -0.04499504342675209, 0.0020650241058319807, -0.018812892958521843, 0.06408918648958206, 0.0005781289073638618, 0.036300189793109894, -0.006054823286831379, -0.00027212785789743066, -0.04064100235700607, 0.0140442019328475, -0.021926002576947212, 0.053231533616781235, 0.01916472613811493, 0.008384733460843563, -0.008089612238109112, -0.012026002630591393, -0.04773467779159546, 0.040363896638154984, -0.08457554876804352, 0.014628972858190536, 0.012183386832475662, 0.008612057194113731, -0.014366195537149906, -0.012980226427316666, 0.037889886647462845, -0.057555776089429855, -0.01914282515645027, -0.018220435827970505, 0.05345529317855835, -0.012901521287858486, -0.0003475142293609679, 0.0393788106739521, -0.021224310621619225, 0.012000486254692078, -0.012027972377836704, 0.03450591117143631, -0.004411942791193724, 0.021765632554888725, 0.014238687232136726, -0.014612122438848019, -0.005455831065773964, -0.019259635359048843, 0.012851114384829998, -0.013249444775283337, 0.06163504719734192, -0.021607456728816032, 0.028847884386777878, -0.05500666797161102, -0.00457640690729022, 0.009507661685347557, 0.027626661583781242, 0.030328400433063507, -0.002450539031997323, 0.00009918503928929567, -0.061983656138181686, -0.05420980975031853, 0.008085395209491253, 0.00968941394239664, -0.022483419626951218, -0.013677471317350864, 0.04381794482469559, -0.01653844118118286, -0.039607368409633636, -0.01849454827606678, 0.09447627514600754, 0.00999296735972166, -0.010174072347581387, -0.029274746775627136, -0.0031445249915122986, -0.011443959549069405, 0.04094937816262245, -0.0026545135769993067, 0.04185662418603897, 0.0199165977537632, -0.017112089321017265, 0.041148725897073746, -0.01146643701940775, 0.015024193562567234, -0.029808001592755318, 0.00980970449745655, 0.024713262915611267, -0.0011060405522584915, 0.014754755422472954, 0.0025698370300233364, 0.06624744087457657, 0.05416420102119446, 0.01251657772809267, 0.012733702547848225, -0.06867087632417679, -0.06683628261089325, 0.04353911057114601, 0.05233670771121979, -0.011680787429213524, 0.000982352765277028, -0.03073081560432911, -0.021368881687521935, 0.060642343014478683, -0.027879780158400536, 0.03059479407966137, 0.0018645473755896091, 0.024324098601937294, -0.014505906961858273, -0.0726049467921257, -0.05228058621287346, -0.007597515359520912, -0.05985516682267189, 0.04967910051345825, -0.011300021782517433, -0.033350467681884766, -0.03310343995690346, 0.0070329876616597176, 0.010069708339869976, 0.04260309785604477, -0.02403981238603592, -0.027720028534531593, -0.008633595891296864, -0.023065349087119102, -0.004573010839521885, -0.054031118750572205, 0.0215778686106205, -0.02152198739349842, -0.010310872457921505, 0.012461552396416664, -0.017459526658058167, -0.028151175007224083, 0.024030620232224464, 0.02337879315018654, -0.0643574446439743, 0.007947548292577267, -0.011263985186815262, 0.04626316949725151, 0.029210126027464867, -0.012777173891663551, -0.005814375355839729, 0.05306747555732727, 0.01214798167347908, -0.014395340345799923, -0.06547346711158752, -0.03480624407529831, 0.0036126107443124056, 0.003033732296898961, -0.026842007413506508, -0.009224620647728443, -0.008028416894376278, 0.028320923447608948, -0.006342078559100628, 0.03601483255624771, -0.025650938972830772, -0.0031706078443676233, -0.02015508897602558, 0.03501814231276512, -0.029957735911011696, -0.02701066993176937, 0.0348987877368927, 0.01382905337959528, -0.005816595628857613, -0.011239760555326939, 0.03830709680914879, -0.05049901828169823, 0.0033418911043554544, 0.0377071276307106, -0.032427482306957245, -0.011700433678925037, -0.03860791027545929, -0.007350052706897259, -0.020880624651908875, -0.02317720837891102, 0.017026720568537712, 0.0016978258499875665, 0.05288152024149895, 0.006350837182253599, 0.0056654056534171104, -0.009494180791079998, -0.004347262438386679, -0.023561134934425354, -0.006931718904525042, -0.024308329448103905, -0.023018991574645042, -0.015211462043225765, 0.010306847281754017, -0.03074130043387413, 0.0012910692021250725, -0.0071010105311870575, 0.03053591400384903, -0.03231789171695709, -0.015702413395047188, -0.020124897360801697, 0.0007916961912997067, -0.03833887353539467, -0.005754942074418068, 0.019494442269206047, -0.02845795266330242, 0.009166508913040161, 0.004886063747107983, 0.016017770394682884, 0.019673509523272514, -0.012161122635006905, -0.0007043146179057658, 0.01718199998140335, 0.002458440838381648, -0.0002406503917882219, -0.00217930949293077, 0.012771312147378922, -0.027093997225165367, -0.003507322398945689, -0.013919459655880928, 0.05030263960361481, 0.026054944843053818, 0.022735165432095528, 0.01976400427520275, 0.026219060644507408, -0.01752048172056675, 0.0011297623859718442, -0.021196749061346054, -0.004755311645567417, 0.014855684712529182, 0.0014218267751857638, -0.00171655195299536, 0.007603098172694445, -0.006638812832534313, -0.0033371776808053255, 0.012266446836292744, -0.0033427507150918245, 0.011457649059593678, 0.015673251822590828, 0.04317370057106018, -0.01268361322581768, 0.011707114987075329, -0.030390605330467224, -0.039871737360954285, 0.05120069533586502, 0.0178045816719532, 0.022598356008529663, -0.026105809956789017, -0.00542980944737792, 0.0015926470514386892, 0.00897441990673542, -0.03842032700777054, -0.003670638194307685, 0.07368679344654083, 0.06669975817203522, 0.053689438849687576, 0.030269848182797432, -0.006460339762270451, -0.026673851534724236, -0.031075933948159218, -0.00745428167283535, -0.02807730995118618, -0.006853009108453989, 0.06771538406610489, 0.00013909584959037602, -0.017670253291726112, 0.05885491147637367, -0.018360428512096405, 0.03325624763965607, 0.044830091297626495, 0.019359320402145386, 0.0017097796080633998, 0.04196446016430855, -0.06363557279109955, -0.05029335618019104, 0.00025016252766363323, -0.046157900243997574, 0.0011219396255910397, 0.008083147928118706, -0.04426874220371246, 0.04810292273759842, 0.01470885332673788, -0.008562704548239708, -0.012285969220101833, -0.023349694907665253, -0.05485525727272034, 0.00863889791071415, -0.01969691924750805, -0.029087195172905922, 0.010480305179953575, -0.023059353232383728, 0.0153093496337533, -0.016459453850984573, 0.05363231152296066, -0.03146371245384216, -0.0623270608484745, -0.05523763224482536, -0.06767939776182175, -0.035187944769859314, 0.0284555833786726, 0.05182835832238197, -0.02011772245168686, 0.013845635578036308, -0.006051131058484316, 0.04727287217974663, 0.015050439164042473, 0.0471421480178833, 0.029617439955472946, 0.009349795058369637, -0.005123725160956383, 0.02598246932029724, -0.036348868161439896, -0.01362060196697712, 0.164792001247406, 0.08267683535814285, 0.07043234258890152, -0.03710779920220375, -0.015188131481409073, 0.004024200141429901, -0.023151308298110962, -0.035546157509088516, 0.009730503894388676, 0.021762218326330185, -0.006323901936411858, 0.0009124567732214928, 0.0007081044605001807, 0.019844159483909607, -0.010915255174040794, 0.030302412807941437, -0.06940900534391403, 0.008888513781130314, -0.0004985384293831885, 0.006684888619929552, 0.015176722779870033, -0.0018763033440336585, -0.04955814406275749, 0.010628882795572281, 0.037383243441581726, -0.06233519688248634, -0.03114912286400795, -0.010429567657411098, -0.01394342165440321, -0.026599163189530373, 0.013275468721985817, 0.03226932883262634, 0.04296454042196274, -0.013384916819632053, 0.017281321808695793, -0.012828240171074867, 0.003679513931274414, -0.026320580393075943, -0.0076538738794624805, -0.00848044641315937, 0.00418226420879364, -0.012307054363191128, 0.01618386246263981, -0.013533477671444416, -0.045686591416597366, -0.02413945086300373, -0.06130686029791832, 0.047584760934114456, -0.022239817306399345, -0.008889882825314999, 0.015763655304908752, -0.030589377507567406, 0.047390569001436234, -0.01943448930978775, -0.007152145262807608, 0.03554241731762886, 0.020715897902846336, -0.005365448072552681, -0.03172200173139572, 0.016723839566111565, 0.017552167177200317, -0.027331572026014328, -0.007592089008539915, 0.011358086951076984, -0.032071489840745926, -0.0292461309581995, -0.02074645459651947, 0.025247972458600998, 0.026524707674980164, 0.013648459687829018, 0.0271903146058321, -0.01827257312834263, 0.015601628459990025, 0.0013586627319455147, -0.01647735759615898, -0.03655758500099182, 0.036509983241558075, -0.011725530959665775, -0.007833491079509258, -0.029261836782097816, -0.048047974705696106, 0.006792725995182991, -0.05217917636036873, -0.013774020597338676, -0.03442730754613876, 0.019490225240588188, 0.0164172500371933, 0.030405696481466293, 0.0036501374561339617, -0.04470200836658478, 0.031906187534332275, 0.05383182317018509, -0.016949601471424103, 0.018270594999194145, -0.03989030793309212, 0.021680545061826706, -0.03010925091803074, 0.03160795569419861, -0.005087441299110651, 0.06850402057170868, 0.037387050688266754, 0.013938413932919502, 0.021603528410196304, 0.003867442486807704, -0.0020958040840923786, 0.009981946088373661, 0.029390888288617134, -0.04337472468614578, 0.013038961216807365, 0.022269336506724358, 0.011059623211622238, -0.06163504347205162, -0.028563974425196648, -0.06622954457998276, -0.014670802280306816, 0.013388139195740223, 0.019467132166028023, -0.01452174223959446, 0.014268914237618446, 0.00615818751975894, 0.021040845662355423, -0.018399283289909363, -0.008495224639773369, -0.009684796445071697, 0.008639225736260414, -0.0017717181472107768, -0.006512959022074938, -0.009795534424483776, 0.011261064559221268, 0.014208037406206131, 0.014063887298107147, 0.013397800736129284, -0.006591233424842358, 0.002484444761648774, 0.013380763120949268, -0.011099322699010372, -0.011421254836022854, 0.02252795733511448, 0.00849119108170271, -0.03140717372298241, -0.002650550799444318, -0.06483431905508041, -0.03284568339586258, 0.003999441396445036, -0.022870568558573723, 0.03480568155646324, 0.019268009811639786, -0.04429139941930771, -0.012627318501472473, 0.035404328256845474, 0.005801538936793804, -0.022425508126616478, 0.05758929252624512, 0.0015077092684805393, 0.029042845591902733, -0.039030641317367554, 0.028047475963830948, -0.005808517802506685, -0.012277694419026375, 0.0036753155291080475, 0.013079207390546799, 0.03930286318063736, -0.03413175418972969, 0.005641164258122444, -0.011266030371189117, 0.0264792051166296, -0.014592846855521202, 0.006034184247255325, 0.027820102870464325, 0.026594575494527817, -0.03632062301039696, 0.03457851707935333, -0.00011303607607260346, -0.0003299677337054163, -0.12168645858764648, -0.044032447040081024, 0.012426801025867462, 0.01995948888361454, 0.054212603718042374, -0.03907627612352371, 0.02934701181948185, 0.0013305143220350146, -0.044545091688632965, 0.04612664878368378, 0.0013923181686550379, -0.0022699518594890833, -0.0460183322429657, 0.023047493770718575, -0.03464193642139435, 0.020635584369301796, 0.008459332399070263, 0.01428363099694252, 0.047643620520830154, 0.033262573182582855, -0.04925594851374626, -0.05805809423327446, -0.03527185320854187, 0.021281978115439415, -0.0065317703410983086, -0.034698497503995895, 0.0403255820274353, -0.04711489751935005, -0.015616084448993206, 0.0017673742258921266, -0.0019479962065815926, -0.02158852107822895, 0.00970942061394453, 0.022210776805877686, 0.011347967199981213, 0.06670274585485458, 0.011632444337010384, -0.01734122820198536, 0.0271034874022007, -0.0019931166898459196, 0.01571792922914028, -0.0056700324639678, 0.005117163062095642, 0.016556501388549805, 0.05807666853070259, -0.02154192514717579, -0.04140089079737663, 0.010622772388160229, 0.014812854118645191, -0.030692990869283676, 0.0107486043125391, 0.01947435736656189, 0.018989505246281624, -0.032861512154340744, -0.04765038937330246, -0.028927382081747055, -0.006956897675991058, 0.0018040445866063237, 0.018887603655457497, -0.0002523763687349856, 0.01990494690835476, -0.03469811752438545, -0.03344122692942619, 0.02596301957964897, 0.015296142548322678, -0.013745388947427273, -0.047354042530059814, 0.009933749213814735, 0.005140706896781921, 0.013401467353105545, -0.0025553852319717407, 0.0023814691230654716, 0.004265184514224529, -0.01257252972573042, -0.01853781007230282, 0.034117527306079865, -0.007083643227815628, 0.019536424428224564, 0.02267286740243435, -0.10055124759674072, 0.045370884239673615, 0.003464394249022007, 0.010384059511125088, 0.0014858098002150655, -0.011598354205489159, -0.04790828749537468, 0.010840858332812786, 0.05215735360980034, -0.006323097739368677, -0.014408052898943424, -0.006273108534514904, -0.023253729566931725, -0.011541644111275673, -0.01745976321399212, 0.05134497210383415, 0.024668734520673752, 0.004170025698840618, -0.0005702864727936685, 0.005319396499544382, 0.03954850137233734, 0.017024628818035126, 0.01177594531327486, 0.027693215757608414, -0.026363836601376534, 0.03239881992340088, -0.02447059005498886, 0.02844061329960823, 0.001510669244453311, 0.007119665388017893, 0.04694609344005585, 0.02176867052912712, 0.000046647226554341614, -0.018591811880469322, -0.01656048558652401, -0.06444824486970901, 0.02339605800807476, -0.05801033973693848, -0.035305481404066086, 0.021038495004177094, 0.028530748561024666, 0.0314292386174202, -0.040281664580106735, 0.01765323616564274, 0.029539532959461212, 0.00883104745298624, -0.011194884777069092, 0.003441099775955081, 0.031946852803230286, 0.07702451199293137, 0.007897593080997467, -0.00044107812573201954, 0.0035402048379182816, 0.014799151569604874, 0.047068532556295395, 0.016513608396053314, -0.001087393146008253, -0.015331849455833435, 0.03327132761478424, 0.03516349196434021, -0.01007752399891615, 0.05158611387014389, 0.0028288736939430237, 0.010510638356208801, 0.00014744950749445707, 0.015789669007062912, 0.03445553779602051, 0.011530334129929543, -0.0313759446144104, 0.02196093089878559, -0.022650819271802902, 0.03129268065094948, -0.0119103342294693, -0.004575071390718222, -0.03184310346841812, -0.0011585359461605549, 0.020949997007846832, 0.02181868441402912, 0.0024894753005355597, 0.04135609045624733, -0.010894988663494587, -0.014321308583021164, 0.007701603230088949, -0.01354669313877821, 0.012511900626122952, -0.007131299935281277, 0.027567971497774124, 0.030974578112363815, 0.0052990997210145, 0.007661955896764994, -0.02880057692527771, 0.008131430484354496, -0.018611278384923935, -0.014888334088027477, 0.04461347684264183, 0.03666083887219429, -0.038641612976789474, -0.0041530015878379345, -0.05846504122018814, 0.052526529878377914, -0.0328715443611145, 0.015808310359716415, -0.054050106555223465, 0.0058776563964784145, 0.020631983876228333, -0.033971481025218964 ]
<p>This question is somewhat of a continuation from an earlier posting: <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/50526/using-em-algorithm-for-record-linking">Using EM algorithm for record linking</a></p> <p>I have two data sets of individual some of whom are in both but a prior it is not know which are and there are no identification id's that are common to both. What we know are the individual's first name, last name, birth year, and birth country. Since I still do not understand how to apply EM to link them, I am converting the name string to Soundex or NYSIIS and requiring exact matches. That is, linking individuals only if their NYSIIS-equivalent first names match, last names match, birth years match, and birth countries match, and this match is unique both within and across data sets. </p> <p>Would it make sense to then assess the match quality by say computing the Jaro-Winkler of the names of the match pairs? So say a pair has names Jon Smith and Jonn Smith and NYSIIS(Jon) == NYSIIS(Jonn), does it make sense to compute Jaro-Winkler (Jon Smith, Jonn Smith)? And if so, should I weigh by the corresponding analyses by the Jaro-Winkler estimates?</p>
35,810
[ -0.022915415465831757, -0.04761911556124687, -0.010514714755117893, -0.024490512907505035, 0.0601133331656456, 0.01289218571037054, -0.012614399194717407, 0.002429901622235775, -0.004285817034542561, 0.03538686782121658, 0.02236495167016983, 0.0008914968348108232, 0.03824492543935776, 0.010842990130186081, 0.006340745370835066, -0.010238210670650005, 0.003402753733098507, 0.0007347356295213103, 0.012223209254443645, -0.024714311584830284, 0.00040288985474035144, 0.03684191033244133, -0.01051213126629591, -0.02809584140777588, -0.038137614727020264, 0.030696701258420944, 0.02554882876574993, -0.04465848207473755, 0.004454363603144884, 0.010914403013885021, -0.027853703126311302, -0.036994755268096924, 0.06394945085048676, 0.006539343856275082, 0.012320926412940025, 0.012031846679747105, -0.06410375237464905, -0.04381430521607399, 0.0009035697439685464, 0.04886510223150253, -0.05281015485525131, -0.02488020807504654, -0.024165034294128418, 0.03786638751626015, -0.015229879878461361, 0.006995802745223045, -0.02965777926146984, 0.035749323666095734, -0.014564531855285168, 0.00002429838787065819, 0.07061433792114258, 0.002272252459079027, 0.0058358535170555115, -0.019118985161185265, -0.026280831545591354, 0.008555194362998009, 0.049359872937202454, 0.04176236689090729, 0.018448365852236748, -0.053784314543008804, -0.01896599680185318, -0.030914943665266037, -0.020822802558541298, -0.02403870038688183, 0.00384874502196908, 0.020070334896445274, -0.0063160983845591545, -0.023196496069431305, 0.04566613584756851, 0.01882835291326046, -0.005775798577815294, 0.00377170299179852, 0.07000456005334854, -0.01560019887983799, 0.03605833277106285, -0.03558754175901413, 0.009227240458130836, 0.034546636044979095, 0.059632159769535065, 0.015779878944158554, -0.0293955747038126, -0.0032935398630797863, 0.0163263026624918, 0.08779402077198029, 0.027467990294098854, -0.034549448639154434, 0.02948675863444805, -0.09583573043346405, 0.006291818339377642, -0.00799152534455061, 0.013840514235198498, -0.03163106366991997, 0.035078708082437515, 0.013029015623033047, -0.05247517675161362, 0.010587001219391823, -0.0006064319750294089, 0.05424414202570915, 0.013219325803220272, -0.008358024060726166, -0.008489211089909077, -0.039669062942266464, 0.024028003215789795, 0.04614176228642464, -0.010345282033085823, -0.025836683809757233, -0.05253738537430763, -0.04156569018959999, -0.035411734133958817, -0.008898882195353508, -0.029822148382663727, -0.006339851301163435, -0.012910104356706142, -0.025602905079722404, 0.04365074262022972, -0.020518476143479347, 0.012854788452386856, 0.009193917736411095, 0.05456525832414627, 0.06954474002122879, 0.04317247495055199, -0.035585444420576096, 0.006467991508543491, -0.015847431495785713, -0.048573922365903854, -0.010210936889052391, -0.010895641520619392, -0.03071470372378826, -0.061482105404138565, 0.039934609085321426, 0.005843822844326496, -0.03112538903951645, 0.012355664744973183, -0.015641162171959877, 0.016606858000159264, 0.015326950699090958, -0.08991742134094238, -0.037276651710271835, 0.03578770160675049, -0.012576925568282604, -0.019748231396079063, -0.08203541487455368, -0.003072383115068078, 0.008247247897088528, 0.03172481432557106, 0.02391701377928257, 0.06707869470119476, 0.02036188542842865, 0.046303462237119675, 0.02269039675593376, -0.0364425890147686, -0.052436813712120056, -0.059360045939683914, -0.054576050490140915, -0.01740257628262043, -0.04532588645815849, -0.010786187835037708, 0.03676958009600639, -0.04680028557777405, 0.02321099117398262, 0.06235019862651825, 0.05698130279779434, -0.033041104674339294, -0.007668230216950178, 0.034728918224573135, -0.003949991427361965, 0.06611189246177673, 0.017537491396069527, 0.039640575647354126, 0.022612236440181732, -0.008177383802831173, 0.034895703196525574, 0.033202163875103, 0.009732297621667385, 0.042973216623067856, -0.05495268106460571, -0.011090219020843506, -0.016466358676552773, 0.005109242629259825, 0.0018075495027005672, -0.011487007141113281, -0.032803140580654144, -0.028169715777039528, -0.02236475609242916, 0.05700749531388283, 0.04232512786984444, -0.01331283338367939, 0.02447754703462124, 0.03375175967812538, -0.061499666422605515, -0.055144790560007095, -0.056190501898527145, 0.026528077200055122, -0.020746400579810143, -0.037195321172475815, 0.0407557412981987, -0.0055352021008729935, 0.017038533464074135, -0.005690382793545723, -0.00458585936576128, -0.030715251341462135, -0.0003941290488000959, 0.021117860451340675, -0.014198999851942062, -0.0031963405199348927, 0.03638863191008568, 0.04425174742937088, -0.019686615094542503, 0.058002445846796036, -0.0715421587228775, -0.11124138534069061, 0.027021825313568115, -0.006513445638120174, 0.010625400580465794, 0.03474032133817673, 0.026407616212964058, -0.006653990130871534, -0.03916223719716072, -0.02723129838705063, -0.007090659812092781, -0.06181412935256958, 0.037041619420051575, 0.05054349824786186, 0.006768019404262304, 0.0062818946316838264, 0.04498390853404999, 0.041359275579452515, 0.017411721870303154, 0.0009339068201370537, -0.00045169010991230607, -0.05067906156182289, -0.00713809859007597, 0.03669625148177147, 0.040485188364982605, -0.037857092916965485, 0.0009195370366796851, 0.04129162058234215, 0.010588197968900204, 0.00001697421794233378, -0.012263590469956398, -0.020533235743641853, 0.016566703096032143, 0.001961144618690014, 0.04441510885953903, -0.022113367915153503, 0.03908759355545044, 0.018353646621108055, 0.006070287898182869, 0.023358438163995743, -0.011716712266206741, -0.0017734915018081665, 0.034932542592287064, 0.01703767105937004, 0.006137064192444086, -0.011860757134854794, -0.010212834924459457, 0.022609632462263107, -0.04740127921104431, 0.05840858072042465, 0.02607838436961174, -0.01067798025906086, -0.03071622923016548, 0.009225485846400261, -0.013033799827098846, 0.008276018314063549, 0.007009528577327728, -0.0030969020444899797, 0.019336169585585594, -0.008059107698500156, -0.033948879688978195, 0.009739769622683525, -0.010452007874846458, -0.02707481198012829, 0.002080566016957164, 0.04385372996330261, 0.0011162353912368417, -0.01791115663945675, 0.021310919895768166, -0.02092110738158226, -0.01754067838191986, -0.029518606141209602, -0.01987246610224247, 0.013128184713423252, 0.007532632909715176, -0.047535043209791183, 0.027512459084391594, 0.0016850319225341082, -0.018079305067658424, 0.010392232798039913, -0.00535764591768384, -0.03015935607254505, 0.06287381798028946, 0.01849042996764183, -0.056779373437166214, -0.03556671366095543, -0.017618214711546898, 0.00842326134443283, -0.012465186417102814, 0.004664391279220581, 0.027273092418909073, 0.025162801146507263, -0.017765022814273834, 0.005516522563993931, -0.03810122609138489, -0.03245621919631958, -0.0018582508200779557, -0.007205679547041655, -0.006009887438267469, -0.027093546465039253, 0.03263039514422417, 0.010427609086036682, -0.02027156576514244, -0.022519215941429138, -0.05666772276163101, -0.05024794116616249, 0.08316148072481155, -0.01079441700130701, 0.02406647801399231, 0.03221576288342476, -0.04069657623767853, 0.032683197408914566, 0.023480774834752083, -0.06828566640615463, -0.029839912429451942, -0.004710751585662365, -0.02052517794072628, -0.019322287291288376, 0.0020097114611417055, 0.006803028751164675, 0.0019567525014281273, -0.0034425496123731136, 0.028485631570219994, -0.032661329954862595, 0.04118280112743378, -0.01943683996796608, 0.02843218483030796, 0.019892292097210884, 0.010133286938071251, -0.008054070174694061, 0.062415916472673416, 0.020633338019251823, -0.04580752179026604, 0.011422327719628811, -0.007000689394772053, 0.02449050545692444, 0.0402400977909565, -0.05696772411465645, 0.0013683116994798183, -0.005979906767606735, 0.018142765387892723, -0.039282284677028656, 0.005474564153701067, 0.012431557290256023, -0.0052571604028344154, 0.01225962582975626, 0.021509308367967606, 0.02107112668454647, -0.004527593031525612, 0.005694246850907803, 0.053040407598018646, 0.03694457560777664, 0.0030108944047242403, -0.00838454533368349, -0.029266830533742905, 0.0034964121878147125, 0.00535512063652277, -0.04995758831501007, -0.04268382862210274, 0.014914405532181263, 0.02750968001782894, -0.009296204894781113, 0.0262311939150095, -0.049128323793411255, 0.0023786602541804314, -0.0760713517665863, 0.0062332069501280785, -0.04185768961906433, 0.02108393795788288, 0.002036066958680749, 0.05531906336545944, -0.018163172528147697, 0.01788380928337574, -0.006418336648494005, 0.0077422079630196095, -0.06668853759765625, -0.006606314331293106, -0.03439817950129509, -0.01512167602777481, -0.0043049766682088375, -0.06157552823424339, 0.013638751581311226, -0.01871948130428791, 0.024915898218750954, -0.03433217108249664, 0.06407738476991653, -0.007706296164542437, 0.011308468878269196, -0.016568632796406746, -0.01018473133444786, 0.0029766815714538097, 0.05313202738761902, 0.02531217224895954, 0.012037262320518494, 0.033013831824064255, 0.03092980943620205, -0.009121019393205643, -0.024281775578856468, -0.05419187620282173, 0.009161215275526047, 0.03593011945486069, 0.05401544272899628, 0.01725098304450512, 0.04353286698460579, -0.0348370186984539, 0.02686028927564621, 0.007826256565749645, -0.004802306182682514, 0.04513076692819595, -0.02355867438018322, -0.014584841206669807, -0.018263766542077065, -0.027986014261841774, -0.015706833451986313, 0.03883615881204605, 0.023375609889626503, -0.002799021080136299, 0.019606512039899826, 0.03498228266835213, -0.006279083900153637, -0.007584398612380028, 0.08521457761526108, 0.042288437485694885, 0.01208670437335968, 0.014134603552520275, 0.0009175186278298497, 0.0006259020301513374, -0.013059798628091812, 0.024839989840984344, 0.05892337113618851, 0.01944025419652462, 0.0011242922628298402, 0.036371927708387375, -0.009778943844139576, -0.01146614272147417, 0.02342170849442482, 0.023886071518063545, 0.031034689396619797, -0.004850232508033514, -0.014587494544684887, 0.02389524318277836, 0.046562470495700836, 0.05722364783287048, -0.005314909853041172, 0.015619383193552494, -0.08792757987976074, -0.008622893132269382, 0.050368014723062515, 0.053351059556007385, -0.05120840668678284, 0.0027741289231926203, -0.047074705362319946, 0.0033239880576729774, 0.03331538289785385, -0.04147005453705788, 0.0034713365603238344, -0.0032065289560705423, 0.001030289102345705, -0.029797406867146492, -0.04869759455323219, -0.02797549217939377, 0.010326037183403969, 0.016594858840107918, 0.053884051740169525, -0.009199348278343678, 0.01822371780872345, 0.003731519915163517, 0.012773806229233742, 0.03108455054461956, 0.030077632516622543, -0.03113572858273983, -0.01919633150100708, 0.02119797095656395, 0.02171197161078453, -0.008170331828296185, -0.05507836863398552, 0.022272933274507523, -0.02108217030763626, -0.02573462203145027, 0.031273581087589264, -0.03518591448664665, -0.024227159097790718, 0.02340465784072876, 0.028627580031752586, 0.007655675057321787, 0.004876826889812946, 0.030911197885870934, 0.07468702644109726, 0.0016584573313593864, -0.004694940056651831, 0.09274942427873611, 0.01932283118367195, -0.02492784895002842, 0.025241510942578316, -0.03685924783349037, 0.004100026562809944, -0.01954944059252739, -0.029078511521220207, -0.015384809114038944, -0.007637221831828356, -0.08582138270139694, 0.023178022354841232, -0.05332637578248978, 0.03937660902738571, -0.07206132262945175, 0.018129071220755577, 0.012251634150743484, 0.01581992581486702, -0.06752651929855347, 0.009558161720633507, 0.011860736645758152, 0.03487350419163704, 0.003022870747372508, -0.00570153770968318, 0.03457101061940193, -0.020465107634663582, 0.007516197394579649, -0.013985571451485157, -0.040599364787340164, 0.06193878874182701, -0.010349668562412262, 0.0011973491637036204, 0.0346834622323513, 0.01629621535539627, 0.025413746014237404, -0.008988379500806332, 0.03259260207414627, -0.0013098957715556026, -0.02218909002840519, 0.023824051022529602, -0.01778409071266651, 0.0038540936075150967, 0.024727804586291313, 0.012788484804332256, 0.02064063958823681, 0.01649339683353901, -0.022901203483343124, -0.03091447800397873, -0.012081395834684372, 0.0033647974487394094, -0.003775092540308833, -0.03629828244447708, -0.0476195327937603, -0.014211075380444527, -0.00480688689276576, 0.018926827237010002, 0.011123614385724068, 0.061009667813777924, 0.008953374810516834, -0.028641527518630028, 0.015352608636021614, 0.03960048407316208, 0.04972922056913376, 0.012390044517815113, 0.04502914100885391, -0.02110607735812664, 0.0051727332174777985, 0.031030675396323204, -0.007162041030824184, 0.018777091056108475, -0.01392321940511465, -0.06265933811664581, -0.04298847168684006, -0.010984323918819427, 0.04045558720827103, 0.0022361879236996174, 0.017652427777647972, 0.012192131951451302, -0.04157444089651108, 0.0039424411952495575, 0.0211801677942276, 0.012756089679896832, -0.041594792157411575, 0.0017884570406749845, -0.0034589311107993126, 0.025958366692066193, 0.03481303155422211, 0.01137478556483984, -0.003974935971200466, -0.012683918699622154, 0.005815919488668442, -0.007232865784317255, 0.07751822471618652, -0.05013357847929001, 0.031224627047777176, 0.01670367270708084, -0.03719760850071907, 0.06593068689107895, 0.003939957823604345, 0.003390663303434849, -0.0076773944310843945, 0.04733557626605034, -0.02884685806930065, -0.04703400656580925, -0.03150472417473793, 0.004809100180864334, 0.08901462703943253, 0.02441791631281376, 0.0023948275484144688, 0.038561396300792694, 0.04531210660934448, 0.006879075430333614, -0.015331367962062359, -0.016537616029381752, -0.017324527725577354, -0.029542073607444763, 0.04999672248959541, -0.008993982337415218, -0.006004482042044401, 0.05613558739423752, 0.01363843958824873, 0.03629858419299126, 0.0050154016353189945, 0.026477618142962456, 0.03434601053595543, -0.007015360053628683, -0.03394391015172005, -0.020657123997807503, 0.0188460610806942, -0.04149980470538139, -0.05390147492289543, -0.024336080998182297, 0.0003334395296406001, 0.032198335975408554, 0.05383940413594246, 0.005378468427807093, -0.04833044484257698, -0.0334964282810688, -0.0426090732216835, 0.05455008149147034, 0.021392066031694412, -0.019212668761610985, 0.03898012638092041, 0.004082707222551107, 0.010434520430862904, 0.011571807786822319, 0.03224169835448265, -0.011138715781271458, -0.09406449645757675, -0.018163420259952545, 0.007165703922510147, -0.033152151852846146, 0.033104944974184036, -0.00007059818017296493, -0.010520425625145435, 0.033928923308849335, -0.0199798122048378, 0.007550301495939493, -0.011142161674797535, 0.05384701490402222, -0.03788062185049057, 0.054392989724874496, -0.00530883576720953, 0.03184733912348747, -0.010075082071125507, 0.007776953745633364, 0.12997421622276306, 0.033556707203388214, 0.04972941428422928, -0.04088892787694931, 0.006441931705921888, 0.0185709111392498, -0.05169237405061722, -0.0037859552539885044, 0.030052149668335915, 0.01736590825021267, -0.02338511310517788, 0.06105342134833336, 0.03460134193301201, 0.0014915924984961748, -0.04330761730670929, 0.03665723651647568, -0.05852199345827103, -0.004587199538946152, 0.017565717920660973, 0.0026899303775280714, -0.005084466654807329, -0.0631207674741745, 0.0023100641556084156, -0.018326271325349808, 0.011796549893915653, -0.0005338412011042237, -0.008000302128493786, 0.0004686441970989108, 0.00925948191434145, 0.0016179060330614448, 0.0012125530047342181, 0.05462529882788658, -0.019411224871873856, 0.03377527743577957, 0.009229732677340508, 0.007022252772003412, 0.017808280885219574, -0.010440655052661896, 0.024701900780200958, 0.01014601718634367, -0.020439432933926582, 0.001735782832838595, -0.012961591593921185, 0.006760694552212954, -0.018953433260321617, -0.054827820509672165, -0.043139055371284485, 0.0055089727975428104, -0.003310772590339184, -0.019935479387640953, 0.015446576289832592, -0.013526631519198418, 0.027715271338820457, -0.06269952654838562, 0.0069950842298567295, 0.01218117494136095, 0.04647791385650635, 0.005066270008683205, 0.003018745454028249, -0.031131889671087265, 0.049135830253362656, 0.018797490745782852, 0.0022969667334109545, 0.027454130351543427, -0.009060108102858067, -0.007145707495510578, -0.04719432443380356, 0.039944399148225784, 0.0015568570233881474, -0.01880912482738495, -0.030394967645406723, -0.046858374029397964, -0.018537582829594612, -0.017946602776646614, -0.012689568102359772, 0.018732205033302307, 0.0538506880402565, -0.014011903665959835, -0.011090518906712532, -0.016924438998103142, -0.03591059148311615, 0.006646403111517429, 0.0050553553737699986, -0.047039132565259933, -0.06268934160470963, -0.0037758450489491224, 0.06819965690374374, 0.026185298338532448, -0.01734529249370098, 0.06406600028276443, -0.021863574162125587, 0.058506883680820465, -0.010676955804228783, -0.02679838053882122, 0.009678804315626621, -0.03523177653551102, -0.010095582343637943, -0.009359496645629406, -0.010960730724036694, 0.04327806085348129, 0.021902626380324364, 0.06363983452320099, -0.014281689189374447, 0.07399725168943405, -0.01867193542420864, 0.011152222752571106, -0.009740345180034637, -0.05355034023523331, -0.029288284480571747, -0.016687411814928055, 0.021232714876532555, -0.019073599949479103, -0.022886646911501884, -0.03993915393948555, -0.026561977341771126, 0.02348628081381321, -0.044339634478092194, -0.03199835866689682, 0.018160518258810043, -0.024016881361603737, -0.008328333497047424, -0.04521043226122856, 0.003187544411048293, -0.020852139219641685, 0.0012731988681480289, -0.030745284631848335, 0.013295608572661877, 0.015215340070426464, -0.006886606570333242, 0.0022298500407487154, 0.012432943098247051, 0.014135133475065231, 0.021530471742153168, -0.026824507862329483, -0.001291925203986466, 0.011602561920881271, -0.014112738892436028, 0.051479633897542953, 0.01184816099703312, -0.01243905071169138, 0.01357472874224186, -0.053118180483579636, -0.026799973100423813, 0.036692168563604355, -0.005531692877411842, 0.020975545048713684, -0.020668741315603256, -0.011966567486524582, -0.025845589116215706, 0.05339620262384415, 0.013801803812384605, -0.015323685482144356, 0.029985900968313217, -0.009798807092010975, -0.016947906464338303, 0.013751654885709286, -0.004475307185202837, 0.03218621760606766, -0.018597373738884926, 0.020701814442873, 0.015485292300581932, -0.0032549852039664984, 0.009249605238437653, 0.004541566129773855, 0.034936051815748215, -0.02059817500412464, -0.021134940907359123, -0.025452731177210808, 0.028208831325173378, 0.06559865921735764, 0.012651213444769382, 0.02205476723611355, -0.007730270270258188, 0.016995906829833984, -0.019188186153769493, -0.015438556671142578, -0.002581715816631913, 0.02994033508002758, 0.03697923198342323, -0.05201757326722145, 0.013162868097424507, -0.001896364032290876, -0.03795083612203598, -0.003994641825556755, 0.003595181507989764, -0.003992417361587286, -0.04493609815835953, 0.04012763872742653, -0.028850967064499855, 0.00520816957578063, 0.017127346247434616, 0.012568202801048756, -0.024070648476481438, -0.012674964964389801, 0.006930789444595575, -0.02113381028175354, -0.061706140637397766, 0.00882526021450758, 0.004988661967217922, -0.04334706813097, 0.08096323162317276, -0.05040602758526802, -0.08936464786529541, 0.024609873071312904, -0.030533866956830025, 0.014987342059612274, 0.005328523460775614, 0.04465845599770546, 0.02847621589899063, 0.005805968306958675, 0.02750188671052456, -0.0010572961764410138, -0.0032642718870192766, 0.007752546574920416, -0.039960846304893494, 0.018198002129793167, -0.03922783583402634, -0.002894548000767827, -0.009309733286499977, -0.009350800886750221, -0.053082797676324844, 0.044711410999298096, 0.016475878655910492, -0.02431991510093212, -0.012621941976249218, -0.009023608639836311, 0.015041757375001907, 0.007776583079248667, 0.005803739186376333, -0.004681644029915333, 0.008636928163468838, 0.023334022611379623, 0.04631343483924866, 0.0030690159182995558, 0.03818755969405174, 0.0115373395383358, -0.03751300647854805, 0.038490165024995804, 0.008132648654282093, -0.013767458498477936, -0.033773306757211685, -0.00814031157642603, -0.0015545374481007457, 0.00413662102073431, 0.006316976621747017, -0.012904254719614983, -0.056163687258958817, 0.04274675250053406, -0.011376133188605309, 0.016015980392694473, 0.020927026867866516, -0.006465529091656208, 0.01528275478631258, -0.06592407077550888, 0.06893340498209, 0.011616387404501438, 0.00784533191472292, -0.019629735499620438, -0.03755217790603638, -0.00501365726813674, -0.019342562183737755, 0.06002200022339821, -0.016770469024777412, -0.017322754487395287, -0.006336891558021307, -0.017796261236071587, -0.025420334190130234, -0.034677643328905106, 0.02049361914396286, 0.005060102790594101, 0.0038338175509124994, -0.008929252624511719, 0.01806071773171425, -0.019401153549551964, 0.01815480925142765, -0.013287830166518688, -0.04601869359612465, -0.0016464351210743189, 0.004460554104298353, 0.034630291163921356, 0.03457733616232872, 0.0013826474314555526, 0.01667262241244316, 0.0080488882958889, -0.01904468610882759, 0.009137782268226147, 0.028407353907823563, -0.043535999953746796, -0.044843316078186035, 0.0748983696103096, -0.029256239533424377, -0.021839164197444916, 0.02041337639093399, 0.020810220390558243, -0.01068083569407463, -0.038416117429733276, 0.029397543519735336, 0.03422969952225685, -0.027881568297743797, 0.003488300833851099, 0.0193657036870718, 0.01926887407898903, 0.010350958444178104, 0.016561441123485565, 0.03435811772942543, 0.003248631488531828, -0.058727312833070755, 0.011236459948122501, -0.010560176335275173, 0.028947044163942337, 0.003057769499719143, 0.003327316604554653, 0.003273681504651904, -0.008089795708656311, 0.01181131973862648, 0.0001235550589626655, 0.036878712475299835, -0.05304291471838951, -0.04169045016169548, 0.057106610387563705, 0.021076669916510582, -0.024788571521639824, -0.005642991978675127, -0.016928479075431824, 0.08208438009023666, -0.021926941350102425, 0.014110120013356209, -0.009398664347827435, -0.005840788595378399, -0.024907996878027916, 0.014317297376692295, -0.040997214615345, -0.02214377373456955, -0.0065843197517097, 0.033989258110523224, -0.03934162110090256, -0.02886795625090599, 0.021478021517395973, -0.03769122436642647, -0.028496835380792618, 0.002603697357699275, -0.0019385848427191377, 0.012934310361742973, 0.019267093390226364, -0.03524433448910713, -0.006953510921448469, -0.0067598395980894566, 0.042922332882881165, 0.00096595857758075, -0.026358308270573616, -0.022632256150245667, 0.009913969784975052, 0.001834828406572342, -0.037269625812768936, -0.02008938603103161, -0.03105299361050129, 0.004412223119288683, -0.009003737010061741, -0.005986894015222788 ]
<p>I aim to discriminate between three populations by using a maximum likelihood classifier. The idea is that every population has a unique distribution $\hat{f_i} (x)$. The pdf $\hat{f_i}(x)$ has been estimated on a set of training data. A new set of observations $(x_1,...x_p)$ will be assigned to the population for which $\log(q_i)+\sum_{j=1}^p \log(\hat{f_i}(x_j))$ is maximized. I want to investigate if the difference in the likelihoods are significant. How should I a perform a likelihood ratio test? I could of course perform the "standard" test in which I test $\lambda=\frac{L_0}{L_1} $ and then take $\chi^2= -2 \log \lambda$, but as I understand this test is used when there is a difference in the number of parameters between $L_1$ and $L_0$ . </p> <p>"Let L0 be the maximum value of the likelihood when the parameters are restricted (and reduced in number) based on the assumption. Assume k parameters were lost (i.e., L0 has k less parameters than L1)." </p> <p>Or is this correct? Otherwise how should the test be performed? </p>
73,431
[ -0.041574884206056595, -0.025279568508267403, -0.011420502327382565, 0.020964007824659348, 0.009824835695326328, 0.008566081523895264, -0.005978379398584366, -0.015627844259142876, 0.011441928334534168, -0.03276927396655083, 0.029283782467246056, 0.043641552329063416, 0.02322111651301384, 0.02544661983847618, 0.043842051178216934, -0.0007726154290139675, -0.04339316487312317, 0.04135126620531082, -0.003281455719843507, -0.0007178941159509122, -0.017358221113681793, 0.030401546508073807, 0.04614177718758583, -0.014038189314305782, -0.017506755888462067, 0.030147148296236992, 0.040806274861097336, -0.017876937985420227, -0.0016822010511532426, 0.05503619462251663, -0.05181112512946129, -0.02460857480764389, -0.012440160848200321, 0.03936678543686867, 0.009780705906450748, 0.019956031814217567, -0.014824872836470604, -0.0464712493121624, -0.002204730873927474, 0.04083692654967308, -0.06672272831201553, -0.013761102221906185, 0.03454915061593056, 0.022405162453651428, 0.0030878265388309956, 0.032556887716054916, -0.006068287882953882, -0.037270743399858475, -0.006561934016644955, -0.0467178151011467, 0.06509838998317719, 0.03773032873868942, 0.005232789553701878, 0.02523130737245083, 0.0122459065169096, -0.04005945101380348, 0.02650446817278862, 0.09761335700750351, -0.005473779048770666, -0.03414896875619888, -0.027773799374699593, -0.021032441407442093, 0.014623229391872883, -0.0005436064093373716, -0.03757062926888466, 0.031234825029969215, 0.0006273240433074534, -0.008641538210213184, 0.029573217034339905, -0.014022882096469402, 0.003923366311937571, 0.028226440772414207, 0.03486405685544014, -0.0008320151828229427, 0.0011123197618871927, -0.011598877608776093, -0.012950293719768524, 0.06718257814645767, 0.04462062940001488, 0.009279520250856876, 0.01530186366289854, 0.008444842882454395, 0.021285122260451317, 0.048304665833711624, 0.017503472045063972, -0.006816624663770199, 0.08904467523097992, -0.03285757452249527, 0.015737134963274002, 0.014697556383907795, -0.06130234897136688, 0.021152189001441002, 0.04481023922562599, -0.03752515837550163, -0.07523372769355774, 0.03270542994141579, -0.029921602457761765, 0.02243346907198429, -0.0069975294172763824, -0.005374903790652752, -0.016631491482257843, -0.033223990350961685, 0.010459515266120434, 0.036468904465436935, 0.011938191950321198, 0.027218615636229515, -0.030451973900198936, -0.0020684050396084785, -0.017671359702944756, -0.016848746687173843, -0.007724821101874113, 0.0409669429063797, -0.01764572411775589, 0.029585355892777443, -0.03268041834235191, -0.004704394843429327, -0.008295407518744469, -0.02510412596166134, 0.07265126705169678, 0.03211592137813568, 0.036250386387109756, -0.006352508906275034, 0.007852357812225819, 0.005254893563687801, -0.03302846848964691, 0.009393200278282166, -0.005502717103809118, -0.0046440837904810905, -0.051265232264995575, 0.06925737112760544, -0.01013693492859602, -0.006804405711591244, 0.04421543329954147, 0.015191401354968548, -0.014229985885322094, -0.0033341513480991125, -0.08233354985713959, -0.020358417183160782, 0.03053763322532177, -0.014056073501706123, 0.03665401414036751, -0.06012563407421112, -0.03261580690741539, 0.053349338471889496, 0.04103073477745056, -0.0018067675409838557, 0.028692353516817093, -0.007352853659540415, 0.02302052453160286, 0.014597635716199875, -0.019995925948023796, -0.009631084278225899, -0.054657235741615295, 0.006077025551348925, -0.03556878864765167, -0.05344214290380478, -0.025421584025025368, 0.022518247365951538, -0.01601349003612995, -0.01531143207103014, 0.05490846931934357, 0.010921118780970573, -0.025703445076942444, 0.003993090242147446, 0.008525831624865532, -0.009556511417031288, 0.06199226155877113, 0.010149801149964333, 0.03409016877412796, 0.003391168313100934, -0.013894988223910332, 0.026052260771393776, 0.009097285568714142, 0.04600854963064194, 0.06598486006259918, -0.03633181378245354, -0.019593095406889915, -0.06634996086359024, 0.03661636635661125, 0.021998008713126183, -0.036483000963926315, -0.012821642681956291, -0.01593203656375408, -0.011537950485944748, 0.032885316759347916, 0.021324144676327705, 0.011064251884818077, -0.012244455516338348, 0.06641187518835068, -0.05989658460021019, -0.05600421875715256, -0.04962152615189552, -0.024171240627765656, 0.0017388710984960198, -0.03129597008228302, 0.04636012762784958, 0.043992601335048676, 0.024700310081243515, -0.011223128996789455, 0.001855484559200704, -0.029333792626857758, -0.017713090404868126, 0.03087000362575054, 0.009211832657456398, 0.022298147901892662, 0.05697863921523094, 0.030333518981933594, -0.03408105671405792, 0.07323483377695084, -0.03308669850230217, -0.03785252943634987, 0.020274866372346878, -0.010744146071374416, 0.011003716848790646, 0.018660448491573334, 0.013899505138397217, -0.0010908889817073941, 0.004772576969116926, -0.036763910204172134, 0.05347175523638725, -0.060607023537158966, 0.06364567577838898, 0.06646057218313217, 0.01285532210022211, 0.0011404633987694979, -0.025873782113194466, -0.0075619337148964405, 0.025050297379493713, -0.02409289963543415, 0.008182763122022152, -0.11315737664699554, -0.020551545545458794, 0.044972989708185196, 0.011754879727959633, -0.06038783863186836, 0.03195076435804367, 0.02560253068804741, 0.00005112201688461937, -0.00409849314019084, 0.03419803828001022, -0.0006724264821968973, -0.030225465074181557, 0.018929727375507355, 0.022018542513251305, -0.014245284721255302, 0.032983891665935516, 0.06969795376062393, -0.03686387464404106, 0.03551614657044411, -0.01714489236474037, 0.008588641881942749, 0.052187398076057434, 0.01033626589924097, 0.008094613440334797, -0.010893895290791988, -0.002060679020360112, 0.014858963899314404, -0.02812179923057556, 0.007890778593719006, 0.010445077903568745, -0.01302294246852398, -0.01284873578697443, -0.01477019302546978, 0.022819574922323227, 0.03905944898724556, 0.022145241498947144, -0.01731875166296959, 0.015846960246562958, 0.024684324860572815, -0.10898707807064056, 0.0009959746384993196, -0.027738142758607864, -0.022168122231960297, -0.012752759270370007, 0.015627209097146988, 0.013772978447377682, -0.0025310227647423744, 0.020690424367785454, -0.012420499697327614, -0.061433251947164536, 0.024134667590260506, -0.033115360885858536, 0.05953538417816162, 0.008741583675146103, -0.05380014702677727, -0.012306192889809608, -0.01478631142526865, -0.040264714509248734, 0.02541792392730713, -0.006606978364288807, 0.0018947913777083158, -0.011696485802531242, -0.01302685309201479, -0.0608864389359951, -0.0383511483669281, -0.031236525624990463, 0.029167741537094116, -0.011814950965344906, -0.011030075140297413, 0.048944324254989624, 0.01459892001003027, -0.022116683423519135, 0.020571881905198097, -0.033109698444604874, -0.017567435279488564, -0.01180423703044653, 0.000060072270571254194, -0.006866586394608021, -0.0034680822864174843, -0.02556033246219158, 0.03464944288134575, -0.001049756072461605, -0.009600446559488773, -0.07567007839679718, -0.0691675990819931, 0.020154573023319244, -0.006735457107424736, 0.04562067240476608, -0.03123793937265873, -0.02918374352157116, 0.06495491415262222, 0.05366838350892067, 0.014761067926883698, -0.03443000093102455, 0.026097679510712624, -0.039134807884693146, -0.013015693053603172, 0.006262814626097679, 0.00928617361932993, 0.02997722662985325, 0.06005936115980148, -0.0022861850447952747, 0.018214337527751923, 0.0326727069914341, -0.025028947740793228, -0.023333314806222916, 0.050269223749637604, 0.0008313839789479971, -0.049755752086639404, 0.05093678832054138, 0.019893931224942207, -0.015643857419490814, 0.034545451402664185, -0.003789168316870928, 0.013090894557535648, 0.020695416256785393, -0.01924951560795307, 0.03380245342850685, -0.00026936212088912725, -0.006696063559502363, 0.0038847560063004494, 0.016163310036063194, 0.027116168290376663, -0.04984927177429199, 0.004508098587393761, 0.02106056921184063, 0.021499870344996452, -0.03391577675938606, -0.02105586975812912, 0.031957175582647324, 0.039224378764629364, -0.014380715787410736, -0.023025965318083763, -0.026623042300343513, -0.055276647210121155, 0.012086655013263226, -0.0008489663596265018, -0.027097800746560097, 0.02557787485420704, 0.010616136714816093, 0.023300083354115486, -0.01868869550526142, -0.022647980600595474, -0.007365761324763298, -0.02685428224503994, 0.0029338740278035402, 0.0010321326553821564, 0.056345585733652115, 0.003264024620875716, 0.02336358092725277, 0.027203509584069252, -0.028591612353920937, 0.018673863261938095, -0.004807267338037491, -0.10184379667043686, 0.042294979095458984, 0.0018361547263339162, 0.011537410318851471, 0.016997305676341057, -0.033489350229501724, 0.039809927344322205, -0.0591312050819397, 0.014053544960916042, -0.017126305028796196, 0.023644182831048965, -0.0421370193362236, 0.024685360491275787, -0.037307076156139374, -0.018433433026075363, 0.0167014691978693, 0.0738222748041153, -0.0129174729809165, -0.006359646562486887, 0.02796122245490551, 0.0740722194314003, -0.011064755730330944, -0.02255762368440628, -0.007869396358728409, 0.015590723603963852, -0.010418453253805637, 0.017303461208939552, 0.026959531009197235, 0.026709824800491333, -0.049221914261579514, 0.03860732167959213, -0.016764111816883087, 0.05441932752728462, 0.03911582753062248, 0.003044081386178732, -0.004679069854319096, -0.030358802527189255, -0.042162422090768814, -0.027189839631319046, 0.02947421558201313, 0.0166846364736557, -0.05756249278783798, 0.04878184199333191, 0.050710249692201614, -0.04984290897846222, 0.020722877234220505, 0.0498582161962986, -0.0005060730618424714, -0.005907568149268627, 0.0083068972453475, 0.008604273200035095, -0.011575935408473015, 0.009933347813785076, -0.0044413842260837555, 0.02500436268746853, -0.02771150693297386, 0.002456552814692259, 0.05569017305970192, 0.006131080910563469, -0.027235666289925575, -0.004982548765838146, 0.011162505485117435, 0.0365157276391983, 0.0024754933547228575, -0.013869385235011578, 0.02823728695511818, 0.02102101780474186, 0.026742415502667427, -0.001823181053623557, 0.037716127932071686, -0.08340933918952942, -0.004708032589405775, 0.06509453803300858, 0.04189540445804596, -0.059963107109069824, -0.013944992795586586, -0.045225366950035095, 0.01658201590180397, 0.013384808786213398, -0.020904766395688057, 0.011546632274985313, 0.008605853654444218, 0.003141873050481081, -0.04085564613342285, 0.012106698006391525, -0.0650733932852745, 0.018382824957370758, -0.024256844073534012, 0.017118675634264946, -0.041263461112976074, 0.01499449647963047, -0.04718374088406563, 0.019314374774694443, 0.003815323580056429, 0.08868909627199173, -0.006546752993017435, -0.032560646533966064, 0.019475707784295082, 0.009173073805868626, -0.024564504623413086, -0.05156008154153824, 0.007440690882503986, -0.003283126512542367, -0.008328280411660671, 0.03234066069126129, -0.032603148370981216, -0.05950455740094185, 0.004776752088218927, 0.00763776246458292, -0.04846569895744324, 0.01861117221415043, -0.004191284999251366, 0.010484514757990837, 0.013135349377989769, 0.015690598636865616, 0.0651581659913063, 0.010682075284421444, -0.016476204618811607, 0.006304472219198942, -0.02825135923922062, 0.009029344655573368, -0.021527327597141266, -0.020488671958446503, -0.051026806235313416, 0.03898042067885399, -0.015767298638820648, 0.0071564931422472, 0.013556936755776405, 0.06349719315767288, -0.008614624850451946, -0.005905544385313988, -0.01612302102148533, -0.00007281512080226094, 0.010943430475890636, 0.01551171112805605, 0.01646866463124752, 0.04525713250041008, -0.004611407406628132, 0.026916375383734703, 0.019754989072680473, -0.04272819310426712, 0.02111138217151165, 0.038093458861112595, -0.03434441611170769, 0.03560108691453934, -0.030736492946743965, -0.014790968969464302, -0.01892242766916752, 0.00328535633161664, 0.056542713195085526, 0.019297132268548012, 0.03982219099998474, 0.02027752809226513, -0.02270151861011982, -0.012458902783691883, 0.009641828015446663, -0.006132620852440596, 0.05716027319431305, -0.039704445749521255, 0.028538784012198448, -0.0155915142968297, 0.00681832293048501, -0.04737401753664017, 0.004734579008072615, -0.02475583367049694, 0.02507454715669155, -0.028924230486154556, -0.03909202665090561, -0.03264307603240013, 0.02481306530535221, -0.03756529837846756, -0.013116786256432533, 0.09077184647321701, -0.001271294429898262, -0.01482507772743702, -0.0031505352817475796, 0.0297634806483984, 0.05770150572061539, 0.014813849702477455, -0.003639142494648695, 0.002458779839798808, 0.014225905761122704, -0.0009656932088546455, -0.005756238475441933, 0.006597436033189297, -0.016378145664930344, -0.029756082221865654, -0.013150623068213463, 0.02418757975101471, 0.015076433308422565, -0.03884365037083626, -0.05384110286831856, 0.016959790140390396, -0.02046123705804348, 0.014589648693799973, -0.04490397870540619, -0.01103898137807846, -0.043854840099811554, 0.008594774641096592, -0.0371328629553318, 0.02551989257335663, -0.0017139629926532507, -0.015815436840057373, 0.05174781382083893, -0.01226488035172224, 0.005750612355768681, 0.006461260840296745, 0.09651193767786026, 0.006519719958305359, 0.007636211346834898, 0.003535509342327714, -0.011857699602842331, 0.0608249269425869, 0.00696688424795866, 0.011711093597114086, -0.0037537384778261185, 0.048942212015390396, -0.018404526636004448, 0.018268339335918427, -0.04598341882228851, -0.00422164611518383, 0.060879502445459366, 0.019591687247157097, 0.031126176938414574, 0.03646843507885933, 0.02167213335633278, 0.02055557444691658, -0.027341680601239204, -0.018652869388461113, -0.018751606345176697, -0.020499812439084053, 0.02050384320318699, -0.005603270139545202, -0.022792553529143333, 0.05917643383145332, -0.025826063007116318, 0.030869020149111748, 0.04990642890334129, 0.016701772809028625, 0.016246633604168892, 0.0049937027506530285, -0.049719907343387604, -0.06387587636709213, 0.06321848183870316, -0.05423852801322937, 0.022237688302993774, -0.037772879004478455, -0.02900671772658825, 0.05760936439037323, 0.02955443598330021, 0.025438029319047928, -0.04249631240963936, -0.014917436987161636, -0.0695224180817604, 0.05529659613966942, 0.04080493003129959, -0.0042404793202877045, 0.06411051750183105, -0.0029534841887652874, 0.06264550983905792, 0.00008380919462069869, 0.006464793812483549, -0.027663499116897583, -0.06187058985233307, -0.029009956866502762, 0.016567980870604515, -0.014260372146964073, 0.010267374105751514, -0.02415315806865692, -0.03998086228966713, 0.014895981177687645, -0.02558101713657379, 0.02119266986846924, -0.009563347324728966, 0.05353355407714844, -0.019321879372000694, 0.06193959340453148, 0.01730947010219097, 0.020695369690656662, -0.004291187971830368, -0.012627747841179371, 0.11900673061609268, 0.054122310131788254, 0.03272172808647156, -0.03357672691345215, 0.02025086060166359, -0.008073021657764912, 0.0022507882677018642, -0.026509715244174004, 0.02049107290804386, -0.01579047553241253, 0.010702146217226982, 0.014959369786083698, 0.01854531653225422, -0.02011093683540821, -0.03222931548953056, 0.07554114609956741, -0.020219117403030396, -0.04941105470061302, 0.03600257262587547, 0.004722912330180407, -0.0009051731321960688, -0.025658410042524338, -0.028234925121068954, 0.02138693816959858, -0.001835160655900836, -0.01424157340079546, -0.015869302675127983, -0.02283337712287903, -0.00281529757194221, -0.03361288458108902, -0.03107115440070629, 0.015511279925704002, 0.0240098275244236, -0.002654338488355279, -0.0015510015655308962, 0.01401747390627861, -0.04689596965909004, -0.04000251367688179, 0.026654278859496117, 0.05974521487951279, 0.021652361378073692, -0.00745314359664917, -0.0011886616703122854, 0.009068287909030914, -0.022813759744167328, -0.030405240133404732, -0.033907972276210785, 0.045566994696855545, -0.0101675009354949, -0.0239707101136446, -0.012467075139284134, 0.0013936464674770832, -0.0365632064640522, -0.023784875869750977, -0.009113488718867302, -0.004627235233783722, 0.0389634445309639, -0.02475936897099018, -0.02538197860121727, -0.05060562118887901, 0.03446520119905472, -0.0005898115341551602, 0.018820632249116898, -0.009208064526319504, -0.032734181731939316, -0.00945669412612915, -0.006303683388978243, 0.01383647695183754, 0.007436526473611593, 0.004013278521597385, -0.0023170295171439648, -0.009344255551695824, 0.005198677536100149, -0.03383269160985947, 0.004750250373035669, 0.012578488327562809, 0.040922969579696655, 0.0319695845246315, -0.02620619162917137, -0.004919603932648897, -0.07966786623001099, 0.011886056512594223, -0.016804488375782967, 0.01414223201572895, -0.04225935786962509, -0.0371318981051445, 0.034643709659576416, 0.01788661628961563, 0.03423052281141281, 0.00021279972861520946, 0.018691081553697586, 0.05748695135116577, 0.0027187790255993605, -0.05037469044327736, -0.03998878225684166, -0.00008666750363772735, -0.012957889586687088, 0.01928420551121235, -0.044083140790462494, 0.03845005854964256, 0.041406579315662384, 0.025260737165808678, 0.007748764008283615, 0.005585901904851198, 0.0034958079922944307, 0.016708416864275932, 0.011481117457151413, -0.011717262677848339, 0.009526778012514114, 0.016637399792671204, 0.012848624028265476, -0.01181354932487011, -0.07131229341030121, -0.034377582371234894, -0.02933442033827305, 0.008491006679832935, -0.03769378736615181, -0.03215370699763298, 0.006034527439624071, -0.025342121720314026, -0.016430474817752838, -0.038721632212400436, -0.021051621064543724, -0.008701409213244915, 0.00509230699390173, -0.008898606523871422, -0.00912631768733263, -0.008699771016836166, 0.008559535257518291, -0.015110685490071774, -0.016736788675189018, 0.035740070044994354, -0.027744540944695473, 0.0054407063871622086, 0.018579136580228806, -0.018401721492409706, -0.0053369272500276566, 0.06139856576919556, -0.023091545328497887, 0.0008087563910521567, 0.05223377048969269, -0.03865626081824303, -0.03800954297184944, 0.013713421300053596, 0.01900538057088852, 0.04901578277349472, 0.0181515421718359, 0.01616746373474598, -0.030283818021416664, 0.016042126342654228, 0.02903170697391033, -0.0027820535469800234, -0.01284088846296072, 0.007581693585962057, -0.008589322678744793, -0.01538048405200243, -0.016037432476878166, -0.002536033745855093, -0.024895157665014267, 0.014464463107287884, 0.039776336401700974, -0.00747576542198658, 0.003189018229022622, 0.012658199295401573, 0.007385447155684233, 0.03492669016122818, -0.011193696409463882, -0.002156257862225175, 0.03197694197297096, 0.03978573903441429, -0.0048090689815580845, 0.020178526639938354, -0.036141932010650635, 0.003616935107856989, -0.10638546198606491, -0.02077212557196617, 0.020588979125022888, 0.010575493797659874, 0.00014940193796064705, -0.06008598208427429, 0.0073716589249670506, 0.02408791147172451, -0.0033222315832972527, -0.018519243225455284, -0.0260612852871418, 0.016625255346298218, -0.04781826213002205, 0.0029331622645258904, 0.013082306832075119, 0.022149041295051575, 0.019547170028090477, -0.00272912485525012, 0.020896023139357567, 0.05121024698019028, -0.012913350947201252, -0.0077562048099935055, -0.014695459045469761, 0.004305470734834671, 0.028039012104272842, -0.07805880159139633, 0.01339089684188366, -0.0021802254486829042, -0.03713109344244003, 0.02890532836318016, 0.019750460982322693, 0.02393573522567749, 0.02691635861992836, -0.00029161933343857527, 0.01260298490524292, 0.05258157476782799, 0.05995407700538635, 0.002527046948671341, -0.0015163334319368005, 0.022826243191957474, 0.00018486705084796995, 0.009750151075422764, -0.03831635043025017, -0.03168395906686783, 0.03260798752307892, -0.021323880180716515, -0.017945416271686554, -0.006678309291601181, -0.017343105748295784, -0.003763279877603054, -0.022391511127352715, -0.022464321926236153, 0.004637436475604773, -0.0010908819967880845, 0.01337438728660345, -0.02954673208296299, -0.04422266036272049, -0.0014346952084451914, 0.05939996987581253, -0.02927779033780098, -0.006183617282658815, -0.052161019295454025, -0.0097147636115551, -0.004375469870865345, 0.012188584543764591, -0.016995932906866074, -0.05301894620060921, -0.009136161766946316, -0.01109688077121973, 0.015866370871663094, -0.04593310132622719, 0.010686577297747135, -0.026191120967268944, 0.02943594753742218, -0.06834733486175537, 0.015812216326594353, -0.0006922032334841788, 0.00004157049988862127, -0.00043724014540202916, -0.08357299119234085, 0.06530755013227463, 0.041369516402482986, -0.010127576068043709, -0.02967950329184532, -0.021617606282234192, -0.06860364973545074, 0.0032955289352685213, 0.048551686108112335, 0.03003469854593277, 0.005438674241304398, -0.005441305227577686, 0.034012988209724426, 0.011840424500405788, -0.05691897124052048, 0.027497626841068268, -0.028688352555036545, -0.034220416098833084, -0.009614715352654457, 0.0023350368719547987, 0.01960572600364685, -0.00823347456753254, 0.037273257970809937, -0.011678867973387241, -0.006997593212872744, 0.01487797312438488, -0.0028846589848399162, 0.014163591898977757, -0.018436485901474953, 0.008004769682884216, 0.032746054232120514, 0.004206767305731773, 0.01990523561835289, -0.014651247300207615, -0.002520844340324402, -0.08162276446819305, 0.027019454166293144, -0.030857067555189133, -0.03800738975405693, -0.007499513681977987, 0.01540036778897047, -0.003607505466789007, -0.017539402469992638, 0.003500391263514757, 0.011141766794025898, -0.02755778655409813, -0.006533666048198938, 0.025157632306218147, 0.038058970123529434, 0.03594692051410675, 0.011541430838406086, 0.024521663784980774, 0.007555810734629631, -0.027863038703799248, 0.019913267344236374, 0.010794672183692455, 0.0034646012354642153, -0.00626957044005394, 0.00041075333137996495, 0.016102731227874756, -0.017445312812924385, 0.006759114097803831, -0.020852725952863693, 0.04370521754026413, -0.04630368947982788, -0.01472171489149332, 0.03939492627978325, 0.008031167089939117, -0.004676569253206253, -0.039725299924612045, 0.005180795211344957, 0.05410528928041458, -0.009685463272035122, -0.009790184907615185, -0.03516530618071556, -0.006640640087425709, 0.007668842561542988, 0.02758309431374073, 0.0206616148352623, 0.011885179206728935, 0.010746159590780735, 0.028531009331345558, -0.007279002107679844, -0.01448085717856884, 0.025393038988113403, -0.02126939594745636, 0.021853631362318993, 0.025820044800639153, -0.021478043869137764, -0.0005043974379077554, -0.019802577793598175, -0.04048866778612137, -0.02078171633183956, 0.015019802376627922, 0.034257180988788605, 0.03704138472676277, -0.04854082316160202, -0.04929588362574577, 0.005125143565237522, 0.004077043384313583, -0.02726152166724205, -0.02216021716594696, -0.03686663135886192, 0.012929674237966537, 0.03823482245206833, -0.04597323760390282 ]
<p>I want to generate some spatial data where the points/location in the space form a multivariate gaussian distribution. I want these points to have certain autocorrelation given by the variogram model like spherical with spill 0.025 and range 15. I then want to generate some sample for this </p> <p>How can I do it?</p> <p>I then want to plot the empirical variogram and again fit a model variogram to check if they come out to be similar. How can I do it?</p>
73,432
[ -0.05237533152103424, 0.00045826149289496243, 0.006958482787013054, 0.00890919379889965, 0.04115677624940872, -0.010368182323873043, -0.018825555220246315, -0.02582317776978016, 0.034041982144117355, -0.02371027134358883, 0.06434210389852524, 0.06140810251235962, 0.0488278903067112, 0.029209166765213013, -0.028022831305861473, -0.021764030680060387, -0.016262132674455643, 0.005303810816258192, -0.009294089861214161, -0.025103511288762093, 0.0008644398767501116, -0.012814255431294441, 0.004631897900253534, -0.034090884029865265, -0.02628617361187935, 0.021295584738254547, 0.06600963324308395, -0.022676507011055946, 0.01839170604944229, 0.06782220304012299, -0.030587617307901382, -0.027125617489218712, 0.03567570075392723, 0.03052745945751667, 0.036138322204351425, 0.011228672228753567, -0.03524495288729668, -0.026626838371157646, 0.02099381573498249, 0.0061570326797664165, -0.07673204690217972, -0.022482039406895638, -0.01975342631340027, 0.03551821783185005, 0.006609719712287188, 0.009700194001197815, -0.023599162697792053, -0.02919889986515045, 0.031645651906728745, -0.01935158669948578, 0.09441870450973511, 0.012767108157277107, 0.03759017586708069, 0.052068501710891724, -0.010619809851050377, 0.012210189364850521, 0.06733981519937515, 0.05829113721847534, -0.003629552200436592, -0.059989940375089645, -0.010969328694045544, -0.038886986672878265, -0.007524779997766018, -0.04409376531839371, -0.03386934474110603, 0.006380974780768156, -0.019337911158800125, -0.01342822890728712, 0.031410422176122665, -0.013254844583570957, 0.017800504341721535, 0.02256300486624241, 0.015827689319849014, -0.033425744622945786, -0.0022289007902145386, -0.0017097156960517168, 0.026946209371089935, 0.030879709869623184, 0.040197137743234634, -0.02335646189749241, 0.049223892390728, 0.05266056954860687, -0.017268074676394463, -0.0017822402296587825, 0.008524850010871887, -0.0019731137435883284, 0.0424613282084465, -0.02685629203915596, 0.0026233424432575703, 0.011687048710882664, -0.007217299193143845, -0.0018336764769628644, 0.06671097874641418, 0.01731758750975132, -0.04341674968600273, 0.037608977407217026, -0.014690721407532692, 0.03829474374651909, -0.028833795338869095, -0.010023264214396477, -0.01839628629386425, -0.03806818276643753, 0.018719658255577087, 0.02832188829779625, -0.035004809498786926, 0.0020911735482513905, -0.011897834949195385, -0.03313623368740082, -0.020011238753795624, -0.032260846346616745, -0.02163090929389, 0.013492275960743427, 0.030433233827352524, -0.001919995411299169, 0.06183728948235512, 0.005168154835700989, -0.000261439272435382, -0.030870812013745308, 0.026164142414927483, 0.04577212035655975, 0.042127516120672226, -0.012419091537594795, 0.05437357351183891, -0.0593625046312809, -0.06276112049818039, -0.020192254334688187, 0.005477845668792725, -0.011750981211662292, -0.041334088891744614, 0.061655640602111816, -0.027431750670075417, -0.03293429687619209, 0.019522646442055702, -0.0013993832981213927, 0.018338492140173912, -0.009373712353408337, -0.07726506143808365, -0.058619365096092224, 0.02564227022230625, -0.018499048426747322, 0.027609771117568016, -0.05089458450675011, 0.019844377413392067, 0.005647152662277222, 0.03196210786700249, 0.024245472624897957, 0.02401437982916832, -0.024991830810904503, 0.03310076519846916, -0.0006200245115906, -0.03585206717252731, -0.029441529884934425, -0.016237325966358185, -0.01289672777056694, -0.01561798807233572, -0.10121745616197586, 0.02047916315495968, 0.03185426443815231, -0.025890912860631943, -0.016305532306432724, 0.037892866879701614, 0.00804649293422699, -0.007243385538458824, -0.015406596474349499, 0.01484224759042263, -0.04179444909095764, 0.0643487498164177, 0.0077848974615335464, 0.003010848304256797, 0.01843963749706745, -0.05381228029727936, -0.002418684307485819, 0.019443409517407417, 0.02136826328933239, 0.06878870725631714, 0.0018117122817784548, -0.00626759510487318, 0.004890847019851208, 0.024403411895036697, 0.025816118344664574, -0.02488597109913826, -0.0013013551943004131, -0.01278735138475895, -0.00590990437194705, 0.015772217884659767, 0.015547463670372963, 0.00382047682069242, 0.0118261082097888, 0.005936189088970423, -0.044426821172237396, -0.029576193541288376, -0.06588109582662582, 0.021179331466555595, 0.029104506596922874, -0.007195069454610348, 0.027532527223229408, -0.01577395386993885, 0.01686430536210537, -0.002772195963189006, -0.03101433999836445, -0.016753671690821648, -0.005088400561362505, 0.02456853538751602, -0.02778680808842182, -0.002974105766043067, 0.05528142303228378, 0.046725425869226456, -0.0041195545345544815, 0.038559406995773315, 0.003291645785793662, -0.008151053451001644, -0.03689393773674965, 0.0000014616082353313686, 0.0016063525108620524, -0.018936211243271828, 0.004932325333356857, -0.022102242335677147, 0.03388923406600952, -0.0366278775036335, 0.0247795507311821, -0.06717361509799957, 0.055466510355472565, 0.12486641854047775, 0.009617729112505913, 0.008420750498771667, 0.0003050150698982179, 0.005881174001842737, 0.046968329697847366, -0.00006636685429839417, -0.059638623148202896, -0.04014800861477852, 0.012548893690109253, 0.017580188810825348, 0.02205011434853077, -0.02193046174943447, -0.0031534130685031414, 0.04539841413497925, 0.04519371688365936, 0.01920667104423046, 0.06399939209222794, 0.015260948799550533, 0.015802858397364616, -0.0019177591893821955, -0.00010169095185119659, 0.03539523109793663, 0.0019609241280704737, 0.03383791819214821, 0.011792411096394062, 0.036420729011297226, -0.038957539945840836, -0.013172972947359085, 0.02270127832889557, -0.032534241676330566, -0.04570743814110756, -0.012793571688234806, 0.01268770918250084, 0.007902825251221657, -0.006938792299479246, 0.00006678153295069933, 0.03757688030600548, -0.004194716922938824, -0.02410234697163105, -0.016650468111038208, -0.019088612869381905, 0.007549754809588194, 0.049993813037872314, -0.017940426245331764, 0.02586827240884304, 0.016419721767306328, -0.019947366788983345, 0.031309276819229126, 0.010764636099338531, -0.015661243349313736, -0.05097593739628792, 0.03018379583954811, 0.04676417261362076, 0.009307896718382835, 0.004900611937046051, -0.004136419855058193, -0.03441606089472771, 0.00633204123005271, 0.008891100063920021, 0.008944109082221985, 0.028308721259236336, -0.0385420061647892, 0.0009725627023726702, -0.02408510446548462, 0.03429392725229263, -0.0036811602767556906, -0.009660241194069386, 0.005252222530543804, 0.01762678660452366, 0.04020429775118828, -0.04166357219219208, 0.01762254908680916, 0.010166897438466549, 0.02297322265803814, -0.03416461497545242, -0.015230054967105389, -0.0015144414501264691, 0.02331649884581566, -0.05015731230378151, 0.026074353605508804, -0.01858612708747387, 0.006930418778210878, -0.017317544668912888, 0.02263491041958332, 0.012178941629827023, -0.04750300943851471, 0.04062419757246971, 0.06450432538986206, 0.001936409855261445, -0.017537856474518776, -0.045794516801834106, -0.03895372897386551, 0.004950690548866987, 0.014431411400437355, 0.02673649601638317, -0.005865221843123436, -0.01789523847401142, 0.04206124320626259, 0.053175751119852066, -0.01683685928583145, -0.056695230305194855, 0.0003783550637308508, -0.013180851936340332, -0.043366689234972, 0.0034544644877314568, -0.015022533014416695, -0.009227457456290722, -0.010429815389215946, 0.012305861338973045, -0.014591827057301998, 0.033371761441230774, -0.005535950884222984, 0.014942816458642483, -0.002526300959289074, -0.014193382114171982, -0.018376115709543228, 0.030903896316885948, -0.007261148653924465, -0.04698062315583229, -0.027351029217243195, -0.005437007639557123, 0.0034152541775256395, 0.019580138847231865, -0.006393902935087681, -0.013594452291727066, -0.015587110072374344, -0.0007039632764644921, -0.05003586411476135, 0.0170782171189785, 0.018595591187477112, -0.014554743655025959, 0.0018286914564669132, 0.019867653027176857, 0.02123335562646389, 0.021914251148700714, -0.03908975422382355, 0.04950176179409027, 0.02158069983124733, -0.023086681962013245, 0.021048391237854958, -0.017390035092830658, 0.03907207027077675, 0.02411237731575966, -0.018996259197592735, -0.003264111001044512, 0.015641197562217712, 0.03405476361513138, 0.04455501213669777, -0.0003703903057612479, -0.04209400340914726, 0.017102597281336784, -0.03831132873892784, 0.027463218197226524, -0.004752229433506727, 0.03345948085188866, 0.013400441035628319, 0.036800358444452286, 0.022907812148332596, -0.030660223215818405, 0.011297080665826797, -0.023414311930537224, -0.04981039837002754, 0.04388110339641571, 0.002343285595998168, -0.01848749816417694, -0.000380840094294399, -0.04459268972277641, 0.021451089531183243, -0.004642069805413485, 0.010425134561955929, 0.03422396257519722, 0.01969192363321781, -0.020050199702382088, 0.010901411063969135, -0.0353977233171463, -0.028101710602641106, -0.03825487196445465, 0.02711469680070877, 0.03488371521234512, -0.02797822654247284, 0.051762014627456665, 0.004373779986053705, 0.0038622694555670023, -0.033169765025377274, -0.003817794844508171, 0.024701116606593132, 0.024415360763669014, 0.02103559672832489, 0.02217346802353859, 0.0270623117685318, -0.023244207724928856, 0.007213253993541002, 0.0007687720353715122, 0.08064035326242447, 0.04965999349951744, 0.012274728156626225, 0.012517026625573635, -0.042517051100730896, -0.012533467262983322, 0.028204824775457382, 0.015024994499981403, -0.027838049456477165, -0.020812591537833214, 0.03518613800406456, -0.0035541413817554712, -0.0779915526509285, 0.016381144523620605, 0.062437646090984344, -0.00800298061221838, 0.018327830359339714, 0.006800930947065353, 0.00434822216629982, 0.010284042917191982, -0.024934547021985054, 0.04731115326285362, 0.00709277531132102, -0.017847340553998947, 0.0016980839427560568, 0.023854056373238564, -0.03368636965751648, -0.0236504003405571, -0.0035497364588081837, 0.042265385389328, 0.05090167745947838, -0.0009694043546915054, -0.050944436341524124, 0.0000013749572644883301, 0.024766258895397186, 0.04401583969593048, 0.052014995366334915, -0.008672064170241356, -0.1002306118607521, -0.0030750075820833445, 0.056924477219581604, 0.01017589122056961, 0.006934558507055044, -0.0033514939714223146, -0.05519990995526314, 0.015150027349591255, 0.017185701057314873, -0.012411671690642834, -0.01663966290652752, -0.004569121170789003, 0.025331472977995872, -0.03097596764564514, -0.04390362650156021, -0.05541147664189339, 0.025264481082558632, -0.023125432431697845, 0.021298622712492943, -0.049266405403614044, -0.035965368151664734, -0.05288377404212952, 0.05809353291988373, -0.0011901409598067403, 0.06310291588306427, -0.004564851056784391, -0.005197842605412006, -0.016905684024095535, 0.03809551149606705, -0.003483982989564538, -0.023770300671458244, 0.019162118434906006, 0.021429691463708878, -0.03868938609957695, 0.07185135781764984, 0.0011501350672915578, 0.008207622915506363, 0.040803901851177216, 0.000051443690608721226, 0.0004494602617342025, 0.00003154972364427522, -0.02884570136666298, 0.05873587355017662, 0.005947472993284464, 0.01633511111140251, 0.0695936307311058, 0.049703825265169144, -0.005517605692148209, -0.025443023070693016, -0.03394229710102081, 0.033526550978422165, -0.01738074980676174, -0.03030702844262123, -0.053478214889764786, -0.004354205448180437, -0.026964694261550903, 0.01710147224366665, -0.00014240233576856554, 0.017767027020454407, -0.042994797229766846, -0.03154044970870018, 0.016120461747050285, 0.055231381207704544, 0.02990923635661602, 0.005752388387918472, -0.0028385333716869354, 0.025634560734033585, -0.013276197016239166, -0.019987069070339203, -0.014333542436361313, 0.003976086620241404, 0.03929797187447548, -0.015887923538684845, -0.009560816921293736, 0.0166852418333292, -0.06350267678499222, -0.011827834881842136, 0.02240384928882122, -0.06883588433265686, 0.02750389836728573, 0.0058283014222979546, 0.046563200652599335, 0.029669396579265594, -0.071368508040905, 0.0042997095733881, 0.03312519192695618, 0.015173389576375484, 0.03199203312397003, -0.029819350689649582, 0.01584041677415371, -0.02202680893242359, 0.04185645282268524, -0.07055505365133286, -0.03364954888820648, 0.05740603804588318, -0.010384705848991871, -0.011051522567868233, -0.059352338314056396, -0.015990059822797775, -0.03281962499022484, 0.012016372755169868, -0.01808960735797882, 0.03273838385939598, -0.01730482280254364, -0.010859953239560127, -0.0012975941644981503, 0.008190631866455078, 0.04090457037091255, -0.028056377544999123, 0.012541904114186764, 0.0290360264480114, 0.02579016610980034, -0.026100507006049156, 0.003126308089122176, 0.02480987459421158, -0.033673591911792755, -0.0338396281003952, -0.04291051626205444, 0.005740146152675152, 0.01911497302353382, -0.030797850340604782, -0.021639451384544373, -0.01683267019689083, 0.02542310208082199, 0.023218302056193352, -0.0469277985394001, -0.03448105603456497, 0.015627101063728333, -0.015281958505511284, -0.05450131371617317, 0.010218766517937183, 0.006331322249025106, 0.01797962561249733, 0.03219195827841759, 0.015074211172759533, 0.02542506344616413, 0.02649093233048916, 0.06709370017051697, -0.012142324820160866, 0.028592050075531006, 0.017438646405935287, 0.01838787831366062, -0.005189270246773958, -0.008864101022481918, -0.03555922582745552, 0.040241219103336334, 0.029250577092170715, -0.04887436330318451, -0.0005754583980888128, -0.041599538177251816, -0.007723839487880468, 0.06142255663871765, -0.010566276498138905, 0.08734344691038132, 0.07332470268011093, 0.010278867557644844, -0.012854899279773235, -0.03833400830626488, -0.012895671650767326, -0.038306672126054764, -0.03076576441526413, 0.059418823570013046, -0.006743937730789185, 0.002665366046130657, 0.013445191085338593, 0.027042238041758537, 0.010663825087249279, 0.07706869393587112, 0.018764883279800415, 0.03770788758993149, 0.014717815443873405, -0.0004889683332294226, -0.038153696805238724, 0.012721125036478043, -0.01013099029660225, 0.025897199288010597, -0.011710972525179386, -0.0075576817616820335, 0.035773761570453644, 0.054058756679296494, -0.03337794542312622, -0.03899795562028885, -0.0157476793974638, -0.07570181041955948, 0.04693680629134178, 0.03154519200325012, -0.02335386537015438, 0.0010184493148699403, 0.010675997473299503, 0.033545151352882385, -0.009817678481340408, -0.008099615573883057, -0.02273371070623398, -0.07549436390399933, 0.011624354869127274, -0.014223683625459671, -0.03178301826119423, 0.009987853467464447, 0.0028723436407744884, -0.03494167700409889, 0.008309607394039631, -0.01182801928371191, 0.0040435632690787315, -0.027476217597723007, 0.01990821212530136, 0.01366205234080553, 0.0740707740187645, 0.0019069069530814886, 0.009886466898024082, -0.0012260974617674947, 0.023069266229867935, 0.11027958244085312, 0.06042410805821419, 0.0017960891127586365, -0.07255721837282181, 0.005586564540863037, -0.02695278823375702, -0.05315755680203438, -0.014764204621315002, -0.009349155239760876, 0.00029449837165884674, -0.017070002853870392, 0.06732627004384995, 0.018826479092240334, -0.0023851485457271338, 0.004974585957825184, 0.048875853419303894, -0.02144693024456501, -0.031167246401309967, -0.020695015788078308, 0.002437327988445759, -0.03880991041660309, 0.025518255308270454, -0.06616026908159256, 0.045909248292446136, -0.03629201650619507, -0.024367807433009148, -0.02063693292438984, -0.05306125432252884, 0.01845819316804409, 0.0752367153763771, -0.012204958125948906, 0.016739239916205406, 0.026706531643867493, 0.020921625196933746, 0.010450022295117378, -0.009811422787606716, 0.001855915179476142, -0.018250418826937675, -0.003993849270045757, 0.002952585695311427, -0.02341298945248127, 0.010224622674286366, -0.025971999391913414, -0.014752178452908993, -0.014176400378346443, -0.022939486429095268, -0.05582619830965996, 0.04257172718644142, -0.014550124295055866, -0.022869519889354706, -0.018179072067141533, 0.01680402085185051, 0.03036119043827057, -0.030143937095999718, -0.033240895718336105, -0.012545363046228886, 0.027304859831929207, -0.04272553697228432, -0.018317168578505516, -0.021759744733572006, 0.013326907530426979, 0.015121383592486382, 0.03224019333720207, 0.03030349686741829, -0.013045953586697578, 0.018307602033019066, -0.045070186257362366, 0.07554396986961365, 0.017698002979159355, -0.044213928282260895, 0.006210587453097105, -0.03243723884224892, -0.03828752413392067, -0.031219786033034325, 0.039161376655101776, 0.0070746950805187225, 0.023551268503069878, 0.016582518815994263, -0.01995939575135708, 0.007604898419231176, -0.02064773254096508, -0.007963010109961033, -0.0343191958963871, -0.024292398244142532, -0.03651487082242966, 0.0042176274582743645, 0.0311670433729887, 0.061374396085739136, 0.02481638267636299, -0.01432267390191555, -0.025186097249388695, 0.02579561062157154, 0.03812410682439804, -0.041904572397470474, -0.018908368423581123, -0.004061713814735413, -0.026731647551059723, -0.006838561967015266, -0.012511149980127811, 0.04688536375761032, 0.008075474761426449, 0.02540811523795128, 0.025834746658802032, 0.024636680260300636, -0.005996950436383486, 0.016508152708411217, -0.0066007403656840324, -0.06054273247718811, 0.010468494147062302, -0.005311648827046156, -0.014047909528017044, -0.026695262640714645, 0.011888905428349972, -0.013432789593935013, -0.023824365809559822, 0.001803097315132618, -0.007488167379051447, -0.026349389925599098, 0.017579324543476105, -0.02391768991947174, 0.004271607846021652, -0.04444464296102524, -0.0007059522322379053, -0.006188179366290569, -0.01683376356959343, -0.006939132697880268, -0.024271007627248764, 0.03071451745927334, 0.00240524229593575, -0.02148228883743286, 0.026501933112740517, 0.059111252427101135, 0.017493510618805885, 0.047001488506793976, 0.02862948551774025, 0.008500730618834496, -0.008090699091553688, 0.0811343714594841, -0.00594306318089366, 0.025054963305592537, 0.0298910029232502, -0.037970200181007385, -0.03358665853738785, -0.0077566104009747505, -0.005288639105856419, 0.06433113664388657, 0.015386542305350304, -0.018579380586743355, -0.031183738261461258, 0.06441956758499146, 0.021076219156384468, -0.0005389577709138393, -0.017141493037343025, 0.022239457815885544, 0.0047486829571425915, 0.016952168196439743, 0.04279788210988045, -0.009274115785956383, -0.00849330984055996, 0.045094866305589676, 0.02547529898583889, 0.021604014560580254, -0.021462565287947655, 0.02013925276696682, -0.031614746898412704, -0.016094554215669632, 0.025704557076096535, -0.005055441055446863, 0.04353611543774605, 0.05383484065532684, -0.0011999709531664848, 0.004199950955808163, -0.003669601632282138, -0.009972269646823406, -0.07235094159841537, -0.04696952924132347, 0.024876931682229042, -0.018568038940429688, 0.012830113992094994, -0.05345359444618225, -0.026268962770700455, 0.042939625680446625, -0.08450766652822495, 0.0008882300462573767, 0.03878083452582359, -0.02733028493821621, -0.03912416845560074, 0.009264308027923107, -0.026213761419057846, 0.007930377498269081, 0.007557567209005356, 0.05460122972726822, 0.018259264528751373, 0.044473905116319656, -0.009312530979514122, -0.018541106954216957, -0.010192949324846268, 0.0058670430444180965, 0.032268960028886795, -0.03502500429749489, -0.004206658806651831, -0.016851024702191353, -0.0036317240446805954, 0.005013962276279926, -0.019680457189679146, -0.00011908633314305916, 0.020261431112885475, 0.021598687395453453, -0.011644645594060421, 0.04418134316802025, 0.05031464248895645, 0.025825295597314835, -0.002125185215845704, -0.02102889120578766, 0.025250665843486786, 0.014430836774408817, -0.041343215852975845, 0.002355678007006645, -0.009134070947766304, -0.021854769438505173, -0.037428081035614014, 0.028064288198947906, 0.011015615426003933, -0.01916913501918316, 0.00033512472873553634, 0.005166899412870407, -0.007011317647993565, -0.02374228462576866, 0.003292070236057043, -0.04383748397231102, -0.03598637133836746, 0.04878944158554077, 0.007997372187674046, -0.030531616881489754, -0.030938854441046715, -0.029327696189284325, -0.05681789666414261, -0.0044710151851177216, 0.023068232461810112, -0.07080095261335373, -0.02631158009171486, -0.001527635264210403, -0.010846476070582867, -0.05130035802721977, 0.0006813788786530495, -0.012293942272663116, -0.040950071066617966, 0.044665999710559845, -0.012856077402830124, -0.012007682584226131, 0.006853038445115089, 0.021261684596538544, -0.013083117082715034, -0.06278061866760254, 0.07317496836185455, -0.003542751306667924, -0.06652297079563141, -0.05595945566892624, -0.0006124890060164034, -0.0010962937958538532, 0.018838651478290558, 0.01853853464126587, 0.0008722323109395802, 0.02136705070734024, 0.022664908319711685, 0.03730841353535652, 0.002692129462957382, -0.03713010251522064, 0.057368144392967224, 0.022536536678671837, -0.05725570395588875, 0.019469259306788445, -0.020544508472085, 0.0019233155762776732, 0.04013214260339737, -0.003681159345433116, -0.02762880176305771, 0.0023069267626851797, 0.00908643752336502, -0.04669801890850067, 0.027252528816461563, 0.003966134041547775, -0.006465262267738581, 0.07387562096118927, -0.027710197493433952, -0.04913631081581116, 0.018159696832299232, 0.025026444345712662, -0.011184754781425, 0.029290445148944855, -0.0628652572631836, -0.04303356632590294, -0.01810135319828987, 0.016872847452759743, 0.005478296894580126, -0.060881879180669785, -0.0020057354122400284, 0.016997070983052254, -0.05673900991678238, 0.007652053609490395, 0.04761258512735367, -0.01281060092151165, 0.038553256541490555, -0.015023193322122097, 0.022172704339027405, -0.021828632801771164, -0.008060107007622719, 0.006462979596108198, -0.0051905205473303795, 0.017949838191270828, -0.016488462686538696, -0.005642443895339966, 0.04541199654340744, 0.00592199619859457, 0.02630055695772171, -0.029012003913521767, 0.023060768842697144, -0.032769255340099335, -0.03234888240695, 0.031968746334314346, 0.015708360821008682, 0.03729208558797836, 0.0013059864286333323, -0.012265714816749096, 0.07255428284406662, -0.042899239808321, -0.026189249008893967, -0.03267575055360794, -0.018574070185422897, -0.0402899906039238, 0.03217544034123421, 0.007578740362077951, 0.007213384844362736, 0.028524648398160934, 0.03167510777711868, 0.0052454532124102116, -0.01043064147233963, 0.030434368178248405, -0.004139916505664587, 0.02947959490120411, -0.030983788892626762, -0.012055493891239166, -0.0027134809643030167, 0.015842610970139503, -0.006496426183730364, -0.025483092293143272, 0.0032142235431820154, 0.013112730346620083, 0.0018404315924271941, 0.015403897501528263, -0.030510982498526573, -0.03449089452624321, 0.035049647092819214, -0.08431187272071838, -0.030829083174467087, -0.018264470621943474, -0.00517181446775794, -0.014885950833559036, 0.011317117139697075 ]
<p>I've read <a href="http://www.evanmiller.org/how-not-to-sort-by-average-rating.html" rel="nofollow">How Not to Sort By Average Rating</a> regarding how to average binary positive/negative ratings in a way that takes the number of ratings into account. The author uses the "lower bound of Wilson score confidence interval for a Bernoulli parameter". However, the items I'm dealing with have continuous ratings from 0 to 1. Is there an analogous averaging technique for this case?</p> <p>My ratings collection is long-tailed: the median item has only 2 ratings, but the average one has 80, and the most-rated item has 36,000 ratings. Intuitively ten ratings of 0.8 should "average" higher than one of 0.9, but I'd like a precise formulation of this intuition.</p> <p>(I'm using this to design a recommender system, which has to deal with 50,000 users and 10,000 items. I'm evaluating various known recommenders, like GroupLens and LSI, and have to design one that doesn't perform too much worse than those (and hopefully better). I was reminded of this blog post on averages when using users' average ratings for a baseline RMSE calculation.)</p>
73,433
[ -0.035875026136636734, -0.016002101823687553, -0.021683987230062485, -0.0017957048257812858, 0.02526714839041233, 0.002313903532922268, -0.02067345753312111, -0.012569892220199108, 0.008596842177212238, -0.039700016379356384, 0.020407868549227715, 0.024254951626062393, 0.0519716702401638, 0.04564811289310455, 0.00481163477525115, -0.018808072432875633, -0.025597434490919113, -0.027649646624922752, -0.008942692540585995, -0.02872001752257347, 0.018296681344509125, 0.030582020059227943, 0.04691252484917641, -0.03224712982773781, -0.006633338052779436, 0.026927726343274117, 0.05491244047880173, -0.024889543652534485, 0.0027420055121183395, 0.05421223118901253, -0.06119908019900322, -0.012292447499930859, 0.011993407271802425, 0.037119440734386444, 0.03027728572487831, -0.0008570560021325946, -0.05795355141162872, -0.00018965463095810264, -0.03760886937379837, -0.0017502199625596404, -0.005312690977007151, -0.02499047853052616, -0.0227833092212677, 0.004111736547201872, -0.03135913237929344, -0.017892373725771904, -0.013239852152764797, -0.05086095631122589, 0.014362087473273277, -0.04277700185775757, 0.06487704068422318, -0.00008722914208192378, 0.033261191099882126, 0.011717397719621658, -0.025097321718931198, -0.012642191722989082, 0.022495150566101074, 0.07035063207149506, -0.01606571115553379, -0.03043476492166519, -0.02904936857521534, -0.024040324613451958, -0.019978752359747887, -0.005607403349131346, 0.010755491442978382, 0.045641809701919556, -0.008473268710076809, -0.01534842886030674, 0.038356997072696686, 0.02389436401426792, -0.00626656087115407, 0.04663361236453056, 0.06274648010730743, -0.01606815494596958, 0.026364298537373543, -0.022959284484386444, 0.06139342859387398, 0.009196174331009388, 0.024059252813458443, 0.03405136242508888, -0.013208662159740925, 0.011995761655271053, 0.03124898485839367, 0.06427118927240372, 0.02116216905415058, -0.0021040032152086496, 0.07862520217895508, -0.043134190142154694, -0.016209563240408897, 0.04843921959400177, 0.0013823281042277813, -0.008436822332441807, 0.011427055113017559, 0.015377923846244812, -0.05027993768453598, 0.044758521020412445, -0.025251105427742004, 0.0295400433242321, 0.01991710625588894, 0.007029673084616661, -0.0036288215778768063, -0.03201238065958023, 0.03328171372413635, 0.052470650523900986, -0.015316442586481571, 0.0021934679243713617, -0.049344245344400406, -0.0014066585572436452, -0.026355737820267677, -0.03647683933377266, -0.025883065536618233, -0.012492723762989044, 0.021402953192591667, 0.0023704252671450377, -0.005237236153334379, 0.013482200913131237, -0.016856243833899498, -0.02035515569150448, 0.015362454578280449, 0.037253160029649734, 0.04725652188062668, 0.01951473206281662, 0.01751982420682907, -0.033951543271541595, -0.03718645125627518, 0.025820042937994003, 0.0019843324553221464, -0.03811801224946976, -0.08104561269283295, 0.02470513805747032, -0.005253874231129885, -0.014013852924108505, 0.06582276523113251, -0.01947450265288353, 0.01822235994040966, -0.005876705516129732, -0.053102221339941025, -0.04571998119354248, 0.02579370327293873, -0.005198669619858265, 0.014996759593486786, -0.06916401535272598, 0.0020416369661688805, 0.06677082926034927, 0.0326828770339489, 0.023899182677268982, 0.02014896273612976, 0.04332711920142174, 0.030204934999346733, -0.028498612344264984, -0.03711789846420288, -0.035042088478803635, -0.019580146297812462, -0.020085981115698814, -0.03025762178003788, -0.0568779893219471, 0.03399692103266716, 0.018042130395770073, 0.023945985361933708, 0.019196001812815666, 0.0034872079268097878, 0.026554392650723457, -0.012489124201238155, -0.04621899873018265, 0.03998933732509613, -0.01882842928171158, 0.05727032572031021, 0.007672927342355251, 0.04051274433732033, -0.016546176746487617, -0.026321113109588623, -0.004371050279587507, 0.006555767729878426, 0.026134807616472244, 0.06822660565376282, 0.008318210951983929, -0.027285316959023476, -0.028733814135193825, 0.021971356123685837, 0.01815900392830372, -0.018597368150949478, -0.05066845566034317, -0.04635860398411751, 0.007698185741901398, 0.0145078981295228, 0.025571921840310097, -0.025090016424655914, -0.012087997980415821, 0.01418937649577856, -0.048985350877046585, -0.03129133582115173, -0.08358161896467209, -0.004680653568357229, 0.036216139793395996, -0.000008688266461831518, 0.03663427755236626, 0.004890004172921181, -0.015891574323177338, -0.034200094640254974, 0.020893041044473648, -0.028624186292290688, -0.02162838540971279, 0.03385029733181, -0.05302121490240097, 0.006927920039743185, 0.04705902561545372, 0.04049048572778702, -0.040169209241867065, 0.03297268599271774, -0.047207195311784744, -0.056716255843639374, -0.02462245710194111, -0.033025067299604416, 0.02389051951467991, 0.013271622359752655, -0.033459749072790146, 0.020829932764172554, -0.027246449142694473, -0.027131227776408195, 0.012219143100082874, -0.03542890399694443, 0.04719463735818863, 0.05782549828290939, -0.017717814072966576, 0.012815630994737148, 0.013059367425739765, 0.026450570672750473, -0.009523363783955574, -0.03208107501268387, 0.0029758538585156202, -0.06330566853284836, -0.025359967723488808, 0.03842732682824135, 0.04027911648154259, -0.02712605893611908, 0.017514668405056, 0.05786390230059624, 0.046328555792570114, 0.02738122083246708, 0.020950110629200935, 0.013032914139330387, 0.0049329535104334354, 0.036970775574445724, 0.055110085755586624, -0.0036669725086539984, -0.011448393575847149, -0.0220098365098238, -0.015918556600809097, 0.0196596160531044, 0.02777186594903469, -0.002558795502409339, -0.029091130942106247, 0.0490448959171772, 0.0356287844479084, -0.021186435595154762, -0.03233622387051582, 0.06269463896751404, -0.018656833097338676, -0.010113777592778206, 0.00452869338914752, -0.007515057921409607, 0.008255261927843094, 0.011712823994457722, -0.034279949963092804, 0.011266966350376606, 0.042656123638153076, -0.054459646344184875, -0.049985405057668686, 0.020681455731391907, -0.0001499515783507377, 0.01899118162691593, -0.01881079562008381, -0.02565981075167656, -0.03563075512647629, 0.022079136222600937, 0.010469024069607258, 0.00553369102999568, 0.02441200613975525, -0.02755063585937023, -0.018147660419344902, -0.004448433872312307, -0.0003609778650570661, -0.021610848605632782, 0.020895909518003464, -0.033229369670152664, -0.01671585999429226, 0.007890983484685421, -0.035659559071063995, 0.05047784745693207, 0.027146877720952034, -0.019378768280148506, 0.034183088690042496, -0.008426009677350521, -0.06652273237705231, -0.015319372527301311, -0.02321552485227585, 0.023140154778957367, -0.009786674752831459, -0.01585645228624344, 0.06849167495965958, 0.030737604945898056, -0.08476994931697845, 0.03497636690735817, -0.0222207922488451, -0.030669571831822395, -0.015258429571986198, -0.0003342648269608617, 0.0012439123820513487, -0.0012178036849945784, -0.0026231245137751102, 0.011439738795161247, -0.0037254313938319683, -0.010908032767474651, -0.08108958601951599, -0.07221581786870956, 0.004209747537970543, 0.01603553630411625, 0.057139959186315536, 0.02337479032576084, -0.002565995790064335, 0.09837740659713745, 0.03429868072271347, -0.04181712865829468, -0.03513232618570328, -0.012174814939498901, 0.006880526430904865, 0.0076720514334738255, 0.0074725523591041565, 0.05353359133005142, -0.009073033928871155, 0.0412280336022377, -0.018940364941954613, 0.02993326261639595, 0.04776385799050331, 0.01047203317284584, 0.023269452154636383, 0.01227937638759613, 0.0007818537997081876, -0.007282845210283995, 0.025525707751512527, 0.024661986157298088, -0.013086582534015179, 0.028818048536777496, 0.05193159356713295, 0.06266290694475174, 0.017062198370695114, -0.034069523215293884, 0.036028992384672165, -0.019738562405109406, -0.005528036039322615, -0.0492059551179409, 0.02579563856124878, 0.022817157208919525, -0.02887549065053463, 0.006119963712990284, 0.03138992562890053, 0.02149937115609646, -0.02802232652902603, 0.011365803889930248, 0.04669615998864174, 0.07864059507846832, -0.013856218196451664, -0.05265713855624199, -0.02204505354166031, -0.03578359633684158, -0.006887918803840876, -0.014762003906071186, 0.012682335451245308, 0.02395334653556347, 0.019248509779572487, 0.008819971233606339, -0.0000679850418237038, -0.04888630285859108, 0.02127491496503353, -0.056370362639427185, -0.009135869331657887, -0.04570377990603447, 0.05542609840631485, 0.019550804048776627, 0.0016980496002361178, 0.020964477211236954, -0.0001339600421488285, 0.03168109059333801, 0.007357989903539419, -0.041482359170913696, 0.036396123468875885, -0.048633649945259094, -0.0044379159808158875, -0.006804713513702154, 0.0004528845311142504, 0.0027872291393578053, -0.012863249517977238, 0.03419985994696617, -0.02040685899555683, 0.07834190130233765, -0.012884419411420822, -0.01327656488865614, -0.03552534431219101, 0.009105154313147068, -0.004782454576343298, -0.001675546751357615, -0.01587233692407608, -0.04043310135602951, 0.048561662435531616, 0.012515975162386894, -0.010183279402554035, 0.014227706007659435, -0.007517168298363686, 0.008359319530427456, -0.01343982107937336, 0.0031068329699337482, 0.01379290409386158, 0.04349992424249649, -0.03269369155168533, 0.012754051014780998, 0.0007009871187619865, 0.03721996769309044, 0.04311021417379379, -0.032418906688690186, 0.020992755889892578, -0.032085176557302475, -0.02837444841861725, 0.01893243007361889, 0.0024109636433422565, -0.016824904829263687, 0.002894073259085417, 0.015998942777514458, -0.00003110340185230598, -0.0706559419631958, 0.014672106131911278, 0.0910821259021759, -0.0011245263740420341, -0.02004220150411129, -0.02032754197716713, -0.0050610327161848545, 0.023172052577137947, 0.018201738595962524, 0.014147340320050716, 0.026596123352646828, -0.015518882311880589, 0.0025988442357629538, 0.02975037880241871, -0.04813569784164429, -0.05885275825858116, -0.016773264855146408, 0.0061063920147717, 0.04713020101189613, -0.026116937398910522, -0.034823428839445114, -0.0021592327393591404, 0.05891576036810875, 0.056801941245794296, 0.015838753432035446, 0.03633914887905121, -0.08817348629236221, 0.005509921815246344, 0.039521168917417526, 0.048805780708789825, -0.002083682455122471, 0.004934616852551699, -0.06887133419513702, 0.005401461850851774, 0.05634698644280434, -0.002400087658315897, 0.015947384759783745, 0.005631933454424143, -0.011579761281609535, -0.018978632986545563, -0.029508495703339577, -0.02655714564025402, 0.015394320711493492, -0.005419953726232052, 0.05096914991736412, -0.009112324565649033, -0.01407608576118946, -0.05227747932076454, 0.028420211747288704, 0.031590163707733154, 0.03941982239484787, -0.0014865313423797488, 0.016197655349969864, 0.031758081167936325, -0.01023657713085413, 0.000496210006531328, -0.043039243668317795, -0.012793296948075294, 0.007325282320380211, -0.016828887164592743, 0.017631543800234795, -0.015802418813109398, -0.038682322949171066, -0.006652940530329943, 0.012293296866118908, -0.041726138442754745, -0.01607413776218891, -0.04265384376049042, 0.05725685507059097, 0.05549139156937599, 0.0017657398711889982, 0.05980445444583893, 0.009871192276477814, -0.03253813832998276, 0.014966110698878765, -0.02463464066386223, 0.012423267588019371, -0.01287740096449852, -0.0034978361800312996, -0.041563406586647034, -0.052920594811439514, -0.015387269668281078, 0.016508426517248154, -0.002705257385969162, 0.0366298072040081, 0.0004934465978294611, -0.005515822675079107, -0.0008475772337988019, 0.006889969576150179, 0.019970295950770378, 0.012824321165680885, 0.03685897961258888, 0.006414508447051048, 0.005283178295940161, -0.018586814403533936, 0.05007993057370186, -0.01593957096338272, 0.02984614111483097, 0.04263394698500633, -0.04938415437936783, 0.017484255135059357, -0.03782041743397713, -0.000009766525181476027, -0.014889411628246307, -0.02004113234579563, 0.066799595952034, -0.00030292835435830057, 0.013017312623560429, 0.018886376172304153, 0.014110364951193333, -0.019508441910147667, -0.0032961321994662285, -0.030571134760975838, 0.023238856345415115, -0.03542625904083252, 0.026542069390416145, -0.0022486161906272173, 0.006624891422688961, -0.062375254929065704, -0.027845414355397224, 0.040274668484926224, 0.00005049296305514872, -0.005797961726784706, -0.039930310100317, -0.010487128049135208, 0.009090529754757881, 0.010453115217387676, 0.009224018082022667, 0.010082781314849854, -0.022149186581373215, -0.02244093082845211, -0.0294924508780241, 0.00641127722337842, 0.10974609851837158, 0.0023195925168693066, -0.02821558527648449, 0.02281658723950386, -0.007883590646088123, -0.015095429494976997, -0.017998745664954185, 0.040665123611688614, -0.05610973760485649, -0.017206139862537384, -0.028374480083584785, 0.015011867508292198, 0.050802554935216904, -0.015999741852283478, -0.008735517039895058, 0.01718279719352722, -0.0015271911397576332, -0.002510485937818885, 0.0027005388401448727, -0.011068800464272499, -0.029428644105792046, 0.017126120626926422, -0.038480281829833984, -0.0024089221842586994, -0.018028412014245987, -0.01750345528125763, 0.03953664377331734, 0.04809494689106941, 0.007229636888951063, -0.010420112870633602, 0.04220059886574745, 0.006478575523942709, -0.00040709818131290376, -0.009898331947624683, -0.056360241025686264, 0.029344074428081512, 0.010276616550981998, -0.011749296449124813, 0.004146002698689699, -0.01786893792450428, -0.022465087473392487, -0.010540005750954151, -0.04001788794994354, -0.008992128074169159, 0.048587046563625336, 0.01017819344997406, 0.030362986028194427, 0.022806955501437187, 0.015926549211144447, -0.02858964540064335, -0.025082796812057495, -0.02853105403482914, -0.018770447000861168, 0.019570929929614067, 0.030554918572306633, -0.031214702874422073, 0.011870667338371277, 0.005084232892841101, -0.023120012134313583, 0.028094161301851273, 0.04790541157126427, 0.004479365888983011, 0.017573565244674683, 0.037610653787851334, -0.012440517544746399, -0.03256388381123543, 0.04884375259280205, -0.07759587466716766, -0.005818020086735487, -0.005056319758296013, -0.040979500859975815, 0.018648622557520866, 0.02086229994893074, -0.0071708387695252895, -0.045157190412282944, -0.018949169665575027, -0.02181595377624035, -0.012332321144640446, 0.01303436141461134, -0.02002003975212574, 0.02788061462342739, 0.01219789870083332, 0.0045325602404773235, 0.03636309877038002, 0.034334488213062286, -0.004045736975967884, -0.04235723614692688, -0.009619967080652714, -0.021132590249180794, -0.06019284576177597, 0.0163800660520792, 0.030751630663871765, -0.016674291342496872, -0.017080333083868027, -0.04276043921709061, 0.0038217739202082157, 0.0227830708026886, 0.010720988735556602, -0.003934388514608145, 0.07606558501720428, 0.00900012906640768, 0.039481304585933685, -0.001582242432050407, -0.010097160004079342, 0.12558090686798096, 0.05037328973412514, 0.0061683664098382, -0.0652492418885231, -0.010341249406337738, 0.005911326035857201, -0.00993257388472557, -0.05176291614770889, 0.023417986929416656, -0.013934735208749771, -0.015551823191344738, 0.05085815489292145, 0.029528947547078133, 0.003682211972773075, -0.01685945689678192, 0.06863177567720413, -0.055727384984493256, 0.017322847619652748, 0.027291281148791313, 0.0070305331610143185, 0.01866711489856243, -0.026839539408683777, -0.057293761521577835, 0.03366507962346077, -0.016371240839362144, 0.024481087923049927, -0.0340525358915329, -0.0015159191098064184, -0.018844308331608772, -0.028625106438994408, 0.014894339255988598, 0.01944744400680065, 0.030631048604846, -0.04354942589998245, 0.06461217254400253, 0.0013626256259158254, 0.03467119112610817, -0.0029857393819838762, 0.048606231808662415, 0.01471730973571539, -0.01901915669441223, -0.013284479267895222, 0.0320056788623333, 0.011224563233554363, -0.026019753888249397, -0.06608767807483673, -0.05904025211930275, 0.010987993329763412, -0.02908434346318245, -0.01936221495270729, -0.01792716048657894, -0.0060153440572321415, -0.0329071581363678, -0.04580613970756531, 0.008752294816076756, -0.010890861041843891, 0.04134869948029518, -0.009472772479057312, -0.059848181903362274, 0.0028374926187098026, 0.03639926388859749, -0.0018147676018998027, 0.03202153742313385, 0.019291142001748085, -0.018402373418211937, -0.044082581996917725, -0.030362267047166824, 0.013120141811668873, 0.017387377098202705, -0.028232084587216377, -0.007478448562324047, 0.006916292477399111, -0.0411735363304615, -0.013005307875573635, -0.02989931032061577, -0.007093293592333794, 0.04609593003988266, 0.009654747322201729, 0.025723416358232498, -0.04055887833237648, -0.0298803448677063, -0.012857800349593163, -0.028226597234606743, -0.010731781832873821, -0.0015992405824363232, -0.01541396789252758, 0.0035758595913648605, 0.01439215149730444, -0.0034192115999758244, -0.011818191967904568, -0.015905626118183136, 0.05085291340947151, 0.0298630204051733, -0.029916007071733475, 0.014115331694483757, 0.020978081971406937, -0.05838518589735031, 0.03349906951189041, -0.007867349311709404, 0.07796932011842728, 0.026862075552344322, -0.012316755950450897, -0.02673337794840336, 0.026211285963654518, 0.0008506026351824403, -0.01414055097848177, 0.004951902199536562, -0.06616514176130295, -0.032545316964387894, 0.017475448548793793, -0.015252509154379368, -0.02109764702618122, -0.045749057084321976, -0.039082080125808716, -0.005989430006593466, 0.01868707872927189, -0.008511045016348362, -0.007473337929695845, -0.007461290340870619, -0.007864079438149929, 0.02687375247478485, -0.035537682473659515, 0.00864835549145937, -0.03909989446401596, 0.024999454617500305, -0.026775704696774483, 0.04783981293439865, -0.027938444167375565, 0.03759075701236725, -0.009498633444309235, -0.022742537781596184, 0.011887396685779095, 0.04622029885649681, -0.003848585532978177, -0.000001747818146213831, -0.0026736960280686617, -0.021439513191580772, 0.029314350336790085, -0.041184984147548676, -0.039945024996995926, 0.033374205231666565, -0.02831365168094635, -0.02739168331027031, 0.014305990189313889, -0.004087076056748629, 0.0017957178642973304, -0.003279763041064143, -0.0297868475317955, -0.04352486878633499, 0.04206989333033562, -0.01771329529583454, -0.05965660884976387, -0.006784174591302872, -0.010136757977306843, 0.030966851860284805, 0.029380856081843376, 0.025832990184426308, 0.0065691363997757435, 0.0031075305305421352, -0.011756449937820435, 0.02501446194946766, -0.013921311125159264, 0.003704396542161703, -0.01830459013581276, 0.004630967974662781, 0.01903575286269188, -0.011402735486626625, 0.02256333827972412, 0.010139165446162224, 0.03279675543308258, -0.05422866716980934, 0.041758716106414795, -0.03779202327132225, -0.009927788749337196, -0.02230159193277359, 0.0006071204552426934, 0.032339874655008316, -0.014982241205871105, 0.04073665291070938, -0.0828520804643631, -0.01403464563190937, 0.04629465937614441, -0.03917533904314041, 0.025954287499189377, 0.012012729421257973, -0.015295853838324547, -0.051270000636577606, 0.0010944660753011703, -0.03578290343284607, 0.03535674884915352, 0.02788379229605198, 0.03334326669573784, 0.015539565123617649, 0.024169910699129105, -0.005336788948625326, -0.022887641564011574, -0.02396254986524582, 0.05062544345855713, 0.03381108120083809, -0.03250787779688835, 0.025639789178967476, -0.05073852092027664, -0.02469051256775856, 0.07178504019975662, 0.018564868718385696, 0.013371978886425495, 0.012227312661707401, 0.03982975333929062, 0.015188141725957394, 0.05065026879310608, 0.015335659496486187, 0.021701941266655922, 0.018217122182250023, 0.008180567063391209, 0.028696691617369652, 0.05048450455069542, -0.008347908966243267, 0.008649732917547226, 0.022992374375462532, -0.02333766780793667, -0.05046628788113594, 0.04968130588531494, 0.003978121094405651, -0.026135923340916634, -0.03294513002038002, 0.01188624370843172, 0.025300759822130203, -0.03728485852479935, 0.015923259779810905, 0.0037706438452005386, -0.022697187960147858, 0.03971129655838013, -0.03208208456635475, -0.017700551077723503, -0.005696856416761875, 0.029983874410390854, -0.03425951302051544, 0.010599922388792038, 0.013470173813402653, 0.00746791809797287, -0.09461318701505661, -0.018867220729589462, -0.023032275959849358, -0.005697852466255426, -0.0014565523015335202, -0.014107177965342999, -0.04654443636536598, 0.02995028719305992, -0.01506049558520317, 0.053532108664512634, 0.01505323313176632, 0.010255116038024426, -0.0033625969663262367, -0.08599304407835007, 0.02864290215075016, 0.030774394050240517, 0.002945395652204752, -0.03560324013233185, -0.013111211359500885, -0.007369705475866795, -0.013524520210921764, 0.042730461806058884, 0.023801472038030624, 0.027598073706030846, -0.015347829088568687, 0.008323362097144127, 0.020916160196065903, -0.05962119251489639, 0.03724114969372749, -0.02214505709707737, -0.006372686475515366, -0.02583608403801918, 0.011903746984899044, -0.004112632013857365, -0.035340938717126846, 0.044185005128383636, -0.002474812790751457, -0.006994422525167465, 0.01844128780066967, 0.009984035044908524, 0.07083249092102051, 0.03906872496008873, -0.020628267899155617, 0.043042149394750595, -0.011821343563497066, 0.02429269626736641, -0.012535976245999336, 0.00594451604411006, -0.053947675973176956, 0.03858374059200287, -0.014852351509034634, 0.001320020528510213, -0.00801375787705183, 0.032048340886831284, -0.0021112088579684496, -0.05889689549803734, 0.0007026683888398111, 0.054398585110902786, -0.041939374059438705, 0.019430892542004585, 0.04521661996841431, -0.025941964238882065, 0.048352766782045364, 0.022845203056931496, 0.04173990339040756, 0.0031399214640259743, 0.002205024939030409, 0.01869729347527027, -0.012658516876399517, 0.040050607174634933, -0.008952336385846138, 0.03073885478079319, 0.04049629718065262, -0.004700247198343277, 0.021447716280817986, 0.00021840434055775404, 0.04181589186191559, -0.0012307636206969619, -0.017167672514915466, 0.0359310507774353, 0.006066613364964724, 0.009195113554596901, 0.018083442002534866, -0.004976296331733465, 0.06334753334522247, -0.024079157039523125, 0.029465127736330032, -0.059871722012758255, -0.00886722281575203, -0.025459803640842438, 0.007372458931058645, -0.014721534214913845, 0.04980732128024101, 0.01247034315019846, 0.0179105494171381, 0.011480247601866722, -0.022874874994158745, 0.015332930721342564, -0.03252917155623436, 0.032360732555389404, 0.0027631332632154226, 0.01622029021382332, -0.006752139888703823, -0.025032371282577515, -0.05737781524658203, -0.02350936271250248, -0.002049901755526662, 0.040803827345371246, 0.03367753326892853, 0.02287229150533676, -0.010146240703761578, 0.002370768692344427, 0.039415907114744186, -0.06609562784433365, 0.009819362312555313, -0.07868433743715286, -0.00114328577183187, -0.030407821759581566, -0.026919962838292122 ]
<p>I have a question about Bayesian Information Criteria. (GARCH models)</p> <p>I have looked for so many hours but still very confused about this BIC especially a negative one. As far as I am concerned it is okay to have a BIC that is negative, but the interpretation of them are different in each book on website. I am not looking for sophisticated answer just a normal explanation as if you were to explain someone who is not math or statisticians.</p> <p>Given same data,length and number of observation which model is better, based on BIC?</p> <blockquote> <ol> <li><p>-4.98749 </p></li> <li><p>-4.995782 </p></li> <li><p>-4.9864</p></li> </ol> </blockquote> <p>Thank you in advance.</p> <p>I am using R software and running 3 models, GARCH-t, GJR model, and simple GARCH (1,1) model. So, I am trying to see which model is better, based only on BIC. I have already concluded what model is better based on other factors but this makes me confused.</p>
12,798
[ -0.03201410919427872, -0.03155180439352989, 0.0016081092180684209, -0.017258645966649055, 0.04583723843097687, 0.03747366741299629, 0.0038565555587410927, 0.0004824248026125133, 0.0388508066534996, -0.04204164817929268, 0.03734120354056358, 0.08960941433906555, 0.021646808832883835, 0.022686630487442017, 0.0038161734119057655, 0.012248261831700802, -0.011235274374485016, 0.020258812233805656, -0.035741176456213, -0.0036676654126495123, -0.002165137557312846, -0.0008812780142761767, 0.040301501750946045, 0.03751682490110397, -0.02757166512310505, 0.024424223229289055, 0.05632878094911575, -0.0061365757137537, 0.01152785774320364, 0.05095743015408516, -0.02944500744342804, -0.0005891854525543749, -0.0034877746365964413, 0.05474122241139412, 0.007474125828593969, 0.008063237182796001, 0.00511003565043211, -0.011690585874021053, -0.026851506903767586, 0.023232057690620422, -0.0449366569519043, -0.027859855443239212, -0.0031726916786283255, 0.02277134731411934, -0.027550090104341507, -0.0012617906322702765, 0.004928500857204199, -0.03626479580998421, 0.046378716826438904, -0.053690798580646515, 0.016967030242085457, -0.04049293324351311, 0.008991564624011517, 0.026624975726008415, 0.03519445285201073, -0.012281653471291065, 0.025756552815437317, 0.09471458196640015, -0.0182680431753397, -0.06295409053564072, -0.021345632150769234, -0.010511321946978569, 0.04480666294693947, -0.01916627027094364, -0.004653401672840118, 0.04978179931640625, 0.022207871079444885, -0.056095726788043976, 0.05199263244867325, 0.005200222600251436, 0.021530359983444214, -0.005503855645656586, 0.013181217946112156, -0.026404783129692078, 0.04945863410830498, -0.04512503743171692, -0.0022209850139915943, 0.04213942214846611, 0.04972048103809357, 0.0555645227432251, -0.009682378731667995, -0.014870204031467438, 0.017817746847867966, 0.05809744447469711, 0.029986469075083733, -0.011371725238859653, 0.0793696790933609, -0.023999445140361786, 0.022549856454133987, 0.021085595712065697, -0.059389740228652954, -0.011166796088218689, 0.039454732090234756, -0.026244278997182846, -0.05063670501112938, 0.055772874504327774, -0.009558766148984432, 0.03625129163265228, 0.006814523600041866, -0.0459572970867157, -0.021983401849865913, -0.0577586404979229, 0.02793004736304283, 0.06782981008291245, 0.004400714300572872, -0.02209564484655857, -0.015441585332155228, -0.0172773115336895, -0.02093825675547123, -0.036718446761369705, -0.025652380660176277, -0.005700475070625544, -0.008036268875002861, -0.023519018664956093, 0.0009309732122346759, -0.03559209778904915, 0.015239519998431206, -0.023285267874598503, 0.07661134004592896, 0.060098469257354736, 0.039998721331357956, -0.005278169643133879, 0.010745706968009472, -0.05072670429944992, -0.04668804258108139, -0.025117702782154083, 0.019167736172676086, -0.012833891436457634, -0.023795759305357933, 0.06291075050830841, 0.021358324214816093, 0.0025246001314371824, 0.05543811246752739, 0.019045287743210793, 0.035532787442207336, -0.009530519135296345, -0.08392619341611862, -0.03209104388952255, 0.07828561961650848, 0.0005768979317508638, 0.0003814241208601743, -0.061907730996608734, 0.009191698394715786, 0.03737004101276398, 0.02947124093770981, -0.00838546734303236, 0.05326879024505615, -0.002157042268663645, 0.023311380296945572, -0.004543875809758902, -0.035291921347379684, -0.004809819161891937, -0.019454248249530792, 0.013978141359984875, -0.04025409370660782, -0.1149788647890091, 0.00722702918574214, 0.019769921898841858, -0.012146602384746075, -0.03390546888113022, 0.038056422024965286, 0.004769605118781328, -0.007217491511255503, -0.02183365635573864, -0.009618761017918587, -0.005317360162734985, 0.05802024155855179, -0.009929902851581573, -0.006323980167508125, 0.01226025726646185, 0.0167100727558136, -0.02400589920580387, 0.003909853752702475, 0.05113409832119942, 0.025891181081533432, -0.0517246387898922, -0.00919446349143982, -0.010780828073620796, 0.04432358220219612, 0.007399189751595259, -0.024896016344428062, 0.006551395636051893, -0.024124501273036003, -0.031191617250442505, 0.009723062627017498, 0.01262733805924654, 0.007459117565304041, -0.005849128123372793, 0.07048641890287399, -0.01762695237994194, -0.04570102319121361, -0.05793927609920502, -0.027285173535346985, 0.016125796362757683, -0.03672538325190544, 0.050691619515419006, -0.0010127088753506541, 0.03289974108338356, -0.013807159848511219, -0.001285630976781249, -0.018653618171811104, 0.002440009033307433, 0.03069767914712429, -0.05235325172543526, 0.02079974114894867, 0.012086165137588978, 0.03522166237235069, -0.02761436253786087, 0.023605937138199806, -0.034914661198854446, -0.05008990317583084, 0.017612671479582787, -0.016584964469075203, 0.021051619201898575, 0.02216712385416031, -0.06671857833862305, 0.035561349242925644, 0.02082795649766922, -0.01916567236185074, 0.018479004502296448, -0.059231389313936234, 0.08594098687171936, 0.030082615092396736, -0.008470213040709496, 0.006763729732483625, 0.03816191107034683, 0.0298016220331192, 0.03873233124613762, -0.07624445855617523, 0.01884678192436695, -0.031191958114504814, -0.006706548389047384, 0.04433529078960419, 0.027858242392539978, -0.02056117355823517, 0.016496922820806503, 0.02917085774242878, 0.008050372824072838, 0.014598646201193333, 0.03267080709338188, 0.0009371737251058221, -0.0421566367149353, 0.0004540602385532111, 0.014898448251187801, 0.01318350713700056, -0.01600571721792221, 0.041895993053913116, -0.006070365663617849, 0.036780331283807755, -0.024035535752773285, -0.0012143715284764767, 0.07039008289575577, 0.01023298129439354, -0.010502103716135025, 0.004647721536457539, -0.00874085258692503, 0.06345845758914948, -0.03296532481908798, -0.007152379024773836, 0.015369142405688763, -0.031932711601257324, -0.007254430558532476, 0.03134482726454735, 0.019861744716763496, 0.033036746084690094, 0.011346027255058289, -0.04363236203789711, 0.0004278466512914747, 0.003939542919397354, -0.04545071721076965, 0.02847026102244854, 0.03674907609820366, -0.01391440536826849, -0.045821208506822586, 0.019860679283738136, 0.04604652151465416, -0.0009713249164633453, 0.029670655727386475, -0.009985714219510555, -0.035811565816402435, 0.0018027047626674175, -0.0036871526390314102, 0.01487125176936388, 0.006768831517547369, -0.05051637440919876, -0.0064704157412052155, -0.0326480008661747, -0.0010765648912638426, 0.028106119483709335, -0.03333180770277977, -0.006200100295245647, -0.01948985457420349, 0.002148902043700218, -0.024961747229099274, -0.05711974576115608, -0.023379376158118248, -0.0008727263193577528, -0.039138566702604294, -0.043065063655376434, 0.06473516672849655, 0.0005899476818740368, -0.022991761565208435, -0.009769591502845287, -0.060639213770627975, -0.05423741787672043, 0.001741974614560604, 0.011497216299176216, 0.0321851409971714, -0.0049187797121703625, 0.02376796491444111, -0.0006495688576251268, -0.017481323331594467, -0.0076819974929094315, -0.05990678071975708, -0.05703478306531906, 0.03663351759314537, -0.021658968180418015, 0.006966038607060909, -0.00828933622688055, -0.022704044356942177, 0.03714968264102936, 0.051421601325273514, -0.004244660492986441, -0.02341301366686821, -0.003640939947217703, -0.0342201329767704, -0.019834378734230995, 0.02681553177535534, 0.04488131031394005, 0.0037784057203680277, 0.02229674533009529, 0.01404870767146349, 0.028501899912953377, 0.029953820630908012, 0.01364060863852501, 0.006803231779485941, 0.026294296607375145, -0.0586281381547451, -0.011189269833266735, -0.002662869868800044, 0.031252507120370865, 0.005146618001163006, -0.005005306098610163, -0.00976218655705452, 0.02056276798248291, 0.009716962464153767, -0.04329376295208931, 0.029696160927414894, 0.02338290959596634, 0.0036785679403692484, -0.048509471118450165, 0.020866136997938156, 0.007353372406214476, -0.0378849022090435, -0.028095660731196404, -0.00639866990968585, 0.006199205294251442, 0.009087230078876019, 0.028655705973505974, 0.05854102596640587, 0.0163645688444376, -0.010549472644925117, 0.02729632519185543, -0.025801297277212143, -0.021168403327465057, 0.017084814608097076, -0.022559529170393944, 0.0012528251390904188, 0.04495897889137268, 0.053071536123752594, 0.01193656213581562, -0.031862448900938034, -0.038489896804094315, -0.008124555461108685, -0.06476020067930222, 0.000483108451589942, -0.02823791652917862, 0.03927277401089668, 0.03412765637040138, 0.024240614846348763, 0.0145038403570652, 0.00022158682986628264, 0.02746479958295822, -0.02429869771003723, -0.05100584030151367, 0.01755044050514698, -0.03480370715260506, 0.004750613123178482, 0.01623743213713169, 0.004966441076248884, 0.037675708532333374, -0.04552123323082924, -0.004837424494326115, -0.019865678623318672, 0.03424457460641861, -0.05105665698647499, 0.014519496820867062, -0.02001502923667431, 0.004904598463326693, 0.02740602195262909, 0.004462589509785175, 0.013600846752524376, -0.006388011854141951, 0.022245384752750397, 0.04728977382183075, 0.016015993431210518, 0.004441921133548021, 0.01558675803244114, 0.038627415895462036, 0.042589981108903885, 0.03727707639336586, 0.03358304873108864, 0.005226572509855032, -0.00014363501395564526, 0.022791553288698196, 0.03983349725604057, 0.011170847341418266, 0.04586166888475418, -0.058700080960989, -0.017653046175837517, -0.030179087072610855, -0.002391601912677288, -0.030296621844172478, 0.01257677935063839, -0.012465124949812889, -0.020510561764240265, 0.06743830442428589, 0.027040714398026466, 0.0070282225497066975, 0.022157402709126472, 0.06310337036848068, 0.03310003504157066, 0.015379632823169231, -0.039977677166461945, -0.028200680390000343, -0.012728261761367321, -0.013289994560182095, 0.03840145468711853, 0.02267511934041977, -0.03459920361638069, -0.011847348883748055, 0.020125186070799828, -0.04594080522656441, -0.03310738876461983, -0.006988922134041786, 0.036032795906066895, 0.040178220719099045, 0.03707241639494896, -0.05342985317111015, 0.022663479670882225, 0.02908436767756939, 0.025872422382235527, 0.010148374363780022, 0.0009736294159665704, -0.10018636286258698, -0.028493501245975494, 0.02863677218556404, 0.017287062481045723, -0.025195017457008362, -0.007354360539466143, -0.041865985840559006, -0.023267962038517, 0.03695393353700638, -0.03460017219185829, 0.021206380799412727, -0.023240629583597183, 0.019790129736065865, 0.019002355635166168, -0.024865105748176575, -0.024278104305267334, 0.004026778507977724, 0.01323879137635231, 0.006398825906217098, -0.015054503455758095, -0.018007412552833557, -0.03886682912707329, -0.035768698900938034, 0.008035227656364441, 0.03066457435488701, -0.04409785941243172, -0.0015151625266298652, 0.02624538168311119, 0.03409547358751297, -0.005215704441070557, -0.0783180370926857, -0.000934314972255379, -0.008901244960725307, -0.007962729781866074, 0.05132142826914787, -0.012971078045666218, -0.04757818952202797, 0.026729688048362732, 0.03206893801689148, -0.04779309034347534, -0.0004549058503471315, -0.023263538256287575, 0.028116730973124504, 0.0034519147593528032, -0.017394227907061577, 0.024076825007796288, -0.008580300025641918, -0.019450318068265915, 0.004702752456068993, -0.05957142636179924, 0.0019236727384850383, -0.01809508539736271, -0.027052542194724083, -0.04688950255513191, 0.007070566993206739, -0.023442085832357407, 0.020983541384339333, 0.015492797829210758, 0.044006772339344025, -0.023243241012096405, -0.010580956004559994, 0.03002014011144638, 0.012770731933414936, 0.011679986491799355, -0.014846695587038994, -0.016240360215306282, 0.007722246926277876, -0.004837728571146727, -0.023501256480813026, 0.003459000727161765, -0.043646492063999176, -0.011698387563228607, 0.006223651114851236, -0.042410511523485184, -0.0034027770161628723, -0.01431957632303238, -0.03466391935944557, 0.013851150870323181, 0.01663343608379364, 0.011240268126130104, 0.023737529292702675, 0.020422589033842087, 0.03870665654540062, -0.026807459071278572, -0.012652467004954815, -0.019803551957011223, 0.0032116989605128765, 0.056891731917858124, -0.03156040981411934, 0.02999102883040905, -0.011213371530175209, -0.036037880927324295, -0.06386911869049072, -0.02044389396905899, -0.00594527181237936, -0.038297995924949646, -0.06841420382261276, 0.0005155694088898599, 0.021093815565109253, -0.019048655405640602, -0.014212784357368946, -0.02865939401090145, 0.026910817250609398, 0.014477632008492947, -0.00921674445271492, 0.011903604492545128, 0.006242530886083841, 0.055217742919921875, -0.011511065065860748, -0.024883965030312538, 0.010819570161402225, -0.023879142478108406, -0.020098021253943443, 0.010166983120143414, 0.04982182756066322, -0.03521114960312843, 0.011760571971535683, 0.0028992106672376394, -0.015501783229410648, 0.03560136258602142, -0.005631175823509693, 0.012611850164830685, 0.044626880437135696, 0.003225910011678934, 0.02078765071928501, -0.03988640010356903, 0.01314518228173256, -0.024681219831109047, 0.03155001252889633, -0.02878379076719284, -0.004212025552988052, -0.005817785859107971, -0.0461055263876915, 0.009897246956825256, -0.02411436103284359, -0.03547316789627075, 0.011242851614952087, 0.059385642409324646, -0.02650660276412964, 0.032864734530448914, -0.00908863265067339, -0.02010279893875122, 0.024482831358909607, -0.00666476134210825, 0.04284728318452835, 0.03152856603264809, 0.014549227431416512, -0.04402274265885353, -0.03180680796504021, -0.04360424727201462, 0.008961765095591545, 0.057301536202430725, 0.007650614716112614, 0.07524233311414719, 0.023797418922185898, 0.03028182126581669, 0.030753329396247864, -0.03268447518348694, 0.00675401883199811, 0.000831366574857384, -0.006326252594590187, 0.06136280670762062, -0.027555840089917183, -0.028796536847949028, 0.043719518929719925, -0.04443751648068428, -0.02135402150452137, 0.03232711926102638, 0.028237922117114067, 0.007338342722505331, 0.004650173708796501, -0.03171597048640251, -0.0356258861720562, 0.04254600405693054, -0.011540524661540985, 0.027866508811712265, -0.02703799121081829, -0.03987233340740204, 0.04466308653354645, 0.03028799034655094, -0.01644301787018776, -0.07603637874126434, 0.003915008623152971, -0.04893622174859047, 0.014178675599396229, 0.031080277636647224, -0.010370881296694279, 0.0034437510184943676, 0.010383889079093933, 0.0510263666510582, 0.011213965713977814, 0.038785669952631, -0.024377750232815742, -0.09574650228023529, -0.02280275896191597, 0.0037429260555654764, -0.054600995033979416, 0.028216838836669922, 0.00525924377143383, -0.007976004853844643, -0.007356695365160704, -0.06105492264032364, -0.00551840104162693, 0.0031953370198607445, 0.018304288387298584, -0.015168634243309498, 0.09741780906915665, -0.012944519519805908, 0.015320348553359509, 0.02271929569542408, -0.014115303754806519, 0.12897811830043793, 0.07340224087238312, 0.016019649803638458, -0.056568119674921036, 0.04345163330435753, 0.040157537907361984, -0.009054405614733696, -0.01619098335504532, 0.04252474009990692, 0.022390620782971382, -0.024304552003741264, 0.05351559445261955, 0.04812382534146309, 0.00026843848172575235, -0.06834074854850769, 0.01933973655104637, -0.01743052713572979, -0.014846780337393284, 0.01761190965771675, 0.02047218568623066, -0.011406756937503815, -0.02410748042166233, -0.03209874778985977, 0.025951359421014786, 0.005957574583590031, -0.02636059932410717, -0.03178387135267258, -0.009694607928395271, -0.024526480585336685, 0.029064234346151352, 0.027601078152656555, -0.009653644636273384, 0.0019852202385663986, -0.008390006609261036, -0.008977659046649933, -0.035530634224414825, -0.01872670091688633, -0.012742266990244389, 0.02143384888768196, 0.012008669786155224, -0.05903401970863342, -0.020668646320700645, 0.01975630782544613, 0.011553061194717884, -0.054990943521261215, -0.027048291638493538, -0.040150076150894165, 0.014492728747427464, -0.0026699958834797144, 0.00629176152870059, -0.01772717572748661, -0.006934888660907745, 0.009210517629981041, -0.04590689763426781, -0.04868166893720627, 0.03888162225484848, 0.054864343255758286, -0.021606318652629852, -0.030821586027741432, -0.037236277014017105, 0.0414152592420578, -0.012082787230610847, 0.06500294059515, 0.006397991441190243, -0.04658913612365723, -0.022066175937652588, -0.028002673760056496, 0.060618072748184204, 0.022765059024095535, 0.03239674121141434, 0.016745546832680702, -0.015244212932884693, -0.04805464297533035, -0.02475643716752529, 0.01267570722848177, -0.015860265120863914, 0.0020077042281627655, -0.010690336115658283, -0.006666915956884623, 0.033409714698791504, -0.003998167812824249, -0.006769666913896799, 0.003069066908210516, -0.027991119772195816, -0.03750714659690857, -0.014876279979944229, 0.027757039293646812, -0.004522417671978474, 0.0040629589930176735, 0.05748036876320839, 0.004233173094689846, 0.0315481498837471, 0.0054562995210289955, -0.06221955269575119, -0.012055310420691967, 0.012613310478627682, -0.01531317550688982, -0.011896987445652485, -0.005796418059617281, 0.04135923460125923, 0.03367399424314499, 0.05306122452020645, -0.020504150539636612, 0.0285965409129858, -0.020876485854387283, -0.0037351080682128668, 0.00013762727030552924, -0.033393289893865585, 0.011786612682044506, 0.04140172153711319, 0.005457462277263403, -0.03234283998608589, -0.0010321501176804304, 0.009218325838446617, 0.006738361902534962, 0.04087229445576668, -0.0041978913359344006, -0.04366401955485344, 0.018124530091881752, 0.0017588972114026546, 0.036475006490945816, -0.02126959152519703, 0.02237260527908802, -0.00933629646897316, 0.055514853447675705, -0.025144601240754128, 0.009317448362708092, 0.027776386588811874, 0.01752367615699768, 0.0007696066168136895, -0.00335524370893836, 0.054691966623067856, 0.0053297607228159904, 0.007008229847997427, -0.0037870847154408693, 0.03591359406709671, -0.025796856731176376, 0.03340531513094902, 0.004690179135650396, -0.022482842206954956, 0.022925246506929398, -0.0332094207406044, 0.008302874863147736, 0.01811990700662136, -0.0029040207155048847, 0.011332251131534576, -0.009244661778211594, -0.02331399917602539, -0.03515487536787987, 0.05082153528928757, -0.02116663195192814, 0.0042283241637051105, 0.010432886891067028, 0.0023110774345695972, -0.007660771254450083, -0.03972300887107849, -0.006652595475316048, 0.01799599453806877, 0.0008542828727513552, 0.006850795354694128, 0.019118964672088623, 0.005200832616537809, -0.02992270328104496, -0.012439736165106297, -0.004478600807487965, 0.007869294844567776, -0.0012290963204577565, -0.04644741117954254, 0.014792956411838531, 0.024493396282196045, -0.007052381988614798, 0.05681058019399643, -0.011212744750082493, 0.021192703396081924, -0.06575842946767807, 0.0044305953197181225, 0.009559303522109985, 0.0027386988513171673, 0.053307268768548965, -0.021644683554768562, 0.016972830519080162, 0.021727072075009346, -0.008685559034347534, 0.0011753614526242018, -0.0029874369502067566, 0.017725929617881775, -0.0424836166203022, -0.00206806231290102, -0.0488751046359539, 0.05838814750313759, 0.04276220127940178, 0.01784410886466503, 0.052785951644182205, 0.033651452511548996, -0.036430247128009796, 0.004987502936273813, -0.014282014220952988, 0.034837864339351654, -0.004973588045686483, -0.07439836859703064, 0.03527136892080307, -0.03131089732050896, -0.016766812652349472, 0.04335591942071915, 0.019481856375932693, -0.005689531564712524, 0.02165829762816429, 0.021886177361011505, 0.017382150515913963, 0.049028217792510986, 0.042922452092170715, -0.035887546837329865, -0.0001922636292874813, 0.01897726207971573, 0.02072150446474552, 0.028148410841822624, 0.012909960933029652, 0.01605168543756008, -0.022966112941503525, -0.01773926056921482, 0.01629396341741085, -0.009481769055128098, -0.02199026197195053, -0.005911491811275482, -0.01127286721020937, 0.0027242458891123533, -0.0050868564285337925, -0.008291179314255714, 0.01455727219581604, -0.012045175768435001, -0.01861688680946827, 0.05275045707821846, 0.03319680318236351, -0.017873607575893402, 0.0003630708088167012, -0.026915419846773148, -0.08095911145210266, 0.04104373976588249, 0.006713292561471462, 0.015710745006799698, -0.03971875086426735, -0.016038624569773674, 0.02729758433997631, 0.02270851843059063, -0.042678218334913254, -0.0028680486138910055, -0.05332266166806221, 0.03333218768239021, -0.02618025802075863, 0.0035948045551776886, 0.02790539152920246, 0.010919235646724701, 0.003522413782775402, -0.10104315727949142, 0.06003696843981743, -0.02895285375416279, -0.019107118248939514, -0.01760684885084629, -0.043826837092638016, -0.0665149837732315, -0.01835620403289795, 0.06518109142780304, 0.013043749146163464, -0.01154272723942995, 0.006499050185084343, 0.014860200695693493, -0.004732344765216112, -0.026892052963376045, 0.058349210768938065, -0.03433027118444443, -0.006649437360465527, 0.012438906356692314, -0.03311613202095032, 0.014866720885038376, 0.040095794945955276, 0.0030918223783373833, -0.02715660072863102, 0.007988138124346733, 0.013182076625525951, -0.023198211565613747, 0.04352249577641487, 0.01616056077182293, -0.04051322862505913, 0.04654228687286377, 0.0020752607379108667, 0.005570586770772934, 0.028821071609854698, 0.006329543422907591, -0.05038199946284294, 0.02951923944056034, -0.0014505614526569843, -0.02982947789132595, 0.012584886513650417, 0.036814626306295395, 0.007413450628519058, -0.028627263382077217, -0.0024628571700304747, 0.04937737062573433, -0.021213321015238762, 0.01330457255244255, 0.011630481109023094, -0.013148680329322815, 0.06154894083738327, -0.0336260050535202, 0.035609450191259384, 0.028324443846940994, -0.024538684636354446, 0.022136952728033066, 0.004788708873093128, 0.03867459297180176, 0.011970330029726028, 0.009962545707821846, 0.022360315546393394, -0.03186710923910141, 0.021014437079429626, -0.028647342696785927, 0.009978334419429302, -0.019431935623288155, -0.004133446607738733, 0.015257797203958035, -0.0011150059290230274, -0.010011843405663967, 0.008506023325026035, -0.010546122677624226, 0.05365927144885063, -0.03749413788318634, -0.03510675206780434, 0.004365290515124798, 0.014427249319851398, -0.02569546550512314, 0.002386039588600397, -0.022003421559929848, 0.0359790101647377, 0.02663056179881096, -0.020118074491620064, -0.0040341024287045, -0.03481985628604889, 0.028202196583151817, -0.05662737786769867, -0.0005603989120572805, -0.014063283801078796, 0.013637217693030834, -0.0218375101685524, -0.037653326988220215, -0.05372922867536545, -0.003687061835080385, -0.0030520453583449125, 0.0207387562841177, 0.006184838712215424, -0.02861005999147892, -0.05555543676018715, 0.003915927838534117, 0.04782941937446594, -0.0468313992023468, 0.010409596376121044, -0.06539411097764969, -0.0065783243626356125, -0.003832835704088211, -0.019164394587278366 ]