question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
int64
0
74.5k
sentence_embeddings
sequencelengths
1.02k
1.02k
<p>Suppose I roll 10 dice (six-sided). What is the probability of seeing k faces that appear more than (or equal to) 3 times?</p> <p>For example, if I see 1, 1, 1, 2, 2, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 then I have observed 2 faces that appeared more than (or equal to) 3 times (1 and 2).</p> <p>I guess I can try running a simulation but was wondering if there is a neat way to calculate this analytically.</p>
73,498
[ -0.03406713530421257, -0.0490226112306118, 0.008785358630120754, -0.02574855089187622, 0.0547860823571682, -0.011451260186731815, 0.007398321758955717, -0.021766962483525276, 0.0012992770643904805, -0.0169121902436018, 0.009348943829536438, 0.03151721879839897, 0.017273416742682457, 0.0262377317994833, -0.005240092519670725, 0.02039443701505661, -0.04530027508735657, -0.0199566837400198, 0.010063626803457737, -0.04716259241104126, 0.0004525305121205747, 0.03946655988693237, -0.002317711478099227, -0.035345565527677536, -0.04526589438319206, 0.051507290452718735, 0.06779534369707108, -0.03675160929560661, 0.07064659148454666, 0.04192855954170227, -0.04472242295742035, -0.0007221054402180016, 0.059789206832647324, 0.05819214880466461, 0.014849738217890263, 0.017810756340622902, 0.022264868021011353, -0.03268449008464813, 0.0008650753879919648, 0.014506204053759575, -0.037931814789772034, -0.003694449784234166, -0.0018321046372875571, 0.0506398044526577, 0.008262055926024914, -0.009725882671773434, -0.030984122306108475, -0.06690622121095657, 0.0071164811961352825, -0.062238723039627075, 0.10579126328229904, -0.013921703211963177, 0.028383515775203705, 0.019459912553429604, -0.005527058616280556, -0.011410596780478954, 0.07516763359308243, 0.0695170909166336, 0.021162953227758408, -0.040596578270196915, -0.0038536451756954193, -0.028015775606036186, -0.01567893661558628, -0.008869125507771969, -0.0160263292491436, 0.02780233509838581, -0.012864657677710056, -0.016921430826187134, 0.026423048228025436, -0.019325604662299156, 0.010973664931952953, 0.02283773012459278, 0.0723191425204277, -0.004339559003710747, 0.0032489923760294914, -0.014146902598440647, 0.04073663428425789, 0.018463876098394394, 0.04863864928483963, 0.012201649136841297, -0.010067380964756012, 0.011737557128071785, 0.04767478629946709, 0.004667090252041817, 0.03619907423853874, -0.010503701865673065, 0.07415971904993057, 0.004173499997705221, 0.01964969001710415, 0.013311733491718769, -0.04610621556639671, 0.008339987136423588, 0.05174348130822182, 0.016073785722255707, -0.07687657326459885, -0.0016716612735763192, -0.007165778893977404, 0.05685833469033241, -0.01478227972984314, 0.01835852488875389, -0.035016268491744995, -0.04988662526011467, -0.000587670539971441, 0.048717714846134186, -0.010615792125463486, 0.012430515140295029, -0.021459126845002174, 0.02323688380420208, -0.006789918057620525, -0.0065784459002316, 0.007482792716473341, 0.025663621723651886, 0.013027038425207138, -0.005094575695693493, 0.0008883387199603021, -0.012692350894212723, -0.015624995343387127, -0.02473565936088562, 0.037100303918123245, 0.08308667689561844, 0.004198185633867979, -0.024819303303956985, 0.01320594735443592, -0.023525811731815338, -0.0665181502699852, 0.023519517853856087, 0.00985583197325468, -0.013895989395678043, -0.01628592424094677, 0.04370767995715141, -0.006121332291513681, -0.02672404609620571, 0.027077101171016693, -0.01488917414098978, 0.0068972003646194935, -0.01755460537970066, -0.05795279145240784, -0.059608932584524155, 0.03420904278755188, -0.02095060609281063, -0.018706781789660454, -0.034322164952754974, 0.03430696576833725, 0.053690072149038315, 0.04141134396195412, 0.007083731237798929, -0.002413281472399831, 0.0024318217765539885, 0.026719864457845688, 0.022892968729138374, -0.03838231787085533, 0.006680041551589966, -0.01843162812292576, -0.008800147101283073, 0.01792583428323269, -0.061710990965366364, 0.03755715489387512, 0.020748911425471306, 0.010629204101860523, -0.03309018537402153, 0.06514986604452133, -0.0031537499744445086, -0.010542407631874084, 0.007526149041950703, -0.007294105365872383, -0.025439301505684853, 0.06993065774440765, -0.0011450626188889146, 0.01814534328877926, -0.009473633021116257, -0.00651510851457715, 0.0017208560602739453, 0.011375890113413334, 0.04224429652094841, 0.04668964445590973, -0.04130569472908974, 0.02432011440396309, -0.009403549134731293, 0.022956587374210358, 0.020119277760386467, -0.018193066120147705, 0.008794750086963177, 0.014431213960051537, 0.00008750694541959092, 0.03731715306639671, -0.02310025505721569, -0.011792641133069992, -0.023380614817142487, 0.0003909847291652113, -0.022347133606672287, -0.04193505272269249, -0.08494924753904343, -0.004384813364595175, 0.0034995893947780132, -0.033540476113557816, 0.009124742820858955, 0.029469728469848633, 0.002264103153720498, -0.016414912417531013, -0.02141236513853073, -0.01656593568623066, -0.01461843028664589, 0.041263923048973083, -0.06829991191625595, -0.03501596301794052, 0.08120779693126678, 0.04776958376169205, 0.004651424940675497, 0.049312274903059006, -0.041805896908044815, 0.016730550676584244, -0.04336415231227875, -0.02152080647647381, -0.015976158902049065, -0.019099170342087746, -0.009783023968338966, 0.035105738788843155, 0.036985479295253754, -0.008642817847430706, 0.03649241849780083, -0.06740216165781021, 0.029781481251120567, 0.07914091646671295, 0.04610077291727066, 0.0053138285875320435, -0.022058958187699318, -0.0009299793164245784, -0.0262161735445261, 0.007597881834954023, -0.02819473296403885, -0.040243178606033325, 0.0014253760455176234, 0.023355452343821526, -0.008030606433749199, -0.03383595496416092, 0.013206424191594124, 0.07135391980409622, 0.012774194590747356, -0.007737061474472284, 0.05718035250902176, -0.013255961239337921, 0.012327156960964203, -0.011294849216938019, -0.03698382154107094, 0.03596474602818489, 0.007843561470508575, 0.025363864377141, -0.0023253292310982943, 0.0062712314538657665, 0.010266682133078575, -0.07101951539516449, 0.025749092921614647, -0.023555273190140724, 0.057477451860904694, -0.009130488149821758, -0.029149407520890236, 0.025699377059936523, -0.008077197708189487, -0.04554343596100807, 0.029567377641797066, 0.03032742813229561, -0.004197980277240276, -0.032277677208185196, -0.051857683807611465, 0.004217175301164389, 0.011332398280501366, -0.028347497805953026, 0.0011668686056509614, 0.002371504670009017, 0.01086881197988987, 0.019085120409727097, -0.011020972393453121, -0.01784338429570198, -0.02209405042231083, 0.0172400064766407, 0.018370918929576874, 0.0019933930598199368, 0.028182750567793846, -0.03825349360704422, -0.04377143085002899, -0.005221156403422356, -0.01959034986793995, -0.0032129862811416388, 0.009476709179580212, -0.10007234662771225, 0.03802518546581268, 0.02755853533744812, -0.048516061156988144, 0.01776781491935253, -0.034000128507614136, -0.0570264495909214, 0.02710169367492199, -0.0015344340354204178, -0.006562797352671623, 0.01707984320819378, -0.01611107960343361, 0.020123537629842758, -0.06108881160616875, 0.0029456373304128647, 0.004908175207674503, 0.01018765103071928, -0.05776281654834747, 0.026465455070137978, -0.03713703900575638, -0.040858782827854156, -0.046115122735500336, -0.01849091611802578, -0.006993340793997049, -0.05045686662197113, -0.02986740879714489, 0.026015089824795723, 0.013464132323861122, -0.0060119363479316235, -0.047236911952495575, -0.08568578213453293, 0.0020612271036952734, -0.006933630909770727, 0.04490041732788086, -0.0038571676705032587, -0.022558405995368958, 0.07123786956071854, 0.03126906231045723, 0.0002836650237441063, -0.024481136351823807, 0.0070557910948991776, -0.006261040456593037, -0.029197877272963524, 0.020677657797932625, -0.004851058125495911, -0.00986978318542242, 0.021296922117471695, 0.008521540090441704, 0.007231420371681452, 0.0754464790225029, -0.038730159401893616, -0.02755814418196678, -0.020726876333355904, -0.01496962085366249, 0.03058495558798313, 0.03408429026603699, 0.0036103632301092148, -0.08183139562606812, 0.004717154428362846, 0.01093960925936699, 0.010760326869785786, 0.021103356033563614, -0.03040718100965023, 0.022172199562191963, -0.02360248565673828, 0.023834064602851868, 0.01998441107571125, 0.03909752145409584, 0.0009560856851749122, -0.02009611390531063, 0.024255860596895218, 0.012121795676648617, 0.07819008082151413, -0.05029470473527908, -0.0009288870496675372, 0.028889168053865433, 0.013503669761121273, -0.01202008593827486, -0.02336660772562027, -0.023541267961263657, -0.020025696605443954, 0.002433351008221507, 0.0033821568358689547, -0.02136487327516079, 0.03378739207983017, 0.03568935766816139, 0.018521998077630997, 0.0024550624657422304, -0.014825088903307915, -0.007398685906082392, -0.029145272448658943, -0.022940965369343758, -0.027018440887331963, 0.020109008997678757, 0.010642184875905514, 0.050170157104730606, -0.01983785629272461, -0.031418006867170334, -0.0036018998362123966, 0.009323952719569206, -0.06793667376041412, 0.03950263932347298, -0.022713784128427505, -0.00331416935659945, -0.01552963349968195, -0.013464732095599174, 0.01949152909219265, -0.03267698362469673, 0.019086359068751335, 0.019373666495084763, 0.013205346651375294, -0.029988115653395653, -0.011082314886152744, -0.026933863759040833, -0.018367167562246323, 0.0008673991542309523, 0.04642331972718239, 0.03990327566862106, 0.007527678273618221, 0.04503166303038597, -0.0000399000127799809, -0.048176322132349014, -0.00010905520321102813, 0.008465698920190334, 0.0059445821680128574, 0.014089114964008331, 0.033109553158283234, 0.007382607087492943, 0.01830989308655262, -0.040295716375112534, 0.020022133365273476, -0.026809819042682648, 0.032968614250421524, 0.0505903922021389, 0.016316939145326614, -0.024747608229517937, -0.0604747012257576, -0.029070429503917694, -0.036866847425699234, 0.026316460222005844, -0.03654851019382477, -0.004590439144521952, 0.06584728509187698, 0.02815272845327854, -0.053079988807439804, 0.0063263061456382275, 0.03509535640478134, 0.004124822560697794, -0.059047434478998184, -0.04560641199350357, -0.0075937542133033276, -0.0038360648322850466, 0.012952334247529507, 0.023233026266098022, 0.003773478325456381, -0.013196077197790146, 0.023893125355243683, 0.01848462224006653, -0.01119517907500267, -0.014080180786550045, -0.0045353746972978115, -0.006327234208583832, 0.017429469153285027, -0.006743650417774916, -0.013516145758330822, 0.024598753079771996, 0.04035210236907005, 0.013914333656430244, 0.005586638581007719, -0.006357379723340273, -0.0420067235827446, -0.003796669654548168, 0.06067536026239395, 0.03049873188138008, -0.05855372175574303, 0.009244170039892197, -0.038586895912885666, -0.0016170184826478362, 0.01739758625626564, -0.041057802736759186, 0.007651154417544603, -0.004802452400326729, 0.009978977963328362, -0.016941752284765244, -0.01461028028279543, -0.04881860688328743, 0.034914642572402954, -0.04291754961013794, 0.02047022059559822, -0.024050822481513023, 0.010216686874628067, -0.03069327399134636, 0.02733001485466957, 0.06391248852014542, 0.07722879946231842, -0.013702462427318096, -0.015538827516138554, 0.002574698766693473, 0.0009977222653105855, -0.02558699995279312, -0.07566559314727783, 0.03085974231362343, -0.029225565493106842, -0.023728428408503532, 0.0676661878824234, -0.050057075917720795, -0.028878267854452133, -0.01606478914618492, 0.004917200189083815, 0.006939074955880642, -0.007741390261799097, -0.024901285767555237, 0.04495920240879059, 0.03689926117658615, -0.019942237064242363, 0.03720710426568985, -0.014598362147808075, 0.00019299420819152147, 0.011236527934670448, 0.02699013240635395, 0.01708192750811577, -0.014902512542903423, 0.027011869475245476, -0.02344471402466297, -0.011598744429647923, -0.04325338080525398, 0.012395699508488178, -0.040503181517124176, 0.021922113373875618, 0.0008156460826285183, -0.007218464277684689, -0.035673800855875015, 0.03181945160031319, 0.06401123851537704, 0.04966922476887703, -0.0043181926012039185, 0.0013621192192658782, 0.0294698104262352, -0.013791658915579319, 0.017415812239050865, -0.006119725294411182, 0.0032997934613376856, -0.006564946845173836, -0.004728220868855715, 0.003336533671244979, -0.0601254366338253, -0.020282570272684097, -0.0015060427831485868, -0.03381132706999779, 0.08146519213914871, -0.03487938642501831, 0.027081456035375595, 0.0027648652903735638, -0.02916191890835762, 0.012642630375921726, -0.010524136014282703, -0.019069025292992592, 0.05139973759651184, -0.011326990090310574, 0.04123469814658165, -0.009876089170575142, 0.02119409665465355, -0.10710085928440094, 0.0013861279003322124, 0.04197840020060539, 0.029395436868071556, -0.02466941624879837, -0.004176189191639423, -0.02824287861585617, -0.01752650737762451, -0.03430226072669029, 0.009071416221559048, 0.04900079965591431, -0.00581083120778203, -0.020584356039762497, 0.013634756207466125, -0.007000246085226536, 0.05353280529379845, 0.017336564138531685, -0.01146213710308075, 0.005405335687100887, -0.03167131170630455, -0.010493694804608822, -0.01648429036140442, 0.02373652346432209, -0.03016117587685585, 0.0011857636272907257, -0.018275482580065727, 0.013989442959427834, 0.045121822506189346, -0.045403268188238144, -0.024280911311507225, -0.010328790172934532, 0.017325758934020996, 0.01577400416135788, -0.04773760586977005, -0.0004445775703061372, -0.02210242487490177, 0.020666269585490227, -0.031586743891239166, -0.013468170538544655, 0.000809273449704051, 0.02482471987605095, 0.019147736951708794, 0.01255034003406763, -0.014884849078953266, -0.011804879643023014, 0.07004261761903763, -0.002596735255792737, -0.02125885710120201, -0.025142591446638107, -0.03531040623784065, 0.028798075392842293, -0.018480520695447922, -0.04067772626876831, 0.03239791840314865, 0.024091068655252457, -0.010199408046901226, -0.02504144050180912, -0.021458471193909645, 0.02126258797943592, 0.05578392744064331, -0.0457291416823864, 0.03431403636932373, 0.028049098327755928, 0.03261379897594452, 0.006849047262221575, 0.014233285561203957, 0.012014525011181831, -0.008685384877026081, 0.01754787750542164, 0.047332633286714554, -0.013365674763917923, 0.05364096164703369, 0.06152523308992386, 0.042954474687576294, 0.02494354546070099, 0.08261201530694962, 0.02451483905315399, 0.016132576391100883, 0.024587012827396393, -0.016907595098018646, -0.02230832912027836, 0.03955761715769768, -0.06845485419034958, 0.008752950467169285, -0.010620404034852982, -0.03168836608529091, 0.0574992373585701, 0.01729644276201725, -0.0010792114771902561, 0.0024882149882614613, -0.05500352010130882, -0.004246885888278484, 0.006195784080773592, 0.018825050443410873, 0.032573699951171875, 0.011608690954744816, -0.0031112534925341606, 0.020023133605718613, 0.008042979054152966, 0.020747657865285873, -0.02011980675160885, -0.08403346687555313, 0.0016284751472994685, -0.023509051650762558, -0.021780086681246758, -0.010639440268278122, 0.045163702219724655, -0.013788268901407719, 0.011891101486980915, -0.019601967185735703, 0.014575853012502193, 0.03403914347290993, 0.054710134863853455, -0.017953794449567795, 0.07470890879631042, 0.031826671212911606, 0.040147989988327026, 0.0022437036968767643, 0.015344752930104733, 0.09893240034580231, 0.04217328876256943, 0.0175162386149168, -0.06105146184563637, 0.04679564759135246, -0.016545293852686882, 0.008250750601291656, -0.01910671591758728, 0.0406142883002758, 0.015153701417148113, 0.007657903712242842, 0.005354298744350672, 0.0441933237016201, -0.006714698392897844, 0.0048614623956382275, 0.03981980308890343, -0.0518798902630806, -0.029662664979696274, 0.013070711866021156, -0.00793917290866375, 0.015896543860435486, -0.008222761563956738, -0.05748918652534485, 0.0017216112464666367, -0.031846556812524796, -0.03330663591623306, -0.037128496915102005, 0.009180382825434208, 0.0011277964804321527, 0.011750675737857819, -0.044392555952072144, -0.0025124496314674616, 0.010432484559714794, -0.03706469386816025, -0.004267908167093992, 0.026059933006763458, 0.03429730609059334, -0.028857866302132607, 0.049989525228738785, 0.0277444738894701, -0.01092605572193861, 0.015742678195238113, 0.002037962432950735, 0.01202926505357027, -0.03003128431737423, -0.0032982819247990847, -0.04146435111761093, 0.059529975056648254, -0.0012425234308466315, 0.01613563857972622, -0.009301059879362583, -0.019372934475541115, -0.005950658582150936, -0.05626867339015007, 0.0034970040433108807, 0.02328786812722683, -0.0026178446132689714, -0.02924809604883194, -0.04734214395284653, -0.013083754107356071, 0.014165375381708145, -0.0026191524229943752, 0.03978724032640457, 0.032137736678123474, -0.002824266441166401, -0.011179843917489052, -0.02896924875676632, 0.033483974635601044, -0.0005905531579628587, -0.007572185713797808, -0.016407225281000137, -0.010743964463472366, -0.02235722355544567, -0.008079825900495052, -0.014777247793972492, -0.001714133657515049, 0.015668828040361404, 0.0053994059562683105, -0.043513115495443344, 0.016036227345466614, -0.014506258070468903, -0.0006260128575377166, -0.02140432596206665, 0.002325948793441057, -0.035565897822380066, -0.00162617361638695, 0.0658254399895668, -0.012050981633365154, -0.008361379615962505, -0.008905003778636456, -0.009987900964915752, 0.007023419253528118, -0.021502209827303886, 0.00008520136179868132, -0.004965502303093672, 0.0011643576435744762, -0.036244213581085205, 0.008174107410013676, -0.018876513466238976, 0.053078990429639816, 0.004545760806649923, 0.01065885554999113, 0.05052350088953972, 0.03786054998636246, -0.01792619749903679, 0.011150549165904522, -0.003107273019850254, -0.05654367431998253, -0.007819108664989471, 0.029607625678181648, 0.02317984774708748, -0.017265062779188156, -0.054444730281829834, 0.005757514853030443, 0.0027996839489787817, 0.022517088800668716, -0.02122017741203308, -0.02971917949616909, -0.005099759437143803, 0.0008718813769519329, 0.01461884006857872, -0.004196958616375923, -0.011953402310609818, -0.033812589943408966, -0.00807456485927105, 0.02960658073425293, 0.0008837456116452813, -0.022856274619698524, -0.002735940972343087, 0.030619675293564796, 0.01791861094534397, 0.027734318748116493, 0.037306491285562515, 0.03095555119216442, -0.008037365972995758, 0.04172097146511078, -0.0194788109511137, 0.03871401026844978, -0.04858572036027908, -0.07462945580482483, 0.04700177162885666, -0.0817134901881218, 0.000009405520358996, 0.03235558420419693, 0.013151643797755241, 0.0660027489066124, 0.028732921928167343, 0.014801131561398506, -0.019436493515968323, 0.03687470406293869, -0.04068610817193985, -0.032813236117362976, 0.015626125037670135, 0.025988545268774033, 0.0060082292184233665, -0.030811190605163574, 0.005196928977966309, 0.012193584814667702, 0.0007951381267048419, 0.018714386969804764, 0.03364945948123932, 0.0046957917511463165, -0.010992450639605522, 0.014183411374688148, 0.042453087866306305, -0.0043570478446781635, 0.0018712495220825076, -0.028094874694943428, 0.012324003502726555, 0.027923347428441048, -0.04157477989792824, 0.0752108246088028, -0.019366225227713585, -0.000998015282675624, -0.0908699482679367, 0.0034527552779763937, 0.003461651038378477, 0.030253948643803596, 0.08634986728429794, -0.07823172211647034, 0.018774082884192467, 0.03255854919552803, -0.027677923440933228, 0.02082420140504837, 0.04814968258142471, -0.005779014900326729, -0.0767926275730133, 0.043720513582229614, -0.0041932882741093636, 0.01624930277466774, 0.02403886988759041, -0.008084584958851337, 0.049630001187324524, 0.0019519415218383074, -0.022105194628238678, -0.06437130272388458, 0.015532621182501316, 0.038144875317811966, -0.02380930632352829, -0.03544105216860771, 0.02241651713848114, -0.01248923409730196, -0.0512143112719059, 0.03356761857867241, -0.008236313238739967, 0.003168467665091157, -0.019386526197195053, 0.009574679657816887, -0.005249139852821827, 0.017038553953170776, 0.029625488445162773, -0.006193486973643303, 0.03247141093015671, -0.0033195510040968657, -0.01401862595230341, 0.003755386918783188, -0.009680701419711113, 0.010364440269768238, 0.055631086230278015, -0.0023096289951354265, -0.013260644860565662, 0.020026199519634247, 0.019994860514998436, -0.006747020408511162, -0.010955305770039558, 0.0019318347331136465, 0.03782548010349274, -0.03142795339226723, 0.03909314423799515, -0.03397202864289284, 0.006239632610231638, -0.015376058407127857, 0.036716803908348083, 0.0027784446720033884, 0.014710817486047745, -0.05023679509758949, -0.04440834000706673, 0.01537666842341423, -0.0038585576694458723, -0.008327406831085682, -0.06229547783732414, -0.0043414076790213585, 0.029982134699821472, 0.016280950978398323, 0.04529678821563721, -0.037141185253858566, -0.023319633677601814, -0.005715285427868366, -0.025748491287231445, 0.03253573551774025, 0.04214228689670563, -0.020994750782847404, -0.004755434580147266, -0.06094503402709961, 0.06745360046625137, -0.007858270779252052, -0.0021374805364757776, -0.041042666882276535, -0.008248536847531796, -0.022345535457134247, 0.01703593321144581, 0.03493664413690567, 0.008439908735454082, -0.023580294102430344, -0.024134134873747826, 0.02179504558444023, 0.015553879551589489, -0.10485100001096725, -0.007408146746456623, -0.03286347910761833, -0.004249109886586666, -0.04907338321208954, -0.014522900804877281, 0.023499390110373497, -0.016681432723999023, 0.014531083405017853, -0.005245196167379618, -0.00001262575460714288, 0.021059272810816765, -0.00017354950250592083, 0.03185414522886276, 0.012545879930257797, 0.00857506599277258, 0.03935930132865906, 0.00200655497610569, -0.002891561947762966, 0.01446489803493023, 0.0010188731830567122, -0.020859813317656517, 0.042841169983148575, -0.036019276827573776, -0.018353018909692764, -0.02076958864927292, -0.01797354780137539, 0.02719980478286743, -0.05951278284192085, 0.0005347252008505166, -0.003582256380468607, -0.03265659511089325, 0.009451741352677345, 0.05141504853963852, 0.01456120889633894, 0.040569715201854706, -0.007639686577022076, 0.047280196100473404, -0.019000425934791565, -0.011648961342871189, -0.007574751507490873, 0.0064255110919475555, -0.013925214298069477, 0.00356296100653708, 0.023572484031319618, 0.016530094668269157, -0.009862205944955349, 0.044999703764915466, -0.02701535075902939, 0.002167005790397525, 0.00031092524295672774, 0.01238042302429676, 0.0007599035161547363, -0.012890876270830631, 0.025587454438209534, -0.028217565268278122, 0.012357261031866074, 0.053706202656030655, 0.009851338341832161, 0.00936262309551239, -0.027107374742627144, -0.02209998480975628, -0.03934849053621292, -0.027714040130376816, 0.024273235350847244, 0.03824963420629501, -0.016496064141392708, -0.019759653136134148, 0.004799273330718279, 0.015128258615732193, 0.04554532468318939, -0.04650893807411194, 0.040660783648490906, -0.025790933519601822, -0.03942352533340454, -0.015260585583746433, -0.020765727385878563, -0.0003940860042348504, -0.015443303622305393, 0.04467957839369774, 0.006232816725969315, 0.011194522492587566, 0.012755134142935276, -0.029480313882231712, 0.0033579471055418253, 0.042751163244247437, -0.03659718483686447, -0.026781760156154633, -0.06913633644580841, 0.05810545012354851, 0.006109675858169794, -0.007242344319820404 ]
<p>Consider four random complex vectors $\mu_i$ of length $K$ whose entries are drawn from the complex normal distribution $\mathcal{CN}(\mathbf{0},\mathbb{1})$ centered in zero and of unit variance. Then form the $2 \times 2$ complex "normalized" matrix $$ \chi=\frac{1}{\sum_i|\mu_i|^2}\begin{pmatrix}\mu_1^*\\\mu_2^*\end{pmatrix}\cdot\begin{pmatrix}\mu_3&amp;\mu_4\end{pmatrix}=\frac{1}{\sum_i|\mu_i|^2} \begin{pmatrix}\mu_1^*\cdot\mu_3&amp;\mu_1^*\cdot\mu_4\\\mu_2^*\cdot\mu_3&amp;\mu_2^*\cdot\mu_4\end{pmatrix} $$ where the asterisk stands for conjugate. I need to calculate the mean value of the largest eigenvalue of $\chi^\dagger\chi$ as a function of $K$ (where the dagger stands for conjugate transpose).</p> <p>...I don't even know where to start from. I found <a href="https://space.zeo.net/g/1ud3t" rel="nofollow">this paper</a> which I hoped could be of help, but the four entries of the matrix $\chi$, above, are not independent of each other, so I'm not sure how to use that characteristic function (eq. 2 in the paper).</p>
73,499
[ -0.028639942407608032, -0.026150193065404892, 0.00047772692050784826, 0.014547796919941902, 0.06748352944850922, 0.013372465968132019, -0.02275780402123928, -0.03920545428991318, -0.003435553051531315, -0.06615987420082092, 0.052497006952762604, 0.04250065237283707, 0.059102095663547516, 0.03223321586847305, 0.011122475378215313, 0.01532512903213501, -0.048851218074560165, 0.0044989436864852905, -0.0320235975086689, -0.03213097155094147, 0.005061534699052572, 0.028055408969521523, 0.01994626596570015, -0.04297088459134102, -0.04901505634188652, 0.036887623369693756, 0.002233966486528516, -0.026086153462529182, -0.008026846684515476, 0.04694662615656853, -0.042742468416690826, -0.04313435032963753, 0.0247248113155365, 0.03025347739458084, -0.027275871485471725, -0.021901164203882217, -0.026932811364531517, -0.02584446221590042, -0.002426526742056012, 0.026818718761205673, -0.06479088962078094, -0.040640801191329956, -0.02637232095003128, -0.0071977670304477215, 0.007931969128549099, 0.0036439227405935526, -0.02129283919930458, -0.040588680654764175, 0.04406646639108658, -0.05947648361325264, 0.10798957198858261, 0.01274074986577034, 0.019909432157874107, -0.001275787129998207, 0.0020587637554854155, -0.04454786702990532, 0.022414837032556534, 0.06418750435113907, 0.025877049192786217, -0.0700843408703804, -0.007788436952978373, -0.007596075069159269, -0.0060403011739254, -0.018499044701457024, -0.026286199688911438, -0.014159467071294785, 0.012640328146517277, -0.039640314877033234, 0.02424822747707367, -0.00872772466391325, -0.015619910322129726, 0.01477313507348299, 0.044877029955387115, -0.0033514383248984814, -0.014583648182451725, 0.01089744083583355, 0.0050264024175703526, 0.03615118935704231, 0.044848907738924026, -0.025518011301755905, 0.00033012154744938016, 0.03594546765089035, 0.012393291108310223, 0.000020306526494096033, -0.009429524652659893, 0.024676047265529633, 0.09131482243537903, 0.015238180756568909, 0.012776507996022701, 0.051083043217659, -0.00813426822423935, 0.02528931386768818, 0.03391561657190323, 0.018296945840120316, -0.04562673345208168, 0.021921459585428238, -0.009371955879032612, 0.047567009925842285, -0.010632047429680824, -0.024133523926138878, -0.02325575239956379, -0.048352573066949844, 0.016375258564949036, 0.042805399745702744, 0.009863029234111309, 0.01425796840339899, -0.017742598429322243, 0.035283610224723816, -0.00815186370164156, -0.028708340600132942, -0.04475880786776543, 0.03451653942465782, -0.052590832114219666, 0.010516113601624966, 0.011590876616537571, -0.03258552774786949, -0.023417390882968903, -0.016564611345529556, 0.021389266476035118, 0.07792618125677109, 0.011533920653164387, -0.010634807869791985, 0.00655103474855423, -0.07269176840782166, -0.03304235264658928, 0.06628241389989853, 0.022631477564573288, 0.025113457813858986, -0.07326890528202057, 0.051151618361473083, 0.014122108928859234, 0.018531689420342445, 0.013462263159453869, -0.01986655779182911, -0.006590517703443766, -0.03962956368923187, -0.09826434403657913, -0.019845180213451385, 0.047176770865917206, -0.040020689368247986, -0.019166694954037666, -0.09027866274118423, -0.019815800711512566, 0.017877547070384026, 0.08570556342601776, -0.02010074257850647, 0.022236276417970657, 0.009221491403877735, 0.016992507502436638, 0.041576288640499115, -0.007272567134350538, -0.0030441877897828817, -0.04122636839747429, -0.0016853574197739363, -0.012980218976736069, -0.02848639152944088, 0.030888725072145462, -0.0015390297630801797, 0.018660077825188637, 0.007146873045712709, 0.05264817923307419, 0.009487222880125046, 0.005392180290073156, 0.02483758144080639, 0.013230876997113228, -0.03474150970578194, 0.06782697141170502, 0.044265322387218475, 0.00809422042220831, -0.007979135029017925, -0.027303941547870636, -0.0062329452484846115, -0.014149489812552929, 0.04216322302818298, 0.023858942091464996, -0.013634104281663895, 0.011357857845723629, -0.006412917748093605, 0.02069794572889805, -0.004418752156198025, -0.004591069649904966, -0.05306278541684151, -0.02311159297823906, -0.008875121362507343, 0.009777449071407318, 0.047270577400922775, -0.0031938564497977495, -0.005237548146396875, 0.019932294264435768, -0.04334264621138573, -0.0060468935407698154, -0.04235788807272911, 0.006058652885258198, 0.015796400606632233, -0.0443623848259449, 0.02619270794093609, -0.0005800619255751371, 0.0252231378108263, 0.031727053225040436, -0.014451348222792149, -0.020548177883028984, -0.0323755145072937, 0.07883384823799133, -0.038043439388275146, -0.005781498737633228, 0.05016675963997841, 0.027585091069340706, -0.004362979903817177, 0.04002518579363823, -0.0035806773230433464, -0.017122643068432808, 0.021585188806056976, 0.004712305963039398, 0.035208456218242645, 0.02449682541191578, -0.00702762883156538, 0.0016550479922443628, 0.0071304431185126305, 0.003981072921305895, 0.0075727649964392185, -0.03367732837796211, 0.035188741981983185, 0.03593166172504425, 0.009981376118957996, 0.012411517091095448, 0.04935280606150627, 0.009649437852203846, 0.025030910968780518, -0.002401024103164673, -0.00683607067912817, -0.0383552685379982, 0.0035167927853763103, 0.01980605535209179, 0.03290557488799095, -0.06909038871526718, 0.012842126190662384, 0.03794324770569801, 0.03471190109848976, 0.04692816361784935, 0.0003891649830620736, -0.00569260586053133, -0.02037309855222702, 0.004848947282880545, 0.0070364223793148994, -0.015063092112541199, 0.009380841627717018, -0.0017982075223699212, -0.0069915251806378365, 0.029994601383805275, 0.01989709958434105, -0.020524246618151665, 0.0343652069568634, -0.032167982310056686, -0.0014350266428664327, -0.03189324960112572, -0.022657319903373718, 0.048895709216594696, -0.01757150888442993, -0.008926810696721077, 0.059840764850378036, -0.027967987582087517, -0.019586782902479172, -0.0026393660809844732, -0.029727764427661896, 0.009958476759493351, -0.005438063759356737, -0.024143116548657417, 0.011601651087403297, 0.011779919266700745, -0.01439413707703352, 0.03476788476109505, -0.03020368330180645, -0.015535449609160423, -0.0192509014159441, -0.00042719824705272913, 0.04728243127465248, -0.00729505205526948, -0.01281771156936884, -0.0024963202886283398, -0.03521440550684929, 0.03471771627664566, 0.01750105619430542, 0.020956557244062424, 0.0426953099668026, -0.05559370666742325, 0.003865247592329979, -0.03846339136362076, -0.018935471773147583, 0.027314288541674614, -0.005104652605950832, 0.026941560208797455, 0.015132038854062557, -0.01714538037776947, -0.045786116272211075, -0.02173982746899128, 0.021269667893648148, 0.013608560897409916, -0.07799474149942398, 0.00723608722910285, 0.009449505247175694, -0.004303278401494026, -0.011535204015672207, -0.008659047074615955, -0.013386426493525505, -0.06491649150848389, -0.0006823788280598819, -0.030413493514060974, 0.021412137895822525, -0.005180134437978268, 0.030945342034101486, 0.03744449093937874, -0.016831832006573677, -0.00972704030573368, -0.07538308948278427, -0.03159695491194725, 0.04752866551280022, -0.0006158868200145662, 0.03249624744057655, 0.02642165496945381, -0.03203456848859787, 0.0912904441356659, 0.02485084906220436, -0.007585157640278339, -0.020798634737730026, 0.024279428645968437, -0.038640815764665604, -0.05309033766388893, -0.002359189558774233, 0.017062073573470116, -0.007810648996382952, 0.0423581637442112, 0.017632296308875084, -0.03688032925128937, 0.052154216915369034, -0.023441726341843605, -0.011446184478700161, 0.016702432185411453, -0.05401945114135742, -0.011076631024479866, 0.04034346342086792, -0.0007034895243123174, 0.003904761513695121, 0.0002379185607424006, 0.04346012696623802, -0.0004924137028865516, -0.041887447237968445, -0.036887869238853455, 0.003746100701391697, -0.01461174339056015, 0.020411105826497078, -0.014429662376642227, 0.04151203855872154, 0.00855996273458004, -0.05677444115281105, -0.0031745017040520906, 0.05688627436757088, 0.04619402065873146, -0.03585675731301308, 0.04335079714655876, 0.020547807216644287, -0.002144403988495469, 0.0042687952518463135, 0.02554548904299736, -0.022201161831617355, -0.0159373190253973, 0.03140711411833763, -0.05154268443584442, -0.040682341903448105, 0.0474528931081295, 0.03631638363003731, 0.025715669617056847, 0.0015127497026696801, -0.017631033435463905, 0.014280830509960651, -0.052564837038517, 0.0353044793009758, -0.046123284846544266, 0.03287883847951889, 0.013113969936966896, 0.027759289368987083, 0.018200648948550224, -0.00987579021602869, -0.017595192417502403, 0.0025591126177459955, -0.11863657087087631, 0.008792863227427006, -0.024357201531529427, 0.012817086651921272, 0.0070629180409014225, -0.04241253063082695, 0.05434217303991318, -0.008267709985375404, 0.027532070875167847, 0.01066066138446331, 0.02038218453526497, -0.03762698173522949, 0.02173362858593464, -0.049563366919755936, 0.007147121708840132, -0.0062437476590275764, -0.00032686089980416, 0.0439775288105011, -0.015658700838685036, 0.019644804298877716, 0.037590786814689636, -0.020472094416618347, 0.012431953102350235, -0.03159937635064125, 0.03049314394593239, 0.01520512904971838, 0.023389087989926338, 0.02010735496878624, 0.021444272249937057, -0.00530864205211401, 0.006530299782752991, -0.0310154277831316, 0.05564458295702934, 0.06547258794307709, 0.017204120755195618, 0.02137763425707817, -0.03995997831225395, 0.0009493305115029216, 0.014821323566138744, 0.04243747144937515, 0.0166705884039402, -0.008031265810132027, 0.04406625032424927, 0.012533826753497124, -0.03843598812818527, 0.03183521702885628, 0.0496455617249012, 0.028487833216786385, 0.0077072130516171455, -0.05782035365700722, 0.014070955105125904, 0.03104843571782112, 0.011159776709973812, 0.017083123326301575, -0.007889585569500923, 0.003455209545791149, -0.011122730560600758, 0.03524644672870636, -0.001955720828846097, 0.016562242060899734, 0.0019212886691093445, 0.013643346726894379, 0.01630786992609501, -0.006212251726537943, 0.010835792869329453, -0.004931104835122824, 0.03538482263684273, 0.011964061297476292, 0.02075720764696598, -0.043621908873319626, -0.0586615689098835, -0.015116744674742222, 0.04114848002791405, 0.033936358988285065, -0.012357799336314201, -0.01476563885807991, -0.036600857973098755, -0.025713812559843063, 0.017441941425204277, 0.004109970293939114, 0.07853493094444275, 0.013253767043352127, -0.015134554356336594, -0.0013259699335321784, -0.032535091042518616, -0.025848397985100746, 0.04809191823005676, 0.005930454470217228, -0.0042782071977853775, -0.022895125672221184, -0.020012231543660164, -0.047979433089494705, 0.008105156011879444, -0.0028418544679880142, 0.04494067654013634, -0.010772920213639736, -0.002812320599332452, 0.03711352497339249, 0.04823971167206764, 0.0028574177995324135, -0.05398326367139816, 0.020299749448895454, 0.0015343597624450922, -0.02133987843990326, 0.04673166573047638, -0.03775753453373909, -0.029005710035562515, 0.030121972784399986, 0.03317714110016823, -0.06916937232017517, 0.020672110840678215, 0.019839223474264145, 0.05374130234122276, 0.030271684750914574, -0.02027144469320774, 0.07286033034324646, 0.04031683877110481, 0.04189981520175934, 0.00963795930147171, -0.030101580545306206, 0.051483120769262314, -0.0023729177191853523, 0.0004499050264712423, -0.04070626571774483, 0.02513924427330494, -0.0014003143878653646, 0.044669948518276215, -0.02689848653972149, 0.05197496339678764, -0.03088054247200489, 0.030949637293815613, -0.023801641538739204, 0.00027163728373125196, -0.014478225260972977, -0.007585958577692509, 0.032845210283994675, 0.034712012857198715, 0.002208135789260268, -0.028191767632961273, 0.02935541421175003, -0.027547134086489677, 0.0076783387921750546, 0.036769285798072815, -0.010593723505735397, 0.010277233086526394, -0.07531411945819855, -0.02131578139960766, 0.002865872113034129, -0.04100658744573593, 0.06360108405351639, -0.021870512515306473, 0.034531500190496445, 0.020371705293655396, -0.02553713321685791, -0.04189120978116989, 0.003988448530435562, -0.006751901935786009, 0.024338025599718094, -0.024162670597434044, 0.010965312831103802, -0.01575113646686077, 0.013598855584859848, -0.057213254272937775, -0.02518007531762123, 0.027819374576210976, 0.009332061745226383, 0.0004208472091704607, -0.050766509026288986, -0.017589595168828964, -0.03016030229628086, -0.03485272824764252, -0.01759743131697178, 0.021105492487549782, -0.023945529013872147, -0.04049570485949516, -0.012335040606558323, 0.03659931942820549, 0.04960965737700462, -0.02100268565118313, -0.027770603075623512, 0.034208547323942184, -0.027179276570677757, 0.01861649937927723, 0.017793593928217888, 0.03187216818332672, -0.03365582227706909, -0.01583799161016941, 0.0029937452636659145, 0.010702700354158878, 0.054771170020103455, -0.007305395323783159, -0.02024087682366371, 0.0025715846568346024, 0.027877816930413246, 0.021890290081501007, -0.028794966638088226, -0.030072908848524094, 0.018665920943021774, 0.017354508861899376, -0.022488698363304138, -0.013061339035630226, -0.007313992362469435, -0.04835997149348259, 0.06194724515080452, 0.01865529827773571, 0.01201644353568554, 0.002562877256423235, 0.07810017466545105, -0.0028793946839869022, -0.01122971810400486, -0.021119374781847, 0.021120870485901833, 0.015563015826046467, 0.006312183104455471, -0.001958907814696431, 0.03931528702378273, -0.012435665354132652, -0.004272260703146458, -0.02283887192606926, -0.048759423196315765, 0.040092773735523224, 0.037889692932367325, -0.008937541395425797, 0.03233175352215767, 0.04900563508272171, -0.0005446570576168597, -0.013384860008955002, 0.0025696565862745047, -0.016218949109315872, 0.008035397157073021, -0.0007023824728094041, 0.053975220769643784, -0.03261541947722435, 0.007911178283393383, 0.01068921945989132, 0.03012740984559059, -0.038759179413318634, 0.0328565277159214, 0.04239177703857422, 0.04155953228473663, -0.01177013199776411, -0.04531361907720566, -0.02590121515095234, 0.03906053304672241, -0.054205551743507385, 0.02270703762769699, -0.025037938728928566, -0.01724972389638424, -0.001928818761371076, 0.019884265959262848, 0.030147166922688484, -0.016658570617437363, -0.024394888430833817, -0.043099336326122284, 0.027327610179781914, 0.05988803878426552, -0.05652228742837906, 0.018252208828926086, 0.03732772171497345, 0.036332834511995316, 0.005796140991151333, 0.025215858593583107, -0.05668460577726364, -0.038628675043582916, 0.01190519891679287, -0.013956326059997082, -0.06001567095518112, 0.005621721502393484, 0.008035420440137386, -0.008640349842607975, 0.05256783217191696, -0.03177035599946976, 0.025892211124300957, 0.004709417931735516, 0.03934717923402786, -0.010449827648699284, 0.043517135083675385, 0.028671860694885254, 0.009421306662261486, 0.042985595762729645, -0.0440945141017437, 0.13992372155189514, 0.05816478282213211, 0.02344338782131672, -0.03148157522082329, -0.004916429985314608, 0.0000733509223209694, 0.014906532131135464, -0.0739111378788948, 0.010320319794118404, -0.03334996849298477, 0.003262865822762251, 0.015968337655067444, 0.053821783512830734, 0.01930338703095913, -0.0035144872963428497, 0.02282068133354187, -0.011928214691579342, -0.04992501065135002, 0.027696950361132622, 0.033275868743658066, -0.021381959319114685, -0.01819080486893654, -0.048574719578027725, 0.04828549921512604, 0.002178758382797241, -0.026370642706751823, -0.046881288290023804, 0.015514292754232883, -0.02601529285311699, -0.023388981819152832, 0.013185715302824974, -0.02754017896950245, 0.02512602135539055, -0.00702959019690752, 0.010572459548711777, 0.03831011801958084, 0.020479172468185425, -0.04118403047323227, 0.044694364070892334, 0.017318973317742348, -0.012980933301150799, 0.015482710674405098, 0.05691369250416756, -0.0165170356631279, -0.03789346665143967, -0.03392526134848595, -0.005754455458372831, 0.05256340280175209, -0.03328589349985123, -0.005959324073046446, -0.007721425034105778, -0.014885129407048225, -0.010510275140404701, -0.02096610516309738, -0.013542271219193935, -0.0013242186978459358, 0.01638091169297695, -0.045809291303157806, 0.02959386259317398, -0.003975633531808853, 0.026572823524475098, 0.03455605357885361, 0.019034842029213905, -0.025358080863952637, 0.009445401839911938, -0.012410363182425499, -0.027380991727113724, 0.04757540300488472, 0.00385778839699924, -0.02775072492659092, 0.002357668709009886, -0.03606338053941727, -0.014106951653957367, -0.043660398572683334, -0.0007088955608196557, -0.030360115692019463, 0.026098569855093956, 0.005267195403575897, -0.01275250781327486, -0.02467499114573002, -0.08500903844833374, -0.014392383396625519, 0.004566203337162733, -0.04101113602519035, -0.013847589492797852, -0.01453180331736803, 0.00992528721690178, 0.04938163980841637, -0.024326574057340622, -0.018306365236639977, 0.012887544929981232, 0.03141338750720024, 0.022915050387382507, -0.013033291324973106, 0.0018986044451594353, -0.027601631358265877, -0.013982759788632393, 0.030199794098734856, -0.031428251415491104, 0.022167377173900604, 0.015377175994217396, -0.008442775346338749, -0.014569045044481754, 0.05283981189131737, -0.05292166396975517, -0.008760732598602772, 0.022668704390525818, -0.043977852910757065, 0.011272406205534935, 0.03167086839675903, 0.022704672068357468, -0.016532599925994873, -0.04009111598134041, -0.009006203152239323, -0.04409811645746231, 0.00769407581537962, -0.008151302114129066, -0.0022743318695575, -0.041579242795705795, -0.03909532353281975, 0.03346755728125572, 0.007905980572104454, 0.009390316903591156, -0.0030430753249675035, 0.04970479756593704, 0.00634073605760932, -0.013219687156379223, -0.03583383560180664, -0.011751208454370499, 0.016124602407217026, 0.0014478304656222463, 0.017329299822449684, 0.011796529404819012, 0.006461224518716335, 0.003373692510649562, -0.023719588294625282, -0.006722625810652971, 0.044988397508859634, 0.017001770436763763, -0.018963662907481194, 0.04467311128973961, -0.023838596418499947, 0.0026941346004605293, 0.0027423095889389515, -0.00010044700320577249, 0.021335572004318237, 0.018399912863969803, -0.025123201310634613, -0.01963585987687111, 0.0016347886994481087, -0.018966833129525185, -0.028791353106498718, 0.0001654080260777846, 0.012038233689963818, -0.011189616285264492, 0.0101842749863863, 0.003371624043211341, 0.004640354309231043, 0.01667230762541294, 0.021199315786361694, 0.0384146012365818, 0.0061102272011339664, 0.0007248464971780777, 0.026731807738542557, 0.004578514490276575, 0.039387885481119156, 0.02457503229379654, -0.004717860370874405, 0.027823327109217644, 0.059930939227342606, -0.02109190635383129, -0.012592129409313202, -0.03503725677728653, 0.03819427266716957, -0.0930928885936737, -0.03173884004354477, 0.005603964906185865, -0.00021672973525710404, 0.037254698574543, -0.05514875426888466, 0.022677959874272346, 0.03374937176704407, -0.05630648136138916, 0.010968461632728577, -0.014714336954057217, -0.024466875940561295, -0.05458461865782738, -0.013659707270562649, -0.00789171364158392, 0.01751726306974888, 0.005128084681928158, 0.0023576009552925825, 0.019373849034309387, 0.025374678894877434, 0.006562072318047285, -0.05157051235437393, 0.003940005786716938, 0.04458479583263397, 0.012870890088379383, -0.055810581892728806, 0.05967353656888008, -0.03530867397785187, -0.030514556914567947, 0.024155454710125923, -0.013438768684864044, -0.019415223971009254, -0.018004683777689934, -0.010115501470863819, -0.01868009939789772, 0.07498148083686829, 0.02498502843081951, -0.0005892069893889129, 0.024081509560346603, -0.02856810949742794, 0.03177369385957718, 0.026053164154291153, -0.03140110895037651, 0.006673064082860947, 0.0501985065639019, 0.0005272636190056801, -0.017827017232775688, 0.03297954425215721, -0.036212701350450516, -0.055344197899103165, -0.02451222762465477, -0.03913397341966629, -0.003960139583796263, -0.05410706624388695, 0.038243018090724945, -0.06260748207569122, -0.01695166528224945, 0.014821939170360565, 0.0583910197019577, -0.013538038358092308, 0.025115443393588066, 0.002896401099860668, -0.0372333787381649, 0.005840052850544453, 0.021306296810507774, -0.017529066652059555, -0.07832840830087662, -0.037544142454862595, -0.002027657115831971, 0.019434262067079544, -0.001762478961609304, -0.041699208319187164, -0.0666988343000412, 0.008243094198405743, -0.022850126028060913, 0.02676677517592907, -0.009833572432398796, -0.007392142899334431, 0.021746499463915825, -0.09411295503377914, 0.010260064154863358, 0.01062718965113163, -0.013980471529066563, -0.004506634548306465, -0.021186068654060364, -0.027966132387518883, 0.004454798065125942, 0.06691338866949081, 0.013798851519823074, -0.007804365362972021, 0.0003546218213159591, 0.04099525138735771, 0.02455505169928074, -0.028414219617843628, 0.012943210080265999, -0.05766279995441437, -0.008583401329815388, -0.04043421521782875, 0.0003161081112921238, 0.03200337290763855, -0.031970374286174774, -0.012293893843889236, -0.006229677237570286, -0.009063340723514557, 0.015540159307420254, -0.008112991228699684, 0.03178200125694275, 0.007269227411597967, -0.005644090007990599, 0.05718562752008438, 0.007131710648536682, -0.018927255645394325, 0.01565232127904892, -0.004207532852888107, 0.01085313968360424, 0.045859772711992264, -0.03979218751192093, -0.030179966241121292, -0.010042435489594936, 0.03466566652059555, 0.023685574531555176, -0.05786678194999695, 0.021305380389094353, 0.026171045377850533, -0.02702915482223034, -0.029977569356560707, 0.050675343722105026, 0.0015261381631717086, 0.021019989624619484, 0.03377137333154678, 0.007619528565555811, 0.028493130579590797, 0.0028770158533006907, 0.04563094675540924, 0.005831169430166483, -0.022832943126559258, -0.013656271621584892, 0.0013655689544975758, -0.007717112544924021, -0.061846114695072174, 0.02133903279900551, -0.041376229375600815, -0.0006219260394573212, -0.014573338441550732, -0.015905337408185005, 0.029144564643502235, -0.005967938806861639, 0.004903305787593126, 0.004533665720373392, -0.011827356182038784, 0.08132916688919067, 0.01887034811079502, -0.010972997173666954, -0.021835261955857277, -0.01363160740584135, -0.008148991502821445, 0.0019194234628230333, 0.018739454448223114, 0.029221627861261368, -0.031082555651664734, -0.00947902724146843, -0.05686869099736214, -0.009360776282846928, -0.0025229849852621555, -0.062414124608039856, 0.015310369431972504, 0.015547947958111763, 0.027659647166728973, 0.0103226937353611, -0.054049309343099594, -0.015745118260383606, -0.0031601989176124334, -0.014555542729794979, 0.03657694533467293, -0.0008225776837207377, -0.011173916049301624, -0.016703426837921143, 0.01751323603093624, 0.027490196749567986, -0.03250855952501297, -0.003212597453966737, -0.04960806667804718, -0.005256138276308775, 0.0011578917037695646, 0.012020109221339226 ]
<p>We get vendor quotes (their prices for different financial securities) every month. I want to compare which of these vendors 'agree' (i.e come close to) with our internal prices [the gold standard].</p> <p>I also want to test these for sub categories - say Vendor A agrees with us on bonds, but vendor B agrees better with equities.</p> <p>What statistical tests can I perform to rank the vendors (in terms of being close to our prices) and quantify the gap.</p> <p>thanks.</p>
31,100
[ -0.002529120072722435, -0.02617361955344677, 0.020241249352693558, -0.018450692296028137, 0.006328382063657045, 0.02366163209080696, 0.017678752541542053, -0.026782335713505745, 0.014179006218910217, 0.0027859278488904238, 0.051513396203517914, 0.01768166571855545, 0.05564229190349579, 0.028204144909977913, -0.038432251662015915, -0.011352479457855225, -0.01959177292883396, -0.030898790806531906, 0.00838606245815754, -0.020236022770404816, 0.01316690444946289, -0.0021285628899931908, -0.004622511565685272, 0.011720506474375725, -0.03029916249215603, 0.012549655511975288, 0.022971278056502342, -0.02854451723396778, -0.010703081265091896, 0.038917213678359985, -0.08970019221305847, -0.014658247120678425, -0.0033160161692649126, 0.021631814539432526, 0.021810272708535194, 0.01900581270456314, 0.014336076565086842, -0.016834469512104988, -0.03380746766924858, 0.030956361442804337, -0.032006457448005676, -0.00283076916821301, 0.0031667824368923903, 0.011792590841650963, 0.011129982769489288, -0.01654929667711258, 0.02170718088746071, -0.033156633377075195, 0.004796064458787441, -0.028928404673933983, 0.0535215400159359, -0.008697164244949818, 0.015308016911149025, 0.0246590506285429, -0.03606785461306572, -0.01983599178493023, 0.04194902256131172, 0.06515463441610336, 0.009824907407164574, -0.04823450744152069, 0.014033539220690727, 0.021032122895121574, 0.03022816777229309, -0.02829931676387787, -0.043862536549568176, 0.04622552916407585, 0.00570623017847538, -0.00838024728000164, 0.04136529564857483, 0.018409155309200287, -0.034102898091077805, 0.005437974818050861, 0.04479396343231201, -0.017352648079395294, 0.042638231068849564, -0.047031790018081665, 0.008201709017157555, 0.04054112732410431, 0.0429658479988575, 0.03044460527598858, -0.04275570064783096, -0.01931869611144066, 0.004741889424622059, 0.022007832303643227, 0.03886745497584343, -0.011692679487168789, 0.06023218110203743, -0.05715296044945717, -0.003095397260040045, 0.019185885787010193, 0.0000880450097611174, -0.005183150991797447, 0.04308287799358368, 0.05429144203662872, -0.024335775524377823, -0.0058088283985853195, -0.012916144914925098, -0.005208283197134733, -0.00895602721720934, -0.03056868351995945, 0.03036728873848915, -0.024320662021636963, 0.026488689705729485, 0.032944630831480026, 0.022897152230143547, -0.004247845150530338, -0.028283294290304184, -0.040455810725688934, -0.01094347145408392, -0.01582571305334568, -0.03896654024720192, 0.04021458700299263, -0.011172881349921227, -0.025196710601449013, 0.0226648710668087, -0.015270790085196495, -0.006942994426935911, -0.016693083569407463, 0.07211734354496002, 0.023658761754631996, 0.03890284150838852, 0.026857417076826096, 0.02875867299735546, -0.018670016899704933, -0.03085058555006981, -0.009053138084709644, 0.013308268040418625, -0.02814660780131817, -0.034032952040433884, 0.056889019906520844, -0.014752325601875782, -0.010615049861371517, 0.03305726870894432, -0.037508610635995865, 0.04555610194802284, 0.013186732307076454, -0.08585268259048462, -0.07145177572965622, 0.06846556067466736, -0.02563781477510929, 0.032958224415779114, -0.06096538528800011, -0.0004648961767088622, 0.012918573804199696, 0.027929671108722687, 0.010118839330971241, 0.043538257479667664, -0.001591652398929, 0.032148148864507675, 0.018551865592598915, -0.011732397601008415, -0.023938341066241264, -0.013127187266945839, 0.011147874407470226, -0.004137654788792133, -0.040508072823286057, -0.03628445789217949, 0.01796893961727619, -0.009251673705875874, 0.010071227326989174, 0.014809499494731426, 0.020164374262094498, -0.04271584749221802, 0.008464166894555092, 0.0036917116958647966, 0.020882269367575645, 0.04745348542928696, 0.01652751863002777, -0.01516140066087246, 0.004993136506527662, 0.006837282329797745, 0.004531360697001219, 0.03475986793637276, 0.0021548715885728598, 0.0682269036769867, -0.02146618813276291, 0.006630961783230305, -0.016232166439294815, 0.002757054753601551, -0.0011568594491109252, -0.05299989506602287, -0.03372054919600487, -0.04278833419084549, -0.008798368275165558, -0.0013319109566509724, 0.012231912463903427, -0.002735086716711521, -0.021941673010587692, 0.021721700206398964, -0.05732183903455734, -0.046750184148550034, -0.0585806779563427, 0.01516370102763176, -0.03409077599644661, -0.04437553137540817, 0.03518195077776909, 0.030089473351836205, -0.0036930697970092297, -0.002522154478356242, -0.008147827349603176, -0.012753092683851719, -0.03077152743935585, 0.05421802029013634, -0.009408092126250267, 0.013262152671813965, 0.04041329026222229, 0.06939750164747238, -0.036416471004486084, 0.02424328774213791, -0.02065136842429638, -0.0783684179186821, 0.02288004383444786, -0.05026722699403763, -0.0179744902998209, 0.03253837674856186, 0.0005731036071665585, 0.031233182176947594, 0.006578963715583086, -0.023091819137334824, 0.016983695328235626, -0.05891921743750572, 0.031828802078962326, 0.0169180016964674, 0.01723260059952736, -0.009564470499753952, 0.00002476034569554031, 0.04558369889855385, 0.07174672931432724, 0.0024787425063550472, 0.018108034506440163, -0.01318097673356533, 0.0042480239644646645, 0.017829950898885727, 0.02839522995054722, -0.054019805043935776, 0.01793554052710533, 0.11166993528604507, 0.001635064953006804, -0.012379909865558147, 0.018068401142954826, 0.027587907388806343, -0.008052247576415539, -0.009618998505175114, 0.016521822661161423, 0.04924879968166351, 0.02775118313729763, 0.03746731951832771, 0.013964197598397732, 0.04478957876563072, 0.026059795171022415, 0.04609895497560501, 0.02712373062968254, 0.006804007571190596, 0.013297747820615768, -0.015811046585440636, -0.059822164475917816, 0.0426972433924675, -0.032591741532087326, -0.005870412569493055, -0.0008524329750798643, 0.010019052773714066, -0.018569432199001312, 0.0004558625805657357, -0.03276635706424713, 0.02385319210588932, 0.04211616888642311, -0.0387684665620327, 0.001404074253514409, 0.028301944956183434, -0.030906129628419876, 0.023252742365002632, -0.03292275592684746, 0.0017610967624932528, -0.04980719834566116, 0.01286428701132536, 0.027615783736109734, -0.015293324366211891, 0.03479072451591492, -0.02165539748966694, -0.05332354083657265, 0.00011710545368259773, -0.015903882682323456, 0.023247579112648964, -0.021982749924063683, -0.028563614934682846, 0.0010465498780831695, 0.031493041664361954, -0.007689052727073431, 0.02116435207426548, -0.004618281498551369, -0.001756854122504592, 0.08986621350049973, 0.014610336162149906, -0.036637090146541595, 0.008270280435681343, 0.023624863475561142, 0.02858823537826538, -0.042900729924440384, -0.039168938994407654, 0.021757477894425392, -0.012735511176288128, -0.014042071998119354, 0.008347103372216225, -0.04605761170387268, 0.012172521091997623, -0.00878339633345604, -0.03735482320189476, -0.04135662689805031, 0.013238721527159214, -0.004053538199514151, 0.043539561331272125, -0.008233653381466866, 0.012150604277849197, -0.051650937646627426, -0.06474705040454865, 0.02159600332379341, 0.009052102454006672, -0.00010245046723866835, -0.025570940226316452, -0.029375221580266953, 0.06730903685092926, 0.02086431160569191, -0.07536395639181137, -0.0569261871278286, -0.014829427935183048, -0.004219409544020891, -0.040096137672662735, 0.04491274431347847, 0.03681784123182297, 0.002152360277250409, 0.009838130325078964, 0.01918831653892994, 0.01688111573457718, 0.02982703223824501, -0.018687164410948753, 0.03136705607175827, -0.002149550011381507, 0.006042290944606066, 0.002244295086711645, 0.04374619573354721, 0.004493713844567537, -0.06110062822699547, -0.009768376126885414, 0.019959429278969765, 0.018863944336771965, 0.019239716231822968, -0.06355670839548111, 0.0007129090372473001, -0.00391648942604661, 0.0033425730653107166, -0.027335984632372856, -0.002230971585959196, 0.028852051123976707, -0.009149153716862202, -0.030877867713570595, -0.015936410054564476, -0.008875750936567783, 0.03464145585894585, 0.00962721649557352, 0.08324776589870453, 0.05311901494860649, -0.02655629813671112, -0.009808485396206379, -0.017858998849987984, -0.03899214044213295, 0.007366788573563099, -0.009365124627947807, -0.04467862471938133, 0.04026878625154495, 0.03326156735420227, 0.04892200231552124, -0.0021163891069591045, -0.0550406388938427, -0.024403810501098633, -0.09456781297922134, -0.021496722474694252, -0.03532153367996216, 0.06592167913913727, -0.0005385858239606023, 0.07191269844770432, 0.016299085691571236, 0.03220866620540619, 0.0069811069406569, 0.019346125423908234, -0.05133942514657974, 0.04316358268260956, -0.015734359622001648, 0.01181696355342865, 0.010379331186413765, -0.013046661391854286, -0.03545266017317772, -0.03283428028225899, 0.012692895717918873, 0.009149942547082901, 0.051866576075553894, 0.019249245524406433, 0.014653832651674747, -0.01528272032737732, -0.00791760440915823, 0.03321535140275955, -0.003669985570013523, 0.016612358391284943, 0.0052476548589766026, 0.060710757970809937, 0.026491137221455574, -0.011187332682311535, -0.007549459580332041, 0.009076251648366451, 0.04717882350087166, 0.011685721576213837, 0.04842206463217735, 0.04831477254629135, 0.019680073484778404, -0.03427517041563988, 0.01599440909922123, -0.008024327456951141, 0.050011035054922104, 0.0256845373660326, -0.0038531399331986904, -0.010870576836168766, -0.02011226676404476, -0.0326666496694088, 0.0009829362388700247, 0.0024685116950422525, -0.0013209957396611571, -0.028139786794781685, 0.0570003017783165, 0.021138105541467667, -0.013791164383292198, -0.0030268323607742786, 0.06391523778438568, 0.027593247592449188, -0.031765636056661606, 0.0078721409663558, -0.06410882622003555, -0.006097322795540094, -0.020086277276277542, 0.02438759058713913, 0.0368042066693306, -0.003591502085328102, 0.006589215714484453, 0.024447564035654068, 0.006606447510421276, -0.02916114777326584, 0.008723956532776356, 0.004873902536928654, 0.03953460231423378, -0.002985655562952161, -0.018833216279745102, 0.03765677660703659, 0.0008102922583930194, 0.054488588124513626, 0.03291421756148338, 0.01823906973004341, -0.0920795351266861, 0.022177230566740036, 0.06136307120323181, 0.02975022792816162, -0.036473844200372696, -0.05187926068902016, -0.006137171760201454, 0.00229014758951962, 0.038865141570568085, 0.005840148311108351, 0.01976322941482067, 0.04147036373615265, 0.010122527368366718, -0.04038291051983833, -0.023272648453712463, -0.011480506509542465, 0.010151714086532593, 0.027666833251714706, -0.01188308373093605, -0.030651327222585678, -0.0269941333681345, -0.019557718187570572, -0.017066659405827522, 0.035329531878232956, 0.04342348501086235, -0.018907025456428528, 0.019541654735803604, 0.002272666897624731, 0.00873761996626854, -0.014135139994323254, -0.07673916220664978, 0.023038195446133614, 0.0029181321151554585, -0.01087725069373846, 0.059218015521764755, -0.008567619137465954, -0.030123373493552208, 0.020634900778532028, 0.0078095439821481705, -0.01565193012356758, 0.03182920813560486, -0.016321305185556412, 0.03165917471051216, 0.05897277221083641, 0.036454517394304276, 0.0487629659473896, 0.004794090520590544, 0.0000475368979095947, 0.009052795358002186, -0.049901291728019714, -0.00226163980551064, -0.015050975605845451, -0.022832810878753662, -0.022894730791449547, -0.040927059948444366, -0.0333557166159153, -0.013818123377859592, -0.010031175799667835, 0.041844844818115234, -0.016939375549554825, 0.012808578088879585, -0.01414449606090784, 0.005818501114845276, -0.013067777268588543, 0.026685681194067, 0.013821320608258247, 0.03652717173099518, -0.014130011200904846, 0.0022682645358145237, 0.01707635261118412, -0.045300375670194626, -0.0017906413413584232, 0.00289201270788908, -0.050366416573524475, -0.0028636592905968428, -0.06130928173661232, -0.0032164487056434155, -0.004262211732566357, -0.013249436393380165, 0.04263363778591156, -0.0014594829408451915, 0.02467348426580429, 0.021801721304655075, -0.0037456504069268703, -0.03813154995441437, 0.02310677245259285, 0.000040048736991593614, 0.04898701608181, -0.010055859573185444, 0.03561629727482796, 0.0027630231343209743, -0.03233499079942703, -0.08703663945198059, -0.03408833220601082, 0.03930390253663063, 0.05155476555228233, -0.04860304668545723, -0.015655675902962685, 0.02220393717288971, -0.016086792573332787, 0.0011350583517923951, -0.008810870349407196, 0.005578422918915749, 0.0215791966766119, -0.03284737467765808, -0.0015765218995511532, -0.004119507037103176, 0.07698976993560791, -0.02317543886601925, -0.005286400206387043, -0.013706180267035961, 0.011791592463850975, -0.0051613617688417435, -0.016793055459856987, 0.014116656966507435, -0.03517313674092293, -0.007092767860740423, -0.023836039006710052, 0.018286021426320076, 0.03296435624361038, -0.044878408312797546, 0.011034454219043255, -0.000690570508595556, -0.014810397289693356, -0.012887991964817047, -0.018784064799547195, 0.029390715062618256, -0.04218832775950432, -0.007618250325322151, -0.047754254192113876, 0.0035351510159671307, -0.018941909074783325, -0.020756520330905914, -0.010985888540744781, -0.021427858620882034, -0.0229522492736578, -0.0057985843159258366, 0.1173497885465622, 0.008724872022867203, -0.00463417824357748, 0.016762591898441315, -0.03756382688879967, 0.02468273416161537, -0.05201663821935654, -0.01609237864613533, -0.01609785482287407, 0.04185372591018677, -0.033994462341070175, -0.04066291078925133, 0.009093906730413437, -0.02055191434919834, 0.053757451474666595, 0.007183086592704058, 0.05930384248495102, 0.05794702470302582, 0.011026519350707531, 0.005626792088150978, -0.03185134008526802, -0.009364607743918896, -0.011913113296031952, 0.005614707712084055, 0.039821773767471313, -0.005928067956119776, 0.03467355668544769, 0.037201814353466034, 0.014792202040553093, 0.009281102567911148, 0.04427439346909523, 0.03512635827064514, 0.02258690446615219, 0.028094613924622536, -0.008235076442360878, -0.04668194055557251, 0.06027502939105034, -0.06143680214881897, 0.03661113232374191, -0.03900470584630966, -0.0201360285282135, 0.023373618721961975, 0.045638665556907654, -0.0324791856110096, 0.003972254227846861, -0.02724272944033146, -0.051112592220306396, 0.024104848504066467, 0.0036914139054715633, -0.013248240575194359, 0.019618861377239227, 0.035655297338962555, 0.04625748470425606, -0.004051471594721079, 0.05361677706241608, -0.023136479780077934, -0.06994706392288208, -0.006000136025249958, -0.001722380518913269, -0.04471899941563606, 0.015088112093508244, 0.0010909525444731116, -0.014023913070559502, 0.014894095249474049, -0.01021263562142849, -0.016871925443410873, -0.010682780295610428, -0.007563502062112093, -0.013331200927495956, 0.05351714417338371, 0.045555371791124344, 0.00962362065911293, 0.008339408785104752, -0.0006744697457179427, 0.0978483185172081, 0.04908548295497894, 0.032916437834501266, -0.06895460933446884, 0.007066562306135893, 0.032750051468610764, 0.013347593136131763, -0.02645421028137207, 0.03776521980762482, -0.0021250294521450996, 0.017285050824284554, 0.04340966418385506, 0.047680847346782684, -0.003490095492452383, -0.00807893741875887, 0.07934538275003433, -0.026961451396346092, 0.017026836052536964, 0.025927860289812088, 0.013287468813359737, 0.001959117827937007, 0.0036249884869903326, -0.059540703892707825, 0.04395419731736183, -0.005019977688789368, -0.035272613167762756, -0.006014302372932434, -0.0459197461605072, 0.029792098328471184, 0.0013327118940651417, 0.01626688428223133, -0.004178542643785477, 0.034054163843393326, 0.031547125428915024, -0.0215521901845932, -0.03165102005004883, 0.04438978061079979, -0.03262052312493324, -0.005160174332559109, 0.007109339348971844, 0.0017357520991936326, -0.039348773658275604, 0.009651804342865944, 0.03583623841404915, -0.021215476095676422, -0.008318121545016766, -0.05884315446019173, -0.03311425819993019, -0.011185514740645885, -0.017247634008526802, -0.03167980909347534, -0.03939389809966087, -0.02296929992735386, -0.0383249893784523, -0.020486466586589813, 0.014356807805597782, 0.023642776533961296, -0.02072330005466938, -0.03565837815403938, -0.06826063245534897, 0.02441619522869587, -0.051984332501888275, 0.012838820926845074, -0.020669037476181984, -0.029969150200486183, 0.0002926086017396301, -0.04703166335821152, 0.03262016177177429, -0.00705178827047348, -0.007280264515429735, 0.01006675511598587, 0.013344410806894302, -0.016892869025468826, -0.025820890441536903, -0.0288381464779377, 0.009153188206255436, 0.04945067688822746, 0.021478738635778427, 0.02100341022014618, 0.009824414737522602, -0.027730504050850868, 0.026668963953852654, -0.01275707595050335, -0.010125439614057541, -0.06220105290412903, -0.027701251208782196, 0.06124275550246239, 0.025044741109013557, 0.04226035624742508, 0.016375787556171417, -0.015844983980059624, 0.07358445972204208, 0.03195778653025627, -0.048375558108091354, -0.027012115344405174, -0.009960141032934189, -0.05333976820111275, -0.01245941687375307, -0.007010238245129585, 0.06662139296531677, 0.012887964956462383, 0.0012272695312276483, 0.02174069546163082, -0.005768106784671545, -0.03146738559007645, 0.00005191332820686512, 0.028715673834085464, -0.029524460434913635, 0.0013811271637678146, 0.03546855226159096, -0.020952897146344185, -0.027438072487711906, -0.007817829959094524, -0.013499082066118717, -0.01863892562687397, 0.030685152858495712, 0.023655900731682777, -0.04586314037442207, 0.01645497791469097, 0.038379084318876266, -0.021184397861361504, -0.03186841681599617, 0.011073238216340542, -0.03283685818314552, -0.03104412741959095, 0.009057444520294666, 0.01510145328938961, -0.02263047732412815, 0.01607310213148594, -0.05748451501131058, -0.016248421743512154, 0.09484151750802994, 0.021571936085820198, 0.03468730300664902, 0.003279208904132247, -0.014987073838710785, 0.012195490300655365, 0.0468769371509552, -0.0016359890578314662, -0.008995605632662773, 0.008739602752029896, -0.04423189163208008, -0.008255578577518463, -0.0009353015339002013, 0.021130084991455078, -0.0047537595964968204, -0.01589774712920189, -0.03463238477706909, -0.02785942330956459, 0.04687226936221123, -0.03505167365074158, -0.017875665798783302, -0.03485859930515289, 0.01681634783744812, 0.030719680711627007, -0.01608317345380783, -0.013180800713598728, 0.0025423732586205006, -0.04652601480484009, 0.013575033284723759, 0.03150096908211708, 0.012305679731070995, -0.008237842470407486, -0.0053305309265851974, 0.01418393012136221, -0.04720569774508476, 0.02348025143146515, 0.00026496348436921835, 0.021594299003481865, 0.03238590061664581, -0.015376676805317402, 0.023941613733768463, 0.0023104615975171328, -0.007516707759350538, -0.05961277335882187, -0.02050686813890934, -0.002011926844716072, 0.011395569890737534, 0.017856156453490257, -0.04662349820137024, 0.01777005009353161, 0.0021864217706024647, -0.05657695606350899, 0.013554995879530907, 0.022994982078671455, -0.03412335738539696, -0.030083155259490013, -0.005510387010872364, -0.015141261741518974, 0.03820803388953209, 0.004289453849196434, 0.005214917939156294, 0.011787754483520985, 0.01763063110411167, 0.01116348709911108, -0.01898723840713501, -0.006756920833140612, 0.005193300079554319, 0.02117948792874813, -0.06385684013366699, 0.026466256007552147, -0.0321228988468647, -0.06890343874692917, 0.023512300103902817, -0.03704465925693512, 0.02839866653084755, 0.011062858626246452, 0.024111445993185043, -0.002553685335442424, 0.04430924355983734, 0.026881685480475426, 0.03955767676234245, -0.007868656888604164, -0.05080759897828102, -0.00904400646686554, 0.018536455929279327, 0.015315144322812557, 0.017214138060808182, 0.10210437327623367, -0.015534295700490475, -0.008775033988058567, 0.0019607171416282654, -0.02349012903869152, 0.006748795974999666, 0.0227153692394495, 0.018519623205065727, 0.058762021362781525, 0.01715836487710476, -0.018109263852238655, -0.032840803265571594, -0.00393702695146203, 0.028195207938551903, 0.03231038525700569, -0.038710273802280426, -0.012186911888420582, -0.010072115808725357, -0.02141663059592247, 0.02200976572930813, 0.030486583709716797, -0.009959316812455654, -0.040695272386074066, 0.006438949145376682, -0.010886136442422867, 0.01125857513397932, -0.03377027437090874, -0.021461166441440582, -0.0003198862250428647, 0.019504364579916, -0.02564033679664135, 0.01404293067753315, 0.01818636804819107, 0.006723033729940653, 0.024726342409849167, -0.07574291527271271, 0.023242833092808723, -0.00476811034604907, -0.0092392573133111, -0.00791084673255682, -0.008951692841947079, -0.02589135430753231, 0.007018676493316889, 0.02701372653245926, -0.014804519712924957, 0.032227952033281326, 0.002592174569144845, -0.01841537095606327, 0.026082858443260193, -0.09037669748067856, 0.04478316754102707, 0.0027548472862690687, -0.04504247009754181, -0.009553649462759495, 0.013091128319501877, 0.012189784087240696, -0.003457077080383897, 0.01965247094631195, -0.0380452424287796, 0.02051343023777008, -0.001739939209073782, -0.0036834822967648506, 0.0036145031917840242, -0.03544212877750397, -0.0022089441772550344, 0.07300220429897308, 0.0014306806260719895, -0.001521966070868075, 0.026825478300452232, -0.01449049822986126, -0.06402526050806046, 0.0633748471736908, -0.022498898208141327, -0.0412028506398201, 0.02757628634572029, 0.011793015524744987, 0.009881073608994484, -0.07996021211147308, -0.008023400790989399, 0.021820593625307083, -0.04998842999339104, 0.02580004185438156, 0.060978226363658905, 0.03344733268022537, -0.005350849591195583, -0.0167508814483881, 0.02240194007754326, 0.017117615789175034, -0.019247043877840042, -0.029729267582297325, 0.0036768903955817223, 0.05344278737902641, -0.013905733823776245, 0.0004165188584011048, 0.04473324120044708, -0.02974148467183113, 0.01038407627493143, -0.021173961460590363, -0.017875296995043755, -0.0419340617954731, -0.03804916515946388, 0.03279445320367813, 0.007311743684113026, 0.052116457372903824, 0.023126089945435524, -0.009032032452523708, 0.05639096722006798, -0.06036281958222389, 0.004326279275119305, -0.036535199731588364, 0.0415026918053627, 0.00003550069595803507, -0.010855366475880146, -0.004858489613980055, -0.0038800339680165052, -0.02144109457731247, 0.009763863869011402, -0.007373299449682236, 0.018420513719320297, 0.006467343773692846, -0.026387015357613564, 0.010939739644527435, -0.01985674351453781, -0.011692380532622337, -0.015315239317715168, 0.008705017156898975, -0.03856945410370827, 0.029601991176605225, -0.0026426503900438547, 0.0023076185025274754, -0.01410779356956482, -0.0008259032620117068, -0.032332926988601685, -0.012695502489805222, 0.05318237841129303, -0.06286821514368057, -0.027284938842058182, -0.07005897909402847, -0.011983420699834824, 0.014015194028615952, -0.01847521960735321 ]
<p>Does the Gibbs sampler converge to a global maximum in the presence of multiple modes? For example in case of a Gaussian mixture distribution?</p>
73,500
[ -0.025570545345544815, -0.008280441164970398, 0.019309135153889656, -0.0062637729570269585, 0.05846564844250679, 0.011462741531431675, -0.0177187230437994, -0.05128644034266472, 0.010509510524570942, -0.032068882137537, 0.02356702834367752, 0.018146108835935593, 0.03261794522404671, 0.022283261641860008, 0.02054758369922638, 0.0016440685139968991, 0.0008332409779541194, 0.017266733571887016, -0.011975575238466263, -0.013007568195462227, -0.041795630007982254, 0.05102032423019409, 0.0449615903198719, -0.05689360946416855, -0.013299568556249142, -0.01438729465007782, 0.021243447437882423, -0.027324695140123367, -0.0002378777862759307, 0.0467870756983757, -0.018081622198224068, -0.006636275444179773, -0.0011699643218889832, 0.0562150813639164, 0.022104570642113686, -0.03320265933871269, -0.017217161133885384, -0.004160071257501841, -0.021061493083834648, 0.001989519689232111, -0.096722312271595, -0.056322790682315826, -0.0028137839399278164, 0.01955076865851879, 0.020787741988897324, 0.002462123055011034, -0.03122321330010891, -0.03983014076948166, 0.0435158871114254, -0.033603258430957794, 0.07296539843082428, 0.027988845482468605, 0.007688631769269705, 0.03678644075989723, -0.00014787650434300303, 0.00028386511257849634, 0.06587747484445572, 0.09356451779603958, 0.035551104694604874, -0.027921099215745926, 0.02309270016849041, -0.007758255582302809, 0.02190312370657921, -0.014038554392755032, -0.04398117586970329, 0.03644958510994911, 0.015138252638280392, -0.027569031342864037, 0.011143381707370281, 0.027798863127827644, -0.03381475806236267, 0.013945396058261395, 0.04813728109002113, -0.0207712110131979, 0.013744316063821316, -0.00032432613079436123, 0.03513631224632263, 0.05066537857055664, 0.006423678714782, 0.02055479772388935, 0.03296124190092087, -0.010651357471942902, -0.008585815317928791, -0.000790770398452878, 0.0032118121162056923, 0.026007268577814102, 0.10416220128536224, -0.03239484131336212, 0.003531194757670164, 0.04717110097408295, -0.02824566699564457, 0.0005655737477354705, 0.023343617096543312, -0.022825058549642563, -0.05403420701622963, 0.04418891668319702, -0.0036416281946003437, 0.01263732835650444, 0.01878572441637516, -0.014342790469527245, 0.008132821880280972, -0.03416488319635391, 0.014933054335415363, 0.03413531929254532, 0.008547807112336159, 0.009739894419908524, -0.04652102664113045, -0.005891164764761925, -0.02139143832027912, -0.0007376372232101858, -0.05097859725356102, 0.005203725304454565, 0.01535907480865717, -0.02069484069943428, 0.009609364904463291, 0.010768442414700985, 0.018232436850667, -0.08312246203422546, 0.018941184505820274, 0.08467727154493332, 0.05099191144108772, -0.0418093241751194, -0.007628764491528273, -0.03364953771233559, -0.06320640444755554, 0.022144420072436333, -0.02514399029314518, -0.017730437219142914, -0.04479469358921051, 0.003959729801863432, 0.008564561605453491, -0.013735405169427395, 0.04514338821172714, 0.0033743255771696568, 0.0020391340367496014, -0.019461344927549362, -0.07843131572008133, -0.040556758642196655, 0.0401187539100647, -0.05815909057855606, 0.039984267204999924, -0.05607353150844574, -0.009484014473855495, 0.03673664480447769, 0.0050491648726165295, -0.02524595521390438, 0.05733635649085045, 0.017967354506254196, 0.06288544833660126, -0.010030698962509632, -0.01470582652837038, 0.016347747296094894, -0.03458232432603836, -0.0016974670579656959, 0.0006198773626238108, -0.08863645792007446, 0.01123428251594305, 0.025076620280742645, -0.0005349385901354253, -0.010566570796072483, -0.014519451186060905, 0.01149943470954895, -0.014595028012990952, -0.0036645953077822924, 0.06325293332338333, -0.03781352564692497, 0.05753757059574127, -0.0055295489728450775, 0.08455400913953781, -0.0015546559588983655, 0.01630694419145584, 0.0038730213418602943, 0.00774505827575922, 0.018536526709794998, 0.026771970093250275, -0.047126639634370804, 0.003843234619125724, -0.015047128312289715, 0.04056662321090698, 0.035234078764915466, -0.026919541880488396, -0.005926718469709158, 0.013637620955705643, 0.01835072785615921, 0.006813657935708761, 0.02134380303323269, -0.003302900353446603, -0.005787855479866266, 0.020835181698203087, -0.0792207345366478, -0.025786394253373146, -0.04866519942879677, 0.035422470420598984, -0.005920405499637127, -0.007460468448698521, 0.03556927293539047, 0.011527236551046371, 0.03013896942138672, -0.036977071315050125, -0.021506130695343018, -0.041119374334812164, 0.010502705350518227, 0.004052612464874983, -0.027834603562951088, 0.0019838432781398296, 0.03612171486020088, 0.03859209269285202, 0.013555899262428284, 0.056847985833883286, -0.009734825231134892, -0.03471378982067108, 0.0091341407969594, -0.03214346244931221, 0.039495233446359634, -0.011153710074722767, -0.03442861884832382, 0.010972758755087852, 0.009321579709649086, -0.022605616599321365, 0.03131029009819031, -0.050481293350458145, 0.024018356576561928, 0.09481047093868256, -0.00898386724293232, -0.012064456939697266, 0.006917086895555258, 0.01222181972116232, 0.0037630770821124315, -0.014942917041480541, 0.005830524954944849, -0.05708052217960358, -0.00795101746916771, 0.042393893003463745, 0.07068699598312378, -0.029183723032474518, 0.055788908153772354, 0.035647936165332794, 0.0027216945309191942, 0.024251144379377365, 0.003827424254268408, -0.016130944713950157, -0.0035701266024261713, 0.029839809983968735, 0.03464362025260925, 0.013665866106748581, -0.002984840888530016, 0.04302901029586792, -0.03342798724770546, 0.012891248799860477, -0.03406786918640137, -0.008552473038434982, 0.00013312557712197304, 0.003916646353900433, 0.001306902733631432, -0.005892281420528889, -0.023277638480067253, 0.000836342282127589, -0.024860987439751625, 0.022690322250127792, 0.014049437828361988, 0.007846551947295666, -0.025585414841771126, -0.014886423945426941, -0.021512797102332115, 0.0516013540327549, 0.01768931746482849, -0.014364981092512608, -0.012750169262290001, 0.04353303462266922, -0.04361330345273018, 0.01232573576271534, -0.05537601560354233, -0.0036503521259874105, -0.032191045582294464, 0.01951300911605358, 0.017722373828291893, -0.014994514174759388, 0.023416748270392418, -0.04081828519701958, -0.023363960906863213, 0.004539031069725752, -0.019839981570839882, 0.006001927889883518, -0.008459692820906639, -0.03211551159620285, 0.017339859157800674, 0.005630478262901306, -0.0019828835502266884, 0.016033872961997986, -0.009548258036375046, -0.0028491548728197813, 0.010195629671216011, -0.008329140022397041, -0.027911333367228508, 0.016285989433526993, 0.009500836953520775, -0.013432175852358341, -0.05576691776514053, 0.04054410755634308, 0.015843737870454788, 0.01359887607395649, -0.02330298349261284, 0.007246710360050201, -0.053595446050167084, -0.04765274375677109, -0.020561859011650085, 0.008549021556973457, 0.047474246472120285, 0.01754113845527172, 0.034833505749702454, 0.03906839340925217, -0.053114861249923706, 0.013111668638885021, -0.04888671636581421, -0.04919453337788582, 0.04987093061208725, -0.022220060229301453, 0.04638318717479706, -0.010763083584606647, 0.03394566476345062, 0.06251773238182068, 0.04381466656923294, -0.047800276428461075, 0.008000215515494347, -0.009789649397134781, -0.02553003653883934, -0.0009977591689676046, 0.005877535790205002, 0.004375999793410301, -0.005039983429014683, 0.05235116556286812, 0.018019801005721092, 0.013110953383147717, 0.07509522140026093, 0.040690623223781586, 0.014183118008077145, 0.018820207566022873, 0.03825138509273529, -0.0008921966655179858, 0.027242690324783325, 0.03159383684396744, 0.0024690248537808657, 0.015886202454566956, 0.0018107282230630517, 0.038096968084573746, 0.001270671491511166, -0.02092600427567959, 0.02952253259718418, -0.026426952332258224, 0.02027420699596405, -0.051037583500146866, 0.025940624997019768, 0.06215328723192215, -0.028476659208536148, -0.004077021963894367, 0.016088008880615234, 0.04474901407957077, -0.013010956346988678, -0.017459049820899963, 0.05116122215986252, -0.0070707849226891994, -0.0409143790602684, -0.025748781859874725, 0.0038239508867263794, 0.005194769240915775, 0.006333919707685709, 0.010255702771246433, -0.0578327514231205, 0.0073869661428034306, 0.007311391178518534, 0.033887967467308044, 0.020267726853489876, -0.012855644337832928, -0.004631394054740667, -0.07347258180379868, 0.02027764730155468, -0.023106539621949196, 0.0032144177239388227, -0.00008781547512626275, 0.045702699571847916, 0.01877969689667225, 0.017937099561095238, -0.01898142322897911, 0.010265831835567951, -0.08884057402610779, -0.003173423232510686, -0.035644520074129105, -0.000057614135585026816, 0.019497236236929893, -0.06018013134598732, 0.05060228332877159, -0.024683363735675812, 0.02385297603905201, -0.005827152635902166, 0.03868493065237999, -0.05821220576763153, 0.017304135486483574, -0.039161574095487595, -0.04111231118440628, -0.01919853873550892, 0.000635347212664783, 0.0374537818133831, -0.0005147599731571972, -0.008173889480531216, 0.04927423596382141, -0.014734935946762562, 0.022729719057679176, 0.006555571220815182, 0.024264438077807426, -0.0039070285856723785, 0.038413967937231064, 0.024973580613732338, 0.04180536046624184, -0.033457767218351364, 0.03642089292407036, 0.03028908371925354, 0.05263550579547882, 0.0038302382454276085, -0.04141654074192047, -0.022969968616962433, 0.014857674017548561, -0.009192957542836666, 0.031161068007349968, -0.009139534085988998, 0.012077788822352886, -0.014087572693824768, 0.02373966947197914, 0.017673132941126823, -0.03937389701604843, 0.04264513775706291, 0.03772417828440666, 0.008339784108102322, -0.022547798231244087, -0.02298314869403839, 0.005376848857849836, -0.010046806186437607, 0.011130370199680328, 0.021735796704888344, 0.010588421486318111, -0.04271730035543442, 0.019863123074173927, -0.012465626932680607, 0.013771780766546726, -0.039813075214624405, 0.009013575501739979, 0.035285044461488724, 0.04935991019010544, 0.015990184620022774, -0.010005665943026543, -0.0014130634954199195, 0.004873234312981367, 0.024060504510998726, 0.0130125992000103, -0.02985590323805809, -0.08080040663480759, 0.0049801054410636425, 0.05400082841515541, 0.0016945364186540246, -0.009494694881141186, 0.0545506477355957, -0.03202958032488823, -0.011986267752945423, 0.022075073793530464, -0.021610530093312263, 0.011417006142437458, -0.018087420612573624, -0.004612441174685955, -0.031384892761707306, -0.02984776347875595, -0.0211415346711874, -0.015877902507781982, -0.0004922940279357135, -0.0255945585668087, 0.02964876964688301, -0.029565569013357162, -0.031832803040742874, 0.0275073554366827, 0.004508944693952799, 0.058528196066617966, -0.010281966999173164, -0.006560417357832193, -0.042056940495967865, 0.004640125669538975, 0.009818908758461475, -0.06304080784320831, 0.05415232852101326, -0.0139355743303895, -0.03464033827185631, 0.030750950798392296, -0.026373855769634247, -0.08273714780807495, 0.06185278296470642, 0.011045241728425026, -0.006944716442376375, -0.0063600908033549786, -0.009575785137712955, 0.030579928308725357, 0.023959679529070854, -0.002252561505883932, 0.02448311448097229, 0.02227882482111454, -0.018898187205195427, -0.026861920952796936, -0.038317348808050156, 0.059594206511974335, -0.048545487225055695, -0.02563118375837803, -0.00021050323266535997, -0.001022677286528051, -0.0010840169852599502, 0.024321582168340683, 0.010792841203510761, 0.031305503100156784, -0.03982290253043175, -0.01767747476696968, -0.007958654314279556, 0.01943434588611126, 0.022113872691988945, 0.003148408606648445, -0.02055099606513977, 0.027198761701583862, 0.003931759856641293, -0.008225771598517895, 0.03905103728175163, -0.024249499663710594, 0.02478683367371559, 0.01804174669086933, -0.009338155388832092, 0.024297213181853294, -0.050447847694158554, 0.004670785740017891, -0.007738265208899975, -0.03121243044734001, 0.06707756966352463, -0.020794007927179337, 0.032075781375169754, 0.015538236126303673, -0.04168250039219856, 0.0009772081393748522, 0.03696516156196594, 0.01920742727816105, 0.017695046961307526, -0.028903493657708168, 0.026731055229902267, -0.02027955837547779, 0.007329028565436602, -0.09890259802341461, -0.010270753875374794, 0.029152169823646545, 0.018269218504428864, 0.01750732958316803, -0.02268003672361374, -0.03464323282241821, 0.0049683102406561375, -0.04055320471525192, -0.027012795209884644, 0.01851128414273262, 0.008632815442979336, -0.015193101949989796, 0.009643178433179855, 0.043890293687582016, 0.043640896677970886, 0.025087174028158188, 0.0011990071507170796, 0.05830485373735428, -0.014068667776882648, 0.02666468545794487, -0.014262417331337929, 0.022897502407431602, -0.025239814072847366, 0.03097834810614586, 0.0005630883388221264, -0.00292428326793015, 0.029479611665010452, -0.01746358722448349, -0.01821836270391941, 0.03226646035909653, -0.003220612183213234, -0.016303781419992447, -0.009289437904953957, -0.06202082708477974, -0.02548346482217312, -0.010751571506261826, 0.01275706198066473, -0.01136299129575491, 0.020196564495563507, -0.03856423497200012, 0.036217350512742996, -0.026481464505195618, -0.020966194570064545, 0.04313267022371292, 0.03546502813696861, -0.029721466824412346, -0.021076753735542297, 0.015256308019161224, -0.030325736850500107, 0.01674874685704708, -0.004195029381662607, 0.01778573915362358, 0.020481323823332787, -0.012362158857285976, -0.00744523573666811, -0.023717889562249184, -0.01596110500395298, 0.00969784241169691, 0.03941992297768593, 0.028335729613900185, 0.009574164636433125, 0.009825663641095161, -0.010552145540714264, -0.011009594425559044, -0.0557856485247612, 0.022662265226244926, 0.009920126758515835, -0.030020100995898247, 0.053691569715738297, -0.030812636017799377, -0.026903651654720306, 0.028735904023051262, 0.027150381356477737, 0.015444068238139153, 0.027597837150096893, 0.004260404966771603, 0.033847320824861526, 0.008994469419121742, -0.01931437849998474, -0.04835295304656029, 0.015583628788590431, -0.0617775097489357, 0.03498154506087303, -0.04963657632470131, -0.034212928265333176, 0.009372328408062458, 0.04214604198932648, 0.013309800997376442, -0.031623899936676025, 0.006370096933096647, -0.03583580628037453, 0.04867956414818764, 0.003698870074003935, 0.04126670956611633, 0.042272187769412994, 0.016636643558740616, 0.03534931689500809, 0.03994234651327133, 0.03616582229733467, -0.015186398290097713, -0.07209693640470505, -0.04290531948208809, 0.019454041495919228, -0.044164855033159256, 0.012559298425912857, 0.04305840656161308, 0.0011667293729260564, 0.01720590516924858, -0.011743535287678242, 0.04351123794913292, -0.011342242360115051, 0.04833605885505676, -0.011401752009987831, 0.04883391782641411, 0.043695349246263504, 0.041616424918174744, 0.012828994542360306, -0.0003463925968389958, 0.1098121851682663, 0.06009164825081825, 0.048781659454107285, -0.06598807871341705, 0.018227623775601387, -0.0295548215508461, -0.01901082508265972, -0.04307647421956062, -0.003060808638110757, 0.020728744566440582, -0.015053436160087585, 0.01717253029346466, 0.034152302891016006, -0.031166130676865578, 0.019991960376501083, 0.04342213645577431, -0.05670640990138054, -0.04454338923096657, 0.012273899279534817, 0.02782561630010605, -0.029593227431178093, 0.000676866911817342, -0.00419594906270504, -0.00012123776832595468, -0.021779069676995277, -0.030059322714805603, -0.020947793498635292, -0.029151052236557007, -0.018050482496619225, -0.005242784041911364, 0.013409349136054516, -0.01644781604409218, -0.006758329924196005, -0.019522305577993393, 0.0031253008637577295, -0.023480333387851715, 0.021478625014424324, -0.0010561076924204826, 0.00902770459651947, 0.03157849237322807, -0.005106528289616108, 0.02071957476437092, 0.04395060986280441, -0.002944725099951029, -0.03955322504043579, -0.00941051822155714, -0.016438202932476997, 0.02054007723927498, 0.0009487236384302378, 0.026773378252983093, -0.0112107889726758, -0.011215190403163433, 0.010499650612473488, -0.0338234007358551, -0.020285841077566147, 0.01056349091231823, 0.056123893707990646, -0.034437283873558044, -0.06333867460489273, -0.021618127822875977, 0.024465365335345268, -0.023823155090212822, -0.004031825345009565, 0.0015447475016117096, -0.029850482940673828, -0.0068507068790495396, -0.03383610397577286, 0.062109772115945816, 0.008217450231313705, -0.020889125764369965, 0.00539673026651144, -0.03461015224456787, -0.04133959859609604, -0.030805129557847977, -0.00004055201861774549, 0.026604898273944855, 0.01865023747086525, -0.006119416560977697, -0.017421027645468712, -0.05237346515059471, -0.08536452800035477, 0.0022188429720699787, -0.0027447002939879894, -0.010023406706750393, -0.008128941059112549, -0.0007476446335203946, 0.03138357773423195, 0.05386863276362419, -0.042132552713155746, 0.02029358595609665, -0.020903417840600014, 0.06753627955913544, 0.014556998386979103, -0.014706178568303585, -0.023302946239709854, -0.008907114155590534, -0.04757239669561386, -0.007178863510489464, -0.016194365918636322, 0.06520189344882965, -0.002410915680229664, 0.01706572435796261, 0.029688607901334763, 0.022876545786857605, -0.022949477657675743, 0.014999115839600563, 0.004849517252296209, -0.029236089438199997, -0.015103212557733059, 0.05600103363394737, 0.000044509160943562165, 0.000043024629121646285, -0.028365377336740494, -0.027741864323616028, 0.00012373246136121452, 0.03717634826898575, -0.002261688932776451, -0.002693865681067109, -0.016336102038621902, 0.0047585549764335155, 0.03255142644047737, -0.03713654726743698, -0.0052485899068415165, -0.008860603906214237, -0.0047485437244176865, -0.010687705129384995, 0.01618354208767414, 0.014893871732056141, 0.0016975816106423736, 0.0021485048346221447, -0.031133132055401802, 0.03503649681806564, 0.024244822561740875, 0.017615770921111107, -0.01991768553853035, 0.0342874638736248, 0.014112037606537342, 0.03206481784582138, -0.014151141047477722, -0.0038036187179386616, 0.015188351273536682, -0.055224958807229996, -0.04443518444895744, 0.013485548086464405, -0.002410859102383256, 0.046696774661540985, 0.006629974581301212, 0.018069276586174965, -0.0019274584483355284, 0.032991841435432434, -0.032245226204395294, -0.010230361483991146, 0.001645705895498395, 0.020233606919646263, 0.0067908079363405704, -0.0057239471934735775, -0.00369500950910151, 0.03659575432538986, -0.030340978875756264, 0.04824088513851166, 0.05661347508430481, -0.009040257893502712, -0.004057206679135561, 0.012085434049367905, -0.04493526369333267, 0.02914908342063427, 0.028507232666015625, 0.009732051752507687, 0.022846370935440063, 0.07220948487520218, -0.001440050546079874, 0.047902680933475494, -0.004116382449865341, 0.017424095422029495, -0.07555126398801804, -0.05503421276807785, 0.013209562748670578, -0.0017441128147765994, 0.057657498866319656, -0.016369985416531563, 0.035043783485889435, 0.02889578975737095, -0.03362009674310684, 0.018958192318677902, 0.0028125776443630457, 0.002883374458178878, -0.08347216993570328, -0.00408701878041029, -0.03225181996822357, 0.025467662140727043, 0.019775625318288803, 0.03956066071987152, 0.02458605170249939, 0.043989550322294235, -0.034193456172943115, -0.031555283814668655, -0.0134523194283247, -0.0034335346426814795, 0.004920582752674818, -0.03844667971134186, 0.03448427841067314, -0.058436691761016846, -0.04303766041994095, 0.013229993171989918, 0.004256346728652716, 0.009112432599067688, 0.013895580545067787, 0.032722268253564835, -0.006287341471761465, 0.014287522062659264, 0.05462034419178963, -0.02630876936018467, 0.019474836066365242, 0.03813045844435692, -0.03230211138725281, 0.01461681816726923, -0.0496244952082634, -0.012165629304945469, 0.0075981756672263145, -0.025643017143011093, -0.018494952470064163, 0.013576784171164036, -0.006340032909065485, -0.06043456122279167, -0.0028543095104396343, 0.02898195944726467, -0.010343546979129314, -0.043074894696474075, 0.024657955393195152, -0.04401020705699921, -0.01043044961988926, 0.03984836861491203, 0.05821452662348747, -0.022202767431735992, -0.00991633627563715, 0.006677583791315556, -0.011007774621248245, 0.010424871928989887, -0.0010024573421105742, -0.03187550604343414, -0.04641688987612724, 0.007814622484147549, -0.011118598282337189, -0.004654982127249241, 0.0012294916668906808, -0.010204948484897614, -0.053605034947395325, 0.023033272475004196, -0.0038109358865767717, 0.048745326697826385, 0.036020677536726, -0.053244128823280334, -0.030037177726626396, -0.10511239618062973, 0.05333016812801361, -0.018074361607432365, -0.020576920360326767, -0.06315360963344574, -0.01954643614590168, -0.004836062900722027, -0.03012087382376194, 0.04656558856368065, -0.012776589952409267, 0.01904626190662384, 0.025644082576036453, 0.07232239097356796, 0.02006075717508793, -0.00042547809425741434, 0.038557931780815125, -0.07553749531507492, -0.04104295000433922, -0.020895253866910934, -0.019830619916319847, 0.030932370573282242, -0.019649671390652657, -0.03147593513131142, -0.039316773414611816, 0.02109850011765957, 0.030192552134394646, 0.0020775431767106056, 0.04578299820423126, 0.008910728618502617, 0.016522010788321495, 0.0522758811712265, -0.06648251414299011, 0.00008932447235565633, 0.003919874783605337, -0.051740314811468124, -0.08411367982625961, 0.006234763190150261, -0.014454547315835953, -0.012342480011284351, -0.03610699623823166, 0.019279122352600098, 0.005548187997192144, -0.005478808656334877, -0.012236271984875202, 0.01604411005973816, -0.05049072206020355, 0.021763499826192856, 0.03178194537758827, -0.006022527813911438, 0.045197393745183945, -0.0057184346951544285, -0.013667164370417595, 0.005490470677614212, 0.030851218849420547, 0.0021615121513605118, 0.05071958899497986, 0.003866741666570306, -0.031190404668450356, 0.008739293552935123, -0.0066567109897732735, -0.03585296869277954, -0.000053624702559318393, -0.034227002412080765, -0.006437173578888178, -0.04024103283882141, -0.06059245765209198, 0.042994651943445206, 0.0007360498420894146, -0.013956284150481224, 0.011587846092879772, -0.02307426556944847, 0.0645410418510437, 0.0022261941339820623, 0.000914686475880444, -0.004496478475630283, -0.02776484750211239, -0.020947666838765144, 0.012747571803629398, -0.002121660625562072, 0.009491057135164738, 0.011682703159749508, 0.008748439140617847, -0.008758406154811382, -0.0013796619605273008, 0.011584362015128136, -0.050247643142938614, 0.031987011432647705, -0.03681492432951927, 0.030473170801997185, 0.00967352744191885, -0.0015190164558589458, -0.04874945804476738, -0.03538912534713745, -0.009161491878330708, 0.04032319039106369, 0.0293149184435606, -0.02961338311433792, -0.021522104740142822, -0.0003579984186217189, 0.04943623021245003, -0.04282526671886444, -0.025262771174311638, -0.05208287760615349, -0.005079073831439018, -0.003659582231193781, 0.010751326568424702 ]
<p>To fit a simple AR(5) model, I use SAS <code>PROC AUTOREG</code>. I called the option <code>ARCHTEST=(QLM)</code> which provides Engle’s Lagrange Multiplier Test for ARCH Disturbances and the Portmanteau Q Test. The statistics SAS provided for Engle’s Lagrange Multiplier Test were:</p> <pre><code>Order LM p-value 1 0.018 0.893 2 0.079 0.961 3 0.881 0.830 4 1.088 0.896 5 1.105 0.954 6 4.114 0.661 7 4.179 0.759 8 4.182 0.840 9 4.528 0.873 10 4.528 0.920 11 5.565 0.901 12 6.318 0.899 </code></pre> <p>I took the residuals of this model and used the <code>ArchTest</code> function of the <code>FinTS</code> package of <code>R</code> ... <code>library(FinTS)</code>.</p> <pre><code># A function to do ArchTest at multiple lags where 'data' are the residuals of # the model. library(FinTS) arch.m1 = matrix(NaN,12,3) for(i in 1:12) {s = ArchTest(data,lags=i) arch.m1[i,1] = s$statistic arch.m1[i,2] = s$parameter arch.m1[i,3] = s$p.value} </code></pre> <p>The test results from the <code>ArchTest</code> function of the <code>FinTS</code> package are very different:</p> <pre><code>Order LM p-value 1 0.014 0.907 2 0.092 0.955 3 0.835 0.841 4 2.194 0.700 5 3.189 0.671 6 13.013 0.043 7 19.157 0.008 8 23.161 0.003 9 18.780 0.027 10 18.467 0.048 11 22.565 0.020 12 23.828 0.021 </code></pre> <p>I thought the SAS <code>ARCHTEST=(QLM)</code> option and the <code>ArchTest</code> function of the <code>FinTS</code> package were performing the same test but apparently not. Does anyone know what the difference is between the tests in SAS and <code>FinTS</code>?</p> <p><strong>Note</strong>, the data used by Tsay (2005) in the example on page 102 is available <a href="http://faculty.chicagobooth.edu/ruey.tsay/teaching/fts2/m-intc7303.txt" rel="nofollow">here</a>.</p> <p>Using the following <code>R</code> code:</p> <pre><code>library(FinTS) intc=read.table("http://faculty.chicagobooth.edu/ruey.tsay/teaching/fts2/m-intc7303.txt", quote="\"") ArchTest(intc$V2,lags=12) </code></pre> <p>I find:</p> <p>$\chi^2$= 48.0425, df = 12, <em>p</em>-value = 3.073e-06</p> <p>However, Tsay (2005:102) reports:</p> <p>$\chi^2$= 43.5041, df = 12, <em>p</em>-value = 0.0000</p> <p>If I use:</p> <pre><code>ArchTest(log(1+intc$V2),lags=12) </code></pre> <p>Then:</p> <p>$\chi^2$= 43.5041, df = 12, <em>p</em>-value = 0.0000</p> <p>However, this doesn't explain the differences observed between SAS and <code>FinTS</code>.</p> <p><strong>Thanks for your reply @mpiktas.</strong></p> <p>The statistic calculated by the <code>FinTS library</code> using the <code>ArchTest function</code> is based on the second statistic provided by @mpiktas:</p> <p>$$TR^2=T\left(1-\frac{SSR_1}{SSR_0}\right)$$</p> <pre><code>intc=read.table("http://faculty.chicagobooth.edu/ruey.tsay/teaching/fts2/m-intc7303.txt",quote="\"") intc.ln=log(1+intc$V2) lag=12 mat=embed(intc.ln^2,lag+1) m=summary(lm(mat[,1]~mat[,-1])) SSR1=sum(residuals(lm(mat[,1]~mat[,-1]))^2) SSR0=sum(residuals(lm(mat[,1]~1))^2) stat=length(mat[,1])*(1-(SSR1/SSR0)) </code></pre> <p>which gives $\chi^2$ = 43.5041.</p> <p>If I apply the first statistic provided by @mpiktas and shown on page 102 of Tsay (2005):</p> <p>$$F=\frac{(SSR_0-SSR_1)/m}{SSR_1/(T-2m-1)}$$</p> <pre><code>intc=read.table("http://faculty.chicagobooth.edu/ruey.tsay/teaching/fts2/m-intc7303.txt",quote="\"") intc.ln=log(1+intc$V2) lag=12 mat=embed(intc.ln^2,lag+1) m=summary(lm(mat[,1]~mat[,-1])) SSR1=sum(residuals(lm(mat[,1]~mat[,-1]))^2) SSR0=sum(residuals(lm(mat[,1]~1))^2) stat=((SSR0-SSR1)/lag)/(SSR1/(length(mat[,1])-(2*lag)-1)) </code></pre> <p>This version of the statistic gives $\chi^2$ = 3.837.</p> <p>These are very different answers? I have provided the residuals for the AR(5) model from SAS below:</p> <pre><code>c(0.14167,0.14019,-0.42499,0.0222,0.04388,-0.03157,0.00897, -0.04567,0.29171,-0.06735,0.05235,-0.04062,-0.18694, -0.2407,0.03766,-0.15011,0.11023,-0.30812,-0.02399, 0.13434,0.05836,0.09368,-0.01832,-0.15669,-0.00127, 0.19431,0.10366,-0.09682,-0.04597,0.07162,0.16411,-0.02181, -0.00459,-0.16325,-0.09615,-0.04581,0.10441,0.12845,-0.0398, -0.03349,-0.01575,0.06923,-0.05006,-0.05827, -0.0317,0.08914,0.07323,0.06519,0.16141,0.0537,0.08213, 0.01073,-0.06628,0.01297,0.00622,-0.10171,0.05598,-0.05615, 0.10322,-0.04991,-0.01223,-0.04975,-0.06043,0.01794, -0.00071,0.05425,-0.05462,0.01659,0.08656,0.02482,-0.04214, 0.01221) </code></pre> <p>For lag 5, SAS gives $\chi^2$ = 1.105, <code>FinTS</code> gives $\chi^2$ = 3.189, and the F-statistic version gives $\chi^2$ = 0.560.</p> <p><strong>References:</strong></p> <p>Engle, R. F. 1982. Autoregressive conditional heteroscedasticity with estimates of the variance of United Kingdom inflation. Econometrica 50:987-1007.</p> <p>Tsay, R. S. 2005. Analysis of financial time series. Second edition. John Wiley &amp; Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey, USA.</p>
38,088
[ -0.01965838298201561, 0.0326370969414711, -0.00848348531872034, -0.014966391958296299, 0.042912185192108154, -0.02018226496875286, -0.012194205075502396, -0.013977360911667347, -0.002991391345858574, -0.025389956310391426, 0.016572587192058563, 0.012004861608147621, 0.033989615738391876, 0.017284223809838295, 0.007612556219100952, 0.04060722514986992, 0.023902667686343193, 0.007856552489101887, 0.017688767984509468, -0.012483267113566399, -0.0005120545392856002, -0.013114041648805141, -0.03571915253996849, -0.0015297437785193324, -0.012795125134289265, 0.04722793400287628, 0.0359429195523262, -0.021732579916715622, 0.02145390585064888, 0.03121165931224823, -0.017820648849010468, -0.0038515764754265547, -0.0066250283271074295, -0.0027381989639252424, -0.004964955151081085, 0.019431697204709053, 0.03483464568853378, 0.002933465875685215, -0.009442104957997799, 0.0730409249663353, 0.011436697095632553, 0.016298368573188782, 0.013738858513534069, 0.012250653468072414, 0.013254618272185326, 0.012964320369064808, 0.061478327959775925, -0.00895354151725769, 0.0606413297355175, -0.0004463286604732275, 0.04443521052598953, -0.0185324065387249, -0.031887032091617584, -0.007509603165090084, -0.06638805568218231, -0.03203180059790611, 0.07111594080924988, 0.07269209623336792, -0.010252436622977257, -0.06740493327379227, -0.008414247073233128, -0.028723377734422684, 0.013070300221443176, -0.02745823934674263, -0.024871710687875748, -0.02883676066994667, 0.016247667372226715, -0.0314127579331398, 0.023023264482617378, -0.020162977278232574, 0.009474356658756733, -0.010300991125404835, 0.019501948729157448, -0.04430624842643738, 0.04525525122880936, -0.0062792799435555935, 0.01289491355419159, 0.014885230921208858, 0.04313206300139427, 0.0067903283052146435, 0.03865937516093254, 0.03267218917608261, 0.02950482815504074, 0.033996157348155975, 0.016556499525904655, -0.020764639601111412, 0.03791277855634689, -0.011934541165828705, 0.06190621852874756, 0.030270354822278023, -0.0319538339972496, 0.03490574657917023, 0.08166723698377609, 0.04612003639340401, -0.02836007997393608, 0.040107570588588715, -0.016415562480688095, 0.006498218514025211, 0.008728289976716042, -0.0018006815807893872, -0.024853503331542015, -0.04931226745247841, 0.011560969986021519, 0.0439121350646019, 0.010372433811426163, -0.02676466293632984, 0.012319040484726429, -0.04052329808473587, -0.0477285198867321, -0.03745690733194351, 0.00520344777032733, 0.04671640321612358, -0.052145037800073624, -0.011407289654016495, 0.005680061876773834, -0.022141670808196068, -0.036454301327466965, -0.01583840884268284, 0.06056082621216774, 0.040805451571941376, 0.03769093379378319, -0.008090494200587273, -0.023087287321686745, -0.03732966631650925, -0.04565315321087837, -0.004211761523038149, -0.009829403832554817, -0.015508081763982773, -0.02076875977218151, 0.05065743625164032, 0.0011933004716411233, 0.000690121145453304, 0.03332212567329407, -0.017681347206234932, 0.028890518471598625, 0.028071509674191475, -0.0821933001279831, -0.05535668507218361, 0.015368432737886906, 0.020991221070289612, 0.014887986704707146, -0.024463538080453873, 0.006139650009572506, 0.0012287086574360728, 0.07336115837097168, 0.019648505374789238, 0.03729528561234474, -0.010899755172431469, 0.009668990969657898, 0.011950420215725899, -0.042968541383743286, 0.035135410726070404, -0.03461342677474022, -0.010036042891442776, 0.00782538577914238, -0.06835293024778366, -0.00022863649064674973, 0.03292938321828842, -0.004456604365259409, 0.0014861886156722903, 0.00016172484902199358, 0.06276222318410873, 0.00022447881929110736, -0.0426475815474987, -0.04788324236869812, -0.015032054856419563, 0.020310252904891968, -0.01581249199807644, -0.0008457798394374549, 0.03348672389984131, -0.0076225996017456055, 0.009447881951928139, -0.03792920708656311, 0.057519637048244476, 0.02872294932603836, -0.042927876114845276, 0.02030782401561737, -0.037158891558647156, -0.01582365296781063, 0.049672920256853104, -0.05121294781565666, -0.012225283309817314, -0.008938144892454147, -0.040822889655828476, -0.007791383657604456, 0.014951278455555439, 0.009729127399623394, 0.016295703127980232, 0.04387880489230156, -0.06441916525363922, -0.05617661774158478, -0.0601324588060379, 0.00994784850627184, -0.002869619522243738, -0.018356122076511383, 0.01775469444692135, -0.007275151554495096, 0.03438291698694229, 0.0355767086148262, -0.03733270987868309, -0.02818012237548828, -0.011432084254920483, 0.06796251982450485, -0.024496104568243027, 0.007440165616571903, 0.0037777801044285297, 0.032149896025657654, -0.01106300763785839, 0.009458843618631363, -0.029991749674081802, 0.022323008626699448, 0.02210945636034012, -0.03301359713077545, 0.04153815656900406, -0.0080108642578125, 0.00827690027654171, 0.0037369951605796814, 0.003987109754234552, -0.0132737522944808, 0.04355155676603317, -0.05531512573361397, 0.042135052382946014, 0.0735316276550293, -0.007529295980930328, 0.0015391462948173285, -0.031023023650050163, -0.017840668559074402, 0.039779096841812134, -0.05494505539536476, 0.005257367622107267, -0.04791637510061264, -0.04131077975034714, 0.040504444390535355, 0.01303989626467228, -0.010618467815220356, 0.015335827134549618, 0.04651247709989548, -0.03609594702720642, -0.023653889074921608, 0.05109666287899017, -0.02513778954744339, -0.0476548932492733, 0.029862776398658752, 0.02040151320397854, 0.03826456516981125, 0.028871824964880943, 0.06765332072973251, 0.006975668948143721, 0.03550742194056511, -0.007893613539636135, 0.003728525247424841, 0.045265886932611465, -0.01699596457183361, 0.001919613336212933, -0.020827868953347206, -0.04645923525094986, 0.02624955028295517, 0.02114569954574108, -0.019428875297307968, 0.015626395121216774, 0.0312596894800663, -0.021020470187067986, 0.01932966522872448, -0.009375772438943386, 0.03287666663527489, 0.054951779544353485, -0.03388797864317894, -0.022874658927321434, 0.015852658078074455, -0.031343795359134674, 0.02550351992249489, -0.03198495879769325, 0.009517512284219265, -0.05273453891277313, 0.006318053230643272, 0.01941823586821556, 0.03230078145861626, 0.007279946468770504, -0.05377349629998207, 0.015692802146077156, 0.02404579147696495, -0.008487776853144169, 0.0416678786277771, 0.007839132100343704, -0.038151536136865616, -0.008255786262452602, -0.029088305309414864, 0.02224767953157425, 0.009194999001920223, -0.018613111227750778, -0.02301272563636303, 0.04443879798054695, 0.0033406016882508993, -0.030356526374816895, -0.03458790108561516, -0.015461956150829792, -0.0196557454764843, -0.03582848608493805, -0.02880421280860901, 0.05498901382088661, 0.04985875263810158, -0.039669353514909744, -0.007767673581838608, -0.057486582547426224, 0.04430839791893959, -0.008247897028923035, -0.006359576713293791, 0.00021280540386214852, -0.004677466116845608, 0.009545967914164066, 0.016081707552075386, 0.019858989864587784, 0.013669490814208984, -0.06673572957515717, -0.04706892743706703, 0.020705580711364746, -0.0034787359181791544, -0.026913583278656006, -0.03220454230904579, 0.011823765933513641, 0.05237654969096184, 0.04758238419890404, -0.006498068571090698, -0.025721319019794464, -0.020586200058460236, -0.02839536964893341, -0.023085571825504303, 0.01794362999498844, 0.049897320568561554, 0.009570752270519733, 0.03919558599591255, -0.06268948316574097, 0.028336478397250175, 0.02479436807334423, -0.010451734997332096, 0.030720889568328857, 0.014032036066055298, -0.04205188900232315, -0.012489812448620796, 0.022545363754034042, 0.035701196640729904, 0.014352831989526749, -0.004349930677562952, 0.011414142325520515, 0.026415899395942688, -0.015579810366034508, -0.040115803480148315, 0.010863176546990871, -0.016656871885061264, 0.0002900637045968324, -0.04187847301363945, 0.025633085519075394, 0.014958253130316734, -0.05779242515563965, -0.020522786304354668, 0.014183053746819496, 0.024324525147676468, 0.008345208130776882, 0.017342185601592064, 0.07089488208293915, 0.03862973675131798, 0.031667694449424744, -0.015953201800584793, -0.047054223716259, -0.02631840854883194, 0.005624574143439531, -0.08659609407186508, -0.010138008743524551, 0.0008832233725115657, 0.0156157361343503, 0.029834412038326263, -0.0006599649786949158, -0.04632405936717987, 0.026228712871670723, -0.072859987616539, 0.021777240559458733, -0.01657954975962639, 0.04503343999385834, 0.02180970273911953, 0.05937305837869644, -0.005165346432477236, -0.018650036305189133, 0.0023710555396974087, -0.02876153402030468, -0.045171286910772324, 0.009211072698235512, 0.009919241070747375, -0.007634291425347328, 0.0059796287678182125, -0.01927304081618786, 0.03527078777551651, -0.07364461570978165, 0.06516137719154358, 0.004733624868094921, -0.000039601363823749125, -0.022818733006715775, 0.015805194154381752, -0.02635783702135086, 0.007018622010946274, 0.0139735983684659, -0.024118375033140182, 0.06295519322156906, -0.044372133910655975, 0.01090673916041851, 0.030536998063325882, 0.006312757730484009, -0.014006522484123707, -0.021692367270588875, 0.00650591216981411, 0.01718582957983017, 0.0642770454287529, 0.07819867879152298, 0.050967711955308914, -0.028895381838083267, 0.03473459556698799, 0.014994329772889614, 0.021607965230941772, 0.03260798379778862, -0.014138495549559593, 0.002108646323904395, -0.009892353788018227, 0.006547213066369295, 0.020553002133965492, -0.007451450452208519, 0.004501651972532272, -0.024024764075875282, 0.04727565124630928, 0.0188683420419693, -0.022752581164240837, -0.005886818747967482, 0.0016561150550842285, 0.03682851418852806, 0.004481472074985504, -0.05412386730313301, 0.003162980545312166, 0.007380010560154915, 0.020238324999809265, 0.048014137893915176, 0.019425388425588608, -0.01633245311677456, 0.018781078979372978, 0.008463938720524311, -0.015731696039438248, -0.005862938240170479, 0.023945029824972153, 0.0506458543241024, 0.04794265702366829, 0.008439033292233944, -0.024919074028730392, 0.03622469678521156, -0.017444023862481117, 0.0025365594774484634, 0.014880746603012085, -0.004865710623562336, -0.1066933125257492, 0.03321020305156708, 0.03845985233783722, 0.05997152626514435, -0.035377029329538345, 0.01936442404985428, -0.06284176558256149, -0.014391642063856125, 0.01783503219485283, -0.009225672110915184, 0.05158396065235138, -0.014288208447396755, 0.030686920508742332, -0.050036508589982986, -0.04597407951951027, -0.039946503937244415, -0.005498830229043961, -0.008391679264605045, 0.004096058197319508, -0.0537644661962986, -0.07798836380243301, -0.005588488187640905, -0.01455523632466793, 0.011371225118637085, 0.007736807689070702, -0.02479906752705574, -0.0018413460347801447, 0.028221260756254196, 0.047370653599500656, 0.047817252576351166, -0.05232779681682587, 0.020824726670980453, -0.02845771238207817, -0.03142418712377548, 0.042598772794008255, -0.008531810715794563, 0.007325537968426943, 0.03248176723718643, 0.008566020056605339, 0.023048335686326027, 0.017443474382162094, -0.03906889259815216, 0.014310980215668678, 0.015251814387738705, 0.003133961232379079, 0.03777487576007843, 0.021444154903292656, -0.0099856061860919, -0.002771902596578002, -0.031499315053224564, -0.006172758527100086, -0.014354768209159374, -0.029541026800870895, -0.03613266348838806, -0.004555373452603817, -0.0014702266780659556, -0.00906310137361288, 0.014530283398926258, 0.015291695483028889, -0.02734212949872017, 0.01107027381658554, 0.044603947550058365, 0.016782918944954872, -0.018880847841501236, 0.034750498831272125, 0.018965361639857292, -0.017305243760347366, -0.032318323850631714, 0.0001685240276856348, 0.009818575344979763, -0.007565150503069162, -0.02385282702744007, 0.009295361116528511, -0.03748924657702446, 0.02967109903693199, 0.011455749161541462, -0.004511989653110504, -0.0009321285178884864, 0.021922722458839417, 0.030264806002378464, 0.02792353369295597, 0.046178970485925674, 0.019926777109503746, -0.01088625006377697, -0.018906941637396812, 0.01880555972456932, -0.029355620965361595, -0.0021547586657106876, 0.014383537694811821, 0.02156585082411766, 0.010751597583293915, -0.001969635719433427, -0.07182932645082474, -0.015547249466180801, 0.018222643062472343, -0.019518733024597168, -0.055931929498910904, 0.01075928844511509, -0.03297095745801926, -0.014292274601757526, 0.012296972796320915, -0.02079363726079464, 0.03762642294168472, -0.06877659261226654, 0.00704540777951479, -0.018485767766833305, 0.013815783895552158, 0.05538416653871536, -0.006560489069670439, -0.018714729696512222, -0.016505369916558266, -0.022913480177521706, -0.004016185645014048, 0.0421484000980854, -0.015203407034277916, -0.008725017309188843, -0.00860042218118906, -0.012340606190264225, 0.002162675838917494, 0.049268875271081924, 0.0243772454559803, -0.04934051260352135, -0.029073264449834824, -0.012442315928637981, 0.040845733135938644, -0.003892694367095828, -0.01591808721423149, -0.004730556160211563, 0.01436918880790472, -0.02507716789841652, -0.030144916847348213, 0.006302181165665388, -0.010586332529783249, 0.003854114096611738, 0.004405527375638485, -0.0016289930790662766, 0.014559077098965645, 0.07827500998973846, 0.016493404284119606, 0.018846306949853897, 0.012090408243238926, -0.011437308974564075, 0.03934086486697197, -0.01646970398724079, 0.027276022359728813, -0.03582188859581947, 0.043076932430267334, -0.01952551305294037, -0.03234396502375603, -0.017171451821923256, 0.01076262816786766, 0.020031634718179703, 0.012483237311244011, 0.009844867512583733, 0.04222177341580391, -0.03540991619229317, 0.014174005948007107, -0.02665906772017479, -0.016062479466199875, 0.0027058126870542765, 0.029509451240301132, 0.07459394633769989, -0.012330625206232071, -0.0034719437826424837, 0.008966872468590736, 0.018898123875260353, 0.013568711467087269, 0.045917827636003494, 0.012861017137765884, -0.0016562521923333406, 0.005996332969516516, -0.038011882454156876, -0.04085463285446167, 0.03402778506278992, -0.02938816510140896, 0.035731952637434006, -0.03913509100675583, 0.0013632423942908645, 0.04754910245537758, 0.042401913553476334, 0.0071693118661642075, -0.05873264744877815, -0.0043457974679768085, -0.08004406094551086, 0.0008328064577654004, 0.016698090359568596, -0.02368777245283127, 0.037805888801813126, 0.036388006061315536, 0.06472239643335342, -0.005299437791109085, 0.04106437787413597, -0.014652667567133904, -0.05399962142109871, -0.02473244071006775, -0.014007505029439926, 0.012260213494300842, 0.05168499797582626, -0.054667215794324875, -0.020928189158439636, -0.015557383187115192, -0.05704722926020622, 0.012535132467746735, 0.01688779890537262, 0.02007763460278511, 0.006397726479917765, 0.08945032209157944, -0.008676719851791859, -0.006233749445527792, -0.014933326281607151, -0.011025642044842243, 0.1525605171918869, 0.05010164901614189, 0.04589538648724556, -0.07589393854141235, -0.005635260604321957, 0.014154581353068352, 0.00261501083150506, -0.007835591211915016, -0.03760476037859917, -0.02183198183774948, -0.02137761190533638, 0.08204390108585358, 0.04485362395644188, 0.002730300650000572, -0.02306155115365982, 0.01642986573278904, -0.03159342333674431, -0.01920391246676445, -0.0023705754429101944, 0.026625078171491623, -0.01256526354700327, 0.0028969189152121544, -0.03226673975586891, -0.0021383475977927446, 0.007193082012236118, -0.007084888871759176, 0.016143357381224632, -0.020761221647262573, -0.00025314989034086466, 0.029990555718541145, -0.010481180623173714, 0.015974927693605423, 0.016466395929455757, 0.015908831730484962, 0.018594078719615936, 0.021902648732066154, 0.004256581421941519, -0.043770916759967804, 0.030774017795920372, 0.048113368451595306, -0.0013345183106139302, -0.024250071495771408, -0.037676166743040085, 0.011201281100511551, -0.006742398254573345, -0.05101590231060982, -0.037027791142463684, 0.06446760147809982, 0.02534191496670246, -0.018928686156868935, -0.011694313958287239, 0.0045458064414560795, 0.016309363767504692, -0.03212945908308029, -0.02741839736700058, 0.0060824062675237656, 0.011566385626792908, -0.03641543537378311, 0.010781871154904366, -0.01748080737888813, 0.021439651027321815, 0.011962338350713253, 0.03192641958594322, 0.030519966036081314, -0.031910572201013565, -0.0240625087171793, -0.011424850672483444, 0.06143512949347496, -0.01778179593384266, 0.05192171037197113, 0.031187912449240685, -0.004284519702196121, -0.028435811400413513, -0.019798792898654938, 0.026083871722221375, 0.01663598231971264, 0.008685141801834106, -0.018691055476665497, -0.000058894034737022594, -0.037474215030670166, -0.026939930394291878, -0.02753494493663311, -0.048714153468608856, 0.010809832252562046, -0.036044929176568985, 0.014177601784467697, 0.020205164328217506, 0.0022963015362620354, 0.022750448435544968, 0.022815469652414322, -0.010462428443133831, 0.05331944674253464, 0.000360210076905787, -0.06682567298412323, -0.05130760744214058, 0.009420398622751236, 0.00011130725033581257, 0.008793431334197521, -0.025795450434088707, 0.07563505321741104, 0.008299382403492928, 0.013940058648586273, -0.018820425495505333, 0.025397373363375664, -0.0017003931570798159, -0.024904994294047356, 0.04433559998869896, -0.0004939488717354834, 0.0077455476857721806, 0.017046445980668068, -0.00014249335799831897, -0.02986261434853077, -0.005172634497284889, -0.07319522649049759, -0.07998816668987274, 0.004953313618898392, -0.04035376012325287, -0.055050771683454514, 0.013964020647108555, -0.01161879301071167, -0.02076534926891327, -0.0584869459271431, -0.016463076695799828, -0.015380044467747211, -0.026064611971378326, -0.0477035753428936, -0.00944788008928299, -0.02266564965248108, -0.014045740477740765, -0.07068724930286407, 0.0015108297811821103, 0.03894549608230591, -0.032873380929231644, 0.010169658809900284, -0.039600152522325516, 0.03205300495028496, 0.015978176146745682, 0.03425469994544983, 0.012700682505965233, 0.011002051644027233, 0.0008029193850234151, -0.03212800621986389, -0.015824170783162117, -0.008189268410205841, -0.021988285705447197, 0.008844000287353992, -0.010314090177416801, 0.03849209472537041, -0.012960942462086678, 0.03362290933728218, -0.02905893512070179, 0.0006960041937418282, -0.04720333218574524, 0.016969434916973114, 0.028658458963036537, -0.018674617633223534, -0.000545624818187207, -0.011609546840190887, -0.010678908787667751, 0.022103922441601753, 0.05835122615098953, -0.006677658762782812, 0.013905846513807774, -0.008507275022566319, -0.05536642298102379, -0.008119730278849602, -0.0032248159404844046, 0.002703919541090727, -0.006135167088359594, 0.01364482007920742, 0.019492188468575478, 0.012583049014210701, -0.05075106397271156, 0.024824324995279312, -0.10648895800113678, -0.013959851115942001, -0.04551860690116882, 0.034210458397865295, 0.022902755066752434, -0.03814655542373657, 0.022700784727931023, 0.026144972071051598, -0.040253348648548126, 0.05187997594475746, 0.005185699090361595, 0.03584284335374832, -0.03496025875210762, -0.004051425959914923, -0.03068806417286396, 0.012427621521055698, 0.04639289900660515, -0.003854065202176571, 0.06277313083410263, 0.04218049347400665, 0.004005464259535074, -0.003759095910936594, -0.005746936425566673, 0.03830690309405327, -0.0031981186475604773, -0.04355835169553757, 0.020198700949549675, -0.009917445480823517, 0.01501185167580843, -0.011529854498803616, 0.00022254449140746146, 0.019417574629187584, 0.01288070622831583, 0.02378489077091217, 0.015420251525938511, 0.028831589967012405, -0.0018724629189819098, 0.015751322731375694, 0.012367656454443932, -0.011086860671639442, 0.005603578872978687, 0.0064596813172101974, -0.040828291326761246, 0.024772631004452705, 0.015810523182153702, -0.02843276597559452, -0.00954713299870491, -0.007378766313195229, -0.01164788007736206, -0.005234303884208202, -0.0008736761519685388, -0.037419840693473816, -0.007166082505136728, -0.0010067666880786419, -0.008818643167614937, -0.030188918113708496, -0.00705409049987793, 0.0655505359172821, 0.03595982864499092, -0.045329511165618896, 0.00028519771876744926, -0.009241593070328236, -0.006682520732283592, 0.06217033043503761, -0.00025176050257869065, 0.0157704409211874, -0.04006912559270859, -0.05070320889353752, 0.013233533129096031, 0.011647087521851063, -0.03195998817682266, 0.04486081004142761, -0.015430670231580734, 0.05286002159118652, -0.03674248605966568, -0.046663764864206314, 0.05644708126783371, -0.004091992042958736, 0.0679495558142662, -0.08717548102140427, 0.043167099356651306, -0.026861250400543213, -0.0116670997813344, -0.018347185105085373, -0.013195734471082687, -0.04263682663440704, 0.03471577540040016, 0.0463443323969841, 0.028161732479929924, 0.0010536711197346449, 0.015420032665133476, 0.03031850978732109, 0.016177617013454437, -0.025434084236621857, 0.0582016259431839, 0.005768036004155874, 0.020511584356427193, -0.006152765359729528, -0.002967333421111107, 0.035480014979839325, 0.011764036491513252, 0.025834862142801285, -0.005290305707603693, -0.026697445660829544, 0.010797387920320034, -0.04873248562216759, 0.011114893481135368, -0.01681334711611271, -0.03536199778318405, 0.02047879807651043, -0.00298905186355114, -0.019384924322366714, 0.03506210818886757, -0.0035989144816994667, -0.07027299702167511, -0.01976030506193638, -0.03341129422187805, 0.009578514844179153, -0.013072997331619263, -0.003400985151529312, -0.017618969082832336, -0.05377115309238434, -0.019434133544564247, 0.026457449421286583, -0.027698349207639694, -0.03349277004599571, 0.007518664468079805, -0.012727617286145687, 0.044200263917446136, -0.04331351816654205, 0.023941222578287125, -0.034377437084913254, 0.0024390947073698044, 0.04112420976161957, 0.007323647849261761, 0.004940505605190992, 0.0057149226777255535, 0.003873111680150032, 0.05473769083619118, -0.05142155662178993, 0.03927471861243248, -0.037953540682792664, 0.05067198723554611, 0.001016130787320435, -0.02082916907966137, 0.00016442794003523886, -0.03852039575576782, 0.00509829493239522, -0.013084630481898785, 0.027551591396331787, 0.03670159727334976, -0.02389073744416237, 0.008788672275841236, -0.01715194061398506, 0.013895122334361076, 0.005512830335646868, 0.020700551569461823, -0.022255022078752518, 0.01710839755833149, -0.023898083716630936, 0.034313518553972244, -0.004599099513143301, -0.02122826874256134, 0.012206848710775375, -0.014384995214641094, -0.012091100215911865, 0.00289300293661654, 0.004718666430562735, 0.005378347355872393, -0.021516472101211548, -0.01602574810385704, -0.02519010752439499, 0.023896630853414536, 0.048567548394203186, 0.002452233573421836, -0.054976191371679306, -0.03758006915450096, 0.005153167061507702, 0.07285265624523163, -0.06030647084116936, -0.026297355070710182, -0.007476154249161482, 0.005370094906538725, -0.007650592364370823, -0.011095796711742878 ]
<p>So its like saying 95% of the items sold in this website costs between $$25 - $150. While some items might cost less than $25 and other items might cost more than $150.</p> <p>Is there a way to find this? Is this something related to CI - confidence Interval?</p>
73,501
[ 0.000029308457669685595, -0.02888915315270424, 0.013663928024470806, -0.006776626221835613, 0.025162024423480034, 0.02654109336435795, 0.006954658310860395, 0.01536930724978447, 0.029906444251537323, -0.019010202959179878, 0.04576576128602028, 0.05775032937526703, 0.04149029031395912, 0.022117819637060165, -0.006552804261445999, 0.04351511597633362, -0.019739799201488495, -0.017115462571382523, 0.012022590264678001, 0.0028081818018108606, 0.01642552949488163, 0.024079278111457825, -0.014299921691417694, -0.03242592141032219, -0.028810670599341393, 0.04196849837899208, 0.036015529185533524, -0.04455776885151863, 0.0031681633554399014, 0.059096597135066986, -0.04866486042737961, -0.02926199696958065, 0.026761198416352272, 0.04268012195825577, 0.026719674468040466, 0.003406388917937875, -0.009311486035585403, -0.005592353641986847, -0.02293696627020836, 0.02527686208486557, -0.04853937029838562, -0.00020093383500352502, 0.03937375172972679, 0.02096545696258545, -0.000979036558419466, 0.023356206715106964, -0.011280586943030357, -0.07186800986528397, -0.0013492144644260406, -0.02081964537501335, 0.09308134764432907, -0.03982162103056908, 0.06828054040670395, 0.01028350368142128, 0.017999397590756416, 0.017301170155405998, 0.07337900996208191, 0.05909368023276329, -0.021710140630602837, -0.04846594110131264, -0.01701604761183262, -0.0006890726508572698, 0.03025800921022892, -0.02428966760635376, -0.009148302488029003, 0.011582518927752972, -0.005399200599640608, -0.02012069709599018, 0.04400862380862236, 0.032209187746047974, 0.0032259796280413866, 0.011734497733414173, 0.05313992127776146, -0.009494472295045853, 0.011793598532676697, -0.055686671286821365, 0.00998466182500124, 0.04574402794241905, 0.015311606228351593, 0.04235793650150299, -0.017049873247742653, 0.005354754626750946, -0.0046468693763017654, 0.040040332823991776, 0.04418141394853592, -0.026114562526345253, 0.040026914328336716, -0.0335547961294651, 0.004429348744452, 0.02811962366104126, 0.011314542964100838, -0.01732446998357773, 0.04421030730009079, 0.01975538209080696, -0.03771039843559265, -0.006666820030659437, -0.010034619830548763, -0.016979938372969627, -0.0058704824186861515, 0.02363629639148712, 0.007345769088715315, -0.018374880775809288, 0.03592870756983757, 0.0454765148460865, -0.028727632015943527, 0.008768903091549873, -0.043733861297369, -0.03469780832529068, 0.02070031873881817, 0.0228403452783823, -0.011771341785788536, 0.04970613494515419, 0.016007447615265846, 0.0017534388462081552, 0.027251264080405235, 0.010963080450892448, -0.04017786681652069, -0.05173759162425995, 0.048711031675338745, -0.004262083675712347, 0.02913103811442852, -0.015293111093342304, 0.028009753674268723, 0.020084183663129807, -0.023329822346568108, 0.0365820936858654, 0.010660049505531788, -0.0012056664563715458, -0.038932353258132935, 0.05692293867468834, -0.026112202554941177, -0.04134282097220421, 0.02558283880352974, 0.016605153679847717, 0.04282120615243912, 0.002862795488908887, -0.06686095148324966, -0.06393265724182129, 0.04695717617869377, -0.011160014197230339, -0.004616392310708761, -0.07651092112064362, 0.027669936418533325, 0.040151022374629974, 0.03495333343744278, 0.01951010338962078, 0.027967708185315132, -0.020218629390001297, -0.019280333071947098, 0.036247383803129196, -0.030970374122262, -0.012326098047196865, -0.003333559026941657, -0.01849377527832985, -0.026913268491625786, -0.07405012100934982, -0.007319028023630381, 0.037746362388134, 0.004540029913187027, -0.018229631707072258, -0.009042358957231045, 0.029616061598062515, -0.02842182107269764, -0.008991333656013012, 0.02012564241886139, -0.02286205254495144, 0.07832344621419907, -0.018083946779370308, 0.006639246363192797, 0.020472882315516472, -0.027173303067684174, -0.011788063682615757, -0.005854922812432051, 0.01418698113411665, 0.09174980223178864, -0.023093661293387413, 0.008516591973602772, -0.03011520393192768, 0.008395710028707981, 0.010323276743292809, -0.04739140346646309, -0.006060941610485315, -0.012876265682280064, 0.03440365940332413, 0.06516829878091812, 0.03197246417403221, -0.027448808774352074, -0.0623682402074337, 0.0013899423647671938, -0.045320697128772736, -0.028256025165319443, -0.031087003648281097, 0.0028900261968374252, 0.007322541903704405, -0.007822347804903984, 0.01971353404223919, 0.018039701506495476, -0.026759376749396324, -0.03366870805621147, -0.011441554874181747, 0.004766151774674654, -0.02675410732626915, 0.03719073534011841, -0.0755385011434555, 0.021938933059573174, 0.019273020327091217, 0.03629506006836891, -0.04133962467312813, 0.040368564426898956, -0.05885551869869232, -0.05607352778315544, -0.01634846441447735, -0.02454771101474762, 0.004069550894200802, 0.004190333187580109, -0.02955346554517746, 0.01728781685233116, 0.0023245711345225573, -0.024285893887281418, 0.03235306590795517, -0.045520465821027756, 0.029230087995529175, 0.05093977227807045, 0.02482243813574314, -0.00792690273374319, -0.02693215385079384, 0.03214211389422417, 0.04192757606506348, 0.014997180551290512, -0.038264013826847076, -0.04044016823172569, 0.00239143380895257, 0.013155737891793251, -0.0007507314439862967, -0.03539109230041504, -0.006989459507167339, 0.09885899722576141, 0.024173881858587265, 0.005805142689496279, 0.03862684592604637, 0.010326066985726357, 0.019110113382339478, -0.01200433261692524, 0.0410689115524292, 0.038975127041339874, 0.03318679332733154, -0.010711615905165672, 0.043335333466529846, 0.045484934002161026, 0.012096622958779335, 0.0158398300409317, 0.02558354288339615, 0.015283571556210518, 0.028797857463359833, -0.018689289689064026, 0.011690110899508, 0.05055951327085495, -0.03239649161696434, 0.018463240936398506, 0.007373872213065624, -0.012258326634764671, -0.020111361518502235, -0.011913307011127472, -0.036921437829732895, 0.021076379343867302, 0.05142908915877342, -0.07658413797616959, 0.03893997520208359, 0.027627527713775635, -0.013876981101930141, 0.00388223584741354, -0.013878736644983292, 0.0021019927226006985, -0.03280457854270935, 0.014258898794651031, 0.06011839956045151, -0.009974916465580463, 0.06280018389225006, -0.04159301146864891, -0.034545574337244034, -0.007545706816017628, -0.0006941738538444042, -0.027626141905784607, -0.03188123553991318, -0.04319451376795769, 0.0008513835491612554, 0.03412555158138275, -0.03532414883375168, -0.006180617958307266, -0.016047278419137, 0.0010897155152633786, 0.02565055713057518, 0.0013354509137570858, -0.05228538438677788, 0.021484050899744034, 0.0069064786657691, 0.028141260147094727, -0.05373096466064453, -0.025516927242279053, 0.009095188230276108, 0.014159047044813633, -0.0033067346084862947, 0.06705369055271149, -0.00920430663973093, -0.038452424108982086, -0.02348964475095272, 0.001755935838446021, -0.004365777131170034, -0.022967426106333733, 0.022395819425582886, 0.016353264451026917, 0.013850477524101734, -0.00492233969271183, -0.0684194341301918, -0.07077979296445847, -0.01126015279442072, 0.021196521818637848, 0.009507174603641033, 0.011589226312935352, -0.02399585209786892, 0.08963653445243835, 0.0353536419570446, -0.05482030287384987, -0.036898329854011536, -0.02554304525256157, -0.0004692578804679215, -0.0070553310215473175, -0.010100489482283592, 0.014043637551367283, -0.039287444204092026, 0.03374611958861351, 0.023599795997142792, 0.022369079291820526, 0.058203719556331635, 0.012698345817625523, 0.03362753242254257, 0.006748741026967764, -0.004122743383049965, -0.0035825225058943033, 0.03882980719208717, 0.010949654504656792, -0.0411297045648098, 0.0273909755051136, -0.000027141859391122125, 0.04839496314525604, 0.0018382970010861754, -0.043654728680849075, 0.021381843835115433, -0.01500742882490158, -0.00014151808863971382, -0.02827736735343933, 0.025834033265709877, 0.024236882105469704, 0.0015050772344693542, -0.017008090391755104, -0.0009843058651313186, 0.026311758905649185, -0.024143101647496223, -0.006788475438952446, 0.038437604904174805, 0.02883833460509777, -0.03730026260018349, -0.02221565507352352, -0.003019842319190502, -0.004022028297185898, -0.028335202485322952, -0.032764166593551636, -0.059594277292490005, 0.022442439571022987, 0.04766741394996643, 0.01985124684870243, 0.009609484113752842, -0.015881141647696495, 0.035740770399570465, -0.07712448388338089, -0.032236259430646896, -0.03385342285037041, 0.03466072306036949, -0.01664552092552185, 0.049155011773109436, 0.04021953418850899, -0.002886859467253089, 0.01857592537999153, 0.0341518260538578, -0.05556148290634155, 0.050651129335165024, -0.015246831811964512, 0.015835557132959366, -0.002121885307133198, -0.06508143991231918, -0.004372481722384691, -0.030124366283416748, -0.021605756133794785, -0.013220160268247128, 0.01343771256506443, -0.021476663649082184, 0.044386886060237885, 0.02501341514289379, 0.008524092845618725, 0.008829187601804733, -0.006486816331744194, -0.020485015586018562, 0.024945834651589394, 0.04402587562799454, 0.009732430800795555, 0.0074388268403708935, -0.024568401277065277, -0.01545101497322321, 0.010137045755982399, 0.036005426198244095, 0.05082329362630844, 0.016037827357649803, 0.026352275162935257, -0.04738379642367363, 0.01287116389721632, -0.017917601391673088, 0.0751461312174797, 0.02851215749979019, -0.04821190983057022, -0.013550660572946072, -0.009342293255031109, 0.008585442788898945, 0.004028188064694405, 0.004685526713728905, -0.0013131910236552358, -0.001327286008745432, 0.06342681497335434, 0.03356045484542847, -0.042755722999572754, 0.018579374998807907, 0.04149609059095383, 0.005619157571345568, -0.004694168455898762, -0.061877425760030746, -0.015668144449591637, -0.02237183228135109, -0.0064279017969965935, 0.007751357741653919, 0.003955676686018705, 0.025091251358389854, 0.02005496621131897, 0.04975711181759834, -0.001884790020994842, -0.04153290018439293, 0.027665182948112488, -0.02036570943892002, 0.042825859040021896, -0.028488434851169586, -0.04129383713006973, 0.052529558539390564, 0.014729904942214489, 0.03951311483979225, 0.04567049816250801, 0.017311394214630127, -0.0581461563706398, 0.020420661196112633, 0.026211533695459366, 0.0505371131002903, -0.023068062961101532, -0.020420439541339874, -0.03709402307868004, -0.00955141894519329, 0.01731826551258564, -0.01972975581884384, 0.03293736279010773, -0.0008737402968108654, 0.025870390236377716, -0.03342386335134506, -0.01245314534753561, -0.0307692289352417, -0.02401551604270935, -0.04730134829878807, 0.006286280695348978, -0.014302952215075493, -0.015140485018491745, -0.03709488734602928, -0.01700723171234131, 0.06953582167625427, 0.0661831945180893, 0.0005543103325180709, 0.015926171094179153, -0.03853454440832138, 0.031862400472164154, -0.03132900223135948, -0.028519097715616226, 0.0339595302939415, -0.024583255872130394, 0.01308286003768444, 0.037274524569511414, 0.005272001959383488, -0.002208143239840865, 0.049839358776807785, 0.005131316836923361, -0.01772376522421837, -0.029792917892336845, -0.04524211585521698, 0.03197422996163368, 0.0426715724170208, -0.0003881016746163368, 0.03770626336336136, 0.0042155031114816666, 0.003294536378234625, -0.0012816083617508411, -0.013574134558439255, 0.03132070228457451, -0.054369617253541946, 0.013303103856742382, -0.04132691025733948, 0.006021809298545122, -0.021961597725749016, -0.006188109517097473, 0.027593668550252914, 0.03252081945538521, -0.03977575525641441, -0.009262061677873135, -0.04683459550142288, -0.015604681335389614, 0.022332554683089256, -0.030676571652293205, -0.007031475193798542, 0.01801849529147148, -0.008098726160824299, -0.002627372043207288, 0.025676529854536057, -0.042747143656015396, 0.026892878115177155, -0.011234734207391739, -0.006780595984309912, 0.034508075565099716, -0.0723324567079544, -0.013101750053465366, 0.009504662826657295, -0.05057327076792717, 0.014111812226474285, -0.04920570179820061, 0.02837812900543213, -0.02970324270427227, -0.024827132001519203, -0.03285900503396988, 0.04552164301276207, 0.01863270439207554, 0.02420612797141075, -0.02419092506170273, 0.060968365520238876, 0.01590375043451786, -0.0137164993211627, -0.05706730857491493, -0.022084029391407967, 0.03826069086790085, 0.04500361159443855, -0.04500250890851021, -0.02517804503440857, -0.0040910979732871056, 0.007386079989373684, -0.015817686915397644, -0.05675535276532173, 0.04955729842185974, 0.030778218060731888, -0.0017055384814739227, -0.010601460002362728, 0.004171061795204878, 0.0652453824877739, 0.007767137140035629, -0.017118077725172043, 0.023023590445518494, 0.04580259695649147, -0.030238712206482887, 0.023815611377358437, -0.005788278300315142, -0.02388240024447441, 0.013351191766560078, -0.028476068750023842, 0.007232058327645063, 0.0019270357443019748, -0.0007769506191834807, 0.0010390818351879716, -0.0041969851590693, 0.028200073167681694, 0.000158322203787975, -0.01576932705938816, 0.0003490027447696775, 0.016337629407644272, 0.03879525512456894, 0.009211299009621143, 0.010502844117581844, -0.007734030485153198, -0.0014672662364318967, 0.04756098613142967, 0.018134484067559242, -0.0013817045837640762, 0.0021515118423849344, 0.11006773263216019, -0.03679630160331726, -0.011393709108233452, -0.01937851496040821, -0.013398668728768826, -0.015677552670240402, 0.0137735391035676, 0.007735463324934244, 0.030106499791145325, 0.018284860998392105, -0.04630668833851814, 0.016986612230539322, -0.03772127255797386, 0.025543417781591415, 0.06456708908081055, 0.009984073229134083, 0.053509749472141266, 0.0633658841252327, 0.010683877393603325, -0.008156117051839828, -0.002890137257054448, -0.030770447105169296, -0.006606015842407942, -0.00854329951107502, 0.031654149293899536, -0.04629475250840187, -0.0011214532423764467, 0.028534669429063797, 0.0410795658826828, -0.017735810950398445, 0.0569186694920063, 0.01413673721253872, 0.020983904600143433, 0.030945176258683205, -0.008266893215477467, -0.013730484992265701, 0.03303196281194687, -0.010881500318646431, 0.0193412397056818, -0.05346837267279625, -0.009456737898290157, 0.010900350287556648, 0.03353365138173103, -0.029875479638576508, -0.03535886108875275, -0.02792549878358841, -0.03043859452009201, -0.0003598341718316078, 0.0037896991707384586, -0.0059934817254543304, 0.008464803919196129, 0.011386190541088581, 0.015952475368976593, 0.010892985388636589, 0.040022820234298706, -0.020162640139460564, -0.022715870290994644, -0.029015028849244118, -0.024105971679091454, -0.031637005507946014, 0.02370275929570198, 0.0020835883915424347, -0.013749765232205391, 0.010877661406993866, -0.014562264084815979, 0.004333627875894308, -0.0012645069509744644, 0.013758424669504166, -0.015164672397077084, 0.05309358239173889, 0.03339827060699463, 0.059606026858091354, -0.0031144926324486732, 0.015124655328691006, 0.12667706608772278, 0.06654457747936249, -0.009223561733961105, -0.05966969206929207, 0.021720437332987785, 0.0102144880220294, -0.00641307607293129, -0.014624102972447872, 0.004557291977107525, 0.004151623230427504, 0.002372143557295203, 0.0746702179312706, 0.06364137679338455, 0.023653214797377586, 0.03641623631119728, 0.023381374776363373, -0.041342079639434814, -0.0009096466819755733, 0.043080974370241165, -0.0022408703807741404, -0.016491618007421494, -0.04985427111387253, -0.046039603650569916, 0.02478584088385105, -0.002841157605871558, -0.002859450178220868, -0.00230748881585896, -0.051671139895915985, 0.0057144793681800365, 0.004425878170877695, -0.0443677119910717, 0.004822600167244673, 0.014353394508361816, -0.0233713760972023, -0.02859940007328987, -0.0012174705043435097, 0.06123877689242363, -0.012921012006700039, -0.028091080486774445, 0.02740645408630371, 0.006763773504644632, 0.0026879608631134033, -0.019563840702176094, 0.039022598415613174, -0.024991827085614204, 0.006422469392418861, -0.07524564862251282, -0.024574685841798782, -0.015548784285783768, 0.004718567710369825, -0.03805401921272278, 0.007103586569428444, -0.01643909513950348, -0.011230504140257835, -0.0025714822113513947, 0.026497887447476387, -0.02541428618133068, -0.024322548881173134, -0.04764674976468086, -0.038134634494781494, -0.02585514821112156, -0.003676855470985174, 0.01799432560801506, 0.03294431045651436, -0.040294233709573746, -0.005071602761745453, -0.015304293483495712, 0.024065576493740082, -0.011484267190098763, -0.05120218172669411, 0.051940687000751495, -0.011471985839307308, -0.021791063249111176, 0.0068154893815517426, -0.04085421562194824, -0.01839495822787285, 0.024160906672477722, -0.019436994567513466, -0.024749141186475754, -0.012640239670872688, -0.0032440905924886465, 0.019929243251681328, -0.030689312145113945, -0.013239679858088493, -0.06032538414001465, -0.01334525179117918, 0.0030559839215129614, 0.021885253489017487, 0.024894777685403824, 0.04462088271975517, -0.04432738572359085, 0.046532660722732544, 0.015747347846627235, -0.013585691340267658, -0.0325884185731411, -0.031974148005247116, -0.05156392976641655, -0.006456716451793909, 0.0008295194711536169, 0.05811896175146103, -0.0021850881166756153, 0.011399046517908573, 0.033820223063230515, -0.017186138778924942, -0.01402510330080986, 0.002686244435608387, 0.018046531826257706, -0.04953264817595482, -0.02860143966972828, 0.06492159515619278, -0.021385839208960533, -0.007786975707858801, 0.0053571672178804874, -0.047779228538274765, -0.027122076600790024, 0.024145234376192093, 0.010182985104620457, -0.024664755910634995, 0.014084639959037304, -0.0011761948699131608, -0.017801256850361824, -0.03302386403083801, -0.033333782106637955, -0.07449755817651749, -0.008385101333260536, 0.019259590655565262, 0.010128648951649666, -0.00854419358074665, -0.0012860989663749933, -0.005281899590045214, 0.012322049587965012, 0.028972506523132324, 0.0109575679525733, -0.008339921943843365, -0.028159156441688538, 0.04581466689705849, 0.012279712595045567, 0.025402676314115524, -0.07329703122377396, 0.003923534415662289, 0.048861198127269745, -0.031237775459885597, -0.020796826109290123, 0.010388331487774849, -0.017865316942334175, 0.03610620275139809, -0.011481507681310177, -0.018724845722317696, -0.025762148201465607, 0.029129965230822563, -0.044499173760414124, -0.032560382038354874, -0.01982318051159382, 0.020412297919392586, 0.029591262340545654, -0.016221439465880394, -0.029528668150305748, 0.030307292938232422, -0.01918531022965908, 0.014292779378592968, 0.01769101619720459, 0.00439240038394928, 0.0016993230674415827, 0.03262985125184059, 0.020147811621427536, 0.026111755520105362, 0.05096380040049553, 0.013012598268687725, 0.008780261501669884, 0.010659357532858849, -0.04028921574354172, 0.01629308983683586, 0.008877207525074482, 0.021748388186097145, -0.02994329296052456, -0.029730262234807014, -0.002656439086422324, 0.007843319326639175, 0.04135795682668686, -0.04783501476049423, 0.017711525782942772, 0.028711820021271706, -0.047856464982032776, 0.05307507887482643, -0.025114137679338455, -0.018057024106383324, -0.06598452478647232, 0.004941099788993597, -0.03637978062033653, 0.017591500654816628, 0.008026626892387867, -0.0024889700580388308, 0.013903290033340454, 0.029448680579662323, -0.004384834785014391, -0.026440754532814026, 0.015889108180999756, 0.01639638841152191, 0.0073173861019313335, -0.09175746142864227, 0.03687240928411484, -0.020343834534287453, -0.04168897122144699, 0.03605489432811737, -0.008207431063055992, -0.01128473225980997, 0.010767190717160702, 0.04654868692159653, 0.005315111950039864, 0.008883987553417683, 0.03301486745476723, -0.0029016700573265553, -0.013017159886658192, -0.01671883836388588, 0.0023896752391010523, 0.04282131791114807, 0.010790376923978329, -0.0019768846686929464, 0.05121748894453049, -0.01832270435988903, -0.05154656246304512, 0.020547103136777878, -0.002311401069164276, 0.006741309072822332, 0.014262218959629536, -0.015237409621477127, -0.013308269903063774, -0.040096789598464966, 0.05955331400036812, -0.07507093995809555, 0.01409202441573143, 0.041683707386255264, 0.00407634861767292, -0.016766024753451347, -0.040347881615161896, -0.000494004285428673, -0.02349497377872467, 0.007495384197682142, 0.0326671302318573, -0.0166618749499321, -0.049107301980257034, 0.016594069078564644, -0.031055789440870285, -0.005067276768386364, -0.0021434093359857798, -0.03164665773510933, -0.05994865670800209, 0.024320323020219803, 0.028966445475816727, -0.015756001695990562, 0.018217531964182854, 0.025242211297154427, 0.012464343570172787, -0.09549718350172043, 0.05916058272123337, -0.009283656254410744, -0.00527594517916441, -0.03212340548634529, 0.015767816454172134, -0.021343670785427094, -0.021806376054883003, 0.03170283883810043, 0.023077072575688362, -0.01377057284116745, 0.009258624166250229, -0.00192566541954875, 0.0025947734247893095, -0.07351448386907578, 0.034481413662433624, -0.031930193305015564, -0.042715996503829956, -0.0031518973410129547, -0.010121329687535763, -0.007821175269782543, -0.011436652392148972, -0.0014906851574778557, 0.01544963289052248, 0.01704154536128044, -0.033260855823755264, 0.017603421583771706, 0.01891891099512577, 0.03106197901070118, 0.023788858205080032, 0.05805850401520729, 0.004639643710106611, -0.01164022646844387, 0.006059834733605385, 0.003554214956238866, -0.07530879974365234, 0.06804707646369934, 0.013300437480211258, -0.02120380476117134, 0.0045570265501737595, 0.02070951648056507, -0.03111988864839077, -0.0425327867269516, 0.004367372952401638, 0.00875732023268938, -0.03809387609362602, 0.0053303781896829605, 0.027888670563697815, 0.005986654199659824, 0.024667968973517418, -0.004214021842926741, 0.0366654247045517, -0.010540368035435677, -0.05500384792685509, -0.01631423458456993, 0.0017061553662642837, 0.014592996798455715, -0.023219391703605652, 0.018762554973363876, 0.03188121318817139, 0.02705479972064495, 0.021530495956540108, -0.03242911398410797, 0.0015324588166549802, -0.047662824392318726, -0.04762278124690056, 0.0057107023894786835, -0.008541320450603962, 0.04181423410773277, -0.005564249586313963, -0.012207363732159138, 0.033760108053684235, -0.028353717178106308, 0.040675900876522064, -0.06440974771976471, 0.003800619626417756, -0.038933105766773224, -0.020815758034586906, 0.023555481806397438, -0.006519601214677095, -0.00838739424943924, -0.01727559231221676, 0.006133421324193478, 0.030594520270824432, 0.021357964724302292, -0.008263466879725456, 0.024608084931969643, -0.011945783160626888, -0.03101527690887451, -0.052039433270692825, -0.007626700680702925, -0.018211400136351585, -0.0063253361731767654, -0.024220336228609085, 0.017894789576530457, 0.04077009856700897, 0.030707472935318947, -0.08503364026546478, 0.023317087441682816, 0.017710445448756218, -0.04330787807703018, 0.003493141382932663, -0.019524333998560905, 0.03902136906981468, 0.015586283057928085, -0.06031891331076622 ]
<p>I'm looking for correlations between the answers to different questions in a survey ("umm, let's see if answers to question 11 correlate with those of question 78"). All answers are categorical (most of them range from "very unhappy" to "very happy"), but a few have a different set of answers. Most of them can be considered ordinal so let's consider this case here.</p> <p>Since I don't have access to a commercial statistics program, I must use R.</p> <p>I tried <a href="http://rattle.togaware.com/">Rattle</a> (a freeware data mining package for R, very nifty) but unfortunately it doesn't support categorical data. One hack I could use is to import in R the coded version of the survey which has numbers (1..5) instead of "very unhappy" ... "happy" and let Rattle believe they are numerical data.</p> <p>I was thinking to do a scatter plot and have the dot size proportional to the number of numbers for each pair. After some googling I found <a href="http://www.r-statistics.com/2010/04/correlation-scatter-plot-matrix-for-ordered-categorical-data/">http://www.r-statistics.com/2010/04/correlation-scatter-plot-matrix-for-ordered-categorical-data/</a> but it seems very complicated (to me).</p> <p>I'm not a statistician (but a programmer) but have had some reading in the matter and, if I understand correctly, <em>Spearman's rho</em> would be appropriate here. </p> <p>So the short version of the question for those in a hurry: <strong>is there a way to quickly plot Spearman's rho in R</strong>? A plot is preferable to a matrix of numbers because it's easier to eye ball and also can be included in materials.</p> <p>Thank you in advance. </p> <p>PS I pondered for a while whether to post this on the main SO site or here. After searching both sites for R correlation, I felt this site is better suited for the question.</p>
73,502
[ -0.06329181045293808, 0.003540751989930868, 0.03602052852511406, -0.026113256812095642, 0.0028417909052222967, -0.02395668439567089, -0.006019826978445053, 0.010982977226376534, 0.025763487443327904, -0.024312488734722137, 0.037945084273815155, 0.040903523564338684, 0.015382773242890835, 0.06688376516103745, 0.00959542952477932, 0.014371806755661964, -0.003233094932511449, -0.008419523015618324, -0.017642784863710403, -0.01071694865822792, 0.03472641855478287, -0.019033189862966537, 0.01712406426668167, -0.0024099270813167095, -0.022975416854023933, 0.08735625445842743, 0.0290648452937603, -0.03592964634299278, 0.009259219281375408, 0.02720213308930397, -0.058027736842632294, -0.020455002784729004, 0.02239195629954338, 0.010773713700473309, 0.032243773341178894, 0.0025826466735452414, 0.022223735228180885, 0.03143154829740524, -0.01610873080790043, 0.0009005600004456937, -0.01541662123054266, 0.0018805096624419093, 0.000040531533159082755, 0.025271063670516014, -0.002432073000818491, 0.02268860675394535, 0.002640793565660715, -0.02987504191696644, 0.04858144000172615, -0.030944913625717163, 0.07779920101165771, 0.02437659166753292, -0.003211114089936018, 0.04037249833345413, -0.0296739861369133, -0.01793377473950386, 0.04506863281130791, 0.045079417526721954, -0.007592393551021814, -0.049291424453258514, 0.010241366922855377, -0.02653694525361061, -0.018431950360536575, -0.006511501502245665, -0.009493399411439896, 0.03437255695462227, 0.0004659293917939067, 0.0069680362939834595, 0.04897666722536087, -0.06661001592874527, 0.012489024549722672, 0.009742168709635735, 0.0626830905675888, -0.028993312269449234, 0.020618531852960587, -0.06730790436267853, 0.017014747485518456, 0.013655471615493298, 0.04683087021112442, 0.06378436088562012, 0.000607248570304364, 0.027063213288784027, 0.027982426807284355, 0.030785368755459785, 0.0061144838109612465, -0.03160719573497772, 0.07920850813388824, -0.022648736834526062, -0.025677988305687904, 0.019439762458205223, 0.0011825131950899959, -0.005755440331995487, 0.06253639608621597, 0.06564309448003769, -0.031848564743995667, -0.003070433158427477, -0.019993441179394722, -0.0003226424159947783, -0.007970419712364674, -0.003689688164740801, -0.022406524047255516, -0.028069529682397842, 0.0043724714778363705, 0.022084584459662437, -0.034722812473773956, -0.030710691586136818, -0.013934007845818996, -0.014154912903904915, -0.010524928569793701, -0.03903121128678322, -0.004227282013744116, 0.03516880422830582, 0.019002685323357582, 0.005022907163947821, -0.005032713990658522, -0.04946034401655197, 0.006728983484208584, 0.0017693310510367155, 0.07680211216211319, 0.08918049186468124, 0.014146857894957066, -0.011255132034420967, 0.01655697450041771, -0.029349276795983315, -0.03706036135554314, -0.01033821515738964, 0.024400025606155396, -0.008634061552584171, -0.010606263764202595, 0.055700045078992844, -0.029634660109877586, -0.015461129136383533, 0.050693463534116745, -0.01670764945447445, 0.044617678970098495, 0.03768457472324371, -0.08278755843639374, -0.04788694158196449, 0.0217566080391407, 0.025291934609413147, -0.028025032952427864, -0.050152476876974106, 0.030471835285425186, 0.024902502074837685, -0.003069940721616149, 0.03765193372964859, 0.015308516100049019, 0.003590641776099801, 0.04188190773129463, 0.050881803035736084, -0.013597598299384117, 0.0234702005982399, -0.02763121761381626, -0.04741579294204712, -0.019972193986177444, -0.05389196053147316, 0.007165027316659689, 0.014880902133882046, 0.033836666494607925, 0.0022088175173848867, 0.011752257123589516, 0.06158954277634621, 0.0013761731097474694, 0.001039845054037869, -0.005606542807072401, 0.017939478158950806, 0.04939284920692444, -0.031966883689165115, 0.009955485351383686, -0.007312824483960867, -0.026238132268190384, 0.008205554448068142, 0.03196335211396217, 0.01881876215338707, 0.03245674818754196, -0.008824396878480911, 0.012560485862195492, -0.011419713497161865, -0.009239621460437775, 0.0100387092679739, -0.03566808998584747, -0.021430006250739098, -0.03027910739183426, -0.0702551007270813, 0.020742254331707954, 0.05038878321647644, -0.0035636986140161753, -0.009267723187804222, 0.04702358320355415, -0.0367136225104332, -0.07398328185081482, -0.045290086418390274, -0.002202765317633748, -0.024540657177567482, -0.026996109634637833, 0.033083222806453705, 0.03056657873094082, 0.004234940744936466, 0.025699051097035408, -0.024750474840402603, -0.004548991564661264, -0.01118159107863903, 0.04308458790183067, -0.022478673607110977, -0.0008260231697931886, 0.038517847657203674, 0.03807555511593819, -0.04787112772464752, 0.007865591906011105, -0.02264595963060856, -0.028048699721693993, -0.009049556218087673, -0.024580631405115128, 0.03397958353161812, -0.0008071378688327968, -0.004409989807754755, 0.024256065487861633, 0.03968524932861328, -0.03781357407569885, 0.017590349540114403, -0.041935089975595474, 0.048061929643154144, 0.048592228442430496, -0.014963541179895401, 0.0015239018248394132, 0.019966688007116318, 0.01596955768764019, 0.005756337661296129, -0.030819633975625038, -0.00198438111692667, -0.024957722052931786, -0.011858604848384857, 0.060778260231018066, 0.058615412563085556, -0.026649340987205505, 0.009298648685216904, 0.050738558173179626, 0.011927983723580837, -0.04261530935764313, 0.040445853024721146, -0.013145528733730316, -0.03269480541348457, 0.0035494095645844936, -0.00973942968994379, -0.000014739683138031978, 0.009008683264255524, -0.006658507045358419, -0.007059265393763781, 0.04497745633125305, 0.015672560781240463, -0.025628499686717987, 0.019437052309513092, -0.024961242452263832, -0.015270836651325226, -0.0007561981328763068, -0.010635429993271828, 0.06149091199040413, -0.007014183327555656, 0.008901541121304035, 0.05442996323108673, -0.008329902775585651, -0.020012009888887405, 0.02824832871556282, 0.008996173739433289, -0.023078395053744316, 0.07143659144639969, -0.03402623161673546, 0.01654105819761753, 0.00715042045339942, -0.048203710466623306, 0.014939798042178154, -0.029957307502627373, -0.011172658763825893, -0.02117852494120598, 0.008983122184872627, 0.0304166991263628, 0.03161592409014702, 0.023779084905982018, -0.01609952561557293, -0.008012484759092331, 0.0009288793080486357, -0.02215925231575966, 0.024951070547103882, 0.020758751779794693, -0.05297261103987694, -0.020709799602627754, -0.028449367731809616, -0.031049519777297974, 0.01140823494642973, -0.0017458556685596704, -0.03706306964159012, 0.08482950180768967, 0.028561081737279892, -0.08150134235620499, -0.006862104404717684, -0.006736050359904766, 0.005464265123009682, -0.05651003494858742, -0.008347422815859318, 0.02013208717107773, -0.019330646842718124, -0.048367731273174286, -0.024666668847203255, -0.029502563178539276, -0.047119349241256714, -0.010335901752114296, -0.008078980259597301, 0.03396790474653244, -0.00310129183344543, -0.017819538712501526, -0.0030435833614319563, 0.0003931936516892165, -0.031586263328790665, -0.07729629427194595, -0.05889638140797615, 0.02485136315226555, 0.012007392942905426, 0.04360518977046013, 0.003833656432107091, -0.02132132463157177, 0.07153952121734619, 0.023079346865415573, -0.03159813955426216, -0.06573078781366348, -0.0013119765790179372, 0.00866330973803997, -0.00391464913263917, 0.025459591299295425, 0.050379082560539246, 0.06074243783950806, -0.0011084835277870297, -0.009745841845870018, 0.05449864640831947, 0.020080694928765297, -0.01757609099149704, 0.024447361007332802, 0.025393985211849213, -0.007946251891553402, -0.032246317714452744, 0.020304644480347633, 0.014048246666789055, -0.026310382410883904, -0.0018972099060192704, -0.021369867026805878, -0.009473467245697975, -0.00040705272112973034, -0.05225233733654022, 0.004980767611414194, -0.003830653615295887, 0.010348702780902386, -0.03595361486077309, 0.006097974721342325, 0.027978437021374702, -0.03868072107434273, -0.03597773239016533, 0.06325988471508026, 0.04360610991716385, -0.04095066338777542, 0.003479953855276108, 0.08506964892148972, 0.05189400911331177, -0.024419503286480904, 0.03258495777845383, 0.017754007130861282, -0.0044753458350896835, 0.04466424882411957, -0.07841702550649643, 0.007142418529838324, 0.03874904289841652, 0.04049470275640488, 0.028868600726127625, -0.00024986552307382226, -0.03727607801556587, 0.05064563825726509, -0.0398116260766983, -0.010791128501296043, -0.056808002293109894, 0.027423115447163582, -0.007361439988017082, 0.08132394403219223, 0.0109432777389884, 0.0022552283480763435, 0.01431206613779068, -0.006548208184540272, -0.028142046183347702, 0.028451330959796906, -0.010102776810526848, 0.013863465748727322, 0.03380812704563141, -0.03402768820524216, -0.010112040676176548, -0.007909074425697327, 0.009325552731752396, 0.014896774664521217, 0.043133918195962906, -0.026723332703113556, 0.001983992289751768, -0.038759034126996994, -0.01404661312699318, 0.022466130554676056, 0.02829975076019764, -0.0013754592509940267, -0.016200874000787735, 0.03356023132801056, 0.02957317791879177, -0.015747761353850365, -0.009539147838950157, -0.007765805348753929, -0.02144245058298111, 0.0003765948349609971, 0.021999554708600044, 0.009467012248933315, 0.023262210190296173, -0.017386198043823242, 0.0384460873901844, -0.0217069610953331, 0.031027767807245255, 0.02498260699212551, -0.037778887897729874, 0.022193334996700287, -0.02336813509464264, 0.0011883379193022847, -0.007822488434612751, 0.030956871807575226, -0.0179042499512434, -0.01703939028084278, 0.05629025399684906, 0.007960375398397446, -0.042275626212358475, 0.029138753190636635, 0.05038083717226982, 0.03714541345834732, -0.005489200819283724, -0.039013300091028214, -0.00828554853796959, 0.010187070816755295, 0.009409971535205841, 0.03562047332525253, 0.01600932516157627, 0.001813850598409772, -0.00391065189614892, 0.04441891238093376, -0.01722448691725731, -0.053430087864398956, -0.021267594769597054, -0.014607789926230907, 0.02576458267867565, -0.03462770953774452, -0.04984293133020401, -0.028797021135687828, 0.019250310957431793, 0.05024257302284241, -0.01544950157403946, 0.015070484951138496, -0.10226459056138992, 0.016718383878469467, 0.03707955777645111, 0.05591900646686554, -0.052114956080913544, 0.003517650067806244, -0.042883507907390594, -0.006868869997560978, 0.03584137186408043, -0.025826074182987213, 0.03488025441765785, -0.026673266664147377, 0.01856955885887146, -0.04302500933408737, -0.027652423828840256, -0.04733340069651604, 0.027295108884572983, 0.014483517035841942, -0.0021337540820240974, 0.0058298660442233086, -0.04389169439673424, -0.05953308939933777, 0.0009557288722135127, 0.047805625945329666, 0.06451313942670822, -0.044998254626989365, 0.0032394591253250837, 0.017361929640173912, -0.026910975575447083, -0.02780686691403389, -0.04983397573232651, 0.04416249692440033, 0.023247070610523224, -0.01989334635436535, 0.09674399346113205, -0.015611501410603523, -0.010805904865264893, 0.005844773259013891, 0.0020369181875139475, -0.012832348234951496, 0.01895195059478283, -0.0013272248907014728, 0.08221174031496048, 0.011936390772461891, -0.004999031312763691, 0.03265068680047989, 0.03615378960967064, -0.0035383079666644335, 0.012002117931842804, -0.026975514367222786, -0.00589830381795764, -0.008489908650517464, -0.02812659554183483, -0.03249223157763481, 0.0010485374368727207, -0.03003833256661892, -0.002231511054560542, -0.01029124204069376, 0.006201617885380983, -0.02041870728135109, -0.0010870196856558323, 0.018838580697774887, 0.006651917472481728, -0.015035796910524368, 0.03561413288116455, 0.03307388350367546, 0.02086721733212471, 0.023803673684597015, -0.04323548451066017, 0.002808494959026575, -0.013858665712177753, -0.003732760436832905, 0.016801277175545692, -0.053143374621868134, -0.02817755937576294, -0.03468756377696991, -0.004502968862652779, 0.012185872532427311, -0.017102522775530815, 0.06335072964429855, -0.006826783996075392, 0.04060208797454834, 0.02385920099914074, -0.025639977306127548, -0.03962665796279907, 0.025225793942809105, -0.022819088771939278, 0.026716770604252815, -0.007818559184670448, 0.0350014865398407, 0.017077451571822166, -0.0158886406570673, -0.02988877147436142, -0.024481456726789474, 0.017075883224606514, -0.019674308598041534, -0.04578230157494545, -0.029428958892822266, -0.016730649396777153, -0.001628800411708653, 0.011447552591562271, 0.024078093469142914, 0.015746189281344414, -0.020029572769999504, 0.004578543361276388, -0.008967473171651363, -0.009643914178013802, 0.05909298360347748, -0.004258128814399242, -0.016277877613902092, 0.013176647014915943, 0.03405137360095978, -0.005253092385828495, 0.0033142303582280874, -0.027333682402968407, -0.0035389054100960493, -0.03831201419234276, -0.03506682440638542, 0.00460704555734992, 0.041419051587581635, -0.035018548369407654, -0.012440470047295094, -0.011022346094250679, -0.015204155817627907, 0.012773036025464535, -0.03979089856147766, 0.02042832039296627, -0.019813591614365578, 0.0007548622088506818, -0.04987635090947151, 0.01106918603181839, -0.015581396408379078, 0.0012808403698727489, -0.013720552437007427, 0.0061918399296700954, -0.04555446654558182, 0.010957499966025352, 0.06750721484422684, 0.048336826264858246, -0.025246283039450645, 0.02226397953927517, -0.016858920454978943, 0.006627029739320278, 0.011010742746293545, 0.016149263828992844, 0.015124978497624397, 0.028965217992663383, -0.0021090975496917963, -0.05516011267900467, -0.021696263924241066, -0.029884932562708855, 0.04219413176178932, 0.025409415364265442, 0.03350183740258217, 0.03845348209142685, -0.02140936814248562, -0.0004314924590289593, -0.011385058984160423, -0.023073043674230576, -0.01300837378948927, 0.029362283647060394, 0.02265029586851597, -0.0033914896193891764, 0.0031005803029984236, 0.013135502114892006, 0.05468819662928581, 0.03053387440741062, 0.057805586606264114, 0.032012633979320526, 0.024810388684272766, 0.03330979496240616, -0.03456224873661995, -0.06267684698104858, 0.008896436542272568, -0.04829495772719383, 0.0307210311293602, -0.02005712129175663, -0.06377679109573364, 0.017101014032959938, 0.011503990739583969, -0.02823939174413681, -0.04569203406572342, -0.01878526248037815, -0.04236975312232971, 0.021917186677455902, 0.007210932206362486, -0.028653986752033234, -0.00016144951223395765, 0.0028293239884078503, 0.03308108076453209, -0.024469178169965744, 0.05434161797165871, -0.030507270246744156, -0.055138759315013885, -0.025930436328053474, 0.001001292490400374, -0.04024792090058327, 0.06329936534166336, 0.010000085458159447, -0.004130358807742596, 0.025858238339424133, -0.07757355272769928, -0.008361357264220715, 0.014023852534592152, 0.04281741753220558, -0.011487642303109169, 0.07593101263046265, -0.029691291972994804, 0.01320065651088953, -0.02267567627131939, -0.027228346094489098, 0.12485849112272263, 0.04391753301024437, 0.04673360660672188, -0.04007977247238159, 0.032031863927841187, 0.035876814275979996, 0.0036008090246468782, -0.02471441589295864, -0.018975194543600082, 0.007727835793048143, -0.0006395729724317789, 0.07725951820611954, 0.056579817086458206, 0.025978809222579002, 0.019575398415327072, 0.058517299592494965, 0.01668093539774418, 0.0008443159167654812, 0.002284115646034479, 0.019368574023246765, -0.013023525476455688, 0.003445548005402088, -0.017155170440673828, 0.004548138007521629, 0.014685403555631638, -0.03045831434428692, -0.004659147001802921, 0.007275966927409172, 0.003996943589299917, -0.008492720313370228, -0.05000343173742294, 0.009315556846559048, 0.03719424828886986, -0.006461259443312883, 0.015493501909077168, 0.0044442396610975266, 0.018374701961874962, -0.02465859241783619, 0.013609415851533413, 0.02538362517952919, -0.020037075504660606, 0.001152241020463407, -0.01429031416773796, 0.018018383532762527, -0.055479053407907486, -0.019754968583583832, -0.03952671214938164, 0.0070914290845394135, -0.02058311551809311, -0.019556041806936264, -0.028093157336115837, 0.009998067282140255, 0.004125936888158321, -0.021220192313194275, -0.015538725070655346, 0.02509705349802971, 0.046045538038015366, -0.03994227200746536, -0.040674082934856415, -0.014164949767291546, -0.04082067683339119, -0.01956363208591938, 0.017564155161380768, 0.0261218398809433, -0.013329998590052128, -0.01663447730243206, -0.026971114799380302, 0.03153761103749275, 0.03897421434521675, -0.0045017339289188385, -0.007291137240827084, 0.01177084632217884, -0.029740536585450172, 0.003920080605894327, -0.014874669723212719, 0.02335633523762226, 0.03681430220603943, 0.02863115258514881, -0.037168633192777634, -0.03680892661213875, -0.01244320534169674, 0.012008074671030045, -0.014657722786068916, -0.04324626550078392, -0.02969081699848175, -0.01793585903942585, 0.01713256537914276, -0.0024499462451785803, 0.012772999703884125, 0.030862046405673027, -0.019816014915704727, 0.04177071154117584, 0.018102742731571198, -0.021948842331767082, -0.03341739997267723, 0.004136526491492987, -0.06149855628609657, -0.017212798818945885, 0.037153538316488266, 0.037625763565301895, 0.02193439193069935, -0.0466507263481617, 0.00534929521381855, -0.0025492741260677576, 0.018546974286437035, 0.012646674178540707, 0.04009971767663956, -0.05484146624803543, 0.001150558702647686, -0.01766945794224739, -0.04623037204146385, -0.02386849746108055, -0.013975822366774082, -0.07900694757699966, -0.030147992074489594, -0.022250398993492126, -0.01944146119058132, -0.006463746540248394, 0.007640896365046501, -0.037745434790849686, -0.005987023934721947, -0.019777217879891396, -0.0068801408633589745, -0.06599873304367065, -0.00973531138151884, -0.025949981063604355, 0.019843649119138718, -0.02837473340332508, 0.037572089582681656, -0.004575876984745264, 0.04788653925061226, 0.016889316961169243, 0.02194773033261299, 0.028958478942513466, 0.012623787857592106, 0.016786178573966026, 0.040825944393873215, 0.047503937035799026, -0.007717873435467482, -0.02299838326871395, 0.012790507636964321, -0.04051074758172035, -0.028019681572914124, -0.005255439784377813, -0.021180840209126472, -0.0070691523142158985, 0.028062589466571808, -0.025081807747483253, -0.003029233543202281, 0.0677984207868576, -0.04567185044288635, -0.019856227561831474, -0.028778724372386932, 0.022536788135766983, 0.009622165001928806, -0.00808892771601677, -0.014891907572746277, -0.004204155411571264, -0.0057511115446686745, 0.027055207639932632, 0.059976235032081604, -0.01990305259823799, 0.008667059242725372, 0.008207731880247593, -0.021888021379709244, 0.004487412981688976, -0.0322381816804409, -0.0128829600289464, 0.009230762720108032, 0.06231219321489334, -0.05075782164931297, 0.03033112920820713, 0.015587997622787952, 0.003330000676214695, -0.07775932550430298, -0.031534697860479355, 0.00018176290905103087, 0.018176337704062462, 0.031251560896635056, -0.050975602120161057, -0.016005873680114746, -0.002255945233628154, -0.08105600625276566, 0.057356204837560654, 0.023547329008579254, -0.01833522692322731, -0.02162707783281803, 0.022736983373761177, -0.012253563851118088, 0.01227744109928608, 0.0297712329775095, 0.03514091670513153, 0.0191327054053545, 0.04487775266170502, -0.02958419732749462, 0.007412462495267391, -0.01885722391307354, 0.035085342824459076, 0.04490051046013832, -0.06470505893230438, 0.033865682780742645, -0.03880222141742706, 0.01962565816938877, 0.00906774215400219, -0.0010096491314470768, 0.01863560825586319, 0.052205879241228104, 0.04368502274155617, -0.03154142200946808, 0.059398215264081955, 0.011744341813027859, -0.04621027782559395, -0.045681048184633255, 0.003129010321572423, 0.018745560199022293, 0.018654579296708107, -0.006851318292319775, 0.02576635219156742, 0.044370051473379135, 0.012458554469048977, -0.0022233992349356413, 0.009489730931818485, -0.03679884597659111, 0.03248266875743866, 0.008498497307300568, -0.02347067929804325, -0.004224077332764864, -0.0024072935339063406, 0.027741992846131325, -0.046471625566482544, -0.0004208431055303663, 0.004707354586571455, -0.005946799647063017, -0.003906965721398592, 0.023102711886167526, -0.013013330288231373, -0.022971848025918007, -0.01732209324836731, -0.006806042045354843, -0.011316297575831413, -0.06761685013771057, 0.000331091316184029, -0.03810090571641922, 0.019495047628879547, -0.013867572881281376, 0.013726509176194668, -0.0031052781268954277, 0.08186714351177216, 0.002542888280004263, -0.010574358515441418, -0.017310036346316338, -0.042689740657806396, 0.04069359973073006, -0.06932153552770615, 0.02550654672086239, 0.05594596639275551, 0.005254654213786125, -0.029070662334561348, 0.008311119861900806, -0.028821595013141632, 0.029738372191786766, 0.02119670808315277, -0.009056957438588142, -0.0030444436706602573, -0.0014908743323758245, 0.01077093556523323, 0.02030513808131218, -0.04176376014947891, 0.03645487129688263, 0.012887091375887394, 0.007951389998197556, -0.009144727140665054, 0.026178471744060516, 0.048459164798259735, -0.01652735471725464, 0.018964458256959915, -0.05593717098236084, 0.004199405200779438, -0.004366799723356962, -0.04945451766252518, 0.017369255423545837, 0.00027907456387765706, -0.007304497994482517, 0.02797873504459858, -0.0028675522189587355, -0.027025364339351654, 0.021957116201519966, 0.008518409915268421, -0.014025839045643806, 0.025644095614552498, -0.030845049768686295, -0.020650368183851242, -0.0019698883406817913, 0.04038023576140404, 0.004866246599704027, -0.08909953385591507, 0.004325425252318382, 0.004037973005324602, 0.009709649719297886, -0.022421203553676605, 0.0022193877957761288, 0.008308717049658298, 0.04300953075289726, 0.045286521315574646, 0.03807257488369942, -0.014152474701404572, -0.06366021931171417, 0.011156761087477207, -0.01362750492990017, 0.02627221867442131, 0.01691203936934471, -0.000038535345083801076, 0.03972194716334343, -0.014102454297244549, 0.005990271922200918, 0.010044329799711704, 0.029912088066339493, 0.0002646962529979646, -0.026533646509051323, 0.05307433381676674, -0.011106419377028942, 0.021426353603601456, 0.044190485030412674, 0.0021614283323287964, 0.052189216017723083, -0.03567953035235405, 0.01849626563489437, -0.04898262396454811, -0.006686058826744556, -0.05499592795968056, -0.004405247047543526, -0.00896250270307064, -0.0033766538836061954, -0.004976952448487282, 0.03086346574127674, -0.005253307521343231, -0.01047834288328886, 0.03482190892100334, -0.030153444036841393, -0.0008707760134711862, 0.02029530704021454, -0.008981996215879917, -0.010496961884200573, -0.0016130595467984676, -0.030921079218387604, -0.03453649580478668, 0.055767130106687546, 0.00558875035494566, -0.04529524967074394, -0.021026695147156715, 0.013281356543302536, -0.021486714482307434, 0.0366404689848423, -0.050475310534238815, -0.05250193178653717, -0.07018405199050903, 0.024948880076408386, 0.013725047931075096, -0.007457262370735407 ]
<p>I would like to have a reality check of my understanding of the MH statistic. I have been trying to reproduce an example of the Mantel-Haenszel test provided in Conover (1999, p. 192-194). The data is structured as other examples provided for the procedure in R.</p> <p>The statistic produces is the $T_{4}$ value, which is described as approximately normal when $H_{0}$ is true. Conover describes $T_{4}$ as:</p> <hr> <p>$$ T_{4} = \frac{\sum x_{i} - \sum{\frac{r_{i}\cdot c_{i}}{N_{i}}}}{\sqrt{\sum{\frac{r_{i}c_{i}(N_{i} - r_{i})(N_{i}- c_{i})} {N^2_{i} (N_{i}-1 ) }} }} $$</p> <hr> <p>The specification of the example on p. 194 is below:</p> <pre><code>cancer.in &lt;- array(c(10,12,1,1,9,11,0,1,8,7,0,3), dim = c(2,2,3), dimnames = list(status = c("treat", "control"), outcome = c("success", "failure"), group = c("group-1", "group-2", "group-3"))) cancer &lt;- as.table(cancer.in) cancer ##### continuity correction applied mantelhaen.test(cancer) ##### no correction applied mantelhaen.test(cancer, correct = FALSE) </code></pre> <p>When examining the structure of the table, it seems to follow the example in the text, but the statistic provided does not match. Conover gets at $T_{4}$ value of $\frac{1.6786 }{1.1719} = 1.4323 $. The $\chi^{2}$ value that is returned in R is 2.0515 (without continuity correction), which equals the value $T_{4}^2$ . </p> <p>From what I understand, $z^2$ is distributed $\chi^{2}_{1}$, so the methods are producing the same results, but represented in a different way.</p> <p>Am I on the right track with this?</p> <p>Any guidance is greatly appreciated.</p>
35,898
[ -0.00461242813616991, -0.01704530604183674, 0.04154851287603378, 0.006278390064835548, 0.04654914513230324, 0.01907336339354515, 0.008782615885138512, -0.0034577136393636465, -0.0014506303705275059, -0.011915016919374466, 0.07276798039674759, 0.022534554824233055, 0.055001210421323776, 0.019144592806696892, 0.014764436520636082, 0.016363561153411865, -0.024971306324005127, 0.012621361762285233, -0.012672537006437778, -0.009904344566166401, 0.032545242458581924, 0.042533643543720245, -0.02242182567715645, -0.011091401800513268, 0.010127809830009937, 0.022734832018613815, -0.0076016453094780445, -0.00901711918413639, -0.014696464873850346, 0.048032816499471664, -0.07541793584823608, -0.03517015650868416, -0.0020697813015431166, -0.018118683248758316, -0.012670500203967094, 0.020544182509183884, 0.01859113946557045, -0.04451988264918327, 0.023675043135881424, 0.053992945700883865, 0.0007487541879527271, -0.04683450981974602, 0.02236291579902172, 0.05801214650273323, -0.00043968597310595214, 0.023981554433703423, 0.01246507279574871, -0.017224302515387535, 0.01848340779542923, -0.01411531027406454, 0.05789612606167793, -0.022162191569805145, 0.02080387994647026, -0.004461054690182209, -0.06672602891921997, 0.010732978582382202, 0.027490248903632164, 0.06254006922245026, 0.0022738142870366573, -0.055967219173908234, -0.03161653131246567, -0.050296682864427567, -0.005797239486128092, -0.0035086378920823336, -0.0275186225771904, -0.019206633791327477, -0.0006708696018904448, -0.0038519292138516903, 0.022018881514668465, -0.0017813955200836062, 0.01694616861641407, 0.00023133191280066967, 0.016325244680047035, -0.02803768217563629, 0.006256920285522938, -0.0322926826775074, -0.010538270696997643, 0.002612111624330282, 0.018679669126868248, -0.0015086777275428176, 0.02016189694404602, 0.01958318054676056, 0.013019771315157413, 0.023746341466903687, -0.016326652839779854, -0.004808597266674042, 0.04012605547904968, -0.01304609328508377, 0.05016641318798065, 0.030864262953400612, -0.003333554370328784, 0.047574691474437714, 0.02710156887769699, 0.027518680319190025, -0.03982324153184891, 0.046767573803663254, -0.022895822301506996, 0.01760556921362877, -0.051248785108327866, -0.002784781390801072, 0.009340616874396801, -0.03670509532094002, 0.027234181761741638, 0.006089130882173777, -0.029269473627209663, -0.03139040246605873, -0.0507371686398983, 0.005215940065681934, -0.015935666859149933, 0.001980838365852833, -0.0446704626083374, 0.05410666763782501, -0.0033293222077190876, -0.02843845635652542, 0.010647756047546864, -0.026324255391955376, -0.02159672975540161, 0.014193694107234478, 0.036260925233364105, 0.03595207259058952, 0.013129626400768757, -0.020901452749967575, 0.05916891619563103, -0.03165459632873535, -0.08054956048727036, 0.001795966294594109, 0.020029397681355476, -0.014802846126258373, -0.019801927730441093, 0.021537477150559425, 0.03865337744355202, -0.027970729395747185, 0.06242122873663902, 0.015922674909234047, 0.04171545431017876, -0.007258184254169464, -0.06763080507516861, -0.029683426022529602, 0.05138252675533295, -0.003296742681413889, -0.015499421395361423, -0.038157474249601364, -0.020051954314112663, 0.027493856847286224, 0.062105387449264526, -0.02395952120423317, 0.03658851981163025, 0.007447058334946632, 0.036834415048360825, 0.028373409062623978, -0.01729244738817215, 0.024130448698997498, -0.017448395490646362, -0.026737336069345474, -0.03280172497034073, -0.08450639992952347, 0.03229431062936783, 0.03355042263865471, 0.025349384173750877, 0.019822897389531136, 0.017290841788053513, 0.02935333549976349, 0.00227698334492743, -0.022649364545941353, -0.041141118854284286, 0.03463943302631378, 0.054048459976911545, 0.009364954195916653, -0.010317363776266575, 0.02473990060389042, -0.027632610872387886, 0.059944119304418564, 0.0011486629955470562, 0.05027671530842781, 0.021141545847058296, -0.039835378527641296, 0.02321895956993103, -0.0051152971573174, -0.032412540167570114, 0.0028263130225241184, -0.0621832050383091, -0.013701324351131916, -0.017677810043096542, -0.0032944949343800545, 0.05779483914375305, 0.011883793398737907, -0.011738800443708897, 0.0005033466732129455, 0.05142982676625252, -0.044223200529813766, -0.04551223665475845, -0.05765760317444801, -0.01952699013054371, -0.03144903481006622, -0.05874861031770706, 0.009750124998390675, -0.02629151940345764, -0.007838132791221142, 0.031521037220954895, 0.0108028007671237, -0.016364965587854385, -0.003830118104815483, 0.04655192792415619, -0.0302203930914402, -0.0014644898474216461, 0.054356642067432404, 0.05764395743608475, 0.058702584356069565, 0.01674290932714939, -0.05755624547600746, -0.029044102877378464, 0.015271281823515892, -0.000919900368899107, 0.003948333207517862, 0.016061389818787575, 0.006969267502427101, -0.013967081904411316, -0.03598416596651077, -0.011791507713496685, 0.03730835020542145, -0.052742280066013336, 0.007415411993861198, 0.05334257706999779, 0.01810474693775177, 0.010345454327762127, -0.041464030742645264, -0.03348330035805702, -0.008988970890641212, -0.011297889053821564, -0.007513706106692553, -0.03133758530020714, -0.025506731122732162, 0.00629571545869112, 0.020976344123482704, -0.024158436805009842, 0.007007488049566746, 0.053929124027490616, 0.011593217961490154, 0.018422581255435944, 0.050191059708595276, -0.013170077465474606, -0.06589175760746002, 0.032319076359272, -0.027491137385368347, -0.004218605812638998, 0.01531795784831047, 0.007959985174238682, -0.008224421180784702, 0.03891097381711006, 0.004325205460190773, 0.015554243698716164, 0.03660524636507034, -0.03216463699936867, 0.023188987746834755, -0.04728514328598976, -0.02246234379708767, 0.020931698381900787, 0.005953580141067505, 0.0016814467962831259, 0.03559158742427826, 0.018854068592190742, -0.028315063565969467, -0.028727328404784203, -0.006930485833436251, 0.012260238640010357, 0.021783003583550453, -0.04759407415986061, -0.0024031323846429586, 0.0010414680000394583, -0.05036729946732521, 0.03593975678086281, -0.0684879869222641, -0.03524099290370941, -0.04523211345076561, -0.005259739700704813, 0.014450724236667156, 0.018491413444280624, 0.004160283599048853, -0.027699396014213562, 0.02823467366397381, 0.016512976959347725, -0.013503855094313622, 0.03305022418498993, -0.0039375703781843185, -0.04032224044203758, -0.05933447554707527, -0.01915241964161396, 0.01211805921047926, 0.037054188549518585, 0.044231221079826355, -0.06106497719883919, 0.04078754782676697, 0.02991527132689953, -0.026654887944459915, -0.0300617516040802, -0.03045336715877056, -0.01578197069466114, -0.015732329338788986, -0.02972179651260376, 0.05051729455590248, 0.015452411025762558, -0.009107292629778385, 0.05336558073759079, -0.025647930800914764, 0.0005516764940693974, -0.020608708262443542, -0.025150809437036514, 0.00356348161585629, 0.015456829220056534, 0.004367556422948837, -0.012346572242677212, -0.011523175053298473, 0.02068171836435795, -0.05912376567721367, -0.06655692309141159, -0.00042732470319606364, 0.017642589285969734, 0.025334183126688004, 0.0021642239298671484, -0.005103359930217266, 0.08650969713926315, 0.0058415550738573074, -0.042945746332407, -0.027159636840224266, 0.020599938929080963, -0.07706887274980545, 0.0058593288995325565, 0.030841566622257233, 0.02369365282356739, 0.030507847666740417, -0.002900047693401575, -0.002402869751676917, 0.03607940301299095, 0.05643530189990997, -0.010927356779575348, 0.01164174173027277, 0.022420011460781097, 0.004230037331581116, -0.017448673024773598, 0.040999703109264374, 0.00998462364077568, 0.001801053062081337, 0.017031008377671242, -0.00223929644562304, -0.0016256861854344606, -0.013641607016324997, -0.0525069460272789, 0.024418069049715996, 0.0017418095376342535, 0.030993402004241943, -0.02787010557949543, 0.04643053561449051, 0.010141364298760891, -0.030924243852496147, -0.018976708874106407, -0.010949687100946903, 0.08189663290977478, -0.06257475912570953, 0.04187474772334099, 0.027847152203321457, 0.004974472802132368, 0.0018091941019520164, 0.014685185626149178, 0.051143452525138855, -0.005097200628370047, 0.014976120553910732, -0.04710863158106804, -0.043364230543375015, 0.010845177806913853, 0.036186497658491135, 0.0025152675807476044, -0.009216656908392906, -0.014349423348903656, 0.045372165739536285, -0.015972135588526726, -0.005137553438544273, -0.02197524718940258, 0.025120213627815247, -0.011519833467900753, 0.05573805794119835, -0.006798743270337582, -0.028842713683843613, 0.01986035145819187, -0.002587761962786317, -0.05661584809422493, 0.005737005267292261, -0.01676207222044468, -0.008936681784689426, 0.012165158987045288, -0.048943594098091125, 0.035769667476415634, 0.032925382256507874, 0.014668246731162071, 0.008623623289167881, -0.01451491005718708, -0.03022976778447628, 0.04532076418399811, -0.008468390442430973, 0.009989198297262192, -0.01224450021982193, -0.023551983758807182, 0.03469391167163849, 0.03479974716901779, -0.0076367235742509365, 0.05017285421490669, -0.001932963146828115, 0.015249108895659447, -0.018352407962083817, -0.004231119062751532, 0.04879307374358177, -0.0010493779554963112, 0.027945056557655334, 0.01574942097067833, -0.0467684380710125, 0.014175385236740112, 0.013336118310689926, 0.04522131383419037, 0.06926874816417694, -0.004108377732336521, 0.01598607376217842, -0.006465541664510965, 0.020717496052384377, 0.009015916846692562, 0.0123633136972785, 0.03836318850517273, 0.022767983376979828, 0.06869781017303467, 0.036583878099918365, -0.019016269594430923, 0.010968211106956005, 0.03210236877202988, 0.039965756237506866, -0.004643592983484268, -0.04074980318546295, 0.011422282084822655, -0.003994897939264774, 0.004256021697074175, 0.05593155696988106, 0.039712708443403244, 0.017241572961211205, 0.004492270760238171, 0.06728875637054443, -0.0012399889528751373, -0.052624087780714035, -0.00637507950887084, 0.019010595977306366, -0.0007981642847880721, -0.0034390203654766083, -0.009493296034634113, 0.03615079075098038, 0.020344926044344902, 0.020182814449071884, 0.010504381731152534, 0.014982211403548717, -0.06637424975633621, -0.022268999367952347, 0.03502640873193741, 0.04375537857413292, -0.01788155362010002, -0.009451515972614288, -0.07335662841796875, 0.003826925763860345, 0.010936460457742214, -0.03962564095854759, 0.04457198828458786, -0.046218425035476685, 0.033288441598415375, -0.03635859489440918, -0.04365439713001251, -0.03319081291556358, -0.015456946566700935, -0.03861010819673538, 0.0027349551673978567, -0.01419333927333355, -0.019916044548153877, -0.015757834538817406, -0.044961076229810715, -0.0008343735826201737, 0.04341711476445198, -0.047891765832901, -0.026087027043104172, 0.03357892483472824, 0.002034206176176667, -0.011834651231765747, -0.012276353314518929, 0.008730655536055565, -0.0039146048948168755, 0.010886754840612411, 0.044775936752557755, -0.0005844322149641812, -0.009198198094964027, 0.0024837306700646877, 0.05259525403380394, 0.0037285846192389727, -0.015610684640705585, -0.028020933270454407, 0.038435835391283035, 0.03819919005036354, -0.03879993408918381, 0.0653090551495552, 0.009302342310547829, -0.01304081454873085, 0.017835799604654312, -0.06293562054634094, -0.021252576261758804, -0.03332336246967316, -0.02029741182923317, -0.07403790950775146, 0.0105705251917243, 0.042395226657390594, 0.025356829166412354, 0.012202355079352856, 0.022458160296082497, -0.007356931921094656, 0.002674075309187174, 0.060616616159677505, 0.03283150866627693, -0.029950102791190147, 0.001141879940405488, -0.023073354735970497, -0.012703345157206059, -0.002092198468744755, -0.01970744878053665, 0.06324929744005203, -0.03983454778790474, -0.0038762600161135197, 0.03277788683772087, -0.06701879948377609, -0.0019474676810204983, -0.02188843861222267, -0.03369887173175812, -0.005389664322137833, -0.014160861261188984, -0.014860960654914379, -0.016330452635884285, 0.039636045694351196, -0.03388148918747902, -0.017158593982458115, -0.0429367758333683, -0.009690044447779655, -0.011411675252020359, 0.030594730749726295, -0.029873348772525787, 0.02618938498198986, 0.05157515034079552, -0.018412165343761444, -0.04039652273058891, -0.0035714521072804928, 0.021617382764816284, 0.00887376256287098, -0.05061403289437294, -0.02316167578101158, -0.07684288173913956, -0.0007238839752972126, -0.03483685851097107, -0.0020537287928164005, 0.04494240880012512, -0.05241542309522629, -0.007397858891636133, 0.00950038805603981, 0.012165756896138191, 0.07515906542539597, -0.010629640892148018, -0.007745529990643263, 0.02603137120604515, -0.03847692161798477, -0.011987647973001003, -0.013705729506909847, -0.03848274424672127, -0.02841833047568798, -0.0077565452083945274, -0.04324318468570709, 0.003053041873499751, 0.049675311893224716, 0.0077353776432573795, -0.03913641348481178, -0.0009944485500454903, -0.014307105913758278, 0.00589411286637187, -0.06033122539520264, -0.039509039372205734, -0.040561649948358536, 0.014303608797490597, -0.02636866271495819, -0.02172478847205639, 0.021110396832227707, -0.02748401276767254, 0.020238440483808517, -0.03351441025733948, 0.0040052118711173534, 0.038082048296928406, 0.06642764806747437, -0.0056152683682739735, 0.025548744946718216, 0.004718718584626913, -0.03127184510231018, 0.02141905575990677, 0.02912231907248497, -0.02197306975722313, -0.01676757074892521, 0.05080655217170715, -0.0037061527837067842, -0.01914687268435955, -0.038960885256528854, 0.06035078316926956, 0.04653249680995941, 0.009285911917686462, 0.030646953731775284, 0.033440642058849335, -0.014600892551243305, -0.006082779262214899, -0.05930308997631073, 0.009685647673904896, 0.0035648683551698923, 0.038325462490320206, 0.019678151234984398, -0.0187903493642807, -0.006365426816046238, 0.07762066274881363, 0.017716560512781143, -0.011708060279488564, 0.026030519977211952, 0.037512701004743576, -0.02459455281496048, -0.02105930633842945, -0.02083718217909336, -0.029891937971115112, 0.023858657106757164, -0.031829457730054855, -0.0034198598004877567, -0.058088235557079315, -0.0015345774590969086, 0.01738404855132103, 0.04303034767508507, 0.003571315435692668, -0.03474678471684456, -0.019571533426642418, -0.020289476960897446, 0.03718552365899086, 0.01185848843306303, -0.04297275096178055, 0.046040114015340805, 0.006271330639719963, 0.024492057040333748, -0.0033525247126817703, 0.03963417187333107, -0.042019281536340714, -0.048526883125305176, 0.009898550808429718, 0.006975001189857721, -0.03500402718782425, 0.03166709467768669, 0.02502322755753994, -0.012908286415040493, -0.009029777720570564, -0.044632796198129654, 0.014689666219055653, 0.024939287453889847, 0.04818156734108925, -0.009367106482386589, 0.06983543932437897, -0.013270954601466656, 0.013680478557944298, -0.015271347016096115, -0.03371118754148483, 0.1531292349100113, 0.08050022274255753, 0.00377838546410203, -0.07179762423038483, 0.0007229582406580448, 0.031449779868125916, -0.010850692167878151, -0.009724338538944721, -0.008455367758870125, 0.035658255219459534, -0.04871801286935806, 0.06043168157339096, 0.06609489023685455, 0.01422256138175726, 0.04091069474816322, 0.015739083290100098, 0.011831187643110752, -0.03775344043970108, 0.016322771087288857, 0.027252880856394768, -0.006226381286978722, -0.003746290225535631, -0.020839117467403412, -0.015512818470597267, 0.032020002603530884, -0.018192889168858528, -0.042121343314647675, 0.036420900374650955, 0.012191284447908401, 0.030287085101008415, -0.03368221968412399, -0.023872599005699158, -0.0013148069847375154, -0.016198309138417244, -0.015342227183282375, -0.02770845964550972, 0.03529224544763565, -0.039958178997039795, 0.0016890134429559112, 0.05988040193915367, -0.014007044956088066, -0.0003679151413962245, 0.022104725241661072, 0.023100625723600388, -0.06546095013618469, -0.009903050027787685, -0.03569793328642845, 0.04405917972326279, -0.021830396726727486, -0.03627811372280121, 0.005178756080567837, -0.023027846589684486, -0.008624013513326645, -0.041482385247945786, 0.010051969438791275, 0.036119818687438965, 0.010002251714468002, -0.04149514436721802, 0.00062865688232705, -0.004275104496628046, -0.02168004959821701, -0.010750205256044865, 0.03552941232919693, 0.031921278685331345, -0.02878192812204361, -0.03306083008646965, -0.046359628438949585, 0.007982832379639149, -0.03285862132906914, 0.011349326930940151, -0.0004120122757740319, -0.01034974679350853, 0.0031637062784284353, -0.011951482854783535, -0.010897248983383179, 0.031065046787261963, 0.03290007635951042, 0.028246073052287102, -0.016508642584085464, -0.01195774506777525, -0.05733643099665642, 0.04890120029449463, -0.030854536220431328, -0.0015641105128452182, -0.02886025607585907, -0.02657778188586235, 0.027794651687145233, 0.05623446777462959, -0.008630411699414253, 0.025214340537786484, -0.027544138953089714, 0.04843587428331375, 0.027482517063617706, -0.022073624655604362, -0.007183792069554329, 0.01830325648188591, -0.03041519783437252, -0.016827447339892387, -0.03480019047856331, 0.05106564611196518, 0.04136228933930397, -0.020580055192112923, -0.021715344861149788, 0.041504476219415665, 0.015605783089995384, -0.016583651304244995, 0.014355611056089401, -0.029572175815701485, 0.027257131412625313, -0.01794872246682644, 0.024433841928839684, -0.008260704576969147, 0.0054596723057329655, -0.021149154752492905, -0.07934414595365524, -0.01569000445306301, -0.01289195567369461, 0.005418295040726662, -0.01612546481192112, 0.016318082809448242, -0.008243860676884651, 0.008856769651174545, -0.035561464726924896, -0.04580719396471977, 0.03008670173585415, -0.0023512535262852907, -0.018922267481684685, -0.030709803104400635, -0.01610102877020836, -0.03315901756286621, 0.020087437704205513, 0.06591353565454483, 0.03859703615307808, -0.004023544490337372, 0.0007290454814210534, -0.007155871484428644, 0.03492584452033043, 0.02228807657957077, 0.011405528523027897, 0.021897107362747192, 0.010281302034854889, -0.038577400147914886, -0.034968916326761246, -0.005894582252949476, 0.03394044563174248, 0.022142425179481506, -0.01905842497944832, -0.010314608924090862, -0.04570824280381203, 0.06109382584691048, -0.059066180139780045, 0.006622009910643101, -0.018479080870747566, 0.002836641389876604, 0.008363164961338043, -0.02776690199971199, 0.011581027880311012, 0.016162153333425522, 0.02884872630238533, 0.013591094873845577, 0.042464036494493484, 0.01363406516611576, -0.0014199329307302833, -0.044043950736522675, -0.055533792823553085, -0.006416537798941135, -0.019078874960541725, 0.011056190356612206, 0.014360137283802032, 0.05523262545466423, -0.004600148182362318, 0.04691149294376373, -0.021704332903027534, 0.015950443223118782, -0.08660668879747391, -0.06569989025592804, 0.01956176944077015, 0.0648416131734848, 0.027686990797519684, -0.024730756878852844, 0.012646723538637161, 0.007260805461555719, -0.012006732635200024, 0.068162702023983, 0.003896992187947035, 0.006596639286726713, -0.07624882459640503, 0.004918691702187061, -0.01629597879946232, 0.02322951704263687, 0.012799342162907124, -0.0030133360996842384, 0.0050257788971066475, 0.03485776111483574, -0.029146118089556694, -0.0033279077615588903, 0.007207625079900026, 0.007891833782196045, 0.019890181720256805, -0.06895750015974045, 0.014432263560593128, 0.026803653687238693, -0.04603785648941994, -0.0017260462045669556, 0.009790443815290928, 0.036595266312360764, -0.003045513993129134, 0.03519054874777794, 0.021819010376930237, 0.04910024628043175, -0.0029277903959155083, -0.0048013669438660145, -0.0031623132526874542, -0.014181327074766159, 0.059665173292160034, 0.018017379567027092, 0.009206877090036869, 0.009976673871278763, 0.05645360052585602, -0.005577698815613985, -0.01550865639001131, 0.028220465406775475, -0.018407847732305527, 0.007205532863736153, 0.003616215195506811, -0.014120465144515038, 0.037142131477594376, -0.03919392079114914, 0.0060598463751375675, -0.03473898768424988, 0.007161226123571396, 0.06280054152011871, 0.048561498522758484, -0.004654817283153534, 0.015932844951748848, 0.026338675990700722, -0.048899322748184204, 0.00536698754876852, 0.010012340731918812, -0.01009298861026764, -0.04993953928351402, 0.004464819561690092, -0.0329318568110466, 0.0009544982458464801, -0.028388358652591705, 0.009647700004279613, -0.017937807366251945, 0.024071795865893364, -0.01922735385596752, -0.025011559948325157, -0.005633097607642412, 0.017305342480540276, 0.0213310644030571, -0.05731603875756264, 0.02822360023856163, -0.0022856872528791428, -0.02237238548696041, -0.02022322453558445, -0.007621454540640116, -0.06104942411184311, -0.001169067807495594, 0.06551884859800339, 0.01713225618004799, -0.02937941811978817, -0.004060580860823393, 0.02995181828737259, -0.017182335257530212, -0.033191803842782974, 0.08102967590093613, -0.009028245694935322, 0.010184111073613167, -0.03680042549967766, 0.004391253460198641, -0.0038628617767244577, 0.016662495210766792, 0.008466442115604877, -0.053742650896310806, 0.01563817262649536, 0.018247179687023163, -0.027342692017555237, 0.02738121710717678, -0.013324934057891369, -0.04187074676156044, 0.029027551412582397, -0.03456268459558487, 0.011171157471835613, 0.05842304974794388, -0.01813027448952198, -0.06046591326594353, -0.01262657530605793, -0.02058231458067894, -0.021447869017720222, 0.020114827901124954, -0.0035750637762248516, -0.007331091444939375, -0.04363061115145683, 0.0025564345996826887, 0.0023149587213993073, -0.004223796539008617, -0.010332254692912102, 0.043333541601896286, 0.0360754057765007, 0.02211599051952362, 0.00860391091555357, 0.009982838295400143, -0.016601018607616425, -0.03374852240085602, 0.046268194913864136, 0.011166085489094257, 0.0207761749625206, 0.021385537460446358, -0.00449246633797884, 0.05252017453312874, -0.03669402375817299, -0.018165336921811104, 0.0024961193557828665, 0.04614640027284622, -0.006306242197751999, -0.015973854809999466, 0.01479985099285841, -0.07647181302309036, -0.004985304549336433, 0.0126271340996027, -0.008450161665678024, 0.052806492894887924, -0.03036658465862274, 0.032286543399095535, -0.003710500430315733, 0.005706037860363722, -0.03527141362428665, 0.0059114922769367695, 0.011192778125405312, 0.009061457589268684, 0.0007478552870452404, 0.01804540492594242, 0.00917551014572382, -0.012321818619966507, 0.018163418397307396, -0.014795531518757343, 0.027398496866226196, 0.009613149799406528, -0.02529710903763771, 0.0064799911342561245, -0.023794174194335938, -0.03853693976998329, -0.005023407284170389, 0.0026788911782205105, 0.003355802735313773, 0.0027785631828010082, -0.03636162355542183, -0.0036760405637323856, 0.00190687773283571, 0.04556090384721756, -0.04365764930844307, -0.045045893639326096, -0.005910318810492754, 0.02918902225792408, 0.032922182232141495, -0.01955992542207241 ]
<p>Let's say I have some kind of survival data - i.e. I'm giving a drug that may cause mortality. So I have three patients: A, B and C. All are given the drug at Time t1.</p> <p>Let's say patient A dies at time t2. Patient B dies at time t3. And Patient C dies at time t100.</p> <p>Clearly, the likelihood that the drug caused the death of patient A and B is higher than the likelihood that the drug cause patient C's death (i.e. patient C likely died from natural causes whereas patients A and B probably died because of the drug).</p> <p>Are there any techniques in survival analysis/related fields that allow one to quantify the probability/likelihood that the treatment caused the effect. For example, if I could calculate the probability that the treatment caused the death given that patient was treated at time X and died at time Y.</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
73,503
[ -0.01902906782925129, -0.038532279431819916, 0.004078416153788567, -0.015645897015929222, 0.04352923110127449, 0.01463454682379961, -0.0069686053320765495, 0.01344335824251175, 0.05759231373667717, -0.03644629195332527, 0.036567144095897675, 0.06728073954582214, 0.03741796687245369, -0.015813536942005157, 0.030053483322262764, 0.0020521453116089106, -0.0010459801414981484, 0.01909928023815155, 0.008872122503817081, -0.01894879899919033, 0.020356031134724617, -0.005387244746088982, 0.02176305279135704, -0.007694373372942209, -0.012319941073656082, 0.05083630979061127, 0.03259725496172905, -0.027080414816737175, -0.019960248842835426, 0.06887935101985931, -0.037701938301324844, -0.041572339832782745, 0.015772497281432152, 0.04030248522758484, 0.036345839500427246, 0.022517843171954155, -0.023659253492951393, -0.0381368026137352, -0.00912419892847538, 0.03410746902227402, -0.01687483862042427, -0.0535469613969326, -0.002820818917825818, 0.06422576308250427, -0.041545212268829346, 0.026931490749120712, -0.021778319031000137, -0.031064826995134354, 0.01757662743330002, -0.05194510146975517, 0.06309688091278076, -0.01898263767361641, 0.061339735984802246, -0.0009442302980460227, -0.027614014223217964, -0.007872181013226509, 0.04852695018053055, 0.08492320775985718, 0.004083673935383558, -0.057324379682540894, -0.0625990629196167, -0.019641321152448654, -0.00902394950389862, -0.031455978751182556, -0.016329238191246986, 0.005320938304066658, -0.017603473737835884, -0.07223597913980484, 0.05024803429841995, -0.0012373904464766383, -0.005783693864941597, 0.0018587320810183883, 0.029771825298666954, -0.002773866755887866, -0.020374812185764313, -0.013554809615015984, 0.007982885465025902, 0.001430695760063827, 0.04286361485719681, 0.005182934924960136, -0.02527875453233719, 0.003818484488874674, 0.00004206928133498877, 0.06334216892719269, -0.0018612142885103822, 0.00670654745772481, 0.06823669373989105, -0.026064783334732056, 0.035227712243795395, 0.012342519126832485, -0.052421990782022476, 0.00625983439385891, 0.015243923291563988, -0.0019944440573453903, -0.05304991453886032, 0.009863139130175114, 0.023724786937236786, 0.0649251639842987, 0.03669295832514763, 0.04888906702399254, 0.01527217123657465, -0.058514464646577835, 0.002345903078094125, 0.060052353888750076, -0.015039315447211266, -0.013264701701700687, -0.02422660030424595, -0.012879541143774986, 0.0020474742632359266, 0.010283452458679676, -0.025221846997737885, 0.0433233343064785, 0.0282653346657753, -0.0083898501470685, -0.019421657547354698, -0.02376873604953289, -0.04501110315322876, -0.01774260215461254, 0.07472072541713715, 0.04016419127583504, 0.05342946946620941, -0.02697230875492096, 0.039754945784807205, -0.002002732129767537, -0.03534659370779991, -0.013236642815172672, 0.028372403234243393, -0.01985461823642254, -0.0194579865783453, 0.053374994546175, 0.01984805054962635, -0.031323377043008804, 0.029005592688918114, -0.03115733154118061, 0.03831888362765312, -0.03740878775715828, -0.05985559895634651, -0.02509547397494316, 0.021255047991871834, 0.0079210689291358, 0.002990603679791093, -0.019890889525413513, 0.005885130260139704, 0.021476175636053085, 0.050331469625234604, 0.01909923367202282, 0.019293395802378654, 0.008749083615839481, 0.018568042665719986, 0.010598292574286461, -0.015253148972988129, -0.0012136460281908512, 0.013124622404575348, -0.0017236857675015926, -0.03199983760714531, -0.10876736044883728, 0.002429291605949402, 0.03098478727042675, 0.006947851274162531, -0.02645237185060978, 0.04931051284074783, -0.006236806977540255, 0.003093276871368289, -0.006673621945083141, 0.004935587290674448, -0.004425074439495802, 0.07941919565200806, 0.01797579787671566, -0.001680673100054264, 0.010841757990419865, 0.0023861427325755358, 0.04697227105498314, 0.02014535292983055, 0.04670283943414688, 0.03364681825041771, -0.027279965579509735, -0.012051902711391449, 0.00009293373295804486, 0.004370236769318581, 0.024542124941945076, -0.0023953570052981377, -0.014162197709083557, -0.016883576288819313, -0.03304000943899155, 0.021888496354222298, 0.015646619722247124, 0.013444259762763977, 0.005795198027044535, 0.025353772565722466, -0.0029903058893978596, -0.01764456368982792, -0.08725161105394363, 0.011997275054454803, 0.00820531789213419, -0.023737384006381035, -0.003073940984904766, -0.006140187382698059, 0.017280666157603264, -0.05188740789890289, -0.021415991708636284, -0.014814944006502628, -0.01724722795188427, 0.01419507060199976, -0.03868107870221138, 0.012685462832450867, 0.04176497086882591, 0.046850357204675674, -0.02097577042877674, 0.03478026017546654, -0.044019728899002075, -0.0409080907702446, -0.010065432637929916, -0.01513681560754776, 0.0056034172885119915, -0.007431847508996725, -0.04224526882171631, 0.006915608886629343, -0.023580051958560944, -0.011875580996274948, 0.017505310475826263, -0.046984974294900894, 0.0713118240237236, 0.0759204849600792, 0.01224206667393446, 0.017389468848705292, 0.004720243625342846, 0.02689877524971962, -0.01745690405368805, 0.01998160220682621, -0.04423852637410164, -0.06272856891155243, -0.007090618368238211, 0.026887713000178337, 0.004685843363404274, -0.01239476166665554, 0.01428836490958929, 0.04867147281765938, 0.002228070981800556, 0.05907781049609184, 0.03384220600128174, 0.001398997730575502, -0.012013007886707783, 0.0031349435448646545, 0.0129671860486269, -0.02177499048411846, -0.016363197937607765, 0.05789151415228844, 0.015837635844945908, 0.029961097985506058, -0.01809711940586567, -0.043625954538583755, 0.043588995933532715, -0.0024908047635108232, 0.014775488525629044, 0.0006930717499926686, -0.020183386281132698, 0.05567927658557892, -0.03902899846434593, 0.03324837237596512, -0.0035027186386287212, 0.003875112859532237, 0.025561759248375893, 0.014492918737232685, -0.026388760656118393, 0.032550159841775894, 0.026464330032467842, -0.040395356714725494, 0.030695244669914246, 0.008181249722838402, -0.026165977120399475, -0.007166039198637009, 0.021905915811657906, -0.033149879425764084, -0.019040999934077263, 0.008210724219679832, 0.03911813348531723, 0.006680786609649658, 0.04741579666733742, 0.002123694634065032, -0.033462878316640854, 0.039767928421497345, -0.05083349347114563, -0.007216054014861584, 0.012121918611228466, -0.029666755348443985, 0.03409421071410179, -0.008889392018318176, -0.03939118608832359, 0.017565222457051277, -0.03148755058646202, -0.009612197987735271, 0.04122243449091911, -0.007786210160702467, -0.049518488347530365, -0.024353262037038803, -0.015128559432923794, 0.0247661080211401, -0.043802496045827866, -0.0026006021071225405, 0.02357674203813076, 0.011961747892200947, -0.01916901208460331, 0.03502264618873596, -0.026905672624707222, 0.008849325589835644, -0.01071495283395052, 0.027676966041326523, 0.03128866106271744, -0.02486853487789631, 0.03064621426165104, 0.01986296847462654, -0.026812685653567314, -0.02936350181698799, -0.06699355691671371, -0.054987646639347076, 0.03956057131290436, 0.006798761431127787, 0.02134811505675316, -0.0139763243496418, -0.01775422692298889, 0.06127828359603882, 0.03821878880262375, -0.029705777764320374, -0.0285367239266634, -0.037751708179712296, -0.013538045808672905, 0.028703324496746063, 0.011342613957822323, -0.03734380006790161, -0.008908743038773537, 0.018608853220939636, 0.023067325353622437, 0.013434783555567265, 0.0162880290299654, 0.010167742148041725, -0.03545619919896126, 0.02175067365169525, 0.02945752814412117, -0.0035311721730977297, 0.024308305233716965, 0.013178488239645958, -0.02975587546825409, 0.03291291370987892, -0.016932910308241844, 0.03358039632439613, -0.006047567818313837, -0.06096161901950836, -0.007283938117325306, 0.00020799381309188902, 0.0013236368540674448, -0.02093811333179474, 0.020972326397895813, -0.02800196036696434, -0.0018362716073170304, 0.01709575578570366, 0.019506748765707016, 0.04668573662638664, -0.03483176976442337, 0.0407702699303627, 0.036428745836019516, 0.06068914011120796, -0.03656182810664177, -0.04314709082245827, -0.0384635254740715, -0.0008308926480822265, 0.025165002793073654, -0.040409114211797714, -0.04886780306696892, 0.0013309713685885072, 0.03520786389708519, 0.015061159618198872, -0.00456493254750967, -0.03310875594615936, -0.010674940422177315, -0.06243705749511719, -0.016207905486226082, -0.03472290560603142, 0.07479947060346603, 0.02463470585644245, 0.02111622504889965, 0.01581110991537571, -0.020028389990329742, 0.02759547159075737, -0.022156378254294395, -0.0820692703127861, 0.0530799962580204, -0.014651423320174217, -0.023628544062376022, -0.008304077200591564, 0.017608128488063812, 0.05675327032804489, -0.01822398416697979, -0.02872772142291069, -0.02178696170449257, 0.008441540412604809, -0.038733046501874924, -0.007988838478922844, -0.03676536679267883, -0.024131622165441513, -0.027889756485819817, 0.00575815187767148, -0.011839197017252445, 0.016676103696227074, 0.027643254026770592, 0.04138284921646118, -0.03530404716730118, -0.006097979377955198, -0.03896929323673248, 0.0020792121067643166, 0.03316125646233559, 0.03267504647374153, 0.00885755941271782, 0.03224450722336769, -0.04644252359867096, 0.03329942002892494, 0.010858644731342793, 0.04427492618560791, 0.038241080939769745, 0.01490579079836607, -0.035940516740083694, -0.041407257318496704, -0.0008320201304741204, 0.005974785424768925, 0.011496136896312237, 0.027029749006032944, -0.002232982311397791, 0.05791206285357475, 0.021803997457027435, -0.06927002221345901, 0.035367950797080994, 0.024109434336423874, 0.027452632784843445, 0.0012485745828598738, -0.037619538605213165, 0.006976577453315258, 0.01618221402168274, -0.022655975073575974, -0.001298333634622395, 0.04029930755496025, -0.012342625297605991, -0.00502164987847209, 0.027326997369527817, 0.007771754637360573, -0.006768529303371906, -0.020067749544978142, 0.04154147207736969, 0.03791947290301323, 0.043482210487127304, -0.03407888859510422, 0.02828959934413433, 0.014222116209566593, 0.03242930769920349, 0.030321557074785233, 0.03396836295723915, -0.08271089941263199, 0.018137922510504723, 0.05994435399770737, 0.04998496547341347, -0.03012031875550747, -0.03239193558692932, -0.022930612787604332, -0.004006096161901951, 0.04181476682424545, -0.04841381683945656, -0.010709935799241066, -0.005908248480409384, 0.0020825446117669344, -0.0015878111589699984, -0.04837778955698013, -0.030953647568821907, 0.044076379388570786, -0.012700876221060753, 0.011277957819402218, -0.009835610166192055, 0.0025429106317460537, -0.008469244465231895, 0.02103746309876442, 0.023447256535291672, 0.04845886677503586, -0.0010189757449552417, -0.002491187071427703, -0.00541274156421423, 0.026784392073750496, -0.019211936742067337, -0.07659289240837097, 0.05120760574936867, -0.006244298070669174, -0.008951321244239807, 0.04416587948799133, -0.026535458862781525, 0.022264443337917328, 0.025765063241124153, 0.008127430453896523, -0.033697426319122314, -0.010957805439829826, 0.018794458359479904, 0.008556080982089043, 0.0349390022456646, 0.006573986727744341, 0.06317756325006485, 0.028176184743642807, 0.02566022239625454, -0.029256047680974007, -0.022241104394197464, -0.00783299095928669, -0.0263625867664814, -0.009579071775078773, -0.050370655953884125, 0.0016385329654440284, -0.015239724889397621, 0.02523939684033394, -0.016947831958532333, 0.01337023451924324, -0.010153794661164284, 0.0080931531265378, -0.003293396206572652, 0.014451075345277786, 0.025078773498535156, -0.03560856357216835, -0.026077575981616974, -0.010070922784507275, 0.014550086110830307, -0.03763869032263756, 0.010601780377328396, -0.026721255853772163, -0.011705904267728329, -0.013142934069037437, -0.04443308711051941, 0.0021571051329374313, -0.03475615382194519, -0.03610401228070259, 0.028773082420229912, 0.006621680688112974, 0.03587010130286217, -0.0138139259070158, 0.03863545507192612, -0.009361677803099155, -0.022108102217316628, -0.012832557782530785, 0.04068983718752861, 0.0031864307820796967, 0.04195499047636986, -0.04629909247159958, 0.018949517980217934, -0.003255475079640746, -0.004345535300672054, -0.07342565804719925, -0.0103011354804039, 0.04721025750041008, 0.028768301010131836, -0.040689289569854736, -0.040742043405771255, 0.01243325974792242, -0.038920242339372635, -0.009064558893442154, 0.009745161980390549, 0.047759875655174255, 0.012332597747445107, -0.02512316219508648, -0.01713322289288044, -0.004853018559515476, 0.07141730189323425, -0.003969241864979267, -0.04740316420793533, 0.01451446209102869, -0.017405224964022636, -0.015561357140541077, -0.007325892336666584, 0.017156848683953285, -0.03215143084526062, 0.006200914736837149, 0.008996592834591866, 0.007246582768857479, 0.023917464539408684, -0.02392207831144333, -0.02528279833495617, 0.012922280468046665, 0.005442654248327017, 0.04389069601893425, -0.032517727464437485, 0.004135859664529562, -0.00923826266080141, 0.016623232513666153, -0.013575217686593533, 0.0062937005423009396, -0.017656002193689346, 0.0022235119249671698, 0.011189314536750317, -0.010177278891205788, -0.030104154720902443, 0.01897980086505413, 0.012291710823774338, 0.02050185203552246, -0.0030899406410753727, -0.01994754746556282, -0.01590137556195259, 0.04790681228041649, -0.006533403880894184, -0.015903079882264137, 0.042476072907447815, 0.02462986670434475, -0.05028480291366577, -0.018293408676981926, -0.035125087946653366, 0.021422235295176506, 0.06660439074039459, -0.023278068751096725, 0.05047386884689331, 0.04778752475976944, 0.01317865401506424, -0.054802123457193375, -0.0013104435056447983, -0.005650197621434927, 0.026253553107380867, 0.00192880944814533, 0.04436914995312691, -0.049545206129550934, -0.0016690564807504416, 0.04098083823919296, 0.01252621691673994, -0.009589710272848606, 0.053202856332063675, -0.02333097904920578, 0.009232107549905777, 0.08456246554851532, -0.015534945763647556, -0.004523334559053183, 0.0588499940931797, -0.05390523374080658, -0.005080196540802717, -0.0544065497815609, -0.045445967465639114, 0.03973262384533882, 0.04985553026199341, -0.009297061711549759, -0.015034399926662445, -0.03826639801263809, -0.06594765186309814, -0.009344389662146568, 0.02640506438910961, 0.011805709451436996, 0.06979450583457947, 0.007236065808683634, 0.03602871298789978, 0.01583387702703476, 0.020857786759734154, -0.02416682243347168, -0.07629724591970444, -0.02851242758333683, -0.02426517754793167, -0.010705276392400265, -0.0005176126142032444, 0.024735355749726295, -0.012504680082201958, 0.00012378381507005543, -0.01220054179430008, 0.01023183111101389, -0.0026846143882721663, 0.040059711784124374, 0.008762633427977562, 0.07764767110347748, 0.02824069745838642, 0.02722184918820858, 0.018395492807030678, -0.003288316773250699, 0.10411759465932846, 0.08028798550367355, 0.047113724052906036, -0.05024370551109314, 0.013226727955043316, 0.018118929117918015, 0.018129929900169373, -0.032127317041158676, 0.011126290075480938, 0.029847780242562294, -0.03175642713904381, 0.032274194061756134, 0.04516832157969475, -0.004471638705581427, 0.00715525122359395, 0.0977678969502449, -0.021176403388381004, -0.038027871400117874, 0.011599427089095116, -0.011264776811003685, -0.004514280240982771, -0.042939845472574234, -0.07540058344602585, 0.04063735902309418, 0.003384785261005163, -0.04565668851137161, -0.016901325434446335, -0.003252290887758136, 0.0022928868420422077, 0.006766691338270903, -0.020910250023007393, -0.012984337285161018, 0.01956125535070896, 0.027528734877705574, -0.021599767729640007, -0.01259926799684763, 0.020447958260774612, -0.0057231355458498, 0.01278865709900856, 0.03866708651185036, 0.01619056612253189, 0.007339041214436293, -0.007922926917672157, 0.05455532670021057, -0.048989854753017426, -0.03659280762076378, -0.034430377185344696, 0.021939335390925407, -0.02531292848289013, -0.005173949059098959, -0.031066372990608215, -0.024126984179019928, 0.026765571907162666, -0.027199169620871544, -0.04940890148282051, -0.0025425769854336977, 0.022085653617978096, -0.035642433911561966, -0.0013445758959278464, -0.012451529502868652, -0.0007204969879239798, -0.023291077464818954, 0.015564868226647377, 0.04136515036225319, -0.033627379685640335, -0.02025635913014412, -0.041327930986881256, 0.020894983783364296, -0.038890860974788666, -0.0024280748330056667, 0.0009124441421590745, -0.059468403458595276, -0.02980617620050907, -0.010840733535587788, -0.0027359845116734505, -0.0009395933011546731, 0.019797738641500473, 0.002525690710172057, 0.008050699718296528, -0.0035025181714445353, -0.04047495499253273, 0.010643798857927322, -0.01833215169608593, 0.014400280080735683, -0.0349007211625576, 0.004305073991417885, 0.06184361129999161, 0.046641357243061066, -0.002972367452457547, 0.005392235238105059, -0.02906644158065319, 0.0018686202820390463, 0.006898627150803804, -0.05176932364702225, -0.00011341418576193973, -0.010093903169035912, -0.006393983960151672, -0.003067470621317625, -0.05077674984931946, 0.05448225140571594, 0.01725168339908123, -0.00003535807263688184, 0.008329478092491627, 0.018555890768766403, -0.005099957343190908, 0.021683283150196075, 0.011399254202842712, -0.07148487120866776, -0.012331785634160042, -0.017900370061397552, 0.032586470246315, 0.010201389901340008, -0.016760457307100296, -0.019808106124401093, 0.008624759502708912, 0.030672883614897728, -0.04311493784189224, 0.001818668213672936, -0.0057870736345648766, -0.02563357539474964, 0.003435749327763915, -0.02161545678973198, 0.026996854692697525, -0.024630587548017502, -0.0048122042790055275, 0.01821836642920971, -0.03683329373598099, -0.014925777912139893, -0.018584582954645157, 0.00035046765697188675, -0.011668809689581394, -0.031159982085227966, 0.0229550339281559, -0.009217380546033382, -0.028741681948304176, 0.02042941376566887, 0.004866309929639101, 0.049173351377248764, -0.02202625386416912, 0.008378604426980019, 0.040831610560417175, -0.08651204407215118, -0.027168365195393562, 0.046345192939043045, 0.010109197348356247, 0.02641337737441063, 0.03894941881299019, -0.012810383923351765, 0.0020639183931052685, 0.027963461354374886, -0.0252394899725914, -0.03511761873960495, -0.012380436062812805, 0.001611407264135778, -0.00787337776273489, 0.017652390524744987, 0.006679742597043514, 0.009657730348408222, -0.03304741531610489, 0.011314860545098782, 0.03882768005132675, 0.013988967053592205, 0.0016095828032121062, 0.01748207025229931, 0.03600939363241196, 0.019807256758213043, 0.008836810477077961, -0.009690169245004654, 0.04749910533428192, 0.06902642548084259, -0.013131584972143173, 0.04770265892148018, 0.017952805384993553, 0.01979839615523815, -0.10163753479719162, -0.0011409647995606065, -0.011435605585575104, 0.01100090891122818, 0.035012632608413696, -0.05646919831633568, 0.020122289657592773, -0.009787515737116337, -0.019359301775693893, 0.03328862413764, -0.024975119158625603, 0.01821005903184414, -0.04935736209154129, 0.014915749430656433, -0.004488508217036724, 0.059619124978780746, 0.03407122939825058, 0.011682551354169846, 0.01522547286003828, 0.029199693351984024, 0.01876813732087612, -0.01095870416611433, -0.026161808520555496, 0.023835480213165283, -0.002660797443240881, -0.07900077104568481, 0.042560700327157974, -0.045544128865003586, -0.0452539399266243, 0.018803760409355164, 0.014879679307341576, 0.018005505204200745, 0.01965167000889778, 0.01742899790406227, -0.0034526395611464977, 0.025879748165607452, 0.007775794714689255, -0.02960864268243313, 0.006203123368322849, -0.0034754693042486906, 0.0034242256078869104, 0.025935394689440727, -0.03645883873105049, 0.037999868392944336, 0.04475823789834976, -0.004371799994260073, -0.008870597928762436, 0.003526442451402545, 0.011472621001303196, -0.028152620419859886, 0.0050689526833593845, -0.040564633905887604, 0.02187604457139969, -0.033153045922517776, 0.021573413163423538, -0.03965988755226135, 0.01960357464849949, 0.050699420273303986, 0.03248166665434837, 0.011442001909017563, 0.012471574358642101, -0.03993795067071915, -0.039939865469932556, 0.03787378594279289, 0.0040463656187057495, -0.00894360151141882, -0.06341320276260376, 0.020373867824673653, -0.038593269884586334, 0.00003399213164811954, -0.04892222210764885, -0.024773769080638885, -0.04688788577914238, 0.03993069380521774, -0.03438461199402809, 0.0030446515884250402, 0.035009343177080154, 0.029625464230775833, 0.03780561313033104, -0.0776074156165123, 0.024706363677978516, -0.010492123663425446, 0.005834479816257954, -0.08000677078962326, -0.003165552159771323, -0.02338908612728119, -0.016608135774731636, 0.050135280936956406, -0.022754577919840813, -0.0013826420763507485, 0.0015690469881519675, 0.032605066895484924, -0.014960392378270626, -0.06566881388425827, 0.04242456704378128, -0.02073761261999607, -0.051073722541332245, -0.056632399559020996, 0.023948661983013153, 0.006052588578313589, -0.0014435003977268934, 0.007304858881980181, -0.04083807393908501, 0.017636559903621674, 0.01695791445672512, 0.0071744597516953945, 0.038323160260915756, 0.0042679705657064915, -0.02384449541568756, 0.049389105290174484, 0.023268921300768852, 0.013006512075662613, 0.034526534378528595, -0.03715451806783676, -0.038133952766656876, 0.04321999475359917, -0.03154393285512924, -0.025065530091524124, 0.0147920036688447, -0.043194547295570374, -0.021650783717632294, -0.05814892798662186, 0.011561291292309761, 0.008272994309663773, -0.03818769380450249, 0.04621697962284088, 0.03861374780535698, 0.011565249413251877, 0.05078734830021858, -0.03316238150000572, 0.009222661145031452, -0.017166053876280785, 0.006371761672198772, -0.012007799930870533, -0.017952345311641693, 0.021329956129193306, -0.004671442322432995, 0.02579636499285698, 0.0065168775618076324, -0.008542384952306747, -0.03619871288537979, 0.012964815832674503, 0.002477938774973154, -0.02650422230362892, 0.0016054208390414715, 0.03312564641237259, 0.0008515468798577785, 0.018036291003227234, -0.021225111559033394, -0.024156495928764343, 0.04340182617306709, -0.015926772728562355, 0.014034325256943703, -0.051431167870759964, -0.010448237881064415, -0.028254803270101547, 0.004758957773447037, 0.02408619411289692, 0.019412340596318245, -0.005514966323971748, 0.02350420132279396, 0.01682107150554657, -0.0016920407069846988, 0.024932773783802986, 0.0000058013374655274674, 0.04279930517077446, -0.040612805634737015, -0.013139769434928894, -0.033180493861436844, -0.024085605517029762, -0.022458449006080627, -0.025271698832511902, 0.004091102164238691, 0.03179903328418732, 0.07695019990205765, -0.012339843437075615, -0.024589594453573227, 0.0006898913416080177, 0.04432850331068039, -0.06954452395439148, -0.026552323251962662, -0.06683434545993805, 0.03172299638390541, -0.013787096366286278, -0.011726029217243195 ]
<p>I have a Q-learning algorithm with a finite number of states. Each state, however, is represented by the usual 32 bit Q-value. These Q-values allow to carry information about the previous experience far beyond the state of the Q-learner (in my case the state of the Q-learner is the sequence of his own choices and rewards). </p> <p>What if the Q-value could be only binary? Then Q-learner wouldn't be able to carry that information and wouldn't learn much. I am very interested in how much memory, in bits, does the Q-learner need to learn different rules. (For example. Q-learner always has two choices, 1 and 0. If he chooses 1 1 0 in a row he gets the reward.)</p> <p>However, I have problems with implementation. Q values are bounded only by experience, so how exactly do I implement the update rule for Q-value if I want to constrain that Q-value can be only one of n different values? </p> <p>My update rule Then $Q_{new} = Q_{old} + \alpha (R + \gamma * \max(Q_{future\ choice\ 1} - Q_{future\ choice\ 0}))$</p> <p>How do I now map this new value on the limited set that Q-value can be? If $\alpha = 1 , \gamma = 1; R,Q $ are elements of $\{0,1\}$ then $Q_{new}$ is element of $\{-1, 0, 1, 2\}$ And mapping is easy. But what if it's different?</p> <p>Has anybody studied that? Papers and any suggestions are appreciated.</p> <p>P.S. I am not sure that this is the best place for machine learning questions. If you know another Stack Exchange site that deals with that or any other site, please let me know.</p>
73,504
[ -0.01476261205971241, -0.03591858223080635, -0.005428876727819443, -0.002759133465588093, 0.019843993708491325, 0.025434115901589394, -0.0262365210801363, -0.00643290625885129, 0.0012777510564774275, -0.03841453418135643, -0.007124842144548893, 0.03915952891111374, 0.005834043957293034, 0.017743751406669617, -0.0056234728544950485, 0.008334618993103504, 0.0035165748558938503, -0.04791099578142166, -0.045778755098581314, 0.003962475340813398, 0.03794484585523605, 0.03932712599635124, 0.033846452832221985, 0.014987767674028873, -0.041915349662303925, 0.03756667301058769, 0.020567087456583977, -0.021674320101737976, 0.022747667506337166, 0.06661054491996765, -0.0007884886581450701, -0.036508847028017044, 0.020517045632004738, 0.03437463939189911, 0.03267207741737366, -0.01205420307815075, -0.048919495195150375, -0.0305474940687418, 0.00982020702213049, 0.024229520931839943, -0.06270460784435272, -0.022049546241760254, -0.023365426808595657, 0.03339678794145584, -0.006967894267290831, -0.0026026929263025522, -0.00037916857399977744, -0.032104719430208206, 0.019003067165613174, -0.03853926807641983, 0.05505392700433731, 0.013446033000946045, 0.0008671123650856316, 0.036035068333148956, 0.020888594910502434, -0.023622969165444374, 0.06641313433647156, 0.06982557475566864, 0.0032709187362343073, -0.015376545488834381, -0.038467466831207275, -0.03525550290942192, 0.024907710030674934, -0.016315676271915436, -0.03452865034341812, 0.025481849908828735, 0.01873469166457653, 0.04349929839372635, -0.012661184184253216, -0.044631995260715485, 0.017340319231152534, 0.04431522637605667, 0.022260690107941628, 0.03149603679776192, 0.01871391199529171, -0.004618431441485882, 0.02710316888988018, 0.043065011501312256, 0.015089388005435467, 0.030687633901834488, -0.00150838284753263, 0.008604797534644604, 0.03474467992782593, 0.04814040660858154, -0.0010741048026829958, -0.02274179272353649, 0.09439533948898315, -0.035413987934589386, 0.02293497323989868, 0.014856602996587753, -0.008775753900408745, -0.001224634936079383, 0.00206671841442585, -0.043208830058574677, -0.05908383056521416, 0.00952520128339529, -0.0036319191567599773, 0.006881813984364271, 0.025691643357276917, -0.029817240312695503, -0.0024483774323016405, -0.06351055204868317, -0.00240729795768857, 0.04871078580617905, -0.016694195568561554, -0.020494624972343445, 0.030255010351538658, -0.017480138689279556, 0.008585281670093536, -0.018868695944547653, -0.027076760306954384, 0.024541813880205154, -0.006609258241951466, 0.009881294332444668, 0.02359028346836567, -0.048377763479948044, -0.03240485489368439, -0.031818926334381104, 0.07207807898521423, 0.07134083658456802, 0.03551589697599411, -0.039056528359651566, 0.019561538472771645, -0.041309796273708344, -0.04592379555106163, 0.04117847979068756, 0.03055565059185028, -0.017821775749325752, -0.04538131505250931, 0.006717167794704437, -0.01625397615134716, -0.017960617318749428, 0.02047743834555149, -0.006560092326253653, 0.031017359346151352, -0.01834818162024021, -0.08041619509458542, -0.028537707403302193, 0.03189487010240555, -0.009423408657312393, -0.025280440226197243, -0.07234108448028564, 0.014819406904280186, 0.06656799465417862, 0.059943243861198425, 0.015404042787849903, 0.02404099702835083, 0.05048300698399544, 0.023409215733408928, 0.04876299947500229, -0.018604489043354988, 0.02966541238129139, -0.03875872120261192, 0.0006277287611737847, -0.008714406751096249, -0.006854345090687275, 0.055119965225458145, 0.036443278193473816, -0.01086000818759203, -0.009762679226696491, 0.05919647216796875, -0.021666092798113823, -0.018625475466251373, -0.023185262456536293, 0.007564513478428125, -0.011690511368215084, 0.09506528824567795, -0.0015495355473831296, 0.027476541697978973, 0.012960925698280334, -0.003869306528940797, -0.019814802333712578, 0.02765679731965065, 0.004915855824947357, 0.05331992730498314, -0.029080435633659363, -0.07314502447843552, -0.04252329468727112, 0.006608259864151478, -0.016062701120972633, -0.027462612837553024, -0.011683830060064793, -0.04235135018825531, 0.038376886397600174, -0.0004207546007819474, 0.004568008705973625, 0.009593745693564415, 0.006406101398169994, 0.00633292505517602, -0.04337448626756668, -0.024084461852908134, -0.04425343498587608, 0.04005607217550278, -0.006540448404848576, 0.025118423625826836, 0.0006330778123810887, -0.0035633505322039127, -0.005605081096291542, 0.0011280726175755262, -0.020418256521224976, -0.009592536836862564, 0.013473999686539173, 0.01808556355535984, -0.056873250752687454, -0.010003327392041683, 0.05893585458397865, 0.0011393580352887511, -0.019423503428697586, 0.05270342901349068, -0.05788373202085495, -0.04718584939837456, 0.0033572688698768616, -0.022892169654369354, 0.046522244811058044, -0.02020588517189026, -0.003085521748289466, 0.013159506022930145, 0.0007048253319226205, -0.0031499317847192287, -0.013512535020709038, -0.044252634048461914, 0.07835471630096436, 0.060610391199588776, 0.013498837128281593, 0.0024265761021524668, 0.0031211746390908957, 0.015162470750510693, 0.000984023790806532, -0.056377116590738297, -0.027058584615588188, -0.061283595860004425, -0.011121525429189205, 0.02706979773938656, 0.015325435437262058, -0.03445131704211235, 0.02295983023941517, 0.02231639437377453, 0.05276608467102051, -0.004648048430681229, -0.02265360578894615, -0.04069497808814049, 0.01786411739885807, 0.02975844033062458, 0.04007032886147499, 0.006447057239711285, -0.00023788612452335656, -0.01944863609969616, -0.018053509294986725, -0.007134077604860067, 0.02371956780552864, 0.002773834392428398, 0.009369635954499245, -0.022207967936992645, -0.01135401800274849, -0.017503654584288597, -0.04576507955789566, 0.038429081439971924, -0.05172901973128319, -0.007240452338010073, 0.015985509380698204, 0.003676024964079261, 0.003187019843608141, 0.0028144640382379293, -0.014596084132790565, 0.01017296314239502, 0.05067019537091255, 0.0007705296156927943, 0.00990663655102253, 0.024386286735534668, -0.04084673523902893, 0.031143296509981155, -0.003959044814109802, -0.02185223624110222, 0.0007560154190286994, 0.025180742144584656, -0.0021033864468336105, -0.006060131825506687, -0.040155813097953796, -0.0795685350894928, -0.0015987305669113994, -0.0166783407330513, 0.026123398914933205, 0.005968248471617699, 0.03466621786355972, -0.04033730924129486, 0.0018227346008643508, -0.02109569124877453, -0.03322042524814606, 0.04220433905720711, 0.0193165373057127, 0.007825283333659172, 0.0070230672135949135, -0.01965409889817238, -0.043863411992788315, -0.007597106974571943, -0.05718901380896568, 0.024554621428251266, -0.022507065907120705, -0.037379276007413864, 0.06637075543403625, 0.02102656476199627, -0.11264035105705261, 0.00443431967869401, -0.04665827006101608, -0.027614368125796318, -0.02277069352567196, -0.006140395067632198, 0.0037961332127451897, -0.008412215858697891, 0.0067283534444868565, 0.03882297873497009, 0.0007970603764988482, 0.0016181888058781624, -0.06916071474552155, -0.07108713686466217, 0.02752738445997238, -0.018205877393484116, 0.013636508025228977, 0.012426665052771568, 0.021964222192764282, 0.07817458361387253, 0.026748334988951683, -0.0038601390551775694, -0.05522795394062996, 0.012070183642208576, -0.004973807372152805, -0.02648298814892769, -0.021189074963331223, 0.026711268350481987, -0.032362911850214005, 0.01844693347811699, 0.024378672242164612, 0.03567139059305191, 0.03552534431219101, 0.016303429380059242, -0.02165345288813114, 0.04929810017347336, 0.0227824617177248, 0.0049269963055849075, 0.04509042948484421, 0.0297402236610651, -0.005116400774568319, -0.004796561319380999, 0.026583701372146606, 0.03260599449276924, 0.004897644743323326, 0.005270048975944519, 0.04910603165626526, 0.005727458279579878, 0.007590909954160452, -0.009347282350063324, 0.05829623341560364, -0.03395494446158409, -0.007903947494924068, -0.007841227576136589, 0.02642163448035717, 0.013913081027567387, -0.048111896961927414, 0.03583493083715439, 0.014129714109003544, 0.03463514521718025, -0.026717575266957283, -0.022295692935585976, -0.017738915979862213, -0.008612568490207195, 0.021145634353160858, -0.03938599303364754, 0.00217883731238544, 0.01453409157693386, 0.02900734916329384, 0.05112751945853233, 0.05018998309969902, -0.020776567980647087, -0.03214654698967934, -0.04396725445985794, -0.031253278255462646, 0.009179333224892616, 0.07312431931495667, 0.0023425291292369366, 0.028012841939926147, 0.01732265017926693, -0.012924442999064922, 0.020877493545413017, 0.022792121395468712, -0.09115294367074966, 0.01576852798461914, -0.02244577184319496, 0.007499982137233019, -0.003722100518643856, -0.014941801317036152, 0.03420757129788399, -0.0012700635707005858, -0.03013075888156891, -0.019956747069954872, -0.02479461580514908, -0.03174133226275444, 0.005673076491802931, -0.04193193465471268, -0.0035079489462077618, -0.02286554127931595, 0.02358674816787243, 0.05949926748871803, -0.045338474214076996, -0.0046637998893857, 0.008230354636907578, -0.03093525394797325, 0.027904754504561424, 0.0037263536360114813, 0.0331057533621788, 0.007525470573455095, 0.02042822726070881, 0.007165925111621618, 0.039110179990530014, 0.0020077505614608526, 0.0016233784845098853, 0.007231870666146278, 0.038341064006090164, 0.061984073370695114, -0.015850836411118507, 0.002999839372932911, -0.04491506144404411, -0.0203014574944973, -0.005879995878785849, 0.0073890467174351215, 0.0033468040637671947, 0.03985220193862915, 0.037896592170000076, 0.016118651255965233, -0.08289570361375809, -0.011313775554299355, 0.08185555040836334, -0.024731339886784554, -0.028063775971531868, -0.00824386440217495, 0.00915161520242691, -0.018051274120807648, 0.015594699420034885, -0.006315837614238262, 0.003371693892404437, -0.0038529420271515846, -0.004865153692662716, -0.005788339301943779, -0.0002810104051604867, -0.016942206770181656, -0.031092828139662743, 0.004976898431777954, 0.0163247212767601, -0.003572062822058797, 0.005707923322916031, -0.007586411200463772, -0.02170402556657791, 0.02202153019607067, 0.00667412718757987, 0.020608972758054733, -0.06779301166534424, -0.02537788264453411, 0.02608845755457878, 0.04123346507549286, 0.027008818462491035, 0.01103727426379919, -0.0575125478208065, -0.0363771989941597, 0.01774599216878414, -0.025783127173781395, 0.06297019124031067, 0.01889546774327755, -0.016917694360017776, -0.04813678562641144, -0.014253095723688602, -0.000612775154877454, 0.01729712262749672, -0.02143056131899357, 0.06062480807304382, 0.021903421729803085, -0.0074644251726567745, -0.029395567253232002, -0.018513178452849388, 0.016080351546406746, 0.08331277221441269, -0.021236443892121315, -0.01582963950932026, 0.01101815328001976, -0.010676826350390911, -0.022957272827625275, -0.070039764046669, 0.014722483232617378, 0.006569188553839922, -0.005013628862798214, -0.00306134857237339, -0.04521122947335243, -0.045760296285152435, 0.02159019373357296, 0.008763234131038189, -0.004304985515773296, -0.01551084965467453, -0.040159206837415695, 0.058678872883319855, 0.0194290392100811, 0.014019438996911049, 0.03551717847585678, 0.010333740152418613, 0.004659491591155529, 0.013788747601211071, 0.003651854582130909, 0.014954554848372936, -0.01683742366731167, -0.024165628477931023, -0.018502134829759598, -0.014885198324918747, -0.0055853151716291904, 0.03827851638197899, -0.000847656512632966, 0.028141329064965248, -0.018668055534362793, -0.023497698828577995, -0.046188488602638245, 0.02936662547290325, -0.008564758114516735, -0.010193378664553165, -0.004566227085888386, 0.027671853080391884, -0.022091379389166832, -0.001249327091500163, 0.04088359326124191, -0.041176047176122665, 0.020670432597398758, 0.04442485421895981, -0.05018318444490433, 0.007138450630009174, -0.03737298771739006, 0.015547085553407669, -0.010315971449017525, 0.005033820867538452, 0.05753433331847191, 0.009897559881210327, 0.014246158301830292, 0.014128941111266613, -0.04896501824259758, 0.0070661092177033424, -0.011295484378933907, -0.02362854592502117, -0.023130595684051514, -0.04516477510333061, 0.03643425554037094, -0.02550222910940647, 0.004424597602337599, -0.07253389805555344, -0.015518203377723694, 0.03935791552066803, -0.013783646747469902, -0.011266721412539482, 0.0021774545311927795, 0.010810482315719128, 0.004826586227864027, -0.038829319179058075, -0.016948966309428215, 0.04657595977187157, -0.014135459437966347, 0.024670030921697617, 0.03608513996005058, 0.019060183316469193, 0.01606476865708828, 0.020085306838154793, -0.012497265823185444, -0.00452552642673254, -0.024585260078310966, -0.0056543960236012936, -0.0020992301870137453, -0.02092805877327919, -0.03662760183215141, -0.03717716783285141, -0.0407586432993412, 0.021365908905863762, -0.008480271324515343, -0.005663295742124319, -0.0017923162085935473, 0.010488748550415039, -0.013450932689011097, -0.028638938441872597, -0.05287807434797287, -0.02559598535299301, 0.003989399876445532, -0.03925429284572601, -0.02400876395404339, -0.012499801814556122, 0.0033067651093006134, -0.026146715506911278, 0.009223558939993382, 0.02303471602499485, -0.003477156860753894, -0.014422482810914516, 0.052309390157461166, -0.037420954555273056, -0.034473270177841187, 0.012149187736213207, -0.043989550322294235, 0.06009209528565407, 0.023484710603952408, 0.003041287185624242, 0.005844308063387871, -0.01734291762113571, -0.011453969404101372, -0.03039407916367054, -0.061220683157444, -0.02098398096859455, 0.07093628495931625, 0.02266674116253853, 0.06719272583723068, 0.015070084482431412, 0.030289534479379654, -0.02922768145799637, 0.0019045769004151225, -0.00715206004679203, -0.019071834161877632, -0.0046823942102491856, 0.008963643573224545, 0.006819998379796743, -0.018225306645035744, 0.00011875830386998132, 0.005107054952532053, 0.004920031875371933, 0.04804560914635658, 0.024842552840709686, 0.048374373465776443, 0.04733363166451454, -0.07473248988389969, -0.048981454223394394, 0.011224745772778988, -0.0556722953915596, -0.01934438943862915, 0.015087686479091644, -0.05352557823061943, 0.024307018145918846, 0.00621185265481472, 0.03526340797543526, -0.02401917241513729, -0.006689444184303284, -0.07302355766296387, 0.009353097528219223, 0.009356975555419922, 0.013602443970739841, 0.038179196417331696, -0.005692224949598312, 0.007349260151386261, 0.010778895579278469, 0.0019513319712132215, -0.012358900159597397, -0.039478179067373276, -0.030087435618042946, -0.04807724803686142, -0.05977241322398186, 0.03251038119196892, 0.03879138082265854, -0.029070589691400528, -0.002029563533142209, -0.01615012437105179, 0.030267218127846718, 0.020480601117014885, 0.04531383514404297, -0.011907820589840412, 0.08146128058433533, -0.03698921948671341, 0.04285362735390663, -0.03547785058617592, -0.003836464136838913, 0.11523723602294922, 0.09292277693748474, 0.017682528123259544, -0.07905108481645584, 0.00048826352576725185, -0.0016734040109440684, 0.004633637610822916, -0.013782979920506477, -0.00033949731732718647, 0.03542275354266167, -0.008391421288251877, -0.008768316358327866, 0.0028417310677468777, -0.005782289896160364, -0.005090274848043919, 0.05705353617668152, -0.04350289702415466, -0.023835673928260803, 0.03372683748602867, 0.02860833890736103, 0.00912836380302906, 0.035458169877529144, -0.013482240960001945, -0.019534306600689888, 0.033847443759441376, -0.03359788656234741, 0.008297037333250046, -0.0033646798692643642, -0.0014956890372559428, -0.0339270643889904, 0.015517081134021282, -0.00902615673840046, -0.006114549934864044, -0.0021572555415332317, 0.02032272331416607, 0.039034828543663025, -0.0070480541326105595, 0.010681849904358387, -0.0016298702685162425, 0.052594397217035294, 0.04014765843749046, -0.020626792684197426, 0.013761376962065697, -0.009914178401231766, -0.02788679488003254, -0.05952756106853485, -0.059794217348098755, 0.022655479609966278, -0.06290546804666519, -0.020993515849113464, 0.009566583670675755, 0.021465614438056946, -0.007170260418206453, -0.02804216556251049, -0.012228631414473057, 0.03847189620137215, 0.039183054119348526, 0.001614755718037486, -0.0027641355991363525, 0.012924819253385067, 0.004186097998172045, -0.020619509741663933, 0.022598950192332268, -0.0215071439743042, -0.05152488872408867, -0.006635728757828474, -0.01213514432311058, 0.016542963683605194, 0.019237270578742027, 0.00485314941033721, -0.02172146551311016, -0.01687854342162609, -0.031442657113075256, -0.028235280886292458, 0.0021582976914942265, 0.008575357496738434, 0.029898591339588165, -0.005953402724117041, -0.014400433748960495, -0.005120912101119757, -0.028359107673168182, -0.01329923328012228, 0.0005816254415549338, 0.013191118836402893, -0.02703356370329857, 0.0012049925280734897, 0.005152166821062565, 0.030761780217289925, -0.009054744616150856, 0.027730897068977356, 0.024857930839061737, 0.014686164446175098, 0.02723180316388607, -0.023618271574378014, 0.008353046141564846, -0.007119558751583099, -0.09600050002336502, 0.02712707780301571, -0.0178608950227499, 0.05596143752336502, 0.024303153157234192, 0.02577405422925949, 0.011653183959424496, 0.034142959862947464, 0.009744786657392979, 0.01863633468747139, -0.027051851153373718, -0.02943173050880432, -0.007436245214194059, -0.0079243965446949, 0.01674916036427021, -0.0458768755197525, -0.029795557260513306, -0.044932104647159576, -0.014917313121259212, 0.0069115376099944115, -0.02105146460235119, -0.03833850845694542, 0.007057725917547941, -0.031213855370879173, -0.007006797008216381, -0.013391154818236828, 0.011174265295267105, -0.00477649224922061, 0.008726156316697598, -0.018293481320142746, 0.022361716255545616, -0.0071532465517520905, 0.003033286891877651, 0.00850926898419857, -0.014775238931179047, 0.027971800416707993, 0.042315274477005005, -0.0017762335482984781, -0.0016141055384650826, -0.004148864187300205, 0.009150661528110504, 0.06418000906705856, -0.07614541798830032, -0.04072180390357971, 0.03791772946715355, -0.04682863503694534, 0.029917147010564804, 0.042412083595991135, 0.0059991395100951195, 0.036937911063432693, 0.04241087660193443, -0.034600451588630676, -0.0005534421652555466, 0.04066791385412216, -0.010103460401296616, -0.024526864290237427, 0.054512158036231995, 0.0010129171423614025, 0.005446352530270815, 0.02612357586622238, -0.0077828895300626755, 0.015347778797149658, -0.01947362720966339, -0.022150876000523567, 0.046721454709768295, 0.02659204602241516, 0.007951796054840088, 0.023502839729189873, 0.020035473629832268, 0.011282211169600487, 0.024744246155023575, 0.01092053484171629, 0.051899563521146774, 0.015186990611255169, -0.017224889248609543, 0.0162686575204134, -0.009803476743400097, -0.0019394000992178917, -0.09386679530143738, -0.005472933873534203, 0.03640713542699814, 0.01839430071413517, 0.051243945956230164, -0.0563865564763546, 0.06999096274375916, 0.013746635988354683, -0.07298608869314194, 0.033611249178647995, -0.00731458468362689, 0.014621264301240444, -0.010991456918418407, 0.021317726001143456, -0.050113338977098465, 0.045776933431625366, -0.004395761992782354, 0.051392193883657455, 0.07766278088092804, 0.014782417565584183, -0.011634659953415394, -0.03706074506044388, -0.019552184268832207, 0.04561304673552513, -0.0067615751177072525, 0.018938805907964706, 0.036518942564725876, -0.06325078010559082, -0.06622925400733948, 0.018714383244514465, -0.009211896918714046, 0.029843367636203766, 0.00664111040532589, 0.0405610166490078, 0.003453910816460848, 0.04468151181936264, 0.05079149082303047, -0.031915053725242615, 0.00656279968097806, -0.026455804705619812, 0.010888566263020039, 0.0056808749213814735, -0.005819773767143488, 0.02764984592795372, 0.03287145495414734, 0.017410874366760254, -0.04568406566977501, 0.010171919129788876, -0.020984617993235588, -0.022879475727677345, 0.019723286852240562, -0.008114357478916645, -0.008167345076799393, -0.025829432532191277, -0.03243646398186684, -0.005365981254726648, 0.006771779619157314, 0.005478431470692158, 0.018926113843917847, 0.018619565293192863, -0.022033249959349632, -0.02013367787003517, -0.06000271067023277, 0.023445598781108856, 0.013672436587512493, -0.00793185830116272, -0.07891268283128738, 0.0018990833777934313, 0.009371030144393444, 0.025646917521953583, -0.008522141724824905, -0.018689226359128952, -0.038726504892110825, 0.014140436425805092, -0.01943923346698284, 0.01880764588713646, -0.0007516896585002542, -0.03894716128706932, 0.001955391839146614, -0.09210772067308426, 0.05841635540127754, -0.019304296001791954, 0.004494423046708107, -0.014513502828776836, -0.019100341945886612, -0.02304544672369957, -0.017284588888287544, 0.04829435423016548, -0.027638575062155724, -0.009061058983206749, -0.026090743020176888, 0.026740578934550285, 0.03771684318780899, -0.009677499532699585, 0.01849507726728916, -0.03431611508131027, 0.02856440283358097, -0.029039204120635986, 0.016515089198946953, -0.005185744725167751, -0.009157133288681507, 0.034348610788583755, 0.01444238144904375, -0.01716146431863308, 0.007419646251946688, -0.0067041777074337006, 0.029142534360289574, 0.007035048678517342, 0.006665499415248632, 0.01850811578333378, 0.025726627558469772, 0.009431878104805946, 0.026113305240869522, -0.010042289271950722, -0.08602102845907211, 0.03026910312473774, -0.030520891770720482, -0.035868894308805466, 0.0290959682315588, 0.017888560891151428, 0.03723171725869179, -0.04545607790350914, -0.033201348036527634, 0.047851212322711945, -0.025851624086499214, 0.012002155184745789, 0.04605881869792938, -0.0008697378798387945, 0.048353713005781174, 0.004156894516199827, 0.053237881511449814, -0.02253168448805809, -0.008586910553276539, 0.008849915117025375, 0.01851501129567623, 0.03965253755450249, -0.027385301887989044, 0.07084909081459045, 0.047843921929597855, -0.006222773343324661, 0.019844215363264084, 0.006316955666989088, 0.03185945749282837, -0.022269804030656815, 0.02503080479800701, 0.05575111135840416, 0.029782908037304878, -0.01223721168935299, 0.0003194632881786674, -0.024868885055184364, 0.06962850689888, 0.00924641638994217, -0.0015880329301580787, -0.02620300091803074, -0.0024882331490516663, -0.028102803975343704, -0.01389827486127615, -0.03077777847647667, 0.07873402535915375, 0.02159634791314602, -0.008662387728691101, 0.015768466517329216, -0.002928529167547822, 0.015583349391818047, -0.01675814390182495, 0.02450099028646946, 0.017156993970274925, 0.033844124525785446, 0.011774278245866299, -0.024778282269835472, -0.017873411998152733, -0.002960857702419162, 0.03306504338979721, 0.02977261133491993, 0.03755822405219078, -0.008217877708375454, -0.022652696818113327, -0.03623669221997261, 0.028476465493440628, -0.023966418579220772, 0.003497868776321411, -0.05238956958055496, 0.00002849770498869475, 0.01397806778550148, -0.015612787567079067 ]
<p>I have a set of data from two nights worth of monitoring.</p> <p>The monitoring picks up how busy a server is in terms of the number of threads processing.</p> <p>A change has been made and we want to analyse if this has had an impact of reducing the threads.</p> <p>How can I compare the two data sets given that the load on the server is going to be a variable (but comparable).</p> <p>I have been thinking of ANOVA, is this a good method? Any others people can suggest?</p> <p>The data seems to display a positively skewed normal distribution. Is ANOVA still valid?</p> <p>As an example (dummy data)</p> <pre><code> Thread Count Night Before Change Night After Change 00:00 341 223 00:05 365 321 00:10 465 445 . . . 08:50 512 243 08:55 314 556 09:00 256 354 </code></pre>
73,505
[ -0.03260801360011101, -0.017800159752368927, -0.029672076925635338, -0.01176849752664566, 0.04540837183594704, 0.02907497249543667, 0.03780112415552139, -0.029142357409000397, 0.0021416088566184044, -0.007276768330484629, 0.029993822798132896, 0.06486093997955322, 0.011408038437366486, 0.03257864713668823, 0.039570290595293045, 0.006729368586093187, -0.009033700451254845, -0.03696262463927269, -0.016565343365073204, 0.008365861140191555, -0.01306189689785242, -0.024759391322731972, 0.03809909150004387, -0.020379185676574707, -0.053890980780124664, 0.02402648515999317, 0.0012994972057640553, -0.0523454025387764, -0.02129386179149151, 0.04060737416148186, -0.04811020940542221, -0.025277622044086456, 0.0009598798351362348, 0.03214433789253235, 0.03450559079647064, 0.04699615389108658, -0.028896449133753777, -0.002804872114211321, 0.027742719277739525, 0.03971445932984352, -0.00023772305576130748, 0.00041763755143620074, -0.0036168613005429506, 0.03230925649404526, 0.02052166685461998, 0.02035074308514595, -0.006802829448133707, -0.01309189572930336, 0.026920167729258537, -0.04570771008729935, 0.06617382168769836, -0.04866600036621094, 0.03268520534038544, 0.044895920902490616, -0.02261868305504322, -0.02806100621819496, 0.047945160418748856, 0.05196289345622063, -0.03288795053958893, -0.07392645627260208, -0.0012544785859063268, -0.018429378047585487, -0.013707020319998264, -0.007337504997849464, -0.03216112032532692, 0.01192503236234188, -0.009344982914626598, -0.031401053071022034, 0.057934682816267014, -0.009761725552380085, 0.014119144529104233, 0.01778045855462551, 0.041735243052244186, -0.017548520117998123, -0.002031178679317236, -0.030679097399115562, 0.0297869686037302, 0.018811574205756187, 0.017401015385985374, 0.05934341996908188, 0.005254609044641256, 0.017572268843650818, 0.037520818412303925, 0.06039554625749588, 0.05604036524891853, -0.024455780163407326, 0.06502856314182281, -0.030116166919469833, 0.024685464799404144, 0.03772278130054474, -0.01298049557954073, -0.01259317435324192, 0.044798221439123154, 0.0158280860632658, -0.04367062821984291, 0.0031214519403874874, -0.011383363045752048, 0.03425504267215729, -0.004861705936491489, -0.011431865394115448, -0.012321248650550842, -0.0471823625266552, 0.03702526539564133, 0.026631323620676994, -0.014226454310119152, 0.02305596135556698, -0.030418256297707558, 0.014337736181914806, -0.029047567397356033, 0.00004773744512931444, -0.049164075404405594, -0.011321961879730225, 0.008595408871769905, 0.01807580329477787, 0.02498958818614483, -0.016486356034874916, -0.0038454679306596518, 0.00863389391452074, 0.07095535099506378, 0.05278186872601509, 0.021117592230439186, 0.004634092096239328, 0.012528474442660809, -0.0517321340739727, -0.03743971139192581, 0.02294282242655754, 0.007056602742522955, -0.0041207983158528805, -0.036619219928979874, 0.07157855480909348, -0.04154781252145767, 0.0059866951778531075, 0.018182577565312386, -0.02400701679289341, 0.05435345321893692, -0.009493641555309296, -0.08740412443876266, -0.047992538660764694, 0.03385933116078377, -0.015658063814044, 0.010589861311018467, -0.06636340916156769, -0.019222857430577278, 0.004087781999260187, 0.03899017348885536, 0.009859520010650158, 0.02250714972615242, -0.01842465251684189, 0.01725989393889904, 0.017402417957782745, -0.0038045139517635107, -0.008193792775273323, -0.004605619702488184, -0.044499535113573074, 0.0035221907310187817, -0.08411800861358643, -0.03580993041396141, 0.029403697699308395, 0.018925940617918968, 0.022156381979584694, 0.026482805609703064, -0.0010271063074469566, -0.009393248707056046, -0.0011342775542289019, 0.017081243917346, -0.053723279386758804, 0.06733416765928268, -0.042320918291807175, 0.014721715822815895, -0.013234875164926052, -0.019303318113088608, 0.02522045560181141, -0.021577198058366776, 0.030210020020604134, 0.03779854625463486, -0.013684459961950779, -0.024342555552721024, -0.028901971876621246, 0.03540659323334694, 0.015618262812495232, -0.025341982021927834, -0.001885938923805952, -0.05074744299054146, 0.012504512444138527, 0.024891065433621407, 0.07614120841026306, -0.003044186159968376, -0.011015580035746098, 0.05952270328998566, -0.02303854376077652, -0.032804425805807114, -0.0741710364818573, 0.002219374990090728, -0.01869443617761135, -0.03993397206068039, 0.011166824027895927, 0.02056000754237175, 0.0017071142792701721, -0.004437906667590141, -0.013461382128298283, -0.008571457117795944, -0.024318914860486984, 0.058336399495601654, -0.04659342020750046, 0.0002517751418054104, 0.012977699749171734, 0.024706928059458733, -0.01617334596812725, 0.050104811787605286, -0.05320730060338974, -0.04264454171061516, -0.01654128171503544, -0.027584556490182877, -0.025912003591656685, -0.0002346748224226758, -0.01233529020100832, 0.038919951766729355, 0.04000357910990715, -0.012855546548962593, 0.00402287719771266, -0.07996489852666855, 0.04786264896392822, 0.07288774847984314, -0.028412260115146637, 0.016514476388692856, -0.020641926676034927, 0.001721941283904016, 0.028993038460612297, -0.003987699747085571, 0.03451160341501236, -0.04140617698431015, 0.015776194632053375, 0.06899814307689667, -0.015413323417305946, -0.036003876477479935, -0.022244174033403397, 0.08934614807367325, 0.0007926122052595019, 0.0008696988807059824, 0.023337094113230705, -0.02520347386598587, -0.050361696630716324, 0.03064926713705063, 0.046202436089515686, 0.03827262297272682, 0.012994705699384212, 0.048439327627420425, -0.010279879905283451, 0.025905249640345573, 0.007224442902952433, 0.014006185345351696, 0.030187714844942093, 0.007964524440467358, 0.01296128798276186, -0.013115644454956055, -0.03013726882636547, 0.048257604241371155, -0.016828006133437157, 0.013868608511984348, 0.04459812492132187, -0.022779829800128937, 0.013589028269052505, -0.001890611369162798, -0.022731978446245193, 0.03128297999501228, -0.017690148204565048, -0.03301749750971794, -0.002097479300573468, 0.02271224744617939, -0.036593325436115265, 0.02950786054134369, 0.010136705823242664, -0.02476503700017929, -0.052576687186956406, -0.003153987228870392, 0.03866884857416153, -0.0010467510437592864, 0.048947472125291824, -0.03593356907367706, -0.00071640161331743, -0.00011693609121721238, -0.003924406133592129, -0.0024821069091558456, 0.03183111548423767, -0.033894963562488556, 0.008557513356208801, 0.010042782872915268, -0.010941789485514164, 0.0201899204403162, -0.013517512008547783, 0.04615461081266403, 0.057772278785705566, 0.001634604181163013, 0.006330416072160006, 0.011496301740407944, 0.015031863935291767, 0.011026828549802303, -0.004173337481915951, -0.02195798233151436, 0.05113942548632622, 0.02688978984951973, -0.04341188818216324, 0.008873597718775272, -0.022262781858444214, -0.027825085446238518, -0.02480255626142025, 0.002987717743963003, 0.031356628984212875, -0.009542834013700485, 0.0021448908373713493, 0.00850539468228817, -0.02061549574136734, 0.009813728742301464, -0.05271926149725914, -0.057534199208021164, -0.01518280804157257, -0.02013220451772213, 0.04201996698975563, -0.018938617780804634, -0.06402261555194855, 0.04258767515420914, 0.049394335597753525, -0.03737039864063263, -0.04639377072453499, -0.0016717503312975168, -0.049703240394592285, 0.0010347941424697638, 0.03724105656147003, -0.005246402230113745, 0.001062244875356555, 0.022784987464547157, 0.015021626837551594, 0.04272462800145149, 0.04108573496341705, 0.056209806352853775, -0.035810377448797226, 0.02251332439482212, -0.013578706420958042, 0.00046116861631162465, 0.017567861825227737, 0.016721200197935104, -0.02274087257683277, -0.013971798121929169, 0.0005410424200817943, -0.010516762733459473, 0.008673314936459064, -0.03422893211245537, 0.01993546262383461, -0.010808773338794708, 0.03361578658223152, -0.03655508533120155, 0.0217166468501091, 0.011974174529314041, -0.04803358390927315, -0.04493153467774391, 0.020983820781111717, 0.0012593658175319433, -0.014988938346505165, -0.00731602031737566, 0.06631767004728317, 0.038005389273166656, -0.0075291832908988, -0.003467476461082697, 0.0009825604502111673, -0.01640596054494381, 0.0037989974953234196, -0.052316922694444656, -0.02562720887362957, 0.01467349287122488, 0.046005409210920334, 0.011625322513282299, -0.011149996891617775, -0.04360441491007805, -0.028351109474897385, -0.0842638909816742, -0.003926874604076147, -0.04121866077184677, 0.03747296705842018, -0.00033829471794888377, 0.04911531135439873, 0.03802721947431564, -0.014622656628489494, 0.027816297486424446, -0.05283728614449501, -0.05731850489974022, 0.03225688263773918, -0.000017522088455734774, -0.00421526562422514, 0.03189631551504135, -0.024437418207526207, -0.010253889486193657, -0.06197591871023178, 0.04355642572045326, 0.010160977952182293, 0.032863423228263855, -0.02889033779501915, -0.009024436585605145, -0.002413192531093955, -0.0023212595842778683, -0.004421311896294355, 0.009609517641365528, 0.019048621878027916, -0.008937311358749866, 0.04971769079566002, 0.013637743890285492, -0.010683397762477398, -0.011625239625573158, -0.015373583883047104, 0.011593307368457317, 0.020945940166711807, 0.03960143029689789, 0.02089187130331993, 0.04819180816411972, -0.011341315694153309, 0.026460282504558563, 0.009033087641000748, 0.021278413012623787, 0.03890553489327431, 0.014241110533475876, -0.0008808764396235347, -0.019433047622442245, -0.03171380236744881, -0.013839945197105408, 0.0052613369189202785, 0.006498036906123161, 0.008793659508228302, 0.015670662745833397, 0.031523168087005615, -0.05595003068447113, 0.0004218753019813448, 0.069870725274086, 0.01759609766304493, 0.006598096806555986, -0.021244332194328308, 0.021235883235931396, -0.010054412297904491, 0.006110359914600849, 0.010731471702456474, 0.017787987366318703, 0.02142254449427128, 0.006874169688671827, 0.03893882408738136, 0.003402090398594737, -0.014907182194292545, 0.02744428440928459, -0.0037730380427092314, 0.01996256783604622, 0.014171845279633999, -0.0050536347553133965, 0.02342052012681961, 0.042393773794174194, 0.03436540067195892, -0.0008310976554639637, -0.03048071637749672, -0.09405361115932465, -0.014949876815080643, 0.05786861851811409, 0.03182799369096756, -0.01835336536169052, -0.020879624411463737, 0.018424037843942642, 0.018406616523861885, 0.011818144470453262, -0.043503034859895706, 0.05327845737338066, -0.004797555040568113, 0.02294018119573593, -0.036308567970991135, -0.03650394082069397, -0.052187900990247726, 0.02466597966849804, -0.0004197565431240946, 0.027366645634174347, 0.009326213970780373, -0.0695657953619957, -0.08948606252670288, 0.004785036202520132, 0.020145807415246964, 0.02274428680539131, -0.04632775858044624, -0.031184958294034004, -0.009776807390153408, 0.030050717294216156, -0.0010002880590036511, -0.046387653797864914, 0.04408491402864456, 0.0033544222824275494, 0.0022285303566604853, 0.035561561584472656, 0.009339690208435059, -0.015745995566248894, 0.007201555650681257, -0.013481772504746914, -0.03171105310320854, 0.007711202371865511, -0.036316294223070145, 0.05826365202665329, 0.03548101335763931, 0.013331147842109203, 0.012429994530975819, 0.027118215337395668, -0.008747258223593235, -0.0016877272864803672, -0.02905932627618313, -0.0033055490348488092, -0.03565455228090286, -0.010075769387185574, -0.020498361438512802, -0.017843548208475113, -0.032237209379673004, 0.027441419661045074, 0.021816592663526535, 0.047840967774391174, -0.010665063746273518, 0.013009238056838512, 0.03633974492549896, 0.0037911783438175917, 0.02396835945546627, -0.03152450919151306, -0.025827087461948395, -0.01441454328596592, -0.03956833481788635, -0.020750096067786217, 0.004556755535304546, -0.03103814832866192, -0.031419817358255386, 0.010299606248736382, -0.0387490876019001, 0.009498237632215023, -0.05217665433883667, -0.031585950404405594, 0.017468079924583435, -0.04079931601881981, 0.011664527468383312, 0.04330495744943619, 0.024638237431645393, 0.019848210737109184, -0.04065847769379616, 0.01293051429092884, 0.013518138788640499, -0.03152264654636383, -0.002087140455842018, -0.03988268971443176, 0.07038231194019318, -0.009118339978158474, -0.022403080016374588, -0.05462878197431564, -0.013143054209649563, 0.027120064944028854, -0.029382582753896713, 0.016727076843380928, -0.035715170204639435, -0.04706079885363579, -0.007178871892392635, -0.015766682103276253, 0.000844424357637763, 0.02215522900223732, -0.0289682075381279, -0.002278087893500924, 0.019733265042304993, -0.004723373334854841, 0.08706480264663696, -0.00782870128750801, 0.009905223734676838, -0.007055254653096199, -0.02050309255719185, -0.03538636863231659, -0.0029359341133385897, 0.00028041619225405157, -0.009730582125484943, 0.007797893136739731, -0.00209445389918983, -0.0233643539249897, 0.05978533998131752, -0.010159152559936047, -0.017308034002780914, 0.013966197147965431, 0.000012528271327028051, 0.00532172666862607, -0.05851782485842705, -0.022838937118649483, -0.00889834389090538, 0.033841442316770554, -0.02607964724302292, 0.00456817215308547, -0.011741803027689457, 0.014589072205126286, 0.008979134261608124, 0.02749583125114441, -0.02293471246957779, 0.02057918719947338, 0.06797552853822708, -0.019178271293640137, -0.022386616095900536, -0.01622556895017624, -0.009405053220689297, 0.0013868160312995315, -0.0034786290489137173, 0.0007031771237961948, -0.014948300085961819, 0.006655924022197723, -0.033114153891801834, -0.024948615580797195, -0.0420057438313961, -0.05336950719356537, 0.05378717929124832, 0.010033512488007545, 0.08193621039390564, 0.02682066708803177, 0.021178070455789566, -0.010397394187748432, 0.0047998614609241486, -0.0011979424161836505, -0.015508151613175869, 0.006135998759418726, 0.041132789105176926, -0.04073645919561386, 0.011758408509194851, 0.023361600935459137, -0.015996048226952553, 0.00858599878847599, 0.07188079506158829, 0.011982455849647522, 0.018681040033698082, 0.03874615579843521, -0.01867641508579254, -0.038303982466459274, 0.023084716871380806, -0.035446200519800186, 0.02518974058330059, -0.0668962150812149, -0.002742381999269128, 0.058954764157533646, 0.035670217126607895, -0.008258526213467121, -0.043622300028800964, -0.0187107864767313, -0.08337903022766113, -0.013849467039108276, 0.02191656455397606, -0.052338987588882446, 0.031483009457588196, 0.032249074429273605, 0.0763866975903511, -0.008329350501298904, 0.03195162117481232, -0.04214197397232056, -0.058405302464962006, -0.014510633423924446, -0.021840807050466537, -0.038106828927993774, 0.05608781799674034, -0.0375724658370018, -0.0312180295586586, 0.02128411829471588, -0.02039450593292713, 0.008667802438139915, -0.004671926610171795, 0.03550911694765091, -0.01867740787565708, 0.07021931558847427, -0.013061068952083588, 0.02818569354712963, 0.008910895325243473, -0.0006819423288106918, 0.08768981695175171, 0.06470873206853867, 0.05322274938225746, -0.055711306631565094, 0.036320168524980545, -0.004053598269820213, 0.014235508628189564, -0.009153051301836967, 0.0017524592112749815, 0.004273981787264347, -0.015652984380722046, 0.09399984776973724, 0.022321149706840515, 0.029784400016069412, -0.01230468787252903, 0.03421390429139137, -0.004231225233525038, -0.04120418429374695, -0.031919926404953, 0.02089231088757515, -0.011974233202636242, -0.02418133057653904, -0.05260864272713661, 0.021725350990891457, 0.004400341771543026, -0.03370964154601097, -0.0048929923214018345, -0.011533048935234547, -0.03895120322704315, -0.017523426562547684, -0.04770428687334061, 0.02912062220275402, 0.045275330543518066, -0.008931871503591537, -0.010580185800790787, -0.03344295546412468, 0.02780623361468315, -0.039974864572286606, 0.008599487133324146, 0.04759405553340912, -0.0154165243729949, -0.025696761906147003, -0.014055772684514523, 0.03787421062588692, -0.06173019856214523, -0.046933650970458984, -0.04013475030660629, 0.027384715154767036, 0.0006466323393397033, -0.008291192352771759, 0.009461689740419388, 0.001148333540186286, -0.019529467448592186, -0.034482236951589584, -0.03174377977848053, 0.017569690942764282, 0.020960116758942604, -0.028682341799139977, -0.0054772053845226765, -0.030307533219456673, -0.0056265913881361485, 0.02943195216357708, 0.01870729587972164, 0.07442886382341385, 0.005606335122138262, -0.00842874962836504, -0.0432807058095932, 0.08969508111476898, -0.018432913348078728, 0.00359098007902503, 0.01262455340474844, -0.015538960695266724, 0.009303659200668335, -0.028158748522400856, 0.024268118664622307, -0.012317662127315998, 0.01699092425405979, -0.01731974072754383, 0.007356808986514807, -0.03268634155392647, -0.015010508708655834, 0.008676823228597641, -0.02250071056187153, 0.022096773609519005, -0.034934718161821365, -0.0018341997638344765, 0.03363456577062607, 0.03792271763086319, 0.040922969579696655, 0.0016944592352956533, 0.025900350883603096, 0.05757682025432587, 0.027367064729332924, -0.05425313115119934, -0.01875985786318779, -0.0011440758826211095, -0.021571695804595947, -0.015341171994805336, -0.02975877933204174, 0.06724543124437332, 0.02224523387849331, -0.015751834958791733, -0.003357010893523693, 0.02751217409968376, -0.015837769955396652, -0.0008610119693912566, 0.006687752902507782, -0.02185508795082569, -0.01798112317919731, 0.014093096368014812, 0.015393530949950218, -0.007111952640116215, -0.0033873142674565315, -0.024502325803041458, -0.021696746349334717, -0.01300855353474617, -0.014630379155278206, -0.004577043931931257, -0.01696201227605343, -0.009431418962776661, 0.012114825658500195, -0.03593537583947182, 0.009892086498439312, -0.04002663120627403, -0.05155560001730919, 0.0072351982817053795, -0.002515599364414811, 0.012205209583044052, -0.007035390008240938, 0.025129908695816994, 0.0011516944505274296, 0.03533317893743515, 0.0022834795527160168, 0.06980011612176895, -0.0116171445697546, -0.0037844034377485514, -0.01597076654434204, 0.04021139070391655, -0.01475527510046959, -0.040603093802928925, 0.05693132057785988, -0.038906436413526535, 0.00449872761964798, 0.04824294522404671, -0.01586742140352726, 0.03886153921484947, -0.029265262186527252, -0.0016617056680843234, -0.001965887378901243, 0.04103410989046097, -0.001032272120937705, -0.0314311720430851, -0.0168415829539299, -0.033476680517196655, 0.013341785408556461, -0.018208438530564308, 0.014987309463322163, 0.016214855015277863, -0.010202067904174328, 0.046178188174963, 0.04287107661366463, 0.02836097963154316, -0.010489147156476974, 0.000770159182138741, 0.03710203617811203, 0.03786701336503029, 0.014813360758125782, -0.019391555339097977, 0.0458662323653698, 0.049755748361349106, -0.06438186019659042, 0.015792975202202797, -0.08760611712932587, -0.035748403519392014, -0.08156163990497589, 0.008046997711062431, 0.0010583502007648349, -0.023927615955471992, 0.03450586646795273, -0.056086216121912, 0.010767059400677681, 0.007475207559764385, -0.0451822429895401, 0.003542734310030937, 0.027098840102553368, -0.01974990777671337, -0.024907344952225685, 0.043564483523368835, -0.028521208092570305, 0.01177163701504469, -0.006404557731002569, 0.03419414907693863, 0.03704240545630455, 0.03931073099374771, 0.013900306075811386, -0.006893149111419916, 0.0032599675469100475, 0.03943357989192009, 0.0395413376390934, -0.04216672480106354, -0.00409828731790185, -0.05505514517426491, -0.004347947891801596, 0.031359922140836716, -0.027056433260440826, 0.023012379184365273, -0.00748115498572588, 0.01853751204907894, 0.017964037135243416, 0.03475095331668854, 0.07010151445865631, -0.005090005230158567, -0.01568378135561943, 0.002087904140353203, 0.00029479103977791965, 0.02690414898097515, 0.014613516628742218, 0.015099359676241875, 0.03250642120838165, -0.003531861584633589, 0.021548040211200714, -0.011977235786616802, -0.014726337976753712, -0.026873338967561722, -0.009374063462018967, 0.01104599330574274, 0.042685091495513916, 0.00404622545465827, -0.0030742145609110594, -0.058344583958387375, 0.02699296362698078, 0.03251661732792854, 0.02999345026910305, -0.03998269513249397, 0.01692780666053295, -0.016514837741851807, -0.054939113557338715, -0.0077543542720377445, -0.0068747540935873985, -0.009283815510571003, -0.04356006532907486, -0.020756663754582405, -0.013523691333830357, 0.01192364189773798, -0.03893610090017319, -0.002192994114011526, 0.008786487393081188, 0.043660469353199005, -0.038964804261922836, -0.0015478137647733092, 0.022815467789769173, -0.026217980310320854, 0.017577698454260826, -0.07465539872646332, 0.04048426076769829, 0.04026984050869942, -0.019352009519934654, -0.05437914654612541, -0.023017369210720062, -0.05590822547674179, 0.05127732455730438, 0.05264696851372719, 0.049274343997240067, 0.009167673997581005, -0.028102673590183258, 0.002706618048250675, 0.0056475140154361725, -0.07490089535713196, 0.05422266945242882, -0.035050537437200546, -0.03179297596216202, 0.031324248760938644, -0.040377426892519, 0.019566943868994713, 0.019692152738571167, 0.01372771430760622, 0.0059644063003361225, 0.0028989349957555532, 0.023137783631682396, -0.022808430716395378, 0.04103870317339897, -0.022716358304023743, -0.036193519830703735, 0.053026702255010605, 0.007912971079349518, 0.005054892972111702, 0.03395669534802437, 0.02919381856918335, -0.05202893912792206, 0.03177449479699135, -0.04432547464966774, -0.006891441997140646, 0.02585483156144619, -0.009083711542189121, -0.005384067073464394, -0.06355670094490051, -0.0064664240926504135, 0.016419975087046623, -0.013074623420834541, -0.0191727876663208, 0.008137539029121399, 0.02378595620393753, 0.012750763446092606, -0.008249727077782154, 0.049206461757421494, 0.01475539244711399, 0.0005924174911342561, 0.004416349809616804, 0.05342691391706467, 0.013177220709621906, 0.0018885242752730846, -0.003361285664141178, 0.03046262636780739, -0.029486069455742836, 0.03300223872065544, -0.025731073692440987, 0.02846074290573597, -0.001058192108757794, 0.0015189177356660366, 0.02023214101791382, 0.0036477961111813784, -0.01910216733813286, 0.03222034499049187, 0.007940503768622875, 0.02257317118346691, -0.04304274916648865, 0.002779146423563361, -0.00903587881475687, -0.02829381451010704, -0.0184475090354681, -0.017472395673394203, 0.024807633832097054, 0.029730917885899544, 0.0067866952158510685, 0.008555738255381584, 0.027537904679775238, -0.013489970937371254, -0.012670681811869144, -0.023907724767923355, 0.02986449934542179, -0.015829548239707947, 0.02489335648715496, -0.0015585033688694239, -0.008779454044997692, -0.026916850358247757, -0.019761350005865097, 0.040184639394283295, 0.026425214484333992, 0.021636268123984337, -0.01740877702832222, -0.041611574590206146, -0.018850108608603477, 0.05290812626481056, -0.0420091487467289, -0.02300519309937954, -0.05537191033363342, -0.0007881741621531546, 0.0029755900613963604, -0.026349563151597977 ]
<p>I have a database with different variables which contains information such as age, date of vaccination, number of doses as well as the number of antibodies (which is my target variable). If the number of antibodies is under 100 and 10, the patient's antibodies level is regarded as low and very low accordingly. My goal is to create a model by which I would be able to determine WHEN a patient should receive his next vaccination based on these facts. Thus far I have only generated decision trees using R studio. My mathematical knowledge is limited to come up with a solution. How could this be achieved?</p>
73,506
[ -0.03823220357298851, -0.036606986075639725, -0.004647244233638048, -0.009403722360730171, 0.01738741621375084, -0.002046538284048438, 0.0024793639313429594, 0.018870079889893532, 0.041536204516887665, 0.00707580428570509, 0.05773436278104782, 0.0034708811435848475, 0.034349579364061356, 0.038206055760383606, 0.01546711940318346, 0.02384536899626255, 0.025091826915740967, -0.03538908436894417, -0.01816699467599392, -0.0005109676858410239, 0.009786952286958694, 0.019191598519682884, 0.028677813708782196, -0.0066247740760445595, -0.039044611155986786, 0.04487031325697899, 0.047974877059459686, -0.0056472718715667725, -0.01851337030529976, 0.033720266073942184, -0.05386017635464668, -0.026284754276275635, 0.02686813846230507, 0.048216577619314194, 0.043704912066459656, 0.015661103650927544, 0.010460596531629562, -0.02750151790678501, -0.035674482583999634, 0.0042354511097073555, -0.010051369667053223, -0.03265323117375374, 0.0017863701796159148, 0.056483689695596695, -0.023990366607904434, -0.016123611479997635, -0.007776580285280943, -0.029799889773130417, 0.03265295922756195, -0.06799444556236267, 0.06002304330468178, -0.0000015603218344040215, 0.06438814848661423, 0.04156018793582916, -0.030539996922016144, -0.05686015263199806, 0.018913758918642998, 0.07947944849729538, 0.019713109359145164, -0.03195437416434288, -0.026277463883161545, -0.036665938794612885, -0.01836509257555008, 0.007549939677119255, -0.024194274097681046, -0.011282348074018955, 0.0024303144309669733, -0.01812390424311161, -0.007205011323094368, -0.019961141049861908, 0.01829478330910206, -0.019206413999199867, 0.014935534447431564, -0.026694098487496376, 0.030053744092583656, -0.016335563734173775, -0.01808704435825348, -0.002423226833343506, 0.04925822839140892, 0.020406953990459442, -0.004443748854100704, 0.00834047794342041, 0.044663239270448685, 0.055601827800273895, 0.015956075862050056, -0.03867950290441513, 0.05054043233394623, -0.03130402788519859, 0.027795841917395592, 0.013138053007423878, -0.047089673578739166, 0.034489307552576065, 0.04386018589138985, 0.012354064732789993, -0.045017141848802567, 0.03380444645881653, -0.023460999131202698, 0.033470336347818375, 0.03215460479259491, 0.02249106578528881, 0.03810124471783638, -0.052285175770521164, -0.01180148683488369, 0.07121618092060089, -0.027479857206344604, -0.018741490319371223, -0.00463058240711689, -0.03663910925388336, -0.02512592077255249, 0.006081766914576292, -0.03379295766353607, 0.027469493448734283, 0.03871011734008789, -0.004883456509560347, 0.023459874093532562, -0.033277787268161774, -0.01830071210861206, -0.031925756484270096, 0.027802078053355217, 0.03471202030777931, 0.025920063257217407, -0.02365073934197426, 0.017567411065101624, -0.0060760751366615295, -0.04083440080285072, -0.0033192706760019064, -0.002955694915726781, -0.01065849233418703, -0.04484488442540169, 0.06064832583069801, -0.025567878037691116, -0.03187888115644455, 0.03508029878139496, 0.00980019848793745, 0.050351809710264206, -0.021376172080636024, -0.06901843100786209, -0.0398540124297142, 0.015051515772938728, 0.0005889544845558703, 0.028764668852090836, -0.04717407375574112, 0.015436608344316483, 0.04135552793741226, 0.022777395322918892, 0.020576346665620804, 0.02821117267012596, 0.03175588697195053, 0.0022878001909703016, -0.02100573666393757, -0.009604697115719318, 0.007617140654474497, 0.002225930104032159, 0.009991141967475414, -0.020788170397281647, -0.06961970031261444, 0.03071979060769081, 0.028734497725963593, -0.018676087260246277, 0.011099436320364475, 0.04157029464840889, -0.02352754957973957, 0.006389795336872339, 0.01009597722440958, 0.016918180510401726, 0.0014837360940873623, 0.0671471580862999, 0.007641267497092485, 0.014441365376114845, 0.042391180992126465, 0.005224436055868864, 0.0018487742636352777, 0.045843254774808884, 0.023787515237927437, 0.023608187213540077, -0.008784949779510498, -0.016002731397747993, 0.0003280552045907825, 0.014469845220446587, 0.042664967477321625, -0.010270372033119202, -0.03328536078333855, -0.0464475080370903, 0.011218777857720852, 0.033820148557424545, -0.015113739296793938, -0.005055162124335766, 0.0032269801013171673, 0.02932204306125641, -0.025921575725078583, -0.06209145486354828, -0.07156011462211609, -0.008279393427073956, -0.012087138369679451, -0.014459311962127686, 0.0016498613404110074, 0.005870855879038572, -0.041913580149412155, 0.009404229000210762, -0.012574576772749424, -0.07150596380233765, -0.008522291667759418, 0.06632667779922485, -0.03106173872947693, -0.021063650026917458, 0.04933156073093414, 0.04951797053217888, -0.020206868648529053, 0.03426375612616539, -0.08560743927955627, -0.06421112269163132, -0.019725987687706947, -0.04180189222097397, 0.041841693222522736, -0.017947209998965263, -0.036094751209020615, 0.04227767139673233, 0.003805342363193631, -0.02335929684340954, 0.0010621219407767057, -0.09103894978761673, 0.05469106510281563, 0.08205697685480118, 0.028887631371617317, 0.035921528935432434, 0.016715535894036293, -0.004336677957326174, 0.03708751127123833, -0.01739649474620819, -0.047110117971897125, -0.03442288935184479, -0.003048425307497382, 0.017831038683652878, 0.006146636791527271, 0.027680814266204834, 0.0350535549223423, 0.04125354811549187, 0.03339749947190285, 0.00912704598158598, 0.03336244821548462, -0.014071114361286163, 0.05511533468961716, 0.00449364772066474, -0.001123980968259275, -0.024168096482753754, 0.008155199699103832, 0.00893647875636816, -0.016825320199131966, 0.035144321620464325, 0.0011594623792916536, -0.03654312342405319, 0.03262118995189667, 0.04286662116646767, 0.01421043649315834, -0.0017212263774126768, -0.03355376794934273, 0.026503395289182663, -0.03601781278848648, 0.018098121508955956, 0.012858650647103786, 0.00007192525663413107, 0.006505837198346853, 0.029104819521307945, -0.0357142835855484, 0.024308277294039726, 0.05133300647139549, -0.04864867404103279, 0.023279983550310135, 0.0210054200142622, -0.0487932451069355, 0.01577357016503811, -0.024479078128933907, -0.04878389090299606, -0.016642846167087555, 0.006843549199402332, 0.03033219277858734, 0.019179927185177803, 0.0060230134986341, -0.019606800749897957, -0.009463509544730186, 0.041145116090774536, -0.05260426178574562, 0.006076397839933634, 0.001317730755545199, -0.03478221222758293, -0.009812678210437298, 0.01626988872885704, -0.03703373670578003, 0.06659051030874252, 0.01154851634055376, -0.04779805243015289, 0.02603667601943016, -0.009248650632798672, -0.0319783054292202, -0.04298066720366478, -0.031278662383556366, 0.020241908729076385, -0.025096474215388298, -0.028978288173675537, -0.022411826997995377, 0.023068992421030998, -0.0291754100471735, 0.012769519351422787, -0.04917236417531967, -0.009481769986450672, -0.0008076342637650669, 0.0012004936579614878, 0.007857747375965118, 0.007556440774351358, 0.010740065015852451, 0.0292610302567482, 0.014949245378375053, -0.026352545246481895, -0.08819160610437393, -0.049082010984420776, 0.017047936096787453, -0.011178660206496716, 0.03011495992541313, 0.03915286436676979, 0.0028282322455197573, 0.0738849937915802, 0.046689894050359726, -0.02930513396859169, -0.030224919319152832, -0.00801763217896223, -0.0235295407474041, -0.014123925939202309, 0.02280445396900177, 0.012455740012228489, -0.0012514005647972226, -0.004651373252272606, -0.0011166678741574287, 0.015009257942438126, 0.06718110293149948, -0.01991613768041134, -0.034741565585136414, 0.01297002099454403, 0.007005592342466116, 0.01623261161148548, 0.028874674811959267, 0.009973852895200253, -0.02966138906776905, 0.01916506327688694, -0.033160265535116196, 0.022809894755482674, 0.006330329459160566, -0.030842917039990425, -0.005530268885195255, -0.023678723722696304, 0.01358261238783598, -0.04083762317895889, 0.016730496659874916, -0.004751924425363541, 0.0007716609397903085, -0.006594396196305752, 0.01872037537395954, 0.03810786083340645, -0.041719261556863785, -0.012547056190669537, 0.046782005578279495, 0.03224112093448639, -0.014419683255255222, 0.022666577249765396, -0.013894030824303627, -0.019561031833291054, 0.019926130771636963, -0.05250949785113335, 0.014583439566195011, 0.03031213954091072, 0.029658257961273193, -0.0050246152095496655, 0.017110444605350494, -0.06101476401090622, -0.014200177043676376, -0.03712248429656029, -0.03745470196008682, -0.0033363131806254387, 0.05055556073784828, -0.004000849090516567, 0.028472693637013435, 0.0381292998790741, 0.0013839752646163106, 0.03835000470280647, 0.0006663624662905931, -0.08367106318473816, 0.04009481519460678, 0.0093244519084692, 0.021687446162104607, 0.011855551972985268, -0.020377876237034798, -0.021170975640416145, 0.0016027505043894053, -0.01148711983114481, -0.018932316452264786, 0.027341382578015327, -0.011005912907421589, 0.009688414633274078, -0.04288840666413307, 0.018274148926138878, -0.007965154014527798, 0.006488702725619078, 0.01929600164294243, 0.01295752078294754, 0.02806079387664795, -0.002585288370028138, 0.0011944936122745275, 0.00869523361325264, -0.00597019400447607, 0.004479936324059963, 0.037385907024145126, 0.050558656454086304, -0.00448436476290226, 0.027949634939432144, -0.03861643001437187, 0.016122987493872643, 0.003880701959133148, 0.028507186099886894, 0.05509205907583237, 0.0077692423947155476, -0.002062169136479497, -0.09032107889652252, -0.02313605323433876, 0.006818218156695366, -0.007136697880923748, 0.0010111232986673713, -0.0069129932671785355, 0.0799589678645134, -0.009798177517950535, -0.05715993046760559, -0.013057627715170383, 0.08199632167816162, 0.02428872510790825, -0.021089836955070496, -0.00773067120462656, 0.0144687220454216, -0.01087493821978569, 0.0010312310187146068, 0.026211794465780258, 0.021942662075161934, -0.000842939130961895, 0.011638827621936798, 0.04307064414024353, -0.020778357982635498, -0.023950085043907166, -0.034251827746629715, -0.00988780427724123, 0.0626157894730568, 0.03359580039978027, -0.03383566066622734, 0.026781633496284485, 0.02608550153672695, 0.02669770084321499, 0.005709711462259293, 0.02282448671758175, -0.12606769800186157, -0.011834071017801762, 0.02942766807973385, 0.026415925472974777, -0.0068168784491717815, -0.0180970449000597, -0.047704000025987625, -0.006843353156000376, 0.06811124086380005, -0.028012484312057495, 0.04672103002667427, -0.008580182678997517, -0.02028963528573513, -0.013927708379924297, -0.030209358781576157, -0.0028308145701885223, 0.04166087880730629, -0.03177565336227417, 0.035511426627635956, 0.024769524112343788, 0.020977476611733437, -0.058795325458049774, -0.0016371069941669703, 0.01300412230193615, 0.023566115647554398, -0.03391258418560028, -0.026480333879590034, 0.0321730375289917, -0.011850805021822453, -0.035480279475450516, -0.07760724425315857, -0.01909954659640789, 0.0017767264507710934, 0.014486268162727356, 0.04056695103645325, 0.006566064432263374, 0.03213448449969292, 0.013063239865005016, 0.004054657183587551, 0.004872349556535482, -0.011608474887907505, -0.011751514859497547, 0.014311014674603939, 0.007043926976621151, 0.00006296705396380275, 0.03519544005393982, 0.014684891328215599, 0.005087460856884718, -0.0012417007237672806, -0.016431137919425964, 0.01480476837605238, -0.02164290100336075, -0.030479969456791878, -0.02573654241859913, -0.027654075995087624, -0.017869165167212486, -0.013836277648806572, -0.01273037027567625, 0.041957080364227295, -0.0030147593934088945, -0.006239430513232946, -0.012695372104644775, 0.008549517951905727, 0.009449615143239498, -0.023362334817647934, -0.027324454858899117, 0.012835139408707619, -0.012048613280057907, -0.0066402386873960495, 0.0453362837433815, -0.03362840414047241, 0.02928215079009533, -0.0181161817163229, -0.05283090099692345, -0.022205838933587074, -0.01563173718750477, -0.023635033518075943, 0.017620645463466644, -0.006275010295212269, 0.05692686513066292, -0.04340234026312828, 0.01901797577738762, 0.01809690333902836, -0.036144182085990906, -0.035622354596853256, 0.013514894060790539, 0.010230513289570808, 0.02611429989337921, -0.00771257234737277, 0.04665122926235199, -0.04951496794819832, 0.0020047291181981564, -0.041698355227708817, -0.008832339197397232, 0.04511222243309021, 0.012647685594856739, -0.05960703641176224, -0.022646337747573853, 0.013804207555949688, -0.044196031987667084, -0.019398968666791916, -0.030835408717393875, 0.057794198393821716, -0.004576575011014938, 0.011067716404795647, -0.03362306207418442, -0.01660061441361904, 0.059774357825517654, 0.015394551679491997, 0.02473311871290207, 0.028095072135329247, -0.026514042168855667, 0.0010919449850916862, -0.01578528620302677, 0.045757412910461426, -0.030491948127746582, 0.028308682143688202, -0.02512098103761673, 0.014964619651436806, 0.04575416073203087, -0.013644659891724586, 0.009397046640515327, -0.00139565858989954, 0.007937348447740078, -0.00895750429481268, -0.03423029184341431, 0.03142077475786209, -0.0054692476987838745, 0.006742578465491533, -0.05740613117814064, 0.013482294045388699, -0.038644276559352875, 0.0017894519260153174, 0.004614683799445629, -0.004450434818863869, 0.014066634699702263, 0.018888304010033607, 0.0638633444905281, -0.027658341452479362, 0.007126012351363897, 0.007840787060558796, 0.008363760076463223, 0.017233533784747124, 0.0000843607122078538, -0.020976118743419647, -0.014056663028895855, -0.0035343822091817856, -0.04015346243977547, -0.044629406183958054, -0.024303587153553963, 0.004787434823811054, 0.05241835117340088, -0.020331524312496185, 0.051347583532333374, 0.03610613942146301, 0.041238389909267426, 0.00777070689946413, -0.006382198538631201, -0.042474836111068726, -0.03081485629081726, 0.028449399396777153, 0.027180301025509834, 0.0040351031348109245, -0.000015319452359108254, 0.03983784839510918, 0.030902134254574776, 0.013562732376158237, 0.042427822947502136, 0.015537666156888008, 0.001937768654897809, 0.008042371831834316, -0.019655726850032806, -0.02860223315656185, -0.0014716021250933409, -0.06281447410583496, 0.01871478743851185, -0.03292630985379219, -0.051126595586538315, 0.050002116709947586, 0.023366043344140053, -0.012395518831908703, -0.044416945427656174, 0.013039694167673588, -0.04939720779657364, 0.014387802220880985, 0.059454601258039474, -0.005560467950999737, 0.025824978947639465, 0.04504825174808502, 0.007526881992816925, -0.013610818423330784, 0.0071168942376971245, -0.03840252012014389, -0.05813107267022133, -0.025046057999134064, -0.01851370744407177, -0.044178321957588196, 0.021637793630361557, 0.03919849544763565, -0.030261751264333725, -0.000012159381185483653, 0.009191402234137058, -0.01847182773053646, 0.027841176837682724, 0.06566892564296722, 0.021067088469862938, 0.06870640069246292, -0.005502425599843264, 0.017361456528306007, 0.018275469541549683, 0.011657247319817543, 0.11760688573122025, 0.07742302864789963, -0.004540029913187027, -0.04583517462015152, 0.028634287416934967, 0.008044212125241756, 0.014758815988898277, -0.018123693764209747, 0.05983490124344826, -0.004756169393658638, -0.03957837447524071, 0.043070267885923386, 0.0013012565905228257, -0.008075257763266563, -0.002024296671152115, 0.07155635952949524, -0.04373655095696449, -0.06705483049154282, 0.0072625987231731415, 0.01854415237903595, -0.008865191601216793, -0.0075324648059904575, -0.036531392484903336, 0.06679704785346985, 0.021096626296639442, -0.04056452214717865, -0.020476195961236954, -0.020473016425967216, -0.005988737568259239, -0.0473153181374073, -0.006946684326976538, 0.023547474294900894, -0.004980755504220724, 0.009403674863278866, -0.01424155943095684, 0.017613982781767845, 0.016572559252381325, -0.013544916175305843, 0.006129513960331678, 0.04182923957705498, 0.01976891979575157, -0.015600482933223248, -0.036953166127204895, 0.06824345886707306, -0.027469543740153313, 0.0078152846544981, -0.05014172941446304, 0.028650041669607162, -0.0014594418462365866, -0.0010273155057802796, -0.04262017831206322, 0.0039288061670959, 0.03329357132315636, -0.045997343957424164, -0.01617748662829399, 0.028363816440105438, 0.04601839557290077, -0.03935709595680237, -0.007727457210421562, -0.009100648574531078, 0.023656699806451797, -0.02139737829566002, 0.017051249742507935, 0.026079166680574417, -0.007281931582838297, -0.006599118933081627, -0.07029430568218231, 0.03904874995350838, -0.03035137616097927, 0.029981080442667007, 0.019702114164829254, 0.007842988707125187, -0.003492465941235423, -0.0006563188508152962, 0.03636584058403969, -0.0016742085572332144, 0.0037606863770633936, -0.015516088344156742, -0.024267248809337616, -0.01840038038790226, -0.017331641167402267, 0.0006396200624294579, -0.028717808425426483, -0.014101652428507805, -0.03512660413980484, -0.010148354806005955, 0.010407885536551476, 0.045752741396427155, 0.009641301818192005, 0.009241261519491673, -0.003717789426445961, 0.011030977591872215, 0.0025948835536837578, -0.05281200632452965, -0.04658561572432518, -0.01173934992402792, -0.026893703266978264, 0.023678477853536606, -0.014218215830624104, 0.09864487498998642, 0.03204434737563133, 0.03714892640709877, -0.016806501895189285, 0.05184366554021835, -0.03436202555894852, 0.013265438377857208, -0.017966793850064278, -0.06656987220048904, -0.007448066491633654, -0.015737367793917656, -0.007673545274883509, -0.029669588431715965, -0.016080044209957123, 0.012924516573548317, -0.03790077194571495, 0.03719831630587578, -0.01328300405293703, 0.011970127001404762, -0.0037356559187173843, 0.021953362971544266, 0.028793441131711006, -0.011779825203120708, 0.04448172077536583, -0.047985274344682693, 0.002126051113009453, -0.008725049905478954, -0.0593641959130764, -0.016788510605692863, -0.0006705567357130349, 0.004257048945873976, -0.024225391447544098, 0.013478324748575687, 0.0007749844226054847, 0.03148556873202324, 0.006476629059761763, -0.015275753103196621, 0.020537374541163445, 0.0441078245639801, -0.026965349912643433, -0.0543244443833828, 0.026551898568868637, -0.04625938460230827, -0.01804368384182453, 0.010452845133841038, 0.02801387384533882, 0.045394543558359146, 0.0464109405875206, -0.023166537284851074, 0.00992281548678875, 0.042330775409936905, -0.029586857184767723, -0.055748943239450455, -0.00364499120041728, -0.009216169826686382, 0.00886620581150055, 0.016029633581638336, -0.012338139116764069, 0.01646306924521923, -0.008856836706399918, -0.015109692700207233, 0.03280146047472954, 0.01563640870153904, -0.018164103850722313, 0.043010156601667404, 0.0436084009706974, -0.019473372027277946, 0.007321284618228674, -0.003886902006343007, 0.019642086699604988, 0.021661581471562386, 0.0018196840537711978, 0.051123037934303284, -0.005748836323618889, 0.015791144222021103, -0.08286771923303604, -0.002096222946420312, 0.004208180122077465, -0.015808457508683205, 0.044303346425294876, -0.07120370119810104, 0.00993416365236044, 0.02048574760556221, -0.04326840117573738, 0.038938406854867935, -0.02107061631977558, 0.012768189422786236, -0.008892911486327648, 0.0033347217831760645, -0.030393144115805626, 0.04658523574471474, 0.02033313177525997, 0.015475322492420673, 0.03444060683250427, 0.014630420133471489, 0.04936787486076355, -0.06671079993247986, -0.019418619573116302, 0.0396830178797245, 0.031059058383107185, -0.061935462057590485, 0.03595549240708351, -0.04198991879820824, -0.019160181283950806, -0.006288595963269472, -0.025231294333934784, 0.03530509024858475, 0.05473664402961731, 0.03630769997835159, 0.04250649735331535, 0.0917125716805458, 0.017645960673689842, -0.004747152328491211, 0.0032745024655014277, -0.017625661566853523, 0.005664101801812649, 0.014372138306498528, -0.015925344079732895, 0.04235788434743881, 0.053394392132759094, -0.01543871033936739, -0.019849034026265144, -0.003512892872095108, -0.012746143154799938, -0.03447149693965912, 0.006761436816304922, -0.03470146283507347, -0.012173358350992203, -0.013370229862630367, -0.028095562011003494, -0.015049932524561882, 0.02034207060933113, 0.06562932580709457, 0.011550946161150932, 0.00291209714487195, -0.009750747121870518, -0.052528250962495804, -0.03631017729640007, 0.0014358100015670061, 0.020052585750818253, -0.002343700034543872, -0.035572219640016556, 0.022412730380892754, -0.017062941566109657, -0.018707841634750366, -0.024035701528191566, 0.031898364424705505, -0.03151055425405502, 0.03251572698354721, -0.01720319129526615, 0.0030330694280564785, 0.03901693969964981, -0.008814585395157337, 0.037235330790281296, -0.07065058499574661, 0.04051550477743149, 0.02528788335621357, -0.012706881389021873, -0.0451921671628952, -0.04279191046953201, -0.05288718268275261, 0.010696087032556534, 0.05163939669728279, 0.011502478271722794, -0.005380574148148298, -0.013305135071277618, 0.011465621180832386, -0.0045369649305939674, -0.06688066571950912, 0.04743700101971626, -0.03223201259970665, 0.01302708126604557, -0.053619787096977234, 0.008885690942406654, 0.036899350583553314, -0.016505029052495956, -0.020205339416861534, 0.016904747113585472, -0.016556736081838608, -0.007450442295521498, 0.000969983171671629, 0.0030932424124330282, 0.020456625148653984, -0.005413340404629707, 0.015420635230839252, 0.003563560778275132, -0.009967797435820103, 0.04029546678066254, 0.029721776023507118, -0.05329760164022446, 0.03871550410985947, -0.02600593864917755, -0.03223491832613945, -0.0052238646894693375, -0.002220766618847847, -0.0064020040445029736, -0.05917203053832054, -0.0073274653404951096, 0.0423143096268177, -0.01530517265200615, 0.012222963385283947, 0.05838153883814812, -0.012476927600800991, 0.056756392121315, 0.0013472806895151734, 0.040047287940979004, -0.0043101320043206215, -0.02046346105635166, -0.022010033950209618, -0.02146538533270359, 0.00029163650469854474, -0.00816987082362175, 0.011206847615540028, 0.03689573332667351, 0.02593439258635044, 0.008511832915246487, -0.002005545888096094, -0.0031094893347471952, 0.020735956728458405, -0.01530107855796814, -0.02169990725815296, -0.03327538073062897, 0.008093100972473621, 0.00736045790836215, -0.0033480117563158274, 0.05156790837645531, -0.05007828772068024, -0.022016866132616997, -0.020078333094716072, -0.02551426738500595, -0.06889428943395615, -0.00426360173150897, 0.034746844321489334, 0.018486257642507553, -0.015805140137672424, 0.014817426912486553, 0.005182208493351936, 0.006602297071367502, -0.0034073570277541876, -0.029418867081403732, 0.05390942841768265, 0.02784116566181183, -0.03399168327450752, -0.017354456707835197, -0.0012842321302741766, -0.043777212500572205, -0.012223134748637676, 0.018255459144711494, 0.04284657910466194, 0.02901438996195793, 0.021531593054533005, -0.0010507905390113592, -0.029681693762540817, 0.0022222816478461027, -0.04563724994659424, -0.02289191074669361, -0.06653520464897156, -0.015190676786005497, -0.00021647058019880205, -0.016731228679418564 ]
<p>Suppose we have a training data set with variables $a,b$ and $c$ and binary outcome variable $y$. We fit a logistic regression model to this data set:</p> <p>$$\text{logit}(p) = \hat{\beta_0}+ \hat{\beta_{1}}a + \hat{\beta_{2}}b + \hat{\beta_{3}}c$$</p> <p>When we get the predicted probabilities from the training data set using the logistic regression model, are we supposed to get perfect classification? Or this depend on the threshold we use? </p>
73,507
[ -0.026852397248148918, -0.01689310371875763, -0.006511874962598085, -0.002373943803831935, 0.021594194695353508, 0.029109202325344086, -0.016821160912513733, -0.015943845734000206, 0.0575670450925827, 0.013469035737216473, 0.03068247251212597, 0.050199780613183975, 0.041908010840415955, 0.027588140219449997, 0.03258122131228447, -0.025444721803069115, 0.004518080968409777, 0.0057674297131598, -0.010299804620444775, 0.012448756024241447, -0.013948168605566025, 0.03020581044256687, 0.04714379832148552, 0.023275919258594513, -0.02319425903260708, 0.03828210383653641, 0.025845946744084358, 0.009048094041645527, 0.011524016037583351, 0.04606375843286514, -0.02715335413813591, -0.011145107448101044, 0.011688192375004292, 0.04873509332537651, 0.03004263900220394, 0.013383478857576847, -0.0008830934530124068, -0.023383941501379013, -0.0015574051067233086, -0.009567692875862122, -0.014764487743377686, -0.034064482897520065, 0.04185735434293747, 0.019385114312171936, -0.011538945138454437, 0.009686386212706566, -0.0020138609688729048, -0.018512465059757233, 0.023002589121460915, -0.03921142965555191, 0.021919982507824898, -0.010198116302490234, 0.03877323865890503, 0.02531934343278408, 0.01084685605019331, -0.007373434025794268, 0.0515311099588871, 0.09134507179260254, -0.038827620446681976, -0.03817490115761757, -0.021983223035931587, -0.02309209108352661, 0.005706958007067442, -0.017541972920298576, -0.045159418135881424, 0.04230710491538048, -0.005726309027522802, -0.0377676896750927, 0.03775030001997948, 0.014352977275848389, 0.012102846056222916, 0.018551001325249672, 0.047294262796640396, -0.0082601523026824, 0.059757884591817856, -0.02984100580215454, 0.003461840795353055, 0.05079907551407814, -0.0005375243490561843, 0.01542861107736826, 0.026368798688054085, 0.03146331012248993, 0.019012736156582832, 0.0848638266324997, 0.017042851075530052, -0.030316967517137527, 0.07837844640016556, -0.01682323031127453, -0.0005117881228215992, 0.016663827002048492, -0.01978467032313347, 0.0065076653845608234, 0.023584190756082535, -0.02350996620953083, -0.03209858760237694, 0.03852889686822891, -0.010484892874956131, 0.038216523826122284, 0.031371742486953735, -0.014911032281816006, 0.0028043328784406185, -0.022525081411004066, -0.013789407908916473, 0.06730522960424423, -0.026406699791550636, -0.019946059212088585, -0.03793732076883316, -0.015261885710060596, 0.0011204072507098317, -0.032107725739479065, -0.019772494211792946, 0.03472578525543213, 0.013298267498612404, 0.005737685598433018, -0.0076812743209302425, -0.011063897982239723, -0.0012236727634444833, -0.06726890802383423, 0.03333183005452156, 0.0047757490538060665, 0.03844622150063515, -0.04947339743375778, 0.020037531852722168, -0.01696612685918808, -0.014787784777581692, -0.009176277555525303, 0.014485486783087254, -0.016816847026348114, -0.05039646103978157, 0.013867891393601894, -0.007010705303400755, -0.03158561512827873, 0.005391219165176153, 0.015961231663823128, -0.000815117615275085, 0.002999381860718131, -0.05192839726805687, -0.02801722101867199, -0.004605046473443508, -0.012619992718100548, 0.010148917324841022, -0.051936306059360504, -0.025890540331602097, 0.03808216378092766, 0.019906427711248398, -0.0009699359652586281, 0.02429671585559845, 0.04238437861204147, 0.015874164178967476, 0.01303091924637556, -0.0002809216675814241, 0.0137710552662611, -0.02220974490046501, -0.025947146117687225, -0.016655847430229187, -0.09779897332191467, 0.008791226893663406, 0.0249050110578537, -0.006941786501556635, -0.04604746028780937, 0.03006446734070778, -0.009322108700871468, -0.024560250341892242, -0.016259057447314262, -0.0332527756690979, 0.0036918253172188997, 0.05531696230173111, 0.012824500910937786, 0.053948819637298584, 0.03172298148274422, 0.00490738358348608, 0.026026573032140732, 0.02353534661233425, 0.05641714110970497, 0.03136061877012253, -0.02871687151491642, -0.01410630438476801, -0.06922979652881622, 0.05581765994429588, -0.004383494146168232, -0.04287441447377205, -0.020766912028193474, -0.04900428280234337, 0.03069586493074894, 0.014860235154628754, 0.05036178603768349, 0.02019786462187767, -0.017979713156819344, 0.03514717146754265, -0.024779001250863075, -0.06959780305624008, -0.05408856272697449, 0.012820965610444546, -0.004455007147043943, -0.028385797515511513, 0.021281041204929352, 0.011735387146472931, 0.04189910367131233, -0.019212547689676285, 0.042515430599451065, -0.042455174028873444, -0.007513813208788633, 0.022369787096977234, -0.050929319113492966, 0.02366594411432743, 0.06564837694168091, 0.035969141870737076, 0.012624873779714108, 0.05651293322443962, -0.05405049026012421, -0.06837788224220276, 0.023180998861789703, 0.00949233490973711, 0.005039266310632229, -0.016454942524433136, -0.030726300552487373, 0.01773235760629177, -0.006242291070520878, -0.021218838170170784, 0.0388326533138752, -0.06938834488391876, 0.05371856689453125, 0.038200750946998596, -0.015086550265550613, 0.005194750148802996, -0.013130027800798416, -0.03703969344496727, 0.032963961362838745, -0.005830666050314903, -0.039840228855609894, -0.07027983665466309, 0.00755483191460371, 0.013934274204075336, -0.0010039976332336664, -0.022086570039391518, 0.034961894154548645, 0.01735917665064335, -0.008152072317898273, 0.022655688226222992, 0.018066193908452988, 0.014762097038328648, 0.003782084211707115, 0.03740356117486954, 0.02686435356736183, 0.010920921340584755, 0.005625654943287373, 0.016584983095526695, 0.008417926728725433, 0.04121625795960426, -0.001644089468754828, -0.013552321121096611, 0.0758044496178627, -0.0010596393840387464, -0.018881719559431076, -0.014500442892313004, -0.009696567431092262, 0.05267983675003052, -0.019336706027388573, 0.00966466125100851, 0.047261398285627365, 0.02518974430859089, -0.00818711705505848, 0.00234318058937788, 0.0026478220243006945, 0.04023756459355354, 0.07493048906326294, -0.027960142120718956, -0.00325170555151999, 0.02068564109504223, -0.06578729301691055, 0.019581491127610207, -0.0014065513387322426, -0.05337014049291611, -0.024922974407672882, 0.03176821395754814, 0.04929984733462334, 0.006753498688340187, 0.04805202782154083, -0.026002762839198112, -0.05411270260810852, 0.015484231524169445, -0.019884660840034485, 0.0443643182516098, 0.004949659574776888, -0.04607801511883736, -0.0283636674284935, -0.04386691749095917, -0.01795819215476513, 0.010229591280221939, -0.029705265536904335, 0.002273497637361288, -0.01422596350312233, -0.048366792500019073, -0.030973413959145546, -0.029254768043756485, -0.03636801615357399, 0.01543120015412569, -0.018582435324788094, -0.028004946187138557, 0.02370361238718033, 0.010644632391631603, -0.03842291980981827, -0.0033775409683585167, -0.016933640465140343, -0.03169460594654083, -0.015677236020565033, 0.0016922465292736888, 0.049538690596818924, -0.008096389472484589, 0.013780076056718826, 0.02978535182774067, -0.01708439365029335, -0.0071589271537959576, -0.07761458307504654, -0.07782010734081268, 0.031346533447504044, -0.03175985440611839, 0.0026747938245534897, 0.005044405814260244, 0.008599621243774891, 0.07724745571613312, 0.0377531498670578, -0.0050158193334937096, -0.014447192661464214, 0.012642168439924717, -0.02910579741001129, -0.007981417700648308, 0.014324070885777473, 0.01951417699456215, 0.01758471690118313, 0.03646214306354523, -0.013598929159343243, 0.030764952301979065, 0.03256501257419586, 0.0028652288019657135, -0.016640478745102882, 0.008260036818683147, 0.04080314561724663, -0.04444298893213272, -0.010279390960931778, 0.041814811527729034, -0.016121244058012962, 0.02399708889424801, -0.012051251716911793, 0.03312283009290695, 0.02603006735444069, -0.02132205106317997, 0.02057189680635929, -0.03159279376268387, 0.04312201961874962, -0.014582052826881409, 0.018938535824418068, 0.01754656806588173, -0.04488735273480415, -0.0070634521543979645, -0.01789894327521324, 0.00887240655720234, -0.018412737175822258, -0.005614944268018007, 0.012388849630951881, 0.04646717756986618, -0.009677371941506863, -0.03169696405529976, 0.008862756192684174, -0.022023599594831467, 0.02269565872848034, 0.0022142017260193825, 0.00464565260335803, 0.026312028989195824, 0.03759916126728058, -0.009024886414408684, -0.031789593398571014, -0.0377524308860302, -0.01039850153028965, -0.07055090367794037, -0.004323568660765886, -0.016344211995601654, 0.03654927760362625, 0.018624797463417053, 0.021727636456489563, 0.006298244930803776, -0.0039694784209132195, 0.035501640290021896, 0.03976305201649666, -0.07689666748046875, 0.008559639565646648, -0.01375977136194706, -0.004874758422374725, -0.0018672547303140163, -0.03418246656656265, 0.05301349237561226, -0.05623985081911087, -0.02415243536233902, -0.013425726443529129, 0.0011894658673554659, -0.01479001808911562, -0.011327994987368584, 0.002866144757717848, -0.018269704654812813, 0.007981473580002785, -0.004384420812129974, -0.026581546291708946, 0.031638532876968384, 0.014699880965054035, 0.06251757591962814, 0.00041044893441721797, -0.008325167000293732, -0.0058760568499565125, -0.0037503873463720083, 0.014816319569945335, 0.08373542875051498, 0.014448543079197407, 0.023770984262228012, -0.03600117936730385, 0.033232033252716064, -0.01515875943005085, 0.05401981994509697, 0.029968228191137314, -0.016484785825014114, -0.0368490107357502, -0.051330775022506714, -0.02831643633544445, -0.001424199203029275, -0.0016322375740855932, 0.005242642015218735, -0.000174465385498479, 0.05592031031847, 0.04427367448806763, -0.0783088356256485, -0.009566769003868103, 0.051380790770053864, -0.019084855914115906, -0.018126484006643295, -0.039635490626096725, 0.016266902908682823, -0.02554485946893692, -0.02647119015455246, 0.004756432492285967, -0.00028673047199845314, -0.044039689004421234, 0.002037682803347707, 0.04986165836453438, 0.018087496981024742, -0.029831087216734886, 0.0012146102963015437, 0.013502519577741623, 0.019953103736042976, -0.00799910631030798, -0.057369131594896317, -0.008440895937383175, 0.06526291370391846, 0.020648909732699394, 0.010685781016945839, -0.011063236743211746, -0.06673039495944977, -0.004772144835442305, 0.0409323014318943, 0.03771119937300682, -0.052826087921857834, -0.00717628188431263, -0.025194838643074036, 0.011033914051949978, 0.015028482303023338, -0.03208138048648834, 0.01884591020643711, -0.02323889546096325, 0.008074883371591568, -0.004982866812497377, -0.016825227066874504, -0.09421080350875854, 0.011854706332087517, -0.0032335580326616764, 0.022125698626041412, 0.0037288377061486244, -0.0032220229040831327, -0.041000332683324814, 0.02418842539191246, -0.0179104246199131, 0.06882056593894958, -0.03363383561372757, -0.011908807791769505, 0.0021450617350637913, 0.014887453988194466, 0.008930080570280552, -0.06105417385697365, -0.01948641426861286, 0.00968845747411251, -0.0273720882833004, 0.01814436912536621, 0.006511429324746132, -0.0484219454228878, 0.01597042754292488, 0.02073669247329235, -0.00823452789336443, -0.0005687712109647691, -0.03892822936177254, 0.020469676703214645, 0.018702292814850807, -0.0005659412126988173, 0.06145041808485985, 0.03387950733304024, 0.008552254177629948, -0.03064991720020771, -0.04123704880475998, 0.00929020531475544, -0.0034022394102066755, -0.021571142598986626, -0.019170742481946945, -0.0006682212697342038, 0.004388066474348307, 0.023135937750339508, -0.00020876286725979298, 0.02789689600467682, -0.023946143686771393, 0.00007872293645050377, -0.029109757393598557, -0.006304587237536907, 0.00732226250693202, -0.0034425128251314163, -0.019619733095169067, 0.029312163591384888, -0.0025416817516088486, 0.007153083570301533, -0.008417708799242973, -0.0012431766372174025, 0.023048456758260727, 0.001322832191362977, -0.02742977999150753, 0.03446043282747269, -0.028318209573626518, -0.025325877591967583, 0.005555311217904091, -0.031646281480789185, 0.020269710570573807, 0.019930921494960785, 0.011349118314683437, -0.012343485839664936, -0.034293536096811295, -0.032397739589214325, -0.00832225102931261, 0.01733008585870266, 0.020638039335608482, -0.04846253991127014, 0.00921939592808485, -0.022299423813819885, -0.000955805997364223, -0.07373396307229996, -0.059100594371557236, 0.004529154393821955, 0.012149694375693798, -0.026820283383131027, -0.0011937044328078628, 0.020502986386418343, 0.001818614429794252, -0.048246730118989944, -0.004781065043061972, 0.08224254846572876, -0.04545458406209946, -0.02645317278802395, -0.02093152515590191, 0.011653846129775047, 0.07143835723400116, 0.021429868414998055, -0.0009332418558187783, 0.00453889649361372, -0.008238107897341251, -0.03201817348599434, 0.009192761033773422, 0.033287376165390015, -0.0250700730830431, -0.04445137083530426, -0.016376569867134094, 0.015332099981606007, 0.028413834050297737, -0.019322004169225693, -0.0112002557143569, 0.014579595066606998, 0.008288433775305748, -0.002232741564512253, -0.0012439143611118197, -0.004229766316711903, 0.004273750353604555, -0.009043815545737743, -0.0024263167288154364, -0.009664366021752357, -0.010421042330563068, -0.02446543425321579, 0.0431864969432354, 0.00801326148211956, -0.009067305363714695, -0.009924818761646748, 0.07921327650547028, -0.001773869851604104, 0.01692119985818863, -0.05049792304635048, -0.06775671988725662, 0.06503593176603317, 0.026235101744532585, -0.022487999871373177, 0.0325399786233902, 0.015648920089006424, -0.03098716400563717, -0.001357857952825725, -0.07817988097667694, 0.00002569081334513612, 0.04139761999249458, 0.007698096334934235, 0.024111635982990265, 0.02374988980591297, 0.015575503930449486, -0.000921119877602905, -0.05120663344860077, -0.019279323518276215, -0.00631228182464838, 0.00045299765770323575, 0.024179808795452118, 0.012669023126363754, -0.03623701632022858, 0.034783460199832916, -0.01065277773886919, 0.01404983177781105, 0.012777567841112614, 0.030055612325668335, 0.0022273119539022446, 0.0015236272010952234, -0.023557772859930992, -0.02259613201022148, 0.04418002814054489, -0.03935403376817703, 0.0048720501363277435, -0.018664848059415817, -0.02614600583910942, 0.0466916523873806, -0.001654196996241808, 0.030865196138620377, -0.06079475209116936, -0.038369014859199524, -0.03483773022890091, 0.008050069212913513, 0.004172083456069231, 0.0031267981976270676, 0.024314070120453835, -0.003829320427030325, -0.0017205867916345596, -0.024241596460342407, 0.029794305562973022, 0.006866210140287876, -0.10960143804550171, -0.06388620287179947, -0.009705101139843464, -0.038361627608537674, 0.004198129288852215, 0.02810853347182274, -0.014219270087778568, 0.02473246306180954, -0.04736144840717316, 0.0491594560444355, 0.018227489665150642, 0.0682590901851654, 0.012321440503001213, 0.03995777294039726, 0.012158245779573917, 0.030698010697960854, 0.01987253688275814, 0.00880866963416338, 0.14916056394577026, 0.08462722599506378, 0.026638569310307503, -0.06953960657119751, 0.021792558953166008, 0.004385410342365503, -0.006618298124521971, 0.011424452066421509, -0.016666311770677567, 0.008091391064226627, -0.0067841545678675175, 0.049859434366226196, 0.011308546178042889, 0.009562269784510136, 0.019636429846286774, 0.05330711975693703, -0.048479821532964706, -0.0007360007730312645, 0.02546580135822296, 0.03299207240343094, -0.01863272674381733, -0.011259369552135468, -0.015416883863508701, -0.007164280861616135, 0.011109128594398499, -0.018383756279945374, -0.017228733748197556, -0.0181556586176157, 0.020688101649284363, -0.026406342163681984, 0.007788471411913633, -0.021073024719953537, 0.009883259423077106, -0.0011735056759789586, 0.005693782586604357, -0.010578191839158535, -0.004801606293767691, -0.03018481656908989, -0.01776120439171791, 0.01917395368218422, -0.02540888637304306, -0.0044380296021699905, -0.0009013940580189228, -0.013666423037648201, -0.05037252604961395, -0.05344949662685394, -0.05479522794485092, 0.04811294376850128, -0.033930227160453796, 0.016836609691381454, 0.0030181396286934614, -0.004335475154221058, -0.019047893583774567, -0.020005453377962112, -0.04198598861694336, 0.056513261049985886, 0.012048391625285149, -0.011778497137129307, -0.028261180967092514, -0.04842642322182655, 0.025123290717601776, -0.016908178105950356, 0.039087578654289246, 0.0033871650230139494, -0.05663131922483444, -0.012012778781354427, -0.0033470499329268932, 0.049532461911439896, 0.0060418699868023396, 0.03828337788581848, 0.021186649799346924, -0.0196743905544281, -0.02309533953666687, -0.035788919776678085, 0.009345643222332, -0.004608341492712498, 0.023101288825273514, -0.00728215929120779, -0.026500925421714783, -0.020938819274306297, -0.042375460267066956, -0.0012322836555540562, -0.027824219316244125, 0.018679551780223846, -0.04638936370611191, 0.01662438176572323, 0.01915084943175316, 0.04452325776219368, 0.05134642496705055, 0.011125841177999973, 0.01103409007191658, 0.003944988828152418, -0.008051838725805283, -0.043441228568553925, -0.006526016164571047, 0.022446200251579285, -0.04384152591228485, 0.025726506486535072, 0.01324185449630022, 0.0856824666261673, 0.020612426102161407, 0.06118345633149147, -0.0163761917501688, 0.03022932820022106, 0.015433440916240215, 0.03921177238225937, -0.005758427083492279, -0.025979191064834595, -0.028630713000893593, 0.004513926338404417, 0.023635758087038994, -0.04150068014860153, -0.05823732167482376, -0.04882313683629036, -0.029850881546735764, 0.03351292759180069, -0.014775571413338184, -0.038398388773202896, 0.03204342722892761, 0.020075498148798943, 0.01986256055533886, -0.044074896723032, -0.015085672028362751, -0.023566005751490593, 0.010316809639334679, 0.010178355500102043, -0.02122565172612667, 0.02539205551147461, 0.012437994591891766, -0.010577529668807983, -0.008331638760864735, 0.040754470974206924, 0.020582707598805428, 0.031448908150196075, 0.0015962879406288266, 0.024827957153320312, -0.012875710614025593, 0.03613642603158951, -0.026595741510391235, -0.015500033274292946, 0.025982631370425224, -0.03791172802448273, -0.02810216322541237, 0.01467833761125803, -0.008373841643333435, 0.023173479363322258, 0.023600514978170395, 0.018171124160289764, -0.007944991812109947, 0.041833922266960144, 0.0012120045721530914, -0.01852186769247055, -0.008687497116625309, 0.02787053771317005, 0.0018023642478510737, 0.036148712038993835, 0.013267885893583298, 0.010341891087591648, -0.022579984739422798, 0.028141696006059647, 0.025624185800552368, 0.015264962799847126, -0.003976362757384777, 0.034064821898937225, -0.00914816651493311, 0.035395361483097076, -0.007257595658302307, -0.006196571979671717, -0.003569426480680704, 0.021758830174803734, 0.00007958299829624593, 0.07452374696731567, 0.012410754337906837, 0.015940118581056595, -0.10446690768003464, -0.0607585534453392, 0.040244169533252716, 0.009583799168467522, 0.015867996960878372, -0.05020875856280327, 0.009613395668566227, 0.034585416316986084, -0.014647779986262321, 0.03142904117703438, 0.027938973158597946, 0.012838554568588734, -0.038691919296979904, 0.02656528912484646, -0.010729312896728516, 0.02667802758514881, 0.050071652978658676, 0.006326778791844845, 0.010127285495400429, 0.01860930025577545, 0.0005994050879962742, -0.017945175990462303, -0.027550112456083298, 0.033519770950078964, -0.010268387384712696, -0.05492999404668808, 0.065284863114357, -0.03419204428792, -0.02825341746211052, 0.05651179701089859, 0.017863532528281212, -0.00214572437107563, 0.04440690204501152, 0.017113719135522842, 0.013613401912152767, 0.037360720336437225, 0.04230375215411186, -0.01036427728831768, -0.02122598886489868, 0.0422901026904583, 0.036992620676755905, 0.03395871818065643, -0.033986493945121765, -0.01328098401427269, -0.0025399497244507074, -0.005166166462004185, -0.07086494565010071, 0.0011635404080152512, -0.004412648268043995, -0.031383298337459564, -0.02979741431772709, 0.008970736525952816, -0.01491160225123167, -0.0371716283261776, 0.025950074195861816, -0.05057092383503914, 0.01072571612894535, 0.028478533029556274, 0.025393197312951088, -0.019935758784413338, -0.0055847689509391785, -0.01777883991599083, -0.02875889092683792, 0.011120186187326908, 0.019109375774860382, -0.01204695738852024, -0.030101433396339417, 0.01537902932614088, 0.038402851670980453, -0.01950226165354252, -0.0015579279279336333, -0.01842542178928852, -0.05468497797846794, 0.028935348615050316, -0.04376661404967308, 0.030425308272242546, 0.04203611612319946, -0.033762138336896896, -0.015027448534965515, -0.08997925370931625, 0.09427571296691895, 0.01502267923206091, -0.029177961871027946, -0.036911845207214355, 0.020088106393814087, -0.052737146615982056, -0.011525269597768784, 0.06690137088298798, 0.0002566691837273538, -0.02013031393289566, -0.0382523350417614, 0.030446471646428108, 0.0038689272478222847, -0.025877855718135834, -0.017239173874258995, -0.017493408173322678, -0.04844066873192787, -0.01644257828593254, -0.005852022673934698, -0.0036150128580629826, 0.04808588698506355, 0.005547497421503067, -0.0281841941177845, 0.02939644455909729, -0.0030892679933458567, 0.0019859091844409704, 0.05436112359166145, -0.014672743156552315, 0.01052121538668871, 0.06032109260559082, 0.0048755151219666, 0.03638037294149399, 0.012580275535583496, -0.02267199195921421, -0.05868610367178917, 0.004193376284092665, -0.032332465052604675, -0.04135071858763695, -0.0013961729127913713, 0.017565039917826653, -0.00543608795851469, -0.03520176187157631, 0.03272038325667381, 0.035633914172649384, -0.00941773783415556, 0.02828773856163025, 0.014272394590079784, 0.004822328221052885, 0.049718935042619705, -0.036412667483091354, 0.02468620054423809, 0.026470083743333817, -0.029616430401802063, 0.025587009266018867, 0.022168440744280815, 0.011132054030895233, 0.004333502147346735, 0.03123338706791401, 0.023090114817023277, 0.009661968797445297, 0.024292130023241043, 0.0021793378982692957, 0.06041470542550087, -0.02094080299139023, 0.009801236912608147, 0.015362843871116638, -0.0024249611888080835, 0.025424355641007423, 0.0014953133650124073, 0.018436184152960777, 0.06352657079696655, -0.004770184867084026, 0.0031647400464862585, -0.037012845277786255, -0.025087401270866394, -0.011831752024590969, -0.0214821919798851, 0.018340349197387695, 0.05289104953408241, 0.022200947627425194, -0.01570422388613224, 0.003823196981102228, -0.002109635155647993, 0.03428178280591965, -0.013296233490109444, 0.010447765700519085, -0.021408168599009514, -0.033009786158800125, -0.019972633570432663, -0.028314275667071342, -0.02985529415309429, -0.037350986152887344, 0.013520822860300541, 0.0473775677382946, 0.021319972351193428, 0.0012814906658604741, -0.02668512426316738, -0.008299062959849834, 0.034733954817056656, -0.05692972242832184, 0.01632644236087799, -0.07605306804180145, 0.008554328233003616, 0.006419022101908922, -0.0903942659497261 ]
<p>What is the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skew_normal_distribution" rel="nofollow">skew normal</a> approximation to Poisson($\lambda$)?</p> <p><a href="http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=Skewness%5BSkewNormalDistribution%5B%CE%BC%2C%CE%BC%2C%CE%B1%5D%5D%3DSkewness%5BPoissonDistribution%5B%CE%BC%5D%5D%20solve%20for%20%CE%B1" rel="nofollow">Am I doing this wrong?</a></p>
73,508
[ -0.03215086832642555, -0.03282768651843071, 0.00842331163585186, -0.006989983841776848, 0.04214173182845116, 0.009910610504448414, 0.009838580153882504, -0.016788950189948082, 0.025370605289936066, -0.03119194693863392, 0.03388146311044693, 0.039131756871938705, 0.04372531175613403, 0.005234336946159601, 0.06396372616291046, 0.010749035514891148, -0.034363266080617905, 0.00330315250903368, 0.0014667477225884795, 0.0029420070350170135, 0.01098213717341423, 0.02724740281701088, 0.02428128756582737, -0.013235112652182579, -0.02898765169084072, 0.016756994649767876, 0.011106424033641815, -0.012548130936920643, 0.017057614400982857, 0.06517361104488373, -0.03874768689274788, 0.00748431496322155, 0.0324569009244442, 0.03472023457288742, 0.03130285069346428, 0.023241980001330376, -0.002559823449701071, -0.0012032086960971355, -0.012643679976463318, 0.0027437275275588036, -0.04307779669761658, -0.007299560122191906, 0.0056059896014630795, 0.05210407078266144, 0.002698528813198209, 0.035318538546562195, -0.025066081434488297, -0.07829495519399643, 0.04512590169906616, -0.040992267429828644, 0.06367872655391693, -0.023911943659186363, 0.025964340195059776, 0.05985172837972641, 0.028263742104172707, -0.021765265613794327, 0.07562709599733353, 0.04843470826745033, -0.018299639225006104, -0.05369830131530762, 0.018673814833164215, -0.024072423577308655, -0.03492860496044159, -0.009985134936869144, -0.024263955652713776, 0.021470310166478157, -0.019024798646569252, -0.04137077555060387, 0.03817100450396538, 0.001222487073391676, 0.01328184362500906, 0.032259345054626465, 0.032132841646671295, -0.049195777624845505, 0.005472450517117977, -0.023045256733894348, 0.015501892194151878, 0.022187208756804466, 0.02255362831056118, 0.029630176723003387, 0.020400505512952805, 0.0011582651641219854, 0.03168877959251404, 0.04290251061320305, 0.020670823752880096, -0.03387439623475075, 0.09196466952562332, -0.005516930017620325, 0.020738553255796432, 0.03964279964566231, -0.025316456332802773, 0.00025918782921507955, 0.02680313028395176, -0.018763937056064606, -0.011022590100765228, 0.06485722959041595, -0.024973377585411072, 0.02099600061774254, -0.011148269288241863, -0.04617667943239212, -0.009097934700548649, -0.04624209180474281, 0.004272693768143654, 0.06762226670980453, -0.008596597239375114, -0.004738365299999714, -0.029004408046603203, 0.028140291571617126, -0.011954297311604023, -0.02406422793865204, -0.042990993708372116, 0.008644575253129005, 0.0022258178796619177, -0.024334989488124847, -0.016018912196159363, -0.020279107615351677, 0.005122843198478222, -0.010512770153582096, 0.009291882626712322, 0.06793077290058136, 0.02014201506972313, 0.003438647836446762, 0.04297887161374092, -0.031391121447086334, -0.05345136299729347, 0.030514424666762352, 0.030010858550667763, -0.015332942828536034, -0.05364770069718361, 0.05142941325902939, 0.02276509441435337, -0.01583891175687313, 0.029652904719114304, -0.001996221486479044, 0.03189772740006447, -0.06183474510908127, -0.08151303231716156, -0.03244679048657417, 0.026000607758760452, -0.020174618810415268, 0.030615607276558876, -0.07271675020456314, -0.019987016916275024, 0.017758207395672798, 0.03984178602695465, 0.017855176702141762, 0.014750057831406593, -0.0015284586697816849, 0.00533281359821558, -0.008086638525128365, -0.021784253418445587, 0.008538161404430866, 0.011452249251306057, -0.04847298935055733, 0.02998458966612816, -0.10388706624507904, -0.015195643529295921, 0.016801025718450546, 0.020982516929507256, -0.010741912759840488, 0.036413077265024185, 0.0016911368584260345, -0.013056797906756401, -0.04116183519363403, 0.027913423255085945, -0.03646016865968704, 0.09306991845369339, 0.014314319007098675, 0.02330150455236435, 0.01238627452403307, -0.042963907122612, -0.0059874881990253925, -0.027219949290156364, 0.049791596829891205, 0.05605126544833183, -0.03407525643706322, -0.022937828674912453, -0.037887103855609894, 0.05748170614242554, -0.002272720215842128, -0.06468819826841354, 0.002875233069062233, 0.007893028669059277, 0.04078095406293869, 0.001700489199720323, 0.05348909646272659, -0.0012462283484637737, 0.017236795276403427, 0.0034307390451431274, -0.046701207756996155, -0.043310653418302536, -0.03901496157050133, -0.002453816821798682, -0.017472565174102783, -0.015003724955022335, 0.042803917080163956, 0.015978515148162842, 0.012081881053745747, -0.007967459969222546, -0.011947761289775372, -0.02805023081600666, -0.010864919051527977, 0.024205034598708153, -0.030871955677866936, 0.029680734500288963, 0.06231251731514931, 0.03735942393541336, -0.028951892629265785, 0.04166203364729881, -0.052677273750305176, -0.02948322705924511, -0.02277301996946335, -0.05365341156721115, 0.028645535930991173, -0.008784824050962925, 0.016415603458881378, 0.020683398470282555, 0.007762284018099308, 0.016775649040937424, 0.022075515240430832, -0.045901261270046234, 0.03457649052143097, 0.051405392587184906, 0.012704607099294662, -0.001972302794456482, 0.004496073350310326, 0.003929244354367256, 0.013504760339856148, -0.00559590570628643, -0.023798098787665367, -0.046034954488277435, 0.022394835948944092, 0.0499427355825901, 0.007771484553813934, -0.03741101920604706, 0.012088317424058914, 0.035584576427936554, 0.00979047454893589, 0.059169359505176544, 0.0204726904630661, -0.011204469949007034, -0.03067600168287754, 0.032079581171274185, 0.01447751559317112, 0.006293370854109526, 0.02021527662873268, 0.05577187240123749, -0.007437029853463173, 0.05221671238541603, 0.0030115770641714334, -0.03747404366731644, 0.08590345084667206, -0.017740538343787193, 0.026504168286919594, -0.011848562397062778, 0.0001769382506608963, 0.05837961286306381, -0.015209068544209003, -0.007817023433744907, 0.05968575179576874, -0.01315401028841734, 0.012994838878512383, -0.03532858192920685, -0.018909158185124397, 0.018166325986385345, 0.022621847689151764, -0.019341211766004562, 0.006701165810227394, -0.00550216855481267, -0.022834688425064087, 0.014709371142089367, -0.03241921588778496, -0.026227178052067757, -0.004399080760776997, 0.015910057350993156, 0.045066118240356445, 0.025126919150352478, 0.004622260574251413, -0.04532276466488838, -0.038500767201185226, 0.00026856991462409496, 0.01913156360387802, 0.018919972702860832, 0.0005724224029108882, -0.031169723719358444, -0.007156617008149624, 0.017021149396896362, -0.04186846315860748, 0.02904794178903103, 0.003686923533678055, 0.008988527581095695, -0.014008265919983387, -0.01719740964472294, -0.028583358973264694, 0.013314222916960716, -0.005621605087071657, 0.009787240996956825, -0.027323255315423012, -0.02959374152123928, 0.0358203686773777, -0.009356508031487465, -0.0013780418084934354, 0.04012563079595566, -0.039699092507362366, -0.06757737696170807, -0.026617174968123436, 0.003945244941860437, 0.030012279748916626, -0.020337067544460297, 0.033101581037044525, 0.02674996666610241, -0.039913397282361984, 0.010360075160861015, -0.0605950728058815, -0.04399040713906288, 0.018880190327763557, -0.0040677497163414955, 0.04076250642538071, -0.0026756497099995613, -0.01973843015730381, 0.08320331573486328, 0.013571775518357754, -0.03519931063055992, 0.011654882691800594, -0.0027637321036309004, -0.048422832041978836, -0.01869654282927513, 0.0180122759193182, 0.01931709609925747, -0.02025631070137024, 0.030774492770433426, -0.0012394350487738848, 0.052782729268074036, 0.02811715565621853, 0.001215678988955915, -0.016953153535723686, 0.0170869342982769, 0.003721717046573758, -0.0019521858775988221, 0.06061339005827904, 0.0043384721502661705, -0.01021554321050644, -0.016871169209480286, -0.001435485202819109, 0.020936843007802963, 0.02211740054190159, -0.04238039255142212, 0.04013992100954056, 0.005872881505638361, -0.0008226714562624693, -0.051101017743349075, 0.04119769111275673, -0.007096140645444393, -0.05597410723567009, -0.005753163248300552, 0.03359369561076164, 0.04652603343129158, -0.030242426320910454, 0.016288582235574722, 0.056000564247369766, 0.05105094984173775, -0.008104560896754265, -0.02461998537182808, -0.0057374173775315285, 0.0040506054647266865, -0.005726946517825127, -0.018200593069195747, 0.007857460528612137, 0.005760674364864826, 0.06463608145713806, 0.016575928777456284, -0.034995660185813904, -0.024905413389205933, 0.03842339664697647, -0.07998006790876389, -0.0007271477952599525, -0.00449224840849638, 0.025963671505451202, 0.011064284481108189, 0.038648732006549835, 0.024081064388155937, -0.004227243829518557, 0.006829187739640474, 0.016832074150443077, -0.0738040953874588, 0.029922358691692352, -0.010764921084046364, -0.01775832660496235, -0.020071225240826607, -0.019837617874145508, 0.028639765456318855, -0.010002072900533676, 0.0019183836411684752, -0.019453437998890877, 0.021820826455950737, 0.0020091135520488024, -0.0095878466963768, -0.013941043987870216, -0.02256406657397747, -0.009079820476472378, 0.0005828684661537409, 0.006999529432505369, -0.02269093133509159, 0.017795756459236145, 0.037657398730516434, -0.013268059119582176, -0.03694213181734085, -0.029692882671952248, 0.01581581123173237, -0.004756250884383917, 0.019811440259218216, 0.04136699065566063, 0.033341165632009506, 0.007016692776232958, -0.017234528437256813, 0.003645217278972268, 0.06076366454362869, 0.05211279168725014, 0.016668587923049927, -0.012884880416095257, -0.07190468907356262, -0.042043112218379974, -0.022778205573558807, -0.013289676047861576, -0.00935983657836914, 0.01980522647500038, 0.05225313827395439, -0.0070089371874928474, -0.0585913360118866, 0.020297836512327194, 0.04525478929281235, -0.017170818522572517, -0.007603269070386887, -0.03069472126662731, -0.014673370867967606, -0.019580719992518425, 0.0023558023385703564, 0.028177453204989433, -0.035544686019420624, -0.01909443736076355, 0.00177886919118464, 0.030704503878951073, -0.016731321811676025, -0.011554303579032421, -0.0011166323674842715, 0.003854772774502635, 0.032459381967782974, 0.0031615791376680136, 0.0052773719653487206, 0.008437464013695717, 0.033204980194568634, 0.03256068378686905, 0.0208373311907053, -0.010203528217971325, -0.06642759591341019, -0.024902626872062683, 0.034506116062402725, 0.02538706734776497, -0.02416478842496872, -0.0034916135482490063, -0.05042359605431557, -0.013704444281756878, 0.026713276281952858, -0.0042242626659572124, 0.03608928248286247, -0.01809128187596798, 0.018034785985946655, -0.0028201614040881395, -0.011892656795680523, -0.04099126532673836, 0.008825059980154037, 0.01764424331486225, 0.004721171222627163, -0.032476648688316345, 0.0015116387512534857, -0.05355999246239662, 0.007396186236292124, 0.010308297351002693, 0.0736515074968338, -0.01843971386551857, -0.027096448466181755, 0.011664220131933689, 0.052826177328825, 0.016738252714276314, -0.07573090493679047, -0.007149760145694017, 0.02310315892100334, 0.009988019242882729, 0.0323677733540535, -0.02359098568558693, -0.04174499586224556, 0.030664129182696342, 0.012267610989511013, -0.043133243918418884, -0.0018771005561575294, -0.011248745024204254, 0.041644830256700516, 0.019902320578694344, 0.009450681507587433, 0.036577433347702026, 0.04113524407148361, -0.016838746145367622, -0.011066094972193241, -0.056995127350091934, 0.013656320981681347, -0.012307513505220413, -0.00854649767279625, -0.062129225581884384, -0.009800721891224384, -0.033209893852472305, 0.037633541971445084, -0.016530906781554222, 0.004745421931147575, -0.049166999757289886, -0.01872928999364376, -0.0009927952196449041, 0.04799874126911163, 0.02821277268230915, 0.030416114255785942, 0.01859240047633648, -0.004740825388580561, -0.012458122335374355, -0.007772959768772125, 0.02562255598604679, -0.010373998433351517, 0.01103107538074255, 0.02237953059375286, -0.018172860145568848, 0.0037226001732051373, -0.03842218592762947, -0.01713661476969719, 0.029853560030460358, -0.05573868751525879, 0.03956548869609833, 0.001253602677024901, 0.012440276332199574, 0.0024853015784174204, -0.053572218865156174, -0.005112528335303068, 0.010733123868703842, -0.04033353924751282, 0.03911403566598892, -0.017074599862098694, 0.027476616203784943, 0.013254253193736076, 0.016732439398765564, -0.05807944014668465, -0.02695181593298912, 0.0371289923787117, -0.03646308183670044, -0.019403012469410896, -0.05785278230905533, -0.011260537430644035, -0.010429334826767445, -0.04683205485343933, 0.0029910176526755095, 0.021878860890865326, -0.02275863289833069, -0.03574496507644653, -0.023448413237929344, -0.021624529734253883, 0.08795870095491409, 0.0012748200679197907, 0.00815574824810028, -0.01718486100435257, -0.02846004068851471, -0.024896452203392982, 0.019633401185274124, 0.06485529243946075, -0.01166774332523346, -0.007044811267405748, 0.0016617656219750643, -0.017674408853054047, 0.005518222227692604, -0.06402204185724258, -0.007974161766469479, -0.0035316653084009886, 0.057973142713308334, 0.022501269355416298, -0.027286656200885773, -0.0060487426817417145, 0.024581044912338257, 0.035824161022901535, -0.023363512009382248, -0.003390783676877618, -0.04941118136048317, -0.009945333935320377, 0.04558145999908447, -0.004948123823851347, 0.050043147057294846, 0.04841899499297142, 0.10079564154148102, -0.03152983635663986, 0.006596195511519909, -0.010038643144071102, -0.024498585611581802, 0.04660612344741821, 0.015500924549996853, -0.019066328182816505, 0.034118298441171646, 0.005876867100596428, -0.017832761630415916, -0.005189679563045502, -0.0666395053267479, 0.027683524414896965, 0.06587998569011688, -0.0381154790520668, 0.04844158887863159, 0.014741259627044201, 0.009531347081065178, -0.01269739493727684, -0.01670508272945881, 0.0014918200904503465, -0.027464905753731728, -0.0181274451315403, 0.046129174530506134, -0.028269298374652863, 0.046794865280389786, 0.011407822370529175, 0.016865437850356102, 0.014487109147012234, 0.028721783310174942, 0.008884301409125328, 0.042319927364587784, 0.017118558287620544, -0.01288694329559803, -0.045263394713401794, 0.04467122256755829, -0.022273574024438858, 0.0458829365670681, -0.02616928145289421, -0.042142849415540695, 0.0837579220533371, 0.007353350054472685, -0.005675249733030796, -0.030591119080781937, -0.0066498881205916405, -0.022935887798666954, 0.005463853012770414, 0.010915403254330158, -0.00464749475941062, 0.0024997591972351074, 0.008587834425270557, 0.05002400651574135, 0.020382951945066452, 0.046989887952804565, -0.009142209775745869, -0.08200768381357193, -0.005945294629782438, -0.03538592904806137, -0.054036419838666916, 0.014630821533501148, -0.0026246102061122656, -0.013618933968245983, 0.017824336886405945, -0.04280371963977814, 0.016580143943428993, 0.016223689541220665, 0.004998422227799892, -0.019985772669315338, 0.0838361531496048, -0.008796666748821735, 0.008787509985268116, -0.024021519348025322, -0.01269356720149517, 0.12176238000392914, 0.07441255450248718, -0.0054636020213365555, -0.05840258672833443, -0.015620828606188297, -0.03156730532646179, 0.0005089766927994788, -0.01608976162970066, 0.01095960009843111, 0.0013096726033836603, -0.019205063581466675, 0.04065212607383728, 0.060198213905096054, 0.023089075461030006, 0.0034527345560491085, 0.05533595383167267, -0.028519796207547188, -0.027433350682258606, -0.00616423599421978, -0.0004904504166916013, 0.007569529116153717, -0.00586558086797595, -0.07130652666091919, 0.03526902571320534, -0.024766676127910614, 0.018056709319353104, -0.032126497477293015, -0.0021053750533610582, -0.032509204000234604, -0.026740580797195435, -0.0076768710277974606, -0.0003189530980307609, 0.03293220326304436, -0.035339515656232834, -0.007516831159591675, 0.014197849668562412, 0.017703739926218987, -0.06142394244670868, 0.04729766398668289, 0.04137658327817917, -0.02115338295698166, 0.008643296547234058, 0.04894378408789635, 0.0037661874666810036, -0.039483360946178436, -0.03941230848431587, -0.01842520385980606, 0.04129909351468086, -0.01778443343937397, 0.014873967505991459, -0.01736718788743019, -0.009056266397237778, 0.004367118701338768, -0.029824109748005867, 0.017326952889561653, 0.011500244960188866, 0.037781972438097, -0.014799267053604126, -0.012307978235185146, -0.04415430501103401, -0.0010695725213736296, 0.03942418098449707, 0.05133703351020813, 0.040583688765764236, -0.001630200888030231, 0.0013343320460990071, -0.03956911340355873, 0.04654174670577049, -0.014971298165619373, -0.004809664562344551, -0.007466872688382864, -0.03748259320855141, -0.014127563685178757, 0.01840689219534397, -0.007785112131386995, -0.024729853495955467, 0.05687275901436806, -0.00909240823239088, 0.00546558341011405, -0.008937778882682323, -0.08100666105747223, 0.04595014080405235, -0.02342388778924942, -0.020376674830913544, -0.04364316165447235, -0.040345270186662674, 0.03232696279883385, 0.04748174548149109, 0.02955131232738495, 0.04021333530545235, 0.009218174032866955, 0.04141923040151596, 0.019461266696453094, -0.02926255203783512, -0.007694092113524675, 0.018761157989501953, -0.027980251237750053, -0.0006512340041808784, -0.025219112634658813, 0.04971533268690109, 0.029239850118756294, 0.03799358382821083, -0.04297585040330887, -0.003106192220002413, -0.038900505751371384, 0.02353755012154579, 0.006013010628521442, -0.05008423328399658, 0.022495687007904053, 0.01167762279510498, -0.01325102336704731, -0.04872879758477211, 0.0009732947219163179, -0.00020527273591142148, -0.029841238632798195, -0.008458231575787067, 0.017311830073595047, -0.028950035572052002, -0.01579449698328972, -0.03866269066929817, 0.012836724519729614, -0.02941538766026497, -0.0456027127802372, -0.013525123707950115, 0.02026103064417839, 0.01284534577280283, 0.009035351686179638, -0.020085912197828293, 0.00043204196845181286, 0.0389048233628273, 0.01796971820294857, 0.04360044002532959, 0.0010599150555208325, 0.0023729675449430943, -0.0012301065726205707, 0.016396474093198776, -0.020475953817367554, 0.015391324646770954, -0.028333475813269615, -0.015859538689255714, 0.0728692039847374, -0.043911952525377274, -0.044135794043540955, 0.03734409809112549, 0.01790282316505909, 0.04743585363030434, 0.01428158301860094, -0.02358108013868332, -0.018961844965815544, 0.05344291031360626, -0.003038132330402732, -0.009962295182049274, -0.002275727456435561, -0.015089049935340881, 0.008460122160613537, -0.02084042690694332, -0.054295770823955536, 0.02948257327079773, 0.029153823852539062, 0.013846433721482754, 0.0016620004316791892, -0.012011105194687843, 0.00006689451402053237, 0.02904089353978634, -0.005282965023070574, 0.0016482623759657145, -0.0006262934184633195, 0.015269760973751545, 0.0027289893478155136, 0.03058905340731144, -0.044090744107961655, 0.02363654598593712, -0.027425449341535568, -0.02033943682909012, -0.08727062493562698, 0.018526844680309296, 0.0333954319357872, -0.031717248260974884, 0.02475244179368019, -0.06386575847864151, -0.005846151150763035, 0.00787575263530016, -0.029883772134780884, 0.027074502781033516, -0.0015956504503265023, -0.017753932625055313, -0.04762016609311104, 0.00009787757880985737, -0.016414182260632515, 0.0674821212887764, 0.010213532485067844, 0.03543594852089882, 0.024269014596939087, 0.030397633090615273, 0.019879860803484917, -0.022497277706861496, 0.004767523147165775, 0.041805416345596313, -0.0057797799818217754, -0.062022142112255096, 0.05192222446203232, -0.002463841810822487, -0.018693281337618828, 0.025603655725717545, -0.004417815245687962, -0.010576322674751282, -0.008590168319642544, 0.012819471769034863, -0.0045822313986718655, 0.01418056059628725, 0.04125171899795532, -0.003826977452263236, -0.010721828788518906, 0.022841842845082283, 0.055299993604421616, 0.02769341506063938, -0.034437570720911026, -0.017009608447551727, 0.018759826198220253, -0.0505584292113781, -0.05267597734928131, 0.031067484989762306, -0.006157842930406332, -0.03205250948667526, 0.005777246318757534, 0.00017882772954180837, -0.0005175289697945118, -0.02077220007777214, 0.03770093247294426, -0.05713694915175438, -0.005662150215357542, 0.06841248273849487, 0.007779052015393972, -0.01863865554332733, 0.021136650815606117, -0.02444147691130638, -0.039700284600257874, 0.011831489391624928, -0.004738946445286274, -0.007858553901314735, -0.06218121573328972, 0.00819624587893486, -0.010495568625628948, 0.00981611106544733, -0.019946971908211708, -0.0010701733408495784, -0.0281959380954504, 0.03585737198591232, -0.016390360891819, 0.018149415031075478, 0.028136486187577248, -0.021910784766077995, -0.008258131332695484, -0.06268095225095749, 0.04550609365105629, 0.017670031636953354, -0.04602661356329918, -0.05348634719848633, -0.012203364633023739, -0.012531498447060585, -0.0012505498016253114, 0.035583849996328354, 0.019407717511057854, -0.017269780859351158, -0.02061208337545395, 0.03859764710068703, 0.016321875154972076, -0.0700974091887474, 0.005250159185379744, -0.039466917514801025, -0.0364748053252697, -0.028492428362369537, -0.016498476266860962, -0.0007833207491785288, 0.0114508718252182, 0.0031199126970022917, -0.03151882067322731, 0.0038962094113230705, 0.017718344926834106, -0.020545924082398415, 0.030912719666957855, 0.025043560191988945, -0.039028361439704895, 0.05583508685231209, -0.010154437273740768, 0.0053435806185007095, 0.003268628614023328, 0.012170015834271908, -0.05016019195318222, 0.02590681053698063, -0.008164787665009499, -0.038058847188949585, -0.007874476723372936, -0.0012671018484979868, 0.010148350149393082, -0.0869794562458992, 0.017172876745462418, 0.011223189532756805, -0.06849846988916397, -0.00761715741828084, 0.0366012267768383, 0.002739599207416177, 0.028231902047991753, 0.011805367656052113, -0.005968170240521431, 0.01585577428340912, -0.041094522923231125, 0.03521174564957619, 0.004964762832969427, 0.010109479539096355, -0.03609929978847504, -0.010881367139518261, 0.023487702012062073, -0.003172665135934949, 0.046222563832998276, 0.018168583512306213, 0.06278496235609055, -0.036640871316194534, -0.014826742000877857, -0.0029999916441738605, 0.001998060615733266, 0.02449374459683895, 0.029195137321949005, -0.01301555149257183, 0.025688208639621735, 0.002621003659442067, 0.011340994387865067, 0.020198045298457146, -0.018550898879766464, -0.02237124927341938, -0.00843025092035532, -0.010141268372535706, 0.025171175599098206, -0.020839082077145576, -0.0008816135232336819, -0.01586608588695526, -0.018922319635748863, 0.01871492527425289, -0.028741421177983284, 0.024292921647429466, 0.010997898876667023, 0.015182141214609146, -0.025950387120246887, -0.009692276827991009, 0.012323122471570969, -0.022325534373521805, 0.029963308945298195, 0.05811513215303421, -0.010279325768351555, -0.016311047598719597, -0.008113306947052479, -0.012507547624409199, 0.05065926909446716, -0.0693993866443634, 0.019109142944216728, -0.041079435497522354, -0.023079024627804756, 0.010766008868813515, -0.024638669565320015 ]
<p>Assume following data set representing each month of the year 2013 with the corresponding consumption of natrual gas to heat my flat and the respective mean temperature.</p> <p>How can I seasonal adjust/normalize this time series?</p> <hr> <pre><code>1 156 m³ 1,4 °C 2 199 m³ 0,3 °C 3 173 m³ 2,3 °C 4 69 m³ 9,6 °C 5 63 m³ 12,2 °C 6 9 m³ 16,9 °C 7 9 m³ 20,8 °C 8 9 m³ 18,5 °C 9 15 m³ 14,3 °C 10 19 m³ 11,4 °C 11 83 m³ 5,2 °C 12 62 m³ 4,2 °C </code></pre> <hr> <p>I would like to take into account that it is colder in winter and warmer in summer and know if I needed more or less energy in comparison. (especially in terms of comparing with the year 2014 for example)</p> <p>I know how to use R, if that makes it easier for you to explain.</p>
73,509
[ -0.040628496557474136, -0.017191728577017784, -0.04904274269938469, 0.048162806779146194, 0.04060732200741768, 0.018053269013762474, 0.00008063846325967461, -0.03920547664165497, 0.00813131034374237, -0.03009551204741001, 0.05127197504043579, 0.02583598904311657, 0.01004976686090231, 0.015180643647909164, 0.0476643443107605, -0.039114389568567276, -0.021088868379592896, 0.004967856220901012, 0.0036883458960801363, -0.014510895125567913, -0.007700371090322733, 0.009831640869379044, 0.021778419613838196, 0.009900783188641071, -0.03407919779419899, 0.06290313601493835, 0.010898420587182045, -0.020867370069026947, -0.00278597348369658, 0.04788995534181595, -0.024768710136413574, -0.039719581604003906, 0.023309653624892235, 0.025985408574342728, -0.005708293989300728, 0.032794103026390076, -0.021286100149154663, 0.010027664713561535, -0.01748313382267952, 0.023910537362098694, -0.0401582345366478, 0.007707079406827688, -0.0007657959358766675, 0.016476551070809364, -0.013651657849550247, 0.01981503702700138, 0.01554382499307394, 0.02174297533929348, 0.021408094093203545, -0.05572417378425598, 0.08731543272733688, 0.027815984562039375, 0.05209619924426079, 0.0451187901198864, -0.009405195713043213, -0.02116880565881729, 0.022213812917470932, 0.06920948624610901, -0.003417686326429248, -0.078595370054245, -0.008701514452695847, -0.050997450947761536, -0.009396322071552277, -0.017556356266140938, -0.03247028961777687, 0.0056820339523255825, -0.017910609021782875, -0.004858031868934631, 0.025075985118746758, 0.0030266880057752132, 0.03421514481306076, -0.0003963916387874633, 0.03567376732826233, -0.018273888155817986, 0.03996150940656662, -0.03198442980647087, -0.011908411979675293, 0.0333845280110836, 0.017712246626615524, 0.04905004799365997, 0.03712664172053337, 0.0005390340811572969, 0.04170985892415047, 0.04395252466201782, 0.05247783288359642, 0.012730292044579983, 0.05734476447105408, -0.015699483454227448, 0.03802536427974701, 0.0012414086377248168, 0.017376068979501724, -0.003064689924940467, 0.06822693347930908, 0.020693866536021233, -0.029932042583823204, 0.04965102672576904, 0.015286246314644814, -0.012324334122240543, -0.010885530151426792, -0.020163435488939285, 0.0026079558301717043, -0.0064084348268806934, 0.019495433196425438, 0.015444096177816391, -0.009241132996976376, -0.026152659207582474, -0.06288594752550125, -0.024250846356153488, 0.0033992452081292868, -0.007065903395414352, -0.018751708790659904, 0.0048441337421536446, -0.021487286314368248, -0.019675157964229584, 0.02646774612367153, -0.03326616436243057, -0.023188777267932892, -0.025558054447174072, 0.048387590795755386, 0.063763327896595, 0.04812825843691826, 0.0019253401551395655, 0.05112823471426964, -0.034192800521850586, -0.08577679842710495, 0.021707985550165176, -0.005190175026655197, -0.020387016236782074, -0.024926120415329933, 0.034055452793836594, -0.015685811638832092, -0.06376948952674866, 0.03383225202560425, -0.012465110048651695, 0.050126753747463226, 0.015296905301511288, -0.05969100445508957, -0.06534750759601593, 0.025411434471607208, -0.02511770650744438, -0.004998026415705681, -0.07460758090019226, 0.02358361706137657, -0.017211170867085457, 0.04469303786754608, 0.0097602354362607, 0.020643630996346474, 0.018148047849535942, -0.015460334718227386, -0.003195282770320773, -0.033608514815568924, -0.03354284539818764, 0.0008863018010742962, -0.04492362216114998, 0.017886731773614883, -0.0583215169608593, 0.027569176629185677, 0.0375477634370327, 0.012192371301352978, 0.016367651522159576, 0.0469709150493145, 0.019725287333130836, -0.04597623273730278, 0.0173091571778059, -0.013588383793830872, -0.049900706857442856, 0.0675625428557396, -0.004717120435088873, 0.013089179992675781, -0.015843916684389114, -0.004069637507200241, 0.010614816099405289, 0.015560301020741463, 0.020388163626194, 0.044352781027555466, 0.011474771425127983, 0.027191799134016037, -0.007053720764815807, 0.017831826582551003, 0.038560282438993454, -0.04395404830574989, -0.022822218015789986, 0.000320526392897591, -0.019186723977327347, 0.02676619216799736, 0.054196447134017944, 0.021872147917747498, -0.023847194388508797, 0.06129202991724014, -0.06931653618812561, -0.029221827164292336, -0.09111340343952179, -0.029169082641601562, -0.03687752038240433, -0.006812929175794125, -0.022872330620884895, 0.027605237439274788, 0.04771387577056885, -0.0013089410495012999, -0.03486147150397301, -0.0005706626689061522, -0.007491679862141609, 0.04007918760180473, -0.02803061529994011, -0.019536642357707024, 0.03360363841056824, 0.06874246150255203, -0.03259756788611412, 0.046526238322257996, -0.04425658658146858, -0.012715062126517296, -0.003914253786206245, -0.05254446342587471, -0.0075088427402079105, -0.0053407917730510235, -0.02903357334434986, 0.016387939453125, 0.03545551374554634, -0.04167196899652481, 0.03406606987118721, -0.03803730756044388, 0.04072294384241104, 0.06160886213183403, -0.01823834888637066, 0.01795109733939171, 0.013389495201408863, 0.02990221045911312, 0.03948533162474632, -0.028121260926127434, -0.004054941236972809, -0.03970055654644966, -0.016776494681835175, 0.06026773527264595, 0.02237994782626629, -0.04271797090768814, -0.009381944313645363, 0.054968517273664474, -0.006739279720932245, 0.04878564551472664, 0.036375947296619415, 0.0007508595008403063, 0.003523011924698949, 0.009308844804763794, 0.005482133477926254, 0.006018945015966892, 0.006242549046874046, 0.0540202297270298, 0.04084498807787895, 0.03218325227499008, 0.00538215134292841, 0.01061693113297224, 0.0687648355960846, -0.006684575695544481, 0.018301043659448624, -0.008902451023459435, -0.0005635588313452899, 0.05115227773785591, -0.016525762155652046, -0.01646193489432335, 0.009576491080224514, -0.009740108624100685, 0.006435316056013107, 0.0023715614806860685, -0.016605349257588387, 0.02687128819525242, 0.030828770250082016, -0.009035497903823853, -0.032722849398851395, 0.015127619728446007, -0.0065789720974862576, 0.06009279936552048, -0.03328196331858635, -0.016472162678837776, -0.05538754165172577, -0.012797939591109753, 0.04249310493469238, 0.009885300882160664, 0.012457483448088169, 0.0027073610108345747, -0.03697764873504639, 0.006516472436487675, -0.019847866147756577, 0.007925712503492832, -0.0034995824098587036, -0.0027901127468794584, 0.0096443397924304, 0.011721116490662098, -0.00847083143889904, 0.028459126129746437, -0.004935044329613447, -0.011550812982022762, 0.05575701594352722, -0.0019293505465611815, -0.004805464763194323, -0.01763266883790493, -0.013013816438615322, 0.005991434212774038, -0.030642954632639885, 0.007110666949301958, 0.05033878982067108, -0.00981963612139225, -0.03552640601992607, -0.010908122174441814, -0.07119203358888626, -0.026606887578964233, -0.037211768329143524, -0.038257550448179245, -0.005419223103672266, 0.007583347149193287, 0.00010566630226094276, 0.01860828325152397, -0.06339515745639801, -0.005654850509017706, -0.0416993573307991, -0.028217803686857224, 0.009824659675359726, -0.003510727547109127, 0.03398958966135979, 0.019267665222287178, -0.012659798376262188, 0.006524506025016308, 0.03240462392568588, -0.011554637923836708, -0.040507301688194275, -0.02124357409775257, -0.008775947615504265, -0.03471056744456291, 0.031777966767549515, 0.03538237512111664, 0.011316828429698944, -0.009629078209400177, 0.014581261202692986, 0.030603885650634766, 0.037445068359375, 0.03525319695472717, -0.01765431836247444, 0.014236974529922009, -0.0053783017210662365, 0.00018705597904045135, 0.05595346540212631, -0.006950398441404104, -0.0019202935509383678, 0.0025493046268820763, -0.012865018099546432, -0.014310439117252827, 0.034833453595638275, -0.04422002285718918, 0.03011706843972206, -0.021463528275489807, 0.022383227944374084, -0.08024158328771591, 0.032667871564626694, -0.00029966660076752305, -0.026704000309109688, 0.010831836611032486, 0.007476029917597771, 0.02833748795092106, 0.006195054389536381, -0.00699272658675909, 0.04479531571269035, 0.05775800719857216, -0.0162712000310421, 0.025049589574337006, 0.03395312279462814, 0.007960792630910873, 0.022247515618801117, -0.021249843761324883, -0.033958543092012405, 0.06983593851327896, 0.03045518696308136, 0.05077524855732918, 0.008777901530265808, -0.07338038831949234, 0.016737347468733788, -0.07748916000127792, 0.005155715625733137, -0.023387594148516655, 0.07790285348892212, -0.015198610723018646, 0.008615204133093357, 0.02193254418671131, -0.0020409293938428164, 0.07967550307512283, -0.030968155711889267, -0.0576045885682106, 0.03386683389544487, 0.045732129365205765, 0.00805581919848919, -0.005798129830509424, -0.03744950145483017, -0.014448008500039577, -0.06328951567411423, 0.02083277329802513, 0.01822577603161335, -0.02058904990553856, -0.022424668073654175, 0.006435524206608534, 0.01808471977710724, -0.008606739342212677, -0.013496823608875275, -0.02778555639088154, 0.05129237473011017, -0.005364770069718361, 0.03272468224167824, 0.037454135715961456, 0.002001367975026369, -0.025629868730902672, 0.010055799968540668, 0.03611740842461586, 0.03097316063940525, 0.016082903370261192, 0.019527530297636986, 0.027537882328033447, -0.023862343281507492, 0.024428779259324074, 0.023444168269634247, -0.004739582538604736, 0.026723379269242287, -0.005115010775625706, -0.007518819533288479, -0.01205949392169714, 0.0006286753341555595, 0.03824310004711151, 0.01428486593067646, 0.040193356573581696, 0.03492991626262665, 0.006411694921553135, -0.008040950633585453, -0.05691014230251312, -0.026905734091997147, 0.09748512506484985, -0.01659957692027092, -0.012828808277845383, -0.045861124992370605, -0.028615588322281837, 0.017238760367035866, 0.027785634621977806, 0.05261268839240074, 0.014748075045645237, -0.02206551469862461, 0.027674242854118347, 0.01974322460591793, 0.0008815312758088112, -0.022734487429261208, 0.010931437835097313, 0.031975653022527695, 0.05302833020687103, 0.017555516213178635, -0.04032722860574722, 0.01171141117811203, 0.021107209846377373, 0.018862588331103325, -0.03572783246636391, -0.004910309799015522, -0.1377265304327011, 0.01452761609107256, 0.049253806471824646, 0.056154508143663406, -0.02444418892264366, -0.02722964435815811, -0.02824082225561142, 0.010036397725343704, 0.05299203470349312, -0.047099340707063675, 0.04362710192799568, -0.03575843200087547, 0.004338196478784084, -0.020235981792211533, -0.04766169190406799, -0.03516782075166702, -0.010589346289634705, -0.021733466535806656, 0.03106776997447014, 0.003004043595865369, -0.04555894061923027, -0.037950821220874786, -0.0075535038486123085, -0.028340347111225128, 0.003566865576431155, -0.026783468201756477, -0.02387814037501812, 0.010070355609059334, 0.01183189544826746, 0.00026993927895091474, -0.050536565482616425, -0.013047144748270512, 0.02200019732117653, -0.011639104224741459, 0.01732693985104561, -0.004281274043023586, -0.010973453521728516, 0.003951783757656813, 0.0021375862415879965, -0.024550018832087517, -0.03413074091076851, -0.03088160790503025, 0.022892819717526436, 0.021131237968802452, 0.012285689823329449, 0.07425690442323685, 0.05249272659420967, 0.013458061963319778, 0.034166350960731506, -0.06867573410272598, -0.0014659175649285316, -0.023085055872797966, -0.03607882559299469, -0.024776538833975792, -0.012990589253604412, 0.0015483797760680318, 0.00797953549772501, -0.0049612857401371, 0.04159675911068916, -0.0033218704629689455, -0.025897696614265442, -0.008309735916554928, 0.02509915828704834, -0.026325441896915436, -0.037725355476140976, 0.005742180626839399, -0.008662647567689419, -0.01120761688798666, -0.01753588393330574, -0.010450653731822968, -0.009989848360419273, -0.0137056028470397, 0.002367780078202486, -0.030536990612745285, 0.03337756544351578, 0.011671450920403004, -0.02548256516456604, 0.01158185675740242, -0.02318071387708187, -0.015414644032716751, -0.014800632372498512, 0.029548700898885727, 0.02945738285779953, -0.03907239809632301, 0.024484911933541298, 0.004266400821506977, 0.03188541159033775, -0.001838176278397441, -0.03336974233388901, 0.0635121688246727, 0.010886994190514088, 0.001952613121829927, -0.04331086575984955, -0.022978322580456734, 0.00837657693773508, 0.0018983008340001106, -0.03304755315184593, -0.07700065523386002, -0.019709890708327293, -0.024235175922513008, -0.0052065071649849415, -0.046246495097875595, 0.04419746994972229, -0.023170776665210724, 0.015002213418483734, -0.007219595834612846, 0.020624453201889992, 0.0695141851902008, -0.013875107280910015, 0.01821131259202957, 0.009926088154315948, -0.030905304476618767, -0.05505911633372307, -0.030668556690216064, 0.014143696054816246, -0.03369242697954178, -0.01695394143462181, -0.023199327290058136, -0.009636752307415009, 0.05530934780836105, -0.009510272182524204, -0.027919357642531395, 0.03512706607580185, 0.01147083006799221, -0.01806064322590828, -0.0456259585916996, -0.008251072838902473, -0.0018425405723974109, 0.034423235803842545, -0.038524821400642395, 0.010060031898319721, -0.006751224864274263, -0.025173410773277283, -0.003312499262392521, -0.012534081004559994, -0.0015950052766129375, 0.012637047097086906, 0.06304553151130676, 0.03918147087097168, 0.02087746001780033, 0.029287539422512054, 0.018252957612276077, 0.022797787562012672, 0.01812441274523735, -0.003981532528996468, 0.007979103364050388, -0.01954866386950016, -0.018193809315562248, -0.04880986735224724, -0.043507229536771774, -0.03715146332979202, 0.03195826709270477, 0.024709125980734825, 0.03669291362166405, 0.019953371956944466, -0.012960030697286129, 0.044473350048065186, -0.023307116702198982, -0.005572653375566006, 0.022113192826509476, 0.008983099833130836, 0.0468316450715065, -0.0003808136680163443, -0.0259382426738739, 0.009691653773188591, 0.006670162081718445, 0.018323197960853577, 0.06592664122581482, 0.0038235452957451344, 0.021890776231884956, -0.015694597736001015, -0.045881111174821854, -0.05371733382344246, 0.02988620102405548, -0.006040164269506931, 0.02557159587740898, -0.06729615479707718, 0.01641780138015747, 0.004804340191185474, 0.022542884573340416, -0.03375991806387901, -0.07756119221448898, 0.0028981275390833616, -0.07563628256320953, 0.015261372551321983, 0.06466620415449142, -0.03195374459028244, 0.03236338868737221, 0.029268192127346992, 0.055854447185993195, -0.012702010571956635, 0.009198501706123352, -0.012227460741996765, -0.0351419672369957, 0.02204357646405697, -0.027218323200941086, -0.03463396057486534, 0.03823911026120186, 0.012174609117209911, -0.017235398292541504, 0.001538122189231217, -0.02571682631969452, -0.021990278735756874, -0.010674419812858105, 0.018384257331490517, 0.042898308485746384, 0.07978019118309021, -0.007764623034745455, 0.007050715386867523, -0.023164352402091026, 0.017367394641041756, 0.14475062489509583, 0.06581656634807587, 0.0387917123734951, -0.04486135393381119, 0.01318162027746439, 0.0604940764605999, -0.01067232247442007, -0.047532495111227036, -0.0266703013330698, 0.0036439329851418734, -0.03705050051212311, 0.04024648666381836, 0.043241772800683975, -0.0011890497989952564, 0.02221541479229927, 0.04965677484869957, 0.0037609776481986046, -0.011921783909201622, 0.015923943370580673, 0.017798250541090965, 0.008605866692960262, 0.029910190030932426, -0.08448000997304916, 0.005334057845175266, 0.011392726562917233, 0.004767409060150385, -0.025796210393309593, -0.024486612528562546, 0.022334851324558258, 0.010091910138726234, -0.042463090270757675, 0.02690827287733555, 0.00014680458116345108, 0.03716936707496643, -0.009743837639689445, -0.02614601142704487, 0.02028645947575569, -0.03804149851202965, 0.011068461462855339, 0.022405633702874184, 0.022140875458717346, 0.00270160217769444, -0.02753884717822075, 0.003589184256270528, -0.03267120569944382, -0.009180918335914612, -0.04234154522418976, 0.029121598228812218, 0.012415437027812004, -0.011919490061700344, 0.0190702136605978, 0.0506407804787159, 0.0037559964694082737, -0.017651034519076347, 0.01295807771384716, 0.008867325261235237, 0.043964724987745285, -0.018886148929595947, -0.02684873528778553, -0.028062405064702034, 0.0037628731224685907, 0.007890680804848671, 0.031265296041965485, 0.02661115676164627, -0.006598783656954765, 0.011472702957689762, -0.043332312256097794, 0.07532237470149994, -0.03658295050263405, -0.006776966154575348, 0.020084518939256668, -0.010526597499847412, -0.00651928037405014, -0.03732701763510704, 0.05738675594329834, 0.014401191845536232, 0.022398270666599274, -0.020573338493704796, 0.013709682039916515, -0.010509750805795193, -0.0473332554101944, 0.013806584291160107, -0.013901249505579472, 0.00005033675188315101, -0.023732082918286324, 0.007073407527059317, 0.013717960566282272, 0.038288891315460205, 0.006024448201060295, -0.001017205766402185, -0.008323021233081818, 0.03446280583739281, 0.03385196626186371, -0.03195600211620331, -0.045692078769207, -0.02997175231575966, -0.04675460606813431, -0.007115232292562723, -0.02920665591955185, 0.039691485464572906, 0.01876106671988964, -0.008002489805221558, -0.014803276397287846, 0.042446669191122055, -0.01803242228925228, 0.00483516464009881, -0.023001329973340034, -0.04013265296816826, -0.013621681369841099, -0.007378588430583477, -0.04106103256344795, -0.035125188529491425, -0.03546753153204918, -0.01198961865156889, -0.017322983592748642, -0.013517428189516068, -0.01242673397064209, -0.03701381757855415, 0.045237425714731216, -0.009411944076418877, 0.005552788730710745, -0.039934296160936356, -0.003956823609769344, -0.046072304248809814, -0.03472037985920906, -0.012815858237445354, -0.01020567025989294, 0.0007851138943806291, 0.0031343044247478247, -0.032696012407541275, 0.01414884440600872, 0.03619653731584549, -0.029328681528568268, 0.01029195636510849, -0.02870774082839489, 0.004847957286983728, -0.02757265418767929, 0.056311558932065964, -0.02057645283639431, -0.02741451933979988, 0.01741131953895092, -0.02730906754732132, -0.01813543029129505, 0.008075405843555927, 0.01594294048845768, 0.05470797047019005, 0.01283507701009512, -0.01168154738843441, -0.00019073318981099874, 0.07281411439180374, -0.00023371413408312947, 0.022491231560707092, -0.03742938116192818, 0.006814153864979744, 0.018771955743432045, 0.029506482183933258, -0.022838346660137177, -0.018232157453894615, -0.004795906133949757, 0.036318350583314896, 0.08377442508935928, -0.0008661718457005918, -0.0026893538888543844, 0.0006260289228521287, -0.011656036600470543, -0.0037809470668435097, -0.008997590281069279, -0.01151068601757288, 0.054282695055007935, 0.03747047111392021, -0.03907827287912369, 0.026570800691843033, -0.02884012833237648, -0.022622302174568176, -0.05899409204721451, -0.03042166493833065, 0.010635959915816784, -0.05087244510650635, 0.009008754044771194, -0.036796923726797104, 0.03931907191872597, 0.005020202603191137, -0.0034013346303254366, 0.017750238999724388, -0.01071122195571661, -0.0042844596318900585, 0.000723581702914089, 0.023410828784108162, 0.001514426781795919, -0.0026052454486489296, 0.03569752722978592, 0.04628487303853035, 0.020787300541996956, 0.00920743215829134, 0.03381606936454773, -0.05567488074302673, 0.007814488373696804, 0.003352880012243986, 0.027668021619319916, -0.07155604660511017, 0.006939201150089502, -0.02723476104438305, -0.022489720955491066, 0.0006633868906646967, -0.04836076870560646, 0.012476306408643723, 0.01668919064104557, 0.018690576776862144, -0.008147303946316242, 0.07741943001747131, 0.03531406819820404, 0.0004805837816093117, -0.03493255749344826, 0.007809505332261324, 0.040031854063272476, 0.03472142666578293, -0.011205080896615982, 0.015498421154916286, -0.011513400822877884, -0.009751968085765839, -0.01950761489570141, 0.02168227732181549, -0.021046843379735947, 0.0006054561818018556, 0.015776371583342552, -0.022061973810195923, -0.029512865468859673, -0.00519538251683116, -0.026077590882778168, 0.005910062696784735, 0.011870174668729305, 0.05561951547861099, 0.004370670299977064, 0.019984031096100807, -0.023463448509573936, -0.0013184529962018132, -0.0061677610501646996, -0.0013822547625750303, 0.032326336950063705, -0.007285294588655233, -0.0157917607575655, 0.0071175070479512215, 0.04048695042729378, -0.02513686753809452, -0.039287012070417404, -0.010105359368026257, -0.03940242528915405, 0.051258206367492676, 0.02546551823616028, -0.0070472946390509605, -0.006985266227275133, -0.012445751577615738, 0.011037386953830719, -0.07779019325971603, 0.04295910522341728, 0.0011096667731180787, -0.02062077820301056, -0.01809714362025261, 0.009900398552417755, -0.0721757560968399, 0.0026841850485652685, 0.045306622982025146, 0.0007596215582452714, -0.004873328376561403, -0.0369989313185215, 0.005135349929332733, 0.029027603566646576, -0.06129468232393265, 0.07248126715421677, -0.016725478693842888, -0.04885152354836464, -0.0030174555722624063, -0.028543751686811447, -0.0027470753993839025, -0.020943334326148033, -0.01786421611905098, -0.017592497169971466, -0.0012318205554038286, 0.008251819759607315, -0.023397278040647507, 0.012140324339270592, 0.024877358227968216, -0.03725546970963478, 0.00391473900526762, -0.016841620206832886, 0.001398008200339973, 0.05660858005285263, 0.008319550193846226, -0.0365142822265625, -0.008530034683644772, -0.058321431279182434, 0.0029887778218835592, -0.0011246390640735626, -0.017353130504488945, 0.021478842943906784, -0.06819535791873932, 0.015512351877987385, 0.03427216038107872, -0.024318987503647804, 0.02242250181734562, 0.02910551056265831, 0.0167718343436718, 0.026815466582775116, -0.024430200457572937, 0.03355361521244049, -0.011654014699161053, 0.03166874125599861, 0.009961949661374092, 0.011544965207576752, 0.009867322631180286, -0.0296950563788414, -0.014122651889920235, 0.004211533814668655, -0.00821448303759098, 0.03154151514172554, 0.01003579143434763, 0.053791437298059464, -0.0038835187442600727, -0.01568569615483284, 0.018556470051407814, -0.00013470389239955693, -0.0047408281825482845, 0.02466496266424656, 0.03195224702358246, 0.005415509454905987, -0.011855972930788994, -0.028502412140369415, -0.03443361818790436, -0.03387308493256569, -0.048631273210048676, 0.012250304222106934, 0.005140635184943676, 0.02759132720530033, -0.0022448634263128042, 0.054007790982723236, 0.002437557326629758, -0.004677989985793829, 0.020199734717607498, -0.010789569467306137, 0.024828340858221054, -0.008278443478047848, -0.016257736831903458, 0.010407330468297005, 0.020193133503198624, -0.03280007094144821, -0.020387105643749237, 0.02603408880531788, 0.04406634718179703, 0.008148162625730038, -0.010221264325082302, -0.010322555899620056, 0.0042149038054049015, -0.00004111200905754231, -0.09526156634092331, -0.05006938800215721, -0.03172602504491806, -0.0260715764015913, -0.025816436856985092, -0.007778146769851446 ]
<p>My major is CS and I have a question about Markov decision process.</p> <p>I have been reading a book, planning with markov decision process an AI perspective. While reading it, I have a question regarding the definition of MDP and its generality.</p> <p>The 2nd order Markov chain can be transformed into 1st order Markov chain. So any stochastic process that is depend on limited length history can be eventually 1st order Markov chain. </p> <p>I think Markov Decision Process is the most general one when we consider discrete and finite state space. I don't know if there is non-Markovian decision process.</p> <p>If we want to find optimal policy of an MDP with respect to maximum total expected utility (M.E.U) using value iteration, dynamic programming; if connectivity graph of MDP is acyclic, value iteration is same as Bellman-Ford shortest path finding algorithm.</p> <p>I am curious about if there is something different decision process that can't be solved by dynamic programming when we are still finding an optimal policy w.r.t. M.E.U?</p> <p>The question itself is confusing, but simply my question is MDP is the most general one if the state space is finite?</p> <p>The additional question is when we are optimizing w.r.t. other metrics than M.E.U, the MDP can be solved by dynamic programming? </p> <p>I hope someone suggest directions to explore this field.</p> <p>Thanks in advance.</p>
73,510
[ -0.011158711276948452, -0.048168573528528214, -0.005146136973053217, 0.003508134512230754, 0.021498704329133034, 0.016283702105283737, -0.008590960875153542, -0.04287880286574364, 0.014592790976166725, -0.026018016040325165, 0.003287761239334941, 0.01044395286589861, 0.05343158543109894, 0.04447571188211441, 0.021203940734267235, -0.014822755008935928, -0.013613125309348106, -0.029422147199511528, -0.008764776401221752, 0.014383315108716488, -0.005714568309485912, 0.006659426726400852, 0.03704476356506348, -0.01459521148353815, -0.025361133739352226, -0.00028374220710247755, -0.001517446362413466, 0.017489684745669365, 0.02311108633875847, 0.020068233832716942, -0.02191469818353653, -0.0387248732149601, -0.020409682765603065, 0.05803319439291954, 0.013436132110655308, 0.006321146618574858, -0.09980341047048569, -0.029122263193130493, -0.04333065077662468, 0.01403249055147171, -0.02136290818452835, -0.0339900366961956, -0.008362391963601112, 0.03162801265716553, -0.029336756095290184, 0.04367128759622574, -0.006532758008688688, -0.0068796356208622456, 0.017049839720129967, -0.0496223121881485, 0.06671762466430664, -0.03590422496199608, 0.025060579180717468, 0.002620534971356392, 0.00770037854090333, -0.027805306017398834, 0.06606578826904297, 0.08849576115608215, 0.02407343126833439, -0.022005120292305946, -0.018734639510512352, -0.011752979829907417, 0.03493918105959892, -0.03255302831530571, -0.03160766512155533, 0.05150900036096573, -0.00005070536644780077, -0.01803435944020748, -0.003885294310748577, 0.014936508610844612, -0.03128654137253761, 0.027259841561317444, 0.06654901057481766, 0.02249971032142639, 0.03913704678416252, 0.013247703202068806, 0.0277416929602623, 0.02391744963824749, 0.02761000394821167, 0.059460077434778214, -0.0014717348385602236, 0.00011712453851941973, 0.006380196660757065, 0.03817916288971901, 0.02426377311348915, -0.006057010032236576, 0.06021077558398247, -0.025147106498479843, 0.010700056329369545, 0.009020824916660786, 0.011227776296436787, 0.004436773713678122, 0.04341316595673561, -0.003615903202444315, -0.060148101300001144, 0.03094882145524025, -0.016004400327801704, 0.019211100414395332, -0.013281332328915596, -0.02832769602537155, 0.0005328382248990238, -0.05124001204967499, -0.017618678510189056, 0.026029670611023903, -0.0019036977319046855, 0.005746243521571159, -0.026529477909207344, 0.056757424026727676, -0.015683956444263458, 0.022784221917390823, -0.07803341001272202, -0.002990399720147252, -0.009913630783557892, 0.005832745227962732, 0.008796590380370617, -0.04280788078904152, -0.05429510399699211, -0.024756813421845436, 0.05061925947666168, 0.11552080512046814, 0.03067980892956257, -0.021936113014817238, 0.051401641219854355, -0.05605475232005119, -0.06386257708072662, 0.012090985663235188, -0.00027177840820513666, -0.019033804535865784, -0.012137536890804768, -0.00023604341549798846, -0.032342735677957535, -0.023726243525743484, 0.03287557512521744, 0.012074082158505917, 0.054632868617773056, -0.05208537355065346, -0.10043066740036011, -0.04857354238629341, 0.022231798619031906, 0.027347054332494736, 0.03689791262149811, -0.05358129367232323, 0.025544404983520508, 0.05293336138129234, 0.05716574192047119, 0.00006362561543937773, 0.05100152641534805, 0.04685084894299507, 0.01605667546391487, -0.020135575905442238, -0.061186786741018295, -0.006986232940107584, -0.007404942065477371, -0.00723758339881897, 0.03020368702709675, -0.06943925470113754, 0.05586792156100273, 0.009883316233754158, 0.030365440994501114, -0.004965111613273621, 0.06348621845245361, -0.0015734010376036167, -0.05261069908738136, -0.004560483153909445, 0.0017299400642514229, -0.007042516488581896, 0.06782890856266022, 0.012348009273409843, 0.053768470883369446, 0.009817926213145256, 0.012280701659619808, 0.030033577233552933, 0.006311583798378706, 0.04422012344002724, 0.05838373675942421, -0.0425027571618557, -0.048518236726522446, 0.004140691366046667, 0.0007126855198293924, 0.007831738330423832, -0.007376427762210369, -0.028698083013296127, -0.02338375896215439, -0.014188777655363083, 0.009519925341010094, 0.037821412086486816, -0.007652137894183397, 0.03500917926430702, 0.04225649684667587, -0.06399726867675781, -0.02784007415175438, -0.045749012380838394, -0.003837801516056061, -0.0351652055978775, 0.015797322615981102, 0.008673586882650852, -0.02724047750234604, -0.010354764759540558, -0.04072173312306404, -0.02432226948440075, -0.01711934059858322, -0.019110744819045067, 0.012790055014193058, -0.03044656291604042, 0.01890646480023861, 0.020890697836875916, 0.026236917823553085, -0.03478320315480232, 0.005520959850400686, -0.02943451516330242, -0.044286735355854034, -0.00717529933899641, -0.008991016075015068, 0.05517416447401047, -0.00722747016698122, -0.0271109938621521, 0.04558466374874115, -0.026890898123383522, -0.045940641313791275, 0.011247117072343826, -0.05032811313867569, 0.06840887665748596, 0.09142935276031494, 0.021686913445591927, 0.0043238261714577675, 0.011235338635742664, 0.022171292454004288, -0.01153250690549612, -0.010878683999180794, 0.01699558086693287, -0.06414216011762619, -0.00834176316857338, 0.016201579943299294, 0.04435380548238754, -0.05690815672278404, 0.018422797322273254, -0.006515076383948326, 0.022679856047034264, 0.004494142718613148, 0.046940360218286514, 0.010258323512971401, 0.0028916362207382917, 0.023523299023509026, 0.038131628185510635, 0.018031729385256767, 0.03769468516111374, 0.006441308185458183, -0.011577416211366653, 0.01177192386239767, -0.008910530246794224, -0.017638294026255608, 0.05517733469605446, -0.015992512926459312, -0.001319774310104549, 0.000413856643717736, -0.05661994218826294, 0.04832739382982254, -0.04904836043715477, 0.020067814737558365, 0.042921826243400574, 0.014663155190646648, -0.017915483564138412, -0.012714194133877754, -0.022229280322790146, -0.023461448028683662, 0.00612928019836545, -0.020624464377760887, -0.01138684805482626, 0.05270712450146675, -0.012393468990921974, 0.03113453835248947, -0.017764581367373466, 0.016725663095712662, -0.022164607420563698, -0.005980716552585363, 0.04990990087389946, -0.03651457279920578, -0.009955113753676414, -0.021172842010855675, -0.02426515892148018, -0.017154905945062637, -0.03604623302817345, 0.008207343518733978, 0.018577156588435173, -0.04925018548965454, 0.030222151428461075, 0.014863262884318829, -0.03507498279213905, 0.008796901442110538, -0.008461606688797474, 0.02523988112807274, 0.011854566633701324, 0.029195016250014305, -0.06239088252186775, -0.018169384449720383, -0.03215118125081062, 0.02805490419268608, -0.01522802747786045, 0.01596725732088089, 0.04890277609229088, 0.015550372190773487, -0.03520052507519722, -0.02061343938112259, -0.04246288537979126, -0.037188004702329636, -0.03650582209229469, -0.016180144622921944, 0.03975300118327141, -0.00428331783041358, 0.008320893160998821, 0.021962791681289673, -0.031351182609796524, -0.005940426606684923, -0.06987252086400986, -0.041331902146339417, 0.037251222878694534, 0.007661010604351759, 0.01257382519543171, -0.00867914967238903, -0.03185904398560524, 0.04750274494290352, 0.03962832689285278, -0.051196277141571045, -0.033185333013534546, -0.028024958446621895, 0.01575232483446598, -0.02052849903702736, -0.023377615958452225, 0.025060098618268967, -0.010247712023556232, 0.0062889582477509975, 0.020313814282417297, 0.01868419349193573, 0.036819733679294586, -0.019282693043351173, 0.02802896499633789, 0.019370827823877335, 0.012705687433481216, -0.024943506345152855, 0.02476307563483715, 0.015132573433220387, -0.01756736822426319, 0.047001421451568604, 0.007267497014254332, 0.018705768510699272, -0.0025423276238143444, -0.04755827412009239, 0.044414766132831573, -0.005701060406863689, -0.011109973303973675, -0.0373603031039238, 0.0317949615418911, -0.01752490922808647, -0.02495991624891758, -0.0075209373608231544, 0.0209205262362957, 0.001981589011847973, -0.03781317174434662, 0.033763639628887177, 0.055680759251117706, 0.02384456992149353, -0.023976383730769157, -0.027988716959953308, -0.026736387982964516, -0.0256181787699461, 0.021545128896832466, -0.0171491801738739, -0.0326729491353035, 0.00830670166760683, 0.01865391992032528, 0.04408448934555054, 0.020881958305835724, -0.027135521173477173, -0.008270691148936749, -0.051646944135427475, -0.0054936641827225685, -0.052741531282663345, 0.09104174375534058, 0.006659516133368015, 0.0007230418850667775, 0.012586886063218117, -0.005088884383440018, 0.03036855347454548, 0.0010695039527490735, -0.11492737382650375, 0.03209172189235687, -0.017598049715161324, 0.02377193421125412, 0.032192833721637726, -0.029114805161952972, 0.05773865431547165, -0.03801610320806503, -0.010488385334610939, 0.010961285792291164, 0.034237559884786606, -0.06113450974225998, -0.004554562736302614, -0.03429489955306053, -0.03050871565937996, -0.03312508761882782, 0.0035275963600724936, 0.028085576370358467, -0.0026062196120619774, 0.02483818493783474, 0.054985929280519485, -0.043833278119564056, -0.00833091326057911, -0.01867551915347576, 0.020247185602784157, 0.029293883591890335, 0.05417696759104729, 0.041788678616285324, 0.04822029173374176, 0.00869855284690857, 0.00779723608866334, 0.0047888681292533875, 0.061200182884931564, -0.019046735018491745, -0.0427570603787899, -0.03868871554732323, -0.04363726079463959, -0.006442142650485039, -0.002098645083606243, 0.000050746690249070525, 0.03616435080766678, 0.01738390140235424, 0.04776326194405556, 0.012681689113378525, -0.01111937128007412, 0.0221252478659153, 0.07678712904453278, -0.005178662482649088, -0.03010861575603485, -0.021251067519187927, 0.0026161635760217905, -0.01724393106997013, 0.0178670734167099, 0.009350122883915901, -0.0035923628602176905, -0.003987501375377178, 0.01886766217648983, -0.006029121112078428, -0.02893194369971752, -0.02771877869963646, -0.004706628620624542, -0.009716828353703022, 0.023457441478967667, 0.04903313145041466, -0.034742098301649094, 0.0027878987602889538, 0.00777352275326848, 0.034644823521375656, 0.005487771239131689, 0.026606252416968346, -0.07280708104372025, 0.022909509018063545, 0.02425033412873745, 0.028407707810401917, -0.0017432288732379675, 0.002920986618846655, -0.03782873973250389, -0.0319957472383976, 0.03363506495952606, -0.009909485466778278, 0.016462218016386032, -0.008491460233926773, -0.005852261558175087, -0.0423438623547554, -0.04024949297308922, -0.030267318710684776, -0.025530898943543434, 0.012549329549074173, 0.01562737673521042, 0.02469359152019024, 0.013017652556300163, -0.04784227907657623, -0.041806694120168686, 0.0174618698656559, 0.06859957426786423, 0.003983431961387396, 0.01529502123594284, 0.008408487774431705, 0.028101090341806412, -0.03264352306723595, -0.0636816993355751, 0.0006647786940447986, 0.028153810650110245, -0.04368329420685768, 0.00334394839592278, 0.0056248074397444725, -0.06695455312728882, 0.042193565517663956, 0.0011379419593140483, -0.011227123439311981, 0.025115305557847023, 0.008462986908853054, -0.002244967268779874, 0.05333174765110016, -0.024409187957644463, 0.011450101621448994, 0.019993487745523453, -0.013472824357450008, 0.01504199393093586, 0.00668974919244647, 0.038087133318185806, -0.02546166442334652, -0.015463827177882195, -0.02849305048584938, -0.011075864546000957, -0.008645441383123398, 0.03758960962295532, 0.02152601070702076, 0.016439054161310196, -0.020448101684451103, -0.02675243653357029, -0.02766120433807373, 0.06047424301505089, 0.0037449307274073362, -0.025254594162106514, 0.01160977128893137, 0.028948109596967697, 0.0047555058263242245, -0.037114426493644714, -0.013269111514091492, -0.004701903555542231, -0.00614080298691988, 0.0392036959528923, -0.020638590678572655, 0.0052179498597979546, -0.04030594974756241, -0.010425620712339878, 0.00895350519567728, -0.007711502257734537, 0.017864814028143883, 0.04067067429423332, -0.0167931467294693, 0.006127695087343454, -0.05925919860601425, -0.021608231589198112, 0.008118665777146816, -0.02250336855649948, -0.030781494453549385, -0.020044853910803795, 0.035546641796827316, -0.01801634579896927, -0.008778112009167671, -0.05055411905050278, -0.06556078046560287, -0.0065574124455451965, 0.004578016698360443, -0.038737379014492035, -0.01490977592766285, 0.01749739795923233, -0.018953097984194756, -0.032875072211027145, -0.0029298749286681414, 0.06104043871164322, 0.031346168369054794, 0.0013781505404040217, 0.047121159732341766, 0.03763468563556671, 0.05655617639422417, 0.02879903092980385, 0.009958743117749691, -0.020745692774653435, -0.00008395850454689935, 0.029653185978531837, -0.027401501312851906, 0.0553773008286953, -0.03625696524977684, 0.004099540412425995, -0.037388987839221954, 0.0021386977750808, 0.06472091376781464, -0.013185515068471432, 0.026719635352492332, 0.009978020563721657, -0.003925217781215906, -0.04761922359466553, -0.0196656696498394, -0.014590827748179436, -0.011502454988658428, -0.004044835455715656, 0.017853109166026115, 0.014913221821188927, 0.0008869444136507809, -0.01434331201016903, 0.00505757937207818, -0.013070700690150261, -0.01822253130376339, 0.028231488540768623, 0.02833932265639305, -0.029606323689222336, -0.007913976907730103, 0.0058565158396959305, -0.039588071405887604, -0.0023264200426638126, -0.028987770900130272, -0.0031486658845096827, 0.024758217856287956, 0.005895404145121574, -0.020241810008883476, -0.01926668919622898, -0.02644314430654049, 0.05903278663754463, 0.03533974662423134, -0.0026226667687296867, 0.008976135402917862, 0.005106577184051275, 0.0023485999554395676, -0.0033964046742767096, -0.04145174100995064, 0.006173473782837391, 0.0004362472682259977, 0.01415715180337429, 0.05022864416241646, 0.0003129523538518697, -0.008775356225669384, 0.038073621690273285, -0.011977020651102066, -0.006577850319445133, -0.0456659309566021, 0.020278824493288994, -0.0008636897546239197, 0.04541439190506935, -0.04174484685063362, -0.019114121794700623, 0.011464428156614304, -0.030701346695423126, -0.02038436569273472, -0.002964896149933338, -0.04073174297809601, 0.038113780319690704, 0.0046127717941999435, 0.01563422754406929, -0.02888493239879608, 0.007561635226011276, -0.039071884006261826, 0.045539725571870804, 0.008904066868126392, 0.03941269963979721, 0.057881422340869904, 0.024591166526079178, 0.01875205710530281, -0.027818020433187485, 0.03147295489907265, 0.031874947249889374, -0.06521487981081009, -0.03961221128702164, -0.01819559559226036, -0.05038744956254959, 0.024397222325205803, 0.023480592295527458, -0.026581240817904472, -0.02394888363778591, -0.029378917068243027, 0.022053543478250504, 0.018094951286911964, 0.03323927894234657, -0.012859594076871872, 0.07783693820238113, 0.016575058922171593, 0.04146231338381767, -0.013947244733572006, 0.0028154568281024694, 0.10633137077093124, 0.09007532149553299, 0.0384083017706871, -0.06696489453315735, 0.01026749238371849, -0.03966691717505455, -0.001012821914628148, -0.027958013117313385, 0.06340159475803375, 0.04729624092578888, -0.008636307902634144, 0.04203464835882187, -0.0000759863542043604, 0.011090141721069813, 0.003094073850661516, 0.08138878643512726, -0.06818373501300812, -0.04330373555421829, 0.03455386310815811, -0.02415783889591694, -0.006772608496248722, -0.0017620086437091231, 0.0032004807144403458, 0.01809512823820114, -0.02279357612133026, -0.011322155594825745, 0.026791604235768318, 0.0005113863153383136, 0.007276257500052452, -0.001994349528104067, 0.030987292528152466, -0.01828904077410698, -0.01637251116335392, 0.010003035888075829, -0.029400048777461052, -0.0027732611633837223, 0.016229497268795967, -0.009696436114609241, 0.024372171610593796, 0.04301914945244789, 0.039368998259305954, 0.0030213785357773304, -0.010968786664307117, 0.015495100058615208, -0.019467636942863464, 0.009662427939474583, -0.05699487775564194, 0.030630264431238174, -0.05186225846409798, 0.014872172847390175, 0.0044631813652813435, -0.010490029118955135, 0.0023457978386431932, -0.05187512934207916, -0.007660901173949242, 0.005098789464682341, 0.07478037476539612, -0.007385742384940386, -0.014316122978925705, -0.062338948249816895, -0.006147286389023066, -0.004620592575520277, 0.006777717266231775, -0.04901602491736412, -0.0016732275253161788, -0.04149121791124344, -0.013120101764798164, 0.009193312376737595, -0.011949727311730385, -0.031788527965545654, -0.004779226612299681, 0.006293310783803463, -0.027868598699569702, -0.03381701558828354, 0.014396757818758488, -0.03559022396802902, 0.03591042384505272, -0.015464947558939457, -0.00557115999981761, -0.010998698882758617, -0.04174157604575157, 0.0063567617908120155, -0.03745964914560318, -0.014847420156002045, -0.012184522114694118, 0.012940866872668266, -0.005975203588604927, 0.019681692123413086, 0.005839644465595484, 0.023711256682872772, -0.014489269815385342, 0.033647071570158005, 0.011466458439826965, -0.009011749178171158, 0.008419579826295376, -0.04364210367202759, -0.04164010286331177, 0.029097115620970726, -0.030026253312826157, 0.024698063731193542, 0.02443401701748371, 0.016865108162164688, -0.04165889322757721, 0.006812239997088909, 0.018224891275167465, 0.02878391556441784, 0.02224067784845829, -0.03887183964252472, 0.009322978556156158, 0.003617812879383564, 0.028475239872932434, -0.05806070566177368, -0.021162740886211395, -0.033045295625925064, 0.015289897099137306, -0.008875495754182339, -0.013349687680602074, -0.030424639582633972, 0.014610166661441326, -0.013508849777281284, 0.007911993190646172, -0.00601597223430872, -0.02775554731488228, -0.02035469189286232, 0.027359401807188988, -0.018591273576021194, -0.018720366060733795, -0.00817706435918808, 0.0006678687641397119, -0.00994799379259348, -0.023050343617796898, 0.008823198266327381, 0.02684929221868515, -0.02044437639415264, 0.002131833229213953, 0.035009875893592834, 0.019055360928177834, 0.05600079521536827, -0.04557139798998833, -0.008637838996946812, 0.04112083092331886, -0.05352749675512314, -0.008551590144634247, 0.018984317779541016, 0.013568999245762825, 0.030759818851947784, 0.015446421690285206, -0.00825229100883007, -0.021135015413165092, 0.06950565427541733, -0.006535188294947147, 0.004973602015525103, 0.00934227928519249, -0.011763537302613258, -0.001766981789842248, -0.004878954961895943, -0.0017185290344059467, -0.008126731030642986, -0.018966592848300934, -0.022682588547468185, 0.017869288101792336, 0.0009259702055715024, -0.010527349077165127, 0.037113383412361145, -0.03138625994324684, 0.05360403656959534, 0.03329404070973396, 0.022549878805875778, 0.018231479451060295, 0.0729622021317482, 0.009577961638569832, -0.00006397075048880652, 0.01170001644641161, 0.004241179674863815, -0.0689639300107956, 0.02360365353524685, 0.03236621618270874, -0.006671005394309759, 0.044306572526693344, -0.024192191660404205, -0.0032505395356565714, 0.02270842343568802, -0.061479147523641586, 0.008115041069686413, 0.00361834280192852, 0.028065133839845657, -0.007909674197435379, -0.0027521296869963408, -0.049376148730516434, 0.04455706477165222, 0.020795855671167374, 0.03793174400925636, 0.06574167311191559, 0.0071013509295880795, -0.01309222262352705, -0.010214744135737419, -0.014869585633277893, 0.04551073536276817, 0.0032951401080936193, -0.05096449330449104, 0.07894942164421082, -0.056817907840013504, -0.04849201440811157, 0.009814845398068428, 0.01675201952457428, 0.03961316868662834, 0.02448771521449089, 0.012440260499715805, 0.011597096920013428, 0.020955968648195267, 0.03859632462263107, -0.02501780539751053, -0.002146471058949828, 0.01460549607872963, -0.0034040273167192936, 0.00532606802880764, 0.02540786936879158, 0.04813233017921448, 0.03907851129770279, -0.020895205438137054, -0.02589438110589981, 0.0104550551623106, -0.017227424308657646, -0.03586873412132263, -0.002336285077035427, -0.022404944524168968, -0.008962750434875488, 0.014611595310270786, 0.0013692084467038512, -0.019036944955587387, -0.033910203725099564, 0.04968845844268799, -0.013123574666678905, 0.025470152497291565, -0.01964053139090538, 0.0034607979469001293, -0.0686330571770668, 0.015488612465560436, -0.0001928159617818892, -0.033513348549604416, -0.04835997149348259, -0.0048066964372992516, -0.0002512134669814259, 0.00328562268987298, -0.012206876650452614, -0.014559340663254261, 0.00153897306881845, 0.04098999872803688, -0.013356455601751804, 0.04308129474520683, 0.02966289408504963, -0.010039011016488075, -0.010634160600602627, -0.07446306943893433, 0.07707002758979797, -0.003359769470989704, -0.006305689923465252, -0.016277650371193886, -0.01269928365945816, -0.006645196583122015, -0.02874699793756008, 0.07755905389785767, -0.03466715291142464, 0.005291424226015806, 0.002645679982379079, 0.027480505406856537, 0.02144424058496952, -0.04090603068470955, -0.009149746969342232, -0.054449662566185, 0.0052849906496703625, -0.029949577525258064, 0.00461364071816206, 0.016251666471362114, -0.003136628307402134, -0.006946172099560499, 0.0101146399974823, 0.01993236504495144, -0.0018010399071499705, -0.009589034132659435, 0.012432525865733624, -0.0037114033475518227, -0.002422874793410301, 0.017518822103738785, -0.04165837913751602, 0.022836958989501, 0.015156284905970097, -0.01219805609434843, -0.026833435520529747, 0.018503068014979362, -0.03701075538992882, -0.01788441836833954, -0.0041994331404566765, -0.011816651560366154, 0.005402265582233667, -0.049719832837581635, -0.012759082950651646, 0.055235911160707474, -0.028203580528497696, -0.02226955071091652, 0.028785450384020805, -0.006623098626732826, 0.06096707284450531, 0.017601018771529198, 0.04138164967298508, 0.0163132231682539, 0.027095500379800797, -0.004539600573480129, 0.03186086565256119, 0.04096565768122673, -0.021859485656023026, 0.020758874714374542, 0.006285622715950012, -0.01697513647377491, 0.05949731916189194, -0.0015427792677655816, 0.041350577026605606, -0.04007817059755325, -0.04124785587191582, 0.03370847925543785, 0.010537861846387386, -0.042845651507377625, 0.0038125815335661173, -0.03410676121711731, 0.03688175976276398, -0.030459770932793617, 0.023971283808350563, -0.003097730688750744, -0.0067493305541574955, -0.07476860284805298, -0.0008151252404786646, -0.031226871535182, 0.022168118506669998, 0.015920499339699745, 0.02912921831011772, 0.024607041850686073, 0.040902748703956604, 0.014824973419308662, -0.02939973771572113, 0.03701221942901611, 0.013954591006040573, -0.01919679157435894, -0.006710069719702005, -0.040150631219148636, -0.03891735523939133, -0.024427546188235283, 0.04228799045085907, 0.05067821219563484, 0.02593398652970791, 0.041411127895116806, -0.005744769237935543, -0.0004975612391717732, 0.0520935021340847, -0.059806082397699356, 0.02142271026968956, -0.04961236193776131, -0.01929357461631298, -0.010067002847790718, 0.009339329786598682 ]
<p>I have an unknown discrete probability distribution $D$ ($D$ is a probability mass function), defined on an interval $[a,b]$ ($a&gt;0$) and an estimation $\hat{D}$ such that, for all $t\in[a,b]$, $$(1-\varepsilon)D(t)\le\hat{D}(t)\le(1+\varepsilon)D(t)$$ for some fixed $\varepsilon\in(0,1)$. Moreover $\hat{D}$ is actually a distribution on $[a,b]$ too.</p> <p>Can anything be said about how well does the index of dispersion $\hat{\sigma}^2/\hat{\mu}$ of $\hat{D}$ approximate the index of dispersion $\sigma^2 / \mu$ of $D$?</p> <p>Note that it is easy to show that $(1-\varepsilon)\mu\le \hat{\mu}\le (1+\varepsilon)\mu$, but I'm stuck at showing a bound for the deviation between the variances $\hat{\sigma}^2$ and $\sigma^2$</p>
35,904
[ -0.02304440177977085, -0.013374324887990952, 0.022144261747598648, -0.02351716160774231, 0.027058036997914314, 0.025809353217482567, 0.006754092872142792, -0.02285805530846119, -0.009997148998081684, -0.03538539260625839, 0.03886750712990761, 0.023931555449962616, 0.08109371364116669, 0.009787271730601788, 0.01594376377761364, 0.0011543765431270003, -0.04326028376817703, 0.010152962058782578, -0.022402232512831688, -0.015193315222859383, -0.02266346476972103, 0.060060564428567886, 0.008188141509890556, -0.02531827613711357, -0.044728681445121765, 0.009902678430080414, 0.020289260894060135, 0.00045393031905405223, -0.027018694207072258, 0.080622598528862, -0.06421530246734619, -0.03218172490596771, 0.07022925466299057, 0.0383857786655426, 0.03583982586860657, 0.01033884659409523, -0.036575477570295334, -0.04289094731211662, -0.028232727199792862, 0.029994778335094452, -0.051116254180669785, -0.04635237157344818, -0.02493891678750515, 0.008372744545340538, 0.008011783473193645, 0.0008109007612802088, 0.011650662869215012, -0.03810203820466995, 0.048074185848236084, -0.03920217230916023, 0.08926854282617569, 0.0011441541137173772, 0.03805333748459816, 0.02851157821714878, -0.023280726745724678, -0.023325417190790176, 0.024848951026797295, 0.08282182365655899, -0.014879075810313225, -0.05069996789097786, -0.009328331798315048, -0.053612276911735535, 0.0384271964430809, -0.005033245775848627, -0.02715250849723816, 0.0173272043466568, 0.006730945315212011, -0.01896064355969429, 0.010056729428470135, -0.023266645148396492, -0.0016946358373388648, 0.003008950036019087, 0.035886332392692566, 0.014666230417788029, 0.029281677678227425, -0.015065347775816917, 0.020459558814764023, 0.020213041454553604, 0.04529711976647377, 0.024767303839325905, 0.009699414484202862, 0.00695220660418272, 0.02837659977376461, 0.0047705210745334625, 0.013213732279837132, -0.007243269123136997, 0.038433779031038284, -0.018639855086803436, -0.001993283163756132, 0.020476510748267174, -0.028498509898781776, -0.008001916110515594, 0.02568347379565239, -0.051333531737327576, -0.06942557543516159, 0.03428075462579727, -0.012897361069917679, 0.0009597745374776423, -0.011990235187113285, -0.04026122763752937, -0.043022386729717255, -0.05669967830181122, 0.05326946824789047, 0.07830552756786346, 0.016843076795339584, -0.034401606768369675, -0.026706291362643242, 0.005793727468699217, -0.034071389585733414, -0.029529865831136703, -0.017441822215914726, 0.017307894304394722, 0.0020338993053883314, -0.02228390984237194, 0.019837593659758568, 0.02520833909511566, -0.006389635615050793, -0.021234635263681412, 0.024930017068982124, 0.08088601380586624, 0.02805958315730095, 0.01510690525174141, -0.005077783018350601, -0.02407699078321457, -0.05410090833902359, 0.051944173872470856, 0.06253112852573395, -0.006915389094501734, -0.08331873267889023, 0.002360517391934991, 0.02091357298195362, -0.020601553842425346, 0.053916532546281815, 0.010932975448668003, 0.020756732672452927, -0.02179800160229206, -0.06184297800064087, -0.05029156804084778, 0.03202584385871887, -0.015460435301065445, -0.0019330427749082446, -0.0661589726805687, -0.02773088775575161, 0.028779150918126106, 0.030195346102118492, 0.02727585658431053, 0.08255109190940857, 0.002327615162357688, 0.03730648383498192, 0.025631235912442207, -0.029217787086963654, -0.03963597118854523, 0.025825683027505875, -0.025376319885253906, 0.003549163229763508, -0.03384169936180115, -0.0038029677234590054, 0.030113058164715767, -0.0274344515055418, -0.004437933675944805, 0.04588721692562103, 0.014026626944541931, 0.002335500903427601, 0.007266998756676912, 0.05496300756931305, -0.008531833067536354, 0.04345477744936943, 0.0068021416664123535, 0.028008833527565002, -0.01622670516371727, 0.0183083638548851, -0.0054230899550020695, 0.002935173222795129, 0.045210737735033035, 0.07594636082649231, -0.0496186800301075, -0.031000180169939995, -0.029402418062090874, 0.008455682545900345, 0.033857811242341995, -0.02282712049782276, -0.02253466658294201, -0.05502953380346298, 0.0097064059227705, -0.01097191497683525, 0.014907728880643845, 0.00044985476415604353, 0.0188450925052166, 0.048788826912641525, -0.05205401033163071, -0.019957631826400757, -0.07006200402975082, -0.005700590088963509, 0.031987264752388, -0.025013240054249763, 0.03497219458222389, -0.0047155641950666904, -0.018904918804764748, -0.0071074445731937885, -0.011590616777539253, 0.0036440491676330566, -0.018404124304652214, 0.027611812576651573, -0.027401527389883995, 0.012868116609752178, 0.04008285328745842, 0.0583365373313427, -0.020345376804471016, 0.04773539677262306, -0.02372800000011921, -0.057422783225774765, -0.0037108061369508505, -0.015421858988702297, 0.014235282316803932, 0.0054797218181192875, -0.00023220367438625544, 0.038425639271736145, -0.05592263862490654, -0.008072509430348873, 0.0003182562650181353, -0.031215613707900047, 0.04004323482513428, 0.0670294240117073, 0.01348148100078106, -0.00033503773738630116, 0.03743681311607361, 0.04500904679298401, 0.006078977137804031, -0.05618353188037872, -0.033695437014102936, -0.017144596204161644, 0.011845852248370647, 0.03873857110738754, 0.06889134645462036, -0.018496260046958923, 0.0012407841859385371, 0.020068015903234482, 0.03543158620595932, 0.028290340676903725, 0.02910161204636097, -0.008624500595033169, -0.014594055712223053, 0.013937219977378845, -0.004467075690627098, 0.0022588802967220545, 0.020287932828068733, 0.015578135848045349, -0.003061611671000719, 0.012576239183545113, 0.018433209508657455, 0.012712067924439907, 0.0002161508018616587, -0.016602978110313416, -0.022140121087431908, 0.01023311447352171, 0.018354710191488266, 0.022586042061448097, -0.03747302666306496, 0.012829260900616646, 0.05673275142908096, -0.009075804613530636, 0.04885030537843704, 0.0031385573092848063, -0.026767954230308533, 0.0760786309838295, 0.01747804880142212, -0.014021910727024078, -0.030202968046069145, 0.01065010391175747, -0.020826486870646477, -0.006986202672123909, -0.0009721264941617846, -0.018564138561487198, 0.000648651912342757, -0.006140262354165316, 0.02455667406320572, 0.02362332120537758, 0.017615817487239838, -0.014683310873806477, -0.020550865679979324, -0.015025915578007698, 0.014344898983836174, 0.03264741599559784, 0.009598891250789165, -0.023755189031362534, -0.021758457645773888, 0.003119101980701089, -0.0170125775039196, 0.050029028207063675, -0.028280744329094887, -0.02056816592812538, 0.001063382369466126, 0.009363113902509212, -0.024206198751926422, -0.016183173283934593, -0.004975969437509775, 0.002037829952314496, -0.05775013566017151, -0.00540500320494175, -0.004976537078619003, -0.0011273679556325078, -0.05876246094703674, 0.040890518575906754, -0.020484838634729385, -0.0714445561170578, -0.06302490085363388, 0.01301525067538023, 0.032272957265377045, -0.018062762916088104, 0.01688978262245655, 0.04202677682042122, 0.011082440614700317, -0.00042388439760543406, -0.05594280734658241, -0.03955213725566864, 0.05590611323714256, 0.00915093719959259, 0.016362134367227554, -0.004601594060659409, -0.020962608978152275, 0.07677432894706726, 0.03563617914915085, -0.014176782220602036, 0.005816156510263681, -0.0029815800953656435, 0.006586975418031216, 0.002944359788671136, 0.006248500198125839, 0.005158092826604843, 0.0064969900995492935, 0.034694913774728775, 0.009368724189698696, 0.04609108343720436, 0.04445420205593109, 0.002961513353511691, -0.015590665861964226, -0.0012624957598745823, -0.009673062711954117, -0.0006300422828644514, 0.030156221240758896, 0.009317724965512753, 0.01638997718691826, 0.025109902024269104, 0.007641573902219534, 0.02872072532773018, 0.028284382075071335, -0.0317704901099205, 0.008923809044063091, -0.035598862916231155, -0.0005302194622345269, -0.010981067083775997, 0.05014553293585777, 0.034998614341020584, -0.00784231722354889, -0.03605218976736069, -0.002683014376088977, 0.01766132563352585, -0.021418578922748566, -0.00055486656492576, 0.07439406216144562, 0.006299902219325304, 0.010899269953370094, 0.02346968837082386, -0.002793053863570094, 0.0222992654889822, -0.01699720323085785, -0.05469188839197159, -0.033150564879179, 0.024144968017935753, 0.06817880272865295, 0.009496277198195457, -0.05688485503196716, -0.03511342778801918, -0.006082956213504076, -0.038802847266197205, 0.012996230274438858, -0.011620267294347286, 0.04942991957068443, 0.007757577113807201, 0.04980739578604698, 0.00881644431501627, -0.0006620572530664504, 0.0054384381510317326, 0.014905160292983055, -0.062389254570007324, 0.0006990196416154504, -0.019547034054994583, -0.044758137315511703, -0.018351975828409195, -0.03080657310783863, 0.0334651917219162, -0.012782203033566475, 0.028243206441402435, -0.012677747756242752, 0.034775260835886, -0.03541497886180878, -0.006887063849717379, -0.038997530937194824, -0.007295448333024979, 0.00048321884241886437, 0.03194557502865791, 0.002220175927504897, -0.027441097423434258, 0.027336088940501213, 0.008211533538997173, -0.03652460128068924, 0.006347120273858309, -0.058035023510456085, 0.02051113359630108, 0.0004346554633229971, 0.0032940020319074392, 0.00768858939409256, 0.003024971578270197, -0.029473042115569115, -0.006354690529406071, 0.006793823093175888, 0.05994105711579323, 0.008763437159359455, -0.01362023688852787, -0.001108713448047638, -0.015369780361652374, -0.02736194245517254, 0.014369172975420952, 0.011003263294696808, -0.03358694538474083, 0.026240406557917595, 0.08271990716457367, -0.011590261943638325, -0.05223208665847778, 0.009900335222482681, 0.050041891634464264, -0.009022615849971771, 0.008644330315291882, -0.03055627830326557, -0.025431569665670395, -0.0247330442070961, -0.006533453240990639, 0.022967534139752388, -0.010865394026041031, -0.0076261176727712154, -0.0012275875778868794, 0.03119620680809021, 0.03726678714156151, -0.020840486511588097, 0.001017045578919351, 0.04791632667183876, 0.020550595596432686, 0.009666903875768185, -0.011096340604126453, 0.011702784337103367, 0.027295460924506187, 0.04022129625082016, 0.032140620052814484, 0.007945259101688862, -0.09124407917261124, -0.013284694403409958, 0.028515636920928955, 0.031166180968284607, -0.024026568979024887, 0.028997134417295456, -0.04703405871987343, -0.010570603422820568, 0.0784374326467514, -0.0368906632065773, -0.01657554879784584, -0.028890876099467278, -0.019332867115736008, -0.027209719642996788, -0.05366368219256401, -0.0329153910279274, 0.017774516716599464, 0.011285054497420788, 0.01833968795835972, -0.02268647775053978, -0.013403482735157013, -0.035298947244882584, 0.009815270081162453, 0.04061088338494301, 0.08972389996051788, -0.01956641860306263, -0.03380047157406807, -0.0029078987427055836, 0.027176063507795334, -0.015263601206243038, -0.06081279367208481, 0.022414859384298325, 0.004917928948998451, 0.0006591476849280298, 0.036900460720062256, -0.04089650511741638, -0.03724372386932373, 0.03664182126522064, 0.023369543254375458, -0.0071467929519712925, 0.02708486095070839, -0.006804067175835371, 0.03446280583739281, 0.007082294672727585, 0.02603539638221264, 0.011180761270225048, 0.02267124131321907, 0.029581904411315918, 0.03204616531729698, -0.008950852788984776, 0.021318433806300163, -0.02537066675722599, -0.033310260623693466, -0.01834649220108986, -0.04073552414774895, -0.03456313535571098, 0.05539574474096298, -0.004243135917931795, 0.04971616342663765, 0.0029923608526587486, -0.0018503362080082297, 0.006350154522806406, 0.02726130560040474, 0.02494879812002182, -0.007910529151558876, 0.014327453449368477, 0.055583082139492035, 0.018294692039489746, -0.015131162479519844, 0.028049428015947342, 0.003362733405083418, -0.013165447860956192, 0.01402515359222889, -0.06515742093324661, 0.017203381285071373, -0.06605798006057739, -0.04624031111598015, -0.019022252410650253, 0.009187337011098862, 0.03885839134454727, -0.017877021804451942, 0.00791222508996725, 0.00977575033903122, -0.043909091502428055, -0.016999978572130203, 0.027173757553100586, -0.024398889392614365, 0.03893965482711792, -0.04391526058316231, 0.03214342147111893, -0.012449907138943672, 0.0034682489931583405, -0.0979212149977684, 0.006283673923462629, -0.020461993291974068, 0.007155526429414749, -0.03215641528367996, -0.038891829550266266, 0.016373643651604652, -0.012075390666723251, -0.02875320240855217, -0.01275397464632988, 0.03877640515565872, 0.017172785475850105, -0.031894829124212265, -0.02480860985815525, 0.01605226658284664, 0.09977839142084122, -0.04742090031504631, 0.006729058921337128, 0.0007263548322953284, -0.02559162676334381, -0.0032740356400609016, 0.048189084976911545, 0.01168951764702797, -0.026800964027643204, 0.00331494165584445, -0.018901951611042023, -0.004836199805140495, 0.026753518730401993, -0.023823613300919533, -0.01029924489557743, 0.027988558635115623, 0.013449187390506268, 0.033083751797676086, -0.0210716649889946, -0.0340912826359272, -0.028575031086802483, 0.014148050919175148, -0.039761532098054886, -0.005074572749435902, -0.002676017815247178, 0.02934676967561245, 0.014203406870365143, 0.019771073013544083, -0.010868274606764317, 0.0037497791927307844, 0.04302574321627617, -0.012372460216283798, 0.015171844512224197, 0.007282791193574667, 0.011108936741948128, 0.03784731402993202, -0.014955420978367329, -0.010575927793979645, 0.028259113430976868, 0.020329371094703674, -0.030311740934848785, -0.0339323915541172, -0.017721613869071007, 0.01360462699085474, 0.0497378334403038, 0.023049207404255867, 0.047027550637722015, 0.018156250938773155, 0.01386304385960102, -0.00984472967684269, -0.013430875726044178, 0.01119673065841198, -0.005350630264729261, -0.03218502551317215, 0.03369246795773506, -0.03749314323067665, 0.021693531423807144, 0.04452575743198395, 0.019069895148277283, 0.017214642837643623, 0.035134926438331604, -0.020397981628775597, 0.020473243668675423, 0.016549592837691307, -0.03425373509526253, -0.03326478227972984, 0.03980744630098343, -0.05996032804250717, -0.006760620046406984, -0.033264096826314926, 0.000900243641808629, 0.033184681087732315, 0.011833764612674713, -0.007703689858317375, 0.03668547421693802, -0.06436871737241745, -0.03677304461598396, 0.03011956252157688, 0.007432541809976101, 0.00099235272500664, 0.03733446076512337, -0.024435963481664658, -0.00021345641289371997, -0.008840679191052914, 0.016302159056067467, -0.011480252258479595, -0.08528744429349899, -0.025468885898590088, -0.033166415989398956, -0.05293691158294678, 0.013266491703689098, 0.013989283703267574, -0.02604973502457142, 0.018710140138864517, -0.043036848306655884, 0.023713283240795135, 0.007537888363003731, -0.009874792769551277, -0.024869440123438835, 0.09351251274347305, 0.007402485702186823, 0.012906307354569435, 0.008127822540700436, 0.008649512194097042, 0.08558360487222672, 0.049372006207704544, 0.03845137357711792, -0.042491063475608826, -0.0031345325987786055, 0.00017073311028070748, 0.022076115012168884, -0.06136706471443176, 0.029534943401813507, 0.00877122487872839, -0.02577551268041134, 0.005039413925260305, 0.03042523004114628, 0.03163909912109375, -0.034143924713134766, 0.03688424453139305, -0.023289170116186142, 0.013527198694646358, -0.0008176764822565019, -0.022670641541481018, 0.016177963465452194, -0.008849482983350754, -0.060468729585409164, -0.005287273321300745, -0.011991203762590885, 0.04410498961806297, -0.02136441133916378, -0.009277863427996635, -0.02973286621272564, -0.005587011110037565, -0.0667107030749321, -0.0038525890558958054, 0.026619428768754005, -0.01407560333609581, -0.017786499112844467, -0.018050482496619225, -0.0036596646532416344, -0.014081111177802086, 0.0020638660062104464, 0.021284764632582664, -0.03159928694367409, 0.03344670683145523, 0.03168056905269623, 0.022649697959423065, -0.006346289534121752, -0.029036983847618103, -0.037064675241708755, 0.04069922864437103, -0.028822533786296844, 0.00786641612648964, 0.03928172215819359, -0.03923464193940163, -0.049905866384506226, -0.0649489089846611, -0.013657713308930397, -0.021708708256483078, 0.02008986286818981, -0.020567473024129868, -0.0013325654435902834, -0.013587318360805511, 0.048072367906570435, -0.0156064098700881, 0.017744820564985275, -0.028530428186058998, -0.02914450317621231, -0.053334228694438934, 0.02977610193192959, 0.06483151763677597, 0.014523402787744999, -0.014937050640583038, 0.022138861939311028, -0.023694220930337906, -0.009857934899628162, -0.018498282879590988, 0.000011309653928037733, -0.03973010554909706, 0.04866985231637955, 0.009574253112077713, 0.024003049358725548, -0.007886353880167007, -0.0617227628827095, 0.0038781973998993635, -0.031656138598918915, 0.00912692490965128, -0.03762715309858322, -0.009477815590798855, 0.05767277255654335, 0.022316910326480865, -0.005734613630920649, 0.018494611606001854, 0.011427321471273899, 0.0606997013092041, 0.03266707807779312, -0.029285132884979248, -0.004234990570694208, -0.003959284629672766, 0.011356490664184093, 0.027185454964637756, 0.0033212187699973583, 0.040943730622529984, 0.027412325143814087, 0.03357413411140442, -0.005490739364176989, 0.014696797356009483, -0.025114260613918304, 0.030653418973088264, 0.006945053115487099, -0.033318642526865005, -0.02452057972550392, 0.030340073630213737, 0.002708299783989787, -0.028397172689437866, -0.025551870465278625, -0.052299872040748596, 0.0000029282759896887, -0.014913374558091164, -0.01037126500159502, -0.03965198993682861, -0.014581475406885147, 0.002736311173066497, -0.003446391085162759, -0.020388053730130196, -0.002168675884604454, -0.020046602934598923, 0.00561675475910306, -0.016195908188819885, 0.008347704075276852, -0.003843564772978425, 0.008131692185997963, -0.008433114737272263, 0.001231884234584868, 0.04149466007947922, 0.06529870629310608, 0.03861406445503235, 0.022213978692889214, 0.011469140648841858, -0.00056219391990453, 0.0539231151342392, -0.041066572070121765, -0.05367680639028549, 0.06244954839348793, -0.043667182326316833, -0.015725167468190193, 0.0612049475312233, -0.012257272377610207, 0.03333255648612976, -0.01195025909692049, -0.006104502826929092, -0.016517339274287224, 0.05644459277391434, -0.02515735849738121, -0.002286796225234866, 0.002577718812972307, -0.03137208893895149, -0.004737216513603926, -0.05053810775279999, 0.029766187071800232, -0.010631577111780643, 0.0019076631870120764, 0.02482026070356369, 0.04521836340427399, 0.021773476153612137, 0.011308731511235237, 0.02256937325000763, -0.017960011959075928, 0.03194583207368851, 0.00009158573811873794, -0.0033508441410958767, 0.03503765910863876, 0.0763525515794754, -0.06290129572153091, 0.012007113546133041, -0.006244762800633907, 0.040770672261714935, -0.08878713846206665, -0.0058128610253334045, 0.04300520196557045, 0.06480884552001953, 0.05645298585295677, -0.03688819706439972, 0.0033467100001871586, 0.04214353859424591, -0.0385403037071228, 0.027736535295844078, -0.023053811863064766, 0.02463710866868496, -0.0460582934319973, -0.005823958665132523, -0.07312865555286407, 0.026997951790690422, 0.019799573346972466, 0.014056411571800709, 0.03347640112042427, 0.05901666730642319, -0.03187106177210808, -0.03962807357311249, 0.00807949062436819, 0.016717134043574333, 0.020893588662147522, -0.07768703252077103, 0.02869504876434803, -0.03138621151447296, -0.01678207702934742, 0.023372497409582138, -0.005781825166195631, -0.015395328402519226, 0.011539271101355553, 0.031467169523239136, -0.0034035348799079657, 0.042623404413461685, 0.040339771658182144, 0.03156178817152977, 0.04096750542521477, -0.0144203407689929, 0.018882855772972107, 0.0013933575246483088, -0.036277007311582565, 0.007189896889030933, 0.025132998824119568, -0.019768986850976944, -0.026591939851641655, 0.024970829486846924, -0.0044364845380187035, -0.04857626557350159, 0.006844366434961557, 0.012108401395380497, 0.010772749781608582, -0.04136698693037033, 0.04468195512890816, -0.02928709238767624, 0.0007890986162237823, 0.054632775485515594, 0.0478862002491951, -0.010408895090222359, 0.010398383252322674, 0.014751454815268517, -0.06162102520465851, 0.03443269804120064, 0.013705483637750149, -0.04737004265189171, -0.08356092870235443, -0.0010224244324490428, -0.013409659266471863, 0.030098935589194298, -0.008061946369707584, -0.03804028779268265, -0.004347092472016811, 0.010523389093577862, -0.02603263221681118, -0.02039971947669983, 0.004393287003040314, 0.009045650251209736, -0.002077452838420868, -0.10999567806720734, 0.0440983809530735, -0.002463588025420904, -0.003179131308570504, -0.037846073508262634, 0.021393222734332085, -0.03479183092713356, -0.007805182598531246, 0.02394729107618332, 0.012709093280136585, -0.018595736473798752, 0.030500119552016258, 0.004721389152109623, 0.027768529951572418, -0.010982844047248363, 0.011400317773222923, -0.03815832734107971, -0.016529172658920288, -0.0061257220804691315, -0.024445153772830963, -0.015730831772089005, 0.007151844445616007, -0.006929661147296429, -0.0006200000643730164, 0.002895607613027096, 0.03425665944814682, -0.007947837933897972, 0.02715873531997204, 0.014875562861561775, -0.0014375621685758233, 0.04980664700269699, 0.022801976650953293, -0.004192146938294172, 0.03713959828019142, -0.027477938681840897, -0.05367942899465561, 0.05937366560101509, 0.026384375989437103, -0.020653367042541504, 0.01074445340782404, 0.04050585255026817, -0.01904143951833248, -0.01670767553150654, 0.002580398228019476, 0.011081738397479057, -0.02082791179418564, -0.010752097703516483, 0.01412335503846407, 0.004157900344580412, 0.04702899232506752, 0.02454974316060543, 0.01949603110551834, 0.05146225541830063, -0.0010574134066700935, 0.007788496557623148, 0.030582133680582047, -0.006115378811955452, -0.03325710818171501, 0.009279432706534863, 0.028781263157725334, -0.035960257053375244, 0.003880599746480584, -0.012494761496782303, 0.01844935491681099, -0.0000895239063538611, -0.024140488356351852, -0.002019138541072607, -0.025863047689199448, -0.02355734072625637, 0.016736485064029694, -0.03432514891028404, 0.038779690861701965, -0.03295470401644707, 0.014043651521205902, -0.018099717795848846, -0.028599778190255165, -0.008886427618563175, 0.01423793938010931, -0.009799695573747158, 0.02480759285390377, 0.0014097479870542884, -0.004193014465272427, -0.011842530220746994, -0.017006821930408478, -0.005668499507009983, -0.04144428297877312, 0.02457183413207531, -0.0005582551239058375, -0.012409728020429611, -0.031338389962911606, -0.024238569661974907, -0.026841795071959496, -0.037927962839603424, 0.005381764844059944, 0.06530319154262543, 0.02311846800148487, -0.004727872088551521, -0.06601134687662125, 0.001971345627680421, 0.026992030441761017, -0.0649406760931015, 0.0010426522931084037, -0.06710517406463623, -0.006351798307150602, -0.04794459789991379, -0.03769683465361595 ]
<p>I have a dataset: </p> <pre><code>5, 10, 11, 13, 15, 35, 50 ,55, 72, 92, 204, 215 </code></pre> <p>The formula for binning into equal-widths is this (as far as I know) $$width = (max - min) / N$$</p> <p>I think N is a number that divides the length of the list nicely. So in this case it is 3. Therefore:</p> <p>width = 70</p> <p>How do I use that 70 to make the bins? </p> <p><strong>EDIT: Found the answer. Should I answer my own question or just delete it?</strong></p>
73,511
[ -0.019058944657444954, -0.03760926052927971, 0.001396769192069769, -0.003050796687602997, 0.021308330819010735, -0.014592930674552917, -0.03790422901511192, -0.02491004951298237, 0.018651233986020088, 0.004843355622142553, 0.03404027968645096, 0.05071180686354637, 0.037094298750162125, 0.03489023074507713, 0.032170653343200684, -0.0016764812171459198, 0.0008449604501947761, -0.03543081507086754, 0.015095426701009274, -0.035706739872694016, -0.008937669917941093, -0.0014616408152505755, 0.026652975007891655, -0.009486236609518528, -0.04685224965214729, 0.04791545867919922, 0.040226396173238754, 0.01622435264289379, 0.02024131827056408, 0.056176166981458664, -0.031890857964754105, -0.06305720657110214, 0.054083146154880524, 0.04405906796455383, 0.04282880201935768, -0.006206413730978966, -0.0199591014534235, -0.041396621614694595, -0.03528779000043869, -0.003390181576833129, -0.022065674886107445, 0.0384821817278862, 0.010058902204036713, 0.016236739233136177, -0.036198873072862625, 0.028281325474381447, -0.006374916527420282, -0.023630063980817795, 0.01594969816505909, -0.04212138429284096, 0.07744894176721573, -0.027604952454566956, 0.0299382284283638, 0.0345008410513401, -0.03930426388978958, 0.0022899045143276453, 0.044169697910547256, 0.045835018157958984, -0.029865533113479614, -0.06749462336301804, -0.023597106337547302, -0.02722037583589554, 0.006663348060101271, 0.004109344445168972, -0.03442113846540451, 0.0035813641734421253, -0.012938333675265312, -0.029948020353913307, 0.015776094049215317, 0.0012307307915762067, -0.0005874908529222012, 0.03127569332718849, 0.04150702804327011, -0.02389082871377468, 0.026054823771119118, -0.027258064597845078, 0.07408034056425095, 0.010822848416864872, 0.030190525576472282, 0.059847623109817505, -0.03078513592481613, 0.02254587598145008, 0.011974961496889591, 0.011503002606332302, 0.036874111741781235, -0.014062893576920033, 0.07841629534959793, -0.03337221220135689, 0.04799026623368263, 0.002375274430960417, -0.006101061590015888, -0.001590041327290237, 0.07920879870653152, 0.004484840668737888, -0.012136195786297321, 0.06672053784132004, -0.012472780421376228, 0.02069677785038948, -0.004569341894239187, -0.021425390616059303, -0.030849942937493324, -0.028573594987392426, 0.016980541869997978, 0.0646524578332901, -0.03685479611158371, -0.003532503033056855, -0.05467529222369194, -0.020088927820324898, 0.01462035533040762, 0.00732299592345953, -0.00538088520988822, 0.011208619922399521, -0.009753293357789516, -0.03175288066267967, -0.01093630213290453, -0.03591499477624893, -0.004792642313987017, 0.020818432793021202, 0.051895011216402054, 0.049905095249414444, 0.05332603305578232, -0.060817379504442215, 0.0610666386783123, -0.022571228444576263, -0.07324996590614319, -0.013202045112848282, 0.009834831580519676, 0.017860593274235725, -0.04268962889909744, 0.054488394409418106, -0.07057550549507141, -0.009884079918265343, 0.023503951728343964, -0.01686111092567444, 0.019267017021775246, -0.0000684554033796303, -0.08768175542354584, -0.04766453057527542, 0.032230813056230545, -0.010966172441840172, -0.01921760104596615, -0.025840263813734055, 0.03877780959010124, 0.040335506200790405, 0.030229615047574043, 0.0055849989876151085, 0.021928168833255768, -0.017709121108055115, 0.0069349477998912334, 0.0348062701523304, -0.0325729064643383, 0.0034432464744895697, 0.008282242342829704, -0.024626580998301506, -0.004083522595465183, -0.041002072393894196, -0.005581398494541645, 0.028108425438404083, 0.014415578916668892, -0.055722761899232864, 0.0426141694188118, -0.024363236501812935, 0.011849501170217991, -0.03871169313788414, -0.0186832994222641, -0.028521647676825523, 0.057510118931531906, -0.005890810862183571, 0.03520052507519722, 0.01946442760527134, -0.05110861733555794, -0.017710261046886444, 0.048593346029520035, 0.012926341034471989, 0.05243881046772003, -0.00918904971331358, 0.004624467808753252, -0.03641926124691963, 0.0254838727414608, 0.013188192620873451, 0.005673041567206383, -0.038278624415397644, 0.011689083650708199, 0.0049557071179151535, 0.045797016471624374, 0.025199035182595253, 0.01823495700955391, -0.017156483605504036, 0.04617995768785477, -0.03984539955854416, -0.01685929484665394, -0.06637793034315109, 0.03124384582042694, 0.019142000004649162, -0.01575654000043869, -0.012199320830404758, 0.018977075815200806, -0.0018219281919300556, 0.009528808295726776, -0.030361898243427277, -0.0063849459402263165, -0.00250562303699553, 0.048762090504169464, -0.03261274844408035, -0.025248980149626732, 0.0770513191819191, -0.0026773831341415644, -0.03591717407107353, 0.07377767562866211, -0.008998301811516285, -0.016921378672122955, 0.013145480304956436, -0.018621860072016716, 0.007963703013956547, -0.017766311764717102, -0.016277071088552475, 0.011071904562413692, 0.020867858082056046, -0.014771775342524052, 0.03443783149123192, -0.02754073403775692, 0.07067899405956268, 0.05844051390886307, -0.018197080120444298, 0.00801538024097681, -0.04073391109704971, -0.010975825600326061, 0.03515882045030594, 0.006138461176306009, -0.007078507915139198, -0.07181703299283981, 0.0022901210468262434, 0.04688257351517677, -0.008722982369363308, -0.014365199953317642, -0.03135991096496582, 0.0581260547041893, -0.006175812799483538, 0.019299965351819992, 0.011976887471973896, -0.034174852073192596, 0.010490236803889275, 0.015834735706448555, 0.01913878321647644, 0.028378399088978767, 0.008971097879111767, 0.015349963679909706, 0.028814133256673813, 0.029286591336131096, 0.042304158210754395, -0.0053909290581941605, 0.00752673065289855, 0.003286210587248206, -0.01090181153267622, -0.01896403729915619, -0.03486703708767891, 0.04036771133542061, -0.007161668036133051, -0.02947128377854824, 0.05679823085665703, 0.0040419031865894794, -0.015225473791360855, 0.02415233477950096, -0.014508645050227642, -0.0250442773103714, 0.045661672949790955, -0.04557335749268532, 0.015334144234657288, 0.021238652989268303, -0.02699124999344349, 0.005856072064489126, 0.01655389554798603, -0.015239780768752098, -0.04320802912116051, 0.0055210888385772705, 0.029238607734441757, -0.005216619931161404, 0.022693583741784096, -0.036777857691049576, -0.0019182900432497263, -0.013680153526365757, -0.009883957915008068, 0.013188105076551437, -0.06260644644498825, -0.08474709093570709, -0.015104872174561024, 0.031683340668678284, -0.030628729611635208, -0.00023637375852558762, -0.004263024311512709, -0.014158290810883045, 0.0214383602142334, -0.029399435967206955, 0.009172151796519756, -0.006335309706628323, -0.03473358973860741, 0.04119737073779106, -0.028486985713243484, -0.01985219679772854, 0.07180658727884293, 0.006763302255421877, -0.08205819129943848, 0.025713615119457245, -0.02913108840584755, -0.017009925097227097, -0.045593101531267166, 0.0042180330492556095, 0.034960683435201645, 0.0019296901300549507, -0.04097381606698036, 0.04775908589363098, 0.015324375592172146, 0.003531913971528411, -0.06436874717473984, -0.039954714477062225, -0.003969560377299786, -0.023489724844694138, 0.007722762878984213, 0.03448980674147606, -0.026934344321489334, 0.06244119256734848, 0.03529410436749458, -0.020909558981657028, -0.03104451298713684, -0.024050313979387283, 0.004803537856787443, -0.041558507829904556, 0.06837347149848938, 0.011038349010050297, 0.007104120217263699, -0.03467074781656265, 0.025884520262479782, 0.06316781789064407, 0.040201231837272644, 0.00011090550833614543, -0.0182638056576252, 0.005577473901212215, 0.009526419453322887, -0.031137702986598015, -0.002539889421314001, 0.027833763509988785, -0.028153102844953537, 0.02751445397734642, -0.01468888483941555, 0.01890716701745987, 0.02854917384684086, -0.00009865948231890798, 0.0032403217628598213, 0.009651786647737026, 0.067923404276371, -0.006307834293693304, 0.037129465490579605, 0.0017105565639212728, -0.052351683378219604, 0.010839559137821198, 0.03340519964694977, 0.04536128044128418, -0.04926464334130287, -0.02800814062356949, 0.03153336048126221, 0.009481696411967278, -0.032143428921699524, 0.012180287390947342, 0.008926634676754475, -0.026018520817160606, -0.010842344723641872, -0.009004362858831882, -0.019843345507979393, 0.01920885033905506, 0.04300522431731224, 0.04686686396598816, 0.0003394639352336526, -0.04554372280836105, 0.0036309377755969763, -0.09309892356395721, 0.012034419924020767, -0.0095348060131073, 0.05920896679162979, 0.013696917332708836, 0.04301091283559799, 0.024158090353012085, 0.013449475169181824, 0.035251013934612274, 0.009672197513282299, -0.04161680489778519, 0.03814515471458435, 0.027355287224054337, 0.007197811733931303, -0.020708678290247917, -0.033810656517744064, 0.0056551676243543625, -0.016691474243998528, 0.018290912732481956, -0.010635493323206902, -0.00614689476788044, -0.018630947917699814, 0.011490059085190296, 0.01183756347745657, 0.013322974555194378, 0.025474373251199722, 0.049975235015153885, 0.056938834488391876, -0.0059015145525336266, 0.04757999628782272, 0.03519091382622719, -0.008258866146206856, -0.0372343584895134, -0.02180921472609043, -0.006838932167738676, -0.013526138849556446, 0.028834765776991844, 0.0030695267487317324, 0.009855862706899643, -0.018914181739091873, 0.02355753630399704, -0.030902624130249023, 0.03171277046203613, 0.026414768770337105, 0.021872855722904205, 0.01681085117161274, -0.010818411596119404, 0.01853223890066147, 0.0017439713701605797, 0.008408170193433762, -0.0217355415225029, 0.025170868262648582, 0.043465692549943924, 0.02111753635108471, -0.05995146185159683, 0.042069364339113235, 0.09614474326372147, -0.019466275349259377, -0.0037582730874419212, -0.05988047644495964, 0.0156074995175004, -0.016183463856577873, 0.001977378036826849, -0.007550747599452734, 0.0448157973587513, 0.03281005471944809, 0.032970160245895386, 0.03584137558937073, -0.019987398758530617, -0.02990504913032055, -0.0005111405625939369, -0.002038107253611088, 0.02544083073735237, -0.015409106388688087, -0.03826789930462837, 0.009598423726856709, 0.023192819207906723, 0.04428032040596008, 0.005026600789278746, -0.016293497756123543, -0.1258724331855774, -0.005951573606580496, 0.05039059743285179, 0.03554990515112877, -0.044798072427511215, -0.008017412386834621, -0.03320639207959175, 0.009858117438852787, 0.04317299649119377, -0.034217868000268936, 0.03859847038984299, -0.04229326173663139, 0.008010488003492355, -0.00515228696167469, 0.01832568645477295, -0.0390901044011116, 0.01903807371854782, -0.0335879884660244, 0.0247071273624897, 0.027380816638469696, -0.03378434106707573, -0.05123189464211464, 0.012676024809479713, 0.027509517967700958, 0.07326778024435043, -0.03695397824048996, -0.026217671111226082, 0.0014529697364196181, 0.006638939492404461, -0.02134016342461109, -0.042717039585113525, 0.015244720503687859, -0.009164219722151756, -0.010883383452892303, 0.03423386439681053, 0.0013560329098254442, -0.031211016699671745, 0.010486502200365067, 0.027451692149043083, -0.014404801651835442, -0.006884814705699682, -0.03542735427618027, 0.06195339560508728, 0.017688162624835968, 0.017327940091490746, 0.010589617304503918, 0.042988572269678116, -0.0027422758284956217, 0.006813329178839922, -0.06690797954797745, 0.027691951021552086, -0.005829188972711563, -0.00523726362735033, -0.048114072531461716, 0.04078397527337074, -0.04335523396730423, 0.0171857587993145, 0.0027505778707563877, 0.025762062519788742, -0.04326242208480835, -0.007148910779505968, -0.04130405932664871, 0.050424810498952866, -0.0016421212349087, -0.007441265974193811, 0.015528359450399876, -0.007483179215341806, -0.0054567609913647175, -0.007299212273210287, 0.03388657048344612, -0.02944134920835495, 0.013763682916760445, 0.015273690223693848, -0.030794676393270493, 0.018895220011472702, -0.029516534879803658, -0.004096444696187973, 0.00024353315529879183, 0.009569715708494186, 0.01454235054552555, 0.042085640132427216, 0.02554934285581112, 0.007305286359041929, -0.03029203973710537, -0.025101665407419205, 0.006229019723832607, -0.027790026739239693, -0.012278389185667038, -0.05946289747953415, 0.0772818997502327, 0.002547886921092868, 0.00756723852828145, -0.06251615285873413, -0.05787143111228943, 0.024760587140917778, 0.002142515731975436, 0.0023795689921826124, -0.046061206609010696, -0.011251529678702354, 0.01934884674847126, -0.0200430266559124, -0.025015302002429962, 0.010068363510072231, -0.01491529867053032, 0.00656683836132288, -0.023160181939601898, -0.016910580918192863, 0.08138411492109299, 0.034253574907779694, 0.02207532711327076, -0.01916295476257801, -0.0027206093072891235, -0.02223477140069008, 0.004507153760641813, -0.03827064484357834, -0.01615753211081028, -0.05015348270535469, -0.00723003875464201, 0.014756501652300358, 0.03668713942170143, -0.011262957006692886, 0.016477085649967194, -0.03626534342765808, -0.002504779025912285, -0.00028362180455587804, -0.028287047520279884, 0.012824068777263165, -0.0329790897667408, 0.00022240247926674783, -0.0675002932548523, 0.015220512636005878, -0.0340677835047245, -0.004219807218760252, 0.005136457271873951, 0.02403952181339264, -0.010921238921582699, 0.02763259969651699, 0.06995703279972076, -0.05850769206881523, 0.006174932233989239, -0.005958094261586666, -0.04364053159952164, 0.08138460665941238, 0.05442674085497856, -0.0075166234746575356, -0.009143330156803131, 0.021827830001711845, -0.019608257338404655, -0.01982344686985016, -0.05179748311638832, -0.011331942863762379, 0.03982081636786461, -0.04091646149754524, 0.029233576729893684, 0.025526108220219612, 0.0026232798118144274, 0.03665287420153618, -0.03125699982047081, -0.020202862098813057, 0.005582199431955814, 0.014746570959687233, 0.04672825336456299, 0.0003939169691875577, 0.02011907286942005, 0.04992184415459633, -0.00355053273960948, 0.039649832993745804, 0.007248625624924898, 0.016224408522248268, -0.03375587239861488, 0.004132458940148354, -0.02674315869808197, -0.024982338771224022, 0.032854821532964706, -0.0066052512265741825, -0.013315041549503803, -0.027497708797454834, -0.005561463534832001, 0.029734956100583076, 0.0028625684790313244, -0.0254060011357069, -0.003943377174437046, -0.005901508964598179, -0.017204485833644867, -0.02239135466516018, 0.04197299852967262, -0.034155555069446564, 0.018686292693018913, 0.009543923661112785, 0.00024792083422653377, -0.01550148706883192, 0.010635322891175747, 0.011834001168608665, -0.024973534047603607, -0.04241276532411575, -0.06442044675350189, -0.05958539620041847, 0.017819512635469437, 0.00571626890450716, -0.011473116464912891, 0.02236340567469597, -0.008988087996840477, 0.037383828312158585, 0.008316783234477043, 0.032741036266088486, 0.006162777543067932, 0.07390624284744263, -0.010687205940485, 0.017432887107133865, -0.011938754469156265, -0.03425317257642746, 0.10689926147460938, 0.05463855713605881, 0.036869440227746964, -0.05432587116956711, 0.030013732612133026, 0.017476964741945267, -0.058997780084609985, -0.011252732947468758, -0.0011290768161416054, 0.016029851511120796, 0.024314366281032562, 0.04149416461586952, 0.028469564393162727, 0.009326649829745293, 0.027754364535212517, 0.01503673568367958, -0.042428091168403625, -0.0067728180438280106, 0.047043632715940475, 0.006374079268425703, -0.0032182259019464254, -0.01094027329236269, -0.1040896326303482, 0.024149345234036446, 0.05644076690077782, -0.028829393908381462, -0.04360438883304596, -0.009696314111351967, 0.006702778395265341, 0.01796373911201954, -0.013519078493118286, 0.014358265325427055, 0.0065172575414180756, -0.0009288903675042093, -0.012314265593886375, -0.03950996324419975, 0.03742821142077446, -0.00806209072470665, -0.03118937462568283, 0.05223463848233223, -0.005543328821659088, 0.016552824527025223, -0.05491838976740837, 0.023606030270457268, -0.052360229194164276, -0.026437882333993912, -0.036205340176820755, -0.000566215836443007, -0.00712802866473794, -0.018685879185795784, 0.003869222942739725, 0.04680286720395088, -0.0008948892937041819, -0.008668417111039162, -0.020142842084169388, 0.04538007825613022, 0.0030837866943329573, -0.027685336768627167, 0.011230513453483582, 0.010951855219900608, -0.007221366744488478, -0.007590421941131353, 0.017789216712117195, -0.01578349806368351, 0.015352698974311352, 0.008358744904398918, -0.04441577568650246, 0.022107833996415138, 0.005891553126275539, -0.0031325400341302156, 0.011068788357079029, -0.0318579338490963, -0.034185994416475296, -0.004739432595670223, 0.03783658519387245, 0.030084937810897827, -0.039235860109329224, 0.00288148014806211, -0.038867998868227005, 0.016085322946310043, -0.024866648018360138, 0.02124798484146595, 0.006644347216933966, -0.01572304032742977, -0.01848306879401207, -0.008052659220993519, -0.004051182884722948, 0.05380737781524658, 0.02503436803817749, 0.03726785629987717, 0.02036161720752716, 0.06358929723501205, -0.010525986552238464, -0.05436858907341957, -0.018653737381100655, -0.008062533102929592, -0.04006389528512955, -0.0031957405153661966, -0.010166285559535027, 0.07576504349708557, 0.006438459735363722, 0.03176935762166977, -0.004582907538861036, 0.021862056106328964, -0.0035358520690351725, 0.01058605033904314, -0.010482223704457283, -0.02738984301686287, 0.034077249467372894, 0.04028770700097084, 0.010584995150566101, -0.07651890814304352, -0.017142033204436302, -0.019925668835639954, -0.01842651329934597, 0.010489570908248425, -0.009476710110902786, -0.03878789767622948, 0.006092090625315905, 0.007333411835134029, -0.019402382895350456, -0.03822321072220802, -0.016988426446914673, -0.02037922292947769, -0.010185535997152328, -0.02054443024098873, 0.008973347023129463, 0.007191841956228018, -0.031158480793237686, -0.027100544422864914, 0.020139150321483612, 0.02972390688955784, -0.010826418176293373, 0.022101566195487976, -0.02776496112346649, 0.017001187428832054, 0.04231564700603485, 0.03862042725086212, -0.021265177056193352, -0.0423022098839283, 0.0524696409702301, -0.06077577546238899, -0.03650509566068649, 0.009855515323579311, -0.025867504999041557, 0.03883587568998337, 0.009426303207874298, 0.005551909562200308, -0.022426040843129158, 0.072104312479496, -0.003885615849867463, -0.027845827862620354, -0.0024018411058932543, 0.017909282818436623, 0.013075885362923145, 0.01100310031324625, -0.02869933843612671, -0.007671675644814968, -0.04160597175359726, 0.038006190210580826, 0.04074608162045479, 0.0075045437552034855, -0.015243134461343288, 0.01729140616953373, 0.030014317482709885, 0.022662384435534477, -0.025052402168512344, -0.02656460553407669, -0.007238398306071758, 0.03952651470899582, -0.0431549958884716, 0.013560105115175247, -0.03024456836283207, -0.01695467345416546, -0.10096091032028198, -0.012347652576863766, -0.01910916157066822, -0.0276303943246603, 0.034541331231594086, -0.07474632561206818, 0.03716597706079483, 0.016080321744084358, -0.013822022825479507, 0.0061613996513187885, 0.018034595996141434, 0.01058502122759819, -0.04161405190825462, 0.04810315743088722, -0.07678426802158356, 0.026873130351305008, 0.03978870436549187, 0.02307562716305256, 0.04943154752254486, -0.002532238606363535, -0.001394394552335143, -0.03684258460998535, -0.01660528965294361, 0.017884444445371628, -0.005580848548561335, -0.040609125047922134, 0.03670601546764374, -0.02087811939418316, -0.039348091930150986, 0.04216033220291138, -0.02924180030822754, -0.02433471940457821, 0.02002718858420849, -0.017715658992528915, -0.006446498446166515, 0.05918855965137482, 0.014894967898726463, -0.004183742683380842, -0.004515036474913359, 0.012089671567082405, 0.020498869940638542, -0.01894967257976532, 0.02470514550805092, 0.02963721565902233, 0.05580069124698639, 0.018919965252280235, -0.037845976650714874, 0.022245215252041817, -0.028051726520061493, 0.0005314824520610273, -0.033567529171705246, 0.017667625099420547, -0.014584066346287727, -0.05393742397427559, 0.007266131229698658, -0.03508545830845833, 0.021157745271921158, 0.020387597382068634, -0.02605859749019146, -0.003750350559130311, 0.020588034763932228, -0.016051160171628, -0.020623939111828804, -0.04470375180244446, 0.05015202611684799, 0.006206798832863569, 0.0037582211662083864, -0.007943165488541126, 0.020206904038786888, 0.029390137642621994, 0.012891191057860851, -0.013345553539693356, -0.010981043800711632, 0.01922418735921383, -0.017262790352106094, 0.024312395602464676, 0.02008909173309803, -0.011726101860404015, 0.028221772983670235, -0.06011602655053139, 0.002543119713664055, 0.016172057017683983, 0.01859365589916706, -0.04454578459262848, -0.018628574907779694, -0.05387977510690689, 0.05084169656038284, 0.03813626244664192, 0.01642744243144989, 0.0067245266400277615, -0.05684090778231621, -0.016020866110920906, -0.004336564335972071, -0.030427096411585808, 0.05670356750488281, -0.0001032035070238635, -0.04357123002409935, 0.001930978032760322, -0.01101846992969513, 0.016664456576108932, 0.008633695542812347, -0.02143542282283306, 0.029121888801455498, -0.03276626393198967, -0.015192754566669464, -0.054982151836156845, 0.02086934633553028, -0.006576054263859987, -0.0029344630893319845, 0.02118341065943241, 0.000039193884731503204, 0.011258178390562534, 0.022929487749934196, 0.038196999579668045, -0.06230438873171806, -0.011948754079639912, -0.06052203103899956, 0.022416705265641212, -0.014816566370427608, 0.024934813380241394, 0.014206214807927608, -0.03675518184900284, 0.019349362701177597, 0.028613680973649025, -0.050100892782211304, -0.03734777867794037, 0.01485093031078577, 0.00160946452524513, 0.04940834641456604, -0.0031830361112952232, 0.025224821642041206, -0.01535090897232294, -0.02866053394973278, 0.02046900987625122, 0.007266076281666756, 0.02489396370947361, -0.01437861006706953, 0.03186933323740959, -0.003238446544855833, 0.012215279042720795, 0.0270778089761734, 0.010464208200573921, 0.040150512009859085, 0.021186206489801407, -0.01221519336104393, 0.019184960052371025, -0.03528439998626709, -0.00776198785752058, -0.003733227727934718, -0.014947176910936832, 0.03876061737537384, 0.028041021898388863, 0.00091534637613222, -0.031029704958200455, 0.009462136775255203, -0.035993583500385284, 0.0305197574198246, -0.004955380689352751, 0.03006943315267563, 0.022961314767599106, 0.005293873604387045, 0.0017756683519110084, 0.003332828637212515, 0.03404579311609268, 0.017016276717185974, 0.013073310256004333, 0.02498512715101242, 0.015518364496529102, -0.04878658056259155, 0.0032661769073456526, -0.027396144345402718, -0.026265466585755348, 0.029807837679982185, 0.02152741700410843, 0.027683261781930923, -0.02955624647438526, -0.001213611220009625, 0.015445463359355927, 0.02167641744017601, -0.023556416854262352, -0.022844692692160606, -0.02357078529894352, -0.038936372846364975, -0.0015239743515849113, -0.010783390142023563 ]
<p>For an independent t-test, if my hypothesis states there will be no significant difference between the two groups, is that a one- or two-tailed test?</p>
49,920
[ -0.02454792708158493, -0.014237443916499615, 0.0017576433019712567, -0.012882542796432972, 0.035613905638456345, 0.013104220852255821, 0.012079098261892796, 0.007230822928249836, 0.010679696686565876, -0.021005729213356972, 0.03317085653543472, 0.052224598824977875, 0.023474188521504402, 0.005450529046356678, 0.017725646495819092, -0.003937823232263327, -0.04330284893512726, -0.0024136442225426435, 0.014740373007953167, 0.017291134223341942, -0.02054840512573719, 0.004515987820923328, 0.032847873866558075, 0.00927465595304966, -0.023401521146297455, 0.03827844187617302, 0.030786506831645966, -0.0072404081001877785, 0.02015984244644642, 0.05073327198624611, -0.045189861208200455, -0.024403005838394165, -0.00002961806603707373, 0.043935999274253845, 0.019219759851694107, -0.013393474742770195, -0.021683933213353157, 0.019664110615849495, -0.023179862648248672, 0.03593026101589203, -0.017582403495907784, -0.0424601212143898, -0.00897850189357996, 0.023442158475518227, -0.015286303125321865, 0.04248470067977905, -0.0060960678383708, -0.0535602904856205, 0.026319827884435654, -0.041505660861730576, 0.02219587378203869, -0.009995469823479652, 0.03901829570531845, 0.011311298236250877, -0.005466837901622057, -0.007025774568319321, 0.019048886373639107, 0.0421847328543663, -0.013652464374899864, -0.035347048193216324, -0.04333944991230965, -0.03579334914684296, 0.03132031485438347, -0.009247113950550556, -0.05317867174744606, 0.012186961248517036, -0.017465615645051003, -0.04033555090427399, 0.02555161528289318, -0.006131179165095091, 0.028865503147244453, 0.025370391085743904, 0.0354144312441349, 0.00023842645168770105, -0.007416668348014355, -0.025543835014104843, 0.04415026307106018, 0.022224560379981995, 0.04429035261273384, 0.11574404686689377, 0.023748470470309258, 0.004757027141749859, 0.024313440546393394, 0.05932208523154259, 0.03770877420902252, -0.03604758158326149, 0.04972744733095169, -0.003503509098663926, -0.021809514611959457, 0.04435783997178078, -0.02135632373392582, -0.01949264295399189, 0.06583534181118011, -0.007711573503911495, -0.04962712153792381, 0.03486037254333496, -0.040795765817165375, 0.01805730164051056, -0.014349937438964844, -0.030212216079235077, -0.018101872876286507, -0.04473966732621193, 0.06556269526481628, 0.05901110917329788, -0.024020032957196236, 0.0014816091861575842, -0.021883105859160423, 0.003949978854507208, -0.03582187369465828, 0.004115707240998745, -0.0008085243753157556, 0.04458560422062874, -0.00031337118707597256, 0.002567736431956291, 0.03268754109740257, 0.025956055149435997, -0.008000209927558899, -0.011398117989301682, 0.040025271475315094, 0.03657635673880577, 0.07184099406003952, 0.000295109988655895, -0.0012758751399815083, 0.014700077474117279, -0.017955245450139046, 0.040284302085638046, 0.03906004875898361, -0.03035544790327549, -0.038734495639801025, 0.05220305174589157, -0.016232144087553024, -0.01115533895790577, 0.026116682216525078, 0.015608314424753189, 0.02879386954009533, -0.00828704796731472, -0.08152173459529877, -0.054841797798871994, 0.056281160563230515, -0.015406887978315353, -0.010447505861520767, -0.0603712797164917, -0.026172788813710213, 0.022132335230708122, 0.06015095114707947, -0.006066425703465939, 0.04574770852923393, -0.014138084836304188, 0.0030127661302685738, -0.004133507143706083, -0.026201393455266953, -0.01088185515254736, -0.020054088905453682, -0.02954890765249729, 0.00877316389232874, -0.06848377734422684, 0.038707152009010315, 0.028404129669070244, 0.0011352975852787495, 0.005732981488108635, 0.02436721697449684, -0.013766104355454445, -0.0041505517438054085, -0.016426807269454002, 0.03595217317342758, 0.008885733783245087, 0.053812798112630844, 0.0013596786884590983, 0.00877671130001545, 0.012576150707900524, 0.0058468058705329895, 0.01198085118085146, 0.011643524281680584, 0.0561627559363842, 0.016455581411719322, -0.022752825170755386, -0.017033357173204422, -0.030717255547642708, 0.03954203799366951, -0.0013182272668927908, -0.02834761142730713, 0.011712740175426006, -0.028845222666859627, -0.0014096919912844896, -0.012924029491841793, 0.04121572896838188, 0.024843547493219376, -0.008692571893334389, 0.06006462499499321, -0.013764145784080029, -0.08160574734210968, -0.07053149491548538, -0.016621684655547142, 0.00832159910351038, -0.04359142482280731, 0.031106004491448402, 0.044706717133522034, 0.029113508760929108, -0.05153769627213478, -0.008886203169822693, -0.015580755658447742, 0.035724930465221405, 0.021986428648233414, -0.05047318711876869, 0.04916095361113548, 0.06879191100597382, 0.060477904975414276, -0.0072496794164180756, 0.03725447878241539, -0.06180014833807945, -0.022670824080705643, -0.0035816107410937548, -0.04204823076725006, 0.022075755521655083, 0.02227216772735119, -0.0018448065966367722, -0.005057661794126034, -0.0006447577034123242, -0.015262369066476822, 0.039220746606588364, -0.054445866495370865, 0.049216825515031815, 0.024573249742388725, -0.005661729257553816, -0.003522666171193123, -0.035843729972839355, -0.00033149385126307607, -0.02758670225739479, -0.0513576976954937, -0.0039517139084637165, -0.06891854107379913, -0.03386512026190758, 0.07544044405221939, 0.013461335562169552, -0.015517406165599823, 0.026703927665948868, 0.046799615025520325, 0.0034279271494597197, -0.008882195688784122, 0.04666391387581825, -0.007900586351752281, -0.042470768094062805, 0.016368644312024117, 0.0294988751411438, 0.008019709028303623, -0.006762226577848196, 0.051584601402282715, 0.015124869532883167, 0.03621456399559975, 0.02288079634308815, -0.023200135678052902, 0.036385901272296906, -0.0023049216251820326, -0.011117981746792793, 0.007954672910273075, -0.03646507114171982, 0.01916438713669777, -0.003645240096375346, -0.019943609833717346, 0.0030451021157205105, -0.003544379258528352, -0.004543572198599577, -0.0023797054309397936, -0.004578123334795237, 0.038472093641757965, 0.00520813325420022, -0.0021849912591278553, 0.008239686489105225, 0.0397518016397953, -0.004298160318285227, -0.0049200220964848995, -0.019048914313316345, -0.04792947322130203, -0.01293607335537672, 0.02304769679903984, 0.020488319918513298, -0.004867600277066231, 0.02979326620697975, 0.0017146171303465962, -0.02725810930132866, 0.022837059572339058, -0.031447455286979675, 0.007008926011621952, -0.003042417112737894, -0.038809891790151596, 0.010027383454144001, -0.025705840438604355, -0.012511514127254486, 0.04027383029460907, 0.011880418285727501, 0.027615617960691452, 0.018577728420495987, -0.0009413393563590944, -0.0836920291185379, -0.02208181656897068, -0.04835490509867668, 0.00011788029951276258, -0.03741772845387459, -0.034561436623334885, 0.042312320321798325, 0.00948768388479948, -0.036350563168525696, 0.048487547785043716, -0.02137857861816883, -0.00911509059369564, -0.024041377007961273, -0.003394044004380703, 0.04424060136079788, -0.02031182497739792, -0.008701331913471222, 0.008838027715682983, -0.06497456878423691, -0.005058685317635536, -0.06615985184907913, -0.0621519535779953, 0.059775300323963165, -0.013323239982128143, 0.018462292850017548, -0.03186699375510216, -0.03225358948111534, 0.05385202541947365, 0.03573357313871384, 0.00756458006799221, -0.02121768705546856, -0.013892782852053642, -0.05511465296149254, -0.009632044471800327, 0.030468782410025597, 0.0024154644925147295, 0.018983161076903343, 0.010029206052422523, 0.009756653569638729, 0.02069351263344288, 0.05104316025972366, 0.03278685361146927, -0.022591130807995796, 0.04506883770227432, 0.03598456829786301, 0.010178233496844769, 0.040597930550575256, 0.0423714779317379, -0.028974713757634163, 0.023011773824691772, 0.03055931255221367, 0.03342488035559654, 0.015133882872760296, -0.011648721061646938, 0.056916285306215286, -0.010455029085278511, 0.0026230544317513704, -0.04756849259138107, 0.054253578186035156, 0.046840786933898926, 0.016922900453209877, -0.016202840954065323, -0.01062708254903555, 0.01608368009328842, -0.030397741124033928, 0.023565305396914482, 0.034733619540929794, 0.053934045135974884, -0.0032447222620248795, -0.03746253624558449, -0.003742988221347332, -0.02900785580277443, 0.025302108377218246, -0.017868634313344955, -0.04364626854658127, 0.04449508711695671, 0.02495988830924034, 0.034332480281591415, 0.0028238981030881405, -0.056944482028484344, -0.004938112106174231, -0.06122540310025215, 0.023859847337007523, -0.03270044922828674, 0.04712027311325073, -0.012545980513095856, 0.025670276954770088, 0.021227993071079254, 0.0261329784989357, -0.0610416904091835, -0.009042395278811455, -0.05798641964793205, 0.038392528891563416, -0.0354621559381485, -0.02442135661840439, 0.02255086973309517, -0.003981748130172491, 0.022406714037060738, -0.026089293882250786, 0.04245925694704056, 0.00035577654489316046, 0.025767797604203224, -0.029261860996484756, 0.020871002227067947, -0.032791368663311005, -0.011813119053840637, 0.02594008669257164, 0.04574427753686905, 0.007255982141941786, -0.01277989149093628, 0.02219104953110218, 0.03557618334889412, -0.003634856315329671, 0.006393954623490572, -0.016254352405667305, -0.021607564762234688, 0.015008836053311825, 0.05997065082192421, 0.04683217406272888, 0.03371746838092804, -0.044551774859428406, 0.03318455442786217, 0.021172210574150085, 0.04090285301208496, -0.0074312034994363785, -0.022421909496188164, -0.006935102865099907, -0.07962195575237274, -0.050016168504953384, -0.01860162429511547, 0.03551388159394264, 0.0009528333321213722, -0.02464047074317932, 0.02849922515451908, 0.02565254271030426, -0.04165768250823021, 0.02863457426428795, 0.038221679627895355, 0.03857870772480965, -0.016307825222611427, -0.0328047089278698, -0.022352375090122223, -0.008608616888523102, -0.02122991532087326, 0.01860317774116993, 0.028670385479927063, -0.025989942252635956, 0.007431675214320421, 0.03697909042239189, -0.010241413488984108, -0.02170681580901146, -0.02906849794089794, -0.017122358083724976, 0.033925820142030716, 0.004072518553584814, -0.03254416584968567, 0.037784986197948456, 0.013744331896305084, -0.011397084221243858, 0.04852040857076645, 0.006492294371128082, -0.06450729817152023, 0.02536790445446968, 0.03502260148525238, 0.0687209740281105, -0.041651759296655655, -0.022105373442173004, 0.008204604499042034, 0.011525075882673264, 0.04858557507395744, -0.04288652539253235, 0.0004817301232833415, -0.004459319170564413, -0.009595285169780254, -0.01836315728724003, 0.019349388778209686, -0.06769344210624695, 0.018814487382769585, -0.008881433866918087, -0.009166435338556767, -0.0013702437281608582, -0.05394291505217552, -0.04179126024246216, -0.02648918330669403, 0.028679238632321358, 0.040797825902700424, -0.031562454998493195, -0.010376977734267712, -0.004429223015904427, -0.003505959175527096, -0.002683906350284815, -0.049806442111730576, 0.012107601389288902, -0.025568079203367233, 0.016566643491387367, 0.05026278644800186, -0.01935499534010887, -0.05003147944808006, 0.01821994036436081, -0.00799623690545559, -0.04265948385000229, -0.009648546576499939, -0.03804153949022293, -0.0034234265331178904, 0.02433805912733078, 0.01567048393189907, 0.059614669531583786, 0.03629540652036667, -0.0027316263876855373, -0.005815971177071333, -0.036968547850847244, 0.03836965188384056, -0.028274085372686386, -0.013107629492878914, -0.018787259235978127, -0.04960976168513298, -0.040412768721580505, -0.002321747364476323, -0.007538168225437403, 0.017658859491348267, -0.03756793960928917, -0.03558792546391487, -0.01534605398774147, 0.0009981899056583643, 0.025539236143231392, 0.015442242845892906, 0.002777518006041646, 0.010259623639285564, -0.02290400303900242, -0.011071219108998775, 0.009200742468237877, -0.02367369271814823, 0.014959508553147316, 0.014887590892612934, -0.0386299267411232, 0.03191596642136574, -0.02857302874326706, -0.04750069975852966, 0.02845177985727787, -0.03243948891758919, 0.021775105968117714, -0.03554055094718933, 0.027932792901992798, 0.024880163371562958, -0.020145107060670853, -0.02791585400700569, 0.044706080108881, 0.028121909126639366, 0.04237321391701698, -0.041658464819192886, 0.04993009567260742, 0.014940652064979076, -0.03845304623246193, -0.07429532706737518, -0.01352903712540865, 0.0017710349056869745, 0.025491133332252502, -0.016188353300094604, -0.0008355388999916613, 0.007962566800415516, -0.0140953054651618, -0.013962182216346264, -0.0248070377856493, 0.047318849712610245, 0.032214052975177765, -0.010015713050961494, -0.006190822925418615, 0.0149761401116848, 0.0710015818476677, 0.02646920643746853, -0.02580009587109089, -0.019502418115735054, -0.03890421614050865, -0.007067940663546324, -0.0033892265055328608, 0.02123694308102131, -0.027835778892040253, 0.0188136026263237, -0.0405731275677681, -0.0216134674847126, -0.015204355120658875, -0.040399957448244095, -0.04614369943737984, 0.010867329314351082, -0.019602520391345024, 0.009414391592144966, -0.01818712428212166, 0.0073210191912949085, -0.021388394758105278, 0.03147293999791145, -0.00504614133387804, -0.002198781119659543, 0.016880052164196968, -0.02699909545481205, 0.014121269807219505, 0.03415565937757492, -0.024164745584130287, 0.008739858865737915, 0.06577739119529724, -0.01942700892686844, 0.020221518352627754, -0.03327831253409386, -0.03238137066364288, -0.008776827715337276, -0.010943426750600338, -0.026861505582928658, -0.025376353412866592, 0.03071296587586403, -0.036787815392017365, -0.002030867151916027, -0.012285645119845867, -0.036454394459724426, 0.03952938690781593, -0.013181901536881924, 0.024569377303123474, 0.060603752732276917, 0.030683651566505432, 0.0025600141379982233, -0.03537365421652794, -0.0036372689064592123, -0.014307948760688305, 0.0027075468096882105, 0.022975880652666092, -0.029913226142525673, 0.002527344273403287, 0.06879431754350662, 0.01599741168320179, 0.03117576614022255, 0.05654646456241608, 0.03338560834527016, 0.002033247146755457, 0.024119049310684204, -0.018203290179371834, -0.06469341367483139, 0.03131875768303871, -0.05163818225264549, 0.03694670647382736, -0.03524169698357582, 0.015412792563438416, 0.04984862729907036, 0.021213961765170097, -0.015897979959845543, -0.055120207369327545, 0.006312916520982981, -0.05151788890361786, 0.008323215879499912, -0.006936060264706612, 0.019194016233086586, 0.03096114844083786, -0.0047495560720562935, 0.044649261981248856, -0.020478781312704086, 0.021142615005373955, -0.02383788488805294, -0.031240615993738174, -0.03164496645331383, -0.0002124275197274983, -0.032181981950998306, 0.0336114838719368, -0.023389942944049835, -0.05262250080704689, 0.010121294297277927, -0.024296807125210762, 0.01282088179141283, 0.020944297313690186, 0.027340108528733253, -0.040155019611120224, 0.050152331590652466, 0.02085227705538273, 0.024279914796352386, 0.00011752950376830995, -0.01555175893008709, 0.11352335661649704, 0.03999421000480652, 0.007122134789824486, -0.06807833909988403, 0.03849324956536293, -0.037166886031627655, 0.015038255602121353, -0.019927391782402992, 0.015713941305875778, 0.000021786379875265993, 0.00648875255137682, 0.07882603257894516, 0.07334107905626297, 0.001014934154227376, -0.040714748203754425, 0.06205318868160248, -0.024784082546830177, -0.02149115689098835, -0.008867395110428333, 0.005426924210041761, 0.0015132407424971461, -0.022234603762626648, -0.02526509016752243, -0.010298419743776321, -0.005931168328970671, 0.0464322492480278, -0.0073320260271430016, -0.03698023408651352, 0.010262591764330864, 0.03309250250458717, -0.031016042456030846, -0.01646156795322895, 0.032112088054418564, 0.0137652438133955, -0.07189424335956573, -0.01318074855953455, -0.001056731678545475, -0.054197728633880615, 0.010510019958019257, 0.047778353095054626, 0.02067604847252369, -0.018332382664084435, 0.03094305470585823, -0.0011326140956953168, -0.07284285873174667, -0.015125368721783161, 0.0004959123325534165, 0.043721895664930344, -0.013525256887078285, 0.019767753779888153, -0.046724651008844376, -0.018908465281128883, 0.0010634508216753602, -0.040669411420822144, -0.004972769878804684, 0.009378527291119099, 0.007936193607747555, -0.04100955277681351, -0.00691125588491559, -0.0391218326985836, 0.027155300602316856, 0.009268411435186863, 0.05228560417890549, 0.045560020953416824, -0.019596751779317856, -0.022049328312277794, 0.0154707757756114, 0.026001248508691788, 0.005412832368165255, -0.02923371084034443, 0.015390806831419468, -0.01687684655189514, -0.03080286830663681, 0.03557312861084938, -0.02112002670764923, 0.008563593029975891, 0.034299012273550034, 0.006348360795527697, -0.0214400552213192, -0.03191109746694565, -0.005150667391717434, 0.00897392351180315, -0.021408546715974808, 0.019121771678328514, -0.017401769757270813, 0.0022420473396778107, 0.012091828510165215, 0.019772885367274284, 0.029411446303129196, 0.030721351504325867, 0.04279867187142372, 0.058439962565898895, 0.03873142600059509, -0.07073421031236649, -0.022717004641890526, -0.024141913279891014, -0.017829174175858498, -0.024830132722854614, -0.02786397933959961, 0.03003852069377899, 0.04730716347694397, 0.00687691755592823, 0.0013883351348340511, -0.0034969188272953033, -0.012079537846148014, 0.019435308873653412, -0.0011374368332326412, -0.053589608520269394, -0.03473125398159027, 0.03982129693031311, 0.0009366220911033452, -0.015268761664628983, -0.04407115280628204, -0.02713603526353836, -0.0011021309765055776, 0.05171707645058632, -0.012968412600457668, -0.034223202615976334, -0.031116832047700882, 0.0005022739642299712, 0.058298029005527496, -0.026944024488329887, -0.014828757382929325, -0.06000245735049248, -0.007605698425322771, 0.02125297486782074, 0.0322253443300724, 0.004942369181662798, 0.031816210597753525, -0.05597173050045967, -0.002861819928511977, 0.048752374947071075, 0.015589465387165546, 0.041186172515153885, 0.04436293616890907, 0.022331437095999718, -0.004818530287593603, 0.023025738075375557, 0.0098240552470088, 0.0016010487452149391, 0.06989104300737381, -0.00935943890362978, -0.055609993636608124, 0.030640248209238052, 0.005667571444064379, 0.062142264097929, 0.010956482030451298, -0.020183755084872246, -0.02332068420946598, 0.02519383653998375, -0.062718465924263, -0.028167422860860825, -0.009845721535384655, -0.007986116223037243, 0.017206771299242973, -0.024715891107916832, -0.003633714048191905, 0.013180936686694622, -0.03882652893662453, 0.01439189538359642, 0.01540372520685196, -0.015582308173179626, -0.020512079820036888, -0.025977706536650658, 0.009298700839281082, 0.04256577044725418, 0.0020543765276670456, -0.009452481754124165, 0.02920760214328766, 0.05340558663010597, 0.00012894337123725563, 0.007614974398165941, -0.04357440397143364, 0.010881174355745316, -0.0721970871090889, -0.0290521327406168, 0.0002217101282440126, 0.02931527979671955, 0.023834409192204475, -0.02715958096086979, 0.0025225395802408457, 0.03468639403581619, -0.05652276426553726, 0.011904286220669746, -0.020752042531967163, -0.0501042865216732, -0.05572788044810295, 0.007733641657978296, -0.029466772451996803, 0.031468089669942856, 0.0039014292415231466, 0.034314971417188644, 0.0036819905508309603, 0.034335993230342865, -0.03831445798277855, -0.0034448534715920687, -0.0018991063116118312, 0.02146400883793831, 0.0022088137920945883, -0.059576358646154404, 0.0033064575400203466, -0.018113980069756508, 0.003912854008376598, 0.03123091720044613, -0.0034888237714767456, 0.03319667652249336, -0.0006980351754464209, 0.015812722966074944, 0.053277600556612015, 0.028134139254689217, 0.03508463129401207, -0.011236934922635555, -0.0317862369120121, 0.01947670616209507, -0.010301603004336357, 0.04918580874800682, -0.023908669129014015, -0.026139553636312485, 0.010688063688576221, -0.036362532526254654, -0.006516097579151392, 0.01991911232471466, -0.00864709448069334, -0.03644020855426788, -0.013105683960020542, -0.012090482749044895, 0.014650148339569569, 0.011963680386543274, -0.007685251533985138, -0.021250203251838684, -0.01567714847624302, 0.04012046381831169, 0.009466963820159435, -0.04016488417983055, 0.021006394177675247, 0.001931750332005322, -0.03119850344955921, 0.022598186507821083, -0.009989159181714058, -0.016860635951161385, -0.06409530341625214, -0.0031103629153221846, -0.032190244644880295, 0.019598977640271187, -0.020191624760627747, 0.003186597488820553, 0.0024827620945870876, 0.015239766798913479, 0.02916036546230316, 0.004559684544801712, -0.0000489962512801867, -0.008140739053487778, -0.013268377631902695, -0.06652364134788513, 0.05862879753112793, -0.008356701582670212, -0.022473754361271858, -0.04851796478033066, -0.02789895609021187, -0.05717342719435692, 0.006801311392337084, 0.06750805675983429, 0.03354734182357788, 0.035346630960702896, 0.009446443058550358, 0.008861636742949486, 0.008751182816922665, -0.05339911952614784, 0.03221076726913452, -0.022668423131108284, -0.016934437677264214, -0.03040192648768425, 0.005828519817441702, 0.014650826342403889, 0.016914309933781624, 0.045135047286748886, -0.020801035687327385, 0.021901967003941536, -0.005774234421551228, 0.012372373603284359, 0.05505179241299629, 0.015477023087441921, -0.031903430819511414, 0.053781334310770035, -0.00304940203204751, 0.035304728895425797, 0.010239440016448498, -0.022174127399921417, -0.044836562126874924, 0.02725052461028099, -0.024386070668697357, 0.008532006293535233, -0.016874702647328377, 0.04740187153220177, -0.009397859685122967, -0.03413568437099457, -0.015713278204202652, -0.003001111326739192, 0.023313773795962334, -0.0023618140257894993, -0.010710823349654675, 0.02787107415497303, 0.02058643475174904, -0.016991866752505302, 0.0040541947819292545, -0.0006370097980834544, -0.01683410070836544, 0.02906891144812107, 0.020470701158046722, 0.004718126263469458, 0.03011620230972767, 0.007667715195566416, 0.013854078017175198, -0.0348830372095108, 0.01430027186870575, -0.01168607734143734, 0.00891135260462761, -0.013399613089859486, -0.04363410547375679, 0.014192544855177402, -0.005894624162465334, 0.018665894865989685, 0.013155520893633366, -0.0016935624880716205, 0.06518594175577164, -0.034461334347724915, 0.02842690423130989, -0.029923027381300926, 0.005101280752569437, -0.012597857974469662, -0.004043755121529102, 0.03838999569416046, 0.018984882161021233, -0.01544381957501173, -0.018219532445073128, 0.04530484229326248, -0.003422701498493552, 0.006767244543880224, -0.04878448322415352, 0.04252569004893303, -0.02100561559200287, -0.02289968729019165, -0.0799269899725914, 0.013300136663019657, -0.09243813902139664, -0.004769810475409031, 0.013009490445256233, 0.047708116471767426, 0.02015143632888794, -0.009052461013197899, -0.030815178528428078, 0.019586818292737007, 0.05723854526877403, -0.07949516922235489, -0.018954526633024216, -0.03435014933347702, 0.025670653209090233, 0.033181916922330856, -0.0342283621430397 ]
<p>Could you please tell me how to conduct an event study? </p> <p>I have 60 companies and 16 events. I am computing the abnormal return within 20 days around the event study (-10,10). </p> <ul> <li>Should I do it for each event for all the companies and then take the average? </li> <li>Or each event for each company and then take the average? </li> <li>Should I use equal weights or value weights? </li> </ul> <p>Also, once I obtain the abnormal returns, I would like to plot it using the 95% confidence interval. </p> <p>Could you please tell me what is the Stata command to do so?</p>
73,512
[ -0.025203870609402657, -0.018426327034831047, -0.037123292684555054, 0.013669404201209545, 0.04367152974009514, 0.01267924066632986, -0.007305787410587072, -0.017892984673380852, 0.0334073044359684, -0.010682922787964344, 0.04896312206983566, 0.060658182948827744, 0.04013071209192276, 0.03011278621852398, -0.010731944814324379, 0.006454748101532459, -0.0326203927397728, 0.009670333936810493, 0.0019689234904944897, 0.019546525552868843, -0.022630931809544563, -0.011932015419006348, -0.021581504493951797, -0.011120300740003586, -0.021166665479540825, 0.04556412249803543, 0.01921689137816429, -0.01588333211839199, -0.007737345062196255, 0.07860026508569717, -0.03335351496934891, -0.0491441935300827, 0.017513833940029144, 0.02404208481311798, 0.02293143793940544, 0.0065027084201574326, -0.0018942301394417882, -0.014442806132137775, -0.021274514496326447, 0.023858197033405304, -0.04246078431606293, 0.0032345764338970184, 0.026449795812368393, 0.001610932988114655, 0.014445752836763859, -0.004973385017365217, 0.030359456315636635, -0.04195951670408249, 0.010831914842128754, -0.04361489787697792, 0.04207959026098251, -0.024163290858268738, 0.03631138429045677, -0.0032971396576613188, -0.0062469663098454475, -0.0060511683113873005, -0.011868826113641262, 0.045814432203769684, 0.023109665140509605, -0.05259797349572182, 0.05240972712635994, -0.012834586203098297, -0.02064824290573597, -0.039153456687927246, -0.046843722462654114, 0.0027735147159546614, -0.005593123380094767, -0.005254135932773352, 0.07243765145540237, -0.022848086431622505, 0.019072553142905235, 0.023381482809782028, 0.026979748159646988, 0.011168058030307293, 0.007631111890077591, -0.046239081770181656, 0.04234692081809044, -0.002996742958202958, 0.06201731413602829, 0.04405548423528671, 0.027391334995627403, 0.007861010730266571, 0.0015286753186956048, 0.01762402057647705, 0.013908391818404198, -0.013380272313952446, 0.10477861016988754, -0.009190293028950691, 0.05310880392789841, -0.0012771503534168005, 0.0024696614127606153, -0.009454633109271526, 0.015889188274741173, 0.02076602354645729, -0.020053766667842865, 0.02786090038716793, -0.026251686736941338, 0.0403173603117466, -0.018253881484270096, -0.020246589556336403, -0.023708194494247437, -0.051825448870658875, 0.02698616124689579, 0.045599691569805145, -0.002135014859959483, 0.018215125426650047, -0.01741899363696575, -0.0000928352092159912, -0.02914797142148018, 0.006215623579919338, -0.002433296525850892, 0.019734226167201996, 0.0064858668483793736, -0.013955362141132355, -0.0019271369092166424, 0.021282341331243515, 0.01847754791378975, 0.034858573228120804, 0.024236304685473442, 0.024559494107961655, 0.036069780588150024, -0.033667512238025665, 0.010150743648409843, -0.028821540996432304, -0.037344254553318024, 0.02586784027516842, 0.04522959887981415, -0.03498828038573265, -0.037425003945827484, 0.05420396849513054, 0.027853358536958694, -0.03141029551625252, 0.021783070638775826, -0.021272260695695877, 0.013159411959350109, -0.0003465985937509686, -0.05991315096616745, -0.0668371170759201, 0.02221047878265381, -0.0038107314612716436, -0.00763785419985652, -0.058265432715415955, -0.06307882070541382, 0.030039386823773384, 0.05341144651174545, 0.02324696071445942, 0.05428142845630646, 0.058859843760728836, 0.032015927135944366, -0.0011109152110293508, -0.022496769204735756, 0.00338388467207551, -0.018034780398011208, 0.013407004065811634, -0.0029572031926363707, -0.0669466033577919, 0.013887420296669006, 0.0014445572160184383, -0.019732190296053886, -0.030638400465250015, -0.010111598297953606, 0.006179851479828358, -0.023973742499947548, 0.017260514199733734, -0.006272513885051012, -0.015247730538249016, 0.04317215085029602, 0.027744941413402557, 0.014853162690997124, 0.011570108123123646, 0.00935306865721941, 0.0014574140077456832, -0.028965884819626808, 0.036923598498106, 0.03410075232386589, -0.013012727722525597, 0.009099043905735016, -0.02606031484901905, -0.00330244074575603, 0.010474801994860172, -0.024800866842269897, -0.019857853651046753, -0.0016360061708837748, -0.007794013246893883, 0.012027839198708534, -0.004172140266746283, 0.008120683021843433, 0.0003100109752267599, 0.02024986408650875, -0.05698927864432335, -0.09677638113498688, -0.051577191799879074, 0.005881852470338345, -0.06917880475521088, -0.01964718848466873, -0.0012643305817618966, 0.0077433716505765915, 0.02431342750787735, -0.016587017104029655, 0.015308422967791557, 0.004905175417661667, -0.012023231945931911, 0.05292939394712448, -0.031713422387838364, 0.000371832080418244, 0.05397516489028931, 0.06486082822084427, -0.031154409050941467, 0.006871091667562723, -0.04671249911189079, -0.04920385777950287, -0.0037625583354383707, -0.0416262112557888, 0.02201853320002556, 0.0056190500035882, -0.022488564252853394, 0.03823160380125046, 0.02059633657336235, -0.020563356578350067, 0.004427751060575247, -0.035482391715049744, 0.06570140272378922, 0.08926065266132355, 0.01302625797688961, 0.013351606205105782, 0.013282849453389645, 0.03459003567695618, 0.049792367964982986, 0.02081291191279888, 0.007474122103303671, -0.03779573738574982, -0.012351061217486858, 0.00759490579366684, -0.011548520997166634, -0.03237977623939514, 0.010933078825473785, 0.08751115947961807, -0.012471620924770832, -0.02607434056699276, 0.03681015968322754, -0.010377802886068821, -0.008489042520523071, 0.024015871807932854, 0.00905438419431448, 0.017872091382741928, 0.001990769524127245, -0.0027988774236291647, 0.0011594516690820456, 0.04696228355169296, 0.00808343943208456, 0.01765948161482811, 0.06644101440906525, -0.033596981316804886, 0.022879233583807945, -0.02242669276893139, -0.01902974583208561, 0.06967662274837494, -0.01766139268875122, -0.030491620302200317, 0.019271593540906906, 0.009996342472732067, 0.005447014234960079, 0.03318952023983002, -0.03938685730099678, -0.0013791767414659262, 0.030202943831682205, -0.009053965099155903, 0.005582408048212528, 0.018410632386803627, -0.010918713174760342, 0.02682795561850071, -0.01864663138985634, -0.013693047687411308, -0.05651223659515381, -0.02034653164446354, 0.053516801446676254, 0.0006161154014989734, 0.006215394474565983, 0.010378742590546608, -0.02566179260611534, 0.006321892607957125, 0.010105803608894348, 0.0028258117381483316, 0.008109739981591702, -0.043089255690574646, -0.008157668635249138, -0.005920779891312122, -0.03263092413544655, 0.02488243393599987, 0.0057607488706707954, -0.01355035975575447, 0.009858681820333004, 0.02204073779284954, -0.0308229960501194, -0.043101418763399124, 0.0072926185093820095, 0.005241685546934605, -0.03539963811635971, -0.0308025274425745, 0.06156958267092705, 0.0312894806265831, -0.010951114818453789, 0.026106610894203186, -0.03867779299616814, 0.006295439787209034, -0.02951209805905819, 0.03430035337805748, -0.007914150133728981, -0.018703877925872803, -0.011834472417831421, -0.031838491559028625, -0.024003734812140465, -0.016443079337477684, -0.06593578308820724, -0.019024763256311417, -0.024545663967728615, 0.009576122276484966, 0.018312180414795876, -0.02448107674717903, 0.0058140866458415985, 0.02764548733830452, 0.02187337540090084, -0.01948149874806404, -0.04390014335513115, -0.024328503757715225, -0.049012407660484314, -0.029218198731541634, 0.02642104960978031, 0.01899619586765766, -0.015004598535597324, -0.003199048340320587, 0.024194445461034775, 0.046942394226789474, 0.06934691965579987, 0.006349197123199701, -0.023294037207961082, 0.005469105206429958, 0.0023650527000427246, -0.025418799370527267, 0.053309351205825806, 0.027690984308719635, -0.04713355749845505, 0.02431931160390377, -0.003957850858569145, 0.008733917959034443, 0.028350261971354485, -0.03955256566405296, 0.017718294635415077, -0.015246313996613026, -0.03999287262558937, -0.044927649199962616, 0.025186812505126, -0.007193968631327152, 0.006883841473609209, 0.0008165541803464293, -0.031291961669921875, 0.02557634562253952, -0.020925141870975494, -0.017749113962054253, 0.02126595750451088, 0.04677010700106621, -0.00749115040525794, -0.059461481869220734, -0.05173555016517639, -0.016067590564489365, 0.013257206417620182, -0.05382666736841202, -0.007910298183560371, 0.005122594069689512, 0.04733150824904442, 0.023050351068377495, -0.02701641246676445, -0.07181964814662933, 0.00988349411636591, -0.06586780399084091, -0.0012628670083358884, -0.02162766642868519, 0.04598991200327873, 0.01108598429709673, 0.022363711148500443, 0.013275166973471642, -0.018979506567120552, 0.04252788424491882, -0.050622813403606415, -0.09995456784963608, 0.03378196805715561, 0.006913038901984692, 0.01658371277153492, 0.029872804880142212, 0.004137136973440647, 0.039695046842098236, -0.0029182133730500937, -0.010936343111097813, 0.0005372723680920899, 0.008509588427841663, -0.04016852378845215, 0.0075738574378192425, -0.02724023349583149, -0.0276030246168375, 0.016348332166671753, -0.011567439883947372, 0.016590487211942673, 0.01038710493594408, 0.022281348705291748, 0.0219882819801569, -0.0009072385146282613, -0.02792326919734478, 0.0048089162446558475, -0.008308895863592625, 0.03572847694158554, 0.05249509960412979, 0.021102460101246834, 0.0024737610947340727, -0.0508778877556324, 0.030115341767668724, -0.00413657957687974, 0.04758219048380852, 0.04302006587386131, -0.01061643473803997, -0.020059755071997643, -0.02520420029759407, -0.008621875196695328, 0.004924851469695568, -0.012431355193257332, 0.009552164003252983, 0.0011639052536338568, 0.040860410779714584, 0.001955309882760048, -0.04060882702469826, 0.0026484131813049316, 0.07525724172592163, 0.04515274241566658, -0.00783180259168148, -0.003717967076227069, -0.013013769872486591, 0.0077205803245306015, -0.01521294191479683, 0.008513298816978931, 0.002802367554977536, 0.005765409674495459, 0.037994641810655594, 0.029739467427134514, -0.041552018374204636, -0.05463290587067604, -0.012226107530295849, 0.04057959094643593, 0.04481232538819313, 0.030426237732172012, -0.041612736880779266, 0.04709749296307564, 0.022005679085850716, 0.03383960947394371, 0.02632543444633484, 0.010294731706380844, -0.09583067148923874, -0.0024377107620239258, 0.07235272973775864, 0.06016206368803978, -0.017680006101727486, -0.010639296844601631, -0.03651842102408409, 0.0002065151638817042, 0.029898149892687798, -0.07812215387821198, -0.01832585781812668, -0.020766546949744225, 0.030527597293257713, -0.025155961513519287, -0.0025859407614916563, -0.03462963551282883, 0.006213599815964699, -0.002084513893350959, 0.05489685758948326, -0.007598978001624346, -0.03961597755551338, -0.011765927076339722, 0.004532459657639265, -0.007848271168768406, 0.030154747888445854, -0.04508029669523239, 0.014578408561646938, -0.025594506412744522, 0.028248507529497147, -0.0633356049656868, -0.08286678045988083, -0.013829410076141357, -0.002607146743685007, 0.0015358178643509746, 0.056181713938713074, 0.007652447558939457, -0.017933983355760574, -0.004756642505526543, 0.014451233670115471, 0.0067416466772556305, -0.010765747167170048, -0.07257693260908127, 0.020136065781116486, 0.022908752784132957, -0.006158942356705666, 0.03820379450917244, 0.011767609976232052, -0.009455930441617966, 0.01808471605181694, 0.007122333161532879, 0.013652440160512924, -0.022925684228539467, -0.010509592480957508, -0.02731417678296566, 0.004910927731543779, 0.015080292709171772, 0.0029721043538302183, 0.005470715928822756, 0.016060827299952507, -0.023417221382260323, 0.010411427356302738, -0.001271413522772491, 0.05274050682783127, 0.008299527689814568, -0.03540939465165138, -0.011532571166753769, 0.018952487036585808, -0.02928471937775612, -0.0014112418284639716, 0.032660290598869324, -0.008226664736866951, 0.02532150037586689, -0.039293210953474045, -0.029597902670502663, 0.012928876094520092, -0.03262372687458992, -0.011711259372532368, 0.02391313575208187, -0.028635935857892036, 0.06088273227214813, -0.011330939829349518, 0.03954843431711197, 0.010393021628260612, -0.0017801098292693496, 0.018164755776524544, 0.031097345054149628, 0.01173577830195427, 0.016751019284129143, -0.05819246172904968, 0.03786583989858627, -0.0018299203366041183, -0.01090344786643982, -0.10193829983472824, -0.07404673099517822, 0.038507189601659775, -0.002263797679916024, -0.05651695281267166, 0.004487683996558189, 0.0005004337290301919, 0.02371719852089882, -0.027129992842674255, -0.029698915779590607, 0.02219897136092186, -0.0050069065764546394, -0.0058282045647501945, 0.013249237090349197, 0.029158655554056168, 0.08089575171470642, 0.0052041844464838505, -0.005669695325195789, 0.029367633163928986, 0.01803617924451828, -0.02709725685417652, -0.03910614177584648, -0.023550087586045265, -0.03855995088815689, -0.00737310666590929, -0.049089279025793076, 0.008075481280684471, 0.009711707942187786, -0.013789177872240543, 0.02125629223883152, 0.00611210847273469, 0.016575675457715988, 0.019848128780722618, -0.04037538915872574, -0.004736641887575388, -0.0483090877532959, 0.008186073042452335, -0.025960370898246765, 0.003959274850785732, -0.0077912169508636, 0.00219939136877656, 0.04062580317258835, 0.0047669666819274426, -0.0001333074615104124, 0.01061128918081522, 0.06689656525850296, -0.009131988510489464, 0.0003286100982222706, -0.008021651767194271, 0.005471165757626295, 0.00701169716194272, -0.03913533315062523, -0.03343156352639198, 0.01960691809654236, -0.023598050698637962, -0.04007245600223541, -0.011499788612127304, -0.058513343334198, 0.029512235894799232, 0.056746408343315125, 0.0214576106518507, 0.04465116187930107, 0.04509509354829788, 0.03469620272517204, -0.007531066425144672, -0.062372274696826935, 0.008714712224900723, -0.017617030069231987, 0.032112859189510345, 0.02328910119831562, 0.01536504551768303, 0.02160545624792576, 0.022564293816685677, 0.08280543237924576, -0.007212099619209766, 0.029536105692386627, 0.01851096749305725, -0.0003307705046609044, 0.01522953249514103, -0.011142849922180176, -0.03266929090023041, -0.02065681666135788, -0.023622741922736168, 0.05407990887761116, -0.05541663616895676, -0.036973219364881516, 0.037532687187194824, 0.04203297942876816, -0.013274082913994789, -0.03061663545668125, 0.010815026238560677, -0.023737570270895958, 0.01988597959280014, -0.01170430053025484, -0.04560769721865654, 0.0337391123175621, 0.035416170954704285, 0.05089475214481354, -0.021947961300611496, 0.024448426440358162, -0.01588519476354122, -0.06572581082582474, -0.032061632722616196, -0.00862111710011959, -0.062411509454250336, 0.03217894211411476, -0.046526119112968445, -0.011721398681402206, 0.04168679192662239, -0.041397929191589355, -0.024611983448266983, 0.042490601539611816, 0.03324253484606743, 0.012495553120970726, 0.0907636433839798, 0.0011021451791748405, 0.005243985448032618, -0.001705699018202722, -0.004145147278904915, 0.14456582069396973, 0.09392498433589935, 0.022437026724219322, -0.04979041963815689, 0.02729703113436699, 0.015851229429244995, 0.040497664362192154, -0.03595739230513573, 0.03330891951918602, -0.011245175264775753, -0.018657445907592773, 0.0590747632086277, 0.06821757555007935, -0.008255023509263992, -0.009939023293554783, 0.03024824522435665, -0.026430880650877953, -0.05299197882413864, -0.0437789112329483, 0.001385309617035091, -0.015936706215143204, 0.0019573166500777006, -0.07729290425777435, 0.04842643439769745, -0.008412575349211693, -0.006422619801014662, -0.021851247176527977, -0.03845402970910072, -0.013673249632120132, 0.028300253674387932, -0.0004898609477095306, 0.0030095274560153484, 0.04450905695557594, 0.022550096735358238, -0.03992589935660362, -0.01595652662217617, 0.022415271028876305, -0.04092645272612572, 0.0047774408012628555, 0.015252259559929371, 0.012808864004909992, -0.02195553667843342, -0.015378995798528194, 0.016834136098623276, -0.04631286486983299, -0.010974514298141003, -0.00967011135071516, 0.03288644179701805, 0.022271903231739998, 0.012053756974637508, -0.030838817358016968, -0.007109234109520912, 0.022881358861923218, -0.02347378432750702, 0.011600075289607048, -0.012598421424627304, 0.01669367216527462, -0.03682137280702591, -0.03913402929902077, -0.02484527789056301, -0.0057687656953930855, -0.024814844131469727, 0.056103236973285675, 0.018622377887368202, -0.014084268361330032, -0.011834094300866127, -0.02426757663488388, 0.011096624657511711, -0.017328428104519844, 0.024978652596473694, -0.013658476062119007, -0.001132378471083939, -0.04651721194386482, -0.017422841861844063, -0.0068443515338003635, -0.0035476943012326956, 0.011149839498102665, 0.030505146831274033, -0.005626692436635494, -0.016189852729439735, -0.03060285560786724, 0.006180579774081707, -0.02906982973217964, -0.029806936159729958, -0.04627474769949913, 0.04766757786273956, 0.020914550870656967, -0.0034567387774586678, 0.01556363608688116, 0.00455892039462924, -0.003148732241243124, 0.05977276712656021, 0.022236239165067673, -0.011994014494121075, -0.027589410543441772, -0.0015860118437558413, -0.019153643399477005, -0.021057575941085815, -0.014223601669073105, 0.06598083674907684, 0.024057339876890182, 0.012941928580403328, -0.0017722196644172072, 0.018064599484205246, -0.027273910120129585, 0.005353094544261694, 0.026592373847961426, -0.07936394959688187, -0.0010874695144593716, 0.01378143671900034, -0.012502077035605907, -0.043644990772008896, -0.025149637833237648, 0.0015320098027586937, -0.007056038826704025, 0.03971397876739502, -0.018365785479545593, -0.04205833747982979, 0.027135202661156654, -0.03738030046224594, 0.08119470626115799, -0.020331209525465965, -0.008005083538591862, -0.034059230238199234, -0.024106228724122047, -0.011074992828071117, -0.007398509886115789, -0.025499852374196053, -0.003948460333049297, 0.006467265076935291, 0.03214564919471741, 0.011160668917000294, 0.009609034284949303, -0.0007025857921689749, 0.009258856996893883, -0.00022116233594715595, 0.0037349285557866096, 0.007250857073813677, 0.002864551031962037, -0.01953437179327011, 0.07451263070106506, -0.01650892198085785, 0.004688891116529703, 0.033776335418224335, 0.01939544640481472, 0.06205388531088829, 0.02084050141274929, 0.012194549664855003, -0.025093847885727882, 0.042192522436380386, -0.04618930071592331, -0.03246452659368515, -0.02477538399398327, -0.013157038018107414, 0.03293978422880173, 0.035297952592372894, 0.0062124296091496944, 0.03718625754117966, -0.03814532980322838, 0.00817215908318758, 0.05039754882454872, -0.02429339662194252, -0.01670447736978531, 0.0059855785220861435, 0.005860530771315098, 0.030277194455266, 0.013619715347886086, -0.019486304372549057, 0.014424319379031658, 0.03380976617336273, -0.016696574166417122, 0.031085452064871788, -0.03224286809563637, -0.0005717603489756584, -0.04177520424127579, -0.009272565133869648, 0.015651948750019073, -0.018387652933597565, 0.014666900038719177, -0.017128439620137215, 0.02000722847878933, 0.019483303651213646, -0.023171529173851013, 0.04524114727973938, -0.007962573319673538, -0.03258848562836647, -0.006936200894415379, -0.008854610845446587, -0.00985497236251831, 0.05065526068210602, -0.0005523766158148646, 0.005906319245696068, 0.027949737384915352, 0.02830330654978752, 0.02838423289358616, -0.0070233773440122604, -0.013661570847034454, 0.014143888838589191, 0.064628466963768, -0.02175314538180828, 0.018230700865387917, -0.026715954765677452, -0.021832479164004326, 0.03635476157069206, -0.019554005935788155, 0.06315324455499649, 0.03414883464574814, -0.023715268820524216, -0.05711834505200386, 0.05305538326501846, 0.04909990727901459, 0.03159414231777191, 0.016138503327965736, -0.031688448041677475, 0.05147327482700348, 0.03202596306800842, 0.0020013100001960993, 0.046218350529670715, 0.007136605679988861, -0.03224455565214157, -0.02549116499722004, -0.005872669164091349, -0.007296431809663773, -0.013516373001039028, -0.01726187765598297, -0.01778797246515751, -0.00609396630898118, 0.0013351313536986709, 0.03746413439512253, 0.015188290737569332, -0.007577915210276842, 0.02763655036687851, -0.006276198662817478, 0.02336689457297325, 0.040768954902887344, 0.022170819342136383, -0.040466077625751495, 0.005886703729629517, -0.014804248698055744, -0.05726626142859459, -0.05596636235713959, 0.02568080648779869, 0.00032959162490442395, -0.01739114336669445, -0.04680253565311432, 0.02187507599592209, -0.005969558376818895, 0.05189530923962593, -0.021275818347930908, -0.011698883958160877, 0.025724029168486595, -0.030764419585466385, 0.04679998755455017, -0.10529288649559021, 0.08437398821115494, 0.0043899985030293465, -0.03487825766205788, -0.041661668568849564, -0.016755927354097366, -0.0050248922780156136, -0.005233095493167639, 0.024180041626095772, 0.006901525892317295, -0.008448604494333267, -0.0036193421110510826, 0.055660709738731384, 0.00404948927462101, -0.017426619306206703, 0.03313925862312317, -0.04418298229575157, -0.02061900682747364, 0.008021681569516659, -0.021700557321310043, 0.012645706534385681, 0.029396718367934227, 0.010219608433544636, -0.029550498351454735, -0.0001924363023135811, 0.02197885513305664, -0.005889220628887415, 0.02909800224006176, 0.03125796839594841, -0.023573918268084526, 0.031910017132759094, 0.01666157878935337, -0.023359937593340874, 0.043673254549503326, -0.011556535959243774, -0.02769027277827263, 0.04877264052629471, -0.013987783342599869, -0.036776017397642136, -0.00391665892675519, -0.02449718676507473, 0.006990737747400999, -0.07982316613197327, -0.009895709343254566, 0.010483003221452236, -0.0025299417320638895, 0.03171944245696068, 0.032308775931596756, 0.04485275223851204, 0.02635967917740345, 0.004489163402467966, -0.00047161514521576464, -0.043380893766880035, -0.020362144336104393, -0.001919893198646605, -0.004317606333643198, 0.043977122753858566, -0.004759171046316624, -0.010328478179872036, 0.02558661252260208, -0.026512237265706062, 0.03612576797604561, -0.017241638153791428, 0.01193046011030674, -0.024103088304400444, -0.047316767275333405, 0.017817072570323944, 0.00018468852795194834, 0.027676593512296677, 0.028279708698391914, -0.006656594108790159, 0.04336755722761154, -0.04015342518687248, 0.02330138348042965, -0.04391443356871605, -0.04557526856660843, -0.06475524604320526, -0.0319337397813797, 0.028863031417131424, 0.006699605844914913, 0.00219075963832438, 0.011888367123901844, -0.028112944215536118, 0.008490401320159435, 0.029045650735497475, -0.031994666904211044, 0.03219473734498024, -0.03568923473358154, 0.03394252806901932, -0.014005863107740879, -0.02384030818939209, -0.02935723215341568, -0.020835842937231064, -0.0207683052867651, 0.03658448904752731, 0.006619452033191919, 0.01870577409863472, -0.007702826056629419, 0.01311965100467205, 0.0341716967523098, -0.03540315106511116, -0.020072175189852715, -0.038232773542404175, -0.02816646732389927, -0.04649778828024864, -0.00990413036197424 ]
<p>I have a time series of daily data and am assuming each point in the time series is normally distributed. If I have a distribution of the daily data and want to scale this to cover a month (30 days) I believe I just scale the standard deviation by square root of 30. I think this assumes the data points are independently distributed. If I use an exponentially weighted moving average to calculate the standard deviation can I still scale the daily data to monthly by multiplying by square root 30?</p>
35,905
[ -0.009210938587784767, -0.011463573202490807, -0.0008303963113576174, -0.022532932460308075, 0.03496023267507553, -0.009229656308889389, -0.03904453292489052, -0.015328834764659405, -0.0006576848099939525, -0.014612117782235146, 0.020964769646525383, -0.0065223840065300465, 0.07324524968862534, -0.014028172008693218, 0.02642282471060753, 0.0016871861880645156, -0.03753140568733215, 0.002092588460072875, -0.029977809637784958, -0.04783618450164795, -0.019929146394133568, -0.0015418266411870718, 0.025977101176977158, -0.05175694450736046, -0.03359575197100639, 0.02458357810974121, 0.002660147612914443, 0.025600412860512733, -0.015363172627985477, 0.07023221254348755, -0.017165672034025192, -0.0394209548830986, 0.04613938927650452, 0.0721609890460968, 0.032734401524066925, 0.02450202777981758, -0.03668149188160896, -0.01390658225864172, -0.04011877626180649, 0.029650507494807243, -0.04199685528874397, -0.020770546048879623, 0.004136131145060062, 0.016721181571483612, -0.019606968387961388, 0.06881865113973618, -0.007674401625990868, -0.005081626586616039, 0.03628084808588028, 0.003153805620968342, 0.09837135672569275, -0.028112143278121948, 0.017477210611104965, 0.019994864240288734, -0.016475645825266838, -0.01711619645357132, 0.051479026675224304, 0.012254616245627403, 0.01179138757288456, -0.02140452340245247, -0.0038349113892763853, 0.014155386947095394, -0.028121476992964745, -0.04111125320196152, -0.006057292222976685, -0.011862737126648426, -0.0020503352861851454, -0.022659387439489365, 0.03906136006116867, -0.023950451985001564, 0.018658405169844627, 0.02755628153681755, 0.043236348778009415, 0.012316640466451645, -0.011205121874809265, -0.017622191458940506, 0.044556669890880585, 0.010000964626669884, 0.047124575823545456, 0.02716469205915928, 0.004867797717452049, 0.03203583508729935, 0.03223802521824837, 0.011130924336612225, 0.027870720252394676, -0.007073142100125551, 0.05956657603383064, -0.02873781882226467, 0.008635365404188633, 0.05093378201127052, 0.007890120148658752, -0.007646312937140465, 0.05143537372350693, -0.025645390152931213, -0.04700860753655434, 0.020174015313386917, -0.0058668144047260284, -0.013513866811990738, 0.011835547164082527, 0.02428637258708477, 0.02384418435394764, -0.05623556300997734, 0.010691582225263119, 0.017439845949411392, 0.0076637063175439835, 0.00029618985718116164, 0.004646583925932646, 0.02146536111831665, -0.03064371645450592, -0.03805701062083244, -0.008883485570549965, -0.030232008546590805, 0.011770373210310936, -0.02380041405558586, 0.059284791350364685, 0.010733000002801418, 0.01504410058259964, -0.0004627080634236336, 0.01328306645154953, 0.05272872745990753, 0.02111353538930416, -0.008390494622290134, 0.01910129189491272, -0.032892242074012756, -0.033958800137043, 0.03813856095075607, -0.02722453884780407, -0.024319786578416824, -0.08222471177577972, 0.04255241900682449, 0.03311893716454506, -0.03409629687666893, 0.06879537552595139, -0.004624560941010714, 0.04277881607413292, 0.0011230851523578167, -0.06949760764837265, -0.029753923416137695, 0.028282739222049713, 0.0009291296009905636, 0.0369722954928875, -0.060043465346097946, -0.013225484639406204, 0.012713904492557049, 0.02508240006864071, 0.04541581869125366, 0.045679736882448196, 0.01809622347354889, 0.0445711649954319, 0.01108002383261919, -0.02081422321498394, 0.0074440608732402325, -0.021013904362916946, -0.06326762586832047, 0.013009831309318542, -0.07390627264976501, 0.0255759097635746, 0.020403390750288963, 0.0024009395856410265, -0.0166514590382576, 0.06456493586301804, 0.022821972146630287, 0.004423218313604593, 0.004401951562613249, 0.011816922575235367, -0.027175182476639748, 0.05352776125073433, 0.003083085874095559, 0.004310304298996925, -0.012690913863480091, 0.015035529620945454, 0.022962739691138268, 0.03939463198184967, 0.04264247044920921, 0.08182071149349213, -0.001370616490021348, -0.0014338311739265919, -0.05634073540568352, 0.03667733445763588, 0.033080149441957474, -0.03408375009894371, 0.000027204789148527198, -0.05614587292075157, -0.007700625341385603, 0.028216883540153503, 0.04047388955950737, 0.010517619550228119, -0.0073704104870557785, 0.009377235546708107, -0.07511631399393082, -0.03889671713113785, -0.04304222762584686, 0.019734473899006844, -0.04055522009730339, -0.02455028146505356, 0.018094319850206375, 0.0003319012466818094, 0.05427667126059532, -0.012360068038105965, -0.03243836760520935, 0.012233876623213291, -0.01707448996603489, 0.028507035225629807, -0.050758276134729385, 0.006537359207868576, 0.028987981379032135, 0.06635697931051254, -0.009614051319658756, 0.006208004429936409, -0.03749893978238106, -0.054938435554504395, -0.0014629355864599347, -0.060524582862854004, 0.03412850946187973, 0.001830195658840239, 0.0038373596034944057, -0.004249131307005882, 0.006109741982072592, -0.02044404298067093, 0.028860926628112793, -0.006849607452750206, 0.04978329688310623, 0.07316961139440536, -0.030322521924972534, 0.007104755379259586, 0.03594877943396568, 0.0439736470580101, 0.002891192212700844, 0.021572070196270943, -0.061414558440446854, -0.058629684150218964, 0.007649892009794712, 0.016936566680669785, 0.023450598120689392, -0.04086431488394737, 0.020255718380212784, 0.09563107043504715, 0.023285454139113426, 0.02176716737449169, 0.07211440056562424, 0.013235576450824738, 0.0028268222231417894, -0.01661979965865612, -0.011385899037122726, 0.0007488045957870781, -0.003485331544652581, 0.02212562970817089, 0.015680955722928047, 0.03746708482503891, 0.009623967111110687, -0.0004346556670498103, -0.006680546794086695, 0.01631208509206772, -0.0005221947794780135, -0.006683241575956345, -0.005535706412047148, 0.038177765905857086, -0.057443443685770035, -0.020770564675331116, 0.00951958168298006, -0.02109077200293541, 0.002660703379660845, 0.0016706455498933792, -0.02466258592903614, 0.021245885640382767, 0.02657652460038662, -0.030964596197009087, -0.007277582306414843, 0.00767740560695529, -0.008700007572770119, -0.015553636476397514, -0.034507863223552704, -0.007920486852526665, -0.01651744544506073, 0.017682945355772972, 0.0505167655646801, 0.0277976356446743, 0.028079485520720482, -0.020444195717573166, -0.028255842626094818, -0.025944530963897705, -0.014564862474799156, 0.025983529165387154, 0.013819165527820587, -0.027338024228811264, 0.034119099378585815, -0.0005983590963296592, -0.06258206069469452, 0.008936353959143162, -0.04989501088857651, 0.010140435770154, 0.02363830804824829, 0.0010701654246076941, -0.021868033334612846, 0.0027401833795011044, -0.025893719866871834, -0.0034595648758113384, -0.04307907074689865, -0.0039021403063088655, 0.06604509800672531, 0.02504010498523712, -0.014264047145843506, -0.023286474868655205, -0.05603140592575073, -0.015115954913198948, -0.03580417484045029, -0.0022470157127827406, -0.009579198434948921, -0.02921544946730137, 0.004709103610366583, 0.04827582836151123, -0.046408139169216156, -0.027894970029592514, -0.029194312170147896, -0.04983033984899521, 0.019188622012734413, -0.0011856803903356194, 0.06574925780296326, 0.020996391773223877, -0.024787044152617455, 0.05330587178468704, 0.03881324827671051, -0.06338601559400558, 0.003799956990405917, 0.027185160666704178, -0.0373937264084816, -0.048404060304164886, 0.011018925346434116, -0.00800859834998846, 0.010465068742632866, -0.002009542193263769, 0.025692880153656006, -0.022226594388484955, 0.05459663271903992, 0.048613276332616806, -0.0172080360352993, -0.020967954769730568, -0.018826911225914955, -0.0035429196432232857, 0.027019113302230835, 0.04002116620540619, -0.020654575899243355, 0.009338880889117718, 0.018102705478668213, 0.07214468717575073, 0.013988702557981014, -0.02470545656979084, 0.056203193962574005, 0.009223384782671928, 0.034508172422647476, -0.05035731568932533, 0.038632337003946304, 0.03297416865825653, -0.01153167150914669, -0.037655144929885864, 0.01907866820693016, -0.012750142253935337, -0.02306048572063446, 0.0009663461241871119, 0.06887438893318176, 0.08400281518697739, 0.0073378561064600945, -0.0385996550321579, 0.0026561645790934563, 0.013906068168580532, 0.02400863729417324, -0.03627559170126915, -0.03742368891835213, 0.023641124367713928, 0.01837766170501709, 0.01645052246749401, -0.015531042590737343, -0.04108700156211853, 0.0016872413689270616, -0.08949287980794907, -0.01512207929044962, 0.007888258434832096, 0.034139037132263184, 0.029747921973466873, 0.018363483250141144, 0.0317067950963974, -0.007193550001829863, -0.018277650699019432, 0.004872207064181566, -0.06748964637517929, 0.060285817831754684, -0.020550750195980072, -0.0646682158112526, 0.013605918735265732, -0.00868123210966587, 0.004264217801392078, 0.004061845131218433, 0.017125139012932777, -0.0014875014312565327, 0.010267702862620354, -0.013223898597061634, -0.009033541195094585, 0.0007418652530759573, -0.020625725388526917, -0.02013062871992588, -0.011857055127620697, 0.043519727885723114, -0.05304979532957077, 0.03762929514050484, 0.028854569420218468, -0.013025087304413319, -0.0376724898815155, -0.015846222639083862, 0.05157184973359108, -0.010038265958428383, 0.013344679959118366, 0.0031808968633413315, 0.024851223453879356, -0.02886941097676754, 0.03856334090232849, 0.016816692426800728, 0.047856830060482025, 0.008984201587736607, -0.058429259806871414, -0.020499246194958687, -0.0436687171459198, -0.03180674463510513, 0.056329693645238876, -0.011826969683170319, 0.020818868651986122, -0.00014634865510743111, 0.05635208263993263, -0.013607794418931007, -0.06419205665588379, -0.026538264006376266, 0.0928552895784378, -0.018206195905804634, -0.016887938603758812, -0.03407474607229233, -0.024648716673254967, -0.0031505869701504707, -0.015256086364388466, 0.0218040831387043, 0.02383301965892315, 0.011882519349455833, -0.003468377748504281, 0.0400983989238739, -0.013142555952072144, -0.019139712676405907, -0.01205906830728054, 0.017587320879101753, 0.05487943813204765, -0.01694932021200657, -0.0019333797972649336, 0.029219286516308784, 0.010545779019594193, 0.01903129741549492, -0.024319130927324295, 0.006233406253159046, -0.08470071107149124, 0.015369657427072525, 0.009184394031763077, 0.03750582039356232, 0.008573582395911217, -0.006824979558587074, -0.044649895280599594, -0.01598423533141613, 0.06124729663133621, -0.013526709750294685, -0.007454988546669483, -0.016166076064109802, 0.0016785325715318322, -0.00009030511864693835, -0.032149866223335266, -0.023933954536914825, 0.00032817802275530994, -0.02621149830520153, 0.011670392006635666, -0.005154901649802923, -0.02064674347639084, -0.06934859603643417, 0.00539283687248826, 0.018739162012934685, 0.0605267696082592, -0.016460329294204712, -0.025570351630449295, -0.003480300074443221, 0.03386131301522255, -0.01267937757074833, -0.07329700887203217, -0.0067451284267008305, 0.015543801710009575, -0.016315581277012825, -0.014483128674328327, -0.0018715552287176251, -0.023841211572289467, 0.021466128528118134, 0.001911743776872754, -0.038425661623477936, -0.0013472684659063816, -0.024155110120773315, 0.06952537596225739, -0.004321604035794735, -0.0017360914498567581, 0.06464038789272308, 0.04857424274086952, 0.012347759678959846, 0.010570463724434376, -0.03773760050535202, 0.02448992431163788, -0.03335118666291237, -0.0028224398847669363, -0.016724465414881706, 0.003107063937932253, -0.011082184500992298, 0.027793854475021362, -0.011132065206766129, 0.016503235325217247, 0.010727700777351856, -0.003610420972108841, 0.003060602117329836, 0.013067934662103653, -0.0078043751418590546, -0.0005641200114041567, 0.0013364037731662393, 0.04038878157734871, -0.025694862008094788, -0.029817931354045868, 0.013927836902439594, 0.001903317286632955, -0.0064560589380562305, 0.01235874742269516, -0.04702585190534592, -0.005795350298285484, -0.012576153501868248, -0.02410840429365635, 0.020328935235738754, -0.02216695249080658, 0.02351129800081253, -0.005483894143253565, -0.0018874870147556067, 0.008696596138179302, -0.043121661990880966, 0.03584643080830574, -0.020662767812609673, -0.008066284470260143, -0.0003747138543985784, -0.049155093729496, -0.004834617022424936, 0.00016119840438477695, -0.024040622636675835, -0.0620654821395874, -0.03160183131694794, 0.02631538361310959, -0.0021142540499567986, 0.016314053907990456, -0.05357110872864723, 0.020535694435238838, -0.04335903376340866, -0.024050099775195122, -0.02075660228729248, 0.03443930670619011, 0.017948942258954048, -0.01860952563583851, -0.0032809702679514885, 0.05268462747335434, 0.07372099906206131, -0.014163259416818619, 0.023892836645245552, 0.010911188088357449, -0.020613061264157295, -0.03449009731411934, 0.005815180949866772, 0.0700232982635498, -0.03503413870930672, 0.029703104868531227, 0.0029700216837227345, -0.035005755722522736, 0.03407846763730049, -0.027687013149261475, -0.044642895460128784, 0.01830132119357586, 0.002743373392149806, 0.030533991754055023, -0.003979467786848545, 0.021445609629154205, 0.005502308253198862, 0.014739975333213806, -0.04393702372908592, -0.015169074758887291, -0.03671323135495186, -0.016100062057375908, -0.01328833494335413, 0.02345023676753044, 0.0023099721875041723, 0.06662348657846451, 0.033360257744789124, 0.009240941144526005, -0.014188364148139954, -0.02139180339872837, -0.0363067090511322, 0.017665663734078407, -0.025017552077770233, -0.009748819284141064, -0.0003612406144384295, -0.007802885491400957, -0.0026245350018143654, -0.03153914585709572, -0.056088887155056, -0.001627957564778626, 0.057251591235399246, 0.007631112355738878, 0.056732065975666046, 0.037005893886089325, 0.02040456421673298, -0.02366217039525509, -0.051061466336250305, -0.00984224397689104, -0.004512093961238861, -0.012324315495789051, 0.04138503596186638, -0.0003283257829025388, -0.00031457567820325494, -0.003840587567538023, 0.01425214298069477, 0.023625705391168594, 0.0727519616484642, 0.03693081811070442, -0.005584985949099064, 0.02009359560906887, -0.005555062089115381, -0.027826031669974327, -0.00015423668082803488, -0.009242297150194645, 0.02865988202393055, -0.03966549038887024, -0.007458364125341177, 0.036018166691064835, 0.004199022892862558, -0.04582195729017258, -0.027105318382382393, -0.03524290397763252, -0.0396902896463871, 0.032797764986753464, 0.007997781038284302, -0.009992776438593864, 0.05230444669723511, 0.000542846682947129, 0.020544251427054405, -0.0112949563190341, 0.013026225380599499, -0.02269561029970646, -0.046046894043684006, -0.028960920870304108, -0.04378033056855202, -0.06020638346672058, 0.02648014761507511, 0.002935348777100444, -0.019225161522626877, -0.03196796774864197, -0.028608113527297974, 0.045518919825553894, -0.021707182750105858, 0.03317916393280029, 0.02607923373579979, 0.11050032824277878, -0.0029009971767663956, -0.01402195729315281, 0.002806968055665493, 0.001621037838049233, 0.12349732220172882, 0.048889320343732834, 0.018938349559903145, -0.021887527778744698, 0.004778033122420311, -0.008144725114107132, -0.0006958019803278148, -0.01510988175868988, 0.012116012163460255, 0.008351068012416363, -0.009620622731745243, 0.04672526568174362, 0.085625059902668, 0.013745029456913471, -0.009644593112170696, 0.09672971814870834, 0.00476498156785965, -0.00839816965162754, 0.023713480681180954, 0.01916036754846573, 0.01387513056397438, 0.000994612113572657, -0.06833283603191376, 0.050268352031707764, -0.016216101124882698, 0.01669909618794918, 0.011848799884319305, -0.03358602151274681, -0.007813746109604836, -0.015948904678225517, -0.037069473415613174, 0.010893739759922028, 0.05408183112740517, 0.0241354089230299, -0.02944362163543701, -0.020894963294267654, 0.025531476363539696, -0.032303810119628906, -0.0087091363966465, 0.030243830755352974, 0.010721219703555107, -0.0017966029699891806, -0.012797466479241848, 0.0039373054169118404, -0.035253480076789856, -0.039377059787511826, -0.036358606070280075, -0.025230951607227325, -0.005658924113959074, 0.01863228902220726, 0.0334041528403759, 0.01165095902979374, -0.006494009867310524, -0.06302005052566528, 0.014650611206889153, -0.0011282515479251742, 0.04746989533305168, -0.01319415308535099, -0.008032606914639473, -0.017409825697541237, 0.005273673217743635, 0.01951795257627964, -0.0023195988032966852, 0.06045355647802353, -0.012329746969044209, -0.028898440301418304, -0.01434072945266962, 0.021853234618902206, 0.0006184192607179284, -0.035442739725112915, 0.02908645011484623, 0.00006420654244720936, 0.01150328479707241, 0.026490774005651474, 0.010969162918627262, -0.03560574725270271, 0.011558840051293373, -0.013182582333683968, 0.014851382933557034, -0.014664691872894764, -0.009569110348820686, 0.03598485141992569, -0.013179179280996323, -0.027583392336964607, -0.02774711698293686, 0.03433968499302864, 0.014355843886733055, 0.0525914691388607, 0.007845010608434677, 0.0020408127456903458, -0.021791694685816765, 0.05782100185751915, 0.03408097103238106, -0.06667046248912811, 0.02407464198768139, 0.010768663138151169, -0.0446087121963501, 0.0009720249217934906, 0.019791996106505394, 0.06643471866846085, 0.04701614752411842, -0.014062666334211826, -0.05353372544050217, 0.04153069481253624, 0.011913305148482323, 0.0068690539337694645, -0.005235746037214994, -0.04323887452483177, 0.004356429446488619, 0.008096350356936455, -0.012031136080622673, -0.013051125220954418, -0.015245945192873478, -0.04506802558898926, -0.03449377790093422, -0.04493694752454758, 0.01740283891558647, -0.01570798084139824, 0.016529839485883713, -0.03790092468261719, 0.015177063643932343, -0.04196052998304367, 0.01491684839129448, -0.03808707371354103, -0.00785733386874199, -0.01422756165266037, -0.02017643116414547, -0.012651464901864529, 0.021042870357632637, -0.014411894604563713, -0.006357602775096893, 0.053601931780576706, 0.03649117797613144, 0.03618694469332695, -0.026764076203107834, 0.011936449445784092, -0.02223021909594536, 0.053699832409620285, -0.0026419959031045437, -0.02674667164683342, 0.09439583867788315, -0.02555127814412117, -0.009022538550198078, 0.04207434877753258, -0.010350766591727734, 0.03960244730114937, -0.003649388439953327, -0.01440438348799944, -0.01730463281273842, 0.026624266058206558, -0.01860673725605011, -0.012878688052296638, -0.01845846138894558, -0.049013976007699966, 0.02152666635811329, 0.019621213898062706, 0.014344966970384121, 0.004310061689466238, 0.0015862910076975822, 0.023998666554689407, 0.026588700711727142, -0.011298456229269505, -0.006133329123258591, 0.00921314675360918, -0.0025133308954536915, 0.02284672111272812, 0.015411540865898132, -0.00663008214905858, 0.06404832005500793, 0.056996118277311325, -0.028659388422966003, -0.0025868455413728952, -0.028371844440698624, -0.02575027011334896, -0.040739770978689194, -0.008257134817540646, 0.014646063558757305, -0.02621476724743843, 0.03829140216112137, -0.02411573752760887, -0.006870567798614502, 0.017724255099892616, -0.03573928773403168, 0.030387025326490402, -0.052326448261737823, -0.03211834654211998, -0.008613289333879948, 0.0019113383023068309, 0.0363013856112957, 0.008332560770213604, 0.0435246042907238, 0.053387753665447235, 0.017438845708966255, 0.03543345630168915, 0.021247606724500656, -0.01772361621260643, -0.016741536557674408, 0.02326604723930359, 0.02924462780356407, -0.04800407215952873, 0.014080632477998734, -0.07371924072504044, -0.008762629702687263, 0.03484663367271423, -0.04672570899128914, 0.02347652055323124, -0.02739187330007553, 0.0010369570227339864, 0.009394547902047634, 0.03820527344942093, 0.0394086018204689, 0.006160822696983814, -0.037096329033374786, 0.013678214512765408, 0.025167353451251984, 0.03189564868807793, 0.0014688047813251615, -0.008670716546475887, 0.02875819243490696, -0.02886795438826084, -0.003173507982864976, -0.012601873837411404, 0.007415166590362787, -0.015047223307192326, -0.03726654872298241, -0.02242940478026867, 0.021567847579717636, 0.005357971414923668, 0.02687162719666958, -0.013504398055374622, -0.002548310672864318, 0.0396634079515934, 0.02539583295583725, -0.02962353639304638, 0.01713581755757332, 0.02109614945948124, -0.04156609997153282, -0.024759013205766678, 0.016404815018177032, 0.024140048772096634, -0.04279571399092674, -0.012136293575167656, -0.017667723819613457, -0.026865124702453613, -0.06140349060297012, -0.0126302819699049, -0.04211310297250748, 0.022337062284350395, -0.0027944401372224092, 0.023914925754070282, 0.03370422124862671, -0.026558367535471916, 0.03838077187538147, -0.05246914178133011, 0.068461112678051, 0.021649669855833054, 0.0011651029344648123, -0.03259270638227463, 0.0006057497230358422, -0.017559807747602463, -0.003901680698618293, 0.04042239859700203, 0.016704948619008064, 0.010214216075837612, 0.00801273062825203, 0.026866430416703224, 0.008564761839807034, -0.05795041471719742, -0.002755406079813838, -0.03390338644385338, -0.027148092165589333, -0.02944882959127426, -0.025071701034903526, 0.010706529021263123, -0.03518569841980934, -0.0201102327555418, -0.018319347873330116, 0.0180764552205801, -0.0010913193691521883, -0.0022578644566237926, 0.03594842553138733, 0.02009975165128708, -0.03664497658610344, 0.004770344123244286, 0.006804203614592552, -0.03077627904713154, 0.024573102593421936, -0.02443467639386654, -0.03010733611881733, 0.021781230345368385, -0.05958651006221771, -0.027465298771858215, 0.032886020839214325, 0.01611139252781868, -0.03285142406821251, -0.05455248802900314, -0.038477953523397446, 0.03948909416794777, 0.0006461577722802758, 0.010878147557377815, 0.015289715491235256, -0.01196004543453455, 0.021847430616617203, 0.019266104325652122, -0.014631968922913074, 0.035239581018686295, 0.024844257161021233, 0.0290883369743824, 0.018635692074894905, -0.016052747145295143, -0.035736873745918274, -0.013562070205807686, -0.017945047467947006, -0.014872676692903042, 0.03904205933213234, -0.0028597780037671328, 0.05490092188119888, 0.007485334295779467, -0.07577091455459595, -0.024392923340201378, 0.008148427121341228, 0.027973059564828873, 0.0050516691990196705, -0.028396792709827423, 0.05539880320429802, -0.018308497965335846, 0.04193731024861336, 0.000788434233982116, -0.017557678744196892, -0.015022681094706059, -0.00006270300218602642, 0.03616710379719734, 0.004854239989072084, -0.015858741477131844, -0.009360087104141712, 0.003718671156093478, 0.0005449490272440016, -0.009815082885324955, -0.06704080104827881, 0.05208728462457657, 0.018078530207276344, -0.009168757125735283, -0.02864459902048111, -0.02667483501136303, -0.07644911855459213, -0.03369835764169693, 0.012410944327712059, 0.003049162682145834, 0.013995541259646416, 0.027556592598557472, -0.02585742622613907, -0.006998617202043533, 0.04139150306582451, -0.07699598371982574, -0.02908647060394287, -0.023414354771375656, 0.007281591184437275, 0.015636635944247246, -0.025205440819263458 ]
<p>Is there a method to find the right distance function in non-parametric regression? I use some time series to learn forecasting. Series are nonlinear and non-gaussian. I can get the right dimension and delay. I can find the right bandwidth with the hdrcde library. I have no problem with kernel functions.<br> My problem is with distances. I use Euclidian, Cosine and Correlation weighting functions. These are the kernel which give good results, but one time, Euclidian is good, then after adding some data, one to 5-7 generally, Euclidian give nothing, even with very little change in statistics. So, my question is if there is a method to choose the right distance. I would like to have advices on that point and on articles that will help solve this problem. What package in R could eventually help?</p> <p>Thank you. </p>
28,190
[ -0.005262254271656275, 0.01784552074968815, 0.0062960609793663025, 0.005628205370157957, 0.020649921149015427, 0.0007286924519576132, -0.013734892010688782, -0.016059035435318947, 0.0183763075619936, -0.0031389789655804634, -0.00824918132275343, 0.029753997921943665, 0.054477427154779434, -0.003456534817814827, 0.0013876090524718165, 0.008205357939004898, -0.032717667520046234, 0.0057877167128026485, -0.00784911960363388, -0.038961391896009445, 0.008233635686337948, 0.037114765495061874, 0.021220708265900612, -0.0264692772179842, -0.026745380833745003, 0.013530815951526165, 0.015489669516682625, -0.01881580427289009, 0.01469187717884779, 0.04361077398061752, -0.020562414079904556, -0.007993718609213829, -0.0063897110521793365, 0.03692615032196045, 0.007803244516253471, -0.00004028267721878365, -0.035379182547330856, -0.01609419472515583, -0.045464660972356796, 0.03534926101565361, -0.05116414651274681, -0.03114432469010353, 0.03452160581946373, 0.0383613184094429, -0.020089751109480858, 0.021744294092059135, 0.02054697275161743, -0.009712683036923409, 0.035137493163347244, -0.04137229919433594, 0.0941675677895546, -0.008599241264164448, 0.011040003970265388, 0.030068913474678993, -0.01784379407763481, -0.01851779967546463, 0.061092525720596313, 0.03965269401669502, -0.04154453054070473, -0.02412298321723938, -0.01711292937397957, -0.03617621958255768, 0.027502119541168213, -0.03928888961672783, -0.000004563958555081626, 0.0546506829559803, 0.01237699668854475, 0.009629825130105019, 0.002176497597247362, -0.03341600298881531, -0.0027844079304486513, 0.01344074122607708, 0.0490051731467247, -0.02864810638129711, 0.005152272526174784, 0.0018029895145446062, -0.0003267285937909037, 0.03822612389922142, 0.0962345153093338, 0.03805107623338699, -0.004317840561270714, -0.023062212392687798, 0.007728224154561758, 0.02458985708653927, 0.03142782300710678, -0.01733078993856907, 0.055405255407094955, -0.031038520857691765, 0.025817222893238068, 0.074491485953331, -0.00526737654581666, -0.010241948999464512, 0.06265835464000702, 0.017939556390047073, -0.006574428640305996, 0.041871435940265656, -0.011080795899033546, 0.016305333003401756, 0.013245755806565285, -0.0050585912540555, -0.021298347041010857, -0.03275730460882187, 0.00424179807305336, 0.037822943180799484, -0.02677101455628872, 0.015842361375689507, 0.0010219831019639969, -0.009131217375397682, -0.00975677091628313, -0.0009176248568110168, -0.031238356605172157, 0.0027180600445717573, 0.008413233794271946, 0.006729765795171261, 0.019065573811531067, -0.009945780038833618, -0.0062573570758104324, -0.03184675797820091, 0.012037632055580616, 0.10026174783706665, 0.023576591163873672, -0.01202547550201416, 0.0268351212143898, -0.011322803795337677, -0.023412151262164116, 0.032279402017593384, 0.03392665460705757, -0.03706338629126549, -0.023040324449539185, 0.034350018948316574, 0.003959440626204014, -0.04212212562561035, 0.03275902196764946, 0.014250902459025383, 0.02986893616616726, 0.03569177910685539, -0.0975308045744896, -0.043337706476449966, 0.050342656672000885, -0.014440584927797318, 0.030375909060239792, -0.03672414273023605, 0.008073003962635994, -0.003364801174029708, 0.059270065277814865, 0.026383107528090477, 0.016193561255931854, 0.029300464317202568, 0.04757949337363243, -0.023895958438515663, -0.01881781779229641, -0.006846264004707336, -0.03673757612705231, -0.01507189217954874, -0.005234299693256617, -0.059347640722990036, 0.02554594911634922, 0.025775184854865074, -0.02385265938937664, -0.007370793726295233, 0.06491141766309738, 0.0036604111082851887, -0.0445593036711216, -0.015423435717821121, 0.018105773255228996, -0.041148219257593155, 0.07334116101264954, 0.0023174539674073458, 0.00416016997769475, -0.004532309249043465, -0.039762482047080994, 0.020876985043287277, 0.013406340964138508, 0.036655936390161514, 0.04321226477622986, 0.00832466222345829, 0.0025775122921913862, -0.006263118702918291, 0.005177462939172983, 0.017625901848077774, -0.027642732486128807, -0.02764200046658516, 0.011044318787753582, -0.021369673311710358, 0.016993841156363487, 0.035391371697187424, 0.005384553223848343, 0.00010640640539349988, 0.05365316569805145, -0.04072923585772514, -0.017310215160250664, -0.026934562250971794, -0.02379728853702545, -0.021739227697253227, -0.023820247501134872, 0.05448387935757637, -0.002945664804428816, 0.025211861357092857, -0.012643596157431602, -0.021712541580200195, -0.022212287411093712, -0.00813668966293335, 0.037820130586624146, -0.03805532306432724, 0.01642216555774212, 0.03350837901234627, 0.03672697767615318, -0.017703935503959656, 0.03303731977939606, -0.03991559520363808, -0.03603024408221245, -0.002811079379171133, -0.0412689708173275, -0.003346462966874242, -0.042362697422504425, 0.009978127665817738, 0.031018711626529694, 0.00665312260389328, -0.02873854711651802, 0.012031469494104385, -0.0536193810403347, 0.07550141960382462, 0.09529006481170654, 0.019509024918079376, 0.005857795476913452, 0.004008783493191004, -0.007258685305714607, 0.02201252616941929, -0.03967856988310814, -0.02861202135682106, -0.037627771496772766, 0.007253672927618027, 0.02527950331568718, 0.03372878208756447, -0.050485629588365555, -0.01405513659119606, 0.05997307598590851, 0.016963133588433266, -0.00599527545273304, 0.017662471160292625, -0.003273838432505727, -0.024338599294424057, 0.030479051172733307, -0.009051431901752949, -0.0274115689098835, -0.018651433289051056, 0.02560599334537983, 0.023859426379203796, 0.04929124563932419, 0.0024901926517486572, 0.000016604471966275014, 0.03421900421380997, -0.00041457926272414625, 0.00421879393979907, -0.029941415414214134, 0.006063081789761782, 0.03963952511548996, -0.01944384165108204, 0.0034031118266284466, 0.012191134504973888, 0.02395200915634632, 0.02068658359348774, 0.03596898540854454, -0.0091458884999156, 0.029364461079239845, 0.010139167308807373, -0.029619397595524788, 0.01693347841501236, 0.011958432383835316, -0.07360085099935532, 0.015403670258820057, -0.030332740396261215, -0.00770421652123332, -0.021940091624855995, -0.014971496537327766, 0.02745785564184189, 0.03022831678390503, 0.00860485527664423, -0.011367403902113438, -0.002894235774874687, -0.001549543347209692, -0.01793920248746872, 0.024706756696105003, 0.015683187171816826, -0.029354847967624664, 0.020250752568244934, -0.04987011104822159, -0.008552324958145618, 0.036034829914569855, -0.04092354327440262, 0.007510129828006029, -0.0033675837330520153, -0.009765055030584335, -0.02880675531923771, -0.048690568655729294, -0.04292558878660202, 0.020277636125683784, -0.03152951970696449, -0.025452911853790283, 0.03508472815155983, -0.032020773738622665, -0.06813088804483414, 0.02095545083284378, -0.02620426006615162, -0.028417278081178665, -0.031421419233083725, 0.03820649906992912, 0.0010637560626491904, -0.027812669053673744, 0.013937672600150108, 0.023311445489525795, 0.006939019542187452, -0.0027325619012117386, -0.047067124396562576, -0.03930183872580528, 0.043015193194150925, 0.001295343041419983, 0.03471183031797409, 0.03498183190822601, -0.0026356675662100315, 0.062295347452163696, 0.01759047619998455, -0.032459113746881485, -0.07212378084659576, 0.032048068940639496, -0.049802690744400024, -0.025687212124466896, 0.007284543942660093, 0.026530751958489418, 0.04997880011796951, -0.01593117043375969, -0.019382471218705177, 0.022876733914017677, 0.07831393927335739, -0.011297672055661678, -0.0012488231295719743, 0.03226213529706001, -0.012620316818356514, -0.01422522496432066, 0.056928154081106186, 0.03331313654780388, -0.031884465366601944, 0.035724371671676636, 0.010721560567617416, -0.014634608291089535, -0.01459312904626131, -0.06986720114946365, -0.0006877949344925582, -0.003086984157562256, -0.005115896463394165, -0.04253723844885826, -0.02341894991695881, -0.0028327188920229673, -0.01953267864882946, 0.009694525972008705, 0.015595242381095886, 0.029374366626143456, -0.010456467047333717, 0.03520464524626732, 0.04016950726509094, 0.028323093429207802, 0.00935288704931736, -0.0016137566417455673, -0.02653099037706852, -0.022493679076433182, 0.020828738808631897, -0.020033231005072594, -0.015967149287462234, 0.016400320455431938, 0.010278328321874142, -0.0019916773308068514, 0.018151940777897835, -0.08732018619775772, 0.02324593998491764, -0.07031085342168808, -0.012401597574353218, -0.011348502710461617, 0.07808587700128555, 0.01587183028459549, -0.022553300485014915, 0.022298794239759445, -0.009985281154513359, 0.005016988608986139, -0.01698925718665123, -0.05281383544206619, 0.040757790207862854, -0.021214723587036133, 0.0001527326530776918, -0.02956581488251686, -0.035508763045072556, -0.01268788706511259, -0.02659803442656994, 0.06526146829128265, 0.009852667339146137, 0.03969843313097954, -0.024685965850949287, -0.02120041847229004, -0.006136578042060137, -0.024146683514118195, -0.026850609108805656, -0.010166405700147152, 0.03028067760169506, -0.03544122353196144, 0.0200746338814497, 0.04488782957196236, -0.008907529525458813, -0.01595194637775421, -0.02277272753417492, 0.018044061958789825, -0.0013223910937085748, 0.02510516531765461, -0.0016392871038988233, 0.014888093806803226, -0.0409453809261322, 0.05513757839798927, -0.04618992656469345, 0.004366649314761162, 0.051665324717760086, -0.0318705178797245, -0.0374465212225914, -0.018885217607021332, -0.00605439068749547, 0.009520023129880428, 0.03933754563331604, 0.018899187445640564, -0.02155863307416439, 0.08640704303979874, -0.0014555425150319934, -0.05659831687808037, -0.03958994522690773, 0.03018490970134735, 0.025819748640060425, -0.024944663047790527, -0.03722569718956947, -0.04334360361099243, 0.007181710097938776, 0.0043801250867545605, 0.017998280003666878, 0.00350567395798862, 0.010168889537453651, -0.031489185988903046, 0.03516177088022232, -0.016666337847709656, -0.011929228901863098, -0.02225138433277607, 0.0561925433576107, 0.04510800167918205, -0.020744478330016136, -0.03352469578385353, 0.018941223621368408, 0.046249065548181534, 0.04777628555893898, 0.023767821490764618, 0.01331615075469017, -0.08240170031785965, -0.002965787658467889, 0.03625762462615967, 0.02203839272260666, 0.012608502060174942, -0.024577805772423744, -0.027287058532238007, -0.024514829739928246, 0.052612774074077606, -0.012442430481314659, 0.01543442066758871, -0.0053412639535963535, -0.018365271389484406, -0.0325317308306694, -0.04687542840838432, -0.040928591042757034, 0.024134686216711998, -0.009410930797457695, 0.03173493593931198, -0.04250004142522812, -0.02796025015413761, -0.03487835079431534, 0.028203319758176804, -0.022882068529725075, 0.04134706035256386, -0.024687808007001877, -0.0020717938896268606, 0.033782053738832474, 0.006268601398915052, 0.027208315208554268, -0.05280698090791702, 0.031440652906894684, 0.006615004036575556, 0.001454762415960431, 0.022472433745861053, 0.001594606670551002, -0.009908544830977917, -0.013193768449127674, 0.0031826761551201344, -0.022573361173272133, 0.024862410500645638, 0.0013379608280956745, 0.017937978729605675, 0.013076276518404484, 0.03519382327795029, 0.0624292828142643, 0.05254834517836571, -0.0016626757569611073, 0.008313811384141445, -0.06038980185985565, 0.017812196165323257, -0.02371976524591446, -0.055384859442710876, -0.010603497736155987, -0.061259835958480835, -0.03473002091050148, 0.026922868564724922, 0.005512956529855728, 0.05497950688004494, -0.03531584516167641, 0.006769577506929636, 0.01637144759297371, 0.05043862760066986, -0.050967052578926086, 0.01862087845802307, -0.001644671312533319, 0.021624932065606117, 0.03275046497583389, 0.005982387810945511, -0.006042590830475092, 0.03155606985092163, 0.008748277090489864, 0.03880401700735092, -0.05324135720729828, -0.017395205795764923, -0.03052258864045143, -0.004811556078493595, 0.02469305507838726, -0.019537078216671944, 0.055117152631282806, 0.0150610925629735, -0.012866656295955181, 0.02448413521051407, -0.031016238033771515, 0.00931321457028389, 0.014954442158341408, -0.036759961396455765, 0.037607189267873764, -0.05188148096203804, -0.0007725028553977609, -0.03255239129066467, 0.014799333177506924, -0.05371725559234619, -0.02390918880701065, -0.002702211495488882, -0.0038517906796187162, -0.020933905616402626, -0.0642123594880104, 0.03205715864896774, -0.020715007558465004, -0.018480641767382622, -0.0011559498962014914, 0.03176836296916008, 0.011894423514604568, 0.007883645594120026, -0.031972624361515045, 0.005438201129436493, 0.06471097469329834, 0.004440484568476677, -0.004431947134435177, 0.013617247343063354, 0.007929440587759018, -0.007248793262988329, 0.016327854245901108, 0.023742571473121643, -0.032674383372068405, 0.004696588031947613, -0.05780753120779991, -0.011485525406897068, 0.024536196142435074, -0.02243022620677948, -0.03127891942858696, -0.000879771017935127, -0.029923956841230392, 0.004900831263512373, -0.007849065586924553, 0.017717920243740082, -0.023347878828644753, -0.027204034850001335, -0.009189130738377571, 0.006071210838854313, -0.012033225037157536, -0.016706528142094612, 0.021305739879608154, 0.004931098315864801, 0.006558520253747702, 0.018741782754659653, 0.026495035737752914, 0.0016810164088383317, 0.019110074266791344, 0.02520471066236496, -0.02003273367881775, 0.04414412006735802, 0.009300123900175095, -0.002732017310336232, -0.010245654731988907, 0.026695851236581802, -0.03812764585018158, -0.06266487389802933, -0.021040327847003937, -0.009281293489038944, 0.06381471455097198, -0.06553006917238235, 0.045461684465408325, 0.038504213094711304, -0.01757274568080902, -0.022195084020495415, -0.005045734345912933, -0.011554639786481857, -0.022516055032610893, 0.010487053543329239, 0.07648523151874542, -0.003917954862117767, 0.011627201922237873, 0.018701661378145218, 0.006743743550032377, 0.019816981628537178, 0.05480051040649414, -0.05738741531968117, 0.043399225920438766, 0.03741173818707466, -0.013261050917208195, -0.041165754199028015, 0.008558359928429127, 0.006239095702767372, 0.018752649426460266, -0.012668857350945473, -0.02443881332874298, 0.028005452826619148, 0.022604577243328094, 0.015750212594866753, -0.031103888526558876, -0.02869987115263939, -0.03584921732544899, -0.011094282381236553, 0.06205294653773308, -0.04626179859042168, 0.02748052030801773, 0.0400853157043457, 0.0313383974134922, 0.003930042497813702, 0.03138969838619232, -0.0204628873616457, -0.047206711024045944, 0.0006057842401787639, -0.03940445929765701, -0.0165345910936594, 0.029979614540934563, 0.005073932930827141, -0.0867655873298645, 0.01557029690593481, 0.017731856554746628, -0.01785605028271675, 0.015407422557473183, -0.0020134311635047197, 0.004009457305073738, 0.082415372133255, -0.013211525976657867, -0.021187886595726013, -0.009886683896183968, 0.005747372750192881, 0.13426950573921204, 0.06604153662919998, 0.050332359969615936, -0.07478729635477066, 0.006567811127752066, -0.004847615025937557, -0.025408603250980377, -0.04798443615436554, 0.02346593700349331, 0.01579383574426174, -0.009240233339369297, 0.02987969107925892, 0.04272183030843735, 0.02382436767220497, 0.00916813313961029, 0.0639178603887558, -0.04459691792726517, -0.0024359095841646194, 0.010718073695898056, -0.00936330109834671, 0.04142571985721588, 0.00010913905134657398, -0.03919138014316559, 0.04419562965631485, -0.01440922636538744, -0.0089862160384655, -0.034744828939437866, -0.03275368735194206, 0.008763338439166546, -0.0108769116923213, -0.004098205827176571, 0.0018695332109928131, 0.01931103505194187, 0.013049752451479435, 0.014308985322713852, 0.014770016074180603, 0.0186565350741148, -0.03152097761631012, 0.021546024829149246, -0.0015307898866012692, 0.026104075834155083, -0.00968337431550026, -0.011716469191014767, -0.01219124998897314, -0.01196361891925335, -0.020168935880064964, -0.03148650750517845, 0.033464688807725906, 0.008020502515137196, -0.0019633201882243156, 0.04607899487018585, 0.014468501321971416, 0.005804350599646568, -0.06784071028232574, -0.017793919891119003, 0.007162135094404221, 0.053322684019804, 0.0070183295756578445, -0.00016094370221253484, -0.006959349382668734, 0.022703800350427628, 0.0011327634565532207, 0.049473267048597336, 0.025304695591330528, -0.027999093756079674, -0.031441830098629, -0.016893170773983, 0.06626730412244797, 0.0017351744463667274, -0.019910547882318497, -0.01406090334057808, -0.008498916402459145, -0.024076273664832115, -0.0037314461078494787, 0.004420008510351181, -0.012759141623973846, 0.011407330632209778, -0.014594964683055878, -0.01476670429110527, -0.017838038504123688, -0.03662220388650894, 0.007103446871042252, -0.0483870804309845, 0.011249610222876072, -0.016956007108092308, -0.018113207072019577, 0.06772036105394363, 0.030465777963399887, 0.05587290599942207, -0.0000064289988586097024, -0.005710081662982702, -0.00017429649597033858, 0.020050616934895515, -0.09610596299171448, 0.02567402645945549, -0.018759841099381447, -0.021978288888931274, -0.003673743223771453, -0.008420093916356564, 0.05584465712308884, 0.028713878244161606, 0.009925276972353458, -0.018314840272068977, 0.01622622273862362, -0.021035103127360344, 0.0136562529951334, -0.014258034527301788, -0.06177130341529846, 0.006556068547070026, -0.04031984508037567, 0.0005867405561730266, -0.0452396385371685, -0.009613758884370327, -0.028662465512752533, -0.02546939067542553, 0.015415916219353676, 0.011655469425022602, -0.023042142391204834, 0.01276598870754242, 0.022803867235779762, -0.007724497001618147, -0.048633795231580734, 0.04117938503623009, -0.029343321919441223, 0.005243143066763878, -0.04940979182720184, -0.02587101422250271, 0.004903202876448631, -0.008849521167576313, -0.03482411056756973, -0.006329718045890331, 0.06144363433122635, 0.00027253763983026147, 0.06135566160082817, 0.01057523675262928, -0.005570727400481701, -0.03944743797183037, 0.040076062083244324, -0.02326018549501896, -0.01943100616335869, 0.0027793077751994133, -0.058759499341249466, -0.06409253925085068, 0.02612534537911415, -0.020380565896630287, 0.010624476708471775, 0.018247047439217567, 0.018401190638542175, -0.015619895420968533, 0.053664810955524445, -0.0015035803662613034, 0.013032584451138973, -0.02707517333328724, -0.000658579112496227, 0.04400291293859482, -0.0007087057456374168, 0.02271038293838501, -0.012879252433776855, -0.014689985662698746, 0.022324441000819206, 0.0523311085999012, 0.035303521901369095, 0.0037123095244169235, 0.025500234216451645, -0.013940916396677494, -0.0015950484666973352, -0.004039589781314135, 0.005054770037531853, 0.04278035834431648, 0.06172274798154831, -0.042915765196084976, 0.03570755943655968, 0.02008930593729019, 0.031249087303876877, -0.09206510335206985, -0.006886509712785482, -0.001358594512566924, 0.010344651527702808, 0.0315757617354393, -0.07777440547943115, 0.01217818632721901, 0.029408184811472893, -0.05680517107248306, 0.03049188293516636, -0.0066138338297605515, -0.013774086721241474, -0.015439987182617188, -0.010466965846717358, -0.0032571947667747736, 0.037275850772857666, 0.09421457350254059, 0.05475728213787079, 0.010920820757746696, 0.027099572122097015, -0.023089030757546425, -0.02027556486427784, -0.006467236205935478, 0.0046871802769601345, 0.007435231003910303, -0.05906594917178154, 0.015759088099002838, -0.017683913931250572, -0.010461485013365746, 0.04054931178689003, -0.027831217274069786, 0.015697147697210312, 0.010065080597996712, 0.018249057233333588, 0.03333773836493492, 0.0490289106965065, 0.024859244003891945, -0.04284019395709038, -0.007227009162306786, -0.034855298697948456, 0.008418697863817215, 0.00435015419498086, -0.06634560972452164, 0.016551479697227478, -0.0017039839876815677, 0.003544262843206525, -0.013953469693660736, 0.0018953430699184537, -0.01071446854621172, -0.022904835641384125, -0.03357532247900963, 0.006461515557020903, -0.009678262285888195, -0.006722227204591036, 0.006545035634189844, -0.0176057368516922, -0.009313412941992283, 0.025961147621273994, 0.03839881718158722, -0.05466005578637123, 0.0010964282555505633, -0.028619466349482536, -0.08640971034765244, 0.006848198361694813, -0.02669726312160492, 0.021978167816996574, -0.035992108285427094, 0.02057032100856304, -0.0010261645074933767, -0.03124864771962166, -0.02991233393549919, -0.008039502426981926, -0.020714133977890015, 0.06227795034646988, 0.0034350876230746508, 0.00020528542518150061, 0.04243747517466545, -0.010271698236465454, 0.009946305304765701, -0.07666581124067307, 0.04009431600570679, 0.015387054532766342, -0.009695586748421192, -0.013961118645966053, -0.015989456325769424, -0.034169752150774, 0.0218350887298584, 0.08528551459312439, -0.00942063145339489, 0.029907967895269394, 0.0020064315758645535, 0.003176596015691757, -0.0005693606799468398, -0.0073003279976546764, 0.004443539772182703, 0.0003132066922262311, -0.04822259768843651, 0.0003442981978878379, -0.014647451229393482, 0.017494508996605873, 0.025069406256079674, -0.013903508894145489, -0.004162179306149483, 0.03159425035119057, 0.02797951176762581, -0.014642997644841671, 0.022472472861409187, 0.007059676107019186, -0.021099595353007317, 0.02529248222708702, 0.009806537069380283, -0.007147510536015034, 0.015797168016433716, 0.012539687566459179, -0.0636616125702858, 0.04150496423244476, -0.036586660891771317, -0.08009647578001022, 0.019359981641173363, 0.006960446946322918, 0.023326359689235687, -0.040834881365299225, -0.026573941111564636, 0.07867063581943512, -0.024926234036684036, 0.0057378956116735935, 0.043577514588832855, 0.008055287413299084, 0.027605343610048294, 0.018866414204239845, 0.01451171189546585, 0.0414617657661438, 0.004311443772166967, 0.016963602975010872, -0.006012955214828253, 0.07210688292980194, 0.012955659069120884, -0.034084487706422806, -0.016075147315859795, -0.03583788126707077, 0.027753572911024094, -0.05122291296720505, 0.06081518530845642, -0.016613421961665154, -0.03411942720413208, -0.0028044250793755054, -0.014609322883188725, -0.021155286580324173, 0.009741147980093956, -0.02885841205716133, 0.06034157797694206, -0.04248671233654022, 0.006530565209686756, -0.022995712235569954, -0.014567237347364426, -0.025128746405243874, 0.026237603276968002, -0.017925523221492767, 0.009206988848745823, -0.015475907362997532, 0.017235830426216125, 0.00352273671887815, -0.010548342019319534, 0.027602430433034897, -0.018096083775162697, 0.00615466246381402, -0.0007155995699577034, -0.0004000783374067396, 0.005849177483469248, -0.015282528474926949, -0.027912406250834465, -0.014340158551931381, 0.024468382820487022, 0.02278975211083889, 0.022105813026428223, -0.026623087003827095, -0.0040141320787370205, 0.010946548543870449, 0.07046670466661453, -0.10304548591375351, -0.013454982079565525, -0.00936387199908495, -0.02842351235449314, -0.013386069796979427, -0.018937697634100914 ]
<p>I am working on SVMs and try to get all the concepts involved. For instance, the kernel mapping. I would like to construct some parts of the algorithm by myself, to understand what is happening.</p> <p>My goal is to create a mapping as in this picture (taken from <a href="http://www.tristanfletcher.co.uk/SVM%20Explained.pdf" rel="nofollow" title="here">here</a>) <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/7yM2K.png" alt="Example mapping 2D --&gt; 3D"></p> <p>I do not fully understand what the input and output values of the kernel are; to map the data points to the 3rd dimension, the output should be the Z-values, right? And the input are (vectors of) the X and Y-values?</p> <p>My (matlab) code to get the z-values is:</p> <pre><code>z = exp(-( (abs(x-y).^2)./ (2*gamma^2) )); </code></pre> <p>But the z-values are just a bell-curve, us such: <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/69m6f.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I don't really know what I am doing wrong, but I think I confuse the concepts of kernel and (implicit/explicit) mapping.</p> <p>How can I construct a (matlab) function that maps the 2D data to 3D space, using the Gaussian Radial Basis Function?</p> <p>-- Edit -- Thanks to user27840 I made it work, with the following matlab code:</p> <pre><code>gamma = 2; D = squareform( pdist(data, 'euclidean') ); D = exp(-(D .^ 2) ./ ( 2*gamma^2)); z = sum(D); </code></pre> <p>This results in the following 3D plot, from original 2D data: <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/qQssQ.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>-- Edit2: -- For those who are interested in one-class support vector machines; I wrote a blog post about it, using the answer from this thread: <a href="http://rvlasveld.github.io/blog/2013/07/12/introduction-to-one-class-support-vector-machines/" rel="nofollow">Introduction to one-class Support Vector Machine</a></p>
73,513
[ -0.022595973685383797, -0.0012301651295274496, 0.009988415986299515, 0.0027268887497484684, 0.013646695762872696, -0.017517250031232834, -0.037503525614738464, -0.04306979477405548, 0.01752404309809208, -0.03943353891372681, 0.040761131793260574, -0.0023885290138423443, 0.06507300585508347, 0.03362014517188072, 0.019717946648597717, 0.002781408606097102, -0.0018611836712807417, -0.015654608607292175, -0.013343133963644505, -0.04186461493372917, 0.020386075600981712, 0.03288276493549347, -0.028760574758052826, -0.019098278135061264, -0.03438742086291313, 0.053362078964710236, 0.028859976679086685, -0.025017661973834038, 0.011859445832669735, 0.06074095144867897, -0.03753971680998802, -0.050028249621391296, 0.04276696592569351, 0.020947251468896866, 0.007118158973753452, 0.023091163486242294, -0.040581874549388885, -0.006448066793382168, 0.005434326361864805, 0.0463486984372139, -0.0066194976679980755, -0.02527640201151371, -0.00555421831086278, 0.08462122827768326, 0.010894227772951126, -0.011043081060051918, 0.009190608747303486, -0.008260139264166355, 0.016970641911029816, -0.030428318306803703, 0.07576654106378555, 0.01809769496321678, 0.013876705430448055, 0.002664259634912014, -0.010489086620509624, -0.004319396335631609, 0.03954150155186653, 0.03322979062795639, 0.024798978120088577, -0.04914328455924988, 0.005324969533830881, -0.009545749053359032, -0.020828887820243835, -0.05024179443717003, -0.014241395518183708, 0.015974942594766617, 0.012256807647645473, 0.009269057773053646, 0.006016820203512907, -0.05069933086633682, 0.02079668827354908, 0.024439522996544838, 0.014544601552188396, -0.03652980923652649, 0.0270135048776865, -0.013196808286011219, -0.014775709249079227, 0.004998077172785997, 0.026130225509405136, 0.004793170839548111, 0.015220323577523232, 0.003030851250514388, -0.00419794162735343, 0.02881540358066559, -0.01555462647229433, 0.020591111853718758, 0.05613549426198006, -0.020062146708369255, 0.012545828707516193, 0.028306951746344566, -0.010496010072529316, 0.026525093242526054, 0.024564335122704506, -0.012078492902219296, -0.029378389939665794, 0.030448632314801216, 0.015605413354933262, 0.05284835398197174, 0.027315765619277954, -0.02685004658997059, -0.0016582236858084798, -0.0034026645589619875, -0.022289423272013664, 0.04619115963578224, -0.05466332659125328, 0.011581861414015293, 0.026738496497273445, 0.018808431923389435, -0.0353398472070694, -0.06248416379094124, -0.03797905892133713, 0.028529664501547813, -0.01827014423906803, -0.003652760526165366, 0.05798590928316116, -0.028338292613625526, -0.025272803381085396, -0.013245281763374805, -0.009236248210072517, 0.03237046301364899, 0.020455582067370415, -0.0278465673327446, 0.0017546142917126417, -0.05286547169089317, -0.06482326239347458, 0.00818779319524765, 0.01980009861290455, 0.02501044049859047, -0.060756050050258636, 0.02905777469277382, 0.03081437014043331, -0.03766024485230446, 0.023388149216771126, -0.012930808588862419, 0.01620054803788662, -0.024406524375081062, -0.07108408212661743, -0.06327987462282181, 0.02136506512761116, -0.010472028516232967, 0.023344388231635094, -0.06886772811412811, -0.004523974843323231, 0.041060734540224075, 0.04645051807165146, -0.00019889901159331203, 0.035173848271369934, 0.04251207411289215, 0.061216484755277634, 0.0032228678464889526, -0.0051544602029025555, -0.016203388571739197, -0.03770313039422035, -0.024913519620895386, -0.015966936945915222, -0.012456037104129791, 0.026114068925380707, 0.0185644943267107, -0.014322399161756039, 0.008478128351271152, 0.033657900989055634, -0.00026197059196420014, 0.0017886013956740499, 0.01955384388566017, -0.02801695466041565, -0.004591240547597408, 0.05055578798055649, 0.016723355278372765, 0.029801402240991592, 0.03608185052871704, -0.06634306907653809, 0.02074030041694641, 0.013343851082026958, 0.02904275618493557, 0.06517912447452545, -0.024994470179080963, -0.02507677860558033, -0.05003945901989937, 0.02613636665046215, 0.043261125683784485, -0.04185321554541588, -0.06776749342679977, -0.013082281686365604, 0.011901033110916615, 0.03782830759882927, 0.045165594667196274, -0.0003274436458013952, -0.044143736362457275, 0.050411157310009, -0.05740710720419884, -0.027772581204771996, -0.02951941452920437, 0.02547096274793148, -0.004928376991301775, -0.030987568199634552, -0.024996493011713028, 0.024390390142798424, 0.02139449305832386, 0.01410987600684166, -0.03288550674915314, -0.027087492868304253, -0.012105072848498821, 0.06599155068397522, -0.02947627753019333, 0.012650885619223118, 0.033887334167957306, 0.06358939409255981, -0.03731739521026611, 0.025077447295188904, -0.018690647557377815, 0.025301160290837288, 0.003112363163381815, -0.006690991576761007, 0.005784709472209215, -0.014558752998709679, -0.02117171697318554, 0.008920153602957726, 0.009423327632248402, -0.02648802660405636, -0.017346274107694626, -0.06151871755719185, 0.05473216250538826, 0.07454708218574524, -0.009315099567174911, -0.011170860379934311, 0.02842738851904869, 0.007121192757040262, 0.05842481553554535, -0.009449087083339691, -0.014675479382276535, -0.0437331385910511, -0.02395760640501976, 0.016409896314144135, 0.06599586457014084, -0.05487065762281418, -0.01291501522064209, 0.0609530434012413, 0.0405573807656765, 0.01829569786787033, 0.04015343263745308, -0.016011623665690422, -0.0049504367634654045, 0.011783485300838947, -0.01162022352218628, -0.007730988785624504, 0.014835987240076065, 0.029771236702799797, -0.02027806267142296, -0.011386577971279621, 0.004480730276554823, -0.028803575783967972, 0.051127199083566666, -0.05261987820267677, -0.017005765810608864, -0.04321581497788429, 0.020405489951372147, 0.03563537821173668, -0.00643026502802968, -0.042860325425863266, 0.04900069907307625, 0.0054854825139045715, -0.00977361761033535, -0.026245154440402985, -0.0016143519897013903, 0.00873169582337141, 0.06516437977552414, -0.030076466500759125, 0.012819789350032806, 0.00521460734307766, -0.0335652194917202, 0.010069851763546467, -0.0004410190158523619, -0.02872556261718273, -0.048885852098464966, 0.0036732633598148823, 0.019528336822986603, 0.02213352918624878, -0.016771122813224792, -0.05376836284995079, -0.05723676458001137, -0.030418509617447853, 0.02957407757639885, 0.04045930132269859, 0.03297710046172142, -0.0734565258026123, 0.016908027231693268, -0.021986374631524086, -0.003403410781174898, 0.03418603539466858, 0.008484728634357452, -0.003920396789908409, 0.005114663392305374, -0.013602127321064472, -0.025006406009197235, -0.006949251517653465, -0.05379452928900719, 0.02122391387820244, -0.014444023370742798, 0.01142917200922966, 0.048582665622234344, 0.004076563753187656, -0.04155051335692406, 0.0525888130068779, -0.04852869361639023, -0.04332578182220459, -0.03303859010338783, -0.010239584371447563, 0.004250928293913603, -0.01789006032049656, 0.02319476567208767, 0.010856579057872295, -0.032440435141325, 0.05024842172861099, -0.052151113748550415, -0.04860490560531616, 0.013845806010067463, 0.007422127760946751, -0.020179640501737595, 0.013207966461777687, -0.009775392711162567, 0.08119238913059235, 0.0012711543822661042, -0.04228055104613304, -0.0581069216132164, 0.021299978718161583, -0.027643349021673203, 0.01007102057337761, 0.033618174493312836, 0.012174119241535664, 0.009113658219575882, 0.03723060339689255, -0.03552502393722534, -0.005234415642917156, 0.06399929523468018, -0.018541336059570312, -0.006417044438421726, 0.04836874082684517, 0.0030624628998339176, -0.033925190567970276, 0.06131825968623161, 0.03284425288438797, -0.02783399075269699, 0.012121163308620453, 0.016314314678311348, -0.03321535140275955, -0.0227978378534317, -0.05039886012673378, -0.0070092990063130856, -0.007152259815484285, 0.025626877322793007, -0.02156946249306202, 0.013407791964709759, 0.02172001823782921, -0.06186734512448311, 0.0030510323122143745, 0.01685546711087227, 0.07182109355926514, -0.009388420730829239, 0.013058505021035671, 0.03992803767323494, 0.019393358379602432, -0.021187208592891693, 0.019222859293222427, 0.013052036054432392, 0.0019905585795640945, 0.03337247669696808, -0.003761954139918089, -0.019279515370726585, 0.06055590510368347, 0.04299674928188324, -0.02190777286887169, 0.00841604359447956, -0.016693413257598877, 0.01669986918568611, -0.03823813423514366, -0.03284040465950966, -0.026042349636554718, 0.048246871680021286, 0.0006011253572069108, 0.07663916796445847, 0.037385955452919006, 0.00001818572673073504, 0.030369123443961143, -0.015208159573376179, -0.038411661982536316, -0.009090227074921131, -0.00929304864257574, 0.009385482408106327, 0.005320203024893999, -0.05445684865117073, 0.04625692963600159, -0.019733916968107224, 0.016256263479590416, 0.013196258805692196, -0.007111074402928352, -0.07566352933645248, 0.020518833771348, 0.0068235923536121845, 0.01319196168333292, -0.027929197996854782, 0.031614597886800766, 0.02780095860362053, -0.013226952403783798, -0.014727194793522358, 0.03492259979248047, -0.03425116091966629, 0.0277695432305336, -0.02498549595475197, 0.017204275354743004, 0.03006921336054802, 0.04961097240447998, -0.011670020408928394, 0.02857949584722519, -0.016629718244075775, -0.0033561927266418934, -0.009162748232483864, 0.027347708120942116, 0.04905352368950844, 0.0016818938311189413, 0.013764223083853722, -0.044375624507665634, -0.0037425123155117035, 0.006421411409974098, 0.03712654858827591, -0.0006586526869796216, 0.04396187141537666, 0.020700186491012573, 0.000857568986248225, -0.04876940697431564, -0.02484406903386116, 0.0726388618350029, -0.015460786409676075, 0.005268906708806753, -0.06884882599115372, -0.02270263060927391, -0.034915491938591, -0.04474068805575371, 0.05048292130231857, -0.006658730562776327, -0.06582029908895493, -0.011871342547237873, 0.0503530278801918, -0.027195468544960022, 0.0033163863699883223, -0.027001764625310898, 0.0380626879632473, 0.03907670080661774, 0.013975238427519798, -0.03868500888347626, -0.015597788617014885, 0.0421665757894516, 0.06312429904937744, 0.02785136178135872, -0.03402736037969589, -0.06053675338625908, -0.022515393793582916, 0.04387565329670906, 0.028338495641946793, 0.009456480853259563, -0.012119892053306103, -0.057962995022535324, -0.025290025398135185, 0.007943631149828434, -0.014109077863395214, 0.01588382013142109, -0.04016086831688881, -0.011893920600414276, -0.04815136268734932, -0.033563852310180664, -0.05334625393152237, -0.004842809401452541, -0.03297906741499901, 0.020356716588139534, -0.060100819915533066, -0.051331475377082825, -0.0447084903717041, 0.01686169020831585, 0.007606123108416796, 0.04590781778097153, -0.013682650402188301, -0.032450344413518906, 0.010143685154616833, 0.020741552114486694, 0.005063078366219997, -0.04032663255929947, 0.012907245196402073, 0.03117574378848076, 0.012563466094434261, 0.08281631767749786, -0.0025716328527778387, -0.030757645145058632, 0.012013076804578304, -0.0008645529160276055, 0.010639549233019352, 0.02944612316787243, -0.016130277886986732, 0.02762853167951107, 0.04864628240466118, -0.0007632686174474657, 0.05979853868484497, 0.048494793474674225, -0.043856117874383926, -0.0047677853144705296, -0.07248431444168091, 0.007682848256081343, 0.0028154822066426277, -0.0070956707932055, -0.035492219030857086, 0.007815402001142502, 0.01696380041539669, 0.011265719309449196, 0.020697860047221184, 0.025136886164546013, -0.05291048809885979, 0.024128703400492668, 0.025142036378383636, 0.0267585888504982, -0.037328481674194336, -0.006602886598557234, -0.04370436072349548, 0.026442255824804306, -0.009952017106115818, -0.02424631454050541, -0.009420769289135933, 0.007032822817564011, -0.008319618180394173, 0.02990773692727089, -0.056410882622003555, -0.0032824603840708733, 0.011301487684249878, -0.013296455144882202, 0.011269180104136467, -0.06877529621124268, 0.01755966804921627, -0.023157162591814995, 0.01782320812344551, 0.045602262020111084, -0.03824431076645851, -0.006016694940626621, -0.03792354837059975, 0.02976944111287594, 0.031442128121852875, -0.02795865200459957, 0.0006216243491508067, 0.025921359658241272, 0.004513738676905632, -0.04989384859800339, -0.048409342765808105, 0.02103768289089203, -0.06523899734020233, -0.01721506379544735, -0.05196525529026985, 0.009009589441120625, 0.001829081797040999, -0.027584105730056763, 0.015166600234806538, 0.05017971619963646, -0.03938235342502594, 0.029266081750392914, 0.026640307158231735, -0.006289579439908266, 0.05755995586514473, -0.0342043861746788, -0.010007043369114399, 0.018446508795022964, 0.011031650938093662, -0.027033373713493347, 0.022744998335838318, 0.015477395616471767, 0.0007814783020876348, -0.0011655159760266542, -0.027547666803002357, 0.019827863201498985, 0.036123715341091156, 0.006968565285205841, -0.033636510372161865, -0.013941716402769089, -0.0023383796215057373, -0.009319302625954151, -0.03811071813106537, -0.019856732338666916, -0.025510253384709358, -0.012237383984029293, -0.009204307571053505, -0.03370250388979912, -0.05972636118531227, -0.006005952600389719, 0.024509372189641, -0.001175472280010581, -0.00942765362560749, 0.010372176766395569, 0.05214720591902733, 0.008527817204594612, 0.022839264944195747, -0.03673790767788887, 0.013624811545014381, 0.03636474534869194, -0.005289576482027769, 0.02032860554754734, 0.0140160471200943, 0.03157071769237518, -0.02411336451768875, 0.018503915518522263, -0.0962795689702034, 0.0007465570815838873, 0.09937793016433716, -0.008412777446210384, 0.06926825642585754, 0.010968814603984356, 0.00970309879630804, 0.013005740940570831, -0.03803890570998192, 0.003451490541920066, 0.01664431393146515, -0.03825550898909569, 0.02881660684943199, -0.007654908578842878, 0.023861631751060486, 0.012135048396885395, 0.02181733213365078, -0.0022755577228963375, 0.022611739113926888, -0.007255225908011198, 0.003037788672372699, -0.008188708685338497, -0.03840487450361252, -0.024416441097855568, 0.032353587448596954, -0.003001514123752713, 0.020170217379927635, 0.018118841573596, 0.008267174474895, 0.03779350966215134, 0.021766753867268562, -0.014874238520860672, -0.04398341104388237, 0.009241780266165733, -0.028772523626685143, 0.010618535801768303, 0.03598305210471153, -0.030543440952897072, 0.008900967426598072, 0.031040888279676437, 0.03976919502019882, -0.0052888356149196625, 0.006351171992719173, -0.02769351191818714, -0.03251097723841667, 0.00706568593159318, -0.061006102710962296, -0.021294180303812027, 0.03559619188308716, 0.02350601553916931, -0.044135529547929764, -0.01149808056652546, -0.026582976803183556, 0.05527426302433014, 0.006900011096149683, 0.047349896281957626, -0.008844047784805298, 0.05720290541648865, -0.015556123107671738, 0.0051624830812215805, -0.029076209291815758, -0.001327845617197454, 0.11614329367876053, 0.04052705317735672, -0.004234432242810726, -0.062679722905159, 0.0005693841958418489, 0.015111112967133522, -0.009622136130928993, -0.017967592924833298, 0.0012361466651782393, -0.010862664319574833, -0.025615816935896873, 0.016041789203882217, 0.02456951141357422, 0.03205142542719841, -0.013662928715348244, 0.023084023967385292, -0.03193240985274315, -0.01964648999273777, -0.018466604873538017, 0.013885770924389362, -0.010033701546490192, -0.005742853973060846, -0.05836376175284386, 0.04392588883638382, -0.025290608406066895, -0.0393439345061779, -0.05157330259680748, -0.010970013216137886, 0.01740902103483677, -0.021958520635962486, -0.015770135447382927, -0.0031671368051320314, 0.012586683966219425, 0.00047076537157408893, -0.008165191859006882, 0.029054544866085052, 0.014269145205616951, 0.0013685114681720734, 0.03144805505871773, 0.01797536201775074, 0.011895721778273582, 0.018370091915130615, -0.019976694136857986, -0.02156318537890911, -0.03852757439017296, -0.025298332795500755, -0.036561835557222366, 0.08667661249637604, -0.0016100177308544517, -0.045756127685308456, 0.018964940682053566, 0.028802789747714996, 0.006252948194742203, -0.061257120221853256, 0.019739767536520958, -0.025441627949476242, 0.00430946983397007, -0.00034481575130485, -0.011006114073097706, -0.003976756241172552, 0.024486063048243523, -0.010790590196847916, 0.0565742626786232, 0.010043094865977764, -0.02690485678613186, 0.006541390437632799, -0.05457295477390289, 0.06421589851379395, -0.04132448509335518, -0.03363621234893799, 0.025473183020949364, -0.03647463023662567, 0.014332485385239124, -0.012828024104237556, 0.0218681488186121, -0.03572656214237213, 0.024107325822114944, -0.009845775552093983, -0.017887063324451447, -0.011426047421991825, -0.0417710542678833, -0.006661314982920885, -0.021374806761741638, 0.013013606891036034, -0.018641924485564232, 0.013763501308858395, 0.038222525268793106, 0.027074100449681282, 0.01870076358318329, 0.024509645998477936, -0.01240561529994011, 0.018361559137701988, 0.008475578390061855, -0.02332373708486557, -0.018143080174922943, 0.030643878504633904, -0.01641516014933586, 0.023156309500336647, -0.03555833548307419, 0.022140158340334892, 0.04970773681998253, 0.044780295342206955, 0.007682951167225838, 0.05592173710465431, -0.0261694248765707, -0.02880355715751648, -0.030789436772465706, -0.028860505670309067, 0.016553714871406555, -0.009632742032408714, -0.0026829992420971394, -0.0249689519405365, 0.02092108689248562, -0.02677265554666519, -0.028112176805734634, -0.03329240158200264, -0.005465431604534388, -0.01866910047829151, -0.029921431094408035, 0.0016940465429797769, 0.009443930350244045, -0.002797194989398122, 0.001741198357194662, -0.0029439786449074745, 0.032927799969911575, -0.03275911882519722, 0.0072033219039440155, -0.01911117136478424, 0.0071891057305037975, 0.005380839109420776, 0.027597889304161072, 0.04831467196345329, 0.0367383137345314, 0.00032328409724868834, 0.008664186112582684, 0.03719746693968773, -0.029884830117225647, 0.035815153270959854, 0.02444394864141941, -0.0047907899133861065, 0.0024764244444668293, -0.04491138458251953, -0.01787758804857731, 0.03306415677070618, -0.04231933131814003, 0.005652053281664848, -0.00412849010899663, 0.007968040183186531, -0.02342638559639454, 0.02777988836169243, 0.025592675432562828, 0.010289231315255165, -0.003761610947549343, -0.014006080105900764, -0.00351103488355875, 0.01979442499577999, 0.03275632485747337, -0.03059939481317997, -0.005074135027825832, -0.011396423913538456, 0.024546116590499878, -0.013720189221203327, 0.017356200143694878, 0.02468685247004032, -0.03163893520832062, -0.0012242414522916079, 0.011776397004723549, -0.02029675804078579, 0.11562754958868027, 0.06256628036499023, -0.017355751246213913, 0.026877790689468384, -0.020969456061720848, 0.018429558724164963, -0.12078921496868134, -0.01379661075770855, 0.008538410067558289, -0.0011041645193472505, 0.03700957074761391, -0.06947564333677292, 0.016573822125792503, 0.0022953308653086424, -0.06592719256877899, 0.04978621006011963, 0.012775746174156666, -0.015466333366930485, 0.0058556245639920235, 0.015171615406870842, -0.01177793275564909, 0.026318183168768883, 0.022496649995446205, 0.04534612596035004, 0.03757766634225845, 0.01756848581135273, -0.047579120844602585, 0.023347659036517143, -0.04970131069421768, 0.028089044615626335, 0.002928871428593993, -0.02478548139333725, 0.03063143603503704, -0.011601587757468224, -0.003164601279422641, 0.0020423380192369223, -0.00328393024392426, -0.007374310400336981, 0.03186739608645439, 0.03587184101343155, 0.017694884911179543, 0.037021517753601074, 0.04518825188279152, -0.0035824361257255077, -0.016181321814656258, -0.02541695348918438, 0.044923264533281326, -0.005614087916910648, -0.014779606834053993, 0.020228097215294838, 0.01616388000547886, 0.01191564928740263, -0.04072881489992142, 0.02071972005069256, -0.011799784377217293, 0.0035979682579636574, -0.014986937865614891, 0.008426399901509285, 0.006386180873960257, -0.05217016488313675, 0.000541055400390178, -0.04429774358868599, 0.0032436635810881853, 0.022242074832320213, 0.01152525283396244, 0.003164703492075205, -0.003517052624374628, -0.020391318947076797, -0.06141086295247078, 0.006868928205221891, -0.0037209384609013796, -0.0004585025308188051, -0.024449743330478668, -0.0098252072930336, 0.024585099890828133, -0.01649904064834118, 0.01756279729306698, -0.004233621060848236, -0.04430640861392021, 0.04718644544482231, 0.010995058342814445, 0.015967998653650284, 0.0018655051244422793, -0.025731725618243217, 0.015768075361847878, -0.11066243797540665, 0.046465396881103516, 0.0017475092317909002, -0.05153986066579819, -0.00414599385112524, 0.018904974684119225, 0.005629940424114466, 0.015930838882923126, 0.03740913048386574, -0.025053149089217186, 0.004937360528856516, -0.0048444983549416065, 0.024192962795495987, 0.053117427974939346, -0.047824960201978683, 0.023754185065627098, -0.003942988812923431, -0.022639431059360504, -0.008582158014178276, 0.012743943370878696, -0.02995694801211357, 0.05404305458068848, 0.019061388447880745, 0.012049270793795586, 0.008540225215256214, -0.022551169618964195, -0.03413920849561691, -0.002847363706678152, 0.024583064019680023, -0.03946881368756294, 0.05413823574781418, -0.006282984744757414, -0.002524274168536067, 0.034743182361125946, 0.010759262368083, -0.04628004878759384, -0.004683998879045248, 0.007067738566547632, 0.003930267412215471, 0.010457498021423817, 0.006447980646044016, 0.036166250705718994, -0.07508165389299393, -0.007606401573866606, 0.04202514514327049, -0.030449699610471725, -0.002800161251798272, 0.05374952405691147, 0.007778868544846773, 0.011721435934305191, -0.000013386494174483232, 0.0409514456987381, -0.01567581668496132, -0.039687853306531906, 0.02709333598613739, 0.016283240169286728, -0.0006052388343960047, 0.008769549429416656, -0.014295783825218678, 0.03694270923733711, -0.019927645102143288, 0.009983665309846401, 0.007959164679050446, 0.03326781094074249, -0.040256254374980927, 0.023755185306072235, -0.000842428533360362, 0.011916672810912132, -0.030752340331673622, 0.004185496363788843, 0.001549288397654891, 0.07761494815349579, -0.03262462839484215, 0.0030403262935578823, -0.0126120550557971, 0.0032091301400214434, -0.045433271676301956, 0.046036090701818466, 0.02649686671793461, 0.05923852697014809, 0.0035344513598829508, 0.016035746783018112, -0.02189546823501587, 0.007582520134747028, 0.008970910683274269, 0.013481087982654572, 0.029797498136758804, 0.013338579796254635, 0.0038476851768791676, 0.06783480197191238, 0.006240603514015675, -0.02888558804988861, -0.02241051197052002, 0.053879205137491226, 0.027452733367681503, -0.016118124127388, -0.007938532158732414, 0.01045533549040556, -0.025746794417500496, 0.005697228480130434, -0.061842381954193115, -0.02510973997414112, -0.007521710358560085, 0.001664305804297328, 0.013652188703417778, 0.01773485355079174 ]
<p>Suppose that one runs 8 correlation analyses but in two separate batches: Would the alpha-correction apply to all 8 tests as a family or each of the 4 tests as a family?</p> <p>For example, if there are two research questions and both require correlation analysis, the researcher conducts the first 4 tests (for research question 1) and then conducts the second 4 tests (for research question 2). In this case, should the alpha be corrected for a family of 4 tests or for a family of 8 tests? (Note that the same statistical test--Pearson's $r$--is used in both cases.)</p> <p>I understand there isn't a consensus on this matter (as with many other matters in statistics as I am learning fast!) but some broad guidelines would be most helpful.</p>
35,908
[ -0.05392216145992279, 0.006169779691845179, 0.002699481323361397, 0.026218583807349205, 0.020499978214502335, 0.0415908508002758, -0.0047261882573366165, -0.020119179040193558, 0.027962766587734222, 0.0017372681759297848, 0.03559732437133789, 0.01911011151969433, 0.0318172313272953, 0.014275075867772102, 0.01922539435327053, 0.013524279929697514, -0.0326753705739975, 0.015602289699018002, 0.010335121303796768, -0.008736892603337765, -0.006558054126799107, 0.015494514256715775, -0.0023037088103592396, 0.001039814786054194, -0.022912833839654922, 0.05097862333059311, -0.000562584784347564, -0.029129276052117348, 0.038847289979457855, 0.002746392274275422, -0.05204818770289421, -0.027026481926441193, 0.0378417894244194, 0.063328817486763, 0.008294427767395973, -0.025139834731817245, 0.0006191044813022017, -0.018505433574318886, 0.0003896705457009375, 0.05784793198108673, -0.07870692759752274, -0.03979599475860596, 0.017809869721531868, 0.006245116237550974, 0.006386434659361839, -0.00202568038366735, 0.012160730548202991, -0.016203567385673523, 0.026980461552739143, -0.032670821994543076, 0.08510363847017288, -0.03844243288040161, 0.001546084531582892, 0.06051744893193245, -0.014686906710267067, -0.004902354441583157, 0.03851405903697014, 0.022705843672156334, -0.01179009210318327, -0.028745178133249283, -0.027756154537200928, -0.0047266012988984585, 0.0063615404069423676, 0.027710989117622375, -0.04379815608263016, 0.04031091555953026, 0.008517400361597538, -0.00597043102607131, 0.036693260073661804, 0.0038370219990611076, 0.02231765165925026, 0.02055932767689228, 0.0764782577753067, -0.018363308161497116, 0.02977597527205944, -0.007903561927378178, -0.017032548785209656, 0.028082039207220078, 0.02508292905986309, 0.048384442925453186, -0.01415230706334114, 0.01900337263941765, 0.0514867939054966, 0.042660556733608246, 0.01448109932243824, -0.03451550379395485, 0.05318034812808037, -0.039027828723192215, 0.003260108409449458, 0.018851183354854584, -0.004229387734085321, 0.002014723140746355, 0.04900494962930679, 0.02943597547709942, -0.028013860806822777, 0.032793182879686356, -0.026648469269275665, 0.04337897151708603, -0.014017882756888866, -0.0010382219916209579, 0.014391476288437843, -0.031195925548672676, -0.005157446023076773, 0.06884922087192535, -0.02753145433962345, 0.0034545566886663437, -0.04959961399435997, 0.014534627087414265, -0.0227811336517334, -0.03103465959429741, -0.017801038920879364, 0.02141503617167473, -0.0172130037099123, 0.013486574403941631, 0.05069467052817345, -0.013665405102074146, 0.02029320038855076, 0.04206571727991104, 0.09167282283306122, 0.061845652759075165, 0.054343048483133316, -0.04770816117525101, 0.013740499503910542, 0.032736025750637054, -0.03380129113793373, 0.030014751479029655, 0.0035469091963022947, -0.046978846192359924, -0.0030475270468741655, 0.03253941237926483, 0.030638543888926506, -0.050014428794384, -0.002558672334998846, -0.0012987757800146937, 0.02611270546913147, 0.02733638510107994, -0.0636579841375351, -0.06015486270189285, 0.039746448397636414, 0.02271689474582672, -0.0022657825611531734, -0.06074603646993637, -0.0011145730968564749, 0.01580675132572651, 0.04425656795501709, -0.02379632741212845, 0.02997584640979767, 0.03080066479742527, 0.03273658826947212, 0.03422394022345543, -0.010642241686582565, -0.012706862762570381, -0.024363920092582703, -0.048873018473386765, -0.007223896682262421, -0.07741734385490417, 0.03339359164237976, 0.0025145765393972397, 0.007885840721428394, 0.028659893199801445, 0.045097414404153824, 0.010421374812722206, -0.0027190125547349453, 0.005106429103761911, 0.06317850202322006, 0.011703678406774998, 0.02362285926938057, -0.014012068510055542, 0.044183697551488876, 0.0005894491332583129, -0.013589432463049889, 0.033342596143484116, -0.02200646884739399, 0.03003530390560627, 0.01159866526722908, -0.004247921984642744, -0.008781024254858494, -0.026554295793175697, 0.03296559303998947, 0.00005778327977168374, 0.0007869883556850255, -0.02894594706594944, -0.010327031835913658, -0.00020024859986733645, 0.04749425873160362, 0.050514381378889084, -0.012396540492773056, -0.06572139263153076, 0.03393951803445816, -0.04224801063537598, -0.031075501814484596, -0.07100442051887512, 0.022046424448490143, -0.040230587124824524, -0.050914935767650604, 0.0475885309278965, -0.013161072507500648, 0.025308266282081604, -0.01310638152062893, -0.017849532887339592, -0.0355660542845726, 0.007745460141450167, 0.028076985850930214, -0.03951697424054146, 0.015035739168524742, 0.036453478038311005, 0.04067153111100197, -0.012691814452409744, 0.045273974537849426, -0.04637226462364197, -0.047972336411476135, 0.04618852958083153, -0.0032662153244018555, 0.03951605409383774, -0.025521153584122658, -0.016836028546094894, -0.035663921386003494, 0.017050186172127724, -0.01682695373892784, 0.034843187779188156, -0.054866570979356766, 0.0680287629365921, 0.04855707287788391, -0.015094814822077751, 0.02374177798628807, -0.002743388758972287, 0.005111820995807648, 0.015158422291278839, -0.052340712398290634, -0.02247733622789383, -0.056766584515571594, -0.02380688488483429, 0.03885961323976517, -0.012441294267773628, -0.048372533172369, -0.009367172606289387, 0.08008398115634918, 0.054084159433841705, -0.0041023981757462025, 0.0010727675398811698, 0.010489116422832012, -0.014854032546281815, -0.004040821455419064, 0.03338656201958656, 0.004567714873701334, 0.013809455558657646, 0.003281877376139164, -0.02396717667579651, 0.047324441373348236, 0.004268101882189512, -0.013427145779132843, 0.031010227277874947, -0.01681199111044407, 0.0267740897834301, -0.03509463742375374, -0.02594129741191864, 0.03348261117935181, -0.020000876858830452, 0.04074231535196304, 0.04384465888142586, 0.010796235874295235, 0.010661236010491848, 0.028716200962662697, -0.006288046017289162, 0.029453502967953682, 0.01221468299627304, -0.019381681457161903, -0.03573029860854149, -0.00234796479344368, -0.020811239257454872, 0.0045052701607346535, -0.05834202840924263, -0.01435286458581686, 0.013534098863601685, 0.04606896638870239, 0.022795245051383972, -0.01832653395831585, 0.041487716138362885, -0.06253498792648315, -0.02190995402634144, -0.007708144839853048, -0.013432799838483334, 0.027904298156499863, -0.026272078976035118, -0.07505711168050766, -0.01716320402920246, -0.052318502217531204, 0.001623236807063222, 0.06960558146238327, -0.008548391982913017, -0.01960788667201996, 0.02404574677348137, 0.025491230189800262, -0.041661351919174194, -0.028066426515579224, -0.012478803284466267, -0.015251602977514267, -0.011148347519338131, -0.016655948013067245, 0.03465377166867256, 0.012906226329505444, -0.037600573152303696, -0.01325272861868143, -0.05238383635878563, -0.008022594265639782, 0.015943612903356552, -0.037521712481975555, 0.024310367181897163, 0.007206016685813665, 0.024575939401984215, 0.01815459504723549, -0.054194819182157516, -0.026848813518881798, -0.011858250945806503, -0.0742259994149208, 0.02671174518764019, -0.011615565977990627, 0.04633164405822754, 0.01478628907352686, -0.02866910584270954, 0.05667829141020775, 0.003959048073738813, 0.008414722047746181, 0.0018532790709286928, -0.012677093036472797, -0.017953088507056236, -0.01482964027673006, 0.030951855704188347, 0.010516878217458725, 0.047945745289325714, 0.017369041219353676, 0.008648994378745556, 0.05084150284528732, 0.04779642075300217, 0.0009799384279176593, -0.011027528904378414, 0.027721868827939034, 0.03151320293545723, -0.02948184311389923, 0.014339057728648186, 0.027367018163204193, -0.016817044466733932, -0.016137130558490753, -0.012503369711339474, 0.012217734009027481, -0.009266473352909088, -0.03963680565357208, 0.00011037965305149555, -0.002476657507941127, -0.015215035527944565, -0.0337003730237484, -0.0029483847320079803, 0.04711352661252022, -0.03478321433067322, -0.03714074194431305, 0.011708082631230354, 0.020805617794394493, -0.013866057619452477, 0.019530313089489937, 0.02248765155673027, 0.015098147094249725, -0.0301720779389143, -0.022439567372202873, -0.017942683771252632, -0.03685599938035011, 0.03462911769747734, -0.0251090656965971, -0.04331190884113312, 0.02392679452896118, 0.004563933238387108, 0.011034434661269188, -0.021090781316161156, -0.0687059685587883, 0.01831437088549137, -0.04943256452679634, -0.0020058027002960443, -0.0531495064496994, 0.005220688413828611, -0.014638897031545639, 0.05883220210671425, 0.021036310121417046, -0.0138960937038064, 0.025243086740374565, 0.025954648852348328, -0.03845066949725151, -0.005647965241223574, -0.030612241476774216, -0.007656600791960955, 0.004106891807168722, -0.024163104593753815, 0.03592099994421005, -0.0248715877532959, 0.008204461075365543, -0.0017129778861999512, 0.008587765507400036, -0.002532406011596322, 0.016892554238438606, -0.03694615140557289, -0.012968920171260834, 0.014224953018128872, 0.02889195643365383, 0.0036078488919883966, -0.009572943672537804, 0.03895439952611923, 0.0013599121011793613, 0.01052076369524002, 0.01944567821919918, -0.02836601622402668, 0.00554201565682888, 0.014524073339998722, 0.03546561300754547, 0.027676424011588097, -0.0018354076892137527, -0.03766482695937157, 0.02668505162000656, 0.02923007868230343, 0.013854686170816422, 0.03003358468413353, -0.0611383318901062, 0.00940734427422285, -0.030696656554937363, -0.007559506222605705, -0.00987098179757595, 0.02277352660894394, 0.0475260429084301, 0.015088463202118874, 0.008864426985383034, 0.020559245720505714, -0.04018925130367279, 0.022891467437148094, 0.06430098414421082, 0.012031901627779007, -0.017629479989409447, -0.046369925141334534, 0.004018018953502178, -0.014475717209279537, 0.007669137790799141, 0.007653181441128254, 0.029219243675470352, -0.041897211223840714, 0.018244491890072823, 0.013052013702690601, -0.01160300150513649, -0.04904816672205925, 0.025036845356225967, 0.0016422244952991605, 0.01808396354317665, -0.0006893436657264829, -0.04938055947422981, 0.027270173653960228, 0.06723730266094208, 0.018932964652776718, 0.02638874761760235, 0.002521952148526907, -0.04580550640821457, 0.028327029198408127, 0.03765452280640602, 0.04143818840384483, -0.03732798993587494, 0.023477725684642792, 0.00028991614817641675, -0.021868690848350525, 0.042244214564561844, -0.026872744783759117, 0.05288434028625488, -0.0036357594653964043, 0.03169672191143036, -0.003937221132218838, -0.032240308821201324, -0.06337049603462219, 0.006731841247528791, 0.018482588231563568, 0.002733553061261773, 0.022846199572086334, 0.02631821110844612, -0.028314152732491493, -0.009124296717345715, 0.030368685722351074, 0.05125570669770241, -0.01310809701681137, -0.02243415080010891, -0.0057705300860106945, 0.0005866935825906694, -0.03064531460404396, -0.015186438336968422, 0.007378615904599428, -0.016997523605823517, -0.002935445634648204, 0.05092250928282738, -0.03720429912209511, -0.0421612486243248, 0.013283480890095234, 0.039773911237716675, -0.025188319385051727, -0.023121099919080734, -0.015085809864103794, 0.05164676159620285, 0.04679697006940842, 0.011288557201623917, 0.07129762321710587, 0.019259372726082802, -0.021652335301041603, -0.013346332125365734, -0.0249007735401392, -0.00637235539034009, -0.047441501170396805, -0.014194195158779621, -0.010418863967061043, -0.011822600848972797, -0.030047055333852768, 0.02684694342315197, -0.03330255299806595, 0.03081805258989334, -0.024647513404488564, -0.003472930518910289, 0.009663846343755722, 0.02506551519036293, -0.034479208290576935, 0.014337860979139805, -0.00012755575880873948, 0.021161887794733047, -0.0047937845811247826, -0.03215436264872551, 0.0187587421387434, -0.017033668234944344, 0.003101097187027335, 0.02688061073422432, -0.059329912066459656, 0.021582292392849922, -0.030192675068974495, -0.014131251722574234, 0.020152060315012932, -0.019015302881598473, 0.0306398943066597, 0.03240033611655235, 0.02350080944597721, -0.027749305590987206, -0.0436943955719471, 0.00787156168371439, 0.026225730776786804, -0.04365861415863037, 0.057917624711990356, -0.027650674805045128, 0.027830300852656364, -0.02920517325401306, -0.01722807250916958, -0.07487352937459946, -0.05204425007104874, 0.0022214145865291357, 0.008685652166604996, -0.007209883537143469, -0.02014140412211418, 0.016070352867245674, -0.0043689655140042305, -0.00778827304020524, -0.018211672082543373, 0.10736267268657684, -0.02541847713291645, -0.02066754177212715, -0.03464629873633385, 0.027089964598417282, 0.0880131870508194, 0.011065413244068623, -0.02899973839521408, 0.006825364660471678, -0.05687420070171356, 0.015727948397397995, -0.004692429676651955, -0.023288005962967873, -0.04504362866282463, 0.016939101740717888, -0.029904386028647423, 0.007640753407031298, 0.04049071669578552, 0.00609482079744339, -0.023625696077942848, -0.0025105024687945843, 0.01025301218032837, -0.00587786640971899, -0.028347330167889595, 0.019939780235290527, -0.03524729236960411, -0.009302151389420033, -0.005080177914351225, -0.006235852371901274, -0.007141340058296919, 0.013136791065335274, 0.025197772309184074, 0.0035408507101237774, -0.054944347590208054, 0.057308442890644073, 0.08708364516496658, -0.000955732655711472, 0.00023865191906224936, -0.022360648959875107, -0.019491732120513916, 0.007036533206701279, 0.006179946940392256, -0.00015660180361010134, -0.02275855280458927, 0.004249710123986006, -0.019708815962076187, -0.02955298312008381, 0.00751103600487113, -0.006095257122069597, 0.07703456282615662, -0.020968563854694366, 0.021248970180749893, 0.07269719243049622, 0.03173601254820824, 0.015061134472489357, -0.03986994922161102, 0.02762734144926071, -0.00945404451340437, -0.010637492872774601, 0.060496892780065536, -0.015245716087520123, -0.023456815630197525, -0.004766474943608046, 0.015126344747841358, 0.008577913045883179, -0.013956082053482533, 0.023192647844552994, 0.047456711530685425, -0.03982874006032944, -0.01932382397353649, -0.04806964099407196, 0.030064227059483528, -0.055706001818180084, -0.015247362665832043, -0.0072671095840632915, -0.021893968805670738, 0.05473273620009422, 0.04640059545636177, 0.03658575564622879, -0.0668056309223175, -0.022609196603298187, -0.011282837018370628, 0.007571337278932333, -0.021904269233345985, 0.02216004766523838, 0.0012834809022024274, -0.006923017557710409, 0.03352869302034378, -0.034366875886917114, 0.04657105356454849, -0.02689380571246147, -0.06225298345088959, -0.05431041121482849, -0.021464653313159943, -0.03194856643676758, 0.05101270601153374, -0.007106680888682604, -0.03894082456827164, -0.003923627082258463, -0.02532665617763996, 0.03797755762934685, 0.03635258600115776, 0.046141620725393295, -0.016267776489257812, 0.04918256029486656, 0.003989511635154486, 0.011025841347873211, 0.01749606803059578, -0.024343863129615784, 0.08187167346477509, 0.10705938935279846, 0.026735059916973114, -0.05343518778681755, 0.02802211605012417, -0.025652293115854263, 0.008199757896363735, -0.03733493387699127, 0.0074392566457390785, 0.01448874082416296, -0.04177619516849518, 0.03530187904834747, 0.09003401547670364, 0.0007771667442284524, 0.009217767976224422, 0.09873297810554504, -0.025772498920559883, -0.019406339153647423, -0.028023097664117813, 0.024101024493575096, 0.012528778053820133, 0.0182095468044281, -0.013904993422329426, -0.03061443753540516, 0.011900002136826515, 0.00800109189003706, -0.05603190138936043, 0.004524738993495703, 0.004405112937092781, -0.010498439893126488, -0.010216323658823967, -0.025440795347094536, 0.011530249379575253, -0.004114301409572363, -0.03686806559562683, -0.04791947826743126, 0.01858627423644066, -0.07246546447277069, 0.033108312636613846, 0.024771029129624367, -0.035436369478702545, -0.009755066595971584, 0.038190606981515884, 0.012719989754259586, -0.035212431102991104, -0.012233377434313297, -0.010771358385682106, 0.022407550364732742, -0.013396842405200005, -0.011259237304329872, -0.002737879054620862, -0.014830906875431538, -0.02076604776084423, -0.0711621642112732, -0.04171928018331528, 0.03568436950445175, -0.007369303144514561, -0.008682147599756718, -0.017669040709733963, -0.025635873898863792, 0.0348585806787014, 0.0010517999762669206, 0.03826941177248955, 0.023345284163951874, -0.03489692136645317, -0.005618581548333168, -0.019299915060400963, 0.02783496305346489, 0.02127082832157612, -0.008533465676009655, -0.004564421251416206, 0.0403636172413826, -0.043467696756124496, 0.051174625754356384, 0.020866110920906067, 0.03209923952817917, 0.06010301038622856, -0.02270440384745598, -0.010631952434778214, 0.0034762530121952295, -0.03319171443581581, -0.021749958395957947, -0.022445522248744965, -0.011860530823469162, -0.044003844261169434, -0.006267399061471224, 0.053245123475790024, 0.04653095826506615, -0.016971489414572716, 0.03614126145839691, -0.014861185103654861, 0.05664164945483208, 0.0481015183031559, -0.040668368339538574, -0.009624543599784374, -0.02441592700779438, -0.038475919514894485, -0.05193450674414635, -0.031794678419828415, 0.05714677646756172, 0.027192024514079094, 0.0009938449366018176, 0.0031571730505675077, 0.027065807953476906, 0.012799492105841637, 0.035995226353406906, 0.01524759829044342, -0.026985712349414825, -0.02260860800743103, 0.00884452648460865, -0.01993292011320591, -0.05055946856737137, -0.012058136984705925, -0.030488843098282814, -0.0042861890979111195, 0.024302052333950996, -0.04682216793298721, -0.032960835844278336, -0.002737472066655755, -0.031870510429143906, 0.00735313817858696, -0.014421578496694565, -0.010721332393586636, -0.03600030019879341, 0.01215355284512043, -0.006546918768435717, -0.009335853159427643, -0.0065492913126945496, 0.021602218970656395, -0.03187424689531326, -0.004410978406667709, 0.027089742943644524, -0.00732703972607851, 0.016386762261390686, -0.0015492435777559876, -0.017465822398662567, 0.017036573961377144, 0.0388021357357502, -0.021585065871477127, -0.015415478497743607, 0.05684778094291687, -0.028132962062954903, -0.016619451344013214, 0.013622140511870384, -0.0001842133206082508, -0.0060598221607506275, 0.006909490097314119, 0.03168109804391861, -0.044610194861888885, 0.033715493977069855, -0.03836211562156677, -0.006957369390875101, -0.00038292305544018745, 0.0002673833223525435, -0.018047278746962547, 0.008402332663536072, -0.00346542801707983, 0.013355350121855736, 0.011855822056531906, 0.006957117468118668, 0.057803183794021606, 0.006308176089078188, -0.014108331874012947, -0.02272680588066578, -0.011067209765315056, 0.01920306123793125, -0.027042942121624947, -0.013034622184932232, 0.032176170498132706, 0.061624638736248016, -0.017658764496445656, 0.02050442062318325, 0.01695992238819599, -0.03003423660993576, -0.08123291283845901, -0.022979535162448883, 0.01618237793445587, 0.03300141170620918, 0.011792313307523727, -0.03504958376288414, 0.013423620723187923, 0.04439052194356918, -0.032798416912555695, 0.03680616244673729, -0.011711569502949715, -0.02472374588251114, -0.044541794806718826, 0.02571754716336727, -0.024676091969013214, 0.03675035759806633, 0.005242110230028629, 0.001312211505137384, 0.0025900565087795258, -0.010246632620692253, 0.0073476266115903854, -0.021764883771538734, -0.011356143280863762, 0.00852277036756277, 0.03551297262310982, -0.02236034907400608, 0.024944422766566277, -0.031588297337293625, -0.041836533695459366, 0.021577520295977592, 0.005529287736862898, 0.03494725003838539, 0.0017427359707653522, 0.022593846544623375, -0.007994611747562885, 0.03197737783193588, 0.013365590013563633, -0.006688134279102087, -0.0023480597883462906, 0.023478103801608086, 0.022190727293491364, 0.05805450305342674, -0.03525076061487198, 0.003494799602776766, 0.003446336602792144, -0.008746321313083172, -0.02110040932893753, 0.03113502264022827, 0.009815113618969917, -0.01580699346959591, 0.012734935618937016, -0.007966887205839157, 0.021825606003403664, 0.010137123987078667, 0.01497122272849083, -0.031710781157016754, 0.0039757974445819855, 0.04398554190993309, 0.05313020944595337, -0.028416668996214867, -0.009951173327863216, -0.00896688923239708, 0.002995208138599992, -0.025930505245923996, -0.021955275908112526, -0.006603705231100321, -0.07400429248809814, 0.003286243649199605, 0.014738134108483791, -0.04272736608982086, -0.013623383827507496, -0.02842395193874836, -0.004853989463299513, 0.047814179211854935, -0.021124031394720078, -0.0017755848821252584, -0.011647539213299751, -0.006068132817745209, -0.013188500888645649, -0.0561559721827507, 0.08253917098045349, 0.013146688230335712, -0.0036474845837801695, -0.02892175316810608, 0.009236116893589497, -0.03682003915309906, 0.010449042543768883, 0.036398693919181824, 0.009139777161180973, -0.0064170085825026035, -0.016178632155060768, -0.005408857949078083, 0.0019236017251387239, -0.06280376017093658, 0.03532475233078003, 0.006397944409400225, -0.003620769828557968, -0.033805955201387405, -0.005158987827599049, -0.016723163425922394, 0.007329560350626707, -0.01603631302714348, -0.017825085669755936, 0.037904977798461914, 0.008566784672439098, -0.012711535207927227, 0.018590405583381653, 0.025894327089190483, -0.03438616916537285, 0.04545328766107559, -0.010590428486466408, 0.013300244696438313, 0.06602820008993149, 0.003998470492660999, -0.07535206526517868, 0.003053643275052309, -0.02737456187605858, -0.00018155200814362615, -0.01374872773885727, 0.009816044010221958, -0.024836115539073944, -0.062208231538534164, 0.014486786909401417, 0.026865916326642036, -0.07260916382074356, 0.011483133770525455, 0.01921110227704048, 0.030045533552765846, 0.0440400168299675, -0.012198220938444138, 0.017564475536346436, 0.017988715320825577, -0.05649244040250778, -0.004782312083989382, 0.018501734361052513, 0.03816208615899086, 0.02297663874924183, 0.027599643915891647, 0.036846060305833817, -0.004616080783307552, 0.030704671517014503, -0.029864756390452385, 0.012445330619812012, -0.023020897060632706, -0.014378714375197887, 0.000465799355879426, -0.038277655839920044, 0.028248880058526993, 0.02547326497733593, -0.020611833781003952, 0.04225778579711914, -0.07420291006565094, 0.004626549314707518, -0.027084695175290108, -0.02703581377863884, -0.05102361738681793, 0.007163524627685547, 0.010560998693108559, 0.06817688047885895, 0.0014412669697776437, 0.0019238473614677787, -0.03151815012097359, -0.047356002032756805, 0.041280847042798996, -0.055420417338609695, 0.032083332538604736, -0.03179120272397995, 0.015456694178283215, 0.00031345419120043516, 0.004271551966667175, -0.046801213175058365, -0.022359352558851242, 0.035887863487005234, 0.0728895291686058, 0.02028314210474491, -0.04629741609096527, -0.02319541573524475, 0.029261434450745583, 0.06074294447898865, -0.048466235399246216, -0.031625740230083466, -0.031020307913422585, 0.00710127642378211, 0.033741727471351624, -0.0023117237724363804 ]
<p>Consider the two-way ANOVA model with mixed effects : $$ Y_{i,j,k} = \underset{M_{i,j}}{\underbrace{\mu + \alpha_i + B_j + C_{i,j}}} + \epsilon_{i,j,k}, $$ with $\textbf{(1)}$ : $\sum \alpha_i = 0$, the random terms $B_j$, $C_{i,j}$ and $\epsilon_{i,j,k}$ are independent, $B_j \sim_{\text{iid}} {\cal N}(0, \sigma_\beta^2)$, $\epsilon_{i,j,k} \sim_{\text{iid}} {\cal N}(0, \sigma^2)$ ; and there are two possibilities for the random interactions : $\textbf{(2a)}$ : $C_{i,j} \sim_{\text{iid}} {\cal N}(0, \sigma_\gamma^2)$ or $\textbf{(2b)}$ : $C_{i,j} \sim {\cal N}(0, \sigma_\gamma^2)$ for all $i,j$, the random vectors $C_{(1:I), 1}$, $C_{(1:I), 2}$, $\ldots$, $C_{(1:I), J}$ are independent, and $C_{\bullet j}=0$ for all $j$ (which means that mean of each random vector $C_{(1:I), j}$ is zero). </p> <p>Model $\textbf{(1)}$ + $\textbf{(2a)}$ is the one which is treated by the nlme/lme4 package in R or the PROC MIXED statement in SAS. Model $\textbf{(1)}$ + $\textbf{(2b)}$ is called the "restricted model", it satisfies in particular $M_{\bullet j} = \mu + B_j$. Do you think one of these two models is "better" (in which sense) or more appropriate than the other one ? Do you know whether it is possible to perform the fitting of the restricted model in R or SAS ? Thanks.</p>
73,514
[ -0.02595558576285839, 0.004845347721129656, 0.020642342045903206, -0.018926942721009254, 0.05584690719842911, 0.02320096828043461, 0.0129389688372612, -0.015924714505672455, 0.02391173504292965, -0.057343825697898865, 0.0655132383108139, 0.007717649452388287, 0.046903401613235474, 0.017614690586924553, 0.031133433803915977, 0.004950941540300846, -0.022981325164437294, 0.01689695380628109, -0.013766530901193619, 0.017964646220207214, -0.025860894471406937, 0.033376652747392654, -0.010710323229432106, -0.02426060102880001, -0.04529891908168793, 0.04937741532921791, 0.033040739595890045, -0.07465527951717377, -0.009597886353731155, 0.045134611427783966, -0.012431726790964603, -0.010672208853065968, 0.005047127604484558, -0.005636280402541161, 0.0033539109863340855, -0.01102902740240097, -0.012465420179069042, -0.020939189940690994, 0.04030073806643486, 0.03704284131526947, -0.06638970226049423, -0.002467349637299776, 0.0005191377131268382, 0.005157638806849718, 0.00920845102518797, -0.004924382083117962, 0.017493348568677902, 0.01655496470630169, 0.033018726855516434, -0.030505651608109474, 0.06382736563682556, -0.028004897758364677, 0.025341251865029335, 0.007226881105452776, -0.024075711145997047, 0.002673342591151595, 0.02478574961423874, 0.05088907852768898, 0.025083554908633232, -0.08757759630680084, -0.009101894684135914, 0.012266631238162518, 0.03352835401892662, 0.015022060833871365, -0.03249809890985489, -0.014353207312524319, -0.0017957828240469098, -0.012501256540417671, 0.013556698337197304, -0.01060531847178936, 0.02537498250603676, -0.010743812657892704, 0.061841171234846115, 0.010663825087249279, 0.031022079288959503, 0.029611611738801003, 0.01635918766260147, 0.0032530243042856455, 0.016622424125671387, 0.02460947446525097, 0.013908960856497288, 0.00731534231454134, 0.0013926601968705654, 0.013601583428680897, 0.012691009789705276, -0.0058205872774124146, 0.05206884816288948, -0.014621623791754246, 0.034086674451828, -0.010536874644458294, -0.016213281080126762, 0.023759592324495316, 0.052314743399620056, -0.014621530659496784, -0.047442927956581116, 0.02122754044830799, -0.013407527469098568, 0.01968955248594284, -0.011069297790527344, -0.020743904635310173, -0.03178742900490761, -0.04416942223906517, 0.001429096912033856, 0.09241382777690887, 0.018962500616908073, -0.014185117557644844, -0.017683319747447968, 0.005999562330543995, -0.03249881789088249, -0.04141926392912865, -0.01093104388564825, 0.028872843831777573, -0.00503591587767005, 0.013455593958497047, 0.010625636205077171, -0.03891277313232422, -0.019128955900669098, -0.004768202546983957, 0.07348190248012543, 0.08441559225320816, 0.05973120033740997, -0.042925622314214706, -0.04882592335343361, 0.002325365785509348, -0.029449133202433586, -0.004783980548381805, 0.020831767469644547, -0.02782784029841423, -0.052123893052339554, 0.03533393144607544, 0.05080519616603851, -0.00013225710426922888, 0.03212936222553253, 0.015081699937582016, 0.03210468217730522, -0.011958720162510872, -0.09370678663253784, -0.05673858895897865, 0.01305507030338049, -0.025452256202697754, 0.033336568623781204, -0.04609446972608566, -0.01633911393582821, 0.027987917885184288, 0.0825086161494255, -0.02831066958606243, 0.025770459324121475, 0.027402829378843307, 0.051314711570739746, 0.020845115184783936, 0.007726521696895361, -0.04127667844295502, -0.0468805693089962, -0.01750876195728779, -0.024553917348384857, -0.0844166949391365, 0.05830065533518791, 0.00016818199947010726, -0.02014612779021263, 0.026110652834177017, 0.004236010834574699, 0.01635729894042015, 0.01327565312385559, 0.010889234021306038, 0.018489310517907143, -0.006057538092136383, 0.046806443482637405, -0.009420271031558514, 0.05501192808151245, 0.02508542500436306, -0.003387474687770009, 0.010608506388962269, -0.034637559205293655, 0.04872241988778114, 0.028708308935165405, -0.031303539872169495, -0.019863760098814964, -0.0031052634585648775, 0.0020266054198145866, 0.0384380966424942, -0.059361524879932404, 0.034572068601846695, -0.05563339963555336, 0.011480884626507759, 0.05040843039751053, 0.014444531872868538, 0.0319705531001091, -0.0025552459992468357, 0.046750254929065704, -0.03415032476186752, 0.010686465539038181, -0.08501975238323212, -0.008956036530435085, 0.003271794645115733, -0.05776544660329819, 0.04447945952415466, -0.040482696145772934, -0.023572364822030067, 0.03721339628100395, -0.007293852511793375, -0.05867127701640129, 0.0077664596028625965, 0.056784432381391525, -0.03581981360912323, 0.025934558361768723, 0.0003571088891476393, 0.06653310358524323, -0.010281926952302456, 0.06826673448085785, -0.023013660684227943, -0.04696411266922951, 0.022258298471570015, -0.01735837012529373, 0.015241787768900394, 0.028532162308692932, -0.016299450770020485, -0.018005233258008957, 0.011262455955147743, -0.027890658006072044, 0.027761787176132202, -0.0792393758893013, 0.024183927103877068, 0.06980924308300018, 0.009710785001516342, -0.0043463800102472305, 0.04884042590856552, 0.02263258583843708, 0.006869019474834204, -0.051591988652944565, -0.004683509934693575, -0.0019098360789939761, -0.019311781972646713, 0.05825788155198097, 0.03858201578259468, -0.04662378877401352, 0.017155086621642113, 0.050330135971307755, 0.021192319691181183, 0.004653930198401213, 0.004722170066088438, 0.0010024181101471186, -0.032852474600076675, 0.021761881187558174, 0.01635139249265194, 0.03263814002275467, -0.005279582925140858, -0.011212125420570374, -0.008023092523217201, 0.03975280374288559, -0.009458178654313087, -0.012483862228691578, 0.026744462549686432, 0.05050364136695862, -0.03081720694899559, -0.04846290126442909, -0.005938454065471888, 0.06676728278398514, 0.0030346750281751156, 0.015300098806619644, 0.04413503780961037, 0.018151316791772842, -0.0002428522566333413, 0.005513374228030443, -0.012810532003641129, 0.06140841916203499, -0.01999739371240139, 0.001380780478939414, -0.01021155621856451, 0.00021052623924333602, -0.031850531697273254, -0.0011076608207076788, 0.001057337038218975, -0.02310788258910179, -0.003374356310814619, -0.01580697111785412, 0.02857712283730507, 0.0000706407445250079, 0.007232048083096743, -0.04664124175906181, -0.01234280876815319, -0.000284682639176026, 0.03354097530245781, 0.03184015676379204, 0.0007649746839888394, -0.040009185671806335, -0.018325049430131912, -0.03656892478466034, 0.03235156461596489, -0.0018429760821163654, -0.017038820311427116, -0.04702183976769447, 0.05196217820048332, -0.017323018983006477, -0.03829694911837578, -0.04838188365101814, -0.004057084675878286, -0.01923673041164875, -0.04457015544176102, -0.004335526376962662, 0.048293035477399826, 0.05232563242316246, -0.04692487418651581, 0.0013202361296862364, -0.02546488679945469, -0.03863095864653587, -0.0008649601950310171, -0.006465936079621315, 0.014150874689221382, 0.000946261512581259, 0.033835574984550476, 0.012614337727427483, -0.02205807715654373, -0.015541072003543377, -0.07179231941699982, -0.049729008227586746, -0.007160218898206949, -0.0059814234264194965, 0.011725838296115398, -0.02057844027876854, -0.017773432657122612, 0.07969933748245239, 0.03370625898241997, 0.0055517456494271755, -0.024035507813096046, 0.0005977418622933328, -0.013543791137635708, -0.01690446399152279, 0.030379893258213997, 0.007893897593021393, -0.02094981074333191, 0.07515867799520493, -0.03089914098381996, 0.02763056941330433, 0.04680467024445534, 0.024878187105059624, -0.004108923953026533, 0.03348232060670853, 0.021702643483877182, -0.009785032831132412, 0.024757491424679756, 0.007511558476835489, 0.016104048117995262, -0.024721486493945122, 0.019760411232709885, 0.025421973317861557, 0.002961900318041444, -0.06535177677869797, -0.012184107676148415, -0.040419064462184906, 0.02022739313542843, -0.04636439308524132, 0.027674412354826927, 0.051535189151763916, -0.03848879411816597, 0.005102291703224182, 0.006729993969202042, 0.008342860266566277, -0.028538530692458153, 0.022824404761195183, 0.018993685021996498, 0.03417067229747772, 0.0003685302217490971, -0.012393021024763584, 0.01581248827278614, -0.02147495374083519, 0.017790907993912697, -0.027118898928165436, 0.03609025105834007, -0.006974040996283293, 0.020623570308089256, -0.003921156283468008, -0.005453175399452448, 0.007097287103533745, -0.03366754576563835, -0.045147500932216644, 0.02074860967695713, -0.04922797158360481, -0.002383028855547309, 0.017920823767781258, 0.027952829375863075, -0.027796030044555664, -0.04594401270151138, -0.035319164395332336, -0.008937917649745941, -0.02999556064605713, 0.014729348942637444, -0.008114911615848541, 0.02058698609471321, 0.029355790466070175, -0.04012247547507286, 0.01500436756759882, -0.004421232268214226, 0.0019837694708257914, -0.0462556816637516, 0.047772135585546494, -0.00987659115344286, -0.003254974028095603, -0.026490140706300735, -0.056418031454086304, -0.011249751783907413, 0.048276130110025406, 0.004524155519902706, -0.042490147054195404, -0.032720621675252914, -0.0006693077739328146, 0.010520992800593376, -0.003978300839662552, -0.007806272711604834, 0.005021282937377691, 0.022359905764460564, 0.02162051759660244, -0.0005536323878914118, 0.020918237045407295, -0.006972020026296377, 0.02179989218711853, 0.05813731253147125, 0.03266153112053871, 0.03392240032553673, 0.03357874974608421, 0.014033103361725807, -0.013336590491235256, -0.025638872757554054, -0.013336964882910252, 0.007544564548879862, 0.030533267185091972, 0.02956349030137062, 0.029121074825525284, 0.020673293620347977, -0.0374910868704319, 0.010656815022230148, 0.048117149621248245, 0.030082618817687035, 0.03008272871375084, -0.030085662379860878, 0.005694875027984381, -0.006346280686557293, 0.008302240632474422, 0.024635471403598785, -0.040503986179828644, 0.0228151623159647, -0.01629490777850151, 0.033693522214889526, 0.01336615439504385, 0.0018442607251927257, 0.014487307518720627, 0.028877632692456245, -0.007243002764880657, 0.02210841327905655, -0.04691062867641449, 0.0046196323819458485, -0.0012721264502033591, 0.018008407205343246, 0.03441263362765312, 0.0008800868527032435, -0.0504940040409565, -0.006844585761427879, 0.04964710772037506, 0.0008930808398872614, -0.02459840476512909, 0.025460481643676758, -0.004917897284030914, 0.005510356277227402, -0.020673662424087524, 0.004261992871761322, 0.05097484216094017, -0.03115391544997692, 0.017928222194314003, -0.01589605025947094, -0.009225151501595974, -0.03539949283003807, 0.03390136733651161, 0.002331274561583996, -0.01795387640595436, 0.0016916290624067187, -0.03592662885785103, -0.026826731860637665, -0.025245798751711845, 0.03753150254487991, 0.03171401470899582, -0.0390300489962101, -0.04747362807393074, 0.03915220499038696, 0.0036433618515729904, -0.02472037449479103, -0.04466914013028145, 0.04230306297540665, 0.02188805676996708, -0.017412899062037468, 0.06330125778913498, -0.0415869876742363, -0.04230319336056709, 0.028034549206495285, 0.007439392618834972, 0.02038353495299816, -0.02113736793398857, 0.0003502908512018621, 0.08003360778093338, 0.03280697762966156, 0.020458228886127472, 0.06789586693048477, 0.032208994030952454, -0.0014362633228302002, -0.0003703719412442297, -0.05120829492807388, 0.0041654398664832115, -0.007397289853543043, -0.015409850515425205, -0.0770311951637268, -0.005807842593640089, 0.00839325599372387, 0.02738259918987751, -0.020313294604420662, 0.019725050777196884, -0.026059137657284737, -0.04167824611067772, 0.013695434667170048, 0.013429098762571812, -0.0258491188287735, -0.023977624252438545, -0.009720017202198505, 0.02452394925057888, 0.009672453626990318, -0.001697419211268425, 0.049968037754297256, -0.028954217210412025, -0.01395020168274641, -0.0012198173208162189, -0.020541386678814888, 0.0038820200134068727, -0.004873858764767647, -0.046653516590595245, -0.019520441070199013, -0.010031702928245068, 0.02886972390115261, -0.01130455732345581, 0.009545543231070042, -0.015409565530717373, -0.06244516745209694, -0.01412950549274683, 0.014324030838906765, 0.002232143422588706, 0.03375991806387901, -0.002884883666411042, 0.016438022255897522, 0.011099696159362793, -0.02345733530819416, -0.08450087904930115, -0.017118187621235847, 0.023415271192789078, -0.031323306262493134, 0.024121172726154327, -0.0077202036045491695, -0.031588852405548096, -0.011391701176762581, -0.06331767141819, -0.002217070432379842, 0.0937410295009613, -0.022127918899059296, 0.000996578368358314, -0.00030144042102620006, 0.053504426032304764, 0.03171603009104729, 0.021297406405210495, -0.017681626603007317, 0.01866522803902626, -0.06628933548927307, 0.004146979656070471, 0.014735417440533638, 0.025486910715699196, -0.03327210992574692, 0.02028035931289196, -0.06135225668549538, 0.003912211861461401, 0.03155558928847313, 0.007047063671052456, -0.03228616341948509, 0.040296006947755814, 0.021612338721752167, 0.003492540679872036, -0.02533758245408535, -0.04754956439137459, -0.0031235055066645145, 0.06123332679271698, -0.027322635054588318, -0.013088313862681389, -0.016969140619039536, 0.03443596512079239, 0.029506804421544075, -0.01246984675526619, -0.028929702937602997, -0.0010394057026132941, 0.06184043362736702, -0.021967073902487755, -0.01703709363937378, 0.012350838631391525, 0.022581156343221664, 0.030322004109621048, -0.0010708596091717482, 0.01920018158853054, 0.03944150730967522, 0.021926691755652428, -0.03182351216673851, 0.009520615451037884, -0.0620800256729126, 0.017100824043154716, 0.0509750135242939, -0.011690986342728138, 0.00882644485682249, 0.03959907218813896, -0.014731586910784245, -0.030785519629716873, -0.06384154409170151, -0.0002105948078678921, -0.0058207460679113865, 0.027186870574951172, 0.04565003514289856, -0.02577032893896103, -0.05507301539182663, 0.03885361924767494, 0.009306074120104313, 0.011945061385631561, 0.029956255108118057, 0.017614006996154785, 0.037169020622968674, -0.0028218417428433895, -0.04316844418644905, -0.03698824346065521, 0.05202704668045044, -0.07170353829860687, 0.021820535883307457, -0.03551869094371796, -0.03688103333115578, 0.031352266669273376, 0.050900958478450775, 0.019236480817198753, -0.0610472597181797, -0.022958209738135338, -0.03825363889336586, 0.014465205371379852, 0.008155027404427528, -0.030415767803788185, 0.02788267284631729, 0.0060456558130681515, 0.03911031782627106, -0.03945406526327133, 0.017586778849363327, -0.02762851119041443, -0.06667441129684448, -0.02881351299583912, 0.025981614366173744, -0.0051917145028710365, 0.015883713960647583, -0.016941415145993233, -0.021546125411987305, -0.008163563907146454, -0.01915179193019867, 0.029283350333571434, -0.0036507684271782637, 0.019377082586288452, 0.0033056053798645735, 0.02807840146124363, -0.002674744464457035, -0.007753198966383934, -0.00682398397475481, -0.03630409389734268, 0.13527467846870422, 0.05981620028614998, 0.04430811479687691, -0.06921762973070145, 0.04570211470127106, 0.026930920779705048, 0.026195267215371132, -0.02932741306722164, 0.0017794598825275898, -0.005469843745231628, -0.037860650569200516, 0.03905075788497925, 0.04285338521003723, 0.00533677451312542, -0.017648976296186447, 0.013795885257422924, -0.023463072255253792, -0.04310989007353783, -0.007421576883643866, 0.00660996837541461, -0.012727643363177776, -0.016038278117775917, -0.0003461097367107868, -0.027804484590888023, 0.013385098427534103, -0.01884031668305397, -0.03435760363936424, -0.01661980338394642, -0.027934705838561058, -0.0087624192237854, -0.010991995222866535, 0.018570031970739365, 0.03281501308083534, 0.0473872609436512, 0.018400615081191063, -0.012695008888840675, 0.04114101827144623, -0.04715571179986, 0.037240467965602875, 0.021507704630494118, -0.02010740526020527, 0.011347402818500996, 0.03296016529202461, -0.0012575499713420868, -0.04297824576497078, -0.029939649626612663, 0.012902947142720222, 0.06945387274026871, -0.011074899695813656, -0.039958853274583817, -0.010627605020999908, -0.012721685692667961, 0.01177859678864479, 0.0029964635614305735, -0.02336113154888153, 0.01965879090130329, 0.014723260886967182, -0.03929702192544937, -0.011179646477103233, -0.017975376918911934, 0.04137735441327095, 0.007346395868808031, 0.046896811574697495, 0.03662895783782005, -0.04228895530104637, -0.024929337203502655, -0.019089993089437485, 0.07612688839435577, 0.03775753453373909, 0.009185109287500381, -0.0017160814022645354, -0.03916497156023979, 0.004602219443768263, -0.03132525458931923, 0.012886798940598965, 0.026594458147883415, 0.02193620055913925, -0.028066828846931458, -0.007631049491465092, -0.04448249936103821, -0.05054193362593651, -0.002560317749157548, -0.010422858409583569, -0.012776574119925499, -0.03797807916998863, -0.029711689800024033, 0.01778746210038662, 0.05208287015557289, -0.026811156421899796, -0.016912784427404404, -0.0025260706897825003, 0.08091085404157639, 0.03331614285707474, -0.06545808911323547, -0.048694364726543427, 0.023492775857448578, 0.01068926602602005, 0.005039353854954243, 0.01603984646499157, 0.018344733864068985, 0.00658727390691638, 0.04679245501756668, -0.007260224781930447, 0.05186118930578232, -0.05794952064752579, -0.022853689268231392, 0.02814900316298008, -0.04428722709417343, -0.0049042776226997375, 0.018820282071828842, 0.02151700109243393, -0.00329253519885242, -0.0017780880443751812, -0.026352273300290108, -0.03378097340464592, -0.004877423867583275, -0.051730677485466, -0.006073276977986097, -0.041181016713380814, -0.019990501925349236, -0.01817055605351925, -0.023825405165553093, -0.020429702475667, 0.0006204429664649069, -0.004552095662802458, 0.007216648664325476, 0.032917965203523636, 0.019098257645964622, 0.015723640099167824, -0.0048033203929662704, -0.0007786507485434413, 0.02003522776067257, 0.017366038635373116, 0.0056487624533474445, -0.022583069279789925, -0.00937708094716072, -0.004143824800848961, 0.02370666339993477, -0.006951098330318928, -0.02011933922767639, 0.006566750817000866, -0.043403659015893936, -0.010628653690218925, -0.00756593095138669, -0.003458860330283642, 0.04690985754132271, 0.003785463282838464, 0.019054105505347252, -0.03658071160316467, 0.049095962196588516, -0.060669079422950745, -0.02670447900891304, -0.010750943794846535, -0.0007775270496495068, 0.008745756931602955, -0.019060185179114342, -0.0036459306720644236, 0.03002329356968403, -0.014718331396579742, 0.06137966737151146, 0.036278508603572845, -0.005782813765108585, -0.028558719903230667, 0.024014504626393318, -0.02730192430317402, 0.03819379583001137, 0.015798918902873993, 0.03131555765867233, -0.004141376353800297, 0.0227276012301445, -0.032636988908052444, 0.04067394509911537, -0.01387489028275013, 0.008304937742650509, -0.09076976776123047, -0.04794620722532272, 0.023966535925865173, 0.04976949840784073, 0.053899239748716354, -0.024967804551124573, 0.03759458661079407, 0.01995568349957466, -0.040575556457042694, -0.011026900261640549, -0.002697765827178955, -0.013346296735107899, -0.01615746133029461, -0.0007598417578265071, -0.03659854456782341, 0.021142417564988136, -0.02006540633738041, 0.02152865380048752, 0.02119656652212143, 0.0037981653586030006, -0.003114157821983099, -0.020523428916931152, -0.004359134938567877, -0.0004071322618983686, 0.047217369079589844, -0.05443238094449043, 0.05056248977780342, -0.02469019591808319, -0.01391674391925335, 0.007112541235983372, -0.0013771505327895284, 0.02357243373990059, -0.018042398616671562, 0.041532788425683975, 0.014341842383146286, 0.024814581498503685, 0.00970397237688303, 0.01478519942611456, 0.057609960436820984, -0.019949093461036682, 0.014823961071670055, 0.02650826796889305, -0.009437844157218933, 0.0027603195048868656, 0.011510657146573067, 0.005262420978397131, -0.043123215436935425, 0.007655074819922447, -0.021720292046666145, -0.04402541369199753, -0.007451443467289209, -0.008727079257369041, 0.009230906143784523, -0.01786925457417965, 0.019302265718579292, -0.01609383523464203, 0.010397221893072128, 0.027000633999705315, 0.06348762661218643, -0.02784467674791813, 0.029807202517986298, -0.010475127026438713, -0.01593724824488163, 0.03111804649233818, 0.008302808739244938, -0.01862858608365059, -0.07386671751737595, -0.044535838067531586, -0.013978292234241962, 0.009318461641669273, -0.005637753754854202, 0.02495761401951313, -0.04763084650039673, 0.003193577751517296, -0.004560338798910379, 0.02554885298013687, -0.03067360632121563, -0.03392036259174347, 0.001418094034306705, -0.10093993693590164, 0.06450385600328445, 0.02159740775823593, -0.028904467821121216, -0.05129120498895645, -0.006349767092615366, -0.028180643916130066, 0.020628849044442177, 0.04549478739500046, 0.02972203493118286, 0.0007355075795203447, -0.037877168506383896, 0.04455505684018135, 0.021322159096598625, -0.053450122475624084, 0.047306615859270096, -0.001654960447922349, 0.014177211560308933, -0.03007722645998001, -0.02392137236893177, -0.001366031588986516, 0.014600667171180248, -0.00522618368268013, 0.003865037113428116, 0.0231876689940691, 0.03176410123705864, -0.015118950046598911, 0.005661513656377792, -0.001595447538420558, -0.01999027654528618, 0.04631625860929489, -0.0008517394890077412, 0.009173285216093063, -0.003057459369301796, 0.0076547544449567795, -0.05828036740422249, 0.013600409962236881, 0.0029327196534723043, -0.023837020620703697, -0.024197624996304512, -0.0019213504856452346, -0.020637061446905136, -0.038019780069589615, 0.015935972332954407, 0.028531275689601898, 0.008551510982215405, -0.02152123861014843, 0.024704232811927795, 0.04333434998989105, 0.02459028922021389, 0.04973240941762924, 0.017146646976470947, -0.025164326652884483, -0.002545526484027505, 0.04548557847738266, -0.018595119938254356, -0.006957302801311016, -0.015454811975359917, -0.030077416449785233, 0.020260505378246307, -0.014071227051317692, -0.00236914143897593, -0.045532021671533585, -0.0001665593881625682, -0.021435916423797607, -0.020184151828289032, 0.06259605288505554, -0.005646903533488512, 0.05125541612505913, -0.013441557064652443, -0.013535347767174244, 0.05869404599070549, -0.06853055953979492, 0.025209570303559303, -0.005451492499560118, 0.01433411706238985, 0.010524931363761425, -0.017453165724873543, 0.002286024857312441, 0.016649842262268066, 0.03323974460363388, -0.0032579803373664618, -0.008478833362460136, -0.055547021329402924, 0.009589577093720436, -0.02179875411093235, 0.025449557229876518, 0.03433746472001076, 0.015554861165583134, -0.031601086258888245, -0.019494909793138504, -0.030029751360416412, -0.0626491904258728, 0.02560194581747055, 0.00637463852763176, 0.005220239982008934, -0.03250662237405777, -0.012589420191943645, 0.02611144259572029, 0.06899325549602509, -0.036142151802778244, -0.020698681473731995, -0.0036844781134277582, -0.00019723146397154778, -0.01830166205763817, -0.004728514701128006 ]
<p>A die is rolled twice,</p> <ul> <li><p>$X_1$ : the minimum value to appear in the two rolls</p></li> <li><p>$X_2$ : the maximum</p></li> </ul> <p>I would like to derive $\ F_{X_1,X_2}(x_1,x_2)$. </p> <p>I know that that the CDF of $\ X_1 $ = $\ 1- [1-{F(x)]} ^ n $, CDF of $\ X_2 $ $\ = $ $ \ [{F(x)]} ^ n $ and $\ F_{X_1,X_2}(x_1,x_2) = P(X_1&lt;x_1|X_2&lt;x_2)F_{X_2}(x_2) $</p> <p>The solution seems to be : </p> <p>$\ F_{X_1,X_2}(x_1,x_2) = 2F(\min[{x_1,x_2}])F(x_2) - F(\min[{x_1,x_2}])^2 $</p> <p>I want to understand how such solution can be obtained.</p>
73,515
[ -0.0196525938808918, -0.02603198029100895, 0.019086793065071106, 0.012202122248709202, -0.01313660480082035, -0.010434580966830254, -0.0018355860374867916, -0.04663550481200218, 0.031313151121139526, -0.029794590547680855, 0.03425215184688568, 0.040182869881391525, 0.042114369571208954, 0.005108532961457968, 0.03581493720412254, -0.00670339772477746, -0.018033094704151154, 0.007705893833190203, 0.0012282662792131305, -0.019779743626713753, 0.004618210718035698, 0.02993038110435009, 0.048905149102211, -0.03667008876800537, -0.003197744954377413, 0.01281799003481865, 0.04604564979672432, -0.0026749807875603437, 0.021787181496620178, 0.09344073385000229, -0.06183067709207535, -0.03726023808121681, -0.003261153120547533, 0.04343022033572197, 0.008016061969101429, 0.021310143172740936, -0.022928137332201004, -0.01637498289346695, -0.003911164589226246, 0.021276652812957764, -0.01978502795100212, -0.018669098615646362, 0.006795473862439394, 0.022340072318911552, -0.011229515075683594, 0.03311542794108391, 0.0062553854659199715, -0.03289055824279785, 0.026387322694063187, -0.06520260125398636, 0.10201147943735123, 0.004016682505607605, 0.026585953310132027, 0.016031038016080856, -0.019169175997376442, -0.022810732945799828, 0.0464068241417408, 0.07445095479488373, 0.018413031473755836, -0.049243271350860596, -0.02789944037795067, -0.050333984196186066, -0.0073358346708118916, 0.005292936693876982, -0.02650764398276806, 0.03842242434620857, 0.003009967040270567, -0.002839354332536459, -0.029447749257087708, -0.0234880018979311, 0.0018693876918405294, 0.016603505238890648, 0.028697501868009567, -0.02714809775352478, 0.02573448047041893, -0.007259722799062729, 0.032816801220178604, 0.03521045297384262, 0.015494061633944511, 0.017845597118139267, 0.024087481200695038, 0.04467376321554184, 0.007200117688626051, 0.012293253093957901, -0.0035975154023617506, -0.009598702192306519, 0.09603606164455414, -0.002606857568025589, 0.045541420578956604, -0.0007784533663652837, -0.009072608314454556, 0.009801175445318222, 0.0515766441822052, -0.07046020776033401, -0.025434482842683792, 0.008694197051227093, -0.005632080137729645, -0.003714700462296605, -0.019180191680788994, -0.02126515842974186, -0.02658834680914879, -0.05834688991308212, -0.00017158236005343497, 0.04175196588039398, -0.020187774673104286, -0.008650104515254498, -0.012836541049182415, 0.02840614877641201, -0.001806502346880734, 0.025884155184030533, -0.0359891839325428, 0.0541423074901104, -0.00575786828994751, 0.010770090855658054, 0.032455217093229294, 0.0032409715931862593, -0.0007074407185427845, 0.018263135105371475, 0.03526779264211655, 0.03177991509437561, 0.04117145761847496, -0.0373087078332901, 0.01611792854964733, -0.02204805053770542, -0.05510241910815239, 0.01697981357574463, 0.019977454096078873, 0.04273151233792305, -0.039515867829322815, 0.035721078515052795, -0.008975576609373093, -0.01626352034509182, 0.022714192047715187, 0.0751124694943428, 0.001089459634386003, 0.021791972219944, -0.09319499880075455, -0.03262081369757652, 0.03193613886833191, -0.02902381680905819, 0.009936567395925522, -0.06374317407608032, 0.034681301563978195, 0.03783529996871948, 0.04584157094359398, 0.020040854811668396, 0.044233255088329315, 0.02589081972837448, 0.027999479323625565, 0.0046293954364955425, 0.011450099758803844, 0.004321211948990822, -0.005267208907753229, -0.009000481106340885, -0.029109342023730278, -0.04395676031708717, 0.045861635357141495, 0.005674082785844803, -0.007232822943478823, -0.035432398319244385, 0.0830928161740303, -0.006400109734386206, -0.006577568594366312, -0.041976168751716614, 0.02624782733619213, 0.011144676245748997, 0.06242608278989792, -0.0007256814278662205, 0.015951162204146385, 0.039262931793928146, -0.016006095334887505, 0.017977379262447357, -0.017677754163742065, 0.05946113169193268, 0.03469715267419815, -0.02397184446454048, -0.03631981089711189, -0.01653478480875492, 0.00519478227943182, 0.025677401572465897, 0.0016238379757851362, 0.025288887321949005, -0.01657033897936344, 0.008652952499687672, 0.04937698692083359, 0.02504042722284794, 0.0022418429143726826, -0.011896682903170586, 0.023296644911170006, -0.044704992324113846, -0.02101750485599041, -0.06879767030477524, -0.019439423456788063, 0.016356585547327995, -0.04679197445511818, 0.06829483807086945, 0.009259781800210476, -0.010603595525026321, -0.005166012328118086, -0.003767843823879957, -0.018145497888326645, 0.009021153673529625, 0.04145849496126175, -0.026056339964270592, -0.0010815344285219908, 0.07568376511335373, 0.07666255533695221, 0.0027526365593075752, 0.03429773077368736, -0.03258661553263664, -0.029471853747963905, -0.01736513152718544, -0.05153033882379532, 0.036311909556388855, -0.02362680621445179, 0.003875610651448369, 0.017797676846385002, -0.005374257918447256, 0.029353339225053787, -0.0016390189994126558, -0.05005596950650215, 0.04964820295572281, 0.08897138386964798, -0.00585069740191102, 0.015501718036830425, 0.012801630422472954, 0.0002626705972943455, 0.012807616032660007, -0.006313732825219631, -0.01698828488588333, -0.04523850232362747, -0.026751697063446045, 0.019642824307084084, 0.06360335648059845, -0.02048240602016449, 0.01223467942327261, 0.07036605477333069, -0.006504938006401062, 0.036988452076911926, 0.04098927974700928, 0.0003644992539193481, 0.0014953589998185635, 0.028456268832087517, -0.006897682324051857, 0.03233453258872032, 0.00011338859621901065, -0.013258556835353374, -0.008014397695660591, 0.0006335246143862605, -0.008183489553630352, -0.062218546867370605, 0.06670116633176804, 0.0015261403750628233, 0.01471245288848877, -0.007541370112448931, -0.00120238633826375, 0.029397306963801384, -0.012695829384028912, -0.01134222000837326, 0.05246295779943466, -0.006649601273238659, -0.018043622374534607, 0.003489222377538681, -0.03614673763513565, 0.02907962165772915, 0.014311394654214382, -0.04703477397561073, -0.018566103652119637, 0.0023105095606297255, -0.02884124219417572, -0.027140937745571136, -0.015879938378930092, -0.06992358714342117, 0.007637024391442537, -0.0032941012177616358, 0.002717144088819623, -0.01183604821562767, -0.0024846040178090334, -0.00795078556984663, -0.012224630452692509, -0.04545489698648453, -0.02784246951341629, 0.027122128754854202, -0.03201986849308014, -0.031103435903787613, 0.0029122133273631334, 0.0018263272941112518, 0.010860037058591843, 0.03886517882347107, 0.0010260377312079072, 0.010124018415808678, 0.009663982316851616, -0.013701020739972591, -0.04050557315349579, -0.014771283604204655, -0.04224332794547081, 0.01735161431133747, -0.029634801670908928, -0.022131433710455894, 0.043154891580343246, 0.01025597844272852, -0.04680241644382477, 0.013107694685459137, -0.0030504658352583647, -0.014396540820598602, -0.06448054313659668, -0.022471148520708084, 0.036614879965782166, 0.0015565732028335333, -0.0195013340562582, 0.024091970175504684, 0.030426600947976112, -0.007113462779670954, -0.0915006622672081, -0.054547134786844254, -0.03648987039923668, -0.03258929401636124, 0.04054061323404312, 0.006222574505954981, -0.032645825296640396, 0.09350138902664185, 0.03262094780802727, 0.002797079738229513, -0.03382197022438049, 0.008920329622924328, 0.01577659696340561, 0.005021031014621258, 0.023775562644004822, 0.031014058738946915, -0.0012492828536778688, 0.06307446956634521, 0.014783231541514397, -0.010041849687695503, 0.1117892861366272, -0.03907354176044464, -0.011908464133739471, -0.00109778658952564, 0.009509051218628883, -0.0032717741560190916, 0.04449177905917168, -0.009501408785581589, -0.010485718958079815, 0.003942835610359907, 0.007591553032398224, 0.012961175292730331, -0.023523511365056038, -0.008753780275583267, 0.00927555002272129, -0.01474140863865614, -0.0028580708894878626, -0.004855039995163679, 0.051953792572021484, 0.04121102765202522, -0.051637548953294754, -0.004949123132973909, 0.0413985438644886, 0.04631321504712105, -0.07124776393175125, 0.021752776578068733, 0.046660080552101135, 0.025580165907740593, -0.04738883301615715, -0.014475173316895962, -0.016387099400162697, -0.012021934613585472, 0.037791021168231964, -0.031321629881858826, -0.01965486817061901, -0.001843805075623095, 0.0043710037134587765, 0.041632119566202164, -0.020000068470835686, -0.0013246563030406833, -0.01923125609755516, -0.05417680740356445, -0.002571630058810115, 0.003287510247901082, 0.05095307156443596, 0.02205127291381359, 0.03667826950550079, -0.008620950393378735, -0.008372651413083076, 0.016550812870264053, 0.007752515841275454, -0.08774971961975098, 0.06661581248044968, -0.014199125580489635, 0.033496204763650894, -0.04026985540986061, -0.00985799916088581, 0.06856660544872284, -0.020176773890852928, 0.022610025480389595, 0.004070119466632605, 0.015322449617087841, -0.03181786462664604, -0.006531023420393467, -0.035154230892658234, -0.03598824143409729, 0.026947369799017906, 0.016108067706227303, 0.037841979414224625, -0.013817960396409035, 0.07314101606607437, 0.05893303453922272, -0.028924601152539253, 0.011390027590095997, -0.03479984402656555, -0.02545884996652603, 0.0279631856828928, 0.022453999146819115, -0.005238856188952923, 0.028930185362696648, 0.01126677356660366, 0.03150218725204468, -0.015153066255152225, 0.06926426291465759, 0.07824215292930603, 0.0024977324064821005, -0.003093477338552475, -0.036576252430677414, -0.010032583959400654, -0.0403447300195694, -0.017839398235082626, -0.008254720829427242, 0.005542293190956116, 0.06519963592290878, 0.02709372527897358, -0.03666771948337555, 0.03385419398546219, 0.03720387443900108, 0.01405966654419899, 0.0007881047204136848, -0.042735885828733444, -0.026750925928354263, -0.0546342097222805, -0.0072664497420191765, 0.02539204992353916, -0.02065323293209076, -0.022477345541119576, -0.0011244756169617176, 0.0674012303352356, -0.02607528492808342, -0.013268294744193554, -0.016430897638201714, -0.0006715292111039162, 0.02243788167834282, 0.01636839099228382, -0.025601068511605263, 0.024774102494120598, 0.044596828520298004, 0.027041958644986153, -0.0022607422433793545, 0.02439369075000286, -0.03298055753111839, -0.024412639439105988, 0.02093336544930935, 0.06145668774843216, -0.03127788379788399, 0.012260557152330875, -0.03731503710150719, 0.0031708483584225178, 0.014541723765432835, -0.02911374531686306, 0.07216856628656387, 0.0047112093307077885, 0.0063162208534777164, -0.01469375193119049, -0.023062603548169136, -0.05122213810682297, 0.023871444165706635, -0.00790536217391491, 0.016681265085935593, 0.01514470111578703, 0.009309877641499043, -0.040718257427215576, -0.000312808551825583, 0.033968787640333176, 0.09071742743253708, 0.001024543191306293, -0.010602455586194992, -0.0072778332978487015, -0.002011347096413374, -0.00016755860997363925, -0.0558965690433979, 0.012112187221646309, 0.012987724505364895, -0.007607194595038891, 0.029670529067516327, -0.02055182494223118, -0.03416748344898224, 0.03492354974150658, 0.016578830778598785, -0.020181436091661453, 0.043656595051288605, -0.00773723004385829, 0.04847889393568039, 0.06129112094640732, -0.01808592863380909, 0.031088724732398987, 0.01607806421816349, -0.00631266413256526, -0.0243111252784729, -0.010597197338938713, 0.009368444792926311, -0.035590291023254395, -0.005880394950509071, -0.05383237823843956, 0.0067595308646559715, -0.010072216391563416, 0.004619880113750696, -0.008808447048068047, 0.03666965663433075, -0.017563439905643463, 0.00010992013267241418, -0.04429720714688301, 0.01992124505341053, 0.036659467965364456, -0.0014783460646867752, -0.007858794182538986, -0.0024140935856848955, 0.005183313507586718, -0.02156473509967327, 0.008316935040056705, -0.007443954702466726, 0.010796129703521729, 0.015914099290966988, -0.025781067088246346, 0.02841983735561371, -0.05197316035628319, -0.03866471350193024, -0.016430409625172615, -0.022541485726833344, 0.03872855752706528, 0.008139080367982388, 0.0046880217269063, 0.00111867964733392, -0.02436484396457672, -0.027310675010085106, 0.021935507655143738, 0.010340034030377865, -0.01866450533270836, -0.05032939091324806, 0.012413623742759228, 0.027514267712831497, -0.037247490137815475, -0.05556505545973778, -0.02507954277098179, 0.02596237324178219, 0.0013393913395702839, -0.036480702459812164, -0.045415136963129044, 0.012179962359368801, -0.0043885549530386925, -0.016400471329689026, -0.008566901087760925, 0.05597642436623573, 0.0029801777563989162, -0.015142095275223255, -0.03754730150103569, -0.013117621652781963, 0.05343161150813103, 0.015331092290580273, -0.018023928627371788, 0.033403005450963974, -0.012457573786377907, -0.031021464616060257, -0.013277851045131683, -0.0033537736162543297, -0.033468492329120636, 0.0043256101198494434, -0.0029794620350003242, 0.011784427799284458, 0.027430083602666855, -0.01645609550178051, -0.0024827683810144663, -0.005862949416041374, 0.017303060740232468, 0.005312264431267977, -0.023791352286934853, -0.02764514647424221, -0.01908853091299534, 0.027691254392266273, -0.01665416546165943, 0.00559975765645504, 0.017875822260975838, -0.03662737458944321, 0.03275323286652565, -0.030711140483617783, -0.011805440299212933, 0.026079805567860603, 0.09042943269014359, -0.03463238850235939, -0.013733450323343277, 0.0021269333083182573, -0.017694048583507538, 0.029180359095335007, -0.01713741384446621, -0.022290805354714394, 0.03927971050143242, 0.02896270900964737, -0.04823016747832298, -0.029677443206310272, -0.017309730872511864, 0.028859391808509827, 0.06836173683404922, -0.059938203543424606, 0.044971976429224014, 0.04123559221625328, -0.013445562683045864, -0.009523606859147549, -0.017274677753448486, -0.01875479333102703, -0.029167527332901955, -0.008146855980157852, 0.06391873955726624, -0.031290341168642044, -0.00005346539182937704, 0.06832141429185867, -0.023707007989287376, 0.00545573839917779, 0.023067167028784752, 0.0026787922251969576, 0.017247823998332024, 0.02110827900469303, -0.02568313106894493, -0.0347452387213707, 0.022828320041298866, -0.022536326199769974, 0.008677850477397442, -0.019495254382491112, -0.06568028032779694, 0.03138801082968712, 0.02405531518161297, -0.007324126549065113, -0.02844262681901455, -0.04051227495074272, 0.008650548756122589, 0.01092815026640892, -0.0037921068724244833, 0.003576737130060792, 0.05862925946712494, -0.009630720131099224, 0.050949327647686005, -0.00550124142318964, 0.014704180881381035, -0.03140486776828766, -0.008847746066749096, 0.01719263754785061, -0.044460952281951904, -0.045216649770736694, -0.0035347563680261374, 0.008777659386396408, -0.014003319665789604, 0.05240578204393387, -0.022911420091986656, -0.0067800236865878105, 0.009183656424283981, 0.009031364694237709, -0.019684728235006332, 0.09485535323619843, 0.051048394292593, 0.02342670038342476, 0.004466602578759193, -0.02774757333099842, 0.10249028354883194, 0.06508364528417587, 0.0191832073032856, -0.06100371107459068, 0.026809168979525566, -0.02774704433977604, 0.00821083877235651, -0.020610695704817772, 0.006761692930012941, 0.019146734848618507, 0.004187343642115593, 0.015942389145493507, 0.02753596194088459, 0.0011400188086554408, 0.0009162072092294693, 0.03330696001648903, -0.04268072172999382, -0.010006937198340893, -0.007258137222379446, 0.001016814960166812, -0.012052226811647415, 0.0038573311176151037, -0.04596325010061264, 0.021495549008250237, -0.004003371112048626, -0.018103403970599174, -0.04221726953983307, -0.03678366169333458, -0.021250467747449875, -0.028050081804394722, -0.011370516382157803, -0.03654906898736954, 0.04330550506711006, -0.02003605291247368, 0.003614137414842844, 0.013507151044905186, -0.0010222684359177947, -0.03886599838733673, 0.01445408072322607, 0.03445346653461456, 0.013830187730491161, 0.04266422614455223, 0.03302772715687752, 0.025881752371788025, -0.04563746601343155, -0.020943671464920044, -0.0480106845498085, 0.012511009350419044, -0.048278260976076126, 0.020371530205011368, -0.005998832639306784, -0.04489936679601669, -0.006798960268497467, -0.010607961565256119, -0.022279566153883934, 0.03175096586346626, 0.04080190509557724, -0.04250695928931236, -0.018714675679802895, -0.004639150109142065, 0.029139457270503044, -0.011837031692266464, 0.02231925167143345, 0.024162638932466507, -0.04454617202281952, -0.00961239542812109, -0.03791190683841705, 0.058973345905542374, -0.016489285975694656, 0.013190598227083683, -0.039436858147382736, -0.004428077954798937, 0.004866590723395348, -0.014772286638617516, 0.04049988090991974, -0.011618800461292267, 0.020322857424616814, 0.019035592675209045, -0.04347291588783264, 0.002447803970426321, -0.05483724921941757, 0.015120499767363071, -0.03987222909927368, -0.007256367243826389, -0.061359528452157974, -0.03622584044933319, 0.014855177141726017, 0.006866263225674629, 0.00911816768348217, -0.007916641421616077, -0.017947101965546608, 0.0383903793990612, -0.0042091114446520805, -0.04097379744052887, -0.002705578226596117, -0.0044936807826161385, 0.0034306179732084274, -0.013979836367070675, -0.04131840914487839, 0.06401282548904419, 0.01526384986937046, 0.03612610697746277, 0.016298852860927582, 0.001713697798550129, -0.026437800377607346, 0.03264855220913887, 0.0012264057295396924, -0.0329827256500721, 0.02661811374127865, 0.037984054535627365, 0.014938091859221458, -0.026300936937332153, -0.001609069760888815, 0.01466837152838707, -0.030147725716233253, 0.01589714176952839, -0.00906241312623024, -0.041284311562776566, -0.03458936884999275, -0.033854663372039795, 0.005811947397887707, -0.030281340703368187, -0.01061374694108963, -0.006417693104594946, 0.043152838945388794, 0.0012918009888380766, -0.015160233713686466, -0.04214930161833763, -0.006886043585836887, 0.01619883067905903, -0.00953808706253767, 0.014949843287467957, 0.02207048237323761, 0.011728719808161259, 0.02426883392035961, -0.009155490435659885, 0.0010384166380390525, 0.028542552143335342, -0.03060678020119667, -0.02346900850534439, 0.05254773795604706, -0.07411648333072662, -0.026259420439600945, 0.01513751968741417, 0.048004139214754105, 0.05222519859671593, 0.012444487772881985, -0.004621932748705149, -0.03095928207039833, 0.022247815504670143, -0.034329984337091446, -0.019461337476968765, -0.008206378668546677, 0.008965176530182362, 0.010644963942468166, -0.044607631862163544, -0.010725091211497784, -0.01877603493630886, -0.005247429013252258, -0.00875029619783163, 0.025855837389826775, -0.014709126204252243, 0.0018247897969558835, 0.06312423944473267, -0.0028677249792963266, 0.015256492421030998, -0.006048308685421944, -0.01972285658121109, 0.03868110477924347, 0.04874216392636299, 0.002497294684872031, 0.04220600426197052, -0.0223856121301651, 0.02252022735774517, -0.08761900663375854, -0.00955092441290617, 0.04355613887310028, -0.022769832983613014, 0.043287117034196854, -0.05361626669764519, -0.03345765545964241, 0.006989958230406046, -0.00930898915976286, -0.005778553895652294, 0.007846142165362835, -0.0008027919102460146, -0.0267892237752676, 0.035912610590457916, -0.06441560387611389, 0.02561280131340027, 0.013560372404754162, 0.022773142904043198, 0.05345192179083824, 0.0139413857832551, -0.022414924576878548, -0.0305054672062397, 0.011010603979229927, 0.022634919732809067, 0.00913128163665533, -0.05037832632660866, 0.042613886296749115, -0.006934077944606543, -0.021348902955651283, 0.037279579788446426, 0.0011548115871846676, -0.0065089017152786255, -0.022260863333940506, 0.003961796872317791, 0.022725941613316536, 0.02384703792631626, 0.021209068596363068, -0.012329141609370708, -0.015910634770989418, -0.03002527356147766, 0.033105168491601944, -0.014844409190118313, -0.025430621579289436, -0.0019972880836576223, 0.08747076988220215, 0.025571519508957863, -0.030952969565987587, 0.030035344883799553, 0.018272394314408302, -0.03744304180145264, 0.001621666015125811, 0.026971029117703438, 0.03100757859647274, -0.022593483328819275, 0.03618059307336807, -0.028348242864012718, -0.07293956726789474, 0.024485819041728973, -0.017018243670463562, -0.017704147845506668, 0.0297094639390707, -0.011331369169056416, -0.05819111317396164, 0.040436752140522, 0.016416138038039207, -0.01951545476913452, -0.0370931439101696, -0.010729292407631874, 0.01672363094985485, -0.008439471945166588, -0.028316602110862732, -0.0354820154607296, -0.04692922160029411, -0.005234445910900831, -0.02482375130057335, 0.021773947402834892, -0.01816740818321705, -0.010785017162561417, 0.03303177282214165, -0.07320881634950638, 0.04173959419131279, -0.016200341284275055, -0.021795373409986496, -0.011079885996878147, -0.011067276820540428, -0.020107736811041832, -0.006951566319912672, 0.038175299763679504, 0.014799173921346664, -0.02034784108400345, -0.0045362673699855804, 0.04993122071027756, 0.029972705990076065, -0.051293518394231796, 0.032896485179662704, -0.03934762254357338, -0.01339623611420393, -0.02171432413160801, 0.0033476476091891527, 0.024074964225292206, 0.004262262023985386, 0.003768753260374069, -0.03299218788743019, 0.00526111014187336, -0.020568381994962692, 0.02750837802886963, 0.01252555102109909, 0.0012124166823923588, -0.014505218714475632, 0.05875597894191742, -0.022764015942811966, 0.019085992127656937, -0.0077463313937187195, 0.020692801102995872, -0.04862966015934944, 0.02593766711652279, -0.04079623892903328, -0.05640781298279762, -0.00830025877803564, 0.0036740023642778397, 0.012773249298334122, -0.07722577452659607, -0.026119304820895195, 0.027716562151908875, -0.01983906701207161, -0.04081417992711067, 0.030383912846446037, 0.02237161621451378, 0.05608350783586502, -0.0006025051116012037, 0.014699101448059082, -0.026387492194771767, -0.030618946999311447, -0.0018676506588235497, -0.010947074741125107, 0.01650705561041832, -0.01233531255275011, 0.002552618505433202, 0.01430598460137844, -0.019305840134620667, 0.03466087952256203, -0.007710984442383051, 0.0328318290412426, -0.004378220997750759, -0.025108009576797485, 0.014488312415778637, 0.00006645214307354763, -0.008725068531930447, -0.03604252263903618, -0.02574528567492962, 0.032168157398700714, 0.012356264516711235, 0.011837161146104336, -0.02611793391406536, 0.016444716602563858, -0.04260317608714104, 0.0037200062070041895, 0.04128038510680199, 0.04145994037389755, -0.0063058966770768166, -0.012398174032568932, 0.012740803882479668, 0.021406373009085655, 0.011943546123802662, 0.03669429197907448, 0.041277673095464706, -0.021225495263934135, -0.020079253241419792, -0.00780566968023777, -0.055421821773052216, -0.003026879858225584, -0.06034053489565849, 0.008941472508013248, 0.03186466544866562, 0.015513265505433083, 0.0029105087742209435, 0.004493220243602991, 0.009458078071475029, 0.06316159665584564, -0.06866801530122757, -0.027086637914180756, -0.05640406906604767, 0.0012856234097853303, 0.018244687467813492, -0.02519921585917473 ]
<p>I'm trying to do some exploratory analysis on some weather. I'd like to do a multiple linear regression on my data and then plot the predicted value against the actual value. Here's where I've got so far: </p> <pre><code>data&lt;-read.csv("Amsterdam.csv", header=TRUE) data2&lt;-data[SolarAltitude&gt;0,] data2.lm&lt;-lm(DirectRadiation ~ DryBulbTemperature + RelHum +AtmosphericPressure, data=data2) data.data.frame(data2,fitted.value=fitted(data2.lm),residual=resid(data2.lm)) </code></pre> <p>If you could help, I would be very grateful,</p>
73,516
[ -0.02348332852125168, -0.025303231552243233, -0.01004812028259039, 0.028336722403764725, 0.005342896096408367, -0.009037802927196026, -0.0034471750259399414, -0.025960171595215797, 0.026998817920684814, -0.03595283254981041, 0.0568632036447525, 0.03404787555336952, 0.06404717266559601, 0.006090483162552118, 0.04833756014704704, -0.0068517993204295635, -0.016061458736658096, 0.005387932062149048, 0.011815921403467655, -0.012159399688243866, -0.022405080497264862, -0.014642889611423016, -0.02627333253622055, 0.0049308487214148045, 0.0102284150198102, 0.05549377575516701, 0.04279868304729462, 0.028912868350744247, 0.00833654124289751, 0.0397319458425045, -0.05481082946062088, -0.054941099137067795, 0.02018051967024803, 0.028624141588807106, 0.051632482558488846, 0.034506574273109436, 0.01324631366878748, -0.03400266170501709, -0.022004177793860435, 0.04290039464831352, 0.002797761932015419, -0.030183609575033188, -0.002878160448744893, 0.04282258823513985, 0.0085702920332551, 0.008386543020606041, 0.017350222915410995, -0.0014820267679169774, 0.05946006998419762, -0.022827213630080223, 0.09508610516786575, -0.014797231182456017, 0.04216349124908447, 0.034821074455976486, -0.05823402479290962, -0.0017268809024244547, 0.06660331785678864, 0.0712968036532402, 0.023722058162093163, -0.042727887630462646, 0.004213265143334866, -0.028952399268746376, -0.030235884711146355, -0.014693092554807663, -0.0593012273311615, -0.03264036029577255, -0.0054039061069488525, -0.021716145798563957, 0.03308045491576195, -0.021425960585474968, 0.040949735790491104, -0.009863541461527348, 0.05078960955142975, -0.05782187730073929, -0.001740326639264822, 0.004432582296431065, 0.0053605870343744755, 0.014223366975784302, 0.008334849029779434, -0.0054135918617248535, 0.011215348728001118, 0.041065558791160583, 0.030603276565670967, 0.04080568253993988, 0.016210684552788734, 0.0029294409323483706, 0.05097365379333496, -0.01271076314151287, 0.06754019856452942, 0.009303025901317596, -0.014306709170341492, 0.018056906759738922, 0.04622885584831238, 0.015127218328416348, -0.019480204209685326, 0.01636548526585102, -0.021384024992585182, 0.03303590416908264, -0.005579288117587566, -0.02320070005953312, 0.0072556412778794765, 0.01829739287495613, 0.03464628756046295, 0.02310122922062874, -0.03073187917470932, -0.02536558173596859, -0.009456159546971321, -0.013912983238697052, 0.0326809287071228, -0.007433743216097355, -0.01980738155543804, 0.01724063791334629, -0.01004735566675663, -0.029490415006875992, 0.015809981152415276, -0.05349090322852135, -0.007306496612727642, 0.045415278524160385, 0.05121183022856712, 0.06264663487672806, 0.03841089457273483, -0.021322350949048996, 0.035066451877355576, 0.004005592316389084, -0.007402322720736265, 0.0132084796205163, 0.009212180972099304, 0.020205378532409668, -0.030057771131396294, 0.043853722512722015, -0.013292314484715462, -0.02262832596898079, 0.025488311424851418, -0.0021556117571890354, 0.04794493317604065, -0.03482756018638611, -0.10270582884550095, -0.0588717944920063, 0.005201717372983694, -0.025188542902469635, 0.025907114148139954, -0.03285571560263634, 0.0067131719551980495, 0.011437899433076382, 0.07163675129413605, 0.028674740344285965, 0.02864038199186325, -0.011620261706411839, 0.01263242494314909, 0.007326397113502026, -0.0402352474629879, -0.003756540594622493, 0.009446606040000916, -0.01836731657385826, -0.021815026178956032, -0.08256299793720245, -0.008569951169192791, 0.03260720148682594, -0.005528684705495834, 0.017651988193392754, 0.05688879266381264, -0.011315745301544666, 0.018123256042599678, -0.01850239560008049, -0.016346868127584457, -0.03904528543353081, 0.08799196034669876, -0.008269421756267548, -0.014512541703879833, -0.0005542628350667655, 0.01134512946009636, 0.014651312492787838, -0.003726723836734891, 0.05940290167927742, 0.0468510165810585, -0.0003680430818349123, -0.0018299600342288613, -0.025823410600423813, 0.04342678561806679, 0.005879536271095276, -0.060014527291059494, -0.011322670616209507, 0.004385396372526884, -0.02794319950044155, 0.019260013476014137, 0.04142673686146736, -0.002217513509094715, -0.044229116290807724, 0.04521312937140465, -0.06598202139139175, -0.007647036109119654, -0.05618201568722725, 0.000524970586411655, -0.030436931177973747, -0.009218384511768818, -0.010332781821489334, 0.010354609228670597, 0.047499753534793854, -0.0004299076972529292, -0.028714919462800026, -0.002807219047099352, 0.0000656424745102413, 0.058801282197237015, -0.014952920377254486, -0.028520943596959114, 0.05432915687561035, 0.06485572457313538, -0.020630396902561188, 0.0281774140894413, -0.04977511242032051, -0.022239236161112785, 0.013870157301425934, -0.05265131592750549, -0.0009159703040495515, -0.006762098055332899, -0.01626742072403431, -0.002921910025179386, 0.011442570015788078, -0.015495343133807182, 0.020321428775787354, -0.030123775824904442, 0.041749563068151474, 0.07818884402513504, 0.011762558482587337, -0.007858333177864552, -0.028616921976208687, -0.016525955870747566, 0.007079849485307932, -0.03886549547314644, -0.012504717335104942, -0.03179435804486275, -0.015139203518629074, 0.017238270491361618, 0.003921763505786657, -0.002063753781840205, 0.02150668203830719, 0.05105022341012955, 0.005130447912961245, 0.01629185676574707, 0.045840222388505936, -0.007252424955368042, 0.0009517692378722131, -0.012879863381385803, 0.018612580373883247, 0.00384018593467772, -0.014498905278742313, 0.024965401738882065, 0.04823821783065796, 0.04865405336022377, -0.041668228805065155, -0.0024360292591154575, 0.0900513231754303, -0.022631868720054626, -0.018054872751235962, -0.007651500403881073, -0.01584887132048607, 0.06877530366182327, -0.031410276889801025, 0.00971726793795824, 0.05868614464998245, 0.0023804078809916973, -0.0065296911634504795, -0.019704928621649742, -0.019573023542761803, 0.008668845519423485, 0.03351357951760292, -0.02451471984386444, -0.0032084640115499496, 0.022392481565475464, -0.05077958479523659, 0.023911282420158386, -0.02969687059521675, -0.004812245257198811, -0.03957221657037735, 0.03285001218318939, 0.029501019045710564, 0.03781301528215408, 0.012195908464491367, -0.01268257200717926, -0.06552722305059433, -0.004530622623860836, -0.04596823453903198, 0.027151169255375862, -0.015313351526856422, -0.02919301763176918, 0.0002418671065242961, -0.0023242109455168247, -0.03702128306031227, 0.03809463605284691, 0.021861983463168144, -0.01813267543911934, 0.04785238206386566, -0.027862994000315666, -0.04920266941189766, -0.042877666652202606, -0.03780457377433777, -0.004337393678724766, -0.018231967464089394, -0.053331710398197174, 0.04684978723526001, 0.0022513559088110924, -0.03444841131567955, -0.00722168106585741, -0.05068635568022728, 0.0092023815959692, -0.022253716364502907, -0.013876940123736858, 0.027334067970514297, 0.004834929946810007, 0.019203200936317444, 0.028736736625432968, -0.0035670152865350246, -0.0030392566695809364, -0.05018129572272301, -0.058180999010801315, 0.015463065356016159, 0.03508254885673523, -0.014232713729143143, -0.00302198831923306, -0.010848337784409523, 0.051959820091724396, 0.02012546919286251, -0.0038310957606881857, -0.06930387765169144, -0.006805643904954195, -0.004854369442909956, -0.03997492790222168, 0.01240685023367405, -0.02013007178902626, 0.03128638491034508, 0.025738775730133057, -0.014780289493501186, 0.005830987356603146, 0.030581897124648094, -0.01369538065046072, 0.01341200154274702, -0.025523031130433083, -0.0029600977431982756, -0.013083316385746002, 0.05594215914607048, 0.013034868985414505, -0.02658833935856819, 0.018177403137087822, -0.00016345226322300732, 0.0026924717240035534, -0.00013575772754848003, -0.03904705494642258, 0.0009288666769862175, 0.00968867726624012, 0.02170330099761486, -0.04274989664554596, -0.0031455683056265116, -0.006691647693514824, -0.054491449147462845, 0.022605810314416885, 0.0007654301007278264, 0.042427968233823776, -0.020294969901442528, -0.014494974166154861, 0.04565678909420967, 0.02522725984454155, -0.023901917040348053, 0.0018883609445765615, 0.022677188739180565, 0.002746154088526964, -0.004445064812898636, 0.001323163858614862, -0.02131258137524128, 0.04822845757007599, 0.024634763598442078, 0.01826929673552513, 0.01964682899415493, -0.04535475745797157, 0.04154064878821373, -0.0327155664563179, 0.006952349562197924, -0.015033088624477386, 0.07017718255519867, 0.00448742788285017, 0.0646105483174324, 0.01971631683409214, -0.029865330085158348, 0.05217975750565529, -0.007834415882825851, -0.0664798840880394, 0.07965853810310364, 0.002145130420103669, 0.0025375785771757364, 0.01280906144529581, 0.0019916638266295195, 0.025781085714697838, -0.03375730663537979, 0.031961262226104736, 0.019859792664647102, 0.02891439013183117, -0.01379654835909605, -0.015550953336060047, -0.018558118492364883, -0.01972438395023346, -0.025943856686353683, 0.007705556694418192, 0.03146882355213165, -0.022058868780732155, 0.023585820570588112, 0.0580936037003994, -0.0018657997716218233, -0.020990045741200447, -0.015051978640258312, -0.006432295311242342, 0.021063782274723053, 0.030834337696433067, 0.05075128749012947, -0.01046764850616455, -0.02817298285663128, -0.00023037687060423195, 0.021209292113780975, 0.01843392290174961, 0.05607688054442406, 0.012279241345822811, -0.013867489993572235, 0.003982109017670155, 0.0031026138458400965, 0.0006648075068369508, -0.0001742042659316212, 0.013254649005830288, -0.005311541259288788, 0.051293935626745224, 0.016942929476499557, -0.03722304105758667, 0.017128199338912964, 0.07954631000757217, -0.017020659521222115, 0.03318535536527634, -0.017319336533546448, 0.013083169236779213, 0.016325052827596664, -0.00014449948503170162, 0.03559497371315956, -0.0053194365464150906, -0.032697100192308426, -0.028858404606580734, 0.05680099502205849, -0.018215598538517952, -0.004773286636918783, 0.03322313725948334, 0.028046730905771255, 0.05294956639409065, 0.021177660673856735, -0.05266315117478371, -0.009328792802989483, 0.06554807722568512, 0.01765105500817299, -0.01680750772356987, -0.0025317904073745012, -0.1168973296880722, 0.024266717955470085, 0.042264971882104874, 0.04372250288724899, -0.02939497120678425, -0.026319386437535286, -0.04023512452840805, 0.0032623521983623505, 0.04235122725367546, -0.046388983726501465, -0.007800951600074768, 0.009560845792293549, 0.02426491677761078, -0.02669503726065159, -0.02815213054418564, -0.07433868199586868, 0.027241531759500504, -0.036518555134534836, 0.019912175834178925, -0.013422857038676739, -0.03265076130628586, -0.041002850979566574, 0.03246267884969711, 0.006135923787951469, 0.045166514813899994, -0.01705349236726761, -0.027529150247573853, 0.0005406346172094345, -0.00883601512759924, -0.009956730529665947, -0.01903923600912094, 0.008304156363010406, -0.01751125603914261, -0.04719270393252373, 0.04970760643482208, 0.019863426685333252, -0.006230985280126333, 0.0207549799233675, 0.03182823210954666, -0.012990602292120457, -0.038823749870061874, -0.0470145158469677, -0.0000342681523761712, 0.033975888043642044, 0.009161373600363731, 0.07265955954790115, 0.02069104090332985, -0.005142417270690203, -0.0027371873147785664, -0.0224965438246727, 0.0181551743298769, 0.012098017148673534, -0.05100604519248009, -0.03557194769382477, -0.0256179291754961, -0.007885856553912163, -0.011258643120527267, 0.008210700936615467, 0.015036245808005333, -0.009943257085978985, -0.0225802231580019, 0.004010114353150129, 0.05628823861479759, -0.0033396293874830008, -0.029078524559736252, -0.00093713344540447, 0.019562451168894768, -0.017289496958255768, -0.015755625441670418, 0.0201104823499918, -0.009245517663657665, 0.004096494521945715, 0.012652109377086163, -0.06307324767112732, 0.029610682278871536, 0.022780388593673706, -0.007621157914400101, -0.007856409065425396, -0.04773399233818054, -0.012668129988014698, -0.007158863358199596, 0.025648171082139015, 0.010777954943478107, -0.06794064491987228, -0.013521355576813221, 0.01084571797400713, 0.003808680921792984, 0.0010718711419031024, -0.04304952174425125, 0.04306451976299286, -0.011671274900436401, -0.024031823500990868, -0.04009265452623367, -0.047139063477516174, 0.006512912455946207, -0.016487235203385353, -0.03573208302259445, -0.039865534752607346, -0.06986808776855469, -0.033479366451501846, -0.0015856344252824783, -0.01088344119489193, 0.027003511786460876, -0.0401749312877655, 0.012087186798453331, 0.014834241941571236, -0.0057557919062674046, 0.0363415889441967, -0.02213989943265915, 0.012697494588792324, -0.0005711208214052022, -0.002863525180146098, -0.041563086211681366, 0.011287800967693329, 0.0012440962018445134, -0.02673543617129326, 0.00010923325316980481, -0.026212282478809357, 0.011341281235218048, 0.0566009096801281, -0.003325056517496705, -0.004911436699330807, -0.011661479249596596, 0.03614846616983414, 0.005273616407066584, -0.031186293810606003, -0.004720214754343033, -0.017014730721712112, -0.017653807997703552, -0.006748192012310028, -0.02174265868961811, 0.0027199420146644115, -0.002824625466018915, 0.0011453530751168728, 0.010924243368208408, 0.020520566031336784, 0.04037926718592644, 0.08516422659158707, 0.010701963678002357, 0.03473466634750366, -0.006471936125308275, -0.012636191211640835, 0.009829781018197536, 0.0036564962938427925, -0.00897650234401226, -0.025141511112451553, 0.034655530005693436, -0.05540957674384117, -0.019791873171925545, -0.02113042026758194, -0.025393180549144745, 0.05983634665608406, -0.02060432732105255, 0.05177275091409683, 0.060515791177749634, 0.04512028023600578, 0.01918807253241539, -0.03237910196185112, -0.010366197675466537, 0.000620152335613966, 0.01776748150587082, 0.05095970258116722, -0.01659436523914337, -0.0027710639405995607, -0.0002678297460079193, -0.005902480334043503, 0.01765579544007778, 0.03451792150735855, -0.0002714264555834234, 0.017293164506554604, 0.015981275588274002, 0.012158583849668503, -0.024041853845119476, 0.008153818547725677, -0.003108150092884898, 0.00383985647931695, -0.0188381839543581, -0.020374499261379242, 0.012592528946697712, 0.017334027215838432, -0.02564781904220581, -0.03156481310725212, -0.020957335829734802, -0.07512066513299942, 0.014843568205833435, 0.039160408079624176, -0.01915256679058075, 0.021288955584168434, 0.03741913288831711, 0.03481601923704147, -0.021083442494273186, 0.02179400622844696, -0.028243854641914368, -0.0652899444103241, 0.00017858917999546975, -0.04758363217115402, -0.018808379769325256, 0.05725433677434921, 0.009341702796518803, -0.03722856193780899, 0.030742332339286804, -0.038792870938777924, 0.022635050117969513, 0.019421279430389404, 0.06008505821228027, 0.05184755101799965, 0.0503566712141037, -0.017785239964723587, -0.039394646883010864, 0.01245418656617403, -0.015013979747891426, 0.11858957260847092, 0.09010327607393265, 0.016907205805182457, -0.08285485953092575, -0.005203337408602238, 0.022999046370387077, -0.014038033783435822, -0.022753987461328506, 0.0021073627285659313, -0.014065182767808437, 0.013118227943778038, 0.04778880625963211, 0.02127569541335106, 0.00589276198297739, 0.04125169292092323, 0.01895400695502758, -0.010984509252011776, -0.010298220440745354, 0.004487648140639067, 0.010614893399178982, -0.01472311932593584, -0.006042446009814739, -0.07501193881034851, 0.025303127244114876, -0.02257971093058586, -0.013152875006198883, -0.007531242445111275, -0.026040615513920784, 0.015628933906555176, -0.004730836488306522, -0.039895083755254745, 0.02955472283065319, 0.012558107264339924, 0.04001918435096741, -0.02769644744694233, 0.02398008480668068, 0.02200930379331112, -0.017726704478263855, 0.004224675241857767, 0.025679688900709152, 0.009257429279386997, 0.008342190645635128, -0.031015127897262573, 0.00878794863820076, -0.02684878744184971, -0.019880743697285652, -0.031028185039758682, 0.04665321856737137, 0.009241358377039433, -0.03320888429880142, 0.0020941905677318573, 0.02580040507018566, -0.0002948812034446746, -0.008527930825948715, -0.0035125943832099438, 0.014769905246794224, 0.03456439450383186, -0.06896442919969559, -0.018394790589809418, -0.013758770190179348, 0.016429459676146507, -0.016358571127057076, 0.027180401608347893, 0.0384753979742527, -0.00565678533166647, 0.003204833948984742, -0.0708194226026535, 0.04961589351296425, -0.003842748934403062, -0.005155303981155157, 0.03098004311323166, -0.004522756673395634, -0.016679318621754646, -0.032563865184783936, 0.08102564513683319, 0.00610786909237504, 0.013139385730028152, 0.007339438423514366, -0.024899547919631004, -0.03066669963300228, -0.02487662062048912, 0.02210872806608677, -0.04947451502084732, -0.018537329509854317, -0.0015858893748372793, 0.02408534102141857, 0.0439167357981205, 0.020976465195417404, 0.014104373753070831, -0.020889190956950188, 0.004443741403520107, 0.018324358388781548, 0.00776462908834219, -0.06081055477261543, -0.003679579822346568, 0.037972163408994675, -0.018058571964502335, 0.018509062007069588, -0.021458953619003296, 0.061761680990457535, 0.0019530761055648327, 0.029428841546177864, -0.03245685622096062, 0.014505776576697826, -0.026720015332102776, -0.013744157738983631, 0.016683397814631462, -0.05115243420004845, 0.029652981087565422, -0.0014154685195535421, -0.006611565127968788, -0.0028670181054621935, -0.010193167254328728, -0.029275763779878616, -0.04298851639032364, -0.009418005123734474, -0.01528097316622734, -0.034540750086307526, 0.03681030869483948, 0.006421133875846863, 0.0069167884066700935, -0.03729204088449478, -0.008437172509729862, -0.07088887691497803, -0.01190156303346157, -0.0031890575774013996, -0.03745216131210327, -0.037517789751291275, 0.007179739885032177, -0.05925754830241203, -0.007167359814047813, 0.041348595172166824, 0.03522669896483421, 0.02461875230073929, -0.01173107884824276, 0.03154458478093147, -0.02545776590704918, 0.05745134502649307, -0.0007044957601465285, -0.013058573007583618, 0.027937958016991615, -0.03080863691866398, -0.03199693188071251, 0.0035083226393908262, 0.0019142907112836838, 0.060097672045230865, 0.020107023417949677, -0.006190272979438305, -0.018111353740096092, 0.0730612650513649, -0.006566726136952639, 0.013254775665700436, -0.019181855022907257, 0.0000952106129261665, 0.004558346699923277, 0.043187692761421204, 0.00743800587952137, -0.04970328509807587, -0.004088152665644884, 0.009646191261708736, 0.0546250157058239, 0.009207762777805328, 0.017058568075299263, -0.020412147045135498, -0.015043171122670174, 0.01608329452574253, 0.002149047562852502, -0.0164098609238863, 0.03856485337018967, 0.05688445642590523, -0.04579099267721176, 0.03880815580487251, -0.01828611269593239, 0.0012212335132062435, -0.08899570256471634, -0.006491171196103096, -0.005417403765022755, 0.01140164490789175, 0.046918973326683044, -0.04757188260555267, 0.011839739046990871, 0.042109180241823196, 0.022477079182863235, -0.029348010197281837, 0.005697134882211685, -0.010041705332696438, 0.02998790703713894, 0.005837404169142246, -0.031205998733639717, 0.011168108321726322, 0.067086361348629, 0.0240225438028574, 0.03085394576191902, 0.026703311130404472, 0.04211439937353134, -0.010089114308357239, -0.036054909229278564, 0.0070467013865709305, 0.039003655314445496, -0.0746319517493248, 0.003498456906527281, -0.029420841485261917, -0.004867150913923979, 0.0060647898353636265, -0.03043806366622448, 0.014277337118983269, 0.0028563670348376036, 0.016882726922631264, 0.021120604127645493, 0.0730777308344841, 0.00039457782986573875, 0.013647573068737984, -0.03375899791717529, -0.014009957201778889, 0.047962408512830734, -0.027601834386587143, -0.024857880547642708, 0.03624627739191055, 0.004360247869044542, 0.023276980966329575, -0.046481210738420486, 0.048797622323036194, -0.007872763089835644, -0.006555796600878239, -0.0031228733714669943, 0.024450942873954773, 0.012953856959939003, -0.06267354637384415, -0.002641465747728944, -0.024985652416944504, -0.01849842630326748, 0.026234908029437065, 0.023260947316884995, -0.03843357786536217, 0.009346910752356052, 0.010739771649241447, -0.04592432454228401, 0.012851622886955738, -0.013398932293057442, -0.034787438809871674, -0.050133224576711655, -0.013444422744214535, -0.01476281601935625, -0.05203670635819435, -0.029825754463672638, -0.008290042169392109, -0.049755826592445374, 0.004381220787763596, -0.03500878065824509, 0.004178233444690704, 0.028464628383517265, -0.04267780855298042, 0.04030511900782585, -0.09651429951190948, 0.06809558719396591, -0.02735944278538227, -0.006232307292521, -0.029376091435551643, -0.001005039899609983, -0.012667790986597538, 0.028560692444443703, 0.008268495090305805, -0.008984366431832314, 0.017914490774273872, -0.027682051062583923, 0.003970420453697443, -0.007777956314384937, -0.042400848120450974, 0.034289442002773285, 0.028172871097922325, -0.057916462421417236, 0.004516825545579195, 0.0004552564350888133, 0.00801895558834076, 0.00609894935041666, 0.04493673890829086, -0.00013910669076722115, 0.009166335687041283, 0.00003505753556964919, -0.017995376139879227, 0.013799532316625118, -0.015181561931967735, -0.030576135963201523, 0.048949990421533585, -0.005665802396833897, 0.01963042840361595, 0.061169352382421494, 0.016516873612999916, -0.0320345014333725, 0.0318298377096653, 0.005092092324048281, -0.002823346760123968, -0.004213752690702677, -0.049678027629852295, -0.011842379346489906, -0.05174959450960159, 0.01303926669061184, -0.005893385969102383, -0.007608435582369566, 0.0049372450448572636, 0.05136726796627045, -0.014057894237339497, 0.002800953108817339, -0.004896547179669142, 0.024265224114060402, -0.001572982408106327, -0.02255983091890812, 0.006088619120419025, 0.013014622032642365, 0.01868724636733532, 0.0022861496545374393, 0.014671765267848969, 0.030303707346320152, -0.007550826761871576, -0.002786050783470273, -0.04612135887145996, 0.04877905547618866, -0.026696398854255676, -0.019025739282369614, 0.010928322561085224, 0.010821985080838203, 0.016660530120134354, -0.04835832491517067, -0.00403114128857851, 0.0162454042583704, -0.052218351513147354, -0.01388834323734045, -0.03415542095899582, -0.030493997037410736, -0.009125232696533203, 0.026809727773070335, 0.014757942408323288, 0.029157204553484917, -0.005412794649600983, 0.06139329448342323, 0.025090374052524567, -0.007038392126560211, 0.032791413366794586, -0.01138800848275423, 0.00038709244108758867, -0.046318043023347855, -0.02693270891904831, -0.02519727498292923, 0.0010486439568921924, 0.01573948934674263, -0.04312770441174507, 0.020950565114617348, 0.033246658742427826, -0.0086052929982543, -0.04349254444241524, -0.019675984978675842, -0.01288039144128561, 0.01689656637609005, -0.08705180138349533, -0.04464965686202049, -0.033902350813150406, -0.013306948356330395, 0.019902225583791733, -0.03703635185956955 ]
<p>I am running some experiments for a few days now and I am asking myself why this is taking so long. So here is the setup:</p> <p>I am using Weka api and have written some code in Java which automates the process of classifcation. I have a dataset consisting of 17,553 samples that contain some labels. For the top-100 most frequent labels I wish to train a binary classifier and test my algorithm with 5-Fold Cross Validation.</p> <p>This is all running on a dell laptop with centrino dual core with the latest Ubuntu 14.04 LTS and a total of 4GB RAM. It takes roughly about 40-45 minutes to get results of one label. The laptop is now running for more than 2 days and I do not even have all results yet.</p> <p>And also, I am training the SMO classifier found in WEKA with its default parameters.</p> <p>I was just wondering, if this normal?</p> <p>FYI before starting to run 5-fold cross validation, I have made an .ARFF file containing the data and read it in with a BufferedReader. However this had to be done only once in the beginning when the program starts.</p> <p>And also, I am training an SMO classifier as found in WEKA with its default parameters.</p>
35,912
[ -0.01267845369875431, -0.027952538803219795, -0.012822349555790424, 0.0006953942938707769, 0.028781751170754433, -0.014162817969918251, -0.004842596128582954, -0.025657156482338905, -0.01608319580554962, -0.0058381687849760056, 0.03716946393251419, 0.05069328844547272, 0.06256156414747238, 0.03044285625219345, -0.0074537647888064384, -0.03092324547469616, -0.031281620264053345, -0.014365160837769508, -0.015224384143948555, -0.0236725565046072, -0.00968480296432972, 0.044800110161304474, 0.029991991817951202, -0.00543160131201148, -0.02841031365096569, 0.014035017229616642, -0.0021406568121165037, -0.020901182666420937, 0.00009186731040244922, 0.036049600690603256, -0.008197357878088951, -0.044846419245004654, 0.01725708693265915, 0.004189573228359222, 0.016890164464712143, -0.008810305967926979, -0.012281962670385838, -0.05825312063097954, -0.0059481458738446236, 0.036791592836380005, 0.017965395003557205, -0.01885114796459675, 0.0008183940080925822, 0.007132069207727909, 0.021277593448758125, 0.004162924829870462, 0.017938746139407158, -0.00048082423745654523, 0.020417891442775726, -0.023374317213892937, 0.06097519025206566, -0.01317741721868515, 0.04262353852391243, 0.01648370735347271, -0.016565382480621338, -0.0017720831092447042, 0.05013523995876312, 0.0340053029358387, -0.025946728885173798, -0.04208497330546379, 0.00671277055516839, -0.02246725745499134, -0.025595858693122864, -0.005478165112435818, -0.014114524237811565, 0.02422625757753849, -0.043513499200344086, -0.015037151984870434, 0.007563273422420025, 0.007740936242043972, 0.03342900797724724, -0.027428442612290382, 0.06856145709753036, -0.06907913088798523, 0.03181016445159912, -0.0038702317979186773, 0.036446236073970795, 0.009620536118745804, 0.014270530082285404, 0.04772321879863739, -0.006890673656016588, 0.029886877164244652, -0.021020852029323578, 0.018390454351902008, -0.00888870656490326, -0.02010587602853775, 0.04522727429866791, -0.015451408922672272, -0.005413616541773081, 0.03089389204978943, 0.007947741076350212, 0.003045628545805812, 0.04849258437752724, 0.022323831915855408, -0.015478173270821571, 0.03653949499130249, 0.026020033285021782, 0.01899641752243042, -0.004537033382803202, -0.013369825668632984, 0.016553038731217384, -0.04985741153359413, 0.0007690245984122157, 0.03937148302793503, -0.038078755140304565, -0.008857591077685356, -0.037056855857372284, -0.03647907078266144, -0.03434279188513756, 0.02949850633740425, -0.04202161729335785, -0.014063200913369656, -0.013761838898062706, -0.03123265504837036, -0.00509470934048295, 0.018989333882927895, 0.0006246283301152289, 0.02210330404341221, -0.0003839112468995154, 0.06309565901756287, 0.018008066341280937, -0.045143939554691315, 0.04068514704704285, -0.030573032796382904, -0.05045932158827782, 0.02985350415110588, -0.01342736929655075, -0.03318699449300766, -0.05537799373269081, 0.05361014977097511, -0.050425972789525986, -0.028376314789056778, 0.050528138875961304, -0.03906139358878136, 0.051745280623435974, 0.015992162749171257, -0.07774339616298676, -0.07888064533472061, 0.004014191217720509, -0.021770454943180084, 0.027633072808384895, -0.09264376014471054, 0.0021789635065943003, -0.008407838642597198, 0.04328889772295952, 0.006637522019445896, 0.03613930940628052, 0.04177265614271164, 0.014360624365508556, 0.012343307957053185, -0.018637973815202713, -0.026504265144467354, -0.05181298032402992, 0.020653272047638893, -0.008931737393140793, -0.057498835027217865, -0.02293294481933117, -0.0038912510499358177, -0.0023539848625659943, -0.007704604417085648, 0.006286204792559147, 0.01721831038594246, 0.026331592351198196, -0.010547840967774391, -0.00862968061119318, -0.043285027146339417, 0.024924850091338158, 0.05255800113081932, 0.0706266462802887, 0.02520257793366909, -0.007621608208864927, 0.003542587161064148, 0.039031703025102615, 0.014199583791196346, 0.019502118229866028, -0.03614799678325653, -0.01649344339966774, -0.02055199258029461, 0.00018800074758473784, 0.013796912506222725, 0.007002870086580515, -0.02807862125337124, 0.03212922438979149, 0.03271859139204025, -0.04216098040342331, 0.06684454530477524, -0.012504051439464092, -0.02285202033817768, 0.0023948759771883488, -0.06805481016635895, -0.06100928783416748, -0.06971719115972519, -0.006162997335195541, -0.025015173479914665, -0.022026551887392998, 0.040212929248809814, -0.009205657988786697, 0.012597803957760334, 0.0069601647555828094, -0.025974217802286148, -0.034604933112859726, 0.00878273043781519, 0.05267031490802765, -0.015255573205649853, 0.01365361176431179, 0.0355234295129776, -0.029161173850297928, -0.03216995671391487, 0.0372493751347065, -0.04415461793541908, -0.08439109474420547, 0.02764146961271763, -0.03711853176355362, -0.0019297191174700856, -0.03721121698617935, -0.01557561568915844, 0.034406647086143494, 0.009836027398705482, 0.012059377506375313, 0.017969492822885513, -0.03544318675994873, 0.05650568753480911, 0.03584254905581474, 0.012275980785489082, 0.013867976143956184, 0.008639880456030369, 0.026914438232779503, -0.000674221315421164, -0.03127441182732582, 0.012372400611639023, -0.045209404081106186, -0.015262095257639885, 0.051250144839286804, -0.013419844210147858, -0.03687090799212456, -0.0017258896259590983, 0.04996689036488533, 0.02145015075802803, 0.012312227860093117, 0.021808268502354622, 0.01509240921586752, 0.0023915176279842854, 0.0005513901705853641, 0.043910156935453415, 0.015281780622899532, 0.024148020893335342, 0.0016694770893082023, 0.0021603419445455074, 0.0453716404736042, 0.02549005299806595, -0.03482735529541969, 0.04705748334527016, 0.003658026224002242, 0.008081276901066303, -0.007597505114972591, -0.07886306196451187, 0.03097260184586048, -0.001489053713157773, 0.010466343723237514, 0.03210897371172905, 0.027603669092059135, 0.03464159741997719, -0.013277866877615452, -0.01921335607767105, 0.032164059579372406, 0.014426411129534245, -0.004505476448684931, -0.026471784338355064, 0.016175201162695885, -0.06336047500371933, 0.0057912259362638, 0.00023066253925208002, 0.011927138082683086, -0.04629217088222504, 0.0071776448749005795, 0.037019141018390656, 0.008124522864818573, 0.05027827247977257, -0.012910455465316772, -0.0042222635820508, 0.020876502618193626, -0.02801544778048992, 0.03921802341938019, -0.008461412973701954, -0.03033345937728882, 0.0027603839989751577, 0.023391108959913254, -0.011289292946457863, 0.05459726229310036, -0.027756668627262115, -0.010866743512451649, 0.030781961977481842, -0.01373443752527237, -0.04530608654022217, -0.04987351596355438, -0.02366415224969387, 0.013020315207540989, -0.018404129892587662, 0.026035785675048828, 0.064278744161129, 0.006061024032533169, -0.03245994448661804, 0.03151058778166771, -0.015870291739702225, 0.011529757641255856, -0.016892286017537117, -0.00907357968389988, 0.012790472246706486, -0.03354967013001442, -0.03981797769665718, 0.008515345863997936, -0.03614632040262222, 0.004402086604386568, -0.06390129774808884, -0.05743659660220146, 0.0145485270768404, -0.01797722466289997, 0.02572135254740715, -0.0034331195056438446, 0.012331043370068073, 0.03819131478667259, 0.03950416296720505, -0.05621383339166641, -0.055662862956523895, -0.01006607711315155, -0.043042004108428955, -0.029901379719376564, -0.022226084023714066, 0.037293560802936554, 0.008285438641905785, 0.00250832992605865, 0.004527840297669172, 0.03249560296535492, 0.051736000925302505, -0.0007246695458889008, -0.009063765406608582, 0.026952235028147697, 0.00013341460726223886, -0.030004870146512985, 0.038269441574811935, -0.004248486831784248, -0.019424930214881897, -0.002418962772935629, -0.03085957281291485, -0.005841042380779982, 0.027247600257396698, -0.05896862596273422, 0.02493327483534813, -0.03944825008511543, 0.0015306853456422687, -0.0351586677134037, 0.0310283824801445, -0.006590301636606455, -0.05172518268227577, -0.006375142373144627, 0.029760323464870453, 0.04372284933924675, 0.02437586896121502, 0.01486163679510355, 0.03181859478354454, 0.017336321994662285, -0.017159968614578247, -0.02134692668914795, -0.05076899379491806, -0.01822463609278202, 0.0004059048369526863, -0.00012227732804603875, -0.02174542285501957, 0.02572321519255638, 0.027713175863027573, 0.024772807955741882, 0.023794714361429214, -0.07676400989294052, -0.0019313194788992405, -0.06901898980140686, -0.020725242793560028, -0.0075182076543569565, 0.04637433588504791, -0.0021313976030796766, 0.010731860995292664, 0.0034714762587100267, -0.011689833365380764, 0.004556252155452967, -0.006551968865096569, -0.07226407527923584, -0.01847110316157341, -0.01979210413992405, 0.00008976073877420276, 0.016428180038928986, -0.0374627448618412, -0.012371182441711426, -0.02088892087340355, 0.020412646234035492, 0.014210130088031292, 0.04081231728196144, -0.06452317535877228, 0.03499047830700874, 0.006672390270978212, 0.0036753667518496513, -0.033921316266059875, -0.015482989139854908, 0.012800632044672966, -0.013358433730900288, 0.007952095940709114, -0.004407750908285379, -0.025308335199952126, -0.009069103747606277, -0.005119374953210354, -0.0026961201801896095, -0.0218803733587265, 0.047617387026548386, 0.03788670152425766, 0.0629730224609375, -0.06622882932424545, -0.011908154934644699, -0.014792891219258308, 0.04546865448355675, 0.056953176856040955, -0.003357239766046405, 0.002390781184658408, -0.0690208226442337, -0.04339756816625595, 0.02701224572956562, 0.02035866491496563, 0.027863681316375732, 0.030321452766656876, 0.014723440632224083, 0.043728455901145935, -0.036740124225616455, -0.0007779045263305306, 0.08031132072210312, -0.022805023938417435, -0.010045305825769901, -0.05008348822593689, -0.031647760421037674, -0.0048050908371806145, -0.008355104364454746, 0.034437838941812515, 0.02777533233165741, -0.024310261011123657, 0.012585064396262169, -0.011591460555791855, -0.0805850476026535, 0.025373024865984917, 0.035011302679777145, 0.020812291651964188, 0.06287126243114471, -0.014062011614441872, 0.008562873117625713, 0.02559897117316723, 0.05338403582572937, 0.04895216226577759, 0.031049078330397606, -0.019799701869487762, -0.039450615644454956, -0.03489486873149872, 0.053320858627557755, 0.056904032826423645, -0.026632893830537796, 0.03135141730308533, -0.03903955593705177, -0.005928564351052046, 0.021649857982993126, -0.018568675965070724, 0.04372444748878479, 0.011915501207113266, 0.01088766474276781, -0.024440571665763855, 0.004419227596372366, -0.02773808315396309, -0.021810777485370636, -0.025895889848470688, 0.055449988692998886, -0.030216693878173828, -0.0355285108089447, -0.014437892474234104, 0.021585019305348396, 0.010102851316332817, 0.04437101259827614, -0.0018160829786211252, 0.02337847836315632, 0.024742761626839638, -0.007938895374536514, -0.00899811927229166, -0.07263542711734772, -0.02402106486260891, -0.011418373323976994, -0.008112595416605473, 0.036487776786088943, -0.013447368517518044, -0.03135649487376213, 0.04543594270944595, 0.040203455835580826, -0.020940961316227913, -0.05659680813550949, -0.053757842630147934, -0.006434652488678694, 0.038331326097249985, 0.008410383015871048, 0.05753262713551521, 0.01088721677660942, -0.015286367386579514, 0.0023568046744912863, -0.005538235884159803, 0.005345435347408056, -0.028220875188708305, 0.00926135666668415, -0.009911919012665749, -0.026080379262566566, -0.0633639544248581, 0.0336177684366703, -0.011594192124903202, 0.005922230426222086, -0.028795700520277023, 0.0019639702513813972, -0.013533423654735088, 0.016555380076169968, -0.01863889954984188, -0.038395512849092484, 0.010648335330188274, 0.020467519760131836, -0.005750850308686495, -0.0075613087974488735, 0.0063073402270674706, -0.03144238889217377, 0.014310973696410656, 0.014282834716141224, 0.0042450339533388615, 0.0026272376999258995, -0.05034744367003441, -0.0033649750985205173, -0.004863227717578411, -0.014460782520473003, 0.020642057061195374, 0.031396690756082535, 0.06283292919397354, 0.03384149447083473, -0.08540443331003189, -0.021234767511487007, 0.00545507250353694, 0.0020719319581985474, 0.00015207903925329447, -0.01907310076057911, 0.03758981451392174, -0.003350654849782586, 0.012231802567839622, -0.06506245583295822, -0.04369845241308212, 0.0331234335899353, -0.00924376118928194, -0.017439961433410645, -0.021789690479636192, -0.00118345208466053, 0.002709641121327877, -0.039150819182395935, 0.011881898157298565, 0.015593352727591991, -0.011065973900258541, 0.0008708826499059796, 0.006234748754650354, 0.03456849604845047, 0.042055003345012665, 0.027672117576003075, 0.043274104595184326, -0.01867331936955452, 0.030796829611063004, -0.03762220963835716, 0.005253775976598263, -0.015987619757652283, -0.014138184487819672, -0.002665494801476598, -0.01570681855082512, -0.0028358399868011475, 0.004418231081217527, -0.006693997420370579, -0.001745441579259932, 0.04415915533900261, -0.022098079323768616, -0.017729025334119797, 0.0036553910467773676, 0.02917669713497162, 0.0427531898021698, -0.036830827593803406, 0.015770845115184784, 0.0003205894317943603, 0.014113427139818668, -0.036519601941108704, 0.028746619820594788, 0.033435434103012085, 0.02294159308075905, 0.020011840388178825, 0.026408305391669273, -0.023818781599402428, 0.002678532153367996, 0.004758824594318867, -0.041502539068460464, 0.02121097594499588, 0.01967855542898178, -0.006453914567828178, -0.017317034304142, -0.013532211072742939, -0.024336792528629303, 0.041427839547395706, -0.02046870067715645, -0.040973637253046036, 0.04154304414987564, 0.006073871627449989, 0.017206313088536263, 0.037329986691474915, 0.04729803651571274, -0.01818496733903885, -0.04555867239832878, -0.01598484069108963, -0.02774691954255104, 0.022993074730038643, 0.057723645120859146, 0.057926926761865616, 0.010998849757015705, 0.04967439919710159, 0.04958106949925423, 0.025941725820302963, 0.056875091046094894, 0.027263930067420006, 0.02361392416059971, 0.017227988690137863, 0.008034094236791134, -0.05461443215608597, 0.0019535855390131474, -0.0015539282467216253, 0.024004552513360977, -0.01289046835154295, -0.043496016412973404, 0.03149505332112312, -0.013902745209634304, 0.0058592758141458035, -0.0467192642390728, -0.024535102769732475, -0.05160891264677048, 0.019903389737010002, 0.02960643544793129, -0.02247324027121067, 0.020726189017295837, 0.03113042190670967, 0.0356769785284996, 0.03400261700153351, 0.03619449585676193, 0.009808937087655067, -0.06342816352844238, -0.01715095154941082, -0.025431599467992783, -0.0494074709713459, 0.08244962990283966, -0.03191762417554855, -0.042224738746881485, 0.001542786369100213, -0.014587091282010078, 0.0785154178738594, -0.009027800522744656, 0.06775825470685959, 0.023857729509472847, 0.0658986046910286, 0.0018906276673078537, -0.0024944068863987923, -0.0006345591973513365, 0.022625839337706566, 0.13725262880325317, 0.0658501461148262, 0.047942161560058594, -0.008550618775188923, -0.011507684364914894, -0.014795846305787563, 0.004338581580668688, -0.010532367043197155, 0.03096533939242363, -0.020668653771281242, -0.002591097028926015, 0.0467899851500988, -0.023176223039627075, 0.029818199574947357, 0.00398628506809473, 0.051695968955755234, -0.044267911463975906, 0.011760626919567585, 0.00981045514345169, 0.01104710903018713, 0.029483329504728317, -0.005813692230731249, -0.029264017939567566, 0.01126953400671482, -0.03483609855175018, -0.06819220632314682, 0.0023822574876248837, -0.04502153769135475, 0.03377082198858261, -0.026722025126218796, -0.010334914550185204, 0.03531800955533981, -0.017433105036616325, 0.0027318340726196766, -0.027338044717907906, 0.023416152223944664, 0.007743443362414837, 0.022221531718969345, -0.010351630859076977, 0.02279079146683216, 0.05388440564274788, -0.029682444408535957, -0.008797629736363888, 0.0014316027518361807, -0.02023741975426674, -0.023604080080986023, -0.04108424857258797, 0.019644103944301605, -0.020711814984679222, -0.0002885542926378548, 0.00012199042976135388, 0.02823234722018242, 0.02014782838523388, -0.048919398337602615, -0.0077278148382902145, 0.03435288369655609, -0.010916472412645817, -0.031984247267246246, 0.0036276481114327908, -0.03462160378694534, 0.04681329056620598, 0.0004366648499853909, 0.03352109715342522, 0.007256137207150459, 0.0034087032545357943, -0.018787872046232224, -0.032598335295915604, 0.011317932046949863, -0.010712743736803532, 0.004911854397505522, 0.004442930221557617, -0.023221032693982124, -0.0017308358801528811, -0.015986625105142593, 0.052224304527044296, 0.0033790634479373693, -0.015932487323880196, -0.021250665187835693, -0.05738802254199982, -0.030292686074972153, -0.020327052101492882, -0.045269496738910675, -0.019325733184814453, 0.0067457170225679874, -0.05915307626128197, 0.008163193240761757, 0.004230875987559557, 0.014315061271190643, 0.027095934376120567, 0.0021553831174969673, 0.005430388730019331, 0.0531056709587574, 0.011406239122152328, -0.014035884290933609, 0.00021553400438278913, 0.001480950159020722, -0.012980577535927296, 0.051165319979190826, -0.010028096847236156, 0.10664651542901993, 0.0033257585018873215, 0.009294860064983368, 0.01650378108024597, 0.01877392828464508, -0.003916126675903797, 0.02907331846654415, 0.034465767443180084, -0.021236659958958626, 0.0018011070787906647, -0.013545848429203033, -0.011376144364476204, -0.0024427068419754505, -0.03532373160123825, -0.055189892649650574, -0.03925447165966034, 0.025535784661769867, 0.006437522359192371, -0.03531401976943016, 0.03712986409664154, -0.00822746753692627, 0.036357879638671875, -0.032946422696113586, 0.0009513292461633682, -0.04292754828929901, 0.01904633641242981, -0.05204830691218376, -0.005175502505153418, 0.006613359320908785, 0.01676497422158718, 0.006543387193232775, 0.005047662649303675, 0.02027151919901371, 0.02010895311832428, 0.0057090106420218945, 0.02245783619582653, 0.03041844256222248, -0.017196299508213997, 0.018997207283973694, -0.038841310888528824, -0.03181445226073265, 0.04846348240971565, -0.07971023768186569, -0.023031586781144142, 0.03568794205784798, -0.03827947750687599, 0.022534077987074852, 0.026532456278800964, -0.0351439006626606, 0.004736900795251131, 0.09207487106323242, -0.019044410437345505, -0.008568618446588516, 0.015386160463094711, -0.0027511974330991507, 0.0216530729085207, 0.07418527454137802, 0.010229332372546196, -0.00014309710240922868, -0.005614778958261013, 0.009582280181348324, 0.027990421280264854, 0.016248127445578575, 0.005724592134356499, 0.012315341271460056, 0.016147851943969727, 0.034936949610710144, 0.031256452202796936, -0.004331527277827263, -0.0017180483555421233, 0.028297552838921547, -0.009596239775419235, 0.048807911574840546, -0.04989892989397049, 0.011103705503046513, -0.11343217641115189, -0.013168641366064548, -0.03870052844285965, 0.016386335715651512, 0.020944176241755486, -0.04019637778401375, -0.0022031613625586033, 0.03645216301083565, -0.04539300128817558, 0.022111812606453896, -0.013570483773946762, -0.02698715776205063, -0.04196319356560707, -0.013662713579833508, -0.00443161791190505, -0.038345277309417725, 0.07931873947381973, 0.021462509408593178, 0.04423532634973526, 0.03232284262776375, -0.01649138703942299, -0.011590969748795033, -0.023907804861664772, 0.06658118218183517, -0.0023466821294277906, -0.025478919968008995, 0.03402717038989067, -0.013953495770692825, -0.026922890916466713, 0.021609460934996605, 0.0015474926913157105, 0.006609981879591942, 0.06247880682349205, 0.04412207379937172, 0.005722786765545607, 0.029418541118502617, 0.05506599321961403, -0.028036922216415405, 0.013082059100270271, 0.016551125794649124, -0.026534322649240494, 0.022889327257871628, -0.00686361500993371, 0.018634462729096413, 0.0046374863013625145, -0.0005135054234415293, -0.02505047433078289, 0.02296075038611889, -0.016945580020546913, -0.027501989156007767, 0.037147026509046555, 0.039639174938201904, 0.010930607095360756, -0.05378776043653488, -0.006539569236338139, -0.01855776458978653, 0.005357291549444199, -0.010008738376200199, 0.01055133156478405, -0.0365670807659626, -0.000623839208856225, -0.017445534467697144, 0.006093221250921488, -0.00404864689335227, 0.0010710509959608316, 0.00036471497151069343, -0.0372573621571064, 0.003742796368896961, -0.025626206770539284, -0.038267336785793304, -0.01283895131200552, -0.021201789379119873, 0.0023950038012117147, 0.01876864954829216, -0.04618087783455849, 0.03477811440825462, 0.015951242297887802, 0.010430469177663326, 0.01268569566309452, -0.05998978763818741, 0.07306317985057831, -0.006993962451815605, 0.022079462185502052, -0.053142186254262924, 0.008538679219782352, -0.03819639980792999, 0.017289483919739723, 0.029087387025356293, 0.03009038232266903, 0.02203369140625, -0.02554837055504322, -0.012421790510416031, -0.01856059767305851, -0.04689858481287956, 0.037175677716732025, -0.03218346834182739, -0.03420938178896904, 0.009380427189171314, -0.03882753849029541, 0.035827118903398514, 0.03659325838088989, 0.013424642384052277, 0.02402830496430397, -0.007277619559317827, 0.017891615629196167, 0.007885169237852097, 0.003978141117841005, 0.005644380580633879, 0.011246689595282078, 0.07368043065071106, 0.009523269720375538, -0.008047693409025669, 0.048989832401275635, 0.020865099504590034, -0.06474123150110245, 0.04732564836740494, -0.01609746925532818, -0.023887116461992264, -0.024192048236727715, 0.0357644259929657, -0.0021566038485616446, -0.06567918509244919, -0.012011739425361156, -0.002453240565955639, -0.03150968253612518, -0.0013473453000187874, 0.022909071296453476, 0.024097269400954247, 0.03858550265431404, 0.012576313689351082, 0.02845948189496994, -0.027588842436671257, 0.029898839071393013, 0.0036557631101459265, 0.026135263964533806, 0.002252381993457675, 0.0021357708610594273, 0.03740442171692848, 0.025299208238720894, -0.04561982676386833, 0.0249731857329607, -0.021348973736166954, 0.04465610906481743, -0.05938710272312164, -0.03733828291296959, -0.018487945199012756, -0.005138670559972525, -0.0033953008241951466, 0.0044090524315834045, -0.015622707083821297, 0.0830940380692482, 0.0016568342689424753, -0.013432049192488194, -0.01756126806139946, -0.020426973700523376, -0.023703254759311676, 0.020129483193159103, -0.009338143281638622, 0.009089711122214794, -0.013087904080748558, 0.021811120212078094, -0.04643447324633598, 0.0026588793843984604, 0.06155289337038994, -0.03441963344812393, -0.009761837311089039, 0.003342841286212206, 0.016245223581790924, -0.0070359366945922375, -0.025041282176971436, -0.007748452015221119, -0.021875033155083656, -0.002356273587793112, 0.05315593257546425, -0.0008193698595277965, -0.018295718356966972, -0.045064691454172134, -0.006138059310615063, 0.06424272060394287, -0.01908915676176548, 0.012262670323252678, -0.0393550805747509, 0.005953288171440363, -0.017597829923033714, -0.03978414461016655 ]
<p>Suppose I have sets A and B of normally distributed data so that:</p> <pre><code> A: mean=250, SD=200, N=25 B: mean=248, SD=200, N=20 </code></pre> <p>Clearly, there is no statistically significant difference between the means (p=0.9736). But does this mean that the means are equal or that we have no evidence to suggest otherwise? Considering the huge standard deviation it seems intuitively unlikely that the means are <strong>equal</strong>. But this is what the null hypothesis says and based on the the t-test we didn't reject that.</p> <p>Having such noisy data, how can one quantify how equal the means are?</p> <p><strong>Update</strong> This question arose from a discussion between myself and a colleague who was testing the effect of two drug treatments on biological samples. As the test revealed an insignificant difference between treatments, my colleague assumed this allows him to claim that the treatments have the same effect. With the example above I tried to show that this is not necessarily the case. But I didn't know the proper terminology to make things more quantitative. Hence this question.</p>
73,517
[ -0.037774309515953064, 0.009147515520453453, -0.037507347762584686, -0.030610203742980957, 0.019279370084404945, 0.04633117839694023, 0.019018208608031273, -0.01832270249724388, -0.002543824026361108, 0.003465416142717004, 0.07094746083021164, 0.03241565078496933, 0.04347948729991913, 0.02467603236436844, 0.029844719916582108, -0.039429470896720886, -0.03918546438217163, -0.005422775633633137, 0.007847188040614128, 0.0022130715660750866, 0.00020177547412458807, 0.02238997258245945, 0.01609504036605358, -0.042106322944164276, -0.033128127455711365, 0.049745649099349976, 0.004479596856981516, 0.004658550024032593, -0.035894766449928284, 0.06794356554746628, -0.037498828023672104, -0.05013037100434303, 0.03620404377579689, 0.0012026529293507338, 0.028363866731524467, 0.012638570740818977, -0.0035509061999619007, -0.009339605458080769, -0.004220143426209688, 0.025617875158786774, -0.038385599851608276, -0.031910307705402374, 0.01706361025571823, 0.04321809858083725, -0.027621451765298843, 0.01215872261673212, 0.02131083980202675, -0.02550438605248928, 0.01721273362636566, -0.03512930870056152, 0.05771039426326752, -0.007184091489762068, 0.08947158604860306, 0.037501074373722076, -0.03637852147221565, -0.034726403653621674, 0.030359016731381416, 0.05777670070528984, -0.030166372656822205, -0.049621134996414185, -0.013752703554928303, -0.04267369583249092, 0.007375161629170179, 0.011003059335052967, -0.015283008106052876, 0.028673026710748672, -0.042206067591905594, -0.03099094331264496, 0.04815685749053955, -0.012054146267473698, -0.011913707479834557, 0.04728439822793007, 0.04139483720064163, -0.00026062631513923407, -0.011579109355807304, -0.026143185794353485, 0.045353930443525314, -0.014577444642782211, 0.05186562240123749, 0.04260826110839844, -0.0031665272545069456, 0.004950786009430885, 0.02274380251765251, 0.08068812638521194, 0.030950501561164856, -0.027287470176815987, 0.049482427537441254, -0.022936133667826653, 0.01199178583920002, 0.027361661195755005, 0.0012203052174299955, 0.00806622114032507, 0.058736372739076614, 0.02165002003312111, -0.03099433146417141, 0.04126282408833504, -0.0039760819636285305, 0.02274169959127903, 0.0014778518816456199, -0.008581237867474556, 0.000027963864340563305, -0.05570057034492493, 0.06489794701337814, 0.05865051597356796, -0.017893871292471886, -0.03936003893613815, -0.04491318017244339, 0.013406949117779732, -0.02008209563791752, -0.005482267122715712, 0.005297430325299501, 0.01989113725721836, 0.02501734159886837, -0.015433581545948982, 0.022912317886948586, -0.0008997452678158879, -0.008910706266760826, -0.008057634346187115, 0.06605608761310577, 0.04221417009830475, 0.06051863729953766, -0.003229215508326888, 0.015542196109890938, -0.01038526464253664, -0.014216011390089989, 0.0119257727637887, 0.026464208960533142, -0.01469252910465002, -0.03269847482442856, 0.04326925426721573, -0.006989454384893179, 0.010777364484965801, 0.008967895992100239, -0.018356049433350563, 0.07992337644100189, -0.010204685851931572, -0.07018840312957764, -0.0640762448310852, 0.07430217415094376, -0.01578097976744175, -0.015625473111867905, -0.07204851508140564, -0.005102093331515789, 0.020754924044013023, 0.027309108525514603, 0.025043975561857224, 0.03910250961780548, -0.004891555290669203, 0.009874355047941208, 0.027019187808036804, -0.027358971536159515, 0.006315854378044605, 0.021393463015556335, -0.05030311271548271, -0.010767065919935703, -0.086110420525074, -0.004160702228546143, 0.013607775792479515, 0.01588842272758484, 0.002129009459167719, 0.020198756828904152, 0.004203219432383776, 0.0007167207659222186, 0.004004614427685738, -0.0014108887407928705, -0.014730008319020271, 0.05399088189005852, 0.013777771964669228, 0.035285141319036484, 0.03407733514904976, -0.025940880179405212, 0.008179258555173874, 0.029234837740659714, 0.04362741857767105, 0.039655253291130066, -0.027997681871056557, 0.006132469046860933, -0.001733706914819777, 0.04421345889568329, 0.011174439452588558, -0.015955237671732903, 0.011810827068984509, -0.026062723249197006, 0.022437281906604767, 0.022149397060275078, 0.0469462126493454, 0.014300579205155373, 0.005989854224026203, 0.02894546277821064, -0.03233855962753296, -0.03522355854511261, -0.10271311551332474, -0.018489429727196693, -0.006309024523943663, -0.04613811522722244, 0.018225794658064842, -0.01628316566348076, 0.0117866862565279, -0.007508962415158749, 0.01033258531242609, 0.005133491940796375, -0.023858889937400818, 0.05176975950598717, -0.03785223141312599, 0.034413229674100876, 0.0534093901515007, 0.05213470384478569, -0.007598355412483215, 0.05089376121759415, -0.018338538706302643, -0.04194708913564682, 0.01232373621314764, -0.02171405218541622, -0.0013663307763636112, 0.009793269447982311, -0.024200372397899628, 0.01961282081902027, -0.022618012502789497, -0.03151571378111839, 0.043735213577747345, -0.06249098852276802, 0.047368552535772324, 0.032138969749212265, 0.0045210327953100204, -0.017351225018501282, 0.014986731112003326, 0.008814539760351181, 0.023868586868047714, 0.008351132273674011, -0.019396062940359116, -0.05741507560014725, -0.016350993886590004, 0.030274007469415665, 0.0359773226082325, -0.01507015060633421, 0.02264978550374508, 0.055058032274246216, 0.012387649156153202, 0.03231848031282425, 0.020959528163075447, -0.0017588710179552436, -0.03247053921222687, 0.02033843658864498, 0.011313067749142647, 0.03003525920212269, 0.01130840927362442, 0.008694314397871494, 0.009224682115018368, 0.024494120851159096, 0.031564146280288696, 0.015907175838947296, 0.04174378886818886, -0.003040741430595517, -0.004198010545223951, -0.025243692100048065, -0.03735244274139404, 0.02937515452504158, 0.0019059068290516734, -0.00844514463096857, -0.003030935535207391, -0.006185329053550959, -0.039607781916856766, 0.0011903132544830441, -0.005830060224980116, 0.020397109910845757, 0.021997949108481407, -0.007906363345682621, 0.02425376884639263, 0.015086246654391289, -0.0303969606757164, 0.009802117012441158, -0.0176191795617342, -0.02569539286196232, -0.026701703667640686, -0.0009085549390874803, 0.01934797875583172, -0.009683475829660892, 0.05033868923783302, -0.030537424609065056, 0.013564461842179298, -0.021900314837694168, -0.01752571202814579, -0.017486710101366043, -0.02557101845741272, -0.03821182996034622, 0.01199895516037941, -0.009409783408045769, -0.016246993094682693, 0.013175996020436287, -0.02659105882048607, -0.00021839870896656066, 0.011013598181307316, -0.015871062874794006, -0.012490004301071167, 0.014548133127391338, -0.058951228857040405, -0.0043151844292879105, -0.027880191802978516, -0.018436815589666367, 0.04306754097342491, -0.0020063931588083506, -0.01634037494659424, 0.041795291006565094, -0.01766556315124035, -0.022709820419549942, -0.0018299553776159883, 0.015670035034418106, 0.03466887027025223, 0.0021860224660485983, -0.004081753082573414, 0.025026993826031685, -0.05837589502334595, -0.034965790808200836, -0.06506753712892532, -0.04823148250579834, 0.024993136525154114, -0.0027188542298972607, 0.04620327427983284, 0.00810602679848671, -0.04028869792819023, 0.06395820528268814, 0.036351002752780914, -0.05221002176403999, -0.02132764272391796, -0.02027316763997078, -0.032374270260334015, 0.013027491979300976, 0.04000401869416237, 0.049826040863990784, 0.007969195023179054, 0.04800150915980339, 0.03792108967900276, -0.0003494049306027591, 0.03398013487458229, -0.003845369443297386, -0.025603340938687325, 0.005120549816638231, 0.03991677239537239, -0.01257302425801754, 0.02122289314866066, 0.031424105167388916, -0.07185003161430359, 0.005578005686402321, 0.033757392317056656, 0.014756250195205212, 0.04203158989548683, -0.038740988820791245, 0.05056426301598549, 0.025371266528964043, 0.01885990984737873, -0.04512333497405052, 0.02885160595178604, 0.0033584246411919594, 0.016561390832066536, -0.023234954103827477, 0.009599586948752403, 0.0008316279272548854, -0.030737202614545822, 0.020701780915260315, 0.086959108710289, 0.04602101072669029, -0.03022429533302784, -0.024659842252731323, -0.01490623876452446, -0.003817899851128459, -0.034000080078840256, -0.045549213886260986, -0.06156787648797035, 0.040012892335653305, 0.02018888294696808, 0.009551528841257095, 0.011561969295144081, -0.039641495794057846, 0.003441424109041691, -0.0828830674290657, -0.029183708131313324, -0.03163527697324753, 0.0321434885263443, 0.0007825882057659328, 0.03589310869574547, 0.005897200666368008, 0.012086419388651848, -0.010725652799010277, -0.017274977639317513, -0.04603251442313194, 0.04385467246174812, 0.002820017049089074, -0.05484659969806671, 0.018850337713956833, -0.05428900942206383, 0.015870973467826843, -0.00915635284036398, 0.029717661440372467, 0.0011135312961414456, 0.01863989420235157, -0.05805942416191101, -0.015307246707379818, -0.003942444454878569, -0.02390131540596485, -0.02368997037410736, -0.0037853792309761047, -0.024391714483499527, -0.018001968041062355, 0.029195409268140793, 0.010396694764494896, -0.03200247511267662, -0.004339697305113077, -0.022278068587183952, 0.03720245510339737, 0.009904928505420685, 0.04857512190937996, 0.018677884712815285, 0.0312613807618618, -0.0510115884244442, 0.011156618595123291, 0.03662689030170441, 0.06306786090135574, 0.019712211564183235, -0.004558815620839596, -0.04281921684741974, -0.04553638771176338, -0.0013735088286921382, 0.029975246638059616, 0.01656406745314598, -0.007267170585691929, -0.02737874537706375, 0.03710387274622917, 0.025064025074243546, -0.04728425666689873, 0.037741951644420624, 0.03222014382481575, 0.018756955862045288, 0.006009654141962528, -0.060952797532081604, -0.04020487889647484, -0.025624511763453484, -0.008068638853728771, 0.048995837569236755, -0.006839850917458534, 0.014565392397344112, 0.025595402345061302, 0.05381787568330765, 0.0006668661953881383, -0.03600750491023064, -0.027034953236579895, 0.004029932897537947, 0.02914425916969776, -0.004339043982326984, -0.009233353659510612, -0.00011624844773905352, 0.03514077886939049, 0.024003146216273308, 0.019383549690246582, -0.01687041111290455, -0.08524071425199509, 0.015576784498989582, 0.022947970777750015, 0.03273216262459755, -0.037475306540727615, 0.0029609513003379107, -0.031951725482940674, 0.0037503165658563375, 0.05296553298830986, -0.0413394458591938, 0.006634623743593693, -0.024827780202031136, 0.046361494809389114, -0.02416010946035385, -0.005342194344848394, -0.02893570065498352, 0.007878197357058525, 0.0275138970464468, 0.0022493365686386824, 0.009702806361019611, -0.03455168753862381, -0.03501610830426216, -0.011356653645634651, 0.03212294355034828, 0.05157013610005379, -0.07082860916852951, -0.024393893778324127, 0.016392629593610764, 0.007026322651654482, 0.014117312617599964, -0.066839300096035, 0.027598675340414047, -0.006837538443505764, -0.012726177461445332, 0.033453479409217834, -0.01965978369116783, -0.006698212120682001, 0.027532363310456276, 0.0003090209502261132, -0.008237697184085846, -0.017597423866391182, -0.02302577532827854, 0.06186655908823013, 0.05539918318390846, 0.03752247989177704, 0.06983426958322525, 0.005472243297845125, 0.009014647454023361, -0.011999889276921749, -0.050364263355731964, 0.00666679535061121, -0.041620709002017975, 0.01657078228890896, -0.06465651094913483, -0.02439531311392784, -0.009682443924248219, 0.052875880151987076, 0.03098405711352825, -0.013599958270788193, -0.006412601098418236, 0.0017133582150563598, -0.00746100302785635, 0.03483238443732262, 0.028996344655752182, -0.011145607568323612, -0.0034223187249153852, 0.0016086696414276958, 0.0038102425169199705, -0.04658559709787369, 0.004918796941637993, -0.024024318903684616, 0.006546760443598032, 0.014594782143831253, -0.036903493106365204, 0.01034566480666399, -0.027935413643717766, -0.019710570573806763, 0.011398382484912872, -0.02231147512793541, 0.008175021037459373, -0.0001558944204589352, 0.044674504548311234, 0.014414798468351364, -0.05462878942489624, -0.007925773970782757, 0.020800556987524033, 0.010550204664468765, -0.004034403245896101, -0.06364335119724274, 0.02840486168861389, 0.0307018905878067, -0.010230924934148788, -0.08131067454814911, -0.015560496598482132, 0.03321311995387077, 0.014265930280089378, 0.004008496645838022, -0.008276625536382198, 0.008002876304090023, -0.006484081503003836, -0.01756628043949604, -0.022301429882645607, 0.05242294445633888, -0.0010175324277952313, -0.05596643313765526, -0.002585464157164097, 0.011147391982376575, 0.08585881441831589, -0.016555355861783028, -0.014047231525182724, -0.006309652701020241, -0.003992946818470955, -0.03724191337823868, 0.020320985466241837, 0.02786063216626644, -0.024578778073191643, -0.010603532195091248, -0.04899704083800316, -0.016012364998459816, 0.03286347910761833, -0.01106224674731493, -0.03209499269723892, 0.006677188910543919, -0.033137574791908264, 0.030687088146805763, -0.048348527401685715, -0.01941068097949028, -0.026311568915843964, 0.04847744479775429, -0.028060559183359146, 0.01366256084293127, 0.0025153711903840303, -0.002097340766340494, 0.03672792389988899, 0.05381544306874275, -0.038212671875953674, 0.017203370109200478, 0.05964216589927673, -0.01653306744992733, 0.03107464499771595, -0.017379477620124817, -0.027004685252904892, 0.0531599223613739, -0.020272554829716682, -0.002032150747254491, -0.016232186928391457, 0.028279731050133705, -0.04882395640015602, -0.020153410732746124, -0.02875681221485138, -0.018470842391252518, 0.038828782737255096, 0.011695923283696175, 0.04972606152296066, 0.08480548858642578, -0.017632003873586655, -0.00334585877135396, -0.040057968348264694, 0.015678973868489265, -0.0214985478669405, 0.018006181344389915, 0.032905708998441696, -0.01072596199810505, -0.010878774337470531, 0.05860321596264839, 0.03583581745624542, 0.0052823941223323345, 0.021382592618465424, 0.030658092349767685, 0.023366574198007584, 0.020866820588707924, -0.024347348138689995, -0.02141505852341652, 0.05428050085902214, -0.04683640971779823, 0.031031155958771706, -0.04040346294641495, 0.01058952882885933, 0.034605611115694046, 0.017885003238916397, -0.018917743116617203, -0.02206754870712757, -0.012323358096182346, -0.053082115948200226, -0.02135574258863926, 0.0050836908631026745, 0.012685582973062992, 0.057246364653110504, -0.035330671817064285, 0.01603216864168644, -0.013828094117343426, 0.0219389870762825, -0.043792303651571274, -0.04412423074245453, -0.046486902981996536, -0.021132880821824074, -0.01641090214252472, 0.07043830305337906, -0.0354992114007473, -0.03652352839708328, 0.016691362485289574, -0.07886654883623123, 0.0265323668718338, 0.009478610940277576, -0.005299680400639772, -0.03859357535839081, 0.05497674271464348, 0.014255005866289139, 0.052268266677856445, -0.008651243522763252, -0.013687729835510254, 0.09474839270114899, 0.059367891401052475, 0.03688263148069382, -0.024498509243130684, 0.018375517800450325, 0.014258402399718761, -0.015322002582252026, 0.01197571586817503, 0.02194969542324543, 0.023471012711524963, 0.022444749251008034, 0.050581321120262146, 0.054100047796964645, 0.03277738392353058, -0.021640397608280182, 0.0355353020131588, -0.014083046466112137, -0.025083232671022415, 0.030703112483024597, 0.02285192720592022, 0.01393919251859188, -0.05530664324760437, -0.05839839205145836, 0.021942785009741783, -0.00909120962023735, -0.009560358710587025, -0.020964646711945534, 0.0049948133528232574, -0.02536865696310997, 0.029426729306578636, -0.018215017393231392, 0.011537154205143452, 0.02308877930045128, 0.00755695067346096, -0.0379888117313385, -0.011242341250181198, 0.0353049710392952, -0.019483735784888268, 0.004893831443041563, 0.026590799912810326, 0.020374270156025887, 0.034933850169181824, -0.003828818444162607, 0.04485425353050232, -0.0339977853000164, -0.011823900043964386, -0.024872595444321632, 0.02735852636396885, -0.01695111393928528, -0.019866909831762314, 0.008337058126926422, 0.009575928561389446, -0.045259468257427216, -0.023267555981874466, -0.021897947415709496, 0.025305921211838722, -0.009869378991425037, -0.007822071202099323, -0.034434475004673004, 0.011379474774003029, 0.03412128984928131, -0.02734442614018917, 0.008312435820698738, 0.0277293361723423, -0.019301945343613625, -0.008670736104249954, -0.005456947721540928, 0.04456179589033127, -0.011371787637472153, 0.001443732064217329, -0.02861778251826763, -0.03664492070674896, -0.03511897847056389, 0.004996208474040031, -0.013859611935913563, 0.009831473231315613, 0.03918478637933731, -0.0016042174538597465, -0.02695704996585846, -0.010819344781339169, -0.036410264670848846, 0.032929692417383194, -0.005250842776149511, 0.018300024792551994, -0.028301434591412544, -0.027519874274730682, 0.006252933759242296, 0.035290107131004333, 0.01768106408417225, 0.034392099827528, 0.03333662077784538, 0.033788248896598816, 0.017135435715317726, -0.061386410146951675, -0.020093293860554695, 0.0029500711243599653, -0.027496686205267906, -0.00673318887129426, 0.008973737247288227, 0.03916534036397934, 0.027085503563284874, 0.036927729845047, -0.0024152996484190226, 0.03773433715105057, -0.015516073442995548, -0.004864220507442951, -0.011534681543707848, -0.04573575779795647, -0.042991142719984055, 0.04109688848257065, 0.014700448140501976, -0.012894137762486935, 0.003070434555411339, -0.05263429507613182, -0.017252719029784203, 0.005960673093795776, -0.02741161175072193, -0.0037926356308162212, -0.025578731670975685, 0.01606760546565056, 0.013093966990709305, -0.023599205538630486, -0.010254568420350552, -0.04558302462100983, -0.008570129983127117, 0.01885189488530159, 0.021199863404035568, -0.013700262643396854, 0.01008558925241232, -0.010221291333436966, -0.03264584392309189, 0.026532627642154694, -0.012606940232217312, -0.011110667139291763, 0.0065325777977705, 0.00943373329937458, 0.010192127898335457, 0.007362226489931345, 0.01304328627884388, -0.028917809948325157, 0.06251353025436401, -0.04526795074343681, -0.05473446846008301, 0.008088567294180393, -0.00455551827326417, 0.008403646759688854, 0.01937197893857956, -0.014897449873387814, -0.007762369234114885, 0.0520985908806324, -0.03830563649535179, -0.029537223279476166, -0.02883283607661724, -0.03911790996789932, 0.0012246345868334174, 0.0009648623527027667, 0.020901914685964584, 0.013798089697957039, -0.01241652574390173, 0.04935620352625847, 0.04912944138050079, 0.006573392543941736, -0.016206063330173492, -0.014662723988294601, 0.015831559896469116, -0.004270839970558882, 0.018639303743839264, 0.013098682276904583, 0.0035931558813899755, 0.051977138966321945, -0.008521920070052147, 0.014611512422561646, -0.034447383135557175, 0.007001577410846949, -0.11436352133750916, -0.008552517741918564, 0.022010186687111855, -0.010584451258182526, 0.026506446301937103, -0.06935504823923111, 0.019370578229427338, -0.007085375487804413, -0.07506411522626877, -0.00555103225633502, -0.06074310839176178, -0.02690788172185421, -0.042986687272787094, 0.042064767330884933, -0.04560655727982521, 0.030342696234583855, 0.006084925960749388, 0.04602612182497978, 0.015049569308757782, 0.024413447827100754, 0.020610330626368523, 0.01435046549886465, -0.027181796729564667, 0.0341547429561615, 0.017974907532334328, -0.059716928750276566, 0.005411738064140081, -0.01150804664939642, -0.008313827216625214, 0.030015503987669945, -0.03599737957119942, 0.030047528445720673, -0.01689421944320202, 0.0086923623457551, 0.03218734636902809, 0.01278933696448803, 0.010916435159742832, 0.016214363276958466, -0.03101651929318905, -0.008079975843429565, 0.010372008197009563, 0.0376073494553566, -0.012767216190695763, -0.016133930534124374, 0.03755602985620499, -0.007420904468744993, -0.03456200659275055, -0.012059533968567848, -0.011039835400879383, -0.00025433555128984153, -0.00043855266994796693, 0.03107031248509884, 0.024348227307200432, 0.014795118942856789, 0.019784873351454735, -0.05211540311574936, 0.040297847241163254, 0.034176722168922424, 0.041658226400613785, -0.03589537367224693, 0.021248621866106987, 0.01419756468385458, -0.021725988015532494, -0.004752689972519875, 0.017608696594834328, -0.0011839955113828182, -0.06136740744113922, -0.0025872194673866034, -0.042601048946380615, 0.005897198803722858, -0.026150399819016457, -0.008372558280825615, -0.05282293260097504, 0.038955893367528915, 0.006681293714791536, 0.016311144456267357, -0.017879722639918327, -0.00004050207280670293, -0.009870554320514202, -0.0771552324295044, 0.040635570883750916, 0.0330338291823864, 0.003296540817245841, -0.06839119642972946, 0.0052918605506420135, -0.05897216126322746, 0.01618059352040291, 0.05180022865533829, 0.07218693196773529, -0.0051796347834169865, 0.043014492839574814, 0.000746140256524086, 0.013854560442268848, -0.07615823298692703, 0.03812790289521217, -0.03395913168787956, -0.04590000957250595, -0.027080032974481583, -0.018967388197779655, 0.0018256093608215451, 0.03228488191962242, 0.014661510474979877, -0.03791103884577751, 0.00920749083161354, -0.018423954024910927, 0.004755995236337185, 0.06238838657736778, -0.012270502746105194, -0.044136177748441696, 0.05093373358249664, 0.007842594757676125, 0.021335037425160408, 0.020781399682164192, 0.010147694498300552, -0.038379229605197906, 0.05347183346748352, -0.011478644795715809, 0.004181399010121822, -0.008730942383408546, 0.02145497314631939, -0.02908250503242016, -0.0630335882306099, 0.01227568555623293, 0.02778291329741478, -0.015173324383795261, -0.016454355791211128, 0.0055681210942566395, 0.016385937109589577, 0.0009032151428982615, -0.00479290122166276, -0.005130750127136707, -0.02461046539247036, 0.012197073549032211, 0.005017551127821207, -0.005154320038855076, 0.016866665333509445, 0.020710887387394905, 0.03923729434609413, 0.028261598199605942, -0.04541316255927086, 0.024831052869558334, -0.0007215056102722883, 0.040163587778806686, 0.0008681467152200639, -0.019122188910841942, -0.026230255141854286, 0.002345690969377756, 0.008117624558508396, 0.011612827889621258, 0.01134925801306963, 0.07185503840446472, -0.021641260012984276, 0.012811999768018723, -0.03362904116511345, -0.01516821887344122, -0.01905125379562378, -0.016681097447872162, 0.03023955598473549, -0.008246226236224174, -0.020673995837569237, 0.009928589686751366, -0.008495877496898174, 0.000499974936246872, 0.010558449663221836, -0.017423119395971298, 0.012206664308905602, -0.03189997747540474, -0.014607497490942478, -0.05131791532039642, 0.026308730244636536, -0.05698361247777939, -0.019906511530280113, 0.0459958054125309, 0.015243287198245525, 0.015856508165597916, -0.02643287368118763, -0.04223779961466789, -0.014980512671172619, 0.07430682331323624, -0.07231931388378143, -0.025626786053180695, -0.03284203261137009, -0.012531516142189503, -0.009724734351038933, -0.04727141559123993 ]
<p>I read that 'Euclidean distance is not a good distance in high dimensions'. I guess this statement has something to do with the curse of dimensionality, but what exactly? Besides, what is 'high dimensions'? I have been applying hierarchical clustering using Euclidean distance with 100 features. Up to how many features is it 'safe' to use this metric?</p>
73,518
[ -0.04239558428525925, 0.008044426329433918, 0.023433400318026543, -0.03706343099474907, 0.029241936281323433, 0.00944597739726305, 0.0027070138603448868, 0.0027828682214021683, 0.0130265848711133, -0.06450936198234558, 0.010093314573168755, 0.018459007143974304, 0.03727174922823906, 0.01331454236060381, 0.017921125516295433, -0.004775477573275566, -0.004085253924131393, -0.008034419268369675, 0.01981205679476261, 0.005867514759302139, 0.04049912840127945, 0.029506249353289604, 0.0653223916888237, -0.03762134537100792, -0.038430459797382355, 0.03764773905277252, 0.00718404958024621, -0.012623419053852558, 0.024760805070400238, 0.03096097521483898, -0.002753989538177848, -0.01045182254165411, 0.008579865097999573, 0.03590980917215347, 0.041232168674468994, -0.018054688349366188, -0.026096051558852196, -0.014338217675685883, -0.045523468405008316, 0.021875429898500443, -0.03801431134343147, -0.05864373967051506, 0.026649905368685722, 0.09334903955459595, -0.012782999314367771, 0.04842604696750641, -0.012624138966202736, -0.0582406111061573, 0.03133825212717056, -0.04643483832478523, 0.07556326687335968, 0.009725652635097504, 0.04713062942028046, 0.016214977949857712, -0.018906358629465103, 0.0001696076215011999, 0.06287970393896103, 0.05139338970184326, -0.0657535269856453, -0.03580516204237938, -0.014728574082255363, -0.01904354616999626, 0.011472241021692753, -0.04208284616470337, -0.01434620562940836, 0.05439293384552002, -0.014554797671735287, -0.001218327204696834, 0.06040322780609131, 0.006008658558130264, -0.01494982372969389, 0.013579433783888817, 0.0390457808971405, -0.02951173298060894, 0.01574540138244629, -0.019906990230083466, 0.011496718041598797, -0.001589931664057076, 0.09191194176673889, 0.04207707196474075, 0.013962259516119957, -0.016014838591217995, 0.0008216038695536554, 0.01695086807012558, 0.03987254202365875, -0.017200490459799767, 0.05821053311228752, -0.011601630598306656, -0.007048596162348986, 0.04941832646727562, -0.007273382972925901, -0.009473438374698162, 0.030893420800566673, 0.04039593040943146, -0.030374910682439804, 0.06341846287250519, -0.009057545103132725, 0.02428831346333027, 0.025848593562841415, -0.01888871379196644, -0.010674180462956429, -0.02101466804742813, 0.03438601270318031, 0.008130822330713272, -0.00485840393230319, -0.0063566588796675205, -0.01555461436510086, 0.008250663988292217, -0.004223702475428581, 0.026116058230400085, -0.03471185639500618, 0.002128723543137312, -0.013229640200734138, 0.0038403153885155916, 0.04499969258904457, -0.009157861582934856, 0.0017869402654469013, -0.017932506278157234, 0.019456638023257256, 0.08356145769357681, -0.005535677075386047, -0.032254766672849655, 0.035648196935653687, -0.023850297555327415, -0.046783171594142914, 0.031276047229766846, 0.03197947517037392, -0.03385969251394272, -0.027385948225855827, 0.02981792949140072, 0.008589422330260277, -0.000878951046615839, 0.010944444686174393, 0.00228734128177166, 0.052060097455978394, -0.009911399334669113, -0.08906295895576477, -0.06588748097419739, 0.031952761113643646, 0.0169383455067873, -0.000743274053093046, -0.06410665810108185, 0.004543969873338938, 0.011608663946390152, 0.04637671262025833, 0.018019288778305054, 0.026586011052131653, 0.015560423023998737, 0.010248950682580471, -0.012521929107606411, -0.0520915612578392, -0.04651585966348648, 0.02229107916355133, -0.022783996537327766, 0.026740944012999535, -0.0800613984465599, 0.009133260697126389, 0.02855416014790535, 0.0005877249641343951, -0.03589574247598648, -0.02590201050043106, 0.006083662621676922, -0.006776575464755297, 0.00987032987177372, -0.006460389122366905, 0.004514042288064957, 0.07261937111616135, -0.0030712736770510674, 0.04593878239393234, 0.02260798215866089, -0.03839103505015373, 0.016602804884314537, 0.034975070506334305, 0.034034691751003265, 0.020606424659490585, 0.03696655109524727, 0.02833334542810917, -0.02177099883556366, 0.030767491087317467, 0.017863096669316292, -0.03808692842721939, -0.0549597293138504, -0.008327568881213665, 0.020787930116057396, -0.01790417544543743, 0.007243673782795668, -0.00009029995271703228, -0.02700580470263958, 0.03917913883924484, -0.03041682578623295, -0.03842823952436447, -0.06506631523370743, 0.012521661818027496, 0.0039121233858168125, -0.019176684319972992, 0.0396496057510376, -0.015933634713292122, -0.009673620574176311, -0.03810465335845947, -0.010354273952543736, -0.03356940299272537, -0.012495976872742176, 0.005929808598011732, -0.05060895159840584, -0.0000430707041232381, 0.0784708708524704, 0.04560720920562744, -0.009192930534482002, 0.057587094604969025, 0.0049064625054597855, -0.031797174364328384, -0.008005747571587563, -0.019777700304985046, -0.00018534217088017613, -0.02314806543290615, -0.007325468119233847, 0.029110221192240715, -0.0393783301115036, -0.03237390145659447, 0.012774809263646603, -0.026442090049386024, 0.08161848783493042, 0.04501686990261078, 0.005480469204485416, -0.015046577900648117, -0.0045095207169651985, 0.005872448906302452, -0.041359078139066696, -0.002266621682792902, -0.008031737990677357, -0.045938994735479355, 0.01895259879529476, 0.042243994772434235, 0.054492343217134476, -0.039593446999788284, 0.014534223824739456, 0.04501769319176674, 0.049478329718112946, -0.0058114733546972275, -0.0006775036454200745, -0.009529120288789272, -0.022643795236945152, 0.023751534521579742, -0.01575845666229725, -0.009768215008080006, 0.02146690897643566, 0.01611132174730301, -0.010893074795603752, 0.02867000550031662, -0.010137797333300114, -0.018931841477751732, 0.05109437182545662, -0.03332776203751564, -0.011350201442837715, 0.012488947249948978, -0.008792506530880928, 0.02611616440117359, -0.032289959490299225, 0.023027943447232246, 0.02054973877966404, 0.0236830897629261, 0.02579381875693798, -0.03765333071351051, -0.02621878683567047, 0.008554684929549694, 0.04997273534536362, -0.03772810846567154, 0.004522903356701136, 0.01685776188969612, -0.04170352965593338, -0.0005758942570537329, -0.0254230760037899, -0.03703067824244499, -0.01726522669196129, -0.017416425049304962, 0.048149026930332184, 0.003373990999534726, 0.03473930433392525, -0.012168067507445812, -0.02665359154343605, 0.014987572096288204, -0.0252261683344841, 0.007198393810540438, -0.016325175762176514, -0.04527832940220833, 0.01880480907857418, -0.021312536671757698, 0.004644169006496668, 0.010792995803058147, -0.026940658688545227, 0.03261472284793854, 0.015223180875182152, -0.022500133141875267, -0.0336708128452301, -0.028798403218388557, -0.008587080985307693, 0.04669392853975296, -0.009105522185564041, -0.026374109089374542, 0.021309448406100273, -0.027049535885453224, -0.03580261394381523, 0.02521749772131443, 0.0036648958921432495, -0.0365547239780426, -0.05750386044383049, 0.02033153921365738, -0.03408580273389816, -0.00550169637426734, -0.0002767491096165031, 0.0585663765668869, -0.03906736895442009, -0.006114782765507698, -0.05765752121806145, -0.08163254708051682, 0.043094780296087265, -0.014671782031655312, 0.058057721704244614, -0.024286340922117233, -0.029203109443187714, 0.06166314706206322, 0.04379773885011673, -0.03602880984544754, -0.03921933472156525, 0.003392453072592616, -0.046100739389657974, -0.01259769406169653, 0.030741499736905098, 0.00566111272200942, 0.01850767992436886, 0.017208281904459, 0.00695562269538641, 0.03586183115839958, 0.06369175761938095, -0.028987865895032883, -0.04245390370488167, 0.02834845706820488, 0.00031436485005542636, -0.009373062290251255, 0.006873144302517176, 0.02324857749044895, -0.06379580497741699, 0.018725281581282616, -0.00984469335526228, 0.010923824273049831, 0.006077992729842663, -0.039893075823783875, 0.0024692409206181765, -0.02830163575708866, 0.010086123831570148, -0.008774634450674057, -0.0001896498870337382, -0.01818923093378544, 0.0038846025709062815, 0.015409835614264011, 0.030842337757349014, 0.0313873216509819, -0.03953854367136955, -0.018339863047003746, 0.023936519399285316, 0.053949274122714996, -0.01653851568698883, 0.03316779434680939, 0.01628446765244007, 0.00029863661620765924, -0.009597291238605976, -0.009972789324820042, -0.007658217567950487, 0.013075701892375946, 0.04302140325307846, 0.01247852947562933, 0.032122012227773666, -0.04354228079319, 0.01896580122411251, -0.06649047136306763, 0.005912978667765856, -0.00973316840827465, 0.0353776216506958, -0.011779812164604664, 0.034350957721471786, 0.036800939589738846, -0.01996830850839615, 0.007823802530765533, -0.008609171956777573, -0.04647495970129967, -0.024967283010482788, -0.050228435546159744, -0.0007038901094347239, -0.035944536328315735, -0.05305495858192444, 0.010350753553211689, -0.004247561097145081, -0.0004749519575852901, -0.0016025856602936983, 0.04893188923597336, -0.0439193993806839, 0.020491205155849457, -0.023966433480381966, 0.0015047552296891809, -0.02342507615685463, 0.012932303361594677, 0.05434172973036766, 0.00926609430462122, 0.03890703245997429, 0.03819455951452255, -0.019185930490493774, -0.009981348179280758, 0.0011722720228135586, 0.021204521879553795, 0.0174065250903368, 0.030825069174170494, -0.015498468652367592, 0.01789042539894581, -0.013019369915127754, 0.03342388942837715, -0.0039104921743273735, 0.05113289877772331, 0.02703731507062912, -0.015085943043231964, -0.023522337898612022, -0.03722662106156349, -0.06549959629774094, -0.019667232409119606, 0.04468666389584541, -0.016609258949756622, 0.0027838614769279957, 0.032491039484739304, 0.021152807399630547, -0.07752354443073273, -0.011195815168321133, 0.0860314667224884, 0.01089166384190321, -0.06203646585345268, -0.033475033938884735, -0.056540824472904205, 0.007706331554800272, -0.014832601882517338, 0.0238226056098938, 0.006957671605050564, -0.019530612975358963, -0.01882556825876236, 0.006198979448527098, -0.03361845016479492, -0.055626217275857925, 0.014757352881133556, 0.02936597354710102, 0.005904727149754763, -0.027978455647826195, -0.0014523568097501993, -0.012399498373270035, 0.02633187361061573, 0.06366469711065292, 0.046862393617630005, 0.004504936747252941, -0.06863386183977127, -0.0017750706756487489, 0.02268226444721222, 0.03849494457244873, 0.000728484068531543, 0.0020539327524602413, -0.01899896189570427, -0.007617915980517864, 0.04815821722149849, -0.041090819984674454, 0.022217096760869026, -0.01734270714223385, -0.02264518477022648, -0.03135241940617561, -0.020909257233142853, -0.0067186737433075905, -0.005264595150947571, 0.023895230144262314, 0.025905271992087364, -0.01834792271256447, -0.02857348881661892, -0.025334611535072327, 0.030580036342144012, -0.0008358883787877858, 0.026787709444761276, 0.012972776778042316, -0.018734827637672424, -0.005552621558308601, 0.031310178339481354, -0.003517742035910487, -0.05735353007912636, 0.035544153302907944, 0.036978233605623245, 0.003321892349049449, 0.04012172296643257, -0.03167922422289848, -0.037620533257722855, -0.007132988888770342, 0.015117463655769825, -0.003436602419242263, -0.002563704503700137, 0.004198460839688778, 0.023746611550450325, 0.05863915756344795, -0.0029723322950303555, 0.017899733036756516, -0.015184535644948483, 0.004309183917939663, -0.001071054837666452, -0.03296412527561188, 0.04514046758413315, -0.04362596943974495, -0.026680640876293182, -0.03215761482715607, -0.013266395777463913, -0.04483415558934212, 0.033996522426605225, -0.01943969912827015, 0.034011613577604294, -0.024474019184708595, -0.02861720323562622, -0.014577428810298443, 0.053115155547857285, -0.004123706370592117, 0.0034962475765496492, -0.004383854102343321, 0.012662017717957497, 0.010947677306830883, 0.00697316462174058, 0.005402359180152416, 0.017337772995233536, 0.021146314218640327, 0.03896595910191536, -0.012819974683225155, -0.02049739472568035, -0.004305699374526739, 0.007159815635532141, 0.021218886598944664, -0.009308128617703915, 0.04324369505047798, -0.04377622529864311, 0.020199960097670555, 0.012361294589936733, -0.05519275739789009, -0.004602290224283934, 0.0037336284294724464, -0.03686259314417839, 0.05038643255829811, -0.047529324889183044, 0.05108217895030975, -0.031347163021564484, 0.036795999854803085, -0.05526942014694214, -0.031296029686927795, 0.005126713775098324, -0.007058211602270603, -0.02535119839012623, -0.025024117901921272, 0.006499100476503372, -0.01852261647582054, -0.026132188737392426, -0.019140997901558876, 0.05196428298950195, -0.01527455635368824, -0.0018914531683549285, 0.01980493776500225, 0.019227225333452225, 0.03525230288505554, 0.008912320248782635, 0.029339738190174103, 0.013652078807353973, 0.024725109338760376, 0.049946174025535583, -0.010014243423938751, 0.038442354649305344, -0.04236650839447975, 0.023444494232535362, -0.04963938146829605, -0.007823952473700047, -0.008204665035009384, -0.04172452166676521, -0.008462715893983841, -0.026574967429041862, -0.032643917948007584, 0.031639646738767624, -0.02506016008555889, 0.02387893944978714, -0.02120130881667137, -0.011663132347166538, -0.023359568789601326, 0.0001629128964850679, -0.006644647102802992, -0.02748841978609562, 0.05159125104546547, 0.012271460145711899, 0.040759120136499405, 0.0036020814441144466, 0.020520737394690514, -0.034142736345529556, -0.0195914413779974, -0.015430506318807602, -0.03825842961668968, 0.03776031360030174, -0.007957272231578827, -0.021352006122469902, 0.01630932278931141, 0.042156968265771866, -0.030093345791101456, -0.04397839680314064, -0.010970150120556355, -0.005110554397106171, 0.07080944627523422, -0.01305297203361988, 0.013981041498482227, 0.038063861429691315, -0.03748076409101486, -0.0059128510765731335, -0.032891031354665756, -0.026210417971014977, 0.01552489772439003, -0.011330008506774902, 0.06430885195732117, 0.01211545616388321, 0.008363231085240841, 0.020520782098174095, 0.029229721054434776, 0.0006946554640308022, 0.025911781936883926, -0.01561173889786005, -0.0047956290654838085, 0.013124777935445309, -0.04463418200612068, -0.06444744020700455, 0.03576849028468132, -0.04006151854991913, -0.003759624669328332, -0.022057965397834778, 0.00349001819267869, 0.031434208154678345, 0.021151335909962654, -0.0009660911746323109, -0.022468628361821175, -0.039859119802713394, -0.001918368972837925, -0.005759753752499819, 0.02844599261879921, 0.014875076711177826, 0.001120665343478322, -0.022568894550204277, 0.02498711459338665, 0.04223403334617615, -0.022800855338573456, 0.0024714975152164698, -0.03278128802776337, -0.07018866389989853, -0.044051263481378555, -0.028348872438073158, 0.017367582768201828, 0.007861181162297726, -0.05285309627652168, -0.024326728656888008, -0.01758541166782379, -0.009080777876079082, 0.008646112866699696, -0.004623293410986662, -0.00660138251259923, 0.044323354959487915, 0.023390423506498337, 0.026894638314843178, -0.010790117084980011, 0.007235626690089703, 0.10079813003540039, 0.08959033340215683, 0.03465113788843155, -0.05373937636613846, 0.02447415329515934, -0.024314772337675095, -0.03823699429631233, -0.05407331883907318, 0.05424585938453674, 0.01422191970050335, 0.023531127721071243, 0.053482379764318466, 0.03674791753292084, 0.024325810372829437, 0.00315646268427372, 0.05586276575922966, -0.05569278448820114, -0.017918923869729042, -0.01187626738101244, -0.012306596152484417, -0.022760964930057526, 0.006158063188195229, -0.020979583263397217, 0.03199860826134682, 0.008077497594058514, 0.006325626280158758, -0.0052695791237056255, 0.007405460812151432, 0.03135808929800987, 0.007121658883988857, -0.0189333688467741, -0.03141232579946518, 0.02016538381576538, 0.002949919318780303, -0.013231556862592697, -0.00608352804556489, -0.00018033840751741081, -0.008182368241250515, -0.01846897415816784, 0.022030960768461227, -0.012676505371928215, -0.008915374986827374, -0.0013321485603228211, -0.006219284608960152, -0.045576442033052444, -0.045705508440732956, -0.025849785655736923, 0.0209487434476614, 0.007287797052413225, 0.026777906343340874, 0.03573821857571602, 0.013525301590561867, 0.011777735315263271, -0.049773432314395905, 0.013336416333913803, 0.01339727733284235, 0.07425682991743088, 0.01921822875738144, -0.005692763719707727, -0.02922939322888851, 0.05797498673200607, -0.01708712987601757, 0.04560799151659012, -0.0033537084236741066, -0.02541072852909565, 0.009948254562914371, -0.04117719084024429, 0.042701996862888336, -0.031688325107097626, -0.020541906356811523, -0.031239841133356094, 0.020137714222073555, -0.0074334098026156425, -0.021550633013248444, -0.023563705384731293, -0.000541605637408793, 0.036921292543411255, 0.015768298879265785, -0.025811396539211273, -0.004169488325715065, -0.04907651245594025, 0.032800059765577316, -0.04828605800867081, -0.028448468074202538, -0.03422342613339424, 0.00775067089125514, 0.02540408819913864, 0.055059731006622314, 0.03469104692339897, 0.03447722643613815, -0.022863857448101044, 0.024726081639528275, 0.006305095739662647, -0.027619117870926857, 0.021143542602658272, -0.010134078562259674, -0.059204939752817154, 0.01342620886862278, 0.004691387061029673, 0.02870338223874569, 0.05091474950313568, -0.0012925643241032958, 0.004051538649946451, 0.03529708459973335, -0.023250307887792587, 0.021346183493733406, 0.019587816670536995, -0.03044775500893593, 0.007578722201287746, 0.001974009908735752, 0.0033348894212394953, -0.06399182230234146, -0.054637666791677475, -0.06312286108732224, -0.032063961029052734, 0.007938293740153313, 0.035071030259132385, -0.032417863607406616, -0.010342619381844997, 0.0024003421422094107, 0.009496002458035946, -0.038956522941589355, -0.021673385053873062, -0.017318977043032646, 0.04495537653565407, -0.01718802936375141, -0.015472428873181343, 0.008811977691948414, -0.018968235701322556, -0.008376823738217354, 0.02142397128045559, 0.04795755818486214, 0.0308547243475914, 0.017628759145736694, -0.008013770915567875, -0.005700180772691965, -0.007087088190019131, 0.046714723110198975, -0.06441232562065125, -0.006582685746252537, 0.05174200236797333, -0.07029380649328232, -0.060567304491996765, 0.03877868503332138, -0.03967487812042236, 0.03363816440105438, 0.023278096690773964, 0.013508995994925499, -0.009904508478939533, 0.03417668864130974, 0.00299686542712152, -0.016465967521071434, 0.02265378274023533, -0.0192320067435503, -0.0033363227266818285, 0.01762511022388935, 0.0197613388299942, -0.02392483316361904, -0.007325726095587015, -0.00717205461114645, 0.02964136004447937, 0.02666846662759781, -0.010930954478681087, 0.020192904397845268, -0.0056430562399327755, 0.023595759645104408, 0.0045860703103244305, 0.002530209254473448, 0.029668111354112625, 0.05428888276219368, -0.04979265481233597, 0.016467608511447906, 0.027770143002271652, 0.030473284423351288, -0.10136118531227112, 0.00043804431334137917, 0.012176208198070526, 0.014996402896940708, 0.016300620511174202, -0.09522660076618195, -0.00922108069062233, 0.0461091585457325, -0.09227485209703445, 0.05858008936047554, -0.011675790883600712, -0.02199690416455269, -0.04211121052503586, 0.040042445063591, -0.009416336193680763, 0.02673286944627762, 0.04516627639532089, 0.05207749456167221, 0.014586811885237694, 0.0037243636325001717, -0.003424240043386817, -0.03546474128961563, -0.00800508726388216, 0.02803104929625988, -0.05531281232833862, -0.022798558697104454, 0.024776818230748177, -0.0176419485360384, -0.0239330492913723, 0.03017907403409481, -0.030539920553565025, 0.015391414985060692, 0.06689802557229996, 0.021504251286387444, 0.06555764377117157, 0.023219045251607895, 0.03562961891293526, -0.03157481923699379, -0.015692340210080147, -0.016657596454024315, 0.012467250227928162, 0.030219700187444687, -0.016024673357605934, 0.02433732897043228, 0.0093636903911829, -0.03204396739602089, -0.03008916787803173, 0.019226226955652237, -0.01962542161345482, -0.016288375481963158, 0.009008650667965412, -0.014498990029096603, 0.002107584848999977, -0.011947102844715118, 0.007784372661262751, -0.018556877970695496, -0.017761273309588432, 0.04705888405442238, 0.010146756656467915, 0.008188359439373016, 0.03347041830420494, -0.04237215220928192, -0.056769635528326035, 0.006771056912839413, -0.02016412280499935, 0.013533509336411953, -0.047315165400505066, 0.02520875446498394, -0.004244862589985132, 0.001530424109660089, -0.011268963105976582, -0.015317029319703579, 0.013283239677548409, 0.05597858875989914, 0.02081097848713398, 0.047185491770505905, 0.02220863848924637, -0.04350550100207329, -0.009669996798038483, -0.07766567170619965, 0.0407266765832901, -0.021922379732131958, -0.006645936984568834, -0.02510756626725197, -0.0010141963139176369, -0.04349416121840477, -0.012479881756007671, 0.05803956091403961, 0.0011353750014677644, 0.027987133711576462, -0.005790562368929386, 0.02110537700355053, 0.019603798165917397, -0.0329894945025444, 0.005710657685995102, -0.037655916064977646, -0.025830160826444626, -0.03754597157239914, -0.03308035060763359, 0.022165564820170403, 0.006900701206177473, -0.003172999946400523, -0.026272937655448914, 0.04307178780436516, 0.01761379837989807, 0.008940165862441063, 0.020465530455112457, 0.009639843367040157, -0.003511088900268078, 0.04634395241737366, 0.01564403623342514, -0.01663154922425747, 0.028734222054481506, 0.009424998424947262, -0.02021283656358719, 0.025400379672646523, -0.022030172869563103, -0.025415323674678802, 0.03004506789147854, 0.04854216426610947, 0.004735568072646856, -0.024108603596687317, -0.01663411781191826, 0.05092766880989075, -0.03037978708744049, -0.02187512442469597, 0.05507071316242218, 0.03351078927516937, 0.014785862527787685, 0.007009510416537523, 0.01952817663550377, 0.03489840403199196, -0.003528665518388152, 0.040789101272821426, 0.005643765442073345, 0.04134482890367508, -0.022576414048671722, 0.02760080248117447, -0.005386555101722479, -0.024692201986908913, 0.013075245544314384, -0.002135713119059801, 0.062352560460567474, -0.02239188179373741, -0.011897011660039425, -0.016463177278637886, -0.035807445645332336, 0.036554306745529175, 0.017536016181111336, -0.024507086724042892, 0.0812237560749054, -0.03126367926597595, -0.007629414089024067, -0.02254066988825798, -0.053896959871053696, -0.027848711237311363, -0.019281720742583275, -0.03382109850645065, 0.0557001568377018, -0.033611495047807693, 0.03644310683012009, -0.02798539400100708, 0.013546406291425228, 0.016936229541897774, -0.02500472590327263, 0.02606821432709694, -0.012268171645700932, 0.02677241526544094, -0.016412898898124695, -0.006795944646000862, -0.000814815575722605, 0.0013296048855409026, 0.030542952939867973, 0.05775847285985947, 0.056952401995658875, 0.04141385480761528, -0.02130998484790325, 0.014279833063483238, 0.028322624042630196, -0.08714231103658676, 0.0018944005714729428, -0.04691075533628464, -0.01320678275078535, -0.016746219247579575, 0.0049315025098621845 ]
<p>This is a question that arose from studying Hogg and Craig "Introduction to Mathematical Statistics",7th edition, pg 568.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/v5FWG.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>It is assumed that we have taken a random sample of $X_1,\ldots,X_{n1}$ and a random sample of $Y_1,\ldots, Y_{n_2}$, $n$ denotes the combined sample size, i.e. $n=n_1+n_2$ and <strong>sgn(.)</strong> is $1$ if the quantity in the brackers is positive,$0$ if it is zero and $-1$ if it is negative. We also rank the variables from low to high.</p> <p>Could you please help me understand how the authors reach the conclusion that the difference in medians estimator solves that equation? There is no explanation from their part and the word "easily" seems out of place :)</p> <p>Thank you.</p>
73,519
[ -0.05864708125591278, -0.014898475259542465, 0.009663718752563, -0.012737897224724293, 0.029508184641599655, 0.030438687652349472, 0.006365580018609762, -0.012073615565896034, 0.017297567799687386, -0.021451139822602272, 0.03388207033276558, 0.02717103622853756, 0.07425294816493988, 0.018980305641889572, 0.028302447870373726, 0.010634290985763073, -0.026293497532606125, 0.039331287145614624, 0.020207202062010765, -0.053834035992622375, -0.002275764709338546, 0.024141529574990273, 0.024172566831111908, -0.019636936485767365, -0.05576971545815468, 0.02577638067305088, 0.02132296748459339, -0.0010493932059034705, 0.006141559220850468, 0.055238377302885056, -0.016359297558665276, -0.02688809297978878, -0.004820623435080051, 0.06249065324664116, -0.02190946601331234, -0.0084792859852314, 0.0017167250625789165, -0.0406808964908123, -0.006759557873010635, 0.013953179121017456, -0.02850867435336113, -0.010909260250627995, -0.03320969268679619, -0.00777960941195488, -0.050935663282871246, 0.02784116193652153, 0.007191237527877092, -0.06380079686641693, 0.011088166385889053, -0.0297935102134943, 0.06505126506090164, 0.01667998544871807, 0.03059672750532627, 0.030116884037852287, -0.0239607822149992, 0.024415254592895508, 0.016129791736602783, 0.0337391197681427, -0.023661095649003983, -0.03317469358444214, -0.015363622456789017, -0.007799005601555109, -0.020201485604047775, -0.02304745651781559, -0.006376895122230053, 0.004190240986645222, -0.002464715391397476, -0.012862768024206161, 0.022942829877138138, 0.00783710926771164, 0.010486618615686893, 0.00504105631262064, 0.040279027074575424, 0.013933788053691387, 0.02362772822380066, -0.03487038612365723, 0.025436708703637123, 0.005546465516090393, 0.06301834434270859, -0.008192567154765129, -0.018897125497460365, 0.030124003067612648, 0.024921298027038574, 0.04570922255516052, -0.011215448379516602, -0.007133152801543474, 0.09290173649787903, -0.03610173240303993, 0.053550221025943756, -0.0011819665087386966, 0.004155110102146864, 0.0009289411827921867, 0.09035172313451767, -0.00840730406343937, -0.02524646185338497, 0.020666537806391716, -0.020457899197936058, 0.011625243350863457, -0.006365368142724037, 0.013098523952066898, -0.00885312631726265, -0.06516846269369125, 0.006401809863746166, 0.04285421222448349, -0.011018008925020695, -0.0056156497448682785, -0.010394904762506485, 0.018390420824289322, -0.004664051812142134, -0.0035778393503278494, -0.0326123982667923, 0.0002832792524714023, -0.011734047904610634, -0.02614581398665905, 0.019204754382371902, 0.010169556364417076, 0.008030438795685768, -0.011009764857590199, 0.04151475802063942, 0.04422193393111229, 0.0525699220597744, -0.031149480491876602, 0.02997930906713009, -0.05864808335900307, -0.04030846431851387, 0.037112295627593994, -0.0012612465070560575, -0.00918626505881548, -0.028440693393349648, 0.058010268956422806, 0.019319120794534683, 0.009504321031272411, 0.04204419627785683, 0.04392373561859131, 0.00648296857252717, 0.05549498647451401, -0.07390382140874863, -0.04418135806918144, 0.05839041620492935, -0.004984167870134115, 0.0527283139526844, -0.05375926196575165, 0.013973109424114227, 0.02776905708014965, 0.02029717154800892, 0.006434335373342037, 0.036889709532260895, 0.006840081419795752, 0.03485436365008354, 0.018919913098216057, -0.023364948108792305, -0.03195984289050102, -0.01727251335978508, -0.03434653952717781, -0.04657883942127228, -0.07729261368513107, 0.02887076884508133, -0.003049636259675026, -0.03797556087374687, -0.04615036025643349, 0.03659538924694061, 0.020167501643300056, -0.01263735257089138, -0.004719618707895279, 0.030604565516114235, -0.007603733334690332, 0.044206563383340836, -0.013614729978144169, -0.009006920270621777, 0.029652759432792664, -0.03344026207923889, 0.007041210308670998, 0.026996351778507233, 0.04492523521184921, 0.02001217007637024, -0.004377214703708887, -0.014797152020037174, -0.014627876691520214, -0.026168517768383026, 0.04440576955676079, -0.04834088683128357, -0.01098594069480896, -0.026858972385525703, 0.0021481921430677176, 0.032724641263484955, 0.05979866161942482, -0.015431996434926987, 0.00829028058797121, -0.008226824924349785, -0.016220178455114365, -0.058289535343647, -0.07603837549686432, -0.021684681996703148, 0.03305278345942497, -0.03882790729403496, 0.032889869064092636, 0.0075918021611869335, 0.006349978968501091, 0.001651183352805674, 0.0012809738982468843, -0.007717749569565058, -0.011232731863856316, 0.01083332858979702, -0.02667412906885147, -0.010910358279943466, 0.060544103384017944, 0.06966201215982437, -0.019148727878928185, 0.06875984370708466, -0.012141942977905273, -0.053107552230358124, 0.029746301472187042, -0.012370124459266663, 0.01760437712073326, -0.011430848389863968, -0.03034520335495472, 0.03770386055111885, -0.029105355963110924, -0.022634392604231834, 0.04235236346721649, -0.09305604547262192, 0.07104071974754333, 0.053127922117710114, 0.014225472696125507, 0.01879141852259636, 0.021727899089455605, 0.01982453651726246, 0.031148076057434082, 0.013439038768410683, -0.007744954898953438, -0.038502391427755356, -0.019869716838002205, 0.02263507805764675, 0.03665566071867943, -0.02770496904850006, 0.01880062371492386, 0.05982053279876709, -0.01581055298447609, -0.007662136107683182, 0.029166962951421738, -0.004636217374354601, -0.0026428920682519674, 0.0002592999371699989, 0.010997338220477104, -0.00021258956985548139, -0.0065367440693080425, -0.03280502185225487, 0.0031459101010113955, 0.04726878181099892, 0.032428719103336334, 0.013226315379142761, 0.04830264672636986, 0.03444374352693558, 0.04424237459897995, -0.02011794224381447, 0.02021162211894989, 0.04161815345287323, -0.02368534542620182, -0.00902916956692934, 0.07029878348112106, 0.015381744131445885, 0.02863115817308426, 0.0157150961458683, 0.004217967391014099, 0.015184473246335983, 0.023085562512278557, -0.04703143984079361, 0.03151271864771843, 0.025004971772432327, -0.06055765599012375, 0.024293996393680573, -0.028959844261407852, -0.045258499681949615, -0.029059218242764473, 0.011040996760129929, 0.020123334601521492, -0.004616278689354658, 0.015501181595027447, -0.03739161044359207, 0.003435574471950531, -0.03134795278310776, 0.005726021248847246, 0.004669516813009977, -0.029962757602334023, -0.047058288007974625, 0.007942224852740765, -0.0350160151720047, -0.012459899298846722, 0.01249241828918457, -0.013145195320248604, -0.024618564173579216, 0.02211323007941246, -0.01175121869891882, -0.07636959105730057, -0.043768368661403656, -0.024396758526563644, 0.003295301692560315, -0.04533807560801506, -0.02354256622493267, 0.06082383915781975, 0.03304407000541687, -0.019697660580277443, 0.042490240186452866, 0.011357349343597889, -0.039008356630802155, -0.04231550171971321, 0.016592977568507195, 0.002053544158115983, -0.025486377999186516, 0.000012756041542161256, 0.004227287136018276, 0.03265960142016411, -0.026559598743915558, -0.055733148008584976, -0.05530766770243645, 0.019285103306174278, 0.01330263540148735, 0.05474383756518364, -0.0023445598781108856, -0.01812366396188736, 0.08297012746334076, 0.012512599118053913, -0.01741218753159046, -0.018649997189641, 0.012533174827694893, -0.023890886455774307, 0.015741605311632156, 0.00509724160656333, 0.04270506277680397, 0.03353693336248398, 0.06334394216537476, -0.0048113027587533, 0.046507611870765686, 0.06718435883522034, -0.015202178619801998, -0.008973963558673859, 0.0179856326431036, -0.032255496829748154, -0.009280825965106487, 0.02017325349152088, 0.011304286308586597, -0.027459271252155304, -0.0006358645623549819, -0.013337080366909504, 0.018331948667764664, -0.021290255710482597, -0.018027067184448242, 0.017764050513505936, 0.004840807989239693, 0.009551946073770523, -0.026068411767482758, 0.03695287927985191, 0.0328432098031044, -0.0021918904967606068, -0.011840252205729485, 0.043288830667734146, 0.04067905619740486, -0.06256324797868729, 0.010861514136195183, 0.05361615866422653, 0.03616344556212425, -0.024313203990459442, -0.02834477834403515, -0.0016143836546689272, -0.032880060374736786, 0.01790316216647625, -0.02861512266099453, 0.0029630609788000584, -0.02289988100528717, 0.043375927954912186, 0.0010273444931954145, 0.002780844457447529, -0.012916411273181438, 0.004040804225951433, -0.055856797844171524, -0.01741226390004158, 0.0069937389343976974, 0.04971105232834816, -0.019451746717095375, 0.03907079994678497, -0.009104969911277294, 0.017945200204849243, 0.007696289569139481, -0.03303400054574013, -0.03228587657213211, -0.009211819618940353, -0.008410012349486351, -0.009450103156268597, 0.012278837151825428, -0.04118575528264046, 0.03966167941689491, -0.05082206428050995, 0.016883360221982002, -0.00529126264154911, 0.0592605359852314, -0.025408564135432243, 0.0031209029257297516, -0.03291873633861542, 0.006615553051233292, 0.009497497230768204, 0.011782856658101082, 0.024175632745027542, -0.029353192076086998, 0.017557917162775993, 0.024583980441093445, 0.0010298577835783362, -0.015621758997440338, -0.05289437621831894, -0.0030610838439315557, 0.035852525383234024, 0.04844392091035843, -0.006363056134432554, 0.03982686623930931, -0.020293554291129112, -0.0039053382351994514, 0.029893353581428528, 0.050274286419153214, 0.007211762014776468, -0.026343228295445442, -0.013184107840061188, -0.022140460088849068, -0.022328339517116547, 0.00684362044557929, 0.028046660125255585, 0.009518243372440338, 0.002236846601590514, 0.04132767394185066, 0.019692206755280495, -0.06872603297233582, 0.030535440891981125, 0.029206665232777596, 0.008869856595993042, 0.00974463764578104, -0.03976394236087799, 0.019377730786800385, -0.04219916835427284, -0.0023732339031994343, 0.04203976318240166, -0.019100550562143326, -0.015015597455203533, -0.031558260321617126, 0.045603711158037186, 0.0018183632055297494, -0.008342590183019638, -0.026670753955841064, 0.011386963538825512, 0.032329361885786057, -0.026029765605926514, -0.05684228986501694, -0.011533142067492008, 0.06042823940515518, 0.03328240290284157, -0.01771933026611805, -0.008792854845523834, -0.05988307297229767, -0.023386288434267044, 0.004911057185381651, 0.023144101724028587, -0.03909027576446533, 0.00930554885417223, -0.045907944440841675, 0.02786823734641075, -0.0047340779565274715, -0.01932426542043686, 0.03880781680345535, 0.012825499288737774, 0.0025163220707327127, 0.009301815181970596, -0.020033525303006172, -0.0415429025888443, -0.0019039930775761604, -0.020467471331357956, 0.007660383824259043, 0.026740720495581627, -0.014639628119766712, -0.053929947316646576, -0.004800104536116123, 0.01705237105488777, 0.03887593001127243, -0.03552611544728279, -0.01288585178554058, 0.021132823079824448, 0.03783489391207695, -0.005395018495619297, -0.06743309646844864, 0.06627783179283142, -0.009461097419261932, -0.005984210874885321, 0.06278292834758759, -0.02324078232049942, -0.06106659024953842, 0.06490330398082733, 0.008669480681419373, -0.015935340896248817, -0.00170389492996037, -0.004232240840792656, 0.055277179926633835, 0.052378859370946884, 0.011417574249207973, 0.05202285945415497, -0.00950801745057106, 0.011940321885049343, 0.016486817970871925, 0.01161547377705574, -0.019841009750962257, -0.044644493609666824, -0.03980967029929161, -0.03284420818090439, 0.017098383978009224, -0.00017164964810945094, 0.013575696386396885, 0.008162210695445538, 0.07348594069480896, 0.014095072634518147, -0.030062459409236908, 0.020928572863340378, -0.008512349799275398, 0.01645723357796669, -0.0027316808700561523, -0.02927338518202305, 0.022715948522090912, 0.05122867971658707, -0.048161108046770096, 0.04171552509069443, -0.0482543483376503, -0.009580441750586033, 0.027338016778230667, -0.04755229875445366, 0.001573695451952517, -0.028437653556466103, -0.0238417387008667, 0.02842908725142479, -0.010278326459228992, 0.041527509689331055, 0.004097535274922848, 0.00438249297440052, -0.024125171825289726, 0.00805917289108038, -0.052171774208545685, -0.011064193211495876, 0.004155495669692755, 0.0006800718838348985, -0.03243749961256981, 0.023268328979611397, 0.028118951246142387, -0.01600055955350399, -0.07830341160297394, -0.022741951048374176, -0.011633503250777721, -0.0065355910919606686, -0.0013525938848033547, -0.03361352160573006, 0.014984323643147945, 0.032808590680360794, -0.008812634274363518, -0.0016971800941973925, 0.03047918528318405, 0.015559043735265732, -0.06132465600967407, -0.03226852044463158, 0.05007483810186386, 0.08033253252506256, -0.007368872407823801, -0.012165816500782967, 0.036441586911678314, -0.01881161518394947, -0.04167606309056282, 0.023965535685420036, 0.02680470235645771, -0.030443359166383743, -0.028143035247921944, -0.03358452394604683, -0.0037993674632161856, 0.012197667732834816, -0.020440882071852684, 0.0007356725982390344, 0.03381555899977684, 0.009427649900317192, 0.0026432485319674015, -0.028687765821814537, 0.0071266829036176205, 0.009637544862926006, 0.044587280601263046, -0.01510855183005333, -0.015812765806913376, 0.017907775938510895, -0.016259223222732544, 0.03840525448322296, 0.0009085982455871999, -0.029496727511286736, 0.007871287874877453, 0.07393021881580353, -0.013282205909490585, -0.010770113207399845, 0.024593837559223175, -0.01832793839275837, 0.060647618025541306, 0.0023133244831115007, 0.003030952764675021, 0.018815236166119576, 0.04523414745926857, -0.005281050223857164, -0.04086287319660187, -0.03483282029628754, 0.057863786816596985, 0.06597831845283508, -0.020194603130221367, 0.04496317356824875, 0.006373901851475239, -0.027721259742975235, 0.008681053295731544, -0.04230139032006264, -0.0053776940330863, -0.03944968059659004, -0.014678675681352615, 0.043020132929086685, 0.0185899306088686, -0.013154035434126854, 0.06407871097326279, 0.015592982061207294, -0.0015548726078122854, 0.02881176955997944, 0.034512195736169815, 0.014936070889234543, 0.020612522959709167, -0.024852681905031204, -0.04043768346309662, 0.0712767168879509, -0.010469324886798859, 0.03434361144900322, -0.0257496926933527, -0.036779046058654785, 0.03738468512892723, 0.017553452402353287, -0.005605063401162624, -0.0878986343741417, -0.04818582907319069, -0.018796749413013458, -0.019691934809088707, -0.0014604382449761033, -0.02772427909076214, 0.023180261254310608, 0.00849812664091587, 0.0006430471548810601, 0.006208215374499559, 0.0372944250702858, 0.014608336612582207, -0.046319566667079926, -0.026740193367004395, -0.01344428863376379, -0.046496447175741196, 0.0006465265178121626, -0.022344430908560753, -0.043683409690856934, 0.04880625009536743, -0.04566732421517372, -0.001380796660669148, 0.014418933540582657, 0.033225417137145996, -0.010336811654269695, 0.08825664967298508, 0.03606049716472626, 0.038084447383880615, 0.02476540021598339, -0.013174918480217457, 0.0838879868388176, 0.06888741254806519, 0.01872885785996914, -0.0352097749710083, 0.020772051066160202, 0.0021451895590871572, -0.0038753938861191273, -0.0025350109208375216, -0.012920204550027847, 0.015949400141835213, 0.011001893319189548, 0.031697701662778854, 0.020405098795890808, 0.0028209490701556206, -0.014669514261186123, 0.01793987676501274, -0.015441345050930977, -0.024712666869163513, 0.017515862360596657, 0.01812250167131424, 0.0203468706458807, -0.02734135277569294, -0.018550092354416847, 0.011174758896231651, 0.014827687293291092, -0.04181035980582237, 0.0004838554305024445, -0.009875086136162281, -0.013714652508497238, 0.0328085832297802, -0.04348987713456154, 0.03477940335869789, 0.01394700724631548, -0.017094314098358154, -0.01828545145690441, 0.00871499814093113, -0.006210511550307274, -0.06011328101158142, 0.0068090748973190784, 0.012658609077334404, 7.625342846040439e-7, 0.007415261585265398, -0.006952534429728985, -0.0006090907845646143, -0.038751352578401566, -0.00848439708352089, -0.015372871421277523, 0.004039669409394264, 0.017173653468489647, -0.013501695357263088, -0.03745612874627113, -0.022323548793792725, -0.013626940548419952, -0.016062282025814056, -0.026314420625567436, 0.02630477212369442, 0.03708168491721153, -0.023826617747545242, -0.035316236317157745, -0.012725448235869408, 0.005066704470664263, -0.00526752695441246, 0.011998524889349937, 0.04176551476120949, -0.03454019874334335, -0.024511093273758888, -0.008489249274134636, 0.04005277156829834, 0.03796623274683952, -0.001305888989008963, -0.04638320952653885, -0.01852376013994217, -0.02804284170269966, -0.02212080918252468, 0.011741616763174534, -0.010253184475004673, 0.03379945084452629, -0.007200941909104586, -0.01854861155152321, -0.015900133177638054, -0.04413440078496933, 0.01195010356605053, -0.03723892942070961, -0.015373902395367622, -0.009442586451768875, -0.03395046666264534, -0.009161246940493584, 0.00824111420661211, 0.015771327540278435, 0.005899230018258095, 0.014043308794498444, 0.07726413756608963, 0.018165260553359985, -0.047075431793928146, -0.020032204687595367, -0.011616464704275131, -0.0390070304274559, -0.006062295753508806, 0.03153781220316887, 0.055978432297706604, 0.00974560808390379, 0.03806615620851517, 0.03245847299695015, 0.006920326501131058, -0.023306705057621002, 0.013631712645292282, -0.0022516155149787664, -0.0857754573225975, 0.05900414660573006, 0.05178358033299446, 0.002649470465257764, -0.026436900720000267, -0.0032454757019877434, 0.005695067346096039, -0.015533726662397385, 0.012055819854140282, 0.009053369052708149, -0.033004093915224075, -0.024793723598122597, 0.010582905262708664, 0.018771568313241005, -0.045184649527072906, -0.01568499580025673, -0.005433417856693268, 0.044468529522418976, -0.03309741988778114, 0.016486909240484238, -0.005294864531606436, 0.009544291533529758, 0.017011446878314018, -0.006230809725821018, 0.029101934283971786, -0.01637876033782959, 0.025610370561480522, -0.02478940039873123, -0.016768068075180054, -0.013882959261536598, 0.05617811158299446, -0.016749899834394455, -0.012417572550475597, 0.056637801229953766, -0.058525942265987396, -0.02613508328795433, -0.00224764714948833, 0.005485848523676395, 0.004526242148131132, 0.006051283795386553, -0.015934128314256668, -0.052135173231363297, 0.05654532089829445, -0.073030985891819, -0.012069173157215118, -0.03745933994650841, 0.0054968553595244884, 0.01660389080643654, -0.06257706135511398, -0.024189721792936325, 0.0014304574579000473, 0.018593715503811836, 0.031343769282102585, 0.01930764690041542, -0.01954493671655655, -0.011600404977798462, 0.034884996712207794, 0.01826244220137596, -0.0000032514853955945, -0.010448631830513477, -0.003176011610776186, 0.0014977726386860013, 0.03499731048941612, -0.05147480219602585, 0.01360652968287468, -0.030751371756196022, 0.012672336772084236, -0.08953305333852768, -0.028832249343395233, 0.02228803187608719, -0.028187520802021027, 0.04812221974134445, -0.04320954158902168, -0.019412152469158173, 0.03836832195520401, -0.05057493969798088, -0.021633561700582504, 0.004698643460869789, 0.028800103813409805, -0.046337395906448364, -0.016753004863858223, -0.03653215616941452, 0.0026485512498766184, 0.03624831140041351, 0.015661610290408134, 0.04455001279711723, 0.02051788754761219, -0.01665414124727249, -0.0018320386298000813, -0.02184668928384781, 0.02417926676571369, 0.02160411886870861, -0.05628274381160736, 0.051534201949834824, -0.04114128649234772, 0.010339501313865185, 0.0858692079782486, -0.017388034611940384, -0.02026563510298729, 0.03147805482149124, 0.04322325065732002, 0.0018799536628648639, 0.017422763630747795, 0.02505658008158207, 0.012453844770789146, -0.002558518201112747, 0.01890019327402115, 0.014701786451041698, 0.008264978416264057, 0.021412508562207222, 0.016561521217226982, 0.03030097298324108, -0.04150775820016861, -0.019245026633143425, 0.006536075845360756, -0.006272110156714916, -0.0009024629835039377, 0.03663547709584236, -0.022458475083112717, -0.0080905482172966, -0.038139261305332184, 0.044349100440740585, -0.05075463652610779, -0.027063030749559402, 0.03271932899951935, 0.0031634687911719084, -0.023489607498049736, 0.012223422527313232, -0.024680599570274353, -0.028268789872527122, -0.009026425890624523, 0.0172682236880064, -0.009679892100393772, -0.039660580456256866, 0.005782027263194323, 0.03098905459046364, -0.0010693329386413097, -0.03924493491649628, -0.01863519288599491, -0.0877266675233841, 0.05763121694326401, -0.010177086107432842, 0.003104776842519641, -0.006245267577469349, -0.020755019038915634, 0.02006191946566105, -0.09909078478813171, 0.07794690132141113, 0.036568012088537216, 0.009331037290394306, -0.030765073373913765, -0.004488821607083082, -0.0526663176715374, -0.02550312504172325, 0.058594051748514175, 0.02573898248374462, -0.0034521552734076977, 0.029326636344194412, 0.027411187067627907, 0.008694606833159924, -0.012403137050569057, 0.061280686408281326, 0.0016629466554149985, -0.00421135313808918, -0.025463050231337547, -0.036884959787130356, 0.029124684631824493, 0.010352207347750664, -0.04442625120282173, -0.024325469508767128, 0.0185483880341053, 0.012665677815675735, 0.011060941964387894, 0.03567785397171974, -0.024539589881896973, -0.02160659432411194, 0.06738243997097015, -0.04053594917058945, 0.004886341281235218, 0.013007762841880322, 0.029021967202425003, -0.08495590090751648, -0.001935569103807211, -0.007021171040832996, -0.04484192654490471, 0.01771465502679348, 0.006804510485380888, -0.020083047449588776, -0.031126152724027634, -0.018337247893214226, 0.005358959082514048, -0.02778770588338375, -0.0180578101426363, -0.0028471210971474648, 0.012669261544942856, 0.04044078662991524, -0.00804902520030737, -0.006555864587426186, 0.00510382978245616, 0.02263644151389599, -0.0023537043016403913, 0.037469282746315, -0.024833517149090767, 0.035052478313446045, 0.0015559156890958548, 0.01056739967316389, 0.009503467939794064, 0.06309013813734055, 0.01217262540012598, 0.022151609882712364, 0.0021678581833839417, -0.050556205213069916, 0.016390766948461533, -0.04792618378996849, 0.0245251152664423, -0.02277229353785515, 0.03328236937522888, 0.07296556234359741, -0.0013906017411500216, 0.02769373171031475, -0.010355263017117977, 0.025431042537093163, -0.022216539829969406, -0.003911023493856192, -0.008497262373566628, -0.04968741163611412, -0.021037092432379723, 0.008768136613070965, 0.010905236937105656, 0.010000640526413918, 0.01058523915708065, -0.012581432238221169, 0.022877397015690804, 0.0023932098411023617, 0.0006436769617721438, -0.0029053203761577606, -0.03660215437412262, 0.011847281828522682, -0.023259030655026436, 0.013644028455018997, 0.024011246860027313, 0.011264058761298656, -0.0009429393103346229, -0.030383702367544174, -0.002915165387094021, 0.044377680867910385, -0.04964331537485123, -0.06466928869485855, -0.025509517639875412, -0.02046665921807289, 0.002508800942450762, -0.056199315935373306 ]
<p>Scikit Learn's <a href="http://scikit-learn.org/stable/tutorial/statistical_inference/model_selection.html" rel="nofollow">page on Model Selection</a> mentions the use of nested cross-validation: </p> <blockquote> <pre><code>&gt;&gt;&gt; clf = GridSearchCV(estimator=svc, param_grid=dict(gamma=gammas), ... n_jobs=-1) &gt;&gt;&gt; cross_validation.cross_val_score(clf, X_digits, y_digits) </code></pre> <p>Two cross-validation loops are performed in parallel: one by the GridSearchCV estimator to set gamma and the other one by cross_val_score to measure the prediction performance of the estimator. The resulting scores are unbiased estimates of the prediction score on new data.</p> </blockquote> <p>From what I understand, <code>clf.fit</code> will use cross-validation natively to determine the best gamma. In that case, why would we need to use nested cv as given above? The note mentions that nested cv produces "unbiased estimates" of the prediction score. Isn't that also the case with <code>clf.fit</code>?</p> <p>Also, I was unable to get the clf best estimates from the <code>cross_validation.cross_val_score(clf, X_digits, y_digits)</code> procedure. Could you please advise how that can be done?</p>
73,520
[ -0.056793462485075, 0.005296428222209215, 0.002534105908125639, 0.03317216411232948, 0.055020131170749664, -0.017322314903140068, 0.007169492542743683, -0.019912680611014366, 0.06493943184614182, -0.04267745092511177, 0.027448289096355438, 0.04313712939620018, 0.049223098903894424, 0.011574231088161469, 0.018083548173308372, 0.021435312926769257, 0.021301601082086563, 0.012094645760953426, 0.014787700027227402, -0.05681995674967766, -0.02332187071442604, 0.04449563845992088, -0.009934134781360626, 0.0012170161353424191, -0.0035498212091624737, 0.028872864320874214, 0.0178814809769392, -0.04223534092307091, -0.0017739624017849565, 0.004836980253458023, -0.05140107870101929, -0.05471827834844589, 0.006719810888171196, 0.04116392880678177, 0.005624945275485516, 0.013086718507111073, -0.020004702731966972, -0.04268927127122879, -0.018348833546042442, 0.046112485229969025, 0.012944968417286873, -0.008838553912937641, -0.01896570809185505, 0.0502052828669548, 0.02387329749763012, 0.03506278619170189, -0.013807874172925949, 0.011543630622327328, 0.011070840060710907, -0.027905387803912163, 0.054695818573236465, -0.041439350694417953, 0.02026834525167942, 0.022009609267115593, -0.015785539522767067, 0.006075385492295027, 0.026870813220739365, 0.03291816636919975, -0.018649926409125328, -0.04077059403061867, -0.022397750988602638, -0.025907069444656372, 0.013542260974645615, -0.00967460684478283, -0.004604104906320572, 0.006530338898301125, -0.0034269376192241907, -0.01003821101039648, 0.043260835111141205, -0.006562278140336275, 0.01656985841691494, 0.020577779039740562, 0.043998152017593384, -0.00620499299839139, 0.028413332998752594, -0.01729562319815159, -0.011833754368126392, 0.031446706503629684, 0.01449236273765564, 0.019363287836313248, 0.010197382420301437, 0.017919208854436874, -0.00674250815063715, 0.020705977454781532, -0.0106974421069026, 0.03850023075938225, 0.06893689930438995, 0.009695489890873432, 0.027578752487897873, 0.0007118051871657372, 0.02110798843204975, -0.01984364725649357, 0.05103985220193863, -0.011497614905238152, -0.01277044229209423, 0.049716800451278687, -0.008348518051207066, 0.006115732714533806, 0.0007022008066996932, -0.011970466002821922, -0.010752491652965546, -0.008506559766829014, 0.020136741921305656, 0.07195240259170532, -0.013636688701808453, 0.0000788174947956577, -0.026082288473844528, -0.016728200018405914, 0.010743227787315845, -0.023056548088788986, -0.06839582324028015, -0.002970116911455989, -0.02831926755607128, -0.022614644840359688, 0.02087077684700489, 0.004808967933058739, -0.015111255459487438, 0.022704442963004112, 0.027954740449786186, 0.045376695692539215, 0.04418913647532463, -0.0475599505007267, 0.0173075869679451, -0.069382444024086, -0.05714411288499832, -0.010285628959536552, 0.04749830439686775, -0.02189292199909687, -0.005177528131753206, 0.028947746381163597, -0.014983623288571835, -0.005330018699169159, 0.01864119991660118, 0.011866881512105465, -0.0007622567936778069, 0.017618216574192047, -0.10419201105833054, -0.09124494343996048, 0.03710378706455231, -0.005785003770142794, 0.02805199846625328, -0.04644462466239929, 0.024573637172579765, -0.011952238157391548, 0.07165273278951645, -0.006469162181019783, 0.01237124390900135, 0.007173681631684303, 0.0024725922849029303, -0.02166348695755005, -0.027161741629242897, -0.00813479907810688, -0.02994079329073429, 0.000724329671356827, -0.032949965447187424, -0.06338634341955185, 0.030876122415065765, -0.018283791840076447, -0.015052382834255695, -0.010515992529690266, -0.013361725956201553, -0.02918761968612671, 0.017144348472356796, -0.030385904014110565, 0.0008208511280827224, -0.045278966426849365, 0.04834816977381706, -0.0049500977620482445, 0.06882410496473312, 0.004368663765490055, -0.027128078043460846, -0.02551867999136448, 0.010733246803283691, -0.007839626632630825, 0.016635190695524216, 0.009066256694495678, 0.000026668789359973744, -0.024092335253953934, 0.04162498190999031, -0.025372283533215523, -0.04382553696632385, -0.02714286930859089, -0.0007531747105531394, 0.047773152589797974, -0.006085437256842852, 0.059776414185762405, 0.010164766572415829, -0.0215621218085289, 0.034996215254068375, -0.04029716178774834, -0.03423822671175003, -0.03462837263941765, 0.018711760640144348, -0.008544708602130413, 0.009793496690690517, 0.03340285271406174, -0.03049648366868496, 0.025814516469836235, -0.0022252360358834267, -0.031003497540950775, 0.0007327076746150851, 0.010567578487098217, 0.021076984703540802, -0.009488632902503014, 0.012806955724954605, 0.04305601492524147, 0.012262028641998768, -0.014303960837423801, 0.0429503507912159, -0.03593403473496437, -0.03152316436171532, 0.015387955121695995, -0.04798568785190582, -0.003903160337358713, -0.015744006261229515, -0.04721788316965103, 0.03560874983668327, 0.03603840991854668, 0.004287670366466045, 0.00033248827094212174, -0.029403895139694214, 0.0765010416507721, 0.03232615813612938, 0.03480035811662674, 0.038826923817396164, 0.032050926238298416, -0.011309105902910233, 0.025638483464717865, -0.0417267382144928, 0.009589648805558681, -0.04876396432518959, -0.04997852072119713, 0.05575978010892868, -0.013325756415724754, -0.04022208973765373, -0.018874503672122955, 0.03994064778089523, -0.006503778975456953, 0.018403396010398865, -0.018373582512140274, -0.0357343852519989, -0.01762671023607254, 0.015943238511681557, 0.04073663055896759, -0.019334712997078896, -0.010990159586071968, 0.011501864530146122, -0.009366975165903568, 0.02323205955326557, 0.0034850717056542635, -0.019175207242369652, 0.059349458664655685, 0.010196403600275517, 0.020358573645353317, 0.008853920735418797, -0.06462915986776352, 0.029532985761761665, 0.004532754421234131, 0.02324221469461918, 0.03104853630065918, -0.02515590749680996, 0.02763362228870392, -0.004169189836829901, -0.02240549772977829, 0.04623802751302719, 0.020341575145721436, -0.05458878353238106, 0.010484919883310795, 0.022203858941793442, -0.07521405816078186, -0.004882271867245436, -0.0088669927790761, -0.03636547178030014, -0.04176879674196243, -0.0034435000270605087, 0.028414448723196983, 0.003400523914024234, 0.008212987333536148, -0.026441948488354683, 0.006379729136824608, -0.05681323632597923, -0.028383053839206696, 0.06849851459264755, -0.0123984944075346, -0.0075167883187532425, 0.006585112772881985, -0.005051371641457081, -0.029051057994365692, 0.039724431931972504, -0.015401072800159454, -0.022565780207514763, 0.013313040137290955, 0.015882227569818497, -0.022549496963620186, -0.0021333976183086634, -0.02366403304040432, 0.03485145419836044, 0.007927034050226212, -0.023833274841308594, 0.011160566471517086, 0.0022641534451395273, -0.07047326117753983, 0.055684302002191544, 0.02625134587287903, -0.04719490930438042, -0.0009195280144922435, -0.019809992983937263, -0.02672486938536167, -0.003064352087676525, 0.027385275810956955, 0.05418791621923447, -0.004402585793286562, 0.0315418504178524, -0.07002970576286316, -0.03535160422325134, 0.029632659628987312, 0.0063499934040009975, 0.009972536005079746, 0.017696628347039223, -0.004725038539618254, 0.08918163180351257, 0.01996506005525589, -0.020555321127176285, -0.03934439644217491, 0.016140341758728027, -0.0430004745721817, -0.011296223849058151, 0.00920175388455391, 0.01055114809423685, -0.014344477094709873, 0.008956055156886578, 0.0008295489824377, 0.021115433424711227, 0.05935896560549736, -0.00970054604113102, 0.014903182163834572, 0.0052576386369764805, 0.00392193952575326, -0.01814686320722103, 0.016238996759057045, 0.003711559111252427, 0.012083207257091999, -0.0017214423278346658, -0.023330355063080788, -0.009050673805177212, 0.0021517316345125437, -0.00022176685160957277, 0.018597763031721115, -0.024775497615337372, -0.018682921305298805, -0.04325515404343605, 0.01603962667286396, 0.0036386754363775253, -0.05009599030017853, 0.013450424186885357, 0.05076585337519646, 0.021957067772746086, -0.0060077691450715065, 0.001989151118323207, 0.015584773384034634, 0.06586970388889313, -0.009089061990380287, -0.0493699386715889, -0.048406701534986496, -0.02923290804028511, 0.021887103095650673, 0.03982016071677208, 0.001624175114557147, 0.05970132723450661, 0.07739932090044022, 0.00008890694880392402, -0.005819329526275396, -0.05873062089085579, 0.010689889080822468, -0.08782896399497986, 0.009894408285617828, -0.04929091036319733, 0.03548148274421692, 0.03984726592898369, 0.00763860484585166, 0.05854502692818642, -0.029558977112174034, 0.0013820966705679893, 0.050544094294309616, -0.06534059345722198, 0.019702937453985214, 0.03226969391107559, 0.014168958179652691, -0.01009615883231163, -0.010255511850118637, 0.0166302677243948, 0.02953842282295227, 0.004545053467154503, 0.015258131548762321, 0.010921350680291653, -0.01895519345998764, -0.020685601979494095, -0.001720847561955452, 0.0028861791361123323, -0.011372867040336132, -0.002385469386354089, 0.02804911881685257, -0.026219239458441734, 0.04198407754302025, 0.042645636945962906, -0.016191303730010986, -0.01688455045223236, -0.04035261645913124, 0.025946596637368202, 0.00457130977883935, 0.01666301116347313, 0.02236245758831501, 0.01702752336859703, -0.056164830923080444, -0.015856336802244186, 0.019093941897153854, -0.007011089939624071, 0.059427980333566666, -0.004620525054633617, -0.026441020891070366, -0.05362442508339882, -0.004904044326394796, 0.025268208235502243, -0.014432624913752079, 0.013340303674340248, 0.04362844303250313, 0.0551009364426136, 0.026477012783288956, -0.040306441485881805, 0.019641265273094177, 0.09761742502450943, 0.02080630511045456, -0.013397837989032269, 0.011874091811478138, -0.04697737097740173, -0.005680392030626535, -0.044439077377319336, 0.04396381974220276, 0.012907854281365871, -0.009679308161139488, 0.007889778353273869, 0.03601841628551483, -0.0359383262693882, -0.0224821325391531, 0.014678001403808594, 0.03341139480471611, 0.04887525364756584, -0.007093389984220266, -0.02848929725587368, -0.01309974305331707, 0.04019986838102341, 0.017277607694268227, 0.04301904886960983, -0.04414677992463112, -0.1091688871383667, -0.06462235003709793, 0.04530034959316254, 0.030861686915159225, -0.017723018303513527, -0.01714114472270012, -0.025830863043665886, -0.02903020568192005, 0.016423186287283897, -0.046810515224933624, 0.04169229045510292, -0.014000769704580307, -0.022745899856090546, -0.017201846465468407, -0.020696137100458145, -0.04133935645222664, 0.030425185337662697, -0.024808362126350403, 0.03741208836436272, -0.009412772953510284, -0.03437061235308647, -0.027850674465298653, 0.013624051585793495, -0.022708691656589508, 0.03320590779185295, -0.01284119300544262, -0.05206314101815224, -0.0063624088652431965, 0.0011806751135736704, 0.005359598435461521, -0.056772127747535706, -0.016715332865715027, -0.022725507616996765, -0.012538413517177105, 0.03953823447227478, 0.00710681639611721, -0.03685402125120163, 0.010194379836320877, 0.0579923652112484, -0.04563245177268982, 0.002108599990606308, -0.04232651740312576, 0.028958387672901154, -0.007943953387439251, 0.004604343790560961, 0.07432971894741058, 0.0186456385999918, -0.023572327569127083, -0.00680122384801507, -0.007660335395485163, 0.015418516471982002, -0.020235374569892883, 0.0082027493044734, -0.030342724174261093, -0.056331075727939606, -0.0029052256140857935, 0.013178626075387001, 0.01442202553153038, 0.018073664978146553, -0.002743443939834833, -0.02337462082505226, 0.005541888065636158, 0.03730365261435509, -0.004440252669155598, -0.008623838424682617, -0.004952572751790285, 0.016856448724865913, 0.0244832094758749, -0.009409009478986263, -0.004313063807785511, -0.02075442671775818, 0.014388998970389366, 0.013477979227900505, -0.04051222279667854, -0.05030970647931099, -0.03561221435666084, -0.002711022039875388, 0.013493919745087624, -0.0061989398673176765, 0.03970959037542343, -0.0031005286145955324, 0.013787046074867249, -0.02406613528728485, -0.0167697686702013, -0.008216416463255882, 0.01116158440709114, -0.016017083078622818, 0.026743369176983833, -0.027667000889778137, 0.06504008173942566, 0.00566847762092948, -0.0169509407132864, -0.06452564895153046, -0.00617757486179471, 0.03549889102578163, 0.03338446840643883, -0.03323577716946602, -0.009612685069441795, -0.009151480160653591, -0.002760563511401415, -0.020880624651908875, -0.008157200179994106, 0.02905186451971531, -0.007210107054561377, -0.00207178620621562, -0.009895838797092438, 0.018133077770471573, 0.03876308351755142, 0.0008653873228468001, 0.01086998451501131, 0.019891442731022835, -0.0016721307765692472, -0.0193791501224041, 0.016142969951033592, 0.014639639295637608, -0.03003133088350296, 0.027619946748018265, -0.014910942874848843, 0.033201199024915695, 0.03633763641119003, 0.00787095446139574, -0.022474637255072594, 0.030411995947360992, -0.04767557978630066, 0.01745542325079441, -0.035357434302568436, -0.024079538881778717, -0.031578462570905685, 0.009341858327388763, 0.012710229493677616, -0.0067765782587230206, -0.004041974898427725, -0.010843189433217049, 0.05215160548686981, 0.00012438968406058848, -0.03539448231458664, -0.0013767970958724618, 0.08318660408258438, -0.01755884848535061, 0.018328389152884483, -0.013367214240133762, -0.013897453434765339, 0.03353817015886307, 0.0031636215280741453, 0.009015874937176704, 0.04165744036436081, 0.048209674656391144, -0.04911544546484947, 0.017402108758687973, -0.023074518889188766, 0.019874190911650658, 0.05127338320016861, -0.03105989843606949, 0.05810405686497688, -0.01028396375477314, -0.020900145173072815, -0.00040262474794872105, -0.0707695335149765, -0.03249408304691315, -0.041451483964920044, -0.0007149360608309507, 0.05687930807471275, 0.04870257526636124, 0.03891366720199585, 0.06719786673784256, 0.011476957239210606, 0.02456410601735115, 0.015582110732793808, 0.0435330756008625, 0.014461595565080643, -0.005193263757973909, -0.023496663197875023, -0.024278098717331886, 0.036338165402412415, -0.050388213247060776, -0.011455069296061993, 0.000150991982081905, -0.032603465020656586, 0.026093872264027596, 0.03437280282378197, 0.012769282795488834, -0.03328658640384674, -0.01688740961253643, -0.06750142574310303, 0.04228752851486206, 0.02058136835694313, -0.02668125554919243, 0.02109467051923275, 0.03237131983041763, 0.017805902287364006, 0.008610404096543789, 0.013259471394121647, -0.05740479379892349, -0.04843626916408539, -0.051511093974113464, -0.03414710611104965, 0.003285773564130068, 0.020288946107029915, 0.01877976767718792, -0.0444636344909668, 0.03745616599917412, -0.017197933048009872, 0.051152098923921585, -0.0021235353779047728, 0.03748060390353203, -0.03714371845126152, 0.03830024227499962, 0.01245096419006586, 0.010554997250437737, -0.015077433548867702, -0.010012011975049973, 0.11832789331674576, 0.10904663056135178, 0.028016775846481323, -0.05925719439983368, 0.023092666640877724, 0.00920195784419775, 0.024485964328050613, -0.007899822667241096, -0.04308617487549782, 0.011724566109478474, 0.002782071242108941, 0.01937456987798214, 0.03534683957695961, 0.06080111488699913, 0.0018777493387460709, 0.023594381287693977, -0.013072480447590351, 0.015608355402946472, 0.01980079896748066, 0.0038697123527526855, 0.04033758491277695, -0.02655172161757946, -0.04740312322974205, 0.0185113362967968, 0.01311089564114809, -0.016622168943285942, -0.029392778873443604, -0.016688546165823936, 0.0037187361158430576, -0.005121330730617046, -0.004713184665888548, 0.01084073819220066, -0.008412422612309456, -0.005559797398746014, 0.00687872339040041, 0.030577940866351128, -0.010767494328320026, -0.001926935976371169, 0.017803804948925972, -0.005356433801352978, 0.00887064915150404, -0.0019526237156242132, 0.0011179777793586254, 0.02200893498957157, -0.034522682428359985, 0.0004385428037494421, -0.03712227940559387, 0.0533258393406868, -0.021531712263822556, -0.031865764409303665, -0.002813916653394699, 0.009550904855132103, 0.00928075984120369, -0.022756239399313927, -0.01115758903324604, 0.014663382433354855, 0.015332541428506374, -0.03374757617712021, -0.05699645355343819, -0.041209425777196884, 0.029174910858273506, -0.012814420275390148, 0.03108786791563034, 0.025884898379445076, -0.042580604553222656, -0.05011190474033356, -0.05282599478960037, 0.06905517727136612, 0.0200656708329916, 0.042932767421007156, 0.018340719863772392, -0.02291620336472988, -0.020374029874801636, -0.024420185014605522, 0.02530243620276451, -0.02209283597767353, 0.03797772899270058, -0.011752746067941189, -0.0231779757887125, -0.026851754635572433, -0.04555075615644455, -0.021320588886737823, -0.0032787334639579058, 0.0003864451718982309, -0.06402941048145294, 0.04349249228835106, 0.0028626902494579554, -0.0011373978340998292, 0.02579023316502571, 0.00020752011914737523, 0.0020711557008326054, 0.03313235566020012, -0.005846590735018253, -0.05764611437916756, -0.026848040521144867, -0.0030144285410642624, 0.004457273054867983, 0.004575793165713549, 0.016032196581363678, 0.05539584159851074, 0.016881758347153664, 0.04430967569351196, 0.011214038357138634, 0.028202714398503304, -0.014902541413903236, -0.01562569849193096, -0.03157370164990425, -0.054984696209430695, -0.015634549781680107, 0.024073375388979912, -0.032446909695863724, -0.02859753742814064, -0.014252584427595139, -0.05340571328997612, -0.057143863290548325, 0.03163376823067665, 0.0021680311765521765, -0.07803712040185928, -0.01736678183078766, -0.006809802260249853, 0.03851667791604996, -0.044705066829919815, -0.0007475324673578143, 0.0023477955255657434, 0.01168800238519907, -0.05681962892413139, -0.060155048966407776, 0.031485699117183685, -0.020405083894729614, -0.012678715400397778, -0.010680748149752617, 0.008340861648321152, 0.0005793247255496681, 0.0291255135089159, -0.0009766682051122189, -0.014042597264051437, 0.005490950774401426, 0.008319837041199207, -0.03502894565463066, -0.024455970153212547, 0.05252460390329361, 0.0006211210275068879, -0.05551047623157501, -0.000902277824934572, -0.007783215492963791, 0.0304779764264822, 0.04017132520675659, 0.019464444369077682, 0.016786282882094383, 0.05304647237062454, -0.014898751862347126, -0.0009065947961062193, -0.009941987693309784, 0.005531412083655596, 0.03188597783446312, -0.030090579763054848, -0.009484455920755863, -0.013048235327005386, 0.012927927076816559, 0.04080469533801079, 0.034966710954904556, 0.009571831673383713, 0.0005866964347660542, -0.002020282670855522, -0.0069318548776209354, 0.029141174629330635, 0.034892477095127106, 0.02349812164902687, 0.005916696507483721, 0.031210724264383316, 0.008705091662704945, 0.01572643592953682, -0.02870423160493374, 0.01247513946145773, -0.08468697220087051, -0.023182688280940056, 0.011629894375801086, 0.028712265193462372, 0.01841607503592968, -0.05443832650780678, 0.025516051799058914, 0.06333499401807785, -0.04868398606777191, 0.0282607264816761, 0.01208873838186264, -0.004495576955378056, -0.012785259634256363, 0.04302855581045151, -0.05838164687156677, 0.0014631953090429306, 0.016845084726810455, -0.007378534879535437, 0.04356568679213524, 0.0188588984310627, 0.009110798127949238, -0.03007066249847412, -0.031823668628931046, 0.007320221047848463, 0.003610726445913315, -0.027071809396147728, 0.06278389692306519, -0.0018297092756256461, -0.03401371091604233, 0.02330450527369976, -0.027157090604305267, -0.0023638075217604637, 0.038333818316459656, 0.050353024154901505, 0.021237019449472427, 0.03980766981840134, 0.023617537692189217, 0.007824701257050037, -0.006151441019028425, 0.0048945690505206585, 0.02212490327656269, 0.03953968733549118, 0.0072819446213543415, 0.02576569840312004, 0.007514700293540955, 0.024011876434087753, -0.010485473088920116, 0.03438467159867287, -0.05750102549791336, -0.0005111356149427593, 0.007490514311939478, 0.0006400347920134664, 0.019340751692652702, -0.031470734626054764, 0.003515298943966627, -0.053545162081718445, 0.014905362389981747, 0.030678806826472282, 0.01022377610206604, -0.02378348633646965, 0.014975322410464287, -0.03851566091179848, -0.02418344095349312, 0.012623081915080547, -0.009305332787334919, 0.009388141334056854, -0.01054682582616806, -0.010609610006213188, 0.024979256093502045, -0.02141501195728779, -0.0004974474431946874, -0.008875508792698383, -0.044706035405397415, 0.04557346925139427, 0.0007355293491855264, 0.03422627970576286, 0.00428701750934124, -0.009349667467176914, 0.004220115952193737, -0.1114957258105278, 0.07379887253046036, -0.005273712798953056, -0.06526993215084076, -0.04068002104759216, -0.028410740196704865, 0.03221382573246956, -0.04699629545211792, 0.04883957654237747, -0.019600674510002136, 0.014336525462567806, -0.01692330464720726, 0.024161579087376595, -0.023292087018489838, -0.02346416749060154, 0.014066031202673912, -0.030260499566793442, -0.01712203025817871, -0.015615442767739296, -0.03107977844774723, -0.023950498551130295, 0.01684325933456421, 0.03365436568856239, 0.00665688794106245, 0.01590307243168354, 0.0012242351658642292, 0.012071619741618633, 0.004091890994459391, 0.009278111159801483, 0.007302224636077881, 0.08251548558473587, 0.05662728473544121, -0.0030988422222435474, 0.01448608934879303, -0.0008490977343171835, -0.05628814548254013, 0.0032303882762789726, -0.018622547388076782, -0.01974284090101719, -0.030173657462000847, 0.028399240225553513, 0.026715833693742752, -0.03972596302628517, -0.007431933656334877, 0.05345231667160988, -0.046557772904634476, -0.01920599676668644, 0.030314669013023376, 0.02976047992706299, 0.04290056973695755, 0.016278957948088646, -0.0021040767896920443, 0.0505128912627697, -0.025711720809340477, -0.019072070717811584, 0.0407257042825222, 0.02425379678606987, 0.018309712409973145, 0.024255897849798203, 0.039935484528541565, -0.028100894764065742, 0.0006990577094256878, -0.03846326470375061, 0.08075002580881119, -0.04995347931981087, -0.018533460795879364, 0.01057746633887291, 0.0013116125483065844, 0.000108370601083152, -0.01999329775571823, -0.035547565668821335, 0.05348488688468933, -0.029201773926615715, -0.0132701201364398, -0.02726544626057148, -0.021648336201906204, -0.03180806711316109, -0.013144001364707947, 0.029080098494887352, 0.02364092692732811, 0.007980022579431534, -0.0007873436552472413, -0.0017080893740057945, 0.009549152106046677, 0.053655870258808136, -0.00863694678992033, 0.010381484404206276, -0.035550329834222794, -0.0013047832762822509, 0.034020595252513885, -0.0006047505885362625, -0.043967507779598236, -0.001200433587655425, 0.017323087900877, 0.031782954931259155, 0.011435039341449738, 0.0016503001097589731, -0.04477708786725998, -0.004334048368036747, 0.060685571283102036, -0.07299796491861343, 0.022709662094712257, -0.06261785328388214, 0.013834876008331776, 0.026458945125341415, -0.00990233663469553 ]
<p>My dataset contains a lot of variables that appear to me as practically categorical on a continuous scale to differing degrees.</p> <p>Many have a large chunk of zeros or specific value followed by one or more apparent separate chunks. In some cases this is obvious where there are literally 2 specific single effectively on/off. Others are much more potential candidates where there are almost 2 or more separate distributions.</p> <p>I am trying to model a continuous normally distributed dependent on a number of potential variables (collected on a continuous scale). Most of these are likely not to contribute to the model. I will be using various modelling methods to explore what is best (i.e. I will be trying tree methods where the apparent binomial appearance isn't a problem). I am not assuming a good model can be produced.</p> <p>In these situations is are there any hard and fast rules/techniques as to whether to categorise or not? Also having potentially performed the transformations what considerations/measures might I have to be aware of? I would say most of the dataset is like this.</p>
73,521
[ -0.05336475372314453, -0.0008026822470128536, -0.008079864084720612, -0.009443696588277817, 0.05116187408566475, -0.022934449836611748, 0.0011888407170772552, 0.0008079655817709863, 0.03676389530301094, -0.029597630724310875, 0.012394181452691555, -0.007994565181434155, 0.027405845001339912, 0.0011562901781871915, 0.026212114840745926, -0.011255511082708836, 0.0008334323647432029, -0.015390103682875633, -0.012127978727221489, 0.03008648194372654, 0.0020000003278255463, 0.0011459080269560218, 0.04820995405316353, -0.024808743968605995, -0.011262369342148304, 0.042662590742111206, 0.021045828238129616, -0.005089119542390108, 0.00618518702685833, 0.01577606610953808, -0.01800871454179287, -0.03136251121759415, 0.0012754877097904682, 0.03604765608906746, -0.0052821701392531395, 0.007911144755780697, -0.020820267498493195, -0.041663847863674164, -0.03253377601504326, 0.023510338738560677, -0.06490437686443329, -0.002498612040653825, 0.004132118076086044, 0.02102837711572647, 0.016397496685385704, 0.0026008521672338247, -0.024169230833649635, -0.003317334922030568, 0.020999277010560036, -0.05454673990607262, 0.09346041828393936, 0.01370040699839592, 0.06714904308319092, 0.04352009296417236, 0.004115661606192589, -0.03296412527561188, 0.07155679166316986, 0.052361637353897095, -0.029485804960131645, -0.05175620689988136, -0.01701318472623825, -0.03548099845647812, -0.014417534694075584, -0.0434030219912529, -0.015023290179669857, 0.024026665836572647, -0.009746738709509373, -0.0296741034835577, 0.06437861174345016, 0.0010395955760031939, 0.036631226539611816, 0.022480923682451248, 0.036922357976436615, 0.009357661940157413, 0.03199448436498642, -0.0065935528837144375, 0.016973664984107018, 0.021882373839616776, 0.04825952649116516, 0.03987035155296326, 0.0038046573754400015, -0.023630542680621147, -0.015627536922693253, 0.0201325174421072, 0.002539400476962328, -0.027068084105849266, 0.06545799970626831, -0.025187991559505463, 0.0043164631351828575, 0.02632514201104641, -0.037606433033943176, -0.006420440040528774, 0.05983548238873482, 0.016377128660678864, -0.049661312252283096, 0.05197398364543915, 0.00013482604117598385, 0.02062624879181385, -0.002760912524536252, 0.001376231899484992, -0.022384366020560265, -0.04694166034460068, 0.010073153302073479, 0.05459658056497574, -0.019912369549274445, 0.03173471987247467, -0.028444087132811546, -0.015886900946497917, -0.020353244617581367, -0.039488617330789566, 0.0009192477446049452, 0.007905310019850731, 0.04129880294203758, -0.007599449250847101, 0.007604383397847414, -0.007130309473723173, 0.009908798150718212, -0.04702800139784813, 0.051550187170505524, 0.06828991323709488, 0.03720352426171303, -0.057513002306222916, 0.05093392729759216, -0.008845282718539238, -0.06759817153215408, -0.012384913861751556, 0.01479781698435545, 0.03318136930465698, -0.030433638021349907, 0.043801356106996536, -0.011879369616508484, -0.046668533235788345, 0.06256400048732758, -0.020901577547192574, 0.03571939840912819, 0.0050304182805120945, -0.08535982668399811, -0.05668048560619354, -0.015457686968147755, -0.03821741044521332, 0.007077889982610941, -0.04029257223010063, -0.02830556035041809, 0.005978819448500872, 0.022315723821520805, -0.012388017028570175, 0.009543349966406822, 0.014876979403197765, 0.028413236141204834, 0.004301809705793858, -0.029057331383228302, 0.008326277136802673, -0.03895770013332367, -0.021619027480483055, -0.043928034603595734, -0.03529566526412964, 0.03592493757605553, 0.03066582791507244, -0.0021107057109475136, -0.0014651104575023055, 0.013057180680334568, 0.012103969231247902, -0.02345891296863556, 0.025898652151226997, 0.029315337538719177, 0.01600145921111107, 0.05007612332701683, -0.01452681515365839, 0.06537896394729614, 0.040337905287742615, 0.022848643362522125, 0.004621358588337898, 0.03146626427769661, 0.051759060472249985, 0.028595924377441406, 0.007631168235093355, -0.02273290976881981, -0.03439032658934593, 0.035102710127830505, 0.029709264636039734, 0.0006734371418133378, -0.02877870574593544, -0.03721723333001137, -0.005079534370452166, 0.03778829053044319, 0.02226991392672062, 0.0019896221347153187, -0.05188150331377983, 0.04771469160914421, -0.06587935239076614, -0.03887402266263962, -0.023994093760848045, 0.023171337321400642, -0.051624663174152374, -0.0014245701022446156, 0.039807166904211044, 0.005260596517473459, 0.016713470220565796, -0.002704566577449441, 0.004133577458560467, -0.036674294620752335, -0.004161649849265814, 0.03161246329545975, -0.035314206033945084, 0.006873200181871653, 0.0496840626001358, 0.026634996756911278, -0.023388057947158813, 0.05687040463089943, -0.012217157520353794, -0.05246012657880783, 0.003195669036358595, -0.031475044786930084, 0.018340924754738808, -0.042886681854724884, 0.016403570771217346, 0.03674369677901268, 0.012326302006840706, -0.03253861144185066, 0.01831303909420967, -0.06618476659059525, 0.0766868069767952, 0.06373123079538345, -0.00006210205901879817, -0.011088097468018532, 0.019193556159734726, 0.012047054246068, 0.011988396756350994, -0.0010707034962251782, -0.019779395312070847, -0.07982932776212692, 0.01424268539994955, 0.058278024196624756, 0.023378508165478706, -0.03202224150300026, 0.0026101411785930395, 0.03759225457906723, 0.038584593683481216, 0.03450286388397217, 0.025599589571356773, -0.021763799712061882, -0.013559323735535145, 0.0342131070792675, 0.006110385060310364, 0.02135705202817917, -0.03460630029439926, 0.00678626261651516, -0.006071708630770445, 0.0624518021941185, -0.0189510490745306, 0.0006342614651657641, 0.05267269164323807, -0.009383266791701317, 0.01649472489953041, -0.015139717608690262, -0.026990480720996857, 0.054080571979284286, -0.03954184427857399, 0.008593074977397919, 0.03564497455954552, 0.010016322135925293, 0.002180968876928091, 0.006585406139492989, -0.021422559395432472, 0.042668092995882034, 0.05973229557275772, -0.028444183990359306, 0.016573559492826462, 0.020639285445213318, -0.02621646039187908, 0.01574285514652729, 0.0006782486452721059, -0.055103860795497894, -0.05348948389291763, 0.02351653389632702, 0.032465796917676926, 0.002193071646615863, 0.03628169000148773, -0.015996132045984268, 0.006121681537479162, 0.007105963304638863, -0.006361157633364201, 0.027827775105834007, 0.008589708246290684, -0.059741485863924026, -0.01250350009649992, -0.044843338429927826, -0.00471519073471427, 0.04291373863816261, -0.03856135904788971, -0.033060379326343536, 0.02198592945933342, -0.00694993743672967, -0.05459366366267204, 0.01653898134827614, -0.011225152760744095, 0.03701135516166687, -0.00313772214576602, -0.03152503818273544, 0.009283723309636116, 0.00664778146892786, -0.05010118708014488, -0.010212738066911697, -0.027781879529356956, -0.008559849113225937, -0.022448768839240074, -0.009702892042696476, 0.02732328698039055, 0.006166654173284769, 0.005368464160710573, 0.018775802105665207, -0.03188565745949745, 0.015316124074161053, -0.05983038619160652, -0.056708212941884995, -0.008939230814576149, -0.028917066752910614, 0.027081135660409927, -0.005532658658921719, 0.003613320179283619, 0.0916542187333107, 0.07023421674966812, -0.025292575359344482, -0.03134838864207268, -0.002638270379975438, -0.04171378165483475, -0.006910564377903938, -0.0032693601679056883, 0.01917468011379242, 0.0031636396888643503, -0.010806276462972164, 0.009691699407994747, 0.019390296190977097, 0.04145188629627228, -0.00019071689166594297, -0.04557281360030174, 0.06906497478485107, 0.0011477194493636489, -0.021128172054886818, 0.025092771276831627, 0.036770470440387726, -0.03366253152489662, 0.026840191334486008, -0.03426090627908707, 0.009375474415719509, 0.054646946489810944, -0.02969025820493698, 0.022932548075914383, -0.008890729397535324, 0.00027842799318023026, -0.017889851704239845, -0.004796262364834547, -0.0063845319673419, -0.08358394354581833, 0.0016508034896105528, 0.05223427340388298, 0.02234158292412758, -0.025351079180836678, 0.0052704219706356525, 0.0745987668633461, 0.07279017567634583, 0.017711350694298744, -0.0026341029442846775, -0.015527104958891869, 0.002110200235620141, 0.04733891040086746, -0.06139106675982475, -0.0009598308242857456, 0.034679725766181946, 0.04240204766392708, 0.055394094437360764, 0.0018471380462870002, -0.0340254083275795, 0.013981497846543789, -0.06096600368618965, -0.0009240488871000707, -0.04992755874991417, 0.05194755271077156, 0.02777513675391674, 0.027490168809890747, 0.01972520351409912, -0.017227279022336006, -0.024655170738697052, 0.04796694964170456, -0.04092812165617943, 0.023440314456820488, -0.010243252851068974, 0.052543431520462036, 0.008171758614480495, -0.014888815581798553, 0.012712664902210236, -0.005576716735959053, -0.002121682045981288, -0.005659343209117651, 0.03037709929049015, -0.018426673486828804, -0.0020615998655557632, -0.007759289350360632, -0.025889955461025238, -0.022736098617315292, -0.016163727268576622, 0.009077321738004684, 0.013528461568057537, 0.04610671103000641, 0.005880767945200205, 0.02088642492890358, -0.008141696453094482, -0.009804355911910534, 0.006460328586399555, -0.006900938693434, 0.05319030582904816, -0.004065282642841339, 0.011739612556993961, -0.013531752862036228, 0.032966598868370056, 0.022886114194989204, 0.04341795668005943, 0.0190449059009552, -0.010260481387376785, -0.020499736070632935, -0.07158863544464111, -0.04606970027089119, 0.014680850319564342, 0.01902242936193943, 0.01678243651986122, -0.004208546597510576, 0.07210280001163483, 0.05079270154237747, -0.0382189117372036, 0.020925210788846016, 0.08767575770616531, 0.025698566809296608, -0.05577770620584488, -0.0004408755339682102, 0.007082867901772261, -0.006820996291935444, 0.018948720768094063, 0.025208184495568275, 0.03819369152188301, 0.004993731621652842, 0.020592112094163895, 0.06163688749074936, -0.012815010733902454, -0.03692769631743431, -0.017943715676665306, 0.010396639816462994, 0.025581154972314835, -0.015476035885512829, -0.046638403087854385, 0.03751475736498833, 0.021383116021752357, 0.026923635974526405, 0.0299209151417017, 0.006094970740377903, -0.12820260226726532, 0.021603647619485855, 0.024901676923036575, 0.020708689466118813, -0.017148146405816078, -0.020643003284931183, -0.04701831564307213, 0.0038064175751060247, 0.04188946634531021, -0.05755859985947609, 0.01895366609096527, -0.028526978567242622, 0.026446184143424034, -0.013916094787418842, -0.020294085144996643, -0.04977891221642494, 0.03611290082335472, -0.03487246856093407, 0.0633651614189148, -0.0067795757204294205, -0.017814630642533302, -0.06810484826564789, 0.05988870933651924, -0.004356970079243183, 0.028286349028348923, 0.0004588291049003601, -0.03567325696349144, 0.01808895915746689, -0.005141374655067921, -0.030423998832702637, -0.06498249620199203, -0.007173591293394566, 0.029663046821951866, 0.004877292551100254, 0.04472769796848297, -0.008331927470862865, -0.05594123899936676, -0.01863320730626583, -0.011798516847193241, -0.01748688519001007, 0.04786930978298187, -0.026973772794008255, 0.0636095404624939, -0.01441575400531292, -0.022882996127009392, 0.03509136661887169, 0.04577845707535744, -0.001482289400883019, 0.01072143018245697, -0.046284738928079605, 0.009400834329426289, 0.003972814418375492, -0.012242984026670456, -0.07137126475572586, -0.009741739369928837, -0.00042974180541932583, 0.010026100091636181, -0.01490912027657032, 0.03181061893701553, -0.0023626084439456463, -0.019439920783042908, -0.00009574274736223742, 0.0314343199133873, 0.036921385675668716, -0.03520164638757706, -0.0065206303261220455, 0.014560974203050137, -0.019484780728816986, -0.006721690762788057, 0.03637038543820381, -0.010522984899580479, 0.013892462477087975, 0.014399876818060875, -0.03473551198840141, -0.002059123944491148, -0.026924632489681244, -0.029063615947961807, 0.008616081438958645, -0.008363554254174232, 0.033200498670339584, 0.017345529049634933, 0.04239606857299805, 0.017489835619926453, -0.042076412588357925, -0.009471932426095009, 0.011612250469624996, 0.014216584153473377, 0.06486830860376358, -0.0451669879257679, 0.029267745092511177, -0.040093351155519485, 0.011594096198678017, -0.05596499890089035, -0.07120788842439651, 0.04367275908589363, 0.026726536452770233, 0.0010764008620753884, -0.05458466708660126, 0.02316724881529808, -0.020302556455135345, -0.004035921301692724, -0.024226678535342216, 0.06352582573890686, -0.031225664541125298, -0.002024478279054165, -0.04272066801786423, 0.04473714530467987, 0.08283022046089172, 0.04057126119732857, -0.0060425722040236, 0.024878494441509247, 0.01861407980322838, -0.015248235315084457, 0.009869899600744247, 0.002586877904832363, -0.022415878251194954, -0.01145261526107788, -0.042333994060754776, -0.0015251890290528536, 0.04104011878371239, -0.04371001198887825, -0.00218481058254838, 0.00634259358048439, -0.027562741190195084, 0.0011138460831716657, -0.0004736803821288049, 0.019906379282474518, -0.005054440349340439, -0.007647491060197353, -0.02251572161912918, -0.0020079249516129494, -0.029019717127084732, -0.019772890955209732, 0.04870835319161415, -0.020330175757408142, -0.0054991161450743675, 0.04143121838569641, 0.05238712579011917, 0.00200229836627841, 0.024437155574560165, 0.0015149647369980812, -0.014548365026712418, 0.04132664203643799, 0.0007253654184751213, -0.020645907148718834, -0.012126739136874676, 0.007973609492182732, 0.013664391823112965, 0.0008713549468666315, -0.04071354866027832, -0.036913104355335236, 0.03286108747124672, 0.017229938879609108, 0.0456891804933548, 0.057603899389505386, 0.03741171583533287, -0.012539312243461609, -0.018507864326238632, -0.00278289383277297, -0.028256040066480637, 0.02473979815840721, 0.03670826554298401, 0.005694336723536253, 0.008166925050318241, 0.010323037393391132, 0.009378987364470959, 0.024911725893616676, 0.05933887138962746, 0.019176704809069633, -0.006350219249725342, 0.027729365974664688, -0.04483674094080925, -0.04129726439714432, 0.026556501165032387, -0.07237028330564499, 0.011013377457857132, -0.012645280919969082, -0.051602642983198166, 0.028078891336917877, 0.04313091188669205, -0.00608321325853467, -0.056147150695323944, -0.02933317981660366, -0.051794979721307755, 0.024550549685955048, 0.023739513009786606, -0.011704196222126484, 0.020999601110816002, -0.01883646287024021, 0.03640897199511528, -0.01115157175809145, 0.03628223389387131, -0.027143007144331932, -0.055367693305015564, -0.03397762030363083, -0.028919506818056107, -0.04930116608738899, 0.013095241971313953, -0.01917150989174843, -0.0005020308308303356, -0.0060002184472978115, -0.04740859195590019, 0.011652752757072449, -0.012874085456132889, 0.02038690634071827, -0.011985319666564465, 0.02132885716855526, -0.016026875004172325, -0.014050202444195747, -0.030405130237340927, -0.0014494735514745116, 0.09999101608991623, 0.08996184170246124, 0.0389140322804451, -0.05335523560643196, 0.005025624763220549, 0.014128354378044605, 0.02648603543639183, -0.02685253880918026, -0.006627845112234354, 0.012968345545232296, 0.0007378961308859289, 0.02082439884543419, 0.03597954288125038, 0.0326797179877758, 0.004237870220094919, 0.06895927339792252, -0.014634236693382263, -0.004466277547180653, 0.002863824600353837, 0.031022440642118454, -0.0187011007219553, -0.010761817917227745, -0.04423324391245842, 0.02793550305068493, -0.012745174579322338, -0.025375057011842728, -0.00463969586417079, 0.004157771356403828, 0.0004983113030903041, -0.027043720707297325, -0.025429323315620422, 0.0069725001230835915, 0.022551633417606354, 0.00723170256242156, 0.0015298387734219432, -0.025923607870936394, 0.02167714200913906, -0.029385438188910484, 0.005389224737882614, 0.019354866817593575, 0.009610681794583797, 0.001747323083691299, 0.03485376760363579, 0.006268111523240805, -0.07404810935258865, -0.038741376250982285, -0.03756824880838394, 0.029299359768629074, 0.020329860970377922, -0.016772260889410973, 0.0014931863406673074, 0.02200109325349331, -0.0016629922902211547, -0.03736693412065506, -0.019154997542500496, -0.007523613516241312, 0.015302499756217003, -0.006446089595556259, -0.036223843693733215, 0.0004988487926311791, 0.01817363128066063, 0.009499444626271725, 0.01867569051682949, -0.004218988586217165, -0.03584609925746918, -0.026584507897496223, -0.004352825693786144, 0.0668216347694397, 0.012813623063266277, -0.006139599252492189, -0.02380838245153427, -0.039555296301841736, -0.011834396980702877, 0.02884778566658497, 0.011834113858640194, -0.010730912908911705, 0.016245968639850616, -0.01602446846663952, -0.00017596948600839823, -0.03310157358646393, -0.035153623670339584, 0.01121328305453062, 0.00847137812525034, 0.02892104908823967, -0.04824752360582352, 0.00997318234294653, 0.001418016734533012, 0.03054850734770298, 0.026872284710407257, 0.03588992729783058, -0.0015135627472773194, 0.05672943592071533, -0.0012097430881112814, -0.039669111371040344, -0.00008339121995959431, -0.0285338144749403, -0.0465376079082489, 0.01145323645323515, 0.000877171172760427, 0.08269338309764862, 0.0025567656848579645, -0.0116025535389781, 0.0008497032686136663, 0.053092535585165024, 0.010457111522555351, 0.03665570169687271, 0.005844339728355408, -0.06450499594211578, -0.004121277015656233, -0.011391155421733856, 0.019861850887537003, -0.015307032503187656, -0.04119475930929184, -0.020584452897310257, -0.015329234302043915, 0.0007627984159626067, -0.026551203802227974, -0.02799852564930916, 0.0036115513648837805, -0.015214722603559494, 0.03638983517885208, -0.051818154752254486, -0.002218088833615184, -0.02340477891266346, 0.023606985807418823, -0.01955314911901951, -0.0551261268556118, 0.02261839248239994, 0.01371406763792038, 0.019110456109046936, 0.0014670221135020256, 0.017805855721235275, 0.01844862848520279, 0.004195177927613258, -0.005866151303052902, 0.0067526125349104404, 0.00023983989376574755, 0.0309600867331028, -0.030498284846544266, 0.01824016310274601, 0.034606367349624634, -0.0018947804346680641, -0.02157292515039444, 0.03678582236170769, -0.004435904789716005, 0.029584258794784546, -0.01909233257174492, -0.024892771616578102, -0.014458752237260342, 0.05014840140938759, -0.028636706992983818, -0.03473658487200737, 0.007591781672090292, 0.02005554735660553, -0.03774651512503624, -0.004667434375733137, 0.02455723285675049, 0.026353934779763222, -0.02595619298517704, 0.054188791662454605, 0.022613827139139175, 0.025463255122303963, -0.019268199801445007, 0.02238762192428112, -0.020521916449069977, 0.04075806587934494, 0.005749699659645557, 0.022257104516029358, 0.03737160190939903, 0.039924103766679764, -0.025800056755542755, 0.011304669082164764, -0.030151592567563057, 0.038589153438806534, -0.049567632377147675, -0.06360772252082825, 0.02535633184015751, 0.015344679355621338, 0.030644021928310394, -0.05834520608186722, -0.022636452689766884, 0.036413561552762985, -0.040178082883358, 0.001164269750006497, -0.013020845130085945, -0.0007651150808669627, -0.009812559932470322, 0.0008839431102387607, -0.02602819725871086, 0.021822048351168633, 0.008520644158124924, 0.00506244134157896, 0.007799099665135145, 0.03640597313642502, -0.009768994525074959, -0.037491969764232635, -0.015002372674643993, -0.01929870806634426, 0.01782330311834812, -0.05694109946489334, 0.024618608877062798, -0.011305480264127254, -0.027679210528731346, 0.028438394889235497, -0.03289775922894478, 0.007403210271149874, 0.06473252922296524, 0.028063269332051277, 0.0420306921005249, 0.03807942569255829, 0.05089036747813225, 0.01001023780554533, -0.014775977469980717, -0.0054245563223958015, 0.027863701805472374, 0.0364341214299202, -0.03282523527741432, -0.015573670156300068, 0.036341093480587006, -0.06071840226650238, -0.02283511869609356, -0.010365497320890427, -0.04355640709400177, -0.012776373885571957, 0.0003823527949862182, -0.010375051759183407, -0.00898617785423994, -0.00014365522656589746, 0.04960694536566734, -0.07131042331457138, -0.004956832621246576, 0.015080845914781094, 0.017966462299227715, 0.004634179174900055, 0.024844443425536156, -0.03987738490104675, -0.055611833930015564, -0.020880747586488724, 0.0015159896574914455, -0.021840477362275124, -0.02893420122563839, -0.015760989859700203, -0.01125493273139, -0.017277799546718597, -0.02590053714811802, -0.015316295437514782, -0.04029150307178497, 0.07040993869304657, -0.036056410521268845, 0.013172867707908154, 0.02848326973617077, -0.024948181584477425, -0.008393922820687294, -0.08541916310787201, 0.047518402338027954, 0.027326103299856186, -0.011033610440790653, -0.03252781927585602, -0.00648238230496645, -0.07147634029388428, 0.009111988358199596, 0.05951232835650444, -0.012744351290166378, -0.0006294088088907301, -0.019794801250100136, 0.019461043179035187, 0.0071940855123102665, -0.033986665308475494, -0.020584411919116974, -0.014940130524337292, -0.025381524115800858, -0.021988442167639732, -0.03679903596639633, 0.01925801672041416, -0.004308487754315138, 0.03487496078014374, -0.003502534469589591, -0.008128408342599869, -0.0016568673308938742, -0.036093585193157196, 0.0436302050948143, -0.021751444786787033, -0.012558971531689167, 0.007706648204475641, 0.008262494578957558, -0.023821678012609482, 0.02068781666457653, 0.002522209659218788, -0.038914754986763, 0.03835282102227211, -0.02066981792449951, -0.02096601203083992, -0.004973230417817831, 0.017079059034585953, 0.02722250297665596, -0.042753662914037704, 0.003658287925645709, 0.019205573946237564, -0.004649854265153408, 0.034138023853302, 0.04270695894956589, 0.02636541612446308, 0.030918413773179054, -0.0017876953352242708, -0.0007928512641228735, 0.020450402051210403, 0.0010501788929104805, 0.017883945256471634, 0.009832458570599556, 0.030369708314538002, -0.020817788317799568, 0.0019187451107427478, -0.0034628051798790693, -0.013553020544350147, 0.017008783295750618, -0.00858505629003048, 0.023046493530273438, -0.04358670487999916, -0.0012825062731280923, 0.03079034388065338, 0.024031851440668106, 0.0038037735503166914, 0.04237893596291542, -0.017605308443307877, 0.04491123929619789, -0.009142653085291386, -0.015664158388972282, -0.02569730579853058, -0.01611342839896679, -0.02034779265522957, 0.011970693245530128, 0.010665025562047958, 0.03274688124656677, 0.002690408378839493, -0.013830771669745445, -0.052892766892910004, -0.011126409284770489, 0.02434762939810753, -0.028180720284581184, -0.0007546998094767332, -0.023301683366298676, 0.0010060364147648215, 0.013908791355788708, -0.011711503379046917, -0.04290596768260002, -0.03443754464387894, 0.0030106916092336178, 0.03208228573203087, 0.04254883527755737, -0.011463346891105175, -0.01752636581659317, 0.013331223279237747, 0.019012708216905594, -0.07362695783376694, -0.04663032293319702, -0.0277373269200325, 0.027718139812350273, 0.0011168011697009206, -0.04523890092968941 ]
<p>I have a loss data arising out of Operation risk for some particular bank. The standard procedure for arriving at the capital charge w.r.t. Operational risk needs I fit some continuous distribution to this loss data. </p> <p>Normally, I am able to fit some standard distributions. Once the distribution is identified, the same distribution is used to simulate future loss amounts.</p> <p>My question is assuming the data is such that I am just not able to fit any statistical distribution, how do I deal with data to simulate the loss amounts. Is there any <strong>non-parametric method</strong> available to deal with such situations.</p> <p>Kindly give me some advice.</p>
31,108
[ -0.02087225578725338, -0.02558879181742668, -0.008390567265450954, 0.003531347494572401, 0.04554688185453415, 0.01868249848484993, 0.02165498025715351, 0.023625094443559647, 0.05042159557342529, -0.026942633092403412, 0.044501595199108124, 0.053647734224796295, 0.024105718359351158, 0.014971700496971607, -0.011688590981066227, -0.008078314363956451, -0.02342532016336918, -0.0038254857063293457, 0.0024349282030016184, 0.009830130264163017, 0.009870917536318302, 0.007250106893479824, -0.02876981534063816, -0.05334251746535301, -0.01718316599726677, 0.007052325643599033, 0.000008632033313915599, -0.033105168491601944, 0.012757877819240093, 0.05595012754201889, -0.024363841861486435, -0.05474318563938141, -0.007090854458510876, 0.06014023348689079, 0.0014298161258921027, 0.05193636193871498, -0.049756553024053574, -0.03507933020591736, -0.026998337358236313, 0.022713664919137955, -0.02936250902712345, -0.020699482411146164, 0.02487890049815178, 0.021389424800872803, 0.013031146489083767, 0.034558553248643875, -0.0214187353849411, -0.032531604170799255, -0.0021810955367982388, -0.02916366420686245, 0.05909646674990654, -0.028943214565515518, 0.04334818199276924, 0.02868768200278282, -0.0015759231755509973, -0.03196413442492485, 0.0586603544652462, 0.06451521068811417, -0.03277728706598282, -0.023194270208477974, 0.003015470691025257, -0.00836191512644291, 0.000012435688404366374, -0.0412590354681015, 0.00835333950817585, 0.014370900578796864, -0.00031384776229970157, -0.019807277247309685, 0.03356107324361801, 0.0022941776551306248, 0.030941486358642578, 0.026180770248174667, 0.03378245234489441, 0.003525163047015667, 0.021643025800585747, 0.04098699241876602, 0.044754207134246826, 0.01593492366373539, 0.06133054196834564, -0.004440106451511383, -0.01496119610965252, 0.014011438004672527, 0.010350588709115982, 0.03325831890106201, -0.015238890424370766, -0.03294574096798897, 0.04897062107920647, -0.05460788682103157, 0.03344359248876572, 0.005145172588527203, -0.014158206060528755, -0.03749208524823189, 0.024768980219960213, -0.027671853080391884, -0.06483995914459229, 0.01603531651198864, -0.02038661763072014, 0.061012547463178635, -0.017670907080173492, -0.020226377993822098, 0.00701602129265666, -0.035815879702568054, -0.01947101764380932, 0.02417248673737049, -0.01984427496790886, 0.014314955100417137, -0.003437767969444394, 0.022471705451607704, 0.0010659565450623631, -0.04215587303042412, -0.03335007280111313, 0.03480403125286102, 0.019785219803452492, 0.015280560590326786, 0.02109110914170742, 0.013840235769748688, -0.0007202256238088012, -0.04452051967382431, 0.023098882287740707, 0.047716788947582245, 0.026625262573361397, 0.004814420361071825, 0.023017581552267075, -0.0004218626127112657, -0.036788567900657654, -0.008914829231798649, 0.02225123904645443, -0.02835245057940483, -0.04973158985376358, 0.03581211343407631, 0.002556523308157921, -0.03352019935846329, 0.046617574989795685, 0.014092971570789814, 0.03821234405040741, -0.0374075211584568, -0.07980982214212418, -0.04041196033358574, -0.03820959851145744, -0.017090924084186554, -0.014792917296290398, -0.02075829915702343, -0.022412119433283806, 0.038651902228593826, 0.019551372155547142, 0.018145913258194923, 0.04965144395828247, 0.017203204333782196, 0.02417720854282379, -0.004981102887541056, -0.020684020593762398, 0.016287576407194138, -0.024313801899552345, 0.011829088442027569, -0.028087088838219643, -0.0837014690041542, 0.02521822229027748, 0.035923901945352554, 0.013732542283833027, -0.0383998304605484, -0.005173680372536182, 0.019508691504597664, -0.02470681071281433, -0.00403713108971715, 0.007263609673827887, -0.04855216667056084, 0.0601617805659771, -0.015396300703287125, 0.02684043161571026, -0.0059474133886396885, 0.005975482985377312, 0.0383213646709919, 0.014036629348993301, 0.011776326224207878, 0.07814452797174454, -0.05184590443968773, 0.0066308919340372086, -0.011416301131248474, 0.027427850291132927, 0.03177386149764061, 0.004354824312031269, 0.026525795459747314, -0.029675519093871117, -0.017006635665893555, 0.010688593611121178, 0.015794547274708748, 0.008384869433939457, -0.037436503916978836, 0.043313346803188324, -0.044255468994379044, -0.06033890321850777, -0.02551780454814434, 0.01963486522436142, -0.027913926169276237, -0.048378873616456985, 0.007849951274693012, -0.015979070216417313, 0.009451020509004593, -0.017973052337765694, -0.006183443125337362, -0.013767633587121964, -0.03485123813152313, 0.037732020020484924, -0.040951844304800034, -0.0009942085016518831, 0.03814776614308357, 0.035250451415777206, 0.02135150507092476, 0.04235772788524628, -0.016491543501615524, -0.07601498067378998, -0.04531969130039215, -0.055798184126615524, -0.00040454388363286853, -0.004140559118241072, -0.010453619994223118, 0.014675555750727654, -0.009259416721761227, -0.002409495646134019, 0.00978759489953518, -0.026055345311760902, 0.04405762627720833, 0.11085626482963562, 0.014607440680265427, -0.026994096115231514, 0.017544513568282127, -0.026813285425305367, 0.01622401922941208, -0.025389859452843666, -0.005415186285972595, -0.07183927297592163, 0.022152936086058617, 0.03565865382552147, 0.025638634338974953, -0.041709672659635544, 0.0029296097345650196, 0.06994695961475372, -0.0023541420232504606, -0.002558656968176365, 0.00603740056976676, -0.02204074338078499, -0.015789873898029327, 0.016990380361676216, 0.00849449448287487, 0.04941737279295921, -0.005453030113130808, 0.016019556671380997, 0.028429238125681877, 0.03969002515077591, -0.046544644981622696, -0.008601626381278038, 0.031088512390851974, -0.005011101718991995, 0.011957123875617981, -0.018149590119719505, -0.029542632400989532, 0.05751289799809456, -0.02602769061923027, 0.024380212649703026, 0.037796467542648315, -0.018437344580888748, 0.007337383460253477, 0.03511170297861099, -0.02286437898874283, 0.041088491678237915, 0.026657825335860252, -0.04869146645069122, 0.017024504020810127, 0.02498886175453663, -0.00032353101414628327, -0.027675287798047066, -0.0049177720211446285, -0.042360998690128326, -0.0281439907848835, 0.03991309925913811, 0.012275868095457554, 0.013838078826665878, 0.01840432919561863, 0.003432715078815818, -0.03028288297355175, 0.010961126536130905, 0.0004276964464224875, 0.010273635387420654, 0.04222143068909645, -0.016137339174747467, 0.001392509788274765, -0.0008804304525256157, -0.013606064952909946, 0.04010993242263794, 0.012721418403089046, -0.005239511374384165, 0.0118148447945714, 0.0018388950265944004, -0.008196547627449036, 0.0021587079390883446, 0.0031531371641904116, -0.0035490759182721376, -0.03641478344798088, -0.006829308345913887, 0.022502928972244263, 0.04132361337542534, -0.04285622760653496, 0.0007698714034631848, -0.059862516820430756, -0.029864780604839325, -0.0411621518433094, 0.009169531986117363, 0.020978713408112526, -0.035209134221076965, 0.044498518109321594, -0.005994835868477821, 0.002920539816841483, 0.005580336786806583, -0.07622562348842621, -0.04539595544338226, -0.0015270496951416135, -0.01125755812972784, 0.012131554074585438, 0.019179146736860275, -0.026856105774641037, 0.07054027915000916, 0.011354824528098106, -0.00800518412142992, -0.048406556248664856, -0.013592835515737534, -0.027987977489829063, -0.015501799061894417, -0.007533990312367678, 0.027514390647411346, 0.015200385823845863, -0.0008097394020296633, -0.006962914019823074, 0.02207578346133232, 0.0526026226580143, -0.00477743661031127, -0.01659555546939373, 0.033880989998579025, 0.01544855535030365, 0.013378700241446495, 0.018016846850514412, -0.006342525128275156, 0.0008902862318791449, 0.043023381382226944, -0.008453592658042908, 0.0002578494022600353, 0.036742791533470154, -0.059989817440509796, -0.0023226116318255663, 0.0030842749401926994, 0.0006426238105632365, -0.0059606218710541725, 0.02829582989215851, -0.0036689969711005688, -0.05541141703724861, 0.003151440294459462, 0.029903190210461617, 0.004583848640322685, -0.0052650016732513905, 0.02349807508289814, 0.08178354054689407, 0.08465363085269928, -0.0027212731074541807, -0.05519404262304306, -0.004532855004072189, -0.012618374079465866, -0.005310247652232647, 0.0014105708105489612, 0.0010884361108765006, 0.005968532990664244, 0.04865247756242752, 0.03234715387225151, -0.013695713132619858, -0.028845397755503654, 0.0074132345616817474, -0.04835221543908119, -0.014354905113577843, -0.04141037538647652, 0.0833296924829483, 0.018686668947339058, 0.011805519461631775, 0.024053074419498444, 0.006394929252564907, 0.013288518413901329, 0.022710198536515236, -0.07792358100414276, 0.04956682026386261, 0.0336386039853096, -0.0012968401424586773, 0.0010545948753133416, -0.004370223730802536, 0.04420856013894081, -0.044130198657512665, 0.013515131548047066, -0.0007498173508793116, -0.008339758962392807, -0.010213056579232216, -0.0012022519949823618, -0.0067054396495223045, -0.003632698906585574, -0.017955325543880463, -0.019226592034101486, 0.021856777369976044, -0.02950112335383892, 0.027570776641368866, 0.019593125209212303, 0.027972770854830742, -0.0297621451318264, -0.023274371400475502, 0.009919503703713417, -0.009042786434292793, 0.02571798861026764, 0.011303102597594261, 0.03880620002746582, -0.05840684100985527, 0.028631677851080894, 0.0065446230582892895, 0.041122566908597946, 0.03860486298799515, -0.027487941086292267, -0.0276760496199131, -0.050919726490974426, -0.009366045705974102, 0.0053950948640704155, -0.004458345472812653, 0.025005731731653214, -0.024871889501810074, 0.05514681711792946, 0.02230190485715866, -0.06459261476993561, -0.014819139614701271, 0.07833875715732574, 0.0574398897588253, -0.002849749056622386, 0.019415264949202538, 0.018520569428801537, -0.015169739723205566, -0.03423009440302849, 0.024502672255039215, 0.046085260808467865, -0.018579913303256035, 0.02509876899421215, 0.07499910891056061, 0.008577295579016209, -0.038947589695453644, 0.020387468859553337, 0.04006399214267731, 0.019638611003756523, 0.03614984452724457, -0.014146287925541401, 0.07193740457296371, 0.0028408770449459553, 0.01178781595081091, 0.035776183009147644, 0.006999341771006584, -0.130600705742836, 0.0053533632308244705, 0.05123275890946388, -0.003980956971645355, 0.015295792371034622, -0.05053786188364029, -0.04443122074007988, 0.00803324580192566, 0.03692121431231499, -0.037869103252887726, -0.003996619954705238, -0.01611972041428089, 0.026910284534096718, 0.002810209756717086, -0.025821300223469734, -0.02071867324411869, 0.021262971684336662, -0.048618439584970474, 0.026060406118631363, -0.027774516493082047, 0.003052488435059786, -0.021841349080204964, -0.0015691977459937334, 0.008025714196264744, 0.06160782650113106, 0.0019311767537146807, -0.04189525544643402, -0.007714985869824886, 0.0406588539481163, -0.02853901870548725, -0.05390505865216255, 0.023158807307481766, -0.0029565002769231796, -0.0003989149408880621, 0.016218727454543114, 0.005867446772754192, -0.04963549226522446, 0.0060489485040307045, -0.0072084227576851845, 0.016897380352020264, 0.04123203083872795, -0.03682440519332886, 0.04183446243405342, 0.0007914991001598537, 0.028918122872710228, 0.03548559546470642, 0.04863952100276947, 0.01486852578818798, -0.003467813367024064, -0.0022397018037736416, 0.019188322126865387, -0.01587306149303913, 0.002543860347941518, -0.06134357675909996, -0.00434822728857398, 0.023437976837158203, 0.014552450738847256, 0.006370337214320898, 0.04144179821014404, 0.0013182898983359337, -0.019712429493665695, 0.008184445090591908, 0.005039917770773172, 0.03239092603325844, -0.016865793615579605, -0.02263406477868557, 0.016237957403063774, -0.024168429896235466, 0.015002557076513767, -0.00521228089928627, 0.028325466439127922, -0.008628484793007374, 0.004995954688638449, -0.056910473853349686, -0.015151074156165123, -0.03448861464858055, -0.03136849403381348, 0.008063633926212788, -0.02061973698437214, 0.0655512809753418, -0.013616724871098995, 0.03919140622019768, 0.007122555281966925, -0.01961781643331051, 0.004311580676585436, 0.03482867404818535, -0.00024586779181845486, 0.027193455025553703, -0.05905885249376297, 0.03607754781842232, 0.0030131181702017784, -0.014817998744547367, -0.07855792343616486, -0.06946718692779541, 0.03798104450106621, 0.02629120834171772, -0.0465841218829155, -0.02864711731672287, 0.01888311840593815, 0.01737876608967781, -0.026503438130021095, -0.033001746982336044, 0.035691723227500916, 0.011508911848068237, -0.005437508225440979, 0.02404969558119774, -0.0198550783097744, 0.07940387725830078, -0.015791771933436394, 0.013187669217586517, 0.036792904138565063, -0.013784094713628292, -0.016090182587504387, -0.021739281713962555, -0.02232096530497074, -0.01986514963209629, -0.008886963129043579, -0.047078415751457214, 0.003947029821574688, 0.013278302736580372, 0.005236742552369833, 0.0163153987377882, 0.01292484812438488, 0.01626542955636978, 0.014784395694732666, -0.020329494029283524, -0.012209336273372173, 0.03364470228552818, 0.038702595978975296, -0.059811368584632874, -0.02130521647632122, -0.023198788985610008, 0.021428538486361504, 0.021579736843705177, 0.005775256082415581, 0.006818040739744902, 0.06256896257400513, 0.04593004658818245, -0.024213489145040512, -0.050847649574279785, -0.01120555866509676, 0.016945496201515198, -0.007482405286282301, 0.020327214151620865, -0.025690333917737007, 0.01719948835670948, 0.03526230528950691, -0.05867261067032814, -0.023640934377908707, -0.05307113751769066, 0.022631824016571045, 0.033518411219120026, 0.007748968433588743, 0.07446166127920151, 0.027090832591056824, 0.017378024756908417, -0.05322478711605072, -0.029190048575401306, -0.019361337646842003, 0.009299536235630512, 0.024970678612589836, 0.0467081256210804, 0.010519919916987419, 0.02731381356716156, -0.0019360727164894342, 0.00699530029669404, 0.020392943173646927, 0.07474299520254135, -0.015200470574200153, 0.012641988694667816, 0.05042962357401848, -0.0026321797631680965, -0.012189540080726147, -0.01146929245442152, -0.0530092716217041, 0.03635713830590248, -0.038138799369335175, -0.02907538041472435, 0.03477552533149719, 0.023558324202895164, 0.023423271253705025, -0.03483021259307861, -0.02946504019200802, -0.04288914054632187, 0.012295135296881199, 0.03599649295210838, -0.015823639929294586, 0.0500582791864872, 0.013645126484334469, 0.052028242498636246, -0.03345390781760216, 0.03383006528019905, -0.028301583603024483, -0.05560813099145889, -0.008786611258983612, -0.03738268092274666, -0.03112788125872612, 0.02337108924984932, -0.005155839025974274, -0.0054274615831673145, -0.00410620030015707, -0.03806944191455841, 0.011943267658352852, 0.007156585343182087, 0.02619268372654915, 0.00005652265826938674, 0.08831817656755447, -0.015859758481383324, 0.024434363469481468, -0.013905844651162624, 0.030249612405896187, 0.11125757545232773, 0.08395236730575562, 0.033769410103559494, -0.07159153372049332, -0.025735383853316307, -0.023928890004754066, 0.004159831441938877, -0.018664563074707985, 0.04313989356160164, 0.022437002509832382, -0.023699700832366943, 0.02365800552070141, 0.05694248154759407, -0.03339748829603195, -0.004373628180474043, 0.0634065493941307, -0.037043794989585876, -0.014142407104372978, 0.03203480318188667, -0.0037669378798455, -0.0016486953245475888, 0.006426174659281969, -0.057498376816511154, 0.018977930769324303, 0.026307227090001106, -0.021044321358203888, -0.012000411748886108, -0.017172209918498993, -0.009011413902044296, 0.01966993510723114, -0.0002939812547992915, 0.01895022764801979, 0.01803000271320343, 0.012764394283294678, -0.004404187202453613, -0.019670790061354637, -0.004900280851870775, -0.03177126869559288, -0.005584103986620903, 0.03077312558889389, -0.00815554615110159, -0.04561439901590347, 0.009015458635985851, 0.014611533842980862, -0.034741297364234924, -0.022032665088772774, -0.05119314044713974, 0.022258007898926735, -0.0007508835406042635, -0.003654863452538848, -0.0270983949303627, -0.01657409779727459, 0.01119472086429596, -0.04700835794210434, -0.01219117920845747, 0.000709849875420332, -0.0022294477093964815, -0.018793601542711258, -0.061726052314043045, -0.009420353919267654, -0.014721806161105633, -0.00234366487711668, 0.021303432062268257, 0.039065636694431305, -0.03700057417154312, -0.026373349130153656, -0.02151237428188324, 0.066347137093544, -0.0032065066043287516, 0.0018700020154938102, 0.02110409364104271, -0.023432573303580284, -0.012933404184877872, -0.019953126087784767, 0.0002704559010453522, -0.020903967320919037, 0.010056328028440475, -0.010442353785037994, 0.006486053578555584, 0.03717241436243057, -0.0444769524037838, 0.04442444443702698, -0.05350175499916077, -0.021512746810913086, -0.048114217817783356, 0.01278975885361433, -0.012282120063900948, 0.03528502210974693, 0.024409012869000435, 0.00417630048468709, 0.0032493676990270615, 0.03381142020225525, 0.033572446554899216, -0.060975853353738785, -0.01677078939974308, -0.02002423256635666, -0.03553289547562599, -0.025314025580883026, 0.0129625853151083, 0.04077483341097832, 0.022633926942944527, 0.005786041263490915, 0.0030012838542461395, -0.007822663523256779, 0.017526211217045784, 0.018413040786981583, 0.004808137658983469, -0.06564787775278091, 0.013576583005487919, -0.009867673739790916, 0.017213787883520126, -0.014107856899499893, 0.014130965806543827, -0.010940096341073513, -0.029161714017391205, -0.0032158850226551294, 0.031522735953330994, -0.03751451149582863, 0.003542293095961213, -0.0198957659304142, 0.02184770256280899, -0.0010404769564047456, 0.009522167965769768, 0.00022606975107919425, -0.015738992020487785, -0.03695695474743843, -0.00493822293356061, -0.005920786410570145, -0.006114587187767029, 0.0186423622071743, 0.01062945555895567, 0.004086815752089024, 0.05156872421503067, -0.0003386868629604578, 0.023146774619817734, -0.02334916964173317, -0.013186553493142128, 0.041592586785554886, -0.02686317265033722, -0.01024689245969057, 0.05459409952163696, -0.04846315085887909, -0.009081743657588959, 0.014811175875365734, -0.008004497736692429, 0.052147362381219864, -0.003315372159704566, 0.04938720911741257, -0.01679721288383007, 0.016702691093087196, -0.04875417426228523, -0.0014754938893020153, -0.01837036944925785, 0.01800326630473137, -0.002870263997465372, -0.0012437929399311543, 0.01528049074113369, 0.011136608198285103, -0.007104884833097458, 0.018749183043837547, 0.02658531442284584, 0.007175560109317303, 0.01472529023885727, 0.05392947420477867, 0.01447383500635624, -0.0198530126363039, 0.015565555542707443, 0.04459116980433464, 0.031369470059871674, 0.06614633649587631, -0.03480472043156624, 0.02115912176668644, -0.045519083738327026, 0.0003647909325081855, -0.1181761771440506, -0.03132069110870361, 0.03129202499985695, -0.02315685898065567, 0.031944114714860916, -0.033456671983003616, -0.01427531149238348, 0.006195455323904753, -0.059150610119104385, 0.001255342154763639, -0.004863955080509186, -0.013067896477878094, -0.05143705755472183, 0.0021047384943813086, -0.028207283467054367, 0.03496213257312775, 0.018878430128097534, 0.04248805716633797, 0.03886021673679352, 0.009815017692744732, -0.01154319103807211, -0.013522572815418243, -0.02831197716295719, -0.012384776957333088, -0.003767508314922452, -0.040633976459503174, 0.02291271835565567, -0.014783481135964394, -0.02100142277777195, 0.0361129492521286, -0.020374184474349022, 0.014623389579355717, 0.01775125227868557, -0.008849894627928734, -0.004719288554042578, 0.07106871902942657, 0.07062861323356628, 0.009568378329277039, 0.00427195243537426, -0.012453150004148483, 0.0286574549973011, 0.04314066842198372, -0.0501500628888607, 0.052650000900030136, 0.049999795854091644, -0.04943842813372612, -0.007286923471838236, 0.011198760010302067, -0.0046921782195568085, -0.009744418784976006, 0.00036346717388369143, 0.008661491796374321, 0.00871118251234293, -0.009081988595426083, 0.030451837927103043, -0.018742509186267853, 0.026823725551366806, 0.06855540722608566, 0.01837083138525486, 0.028229696676135063, 0.012906474061310291, -0.05701524019241333, -0.06961924582719803, -0.022679289802908897, 0.003518512472510338, -0.02888265624642372, -0.03579163923859596, -0.006547112017869949, -0.0010527780978009105, -0.0019523450173437595, -0.02625790238380432, -0.023120617493987083, -0.013334215618669987, 0.053814925253391266, -0.03643502667546272, -0.03130446746945381, 0.044766198843717575, -0.024385036900639534, 0.005221333354711533, -0.08979523926973343, 0.06542450189590454, -0.011463905684649944, -0.005617076531052589, -0.0008198333089239895, -0.010145168751478195, -0.04245997592806816, -0.021325305104255676, 0.07632221281528473, 0.007310331333428621, -0.0023477349895983934, -0.011580060236155987, 0.024925418198108673, -0.03576648235321045, -0.04507947340607643, -0.00433171633630991, -0.013172145932912827, -0.042864181101322174, -0.011309009976685047, -0.023430734872817993, 0.021579766646027565, -0.024843323975801468, -0.022475596517324448, -0.0019899532198905945, -0.0049903616309165955, 0.017365911975502968, -0.02674427442252636, 0.024224640801548958, -0.0016059610061347485, 0.01684344746172428, 0.036525316536426544, 0.002342388266697526, -0.0023857001215219498, -0.002996681025251746, -0.004311327822506428, -0.07037070393562317, 0.04205876961350441, -0.0257936529815197, -0.0076500289142131805, -0.0021669750567525625, 0.012419464997947216, 0.02083239145576954, -0.043545376509428024, -0.0360063761472702, 0.058509811758995056, -0.033978674560785294, 0.015718821436166763, 0.01784171536564827, 0.017695870250463486, 0.0005561416619457304, -0.00789045263081789, -0.015475677326321602, 0.010021181777119637, -0.007937206886708736, 0.039540909230709076, -0.0000799071422079578, 0.051613252609968185, 0.0054053268395364285, 0.003946859389543533, 0.029632797464728355, -0.03721315786242485, -0.00035509790177457035, -0.016923485323786736, 0.015121824108064175, -0.04098394513130188, -0.012414122000336647, 0.020270036533474922, 0.03388694301247597, -0.01990475505590439, -0.023600101470947266, -0.03042111173272133, 0.08917267620563507, -0.00745909521356225, 0.03688453510403633, -0.01600418984889984, -0.009502778761088848, -0.04378598555922508, 0.0034684494603425264, 0.016949662938714027, 0.01652262918651104, -0.00748007046058774, -0.0036327820271253586, 0.009415424428880215, 0.02649679034948349, 0.028498485684394836, -0.0025819079019129276, 0.004308947362005711, -0.022609544917941093, 0.008297353982925415, -0.024654757231473923, -0.04894668236374855, -0.03166009113192558, -0.01801520399749279, 0.005177511367946863, 0.020173069089651108, 0.018229762092232704, -0.0034634871408343315, -0.0739525631070137, 0.013081715442240238, 0.044886261224746704, -0.07929911464452744, -0.03087291494011879, -0.028954878449440002, 0.005824361462146044, -0.018729938194155693, -0.029877282679080963 ]
<p>I am trying to find the optimal estimator for the maximal expected $\Sigma X_i$ where $X_i$ is sampled from an unknown distribution which is chosen to be maximal. To clarify and simplify, there are two sets of data $Y_i$ and $Z_i$ which are drawn from similar but likely different pdf distributions $y$ and $z$. I would like an estimator on $Z_i$ and $Y_i$ which would predict which pdf would produce a larger sum over a future sampling, ie $\Sigma X_i$. </p> <p>The number of elements in each set $N_y$ and $N_z$ is chosen by our implementation so we have to normalize the number of elements out. Or put another, way we are more interested in the mean $\mu = \Sigma X_i / N_x$ because our future sampling has a fixed $N_x$ independent of the choice of $y$ or $z$. This leads to the standard method of making a choice based on each scenario's mean, $\mu$, and error on mean $\sigma_\mu$. What I am interested in is if the mean is really the best estimator to choose the scenario which leads to the highest expected $\Sigma X_i$. In a simple scenario I am sure the answer is yes but there are some complications.</p> <p>There is no good model for the underlying distributions which produces $Y_i$ or $Z_i$ but a histogram of either decreases exponentially. Hence the occurrence of a few high large value outliers which make things complicated. The main reason I think the mean may not be the best is because of its sensitivity to these outliers. The solution of removing outliers and doing a bootstrapping method is discussed here: <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/72242/bootstrapping-do-i-need-to-remove-outliers-first">Bootstrapping - do I need to remove outliers first?</a> From this I think it is clear that the removal of outliers is ill advised. Additionally, the number of elements, $N_y$ and $N_z$, is in the millions so the CLT asserts we do not need to bootstrap at all to obtain $\sigma_\mu$.</p> <p>Another complication is that the distribution is quantize/discrete in two ways. To illustrate this lets take the example of optimizing for future revenue in a split test. There are two scenarios that lead to two sets $Z_i$ and $Y_i$ representing the amount spent for each customer. To illustrate that the underlying pdfs are not continuous one must first off note that the smallest unit of money is a penny so the range of each pdf is the integers. Secondly and more importantly the items to buy do not span the space. Let say for example there is one item that costs \$20 but no other items in the price range [\$15,\$25]. Since there are a lot of single purchase customers there will be a peak at \$20.</p> <p>The simplest choice of an alternative estimator would be the median, $\tilde{x}$ since it is less sensitive to outliers and insensitive to reparameterizations. However, since greater than 95% of customers spend \$0 the median will always be \$0. Also, I am not sure the median is a good estimator of the expected $\Sigma X_i$ in general.</p> <p>So the question is, is there a better estimator than the mean of $Y_i$ and $Z_i$ for maximum expected $\Sigma X_i$? The word "better" in the context refers to the sense of gambling where the best bet is the best.</p>
73,522
[ -0.02294864133000374, -0.013413318432867527, 0.03092360682785511, -0.024143395945429802, 0.023827509954571724, 0.02191133238375187, -0.020282823592424393, -0.01842869259417057, -0.004248743876814842, -0.044241879135370255, 0.049600061029195786, 0.031181374564766884, 0.052239783108234406, -0.001435919781215489, 0.008628357201814651, -0.011300588957965374, -0.02786136418581009, 0.020847398787736893, 0.001810870599001646, -0.025872234255075455, -0.008572877384722233, 0.04311127960681915, 0.0383966825902462, -0.02053849771618843, -0.055385228246450424, 0.01122762355953455, 0.03006228432059288, 0.00851445458829403, -0.006605892442166805, 0.09096315503120422, -0.05316838249564171, -0.01164195779711008, 0.03876354172825813, 0.052595172077417374, 0.034342337399721146, -0.012286457233130932, -0.0168335922062397, -0.018728919327259064, -0.0026088031008839607, -0.005544810555875301, -0.04370710253715515, -0.012463955208659172, 0.014186693355441093, 0.026713557541370392, -0.009445847012102604, 0.045949537307024, -0.0602555088698864, -0.049257129430770874, 0.013469958677887917, -0.024555502459406853, 0.06361404061317444, -0.008426736108958721, 0.0004659305850509554, 0.02482926845550537, -0.00743788992986083, -0.03642469644546509, 0.027428673580288887, 0.08476470410823822, 0.008843162097036839, -0.031346917152404785, 0.021586734801530838, -0.0017360224155709147, -0.020043399184942245, -0.001332635059952736, -0.012376533821225166, 0.018627913668751717, 0.0013930164277553558, -0.03129690885543823, 0.005662116687744856, 0.0003736785729415715, 0.008450239896774292, -0.014406207948923111, 0.027329731732606888, -0.012536213733255863, 0.027590984478592873, -0.004596857354044914, -0.04127512872219086, 0.020587213337421417, 0.04180532321333885, 0.03111651912331581, 0.020740697160363197, 0.0073396372608840466, 0.02912905439734459, 0.02523663640022278, 0.008653774857521057, -0.03080432303249836, 0.10003698617219925, -0.030677270144224167, 0.013939805328845978, 0.043775033205747604, -0.03657787665724754, -0.006045129615813494, 0.04878805950284004, -0.03311079740524292, -0.031082993373274803, 0.033352747559547424, -0.010455453768372536, 0.011204879730939865, -0.030394796282052994, -0.016656678169965744, 0.02869974635541439, -0.02556616999208927, 0.0068156723864376545, 0.05440974235534668, 0.007488342467695475, 0.022200923413038254, -0.04378987476229668, -0.023026486858725548, -0.051555655896663666, -0.04167485982179642, -0.03439567983150482, 0.031855467706918716, -0.026462463662028313, -0.007665593642741442, 0.029646968469023705, 0.03698955476284027, 0.01812978833913803, -0.0412159338593483, -0.0026082475669682026, 0.05125764012336731, 0.019545499235391617, -0.01691025123000145, -0.018860498443245888, -0.04932524636387825, -0.020295524969697, -0.008735114708542824, 0.01995290070772171, 0.022016368806362152, -0.011674033477902412, 0.04331839457154274, 0.018298473209142685, 0.008658746257424355, 0.041218213737010956, 0.026183173060417175, 0.03564826771616936, 0.010831381194293499, -0.0892554223537445, -0.045678313821554184, 0.06776328384876251, -0.024492517113685608, 0.032648686319589615, -0.06617981195449829, -0.03217823803424835, 0.03550993651151657, -0.005790439434349537, 0.02664097584784031, 0.0399923101067543, 0.01514254417270422, 0.03856535628437996, 0.02291051857173443, -0.03290297091007233, 0.009148471988737583, -0.022693246603012085, -0.028749758377671242, -0.0015847125323489308, -0.08224091678857803, 0.03852641209959984, -0.002201010240241885, -0.010302172042429447, -0.014935623854398727, 0.01089812908321619, 0.029740329831838608, -0.0018248393898829818, -0.03410322591662407, 0.022278085350990295, -0.00461686821654439, 0.08062642812728882, -0.0032185374293476343, 0.08179154992103577, 0.029249140992760658, -0.03815074265003204, 0.01778993010520935, 0.029975704848766327, 0.0016826755600050092, 0.060331232845783234, -0.02464328147470951, -0.009468874894082546, -0.06732723861932755, 0.00842936523258686, 0.01793266274034977, -0.018356364220380783, -0.012317221611738205, -0.03371667489409447, 0.005900043528527021, 0.024936286732554436, 0.05370907858014107, 0.03505105525255203, -0.04051981493830681, 0.02024303749203682, -0.05318605154752731, -0.031717415899038315, -0.04386189207434654, -0.0034945604857057333, -0.001162269152700901, -0.024694787338376045, 0.038974884897470474, -0.024054953828454018, 0.011894355528056622, 0.004752673674374819, -0.0038750639650970697, 0.00826942641288042, -0.009748331271111965, 0.053492221981287, -0.047682832926511765, 0.016168128699064255, 0.037673186510801315, 0.046280067414045334, 0.01405132282525301, 0.029041703790426254, -0.027111463248729706, -0.0459032766520977, -0.014252143912017345, -0.035770233720541, -0.013980245217680931, 0.011617040261626244, -0.009024469181895256, 0.03549285978078842, -0.01985781639814377, -0.022599153220653534, 0.0028481101617217064, -0.04456460103392601, 0.01223122887313366, 0.027771547436714172, -0.02933172509074211, -0.033314839005470276, 0.012703523971140385, 0.008814954198896885, 0.019198449328541756, -0.012290669605135918, 0.014599120244383812, -0.07624012231826782, -0.01637662947177887, 0.036979954689741135, 0.051012128591537476, -0.05080623924732208, 0.010072619654238224, 0.07217419147491455, 0.028270967304706573, 0.0007810659008100629, 0.021230803802609444, -0.017600836232304573, -0.03659379109740257, 0.024064280092716217, 0.012767918407917023, 0.022829988971352577, -0.005863573402166367, 0.005567111074924469, -0.03268783539533615, 0.018635861575603485, 0.009683942422270775, 0.033693309873342514, -0.001976421568542719, 0.018500395119190216, 0.010086857713758945, -0.0065953703597188, -0.027269598096609116, -0.006795414723455906, -0.015642892569303513, -0.015312643721699715, 0.03880651295185089, -0.00258482713252306, 0.017912790179252625, -0.012688593938946724, -0.015833590179681778, 0.0005443171830847859, 0.05932864546775818, -0.055673494935035706, 0.020116494968533516, 0.02560972049832344, -0.026959611102938652, -0.008849994279444218, -0.019813260063529015, -0.0165677722543478, 0.015226983465254307, 0.008302051573991776, 0.02033291570842266, -0.017054248601198196, -0.025582261383533478, -0.012067986652255058, -0.036020707339048386, -0.033834680914878845, 0.0034290815237909555, 0.038670506328344345, 0.02197650633752346, -0.04127539321780205, -0.024663712829351425, -0.04130617156624794, -0.04050365462899208, -0.0035063144750893116, -0.00020541796402540058, 0.017281517386436462, 0.011989851482212543, 0.016455531120300293, -0.013199297711253166, -0.0074164425022900105, -0.0185043103992939, 0.0534270815551281, -0.007712239865213633, -0.031290337443351746, 0.06969340145587921, 0.04476040229201317, -0.059727538377046585, 0.016934610903263092, -0.03678373619914055, -0.0591534823179245, -0.04359060153365135, 0.015205894596874714, 0.0053447033278644085, 0.0005730609991587698, -0.007282080594450235, -0.003856632160022855, 0.015643883496522903, -0.0056305257603526115, -0.06053813546895981, -0.05089069530367851, 0.0022984454408288, -0.04053579270839691, 0.050667501986026764, -0.010743958875536919, -0.01327137928456068, 0.07482906430959702, 0.03389216586947441, -0.007778654340654612, 0.0024639987386763096, -0.004869703669101, -0.009276190772652626, -0.03165411949157715, 0.012645313516259193, 0.015710681676864624, 0.004032050259411335, 0.034156959503889084, -0.009585501626133919, -0.016173623502254486, 0.01882779598236084, 0.0177335012704134, 0.025467263534665108, -0.005732829216867685, -0.0015204226365312934, -0.007591142784804106, 0.05115184187889099, 0.01988254114985466, 0.01390558946877718, -0.01260027103126049, 0.05038965120911598, 0.058007434010505676, 0.017640449106693268, -0.060704730451107025, 0.01251144614070654, -0.026181023567914963, 0.011131566017866135, -0.01869110018014908, 0.027158424258232117, 0.0014686541398987174, -0.05861808732151985, -0.026639092713594437, -0.013091478496789932, 0.02317667379975319, -0.015352392569184303, 0.03134049475193024, 0.051190830767154694, 0.027221569791436195, -0.005837675649672747, 0.02281470224261284, -0.05213453993201256, -0.009662258438766003, 0.033472172915935516, -0.025231515988707542, -0.022246789187192917, -0.009339406155049801, 0.07263864576816559, -0.024103039875626564, -0.02880951389670372, -0.01795732043683529, -0.009471680037677288, -0.055152151733636856, 0.015144707635045052, -0.021722808480262756, 0.05751921609044075, 0.010006106458604336, 0.057805124670267105, -0.03864650800824165, 0.003296018112450838, -0.035510435700416565, -0.004719964228570461, -0.07030035555362701, 0.008960707113146782, -0.023052621632814407, 0.004535607527941465, -0.005448512267321348, -0.06851380318403244, 0.053166091442108154, -0.01815243996679783, 0.05127150937914848, -0.01793990656733513, 0.0413677878677845, -0.015219626948237419, 0.002399382647126913, -0.016888676211237907, 0.01515788771212101, -0.000051581941079348326, 0.028935875743627548, -0.011617793701589108, -0.029299797490239143, 0.05197534337639809, -0.0033137511927634478, 0.0023997609969228506, -0.031274259090423584, -0.00817533116787672, 0.040697131305933, 0.010119916871190071, 0.029239265248179436, -0.002114448929205537, 0.014536893926560879, -0.045492883771657944, 0.011831153184175491, 0.017879487946629524, 0.048787567764520645, 0.02098243497312069, -0.01654636673629284, -0.010761670768260956, -0.007323357276618481, -0.03224007785320282, 0.00889115035533905, 0.038183700293302536, 0.006924725137650967, 0.005161874927580357, 0.07345810532569885, -0.026902951300144196, -0.03617829084396362, -0.011044486425817013, 0.01709466427564621, 0.00035333173582330346, 0.007917257025837898, -0.011691666208207607, -0.018199201673269272, -0.010501150041818619, 0.01691693626344204, 0.011984437704086304, 0.03308935463428497, -0.00953107699751854, -0.024556569755077362, 0.044418156147003174, 0.015182241797447205, -0.028184344992041588, 0.02306947484612465, 0.0608740858733654, 0.05717029795050621, 0.029695894569158554, -0.014753245748579502, 0.014568156562745571, 0.014548993669450283, 0.03381866589188576, 0.02815195359289646, 0.02460324577987194, -0.06350047886371613, -0.01181294210255146, 0.0417652502655983, 0.04035880044102669, -0.03622722253203392, 0.009795512072741985, -0.03614186495542526, 0.0014014319749549031, 0.014987796545028687, -0.013892321847379208, 0.018150832504034042, -0.03618659824132919, -0.0037346365861594677, -0.0017632486997172236, -0.058476872742176056, -0.07214131951332092, -0.038640059530735016, -0.015519770793616772, 0.0025127131957560778, -0.042863622307777405, -0.02411702089011669, -0.035952597856521606, -0.006011651363223791, 0.018857881426811218, 0.07258817553520203, -0.017532311379909515, 0.006358588580042124, 0.013336735777556896, 0.03613145649433136, -0.01922549307346344, -0.045733194798231125, 0.02501022256910801, 0.003536794800311327, -0.009733172133564949, 0.041692666709423065, 0.0028273125644773245, -0.09606357663869858, 0.034725792706012726, 0.030467072501778603, -0.012284800410270691, 0.0022238611709326506, 0.0064556896686553955, 0.02240900695323944, 0.055299919098615646, 0.005620491690933704, 0.05497123673558235, 0.04918055236339569, 0.0024188458919525146, 0.0288448017090559, -0.04219454526901245, -0.012664290145039558, -0.058610156178474426, -0.045553263276815414, -0.058923643082380295, -0.003222559578716755, -0.015231859870254993, 0.03395046666264534, -0.016040150076150894, 0.05188412964344025, -0.011346263810992241, -0.04319227114319801, 0.029438477009534836, 0.025120431557297707, -0.012334517203271389, 0.019723979756236076, -0.05800929665565491, 0.03206418827176094, -0.003787343157455325, 0.002591193187981844, -0.012711338698863983, 0.03496770188212395, -0.004745417274534702, 0.012695051729679108, -0.06433869898319244, -0.0032525837887078524, -0.06096344813704491, -0.02227836288511753, 0.0004928053822368383, 0.02274298667907715, 0.03556922823190689, 0.024460969492793083, 0.03367454931139946, 0.010275410488247871, -0.03645468130707741, -0.011187822557985783, 0.023515529930591583, -0.02223500981926918, 0.011512565426528454, -0.011196929030120373, 0.01943032629787922, -0.031122131273150444, 0.0085174310952425, -0.06266382336616516, -0.02018669620156288, 0.03446514159440994, 0.00380143360234797, -0.009431969374418259, -0.014546752907335758, 0.008708978071808815, -0.02003731206059456, -0.04169297218322754, -0.04941121116280556, 0.043255195021629333, 0.015495938248932362, -0.0263475701212883, 0.0017792023718357086, 0.04303514584898949, 0.05713457241654396, -0.023760918527841568, -0.002108420245349407, 0.0076432740315794945, -0.026089461520314217, -0.01565520465373993, 0.01327458955347538, 0.008275262080132961, -0.010991440154612064, -0.019393201917409897, -0.01807096228003502, -0.013660591095685959, 0.01102773193269968, -0.013639330863952637, -0.030562786385416985, 0.03254713863134384, 0.007103687152266502, 0.016020381823182106, -0.01048029214143753, -0.06517644226551056, -0.01443976815789938, 0.01202867366373539, -0.015277264639735222, -0.000046713394112885, 0.01859980635344982, -0.01673278957605362, 0.040697161108255386, 0.012501535937190056, -0.0178143959492445, 0.004155317787081003, 0.04181414842605591, 0.010832023806869984, -0.002724574413150549, -0.0381050780415535, -0.05387970432639122, 0.06961136311292648, -0.027234690263867378, 0.002684922656044364, 0.04920882731676102, -0.014408254064619541, -0.008226457983255386, -0.023014944046735764, -0.027467278763651848, 0.016319656744599342, 0.010470906272530556, 0.039131201803684235, 0.03659772127866745, 0.007558097131550312, 0.009384970180690289, 0.012055134400725365, -0.045510903000831604, 0.010234718210995197, 0.03078022226691246, -0.021329673007130623, 0.02569783478975296, 0.020941991358995438, 0.009553271345794201, 0.034030139446258545, -0.04999452829360962, 0.021268464624881744, 0.030607976019382477, 0.0017857459606602788, 0.017615118995308876, 0.024768711999058723, -0.04509200155735016, -0.039977509528398514, -0.0024774048943072557, -0.08921868354082108, 0.024774840101599693, -0.022201932966709137, -0.02821248024702072, -0.008791789412498474, 0.037560466676950455, 0.019094329327344894, -0.023148609325289726, 0.008159685879945755, -0.05811387673020363, -0.008167768828570843, 0.02075064741075039, -0.017778988927602768, 0.06075044721364975, 0.011782567948102951, 0.004135319963097572, -0.03803481534123421, 0.02086327038705349, -0.05458066985011101, -0.08216597884893417, -0.00824834406375885, -0.001770712435245514, -0.07581591606140137, 0.026825115084648132, -0.017611175775527954, -0.02334701456129551, 0.020058907568454742, -0.03738676756620407, 0.029218805953860283, -0.00875341147184372, 0.046793509274721146, -0.013116548769176006, 0.06851528584957123, 0.010573025792837143, 0.040121376514434814, -0.008811064064502716, 0.034225091338157654, 0.12056000530719757, 0.09406651556491852, 0.04547371342778206, -0.03701552003622055, -0.0020981847774237394, -0.017541540786623955, -0.004157478455454111, -0.03980714827775955, 0.008520976640284061, 0.04048589989542961, -0.02434350550174713, 0.01730247028172016, 0.05123833566904068, -0.03325037285685539, -0.02965482696890831, 0.05554891377687454, -0.03744889050722122, 0.028355760499835014, 0.04110827296972275, 0.023303428664803505, 0.015046750195324421, 0.011083911173045635, -0.07245133817195892, 0.02628432773053646, -0.010088946670293808, -0.032031409442424774, -0.010430656373500824, -0.028905222192406654, -0.03247401863336563, -0.01524914987385273, 0.009753798134624958, -0.02021634764969349, 0.02809896506369114, -0.04906867817044258, 0.012787033803761005, -0.009475750848650932, -0.0533638633787632, -0.0534968264400959, 0.022935915738344193, 0.03852018341422081, 0.02459816075861454, 0.025937264785170555, 0.017288299277424812, 0.03036167100071907, -0.050324615091085434, -0.006015487015247345, -0.04971637949347496, 0.05081658810377121, -0.01476091705262661, 0.02392764203250408, -0.014057924970984459, 0.026254335418343544, 0.0004087545967195183, -0.017203278839588165, -0.022518031299114227, 0.017898056656122208, 0.005319803953170776, -0.018957538530230522, -0.025814758613705635, -0.0181351937353611, 0.010966719128191471, 0.02588994987308979, 0.032261986285448074, 0.0020915837958455086, -0.02665146440267563, -0.038074005395174026, 0.007082800846546888, 0.026370558887720108, 0.03851167485117912, -0.003320864634588361, -0.010987135581672192, 0.015338662080466747, -0.018336016684770584, -0.02254045009613037, 0.03474275395274162, -0.04354526475071907, 0.07439117133617401, 0.010987905785441399, 0.007959750480949879, -0.042315974831581116, -0.028567010536789894, -0.007536426652222872, -0.048119667917490005, 0.022765018045902252, -0.042663611471652985, 0.016564028337597847, -0.011227156966924667, 0.0555880181491375, 0.03979866951704025, -0.008011732250452042, 0.006389664951711893, 0.07590435445308685, 0.017617613077163696, -0.034717898815870285, -0.016388898715376854, -0.035998690873384476, -0.045237619429826736, 0.006758471485227346, -0.030252687633037567, 0.07630982249975204, 0.00346691464073956, 0.04106178134679794, 0.03478693589568138, 0.038710106164216995, -0.019655879586935043, 0.020654283463954926, 0.04936158284544945, -0.05433692783117294, -0.010234717279672623, 0.030406169593334198, 0.003803857835009694, 0.02237710729241371, 0.015449854545295238, 0.0009045613696798682, -0.017476780340075493, 0.008773073554039001, -0.03396989032626152, -0.030601216480135918, -0.004642757587134838, -0.00906642246991396, -0.0058815558440983295, -0.0027225594967603683, -0.05099666118621826, -0.024089377373456955, -0.0016099766362458467, -0.03567303717136383, 0.017914239317178726, -0.005018413998186588, 0.011277176439762115, 0.006318315397948027, 0.005550186615437269, 0.023553844541311264, 0.006717226002365351, -0.007843242026865482, -0.0242946594953537, 0.011114269495010376, 0.016733188182115555, 0.03082500584423542, -0.007804739288985729, 0.05379403755068779, 0.05554520711302757, -0.021301990374922752, -0.020774101838469505, 0.027965283021330833, 0.019287550821900368, 0.006307210307568312, 0.018509777262806892, 0.0039513735100626945, -0.04415334388613701, 0.008115863427519798, -0.019714051857590675, -0.004844389855861664, -0.04564303532242775, 0.01117756124585867, 0.006151913665235043, 0.000170643295859918, 0.02015971578657627, 0.01610490493476391, -0.017798705026507378, 0.038698308169841766, 0.028360242024064064, 0.003809483954682946, -0.025509092956781387, 0.004330726806074381, 0.011252332478761673, 0.029901843518018723, -0.03316932171583176, 0.02308901958167553, 0.05917926877737045, 0.050304654985666275, -0.04145354405045509, 0.012546218931674957, -0.022627299651503563, -0.02288764715194702, -0.07502033561468124, -0.03509533405303955, 0.03874537721276283, 0.023388179019093513, 0.030627528205513954, -0.015632620081305504, -0.00031015754211694, 0.025526810437440872, -0.020398728549480438, 0.022571349516510963, 0.011448938399553299, 0.0035176165401935577, -0.054230742156505585, -0.016517439857125282, -0.04756965860724449, -0.0024364173877984285, 0.023282190784811974, 0.033089082688093185, 0.003924257587641478, 0.0648370310664177, -0.018169021233916283, -0.013829012401401997, -0.01067725196480751, 0.025654897093772888, 0.03337971866130829, -0.055100586265325546, 0.03641268238425255, -0.06369759887456894, -0.0026236281264573336, 0.029409339651465416, 0.041213762015104294, 0.011613445356488228, -0.01388468500226736, 0.01558675803244114, 0.03705611824989319, 0.0661400631070137, 0.04343864321708679, -0.009613449685275555, 0.009123632684350014, -0.02039632573723793, 0.012312705628573895, -0.00040691447793506086, -0.008628754876554012, -0.005130196455866098, 0.0031116348691284657, 0.0005699039902538061, -0.02836807258427143, 0.003369644982740283, 0.013994100503623486, -0.0426623672246933, -0.005711969919502735, 0.01527310349047184, -0.011112282052636147, -0.029924746602773666, -0.004287348128855228, -0.01863381825387478, 0.02735375240445137, 0.035040922462940216, 0.058754291385412216, -0.0033026833552867174, -0.002583283931016922, -0.022583207115530968, -0.037456002086400986, 0.011872030794620514, -0.01642633229494095, -0.008916801773011684, -0.06622661650180817, -0.004628382157534361, -0.00726077426224947, 0.005977110005915165, 0.004730500280857086, -0.013645073398947716, -0.04023624211549759, 0.0038919427897781134, -0.033735379576683044, 0.038993850350379944, 0.011293334886431694, -0.002326324349269271, 0.002818375825881958, -0.08892103284597397, 0.07390567660331726, -0.007180185988545418, 0.016267241910099983, -0.0060668280348181725, -0.025702157989144325, -0.014367636293172836, -0.0057831197045743465, 0.06551754474639893, 0.029065433889627457, -0.004703997168689966, -0.0031652392353862524, 0.05912894755601883, 0.019630590453743935, -0.04501301422715187, 0.04097675904631615, -0.01445203460752964, 0.0036923245061188936, -0.011632067151367664, -0.015156961046159267, 0.023792648687958717, 0.0068396213464438915, 0.04372027516365051, -0.018816139549016953, 0.018466530367732048, 0.03503471240401268, 0.044248003512620926, 0.024297408759593964, -0.0005534587544389069, -0.02658206783235073, 0.04525982216000557, -0.011893312446773052, -0.005663162097334862, 0.02162782847881317, -0.017502157017588615, -0.05681026726961136, -0.006377702113240957, -0.011515738442540169, -0.010909288190305233, -0.001133851008489728, 0.01933988370001316, -0.012230345979332924, -0.05718325823545456, -0.02299819141626358, 0.003580524818971753, -0.030569659546017647, -0.0005992091610096395, 0.011710173450410366, 0.005312222056090832, 0.04840110242366791, -0.015892503783106804, 0.032457806169986725, 0.0014734130818396807, -0.005006543360650539, 0.01398809626698494, 0.014807282015681267, 0.007840721867978573, 0.012397393584251404, 0.031948674470186234, 0.031772054731845856, -0.004639527760446072, 0.057311199605464935, -0.03734863921999931, 0.03445224091410637, -0.007817767560482025, -0.025127025321125984, 0.030479542911052704, -0.01750950887799263, 0.005582524463534355, -0.007296479307115078, -0.008876055479049683, 0.0649392232298851, -0.02058436907827854, -0.030080242082476616, -0.015731923282146454, -0.017564572393894196, -0.03581006079912186, 0.0224891509860754, 0.0033882802817970514, 0.006116085685789585, -0.003550285706296563, 0.0016880921320989728, 0.01824917271733284, 0.030531208962202072, 0.003355948254466057, -0.026678437367081642, 0.03794264420866966, -0.01559351198375225, -0.0001345251512248069, -0.0014443735126405954, -0.04114369675517082, -0.037841666489839554, -0.02227611653506756, 0.008141097612679005, 0.029696820303797722, 0.019328299909830093, -0.016550399363040924, -0.06208780035376549, 0.001673230086453259, 0.0357491634786129, -0.0304282084107399, 0.0038611881900578737, -0.031010065227746964, -0.006044638343155384, -0.03298250213265419, -0.047836244106292725 ]
<p>My aim is to estimate the 2.5%- and 97.5%-quantile function (to get reference intervals) for a specific score in dependence of age separated by classes of a third variable cag. So first I built 11 categories of cag and for each of these categories I modeled the 2 quantile functions for the association score to age (with software R). In a second analysis I used cag directly in my model <code>[score ~ factor(cag)+age*factor(cag)]</code> and get also 11 plots, but they are different from the first 11 plots. By the way, I modeled exponential functions via linear quantile regression.</p> <p>Due to the plots, the first analysis fits the 2.5% quantile function better to the data than the second analysis. And vice versa with the 97.5% quantile function. So I am confused which analysis I should take, and my question is: </p> <p>May I take the 2.5% quantile function of the first analysis and the 97.5% quantile function of the second analysis? May I mix it up?</p>
73,523
[ -0.016654180362820625, -0.0017860331572592258, 0.017078163102269173, 0.03162310644984245, 0.021603886038064957, -0.006288939155638218, -0.018181685358285904, -0.02840237319469452, 0.023101234808564186, -0.013387792743742466, 0.05951858311891556, 0.030710915103554726, 0.09191559255123138, 0.003383525414392352, 0.020593799650669098, 0.01632550172507763, -0.009213199838995934, 0.02074730023741722, 0.003929137252271175, -0.014275415800511837, -0.026638183742761612, 0.018386468291282654, -0.007563136983662844, -0.032956209033727646, -0.008108064532279968, 0.0561467707157135, 0.036153897643089294, -0.04629557952284813, 0.010207770392298698, 0.011806793510913849, -0.03143987059593201, -0.039781611412763596, 0.013251587748527527, 0.01744484156370163, 0.018366629257798195, -0.013352161273360252, -0.0326051190495491, -0.038881246000528336, -0.029301153495907784, 0.02954637072980404, -0.06403637677431107, -0.007987748831510544, -0.0049516586586833, 0.011236624792218208, -0.0059653157368302345, 0.02565409243106842, -0.00957134272903204, -0.02504660375416279, 0.04270119220018387, -0.022250693291425705, 0.04964606091380119, -0.004824914503842592, 0.00926140695810318, 0.04133899509906769, -0.019038137048482895, 0.004972110036760569, 0.04347716271877289, 0.05012039095163345, 0.02052365429699421, -0.040289197117090225, -0.028992056846618652, -0.009406263940036297, -0.012760949321091175, -0.015034705400466919, -0.01527857594192028, 0.021959351375699043, 0.0014714080607518554, -0.03108629398047924, 0.00734643405303359, -0.021769214421510696, 0.032720185816287994, 0.01468858402222395, 0.04668387770652771, -0.05274847522377968, 0.02018403261899948, 0.006660053040832281, 0.025817779824137688, 0.024047743529081345, 0.025239599868655205, 0.022314220666885376, 0.0070083350874483585, 0.024056347087025642, 0.036716461181640625, 0.034163251519203186, 0.014500451274216175, -0.01572151482105255, 0.05369061231613159, -0.03261391073465347, 0.022579967975616455, 0.0021538925357162952, -0.018289757892489433, 0.026658417657017708, 0.061124350875616074, 0.004701972007751465, -0.014753792434930801, 0.017353536561131477, 0.012819058261811733, 0.00376773695461452, 0.006665428169071674, 0.030625581741333008, -0.015395602211356163, -0.061171095818281174, 0.021500835195183754, 0.015141312032938004, -0.022132644429802895, -0.0009387492318637669, -0.01957852579653263, -0.006130187772214413, -0.03883018344640732, -0.018176931887865067, -0.008503468707203865, 0.03223007917404175, 0.01588045246899128, -0.00818171538412571, 0.0507226288318634, 0.018367690965533257, 0.00003930067759938538, 0.009587716311216354, 0.0826156735420227, 0.04581733047962189, 0.06538979709148407, -0.012485076673328876, 0.0007712064543738961, 0.0020053109619766474, -0.020165765658020973, -0.0009065459598787129, 0.004600579384714365, -0.005394898355007172, -0.026011167094111443, 0.034387726336717606, -0.025500867515802383, -0.01913141831755638, 0.03211422264575958, 0.028990330174565315, 0.026248903945088387, -0.034181147813797, -0.03450004756450653, -0.0596914142370224, 0.012349358759820461, 0.00023872034216765314, 0.03310365229845047, -0.0560389868915081, 0.012352968566119671, 0.02538846805691719, 0.06199439615011215, 0.024219777435064316, 0.048939578235149384, -0.010481737554073334, -0.0035528801381587982, 0.021866941824555397, 0.0064063710160553455, 0.025845637544989586, -0.013387586921453476, -0.019139746204018593, -0.025417229160666466, -0.11062968522310257, 0.013451590202748775, 0.026726286858320236, -0.0010836673900485039, -0.004159154836088419, 0.04912233352661133, 0.0006102481856942177, -0.009100337512791157, -0.017665471881628036, 0.015477168373763561, -0.02045033685863018, 0.04818789288401604, -0.026734191924333572, 0.034516848623752594, -0.003966786433011293, -0.001167614245787263, 0.021236559376120567, 0.040494248270988464, 0.037284351885318756, 0.04731142893433571, 0.023278094828128815, -0.003464363981038332, -0.03250529617071152, 0.0007792447577230632, 0.012751542963087559, -0.053565215319395065, -0.036457471549510956, -0.02867192216217518, -0.023265305906534195, 0.001896503148600459, 0.00811763759702444, -0.017135607078671455, -0.042591072618961334, 0.04181767255067825, -0.00838326197117567, -0.07614515721797943, -0.042228519916534424, -0.03042043186724186, -0.0334056057035923, 0.007900344207882881, 0.04700644686818123, -0.018469270318746567, 0.04003395512700081, 0.0022512127179652452, -0.004576797131448984, -0.0006694298353977501, -0.011268450878560543, 0.04978324845433235, -0.026974380016326904, 0.0372963473200798, 0.03333781287074089, 0.033721406012773514, 0.021330129355192184, 0.018839986994862556, -0.05033810809254646, -0.04001174494624138, 0.04814063385128975, -0.05737600103020668, 0.01899123564362526, -0.0003386697790119797, -0.005117118824273348, -0.017133809626102448, 0.031286947429180145, -0.019364649429917336, 0.03868233039975166, -0.047951940447092056, 0.10064917802810669, 0.07810839265584946, 0.011222660541534424, -0.037719421088695526, 0.029029598459601402, 0.012012474238872528, 0.05893649533390999, -0.010533490218222141, -0.022612841799855232, -0.03706967830657959, 0.018600227311253548, 0.045161761343479156, 0.006231762934476137, -0.016946177929639816, 0.0012786959996446967, 0.08250035345554352, -0.02723352611064911, 0.012442613020539284, 0.035847268998622894, -0.004028590861707926, -0.023204978555440903, 0.014702473767101765, 0.012748826295137405, 0.00023585851886309683, -0.010604745708405972, 0.02442864328622818, 0.009976392611861229, 0.04571501538157463, -0.0179023165255785, 0.010818901471793652, 0.07901269942522049, -0.037723951041698456, -0.0019505044911056757, -0.01756337285041809, 0.006526276934891939, 0.04381910338997841, -0.029285626485943794, 0.021511105820536613, 0.046110983937978745, -0.025565432384610176, -0.04374260455369949, 0.05233889818191528, -0.015018941834568977, 0.005135490093380213, 0.051241323351860046, -0.04583118110895157, 0.010624516755342484, 0.016262125223875046, -0.01346889790147543, -0.007586990017443895, -0.04081788659095764, -0.04608403891324997, -0.02071019634604454, 0.034113239496946335, 0.019730642437934875, -0.004471860826015472, -0.006419704761356115, -0.028439395129680634, -0.05803680419921875, -0.019244078546762466, -0.014306561090052128, 0.04137628525495529, -0.015168244019150734, -0.030927667394280434, -0.021819069981575012, -0.05401812866330147, 0.015746375545859337, 0.014077971689403057, 0.0038636091630905867, -0.015697047114372253, 0.0021225097589194775, 0.014251640066504478, -0.052166618406772614, -0.03404237702488899, -0.023549867793917656, 0.012735853902995586, 0.008034942671656609, -0.055835921317338943, 0.02579030767083168, 0.019637903198599815, -0.0007334305555559695, 0.02213919535279274, -0.012623526155948639, -0.004595709033310413, 0.019299235194921494, 0.03025917336344719, 0.0006466958438977599, 0.011014780029654503, 0.0008504363941028714, 0.015195460058748722, 0.0027705805841833353, -0.020272117108106613, -0.07728585600852966, -0.0863899290561676, 0.01889224350452423, 0.014783503487706184, 0.02851797640323639, 0.01605108380317688, 0.0077323224395513535, 0.051883552223443985, 0.03261765092611313, -0.01747891493141651, -0.04115467891097069, -0.009073552675545216, -0.0672965794801712, -0.0033051299396902323, -0.03650171682238579, 0.007778877392411232, 0.02237473614513874, 0.0019129227148368955, 0.01633140817284584, 0.03133915364742279, 0.048780132085084915, -0.026352856308221817, 0.02315598353743553, 0.025645967572927475, 0.028841732069849968, -0.029033618047833443, 0.05874339118599892, 0.023311179131269455, 0.017009083181619644, 0.006948286667466164, -0.023913323879241943, 0.04706281051039696, 0.02246149443089962, -0.06206512823700905, 0.002834304701536894, -0.004102692008018494, 0.0190107524394989, -0.07113455981016159, 0.03145875409245491, 0.024746697396039963, -0.04248494282364845, -0.008980135433375835, 0.003709052689373493, 0.055661898106336594, -0.05741635710000992, 0.0013691060012206435, 0.05642857775092125, 0.05407067760825157, -0.031030843034386635, -0.016836246475577354, -0.008178637363016605, -0.008052950724959373, 0.056885864585638046, -0.016844697296619415, -0.01962125301361084, 0.01721613109111786, 0.021569041535258293, 0.023697134107351303, 0.0026013380847871304, -0.03740115836262703, 0.03719894960522652, -0.07884389907121658, -0.029562128707766533, -0.029680797830224037, 0.04583767428994179, 0.02759687416255474, 0.04968330264091492, -0.0014133641961961985, -0.03218302130699158, -0.027659334242343903, -0.012777364812791348, -0.03682183846831322, 0.028690345585346222, 0.02422204613685608, -0.0023039900697767735, -0.004271074663847685, -0.030710740014910698, 0.04398868605494499, -0.004739412572234869, -0.007277573458850384, 0.01613493077456951, 0.009866966865956783, -0.005343398544937372, 0.023579459637403488, -0.04276645556092262, -0.004272186663001776, 0.018323596566915512, -0.00875538308173418, -0.03469053655862808, -0.02581484243273735, 0.033534616231918335, 0.03214693441987038, 0.00660639489069581, -0.012781274504959583, 0.0032943414989858866, 0.03295651450753212, 0.013969025574624538, 0.018278509378433228, 0.024455424398183823, 0.040539976209402084, -0.007806091103702784, 0.007377267349511385, 0.0019121047807857394, 0.013633023016154766, 0.06389503926038742, -0.01530030369758606, -0.019008323550224304, -0.04602314904332161, -0.013015421107411385, -0.016075437888503075, 0.015767090022563934, 0.011145840398967266, -0.04274549335241318, 0.014758406206965446, 0.017354069277644157, -0.04543552175164223, -0.006944214925169945, 0.04543183743953705, 0.020855853334069252, 0.001163648208603263, -0.05179080739617348, -0.022497259080410004, -0.023490557447075844, -0.03513680398464203, 0.04325610771775246, 0.02116749808192253, -0.013917594216763973, -0.010906832292675972, 0.05554305389523506, -0.008327110670506954, -0.0471491664648056, -0.035147957503795624, 0.06204094737768173, 0.02660582959651947, -0.0021066705230623484, -0.05677177757024765, -0.00645723519846797, 0.012300834059715271, 0.0268266424536705, -0.009158983826637268, -0.0363752506673336, -0.06944641470909119, 0.002083243802189827, 0.03437920659780502, 0.01839154213666916, -0.03823993727564812, -0.026114752516150475, -0.03812633827328682, -0.007179709617048502, 0.004088323097676039, -0.01576138846576214, 0.03243355453014374, -0.020998353138566017, 0.034111205488443375, 0.0010630827164277434, -0.0036232401616871357, -0.04499563202261925, -0.006345843896269798, -0.011446965858340263, 0.016878914088010788, -0.03846783563494682, -0.030621802434325218, 0.003096409607678652, 0.009330241940915585, 0.012302182614803314, 0.05912042036652565, -0.02654316835105419, -0.041485484689474106, -0.007823211140930653, 0.01515495590865612, -0.021168550476431847, -0.0604146383702755, 0.007079241331666708, -0.017504587769508362, 0.04865211993455887, 0.0563049353659153, -0.0031251017935574055, 0.003881029551848769, -0.0003061029710806906, 0.01143352035433054, -0.028088398277759552, 0.014402355998754501, 0.017665982246398926, 0.07403229176998138, 0.0192380603402853, 0.008933356031775475, 0.0640508234500885, 0.03664100915193558, 0.001584765501320362, 0.0012222370132803917, -0.03385608643293381, 0.0036263896618038416, -0.027416907250881195, -0.00807850994169712, -0.04697023332118988, -0.01668088510632515, -0.01621124893426895, 0.007016015239059925, -0.02632521651685238, 0.05223521217703819, -0.049167148768901825, -0.02425912395119667, 0.041194841265678406, 0.023500027135014534, 0.007780994288623333, 0.00792557280510664, -0.011170499958097935, 0.008303390815854073, -0.007650659419596195, -0.005459149833768606, 0.013157996349036694, -0.030223332345485687, 0.01739570125937462, 0.0336417555809021, -0.03178974241018295, 0.04467986896634102, -0.02314850501716137, 0.0024694509338587523, -0.007047544699162245, -0.01203818991780281, 0.005921483971178532, 0.012535583227872849, 0.058355990797281265, 0.011156504042446613, -0.017608514055609703, -0.00044851945131085813, -0.013590182177722454, -0.026495935395359993, 0.041139665991067886, -0.04292657971382141, 0.08144184201955795, -0.005359173286706209, -0.03373118117451668, -0.07619898021221161, -0.04349478334188461, 0.006608529947698116, 0.03369903191924095, -0.04896474629640579, -0.02090385928750038, 0.023796619847416878, 0.005369576159864664, 0.0033252618741244078, -0.02378414385020733, 0.044487763196229935, -0.017564155161380768, -0.011693282052874565, -0.0053305416367948055, 0.018240459263324738, 0.05839056149125099, 0.02889549545943737, 0.0352146290242672, 0.004877355415374041, -0.0056432862766087055, -0.016188830137252808, -0.03256792202591896, -0.007006334140896797, -0.02372107468545437, 0.0033332284074276686, -0.03415074944496155, 0.024970747530460358, 0.037663184106349945, 0.0017938589444383979, -0.03317135199904442, 0.014256725087761879, 0.02621198445558548, 0.042957037687301636, -0.036250434815883636, -0.011166400276124477, -0.03989534080028534, -0.026322336867451668, -0.01349442359060049, -0.002044583670794964, -0.01403713971376419, -0.015241428278386593, -0.00124550296459347, -0.031010940670967102, -0.04529638960957527, 0.05676515772938728, 0.08483631163835526, -0.015373551286756992, 0.009406914003193378, -0.015236666426062584, -0.04417145997285843, 0.04153817147016525, -0.002473792526870966, -0.04342058673501015, 0.012254681438207626, 0.022736886516213417, -0.020161544904112816, -0.012354506179690361, -0.05497195944190025, 0.0019340576836839318, 0.07256154716014862, -0.0008500544354319572, 0.08088652044534683, 0.034578435122966766, 0.005669847130775452, 0.007869807071983814, -0.051616985350847244, -0.033549241721630096, -0.027464350685477257, 0.0059732371009886265, 0.05421571433544159, -0.03013531304895878, 0.012894148007035255, 0.024561498314142227, -0.026319945231080055, 0.011394854635000229, 0.06373359262943268, -0.010895577259361744, 0.021595824509859085, 0.0007607612642459571, 0.012751435860991478, -0.0017724611097946763, -0.002250866498798132, -0.020232701674103737, 0.027859214693307877, -0.06550028175115585, -0.026324491947889328, 0.0203987006098032, 0.03897646814584732, -0.038533058017492294, -0.09733571112155914, -0.025536606088280678, -0.06073259934782982, -0.004116702359169722, 0.007721482310444117, 0.021939367055892944, 0.04164065048098564, 0.013582723215222359, 0.036633480340242386, 0.001003057579509914, 0.004149359185248613, -0.03724260255694389, -0.03380858898162842, -0.0377139151096344, -0.026178468018770218, -0.04037193953990936, 0.039814192801713943, 0.010704872198402882, -0.02186368778347969, 0.04714849218726158, -0.04363107681274414, 0.015196072869002819, 0.005965835880488157, 0.025423923507332802, -0.005085991229861975, 0.08657781779766083, 0.00981446634978056, 0.0035001325886696577, -0.030094007030129433, 0.0007970932056196034, 0.13184288144111633, 0.07275435328483582, 0.02000061236321926, -0.06424261629581451, 0.04461943358182907, 0.017842981964349747, -0.0007609448512084782, -0.0048235561698675156, -0.008634082041680813, 0.027179548516869545, -0.02553272247314453, 0.07418517023324966, 0.0505695715546608, 0.014409850351512432, 0.010942320339381695, 0.03725610673427582, 0.010319235734641552, -0.005100015085190535, 0.004006092436611652, 0.026776308193802834, 0.01819021813571453, -0.010099093429744244, -0.01625942811369896, -0.0056759510189294815, 0.009678693488240242, 0.016533927991986275, -0.03234923258423805, -0.03934846445918083, 0.005505050998181105, 0.014554502442479134, -0.041628528386354446, -0.000923718442209065, 0.03979555517435074, 0.017917487770318985, -0.0268543791025877, -0.010350914672017097, -0.001323161763139069, -0.05215281620621681, -0.00049110985128209, 0.054498687386512756, 0.0026979793328791857, -0.009067246690392494, 0.0005853569600731134, -0.0027106867637485266, -0.06339390575885773, -0.03314844146370888, -0.027916721999645233, 0.007237100973725319, -0.01849985495209694, -0.0021275184117257595, -0.02591576613485813, 0.027609700337052345, 0.025279486551880836, -0.03007187694311142, -0.028857333585619926, 0.016148455440998077, 0.01921026036143303, -0.024569928646087646, -0.0013132875319570303, -0.029254665598273277, 0.020120207220315933, -0.0012316260254010558, 0.0507018081843853, 0.019190045073628426, -0.028069663792848587, 0.003893943503499031, -0.05300052464008331, 0.05485958233475685, 0.001115721301175654, -0.03889371082186699, 0.011921814642846584, 0.010925797745585442, -0.018210675567388535, 0.00019309176423121244, -0.023110199719667435, 0.054727524518966675, 0.035727862268686295, -0.023101050406694412, -0.01909090019762516, -0.012714546173810959, -0.032356441020965576, 0.011431421153247356, -0.02429904416203499, -0.0007782435859553516, -0.013612217269837856, 0.03982117772102356, -0.0005535164964385331, 0.022788532078266144, 0.018400724977254868, 0.04346459358930588, 0.009327384643256664, 0.04059486836194992, 0.015129061415791512, -0.06505188345909119, -0.01102400105446577, -0.011251114308834076, -0.04182526841759682, -0.021384423598647118, -0.0496843121945858, 0.07112814486026764, -0.009870071895420551, 0.011269304901361465, -0.007998048327863216, 0.007750371471047401, -0.002213038271293044, 0.022848887369036674, 0.00859848503023386, -0.023571601137518883, 0.007323138415813446, -0.00028830853989347816, 0.0068906210362911224, -0.019742343574762344, -0.00874433945864439, -0.03977298364043236, -0.07192092388868332, 0.013006956316530704, -0.030823444947600365, -0.033468879759311676, 0.016419608145952225, -0.012252410873770714, -0.015507200732827187, -0.02565700002014637, -0.013981474563479424, -0.03502490371465683, 0.012605063617229462, -0.009102084673941135, -0.021915383636951447, -0.001022691954858601, 0.006527170073240995, -0.029820816591382027, -0.011725066229701042, 0.032165780663490295, 0.024565933272242546, 0.012616254389286041, -0.01616273820400238, 0.013660204596817493, -0.0005400040536187589, 0.04447503760457039, -0.010240026749670506, 0.01660739816725254, 0.025790700688958168, -0.03788565844297409, -0.00039277353789657354, 0.017040027305483818, 0.012466813437640667, 0.02552798017859459, 0.026118164882063866, 0.03396494314074516, 0.010944340378046036, 0.032482367008924484, -0.001253571710549295, -0.03327411785721779, -0.007520813029259443, -0.0235846359282732, -0.017852144315838814, -0.01391850970685482, -0.04596753790974617, 0.026756782084703445, 0.018128007650375366, 0.029201826080679893, 0.024740958586335182, -0.014022374525666237, -0.016354087740182877, -0.02007012628018856, -0.008447053842246532, 0.013830650597810745, 0.0062050544656813145, -0.012290140613913536, 0.06915619224309921, 0.04255533963441849, -0.007605693768709898, 0.02939441241323948, -0.02945493720471859, -0.03064817748963833, -0.06693989783525467, -0.0785507783293724, 0.036488208919763565, 0.007839750498533249, 0.017016692087054253, -0.021239636465907097, 0.0022142345551401377, 0.02609812654554844, -0.02583700232207775, 0.033321551978588104, -0.005908719729632139, -0.00426483154296875, -0.006365700159221888, 0.010935905389487743, -0.010007090866565704, -0.025973115116357803, 0.041024670004844666, 0.03316360339522362, 0.06916237622499466, 0.02890818566083908, 0.017526457086205482, -0.024599095806479454, -0.036861322820186615, -0.012241862714290619, 0.03433215990662575, -0.06605978310108185, 0.06173606589436531, -0.029871460050344467, -0.06554009020328522, 0.03324685990810394, -0.021766571328043938, 0.04010695964097977, 0.0294481310993433, -0.006952415220439434, 0.030693186447024345, 0.03516127169132233, 0.03121199831366539, -0.015046180225908756, -0.01613852195441723, -0.03464289754629135, 0.012164628133177757, -0.0025265614967793226, -0.019298793748021126, 0.02083638310432434, 0.022182097658514977, -0.031718991696834564, -0.033291228115558624, 0.024588534608483315, 0.01619812659919262, -0.0008108938345685601, 0.004148430190980434, 0.006200564559549093, 0.003846624167636037, -0.018549425527453423, -0.006775957066565752, -0.027100149542093277, 0.006934622768312693, 0.07100320607423782, 0.0031202237587422132, 0.02469818666577339, 0.0045122504234313965, -0.032478608191013336, -0.02445758506655693, -0.005881951656192541, 0.030103962868452072, 0.011823732405900955, -0.06169305369257927, 0.0013364421902224422, -0.023427115753293037, -0.021512215957045555, -0.034434352070093155, -0.03220393508672714, -0.06280634552240372, 0.027594996616244316, -0.03564031422138214, -0.015149683691561222, -0.012035341002047062, 0.013874314725399017, 0.02813715673983097, -0.0783974900841713, 0.044503260403871536, 0.02400699071586132, -0.05233340337872505, -0.03316542133688927, -0.0010335149709135294, -0.0590018667280674, 0.015979211777448654, 0.03771497309207916, 0.003824941348284483, -0.021231787279248238, -0.021236198022961617, 0.01012067124247551, -0.011508130468428135, -0.05107095092535019, 0.029328860342502594, 0.007076173089444637, 0.02777119167149067, -0.02235684171319008, 0.030739864334464073, -0.0196420568972826, 0.024712001904845238, 0.013876941055059433, -0.005061511415988207, 0.03613072633743286, 0.013161097653210163, -0.001833431189879775, 0.008548002690076828, 0.0020154323428869247, -0.015078452415764332, 0.04559282958507538, -0.008024285547435284, -0.0029187453910708427, 0.03084859438240528, -0.0251254104077816, -0.029370293021202087, 0.033449865877628326, 0.03136800602078438, -0.007691594772040844, -0.004833574872463942, 0.005494255572557449, 0.03675459325313568, -0.10123763978481293, -0.010079849511384964, 0.04081568121910095, -0.02984224446117878, -0.006853900849819183, 0.00995154120028019, 0.026546193286776543, 0.032392438501119614, -0.0029478566721081734, 0.035357505083084106, -0.010542411357164383, -0.02677312307059765, 0.020371994003653526, -0.032856784760951996, 0.023215491324663162, 0.006446062587201595, 0.021169880405068398, 0.050075601786375046, -0.011326903477311134, 0.003159790998324752, -0.036871809512376785, 0.08486872911453247, -0.012860186398029327, 0.0040838103741407394, -0.004359084647148848, -0.004573450889438391, 0.021801970899105072, 0.01326272264122963, -0.03873800113797188, 0.02699584886431694, -0.04833665490150452, 0.017249785363674164, -0.014720956794917583, -0.029816919937729836, -0.04433836787939072, 0.00361438887193799, -0.00912737287580967, 0.02775171399116516, 0.029918622225522995, 0.005728376097977161, 0.006837501656264067, -0.022861674427986145, 0.04564686492085457, -0.00878103543072939, 0.00707212882116437, -0.04830550402402878, -0.03478692099452019, -0.020797526463866234, -0.018452364951372147, -0.02056666649878025, -0.0354975089430809, 0.03843262419104576, 0.04068266227841377, 0.007234618999063969, -0.020471150055527687, -0.04387926310300827, -0.004902266897261143, 0.007619393989443779, -0.03980168700218201, -0.02891862392425537, -0.02576807513833046, 0.0028860506135970354, 0.048394717276096344, -0.04726317152380943 ]
<p>i have a data set that is strictly binary. each variable's set of values is in the domain: true, false. </p> <p>the "special" property of this data set is that an overwhelming majority of the values are "false".</p> <p>i have already used a bayesian network learning algorithm to learn a network from the data. however, for one of my target nodes (the most important one, being death), the AUC result is not very good; it is slightly better than chance. even the positive-predictive value (PPV), which has been suggested to me on CV, was not competitive with what's reported in the literature with other approaches. note that AUC (ROC analysis) is the typical benchmark reported in this area of clinical research, but i am also opened to suggestions on how to more appropriately benchmark the classification model if there are any other ideas.</p> <p>so, i was wondering what other classification models i can try for this type of data set with this property (mostly false values).</p> <ul> <li>would support vector machine help? as far as i know, SVM only deals with continuous - variables as the predictors (although it has been adapted to multi-class). but my variables are all binary.</li> <li>would a random forest help? </li> <li>would logistic regression apply here? as far as i know, the predictors in logistic regression also are continuous. is there a generalized version for binary variables as the predictors? </li> </ul> <p>aside from classification performance, i suspect SVM and random forest might very well outperform the bayesian network, but the problem shifts to how to explain the relationships in these models (especially to clinicians). </p>
235
[ -0.03109574317932129, -0.041113559156656265, -0.015206752344965935, -0.009592841379344463, 0.02947920188307762, -0.01808401569724083, -0.006167957559227943, -0.016082478687167168, 0.039133019745349884, -0.03715440258383751, 0.03145752474665642, 0.020685860887169838, 0.04151729494333267, 0.042653560638427734, -0.015608873218297958, -0.00025564449606463313, 0.0048234411515295506, -0.030585795640945435, -0.02881026826798916, -0.018290318548679352, -0.005581303499639034, 0.01156005822122097, 0.060359206050634384, 0.016935177147388458, -0.01368112862110138, 0.07565125077962875, 0.03230760619044304, -0.0020570310298353434, -0.017875680699944496, 0.006011247634887695, -0.04411681368947029, -0.018197335302829742, -0.013778893277049065, 0.04463980719447136, 0.007034689653664827, 0.006050727795809507, -0.01760249026119709, -0.026590554043650627, -0.01480135042220354, 0.051009681075811386, -0.01354382373392582, -0.022401027381420135, -0.02434731461107731, 0.05020465329289436, -0.005955559201538563, 0.011092886328697205, 0.01016597356647253, -0.01303822547197342, 0.031155269593000412, -0.05403684452176094, 0.053600721061229706, -0.044357314705848694, 0.06639645248651505, 0.04542606696486473, -0.006782787386327982, -0.01700882613658905, 0.045409370213747025, 0.09519428014755249, 0.018640289083123207, -0.05275312438607216, -0.035416875034570694, -0.004979411605745554, -0.010833028703927994, 0.013661876320838928, -0.009133580140769482, 0.04624472185969353, -0.004085301887243986, -0.051373839378356934, -0.013766334392130375, 0.02448851801455021, 0.01192067563533783, 0.005285914521664381, 0.019399696961045265, 0.02296588383615017, 0.01980559527873993, -0.009160732850432396, -0.026279523968696594, 0.013507120311260223, 0.018709000200033188, 0.012829843908548355, -0.01233521569520235, -0.014083674177527428, -0.014305499382317066, 0.06636275351047516, 0.02006719261407852, -0.03491922467947006, 0.07432369887828827, -0.012102518230676651, 0.02653278037905693, -0.004557417705655098, -0.04635649174451828, 0.03015698492527008, 0.01759164221584797, 0.008323313668370247, -0.06828643381595612, 0.004442937672138214, -0.009940034709870815, 0.04556811600923538, 0.012705090455710888, 0.008675354532897472, 0.004590285010635853, 0.004315578378736973, 0.007093751337379217, 0.07785645127296448, -0.028526317328214645, -0.027663836255669594, -0.03661315515637398, -0.019451022148132324, -0.01168631948530674, 0.010911962948739529, -0.04271819442510605, 0.007883436046540737, 0.018450167030096054, 0.028927190229296684, -0.01844322867691517, -0.05623622238636017, -0.008772018365561962, -0.055363334715366364, 0.01620219647884369, 0.0511942021548748, 0.03200894221663475, -0.0419662781059742, 0.0421275869011879, -0.050070274621248245, -0.04741900786757469, -0.013149363920092583, 0.02885202132165432, -0.0075960056856274605, -0.03473629429936409, 0.04625257849693298, 0.01592712663114071, -0.008748918771743774, 0.061980992555618286, -0.01195045467466116, 0.0376034677028656, 0.01886472851037979, -0.08587047457695007, -0.05649552866816521, 0.004222056362777948, -0.005280328914523125, 0.028720054775476456, -0.038150180131196976, -0.017286965623497963, 0.01314958743751049, 0.038006264716386795, -0.0073577724397182465, 0.012589747086167336, 0.030049748718738556, 0.031917862594127655, 0.00005122070433571935, -0.0012804428115487099, 0.024634284898638725, -0.034617211669683456, -0.010022268630564213, -0.05260058864951134, -0.07331302762031555, 0.02838398888707161, -0.010672380216419697, 0.00735508231446147, -0.0028168309945613146, 0.00923212245106697, -0.02580663375556469, -0.006758160423487425, -0.018047461286187172, -0.01819015108048916, 0.0013687916798517108, 0.08075863122940063, 0.006577926222234964, 0.022248251363635063, 0.010162227787077427, 0.01903732679784298, 0.008936738595366478, 0.04952600598335266, 0.05125686153769493, 0.024282941594719887, -0.0028102814685553312, 0.012665653601288795, -0.02933121845126152, 0.03239411488175392, 0.029385890811681747, -0.02128298208117485, -0.020115740597248077, -0.0646309033036232, -0.014070000499486923, 0.007926791906356812, 0.02523217722773552, -0.002094488823786378, -0.01922895759344101, 0.06159478425979614, -0.03506191819906235, -0.03748283162713051, -0.03831879422068596, 0.00018043651652988046, -0.010388871654868126, -0.00810574647039175, 0.033916376531124115, 0.019913891330361366, 0.008049331605434418, -0.04582665115594864, -0.0050736404955387115, -0.035435471683740616, -0.013151450082659721, 0.05318513140082359, -0.011085591278970242, 0.006805661600083113, 0.031644679605960846, 0.014301382936537266, -0.033157967031002045, 0.03145714849233627, -0.05021950975060463, -0.08638769388198853, -0.011456355452537537, -0.013995910063385963, 0.02693469263613224, -0.035657089203596115, -0.023126276209950447, 0.024096036329865456, -0.0289908554404974, -0.014315606094896793, 0.005793520249426365, -0.043958231806755066, 0.08463522046804428, 0.07790394872426987, 0.005853723734617233, 0.017894363030791283, 0.044052854180336, -0.001311367261223495, 0.011672229506075382, 0.005903883371502161, -0.031073570251464844, -0.057396300137043, -0.007406724151223898, 0.044795408844947815, -0.01113318931311369, -0.01397334411740303, 0.05530950427055359, 0.008706795983016491, 0.015703529119491577, 0.041509438306093216, -0.015149164944887161, -0.024895155802369118, -0.018107527866959572, 0.03321773558855057, 0.011308054439723492, -0.018784567713737488, -0.02024233527481556, 0.017539484426379204, -0.01106985379010439, 0.04877331480383873, -0.04285741224884987, -0.023808183148503304, 0.060591015964746475, 0.02021612785756588, 0.013324744999408722, -0.010119840502738953, -0.04540155827999115, 0.02370217628777027, -0.012120774015784264, -0.004942832048982382, 0.018740173429250717, 0.0233040489256382, 0.0035176121164113283, 0.020815782248973846, -0.014004175551235676, 0.05271786078810692, 0.07196040451526642, -0.03831140697002411, 0.027401763945817947, 0.027822909876704216, -0.06532102078199387, 0.01731366105377674, -0.026535574346780777, -0.05646546930074692, -0.05136790871620178, 0.05929405614733696, 0.01579166390001774, -0.008518549613654613, 0.039579298347234726, -0.013650310225784779, -0.03871426358819008, 0.01496034860610962, -0.018687307834625244, 0.008327544666826725, 0.020894167944788933, -0.040807537734508514, -0.026078563183546066, 0.0024269004352390766, -0.022839872166514397, 0.01641383394598961, 0.00012154258001828566, -0.0461886003613472, 0.012905172072350979, -0.01934748701751232, -0.04209255427122116, -0.02790611796081066, -0.02281784452497959, 0.008561549708247185, -0.01881038397550583, -0.02592657320201397, 0.01270175538957119, 0.005072171799838543, -0.00906011275947094, 0.04419160261750221, 0.0008988688350655138, 0.006277311593294144, 0.0010019007604569197, -0.002004268579185009, 0.04353773593902588, 0.010909093543887138, 0.01741165854036808, 0.0036111169029027224, -0.022458408027887344, 0.0037121200002729893, -0.0624225027859211, -0.06537806242704391, 0.05301619693636894, 0.011483860202133656, 0.017250584438443184, 0.033661916851997375, 0.01991480216383934, 0.05488299950957298, 0.022114507853984833, -0.03639344125986099, -0.030349019914865494, -0.0016683413414284587, -0.03770613297820091, -0.0017395422328263521, 0.01301692146807909, 0.035574186593294144, 0.021461380645632744, 0.02689882181584835, -0.031388916075229645, 0.000423340912675485, 0.03352734073996544, -0.006076551042497158, -0.031272392719984055, 0.06788376718759537, 0.01830063760280609, -0.02662312425673008, 0.026868291199207306, 0.04304871708154678, -0.028813732787966728, 0.001453318283893168, -0.002808451885357499, -0.019860541447997093, 0.010519586503505707, -0.06906214356422424, -0.008307251147925854, 0.013761857524514198, 0.027392923831939697, -0.02797866240143776, -0.019856102764606476, 0.0067304507829248905, -0.04895410314202309, -0.008174841292202473, 0.011746003292500973, 0.04325097054243088, 0.0005861446261405945, 0.0225174929946661, 0.041790757328271866, 0.06093794107437134, 0.008761842735111713, -0.01908578909933567, -0.017529930919408798, -0.011816841550171375, 0.001949673518538475, -0.03386271744966507, 0.030294625088572502, 0.0386073961853981, 0.010517757385969162, 0.019674787297844887, -0.010745816864073277, -0.060431309044361115, -0.002691009547561407, -0.016548413783311844, -0.015170884318649769, -0.04905564337968826, 0.03925309702754021, -0.010316843166947365, 0.009081154130399227, 0.0060635097324848175, -0.038585249334573746, 0.0313490629196167, 0.01751534268260002, -0.061089299619197845, -0.0049943807534873486, 0.0010066786780953407, 0.01684759184718132, 0.012145215645432472, 0.0017040347447618842, 0.03815769776701927, -0.002592823700979352, -0.014013241976499557, -0.024025632068514824, 0.005416474305093288, -0.01872827671468258, -0.025473879650235176, -0.048558205366134644, -0.014732355251908302, 0.015486326068639755, -0.020035361871123314, -0.013810794800519943, -0.013005350716412067, 0.011642922647297382, 0.04022729769349098, 0.007121029309928417, -0.0075595080852508545, -0.008226019330322742, 0.006912437733262777, 0.005511220078915358, 0.04511626809835434, 0.007085258606821299, 0.01929028145968914, -0.026541097089648247, 0.00643518241122365, -0.001328202080912888, 0.03964890167117119, 0.03311999514698982, -0.008214781060814857, -0.000994039117358625, -0.03851300850510597, -0.02235647290945053, -0.004297142848372459, 0.025167429819703102, 0.04099433869123459, 0.025561871007084846, 0.07694704085588455, 0.02295677922666073, -0.09199436753988266, -0.0011862529208883643, 0.04080986976623535, 0.008337575010955334, -0.010707193054258823, 0.0034683432895690203, 0.0037703015841543674, -0.003172824624925852, -0.03114798665046692, 0.046722639352083206, 0.0377863384783268, -0.023389698937535286, -0.016109226271510124, 0.018749792128801346, -0.027959555387496948, -0.025260072201490402, -0.03881971538066864, -0.010867531411349773, 0.026306450366973877, -0.0032084686681628227, -0.04532714933156967, 0.012105069123208523, 0.03681889548897743, 0.03893614560365677, 0.028453689068555832, 0.026892846450209618, -0.1094907894730568, -0.0003186905523762107, 0.048006195574998856, 0.060843341052532196, -0.01706640236079693, -0.04582435265183449, -0.07598364353179932, -0.01462640892714262, 0.023836566135287285, -0.034271545708179474, -0.007268759422004223, 0.0036920695565640926, 0.020027846097946167, -0.03138737380504608, -0.060654498636722565, -0.026733215898275375, -0.006558940280228853, -0.02571798302233219, 0.020490199327468872, -0.010297584347426891, -0.011607157066464424, -0.015605177730321884, 0.02154584228992462, 0.003441347973421216, 0.07400663197040558, 0.0005376649787649512, -0.039931390434503555, 0.03342299535870552, -0.0005299088079482317, 0.021263035014271736, -0.07993007451295853, 0.003054835833609104, 0.027111418545246124, -0.03268768638372421, 0.04545631259679794, -0.0022660945542156696, -0.06146378815174103, 0.007871488109230995, -0.017301863059401512, -0.06619695574045181, 0.0000451081978098955, -0.03188154846429825, 0.021789951249957085, -0.01070641353726387, 0.010431257076561451, 0.035071276128292084, 0.022102175280451775, 0.0017078283708542585, -0.0008374633616767824, -0.020525213330984116, 0.024440785869956017, -0.016846634447574615, -0.013260805048048496, -0.02850884199142456, -0.024373268708586693, -0.01171798910945654, 0.0049881176091730595, 0.04579142481088638, 0.03672071918845177, 0.03526350483298302, 0.017040343955159187, 0.0005712290876545012, -0.013476013205945492, -0.002476263325661421, -0.002429733984172344, -0.00814746879041195, 0.001163442269898951, -0.014016514644026756, 0.018104204908013344, 0.03649158030748367, -0.017139006406068802, 0.02465217560529709, 0.04450489580631256, -0.07031117379665375, 0.021905019879341125, -0.03141200914978981, -0.01229073666036129, 0.011623896658420563, -0.019621752202510834, 0.03429391607642174, 0.02241489291191101, 0.05254051834344864, -0.00033212359994649887, -0.04897113889455795, -0.03307340666651726, -0.017302224412560463, 0.02472687140107155, 0.035346101969480515, -0.013027181848883629, 0.026987718418240547, -0.04444558918476105, -0.0012474005343392491, -0.047148797661066055, -0.038456402719020844, 0.0076306783594191074, 0.015407375060021877, -0.014361758716404438, -0.07626652717590332, 0.06953530758619308, -0.011400463990867138, -0.02332002855837345, 0.017348965629935265, 0.051050856709480286, -0.024505559355020523, -0.0027938662096858025, -0.013350402005016804, 0.0021742924582213163, 0.0635383129119873, 0.017140036448836327, -0.0006000266876071692, 0.01968919299542904, 0.0006525630597025156, -0.0004395438591018319, 0.0293576717376709, 0.024111071601510048, -0.03583146259188652, 0.015123853459954262, -0.02579164132475853, 0.016731342300772667, 0.052164118736982346, 0.012624957598745823, 0.025181110948324203, 0.01885806955397129, -0.004906484391540289, 0.006807343102991581, -0.024512408301234245, 0.023132815957069397, -0.016276204958558083, -0.003336728550493717, -0.02321041189134121, 0.025103740394115448, -0.006542445160448551, -0.00635757390409708, -0.006546192802488804, -0.029692161828279495, -0.02108861692249775, 0.03228086978197098, 0.013511155731976032, 0.00759911211207509, 0.032582566142082214, -0.0165481586009264, -0.01888618804514408, 0.05423221364617348, -0.008982723578810692, -0.01439212542027235, 0.014857888221740723, 0.026603344827890396, -0.025205474346876144, -0.022527266293764114, -0.04913758113980293, -0.04401058331131935, 0.029232995584607124, 0.009525907225906849, 0.048276856541633606, 0.03987056761980057, -0.003864160506054759, 0.010727211833000183, -0.022747620940208435, 0.01681673899292946, 0.01989826187491417, 0.0013286275789141655, 0.028383566066622734, -0.044532258063554764, 0.016347479075193405, 0.03649820759892464, -0.0028659249655902386, 0.0035056902561336756, 0.021523674950003624, 0.02085925079882145, 0.03670918941497803, 0.08374523371458054, -0.025990938767790794, -0.0071018161252141, 0.06130533292889595, -0.03327307105064392, 0.026097236201167107, -0.006618230603635311, -0.03682084381580353, 0.05321871489286423, 0.04078513756394386, -0.010735856369137764, -0.014715935103595257, -0.02823776565492153, -0.039140019565820694, 0.0197235569357872, 0.004995996598154306, 0.001948819262906909, 0.01407528668642044, -0.02947748266160488, 0.012600180692970753, -0.0023231382947415113, 0.03130009025335312, -0.026858538389205933, -0.10790764540433884, -0.030847016721963882, 0.005657638888806105, -0.02444269508123398, 0.02303505688905716, 0.018392978236079216, -0.05502961948513985, -0.0022596707567572594, -0.030021322891116142, -0.002947760745882988, -0.011985686607658863, 0.03989863023161888, 0.007744316477328539, 0.03005194291472435, -0.0083557004109025, -0.014893487095832825, 0.03485679626464844, -0.020923832431435585, 0.12549307942390442, 0.0943194180727005, 0.06208020821213722, -0.033705972135066986, 0.00303523987531662, 0.017186306416988373, 0.021522829309105873, -0.015547643415629864, 0.015834206715226173, 0.027876852080225945, -0.017619838938117027, 0.02303905412554741, 0.01461431011557579, 0.03906085714697838, -0.01446459349244833, 0.07391035556793213, -0.024712039157748222, -0.0031529224943369627, 0.024510925635695457, 0.010796323418617249, 0.007349151186645031, -0.014392049051821232, -0.022423097863793373, 0.037091102451086044, 0.018714534118771553, -0.06292475759983063, -0.050712425261735916, 0.0008653567638248205, 0.02588662877678871, 0.012834691442549229, 0.009590093977749348, -0.01677640713751316, 0.01487991213798523, 0.01841937191784382, 0.03655358403921127, -0.008277304470539093, 0.008845400996506214, 0.0005178069695830345, -0.0007628081948496401, 0.04354390874505043, 0.02370399236679077, -0.0033821805845946074, 0.0030795386992394924, 0.0017907058354467154, -0.057195115834474564, -0.03794198855757713, -0.05325452610850334, 0.06925344467163086, -0.0031805788166821003, -0.018098099157214165, -0.015793565660715103, -0.016256244853138924, -0.005084074568003416, -0.02625068835914135, -0.03729577362537384, 0.008466380648314953, 0.06287757307291031, -0.035487011075019836, -0.045378390699625015, -0.0024073754902929068, 0.029214052483439445, -0.010212196968495846, 0.04436430335044861, 0.01066325418651104, -0.04580789804458618, -0.03528089076280594, -0.03889911249279976, 0.03608095645904541, 0.003699654946103692, 0.014062538743019104, 0.01907065138220787, -0.0067368559539318085, 0.0016893025022000074, 0.028834113851189613, 0.02400064654648304, -0.001715462887659669, 0.00380091299302876, -0.01676991581916809, -0.0004186197475064546, -0.0073302434757351875, -0.046106863766908646, -0.0006464476464316249, -0.037168845534324646, 0.0059638917446136475, -0.026191385462880135, -0.00982952956110239, 0.005274447146803141, 0.03417830914258957, 0.03545331954956055, 0.02725844644010067, 0.0013843625783920288, 0.030883977189660072, -0.017154635861516, -0.04104137793183327, -0.013143893331289291, -0.02817355841398239, -0.04062739014625549, 0.027695897966623306, 0.027747640386223793, 0.06264951080083847, 0.013927245512604713, 0.030913103371858597, -0.0013343453174456954, 0.052559174597263336, -0.0008227524813264608, 0.014677133411169052, -0.015350050292909145, -0.0589432492852211, 0.007194435223937035, 0.006692295894026756, 0.02295614220201969, -0.008683007210493088, -0.05415179207921028, -0.021414674818515778, -0.01643015630543232, 0.001967407064512372, -0.01451877225190401, -0.02087533473968506, -0.004248809069395065, -0.016251156106591225, 0.028627844527363777, -0.04536282643675804, 0.00487122219055891, -0.019524307921528816, 0.015451997518539429, -0.005175233818590641, -0.026373760774731636, -0.0013169052544981241, 0.00625403318554163, 0.023193908855319023, -0.012970995157957077, 0.027931978926062584, 0.0011406090343371034, -0.006320341024547815, -0.01782269962131977, 0.00807623565196991, 0.01798996888101101, 0.018902473151683807, -0.03726901859045029, -0.02026643417775631, 0.026953384280204773, -0.044912781566381454, -0.002274901606142521, 0.035234466195106506, -0.012199481949210167, 0.02527259662747383, -0.010411922819912434, 0.009035799652338028, 0.012764432467520237, 0.04599054902791977, -0.03853648528456688, -0.01329749170690775, -0.02288748137652874, 0.011038650758564472, -0.02594595216214657, 0.022108551114797592, 0.01866118423640728, 0.021919863298535347, -0.019077008590102196, 0.007832633331418037, 0.011435776948928833, 0.016190065070986748, -0.007816317491233349, 0.012429202906787395, -0.017563052475452423, 0.007353661581873894, 0.023249737918376923, 0.006040265783667564, 0.046804413199424744, 0.019079290330410004, -0.0055884551256895065, 0.08852671831846237, 0.001186451641842723, 0.05316341668367386, -0.09315147250890732, -0.04176698252558708, 0.011693102307617664, 0.005186313763260841, 0.034386418759822845, -0.05197935551404953, 0.013209477066993713, -0.013844548724591732, -0.03679746389389038, 0.03066571056842804, 0.03283090516924858, -0.011392246931791306, -0.010797716677188873, -0.013048037886619568, -0.026571452617645264, -0.011244270950555801, 0.022395143285393715, 0.03913052752614021, 0.015064412727952003, 0.03896544873714447, 0.0070719290524721146, -0.03963255509734154, -0.026010973379015923, 0.041235532611608505, 0.0144568532705307, -0.05089340731501579, 0.01424636971205473, -0.06824488937854767, -0.024724800139665604, 0.02540053427219391, 0.01260341890156269, 0.0169471874833107, 0.056871525943279266, 0.0014456523349508643, -0.012964065186679363, 0.04198087006807327, 0.0414346344769001, -0.007059961091727018, -0.005665357690304518, -0.020579347386956215, 0.02138567343354225, 0.014802233316004276, -0.026956720277667046, 0.04829255864024162, 0.027918169274926186, -0.020012352615594864, -0.0012053443351760507, -0.016008004546165466, -0.0370735265314579, -0.0023620878346264362, -0.00835156999528408, -0.02233501523733139, 0.009257536381483078, 0.0037093195132911205, -0.02618371695280075, -0.09080065041780472, -0.0029594721272587776, 0.04732711613178253, 0.030610010027885437, 0.02964998222887516, -0.0021949447691440582, -0.02293521724641323, -0.029453620314598083, -0.036044057458639145, 0.0004208987229503691, 0.009044703096151352, -0.04778475686907768, 0.00917394831776619, -0.0052080824971199036, -0.012453296221792698, -0.03601931780576706, 0.004053361248224974, -0.008445347659289837, 0.05507003143429756, 0.010094382800161839, 0.0331231914460659, 0.030115969479084015, 0.002633472438901663, 0.01709350198507309, -0.06194034218788147, 0.03415229171514511, 0.01678997278213501, -0.012253634631633759, -0.04682277888059616, 0.02911657653748989, -0.022722361609339714, -0.02410970814526081, 0.0604933425784111, -0.03038465976715088, 0.018274156376719475, -0.03141491860151291, 0.004265285097062588, -0.010160399600863457, -0.05639609321951866, 0.02278999611735344, -0.052504751831293106, -0.039243921637535095, -0.04323796555399895, 0.012286501936614513, -0.017695894464850426, -0.003435661783441901, 0.032156139612197876, -0.06866811960935593, -0.022828351706266403, 0.0035100653767585754, 0.009897997602820396, 0.01851494424045086, -0.0468786284327507, 0.0011183529859408736, 0.03181636333465576, -0.007099087815731764, -0.005006125196814537, 0.02024821750819683, 0.010460620746016502, -0.05465175583958626, 0.07623796910047531, 0.013119916431605816, -0.03431890904903412, -0.00793712493032217, -0.009030947461724281, -0.009669365361332893, -0.06853960454463959, 0.024324463680386543, 0.05856883525848389, -0.03796759247779846, 0.033650126308202744, 0.037371762096881866, -0.017961185425519943, 0.04569126293063164, 0.013088955543935299, 0.020421640947461128, -0.01391314435750246, -0.03464833274483681, -0.011558620259165764, -0.020993629470467567, 0.043533243238925934, -0.021407049149274826, 0.033021580427885056, 0.02639342099428177, -0.021964214742183685, 0.04300171881914139, 0.009291495196521282, 0.04029642418026924, -0.052227217704057693, 0.015177571214735508, -0.015788385644555092, 0.003601282835006714, 0.013857918791472912, -0.013147235848009586, 0.017174692824482918, 0.06347836554050446, -0.03398909047245979, -0.006601538509130478, -0.05016380548477173, -0.033421631902456284, -0.020968299359083176, 0.022817067801952362, 0.01311277225613594, 0.04898819699883461, 0.01422913558781147, 0.03793015703558922, -0.019864361733198166, -0.0008921562694013119, 0.011887205764651299, -0.025649646297097206, 0.005912462715059519, -0.019335255026817322, -0.003336119931191206, 0.022175464779138565, -0.0170346200466156, -0.0023600293789058924, -0.033414438366889954, 0.013267752714455128, 0.06315519660711288, 0.02044490911066532, 0.012416811659932137, -0.01416760589927435, 0.006258674431592226, 0.038932621479034424, -0.06103507801890373, 0.00588203826919198, -0.06113571301102638, 0.010942833498120308, -0.0023188679479062557, -0.030063943937420845 ]
<p>I have data of two random variables X and Y (each of size n x 1) and their joint pdf (probability density function) (of size m x m where m is NOT EQUAL TO n). How can I evaluate their joint moment generating function (MGF)? Importantly, I do NOT know the type of random variables. Thanks</p>
35,916
[ -0.004597126971930265, -0.010645627975463867, 0.0006985591608099639, -0.02500428818166256, 0.0459895133972168, 0.025558048859238625, -0.0191989466547966, -0.04966561496257782, 0.06188211590051651, -0.04574738070368767, 0.057697881013154984, 0.05747159942984581, 0.0777655839920044, 0.017118485644459724, 0.04053571820259094, -0.0009493869147263467, -0.022749928757548332, 0.025500118732452393, 0.02233603596687317, -0.0437651127576828, -0.009864442981779575, 0.016968991607427597, 0.05574185773730278, -0.00932583212852478, -0.026742901653051376, 0.06569237262010574, 0.03919692710042, -0.02598787099123001, 0.052061766386032104, 0.06747806072235107, -0.0522555336356163, -0.0400518923997879, 0.024915413931012154, 0.04279054328799248, -0.030323848128318787, 0.013066667132079601, -0.059297557920217514, -0.016861775889992714, -0.00829973816871643, 0.003903049975633621, -0.0497874841094017, -0.02243649959564209, 0.01422764454036951, 0.02774221822619438, -0.033237241208553314, 0.008495633490383625, 0.005079333204776049, -0.014348508790135384, 0.017696600407361984, -0.048593997955322266, 0.11915409564971924, 0.012759502045810223, 0.06207573413848877, 0.016710802912712097, -0.026650698855519295, 0.023381061851978302, 0.041279587894678116, 0.08405768871307373, 0.028896179050207138, -0.056964218616485596, -0.019326377660036087, -0.035975780338048935, -0.004332611802965403, -0.05311529338359833, -0.0029124668799340725, 0.004422010388225317, -0.017380300909280777, -0.033268049359321594, -0.008276616223156452, 0.012152018956840038, 0.03433208167552948, 0.055172666907310486, 0.08954409509897232, -0.04687760770320892, 0.01015414111316204, -0.024668924510478973, 0.03488544002175331, -0.018706386908888817, 0.03878127411007881, 0.005767321679741144, 0.0017422866076231003, 0.040345244109630585, 0.026430021971464157, -0.0004760458832606673, 0.015907039865851402, -0.010263177566230297, 0.09653624147176743, 0.021102020516991615, 0.04302160441875458, -0.007054367568343878, -0.04473377764225006, -0.011226252652704716, 0.06362219154834747, 0.020812995731830597, -0.05412043631076813, -0.000002381869080636534, -0.022723527625203133, 0.053953152149915695, -0.008029017597436905, -0.02018401399254799, -0.0071981907822191715, -0.047587476670742035, 0.034524139016866684, 0.0565728098154068, -0.01801937259733677, 0.017741799354553223, -0.0008292401325888932, -0.007932002656161785, -0.0003698845684994012, 0.018603496253490448, -0.0169544517993927, 0.015918893739581108, -0.0014043182600289583, -0.02123207040131092, 0.0627201646566391, 0.017200462520122528, -0.021887728944420815, -0.021336572244763374, 0.048391781747341156, 0.07344509661197662, 0.05838174372911453, -0.0350101999938488, 0.018753226846456528, -0.03517124801874161, -0.07221176475286484, 0.009346715174615383, -0.013645421713590622, 0.001784138148650527, -0.044803816825151443, 0.05160526558756828, -0.04375311732292175, -0.02872873656451702, 0.021573401987552643, -0.015753112733364105, 0.0031716502271592617, -0.01125341560691595, -0.06135885417461395, -0.039647527039051056, 0.007974506355822086, -0.027916142717003822, 0.000039962273149285465, -0.0614275261759758, 0.023331422358751297, 0.028093159198760986, 0.02369564212858677, 0.011539194732904434, 0.04300512373447418, -0.024334002286195755, 0.04291601851582527, -0.015690630301833153, -0.01119034830480814, -0.025358105078339577, -0.042109448462724686, -0.02114066295325756, -0.0012325450079515576, -0.05423605814576149, 0.032015226781368256, 0.0073001813143491745, -0.03441227599978447, -0.03200341761112213, 0.0466390959918499, 0.02199244312942028, -0.017292214557528496, -0.029568316414952278, 0.030426068231463432, -0.03571823984384537, 0.08036449551582336, 0.022288667038083076, 0.04293394461274147, 0.024476539343595505, 0.007521929685026407, -0.009761897847056389, 0.02066487818956375, 0.06859183311462402, 0.03020472824573517, -0.00020191473595332354, -0.005939829628914595, -0.0025985788088291883, 0.03281591832637787, 0.024589242413640022, -0.009637763723731041, -0.015142806805670261, -0.028987612575292587, -0.022441718727350235, 0.02380191534757614, 0.017429612576961517, 0.02754724957048893, -0.026852861046791077, 0.0021545756608247757, -0.04598099738359451, -0.050269052386283875, -0.07080359756946564, 0.005779700353741646, -0.006217307411134243, -0.021385403349995613, 0.011884302832186222, 0.01752082072198391, 0.05885249748826027, -0.031156495213508606, -0.04932195693254471, -0.03346870467066765, -0.029413677752017975, 0.00395433371886611, -0.001172557589598, -0.01620464026927948, 0.011321641504764557, 0.06578419357538223, -0.005033975932747126, 0.05063358321785927, -0.031972747296094894, -0.035290904343128204, 0.017734162509441376, -0.01761786825954914, -0.0006937432335689664, 0.019215064123272896, -0.02240682952105999, 0.013017083518207073, 0.0031374148093163967, 0.011815381236374378, -0.02445821277797222, -0.009905582293868065, 0.03991807624697685, 0.06431617587804794, 0.031340569257736206, -0.016024162992835045, 0.022015182301402092, 0.025002947077155113, -0.0042616743594408035, -0.022901155054569244, -0.028755130246281624, -0.03806844353675842, -0.03815707564353943, 0.04926273599267006, 0.04080507159233093, -0.04601280763745308, 0.011713542975485325, 0.0714188814163208, -0.008612817153334618, 0.029087422415614128, 0.04900461435317993, -0.021226653829216957, -0.010289051569998264, -0.014774884097278118, 0.04818354547023773, -0.0009716302738524973, 0.025892337784171104, 0.012550894170999527, 0.026161007583141327, 0.01986503228545189, -0.015831826254725456, -0.04592806473374367, 0.065229631960392, -0.0006125755608081818, 0.008946258574724197, -0.022029675543308258, -0.046243272721767426, 0.044648945331573486, -0.007391324266791344, -0.021901406347751617, 0.030073905363678932, -0.015390686690807343, 0.004533848259598017, 0.03199296072125435, -0.04133739694952965, 0.024627072736620903, 0.014839102514088154, -0.016482671722769737, -0.0034356070682406425, 0.015800651162862778, -0.017282404005527496, 0.020148176699876785, 0.008120265789330006, -0.0400792732834816, -0.018422599881887436, 0.006673931609839201, 0.005171518307179213, 0.0016619308153167367, 0.04846063256263733, -0.013998670503497124, -0.049431007355451584, 0.0024011973291635513, -0.04065130650997162, -0.0006292053149081767, -0.03751670569181442, -0.05109773948788643, 0.011814361438155174, -0.0028552901931107044, -0.02181132882833481, 0.01793912798166275, -0.013712435960769653, 0.00851970724761486, 0.010264628566801548, -0.02128743939101696, -0.039990123361349106, 0.011921747587621212, 0.000563642883207649, 0.01659272238612175, -0.023665467277169228, 0.01553000696003437, 0.02650626003742218, 0.006440835073590279, -0.03204061836004257, 0.012669622898101807, -0.02118850313127041, -0.02565671131014824, -0.06244121119379997, 0.017471877858042717, 0.032529063522815704, -0.005888202227652073, 0.012866617180407047, 0.012124462053179741, -0.0209644865244627, -0.04207388684153557, -0.04057001695036888, -0.053783174604177475, -0.0029291105456650257, -0.010182890109717846, 0.02954787388443947, 0.011212469078600407, -0.06468824297189713, 0.04409264028072357, 0.02437005005776882, -0.023806380107998848, -0.01737295277416706, -0.01871907152235508, 0.009768148884177208, -0.0147640909999609, 0.04976184666156769, -0.0007043441291898489, -0.01431974582374096, 0.03814562410116196, 0.013059159740805626, -0.032832641154527664, 0.06520529836416245, -0.025859924033284187, 0.008796896785497665, 0.006330606061965227, 0.0027612210251390934, 0.000008617465937277302, 0.04580851271748543, 0.02090800739824772, -0.03645329922437668, 0.03552605211734772, 0.015532406978309155, 0.01930665224790573, -0.01451319269835949, -0.02497522532939911, 0.022807778790593147, -0.012024572119116783, 0.014438837766647339, -0.06173945218324661, 0.04647527635097504, 0.029208695515990257, -0.04398878291249275, 0.020517736673355103, 0.026111502200365067, 0.020570876076817513, -0.011750105768442154, 0.015529011376202106, 0.052991293370723724, 0.006818409543484449, 0.003468114184215665, -0.027470596134662628, -0.0196315199136734, 0.006156490184366703, 0.030214715749025345, -0.015260587446391582, -0.018515584990382195, 0.02336934767663479, -0.0003136625455226749, 0.01436921488493681, -0.022547153756022453, -0.014132692478597164, -0.0071980818174779415, -0.051060762256383896, 0.020176898688077927, -0.02167760767042637, 0.06122438982129097, 0.01561976969242096, 0.085646852850914, 0.0011009040754288435, -0.0017921201651915908, 0.016639098525047302, -0.03092300146818161, -0.08039174973964691, 0.04893689230084419, -0.020630991086363792, -0.006779937073588371, -0.017542829737067223, -0.015306728892028332, 0.045110516250133514, -0.009272847324609756, 0.003368476638570428, 0.006452655419707298, -0.004751411732286215, -0.04275902360677719, -0.024149741977453232, -0.04394589364528656, -0.03341267630457878, -0.0039344169199466705, 0.05129300430417061, 0.02723880484700203, -0.017331022769212723, 0.015977246686816216, 0.0483568049967289, -0.021837282925844193, -0.024260535836219788, -0.01516805775463581, 0.014099959284067154, -0.0017902492545545101, 0.04510624706745148, 0.011496083810925484, 0.05351362004876137, -0.025666553527116776, 0.012538880109786987, 0.005456689745187759, 0.07367435097694397, 0.028130823746323586, -0.02463848516345024, -0.03448967635631561, -0.04228425398468971, -0.0042547243647277355, -0.011340380646288395, 0.022394945845007896, 0.0016044892836362123, 0.015305349603295326, 0.03427732735872269, 0.0437321662902832, -0.02313130535185337, 0.03613857179880142, 0.07732705771923065, 0.020127059891819954, 0.009195839986205101, -0.02012520283460617, 0.03282979875802994, -0.026008250191807747, -0.0231194868683815, 0.01615806296467781, 0.021647006273269653, -0.013081718236207962, -0.025469325482845306, 0.031504981219768524, -0.032482996582984924, 0.0008876096690073609, -0.004270866047590971, 0.038507312536239624, 0.04971079155802727, 0.02134026400744915, -0.036114614456892014, -0.001768814167007804, 0.06099767982959747, 0.023934751749038696, 0.005046541336923838, -0.01113428920507431, -0.03947900980710983, 0.03545401617884636, 0.06660683453083038, 0.023557821288704872, -0.032890018075704575, -0.005366723518818617, -0.030682096257805824, 0.01569555699825287, 0.047307390719652176, -0.03345217555761337, 0.0008205848862417042, 0.030287448316812515, 0.005911684595048428, 0.018579762428998947, 0.026890849694609642, -0.06089598312973976, 0.018018120899796486, -0.014862519688904285, 0.03832044079899788, -0.026816174387931824, -0.027232803404331207, -0.03925931826233864, 0.03511044383049011, 0.03486369550228119, 0.04613162577152252, 0.004869420081377029, -0.031196290627121925, 0.003539017401635647, 0.0220809169113636, 0.017062339931726456, -0.0539282001554966, 0.0340336449444294, -0.010458719916641712, -0.030907073989510536, 0.05056580528616905, -0.022622786462306976, -0.04528067260980606, 0.033723119646310806, -0.014292015694081783, 0.016514630988240242, 0.004434805363416672, 0.012761539779603481, 0.019382886588573456, 0.029878417029976845, 0.0009262451203539968, 0.03842560201883316, 0.00011006135900970548, -0.013460690155625343, -0.022273674607276917, -0.026066813617944717, 0.03558885678648949, -0.027073053643107414, -0.006815480533987284, -0.04053108021616936, -0.012433040887117386, -0.0031923495698720217, 0.013745693489909172, -0.021380392834544182, 0.03704727813601494, -0.015333343297243118, -0.010019895620644093, -0.004007645882666111, 0.0241714958101511, 0.0051395948976278305, 0.0034736800007522106, -0.006195051595568657, 0.011249692179262638, 0.0008802085649222136, -0.00878438912332058, 0.007267174776643515, -0.01426476240158081, -0.028878862038254738, -0.014928888529539108, -0.028740214183926582, 0.0031473112758249044, -0.056386493146419525, -0.019771456718444824, 0.010968049056828022, -0.0051901196129620075, 0.01793355494737625, -0.031118499115109444, 0.033363260328769684, 0.040695901960134506, -0.057355623692274094, -0.0035065417177975178, 0.002954404568299651, 0.03522124141454697, 0.06345678865909576, -0.025006717070937157, 0.02405795082449913, -0.03298655152320862, -0.03608601912856102, -0.09245434403419495, -0.027566254138946533, 0.00592811219394207, -0.004769118037074804, -0.021480390802025795, -0.06889268010854721, 0.010571504011750221, -0.03067680448293686, -0.002105070510879159, -0.001668634475208819, 0.04471436142921448, 0.01239868439733982, -0.03459179773926735, 0.002629051450639963, -0.006191259250044823, 0.06801625341176987, -0.014347854070365429, 0.004109533503651619, 0.02476564794778824, -0.015606849454343319, -0.008027281612157822, 0.008665886707603931, 0.021857192739844322, -0.017665674909949303, 0.009245363064110279, -0.00033455315860919654, -0.029150303453207016, 0.024520358070731163, -0.07241835445165634, 0.03158010542392731, 0.029729649424552917, 0.012354296632111073, 0.00586435804143548, -0.005283173639327288, 0.018564486876130104, -0.016580093652009964, -0.014452226459980011, -0.03946925327181816, -0.00040751814958639443, -0.016485661268234253, -0.015070700086653233, 0.04185979440808296, -0.008170826360583305, 0.0058663999661803246, 0.015640446916222572, 0.0652332529425621, -0.017857350409030914, -0.013349396176636219, 0.011713705956935883, 0.011193185113370419, 0.028000731021165848, -0.019943255931138992, 0.005692562088370323, 0.01820482686161995, 0.012554691173136234, -0.031231200322508812, 0.0032146775629371405, -0.06576942652463913, -0.026018137112259865, 0.07870251685380936, -0.029528627172112465, 0.055292267352342606, 0.038074590265750885, 0.010296136140823364, 0.021060246974229813, -0.018973279744386673, -0.0032368197571486235, 0.0027219548355787992, -0.011259200982749462, 0.03811374306678772, -0.0027256265748292208, -0.012895382940769196, 0.030815791338682175, 0.015604552812874317, 0.002495853928849101, 0.05174552649259567, -0.01443078275769949, 0.03394476696848869, 0.05663171783089638, -0.006990683730691671, -0.019511569291353226, 0.010963746346533298, -0.039721861481666565, -0.005309477914124727, -0.030200887471437454, -0.015546401031315327, 0.02390921674668789, 0.06313483417034149, -0.019587179645895958, -0.012895171530544758, 0.005572001915425062, -0.029111027717590332, 0.0035974737256765366, 0.053693633526563644, -0.01163520012050867, 0.022425014525651932, 0.0738721564412117, 0.018624983727931976, -0.019934680312871933, 0.02472868748009205, -0.0027940976433455944, -0.08128675818443298, -0.030469508841633797, -0.025766322389245033, -0.05585476756095886, 0.018778188154101372, 0.010776646435260773, -0.035458918660879135, 0.03086588717997074, 0.004037581384181976, 0.013058866374194622, -0.013881678692996502, 0.02093035914003849, -0.023469211533665657, 0.0870508998632431, 0.01297066267579794, 0.02918393164873123, 0.0054011293686926365, 0.007345412392169237, 0.08875970542430878, 0.04102837294340134, 0.03853863105177879, -0.09504007548093796, -0.01756291836500168, -0.05530237406492233, -0.025538748130202293, -0.01515502855181694, 0.01886146143078804, 0.028439391404390335, -0.006143335718661547, 0.07945897430181503, 0.03508606553077698, 0.0153071703389287, 0.004097713157534599, 0.050262656062841415, 0.0004479738126974553, -0.03970666974782944, 0.002306662267073989, 0.02345697395503521, -0.012724406085908413, -0.030576100572943687, -0.06526710093021393, 0.013979199342429638, -0.02082740142941475, -0.034677598625421524, -0.02187996357679367, -0.04168006777763367, 0.03387196362018585, 0.021683264523744583, -0.009230655618011951, 0.014303483068943024, 0.023415610194206238, 0.01996924914419651, 0.004927825182676315, -0.001918062916956842, 0.02790120802819729, -0.0033875228837132454, 0.002618011785671115, 0.034326422959566116, 0.02352738380432129, -0.010824437253177166, -0.000575298210605979, -0.020890027284622192, -0.040232155472040176, -0.048560287803411484, -0.03547467291355133, 0.05628585442900658, -0.007636136841028929, 0.001527863903902471, -0.00808216817677021, 0.012657085433602333, -0.012277893722057343, -0.03992703557014465, -0.0016352360835298896, 0.010759259574115276, 0.037789151072502136, -0.04752952232956886, 0.00691101374104619, -0.026262888684868813, 0.04397552087903023, -0.02747071348130703, 0.03442677482962608, 0.004629533272236586, -0.04104926809668541, 0.008053927682340145, -0.007919639348983765, 0.03002198413014412, -0.008065407164394855, -0.046435240656137466, -0.01555049791932106, -0.018801067024469376, -0.0029964593704789877, -0.026341915130615234, 0.03012758307158947, -0.007006799802184105, 0.0042124465107917786, 0.007466382812708616, 0.02162865735590458, -0.011690505780279636, -0.038776807487010956, 0.004374013282358646, -0.010474576614797115, -0.008348404429852962, -0.01823095604777336, -0.00883772224187851, 0.05439658463001251, 0.04921584203839302, 0.02617696300148964, -0.014688348397612572, -0.05344246327877045, 0.028911259025335312, 0.02777663618326187, -0.0548982210457325, -0.0004579125379677862, -0.001983724068850279, 0.003543306142091751, -0.027825329452753067, -0.03637947887182236, 0.0226383525878191, 0.034940026700496674, 0.022418899461627007, 0.023847145959734917, 0.04583792760968208, -0.014007451012730598, 0.007622650358825922, -0.023458704352378845, -0.051141977310180664, -0.007794615812599659, 0.0014926913427188993, -0.010318444110453129, -0.0006321659311652184, -0.014220643788576126, -0.009256490506231785, -0.00970733817666769, 0.004364753141999245, 0.014903286471962929, -0.026265017688274384, -0.04334999620914459, -0.006518044043332338, 0.023957960307598114, 0.008099657483398914, 0.008199942298233509, -0.010366497561335564, -0.012056785635650158, 0.004006438888609409, 0.015864958986639977, -0.04290079325437546, -0.009146108292043209, -0.027574799954891205, 0.0003584385849535465, 0.014487842097878456, 0.008882583118975163, 0.02337217703461647, -0.02474171482026577, 0.023380097001791, -0.0296518225222826, 0.050540465861558914, -0.016726279631257057, 0.02809746377170086, 0.053974349051713943, -0.04279591888189316, -0.02850738912820816, 0.003497394500300288, 0.011147812940180302, 0.047254253178834915, 0.02734782174229622, -0.01662604510784149, -0.05616189166903496, 0.059292424470186234, -0.02964956872165203, -0.008918726816773415, -0.02020583488047123, 0.006794794928282499, 0.006357191596180201, -0.0047928388230502605, 0.0016478284960612655, -0.014687731862068176, -0.013149028643965721, 0.029274029657244682, 0.016144437715411186, -0.004241111222654581, 0.00976213812828064, 0.043865591287612915, 0.04388680309057236, 0.010523524135351181, 0.0043381741270422935, -0.007757911458611488, 0.0372980572283268, 0.05077560618519783, -0.017793850973248482, -0.005589979700744152, -0.02087371237576008, 0.01813632994890213, -0.08885370939970016, -0.03501594811677933, -0.0016530121210962534, -0.036790430545806885, 0.057921864092350006, -0.06476612389087677, -0.01056225597858429, 0.015318800695240498, -0.03747349977493286, -0.020425641909241676, -0.003701986977830529, -0.02039099484682083, -0.017894595861434937, 0.007212144788354635, 0.03038829192519188, 0.048204969614744186, 0.019491098821163177, 0.043221376836299896, 0.039656274020671844, 0.019208669662475586, -0.032470960170030594, -0.01084065344184637, -0.04988778382539749, -0.0034860563464462757, -0.0025294488295912743, -0.03581921011209488, 0.05785876139998436, -0.045023757964372635, -0.040221910923719406, 0.0366353876888752, -0.0161840058863163, 0.00904137920588255, -0.033701878041028976, 0.004836482927203178, 0.010069604031741619, 0.03177770972251892, 0.03261352702975273, -0.03455905616283417, -0.0017302435589954257, -0.013363692909479141, 0.006712835747748613, 0.00446312827989459, -0.03773707151412964, 0.0007984251715242863, 0.009291240014135838, -0.00780867412686348, -0.03565635159611702, 0.028041893616318703, 0.002139645628631115, -0.06298644095659256, -0.013113743625581264, 0.0033965150360018015, 0.006437948904931545, -0.038285572081804276, 0.05138320475816727, -0.059794336557388306, -0.011281056329607964, 0.03313671424984932, 0.003623428288847208, -0.02592618763446808, 0.015172174200415611, 0.010881215333938599, -0.03789070248603821, 0.013299435377120972, -0.0005493945791386068, -0.021241512149572372, -0.06588908284902573, -0.0031982220243662596, 0.0038489652797579765, 0.014617107808589935, 0.014331616461277008, -0.044592101126909256, -0.04818095266819, -0.003433076897636056, -0.005779074039310217, 0.022428926080465317, 0.0192657969892025, -0.02824794128537178, 0.0024140786845237017, -0.04725981131196022, 0.03445810824632645, 0.016496971249580383, -0.04900768771767616, -0.047012630850076675, 0.011942381970584393, 0.003056908957660198, -0.04260635748505592, 0.040614038705825806, 0.011704408563673496, -0.001104516675695777, -0.010538303293287754, 0.021284665912389755, 0.017785023897886276, -0.059929948300123215, 0.002453339286148548, -0.044119417667388916, -0.03409615159034729, -0.0002486908051650971, -0.013872107490897179, 0.022560622543096542, 0.03180546313524246, -0.019923284649848938, -0.021288666874170303, -0.010222241282463074, 0.017964595928788185, -0.02173651196062565, 0.005695177707821131, -0.008806588128209114, -0.0261581689119339, 0.03835245966911316, -0.016015438362956047, 0.008199724368751049, 0.006189662031829357, 0.0229753777384758, -0.05362445116043091, 0.00532354274764657, -0.024997739121317863, -0.016012800857424736, -0.027354488149285316, 0.005430680233985186, 0.01407286524772644, -0.06205766648054123, -0.007746994961053133, 0.02076648361980915, -0.026304593309760094, 0.02552809752523899, 0.03129732608795166, 0.060015443712472916, 0.03171926736831665, 0.005024526733905077, 0.005181275308132172, 0.0045090122148394585, -0.011674555949866772, 0.014724762178957462, 0.008290713652968407, 0.0006740399403497577, -0.025276239961385727, 0.014223875477910042, 0.007411180529743433, -0.022132940590381622, 0.023927489295601845, -0.004719806835055351, 0.023386554792523384, -0.0057963039726018906, -0.03698541969060898, 0.0235814917832613, -0.03217892348766327, 0.028361188247799873, -0.0010624751448631287, -0.025696685537695885, 0.06944412738084793, -0.026769069954752922, -0.01607380621135235, -0.04573291167616844, -0.015570824965834618, -0.02927311509847641, -0.01057326328009367, 0.021165402606129646, 0.03276492655277252, -0.0009678815258666873, 0.021155033260583878, 0.015904737636446953, -0.04074154421687126, 0.03615727648139, -0.03321363404393196, 0.02849058248102665, -0.029405029490590096, 0.029125628992915154, -0.004036047961562872, -0.018740525469183922, -0.044256020337343216, -0.019267480820417404, 0.04480316862463951, 0.05446043610572815, 0.03283330053091049, -0.029958020895719528, -0.016174020245671272, 0.0016818706644698977, 0.04142194241285324, -0.07576567679643631, -0.005823398008942604, -0.030885566025972366, 0.018615294247865677, 0.02085856720805168, -0.013146542012691498 ]
<p>For simple linear regression, the regression coefficient is calculable directly from the variance-covariance matrix $C$, by $$ C_{d, e}\over C_{e,e} $$ where $d$ is the dependent variable's index, and $e$ is the explanatory variable's index.</p> <p>If one only has the covariance matrix, is it possible to calculate the coefficients for a model with multiple explanatory variables? </p> <p>ETA: For two explanatory variables, it appears that $$\beta_1 = \frac{Cov(y,x_1)var(x_2) - Cov(y,x_2)Cov(x_1,x_2)}{var(x_1)var(x_2) - Cov(x_1,x_2)^2} $$ and analogously for $\beta_2$. I'm not immediately seeing how to extend this to three or more variables.</p>
73,524
[ -0.02311525121331215, 0.026981942355632782, 0.0030718084890395403, 0.012715315446257591, 0.032269131392240524, 0.021413659676909447, -0.03936614841222763, -0.02936231903731823, 0.05162787437438965, -0.07182064652442932, 0.008181190118193626, 0.02872449904680252, 0.0739235207438469, -0.008465022780001163, 0.04854871705174446, 0.024581683799624443, -0.00017541606212034822, 0.02331252582371235, 0.01420181430876255, -0.005090367514640093, 0.00017487136938143522, 0.017065012827515602, 0.009985736571252346, 0.0017708407249301672, 0.012341825291514397, 0.06297911703586578, 0.02805047482252121, -0.01627558097243309, 0.011015839874744415, 0.029239822179079056, 0.002383087296038866, -0.013556484133005142, 0.014680840075016022, 0.0389813669025898, 0.013306188397109509, -0.012377683073282242, -0.0070218597538769245, -0.035058002918958664, 0.0019446501974016428, 0.04799072444438934, -0.014319361187517643, -0.04121100902557373, -0.01961829699575901, 0.034616753458976746, 0.0036467243917286396, 0.010327908210456371, -0.016981028020381927, -0.037614770233631134, 0.021120961755514145, -0.05291740968823433, 0.13079562783241272, 0.005021512042731047, 0.06334473192691803, 0.05347276106476784, -0.04003613069653511, 0.00194016401655972, 0.07257676124572754, 0.04624819755554199, -0.0018148859962821007, -0.01457285601645708, -0.020146574825048447, -0.0019088604021817446, 0.018352190032601357, -0.013377605937421322, -0.04284160956740379, 0.006227365229278803, 0.017920853570103645, -0.003047419711947441, 0.034484751522541046, -0.037400271743535995, 0.01857343129813671, 0.006763725075870752, 0.04255788400769234, -0.01778453215956688, -0.009145618416368961, -0.006763737183064222, 0.030561065301299095, 0.026931140571832657, 0.03129555657505989, 0.018130522221326828, 0.005130219738930464, 0.018891407176852226, 0.03755686804652214, 0.051852352917194366, 0.0029226935002952814, 0.02462853118777275, 0.0728313997387886, -0.02846994437277317, 0.027615947648882866, 0.03375217318534851, -0.024606220424175262, 0.019808297976851463, 0.04250400513410568, 0.008828144520521164, -0.05049821734428406, 0.03371252492070198, -0.00849695410579443, 0.040119729936122894, 0.04144690930843353, -0.0013090751599520445, -0.029219219461083412, 0.004631303250789642, 0.0024657759349793196, 0.024001648649573326, -0.01754111237823963, -0.0019013934070244431, -0.008589996956288815, 0.02110145054757595, -0.019026631489396095, -0.04919871687889099, -0.014695469290018082, 0.03187425807118416, -0.011751096695661545, -0.021996334195137024, 0.034029144793748856, -0.021769540384411812, 0.00015879812417551875, -0.02188372053205967, 0.05077265948057175, 0.07889404892921448, 0.005554026458412409, -0.052327096462249756, 0.011231759563088417, -0.02217942848801613, -0.045319199562072754, 0.024234483018517494, 0.020162124186754227, -0.024425474926829338, -0.03946031257510185, 0.035567499697208405, -0.003391863312572241, -0.04436681792140007, 0.006392431445419788, 0.0058255884796381, -0.009611462242901325, -0.009934895671904087, -0.07073578983545303, -0.037844158709049225, -0.0005920703988522291, -0.020143577829003334, 0.01627582125365734, -0.04853077977895737, 0.018085800111293793, 0.03199741244316101, 0.0728839784860611, 0.00792671274393797, 0.03074912168085575, 0.02380196563899517, 0.014147692359983921, -0.0014786755200475454, -0.03992651030421257, -0.023472510278224945, -0.02605816349387169, -0.018501000478863716, -0.03784272447228432, -0.08636748790740967, 0.016697270795702934, 0.027146322652697563, 0.0020502875559031963, 0.028207257390022278, 0.07139728218317032, 0.027127306908369064, -0.04284800961613655, 0.01596618816256523, 0.016586728394031525, -0.04738335683941841, 0.0551505982875824, -0.021664388477802277, 0.017609557136893272, 0.009387994185090065, -0.0008903728448785841, 0.00218060240149498, -0.017911279574036598, 0.07441642880439758, 0.05892256274819374, -0.01570357009768486, -0.03493420034646988, 0.014246838167309761, 0.026109620928764343, 0.024621617048978806, -0.06580165773630142, -0.047851234674453735, 0.004723260644823313, -0.00908848736435175, 0.027720704674720764, 0.024295618757605553, -0.0019805291667580605, -0.03135810047388077, 0.045867208391427994, -0.037522368133068085, -0.002601138548925519, -0.06619636714458466, 0.007826047949492931, 0.0016357672866433859, -0.024564584717154503, 0.01435635145753622, 0.021276205778121948, 0.027587508782744408, 0.015802687034010887, -0.036282073706388474, -0.013492018915712833, 0.04048082232475281, 0.0506691113114357, -0.031719353049993515, -0.0072860862128436565, 0.018881570547819138, 0.08254186064004898, -0.0037595806643366814, 0.04637774080038071, -0.02486642636358738, -0.049686357378959656, -0.006096153520047665, -0.06237926706671715, 0.03636300936341286, -0.04440474882721901, -0.00898295734077692, 0.0040684835985302925, 0.0024252310395240784, -0.02223432995378971, 0.03801070526242256, -0.04395300894975662, 0.04960620775818825, 0.06955123692750931, 0.008707690052688122, 0.004440400283783674, -0.013044361025094986, 0.02157977968454361, 0.021385176107287407, -0.04351325333118439, -0.013784011825919151, -0.04274934530258179, -0.049158480018377304, 0.030842240899801254, 0.019662288948893547, -0.04028290882706642, 0.032812271267175674, 0.039860665798187256, 0.049159929156303406, 0.004235837142914534, 0.03138026222586632, 0.005955142434686422, 0.002108044922351837, -0.02922256663441658, -0.0004486597899813205, 0.0033685206435620785, 0.00468116719275713, -0.0028277321252971888, 0.029202517122030258, 0.028562936931848526, 0.006247306242585182, 0.010920537635684013, 0.05527697131037712, 0.002660583471879363, -0.014776484109461308, 0.004080132581293583, -0.021160248667001724, 0.0502261258661747, 0.006387005094438791, 0.039733946323394775, 0.031046729534864426, 0.025029869750142097, -0.003036130452528596, 0.01843683235347271, -0.014761339873075485, 0.027783170342445374, 0.037990469485521317, -0.05310189723968506, 0.03004227764904499, 0.016875917091965675, -0.03611830994486809, 0.040463902056217194, -0.032312698662281036, -0.01317877322435379, -0.012828024104237556, 0.0156394150108099, -0.004906568676233292, 0.01943824253976345, 0.039176784455776215, -0.016285264864563942, -0.044317759573459625, 0.016019703820347786, -0.023945629596710205, 0.023612292483448982, -0.005261299666017294, -0.03941481560468674, 0.020006835460662842, -0.03628726303577423, -0.009827866218984127, 0.026117222383618355, 0.004407053347676992, -0.029067935422062874, 0.029547160491347313, -0.011408690363168716, -0.07883000373840332, -0.015492706559598446, -0.023364383727312088, 0.012657283805310726, -0.03750777989625931, -0.017672302201390266, 0.009687989018857479, -0.008790062740445137, -0.04848506301641464, 0.005098595749586821, -0.02819717302918434, -0.026181276887655258, -0.02130737714469433, -0.019722342491149902, 0.0006694650510326028, -0.014492742717266083, 0.014941330067813396, 0.04892534017562866, -0.041664008051157, -0.028642958030104637, -0.06738058477640152, -0.07679534703493118, 0.03957556560635567, 0.01887827180325985, 0.00945574976503849, -0.018151594325900078, -0.0553886704146862, 0.05416294187307358, 0.006826859433203936, -0.015090186148881912, -0.024588370695710182, -0.0034473389387130737, 0.004154072143137455, -0.031649596989154816, -0.00031768897315487266, -0.007780392188578844, 0.015508289448916912, 0.0477694496512413, -0.008455280214548111, -0.006621890235692263, 0.0633348673582077, 0.008705091662704945, 0.03914806991815567, 0.020651815459132195, 0.014346763491630554, 0.0036847717128694057, 0.025492846965789795, 0.02001715451478958, 0.01020778901875019, 0.031760163605213165, 0.001128515461459756, 0.03914331644773483, 0.001191057963296771, -0.02216234803199768, -0.0029271577950567007, -0.009765833616256714, -0.008011842146515846, -0.051362842321395874, 0.01561412587761879, 0.04203666001558304, -0.014892016537487507, -0.019688056781888008, 0.034095391631126404, 0.018594887107610703, -0.012943912297487259, 0.007908881641924381, 0.035006266087293625, 0.027544710785150528, -0.005275607109069824, -0.03466261923313141, -0.022382142022252083, -0.013525400310754776, -0.0010532635496929288, -0.008432259783148766, 0.0023175969254225492, 0.05741075798869133, 0.019560877233743668, 0.02389496937394142, -0.02940457873046398, -0.035975612699985504, 0.01790628768503666, -0.06606233865022659, 0.01606276072561741, -0.022938653826713562, 0.02983563207089901, -0.015171555802226067, 0.047479528933763504, -0.020842207595705986, -0.014521490782499313, 0.04321269318461418, 0.0036517104599624872, -0.05142180621623993, -0.003252041758969426, -0.02889920026063919, -0.007697402033954859, 0.015172130428254604, -0.0032911240123212337, 0.0921841636300087, -0.003879941301420331, -0.009397407062351704, -0.020626261830329895, -0.008184056729078293, -0.027682200074195862, 0.01008005253970623, -0.03536079078912735, -0.036061596125364304, 0.0227669570595026, 0.022250069305300713, -0.0027260177303105593, -0.034784745424985886, -0.005634661298245192, 0.05968897417187691, -0.01760002411901951, 0.020873628556728363, -0.05054638907313347, -0.0029570236802101135, 0.009974004700779915, 0.03416717052459717, 0.036662712693214417, 0.024481715634465218, -0.00869937613606453, 0.027971863746643066, -0.03248322755098343, 0.026412013918161392, 0.041568905115127563, 0.003248529275879264, -0.018628917634487152, -0.04139099642634392, -0.008915466256439686, 0.009853977710008621, 0.014802836813032627, -0.006141204386949539, 0.028427105396986008, 0.06071506440639496, 0.05169677734375, -0.05621838569641113, 0.029161347076296806, 0.039693668484687805, 0.024059880524873734, -0.01673312485218048, -0.023236246779561043, 0.035892389714717865, 0.012422444298863411, -0.01886073872447014, 0.0038873536977916956, 0.008710569702088833, -0.023761505261063576, -0.010020201094448566, 0.012697845697402954, -0.04126870632171631, 0.01216292567551136, 0.014992307871580124, 0.0389532707631588, 0.0691390261054039, 0.011015161871910095, -0.05575835332274437, -0.01238213200122118, 0.048414066433906555, 0.0032058905344456434, 0.036243047565221786, -0.00300305406562984, -0.07454666495323181, 0.01971759833395481, 0.010469327680766582, 0.0436805859208107, -0.05712107941508293, -0.016762159764766693, 0.004161942284554243, -0.03898626193404198, 0.021124644204974174, 0.009718531742691994, 0.022837599739432335, 0.00046456287964247167, -0.021945681422948837, -0.016711775213479996, 0.009529423899948597, -0.06525570154190063, 0.04250996187329292, -0.028474479913711548, 0.017281606793403625, -0.013944411650300026, 0.011051913723349571, -0.026714012026786804, 0.017726266756653786, 0.02416965365409851, 0.0798431858420372, 0.002575451973825693, -0.031214404851198196, -0.0018580086762085557, 0.025511300191283226, -0.003212283831089735, -0.05763373523950577, 0.0004726448096334934, 0.042476508766412735, -0.03677629679441452, 0.048773393034935, -0.014883708208799362, -0.02951670251786709, 0.015989871695637703, 0.02414698712527752, -0.0038652075454592705, 0.014387211762368679, 0.006411024834960699, 0.046717941761016846, 0.039796046912670135, -0.0006056089769117534, 0.09038233011960983, 0.03460294008255005, 0.00858158990740776, 0.008437160402536392, -0.030859285965561867, -0.0024277903139591217, -0.01530416589230299, -0.06505046784877777, -0.027284903451800346, -0.010435265488922596, -0.006156260147690773, -0.0008310317061841488, -0.019295232370495796, 0.018875105306506157, -0.024906227365136147, -0.011347913183271885, -0.01686529628932476, 0.021768400445580482, -0.022800760343670845, -0.01949579268693924, 0.019195502623915672, 0.031031768769025803, -0.006878864951431751, -0.051964230835437775, 0.013444934971630573, -0.007209458854049444, 0.01869916170835495, -0.0015593369025737047, -0.03403356298804283, -0.0034129368141293526, -0.014184333384037018, -0.00449425308033824, -0.016370153054594994, -0.01198267750442028, 0.034038715064525604, -0.028585346415638924, 0.020371874794363976, -0.02122514881193638, -0.04228150099515915, -0.015765974298119545, 0.03920022398233414, 0.011972742155194283, 0.0276794470846653, -0.022053871303796768, 0.0035493660252541304, -0.031161360442638397, -0.03311331570148468, -0.055700112134218216, -0.03687067702412605, -0.005529595073312521, -0.0028391373343765736, 0.021959643810987473, -0.028115764260292053, -0.004677797667682171, -0.04625474661588669, -0.04171810671687126, -0.019333144649863243, 0.0550663135945797, -0.020196743309497833, 0.007107413839548826, 0.003307151375338435, -0.00018215856107417494, 0.05596524104475975, -0.013135181739926338, -0.01988895982503891, 0.03202938288450241, -0.016644353047013283, -0.019117480143904686, 0.0389060415327549, 0.011377150192856789, -0.021341165527701378, 0.005346733145415783, -0.04111674800515175, 0.01256581861525774, 0.05005698651075363, -0.026338519528508186, -0.039554059505462646, 0.012374145910143852, 0.0062090810388326645, 0.004908746108412743, -0.04464802145957947, 0.011471436358988285, 0.01599864661693573, 0.04106804355978966, -0.022444959729909897, -0.008473473601043224, -0.03355403617024422, 0.022062553092837334, 0.03850378468632698, -0.00016247990424744785, -0.005269342567771673, -0.0076828706078231335, 0.062060605734586716, 0.00485992431640625, -0.009770452044904232, 0.0005162051529623568, 0.01093434076756239, 0.034136537462472916, 0.011477861553430557, 0.01804802380502224, 0.01423961017280817, 0.04318303242325783, -0.06226241588592529, -0.04615084454417229, -0.057652797549963, 0.01589987985789776, 0.08391965180635452, -0.05778311938047409, 0.022449783980846405, 0.06777594238519669, -0.0028344483580440283, -0.004114421084523201, -0.04929234832525253, -0.022823769599199295, 0.010019627399742603, -0.009597384370863438, 0.058896418660879135, -0.010739162564277649, -0.018676146864891052, 0.037305593490600586, 0.027303434908390045, -0.014696506783366203, 0.044019076973199844, -0.02028936892747879, 0.027473796159029007, -0.007357147056609392, -0.01891835406422615, -0.042948611080646515, 0.049964793026447296, -0.021622831001877785, -0.011054689064621925, -0.026836054399609566, -0.048694267868995667, 0.06798519939184189, 0.04985833168029785, -0.010823492892086506, -0.03477256000041962, -0.04608999937772751, -0.052858881652355194, 0.02893764339387417, 0.028063569217920303, 0.006792475003749132, 0.006933932658284903, -0.017690859735012054, 0.048531368374824524, -0.02230183780193329, 0.03225342556834221, -0.020140988752245903, -0.10136500000953674, -0.011161558330059052, -0.018139945343136787, -0.011303306557238102, 0.017040090635418892, 0.025186212733387947, -0.03732049837708473, 0.025795049965381622, -0.05355483293533325, 0.021787026897072792, -0.006943394895642996, 0.0555470809340477, -0.003965996205806732, 0.0639338493347168, -0.019371183589100838, -0.028812183067202568, -0.02103843167424202, -0.003808696288615465, 0.08825946599245071, 0.08511988073587418, 0.00905927550047636, -0.08713258802890778, -0.007313191890716553, -0.01135299727320671, -0.005844398867338896, -0.029780711978673935, 0.007322011515498161, -0.008044106885790825, -0.002486736048012972, 0.021511543542146683, 0.09454046189785004, -0.0077176447957754135, -0.0013191651087254286, 0.04335109516978264, -0.0096352007240057, -0.020182840526103973, -0.010322272777557373, -0.0015599518083035946, 0.0039848159067332745, -0.005182626191526651, -0.03188775107264519, 0.0017704947385936975, -0.011663154698908329, -0.004009112250059843, -0.03297153487801552, -0.005007965490221977, -0.00523834815248847, -0.027896670624613762, -0.03360148146748543, 0.0015875346725806594, 0.004669748712331057, 0.028795817866921425, -0.02582167088985443, 0.020442858338356018, 0.0405440479516983, -0.017654208466410637, -0.004978569690138102, 0.02484096586704254, -0.026514234021306038, 0.027629904448986053, 0.010902785696089268, -0.01425221934914589, -0.04723651334643364, -0.03166170418262482, -0.01877555064857006, 0.04328959062695503, -0.011902300640940666, -0.012695033103227615, -0.017675889655947685, -0.012241117656230927, 0.009290233254432678, -0.029235413298010826, -0.025760922580957413, 0.02603166550397873, 0.02482130192220211, -0.047208044677972794, -0.009558635763823986, -0.03373313322663307, 0.03105265460908413, -0.01920720562338829, 0.034049972891807556, -0.004823700059205294, -0.044429611414670944, -0.010664093308150768, -0.01604977808892727, 0.04821193963289261, 0.021408366039395332, -0.020269539207220078, -0.003653647843748331, -0.03204377740621567, -0.011209520511329174, -0.0037767873145639896, 0.046050090342760086, 0.014234155416488647, -0.0011305309599265456, -0.002460494404658675, 0.002524535870179534, -0.009276648052036762, -0.03409705311059952, -0.0036613873671740294, -0.02749522589147091, 0.018386978656053543, -0.06479194760322571, -0.0020980520639568567, 0.025758562609553337, 0.04793614521622658, 0.021459700539708138, 0.00043765813461504877, -0.011647973209619522, 0.048725638538599014, 0.013339847326278687, -0.04407113417983055, -0.02467578835785389, 0.0008488662424497306, -0.029315946623682976, -0.0033892446663230658, -0.022092247381806374, 0.048998937010765076, 0.01377292163670063, 0.053288865834474564, -0.03198874741792679, 0.01515701413154602, -0.018827561289072037, 0.015056170523166656, 0.00820096954703331, -0.04742191731929779, 0.0069357468746602535, 0.029836535453796387, 0.00040754611836746335, 0.0022761928848922253, 0.002008498413488269, -0.04794628545641899, -0.04028570279479027, 0.0031338839326053858, -0.008663557469844818, -0.05264320224523544, 0.021420560777187347, -0.03316035121679306, 0.021457545459270477, -0.06724575161933899, -0.0008591247606091201, -0.02648603729903698, 0.03802378103137016, 0.011332201771438122, -0.04433770850300789, 0.0025269605685025454, 0.00012072439858457074, -0.026941893622279167, 0.022625908255577087, 0.05777043104171753, 0.015290957875549793, 0.024927424266934395, -0.011891412548720837, 0.013207602314651012, -0.014880218543112278, 0.04681196063756943, -0.03304116800427437, -0.016584308817982674, 0.030011305585503578, -0.044597890228033066, -0.03061264008283615, 0.005424728151410818, 0.014603572897613049, 0.0629192516207695, 0.03434785082936287, 0.01009318232536316, -0.044483449310064316, 0.044153887778520584, -0.03447491303086281, 0.006999033968895674, -0.010068756528198719, 0.028245000168681145, -0.005391359329223633, -0.015790056437253952, 0.037848737090826035, -0.007375132758170366, 0.0046902853064239025, 0.043228015303611755, 0.03262961655855179, -0.006982294376939535, -0.018045226112008095, 0.028299562633037567, 0.00674234377220273, 0.006850247271358967, 0.03050253726541996, 0.0004635508230421692, 0.029764149338006973, 0.04615219682455063, -0.021588200703263283, 0.05689297243952751, 0.015755902975797653, 0.046377889811992645, -0.09544837474822998, -0.027371760457754135, -0.0011470268946141005, 0.02690361626446247, 0.029556574299931526, -0.055549561977386475, 0.025576449930667877, 0.029440997168421745, -0.038317691534757614, 0.00932538602501154, -0.0038677493575960398, 0.004401791840791702, -0.019193515181541443, 0.003921002149581909, -0.007713774684816599, 0.03714124858379364, 0.03629182651638985, -0.0007967787678353488, 0.019823245704174042, 0.049877747893333435, -0.010465916246175766, -0.038864556699991226, -0.034485090523958206, -0.004529193043708801, 0.0027749082073569298, -0.08069314807653427, 0.03765862062573433, -0.052820708602666855, -0.015603955835103989, 0.0220929104834795, -0.007124859374016523, 0.018676672130823135, 0.004164551384747028, 0.033979449421167374, -0.004098237492144108, 0.03692391887307167, 0.024681419134140015, -0.000163211501785554, 0.009674480184912682, 0.0032826794777065516, -0.012434623204171658, 0.0022849675733596087, -0.035803940147161484, -0.000609031820204109, 0.031836070120334625, 0.006437482312321663, -0.022806232795119286, 0.001885954407043755, -0.007532923948019743, -0.01641588844358921, -0.002073315205052495, -0.011783773079514503, 0.0019699311815202236, -0.021759560331702232, 0.03995494544506073, -0.08176176249980927, -0.021679487079381943, 0.02270634099841118, 0.0076953573152422905, -0.023038016632199287, -0.010015430860221386, -0.01769440993666649, -0.052319955080747604, 0.020594412460923195, 0.01181572675704956, -0.0010429638205096126, -0.09111865609884262, -0.03735555708408356, 0.03975958004593849, -0.025767551735043526, -0.017892740666866302, -0.013693236745893955, -0.04177809879183769, 0.037846602499485016, -0.000503852847032249, 0.003984972834587097, 0.01646631769835949, -0.02084323763847351, 0.0017782850190997124, -0.05626733601093292, 0.03559596464037895, 0.03414253517985344, -0.013176728039979935, -0.033519044518470764, 0.012410738505423069, -0.01990559697151184, -0.030286937952041626, 0.04823066666722298, -0.024392683058977127, 0.013639654964208603, -0.011216950602829456, 0.06390798091888428, -0.010441574268043041, -0.05764113366603851, 0.03700361028313637, -0.004220709670335054, -0.014543959870934486, -0.03342333436012268, -0.010666605085134506, 0.00009339667303720489, -0.007382309529930353, 0.005905764177441597, -0.016367269679903984, 0.004524953663349152, -0.009457956999540329, -0.004305381327867508, 0.019797546789050102, 0.015021245926618576, -0.023357905447483063, 0.038380611687898636, -0.008603531867265701, 0.023089533671736717, 0.03749701753258705, 0.014779911376535892, -0.04456853121519089, 0.002893779193982482, -0.026469632983207703, -0.025396406650543213, -0.016258908435702324, 0.00427347281947732, -0.013815635815262794, -0.05568099021911621, 0.02866561897099018, 0.027285318821668625, -0.03960967808961868, -0.0001274024834856391, 0.018970642238855362, 0.0055607897229492664, 0.03694263845682144, 0.003770181443542242, 0.013045684434473515, 0.06474117934703827, -0.026082569733262062, 0.03391461446881294, 0.025013742968440056, 0.06602223962545395, 0.01903248205780983, -0.006990463938564062, 0.03236415237188339, 0.00363426236435771, 0.024724269285798073, -0.011918785981833935, 0.019732454791665077, -0.03367515653371811, -0.027262503281235695, 0.0024812566116452217, -0.0024999429006129503, 0.02289656735956669, -0.04133262857794762, -0.018864300101995468, 0.04505511745810509, -0.041688259690999985, -0.026137053966522217, -0.01493115909397602, 0.035752780735492706, -0.011121242307126522, -0.027783701196312904, -0.0004715020477306098, 0.01802997663617134, 0.0035322371404618025, 0.004161510616540909, -0.022252386435866356, -0.03150726854801178, 0.020996475592255592, -0.01992151141166687, 0.019489090889692307, -0.012653057463467121, -0.0004793764092028141, -0.012813176028430462, -0.029818721115589142, -0.03958342596888542, -0.04608969762921333, 0.0402565561234951, 0.044584136456251144, 0.0348982997238636, -0.03726844862103462, -0.018507862463593483, -0.0027216800954192877, 0.05566547065973282, -0.08659981191158295, -0.016574308276176453, -0.033523377031087875, 0.023091306909918785, -0.015278429724276066, -0.02407270297408104 ]
<p>I am trying to find the best way to visualize the following data:</p> <p>I have values for 3 different times/dates, each time/date has the same 20 species. For each species I have the average height and standard deviation (that was obtained from n observations). I don't have the observations from where the average and standard deviation was obtained.</p> <p>This is how the data looks like. Species are numerated from 1 to 20.</p> <pre><code>t1 = cbind(seq(1,20,1),runif(20,0.5,5.0),runif(20,0,1.0)) t2 = cbind(seq(1,20,1),runif(20,0.9,6.0),runif(20,0.2,1.5)) t3 = cbind(seq(1,20,1),runif(20,0.1,8.5),runif(20,0.4,1.0)) </code></pre> <p>Can anyone give any advice on what would be the best plot/graphic to use? I want to show the evolution of the average and standard deviation in time, however I don't want to do a line plot, and for a heat map I have a small dataset.</p>
73,525
[ -0.04411288723349571, -0.013608675450086594, -0.002669399604201317, 0.031932126730680466, 0.031811367720365524, -0.001447120332159102, 0.006536488886922598, -0.016875406727194786, 0.0014278682647272944, -0.04288911446928978, 0.043691765516996384, 0.06726030260324478, 0.06112265586853027, 0.03639386221766472, 0.0544854961335659, -0.03823591768741608, -0.0017241435125470161, -0.02298877015709877, -0.016021639108657837, -0.03623382747173309, 0.008587685413658619, 0.00264742667786777, -0.00464005209505558, -0.026188742369413376, -0.0296406839042902, 0.0707017034292221, 0.03445598855614662, 0.0067461756989359856, -0.0055176811292767525, 0.05788800120353699, -0.0979909673333168, -0.06419748812913895, 0.014234280213713646, 0.016059013083577156, 0.005509206559509039, -0.008119537495076656, 0.0022289068438112736, -0.040201060473918915, -0.02171388827264309, 0.006266024429351091, -0.02138211950659752, -0.007390502840280533, -0.0027638643514364958, 0.01000761054456234, -0.012507962994277477, 0.04317282885313034, 0.01848970353603363, 0.0032666835468262434, 0.04603520780801773, -0.03478822857141495, 0.08398683369159698, -0.00030679002520628273, 0.027340039610862732, 0.00861696619540453, -0.020621957257390022, 0.030902745202183723, 0.014105934649705887, 0.034701600670814514, 0.00935138389468193, -0.051318876445293427, 0.013429660350084305, -0.028180096298456192, -0.00046677934005856514, 0.009701856411993504, -0.02548259310424328, 0.023679282516241074, -0.024131184443831444, -0.011808812618255615, 0.036724381148815155, -0.032466545701026917, -0.0004526652046479285, 0.025905752554535866, 0.054217126220464706, -0.0023162218276411295, -0.0014774255687370896, -0.027410464361310005, 0.021703239530324936, -0.005713702645152807, 0.06915014237165451, 0.023121977224946022, 0.011435061693191528, 0.03699316829442978, -0.0006756092770956457, 0.047699376940727234, -0.0009906580671668053, 0.019841793924570084, 0.07112708687782288, -0.02555762231349945, 0.025673741474747658, 0.03327183797955513, -0.005543394014239311, 0.019838852807879448, 0.059707507491111755, 0.04064873233437538, -0.03306525573134422, 0.03910345584154129, 0.01678653620183468, 0.029125327244400978, 0.016056692227721214, -0.02309100516140461, -0.011814531870186329, -0.037809908390045166, 0.003098619170486927, 0.04573175683617592, -0.01190674863755703, 0.023083632811903954, -0.033767446875572205, -0.030802369117736816, -0.002383324783295393, -0.009486537426710129, -0.008700127713382244, 0.0076059033162891865, -0.009517168626189232, -0.01232130080461502, 0.000511186895892024, -0.029710333794355392, 0.029751257970929146, 0.02668842114508152, 0.043259862810373306, 0.05364876240491867, -0.00019376847194507718, -0.017483370378613472, 0.034635938704013824, -0.0024068572092801332, -0.06650073081254959, 0.02481566183269024, 0.012146011926233768, -0.008805379271507263, -0.0324573889374733, 0.05743171647191048, -0.03899863734841347, -0.008050793781876564, 0.06127573922276497, -0.046896129846572876, 0.017049338668584824, -0.03952018544077873, -0.06682358682155609, -0.05269273370504379, 0.030022069811820984, -0.054575975984334946, 0.01313313003629446, -0.043522030115127563, 0.03049294464290142, 0.04019905999302864, 0.017508937045931816, 0.00370014482177794, 0.01284865289926529, -0.008003694005310535, 0.06245563551783562, -0.002174151362851262, -0.012154952622950077, -0.006565942894667387, 0.0024049882777035236, -0.03574053943157196, -0.004789445083588362, -0.061252497136592865, -0.007531443610787392, 0.03595526143908501, 0.019101029261946678, -0.00014298253518063575, 0.02411183901131153, -0.01866903342306614, 0.03127546235918999, 0.00891127996146679, -0.004370834678411484, -0.025313060730695724, 0.0900835245847702, 0.006495672278106213, 0.04910080507397652, -0.003012922592461109, 0.00022024648205842823, 0.008514647372066975, 0.014392368495464325, 0.021635284647345543, 0.02075699344277382, -0.022081710398197174, 0.02335759624838829, 0.00908769853413105, -0.016971487551927567, 0.05054999887943268, -0.0077132112346589565, -0.019014563411474228, -0.01984904706478119, -0.054452795535326004, 0.03758730739355087, 0.021973667666316032, -0.005445482674986124, -0.02121857739984989, 0.05638554319739342, -0.06511030346155167, -0.0383981354534626, -0.09634866565465927, 0.006469797808676958, 0.03564867749810219, -0.014120345935225487, -0.015121996402740479, 0.03151584044098854, 0.051555316895246506, 0.018314095214009285, 0.0009813607903197408, -0.024350089952349663, 0.009636374190449715, 0.045425016433000565, -0.055860813707113266, -0.01978447660803795, 0.03162819892168045, 0.03790600225329399, -0.0376022644340992, 0.010239600203931332, -0.05755612999200821, -0.013790691271424294, 0.0013759820722043514, -0.05975698307156563, -0.0035623095463961363, 0.009112441912293434, -0.02491367608308792, -0.01637493632733822, 0.028371740132570267, -0.04825471714138985, 0.029363274574279785, -0.030945993959903717, 0.048893433064222336, 0.04100260138511658, -0.006534283515065908, -0.0021000162232667208, -0.0036896050442010164, 0.03241017833352089, 0.025782043114304543, -0.026945505291223526, 0.016736293211579323, -0.03101995214819908, 0.015092608518898487, 0.0310826376080513, 0.05480479449033737, -0.016075994819402695, 0.011525670066475868, 0.03816378489136696, 0.01129489578306675, 0.013235841877758503, 0.022407716140151024, -0.02044498920440674, 0.004251280799508095, 0.004293289501219988, 0.005016064736992121, 0.035704005509614944, -0.002650233916938305, 0.03258415311574936, 0.021024050191044807, 0.03542860969901085, 0.023001568391919136, 0.011906369589269161, 0.03942983224987984, -0.024835124611854553, 0.010649025440216064, -0.02305195853114128, -0.03687477856874466, 0.037667494267225266, -0.022443069145083427, -0.03128201514482498, 0.005042730364948511, 0.005677381996065378, -0.03874689340591431, 0.005214094650000334, -0.018617073073983192, -0.029023487120866776, 0.042243797332048416, -0.025238526985049248, -0.01452817302197218, 0.02561354637145996, -0.012751528061926365, 0.0623127706348896, -0.03280143439769745, -0.01567029021680355, -0.06415960192680359, 0.010268601588904858, 0.017717748880386353, -0.017388883978128433, 0.012260870076715946, -0.03630524501204491, -0.05729725584387779, -0.012890385463833809, 0.029895765706896782, 0.031628090888261795, -0.021922430023550987, -0.06775430589914322, 0.02571498230099678, -0.022806769236922264, -0.055477697402238846, 0.029713094234466553, -0.00942294206470251, -0.02536599710583687, 0.05447785556316376, -0.0038878354243934155, -0.042533695697784424, -0.04635132849216461, -0.048883210867643356, 0.020634476095438004, -0.020913902670145035, -0.01913965493440628, 0.04584994167089462, -0.017633842304348946, -0.020157992839813232, 0.03879890963435173, -0.0657595545053482, -0.029745882377028465, -0.018350370228290558, 0.04051866754889488, 0.009781737811863422, 0.05485667660832405, -0.01298532821238041, 0.03133812174201012, -0.04305679351091385, -0.041613299399614334, -0.0697576180100441, -0.04838764667510986, 0.012216288596391678, 0.012064692564308643, 0.01773512177169323, -0.005805106833577156, -0.011846812441945076, 0.025064406916499138, 0.023929141461849213, -0.0712113156914711, -0.06279612332582474, -0.0017875895136967301, 0.011486878618597984, -0.024621056392788887, 0.03950415924191475, 0.008776675909757614, -0.00040314297075383365, -0.013900728896260262, -0.021500607952475548, 0.03012705221772194, 0.05112827196717262, -0.008144121617078781, -0.0036644437350332737, 0.03387027978897095, -0.025467734783887863, -0.015141953714191914, 0.029648495838046074, 0.046266715973615646, -0.019276795908808708, 0.027838880196213722, -0.018028000369668007, 0.013972457498311996, -0.0040442501194775105, -0.05706314370036125, 0.023788385093212128, 0.0007752404198981822, 0.040475133806467056, -0.03798612207174301, 0.01973193697631359, 0.023998916149139404, -0.002835775027051568, -0.01028985995799303, 0.036928195506334305, 0.04884495586156845, -0.021430527791380882, -0.0008889655000530183, 0.0636071041226387, 0.04713277518749237, -0.037883345037698746, -0.0076262266375124454, 0.009628046303987503, 0.004957230295985937, -0.02758035622537136, -0.03350507467985153, -0.012552033178508282, 0.05405233055353165, 0.032086607068777084, 0.023203564807772636, 0.023050181567668915, -0.030679548159241676, 0.047263745218515396, -0.05892343819141388, 0.01347245741635561, -0.019093388691544533, 0.05993468314409256, 0.04000240936875343, 0.04066787660121918, -0.026249060407280922, 0.020442089065909386, 0.034847769886255264, -0.026996150612831116, -0.04449461027979851, 0.04060593992471695, 0.00866072066128254, -0.004016717430204153, 0.01799234189093113, -0.016713371500372887, 0.011100524105131626, 0.00716292392462492, 0.05180944874882698, 0.028560787439346313, 0.019595568999648094, -0.042756326496601105, -0.021601470187306404, -0.028298359364271164, 0.025403419509530067, -0.05088464915752411, 0.01154279988259077, 0.05407619848847389, -0.011978798545897007, 0.03231281042098999, 0.023451032117009163, -0.012787997722625732, 0.004525342024862766, -0.0023051693569868803, -0.01979283057153225, 0.0003296574286650866, 0.011376626789569855, 0.023094352334737778, 0.023223845288157463, -0.025206726044416428, 0.028715945780277252, 0.01424560695886612, 0.05233413353562355, 0.00930212251842022, 0.03216313198208809, 0.03418797627091408, -0.0197555273771286, 0.028374450281262398, 0.018513748422265053, 0.016922635957598686, 0.01265009306371212, 0.009445857256650925, -0.015861500054597855, 0.015284286811947823, -0.04772909730672836, 0.005042992066591978, 0.04941871762275696, 0.008226180449128151, 0.0068161096423864365, -0.04482714459300041, -0.03677496314048767, -0.0316762737929821, -0.02393151819705963, 0.032503534108400345, 0.036729443818330765, 0.00446022255346179, 0.03438354656100273, 0.02419866994023323, 0.0038321574684232473, 0.009146026335656643, -0.008513734675943851, 0.021170085296034813, 0.08470989763736725, -0.0060421074740588665, -0.046061206609010696, 0.003821249585598707, 0.04148499295115471, 0.026620162650942802, 0.006048114039003849, -0.04477927088737488, -0.09073098003864288, -0.020472126081585884, 0.06558657437562943, 0.01659400388598442, -0.03495985269546509, -0.03144575282931328, -0.06036898493766785, -0.024638833478093147, 0.03739023581147194, -0.0451275035738945, -0.006473522167652845, -0.010453393682837486, -0.014315941371023655, -0.03915555402636528, 0.0009657013579271734, -0.03366100415587425, 0.0541217103600502, -0.02507138065993786, 0.034062713384628296, -0.021717390045523643, -0.002086307154968381, -0.010274549946188927, 0.034787606447935104, -0.0004239987174514681, 0.031078917905688286, -0.027218777686357498, -0.022692715749144554, 0.041637104004621506, 0.03394443541765213, 0.020404964685440063, -0.02221197634935379, 0.01444820687174797, -0.008584648370742798, -0.014082588255405426, 0.05973239615559578, 0.005203098990023136, -0.0008172639645636082, 0.022019941359758377, 0.005626892205327749, 0.004523908719420433, -0.020576609298586845, -0.02229410596191883, 0.03311112895607948, 0.023542646318674088, -0.003381401300430298, 0.0265977680683136, 0.04839368909597397, 0.01877463050186634, 0.03691309317946434, -0.0475086085498333, 0.03536585718393326, -0.007512024603784084, -0.023451652377843857, -0.06996458768844604, -0.03351955488324165, -0.0378391295671463, 0.0010706434259191155, -0.026784256100654602, -0.0009447877528145909, -0.05497734248638153, 0.008380105718970299, 0.03949308767914772, 0.03336194530129433, 0.01275833323597908, -0.04277165234088898, 0.016313811764121056, -0.01859361119568348, 0.008940431289374828, -0.02822953835129738, 0.015064872801303864, -0.03211798518896103, -0.01060143206268549, 0.01930951327085495, -0.03177591413259506, 0.02053101360797882, -0.015170248225331306, -0.02346915565431118, -0.005166369490325451, -0.0490286685526371, 0.017513133585453033, -0.007721740752458572, 0.056805964559316635, 0.02799151837825775, -0.051851797848939896, 0.018436534330248833, -0.0004690937348641455, 0.004067896865308285, -0.009860364720225334, -0.08410105109214783, 0.06174410507082939, -0.02565835416316986, -0.006913468707352877, -0.04891277104616165, -0.06270671635866165, 0.008661100640892982, 0.011396831832826138, -0.04160689562559128, -0.029341544955968857, -0.019587518647313118, -0.0244761910289526, 0.01593983918428421, -0.00027944642351940274, -0.00024114477855619043, 0.001092721475288272, -0.01031456608325243, 0.0033383655827492476, 0.017019139602780342, 0.03941948339343071, -0.0005809105932712555, 0.014531747438013554, -0.005228063557296991, 0.004806167911738157, -0.03228837624192238, -0.008343463763594627, 0.004851371515542269, -0.010878171771764755, 0.01584889180958271, -0.03385550156235695, 0.03479114547371864, 0.05283728614449501, -0.02248530648648739, -0.010456517338752747, 0.01548165362328291, 0.012687120586633682, -0.011407099664211273, -0.04665539413690567, 0.04323986545205116, -0.04338682070374489, -0.0028458016458898783, -0.03255191817879677, -0.00584765337407589, 0.008488819003105164, -0.03508840873837471, -0.004205385223031044, 0.01257379911839962, -0.021535439416766167, 0.025073595345020294, 0.04783717542886734, -0.007216725964099169, -0.00627301586791873, -0.02897541970014572, -0.027922943234443665, 0.03125087171792984, 0.0060967872850596905, 0.003672720631584525, 0.01373401191085577, 0.0009172524441964924, -0.002200839575380087, 0.027498630806803703, -0.034445393830537796, 0.019105231389403343, 0.053508955985307693, -0.01974361576139927, 0.033726662397384644, 0.029992420226335526, 0.03817661479115486, 0.035389937460422516, -0.036271363496780396, -0.013693359680473804, -0.0024265011306852102, 0.0025056167505681515, 0.0764257162809372, -0.013204425573348999, 0.007986235432326794, 0.0379340685904026, 0.033562954515218735, 0.008500915952026844, 0.057484228163957596, 0.004612067248672247, -0.025125054642558098, 0.026536723598837852, -0.013547149486839771, -0.045969851315021515, -0.002205917611718178, -0.03543492406606674, 0.06724373996257782, -0.03730843961238861, -0.014991778880357742, 0.006435824558138847, 0.027116218581795692, -0.04781803861260414, -0.06353730708360672, 0.0060953060165047646, -0.0394817553460598, -0.024447361007332802, 0.028930772095918655, -0.003956900909543037, 0.0037405153270810843, 0.023905569687485695, 0.04523150250315666, -0.03775829076766968, -0.0038925898261368275, -0.033552996814250946, -0.053134556859731674, -0.03471743315458298, -0.006625543348491192, -0.02506655640900135, 0.0651378482580185, 0.006809688173234463, -0.017761310562491417, 0.011471318081021309, -0.03192964568734169, -0.0038638347759842873, -0.009894121438264847, 0.041929226368665695, 0.03365571051836014, 0.05999111011624336, 0.014569188468158245, -0.027482153847813606, 0.017184967175126076, 0.008961010724306107, 0.12110445648431778, 0.07630942016839981, 0.04165475815534592, -0.04328087717294693, 0.0253086369484663, 0.018991777673363686, -0.03431073948740959, -0.024418778717517853, 0.024009667336940765, 0.033643271774053574, 0.04297880828380585, 0.04015084356069565, 0.04792574793100357, 0.020793737843632698, -0.016217434778809547, 0.0252084881067276, -0.020531250163912773, 0.003162648994475603, -0.01609976775944233, 0.01769828610122204, -0.0073915524408221245, -0.015663351863622665, -0.10683099925518036, -0.0031452334951609373, 0.01436848845332861, -0.003616528119891882, -0.023145116865634918, -0.023014403879642487, -0.006141869351267815, 0.020739376544952393, -0.010352293960750103, -0.0028863807674497366, 0.018627401441335678, 0.010566376149654388, -0.03972237929701805, -0.01400977186858654, 0.004716384224593639, -0.0349336601793766, 0.02067437767982483, 0.03834092617034912, 0.029053669422864914, -0.007340246811509132, -0.02856207825243473, 0.009391007013618946, -0.011868953704833984, -0.04920501261949539, -0.04993823915719986, 0.00449700653553009, -0.026721421629190445, -0.009453888982534409, -0.006430009845644236, 0.024987036362290382, 0.029122918844223022, -0.0217686016112566, 0.02076525054872036, -0.008301530964672565, 0.03740314394235611, 0.008851461112499237, 0.002296125516295433, -0.03138835355639458, 0.002975833835080266, -0.028667695820331573, 0.03935549408197403, 0.035262223333120346, -0.00707489438354969, -0.015471191145479679, -0.02618531882762909, 0.05770961195230484, -0.02299882099032402, 0.007343022618442774, 0.023339755833148956, -0.005188511684536934, -0.02339906059205532, 0.008799856528639793, 0.016793347895145416, 0.027156295254826546, -0.014850099571049213, 0.01944131776690483, -0.040204085409641266, 0.01644815504550934, -0.025613145902752876, 0.02008487656712532, 0.014527946710586548, -0.007565689273178577, -0.013638321310281754, 0.017187893390655518, 0.02770572528243065, 0.01925843395292759, 0.02431247942149639, 0.03156803920865059, -0.014962035231292248, 0.06832235306501389, 0.029040321707725525, -0.048602160066366196, -0.002100679324939847, 0.025944894179701805, -0.029375901445746422, -0.007750866934657097, -0.017055124044418335, 0.08576978743076324, 0.003579522483050823, 0.015965376049280167, -0.02262911945581436, 0.04208109900355339, 0.019470425322651863, -0.0028002802282571793, 0.006171120330691338, -0.06310972571372986, 0.041315797716379166, -0.018676353618502617, -0.03999418765306473, -0.02714926190674305, -0.018944159150123596, -0.020542163401842117, -0.025821564719080925, -0.032606031745672226, -0.0030520332511514425, -0.010876036249101162, 0.03512704372406006, -0.006029665470123291, 0.01801712065935135, -0.026510855183005333, 0.027164870873093605, -0.0532449409365654, -0.027699580416083336, -0.0160661730915308, 0.0027544479817152023, -0.0267703365534544, 0.05544999614357948, -0.044877853244543076, -0.018465673550963402, 0.02949926257133484, -0.016571534797549248, 0.015168651938438416, -0.027763240039348602, 0.00030348135624080896, 0.018136603757739067, 0.027098406106233597, 0.020735517144203186, -0.003417826956138015, 0.0021796945948153734, -0.04586249962449074, -0.0427645780146122, -0.044055789709091187, 0.00019390980014577508, 0.010858569294214249, -0.02594362571835518, -0.0158001147210598, -0.009280999191105366, 0.036934737116098404, -0.01815151236951351, -0.018885990604758263, -0.019466549158096313, -0.00949805323034525, -0.013820772990584373, 0.012701031751930714, -0.003962700720876455, -0.00500514917075634, -0.002279864391312003, 0.0069957394152879715, 0.03742007166147232, -0.03825812414288521, -0.006647743750363588, -0.00021754359477199614, -0.03306800127029419, 0.005549909546971321, -0.023960627615451813, -0.03561019524931908, 0.06387010216712952, 0.05550730973482132, -0.062092769891023636, 0.015532313846051693, -0.044692255556583405, 0.0025902441702783108, -0.06292291730642319, 0.0049117752350866795, 0.009852692484855652, -0.015403276309370995, 0.013780945912003517, -0.07605895400047302, -0.0014388237614184618, 0.016527490690350533, -0.027979617938399315, 0.030594903975725174, -0.02065824344754219, -0.0001971081946976483, 0.000876741367392242, 0.002277697203680873, 0.013430069200694561, 0.016346421092748642, 0.04518186300992966, 0.04274449124932289, 0.05023535341024399, 0.020573284476995468, 0.020789137110114098, -0.014092682860791683, -0.015955019742250443, 0.002726240549236536, 0.04807436466217041, -0.08424912393093109, 0.020965689793229103, -0.01201805379241705, 0.008101622574031353, 0.011363034136593342, -0.01858619786798954, 0.04430089145898819, 0.014576488174498081, -0.01489228755235672, -0.031424541026353836, 0.0640036091208458, 0.012643951922655106, -0.030363596975803375, -0.026041675359010696, 0.014081099070608616, 0.0058086528442800045, -0.02611258439719677, -0.019670046865940094, 0.029797732830047607, 0.03896784782409668, 0.000948144297581166, -0.0546589195728302, -0.01979098469018936, 0.00840342789888382, -0.04225535690784454, -0.030895141884684563, -0.027972392737865448, 0.029695147648453712, -0.003116213483735919, -0.011399375274777412, -0.02211103029549122, 0.009176180697977543, 0.017064768821001053, -0.010281211696565151, 0.010420164093375206, 0.016723446547985077, -0.007962191477417946, -0.04802464321255684, -0.05250720679759979, 0.011102506890892982, -0.004256145562976599, -0.030565567314624786, -0.01987164281308651, -0.022918077185750008, 0.01673237979412079, -0.023682186380028725, 0.004468163941055536, -0.03893423452973366, 0.05962850898504257, 0.011529655195772648, 0.015904609113931656, 0.06191486492753029, 0.010135767981410027, 0.01888984814286232, -0.06533046066761017, 0.061156995594501495, -0.000368965178495273, 0.024328647181391716, -0.03330831229686737, 0.0010305229807272553, -0.044082920998334885, 0.04389587417244911, 0.039393190294504166, 0.010279531590640545, 0.022436054423451424, -0.004180935677140951, 0.05538914352655411, 0.01600981317460537, -0.05082026869058609, 0.018890831619501114, 0.01593179814517498, -0.0064247976988554, -0.0022333385422825813, -0.0014306898228824139, 0.04648810625076294, -0.002999101998284459, 0.013892404735088348, -0.020341049879789352, 0.006774429231882095, 0.020327916368842125, -0.0155939981341362, -0.009952843189239502, -0.005849000066518784, -0.09296750277280807, 0.027284102514386177, 0.01315924059599638, -0.031326573342084885, 0.03452640771865845, -0.0033156753052026033, -0.024473262950778008, 0.02280091866850853, -0.031842950731515884, -0.004592773038893938, -0.005557063966989517, -0.01951373741030693, -0.009318700060248375, -0.12381630390882492, 0.01778983511030674, -0.0040978179313242435, -0.025339612737298012, -0.0069145685993134975, 0.0009424479212611914, -0.021930338814854622, 0.020025424659252167, -0.03550920635461807, 0.025197524577379227, -0.011769667267799377, 0.009086927399039268, 0.001574989059008658, -0.0031851078383624554, -0.003542240709066391, 0.0021996009163558483, 0.013395356014370918, -0.006852497346699238, -0.04637976363301277, 0.037507303059101105, -0.007449278607964516, 0.06294447928667068, -0.014133390970528126, -0.020641956478357315, 0.028696084395051003, 0.007849904708564281, 0.0008073978242464364, -0.0019640219397842884, 0.0029374391306191683, 0.0379154235124588, -0.022918596863746643, 0.0009519250015728176, -0.030559295788407326, -0.05154120549559593, -0.053934965282678604, 0.0005432373727671802, 0.008982758037745953, 0.055684857070446014, -0.006911233998835087, 0.04529869928956032, 0.0007610117318108678, 0.013383332639932632, 0.03817308321595192, 0.010496511124074459, 0.048659488558769226, -0.04461954906582832, 0.017235057428479195, -0.0016384426271542907, 0.00835992582142353, -0.015587156638503075, 0.008374573662877083, 0.015151916071772575, 0.0016120262444019318, 0.014285169541835785, -0.03359609842300415, -0.005023002624511719, 0.009286345914006233, -0.00609451811760664, -0.04423247650265694, -0.009881390258669853, -0.015489315614104271, 0.009237068705260754, 0.03713688626885414, -0.02346714958548546 ]
<p>If the best linear approximation (using least squares) of my data points is the line $y=mx+b$, how can I calculate the approximation error? If I compute standard deviation of differences between observations and predictions $e_i=real(x_i)-(mx_i+b)$, can I later say that a real (but not observed) value $y_r=real(x_0)$ belongs to the interval $[y_p-\sigma, y_p+\sigma]$ ($y_p=mx_0+b$) with probability ~68%, assuming normal distribution?</p> <p>To clarify:</p> <p>I made observations regarding a function $f(x)$ by evaluating it a some points $x_i$. I fit these observations to a line $l(x)=mx+b$. For $x_0$ that I did not observe, I'd like to know how big can $f(x_0)-l(x_0)$ be. Using the method above, is it correct to say that $f(x_0) \in [l(x_0)-\sigma, l(x_0)+\sigma]$ with prob. ~68%?</p>
73,526
[ -0.0011009620502591133, -0.005167781375348568, -0.03413430601358414, 0.011543824337422848, 0.014749661087989807, 0.05740981176495552, 0.008252364583313465, -0.03319112956523895, -0.003646548604592681, -0.000647490902338177, 0.004260851535946131, -0.004358505364507437, 0.049744006246328354, 0.039337001740932465, 0.017284883186221123, -0.007850821129977703, -0.03776026889681816, 0.02993367798626423, -0.023033328354358673, -0.006521970499306917, 0.01614685170352459, 0.03851385787129402, 0.03604536131024361, -0.01665637455880642, -0.058695826679468155, 0.009423382580280304, 0.012212326750159264, 0.0003715544880833477, 0.003934845328330994, 0.06483234465122223, -0.019333545118570328, -0.037972189486026764, -0.007077405229210854, 0.00819930899888277, 0.057920731604099274, 0.04171464592218399, -0.028589941561222076, -0.012386225163936615, 0.008470517583191395, 0.0338858962059021, -0.052158623933792114, -0.005652350373566151, 0.04285157471895218, 0.035241611301898956, 0.027020348235964775, 0.009119759313762188, -0.015415019355714321, -0.0819525346159935, 0.0323946438729763, -0.019421933218836784, 0.08035984635353088, -0.03174204379320145, 0.024046573787927628, 0.03144010156393051, -0.003072534454986453, -0.030665189027786255, 0.030991697683930397, 0.06563431769609451, -0.012020197696983814, -0.016678625717759132, 0.0031488891690969467, -0.01953248120844364, 0.004041869658976793, 0.014718343503773212, -0.01991927996277809, 0.0013170520542189479, -0.026849357411265373, -0.024365738034248352, 0.03697656840085983, 0.004539037588983774, -0.032140012830495834, 0.03880421072244644, 0.006289432756602764, 0.0037797121331095695, 0.034178417176008224, -0.018012570217251778, 0.03089616261422634, 0.02168165147304535, 0.03140519559383392, 0.016167934983968735, 0.025449663400650024, 0.009576898068189621, 0.05472785606980324, 0.017022063955664635, 0.03970637172460556, -0.010533466935157776, 0.06405118852853775, 0.0031894100829958916, 0.03660278022289276, 0.02609550766646862, 0.021079400554299355, 0.03896894305944443, 0.04793955385684967, -0.024921007454395294, -0.05040439963340759, 0.006906308699399233, -0.004227294120937586, 0.02523905225098133, 0.036870021373033524, -0.046902913600206375, -0.0038823403883725405, -0.0916539654135704, 0.023122821003198624, 0.059861209243535995, 0.02030402421951294, -0.04760786518454552, 0.009962369687855244, 0.009027360938489437, 0.024887286126613617, -0.045170750468969345, 0.005646624136716127, 0.019164899364113808, 0.03071470558643341, 0.02970999665558338, 0.033050160855054855, -0.00959338154643774, -0.020839933305978775, -0.003052328946068883, 0.024149473756551743, 0.06769197434186935, 0.04234158247709274, -0.02641560696065426, 0.02814529463648796, -0.0017037622164934874, -0.019355032593011856, 0.033497635275125504, 0.013494240120053291, -0.024322370067238808, -0.05152718722820282, 0.004932378884404898, 0.02945167012512684, -0.044275037944316864, 0.013968994840979576, 0.013279632665216923, 0.028297238051891327, 0.009399314410984516, -0.07973536849021912, -0.05098811537027359, 0.009327903389930725, 0.0014768660767003894, 0.015229342505335808, -0.0551159493625164, -0.032164253294467926, 0.03892873600125313, 0.032439813017845154, 0.033792704343795776, 0.02396664023399353, 0.02006431668996811, 0.026203252375125885, -0.013808119110763073, -0.028935106471180916, 0.0019317844416946173, -0.011808088980615139, -0.05549966171383858, -0.03020472452044487, -0.04898443818092346, 0.0481419637799263, 0.012798205949366093, -0.004504369106143713, -0.052133504301309586, 0.036483701318502426, -0.029978055506944656, -0.0066658626310527325, 0.018187155947089195, -0.008438191376626492, -0.014157782308757305, 0.06452275067567825, 0.02490999922156334, 0.0064262025989592075, 0.00931065995246172, 0.0020666231866925955, 0.007837371900677681, 0.027300238609313965, 0.03707422316074371, 0.04165813699364662, -0.036043617874383926, -0.03099026158452034, -0.04392072930932045, 0.023970654234290123, 0.02490694262087345, -0.0664399266242981, -0.01198924332857132, -0.015464123338460922, 0.013852938078343868, 0.03769329562783241, 0.07027602195739746, 0.007366009056568146, -0.002696451498195529, 0.05291344225406647, -0.060895416885614395, -0.016736675053834915, -0.060842499136924744, 0.01210868265479803, -0.005181330256164074, -0.030941246077418327, -0.009710926562547684, 0.004420086275786161, 0.002287240233272314, -0.026022225618362427, 0.004847044125199318, 0.009537158533930779, 0.0015073948306962848, 0.053542252629995346, -0.03308117017149925, 0.028090616688132286, 0.06052082031965256, 0.024010680615901947, -0.012615242972970009, 0.043970491737127304, -0.06535939872264862, -0.037535473704338074, 0.02322223410010338, -0.029447458684444427, 0.01723444275557995, 0.003839584067463875, -0.026382215321063995, -0.028942815959453583, -0.02487737499177456, 0.00860022846609354, 0.04029727727174759, -0.03828108683228493, 0.021541081368923187, 0.084626704454422, 0.034809865057468414, -0.0198522936552763, 0.008672824129462242, 0.012936786748468876, -0.005828086286783218, 0.0065757036209106445, -0.030360130593180656, -0.053025711327791214, -0.010605736635625362, 0.01303930301219225, 0.032472532242536545, -0.03997538611292839, -0.003046476049348712, 0.04660524055361748, -0.0036388097796589136, 0.009079555980861187, 0.015357984229922295, -0.02869274839758873, -0.018987175077199936, 0.006410527974367142, 0.0028976958710700274, 0.011815160512924194, 0.0022532111033797264, -0.012115778401494026, 0.03821008279919624, 0.021114738658070564, -0.006157954689115286, 0.028817588463425636, 0.03455541282892227, -0.008067628368735313, 0.012739201076328754, -0.008944343775510788, -0.004713634494692087, 0.043667420744895935, -0.036925770342350006, 0.01576497219502926, 0.03147268295288086, -0.028563452884554863, -0.001833129208534956, 0.004371299408376217, -0.007538767531514168, 0.023590650409460068, 0.012177393771708012, -0.03878282755613327, -0.02480630949139595, 0.02460341900587082, -0.035145774483680725, -0.004841791000217199, -0.028285972774028778, -0.0005263529601506889, -0.003291303990408778, -0.0037774695083498955, 0.029574694111943245, 0.017533017322421074, 0.012278757058084011, -0.026415716856718063, -0.020725155249238014, -0.010881188325583935, -0.023597722873091698, 0.027501143515110016, 0.013306163251399994, -0.02250690758228302, 0.006001135800033808, -0.03657118231058121, -0.04315705597400665, -0.0051276348531246185, -0.000044437671022024006, 0.004324053414165974, 0.04328812286257744, 0.0016069515841081738, -0.03510848432779312, -0.00519288657233119, -0.04916072636842728, -0.01830323413014412, 0.03294285759329796, -0.03921132907271385, 0.01709195040166378, -0.02804253250360489, -0.03051387146115303, 0.03539198637008667, -0.017289409413933754, -0.019128747284412384, -0.02477855794131756, 0.018826361745595932, -0.019557422026991844, 0.011762307025492191, 0.014402126893401146, -0.005756159778684378, 0.01115601509809494, -0.009222476743161678, -0.06504698842763901, -0.04844396933913231, 0.0038377477321773767, -0.011658401228487492, 0.001394971157424152, 0.0019704042933881283, -0.009981118142604828, 0.09079808741807938, 0.019723597913980484, -0.019474897533655167, -0.0033696896862238646, 0.03003128245472908, -0.007044502999633551, -0.016668563708662987, 0.016403015702962875, 0.005869003944098949, -0.0053335390985012054, 0.036991748958826065, -0.011194474063813686, 0.020407263189554214, 0.05782067030668259, 0.013018312864005566, 0.044129885733127594, -0.01803424023091793, -0.04776059091091156, -0.0009852871298789978, 0.051598384976387024, 0.0038318855222314596, -0.016789894551038742, 0.021232910454273224, 0.008276430889964104, 0.03149036318063736, 0.05932394042611122, -0.05665650591254234, 0.012789616361260414, 0.004526802804321051, 0.028384767472743988, -0.036996155977249146, 0.04647116735577583, 0.012079308740794659, -0.02399706467986107, 0.007074172608554363, 0.0037054824642837048, 0.027538664638996124, -0.011434252373874187, 0.006005620118230581, 0.04544252157211304, 0.067299485206604, 0.008017719723284245, -0.05177765712141991, -0.012085579335689545, -0.00773624237626791, 0.0024226834066212177, -0.03430972248315811, -0.036559805274009705, 0.044917769730091095, 0.06395512074232101, -0.022334426641464233, -0.026705032214522362, -0.017795715481042862, -0.001262466423213482, -0.06361164897680283, -0.01079938467592001, -0.01815258525311947, 0.04654569923877716, 0.008391314186155796, 0.0178217776119709, -0.013829769566655159, -0.05170559138059616, 0.038532376289367676, 0.020038386806845665, -0.042313434183597565, 0.0629304051399231, -0.0034272312186658382, -0.039802435785532, -0.001635308493860066, -0.04017002135515213, 0.041344162076711655, -0.03887709230184555, 0.02297862619161606, -0.022447217255830765, 0.011404399760067463, -0.03747854009270668, -0.03661924600601196, -0.011832963675260544, -0.01453661173582077, -0.02301385998725891, 0.007578243501484394, -0.004855350125581026, -0.04946861416101456, 0.012044311501085758, 0.025674832984805107, -0.02014605700969696, -0.02539598010480404, -0.04168853163719177, 0.024374352768063545, 0.004990254063159227, 0.05419401079416275, 0.03481561690568924, 0.024674249812960625, -0.016408739611506462, 0.022713597863912582, 0.013824465684592724, 0.04553065076470375, 0.036150455474853516, -0.030393894761800766, -0.02156229130923748, -0.037333227694034576, 0.011580529622733593, 0.018203526735305786, 0.01702328771352768, -0.020577700808644295, -0.0001829079701565206, 0.06768456846475601, 0.0011153740342706442, -0.01515272632241249, 0.01676371693611145, 0.04652458801865578, -0.0003054849221371114, 0.0332774892449379, -0.05150354653596878, -0.019702833145856857, -0.019071752205491066, -0.015353036113083363, 0.01964074932038784, 0.004825865384191275, 0.012925763614475727, -0.014383361674845219, 0.049037884920835495, 0.0386512391269207, -0.02986978366971016, 0.0044303941540420055, 0.03555482253432274, 0.037755630910396576, 0.002926825312897563, -0.008048337884247303, 0.037785083055496216, 0.04217040166258812, 0.06981731206178665, 0.018146516755223274, 0.029118986800312996, -0.0776968002319336, -0.007037543226033449, 0.01655389554798603, 0.03084573522210121, -0.004130716435611248, 0.0035277390852570534, -0.03043850138783455, 0.0077201793901622295, 0.05610203742980957, 0.004607297480106354, -0.007146230898797512, -0.03586823120713234, 0.029303420335054398, -0.04232011362910271, -0.02440495789051056, -0.04792523756623268, -0.016151651740074158, -0.010516885668039322, 0.028250262141227722, -0.056018367409706116, -0.02580484189093113, -0.027701012790203094, -0.001312263892032206, 0.05724353715777397, 0.08015283942222595, -0.0019377687713131309, -0.02477094531059265, -0.014512155205011368, 0.021638352423906326, -0.01712992787361145, -0.05352408066391945, 0.023524940013885498, 0.015383478254079819, -0.04754877835512161, 0.019971506670117378, 0.009282133542001247, -0.012298348359763622, 0.049439992755651474, 0.02811283990740776, -0.015922047197818756, -0.00432891771197319, -0.025511454790830612, 0.03799484670162201, 0.03329925239086151, 0.050285376608371735, 0.0512971393764019, 0.022044915705919266, 0.02614434063434601, 0.011188686825335026, -0.023314010351896286, 0.004649139940738678, 0.008603204973042011, -0.03782736510038376, -0.03191271796822548, -0.029390977695584297, 0.01345539465546608, 0.012342878617346287, 0.0046003577299416065, 0.025859227403998375, -0.030641084536910057, -0.011645439080893993, -0.016051873564720154, 0.036847058683633804, -0.011695806868374348, 0.024996206164360046, -0.02236756682395935, 0.055596642196178436, 0.022661441937088966, 0.006723640952259302, 0.010831307619810104, -0.018469978123903275, 0.017039267346262932, 0.0477171316742897, -0.03271367400884628, 0.018011366948485374, -0.03905376046895981, -0.008312184363603592, -0.005291904788464308, -0.046850770711898804, 0.035709597170352936, -0.004409222397953272, 0.008422328159213066, -0.0019040419720113277, -0.030011074617505074, -0.004662206396460533, -0.01866900362074375, 0.007233090233057737, 0.03636561706662178, -0.062008459120988846, 0.005487531889230013, -0.00612854678183794, 0.0032582806888967752, -0.07502208650112152, -0.048185430467128754, -0.01138030830770731, 0.0206468403339386, -0.053329747170209885, -0.00143888546153903, -0.008748713880777359, -0.007827130146324635, -0.008753253147006035, -0.03323841094970703, 0.02781706303358078, -0.022808877751231194, -0.04439838230609894, -0.032682765275239944, -0.00008299346518469974, 0.06974216550588608, -0.03463931754231453, 0.020710373297333717, 0.014711305499076843, -0.020503198727965355, -0.006554122548550367, -0.007543161977082491, 0.017636895179748535, -0.025805998593568802, 0.014784167520701885, -0.020010339096188545, -0.011410833336412907, 0.036500900983810425, 0.01234382949769497, -0.03423236683011055, 0.010070567019283772, 0.035153828561306, -0.006945245433598757, 0.025208553299307823, -0.008962119929492474, -0.005216275807470083, -0.00083804881433025, -0.02320106327533722, 0.013147743418812752, 0.007715448271483183, -0.00506961764767766, 0.04138999432325363, -0.009608469903469086, -0.03263995051383972, 0.0038707954809069633, 0.06256217509508133, 0.0024071899242699146, 0.001725008711218834, -0.0004207060264889151, -0.024422256276011467, 0.027104787528514862, 0.020040836185216904, 0.025573495775461197, 0.021418949589133263, 0.03421943262219429, -0.029130609706044197, -0.023984571918845177, -0.047335151582956314, 0.02196008712053299, 0.06167342886328697, -0.0019347561756148934, 0.03558811917901039, 0.04108070954680443, 0.020731065422296524, -0.022711485624313354, -0.041124165058135986, -0.03418242186307907, -0.017404716461896896, -0.013519617728888988, 0.06629586219787598, -0.019934164360165596, -0.03013831563293934, 0.02040356770157814, -0.008146312087774277, -0.01891518197953701, 0.025945916771888733, -0.0010163555853068829, 0.03935468941926956, 0.0034405130427330732, -0.014316428452730179, -0.023377161473035812, 0.01858046092092991, -0.0076578580774366856, -0.006067235022783279, -0.01328995544463396, -0.011123282834887505, 0.04239662364125252, 0.02616533450782299, 0.018401294946670532, -0.043232303112745285, -0.011539401486515999, -0.03190368413925171, -0.010417239740490913, -0.0217937882989645, -0.005549889989197254, 0.05282288417220116, 0.009213846176862717, -0.0004768316575791687, -0.0018641919596120715, 0.039253395050764084, 0.0029624407179653645, -0.10423595458269119, -0.026245690882205963, -0.029755206778645515, -0.057639434933662415, 0.014560806564986706, -0.006658514030277729, -0.06129750981926918, -0.00018107770301867276, -0.03796400502324104, 0.04552667215466499, -0.000718967872671783, 0.02002706378698349, -0.03626830130815506, 0.05740327388048172, -0.02180805429816246, 0.020942382514476776, 0.002828409895300865, -0.0003211757866665721, 0.09993889182806015, 0.0563097819685936, 0.014880594797432423, -0.06706944853067398, 0.025737768039107323, -0.039573654532432556, -0.020878316834568977, -0.02248969115316868, 0.007188457529991865, 0.006505535449832678, -0.019566573202610016, 0.02384292334318161, 0.024496659636497498, -0.001567835221067071, -0.01649918407201767, 0.04808538779616356, -0.055614933371543884, -0.02009223774075508, 0.03794796019792557, -0.009950977750122547, 0.026538526639342308, -0.023766212165355682, -0.004980313591659069, -0.006291409023106098, -0.0005163770401850343, -0.005569129250943661, -0.004657310899347067, -0.008716276846826077, 0.03048638440668583, -0.03706533461809158, -0.06059691309928894, 0.025012396275997162, 0.03503277152776718, 0.011889866553246975, -0.015873003751039505, 0.009899540804326534, 0.04195619001984596, -0.024717718362808228, 0.023770557716488838, 0.042483292520046234, -0.02540125697851181, 0.012457938864827156, 0.0013756618136540055, 0.029566895216703415, -0.032826974987983704, -0.0725264623761177, -0.08572014421224594, 0.04630705714225769, -0.010643611662089825, -0.029807744547724724, 0.014685845002532005, 0.013325443491339684, 0.007846968248486519, -0.06210242584347725, -0.003828790970146656, 0.021018754690885544, 0.022288506850600243, 0.006486809346824884, -0.015494770370423794, 0.002646805252879858, 0.036966003477573395, -0.002521314425393939, -0.01705748401582241, 0.05691564083099365, -0.02873719483613968, -0.01709076017141342, 0.043560586869716644, 0.01478520967066288, 0.026124851778149605, 0.023511206731200218, -0.0021199635230004787, -0.01638749986886978, -0.009542129933834076, -0.041614431887865067, -0.007848083972930908, -0.010555458255112171, 0.01899254508316517, 0.017846878618001938, 0.01932687498629093, -0.032503094524145126, -0.07371222972869873, 0.010999233461916447, -0.025737864896655083, 0.0121826883405447, -0.07529851049184799, -0.009878153912723064, 0.030013278126716614, 0.054138846695423126, 0.017332926392555237, -0.02628093957901001, 0.014353111386299133, 0.04668442904949188, -0.01183780375868082, -0.05808337405323982, -0.018515776842832565, -0.0005409750738181174, -0.02924535796046257, 0.006118044722825289, 0.017642108723521233, 0.08003497123718262, 0.011941736564040184, 0.062259241938591, 0.0003875281836371869, 0.04649808257818222, -0.020913541316986084, 0.01768597401678562, 0.002517284359782934, -0.0069994875229895115, -0.018368035554885864, 0.0037192334420979023, 0.010319073684513569, -0.04487128183245659, -0.0063536278903484344, -0.03314892575144768, -0.04542070999741554, -0.010341516695916653, -0.014289051294326782, -0.0386989489197731, 0.0013071075081825256, 0.01621962897479534, -0.04728461802005768, -0.028129184618592262, -0.02049422636628151, 0.009811965748667717, -0.0115384291857481, -0.02115982212126255, -0.010378682054579258, -0.045613694936037064, -0.0008120590355247259, -0.003138443222269416, 0.005516365636140108, 0.059005506336688995, 0.018155360594391823, 0.008836614899337292, -0.025548655539751053, 0.014759805984795094, 0.008312325924634933, 0.02084227278828621, -0.039362408220767975, -0.01081010140478611, 0.016056841239333153, -0.0670335441827774, -0.0349569097161293, 0.02600727044045925, 0.006835495587438345, 0.01413790788501501, 0.03221873193979263, 0.013320661149919033, -0.016876649111509323, 0.04836510494351387, 0.0055821603164076805, -0.0027732623275369406, -0.032929860055446625, 0.008864341303706169, 0.000043338892282918096, -0.004820646718144417, 0.008403485640883446, -0.007732823491096497, 0.049018681049346924, -0.002293664962053299, 0.015070686116814613, -0.017366046085953712, 0.03635682910680771, 0.02971574291586876, 0.018577035516500473, -0.0012717914069071412, -0.01645210012793541, -0.014394617639482021, 0.008867365308105946, 0.02928849682211876, -0.01624813862144947, 0.025964755564928055, 0.03847092017531395, 0.006015138700604439, -0.08991067856550217, 0.0031097852624952793, -0.008237335830926895, 0.0017286392394453287, 0.025668004527688026, -0.08110826462507248, 0.025164490565657616, 0.045186545699834824, -0.02062620408833027, -0.0398295558989048, -0.04861515760421753, 0.007696615997701883, -0.018319547176361084, 0.02502586878836155, -0.0418519526720047, 0.009348972700536251, 0.05488789081573486, 0.02175254561007023, 0.03513201326131821, 0.009909816086292267, -0.0013590498128905892, -0.024150187149643898, 0.027132593095302582, 0.006518261972814798, 0.020862849429249763, -0.08004188537597656, 0.0327218659222126, -0.056756969541311264, -0.05152839049696922, 0.035148993134498596, 0.007354072295129299, 0.04079198092222214, 0.0015775869833305478, 0.02896873839199543, -0.006718555931001902, 0.027797041460871696, 0.05041725933551788, -0.011985013261437416, -0.009827718138694763, -0.002154191257432103, 0.013085344806313515, 0.004336189478635788, -0.028606878593564034, 0.011458742432296276, 0.025992032140493393, -0.013086223974823952, -0.05117211863398552, 0.0046726129949092865, 0.007301356177777052, -0.01321712601929903, -0.016229931265115738, 0.02863374724984169, -0.012818499468266964, -0.050212517380714417, 0.055175814777612686, 0.001300803734920919, 0.031341321766376495, 0.055803604423999786, 0.05745996907353401, -0.06337819248437881, 0.005476104095578194, -0.013852489180862904, -0.05864845961332321, 0.003951482940465212, -0.023587996140122414, 0.006990934256464243, -0.10727837681770325, -0.013603503815829754, -0.017120037227869034, -0.02825053781270981, -0.02100781910121441, -0.021657796576619148, -0.037820469588041306, 0.043999120593070984, -0.017974840477108955, 0.039641156792640686, 0.035237934440374374, -0.021758457645773888, 0.0023767282254993916, -0.07975002378225327, 0.08116241544485092, 0.004399275407195091, -0.01584014669060707, -0.02177494764328003, -0.013527726754546165, -0.03842373937368393, -0.012653430923819542, 0.047498658299446106, 0.03720713034272194, 0.018461085855960846, 0.016363484784960747, 0.02953311614692211, 0.01211102120578289, -0.03402818739414215, 0.01991085894405842, -0.031152648851275444, -0.01864401437342167, 0.0031152721494436264, 0.003766497829928994, -0.005670786369591951, 0.006225047633051872, 0.03105606511235237, 0.015871603041887283, 0.027648046612739563, 0.031853578984737396, -0.049164917320013046, 0.03049326315522194, 0.038755569607019424, -0.028193438425660133, 0.037984296679496765, 0.008101451210677624, 0.013342631049454212, 0.024035027250647545, -0.0496196448802948, -0.05952984467148781, 0.012236934155225754, -0.002356021897867322, -0.02186059206724167, -0.013376187533140182, -0.012853429652750492, -0.05543946847319603, -0.02162138558924198, 0.01923997886478901, 0.04637644812464714, -0.016851356253027916, -0.006812123116105795, 0.04157411679625511, 0.0115654356777668, 0.026464411988854408, 0.012361164204776287, 0.03136706352233887, 0.014917148277163506, -0.004277336876839399, 0.022591127082705498, -0.04385552182793617, 0.03590065613389015, -0.025791460648179054, 0.02322768233716488, 0.047344304621219635, -0.01732560060918331, 0.015858091413974762, -0.0053320578299462795, 0.06750878691673279, -0.015195867046713829, -0.015667196363210678, 0.0035554859787225723, -0.0012339488603174686, -0.023939993232488632, -0.0020765059161931276, -0.03545534983277321, 0.06866534799337387, -0.039674438536167145, 0.006775326561182737, -0.05332905426621437, 0.0014457571087405086, -0.01197875291109085, -0.01913578435778618, -0.020021596923470497, -0.005591423250734806, 0.028589483350515366, 0.019281551241874695, -0.00754595035687089, 0.007022932171821594, 0.03655814379453659, -0.03795671835541725, 0.026498133316636086, -0.004653132054954767, -0.0006479654693976045, -0.035808514803647995, -0.01258199941366911, -0.00441993260756135, 0.005437821615487337, 0.018289804458618164, 0.0642213448882103, 0.021258627995848656, -0.0021511779632419348, -0.03745868429541588, -0.009203065186738968, 0.052244819700717926, -0.10222425311803818, -0.01619338057935238, -0.06071114167571068, 0.020283399149775505, -0.03932405263185501, -0.03696155920624733 ]
<p>The separate function of SVM is :<br> $wx+b=0$<br> The function distance of support vector to the separate plane is :<br> $|r| = wx_i+b$<br> And we can normalize the $w$, then the distance can be write as :<br> $\frac{|r|}{|w|} = \frac{wx_i+b}{|w|}$ </p> <p>And then approximate $|r|$ by 1. So we should get the maximal $\frac{1}{|w|}$.<br> Actuarially, I didn't understand <strong>why can the $|r|$ be approximated by 1. Because the $|r|$ is also include the factor $w$.</strong></p>
73,527
[ -0.04654096066951752, -0.020506273955106735, -0.010769265703856945, 0.010164064355194569, 0.005524313077330589, -0.024955421686172485, -0.01332555990666151, 0.006309471558779478, 0.03990074247121811, -0.036348216235637665, 0.0003562429337762296, 0.014749839901924133, 0.08018617331981659, 0.03216952830553055, 0.03670451417565346, -0.010779065079987049, -0.011718201451003551, -0.016381554305553436, -0.0045531936921179295, 0.004680925514549017, 0.0024991994723677635, 0.02091163769364357, 0.0219538863748312, -0.0447109192609787, -0.018538037315011024, 0.01673736982047558, -0.018062232062220573, -0.02005648799240589, 0.01762385666370392, 0.05710389092564583, -0.03938118740916252, -0.02669507823884487, 0.0007244230364449322, 0.034358009696006775, 0.021917525678873062, 0.017230164259672165, -0.04084070771932602, 0.012480787932872772, -0.013151922263205051, 0.02200101874768734, -0.005562789272516966, -0.004580187611281872, -0.007564251776784658, 0.057550396770238876, -0.02284921333193779, 0.04769304394721985, -0.004788473714143038, -0.0853734090924263, 0.01209722738713026, -0.048084888607263565, 0.07799319177865982, -0.011435410939157009, 0.032066162675619125, 0.0007208175375126302, 0.0023957325611263514, -0.034246135503053665, 0.041412170976400375, 0.05595577135682106, 0.025757329538464546, -0.044790178537368774, 0.01528194174170494, 0.0060762991197407246, -0.0034752758219838142, -0.0003431816294323653, -0.00772813381627202, 0.045629359781742096, -0.006016318220645189, -0.015891462564468384, 0.01943395286798477, -0.039747241884469986, -0.03010988049209118, 0.0284462571144104, 0.01050462108105421, -0.03498192876577377, 0.0030576332937926054, 0.013558825477957726, 0.0010601417161524296, 0.01926032453775406, 0.042664896696805954, 0.006686943117529154, 0.0373215414583683, 0.018470292910933495, 0.03310872241854668, 0.015070398338139057, 0.0031092583667486906, 0.02835242636501789, 0.08378679305315018, 0.0199687872081995, 0.01040390133857727, 0.02991395629942417, -0.008274207822978497, 0.023873792961239815, 0.03092271089553833, -0.013298696838319302, -0.04962525516748428, 0.03711488097906113, -0.038677193224430084, -0.0058427853509783745, 0.02733566239476204, -0.027872344478964806, -0.0023087398149073124, -0.0555705688893795, -0.02045716904103756, 0.051020290702581406, -0.030954409390687943, -0.014592904597520828, -0.013928425498306751, 0.022707955911755562, -0.029521197080612183, -0.02732672356069088, -0.05010193586349487, 0.023496195673942566, 0.00553187495097518, 0.0016269516199827194, 0.024762995541095734, -0.008495159447193146, 0.00804085936397314, -0.023518957197666168, 0.005016851704567671, 0.06779168546199799, 0.05675852298736572, -0.03151065111160278, 0.004502090625464916, -0.01212537195533514, -0.03591805696487427, 0.057520825415849686, 0.003508061869069934, -0.03494071215391159, -0.07382592558860779, 0.026017695665359497, 0.028634220361709595, -0.022860925644636154, 0.040856219828128815, -0.0006430260837078094, 0.030233323574066162, -0.011046447791159153, -0.07981707900762558, -0.036669518798589706, 0.06758306920528412, -0.023462897166609764, 0.038341980427503586, -0.050848521292209625, -0.008310660719871521, 0.032603729516267776, 0.047574494034051895, 0.02299392595887184, 0.06834885478019714, 0.045290980488061905, 0.017680548131465912, -0.014835784211754799, -0.04203645512461662, -0.014785541221499443, -0.016506675630807877, -0.039727505296468735, -0.01894846372306347, -0.05495830625295639, -0.017536984756588936, 0.01804434321820736, -0.057368941605091095, -0.021475737914443016, 0.023662274703383446, -0.010118936188519001, -0.027944132685661316, -0.0065177432261407375, 0.008462927304208279, -0.01618514582514763, 0.037630174309015274, 0.021168332546949387, 0.05530139058828354, 0.023106267675757408, -0.030408844351768494, -0.009603051468729973, 0.04507030174136162, 0.01117174793034792, 0.03986845910549164, -0.0035021656658500433, -0.02710914984345436, -0.006214133929461241, 0.04211529344320297, 0.03091629222035408, -0.06251897662878036, -0.03006032481789589, -0.03107425943017006, 0.053411658853292465, 0.011739546433091164, 0.05858800560235977, -0.011230293661355972, -0.03290778398513794, -0.004781451541930437, -0.02694585546851158, 0.004177102819085121, -0.037583619356155396, 0.009180422872304916, 0.015419797040522099, -0.02503844164311886, 0.00006631212454522029, -0.013731271959841251, 0.005975257605314255, 0.01857386901974678, 0.01826411299407482, -0.03411126881837845, -0.002450707135722041, 0.015224158763885498, -0.040685445070266724, 0.0020620888099074364, 0.05020437389612198, 0.04485407844185829, -0.009319177828729153, 0.0031111175194382668, -0.006155106704682112, -0.032061588019132614, 0.013594284653663635, -0.03268351033329964, 0.01649477519094944, -0.013973749242722988, -0.024149805307388306, 0.05099393427371979, -0.014609851874411106, -0.004922097083181143, 0.011957677081227303, -0.04637372866272926, 0.03788384050130844, 0.09126482903957367, 0.01429626252502203, -0.014463699422776699, -0.015894170850515366, 0.011755925603210926, 0.004931223578751087, 0.017137451097369194, -0.01697501912713051, -0.056205905973911285, -0.02738393098115921, 0.021400384604930878, 0.021239209920167923, -0.04014419764280319, 0.022493312135338783, 0.023084724321961403, -0.015199679881334305, 0.023331183940172195, -0.029772287234663963, -0.003336922265589237, -0.005175200756639242, 0.00017162199947051704, 0.010789075866341591, 0.005949134007096291, -0.04106665775179863, -0.053070470690727234, 0.0053225550800561905, 0.0370221845805645, 0.0010655155638232827, -0.017815442755818367, 0.05181330814957619, -0.003867505583912134, 0.024930687621235847, -0.015159468166530132, 0.005377639550715685, 0.044857271015644073, -0.05043279379606247, -0.022937852889299393, 0.046556346118450165, -0.011901539750397205, -0.028839686885476112, 0.029782148078083992, -0.023376083001494408, 0.029111729934811592, 0.04425835981965065, -0.018803996965289116, 0.007382082287222147, 0.016442211344838142, -0.06331032514572144, -0.004797076806426048, -0.04449406638741493, -0.031164688989520073, -0.008850352838635445, -0.021017935127019882, 0.029777513816952705, 0.02878854051232338, 0.005284882616251707, -0.034328386187553406, 0.001479352475143969, -0.0021456480026245117, -0.02044484205543995, 0.021925268694758415, -0.022481273859739304, -0.0247906856238842, 0.01113604474812746, -0.04094422236084938, -0.007259543053805828, 0.007501710671931505, -0.017471954226493835, -0.03876807168126106, -0.005082385148853064, 0.01916508376598358, -0.0526176318526268, -0.021474327892065048, -0.0681287944316864, 0.03192272037267685, -0.015825020149350166, -0.008226605132222176, 0.04422565922141075, 0.004612216260284185, -0.026343077421188354, 0.008493288420140743, -0.027388738468289375, -0.031702157109975815, -0.035247817635536194, -0.020846914499998093, -0.02670241892337799, -0.002239265013486147, -0.0067658741027116776, 0.0006319877575151622, -0.02661881037056446, 0.008352010510861874, -0.043908532708883286, -0.03629278391599655, 0.0347934365272522, -0.013331761583685875, 0.019372353330254555, 0.023567544296383858, -0.027550816535949707, 0.10758105665445328, 0.035797636955976486, -0.05648450180888176, -0.04003240540623665, 0.0009870579233393073, -0.04942473769187927, -0.000052376188250491396, 0.001501761027611792, 0.04157865047454834, 0.031648024916648865, 0.03760766237974167, 0.005116170272231102, 0.019923536106944084, 0.061728693544864655, 0.015701765194535255, -0.05724797397851944, 0.021717308089137077, -0.028004227206110954, -0.03734102100133896, 0.04532748460769653, 0.0036065890453755856, 0.004644863773137331, 0.014918400906026363, 0.023708805441856384, 0.01976156421005726, 0.03624434024095535, -0.04488283395767212, 0.019682271406054497, -0.009358547627925873, 0.04400643706321716, -0.04861323535442352, 0.055069029331207275, 0.037824708968400955, -0.01782172918319702, 0.01194887887686491, 0.009840134531259537, 0.029850374907255173, -0.040484607219696045, -0.01730513945221901, 0.03001982718706131, 0.02941279485821724, -0.037768878042697906, 0.0020476020872592926, -0.04585776850581169, 0.028096087276935577, 0.02409970387816429, -0.004415259230881929, -0.005530749447643757, 0.03253037482500076, 0.047745589166879654, -0.008026822470128536, 0.03235597535967827, -0.023949481546878815, -0.003857937641441822, -0.06843207776546478, -0.017000751569867134, -0.0020824491512030363, 0.07011514902114868, -0.00404675118625164, 0.015288561582565308, 0.04057127237319946, -0.016019005328416824, 0.04479924216866493, -0.017347753047943115, -0.05948881432414055, -0.00907447561621666, -0.009176740422844887, 0.005445276852697134, 0.001767737790942192, -0.05528777465224266, 0.023845477029681206, -0.01967264525592327, 0.000873984768986702, -0.032172467559576035, 0.009184367954730988, -0.0663190558552742, 0.008439555764198303, 0.010196574963629246, -0.018015844747424126, -0.014834292232990265, -0.00920385867357254, 0.041913971304893494, -0.016174491494894028, 0.012577359564602375, 0.05951932817697525, -0.031280502676963806, 0.014029869809746742, -0.011585673317313194, 0.007874428294599056, 0.023906659334897995, 0.01705584116280079, 0.01808670535683632, 0.022783758118748665, -0.01955271139740944, -0.014077671803534031, 0.0033681222703307867, 0.010604427196085453, 0.06362978368997574, 0.00844167172908783, -0.033145952969789505, -0.04384726285934448, -0.026890084147453308, -0.029964188113808632, 0.008280624635517597, -0.01967189460992813, -0.025770291686058044, 0.030907107517123222, 0.02115952968597412, -0.07255487143993378, -0.01975274458527565, 0.06715723127126694, 0.021758301183581352, -0.01997673511505127, -0.04311984404921532, -0.052113596349954605, -0.010815282352268696, -0.04190325364470482, 0.033725935965776443, -0.018467990681529045, -0.028377952054142952, -0.005442633759230375, 0.03846825659275055, -0.026099488139152527, -0.024295128881931305, 0.007600859738886356, 0.005599383730441332, 0.015078652650117874, -0.00485061202198267, -0.00774005614221096, -0.039039116352796555, 0.03433935344219208, 0.052450891584157944, 0.004675031639635563, -0.008113200776278973, -0.06788896769285202, -0.001818066113628447, 0.04261459410190582, 0.009720759466290474, -0.010772999376058578, 0.00044660401181317866, -0.05405614897608757, -0.01821146532893181, 0.02709910273551941, -0.011610153131186962, 0.02978387475013733, -0.01731906458735466, -0.014359832741320133, -0.04889434576034546, -0.04052788391709328, -0.03268514946103096, 0.03825020045042038, -0.02310149557888508, 0.047221288084983826, -0.015075618401169777, -0.01140850130468607, -0.05728580057621002, -0.006485399790108204, 0.02810033969581127, 0.06861601769924164, -0.0067978063598275185, 0.0006357376114465296, -0.03598541393876076, 0.03620485961437225, -0.009362983517348766, -0.07813780009746552, -0.003554834518581629, 0.03941384702920914, -0.043749406933784485, 0.011816090904176235, -0.01744554005563259, -0.06384299695491791, 0.03882400318980217, 0.035754475742578506, -0.026555290445685387, -0.006042401306331158, -0.015567892231047153, 0.0801093652844429, 0.03946105018258095, 0.013167397119104862, 0.008871929720044136, 0.021221719682216644, 0.02951345220208168, -0.02130262367427349, -0.028519874438643456, 0.011057978495955467, -0.017382614314556122, -0.03802898898720741, -0.0278746597468853, -0.012746458873152733, -0.011852624826133251, 0.01366507913917303, 0.012646532617509365, 0.04734539985656738, -0.05773337930440903, -0.013962239027023315, 0.0029252611566334963, 0.04387079179286957, -0.03669147938489914, -0.005730750504881144, 0.00683424761518836, 0.05506452918052673, 0.0013813842087984085, 0.006138347089290619, 0.00988003145903349, -0.03487178310751915, 0.013779460452497005, 0.053743574768304825, 0.007055231370031834, 0.026275476440787315, -0.022803185507655144, -0.012634418904781342, -0.0022847983054816723, -0.03676762804389, 0.06334328651428223, -0.047238145023584366, 0.05055343359708786, 0.017080388963222504, -0.029777811840176582, -0.013600729405879974, -0.002011806471273303, -0.018492979928851128, 0.028155697509646416, -0.039668407291173935, 0.008588852360844612, 0.0275859497487545, -0.012439578771591187, -0.06709661334753036, -0.04433858022093773, 0.007478414569050074, 0.026820175349712372, -0.024264847859740257, -0.041492342948913574, 0.004672907292842865, -0.003525442210957408, -0.03407341241836548, -0.018144844099879265, 0.025422750040888786, 0.0063430857844650745, -0.02908872812986374, -0.010221277363598347, -0.01291575189679861, 0.05103527754545212, 0.016149645671248436, 0.02875136211514473, 0.004579078871756792, -0.01374820340424776, -0.0007717282860539854, 0.030931225046515465, 0.053239043802022934, -0.032305698841810226, -0.01438468974083662, -0.03065107762813568, 0.007572272326797247, 0.03962899371981621, 0.035475295037031174, 0.00885314866900444, 0.014448567293584347, -0.0007606453727930784, -0.019526969641447067, 0.012550827115774155, -0.0016326080076396465, 0.03459906205534935, 0.0029924334958195686, 0.01643599569797516, -0.029321400448679924, -0.04454595968127251, -0.009756545536220074, 0.0015256820479407907, 0.009478343650698662, -0.01809408701956272, -0.0037388403434306383, 0.06529704481363297, -0.04390112683176994, 0.018140237778425217, -0.011485451832413673, -0.008161976002156734, 0.017586030066013336, -0.029400179162621498, 0.015953881666064262, 0.00816471129655838, 0.04526668041944504, -0.025922203436493874, 0.011706112883985043, -0.05278139188885689, 0.033103011548519135, 0.03309878334403038, -0.014140217565000057, 0.04949251189827919, 0.0008570565842092037, -0.009754274971783161, -0.02405698224902153, -0.05538695305585861, -0.01879783719778061, -0.02136947028338909, -0.02178872376680374, 0.050174079835414886, -0.017054347321391106, 0.017246654257178307, 0.04254312068223953, 0.03556175157427788, 0.014617033302783966, -0.011042939499020576, 0.004858877509832382, 0.016770096495747566, 0.034085214138031006, -0.005451173521578312, -0.02691211737692356, 0.05007384344935417, 0.011861130595207214, 0.014792302623391151, -0.0010417877929285169, 0.0032150771003216505, 0.0546567402780056, -0.012180168181657791, 0.007173444144427776, -0.046100910753011703, -0.037532463669776917, -0.011213693767786026, 0.03614027053117752, 0.03197590261697769, -0.015606220811605453, 0.06310603767633438, 0.004754434805363417, -0.0035620226990431547, -0.015407637692987919, 0.026132825762033463, -0.025938158854842186, -0.08064219355583191, -0.03469286113977432, -0.06348457932472229, -0.04359949007630348, 0.039435677230358124, 0.0218432005494833, -0.05550241842865944, 0.02528104931116104, -0.04613380879163742, 0.05732022225856781, -0.016102373600006104, 0.019560890272259712, 0.03363601118326187, 0.04926286265254021, 0.030810106545686722, 0.02752869576215744, -0.0010953921591863036, 0.00011927866580663249, 0.14644961059093475, 0.05270078033208847, 0.0011946667218580842, -0.04146697744727135, -0.006281131412833929, -0.014053204096853733, -0.014355599880218506, -0.07495909184217453, 0.031205007806420326, -0.011330584064126015, 0.006684201769530773, 0.017804177477955818, 0.010588354431092739, 0.02814839966595173, 0.023808766156435013, 0.03604048490524292, -0.04763180390000343, -0.02279963530600071, 0.015568041242659092, 0.013362085446715355, -0.013693089596927166, 0.0021031154319643974, -0.02644224278628826, -0.015482218004763126, 0.004441728815436363, -0.03776058927178383, -0.0042995125986635685, -0.015693046152591705, 0.023667318746447563, -0.04275710508227348, -0.005114411469548941, 0.029148424044251442, 0.015419366769492626, -0.0011244071647524834, -0.024164842441678047, -0.011764612048864365, 0.029499920085072517, 0.0038894934114068747, 0.017498517408967018, 0.022801410406827927, 0.01697881892323494, 0.023584332317113876, 0.02087424322962761, -0.018330411985516548, -0.04841788485646248, -0.025804664939641953, -0.060688186436891556, 0.022801944985985756, 0.009084160439670086, 0.023515140637755394, 0.011631680652499199, 0.016680842265486717, -0.017822684720158577, -0.04966473951935768, 0.02843143232166767, 0.0011003334075212479, 0.032105740159749985, -0.011292648501694202, -0.004522223956882954, 0.001792208175174892, 0.04443397745490074, 0.0005487831076607108, 0.02412261627614498, -0.013423013500869274, -0.04854646697640419, 0.0021386868320405483, -0.012376310303807259, 0.041622698307037354, -0.01799638941884041, -0.0031640511006116867, -0.02612403966486454, -0.011236175894737244, 0.0018937899731099606, 0.005083188414573669, 0.02563098818063736, -0.0003466929483693093, 0.029222121462225914, -0.009200746193528175, 0.007844069972634315, -0.022054525092244148, -0.08293122053146362, 0.019978117197752, -0.024009954184293747, 0.007300877012312412, -0.011090538464486599, -0.0007314313552342355, 0.008395764045417309, 0.06315658986568451, 0.02979997731745243, -0.026100890710949898, 0.0029575808439403772, 0.030122531577944756, 0.010560213588178158, -0.03553497791290283, -0.022348586469888687, 0.006362916901707649, -0.03987791761755943, 0.011887114495038986, 0.007711970247328281, 0.04158329218626022, 0.05171262472867966, 0.00035377038875594735, 0.014514134265482426, 0.03183336183428764, -0.02159186080098152, 0.006800658069550991, -0.015949446707963943, -0.06786326318979263, 0.008171634748578072, 0.018587127327919006, -0.049199867993593216, -0.008713282644748688, 0.006901586893945932, 0.017732171341776848, -0.022778941318392754, -0.0014918826054781675, 0.031205104663968086, -0.032252050936222076, 0.014276924543082714, 0.004585488233715296, 0.021686885505914688, -0.019445553421974182, -0.02245296724140644, 0.03328266367316246, 0.04896404594182968, -0.010191025212407112, -0.04351304844021797, 0.0122160529717803, 0.021131297573447227, 0.022818055003881454, 0.03186948597431183, 0.03041408769786358, 0.019906774163246155, 0.018436972051858902, -0.011552910320460796, -0.0032888620626181364, -7.122914098545152e-7, 0.06379308551549911, -0.03794363886117935, -0.0025584371760487556, 0.005284631159156561, -0.041596341878175735, -0.0328533910214901, 0.03208613395690918, -0.005912896245718002, 0.03138391301035881, 0.014681733213365078, 0.019954850897192955, -0.01965196244418621, 0.04047864302992821, -0.0006815058877691627, 0.006991263944655657, 0.02350020594894886, 0.007669754326343536, 0.029298126697540283, -0.01512829214334488, 0.00036260084016248584, 0.011583156883716583, 0.020473672077059746, 0.006293489132076502, 0.0358109287917614, -0.02780986577272415, 0.005518483929336071, 0.040333282202482224, 0.02586478926241398, 0.02546607330441475, 0.006999031640589237, -0.001378433546051383, 0.07696936279535294, 0.029685230925679207, -0.010384594090282917, 0.0385279506444931, -0.022334834560751915, 0.02498682215809822, -0.10108176618814468, -0.0388096421957016, 0.03393349051475525, 0.0033217270392924547, 0.05608149245381355, -0.07467836141586304, 0.020848697051405907, 0.0520351268351078, -0.0999823585152626, 0.04392286762595177, -0.006489526946097612, 0.013538677245378494, -0.03726571425795555, -0.013439281843602657, -0.034396834671497345, 0.038947124034166336, 0.029142268002033234, 0.029145067557692528, 0.04582774266600609, 0.022929299622774124, 0.006925642490386963, -0.03419221565127373, -0.04038058593869209, 0.04752255231142044, -0.026094581931829453, -0.055271223187446594, 0.033347830176353455, -0.02509540133178234, -0.039583150297403336, 0.002390494104474783, 0.0009702848619781435, -0.014734763652086258, 0.04495914652943611, 0.055025048553943634, 0.024399621412158012, 0.01627158187329769, 0.04207252338528633, -0.014006231911480427, -0.02099139243364334, 0.010828209109604359, 0.04428271949291229, 0.013600362464785576, -0.025212889537215233, 0.012816882692277431, 0.04319300502538681, -0.036654092371463776, -0.026603806763887405, 0.0032827924005687237, -0.006764455232769251, -0.026081359013915062, 0.008372590877115726, 0.026965390890836716, -0.0344284363090992, -0.0559048131108284, -0.032889146357774734, -0.02167564630508423, 0.0006096155848354101, 0.03291167691349983, 0.008126233704388142, -0.031000696122646332, 0.006786201149225235, 0.004114946816116571, -0.05594680458307266, -0.00636457372456789, 0.0022808180656284094, -0.007597510237246752, -0.04924239218235016, -0.0009169783443212509, 0.010251051746308804, 0.014456179924309254, -0.028190964832901955, -0.007847988978028297, -0.013544111512601376, 0.015260348096489906, -0.0016294936649501324, -0.005158735904842615, 0.009938747622072697, 0.002134862821549177, -0.031046174466609955, -0.09373500943183899, 0.07037615031003952, 0.020279964432120323, -0.054319798946380615, -0.00833736453205347, -0.012062286958098412, -0.005877181887626648, -0.015843402594327927, 0.048171959817409515, 0.014052244834601879, 0.0019941104110330343, -0.01053561456501484, 0.020749244838953018, -0.001392583828419447, -0.017741063609719276, 0.026090411469340324, -0.005557412747293711, -0.012536345049738884, 0.01910889521241188, 0.014329801313579082, 0.0008614649414084852, 0.00652815168723464, -0.01895512081682682, 0.008932432159781456, -0.007736905477941036, 0.014270434156060219, 0.014097249135375023, 0.002304061781615019, -0.0011050197063013911, 0.002119446871802211, 0.08638709038496017, 0.01905192993581295, -0.023935966193675995, 0.0122836297377944, -0.037173639982938766, -0.02848939783871174, 0.02901299111545086, -0.013438829220831394, -0.023499034345149994, -0.03400007635354996, 0.02762029506266117, 0.05284525826573372, -0.08184419572353363, -0.02695208229124546, 0.06314104795455933, -0.029866278171539307, 0.012040788307785988, 0.03177977353334427, 0.013490568846464157, 0.012012687511742115, 0.041577234864234924, -0.0017159406561404467, -0.006884417030960321, -0.01729663275182247, 0.0239883903414011, 0.0035707480274140835, 0.008274014107882977, -0.0017459183000028133, 0.020465290173888206, 0.006543674971908331, 0.01629624515771866, 0.03665680065751076, 0.03224997967481613, 0.017366835847496986, -0.03195889666676521, -0.016131551936268806, 0.0021688900887966156, 0.008459139615297318, 0.0069990395568311214, -0.014897923916578293, -0.016134100034832954, 0.09511330723762512, -0.018698973581194878, 0.018824422731995583, -0.0356135293841362, -0.0061630187556147575, -0.060273945331573486, 0.0277252197265625, 0.046927597373723984, 0.0029676519334316254, 0.005554389674216509, -0.021810967475175858, -0.005844886414706707, 0.01838838867843151, 0.017619358375668526, -0.008743222802877426, 0.013631055131554604, -0.017473066225647926, 0.008540376089513302, -0.0011194751132279634, -0.012801582925021648, -0.010908573865890503, 0.025636672973632812, -0.0015915833646431565, 0.06562253087759018, 0.020233916118741035, 0.02551204524934292, 0.006021182984113693, 0.012970638461411, 0.03186534345149994, -0.07955064624547958, -0.00047659495612606406, -0.06422340124845505, 0.004575271625071764, -0.0022399569861590862, -0.025583025068044662 ]
<p>What is the difference of gaussian HMM and gaussian mixture HMM (the emission is gaussian or gaussian mixture)? I want to know if it is the same thing. What is the point when estimating the parameters using Baum Welch algorithm.</p>
73,528
[ -0.0560283288359642, -0.016148172318935394, 0.005889739841222763, -0.027324847877025604, 0.024892620742321014, 0.012460595928132534, -0.018056582659482956, -0.04390678554773331, 0.03018253482878208, -0.014626135118305683, 0.035539381206035614, 0.04949595406651497, 0.03255487233400345, 0.023594751954078674, 0.04140791296958923, 0.022648338228464127, 0.0066410633735358715, 0.024210955947637558, -0.015923993661999702, 0.02535095624625683, -0.02326003462076187, 0.02128172479569912, 0.02456704154610634, -0.01983877457678318, -0.008781727403402328, 0.04046062007546425, 0.044091638177633286, 0.004490344785153866, 0.019670069217681885, 0.027079567313194275, -0.04692329093813896, -0.03203142061829567, 0.0037187694106251, 0.03282547742128372, 0.016688324511051178, -0.016883395612239838, -0.03087630681693554, -0.032477006316185, -0.012205199338495731, 0.03909241035580635, -0.052435822784900665, -0.041154567152261734, 0.02891414985060692, 0.05327250063419342, -0.007101841736584902, -0.004756735637784004, -0.007094986271113157, -0.041192322969436646, 0.005426452029496431, -0.06276194751262665, 0.0685320496559143, -0.02901284210383892, 0.007392005994915962, 0.01051091868430376, 0.012512531131505966, 0.036457229405641556, 0.0709124282002449, 0.08156605809926987, -0.011982087977230549, -0.037718817591667175, 0.028883131220936775, -0.005065355449914932, 0.04800155386328697, -0.0187065452337265, -0.01581357605755329, 0.017341790720820427, -0.002253325656056404, -0.0360102653503418, 0.04099756106734276, 0.017256194725632668, 0.0019651593174785376, 0.008403932675719261, 0.07678914815187454, -0.031498976051807404, 0.058118972927331924, -0.02490970306098461, -0.0027291548904031515, 0.05465677008032799, 0.04378270357847214, 0.02117101661860943, 0.02131151780486107, -0.017332199960947037, 0.007104459684342146, -0.009870546869933605, -0.013475371524691582, -0.002927090274170041, 0.06300003081560135, -0.041194137185811996, 0.004980373661965132, 0.026859227567911148, -0.057008735835552216, 0.03117011860013008, 0.030869100242853165, 0.02195616438984871, -0.01460198126733303, 0.035441555082798004, 0.001470097224228084, 0.024152308702468872, 0.030222365632653236, -0.03426310420036316, 0.013209924101829529, -0.016372909769415855, 0.01726365275681019, 0.04006588086485863, -0.048584386706352234, 0.0008738769683986902, -0.014865892007946968, 0.011997174471616745, -0.02167341485619545, -0.01662067510187626, -0.030307039618492126, 0.004079415928572416, -0.01390905398875475, 0.0039036578964442015, 0.018527023494243622, -0.0025652784388512373, 0.006930097471922636, -0.023440930992364883, 0.020849045366048813, 0.08174354583024979, 0.028400937095284462, -0.03658182546496391, 0.0038048948626965284, -0.034801218658685684, -0.06683705002069473, -0.02118649333715439, -0.00712481327354908, -0.019596418365836143, -0.06352239102125168, 0.0540231391787529, -0.013693884946405888, -0.035478733479976654, 0.08058410882949829, -0.0001348917285213247, 0.00021061893494334072, -0.021398982033133507, -0.09512295573949814, -0.019706813618540764, 0.035242702811956406, -0.053366519510746, 0.04214232787489891, -0.09476455301046371, 0.024156829342246056, 0.01761638931930065, 0.01731039769947529, 0.012412267737090588, 0.04771382361650467, -0.022689511999487877, 0.030935069546103477, -0.027754146605730057, -0.02782115899026394, -0.025054043158888817, -0.010863185860216618, -0.002021210268139839, -0.009242456406354904, -0.07800168544054031, -0.015171665698289871, 0.03275764361023903, -0.036109063774347305, -0.03449488803744316, 0.01398103404790163, 0.022785736247897148, -0.03582330793142319, 0.0184027086943388, 0.0011989708291366696, -0.034051522612571716, 0.06214884668588638, 0.010360854677855968, 0.06650977581739426, 0.02561851777136326, 0.0012231793953105807, 0.012444045394659042, 0.011932725086808205, 0.013627921231091022, 0.039597176015377045, -0.02189575508236885, -0.04294632002711296, -0.01203858945518732, 0.07087203860282898, 0.033819589763879776, -0.03726215660572052, -0.023232031613588333, 0.007821173407137394, 0.016353808343410492, -0.005403624381870031, 0.01892836205661297, 0.0305208470672369, -0.0018455421086400747, 0.06478328257799149, -0.049427736550569534, -0.008468983694911003, -0.04198914393782616, 0.011902476660907269, -0.03983531892299652, 0.004124097991734743, 0.01903829351067543, 0.0025372407399117947, -0.004181977361440659, -0.029488788917660713, -0.008942192420363426, -0.04024617001414299, -0.011741723865270615, -0.017144249752163887, -0.04142271727323532, -0.012384219095110893, 0.05734563618898392, 0.025011030957102776, -0.011438447050750256, 0.04979874566197395, -0.05060882493853569, -0.05020879954099655, 0.034492697566747665, -0.0017256642458960414, 0.015078263357281685, -0.01852346956729889, -0.030436700209975243, -0.02268717624247074, -0.023191004991531372, -0.03442638739943504, 0.005417887587100267, -0.04481516033411026, 0.07408234477043152, 0.07485830038785934, 0.013736488297581673, -0.004661317449063063, 0.018189292401075363, 0.0015227218391373754, 0.007170871831476688, -0.004899929277598858, 0.0038212796207517385, -0.04843968525528908, -0.007297588512301445, 0.04260251298546791, 0.02299405261874199, -0.0449087992310524, 0.01857948862016201, 0.014398944564163685, 0.02675320766866207, 0.026227163150906563, 0.028899045661091805, -0.018591416999697685, -0.023048950359225273, 0.01459433976560831, 0.02203385718166828, -0.00037437607534229755, 0.03519294783473015, 0.030279656872153282, -0.0025689031463116407, 0.043572619557380676, -0.027797067537903786, -0.028656136244535446, 0.04918927699327469, 0.003007930237799883, -0.014156504534184933, -0.02681952714920044, -0.021719180047512054, -0.008889177814126015, -0.058056361973285675, 0.008197679184377193, 0.0144718112424016, -0.020238779485225677, -0.019170118495821953, 0.013821030035614967, -0.035557329654693604, 0.01380685344338417, 0.029182162135839462, -0.036607593297958374, -0.0005986897740513086, 0.0197158046066761, -0.037081439048051834, 0.03236018866300583, -0.0141860730946064, -0.007104092743247747, -0.04021015390753746, 0.021781092509627342, 0.040766309946775436, -0.015014629811048508, 0.02734760008752346, -0.04746157303452492, -0.06707936525344849, -0.002081914572045207, -0.02929963730275631, 0.02403831109404564, 0.005205413326621056, -0.03629644960165024, 0.03317432850599289, -0.010608596727252007, -0.021350108087062836, 0.02131538838148117, -0.027203097939491272, 0.0010860114125534892, 0.02469305694103241, -0.02329382859170437, -0.048222966492176056, -0.019791895523667336, 0.0003184639208484441, 0.01664668694138527, 0.009852725081145763, -0.012305629439651966, 0.04855239391326904, -0.02779890038073063, -0.01854597218334675, 0.013475112617015839, -0.07100396603345871, -0.042823661118745804, -0.07232122123241425, -0.02297677844762802, 0.041765403002500534, -0.0005324259982444346, 0.04443904757499695, 0.0432218573987484, -0.04910929501056671, 0.027247773483395576, -0.04108678922057152, -0.044180434197187424, 0.05089070275425911, -0.003772052936255932, 0.02387223392724991, 0.008333059959113598, -0.026162398979067802, 0.051370151340961456, 0.04421345517039299, -0.04095188528299332, 0.0001250948989763856, -0.0019252904457971454, -0.010161480866372585, -0.025229550898075104, -0.0036079532001167536, 0.03129010647535324, 0.025002693757414818, 0.02392513118684292, 0.028953809291124344, -0.020704170688986778, 0.06672375649213791, 0.02618122473359108, 0.01870424672961235, 0.00046555459266528487, -0.003910399042069912, -0.019307464361190796, 0.05339589715003967, 0.0038912356831133366, -0.027385398745536804, 0.010931584984064102, 0.018612554296851158, 0.009575212374329567, 0.004793352447450161, 0.003150547854602337, 0.012055180966854095, -0.012319380417466164, 0.01993572525680065, -0.05579023435711861, 0.0401560515165329, 0.005946391727775335, -0.014485664665699005, 0.005841293837875128, 0.003245143685489893, 0.01694531738758087, -0.028458407148718834, -0.003053870517760515, 0.046309564262628555, 0.02042168378829956, -0.030856478959321976, -0.013991223648190498, 0.02741464227437973, -0.023732071742415428, 0.007811738643795252, -0.017673658207058907, -0.013481480069458485, 0.04464733228087425, 0.035933222621679306, -0.003245778614655137, 0.014145508408546448, -0.012889854609966278, -0.05366818979382515, -0.053721070289611816, 0.03200512006878853, 0.004449074622243643, 0.02042144536972046, -0.008094781078398228, 0.06773332506418228, 0.028425196185708046, -0.0049785953015089035, 0.010776638984680176, -0.035780876874923706, -0.07764776796102524, 0.0002507875324226916, -0.037738949060440063, -0.01336878165602684, 0.016307039186358452, -0.02653229609131813, 0.011457444168627262, -0.04110413044691086, -0.01503248792141676, -0.017365552484989166, 0.04323357716202736, -0.07419469207525253, 0.04801701009273529, -0.01224838849157095, -0.023269902914762497, 0.0011124457232654095, 0.00944167748093605, -0.0044042752124369144, 0.008206586353480816, 0.01332134660333395, 0.044663649052381516, -0.021741455420851707, 0.0072459932416677475, -0.016443835571408272, 0.0022736224345862865, 0.011836281046271324, 0.04774446040391922, 0.04480702802538872, 0.05429694801568985, -0.061299871653318405, 0.014362027868628502, 0.030752645805478096, 0.07264848798513412, 0.016860289499163628, -0.03600604087114334, -0.035470616072416306, -0.0271559227257967, -0.030076388269662857, -0.015882642939686775, 0.048190515488386154, 0.008336957544088364, -0.0023436874616891146, 0.02044024132192135, -0.01293463259935379, -0.009411906823515892, 0.019391877576708794, 0.06658969819545746, 0.007093825377523899, -0.009726710617542267, -0.04813117906451225, -0.009672988206148148, -0.01157180406153202, -0.0284672062844038, 0.013998844660818577, 0.028854405507445335, -0.009400238282978535, -0.017126182094216347, 0.03398754820227623, -0.0259145088493824, -0.00476269843056798, -0.023577501997351646, 0.05457421392202377, 0.019811786711215973, 0.013918858021497726, -0.021701209247112274, -0.0354573056101799, 0.042293354868888855, 0.009613296017050743, 0.00077979383058846, -0.004406777676194906, -0.07477933168411255, -0.0024808922316879034, 0.03727926313877106, 0.016069170087575912, -0.04043983668088913, 0.012530059553682804, -0.04045349732041359, 0.02440587989985943, -0.0007663261494599283, -0.008836614899337292, 0.03920893371105194, -0.03741825744509697, 0.0009329423774033785, -0.020008277148008347, 0.025301320478320122, -0.01829945668578148, 0.019641032442450523, 0.015001070685684681, 0.005388682708144188, -0.023255053907632828, -0.021840518340468407, -0.040816035121679306, -0.01223684661090374, 0.02783329412341118, 0.06154125556349754, -0.027525154873728752, 0.008012712933123112, 0.04418637230992317, 0.05023082718253136, 0.021267641335725784, -0.04220500588417053, -0.009266922250390053, 0.013775075785815716, -0.014369026757776737, 0.052994951605796814, -0.023357579484581947, -0.07078003138303757, -0.001714268117211759, 0.013286883942782879, -0.017311276867985725, -0.014592322520911694, 0.006196672096848488, 0.032600805163383484, 0.006160688120871782, -0.0015879468992352486, 0.04792778193950653, -0.009099223650991917, -0.018789812922477722, -0.010475675575435162, -0.04075563699007034, 0.03230296075344086, -0.048610296100378036, -0.009297355078160763, -0.02187170460820198, 0.014604412950575352, -0.03196470066905022, 0.05561580881476402, 0.0026107437442988157, 0.020791390910744667, -0.03651971369981766, -0.026269609108567238, 0.018296483904123306, 0.06504050642251968, -0.024482617154717445, 0.007646471261978149, -0.026331838220357895, 0.031205421313643456, -0.022537807002663612, -0.0016679521650075912, 0.018992748111486435, -0.027065472677350044, -0.00010660602856660262, 0.022644441574811935, -0.02460748702287674, 0.021913010627031326, -0.06400474905967712, -0.018448710441589355, 0.04408087953925133, -0.013288342393934727, 0.04097339138388634, -0.012727903202176094, 0.03338352218270302, 0.028145503252744675, -0.08370991051197052, -0.019947072491049767, -0.02557406574487686, -0.015931105241179466, 0.05848825350403786, -0.02900826930999756, 0.04546837881207466, -0.008984292857348919, 0.002872706390917301, -0.06662499159574509, -0.038735195994377136, 0.020380737259984016, 0.0012382763670757413, 0.0011519966647028923, -0.016088036820292473, 0.027278784662485123, -0.015216694213449955, -0.024432092905044556, -0.00831825565546751, 0.024564852938055992, 0.00931181013584137, 0.003828304121270776, 0.005524739157408476, -0.000545468064956367, 0.05666537955403328, 0.06768222898244858, -0.006039548199623823, 0.008647127076983452, 0.010693613439798355, 0.014317983761429787, 0.0033721444196999073, 0.021684974431991577, -0.007431356701999903, 0.00358884921297431, -0.0016015361761674285, 0.001807143329642713, 0.06724155694246292, -0.026564713567495346, -0.023348672315478325, 0.015176456421613693, 0.034817978739738464, -0.0071436683647334576, -0.016710996627807617, -0.017205635085701942, -0.028460053727030754, -0.003325886558741331, -0.003277278970927, -0.020357441157102585, 0.0038809888064861298, -0.0031180735677480698, 0.04523759335279465, -0.012391113676130772, -0.006333851721137762, 0.005873689893633127, 0.04844104126095772, -0.026823829859495163, 0.00510408915579319, 0.015743520110845566, -0.006778213195502758, 0.009253835305571556, -0.021485034376382828, 0.013772153295576572, 0.03573289513587952, 0.03543457016348839, -0.01919739879667759, -0.009538444690406322, -0.055866338312625885, -0.00041802070336416364, 0.06170149892568588, 0.022399339824914932, 0.06549356132745743, 0.028055019676685333, 0.016702216118574142, 0.034370362758636475, -0.05106335133314133, -0.01118380855768919, 0.002952295122668147, -0.052404940128326416, 0.010133301839232445, 0.02242664434015751, -0.02267531119287014, 0.0403997041285038, -0.01792079582810402, 0.009303039871156216, 0.03423946350812912, 0.01924780197441578, 0.04661249369382858, -0.00360419531352818, 0.027129171416163445, -0.03512851893901825, 0.04404930770397186, -0.010387392714619637, 0.012711096554994583, -0.039150137454271317, 0.007263048551976681, 0.028969042003154755, 0.035452138632535934, 0.0020145417656749487, -0.06877973675727844, 0.011032537557184696, -0.059432439506053925, 0.02783227525651455, 0.03489721566438675, -0.019830361008644104, 0.01827969402074814, 0.007114438805729151, 0.01689799502491951, -0.012369354255497456, 0.01176999881863594, -0.03287186846137047, -0.07751829922199249, -0.058637261390686035, 0.014505969360470772, -0.04690086841583252, 0.03879820927977562, 0.003410493955016136, -0.06070856750011444, -0.009182860143482685, -0.018155157566070557, 0.030797624960541725, -0.0009660391951911151, 0.03436710685491562, -0.006069924682378769, 0.054884787648916245, 0.001015452085994184, 0.03050268068909645, 0.004283767193555832, 0.033302199095487595, 0.1233169361948967, 0.03654683008790016, 0.06315293163061142, -0.06979160010814667, 0.006287654396146536, -0.020743856206536293, 0.011067664250731468, -0.011967816390097141, 0.019933367148041725, 0.028744854032993317, 0.026432977989315987, 0.017121339216828346, -0.0021790165919810534, 0.0367915965616703, -0.00022440361499320716, 0.027721257880330086, -0.04229642450809479, -0.05240480229258537, 0.00703093409538269, 0.0003538083692546934, -0.020404480397701263, 0.04302201047539711, -0.03799742832779884, -0.015434305183589458, -0.008510728366672993, -0.027938582003116608, -0.00861354824155569, -0.024297408759593964, 0.028450675308704376, -0.015495563857257366, -0.0014682228211313486, 0.0029891720041632652, -0.009326647035777569, -0.024876955896615982, -0.013948263600468636, 0.010641827248036861, 0.009918360970914364, -0.01439572311937809, -0.01658356748521328, 0.017342746257781982, 0.03176618367433548, -0.024900361895561218, 0.007538130972534418, 0.013122319243848324, -0.03061096929013729, 0.002339450176805258, -0.023617949336767197, 0.042069949209690094, 0.0033597478177398443, 0.006352289579808712, 0.014310905709862709, 0.0030191419646143913, -0.006296943407505751, -0.08691134303808212, -0.0069810813292860985, 0.01734681986272335, 0.02968430332839489, -0.02518566884100437, -0.03878884017467499, -0.07189605385065079, 0.037123069167137146, -0.016379866749048233, 0.03681188076734543, 0.017278488725423813, -0.04391565918922424, 0.028595643118023872, -0.010347150266170502, 0.04366115853190422, -0.02645748481154442, -0.03014284186065197, -0.0007256091921590269, -0.02178853191435337, -0.041412364691495895, -0.04590265452861786, -0.0010036119492724538, -0.01363441627472639, 0.033904992043972015, -0.021107275038957596, -0.02030051313340664, 0.022012628614902496, -0.02202977053821087, 0.004279157146811485, 0.025494446977972984, -0.013536380603909492, -0.01872776262462139, 0.0030641513876616955, 0.052918240427970886, 0.01127036102116108, -0.005650836508721113, 0.050415560603141785, -0.009508908726274967, 0.022314757108688354, 0.0032968532759696245, -0.025273455306887627, -0.02382682077586651, 0.044946927577257156, -0.013562027364969254, -0.0013183550909161568, -0.02411959506571293, 0.05422836169600487, 0.05018560215830803, -0.00949072279036045, -0.02702081948518753, 0.03313339874148369, -0.025836216285824776, -0.011022752150893211, -0.017234332859516144, -0.012577119283378124, -0.019543247297406197, 0.031026236712932587, 0.01231151819229126, -0.004089036025106907, -0.01870652288198471, -0.018546100705862045, 0.007791886571794748, 0.03113025426864624, -0.012452789582312107, -0.027054307982325554, 0.021104581654071808, -0.006785572972148657, 0.007191286887973547, -0.019142327830195427, -0.029317045584321022, 0.007216219324618578, 0.04554152488708496, -0.015908481553196907, -0.03626064956188202, -0.0033110647927969694, -0.019119713455438614, 0.00503528630360961, -0.0272360872477293, 0.0332978256046772, 0.036940690129995346, 0.031204160302877426, 0.00943551305681467, 0.045198991894721985, -0.03515230864286423, 0.07312391698360443, -0.010128920897841454, 0.0049076019786298275, 0.021611904725432396, -0.04094933718442917, -0.05358133837580681, 0.0445479080080986, -0.004509381949901581, 0.03207461163401604, 0.02289656735956669, 0.012273913249373436, -0.01777021586894989, 0.04093635082244873, -0.03444550186395645, -0.00025166006525978446, -0.028337830677628517, 0.009782930836081505, -0.02196977101266384, -0.01949491910636425, -0.004585722927004099, 0.008174155838787556, -0.026379648596048355, 0.013653297908604145, 0.030131909996271133, 0.025641238316893578, -0.007243349216878414, 0.02724938467144966, 0.01392736379057169, 0.01789187453687191, 0.02784976176917553, 0.006164343096315861, 0.016019169241189957, 0.05804047733545303, 0.000314888427965343, 0.045910563319921494, -0.008792413398623466, 0.012464947998523712, -0.08278421312570572, -0.028636539354920387, 0.01639503426849842, -0.015331495553255081, 0.057974886149168015, -0.05750780180096626, 0.008658409118652344, 0.0492689348757267, -0.048090651631355286, 0.0008687894442118704, -0.010255478322505951, -0.004057158716022968, -0.03342849016189575, 0.027181142941117287, -0.007602320518344641, 0.04638456553220749, 0.013763477094471455, 0.033690061420202255, 0.042485762387514114, 0.030027834698557854, -0.02819816954433918, -0.005127268843352795, -0.023411579430103302, 0.021221712231636047, -0.014374078251421452, -0.04814402386546135, 0.09045834839344025, -0.04784207046031952, -0.013278095982968807, 0.05231114476919174, 0.015401910059154034, 0.024634014815092087, 0.014921030960977077, 0.02487127110362053, 0.007352618966251612, 0.0009906756458804011, 0.05530089512467384, -0.02262810617685318, 0.007876243442296982, 0.021397998556494713, -0.004535548388957977, 0.025199411436915398, -0.03864452615380287, 0.005054281558841467, -0.015856748446822166, -0.013676982372999191, 0.0071082632057368755, 0.00391423562541604, -0.0011614232789725065, -0.04578731581568718, -0.01555078849196434, 0.010517360642552376, 0.011326715350151062, -0.04238634929060936, 0.01737188547849655, -0.03417159989476204, -0.007629924453794956, 0.006061721593141556, 0.023739570751786232, -0.0006433403468690813, -0.015099316835403442, 0.0010664191795513034, -0.03932291269302368, 0.015381253324449062, -0.013469431549310684, -0.013262251392006874, -0.03817441314458847, 0.013477480970323086, 0.0008977074176073074, 0.02743157558143139, -0.0002793274470604956, 0.00923045352101326, -0.05701300874352455, 0.058736059814691544, -0.002297324128448963, 0.04496384039521217, 0.01781802624464035, -0.015255903825163841, -0.03592580929398537, -0.06870973855257034, 0.07455684244632721, -0.004790722392499447, -0.034756872802972794, -0.05775487422943115, -0.012769858352839947, -0.01299294177442789, -0.003427180927246809, 0.057395633310079575, 0.00999472290277481, -0.011823310516774654, -0.012783974409103394, 0.04094397649168968, 0.002062709303572774, -0.0004955930053256452, -0.0002148757630493492, -0.010784045793116093, -0.039777908474206924, 0.0017079981043934822, -0.01682894304394722, -0.030649639666080475, 0.030240142717957497, -0.008352634496986866, -0.03484801948070526, 0.03556373715400696, -0.01653633639216423, 0.006108687724918127, 0.014976686798036098, 0.017456412315368652, 0.01383180357515812, 0.0373670756816864, -0.044914476573467255, 0.050729576498270035, 0.027615994215011597, 0.004837756045162678, -0.06659069657325745, 0.006504313554614782, 0.00034424170735292137, -0.030307870358228683, 0.004605684895068407, 0.0008354532765224576, 0.03608249872922897, -0.05243409797549248, -0.04398859664797783, 0.040229570120573044, -0.05479038879275322, 0.014536615461111069, 0.05627855658531189, 0.026347974315285683, 0.03131930157542229, 0.010137951001524925, 0.022905495017766953, 0.006615672260522842, -0.014126346446573734, 0.02968507446348667, 0.0536947064101696, -0.02799052745103836, -0.021641047671437263, 0.04419339820742607, 0.00516422837972641, -0.02444605529308319, 0.02601037733256817, 0.007221957668662071, 0.023030076175928116, -0.02648651972413063, -0.040937650948762894, -0.00999705120921135, -0.0005463921115733683, -0.027250293642282486, 0.020061200484633446, -0.03663506731390953, 0.053327564150094986, -0.045664556324481964, -0.03139720857143402, -0.03173050284385681, -0.003548302687704563, -0.03377869725227356, -0.04381151497364044, -0.01508254837244749, 0.00035549135645851493, 0.038788411766290665, 0.015291555784642696, 0.006827353034168482, -0.01676267199218273, 0.044942568987607956, -0.04625990241765976, -0.010800753720104694, -0.029987283051013947, 0.0020670918747782707, -0.001264449441805482, -0.010036061517894268, -0.024422574788331985, 0.007529659196734428, 0.007846360094845295, 0.053665000945329666, 0.02280161902308464, -0.027050016447901726, -0.04686089977622032, -0.05261571705341339, 0.03654945269227028, -0.07286212593317032, 0.019749892875552177, -0.035211678594350815, -0.003354492364451289, -0.012284853495657444, -0.022609109058976173 ]
<p>I have often seen the statement that linear separability is more easily achieved in high dimensions, but I don't see why. Is it an empirical fact? An heuristic? Plain nonsense?</p>
35,921
[ -0.018955081701278687, 0.051963455975055695, -0.0018250411376357079, -0.042630940675735474, 0.02972104586660862, -0.010305775329470634, -0.019515682011842728, 0.01544803474098444, 0.024447141215205193, -0.03784819692373276, 0.006346200592815876, 0.02816629596054554, 0.05060456693172455, 0.036263611167669296, 0.023458221927285194, 0.005423662718385458, 0.0017190497601404786, 0.018240105360746384, 0.00890151783823967, -0.004386918619275093, -0.014308400452136993, 0.043008871376514435, 0.027707723900675774, -0.035013582557439804, -0.03015032783150673, 0.02308797836303711, 0.028062380850315094, 0.007392531726509333, 0.011451122350990772, 0.049865271896123886, -0.018728433176875114, -0.005286047700792551, 0.04008037969470024, 0.08682849258184433, 0.015178749337792397, -0.04306670278310776, 0.0010855982545763254, -0.03594319894909859, 0.012439556419849396, 0.02808428555727005, -0.011784781701862812, -0.01257410179823637, -0.013911942020058632, 0.042371124029159546, -0.00901077315211296, 0.08140870928764343, 0.013321690261363983, -0.06990690529346466, 0.026743313297629356, -0.04872282221913338, 0.03534092754125595, 0.01801060326397419, 0.034247733652591705, 0.029847703874111176, -0.001330729341134429, 0.027641862630844116, 0.04011334106326103, 0.07263749837875366, -0.010136691853404045, -0.017989326268434525, -0.02605869062244892, -0.004926083609461784, -0.0021187590900808573, -0.0005542893777601421, -0.024868018925189972, 0.024204188957810402, 0.012149205431342125, -0.0016602666582912207, 0.034900832921266556, -0.023420780897140503, -0.02932862937450409, 0.03710971772670746, 0.03074902854859829, -0.012842705473303795, -0.00972797442227602, -0.004674991592764854, 0.0037042726762592793, 0.018196702003479004, 0.05152764543890953, -0.011051587760448456, 0.021772809326648712, -0.013986841775476933, 0.02586090937256813, 0.019528506323695183, 0.028520572930574417, -0.0006213398883119226, 0.06969303637742996, -0.03235357999801636, -0.011149612255394459, 0.0218338742852211, -0.0006515969871543348, -0.02092265710234642, 0.05885947123169899, 0.04214772954583168, -0.03275473415851593, 0.05104769021272659, -0.0004594735219143331, 0.05117090046405792, 0.03790799900889397, -0.037743691354990005, -0.04252605512738228, -0.03399093076586723, 0.008488371036946774, 0.04744722694158554, 0.03446948528289795, -0.022569527849555016, -0.011369451880455017, 0.02615387924015522, 0.000797382032033056, -0.008385892026126385, -0.03817010298371315, 0.01508962269872427, 0.02363850362598896, -0.006666460074484348, 0.02364327944815159, -0.0007437526364810765, 0.010309075936675072, -0.03029901348054409, 0.03505810722708702, 0.09795160591602325, 0.0015348490560427308, -0.025096865370869637, 0.044043879956007004, -0.0017677071737125516, -0.0655001774430275, 0.03608645871281624, -0.001187338843010366, -0.01643523760139942, -0.06847606599330902, 0.04869904741644859, -0.020048920065164566, -0.02129201777279377, 0.03096579760313034, -0.029961464926600456, 0.022741947323083878, -0.014798225834965706, -0.06986353546380997, -0.03652095049619675, 0.06155862659215927, -0.010348494164645672, 0.001711085787974298, -0.04237431660294533, -0.0022243920248001814, 0.01738596148788929, 0.08294638991355896, -0.02382318675518036, 0.0706382691860199, 0.05124989151954651, -0.01753014512360096, 0.007960773073136806, -0.045041486620903015, -0.04670897126197815, 0.007643792312592268, -0.026162100955843925, 0.01377163641154766, -0.05107435584068298, -0.03391064330935478, 0.0369754433631897, -0.016856739297509193, 0.004494282882660627, -0.006145054940134287, 0.018271850422024727, -0.006187963765114546, -0.0009186482056975365, 0.013588995672762394, -0.016512854024767876, 0.06169574335217476, -0.018889043480157852, 0.05666719377040863, 0.049028430134058, -0.03490566089749336, 0.0037757325917482376, 0.04836331680417061, 0.03731734678149223, 0.007497962098568678, -0.023027829825878143, 0.015222713351249695, 0.00002275538645335473, -0.009213661774992943, -0.013659053482115269, -0.04730919376015663, -0.019460149109363556, -0.012106494978070259, 0.01721354015171528, -0.0037370312493294477, 0.062407590448856354, -0.0013135104672983289, -0.03850478306412697, 0.026233438402414322, -0.03803412616252899, -0.02271788753569126, -0.06630133837461472, 0.004242780618369579, 0.016805492341518402, -0.030692117288708687, 0.05486736446619034, -0.0084817660972476, 0.00894233025610447, -0.010249492712318897, -0.014062600210309029, -0.02161221019923687, -0.004115270916372538, 0.03176666796207428, -0.01732797548174858, 0.01666555553674698, 0.07663744688034058, 0.05169880390167236, -0.021083254367113113, 0.039259348064661026, 0.009215117432177067, -0.05884890258312225, 0.03232114389538765, 0.0031626250129193068, 0.015786875039339066, -0.01431046612560749, -0.029149800539016724, -0.002196722663938999, -0.034624066203832626, -0.051460057497024536, 0.06886541098356247, -0.05434061959385872, 0.06083308160305023, 0.035898659378290176, 0.03905240446329117, -0.0012918970314785838, 0.012457707896828651, -0.0011262954212725163, -0.018352661281824112, 0.008572915568947792, 0.020232368260622025, -0.060926273465156555, -0.006414745002985001, 0.039459917694330215, 0.08522363752126694, -0.044464144855737686, 0.03942868113517761, 0.04031021147966385, 0.05336783826351166, -0.019807234406471252, 0.038100339472293854, -0.009631823748350143, 0.003905356163159013, 0.021204303950071335, -0.020050769671797752, 0.02364818938076496, -0.00936640053987503, -0.006547530181705952, 0.018597004935145378, 0.044555436819791794, -0.019763492047786713, -0.02274635061621666, 0.02390994131565094, -0.02410104125738144, -0.006408969406038523, 0.003899987321346998, -0.025594960898160934, 0.015338115394115448, -0.029923003166913986, 0.011998415924608707, 0.013842536136507988, 0.026719888672232628, 0.006159061100333929, -0.052814725786447525, 0.00596295902505517, 0.02017505094408989, -0.003745908383280039, -0.013169342651963234, 0.013894908130168915, 0.04681335389614105, -0.009512221440672874, 0.012100218795239925, -0.042269155383110046, -0.003410482546314597, -0.016865290701389313, 0.017154289409518242, 0.044407203793525696, -0.012954655103385448, 0.03241278603672981, 0.0058939214795827866, -0.008199676871299744, -0.0057326629757881165, -0.014824685640633106, 0.027996685355901718, -0.021445605903863907, -0.05958876013755798, 0.004166589584201574, -0.029427429661154747, -0.013286270201206207, 0.016907772049307823, -0.027736395597457886, 0.061051711440086365, -0.019982464611530304, -0.00023004638205748051, -0.07002568244934082, -0.035920318216085434, -0.049819860607385635, 0.04002750664949417, 0.0021383604034781456, -0.021096276119351387, 0.015218399465084076, 0.003358346177265048, -0.07199662178754807, 0.012601310387253761, -0.011408444494009018, -0.03536270558834076, -0.025997528806328773, -0.02889014594256878, 0.008436736650764942, -0.014714905060827732, -0.006206129211932421, 0.031527359038591385, -0.05173620209097862, -0.007951084524393082, -0.07123100012540817, -0.041407227516174316, 0.01894429512321949, 0.0021165895741432905, 0.05304833501577377, -0.01491483859717846, -0.030202314257621765, 0.07280861586332321, 0.024562392383813858, -0.03506261110305786, -0.02761905826628208, -0.0032729569356888533, -0.03168652951717377, -0.006948451977223158, 0.03853604942560196, 0.017260201275348663, 0.02093539759516716, 0.030526282265782356, 0.012933037243783474, 0.018356455489993095, 0.031359076499938965, -0.012418294325470924, -0.007531838025897741, -0.021742451936006546, -0.006986995693296194, -0.0018743746913969517, -0.020388439297676086, -0.00732762273401022, -0.06102323532104492, 0.0117377620190382, 0.00688156159594655, 0.022823328152298927, 0.03383505344390869, -0.051057323813438416, 0.03429824113845825, 0.0055305552668869495, 0.031144533306360245, -0.006683832034468651, -0.01452708151191473, -0.006322963163256645, 0.0038038527127355337, 0.019118575379252434, 0.013224536553025246, 0.03801542520523071, -0.012867854908108711, -0.0076073394156992435, 0.018007125705480576, 0.024365754798054695, -0.030730562284588814, 0.05810927972197533, 0.007631933316588402, 0.01131724938750267, -0.0029990868642926216, -0.011902306228876114, -0.017082776874303818, 0.034316904842853546, 0.01522115059196949, -0.006859051529318094, 0.013459976762533188, -0.014316975139081478, 0.0033550795633345842, -0.0863572433590889, 0.01020168699324131, 0.002166595309972763, 0.02093518152832985, -0.0004772196407429874, 0.03707968816161156, 0.005858124233782291, -0.020915666595101357, -0.015708258375525475, -0.0038150546606630087, -0.07260695099830627, -0.04147700220346451, -0.038503214716911316, 0.004866240546107292, 0.0074953665025532246, -0.04403093829751015, -0.008218933828175068, -0.009787473827600479, -0.022116510197520256, -0.03216889873147011, 0.024565523490309715, -0.05370064824819565, 0.014303511008620262, -0.011229978874325752, 0.004690662492066622, -0.026349307969212532, 0.008764497004449368, 0.058613575994968414, 0.00832462403923273, 0.01539952214807272, 0.03409898653626442, -0.01780758984386921, -0.013926714658737183, -0.0031627046409994364, 0.044647008180618286, 0.02628769539296627, 0.03652678430080414, -0.019867852330207825, 0.02564919926226139, 0.01712045632302761, 0.0038970881141722202, 0.008979424834251404, 0.03734656423330307, -0.009097769856452942, -0.002932283328846097, -0.020052505657076836, -0.05727258697152138, -0.03922886773943901, 0.0024574913550168276, 0.030017433688044548, -0.0029352926649153233, -0.006868938449770212, 0.05906634405255318, 0.03853531926870346, -0.029298942536115646, 0.019787877798080444, 0.04350109398365021, 0.009497090242803097, -0.016742464154958725, -0.011482498608529568, -0.024623019620776176, -0.004967365879565477, -0.0059929052367806435, 0.040966518223285675, -0.02524423599243164, -0.024795962497591972, -0.004367091227322817, 0.05964531749486923, -0.005120522808283567, -0.023327238857746124, 0.008824897930026054, -0.0019302013097330928, 0.00034261669497936964, -0.021972229704260826, -0.01770773157477379, 0.0021954772528260946, 0.06369829922914505, 0.04585205018520355, 0.04503539204597473, 0.0018799296813085675, -0.062160082161426544, 0.0030704219825565815, -0.004319033585488796, 0.007418967317789793, 0.006643496919423342, -0.005939245689660311, -0.042862068861722946, -0.01884753257036209, 0.030902618542313576, 0.008923282846808434, 0.038994867354631424, -0.02999190427362919, 0.014505577273666859, -0.03742752969264984, -0.032374076545238495, -0.022729067131876945, -0.00932867918163538, 0.04548221454024315, 0.0248985905200243, -0.013903716579079628, -0.031019894406199455, -0.026036370545625687, 0.04513416811823845, 0.032127585262060165, 0.0651172623038292, 0.03599012643098831, -0.006822528317570686, -0.012243294157087803, 0.038330428302288055, -0.043483950197696686, -0.04800174757838249, 0.028886612504720688, -0.004279807209968567, -0.03094582073390484, 0.03596394509077072, -0.03061993047595024, -0.03696809336543083, 0.004875291604548693, 0.016800224781036377, -0.01170446164906025, 0.011114224791526794, -0.00001529091787233483, 0.051594484597444534, 0.03223558887839317, 0.0310132447630167, 0.07637716084718704, -0.00532611133530736, -0.037119023501873016, -0.020980902016162872, -0.012274942360818386, 0.03525744378566742, -0.04343629628419876, 0.00010548916907282546, -0.02037341520190239, 0.0049356212839484215, -0.023169444873929024, 0.03632700815796852, 0.0011007061693817377, 0.03676309436559677, -0.010930017568171024, -0.014076173305511475, -0.0015260440995916724, 0.046864114701747894, 0.007395273540169001, -0.006266560405492783, -0.0011923894053325057, 0.04314252361655235, -0.021599136292934418, 0.007348060142248869, 0.027538053691387177, 0.016058851033449173, 0.01871682144701481, 0.048750948160886765, 0.0013156015193089843, -0.005047233309596777, -0.043184082955121994, -0.017343223094940186, -0.0028607023414224386, -0.024432625621557236, 0.02933938056230545, -0.02013998106122017, 0.016489015892148018, 0.01235138438642025, -0.06997503340244293, 0.035136669874191284, -0.0009915728587657213, -0.01806282065808773, 0.035676389932632446, -0.024184221401810646, 0.004372200928628445, -0.02215064875781536, -0.013641892932355404, -0.0665142610669136, -0.08788539469242096, 0.0035432088188827038, 0.016985109075903893, 0.00620851619169116, -0.039788465946912766, -0.014835425652563572, -0.027324160560965538, -0.04362984001636505, -0.03180248662829399, 0.08257178217172623, 0.01552849542349577, -0.01342321839183569, 0.006957381963729858, 0.03195398300886154, 0.03490366414189339, -0.032478608191013336, 0.012121285311877728, -0.022931305691599846, -0.013055328279733658, 0.05181784927845001, -0.011794856749475002, 0.026256125420331955, -0.02404361590743065, 0.0029973324853926897, -0.023454658687114716, -0.022205926477909088, 0.04232773929834366, -0.027302134782075882, -0.02030090242624283, 0.021430131047964096, -0.008686535991728306, 0.004419182427227497, 0.01242873352020979, 0.0008837088826112449, -0.0218500979244709, -0.00699196569621563, 0.01061240304261446, -0.012926380150020123, -0.020285502076148987, -0.044019997119903564, 0.062134452164173126, -0.002320680534467101, 0.02366517297923565, 0.000686035375110805, 0.028733117505908012, -0.0129923140630126, -0.0013576417695730925, -0.0016031739069148898, 0.004447532817721367, 0.02884187176823616, -0.011620007455348969, -0.0008214590488933027, -0.01270661223679781, 0.026839962229132652, -0.0302159134298563, -0.05410677194595337, 0.0017817766638472676, 0.06344106793403625, 0.04181819409132004, -0.015561720356345177, 0.03850335255265236, 0.04855996370315552, -0.030313795432448387, -0.014843545854091644, -0.034079890698194504, -0.013922069221735, 0.00432707741856575, -0.016570663079619408, 0.06553581357002258, 0.01466826070100069, -0.022546440362930298, 0.03276728466153145, 0.03445730358362198, 0.017047030851244926, 0.008072469383478165, 0.033385809510946274, -0.013927948661148548, 0.04370323568582535, -0.025083277374505997, -0.03274199366569519, 0.05558672174811363, -0.06623418629169464, -0.010320961475372314, -0.00868718046694994, 0.012774565257132053, 0.016724945977330208, 0.01921978034079075, -0.011671682819724083, -0.0451272614300251, -0.0349394828081131, -0.017991112545132637, -0.003711210796609521, 0.018454793840646744, 0.010719806887209415, 0.05302281677722931, -0.011236936785280704, 0.02047187276184559, 0.030958129093050957, 0.0060260179452598095, 0.022299423813819885, -0.05629393830895424, -0.05948891118168831, -0.048424698412418365, -0.03601390868425369, 0.02301274612545967, 0.03865024819970131, -0.05211653932929039, 0.039139360189437866, -0.06464873254299164, 0.01869524084031582, 0.01205226220190525, 0.024427274242043495, -0.017577001824975014, 0.03401881456375122, 0.01980559527873993, 0.0055878073908388615, -0.032289378345012665, -0.013867013156414032, 0.11567721515893936, 0.09996958822011948, 0.043321095407009125, -0.07339291274547577, 0.034772977232933044, -0.012134140357375145, -0.0387580469250679, -0.05157564952969551, 0.015592769719660282, 0.009753966704010963, 0.002614313270896673, 0.011246216483414173, 0.061959508806467056, 0.013290183618664742, -0.026845518499612808, 0.03507450222969055, -0.08272677659988403, 0.013362830504775047, 0.008250013925135136, -0.00984910223633051, -0.004923827014863491, -0.022344181314110756, -0.06102493405342102, -0.006228724494576454, 0.002942613558843732, -0.02814636379480362, -0.020288746803998947, 0.022998768836259842, 0.019861167296767235, -0.004908081144094467, -0.045911554247140884, 0.002682984806597233, 0.031042780727148056, -0.014742637053132057, -0.012015914544463158, 0.03737093135714531, -0.0005534300580620766, -0.019296444952487946, -0.007360825315117836, -0.02250063046813011, 0.00041321158641949296, -0.004494701977819204, -0.010579301975667477, -0.02030881494283676, -0.04494998976588249, -0.040888912975788116, -0.046749047935009, 0.03806046396493912, -0.021421056240797043, -0.03839055076241493, 0.004449429456144571, -0.0036857929080724716, 0.009790005162358284, -0.047769222408533096, 0.0009917428251355886, 0.013475713320076466, 0.0448107048869133, 0.019564229995012283, -0.012612604536116123, -0.00820221845060587, 0.034522101283073425, -0.01261297520250082, 0.017420820891857147, -0.02425307035446167, -0.05838949605822563, -0.009174769744277, -0.0016268453327938914, 0.0023433598689734936, 0.006682069040834904, 0.022811446338891983, -0.03245930001139641, 0.0031160416547209024, -0.04476422443985939, -0.04654645547270775, -0.01405034214258194, -0.005727387499064207, 0.026147305965423584, 0.014988381415605545, -0.0501067154109478, 0.002863120287656784, -0.06256496161222458, 0.004722481593489647, -0.01825837604701519, -0.028380008414387703, -0.03475695848464966, 0.00560131436213851, 0.020575307309627533, 0.04385681822896004, 0.03665034472942352, 0.00027284593670628965, -0.03244692459702492, 0.024577906355261803, -0.019935932010412216, -0.029625479131937027, 0.0025194173213094473, -0.023877417668700218, -0.0380009226500988, 0.023377390578389168, 0.012039738707244396, 0.03167261183261871, 0.032400015741586685, 0.00720901507884264, 0.005521990358829498, 0.04371670261025429, -0.005210012197494507, 0.003775112796574831, 0.05237739905714989, -0.035438694059848785, -0.019068606197834015, 0.03664151206612587, 0.018191887065768242, -0.03708629310131073, -0.032310113310813904, -0.06154632940888405, 0.011024469509720802, -0.0023584128357470036, 0.009426448494195938, -0.022535359486937523, 0.0032902080565690994, -0.003656434128060937, 0.04415678232908249, -0.036534879356622696, -0.045609667897224426, -0.0179151464253664, 0.031911760568618774, -0.01053475122898817, -0.011002681218087673, -0.008149645291268826, -0.010354910977184772, -0.01023076195269823, 0.0005450148601084948, 0.04364735260605812, 0.0038407682441174984, -0.004643294028937817, -0.014736993238329887, 0.029624732211232185, 0.00668921647593379, 0.028121374547481537, -0.05011190101504326, -0.014566197991371155, 0.028130633756518364, -0.0343056358397007, -0.08009058982133865, -0.026518462225794792, -0.027545390650629997, 0.00456987926736474, 0.0268842875957489, -0.001793638220988214, -0.06876876950263977, 0.03837712109088898, -0.028919853270053864, -0.01136457733809948, 0.01657918095588684, 0.009091534651815891, -0.009190703742206097, -0.005472743883728981, 0.006909307092428207, -0.035009827464818954, -0.019727429375052452, -0.003616832196712494, -0.0236527007073164, 0.027783101424574852, -0.01693301647901535, 0.012446735985577106, -0.01793862320482731, 0.06882345676422119, 0.010991486720740795, -0.029832376167178154, 0.02761227637529373, 0.06031094118952751, -0.057045962661504745, 0.013772782869637012, 0.060141656547784805, 0.01710803620517254, -0.10283820331096649, -0.020985253155231476, 0.000499504734762013, 0.007881681434810162, 0.034287743270397186, -0.059103187173604965, 0.006881106179207563, 0.0439358726143837, -0.09891336411237717, 0.00963585451245308, -0.007905382663011551, 0.010783864185214043, -0.07396713644266129, -0.003929166588932276, -0.04933914169669151, 0.03519560769200325, 0.033802226185798645, 0.015062114223837852, 0.011934704147279263, 0.0528559572994709, 0.0038005239330232143, -0.015783771872520447, -0.01472286507487297, -0.01101960800588131, -0.035134367644786835, -0.03229654207825661, 0.04628138989210129, 0.01840296946465969, -0.0702463686466217, 0.007225069683045149, -0.0282638780772686, -0.014617424458265305, 0.01306784525513649, 0.028333289548754692, 0.037549618631601334, 0.030655022710561752, 0.01802666112780571, -0.0240384042263031, -0.008599640801548958, -0.012692754156887531, 0.006431272719055414, 0.014198428019881248, 0.022816307842731476, -0.009136397391557693, 0.017303908243775368, -0.003525731386616826, -0.030150577425956726, 0.00821276567876339, -0.0033275450114160776, -0.007790890522301197, -0.0014067006995901465, 0.011819957755506039, 0.012010624632239342, -0.011654628440737724, 0.018533136695623398, -0.019666267558932304, -0.02556057646870613, 0.003284204052761197, 0.02361851930618286, -0.035474743694067, 0.008059212937951088, -0.032220203429460526, -0.05153389275074005, 0.0018652346916496754, 0.03978831321001053, 0.03851215913891792, -0.06272386014461517, -0.012808499857783318, 0.010724936611950397, -0.014660482294857502, 0.014223604463040829, -0.03496431186795235, -0.011790315620601177, 0.03583010658621788, 0.011204221285879612, 0.04173025116324425, -0.02261493355035782, -0.019320877268910408, 0.014872037805616856, -0.055693261325359344, 0.07878012955188751, -0.026374202221632004, 0.03817136958241463, -0.027149252593517303, -0.02700037695467472, -0.04429978132247925, 0.008842955343425274, 0.05545993521809578, 0.014122866094112396, 0.011350525543093681, -0.004373309668153524, 0.00835383404046297, -0.015889761969447136, 0.0014857930364087224, 0.01667172461748123, -0.008146601729094982, -0.014744491316378117, -0.00973830558359623, -0.03261662647128105, 0.03405090048909187, 0.02224506251513958, 0.01818438060581684, -0.016605395823717117, 0.019407982006669044, -0.0066267140209674835, 0.008025338873267174, 0.046606577932834625, 0.004522652830928564, -0.028697537258267403, 0.06529957801103592, 0.013215438462793827, 0.043440017849206924, -0.0031621784437447786, -0.024771464988589287, -0.030714862048625946, -0.009235712699592113, -0.041682664304971695, -0.007237112615257502, -0.031271494925022125, 0.052700020372867584, -0.005830646958202124, -0.009184753522276878, 0.012076917104423046, 0.033339984714984894, -0.016319187358021736, -0.013400412164628506, 0.03576583415269852, -0.006447345484048128, 0.019116777926683426, 0.007986973039805889, 0.02007349394261837, 0.011438324116170406, 0.01122163888067007, 0.016357071697711945, 0.010024460032582283, 0.045031629502773285, -0.00213259388692677, 0.01356058195233345, 0.04243630915880203, -0.016964834183454514, 0.04645325616002083, 0.0046684471890330315, 0.07941734790802002, -0.016240548342466354, -0.011887536384165287, -0.00296806707046926, -0.022541917860507965, 0.013756430707871914, -0.001685526454821229, -0.038871657103300095, 0.08910613507032394, -0.03454620763659477, -0.01642640121281147, -0.025282476097345352, -0.0006601028726436198, 0.0122574707493186, -0.03498726710677147, -0.00030974281253293157, 0.02787616290152073, -0.023513365536928177, 0.016207881271839142, -0.01957172527909279, 0.0067188069224357605, 0.02658643014729023, -0.0010516170877963305, 0.008831840008497238, 0.019404051825404167, -0.0010518773924559355, -0.0016329610953107476, -0.0022894437424838543, -0.0014642230235040188, -0.023466330021619797, 0.021867116913199425, 0.04912158474326134, 0.00943131186068058, -0.014795864932239056, -0.0455918125808239, -0.018624484539031982, 0.05970136076211929, -0.0671442300081253, -0.013313136994838715, -0.05121824890375137, 0.022568928077816963, -0.02066199481487274, 0.019472159445285797 ]
<p>1. Which one is NOT a linear regression models? Please give a 1-2 sentences brief explanation to your choice.<br> (a) $y_i = β_0 +\exp(β_1x_i)+E_i, i = 1, 2, \ldots, n$<br> (b) $y_i = β_0 + β_1x_i + β_2 x_{ii} + E_i , i = 1, 2, \ldots, n$<br> (c) $y_i =β_0\exp(x_i)+β_2x_i^7 +E_i, i=1, 2,\ldots, n$ </p> <p>2. Suppose $X$ and $Y$ has linear correlation coefficient $r = 0.5$, and there are 77 observations, what is the test statistic for the hypothesis test </p> <p>$$H0:β_1=0 \quad\text{vs.}\quad Ha:β_1\neq0 $$</p> <p>where $β_1$ comes from the simple linear regression model below? Please give a 1-2 sentences brief explanation to your choice. $\quad Y = β_0 + β_1X + E$ </p> <p>(a). Not enough information<br> (b). 5<br> (c). 0.25 </p> <p>3. Which model is more possible to have smaller $R^2$? Please give a 1-2 sentences brief explanation to your choice.<br> A: $Y=β_0+β_1X_1+E$<br> B: $Y=β_0^*+β_1^*X_1+β_2^*X_2+E^*$<br> where $Y$ and $X_1$ in model A and B are the same.</p> <p>(a). Not enough information<br> (b). Model A<br> (c). Model B </p>
73,529
[ -0.05081818252801895, 0.008021666668355465, -0.015552599914371967, -0.00411271071061492, 0.02730296552181244, -0.0024944415781646967, 0.009322483092546463, -0.009029855951666832, 0.05238652229309082, -0.01502986066043377, 0.02881035767495632, 0.03061326965689659, 0.03296159580349922, 0.008752606809139252, 0.03215717524290085, 0.034068718552589417, -0.004862226080149412, 0.01811918243765831, 0.004430336412042379, 0.011967948637902737, 0.0030002640560269356, -0.021696003153920174, 0.041348639875650406, 0.02454681508243084, -0.028821712359786034, 0.0500386618077755, 0.05913218855857849, -0.02470027655363083, -0.008245437406003475, 0.06202564388513565, 0.02141321264207363, -0.016215095296502113, 0.0037198495119810104, 0.03946975991129875, 0.0013107871636748314, -0.0021901193540543318, 0.005683029070496559, -0.028700627386569977, 0.008589193224906921, 0.01211259700357914, 0.0012026423355564475, -0.051603443920612335, 0.043436747044324875, 0.028233304619789124, -0.0008632739190943539, -0.006793828681111336, 0.04249877855181694, -0.04489971324801445, 0.015992887318134308, -0.03573286160826683, 0.0757918581366539, -0.002909525530412793, 0.015737781301140785, 0.032208237797021866, -0.025988472625613213, -0.009157666936516762, 0.008858365938067436, 0.07000061869621277, -0.025920363143086433, -0.07050580531358719, -0.011890004388988018, -0.009674126282334328, 0.013765497133135796, 0.014598180539906025, -0.05960695445537567, 0.02658945508301258, -0.002016032813116908, -0.020673682913184166, 0.04887615516781807, -0.00201884051784873, 0.029518183320760727, 0.030535174533724785, 0.027234140783548355, -0.00029176368843764067, 0.02223786525428295, -0.0007512623560614884, -0.0005451062461361289, 0.03191779926419258, 0.04916843771934509, 0.058642029762268066, 0.004277351778000593, 0.019209889695048332, 0.05315330997109413, 0.054440636187791824, 0.020408250391483307, -0.01923571527004242, 0.07578127831220627, 0.019183749333024025, 0.0022133656311780214, 0.018541773781180382, -0.01150252390652895, -0.005612748209387064, 0.03606921061873436, -0.003364869626238942, -0.025835150852799416, 0.04270080476999283, -0.008657196536660194, 0.056896090507507324, 0.027025599032640457, -0.010713857598602772, -0.026337623596191406, -0.038928497582674026, 0.02047211118042469, 0.055845584720373154, -0.007336209062486887, -0.030860649421811104, -0.030413322150707245, 0.0217390488833189, -0.001485119923017919, -0.027254199609160423, -0.025083141401410103, 0.03920380026102066, -0.015206905081868172, 0.016834640875458717, 0.019320474937558174, -0.02371937967836857, -0.020538290962576866, -0.02568756230175495, 0.08215565979480743, 0.07379093021154404, 0.05990166217088699, -0.021756606176495552, -0.008972818031907082, 0.004376507829874754, -0.028584906831383705, -0.014658215455710888, -0.0015593372518196702, -0.0283631831407547, -0.05586928129196167, 0.056427180767059326, -0.018116671591997147, -0.02036544308066368, 0.006143960636109114, 0.0014173532836139202, 0.019908258691430092, 0.029916075989603996, -0.08285308629274368, -0.05587245523929596, 0.060726065188646317, -0.015810424461960793, -0.0036370749585330486, -0.024284249171614647, -0.02030847780406475, 0.05348769947886467, 0.06620614975690842, 0.010349435731768608, 0.035166360437870026, -0.006182757671922445, 0.021370580419898033, 0.01833263598382473, -0.013375254347920418, 0.002408138941973448, -0.025518283247947693, -0.04018539562821388, 0.015047886408865452, -0.08764380216598511, -0.0012520903255790472, 0.013483182527124882, -0.03322213515639305, -0.011931905522942543, 0.04187556728720665, 0.007673772983253002, -0.027836505323648453, 0.019568610936403275, 0.006114585790783167, 0.009740959852933884, 0.0627419725060463, 0.011262883432209492, 0.0203465074300766, 0.03742038086056709, -0.025244547054171562, 0.03223257511854172, -0.00012833175424020737, 0.019948676228523254, 0.04384622350335121, 0.001111285644583404, -0.01752791926264763, -0.00787998829036951, 0.02820327691733837, 0.0352914035320282, -0.10361358523368835, -0.03792401775717735, -0.011487388052046299, -0.006003457121551037, 0.02021019533276558, 0.05604073032736778, 0.0005316773313097656, -0.03628028929233551, 0.032327380031347275, -0.00897061824798584, -0.049754783511161804, -0.06198819726705551, 0.012845483608543873, -0.00819643959403038, -0.013694428838789463, 0.038837168365716934, -0.008808262646198273, -0.02275215834379196, -0.016786785796284676, -0.009336761198937893, -0.024054469540715218, 0.01494309026747942, 0.02340007573366165, -0.016773784533143044, 0.0126866539940238, 0.05009504407644272, 0.019959021359682083, -0.03742513805627823, 0.01717950589954853, -0.0388433001935482, -0.010354319587349892, 0.016293445602059364, 0.018684085458517075, 0.01191274356096983, -0.026071986183524132, -0.024184880778193474, -0.017354249954223633, 0.002636286895722151, -0.01760047860443592, 0.04494427889585495, -0.0721784234046936, 0.031100651249289513, 0.05931293964385986, 0.055533476173877716, 0.010789432562887669, 0.002831351011991501, 0.016236091032624245, 0.05040929093956947, -0.028122328221797943, 0.011870767921209335, -0.04203937202692032, 0.014532939530909061, -0.003738515777513385, 0.0018232621951028705, -0.029605807736516, 0.034142084419727325, 0.056008316576480865, 0.02421109937131405, -0.025227993726730347, 0.02132442221045494, 0.005547193344682455, -0.019196202978491783, -0.010835712775588036, -0.0022801130544394255, 0.007550597190856934, -0.0021103299222886562, 0.0005187856731936336, 0.0063622212037444115, 0.043683093041181564, -0.01608589105308056, 0.010745593346655369, 0.06259336322546005, 0.024076612666249275, -0.02611488476395607, -0.007662058807909489, -0.003319980576634407, 0.0241702813655138, 0.008704989217221737, -0.014959071762859821, 0.022073369473218918, -0.014188108965754509, 0.014115093275904655, 0.0066266655921936035, -0.014116107486188412, -0.0016443844651803374, 0.0011297640157863498, -0.013229915872216225, -0.00958980992436409, 0.022098559886217117, -0.05549158155918121, 0.0016426157671958208, -0.03383912518620491, -0.004813530948013067, -0.06202886998653412, -0.008717397227883339, 0.05643531680107117, 0.0021461311262100935, 0.02515481784939766, -0.022580603137612343, -0.013817008584737778, 0.028567209839820862, -0.0558742992579937, 0.006944236811250448, -0.025124697014689445, -0.07836472988128662, 0.013007975183427334, -0.07700283825397491, 0.015199407935142517, 0.023775983601808548, -0.029373954981565475, -0.016390401870012283, 0.03247435763478279, 0.0023998518008738756, -0.06623795628547668, -0.06109847500920296, -0.04798909276723862, 0.027713755145668983, -0.019572116434574127, -0.06041070818901062, 0.0398038811981678, -0.02197585068643093, -0.040937647223472595, 0.024311410263180733, -0.04131391644477844, -0.017652861773967743, 0.005477861501276493, -0.006953695323318243, 0.002375831129029393, 0.024843690916895866, 0.005706472788006067, 0.010049194097518921, -0.011443497613072395, 0.0007572387694381177, -0.07645905762910843, -0.05055835098028183, 0.011345714330673218, -0.008012092672288418, 0.01764230616390705, -0.00450233044102788, -0.026896754279732704, 0.04465112090110779, 0.05335332825779915, -0.034155040979385376, -0.04561857879161835, 0.02019602805376053, -0.024655910208821297, -0.0371537059545517, 0.012620799243450165, 0.018946465104818344, 0.0020775706507265568, 0.010059610940515995, 0.0202037300914526, 0.02158098667860031, 0.004496798384934664, -0.03352644667029381, 0.021290598437190056, 0.006727004423737526, 0.013597733341157436, -0.03000979870557785, 0.042349133640527725, 0.016717268154025078, -0.028473349288105965, 0.027100693434476852, -0.0118284085765481, 0.028548914939165115, 0.030476020649075508, -0.01765238493680954, 0.018862923607230186, 0.0235081035643816, -0.00022183527471497655, -0.005642589647322893, 0.002740070689469576, 0.03465312346816063, -0.0055053262040019035, 0.0075800069607794285, -0.0159764364361763, 0.009002241306006908, -0.023402977734804153, -0.0024891295470297337, 0.033957939594984055, 0.053032729774713516, -0.023288032039999962, 0.00459953723475337, -0.004835069179534912, -0.00958182755857706, 0.011239736340939999, -0.00336688500829041, -0.007767218630760908, 0.08400487899780273, 0.036324746906757355, 0.036474213004112244, 0.00015990811516530812, -0.029395652934908867, -0.014327598735690117, -0.08140590041875839, 0.0278067197650671, -0.020216654986143112, 0.06225255876779556, 0.009211740456521511, 0.015288378112018108, -0.0047010332345962524, -0.03581707179546356, 0.02752036601305008, -0.004178515635430813, -0.06776639819145203, 0.05317114666104317, -0.0015910203801468015, 0.005087712779641151, 0.045014072209596634, 0.0227192472666502, 0.03816300258040428, -0.030539903789758682, 0.012413978576660156, 0.008603524416685104, 0.02093125320971012, -0.015326880849897861, -0.018142713233828545, -0.022711217403411865, -0.03040318936109543, 0.020521998405456543, -0.0019901965279132128, -0.03290017321705818, -0.04342440515756607, 0.020293209701776505, 0.03792509436607361, -0.010828064754605293, 0.02430586703121662, 0.02422180585563183, -0.009528298862278461, 0.013580908998847008, 0.037320565432310104, 0.016181549057364464, 0.012067197822034359, 0.0023878987412899733, -0.010449858382344246, 0.005514506716281176, 0.007568345870822668, 0.042455121874809265, 0.010684837587177753, -0.028480350971221924, -0.02997683174908161, -0.0004338711150921881, -0.026408644393086433, 0.047858480364084244, 0.016553832218050957, -0.01739637181162834, 0.051606450229883194, 0.018068891018629074, 0.0009030613582581282, 0.03517543151974678, 0.04680303484201431, 0.014318211935460567, 0.02080121450126171, 0.012578827328979969, -0.012643805705010891, -0.0029059594962745905, 0.00555186765268445, 0.030873645097017288, -0.018370646983385086, 0.005351079627871513, -0.03548517823219299, 0.05965208262205124, -0.021698856726288795, -0.012344366870820522, 0.015868671238422394, 0.026370717212557793, 0.027900999411940575, 0.030163848772644997, -0.08845767378807068, -0.016131510958075523, 0.034793026745319366, 0.03679465129971504, -0.0013509419513866305, -0.03286474198102951, -0.062233153730630875, 0.012530998326838017, 0.03165743872523308, 0.05830366164445877, -0.028575822710990906, -0.022283367812633514, -0.010695362463593483, -0.04188170284032822, 0.017846252769231796, -0.03615259751677513, 0.008401560597121716, -0.023883897811174393, 0.027429256588220596, -0.018000660464167595, -0.005864276550710201, -0.06311579048633575, -0.0017981104319915175, -0.003510920563712716, 0.016844678670167923, -0.03251998499035835, -0.030581530183553696, -0.028265247121453285, -0.022617902606725693, 0.030479028820991516, 0.0597369521856308, -0.04211374744772911, -0.03671935200691223, 0.03953388333320618, 0.02950429357588291, -0.016070570796728134, -0.0533650666475296, 0.01043615024536848, 0.0018360997783020139, -0.036646950989961624, 0.05515130236744881, -0.03534916415810585, -0.04932514205574989, -0.00712269451469183, -0.008906636387109756, -0.044089674949645996, -0.0005370789440348744, -0.012909432873129845, 0.06334547698497772, 0.0407213531434536, 0.022694872692227364, 0.06646508723497391, 0.051551029086112976, -0.016564153134822845, -0.0034738504327833652, -0.04491265118122101, -0.05178631469607353, -0.012912395410239697, -0.018073318526148796, -0.06129474192857742, 0.0018927148776128888, -0.011516349390149117, 0.023266905918717384, 0.006378966383635998, 0.004392209928482771, -0.04866531863808632, -0.027964362874627113, 0.006585931871086359, 0.05017756298184395, -0.028313303366303444, -0.021787801757454872, -0.0004194935318082571, 0.0094341104850173, -0.008097252808511257, -0.039371803402900696, 0.017372123897075653, -0.014107882045209408, 0.013579079881310463, 0.03183332085609436, -0.032708365470170975, 0.01835056021809578, -0.011353913694620132, 0.024209225550293922, -0.02056434378027916, -0.06203199923038483, 0.02199849858880043, 0.029423542320728302, 0.019986644387245178, 0.007843690924346447, -0.0124278012663126, -0.038506414741277695, 0.002866139402613044, 0.012835511937737465, 0.020986083894968033, -0.02994396537542343, 0.03846753016114235, -0.03486456722021103, -0.04488484188914299, -0.04875320568680763, -0.061216216534376144, 0.022786926478147507, 0.022749176248908043, -0.01375481765717268, -0.019243383780121803, -0.0008337784674949944, -0.041583627462387085, 0.010889374651014805, -0.06479434669017792, 0.03907546028494835, -0.02071192115545273, -0.0091540003195405, 0.023774800822138786, 0.02885327860713005, 0.06834492832422256, 0.015995988622307777, -0.023555587977170944, 0.005993777886033058, 0.008939685299992561, -0.026369526982307434, 0.0023892333265393972, 0.013733727857470512, -0.03868837654590607, -0.011504655703902245, -0.03025408461689949, -0.012397825717926025, 0.053802601993083954, 0.007489569019526243, -0.023454435169696808, 0.008879649452865124, -0.0008313869475387037, -0.044016189873218536, -0.006640223786234856, -0.01725565455853939, -0.022748244926333427, 0.034839291125535965, -0.01327553205192089, 0.007360893301665783, -0.01372003648430109, 0.0032789306715130806, 0.021714571863412857, -0.0026924589183181524, -0.04142049327492714, 0.02340337261557579, 0.09048379957675934, 0.017787102609872818, 0.049600355327129364, 0.008357184007763863, -0.015191531740128994, 0.056119486689567566, 0.014915949665009975, 0.007128326687961817, -0.006586609873920679, 0.02617792598903179, -0.025232097133994102, -0.04100225865840912, -0.049490176141262054, 0.04971819370985031, 0.045610006898641586, -0.03708336502313614, 0.019364632666110992, 0.04280110076069832, 0.0052727521397173405, -0.0050260466523468494, -0.0329168476164341, -0.018375134095549583, -0.029811019077897072, 0.03180701658129692, 0.031084951013326645, -0.02695637196302414, -0.04721967130899429, 0.03910766541957855, 0.023854989558458328, 0.008658421225845814, 0.0111167524009943, 0.02047370746731758, 0.020221006125211716, 0.012563740834593773, -0.04659632593393326, -0.04405862092971802, 0.0384785495698452, -0.025742916390299797, 0.005347904749214649, -0.02437438629567623, -0.034752897918224335, 0.062336765229701996, 0.012908305041491985, -0.011451181024312973, -0.08680631965398788, -0.02163371630012989, -0.06874843686819077, 0.00166962924413383, -0.00007764388283248991, -0.01655801571905613, 0.021032797172665596, -0.013090484775602818, -0.006472595036029816, -0.012839660979807377, 0.0467219352722168, -0.03719734400510788, -0.09850326925516129, -0.04003448039293289, -0.005962322931736708, -0.04371611028909683, 0.039235830307006836, 0.01605033129453659, -0.05197485163807869, 0.025086713954806328, -0.04306034743785858, 0.022721465677022934, 0.028681930154561996, 0.03475707396864891, -0.027211423963308334, 0.045889321714639664, -0.04229627549648285, -0.025962047278881073, -0.001721980283036828, -0.02778535895049572, 0.10720045119524002, 0.05968134105205536, 0.014842452481389046, -0.05896499752998352, 0.039349235594272614, 0.013342209160327911, 0.0018392038764432073, -0.003339490620419383, -0.0147540383040905, 0.0056055462919175625, 0.019401803612709045, 0.050999391824007034, 0.07709863036870956, -0.00011864144471473992, 0.011063227429986, 0.025289956480264664, -0.02342325635254383, -0.032379914075136185, -0.014765800908207893, -0.0048172310926020145, 0.024160899221897125, 0.008929641917347908, -0.032730501145124435, -0.02923702448606491, 0.004557330161333084, 0.013911213725805283, -0.03231293335556984, -0.025202419608831406, 0.020397191867232323, 0.029609601944684982, -0.015743635594844818, 0.029530232772231102, 0.01638312079012394, 0.01879909634590149, -0.013613888062536716, 0.020444976165890694, 0.016421591863036156, -0.03822963684797287, 0.017497893422842026, 0.009879046119749546, -0.008766455575823784, -0.00452899094671011, 0.012896109372377396, 0.007080922834575176, -0.07193002104759216, 0.00994157325476408, -0.03462853655219078, 0.03909884765744209, -0.024713870137929916, -0.026419419795274734, 0.00019971124129369855, 0.00591679522767663, -0.022814681753516197, -0.002555384300649166, -0.03216913342475891, 0.040214113891124725, 0.013884199783205986, -0.027363190427422523, -0.04388440400362015, -0.04739692807197571, 0.017665741965174675, -0.011291736736893654, 0.03874002769589424, 0.04001530259847641, -0.0524187795817852, -0.0021923487074673176, 0.0047199600376188755, 0.06296996027231216, 0.000747367215808481, 0.0117034325376153, 0.01966889388859272, -0.00017587596084922552, -0.009378122165799141, -0.016961174085736275, 0.03039548173546791, 0.010795438662171364, 0.02928922325372696, -0.012692036107182503, 0.005859884899109602, 0.002427221043035388, -0.023550940677523613, -0.019802844151854515, 0.028069108724594116, 0.009147061966359615, -0.06726856529712677, -0.004751348868012428, 0.01915905810892582, 0.017372198402881622, 0.015895595774054527, -0.01963040418922901, 0.015497862361371517, 0.03443958982825279, 0.010914493352174759, -0.07599982619285583, -0.003827066859230399, -0.007604766637086868, -0.010458787903189659, -0.0029234939720481634, -0.015987345948815346, 0.05659235641360283, 0.011417588219046593, 0.0008743786020204425, -0.0012999254977330565, 0.017355671152472496, -0.03852415829896927, -0.0219894926995039, 0.011280435137450695, -0.05172820761799812, 0.019092056900262833, 0.06257284432649612, 0.009162613190710545, -0.04199552163481712, -0.014927161857485771, -0.037690334022045135, -0.018005287274718285, 0.0003249339060857892, -0.003246538108214736, -0.05573621392250061, 0.010335213504731655, -0.0024794447235763073, 0.029466941952705383, -0.044988613575696945, 0.009349819272756577, -0.027670161798596382, 0.021234499290585518, 0.014523552730679512, -0.023485306650400162, 0.011623743921518326, 0.047489702701568604, -0.033793143928050995, -0.009526675567030907, 0.022194426506757736, 0.029307963326573372, 0.016626950353384018, -0.013682662509381771, -0.022202353924512863, 0.0027209091931581497, 0.04328779876232147, -0.029673216864466667, -0.027321096509695053, 0.04119322448968887, -0.02778848446905613, -0.027343805879354477, 0.007634672336280346, 0.006557032465934753, 0.015863221138715744, -0.00140293943695724, -0.014401828870177269, -0.0007062277873046696, 0.06060219556093216, -0.018050741404294968, 0.004405088257044554, -0.027537977322936058, -0.012845545075833797, -0.00952601246535778, -0.009225934743881226, 0.02650962397456169, -0.00833957176655531, -0.0007772893877699971, 0.03836829960346222, 0.06415969133377075, -0.023518960922956467, -0.01876208744943142, 0.003623194294050336, 0.041995543986558914, 0.024867353960871696, -0.0009049981599673629, 0.000585363304708153, 0.01770624704658985, 0.02548803575336933, -0.035075269639492035, 0.03896592929959297, 0.013616387732326984, 0.004310620483011007, -0.10324770957231522, -0.03533320501446724, 0.008133308961987495, 0.01487320102751255, 0.025925064459443092, -0.035389434546232224, 0.010526027530431747, 0.06724561005830765, -0.08050300180912018, -0.010499313473701477, -0.014573482796549797, 0.005368431098759174, -0.015535819344222546, 0.007082242518663406, -0.025388654321432114, 0.028550542891025543, 0.027777494862675667, 0.061061251908540726, 0.03482428565621376, 0.012966391630470753, 0.010426638647913933, -0.042752474546432495, 0.0015829588519409299, 0.012901845388114452, -0.0033827784936875105, -0.08514945209026337, 0.022097272798419, -0.025985466316342354, -0.017297713086009026, 0.05202707648277283, -0.007458056323230267, 0.040892455726861954, -0.0002119681885233149, -0.00875864177942276, 0.007392526138573885, 0.019394617527723312, 0.030298633500933647, -0.01634492166340351, -0.03259635716676712, -0.02662171982228756, -0.005392174236476421, 0.016248956322669983, 0.017869679257273674, 0.014610840938985348, 0.0020777536556124687, 0.03182976692914963, -0.006992545444518328, 0.016918977722525597, -0.025178242474794388, -0.02943190559744835, -0.009580531157553196, -0.0014045990537852049, -0.038570769131183624, -0.03443131968379021, -0.006027102004736662, -0.03108067251741886, -0.0034339609555900097, 0.010944610461592674, 0.02184605970978737, -0.04322028160095215, 0.0009018559358082712, -0.019546382129192352, -0.029088443145155907, 0.015287921763956547, -0.0062945508398115635, 0.01319833006709814, -0.06583677232265472, -0.0014102208660915494, 0.010711542330682278, -0.013132035732269287, -0.009957164525985718, -0.041936252266168594, -0.05475819110870361, 0.03384215012192726, -0.012540198862552643, -0.01830330491065979, -0.0007149327429942787, 0.00829530693590641, 0.021007951349020004, -0.055883005261421204, 0.04941599443554878, 0.015850000083446503, 0.0010207026498392224, -0.025025328621268272, 0.016791418194770813, -0.04818553104996681, 0.023719187825918198, 0.08709739148616791, 0.030954360961914062, 0.02371574193239212, -0.0009239494684152305, 0.012720818631350994, -0.009034587070345879, -0.028279529884457588, 0.040625233203172684, 0.025522729381918907, 0.011075405403971672, -0.0003648144192993641, -0.021773694083094597, 0.02300403080880642, 0.0027502772863954306, 0.027675369754433632, 0.013799176551401615, 0.0478152334690094, 0.016783662140369415, -0.003408036194741726, -0.0007601156830787659, -0.010096069425344467, -0.019772907719016075, 0.05433129891753197, 0.006128139328211546, 0.021065250039100647, 0.016722561791539192, -0.00770589429885149, -0.01178272906690836, 0.01356193795800209, -0.041105661541223526, -0.020598219707608223, 0.009856978431344032, -0.001808022614568472, -0.00913722813129425, -0.060674238950014114, 0.02425508014857769, 0.03127831965684891, -0.02650408260524273, -0.016931597143411636, -0.011124787852168083, 0.01628538966178894, 0.05363788828253746, -0.011192701756954193, 0.024203866720199585, 0.009389843791723251, -0.028865939006209373, 0.0034699002280831337, -0.0014994395896792412, 0.06441245228052139, -0.003145819064229727, 0.0236736461520195, 0.043712068349123, -0.0217695664614439, 0.035896528512239456, -0.0266489926725626, 0.029389111325144768, -0.0137244937941432, -0.038825247436761856, 0.07153955101966858, -0.009453663602471352, -0.00564167182892561, -0.009997155517339706, 0.028310399502515793, 0.03680310770869255, -0.061771880835294724, -0.0037437384016811848, -0.0068224635906517506, 0.01835298165678978, -0.028740789741277695, 0.003915246110409498, -0.004615874029695988, -0.0014900453388690948, 0.05322536826133728, 0.017042487859725952, -0.027109822258353233, -0.008016097359359264, 0.020640380680561066, -0.021224435418844223, -0.006986567284911871, -0.01408159639686346, -0.046772830188274384, -0.02934466116130352, -0.008883812464773655, 0.006952017545700073, 0.0014707300579175353, 0.0770566314458847, 0.055545441806316376, -0.0011520853731781244, -0.06669459491968155, -0.04439912736415863, 0.015438873320817947, 0.06776104867458344, -0.049406498670578, -0.0034055847208946943, -0.019716929644346237, -0.04176245257258415, -0.013112335465848446, -0.044837336987257004 ]
<p>What do you think these dummy variables do to the resulting weight values in a BCC/VRS data envelopment analysis? It appears the 1 and -1 relations drive the program to make the weights for the included columns equal, but that's not necessarily true. </p> <p>The program directions that convex constraints on the weights can be included and that they are conical. This is an example file.</p> <pre><code> ------------------------------------------- DMU MktSh-I Salar-I Occ$-I #Hous-I IncHs-I OtherExp-I NetCntr-Out ------------------------------------------- DMU1 1.332 1.706 1.414 1.326 0.853 3.005 1.003 DMU2 1.264 1.429 0.965 1.218 0.982 1.897 1.570 DMU3 1.544 1.496 1.363 0.803 0.703 2.283 1.415 DMU4 0.926 1.861 2.333 1.965 0.796 1.950 1.134... Wynnewd 0.733 0.937 0.581 1.583 0.579 0.833 0.566 CasaLind 1.247 1.017 0.563 1.881 0.795 0.962 1.706 JoseyLn 0.823 0.675 0.416 0.769 0.972 0.523 0.500 . . DMU32 1.073 0.603 0.499 0.765 1.636 0.656 0.758 Dummy01 -0.950 0.050 0.050 0.050 0.050 0.050 0.000 Dummy02 0.000 1.000 -1.00 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 Dummy03 0.000 1.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 -1.00 0.000 Dummy04 0.050 0.050 0.050 -0.95 0.050 0.050 0.000 Dummy05 0.050 0.050 0.050 0.050 -0.95 0.050 0.000 Dummy06 0.000 1.000 0.000 0.000 -1.00 0.000 0.000 </code></pre> <p>Here are a few DMU results when I only implement Dummy02</p> <pre><code>Summary Results for Wynnewd Level: 1 Status: Efficient Efficiency Rating: 1 Reference Set Value Multipliers Value Slack NetCntrb(O) 0.077685 MktShare(I) 0.04682 Salaries(I) 0.070701 Occupan$(I) 0.070701 #_Houses(I) 0.04682 Inc/Hous(I) 1.1268 OtherExp(I) 0.04682 ----------------------------------- Summary Results for CasaLind Level: 1 Status: Efficient Efficiency Rating: 1 Reference Set Value Multipliers Value Slack NetCntrb(O) 0.17643 MktShare(I) 0.020472 Salaries(I) 0.020472 Occupan$(I) 0.069489 #_Houses(I) 0.020472 Inc/Hous(I) 1.3244 OtherExp(I) 0.020472 ---------------------------------------------- Summary Results for JoseyLn Level: 1 Status: Inefficient Efficiency Rating: 0.84999 Reference Set Value Multipliers Value Slack OakCliff 0.33882 NetCntrb(O) 1.3178e-017 FarmBrch 0.57486 MktShare(I) 0.028515 Plsntgrv 0.086311 Salaries(I) 0.059021 Occupan$(I) 0.31351 #_Houses(I) 0 Inc/Hous(I) 0.67949 OtherExp(I) 0.15003 Variables Observed Ideal NetCntrb(O) 0.5 1.3737 MktShare(I) 0.823 0.67496 Salaries(I) 0.675 0.52583 Occupan$(I) 0.416 0.35359 #_Houses(I) 0.769 0.60187 Inc/Hous(I) 0.972 0.82619 OtherExp(I) 0.523 0.44454 </code></pre> <p>And Here is Wynnewd when I implement Dummy02 and Dummy03</p> <pre><code> Summary Results for Wynnewd Level: 1 Status: Efficient Efficiency Rating: 1 Reference Set Value Multipliers Value Slack NetCntrb(O) 0.074264 MktShare(I) 0.049537 Salaries(I) 0.049537 Occupan$(I) 0.079083 #_Houses(I) 0.049537 Inc/Hous(I) 1.1379 OtherExp(I) 0.049537</code></pre> <p>Also, any tips on Non-discretionary variables as categorical/dummy? </p>
49,183
[ -0.04555733501911163, 0.013189258053898811, -0.010277749970555305, -0.03515781834721565, 0.02337905578315258, 0.04904422536492348, 0.0008400474325753748, -0.022358758375048637, 0.010086656548082829, -0.04145926237106323, 0.011134788393974304, 0.07113239914178848, 0.06800777465105057, 0.03893185779452324, 0.005301330704241991, -0.02118208073079586, -0.006637056358158588, -0.01618732511997223, -0.014701087959110737, -0.013147189281880856, 0.023840535432100296, 0.04660353809595108, 0.016719209030270576, -0.0005760702770203352, -0.015183295123279095, 0.06073502451181412, -0.018844395875930786, -0.03373429551720619, 0.00011787307448685169, 0.04740661010146141, -0.03188588470220566, -0.02872014418244362, -0.016537848860025406, -0.019726086407899857, -0.027116313576698303, 0.0028081100899726152, -0.023947501555085182, -0.023614652454853058, -0.006075040437281132, 0.026241296902298927, -0.020528649911284447, -0.005175926722586155, -0.013023545034229755, 0.03614684194326401, 0.01148245483636856, 0.04472846910357475, 0.017949596047401428, 0.0008933900971896946, 0.030649643391370773, -0.06900732219219208, 0.05788687244057655, 0.0039142342284321785, 0.016961505636572838, 0.0066885268315672874, -0.031246332451701164, -0.00008005341078387573, 0.02232407033443451, 0.07307340949773788, 0.012045004405081272, -0.03838403522968292, 0.011461126618087292, 0.01599171757698059, 0.009903903119266033, -0.010076034814119339, -0.007234213408082724, 0.04311147704720497, 0.010838904418051243, -0.013792646117508411, 0.0188058540225029, -0.031496480107307434, 0.02543048933148384, 0.015526237897574902, -0.0020563509315252304, -0.0012122915359213948, -0.0034404206089675426, 0.016024688258767128, 0.027298904955387115, 0.008147387765347958, 0.018988557159900665, 0.030282514169812202, -0.01768355816602707, -0.0010435915319249034, 0.00034780343412421644, 0.025208409875631332, 0.025861844420433044, 0.029657799750566483, 0.03427097573876381, -0.057010892778635025, 0.06367386877536774, 0.01213343720883131, 0.005450022406876087, 0.01641829125583172, 0.06952916830778122, 0.00027471501380205154, -0.012369167059659958, -0.011310816742479801, 0.013642513193190098, 0.04781503975391388, -0.04579515382647514, -0.026663074269890785, -0.04307863116264343, -0.04130314290523529, -0.0062238601967692375, 0.04344892129302025, -0.004708427935838699, -0.008810814470052719, -0.018984727561473846, 0.034888651221990585, -0.007613495923578739, -0.03453721106052399, -0.029499387368559837, 0.013049584813416004, 0.009135982021689415, -0.016284579411149025, 0.0019645849242806435, -0.05035864934325218, 0.016692625358700752, -0.006856197491288185, 0.017248766496777534, 0.043322041630744934, 0.036837536841630936, 0.010743171907961369, 0.02326691523194313, -0.037887267768383026, -0.09845466166734695, 0.022244231775403023, 0.03081713430583477, -0.036384303122758865, -0.01836385391652584, 0.030302610248327255, 0.007444214075803757, -0.05732535198330879, 0.03964647278189659, 0.014412928372621536, 0.0012209683191031218, 0.011843088082969189, -0.0967220813035965, -0.060330454260110855, 0.017555639147758484, -0.024840446189045906, 0.015376495197415352, -0.048298731446266174, 0.008555185049772263, 0.02870476059615612, 0.04764721915125847, 0.0043277195654809475, 0.05032514035701752, 0.01401583757251501, 0.005806813016533852, 0.016360582783818245, -0.023952625691890717, 0.0014080951223149896, -0.02951282449066639, -0.02989853359758854, -0.030744537711143494, -0.07091300189495087, 0.037402305752038956, 0.028876300901174545, -0.010327888652682304, 0.0023917004000395536, 0.04350823536515236, 0.017269879579544067, -0.015111539512872696, -0.012328331358730793, -0.015053470619022846, -0.034105442464351654, 0.005856487900018692, -0.01736455224454403, 0.04173882305622101, 0.010675921104848385, -0.010681877844035625, 0.01929393596947193, -0.030634218826889992, 0.025926318019628525, 0.036659225821495056, -0.0077746170572936535, -0.02062566764652729, -0.04469987004995346, -0.020100994035601616, 0.01056982297450304, -0.04445372521877289, -0.08035337924957275, -0.028970152139663696, -0.005506719928234816, 0.019541461020708084, 0.04358352720737457, -0.017306482419371605, -0.03920483589172363, 0.06535908579826355, -0.014109517447650433, -0.030701769515872, -0.04041317477822304, 0.010831384919583797, -0.028660571202635765, -0.053759731352329254, -0.006162737496197224, -0.0386822372674942, 0.013258373364806175, 0.028177693486213684, 0.0010916738538071513, -0.013961759395897388, 0.016546811908483505, 0.046765994280576706, -0.011985287070274353, 0.006804418750107288, 0.013018338941037655, 0.08516158908605576, -0.04606510326266289, 0.028224414214491844, -0.00061620312044397, -0.04251142218708992, 0.01770116202533245, -0.0037567773833870888, -0.020976785570383072, -0.031456414610147476, -0.002110506407916546, 0.01623624376952648, 0.03028990887105465, -0.01642519049346447, -0.011552703566849232, -0.06521254777908325, 0.044722139835357666, 0.07674653083086014, 0.016894584521651268, 0.014687168411910534, 0.04726120084524155, -0.0038621779531240463, 0.024033473804593086, 0.0023417132906615734, 0.039901960641145706, -0.03179633617401123, -0.003682612208649516, 0.013584974221885204, 0.04950029030442238, -0.0353570282459259, 0.004329702816903591, 0.04725654795765877, -0.0022844946943223476, 0.016415467485785484, 0.03398001566529274, -0.03713119029998779, 0.014947410672903061, 0.029217133298516273, 0.021770630031824112, 0.028988519683480263, -0.017343545332551003, 0.02390279993414879, 0.04565323516726494, 0.01601499505341053, -0.02354768104851246, 0.028152097016572952, 0.04391169175505638, -0.004544530995190144, -0.018847044557332993, -0.041981086134910583, -0.02105843834578991, 0.05827377364039421, -0.040765173733234406, -0.0010107826674357057, 0.03689960390329361, -0.001974422950297594, -0.00494264904409647, -0.0017918719677254558, -0.0290601197630167, -0.016035087406635284, 0.04971614107489586, -0.009214796125888824, -0.0067668785341084, 0.010312477126717567, -0.0704478994011879, 0.02012353576719761, 0.004943720996379852, -0.006181968376040459, -0.0655987560749054, 0.01137317530810833, 0.03698328882455826, -0.026146210730075836, 0.0404173918068409, -0.0019930433481931686, -0.0084665697067976, 0.007371576502919197, -0.008225508965551853, 0.01633334718644619, 0.03320722281932831, -0.020623719319701195, -0.025084661319851875, -0.05550055205821991, 0.009921791031956673, 0.03811579570174217, -0.009155857376754284, -0.02258179895579815, 0.059384025633335114, 0.0035345868673175573, -0.013765586540102959, -0.019438523799180984, -0.009823516011238098, -0.015397975221276283, -0.004358426667749882, -0.012640463188290596, 0.048836421221494675, 0.027476349845528603, -0.0320437029004097, 0.014684220775961876, -0.023684700950980186, -0.02578647993505001, 0.009030149318277836, 0.0022899534087628126, -0.01419736910611391, -0.013490138575434685, -0.005075426306575537, 0.005541020538657904, -0.01075764000415802, 0.01959921605885029, -0.0726889818906784, -0.040828805416822433, 0.003167189424857497, 0.02066078782081604, -0.010658110491931438, 0.006608165800571442, -0.03404184803366661, 0.07998219132423401, 0.00807739794254303, -0.058318719267845154, -0.04620568826794624, -0.01667182706296444, -0.05193337798118591, 0.021467767655849457, 0.02743813581764698, 0.01572653278708458, 0.021202679723501205, 0.03597257286310196, 0.010651716031134129, 0.039471980184316635, 0.05878753960132599, 0.008440932258963585, 0.031768035143613815, 0.05055514723062515, -0.031623080372810364, -0.021706877276301384, 0.03262576833367348, -0.0030912021175026894, 0.011794378980994225, 0.04411562904715538, 0.011136682704091072, 0.01600685343146324, 0.005756410304456949, -0.03588077425956726, -0.0077327159233391285, 0.004307566676288843, 0.019652219489216805, -0.03651115298271179, 0.003182187909260392, 0.0008441859972663224, -0.036376483738422394, -0.0074615092016756535, -0.0385306216776371, 0.02219562791287899, -0.04743656516075134, 0.013318345881998539, 0.038450688123703, 0.022959992289543152, 0.006582286208868027, 0.013553916476666927, -0.01566476561129093, -0.027393152937293053, -0.005373767111450434, -0.06935828179121017, -0.04188155755400658, 0.042448025196790695, 0.055686820298433304, 0.010360324755311012, -0.00631423806771636, -0.03241360932588577, -0.006683447398245335, -0.05348160117864609, -0.0062567912973463535, -0.038671109825372696, 0.05001886934041977, 0.019957130774855614, 0.031180845573544502, 0.026376964524388313, -0.005294075235724449, -0.03260062262415886, -0.063955157995224, -0.04248008877038956, 0.017844097688794136, 0.006564508657902479, -0.014196171425282955, 0.05907487869262695, -0.027701782062649727, -0.01414670329540968, -0.06026281788945198, -0.029706625267863274, 0.029701443389058113, 0.04009836167097092, -0.026229070499539375, 0.035687390714883804, 0.006669030524790287, -0.006561651825904846, 0.009139706380665302, 0.023868964985013008, 0.03994535654783249, -0.05096755921840668, 0.03725855425000191, 0.01240124087780714, -0.04612407833337784, 0.00516146793961525, -0.039056260138750076, 0.010866851545870304, 0.010064791887998581, 0.04498995468020439, -0.0005741843488067389, 0.015902340412139893, 0.013322439976036549, 0.017628030851483345, 0.02125680074095726, 0.05841735377907753, 0.043083254247903824, -0.025562826544046402, -0.04840439558029175, -0.015785368159413338, -0.03532693535089493, 0.007769901771098375, 0.016039645299315453, 0.0027190055698156357, -0.011377749033272266, 0.06922230869531631, 0.00363117060624063, 0.007807073183357716, 0.02331765927374363, 0.044474534690380096, 0.03552558273077011, -0.015009958297014236, -0.024317942559719086, -0.02751711755990982, -0.017960894852876663, -0.016115300357341766, 0.036800988018512726, -0.009377621114253998, 0.0033410415053367615, -0.001703177927993238, 0.05266961827874184, -0.009667984209954739, -0.024027826264500618, 0.005427706986665726, 0.014784553088247776, 0.019758552312850952, 0.013094975613057613, -0.007101645693182945, 0.05112892761826515, 0.01417689397931099, 0.04747704043984413, 0.042161811143159866, 0.01476584654301405, -0.06400470435619354, -0.005903087556362152, 0.04402390867471695, 0.059172373265028, -0.013614697381854057, 0.000023000086002866738, -0.039202407002449036, 0.03646695241332054, 0.0521848127245903, -0.0634889081120491, 0.05977180227637291, -0.025459544733166695, 0.030442267656326294, -0.03283029422163963, -0.055793941020965576, -0.039935626089572906, -0.013947778381407261, 0.003847285406664014, 0.05493669584393501, -0.01921902783215046, -0.04184729978442192, -0.01069002877920866, 0.03276289999485016, 0.016613587737083435, -0.0025852355174720287, -0.04100940749049187, -0.019279208034276962, 0.0027428707107901573, 0.03163186088204384, -0.022411998361349106, -0.060521937906742096, 0.007475769612938166, 0.024931875988841057, 0.017465004697442055, 0.07702946662902832, -0.02034495770931244, -0.026025958359241486, 0.00023165837046690285, 0.017119843512773514, 0.0026510925963521004, -0.03756799176335335, -0.02669101022183895, 0.07366948574781418, 0.021599864587187767, -0.019561797380447388, 0.00652493629604578, -0.027248002588748932, -0.014260713942348957, 0.00687327841296792, -0.07290484756231308, -0.013040095567703247, 0.003765588626265526, -0.04586392641067505, -0.058563005179166794, 0.0020570599008351564, 0.010295655578374863, -0.009680296294391155, 0.0005765170208178461, 0.03062404878437519, -0.038185540586709976, -0.003393793711438775, -0.00773359602317214, 0.018141454085707664, -0.01634064130485058, -0.019483743235468864, -0.012896333821117878, 0.018514666706323624, 0.0033382733818143606, -0.0546293780207634, -0.010618987493216991, -0.020803231745958328, -0.011426261626183987, 0.024654103443026543, -0.017237726598978043, -0.016712332144379616, 0.0021863810252398252, 0.02403583750128746, 0.029213789850473404, -0.028686555102467537, 0.011272206902503967, -0.003069663653150201, 0.02574453130364418, 0.026069695129990578, 0.018851451575756073, -0.019564518705010414, 0.01427121926099062, -0.018856970593333244, -0.02429751493036747, -0.027161503210663795, 0.0056777577847242355, 0.012480705045163631, 0.03130262717604637, -0.050599105656147, -0.03767583519220352, 0.008543507196009159, -0.011239913292229176, -0.03862125799059868, -0.0334465391933918, -0.033809516578912735, 0.004202154465019703, -0.04410412535071373, -0.012431561946868896, 0.05904458835721016, -0.04693633317947388, 0.04763345792889595, 0.02488003671169281, 0.018319599330425262, 0.054047949612140656, 0.02183287963271141, 0.012415202334523201, 0.0059606293216347694, -0.01814368925988674, -0.024127764627337456, 0.009116845205426216, -0.0524384044110775, -0.026212049648165703, -0.019686654210090637, -0.024278003722429276, -0.015346929430961609, 0.05683613941073418, 0.012687129899859428, 0.0031006622593849897, -0.0008635769481770694, 0.0044590686447918415, -0.0020145990420132875, 0.009689518250524998, 0.015490029007196426, -0.0159585103392601, 0.015485518611967564, 0.024445071816444397, -0.008364519104361534, -0.007003489416092634, -0.007942051626741886, 0.0037241315003484488, -0.04041977599263191, -0.04753871262073517, 0.010985179804265499, 0.09064028412103653, 0.029803745448589325, 0.007030918728560209, -0.01618712954223156, -0.021284518763422966, 0.03776867687702179, 0.01466415449976921, 0.0012282229727134109, -0.024718506261706352, 0.028163019567728043, -0.0015352426562458277, -0.016824793070554733, -0.043022751808166504, 0.04214360564947128, 0.05775796249508858, 0.028941603377461433, 0.04875941202044487, 0.052208803594112396, 0.001408372656442225, 0.0004294617392588407, -0.033856939524412155, -0.012068340554833412, -0.011092514730989933, -0.030606700107455254, 0.029315488412976265, 0.0012099652085453272, -0.031861674040555954, 0.07027974724769592, 0.014108370989561081, -0.0018409483600407839, 0.009852967225015163, -0.018573889508843422, -0.0034599443897604942, 0.01956816390156746, -0.029177099466323853, -0.044415101408958435, 0.037073779851198196, -0.026048991829156876, 0.01416097953915596, -0.009927405044436455, -0.04553929343819618, 0.04541286081075668, 0.026133624836802483, 0.011437238194048405, -0.08453180640935898, -0.04345593601465225, -0.029419271275401115, -0.0006515050772577524, 0.006695846561342478, -0.06532428413629532, -0.003080383874475956, 0.03194434568285942, 0.0291343592107296, -0.02465531975030899, 0.030821215361356735, -0.04786985367536545, -0.051111698150634766, -0.0566108264029026, -0.010466580279171467, -0.03426282852888107, 0.052508868277072906, -0.005387469660490751, -0.04372676461935043, 0.015001797117292881, -0.02167840488255024, 0.014600117690861225, 0.008576761931180954, 0.024569721892476082, 0.06104149669408798, 0.05298575386404991, 0.0076966057531535625, 0.03205769881606102, -0.001471067895181477, -0.014577214606106281, 0.1472460925579071, 0.0461367666721344, 0.016870111227035522, -0.043243493884801865, 0.01874392479658127, 0.02458104118704796, 0.014621593989431858, -0.025501856580376625, -0.025751471519470215, 0.020916452631354332, 0.0044424948282539845, 0.022639844566583633, 0.012603120878338814, 0.007976578548550606, 0.02052145078778267, 0.02848646230995655, -0.004915767814964056, -0.048366159200668335, 0.017449114471673965, 0.024823369458317757, 0.00749695859849453, -0.02930549532175064, -0.05286550149321556, -0.02078111469745636, 0.011375182308256626, -0.032684143632650375, -0.03381780907511711, -0.007262097205966711, 0.02630884014070034, 0.014974192716181278, -0.029282210394740105, 0.0022778408601880074, 0.008046356029808521, 0.03624990954995155, 0.030145961791276932, -0.009538826532661915, 0.01425571832805872, -0.05186627060174942, -0.008057108148932457, -0.013585267588496208, 0.01161282416433096, -0.006515831220895052, -0.017835017293691635, 0.019599173218011856, -0.04322876036167145, 0.020298203453421593, -0.031510598957538605, 0.023009879514575005, -0.042111676186323166, 0.008151796646416187, 0.002533398102968931, -0.01401564385741949, 0.008903439156711102, -0.09424175322055817, -0.024342650547623634, -0.015708062797784805, 0.029236912727355957, 0.02752893604338169, -0.0019570232834666967, 0.015128684230148792, -0.04268093407154083, 0.025671157985925674, 0.00643572211265564, 0.02953251264989376, -0.05132220685482025, -0.04088384285569191, -0.04713461175560951, 0.06668328493833542, -0.006631090305745602, -0.0004036123282276094, -0.010344736278057098, -0.021379606798291206, -0.017320021986961365, -0.03780028969049454, 0.006438912823796272, 0.008682172745466232, 0.041187211871147156, -0.02207065001130104, -0.0007761593442410231, -0.00037955286097712815, -0.035451412200927734, 0.010360097512602806, -0.023587888106703758, 0.008318066596984863, -0.06935833394527435, -0.0012499369913712144, 0.030223054811358452, 0.034549303352832794, 0.03824525699019432, -0.0009406840545125306, -0.035527005791664124, 0.04617563635110855, -0.015968240797519684, -0.029823919758200645, -0.029026871547102928, 0.034052129834890366, -0.022566331550478935, -0.015937672927975655, 0.01743738166987896, 0.07450064271688461, -0.0021956097334623337, 0.0042654974386096, -0.032041262835264206, 0.07272529602050781, 0.026621999219059944, 0.010103835724294186, 0.015682853758335114, -0.056665197014808655, 0.03782462328672409, 0.0051865954883396626, -0.01855766586959362, -0.06306006759405136, 0.005614278372377157, -0.04371846094727516, -0.02708304300904274, -0.00740191200748086, -0.008367728441953659, -0.04755816236138344, -0.01660631224513054, 0.014733612537384033, 0.005239071324467659, 0.021488705649971962, 0.004438345320522785, -0.0013852943666279316, 0.0016333271050825715, -0.03217148408293724, 0.00958111509680748, -0.01336235087364912, 0.002790403086692095, -0.02730749361217022, 0.012328420765697956, 0.017349380999803543, 0.029426097869873047, -0.011611313559114933, -0.048626646399497986, -0.004255176056176424, 0.051502298563718796, 0.04967588558793068, 0.027469323948025703, -0.004461012315005064, -0.018096989020705223, -0.008310116827487946, -0.0023350289557129145, 0.008121277205646038, -0.010563703253865242, 0.04127751290798187, -0.01807296834886074, -0.011760145425796509, -0.056308813393116, 0.04979310557246208, -0.05286025255918503, 0.008106621913611889, -0.02005772478878498, -0.025803491473197937, 0.040994513779878616, -0.009406386874616146, -0.007992061786353588, 0.018333636224269867, -0.059946153312921524, 0.004621998872607946, 0.011477649211883545, -0.0013480141060426831, -0.0013534759636968374, -0.02124173380434513, 0.008866818621754646, 0.04170263931155205, 0.005357937887310982, -0.020634299144148827, 0.056596435606479645, 0.040029071271419525, -0.029673423618078232, 0.045839086174964905, 0.012881513684988022, 0.00691874697804451, -0.06741679459810257, -0.011306648142635822, 0.007218868471682072, 0.015512272715568542, 0.03430332615971565, -0.03442246466875076, 0.0486065112054348, 0.00002160173789889086, -0.046587951481342316, 0.029925694689154625, 0.006884948816150427, 0.01136846374720335, -0.010004968382418156, 0.029324842616915703, -0.017073767259716988, 0.010159650817513466, -0.007465811911970377, -0.005947874393314123, 0.042035531252622604, -0.00007181063847383484, 0.015629880130290985, 0.002421361394226551, 0.004421137738972902, 0.005655675195157528, -0.0078057763166725636, -0.021121229976415634, 0.03725661709904671, -0.026417570188641548, -0.024553021416068077, 0.01903235726058483, 0.008678318001329899, 0.015056094154715538, 0.00003426297917030752, 0.03890024125576019, 0.052808452397584915, 0.060607172548770905, 0.029512936249375343, 0.0521334670484066, 0.015112805180251598, -0.02541128359735012, -0.014087500050663948, -0.002572811907157302, 0.008300364017486572, 0.024807965382933617, 0.028690196573734283, -0.019341250881552696, -0.019725611433386803, 0.021235866472125053, -0.02424093335866928, 0.011204409413039684, -0.03351457789540291, -0.016091080382466316, 0.022641541436314583, -0.003357497276738286, 0.02015857771039009, -0.04626470059156418, -0.016042882576584816, 0.013490702025592327, 0.02899773046374321, -0.019195063039660454, 0.022946154698729515, 0.027551909908652306, -0.037290770560503006, -0.006308546755462885, 0.034439511597156525, 0.005189005751162767, -0.05573340505361557, 0.017061816528439522, 0.01875266246497631, -0.023238955065608025, -0.007231210358440876, -0.023998312652111053, -0.0490914061665535, 0.05273935943841934, -0.020275825634598732, -0.006539095193147659, 0.02906089834868908, -0.006952209863811731, 0.03561455011367798, -0.10841844975948334, 0.06054094061255455, -0.011459159664809704, -0.03174129128456116, -0.008796432055532932, -0.001725891139358282, -0.024905340746045113, 0.031016068533062935, 0.015596526674926281, 0.00907529704272747, -0.009146451950073242, 0.014684444293379784, 0.020458484068512917, -0.017844531685113907, -0.027245180681347847, 0.08749517053365707, 0.009115064516663551, -0.008392168208956718, 0.011551271192729473, 0.004230757709592581, -0.004754103720188141, 0.002723277546465397, 0.008206255733966827, 0.005155786871910095, -0.013974917121231556, 0.02244383469223976, -0.010941775515675545, 0.008556047454476357, -0.011369054205715656, 0.0031433349940925837, 0.04697662591934204, 0.017493437975645065, 0.012307614088058472, 0.04410065338015556, -0.01248116698116064, -0.046562694013118744, 0.05115891620516777, 0.02299203909933567, -0.05589056760072708, 0.004758363589644432, -0.03359164670109749, 0.05252941697835922, -0.02153894118964672, 0.006166291423141956, 0.010871835984289646, -0.01868744194507599, -0.00673446711152792, 0.04242724925279617, 0.032752323895692825, 0.03312046453356743, -0.021206118166446686, 0.04544217512011528, -0.030596276745200157, -0.04075360298156738, 0.04099882394075394, 0.042863987386226654, 0.05387561395764351, 0.0006298841326497495, -0.027239754796028137, 0.051371488720178604, -0.052774764597415924, 0.03522288426756859, -0.017322830855846405, 0.03317234292626381, -0.06380769610404968, -0.05672459304332733, 0.02989397756755352, -0.008009581826627254, 0.020401692017912865, 0.00322265038266778, -0.03385213762521744, 0.060875434428453445, -0.046205826103687286, 0.01980525255203247, -0.056901223957538605, -0.007976030930876732, -0.008358137682080269, 0.011185863055288792, 0.006723680533468723, 0.05921420827507973, -0.009943186305463314, 0.0027621136978268623, 0.027136223390698433, -0.01516253873705864, 0.013886488974094391, -0.02714526653289795, -0.003954346291720867, 0.004376345779746771, 0.034558381885290146, 0.01435154490172863, -0.005954503081738949, 0.0025254664942622185, -0.027908867225050926, 0.04271220043301582, 0.022764187306165695, -0.013500157743692398, -0.04007118195295334, -0.01740763895213604, -0.005749197211116552, 0.05613594129681587, -0.03365453705191612, -0.06362935155630112, -0.013370872475206852, 0.01788264885544777, 0.0007237397949211299, -0.020123915746808052 ]
<p>I have large correlation matrix in Excel that I'd like to use to inform my choice of explanatory variables in a multiple linear regression model. One problem is that the initial data was very sparse, and some columns had significantly more zeroes than others. How would I go about choosing the variables with the lowest correlation without falling into the trap of choosing those that have the lowest pairwise correlation solely because they were both very sparse? </p>
73,530
[ -0.011432789266109467, -0.000749667698983103, 0.015088643878698349, 0.008771572262048721, 0.022212058305740356, -0.000024766752176219597, 0.007259041536599398, -0.014360114000737667, 0.057032499462366104, -0.04555991664528847, -0.0015403992729261518, 0.040890883654356, 0.048931851983070374, 0.035524625331163406, 0.05175170674920082, 0.014591996558010578, -0.012616654857993126, 0.0135789280757308, -0.0025606134440749884, -0.019232824444770813, -0.016485976055264473, -0.018448056653141975, 0.03287291154265404, 0.020190807059407234, -0.02516859583556652, 0.07971101999282837, 0.02317935787141323, -0.02577347867190838, -0.005197563208639622, 0.03060406818985939, -0.03509446233510971, 0.008694835007190704, 0.00396540155634284, 0.048310521990060806, 0.026453664526343346, -0.026496313512325287, -0.011601424776017666, -0.011319734156131744, 0.008246573619544506, 0.019938521087169647, -0.01063386257737875, -0.061128612607717514, 0.015666058287024498, 0.013818996027112007, -0.00877770408987999, 0.020192809402942657, 0.03081219643354416, -0.06768187880516052, 0.042884260416030884, -0.059641942381858826, 0.07660991698503494, 0.00870759878307581, 0.05457022413611412, 0.05987580493092537, -0.004862918984144926, -0.015981217846274376, 0.05439838021993637, 0.049588192254304886, -0.0031062455382198095, -0.04328591749072075, 0.004116463474929333, -0.00507061742246151, -0.0016320627182722092, -0.045098960399627686, -0.02476181462407112, 0.0471796989440918, -0.00016942749789450318, 0.0070977602154016495, 0.06541343778371811, -0.0057890284806489944, 0.0033846187870949507, 0.021446513012051582, 0.03569993004202843, -0.020508455112576485, 0.002743246266618371, -0.02964698150753975, 0.03545251861214638, 0.021196715533733368, 0.05593806505203247, 0.022824062034487724, 0.003428908996284008, 0.017804719507694244, 0.025488343089818954, 0.015769479796290398, 0.0009194482699967921, 0.007480858825147152, 0.043290916830301285, -0.04982050508260727, 0.0141227338463068, 0.05371233448386192, -0.05757930129766464, 0.02083485759794712, 0.026059329509735107, 0.02845274843275547, -0.030582409352064133, 0.024313542991876602, -0.0015301305102184415, 0.06758973747491837, 0.010242440737783909, -0.006813572254031897, -0.024989431723952293, 0.01492200419306755, -0.012864573858678341, 0.04873448237776756, -0.02376158908009529, 0.013449498452246189, -0.03941960260272026, 0.03636068105697632, -0.005379056558012962, -0.047983814030885696, -0.009391441009938717, 0.011076979339122772, 0.022912435233592987, -0.012817149050533772, 0.05774177983403206, -0.016512200236320496, -0.005469528492540121, -0.03237440809607506, 0.05162692070007324, 0.08410588651895523, 0.015799660235643387, -0.04810570180416107, 0.04264995828270912, -0.010176840238273144, -0.020658930763602257, -0.0006690335576422513, 0.009796959348022938, -0.010937570594251156, -0.0035019824281334877, 0.0683966651558876, 0.00022773686214350164, -0.021571826189756393, 0.04219138249754906, -0.026259353384375572, -0.0026059532538056374, 0.02751772478222847, -0.07941325753927231, -0.017668219283223152, 0.06322866678237915, -0.049486786127090454, 0.01658962480723858, -0.0326496958732605, -0.017460983246564865, 0.008645344525575638, 0.07269379496574402, 0.0015729034785181284, 0.02354614995419979, 0.015405578538775444, 0.021608777344226837, 0.00818195752799511, -0.02007698081433773, -0.006781585048884153, -0.02949831821024418, -0.011659673415124416, -0.0038168190512806177, -0.06876716762781143, 0.0015197652392089367, 0.022507529705762863, -0.004322441294789314, 0.0002606298658065498, 0.030478546395897865, -0.004011780023574829, -0.02059943415224552, -0.01072671078145504, 0.007488868199288845, -0.01788737252354622, 0.0706530511379242, -0.022339127957820892, -0.0036214932333678007, 0.031779851764440536, -0.012080183252692223, -0.030666891485452652, 0.016481323167681694, 0.05270867422223091, 0.03423525393009186, 0.004501280840486288, 0.004135222639888525, -0.0017351354472339153, 0.020580822601914406, -0.004614347591996193, -0.04601459205150604, -0.027941716834902763, -0.012091014534235, -0.0040674153715372086, 0.025948751717805862, 0.07450373470783234, -0.012358537875115871, -0.02803642861545086, 0.017971301451325417, -0.0038315323181450367, -0.02545328065752983, -0.05540495738387108, -0.007596357259899378, 0.047589316964149475, -0.02284332923591137, 0.04143036529421806, 0.005968824494630098, 0.006980031728744507, 0.022411147132515907, 0.00586245022714138, -0.04354003444314003, -0.026620056480169296, 0.012873099185526371, -0.030347557738423347, 0.009907382540404797, 0.034517306834459305, 0.04319329932332039, -0.029989972710609436, 0.030142635107040405, -0.022076427936553955, -0.014768022112548351, 0.024179717525839806, -0.0017923451960086823, 0.038290124386548996, -0.03369825333356857, -0.026754800230264664, -0.006213784217834473, -0.005226473789662123, -0.012810278683900833, 0.018251128494739532, -0.04120945185422897, 0.04230106249451637, 0.04259936138987541, 0.04654720798134804, 0.0035620995331555605, -0.024090202525258064, 0.011885493993759155, 0.0045142569579184055, -0.009366224519908428, 0.011795678175985813, -0.03463507816195488, -0.019041607156395912, 0.03563268855214119, 0.0459555946290493, -0.0566999651491642, 0.019230635836720467, 0.047606464475393295, 0.024572154507040977, 0.0256655253469944, 0.0439879409968853, -0.01779535412788391, 0.007079961709678173, -0.012960894964635372, 0.02298692613840103, 0.010884745046496391, -0.012391355820000172, -0.003880000440403819, 0.011936252936720848, 0.023374198004603386, 0.005834892857819796, -0.038017839193344116, 0.03728817403316498, 0.017405005171895027, 0.009423629380762577, -0.02137434482574463, -0.02951088175177574, 0.019118623808026314, -0.01758909411728382, 0.006012069992721081, 0.03208201751112938, 0.025393633171916008, -0.013251305557787418, 0.031948138028383255, -0.022374114021658897, 0.03182715177536011, 0.04766472801566124, -0.020090734586119652, 0.009884967468678951, 0.030991539359092712, -0.049563709646463394, 0.012151254341006279, -0.008280053734779358, -0.04006483778357506, -0.04325369372963905, 0.01580817438662052, 0.057800792157649994, 0.008373248390853405, 0.02692878432571888, 0.0024684544187039137, -0.01379880029708147, -0.00018212318536825478, -0.015040930360555649, 0.023901009932160378, 0.012474394403398037, -0.049499619752168655, -0.03916124999523163, -0.0380280464887619, -0.017494117841124535, 0.027138516306877136, -0.00334918568842113, -0.00978121068328619, 0.032380469143390656, -0.017149483785033226, -0.07432978600263596, -0.01738749071955681, -0.0017499736277386546, 0.012784547172486782, 0.012667608447372913, -0.026068517938256264, 0.01882677525281906, -0.01140168122947216, -0.06651058793067932, -0.032190173864364624, -0.06593848019838333, -0.02414831519126892, -0.013337865471839905, -0.02053537406027317, -0.004341390915215015, 0.015447032637894154, -0.008509131148457527, 0.0075289420783519745, -0.006970510818064213, -0.0029924630653113127, -0.05821466073393822, -0.0357118584215641, 0.013800705783069134, 0.016841847449541092, 0.019830109551548958, -0.016791537404060364, -0.010193943046033382, 0.08126485347747803, 0.03293193131685257, -0.006671648006886244, -0.04932517558336258, -0.027310920879244804, -0.04360515996813774, -0.01147732324898243, 0.04631533846259117, -0.0022019988391548395, 0.02530187927186489, 0.04701683297753334, -0.0007022597128525376, 0.04337885230779648, 0.038287147879600525, 0.007947510108351707, 0.014703908003866673, 0.029821818694472313, -0.040392134338617325, -0.009473646059632301, -0.006836262531578541, -0.002271439181640744, -0.019391940906643867, 0.05213358253240585, 0.009309393353760242, 0.009732010774314404, -0.0298725925385952, -0.03830484673380852, -0.031690433621406555, -0.00824793241918087, 0.06270994246006012, -0.011739957146346569, -0.030963268131017685, 0.026359574869275093, -0.009327426552772522, 0.008168661966919899, 0.02038952149450779, 0.03946388512849808, -0.04046676680445671, 0.026965508237481117, 0.0496990792453289, -0.01669958606362343, -0.02640899084508419, 0.009546047076582909, 0.0026878153439611197, -0.018865037709474564, 0.029644299298524857, -0.009854817762970924, -0.004522325005382299, 0.03870458900928497, -0.015929637476801872, 0.03923815116286278, -0.0005154998507350683, -0.049932755529880524, 0.027846187353134155, -0.04639827832579613, -0.011759721674025059, -0.009975035674870014, 0.04139751195907593, 0.008872327394783497, 0.029616480693221092, 0.037285856902599335, -0.008887983858585358, -0.00886608473956585, 0.017254643142223358, -0.0676177516579628, 0.04447884485125542, -0.026623129844665527, 0.017842691391706467, 0.03062213771045208, -0.009601814672350883, 0.023018619045615196, -0.037287596613168716, -0.014278155751526356, 0.016908209770917892, 0.024247432127594948, -0.015693292021751404, 0.014148416928946972, -0.03259452432394028, 0.02517235092818737, -0.02812357246875763, 0.011300774291157722, -0.004138187970966101, -0.024391792714595795, 0.06541473418474197, 0.04157397523522377, -0.013428558595478535, 0.010813341476023197, -0.011434661224484444, 0.011375083588063717, 0.023350315168499947, 0.012392405420541763, -0.025292182341217995, 0.014587445184588432, -0.028416866436600685, -0.0070768664591014385, -0.038493670523166656, 0.030402572825551033, 0.023508140817284584, 0.023453617468476295, -0.026497868821024895, -0.017407700419425964, -0.011260716244578362, -0.021881623193621635, 0.016218233853578568, 0.0012910050572827458, 0.01262878067791462, 0.05874340236186981, 0.02614419162273407, -0.03317940980195999, 0.05875350534915924, 0.059429001063108444, 0.053331408649683, 0.006444285158067942, 0.033024031668901443, -0.010433473624289036, -0.020384592935442924, 0.014426806941628456, 0.04313960298895836, 0.0040697017684578896, -0.0007183150155469775, -0.05936701223254204, 0.04526830092072487, 0.015963353216648102, -0.02408367209136486, -0.01426065992563963, 0.012432916089892387, 0.07962872833013535, -0.016721142455935478, -0.06907054036855698, -0.0037613159511238337, 0.024580076336860657, 0.006185202393680811, 0.05137374997138977, 0.016822827979922295, -0.06946704536676407, -0.00852258037775755, 0.035354938358068466, 0.03634537756443024, -0.0418035052716732, -0.0043529244139790535, -0.048492006957530975, -0.06493213027715683, 0.05690297484397888, -0.015427936799824238, 0.022773753851652145, -0.013954682275652885, 0.029988478869199753, -0.0276021845638752, 0.009018788114190102, -0.0632982924580574, 0.0022578395437449217, -0.020306510850787163, 0.04843167960643768, -0.02084534615278244, -0.025483163073658943, -0.06625112891197205, 0.052767518907785416, 0.00896626990288496, 0.04337669536471367, 0.019759422168135643, -0.024216067045927048, 0.024413276463747025, -0.0066646793857216835, 0.00973461288958788, -0.06679076701402664, 0.02539238892495632, -0.006924999412149191, -0.03842344507575035, 0.06553511321544647, -0.011991207487881184, -0.026559827849268913, -0.011312160640954971, -0.00730593828484416, -0.020744943991303444, 0.013308128342032433, -0.018197378143668175, 0.012405553832650185, 0.008541451767086983, 0.008570847101509571, 0.04537889361381531, 0.038426682353019714, -0.016055403277277946, -0.007746582850813866, -0.044422704726457596, 0.008235588669776917, -0.034503523260354996, -0.01718713529407978, -0.055871009826660156, -0.00827942043542862, -0.028259269893169403, 0.029713032767176628, 0.004408205393701792, 0.03473866358399391, 0.012301178649067879, -0.035762619227170944, -0.006816694978624582, 0.05762321129441261, -0.030007049441337585, -0.010324427857995033, 0.03112635761499405, 0.01779978722333908, -0.04734037071466446, -0.02665100432932377, 0.009963152930140495, -0.002589411800727248, 0.02108098566532135, 0.015180646441876888, -0.036116715520620346, 0.013875216245651245, -0.02131986804306507, -0.01956520602107048, -0.008595850318670273, -0.020834829658269882, 0.0480584092438221, 0.02215268835425377, 0.012032230384647846, -0.0038563788402825594, -0.03973710164427757, 0.010261345654726028, 0.03746752813458443, -0.0013315234100446105, 0.06299798935651779, -0.048576053231954575, 0.03684297576546669, -0.06719150394201279, -0.024249451234936714, -0.06647848337888718, -0.06305984407663345, -0.03625859320163727, 0.061463043093681335, 0.008377962745726109, -0.042179372161626816, 0.006908769719302654, -0.0211450457572937, 0.009815638884902, -0.01977583020925522, 0.0580923967063427, -0.0011949206236749887, -0.029831113293766975, 0.036047451198101044, 0.03186734393239021, 0.057666536420583725, -0.007646254263818264, -0.04750105366110802, 0.03914403170347214, -0.0295714121311903, -0.02182627096772194, 0.004082696512341499, 0.008132328279316425, -0.03734524920582771, -0.011513649486005306, -0.03913097456097603, -0.017700854688882828, 0.05146634578704834, -0.008758177049458027, -0.007423362694680691, 0.004325993824750185, -0.01939409039914608, -0.0017795137828215957, -0.026820361614227295, 0.030847538262605667, -0.02545652911067009, 0.0038939800579100847, 0.013698901049792767, -0.012436998076736927, -0.03476421907544136, -0.004445718135684729, 0.019930822774767876, 0.015288274735212326, -0.010774221271276474, 0.023929757997393608, 0.04846161976456642, 0.040098000317811966, -0.009127329103648663, -0.018002834171056747, -0.009649950079619884, 0.018268369138240814, 0.028919754549860954, 0.028820127248764038, -0.027592381462454796, 0.04064205661416054, -0.023952389135956764, -0.03577766567468643, -0.04700010269880295, 0.00519553991034627, 0.058813996613025665, -0.019763952121138573, 0.01066635176539421, 0.06784932315349579, -0.006284334696829319, -0.015481045469641685, -0.04046587273478508, 0.010676044039428234, -0.003998219035565853, 0.023437686264514923, 0.052176862955093384, -0.00047798562445677817, -0.0077773528173565865, 0.036171235144138336, 0.005612516775727272, 0.02223837375640869, 0.045976582914590836, 0.026222003623843193, 0.0039478181861341, 0.056349728256464005, -0.020485367625951767, -0.05140459164977074, -0.006388197187334299, -0.04451699182391167, 0.03493637591600418, 0.004870945122092962, -0.04159322381019592, 0.009744609706103802, 0.06670187413692474, -0.006790088023990393, -0.02566751278936863, -0.033003196120262146, -0.03145201504230499, 0.001133317593485117, 0.007959879003465176, -0.039433542639017105, 0.021363815292716026, 0.0469728522002697, 0.019734563305974007, -0.021066814661026, 0.016570765525102615, -0.01965501345694065, -0.05646311491727829, -0.028800861909985542, -0.008322213776409626, -0.013157879933714867, 0.055767226964235306, 0.021645385771989822, -0.04766778647899628, 0.03610304370522499, -0.03269047662615776, -0.013276834040880203, -0.021561075001955032, 0.031023818999528885, -0.006834512576460838, 0.04708006605505943, 0.033223241567611694, -0.026745667681097984, 0.020220156759023666, -0.005833729170262814, 0.10226497799158096, 0.08456382900476456, 0.035918548703193665, -0.09549031406641006, 0.01978575438261032, 0.01258031278848648, -0.022718310356140137, -0.058807116001844406, 0.005925396922975779, -0.015473219566047192, 0.02649512141942978, 0.03975220024585724, 0.03213543817400932, -0.010936561971902847, 0.03135235607624054, 0.048787910491228104, -0.010949401184916496, -0.04034756124019623, -0.02093043550848961, 0.03622209653258324, 0.03245192766189575, -0.03475162759423256, -0.04767382889986038, 0.01898658275604248, -0.002264641923829913, -0.04005862772464752, -0.012586098164319992, -0.005582921206951141, 0.03673512116074562, -0.037703920155763626, 0.006476266775280237, 0.03289848193526268, 0.06049980968236923, 0.04655111953616142, 0.007542853243649006, 0.024968145415186882, 0.05243778973817825, -0.027539564296603203, 0.029024025425314903, -0.010511749424040318, -0.0439721904695034, 0.008079114370048046, 0.008809441700577736, -0.03371388837695122, -0.036101046949625015, -0.015945157036185265, -0.020325396209955215, 0.041512664407491684, 0.01760459505021572, -0.036609891802072525, -0.003080528462305665, 0.001236165058799088, 0.002911754185333848, -0.030025778338313103, -0.03647182136774063, 0.03803678974509239, 0.044414110481739044, -0.05595256760716438, -0.01421411707997322, -0.014811625704169273, 0.0177073385566473, -0.01860368810594082, 0.014385119080543518, 0.043936293572187424, -0.008114256896078587, -0.0020144623704254627, -0.0408448688685894, 0.043081656098365784, 0.01712360791862011, -0.0013021404156461358, -0.008085445500910282, -0.027289532124996185, -0.017432715743780136, -0.031634725630283356, 0.014477730728685856, 0.012334641069173813, 0.021190254017710686, -0.00811068620532751, 0.011104288510978222, -0.03321791812777519, -0.04664929583668709, 0.006019993219524622, -0.0021979922894388437, -0.0017371586291119456, -0.02182258665561676, -0.010005814023315907, 0.0031196747440844774, 0.0642399713397026, 0.028925534337759018, -0.0017475454369559884, -0.02096709795296192, 0.041055046021938324, 0.01543469913303852, -0.057287123054265976, -0.005173349287360907, -0.01897445134818554, -0.042883917689323425, 0.024985654279589653, -0.006336647551506758, 0.057232026010751724, -0.009070701897144318, -0.003226629691198468, -0.02927827648818493, 0.004637238569557667, -0.036865584552288055, -0.009499631822109222, 0.03297629952430725, -0.03650783374905586, 0.002098991069942713, 0.024341396987438202, -0.0011987191392108798, -0.02944369986653328, -0.036133140325546265, -0.03292815387248993, -0.016652898862957954, -0.007834745571017265, 0.027832988649606705, -0.03538453206419945, 0.0117124542593956, -0.01112450659275055, 0.014364628121256828, -0.026348639279603958, -0.02166132815182209, -0.0863797590136528, 0.01844806969165802, 0.01634056307375431, -0.028031378984451294, -0.0203851405531168, 0.01888224482536316, -0.02319348230957985, 0.010297903791069984, 0.02182205766439438, -0.007774103432893753, 0.025514986366033554, -0.0357966348528862, -0.007547555956989527, -0.01796426624059677, 0.07934484630823135, -0.05533430352807045, 0.006512735970318317, 0.019108792766928673, -0.04917812719941139, -0.04165289178490639, -0.00950203463435173, -0.010327468626201153, 0.034558236598968506, 0.02155381813645363, 0.004836489912122488, -0.04520789161324501, 0.037896398454904556, -0.027295390143990517, -0.03400566428899765, -0.022044088691473007, 0.06185344606637955, 0.006656080484390259, 0.01562541536986828, -0.014004852622747421, -0.005204821936786175, -0.025104833766818047, 0.01076812855899334, 0.06190650165081024, 0.01587824709713459, -0.013033104129135609, 0.003184472443535924, 0.01724994368851185, 0.028662770986557007, 0.029749052599072456, -0.0205629114061594, 0.019906237721443176, 0.06900551915168762, -0.03316757082939148, 0.018883701413869858, 0.014450912363827229, 0.040153831243515015, -0.08103351294994354, -0.030712246894836426, -0.0009375219815410674, -0.0063389502465724945, 0.02453019469976425, -0.027385514229536057, 0.008447350934147835, 0.07777554541826248, -0.028486648574471474, 0.019695069640874863, 0.039252858608961105, 0.0008477601804770529, -0.007360882591456175, -0.003719448344781995, -0.006994666066020727, 0.03289979323744774, 0.021529797464609146, 0.01604522205889225, 0.04403381794691086, 0.019476981833577156, 0.018992135301232338, -0.009299910627305508, -0.015873193740844727, 0.014717941172420979, -0.0018069295911118388, -0.050138600170612335, 0.015287349000573158, -0.049840718507766724, -0.06507418304681778, 0.04359567165374756, -0.037136420607566833, 0.019726887345314026, 0.005623964127153158, 0.00781469326466322, -0.025307487696409225, 0.04763555899262428, 0.02152125909924507, -0.03607477620244026, 0.029881007969379425, -0.018295152112841606, -0.0028896545991301537, 0.017203273251652718, 0.025852300226688385, 0.041207414120435715, 0.006161463912576437, -0.01481577381491661, -0.014828075654804707, -0.02224631980061531, -0.004929457325488329, 0.011161343194544315, 0.006225748918950558, -0.004276853986084461, 0.02215166948735714, -0.028910517692565918, -0.002084418898448348, -0.058443695306777954, -0.03792403265833855, 0.030938025563955307, 0.015007518231868744, -0.03624989837408066, 0.024670781567692757, -0.028891772031784058, -0.055749643594026566, -0.012089576572179794, -0.00641427468508482, -0.012622173875570297, -0.059064555913209915, -0.040793124586343765, 0.0032006276305764914, -0.02936949022114277, -0.04286550357937813, -0.02558024413883686, -0.044239986687898636, 0.050091035664081573, -0.023185797035694122, 0.01862863264977932, 0.007836434990167618, -0.034269798547029495, 0.008788270875811577, -0.0944429263472557, 0.026242120191454887, 0.000557533057872206, -0.021488964557647705, 0.009271089918911457, -0.025905661284923553, -0.042127929627895355, 0.01822972111403942, 0.03440127894282341, 0.006720558740198612, 0.022526940330863, -0.04677353799343109, 0.02116282843053341, 0.014392494224011898, -0.015933288261294365, 0.04064413160085678, 0.02809935063123703, -0.0162308719009161, 0.011000227183103561, -0.014158489182591438, 0.02764531597495079, -0.043053146451711655, -0.0220551285892725, -0.012898072600364685, -0.002977611031383276, 0.01621384732425213, -0.024907048791646957, 0.04146541282534599, -0.029905781149864197, -0.03207840397953987, 0.03397445008158684, 0.0009744723211042583, 0.01495235413312912, 0.032723333686590195, 0.013264240697026253, -0.08269907534122467, 0.048985838890075684, -0.057036928832530975, -0.014842142350971699, 0.012485330924391747, 0.04631853848695755, 0.00008992806397145614, -0.057902321219444275, 0.027552984654903412, 0.014067906886339188, -0.043515801429748535, 0.01285503525286913, -0.00691899424418807, -0.0011185766197741032, 0.03818107396364212, 0.016413172706961632, 0.01289454661309719, 0.013767178170382977, -0.02173587679862976, 0.015669336542487144, 0.01823090761899948, 0.02205170877277851, -0.007046276703476906, -0.017637943848967552, 0.04113404452800751, 0.007402986753731966, 0.01643955707550049, -0.022497763857245445, -0.012870917096734047, -0.04428601637482643, -0.03216684237122536, 0.03432747721672058, -0.020977778360247612, 0.020797723904252052, -0.04791603609919548, 0.021909717470407486, 0.0077710822224617004, -0.058536890894174576, -0.03179430216550827, -0.04203950613737106, -0.005723246838897467, -0.02912185899913311, 0.01249175425618887, -0.011822637170553207, 0.021487759426236153, -0.022409489378333092, 0.0261230506002903, 0.007359061390161514, -0.02547420561313629, 0.022313306108117104, -0.030899329110980034, 0.005315229296684265, -0.01938730478286743, 0.0038802423514425755, -0.002193211577832699, -0.013550536707043648, -0.013036826625466347, -0.01631442829966545, 0.03137821704149246, 0.06310595571994781, 0.005663789343088865, -0.060010749846696854, -0.01751120388507843, -0.022374313324689865, 0.019976353272795677, -0.022398468106985092, -0.03390389680862427, -0.049948375672101974, 0.03416287526488304, -0.02009880356490612, 0.019110528752207756 ]
<p>I was just reading <a href="http://www.bayesian-inference.com/bayesfactors">this article</a> on the Bayes factor for a completely unrelated problem when I stumbled upon this passage</p> <blockquote> <p>Hypothesis testing with Bayes factors is more robust than frequentist hypothesis testing, since the Bayesian form avoids model selection bias, evaluates evidence in favor the null hypothesis, includes model uncertainty, and allows non-nested models to be compared (though of course the model must have the same dependent variable). <strong>Also, frequentist significance tests become biased in favor of rejecting the null hypothesis with sufficiently large sample size.</strong> [emphasis added]</p> </blockquote> <p>I've seen this claim before in <a href="http://www.fil.ion.ucl.ac.uk/~karl/Ten%20ironic%20rules%20for%20non-statistical%20reviewers.pdf">Karl Friston's 2012 paper in NeuroImage</a>, where he calls it the <em>fallacy of classical inference</em>.</p> <p>I've had a bit of trouble finding a truly pedagogical account of why this should be true. Specifically, I'm wondering:</p> <ol> <li>why this occurs</li> <li>how to guard against it</li> <li>failing that, how to detect it</li> </ol>
35,923
[ -0.048460766673088074, 0.010642074048519135, -0.0175529345870018, -0.06013273075222969, 0.05497772619128227, 0.004827182274311781, 0.03827677294611931, -0.016573581844568253, 0.04743269830942154, -0.014632534235715866, 0.03384171053767204, 0.02167593315243721, 0.09897021949291229, -0.013887972570955753, 0.02864491380751133, 0.028214888647198677, 0.00859505869448185, 0.006824457086622715, -0.01549523789435625, -0.04259414225816727, -0.02100517228245735, 0.08122923970222473, 0.02168017067015171, -0.029171030968427658, -0.011906977742910385, 0.00897291675209999, 0.032707810401916504, 0.0060087512247264385, 0.002842240035533905, 0.07408276945352554, -0.03435283899307251, -0.004069754388183355, 0.022322503849864006, 0.04178035631775856, -0.004610429517924786, -0.03134549409151077, 0.011001216247677803, 0.009786773473024368, -0.01162672694772482, 0.05688582733273506, -0.013660579919815063, -0.010082947090268135, -0.01053610909730196, 0.04922487214207649, -0.01382962241768837, 0.03881959617137909, -0.011941452510654926, -0.05076814442873001, 0.02782411128282547, -0.027476195245981216, 0.03878314420580864, 0.002994735725224018, 0.03978622704744339, 0.03570510074496269, -0.0254987683147192, -0.04230378940701485, 0.04818400368094444, 0.06935206800699234, -0.057621974498033524, -0.05693645030260086, -0.0569143109023571, -0.05395154282450676, 0.012197175994515419, -0.0009426131728105247, -0.05301881954073906, 0.030564378947019577, 0.016658255830407143, -0.041135024279356, 0.053664516657590866, 0.0036093241069465876, -0.013181814923882484, 0.026673270389437675, 0.04425210878252983, 0.023271119222044945, -0.014154416508972645, -0.0234055295586586, 0.03265083581209183, 0.037038154900074005, 0.05271748825907707, 0.04866490513086319, -0.0203276127576828, 0.007158107589930296, 0.027541019022464752, 0.0287405326962471, 0.0451347716152668, -0.03486530855298042, 0.04674730449914932, 0.0033068875782191753, 0.0053547453135252, 0.021027501672506332, -0.060724008828401566, -0.012244263663887978, 0.03487548604607582, -0.03004782274365425, -0.04562648758292198, 0.02267276868224144, -0.03344446048140526, 0.024269670248031616, 0.032986875623464584, -0.01032192725688219, -0.006571653299033642, -0.009410100057721138, 0.03809764236211777, 0.04119868949055672, -0.01967938430607319, 0.0030995667912065983, -0.003493019612506032, 0.01578274928033352, -0.05025418475270271, -0.037174805998802185, -0.05296604707837105, 0.04930294677615166, 0.0026241266168653965, 0.032071564346551895, 0.0009408593759872019, -0.0008150390931405127, 0.021082062274217606, -0.03172912821173668, 0.0663837343454361, 0.037322986871004105, 0.04572600871324539, 0.0013513409066945314, 0.038224801421165466, -0.05291907861828804, -0.019171366468071938, 0.00935999397188425, 0.013020409271121025, -0.02715836651623249, 0.007484291680157185, 0.05879606306552887, 0.0052690147422254086, 0.019839659333229065, 0.03347340226173401, 0.0389973409473896, -0.02686522901058197, -0.022164361551404, -0.06766337901353836, -0.041271619498729706, 0.0797739252448082, 0.06683266907930374, -0.021730318665504456, -0.09432654827833176, -0.007387602236121893, 0.04325457289814949, 0.035315755754709244, -0.010278959758579731, 0.018960433080792427, -0.017231253907084465, 0.011735656298696995, -0.01463274471461773, -0.029035553336143494, -0.03139246627688408, 0.005903807934373617, 0.0076315454207360744, -0.03060581535100937, -0.09476389735937119, 0.00020766419766005129, -0.012581435032188892, 0.015025092288851738, 0.004148641135543585, 0.03201892599463463, -0.007173024583607912, -0.01277430634945631, -0.022571230307221413, 0.003971944097429514, -0.013431472703814507, 0.10901253670454025, 0.0407627671957016, 0.01895815320312977, 0.023632816970348358, -0.005663958378136158, 0.03906489908695221, 0.020336242392659187, 0.031532350927591324, 0.008649894036352634, -0.03532266616821289, -0.010789499618113041, -0.022721372544765472, 0.04088544100522995, 0.0032851758878678083, -0.007337027695029974, -0.014262606389820576, -0.01003358419984579, -0.012047713622450829, -0.02994695119559765, 0.06561239808797836, -0.002985779196023941, 0.0069708856754004955, 0.024331122636795044, -0.026247220113873482, -0.0434030257165432, -0.045422423630952835, 0.013532855547964573, 0.00023014566977508366, -0.03945339098572731, 0.03623467683792114, -0.005894429050385952, 0.03824174031615257, -0.02272569015622139, 0.02856048382818699, -0.013803825713694096, -0.036713965237140656, 0.02202783152461052, -0.03522147238254547, 0.02270319126546383, 0.029116299003362656, 0.040284305810928345, 0.007873098365962505, 0.021894926205277443, -0.052245426923036575, -0.05164390057325363, -0.005893310997635126, -0.001146351103670895, 0.020673831924796104, -0.007118855137377977, -0.0315437987446785, 0.024182038381695747, -0.04137226939201355, -0.02716100588440895, 0.041070606559515, -0.06603538990020752, 0.06121447682380676, 0.034730564802885056, 0.008955004625022411, 0.007373610977083445, 0.03317679464817047, 0.02759324572980404, 0.010663170367479324, -0.02213427796959877, 0.027693722397089005, -0.049176182597875595, -0.02347763068974018, 0.025868147611618042, 0.008309380151331425, -0.020378105342388153, 0.03312545269727707, 0.019286874681711197, 0.05565376952290535, 0.01937454752624035, 0.035771965980529785, 0.004577708896249533, -0.025682741776108742, -0.025480659678578377, 0.005998227745294571, -0.0005078443209640682, 0.04534595459699631, 0.05298314243555069, 0.032924726605415344, 0.01459523756057024, 0.013073578476905823, -0.01906304992735386, 0.01766735501587391, -0.007671224419027567, 0.03068491630256176, 0.013725760392844677, 0.0117131806910038, -0.016106273978948593, -0.013248884119093418, 0.016129354014992714, 0.017689671367406845, 0.0026542297564446926, -0.03387104347348213, -0.03942937031388283, -0.02810928411781788, 0.02795131504535675, -0.003233627649024129, -0.033183638006448746, 0.014026857912540436, 0.014025799930095673, -0.0716550201177597, -0.014224383980035782, -0.02303415536880493, -0.06348790973424911, -0.00810281839221716, 0.03413885459303856, -0.01838889718055725, 0.004155824426561594, 0.015979794785380363, -0.013382997363805771, -0.0187352504581213, -0.035353485494852066, -0.014531695283949375, 0.015942346304655075, 0.010847292840480804, -0.026971546933054924, 0.019114386290311813, -0.039887718856334686, -0.016414353623986244, 0.029364636167883873, -0.04020150005817413, 0.0019275672966614366, -0.002702956786379218, 0.00015459471615031362, -0.0319293811917305, -0.012639696709811687, -0.018404604867100716, -0.0266423337161541, -0.019642388448119164, -0.013466096483170986, 0.043696388602256775, 0.01639435812830925, -0.03919294476509094, 0.014355230145156384, 0.011026927269995213, -0.0491841584444046, -0.0018217182951048017, 0.0016431225230917335, -0.045369647443294525, 0.016809070482850075, 0.0012590071419253945, -0.01006322167813778, -0.044137291610240936, -0.018937092274427414, -0.030831892043352127, -0.06811556220054626, 0.00108933518640697, 0.008787308819591999, 0.043681882321834564, -0.019548410549759865, 0.014189353212714195, 0.05006175488233566, 0.022069092839956284, -0.007515631150454283, -0.022764811292290688, -0.0016953540034592152, -0.012637109495699406, -0.02183487080037594, -0.024160075932741165, 0.019434185698628426, -0.016567813232541084, 0.021568207070231438, -0.02596333622932434, 0.01662903092801571, 0.018630167469382286, 0.014893741346895695, 0.0013230426702648401, 0.035569705069065094, -0.028578437864780426, -0.034996502101421356, 0.007165870163589716, 0.05257956683635712, -0.021172357723116875, 0.007572788745164871, -0.023578321561217308, 0.06454481184482574, 0.00152940908446908, -0.02022494748234749, 0.023865222930908203, -0.003746527247130871, 0.0028044627979397774, -0.052276819944381714, 0.025476569309830666, 0.018298231065273285, 0.008693516254425049, 0.01670319028198719, -0.01703198067843914, 0.03221962973475456, -0.04758202284574509, 0.028291599825024605, 0.02543427236378193, 0.03156697377562523, -0.0009259473299607635, -0.03502746671438217, -0.025642871856689453, 0.0067514292895793915, 0.026790881529450417, 0.011974338442087173, -0.03006199188530445, 0.05931464582681656, -0.007400874048471451, 0.049244534224271774, -0.06699179857969284, -0.05470074713230133, -0.0022690175101161003, -0.04682937636971474, 0.016641046851873398, 0.0037485624197870493, 0.03792141005396843, 0.047988612204790115, -0.002851557219401002, 0.03197232633829117, -0.020799456164240837, -0.049916937947273254, 0.02072198875248432, -0.0685257613658905, 0.009263025596737862, -0.02369772456586361, -0.032998617738485336, 0.008330891840159893, -0.005515588913112879, 0.045880090445280075, -0.02972387708723545, -0.01483728364109993, -0.03926506265997887, 0.02069682441651821, -0.03866541013121605, -0.0003035712579730898, -0.023994173854589462, -0.031512994319200516, -0.013070452958345413, 0.015527185052633286, 0.025864727795124054, -0.03242458030581474, 0.028083911165595055, 0.028859399259090424, -0.030433615669608116, -0.014367528259754181, -0.017635403200984, 0.04478340595960617, 0.03537329286336899, 0.029304955154657364, 0.003919463139027357, 0.02206050232052803, -0.07397670298814774, 0.055804066359996796, 0.01229926384985447, 0.0749925822019577, 0.028092125430703163, -0.008291244506835938, -0.012880627065896988, -0.020289946347475052, -0.03465714678168297, 0.019591400399804115, 0.040567152202129364, -0.003757519880309701, -0.0027095230761915445, 0.05452725663781166, 0.03094143234193325, -0.028873035684227943, 0.03494848683476448, 0.005440155044198036, 0.023825116455554962, 0.007303182501345873, 0.0012218477204442024, -0.011867846362292767, -0.038846589624881744, 0.025340955704450607, 0.011801292188465595, 0.0048479847609996796, -0.004888806492090225, -0.015451877377927303, 0.01175614818930626, -0.02373362146317959, -0.03181172162294388, -0.03022981435060501, -0.00783439353108406, 0.02152068167924881, 0.006473052781075239, -0.022802015766501427, 0.042658481746912, 0.020367512479424477, 0.018998872488737106, 0.016356386244297028, -0.027791058644652367, -0.06930851191282272, 0.00027239968767389655, 0.032752349972724915, 0.01981191337108612, -0.040470510721206665, 0.05183796212077141, -0.026100175455212593, -0.00531842140480876, 0.05507832393050194, -0.028538769111037254, 0.013754155486822128, -0.027598964050412178, 0.04688169062137604, -0.03629270941019058, -0.05378520488739014, -0.031261567026376724, -0.008341902866959572, -0.03705170750617981, 0.037930477410554886, -0.0008266129880212247, -0.011017643846571445, -0.03130500018596649, -0.0037693383637815714, 0.004721385892480612, 0.06085538491606712, -0.011347451247274876, -0.05958837270736694, 0.01485419925302267, -0.013670775108039379, -0.02554435096681118, -0.06392798572778702, 0.024428339675068855, -0.03616950660943985, -0.009266176261007786, 0.034340109676122665, -0.03700437769293785, -0.08251713961362839, 0.007322955410927534, -0.024012668058276176, -0.05360603332519531, -0.017542151734232903, -0.017020655795931816, 0.046286314725875854, -0.0005177932907827199, 0.027478359639644623, 0.05808272212743759, -0.012367823161184788, 0.015430022962391376, -0.006696617230772972, -0.0386078879237175, 0.024959754198789597, -0.05761130154132843, 0.0038482826203107834, -0.05114385485649109, 0.0020762591157108545, -0.021845664829015732, 0.036186907440423965, 0.022605983540415764, 0.019766736775636673, -0.020742911845445633, -0.024246906861662865, 0.03741583600640297, -0.013568633235991001, -0.0027801175601780415, 0.015309115871787071, -0.0034720373805612326, 0.018755080178380013, 0.01482485607266426, 0.010187225416302681, 0.07732613384723663, -0.019325852394104004, 0.005785255692899227, 0.01557794027030468, -0.010362627916038036, 0.017783604562282562, -0.06384750455617905, -0.013074965216219425, 0.018021903932094574, -0.032510437071323395, 0.009737862274050713, -0.032023075968027115, 0.025376686826348305, -0.013103590346872807, -0.00582027668133378, -0.022384749725461006, -0.023560920730233192, 0.016967853531241417, 0.047336552292108536, -0.03645842894911766, -0.004167833365499973, -0.026134636253118515, -0.0034603176172822714, -0.05109746754169464, -0.0219862163066864, 0.01960093155503273, 0.03817005828022957, -0.000005473193141369848, -0.010137982666492462, -0.009123900905251503, -0.0206855908036232, 0.0068879020400345325, -0.030222460627555847, 0.046112943440675735, -0.008701148442924023, -0.011892405338585377, 0.007020498160272837, 0.022811412811279297, 0.0641111359000206, -0.0017032736213877797, -0.012850889936089516, -0.011491775512695312, -0.029867155477404594, -0.01131849642843008, 0.0023934030905365944, 0.013881474733352661, -0.04774419963359833, -0.038547784090042114, -0.015985848382115364, -0.0005448488518595695, 0.03256562352180481, -0.02893051877617836, -0.016679121181368828, 0.0583830326795578, -0.016474321484565735, 0.03699827939271927, -0.01271425187587738, 0.01393142994493246, 0.011406554840505123, -0.012208121828734875, -0.0030920731369405985, 0.012487425468862057, 0.01397056132555008, -0.009892318397760391, 0.03884170949459076, -0.00007498922786908224, -0.03548571094870567, 0.0041934046894311905, 0.03647858649492264, -0.038117360323667526, 0.020489400252699852, -0.011113078333437443, -0.022130269557237625, 0.04873586446046829, 0.05713135749101639, 0.014512595720589161, 0.026796916499733925, 0.017443638294935226, -0.037224724888801575, -0.01830766536295414, -0.06455204635858536, 0.05093196779489517, 0.05299711972475052, -0.014328780584037304, 0.02057144232094288, 0.019014349207282066, -0.011728031560778618, 0.016182251274585724, -0.0220703836530447, 0.013475364074110985, -0.008561030961573124, 0.005623861216008663, 0.026543019339442253, -0.05995285511016846, 0.033801496028900146, 0.0582742877304554, -0.013587516732513905, -0.011738520115613937, 0.010826054960489273, 0.03325163945555687, 0.04276631772518158, 0.015185904689133167, -0.01424364373087883, -0.031206823885440826, 0.03877360373735428, -0.05317910760641098, 0.023353125900030136, -0.004645249806344509, -0.029905278235673904, 0.02488505095243454, 0.03770431876182556, -0.0003797326353378594, -0.061422236263751984, -0.044822242110967636, -0.030199645087122917, 0.026486150920391083, -0.0037525107618421316, 0.03308816999197006, 0.019107943400740623, -0.026301834732294083, 0.03335151448845863, 0.014259901829063892, 0.005865295883268118, -0.015265122056007385, -0.09000059217214584, -0.06489574164152145, 0.01815352961421013, -0.00006568953540408984, 0.04063001647591591, -0.00631911214441061, -0.03459007665514946, 0.03234552964568138, -0.04455152899026871, 0.01850694790482521, 0.03978446498513222, 0.01827233098447323, -0.02746199630200863, 0.04490423575043678, -0.004240959417074919, 0.014970866963267326, -0.018904458731412888, 0.006462596822530031, 0.12276845425367355, 0.05626584589481354, 0.04194191098213196, -0.03687293082475662, 0.03428298234939575, -0.016130996868014336, 0.0011400991352275014, -0.013216665014624596, 0.0025398677680641413, -0.011505935341119766, -0.0007447549724020064, -0.012833496555685997, 0.07083401829004288, 0.06086916849017143, -0.03800002858042717, 0.07030496001243591, -0.03937210887670517, -0.01949581317603588, 0.004705121740698814, 0.025990724563598633, 0.018910309299826622, -0.024916930124163628, -0.019313151016831398, -0.012604721821844578, -0.017796728760004044, -0.023680150508880615, -0.007813312113285065, 0.011558742262423038, -0.019678371027112007, 0.007774711586534977, -0.0024647044483572245, -0.013486978597939014, 0.05081881955265999, -0.016965782269835472, 0.000045262939238455147, -0.02470363862812519, 0.011093145236372948, -0.005359530448913574, 0.024579549208283424, 0.03475859388709068, -0.03292423486709595, 0.01998949609696865, 0.028954073786735535, 0.03186008334159851, -0.008201436139643192, -0.028465865179896355, -0.03690354526042938, 0.07530097663402557, -0.03354717046022415, 0.009121537208557129, -0.023847058415412903, -0.03968202695250511, 0.019616538658738136, -0.05554034188389778, -0.004811652470380068, 0.020741140469908714, 0.00590269872918725, -0.03308482840657234, -0.01175762340426445, -0.02352113462984562, 0.018760105594992638, -0.003052038373425603, 0.0312496367841959, 0.0525355264544487, 0.005771220661699772, -0.029271122068166733, 0.0015859324485063553, 0.00979719776660204, 0.03469429165124893, -0.0022146999835968018, -0.02415218949317932, -0.02134918048977852, -0.0720391720533371, 0.010545669123530388, 0.01045854389667511, -0.00934422854334116, 0.030850443989038467, -0.004625512752681971, -0.022463668137788773, -0.017684906721115112, -0.01745428703725338, -0.019105076789855957, -0.06616461277008057, -0.02449658326804638, -0.021976515650749207, 0.0018749466398730874, 0.017172832041978836, 0.034788887947797775, 0.022867515683174133, -0.00018455585814081132, -0.01133875735104084, 0.037369370460510254, 0.03867699205875397, -0.07395120710134506, -0.040908332914114, -0.020104937255382538, -0.021867061033844948, -0.02846498228609562, 0.015746908262372017, 0.02895842306315899, 0.028693335130810738, 0.04335034638643265, -0.003410225734114647, 0.032740261405706406, 0.0057013011537492275, 0.0068821050226688385, 0.009544940665364265, -0.029152585193514824, -0.005200435873121023, 0.046681180596351624, -0.00712374085560441, -0.04044787958264351, -0.019253136590123177, -0.03170584887266159, -0.007427177857607603, -0.02226632460951805, 0.0012630164856091142, -0.03265847638249397, 0.0025844494812190533, 0.016623778268694878, 0.03920445218682289, -0.02764906734228134, 0.014607501216232777, -0.01946147158741951, -0.027866847813129425, 0.003997046500444412, -0.018070103600621223, -0.012341028079390526, 0.03226349875330925, -0.03541968762874603, -0.00992746651172638, 0.023582518100738525, -0.000769947946537286, 0.007300196215510368, -0.02914561703801155, 0.05081269517540932, 0.03691056743264198, 0.03653308376669884, -0.01731118932366371, -0.015301976352930069, 0.06133148819208145, -0.03732660040259361, -0.033781908452510834, 0.022391945123672485, -0.032691095024347305, 0.020908430218696594, 0.02109530009329319, 0.03677181899547577, 0.012781606055796146, 0.01261189766228199, -0.030813125893473625, -0.01705944910645485, 0.0338137224316597, 0.016477778553962708, 0.0034360799472779036, -0.024491390213370323, -0.013924580067396164, 0.021387387067079544, 0.002515916945412755, 0.03242047131061554, 0.05773442983627319, 0.029485411942005157, 0.006755161564797163, 0.011599387973546982, -0.01377186831086874, -0.0016870254185050726, 0.004982728976756334, -0.012456435710191727, 0.012247583828866482, 0.08861548453569412, -0.025874733924865723, 0.027969321236014366, -0.011630582623183727, 0.017585357651114464, -0.10501569509506226, -0.03420712426304817, 0.02497454546391964, 0.009199652820825577, 0.027690786868333817, -0.05329107120633125, 0.02494443766772747, 0.01448590587824583, -0.07637642323970795, 0.006688314490020275, -0.013648923486471176, -0.047849733382463455, -0.04895595461130142, -0.0009047595085576177, -0.01142495684325695, 0.017621595412492752, -0.01110401377081871, 0.01616235449910164, 0.014864413067698479, 0.027543500065803528, 0.016501042991876602, -0.02437577210366726, -0.015752693638205528, 0.037114404141902924, -0.025522416457533836, -0.04532814025878906, 0.02138904109597206, 0.015636349096894264, -0.015053396113216877, 0.028508393093943596, 0.05222168192267418, 0.03246842324733734, 0.022374987602233887, 0.028891514986753464, 0.024357613176107407, 0.03944873809814453, 0.032818686217069626, 0.01637015864253044, -0.02451748214662075, -0.011774740181863308, 0.00453723082318902, 0.068557970225811, -0.006220939569175243, -0.03268485888838768, -0.004884704481810331, -0.04983498528599739, -0.04584798216819763, 0.005453778896480799, -0.00898861326277256, 0.005691776052117348, 0.005789122078567743, -0.0025823803152889013, -0.028693662956357002, -0.010564561933279037, -0.007194783538579941, -0.04091069847345352, -0.026762131601572037, 0.049526654183864594, 0.0394207164645195, -0.0015738342190161347, -0.0021990365348756313, -0.010769039392471313, 0.01501911599189043, -0.006766404025256634, -0.010158231481909752, -0.0014704500790685415, -0.03877926990389824, 0.013787184841930866, -0.005686567630618811, 0.006549371872097254, -0.012183108367025852, -0.04272037371993065, -0.03868131712079048, 0.014607347548007965, -0.0285207387059927, 0.0061659133061766624, -0.013695287518203259, -0.008394327014684677, 0.0025419413577765226, -0.07946104556322098, 0.07320919632911682, -0.02019163779914379, -0.0025089788250625134, -0.06012987345457077, -0.023357419297099113, -0.005420958157628775, 0.008549507707357407, 0.05284576863050461, -0.01411291491240263, 0.016603101044893265, 0.0141650615260005, 0.023439642041921616, -0.007017694879323244, -0.055692195892333984, 0.03197028487920761, 0.007908966392278671, 0.009243713691830635, 0.009488346055150032, -0.008095200173556805, 0.023873992264270782, 0.014170357026159763, 0.040550146251916885, 0.01717219687998295, 0.023367419838905334, 0.01331156212836504, 0.0020187264308333397, 0.052223362028598785, 0.009707091376185417, 0.0403764545917511, 0.02578013204038143, 0.010198532603681087, 0.03668498620390892, -0.0196116603910923, -0.017442867159843445, -0.0569002740085125, 0.01281122025102377, -0.022863438352942467, -0.0274345725774765, 0.02004263363778591, 0.029264558106660843, 0.0010689544724300504, -0.011596129275858402, 0.01784544438123703, 0.05100040137767792, -0.03022921085357666, -0.0055686114355921745, 0.01239174883812666, -0.00004422647907631472, 0.03170417994260788, -0.0014443411491811275, -0.0038285385817289352, 0.01677950844168663, -0.024732884019613266, -0.011468615382909775, 0.00683341221883893, 0.013662410899996758, -0.0042015858925879, 0.017806401476264, 0.07676943391561508, 0.00734490342438221, -0.011251791380345821, 0.01394046563655138, 0.06855325400829315, -0.032322145998477936, -0.052500102669000626, -0.01577557623386383, -0.031366560608148575, -0.0034465158823877573, -0.020790066570043564, 0.02221265248954296, 0.08845340460538864, 0.01838642545044422, 0.00796458125114441, 0.0024089068174362183, -0.0041078366339206696, -0.024754591286182404, -0.008744584396481514, 0.011021934449672699, -0.00034644006518647075, -0.03757987916469574, 0.0004414808063302189, 0.0050699845887720585, -0.022135267034173012, 0.033150337636470795, -0.012568754144012928, -0.013491256162524223, -0.0011147073237225413, -0.010919363237917423, -0.008307102136313915, 0.014388250187039375, -0.035030797123909, -0.022844871506094933, -0.005284781567752361, 0.019964560866355896, 0.009531413204967976, -0.05467383936047554, -0.006708883214741945, -0.009697923436760902, 0.05661388859152794, -0.062358200550079346, 0.027683841064572334, -0.02237229235470295, 0.04836152866482735, 0.001930896076373756, -0.01042117178440094 ]
<p>I have a distance matrix for some data I want to cluster. However, I don't just want to assign elements to clusters, but I also want to assign a probability for each element to belong to each cluster. </p> <p>Can you give me examples of clustering algorithms that can do that?</p> <p>Is there, for instance, a hierarchical clustering algorithm that returns, for each element, a probability to belong to any cluster? </p>
73,531
[ -0.04793161898851395, -0.005743915215134621, 0.012019370682537556, -0.03318510577082634, 0.02183464542031288, 0.007551325019448996, -0.012187395244836807, -0.007617303170263767, 0.028289223089814186, -0.03575662150979042, 0.0025964328087866306, 0.06308948993682861, 0.056213539093732834, 0.050142552703619, 0.020870482549071312, 0.019133158028125763, -0.0052400752902030945, -0.02303340472280979, -0.03553202003240585, 0.0022040840703994036, 0.027901064604520798, 0.004047754220664501, 0.017524173483252525, -0.03360695019364357, -0.036553122103214264, 0.03336517512798309, 0.004028460010886192, -0.022583533078432083, 0.032438017427921295, 0.07653822749853134, -0.052630458027124405, -0.023812225088477135, 0.023129818961024284, 0.027686625719070435, -0.0039713517762720585, -0.03071240708231926, -0.018155116587877274, -0.0035118439700454473, -0.06657145917415619, -0.006289957091212273, -0.05207900330424309, -0.03106214478611946, -0.01822802983224392, 0.058928392827510834, -0.02130221202969551, 0.0300032626837492, -0.021414367482066154, -0.03448674455285072, -0.0033533633686602116, -0.043134815990924835, 0.0898459330201149, -0.0029615170788019896, 0.0315093919634819, 0.03137676417827606, -0.0205649733543396, 0.007744818925857544, 0.0387759692966938, 0.07046060264110565, -0.0018877264810726047, -0.01836852915585041, -0.022106483578681946, -0.03098331391811371, 0.00595491286367178, -0.04273597523570061, -0.03146829828619957, 0.035191863775253296, -0.024942200630903244, -0.02555210515856743, 0.05604832246899605, 0.013358164578676224, -0.01610099896788597, 0.021159201860427856, 0.04059675708413124, -0.05734265223145485, 0.011317906901240349, -0.028102558106184006, -0.0038899702485650778, -0.002073004376143217, 0.05016319453716278, 0.018676988780498505, 0.044645607471466064, 0.022899609059095383, 0.013732575811445713, -0.004472971893846989, 0.019358428195118904, -0.027939438819885254, 0.04812996834516525, -0.038371361792087555, -0.0034114394802600145, 0.03721261024475098, -0.026148024946451187, -0.029039889574050903, 0.006672740913927555, 0.05036824196577072, -0.04134509339928627, 0.04902609437704086, -0.004288466647267342, 0.041505079716444016, 0.013884570449590683, 0.00008308283577207476, 0.0020924864802509546, -0.027201252058148384, 0.0051708403043448925, 0.014082234352827072, -0.0292937271296978, 0.011255191639065742, -0.04650111123919487, -0.014470105990767479, -0.024296872317790985, 0.041070420295000076, -0.003894163528457284, 0.04833398759365082, 0.004281846806406975, 0.004746085032820702, 0.03639598190784454, -0.04420538991689682, -0.01015922799706459, -0.03293073922395706, 0.006985167972743511, 0.07917224615812302, 0.022210009396076202, -0.028077267110347748, 0.04505142197012901, -0.03095104545354843, -0.04449940472841263, 0.01386174000799656, 0.005327622871845961, -0.013093301095068455, -0.014453083276748657, 0.0392005555331707, -0.0214749313890934, -0.02171468734741211, 0.046581536531448364, -0.0238037146627903, 0.021265361458063126, -0.006109877023845911, -0.08091827481985092, -0.03648367524147034, 0.0184522345662117, -0.01020121295005083, 0.014026925899088383, -0.0433456115424633, 0.025580963119864464, 0.015146676450967789, 0.03290943801403046, 0.0400683768093586, 0.035389211028814316, 0.007054951041936874, 0.0494384691119194, -0.0007003406644798815, -0.030019938945770264, -0.025629838928580284, -0.02287462167441845, -0.01828894019126892, 0.03056591935455799, -0.08482829481363297, 0.011251227930188179, 0.01160429511219263, -0.012982286512851715, 0.001389597775414586, 0.01311649288982153, -0.0006942256586626172, -0.016969069838523865, 0.005719110835343599, 0.006176033057272434, 0.00841159000992775, 0.0648890808224678, 0.029290661215782166, 0.035782165825366974, 0.015162857249379158, -0.039627186954021454, 0.02895336225628853, 0.0220851581543684, 0.04922810196876526, 0.06206514313817024, -0.004537797998636961, -0.021779384464025497, 0.020784666761755943, 0.05912207067012787, -0.0028505143709480762, 0.00309420982375741, -0.017332740128040314, 0.0356815904378891, -0.009856020100414753, 0.006623249500989914, 0.026933129876852036, 0.021580493077635765, -0.05411878973245621, 0.017770517617464066, -0.01968253217637539, -0.026951447129249573, -0.03522629290819168, 0.025530947372317314, -0.03440278023481369, -0.026308832690119743, 0.017515722662210464, 0.0149161946028471, -0.0037274996284395456, -0.008813285268843174, -0.013586029410362244, -0.05240068957209587, -0.04177948832511902, 0.0006906599155627191, -0.05776432901620865, -0.03456949070096016, 0.05778783932328224, 0.03364907577633858, 0.008132723160088062, 0.0484011135995388, -0.03733605518937111, -0.0489305779337883, -0.050398219376802444, -0.01792924478650093, -0.008602510206401348, -0.022108761593699455, -0.010783280245959759, 0.01921604573726654, -0.005332280416041613, -0.039365027099847794, -0.001052340492606163, -0.041094452142715454, 0.08533944189548492, 0.05070919916033745, 0.009966216050088406, 0.027988383546471596, -0.009169955737888813, 0.0043495348654687405, -0.008652378804981709, -0.0031311025377362967, -0.02367328479886055, -0.0771733745932579, 0.03227319195866585, 0.03787143528461456, 0.010167457163333893, -0.04921169951558113, 0.024284593760967255, 0.058121003210544586, 0.025638049468398094, 0.00014946232840884477, 0.025117812678217888, -0.030675536021590233, -0.0024275591131299734, 0.02037177048623562, 0.025513140484690666, 0.008494218811392784, -0.02262173220515251, 0.017203111201524734, 0.016053400933742523, 0.02390323020517826, -0.024935225024819374, -0.029229383915662766, 0.03735741600394249, -0.016315726563334465, 0.029505738988518715, -0.00259930151514709, -0.04739302396774292, 0.016781389713287354, 0.009031571447849274, -0.009556201286613941, 0.020268520340323448, 0.008814999833703041, -0.002232769737020135, 0.00981973484158516, -0.07168959081172943, 0.004655505530536175, 0.059169918298721313, -0.05949634313583374, 0.02419145032763481, 0.021267442032694817, 0.003215296659618616, 0.034261468797922134, 0.0009283368708565831, -0.007859533652663231, -0.016613679006695747, 0.022261139005422592, 0.05692283809185028, -0.013567917048931122, 0.03243535757064819, -0.014394188299775124, -0.019519396126270294, 0.0023173154331743717, -0.024469150230288506, -0.00017061519611161202, 0.008885640650987625, -0.05359894782304764, 0.009155919775366783, -0.03911339119076729, -0.03635833039879799, 0.024617720395326614, -0.0009255118202418089, -0.04703110083937645, 0.006880508735775948, 0.013733094558119774, -0.020072784274816513, 0.005547712557017803, -0.026358643546700478, 0.02485961653292179, -0.02699929103255272, 0.017939088866114616, 0.013348700478672981, -0.007887938059866428, -0.04825093597173691, 0.03271552547812462, -0.04477803036570549, -0.030841374769806862, -0.04920848831534386, 0.000865501759108156, 0.020723745226860046, -0.022333767265081406, 0.004240922164171934, 0.05170729383826256, -0.04427465796470642, 0.02499089203774929, -0.045374512672424316, -0.08486515283584595, 0.013322367332875729, 0.004207259975373745, 0.02788599766790867, 0.01852375827729702, -0.009890323504805565, 0.06631600111722946, 0.016742700710892677, -0.05668940767645836, -0.0107012540102005, 0.0006214590976014733, -0.03343691676855087, -0.006291733589023352, 0.024284780025482178, -0.007045029662549496, -0.01968579925596714, -0.005735124461352825, 0.024739384651184082, 0.011042852886021137, 0.07519328594207764, -0.00810651108622551, -0.014706737361848354, 0.02457618899643421, 0.006399284116923809, -0.02619827538728714, 0.04059840738773346, 0.012742545455694199, -0.0465112030506134, -0.0038276074919849634, 0.0023268871009349823, -0.018342170864343643, -0.011134663596749306, -0.035838037729263306, -0.0030663853976875544, -0.04434124380350113, -0.0002549781638663262, -0.04188476502895355, 0.0360335111618042, 0.005961899645626545, -0.009285097941756248, 0.06107247993350029, 0.050972871482372284, 0.03160419315099716, -0.025136828422546387, -0.013436953537166119, 0.0398053303360939, 0.061823900789022446, -0.05505659058690071, -0.017986120656132698, 0.007115618325769901, -0.013246790505945683, 0.014837981201708317, -0.021459689363837242, -0.013552185148000717, 0.012292775325477123, 0.03750386834144592, 0.012228259816765785, 0.035814471542835236, -0.049632053822278976, 0.04056348651647568, -0.06490588188171387, 0.013743185438215733, -0.03087751939892769, 0.043593425303697586, -0.012464407831430435, 0.03613186627626419, 0.020501233637332916, -0.003371510421857238, 0.016840748488903046, 0.010054401122033596, -0.05947989597916603, 0.02199002541601658, -0.026084713637828827, -0.0013408964732661843, -0.02532031759619713, -0.023734088987112045, 0.03626079857349396, -0.015630943700671196, 0.0031830426305532455, -0.0014527953462675214, 0.05594801530241966, -0.062332216650247574, 0.009279342368245125, -0.022265544161200523, -0.02255663461983204, -0.013049552217125893, -0.0050051892176270485, 0.0234761331230402, 0.013160697184503078, 0.05081753432750702, 0.021813062950968742, -0.01772889867424965, -0.00866031926125288, 0.016929995268583298, 0.01646893285214901, 0.026342401280999184, 0.03688342496752739, 0.018686780706048012, 0.039281100034713745, -0.043015241622924805, -0.013187296688556671, -0.024204153567552567, 0.05982596054673195, 0.037593744695186615, -0.021603848785161972, 0.010323643684387207, -0.042067017406225204, -0.04201412945985794, -0.005605196580290794, 0.01929458975791931, -0.03637074679136276, -0.006785717327147722, 0.019569989293813705, 0.018463339656591415, -0.08357987552881241, 0.0014140745624899864, 0.0937218964099884, 0.020531874150037766, -0.05117325112223625, -0.03553912416100502, -0.03668338805437088, 0.012937543913722038, -0.01437458023428917, 0.002090261783450842, -0.002116131829097867, -0.000357677141437307, 0.00036177985020913184, 0.012986930087208748, -0.008413461036980152, -0.0216367207467556, -0.008462087251245975, 0.015035378746688366, 0.05684429034590721, -0.000007218281098175794, -0.03748413920402527, 0.0021515495609492064, 0.027072325348854065, 0.045920416712760925, 0.04487141594290733, -0.012063577771186829, -0.08000075072050095, 0.027337754145264626, 0.03603658825159073, 0.033391762524843216, -0.03626181185245514, 0.0030369155574589968, -0.01448312122374773, -0.0019778739660978317, 0.07675258815288544, -0.03906388580799103, 0.03870391845703125, -0.018664022907614708, -0.015748651698231697, -0.00041839550249278545, 0.02175455540418625, -0.011002259328961372, 0.004172997549176216, 0.014808589592576027, 0.02351664938032627, -0.021181458607316017, -0.008981745690107346, -0.07735851407051086, 0.006075549870729446, 0.03268328309059143, 0.05654468759894371, -0.018025783821940422, 0.009373432025313377, 0.004127496387809515, 0.021480167284607887, -0.007741210982203484, -0.05673279985785484, 0.028379525989294052, 0.021541355177760124, -0.0026259482838213444, 0.042461805045604706, -0.028741851449012756, -0.046601563692092896, -0.0018236880423501134, -0.04202563315629959, -0.043861500918865204, -0.010045825503766537, -0.0010023004142567515, 0.026761827990412712, 0.029828939586877823, 0.025605684146285057, 0.04456369951367378, 0.020788511261343956, -0.005897567141801119, 0.02161102183163166, -0.049139998853206635, 0.022108595818281174, -0.014268686063587666, 0.003029267070814967, -0.03002515807747841, 0.0038107724394649267, -0.015796678140759468, 0.027366984635591507, -0.0037845876067876816, 0.02729175053536892, -0.0020237991120666265, -0.04508265107870102, -0.04085508733987808, 0.03526764363050461, -0.0012578412424772978, 0.0017026762943714857, 0.014468073844909668, 0.013605974614620209, 0.009482655674219131, -0.015449623577296734, 0.03965306654572487, 0.0012372408527880907, 0.010410529561340809, -0.044085849076509476, -0.042635854333639145, -0.010997654870152473, -0.0608610175549984, -0.0013004412176087499, 0.04825427383184433, -0.04940742626786232, 0.05657568201422691, -0.0058312127366662025, 0.045308277010917664, 0.008127176202833652, -0.05245816335082054, -0.022876091301441193, 0.0010380407329648733, -0.02379489876329899, 0.0478939451277256, -0.03973589837551117, 0.01699240133166313, -0.026805680245161057, -0.011564328335225582, -0.06665831059217453, -0.03722088038921356, -0.01949538104236126, 0.019533688202500343, -0.032423797994852066, -0.08821851760149002, 0.017959637567400932, -0.020121833309531212, -0.0177986528724432, -0.0009078155853785574, 0.059643302112817764, 0.019687101244926453, -0.005666785873472691, -0.00028860627207905054, 0.0071594370529055595, 0.06439093500375748, 0.03784923627972603, -0.009557664394378662, 0.03343256562948227, 0.015220005996525288, 0.023049136623740196, -0.02568747103214264, 0.01964477449655533, -0.0482194609940052, -0.01072095986455679, -0.034547850489616394, 0.04371180012822151, 0.045951198786497116, -0.03658619895577431, -0.016032284125685692, -0.027910644188523293, 0.030065350234508514, 0.010558140464127064, -0.02453240565955639, 0.020553667098283768, -0.009427047334611416, -0.016086267307400703, -0.009957479313015938, 0.026469506323337555, -0.01886007748544216, 0.003895747009664774, 0.023097503930330276, -0.0003625524404924363, 0.028956590220332146, 0.004997830372303724, 0.058685142546892166, -0.007176636252552271, -0.022161541506648064, 0.01994980312883854, -0.041390612721443176, 0.03190236911177635, 0.0017964865546673536, -0.022558314725756645, 0.020979655906558037, 0.020380286499857903, -0.014120103791356087, -0.017224187031388283, -0.0031288922764360905, -0.012192572467029095, 0.06589911878108978, 0.0008599654538556933, 0.03732958063483238, 0.07576882094144821, -0.011090618558228016, 0.0065797618590295315, -0.011998492293059826, -0.01832052506506443, -0.0038699673023074865, 0.020095638930797577, 0.03645520284771919, 0.003614425892010331, 0.013352002017199993, 0.03242916986346245, 0.018358634784817696, -0.0013868326786905527, 0.04216144233942032, 0.014540630392730236, 0.052042700350284576, 0.025815734639763832, -0.017949966713786125, -0.06246709078550339, 0.02892976440489292, -0.025209832936525345, 0.02470424212515354, -0.03966117277741432, -0.033048368990421295, 0.05738905072212219, 0.03929594159126282, -0.022883832454681396, 0.009524707682430744, -0.012495007365942001, -0.03331790491938591, 0.03082077018916607, 0.015955153852701187, 0.008178084157407284, -0.01039773691445589, 0.005754868034273386, 0.029995040968060493, 0.0034528044052422047, -0.01595558039844036, -0.023697994649410248, -0.050676558166742325, -0.03926316648721695, -0.04726655036211014, -0.06584297865629196, 0.003848328720778227, 0.03718224912881851, -0.05767689645290375, 0.012230710126459599, 0.0246767345815897, 0.0038778919260948896, 0.02249814197421074, 0.03314979746937752, 0.008766889572143555, 0.06382611393928528, 0.033292174339294434, 0.0284926388412714, 0.015040785074234009, -0.0012595985317602754, 0.10666155070066452, 0.07522911578416824, 0.04811668023467064, -0.04863407090306282, 0.027721932157874107, -0.02394477277994156, -0.017825307324528694, -0.02778657153248787, 0.052465055137872696, 0.016642745584249496, 0.00396296801045537, 0.006998760625720024, 0.051893215626478195, 0.0006150773842819035, 0.014641763642430305, 0.07687018811702728, -0.026862459257245064, -0.03727009892463684, -0.013328993692994118, -0.029369257390499115, -0.029374683275818825, 0.0035330120008438826, -0.07430805265903473, 0.024758867919445038, 0.03484527766704559, -0.01042279414832592, -0.03789788857102394, -0.014952956698834896, 0.007651527412235737, 0.0031292657367885113, -0.00043690387974493206, -0.01686478778719902, 0.04420109838247299, 0.0031767708715051413, -0.025292638689279556, -0.009509052149951458, 0.001012455322779715, -0.0026068291626870632, -0.00030189979588612914, -0.012531109154224396, 0.024687396362423897, -0.007000919431447983, -0.02235323004424572, 0.013613239862024784, -0.04443735629320145, -0.015651816502213478, -0.02897379733622074, 0.02777315117418766, -0.024157028645277023, 0.024329734966158867, 0.005397779867053032, 0.020580805838108063, -0.00043264005216769874, -0.028302405029535294, 0.007381884381175041, 0.015887577086687088, 0.057844217866659164, 0.02672004885971546, -0.027313483878970146, -0.051850877702236176, 0.034907326102256775, -0.031362392008304596, 0.019400352612137794, 0.03398158401250839, -0.009906119666993618, -0.037789300084114075, -0.0388353206217289, 0.02739325538277626, -0.027344247326254845, -0.04455750435590744, -0.03451145812869072, -0.009778250008821487, -0.0320180207490921, -0.013790737837553024, -0.002051549730822444, -0.020757846534252167, 0.05508945509791374, 0.03040286712348461, -0.015986887738108635, 0.04233843460679054, -0.023551493883132935, -0.01997365802526474, -0.037319641560316086, -0.009276620112359524, -0.04019555449485779, 0.02444235235452652, 0.05694865435361862, 0.020930498838424683, 0.012585545890033245, 0.0316772535443306, -0.027881184592843056, -0.018303001299500465, -0.011430368758738041, -0.02887866087257862, -0.005741055589169264, -0.005750237498432398, -0.02807741053402424, 0.027769755572080612, -0.012058890424668789, 0.039321720600128174, 0.016020871698856354, -0.017973963171243668, -0.02055392973124981, 0.01868279278278351, -0.0005222914624027908, 0.034346144646406174, -0.011492638848721981, -0.05519502982497215, 0.004498523660004139, -0.0004745299811474979, 0.0083933649584651, -0.0249303188174963, -0.02359388768672943, 0.012502730824053288, -0.0385427288711071, 0.010668432340025902, 0.003949077799916267, -0.026728833094239235, -0.025114087387919426, -0.016463087871670723, 0.013122919015586376, -0.036447372287511826, 0.0033551629167050123, -0.019364885985851288, -0.0020044338889420033, -0.01014139223843813, -0.014886470511555672, -0.020478103309869766, 0.0032531851902604103, -0.010828503407537937, 0.008655908517539501, 0.04370477795600891, 0.014268696308135986, 0.02436126209795475, 0.0169939287006855, 0.021111594513058662, -0.03101850301027298, 0.052271679043769836, -0.042945582419633865, -0.013728738762438297, 0.04877535253763199, -0.052171096205711365, -0.03672972694039345, 0.008477645926177502, -0.02618901990354061, 0.05810006335377693, 0.04663990065455437, -0.016435807570815086, -0.0008405264234170318, 0.0316215343773365, -0.03466452658176422, -0.04735567048192024, -0.006118231453001499, -0.010585101321339607, 0.007553749717772007, 0.023714251816272736, -0.00825346726924181, 0.025041885673999786, -0.047777462750673294, 0.007306735962629318, 0.029099173843860626, -0.015307094901800156, -0.0227469764649868, 0.030777281150221825, 0.02143138460814953, 0.03071979433298111, 0.017873022705316544, -0.0070627364329993725, 0.049499765038490295, 0.04173007979989052, -0.013881715945899487, 0.054923348128795624, -0.0031010981183499098, 0.01162663847208023, -0.07772242277860641, -0.0239653792232275, 0.01735144853591919, -0.008087201043963432, 0.05338960886001587, -0.07615946978330612, -0.009100162424147129, 0.0485086664557457, -0.056836578994989395, 0.038945022970438004, 0.04443305358290672, -0.03238817676901817, -0.02829928696155548, 0.023795442655682564, -0.028889209032058716, 0.04623168334364891, 0.04361223056912422, 0.03447898477315903, 0.027619557455182076, -0.0012386705493554473, 0.0012372889323160052, -0.01415157038718462, -0.02520998939871788, 0.03321570158004761, 0.012032280676066875, -0.03086855448782444, 0.026470554992556572, -0.049249954521656036, -0.03504534065723419, 0.03429603576660156, 0.018395787104964256, -0.006837852299213409, 0.05175330862402916, -0.000994312227703631, -0.009967580437660217, 0.04059427231550217, 0.000845802016556263, -0.008334318175911903, 0.005866882856935263, 0.015324452891945839, 0.013658953830599785, 0.024857522919774055, -0.034945446997880936, 0.0077523537911474705, 0.02313910238444805, -0.013566569425165653, -0.03886435553431511, 0.024269599467515945, -0.017517585307359695, -0.02022623084485531, -0.008202744647860527, -0.033960971981287, -0.014298491179943085, -0.01831958256661892, -0.0038117757067084312, 0.0011671105166897178, 0.02288307063281536, 0.0382855199277401, 0.0036845302674919367, 0.010417010635137558, 0.02879983000457287, -0.005852815695106983, -0.05756383389234543, 0.012182500213384628, -0.030378203839063644, -0.01466439850628376, -0.048835624009370804, 0.004268020857125521, 0.005393902771174908, 0.005285855382680893, 0.0010756247211247683, -0.02835005708038807, -0.01026833988726139, 0.05295118689537048, -0.05055626854300499, 0.011339455842971802, 0.02893448993563652, 0.006712386384606361, 0.015037020668387413, -0.06105292961001396, 0.056754130870103836, -0.004811791703104973, 0.011753513477742672, -0.037332478910684586, 0.02012522518634796, -0.023127395659685135, 0.0031850473023951054, 0.03640873730182648, 0.019280215725302696, 0.03532546013593674, -0.020121999084949493, 0.015614539384841919, 0.02250405214726925, -0.04659174755215645, 0.04360096901655197, -0.02577844262123108, -0.046899475157260895, -0.037520382553339005, -0.013324004597961903, 0.0063392771407961845, -0.010943274945020676, 0.008758343756198883, -0.013613209128379822, -0.011449914425611496, -0.0028861749451607466, 0.010914585553109646, 0.03735712915658951, -0.0037537291646003723, -0.00814034417271614, 0.04292398318648338, -0.015551370568573475, 0.0024990453384816647, 0.02103208750486374, -0.006554830353707075, -0.008360365405678749, 0.03764549270272255, -0.057141222059726715, -0.051756687462329865, 0.024086400866508484, 0.028977110981941223, 0.006989472080022097, -0.06521016359329224, 0.0008252612897194922, 0.031095042824745178, -0.048890627920627594, 0.008723079226911068, 0.03199557960033417, 0.02230549044907093, 0.06809739768505096, -0.004920742940157652, 0.0237877257168293, 0.006915862672030926, -0.002726292470470071, 0.013277451507747173, 0.014263818971812725, 0.0479094497859478, -0.009204251691699028, 0.02425381913781166, -0.015164441429078579, -0.018354488536715508, 0.010040439665317535, 0.0013627263251692057, 0.018160972744226456, -0.030651729553937912, -0.007729367818683386, 0.014126050285995007, -0.03174936771392822, 0.02538425289094448, 0.017270484939217567, -0.004902753047645092, 0.039388153702020645, -0.0117613160982728, 0.004174164030700922, -0.07299719005823135, -0.007257318124175072, -0.027936704456806183, -0.004387473687529564, -0.003233234165236354, 0.04945223033428192, -0.006159608252346516, 0.03566846251487732, 0.00765755632892251, 0.013502857647836208, 0.05537545680999756, -0.022008296102285385, 0.05612902715802193, -0.013855150900781155, -0.0025514569133520126, -0.02313704788684845, -0.0030965947080403566, -0.033032603561878204, 0.007377492263913155, 0.023603344336152077, 0.045723091810941696, 0.04652395099401474, 0.032677214592695236, -0.020822620019316673, -0.007904714904725552, 0.025852544233202934, -0.04786919057369232, -0.012430121190845966, -0.10141794383525848, 0.008776536211371422, -0.024198129773139954, 0.013435052707791328 ]
<p>I have a sample taken from a population that I know to have a highly positive skew, although I know nothing else about the population. </p> <p>My sample displays a similar skew. Sample size is 120.</p> <p>Is it incorrect to transform (Box-Cox) my sample to normality to perform simple parametric tests like a mean with a confidence interval?</p> <p>Should I just stick with medians?</p>
47,351
[ -0.038819655776023865, -0.031021684408187866, -0.0004088049754500389, 0.0010171363828703761, 0.049301378428936005, 0.024228543043136597, -0.009908994659781456, -0.010469979606568813, 0.02310005947947502, -0.04354910925030708, 0.05428743362426758, 0.015076781623065472, 0.0031672490295022726, -0.022610247135162354, 0.005156278144568205, 0.024307511746883392, -0.03937839716672897, 0.002577444538474083, -0.004963621962815523, 0.002039602492004633, -0.0021191949490457773, 0.020048899576067924, 0.03620024025440216, 0.008426330052316189, -0.04321333020925522, 0.06881409883499146, 0.020185304805636406, -0.03809201344847679, 0.0028383522294461727, 0.07104270905256271, -0.040929749608039856, -0.009631115011870861, 0.027857434004545212, 0.03908707946538925, 0.03467240557074547, 0.025066860020160675, 0.002941698068752885, -0.0020893982145935297, 0.023187369108200073, 0.02323504537343979, -0.01284095924347639, -0.00711630517616868, 0.01510633435100317, 0.022221866995096207, 0.0006629657582379878, 0.061336737126111984, -0.00475354352965951, -0.06380289793014526, -0.00979702826589346, -0.04731591418385506, 0.06833478808403015, -0.039524734020233154, 0.016601402312517166, 0.05460748448967934, -0.0023556773085147142, -0.047102976590394974, 0.048901576548814774, 0.0623028390109539, -0.04730726778507233, -0.03175349533557892, 0.033473968505859375, -0.025234084576368332, -0.033949702978134155, -0.02458975464105606, -0.05217534676194191, -0.00613046670332551, -0.016334783285856247, -0.017964964732527733, 0.05129058286547661, -0.02160412073135376, 0.029791846871376038, 0.04041700437664986, 0.014970437623560429, -0.041803810745477676, 0.013436169363558292, -0.04956953227519989, 0.022215543314814568, 0.02936571091413498, 0.03402133658528328, 0.015451662242412567, 0.03199290111660957, -0.02367030642926693, 0.032698776572942734, 0.03552553057670593, 0.029844151809811592, -0.021213900297880173, 0.05745193362236023, -0.04475361481308937, 0.016888104379177094, 0.043377216905355453, 0.002182136522606015, -0.03534097969532013, 0.07039138674736023, -0.0005701223271898925, -0.01584087498486042, 0.04742690175771713, -0.050386060029268265, 0.05208657681941986, -0.006486443802714348, -0.022067183628678322, -0.00585844786837697, -0.053584206849336624, 0.01214270107448101, 0.024229809641838074, -0.017137231305241585, 0.03882189840078354, -0.011813879013061523, 0.008434263989329338, 0.019994884729385376, -0.010100608691573143, -0.019650518894195557, -0.018817950040102005, -0.02030264586210251, 0.0035415985621511936, 0.025527076795697212, -0.005725984461605549, -0.009282434359192848, -0.03694259375333786, 0.019598230719566345, 0.027333663776516914, 0.03195710480213165, -0.008624523878097534, 0.03637633100152016, -0.035799071192741394, -0.051041729748249054, 0.016899408772587776, 0.014632890932261944, 0.0019301132997497916, -0.06544607132673264, 0.06616097688674927, 0.020517827942967415, 0.013280203565955162, 0.029699018225073814, -0.013699729926884174, 0.030598031356930733, 0.006758254487067461, -0.06252217292785645, -0.06083489954471588, 0.03134395554661751, -0.01493856217712164, -0.034900084137916565, -0.0622689351439476, -0.02594277448952198, 0.045741479843854904, 0.013779631815850735, -0.015328504145145416, 0.050049737095832825, -0.0060262978076934814, 0.043227504938840866, -0.010352029465138912, -0.020002251490950584, -0.00818270817399025, -0.036109838634729385, -0.0054740095511078835, 0.019026828929781914, -0.1124543622136116, -0.006491262000054121, 0.002429582644253969, 0.027992267161607742, -0.0268805380910635, 0.03022713027894497, -0.02292359620332718, 0.002777318237349391, -0.022132785990834236, 0.0005784987006336451, -0.002163712866604328, 0.10243309289216995, 0.004973075818270445, 0.032746221870183945, -0.008488673716783524, -0.01110351923853159, 0.03404807671904564, 0.015405100770294666, 0.04533463343977928, 0.05866905674338341, -0.05076078325510025, 0.0020348303951323032, -0.015548495575785637, 0.045641545206308365, 0.01041010208427906, -0.05576334521174431, -0.0019272749777883291, -0.03172047808766365, 0.026432976126670837, 0.012001938186585903, 0.051284316927194595, -0.017527634277939796, -0.006556942593306303, 0.045261699706315994, -0.05694789066910744, -0.025915727019309998, -0.07017001509666443, -0.006104609929025173, -0.0009297009091824293, -0.03128949552774429, -0.00021676534379366785, 0.013216259889304638, 0.02984374202787876, -0.014428502880036831, -0.0036502890288829803, -0.005718915723264217, 0.00008739047189010307, 0.058296941220760345, -0.03543207794427872, 0.010488533414900303, 0.06985077261924744, 0.06134525313973427, -0.04642034322023392, 0.0038338808808475733, -0.033181216567754745, -0.03149387240409851, 0.0003227844717912376, -0.04213925823569298, 0.01658058352768421, -0.008507778868079185, -0.005170140415430069, 0.0006560844485647976, 0.010992104187607765, -0.015534338541328907, 0.02709524892270565, -0.04439428448677063, 0.07607979327440262, 0.041332345455884933, -0.024457259103655815, 0.004182836040854454, 0.003874914487823844, 0.02234436757862568, -0.004971832036972046, -0.004316140431910753, -0.005097065586596727, -0.06805048882961273, 0.006923429202288389, 0.035427276045084, -0.019548548385500908, -0.055858638137578964, 0.004524314310401678, 0.05452454462647438, -0.006569383200258017, 0.008102611638605595, 0.035113625228405, 0.03409002348780632, -0.040231768041849136, 0.018749788403511047, 0.018498791381716728, 0.04288182780146599, 0.017830731347203255, -0.0011657349532470107, -0.02366374060511589, 0.015827931463718414, 0.007116309367120266, 0.026254525408148766, 0.03613093122839928, 0.030209902673959732, 0.0175317395478487, -0.018001196905970573, -0.004610808566212654, 0.019881421700119972, -0.024849306792020798, -0.03207746520638466, 0.04915681481361389, -0.015082904137670994, 0.003249561879783869, 0.010042506270110607, -0.0053087687119841576, 0.013061539269983768, 0.049613580107688904, -0.018915198743343353, 0.012678085826337337, 0.03024333529174328, -0.05791160464286804, 0.0020693561527878046, -0.01758386567234993, -0.05324023589491844, -0.011410186067223549, -0.008158659562468529, 0.03174109384417534, 0.026192324236035347, 0.045433517545461655, -0.03170459717512131, -0.011679904535412788, 0.014861582778394222, 0.02413766458630562, -0.00748149398714304, 0.007179462816566229, -0.0714164450764656, -0.029075073078274727, -0.007585721556097269, -0.04446171596646309, 0.00935221929103136, 0.005750164855271578, 0.0006655784673057497, 0.014638612978160381, -0.012859158217906952, -0.007841384969651699, -0.0326516218483448, -0.02201702445745468, -0.008399836719036102, -0.017373202368617058, -0.05959019064903259, 0.07268022000789642, 0.009982699528336525, -0.01440105214715004, 0.05668504908680916, -0.012400404550135136, -0.04675314202904701, -0.02758738212287426, 0.021988578140735626, 0.028564663603901863, -0.009194402024149895, 0.009842452593147755, 0.012491394765675068, -0.037451937794685364, -0.005971027072519064, -0.06085904687643051, -0.03004910796880722, 0.008131646551191807, 0.006691477261483669, 0.06268307566642761, 0.023369764909148216, -0.01647508516907692, 0.09009533375501633, 0.036176495254039764, -0.028624068945646286, -0.02815413475036621, -0.032427042722702026, -0.052818719297647476, -0.012165217660367489, 0.009346586652100086, 0.010335219092667103, 0.022845091298222542, 0.0378032810986042, -0.0048651318065822124, 0.05334791541099548, 0.012531372718513012, 0.013393782079219818, -0.0469156876206398, 0.002619672566652298, -0.019185826182365417, -0.02467084676027298, 0.045784298330545425, 0.05454108864068985, -0.021854307502508163, -0.00019411093671806157, 0.001914536114782095, -0.002423439174890518, 0.02379491738975048, -0.03642122447490692, 0.027227329090237617, -0.017297862097620964, -0.004991437308490276, -0.03422738239169121, 0.05175914242863655, -0.0001858954201452434, -0.03021976538002491, -0.021647704765200615, 0.014642423018813133, 0.036036841571331024, -0.0027818623930215836, 0.018264928832650185, 0.044790349900722504, 0.015277711674571037, 0.018285805359482765, 0.004119132179766893, 0.009127939119935036, -0.01799900457262993, 0.01208439376205206, -0.0014831257285550237, 0.008536449633538723, 0.005842720158398151, 0.053206030279397964, 0.017797401174902916, -0.010555281303822994, -0.03350341320037842, 0.024984948337078094, -0.03603760153055191, -0.0012661702930927277, -0.002534533618018031, 0.009850422851741314, 0.008218509145081043, 0.023630542680621147, 0.039949942380189896, -0.03222564607858658, 0.015258182771503925, 0.0036384935956448317, -0.04435928538441658, 0.02378784492611885, -0.03474963828921318, 0.02375124953687191, -0.012466042302548885, -0.0054503087885677814, 0.041732050478458405, -0.012163253501057625, 0.010380490683019161, -0.014318127185106277, 0.058054182678461075, -0.0030987642239779234, 0.013728675432503223, -0.03776174411177635, -0.015683721750974655, 0.008151753805577755, 0.014190667308866978, -0.006270219571888447, -0.024895863607525826, 0.011786162853240967, 0.03659166395664215, 0.02506273053586483, -0.0038853250443935394, 0.008798346854746342, 0.04318813234567642, 0.0029857701156288385, 0.046286921948194504, 0.016457730904221535, 0.034350425004959106, -0.02100091055035591, 0.01001732237637043, 0.00799299031496048, 0.055584367364645004, 0.032677777111530304, 0.005101680289953947, -0.009832525625824928, -0.05151581019163132, -0.03621463105082512, -0.012858697213232517, -0.026275284588336945, 0.010247893631458282, -0.005243320949375629, 0.055941518396139145, 0.01815587840974331, -0.0810428261756897, 0.0064283632673323154, 0.0530434176325798, -0.004849754273891449, 0.01033556368201971, -0.05954146012663841, -0.004440012853592634, -0.016298510134220123, -0.029747480526566505, 0.019572865217924118, -0.002055027987807989, -0.010475190356373787, -0.027895068749785423, 0.04212571308016777, -0.00066204002359882, -0.05838881433010101, 0.0040254611521959305, 0.011400916613638401, 0.026563964784145355, 0.003523588180541992, -0.0015135842841118574, 0.038992639631032944, 0.026665985584259033, 0.017785387113690376, 0.009039433673024178, 0.008577101863920689, -0.08524524420499802, 0.032607268542051315, 0.044512033462524414, 0.060073383152484894, -0.008311721496284008, 0.014585825614631176, -0.033828187733888626, 0.03396274894475937, 0.03637684881687164, -0.03982989490032196, 0.006535010877996683, -0.02333790995180607, -0.0036530038341879845, -0.018990343436598778, -0.028343606740236282, -0.06330478191375732, 0.007266019470989704, 0.010437804274260998, -0.014726678840816021, -0.005329090170562267, -0.03549306467175484, -0.0680239349603653, 0.029214568436145782, -0.008807102218270302, 0.06126740947365761, -0.0659242644906044, -0.012092359364032745, 0.016790643334388733, 0.02806343324482441, -0.010788435116410255, -0.042304132133722305, -0.01144255232065916, -0.0032789786346256733, -0.007491900119930506, 0.048257146030664444, 0.039947401732206345, -0.02851337194442749, 0.012648173607885838, -0.03393707796931267, -0.029752977192401886, -0.0020056443754583597, -0.010679217055439949, 0.01973334327340126, 0.02263411320745945, 0.04640213027596474, 0.033326081931591034, 0.030844146385788918, -0.005779099650681019, -0.0086603919044137, -0.05933373421430588, -0.009598324075341225, -0.0438709631562233, 0.00003503648258629255, -0.044407449662685394, 0.008331895805895329, -0.013013510033488274, 0.010003999806940556, 0.001685194089077413, 0.04028796777129173, -0.002425586339086294, -0.0035774267744272947, 0.051452383399009705, 0.01336598303169012, 0.033921558409929276, -0.013213517144322395, -0.00384932360611856, -0.0028513330034911633, -0.01802719570696354, -0.006518271751701832, -0.0014489935711026192, -0.027280952781438828, 0.030754663050174713, 0.013613997027277946, -0.039162471890449524, 0.005574035923928022, -0.047885116189718246, -0.02491954155266285, -0.0104155158624053, -0.07306290417909622, 0.03401446342468262, 0.01295456849038601, 0.0178662221878767, 0.03462055325508118, -0.028869155794382095, 0.004374086856842041, 0.025781091302633286, 0.0005584132159128785, 0.02368370071053505, -0.03776702657341957, 0.04912441596388817, -0.014314137399196625, 0.03575915843248367, -0.06295858323574066, -0.05369693413376808, 0.015706753358244896, -0.01192100252956152, 0.019461434334516525, -0.05356432870030403, 0.003979431930929422, 0.012112710624933243, -0.02368166483938694, -0.018712477758526802, 0.04545575752854347, -0.012373358942568302, -0.03963563218712807, -0.038211703300476074, 0.02157643623650074, 0.10209248960018158, -0.046492062509059906, 0.008999197743833065, 0.012896720319986343, 0.012158114463090897, -0.042741402983665466, -0.002306479262188077, 0.034616440534591675, -0.017938319593667984, -0.03880949318408966, -0.011538899503648281, -0.009765926748514175, 0.02130548655986786, -0.040193941444158554, -0.003880841424688697, 0.0037861373275518417, 0.03430870175361633, 0.016279637813568115, -0.015731703490018845, -0.020354270935058594, 0.0044539012014865875, 0.009027336724102497, -0.020004242658615112, 0.024990880861878395, -0.014592133462429047, -0.01670362614095211, 0.05202541872859001, 0.01961248368024826, 0.011884929612278938, 0.02778126671910286, 0.06432847678661346, -0.020298350602388382, 0.014771582558751106, -0.031929630786180496, -0.04914538189768791, 0.014332341030240059, 0.04317142441868782, -0.020219121128320694, 0.013958845287561417, -0.005923374556005001, -0.0052471221424639225, -0.010300000198185444, -0.03999536111950874, -0.010271546430885792, 0.04514892399311066, -0.006251444108784199, 0.043405931442976, 0.03246885910630226, 0.0025901480112224817, -0.006329761818051338, -0.0037662924733012915, 0.006753499154001474, -0.024018051102757454, 0.004803660325706005, 0.04934072494506836, 0.018683278933167458, 0.04933242127299309, -0.01325454842299223, 0.044322527945041656, -0.004785250872373581, 0.03230379521846771, 0.04977262765169144, 0.013612335547804832, 0.03432949632406235, -0.02008996158838272, -0.056444115936756134, 0.04820750281214714, -0.051885731518268585, 0.055865198373794556, -0.04468686133623123, 0.02095407247543335, 0.0585157684981823, 0.026699131354689598, -0.019215067848563194, -0.03540615364909172, -0.014806121587753296, -0.04214569181203842, -0.031776558607816696, 0.007933991961181164, -0.03413594514131546, 0.01948799192905426, 0.0265307929366827, 0.08012028783559799, -0.012381982989609241, 0.026660114526748657, -0.04221801832318306, -0.05722455680370331, -0.027977004647254944, -0.019454604014754295, -0.050635822117328644, 0.010231557302176952, -0.05409757047891617, 0.022969258949160576, 0.0031171077862381935, -0.03931499645113945, 0.009561467915773392, -0.009919443167746067, 0.04549066349864006, -0.030346054583787918, 0.04514450207352638, 0.01022403221577406, 0.006867733784019947, -0.00928746722638607, -0.012857776135206223, 0.12267915904521942, 0.08075658977031708, -0.0034230798482894897, -0.07131992280483246, 0.0028894736897200346, -0.02702796645462513, 0.008373560383915901, 0.007081472780555487, 0.014398296363651752, -0.015111131593585014, -0.01423592958599329, 0.062231309711933136, 0.03550925850868225, 0.011235155165195465, -0.004569340031594038, 0.03908700495958328, -0.0037421321030706167, -0.03055199421942234, 0.0043754796497523785, 0.026813749223947525, -0.01136762648820877, -0.0008444218547083437, -0.06714478135108948, 0.01322589535266161, -0.01822309009730816, -0.023636484518647194, -0.0018422275315970182, -0.033628810197114944, -0.021560342982411385, -0.006436813622713089, -0.014347308315336704, 0.017494237050414085, 0.041688740253448486, -0.027250876650214195, -0.03310650587081909, -0.016240058466792107, 0.00854517426341772, -0.02667275257408619, 0.018618907779455185, 0.04123811423778534, -0.023441363126039505, 0.03352159634232521, 0.007056009024381638, 0.00995682179927826, -0.03897048160433769, -0.007630345411598682, -0.0036251419223845005, 0.0164014995098114, -0.014074841514229774, -0.01272631250321865, -0.020663321018218994, -0.031336694955825806, -0.015866052359342575, -0.07456506788730621, -0.0122114522382617, 0.02229079231619835, 0.00989493913948536, -0.02052217163145542, -0.013171973638236523, -0.017369955778121948, 0.013524326495826244, 0.039653170853853226, 0.00217268243432045, 0.04717813432216644, 0.00956025067716837, 0.010229191742837429, -0.030798738822340965, 0.052293382585048676, -0.0015430316561833024, -0.007396820932626724, 0.004956250078976154, -0.010807658545672894, -0.027779940515756607, 0.008126313798129559, 0.032870132476091385, -0.014404118061065674, 0.03893111273646355, -0.0030600829049944878, 0.021824950352311134, -0.02445101924240589, -0.044607315212488174, 0.050614260137081146, -0.031072137877345085, 0.0031174535397440195, -0.04984241724014282, -0.018100064247846603, 0.00040213443571701646, 0.07120588421821594, 0.029688294976949692, 0.025693446397781372, 0.00798632763326168, 0.06061450019478798, 0.00894923321902752, -0.021761054173111916, -0.020675892010331154, 0.024288319051265717, -0.024222305044531822, 0.002103818580508232, -0.01455934252589941, 0.06730801612138748, 0.028705181553959846, -0.009608258493244648, -0.034172993153333664, 0.0015461159637197852, 0.011680608615279198, 0.014086193405091763, 0.01251538097858429, -0.06909125298261642, 0.011659218929708004, 0.02122022584080696, -0.001972523285076022, -0.02959810197353363, -0.021243155002593994, -0.023712987080216408, -0.037791892886161804, 0.019219709560275078, 0.005790031515061855, -0.00638178177177906, -0.003962561953812838, -0.04428739473223686, 0.03130700811743736, -0.03471517935395241, -0.007279504556208849, -0.016890471801161766, -0.005370470695197582, 0.007913959212601185, -0.0061935619451105595, -0.004200942348688841, 0.003236419055610895, 0.03124474547803402, 0.04926862195134163, 0.050207000225782394, 0.002829227363690734, -0.007076782174408436, 0.007981611415743828, -0.007716057822108269, -0.0114378547295928, 0.031634371727705, -0.04863477125763893, -0.013651321642100811, 0.06951320171356201, -0.03727689012885094, -0.018125304952263832, 0.025699330493807793, 0.005491520743817091, 0.017736079171299934, -0.015953684225678444, -0.00846890453249216, -0.004928719252347946, 0.019081249833106995, -0.018492402508854866, -0.014399285428225994, -0.02577059529721737, 0.0034647646825760603, 0.007053835783153772, 0.007225619629025459, 0.010072935372591019, 0.002857479965314269, -0.01877960003912449, 0.05251992493867874, 0.013394066132605076, 0.012128563597798347, 0.005844480823725462, 0.012452509254217148, 0.01840897463262081, 0.011571784503757954, 0.0016078987391665578, 0.02252630516886711, 0.03194088116288185, 0.014232724905014038, -0.05202320218086243, 0.03279776871204376, -0.05879903584718704, -0.03365487977862358, -0.08259125798940659, 0.0001694861421128735, 0.029454315081238747, -0.0026303136255592108, 0.04222759231925011, -0.050879329442977905, -0.020580023527145386, 0.02703278511762619, -0.024922451004385948, 0.010095476172864437, 0.0032033296301960945, -0.032923877239227295, -0.03214108943939209, 0.005785499699413776, -0.019498707726597786, 0.02980116195976734, 0.010615621693432331, 0.043833836913108826, 0.006907800678163767, 0.025532573461532593, 0.031893450766801834, 0.021064192056655884, 0.024704325944185257, 0.03864852711558342, 0.0054416474886238575, -0.07224667072296143, 0.024922458454966545, -0.017458204180002213, -0.022187476977705956, 0.042935218662023544, 0.01023622415959835, 0.04175439476966858, 0.018903767690062523, 0.008347440510988235, 0.0018273219466209412, 0.04818754270672798, 0.0508926697075367, 0.016814256086945534, -0.036212023347616196, -0.011314415372908115, 0.03205496072769165, 0.03435353562235832, -0.010333179496228695, 0.008730662055313587, 0.03357787802815437, -0.04034338518977165, -0.019169144332408905, 0.027691958472132683, -0.04521258547902107, -0.01924847811460495, -0.020505934953689575, 0.007001733873039484, -0.018013102933764458, 0.00586683489382267, 0.04337485879659653, -0.03771045804023743, -0.009354512207210064, 0.06576840579509735, 0.008821939118206501, -0.019574342295527458, 0.014525530859827995, -0.022660547867417336, -0.0504060722887516, 0.019119106233119965, 0.011933251284062862, 0.003919410984963179, -0.04653700441122055, -0.013690882362425327, -0.00642293319106102, 0.027999695390462875, -0.024650132283568382, -0.04131237044930458, -0.04523161053657532, 0.04814477637410164, -0.031499918550252914, 0.035772424191236496, 0.027353206649422646, 0.011995967477560043, -0.03256377577781677, -0.09378285706043243, 0.07159481197595596, 0.021700778976082802, -0.014467118307948112, -0.04354274645447731, 0.023724757134914398, -0.042480915784835815, -0.008077706210315228, 0.03443937003612518, 0.03143893554806709, 0.03273135796189308, -0.03642436861991882, -0.009182404726743698, 0.01181873306632042, -0.06042119860649109, 0.015103230252861977, -0.01639622263610363, -0.004053275566548109, -0.012632057070732117, -0.021479148417711258, 0.013477870263159275, 0.025247592478990555, 0.008966655470430851, -0.04134926572442055, 0.025433307513594627, 0.0020378981716930866, 0.010481269098818302, 0.055003754794597626, 0.006778416223824024, -0.03949451446533203, 0.04038355499505997, -0.012495992705225945, 0.012327631935477257, 0.033430930227041245, 0.01771581545472145, -0.05468316376209259, 0.01161095779389143, -0.024857323616743088, -0.04472286254167557, -0.007418525870889425, -0.002191412029787898, -0.003973817452788353, -0.0710340365767479, 0.021527739241719246, 0.00905506033450365, -0.07757937908172607, 0.01490303035825491, 0.045344650745391846, 0.006153035908937454, -0.0049513475969433784, -0.030686918646097183, 0.005818286444991827, 0.023412145674228668, -0.04864775016903877, 0.012706807814538479, -0.004674473777413368, -0.014859518967568874, -0.02664678916335106, -0.007296738214790821, 0.05037445202469826, -0.011118213646113873, 0.05296548455953598, 0.02022801712155342, 0.03194199129939079, -0.015467305667698383, -0.01718643121421337, 0.018838079646229744, -0.0043820287100970745, 0.05283893272280693, -0.015940237790346146, -0.0015129055827856064, 0.0035510403104126453, -0.005110789556056261, -0.020717255771160126, -0.02408534102141857, -0.0475371778011322, -0.040195710957050323, -0.004201791249215603, 0.0006576101877726614, -0.017015129327774048, 0.006156477145850658, 0.003911527339369059, -0.013823430985212326, 0.012204603292047977, 0.028377698734402657, -0.05297934636473656, 0.01495917234569788, -0.00900324061512947, 0.006989813409745693, 0.024770032614469528, -0.01650124415755272, -0.02497101202607155, -0.008349831216037273, -0.015013118274509907, 0.029257791116833687, -0.009445445612072945, -0.00819476880133152, -0.009138239547610283, -0.012868410907685757, 0.04082655534148216, -0.04868869483470917, -0.000569861033000052, -0.041806865483522415, -0.016625672578811646, 0.004705931060016155, -0.03759172931313515 ]
<p>Part of my thesis tries to investigate the extent to which students "test Score" on the topic of electrical circuits in physic can be predicted from how they find the topic to be "interesting" ,Their "enjoyment" of the topic, and their perception of how "difficult" the topic is. I intend to use linear multiple regression analysis to do this, where "test Score" will be my independent variable and the predictors will be the "Student's enjoyment", "Students perception of difficulty" and how "interesting" student find the topic. I think student's test score is a continues variable. However the suspected predictors were obtained thus: </p> <p>1. Working with electric circuits in physics is not interesting</p> <p>Strongly Agree[ ] Agree[ ] Undecided[ ] Disagree[ ] Strongly Disagree[ ]</p> <p>2. Working with electric circuits in physics is not difficult</p> <p>Strongly Agree[ ] Agree[ ] Undecided[ ] Disagree[ ] Strongly Disagree[ ]</p> <p>3. I do not enjoy practical work involving electrical circuits in physics</p> <p>Strongly Agree[ ] Agree[ ] Undecided[ ] Disagree[ ] Strongly Disagree[ ]</p> <p>the options are given these values:</p> <pre><code>Strongly Agree ---- 1 Agree ------------- 2 Undecided --------- 3 Disagree ---------- 4 Strongly Disagree - 5 </code></pre> <p>Now since this is an ordinal scale, is it proper to use linear multiple regression analysis ?</p>
73,532
[ -0.03250480070710182, -0.023101679980754852, -0.011289091780781746, 0.015548947267234325, 0.012074713595211506, 0.03532843291759491, 0.029851382598280907, -0.004651382099837065, 0.011130603030323982, -0.018895668908953667, 0.02310711145401001, 0.00398581987246871, 0.07061263173818588, -0.003912115469574928, 0.02198028936982155, 0.020526671782135963, 0.016446033492684364, 0.02040829136967659, 0.021670546382665634, 0.011468479409813881, -0.0297920573502779, 0.016699936240911484, -0.006228151265531778, -0.030697640031576157, -0.012131749652326107, 0.0470275804400444, 0.027755215764045715, -0.007802728563547134, 0.00666934996843338, -0.0010724120074883103, -0.0029541016556322575, -0.026821758598089218, 0.031165719032287598, 0.002599503844976425, 0.030256494879722595, 0.02066132053732872, -0.015226427465677261, 0.005277556832879782, -0.029785118997097015, 0.03221257030963898, -0.004841858055442572, -0.008374831639230251, -0.01983434334397316, 0.03422236442565918, 0.009825027547776699, 0.022246886044740677, -0.015072151087224483, -0.012217256240546703, 0.02818146161735058, -0.005899617914110422, 0.06659293174743652, -0.0008120218408294022, 0.019684648141264915, 0.014278560876846313, -0.02524528279900551, -0.013519007712602615, 0.040522437542676926, 0.07095569372177124, -0.0017294838326051831, -0.07197951525449753, -0.008520961739122868, 0.010822795331478119, 0.008073120377957821, 0.010324567556381226, -0.03786284849047661, 0.030928099527955055, 0.01100429892539978, 0.008741311728954315, 0.04341679811477661, -0.022647108882665634, -0.0007873785798437893, 0.012301848269999027, 0.06913463026285172, -0.04283460974693298, -0.014385553076863289, -0.029335075989365578, -0.01493606623262167, 0.024492371827363968, 0.028105847537517548, 0.0367995984852314, -0.013245909474790096, 0.023861555382609367, 0.01683521643280983, 0.021521836519241333, 0.0501180924475193, -0.02406960539519787, 0.02935958467423916, -0.028786003589630127, 0.035679951310157776, 0.058525800704956055, -0.01557435467839241, -0.022610165178775787, 0.035475071519613266, 0.037251003086566925, -0.020748406648635864, -0.0018738710787147284, 0.0025800997391343117, 0.04134223237633705, 0.07152585685253143, -0.019185759127140045, -0.0037498706951737404, -0.03674900531768799, -0.0002234454732388258, 0.03673486411571503, -0.030007433146238327, -0.06727037578821182, -0.027503356337547302, -0.011705984361469746, 0.014895281754434109, -0.06053761765360832, 0.009833404794335365, 0.050949543714523315, 0.033616211265325546, 0.0057291071861982346, 0.02148323878645897, -0.029050374403595924, -0.009646464139223099, 0.0114713404327631, 0.05063039809465408, 0.057566896080970764, -0.012168004177510738, -0.030448613688349724, 0.059388548135757446, 0.0009680708171799779, -0.04646331071853638, 0.008826343342661858, 0.021037932485342026, -0.008037322200834751, -0.027889462187886238, 0.05874405428767204, -0.03170463442802429, 0.06712312251329422, 0.022742576897144318, 0.023446032777428627, 0.010269805788993835, 0.024142848327755928, -0.07167655229568481, -0.06122054532170296, 0.033211760222911835, -0.013588017784059048, 0.00442403694614768, -0.04728062078356743, -0.017421720549464226, 0.01671518385410309, 0.06945058703422546, 0.03781701996922493, 0.021938424557447433, 0.04496100917458534, -0.0004279714485164732, 0.018926328048110008, -0.03225867822766304, 0.01167027372866869, -0.028767086565494537, -0.03058399260044098, -0.00801587849855423, -0.0977117195725441, -0.0004945265245623887, 0.008244936354458332, 0.017802096903324127, 0.017464015632867813, 0.025712836533784866, -0.008176466450095177, 0.013473549857735634, -0.01192095223814249, -0.0036894537042826414, 0.011739494279026985, 0.08816304057836533, -0.032292142510414124, 0.04101033881306648, 0.013544776476919651, 0.03302958235144615, 0.0056042904034256935, -0.012241902761161327, 0.014221906661987305, 0.07714208960533142, 0.029112646356225014, 0.0015871499199420214, -0.02370818331837654, 0.03522705286741257, -0.0016869351966306567, -0.05474530905485153, -0.06919573247432709, -0.03769906982779503, -0.024685639888048172, -0.025107543915510178, 0.059567078948020935, 0.0023725745268166065, -0.021525394171476364, -0.01462153997272253, -0.027299664914608, -0.0731198638677597, -0.0635819360613823, 0.02820483408868313, -0.028508072718977928, -0.02802523411810398, 0.05687757954001427, -0.031822238117456436, -0.017915213480591774, -0.006046983879059553, -0.015834735706448555, -0.01837947405874729, -0.029660405591130257, 0.05614849552512169, -0.018267760053277016, 0.009773645550012589, 0.01986669935286045, 0.03905685991048813, -0.009367411956191063, 0.03651320934295654, -0.027939097955822945, -0.021210510283708572, 0.0184656772762537, -0.017568429931998253, 0.016163570806384087, 0.0079991165548563, -0.01749611459672451, 0.001959569752216339, 0.0038548975717276335, -0.037437181919813156, 0.019382009282708168, -0.04673813283443451, 0.0858699232339859, 0.058379266411066055, 0.003175680059939623, -0.012207216583192348, 0.006001782137900591, -0.021495774388313293, 0.02707754075527191, -0.004512195475399494, -0.029372120276093483, -0.06598818302154541, 0.0024728630669414997, 0.002546092960983515, 0.051055651158094406, -0.047183115035295486, 0.05375039577484131, 0.06691397726535797, 0.019116636365652084, 0.00755780003964901, 0.030474860221147537, -0.01729048416018486, -0.028536736965179443, 0.024478096514940262, 0.016287125647068024, 0.016646647825837135, 0.01923525705933571, -0.011067528277635574, 0.04723744094371796, 0.03889697417616844, 0.019033469259738922, 0.03708935156464577, 0.0672219768166542, 0.00658825971186161, -0.0024835746735334396, -0.004434152506291866, -0.007531073875725269, 0.024667492136359215, -0.01205508317798376, 0.035098399966955185, 0.06515107303857803, 0.021030250936746597, -0.0013545386027544737, 0.013143902644515038, -0.003034216118976474, -0.016859373077750206, 0.02039303444325924, -0.04419964551925659, 0.032581936568021774, 0.008111863397061825, -0.0470462441444397, 0.0025418363511562347, -0.04167693108320236, -0.010634126141667366, -0.01717371679842472, 0.002469566883519292, 0.03705085813999176, 0.010749490931630135, 0.008849036879837513, -0.015137001872062683, -0.007106507197022438, 0.01211750041693449, -0.02844366803765297, -0.013769148848950863, -0.0008917694794945419, -0.039675887674093246, -0.025835631415247917, -0.03714112192392349, -0.00942380540072918, 0.04318734630942345, -0.010737082920968533, -0.014673340134322643, 0.056310106068849564, -0.001956883119419217, -0.07959891110658646, -0.032226212322711945, -0.022229837253689766, 0.012954046949744225, 0.00008323758083861321, -0.032045669853687286, 0.03418717905879021, 0.00990272406488657, -0.01877732388675213, 0.012147878296673298, -0.030631568282842636, -0.003367896191775799, 0.002434076741337776, -0.012829728424549103, -0.006821243092417717, 0.03360247611999512, 0.0177286546677351, 0.030008617788553238, 0.013589111156761646, -0.031231224536895752, -0.08866383135318756, -0.055819280445575714, 0.015145165845751762, 0.006083271931856871, 0.027333632111549377, 0.015179970301687717, -0.02400689385831356, 0.07532531768083572, 0.018662432208657265, -0.03367861732840538, -0.04736455902457237, -0.0037720492109656334, -0.0246110949665308, 0.0070550465025007725, 0.0009629478445276618, 0.029999904334545135, 0.017053142189979553, -0.00021995646238792688, -0.0007852077833376825, 0.014690901152789593, 0.03038695454597473, -0.008327145129442215, 0.019794268533587456, 0.02514941245317459, -0.022339627146720886, -0.04837552085518837, 0.027891749516129494, 0.029534725472331047, -0.02025904506444931, 0.031548917293548584, -0.006719154305756092, -0.01385533157736063, 0.006028024014085531, -0.04110083729028702, -0.0007891121786087751, -0.005472840275615454, -0.0015184208750724792, -0.033482011407613754, 0.012903725728392601, -0.00342279183678329, -0.028722042217850685, -0.006385045126080513, 0.01805676333606243, 0.0345747284591198, -0.018555577844381332, -0.004372832830995321, 0.05972599983215332, 0.04800879582762718, -0.01579260267317295, 0.008436636999249458, -0.015400035306811333, 0.014830381609499454, -0.009138084948062897, -0.05015155300498009, -0.006214240565896034, 0.02936304546892643, 0.027905911207199097, 0.02682477980852127, 0.03388587757945061, -0.018065927550196648, 0.020354855805635452, -0.05846739932894707, -0.013861916027963161, -0.04241422563791275, 0.055660128593444824, 0.00897003710269928, 0.03439774736762047, 0.007997652515769005, -0.009777331724762917, 0.022949811071157455, -0.007144309114664793, -0.057050179690122604, 0.05334959179162979, -0.018082989379763603, -0.004000421613454819, 0.021115247160196304, 0.0052218507044017315, 0.005892579909414053, -0.016065873205661774, 0.01963227242231369, 0.006195413880050182, 0.028185969218611717, -0.02941557951271534, 0.013384073972702026, -0.023170743137598038, -0.009095747023820877, -0.005724562797695398, 0.021065354347229004, 0.04325971379876137, -0.052768293768167496, 0.04682210460305214, 0.00625613471493125, -0.03767570108175278, -0.019902551546692848, -0.008798393420875072, -0.0024868117179721594, 0.016649015247821808, 0.04873942211270332, -0.00604117289185524, 0.01340451743453741, -0.024669092148542404, 0.03838009759783745, 0.027962487190961838, 0.05188307538628578, 0.03030419535934925, -0.010028528980910778, -0.04611913859844208, 0.0025395133998245, -0.0023344182409346104, -0.0067776646465063095, 0.02171124331653118, 0.027171501889824867, -0.008800506591796875, 0.03385826572775841, 0.05186231806874275, -0.064149409532547, 0.03592327609658241, 0.060617461800575256, 0.001126557937823236, 0.014234540052711964, -0.017787529155611992, -0.0033507472835481167, 0.018302978947758675, -0.0017800601199269295, 0.051420655101537704, 0.023417504504323006, -0.038142286241054535, -0.005548691842705011, 0.03687049075961113, 0.013033309951424599, -0.06892959028482437, 0.023183301091194153, -0.04756571352481842, 0.05779426917433739, 0.00958903320133686, -0.052302248775959015, -0.015730833634734154, 0.06672172248363495, 0.043375350534915924, -0.023612823337316513, -0.012778624892234802, -0.11024877429008484, 0.03557353466749191, 0.018402814865112305, 0.07905769348144531, -0.051678650081157684, -0.002880481304600835, -0.012937896884977818, 0.016170119866728783, 0.023507528007030487, -0.03540860861539841, 0.030968984588980675, 0.005632481072098017, 0.035052936524152756, -0.0719267800450325, -0.044402968138456345, -0.08305922895669937, -0.005049908999353647, -0.03234199434518814, 0.0329611711204052, -0.02456270344555378, -0.058380044996738434, -0.03797614946961403, -0.009910128079354763, 0.03880272060632706, 0.039250247180461884, -0.020786840468645096, -0.0408058688044548, -0.0069355433806777, -0.01638001762330532, -0.04270166531205177, -0.0506715252995491, 0.017833977937698364, 0.018824443221092224, -0.0126443887129426, 0.07297366112470627, -0.021592527627944946, -0.014347721822559834, 0.012226955033838749, 0.03580494225025177, -0.0005923142889514565, 0.01878814585506916, -0.00010249968181597069, 0.049976468086242676, 0.008004034869372845, 0.0037180157378315926, 0.024356411769986153, 0.021277904510498047, 0.0018593015847727656, 0.004134335555136204, -0.02576594054698944, -0.030702082440257072, -0.03185829520225525, -0.016406293958425522, -0.007409609854221344, -0.017900504171848297, -0.032034073024988174, 0.029915278777480125, -0.008071175776422024, 0.0009188920957967639, -0.029477952048182487, 0.001280417200177908, -0.00040375819662585855, 0.02203298546373844, -0.010869658552110195, -0.028344592079520226, -0.00989228580147028, -0.0023867269046604633, -0.02185809426009655, -0.016895689070224762, -0.006840934045612812, -0.02885192446410656, 0.03998148813843727, 0.05373544991016388, -0.039300065487623215, -0.018642932176589966, -0.028135504573583603, -0.03786465898156166, -0.0077382661402225494, -0.024932818487286568, 0.016526542603969574, -0.022762103006243706, 0.020923174917697906, 0.013329068198800087, -0.02652928978204727, -0.029284199699759483, 0.04528399556875229, 0.009620382450520992, 0.014401381835341454, -0.009618425741791725, 0.04837141931056976, -0.022428765892982483, -0.00706320209428668, -0.05101662501692772, -0.07103288918733597, 0.014626597054302692, 0.031522247940301895, -0.022938471287488937, 0.007373584900051355, -0.037181321531534195, -0.023720020428299904, -0.009303495287895203, -0.010536705143749714, 0.027522999793291092, -0.03394550085067749, -0.0011003273539245129, -0.015541120432317257, 0.0019469341496005654, 0.08657586574554443, 0.006490910891443491, 0.01158834807574749, 0.00712313037365675, 0.009863970801234245, 0.037175364792346954, -0.004730378743261099, 0.0007942900410853326, -0.04566366970539093, -0.021376337856054306, -0.021123357117176056, 0.03054727613925934, 0.06739456951618195, 0.014251278713345528, -0.003868103725835681, -0.0012732051545754075, -0.01125654298812151, 0.012895871885120869, -0.009729928337037563, -0.013464421965181828, -0.029195647686719894, -0.015346701256930828, 0.017366774380207062, -0.02450840175151825, -0.04112778976559639, 0.010817889124155045, 0.029356112703680992, 0.026800669729709625, -0.033178407698869705, 0.008317778818309307, 0.0740426629781723, 0.04504790157079697, 0.008102433755993843, 0.021010469645261765, -0.03177827596664429, 0.012062295340001583, -0.012931355275213718, 0.02028246596455574, -0.012198090553283691, 0.0353778600692749, -0.011842367239296436, -0.06343960016965866, -0.025722874328494072, -0.029768195003271103, 0.06657085567712784, 0.004117288626730442, 0.03810715675354004, 0.1119326651096344, -0.0397593192756176, -0.01905040815472603, -0.03158828243613243, -0.01055906992405653, -0.0211471039801836, 0.030157553032040596, 0.03285665810108185, -0.013063319958746433, -0.01327565312385559, 0.0017430416774004698, -0.00831408891826868, 0.007551194634288549, 0.0166343841701746, 0.037021711468696594, 0.016845086589455605, 0.012200513854622841, -0.013582834973931313, -0.038057077676057816, 0.009263450279831886, -0.04943635314702988, 0.030986085534095764, -0.04621775448322296, -0.03529662266373634, -0.009729677811264992, 0.05208534747362137, -0.009236241690814495, -0.069330133497715, -0.02671993523836136, -0.044568970799446106, 0.01139797456562519, 0.0006629530689679086, -0.0017440906958654523, 0.03548998758196831, 0.012629890814423561, 0.04340042173862457, 0.015594390220940113, 0.011821355670690536, -0.05658142641186714, -0.07941225171089172, -0.0203088391572237, -0.0014775232411921024, -0.025105006992816925, 0.061067961156368256, -0.011632058769464493, -0.029002519324421883, 0.026458673179149628, -0.011126524768769741, 0.008654504083096981, -0.0002591460070107132, 0.033412665128707886, -0.026253432035446167, 0.045259028673172, -0.021583283320069313, -0.03344840183854103, -0.000717127462849021, -0.008761142380535603, 0.13486720621585846, 0.08642755448818207, 0.04673386737704277, -0.037895895540714264, 0.06634629517793655, 0.0069236247800290585, 0.0017871524905785918, -0.020556939765810966, -0.026577455922961235, 0.010722546838223934, -0.017375260591506958, 0.027805034071207047, 0.028516730293631554, 0.02559725195169449, 0.024866318330168724, 0.05053790286183357, -0.03194041922688484, -0.018436474725604057, 0.0048224045895040035, -0.01597907394170761, 0.016309088096022606, 0.016102323308587074, -0.03284472972154617, -0.0033074715174734592, -0.0023520118556916714, 0.011433548294007778, 0.029197275638580322, -0.04027561470866203, 0.04427012428641319, -0.0005454701604321599, -0.001734586781822145, 0.02513788640499115, 0.0015600521583110094, 0.04591454938054085, -0.04900394752621651, 0.010311807505786419, 0.04455382376909256, -0.032089874148368835, 0.02347019501030445, 0.03283620998263359, -0.01149672083556652, -0.033543918281793594, 0.009027346968650818, 0.04504118859767914, -0.046640124171972275, -0.00907948799431324, -0.05012135952711105, 0.03497852385044098, 0.03042195923626423, -0.036489058285951614, 0.018636289983987808, 0.009245073422789574, 0.01367390900850296, -0.023106146603822708, -0.017095200717449188, 0.01919282227754593, 0.03288144990801811, -0.022587351500988007, 0.010068975389003754, 0.0055526974610984325, -0.03524498641490936, -0.009249469265341759, -0.012788264080882072, 0.03579140082001686, -0.016088344156742096, -0.0056317467242479324, 0.002516798209398985, 0.024704452604055405, 0.008406777866184711, 0.021056195721030235, -0.017199231311678886, -0.0020402264781296253, -0.03374737873673439, 0.009856064803898335, 0.0015002164291217923, 0.005547731649130583, 0.005733552388846874, 0.0026790136471390724, -0.016074974089860916, -0.06839784234762192, -0.007118110544979572, 0.02635825052857399, -0.031051291152834892, -0.023467116057872772, -0.052238523960113525, 0.020863471552729607, 0.01491476409137249, 0.04728219285607338, 0.025417670607566833, 0.0009814465884119272, 0.036238353699445724, 0.033514004200696945, -0.005721262190490961, -0.04552489519119263, -0.00400004955008626, -0.03656923398375511, -0.023392777889966965, 0.008193952962756157, -0.008618897758424282, 0.0568978451192379, -0.004391707479953766, -0.0194857195019722, 0.0044782268814742565, 0.012880006805062294, -0.009466757997870445, 0.01540769636631012, 0.0739007443189621, -0.048916418105363846, -0.026982560753822327, 0.02466495707631111, -0.009328017942607403, -0.02804587222635746, 0.004618652630597353, -0.03314226493239403, -0.05011533573269844, 0.003532998962327838, -0.013163028284907341, -0.043500714004039764, 0.03350529074668884, -0.014290834777057171, 0.041792646050453186, -0.058607567101716995, -0.0018815501825883985, -0.025058720260858536, -0.006055851932615042, 0.009080402553081512, -0.00314698345027864, -0.008511457592248917, -0.000808602839242667, -0.0288233682513237, 0.013691824860870838, 0.027669541537761688, 0.013158546760678291, 0.010659120976924896, -0.029086051508784294, 0.01878252997994423, -0.027263889089226723, 0.031187303364276886, -0.029128143563866615, -0.03870373219251633, 0.021886924281716347, -0.07125501334667206, -0.024280695244669914, 0.023704173043370247, -0.019962219521403313, 0.023876063525676727, 0.02461869828402996, 0.0066305361688137054, 0.00870264507830143, 0.0163407139480114, -0.019541777670383453, -0.031598638743162155, -0.03650093078613281, -0.00887087732553482, 0.004743834491819143, -0.02570909634232521, -0.015353002585470676, 0.0027654916048049927, -0.021015020087361336, 0.01880425028502941, 0.07287959009408951, 0.03218530863523483, -0.01979968138039112, -0.006993906106799841, -0.015051906928420067, 0.00660839444026351, 0.008344481699168682, -0.010156012140214443, 0.008926560170948505, 0.04735340550541878, -0.08119948953390121, 0.028483767062425613, -0.009031175635755062, 0.02459900826215744, -0.08406037837266922, -0.04438318684697151, 0.0030199713073670864, -0.009487963281571865, 0.033980559557676315, -0.054527126252651215, -0.016674062237143517, 0.022136259824037552, -0.04276062548160553, -0.00005632035026792437, -0.04160168021917343, -0.018122335895895958, -0.0020350879058241844, -0.008063208311796188, -0.04222739115357399, 0.007852811366319656, 0.03170290216803551, 0.02599145844578743, 0.04728570580482483, 0.01029905304312706, 0.0313284732401371, -0.010514105670154095, -0.009443138726055622, -0.012029387056827545, 0.0011076234513893723, -0.10161452740430832, 0.04462895169854164, -0.03994147479534149, -0.030152631923556328, 0.03900891914963722, -0.03340534865856171, 0.019836733117699623, 0.029930444434285164, 0.010298437438905239, 0.010914923623204231, 0.051853567361831665, 0.03170411288738251, -0.016984330490231514, -0.04359648376703262, -0.005702748894691467, -0.0033298227936029434, 0.010589037090539932, 0.03325174003839493, 0.03480630740523338, 0.03719799593091011, -0.017702218145132065, -0.01157900970429182, -0.0030511280056089163, -0.010078190825879574, -0.01989353820681572, -0.008157791569828987, 0.015117148868739605, -0.014368096366524696, -0.06714757531881332, -0.0017980756238102913, -0.07111041247844696, -0.007759999018162489, 0.019557027146220207, 0.038370467722415924, -0.00831225048750639, 0.00004074265598319471, 0.016036655753850937, -0.03809664398431778, -0.01416250690817833, -0.041108060628175735, -0.002541562542319298, -0.0418696291744709, 0.03798794746398926, -0.0008871295140124857, -0.027424950152635574, -0.027073251083493233, -0.025002555921673775, 0.006005983334034681, 0.04712456837296486, -0.04318047687411308, -0.01987999491393566, -0.0016832061810418963, -0.04787736386060715, 0.042327914386987686, -0.03818994015455246, 0.040193378925323486, -0.013192164711654186, -0.021943606436252594, -0.0345703586935997, 0.010182793252170086, -0.03628658130764961, 0.012221870943903923, 0.03884132578969002, -0.004922330379486084, -0.003126583993434906, 0.012838844209909439, -0.0027267583645880222, 0.008904388174414635, -0.005208152346313, 0.007766729686409235, -0.005289633758366108, -0.0012527970829978585, -0.019805293530225754, 0.017655083909630775, 0.007911724038422108, -0.02346775308251381, 0.042469751089811325, -0.003350889077410102, -0.00022437259030994028, 0.0017200576839968562, -0.006278913002461195, -0.007652614265680313, -0.01974356546998024, -0.006386287044733763, 0.05792824923992157, 0.006306573748588562, 0.021470049396157265, 0.037916041910648346, 0.007305948529392481, -0.03524896875023842, 0.032259006053209305, -0.013174155727028847, -0.025395860895514488, -0.005989912431687117, 0.005526998545974493, -0.0030494339298456907, -0.07067438960075378, -0.010917813517153263, 0.018118049949407578, -0.030116667971014977, -0.031430356204509735, 0.019106898456811905, 0.02564527653157711, 0.029983099550008774, -0.005440243985503912, 0.03437385708093643, -0.016442039981484413, -0.04105435684323311, 0.007606660481542349, 0.03180651366710663, 0.04979897290468216, 0.03483410179615021, 0.0115879587829113, 0.033926088362932205, -0.016150740906596184, 0.02851511724293232, 0.02624286152422428, 0.017144570127129555, -0.020477766171097755, -0.02094820700585842, 0.021482093259692192, -0.00004898302722722292, 0.03170602396130562, 0.013358330354094505, -0.014702033251523972, 0.00988975539803505, -0.05796618014574051, -0.010105103254318237, -0.03947976604104042, -0.04954849183559418, -0.023140734061598778, 0.012563095428049564, 0.011844256892800331, 0.051113758236169815, 0.03589245304465294, 0.03054133616387844, -0.021816251799464226, -0.019477056339383125, 0.04035767540335655, -0.009565870277583599, 0.012004450894892216, -0.019853003323078156, -0.020494043827056885, 0.012313061393797398, -0.00024333516194019467, 0.006458078045397997, -0.011840090155601501, 0.03349112346768379, 0.019276199862360954, 0.026676297187805176, -0.06111651659011841, -0.012571290135383606, -0.01915816031396389, 0.021304547786712646, -0.016587156802415848, -0.04981417581439018, -0.022479474544525146, 0.036541733890771866, 0.04926704242825508, -0.002107245149090886 ]
<blockquote> <p><strong>Possible Duplicate:</strong><br> <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/30275/giving-more-details-to-my-last-post-im-very-lost-and-dont-know-which-tests-to">Giving more details to my last post: I&#39;m very lost and don&#39;t know which tests to use or how to enter data in SPSS</a> </p> </blockquote> <p>I conducted an experiment using a within subjects design and 2x2 categorical fixed factors design with a categorical DV (every subject was in every condition). I have no idea what test to use. </p> <p>Thanks for your help, Emily</p>
49,329
[ -0.03648675978183746, -0.042352307587862015, 0.011473891325294971, 0.04081948101520538, 0.04963722079992294, -0.01236118096858263, -0.0020124735310673714, -0.034235093742609024, 0.03294328227639198, -0.01154392771422863, 0.05386612191796303, 0.03430710732936859, 0.023409638553857803, 0.040979329496622086, 0.0020773939322680235, 0.036477312445640564, -0.03283481299877167, -0.007199424784630537, -0.0017377136973664165, 0.046453457325696945, -0.012468068860471249, 0.02282201685011387, -0.0072923810221254826, -0.006236033979803324, -0.01811929978430271, 0.040597230195999146, 0.03702070936560631, -0.05550182983279228, 0.013941548764705658, 0.03774140402674675, -0.03008781373500824, -0.015912426635622978, -0.002446310129016638, 0.004299914464354515, 0.011824854649603367, 0.004631378222256899, -0.0008968891925178468, -0.006674638949334621, -0.009644507430493832, 0.02444278635084629, -0.009644581004977226, 0.02867201715707779, -0.009357438422739506, 0.03945391625165939, 0.00864124484360218, 0.014241987839341164, 0.00004118753713555634, 0.017260370776057243, -0.021378502249717712, -0.04051588848233223, 0.0711836889386177, -0.03014713153243065, 0.049684491008520126, 0.045264411717653275, -0.0019436017610132694, -0.009001802653074265, 0.020951682701706886, 0.06061180680990219, -0.004227439407259226, -0.05414212495088577, -0.01828901842236519, -0.04048668593168259, 0.011695187538862228, -0.020609606057405472, -0.06658588349819183, 0.019234664738178253, 0.01871129497885704, -0.0034756609238684177, 0.05084270238876343, -0.008913757279515266, 0.05405272915959358, 0.0241107027977705, 0.0289443489164114, 0.013395965099334717, 0.021912626922130585, -0.031090781092643738, 0.02675752528011799, 0.03948605805635452, 0.04986198991537094, 0.055736273527145386, -0.009460893459618092, 0.03569720685482025, 0.006306373048573732, 0.03558303415775299, 0.0034674773924052715, -0.05123418942093849, 0.09609457105398178, -0.021930014714598656, -0.021996717900037766, 0.019336581230163574, -0.029625097289681435, -0.004179699346423149, 0.02388673461973667, 0.03540121018886566, -0.04966671019792557, -0.009161227382719517, -0.04101751744747162, 0.025369908660650253, -0.011319913901388645, -0.0011377306655049324, 0.0077378717251122, -0.029105812311172485, 0.0372798778116703, 0.0602024607360363, -0.008838045410811901, 0.029645012691617012, -0.011064805090427399, -0.011072495020925999, -0.04033718630671501, -0.029218897223472595, -0.005299177020788193, 0.04098740592598915, -0.00766282994300127, -0.02913409285247326, 0.00109209178481251, -0.03949979692697525, -0.038664788007736206, -0.023735569790005684, 0.05310475081205368, 0.05357973277568817, 0.05437411740422249, -0.04343421012163162, 0.028138164430856705, -0.024047767743468285, -0.03697332367300987, -0.011157368309795856, 0.02130870707333088, 0.01036601047962904, -0.024247970432043076, 0.06155819445848465, 0.0006950626848265529, -0.002820739056915045, -0.0005584239261224866, 0.016957854852080345, -0.004327625501900911, 0.01861458830535412, -0.1013091430068016, -0.0831039771437645, 0.042980194091796875, 0.023579420521855354, -0.019293425604701042, -0.08275646716356277, -0.016320647671818733, 0.005262214690446854, 0.008459734730422497, -0.014318970963358879, 0.041519202291965485, 0.006041158456355333, 0.024899760261178017, 0.036353856325149536, -0.04228133335709572, -0.00633568549528718, -0.06329730898141861, -0.0025093795266002417, -0.021811312064528465, -0.06559067964553833, 0.0014180914731696248, 0.017186321318149567, 0.005785488057881594, 0.016971345990896225, 0.027943560853600502, 0.02330276556313038, 0.014734438620507717, -0.00352810462936759, 0.0086934519931674, 0.0025010143872350454, 0.016242219135165215, -0.01892281509935856, 0.017589157447218895, 0.02275860868394375, -0.03178994730114937, -0.007082020398229361, 0.00819101370871067, 0.04507638141512871, 0.02790580503642559, -0.009588861837983131, -0.011795034632086754, -0.010911179706454277, 0.011408497579395771, 0.019521377980709076, -0.04512220248579979, -0.009600224904716015, -0.013229873031377792, -0.0272806566208601, 0.031326889991760254, 0.08758659660816193, -0.002792073180899024, -0.02625201642513275, 0.020218830555677414, -0.04296858608722687, -0.07871243357658386, -0.021594524383544922, 0.025966094806790352, -0.012625179253518581, -0.04880213364958763, -0.007958263158798218, -0.02438081055879593, 0.03789782524108887, -0.028583643957972527, -0.0052963560447096825, -0.014406147412955761, -0.008076310157775879, 0.03870520368218422, -0.0263319481164217, 0.018228257074952126, 0.045366544276475906, 0.043986622244119644, -0.05299175903201103, 0.0032582932617515326, -0.029142340645194054, -0.014982793480157852, 0.002236095257103443, -0.00941020529717207, 0.04705779254436493, -0.010428385809063911, -0.03162361681461334, 0.015223964117467403, 0.0684879943728447, -0.029697421938180923, 0.05025944858789444, -0.04773202911019325, 0.0687832236289978, 0.028378581628203392, 0.0019385390914976597, 0.02027127332985401, -0.0017879973165690899, 0.018151776865124702, -0.005321362055838108, -0.03332265466451645, -0.0024026327300816774, -0.021676428616046906, -0.013787595555186272, 0.0464913509786129, -0.040776126086711884, -0.04322462156414986, -0.0034908524248749018, 0.01772577129304409, -0.01222217082977295, -0.006989526562392712, 0.018772495910525322, -0.005343001335859299, -0.020220927894115448, 0.021196212619543076, 0.038683369755744934, -0.0032418991904705763, 0.0180105809122324, 0.017569730058312416, 0.012797278352081776, 0.047087859362363815, 0.010291538201272488, 0.02653690241277218, 0.06011129543185234, 0.020607564598321915, 0.013184009119868279, -0.012650716118514538, -0.005968539044260979, 0.06816339492797852, -0.0031205257400870323, 0.008918815292418003, 0.07221464067697525, 0.04690326377749443, -0.02795315533876419, 0.016958991065621376, 0.009474864229559898, 0.03578690439462662, 0.06984812021255493, -0.014845161698758602, 0.0056681279093027115, 0.022800397127866745, -0.017758039757609367, 0.036784812808036804, -0.009863637387752533, -0.02227441407740116, -0.03715033829212189, -0.015878716483712196, 0.04135141149163246, 0.025906028226017952, 0.01844773255288601, -0.07074481248855591, 0.0261733066290617, -0.009918018244206905, 0.0019909862894564867, 0.04160789027810097, 0.004275389481335878, -0.057347897440195084, -0.01566906087100506, -0.03712858632206917, 0.0049168141558766365, 0.03614956885576248, -0.012832652777433395, -0.04363222047686577, 0.03015151061117649, -0.0062838466838002205, -0.062172289937734604, -0.02780608832836151, -0.02113751694560051, 0.038830533623695374, -0.011362302117049694, -0.022982915863394737, 0.03610481694340706, 0.0026738042943179607, -0.02710994891822338, 0.018088996410369873, -0.03069351240992546, -0.00571924913674593, 0.0018017834518104792, 0.013316696509718895, 0.03216392919421196, -0.03528469800949097, 0.00009527476504445076, -0.011110878549516201, -0.004974170587956905, -0.004659858997911215, -0.07960961014032364, -0.09769517928361893, 0.000958580058068037, 0.025174375623464584, 0.022608419880270958, -0.022115925326943398, -0.018598061054944992, 0.06383297592401505, 0.006448626052588224, -0.00550867011770606, -0.06396526098251343, -0.032841287553310394, -0.034506622701883316, -0.04760386049747467, 0.027526624500751495, 0.009952867403626442, -0.010196961462497711, 0.01219799555838108, 0.01526237465441227, 0.040931299328804016, -0.0044005089439451694, 0.04593667387962341, -0.009677868336439133, 0.053577106446027756, 0.024461938068270683, -0.054921954870224, 0.030243847519159317, 0.03376445174217224, -0.013941621407866478, -0.01591094583272934, -0.0019432632252573967, 0.04174555838108063, -0.02246945910155773, -0.040018655359745026, 0.02922566421329975, -0.05389229208230972, -0.015162010677158833, -0.04022464156150818, 0.038916394114494324, 0.0010963757522404194, -0.03160274028778076, -0.007650361396372318, 0.019465619698166847, 0.018117913976311684, -0.010281036607921124, 0.01364333089441061, 0.07739178091287613, 0.05913720279932022, -0.03705200180411339, -0.019329458475112915, -0.0444030798971653, -0.01542384922504425, 0.047630492597818375, -0.008379196748137474, -0.0071403938345611095, 0.007230485789477825, 0.06563734263181686, 0.043837208300828934, -0.009919445030391216, -0.04438316076993942, 0.036658212542533875, -0.0871061310172081, 0.01072471123188734, -0.04644952341914177, 0.06371834874153137, -0.016072643920779228, 0.04887399449944496, 0.030510887503623962, 0.0028419147711247206, -0.005888867191970348, 0.003961681388318539, -0.07313383370637894, 0.038507264107465744, 0.01682019978761673, 0.015223036520183086, 0.05688655003905296, -0.0138301532715559, 0.033820029348134995, -0.018678082153201103, 0.0038509415462613106, 0.02192692458629608, 0.030481873080134392, -0.024362899363040924, 0.0038022962398827076, -0.00876592192798853, 0.002435716800391674, -0.002850668504834175, 0.031662214547395706, 0.004378642421215773, -0.02288173697888851, 0.03433921933174133, 0.017330296337604523, -0.013608901761472225, -0.018727172166109085, -0.006691363640129566, -0.03884588181972504, 0.019967319443821907, 0.03889830410480499, 0.018438594415783882, 0.007386357057839632, -0.012594548054039478, 0.022611672058701515, 0.019408291205763817, 0.017558764666318893, 0.019453413784503937, -0.036677610129117966, -0.005333520006388426, -0.0019717051181942225, 0.011429228819906712, -0.031260326504707336, 0.042840514332056046, -0.03252611681818962, -0.014371020719408989, 0.043276287615299225, 0.025453250855207443, -0.04307439923286438, 0.04430572688579559, 0.04640994966030121, 0.015087448060512543, -0.022454719990491867, -0.02190910093486309, -0.01938609592616558, -0.0468217171728611, -0.002900025574490428, 0.03039952740073204, 0.029200859367847443, 0.004731174558401108, -0.007186342962086201, 0.032359980046749115, -0.04492925480008125, -0.025948937982320786, 0.0044105034321546555, -0.046124618500471115, -0.00485339667648077, 0.04083023592829704, -0.04582322761416435, -0.003284165868535638, 0.028884517028927803, 0.04033955559134483, -0.0037810890935361385, 0.006715362425893545, -0.09086817502975464, 0.007807405199855566, 0.029942277818918228, 0.0689152255654335, -0.04936518892645836, 0.008574950508773327, -0.006654030177742243, -0.01758398488163948, 0.008124159649014473, -0.05404198169708252, 0.023994330316781998, -0.015311052091419697, 0.0036386395804584026, -0.020469985902309418, -0.03300199285149574, -0.05169560760259628, -0.007826474495232105, -0.002126467414200306, 0.025932552292943, 0.038838133215904236, -0.0024651025887578726, -0.0563037246465683, 0.016415460035204887, 0.03056083619594574, 0.04993802309036255, -0.05364687368273735, -0.01677682064473629, 0.018800195306539536, 0.009319343604147434, -0.06617312133312225, -0.04503180459141731, 0.009564266540110111, -0.0010176391806453466, -0.02240666188299656, 0.05521070957183838, -0.005717074498534203, -0.05658063665032387, 0.014053592458367348, 0.00454920157790184, 0.008050471544265747, 0.012165962718427181, -0.04142474755644798, 0.03935357928276062, 0.03046329692006111, 0.035612553358078, 0.05257495492696762, 0.0360078290104866, 0.0004666759050451219, 0.03321945667266846, -0.003951091319322586, 0.005084733013063669, -0.0086463438346982, -0.06080298498272896, -0.040253207087516785, -0.014821359887719154, -0.015590471215546131, 0.029200473800301552, -0.014314703643321991, 0.007733517326414585, -0.05207548663020134, -0.06499561667442322, 0.023297371342778206, 0.019754914566874504, 0.06347529590129852, -0.004337449558079243, 0.00899016298353672, -0.0014114187797531486, 0.006811919156461954, -0.024721411988139153, 0.01047569140791893, -0.04512457922101021, 0.0032413052394986153, 0.006998456548899412, -0.03070068173110485, 0.0012304738629609346, -0.017967095598578453, -0.01873861253261566, 0.016447799280285835, -0.054954756051301956, 0.04661264643073082, -0.0027256980538368225, 0.03344758599996567, -0.010185835883021355, -0.03818264976143837, -0.011013912037014961, 0.04355234652757645, 0.006850339937955141, 0.0337357223033905, -0.010432287119328976, 0.045384760946035385, 0.005375003907829523, -0.027949882671236992, -0.05761520192027092, -0.019438493996858597, 0.012853773310780525, -0.006949452683329582, -0.03912240266799927, -0.014865649864077568, 0.04181084409356117, -0.03477553650736809, -0.004577367100864649, -0.05440954491496086, 0.03832866996526718, -0.024452337995171547, 0.008754821494221687, -0.009526056237518787, -0.003978740889579058, 0.03599875047802925, 0.02438906766474247, -0.011726541444659233, 0.0016750037902966142, 0.001108325901441276, -0.022264136001467705, 0.004926938563585281, -0.026959942653775215, -0.014426212757825851, -0.05228376016020775, -0.03240148723125458, 0.04425425082445145, 0.04134412854909897, -0.014870855025947094, 0.0254033375531435, 0.016908740624785423, -0.03985096141695976, -0.0037809296045452356, -0.026173215359449387, 0.01189139112830162, 0.0019598265644162893, 0.018458260223269463, -0.018044879660010338, 0.050863251090049744, -0.04045480862259865, 0.0132215591147542, -0.015967926010489464, -0.036958202719688416, -0.03844783455133438, 0.0043689715676009655, 0.09947642683982849, 0.017802175134420395, 0.02780122682452202, 0.03335253894329071, 0.016266824677586555, 0.02372552827000618, 0.01643163338303566, 0.00790315866470337, 0.015876105055212975, 0.03350144624710083, -0.010900044813752174, 0.012594201602041721, -0.037606824189424515, -0.008500310592353344, 0.04760383442044258, 0.0075326221995055676, 0.017534565180540085, 0.0540052130818367, 0.0026706114877015352, 0.01615036092698574, -0.036261022090911865, 0.0262460894882679, -0.03171112760901451, 0.04457304999232292, 0.07423097640275955, -0.0030650722328573465, 0.001735517755150795, 0.021844828501343727, 0.036403805017471313, 0.02131788618862629, 0.00911135133355856, 0.03335779532790184, 0.0019014293793588877, 0.032208383083343506, -0.024742208421230316, -0.03816452994942665, -0.0058327182196080685, -0.06311333179473877, -0.00883854366838932, -0.021384859457612038, -0.032855622470378876, 0.05322183668613434, 0.01283249631524086, 0.002648609457537532, -0.03539927303791046, -0.02012387290596962, -0.04462379217147827, 0.020021317526698112, 0.019165681675076485, -0.0036520021967589855, -0.000010357643986935727, 0.016681397333741188, 0.04207132011651993, -0.0034386718180030584, 0.012116541154682636, -0.021568449214100838, -0.07096445560455322, -0.00832042284309864, 0.025405561551451683, -0.045735739171504974, 0.045561470091342926, -0.03104705922305584, -0.017159173265099525, 0.01196348574012518, -0.08381415158510208, 0.010363481938838959, 0.018314911052584648, 0.01297740638256073, -0.006648571230471134, 0.06892015039920807, -0.019534921273589134, 0.012483335100114346, -0.003505036700516939, 0.0035140730906277895, 0.09622275829315186, 0.054190754890441895, 0.04381650686264038, -0.05230042338371277, 0.016147935763001442, 0.02128041349351406, 0.04627140611410141, -0.002148540923371911, 0.008122777566313744, 0.015178587287664413, -0.008332752622663975, 0.05193934962153435, 0.06049560755491257, 0.024832993745803833, 0.014054172672331333, 0.027078360319137573, -0.011323769576847553, -0.041534554213285446, -0.01325209904462099, -0.021042877808213234, 0.012336894869804382, -0.03191569074988365, 0.01168116182088852, -0.012967607006430626, 0.010688281618058681, 0.03648968040943146, -0.019262487068772316, -0.021328873932361603, -0.005886806175112724, 0.0116359181702137, -0.027178578078746796, 0.0037120275665074587, 0.011672056280076504, 0.04000554233789444, -0.04496674984693527, -0.042121753096580505, 0.05599481239914894, -0.026394370943307877, 0.03250683471560478, 0.023153388872742653, -0.029882092028856277, -0.022649722173810005, 0.008907466195523739, -0.004749040585011244, -0.06448721140623093, -0.035683177411556244, -0.02183506265282631, 0.04725782573223114, -0.011198077350854874, -0.06045832112431526, -0.024944741278886795, 0.0093856705352664, -0.02156112901866436, -0.022505290806293488, -0.03344701603055, 0.02995028719305992, 0.03512585908174515, -0.03427450358867645, -0.03646455705165863, -0.02951780892908573, -0.008335952647030354, 0.019006604328751564, 0.007191439624875784, -0.011143209412693977, -0.003214197000488639, -0.0005984774907119572, -0.018591556698083878, 0.012505090795457363, 0.02947467379271984, 0.010798828676342964, -0.0069524734281003475, 0.007047262974083424, -0.0237245112657547, 0.001666830386966467, 0.03899359703063965, 0.016666825860738754, 0.0052627925761044025, 0.010905956849455833, -0.00023153155052568763, -0.004759324248880148, -0.06282946467399597, -0.018269944936037064, 0.006992659065872431, 0.00926447007805109, -0.03774750232696533, 0.03167961165308952, 0.0006585006485693157, -0.009760774672031403, 0.026472296565771103, 0.022971874102950096, 0.01611923612654209, 0.07376459985971451, -0.0031345838215202093, -0.028994891792535782, -0.002180688548833132, -0.013497860170900822, -0.018974803388118744, -0.006976271513849497, -0.028288763016462326, 0.049668196588754654, 0.015297461301088333, 0.04447242245078087, 0.0240385252982378, 0.0258671585470438, -0.009103596210479736, 0.008518347516655922, 0.012342579662799835, -0.06292595714330673, -0.012815332040190697, 0.006643724162131548, -0.004339311271905899, 0.0020801906939595938, -0.022875629365444183, -0.040630318224430084, -0.031210916116833687, -0.004501465708017349, -0.028918446972966194, -0.022469887509942055, 0.0003088344819843769, -0.031347714364528656, 0.005102482158690691, -0.024603139609098434, 0.010653057135641575, -0.053487829864025116, -0.029693955555558205, -0.02208392508327961, -0.03433183580636978, -0.004825392737984657, 0.020014794543385506, -0.00048734608571976423, 0.035682808607816696, 0.005361214280128479, 0.0027774334885179996, -0.009531225077807903, -0.006860117428004742, -0.0023102809209376574, 0.037325866520404816, 0.04550771042704582, -0.004235587082803249, -0.029327193275094032, 0.0343300960958004, -0.022461101412773132, 0.005044897086918354, 0.011053883470594883, 0.023768655955791473, 0.04720209166407585, 0.04275347292423248, 0.01517368946224451, 0.013629021123051643, 0.0736282542347908, -0.01054704375565052, -0.022216476500034332, -0.008672038093209267, -0.0017416455084457994, 0.0018040890572592616, 0.000996879767626524, 0.003873879788443446, 0.011658761650323868, -0.017047446221113205, 0.03775637224316597, 0.022317934781312943, -0.006889094598591328, -0.02670826017856598, 0.03665056824684143, -0.016898389905691147, 0.03325160965323448, 0.010813223198056221, -0.017042702063918114, 0.020976051688194275, 0.03604597970843315, -0.00130804895889014, -0.0008377410122193396, -0.05846921727061272, 0.004464998841285706, -0.08805438876152039, 0.0003626210964284837, -0.002113891765475273, 0.030156029388308525, 0.028572162613272667, -0.04883184656500816, 0.02053561434149742, 0.021440958604216576, -0.07980872690677643, 0.015050426125526428, 0.005084190517663956, -0.017812803387641907, -0.027830837294459343, 0.018439922481775284, -0.0254824236035347, 0.039613328874111176, 0.0147642120718956, 0.034583449363708496, 0.0012922112364321947, 0.03542736917734146, 0.00828639604151249, -0.0438208170235157, 0.011176632717251778, 0.04255546256899834, 0.027264347299933434, -0.0583781972527504, 0.01161685399711132, 0.024038057774305344, -0.04347698763012886, -0.010573526844382286, -0.0004044232773594558, 0.03036605939269066, 0.04446827992796898, 0.02410658448934555, -0.00843478087335825, 0.03542977198958397, 0.02502063661813736, 0.000600420986302197, -0.026906495913863182, -0.0049768975004553795, -0.012033550068736076, 0.0434444397687912, 0.019947074353694916, 0.03380895033478737, 0.04863700643181801, -0.01032330747693777, -0.02099459245800972, 0.006768985651433468, -0.05796090140938759, 0.004150867462158203, 0.011862672865390778, -0.047994669526815414, 0.020180508494377136, -0.03534146025776863, -0.02972322143614292, -0.07294757664203644, -0.01427893340587616, 0.017579607665538788, -0.01821674220263958, -0.023043695837259293, 0.029756229370832443, -0.019233858212828636, -0.021712278947234154, -0.008373950608074665, -0.002942707622423768, -0.006734861060976982, -0.02390359714627266, -0.008630518801510334, -0.015966635197401047, 0.014230825006961823, -0.044545020908117294, -0.011184217408299446, -0.01638709008693695, 0.06614168733358383, -0.0010967454873025417, -0.008854527957737446, -0.0025803870521485806, -0.02969381771981716, 0.014253007248044014, -0.0790899395942688, 0.058111682534217834, 0.03591271489858627, -0.02676137164235115, -0.034328605979681015, -0.004366966430097818, -0.024968639016151428, 0.005819519050419331, 0.02676991932094097, 0.007870609872043133, 0.032490458339452744, -0.00677209347486496, 0.03754933178424835, -0.0016114232130348682, -0.04683636873960495, 0.04187178984284401, 0.017751477658748627, -0.016788555309176445, -0.008253289386630058, -0.00004111327143618837, 0.009514524601399899, -0.017012203112244606, 0.05743240937590599, -0.026347549632191658, 0.015727732330560684, -0.023182706907391548, -0.003070953069254756, 0.0031281441915780306, 0.020576121285557747, -0.03127330541610718, 0.03718475252389908, -0.016954224556684494, -0.03387000411748886, 0.03450842574238777, -0.01120173279196024, -0.020649341866374016, 0.027886513620615005, -0.005486720707267523, 0.006431400775909424, -0.01145407184958458, 0.002645727712661028, -0.024994775652885437, -0.0446929894387722, -0.02609211951494217, 0.04095704108476639, -0.03442353755235672, -0.015033106319606304, 0.015594427473843098, 0.07605524361133575, 0.009088863618671894, -0.009152567014098167, 0.0022743907757103443, 0.0017628399655222893, -0.04994737729430199, 0.002564953174442053, 0.015745380893349648, 0.05399053171277046, 0.011770862154662609, -0.03207989037036896, 0.021805662661790848, 0.0042478907853364944, 0.0016177704092115164, -0.03274982050061226, 0.0232364684343338, -0.018709441646933556, 0.004822320304811001, -0.004219912923872471, 0.009678390808403492, -0.014759502373635769, -0.007863936014473438, -0.008743973448872566, 0.0597766637802124, -0.009927308186888695, -0.006169017404317856, -0.016246460378170013, 0.007748006377369165, -0.05105233192443848, 0.007247210014611483, 0.05613576993346214, 0.014665322378277779, 0.00541391596198082, -0.027454562485218048, 0.004691003356128931, -0.0381757952272892, -0.004199552815407515, -0.002652916358783841, 0.012894964776933193, -0.01473515946418047, -0.012329623103141785, -0.05786769837141037, -0.04281841963529587, -0.04367324709892273, -0.027431031689047813, 0.05952753499150276, 0.005393700674176216, -0.012600179761648178, -0.040937040001153946, -0.022842077538371086, 0.022692406550049782, 0.04160004109144211, -0.046474531292915344, -0.026348980143666267, -0.03730824217200279, 0.011476300656795502, 0.02050754614174366, -0.004744174424558878 ]
<p>I ran a Canonical Correlation Analysis on about 845 cases with 1000 variables each. (It originally started with 1000 cases and 400 variables but by using a kernel I got a 1000x1000 matrix)</p> <p>As a result I got mainly eigenvalues very close to 1 (e.g. the highest: 0.9999987616532545), then there were a couple with E-8, five with 0 and some negative ones.</p> <p>I find especially the nearly 1000 1's quite strange or is that a result that is possible/makes sense? I didn't quite get the results that I was hoping for, so I was wondering if all those nearly 1's could be the cause and if anyone has an idea what might have caused those?</p> <p>I use EigenDecomposition from Commons Math 3.0 (<a href="http://commons.apache.org/math/apidocs/index.html" rel="nofollow">http://commons.apache.org/math/apidocs/index.html</a>). I also tried some other matrices earlier and then got "MaxCountExceededException: illegal state: convergence failed" error. Not sure if that has anything to do with it, but I thought I'd add it.</p>
73,533
[ -0.03207134082913399, 0.013284779153764248, 0.006211528088897467, 0.023180915042757988, 0.05813761055469513, -0.028057122603058815, -0.0047724745236337185, -0.019381459802389145, -0.00529579957947135, -0.014236776158213615, 0.04025646671652794, 0.02310200408101082, 0.01977204903960228, 0.050797417759895325, 0.040736403316259384, 0.0065375627018511295, -0.0024119848385453224, 0.02800322324037552, 0.01985611952841282, -0.011905290186405182, 0.010596651583909988, 0.03548808768391609, 0.0006346313166432083, -0.010224978439509869, -0.012272405438125134, 0.011630143970251083, -0.0126075129956007, -0.06304319947957993, 0.029395923018455505, 0.03299572318792343, -0.07818339765071869, -0.025861214846372604, 0.014763439074158669, 0.04371481388807297, 0.042958129197359085, 0.008289496414363384, -0.021237768232822418, -0.031056003645062447, -0.020136453211307526, 0.01621868833899498, 0.010843455791473389, -0.07398687303066254, -0.0371188260614872, 0.05508752912282944, 0.006933201104402542, 0.0019851787947118282, 0.032513540238142014, -0.017537526786327362, 0.06867912411689758, -0.03077096864581108, 0.0925363227725029, 0.022404208779335022, 0.018534278497099876, 0.004282037727534771, -0.02856775000691414, -0.03293779492378235, 0.05391669645905495, 0.02763921394944191, 0.027951961383223534, -0.03664290904998779, -0.0013735636603087187, -0.04282519221305847, -0.034216586500406265, 0.03454460948705673, -0.022643063217401505, 0.035972949117422104, 0.009841816499829292, -0.015975043177604675, 0.028183704242110252, -0.03606344386935234, 0.023699916899204254, 0.013494125567376614, 0.030484577640891075, -0.03130277618765831, 0.025298722088336945, -0.0008078720420598984, -0.0031440369784832, 0.00045220673200674355, 0.04719368740916252, 0.040960222482681274, -0.01607670821249485, 0.0063644880428910255, -0.022884946316480637, -0.009170060977339745, 0.03321985527873039, -0.0016843090998008847, 0.07304395735263824, -0.026744594797492027, -0.0013466966338455677, 0.04948463290929794, -0.008589178323745728, -0.017741896212100983, 0.05037003383040428, 0.04425985366106033, -0.024763699620962143, 0.02984352596104145, -0.00041957764187827706, 0.040733110159635544, 0.0066187139600515366, -0.006822502706199884, -0.050754837691783905, -0.014956219121813774, 0.007526649162173271, 0.012792372144758701, -0.020674463361501694, -0.00842694379389286, -0.04163868725299835, 0.017886795103549957, -0.018230734393000603, -0.0394006073474884, -0.03260396793484688, -0.01013149879872799, 0.010051933117210865, 0.00366586702875793, -0.005995659157633781, -0.022096876055002213, -0.025932634249329567, -0.0036949391942471266, 0.0179294366389513, 0.08108071982860565, 0.04578264802694321, 0.013896324671804905, 0.01381608098745346, -0.05474136397242546, -0.048787567764520645, 0.028201887384057045, 0.012599693611264229, -0.018272357061505318, -0.04413871467113495, 0.059762343764305115, 0.018330559134483337, -0.04719139263033867, 0.03589256480336189, -0.02344662696123123, 0.05306379124522209, -0.03639945760369301, -0.10201932489871979, -0.05642855167388916, 0.04818238317966461, -0.02794657088816166, 0.0023065805435180664, -0.055967241525650024, 0.006224106065928936, 0.043062467128038406, 0.08375762403011322, 0.006756685208529234, 0.024557601660490036, 0.02660554088652134, 0.05282027646899223, 0.03670197352766991, -0.037151023745536804, -0.01287523191422224, -0.03031223826110363, -0.018434377387166023, -0.00030848485766910017, -0.040729962289333344, 0.016622409224510193, 0.030956251546740532, 0.025068236514925957, 0.003948344383388758, 0.02641981467604637, 0.019649142399430275, 0.02674684301018715, -0.011106614954769611, -0.0029523929115384817, -0.015262278728187084, 0.04915643110871315, 0.021220305934548378, 0.03368939831852913, 0.018029112368822098, -0.039111264050006866, 0.04277883842587471, 0.003684909548610449, 0.040756452828645706, 0.023289944976568222, -0.023462491109967232, 0.01744350977241993, -0.05752972140908241, 0.01645389385521412, 0.008316081017255783, -0.057825058698654175, -0.06276917457580566, 0.008580760098993778, 0.0071467747911810875, 0.026046060025691986, 0.04654331132769585, -0.04289180040359497, -0.03878321126103401, 0.032728176563978195, -0.04787718504667282, -0.032807573676109314, -0.02860291860997677, 0.031317006796598434, -0.020266609266400337, -0.030528925359249115, 0.029186222702264786, -0.032110728323459625, 0.03153105080127716, -0.010845089331269264, 0.002589816227555275, -0.03824812173843384, 0.00538167729973793, 0.05180332809686661, -0.048638030886650085, 0.006872862111777067, 0.027141636237502098, 0.017651909962296486, -0.03212001174688339, 0.026334628462791443, -0.055999577045440674, -0.04799211770296097, 0.021384883671998978, -0.004364271182566881, 0.019420821219682693, 0.0014883173862472177, -0.01841595396399498, 0.002827115124091506, 0.0022037269081920385, -0.02252117171883583, 0.009291423484683037, -0.029725918546319008, 0.0424455963075161, 0.043300122022628784, 0.011546766385436058, -0.026460031047463417, 0.038714874535799026, -0.006996911019086838, -0.030658915638923645, -0.006806576624512672, 0.025292089208960533, -0.06266383826732635, 0.00898001715540886, 0.014833180233836174, 0.07692378014326096, -0.04863980785012245, -0.010710438713431358, 0.07494674623012543, 0.047343604266643524, -0.026187025010585785, -0.015730472281575203, 0.01216480415314436, 0.008122636936604977, 0.01660863310098648, 0.04079760983586311, 0.01971779763698578, -0.030690817162394524, -0.021550653502345085, -0.00893655139952898, 0.04105975106358528, 0.025647655129432678, -0.05132109671831131, 0.0022251387126743793, -0.024232622236013412, 0.0252805445343256, -0.03247855603694916, -0.016876336187124252, 0.032180700451135635, -0.030075369402766228, -0.00589523371309042, 0.043051864951848984, 0.0028057245071977377, 0.02267635241150856, -0.028773272410035133, -0.028986703604459763, 0.0096758296713233, 0.007142893970012665, -0.021316276863217354, -0.010928340256214142, 0.014561885967850685, -0.04509813338518143, 0.005260762758553028, -0.040896810591220856, -0.03148955851793289, -0.04449060559272766, 0.03879695385694504, 0.04503638669848442, 0.01889379322528839, 0.05119096115231514, -0.04414879530668259, -0.00724763935431838, 0.019945096224546432, -0.011323714628815651, 0.006068466231226921, -0.0016673431964591146, -0.07615024596452713, 0.014037152752280235, -0.024583840742707253, -0.007571557071059942, 0.043975841253995895, -0.004331186879426241, -0.010275660082697868, 0.03840775787830353, -0.005096282809972763, -0.047905340790748596, -0.03295106440782547, -0.010055603459477425, -0.009459410794079304, -0.01900254376232624, 0.013116455636918545, 0.05208003148436546, -0.020076755434274673, -0.04603707045316696, 0.012773695401847363, -0.011779201216995716, 0.000529496232047677, -0.021919958293437958, -0.03603828325867653, 0.011601279489696026, -0.013911099173128605, -0.001635245280340314, -0.005833720322698355, 0.01975591480731964, 0.03603816404938698, -0.07441023737192154, -0.062379080802202225, 0.00745907099917531, 0.007429090328514576, 0.0777866318821907, -0.0015980276511982083, 0.01471040491014719, 0.061283573508262634, 0.027029603719711304, -0.04388277977705002, -0.05338657647371292, -0.003939336631447077, -0.048359550535678864, -0.027578597888350487, 0.004963363986462355, 0.010934515856206417, 0.01923106051981449, 0.03622840344905853, -0.031189411878585815, 0.028667980805039406, 0.04590383544564247, -0.022217877209186554, 0.018317945301532745, 0.033963534981012344, -0.023653296753764153, -0.026611821725964546, 0.04824073985219002, 0.0002793076273519546, -0.008329179137945175, -0.006116156000643969, 0.022969147190451622, 0.003036667127162218, 0.006979524157941341, -0.06338093429803848, -0.002333764685317874, -0.009138478897511959, 0.05787278339266777, -0.047252193093299866, -0.007275022100657225, -0.001041854964569211, -0.013027527369558811, -0.04363997280597687, 0.06219226494431496, 0.03467625752091408, -0.034254077821969986, 0.0038612636271864176, 0.023609831929206848, 0.0030885941814631224, -0.034170810133218765, 0.015582838095724583, -0.014966345392167568, -0.02170960046350956, 0.020855795592069626, -0.0191997941583395, 0.011236106045544147, 0.05501210317015648, -0.0038013497833162546, 0.016377657651901245, 0.010638348758220673, -0.05448748171329498, 0.01074998825788498, -0.05188395455479622, 0.0033735481556504965, -0.07459218055009842, 0.03013404831290245, -0.009593294933438301, 0.03544221445918083, 0.018856888636946678, -0.010310596786439419, 0.015524844639003277, 0.004701611585915089, -0.09093239158391953, -0.04093093052506447, -0.01602308638393879, -0.007536382880061865, 0.011889442801475525, -0.03873145207762718, -0.01114802435040474, 0.0019500204361975193, 0.03096042014658451, 0.007878740318119526, 0.020745988935232162, -0.05155803635716438, 0.015017352066934109, -0.03126348927617073, 0.01684766821563244, -0.019907543435692787, -0.04924364387989044, 0.02189324051141739, 0.018045034259557724, 0.04585779458284378, 0.03975078836083412, -0.03624388948082924, -0.01840134710073471, -0.02127258852124214, 0.019899288192391396, 0.017440315335989, 0.032302312552928925, -0.009305045008659363, 0.027574818581342697, -0.027763674035668373, 0.017369501292705536, -0.02602536790072918, 0.018756885081529617, 0.06564655900001526, -0.012684164568781853, 0.0032794680446386337, -0.03285251557826996, -0.02089853771030903, 0.041140276938676834, 0.019300974905490875, -0.009350631386041641, 0.03232168033719063, 0.03674447163939476, 0.035070568323135376, -0.030753545463085175, 0.01702028512954712, 0.0761885866522789, -0.01029784232378006, -0.008200548589229584, -0.028039561584591866, -0.007728230208158493, 0.015606961213052273, 0.01046424638479948, 0.025052785873413086, -0.0014315203297883272, -0.036595750600099564, -0.03898661583662033, 0.04912419244647026, -0.05059176683425903, 0.016427062451839447, 0.03327812999486923, 0.010988835245370865, 0.02909228578209877, -0.027745114639401436, -0.014487041160464287, 0.017339950427412987, 0.03652102127671242, 0.03904371336102486, 0.031030386686325073, 0.011482651345431805, -0.05154448375105858, 0.00865198578685522, 0.06241385266184807, 0.019646132364869118, -0.019548187032341957, 0.017304562032222748, -0.06166534870862961, -0.05959572643041611, 0.018639421090483665, -0.02639029547572136, 0.02811148762702942, 0.010055290535092354, 0.021078137680888176, -0.025913365185260773, -0.035755567252635956, -0.025382332503795624, 0.009006083942949772, -0.01070469245314598, 0.0331759937107563, -0.039521005004644394, -0.006631424184888601, -0.027385612949728966, 0.028975119814276695, 0.050761640071868896, 0.032371800392866135, -0.01850549317896366, 0.016568433493375778, 0.021556861698627472, 0.0018299275543540716, -0.039445728063583374, -0.06021818891167641, 0.0428580716252327, 0.029001453891396523, -0.015210634097456932, 0.03189963102340698, -0.0454096719622612, -0.003914595115929842, -0.0019664173014461994, 0.02486918680369854, -0.030047781765460968, -0.04380730167031288, 0.011563368141651154, 0.03205578774213791, 0.022076882421970367, -0.024946551769971848, 0.04153717681765556, 0.02082134783267975, 0.0019064538646489382, 0.026686690747737885, -0.03221748024225235, -0.0014094485668465495, 0.011660581454634666, 0.0106964698061347, -0.033333007246255875, 0.02565324865281582, -0.03058977611362934, 0.0031949016265571117, 0.03368674963712692, 0.05246046930551529, -0.02195797860622406, 0.02037840709090233, -0.007951744832098484, 0.027194127440452576, -0.03204938769340515, 0.020817730575799942, 0.030844420194625854, -0.002284711692482233, -0.0014449337031692266, -0.0161957498639822, 0.06804350018501282, -0.02497631311416626, 0.008204041048884392, 0.05333149433135986, -0.042678650468587875, -0.024275096133351326, -0.038065891712903976, 0.01270572654902935, 0.014443287625908852, -0.04141702130436897, 0.0342482291162014, 0.010325424373149872, 0.04958278685808182, 0.03399541601538658, 0.009835571981966496, -0.015458522364497185, 0.005999058019369841, -0.030197838321328163, 0.050541386008262634, -0.009338815696537495, 0.013185600750148296, -0.011172167025506496, 0.02091490477323532, -0.027435988187789917, -0.06596092134714127, 0.02847895957529545, 0.019552825018763542, -0.012604137882590294, -0.04544224962592125, -0.03218210116028786, -0.019974587485194206, -0.011017529293894768, -0.016573118045926094, 0.025948477908968925, -0.03456839174032211, -0.0013062513899058104, 0.029059378430247307, 0.002934496384114027, 0.05631664767861366, -0.03398787975311279, -0.0043687219731509686, 0.023153964430093765, -0.01109533105045557, -0.03425280377268791, 0.013010896742343903, 0.04158417508006096, -0.0469629168510437, -0.028545819222927094, -0.039691586047410965, -0.010419006459414959, 0.048998113721609116, -0.01096908189356327, -0.016766881570219994, 0.028209784999489784, -0.01904456503689289, 0.0431818887591362, 0.0006298592197708786, 0.018509704619646072, -0.020385390147566795, -0.037042200565338135, 0.021519070491194725, -0.04225139319896698, -0.021781928837299347, -0.03838835284113884, 0.02372436411678791, 0.01569977216422558, 0.0064844354055821896, 0.03709551319479942, 0.07301190495491028, 0.022131754085421562, 0.026677129790186882, 0.00020947599841747433, -0.009451499208807945, 0.028661981225013733, 0.03828592225909233, 0.020152801647782326, -0.002012681681662798, 0.0052757528610527515, -0.015007240697741508, -0.05702189728617668, -0.027096396312117577, 0.026972787454724312, 0.043937280774116516, 0.016664743423461914, 0.03995278477668762, 0.0703204870223999, -0.017754439264535904, -0.04385050758719444, -0.014145566150546074, -0.009748493321239948, 0.021756786853075027, 0.00960749201476574, 0.02408965863287449, -0.021615805104374886, -0.028522219508886337, 0.020324168726801872, 0.05711997672915459, 0.027449650689959526, 0.0006427730550058186, 0.010678039863705635, 0.015567260794341564, 0.03158402815461159, -0.012797147035598755, -0.062367383390665054, 0.023539220914244652, -0.03853297978639603, 0.027955668047070503, 0.0022195703350007534, -0.026235854253172874, 0.04550223425030708, 0.00030532825621776283, 0.02265654318034649, -0.020250558853149414, -0.046273816376924515, -0.0309967752546072, 0.005123634822666645, 0.015633733943104744, -0.02977830171585083, 0.03132109344005585, 0.009603996761143208, 0.038570426404476166, 0.041443269699811935, 0.04253040999174118, -0.037289779633283615, -0.06414461135864258, -0.0490603893995285, -0.020719166845083237, -0.03508259356021881, 0.04026675596833229, 0.027403971180319786, -0.03517881780862808, 0.024815401062369347, -0.015594842843711376, 0.02671077847480774, 0.012855826877057552, 0.02933916263282299, 0.003081332193687558, 0.023595623672008514, 0.02021743170917034, -0.012435044161975384, -0.012785252183675766, -0.0029217367991805077, 0.10210160166025162, 0.06716418266296387, 0.023664383217692375, -0.04695652052760124, -0.015586652792990208, 0.022935092449188232, -0.00843876227736473, -0.06518422067165375, 0.023110872134566307, -0.01731889694929123, 0.010093329474329948, 0.04076581075787544, 0.028489690274000168, 0.02138880081474781, 0.02291855961084366, 0.018888460472226143, 0.0006017822888679802, -0.04022962972521782, 0.028407469391822815, 0.025614364072680473, -0.012658816762268543, -0.015658482909202576, -0.013771354220807552, 0.017772940918803215, -0.049298278987407684, -0.05937328562140465, -0.03155619278550148, -0.03162381798028946, 0.003337056841701269, -0.0076222470961511135, 0.008915220387279987, 0.04335825890302658, 0.018620574846863747, -0.010808087885379791, -0.01763082854449749, 0.01604468561708927, 0.002655699849128723, -0.01683104783296585, 0.020273417234420776, 0.022864902392029762, -0.009711898863315582, -0.0056460280902683735, 0.022349171340465546, -0.024859486147761345, 0.009630168788135052, -0.015061295591294765, -0.03130076453089714, 0.06276895105838776, 0.006900613661855459, -0.008578150533139706, -0.03279929980635643, 0.001866956939920783, -0.016901826485991478, -0.0544145368039608, -0.002112053567543626, -0.009730946272611618, 0.03507782518863678, -0.003768215188756585, -0.038285791873931885, -0.013578524813055992, -0.009688552469015121, 0.008940819650888443, 0.02937096729874611, 0.01225248072296381, -0.01990295574069023, -0.012224961072206497, -0.044792596250772476, 0.061722997575998306, -0.00899295974522829, 0.0009230942232534289, -0.010732359252870083, -0.04202551022171974, -0.02278558537364006, -0.053364336490631104, 0.019386310130357742, 0.005537673365324736, 0.04119022190570831, -0.0021139183081686497, -0.006777365691959858, -0.059075478464365005, -0.06812126934528351, -0.016856471076607704, -0.013721649535000324, -0.024805570021271706, -0.05248023942112923, -0.014116772450506687, -0.01763743720948696, 0.035385459661483765, -0.007433019112795591, -0.026971351355314255, -0.0019857464358210564, 0.05983394756913185, -0.020019058138132095, 0.0039009791798889637, -0.021477514877915382, -0.04317759722471237, -0.026289986446499825, 0.02353321760892868, -0.030675385147333145, 0.06167742982506752, -0.0003484759945422411, -0.019484125077724457, 0.009696748107671738, 0.008246559649705887, -0.025245845317840576, 0.001996164908632636, 0.04952063411474228, -0.022491127252578735, 0.009885644540190697, -0.010982764884829521, -0.029723769053816795, -0.019544780254364014, 0.0006615719175897539, -0.045369554311037064, -0.014465049840509892, -0.0037858488503843546, 0.011334545910358429, -0.06424759328365326, -0.007736113853752613, -0.02037474513053894, 0.01808912493288517, -0.025229942053556442, -0.020960744470357895, -0.04410243779420853, 0.009353204630315304, -0.02312219701707363, 0.00995764322578907, -0.023501761257648468, -0.000150681720697321, 0.013883369043469429, 0.01922042854130268, 0.05500541254878044, 0.02753661759197712, 0.009493935853242874, -0.014733047224581242, 0.020338838919997215, 0.011501438915729523, 0.024222634732723236, -0.0321250818669796, -0.03625006601214409, 0.05561245605349541, -0.05599524825811386, -0.001478390651755035, 0.03563559427857399, 0.010903988964855671, 0.028918923810124397, 0.013708164915442467, -0.011010386981070042, -0.03360915556550026, 0.06577278673648834, -0.016105281189084053, 0.00670095719397068, 0.02234879694879055, -0.000167991136549972, 0.014724559150636196, 0.030271239578723907, 0.022704193368554115, -0.00551889231428504, -0.013977318070828915, -0.014330806210637093, 0.059369128197431564, -0.004743542056530714, 0.004787937272340059, 0.019654780626296997, 0.0020077452063560486, 0.023859845474362373, 0.025875680148601532, -0.003955741412937641, 0.01734246499836445, 0.05955903232097626, -0.042078591883182526, -0.00008965266169980168, 0.019275784492492676, 0.04815055429935455, -0.05701379477977753, -0.004248728044331074, -0.013964961282908916, -0.010019674897193909, 0.01989917643368244, -0.06742314249277115, 0.0030629336833953857, 0.06558632850646973, -0.028514035046100616, 0.038448724895715714, -0.005406240001320839, -0.005870338529348373, -0.06792942434549332, 0.03147389367222786, -0.0033344717230647802, 0.03306280076503754, 0.050597306340932846, 0.036348775029182434, 0.02794642560184002, 0.03752851113677025, -0.005696969572454691, -0.034523725509643555, -0.030421175062656403, 0.003804196137934923, -0.018771637231111526, -0.036561112850904465, 0.012646551243960857, -0.04759136214852333, -0.07478712499141693, 0.02188229374587536, -0.02333863452076912, -0.023642022162675858, 0.021395081654191017, 0.05887114629149437, 0.027174241840839386, 0.05215376615524292, 0.043948978185653687, -0.020849989727139473, 0.024690786376595497, -0.0014821084914729, 0.0002835181658156216, 0.02541772834956646, -0.007755422964692116, 0.03670573979616165, 0.02601942978799343, -0.02218918316066265, -0.05294197425246239, 0.026864822953939438, -0.019214846193790436, 0.004576543346047401, -0.010783055797219276, -0.006007131189107895, -0.0063253347761929035, -0.020414717495441437, 0.004210249055176973, -0.010705347172915936, -0.010917127132415771, 0.02715233527123928, 0.03972485661506653, -0.029548119753599167, 0.0019257335225120187, -0.0061528682708740234, -0.01646386831998825, 0.02383984625339508, -0.01790226250886917, -0.010743565857410431, -0.04241018369793892, 0.018497316166758537, 0.018234163522720337, -0.04645521938800812, 0.0006357395905070007, -0.021767087280750275, -0.04845656082034111, 0.043433863669633865, -0.006476114504039288, 0.008037463761866093, 0.024845711886882782, -0.049356382340192795, 0.024795103818178177, -0.08429121226072311, 0.016326507553458214, -0.022256121039390564, -0.008335163816809654, 0.0005918450187891722, 0.005121177528053522, 0.0007233362412080169, -0.005426847375929356, 0.009667591191828251, -0.024492362514138222, 0.015203023329377174, 0.006373821757733822, -0.0030447456520050764, 0.02278626523911953, -0.006634199060499668, 0.03442918509244919, -0.03707033768296242, -0.033171676099300385, 0.003256574273109436, -0.009673438966274261, 0.013610996305942535, -0.03822498768568039, 0.011955954134464264, -0.025779422372579575, -0.0028962818905711174, 0.00551200658082962, -0.02863892912864685, 0.06281134486198425, 0.0008912115008570254, -0.02242198772728443, 0.09179003536701202, -0.009829796850681305, 0.003210826776921749, 0.02642687037587166, -0.016643797978758812, -0.04215921089053154, 0.03199787437915802, -0.004892581608146429, -0.03260510042309761, 0.004140046890825033, 0.011385836638510227, 0.005265280604362488, -0.03487420082092285, 0.0071335285902023315, 0.05616752803325653, -0.04669950529932976, 0.011288999579846859, 0.0226310845464468, -0.011104067787528038, 0.025317266583442688, 0.026497066020965576, 0.03802129253745079, 0.044768285006284714, -0.029096759855747223, 0.02680925466120243, 0.03928087279200554, 0.0327569879591465, -0.00971360132098198, -0.020355070009827614, 0.02347802184522152, -0.03839857503771782, 0.010674389079213142, -0.025160426273941994, 0.0107301389798522, -0.03740348666906357, 0.0014233571710065007, 0.03206560015678406, -0.008732205256819725, 0.02567543089389801, 0.014910675585269928, -0.03899482265114784, 0.08259501308202744, -0.04157662391662598, 0.024517346173524857, 0.010652818717062473, -0.008107569068670273, 0.01597699336707592, -0.004172039218246937, -0.023615702986717224, 0.044813502579927444, 0.004711882211267948, 0.006226711440831423, -0.01028931699693203, -0.0050641270354390144, 0.031261757016181946, -0.027661962434649467, -0.0024296294432133436, -0.016172660514712334, 0.020162610337138176, 0.0033353380858898163, 0.0036506291944533587, -0.005365706980228424, -0.02961336448788643, 0.04450042545795441, 0.010852238163352013, 0.0265054851770401, -0.07257739454507828, -0.019485587254166603, -0.008365275338292122, 0.03615167737007141, -0.016838401556015015, -0.0443759560585022, -0.043128471821546555, 0.05239894613623619, -0.022997964173555374, 0.018830837681889534 ]
<p>I was reading in "A Guide to Econometrics" that given $Y = X \beta + \epsilon$, the variance covariance matrix of $\beta^\text{OLS}$ is given by $\sigma^2 (X&#39; X)^{-1}$ where $\sigma^2$ is the variance of the error term...</p> <p>it then says that in the case of a single regressor $y = \beta_1 + \beta_2 x$, that this simplifies to $\sigma^2 / \sum(x-\bar{x})^2$. I don't quite see this. Isn't the matrix $X$ in this case still a two by two matrix? Namely:</p> <p>$$ X = \left( \begin{array}{cc} 1 &amp; x_1 \\\ 1 &amp; x_2 \end{array} \right) $$</p> <p>How are we getting something like $\sum(x-\bar{x})^2$ ?</p>
47,357
[ -0.026207536458969116, 0.02706894464790821, 0.005496134050190449, -0.007070384919643402, 0.04026472568511963, 0.024528365582227707, -0.0015740948729217052, -0.01920240931212902, 0.04954567179083824, -0.03837965801358223, 0.03347614035010338, 0.014950275421142578, 0.1256786584854126, 0.001990328775718808, 0.05819661170244217, 0.02281881682574749, -0.023284422233700752, 0.03628665953874588, -0.011704047210514545, 0.028000453487038612, -0.009873323142528534, 0.019465386867523193, 0.008962970227003098, 0.0032181842252612114, 0.004757806193083525, 0.025326259434223175, 0.04411135986447334, -0.01837798021733761, 0.012759091332554817, 0.0537901297211647, -0.01674163155257702, -0.03641272708773613, 0.035662971436977386, 0.034536004066467285, 0.019446009770035744, -0.0210797768086195, -0.01797555945813656, -0.06761795282363892, 0.014603067189455032, 0.044665295630693436, -0.016619650647044182, -0.007678180932998657, -0.012903818860650063, 0.017349041998386383, -0.022099895402789116, 0.02281496673822403, -0.01970672979950905, -0.05025891214609146, 0.022389357909560204, -0.03156118094921112, 0.1024973914027214, -0.018452173098921776, 0.0522039532661438, 0.05994458496570587, 0.0017511476762592793, 0.027425425127148628, 0.05984934791922569, 0.015755390748381615, 0.020791398361325264, -0.0012524094199761748, -0.015922170132398605, 0.011297148652374744, 0.03176497668027878, 0.011277052573859692, -0.002790615661069751, -0.029239965602755547, 0.021232016384601593, 0.010054939426481724, 0.03750724717974663, -0.04281244054436684, 0.027389101684093475, 0.022344553843140602, 0.009681059047579765, -0.003660086076706648, -0.0063544693402945995, 0.014655107632279396, 0.014528332278132439, 0.009567953646183014, 0.03004511632025242, 0.02397504821419716, 0.04799112305045128, 0.01355786807835102, 0.03352972865104675, 0.010166495107114315, 0.0027607129886746407, 0.00889218132942915, 0.05595632269978523, -0.04644201323390007, 0.00981991644948721, 0.0038249182980507612, 0.010368590243160725, 0.010335502214729786, 0.03146996721625328, -0.03973625227808952, -0.054383423179388046, 0.06679017841815948, 0.0028193891048431396, 0.012265210971236229, 0.020595474168658257, -0.019374817609786987, -0.051519352942705154, -0.03493461757898331, -0.006305627059191465, 0.04453723505139351, -0.002383769489824772, -0.012272321619093418, 0.0077867936342954636, 0.03702981024980545, 0.005995514336973429, -0.06834277510643005, -0.03191366791725159, 0.026210788637399673, -0.013201395981013775, 0.0012041935697197914, 0.03753058239817619, -0.010204559192061424, 0.0022684999275952578, 0.02395743876695633, 0.007961022667586803, 0.07452134042978287, 0.032388702034950256, 0.005866591352969408, 0.028768302872776985, 0.003068753518164158, -0.020529549568891525, 0.05475100874900818, 0.06043333560228348, -0.025639016181230545, -0.07244347035884857, 0.03645902872085571, 0.02167440392076969, -0.05239125341176987, -0.004153084941208363, 0.019554564729332924, 0.00791263859719038, 0.007087156642228365, -0.12351294606924057, -0.05854153633117676, -0.00667553348466754, 0.009846152737736702, 0.007468544878065586, -0.05566248670220375, -0.016055630519986153, 0.010583939962089062, 0.06760500371456146, -0.004759000148624182, 0.05359644070267677, 0.03126399219036102, -0.004488665144890547, 0.022970592603087425, -0.027445374056696892, -0.019722601398825645, -0.03190314769744873, -0.02045520953834057, -0.014188878238201141, -0.053423307836055756, -0.015841452404856682, 0.014788670465350151, 0.016569020226597786, -0.010160719975829124, 0.023339491337537766, -0.0030117833521217108, -0.010899771936237812, 0.017114346846938133, 0.014843282289803028, -0.03745134174823761, 0.028855089098215103, 0.0037371357902884483, 0.006075432989746332, 0.034525249153375626, 0.004936531186103821, 0.0021168538369238377, -0.0010545375989750028, 0.0711081475019455, 0.053403340280056, -0.010981123894453049, -0.016506098210811615, -0.015884993597865105, -0.004644384607672691, 0.0197795107960701, -0.10614842921495438, -0.023463627323508263, -0.01930954121053219, 0.013469346798956394, 0.003153871512040496, 0.06068604812026024, 0.025533778592944145, -0.020555216819047928, 0.0108236875385046, -0.06618313491344452, -0.015173518098890781, -0.06583668291568756, 0.012316081672906876, -0.01398387923836708, -0.003951184917241335, 0.011834973469376564, 0.03223363310098648, 0.007738330867141485, -0.0012821770505979657, -0.04102538898587227, -0.008137152530252934, 0.040224265307188034, 0.04399076849222183, -0.02989407256245613, 0.03249312937259674, 0.02153804711997509, 0.07016166299581528, -0.0029724997002631426, 0.059775181114673615, -0.0262058787047863, -0.02636941894888878, 0.010791054926812649, -0.02521204762160778, 0.02441204898059368, -0.011983812786638737, -0.01668412610888481, 0.008779797703027725, -0.016173822805285454, -0.03144686669111252, 0.0308805163949728, -0.07365648448467255, 0.04566910117864609, 0.08190415054559708, 0.008613098412752151, -0.011589942499995232, 0.005154105834662914, 0.02630576118826866, 0.002325634704902768, -0.04685033857822418, -0.020726677030324936, 0.0008057176019065082, -0.011999186128377914, 0.048426952213048935, 0.05021745339035988, -0.029882824048399925, 0.020893782377243042, 0.04742326959967613, 0.04690453037619591, -0.0014809789136052132, 0.05091341584920883, -0.008029830642044544, 0.009613818489015102, -0.0055207666009664536, -0.02041846700012684, 0.01664842665195465, -0.00787363201379776, 0.00997459702193737, 0.02219112031161785, 0.03721388056874275, 0.03694656118750572, -0.002642671810463071, 0.04167057201266289, -0.03852603957056999, -0.0010559986112639308, -0.01469794288277626, -0.004010344389826059, 0.04446708783507347, -0.008939002640545368, 0.04736160486936569, 0.02959451824426651, 0.018883438780903816, 0.0120076984167099, 0.011558680795133114, 0.009660513140261173, 0.02301832288503647, 0.045217908918857574, -0.03583534434437752, 0.003350871615111828, 0.0221111923456192, -0.01061089988797903, 0.02941160649061203, -0.023334534838795662, -0.03510308638215065, 0.005294886417686939, 0.022516442462801933, 0.0042666844092309475, 0.01565619930624962, 0.0159443449229002, -0.012695658020675182, -0.04319297894835472, -0.029608316719532013, 0.011949537321925163, 0.0407622829079628, 0.03093622252345085, -0.04736984148621559, 0.004752772860229015, -0.0664161667227745, 0.01609935238957405, 0.04230289161205292, 0.002032792428508401, -0.01933090202510357, -0.026486793532967567, -0.009609323926270008, -0.06569670140743256, -0.05583338811993599, -0.024469146504998207, -0.0013849027454853058, -0.043489664793014526, -0.014079870656132698, 0.023196956142783165, -0.001686453353613615, -0.011996501125395298, 0.0158300269395113, -0.037236377596855164, -0.04000737518072128, -0.032954756170511246, -0.04272588714957237, 0.03741831332445145, -0.017584173008799553, 0.013994649983942509, 0.009593465365469456, -0.02890559285879135, -0.0339478962123394, -0.029453599825501442, -0.08095712959766388, 0.00029627271578647196, -0.01787417382001877, -0.0017988180043175817, 0.014439093880355358, -0.048492249101400375, 0.09955160319805145, -0.002554435282945633, -0.00521483551710844, -0.029813803732395172, 0.04199950397014618, -0.001841335673816502, -0.04586672782897949, 0.013522778637707233, 0.012617834843695164, 0.008590858429670334, 0.06233761087059975, -0.03332153707742691, 0.02150270901620388, 0.045057766139507294, -0.017311254516243935, -0.0023668103385716677, -0.013435372151434422, -0.02454010397195816, 0.010479534044861794, 0.023050714284181595, 0.0002806280681397766, 0.010730241425335407, 0.013594437390565872, 0.03280792757868767, 0.02940961718559265, -0.003985211253166199, -0.035025592893362045, 0.009908285923302174, -0.043625835329294205, -0.011587283574044704, -0.039862990379333496, 0.06101551651954651, 0.015078146941959858, -0.02010675147175789, -0.04095851629972458, 0.0026235852856189013, 0.01155704166740179, -0.010447508655488491, 0.01847211644053459, 0.018612921237945557, 0.053447283804416656, -0.007938648574054241, -0.008883319795131683, 0.013643145561218262, -0.015617415308952332, 0.01844039373099804, -0.01376962661743164, -0.020370513200759888, 0.036776989698410034, 0.01902984455227852, -0.022677969187498093, -0.021416258066892624, -0.03017011657357216, 0.008573646657168865, -0.06101689487695694, 0.01793120801448822, -0.009952257387340069, 0.01916276104748249, -0.019284425303339958, 0.04152657836675644, -0.023506643250584602, -0.01631801761686802, 0.0265596155077219, -0.026242824271321297, -0.039862196892499924, -0.008311836048960686, -0.03280201926827431, -0.02461589127779007, 0.024617956951260567, -0.011759286746382713, 0.05450136214494705, -0.018008483573794365, 0.0012754189083352685, -0.031769055873155594, -0.003159739775583148, -0.011223871260881424, -0.016170157119631767, -0.02599378302693367, -0.016853375360369682, 0.0021854396909475327, 0.0022127802949398756, 0.02470468357205391, -0.0504416823387146, -0.012518069706857204, 0.04458164796233177, -0.014462172985076904, -0.007143592461943626, -0.05016329884529114, 0.01739652454853058, 0.028642645105719566, 0.017162177711725235, 0.03632725402712822, 0.0383598655462265, -0.0032559572719037533, 0.034515827894210815, 0.01861121691763401, 0.07050172239542007, 0.018915420398116112, -0.010244184173643589, -0.017127780243754387, -0.030950386077165604, -0.030633455142378807, 0.01220293715596199, -0.00262855039909482, 0.025568734854459763, 0.00437252689152956, 0.07337139546871185, 0.05366326496005058, -0.022469762712717056, 0.025567572563886642, 0.07834284752607346, -0.006219959817826748, 0.01145528256893158, -0.04070079326629639, 0.014150936156511307, -0.019560597836971283, -0.004994410090148449, -0.0015781046822667122, -0.005912246648222208, -0.01621061936020851, -0.015298389829695225, 0.05693262815475464, -0.035890307277441025, 0.013284907676279545, 0.0074205114506185055, 0.03402293100953102, 0.038426730781793594, 0.0016698589315637946, -0.02760116010904312, 0.000523090420756489, 0.027365127578377724, 0.05857749655842781, 0.05008789896965027, -0.00478049973025918, -0.04580908641219139, -0.00043782329885289073, -0.008645390160381794, 0.0003592185094021261, -0.029929690062999725, -0.0030576400458812714, -0.009154519066214561, -0.05098145455121994, 0.025223085656762123, 0.011877746321260929, 0.04499335214495659, -0.008889421820640564, 0.0018224332015961409, 0.014198756776750088, 0.0025910730473697186, -0.05265122279524803, -0.0038023535162210464, 0.010297236032783985, 0.04483332484960556, 0.016004329547286034, -0.025400476530194283, -0.04503631964325905, -0.0010865912772715092, 0.009113912470638752, 0.041431326419115067, -0.004613042343407869, -0.03985634073615074, -0.011250413954257965, 0.07096081972122192, -0.036214761435985565, -0.0849413275718689, 0.001876931986771524, 0.022931041195988655, -0.02145128883421421, 0.027877328917384148, 0.022182056680321693, -0.037197623401880264, 0.004288880154490471, 0.008721777237951756, -0.012638257816433907, 0.004370468202978373, -0.010651430115103722, 0.03541766479611397, 0.051107101142406464, 0.03069223463535309, 0.07870253175497055, 0.01662403717637062, 0.004696905147284269, 0.01212996244430542, -0.028048217296600342, 0.011855578050017357, -0.006754014175385237, -0.03776450827717781, -0.05798674374818802, -0.005794155411422253, 0.0018567742081359029, -0.014972368255257607, -0.02638915367424488, 0.05111970752477646, -0.030603716149926186, -0.032399699091911316, 0.025958221405744553, 0.019152838736772537, 0.004106526728719473, -0.03477374091744423, 0.005079301074147224, 0.055423229932785034, -0.015248474664986134, -0.04117320105433464, 0.01220748946070671, -0.011784207075834274, -0.009547065012156963, 0.01734273135662079, -0.002081779297441244, -0.00932671595364809, -0.032460007816553116, -0.036572057753801346, -0.013400090858340263, -0.026646850630640984, 0.027027713134884834, -0.02248378098011017, -0.0011104183504357934, -0.006498515605926514, -0.044807069003582, -0.031549952924251556, 0.034207575023174286, -0.011823421344161034, -0.0027035579551011324, -0.046785201877355576, -0.0023773619905114174, -0.0010028512915596366, -0.02703656628727913, -0.08938486129045486, -0.04137250408530235, -0.005062786862254143, -0.035654786974191666, 0.000393281108699739, -0.0032777786254882812, -0.004711845424026251, -0.015138420276343822, -0.046595871448516846, -0.031790222972631454, 0.06121404841542244, -0.03167818486690521, 0.008065725676715374, -0.016790159046649933, 0.03361595794558525, 0.08075589686632156, -0.019849466159939766, -0.009361665695905685, 0.028489671647548676, -0.03046262450516224, -0.016528179869055748, 0.007357900496572256, 0.0468750074505806, -0.04188310354948044, 0.008636380545794964, -0.05424364656209946, -0.02384384162724018, 0.014346386305987835, -0.041588615626096725, -0.0219823457300663, 0.02826041728258133, 0.030658410862088203, 0.017359014600515366, -0.0273115336894989, -0.004670284688472748, -0.00027044423040933907, 0.04806729033589363, -0.013820539228618145, -0.030512971803545952, -0.04320595785975456, 0.004517761059105396, 0.057953204959630966, 0.01028764434158802, 0.00404184078797698, 0.0401497446000576, 0.07739999890327454, -0.031532663851976395, -0.010580554604530334, 0.032816797494888306, -0.015207103453576565, 0.025676175951957703, 0.031217481940984726, -0.009414169937372208, 0.012983309105038643, 0.03289519250392914, -0.04343019798398018, -0.06317933648824692, -0.033741917461156845, 0.03269996866583824, 0.08544278144836426, -0.04387969151139259, 0.02644827775657177, 0.05641448497772217, -0.005076776258647442, -0.028754739090800285, -0.04296060651540756, -0.026921963319182396, -0.017435045912861824, -0.03868209943175316, 0.037906210869550705, -0.03299332037568092, -0.04165615513920784, 0.008696544915437698, 0.03407004103064537, -0.006394416559487581, 0.019609030336141586, -0.007942890748381615, 0.018345866352319717, 0.010701430961489677, 0.013884440064430237, -0.020220281556248665, 0.01940411515533924, -0.012482786551117897, -0.0037133824080228806, -0.060521453619003296, -0.023945564404129982, 0.04145639017224312, 0.022006796672940254, -0.010487613268196583, -0.04934246838092804, -0.031624503433704376, -0.042187709361314774, 0.027302009984850883, 0.02149820886552334, -0.010137463919818401, 0.030205082148313522, -0.00028747101896442473, 0.05149487033486366, 0.0011680109892040491, 0.024934282526373863, -0.029417887330055237, -0.10822233557701111, -0.0153966611251235, 0.014922703616321087, -0.01609000563621521, 0.010696638375520706, 0.006218197755515575, -0.03427905589342117, -0.018604068085551262, -0.03584938868880272, -0.014351863414049149, 0.0049292161129415035, 0.010914175771176815, -0.0316193513572216, 0.06174290552735329, -0.012137620709836483, 0.001290898653678596, -0.006857692264020443, 0.016673164442181587, 0.08836347609758377, 0.09563340246677399, 0.03449597582221031, -0.06848889589309692, -0.0014994654338806868, -0.021441448479890823, -0.007941294461488724, -0.02430618181824684, 0.007696273270994425, 0.002916973317041993, 0.03784031420946121, 0.007339670788496733, 0.06544487178325653, 0.019961651414632797, -0.04682214558124542, 0.010877867229282856, -0.005328425206243992, -0.025937410071492195, -0.005387123674154282, -0.0057948618195950985, -0.003503778949379921, 0.010884230025112629, -0.03584187850356102, 0.009270621463656425, -0.01557911466807127, 0.010161261074244976, -0.03570161387324333, -0.0016282704891636968, -0.006859963294118643, -0.00475445156916976, -0.027147119864821434, 0.011819259263575077, -0.0018241741927340627, 0.022507337853312492, -0.05567033216357231, 0.027181243523955345, 0.04026642441749573, -0.009371824562549591, 0.02993529476225376, 0.021495839580893517, -0.03579620271921158, 0.04086422920227051, 0.012229898013174534, 0.0020505147986114025, -0.012352854013442993, -0.02088122069835663, -0.008470306172966957, 0.04622271656990051, -0.02605101838707924, 0.012690164148807526, -0.02384757436811924, -0.008447041735053062, 0.015558541752398014, -0.036538686603307724, 0.015061034820973873, 0.037291787564754486, 0.01778215914964676, -0.027661694213747978, 0.0034927106462419033, -0.018785104155540466, 0.031918395310640335, -0.010556507855653763, 0.005259011406451464, -0.0019990382716059685, -0.052955642342567444, -0.032444074749946594, 0.0022074473090469837, 0.03381597623229027, 0.03083522990345955, 0.007561811711639166, -0.015987273305654526, -0.0015937284333631396, -0.003505752421915531, -0.01366721373051405, 0.015540331602096558, 0.01553109847009182, 0.01353247370570898, -0.01703225076198578, 0.009315641596913338, -0.004755791742354631, -0.04528204724192619, 0.011588584631681442, -0.03356187418103218, -0.01432743202894926, -0.025819949805736542, -0.024518048390746117, 0.014608582481741905, 0.03010314144194126, -0.023314280435442924, -0.00511195370927453, 0.005441071931272745, 0.04823596775531769, 0.015254545956850052, -0.05039498955011368, -0.02545204572379589, 0.03281471133232117, -0.0017399780917912722, -0.025379113852977753, 0.0012729514855891466, 0.04579521343111992, 0.0227996576577425, 0.05786493420600891, -0.03211354836821556, 0.03208811208605766, -0.035156238824129105, 0.007330985274165869, 0.043611422181129456, -0.03328109160065651, 0.03543885797262192, 0.03140096366405487, 0.016824912279844284, -0.020122447982430458, 0.0004670734051615, -0.01632445491850376, -0.038833584636449814, -0.010379726998507977, 0.006105725187808275, -0.04514611139893532, 0.009937635622918606, -0.015853242948651314, 0.031909406185150146, -0.0310861524194479, -0.005999268032610416, -0.033815063536167145, 0.02777203731238842, 0.0219202172011137, 0.0028729871846735477, -0.01077231764793396, 0.011437884531915188, 0.0072374502196908, -0.017902852967381477, 0.048674069344997406, 0.05621891841292381, -0.0011647726641967893, 0.007376912049949169, 0.00813609454780817, 0.004127864725887775, 0.03740737587213516, -0.034515850245952606, -0.0027365083806216717, 0.07073505967855453, -0.031187675893306732, -0.028954558074474335, 0.02202090620994568, 0.011786048300564289, 0.037050697952508926, 0.010121802799403667, 0.01361068245023489, -0.06405927240848541, 0.011940659023821354, -0.07267746329307556, 0.028331227600574493, -0.013216518796980381, 0.010144436731934547, 0.004038035869598389, -0.030788134783506393, 0.025492558255791664, -0.005390062462538481, 0.027414636686444283, 0.038730837404727936, 0.020629726350307465, -0.03896370157599449, 0.008809520862996578, 0.00938334409147501, -0.026668308302760124, 0.000722213473636657, 0.0012582277413457632, 0.018214428797364235, -0.011019323021173477, 0.03306782990694046, -0.050353627651929855, 0.016264721751213074, -0.021316740661859512, 0.01048547774553299, -0.06643104553222656, -0.004952393006533384, 0.03317682072520256, 0.025629693642258644, 0.04659906029701233, -0.03828875720500946, 0.00725803105160594, 0.02061031572520733, -0.03000282123684883, -0.019284337759017944, -0.010895931161940098, -0.034286078065633774, -0.025169281288981438, 0.007521413266658783, -0.02389044314622879, 0.04335019737482071, 0.024159306660294533, 0.02665741741657257, 0.01806764304637909, 0.01018520351499319, 0.008490946143865585, -0.04618954285979271, -0.009601619094610214, -0.005676359869539738, 0.0030046056490391493, -0.04276638850569725, 0.04499250277876854, -0.02675512805581093, -0.020361004397273064, 0.04683884605765343, 0.0029638209380209446, 0.003803508123382926, 0.01561920065432787, 0.030151458457112312, 0.006815657019615173, 0.039715781807899475, 0.032962165772914886, -0.001472601667046547, 0.024998657405376434, 0.013650110922753811, 0.022080594673752785, 0.03197703883051872, -0.02659853920340538, 0.021574774757027626, 0.010462794452905655, 0.0005733378347940743, -0.05032068118453026, 0.004585305228829384, -0.032362908124923706, -0.03707011789083481, 0.001881454256363213, 0.026959283277392387, 0.018896184861660004, -0.03253233805298805, 0.037418119609355927, -0.034086693078279495, -0.009878464974462986, 0.06891244649887085, 0.0031247201841324568, -0.03642573580145836, 0.012345944531261921, -0.0076011414639651775, -0.058644089847803116, 0.03217709809541702, 0.032082803547382355, -0.017029481008648872, -0.07508692145347595, -0.03989461436867714, 0.03589119762182236, -0.037169188261032104, -0.0005891278269700706, -0.004628731869161129, -0.029840359464287758, 0.023825982585549355, -0.009097760543227196, 0.008715257979929447, -0.004857104737311602, -0.02942791022360325, 0.004230485763400793, -0.07552018761634827, 0.055762745440006256, 0.008716249838471413, -0.025683436542749405, -0.008952910080552101, 0.010779413394629955, -0.04777524247765541, -0.02443157508969307, 0.04560002312064171, 0.0105995899066329, 0.002315426478162408, -0.003045799909159541, 0.035089652985334396, -0.004529600031673908, -0.032015543431043625, 0.0660381093621254, 0.008759582415223122, -0.028527578338980675, -0.01991438679397106, -0.024215741083025932, -0.0027469617780297995, 0.006106612738221884, 0.013536306098103523, -0.015610119327902794, 0.021995551884174347, -0.02535998821258545, -0.004339956678450108, 0.03556855022907257, 0.03186718747019768, -0.010411999188363552, 0.040706533938646317, 0.001449288334697485, 0.03731616958975792, 0.05209380388259888, -0.002586694899946451, -0.050424471497535706, -0.0011993119260296226, -0.013022205792367458, -0.005824150983244181, -0.042782898992300034, 0.02436004765331745, 0.013330613262951374, -0.03352000191807747, 0.00034099770709872246, 0.030403809621930122, -0.00701226107776165, -0.0298894215375185, 0.029210079461336136, 0.0285173412412405, 0.012776629999279976, 0.006914386060088873, -0.005681904032826424, 0.02593439631164074, -0.008042930625379086, 0.011190755292773247, 0.033092793077230453, 0.06107760965824127, 0.019842201843857765, -0.015356067568063736, 0.030047208070755005, -0.011192924343049526, 0.023038694635033607, -0.02383582293987274, 0.023658331483602524, -0.039760466665029526, -0.014079760760068893, -0.027496883645653725, -0.03870562091469765, 0.010935191996395588, -0.02382492832839489, -0.022070612758398056, 0.04627867043018341, -0.05621311068534851, -0.001288332394324243, -0.011181306093931198, 0.01590752601623535, -0.03261488303542137, -0.029723120853304863, -0.003380939131602645, 0.006282734218984842, 0.026550818234682083, -0.019445830956101418, -0.03354288637638092, -0.014300398528575897, 0.006628161761909723, -0.04603568837046623, 0.024247677996754646, -0.003367344383150339, -0.0120256831869483, -0.039443474262952805, -0.0276926439255476, -0.04643584415316582, -0.04840195178985596, 0.03838009014725685, 0.016784949228167534, 0.01780606247484684, -0.012713008560240269, -0.053609173744916916, -0.013136353343725204, 0.05104720592498779, -0.09845948219299316, -0.006409056019037962, -0.031170615926384926, 0.028192643076181412, -0.004795561544597149, 0.023124700412154198 ]
<p>I know I can subdivide a dataset by socio-demographic factors such as gender, age, income level etc. and analyse the responses for each set separately and then compare the results.</p> <p>For example, I am testing the relationship between Variable A (hours of study) and Variable B (exam marks), and I have a dataset made up of 400 students. I have subdivided the dataset by gender and have 220 male students and 180 female students. I can run Pearson correlation on hours of study and exam marks separately for male students and for female students.</p> <p>While the above is fairly straight forward, my difficulty is in dividing my dataset by a factor that is not a socio-economic factor. I want to divide my dataset by two locations as follows:</p> <ul> <li>School (hours of study vs. exam marks)</li> <li>Home (hours of study vs. exam marks)</li> </ul> <p>To do this, I included a simple statement in my questionnaire that asked "where do you generally do most of your assignments?". The answer is either "home" (coded as "1") or "school" (coded as "2"). </p> <p>This is a forced statement and I have deliberately made this nominal coding to avoid correlating it with the two variables I am testing. In my mind (which is not very statistically-orientated!), this statement functions like the socio-demograhic factors as above i.e. is a constant because I have deliberately coded it that way. </p> <p>At the end of the day, and depending on my findings, I want to say something like "The relationship between hours of study and exam marks is stronger for students who completed their assignments in school".</p> <p>Is this a risky approach?</p>
73,534
[ -0.02911347895860672, 0.021683352068066597, 0.006658526603132486, 0.016529632732272148, 0.030530240386724472, 0.035748351365327835, 0.011132333427667618, -0.011911774054169655, 0.07573898136615753, -0.009699145331978798, 0.03012183867394924, 0.024215880781412125, 0.05410108342766762, 0.03317805752158165, 0.02988559566438198, -0.0016861523035913706, 0.027294887229800224, -0.00120282091666013, -0.011947651393711567, -0.028601255267858505, 0.004937577992677689, 0.01696034148335457, 0.02094278298318386, -0.026303991675376892, -0.000855875841807574, 0.05010129511356354, -0.006031275726854801, -0.05828887224197388, -0.00031725881854072213, 0.029368804767727852, -0.03025074303150177, -0.0636645182967186, 0.007939617149531841, -0.004626221023499966, 0.04769471287727356, 0.009226594120264053, -0.03457135707139969, -0.014820288866758347, 0.010892930440604687, 0.03196066990494728, -0.046568065881729126, -0.013342593796551228, 0.007262322586029768, 0.06327489018440247, -0.009260798804461956, 0.03857245296239853, 0.022120727226138115, 0.004692853894084692, 0.01871328614652157, -0.024295100942254066, 0.07013589888811111, -0.0096508814021945, 0.03489698842167854, 0.043539419770240784, -0.029578670859336853, 0.005106278229504824, 0.02341890148818493, 0.03602631017565727, -0.04679758846759796, -0.042989857494831085, -0.03651370108127594, -0.02600194327533245, -0.020938364788889885, 0.010593509301543236, -0.025643015280365944, -0.03668234124779701, -0.014465252868831158, 0.02541160210967064, 0.03159322962164879, -0.020592153072357178, 0.022933639585971832, 0.045221783220767975, 0.05082111433148384, -0.007156836334615946, 0.005835851188749075, -0.030950231477618217, 0.04427378252148628, 0.024030867964029312, 0.05129905417561531, 0.026230568066239357, 0.014752461574971676, -0.019195113331079483, 0.0052620661444962025, 0.026567809283733368, 0.041738055646419525, -0.023111656308174133, 0.05215451866388321, -0.025486040860414505, -0.019775262102484703, 0.04415437579154968, 0.012724860571324825, 0.009287083521485329, 0.06301209330558777, 0.0542338602244854, -0.025333981961011887, 0.0421796590089798, -0.036143332719802856, 0.020997093990445137, 0.002030389616265893, 0.021798834204673767, -0.027610067278146744, -0.03157388046383858, 0.019760603085160255, 0.045961346477270126, -0.030612748116254807, -0.0162928719073534, -0.01614193618297577, -0.017526281997561455, 0.0006734932539984584, -0.0582999587059021, -0.028254959732294083, 0.01702882908284664, -0.0034589010756462812, 0.04072554409503937, 0.03552648052573204, -0.0407174788415432, -0.014506885781884193, -0.007057831156998873, 0.0058420621789991856, 0.09131447225809097, 0.0213624220341444, -0.03933226317167282, 0.030575722455978394, -0.020895227789878845, -0.07110145688056946, 0.032807495445013046, 0.007845061831176281, -0.011017165146768093, 0.003209329443052411, 0.02420038916170597, -0.002148822881281376, -0.014018874615430832, 0.022148776799440384, -0.017364131286740303, 0.01081443578004837, 0.02736741304397583, -0.10713128745555878, -0.03986934572458267, 0.0022020635660737753, 0.05440898239612579, 0.009334111586213112, -0.03599698096513748, 0.010661360807716846, 0.011174921877682209, 0.04207199066877365, 0.006462953053414822, 0.03707844763994217, -0.01049142237752676, 0.015674343332648277, 0.02220834419131279, -0.04501933231949806, -0.033965326845645905, 0.017000757157802582, -0.010223804973065853, -0.007522510830312967, -0.06827907264232635, 0.01834256947040558, 0.046178098767995834, 0.011065900325775146, -0.0070944251492619514, 0.03674346208572388, -0.010049626231193542, -0.03578321635723114, 0.038169559091329575, -0.004180502612143755, -0.00919434055685997, 0.06168533116579056, 0.005311437416821718, 0.04056888818740845, 0.01777702197432518, -0.0016144025139510632, -0.002477973699569702, 0.01160658523440361, 0.04105570167303085, 0.04604196175932884, -0.004797391593456268, 0.000053243336878949776, -0.03634287416934967, 0.01609407551586628, -0.014042886905372143, -0.009889304637908936, -0.032506681978702545, -0.04280158877372742, -0.011937667615711689, 0.03812992945313454, 0.043501049280166626, 0.034906066954135895, -0.020443743094801903, 0.04880782961845398, -0.05454779043793678, -0.06934349983930588, -0.04073359817266464, 0.02826320193707943, -0.057546403259038925, -0.030445124953985214, -0.0069405571557581425, -0.025989389047026634, 0.016000039875507355, -0.011386263184249401, -0.03827355429530144, -0.028662143275141716, -0.006424992810934782, 0.04229965806007385, -0.021740220487117767, -0.0015409266343340278, 0.013720627874135971, 0.00733274407684803, 0.004506138153374195, 0.008776678703725338, -0.05016666278243065, -0.02031444013118744, 0.025438135489821434, -0.04016701877117157, 0.045160990208387375, -0.010143271647393703, -0.026581846177577972, 0.0011582276783883572, 0.02163357473909855, -0.041101980954408646, 0.027369506657123566, -0.06822100281715393, 0.08633331954479218, 0.08280091732740402, -0.02329120971262455, 0.02037329599261284, -0.009670841507613659, 0.03388053551316261, 0.020739147439599037, -0.02859797328710556, -0.019232889637351036, -0.039476435631513596, -0.0006368168396875262, 0.025584828108549118, -0.03846673667430878, -0.01669974997639656, 0.03345124050974846, 0.06183630973100662, -0.005853153765201569, -0.03612895682454109, 0.014177666045725346, 0.0035017800983041525, 0.009190118871629238, 0.008539479225873947, 0.0035268887877464294, 0.02296293154358864, 0.031583234667778015, 0.01796027272939682, -0.0065710884518921375, 0.01666361466050148, -0.01618366315960884, 0.0331725999712944, 0.050162963569164276, -0.0013483711518347263, 0.007126374635845423, 0.01558903232216835, -0.01083347387611866, 0.02622738666832447, -0.03555965796113014, 0.012361738830804825, 0.04310973361134529, -0.014950016513466835, -0.027867909520864487, 0.030499935150146484, -0.05243554711341858, 0.014544026926159859, 0.05313091352581978, -0.0505896732211113, 0.021487990394234657, 0.02169485203921795, -0.037003472447395325, -0.01099997479468584, -0.006651562172919512, -0.016843851655721664, -0.0361965037882328, -0.006564396433532238, 0.05946601554751396, 0.0015801340341567993, 0.03169539198279381, -0.03932821378111839, 0.023389505222439766, -0.01821666955947876, -0.03098527155816555, 0.026340587064623833, -0.020416414365172386, -0.06016060709953308, -0.01982082426548004, 0.0068513937294483185, -0.01979636214673519, 0.0008881796384230256, -0.017170537263154984, -0.012533674947917461, 0.014907073229551315, 0.011788537725806236, -0.03488688915967941, -0.033149801194667816, -0.03952459990978241, -0.019850991666316986, -0.01462541799992323, 0.0019497615285217762, 0.040564242750406265, -0.003083944320678711, -0.04240987077355385, -0.015375286340713501, -0.00805345457047224, -0.01746358908712864, -0.015418265014886856, -0.030449679121375084, -0.008617062121629715, 0.03369675576686859, -0.015517042018473148, 0.02219117246568203, 0.018052654340863228, -0.022378291934728622, -0.08690964430570602, -0.06242934614419937, 0.01233624666929245, 0.018628273159265518, 0.027065515518188477, -0.004524428863078356, -0.004273111000657082, 0.055291179567575455, 0.023319242522120476, -0.028349466621875763, -0.05762697756290436, -0.02675718441605568, -0.025881465524435043, -0.04065031558275223, 0.023853695020079613, 0.01475710142403841, 0.018949829041957855, 0.02757326513528824, -0.0034762402065098286, 0.03963443636894226, 0.01810741052031517, 0.024583891034126282, 0.005252603441476822, 0.028725896030664444, -0.001880267052911222, -0.015044187195599079, 0.04225962236523628, 0.06333993375301361, -0.05647696182131767, -0.032396163791418076, -0.009261718951165676, 0.00963148009032011, 0.04147222265601158, -0.04600635915994644, -0.006498553324490786, -0.022085482254624367, -0.0032442372757941484, -0.06202636659145355, 0.0010073032462969422, 0.039933670312166214, -0.028302205726504326, 0.0013786451891064644, 0.03343416377902031, 0.04262819141149521, -0.03176966682076454, -0.003928499761968851, 0.06491122394800186, 0.05597234517335892, 0.028570506721735, -0.02489946410059929, -0.021296348422765732, 0.03441016748547554, 0.029556233435869217, -0.04801163449883461, -0.02353181317448616, 0.04641999304294586, 0.027511287480592728, 0.04005693271756172, -0.008119810372591019, -0.06496962159872055, 0.029441801831126213, -0.09354865550994873, -0.020157890394330025, -0.02822997234761715, 0.0530409999191761, 0.0386054702103138, 0.0019056573510169983, 0.041332412511110306, -0.02889242023229599, -0.030893493443727493, 0.027672553434967995, -0.036419857293367386, -0.003867826424539089, 0.014667904935777187, -0.0016551344888284802, 0.04509944096207619, -0.02979772351682186, -0.01195309218019247, -0.026891645044088364, -0.02698667161166668, 0.021804334595799446, 0.008317873813211918, -0.01816565729677677, 0.0016942000947892666, -0.017276594415307045, -0.020994700491428375, 0.001405511749908328, 0.014718381687998772, 0.01655360870063305, 0.006722067017108202, 0.010985605418682098, 0.03192237764596939, 0.028986308723688126, -0.007087664678692818, -0.014647386968135834, 0.014020673930644989, 0.02656620368361473, 0.04524822533130646, -0.01885657198727131, 0.009260092861950397, -0.05247639864683151, 0.023710012435913086, 0.008259953930974007, -0.004825684241950512, 0.04080667346715927, -0.06521271169185638, -0.018076885491609573, 0.05254092067480087, 0.009446182288229465, 0.01065748743712902, 0.018095629289746284, -0.00024372378538828343, 0.014691471122205257, 0.034006137400865555, 0.0558151938021183, -0.047096073627471924, 0.01296869944781065, 0.07948358356952667, 0.019215533509850502, 0.01987757533788681, -0.03556200861930847, -0.011861966922879219, 0.01774030178785324, -0.014173413626849651, -0.014416548423469067, 0.02153216488659382, 0.01805257424712181, 0.01788746565580368, 0.05520886927843094, -0.02302139438688755, -0.009057119488716125, 0.0635613277554512, -0.009526454843580723, 0.034991294145584106, 0.005220687482506037, -0.06014172360301018, 0.013395224697887897, 0.047679319977760315, 0.04204979166388512, 0.024316677823662758, -0.027907254174351692, -0.11752860248088837, -0.014028958044946194, 0.026173822581768036, 0.028834601864218712, 0.019836775958538055, -0.020685752853751183, -0.0012720100348815322, -0.01672876626253128, 0.03333821892738342, -0.05004292353987694, 0.012090264819562435, -0.030607104301452637, 0.0255209319293499, -0.02164236083626747, -0.023332087323069572, -0.05413927882909775, 0.024364130571484566, 0.007526865229010582, 0.02565331943333149, 0.02969685196876526, -0.07522948086261749, -0.05421563982963562, 0.03417845815420151, 0.0077775875106453896, 0.04592210426926613, -0.03749687969684601, -0.044531937688589096, -0.019108887761831284, -0.01519855484366417, 0.008304997347295284, -0.04828937351703644, -0.0012238151393830776, 0.01730906032025814, 0.004602021537721157, 0.05908236652612686, 0.015492677688598633, -0.0276530422270298, -0.004709657747298479, -0.012953490950167179, -0.019887927919626236, 0.020614584907889366, -0.017949864268302917, 0.07589167356491089, 0.01564495638012886, 0.012601364403963089, 0.037158966064453125, 0.018239468336105347, 0.0024795616045594215, 0.04861591383814812, -0.056356675922870636, -0.0032993252389132977, -0.006601280998438597, 0.014758901670575142, -0.035738442093133926, -0.0003979309112764895, -0.010626784525811672, 0.009006990119814873, -0.00663670152425766, 0.01715240627527237, -0.06670233607292175, -0.01887868344783783, -0.04014718160033226, 0.015916302800178528, -0.007596381939947605, -0.0050829388201236725, 0.012187165208160877, 0.010194185189902782, 0.0017485686112195253, -0.024760156869888306, 0.028147263452410698, -0.03973666578531265, -0.0011749322293326259, 0.009093102067708969, -0.005345366429537535, 0.023783162236213684, -0.028035804629325867, -0.02315566875040531, 0.007530001923441887, -0.0029483595862984657, 0.004509143065661192, 0.02848442643880844, 0.036256615072488785, -0.010305250994861126, -0.02400398626923561, 0.017645902931690216, 0.0173261146992445, -0.008088480681180954, 0.003917111083865166, 0.0009219730854965746, 0.036586012691259384, -0.01677316427230835, -0.011637147516012192, -0.07194515317678452, -0.03165777027606964, -0.0004164257843513042, -0.0017621550941839814, 0.0014511346817016602, -0.02704879455268383, 0.012254679575562477, -0.005196044687181711, -0.014304574579000473, -0.01516896765679121, 0.05651428923010826, -0.08050978183746338, -0.0016745002940297127, -0.018149403855204582, 0.015570953488349915, 0.04006415605545044, -0.018068857491016388, 0.019763698801398277, -0.015711085870862007, 0.016266951337456703, 0.0034450229723006487, 0.0003726842696778476, -0.029562778770923615, -0.03621301054954529, -0.030183425173163414, -0.035372402518987656, 0.01263193879276514, 0.05330177769064903, -0.0005964037263765931, -0.009509020484983921, -0.01904282532632351, -0.04213155806064606, 0.015474922023713589, -0.002848513424396515, 0.011363483034074306, 0.010920100845396519, 0.017340365797281265, -0.03063158504664898, 0.0583651028573513, -0.04352746158838272, 0.0103434007614851, 0.014626489020884037, 0.014899877831339836, -0.022412531077861786, 0.029157310724258423, 0.05278036743402481, -0.024587642401456833, 0.012120264582335949, 0.02856536954641342, -0.018244249746203423, 0.028800206258893013, 0.03973815217614174, 0.004344253800809383, -0.01004103198647499, -0.0021565775386989117, -0.028844716027379036, -0.017087286338210106, -0.006995832547545433, -0.022625042125582695, 0.06061730533838272, 0.0029258758295327425, 0.027011677622795105, 0.04145610332489014, 0.024043818935751915, 0.031574007123708725, -0.025894396007061005, 0.009808013215661049, -0.011815818957984447, -0.009397937916219234, 0.06732193380594254, -0.010517805814743042, -0.027081232517957687, 0.03759049251675606, 0.0637824684381485, 0.008074844256043434, 0.04001820459961891, 0.026296725496649742, 0.0072576687671244144, 0.017614955082535744, -0.012882223352789879, -0.05707232281565666, -0.00927348155528307, -0.04632936790585518, -0.016791513189673424, -0.0632508397102356, -0.03605923056602478, 0.011919736862182617, 0.035465095192193985, -0.019691772758960724, -0.07081146538257599, -0.025989767163991928, -0.03004867024719715, 0.022811587899923325, 0.016362888738512993, -0.05359596386551857, 0.020924128592014313, -0.003582844976335764, 0.05755425617098808, -0.031804025173187256, -0.002626309171319008, -0.05248075723648071, -0.061057936400175095, -0.04045930504798889, -0.033318210393190384, -0.05457320436835289, 0.023660490289330482, -0.036825794726610184, -0.025805067270994186, 0.027068031951785088, -0.03269476071000099, 0.03557944670319557, 0.004350446164608002, -0.0029621622525155544, 0.0032366393133997917, 0.03052443265914917, -0.0082740169018507, -0.005726747680455446, -0.00464339554309845, -0.029148129746317863, 0.13088878989219666, 0.06840333342552185, 0.059995945543050766, -0.055925313383340836, 0.0028919305186718702, 0.013210893608629704, -0.0017775652231648564, -0.007939818315207958, 0.0011247135698795319, 0.03210170567035675, -0.020347101613879204, 0.08783072978258133, 0.07795332372188568, 0.033775970339775085, 0.012657368555665016, 0.044794678688049316, -0.023671245202422142, 0.02194424346089363, -0.00196556537412107, 0.013676299713551998, 0.016902925446629524, -0.03582746908068657, -0.02644549123942852, -0.005445242393761873, 0.033697839826345444, 0.005944899749010801, -0.024808790534734726, -0.025811225175857544, 0.02394712343811989, 0.033470187336206436, -0.05310865119099617, 0.009828473441302776, 0.028312912210822105, 0.0416683703660965, -0.0005701190093532205, -0.03435312584042549, 0.016316300258040428, -0.024540895596146584, -0.0016038477187976241, -0.0120925297960639, -0.015137127600610256, -0.011277448385953903, 0.023822331801056862, -0.003865994745865464, -0.07255887240171432, -0.015594529919326305, -0.03093717060983181, 0.010417073033750057, -0.033785752952098846, -0.06599856913089752, -0.012617378495633602, 0.03894031420350075, 0.03765567019581795, -0.015369516797363758, -0.01682877168059349, 0.04071427509188652, 0.01369214616715908, -0.02572821080684662, 0.004090006463229656, -0.015276892110705376, 0.012802373617887497, 0.009004074148833752, 0.03754403442144394, 0.029023706912994385, 0.0001249868655577302, -0.03947168216109276, -0.0344502218067646, 0.035200219601392746, 0.017484150826931, -0.012388844974339008, -0.006743141449987888, -0.005971150938421488, -0.030049623921513557, 0.008391004987061024, 0.0002903822169173509, 0.0032270639203488827, -0.02677832543849945, -0.019327852874994278, -0.0015709275612607598, -0.03975865989923477, 0.03926008194684982, -0.008987725712358952, -0.012607524171471596, -0.025178512558341026, -0.019348053261637688, -0.003073186846449971, -0.016153991222381592, 0.03311759978532791, 0.02782469429075718, 0.006203303579241037, 0.004819382913410664, 0.0682690292596817, 0.011899682693183422, -0.06526180356740952, -0.054906368255615234, -0.0405915193259716, -0.031150605529546738, 0.005880667362362146, -0.011877670884132385, 0.024985479190945625, -0.010770129039883614, 0.023550234735012054, -0.0044629210606217384, 0.00632286025211215, -0.024583397433161736, 0.051354069262742996, 0.01592716947197914, -0.05845073610544205, -0.009447192773222923, 0.0056565129198133945, -0.011528539471328259, -0.014912731945514679, -0.008639191277325153, -0.033436067402362823, -0.022840583696961403, 0.008829507045447826, -0.025703418999910355, -0.01363866776227951, 0.017189109697937965, -0.007769562304019928, 0.005571282934397459, -0.06684695184230804, 0.007686445489525795, -0.030294694006443024, -0.007056897506117821, -0.0027782071847468615, -0.016024552285671234, 0.018281543627381325, 0.01687309518456459, 0.013794191181659698, 0.04439448565244675, 0.03971986472606659, 0.026068197563290596, 0.00010904988448601216, -0.015724658966064453, 0.03162994235754013, 0.022433971986174583, 0.040752433240413666, -0.003218606347218156, 0.0010206798324361444, 0.021638939157128334, -0.002061741892248392, -0.026771659031510353, 0.02946745976805687, -0.008947241120040417, 0.04784753546118736, 0.007386682089418173, 0.0227709598839283, -0.00191929517313838, 0.05988062918186188, -0.008524809964001179, -0.04104665666818619, 0.008927269838750362, 0.022784529253840446, 0.04782041162252426, -0.022306889295578003, -0.017731454223394394, -0.01309776958078146, -0.015145068056881428, 0.032002005726099014, 0.02985869161784649, 0.04828527942299843, -0.030983716249465942, 0.01134418323636055, -0.030695397406816483, -0.014478134922683239, 0.0043648602440953255, -0.02014782838523388, 0.02348434180021286, 0.024613307788968086, -0.04754355177283287, 0.007586236111819744, 0.010855909436941147, 0.017170103266835213, -0.05542420223355293, -0.04994060844182968, 0.011823813430964947, -0.025256244465708733, 0.012177130207419395, -0.03566163033246994, 0.009739421308040619, 0.010658432729542255, -0.06613031029701233, 0.038942012935876846, -0.010768226347863674, 0.006453201174736023, -0.005175279453396797, 0.040251750499010086, -0.03656119480729103, 0.005388730205595493, 0.04293958097696304, 0.027680478990077972, 0.009697835892438889, 0.03271577134728432, 0.006076366640627384, -0.056207817047834396, -0.009874189272522926, -0.02915891632437706, -0.010949415154755116, -0.07580515742301941, 0.06855560839176178, -0.007930075749754906, -0.024315377697348595, 0.04213428869843483, -0.040401507169008255, 0.012823488563299179, 0.03981955721974373, 0.01891380548477173, -0.0043670195154845715, 0.037046607583761215, 0.02376438118517399, 0.005401083268225193, -0.01809260994195938, 0.0033495512325316668, 0.03488800674676895, 0.029233774170279503, -0.028345497325062752, -0.020377913489937782, 0.008335511200129986, -0.002410191111266613, -0.013384902849793434, 0.041699185967445374, -0.009333581663668156, 0.02149139903485775, -0.03025432489812374, -0.0003582898643799126, 0.03961510211229324, -0.021293919533491135, 0.03253977373242378, -0.05345592647790909, -0.00944305770099163, 0.022420713678002357, 0.023799322545528412, -0.014649701304733753, 0.01485652755945921, 0.0005949769401922822, -0.04495348781347275, -0.02511339634656906, 0.020171256735920906, -0.007573932874947786, -0.02119118720293045, -0.028643978759646416, -0.008116479031741619, -0.0021204757504165173, -0.008727801963686943, 0.015252147801220417, 0.02309485338628292, 0.019381701946258545, 0.0030777815263718367, 0.010895639657974243, 0.024555763229727745, -0.010338393971323967, 0.014310862869024277, -0.0808943435549736, 0.05538587272167206, 0.022922277450561523, -0.012391332536935806, -0.03470420464873314, -0.009699461050331593, -0.07537882775068283, -0.019659392535686493, 0.07752041518688202, 0.017201267182826996, 0.042284589260816574, -0.02398764155805111, 0.011787701398134232, -0.011397955939173698, -0.022730916738510132, 0.04258999601006508, -0.006362963002175093, -0.009319130331277847, 0.01030984241515398, 0.0001909903367049992, 0.0037702913396060467, -0.019410893321037292, -0.00945936981588602, 0.014426494017243385, 0.022235868498682976, 0.016924608498811722, -0.015289911068975925, -0.01952379010617733, -0.0033726159017533064, -0.004914990160614252, 0.016466036438941956, 0.0029270267114043236, -0.0033836327493190765, 0.04755222052335739, -0.02965044043958187, -0.05363287031650543, 0.027993064373731613, -0.004269295837730169, -0.014451947994530201, -0.004012614488601685, 0.04179304465651512, -0.009836153127253056, -0.03898664936423302, -0.005178597755730152, 0.028254199773073196, -0.02842850424349308, -0.03231612220406532, -0.013468611985445023, 0.0095741655677557, 0.03236641362309456, -0.020400095731019974, 0.025261858478188515, 0.020124638453125954, -0.04024166613817215, 0.033250246196985245, -0.01641051471233368, 0.041401177644729614, 0.013582302257418633, 0.015238020569086075, 0.051837846636772156, -0.014333990402519703, 0.03944094106554985, -0.03482522815465927, 0.05076880753040314, -0.005026411265134811, -0.0045593855902552605, 0.022653862833976746, 0.018389053642749786, -0.016461392864584923, 0.02326597087085247, -0.00013432506239041686, 0.023645134642720222, -0.0021113099064677954, -0.01960567757487297, -0.04509342089295387, -0.021393578499555588, -0.04958458989858627, 0.013038842007517815, 0.04301314055919647, 0.024655302986502647, 0.01713230088353157, -0.0019080976489931345, -0.010156707838177681, -0.05995159596204758, -0.009764960035681725, 0.0004331809759605676, 0.028666682541370392, -0.026561686769127846, 0.003813405055552721, -0.007686221972107887, 0.004373823758214712, -0.0670495256781578, -0.012324539944529533, 0.06165164336562157, 0.018970461562275887, 0.027929238975048065, -0.02181309647858143, -0.025229908525943756, 0.027234910055994987, 0.04030022770166397, -0.05982368066906929, -0.053040821105241776, -0.011734772473573685, 0.012341498397290707, 0.013333519920706749, -0.023801740258932114 ]
<p>I am completely new to R, just downloaded and installed it today. I am familiar with SAS and Stata; I am using R because I have found out that in survey regression analysis, R is capable of using data that have stratum with one PSU. However, I cannot figure out how to write the code at all.</p> <p>Here is what I have done so far: read a Stata dataset and save the .RData file. I have also put in the MASS, pscl, and survey (for svyglm) packages.</p> <p>Here's what I need to do: 1) I am using survey data, so I have a "weight" variable, a "strata" variable, and a "PSU" variable. I need to incorporate those; I know how to use svyset in Stata, but no idea in R. 2) I have stratum with singleton PSUs. I need to use an option called survey.lonely.psu I believe, and I have no idea where to even begin with that. This is the reason why I am using R instead of Stata as I do not want to collapse stratum or delete observations. 3) The types of regression models I have to run: survey negative binomial, survey zero-inflated negative binomial (need to also determine the predictors of zeros), survey logistic, and survey OLS regression. 4)I also really can't make much sense in R of how to write the model in R code. In Stata, I can simply write the model as:</p> <p>svy: nbreg dependent_var independent_var1 independent_var2 independent_var3</p> <p>I can't figure out how to do that at all in R.</p> <p>Any and all help will be greatly appreciated.</p>
35,931
[ -0.016201695427298546, -0.01924186386168003, -0.022610506042838097, 0.03053733892738819, 0.010699940845370293, -0.043213024735450745, -0.002501208335161209, 0.00016920079360716045, 0.0814388319849968, -0.03366255387663841, 0.03519657999277115, 0.035701051354408264, 0.04595628380775452, 0.007575587835162878, 0.004932842683047056, -0.011330492794513702, -0.03176401928067207, -0.008343778550624847, 0.012476859614253044, 0.021539639681577682, 0.0016306099714711308, -0.02438684180378914, 0.03753919526934624, 0.02556951716542244, -0.015388207510113716, 0.08284104615449905, 0.020396433770656586, -0.018350981175899506, -0.001818187301978469, 0.058808211237192154, -0.026321161538362503, -0.011641114950180054, -0.017661938443779945, 0.030216781422495842, 0.047745488584041595, 0.012226051650941372, -0.041872404515743256, -0.006737148389220238, -0.007014064118266106, 0.039220865815877914, -0.03252615034580231, -0.0317220464348793, 0.014850758016109467, 0.01339222677052021, -0.0037450429517775774, 0.003777754260227084, -0.0014007514109835029, -0.01625501923263073, 0.06777741014957428, -0.05485223978757858, 0.04219492897391319, 0.010142941027879715, 0.029147474095225334, 0.03882895037531853, -0.009587733075022697, -0.008616680279374123, 0.050137221813201904, 0.06287048757076263, -0.0059388200752437115, -0.04425150156021118, -0.018698031082749367, -0.004502579569816589, -0.032308414578437805, -0.048099879175424576, -0.0579851008951664, 0.01640411466360092, 0.004872202407568693, -0.00174265808891505, 0.06946156173944473, -0.02777259796857834, 0.025117501616477966, 0.01763254962861538, 0.008094233460724354, -0.0102787334471941, 0.010968266054987907, -0.05708620697259903, -0.002101046731695533, 0.014102011919021606, 0.026901980862021446, 0.027541927993297577, 0.002555486047640443, 0.014139498583972454, -0.013643239624798298, 0.04104621335864067, 0.006488679908216, -0.012865247204899788, 0.049831707030534744, -0.003701159032061696, 0.046820268034935, 0.00016995382611639798, -0.02321731299161911, 0.01256696879863739, 0.07646625488996506, 0.01589406467974186, -0.020930496975779533, 0.06285205483436584, 0.003791029565036297, 0.06967687606811523, 0.010654094628989697, 0.012765629217028618, 0.030796311795711517, -0.03257950022816658, 0.001868557883426547, 0.07309027761220932, -0.05238087847828865, -0.011167262680828571, -0.009759141132235527, 0.01907295361161232, -0.000713579764124006, -0.06955695152282715, -0.0053824312053620815, 0.0019787875935435295, 0.009866544976830482, -0.05354493856430054, 0.013411274179816246, -0.033735524863004684, -0.02126135490834713, -0.031957533210515976, 0.018219970166683197, 0.04902781546115875, 0.035441506654024124, -0.04110965505242348, 0.05557185783982277, -0.045150406658649445, -0.07913587987422943, 0.01490892842411995, 0.01768147386610508, -0.0030081206932663918, -0.06047637015581131, 0.05078282207250595, 0.0232582725584507, -0.041071392595767975, 0.07448159158229828, 0.011737960390746593, 0.01726413518190384, 0.008031688630580902, -0.05533146858215332, -0.07296697795391083, -0.0057006594724953175, -0.031463317573070526, 0.03724422678351402, -0.03858007863163948, -0.03370306268334389, -0.011765090748667717, 0.04753963276743889, -0.01130195427685976, 0.04306894913315773, 0.023156648501753807, 0.0559300035238266, -0.004733629059046507, -0.008825637400150299, -0.007734186947345734, -0.05976230651140213, -0.0151997534558177, -0.034663066267967224, -0.06132112815976143, 0.055171020328998566, 0.015453282743692398, -0.013287201523780823, -0.0277834665030241, 0.041794564574956894, 0.02600368857383728, 0.0029767032247036695, -0.0116807222366333, 0.022116877138614655, -0.018557269126176834, 0.049281008541584015, -0.017183756455779076, -0.015985803678631783, 0.04131535068154335, -0.01712455041706562, -0.0025852113030850887, 0.00902017392218113, 0.03566182404756546, 0.009704796597361565, -0.022180970758199692, -0.016235392540693283, -0.025857767090201378, -0.0006193601293489337, 0.029980449005961418, -0.03577880933880806, -0.02449456788599491, -0.0005501628038473427, -0.018076393753290176, 0.03784581273794174, 0.04801081120967865, 0.001761891064234078, 0.006184486672282219, 0.022792955860495567, -0.03210079297423363, -0.03903472423553467, -0.05338093265891075, 0.00714104063808918, 0.013573120348155499, 0.00322950491681695, 0.02078755386173725, 0.01997379958629608, 0.011434758082032204, 0.0201692096889019, 0.0002879949170164764, -0.028466392308473587, -0.0017613788368180394, 0.06396983563899994, 0.000868053815793246, -0.016437489539384842, 0.050830911844968796, 0.05042078346014023, -0.04739361256361008, 0.03139812499284744, -0.009056934155523777, -0.034176331013441086, 0.0038644778542220592, -0.004181942902505398, 0.019476929679512978, -0.012650980614125729, -0.0010401071049273014, 0.014373165555298328, 0.0016209796303883195, -0.0064679160714149475, 0.05068961903452873, -0.0870184451341629, 0.049724966287612915, 0.08398200571537018, 0.0023962953127920628, 0.00247202324680984, 0.017564842477440834, -0.027951274067163467, 0.03325541689991951, -0.050482600927352905, 0.028279965743422508, -0.04410110414028168, -0.006760809104889631, 0.02970709092915058, 0.011476225219666958, -0.01876024715602398, 0.011898146942257881, 0.07066317647695541, 0.0011619389988481998, 0.006901124492287636, 0.012533065862953663, -0.021261751651763916, 0.028474561870098114, 0.01940811239182949, 0.012911494821310043, 0.022837195545434952, 0.021121973171830177, 0.018508773297071457, 0.02860787697136402, 0.057421401143074036, 0.020258909091353416, -0.021935099735856056, 0.06364849209785461, 0.005169535055756569, 0.01295926608145237, -0.010652422904968262, 0.0005020709941163659, 0.06334500014781952, -0.004266111645847559, -0.004615703132003546, 0.05954925715923309, -0.0059500643983483315, -0.020462578162550926, -0.004869614727795124, -0.010778235271573067, -0.005622084718197584, 0.05455520376563072, -0.02843358740210533, 0.0031780179124325514, -0.0013299345737323165, -0.04906913638114929, 0.027177240699529648, 0.010702523402869701, -0.04861220344901085, -0.056092604994773865, 0.01620379276573658, 0.03305759280920029, 0.014317669905722141, 0.0029559864196926355, -0.01637018658220768, -0.05431615561246872, 0.026284262537956238, -0.01813666708767414, 0.032499492168426514, -0.0057020289823412895, -0.09106726199388504, -0.026589369401335716, -0.033548783510923386, -0.027762623503804207, 0.0153267290443182, 0.020428579300642014, -0.04404451325535774, 0.037817150354385376, -0.03436633571982384, -0.07325582951307297, -0.0179995559155941, -0.015114878304302692, -0.006814274005591869, -0.01339038461446762, -0.031575288623571396, 0.048188816756010056, 0.038432776927948, -0.016389500349760056, 0.002962751779705286, -0.07874731719493866, -0.006421556696295738, -0.02918156422674656, -0.013567425310611725, 0.006695406045764685, -0.02821536175906658, -0.0068900492042303085, 0.006360229104757309, -0.03388397395610809, -0.016329120844602585, -0.03943279758095741, -0.0196539219468832, -0.02125592529773712, 0.03253759816288948, 0.02088852785527706, -0.004643756430596113, 0.009966916404664516, 0.06925273686647415, 0.02683904580771923, -0.01725812442600727, -0.05705126374959946, 0.004749510902911425, -0.060570284724235535, 0.008224179968237877, 0.02906949445605278, -0.011653282679617405, 0.043994251638650894, -0.0052881622686982155, 0.027346868067979813, 0.004216034896671772, 0.02233033999800682, 0.016696302220225334, -0.015919189900159836, 0.025464268401265144, -0.022776151075959206, -0.01441105268895626, 0.0666123479604721, 0.015302401967346668, -0.02400103211402893, 0.024703994393348694, -0.026138372719287872, -0.0071151042357087135, -0.013162058778107166, -0.026827728375792503, -0.025722742080688477, -0.004913307726383209, -0.009913378395140171, -0.048516277223825455, -0.002904163207858801, 0.015524274669587612, -0.04006565362215042, 0.006608982104808092, -0.0173847246915102, 0.05331411212682724, -0.041099026799201965, -0.0299933273345232, 0.03609947860240936, 0.014199551194906235, -0.02673177793622017, -0.0032840692438185215, -0.003672247286885977, 0.007361604832112789, 0.0007566057029180229, -0.02653404325246811, 0.007494039833545685, 0.03013496845960617, 0.030972151085734367, 0.05169156566262245, -0.05837124213576317, -0.030078019946813583, 0.0401587076485157, -0.04681691154837608, 0.008320698514580727, 0.0013310038484632969, 0.06688424199819565, 0.018195729702711105, 0.02321791462600231, 0.018826855346560478, -0.03245845064520836, 0.017499785870313644, -0.03406001999974251, -0.06630463153123856, 0.020403288304805756, -0.02377111092209816, -0.008800307288765907, 0.018343474715948105, 0.01396945770829916, 0.014039631001651287, -0.007443788927048445, -0.016624806448817253, 0.0002240106405224651, 0.002780916402116418, -0.01876046136021614, -0.009475916624069214, -0.011019730940461159, -0.005293600261211395, 0.0008452682523056865, 0.02203361876308918, -0.021902715787291527, 0.007514490280300379, -0.005714671220630407, 0.05926339328289032, 0.001600755495019257, -0.003278457559645176, -0.019101573154330254, -0.0021989867091178894, 0.012246176600456238, 0.054398976266384125, 0.035734135657548904, 0.04941282421350479, -0.02809378318488598, 0.030736109241843224, 0.0040532262064516544, 0.02267601154744625, 0.051252152770757675, -0.01192269753664732, 0.010221721604466438, -0.018780944868922234, 0.015578467398881912, -0.016453206539154053, -0.01658693142235279, 0.013223223388195038, 0.024073220789432526, 0.07527371495962143, 0.012352373450994492, -0.03810559958219528, -0.017345011234283447, 0.05308946967124939, 0.020927226170897484, 0.02528955228626728, -0.030463382601737976, 0.012655956670641899, 0.003261372447013855, 0.026050690561532974, 0.012515213340520859, 0.010067329742014408, 0.0017114338697865605, -0.019868982955813408, 0.047941870987415314, 0.003988551441580057, -0.022593814879655838, 0.00454645324498415, 0.05206023529171944, 0.06085394695401192, -0.037542764097452164, -0.05392751470208168, 0.0037591473665088415, 0.04694903641939163, 0.0283367857336998, -0.03473566845059395, 0.005514209624379873, -0.10549983382225037, 0.0016261275159195065, 0.027342520654201508, 0.0480026938021183, -0.015051142312586308, -0.011312183924019337, -0.02559434436261654, -0.012136179022490978, 0.034841280430555344, -0.04070085287094116, 0.025877881795167923, -0.015964725986123085, 0.01764588989317417, 0.0036884790752083063, -0.022525642067193985, -0.04590647667646408, 0.013999603688716888, -0.04614919051527977, 0.04096240922808647, 0.010906132869422436, -0.039662983268499374, -0.039017222821712494, 0.03930501267313957, 0.005369189660996199, 0.05104425176978111, -0.0732998251914978, -0.03145094960927963, 0.049093592911958694, 0.04343441128730774, -0.004264357034116983, -0.04759783670306206, -0.009709172882139683, -0.0020538910757750273, -0.034656722098588943, 0.06509172916412354, 0.011921269819140434, -0.02767881192266941, -0.022555284202098846, 0.03692464157938957, 0.013721245341002941, 0.012730129063129425, -0.0540757030248642, -0.0018732266034930944, -0.010703313164412975, 0.003956597764045, 0.04641062021255493, 0.030454430729150772, -0.022999679669737816, 0.00017320153710898012, -0.04161464795470238, -0.014597819186747074, -0.000006927197773620719, -0.03345463424921036, -0.05530289560556412, -0.0013008259702473879, -0.005382203031331301, 0.01025152113288641, -0.0025246096774935722, 0.017299901694059372, -0.03460889682173729, 0.001503458945080638, 0.019349411129951477, 0.035347092896699905, -0.01740630529820919, -0.000883826520293951, -0.03363129496574402, 0.044920798391103745, -0.025462646037340164, -0.04296654090285301, 0.033143553882837296, -0.006064497400075197, 0.0009595432784408331, -0.025057105347514153, -0.05606599152088165, 0.020122472196817398, 0.0029714354313910007, -0.036807455122470856, 0.02478910982608795, -0.014186501502990723, 0.040482524782419205, -0.0031756749376654625, 0.05601789429783821, -0.011920391581952572, -0.03637233376502991, -0.012288599275052547, 0.0006956342840567231, -0.01468555349856615, -0.014276311732828617, -0.044221095740795135, 0.026281332597136497, -0.03013477474451065, -0.022031361237168312, -0.0847710594534874, -0.06751001626253128, 0.0004494634340517223, 0.003039846895262599, -0.014223122037947178, -0.04555779695510864, 0.016007646918296814, -0.0011909023160114884, -0.010311203077435493, 0.0012274105101823807, 0.0542435385286808, -0.030233709141612053, 0.006580752320587635, -0.01775180920958519, 0.033654287457466125, 0.06095575541257858, 0.011750420555472374, -0.009671109728515148, 0.0036832804325968027, -0.008267885074019432, -0.012406040914356709, 0.020069021731615067, -0.0003291151369921863, -0.027326304465532303, -0.010844089090824127, 0.0031996590550988913, 0.014255656860768795, 0.0514538548886776, -0.000648105051368475, -0.008061123080551624, -0.018374228850007057, -0.019345825538039207, 0.015943560749292374, -0.04221230000257492, 0.00822310522198677, -0.019288627430796623, 0.01578349620103836, -0.04522162675857544, -0.01170895341783762, -0.03103010542690754, 0.004604066256433725, 0.05043516308069229, -0.01041928306221962, 0.007180720567703247, 0.012510827742516994, 0.04893942549824715, 0.051205672323703766, 0.024476375430822372, 0.005272798705846071, 0.0011986989993602037, 0.059884462505578995, 0.0023514500353485346, -0.01140597928315401, 0.02471533976495266, 0.03802667185664177, -0.006589886732399464, -0.04702785611152649, -0.04741521179676056, 0.0002287039824295789, 0.06168412044644356, 0.003175612073391676, 0.0421878956258297, 0.014466107822954655, -0.020637858659029007, 0.027164116501808167, -0.061865806579589844, -0.01274685375392437, -0.007478560321033001, 0.03571035712957382, 0.038739245384931564, 0.012483510188758373, -0.009289010427892208, 0.06313172727823257, 0.047095686197280884, 0.045476675033569336, 0.03199557214975357, 0.03649666905403137, -0.008589772507548332, 0.03417982906103134, -0.048552777618169785, -0.025309279561042786, 0.0008384563261643052, -0.015103007666766644, 0.012135850265622139, -0.026051977649331093, -0.02951446920633316, 0.04385792836546898, 0.022055815905332565, 0.023526789620518684, -0.06754537671804428, -0.009176237508654594, -0.05283535644412041, 0.0073754871264100075, 0.016598181799054146, -0.02511783316731453, 0.03076918050646782, 0.00964291300624609, 0.00756579777225852, -0.0028733110520988703, 0.040759745985269547, -0.04082557186484337, -0.08675267547369003, -0.01967339962720871, -0.031725991517305374, -0.04560009762644768, 0.05452335998415947, 0.01922699809074402, -0.019736135378479958, 0.006464347243309021, -0.03431681916117668, 0.016000917181372643, -0.0023531001061201096, 0.027971144765615463, 0.008173570036888123, 0.05914044380187988, -0.027439706027507782, 0.031133651733398438, -0.02570674940943718, -0.0060125682502985, 0.14005719125270844, 0.07749126851558685, 0.055325496941804886, -0.06867443770170212, -0.013660783879458904, 0.028897851705551147, 0.013232409954071045, -0.003343573771417141, -0.010207242332398891, -0.01116679236292839, -0.060744352638721466, 0.07275363057851791, 0.03369094803929329, -0.00013613766350317746, 0.025148699060082436, 0.041887469589710236, -0.02308393083512783, -0.030515724793076515, -0.01839965395629406, -0.008122153580188751, -0.02111055515706539, -0.036518171429634094, -0.04000347480177879, 0.02012133039534092, -0.005786162801086903, -0.038813088089227676, -0.03418106213212013, -0.0068761673755943775, 0.00741136958822608, 0.010725749656558037, -0.002321493811905384, 0.009167509153485298, -0.00170095544308424, 0.029720298945903778, 0.018646240234375, -0.0234000775963068, 0.041965991258621216, -0.05302029103040695, 0.008897010236978531, 0.038770560175180435, -0.026321670040488243, 0.006965703796595335, -0.011045332066714764, -0.00024445669259876013, -0.02599390037357807, -0.006319997366517782, -0.02797861211001873, 0.058821696788072586, -0.006343638990074396, -0.005402910523116589, -0.0037415216211229563, -0.011829364113509655, 0.0070029571652412415, -0.037776391953229904, -0.015853872522711754, 0.02539866790175438, 0.04165395349264145, -0.07461745291948318, -0.03196858987212181, -0.004758145660161972, -0.0035767622757703066, 0.02824968658387661, 0.022288287058472633, 0.03713325783610344, -0.015224946662783623, -0.001004895893856883, -0.04548745974898338, 0.045205019414424896, -0.031614504754543304, 0.0313570499420166, 0.057037536054849625, -0.025949055328965187, -0.026996202766895294, -0.025192243978381157, 0.018596552312374115, 0.047743428498506546, 0.013245479203760624, -0.05622103810310364, -0.0014904225245118141, -0.02635037526488304, -0.01788998581469059, -0.03062821552157402, -0.03589685261249542, -0.002631476614624262, -0.015653379261493683, 0.0027765363920480013, 0.005197335500270128, 0.01134534738957882, -0.0005681926850229502, 0.024798283353447914, 0.013512064702808857, 0.06020497903227806, -0.030281132087111473, -0.054639171808958054, -0.008363506756722927, 0.015108629129827023, -0.06397702544927597, 0.008170916698873043, -0.005200978368520737, 0.04401572421193123, 0.002578724641352892, 0.022502422332763672, -0.0033583634067326784, 0.03990352898836136, -0.008178330026566982, 0.02132749743759632, 0.012650562450289726, -0.047897953540086746, 0.01251294743269682, -0.030062038451433182, 0.022570492699742317, -0.012837362475693226, -0.017553914338350296, -0.029425211250782013, -0.029708586633205414, -0.00302288681268692, -0.000020018607756355777, -0.07129216194152832, 0.05319330468773842, -0.03458593413233757, -0.01191326417028904, -0.004439411219209433, -0.0014360054628923535, -0.009532202035188675, 0.009779011830687523, 0.019747059792280197, -0.03563149645924568, 0.030418530106544495, -0.0053743901662528515, -0.010762276127934456, -0.016385989263653755, 0.028121154755353928, 0.018354877829551697, 0.007506310939788818, 0.0027127424255013466, -0.004295801743865013, 0.018389316275715828, 0.07374276965856552, -0.008191392756998539, 0.017194246873259544, 0.0020767799578607082, -0.02158513106405735, -0.048091255128383636, 0.017217857763171196, -0.01178415585309267, 0.036542508751153946, 0.004587390925735235, -0.02943957969546318, -0.022387567907571793, 0.03768423944711685, -0.0057666911743581295, -0.016337865963578224, -0.034029603004455566, -0.0032414859160780907, -0.004045447800308466, 0.021047815680503845, 0.0017158271512016654, 0.010521113872528076, -0.021934788674116135, 0.03465178981423378, 0.0541454553604126, -0.013153215870261192, -0.0002511656784918159, -0.0006724023842252791, 0.010372458957135677, 0.027696814388036728, -0.009615588933229446, -0.018750520423054695, 0.018907787278294563, 0.06409070640802383, -0.019015388563275337, 0.03870348632335663, -0.020402656868100166, 0.022626793012022972, -0.07370291650295258, -0.03009646013379097, -0.0016451660776510835, -0.010622087866067886, 0.00894017331302166, -0.045720670372247696, -0.022462667897343636, 0.030398273840546608, -0.009746314026415348, -0.001972199184820056, 0.016809968277812004, 0.005917706526815891, 0.0056968312710523605, 0.005267675034701824, -0.04315006360411644, 0.001261204364709556, -0.004175408743321896, -0.01987493224442005, 0.017421018332242966, 0.006058996543288231, 0.012551152147352695, -0.04263841733336449, -0.020099980756640434, -0.004873218946158886, 0.026947056874632835, -0.048025134950876236, 0.011933885514736176, -0.029557235538959503, 0.024423781782388687, 0.01181425154209137, -0.010538787581026554, 0.048749763518571854, 0.04539205878973007, 0.0042654601857066154, -0.026798436418175697, 0.07533278316259384, 0.031009012833237648, 0.024837676435709, -0.009845354594290257, 0.010462738573551178, 0.040671925991773605, 0.03513268753886223, -0.012926897034049034, 0.014529791660606861, 0.0037738787941634655, -0.00845671258866787, 0.013203705660998821, 0.015112683176994324, -0.017060987651348114, 0.021648956462740898, -0.018089214339852333, -0.016872208565473557, -0.029993237927556038, -0.035182032734155655, 0.02474837377667427, -0.05016089603304863, -0.014274620451033115, 0.03946974501013756, 0.007728599011898041, -0.014798183925449848, 0.013294504955410957, -0.0052632614970207214, -0.03500060364603996, 0.022094443440437317, -0.015703490003943443, -0.005801024846732616, -0.02178804762661457, 0.008853647857904434, 0.0033125763293355703, -0.012238288298249245, -0.05151422694325447, 0.02849137783050537, -0.055398207157850266, 0.07195641845464706, -0.033231012523174286, -0.011240929365158081, 0.01528181228786707, -0.02897714264690876, 0.03641873598098755, -0.07827945053577423, 0.0673198401927948, -0.014418312348425388, -0.004294440615922213, -0.013389366678893566, -0.014040789566934109, -0.03281949833035469, 0.020361116155982018, 0.028434162959456444, -0.034944675862789154, -0.0013609803281724453, 0.025657378137111664, 0.01936419866979122, 0.015605200082063675, -0.01520024798810482, 0.036192480474710464, 0.03513475880026817, -0.029994258657097816, 0.0017116982489824295, -0.01784454844892025, -0.006130598951131105, -0.0095518808811903, 0.007679453585296869, -0.002610387746244669, 0.0032485779374837875, 0.011303160339593887, -0.04363993927836418, 0.014820989221334457, -0.01377756055444479, -0.011765649542212486, 0.03688624128699303, 0.010409142822027206, 0.003181623760610819, 0.06467460095882416, 0.029709717258810997, -0.034987661987543106, 0.03211540728807449, -0.030800865963101387, -0.029600264504551888, 0.009561867453157902, -0.010022018104791641, 0.003399267792701721, -0.050627171993255615, 0.010550474748015404, -0.007965185679495335, -0.022001167759299278, 0.035967253148555756, 0.015292148105800152, -0.008944940753281116, 0.035659532994031906, -0.018028756603598595, -0.01268258597701788, -0.030873408541083336, -0.009215454570949078, 0.0036850885953754187, 0.02788681723177433, 0.013268516398966312, -0.007737227249890566, 0.004487207625061274, 0.04557760804891586, 0.022015972062945366, 0.04013541340827942, 0.00041381403570994735, 0.029304934665560722, -0.030882982537150383, -0.015566658228635788, 0.004612264223396778, 0.013411584310233593, 0.008916748687624931, 0.0037544455844908953, -0.024494435638189316, 0.04853086173534393, -0.04668063670396805, 0.00962129794061184, -0.039434969425201416, 0.0014330012490972877, -0.0014058760134503245, -0.02747131884098053, -0.02511301264166832, 0.041335273534059525, -0.0012258273782208562, 0.03900465369224548, 0.0054070050828158855, -0.02614431269466877, 0.039756231009960175, -0.024111462756991386, 0.009106194600462914, -0.015210955403745174, 0.023838669061660767, 0.008931763470172882, -0.02451288513839245, 0.008901458233594894, -0.03158765658736229, 0.03381621092557907, 0.04371257871389389, 0.019337397068738937, -0.03416568785905838, 0.004278562963008881, -0.026095498353242874, 0.04551471024751663, -0.029712067916989326, -0.03857715055346489, -0.009889025241136551, -0.0025188422296196222, -0.03111928142607212, -0.0331108421087265 ]
<blockquote> <p><strong>Possible Duplicate:</strong><br> <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/577/is-there-any-reason-to-prefer-the-aic-or-bic-over-the-other">Is there any reason to prefer the AIC or BIC over the other?</a> </p> </blockquote> <p>Can anyone please interpret each term in AIC, BIC and KIC. And the difference between the three.</p> <p>Thanks in advance,</p>
49,615
[ -0.04902418702840805, -0.027758603915572166, -0.026956651359796524, -0.03329833224415779, 0.03945457190275192, 0.03138607367873192, 0.00507644796743989, -0.01172641385346651, 0.006775123532861471, -0.02531917206943035, 0.052249617874622345, 0.05472710356116295, 0.05016808584332466, -0.003174735698848963, 0.010069219395518303, 0.030783100053668022, 0.0037056615110486746, 0.03177298605442047, -0.014479540288448334, -0.018666701391339302, 0.010784340091049671, -0.012968005612492561, 0.02876211144030094, 0.04234004393219948, -0.0320095457136631, 0.026920074597001076, 0.012791132554411888, -0.031404510140419006, 0.005417390260845423, 0.03551601991057396, -0.03850170224905014, 0.04513043537735939, 0.017986368387937546, 0.04054844006896019, 0.0027968240901827812, 0.03475544601678848, 0.01179640181362629, -0.015977153554558754, -0.01819598115980625, 0.007670929655432701, -0.030954545363783836, -0.03781355544924736, 0.020831748843193054, 0.006619742605835199, -0.02309282310307026, 0.021426694467663765, -0.008046440780162811, -0.04719196632504463, -0.013589122332632542, -0.04844845458865166, 0.023785920813679695, -0.03919333964586258, 0.016855856403708458, 0.05155064910650253, -0.024818209931254387, -0.005926584824919701, 0.030354605987668037, 0.06786905229091644, -0.03029133938252926, -0.04652170091867447, 0.03497203066945076, -0.0071318247355520725, 0.00792103074491024, 0.023462310433387756, -0.02034205012023449, 0.042722150683403015, 0.016978397965431213, -0.02969443053007126, 0.052914492785930634, -0.011055884882807732, 0.02823001518845558, -0.00030281220097094774, 0.02258153446018696, -0.021625367924571037, 0.021420365199446678, -0.029775647446513176, -0.014444650150835514, 0.016359392553567886, 0.06928341835737228, 0.07025858014822006, -0.008501753211021423, 0.02157360315322876, 0.006568151991814375, 0.01227392628788948, 0.055533312261104584, -0.007607926614582539, 0.09695149958133698, -0.03779888525605202, -0.0035278755240142345, 0.005189805757254362, -0.03362174332141876, -0.00942231621593237, 0.06065959855914116, 0.02432737499475479, -0.014827599748969078, 0.00737367756664753, -0.028421442955732346, 0.04895968735218048, 0.020709479227662086, 0.004533654544502497, -0.023195486515760422, -0.02297890931367874, -0.0020453287288546562, 0.04318593814969063, 0.027337638661265373, 0.007950150407850742, -0.030132809653878212, -0.010491829365491867, -0.024885090067982674, -0.023256538435816765, -0.03478170558810234, 0.0016822199104353786, -0.01342734694480896, 0.033968597650527954, 0.023801768198609352, -0.012231848202645779, 0.015272860415279865, 0.012088305316865444, 0.017195018008351326, 0.07888492196798325, 0.02946106716990471, -0.0038523825351148844, 0.01438712328672409, -0.022614119574427605, -0.046554189175367355, 0.02345491386950016, 0.025995619595050812, 0.004552426282316446, -0.036334678530693054, 0.045384202152490616, -0.024881402030587196, 0.04520847275853157, 0.02818644791841507, 0.0009086906793527305, -0.004807352554053068, 0.004928565118461847, -0.08211173117160797, -0.04357365146279335, 0.06933970004320145, -0.0004191115440335125, -0.0196481142193079, -0.05993898585438728, 0.03025588020682335, 0.018210211768746376, 0.020762590691447258, 0.037124138325452805, 0.025665778666734695, -0.016932286322116852, -0.01081049907952547, 0.012292847968637943, -0.03891373798251152, -0.009191779419779778, -0.0012573669664561749, -0.05604409798979759, -0.007648009341210127, -0.09411127120256424, 0.011882693506777287, 0.008961898274719715, 0.004457870032638311, -0.007929746992886066, 0.01204204373061657, 0.020788706839084625, -0.04116925224661827, -0.025214629247784615, -0.01265779696404934, 0.027811715379357338, 0.050904955714941025, 0.019207390025258064, 0.008318341337144375, -0.003860474331304431, -0.0030568107031285763, 0.041009679436683655, -0.019847292453050613, 0.030748842284083366, 0.04672705754637718, -0.03203529864549637, 0.008686582557857037, -0.02684461511671543, 0.023243989795446396, 0.0273350290954113, -0.07146704941987991, -0.01509129162877798, -0.02996649593114853, -0.026082884520292282, 0.01167576014995575, 0.05488638952374458, -0.01009594276547432, 0.011075281538069248, 0.06336510926485062, -0.0231610294431448, -0.039862629026174545, -0.0663101077079773, -0.004854419734328985, 0.024057429283857346, -0.06186843290925026, 0.010766617953777313, 0.008860261179506779, 0.02709898352622986, -0.0022854323033243418, 0.015726396813988686, -0.02137097157537937, 0.003935846965759993, 0.03270111232995987, -0.026870161294937134, 0.021846748888492584, 0.021878400817513466, 0.006291198544204235, -0.03081543743610382, 0.01973559707403183, -0.032569143921136856, -0.023366475477814674, 0.009908473119139671, -0.06704914569854736, 0.03245404362678528, -0.008469415828585625, 0.000741345458664, 0.0003397187974769622, 0.03273564204573631, -0.036538515239953995, 0.01126917079091072, -0.050153400748968124, 0.09200192242860794, -0.001929211663082242, -0.03032146953046322, -0.013029416091740131, 0.041696932166814804, 0.02722347341477871, 0.01071096956729889, -0.0216333270072937, -0.01656823791563511, -0.06349406391382217, 0.016237102448940277, 0.027251288294792175, 0.004147470463067293, -0.051347099244594574, 0.042907536029815674, 0.007138929329812527, 0.021148230880498886, -0.0003656442277133465, 0.004331415984779596, 0.0031574734020978212, -0.030389755964279175, 0.03443926200270653, 0.010411970317363739, -0.014097572304308414, 0.008641038089990616, 0.029364995658397675, -0.029839850962162018, 0.02382725290954113, -0.02560080774128437, -0.004582143388688564, 0.03311067074537277, -0.027870014309883118, 0.005522402934730053, -0.020032860338687897, -0.008460468612611294, 0.059248849749565125, -0.02594926208257675, -0.007325437385588884, 0.042370546609163284, 0.013571071438491344, -0.03996562957763672, 0.0005731917917728424, 0.006713965907692909, 0.010269827209413052, 0.02350747212767601, -0.0367794893682003, -0.004548299126327038, 0.015388025902211666, -0.014113079756498337, 0.02906833402812481, 0.009531646966934204, 0.0006307964213192463, -0.03624100238084793, -0.033511560410261154, 0.01885414682328701, -0.002568714553490281, 0.03277211636304855, -0.003969167359173298, -0.0019948885310441256, -0.007125129923224449, 0.01834227330982685, -0.0022628188598901033, -0.007281067315489054, -0.03930521383881569, 0.00958176888525486, -0.04500677064061165, -0.0261950995773077, 0.026829201728105545, -0.035011354833841324, -0.028135761618614197, 0.008614536374807358, -0.010223927907645702, -0.06074852868914604, 0.0034296936355531216, 0.020195897668600082, 0.035171326249837875, -0.025084851309657097, -0.03890228644013405, 0.06713169068098068, -0.030451355502009392, -0.04695926979184151, 0.004204270895570517, -0.028147047385573387, -0.01805891841650009, -0.002686492633074522, 0.021349314600229263, 0.025101345032453537, -0.016029449179768562, 0.016375530511140823, 0.02723045088350773, -0.037904053926467896, -0.00623880373314023, -0.05326300114393234, -0.051385920494794846, 0.035156942903995514, -0.01348492968827486, 0.019766001030802727, -0.012334407307207584, -0.040973909199237823, 0.016847480088472366, 0.06447774916887283, -0.02388784848153591, -0.0377223938703537, -0.028732018545269966, -0.017116505652666092, -0.013813082128763199, 0.011866920627653599, 0.011093529872596264, -0.02483762614428997, -0.002947538858279586, 0.025823790580034256, 0.03499707579612732, 0.03875083103775978, 0.015038021840155125, 0.009593530558049679, 0.00847643706947565, -0.0019459774484857917, -0.0395130030810833, 0.01822127401828766, 0.05544665828347206, -0.017551543191075325, -0.04712466150522232, -0.026942633092403412, 0.016284886747598648, 0.022638412192463875, -0.035831063985824585, 0.06655838340520859, -0.010809794999659061, -0.005818800535053015, -0.052426908165216446, 0.03853343799710274, 0.014864671044051647, -0.02104593813419342, -0.031483348459005356, 0.0009762686677277088, 0.004442710895091295, -0.007240646984428167, -0.004380078986287117, 0.04453127086162567, 0.04561002179980278, -0.0150840375572443, 0.023711690679192543, -0.02649538405239582, -0.00224230345338583, 0.017367277294397354, -0.03521481156349182, -0.006600597407668829, 0.017617780715227127, 0.043462760746479034, 0.0051279328763484955, -0.015260814689099789, -0.05318097770214081, 0.029007650911808014, -0.08806676417589188, -0.011301609687507153, -0.03544711321592331, 0.03960755467414856, 0.013220332562923431, 0.023558376356959343, 0.02696062996983528, 0.01703093945980072, 0.021777745336294174, -0.011444450356066227, -0.047053538262844086, 0.002251395955681801, -0.04266743361949921, 0.0030415665823966265, -0.005875590723007917, -0.00845213234424591, 0.027533117681741714, -0.038522038608789444, -0.019677922129631042, 0.009695729240775108, 0.02968614175915718, -0.004835867788642645, 0.029534505680203438, -0.015589989721775055, 0.0003784197906497866, 0.028371326625347137, 0.009002779610455036, 0.04852354899048805, -0.012018119916319847, 0.03420305624604225, 0.03174258768558502, 0.010351517237722874, -0.028723977506160736, 0.009306106716394424, 0.017436010763049126, -0.00030393205815926194, 0.022849196568131447, -0.008560903370380402, 0.02651466429233551, 0.041848454624414444, -0.0099156703799963, 0.03144409507513046, 0.0018129802774637938, 0.004045023582875729, -0.04250490665435791, -0.042198799550533295, -0.04028500244021416, -0.020265886560082436, -0.00857305247336626, 0.0645766481757164, -0.006867754273116589, -0.011587884277105331, 0.03557148203253746, 0.03992649167776108, -0.0010452495189383626, 0.0370512381196022, 0.026455329731106758, 0.023992260918021202, -0.01569761335849762, -0.02680656500160694, 0.014804950915277004, 0.014764553867280483, -0.02124909870326519, 0.038235537707805634, 0.019634868949651718, -0.008112731389701366, 0.03714684769511223, 0.06190798804163933, -0.031349360942840576, -0.03277002274990082, 0.015930401161313057, -0.0046939002349972725, -0.000237075422774069, 0.011412471532821655, -0.05043419450521469, -0.00044639190309681, 0.04657921567559242, 0.03358961641788483, 0.06532708555459976, 0.0155401099473238, -0.05760747194290161, -0.03338398411870003, 0.04190915822982788, 0.025151975452899933, -0.0901324599981308, -0.018193040043115616, -0.05216199904680252, -0.04854707792401314, 0.021982304751873016, -0.018923932686448097, 0.040347833186388016, -0.0593380481004715, 0.0010366853093728423, 0.02765973098576069, -0.03289882838726044, -0.03451806679368019, -0.01937037520110607, 0.003823742037639022, 0.008306752890348434, -0.007369679398834705, 0.007290191948413849, 0.0007363774348050356, -0.012168985791504383, 0.011165453121066093, 0.044390130788087845, -0.03771832957863808, -0.0014041941612958908, 0.03233656287193298, 0.03748229146003723, -0.011493709869682789, -0.03896287828683853, 0.009339652955532074, 0.02044338919222355, 0.0017985556041821837, 0.04248453676700592, -0.026511460542678833, -0.06787380576133728, 0.011490720324218273, 0.02030046656727791, -0.04201262816786766, 0.02745913714170456, -0.024073123931884766, 0.03405337780714035, 0.05144413560628891, 0.004641842097043991, 0.04057449474930763, 0.003252200549468398, -0.06468396633863449, -0.007430089637637138, -0.03338584303855896, -0.002050041686743498, -0.024160319939255714, -0.0628184974193573, -0.013703588396310806, 0.01242909673601389, -0.02789635770022869, 0.019921446219086647, -0.003426383249461651, 0.0395892858505249, -0.04899000748991966, -0.04092516005039215, 0.007524300366640091, 0.02306407317519188, -0.013062280602753162, -0.011172731406986713, -0.010201843455433846, 0.024061325937509537, 0.006541724782437086, -0.0449528805911541, 0.006951688788831234, -0.04191332310438156, -0.010349026881158352, 0.04676586017012596, -0.04159525781869888, 0.007983283139765263, -0.04076350852847099, -0.02678188867866993, 0.013478036969900131, -0.000356582022504881, 0.011090322397649288, -0.004770116880536079, -0.01952287182211876, 0.0031951810233294964, -0.025592977181077003, 0.0033101460430771112, -0.024350257590413094, -0.0316510908305645, 0.059382498264312744, 0.015551481395959854, 0.02156889997422695, -0.005467299837619066, -0.033210545778274536, -0.0991680771112442, -0.01938505843281746, -0.008851444348692894, -0.015571470372378826, -0.035575348883867264, 0.010153653100132942, -0.00340487202629447, -0.0038343232590705156, -0.018858565017580986, 0.004851400852203369, 0.04197632521390915, 0.004796484485268593, -0.01382339745759964, 0.008158951066434383, 0.004748865962028503, 0.027528993785381317, 0.00818420760333538, -0.020651021972298622, -0.001897546579129994, -0.03182400017976761, -0.010470333509147167, 0.03856542706489563, 0.05867236480116844, -0.01679336465895176, -0.023261141031980515, -0.018581200391054153, -0.046211499720811844, 0.02878846414387226, 0.014886048622429371, -0.019818678498268127, 0.0370110422372818, -0.013295905664563179, -0.01860446110367775, -0.030361030250787735, 0.03151290863752365, -0.03295474871993065, 0.030783670023083687, -0.03276924788951874, 0.021470125764608383, -0.021347137168049812, -0.028399981558322906, 0.007059886585921049, -0.007597482297569513, -0.03884872421622276, 0.019058888778090477, 0.04900642856955528, -0.05301758274435997, 0.01070084236562252, -0.018614206463098526, -0.014704329892992973, 0.021487785503268242, 0.01195998303592205, 0.016925347968935966, 0.018080295994877815, 0.01849186047911644, -0.010748201981186867, -0.015761781483888626, -0.016693565994501114, 0.0435035303235054, 0.06194192171096802, -0.005765019915997982, 0.06721340119838715, 0.06263899058103561, -0.011050913482904434, 0.03135913982987404, -0.04887311905622482, 0.01935589127242565, 0.005911785177886486, 0.0025242893025279045, 0.051545385271310806, -0.02775387652218342, -0.027621831744909286, 0.04706912115216255, 0.014634083956480026, -0.021121473982930183, 0.014101777225732803, 0.014861025847494602, 0.05066602677106857, -0.003773845499381423, -0.030246185138821602, -0.043484918773174286, 0.03695019334554672, -0.025636792182922363, 0.030772754922509193, -0.02333805523812771, -0.05755199119448662, 0.05238700658082962, 0.019846798852086067, 0.018742768093943596, -0.07753307372331619, -0.018537575379014015, -0.05525530129671097, -0.0026079420931637287, 0.01873827539384365, 0.0018163429340347648, -0.017838992178440094, -0.020108871161937714, 0.03464236482977867, 0.007528935559093952, 0.024600084871053696, -0.018268899992108345, -0.10837164521217346, -0.0525490865111351, 0.008575668558478355, -0.03793112933635712, 0.0387209951877594, -0.011464129202067852, -0.011272999458014965, 0.012105893343687057, -0.05378284305334091, 0.004352407995611429, 0.016069628298282623, 0.0538594126701355, -0.02671041153371334, 0.08759292215108871, -0.04205809161067009, -0.03436065837740898, 0.018164461478590965, -0.021245110780000687, 0.12687788903713226, 0.050118912011384964, 0.021140003576874733, -0.08405285328626633, 0.05365993455052376, 0.04750599339604378, -0.025994718074798584, 0.012100832536816597, -0.010817037895321846, 0.02257021702826023, -0.009829144924879074, 0.05408504605293274, 0.059176765382289886, -0.009808313101530075, -0.0005246918881312013, 0.035127464681863785, -0.01643342711031437, -0.027354776859283447, 0.012297764420509338, 0.009380686096847057, 0.04537779092788696, -0.013542990200221539, -0.003887035883963108, 0.010257994756102562, 0.029687415808439255, -0.013538761995732784, -0.022797388955950737, -0.005540845915675163, -0.007805195637047291, 0.04337996989488602, -0.021510113030672073, -0.014661620371043682, 0.0239714328199625, -0.00009656105248723179, 0.00575227802619338, -0.013597643002867699, 0.0027997647412121296, -0.057463083416223526, 0.020910130813717842, 0.018331505358219147, -0.018288252875208855, -0.04245318844914436, 0.025605423375964165, -0.026152653619647026, -0.05472021549940109, -0.021712517365813255, -0.039618078619241714, -0.014830470085144043, -0.003800423350185156, -0.0018188422545790672, -0.05609751120209694, -0.0117553835734725, 0.03681198135018349, -0.008115777745842934, -0.024070465937256813, 0.027004040777683258, 0.038408633321523666, -0.05163699388504028, -0.05536108464002609, -0.050946999341249466, 0.0005020516691729426, -0.010334022343158722, 0.05413500592112541, 0.00826680101454258, -0.06817792356014252, -0.04039635509252548, -0.0014385072281584144, 0.048882994800806046, 0.019288847222924232, 0.03904471918940544, 0.03940568491816521, 0.021498918533325195, -0.08701688796281815, -0.01042916439473629, -0.03306514024734497, 0.01962726004421711, 0.04453078284859657, -0.009932954795658588, -0.009895221330225468, -0.007634412497282028, -0.025239596143364906, -0.033899225294589996, -0.014812690205872059, 0.012834727764129639, -0.014066752977669239, 0.007955547422170639, 0.022462142631411552, -0.009238147176802158, 0.026181310415267944, 0.052541885524988174, 0.0019092612201347947, 0.08532752096652985, -0.024009164422750473, -0.07771098613739014, -0.02609040029346943, -0.0002743802033364773, -0.04292451590299606, -0.021026933565735817, -0.016520848497748375, 0.02293586917221546, 0.0020940913818776608, 0.02144455723464489, 0.003501116530969739, 0.015148886479437351, -0.03847872465848923, 0.01427562814205885, 0.019946295768022537, -0.053799331188201904, -0.017677729949355125, 0.0429442934691906, 0.037309225648641586, -0.060317911207675934, -0.011472889222204685, -0.01782361976802349, -0.01484641619026661, 0.05859285593032837, -0.005599635187536478, -0.042340707033872604, 0.008999606594443321, -0.009392022155225277, 0.01458067074418068, -0.03324223682284355, -0.025449678301811218, -0.031683869659900665, -0.012247960083186626, -0.019482415169477463, 0.007602545898407698, 0.03014104999601841, 0.034688081592321396, -0.021184120327234268, 0.001456310274079442, 0.05317835137248039, 0.006388756446540356, -0.025833357125520706, 0.009007077664136887, -0.014637728221714497, -0.015109814703464508, 0.0486118420958519, -0.029840031638741493, 0.021221831440925598, 0.025880232453346252, -0.026824790984392166, -0.006692561320960522, 0.030988067388534546, -0.027940526604652405, -0.014903073199093342, 0.027098169550299644, 0.01574065163731575, 0.011315206065773964, 0.03798176720738411, -0.02633090317249298, 0.007049646228551865, -0.02640424855053425, -0.013417034409940243, -0.004278586711734533, -0.018816592171788216, -0.026726892217993736, 0.02941827103495598, -0.007508027367293835, 0.05056905373930931, -0.0015920639270916581, 0.0020993126090615988, -0.015393439680337906, 0.005364148411899805, 0.022098274901509285, 0.010563439689576626, -0.002888736315071583, -0.015012538060545921, 0.0060456315986812115, 0.01145324856042862, -0.02612351067364216, 0.02664896287024021, -0.012507522478699684, 0.028083451092243195, -0.07149101793766022, -0.016378819942474365, 0.001803552033379674, 0.019182153046131134, 0.0319615863263607, -0.01682916469871998, 0.0010103278327733278, 0.0196525901556015, -0.05198179557919502, 0.03502344712615013, 0.008131619542837143, 0.023556265980005264, -0.05621946603059769, 0.00927755143493414, -0.007597615011036396, 0.03900967538356781, 0.016441352665424347, 0.02603502757847309, 0.0105759771540761, 0.04644456133246422, 0.003192537697032094, -0.011730091646313667, -0.0031660045497119427, -0.020484138280153275, 0.013934015296399593, -0.03993060067296028, 0.08734804391860962, -0.024968985468149185, -0.005470142234116793, 0.03345269337296486, 0.00741750281304121, 0.0466034822165966, 0.03197138383984566, -0.001812269096262753, 0.023251019418239594, 0.021465571597218513, 0.023777145892381668, -0.041729073971509933, -0.011974397115409374, 0.02030504308640957, 0.0019246033625677228, 0.0570412278175354, 0.035352811217308044, 0.005494119133800268, 0.012875544838607311, -0.0010637108935043216, 0.0013954798923805356, 0.0023326545488089323, -0.025221168994903564, -0.05187935009598732, -0.03669465333223343, -0.006839651148766279, 0.02792501077055931, 0.012267842888832092, -0.01776406355202198, -0.055953498929739, 0.009125171229243279, 0.0029024204704910517, 0.016978546977043152, 0.025834189727902412, -0.00031834308174438775, -0.04276793450117111, -0.027596741914749146, 0.011389588937163353, -0.00022564396203961223, -0.016862090677022934, -0.015536779537796974, -0.031874291598796844, 0.04463663324713707, 0.0289782602339983, -0.0188191756606102, 0.07135061919689178, -0.03275732323527336, 0.035454317927360535, -0.01116351131349802, 0.00036470292252488434, 0.01801125705242157, -0.024050718173384666, -0.03300347551703453, -0.05193621665239334, 0.06037247180938721, 0.03698274493217468, -0.0013570893788710237, -0.021483901888132095, -0.04721974581480026, -0.02036941424012184, 0.009400015696883202, 0.07994642108678818, -0.0010631972691044211, -0.019565416499972343, -0.005779909435659647, 0.027550730854272842, -0.020196745172142982, -0.012488188222050667, 0.00749553507193923, 0.006179037969559431, 0.016955196857452393, -0.0011321770725771785, 0.005056782625615597, 0.0181578416377306, 0.0441870354115963, 0.009148693643510342, -0.03699104115366936, 0.029791489243507385, 0.013765061274170876, 0.011646757833659649, 0.036360230296850204, 0.009365714155137539, -0.03435059264302254, 0.06061466410756111, -0.015796922147274017, -0.010209440253674984, 0.00955128762871027, -0.008680707775056362, -0.03320718929171562, 0.054234202951192856, -0.008694835007190704, -0.016431564465165138, -0.0071908654645085335, -0.008878103457391262, -0.012524880468845367, -0.03876141831278801, 0.003612615866586566, 0.02033822610974312, -0.032533615827560425, -0.010175412520766258, 0.021814532577991486, 0.029437333345413208, 0.0844452902674675, -0.000994239468127489, -0.007500249892473221, 0.010620583780109882, -0.03769683837890625, 0.010873755440115929, 0.02825135365128517, 0.07915710657835007, 0.03883378580212593, -0.0021780082024633884, -0.016746269538998604, -0.002890703035518527, 0.01864827610552311, -0.012171798385679722, 0.03659665212035179, 0.0041208453476428986, -0.025575043633580208, 0.040210653096437454, 0.03530089557170868, 0.03440479561686516, 0.035571273416280746, 0.004749760497361422, 0.07856898009777069, -0.018965601921081543, -0.01800910197198391, -0.009162572212517262, -0.009362434037029743, -0.021752772852778435, -0.012048919685184956, 0.037556156516075134, 0.010515575297176838, 0.00950418971478939, -0.01888575404882431, 0.005077005364000797, -0.018574370071291924, 0.026814917102456093, -0.02732977271080017, -0.007474972866475582, -0.024555295705795288, 0.04605008661746979, -0.020775701850652695, -0.042149826884269714, -0.02911737561225891, -0.031567297875881195, 0.005419561173766851, 0.0435495488345623, 0.032193031162023544, 0.0006965163047425449, -0.05658634379506111, 0.014648289419710636, 0.06974019855260849, -0.032922618091106415, 0.005971155595034361, -0.042689595371484756, 0.037089962512254715, 0.016006173565983772, 0.00017510206089355052 ]
<p>There have been good questions on handling imbalanced data in the <em>classification</em> context, but I am wondering what people do to sample for regression.</p> <p>Say the problem domain is very sensitive to the sign but only somewhat sensitive to the magnitude of the target. However the magnitude is important enough that the model should be regression (continuous target) not classification (positive vs. negative classes). And say in this problem domain that any set of training data will have 10x more negative than positive targets.</p> <p>In this scenario, I might oversample the positive-target examples to match the count of negative-target examples, and then train a model to differentiate the two cases. Obviously the training approach does badly on imbalanced data, so I need to do sampling of some sort. What would be a decent way to "undo" this oversampling when making predictions? Perhaps translating by the (negative) mean or median of the target of the natural training data?</p>
73,535
[ 0.0030991341918706894, -0.0064961533062160015, -0.02251044288277626, -0.02299199067056179, 0.03519366681575775, 0.025052426382899284, -0.03100939281284809, -0.0012385390000417829, 0.05052250996232033, 0.008241401985287666, 0.018110424280166626, 0.04780099168419838, 0.037996236234903336, -0.05054762214422226, -0.007062009070068598, -0.0058571104891598225, -0.017611796036362648, -0.0009053346002474427, -0.00990819651633501, -0.026813320815563202, 0.01624218560755253, 0.018438538536429405, 0.051146332174539566, 0.022950926795601845, -0.029855530709028244, 0.03511247783899307, 0.05898958072066307, -0.004279713612049818, 0.008716960437595844, 0.02502564713358879, -0.03968453034758568, 0.03431450575590134, 0.028910567983984947, 0.042937006801366806, 0.01943381503224373, -0.003759964369237423, 0.008652685210108757, -0.04265062138438225, -0.009482325054705143, 0.017053382471203804, -0.017977554351091385, 0.010791623964905739, 0.034060198813676834, 0.008768363855779171, 0.006107724737375975, -0.019424695521593094, -0.03680632635951042, -0.022266225889325142, 0.040866635739803314, -0.05362173542380333, 0.0496610552072525, -0.014172210358083248, 0.030320120975375175, 0.04430484026670456, -0.005147578660398722, -0.009746856987476349, 0.05811452493071556, 0.06061817705631256, -0.007255133707076311, -0.019007857888936996, -0.007393854204565287, -0.02242421731352806, -0.010859739035367966, 0.005456400569528341, -0.008705422282218933, 0.017586592584848404, 0.005478828214108944, -0.02999771386384964, 0.0026907382998615503, -0.021524576470255852, 0.02506575919687748, 0.000769769016187638, 0.019153565168380737, 0.007785290479660034, -0.005276612471789122, -0.0419979989528656, 0.0070111751556396484, 0.05998097360134125, 0.04605790227651596, 0.014501207508146763, -0.00804352667182684, 0.02714376337826252, -0.0029161858838051558, 0.05661584809422493, 0.0328584723174572, -0.012199162505567074, 0.07406707108020782, -0.017615027725696564, 0.02946200594305992, 0.04774687439203262, -0.037682075053453445, -0.02383815124630928, 0.035971857607364655, -0.03869887813925743, -0.06258426606655121, 0.014933268539607525, 0.023742523044347763, 0.02397722192108631, 0.026935651898384094, 0.023510735481977463, -0.042423706501722336, -0.015219996683299541, 0.024329163134098053, 0.06297210603952408, -0.03351748734712601, 0.009104856289923191, -0.02740584686398506, -0.018021846190094948, 0.004912698641419411, -0.02947544865310192, -0.021616224199533463, 0.009776799008250237, 0.023859385401010513, -0.016672395169734955, 0.024079548195004463, 0.02801758423447609, 0.013724389486014843, -0.041896067559719086, 0.031983762979507446, 0.04217354208230972, 0.045318812131881714, -0.0193669181317091, 0.039643365889787674, 0.0014209996443241835, -0.009842678904533386, -0.015485976822674274, 0.022920196875929832, -0.0013919128105044365, -0.03505745530128479, 0.0021196964662522078, 0.019082874059677124, -0.05291035398840904, 0.04936610907316208, -0.009143778122961521, 0.05475633218884468, 0.009640033356845379, -0.06996903568506241, -0.05542844906449318, 0.03427664563059807, -0.016175061464309692, -0.027970008552074432, -0.012332772836089134, -0.039000414311885834, 0.04652511328458786, 0.033743444830179214, 0.04885759949684143, 0.029542772099375725, 0.025551870465278625, -0.001918953494168818, 0.035974640399217606, 0.004857915919274092, 0.0007795352721586823, -0.0544770173728466, 0.01594211347401142, -0.04050270840525627, -0.06467893719673157, 0.025147275999188423, -0.0017740949988365173, -0.03445351868867874, 0.003489892464131117, 0.011214899830520153, -0.009288772009313107, -0.015093769878149033, -0.006887798197567463, -0.012174668721854687, -0.03197495639324188, 0.08594033867120743, 0.004900663625448942, 0.02948395535349846, 0.004934403114020824, -0.017299827188253403, 0.031098302453756332, 0.043107952922582626, 0.04091106727719307, 0.0683218315243721, -0.0001964892289834097, 0.014327079989016056, -0.060338784009218216, 0.02958802692592144, 0.006097916979342699, -0.01800839602947235, -0.045127127319574356, 0.010705087333917618, -0.00013731414219364524, 0.026296092197299004, 0.005072432104498148, 0.005922957323491573, -0.04628102481365204, 0.06053698807954788, -0.05533237382769585, -0.04344037175178528, -0.03223347291350365, -0.01431237906217575, -0.005348005797713995, -0.020813319832086563, 0.01867896132171154, 0.02924170531332493, 0.028803221881389618, -0.022650722414255142, -0.0454564206302166, -0.02208918333053589, -0.017015477642416954, 0.05809923633933067, -0.05208306014537811, -0.011350325308740139, 0.04698585718870163, 0.016050394624471664, -0.01701935939490795, 0.06543592363595963, -0.06363559514284134, -0.04636622965335846, -0.010914932936429977, -0.01698617823421955, -0.008523204363882542, -0.010545048862695694, -0.020644046366214752, 0.016404859721660614, -0.011055821552872658, -0.040181055665016174, 0.04424027353525162, -0.04499393329024315, 0.06105060130357742, 0.08973869681358337, -0.018947357311844826, -0.012269909493625164, -0.009324220009148121, 0.003570794127881527, 0.019877959042787552, -0.02551913447678089, -0.0007107603014446795, -0.0338856540620327, -0.00868019089102745, 0.01257829088717699, -0.023845124989748, -0.02795199304819107, 0.01821393333375454, 0.07488427311182022, -0.0007799057639203966, 0.02606525830924511, 0.007094195578247309, -0.01989585906267166, -0.010716882534325123, -0.025396184995770454, 0.005023384466767311, 0.040232546627521515, -0.02906113490462303, 0.02313452959060669, -0.0010340732987970114, 0.0028579854406416416, -0.004632797557860613, -0.019192207604646683, 0.01888453960418701, 0.005706248804926872, 0.030477013438940048, -0.012926379218697548, -0.02568967640399933, 0.01658731885254383, -0.01859642192721367, -0.019066913053393364, 0.030708227306604385, -0.002550358884036541, 0.017350642010569572, 0.01944778859615326, 0.000629338261205703, 0.0030869650654494762, 0.007170446682721376, -0.00808555819094181, 0.04126099497079849, 0.0343320332467556, -0.06818045675754547, -0.002393924631178379, -0.00758341746404767, -0.04002009332180023, -0.05526316910982132, 0.010417472571134567, 0.030504988506436348, 0.003442724933847785, 0.037696558982133865, -0.006931134033948183, -0.03348314017057419, 0.0017627824563533068, 0.0011852653697133064, 0.04443265497684479, 0.03529401868581772, -0.042461760342121124, 0.007886138744652271, -0.04741581156849861, -0.024093622341752052, 0.027219222858548164, 0.028107760474085808, -0.019359199330210686, -0.01573294959962368, 0.004621742758899927, -0.05311952158808708, -0.036459773778915405, -0.034328535199165344, 0.008348449133336544, -0.019250918179750443, -0.03919471427798271, 0.06699654459953308, 0.02764802798628807, -0.06741733849048615, -0.0036859025713056326, 0.004238275345414877, -0.02664514258503914, -0.034936707466840744, -0.02390684187412262, 0.030496317893266678, -0.0011329387780278921, -0.007055798079818487, 0.006153483409434557, -0.013789819553494453, 0.038506947457790375, -0.048805270344018936, -0.046714749187231064, -0.0013793983962386847, 0.010193036869168282, 0.03451313450932503, 0.05110805109143257, 0.026706183329224586, 0.09587239474058151, 0.03674662858247757, 0.009085161611437798, -0.008720213547348976, 0.012379342690110207, -0.017883317545056343, -0.03471190854907036, -0.0011971122585237026, 0.018572352826595306, 0.007244020234793425, 0.029069118201732635, -0.02676757238805294, 0.017145667225122452, 0.03016696870326996, 0.008493986912071705, -0.046422187238931656, 0.01818092167377472, -0.0014403046807274222, 0.02618853747844696, 0.016128934919834137, 0.013254229910671711, -0.004304626490920782, 0.028706835582852364, 0.009364145807921886, 0.051067739725112915, 0.012331834062933922, -0.005111297592520714, 0.013299732469022274, -0.017231840640306473, 0.01145773846656084, -0.025668330490589142, 0.021833021193742752, 0.007461522705852985, -0.03730691596865654, -0.02375956065952778, 0.018323412165045738, 0.011788429692387581, -0.04130398854613304, -0.009868012741208076, 0.03586498647928238, 0.021298212930560112, -0.005485180299729109, -0.0074891760013997555, -0.009390752762556076, -0.009764773771166801, 0.0345132015645504, -0.013179984875023365, 0.005791858769953251, 0.033544909209012985, 0.06535761803388596, -0.025721248239278793, 0.00725570460781455, -0.034282535314559937, 0.007991599850356579, -0.04632692039012909, -0.014695905148983002, -0.00686177983880043, 0.07124051451683044, 0.002161671407520771, -0.014485880732536316, 0.0036547856871038675, -0.01278372947126627, 0.0015927401836961508, 0.022430704906582832, -0.06028138846158981, 0.05040828511118889, -0.002488071098923683, -0.027339765802025795, -0.018198607489466667, -0.013614188879728317, 0.04572704806923866, -0.053115010261535645, -0.006873717065900564, -0.022198643535375595, 0.01893599145114422, -0.021952588111162186, 0.011729341000318527, -0.01794513128697872, 0.009626859799027443, -0.02616025134921074, -0.001101252157241106, 0.009967787191271782, -0.008064406923949718, -0.006050920579582453, -0.00218353234231472, -0.006555553991347551, -0.024349363520741463, -0.046857986599206924, 0.03279982507228851, 0.005976625252515078, 0.049293965101242065, 0.030383624136447906, 0.04346767067909241, -0.08109069615602493, 0.03217710554599762, -0.04378880187869072, 0.058752696961164474, 0.028379768133163452, -0.02006511576473713, -0.01797216199338436, -0.05908561125397682, -0.0399608314037323, 0.002456472720950842, 0.039642803370952606, -0.000523083028383553, -0.029012344777584076, 0.055710531771183014, 0.020954882726073265, -0.06752806901931763, 0.013184781186282635, 0.0797538235783577, 0.016453593969345093, 0.016551772132515907, -0.007009758148342371, 0.023166440427303314, 0.004320849664509296, 0.04490617290139198, 0.02781679853796959, 0.005028959363698959, 0.017858359962701797, 0.01216509472578764, 0.031136786565184593, 0.01155696902424097, 0.0013759878929704428, 0.002228639554232359, 0.006572878919541836, 0.06569171696901321, 0.0058784522116184235, -0.027075309306383133, 0.034262292087078094, 0.024471445009112358, 0.0625053197145462, 0.02755758725106716, 0.013343516737222672, -0.11496766656637192, -0.0014730008551850915, 0.058697137981653214, 0.026018094271421432, -0.022524984553456306, -0.01653486303985119, -0.04180551692843437, 0.005587364546954632, 0.030988996848464012, -0.05588527396321297, -0.026829175651073456, -0.023809803649783134, 0.025656746700406075, -0.03345435485243797, 0.004773758817464113, -0.03764022886753082, 0.010900929570198059, -0.023275412619113922, 0.04247799888253212, 0.004417740739881992, -0.029095517471432686, -0.060129694640636444, 0.014497260563075542, -0.008403885178267956, 0.08648446202278137, -0.011759678833186626, -0.050798606127500534, 0.016089817509055138, 0.010702141560614109, -0.0072207082994282246, -0.06795132905244827, -0.042803116142749786, 0.02539117820560932, 0.009595507755875587, 0.03006831184029579, 0.003087157616391778, -0.04325403273105621, 0.009823808446526527, -0.005410295911133289, -0.05074126273393631, -0.01668623648583889, -0.04060322418808937, 0.00306659284979105, 0.010371675714850426, 0.002200171584263444, 0.056719742715358734, 0.016173752024769783, 0.01449765544384718, -0.012774644419550896, -0.01614692062139511, 0.031176641583442688, -0.0392267145216465, -0.06537823379039764, -0.04653999209403992, -0.008481785655021667, -0.021080296486616135, 0.022946568205952644, 0.02053418569266796, 0.029848737642169, 0.022079508751630783, -0.018640747293829918, -0.0002890958567149937, 0.013426690362393856, -0.00440902030095458, -0.020583881065249443, 0.014538630843162537, 0.017029227688908577, -0.023042703047394753, 0.008340428583323956, 0.012611285783350468, 0.0026183826848864555, 0.0074186478741467, 0.029359841719269753, -0.07169721275568008, 0.012567892670631409, -0.05370215326547623, -0.0072769708931446075, 0.004051648546010256, -0.022995885461568832, 0.02136612869799137, 0.010522655211389065, 0.04063543677330017, -0.0026337765157222748, -0.018047619611024857, 0.001802204642444849, 0.0377262607216835, -0.0025034595746546984, 0.005209738854318857, -0.048849333077669144, 0.05422767996788025, -0.006783572491258383, -0.007197324652224779, -0.08214936405420303, -0.05751076713204384, 0.0233444981276989, -0.008955623023211956, -0.03493168577551842, -0.01476916205137968, -0.010872055776417255, 0.03095407225191593, -0.013890490867197514, 0.004406530875712633, 0.07192472368478775, -0.02859639562666416, -0.03133545443415642, -0.013630875386297703, -0.0007317984127439559, 0.07860212028026581, -0.05607841908931732, -0.014211480505764484, 0.03672919422388077, -0.0227485541254282, -0.037727344781160355, 0.02727123163640499, 0.0108204809948802, -0.04175534471869469, -0.04086744040250778, -0.03993716463446617, -0.0022421486210078, 0.017769113183021545, -0.0008970547933131456, 0.001518728444352746, -0.007350856903940439, 0.02262398600578308, 0.010407764464616776, -0.03192257508635521, -0.01150763314217329, 0.0018311863532289863, 0.010794204659759998, -0.025589510798454285, 0.010127926245331764, 0.02124900184571743, -0.02688133530318737, 0.04442790895700455, 0.05074930191040039, 0.016750970855355263, 0.013468265533447266, 0.03346317633986473, -0.00913590844720602, 0.004794267006218433, -0.016300570219755173, -0.05618952587246895, 0.0753774344921112, -0.006744781509041786, 0.010039343498647213, -0.0012281505623832345, 0.03805732727050781, -0.04382205754518509, -0.04871142655611038, -0.05098683387041092, -0.015653574839234352, 0.012052868492901325, -0.007154938764870167, 0.07499241828918457, 0.06163381040096283, 0.01187653187662363, 0.016749611124396324, -0.04285077750682831, 0.001659404137171805, -0.030243108049035072, -0.007951964624226093, 0.03978950157761574, 0.010184244252741337, 0.06524951010942459, -0.005006872117519379, -0.021197877824306488, 0.03529961779713631, 0.036785926669836044, -0.013367408886551857, 0.03887573629617691, 0.01766344904899597, -0.027738189324736595, -0.028075149282813072, -0.006774898152798414, -0.0480608306825161, 0.0005486459122039378, -0.0022669846657663584, -0.039715684950351715, 0.0326228104531765, 0.02337859384715557, 0.035848233848810196, -0.059875115752220154, -0.0246356762945652, -0.08491575717926025, 0.0058026923798024654, -0.01687617413699627, 0.01223992370069027, 0.015890832990407944, 0.0037734832148998976, 0.030836813151836395, -0.015763381496071815, 0.018656296655535698, -0.03524697571992874, -0.06273331493139267, -0.06189750134944916, -0.0304292980581522, -0.02631615847349167, 0.012613082304596901, 0.013038764707744122, -0.018281642347574234, 0.047234486788511276, -0.0306849405169487, 0.05268620699644089, -0.00344138708896935, 0.038405925035476685, -0.03750596195459366, 0.028549524024128914, -0.011409029364585876, 0.008367946371436119, 0.0011813611490651965, 0.002686764346435666, 0.12488078325986862, 0.06440965831279755, 0.04909907281398773, -0.07684070616960526, 0.0267525352537632, -0.002696623094379902, -0.03756037354469299, -0.019242556765675545, -0.012977463193237782, 0.009894207119941711, 0.018743066117167473, 0.013256855309009552, 0.03808741271495819, 0.02138807438313961, -0.012000033631920815, 0.05281596630811691, -0.014953295700252056, 0.028827011585235596, 0.016268881037831306, 0.02857811003923416, 0.014385759830474854, 0.01896602287888527, -0.06359894573688507, 0.028331637382507324, -0.020132098346948624, -0.018895236775279045, -0.03302564099431038, -0.03282500058412552, -0.027444466948509216, 0.0035583411809056997, 0.01106338482350111, 0.008135075680911541, 0.00122019462287426, -0.00935925543308258, 0.03249726817011833, -0.01349444966763258, -0.008415000513195992, -0.03926503285765648, -0.011609204113483429, 0.004736199043691158, 0.02085413597524166, 0.007990413345396519, -0.020490074530243874, 0.01893477514386177, -0.029545262455940247, -0.024330398067831993, -0.020541923120617867, 0.026831666007637978, 0.0005946137825958431, 0.0002640409511514008, 0.01646050438284874, 0.017926426604390144, 0.029053620994091034, -0.036260053515434265, -0.039418790489435196, 0.011687777936458588, 0.03856919705867767, -0.011371660977602005, -0.054371338337659836, -0.001504942192696035, 0.05692833289504051, 0.02141506038606167, 0.004200540482997894, -0.024969706311821938, -0.026427941396832466, -0.014630679041147232, -0.01575147919356823, -0.0021143988706171513, 0.043174128979444504, -0.002681155689060688, 0.01988034136593342, -0.00439667422324419, -0.019063951447606087, -0.0055451774969697, 0.03637632727622986, -0.010852853767573833, 0.026878779754042625, -0.016316449269652367, -0.03107358142733574, -0.043020907789468765, -0.02444058284163475, 0.008564574643969536, -0.049601566046476364, 0.03333192691206932, -0.032185543328523636, -0.021550912410020828, 0.0052537452429533005, 0.023757124319672585, 0.034066155552864075, 0.017045531421899796, 0.005292197689414024, 0.04310450702905655, -0.007484770379960537, -0.015819348394870758, 0.007920277304947376, -0.012339328415691853, -0.02764178067445755, 0.029494715854525566, -0.007290183566510677, 0.0897742435336113, 0.016910310834646225, 0.001269672648049891, -0.008414212614297867, 0.04753081873059273, 0.003394154366105795, 0.003357148263603449, 0.02336215414106846, -0.08030441403388977, 0.01596973091363907, -0.022636892274022102, -0.002336355857551098, -0.04409302398562431, -0.0193079374730587, -0.02394363470375538, -0.05578787997364998, -0.00455078762024641, 0.010493909940123558, -0.03481319919228554, 0.027991272509098053, -0.010516375303268433, 0.035017114132642746, -0.04031853377819061, -0.01912692002952099, -0.05183282867074013, 0.006336661521345377, -0.024637307971715927, -0.05813165754079819, 0.013422297313809395, -0.04888814687728882, -0.011162171140313148, -0.007231850642710924, 0.01629498600959778, 0.012299859896302223, 0.035733405500650406, 0.024472670629620552, 0.036313265562057495, -0.003105711657553911, 0.029369337484240532, -0.02869749255478382, 0.026129353791475296, 0.040629271417856216, 0.009130056016147137, 0.011182229965925217, 0.021874921396374702, 0.0013503333320841193, 0.029322337359189987, 0.013299939222633839, -0.022649452090263367, -0.020236415788531303, 0.030220499262213707, -0.01273265853524208, -0.024070855230093002, -0.025199316442012787, 0.030495071783661842, -0.02222334034740925, -0.010634757578372955, 0.04625964164733887, -0.013775455765426159, 0.000778447138145566, 0.0008946713642217219, 0.0393509678542614, 0.02701595425605774, -0.009856131859123707, 0.006427887827157974, -0.011820199899375439, 0.048700399696826935, -0.0163264237344265, 0.001156059792265296, 0.01935155689716339, 0.024934010580182076, -0.012910407036542892, 0.03533542901277542, -0.011394812725484371, 0.021467560902237892, -0.09636548906564713, -0.05824849009513855, 0.03748791664838791, -0.021314464509487152, 0.033169981092214584, -0.05770327150821686, -0.017162468284368515, 0.02639429084956646, -0.03464948385953903, 0.0053006443195044994, -0.033035505563020706, -0.02706991322338581, -0.02194245159626007, 0.008638589642941952, -0.00699697295203805, -0.007450268603861332, 0.0014390017604455352, -0.00019269695621915162, 0.01024596020579338, 0.015031364746391773, 0.001721061416901648, 0.009267240762710571, -0.018831495195627213, 0.0026430075522512197, 0.004791926592588425, -0.039318688213825226, 0.016329774633049965, -0.02012600190937519, -0.00028121890500187874, 0.05516776815056801, 0.0031798274721950293, -0.005695131607353687, 0.05506883189082146, 0.05186978355050087, 0.013048895634710789, 0.049881402403116226, 0.025854039937257767, -0.0041311816312372684, 0.005126824136823416, 0.012682151049375534, 0.012835093773901463, 0.039971377700567245, -0.011247462593019009, 0.045071572065353394, 0.014760724268853664, -0.0054480405524373055, 0.021291805431246758, 0.05439741536974907, -0.009108423255383968, -0.021169332787394524, -0.002355723176151514, 0.021175548434257507, -0.017241936177015305, -0.001941123977303505, 0.030330142006278038, -0.022052109241485596, 0.02868473529815674, -0.0008664849447086453, 0.009036684408783913, -0.024082647636532784, 0.009894924238324165, -0.03388942778110504, -0.05752088129520416, -0.012295816093683243, -0.009411095641553402, -0.0010004689684137702, -0.06181102246046066, -0.005964187439531088, 0.02212817780673504, -0.026733066886663437, -0.02200319804251194, -0.038185350596904755, -0.050367627292871475, 0.05936894193291664, -0.02888830006122589, 0.03785906359553337, 0.02023761346936226, -0.035245057195425034, 0.007033881265670061, -0.08407042175531387, 0.05825064703822136, -0.0016829571686685085, 0.01693562977015972, -0.009564900770783424, 0.005978756584227085, 0.004168108571320772, -0.004481655545532703, 0.05466530844569206, 0.010174100287258625, 0.017585288733243942, -0.027258355170488358, 0.004135643597692251, 0.006814389489591122, -0.024968642741441727, 0.021785391494631767, 0.010685792192816734, -0.03901129215955734, -0.01663341373205185, -0.017828064039349556, 0.006704853381961584, 0.0022686487063765526, 0.019728126004338264, 0.012313658371567726, 0.037127118557691574, 0.026727108284831047, 0.00728846387937665, 0.07680463045835495, 0.012197562493383884, 0.05392301082611084, 0.03868170455098152, 0.02409873902797699, 0.010156127624213696, 0.004237151239067316, 0.00958073791116476, -0.06816031783819199, 0.006680236663669348, -0.014681118540465832, -0.02220088802278042, -0.002384869148954749, -0.0005474776262417436, 0.006289752200245857, -0.0367266908288002, 0.008087694644927979, -0.0025398049037903547, -0.016935277730226517, 0.025948679074645042, 0.023527711629867554, 0.0032832310535013676, 0.04006735980510712, -0.04606727138161659, 0.03510618209838867, 0.029484132304787636, 0.009551768191158772, 0.009801970794796944, -0.024292701855301857, -0.0008937480743043125, 0.024585291743278503, 0.012229397892951965, 0.014680206775665283, 0.010673858225345612, 0.05615568161010742, -0.027270423248410225, 0.041264597326517105, -0.04027799144387245, -0.025696858763694763, -0.001136571867391467, -0.007145880255848169, 0.03615163266658783, -0.006968897767364979, 0.013527794741094112, 0.057582370936870575, -0.022180907428264618, 0.006538057699799538, -0.04786168038845062, -0.04701593145728111, -0.010474241338670254, 0.00028600188670679927, -0.021436229348182678, 0.05227076634764671, -0.007877604104578495, -0.011097022332251072, -0.0029144517611712217, 0.0042348201386630535, 0.012042215093970299, -0.03559326380491257, 0.06848347187042236, -0.008738509379327297, -0.0011825993424281478, -0.02292439341545105, -0.06778478622436523, -0.023115837946534157, -0.01577950455248356, -0.01773848943412304, 0.03539455309510231, 0.049580492079257965, -0.024964187294244766, -0.03670158609747887, -0.0036640758626163006, 0.00007566761632915586, -0.07656782865524292, -0.021373983472585678, -0.032279133796691895, 0.009422331117093563, -0.021495996043086052, -0.0564737543463707 ]
<p>In <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Girsanov_theorem" rel="nofollow">Girsanov</a> theorem, the change of probability measure variable $Z_t = \frac{dQ}{dP}|_{\mathcal{F}_t}$, why does it need to be a martingale with respect to measure $P$ for the change of measure $\frac{dQ}{dP}$ to exist?</p> <p>I am having trouble understanding this. Anyone familiar with this?</p>
73,536
[ 0.015091965906322002, -0.00031259996467269957, 0.031003538519144058, -0.04525245726108551, 0.042752839624881744, 0.030019095167517662, -0.025903476402163506, -0.02059759385883808, 0.002816207939758897, -0.004159221891313791, 0.024139367043972015, 0.00979949813336134, 0.06421510875225067, -0.010322751477360725, 0.03273526579141617, 0.03464106470346451, -0.013833265751600266, -0.01811092160642147, -0.02889222279191017, -0.010448156856000423, -0.031829625368118286, 0.06152394041419029, 0.05116736516356468, -0.021435055881738663, -0.014966531656682491, 0.014983532950282097, -0.025365756824612617, 0.06119223311543465, 0.025642553344368935, 0.07643407583236694, -0.040783680975437164, -0.016630513593554497, -0.027722539380192757, 0.025863418355584145, 0.011412694118916988, 0.014625458978116512, -0.06855388730764389, -0.022070450708270073, 0.008101504296064377, -0.003837375435978174, -0.03237223997712135, 0.003805172862485051, 0.008875436149537563, 0.05044787377119064, -0.05057377740740776, 0.009725512005388737, -0.004044348374009132, -0.022934816777706146, 0.06836625188589096, -0.016876401379704475, 0.06108413636684418, 0.002073634648695588, 0.01057602372020483, 0.04803871735930443, 0.028472308069467545, 0.011246232315897942, 0.05099472030997276, 0.09030219912528992, -0.04178334400057793, -0.01805281825363636, -0.015879016369581223, -0.0404287725687027, 0.024395909160375595, -0.03441615775227547, -0.02198185585439205, 0.017427321523427963, 0.003721181768923998, -0.021304739639163017, 0.007596480194479227, 0.01764189451932907, 0.016935788094997406, 0.02027229405939579, 0.0207360852509737, -0.013169130310416222, 0.01875223219394684, -0.019614411517977715, 0.023826271295547485, 0.04077575355768204, 0.05501633882522583, 0.03347489982843399, 0.007757266983389854, -0.004868261516094208, 0.015364455990493298, 0.0038189387414604425, 0.028308503329753876, -0.028813716024160385, 0.08481555432081223, 0.005704973824322224, 0.038821253925561905, 0.03185682371258736, -0.03492110222578049, -0.020565086975693703, 0.023594995960593224, -0.0229421965777874, -0.04456259310245514, 0.031877368688583374, -0.011250465176999569, 0.02360999956727028, -0.00497846445068717, -0.01200184691697359, 0.0016600502422079444, -0.048012346029281616, 0.025056658312678337, 0.024114033207297325, -0.009147876873612404, -0.007435910403728485, -0.009995300322771072, -0.022727899253368378, -0.00982770323753357, -0.023197269067168236, -0.029769737273454666, 0.05123268440365791, -0.007111027836799622, 0.009986704215407372, 0.018508683890104294, 0.023479005321860313, -0.026077507063746452, -0.015165523625910282, 0.04105247184634209, 0.05029930919408798, 0.06413974612951279, -0.0044279140420258045, 0.027438780292868614, -0.02719203196465969, -0.07654088735580444, 0.04455265402793884, -0.01802419312298298, 0.025938857346773148, -0.03667735680937767, 0.04310741275548935, -0.004624643828719854, 0.01072657760232687, 0.020773112773895264, 0.04124467819929123, 0.034290675073862076, -0.03984413668513298, -0.07690206915140152, -0.04789379611611366, 0.08711665868759155, -0.01559271290898323, 0.012371617369353771, -0.06364308297634125, 0.011611200869083405, -0.007175506092607975, 0.06114567071199417, -0.008263450115919113, 0.044287875294685364, 0.01632796972990036, 0.04294116795063019, 0.0008133398951031268, -0.028840651735663414, -0.049201954156160355, 0.0007099786307662725, 0.01565157063305378, -0.004702728241682053, -0.043432436883449554, 0.032414089888334274, 0.017637141048908234, -0.048910725861787796, -0.02532794326543808, 0.04322931170463562, -0.027878642082214355, -0.018814589828252792, 0.0003757597878575325, 0.002381759462878108, 0.0032601358834654093, 0.08809870481491089, 0.03390125185251236, 0.003009823616594076, 0.01964319311082363, 0.028626758605241776, 0.030593326315283775, 0.00006608843978028744, 0.09876561164855957, 0.028415396809577942, -0.031136468052864075, -0.030107099562883377, -0.005442480091005564, 0.04165530204772949, 0.017376260831952095, 0.005652065854519606, 0.001199825550429523, -0.04675755649805069, 0.01796613819897175, -0.008889268152415752, 0.03011578880250454, 0.0017431796295568347, 0.043228793889284134, -0.0028536238241940737, -0.08121968805789948, -0.030596815049648285, -0.03911421820521355, 0.026284923776984215, -0.02424168772995472, -0.03398094326257706, 0.008617430925369263, 0.04357736185193062, 0.01093225833028555, -0.03387654200196266, -0.023821905255317688, 0.020645620301365852, -0.00987359881401062, -0.017726905643939972, -0.03183459863066673, 0.013733147643506527, 0.07048158347606659, 0.05730479210615158, 0.008337576873600483, 0.021129842847585678, -0.03440649062395096, -0.01832520216703415, 0.007445342373102903, -0.013121537864208221, -0.014782652258872986, -0.0063862428069114685, -0.01615545153617859, 0.02473754622042179, -0.011974984779953957, 0.012363201007246971, 0.048104703426361084, -0.060018397867679596, 0.013454359024763107, 0.08467479050159454, 0.00593686755746603, -0.005265255458652973, 0.054283708333969116, -0.000664626422803849, 0.029956506565213203, -0.020735230296850204, -0.04372698441147804, -0.052199140191078186, 0.007910954765975475, 0.03970274329185486, 0.03806155174970627, -0.016890021041035652, 0.012522903271019459, 0.059687674045562744, 0.013747542165219784, 0.007102899253368378, 0.06181247904896736, 0.0044066812843084335, -0.035460952669382095, -0.010340112261474133, -0.005791970528662205, 0.0015734952175989747, -0.020578356459736824, -0.0008889671298675239, -0.011301805265247822, -0.003818708937615156, -0.013729454018175602, -0.030664673075079918, 0.03242335841059685, 0.0017383006634190679, 0.03857309743762016, -0.008794782683253288, -0.005410594865679741, 0.01948525197803974, -0.03443188592791557, 0.02412792295217514, 0.024958699941635132, 0.03341388702392578, -0.005437877960503101, 0.00922852847725153, -0.06640810519456863, 0.018314428627490997, 0.044116873294115067, -0.03471491485834122, -0.03302321583032608, 0.026078874245285988, 0.0077964551746845245, -0.009336032904684544, 0.029292071238160133, -0.021691819652915, 0.006150474306195974, -0.018630722537636757, -0.0005916409427300096, -0.013073528185486794, 0.02493426203727722, -0.043774157762527466, -0.03312515839934349, 0.009450351819396019, -0.01981479674577713, 0.023356733843684196, -0.006200185976922512, -0.0333806574344635, 0.023120637983083725, 0.00282023916952312, -0.017194239422678947, 0.045588359236717224, -0.012699879705905914, 0.0509776696562767, -0.0034417202696204185, -0.011315341107547283, -0.04517405480146408, -0.02896275371313095, -0.012627028860151768, 0.034346193075180054, -0.006589740980416536, -0.007172611076384783, 0.0637708231806755, 0.002133272122591734, -0.024526281282305717, 0.02351924031972885, -0.04986937716603279, -0.025874223560094833, -0.04377846419811249, -0.004425260704010725, 0.018127618357539177, -0.025509972125291824, 0.0428665392100811, 0.028733495622873306, -0.08566523343324661, 0.0003465678310021758, -0.03418667986989021, -0.0826188251376152, 0.007529441267251968, -0.009912138804793358, 0.0029790967237204313, -0.014420730993151665, -0.0511300191283226, 0.0788177028298378, 0.02816084772348404, -0.028140297159552574, 0.0027345544658601284, 0.012867257930338383, -0.010966734029352665, -0.06892692297697067, 0.012406222522258759, 0.029136572033166885, -0.05808361992239952, 0.06768254935741425, 0.020062796771526337, 0.03371682018041611, 0.0436193123459816, 0.011959293857216835, -0.014452029019594193, 0.006402811035513878, -0.011723906733095646, 0.03493320196866989, 0.018581906333565712, 0.022987909615039825, -0.05470441281795502, -0.002522449241951108, 0.04731036722660065, 0.05727718397974968, 0.0013667336897924542, -0.06126132607460022, 0.05657115578651428, 0.0036091350484639406, -0.00866524875164032, -0.029454244300723076, 0.05924392119050026, 0.011386786587536335, -0.01740594580769539, 0.007305855862796307, -0.00750544061884284, 0.039988674223423004, -0.03356439620256424, -0.0005292939604260027, 0.025955550372600555, -0.013453546911478043, -0.024655288085341454, 0.013069119304418564, -0.030975831672549248, -0.004690554924309254, 0.01629127748310566, -0.044018592685461044, -0.030844297260046005, 0.045155949890613556, 0.03335393965244293, 0.035467397421598434, -0.03964095190167427, -0.02910858392715454, -0.014843902550637722, -0.02874222956597805, 0.014722547493875027, 0.026827827095985413, 0.02205941639840603, 0.030765123665332794, 0.06098787114024162, -0.0013095359317958355, 0.01562180370092392, 0.011985406279563904, -0.011255371384322643, -0.10205978900194168, 0.03355373814702034, -0.030844997614622116, -0.011525697074830532, -0.02053636498749256, -0.03580199554562569, 0.002995235612615943, -0.02135745994746685, -0.008091297931969166, -0.017818633466959, 0.0026055832859128714, -0.0842832401394844, -0.007722009439021349, -0.015541129745543003, -0.03918903321027756, -0.013543686829507351, 0.0077508860267698765, 0.049245819449424744, -0.030300240963697433, -0.011693030595779419, 0.03533935546875, -0.0012858976842835546, -0.024023737758398056, -0.03583116456866264, 0.02649354562163353, 0.04981240630149841, 0.048678524792194366, 0.05210798978805542, 0.01742212288081646, 0.0011450216406956315, 0.05738307535648346, 0.019432010129094124, 0.04650811851024628, 0.013789394870400429, -0.0189052764326334, -0.04092751070857048, -0.08605904132127762, -0.007585857529193163, 0.02401193603873253, 0.03244326636195183, 0.03962799161672592, 0.005431919824331999, 0.05612482503056526, 0.010466760955750942, -0.0146983927115798, 0.012936154380440712, 0.047762539237737656, 0.0003379784757271409, -0.012358746491372585, -0.024573620408773422, 0.0033627827651798725, -0.03126863017678261, -0.003840622492134571, 0.01411913800984621, -0.009825910441577435, -0.009206200018525124, 0.020344126969575882, -0.008522930555045605, -0.015078729949891567, 0.02562830038368702, -0.020510714501142502, 0.01840827986598015, 0.008843185380101204, 0.040617331862449646, -0.021815111860632896, 0.03303845226764679, 0.00007869255205150694, 0.03158159181475639, 0.020675864070653915, 0.0011717065935954452, -0.036811619997024536, 0.008553396910429, -0.0078026787377893925, 0.041869401931762695, -0.019204571843147278, -0.00729114655405283, -0.0795505940914154, -0.042294833809137344, 0.045741017907857895, -0.024757904931902885, 0.005129237659275532, -0.0373041145503521, -0.02148350514471531, -0.02268061414361, -0.04012405872344971, -0.0019183713011443615, -0.028338365256786346, -0.002223189687356353, 0.03647470101714134, 0.01548316515982151, -0.01764173060655594, -0.03164460510015488, -0.020334525033831596, 0.021143319085240364, 0.022589370608329773, 0.0004484640376176685, 0.020773138850927353, -0.032316483557224274, 0.04860551282763481, -0.02170700393617153, -0.09154686331748962, 0.00967702828347683, -0.03714418038725853, 0.058557067066431046, 0.014059122651815414, -0.009025837294757366, -0.06112102419137955, 0.015619984827935696, 0.021944956853985786, -0.010327457450330257, 0.04215896502137184, 0.005443296395242214, 0.026716014370322227, 0.05142499506473541, 0.001841995632275939, 0.08437307178974152, 0.04791567474603653, 0.011568219400942326, 0.02943439967930317, -0.002689777407795191, 0.026095589622855186, -0.03915322199463844, 0.014846481382846832, -0.04981269687414169, 0.02845855802297592, -0.0050002411007881165, 0.053367242217063904, 0.012934806756675243, -0.012448593974113464, -0.021665170788764954, -0.004706833511590958, -0.014836644753813744, 0.02957666479051113, 0.00792261678725481, -0.03212565556168556, -0.0265622790902853, 0.02120424434542656, -0.001118938555009663, -0.008911420591175556, 0.046178046613931656, -0.030955789610743523, -0.018600821495056152, 0.010299639776349068, -0.0030786017887294292, 0.014614280313253403, -0.02690000832080841, -0.022733835503458977, 0.03326427564024925, -0.0193673986941576, -0.0013744734460487962, -0.006412806920707226, 0.04423730447888374, 0.036007657647132874, -0.04812122881412506, -0.029843250289559364, -0.010338583029806614, -0.008501251228153706, 0.01360305305570364, -0.06961948424577713, 0.013920658268034458, -0.014263581484556198, 0.0034368131309747696, -0.0668901652097702, -0.026206180453300476, 0.030476614832878113, -0.012196982279419899, -0.04901426285505295, -0.022198263555765152, -0.008081269450485706, -0.005310432985424995, -0.03677820414304733, -0.0265637394040823, 0.04634163901209831, 0.011259965598583221, -0.030903011560440063, 0.01655164174735546, 0.0009476666455157101, 0.03982677683234215, -0.027011306956410408, 0.012015563435852528, 0.0011126651661470532, -0.013346445746719837, -0.009104492142796516, 0.002203739248216152, 0.04322711378335953, -0.010046964511275291, -0.005313226953148842, -0.020363178104162216, -0.006249923259019852, 0.0048958235420286655, -0.015606331638991833, 0.016512040048837662, 0.017632607370615005, -0.0040796976536512375, 0.021329283714294434, 0.009187350980937481, -0.009592123329639435, 0.008695714175701141, 0.015817005187273026, 0.006396798882633448, 0.01037907786667347, 0.013136323541402817, -0.018056469038128853, 0.022427117452025414, -0.015387970954179764, 0.03219803422689438, 0.006756625138223171, 0.07816725969314575, -0.022915232926607132, -0.0030996864661574364, 0.019311020150780678, -0.02507110871374607, 0.024160852655768394, -0.034538570791482925, 0.007652265019714832, 0.011074233800172806, -0.011147820390760899, -0.05749357119202614, -0.004987754859030247, -0.042035333812236786, 0.032374296337366104, 0.054034408181905746, -0.003923477604985237, 0.02585792914032936, 0.025781111791729927, -0.007808944676071405, 0.023130351677536964, -0.005398897919803858, 0.01079357136040926, 0.04094543680548668, -0.02514025568962097, 0.0442962609231472, -0.029260629788041115, 0.0040360973216593266, 0.020368466153740883, 0.041894908994436264, 0.002990422071889043, 0.021071242168545723, 0.038029011338949203, 0.012853443622589111, 0.03804711997509003, -0.011671510525047779, -0.05311419814825058, 0.05046531930565834, -0.05147163197398186, 0.0016906139208003879, -0.01976855657994747, -0.019919931888580322, 0.047798290848731995, 0.011134064756333828, 0.008270790800452232, -0.009000315330922604, -0.020518124103546143, -0.04814966768026352, 0.038603927940130234, -0.01746263913810253, 0.03924160078167915, 0.06272080540657043, 0.0049553825519979, 0.05214930325746536, -0.0017052682815119624, -0.012482333928346634, 0.007889794185757637, -0.0251165684312582, -0.02933454141020775, -0.03220720589160919, -0.03258422389626503, 0.013500594533979893, -0.016912421211600304, 0.001895332708954811, -0.004279772285372019, -0.031258370727300644, -0.002415401628240943, -0.0015350414905697107, -0.02872440032660961, -0.02447814680635929, 0.1009923592209816, 0.020264282822608948, 0.02123197540640831, -0.06072612479329109, 0.020115988329052925, 0.10433303564786911, 0.034733351320028305, 0.01236492209136486, -0.08152630925178528, -0.01930052600800991, -0.024553455412387848, -0.015475235879421234, -0.026899302378296852, 0.05064675584435463, 0.02832759916782379, -0.010922741144895554, 0.00077541678911075, 0.045906923711299896, 0.02093653194606304, -0.023564143106341362, 0.04655389487743378, -0.07067589461803436, -0.054601117968559265, 0.027440980076789856, -0.029477434232831, -0.021660907194018364, -0.012205488979816437, -0.007498172577470541, 0.012220115400850773, -0.0077242422848939896, -0.024697372689843178, -0.00632106838747859, -0.026931868866086006, -0.014835740439593792, 0.000588715192861855, -0.011827105656266212, -0.014793560840189457, 0.020179197192192078, 0.006275364197790623, -0.06645135581493378, 0.03068871982395649, -0.001990419579669833, 0.007822143845260143, 0.04044622182846069, 0.005229456350207329, -0.005284136161208153, -0.021260084584355354, 0.017415914684534073, -0.011620762757956982, -0.002215595915913582, -0.011111048050224781, -0.0270346999168396, 0.03496771678328514, -0.0005309432162903249, -0.006750169210135937, -0.004139389842748642, 0.013011710718274117, -0.004134888760745525, -0.06357807666063309, -0.008899589069187641, 0.011715840548276901, -0.0002516171371098608, -0.001439036801457405, 0.003370126476511359, -0.02559731900691986, -0.018880877643823624, -0.01134684681892395, 0.015426479279994965, -0.011349467560648918, -0.0488581657409668, 0.0007886755629442632, -0.01913178339600563, 0.028506066650152206, -0.021763604134321213, -0.009838491678237915, -0.0006127757369540632, 0.004871310666203499, -0.051633402705192566, -0.049152672290802, -0.013844805769622326, -0.006220607552677393, 0.025326434522867203, 0.010005827061831951, -0.02136879414319992, 0.025102507323026657, -0.0526777058839798, 0.046076275408267975, -0.020815517753362656, 0.013196040876209736, -0.04551507160067558, -0.004122916609048843, 0.007653819862753153, 0.03923361003398895, 0.00406322767958045, 0.0013424147618934512, -0.03372349962592125, 0.009937385097146034, 0.0306733138859272, -0.02261517383158207, 0.003499081591144204, -0.01030250359326601, -0.02953033708035946, 0.003705884562805295, -0.05561980605125427, 0.04101473093032837, 0.023494910448789597, 0.006782988086342812, -0.03143506869673729, -0.0012224612291902304, -0.04065612331032753, 0.025909066200256348, 0.007120800670236349, -0.021099518984556198, -0.006569220684468746, 0.04241595417261124, 0.04218174144625664, -0.03596450015902519, -0.02893149107694626, -0.01095364149659872, 0.0064937649294734, 0.0003569206455722451, 0.009120787493884563, -0.060973599553108215, -0.02126590721309185, -0.026538128033280373, 0.04753360152244568, 0.0020013130269944668, -0.021379929035902023, -0.04523162916302681, 0.024393433704972267, 0.002836514264345169, 0.008224830962717533, -0.009059646166861057, -0.009409073740243912, -0.014557167887687683, -0.03600672632455826, 0.010999771766364574, 0.038857001811265945, -0.027246324345469475, 0.004627313930541277, 0.022237103432416916, -0.013758847489953041, 0.01740165241062641, -0.04000958055257797, -0.028217913582921028, 0.05842236056923866, -0.07416531443595886, -0.01828571781516075, 0.020514292642474174, 0.035979870706796646, 0.018066175282001495, -0.0032831889111548662, 0.002014479599893093, -0.03555208444595337, 0.032173048704862595, -0.0019748269114643335, -0.01592089608311653, -0.009579571895301342, -0.041006628423929214, 0.020628878846764565, -0.03710632026195526, 0.007787281647324562, 0.0349586196243763, 0.02384408563375473, 0.015515763312578201, 0.04259851574897766, 0.0008287230157293379, 0.008776371367275715, 0.03269634768366814, -0.02239576168358326, 0.019664093852043152, 0.015847867354750633, 0.02256813459098339, 0.031447507441043854, 0.0445561520755291, -0.016684366390109062, -0.03749489784240723, -0.020287081599235535, 0.007400269154459238, -0.08873903006315231, 0.021142002195119858, 0.02624705620110035, -0.005398137960582972, 0.03446343541145325, -0.045398276299238205, 0.007751817349344492, -0.005654334090650082, -0.06289707124233246, -0.01738668605685234, -0.026561414822936058, -0.035631220787763596, -0.05087566375732422, -0.01635289378464222, -0.027993876487016678, 0.07487744837999344, 0.03968104347586632, -0.004602132830768824, 0.055911220610141754, -0.004652358591556549, 0.0007835552096366882, -0.023045752197504044, -0.00021852993813809007, 0.018351081758737564, -0.03479274734854698, -0.03440164402127266, 0.04179396107792854, -0.02201787382364273, -0.023856790736317635, 0.0371987409889698, -0.0025230320170521736, 0.006568793207406998, -0.008624509908258915, 0.02332264743745327, 0.019778966903686523, 0.01288710255175829, 0.03946134075522423, 0.018766280263662338, 0.021424036473035812, -0.022484304383397102, -0.00010731331713031977, 0.001734740799292922, 0.006921655964106321, 0.012337644584476948, 0.020969104021787643, -0.015872644260525703, -0.010376246646046638, -0.038995690643787384, -0.000887286092620343, -0.011562935076653957, 0.026996824890375137, 0.008144271560013294, 0.012650229968130589, -0.009547067806124687, 0.03630197420716286, -0.024910995736718178, -0.01369412150233984, 0.043561797589063644, 0.04812638834118843, 0.006104495842009783, -0.026161890476942062, -0.002204484073445201, -0.07134879380464554, 0.043845970183610916, 0.01739444024860859, -0.03945048898458481, -0.04700348153710365, -0.00868496298789978, -0.026181386783719063, -0.007686843629926443, -0.026700126007199287, -0.005943464580923319, -0.046394333243370056, -0.00023715751012787223, -0.021099068224430084, 0.013628972694277763, -0.04017510637640953, -0.01987040601670742, 0.010923421941697598, -0.06495197117328644, 0.07405553013086319, -0.015427632257342339, -0.04237964376807213, -0.019300471991300583, -0.03710831329226494, -0.0317290835082531, -0.027991365641355515, 0.029719237238168716, 0.005696546286344528, 0.00556648476049304, 0.006060145795345306, 0.0015514130936935544, 0.04548460245132446, -0.03617118299007416, 0.01235491968691349, -0.03656303882598877, -0.02423563040792942, -0.011759939603507519, 0.0012633348815143108, 0.02738194167613983, 0.01117141917347908, 0.01027070265263319, 0.024294167757034302, 0.04409981146454811, -0.029823150485754013, -0.004365584347397089, 0.018754085525870323, 0.022493423894047737, -0.016052577644586563, 0.05414680391550064, -0.03499262034893036, 0.02720133401453495, -0.006479308940470219, -0.009538091719150543, -0.059602733701467514, 0.007960699498653412, -0.03348099812865257, 0.011802216991782188, -0.011705629527568817, 0.02102937363088131, 0.009209691546857357, -0.02568441443145275, -0.022269584238529205, 0.034761618822813034, -0.04996413365006447, -0.002585804322734475, 0.04809318482875824, 0.02245441824197769, 0.07549143582582474, 0.009400581009685993, -0.019679954275488853, 0.0020221504382789135, 0.0119789345189929, 0.009850410744547844, 0.018812667578458786, 0.05444147437810898, 0.0014672239776700735, 0.029769323766231537, 0.017638806253671646, -0.024333572015166283, -0.01541128009557724, 0.02068173512816429, 0.024823985993862152, -0.009437352418899536, -0.06388716399669647, -0.010111001320183277, -0.009126922115683556, 0.005562281236052513, 0.041081465780735016, -0.02898879162967205, 0.055319901555776596, -0.009130883030593395, 0.01109803095459938, 0.017644347622990608, 0.017474211752414703, -0.025690501555800438, 0.010811707936227322, 0.0399538017809391, -0.01037443708628416, -0.012852031737565994, 0.030193043872714043, -0.0006130214896984398, 0.020116763189435005, 0.016422385349869728, -0.03023746982216835, -0.0031116660684347153, 0.032920464873313904, -0.030090143904089928, -0.022915778681635857, 0.0015944214537739754, -0.0061514126136898994, -0.01866833120584488, 0.003246612846851349, 0.055845316499471664, 0.00018210479174740613, -0.005267331376671791, -0.03445683792233467, -0.01035122200846672, 0.04325905814766884, -0.08509333431720734, -0.01952539011836052, -0.01985505409538746, 0.008229873143136501, -0.018561633303761482, 0.03672712296247482 ]
<p>I have same data and I would like to choose a model for it. To start with I fit an exponential distribution and a gamma distribution. Now I wanted to do a simple <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Likelihood-ratio_test" rel="nofollow">likelihood ratio test</a> . However, I am told that to do this properly the two models have to be nested (which they are) and the parameter space of one has to be in the interior of the other, not on the boundary. This second condition doesn't seem to hold unfortunately. </p> <p>What can I do?</p>
73,537
[ -0.012117555364966393, -0.013828448951244354, 0.017394859343767166, 0.004178657196462154, -0.028235839679837227, -0.0010896000312641263, 0.022278204560279846, -0.0013489495031535625, 0.04555254429578781, -0.023794816806912422, 0.03340694308280945, 0.06349465250968933, 0.0498899482190609, 0.0040642935782670975, 0.007482447195798159, 0.02531040646135807, -0.008095061406493187, 0.02762087620794773, 0.001714089303277433, -0.042911652475595474, 0.006165257189422846, -0.024841096252202988, 0.01790841668844223, -0.025558117777109146, -0.0319032222032547, 0.030799223110079765, 0.059413325041532516, -0.03303486108779907, 0.009331652894616127, 0.05647541582584381, -0.01779904216527939, -0.04715169221162796, 0.003411708166822791, 0.059782784432172775, -0.0010381423635408282, -0.008143199607729912, -0.017811520025134087, -0.022538434714078903, -0.024630039930343628, 0.043043896555900574, -0.031922388821840286, -0.03601547330617905, -0.002912116004154086, 0.014568906277418137, 0.00010945060785161331, 0.01289447396993637, 0.007070671301335096, -0.009284629486501217, 0.024377254769206047, -0.0481930673122406, 0.06064208969473839, -0.01623060554265976, 0.006662929896265268, 0.06963910162448883, 0.027954788878560066, -0.03453587368130684, 0.05006788671016693, 0.08685324341058731, 0.005021264776587486, -0.054800234735012054, -0.03582674637436867, -0.014662232249975204, -0.020459700375795364, -0.030706185847520828, -0.02756020613014698, 0.017099348828196526, -0.004153436981141567, -0.01990940049290657, 0.04203420504927635, 0.007084910292178392, 0.016045739874243736, 0.010748524218797684, 0.04559088125824928, -0.022205868735909462, 0.02460024319589138, 0.002825848525390029, 0.030473504215478897, 0.06152665987610817, 0.03381581977009773, 0.010535907931625843, -0.03540336713194847, 0.010734595358371735, 0.03440592810511589, 0.03081573359668255, 0.00047992236795835197, 0.007448739837855101, 0.06487347930669785, 0.001729284762404859, -0.041788987815380096, 0.019949786365032196, -0.055075258016586304, 0.010063009336590767, 0.05988951772451401, -0.007719688583165407, -0.00559514993801713, 0.059415966272354126, -0.006494414061307907, 0.04353100061416626, -0.014905416406691074, -0.00542702991515398, -0.01961350068449974, -0.046361830085515976, -0.011549361050128937, 0.05208588391542435, 0.04086151346564293, 0.009872343391180038, -0.0005758554325439036, -0.007853043265640736, -0.03367249295115471, -0.01284768246114254, -0.026943640783429146, 0.05023105442523956, -0.01688273996114731, 0.004921071697026491, 0.009127766825258732, -0.022926446050405502, -0.027964681386947632, -0.049679700285196304, 0.06065845862030983, 0.04019341245293617, 0.05195590853691101, -0.039438873529434204, 0.01969224214553833, -0.03983864188194275, -0.07950958609580994, -0.013951151631772518, 0.003559629200026393, -0.0004839817702304572, -0.04164956510066986, 0.07568463683128357, -0.019211048260331154, -0.03635268285870552, 0.04790389537811279, 0.016242239624261856, 0.07629797607660294, 0.012155722826719284, -0.06678567081689835, -0.06385823339223862, 0.029900413006544113, -0.00923655740916729, 0.013669868931174278, -0.06486262381076813, -0.005573688540607691, 0.04185684770345688, 0.06521792709827423, 0.011653909459710121, 0.047897882759571075, -0.005543109495192766, 0.047355033457279205, 0.019666973501443863, -0.021277956664562225, -0.03196338936686516, -0.05393075570464134, 0.014356592670083046, 0.04015764966607094, -0.06877803802490234, 0.018333442509174347, -0.012225084006786346, -0.04206712916493416, 0.013412915170192719, 0.047151900827884674, -0.020435726270079613, -0.010064252652227879, -0.023615360260009766, 0.019868548959493637, -0.045721907168626785, 0.05472688004374504, -0.016230180859565735, 0.0015278966166079044, 0.018687523901462555, -0.015758143737912178, -0.02707003243267536, 0.016730861738324165, 0.00471405079588294, 0.025717196986079216, -0.013498353771865368, -0.006261423695832491, -0.016505468636751175, 0.04192186892032623, 0.06033932417631149, -0.004828157834708691, 0.020364871248602867, -0.020275024697184563, 0.0002135187532985583, 0.021139318123459816, 0.03503076732158661, 0.010425221174955368, -0.04741370305418968, 0.022128304466605186, -0.05614390969276428, -0.06280980259180069, -0.0280382689088583, 0.005801667459309101, -0.02147502824664116, 0.00029468024149537086, 0.03718116879463196, -0.02223656140267849, -0.0032138836104422808, -0.01803545467555523, -0.029988929629325867, -0.038026828318834305, -0.027229802682995796, 0.008327626623213291, -0.00157822051551193, 0.0030155836138874292, 0.027918001636862755, 0.0717519223690033, -0.048044633120298386, 0.04252631217241287, -0.014352694153785706, -0.018647925928235054, -0.005542409606277943, -0.03327333182096481, -0.008230329491198063, 0.005730447359383106, -0.0168633870780468, -0.003137210151180625, 0.009531921707093716, 0.004180160351097584, 0.035664282739162445, -0.0349775068461895, 0.07573315501213074, 0.05256643146276474, 0.0247809998691082, 0.026793604716658592, 0.00793436635285616, 0.015805426985025406, 0.05111158639192581, -0.033934082835912704, 0.009956754744052887, -0.04732344299554825, 0.007268836256116629, 0.046326376497745514, -0.040636997669935226, -0.029955903068184853, 0.026004552841186523, 0.04249067232012749, 0.002698454773053527, -0.005100706592202187, 0.06085716933012009, -0.0035312252584844828, -0.036734048277139664, 0.01184085477143526, 0.024390846490859985, 0.005367227829992771, 0.020023591816425323, 0.022829484194517136, -0.01855045184493065, 0.04857442155480385, -0.03841029107570648, 0.002286340342834592, 0.04616634547710419, -0.015500029549002647, 0.0252357367426157, -0.013281467370688915, 0.008825051598250866, 0.04867657274007797, -0.007796979043632746, 0.011194486171007156, 0.020942900329828262, -0.021972980350255966, -0.003251690650358796, -0.0019533077720552683, 0.018461959436535835, 0.028015341609716415, 0.030459025874733925, -0.03262763470411301, 0.0324498675763607, 0.02610062249004841, -0.03307418152689934, -0.0035451024305075407, 0.02489728108048439, -0.003477774327620864, -0.05081981420516968, 0.019761132076382637, 0.017198890447616577, -0.00778996292501688, 0.006757510360330343, -0.0021370500326156616, -0.0716760903596878, 0.014077556319534779, -0.028885740786790848, 0.03778539597988129, -0.008744764141738415, -0.04069073498249054, 0.027004530653357506, -0.02746601402759552, -0.01453147642314434, 0.040326692163944244, 0.008566953241825104, 0.005363656207919121, -0.03445674851536751, -0.00029752557747997344, -0.017517898231744766, -0.02878056839108467, 0.0017159957205876708, 0.003935286309570074, -0.015421858988702297, -0.021439505741000175, 0.06322973221540451, -0.0036665252409875393, -0.047846291214227676, 0.01108538918197155, -0.04250146076083183, -0.0514599084854126, -0.03279493376612663, 0.0003662614617496729, 0.004318900406360626, 0.011998391710221767, 0.019108319655060768, 0.06416437774896622, -0.03261767700314522, -0.00018965473282150924, -0.1008627861738205, -0.07047705352306366, 0.026520002633333206, -0.0033940430730581284, -0.005629530642181635, -0.010140967555344105, -0.040924377739429474, 0.03925284370779991, 0.019742678850889206, -0.00517128873616457, -0.04887867346405983, 0.013391859829425812, -0.06134337559342384, -0.025747312232851982, 0.010987267829477787, 0.011667365208268166, -0.019961807876825333, 0.012216106988489628, 0.020814303308725357, 0.023215277120471, 0.006488071288913488, 0.005897400435060263, 0.007310131564736366, 0.048845503479242325, 0.030674505978822708, -0.022762766107916832, 0.04233458265662193, 0.04026111215353012, 0.015002822503447533, 0.016391385346651077, -0.017323898151516914, 0.004914283286780119, 0.006236643064767122, -0.03860126808285713, -0.008915366604924202, -0.006993552669882774, -0.033355068415403366, -0.01430333312600851, 0.004027996677905321, 0.038169968873262405, -0.04489543288946152, 0.016667047515511513, 0.04747123271226883, 0.01801840402185917, 0.008788940496742725, 0.011822624132037163, 0.04273182153701782, 0.050001271069049835, -0.017583651468157768, -0.02826225571334362, -0.0011321057099848986, -0.015110532753169537, 0.03139946982264519, -0.005226008594036102, -0.034983858466148376, 0.0513782799243927, 0.046401627361774445, 0.036579109728336334, -0.01520079467445612, -0.056607697159051895, -0.008865510113537312, -0.059651318937540054, 0.009524960070848465, -0.009035770781338215, 0.065004363656044, 0.03630479425191879, 0.016882631927728653, 0.024144722148776054, -0.04315442591905594, 0.04493296518921852, 0.0183426346629858, -0.0710005983710289, 0.030740000307559967, 0.0054011414758861065, 0.014687920920550823, 0.00014592075604014099, -0.015272155404090881, 0.011904356069862843, -0.033787988126277924, 0.003042957279831171, 0.024968260899186134, 0.014537425711750984, -0.04632717743515968, -0.010714002884924412, -0.059676844626665115, 0.014703732915222645, -0.018041227012872696, 0.01930251158773899, 0.003661450929939747, 0.010387368500232697, -0.009379859082400799, 0.06251309812068939, -0.007953766733407974, -0.02132648602128029, -0.01842161826789379, 0.003652632934972644, 0.026435354724526405, 0.05801507085561752, 0.030900772660970688, 0.028120754286646843, -0.03074583038687706, 0.02199007198214531, 0.03363892436027527, 0.028927650302648544, 0.04426738992333412, -0.0348702073097229, -0.026441901922225952, -0.04821871593594551, -0.045134060084819794, -0.018582092598080635, 0.04445870593190193, 0.001300317351706326, -0.033935483545064926, 0.05420971289277077, 0.02540263719856739, -0.006004529073834419, 0.007731428369879723, 0.07217507064342499, 0.006396478973329067, -0.014774981886148453, 0.011571202427148819, -0.032212916761636734, -0.021232541650533676, -0.016235755756497383, 0.01767273247241974, 0.005800512153655291, -0.031350065022706985, -0.041532550007104874, 0.029747333377599716, -0.019788123667240143, -0.003969936165958643, 0.003528566798195243, 0.0035976250655949116, 0.012743005529046059, 0.0004577070940285921, -0.06464271992444992, 0.02769443392753601, 0.0074447463266551495, 0.07118769735097885, 0.0570029690861702, -0.0003551811387296766, -0.08352310955524445, -0.010216347873210907, 0.07213184237480164, -0.018536530435085297, -0.009082282893359661, -0.036241564899683, -0.012043642811477184, -0.04018443077802658, 0.03644821420311928, -0.017590351402759552, 0.015444896183907986, -0.009476429782807827, 0.011030868627130985, -0.002297251718118787, -0.02320149540901184, -0.03540881723165512, 0.023958124220371246, 0.000879711820743978, -0.01799118146300316, -0.0345938615500927, -0.00004172238186583854, -0.06420549750328064, 0.031932782381772995, -0.004900126717984676, 0.038300447165966034, -0.018474359065294266, -0.0249207504093647, 0.04567465931177139, -0.0009545133798383176, -0.023061884567141533, -0.04742695018649101, 0.02148275263607502, -0.02361224964261055, 0.007765038870275021, 0.024087421596050262, 0.01391261164098978, -0.033034343272447586, 0.0041898139752447605, 0.010721307247877121, -0.03609948605298996, 0.010183143429458141, 0.01115549635142088, 0.01900589093565941, -0.0029001429211348295, 0.0014866216806694865, 0.055479325354099274, 0.044843949377536774, -0.01124768890440464, -0.03483070433139801, -0.041385717689991, 0.02123979665338993, -0.027514087036252022, 0.004290684126317501, -0.05998976528644562, 0.0020875607151538134, -0.03829577937722206, 0.030475659295916557, -0.001770267728716135, 0.0328257717192173, -0.03059018962085247, -0.029493410140275955, -0.006898363120853901, 0.022423069924116135, -0.03977515920996666, -0.010682820342481136, 0.024519015103578568, 0.008727451786398888, 0.007371271029114723, -0.02623947337269783, -0.0068158479407429695, -0.04954843968153, 0.0016581837553530931, 0.012607631273567677, -0.04471951350569725, -0.009896269999444485, -0.016314471140503883, -0.02407217212021351, 0.008171497844159603, -0.005701594054698944, 0.045817527920007706, 0.007329454645514488, 0.015594108030200005, 0.026552937924861908, -0.02391715534031391, -0.0017702284967526793, 0.017199065536260605, -0.0004322003514971584, 0.036882080137729645, -0.02668326161801815, 0.03348569944500923, -0.017254415899515152, -0.025619233027100563, -0.08871078491210938, -0.028818266466259956, 0.020290037617087364, -0.0017541467677801847, -0.022148380056023598, -0.06276961416006088, -0.00828093383461237, -0.00703688059002161, -0.011246072128415108, -0.03384174779057503, 0.0732349380850792, 0.010975855402648449, 0.018096856772899628, 0.002816734602674842, 0.045816466212272644, 0.06065801903605461, 0.03287310153245926, 0.02156706340610981, 0.03397928923368454, -0.013357087038457394, 0.002328913426026702, 0.029455095529556274, 0.022365622222423553, -0.036330077797174454, -0.010525209829211235, -0.015751345083117485, 0.03423053398728371, 0.046749379485845566, -0.04809398576617241, -0.019402774050831795, 0.031610168516635895, 0.008180291391909122, 0.028209513053297997, -0.03322139009833336, -0.01755455695092678, -0.03258394077420235, 0.0003745235444512218, -0.03608056157827377, 0.019425641745328903, -0.016576241701841354, -0.02731882780790329, 0.02992135100066662, -0.017642535269260406, -0.00658213347196579, 0.03266056999564171, 0.10238967090845108, 0.019407140091061592, -0.027330050244927406, -0.003452348057180643, 0.013340185396373272, 0.024581685662269592, -0.014305708929896355, -0.00876475591212511, 0.03331037238240242, 0.07054902613162994, -0.05391237139701843, -0.00942282471805811, -0.02138538286089897, -0.011016304604709148, 0.03990538418292999, -0.02967432141304016, 0.0766008049249649, 0.013569807633757591, 0.007372835651040077, 0.011790117248892784, -0.01422080397605896, -0.02284429781138897, -0.02656704932451248, -0.007739040069282055, 0.0443040169775486, -0.00639463821426034, 0.015274000354111195, 0.05022883042693138, 0.008881472051143646, -0.0126906493678689, 0.04254859313368797, 0.02053801156580448, 0.021100405603647232, 0.031985823065042496, -0.004162426106631756, -0.017867300659418106, 0.05264444649219513, -0.04576058313250542, 0.0350475013256073, -0.02628379873931408, -0.005905318073928356, 0.04155649244785309, 0.07778327912092209, -0.014784315600991249, -0.027785414829850197, -0.0042664953507483006, -0.07561066001653671, 0.05608706176280975, 0.056940168142318726, 0.005678113549947739, 0.029543548822402954, 0.0667819157242775, 0.04470590502023697, -0.0072735147550702095, -0.014821204356849194, -0.02754083275794983, -0.059332769364118576, -0.00585280591621995, -0.010943823494017124, -0.04679657891392708, 0.010201663710176945, 0.00428543146699667, -0.01492950040847063, 0.03853543475270271, -0.012961693108081818, -0.004513422958552837, -0.004319077357649803, 0.024512238800525665, -0.02521531842648983, 0.08196459710597992, 0.004093728959560394, -0.021711478009819984, -0.02574387937784195, 0.01889239065349102, 0.11906605958938599, 0.06559307128190994, 0.019041437655687332, -0.08204902708530426, 0.02357427589595318, -0.012371763586997986, -0.006123797036707401, -0.013536099344491959, 0.011180118657648563, 0.03531557321548462, -0.012128759175539017, 0.04489721730351448, 0.06330066919326782, -0.0022807770874351263, -0.03550026938319206, 0.07595010846853256, -0.010655867867171764, -0.04981499910354614, 0.015441772527992725, 0.008037107065320015, -0.008454309776425362, -0.032225944101810455, -0.016914114356040955, 0.022115949541330338, -0.019482174888253212, 0.01388595625758171, -0.026145089417696, -0.051568083465099335, 0.028849465772509575, -0.015099097974598408, -0.028182663023471832, -0.006275779101997614, 0.016833532601594925, 0.023547964170575142, 0.0069518014788627625, -0.0005741757922805846, 0.0032508326694369316, -0.017681099474430084, -0.009321380406618118, 0.03385549783706665, 0.024841977283358574, -0.00967406015843153, -0.013206218369305134, 0.00013486441457644105, -0.03304677829146385, -0.03302460536360741, -0.045732516795396805, 0.03929965943098068, -0.0013399559538811445, -0.006408648565411568, 0.013036583550274372, 0.023893220350146294, -0.009503558278083801, -0.022233283147215843, -0.007954408414661884, 0.0019367232453078032, 0.035395700484514236, -0.024575894698500633, -0.016213001683354378, -0.028928078711032867, 0.051498040556907654, -0.0026886791456490755, 0.03614121675491333, 0.021312175318598747, -0.03758712857961655, -0.01847185380756855, -0.05464284494519234, 0.07888844609260559, -0.008679618127644062, -0.01584996096789837, 0.022068986669182777, -0.04063888639211655, -0.001562972436659038, -0.004295198246836662, 0.020335853099822998, -0.0056088585406541824, 0.03383295238018036, -0.0001550662418594584, -0.022145956754684448, -0.00351944612339139, -0.04479518532752991, -0.021449729800224304, -0.01614641584455967, -0.004584914539009333, -0.05614401400089264, -0.006563425995409489, 0.02215542644262314, 0.020342741161584854, 0.013274962082505226, 0.00659927586093545, 0.017085356637835503, 0.04586796835064888, 0.0032057983335107565, -0.05961475521326065, -0.012467741966247559, -0.015409515239298344, -0.03414645791053772, -0.0009106670040637255, -0.02589062787592411, 0.03679303824901581, -0.016271457076072693, 0.040197815746068954, 0.025365693494677544, 0.0184632558375597, -0.022294603288173676, 0.001608109101653099, -0.03326689451932907, -0.021493839100003242, -0.0067840274423360825, 0.005705057643353939, 0.007526478264480829, -0.009029211476445198, -0.02228015474975109, -0.04551900923252106, -0.018797164782881737, 0.00913699995726347, -0.00264745787717402, -0.05132230743765831, 0.008353954181075096, -0.02579190954566002, 0.006446531508117914, -0.0147629976272583, 0.019763024523854256, -0.01011754386126995, -0.0302758626639843, 0.005068802274763584, 0.005056080874055624, -0.018790235742926598, -0.00860258936882019, -0.030696706846356392, -0.019883906468749046, 0.0060605816543102264, 0.015121695585548878, -0.008527816273272038, 0.01845131814479828, 0.012467745691537857, 0.0007479198393411934, 0.03351961076259613, -0.027642743661999702, 0.005655466113239527, 0.053661372512578964, -0.032506003975868225, -0.047952502965927124, -0.003446384333074093, -0.003014477202668786, 0.010726421140134335, 0.006503051612526178, -0.006179539021104574, 0.003553053131327033, 0.030592873692512512, 0.010172873735427856, -0.003946421202272177, -0.02694266103208065, -0.004740122240036726, 0.015782520174980164, -0.02087409980595112, 0.010405095294117928, 0.00878689531236887, 0.014802520163357258, 0.008379532024264336, 0.012534074485301971, -0.0031130784191191196, -0.024660389870405197, -0.00732260849326849, 0.008195241913199425, 0.05182189866900444, -0.007392640691250563, -0.0208436269313097, 0.05674033612012863, 0.041041579097509384, 0.005250048357993364, 0.001598083646968007, -0.018449651077389717, -0.006896649952977896, -0.06744210422039032, -0.02415599673986435, 0.01800922118127346, -0.018101394176483154, 0.027069590985774994, -0.05423978343605995, -0.010798864997923374, 0.03408820182085037, -0.024219127371907234, -0.04360247030854225, 0.031092744320631027, 0.01399052981287241, -0.021664908155798912, -0.039226606488227844, -0.030616236850619316, 0.0332479290664196, 0.02503177337348461, 0.036641404032707214, 0.03196442127227783, 0.011559569276869297, 0.004378206096589565, -0.006970251444727182, 0.003909732215106487, 0.006174167152494192, 0.0184165108948946, -0.02870994806289673, 0.015318553894758224, -0.025574639439582825, -0.004654830787330866, 0.009422624483704567, -0.009020431898534298, 0.012714877724647522, 0.001534605398774147, 0.016300225630402565, 0.021480625495314598, 0.04942730814218521, 0.07286111265420914, 0.02818184345960617, -0.00021728011779487133, 0.014525095000863075, 0.024164650589227676, 0.0024273947346955538, -0.030472910031676292, 0.009616594761610031, -0.0014223981415852904, -0.0135133545845747, 0.017588015645742416, 0.012767421081662178, -0.01798047125339508, 0.010424038395285606, -0.002623798558488488, -0.05544719472527504, 0.013269094750285149, -0.012017056345939636, -0.007331751752644777, -0.041775867342948914, 0.012020159512758255, 0.03996763005852699, 0.043626975268125534, -0.03167792409658432, -0.010627725161612034, -0.014747188426554203, -0.06477082520723343, -0.01699872501194477, 0.044305868446826935, -0.01576128788292408, -0.029138267040252686, -0.027602262794971466, 0.0014675187412649393, -0.012798533774912357, -0.03224751725792885, -0.011126921512186527, -0.05638624355196953, 0.029938241466879845, -0.034127622842788696, 0.029608631506562233, 0.024177197366952896, 0.0014375427272170782, 0.03273266181349754, -0.06811277568340302, 0.058646123856306076, 0.004653797019273043, -0.038520269095897675, -0.023661592975258827, 0.0013827839866280556, 0.0070593333803117275, -0.03133240342140198, 0.055197034031152725, 0.007316383998841047, -0.014584728516638279, 0.0026835063472390175, 0.02425250969827175, -0.006813834421336651, -0.05404532328248024, 0.017131907865405083, -0.011109322309494019, -0.0422062911093235, -0.0201155636459589, 0.008328425697982311, 0.045161910355091095, 0.02750365622341633, 0.004966442473232746, 0.0015605927910655737, -0.008907288312911987, 0.02542892098426819, -0.022607985883951187, -0.022664707154035568, -0.05014964938163757, -0.02085903100669384, 0.051017146557569504, -0.01042423490434885, -0.01123647578060627, -0.007533978670835495, -0.003869341453537345, -0.03747573494911194, 0.039854153990745544, -0.020967375487089157, -0.010903819464147091, 0.0013159604277461767, 0.02568896859884262, -0.0026494434569031, -0.02520543336868286, -0.048526596277952194, 0.027065034955739975, -0.0748554989695549, -0.01949511468410492, 0.01158587820827961, 0.02814352698624134, 0.04473896697163582, -0.029142457991838455, 0.02833898738026619, 0.0195965263992548, -0.02279237098991871, -0.010362048633396626, -0.007436685264110565, 0.05958188325166702, -0.03382016718387604, -0.002279625041410327, 0.039839137345552444, -0.020825926214456558, 0.02725408785045147, -0.04467758536338806, 0.03191666305065155, -0.027277320623397827, -0.0062207854352891445, 0.03393951803445816, 0.0004450590640772134, 0.012095723301172256, -0.03874883055686951, -0.024090014398097992, 0.07035855948925018, -0.0241010170429945, -0.002678279997780919, -0.012833810411393642, 0.020940618589520454, -0.010917934589087963, 0.043142519891262054, 0.057105548679828644, -0.03414835035800934, 0.054595738649368286, 0.004134885035455227, -0.01132192462682724, -0.033873047679662704, 0.03242633119225502, -0.00044544346746988595, 0.007486135698854923, -0.018705809488892555, -0.01929832436144352, -0.023996014147996902, 0.0024893772788345814, -0.030795840546488762, -0.03437438979744911, 0.025992179289460182, 0.014309568330645561, 0.02108968235552311, -0.009654771536588669, -0.027657924219965935, 0.014701350592076778, 0.0337974950671196, -0.08574705570936203, -0.029659640043973923, -0.042292263358831406, -0.010988989844918251, 0.028969570994377136, -0.018220815807580948 ]
<p>In my data, some individuals have missing data on the central predictor (father missed the intake assessment). Comparing the DVs' means for those with a missing/non-missing predictor yielded some sizeable effects.</p> <p>Now I want to find out whether the systematic missings may have led me to underestimate the size of the OLS regression coefficients. What's a good way to do this?</p> <p>Simply comparing the variances of the DVs in the group without missings to the group with missings is easy to do?<br> But conceptually I want to know whether the whole sample has significantly less variability when I leave the group with missings (and significantly-lower-than-average-scores) out, not whether the two groups (with missings and without missings) have different variances.<br> All that I found so far was about independent samples, not about subsets.</p> <p>Also, just to bring me up to speed: heteroscedasticity is usually used in the context of residual variance, right? What's a good term for constricted variance that would give me better luck with google?</p>
73,538
[ -0.02048671618103981, 0.011575710028409958, 0.018277691677212715, -0.009470909833908081, 0.08524412661790848, 0.024873176589608192, -0.016153745353221893, -0.04956788942217827, 0.015251634642481804, 0.0033336204942315817, 0.04822247847914696, -0.008648496121168137, 0.07009705901145935, 0.008447190746665001, 0.0033109874930232763, 0.00558192003518343, -0.021412229165434837, -0.0052444604225456715, -0.0013135963818058372, -0.002413083566352725, -0.019885241985321045, 0.022443072870373726, -0.0003879496071022004, -0.026752792298793793, 0.0002784419630188495, 0.03828661888837814, 0.05251934379339218, -0.002850190969184041, 0.008798851631581783, 0.022352777421474457, -0.0645216703414917, -0.024609189480543137, 0.013487718068063259, 0.02810942381620407, 0.03108922950923443, -0.006957930512726307, -0.005026473198086023, -0.0348132885992527, -0.006333335768431425, 0.04506103694438934, -0.04093506932258606, -0.022212913259863853, -0.045838385820388794, 0.040489938110113144, 0.009504100307822227, 0.03444491699337959, -0.028180204331874847, 0.004608660005033016, 0.04226918891072273, -0.05405823513865471, 0.0650765597820282, -0.00562160462141037, 0.04140515252947807, 0.04603845253586769, -0.00838554184883833, 0.007640299387276173, 0.027431031689047813, 0.05394940450787544, -0.0067057013511657715, -0.027270743623375893, -0.03044389747083187, 0.004976572003215551, 0.033582162111997604, 0.00616282457485795, -0.021585214883089066, 0.008983413688838482, 0.005834001116454601, -0.05266736075282097, 0.032407812774181366, -0.02497200109064579, 0.0014962302520871162, 0.00810131523758173, 0.018995245918631554, 0.011209198273718357, 0.007779720705002546, -0.01930178701877594, 0.0023032263852655888, -0.003918697126209736, 0.03214685246348381, 0.04469142109155655, 0.023640651255846024, 0.022785549983382225, 0.01185694057494402, 0.0009133238927461207, 0.011256285943090916, 0.0038699365686625242, 0.031123017892241478, -0.025105250999331474, -0.030018452554941177, 0.03854253515601158, -0.013121696189045906, 0.0070653571747243404, 0.025460664182901382, 0.010005136020481586, -0.04136650264263153, 0.008404453285038471, -0.01774710789322853, 0.012706190347671509, -0.006785970646888018, 0.029922431334853172, -0.02066316269338131, -0.031130284070968628, 0.04456387087702751, 0.06055033951997757, -0.013397983275353909, -0.03834710270166397, -0.006664104759693146, 0.019812578335404396, -0.02388489991426468, -0.015697821974754333, 0.007009137887507677, 0.02376510761678219, 0.01932627148926258, 0.04023166000843048, 0.028395861387252808, 0.013932100497186184, -0.026456717401742935, 0.00279442360624671, 0.053073372691869736, 0.07848332822322845, 0.04947934299707413, -0.010690202936530113, 0.006783999968320131, -0.022197727113962173, -0.023265572264790535, 0.04352974519133568, 0.04401605576276779, 0.003902893979102373, -0.03065265528857708, 0.03727787733078003, 0.02202867716550827, -0.024807799607515335, 0.012096286751329899, -0.004985150881111622, 0.029565075412392616, 0.007146555930376053, -0.10517197847366333, -0.07146593183279037, 0.018388813361525536, -0.023563478142023087, -0.02120380662381649, -0.0592421256005764, -0.06056739017367363, 0.00041423627408221364, 0.03887712582945824, 0.010158543474972248, 0.04378150776028633, -0.01730990968644619, 0.004523054696619511, 0.04592590779066086, -0.0163312628865242, -0.007483652327209711, -0.016238955780863762, -0.015346609055995941, -0.0065035209991037846, -0.055752918124198914, 0.009701959788799286, 0.0422774963080883, 0.0033749255817383528, 0.009819542989134789, 0.04725423827767372, -0.01063987985253334, -0.025228407233953476, -0.004171502776443958, 0.032096393406391144, -0.024162190034985542, 0.049974262714385986, -0.017254071310162544, 0.023472752422094345, 0.00012609714758582413, -0.011124235577881336, -0.01151213701814413, 0.05113565921783447, 0.06543722748756409, 0.0651588961482048, 0.015978030860424042, -0.013638659380376339, -0.006830022670328617, -0.0012543152552098036, 0.00729913217946887, -0.02387026511132717, -0.0517360158264637, -0.031065698713064194, 0.0022900730837136507, 0.018884623423218727, 0.062339283525943756, 0.003100139554589987, 0.010125515051186085, 0.0353267639875412, -0.05172443762421608, -0.050942063331604004, -0.029454855248332024, 0.003205028362572193, -0.008616330102086067, -0.037797387689352036, 0.01806989125907421, 0.044442106038331985, 0.014776667580008507, -0.009424731135368347, -0.03242291137576103, -0.0057259718887507915, -0.0030431123450398445, 0.04651457071304321, -0.04339390620589256, 0.04582544043660164, 0.03958296403288841, 0.037570465356111526, -0.050393085926771164, 0.03573501110076904, -0.027710963040590286, -0.07147148251533508, 0.019815826788544655, -0.026664098724722862, 0.031974758952856064, -0.007770766504108906, -0.009461657144129276, -0.005383599083870649, -0.027126984670758247, -0.03395196422934532, 0.055187273770570755, -0.014749155379831791, 0.05065424367785454, 0.03775399550795555, -0.02310756966471672, 0.0012702103704214096, -0.006697004660964012, 0.0046838559210300446, 0.01177089475095272, -0.04349168762564659, -0.022277576848864555, -0.03276333212852478, -0.008534696884453297, 0.059852417558431625, -0.007025470491498709, -0.016552671790122986, -0.019537106156349182, 0.06429082155227661, -0.011336905881762505, 0.026113828644156456, 0.018636373803019524, -0.024388546124100685, -0.03888629376888275, -0.00954721961170435, -0.004416177049279213, 0.055540747940540314, 0.015883387997746468, 0.013945155777037144, 0.017329096794128418, 0.03381924331188202, 0.013247714377939701, 0.00998112466186285, 0.03720415383577347, 0.047513946890830994, -0.010616912506520748, -0.051346760243177414, -0.01385319884866476, 0.06252670288085938, -0.0027664320077747107, 0.03467431664466858, 0.07908708602190018, -0.013474028557538986, -0.012468764558434486, 0.012761278077960014, 0.010484123602509499, 0.03111531026661396, 0.04917329549789429, -0.004948294721543789, 0.005031738430261612, 0.006483990699052811, -0.01799760013818741, 0.01151385996490717, -0.042003605514764786, -0.027218716219067574, -0.03516272455453873, -0.011873077601194382, 0.044971782714128494, -0.014136575162410736, 0.013865934684872627, -0.03165201470255852, 0.0002671845140866935, -0.00008320866618305445, 0.020248552784323692, 0.020262377336621284, 0.020315101370215416, -0.012135193683207035, -0.007968799211084843, -0.036432504653930664, 0.0015105033526197076, 0.03311550244688988, -0.019830238074064255, -0.029470359906554222, 0.05268428102135658, -0.01833939552307129, -0.04369313269853592, -0.02311861701309681, -0.017013482749462128, 0.003980052191764116, -0.026673924177885056, -0.03530164435505867, 0.025725074112415314, -0.020730527117848396, -0.03492853045463562, 0.0070199985057115555, -0.0070547438226640224, 0.01052959356456995, -0.011631465516984463, 0.018589891493320465, 0.012610569596290588, 0.011973933316767216, 0.004856995772570372, -0.0009749999735504389, -0.02622283808887005, -0.005761845037341118, -0.06210612133145332, -0.10839638859033585, 0.017317531630396843, -0.011238466948270798, 0.021279698237776756, -0.013385391794145107, -0.03929799795150757, 0.04847346618771553, 0.021687539294362068, -0.007575222756713629, -0.03653452917933464, -0.01945505104959011, -0.027997391298413277, -0.03006858192384243, 0.036148861050605774, 0.004783443175256252, 0.005605607759207487, 0.03967933729290962, -0.014577341265976429, 0.041324734687805176, 0.03150096535682678, 0.033689409494400024, -0.008372101001441479, 0.009599680081009865, -0.036676567047834396, -0.020468836650252342, 0.006618365179747343, 0.030608288943767548, -0.06401242315769196, -0.002536606742069125, -0.022868499159812927, 0.03638272359967232, 0.002831075806170702, -0.059077173471450806, -0.005898086354136467, -0.0032864727545529604, 0.00965532474219799, -0.015601974911987782, 0.011286955326795578, 0.02626674808561802, -0.020856104791164398, -0.026492439210414886, 0.026466401293873787, 0.01157053280621767, 0.010670931078493595, 0.0003222848172299564, 0.031963713467121124, 0.0541074275970459, 0.017002925276756287, 0.0002875702630262822, -0.022524090483784676, -0.01641499623656273, 0.04064765200018883, -0.0019368286011740565, -0.0382281094789505, 0.061309944838285446, 0.059274859726428986, 0.014495817013084888, -0.012831822037696838, -0.05149226635694504, 0.010387443006038666, -0.08149044960737228, 0.032991670072078705, -0.050621069967746735, 0.04008815065026283, -0.007573375944048166, 0.033999521285295486, 0.02655639685690403, 0.02220081351697445, -0.011707209050655365, -0.0012621224159374833, -0.06630565971136093, 0.02917630970478058, -0.012254074215888977, -0.01970907486975193, -0.01134626753628254, -0.00608802679926157, 0.060656532645225525, -0.00023881561355665326, 0.009573066607117653, -0.021651864051818848, 0.021291440352797508, -0.02163052186369896, 0.0372948944568634, -0.009685621596872807, -0.0024229821283370256, 0.03551468625664711, 0.005902845878154039, -0.016316575929522514, -0.04129680618643761, 0.01743534579873085, 0.027339600026607513, -0.020283168181777, -0.02213870733976364, -0.04206029325723648, 0.02978452481329441, 0.0034710157196968794, 0.0459752194583416, 0.03781285136938095, 0.042513348162174225, -0.04592225328087807, 0.014368929900228977, 0.010217719711363316, 0.03692268952727318, 0.02328786626458168, 0.031364355236291885, -0.0216045044362545, -0.005992621183395386, -0.003702405374497175, -0.010114329867064953, -0.010744261555373669, -0.005286681465804577, 0.024002864956855774, 0.05127584561705589, 0.03888572379946709, -0.03526272624731064, 0.012438029050827026, 0.04187920317053795, 0.03270235285162926, -0.02114454098045826, -0.05073903873562813, -0.0023447424173355103, -0.005833304021507502, -0.015664532780647278, 0.033146683126688004, 0.03428027033805847, 0.018768398091197014, -0.009136917069554329, 0.03944943845272064, -0.023426711559295654, -0.022655948996543884, -0.0037790562491863966, -0.01662125065922737, 0.03881223499774933, -0.0027975914999842644, -0.01601504534482956, 0.008513488806784153, 0.015004015527665615, 0.04099758341908455, 0.06990896910429001, 0.018821129575371742, -0.08446609228849411, 0.013390487991273403, 0.05582927539944649, 0.0436844676733017, -0.04788010194897652, 0.006083130370825529, 0.0034027022775262594, 0.0035673705860972404, 0.03167465701699257, -0.016483992338180542, -0.0006993428687565029, 0.00958488043397665, 0.0034144462551921606, -0.03824619948863983, -0.03239889070391655, -0.048930175602436066, 0.002537686610594392, -0.02057652734220028, 0.025304939597845078, -0.038269996643066406, -0.034439489245414734, -0.04768812283873558, -0.011445327661931515, 0.02321522869169712, 0.0706992968916893, -0.010216082446277142, -0.035483840852975845, 0.004636386875063181, 0.05192495882511139, -0.00017403619131073356, -0.059359531849622726, -0.005030155181884766, 0.02416437305510044, -0.009768467396497726, 0.07383549958467484, -0.02071480080485344, -0.06548534333705902, 0.016192154958844185, -0.007791547570377588, -0.014238151721656322, -0.005774766206741333, -0.01780511438846588, 0.04460790380835533, 0.04328108951449394, 0.030132751911878586, 0.04371080920100212, 0.02108639106154442, 0.026266420260071754, 0.010500060394406319, -0.03875923529267311, 0.010511117056012154, -0.06469271332025528, -0.06329268217086792, -0.07234843075275421, -0.04486316442489624, -0.019998198375105858, -0.008198510855436325, 0.004367533139884472, 0.007814929820597172, -0.053312160074710846, -0.0318121612071991, 0.027008000761270523, 0.006825745105743408, 0.004309607669711113, 0.005252114497125149, -0.014540113508701324, -0.000838415406178683, 0.02213365212082863, 0.0034037784207612276, 0.03661554679274559, 0.007312741596251726, 0.04392404481768608, 0.03120708279311657, -0.059121258556842804, -0.014692941680550575, -0.030028995126485825, -0.0018528492655605078, 0.02128286100924015, 0.004938818980008364, 0.022846577689051628, -0.022355396300554276, 0.03251085430383682, -0.016869202256202698, -0.021532444283366203, -0.009381559677422047, -0.00783619750291109, -0.037504203617572784, 0.03616845980286598, -0.04438494145870209, 0.022341692820191383, -0.024969641119241714, -0.0006892125820741057, -0.09181683510541916, -0.0003348755417391658, 0.007306286599487066, 0.020881973206996918, -0.04192410036921501, 0.007222098298370838, 0.003375889267772436, -0.0305076465010643, -0.016243720427155495, -0.03531177341938019, 0.05003884807229042, -0.02166597917675972, -0.021811123937368393, -0.03454062342643738, 0.006152646150439978, 0.09220539778470993, -0.031214969232678413, -0.02057097852230072, 0.02439967356622219, -0.03279336914420128, -0.020674772560596466, 0.03148322552442551, 0.006036543287336826, -0.0359012745320797, -0.052687402814626694, -0.04045921191573143, 0.01815110072493553, 0.028195897117257118, -0.05022130534052849, -0.0016566038830205798, 0.0248100608587265, -0.03074599616229534, 0.013314574956893921, -0.03963267803192139, 0.02417975664138794, -0.033658359199762344, 0.01882106624543667, -0.02813374064862728, 0.026690470054745674, 0.012296142987906933, 0.0015046369517222047, 0.004259335808455944, 0.03162601217627525, -0.024743350222706795, -0.004961210768669844, 0.04889910668134689, -0.012436636723577976, -0.0026217857375741005, 0.03679930791258812, -0.02954765409231186, 0.0680977925658226, 0.01637551560997963, 0.02545139566063881, 0.012576457113027573, 0.05486343428492546, -0.06066880375146866, -0.05738736689090729, -0.038782719522714615, 0.014391236007213593, 0.051148466765880585, -0.05130424723029137, 0.05766023322939873, 0.06493239849805832, -0.03094320185482502, -0.0028648849111050367, -0.06671274453401566, 0.03463137149810791, 0.02112606354057789, 0.004589775577187538, 0.06073882803320885, -0.011576521210372448, 0.006958239246159792, 0.03192325681447983, 0.0325203612446785, 0.025075383484363556, 0.04378018155694008, 0.008831986226141453, 0.022946838289499283, -0.010652279481291771, -0.03759096935391426, -0.06755360215902328, 0.008417400531470776, -0.0399625338613987, -0.015637913718819618, -0.03459899500012398, 0.008535830304026604, 0.04884200915694237, 0.052907612174749374, 0.03261208534240723, -0.02864154987037182, -0.03346827253699303, -0.05828768014907837, 0.05487624183297157, 0.026305293664336205, -0.031551867723464966, -0.006804259493947029, -0.022980647161602974, 0.052394166588783264, -0.015749355778098106, -0.00745403254404664, -0.05825274437665939, -0.07840884476900101, -0.006414654664695263, 0.012044238857924938, -0.007823172025382519, 0.0004228528996463865, -0.010698163881897926, -0.027673060074448586, -0.008575533516705036, -0.02503295987844467, -0.005220832768827677, -0.012333126738667488, 0.002030487172305584, -0.01761002093553543, 0.05246075987815857, 0.006528998725116253, 0.036987174302339554, -0.007668336853384972, 0.007901458069682121, 0.1034451574087143, 0.044233452528715134, 0.04072088375687599, -0.022844767197966576, -0.00022526115935761482, 0.014847173355519772, 0.0147221889346838, 0.002897009253501892, 0.012012060731649399, -0.014525036327540874, 0.00253484514541924, 0.026940058916807175, 0.03784920275211334, 0.015940137207508087, -0.028059806674718857, 0.06002886965870857, -0.03365727514028549, 0.02191787213087082, 0.00978891458362341, 0.013546491041779518, 0.03336617350578308, -0.029613949358463287, -0.06710440665483475, 0.027746902778744698, 0.02384854108095169, 0.021688187494874, -0.0387304462492466, 0.0018100007437169552, 0.0005647405632771552, 0.006071179173886776, -0.05993898957967758, 0.009490946307778358, 0.02470594272017479, 0.04791375249624252, -0.02401633933186531, -0.007213591132313013, 0.0682285949587822, -0.01967567391693592, -0.006659987848252058, 0.06410041451454163, -0.009142836555838585, -0.025228561833500862, -0.006759619805961847, 0.01869324967265129, -0.0034389751963317394, -0.04965044558048248, -0.0023552346974611282, 0.04335577413439751, -0.011777034029364586, -0.013560967519879341, -0.014937210828065872, 0.004251297563314438, -0.020982421934604645, -0.05887867510318756, -0.01677205041050911, 0.04222439229488373, 0.01308554969727993, -0.022777803242206573, -0.00897444598376751, -0.008114325813949108, 0.018854301422834396, 0.004777139984071255, 0.007680368144065142, -0.005114145576953888, -0.007783058565109968, -0.002078315243124962, -0.01891787350177765, 0.04064996913075447, 0.02245047502219677, -0.013141953386366367, 0.009251725859940052, -0.00332032167352736, 0.007944234646856785, 0.021211901679635048, -0.0022087027318775654, -0.03764187917113304, 0.027012022212147713, 0.0017047700239345431, -0.0026343241333961487, -0.04170758277177811, -0.05358569696545601, 0.018802981823682785, -0.020675484091043472, 0.012484358623623848, -0.045099060982465744, -0.019306400790810585, 0.007325115613639355, 0.05595624819397926, 0.02294844202697277, 0.03400709107518196, 0.02807808481156826, 0.0596315860748291, -0.007349416613578796, -0.04890471324324608, -0.014094877988100052, 0.0026532704941928387, -0.02805672585964203, -0.010029703378677368, -0.011064708232879639, 0.04883681982755661, 0.008353653363883495, 0.0329410582780838, -0.021919727325439453, 0.03560091555118561, 0.02566453255712986, 0.03816639631986618, 0.008267122320830822, -0.050494588911533356, -0.010614791885018349, -0.014512975700199604, -0.00408498290926218, -0.057127125561237335, -0.00550717581063509, -0.030696067959070206, -0.03838825970888138, 0.016414297744631767, -0.020243575796484947, -0.03525536134839058, 0.039112575352191925, -0.0011047841981053352, 0.02973337657749653, -0.015981361269950867, -0.005492504220455885, -0.04037992283701897, -0.040405429899692535, 0.03651360422372818, -0.005400503054261208, 0.029123853892087936, 0.03359987586736679, -0.00849677063524723, -0.01746964082121849, 0.042158160358667374, 0.03994086757302284, 0.039628177881240845, 0.014373424462974072, -0.022408979013562202, 0.023680396378040314, 0.0460788756608963, -0.006138386204838753, -0.015410331077873707, 0.021515067666769028, -0.020967934280633926, -0.019066540524363518, 0.01125714834779501, -0.01716533675789833, 0.027572736144065857, 0.005877913441509008, -0.006010840646922588, -0.04974045976996422, 0.04784654080867767, -0.03365107998251915, 0.010367396287620068, 0.0017186541808769107, 0.022038351744413376, -0.01403996255248785, -0.04397512599825859, 0.0021710931323468685, 0.04998821020126343, -0.01900225505232811, -0.010487817227840424, 0.026739317923784256, 0.005708429031074047, 0.006253741215914488, 0.016549918800592422, -0.0185430608689785, -0.0019784767646342516, -0.038167279213666916, -0.024538317695260048, -0.025315169245004654, 0.053734831511974335, -0.020907383412122726, 0.029865577816963196, -0.0021993424743413925, 0.03710133954882622, -0.10705917328596115, -0.01644219271838665, 0.002589419251307845, 0.021416665986180305, 0.011288371868431568, -0.04316122084856033, -0.0010264572920277715, 0.019990742206573486, -0.06473156064748764, -0.007552728056907654, -0.01958828791975975, -0.010073606856167316, -0.02885372005403042, 0.010584327392280102, -0.04549692943692207, -0.007725876290351152, -0.012797370553016663, 0.009769459255039692, 0.0069329869002103806, 0.050946902483701706, 0.018553951755166054, -0.03598811477422714, 0.006605653092265129, 0.014132405631244183, 0.03065592423081398, -0.054711390286684036, 0.013110492378473282, -0.027490006759762764, -0.04486733302474022, 0.029564684256911278, -0.009008871391415596, 0.02803647331893444, -0.03383353352546692, 0.007921352051198483, 0.02050079219043255, 0.06565362960100174, 0.0026011597365140915, 0.026338299736380577, -0.003665708238258958, -0.01768460124731064, -0.012980024330317974, 0.04004282504320145, -0.005338524933904409, 0.022248387336730957, 0.04779636859893799, -0.016449138522148132, -0.004757643677294254, 0.0028635147027671337, -0.0111030088737607, -0.015689201653003693, 0.00014218769501894712, -0.012688890099525452, 0.012206531129777431, -0.0008571657235734165, 0.00556422071531415, -0.05115673691034317, -0.0152682950720191, 0.06829291582107544, 0.014110289514064789, -0.040717482566833496, 0.014396682381629944, -0.03339776396751404, -0.029687559232115746, 0.013830050826072693, 0.02764463610947132, -0.02587011270225048, -0.045896876603364944, -0.013141975738108158, -0.01668786257505417, 0.005395707208663225, -0.006141160614788532, -0.011908140033483505, -0.02038157917559147, 0.05108856037259102, -0.02459787391126156, 0.009534448385238647, 0.02909473329782486, -0.029703771695494652, 0.011973215267062187, -0.08119846880435944, 0.04749976471066475, 0.009216603823006153, -0.04142025485634804, -0.0336594320833683, -0.0010836622677743435, -0.021512122824788094, -0.007486359216272831, 0.03933034837245941, 0.00040184726822189987, 0.03271312639117241, -0.014106294140219688, 0.016067024320364, 0.00017281537293456495, -0.055217817425727844, 0.10044196993112564, 0.0224493145942688, 0.026119602844119072, -0.014047767035663128, -0.020051034167408943, -0.001481546089053154, 0.0017765018856152892, 0.04574352502822876, -0.025437477976083755, 0.005622267257422209, 0.024881670251488686, 0.034738436341285706, 0.0488218255341053, 0.012615007348358631, -0.002402260899543762, 0.014989076182246208, -0.011627107858657837, -0.015666445717215538, 0.02694522775709629, -0.0019843382760882378, -0.037045110017061234, 0.0011920265387743711, -0.0027199576143175364, -0.004373383708298206, 0.007589964661747217, 0.014556309208273888, -0.004101033788174391, -0.029511915519833565, -0.004112486727535725, 0.045722100883722305, -0.018898876383900642, -0.008947465568780899, 0.02919013984501362, 0.03363913670182228, 0.01882678084075451, -0.016942456364631653, 0.006228795275092125, 0.043497975915670395, -0.03134286403656006, -0.003088047495111823, 0.01053917407989502, 0.05948257073760033, 0.0299119483679533, -0.019543686881661415, 0.02886870503425598, -0.010057369247078896, 0.013184904120862484, -0.01927845925092697, -0.0010922218207269907, -0.054547034204006195, -0.035313911736011505, -0.013889328576624393, -0.014447175897657871, 0.0230773463845253, 0.0003401915600989014, 0.016013534739613533, 0.06148803234100342, -0.0012885215692222118, -0.017370935529470444, -0.052501991391181946, -0.008060871623456478, -0.009081565774977207, -0.0015499047003686428, 0.002228263532742858, -0.01296135876327753, 0.02311044931411743, 0.024372771382331848, -0.01270876545459032, -0.019600536674261093, 0.03424245864152908, -0.044414736330509186, 0.029811860993504524, -0.029102567583322525, -0.012594442814588547, -0.02979232557117939, -0.01154955755919218, -0.04120706766843796, -0.02329356037080288, 0.018979189917445183, 0.03287320211529732, 0.016144828870892525, -0.035761311650276184, -0.04855520278215408, 0.021416325122117996, 0.02078297547996044, -0.1027463972568512, -0.005293190944939852, -0.05662962421774864, 0.020276637747883797, -0.010669215582311153, -0.04179789870977402 ]
<p>By the definition</p> <p>(1) $S(x)=\begin{cases} S_0 = a_0x^3 + b_0x^2 + c_0x + d_0, &amp; \text{if }t_0\le x\le t_1\\ .....\\ S_{k} = a_kx^3 + b_kx^2 + c_kx + d_k, &amp; \text{if }t_{k-1}\le x\le t_k\\ \end{cases} $</p> <p>Using the necessary conditions which ensure that $S(x)$ is twice differentiable at the knots $t_0,...,t_k$ yields:</p> <p>(2) $ \ S_i(x) = \frac{z_i}{6h_i}(t_{i+1}-x)^3 + \frac{z_{i+1}}{6h_i}(x-t_{i})^3 + (\frac{y_{i+1}}{h_i}-\frac{z_{i+1}h_i}{6})(x-t_i) + (\frac{y_{i}}{h_i}-\frac{z_{i}h_i}{6})(t_{i+1}-x)$</p> <p>where $z_i = S_i''(t_i)$, $y_i = S_i(t_i)$ and $h_i = t_{i+1}-t_i$.</p> <p>According to <em>Wood - Generalized Additive Models an Introduction with R (page 145, 146)</em>, one can rewrite (1) and (2) to</p> <p>(3) $S(X) = a_j^-(x)\beta_j + a_j^+(x)\beta_{j+1} + c_j^-(x)\boldsymbol{F}_j\boldsymbol{\beta} + c_j^+(x)\boldsymbol{F}_{j+1}\boldsymbol{\beta}$</p> <p>Since this is just a reformulation of (2) I'm really interested in how the exact formulation of $b_i(x)$ will look like since</p> <p>$S(x) = \sum_{i=1}^k b_i(x)\beta_i$</p> <p>is actually used to fit the data.</p>
73,539
[ -0.019221937283873558, -0.014491848647594452, 0.02384844608604908, -0.039389126002788544, 0.02141602337360382, -0.00021360932441893965, -0.04891983047127724, 0.0011628945358097553, 0.015905946493148804, -0.07668794691562653, 0.027161911129951477, 0.002892969874665141, 0.017312979325652122, 0.025097740814089775, 0.025844359770417213, -0.001013564527966082, -0.00804772600531578, 0.007783242966979742, -0.0070607322268188, -0.000488795805722475, 0.02346889115869999, 0.02558806724846363, -0.01460353098809719, -0.017860224470496178, -0.015523281879723072, 0.03090783767402172, 0.031060991808772087, -0.0005821026279591024, -0.021399300545454025, 0.03423282876610756, -0.003889851737767458, -0.027709657326340675, -0.013459772802889347, 0.02449026331305504, 0.011088214814662933, 0.011924739927053452, -0.0054979342967271805, -0.056509003043174744, 0.010876880958676338, 0.026947110891342163, -0.005688069853931665, -0.014380615204572678, -0.03968507796525955, 0.013156477361917496, -0.01776859350502491, 0.030616868287324905, -0.03163827210664749, -0.019709067419171333, 0.035904642194509506, -0.02580505982041359, 0.049957361072301865, -0.027226433157920837, 0.011611993424594402, 0.006562487687915564, -0.0007618213421665132, -0.010470066219568253, 0.04579785838723183, 0.06956209987401962, -0.02026667259633541, -0.0074874041602015495, -0.004708706401288509, -0.001375964842736721, 0.04375976696610451, -0.0359354205429554, -0.016622968018054962, -0.028812438249588013, 0.004876742139458656, -0.042030028998851776, -0.006590384058654308, -0.047817572951316833, 0.015370073728263378, 0.006268884055316448, -0.02207249589264393, 0.01786438561975956, -0.021494105458259583, 0.011792548932135105, -0.036799248307943344, 0.0506439246237278, 0.04869271069765091, 0.015901638194918633, 0.03309369087219238, -0.023402266204357147, -0.012333357706665993, 0.0373239740729332, 0.019228946417570114, -0.03887039050459862, 0.05675746873021126, 0.009188852272927761, 0.01895107515156269, 0.014792228117585182, 0.013213356025516987, -0.0004759424482472241, 0.037632234394550323, -0.028305741026997566, -0.017417065799236298, 0.042658109217882156, 0.003974197898060083, 0.019661806523799896, -0.03662518039345741, 0.04583500698208809, -0.041586991399526596, -0.11224985122680664, -0.0544113852083683, 0.03654591739177704, -0.013048343360424042, 0.0003044612240046263, 0.014047124423086643, 0.03715501353144646, -0.025057539343833923, -0.022739898413419724, -0.0437803640961647, 0.02274349518120289, -0.005238870624452829, -0.027392787858843803, -0.029407402500510216, 0.004701354540884495, -0.005985012277960777, -0.0544060654938221, 0.042492736130952835, 0.06037445738911629, 0.06948964297771454, -0.03307678550481796, -0.014858941547572613, 0.0013146908022463322, -0.07494207471609116, -0.01387764886021614, 0.03214443475008011, -0.03441739082336426, -0.02325323037803173, 0.034131795167922974, 0.07382659614086151, -0.01817941479384899, 0.04215242341160774, 0.01799558848142624, 0.007024598773568869, 0.02220197767019272, -0.09023769199848175, -0.018965773284435272, 0.05663883313536644, 0.011227656155824661, 0.029937544837594032, -0.015302211977541447, -0.008137385360896587, 0.05623352527618408, 0.06214338168501854, -0.010364551097154617, 0.020686812698841095, 0.03636300191283226, 0.00992788840085268, 0.020913537591695786, -0.02994462288916111, -0.03678013011813164, -0.0011600268771871924, -0.03255194425582886, -0.03445562720298767, -0.048289861530065536, 0.007435519248247147, 0.01754048652946949, -0.03427719324827194, -0.0017077848315238953, 0.07224807888269424, -0.003640176961198449, -0.011701073497533798, 0.022826509550213814, -0.03787894546985626, -0.03575081378221512, 0.03735094889998436, -0.014142722822725773, 0.01815919019281864, -0.013246183283627033, 0.007471539545804262, -0.011275596916675568, -0.050301965326070786, 0.034319233149290085, 0.03410561382770538, -0.02149243652820587, 0.02714299038052559, 0.005660721566528082, -0.03849057853221893, 0.0773165300488472, -0.0717136338353157, -0.019529758021235466, -0.02832750976085663, -0.01698247902095318, 0.03350656479597092, 0.05752520635724068, -0.034830719232559204, 0.0019992245361208916, 0.03048914298415184, -0.05399743467569351, -0.019023995846509933, -0.06148939207196236, 0.012593460269272327, -0.015366747975349426, -0.02399979531764984, 0.042660199105739594, -0.04325750842690468, -0.013317511416971684, 0.010792169719934464, -0.029725361615419388, 0.02612152323126793, 0.020166397094726562, 0.05532972142100334, -0.029970329254865646, 0.002341238083317876, 0.022821055725216866, 0.06203038617968559, 0.02862267568707466, 0.04144970327615738, -0.03594949468970299, -0.002234251471236348, 0.002168207196518779, -0.021937701851129532, 0.04416390508413315, -0.03840956836938858, -0.01246777642518282, 0.006449398584663868, -0.03189472854137421, -0.00008976253593573347, 0.02756545878946781, -0.05160864442586899, 0.012476484291255474, 0.08356422930955887, 0.023506473749876022, 0.0018425468588247895, 0.044314444065093994, -0.03198227658867836, 0.06267513334751129, -0.016801858320832253, -0.04337382689118385, -0.04757295921444893, -0.011721408925950527, 0.017048638314008713, 0.07279449701309204, -0.03458400070667267, -0.011602125130593777, 0.025888832286000252, 0.044816575944423676, -0.00786994956433773, 0.022662734612822533, -0.01705419458448887, -0.02591889165341854, 0.07454214990139008, -0.030432112514972687, 0.05656743422150612, -0.006244048476219177, -0.005965198390185833, -0.001503653358668089, 0.015228173695504665, -0.0013402478070929646, 0.023593269288539886, 0.01915596053004265, -0.011746368370950222, -0.04053271934390068, -0.005989340133965015, 0.0226079560816288, 0.003018043702468276, -0.019297035411000252, -0.02709146961569786, 0.03854238986968994, 0.02301350235939026, 0.021400563418865204, 0.024219920858740807, -0.0008158585405908525, 0.02100832387804985, -0.006347340531647205, -0.0003658903297036886, -0.042094916105270386, 0.027468495070934296, -0.03650379553437233, -0.017683755606412888, -0.05865216255187988, 0.005845294333994389, -0.017007114365696907, -0.03569510206580162, 0.029948854818940163, 0.030886633321642876, 0.015026272274553776, -0.0258711576461792, 0.006824956741183996, 0.0057846494019031525, 0.01988704316318035, 0.0539037249982357, -0.005602310411632061, -0.07869424670934677, 0.004302072338759899, -0.02374945767223835, 0.017526371404528618, 0.03518066182732582, -0.019259829074144363, -0.04263736680150032, 0.013679463416337967, 0.007422616705298424, -0.0372515544295311, -0.039268847554922104, -0.009611193090677261, 0.028810983523726463, -0.04004506394267082, -0.012284921482205391, 0.05228098854422569, 0.00753964064642787, -0.04524422809481621, 0.01860857382416725, -0.07646109163761139, 0.011350464075803757, 0.013287256471812725, -0.01355112623423338, 0.0018530907109379768, 0.026017652824521065, 0.05366915091872215, 0.019873034209012985, -0.027435090392827988, 0.012125372886657715, -0.09616314619779587, -0.0475141741335392, 0.01644117757678032, -0.0033743453677743673, 0.04140520468354225, -0.006759066600352526, -0.04978913813829422, 0.09522218257188797, 0.05963806435465813, 0.00976634118705988, -0.022289905697107315, 0.03493461757898331, -0.0376720167696476, -0.037648215889930725, 0.013956044800579548, 0.030698856338858604, 0.016150258481502533, 0.03372480720281601, -0.007811307907104492, 0.019780537113547325, 0.07283893972635269, -0.02762158401310444, 0.017306635156273842, 0.03426254168152809, -0.03931222856044769, -0.019239865243434906, 0.02802868001163006, 0.01957520842552185, -0.00034866793430410326, -0.005585816688835621, -0.013794139958918095, -0.003091569058597088, 0.015374887734651566, -0.07407854497432709, 0.014399020932614803, 0.007197744678705931, -0.005500213708728552, 0.03047974407672882, 0.04427142068743706, 0.010810975916683674, -0.050075713545084, -0.02289368212223053, 0.005121693480759859, 0.029924148693680763, -0.01978358067572117, 0.044801976531744, 0.009337426163256168, 0.025480370968580246, 0.018094457685947418, 0.02770298719406128, -0.02417207509279251, -0.032785844057798386, 0.05585579574108124, -0.06912405788898468, -0.04937687888741493, 0.012352658435702324, 0.011376800015568733, -0.010592096485197544, -0.006837787106633186, 0.005150471813976765, 0.002452267101034522, -0.05425124615430832, 0.005268625915050507, -0.06006030738353729, 0.032847810536623, 0.022797677665948868, 0.03669414296746254, -0.02423245459794998, -0.013611254282295704, 0.027111388742923737, 0.0016390006057918072, -0.038299478590488434, 0.010839437134563923, -0.011570940725505352, 0.013421498239040375, 0.037872061133384705, 0.004894568119198084, 0.042293235659599304, -0.011569476686418056, 0.015679700300097466, 0.00042034636135213077, 0.00375686795450747, -0.05085517093539238, 0.017374053597450256, -0.004350679460912943, -0.03656939044594765, -0.016443006694316864, 0.009889400564134121, 0.02762346900999546, -0.04799908772110939, 0.02160961739718914, -0.0014179536374285817, 0.01575491391122341, 0.04129927232861519, -0.03710194304585457, 0.021828804165124893, 0.04379557818174362, 0.019679835066199303, 0.008668816648423672, 0.023557700216770172, -0.01513677928596735, 0.048261865973472595, 0.02749013341963291, 0.02047806791961193, 0.09091780334711075, -0.01002475619316101, -0.004903758410364389, -0.04311073198914528, -0.03125305846333504, 0.049873314797878265, 0.04851030185818672, 0.05652889609336853, -0.040086355060338974, 0.03956842049956322, 0.025128860026597977, 0.003351560328155756, 0.025093145668506622, 0.008637110702693462, 0.006743201054632664, -0.01785077340900898, -0.03197554871439934, -0.014176568016409874, -0.007090377155691385, 0.00413677841424942, 0.029632020741701126, 0.011339251883327961, 0.010038089007139206, -0.010400553233921528, 0.027056969702243805, 0.021854648366570473, -0.0014711386756971478, 0.018703477457165718, 0.0190151184797287, 0.013326236046850681, 0.01805499754846096, -0.03339993581175804, 0.025010040029883385, 0.01343214325606823, 0.016724826768040657, 0.023991091176867485, 0.01934625767171383, -0.051772236824035645, -0.01766570471227169, 0.03357519954442978, 0.03138985112309456, -0.013004829175770283, 0.017221003770828247, -0.05430580675601959, 0.002498558722436428, 0.006728847045451403, 0.017750121653079987, 0.015364992432296276, -0.016020696610212326, 0.012344758957624435, -0.0270681194961071, -0.05498235300183296, -0.06346279382705688, 0.005982434842735529, 0.005771451164036989, -0.023038189858198166, -0.050677817314863205, 0.005985136143863201, -0.010240760631859303, 0.017680974677205086, -0.007625263649970293, 0.023321816697716713, -0.022309307008981705, -0.016415707767009735, 0.011102434247732162, 0.00783564057201147, -0.02598983235657215, -0.06311451643705368, 0.03536014258861542, 0.01570712961256504, 0.014587069861590862, 0.06392581760883331, -0.03354043886065483, -0.022234950214624405, 0.023792283609509468, 0.03442531079053879, 0.005065970588475466, 0.02471318654716015, -0.0018188462127000093, 0.050538185983896255, 0.04922376945614815, -0.013670423068106174, 0.0891755074262619, 0.0570516511797905, -0.011701461859047413, 0.001121761742979288, 0.004844522103667259, -0.008769762702286243, -0.016228502616286278, -0.005244317464530468, -0.08589271456003189, 0.0038306904025375843, 0.006524295546114445, 0.0002139019052265212, -0.03964593634009361, -0.002260415116325021, -0.035897281020879745, -0.01848888397216797, 0.014645446091890335, 0.0006533337291330099, 0.013235935010015965, -0.01273302175104618, -0.013901427388191223, 0.020425474271178246, 0.04564589262008667, 0.009850060567259789, 0.03078562766313553, -0.018432186916470528, 0.00946885161101818, 0.03127612918615341, 0.005512842908501625, 0.011405677534639835, -0.013550814241170883, -0.01887306198477745, 0.01707874983549118, -0.02224843017756939, 0.042703162878751755, 0.009283018298447132, 0.03265988081693649, 0.009650097228586674, -0.015099067240953445, -0.0013423777418211102, -0.03245524689555168, -0.007738819811493158, -0.01706588827073574, -0.03044087253510952, 0.019194355234503746, -0.002282005501911044, -0.020980212837457657, -0.02987894043326378, -0.008185245096683502, 0.05402344837784767, -0.012586893513798714, -0.03389417380094528, -0.037249691784381866, 0.00666899885982275, -0.018293514847755432, -0.03034588322043419, -0.007507248781621456, 0.07312104851007462, -0.06405676901340485, 0.02575005032122135, 0.017813120037317276, 0.07190456241369247, 0.040151286870241165, 0.026742802932858467, 0.03914584964513779, 0.042441245168447495, -0.03299205005168915, -0.00796075165271759, -0.01662234403192997, 0.004223523195832968, -0.031650882214307785, 0.01278548501431942, 0.0033952619414776564, 0.006399098783731461, 0.036396898329257965, -0.02106585167348385, -0.04362151771783829, -0.039591629058122635, -0.0006161325727589428, -0.010341508314013481, -0.010871132835745811, -0.052876632660627365, -0.014532678760588169, 0.0016503076767548919, -0.017944063991308212, 0.011660663411021233, -0.0017421888187527657, -0.025015946477651596, 0.033977482467889786, -0.008463148958981037, -0.04862543195486069, 0.007639144081622362, 0.06362567842006683, 0.0028567116241902113, 0.0011265227803960443, 0.01908332295715809, 0.0023588736075907946, 0.04835834726691246, -0.016485275700688362, 0.0004460638447199017, 0.03278045728802681, -0.0166656244546175, -0.009014749899506569, -0.01490828301757574, -0.034302107989788055, 0.0512695237994194, 0.05658482387661934, -0.0034868987277150154, 0.026266412809491158, 0.029021551832556725, -0.033714137971401215, -0.003629948478192091, 0.0006083723856136203, -0.00912044383585453, 0.0030707060359418392, -0.0039343880489468575, 0.0426238588988781, -0.06189402565360069, -0.038050852715969086, 0.044398363679647446, 0.022104892879724503, -0.040045998990535736, 0.018793854862451553, -0.011510739102959633, -0.026664813980460167, -0.014654051512479782, -0.04104116931557655, -0.06160617619752884, 0.07508265972137451, 0.0006781458505429327, 0.05160071700811386, 0.0020011914893984795, -0.06020953133702278, 0.03321297466754913, 0.06191202253103256, 0.029924022033810616, -0.09059404581785202, -0.05571506544947624, -0.05085145682096481, -0.029186101630330086, 0.01940281130373478, -0.03267497569322586, 0.08000244200229645, 0.007957481779158115, 0.023101244121789932, -0.0007445938535965979, 0.015737762674689293, -0.033422667533159256, -0.05348166450858116, 0.0056761279702186584, 0.0038612382486462593, -0.03910692781209946, 0.014699792489409447, 0.009170308709144592, -0.024977657943964005, 0.006389986258000135, -0.0025113008450716734, 0.02549687586724758, 0.04820306971669197, -0.00639050779864192, 0.04268094152212143, 0.06014096364378929, -0.03236867114901543, -0.018950674682855606, -0.018619898706674576, -0.022828614339232445, 0.150537371635437, 0.055879686027765274, -0.007235129829496145, -0.03413093090057373, -0.0064279199577867985, 0.007789119146764278, -0.008498601615428925, -0.005451308097690344, 0.011377789080142975, 0.023271461948752403, -0.03869287297129631, 0.018454935401678085, 0.04691655933856964, -0.041048817336559296, -0.019243186339735985, 0.02096032351255417, -0.048637572675943375, -0.01585211046040058, -0.003252207301557064, -0.013910530135035515, 0.02765580639243126, -0.011177610605955124, -0.011793228797614574, -0.0402369387447834, 0.022786417976021767, -0.0177730955183506, 0.004074912052601576, 0.001862255041487515, -0.007816607132554054, 0.055949315428733826, -0.04028501361608505, -0.0012988575035706162, -0.001510164118371904, 0.015113153494894505, -0.003275081515312195, 0.012118539772927761, 0.03356792405247688, -0.044104576110839844, 0.037464439868927, 0.06195475533604622, 0.006887837313115597, 0.04540964961051941, 0.013216222636401653, 0.02740090899169445, -0.04549336060881615, -0.0437491312623024, -0.03316128998994827, 0.0032615289092063904, -0.011390401050448418, -0.04360398277640343, -0.015610982663929462, -0.019518710672855377, 0.009536463767290115, -0.02410862036049366, -0.024824660271406174, 0.013173161074519157, -0.0060295406728982925, -0.05270218476653099, -0.006301764864474535, 0.003962972201406956, -0.021676383912563324, 0.013876482844352722, -0.017710579559206963, 0.033432867377996445, -0.06228995323181152, 0.0011663251789286733, -0.03723984211683273, 0.06794648617506027, 0.009309095330536366, 0.03570786491036415, -0.026783080771565437, 0.01638980582356453, 0.02327144704759121, -0.02692568488419056, 0.005068380851298571, 0.004516870714724064, 0.03920939192175865, -0.0022035937290638685, -0.012357177212834358, -0.026823438704013824, -0.016880180686712265, 0.0035615263041108847, -0.025440765544772148, 0.011704127304255962, -0.03859549015760422, -0.021618034690618515, 0.0382617823779583, 0.0278073251247406, -0.001021858653984964, 0.017674151808023453, -0.0278941597789526, 0.08351150155067444, 0.02091134525835514, -0.02998758852481842, 0.0105636240914464, 0.0009154999279417098, 0.0013939400669187307, -0.013805262744426727, 0.020334823057055473, 0.045247454196214676, 0.0413513109087944, 0.02144973911345005, -0.026837442070245743, 0.05320436879992485, 0.02043835259974003, -0.0132973687723279, 0.01985933631658554, -0.03558637201786041, 0.03802397847175598, 0.05177755653858185, 0.0379946231842041, -0.03347061201930046, 0.00607955502346158, -0.02952849306166172, -0.01623307354748249, 0.05468542128801346, -0.03109857253730297, -0.05434500798583031, -0.03715048357844353, -0.01787489466369152, 0.013011234812438488, -0.00835743360221386, 0.00448806444182992, 0.03370464965701103, 0.011768287979066372, -0.021760063245892525, 0.039081186056137085, 0.0037546884268522263, -0.011386995203793049, -0.03179604187607765, 0.01352756004780531, 0.041865669190883636, -0.030103014782071114, 0.011807600036263466, -0.0262655820697546, -0.018994569778442383, 0.022084487602114677, 0.024722501635551453, -0.0037615615874528885, -0.05504579842090607, 0.010868928395211697, -0.03298326954245567, 0.01961737684905529, 0.017875704914331436, 0.010233193635940552, 0.015389639884233475, 0.0030686852987855673, 0.004922326188534498, 0.006150243803858757, -0.024663135409355164, 0.01049218699336052, -0.008411913178861141, 0.005644157994538546, 0.010661228559911251, 0.03310598060488701, -0.06315074115991592, 0.01885099895298481, -0.009267856366932392, 0.006185478996485472, -0.01821313612163067, 0.034914735704660416, -0.040734320878982544, -0.029366599395871162, -0.014097169041633606, -0.05172787606716156, -0.0018469435162842274, -0.028329525142908096, -0.003083428367972374, 0.028605889528989792, -0.006368383765220642, 0.004976117517799139, 0.010935761965811253, 0.018065523356199265, -0.00959949940443039, -0.07902972400188446, 0.003339870600029826, 0.009613116271793842, 0.013769770972430706, 0.055582720786333084, -0.01458085235208273, -0.004468437749892473, 0.027161315083503723, -0.04243660718202591, 0.03562309592962265, -0.00948320608586073, 0.03261248767375946, -0.02260296419262886, -0.029623087495565414, 0.002843093127012253, 0.02724180556833744, 0.022275222465395927, 0.02545730397105217, -0.0015970026142895222, 0.03185158967971802, -0.031176172196865082, -0.02774479053914547, 0.0032979368697851896, 0.005626705475151539, -0.0014062145492061973, -0.05177219212055206, 0.038247838616371155, -0.031213177368044853, 0.006378557998687029, -0.011861667968332767, 0.024593865498900414, -0.007258182857185602, -0.028737913817167282, 0.02522231452167034, 0.019398055970668793, 0.02829880639910698, 0.02680276520550251, 0.013264008797705173, 0.0005456146318465471, -0.024037890136241913, -0.033817678689956665, -0.004096821881830692, -0.00571846030652523, 0.023103879764676094, 0.024302680045366287, -0.020424574613571167, -0.06190362945199013, 0.007543643470853567, -0.016878444701433182, -0.029414651915431023, 0.0006053277174942195, -0.031752943992614746, 0.02685132622718811, -0.006780573166906834, -0.027196235954761505, -0.023280108347535133, -0.013390297070145607, 0.039421238005161285, 0.018810991197824478, -0.043573327362537384, 0.009386257268488407, -0.034103844314813614, -0.019627761095762253, -0.00042051650234498084, 0.016370972618460655, 0.009430274367332458, -0.041527703404426575, 0.011948434635996819, 0.008416238240897655, -0.021292254328727722, -0.06621850281953812, 0.04200969636440277, -0.015880681574344635, 0.03971175476908684, -0.0029529801104217768, -0.01799723505973816, 0.010449410416185856, -0.01945825107395649, 0.013643527403473854, -0.05125255882740021, 0.05041412636637688, 0.026959994807839394, -0.014590359292924404, -0.018613211810588837, -0.025010963901877403, -0.012481491081416607, 0.031038008630275726, 0.05787288025021553, 0.007383421063423157, -0.017951305955648422, 0.027060940861701965, 0.05766785517334938, 0.03362958878278732, -0.02055826596915722, 0.04023967683315277, 0.0159688051789999, 0.036824241280555725, -0.04202420264482498, -0.014901222661137581, -0.022296808660030365, 0.014960505068302155, -0.000759974354878068, -0.006643447559326887, 0.02069465070962906, -0.011173517443239689, -0.00658719427883625, -0.01215048972517252, 0.02990713343024254, -0.035311754792928696, 0.06225534901022911, -0.03883195295929909, 0.008037137798964977, 0.013785202987492085, -0.017772946506738663, -0.04718396067619324, -0.0051045967265963554, -0.03751583769917488, -0.009016009047627449, -0.00897487998008728, -0.03928077220916748, 0.031186556443572044, 0.00042840917012654245, 0.028960037976503372, -0.006545240059494972, -0.007217804901301861, -0.07054189592599869, 0.05072043091058731, 0.03932204470038414, 0.02194942533969879, -0.017247941344976425, -0.002143269404768944, 0.031980693340301514, -0.01680695079267025, 0.006401528604328632, 0.013516731560230255, 0.006351009476929903, -0.02140379324555397, -0.024111244827508926, -0.026325080543756485, -0.019921569153666496, 0.058457840234041214, 0.0161754097789526, -0.00036098636337555945, -0.006128461565822363, -0.011569433845579624, 0.032504502683877945, -0.030293086543679237, 0.007240643259137869, 0.00945981778204441, -0.012407027184963226, 0.06541721522808075, 0.030478160828351974, -0.000998623319901526, 0.008279633708298206, -0.005266789812594652, -0.023429077118635178, 0.022224904969334602, -0.011985894292593002, 0.006535490043461323, -0.01525520533323288, -0.007455590181052685, 0.00884230062365532, -0.016183508560061455, 0.009236734360456467, -0.035921938717365265, -0.019628196954727173, 0.030400758609175682, 0.0016416475409641862, 0.02635575830936432, -0.04318425431847572, -0.012055088765919209, 0.004159036558121443, 0.015545403584837914, 0.04625799506902695, 0.007690719328820705, -0.01413711253553629, -0.016362477093935013, -0.013776593841612339, 0.053672563284635544, -0.05791754275560379, -0.010171663016080856, 0.011455509811639786, -0.03499094769358635, -0.0004927683039568365, -0.022925984114408493 ]
<p>I run two univariate linear regressions within one sample (same subjects, two different conditions). Now I would like to know how to compare the regression coefficients in order to find out whether they differ significantly. All of the methods I find apply to a case with two different independent samples. How do I do this in SPSS?</p>
73,540
[ -0.031453363597393036, 0.013441996648907661, -0.035000745207071304, 0.04593140259385109, 0.011185197159647942, 0.011772447265684605, 0.0011901836842298508, -0.044060446321964264, 0.03522465005517006, 0.0018677458865568042, 0.0292220301926136, 0.03882379084825516, 0.03678380697965622, 0.005255301017314196, 0.03431064262986183, -0.0005336612230166793, -0.01586899347603321, 0.019087109714746475, -0.0042124358005821705, 0.027197714895009995, -0.005323536694049835, 0.009624490514397621, 0.021156098693609238, -0.0075997281819581985, -0.0018316257046535611, 0.06274481117725372, 0.014098514802753925, -0.03104846552014351, 0.014735318720340729, 0.06024917960166931, -0.028828034177422523, -0.04075856879353523, 0.0009597694734111428, 0.023653043434023857, 0.02740509994328022, -0.005376311484724283, -0.028309527784585953, -0.040724825114011765, -0.0163193978369236, 0.0488068126142025, -0.026166915893554688, -0.04451292008161545, -0.0019855783320963383, 0.04300021007657051, -0.00015377205272670835, 0.010655785910785198, 0.002060316503047943, -0.03559524565935135, 0.022001340985298157, -0.0322139710187912, 0.04801114648580551, 0.00037538009928539395, 0.05234628915786743, 0.06346156448125839, -0.018228186294436455, 0.047924261540174484, 0.02893006056547165, 0.04116646200418472, -0.006776772905141115, -0.04671778902411461, -0.007080691866576672, -0.026879390701651573, 0.02334747649729252, -0.029834959656000137, -0.06054995581507683, -0.011131785809993744, -0.006070374045521021, -0.015826581045985222, 0.03123639151453972, -0.005851421970874071, 0.03663421422243118, 0.037232764065265656, 0.04081901162862778, -0.016942447051405907, -0.015755634754896164, -0.03183213248848915, 0.007589408196508884, 0.02535221166908741, 0.053662583231925964, 0.027770493179559708, 0.02668190747499466, 0.019621822983026505, 0.033444441854953766, 0.025221003219485283, 0.024038882926106453, -0.02547685243189335, 0.061057597398757935, -0.008342023007571697, 0.02768968977034092, 0.014524227008223534, -0.004261483438313007, 0.0033260707277804613, 0.038097500801086426, 0.04522886127233505, -0.02510138787329197, -0.00459384685382247, -0.023932185024023056, 0.03692574054002762, 0.022966407239437103, 0.014058398082852364, 0.020270612090826035, -0.041851677000522614, 0.034788619726896286, 0.015218295156955719, -0.0077799283899366856, 0.00853582564741373, -0.00810482632368803, 0.0031777077820152044, 0.0044465698301792145, -0.040773797780275345, -0.016545260325074196, 0.0250856876373291, 0.012486913241446018, -0.0035403843503445387, 0.027922378852963448, -0.01043468527495861, -0.008233906701207161, -0.006017615552991629, 0.032987598329782486, 0.037262924015522, 0.0659852847456932, -0.03627244010567665, 0.004819354973733425, -0.006303636822849512, -0.015453517436981201, 0.014059380628168583, -0.00557365920394659, -0.004623346030712128, -0.06355024129152298, 0.06912916898727417, -0.01081417128443718, -0.008382607251405716, 0.0004771060775965452, 0.010314319282770157, 0.011486673727631569, 0.03950094059109688, -0.05970609188079834, -0.07782444357872009, 0.012285961769521236, -0.005597230978310108, 0.010539046488702297, -0.030748099088668823, -0.005309476982802153, 0.008162799291312695, 0.07880902290344238, 0.00483953021466732, 0.04161710664629936, 0.010893323458731174, -0.0012544755591079593, 0.014398911967873573, -0.007029747124761343, -0.0026425854302942753, -0.03881396725773811, -0.02322961576282978, 0.004046796355396509, -0.10350287705659866, -0.033872801810503006, 0.01852261833846569, -0.027495302259922028, -0.00121492485050112, 0.04014422371983528, 0.024135734885931015, -0.01678023487329483, 0.013409879989922047, 0.031644877046346664, -0.011399311013519764, 0.06903945654630661, -0.02522650919854641, 0.02039695903658867, 0.02017039619386196, -0.012463190592825413, 0.007003696169704199, 0.01564377173781395, 0.05768778920173645, 0.03203699365258217, 0.011720920912921429, -0.011637629009783268, 0.010174497030675411, 0.004407085478305817, 0.005845071282237768, -0.06738708168268204, -0.015243700705468655, -0.019593147560954094, 0.0013975241454318166, 0.0014703063061460853, 0.0570744164288044, 0.012257927097380161, -0.010810400359332561, 0.02280620113015175, -0.030697988346219063, -0.06376306712627411, -0.07979455590248108, 0.014268293045461178, 0.04008099064230919, -0.038083747029304504, 0.03525768592953682, 0.004389500245451927, 0.011145939119160175, -0.020387180149555206, -0.05794181302189827, -0.03946855664253235, 0.022893885150551796, 0.036748334765434265, -0.025132998824119568, -0.000567780458368361, 0.060201097279787064, 0.07208123058080673, -0.024280225858092308, 0.0375639908015728, -0.05616682395339012, -0.03471715748310089, 0.05510958656668663, -0.038805410265922546, 0.009059613570570946, 0.011227822862565517, -0.02128629945218563, 0.0032357778400182724, 0.003988475538790226, -0.025586647912859917, 0.030088679865002632, -0.036315303295850754, 0.06868056952953339, 0.08415795117616653, 0.008084414526820183, -0.014404790475964546, -0.002931737806648016, 0.01608465053141117, 0.017069587484002113, -0.034942079335451126, -0.01498088613152504, -0.033904917538166046, -0.027132991701364517, 0.0192111786454916, 0.0035697065759450197, -0.05385146662592888, 0.017660576850175858, 0.07155169546604156, 0.002481916919350624, 0.0026112461928278208, 0.010549057275056839, -0.00900220312178135, -0.04673983156681061, -0.010076052509248257, 0.00008904895366868004, 0.052421774715185165, 0.03780662640929222, -0.01492217555642128, 0.029424788430333138, 0.06196022406220436, 0.0019879648461937904, 0.006170573178678751, 0.06675216555595398, 0.0036520897410809994, 0.0026343741919845343, -0.002998613752424717, -0.024137746542692184, 0.01544618234038353, -0.000829018303193152, -0.009260904043912888, 0.04721834510564804, 0.003244667546823621, -0.018980111926794052, 0.03361111879348755, -0.0006263324758037925, 0.03774525597691536, 0.024284394457936287, -0.0345996655523777, 0.02882574312388897, 0.0196433886885643, -0.046321649104356766, 0.03410961106419563, -0.02019127830862999, -0.040792543441057205, -0.05606004223227501, 0.00009316617069998756, 0.04418649524450302, 0.018382415175437927, 0.018227286636829376, -0.024206554517149925, -0.018563436344265938, 0.018464380875229836, -0.015587789006531239, 0.016757460311055183, -0.03971267491579056, -0.06194564327597618, 0.00684741185978055, -0.02901856228709221, -0.022141646593809128, 0.018553027883172035, 0.013581989333033562, -0.016850406304001808, 0.04271605610847473, 0.0047493805177509785, -0.04949013516306877, -0.045375626534223557, -0.03069586120545864, -0.016975725069642067, 0.0008475508075207472, -0.029658641666173935, 0.03509362041950226, -0.011650430969893932, -0.05818105861544609, -0.0012402795255184174, -0.0276732686907053, 0.01651664450764656, -0.028675565496087074, 0.029410697519779205, 0.01961801014840603, 0.021387089043855667, -0.006230119150131941, 0.03655821830034256, -0.010978443548083305, -0.018707288429141045, -0.05439739674329758, -0.045513611286878586, 0.01018176693469286, 0.026783354580402374, 0.03143555670976639, -0.026142310351133347, -0.01620267704129219, 0.08345242589712143, -0.0028574413154274225, -0.0255636777728796, -0.06064239889383316, -0.02290808968245983, -0.0426982119679451, 0.0016526055987924337, 0.046379782259464264, 0.002554398262873292, -0.003801708808168769, 0.013537408784031868, -0.0006501037860289216, 0.002222678856924176, 0.06443576514720917, 0.007473926059901714, 0.024563387036323547, -0.020130136981606483, 0.0040488094091415405, -0.027088066563010216, 0.04159582033753395, 0.016854990273714066, -0.05593229457736015, 0.020945653319358826, 0.04510829597711563, 0.022372910752892494, -0.002933900337666273, -0.01723710633814335, 0.011207795701920986, -0.008572346530854702, -0.009867172688245773, -0.04534951224923134, 0.02259368635714054, 0.01660504937171936, 0.002184977987781167, -0.006973273120820522, 0.0018611970590427518, 0.00813739188015461, -0.014031791128218174, -0.006055339705199003, 0.04633145406842232, 0.04348895698785782, -0.010504161939024925, -0.0033985332120209932, -0.03715452924370766, -0.01066514104604721, 0.03476911410689354, -0.015032879076898098, -0.03145924583077431, 0.05547916889190674, 0.033586617559194565, 0.024443330243229866, -0.004106319509446621, -0.04234645143151283, 0.012142997235059738, -0.07350218296051025, 0.0032900574151426554, -0.015416673384606838, 0.046991754323244095, -0.007209365256130695, 0.02346731908619404, 0.016206111758947372, -0.0025124000385403633, 0.0416845977306366, -0.00579643901437521, -0.06505714356899261, 0.06079923361539841, -0.029331263154745102, -0.014102325774729252, 0.030106760561466217, 0.009280753321945667, 0.016157640144228935, -0.0429762564599514, 0.03192439675331116, 0.007817141711711884, 0.020684635266661644, -0.021141111850738525, 0.03273553401231766, -0.025469055399298668, -0.008008014410734177, -0.0013038474135100842, 0.004293258301913738, -0.009722190909087658, -0.034698598086833954, -0.007868329994380474, 0.017490576952695847, -0.01957729272544384, 0.013831689022481441, -0.02750447764992714, 0.0035129254683852196, 0.019487205892801285, 0.03990981727838516, 0.016025369986891747, 0.02757791057229042, -0.028128882870078087, 0.03722802549600601, 0.005392442923039198, 0.027568189427256584, 0.052217792719602585, 0.013278158381581306, -0.032041285187006, -0.02654154784977436, 0.0029252732638269663, -0.04078734666109085, 0.03300194814801216, -0.024693459272384644, -0.012938057072460651, 0.04158938676118851, 0.036855876445770264, -0.05652141943573952, 0.02683539129793644, 0.07096078991889954, 0.03869596868753433, -0.008559759706258774, -0.00281799235381186, 0.003131770994514227, 0.0013230922631919384, -0.011699781753122807, 0.019655559211969376, 0.027767769992351532, 0.0067634908482432365, -0.012720435857772827, 0.055365193635225296, -0.018831433728337288, -0.037489961832761765, -0.009715498425066471, 0.00432882783934474, 0.05869521573185921, 0.022900540381669998, -0.0656750276684761, 0.02256033755838871, 0.05249498039484024, 0.02736290544271469, 0.029060663655400276, 0.006386879365891218, -0.06386912614107132, 0.0025324965827167034, 0.05231831595301628, 0.0316551998257637, -0.06696492433547974, -0.029607661068439484, 0.009451230056583881, -0.0037303410936146975, 0.03313351795077324, -0.03165266290307045, 0.015917908400297165, 0.012364723719656467, 0.03207122161984444, -0.0326884500682354, 0.02349264919757843, -0.059454672038555145, 0.03893842175602913, -0.022276543080806732, 0.01613294519484043, -0.016614405438303947, -0.03469797223806381, -0.06890051066875458, 0.018539296463131905, 0.016005340963602066, 0.061463650315999985, -0.03685058280825615, -0.0140827102586627, 0.020758159458637238, 0.035705599933862686, -0.00537177175283432, -0.03590472787618637, 0.010515131987631321, 0.009809168055653572, -0.03643348440527916, 0.05286437273025513, -0.015942754223942757, -0.030404118821024895, 0.0029489074368029833, 0.0025901547633111477, -0.015350420027971268, -0.021061470732092857, -0.017750389873981476, 0.022825321182608604, 0.03513143211603165, 0.02379591390490532, 0.07690910249948502, 0.005126081872731447, 0.022353600710630417, -0.0349605455994606, -0.023013822734355927, 0.004327819682657719, -0.028180448338389397, -0.05213708430528641, -0.03386864438652992, -0.013646449893712997, -0.009143960662186146, 0.03571733459830284, -0.01189099345356226, 0.029233627021312714, -0.03596023470163345, -0.011669429950416088, 0.0006313623744063079, 0.04735606163740158, 0.012545197270810604, 0.012686428613960743, -0.00013010863040108234, 0.016052717342972755, -0.04940297082066536, -0.020598886534571648, 0.018000178039073944, -0.019436074420809746, 0.0064169298857450485, -0.0049555073492228985, -0.04714162275195122, 0.046643465757369995, -0.005791072733700275, -0.0330398827791214, -0.003490208648145199, -0.050956692546606064, 0.024520620703697205, -0.006148037500679493, 0.059778399765491486, 0.005582642275840044, -0.03648656979203224, -0.004313523881137371, 0.041051723062992096, 0.025084376335144043, 0.03412219509482384, -0.06156349927186966, 0.0656820759177208, -0.005285914056003094, -0.04500272870063782, -0.06817454099655151, -0.04898770526051521, -0.0009096860885620117, 0.01744682900607586, 0.0008469083695672452, -0.03195538371801376, -0.009352516382932663, -0.00845849048346281, 0.0035011563450098038, -0.03287382423877716, 0.06612006574869156, -0.023706024512648582, -0.02950969897210598, -0.033088020980358124, -0.004071271978318691, 0.05736982077360153, -0.03656506538391113, -0.017725499346852303, -0.015555741265416145, -0.028890106827020645, -0.01598629169166088, -0.004591759294271469, 0.01431543193757534, -0.023349234834313393, -0.028911203145980835, -0.04991166293621063, 0.011271081864833832, 0.047632355242967606, -0.023211944848299026, -0.01786527968943119, -0.0014002097304910421, -0.028242740780115128, 0.001641394686885178, -0.017385898157954216, -0.009355323389172554, -0.021998360753059387, 0.014281149953603745, -0.0382559560239315, 0.013820198364555836, -0.014189500361680984, -0.002581565175205469, 0.03569217398762703, 0.012094395235180855, -0.018114926293492317, -0.015648825094103813, 0.09056910872459412, -0.0017725664656609297, 0.025467107072472572, -0.022802339866757393, -0.0058946795761585236, 0.02342124469578266, 0.027276381850242615, 0.012862144969403744, 0.010128646157681942, 0.05178141966462135, -0.039491262286901474, -0.020926861092448235, -0.013693206012248993, -0.016268467530608177, 0.06598717719316483, -0.02497495710849762, 0.04831140488386154, 0.12612317502498627, -0.018057754263281822, 0.010575572960078716, -0.050742149353027344, -0.013462314382195473, -0.021123552694916725, 0.006952459923923016, 0.07600383460521698, 0.0004904710222035646, -0.01428175624459982, 0.0293875765055418, 0.017597483471035957, 0.03328990191221237, 0.046429090201854706, -0.002085981657728553, 0.03825143724679947, 0.04261741042137146, -0.03776101395487785, -0.035396598279476166, 0.010908782482147217, -0.02520865760743618, -0.01810886152088642, -0.04595062509179115, -0.03136732056736946, 0.02280222624540329, 0.0720239132642746, 0.01226782612502575, -0.05118696391582489, -0.018454020842909813, -0.07112636417150497, 0.013039527460932732, -0.000594217621255666, -0.014502452686429024, 0.03270464390516281, 0.01522130984812975, 0.016005098819732666, 0.016966156661510468, 0.01828899420797825, -0.04151929169893265, -0.07079324126243591, -0.024109164252877235, -0.034537144005298615, -0.02777867019176483, 0.03505620360374451, -0.018156882375478745, -0.03421318531036377, 0.0323994942009449, -0.0200848076492548, 0.0018708768766373396, -0.0011759287444874644, 0.03216883912682533, 0.011824878863990307, 0.04352448135614395, -0.011708097532391548, 0.00889534316956997, 0.0033702710643410683, -0.0032945312559604645, 0.0976119339466095, 0.0693841427564621, 0.01676994003355503, -0.06506417691707611, 0.034129202365875244, -0.004322982393205166, -0.013484068214893341, -0.016853362321853638, 0.0036985448095947504, 0.011681165546178818, 0.005337296519428492, 0.07959561794996262, 0.056435566395521164, 0.02729942835867405, -0.03238698095083237, 0.05427022650837898, -0.015412702225148678, 0.021257970482110977, -0.0020282394252717495, 0.0035035349428653717, -0.002694387687370181, -0.01127622276544571, -0.0057476116344332695, 0.007480233907699585, -0.01010641735047102, 0.000016363152099074796, -0.032883062958717346, -0.028450246900320053, 0.005197815131396055, -0.0187065489590168, -0.03281909227371216, 0.020807044580578804, 0.026783404871821404, 0.03594560921192169, -0.05917001888155937, 0.012965498492121696, 0.04413938522338867, -0.05700669810175896, -0.0033493300434201956, 0.005506206303834915, -0.027925793081521988, -0.01507868804037571, -0.00995192863047123, -0.0029558094684034586, -0.04294814169406891, -0.01823395863175392, -0.024315526708960533, 0.03524322807788849, 0.006053016986697912, -0.06948036700487137, -0.017803935334086418, 0.0036491432692855597, -0.002482223091647029, -0.0492028184235096, -0.04023953154683113, -0.00008046648872550577, 0.014710078947246075, -0.055400997400283813, -0.0035524610430002213, -0.051514409482479095, 0.013840161263942719, 0.021796545013785362, 0.03866209089756012, 0.024454614147543907, -0.014089347794651985, 0.01466774195432663, -0.016933856531977654, 0.0238810908049345, -0.023909905925393105, 0.004660560749471188, 0.0014505439903587103, -0.0064702993258833885, -0.020737968385219574, 0.0008946442394517362, 0.049524836242198944, 0.02244836650788784, 0.005912198685109615, 0.0005399614456109703, -0.01601959764957428, -0.04267258569598198, -0.0636015236377716, 0.01046423614025116, -0.020859960466623306, 0.03648168221116066, -0.04301624745130539, 0.0031886568758636713, 0.07648936659097672, 0.019536206498742104, 0.034529656171798706, 0.007782097440212965, 0.012300662696361542, 0.030220918357372284, 0.018037740141153336, -0.06686964631080627, -0.006718539632856846, -0.0042854719795286655, -0.029878485947847366, 0.0009570749243721366, -0.03201926127076149, 0.05916721373796463, 0.03237098827958107, 0.022275030612945557, -0.036394886672496796, 0.02216801792383194, -0.036705583333969116, 0.022901559248566628, -0.014856468886137009, -0.05915258824825287, -0.028677018359303474, 0.024824080988764763, 0.003248522523790598, 0.01321619376540184, -0.011482656002044678, -0.05495475232601166, -0.04636329784989357, 0.04007939249277115, -0.02198181301355362, -0.024911487475037575, 0.02159499004483223, 0.015081052668392658, 0.016947338357567787, -0.02997725084424019, 0.004179006442427635, -0.0356505885720253, 0.0013678777031600475, 0.039230018854141235, -0.027764683589339256, -0.018516451120376587, -0.0015956568531692028, -0.02852005697786808, 0.0017075082287192345, 0.053895290940999985, -0.0036887528840452433, 0.047383181750774384, 0.016887955367565155, 0.023846792057156563, -0.01709355227649212, 0.058946430683135986, -0.012959690764546394, -0.02339896745979786, 0.009275178425014019, -0.020419180393218994, -0.017356349155306816, 0.01729924976825714, -0.0228966623544693, 0.051875095814466476, 0.020594649016857147, -0.0018196863820776343, -0.03013065829873085, 0.04239464923739433, -0.031892526894807816, -0.011512151919305325, -0.047871675342321396, 0.008907094597816467, -0.0077174147590994835, -0.003636589739471674, 0.014630775898694992, -0.017179181799292564, -0.03746107593178749, 0.047182582318782806, 0.05263911560177803, -0.016075704246759415, 0.004780465736985207, -0.018383275717496872, 0.008142458274960518, 0.031020259484648705, 0.004856147803366184, -0.02272898145020008, 0.03781963512301445, 0.04381163418292999, -0.017142629250884056, 0.029254909604787827, -0.02072376385331154, 0.019592542201280594, -0.0782463327050209, -0.017558416351675987, -0.017097849398851395, -0.001701049623079598, 0.015836328268051147, -0.05230695381760597, 0.0004175885405857116, 0.0338098406791687, -0.029532987624406815, -0.009626943618059158, -0.015317938290536404, 0.00773012638092041, -0.02837713621556759, 0.010980521328747272, -0.02047656662762165, 0.02895011007785797, 0.01895664446055889, 0.019907888025045395, 0.010917260311543941, 0.04028400033712387, 0.037181198596954346, 0.01671791821718216, -0.03752601519227028, -0.022090788930654526, 0.012074002996087074, -0.07288964092731476, -0.012896399945020676, -0.04479457065463066, -0.01621992327272892, 0.02573808655142784, -0.03924650698900223, 0.011208567768335342, 0.042672235518693924, 0.011516309343278408, 0.005166229326277971, 0.016081999987363815, -0.005384368356317282, -0.009031915105879307, -0.03306887298822403, -0.015340845100581646, -0.005405253730714321, 0.016851456835865974, -0.04553014412522316, 0.020966142416000366, 0.021950388327240944, 0.00505047058686614, -0.016368305310606956, 0.0039499844424426556, -0.011399202048778534, -0.025299234315752983, 0.0014258752344176173, -0.0015667660627514124, 0.045346394181251526, -0.007635788526386023, 0.017124559730291367, -0.040420617908239365, -0.001928150886669755, 0.03783904388546944, 0.01105289813131094, -0.027854472398757935, 0.01516679022461176, -0.027773285284638405, -0.03239975497126579, 0.03836176544427872, -0.008953599259257317, -0.0075246719643473625, -0.04775331914424896, -0.00309162400662899, -0.0007366436184383929, -0.028883010149002075, -0.04127540439367294, -0.006018851418048143, -0.011297464370727539, 0.030118683353066444, -0.012982740066945553, -0.026518765836954117, 0.0017671380192041397, 0.0072803315706551075, 0.015860581770539284, -0.05645652487874031, 0.04388609901070595, 0.005314347799867392, -0.039534103125333786, -0.04117991775274277, -0.019971659407019615, -0.06709816306829453, 0.029893390834331512, 0.04889906570315361, 0.0019128298154100776, 0.02222825400531292, -0.005847786087542772, 0.04365558922290802, -0.004805599804967642, -0.027127740904688835, 0.05938116833567619, 0.03358849510550499, -0.03549344837665558, -0.020010104402899742, -0.026626477017998695, -0.003807394066825509, 0.014522524550557137, 0.019407188519835472, -0.027006721124053, 0.016766535118222237, 0.025572756305336952, 0.008542097173631191, 0.03538902476429939, 0.0021066232584416866, -0.017018107697367668, 0.03848111256957054, 0.000556016166228801, 0.0017746160738170147, 0.04067423194646835, 0.025532662868499756, -0.044091127812862396, 0.03937960043549538, -0.046439219266176224, -0.022245151922106743, -0.01899937354028225, 0.0029793046414852142, -0.030952826142311096, -0.07126148790121078, 0.006861022207885981, -0.01905628852546215, -0.03085719607770443, 0.0024060909636318684, 0.017159372568130493, 0.017708612605929375, 0.014438360929489136, -0.009390384890139103, 0.020180432125926018, -0.004199026618152857, -0.0022145071998238564, 0.03581172972917557, 0.01886465959250927, 0.04060047119855881, 0.006198450457304716, 0.01889919303357601, 0.05347376689314842, -0.005967970471829176, 0.041625745594501495, -0.017172398045659065, 0.014979603700339794, -0.01895291544497013, -0.02766532078385353, 0.014400554820895195, 0.0033759407233446836, 0.025215134024620056, 0.008343889378011227, -0.012536617927253246, 0.03432979807257652, -0.05030487850308418, -0.00034455442801117897, -0.04494383558630943, 0.017983919009566307, -0.0342494435608387, -0.027878332883119583, 0.04013824462890625, 0.011379831470549107, 0.004857946187257767, 0.006973687093704939, 0.007093798369169235, -0.025535017251968384, 0.03675374761223793, 0.025612076744437218, 0.00770753575488925, -0.0275151077657938, -0.019675757735967636, -0.033617425709962845, -0.04306322708725929, -0.010606609284877777, 0.0005692983395420015, 0.04837290570139885, 0.03549515828490257, 0.035464510321617126, -0.03116188570857048, -0.04694727063179016, 0.0014731966657564044, 0.058779940009117126, -0.07670595496892929, -0.04500797763466835, -0.014264511875808239, 0.021770348772406578, -0.007891927845776081, -0.026348428800702095 ]
<p>Let's say I have a file A1.txt and a file A2.txt. I have written the statements</p> <pre><code>filename in1 'A1.txt'; filename in2 'A2.txt'; </code></pre> <p>Now, I want to re-do this using B1 and B2 (and eventually C1, C2, D1, D2), and just rename the variable in one place. So, I want a statement like</p> <pre><code>%let prefix = 'B'; </code></pre> <p>and then I want to put that prefix in the filename statements. </p> <pre><code>filename in1 '&amp;prefix1.txt'; filename in2 '&amp;prefix2.txt'; </code></pre> <p>I'm not doing this in a data statement. I can almost get it. filename in1 &amp;prefix'.txt' tries to read B'.txt but that extra quote is pesky. There's something vague in my memory banks about using an _ but I can't pull it out. </p> <p>Thanks. </p>
73,541
[ -0.00030282887746579945, 0.008344615809619427, -0.031650610268116, 0.022844787687063217, 0.0007669824408367276, 0.031021522358059883, 0.014320545829832554, -0.0027338380459696054, 0.006830235011875629, -0.02292896807193756, 0.02677086740732193, 0.047894541174173355, 0.07212409377098083, -0.009856512770056725, 0.023458631709218025, -0.020708540454506874, 0.0185230802744627, -0.06157764047384262, -0.04482688382267952, -0.005345715209841728, 0.01877451315522194, 0.01578093320131302, 0.020698359236121178, 0.016333745792508125, 0.02559821680188179, 0.04305044561624527, 0.018651427701115608, -0.024551980197429657, -0.008104430511593819, 0.002827591961249709, 0.026846686378121376, -0.0602506548166275, 0.001967580756172538, -0.002202798845246434, 0.023175861686468124, -0.016955837607383728, -0.05761173367500305, -0.03765193372964859, 0.03465498983860016, -0.013078579679131508, -0.028253423050045967, 0.002929222071543336, -0.03608595207333565, 0.07851268351078033, -0.0038669565692543983, -0.00975708570331335, 0.024294715374708176, 0.020751167088747025, -0.011854824610054493, -0.014803561381995678, 0.07047556340694427, 0.005319351330399513, 0.046932052820920944, 0.015750719234347343, -0.0184401273727417, 0.027855677530169487, 0.03453681245446205, 0.08610676974058151, 0.02950172685086727, 0.004145290702581406, 0.05660496652126312, -0.0008432688773609698, 0.023493481799960136, -0.01955454796552658, -0.02658662386238575, -0.0022819656878709793, -0.04983745515346527, -0.03736976534128189, 0.006665359251201153, -0.024365486577153206, -0.019108537584543228, -0.013221342116594315, 0.06027791649103165, -0.04293312877416611, 0.05519718676805496, -0.025091132149100304, 0.038640204817056656, -0.015745848417282104, 0.04052678868174553, 0.06986597925424576, -0.05779455602169037, 0.03899342939257622, 0.025291232392191887, 0.00913276243954897, 0.04452226310968399, -0.036242078989744186, 0.019843148067593575, -0.009199971333146095, 0.020263589918613434, 0.03375619277358055, -0.002724582562223077, -0.01869668811559677, 0.0359291136264801, 0.05598179250955582, -0.012238571420311928, 0.009977937676012516, -0.007212611846625805, 0.02628464438021183, 0.009829274378716946, -0.015061802230775356, 0.012152905575931072, -0.014508431777358055, 0.017409084364771843, 0.08007773011922836, -0.046130962669849396, 0.02408270724117756, -0.022405734285712242, 0.0050104581750929356, -0.013442429713904858, 0.0016022882191464305, -0.01874774880707264, 0.022532321512699127, 0.004057166166603565, 0.006569250021129847, 0.02521643228828907, -0.03413501754403114, -0.01608245074748993, 0.053066302090883255, 0.03353012725710869, 0.05326441302895546, 0.05061006546020508, -0.06805146485567093, 0.07056514173746109, 0.001767034875229001, -0.04215196892619133, -0.013059318996965885, -0.04645124450325966, -0.0022014148999005556, -0.048711393028497696, 0.06159808486700058, -0.05562356114387512, -0.011904658749699593, 0.003478793427348137, -0.0008402435923926532, 0.014906355179846287, -0.026152852922677994, -0.06363231688737869, -0.10361351072788239, 0.018590962514281273, -0.014091536402702332, 0.019977742806077003, -0.06490201503038406, 0.049689386039972305, -0.00724343815818429, 0.041168540716171265, 0.0056121437810361385, -0.017148319631814957, 0.04731376841664314, -0.039158765226602554, 0.02288544736802578, 0.033190395683050156, -0.016403838992118835, 0.012683603912591934, -0.012336362153291702, 0.0078055886551737785, -0.023037364706397057, 0.01550843846052885, 0.0038334387354552746, -0.037992432713508606, -0.021186409518122673, 0.033696822822093964, 0.005070941057056189, 0.02559743821620941, -0.035595886409282684, -0.0023934664204716682, -0.07933248579502106, 0.07121634483337402, 0.06981491297483444, -0.0059975492767989635, 0.06023917347192764, 0.00811399519443512, -0.01010627206414938, -0.02902916818857193, 0.012200846336781979, 0.08137551695108414, -0.018816867843270302, -0.000044823886128142476, -0.008912391029298306, 0.016038652509450912, 0.018228204920887947, 0.02079385332763195, -0.044431548565626144, -0.009357920847833157, 0.01931587979197502, 0.05679820105433464, 0.024165349081158638, 0.04079962894320488, 0.05620846897363663, 0.043265629559755325, -0.057554133236408234, 0.006818373221904039, -0.06896818429231644, 0.009380877017974854, 0.0023973481729626656, -0.047598715871572495, -0.030918702483177185, -0.013729820027947426, -0.017725784331560135, 0.0008796148467808962, -0.04931626468896866, -0.03190735727548599, -0.038432810455560684, 0.01613560877740383, -0.04774344339966774, -0.005212489981204271, 0.08878681808710098, 0.048936378210783005, -0.000834419799502939, 0.04215503856539726, -0.029651349410414696, 0.01962725631892681, 0.05558671057224274, 0.0010540814837440848, 0.024415981024503708, -0.0042771585285663605, 0.0022148718126118183, 0.03683594614267349, 0.031850412487983704, -0.0015441721770912409, -0.03675004839897156, -0.05475403368473053, 0.048818424344062805, 0.06824135780334473, 0.04377080127596855, 0.027541689574718475, -0.005587540101259947, 0.06632090359926224, 0.037796419113874435, 0.0072971307672560215, -0.0341358557343483, -0.005804342683404684, -0.004244870040565729, 0.014647548086941242, -0.04293724149465561, -0.03626858443021774, -0.020014412701129913, 0.034963637590408325, -0.02746698074042797, 0.018929418176412582, 0.073243148624897, -0.01869158446788788, 0.023694656789302826, -0.029951870441436768, 0.02659226581454277, 0.04948249086737633, 0.019724657759070396, 0.010316790081560612, 0.02141815610229969, 0.05725324898958206, 0.010838828049600124, 0.03923090547323227, -0.02657129243016243, -0.0019301573047414422, -0.05580807477235794, 0.02025705948472023, -0.04210043326020241, 0.046225301921367645, -0.016928888857364655, -0.005468891002237797, 0.04333437979221344, 0.017814867198467255, -0.025950703769922256, 0.026847051456570625, -0.02836514636874199, -0.02615215629339218, -0.000730070867575705, 0.018704205751419067, 0.012477603740990162, 0.0305328406393528, -0.013025404885411263, 0.030371278524398804, 0.006947490386664867, 0.008270281367003918, -0.035675037652254105, 0.011860689148306847, -0.03570282459259033, -0.005742986220866442, 0.030136166140437126, -0.031008021906018257, -0.021126283332705498, -0.00003045121775357984, -0.011313489638268948, 0.007051826920360327, -0.03803848847746849, -0.04643911123275757, 0.034227192401885986, 0.01897185854613781, -0.009178782813251019, 0.025050176307559013, 0.0015248565468937159, -0.025195050984621048, -0.00933153834193945, -0.03205573186278343, -0.036452606320381165, 0.00803835503757, -0.03811455890536308, -0.011297224089503288, -0.005737344268709421, 0.015696324408054352, 0.06310265511274338, 0.019345460459589958, -0.028035705909132957, -0.015977581962943077, -0.021447107195854187, -0.02100740186870098, -0.019001059234142303, 0.00594699801877141, -0.02099217101931572, 0.004863285459578037, 0.009738192893564701, 0.012195657938718796, -0.01861702650785446, -0.003062616800889373, -0.019002793356776237, -0.041217342019081116, 0.035144221037626266, 0.03137313574552536, 0.03430737555027008, -0.0061858464032411575, -0.025416338816285133, 0.05992506444454193, -0.005440024193376303, -0.02023543231189251, -0.02627231553196907, -0.011789169162511826, 0.019711505621671677, -0.02969047799706459, -0.019867990165948868, 0.010844912379980087, -0.006131469737738371, 0.0008545680902898312, 0.04762396216392517, 0.01550755463540554, 0.06229856237769127, 0.02672618068754673, 0.0008690643007867038, -0.02671760506927967, 0.038558825850486755, -0.010475329123437405, 0.053116898983716965, 0.05248163267970085, -0.0006840422283858061, 0.008944015018641949, -0.005213649477809668, -0.004662704654037952, 0.013790391385555267, -0.034206490963697433, -0.012664896436035633, 0.011441141366958618, 0.010999711230397224, -0.006981232203543186, -0.01295444369316101, -0.019490709528326988, 0.0010282377479597926, 0.03193434327840805, 0.02986588329076767, 0.03801211342215538, -0.02038586512207985, 0.037244681268930435, 0.00013885629596188664, 0.01463381014764309, 0.004705549217760563, -0.004228772129863501, 0.008103471249341965, -0.024616174399852753, 0.02223971299827099, -0.01668303832411766, -0.03978801146149635, 0.05016651749610901, 0.04113217815756798, 0.0018533514812588692, 0.03279293701052666, -0.040483854711055756, 0.04735463857650757, -0.06149754300713539, -0.029730668291449547, -0.004033977165818214, 0.07435381412506104, 0.004763496108353138, 0.04568857327103615, 0.014581280760467052, 0.044609926640987396, -0.014391581527888775, 0.005208971444517374, -0.07504075765609741, -0.002323948312550783, 0.03813222050666809, -0.03264085575938225, 0.010013628751039505, -0.031931616365909576, -0.016229800879955292, -0.055163249373435974, -0.02942381612956524, 0.015647616237401962, -0.014196662232279778, -0.0459645539522171, 0.04491915553808212, -0.0347137413918972, -0.010938826948404312, -0.05212218686938286, 0.018682075664401054, 0.0393286794424057, -0.02442813664674759, 0.024283966049551964, 0.005810847971588373, -0.03742966800928116, -0.02589106746017933, -0.051485881209373474, 0.0030086743645370007, 0.023570165038108826, 0.01290886476635933, 0.045011669397354126, 0.06290289014577866, -0.03642679378390312, -0.020845431834459305, -0.02804606780409813, 0.018532883375883102, 0.01829550787806511, 0.018321413546800613, -0.015984253957867622, -0.0026688396465033293, 0.0031112544238567352, -0.021718809381127357, 0.031619593501091, -0.026206063106656075, 0.022679811343550682, 0.01823723502457142, 0.026524744927883148, -0.03340201452374458, 0.009350111708045006, 0.07770504802465439, 0.03235529363155365, -0.03849366307258606, -0.023539796471595764, 0.012738481163978577, 0.003936787601560354, -0.040216077119112015, 0.0007782251923345029, 0.029254456982016563, -0.004252787213772535, -0.022705180570483208, 0.023005425930023193, -0.03411249816417694, 0.012214450165629387, 0.015646498650312424, -0.035712067037820816, -0.0025926108937710524, 0.0404561311006546, -0.006028510630130768, 0.011588271707296371, 0.004234220366925001, 0.02120804414153099, 0.05715881660580635, -0.012534504756331444, -0.0946868285536766, 0.011249604634940624, 0.04104488715529442, 0.054790254682302475, -0.019808916375041008, -0.019218524917960167, 0.01301865465939045, -0.030330821871757507, 0.020007207989692688, -0.06370975822210312, 0.030327266082167625, -0.068137988448143, 0.02500932104885578, -0.017785632982850075, -0.0433339886367321, -0.02592349424958229, 0.008990727365016937, -0.061081841588020325, -0.005146713927388191, -0.021361831575632095, -0.027291933074593544, -0.03279220685362816, 0.008644328452646732, 0.0030867443419992924, 0.00195567449554801, -0.015381214208900928, -0.052353665232658386, 0.004341449588537216, 0.06301291286945343, -0.03630709648132324, -0.02533472515642643, 0.046742554754018784, 0.016855647787451744, -0.022926466539502144, 0.04779881238937378, -0.01646760292351246, -0.027407793328166008, 0.032883062958717346, -0.00832458958029747, -0.029724692925810814, -0.012430322356522083, -0.006967230699956417, 0.0022071050480008125, 0.03736371919512749, 0.023914504796266556, 0.0259392112493515, 0.05104842409491539, 0.002478858921676874, -0.019047368317842484, -0.02427407167851925, 0.0053318883292376995, -0.04138994589447975, 0.0014639318687841296, -0.03245234861969948, 0.044281765818595886, -0.020298302173614502, 0.008789416402578354, -0.019307931885123253, 0.013908355496823788, -0.013075481168925762, -0.01503928005695343, -0.006312151439487934, 0.04487879201769829, -0.03496572747826576, -0.0029059553053230047, -0.024790536612272263, 0.02638167329132557, -0.03458637744188309, -0.0269174687564373, 0.016058437526226044, -0.049858659505844116, -0.03231736272573471, -0.013840840198099613, -0.00840832944959402, 0.01945212483406067, -0.02030027098953724, -0.03418087214231491, 0.02745373360812664, -0.022006941959261894, -0.010329586453735828, 0.0005864060949534178, 0.021777508780360222, -0.015032095834612846, -0.03522111847996712, -0.022265061736106873, 0.019564852118492126, 0.003768587252125144, -0.01690293289721012, -0.05901617184281349, 0.06831291317939758, -0.0028318369295448065, 0.009161805734038353, -0.06265965104103088, -0.08516588062047958, 0.0337960459291935, 0.004081736784428358, 0.026846395805478096, -0.04013146087527275, -0.013779514469206333, 0.009068752638995647, -0.009919833391904831, -0.010659023188054562, 0.026616685092449188, -0.058257684111595154, -0.023888982832431793, 0.0367140956223011, -0.0030770746525377035, 0.057079069316387177, 0.03392007201910019, 0.03028959408402443, 0.02565746381878853, -0.016911614686250687, 0.00030473817605525255, 0.015001202002167702, -0.03060445748269558, -0.017780499532818794, -0.02321048453450203, -0.040170371532440186, -0.002394748153164983, 0.05051741749048233, 0.01862134039402008, 0.024440350010991096, -0.012462298385798931, -0.00918755866587162, 0.010478490963578224, -0.025800982490181923, -0.020962640643119812, -0.05651487410068512, 0.004099920392036438, -0.057358283549547195, 0.017482392489910126, 0.004446793347597122, 0.051089175045490265, -0.026859788224101067, 0.03841281682252884, 0.009521986357867718, 0.010356704704463482, 0.04799346253275871, -0.02641579881310463, 0.02631782367825508, 0.03828766196966171, 0.018494118005037308, 0.06389819830656052, 0.003761361353099346, -0.030791910365223885, -0.004688975401222706, 0.025144843384623528, 0.012864962220191956, 0.04693880304694176, -0.02969246543943882, -0.025680964812636375, 0.02384476736187935, -0.038534898310899734, -0.011425674892961979, 0.0006465876358561218, 0.006360726431012154, 0.012215214781463146, 0.009877936914563179, -0.021036406978964806, -0.016249818727374077, -0.0355568453669548, 0.058673352003097534, 0.00170385860837996, -0.03209679573774338, 0.025193490087985992, 0.022424623370170593, 0.05409713834524155, -0.008245795965194702, -0.020894134417176247, -0.017631135880947113, -0.02972126379609108, -0.007515145931392908, -0.040312159806489944, 0.004491530824452639, -0.04827262833714485, 0.01593964546918869, 0.005722571164369583, -0.05564575269818306, 0.032174285501241684, 0.009772263467311859, -0.008709132671356201, -0.03493665158748627, -0.037673886865377426, -0.050595786422491074, 0.01404198445379734, 0.019524982199072838, -0.015089158900082111, 0.04487384483218193, -0.033847127109766006, 0.03126299008727074, -0.001654486870393157, 0.004836884792894125, -0.025456581264734268, -0.020348254591226578, 0.0050179623067379, -0.06282772123813629, -0.034014031291007996, 0.05205420032143593, -0.0037949266843497753, -0.003070129081606865, 0.023489082232117653, -0.016554705798625946, 0.022229474037885666, 0.008351145312190056, 0.07322739064693451, 0.019444119185209274, 0.08196643739938736, 0.0032098032534122467, 0.025377050042152405, 0.003511051880195737, -0.032403960824012756, 0.12310245633125305, 0.04802481085062027, 0.035374805331230164, -0.06039579212665558, 0.04261058196425438, -0.004128257744014263, -0.007696022745221853, -0.02377104014158249, -0.009216750040650368, 0.023707928135991096, 0.01505240611732006, 0.038237590342760086, 0.012407343834638596, -0.006311662029474974, 0.020219339057803154, -0.010586438700556755, -0.07405869662761688, -0.02526332065463066, 0.04186471179127693, 0.022848816588521004, 0.021350448951125145, -0.050539299845695496, -0.04435748606920242, -0.006099808029830456, 0.04599389061331749, 0.012700384482741356, -0.023319659754633904, 0.010322151705622673, 0.022566545754671097, 0.019939828664064407, -0.004441132768988609, -0.010980341583490372, 0.014793621376156807, -0.0013712812215089798, 0.020320385694503784, -0.03363288193941116, 0.02740023471415043, 0.0045409793965518475, 0.007625446189194918, 0.00176197977270931, 0.015437048859894276, 0.02189633809030056, -0.028436971828341484, 0.010195756331086159, -0.04068845137953758, -0.033309366554021835, -0.030970877036452293, -0.02679084800183773, -0.019487814977765083, -0.02494375966489315, -0.01485887635499239, -0.005413584876805544, 0.06883194297552109, -0.046663399785757065, -0.019512701779603958, 0.034810345619916916, -0.009774984791874886, 0.007195950020104647, 0.007603053003549576, -0.0161115899682045, 0.012206388637423515, -0.011952782049775124, 0.027306444942951202, -0.013467049226164818, -0.006183842662721872, 0.014684638008475304, -0.03625435382127762, 0.041962191462516785, -0.019478216767311096, -0.032275523990392685, -0.011160450987517834, 0.010582039132714272, -0.008535322733223438, -0.02116375043988228, 0.009075934067368507, 0.025761878117918968, 0.004066151566803455, -0.05129317194223404, 0.0013124378165230155, -0.0052188546396791935, -0.002174496417865157, -0.016317052766680717, -0.053759533911943436, -0.005544977728277445, -0.019598577171564102, 0.02511407993733883, 0.04383230209350586, 0.014149320311844349, -0.031282633543014526, 0.018894370645284653, -0.011389750987291336, 0.029954398050904274, 0.028998391702771187, -0.0674843117594719, -0.011713345535099506, 0.0016537067713215947, -0.01831752061843872, 0.020545100793242455, -0.04038649797439575, 0.05848652124404907, 0.04148917645215988, 0.002158938441425562, -0.026300065219402313, 0.02638440765440464, -0.017164207994937897, 0.007296518888324499, 0.054156672209501266, 0.001498094410635531, -0.0362870953977108, 0.0237811841070652, 0.023562267422676086, -0.015598216094076633, 0.013345797546207905, -0.010569830425083637, -0.025702374055981636, 0.013882347382605076, 0.010113321244716644, -0.009336312301456928, 0.01694849692285061, -0.01914132572710514, 0.002329012844711542, 0.00944557972252369, 0.0552150160074234, -0.0344727449119091, -0.010723454877734184, -0.02554434724152088, -0.022921616211533546, -0.08346790820360184, 0.005644184071570635, -0.021787356585264206, 0.004142980556935072, 0.0008983986335806549, 0.02475610375404358, -0.009705825708806515, -0.012089041993021965, 0.009765783324837685, 0.0034879304002970457, 0.04588615149259567, -0.03670765087008476, 0.011976542882621288, 0.013857183046638966, -0.018120720982551575, 0.01358832512050867, 0.031234264373779297, -0.015522779896855354, 0.009883576072752476, -0.011335381306707859, 0.0414762906730175, -0.0057598985731601715, 0.09638956189155579, 0.025161145254969597, -0.016916612163186073, 0.004046977031975985, -0.03308107703924179, 0.01998039335012436, 0.032711662352085114, 0.018319178372621536, 0.0051246327348053455, -0.015034006908535957, -0.012753689661622047, 0.023355163633823395, 0.030108312144875526, -0.0031430618837475777, 0.011212517507374287, 0.030115541070699692, 0.011080880649387836, -0.0052134073339402676, -0.023808570578694344, 0.0017333469586446881, 0.045672498643398285, -0.006296919193118811, -0.011331292800605297, 0.023543044924736023, 0.0374637246131897, -0.037947990000247955, 0.0018590958788990974, 0.0029886430129408836, 0.006394768133759499, 0.01533224806189537, -0.013605370186269283, 0.019178230315446854, 0.01815141923725605, -0.03237330913543701, -0.019666289910674095, -0.0018218369223177433, 0.009875890798866749, -0.053480364382267, 0.02104826644062996, -0.07152605056762695, 0.02435535378754139, 0.00416267104446888, 0.011348309926688671, 0.04069148749113083, -0.011810462921857834, 0.0157858245074749, -0.058667734265327454, -0.03132471442222595, -0.010297093540430069, 0.007988049648702145, -0.023456798866391182, 0.0185053963214159, -0.026893166825175285, -0.03087838552892208, -0.0037776154931634665, -0.032892707735300064, -0.0017356433672830462, 0.02833119034767151, 0.005645423661917448, 0.04185133054852486, 0.050854429602622986, 0.021142905578017235, 0.030338125303387642, -0.004735162016004324, 0.027894917875528336, 0.025713371112942696, -0.006859878543764353, -0.02579016610980034, 0.025481397286057472, 0.0121946781873703, -0.006422348786145449, -0.018805818632245064, 0.03173305466771126, -0.025583092123270035, -0.0011066354345530272, -0.03321216255426407, -0.012550207786262035, 0.04023866355419159, -0.06154694780707359, -0.018069596961140633, -0.02563038468360901, 0.032627224922180176, 0.041060350835323334, -0.02125103771686554, 0.01794447749853134, -0.002091882051900029, -0.00907848309725523, -0.04891257733106613, -0.03810221329331398, 0.038550637662410736, -0.010563728399574757, -0.015827229246497154, 0.010553346946835518, -0.0032593475189059973, -0.014971526339650154, -0.00403218436986208, -0.025305472314357758, 0.020943565294146538, 0.05380302667617798, -0.03149685636162758, -0.014646405354142189, -0.014777908101677895, 0.035288505256175995, 0.04173845797777176, -0.06370944529771805, 0.029666217043995857, 0.009004637598991394, 0.011976736597716808, -0.05388271436095238, -0.012241460382938385, -0.033190906047821045, 0.04295671358704567, 0.04642099514603615, -0.023346683010458946, 0.012053210288286209, -0.05206386372447014, 0.022843945771455765, 0.025557346642017365, -0.06444421410560608, 0.04593612998723984, -0.03331556171178818, 0.00927564688026905, -0.0013181093381717801, -0.010814877226948738, -0.0537395104765892, 0.0402444452047348, 0.007151051890105009, 0.0023810709826648235, 0.007173551246523857, 0.007867150940001011, -0.04632078856229782, -0.031376827508211136, 0.029956182464957237, -0.006837523076683283, 0.03067711740732193, 0.008179868571460247, -0.010008245706558228, 0.050255101174116135, 0.016360849142074585, -0.0319807268679142, 0.033532433211803436, -0.07716753333806992, 0.0368669256567955, -0.022444698959589005, -0.026584168896079063, -0.005822747480124235, -0.060909707099199295, 0.03863582760095596, -0.022913584485650063, -0.05551702156662941, -0.011506734415888786, 0.022062506526708603, -0.0011143177980557084, 0.04895653575658798, 0.012356617487967014, 0.041732773184776306, -0.024664754047989845, -0.009771288372576237, -0.021899471059441566, 0.017486728727817535, -0.01284821517765522, -0.020013580098748207, 0.025888876989483833, 0.026281600818037987, -0.0028135378379374743, 0.025251559913158417, -0.013799444772303104, 0.005010005086660385, 0.010235408321022987, -0.01387635525316, -0.010796747170388699, -0.0345064178109169, -0.016469841822981834, 0.0022384694311767817, -0.033301807940006256, 0.02768038585782051, -0.028955314308404922, 0.024857621639966965, -0.012324797920882702, 0.021798741072416306, -0.01182091236114502, 0.020998608320951462, -0.05059567466378212, -0.01979096792638302, 0.005154382437467575, 0.016684290021657944, -0.015478702262043953, -0.04617449641227722, 0.006947482470422983, -0.022973056882619858, -0.005730607081204653, -0.016347143799066544, 0.007533385418355465, 0.008312073536217213, 0.0025556867476552725, -0.08631889522075653, -0.01674877665936947, 0.03361239656805992, 0.007513072341680527, -0.022481119260191917, -0.012988175265491009, -0.04984816908836365, 0.040432609617710114, 0.02755083702504635, 0.011012788861989975, 0.0017122511053457856, 0.022574948146939278, -0.020613161846995354, 0.009905217215418816, 0.013129939325153828 ]
<p>I have written a paired t-test and I am looking for some standard unit tests that I can make sure my code is correct. Do such tests exist? How does R take care of unit testing for its t.test()?</p>
35,940
[ -0.026363858953118324, -0.008295265957713127, -0.0026496348436921835, 0.018122708424925804, -0.004803002346307039, 0.01569625921547413, 0.015616604126989841, -0.021016346290707588, 0.02325783483684063, 0.0289172250777483, 0.057116322219371796, 0.0737452283501625, 0.016509784385561943, -0.0004304297617636621, 0.010515791364014149, -0.028993407264351845, -0.038366395980119705, -0.031575869768857956, -0.008777770213782787, -0.0006876682746224105, 0.007615113165229559, -0.00866520032286644, 0.024246593937277794, -0.022507909685373306, 0.039694007486104965, 0.022736303508281708, -0.0065492792055010796, -0.0018599532777443528, 0.010331284254789352, 0.07872118055820465, -0.07730839401483536, -0.0468674935400486, 0.01180181372910738, 0.037727151066064835, -0.0171811506152153, 0.007891645655035973, -0.016904572024941444, -0.02180524915456772, -0.029952319338917732, 0.012853016145527363, -0.026807665824890137, -0.04644576832652092, -0.0028429424855858088, 0.016248278319835663, -0.0019296511309221387, 0.038471806794404984, -0.008502217940986156, -0.005094206891953945, 0.02794135920703411, -0.03969508036971092, 0.047912079840898514, 0.03196733817458153, 0.047837335616350174, 0.02839372120797634, -0.005943024065345526, 0.009910673834383488, 0.07110711932182312, 0.03765961527824402, -0.0330592542886734, -0.04955027252435684, -0.023068547248840332, -0.07063335180282593, 0.03318808227777481, -0.020573468878865242, -0.0793316438794136, 0.020698461681604385, -0.011629859916865826, 0.012767709791660309, -0.009678659960627556, -0.03691216558218002, 0.006404671352356672, 0.01519868429750204, 0.029393499717116356, -0.005982891656458378, -0.021979816257953644, -0.007256682496517897, 0.033988818526268005, 0.0028405769262462854, 0.06476737558841705, 0.056476373225450516, 0.008476024493575096, 0.02200273610651493, 0.025258749723434448, 0.04190930351614952, 0.031011415645480156, -0.038647498935461044, 0.027040135115385056, -0.0104457326233387, -0.007767714560031891, 0.01865551993250847, 0.015848195180296898, -0.04896043613553047, 0.05747969076037407, 0.029681270942091942, -0.0401516817510128, 0.012256797403097153, -0.02172117680311203, 0.018069017678499222, -0.0025313745718449354, -0.009212074801325798, 0.020674249157309532, -0.043465886265039444, 0.030528783798217773, 0.04454193264245987, -0.0457170270383358, -0.02732151933014393, -0.027172446250915527, -0.026588594540953636, 0.001163708628155291, 0.014094398356974125, -0.04423441365361214, 0.038946717977523804, -0.03973640501499176, -0.004173677880316973, 0.05794546380639076, -0.0116354338824749, -0.01994764432311058, -0.020793698728084564, 0.10095774382352829, 0.05488182231783867, 0.07703986763954163, -0.031790539622306824, 0.019883794710040092, -0.025588342919945717, -0.06207091361284256, 0.027250630781054497, 0.012065106071531773, -0.03391950577497482, -0.03499562665820122, 0.058454763144254684, -0.024930402636528015, -0.04158629849553108, 0.01391727663576603, 0.01502901129424572, 0.0523737296462059, -0.029856722801923752, -0.07033721357584, -0.07537706196308136, 0.006030218675732613, -0.03406968712806702, -0.026121819391846657, -0.04390765354037285, 0.018195629119873047, -0.00271361181512475, 0.03645424172282219, 0.015810037031769753, 0.02567717246711254, 0.01616758294403553, -0.00012277250061742961, 0.008148301392793655, -0.016484472900629044, -0.03211112320423126, -0.0017900230595842004, -0.011854949407279491, -0.004492452833801508, -0.06430058181285858, 0.011491179466247559, 0.012164994142949581, -0.021752631291747093, -0.00533874798566103, 0.03019811399281025, 0.01564483344554901, -0.015556643716990948, -0.010552254505455494, 0.021148808300495148, -0.023247459903359413, 0.05717252194881439, -0.02197127602994442, 0.030856765806674957, 0.00932404212653637, -0.04086627438664436, 0.0040412843227386475, 0.04572446644306183, 0.02354222908616066, -0.007632474415004253, -0.030587999150156975, -0.012489241547882557, -0.026446128264069557, 0.031636834144592285, 0.010062589310109615, -0.017776327207684517, 0.01181828323751688, 0.010025234892964363, -0.007840195670723915, -0.008565371856093407, 0.03324455767869949, 0.0018765460699796677, -0.007217108272016048, 0.05873989686369896, -0.06500154733657837, -0.029212038964033127, -0.054649464786052704, 0.014611748978495598, 0.001487170229665935, -0.033570773899555206, -0.009038656018674374, 0.0020977349486202, 0.045196615159511566, -0.022383790463209152, -0.006631255615502596, -0.02847759798169136, 0.04201910272240639, 0.02171720191836357, -0.014544568955898285, 0.007521686144173145, 0.026318613439798355, 0.06612125039100647, -0.024111803621053696, 0.03984185308218002, -0.037497956305742264, -0.04798785597085953, 0.012191523797810078, -0.057840414345264435, 0.01376307476311922, -0.005717798136174679, -0.04235086590051651, 0.03271159902215004, 0.0010026575764641166, -0.005244147963821888, 0.045854609459638596, -0.04677345231175423, 0.025444120168685913, 0.012302756309509277, 0.039996467530727386, -0.0008554721134714782, -0.02840050309896469, 0.004790642764419317, 0.002017169026657939, -0.03888506442308426, 0.018789658322930336, -0.05833112820982933, -0.0057448274455964565, 0.06292401254177094, 0.02574065327644348, -0.025340015068650246, 0.02762993425130844, 0.058001305907964706, 0.0025878907181322575, -0.003291202476248145, 0.03752657771110535, -0.0032329114619642496, -0.013705131597816944, -0.015585316345095634, 0.0273379385471344, 0.02924572117626667, 0.02918628789484501, 0.020480671897530556, 0.006697002798318863, 0.056182026863098145, 0.029864497482776642, -0.029457304626703262, 0.04388417676091194, 0.0024975878186523914, -0.00600166292861104, -0.0012365075526759028, -0.034758083522319794, 0.042590122669935226, -0.016302280128002167, -0.0038367051165550947, 0.0231003537774086, 0.028601419180631638, -0.0023854610044509172, 0.005145389121025801, -0.012654777616262436, 0.01820850931107998, 0.029518788680434227, -0.025774270296096802, -0.010315773077309132, 0.037227217108011246, -0.03543464094400406, 0.022237829864025116, -0.043885450810194016, -0.0013316607801243663, -0.038736991584300995, 0.012424160726368427, 0.019496189430356026, -0.010054191574454308, 0.03663768246769905, -0.014214174821972847, 0.0074310810305178165, 0.004844678100198507, -0.03186513110995293, 0.007553756702691317, -0.03375237062573433, -0.032473500818014145, 0.04384011775255203, -0.02110699564218521, -0.04306038096547127, 0.042053353041410446, 0.00975894182920456, 0.008476503193378448, 0.03598719835281372, -0.012173691764473915, -0.034358810633420944, -0.02347840555012226, -0.043227095156908035, -0.009605332277715206, -0.04910051077604294, 0.014752981252968311, 0.033091239631175995, -0.018616782501339912, -0.06355877220630646, 0.03214319795370102, -0.04058443009853363, 0.03603345900774002, -0.0546715073287487, -0.020465828478336334, 0.018062835559248924, -0.009692984633147717, 0.004846134223043919, 0.04901948571205139, -0.06731796264648438, -0.0130762979388237, -0.0655914917588234, -0.023920904844999313, 0.008236764930188656, 0.015741784125566483, 0.04631456360220909, 0.01854381337761879, -0.02383309416472912, 0.056733351200819016, 0.00758702727034688, -0.05302265286445618, -0.036616139113903046, -0.004703714977949858, -0.04235636442899704, -0.023584652692079544, 0.031355321407318115, 0.014820066280663013, 0.030189964920282364, -0.015153317712247372, 0.019834905862808228, 0.007879549637436867, 0.04866756498813629, 0.02362881600856781, 0.008402706123888493, 0.0028339335694909096, 0.03354715555906296, -0.02578829601407051, 0.03380293399095535, -0.002060337457805872, -0.024264048784971237, -0.006074102595448494, 0.0036779085639864206, 0.001154365949332714, -0.005662235897034407, -0.002801586640998721, 0.010117278434336185, -0.009979335591197014, -0.00658043846487999, -0.020514847710728645, 0.02078975923359394, 0.011177190579473972, -0.021228939294815063, -0.0036630930844694376, 0.05498670041561127, 0.03016221895813942, -0.019151506945490837, 0.021821700036525726, 0.036316704005002975, 0.034527506679296494, -0.04996111989021301, 0.0062827118672430515, -0.01683603972196579, 0.001170610310509801, 0.016456572338938713, -0.016532912850379944, -0.036875005811452866, 0.057197049260139465, 0.00401648972183466, 0.058925844728946686, 0.03424299880862236, -0.03758374601602554, 0.027158217504620552, -0.0322435200214386, 0.007593793328851461, -0.03531430661678314, 0.034533675760030746, 0.004866651725023985, 0.02577008120715618, 0.031001536175608635, 0.013610302470624447, 0.019721897318959236, -0.006070203613489866, -0.03897225484251976, 0.01449927594512701, -0.028885556384921074, -0.058824215084314346, 0.02142173983156681, 0.0036264925729483366, -0.016869647428393364, -0.012455900199711323, 0.022226084023714066, -0.014755803160369396, 0.0003945169737562537, -0.0335518904030323, 0.029357673600316048, -0.004820782225579023, -0.014724904671311378, 0.020906029269099236, 0.026121649891138077, 0.011117691174149513, -0.016718391329050064, 0.0011322459904477, 0.024699511006474495, -0.00825869757682085, 0.02520342729985714, 0.0008067481103353202, -0.008721703663468361, 0.0253737960010767, 0.048854757100343704, 0.07138476520776749, 0.05897777900099754, -0.045187320560216904, 0.014859453774988651, -0.0028650336898863316, 0.05846879631280899, 0.047148000448942184, -0.035775892436504364, -0.04021431505680084, -0.0324583426117897, -0.04147769510746002, 0.01796373724937439, 0.03471377119421959, -0.00008440799865638837, -0.006946328561753035, 0.03123943880200386, 0.03855070471763611, -0.04387153312563896, -0.012916718609631062, 0.07126280665397644, 0.0234934464097023, -0.016122009605169296, 0.00019534995954018086, -0.04310343414545059, 0.005528965499252081, -0.001298084040172398, 0.023775942623615265, 0.028491828590631485, -0.011434899643063545, 0.0169144868850708, 0.01641256920993328, -0.01850721426308155, -0.02645830437541008, -0.01583448052406311, 0.02118890918791294, 0.035774920135736465, -0.0027839047834277153, -0.01656033843755722, 0.013413884676992893, 0.02161279506981373, 0.00032963426201604307, 0.018611092120409012, -0.013831681571900845, -0.05475644767284393, 0.03202562779188156, 0.08990634977817535, 0.03398790583014488, -0.01930268667638302, -0.040100522339344025, -0.00894225388765335, -0.004387629218399525, 0.05301564931869507, -0.05474304035305977, 0.01177284587174654, -0.020365232601761818, 0.013254445046186447, -0.058450136333703995, 0.022325120866298676, -0.0338810496032238, 0.027048595249652863, -0.04780515655875206, 0.02968686632812023, -0.01638050377368927, -0.037847649306058884, -0.031240276992321014, 0.020718421787023544, 0.007224199827760458, 0.05090823397040367, -0.047818999737501144, -0.033388249576091766, 0.005334766115993261, -0.0004914335440844297, -0.025926584377884865, -0.017368469387292862, -0.009943255223333836, -0.01762435957789421, 0.004610463976860046, 0.04023515433073044, 0.00905422493815422, -0.023380950093269348, 0.03779350966215134, 0.01917063631117344, -0.03397712856531143, 0.03903665021061897, -0.019401103258132935, -0.022305641323328018, 0.03514442592859268, 0.014225560240447521, 0.047713752835989, 0.010191649198532104, 0.017775965854525566, 0.01245623268187046, -0.030741961672902107, 0.01102125272154808, -0.04294994845986366, -0.021590953692793846, -0.04488274082541466, -0.03312239795923233, -0.024561766535043716, 0.016631802543997765, 0.012974640354514122, 0.015406214632093906, -0.03048514947295189, 0.0008255655411630869, 0.0028238422237336636, 0.04254626855254173, -0.0050264098681509495, 0.0002314327284693718, 0.00994255393743515, -0.002885739551857114, -0.03423842415213585, -0.002359848702326417, 0.0212941225618124, -0.006583048030734062, -0.005326137412339449, 0.021125245839357376, -0.03183523193001747, 0.04842644929885864, -0.012223728932440281, -0.014934680424630642, 0.021552618592977524, -0.02420688234269619, 0.03675729036331177, -0.01678159087896347, 0.018983349204063416, -0.013258224353194237, -0.01212997641414404, -0.0018049875507131219, 0.06386072933673859, 0.017589544877409935, 0.026445018127560616, -0.037560660392045975, 0.07236815243959427, -0.015307958237826824, -0.027419699355959892, -0.03871186450123787, -0.04461874067783356, 0.02540716715157032, -0.00044431095011532307, -0.022978896275162697, -0.04466377943754196, 0.026706164702773094, -0.03276229277253151, 0.0217453520745039, -0.03791790083050728, 0.06817309558391571, -0.0277443565428257, -0.02010664902627468, -0.05193072184920311, -0.0027221282944083214, 0.05011249706149101, 0.03932882100343704, 0.015147959813475609, -0.00895763374865055, -0.003822048893198371, -0.02875121310353279, -0.004411645233631134, -0.009771793149411678, -0.028327040374279022, -0.014661164954304695, -0.03942084312438965, -0.003342714859172702, 0.03864560276269913, -0.025904735550284386, -0.016356993466615677, 0.011549933813512325, -0.04134557768702507, -0.02152310125529766, -0.06247126683592796, 0.036056775599718094, -0.03141268342733383, -0.002916665282100439, -0.06539175659418106, -0.00018515992269385606, 0.0005518320249393582, -0.0475507453083992, 0.018070915713906288, -0.011227259412407875, 0.006997252348810434, 0.02143302746117115, 0.06443890184164047, 0.017568040639162064, 0.02984410896897316, -0.02989024668931961, -0.006481021177023649, 0.007020496763288975, -0.018588000908493996, -0.02267874963581562, -0.009829171001911163, 0.008795628324151039, -0.049737829715013504, -0.018811682239174843, 0.013597331941127777, -0.022459104657173157, 0.04597533866763115, 0.0035451326984912157, 0.071651890873909, 0.059872180223464966, 0.016359619796276093, -0.009055268950760365, 0.0024439948610961437, -0.021011564880609512, -0.0023769757244735956, 0.022952008992433548, 0.0506771020591259, 0.03720519691705704, 0.016706930473446846, 0.04296332970261574, 0.007785182911902666, 0.024558207020163536, 0.05585731565952301, -0.02241939678788185, -0.005909567698836327, 0.016258440911769867, -0.005290474742650986, -0.041898198425769806, 0.007788772229105234, -0.06980323791503906, 0.003398407716304064, -0.0386359803378582, -0.014110528863966465, 0.02349543385207653, 0.025974033400416374, -0.011379153467714787, -0.02330639958381653, -0.036268703639507294, -0.0738731250166893, 0.028115250170230865, 0.020054742693901062, -0.03606082499027252, 0.025702225044369698, 0.022469570860266685, 0.020962972193956375, -0.013493905775249004, 0.06396456807851791, -0.04657236114144325, -0.06769032031297684, -0.03437648341059685, -0.0069406041875481606, -0.03213072568178177, 0.028248213231563568, 0.013123095035552979, -0.01277207862585783, -0.0014597446424886584, -0.05825874209403992, 0.035566188395023346, 0.012209760956466198, 0.04943400248885155, -0.038517650216817856, 0.07052291929721832, -0.020875820890069008, 0.013453902676701546, -0.010105052962899208, -0.020242221653461456, 0.12806542217731476, 0.05866947025060654, 0.06578506529331207, -0.09906642138957977, 0.025903062894940376, 0.0044803498312830925, 0.0020498246885836124, -0.02808212675154209, 0.013821247965097427, 0.038504764437675476, 0.003251939080655575, 0.06601931899785995, 0.05308808386325836, 0.01903940737247467, -0.0036478738766163588, 0.0644310787320137, -0.022014789283275604, -0.03252451866865158, 0.01574077643454075, 0.022330941632390022, 0.007597833871841431, -0.034703291952610016, -0.05169837176799774, -0.016223059967160225, 0.00555611914023757, 0.011363857425749302, -0.015099743381142616, -0.008724057115614414, 0.02701147273182869, 0.027253227308392525, -0.02034803293645382, -0.0117962546646595, 0.014838510192930698, 0.0051979259587824345, -0.015391863882541656, -0.012114577926695347, 0.006715813651680946, -0.02445634827017784, 0.03123711235821247, 0.0445944145321846, 0.02118249610066414, 0.003362257033586502, 0.021661004051566124, 0.012957995757460594, -0.033617764711380005, -0.01732819341123104, -0.02429930493235588, 0.03990847244858742, -0.03383204713463783, -0.0167176965624094, -0.007656614296138287, 0.02288825809955597, 0.008263838477432728, -0.04078729450702667, -0.012935509905219078, 0.03569396585226059, 0.022089114412665367, -0.026118237525224686, 0.013971005566418171, -0.01417035236954689, 0.0461648590862751, -0.03378419205546379, 0.05069999024271965, 0.006152940448373556, -0.024866480380296707, -0.0060326457023620605, -0.02404099330306053, 0.045093562453985214, -0.013688618317246437, 0.012995203025639057, 0.023729577660560608, -0.023669719696044922, 0.0070113856345415115, 0.007312744855880737, 0.04174044728279114, 0.02723870426416397, -0.007844611071050167, 0.002434325870126486, 0.016675520688295364, -0.0059405481442809105, -0.019452549517154694, 0.015447390265762806, -0.047524385154247284, -0.03650786355137825, -0.042182374745607376, -0.012921313755214214, 0.07409898191690445, 0.028473645448684692, 0.027299735695123672, 0.013899941928684711, -0.03277505189180374, 0.029961837455630302, 0.014751571230590343, -0.058701042085886, 0.0008629948133602738, -0.016160443425178528, -0.010919869877398014, -0.03408176824450493, -0.04905533790588379, 0.028955353423953056, 0.06568692624568939, 0.04791519045829773, -0.01839429698884487, -0.007620197255164385, -0.003596401307731867, 0.006643163971602917, 0.011796990409493446, -0.0690731629729271, -0.02859587036073208, -0.011539650149643421, -0.006768808234483004, -0.02448849193751812, -0.001722637563943863, -0.06219523027539253, -0.020836561918258667, 0.019798029214143753, -0.028444163501262665, -0.03980259969830513, -0.0011195322731509805, -0.001830084016546607, 0.02387893944978714, -0.038129307329654694, 0.0111331045627594, -0.02208058349788189, -0.04292085021734238, 0.006716524716466665, -0.01986360177397728, -0.018506886437535286, -0.0008514551445841789, -0.012997196055948734, 0.0109679801389575, 0.04700708016753197, -0.000929691712372005, 0.010505775921046734, 0.0354204960167408, -0.01526697538793087, 0.020381681621074677, 0.01904977858066559, -0.005136827006936073, -0.015136764384806156, 0.06070281192660332, -0.030036134645342827, -0.006009935867041349, -0.010974871926009655, -0.01567736640572548, 0.027451835572719574, -0.018701741471886635, -0.03868749737739563, -0.00291747460141778, 0.0461774542927742, -0.03666447103023529, -0.013508344069123268, 0.013804905116558075, 0.004163438454270363, 0.010570804588496685, 0.03097030147910118, 0.022092623636126518, -0.019002318382263184, -0.01828457973897457, 0.0049383267760276794, 0.048199862241744995, 0.013991130515933037, 0.005051373038440943, 0.015570686198771, -0.0003552545385900885, 0.04555089771747589, 0.02113780565559864, -0.008708164095878601, 0.019191689789295197, 0.03542225807905197, -0.012101823464035988, 0.05223802849650383, -0.010557274334132671, 0.02215086854994297, -0.09395354986190796, -0.000407766638090834, 0.023069998249411583, -0.0029042952228337526, 0.03516253083944321, -0.052029918879270554, -0.007289426401257515, 0.034686826169490814, -0.03863278031349182, 0.024142973124980927, -0.01679806597530842, -0.04166164621710777, -0.016124658286571503, 0.01184556819498539, -0.009697874076664448, 0.01104951836168766, 0.02290482632815838, 0.016653766855597496, 0.014395511709153652, 0.02080906741321087, -0.0007911638240329921, 0.002030697651207447, -0.037008386105298996, -0.011278764344751835, 0.02563406527042389, -0.05321909859776497, 0.040730517357587814, -0.016407350078225136, -0.020878849551081657, -0.008730580098927021, 0.02993280440568924, 0.034445155411958694, 0.005136467050760984, 0.05545557662844658, 0.013643672689795494, 0.056743912398815155, 0.043752655386924744, -0.004698645789176226, -0.032159268856048584, -0.008234011940658092, -0.011650187894701958, 0.015762468799948692, -0.03446207195520401, 0.0037097190506756306, 0.023590007796883583, -0.011172991245985031, -0.0033168962690979242, 0.045087020844221115, -0.0076721967197954655, -0.044632866978645325, -0.026162544265389442, 0.017597442492842674, 0.034680888056755066, -0.027288099750876427, -0.0037816811818629503, -0.021482378244400024, 0.022573323920369148, 0.05138210207223892, 0.0312933549284935, -0.01265134196728468, 0.010082856751978397, 0.0018170870607718825, -0.021218134090304375, 0.02999376505613327, -0.008183751255273819, 0.00005357553527574055, -0.07477397471666336, 0.009476312436163425, -0.012668942101299763, -0.013781698420643806, -0.04026388004422188, -0.015058415941894054, 0.019046584144234657, 0.050577521324157715, -0.00029024615650996566, 0.0031482730992138386, 0.010294211097061634, 0.004578722640872002, 0.009147697128355503, -0.05678920820355415, 0.07904020696878433, -0.013163398019969463, 0.0186696108430624, -0.039723414927721024, 0.01844814233481884, -0.04150042310357094, -0.007957962341606617, 0.053101249039173126, 0.032233674079179764, 0.024908646941184998, 0.0028561882209032774, 0.00505734933540225, 0.006532770581543446, -0.07669279724359512, 0.031012939289212227, -0.04118207469582558, -0.023594893515110016, -0.039291299879550934, -0.026803359389305115, 0.039983998984098434, 0.008047813549637794, 0.007040195632725954, -0.0289172250777483, -0.012535205110907555, -0.014496018178761005, -0.012938537634909153, 0.03670423477888107, 0.02420668490231037, 0.0033802592661231756, 0.05692568048834801, 0.007221428211778402, 0.04967432841658592, 0.027191929519176483, -0.0068013621494174, -0.019089387729763985, 0.03761424124240875, -0.036340899765491486, -0.024849841371178627, -0.01908177323639393, 0.035288453102111816, -0.038641031831502914, -0.04706031456589699, -0.03779926151037216, 0.007653150241822004, -0.018589846789836884, 0.018880309537053108, 0.006944398861378431, 0.03837118297815323, 0.03364343196153641, -0.04078954458236694, 0.020150069147348404, 0.024773038923740387, 0.003919360693544149, -0.001570165972225368, -0.0007551193702965975, 0.008685528300702572, -0.0147285470739007, -0.01110342051833868, 0.008784807287156582, -0.06675145030021667, 0.03638980910181999, -0.034964580088853836, 0.0850817859172821, -0.022786209359765053, -0.01849319413304329, 0.035361308604478836, -0.037044957280159, 0.02481299825012684, -0.011543210595846176, -0.017887037247419357, 0.04777955636382103, -0.05978589504957199, 0.0015485899057239294, -0.05968817323446274, -0.020807405933737755, 0.0004066426772624254, 0.020452335476875305, 0.03318502753973007, 0.007147219032049179, -0.03951936587691307, 0.021083224564790726, 0.011460704728960991, -0.02311922051012516, 0.010216795839369297, -0.0010332348756492138, 0.01580350659787655, -0.03820427134633064, 0.005213216412812471, -0.01210485678166151, -0.005526266526430845, -0.057467132806777954, -0.0003325979632791132, 0.006595944054424763, 0.029671039432287216, 0.027337756007909775, -0.05440822243690491, 0.01179690845310688, 0.0197824127972126, 0.019544610753655434, -0.0915866419672966, -0.006392406765371561, -0.03634924814105034, 0.018687691539525986, -0.0038992136251181364, -0.021042704582214355 ]
<p>I am new to bootstrapping. Assume I have some non-normal data, can be any distribution, it doesn't matter, and I want to find a confidence interval for the mean, median and standard deviation. For the median this question is relevant also for the normal case. What I don't know is (and asking you to help with) is:</p> <p>I understand the idea of bootstrapping, the re-sampling idea of generating n samples with replacement, and therefore getting n means, medians or standard deviations. What I don't understand, is how the confidence interval is being calculated. I mean, given a sample of n medians, which aren't normally distributed, how do I calculate it, I don't have Z's or t's values.</p>
28,353
[ -0.007739771157503128, -0.023085739463567734, -0.0022183789405971766, 0.003483981592580676, 0.01852468028664589, 0.01514354906976223, 0.0002656237338669598, -0.02713993564248085, 0.025358065962791443, -0.02724040113389492, 0.026238588616251945, 0.02905632182955742, 0.026091787964105606, -0.011273407377302647, 0.015148207545280457, -0.009490917436778545, -0.04112645611166954, -0.0032715892884880304, 0.01214575208723545, -0.02343572862446308, 0.002977382391691208, 0.02361178956925869, 0.013638966716825962, -0.0014432448660954833, -0.003769782604649663, 0.015575776807963848, 0.017052803188562393, -0.0016739827115088701, 0.05553264915943146, 0.05503097176551819, -0.05884755775332451, -0.03818250074982643, 0.004535720217972994, 0.05251083895564079, -0.012626178562641144, -0.008020992390811443, -0.01785038784146309, -0.02298450469970703, 0.003242623759433627, 0.013818785548210144, -0.04736664518713951, 0.002437687711790204, -0.010348638519644737, 0.015786904841661453, -0.02135656774044037, 0.0066396561451256275, -0.019349608570337296, -0.051541879773139954, 0.011034535244107246, -0.042276930063962936, 0.07580702751874924, 0.005680636502802372, 0.04408502206206322, 0.04584202915430069, 0.003377011511474848, 0.004778272472321987, 0.043186254799366, 0.036493342369794846, -0.02334592118859291, -0.05451646447181702, 0.0010697176912799478, -0.04107869043946266, -0.007960041984915733, -0.031006524339318275, -0.014144913293421268, 0.014084733091294765, 0.004335747566074133, 0.010529644787311554, 0.04872039705514908, -0.001311346422880888, 0.02288985066115856, 0.02897479385137558, 0.057039692997932434, -0.025661204010248184, 0.0009876335971057415, -0.03244376555085182, 0.032540347427129745, -0.013552248477935791, 0.07493002712726593, 0.016150668263435364, 0.0013496322790160775, 0.016149021685123444, 0.009022283367812634, 0.050143394619226456, 0.011077097617089748, -0.02894870936870575, 0.07496751099824905, -0.023986466228961945, 0.033408768475055695, 0.02301754243671894, -0.03363163769245148, -0.01746988482773304, 0.047524698078632355, -0.032402634620666504, -0.03965188190340996, 0.040990520268678665, -0.015225567854940891, 0.052468687295913696, -0.03401810675859451, -0.0017918278463184834, 0.03568698838353157, 0.000373228220269084, 0.015753919258713722, 0.027873435989022255, -0.02450471930205822, 0.006647540256381035, -0.013307934626936913, -0.0034058219753205776, 0.025594254955649376, -0.022571580484509468, -0.031751155853271484, 0.02919306419789791, -0.011920955032110214, 0.01679893396794796, 0.04025465250015259, -0.004791900049895048, -0.005436968058347702, -0.038685865700244904, 0.027561886236071587, 0.010682942345738411, 0.025939874351024628, -0.017960775643587112, 0.03317201882600784, -0.02189699374139309, -0.031600937247276306, 0.020012253895401955, -0.0026503826957195997, -0.004744216334074736, -0.02149684727191925, 0.034398093819618225, -0.026807675138115883, -0.0230712890625, 0.04400978609919548, 0.01550448127090931, 0.058016013354063034, -0.0009654684108681977, -0.06624387949705124, -0.04357044771313667, 0.0038280636072158813, -0.023485641926527023, 0.0038180698174983263, -0.06615319848060608, -0.001577926566824317, 0.03150102123618126, 0.0025080349296331406, 0.03373734652996063, 0.03997616842389107, -0.02094028703868389, 0.025571033358573914, 0.019478468224406242, -0.03692556917667389, -0.006281561218202114, -0.016424154862761497, 0.007705016527324915, 0.024583443999290466, -0.07701954990625381, 0.05801823362708092, -0.0012785233557224274, -0.017274143174290657, -0.0559089258313179, 0.015454869717359543, 0.0038989114109426737, -0.03232748061418533, -0.01895291917026043, 0.02096930518746376, 0.011841795407235622, 0.06818170845508575, -0.03407832607626915, 0.002597366226837039, 0.012298106215894222, -0.015794003382325172, 0.007667247671633959, -0.005497748963534832, 0.05557376891374588, 0.07023216784000397, -0.026766490191221237, -0.031308189034461975, -0.04976211488246918, 0.036295048892498016, 0.018714552745223045, -0.03112776018679142, 0.0014592284569516778, 0.00492802495136857, 0.03517691791057587, 0.024019036442041397, 0.011502210050821304, 0.011051120236515999, -0.029138850048184395, 0.042215634137392044, -0.04311392083764076, 0.006152583751827478, -0.06652621924877167, -0.010138401761651039, -0.00950560625642538, -0.005721616093069315, 0.02241596020758152, 0.03910454362630844, 0.04031376913189888, -0.023231860250234604, -0.027877960354089737, -0.0021836492232978344, -0.014338402077555656, 0.04376668855547905, -0.06772468239068985, 0.037289779633283615, 0.04380122572183609, 0.03937461972236633, -0.010671410709619522, 0.058707285672426224, -0.0235607773065567, -0.01965278945863247, 0.0014639263972640038, -0.03330056741833687, -0.023340685293078423, 0.007550808135420084, -0.03643205016851425, 0.025094278156757355, -0.014921847730875015, 0.0092611750587821, 0.03338602930307388, -0.037623848766088486, 0.05439959093928337, 0.051771700382232666, -0.012331301346421242, -0.012924239039421082, -0.002003426430746913, 0.010491034016013145, 0.026013260707259178, -0.011391902342438698, 0.0031361884903162718, -0.05504235252737999, -0.05592013895511627, 0.028971988707780838, -0.008248641155660152, -0.034219782799482346, 0.006308892276138067, 0.07894431799650192, -0.00022462439665105194, 0.030195703729987144, 0.04977293685078621, -0.01789858005940914, -0.007037122268229723, -0.008915422484278679, 0.042567383497953415, 0.03148976340889931, -0.001731890020892024, -0.024947691708803177, 0.027413049712777138, 0.025529302656650543, 0.046393897384405136, 0.010662492364645004, 0.043293096125125885, 0.001018403097987175, 0.003895233618095517, -0.02105688862502575, -0.03416445851325989, 0.04299772158265114, -0.0075372206047177315, -0.01086178794503212, 0.05309556424617767, 0.0038971216417849064, 0.0028263013809919357, 0.007664207369089127, -0.015445545315742493, 0.024131877347826958, 0.05205175280570984, -0.05734320729970932, 0.018156416714191437, 0.016391444951295853, -0.005717888940125704, 0.0006476271082647145, -0.029085418209433556, -0.03722770884633064, -0.02742197923362255, 0.0019305410096421838, 0.0069105844013392925, -0.017763013020157814, 0.055200979113578796, 0.0036309442948549986, -0.028943588957190514, -0.01209284644573927, -0.0019472484709694982, -0.00009578726894687861, 0.005751791875809431, -0.060476530343294144, -0.009357446804642677, -0.0035803099162876606, -0.06285907328128815, 0.00003369291516719386, -0.006394141353666782, -0.009862531907856464, 0.024693693965673447, -0.02648996002972126, -0.013698756694793701, -0.006757756695151329, -0.018041247501969337, 0.007954545319080353, -0.0073147970251739025, -0.005778421647846699, 0.05454026535153389, 0.031888075172901154, -0.03964541107416153, 0.06920663267374039, -0.028562339022755623, -0.06368663907051086, -0.07228036969900131, 0.021182309836149216, 0.0026630666106939316, -0.008131636306643486, 0.022110508754849434, -0.0024557258002460003, -0.012185958214104176, 0.021659167483448982, -0.05019070580601692, -0.02957112155854702, 0.014900164678692818, 0.026324303820729256, 0.03471501171588898, 0.009519523940980434, -0.010568187572062016, 0.09650592505931854, -0.0023443771060556173, -0.02506047673523426, 0.0029200073331594467, -0.015931639820337296, -0.0338069349527359, -0.0065283505246043205, 0.006122939754277468, 0.014325033873319626, 0.01644214056432247, 0.005050762090831995, 0.008685176260769367, 0.022825807332992554, 0.0784454271197319, 0.003092695726081729, 0.022303877398371696, -0.012105279602110386, 0.004624092485755682, -0.014037864282727242, 0.05720367282629013, 0.02408931590616703, -0.0319635346531868, 0.0012809685431420803, 0.007022488862276077, 0.024691492319107056, 0.01032343227416277, -0.05699506402015686, 0.024365143850445747, -0.019075220450758934, -0.007398765534162521, -0.047697413712739944, 0.026429124176502228, 0.018721966072916985, -0.017721496522426605, 0.045592453330755234, 0.025609849020838737, 0.008369579911231995, -0.026678144931793213, -0.004940213169902563, 0.03034329041838646, 0.040020644664764404, -0.02080008201301098, -0.021627768874168396, -0.011612644419074059, -0.027994276955723763, -0.006688250228762627, -0.00800353568047285, 0.002788017736747861, 0.022709805518388748, 0.07441424578428268, -0.0009354591020382941, -0.01373253669589758, -0.030881348997354507, 0.025642836466431618, -0.02099832333624363, 0.007298225071281195, 0.012323963455855846, 0.015704819932579994, -0.02963515743613243, 0.08343320339918137, 0.015501581132411957, -0.00474885106086731, 0.013500646688044071, 0.011288532987236977, -0.03562996909022331, 0.04364459589123726, -0.03510225564241409, -0.025651590898633003, 0.00390962790697813, -0.01666330173611641, 0.03076086938381195, -0.013318507932126522, 0.03061266615986824, -0.0033141355961561203, 0.016278769820928574, -0.02283521369099617, 0.02216273546218872, -0.02671228162944317, 0.02847922034561634, -0.002592038828879595, 0.026255158707499504, 0.01682998798787594, -0.02224821224808693, 0.002289016731083393, 0.036295145750045776, 0.03178129345178604, -0.00878515001386404, -0.016254933550953865, 0.01828671246767044, 0.02971293404698372, 0.04120690003037453, 0.06595749408006668, 0.013587823137640953, -0.04387437179684639, -0.0000010612139931254205, -0.033644601702690125, 0.0871567353606224, 0.016641078516840935, -0.0210431981831789, -0.005929006729274988, -0.03617230802774429, -0.00531360600143671, -0.026254266500473022, 0.024736588820815086, -0.017705164849758148, 0.025087932124733925, 0.06660345941781998, -0.0015339519595727324, -0.08207257837057114, 0.00046060606837272644, 0.053690530359745026, 0.0076592001132667065, -0.017802486196160316, -0.04400784522294998, 0.013290886767208576, -0.045193709433078766, -0.011095314286649227, 0.03771882876753807, 0.008975133299827576, 0.004116359632462263, 0.03065553866326809, 0.07071681320667267, -0.023532968014478683, -0.03258668631315231, -0.007422498892992735, 0.042669616639614105, 0.05943041667342186, -0.0005568034248426557, -0.04767588526010513, 0.0046605439856648445, 0.01979081705212593, 0.003803231054916978, -0.0020134791266173124, 0.006027542520314455, -0.10630802810192108, 0.035726699978113174, 0.04160532355308533, 0.026352979242801666, -0.024067163467407227, -0.023162422701716423, -0.0403403714299202, 0.0109941391274333, 0.06610686331987381, -0.0470607727766037, 0.0024952793028205633, -0.01853862777352333, -0.014956007711589336, -0.022057346999645233, 0.02922433242201805, -0.04677405580878258, 0.0017902671825140715, -0.005862744525074959, 0.010483806021511555, -0.0205696951597929, -0.022185450419783592, -0.05482656881213188, -0.00881300400942564, 0.02851015515625477, 0.08054756373167038, -0.024763185530900955, 0.0021499597933143377, 0.00009397856774739921, 0.03563530743122101, -0.007398221176117659, -0.05769399181008339, 0.02164974808692932, -0.0009368365281261504, -0.005698285065591335, 0.0575687475502491, 0.005099788773804903, -0.04898855462670326, 0.04649076610803604, 0.011311730369925499, -0.04247608780860901, -0.0019891527481377125, -0.012883882038295269, -0.002012876095250249, 0.033825457096099854, 0.016040310263633728, 0.06666931509971619, -0.0007644720608368516, -0.0240611769258976, -0.006029288284480572, -0.03746741637587547, 0.03441222757101059, -0.03352678194642067, -0.012870360165834427, -0.030280331149697304, -0.004885202739387751, -0.02766435034573078, 0.01997176930308342, 0.0104015301913023, 0.007648323196917772, 0.008254061453044415, 0.008710559457540512, 0.02195931412279606, 0.03717746585607529, -0.0021326064597815275, 0.04010806977748871, -0.011339513584971428, 0.008208916522562504, 0.002327428199350834, -0.032382115721702576, 0.014642392285168171, 0.012941631488502026, -0.003055368782952428, -0.02491067722439766, -0.061276912689208984, 0.01715785823762417, -0.05586732551455498, -0.032216280698776245, 0.0345270000398159, -0.04513901099562645, 0.020061904564499855, 0.001188932335935533, 0.012468324974179268, -0.008395222947001457, -0.028888290748000145, -0.005492139607667923, 0.00356362946331501, -0.013196301646530628, 0.03492468595504761, -0.04977797344326973, 0.04807240143418312, 0.000903549836948514, 0.015024622902274132, -0.07703127712011337, -0.04333045706152916, 0.023608965799212456, 0.02400033175945282, -0.026098111644387245, -0.05169886350631714, 0.0036761355586349964, 0.008871542289853096, -0.037515196949243546, -0.024434136226773262, 0.0325966440141201, 0.0139699662104249, -0.020362382754683495, -0.018932173028588295, 0.02219473384320736, 0.06484217941761017, -0.01689758710563183, -0.006890323478728533, 0.010199413634836674, -0.03509587049484253, -0.015642832964658737, 0.021687742322683334, 0.01993446610867977, -0.0241705272346735, -0.01556606125086546, -0.03857606276869774, 0.01564631052315235, 0.01560745108872652, -0.021054808050394058, -0.011884738691151142, -0.01012512482702732, -0.0036640337202697992, 0.03250468149781227, -0.02754257246851921, -0.02586427889764309, -0.025219419971108437, 0.021086208522319794, -0.027165280655026436, 0.00002996884359163232, -0.0026509761810302734, 0.003730533877387643, 0.04824208468198776, 0.002002907916903496, 0.029774677008390427, 0.001978545915335417, 0.04938490316271782, -0.01729566790163517, 0.018491217866539955, -0.024284491315484047, -0.04105164483189583, 0.035265982151031494, 0.007934888824820518, -0.014463155530393124, 0.023063110187649727, -0.028452623635530472, -0.03101765178143978, -0.004316794686019421, -0.0422140471637249, 0.017069455236196518, 0.03999222442507744, 0.0019276818493381143, 0.04540150240063667, 0.029962990432977676, -0.012351933866739273, 0.008221432566642761, 0.0027260975912213326, -0.008796597830951214, 0.006663984153419733, -0.0072533078491687775, 0.04373494163155556, 0.023969709873199463, 0.008142580278217793, 0.0208885557949543, 0.008509475737810135, 0.04140134155750275, 0.04289261996746063, 0.02770179882645607, 0.0024063235614448786, 0.00702982721850276, 0.00010805505007738248, -0.007399687077850103, 0.04158846661448479, -0.03681815788149834, -0.00602644681930542, 0.0031637116335332394, 0.002445796737447381, 0.02317875809967518, 0.01930193230509758, 0.02182035893201828, -0.01831888221204281, -0.014522089622914791, -0.004279434680938721, 0.009318073280155659, 0.010858346708118916, -0.028638511896133423, 0.012466918677091599, 0.03849918022751808, -0.0046625505201518536, -0.04527954012155533, 0.043297432363033295, -0.026165179908275604, -0.0528252013027668, -0.02963406592607498, -0.030541829764842987, -0.06704075634479523, 0.028285279870033264, 0.006883000489324331, -0.023872967809438705, 0.022652659565210342, -0.04408370330929756, 0.031637564301490784, -0.02006826363503933, 0.03688991442322731, -0.03338197246193886, 0.11237527430057526, 0.0439516045153141, 0.045749180018901825, 0.01629834994673729, -0.01531337108463049, 0.09090881049633026, 0.07240588217973709, 0.0010722479782998562, -0.08432513475418091, 0.011631825007498264, -0.028711365535855293, 0.0035990760661661625, -0.040920156985521317, 0.01753539778292179, 0.03370478004217148, 0.004192875232547522, 0.03312384709715843, 0.029680481180548668, -0.008760626427829266, -0.007271005306392908, 0.07311923056840897, -0.037897489964962006, -0.03385394439101219, 0.002631288953125477, 0.001895431661978364, -0.04375862330198288, -0.024857047945261, -0.06579804420471191, 0.034750815480947495, -0.036131177097558975, 0.010589673183858395, -0.013636456802487373, -0.043584324419498444, -0.0029269172810018063, -0.009285968728363514, -0.027742575854063034, -0.0016909552505239844, 0.00786653533577919, -0.025200145319104195, -0.022641126066446304, -0.013197530061006546, -0.005558948963880539, 0.003848031163215637, 0.03627391904592514, 0.024395987391471863, 0.008320684544742107, 0.002024863613769412, -0.010820027440786362, -0.006473522633314133, -0.02392006665468216, -0.04810605198144913, -0.032265935093164444, 0.05433867499232292, 0.01468644943088293, 0.004677332937717438, -0.01489184983074665, 0.022661345079541206, -0.022355996072292328, -0.027370456606149673, -0.011988255195319653, 0.018478961661458015, 0.010160213336348534, -0.0313679538667202, -0.01992376334965229, -0.029750576242804527, 0.0163915753364563, 0.009662486612796783, 0.017350690439343452, 0.026144415140151978, 0.0012797703966498375, -0.009862999431788921, -0.042040709406137466, 0.021108537912368774, -0.00902771856635809, -0.033789537847042084, -0.030416207388043404, -0.01869390904903412, -0.037309084087610245, 0.004602309316396713, 0.030475253239274025, -0.016127273440361023, 0.038965921849012375, -0.02321421541273594, 0.006298125255852938, -0.008050837554037571, -0.014747506938874722, -0.00026957859518006444, -0.032472021877765656, -0.003644404234364629, -0.03889892250299454, -0.006675137672573328, 0.026991598308086395, 0.05772636830806732, 0.01858299970626831, 0.029548484832048416, -0.02529110386967659, 0.03453445062041283, 0.023182766512036324, -0.08700472116470337, -0.02018054574728012, -0.0019710056949406862, -0.045812275260686874, -0.003288424573838711, -0.05224255844950676, 0.04688020050525665, 0.028661401942372322, 0.04725843667984009, -0.01614287681877613, 0.021206697449088097, 0.015328207984566689, 0.02551288902759552, -0.001874347566626966, -0.08649995177984238, -0.002093167044222355, 0.04918576404452324, 0.022306475788354874, -0.03991127386689186, -0.020925065502524376, -0.0008103801519609988, -0.03663686662912369, 0.020379474386572838, 0.004610283300280571, -0.05137263238430023, -0.03152891620993614, -0.012379836291074753, -0.0023113659117370844, -0.02707112953066826, -0.014102424494922161, -0.02470729500055313, 0.03264684975147247, -0.025638632476329803, 0.029619522392749786, -0.008524036966264248, -0.01273538637906313, -0.0037344142328947783, 0.008697070181369781, 0.04430427774786949, -0.006710464600473642, 0.02365809865295887, 0.0033367464784532785, -0.003958629909902811, -0.009882285259664059, 0.030639182776212692, -0.0023284940980374813, 0.013373509049415588, 0.06087607145309448, -0.03828630596399307, -0.0489300899207592, 0.018868623301386833, 0.029030118137598038, 0.04807490482926369, 0.020510058850049973, -0.02303176000714302, -0.03814784437417984, 0.027299199253320694, -0.0501442551612854, -0.025414908304810524, -0.0442529134452343, -0.01751449704170227, 0.009806503541767597, 0.024737946689128876, 0.0010668295435607433, -0.0007995400228537619, -0.014510282315313816, 0.02352583035826683, 0.05571886897087097, -0.008416789583861828, 0.017826829105615616, 0.04619280993938446, 0.05100686848163605, 0.002166400197893381, 0.006411348003894091, 0.010790066793560982, 0.023797396570444107, 0.09246311336755753, -0.03295121341943741, 0.028593728318810463, -0.012735793367028236, 0.01025378704071045, -0.0704425647854805, 0.0025474787689745426, -0.021959586068987846, -0.004326082766056061, 0.04973042383790016, -0.042392291128635406, -0.010245570912957191, 0.04411746934056282, -0.024427158758044243, 0.01101863943040371, -0.022800128906965256, -0.011405757628381252, -0.020688697695732117, -0.008488868363201618, -0.010133923031389713, 0.060924652963876724, 0.04537380859255791, 0.010863764211535454, 0.02371162362396717, -0.0015107601648196578, -0.017655296251177788, 0.022957930341362953, -0.00339125981554389, 0.04525939002633095, 0.03497200459241867, -0.08686932176351547, 0.00609394209459424, -0.03293923661112785, -0.026162641122937202, 0.0476905032992363, 0.015314191579818726, 0.010940073989331722, 0.008972641080617905, 0.028668131679296494, 0.006182577461004257, 0.06240939348936081, 0.02367519401013851, 0.030789511278271675, -0.01671101525425911, 0.005400671623647213, 0.048811763525009155, 0.015375406481325626, -0.011227968148887157, -0.005126891657710075, 0.03363437205553055, -0.02575487457215786, -0.032845135778188705, 0.03843918442726135, -0.01594451814889908, -0.014945870265364647, 0.011165928095579147, -0.007844716310501099, -0.00431715277954936, -0.028373127803206444, 0.0436556451022625, -0.05532864108681679, 0.0199095718562603, 0.04045627638697624, 0.03376387432217598, -0.00288367853499949, -0.002071443945169449, -0.015549975447356701, -0.047614686191082, 0.004208715632557869, -0.023442642763257027, -0.03804512321949005, -0.07190266996622086, -0.0009153115679509938, 0.0032422346994280815, 0.0029983744025230408, 0.015117584727704525, -0.011944250203669071, -0.05619005858898163, 0.05110606178641319, -0.03199591115117073, -0.01370623242110014, -0.003286483697593212, -0.03019668534398079, 0.004404942970722914, -0.0936538428068161, 0.08380067348480225, -0.01108354702591896, -0.03904826566576958, -0.06089650094509125, 0.02960537001490593, -0.022457802668213844, -0.03853665292263031, 0.047106627374887466, 0.0346936360001564, 0.027092577889561653, -0.011859568767249584, 0.045924194157123566, 0.036590613424777985, -0.06070604920387268, 0.004147713538259268, 0.014651899226009846, -0.014278667978942394, -0.03371690213680267, -0.02152642235159874, 0.013331521302461624, 0.0303267240524292, 0.009765359573066235, -0.003667981131002307, 0.03715397045016289, 0.025538429617881775, 0.008475001901388168, 0.02133495733141899, -0.007203436456620693, -0.024089498445391655, 0.05674715340137482, -0.0270296148955822, -0.006331222131848335, 0.04684426635503769, 0.03417995199561119, -0.04625207185745239, 0.019528673961758614, -0.021268486976623535, -0.03919212892651558, -0.028055189177393913, -0.004038764163851738, -0.009120847098529339, -0.055188003927469254, -0.02235369198024273, 0.013665569014847279, -0.052517637610435486, 0.03831017389893532, 0.0321529284119606, 0.010436678305268288, 0.024708446115255356, -0.02182488702237606, -0.014797640033066273, 0.01120668463408947, -0.03983495011925697, 0.01573033630847931, -0.0015308884903788567, -0.0014240049058571458, -0.00964326597750187, 0.022867487743496895, 0.020689431577920914, -0.02379252202808857, 0.05015374347567558, 0.0069222403690218925, 0.05166080966591835, 0.0008053801720961928, -0.06301546096801758, 0.002322830492630601, -0.02533184550702572, 0.05720524862408638, 0.0020012701861560345, -0.008842353709042072, 0.05323803797364235, -0.035924363881349564, 0.007113344501703978, -0.03376699984073639, -0.009821675717830658, -0.0599207729101181, -0.00040253507904708385, 0.0008785496465861797, -0.009464877657592297, -0.008227973245084286, 0.030213987454771996, -0.0029730007518082857, 0.02680489793419838, 0.037230998277664185, -0.022537680342793465, 0.049690842628479004, -0.003858550451695919, -0.00959206186234951, -0.024000093340873718, -0.0440077967941761, -0.04878062754869461, -0.032910458743572235, -0.015975885093212128, 0.03536464273929596, 0.033000051975250244, 0.010454158298671246, -0.04706854000687599, -0.03368578478693962, 0.03347482159733772, -0.05377846956253052, -0.038698457181453705, -0.0514325387775898, 0.006396488752216101, -0.01811816915869713, -0.040793292224407196 ]
<p>I am fitting a linear model in R with many variables:</p> <p><code>lm(Y~X1+X2+...+X100)</code></p> <p>I want to check also for all pairwise interactions. Writing <code>X1*X2*...*X100</code> is not good since it checks the full model (more than pairwise). Writing all pairs explicitly is annoying (100 over 2). Is there a way to do this in R?</p>
73,542
[ -0.03019133396446705, 0.027763493359088898, 0.010279214940965176, 0.03939388692378998, -0.003204382723197341, -0.0011134098749607801, 0.012946095317602158, -0.010963046923279762, 0.034195996820926666, -0.016306111589074135, 0.04589452967047691, 0.059772368520498276, 0.04080586135387421, 0.027701206505298615, 0.031099865213036537, 0.004123354330658913, 0.0008630903321318328, -0.0063250004313886166, 0.015250599011778831, -0.018738441169261932, -0.040156006813049316, -0.015375225804746151, 0.013792745769023895, -0.009408930316567421, 0.01942659355700016, 0.0755680650472641, 0.03142274543642998, -0.017607087269425392, 0.01632111333310604, 0.0403355211019516, -0.03369966521859169, -0.07397717237472534, 0.036771416664123535, 0.009460318833589554, 0.026014186441898346, 0.01233720500022173, -0.013852672651410103, -0.02355918660759926, 0.010599265806376934, 0.033394698053598404, -0.03699054196476936, 0.012370686046779156, 0.03924955800175667, 0.046239692717790604, -0.014813227578997612, 0.033420197665691376, 0.005516938399523497, 0.032988619059324265, 0.029384274035692215, -0.034024789929389954, 0.07375460118055344, 0.008192566223442554, 0.04676217958331108, 0.012720633298158646, -0.011108899489045143, 0.019112128764390945, 0.05212835595011711, 0.07045101374387741, 0.03351424261927605, -0.05741254985332489, -0.023766620084643364, -0.06566563993692398, 0.01705937832593918, -0.03230030834674835, -0.05039173737168312, 0.04237733408808708, 0.023910541087388992, -0.0011528064496815205, 0.01681888848543167, -0.023283906280994415, -0.0026225822512060404, -0.01968839019536972, 0.030219754204154015, 0.004287633113563061, -0.00579480966553092, 0.034514401108026505, 0.018426651135087013, 0.010819352231919765, 0.040395110845565796, 0.03567506745457649, -0.022503897547721863, 0.026705127209424973, 0.011863361112773418, -0.0021473392844200134, 0.047082606703042984, -0.005798800848424435, 0.04841940477490425, 0.006104673724621534, 0.0007111686863936484, 0.013587197288870811, -0.0020104944705963135, 0.03573635593056679, 0.05137273296713829, 0.020914889872074127, -0.04212852567434311, 0.025681501254439354, -0.009745663963258266, 0.03664056956768036, 0.0008909509051591158, -0.0059896791353821754, -0.02885151095688343, -0.012144550681114197, -0.004065379966050386, 0.02354552410542965, -0.026860620826482773, -0.003495306009426713, -0.04444362223148346, -0.0030426306184381247, -0.009554995223879814, -0.016554955393075943, 0.031245896592736244, 0.03801349923014641, -0.008198879659175873, 0.01631883718073368, -0.0020129031036049128, -0.04935839772224426, -0.027538584545254707, -0.018955226987600327, 0.03581788018345833, 0.047952909022569656, 0.022198790684342384, -0.039374928921461105, 0.03473495692014694, 0.012946327216923237, -0.019858818501234055, -0.004791121929883957, 0.0010784200858324766, -0.0037990752607584, -0.046392567455768585, 0.053302910178899765, 0.02528887614607811, -0.06327317655086517, -0.017985718324780464, 0.02792334370315075, 0.036512020975351334, -0.024751268327236176, -0.0383482500910759, -0.05259621515870094, 0.022693229839205742, -0.00980804581195116, 0.014757237397134304, -0.026497595012187958, 0.005782200023531914, 0.030363626778125763, 0.0877332091331482, -0.00364321144297719, 0.00809624046087265, 0.04852193966507912, -0.018560921773314476, 0.027096712961792946, -0.032847389578819275, -0.03336116299033165, -0.03200748935341835, -0.02819526381790638, -0.004254266619682312, -0.08130823820829391, 0.0015308009460568428, 0.022036371752619743, -0.017396317794919014, 0.04589425027370453, 0.013968025334179401, 0.013548360206186771, 0.01109174732118845, -0.02499416656792164, -0.024331210181117058, -0.0114079425111413, 0.07800181955099106, -0.022676777094602585, 0.035011548548936844, 0.010986643843352795, -0.028519466519355774, 0.01480890903621912, 0.016535304486751556, 0.03351012244820595, 0.05336543917655945, -0.003267118241637945, 0.014369974844157696, -0.04214698076248169, 0.021301284432411194, 0.032062992453575134, -0.04291169345378876, -0.03124237060546875, -0.02187882922589779, -0.021331870928406715, 0.025474609807133675, 0.03548261895775795, -0.010655266232788563, -0.024828940629959106, 0.049131859093904495, -0.00628146156668663, -0.033584367483854294, -0.059723734855651855, 0.0008379474165849388, -0.004133148584514856, -0.043524790555238724, -0.005077751819044352, 0.0037572968285530806, 0.013960438780486584, -0.016973264515399933, -0.04458010196685791, -0.03177487105131149, 0.025397028774023056, 0.05088163539767265, -0.031199222430586815, 0.0040169707499444485, 0.02770807221531868, 0.08137970417737961, -0.016592415049672127, 0.032807718962430954, -0.042666565626859665, -0.0225837342441082, 0.03989364206790924, -0.02819221280515194, 0.0008407647837884724, -0.012732202187180519, -0.011341173201799393, -0.0018494102405384183, 0.035173434764146805, -0.011438013054430485, 0.0455586276948452, -0.06158442795276642, 0.028233006596565247, 0.08016687631607056, 0.011424067430198193, -0.012848683632910252, -0.041421372443437576, 0.005393549799919128, 0.007184765767306089, -0.00625761691480875, 0.00465834466740489, -0.061550043523311615, -0.029330307617783546, 0.032255493104457855, 0.01226263027638197, -0.03843351826071739, -0.015184316784143448, 0.051877088844776154, -0.00994754210114479, -0.009730692021548748, 0.039116326719522476, -0.016080573201179504, -0.009414312429726124, 0.02637237310409546, 0.03937063738703728, 0.015882480889558792, -0.0018380839610472322, 0.07267280668020248, 0.03607645258307457, 0.04535099118947983, 0.014537252485752106, -0.044682472944259644, 0.02999376505613327, 0.0015733451582491398, 0.022338878363370895, -0.01582677662372589, -0.03468111529946327, 0.04069746658205986, 0.007412665523588657, 0.023577969521284103, 0.04268451780080795, 0.04007747769355774, -0.04656721279025078, 0.010765678249299526, -0.009486746042966843, -0.03947274759411812, 0.043757595121860504, -0.04817898944020271, -0.04456920921802521, 0.022290382534265518, -0.06673435121774673, 0.008467628620564938, -0.005686216056346893, -0.03645588830113411, -0.039611201733350754, 0.03824637085199356, 0.06654287874698639, 0.02568475343286991, 0.016408810392022133, -0.0434601865708828, -0.035231489688158035, 0.0196720901876688, -0.037997420877218246, 0.05480755865573883, 0.0004048889095429331, -0.05114006623625755, 0.0049768784083426, -0.02916126139461994, -0.016765305772423744, 0.01027738768607378, -0.003761056112125516, -0.009663861244916916, 0.060509953647851944, -0.02800343930721283, -0.06284312903881073, -0.017699582502245903, -0.009499707259237766, -0.0030335530173033476, -0.007251186296343803, -0.007377206813544035, -0.0036853651981800795, 0.03160249814391136, -0.07442296296358109, -0.018082907423377037, -0.03890174999833107, 0.004780464805662632, -0.03896263614296913, -0.04012976959347725, 0.01852620393037796, 0.0322350338101387, 0.008551324717700481, 0.060747142881155014, -0.023120703175663948, -0.015477337874472141, -0.08558344095945358, -0.042728766798973083, -0.007927336730062962, 0.026490570977330208, 0.03266361355781555, -0.012910903431475163, -0.013413880951702595, 0.04583614319562912, 0.030563514679670334, -0.009728989563882351, -0.03687852621078491, 0.005386935081332922, -0.0363721027970314, -0.03309019282460213, 0.02104129083454609, -0.03258427977561951, 0.018729286268353462, 0.020408442243933678, -0.0021228420082479715, 0.006884987000375986, 0.014941725879907608, -0.0025220864918082952, 0.02224002219736576, -0.01314233336597681, -0.012380675412714481, -0.01552362460643053, 0.03202516958117485, 0.029350919649004936, 0.0007470268756151199, 0.02629304863512516, 0.02163686789572239, -0.014065411873161793, -0.025576185435056686, -0.045601215213537216, 0.0244220569729805, -0.03612727299332619, 0.02850211039185524, -0.014027132652699947, 0.00401766411960125, -0.0038521229289472103, -0.06429571658372879, 0.010916396044194698, 0.040588412433862686, 0.05094313248991966, -0.03601815551519394, 0.004178933799266815, 0.04648517072200775, 0.033232465386390686, -0.02825389802455902, 0.01247631199657917, 0.02970053441822529, -0.006622273474931717, 0.019667938351631165, -0.026943296194076538, -0.004469164181500673, 0.0018400279805064201, 0.017001952975988388, 0.016507886350154877, 0.014893805608153343, 0.015584980137646198, 0.03216652199625969, -0.037025149911642075, 0.014195680618286133, -0.06308021396398544, 0.0484573133289814, 0.015500092878937721, 0.045325182378292084, 0.004039017483592033, -0.019498752430081367, -0.0002957750402856618, -0.015629496425390244, -0.04924587532877922, 0.023603860288858414, -0.014790003187954426, -0.021931231021881104, 0.046796321868896484, -0.0016198643716052175, -0.00000852998437039787, -0.028140049427747726, 0.02817690558731556, -0.029099324718117714, 0.01588924415409565, 0.003881440032273531, -0.001897637965157628, -0.033678874373435974, -0.05509470775723457, -0.028672080487012863, 0.02989351563155651, -0.003587055252864957, -0.028626278042793274, 0.003343901364132762, 0.045747898519039154, -0.013560175895690918, -0.005265507847070694, -0.013551493175327778, 0.0032521174289286137, 0.02818690612912178, 0.03260193392634392, 0.0035144779831171036, 0.043682001531124115, -0.024568844586610794, 0.005383666604757309, 0.006286362651735544, 0.0417257696390152, 0.056070972234010696, 0.002517919521778822, -0.01103157177567482, -0.010736007243394852, -0.025620678439736366, -0.02332673780620098, 0.02396647073328495, -0.006175869144499302, -0.00792165007442236, 0.05797828733921051, 0.05479584261775017, -0.05414387583732605, 0.03239158168435097, 0.09333628416061401, 0.014826929196715355, -0.03080279752612114, 0.0015947750071063638, -0.0014872986357659101, 0.008040936663746834, 0.02667372301220894, 0.0038701239973306656, 0.006036987528204918, -0.005674362648278475, 0.012069919146597385, 0.01666541025042534, -0.019942039623856544, -0.03656676411628723, -0.0218945499509573, 0.023634478449821472, 0.05914611741900444, -0.00961861852556467, -0.04598410055041313, 0.0016408433439210057, 0.030793743208050728, -0.018653059378266335, -0.004141177050769329, -0.008091527968645096, -0.0704348161816597, 0.04897737875580788, 0.06269801408052444, 0.08294432610273361, -0.03433731570839882, -0.04897930100560188, -0.00665759202092886, -0.03319070488214493, 0.03998652845621109, -0.032588131725788116, 0.025576965883374214, -0.005460395012050867, 0.02775365300476551, -0.023221390321850777, -0.010907662101089954, -0.07761933654546738, 0.013897446915507317, -0.053643956780433655, 0.007911023683845997, -0.04367555305361748, -0.043119508773088455, -0.026991859078407288, 0.04985760897397995, 0.005236717872321606, 0.02961532399058342, -0.019722405821084976, -0.012523025274276733, 0.0249890498816967, -0.007408624980598688, 0.007915723137557507, -0.03353412076830864, 0.050537895411252975, 0.013586170971393585, -0.018818609416484833, 0.05174559727311134, -0.007583471015095711, -0.019619708880782127, 0.016201190650463104, 0.0024053500965237617, 0.005102204158902168, -0.042596884071826935, 0.014582199044525623, 0.0296934824436903, 0.04823720082640648, 0.020773427560925484, 0.06738371402025223, 0.036107420921325684, -0.03564266115427017, -0.007838691584765911, -0.034615203738212585, -0.013395561836659908, -0.00466297660022974, -0.025462903082370758, -0.05775069817900658, -0.011883922852575779, -0.031931132078170776, -0.006038661580532789, -0.05341886356472969, 0.009815010242164135, -0.021181106567382812, 0.010450097732245922, -0.019128547981381416, 0.04120306298136711, -0.041603945195674896, -0.027861660346388817, 0.016789961606264114, 0.028900567442178726, -0.03549676015973091, -0.02014210820198059, -0.00036324700340628624, -0.02297097072005272, -0.01524948887526989, -0.0029072812758386135, 0.029955022037029266, -0.0003597768081817776, -0.018168073147535324, -0.007398577407002449, -0.036652859300374985, -0.009263909421861172, 0.019676731899380684, -0.015932021662592888, 0.038511309772729874, -0.033707886934280396, -0.014891719445586205, 0.0013731466606259346, 0.030631300061941147, 0.004172722343355417, 0.0192825049161911, -0.005689607467502356, 0.06072345748543739, -0.05990413576364517, 0.00018614561122376472, -0.030147187411785126, -0.05449642241001129, -0.005182076711207628, -0.03936062380671501, 0.0021746510174125433, -0.06093824654817581, -0.03536070138216019, -0.021948058158159256, 0.04192353039979935, -0.03282761573791504, 0.01844905875623226, -0.04605015367269516, 0.02079065330326557, -0.004973419010639191, -0.030288521200418472, 0.011893454007804394, 0.034961458295583725, -0.009180483408272266, 0.03376307338476181, 0.00644802488386631, 0.00009643565863370895, -0.0012616976164281368, -0.0532766655087471, -0.026148837059736252, -0.016351129859685898, -0.0294688381254673, -0.0019579571671783924, 0.05901110917329788, -0.005125245079398155, -0.01872333511710167, -0.009609885513782501, -0.04794018715620041, 0.0001247729524038732, -0.04581804946064949, -0.005377617198973894, -0.022920329123735428, 0.0026850274298340082, -0.0006776212831027806, 0.013108489103615284, 0.007555973716080189, 0.004514884203672409, -0.014103020541369915, 0.0019350487273186445, -0.0339728407561779, 0.009484359063208103, 0.07750654220581055, 0.06396515667438507, -0.008351323194801807, -0.03786316141486168, -0.0289548821747303, 0.03101281262934208, 0.00007430381083395332, -0.022665224969387054, -0.01229877769947052, 0.0323382131755352, -0.014835868962109089, -0.03837377205491066, -0.008747918531298637, -0.03191167861223221, 0.03934669867157936, -0.014441979117691517, 0.03529483452439308, 0.06582463532686234, 0.006426636129617691, 0.015440529212355614, -0.037526700645685196, -0.029006080701947212, 0.02495807781815529, 0.05837468057870865, 0.05969124287366867, 0.014493584632873535, 0.007116544526070356, 0.0652564987540245, 0.008155802264809608, 0.03703590855002403, 0.01220368780195713, -0.03295852988958359, -0.0138663025572896, 0.03912191465497017, 0.012579475529491901, -0.02870156243443489, 0.036210112273693085, -0.04651768505573273, -0.02374095655977726, -0.016308384016156197, -0.034701019525527954, 0.016075607389211655, 0.017865285277366638, 0.007112972438335419, -0.014612141065299511, -0.02831856533885002, -0.04507218673825264, -0.00592527911067009, 0.03415617719292641, 0.006179274525493383, 0.04887310042977333, 0.019890084862709045, 0.03436784818768501, 0.01499037817120552, 0.01491584163159132, -0.0063437819480896, -0.0705026388168335, -0.016618020832538605, 0.020847169682383537, -0.0022399069275707006, 0.043710846453905106, 0.034987155348062515, 0.013603007420897484, 0.01185738667845726, -0.012446814216673374, 0.014120482839643955, -0.027384692803025246, 0.027277827262878418, 0.017992420122027397, 0.01572755165398121, 0.002044079825282097, 0.032322484999895096, -0.009355639107525349, -0.019628992304205894, 0.12635938823223114, 0.029912229627370834, 0.03276767581701279, -0.0789569541811943, -0.0004495146858971566, -0.01168209221214056, -0.058085545897483826, -0.030090918764472008, -0.031854260712862015, 0.012720336206257343, 0.013239619322121143, 0.06667804718017578, 0.023317985236644745, 0.019317520782351494, 0.012422711588442326, 0.043182797729969025, -0.03275526687502861, 0.0007568204891867936, 0.020845701918005943, -0.009125740267336369, 0.002986108884215355, -0.0017163194715976715, -0.057880327105522156, 0.010625015012919903, 0.011378425173461437, -0.011869346722960472, -0.047340188175439835, -0.0032005321700125933, 0.023711176589131355, 0.05058886483311653, -0.01829446852207184, 0.009604305028915405, -0.012542917393147945, 0.03482145443558693, 0.027246786281466484, 0.013430542312562466, 0.029291994869709015, -0.009609066881239414, 0.009325427934527397, 0.03159322962164879, -0.012737837620079517, 0.03536277264356613, -0.012788621708750725, -0.04252289980649948, -0.029253710061311722, -0.03172484040260315, -0.003413872793316841, 0.05860180780291557, 0.02031291462481022, -0.01515223179012537, 0.010376306250691414, 0.023371614515781403, 0.054565224796533585, -0.01382277812808752, -0.01888112537562847, 0.055659424513578415, 0.038782890886068344, -0.016894599422812462, 0.03418096527457237, -0.025039656087756157, 0.013127714395523071, -0.0035042399540543556, 0.04581490531563759, 0.03190632909536362, -0.03586466610431671, 0.0061995298601686954, -0.044697199016809464, 0.0303785502910614, -0.019632522016763687, -0.0049582370556890965, 0.02861364744603634, -0.029992686584591866, -0.016937926411628723, -0.02510705776512623, 0.036532457917928696, 0.011344239115715027, 0.018897006288170815, -0.014789680950343609, -0.002116778399795294, -0.019914140924811363, -0.030917372554540634, -0.017904914915561676, -0.04445841908454895, -0.012468570843338966, -0.019041171297430992, -0.0025345792528241873, 0.02686949446797371, -0.010798665694892406, 0.011076722294092178, -0.005193325225263834, -0.035292722284793854, 0.02852478064596653, 0.02065029740333557, -0.02656298689544201, -0.043703995645046234, 0.013114728964865208, -0.03701617196202278, 0.009833619929850101, -0.024994509294629097, 0.06091124191880226, 0.036422230303287506, 0.03563564643263817, 0.004351145122200251, 0.00450417585670948, -0.035018209367990494, -0.0034269606694579124, 0.05131692811846733, -0.021283458918333054, -0.01669255830347538, -0.0008785747340880334, -0.005457225255668163, -0.007761893328279257, 0.010416300036013126, -0.046260587871074677, -0.04429971054196358, 0.03527950868010521, -0.02705807238817215, -0.058874644339084625, 0.017633836716413498, -0.017758576199412346, -0.013923076912760735, -0.029576901346445084, -0.009107558988034725, -0.05501546710729599, -0.031039996072649956, 0.014035327360033989, -0.04759451374411583, -0.025404656305909157, 0.008253084495663643, -0.03559909760951996, 0.016296355053782463, 0.030723948031663895, 0.020770421251654625, 0.007671259343624115, -0.0017624464817345142, 0.034869372844696045, -0.006677187047898769, 0.056228093802928925, -0.020645689219236374, -0.006200958974659443, 0.009239694103598595, -0.04727878049015999, -0.017591925337910652, -0.011906937696039677, -0.01870712824165821, 0.044478219002485275, 0.024907436221837997, -0.014577720314264297, -0.04981154575943947, 0.01388038881123066, -0.00906926766037941, 0.00747693981975317, 0.006595544517040253, 0.030252858996391296, 0.019361741840839386, 0.02729501947760582, 0.003726513357833028, -0.029928673058748245, -0.005184442736208439, -0.01333572342991829, 0.03851103410124779, 0.020723722875118256, -0.008555700071156025, 0.011386735364794731, -0.026629606261849403, 0.06992781907320023, 0.013049377128481865, -0.02518458291888237, 0.015218155458569527, 0.03439794480800629, -0.008405888453125954, 0.04557747393846512, -0.024485092610120773, 0.02482607215642929, -0.0951886773109436, -0.015655698254704475, -0.03791879490017891, 0.01855800859630108, 0.024532541632652283, -0.055458519607782364, 0.023204144090414047, 0.009664812125265598, -0.037021078169345856, 0.032057613134384155, -0.007814683951437473, 0.012423671782016754, -0.04253300279378891, 0.04190085828304291, -0.014798691496253014, -0.01463629025965929, 0.012694742530584335, 0.04850119724869728, 0.03612712770700455, -0.0085191885009408, 0.02941715158522129, -0.03448648378252983, -0.03375442698597908, -0.028236623853445053, -0.0016443678177893162, -0.049829185009002686, 0.02677708864212036, -0.005596437957137823, -0.030696554109454155, -0.008240721188485622, -0.009208920411765575, -0.0010024347575381398, 0.015440020710229874, 0.05861164256930351, 0.027417931705713272, 0.09446615725755692, -0.006711068097501993, -0.02341795153915882, 0.013230430893599987, -0.0008691400871612132, -0.006962426472455263, 0.01991289108991623, -0.03972332924604416, 0.01653316058218479, -0.011464238166809082, 0.005879366770386696, -0.044372353702783585, 0.05058209225535393, 0.009931591339409351, -0.0005598774296231568, -0.019331181421875954, -0.0072351847775280476, -0.0008393074967898428, -0.07220637798309326, -0.0015550912357866764, -0.046851739287376404, 0.002387940650805831, 0.02791370265185833, 0.04637864977121353, -0.008590972051024437, -0.00034624789259396493, -0.02588963322341442, -0.0072565870359539986, 0.009756955318152905, 0.00903068296611309, -0.01265171729028225, -0.06697084754705429, -0.007862395606935024, -0.006679362617433071, -0.019318638369441032, -0.020046759396791458, -0.016127366572618484, -0.030047453939914703, 0.03650611639022827, -0.03237822279334068, 0.0017864764668047428, 0.01998705044388771, -0.04876238852739334, 0.03173217177391052, -0.09468984603881836, 0.02632731758058071, 0.010157150216400623, 0.01142002921551466, -0.034494224935770035, 0.00899037066847086, -0.044087689369916916, -0.01890234276652336, 0.021620452404022217, 0.024861320853233337, -0.005508051719516516, -0.03148433938622475, 0.028880376368761063, 0.03172285854816437, -0.02677171491086483, 0.05206580460071564, -0.031855709850788116, -0.006395385134965181, -0.0035354257561266422, -0.00898157898336649, 0.012090234085917473, 0.009502073749899864, 0.0392746701836586, -0.01035617757588625, 0.0065710535272955894, -0.01378574687987566, -0.04149043187499046, 0.03277480974793434, -0.002468293532729149, -0.0004542647220660001, 0.0072042206302285194, 0.019901081919670105, 0.04010399803519249, 0.059049736708402634, 0.009251303039491177, -0.052223753184080124, 0.010864393785595894, -0.032753001898527145, -0.017171064391732216, 0.010161771439015865, 0.03350670263171196, -0.0008774490561336279, -0.03166443854570389, 0.057414114475250244, 0.045470014214515686, -0.018086347728967667, 0.0069359601475298405, 0.02667752280831337, 0.005799948237836361, 0.06593005359172821, -0.0008985314052551985, 0.0366368368268013, -0.000812188780400902, -0.038471024483442307, 0.015088378451764584, 0.008757011033594608, 0.010544147342443466, -0.005428302567452192, -0.008321871981024742, 0.034035082906484604, -0.019264010712504387, 0.01162619236856699, 0.0015831678174436092, 0.032273728400468826, 0.0045812856405973434, 0.010167444124817848, 0.021906496956944466, -0.04443046450614929, 0.031834106892347336, -0.03345660865306854, -0.01949426904320717, 0.02015385963022709, -0.09658541530370712, 0.006382941734045744, -0.07204272598028183, -0.00727098248898983, 0.0002070499467663467, 0.00043031421955674887, -0.004999435041099787, 0.006149386987090111, -0.01735357753932476, 0.02367466315627098, 0.01127131748944521, -0.02534087747335434, 0.017917506396770477, -0.020002759993076324, 0.034729525446891785, -0.024864325299859047, 0.012907307595014572, -0.014453868381679058, -0.0022466506343334913, 0.009805165231227875, -0.055542074143886566, 0.04478965699672699, 0.04236248508095741, 0.019776269793510437, -0.04980288818478584, 0.02745463326573372, -0.030004039406776428, 0.009950433857738972, -0.06145840138196945, 0.0029495363123714924, -0.05260385200381279, 0.010417734272778034, 0.0033216618467122316, -0.0030550325755029917 ]
<p>I am performing quantile regressions in R using the package quantreg. My dataset includes 12,328 observations ranging from 0.12 to 330. The timepoints for my data are not exactly continuous; all data fall into one of a few dozen bins ranging from 73 to 397.</p> <p>When I performed a linear regression on this data using the lm() function, I was able to do this with polynomials up to 4:</p> <pre><code>lm(Y~poly(X,3,raw=TRUE),data=mydata) </code></pre> <p>However, with the package quantreg and the rq() command, I cannot use any polynomials. A simple regression works just fine:</p> <pre><code>rq(Y~X,data=mydata,tau=.15) </code></pre> <p>But as soon as I get into polynomials, no dice. When I enter this:</p> <pre><code>rq(Y~poly(X,2,raw=TRUE),data=mydata,tau=.15) </code></pre> <p>I get the following error message:</p> <pre><code>Error in rq.fit.br(x, y, tau = tau, ...) : Singular design matrix </code></pre> <p>I am very new to all of this. I've read up on singular matrices as much as I can and I think there might be two reasons for this: (1) I only have one variable on each axis, or (2) my data are binned/the Y variable isn't truly continuous.</p> <p>Can anyone tell me why I'm getting this error?</p> <p>Thank you!</p> <p>PS - This is how the graph looks:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/htUdA.png" alt="enter image description here"></p>
73,543
[ 0.01890645921230316, 0.0067959618754684925, 0.010543402284383774, 0.015677563846111298, 0.021512100473046303, -0.031501736491918564, -0.013171275146305561, 0.0035906482953578234, 0.03399934247136116, -0.01891746185719967, 0.03769446909427643, 0.04137106239795685, 0.10248623788356781, -0.002100996905937791, 0.011358327232301235, 0.00283615430817008, -0.005420838017016649, -0.04544525220990181, 0.004011059179902077, -0.037233803421258926, -0.016660574823617935, 0.029452376067638397, -0.01488290075212717, 0.0046222275123000145, -0.017147701233625412, 0.041700128465890884, 0.0025040823966264725, 0.011616379022598267, 0.03391618654131889, 0.05396739020943642, -0.04057787358760834, -0.05329250916838646, 0.020462922751903534, 0.0002169440995203331, 0.016276327893137932, 0.004129314795136452, -0.007751357741653919, -0.04166414588689804, -0.03058786876499653, 0.010588690638542175, -0.04661418870091438, -0.019145529717206955, -0.008346650749444962, 0.019045745953917503, 0.0157136470079422, 0.006630104500800371, 0.048192594200372696, -0.020721465349197388, 0.09203550219535828, -0.012928572483360767, 0.09494348615407944, 0.009198593907058239, 0.023394087329506874, 0.055026136338710785, -0.03448520600795746, 0.023096421733498573, 0.0776919573545456, 0.07244744151830673, -0.016751548275351524, -0.06373234838247299, -0.024422092363238335, -0.03673989325761795, -0.03039422631263733, -0.0021597796585410833, -0.04500751942396164, -0.002333468059077859, -0.004180874675512314, -0.0009342943085357547, -0.0026354994624853134, -0.04477711766958237, 0.03460189700126648, 0.0002951027126982808, 0.039171453565359116, 0.004631639923900366, 0.00527780270203948, -0.006139454431831837, 0.002039860701188445, 0.03666698932647705, 0.050597742199897766, -0.0012674868339672685, 0.004453494679182768, 0.018819771707057953, 0.010778502561151981, -0.006158480886369944, 0.00914081372320652, -0.01662743091583252, 0.03717271238565445, -0.017102854326367378, 0.010931158438324928, 0.008879629895091057, -0.04120160639286041, 0.020999867469072342, 0.0729256421327591, 0.02865566499531269, -0.04072108864784241, 0.037392791360616684, 0.026362475007772446, 0.014871985651552677, 0.0000772748826420866, -0.021663332358002663, 0.013113237917423248, -0.05060289427638054, 0.022729547694325447, 0.012455462478101254, -0.020184779539704323, -0.011257016099989414, -0.007293795235455036, -0.009384223259985447, 0.00544407544657588, -0.05942779779434204, -0.052450068295001984, 0.021970048546791077, -0.009804122149944305, -0.03850531205534935, -0.013021156191825867, -0.023343725129961967, 0.01720765233039856, 0.012826136313378811, 0.06369936466217041, 0.0604180246591568, 0.054038599133491516, -0.013060334138572216, 0.028928644955158234, -0.03324393182992935, -0.056113455444574356, 0.04141164571046829, 0.03002230077981949, -0.014282931573688984, -0.04278373718261719, 0.031976744532585144, -0.014377147890627384, -0.01702408865094185, 0.03923686593770981, -0.047706637531518936, 0.04384418949484825, -0.006214305758476257, -0.06240697577595711, -0.07326645404100418, 0.013308081775903702, 0.018652761355042458, -0.0033235009759664536, -0.04197804257273674, 0.011528953909873962, 0.02883990667760372, 0.06589987128973007, 0.029181770980358124, 0.02873186394572258, -0.008317187428474426, 0.003192285308614373, -0.00130075600463897, -0.07201118022203445, 0.02150498516857624, -0.02901826798915863, -0.02709679864346981, 0.013609416782855988, -0.05443606525659561, -0.015607725828886032, 0.027463136240839958, 0.029501458629965782, 0.009446433745324612, 0.030953895300626755, 0.01639619469642639, 0.015436127781867981, 0.009785586968064308, -0.047369737178087234, -0.037438713014125824, 0.08254113793373108, 0.00020496280922088772, 0.02962903492152691, 0.010368702933192253, 0.008142929524183273, 0.017358241602778435, 0.023318851366639137, 0.06595595180988312, 0.03409591317176819, -0.011809526942670345, -0.002521738177165389, -0.0010615416103973985, 0.015083778649568558, 0.03839996084570885, -0.059700630605220795, -0.003567638574168086, -0.024738457053899765, -0.025424975901842117, 0.0077812704257667065, 0.02411983162164688, -0.03651677817106247, -0.016530301421880722, 0.031022367998957634, -0.026763783767819405, -0.04578292369842529, -0.037110839039087296, -0.003987903706729412, -0.04118168354034424, -0.023811351507902145, -0.013726778328418732, 0.027847573161125183, 0.02925335057079792, 0.005588691681623459, -0.015592572279274464, -0.03190808743238449, -0.003795518772676587, 0.04711242765188217, 0.00931811984628439, 0.001833402900956571, 0.04803365841507912, 0.037939757108688354, -0.014574662782251835, 0.010806435719132423, -0.023841289803385735, 0.006549371872097254, 0.020146740600466728, -0.03229061886668205, 0.035314444452524185, -0.02879708632826805, -0.022429896518588066, -0.004637258592993021, -0.020629536360502243, -0.04035325348377228, 0.05469556897878647, -0.028925122693181038, 0.04146108776330948, 0.05383436381816864, 0.015840621665120125, -0.030768727883696556, 0.02096853405237198, -0.031316641718149185, 0.02216707170009613, -0.048977259546518326, -0.04026632383465767, -0.033091332763433456, 0.014981196261942387, 0.009031142108142376, 0.01565583236515522, -0.024128451943397522, 0.008044960908591747, 0.09273067116737366, 0.013045335188508034, 0.0017060845857486129, 0.02103421650826931, -0.0013336667325347662, -0.0021950555965304375, 0.0247566569596529, -0.008539587259292603, 0.0442473478615284, -0.022267894819378853, 0.004713733214884996, -0.03285239636898041, 0.02418765239417553, -0.008580070920288563, 0.008560924790799618, 0.06553039699792862, -0.053898055106401443, -0.006204984150826931, -0.026362339034676552, -0.04479039087891579, 0.0614507794380188, -0.012413187883794308, -0.007001965306699276, 0.024562757462263107, 0.0009237162885256112, -0.0022484154906123877, 0.021917248144745827, -0.016954127699136734, 0.008092560805380344, 0.08427731692790985, -0.033716779202222824, 0.010672659613192081, 0.008192060515284538, -0.0198555588722229, 0.010874209925532341, -0.05248165875673294, -0.061488691717386246, -0.022547004744410515, 0.030294246971607208, -0.0010109100257977843, 0.04756462574005127, 0.021963441744446754, -0.04284926503896713, 0.0009587064851075411, 0.008163366466760635, -0.02030135691165924, 0.04086623340845108, -0.03303614258766174, -0.06398798525333405, -0.012236244045197964, -0.02179848775267601, 0.007960440590977669, 0.005606410093605518, 0.01694580540060997, -0.03560149669647217, 0.0008168774656951427, -0.050215285271406174, -0.017212320119142532, -0.03236808627843857, -0.020965540781617165, -0.006675449665635824, -0.0004345361376181245, -0.07032173126935959, 0.018608836457133293, -0.005799904465675354, -0.035260673612356186, 0.01674216240644455, -0.050398923456668854, 0.02898580953478813, -0.02198551595211029, 0.01668289117515087, 0.026436496526002884, 0.010594898834824562, -0.00044615258229896426, 0.05220986157655716, -0.005410782061517239, -0.010982144623994827, -0.05412612855434418, -0.0655362531542778, 0.044819049537181854, 0.016807712614536285, -0.0005072921048849821, 0.024899564683437347, -0.010705661959946156, 0.06355323642492294, 0.025991549715399742, -0.024206874892115593, -0.07778902351856232, -0.002490078564733267, -0.03361785039305687, -0.0252247117459774, 0.016771702095866203, -0.02333475649356842, 0.029902152717113495, -0.012010985985398293, -0.05191400647163391, 0.044223323464393616, 0.041348498314619064, -0.04702524095773697, -0.020155956968665123, 0.012627584859728813, 0.0011988251935690641, -0.04775470122694969, 0.04134871065616608, 0.03161725029349327, 0.008808059617877007, 0.006580135319381952, -0.024834470823407173, 0.012073329649865627, -0.012962725944817066, -0.03659921884536743, 0.03199774771928787, -0.017912060022354126, 0.057628482580184937, 0.0014718873426318169, 0.030115386471152306, 0.006698567885905504, -0.09532985836267471, -0.0018919635331258178, 0.00948154553771019, 0.04161045327782631, -0.01960689388215542, 0.019680660218000412, 0.032057128846645355, 0.010262521915137768, -0.05139390379190445, 0.015402177348732948, 0.010300719179213047, -0.046122364699840546, 0.015908556059002876, -0.05571765452623367, 0.0046817343682050705, 0.0311721283942461, 0.0004884660011157393, 0.0052263387478888035, 0.01958722621202469, -0.03970641642808914, -0.004844733513891697, -0.014825647696852684, 0.018837319687008858, -0.013343407772481441, 0.05193927511572838, 0.011891782283782959, 0.03138658404350281, 0.021120887249708176, -0.006583309266716242, 0.004730815067887306, -0.024235839024186134, -0.04007163643836975, 0.04831496626138687, 0.015422957018017769, -0.019827375188469887, 0.04071779176592827, -0.03386778011918068, 0.026344455778598785, -0.024125393480062485, 0.0011587957851588726, 0.01360146515071392, 0.006667912472039461, -0.04596690833568573, -0.001893540727905929, -0.027283571660518646, 0.0075862230733036995, -0.011962095275521278, -0.016598615795373917, 0.035803455859422684, -0.03782416880130768, 0.02221406251192093, 0.04279947653412819, -0.027816323563456535, -0.008548703975975513, -0.015958979725837708, 0.003074395703151822, 0.035661280155181885, 0.028047185391187668, 0.040269237011671066, 0.02604125253856182, -0.0005320377531461418, 0.02909882180392742, 0.012381779961287975, 0.05355649068951607, 0.044884923845529556, 0.008783040568232536, -0.0078091747127473354, -0.03606491535902023, 0.036669135093688965, 0.032143305987119675, -0.019088324159383774, -0.005937756970524788, -0.010300966911017895, 0.04272010177373886, 0.010407445020973682, -0.04841740056872368, 0.0032544168643653393, 0.05149456858634949, 0.04158307984471321, 0.011799728497862816, -0.012261081486940384, -0.002042339416220784, -0.01192366424947977, -0.006473464425653219, 0.023422550410032272, 0.0024599579628556967, -0.021032702177762985, 0.006006656680256128, 0.05109028518199921, -0.02643968164920807, -0.0010453603463247418, 0.020718855783343315, 0.031909432262182236, 0.014780491590499878, -0.06456242501735687, -0.040035687386989594, -0.0020386939868330956, 0.0032716887071728706, 0.02959538623690605, 0.012272628955543041, -0.02253922075033188, -0.07785151153802872, 0.017450273036956787, 0.02910097874701023, 0.056604672223329544, -0.01957087032496929, -0.04634964093565941, -0.059588488191366196, -0.03250572457909584, -0.005997319705784321, -0.024139750748872757, 0.05132049694657326, -0.02801862359046936, 0.01568855531513691, -0.01813436485826969, -0.01914648525416851, -0.008124084211885929, -0.008984840475022793, 0.0012273918837308884, 0.048056963831186295, -0.005972741171717644, -0.036135442554950714, -0.007026339881122112, 0.037877220660448074, -0.01641959697008133, 0.06008734926581383, 0.010797918774187565, -0.023315737023949623, 0.028326330706477165, -0.028593195602297783, -0.02027689293026924, -0.06918678432703018, 0.028620006516575813, -0.018026217818260193, 0.007081407122313976, 0.05043096840381622, 0.017340797930955887, -0.013471817597746849, -0.010959666222333908, 0.020615383982658386, 0.005978964734822512, 0.00481356680393219, -0.033442169427871704, -0.005567535758018494, 0.04174470528960228, 0.021404214203357697, 0.05648612231016159, 0.04298311844468117, -0.024480964988470078, 0.031299419701099396, -0.09275820106267929, -0.0028521970380097628, 0.005640511866658926, -0.005544664803892374, -0.04947216808795929, -0.0021424945443868637, 0.006130809895694256, 0.013141196221113205, -0.03996271267533302, 0.0009396995301358402, -0.035368066281080246, 0.013032481074333191, 0.021004164591431618, 0.008386568166315556, -0.012306442484259605, -0.012200070545077324, 0.001381722860969603, -0.005236269440501928, -0.014868810772895813, 0.012786521576344967, 0.02147076092660427, -0.04568322002887726, -0.008805850520730019, 0.029486771672964096, -0.010208428837358952, 0.009268373250961304, 0.014085023663938046, -0.016060132533311844, 0.011329556815326214, -0.022497348487377167, 0.01671783998608589, -0.004442996345460415, 0.024688418954610825, -0.014675294980406761, -0.017230147495865822, -0.017300216481089592, -0.039841145277023315, -0.000974858645349741, 0.01237432286143303, -0.02200513333082199, 0.0735250785946846, -0.03245893120765686, 0.0005720313638448715, -0.05194510519504547, -0.06043790653347969, 0.004669248592108488, 0.008629770018160343, -0.028443459421396255, -0.04622231796383858, 0.0018125978531315923, -0.0003578615142032504, 0.014725267887115479, -0.00466871727257967, 0.03914147987961769, -0.053976740688085556, -0.000956775329541415, -0.001988173695281148, 0.034624285995960236, 0.05101582407951355, -0.007243119180202484, 0.014634438790380955, 0.017885014414787292, 0.01560121588408947, -0.044541455805301666, 0.012333463877439499, 0.000002712919012992643, -0.02774673141539097, 0.011142090894281864, -0.008607810363173485, 0.022451866418123245, 0.04241527244448662, 0.021904271095991135, -0.002644423395395279, -0.0035966236609965563, 0.010815603658556938, 0.034037742763757706, -0.025637993589043617, 0.01010825578123331, 0.013282516971230507, -0.005737037397921085, -0.038202930241823196, -0.034872397780418396, -0.012523963116109371, -0.0018869987688958645, 0.052419014275074005, -0.011742370203137398, -0.0032226908951997757, 0.02064899355173111, 0.12122979760169983, 0.016113847494125366, 0.017148524522781372, -0.025388339534401894, -0.04323631152510643, 0.038348689675331116, 0.03299911320209503, -0.0310272965580225, -0.022895224392414093, 0.009595018811523914, -0.016721447929739952, -0.02309744991362095, -0.05557408928871155, 0.020315948873758316, 0.03120735101401806, -0.022898368537425995, 0.04376989230513573, 0.0641062930226326, -0.03568499907851219, -0.0017898653168231249, -0.016601014882326126, -0.0465540736913681, -0.008052019402384758, 0.02301742509007454, 0.03177102655172348, 0.026139112189412117, -0.011043005622923374, -0.0003215180477127433, 0.027614707127213478, 0.020122967660427094, 0.06412826478481293, -0.0020946876611560583, 0.041511811316013336, 0.005442125257104635, 0.010290228761732578, -0.0537569634616375, -0.007834047079086304, -0.03939177840948105, 0.011345754377543926, -0.025736842304468155, -0.04846768453717232, 0.02727045677602291, 0.04553188756108284, -0.008564312011003494, -0.017452716827392578, -0.016726311296224594, -0.027524221688508987, 0.0015189885161817074, -0.00020093003695365041, -0.019327694550156593, 0.024014340713620186, 0.00917945709079504, 0.03087678924202919, 0.010258011519908905, 0.04390323534607887, -0.016054430976510048, -0.03300558775663376, -0.013340476900339127, -0.053456708788871765, -0.018649378791451454, 0.05404423922300339, -0.011095551773905754, -0.024101944640278816, 0.033032577484846115, -0.03259863704442978, 0.018165552988648415, -0.0059953248128294945, 0.0474412739276886, 0.0183755774050951, 0.02320954203605652, -0.01699991337954998, -0.014539367519319057, -0.004217279143631458, 0.013745308853685856, 0.1307380497455597, 0.09417382627725601, -0.0037540984340012074, -0.05768660083413124, -0.007283586077392101, -0.01976291462779045, 0.02048378810286522, -0.031227439641952515, -0.00909741036593914, 0.01625499688088894, -0.033266156911849976, 0.05018866807222366, 0.056329891085624695, 0.03677217662334442, 0.014788169413805008, 0.021983232349157333, -0.01816851645708084, -0.027090629562735558, 0.012238784693181515, 0.033918630331754684, 0.0012036607367917895, -0.024610145017504692, -0.04888059198856354, 0.008279803209006786, -0.013793177902698517, -0.014777973294258118, -0.040289729833602905, -0.03207122161984444, -0.030130088329315186, 0.03744039684534073, -0.013018405064940453, 0.013301548548042774, 0.01407675165683031, -0.005112438462674618, 0.006907281931489706, 0.017452102154493332, 0.014789796434342861, -0.02314676158130169, 0.004160626791417599, 0.03958040103316307, 0.00911091361194849, -0.00701917614787817, -0.019919492304325104, 0.005683764815330505, -0.036919549107551575, -0.007124715484678745, -0.004810136277228594, 0.02643023058772087, 0.020376702770590782, -0.012772692367434502, -0.005918791517615318, -0.00021077827841509134, 0.007344442419707775, -0.04482566565275192, -0.008829298429191113, 0.008632366545498371, -0.024950392544269562, -0.039517633616924286, -0.03511369973421097, 0.011485337279736996, -0.028659429401159286, 0.022562284022569656, 0.024371620267629623, 0.05573839694261551, -0.049970079213380814, 0.023037441074848175, -0.032809581607580185, 0.040275633335113525, -0.013545804657042027, -0.0013289417838677764, -0.0045686266385018826, -0.0340835340321064, -0.010202288627624512, -0.05502783879637718, 0.04823976382613182, 0.03267213702201843, 0.04565107449889183, -0.03262723237276077, -0.036928847432136536, -0.004243412986397743, -0.04435364529490471, 0.026431307196617126, -0.016525903716683388, -0.02592042274773121, -0.02836168371140957, 0.009434309788048267, 0.008931390941143036, 0.04715540260076523, 0.004144379869103432, -0.020891305059194565, -0.018931733444333076, 0.03880808502435684, 0.02593337558209896, -0.022175589576363564, -0.0006317658699117601, 0.01920258440077305, -0.02748028002679348, 0.007517601363360882, -0.014851531945168972, 0.054135315120220184, 0.019829239696264267, 0.04878687486052513, 0.0012870773207396269, 0.02458079531788826, -0.006947631016373634, 0.008690845221281052, 0.04529774561524391, -0.06089624762535095, 0.039193347096443176, 0.009088607504963875, 0.014931447803974152, -0.05188927799463272, -0.04002164304256439, -0.06079820543527603, -0.04739725589752197, -0.012386214919388294, -0.0012834897497668862, -0.0685274749994278, -0.0015129417879506946, -0.016880273818969727, -0.022141041234135628, -0.02227698639035225, 0.001989419339224696, -0.012104698456823826, 0.015013554133474827, -0.021288549527525902, -0.0023902577813714743, -0.05656684562563896, -0.014880060218274593, -0.002025388414040208, 0.017436882480978966, 0.030099084600806236, 0.03078206069767475, 0.02242930792272091, 0.005578495562076569, 0.027169877663254738, 0.04629354923963547, 0.048523250967264175, 0.003237328724935651, 0.01815875805914402, 0.032447174191474915, -0.031176334246993065, -0.04063147306442261, -0.01874050684273243, -0.015506656840443611, 0.011283410713076591, 0.017466597259044647, -0.006973493844270706, -0.04090796038508415, 0.05222803354263306, 0.0053168111480772495, 0.016348307952284813, -0.001373260049149394, 0.034756824374198914, -0.028483331203460693, -0.01804865151643753, -0.0076507204212248325, 0.013266590423882008, -0.0006740266690030694, 0.020593803375959396, 0.06340588629245758, 0.02138836309313774, 0.012841184623539448, -0.0006779152899980545, -0.007570234127342701, 0.006599698215723038, 0.01403295248746872, 0.0024603980127722025, 0.06724634766578674, 0.04576113820075989, -0.04115527495741844, -0.004901378881186247, -0.04396388679742813, 0.0071013690903782845, -0.0886555090546608, -0.053562507033348083, -0.025279371067881584, 0.010066237300634384, 0.006297378335148096, -0.06722408533096313, -0.003926617093384266, 0.06818030774593353, -0.04426705092191696, 0.005511518567800522, -0.030115138739347458, -0.0001064816169673577, -0.022122444584965706, 0.006757910829037428, -0.0020417168270796537, 0.006173497531563044, 0.025221271440386772, 0.030425211414694786, 0.051210299134254456, 0.011228968389332294, 0.020663736388087273, -0.0008130890782922506, -0.0018333891639485955, -0.011863642372190952, -0.008418168872594833, -0.0466274619102478, 0.024426080286502838, -0.02464132197201252, -0.006471082102507353, 0.029198400676250458, -0.032274357974529266, 0.011472187004983425, 0.0382700115442276, 0.041666992008686066, 0.020096007734537125, 0.0560363233089447, 0.03161590173840523, 0.016072619706392288, -0.003872708650305867, -0.03885996714234352, 0.009590283036231995, 0.01520033460110426, -0.015904372557997704, 0.050796989351511, 0.03570409491658211, -0.0032135164365172386, -0.03952071815729141, 0.031087582930922508, -0.006875659339129925, 0.013802152127027512, 0.021853435784578323, 0.020955940708518028, 0.006835114676505327, -0.056778185069561005, 0.025994805619120598, -0.010402163490653038, 0.004051720257848501, 0.0012895731488242745, 0.02499075047671795, 0.005232962314039469, -0.02141466736793518, -0.019210614264011383, -0.05002497136592865, -0.009937352500855923, -0.010645272210240364, -0.036140076816082, -0.059594471007585526, -0.0070331161841750145, 0.005638753995299339, -0.0047895414754748344, -0.014381553046405315, 0.00213840720243752, -0.034044984728097916, 0.029665866866707802, -0.006187452469021082, -0.02486734464764595, 0.046449288725852966, -0.0006332608172670007, 0.006386592518538237, -0.09840847551822662, 0.03207007795572281, 0.018066618591547012, -0.02028224989771843, -0.014063882641494274, 0.010331983678042889, -0.06523426622152328, 0.014582155272364616, 0.02849384769797325, -0.0063237957656383514, 0.03453873470425606, 0.03654226288199425, 0.02931632660329342, 0.007838256657123566, -0.02986406907439232, 0.02808378078043461, 0.005622261669486761, -0.015200613997876644, -0.004092113114893436, 0.004697047173976898, -0.010836484842002392, 0.03422420471906662, 0.04154530167579651, -0.008729306980967522, 0.011299192905426025, 0.007428830489516258, -0.05279655009508133, 0.03831305354833603, -0.004561472684144974, -0.0015258187195286155, 0.031649570912122726, -0.0004102785896975547, 0.0027599926106631756, 0.05442604050040245, 0.003304625628516078, -0.052112601697444916, 0.03712114319205284, -0.004293549340218306, -0.02490084059536457, -0.00016193281044252217, -0.02854672633111477, -0.0057084038853645325, -0.07657178491353989, 0.021065814420580864, 0.023064767941832542, -0.04488082975149155, 0.03009764291346073, -0.007123787421733141, 0.0018463851884007454, 0.04097040370106697, -0.004958645440638065, 0.00970629695802927, 0.015371083281934261, -0.04131666570901871, 0.04051888361573219, 0.0038551143370568752, 0.02313828095793724, 0.004516424145549536, 0.010919297114014626, 0.05991506576538086, -0.05583367124199867, 0.02379407361149788, 0.000904889078810811, 0.06542300432920456, 0.013450848869979382, -0.03251027315855026, -0.01937456615269184, 0.00030454524676315486, 0.01383412629365921, 0.006911171600222588, -0.0152545515447855, 0.036501262336969376, -0.027278508991003036, 0.029857130721211433, 0.00177964533213526, -0.0076504857279360294, -0.02595801278948784, 0.055745579302310944, 0.019214646890759468, 0.04094335436820984, -0.03298172354698181, 0.00637495331466198, -0.020183617249131203, -0.04685443267226219, 0.019747769460082054, 0.009641495533287525, -0.025824734941124916, 0.0041711279191076756, 0.00967402383685112, -0.011822721920907497, -0.024379711598157883, 0.022222351282835007, -0.037783849984407425, 0.01906445436179638, 0.027984479442238808, 0.02197996713221073, -0.0653366819024086, -0.03944482281804085, -0.022767430171370506, 0.025443194434046745, -0.05961393937468529, -0.013375969603657722, 0.011621862649917603, 0.030582135543227196, 0.017042018473148346, -0.017744924873113632 ]
<p>Setting: Large N, short T panel dataset. Very few 1's (probably 1 percent), most zeroes. I estimate a logistic regression and find a negative significant coefficient on the IV of interest. Reassuringly, it's negatively correlated with the indicator variable.</p> <p>But when I run this in a LPM (with OLS), I find a positive significant coefficient.</p> <p>What's driving this? Which (the negative or positive) is more likely correct?</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
73,544
[ -0.015851251780986786, 0.03311922028660774, -0.03398943319916725, 0.005566975101828575, 0.029504893347620964, 0.025762928649783134, -0.02082749269902706, 0.00961550697684288, 0.033866044133901596, -0.06393615901470184, 0.0051200720481574535, 0.05090276151895523, 0.049667831510305405, -0.00905746128410101, -0.0005902457633055747, -0.00031182868406176567, 0.03319958224892616, 0.011644651181995869, -0.005485227797180414, 0.008933905512094498, -0.0291996318846941, 0.03184877336025238, 0.027647608891129494, 0.013314811512827873, -0.027537424117326736, 0.05755464732646942, 0.036271125078201294, 0.017624173313379288, -0.00588825112208724, 0.06134946271777153, -0.03154204413294792, -0.0023015285842120647, -0.01862662099301815, 0.011864354833960533, 0.005643988959491253, 0.0009726189891807735, -0.02281501516699791, -0.0335010327398777, 0.015948396176099777, 0.03941410779953003, 0.0030628084205091, -0.030008114874362946, -0.0024250750429928303, 0.040479470044374466, 0.001836199196986854, 0.015578042715787888, 0.0006865644245408475, -0.030019711703062057, 0.06093350052833557, -0.03576534613966942, 0.016718368977308273, -0.007759334985166788, 0.03741971403360367, 0.023059533908963203, -0.0086207315325737, -0.02300567552447319, 0.05465688556432724, 0.08217939734458923, -0.014454391784965992, -0.03664066269993782, -0.008161626756191254, 0.00027225943631492555, -0.0348488986492157, -0.016535498201847076, -0.004140119068324566, -0.007110557518899441, 0.006865567062050104, -0.00997183844447136, 0.042430318892002106, -0.023708108812570572, 0.006756445858627558, 0.0328977033495903, 0.018723109737038612, -0.01163356751203537, 0.0046265628188848495, -0.037681449204683304, 0.0063001858070492744, -0.021873202174901962, 0.027074052020907402, 0.06376438587903976, 0.007355250883847475, -0.0033381611574441195, 0.029334409162402153, 0.03607148677110672, 0.015819324180483818, -0.012822420336306095, 0.05284778028726578, -0.022641433402895927, 0.018568430095911026, 0.024720845744013786, -0.05881764739751816, 0.016050204634666443, 0.05421708896756172, -0.01092380192130804, -0.011492105200886726, 0.02845238335430622, -0.03315584361553192, 0.05537229776382446, 0.07018310576677322, 0.01780153252184391, -0.05195709690451622, -0.06533575803041458, 0.005659355316311121, 0.045542411506175995, -0.030019378289580345, 0.0007709439378231764, -0.030423566699028015, 0.025839265435934067, 0.019991232082247734, -0.05597740411758423, 0.005498370621353388, -0.003510664450004697, 0.01748795248568058, -0.0054287975654006, -0.014995989389717579, -0.03156473860144615, 0.019025681540369987, -0.025212394073605537, 0.05523473769426346, 0.03814619779586792, 0.012961597181856632, -0.03722523897886276, 0.006397794000804424, 0.0049844346940517426, -0.022439060732722282, 0.02198873646557331, 0.020470457151532173, 0.003084230236709118, -0.028351211920380592, 0.03967808187007904, 0.014856419526040554, -0.0021435318049043417, 0.03787224367260933, 0.014277671463787556, 0.038886766880750656, 0.029218802228569984, -0.05094865337014198, -0.057559534907341, 0.01399664394557476, -0.0059159607626497746, 0.002609014045447111, -0.030323529615998268, -0.05373384431004524, 0.020609451457858086, 0.07088577002286911, -0.013356061652302742, 0.023660682141780853, 0.03151280805468559, 0.014039457775652409, 0.022792674601078033, -0.010015583597123623, 0.004144693724811077, -0.06369046866893768, -0.03278522565960884, -0.007484951056540012, -0.07110067456960678, 0.0276211965829134, 0.03780817240476608, 0.013159018941223621, -0.006992587354034185, 0.0059055909514427185, 0.003048008307814598, -0.0164958406239748, 0.008004330098628998, -0.027955161407589912, -0.021263977512717247, 0.06587927788496017, -0.028391648083925247, 0.028350960463285446, 0.031037654727697372, 0.00679562333971262, 0.01367967203259468, 0.02373947761952877, 0.03969290107488632, 0.026535790413618088, -0.022356227040290833, 0.011208690702915192, -0.06785898655653, 0.036632418632507324, 0.012651308439671993, -0.04733215644955635, -0.033472687005996704, -0.05093636363744736, -0.037751443684101105, -0.002839178778231144, 0.025318168103694916, -0.02103523537516594, 0.012730859220027924, 0.0507030189037323, -0.048849646002054214, -0.06229155883193016, -0.04601635783910751, 0.023639405146241188, 0.026674671098589897, -0.03381257504224777, 0.05232839658856392, 0.005795195233076811, 0.012352382764220238, 0.00538558978587389, 0.04369073361158371, 0.006812465842813253, -0.0041787042282521725, 0.028310900554060936, -0.07001306861639023, 0.05294625461101532, 0.06007766351103783, 0.07479074597358704, -0.019087912514805794, 0.06300800293684006, -0.0507381409406662, -0.03019980899989605, 0.05208112671971321, 0.013095955364406109, 0.009894920513033867, -0.024433402344584465, -0.051895540207624435, 0.017682883888483047, -0.007268394809216261, -0.052975963801145554, 0.03099304623901844, -0.0721992626786232, 0.09290697425603867, 0.07525316625833511, -0.006967269815504551, 0.006979709025472403, -0.003993451129645109, 0.020700804889202118, 0.009314995259046555, -0.0043803621083498, 0.006709002889692783, -0.043782878667116165, -0.054004885256290436, 0.07489845901727676, 0.03555181622505188, -0.010146991349756718, 0.013255503959953785, 0.055475085973739624, -0.004742817487567663, -0.005411603022366762, 0.015627428889274597, -0.005522299092262983, -0.01835189014673233, 0.0028733061626553535, 0.00386429438367486, -0.00012319434608798474, -0.005710497498512268, 0.034167755395174026, 0.01662171445786953, 0.04775422438979149, -0.017381340265274048, -0.010679465718567371, 0.04394610971212387, 0.028811438009142876, 0.005072186700999737, -0.027770033106207848, 0.003082778537645936, 0.04766623303294182, -0.04056594893336296, -0.014076451770961285, 0.03753022104501724, 0.017603281885385513, 0.018686527386307716, 0.01853707991540432, -0.039636969566345215, 0.019687427207827568, 0.04349709674715996, -0.019047878682613373, 0.015660515055060387, 0.013495677150785923, -0.03819205239415169, 0.03074292466044426, -0.013640378601849079, -0.029349403455853462, -0.002673912327736616, 0.019828561693429947, 0.032752737402915955, -0.009953778237104416, -0.010605625808238983, -0.014485148712992668, -0.008067775517702103, -0.00722044100984931, -0.023870065808296204, 0.026120750233530998, 0.016357839107513428, -0.037281036376953125, -0.023401781916618347, -0.04026515409350395, -0.046709105372428894, 0.024645736441016197, -0.00633632019162178, -0.02162669226527214, 0.027150392532348633, -0.029665976762771606, -0.041899554431438446, -0.04938734695315361, -0.040112752467393875, -0.006673917174339294, -0.02744262106716633, -0.030021555721759796, 0.04881497099995613, -0.011110813356935978, -0.02620651200413704, 0.030756549909710884, -0.04154824838042259, -0.003948237281292677, -0.035577159374952316, -0.02213660627603531, 0.024470612406730652, -0.0023699207231402397, 0.0050340685993433, -0.039678480476140976, -0.006252267397940159, -0.011019011028110981, -0.07659918814897537, -0.048265762627124786, -0.009313493967056274, 0.039596330374479294, 0.007165639661252499, -0.030463891103863716, -0.001980770844966173, 0.06433349847793579, 0.026741746813058853, 0.004731318913400173, -0.06413175165653229, -0.013337924145162106, -0.05298013985157013, -0.0314941480755806, 0.039222896099090576, 0.007650414947420359, 0.030434507876634598, 0.07899836450815201, -0.031707849353551865, 0.025144679471850395, 0.0221402607858181, 0.031550075858831406, 0.000900978920981288, 0.041957512497901917, -0.04329342022538185, -0.020994307473301888, 0.0165996290743351, 0.025129275396466255, -0.023322418332099915, 0.03338438645005226, 0.0012478198623284698, 0.02744898945093155, -0.0019049012335017323, -0.016842888668179512, 0.009742463938891888, -0.01935625448822975, 0.00964622013270855, -0.02437090128660202, -0.030594507232308388, 0.017305633053183556, -0.013911993242800236, -0.06432009488344193, -0.028150347992777824, 0.0009706944692879915, -0.04297683760523796, -0.009373513981699944, 0.0018248758278787136, -0.010746592655777931, 0.004175761714577675, 0.006500702816992998, -0.023813268169760704, -0.0024382455740123987, 0.0028875661082565784, -0.03785008192062378, -0.020860692486166954, 0.04876405745744705, 0.045607682317495346, -0.0036652879789471626, -0.03155517578125, -0.07318457961082458, -0.01086767204105854, -0.03721870481967926, -0.02177250012755394, -0.020730428397655487, 0.04359141364693642, -0.03152552247047424, 0.029803993180394173, 0.01650330238044262, 0.022372663021087646, -0.0031499480828642845, 0.031288206577301025, -0.08655403554439545, 0.04913407191634178, -0.05233893170952797, -0.016915610060095787, 0.021814635023474693, -0.010828057304024696, 0.055589474737644196, -0.03179577365517616, 0.0062925261445343494, -0.024649569764733315, 0.034890517592430115, 0.0014758214820176363, 0.028977368026971817, 0.003034100402146578, -0.0055612362921237946, -0.0042001050896942616, -0.01799400895833969, -0.04010229930281639, 0.025066155940294266, 0.0014465349959209561, 0.04232347011566162, 0.00040609328425489366, 0.032162848860025406, -0.019335763528943062, -0.006911478005349636, 0.03706350922584534, 0.05191124230623245, 0.020039385184645653, -0.00017927633598446846, -0.05595399811863899, 0.03277347609400749, 0.015623239800333977, 0.04977928102016449, 0.031941648572683334, 0.019782528281211853, -0.04162250831723213, -0.014065029099583626, -0.023066021502017975, 0.014987212605774403, 0.013955596834421158, -0.011434447020292282, -0.004514439031481743, 0.07361465692520142, 0.03554042801260948, -0.03707192838191986, 0.015919512137770653, 0.04936477914452553, 0.030149659141898155, 0.015501555055379868, -0.01563231460750103, 0.009710963815450668, -0.010702294297516346, 0.0022219717502593994, 0.02445076033473015, 0.04000866040587425, -0.014129580929875374, -0.02549031376838684, 0.040854036808013916, -0.027548599988222122, -0.04318716749548912, 0.011753527447581291, 0.006197711452841759, -0.006305459421128035, -0.014076701365411282, -0.03675585240125656, 0.040177904069423676, 0.0419534295797348, 0.010897445492446423, 0.03765464574098587, 0.01648002304136753, -0.08677300065755844, 0.019970782101154327, 0.04049922898411751, 0.0531369186937809, -0.041937071830034256, -0.021716026589274406, -0.043579600751399994, -0.015788761898875237, 0.033940479159355164, -0.057934924960136414, 0.014080032706260681, -0.02781626023352146, 0.02476995438337326, -0.021783865988254547, -0.013523281551897526, -0.09565389156341553, -0.014531020075082779, -0.006035565864294767, 0.05530233681201935, -0.03322094678878784, -0.0222723800688982, -0.08158513903617859, 0.025045905262231827, 0.02369796857237816, 0.047848328948020935, -0.02198326401412487, -0.009166884236037731, 0.011100893840193748, 0.02393685095012188, 0.009787965565919876, -0.057254765182733536, 0.028066379949450493, 0.0027529371436685324, -0.012038103304803371, 0.022419994696974754, 0.00255547440610826, -0.039863746613264084, 0.01600470021367073, -0.003995883744210005, 0.0004521452938206494, -0.019082728773355484, -0.041218094527721405, 0.04628675803542137, 0.0008558551198802888, -0.014868427067995071, 0.030629312619566917, 0.004284646362066269, -0.005212609656155109, 0.023917019367218018, -0.06428880989551544, -0.005601321347057819, -0.020323902368545532, -0.03265945613384247, -0.008338725194334984, 0.009000583551824093, -0.001622903859242797, 0.02869667112827301, 0.024356486275792122, 0.017936168238520622, -0.01593334972858429, -0.03947024047374725, 0.015705062076449394, 0.010449390858411789, -0.008348852396011353, -0.021285612136125565, 0.04493330419063568, -0.0015793016646057367, -0.003342838492244482, -0.025224313139915466, 0.02356894314289093, -0.04082842916250229, 0.010604157112538815, 0.04174363985657692, -0.02076481282711029, -0.00949636660516262, 0.004130133893340826, -0.02407665178179741, 0.006218404974788427, -0.001864806516095996, 0.016723232343792915, 0.0017147952457889915, 0.007737147621810436, -0.027112267911434174, -0.036851752549409866, -0.004207400139421225, 0.022492310032248497, -0.014240121468901634, 0.06399908661842346, -0.021354516968131065, 0.02149275131523609, -0.007486261893063784, -0.03425924852490425, -0.06953779608011246, -0.05247383937239647, -0.011411779560148716, 0.009613318368792534, -0.012175042182207108, -0.022389499470591545, -0.030194642022252083, -0.021007834002375603, -0.02527148835361004, -0.0036353145260363817, 0.05805809423327446, -0.05333602800965309, -0.016527002677321434, -0.020781291648745537, 0.02247358113527298, 0.06511829048395157, -0.03839344531297684, -0.0298050157725811, 0.002161960583180189, -0.026127399876713753, -0.025067996233701706, -0.005640351679176092, 0.00014597168774344027, -0.019239339977502823, 0.0031638320069760084, 0.01632416807115078, -0.0001948052813531831, 0.026429811492562294, -0.005479094106703997, -0.022920161485671997, 0.03203203156590462, -0.025692332535982132, 0.01768386922776699, 0.0010210879845544696, 0.044120654463768005, -0.015563885681331158, 0.013269537128508091, 0.004099537618458271, -0.02236388809978962, -0.011210400611162186, -0.017642498016357422, 0.04807284474372864, -0.015379550866782665, -0.003413052996620536, 0.014921612106263638, 0.050135936588048935, -0.018253866583108902, 0.02451958879828453, -0.015057908371090889, -0.02263636514544487, 0.05813116207718849, 0.01032622903585434, -0.0061239334754645824, -0.016436489298939705, 0.04445261135697365, -0.03590238466858864, -0.04021468758583069, -0.021725008264183998, 0.00021222213399596512, 0.0010978737846016884, 0.08293408155441284, 0.00803125835955143, 0.026212558150291443, -0.013839677907526493, -0.006769940257072449, -0.019512839615345, -0.010778426192700863, 0.020422136411070824, -0.013254103250801563, 0.02443763241171837, -0.05499497428536415, -0.0003932971158064902, 0.035332102328538895, 0.011625212617218494, 0.015565779991447926, 0.0031222179532051086, 0.034892693161964417, 0.010012377053499222, 0.05468800291419029, -0.020683515816926956, -0.0651288777589798, 0.05073988065123558, -0.03825076296925545, 0.030325310304760933, -0.03586578369140625, -0.012423689477145672, 0.022175079211592674, 0.03778430446982384, 0.017465978860855103, -0.08789854496717453, -0.007572776637971401, -0.014891278930008411, -0.007958230562508106, 0.0478377491235733, -0.03543062135577202, 0.023113710805773735, -0.017353231087327003, 0.03768906742334366, 0.008021142333745956, 0.009449408389627934, -0.01257971953600645, -0.05067971348762512, -0.024623554199934006, -0.005695008207112551, -0.027378275990486145, -0.0018731188029050827, 0.005173339508473873, 0.012510010972619057, 0.010760793462395668, -0.07101605087518692, -0.012208414264023304, 0.010747539810836315, 0.048340145498514175, 0.021206626668572426, 0.0498482882976532, -0.007807150948792696, 0.048622969537973404, -0.006616022903472185, -0.023084042593836784, 0.1132369190454483, 0.08395243436098099, -0.021895263344049454, -0.07477343082427979, 0.005108396057039499, 0.015557211823761463, 0.024041583761572838, -0.01777431182563305, -0.015219217166304588, -0.0012921179877594113, -0.025666281580924988, 0.043664369732141495, 0.0700865387916565, 0.011297261342406273, -0.00031828039209358394, 0.030408324673771858, -0.029405895620584488, -0.010253130458295345, 0.0025509309489279985, 0.005873234011232853, -0.021183863282203674, -0.03563157841563225, -0.03534509986639023, 0.02127612568438053, -0.020213356241583824, -0.039058513939380646, -0.007935811765491962, -0.009135366417467594, 0.009575878269970417, -0.0030087600462138653, -0.03666974604129791, -0.03034966252744198, 0.025064993649721146, 0.009219513274729252, -0.008360741659998894, -0.007807518355548382, 0.00843475665897131, -0.016941841691732407, 0.0067744129337370396, 0.037277303636074066, -0.015040929429233074, 0.019925285130739212, -0.0012198641197755933, -0.026438752189278603, -0.06340834498405457, -0.010709578171372414, -0.027824727818369865, 0.030276689678430557, 0.02922891639173031, 0.001589679392054677, -0.012733030132949352, 0.0031835720874369144, 0.01439351961016655, -0.01349176000803709, -0.034622255712747574, 0.03167244419455528, 0.01598438248038292, -0.06396810710430145, -0.013743055053055286, -0.0062360865995287895, 0.01019888836890459, 0.013793489895761013, 0.02497095614671707, 0.044098298996686935, -0.03606712818145752, -0.0030224951915442944, -0.006536329165101051, 0.03419475257396698, 0.00028378143906593323, -0.0014773767907172441, 0.03053385391831398, -0.021159987896680832, -0.040728915482759476, 0.004684588871896267, 0.004471566062420607, 0.018631789833307266, 0.023896677419543266, -0.012373586185276508, 0.01168312318623066, -0.0662977322936058, -0.026937752962112427, 0.024551428854465485, -0.026067977771162987, -0.028084471821784973, -0.042868196964263916, -0.01608928106725216, -0.005489632952958345, 0.025415493175387383, 0.014623124152421951, 0.0028686881996691227, 0.014732480980455875, 0.06355252861976624, 0.009593509137630463, -0.04937491565942764, -0.03612908720970154, -0.0012705966364592314, -0.05098618194460869, 0.01765497773885727, 0.04413161054253578, 0.04500453174114227, 0.02068755403161049, 0.037256184965372086, 0.023361552506685257, 0.0008354004239663482, -0.047320667654275894, 0.004445814527571201, 0.032058145850896835, -0.02376089245080948, -0.03634802997112274, 0.02992096170783043, 0.010578363202512264, -0.006983723491430283, -0.010835052467882633, -0.05687234178185463, -0.022586612030863762, 0.00209181010723114, 0.00760880671441555, -0.03306630626320839, 0.015096436254680157, 0.007660454139113426, 0.0635446235537529, -0.02797224558889866, -0.024730850011110306, -0.056577540934085846, 0.007655316963791847, 0.021789228543639183, -0.011560342274606228, 0.008187571540474892, 0.03988242894411087, -0.0007960820221342146, 0.009133310988545418, 0.004068645648658276, 0.011590467765927315, 0.027277398854494095, 0.01653124950826168, 0.04029088839888573, -0.02231452614068985, 0.0291304811835289, 0.001320960116572678, -0.03138118237257004, 0.022737151011824608, 0.013524000532925129, -0.04717389866709709, 0.03181907534599304, -0.006840166170150042, 0.01936340518295765, -0.0019376875134184957, 0.0006807110621593893, -0.04425807297229767, 0.039045002311468124, -0.021021252498030663, 0.007031240500509739, -0.017303895205259323, 0.01543140783905983, 0.022376084700226784, 0.013312475755810738, -0.02215408720076084, 0.003656422020867467, -0.03101271018385887, 0.010350973345339298, 0.058457352221012115, -0.02127528004348278, -0.0025847989600151777, -0.0004841769696213305, -0.014598669484257698, 0.03548938035964966, 0.02898517996072769, -0.010428018867969513, 0.009253326803445816, 0.016636885702610016, -0.01916879042983055, 0.03531650826334953, -0.02273901179432869, 0.02157250978052616, -0.057693757116794586, -0.04374345391988754, -0.00635095639154315, 0.02700677514076233, 0.04097239673137665, -0.04252874106168747, -0.029450541362166405, 0.03710334002971649, -0.03181132674217224, 0.02206977643072605, 0.0013306187465786934, -0.02185293845832348, -0.040600698441267014, -0.0262589231133461, -0.0011681466130539775, 0.008170904591679573, -0.005964240990579128, -0.0013071767752990127, 0.036363065242767334, 0.04692567512392998, -0.0065650418400764465, -0.016066523268818855, -0.017093637958168983, -0.0012167571112513542, 0.01572881080210209, -0.043285153806209564, 0.0399007722735405, -0.06430249661207199, 0.01012074202299118, 0.04725323244929314, 0.008924017660319805, -0.0011023558909073472, 0.04884069412946701, 0.03284415602684021, 0.03418542072176933, 0.09533850103616714, 0.04254252091050148, 0.02321864478290081, 0.016445746645331383, -0.018078582361340523, 0.023982377722859383, 0.021271798759698868, -0.01522818859666586, 0.02466936782002449, -0.006287734489887953, -0.025325510650873184, 0.006390898022800684, 0.006896341219544411, 0.006661820225417614, 0.00717935198917985, -0.00706885801628232, -0.03054238110780716, -0.002493922831490636, -0.03402833268046379, 0.05578028783202171, -0.050470009446144104, -0.04643143713474274, 0.04614199325442314, 0.019555389881134033, -0.06042579561471939, 0.004364879801869392, 0.0024046602193266153, -0.03309182822704315, 0.011096363887190819, -0.016448132693767548, 0.00638954434543848, -0.04394634813070297, 0.004845426417887211, -0.016574140638113022, 0.003143361769616604, -0.03788520395755768, 0.0036918572150170803, -0.04377545788884163, 0.03824014216661453, -0.01992962323129177, 0.020932506769895554, 0.016709569841623306, -0.060508474707603455, 0.009859704412519932, -0.1091182753443718, 0.05645173788070679, 0.007495323661714792, -0.014944927766919136, 0.0016214301576837897, -0.029102178290486336, -0.05914335697889328, 0.020834453403949738, 0.0493101105093956, -0.008333500474691391, -0.030411027371883392, 0.021423060446977615, -0.0034157505724579096, 0.01307172141969204, -0.01608332246541977, 0.051457539200782776, -0.0026398624759167433, -0.03477945923805237, 0.01514153741300106, -0.013046227395534515, 0.024560609832406044, 0.0015081034507602453, 0.029686065390706062, -0.019906368106603622, -0.021526705473661423, -0.023103097453713417, -0.030772628262639046, 0.07394279539585114, 0.005960305221378803, 0.020549830049276352, 0.06089765578508377, 0.016323652118444443, 0.03069397620856762, 0.03524986281991005, 0.0009592550923116505, -0.07297159731388092, 0.00855180248618126, -0.020747890695929527, -0.023116907104849815, 0.01746615767478943, 0.021043917164206505, 0.029392948374152184, -0.03720536828041077, 0.024269137531518936, -0.0015914675313979387, 0.017439715564250946, -0.010998943820595741, 0.01427073311060667, -0.01344781368970871, 0.012338712811470032, 0.022901853546500206, 0.03778078034520149, 0.001838412368670106, 0.03276475891470909, 0.017325755208730698, 0.055054813623428345, 0.024881966412067413, -0.00859017763286829, 0.017356783151626587, 0.02454460971057415, -0.0037492895498871803, 0.04911137744784355, -0.011248423717916012, 0.03992684185504913, -0.060959137976169586, -0.01917445659637451, 0.03589845448732376, -0.014123733155429363, 0.04209468886256218, 0.024512063711881638, 0.01191752403974533, 0.06257922947406769, -0.06161614507436752, 0.023331403732299805, -0.022028189152479172, 0.014670740813016891, -0.029000530019402504, -0.02086016722023487, 0.01143314503133297, 0.008702518418431282, 0.005406477488577366, 0.02189253643155098, 0.03386504203081131, -0.03597187250852585, -0.01566028781235218, -0.038288719952106476, -0.012596562504768372, -0.005319435149431229, 0.02584589645266533, -0.037111546844244, -0.0167913269251585, -0.034274376928806305, -0.03644922375679016, -0.012970739044249058, 0.05104983597993851, 0.009537103585898876, -0.010374721139669418, -0.016504231840372086, 0.028837434947490692, 0.008412356488406658, -0.020157847553491592, 0.02271938882768154, -0.03181071579456329, 0.021593160927295685, 0.007527316454797983, -0.018031593412160873 ]
<p>In baseball statistics, there is a statistic called "luck" which is the difference between a team's win-loss record and their <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pythagorean_expectation" rel="nofollow">Pythagorean win-loss record</a>. This statistic is supposed to measure how lucky or unlucky a team was to win however many games they did in a season. </p> <p>Suppose one has a big data set which, for each year n, includes </p> <ol> <li>team winning percentage $P(n)$</li> <li>team winning percentage the previous year $P(n-1)$</li> <li>team luck the previous year $L(n-1)$</li> </ol> <p>and wants to create a linear regression model using $P(n-1)$ and $L(n-1)$ to estimate $P(n)$. </p> <p>There's no apparent relationship between $L(n-1)$ and $P(n)$, but it seems as though we could use $L(n-1)$ in conjunction with $P(n-1)$ to better predict $P(n)$ based on how "flukey" $P(n-1)$ was and in what way. </p> <p>So, the question is, how could one incorporate a luck-type measure into a linear regression model like I've discussed? I'm not concerned with this particular luck-type measure, but rather any measure which does something similar to what this one is supposed to do. </p>
35,943
[ -0.061819661408662796, 0.0003936863213311881, 0.003495696233585477, -0.021306995302438736, 0.013155253604054451, 0.01894341967999935, 0.010079966858029366, -0.005570246372371912, 0.023964757099747658, -0.002528426004573703, 0.03311500698328018, 0.05450601875782013, 0.052510034292936325, 0.07598678022623062, -0.00440905662253499, 0.003302972298115492, -0.015593374148011208, 0.005595919210463762, -0.010099628008902073, -0.01172250509262085, 0.0375259593129158, 0.0324932225048542, 0.00041566573781892657, 0.0032839830964803696, -0.024480462074279785, 0.06203775107860565, 0.03328365460038185, -0.019830763339996338, 0.022517405450344086, 0.03399975597858429, 0.028283407911658287, 0.0035360355395823717, 0.017824100330471992, 0.048084575682878494, 0.018015895038843155, -0.009303287602961063, -0.010804238729178905, -0.04401825740933418, 0.013703574426472187, 0.0279436893761158, -0.03222814202308655, -0.056816842406988144, 0.014831142500042915, 0.03362688422203064, -0.011456593871116638, 0.04283465817570686, -0.04987188056111336, -0.03550790622830391, 0.038842588663101196, -0.009886795654892921, 0.05757477879524231, 0.02842787466943264, 0.02095312625169754, -0.0048900023102760315, -0.020740706473588943, -0.015094300732016563, 0.03223549202084541, 0.08223006874322891, 0.01319310162216425, -0.07262210547924042, -0.018060097470879555, -0.047908347100019455, 0.014502777718007565, 0.014702347107231617, -0.04572232440114021, -0.00020336033776402473, 0.0078104110434651375, -0.037912655621767044, 0.01651124283671379, -0.0024437878746539354, -0.027485279366374016, 0.017717912793159485, 0.02892187051475048, 0.013580192811787128, 0.0007561976672150195, -0.029497630894184113, -0.01949950121343136, -0.0012436300748959184, 0.06469324976205826, 0.00438701780512929, -0.02879929170012474, 0.02292192354798317, 0.0312856063246727, 0.05111806467175484, 0.03256930783390999, -0.009424048475921154, 0.026202023029327393, -0.06622768193483353, 0.03021285869181156, 0.016279177740216255, 0.0071934605948626995, -0.03381374105811119, 0.045199666172266006, -0.008814217522740364, -0.07210668921470642, 0.01225617341697216, -0.04333580285310745, 0.01609126105904579, 0.03404098376631737, 0.022613385692238808, 0.014078075997531414, -0.07066766917705536, 0.0024549285881221294, 0.028250183910131454, 0.02089668996632099, -0.044697538018226624, -0.03608914837241173, -0.018176130950450897, 0.00753969419747591, -0.0161189716309309, -0.007890543900430202, 0.04145133122801781, 0.02321162074804306, 0.027872372418642044, 0.004697504919022322, -0.035829439759254456, -0.027510490268468857, 0.004817404318600893, 0.04776144027709961, 0.0701899379491806, 0.026753751561045647, -0.021474897861480713, 0.057011593133211136, -0.029723649844527245, -0.0336829237639904, 0.01885913498699665, 0.010909642092883587, -0.024238672107458115, -0.05633962154388428, 0.038291990756988525, -0.00048239450552500784, -0.003678745124489069, 0.05940848961472511, 0.02685162052512169, 0.050225406885147095, 0.01388075202703476, -0.09514506906270981, -0.020537588745355606, 0.05717000737786293, 0.0012611716520041227, 0.011095341295003891, -0.06302309036254883, -0.002654821379110217, 0.03552425652742386, 0.10652556270360947, 0.04556043818593025, 0.03912510350346565, -0.0037612745072692633, 0.021842023357748985, 0.016607634723186493, 0.009612023830413818, -0.02424425259232521, -0.003335225163027644, -0.05609742924571037, -0.03089020401239395, -0.09673765301704407, 0.04445486143231392, 0.014812525361776352, -0.02183462306857109, 0.0098795797675848, 0.0527941957116127, 0.022469257935881615, -0.004284914117306471, -0.011757750995457172, 0.041248027235269547, -0.016871344298124313, 0.06435150653123856, 0.037078723311424255, 0.014956246130168438, 0.004265719559043646, -0.02213752083480358, 0.027813028544187546, 0.04174124449491501, 0.05563041567802429, 0.06964284926652908, -0.002201440278440714, 0.002473290078341961, -0.005886025261133909, -0.007370591163635254, -0.047225791960954666, -0.05346507579088211, 0.022971274331212044, 0.006302498281002045, -0.01780478097498417, 0.013055496849119663, 0.032994866371154785, 0.01358494721353054, 0.00661954702809453, 0.05300827696919441, -0.022828854620456696, -0.057334307581186295, -0.10421299934387207, -0.008756406605243683, -0.0064445300959050655, -0.004191854503005743, 0.016673173755407333, -0.00483426870778203, 0.032899726182222366, -0.004457355476915836, 0.04373384639620781, 0.012473518028855324, 0.020251071080565453, 0.05317997932434082, -0.05999690666794777, -0.039217058569192886, 0.057467494159936905, 0.036437343806028366, -0.004295699298381805, 0.007820015773177147, -0.07114044576883316, -0.02928847447037697, 0.010332375764846802, -0.025815216824412346, -0.0044250464998185635, -0.004203200805932283, 0.01388440653681755, 0.014457453042268753, -0.02153666503727436, 0.015899894759058952, 0.022781673818826675, -0.029937993735074997, 0.019137892872095108, 0.038810718804597855, 0.02047257125377655, 0.05030478164553642, 0.023535290732979774, -0.00794964749366045, -0.00584224471822381, -0.0015780582325533032, -0.014310766942799091, -0.012589079327881336, -0.000856841157656163, 0.011023659259080887, 0.046444378793239594, -0.005881332326680422, 0.03738383948802948, 0.08260957151651382, -0.01590101793408394, -0.02336735837161541, 0.014292714186012745, -0.045339275151491165, -0.018267858773469925, -0.03918793052434921, 0.017329638823866844, 0.029230313375592232, -0.019827911630272865, 0.010904345661401749, 0.04286090284585953, 0.025059575214982033, 0.012389722280204296, -0.04015437141060829, 0.04102584719657898, 0.0244669858366251, 0.011560972779989243, 0.008006981573998928, -0.024681096896529198, 0.05973981320858002, -0.009848587214946747, -0.009365200065076351, 0.006277361884713173, -0.013010770082473755, 0.0015118123264983296, -0.03037252277135849, -0.021499373018741608, 0.01736793853342533, 0.05760069191455841, -0.010879609733819962, 0.006543079856783152, 0.020956499502062798, -0.009075524285435677, 0.017507804557681084, 0.004063491243869066, -0.014323818497359753, -0.021000763401389122, 0.022829819470643997, 0.004147382453083992, -0.004945634864270687, 0.011548419483006, 0.015514803119003773, -0.03874368220567703, 0.010569741018116474, -0.0142141068354249, 0.007995124906301498, 0.028123540803790092, -0.06699519604444504, -0.03697727248072624, -0.020152771845459938, 0.01108072604984045, -0.007381708826869726, -0.01876853033900261, 0.03327997028827667, 0.025889242067933083, 0.0035499653313308954, -0.0765090063214302, -0.04231492802500725, -0.045930009335279465, -0.010108629241585732, -0.03822489455342293, -0.04438188672065735, 0.025899464264512062, 0.019308926537632942, -0.011020688340067863, 0.0074181160889565945, -0.04489756375551224, -0.001210894319228828, -0.0444231778383255, 0.0112067349255085, 0.012738354504108429, -0.003916193265467882, 0.03611002117395401, 0.04006035625934601, -0.0111294686794281, -0.024001553654670715, -0.07468871772289276, -0.034146931022405624, -0.0051436396315693855, -0.013232837431132793, 0.009239718317985535, 0.030680319294333458, -0.012385958805680275, 0.06344176083803177, 0.040050208568573, -0.019683903083205223, -0.034843120723962784, 0.002954156370833516, -0.020367799326777458, -0.057684946805238724, -0.01634957455098629, 0.017953217029571533, -0.007085254415869713, 0.018061155453324318, -0.03345183655619621, -0.02696678414940834, 0.048255421221256256, 0.008020767010748386, -0.008707059547305107, 0.040198374539613724, 0.005637056194245815, 0.022200409322977066, 0.022602444514632225, -0.004106131382286549, -0.011674726381897926, 0.04099643602967262, -0.004672411363571882, -0.007908056490123272, 0.024675849825143814, -0.05366286262869835, 0.0222867913544178, -0.002847191644832492, -0.030129853636026382, -0.0071206833235919476, 0.02381407469511032, -0.008440536446869373, -0.0021472368389368057, -0.03230128437280655, 0.03491535410284996, 0.034417774528265, 0.019025452435016632, -0.0036842606496065855, 0.023137768730521202, 0.023256409913301468, -0.02005540207028389, -0.018096325919032097, -0.02828764170408249, -0.020991042256355286, 0.0020181923173367977, -0.027277536690235138, 0.009104705415666103, -0.0015052962116897106, 0.010056107304990292, -0.008129410445690155, -0.02044096402823925, -0.03152177855372429, 0.00629174429923296, 0.003254193114116788, -0.010296933352947235, -0.01636543497443199, 0.03949149325489998, 0.007674780674278736, 0.008190673775970936, -0.015373964793980122, -0.020834961906075478, 0.035282403230667114, 0.014921087771654129, -0.10290687531232834, 0.0172146987169981, -0.007037274539470673, -0.0120638282969594, -0.007831408642232418, -0.008923441171646118, 0.06227530539035797, -0.017502186819911003, -0.012803110294044018, -0.012320431880652905, 0.0006403149454854429, -0.01964758336544037, -0.03245308995246887, -0.03702104836702347, -0.04782229661941528, -0.012158030644059181, 0.030535079538822174, 0.025723924860358238, -0.026307182386517525, 0.03715036064386368, 0.008128193207085133, 0.00754008861258626, -0.05582091957330704, -0.01853741519153118, 0.0338885635137558, 0.012278244830667973, -0.010430630296468735, 0.03566393628716469, 0.034013018012046814, -0.01016710139811039, 0.02853403426706791, -0.007727446034550667, 0.02888181246817112, 0.06008271500468254, 0.028823841363191605, -0.014558784663677216, -0.04881490021944046, -0.010826274752616882, 0.04446607455611229, 0.031142793595790863, -0.0006248896243050694, -0.012514655478298664, 0.06944739073514938, 0.03210099786520004, -0.03396026790142059, 0.023823322728276253, 0.0173062514513731, -0.014857268892228603, 0.009713065810501575, -0.021513039246201515, 0.022658774629235268, 0.001079323934391141, 0.004159535281360149, 0.008665335364639759, 0.012550721876323223, 0.043555088341236115, -0.008135191164910793, 0.04842430353164673, 0.00849070679396391, -0.049470603466033936, -0.01030623447149992, 0.014428935945034027, 0.028870057314634323, -0.017104092985391617, -0.04961369186639786, 0.06291914731264114, 0.06414241343736649, 0.001688399352133274, 0.03460052236914635, 0.022638220340013504, -0.07016614079475403, -0.015471682883799076, 0.0040675378404557705, 0.05469203740358353, -0.02193268947303295, -0.0379532054066658, -0.06604456156492233, -0.023488998413085938, 0.02637534774839878, 0.0011585120810195804, 0.026178810745477676, -0.025721002370119095, -0.004600703250616789, -0.03733528405427933, -0.02564782090485096, -0.04077473282814026, 0.05857117101550102, -0.02273254282772541, 0.021895643323659897, -0.02581055276095867, -0.0038033940363675356, -0.02610675059258938, -0.012327935546636581, 0.009366665035486221, 0.04460042715072632, -0.042599666863679886, -0.006472693756222725, -0.00942436046898365, 0.042356446385383606, -0.0011818620841950178, -0.05185262858867645, 0.03390558809041977, 0.020107246935367584, -0.018569383770227432, 0.019595474004745483, -0.002731721382588148, -0.013225148431956768, -0.011677304282784462, -0.012276103720068932, -0.03793573006987572, 0.022684574127197266, -0.030994145199656487, 0.03801867738366127, 0.022822130471467972, 0.008495435118675232, 0.04487195611000061, 0.01925714872777462, -0.00910243671387434, -0.0014268800150603056, -0.02757856994867325, -0.011045526713132858, 0.007104938384145498, 0.0011287425877526402, -0.04121509566903114, -0.0317961685359478, -0.042520105838775635, 0.03737258166074753, 0.025570977479219437, 0.039964709430933, -0.01244630292057991, -0.03542817384004593, -0.021012084558606148, -0.006667998153716326, -0.01674041338264942, -0.01139968540519476, 0.002772243693470955, 0.005568011198192835, -0.0006329771713353693, 0.008355049416422844, -0.006354494020342827, -0.009741797111928463, 0.02327589876949787, 0.021227777004241943, -0.007383683230727911, 0.05694887042045593, -0.0006128997192718089, -0.0013248238246887922, 0.0027475410606712103, 0.0029730298556387424, 0.02524595893919468, -0.005661057773977518, 0.005829984787851572, -0.023474685847759247, -0.01566269062459469, -0.02538231760263443, 0.0007322036544792354, 0.0036521393340080976, 0.01408551074564457, -0.02939712628722191, -0.0050154621712863445, -0.0013749779900535941, -0.05382933467626572, -0.05374192073941231, -0.00003101968832197599, -0.003532206639647484, -0.027361111715435982, -0.01904260367155075, -0.0329182893037796, -0.010080553591251373, -0.01627076417207718, -0.027904139831662178, 0.015413254499435425, 0.07826457172632217, -0.016237737610936165, -0.06984402239322662, 0.01328487228602171, 0.00048315065214410424, 0.07244683057069778, -0.011305084452033043, -0.0389796607196331, 0.012170487083494663, -0.02875317446887493, 0.011797063052654266, -0.006751956883817911, 0.036653947085142136, -0.044671542942523956, 0.012703653424978256, 0.015751630067825317, -0.013134177774190903, 0.04416113346815109, -0.0006679724901914597, -0.015424895100295544, -0.007145284209400415, 0.00864227395504713, 0.034604791551828384, 0.002051085000857711, 0.021057004109025, -0.005301338154822588, 0.020398780703544617, -0.03418498858809471, 0.017895793542265892, 0.020196164026856422, 0.0031313125509768724, 0.01781087927520275, 0.030968215316534042, 0.02693144604563713, -0.006460119038820267, 0.031818341463804245, -0.007647118531167507, -0.019728664308786392, 0.0019626591820269823, -0.014489042572677135, 0.055694904178380966, 0.038667481392621994, -0.00843814481049776, 0.002968349726870656, 0.025134768337011337, -0.024066591635346413, -0.050613828003406525, -0.05383419990539551, -0.010256088338792324, 0.04481746256351471, -0.04494204372167587, 0.025810999795794487, 0.028950277715921402, 0.015182661823928356, -0.02114390954375267, -0.017999330535531044, -0.0026947995647788048, -0.013109104707837105, -0.017914289608597755, 0.06242186203598976, -0.005553665105253458, 0.0034435943234711885, 0.0567052997648716, -0.017414862290024757, -0.011951113119721413, 0.014383058995008469, 0.03882001340389252, 0.04610244929790497, 0.032438963651657104, -0.04395173490047455, -0.005708052311092615, 0.02487272024154663, -0.0407252237200737, -0.005983483046293259, -0.036499667912721634, -0.012747482396662235, 0.04595636576414108, 0.06344003230333328, 0.011162509210407734, -0.0641285628080368, -0.007609895430505276, -0.05050421506166458, -0.010875396430492401, 0.0467090904712677, 0.01491040550172329, 0.03679617866873741, -0.015220395289361477, -0.0017986561870202422, 0.01242961548268795, 0.014599992893636227, -0.012640116736292839, -0.04794032499194145, -0.008122630417346954, -0.0012375371297821403, -0.07631997764110565, -0.015570865012705326, 0.010971798561513424, 0.00350441737100482, 0.010319815948605537, -0.021748345345258713, -0.007245723158121109, 0.0025319326668977737, 0.009199467487633228, -0.013794424943625927, 0.0889790803194046, 0.014881526120007038, -0.0033669571857899427, -0.005598724354058504, -0.01709841378033161, 0.15177570283412933, 0.07720767706632614, 0.05959324911236763, -0.03671208769083023, -0.0038312163669615984, -0.01999901607632637, -0.026009973138570786, -0.0368662066757679, -0.004526004660874605, 0.00609829043969512, -0.015750059857964516, -0.01533457636833191, 0.050466280430555344, 0.005781793035566807, -0.023136526346206665, 0.027240028604865074, -0.042841795831918716, 0.033712614327669144, 0.021626939997076988, -0.043703194707632065, 0.010383843444287777, -0.006173343397676945, -0.0042497385293245316, 0.0013716258108615875, 0.014545254409313202, 0.0024775308556854725, 0.008223164826631546, -0.01748781092464924, -0.012187114916741848, 0.00213794456794858, -0.021275058388710022, 0.04682082310318947, 0.023642128333449364, 0.024317840114235878, -0.0014372422592714429, 0.017503060400485992, 0.023465711623430252, -0.05481628328561783, 0.01844954863190651, -0.0066201770678162575, 0.02055611088871956, -0.022717200219631195, 0.020215949043631554, -0.0010661289561539888, -0.04058781638741493, -0.03774568438529968, -0.042348090559244156, 0.04245991259813309, 0.022560568526387215, 0.023521877825260162, -0.03511568903923035, -0.026539543643593788, 0.009494091384112835, -0.01511501893401146, -0.0016163670225068927, 0.05178588628768921, 0.07152379304170609, -0.03272547200322151, -0.040630001574754715, 0.01729501597583294, -0.03689182549715042, -0.020612552762031555, 0.03925293684005737, 0.01938137412071228, -0.026447301730513573, -0.0011557139223441482, -0.009155673906207085, 0.028998270630836487, 0.014260777272284031, 0.010274640284478664, -0.009618778713047504, 0.00034587373374961317, -0.047451939433813095, 0.005311906803399324, 0.012762870639562607, -0.015310419723391533, 0.005089000333100557, -0.007372000254690647, -0.025788260623812675, 0.003387600649148226, -0.03396274894475937, 0.022844554856419563, -0.045385949313640594, -0.0031116902828216553, -0.04696688801050186, -0.03344764932990074, 0.029674209654331207, 0.01252488512545824, -0.014351491816341877, 0.0017307768575847149, -0.012270734645426273, 0.05066061392426491, 0.032570961862802505, -0.0428159162402153, 0.0004825758805964142, -0.020885659381747246, -0.04971376806497574, 0.02095421776175499, -0.00246062153019011, 0.0788579136133194, 0.03655653074383736, 0.0066679553128778934, 0.011487039737403393, 0.02373095043003559, -0.008463334292173386, 0.009784218855202198, 0.003547040745615959, -0.08983778953552246, 0.01762331835925579, 0.0016434061108157039, -0.004874703474342823, -0.012982095591723919, -0.04051514342427254, -0.02837858349084854, -0.008835064247250557, -0.013726877979934216, -0.018639659509062767, -0.04298219829797745, 0.01797199435532093, -0.01410994678735733, -0.0028617146890610456, 0.04434068500995636, 0.004484443459659815, -0.011357937008142471, -0.010087723843753338, -0.01557096466422081, 0.0069301677867770195, 0.0010553090833127499, 0.047104738652706146, -0.009425463154911995, 0.008911654353141785, 0.02624659053981304, -0.005237756296992302, 0.007218610029667616, -0.006216396111994982, -0.021419012919068336, -0.0257803313434124, 0.032755449414253235, -0.03653895482420921, -0.04430769383907318, 0.06769586354494095, -0.027002716436982155, -0.049157291650772095, 0.02557791769504547, 0.0028321167919784784, 0.05426342785358429, 0.02131200209259987, 0.015408048406243324, -0.049928437918424606, 0.017278917133808136, -0.02411750890314579, -0.019222306087613106, -0.02162349969148636, -0.003141846042126417, 0.007954378612339497, -0.009494278579950333, -0.01030952762812376, -0.0018724402179941535, -0.034156620502471924, -0.046022798866033554, 0.044995009899139404, -0.010059211403131485, -0.016505051404237747, 0.009933378547430038, -0.030550051480531693, 0.019999617710709572, -0.019986560568213463, -0.00879895780235529, 0.023869767785072327, -0.0051284716464579105, -0.024025609716773033, 0.007627422921359539, 0.020445391535758972, -0.0015035856049507856, -0.10708311200141907, -0.011779348365962505, 0.007567554712295532, 0.049642473459243774, 0.023042086511850357, -0.08769575506448746, 0.009776881895959377, 0.022403549402952194, -0.02793803997337818, 0.033862072974443436, 0.0342903696000576, 0.01046658307313919, -0.041958075016736984, 0.03111480548977852, -0.04222862794995308, 0.0024063815362751484, -0.008800376206636429, 0.021954452618956566, 0.030395885929465294, 0.048136547207832336, 0.009123045951128006, -0.0018499213038012385, -0.02551962248980999, 0.0248725488781929, 0.006219441536813974, -0.05476313829421997, 0.049971338361501694, -0.046023234724998474, -0.04392613098025322, 0.025740649551153183, -0.030617468059062958, 0.033158089965581894, -0.00020811795548070222, -0.004535561427474022, -0.011266494169831276, 0.0008562842267565429, 0.038200683891773224, -0.02648908644914627, -0.013921158388257027, 0.005924534052610397, 0.039923593401908875, 0.01917104423046112, -0.005628642160445452, -0.008762930519878864, 0.006504175253212452, -0.008976605720818043, -0.000027018109904020093, -0.0027234444860368967, -0.0020863544195890427, 0.053007129579782486, 0.020607393234968185, -0.02310827746987343, 0.001960586989298463, -0.020714016631245613, 0.0026563319843262434, -0.028006840497255325, 0.010960616171360016, 0.036399804055690765, 0.010164317674934864, -0.03289064019918442, 0.03535028174519539, -0.002555418061092496, -0.05175692215561867, -0.026293303817510605, -0.009171776473522186, -0.005481501575559378, -0.04468581825494766, -0.019808156415820122, 0.013174856081604958, 0.00013858625607099384, -0.025573359802365303, -0.021675189957022667, -0.0742591843008995, 0.023021358996629715, -0.02814590558409691, 0.008849349804222584, 0.042908668518066406, 0.02528340555727482, 0.02709363028407097, -0.08372291177511215, 0.06132126972079277, 0.0015039407880976796, 0.041791029274463654, 0.012061127461493015, 0.00104251888114959, -0.006833990570157766, -0.009913445450365543, 0.09684479236602783, 0.010270404629409313, -0.021172495558857918, 0.021805958822369576, 0.003564454149454832, 0.010639014653861523, -0.03156382963061333, 0.027833975851535797, -0.05039579048752785, -0.00796754751354456, -0.04277397319674492, -0.009554451331496239, 0.0039026415906846523, -0.0206815917044878, 0.028814420104026794, 0.006205154582858086, -0.027721351012587547, -0.015467281453311443, -0.02476957067847252, 0.029440773651003838, -0.001461549662053585, -0.016209447756409645, 0.023975970223546028, 0.021888907998800278, 0.0312914177775383, 0.015853669494390488, -0.01806836947798729, -0.06112642586231232, 0.08184897154569626, -0.05747382342815399, -0.05805765464901924, -0.01743170991539955, 0.0015042092418298125, -0.04181723669171333, -0.03856227174401283, -0.010052750818431377, 0.0325680747628212, -0.006478940602391958, -0.0060476744547486305, 0.04125254228711128, -0.018126247450709343, 0.047564547508955, -0.010252810083329678, -0.0030153472907841206, -0.003711178433150053, -0.0077578541822731495, -0.011051252484321594, -0.015976060181856155, 0.042337566614151, 0.006623117718845606, 0.021430663764476776, 0.022841032594442368, 0.013663627207279205, 0.031617339700460434, 0.03367287293076515, 0.029727984219789505, -0.047666169703006744, 0.026081018149852753, 0.014660126529633999, 0.0028398679569363594, -0.007843191735446453, -0.000368207402061671, 0.018435686826705933, 0.053260333836078644, -0.018661443144083023, 0.0382746197283268, -0.04883729666471481, -0.002665318315848708, -0.01137892808765173, -0.03383807837963104, 0.01184284221380949, -0.000351559225236997, 0.015523629263043404, 0.016870837658643723, 0.016111252829432487, 0.012665359303355217, 0.04969165846705437, -0.003339521586894989, -0.01826127991080284, 0.007122917100787163, -0.015768857672810555, -0.01374503131955862, -0.032570358365774155, -0.03755870833992958, -0.04558116942644119, -0.0030017406679689884, 0.024903681129217148, 0.03113938495516777, -0.015165218152105808, -0.012665992602705956, 0.013514232821762562, 0.05545946955680847, -0.048358313739299774, -0.02971460483968258, -0.06357020884752274, 0.06365413218736649, 0.00565654132515192, -0.04267021268606186 ]
<p>Let $B(t)$ be Brownian motion. I want to calculate $\int B(t)^2 dB(t)$.</p> <p>definition.A process $\{X(t),0\le t \le T \}$ is called a simple adapted process if there exist times $0=t_{0}&lt;t_{1}&lt;t_{2}&lt;\cdots&lt;t_{n}=T $ and random variables $\eta_{0},\eta_{1},\cdots,\eta_{n}$ such that $\eta_{0}$ is a constant,$\eta_{i}$ is $\mathcal F_{i}$-measurable,For simple adapted processes Ito integral $\int X dB$ is defined as a sum $$\int_{0}^{T}X(t)dB(t)=\sum_{i=0}^{n-1}\eta_{i}(B(t_{i+1}-B(t_{i}))$$ </p>
73,545
[ 0.005346287041902542, -0.01410035789012909, 0.024755513295531273, -0.0027786167338490486, 0.03183016553521156, 0.011397815309464931, 0.012576155364513397, -0.036450061947107315, 0.03275744989514351, -0.043873559683561325, 0.05280671268701553, 0.03988754749298096, 0.045977480709552765, 0.02395339123904705, 0.05876128748059273, 0.018009617924690247, -0.03140680119395256, -0.022231172770261765, -0.040303315967321396, -0.017661243677139282, 0.0032559214159846306, 0.009678341448307037, 0.02911057323217392, 0.0032580287661403418, -0.041395403444767, 0.002931461436673999, 0.023229295387864113, 0.021008269861340523, -0.012909612618386745, 0.061017509549856186, -0.06333629786968231, -0.0191668588668108, 0.005779193248599768, 0.02643406391143799, -0.0057049961760640144, 0.019192451611161232, -0.06215715780854225, -0.03095436841249466, -0.016260070726275444, -0.01430913619697094, 0.006903294939547777, -0.03217543661594391, -0.009402872063219547, 0.06347494572401047, -0.012919547036290169, 0.01870330423116684, 0.01569695957005024, -0.020814886316657066, 0.044816967099905014, -0.040880993008613586, 0.06978913396596909, -0.000013438771020446438, 0.019322343170642853, 0.02769916132092476, 0.027003882452845573, -0.02586822398006916, 0.008008304983377457, 0.04318299889564514, 0.008191771805286407, -0.028481125831604004, -0.01500870380550623, -0.04285060241818428, 0.02746741473674774, -0.009399492293596268, -0.015952173620462418, 0.0019684606231749058, 0.005083097610622644, -0.049531981348991394, -0.0014649549266323447, -0.031212707981467247, 0.013628744520246983, 0.003957564476877451, 0.0403544083237648, -0.03593017905950546, -0.010474896058440208, 0.0028227304574102163, 0.008238183334469795, 0.030169200152158737, 0.03899981081485748, 0.04174454137682915, 0.013841730542480946, -0.005388071294873953, 0.00652188528329134, 0.03138665854930878, 0.01067581307142973, -0.03782014548778534, 0.0687798410654068, -0.019606932997703552, 0.0326065830886364, 0.00627050269395113, -0.0023270591627806425, 0.03802628815174103, 0.04766025021672249, -0.006971132941544056, -0.04518745467066765, 0.03887331113219261, -0.006424589082598686, 0.023034775629639626, 0.006968377158045769, -0.014959213323891163, -0.008415530435740948, -0.06913499534130096, 0.03804369270801544, 0.046436309814453125, 0.009175554849207401, 0.0011716998415067792, -0.007473016623407602, 0.011552473530173302, -0.012337302789092064, -0.025457097217440605, -0.04905376210808754, 0.028738804161548615, -0.009111137129366398, -0.012108284048736095, 0.01054367981851101, -0.009997015818953514, -0.05050978064537048, -0.0033252297434955835, 0.010630709119141102, 0.061221424490213394, 0.04559389874339104, -0.02002009190618992, 0.06414402276277542, -0.028274213895201683, -0.06410841643810272, 0.03527425229549408, 0.005193263292312622, -0.02737709879875183, -0.05136116221547127, 0.06938610225915909, 0.0032023752573877573, -0.05227406322956085, 0.03315139189362526, 0.04438535124063492, 0.015293867327272892, -0.003235595067963004, -0.06321367621421814, -0.05990104377269745, 0.021128490567207336, -0.03751278296113014, -0.0040469602681696415, -0.06296151131391525, 0.027715014293789864, 0.0663677453994751, 0.05126397684216499, 0.017412440851330757, 0.04145810380578041, 0.008918467909097672, -0.013039234094321728, 0.013275467790663242, -0.04523637145757675, -0.04950840398669243, -0.00651815440505743, -0.003821024438366294, 0.017621371895074844, -0.05640913173556328, -0.0029305466450750828, 0.04210887849330902, -0.0431968979537487, -0.024194709956645966, 0.06509173661470413, 0.00044954815530218184, -0.02207583747804165, -0.03222868964076042, 0.006279986817389727, -0.03161031752824783, 0.07329724729061127, 0.026331059634685516, -0.00547332176938653, -0.007854362949728966, 0.008180949836969376, -0.02225189469754696, -0.03721962496638298, 0.03309972584247589, 0.031022045761346817, -0.028347911313176155, -0.029215432703495026, 0.010344121605157852, 0.05204884335398674, 0.05114365369081497, -0.014738650061190128, 0.001382195856422186, -0.023282187059521675, -0.00801059603691101, 0.003182676387950778, 0.007666485384106636, 0.018605777993798256, 0.022660085931420326, 0.010443695820868015, -0.05688754841685295, -0.002897521248087287, -0.04634515196084976, 0.024377163499593735, 0.0018976758001372218, -0.05099213123321533, -0.004984325263649225, -0.009710486978292465, 0.018830297514796257, 0.0012478273129090667, -0.01693081296980381, 0.002387484535574913, 0.008352347649633884, -0.01394595019519329, -0.0391739159822464, -0.007693430408835411, 0.03758604824542999, 0.061924103647470474, 0.008696925826370716, 0.03993348032236099, -0.023795221000909805, -0.00008417074423050508, -0.024164598435163498, -0.05356006696820259, 0.029444778338074684, -0.025163060054183006, -0.047945279628038406, 0.03569691255688667, -0.05331080034375191, 0.014210749417543411, 0.050277069211006165, -0.07430519908666611, 0.05979114770889282, 0.07822328805923462, 0.04032111540436745, 0.011985276825726032, 0.04041449353098869, 0.03400178998708725, 0.0208046343177557, -0.01303161308169365, 0.0030252698343247175, -0.01659799925982952, 0.010684022679924965, 0.008891183882951736, 0.07926903665065765, -0.024903753772377968, -0.016604820266366005, 0.05083470046520233, -0.006140373647212982, -0.0037027483340352774, 0.05744119733572006, 0.003879701253026724, -0.02703082375228405, 0.022688083350658417, -0.02699926123023033, -0.002291265642270446, 0.004851626232266426, -0.029504602774977684, -0.002667033579200506, 0.04151514917612076, -0.00701538473367691, -0.01675480045378208, 0.023486489430069923, 0.0359051488339901, 0.031832024455070496, -0.008420268073678017, -0.001027467893436551, 0.04468279331922531, -0.01669333316385746, 0.004251936916261911, 0.035015005618333817, -0.010871787555515766, 0.014982379041612148, 0.023748481646180153, -0.030524153262376785, 0.04044008627533913, 0.007353703025728464, -0.021914534270763397, -0.061475008726119995, 0.018804624676704407, -0.01527739129960537, -0.0008343317313119769, 0.0061133382841944695, -0.008876550011336803, -0.010101745836436749, 0.002606825903058052, 0.01160560455173254, -0.0006711991736665368, -0.009180481545627117, -0.029213212430477142, -0.03684738278388977, -0.020230643451213837, 0.034634463489055634, 0.02323080785572529, -0.020002836361527443, -0.02972494065761566, 0.016571542248129845, -0.0035222135484218597, -0.025471188127994537, 0.03220762312412262, -0.00299580255523324, 0.01683877967298031, 0.020121511071920395, 0.01650570146739483, -0.05011588707566261, -0.015625696629285812, 0.013855027966201305, -0.012750789523124695, -0.039762962609529495, -0.026521041989326477, 0.03462132811546326, 0.06635095179080963, 0.0003181045758537948, 0.0029398882761597633, -0.03367399051785469, -0.052675288170576096, -0.039837952703237534, -0.009155981242656708, 0.04734962806105614, -0.009960110299289227, 0.05670110136270523, 0.009706257842481136, -0.04061044007539749, -0.030344169586896896, -0.0516664944589138, -0.07802753150463104, 0.008087106049060822, 0.006110395770519972, 0.01362462155520916, -0.001097097177989781, -0.04386138543486595, 0.06682221591472626, 0.007935762405395508, -0.017100466415286064, -0.009128263220191002, -0.04034655913710594, 0.026569446548819542, -0.023812836036086082, 0.004371397662907839, 0.010414336808025837, -0.03971561789512634, 0.023478709161281586, 0.018178706988692284, 0.02176836133003235, 0.09055722504854202, -0.000639634090475738, -0.0050500244833528996, 0.034344736486673355, -0.015359582379460335, 0.005286890547722578, 0.009927719831466675, -0.021315984427928925, 0.003414245555177331, 0.029818492010235786, 0.01259081345051527, 0.000011101938980573323, 0.027317091822624207, -0.04749847576022148, 0.03971986845135689, -0.0006445575272664428, -0.019979866221547127, -0.026105597615242004, 0.049464598298072815, -0.022303305566310883, -0.03461886942386627, -0.011796788312494755, 0.03547525778412819, 0.004410856869071722, 0.013425490818917751, 0.020535094663500786, 0.02034764178097248, 0.023835400119423866, -0.00375869357958436, -0.017975395545363426, 0.009523308835923672, -0.003643664065748453, 0.014179267920553684, -0.045795269310474396, -0.0002806733245961368, 0.029221197590231895, 0.0375308096408844, 0.009332749992609024, -0.05320761352777481, -0.027489861473441124, 0.007718581706285477, -0.06818937510251999, -0.0033636651933193207, -0.013392685912549496, 0.0671972930431366, 0.010151800699532032, 0.014855130575597286, 0.001919493661262095, -0.03184840455651283, 0.07230036705732346, -0.0022563969250768423, -0.04049653559923172, 0.030704258009791374, 0.006020830944180489, 0.002987043233588338, -0.012366066686809063, 0.0022140792571008205, 0.027642592787742615, -0.00020664531621150672, 0.003871666267514229, -0.017352303490042686, 0.043077800422906876, -0.04804152622818947, 0.0010502167278900743, -0.005156971048563719, -0.0010273780208081007, -0.026195891201496124, 0.03367796540260315, 0.03751020133495331, -0.014188338071107864, 0.01680629886686802, 0.0527857169508934, 0.008452832698822021, -0.022210270166397095, -0.02571919746696949, -0.029300395399332047, 0.038748037070035934, 0.029246361926198006, 0.06114492565393448, 0.03271081671118736, -0.0023737505543977022, 0.02232593670487404, 0.023534270003437996, 0.02527078613638878, 0.041390251368284225, 0.024956118315458298, 0.005002536345273256, -0.06575851142406464, 0.005395924672484398, 0.009198648855090141, 0.040067531168460846, 0.029679538682103157, 0.012330803088843822, 0.0508907288312912, 0.03922203555703163, -0.02188546396791935, 0.00859108567237854, 0.04982949048280716, 0.01930886134505272, 0.004128410015255213, -0.0394122451543808, 0.007824859581887722, -0.013370322994887829, 0.01151262130588293, 0.030857114121317863, 0.0025996945332735777, -0.03122963383793831, -0.011088619939982891, 0.04091444984078407, 0.02795477770268917, 0.03070845454931259, -0.009460123255848885, 0.011144455522298813, 0.049386437982320786, 0.03044167533516884, -0.019534265622496605, 0.027452604845166206, 0.03297882154583931, 0.029810115694999695, 0.02216685749590397, 0.013099493458867073, -0.07551631331443787, -0.013684147968888283, -0.002780255628749728, 0.04999566078186035, -0.005492211785167456, 0.0070818099193274975, -0.03442998230457306, -0.023306844756007195, 0.07565225660800934, -0.015279714949429035, -0.000878222519531846, -0.013070781715214252, -0.004297720734030008, -0.003796153701841831, -0.011957066133618355, 0.004341452848166227, 0.0030203796923160553, 0.006574422586709261, 0.031667523086071014, -0.029830334708094597, 0.00540694035589695, -0.0315728522837162, -0.0034273697528988123, -0.014716997742652893, 0.057809021323919296, -0.027458498254418373, -0.007283498533070087, -0.015940705314278603, 0.04592963308095932, -0.0452803410589695, -0.044538043439388275, 0.014139165170490742, 0.013413828797638416, 0.007237917277961969, 0.03050346113741398, -0.010631728917360306, -0.01955546624958515, 0.02520766854286194, 0.005074767861515284, -0.024465732276439667, 0.007979188114404678, -0.03912951052188873, 0.042923830449581146, 0.03762863576412201, -0.008081197738647461, 0.1072462722659111, 0.03343570977449417, 0.017506809905171394, 0.016469551250338554, 0.013623298145830631, 0.018809672445058823, -0.038635432720184326, 0.004605312831699848, -0.028655214235186577, -0.012148234993219376, -0.011022058315575123, 0.03637637570500374, -0.0014281445182859898, 0.026677804067730904, -0.01003766804933548, -0.011249048635363579, 0.03281700983643532, 0.05534560605883598, -0.005795507226139307, -0.01903727278113365, -0.007403166498988867, 0.014007712714374065, 0.013389525935053825, -0.031061019748449326, -0.0008518442045897245, -0.01998305320739746, 0.019292213022708893, -0.016107045114040375, 0.010389319621026516, 0.0069625056348741055, -0.05815519019961357, -0.02974153868854046, 0.0017736386507749557, -0.021474868059158325, 0.02181788720190525, -0.003727247240021825, 0.009705770760774612, -0.019742218777537346, -0.03931095823645592, -0.002280814340338111, -0.04330950602889061, 0.01656831055879593, 0.017839232459664345, -0.06947916001081467, 0.057169537991285324, 0.0004552281752694398, -0.02512967772781849, -0.07283159345388412, -0.018860438838601112, 0.03470241650938988, -0.026710793375968933, -0.00318822986446321, -0.06107599288225174, 0.004960973281413317, -0.023862646892666817, -0.02275012992322445, -0.03446625545620918, 0.072783924639225, 0.04954138770699501, -0.0025829491205513477, 0.0012458066921681166, 0.004658881109207869, 0.01508983876556158, -0.004405552521348, 0.03409726917743683, 0.012617682106792927, -0.01942482404410839, -0.05012952908873558, -0.02819211781024933, 0.040173668414354324, -0.03458454832434654, 0.01893048919737339, 0.009234200231730938, -0.025574125349521637, -0.0020995254162698984, -0.03179711848497391, -0.04435258358716965, 0.0036459218244999647, 0.007049784529954195, -0.02289118804037571, -0.014396961778402328, -0.03462207689881325, -0.0026979579124599695, -0.0055467854253947735, -0.007327779661864042, -0.02150745689868927, -0.006331516895443201, -0.02092970907688141, -0.006790708750486374, -0.022951025515794754, -0.011813736520707607, -0.00900157168507576, 0.08719169348478317, 0.008803618140518665, -0.016573108732700348, 0.031848158687353134, -0.005608308129012585, 0.038663893938064575, -0.019658442586660385, -0.020661478862166405, 0.037635937333106995, -0.022885363548994064, -0.05968865752220154, -0.028613772243261337, -0.0467681847512722, 0.013009277172386646, 0.05610666796565056, -0.039154548197984695, 0.037462856620550156, 0.02262629009783268, 0.010822365991771221, 0.019898798316717148, 0.01181734073907137, 0.007861101068556309, 0.0009550905670039356, -0.018588028848171234, 0.024901418015360832, -0.020523913204669952, -0.04920685663819313, 0.01671096868813038, -0.006556923966854811, -0.001298171584494412, 0.04193665459752083, 0.0060162474401295185, -0.0010377907892689109, 0.011007861234247684, -0.026241810992360115, -0.03259957954287529, 0.008198458701372147, 0.008365136571228504, 0.01481472235172987, -0.016956789419054985, -0.05048674717545509, 0.07254066318273544, 0.008409185335040092, 0.00515906885266304, 0.018082717433571815, 0.013382362201809883, -0.040150806307792664, 0.028335990384221077, 0.02989042177796364, 0.005792895331978798, 0.04298924654722214, 0.01865537092089653, -0.0021872399374842644, -0.00825835857540369, 0.0020877360366284847, -0.04435946047306061, -0.041410207748413086, -0.014765980653464794, -0.03153597190976143, -0.04729392006993294, 0.06881216913461685, 0.010300393216311932, -0.004284007474780083, -0.002741004340350628, -0.020023571327328682, 0.013501527719199657, 0.006532335188239813, 0.01730218529701233, 0.002503402763977647, 0.09507985413074493, -0.009798428043723106, 0.005958615802228451, -0.007222410291433334, 0.0027219983749091625, 0.13401806354522705, 0.0545671172440052, 0.0014230910455808043, -0.10097962617874146, -0.03024999424815178, 0.018141619861125946, 0.0023589166812598705, -0.017669882625341415, 0.00508207269012928, 0.026126492768526077, -0.03801541030406952, 0.006305206101387739, 0.042224716395139694, -0.0051887910813093185, -0.02533331885933876, -0.0017385304672643542, -0.007255675736814737, -0.044344060122966766, 0.052554693073034286, 0.012743485160171986, -0.023162728175520897, -0.04332569241523743, -0.06857483834028244, 0.02362149953842163, -0.01942427270114422, 0.01800519973039627, -0.02787908911705017, -0.004202224314212799, -0.029193073511123657, -0.014661143533885479, -0.005882370751351118, -0.01103886403143406, 0.038095708936452866, -0.031813956797122955, -0.00864986889064312, 0.002975109964609146, 0.004989096894860268, -0.0011578175472095609, 0.03414766490459442, 0.044911473989486694, 0.030234092846512794, 0.002003246685490012, 0.031696632504463196, 0.023898418992757797, -0.008327662944793701, -0.049808599054813385, -0.012628286145627499, 0.04572239890694618, -0.00838211178779602, 0.002629664493724704, -0.015891386196017265, -0.002459688577800989, 0.010157771408557892, -0.060773469507694244, 0.00510743074119091, 0.019656067714095116, 0.06132432818412781, -0.025998622179031372, -0.0022373886313289404, -0.04866308346390724, 0.012362598441541195, -0.0055471742525696754, -0.02187124639749527, 0.01321488618850708, -0.023070110008120537, 0.008250015787780285, -0.01284275483340025, 0.06144886836409569, -0.00840994156897068, -0.006096318364143372, -0.03289952501654625, 0.011389950290322304, -0.027317063882946968, 0.00717823626473546, -0.0128978556022048, -0.009652310982346535, 0.04599713906645775, -0.01960248500108719, -0.032354068011045456, 0.004486611112952232, -0.045056186616420746, 0.044498976320028305, -0.01370425708591938, -0.031176473945379257, -0.02783104032278061, -0.009024912491440773, 0.03342273086309433, 0.02545749396085739, -0.0029330404940992594, 0.032359056174755096, -0.025920722633600235, 0.0449918657541275, 0.02656259387731552, -0.04006669670343399, -0.013260271400213242, -0.014795936644077301, 0.03072444535791874, -0.026495669037103653, -0.04275570809841156, 0.029429344460368156, 0.0026783866342157125, 0.02797173336148262, -0.03980584070086479, 0.027755532413721085, -0.03756563737988472, 0.0061293430626392365, -0.05033480003476143, -0.024020075798034668, 0.017567988485097885, 0.05465361475944519, 0.01594652608036995, -0.03560766950249672, 0.00039662508061155677, -0.04640420898795128, -0.006843269802629948, -0.020274227485060692, 0.023572558537125587, -0.05340898782014847, 0.01722494140267372, -0.05080059543251991, -0.006215893663465977, 0.00037407249328680336, 0.01815027929842472, -0.03221903368830681, -0.016260875388979912, -0.014064104296267033, 0.021600188687443733, -0.034719519317150116, -0.005324828438460827, -0.020148221403360367, -0.019663484767079353, 0.022593548521399498, 0.03860776498913765, 0.024774152785539627, -0.009275372140109539, 0.007728224620223045, -0.02636188082396984, 0.02136191725730896, -0.008225137367844582, -0.04959719255566597, 0.08506372570991516, -0.03494960814714432, -0.012078850530087948, 0.030800269916653633, 0.02547374740242958, 0.02153133414685726, 0.01639499142765999, 0.010844445787370205, -0.0381767600774765, 0.048607807606458664, -0.04491506144404411, -0.026041237637400627, 0.028137532994151115, -0.040993813425302505, -0.01839285157620907, -0.01357989851385355, 0.01716131716966629, 0.03783009573817253, 0.01356055773794651, -0.021141082048416138, 0.014955529943108559, -0.0036250471603125334, 0.007206419482827187, 0.029174523428082466, 0.004145992454141378, 0.030226098373532295, -0.007477335166186094, -0.021107763051986694, 0.020991690456867218, 0.06439419090747833, 0.0016808296786621213, 0.00645751366391778, -0.036317385733127594, -0.026963237673044205, -0.08468928188085556, 0.04525573179125786, 0.02734491229057312, 0.02379508502781391, 0.04359351471066475, -0.04790830984711647, 0.008511344902217388, 0.029624510556459427, 0.005115943029522896, -0.006837747525423765, -0.030341794714331627, -0.023523755371570587, 0.015511962585151196, -0.041614893823862076, -0.046444233506917953, 0.06172182783484459, 0.06181928515434265, 0.05070532485842705, 0.06543464213609695, -0.0017261177999898791, -0.028571294620633125, -0.030674060806632042, -0.00750738475471735, 0.015285048633813858, 0.007613836321979761, -0.0765727087855339, 0.041616909205913544, -0.02074599824845791, -0.030741317197680473, 0.022687789052724838, -0.005032379180192947, -0.022362876683473587, -0.030487023293972015, 0.005347950384020805, 0.02161593921482563, 0.024492790922522545, 0.03190010413527489, -0.01657126285135746, 0.02808108739554882, -0.0062044234946370125, 0.01667669415473938, -0.02538657933473587, -0.03158468380570412, 0.002869219286367297, 0.028396617621183395, 0.017492564395070076, -0.06876109540462494, 0.03668028861284256, 0.0037173551972955465, -0.045780327171087265, -0.031136857345700264, -0.043474119156599045, 0.03785812109708786, -0.04259711876511574, 0.00009259121725335717, -0.0009552758419886231, -0.018172824755311012, 0.04248278960585594, 0.008167116902768612, -0.06517476588487625, 0.014351950027048588, -0.008383160457015038, -0.07939928025007248, 0.021637264639139175, 0.04503743723034859, -0.05889301747083664, -0.037637557834386826, -0.043831437826156616, -0.005444628186523914, -0.0025443146005272865, -0.03927067667245865, 0.0021999699529260397, -0.0473124235868454, 0.02137046679854393, 0.0023985616862773895, 0.010799679905176163, 0.0011042776750400662, -0.019256997853517532, 0.006884553469717503, -0.040322184562683105, 0.07519233226776123, -0.030184591189026833, -0.06505629420280457, 0.004539125133305788, -0.020665166899561882, -0.021577225998044014, 0.004856678657233715, 0.046832069754600525, -0.010658727027475834, 0.004557623527944088, -0.002384547609835863, 0.03619951754808426, 0.021159103140234947, -0.06204590946435928, 0.010203986428678036, -0.013484186492860317, 0.01244310662150383, -0.01616101711988449, 0.029697945341467857, 0.006588289979845285, 0.01456958893686533, 0.0026563555002212524, 0.0034631029702723026, -0.0016555686015635729, -0.022460762411355972, -0.019216936081647873, 0.03061765432357788, 0.009382566437125206, 0.005368234124034643, 0.04089901223778725, -0.014202883467078209, -0.00300711952149868, 0.0314117893576622, -0.013662130571901798, -0.05228501930832863, -0.002070636721327901, -0.018095122650265694, -0.03211390599608421, -0.012155096977949142, 0.009682876989245415, -0.022159168496727943, -0.04801128804683685, -0.03106808476150036, 0.05037609115242958, -0.006740547250956297, -0.021914854645729065, 0.04669192433357239, 0.04211217164993286, 0.0448303259909153, 0.05104838311672211, 0.010526088997721672, 0.024715324863791466, 0.016325484961271286, -0.00832713209092617, 0.01639603078365326, 0.00769667187705636, -0.052513882517814636, 0.02932998165488243, -0.006803180556744337, -0.0394337996840477, 0.01747976616024971, -0.008603504858911037, -0.0008838062058202922, -0.027738917618989944, -0.04758797958493233, 0.010714396834373474, -0.012820247560739517, 0.02495081163942814, 0.008655195124447346, -0.029302211478352547, 0.05239969491958618, -0.03323761373758316, 0.016595838591456413, 0.03117338754236698, 0.007041087839752436, -0.005330689717084169, 0.014110403135418892, 0.015570207498967648, 0.012419582344591618, -0.021828100085258484, 0.0036072703078389168, 0.00566247059032321, 0.004651462659239769, 0.03687465563416481, -0.04765701666474342, -0.0027744590770453215, 0.016080236062407494, -0.02897343412041664, -0.014999550767242908, -0.006956529337912798, -0.03233576938509941, -0.04033416137099266, -0.0009856026154011488, 0.07360047847032547, 0.018219508230686188, 0.030795086175203323, 0.019357558339834213, 0.017173532396554947, 0.04757154360413551, -0.0831955224275589, 0.013036629185080528, -0.039367783814668655, -0.005540821235626936, -0.028130149468779564, -0.005934389308094978 ]
<p>When doing a paired t-test, is it appropriate to use the paired t value to calculate $\eta^2$?<br> I ask because it is not appropriate to calculate Cohen's d based on the paired t value.</p> <p>Thanks.</p>
73,546
[ -0.008813584223389626, -0.011695455759763718, -0.008428743109107018, 0.008449053391814232, 0.028995418921113014, 0.002722953911870718, -0.004438492003828287, -0.01431973185390234, 0.012144973501563072, -0.01532330084592104, 0.024604570120573044, 0.0034800260327756405, 0.036648694425821304, 0.008247644640505314, 0.004760390613228083, 0.011816735379397869, -0.06184462085366249, -0.022058973088860512, -0.008412059396505356, -0.009668058715760708, 0.011260648258030415, 0.026809804141521454, -0.012640184722840786, -0.005306952632963657, -0.038624491542577744, 0.0747838094830513, 0.019166162237524986, -0.028966907411813736, -0.030179675668478012, 0.048934612423181534, -0.06130040064454079, -0.014745110645890236, 0.057727545499801636, 0.0243216585367918, 0.009144795127213001, 0.003730391152203083, -0.021464230492711067, -0.018231140449643135, -0.02345549874007702, 0.02984302118420601, 0.00978395901620388, -0.04258131980895996, 0.0008731467532925308, 0.044247936457395554, 0.010697335004806519, 0.03937353193759918, -0.024723615497350693, -0.03798341378569603, 0.0073799556121230125, -0.05984072759747505, 0.05850802734494209, 0.023319341242313385, 0.028378581628203392, 0.005327691789716482, -0.018764333799481392, -0.01430045161396265, 0.028467988595366478, 0.041476838290691376, -0.008723189122974873, -0.04308599233627319, 0.00021986555657349527, -0.058406803756952286, 0.023185942322015762, -0.011867102235555649, -0.032176848500967026, 0.02094954252243042, 0.024779777973890305, -0.0001065614924300462, -0.01723264716565609, -0.04788273200392723, 0.02285333350300789, 0.013999666087329388, 0.04989467188715935, -0.01458753552287817, 0.022420860826969147, 0.006236848887056112, 0.03965822234749794, 0.03110925853252411, 0.06443876773118973, 0.02445848472416401, 0.024059731513261795, -0.013631877489387989, 0.048982564359903336, 0.05507408455014229, 0.010412496514618397, -0.007200377993285656, 0.03352456912398338, -0.020907629281282425, -0.015768129378557205, 0.03462585434317589, -0.009925572201609612, 0.017333410680294037, 0.03341863676905632, -0.016279306262731552, -0.0020796945318579674, 0.026033299043774605, -0.03909764438867569, 0.03978162631392479, -0.01929306983947754, -0.02309020422399044, -0.015611507929861546, -0.05105718597769737, 0.016961345449090004, 0.04384571313858032, 0.004976304713636637, 0.0037711174227297306, -0.024438587948679924, 0.017534246668219566, 0.00480865640565753, -0.0321444608271122, -0.05050668865442276, 0.026028476655483246, -0.0299244187772274, 0.0055086808279156685, 0.03633001074194908, 0.0017809593118727207, -0.02248215116560459, -0.0172015018761158, 0.042794812470674515, 0.06415601074695587, 0.04325837641954422, -0.021403498947620392, 0.00046968553215265274, -0.008228427730500698, -0.04264085367321968, 0.0625251978635788, 0.028415324166417122, -0.026039719581604004, -0.019292213022708893, 0.048152294009923935, 0.004185972735285759, 0.010064524598419666, 0.01701131835579872, 0.021826794371008873, -0.0009866058826446533, 0.006574238184839487, -0.05736608803272247, -0.04517305642366409, 0.02454245090484619, -0.016700513660907745, -0.008905029855668545, -0.09263086318969727, -0.032125260680913925, 0.021084722131490707, 0.042344849556684494, 0.0012194813461974263, 0.06146018207073212, 0.008294220082461834, 0.0373578704893589, 0.014268339611589909, -0.07050462067127228, -0.039981793612241745, -0.018414871767163277, -0.04859578236937523, -0.011435833759605885, -0.05102581903338432, 0.0010848782258108258, 0.009087092243134975, 0.01466204971075058, 0.002936320146545768, 0.03564833104610443, -0.028377175331115723, -0.04126719385385513, 0.03313382342457771, 0.0066249780356884, -0.042760446667671204, 0.06667374819517136, 0.026221977546811104, 0.07304088026285172, -0.026526007801294327, -0.003770796349272132, 0.04527859017252922, 0.02237524278461933, 0.02286369353532791, 0.05838792398571968, -0.017712442204356194, -0.014704649336636066, -0.015800826251506805, 0.04111003503203392, 0.009263397194445133, -0.03536318615078926, -0.02259683609008789, -0.03446497023105621, 0.018588395789265633, -0.033508650958538055, 0.05193634703755379, -0.00915863923728466, 0.011808433569967747, 0.06530579924583435, -0.04655568301677704, -0.06256807595491409, -0.05047966539859772, -0.002433658577501774, 0.01816435717046261, -0.018937693908810616, -0.016789741814136505, -0.021541360765695572, 0.0406457856297493, -0.0032466391567140818, -0.01072018314152956, -0.013230285607278347, 0.0173936914652586, 0.019525453448295593, -0.04329659044742584, 0.04319709166884422, 0.06563571840524673, 0.05384006351232529, 0.013529175892472267, 0.03866971656680107, -0.04818525165319443, -0.021210743114352226, 0.007759030908346176, -0.02867956832051277, 0.03829945996403694, -0.01856790855526924, -0.039159614592790604, 0.006278324406594038, 0.010696322657167912, -0.03136272728443146, 0.04570675641298294, -0.06776008009910583, 0.07016659528017044, 0.050940465182065964, 0.03023015521466732, -0.002223758725449443, -0.00928508024662733, 0.0337006039917469, 0.00675181532278657, -0.013745595701038837, -0.0013094886671751738, -0.034744154661893845, -0.0017942904960364103, 0.03714166209101677, 0.028762705624103546, -0.041995901614427567, 0.012446300126612186, 0.028291797265410423, 0.015329767018556595, -0.028944367542862892, 0.008946060203015804, 0.01633329875767231, -0.048475176095962524, -0.0027066257316619158, 0.028375091031193733, 0.0008736987947486341, 0.0001697572151897475, 0.028545543551445007, -0.011748597025871277, 0.029438044875860214, 0.006041038315743208, -0.009584400802850723, 0.028069814667105675, -0.0387498177587986, -0.009496609680354595, 0.001230495166964829, -0.01527104526758194, 0.0554058700799942, -0.04358014091849327, 0.00443523284047842, 0.03614223748445511, 0.009647886268794537, -0.01654847338795662, 0.004862272180616856, -0.03815319389104843, 0.029702190309762955, 0.01484219916164875, -0.0374898836016655, -0.002889528637751937, 0.032437968999147415, -0.05670905485749245, -0.0008828400168567896, 0.0022342100273817778, -0.029749996960163116, -0.005815515294671059, -0.002219045301899314, 0.011489655822515488, -0.02145157940685749, 0.006940319202840328, -0.00102909654378891, -0.010762656107544899, -0.01798592507839203, -0.017653340473771095, -0.02090420201420784, -0.010853630490601063, -0.08222834020853043, 0.011863384395837784, -0.033594224601984024, -0.0016314616659656167, 0.026895100250840187, -0.015552005730569363, -0.0036093334201723337, 0.007298261858522892, -0.0053315856494009495, -0.014463648200035095, -0.04033653810620308, -0.004562835209071636, -0.005052426364272833, -0.03472407907247543, 0.010381064377725124, 0.028848670423030853, 0.018716633319854736, -0.03293449431657791, 0.010214915499091148, -0.04611187428236008, -0.030321210622787476, 0.015524045564234257, -0.0054137432016432285, 0.012723037973046303, -0.02830735594034195, 0.0012470176443457603, 0.008861160837113857, -0.04534483328461647, -0.025325501337647438, -0.07868004590272903, -0.05972781404852867, 0.051698893308639526, 0.008028486743569374, 0.029532305896282196, 0.01608467288315296, -0.0686010792851448, 0.09151371568441391, 0.01956392265856266, -0.04765346646308899, -0.005858531221747398, -0.03338474780321121, -0.01965818740427494, -0.03651755303144455, 0.012416079640388489, 0.0022671304177492857, 0.001483613857999444, 0.008850771002471447, -0.011039955541491508, 0.018352750688791275, 0.05437570810317993, 0.002168514532968402, -0.017191685736179352, 0.016534462571144104, 0.06295410543680191, -0.025709956884384155, 0.02557552419602871, -0.004583131987601519, -0.012904868461191654, -0.005538661498576403, 0.009100433439016342, 0.022296585142612457, -0.0027793145272880793, -0.013984637334942818, 0.030611690133810043, -0.050171852111816406, -0.0038031332660466433, 0.01542733982205391, 0.06242191419005394, 0.035368092358112335, -0.007213063538074493, -0.015343091450631618, 0.024279039353132248, 0.01045258715748787, -0.03664273023605347, 0.01876320131123066, 0.06557963043451309, 0.015456601046025753, 0.043719641864299774, -0.03168727084994316, 0.02079910971224308, 0.00677602319046855, 0.03422105312347412, -0.04337364062666893, -0.022224724292755127, 0.02963307872414589, 0.03826504573225975, 0.04135695472359657, 0.017120929434895515, -0.030674811452627182, 0.011484974063932896, -0.06031426042318344, 0.023895153775811195, -0.05237683281302452, 0.05351918190717697, 0.027196627110242844, 0.03908887133002281, 0.016100997105240822, -0.009829957038164139, -0.006422079633921385, -0.003544311737641692, -0.027289552614092827, -0.025057539343833923, 0.00023452665482182056, -0.04449153691530228, 0.04932137578725815, -0.027392035350203514, 0.045733749866485596, 0.0035392821300774813, 0.030156850814819336, -0.02664392627775669, 0.030071847140789032, -0.03555840626358986, 0.03461093455553055, -0.02686365693807602, -0.008949889801442623, -0.03138104826211929, 0.055795423686504364, 0.02838469296693802, -0.03005922958254814, 0.004422405268996954, 0.05792747437953949, -0.016335250809788704, 0.0029501384124159813, -0.026501139625906944, 0.04190031439065933, 0.01794498972594738, 0.02156653441488743, 0.02565775066614151, 0.04039010405540466, -0.04197845607995987, 0.014040987938642502, -0.015361536294221878, 0.03789211064577103, 0.017247339710593224, -0.018736859783530235, -0.028532903641462326, -0.00935328844934702, -0.04700804501771927, -0.024755934253335, 0.062264811247587204, -0.0061408658511936665, -0.005298303905874491, 0.05841830372810364, 0.027983861044049263, -0.004217015113681555, 0.030170578509569168, 0.039542559534311295, 0.042030900716781616, -0.03969111293554306, -0.02485475316643715, -0.0018351988401263952, -0.0215506199747324, -0.027212640270590782, 0.016334958374500275, 0.044453155249357224, -0.016785409301519394, -0.0002319098566658795, 0.02587173879146576, 0.0012690610019490123, -0.029037263244390488, 0.0232058297842741, 0.027393462136387825, 0.002405346604064107, 0.03143872693181038, -0.02537168189883232, 0.022485747933387756, 0.040160171687603, 0.012734348885715008, 0.028713436797261238, 0.037158846855163574, -0.0748162493109703, -0.01235935091972351, 0.02452775649726391, 0.050915662199258804, -0.03820021077990532, -0.022739242762327194, -0.015124441124498844, 0.015969829633831978, 0.01986841857433319, -0.027883363887667656, 0.017821496352553368, -0.014064074493944645, -0.004554627928882837, -0.020260227844119072, 0.0015412661014124751, -0.01833021268248558, 0.034830596297979355, 0.013485443778336048, 0.019537191838026047, -0.011286385357379913, -0.014285614714026451, -0.014823265373706818, -0.010827018879354, -0.01629614643752575, 0.05856587737798691, 0.0075307744555175304, -0.026063885539770126, 0.005466630682349205, 0.024623306468129158, -0.030693940818309784, -0.022119522094726562, 0.026064667850732803, 0.0032732177060097456, 0.016083326190710068, 0.040600620210170746, -0.02700420841574669, -0.03529932349920273, 0.027968432754278183, 0.019625019282102585, -0.026691945269703865, 0.012034193612635136, -0.0003233094175811857, 0.030875220894813538, 0.06270434707403183, 0.003301540855318308, 0.10753336548805237, 0.05909270420670509, 0.0009480140870437026, -0.02553524076938629, -0.03424547240138054, 0.032046958804130554, -0.038790736347436905, 0.01743389666080475, -0.018291959539055824, -0.01933535747230053, -0.0339343398809433, 0.007832006551325321, -0.027771763503551483, 0.040930621325969696, -0.014915167354047298, -0.01919327676296234, 0.003086411627009511, 0.03181754797697067, 0.01320674642920494, 0.014132863841950893, 0.011937158182263374, 0.0262009147554636, -0.007340421434491873, 0.005620485171675682, 0.017618389800190926, -0.0454990491271019, 0.016160666942596436, -0.007271253038197756, -0.01981784589588642, 0.041152581572532654, -0.0399835929274559, -0.028621582314372063, -0.00881841592490673, -0.03674217313528061, 0.017888948321342468, -0.03199322149157524, -0.03219248726963997, -0.00995023176074028, -0.03865278884768486, -0.02216447703540325, 0.03671187162399292, 0.0452171228826046, 0.05634041503071785, -0.05402905493974686, 0.06083068251609802, -0.02849535644054413, -0.006992453709244728, -0.0428745299577713, -0.003192522330209613, 0.03052198328077793, 0.001454750308766961, -0.009263981133699417, -0.0038378729950636625, 0.018886517733335495, -0.04489462822675705, -0.013089033775031567, -0.021836012601852417, 0.06281332671642303, 0.02717146836221218, -0.02059854380786419, -0.03175116702914238, 0.003082938026636839, 0.046722009778022766, 0.010325316339731216, 0.006420384161174297, 0.007775671314448118, 0.02394934557378292, -0.013329289853572845, 0.006171947345137596, 0.013857564888894558, -0.05650400370359421, 0.005399713758379221, -0.029604816809296608, -0.017140522599220276, 0.04401548206806183, 0.00019694257935043424, -0.050148315727710724, 0.005100250709801912, -0.009257310070097446, -0.012337623164057732, -0.023806201294064522, -0.01495642401278019, -0.005659922957420349, 0.014539288356900215, -0.017402147874236107, -0.0011032016482204199, 0.011293628253042698, -0.00010765320621430874, -0.02526877261698246, 0.00810544565320015, -0.036006584763526917, -0.00515593821182847, 0.04948566481471062, 0.007416095584630966, -0.020753487944602966, -0.0258655808866024, -0.02656278759241104, 0.0022762941662222147, 0.005402994342148304, -0.03168795257806778, 0.01910662278532982, 0.045381005853414536, -0.05535278469324112, -0.019787805154919624, -0.0033678582403808832, -0.007902773097157478, 0.07465332001447678, -0.045540645718574524, 0.04264706373214722, 0.03788347914814949, -0.008066115900874138, 0.008740195073187351, -0.026166822761297226, -0.013129373081028461, -0.0413280725479126, 0.02309013344347477, 0.0005614885012619197, -0.009154453873634338, -0.012913682498037815, 0.039797842502593994, 0.0243590846657753, -0.021241815760731697, 0.028348110616207123, 0.03728625178337097, -0.01684824377298355, 0.0013492690632119775, -0.0322960689663887, -0.040115583688020706, 0.01240018755197525, -0.06218359246850014, 0.0006720087840221822, -0.039599739015102386, -0.029096806421875954, 0.06426715105772018, 0.03300714120268822, 0.007901394739747047, -0.04285862669348717, -0.008804102428257465, -0.03881216421723366, 0.0010347667848691344, 0.01059383898973465, -0.005405673291534185, 0.024275070056319237, 0.0056446571834385395, 0.0316549688577652, 0.010317765176296234, 0.012470763176679611, -0.02322385460138321, -0.060154154896736145, -0.013303238898515701, 0.016026891767978668, -0.028814872726798058, 0.014378582127392292, -0.03198122978210449, -0.01570778526365757, 0.008932379074394703, -0.04306904599070549, 0.04022318869829178, -0.032419368624687195, 0.05028953403234482, -0.055743373930454254, 0.08513151109218597, -0.014054762199521065, 0.02009858563542366, 0.0000472851752419956, -0.026938321068882942, 0.12326393276453018, 0.05327973887324333, 0.02088005468249321, -0.08049999922513962, 0.02163863554596901, -0.025999808683991432, -0.008157243020832539, -0.03474881872534752, 0.0016137035563588142, 0.024343598634004593, -0.02035335823893547, 0.031124478206038475, 0.08230327814817429, 0.02541317418217659, -0.02627253346145153, 0.056538183242082596, -0.025374244898557663, -0.05140772461891174, 0.005588626489043236, 0.04299221560359001, -0.0009066432830877602, -0.038721147924661636, 0.018038753420114517, 0.0037094277795404196, -0.016069741919636726, 0.02778513915836811, 0.004237513989210129, 0.0000843714879010804, -0.03270215913653374, 0.03712907433509827, -0.04143040254712105, -0.010828313417732716, 0.03129640221595764, 0.010270587168633938, -0.06856291741132736, 0.00328896869905293, -0.012472566217184067, -0.0006409542984329164, 0.021647972986102104, 0.042752403765916824, -0.02023073472082615, 0.018235664814710617, 0.029062269255518913, 0.021222149953246117, -0.04480985552072525, -0.026841556653380394, -0.015132617205381393, 0.053907494992017746, -0.0034538169857114553, -0.015332184731960297, 0.001604523858986795, -0.02825271338224411, 0.015239055268466473, -0.04213271662592888, -0.01645767316222191, 0.038157638162374496, -0.01234873291105032, -0.026675067842006683, -0.003856142982840538, -0.03738373890519142, 0.020180627703666687, -0.0022648971062153578, 0.023577360436320305, 0.011808834038674831, -0.019507305696606636, 0.0013310917420312762, -0.009885353036224842, 0.03639480471611023, 0.02409125119447708, -0.007693171966820955, -0.01881476119160652, -0.0071739694103598595, -0.05749328061938286, -0.00820067897439003, 0.0031291393097490072, 0.02596564032137394, 0.04309316724538803, -0.01729126274585724, -0.008108671754598618, -0.01786665990948677, -0.04009335860610008, 0.040994636714458466, -0.02591952495276928, -0.022954517975449562, -0.08085635304450989, -0.00003655612454167567, 0.017260955646634102, 0.0175547543913126, -0.020374447107315063, 0.018331928178668022, 0.001980637200176716, 0.06800977885723114, 0.016349947080016136, -0.053744327276945114, -0.02772192656993866, 0.0016596452333033085, -0.03506509214639664, -0.03361612930893898, 0.0029044661205261946, -0.0010553337633609772, 0.02791518345475197, 0.06200241297483444, -0.03317534178495407, 0.015250034630298615, 0.03316879644989967, 0.016042370349168777, -0.02229500003159046, -0.0498468391597271, -0.006187241990119219, 0.021984731778502464, 0.005517748650163412, -0.019458945840597153, 0.0019578570500016212, -0.05405999720096588, -0.023736948147416115, 0.026772044599056244, -0.01517416164278984, -0.028316210955381393, -0.01823323965072632, -0.048342134803533554, 0.013655639253556728, -0.02268114499747753, 0.016222046688199043, -0.015114693902432919, -0.007187227252870798, -0.017027249559760094, 0.015678882598876953, -0.004171088337898254, 0.04169691726565361, -0.014225427061319351, 0.0341019406914711, 0.09467083215713501, -0.018076814711093903, 0.002754364162683487, 0.010154820047318935, -0.0067405980080366135, 0.00894610770046711, 0.05281277000904083, -0.005265096202492714, -0.029139908030629158, 0.04435940831899643, -0.032936375588178635, -0.007178947329521179, 0.014748656190931797, 0.01962810382246971, 0.012884015217423439, 0.016672978177666664, 0.01361775305122137, -0.01775970496237278, 0.02096143178641796, -0.061741508543491364, -0.03016914241015911, 0.027521872892975807, -0.036654431372880936, 0.010022128000855446, -0.009884340688586235, -0.014324956573545933, 0.040953099727630615, 0.02986382693052292, -0.006210672669112682, 0.023171933367848396, 0.022353291511535645, 0.0324762761592865, -0.015808019787073135, 0.006474332883954048, 0.02534482441842556, 0.04098944365978241, -0.010953117161989212, -0.004699693992733955, 0.06646440923213959, 0.022784464061260223, -0.017186034470796585, 0.007742006331682205, -0.024164512753486633, -0.11361996829509735, -0.02334783226251602, 0.028137942776083946, 0.013876194134354591, 0.028290124610066414, -0.0402555949985981, 0.022305648773908615, 0.015482231043279171, -0.05103983357548714, 0.05091254785656929, -0.009980406612157822, -0.04105880483984947, -0.0387054905295372, -0.010937720537185669, -0.0028274995274841785, 0.021532166749238968, 0.014532377943396568, 0.030518561601638794, 0.04107830673456192, -0.010455862618982792, -0.005917988717556, -0.017185749486088753, -0.005098963622003794, 0.007550274021923542, -0.0057439557276666164, -0.06267424672842026, 0.02243816666305065, -0.02092079445719719, -0.05133599415421486, 0.02320088818669319, 0.004302737303078175, 0.022916633635759354, -0.01343388482928276, 0.03770624101161957, 0.028200507164001465, 0.031956467777490616, 0.06040899083018303, -0.014186758548021317, -0.039310358464717865, 0.0001938144414452836, -0.02056405320763588, 0.00398182962089777, -0.0375303290784359, 0.024180196225643158, 0.024318285286426544, -0.00513064069673419, -0.038933880627155304, 0.048040926456451416, -0.04495435208082199, -0.03295047581195831, -0.022589003667235374, -0.006903171073645353, 0.007799135986715555, -0.021122246980667114, 0.020974384620785713, -0.03815999999642372, 0.001307474565692246, 0.04181581363081932, 0.00013174008927308023, -0.008410423994064331, 0.02949358895421028, -0.027196887880563736, -0.06681155413389206, 0.0443769209086895, 0.0199583787471056, -0.00359313003718853, -0.0673750713467598, -0.02272529900074005, -0.006682033650577068, -0.009736333042383194, -0.02811516262590885, -0.022166771814227104, -0.0313897542655468, 0.04295561462640762, 0.010747984983026981, 0.024493001401424408, 0.008411192335188389, -0.013699119910597801, 0.012076320126652718, -0.04419390484690666, 0.04123268276453018, -0.016137219965457916, -0.03353947401046753, -0.02409731037914753, 0.04671282693743706, -0.03254672512412071, 0.003986447583884001, 0.057734981179237366, 0.03777065873146057, 0.03527696058154106, 0.010283656418323517, 0.04049712419509888, 0.00683180196210742, -0.051974520087242126, -0.009147068485617638, -0.004827096126973629, 0.023068835958838463, -0.038118138909339905, 0.0053435321897268295, -0.0027710061985999346, 0.020619235932826996, 0.02272852137684822, -0.019715694710612297, 0.06539972871541977, 0.011696616187691689, 0.007521273568272591, 0.054478250443935394, 0.02234276942908764, -0.002940064063295722, 0.0623338408768177, 0.019814755767583847, 0.030102882534265518, 0.01587754301726818, -0.02472115308046341, -0.058836113661527634, 0.04245343804359436, -0.03958026319742203, -0.03171603009104729, 0.026977811008691788, 0.015330221503973007, -0.03801918774843216, -0.02927154302597046, 0.02069331519305706, 0.05623241513967514, -0.010838810354471207, 0.0170755535364151, 0.025854427367448807, 0.05750695988535881, 0.009286669082939625, -0.018579751253128052, 0.03235073760151863, 0.04003112390637398, -0.01945161633193493, 0.0385669507086277, 0.014331002719700336, 0.0188007690012455, 0.0019460038747638464, -0.0018219829071313143, -0.0012793843634426594, -0.05084148049354553, -0.005221426486968994, -0.0009195894235745072, 0.009286434389650822, 0.002181034768000245, -0.03733289614319801, 0.0061532920226454735, -0.0010183214908465743, 0.051535625010728836, -0.0007393629057332873, -0.016559390351176262, 0.08760412782430649, -0.04028023034334183, 0.0027372906915843487, -0.021680761128664017, -0.010394583456218243, -0.03441895917057991, 0.02916811779141426, 0.044149238616228104, 0.012267968617379665, -0.02289513312280178, -0.01894701085984707, 0.008382007479667664, -0.02042442187666893, -0.029711635783314705, -0.031099455431103706, -0.013279319740831852, -0.002157558687031269, 0.007952837273478508, -0.03052208200097084, -0.02568850852549076, -0.01750752702355385, -0.051021821796894073, 0.0100469458848238, 0.006453042849898338, 0.013195158913731575, -0.03017636016011238, -0.01782187819480896, 0.02579004317522049, 0.04740118607878685, -0.08129850029945374, -0.01772439479827881, -0.04147280380129814, -0.0028773637022823095, -0.0053059738129377365, -0.03430252522230148 ]
<p>SPSS uses the Levene test to evaluate homogeneity of variances in the independent group t-test procedure. </p> <p>Why is the Levene test better than a simple F ratio of the ratio of the variances of the two groups?</p>
73,547
[ -0.03464299812912941, -0.0022070950362831354, 0.01789942942559719, -0.003944189287722111, 0.042112670838832855, 0.0028447918593883514, 0.016428792849183083, -0.022824283689260483, 0.017477795481681824, 0.00024576944997534156, 0.03302498161792755, 0.05581757053732872, -0.005491525866091251, 0.04600115865468979, -0.018756741657853127, -0.013515827246010303, -0.019270960241556168, 0.009558921679854393, -0.03364884853363037, 0.020087875425815582, -0.038121357560157776, 0.0004704032326117158, -0.006350142881274223, -0.04582606256008148, -0.012217716313898563, 0.002353588119149208, 0.013434053398668766, -0.012391578406095505, 0.061571646481752396, 0.05607083439826965, -0.03388163819909096, 0.008698003366589546, -0.0011415985645726323, 0.018168263137340546, 0.013573933392763138, -0.020594235509634018, 0.020652825012803078, 0.014860912226140499, -0.0017426060512661934, 0.055474258959293365, -0.028744209557771683, -0.007771453354507685, -0.010333185084164143, 0.059476401656866074, -0.005214657634496689, 0.06190779060125351, -0.025787774473428726, -0.028094718232750893, -0.0029991036280989647, -0.022236831486225128, 0.03906702250242233, -0.002668867353349924, 0.008813662454485893, -0.009040364995598793, 0.01426393911242485, 0.01620846800506115, 0.029115889221429825, 0.06128295511007309, -0.011914270929992199, -0.030842961743474007, -0.015189043246209621, -0.034857507795095444, 0.008624186739325523, -0.014960281550884247, -0.012407730333507061, 0.019696295261383057, -0.015314389951527119, -0.019770827144384384, 0.051578912883996964, 0.0027383225969970226, 0.025807423517107964, 0.02004786767065525, 0.027837248519062996, -0.014581163413822651, -0.009129753336310387, -0.015060718171298504, 0.023414652794599533, 0.011887140572071075, 0.02646244876086712, 0.048545219004154205, 0.042847488075494766, 0.00024201074847951531, 0.02193649858236313, 0.017254697158932686, 0.04282864183187485, -0.028895080089569092, 0.05018977075815201, 0.003983133006840944, -0.002732321619987488, 0.025137554854154587, -0.01846087910234928, 0.028720621019601822, 0.05411969870328903, 0.005527033936232328, -0.047766100615262985, 0.027286935597658157, -0.03850603103637695, 0.005768024828284979, 0.0029953112825751305, 0.002156274626031518, -0.02739526517689228, -0.05808305740356445, 0.06074099615216255, 0.04873199760913849, 0.001612536609172821, -0.01739850454032421, -0.030154738575220108, -0.0302822757512331, -0.002802828326821327, -0.02091418392956257, 0.015373497270047665, -0.0008170971996150911, -0.0012468131026253104, 0.007663764525204897, 0.011927937157452106, -0.017750535160303116, -0.006849654950201511, -0.03827160969376564, 0.03073347546160221, 0.05465511605143547, 0.05043797567486763, 0.010299654677510262, 0.01629062555730343, 0.029499804601073265, -0.024488631635904312, 0.04933692514896393, 0.005893218331038952, -0.003126189112663269, -0.05730681121349335, 0.08496532589197159, 0.004180384799838066, 0.0026897599454969168, 0.005244397558271885, 0.002185957971960306, 0.010537172667682171, 0.025569453835487366, -0.08822929114103317, -0.08344855159521103, 0.0402463898062706, 0.002035701647400856, -0.000192163948668167, -0.08832218497991562, -0.022079648450016975, 0.008802811615169048, 0.05841321498155594, -0.020260047167539597, 0.044091999530792236, 0.009617957286536694, 0.011410295031964779, 0.00038008426781743765, -0.050993796437978745, -0.025545431300997734, -0.0011692083207890391, -0.06752055883407593, 0.018028035759925842, -0.07603321224451065, -0.025215884670615196, 0.026940742507576942, -0.026749595999717712, 0.034925904124975204, 0.0016756881959736347, 0.014643163420259953, -0.000041642135329311714, -0.012677703984081745, -0.0010402575135231018, 0.010825213976204395, 0.011719787493348122, -0.00293808919377625, 0.04771720990538597, 0.030184876173734665, 0.0014268317027017474, 0.045763030648231506, 0.02440866082906723, 0.05868605896830559, -0.029652690514922142, -0.01009982917457819, -0.013180546462535858, 0.023821568116545677, 0.004410513211041689, 0.030994998291134834, -0.07391317188739777, 0.03129510581493378, -0.010003475472331047, 0.05208133906126022, 0.007560585159808397, 0.027676917612552643, 0.007914431393146515, 0.027289416640996933, 0.04212659224867821, -0.04241311550140381, -0.08420423418283463, -0.06079735606908798, 0.019303223118185997, -0.0013018783647567034, -0.054635729640722275, 0.03517243266105652, 0.02055555209517479, 0.01785389892756939, -0.006927174050360918, -0.02725999988615513, -0.03629504516720772, 0.017308257520198822, 0.05702357366681099, -0.05810509994626045, 0.06802837550640106, 0.06084594875574112, 0.03565576300024986, -0.0415368489921093, 0.01504473201930523, -0.01671040616929531, -0.03449619188904762, 0.05051072686910629, -0.03533242270350456, 0.02742641419172287, 0.022150125354528427, -0.02251945622265339, -0.008731408044695854, 0.03054535575211048, -0.040445562452077866, 0.06437020003795624, -0.044686052948236465, 0.07415547221899033, 0.052949126809835434, -0.0062088510021567345, -0.0023798923939466476, -0.03455355390906334, -0.005318937357515097, -0.021489398553967476, -0.015849923714995384, -0.004189333878457546, -0.06649746745824814, -0.014451446942985058, 0.011215295642614365, -0.006320545915514231, -0.039319977164268494, -0.0014348954427987337, 0.03389411047101021, 0.01840369962155819, -0.014254634268581867, 0.025782763957977295, -0.04485516622662544, -0.062388014048337936, 0.026563307270407677, 0.025694606825709343, 0.038454484194517136, 0.01047583669424057, -0.0016356917330995202, 0.05054599046707153, 0.04672038555145264, 0.03166937083005905, 0.009783354587852955, 0.05519238859415054, 0.0069923498667776585, 0.009476516395807266, 0.022028537467122078, -0.04469025135040283, 0.014340153895318508, -0.025447478517889977, -0.015355468727648258, 0.023633543401956558, -0.0019447557860985398, 0.0026990962214767933, -0.006626715883612633, -0.035324640572071075, 0.039623361080884933, 0.002168892417103052, -0.02855801023542881, 0.019773345440626144, 0.040676720440387726, -0.03662627935409546, 0.006962484680116177, -0.03432192653417587, -0.016185590997338295, -0.06780354678630829, -0.008206913247704506, 0.01941181719303131, -0.02047044411301613, 0.00003986048250226304, -0.02448832243680954, 0.03008214943110943, 0.018160490319132805, 0.012472369708120823, 0.007055382709950209, -0.023558687418699265, -0.03786901757121086, 0.004048099275678396, 0.007048984989523888, 0.008013585582375526, 0.01658478192985058, 0.018819773569703102, -0.02338670752942562, 0.017837129533290863, 0.0338098406791687, -0.02294827625155449, -0.0120153296738863, -0.024615032598376274, -0.00431278720498085, 0.016001274809241295, -0.028096958994865417, 0.006561288144439459, -0.013788202777504921, -0.0213740523904562, 0.06976928561925888, -0.051616933196783066, 0.0042726220563054085, -0.007763756439089775, 0.015297535806894302, -0.0073906718753278255, 0.011547955684363842, 0.006352898199111223, -0.01953486166894436, -0.040619537234306335, -0.03514837101101875, -0.06045174598693848, -0.06390094757080078, 0.02134212851524353, 0.021202050149440765, 0.052972130477428436, -0.01247958280146122, -0.04109232500195503, 0.08001650869846344, 0.02804614044725895, -0.013791505247354507, -0.06585105508565903, -0.0337967611849308, -0.033290840685367584, -0.00569126708433032, 0.032384585589170456, 0.017532452940940857, 0.022786984220147133, 0.011879547499120235, -0.000005866146238986403, 0.043451398611068726, 0.05391913279891014, -0.006545784883201122, -0.0287780724465847, -0.007777710910886526, -0.011192349717020988, -0.017165934666991234, 0.043570004403591156, 0.029433803632855415, -0.01577211171388626, -0.0017511011101305485, 0.044386036694049835, 0.03718601167201996, -0.01914660818874836, -0.031549759209156036, 0.023314181715250015, -0.028453093022108078, 0.04248109832406044, -0.05412718653678894, 0.04148662090301514, -0.012872082181274891, 0.04624100401997566, -0.01053338311612606, -0.003665679134428501, 0.03002868965268135, -0.00153075170237571, -0.006555568426847458, 0.04216746240854263, 0.06663483381271362, -0.0022021648474037647, -0.0251731276512146, -0.04775671660900116, -0.052932415157556534, 0.037135593593120575, -0.027394240722060204, -0.001019260031171143, -0.004840833600610495, 0.03872283175587654, 0.05802087113261223, 0.01611335389316082, -0.04128582775592804, 0.014745834283530712, -0.04143460467457771, 0.02100704424083233, -0.05520336702466011, 0.007143528200685978, -0.00019633903866633773, 0.06464099138975143, 0.04534124955534935, -0.01758923940360546, -0.028866786509752274, -0.032347530126571655, -0.021814165636897087, 0.03107443079352379, -0.011017938144505024, 0.02654179558157921, 0.02350100874900818, 0.002787440549582243, 0.014021732844412327, 0.022312035784125328, 0.009873146191239357, 0.013906504027545452, 0.0268571637570858, -0.018671244382858276, 0.023788822814822197, 0.00883454829454422, 0.014336910098791122, 0.019993804395198822, 0.0558520182967186, -0.0013817199505865574, -0.022620385512709618, -0.005695451516658068, 0.03592019900679588, -0.016908200457692146, -0.01881709136068821, 0.029025699943304062, -0.003046071855351329, -0.01041408907622099, 0.04682265967130661, 0.03566618636250496, 0.03214714303612709, -0.029122019186615944, 0.005294107832014561, -0.02282216027379036, 0.02077939547598362, 0.031010931357741356, 0.004416860174387693, -0.0385228767991066, -0.025632891803979874, -0.0001673461083555594, -0.007473102305084467, 0.01769038662314415, -0.006987530272454023, -0.003563090693205595, 0.04393131658434868, 0.031465597450733185, -0.011999399401247501, 0.03262956440448761, 0.02644125558435917, 0.03251924738287926, -0.011846751905977726, -0.03586148843169212, -0.001933516701683402, 0.008001825772225857, -0.02300301007926464, 0.003777035977691412, 0.02306039072573185, -0.025497673079371452, 0.013347099535167217, 0.048805784434080124, 0.01432808581739664, -0.018265461549162865, -0.00531258899718523, -0.008972804062068462, 0.016217248514294624, 0.013741510920226574, -0.014841542579233646, 0.008326377719640732, 0.044014833867549896, 0.03532186523079872, 0.03567390888929367, -0.026233693584799767, -0.07905811071395874, 0.00707510719075799, 0.02913372591137886, 0.06979263573884964, -0.061160556972026825, 0.024576909840106964, 0.011582925915718079, 0.007409187965095043, 0.04884742572903633, -0.049477703869342804, 0.00817547645419836, -0.0187011007219553, -0.021798932924866676, -0.06870551407337189, -0.02474297396838665, -0.010403910651803017, 0.04030720517039299, 0.016067232936620712, 0.0018913538660854101, -0.010062500834465027, -0.035882022231817245, -0.02862878516316414, 0.012574293650686741, 0.004129890818148851, 0.04535738006234169, -0.01665976457297802, -0.012034169398248196, 0.00136188801843673, 0.032064326107501984, -0.007057872135192156, -0.02811218798160553, 0.016055116429924965, 0.010829812847077847, 0.0019318939885124564, 0.04679562523961067, 0.0008561766007915139, -0.009410105645656586, 0.025201423093676567, -0.015163187868893147, -0.01643390581011772, -0.02887299656867981, -0.01972699537873268, 0.018390726298093796, 0.034604787826538086, 0.017785364761948586, 0.06192896142601967, 0.024091163650155067, -0.010974179953336716, -0.015048867091536522, -0.061210647225379944, 0.03023368865251541, -0.04320214316248894, -0.016027919948101044, -0.014682007022202015, -0.02320041134953499, -0.02733464166522026, 0.02993312105536461, 0.01722719892859459, 0.020475119352340698, -0.02784017287194729, 0.0018999989842996001, 0.02958250790834427, 0.01780962571501732, -0.0029376635793596506, 0.009383055381476879, 0.011123182252049446, -0.0003767124726437032, -0.012406733818352222, -0.0025218010414391756, 0.04510955139994621, -0.03229483962059021, 0.022229602560400963, 0.023765012621879578, -0.01675778441131115, -0.014337084256112576, -0.02808045595884323, -0.025924935936927795, 0.014377453364431858, -0.0155369583517313, 0.019669482484459877, -0.014717222191393375, 0.020268775522708893, 0.02523195371031761, -0.03833042457699776, 0.02406451664865017, 0.03667578473687172, -0.017001038417220116, 0.060913410037755966, -0.002364919288083911, 0.03422410786151886, 0.017442958429455757, -0.000491232902277261, -0.11636243760585785, -0.006810263730585575, -0.007762927561998367, 0.04201170429587364, -0.023156968876719475, -0.03943241387605667, -0.013824887573719025, 0.0017930507892742753, -0.01283092051744461, 0.01312471553683281, 0.06408146768808365, -0.015364523977041245, -0.04496040567755699, -0.05881453678011894, -0.00006621216743951663, 0.09176991879940033, 0.011412853375077248, 0.0014826185069978237, -0.011343259364366531, -0.02933502197265625, 0.00006474783003795892, -0.016771817579865456, -0.005900589283555746, -0.04866039752960205, -0.004689421970397234, -0.002682757331058383, -0.007466089446097612, 0.02174808830022812, -0.03159822151064873, -0.05894368514418602, 0.03897561505436897, -0.004059491213411093, 0.01455782726407051, 0.0021944104228168726, 0.011312754824757576, -0.04961074888706207, 0.01566314324736595, -0.004330893512815237, 0.0444769486784935, 0.008703099563717842, 0.01664309948682785, 0.011979539878666401, 0.02929837815463543, -0.014644253998994827, 0.018639247864484787, 0.10840698331594467, 0.006993369664996862, 0.02681840769946575, -0.015171046368777752, -0.003706030547618866, -0.01156704407185316, 0.020090702921152115, 0.03908863291144371, -0.02462637424468994, 0.032525092363357544, 0.01325100939720869, -0.009078076109290123, 0.004743161611258984, -0.007957808673381805, 0.05123606324195862, -0.00726343784481287, 0.03258955851197243, 0.07499715685844421, -0.01818917505443096, -0.01746026612818241, -0.051635827869176865, 0.053161170333623886, -0.022243183106184006, -0.0150727154687047, 0.004433551337569952, 0.0021282616071403027, -0.025616450235247612, 0.02916749007999897, 0.051394734531641006, 0.012552577070891857, 0.006829555612057447, 0.03740733861923218, 0.017303405329585075, 0.03749019280076027, -0.06313110888004303, -0.06997100263834, 0.023023728281259537, -0.05260862410068512, 0.04615624621510506, -0.05571810156106949, -0.03291138634085655, 0.020269492641091347, -0.012751352973282337, -0.0184404905885458, -0.036038029938936234, -0.005149945616722107, -0.028716176748275757, 0.013748673722147942, 0.027137644588947296, -0.022532036527991295, 0.010312210768461227, 0.015871865674853325, 0.03591237962245941, -0.007305368781089783, 0.012811953201889992, -0.044601455330848694, -0.07329079508781433, -0.019546879455447197, 0.0221240296959877, -0.025829724967479706, 0.038401465862989426, -0.034130558371543884, -0.06084033474326134, 0.010454571805894375, -0.03108447976410389, 0.022345775738358498, -0.041319169104099274, 0.006610304582864046, 0.012698173522949219, 0.04669833183288574, -0.0016340379370376468, 0.026700478047132492, 0.0031201473902910948, -0.02965722419321537, 0.11544069647789001, 0.06976467370986938, 0.031094495207071304, -0.056882478296756744, 0.029202155768871307, -0.03945387154817581, -0.017713528126478195, -0.0035344441421329975, -0.009232403710484505, 0.0094339270144701, 0.019016899168491364, 0.029489535838365555, 0.0848795548081398, 0.035768650472164154, -0.012624267488718033, 0.03919374942779541, -0.04317907989025116, 0.0076659549959003925, 0.005745741538703442, -0.009704128839075565, 0.02380809187889099, 0.0033049024641513824, -0.010849731974303722, -0.03452625498175621, 0.023545050993561745, 0.015200750902295113, -0.047902610152959824, -0.01788642629981041, 0.0070920707657933235, 0.053900886327028275, -0.03235548734664917, -0.004077144432812929, -0.013828562572598457, 0.03403209149837494, -0.06885969638824463, -0.03677789866924286, 0.011071514338254929, -0.03363467752933502, 0.015401847660541534, 0.024715054780244827, -0.01204343605786562, -0.035005778074264526, -0.01888696663081646, -0.007317729294300079, -0.045478347688913345, 0.0011490865144878626, -0.01789757050573826, 0.010377447120845318, 0.004013822879642248, -0.022484809160232544, -0.04313606396317482, 0.008194657042622566, -0.02655031904578209, -0.0630951076745987, -0.008649967610836029, 0.008499006740748882, 0.01633118838071823, -0.04217167943716049, -0.033616892993450165, -0.04972655326128006, -0.00861341692507267, -0.021082108840346336, 0.05630982294678688, 0.019402870908379555, -0.007490879390388727, -0.014015288092195988, -0.044814568012952805, 0.0037431323435157537, 0.0030559326987713575, -0.018999706953763962, -0.02462073415517807, -0.02629219740629196, -0.014762206003069878, 0.008933973498642445, -0.022619469091296196, 0.040743108838796616, 0.022846080362796783, 0.008897460997104645, -0.005612676963210106, -0.03584863618016243, -0.08889493346214294, 0.03985801339149475, -0.002782493829727173, 0.029391851276159286, -0.03086487576365471, -0.017898954451084137, 0.03804924711585045, -0.01784692332148552, -0.001692527555860579, 0.052923765033483505, 0.0024511234369128942, 0.039305590093135834, 0.0005001600366085768, -0.06264883279800415, -0.05101444572210312, 0.0015219870256260037, -0.040632933378219604, 0.005353142973035574, -0.0452689565718174, 0.019729401916265488, 0.03253225237131119, 0.02360299788415432, -0.014131421223282814, -0.023754362016916275, 0.003254228737205267, 0.01252999622374773, -0.006515220273286104, -0.043373510241508484, -0.045316316187381744, 0.029463233426213264, 0.006991368718445301, -0.04321318864822388, -0.006073856260627508, -0.0438242182135582, -0.04152313247323036, 0.034538719803094864, -0.021646078675985336, -0.04401469603180885, -0.017356660217046738, -0.0017237156862393022, 0.06595360487699509, -0.02715696394443512, 0.01222131960093975, -0.012068178504705429, -0.025496194139122963, 0.0067192078568041325, 0.020993586629629135, 0.009104901924729347, 0.0228114016354084, -0.01576736755669117, 0.019092900678515434, 0.046763330698013306, -0.01501073595136404, 0.06797509640455246, 0.022979358211159706, 0.004989940207451582, 0.002190380822867155, 0.022226057946681976, -0.03705635666847229, 0.0021662733051925898, 0.052213434129953384, -0.06036445498466492, -0.02805379591882229, -0.013031152077019215, -0.027809182181954384, 0.03994489088654518, -0.006596518214792013, -0.011303125880658627, -0.01592153310775757, 0.0006798016838729382, -0.06579235196113586, -0.01784253492951393, -0.017093254253268242, -0.0208644587546587, 0.04491715133190155, -0.014793714508414268, 0.0019208693411201239, 0.018829593434929848, -0.02220996655523777, 0.023717012256383896, 0.040528543293476105, -0.00006757360824849457, -0.03340085595846176, -0.009011611342430115, -0.022276073694229126, -0.012517009861767292, -0.0003283180412836373, 0.0005559802521020174, 0.03707573190331459, 0.023370008915662766, 0.003670919919386506, -0.010734820738434792, -0.036897122859954834, 0.00386985600925982, -0.08485984057188034, -0.007318434771150351, -0.01918722130358219, 0.01916782185435295, 0.0059191337786614895, -0.004582577850669622, 0.005572199355810881, 0.02059108018875122, -0.03179533779621124, 0.015557601116597652, -0.04535633325576782, -0.01134637463837862, -0.05698058754205704, -0.029025282710790634, -0.0023395437747240067, 0.03181992843747139, 0.015088812448084354, 0.01676902174949646, 0.02996731735765934, 0.006007301155477762, -0.003810373367741704, -0.01036393828690052, 0.00792649481445551, 0.004155480302870274, 0.012551594525575638, -0.04482502490282059, -0.01207446027547121, 0.0247713103890419, -0.0010600559180602431, -0.021567337214946747, 0.010808841325342655, 0.03095490299165249, 0.022872256115078926, 0.028522010892629623, -0.027035469189286232, -0.016121968626976013, 0.014417433179914951, 0.022112522274255753, -0.04368434101343155, 0.01094144955277443, 0.019421640783548355, 0.034426428377628326, 0.0071028973907232285, -0.050601281225681305, 0.025432340800762177, -0.02037806808948517, 0.008157621137797832, -0.008827910758554935, -0.04177699610590935, -0.06258995085954666, 0.001648848643526435, -0.036293935030698776, 0.03073281981050968, 0.007349946070462465, 0.0017723513301461935, 0.0021904828026890755, -0.05625290796160698, 0.04483700543642044, 0.001753981108777225, -0.015654731541872025, 0.03007897548377514, 0.003607584396377206, -0.010583360679447651, -0.008991612121462822, 0.0065995980985462666, -0.010746253654360771, -0.03280263766646385, 0.010500586591660976, 0.0012216076720505953, 0.014095616526901722, -0.0284002423286438, 0.010738331824541092, 0.0184512659907341, 0.054950516670942307, -0.001219568308442831, 0.014890720136463642, -0.021111683920025826, -0.006543637719005346, -0.0037059071473777294, -0.027562372386455536, 0.050797395408153534, -0.02446974255144596, -0.06003241613507271, -0.07101339101791382, -0.034665677696466446, -0.022763138636946678, 0.014472885057330132, 0.02235964871942997, 0.01386463176459074, 0.011373543180525303, -0.018265603110194206, 0.025379402562975883, -0.021750789135694504, -0.012118675746023655, 0.07979140430688858, 0.009144282899796963, -0.033854931592941284, -0.0011915857903659344, -0.0032107187435030937, 0.002829529345035553, -0.005982839036732912, 0.029307888820767403, -0.02549184486269951, 0.006215157452970743, 0.01792125031352043, 0.005657427944242954, 0.020250027999281883, 0.008403428830206394, -0.03169184923171997, 0.025713207200169563, -0.010656175203621387, -0.012211778201162815, 0.04557777941226959, 0.01510400790721178, -0.03913172706961632, 0.02633369155228138, -0.044081900268793106, 0.011166428215801716, -0.02823982946574688, 0.042960718274116516, -0.03230160102248192, -0.030451925471425056, 0.03230082988739014, 0.03741345927119255, -0.021304894238710403, -0.009792438708245754, 0.031932126730680466, 0.011838838458061218, 0.05155831202864647, -0.00285969115793705, 0.01900448463857174, 0.011755721643567085, -0.024266164749860764, 0.027294300496578217, 0.03453189507126808, 0.022221995517611504, -0.005397677421569824, -0.03270835429430008, 0.033392537385225296, -0.010693882592022419, 0.052809759974479675, 0.04083927348256111, 0.008692714385688305, -0.009550398215651512, -0.03790909796953201, 0.030173979699611664, -0.01656501367688179, 0.056219104677438736, 0.006383843254297972, -0.011595116928219795, 0.03194840997457504, -0.030715610831975937, 0.0288479495793581, -0.0467730313539505, 0.012501448392868042, -0.017055775970220566, 0.01148304808884859, 0.06091305986046791, 0.03389132022857666, 0.013603626750409603, 0.013572915457189083, -0.01611904986202717, -0.03649391978979111, 0.007651509251445532, -0.002168995561078191, 0.000021846462914254516, -0.031725164502859116, 0.010847720317542553, -0.014985352754592896, 0.0002813809842336923, -0.08163198828697205, -0.019983094185590744, -0.011781125329434872, 0.018884427845478058, 0.023554250597953796, -0.01226783636957407, -0.03484132140874863, 0.05892246961593628, 0.06434828788042068, -0.04724469780921936, -0.0268651582300663, -0.07285626977682114, -0.0009182051289826632, -0.0071833315305411816, -0.006174564827233553 ]
<p>Suppose you have some measurement series with quite different variances, see e.g., figure below.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/sxuOB.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>The problem is that the differences between a, b, and d are barely recognizable, because the y-scale is rather large, because of the first measurement (these are no measurement errors, they are quite essential and can not be ignored). What is the most elegant way to plot the data without losing too much information.</p> <p>Two possibilities come to my mind:</p> <p>a) Leave the first measurement out, and supply it otherwise (e.g., in the text or as a table).</p> <p>b) Make the y-scale exponential (inverse of log). However, this is quite uncommon (how do you do this with R?).</p> <p>What would you suggest?</p>
73,548
[ -0.04177786782383919, 0.04512828588485718, 0.0030336857307702303, 0.0007933814777061343, 0.006381933111697435, 0.04377131909132004, 0.013734317384660244, 0.004157709889113903, 0.010678669437766075, -0.003588586114346981, 0.051854003220796585, 0.0179358571767807, 0.03299930691719055, 0.01081764604896307, 0.0382661297917366, -0.007315765600651503, -0.012137863785028458, -0.006382806226611137, -0.01668984442949295, -0.02396477200090885, -0.023906143382191658, -0.02529994398355484, 0.01200168952345848, 0.00007682164869038388, -0.037260107696056366, 0.08058749884366989, 0.04572547599673271, 0.02727501280605793, 0.019503191113471985, 0.07480223476886749, -0.03658478334546089, -0.006107740569859743, -0.010617302730679512, 0.02512611262500286, 0.028649762272834778, 0.0037722443230450153, -0.03817865625023842, -0.04522041976451874, 0.009886008687317371, 0.025552811101078987, -0.039711691439151764, 0.02004070393741131, 0.013993379659950733, 0.03005039691925049, 0.007754756137728691, 0.03391188010573387, -0.011660399846732616, -0.008668756112456322, 0.053003303706645966, -0.02834334224462509, 0.05158628150820732, -0.0003847370680887252, 0.046055518090724945, 0.037999287247657776, -0.03538024052977562, -0.01306613814085722, 0.04652062803506851, 0.06294456869363785, -0.017344046384096146, -0.0315031036734581, -0.016262048855423927, 0.02542560175061226, 0.00008674624405102804, -0.02516133524477482, -0.01909557916224003, 0.02040686458349228, -0.016300387680530548, -0.008638350293040276, 0.019211065024137497, -0.025045573711395264, 0.04379219934344292, 0.03351029381155968, 0.041238464415073395, -0.026564057916402817, 0.0576687790453434, -0.041585709899663925, 0.038911741226911545, 0.0031071752309799194, 0.05633789300918579, 0.039617106318473816, 0.008587680757045746, 0.0068086888641119, 0.04565280303359032, 0.013089356943964958, -0.007373574655503035, -0.005073185544461012, 0.06379269808530807, 0.006641889922320843, 0.010155923664569855, 0.06706657260656357, 0.01171430665999651, -0.011037737131118774, 0.08084792643785477, 0.003566780360415578, -0.03849219158291817, 0.03637043386697769, -0.04203590005636215, 0.05236300826072693, 0.008661647327244282, -0.0076563358306884766, -0.021568115800619125, -0.040246181190013885, 0.03146163374185562, 0.04484141245484352, -0.006473167799413204, -0.013969089835882187, 0.005573291331529617, 0.002310842741280794, 0.020973792299628258, -0.038173556327819824, 0.01979687809944153, 0.008193997666239738, 0.01187030877918005, 0.035678930580616, 0.05509429797530174, -0.019170861691236496, -0.01648889295756817, 0.011160343885421753, 0.05195217579603195, 0.07198764383792877, 0.04429284483194351, -0.03730950877070427, 0.002194940112531185, 0.01769140176475048, -0.023655137047171593, 0.0069697462022304535, 0.020346326753497124, -0.006187093909829855, -0.040450211614370346, 0.03747062757611275, -0.028987683355808258, -0.01532832719385624, 0.06450852751731873, -0.044893618673086166, 0.03452018275856972, 0.027093226090073586, -0.10871423035860062, -0.07404414564371109, 0.03829142078757286, -0.012591391801834106, 0.001820127828978002, -0.0648854449391365, -0.025045787915587425, 0.026481065899133682, 0.014334813691675663, 0.00962052121758461, -0.019325371831655502, 0.016956830397248268, 0.04039888456463814, -0.006253933068364859, 0.015103391371667385, -0.022453390061855316, 0.020258279517292976, -0.05916941910982132, 0.020503852516412735, -0.04549416899681091, 0.0041015795432031155, 0.0434725359082222, -0.03346533700823784, -0.0005596918053925037, 0.04903898015618324, 0.007856148295104504, 0.008357618004083633, 0.009249618276953697, 0.017107898369431496, -0.02575470507144928, 0.09828214347362518, -0.024720599874854088, 0.03335779532790184, 0.015734229236841202, -0.013482654467225075, 0.022053003311157227, -0.004317853134125471, 0.019701868295669556, 0.04644923657178879, 0.00415453314781189, -0.012745348736643791, 0.005170533433556557, 0.009066933766007423, 0.040360886603593826, -0.03864596039056778, -0.06197553128004074, -0.014670304954051971, -0.028717536479234695, 0.03519053012132645, 0.050085339695215225, -0.001627946039661765, -0.012655616737902164, 0.05719408392906189, -0.04948190599679947, -0.07961003482341766, -0.04700382426381111, -0.006954018026590347, 0.003418340114876628, -0.023370832204818726, 0.0289873406291008, 0.0043231649324297905, 0.005607209168374538, 0.001108942786231637, -0.012463608756661415, 0.04271009564399719, 0.018874235451221466, 0.05011099949479103, -0.04251982644200325, -0.004939130507409573, 0.043069373816251755, 0.08294319361448288, -0.03212209418416023, 0.03310515359044075, -0.011033176444470882, -0.007324177771806717, 0.002334633143618703, -0.042146388441324234, 0.017099745571613312, -0.0017509573372080922, -0.0010246098972856998, -0.0042780726216733456, 0.009041313081979752, -0.04456105828285217, 0.002492597559466958, -0.06425105035305023, 0.05229029059410095, 0.06256869435310364, -0.019790044054389, -0.02317711152136326, 0.02074573189020157, 0.019990911707282066, 0.051090631633996964, -0.018985090777277946, -0.012800261378288269, -0.0659048855304718, -0.0026982296258211136, 0.025264836847782135, 0.047017473727464676, -0.02498859167098999, 0.03221014142036438, 0.046791862696409225, 0.0011869203299283981, 0.00970250554382801, 0.03147530183196068, -0.0060220882296562195, -0.020125266164541245, -0.016739290207624435, -0.0009039358701556921, 0.017295226454734802, -0.0029482075478881598, 0.01420869491994381, -0.009703497402369976, 0.039720650762319565, -0.019272444769740105, 0.015559463761746883, 0.009213068522512913, -0.00815112516283989, 0.006937517784535885, -0.011571576818823814, -0.00976627692580223, 0.06484601646661758, -0.022571876645088196, 0.01118367351591587, 0.018009282648563385, -0.011791466735303402, -0.014114685356616974, 0.02750663086771965, -0.0071395691484212875, -0.0003254474140703678, 0.043126028031110764, -0.04975243657827377, -0.014181969687342644, 0.011687695048749447, -0.03784376010298729, 0.0065491050481796265, -0.04740028828382492, -0.026256216689944267, -0.03955458849668503, -0.0067199161276221275, 0.027801822870969772, 0.013269087299704552, 0.01898566633462906, -0.04338281974196434, -0.06384822726249695, 0.006101546343415976, -0.012353525497019291, 0.01569628156721592, 0.002280342159792781, -0.03812265023589134, -0.0033048551995307207, -0.030953720211982727, -0.011010427959263325, 0.01081780344247818, -0.012358552776277065, 0.006770803593099117, 0.0012358996318653226, 0.0071786921471357346, -0.08053693175315857, -0.03930989280343056, -0.010301868431270123, 0.012273023836314678, 0.010852335952222347, -0.02773676998913288, 0.070674367249012, 0.008632180280983448, -0.03511600196361542, 0.0022736797109246254, -0.07303889095783234, 0.010967985726892948, -0.025020115077495575, 0.024530744180083275, -0.002929537557065487, 0.008898735046386719, -0.019023818895220757, -0.0018977331928908825, -0.04663829132914543, -0.048479530960321426, -0.06153211370110512, -0.0824841558933258, 0.012851749546825886, 0.01832650788128376, 0.03314486891031265, -0.04117641597986221, -0.02500753663480282, 0.06817075610160828, 0.0358838252723217, -0.012906248681247234, -0.03769855946302414, -0.0077590737491846085, -0.0049911849200725555, -0.052760571241378784, 0.028530312702059746, 0.03543289005756378, 0.010588837787508965, 0.022837571799755096, 0.007902820594608784, 0.02087721787393093, 0.01738438755273819, -0.011189560405910015, 0.0063987430185079575, 0.0006842187722213566, 0.004614409990608692, -0.015048623085021973, 0.040102988481521606, 0.02734450064599514, -0.03582305088639259, 0.01700163073837757, -0.011462288908660412, 0.02034282684326172, -0.0004647814785130322, -0.039121728390455246, 0.009782440029084682, -0.014808392152190208, 0.022872650995850563, -0.04898206517100334, 0.0011883167317137122, 0.05470160022377968, 0.010207596234977245, -0.03260516747832298, 0.02693292871117592, 0.03683077543973923, -0.01557349506765604, -0.015407314524054527, 0.07144534587860107, 0.05138832703232765, 0.0036148885264992714, -0.001456455560401082, 0.02166317030787468, -0.004167905542999506, 0.03529549390077591, -0.019874755293130875, -0.008633424527943134, 0.04375715181231499, 0.037625446915626526, -0.002700361656025052, -0.0036340386141091585, -0.02430517040193081, 0.00861898623406887, -0.07813802361488342, -0.008992166258394718, -0.012170893140137196, 0.07796776294708252, 0.03636603802442551, 0.038476213812828064, 0.019807007163763046, 0.022109458222985268, -0.0191026758402586, -0.0049982937052845955, -0.07543177902698517, 0.03118245303630829, -0.009713496081531048, -0.009456378407776356, -0.008895736187696457, -0.0002192509564338252, 0.03610623627901077, -0.031166620552539825, 0.034582726657390594, 0.02069549448788166, 0.021594049409031868, -0.03171353042125702, -0.046624790877103806, 0.009236597456037998, -0.0010930635035037994, -0.04147520661354065, 0.028033370152115822, 0.02503388002514839, -0.012330513447523117, 0.017182540148496628, 0.023717984557151794, -0.009214082732796669, -0.03507436811923981, -0.019120072945952415, 0.01581549271941185, -0.012988384813070297, 0.038763877004384995, -0.021884866058826447, 0.014645942486822605, -0.017346294596791267, 0.012679126113653183, 0.00975456926971674, 0.03241002559661865, 0.014292421750724316, -0.015320279635488987, -0.012346782721579075, -0.015315349213778973, -0.0206541009247303, -0.00818953663110733, 0.05614541471004486, -0.003974371589720249, -0.006440441589802504, 0.03291179612278938, 0.025406518951058388, -0.047707971185445786, 0.03545480594038963, 0.023742513731122017, 0.0054710498079657555, -0.011206264607608318, -0.017338614910840988, -0.011615418829023838, -0.009295891039073467, 0.002378948964178562, 0.004411475267261267, 0.029052412137389183, 0.014799177646636963, -0.02807587757706642, 0.04819182679057121, 0.009350822307169437, -0.015143146738409996, 0.018453817814588547, 0.04137265309691429, 0.0346241220831871, 0.0030796569772064686, -0.03117384761571884, 0.04505293071269989, 0.023864734917879105, 0.04524888098239899, 0.02194220945239067, -0.027226615697145462, -0.05869247019290924, -0.0027174553833901882, 0.018025552853941917, 0.02033403143286705, -0.023737851530313492, -0.027443138882517815, -0.036199916154146194, -0.03418843075633049, 0.04906182736158371, -0.04112651199102402, 0.032319579273462296, -0.05229305103421211, -0.010151873342692852, -0.028751786798238754, -0.030577221885323524, -0.07447442412376404, -0.0017856665654107928, -0.0029611866921186447, 0.007398505229502916, -0.002203148789703846, -0.030294574797153473, -0.03651113063097, 0.02374761365354061, 0.02235134318470955, 0.08569230884313583, -0.03853033483028412, -0.04310004040598869, 0.014471212401986122, 0.017134204506874084, -0.010797468945384026, -0.039156947284936905, 0.034944530576467514, 0.009777993895113468, 0.005673693493008614, 0.052521806210279465, 0.014371917583048344, -0.056134287267923355, 0.0036759180948138237, 0.010391143150627613, 0.007395836524665356, 0.012285291217267513, 0.005911309737712145, 0.0575234591960907, 0.06703142076730728, -0.004157514777034521, 0.046046655625104904, 0.053389668464660645, 0.025276528671383858, 0.025198377668857574, -0.03567070886492729, -0.001976953586563468, -0.04337730258703232, -0.03543970361351967, -0.061050254851579666, 0.010227544233202934, -0.052308958023786545, 0.007921374402940273, -0.02398378774523735, 0.039589814841747284, -0.029420483857393265, -0.032842736691236496, 0.04694882407784462, 0.005992997903376818, 0.007523119915276766, -0.024776974692940712, 0.017243733629584312, 0.033185940235853195, 0.0014579404378309846, -0.012788819149136543, -0.008504104800522327, 0.03037448041141033, -0.011898403987288475, 0.00996795017272234, -0.05481135845184326, 0.017116354778409004, -0.017647823318839073, -0.025553343817591667, 0.013108858838677406, -0.03806203976273537, 0.002685075392946601, -0.012277844361960888, 0.04483342543244362, 0.028891023248434067, -0.0509210005402565, -0.020374689251184464, 0.043248578906059265, -0.008098158985376358, 0.003967527765780687, -0.08603135496377945, 0.03195349499583244, -0.042148344218730927, -0.004834290593862534, -0.07542892545461655, -0.04294554889202118, 0.025851763784885406, -0.01525782234966755, -0.010014846920967102, -0.00016741876606829464, -0.010672751814126968, 0.008524387143552303, -0.014073215425014496, -0.017514491453766823, 0.020018354058265686, -0.005137012340128422, -0.00743752159178257, -0.03810980170965195, 0.05425272509455681, 0.09537222981452942, 0.00214673625305295, 0.002897964557632804, 0.027927132323384285, -0.03686832636594772, -0.023732146248221397, 0.009298513643443584, 0.019748536869883537, -0.015297862701117992, 0.006457798648625612, -0.014011077582836151, 0.021647632122039795, 0.009564428590238094, -0.020483361557126045, -0.017161743715405464, 0.02038324996829033, 0.014403709210455418, -0.0038077612407505512, -0.00807948037981987, 0.024720950052142143, -0.04148993268609047, 0.01503620482981205, -0.02713244967162609, -0.01331314817070961, -0.018118295818567276, -0.031131325289607048, -0.01761801913380623, 0.031666602939367294, -0.04007133096456528, 0.01441743690520525, 0.033582061529159546, 0.01946284994482994, -0.03008272685110569, -0.0017636566190049052, -0.024908902123570442, 0.018367191776633263, -0.0036008155439049006, 0.0020314110442996025, 0.0043184454552829266, 0.011199931614100933, -0.050708360970020294, -0.03302916884422302, -0.012705088593065739, -0.014840242452919483, 0.049567896872758865, 0.007418861612677574, 0.06424079090356827, 0.03977587819099426, 0.025499239563941956, 0.0164440106600523, -0.029586108401417732, -0.02728017419576645, -0.024420324712991714, 0.007882418110966682, 0.0595654658973217, -0.0075323269702494144, -0.0008880235836841166, 0.0032613028306514025, 0.006894001737236977, 0.03404250741004944, 0.050546783953905106, 0.020572373643517494, 0.016493739560246468, 0.025721350684762, -0.04125618934631348, -0.036015357822179794, -0.00036621338222175837, -0.03657063469290733, 0.03838558867573738, -0.02493792586028576, -0.00877593643963337, 0.04611503332853317, 0.006742972414940596, -0.013677095994353294, -0.04373569041490555, -0.03817874565720558, -0.06981765478849411, -0.02679034322500229, 0.032925330102443695, -0.003829590044915676, 0.024799086153507233, -0.024471465498209, 0.05286785960197449, -0.03713688999414444, 0.04045364633202553, -0.04924706369638443, -0.08109867572784424, -0.04773078113794327, -0.000560145708732307, -0.028114503249526024, 0.07498425245285034, -0.0323801226913929, -0.039691679179668427, -0.00605668593198061, -0.03189685195684433, 0.03575978800654411, 0.007136511616408825, 0.013799881562590599, -0.021588735282421112, 0.027364907786250114, -0.001689809374511242, -0.0014392471639439464, -0.024474143981933594, -0.02123800851404667, 0.10086343437433243, 0.06253765523433685, 0.05173608288168907, -0.05744766443967819, 0.044249340891838074, 0.015918714925646782, 0.031479962170124054, 0.00023419155331794173, 0.007253211922943592, 0.02223394252359867, 0.014117959886789322, 0.007400381378829479, 0.04986400902271271, 0.015159914270043373, 0.02643142268061638, 0.05116669088602066, -0.03229167312383652, 0.029964882880449295, -0.004698483739048243, 0.027805354446172714, -0.001591626089066267, -0.02547510527074337, -0.06054644286632538, 0.00962152797728777, 0.014342591166496277, -0.03119899518787861, -0.04083777964115143, -0.040529947727918625, 0.016156382858753204, 0.03460495546460152, -0.016619360074400902, 0.050135791301727295, 0.035733964294195175, 0.013196674175560474, 0.006007813848555088, -0.0034775189124047756, 0.014519100077450275, -0.017278768122196198, 0.013200408779084682, 0.031215569004416466, 0.007485577836632729, -0.035254571586847305, 0.002409096574410796, 0.013944968581199646, -0.05037503316998482, -0.040014542639255524, -0.02449881285429001, 0.057637885212898254, -0.004429413937032223, 0.010149451903998852, -0.018963031470775604, 0.021513786166906357, -0.02853904664516449, -0.053739823400974274, -0.018480706959962845, 0.025663794949650764, -0.008099258877336979, -0.02008611522614956, -0.03913148492574692, 0.0007494019810110331, 0.014426156878471375, -0.020552068948745728, 0.04350614175200462, 0.03287019953131676, -0.02924724854528904, -0.03356732800602913, 0.00994857121258974, 0.047201305627822876, 0.009031623601913452, -0.017249850556254387, 0.013004334643483162, -0.01683804951608181, -0.006719308439642191, -0.025238338857889175, 0.0034201161470264196, -0.006811340339481831, -0.004875063430517912, 0.006272008642554283, 0.018645696341991425, -0.041513849049806595, -0.0016420333413407207, 0.02255677618086338, -0.007196623831987381, -0.0021421571727842093, -0.03172141686081886, -0.005819300655275583, 0.03581364452838898, 0.006399865727871656, 0.015753522515296936, -0.0038973193150013685, 0.011516515165567398, 0.04580079764127731, 0.033971358090639114, -0.04788912460207939, -0.006329003721475601, 0.023947060108184814, -0.034461602568626404, -0.01705728843808174, 0.002602326450869441, 0.07741277664899826, 0.030554451048374176, 0.0015082909958437085, 0.022750401869416237, 0.02227102778851986, -0.02149989828467369, 0.0019190561724826694, 0.023267218843102455, -0.07838531583547592, -0.010190372355282307, 0.015491591766476631, -0.01784759946167469, -0.010354540310800076, -0.003960208501666784, -0.04037562012672424, -0.05106508359313011, -0.014332534745335579, -0.010511081665754318, -0.02147495187819004, 0.01051371730864048, -0.023423338308930397, 0.009702949784696102, -0.050976984202861786, -0.0011544080916792154, -0.04781438410282135, -0.03389785811305046, -0.03260669484734535, -0.009585659019649029, 0.01774768717586994, 0.0429796539247036, -0.04287843033671379, 0.01557844877243042, 0.02096765860915184, 0.014165440574288368, 0.053628820925951004, -0.01914551481604576, 0.0020618306007236242, 0.011262116022408009, 0.02166798710823059, -0.015304545871913433, -0.012678050436079502, 0.029255807399749756, -0.03837697207927704, -0.01612137444317341, 0.03388936072587967, -0.03538690134882927, 0.014599121175706387, -0.0031069046817719936, -0.01563936471939087, -0.03974565118551254, 0.0552515871822834, -0.02499571070075035, -0.0009733729530125856, -0.015324633568525314, -0.020515091717243195, 0.0034221017267555, -0.010072511620819569, 0.011552178300917149, -0.018742065876722336, 0.01145212259143591, 0.029705099761486053, 0.02102639339864254, 0.013775002211332321, -0.032685890793800354, -0.004754046443849802, 0.006159251555800438, 0.05230230093002319, -0.02388262376189232, -0.014970047399401665, 0.03780003637075424, 0.023816999047994614, -0.05863888934254646, -0.026853438466787338, 0.00044233311200514436, -0.014563816599547863, -0.053977616131305695, -0.03821277618408203, 0.013304054737091064, 0.016830870881676674, 0.021719226613640785, -0.062054309993982315, -0.021322347223758698, 0.018466072157025337, -0.06472133845090866, 0.012704456225037575, -0.03721882402896881, 0.014052767306566238, -0.013276231475174427, 0.004640677943825722, -0.01578616164624691, 0.04499472305178642, 0.048358187079429626, 0.05630781129002571, 0.017928065732121468, 0.012964260764420033, 0.0026785777881741524, -0.018639035522937775, -0.0033796876668930054, 0.006509075872600079, 0.028621366247534752, -0.0911526307463646, 0.04019812121987343, -0.019544266164302826, 0.02031983621418476, 0.03578995168209076, -0.030692083761096, 0.0690830796957016, -0.014181581325829029, 1.6860917639860418e-7, 0.010979746468365192, 0.03676636144518852, 0.007061903364956379, -0.03729330748319626, -0.04495144262909889, -0.019521430134773254, 0.03340981900691986, 0.034169044345617294, 0.014989924617111683, -0.0011318280594423413, 0.0012249426217749715, 0.003845933126285672, -0.004757753573358059, -0.020408032462000847, 0.008807736448943615, -0.006014746613800526, -0.027907902374863625, 0.004901750944554806, 0.01660262420773506, -0.018520386889576912, -0.008514265529811382, -0.044990234076976776, -0.023361802101135254, 0.04762759059667587, 0.012722454033792019, -0.012962806038558483, 0.019047515466809273, -0.011121181771159172, -0.04614732414484024, 0.011460743844509125, 0.004256058484315872, -0.0032072507310658693, -0.06107586249709129, 0.000543189060408622, -0.001221759244799614, -0.029998907819390297, 0.003477351041510701, -0.0034714224748313427, -0.04813496768474579, 0.033486396074295044, -0.018218878656625748, 0.010989300906658173, 0.013699633069336414, -0.018987463787198067, 0.009388700127601624, -0.08265180140733719, 0.04742920398712158, 0.025739867240190506, -0.019707899540662766, -0.017252348363399506, 0.026418952271342278, -0.029649412259459496, 0.05789143592119217, 0.08481985330581665, 0.028384588658809662, -0.025058582425117493, 0.017173780128359795, 0.03494377061724663, 0.0013987654820084572, -0.05056474357843399, 0.025050293654203415, -0.0029018488712608814, -0.01802344061434269, 0.025819608941674232, -0.011614732444286346, 0.018298542127013206, 0.009851097129285336, 0.005733690224587917, 0.013906857930123806, -0.009330280125141144, 0.027236079797148705, -0.006846458185464144, 0.017603620886802673, -0.019282767549157143, -0.057503215968608856, 0.008737356401979923, 0.030830947682261467, -0.004133136942982674, 0.016243217512965202, 0.01912633888423443, -0.03917812183499336, 0.022193821147084236, -0.031163299456238747, -0.020204361528158188, -0.007207173388451338, 0.005153161473572254, -0.010731576010584831, -0.048339925706386566, 0.007591793313622475, 0.0012551816180348396, -0.02225515991449356, -0.014905555173754692, 0.016575150191783905, 0.010552837513387203, 0.056806471198797226, 0.0036649175453931093, 0.010997343808412552, -0.0022404524497687817, -0.02420176938176155, 0.0036816364154219627, -0.02902008220553398, 0.010598649270832539, 0.02357584424316883, -0.01243001502007246, 0.023480307310819626, -0.027238765731453896, 0.044889435172080994, -0.016963956877589226, 0.05441970378160477, -0.009213880635797977, -0.007485038600862026, 0.018093202263116837, -0.023628564551472664, 0.009175450541079044, 0.0043950555846095085, -0.005829520523548126, 0.039839111268520355, -0.028224412351846695, -0.007184991147369146, -0.042909786105155945, -0.036129631102085114, -0.03230251744389534, -0.015032187104225159, -0.00003760758045245893, 0.027392474934458733, 0.00782334990799427, 0.029771456494927406, -0.013309687376022339, -0.005504237487912178, -0.025143664330244064, -0.030979476869106293, 0.05165405571460724, -0.05039016157388687, -0.028622550889849663, -0.004170563071966171, 0.006000241730362177, -0.05437183380126953, -0.025630133226513863, 0.06051275506615639, 0.027843516319990158, 0.019828075543045998, -0.025694245472550392, -0.03932572901248932, 0.016302889212965965, 0.0355178602039814, -0.06145576387643814, -0.03067416325211525, -0.021819261834025383, 0.018594937399029732, 0.028919436037540436, -0.03347362205386162 ]
<p>I am applying binary logistic regression as my dependent variable is a dichotomous variable with 740 sample size. I have used enter method to input my variables and have designed two blocks. In block 1 I have tried to see the impact of only demographic variables and in block 2 I have added 10 new predictors. Chi-Square value has increased significantly from block 1 to block 2, Hosmer and lemeshow test has value greater than 0.05 (It was 0.000 for block 1)and -2 log likelihood has also decreased drastically from block 1 to block 2, indicating good model fit. But In block 1 I can see significant impact of some of the demographic variables, however in block 2 there is no impact of any of the predictors. Please help me with my output..what does it signify? Am i mistaking somewhere?</p>
26,740
[ -0.04924973472952843, -0.035454124212265015, -0.024854520335793495, 0.02831423468887806, 0.038137588649988174, -0.0200081504881382, 0.0027988774236291647, -0.034729085862636566, 0.020345184952020645, -0.023653170093894005, 0.033513981848955154, 0.026188114657998085, 0.045130036771297455, 0.0016119907377287745, 0.03340338543057442, 0.02097788080573082, -0.0109550217166543, 0.010629004798829556, 0.010343837551772594, 0.006433637347072363, -0.023191435262560844, 0.043342992663383484, 0.08165422827005386, -0.014879410155117512, -0.00852128304541111, 0.07631129026412964, 0.033071063458919525, -0.031527478247880936, 0.024451134726405144, 0.02481125481426716, -0.007331481669098139, -0.06078154593706131, -0.013441158458590508, 0.001669442979618907, -0.014857305213809013, -0.018950022757053375, -0.02563069947063923, -0.03355773165822029, 0.002679293043911457, 0.012645495124161243, -0.05384835600852966, -0.0034440967720001936, -0.013388793915510178, 0.025681741535663605, -0.04540345072746277, -0.008568260818719864, -0.003396424697712064, 0.007355433888733387, 0.049761973321437836, -0.031473200768232346, 0.060313042253255844, -0.0058609480038285255, 0.0683135986328125, 0.03325710445642471, -0.014698527753353119, -0.008915073238313198, 0.044520992785692215, 0.06865659356117249, -0.012792729772627354, -0.01567571423947811, -0.015624982304871082, -0.020066481083631516, -0.005532498005777597, 0.003058661939576268, -0.04547663405537605, 0.03805689886212349, -0.01254434883594513, -0.027815520763397217, 0.02272978238761425, 0.012220382690429688, 0.034973032772541046, 0.008441700600087643, 0.023946266621351242, -0.00986979715526104, 0.03972296044230461, -0.03565717115998268, -0.019368838518857956, 0.028143711388111115, -0.002724928082898259, 0.03470595180988312, -0.02043035626411438, 0.02080214023590088, 0.017267413437366486, 0.07099934667348862, 0.029446754604578018, -0.016955707222223282, 0.05280781164765358, -0.041349850594997406, 0.00544873857870698, 0.01932027004659176, -0.026562517508864403, 0.018227767199277878, 0.06095270812511444, 0.015017463825643063, -0.02663910575211048, 0.017319796606898308, -0.0419173501431942, 0.06100745499134064, 0.01939910091459751, 0.023562831804156303, -0.036980077624320984, -0.02794000133872032, 0.06876158714294434, 0.06505079567432404, -0.040823157876729965, 0.01327815093100071, -0.041244812309741974, -0.011455843225121498, 0.003038528375327587, -0.028308257460594177, 0.013940097764134407, 0.004827422089874744, -0.005809560418128967, -0.007123555522412062, -0.0044405097141861916, -0.037343841046094894, -0.04768148064613342, -0.0032414670567959547, 0.04929514229297638, 0.031601425260305405, 0.0545026920735836, -0.00961779523640871, 0.018968673422932625, -0.005935657769441605, -0.07342172414064407, -0.0025739718694239855, 0.00993467029184103, -0.02909192442893982, -0.04887140169739723, 0.04980713501572609, 0.024399014189839363, -0.006759302690625191, 0.0074914428405463696, 0.029110457748174667, 0.02838938869535923, -0.020168107002973557, -0.09786199778318405, -0.04345235228538513, 0.01684250682592392, -0.015581023879349232, 0.06622182577848434, -0.05074615031480789, -0.008192399516701698, 0.03477926924824715, 0.04532279446721077, -0.01718766614794731, -0.004679631907492876, 0.04384097829461098, 0.02424013987183571, 0.027094872668385506, -0.038737159222364426, 0.03096829168498516, -0.06608908623456955, -0.014415801502764225, -0.010620689019560814, -0.060189083218574524, 0.00889801885932684, 0.03469773754477501, -0.030777957290410995, -0.04806391894817352, 0.028490059077739716, 0.015927093103528023, -0.009146123193204403, -0.005750658456236124, 0.001518293167464435, -0.004470180720090866, 0.0739886686205864, -0.02271554246544838, 0.0243814866989851, 0.02750687673687935, 0.031711336225271225, 0.016079919412732124, 0.015703750774264336, 0.060982171446084976, 0.02640870027244091, 0.009726112708449364, -0.004664702340960503, -0.024007471278309822, 0.0199567973613739, -0.009275268763303757, -0.046587444841861725, -0.06034674867987633, -0.06367294490337372, -0.034672513604164124, 0.025458162650465965, 0.05908143147826195, -0.019064325839281082, -0.004408624488860369, 0.05476066842675209, -0.05241469293832779, -0.05070431903004646, -0.051972951740026474, -0.00782034918665886, 0.02010423131287098, -0.0027254680171608925, -0.0028377599082887173, 0.00559791037812829, 0.03548447787761688, -0.025057338178157806, 0.01940750516951084, -0.028328286483883858, -0.024885986000299454, 0.037441667169332504, -0.015780190005898476, 0.04035952314734459, 0.022704854607582092, 0.01196736004203558, -0.017306426540017128, 0.04149412736296654, -0.05648979917168617, 0.0009114116546697915, 0.07021898776292801, 0.012712805531919003, 0.007310462649911642, -0.035527653992176056, -0.02605191431939602, 0.0033188671804964542, -0.00670498376712203, -0.005365560296922922, 0.06499895453453064, -0.06659884750843048, 0.0948401615023613, 0.049767084419727325, 0.00830356776714325, 0.013985957950353622, 0.022833069786429405, -0.0007018596515990794, 0.019237836822867393, -0.0613793283700943, -0.024873679503798485, -0.05448709800839424, 0.0152360238134861, 0.05465467646718025, -0.0089362608268857, -0.04717494174838066, 0.0168068278580904, 0.0024500794243067503, -0.03681303933262825, 0.010614913888275623, 0.021383091807365417, -0.008365890011191368, -0.004920121282339096, 0.03339168429374695, 0.049949608743190765, -0.019986016675829887, -0.013669661246240139, 0.04325311258435249, 0.016244051977992058, 0.019588645547628403, -0.003454016288742423, -0.0018351984908804297, 0.07762150466442108, -0.002155769383534789, 0.008300031535327435, -0.0559566430747509, 0.007616355549544096, 0.036650411784648895, -0.019550630822777748, -0.03264227882027626, 0.05893881246447563, 0.020812828093767166, -0.012717672623693943, -0.016984673216938972, -0.00367128849029541, 0.022331466898322105, 0.06353345513343811, -0.0340844951570034, -0.009108386002480984, 0.011419873684644699, -0.06503148376941681, 0.032932743430137634, 0.03755391389131546, -0.03757474943995476, -0.024210751056671143, 0.029374316334724426, 0.050021275877952576, -0.012123055756092072, 0.030178220942616463, -0.018729470670223236, -0.06285557150840759, -0.025541966781020164, 0.0014676977880299091, 0.028880851343274117, -0.017245082184672356, -0.0713840052485466, -0.0444151870906353, -0.04854443669319153, 0.013649743981659412, 0.04547679424285889, -0.027065208181738853, -0.0341569259762764, 0.029679015278816223, -0.02058274671435356, -0.031573351472616196, -0.04598735645413399, -0.00873571541160345, -0.000056931356084533036, -0.01616998016834259, -0.007081125397235155, 0.04128948226571083, 0.0231062863022089, -0.013359143398702145, 0.005307506769895554, -0.038937997072935104, -0.0010886471718549728, -0.022605998441576958, -0.015631578862667084, 0.020539449527859688, 0.002622066531330347, 0.0135466568171978, 0.0063962992280721664, -0.006046116352081299, 0.018403951078653336, -0.0679243952035904, -0.061964090913534164, 0.008728626184165478, -0.01574699953198433, 0.032364461570978165, -0.018735764548182487, 0.0007536649354733527, 0.03452536463737488, 0.043650612235069275, 0.003526088083162904, -0.09000685811042786, -0.027490222826600075, -0.035790421068668365, -0.031702108681201935, 0.02797505259513855, 0.045720115303993225, 0.038176726549863815, 0.03166278451681137, -0.006844657473266125, 0.046155862510204315, 0.047608185559511185, -0.0060242097824811935, -0.025096021592617035, 0.04395993798971176, -0.009953243657946587, -0.043005041778087616, -0.002670291578397155, 0.012690872885286808, -0.03807466849684715, -0.0027025206945836544, -0.0028173949103802443, 0.027085766196250916, 0.007213926408439875, -0.05455080792307854, -0.00813475251197815, 0.00343214999884367, 0.016564521938562393, -0.03256208449602127, -0.00210189470089972, 0.00876987911760807, -0.04875105619430542, -0.0012380164116621017, -0.00550192641094327, 0.011583982966840267, -0.035492852330207825, -0.011929544620215893, 0.03814136981964111, 0.010305997915565968, -0.0067611881531775, 0.013540014624595642, -0.004517261870205402, -0.008219027891755104, 0.03793042153120041, 0.03746408969163895, 0.013639614917337894, 0.04831789433956146, 0.03841006010770798, -0.0186189953237772, -0.013496927917003632, -0.045521464198827744, 0.004381739068776369, -0.029580196365714073, -0.010021213442087173, 0.03106795623898506, 0.06345981359481812, -0.00458033150061965, 0.01464416179805994, 0.015568756498396397, -0.014735550619661808, 0.02326624095439911, -0.007367520593106747, -0.020042400807142258, 0.04596926271915436, -0.0029813782311975956, -0.017637716606259346, 0.057206105440855026, -0.010534963570535183, 0.02025652676820755, -0.02104719914495945, -0.02342117577791214, 0.008125752210617065, 0.04675798863172531, -0.03906821459531784, -0.01077587902545929, -0.002966363914310932, 0.015021485276520252, -0.006070172414183617, 0.017321279272437096, -0.01785867288708687, 0.007996193133294582, 0.02075442671775818, 0.049619410187006, 0.024294383823871613, -0.014458680525422096, -0.015426135621964931, 0.015323803760111332, 0.0236517321318388, 0.04340524971485138, 0.030266791582107544, -0.0014405945548787713, -0.05185256898403168, 0.02511564828455448, 0.003467962611466646, 0.013355414383113384, 0.037305161356925964, 0.0066823773086071014, -0.02147953398525715, -0.05003810301423073, -0.015761397778987885, -0.00927644595503807, -0.009986525401473045, 0.018182165920734406, 0.038065195083618164, 0.0797404944896698, 0.01067395694553852, -0.014198904857039452, 0.016627302393317223, 0.025911113247275352, -0.013217287138104439, 0.02135840244591236, -0.014487859793007374, -0.018085751682519913, -0.033296313136816025, -0.012276059947907925, 0.013106849044561386, -0.014035925269126892, -0.0059454613365232944, -0.013894247822463512, 0.07758283615112305, -0.013990283943712711, -0.03740544989705086, -0.024610448628664017, 0.009472372941672802, 0.0315001979470253, 0.01347419060766697, -0.06041497364640236, 0.041837580502033234, 0.03929673880338669, 0.0025103825610131025, 0.043347131460905075, 0.02329547517001629, -0.10328569263219833, 0.02115173079073429, 0.0067892116494476795, 0.04545320197939873, -0.06144098937511444, -0.02426236867904663, -0.0403364896774292, 0.020730657503008842, -0.017923451960086823, -0.0454547256231308, 0.02141612209379673, 0.0041266633197665215, 0.07546722143888474, -0.01665782742202282, -0.00034554165904410183, -0.03784538432955742, 0.0006869446951895952, -0.03349859267473221, 0.011553019285202026, -0.025889849290251732, -0.03676392138004303, -0.01412472315132618, 0.03400357812643051, 0.0033194641582667828, 0.06610853224992752, -0.0007708793273195624, -0.020904624834656715, 0.0021889761555939913, 0.04934635013341904, -0.022126946598291397, -0.021796461194753647, 0.007603551726788282, -0.030915355309844017, 0.0039693149738013744, 0.05786866694688797, 0.008576675318181515, -0.04144052416086197, -0.015641262754797935, 0.013553919270634651, -0.017836794257164, -0.024011457338929176, -0.054089706391096115, 0.032161686569452286, -0.011146322824060917, 0.010900303721427917, 0.03675268217921257, 0.05206826701760292, -0.031165987253189087, -0.0003074340056627989, -0.05515137314796448, 0.0023913916666060686, 0.004257175140082836, -0.03781953454017639, -0.02786177210509777, -0.002227251883596182, -0.016523923724889755, 0.019410936161875725, 0.017072005197405815, 0.019442379474639893, -0.03888373821973801, -0.017315149307250977, 0.008539048954844475, 0.02345390059053898, -0.017595889046788216, 0.01258525438606739, -0.010667921975255013, -0.004264948423951864, -0.007880651392042637, -0.029421091079711914, 0.04005866497755051, -0.0151462247595191, -0.0023789373226463795, 0.01198178343474865, -0.017882050946354866, 0.018049078062176704, -0.022515611723065376, -0.008733302354812622, -0.000013906925232731737, -0.022009197622537613, 0.003412004793062806, 0.006016716361045837, 0.03513721749186516, -0.008718717843294144, -0.04937951639294624, 0.0007177500519901514, 0.04172530397772789, 0.0028181602247059345, 0.03781605884432793, -0.005140392575412989, 0.0325804241001606, -0.016485804691910744, -0.024125251919031143, -0.05429429933428764, -0.0545390285551548, 0.00754196010529995, 0.006537463515996933, -0.0207495279610157, -0.031688541173934937, -0.02648637630045414, -0.017158519476652145, -0.027825236320495605, -0.011636892333626747, 0.040955476462841034, 0.002725649392232299, 0.016016704961657524, 0.007290750741958618, -0.010881278663873672, 0.07971798628568649, 0.017849335446953773, -0.043406322598457336, -0.012922138907015324, 0.009626408107578754, -0.04964672774076462, -0.0009037099662236869, -0.029567550867795944, -0.029387393966317177, -0.027592908591032028, -0.002535169245675206, -0.0067504714243113995, 0.022053193300962448, -0.023994436487555504, 0.0003229460271541029, -0.004341705236583948, -0.00770877581089735, 0.043064676225185394, -0.017122820019721985, -0.012926110997796059, -0.039926767349243164, 0.01185598038136959, -0.010705663822591305, 0.013916020281612873, -0.011353868059813976, -0.043756771832704544, 0.01781553030014038, 0.0145108075812459, -0.03778723627328873, 0.0155878234654665, 0.0651768371462822, 0.027281615883111954, 0.04095876216888428, -0.027347298339009285, -0.020616641268134117, 0.050341784954071045, 0.04625627398490906, -0.006439753342419863, 0.020527193322777748, 0.06022724136710167, -0.02747672237455845, -0.016072455793619156, -0.030477255582809448, 0.032687392085790634, 0.05801813676953316, -0.02715413272380829, 0.028967922553420067, 0.03990625962615013, -0.018847789615392685, 0.012427456676959991, -0.032985396683216095, 0.01943870633840561, -0.0043515898287296295, -0.024710817262530327, 0.048763666301965714, 0.010537379421293736, -0.030548185110092163, 0.04137387499213219, 0.005472701974213123, 0.04191666096448898, 0.03756697475910187, 0.025514697656035423, 0.009193344973027706, -0.013042931444942951, -0.0370548814535141, -0.03324676677584648, 0.03683093190193176, -0.026613840833306313, 0.009692968800663948, -0.02503117360174656, 0.005649236962199211, 0.0736999586224556, 0.04954604059457779, 0.03830360248684883, -0.03916866332292557, -0.022004717960953712, -0.03169477730989456, -0.029605016112327576, -0.0009854023810476065, -0.015195081941783428, 0.019038714468479156, 0.03532356023788452, 0.010694016702473164, 0.031074391677975655, 0.002478993032127619, -0.022124916315078735, -0.07414718717336655, -0.0338759571313858, -0.027883050963282585, -0.012608835473656654, 0.029361000284552574, -0.007965630851686, -0.02227681875228882, 0.011078588664531708, -0.05154428631067276, 0.017880402505397797, -0.01696951501071453, 0.004735826980322599, 0.010302604176104069, 0.06496816128492355, 0.011342765763401985, 0.026396358385682106, 0.044579099863767624, -0.01041225902736187, 0.09799998998641968, 0.09593760967254639, 0.005521596875041723, -0.04823911562561989, 0.017038673162460327, 0.020406020805239677, 0.02536916732788086, 0.0026323271449655294, -0.022008955478668213, 0.02103937603533268, -0.02135215885937214, 0.04523609206080437, 0.005529708694666624, 0.051921967417001724, 0.0012989738024771214, 0.0565468966960907, -0.04528038948774338, -0.06651561707258224, 0.02728409506380558, -0.0026651713997125626, 0.0012998433085158467, -0.02623511664569378, -0.022999566048383713, 0.02084987424314022, -0.009408296085894108, -0.020062703639268875, -0.030973218381404877, 0.0011517693055793643, 0.006478617433458567, -0.008926852606236935, -0.03203582391142845, -0.007476243656128645, 0.024120330810546875, 0.02246231772005558, -0.021768035367131233, -0.008669366128742695, -0.017001882195472717, -0.036461710929870605, 0.021080847829580307, 0.02992303855717182, -0.058284539729356766, -0.00947497133165598, 0.009271849878132343, -0.006677683442831039, -0.04467451944947243, 0.0037686515133827925, -0.03810809180140495, 0.05013749375939369, 0.0015288320137187839, -0.031239600852131844, -0.019792983308434486, 0.015143548138439655, -0.032915882766246796, -0.045724593102931976, -0.04175844416022301, 0.05680497735738754, 0.02381700836122036, -0.008947235532104969, -0.06406643241643906, -0.020303549244999886, 0.02497009001672268, 0.012496234849095345, 0.030502399429678917, 0.03801100701093674, -0.04048629477620125, -0.00017799687338992953, -0.028386486694216728, 0.063614621758461, -0.029446283355355263, 0.012555958703160286, 0.013842152431607246, -0.0062135569751262665, -0.033624786883592606, -0.02835274673998356, 0.0040769269689917564, 0.016529252752661705, -0.004943285137414932, -0.01671905815601349, 0.0010411988478153944, -0.04328754171729088, -0.042160023003816605, 0.011416797526180744, -0.024371059611439705, 0.012488958425819874, -0.07060705870389938, 0.019669679924845695, 0.01515465509146452, 0.0150357186794281, 0.014670738950371742, 0.012819742783904076, -0.004592088051140308, 0.033962853252887726, -0.014449908398091793, -0.05980547145009041, -0.03806548938155174, 0.0037504087667912245, -0.03820851072669029, 0.016010480001568794, -0.04906265065073967, 0.03985466808080673, -0.018212689086794853, -0.009273759089410305, 0.022038539871573448, 0.044829804450273514, 0.013492442667484283, 0.006526704877614975, 0.005959410220384598, -0.02402263879776001, 0.016454406082630157, 0.011606818996369839, 0.009266729466617107, -0.004991683177649975, -0.016619762405753136, -0.028163811191916466, -0.04148353636264801, 0.03641537204384804, -0.05559121072292328, -0.013219105079770088, -0.01656479202210903, -0.04926186800003052, 0.030046986415982246, -0.011172495782375336, -0.005690603982657194, -0.06420856714248657, -0.009246946312487125, 0.0009090292151086032, -0.020452605560421944, 0.009552798233926296, 0.02120407484471798, -0.009873722679913044, -0.009919147938489914, 0.0261810552328825, 0.02590462751686573, 0.004490633495151997, -0.013156569562852383, 0.05324823409318924, -0.013561565428972244, 0.047573626041412354, -0.057710565626621246, -0.013465886004269123, 0.037518832832574844, -0.029037069529294968, 0.0005765817477367818, 0.046204790472984314, -0.016099588945508003, 0.029501432552933693, 0.013533019460737705, 0.001697030384093523, 0.009610430337488651, 0.07659422606229782, -0.0069603086449205875, 0.0002561549190431833, -0.025517165660858154, -0.0026083204429596663, -0.007062998600304127, 0.008968428708612919, -0.0497923344373703, 0.022209547460079193, -0.01997976191341877, 0.040832117199897766, 0.050268176943063736, 0.00863446295261383, -0.037769824266433716, -0.034052349627017975, 0.041874125599861145, 0.020726069808006287, 0.017357539385557175, -0.026360129937529564, 0.033633217215538025, 0.03878633305430412, -0.01813453622162342, 0.011074880138039589, -0.0048963832668960094, 0.014137850143015385, -0.0634586364030838, -0.03997289761900902, 0.007367963902652264, 0.022717144340276718, 0.03897518664598465, -0.04735976457595825, 0.03616837039589882, 0.023106537759304047, 0.009506170637905598, -0.031767476350069046, 0.01016249693930149, -0.009703136049211025, -0.015853799879550934, -0.007597771007567644, 0.007206002250313759, 0.01869949698448181, 0.03720732033252716, 0.015102994628250599, 0.035389624536037445, 0.007001448422670364, -0.0237454604357481, -0.033313002437353134, -0.00280465604737401, 0.01635160483419895, 0.009038611315190792, -0.040791384875774384, 0.012989869341254234, -0.021908478811383247, -0.04028851538896561, 0.04177778959274292, -0.008514308370649815, -0.007812919095158577, 0.08522295206785202, 0.022236613556742668, 0.03609732538461685, 0.06034515053033829, 0.014142768457531929, -0.01267244853079319, -0.010245955549180508, 0.00360754132270813, -0.0011355344904586673, 0.009559929370880127, -0.0003715466591529548, 0.018137937411665916, 0.02081531658768654, -0.025068312883377075, 0.003650850150734186, -0.007402470801025629, -0.043340858072042465, 0.00015675548638682812, -0.029170267283916473, -0.0015938469441607594, 0.010328308679163456, -0.032141197472810745, 0.04414418712258339, -0.03994244709610939, -0.028136469423770905, 0.047494616359472275, 0.01830284856259823, -0.03275929391384125, -0.014765115454792976, 0.0004648550821002573, -0.011621071957051754, -0.0008037494262680411, 0.010303384624421597, 0.013781198300421238, -0.01707593724131584, -0.033970825374126434, -0.009842735715210438, -0.014172530733048916, -0.009713025763630867, 0.02893923781812191, -0.06882909685373306, 0.046560902148485184, -0.04958074912428856, 0.002135519403964281, 0.03630892187356949, -0.0009588726097717881, 0.016991805285215378, -0.07510283589363098, 0.04152486100792885, 0.00983999203890562, -0.041448552161455154, -0.04939830303192139, 0.022561756893992424, -0.05638964846730232, 0.002913032891228795, 0.05926709994673729, 0.004763023462146521, 0.010318338871002197, -0.017308862879872322, 0.020548120141029358, -0.015892302617430687, 0.0007294495590031147, 0.04845324158668518, -0.0019197429064661264, -0.03305242210626602, -0.017535341903567314, -0.01015041209757328, 0.02706502377986908, 0.01850748062133789, 0.011670125648379326, -0.017028218135237694, -0.014697467908263206, 0.006883131805807352, -0.004876736551523209, 0.03803062438964844, -0.006978414952754974, -0.002158570569008589, 0.0454857237637043, -0.022060563787817955, 0.04063905403017998, 0.018153736367821693, -0.006728081498295069, -0.06200491636991501, 0.063469797372818, 0.0100135188549757, -0.018957732245326042, 0.01613321527838707, -0.013909725472331047, 0.01047065481543541, -0.006249977741390467, 0.03386171907186508, 0.02490522712469101, -0.010357901453971863, 0.01304609701037407, 0.04374679550528526, 0.019337298348546028, 0.006314869970083237, -0.024069271981716156, 0.020262522622942924, -0.010721375234425068, -0.028757369145751, -0.004262734670192003, 0.012715021148324013, 0.011053708381950855, 0.001631897292099893, 0.032283373177051544, 0.023547064512968063, -0.00554309319704771, 0.038703180849552155, 0.015066378749907017, 0.03424927219748497, -0.006547318305820227, 0.007209776435047388, -0.01771954819560051, 0.0025802941527217627, 0.03198790177702904, -0.0044410256668925285, -0.013024595566093922, 0.030893752351403236, -0.031205397099256516, 0.01782529056072235, -0.0368710458278656, -0.04386518523097038, -0.02157456986606121, -0.01396472379565239, 0.04951220750808716, 0.06424128264188766, 0.027390558272600174, 0.009162355214357376, 0.02351858839392662, -0.04456228390336037, 0.014245150610804558, -0.010927412658929825, -0.0138180460780859, -0.005400547757744789, -0.029372628778219223, -0.013375801965594292, -0.010197087191045284, -0.028186170384287834, -0.028559556230902672, 0.0271263737231493, 0.051541805267333984, 0.010606436058878899, -0.01933925412595272, -0.039380259811878204, 0.014545297250151634, 0.026620961725711823, -0.03650490939617157, 0.008099357597529888, -0.047618474811315536, 0.010475479066371918, 0.0008925122092477977, -0.01431730855256319 ]
<p>I have six variables measuring hotels' facilities by a group of managers. In the end, I want to compare mean scores for these six variables to determine which facility is actually favored in the hotel industry. </p> <p>Can I use a one-way repeated measures ANOVA to check if there are statistical differences between mean scores for these variables?</p>
73,549
[ -0.08006007224321365, 0.01355131808668375, -0.0202860776335001, 0.0073701851069927216, 0.0791284516453743, 0.03833092749118805, 0.019862867891788483, -0.010885810479521751, -0.008238337002694607, -0.006583480164408684, 0.04301154240965843, 0.017683545127511024, 0.04598693177103996, 0.01543375849723816, 0.023476921021938324, -0.026156971231102943, 0.006880519445985556, 0.01125576812773943, -0.013588432222604752, -0.00919324904680252, -0.01662531867623329, 0.011321966536343098, -0.007874707691371441, -0.008563553914427757, -0.01787869818508625, 0.026036065071821213, 0.011826692149043083, -0.06313394010066986, 0.0030920859426259995, 0.02568156272172928, -0.011758320033550262, -0.028173254802823067, -0.00527293561026454, 0.05349579453468323, 0.036779291927814484, -0.024211401119828224, -0.004312886390835047, 0.01819480210542679, -0.0013600318925455213, 0.03419867157936096, -0.015826357528567314, -0.016207227483391762, -0.00038811733247712255, 0.023121695965528488, 0.007250609342008829, 0.014226168394088745, -0.016461770981550217, -0.03487517684698105, 0.031252581626176834, -0.06131715327501297, 0.07858366519212723, 0.009290658868849277, 0.014419876970350742, 0.03868197277188301, -0.027484077960252762, -0.006031882483512163, 0.029909703880548477, 0.03345394507050514, 0.008191464468836784, -0.0430464893579483, 0.024379601702094078, 0.003997667692601681, -0.0005007048603147268, 0.03725069388747215, -0.06407327204942703, 0.015609062276780605, -0.013365686871111393, -0.0027192707639187574, 0.06331536918878555, -0.0228144358843565, 0.016244912520051003, 0.024779727682471275, 0.054569751024246216, 0.006050894968211651, 0.009872889146208763, -0.01942460983991623, 0.028589796274900436, -0.020885789766907692, 0.07550002634525299, 0.04700737074017525, 0.011708385311067104, 0.000454330031061545, -0.0011048360029235482, 0.027613187208771706, 0.040436308830976486, -0.044594068080186844, 0.04064905643463135, -0.059687647968530655, -0.004880924243479967, 0.0301872156560421, 0.003576885908842087, -0.013485473580658436, 0.04216824844479561, 0.0382615365087986, -0.03152120113372803, 0.008033912628889084, -0.03997490182518959, 0.04601254686713219, -0.017807641997933388, 0.005680459085851908, -0.02402619831264019, -0.030302781611680984, 0.012563571333885193, 0.02078203484416008, -0.02678724192082882, 0.0067536490969359875, -0.002362386789172888, 0.023395290598273277, 0.020361531525850296, 0.006452739704400301, -0.04949181154370308, 0.013942322693765163, 0.028503013774752617, -0.013797106221318245, 0.04978556931018829, -0.013714396394789219, -0.03928355872631073, -0.0004407835949677974, 0.04875811189413071, 0.08487468957901001, 0.05558855086565018, -0.03456588461995125, 0.009850677102804184, -0.0278145931661129, -0.015540065243840218, 0.00035951886093243957, 0.010350133292376995, 0.003024681005626917, -0.027231315150856972, 0.08054114133119583, 0.0005387492710724473, 0.012723414227366447, 0.035910919308662415, -0.012968512251973152, 0.045466549694538116, 0.022013043984770775, -0.11711852252483368, -0.058288056403398514, 0.004664949141442776, 0.004882180131971836, 0.0008971207425929606, -0.04119652882218361, 0.002430235967040062, 0.021762866526842117, 0.03470875695347786, 0.03386169672012329, 0.02565990760922432, 0.013625754043459892, 0.0225199144333601, 0.014443651773035526, 0.006293344311416149, -0.01985648274421692, -0.008257742039859295, -0.04786543548107147, -0.0013220661785453558, -0.11765479296445847, 0.018341004848480225, -0.01144418679177761, -0.017790846526622772, 0.010513760149478912, 0.00819051917642355, 0.01712450385093689, -0.003965163603425026, 0.033302191644907, 0.04737981781363487, 0.007674977649003267, 0.03230860456824303, -0.035337794572114944, 0.018908893689513206, 0.005716689862310886, 0.0073975324630737305, -0.01213773712515831, -0.017401425167918205, 0.020755110308527946, 0.03853389248251915, -0.014565341174602509, 0.009455148130655289, 0.012312471866607666, 0.037982672452926636, 0.024193815886974335, -0.029165929183363914, -0.021577034145593643, -0.0523257702589035, -0.006098947022110224, 0.017798371613025665, 0.04182321950793266, -0.0012714228359982371, -0.0025499495677649975, 0.05158445984125137, -0.02076810598373413, -0.024049099534749985, -0.08035948127508163, 0.0004216589732095599, 0.0005134464590810239, -0.0020932313054800034, 0.0404936745762825, 0.0027072113007307053, 0.00017029284208547324, -0.039790078997612, -0.00890293251723051, -0.014133934862911701, -0.009394457563757896, 0.04643722623586655, -0.05600275844335556, 0.01246038731187582, 0.029416626319289207, 0.06442046910524368, -0.032351087778806686, 0.05756184086203575, -0.07385072857141495, -0.06371761113405228, -0.018503602594137192, -0.04672306776046753, -0.008625898510217667, 0.005536722019314766, 0.018655551597476006, 0.03736976161599159, 0.03854834660887718, -0.0438137911260128, 0.03814060986042023, -0.05132400617003441, 0.04422587528824806, 0.06513737887144089, -0.02390403114259243, 0.035527680069208145, 0.003761992556974292, 0.03225567936897278, 0.02900712937116623, -0.021526450291275978, -0.04521747678518295, -0.05811423435807228, -0.012111932039260864, 0.014044689945876598, -0.012768654152750969, -0.03216017410159111, 0.054346270859241486, 0.05766989663243294, 0.01552983932197094, 0.008949676528573036, 0.023422494530677795, 0.009941311553120613, 0.014407415874302387, 0.011687802150845528, 0.05723016336560249, 0.058706339448690414, 0.0312546007335186, 0.007214554585516453, 0.021376589313149452, 0.028498707339167595, 0.02580486424267292, 0.058317288756370544, 0.0012880851281806827, 0.001403373433277011, 0.006150176748633385, -0.021314680576324463, -0.018096456304192543, 0.04213332384824753, -0.021853206679224968, 0.017203733325004578, 0.03555496037006378, 0.016408931463956833, -0.01053998339921236, 0.019484149292111397, -0.05415363982319832, 0.020378349348902702, 0.036496881395578384, 0.0016092263394966722, -0.010272877290844917, 0.022857116535305977, -0.008530129678547382, 0.045228276401758194, -0.062351446598768234, -0.005811548326164484, -0.01725977659225464, 0.00942171085625887, 0.028424415737390518, -0.02991381473839283, -0.008957062847912312, -0.03497287631034851, 0.029590316116809845, -0.01634984277188778, -0.037648726254701614, -0.033636875450611115, 0.007966116070747375, -0.04843005910515785, 0.020349374040961266, -0.031477078795433044, 0.027331644669175148, 0.013449713587760925, -0.03729571774601936, -0.0010488310363143682, 0.06947683542966843, 0.01910197176039219, -0.05952584370970726, -0.02924872562289238, -0.014726506546139717, 0.0208795927464962, -0.01242632232606411, -0.02060098573565483, 0.04174401983618736, 0.015929363667964935, -0.027031730860471725, 0.008024223148822784, -0.02386145293712616, 0.009275571443140507, 0.02333569899201393, -0.03742830082774162, 0.023299984633922577, -0.009016990661621094, -0.00986015610396862, 0.035653989762067795, -0.03737733140587807, -0.010818833485245705, -0.056457653641700745, -0.060870032757520676, 0.004001650493592024, -0.015752237290143967, 0.039858825504779816, 0.0005585549515672028, 0.00564414169639349, 0.055028948932886124, 0.05905594676733017, -0.04360956326127052, -0.04715043306350708, -0.01726360432803631, -0.015550337731838226, -0.044494710862636566, 0.03434496372938156, -0.0005625109188258648, -0.010537237860262394, 0.023679831996560097, 0.02034156396985054, 0.014560622163116932, 0.056681130081415176, 0.023885516449809074, -0.03077797405421734, -0.008343568071722984, 0.040398821234703064, -0.006495170760899782, 0.02696361392736435, -0.017804710194468498, -0.041881050914525986, -0.01366370264440775, 0.01789082959294319, 0.04242832958698273, -0.0015339964302256703, -0.03378653898835182, 0.03816251829266548, -0.04041231423616409, 0.010084296576678753, -0.012691445648670197, 0.01430334523320198, 0.025296073406934738, 0.030685413628816605, -0.016543637961149216, 0.010525303892791271, 0.0035719096194952726, -0.03506307303905487, 0.017964795231819153, 0.03959831967949867, 0.040314365178346634, 0.002457314869388938, -0.0204030591994524, -0.017953136935830116, -0.008903486654162407, 0.01492179837077856, -0.01557761151343584, -0.03674667328596115, 0.0217733196914196, 0.03158683329820633, 0.0245666541159153, -0.020111989229917526, -0.025594545528292656, 0.007237755227833986, -0.05726885050535202, 0.019043738022446632, -0.03308791294693947, 0.02917640283703804, 0.009569664485752583, 0.05119871720671654, 0.007584959268569946, -0.019716085866093636, -0.03680579736828804, -0.026072341948747635, -0.02835667133331299, 0.0156706515699625, -0.026689207181334496, 0.006406878586858511, 0.011243654415011406, -0.04416033625602722, 0.022930342704057693, -0.007944920100271702, 0.030998583883047104, -0.01126550417393446, 0.03438575193285942, -0.016488635912537575, -0.025091366842389107, -0.009566129185259342, -0.03169967234134674, -0.0076123857870697975, 0.0352032370865345, 0.021072836592793465, -0.037382204085588455, 0.05085472762584686, 0.0051713185384869576, -0.014210285618901253, -0.01090745348483324, -0.009670061990618706, 0.01788385957479477, -0.00041773144039325416, 0.03847154602408409, 0.0035448987036943436, 0.024183789268136024, -0.03759331628680229, 0.03230937197804451, 0.015876691788434982, 0.01356277335435152, 0.013877389952540398, 0.01780068129301071, -0.02882504276931286, -0.014892223291099072, -0.03825324773788452, 0.01564224623143673, 0.010258413851261139, 0.002314432756975293, -0.009107641875743866, 0.00843123160302639, 0.027166713029146194, -0.06384724378585815, -0.007094049360603094, 0.036090824753046036, 0.03942418843507767, -0.009225821122527122, -0.036688730120658875, -0.01373566035181284, -0.005286088213324547, -0.04036400094628334, 0.023837272077798843, 0.023345082998275757, -0.02268601581454277, 0.037767812609672546, 0.051081735640764236, 0.031668491661548615, -0.07004635781049728, 0.010690310038626194, -0.012118888087570667, 0.011530137620866299, -0.0018013854278251529, -0.02462671883404255, 0.018727140501141548, 0.03435142710804939, 0.012449623085558414, 0.012240001931786537, -0.018798919394612312, -0.06839054822921753, -0.0015691736480221152, 0.06453724205493927, 0.011805003508925438, -0.012694847770035267, 0.017700528725981712, 0.012975061312317848, -0.008210867643356323, 0.0317685641348362, -0.023630045354366302, 0.030758852139115334, 0.008013402111828327, 0.011654801666736603, -0.0442809984087944, -0.014833071269094944, -0.04244145378470421, 0.015228652395308018, -0.02112969569861889, 0.015529950149357319, 0.015237917192280293, -0.014342455193400383, -0.04598311334848404, -0.02292240783572197, 0.06310202926397324, 0.014146437868475914, -0.0036933787632733583, 0.011690004728734493, 0.02895360440015793, 0.015010486356914043, -0.020233232527971268, -0.06712254136800766, 0.028861066326498985, 0.0191997941583395, -0.0031447731889784336, 0.05984015017747879, -0.04424992948770523, -0.043820761144161224, 0.026972776278853416, -0.004949945490807295, 0.006589604075998068, -0.003988313488662243, -0.03377123549580574, 0.028779789805412292, 0.01853623241186142, 0.012968264520168304, 0.056229498237371445, 0.013074402697384357, 0.006552386563271284, 0.023690856993198395, -0.02746974304318428, 0.01144964899867773, -0.03232511505484581, -0.03609723597764969, -0.005087046418339014, -0.021764762699604034, -0.003855668008327484, 0.007672171574085951, 0.004196193069219589, 0.05770563334226608, -0.02436027117073536, -0.015574950724840164, 0.01728307642042637, 0.014729822985827923, 0.02993086352944374, -0.010530575178563595, -0.00007177892257459462, -0.004685566294938326, -0.0307661984115839, -0.021633237600326538, 0.01805207133293152, -0.03228755295276642, 0.0023628927301615477, 0.012670175172388554, -0.06253435462713242, 0.03774649649858475, -0.02869044803082943, -0.027082527056336403, 0.017071682959794998, -0.05689100921154022, 0.03657156601548195, -0.026872649788856506, 0.029208067804574966, 0.031053980812430382, -0.021584616973996162, -0.0028414237312972546, 0.040659889578819275, -0.01866813562810421, -0.01382425706833601, -0.009831845760345459, 0.03585170954465866, -0.03189506009221077, -0.0035977307707071304, -0.07409989088773727, -0.003700884757563472, 0.01712390035390854, 0.021014900878071785, 0.0024288895074278116, -0.010013557970523834, -0.0346192941069603, 0.009547696448862553, -0.008266576565802097, -0.08702351897954941, 0.06330696493387222, 0.007865365594625473, 0.002515455475077033, 0.046257611364126205, 0.027406854555010796, 0.08942443877458572, 0.0023802875075489283, -0.018580567091703415, -0.006834807805716991, -0.017510106787085533, 0.0018832838395610452, -0.019240275025367737, -0.0024263677187263966, -0.03943663835525513, -0.023240461945533752, -0.03961571678519249, 0.016881080344319344, 0.023105600848793983, -0.03412830829620361, -0.01658259518444538, 0.03327389806509018, -0.02162209153175354, -0.016283534467220306, -0.055733051151037216, 0.01769924908876419, -0.0012220824137330055, -0.01819075457751751, -0.021502533927559853, 0.027073776349425316, -0.017026346176862717, 0.026264501735568047, 0.019139030948281288, 0.03105464205145836, -0.02256247028708458, 0.023045092821121216, 0.08243671804666519, 0.011774878948926926, -0.003110113786533475, 0.01095835492014885, -0.013362906873226166, 0.0008620279259048402, -0.006695337127894163, -0.0379183329641819, -0.021853752434253693, 0.030287131667137146, -0.050082821398973465, -0.007506371475756168, 0.005620029289275408, -0.024648072198033333, 0.0633072778582573, 0.025450121611356735, 0.03398635610938072, 0.06071702390909195, 0.030103256925940514, -0.014076679944992065, -0.033334698528051376, 0.013954189606010914, 0.02439536154270172, 0.00602782191708684, 0.06859738379716873, 0.00013257924001663923, 0.02501043677330017, -0.0045470683835446835, 0.044422902166843414, 0.009256767109036446, 0.044653069227933884, 0.02006000652909279, 0.03341544046998024, 0.01853429339826107, 0.006395505275577307, -0.032390296459198, 0.04879504442214966, -0.03567423298954964, 0.017387066036462784, -0.06037309020757675, 0.01628340594470501, 0.03444861248135567, 0.061914484947919846, -0.003706236369907856, -0.05858511105179787, -0.01655741222202778, -0.05236091464757919, 0.03569499030709267, 0.0205544363707304, 0.01531403511762619, 0.008514579385519028, 0.03739502653479576, 0.05264735594391823, -0.03011687472462654, -0.028414014726877213, -0.0366857685148716, -0.047097060829401016, -0.00715864822268486, -0.01107687596231699, -0.024403434246778488, 0.03838708624243736, -0.02550230547785759, -0.020484279841184616, 0.026821615174412727, -0.04264906421303749, -0.002267935313284397, -0.022440314292907715, 0.013769568875432014, 0.024270864203572273, 0.01853541098535061, 0.004296408034861088, -0.0016554034082219005, 0.01576395146548748, 0.029146891087293625, 0.11580115556716919, 0.05731453746557236, 0.026976851746439934, -0.05764924734830856, 0.01499915961176157, 0.03190470486879349, 0.007848234847187996, -0.01960710436105728, 0.010215237736701965, -0.037310972809791565, 0.0013223420828580856, 0.04201660305261612, 0.0463697649538517, 0.005087411962449551, 0.007485176436603069, 0.05873175337910652, -0.019814852625131607, 0.005096798297017813, 0.0018552513793110847, 0.00429545808583498, 0.007573935203254223, -0.02452518604695797, -0.008700134232640266, 0.02803894504904747, 0.022949809208512306, 0.008289250545203686, 0.006624220870435238, -0.051561374217271805, 0.005888577550649643, 0.02202627621591091, 0.025907855480909348, 0.043548665940761566, 0.005634943954646587, 0.0024883178994059563, -0.03986900672316551, -0.0038538933731615543, 0.039122872054576874, -0.05331035330891609, -0.011378880590200424, 0.02983039617538452, -0.01983628049492836, -0.02236633375287056, -0.003531831316649914, -0.0025519898626953363, -0.06446746736764908, -0.007844839245080948, -0.010392953641712666, -0.009878816083073616, 0.03283146023750305, -0.029477430507540703, -0.030368002131581306, -0.022445939481258392, -0.004027788992971182, -0.036696210503578186, -0.008524621836841106, 0.022784579545259476, 0.0359734483063221, -0.061742138117551804, -0.01450105756521225, -0.05296184867620468, -0.007193363271653652, -0.02255556359887123, 0.02640647254884243, 0.0029663024470210075, -0.016531631350517273, -0.027969738468527794, -0.0546998456120491, 0.038646116852760315, 0.014677455648779869, -0.03174500912427902, -0.025233741849660873, 0.001301424577832222, -0.021570978686213493, 0.00288453814573586, -0.006645627785474062, 0.015948228538036346, 0.03536083176732063, 0.03194412589073181, -0.016439035534858704, -0.025600243359804153, -0.04875856637954712, -0.003848370397463441, -0.03936222195625305, -0.026335833594202995, -0.009775916114449501, -0.030032750219106674, 0.03894171491265297, 0.059333786368370056, 0.04749511554837227, -0.016984837129712105, 0.015542374923825264, 0.056657254695892334, 0.036108266562223434, -0.0651988834142685, 0.01105467788875103, -0.02088981494307518, -0.06208835914731026, -0.02684762515127659, -0.04112747311592102, 0.052724435925483704, 0.04898252710700035, 0.00856015831232071, -0.01930946111679077, 0.012722818180918694, -0.043226420879364014, 0.015513136051595211, 0.025933893397450447, -0.061149805784225464, -0.010643300600349903, 0.018576163798570633, 0.022173501551151276, -0.02216522768139839, -0.06851085275411606, -0.048438191413879395, -0.03302406147122383, 0.02594071999192238, -0.04973302409052849, 0.011488242074847221, -0.009579576551914215, 0.02038402669131756, 0.02919859066605568, -0.025296663865447044, -0.022356592118740082, -0.05940797179937363, -0.036427296698093414, -0.0018644442316144705, -0.004362192004919052, -0.002347413217648864, 0.005024705082178116, -0.02539212442934513, 0.027710728347301483, 0.051253750920295715, 0.0035993806086480618, 0.01952548138797283, -0.007712998427450657, -0.009618498384952545, 0.018887383863329887, 0.07194648683071136, 0.007074205204844475, 0.000345964333973825, 0.03100290521979332, -0.007886340841650963, -0.015350127592682838, -0.007555392105132341, 0.014718042686581612, 0.04676290601491928, 0.017784424126148224, 0.01500408910214901, -0.009950988925993443, 0.02186516672372818, -0.03164179250597954, -0.04472030699253082, -0.015316901728510857, -0.006083537824451923, 0.04583558067679405, -0.006120412610471249, 0.011153238825500011, 0.007559811230748892, -0.044309310615062714, 0.026975048705935478, 0.0426831990480423, 0.010169786401093006, -0.00831308588385582, -0.03238054737448692, -0.017617138102650642, 0.00011466153955552727, 0.007644958328455687, -0.013384995982050896, 0.005470868665724993, 0.04505493864417076, -0.029530396685004234, 0.015743235126137733, -0.007441289257258177, 0.003249797970056534, -0.05429798364639282, -0.025640740990638733, -0.0061874850653111935, 0.005608469247817993, 0.02167167142033577, -0.03994229435920715, 0.011549059301614761, 0.039815761148929596, -0.06953328847885132, 0.016158921644091606, 0.024480927735567093, -0.0447525754570961, -0.0406607948243618, 0.035667598247528076, -0.004666527267545462, -0.004757025744765997, 0.0035968509037047625, 0.0010368447983637452, -0.0013563017128035426, 0.04449016600847244, 0.013750278390944004, -0.047052718698978424, 0.026314161717891693, 0.040693510323762894, 0.029862046241760254, -0.08108656853437424, 0.0244270209223032, -0.03208741173148155, -0.04579249769449234, 0.008390816859900951, -0.03577592223882675, 0.010984230786561966, 0.0024793001357465982, 0.007836390286684036, 0.010500282980501652, 0.07072523236274719, 0.04637930914759636, 0.007660612463951111, -0.026231177151203156, -0.01943700760602951, -0.017852656543254852, 0.012254339642822742, -0.0031292513012886047, 0.009779243730008602, 0.05643855780363083, -0.0036377471406012774, -0.040299128741025925, 0.011196136474609375, -0.016612583771348, -0.040021348744630814, -0.03613080456852913, -0.012492498382925987, 0.03709855675697327, 0.0057719117030501366, 0.008616812527179718, -0.04487047716975212, 0.020796392112970352, 0.027689747512340546, -0.019546035677194595, -0.04771127551794052, 0.03271297737956047, 0.02029244601726532, -0.025760186836123466, 0.020343340933322906, -0.017642391845583916, -0.04446613788604736, -0.06645698100328445, 0.015913594514131546, -0.014045972377061844, -0.01402439083904028, -0.04678985849022865, -0.0025459975004196167, 0.005420607049018145, -0.006541081238538027, -0.019293352961540222, -0.0005119028501212597, 0.03362821787595749, -0.0180561151355505, -0.02030104026198387, -0.08681001514196396, 0.06896264851093292, 0.021715199574828148, -0.03662426769733429, -0.03157418593764305, -0.03625214844942093, -0.05880429595708847, 0.009216110222041607, 0.06629636883735657, 0.020703256130218506, -0.001395337749272585, 0.02230341173708439, 0.01494824793189764, 0.022766191512346268, -0.08484720438718796, 0.0304860882461071, -0.007503168191760778, -0.026195229962468147, 0.034610092639923096, 0.008428854867815971, 0.0027780127711594105, -0.014705662615597248, 0.026202455163002014, -0.03431747108697891, 0.024579834192991257, 0.0003727538569364697, 0.014231658540666103, 0.02498561516404152, 0.018179340288043022, -0.023299841210246086, 0.017136380076408386, -0.020346349105238914, 0.0018907854100689292, 0.018645908683538437, -0.012375300750136375, -0.051214076578617096, 0.039190713316202164, -0.022483112290501595, -0.005448583047837019, 0.0034583795350044966, 0.00825447216629982, -0.00920606218278408, -0.05570442974567413, 0.008636914193630219, 0.026723414659500122, -0.031174546107649803, 0.004161754157394171, 0.027271589264273643, 0.005415272433310747, -0.02203569933772087, -0.01860564947128296, 0.030550211668014526, -0.016084088012576103, -0.02552742138504982, -0.007219573017209768, 0.041637156158685684, 0.012283387593925, 0.011922562494874, -0.022092482075095177, 0.028669679537415504, -0.013082889840006828, 0.023581326007843018, 0.013036536984145641, 0.03858394920825958, 0.0003850754292216152, -0.019828779622912407, 0.04064719006419182, 0.011535387486219406, 0.01651054434478283, -0.0014899467350915074, -0.011926434934139252, 0.07456813752651215, -0.02556736394762993, 0.018423672765493393, -0.04582950100302696, -0.000660591060295701, -0.031999893486499786, -0.02659645862877369, 0.03905627876520157, 0.016593197360634804, 0.014652376994490623, -0.009381318464875221, 0.013014474883675575, -0.010639903135597706, -0.025217805057764053, -0.03676917776465416, 0.02068011835217476, -0.014059492386877537, 0.011263420805335045, -0.046484291553497314, -0.008377615362405777, -0.04964163526892662, -0.010750418528914452, 0.04227380454540253, 0.024438008666038513, 0.03800167143344879, -0.016586672514677048, -0.05066126212477684, 0.009946941398084164, 0.06355039030313492, -0.07141194492578506, -0.043749336153268814, -0.028179125860333443, -0.0013762960443273187, -0.01632358878850937, -0.021794568747282028 ]
<p>In <em>Optimal Hedging Using Cointegration</em>, C. Alexander, 1999 (<a href="http://www.icmacentre.ac.uk/pdf/cointegration.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://www.icmacentre.ac.uk/pdf/cointegration.pdf</a>), page 3, footnote #2:</p> <blockquote> <p>[...] a PCA of cointegrated variables will yield the common stochastic trend as the first Principal Component [..]</p> </blockquote> <p>I am struggling to work out a proof of this statement. I'd be thankful if you could give me a hand.</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
35,946
[ -0.03037862852215767, -0.03738223761320114, 0.0332828089594841, 0.029386257752776146, 0.026542875915765762, 0.010053416714072227, 0.006144208367913961, -0.009564176201820374, 0.055772967636585236, -0.05269860103726387, 0.012547195889055729, 0.028673863038420677, 0.08902237564325333, 0.05429742857813835, 0.00600667018443346, 0.010225672274827957, 0.01683090627193451, 0.00904824212193489, 0.009271882474422455, -0.005133984610438347, 0.011865186505019665, 0.03684588149189949, 0.017918748781085014, -0.004545378498733044, 0.01797899790108204, 0.045740023255348206, 0.024356001988053322, -0.004282045178115368, 0.017775464802980423, 0.08272085338830948, -0.0455196239054203, -0.012941124849021435, 0.005744383670389652, 0.04540319740772247, 0.004963852930814028, 0.01593148335814476, -0.005437009502202272, 0.0019940470810979605, 0.033437252044677734, 0.05283109471201897, -0.018919482827186584, -0.0328335277736187, 0.05795474722981453, 0.05716418847441673, -0.0004132873145863414, 0.017926717177033424, 0.005885527469217777, -0.011746170930564404, 0.06985853612422943, -0.03169895336031914, 0.08840300887823105, -0.029197553172707558, 0.0314403772354126, 0.04177898168563843, 0.00012216631148476154, 0.01279499102383852, 0.04282325133681297, 0.05975855514407158, -0.01919054239988327, -0.0917600691318512, -0.0029733607079833746, -0.011826288886368275, 0.019456518813967705, -0.022308625280857086, -0.0421418659389019, 0.00530507555231452, -0.01378517597913742, -0.03591407462954521, 0.021112848073244095, -0.051841579377651215, 0.018351653590798378, -0.03788105025887489, 0.03944802284240723, -0.038457442075014114, -0.006435163784772158, -0.012080606073141098, -0.001940055750310421, 0.06103569269180298, 0.04590495303273201, 0.01846323534846306, -0.003040816867724061, 0.01172614749521017, 0.02538011223077774, 0.02034624107182026, 0.009200531989336014, 0.021540919318795204, 0.08567587286233902, -0.03478323295712471, 0.04555685818195343, 0.02785309962928295, 0.00291655957698822, 0.005432199686765671, 0.04754694178700447, -0.005896248389035463, -0.049512285739183426, 0.040164243429899216, -0.0002588966453913599, 0.021296652033925056, 0.00902252271771431, -0.013519711792469025, -0.0031949710100889206, -0.037314776331186295, -0.005131058394908905, 0.01683223806321621, 0.004135672934353352, 0.02465932071208954, -0.03370792791247368, 0.018816301599144936, -0.0374763198196888, -0.016224758699536324, -0.06773924082517624, 0.02710135281085968, 0.019478866830468178, -0.021470263600349426, -0.027795789763331413, 0.005124310497194529, -0.011416399851441383, 0.028329279273748398, 0.028531495481729507, 0.04002171382308006, 0.03501443564891815, -0.016937898471951485, 0.002911830320954323, -0.01396286953240633, -0.06807181239128113, 0.0075362916104495525, -0.001147271366789937, -0.035068731755018234, -0.06379371881484985, 0.08316171169281006, -0.0045542847365140915, -0.04691160470247269, 0.018574578687548637, 0.026491492986679077, 0.006650790572166443, -0.010035308077931404, -0.09903914481401443, -0.0518951341509819, 0.04668036103248596, -0.0377282090485096, 0.04142972454428673, -0.07172451168298721, 0.02429637499153614, 0.030516156926751137, 0.08145776391029358, -0.027947165071964264, 0.031261883676052094, -0.007568705826997757, 0.037529896944761276, 0.021619675680994987, -0.025509316474199295, -0.07120261341333389, 0.04199336841702461, -0.01634940877556801, -0.04114985838532448, -0.0888984426856041, -0.015566390007734299, 0.03359257057309151, -0.026330506429076195, -0.006123496685177088, 0.05631457269191742, 0.021617025136947632, -0.019520927220582962, -0.035764481872320175, -0.010041420347988605, -0.021500876173377037, 0.04114878550171852, -0.011973519809544086, 0.0069804624654352665, 0.0008109142654575408, 0.0119550209492445, 0.027585668489336967, -0.032676178961992264, 0.04869295656681061, 0.029495978727936745, -0.05674833804368973, 0.012497085146605968, 0.027914749458432198, -0.04459550231695175, 0.01454236451536417, -0.03279406204819679, -0.006730622611939907, -0.041840989142656326, -0.004784847609698772, 0.01895398460328579, 0.06558454781770706, -0.015028735622763634, -0.037829361855983734, -0.01229192316532135, -0.05227500945329666, -0.05359267443418503, -0.07836269587278366, 0.014162817969918251, 0.002486475510522723, -0.015868069604039192, 0.034936048090457916, -0.028326116502285004, 0.014158722013235092, -0.018279939889907837, -0.003481640014797449, -0.027579395100474358, -0.04608622193336487, 0.01265448797494173, -0.06811586767435074, 0.02224152162671089, 0.027349337935447693, 0.0693264901638031, -0.005642310716211796, 0.03970908001065254, -0.014431587420403957, -0.015395771712064743, 0.03517940267920494, -0.02631872147321701, 0.012541564181447029, -0.022059833630919456, 0.014231251552700996, 0.0349428653717041, 0.023019930347800255, -0.011715119704604149, 0.016033733263611794, -0.03445723280310631, 0.02437889762222767, 0.054982464760541916, -0.003970650490373373, -0.003609629115089774, 0.02661444991827011, 0.03746360167860985, 0.039146341383457184, 0.017895640805363655, -0.024713817983865738, -0.039802927523851395, -0.0007164775743149221, 0.02446672134101391, 0.07219476997852325, -0.052596863359212875, 0.0055751437321305275, 0.1015029326081276, 0.0556679405272007, -0.009865147061645985, 0.043389108031988144, 0.031093671917915344, 0.006511221174150705, -0.002707951469346881, 0.005368368234485388, -0.02519993856549263, 0.0024058078415691853, -0.005101125221699476, -0.023641232401132584, 0.038912173360586166, 0.04457240179181099, -0.06493561714887619, 0.03786040097475052, -0.012372015044093132, 0.023278532549738884, -0.002847453346475959, -0.01688498817384243, 0.05890801548957825, -0.049093957990407944, 0.017210768535733223, -0.02112298458814621, 0.010634270496666431, -0.014967294409871101, -0.005839431658387184, -0.029584329575300217, 0.020102398470044136, 0.014838937669992447, -0.05842415615916252, 0.024165896698832512, 0.009118271060287952, -0.025822078809142113, -0.015403518453240395, -0.03870536386966705, -0.037539418786764145, -0.01860697939991951, 0.012355433776974678, 0.05118006840348244, 0.018324412405490875, 0.051465604454278946, -0.018508173525333405, -0.021847771480679512, 0.020363902673125267, 0.002007516333833337, 0.010310368612408638, -0.027776600793004036, -0.05306236445903778, 0.023149587213993073, 0.017870526760816574, -0.005764546804130077, 0.023253392428159714, -0.029210984706878662, 0.027712587267160416, 0.05667812377214432, -0.016425753012299538, -0.02784709818661213, -0.027825769037008286, -0.008416368626058102, 0.020220058038830757, -0.007681556046009064, -0.03864933177828789, 0.011252251453697681, 0.014198877848684788, -0.022620342671871185, -0.01840568147599697, -0.004913706798106432, -0.014649496413767338, -0.045123156160116196, -0.014741760678589344, -0.02197897620499134, -0.019715141505002975, 0.03907427936792374, -0.027543874457478523, -0.0059342957101762295, -0.013958252966403961, -0.035001032054424286, -0.05062670633196831, 0.003492983989417553, 0.027842547744512558, 0.028881410136818886, -0.026454951614141464, -0.033507540822029114, 0.04556488245725632, 0.016142914071679115, -0.055251993238925934, -0.04271269217133522, 0.020812708884477615, -0.03268282860517502, -0.054665014147758484, 0.004125308245420456, 0.00115299376193434, -0.004542037378996611, 0.0420709028840065, -0.004927370231598616, 0.03128833323717117, 0.07156898826360703, 0.017817147076129913, 0.012087028473615646, -0.001855701906606555, -0.024238428100943565, 0.0309727992862463, -0.002723452402278781, 0.03520924970507622, 0.005026338621973991, -0.017384223639965057, 0.04130616784095764, 0.014982418157160282, 0.021095402538776398, -0.03111620619893074, 0.01642289012670517, -0.058631978929042816, 0.01424160972237587, -0.07302934676408768, 0.018064016476273537, 0.03466619551181793, -0.02500053495168686, 0.0022918670438230038, -0.0046685002744197845, 0.017696645110845566, -0.005900208838284016, -0.015064995735883713, 0.027909403666853905, 0.009336876682937145, 0.024284813553094864, -0.03218322992324829, -0.03607983514666557, -0.006583928130567074, 0.021503539755940437, -0.028567872941493988, 0.009440870955586433, 0.01347669679671526, 0.01549512054771185, 0.02161695435643196, -0.02170068770647049, -0.060984574258327484, 0.0261004026979208, -0.08289652317762375, 0.03042205609381199, 0.003857773495838046, 0.028851447626948357, -0.016905207186937332, 0.04491455852985382, 0.004479421302676201, -0.01860262267291546, 0.013762230053544044, 0.0040113553404808044, -0.09619021415710449, 0.014832861721515656, 0.00905466265976429, 0.02004820853471756, -0.006593660917133093, -0.035563740879297256, 0.017109112814068794, -0.020322788506746292, 0.0002845214039552957, -0.004037334118038416, 0.00018099197768606246, -0.03648940846323967, 0.00792341586202383, -0.020449355244636536, -0.05887865647673607, -0.015262594446539879, -0.012939239852130413, 0.0549098439514637, -0.026236306875944138, 0.049349453300237656, 0.055301062762737274, -0.01822715438902378, -0.031014984473586082, -0.009209949523210526, 0.0072800712659955025, 0.06196381151676178, 0.027493758127093315, 0.011147752404212952, -0.011220818385481834, -0.01896951161324978, 0.039932191371917725, -0.012936064042150974, 0.058473218232393265, 0.02208326756954193, -0.003836951684206724, -0.028394533321261406, -0.019974978640675545, -0.02574865333735943, 0.01850723847746849, 0.006483783479779959, 0.029629958793520927, -0.012197884730994701, 0.060381513088941574, 0.028814498335123062, -0.016431443393230438, 0.01597343012690544, 0.06642106920480728, 0.05434245988726616, 0.014309135265648365, -0.03850824013352394, -0.025401582941412926, 0.01599913276731968, 0.0026068200822919607, 0.029444731771945953, 0.006138136610388756, -0.006767880171537399, -0.009145081974565983, 0.04699642211198807, -0.0141685726121068, -0.0038696969859302044, -0.015982478857040405, 0.02284865267574787, 0.06917144358158112, 0.010882382281124592, -0.0038064937107264996, 0.015070030465722084, 0.01600571535527706, 0.028649523854255676, 0.02551499754190445, -0.006645843852311373, -0.07363405078649521, -0.0016907048411667347, 0.0005182909080758691, 0.0447063185274601, -0.024757642298936844, -0.0484047569334507, -0.03306229040026665, -0.013379832729697227, 0.01629924587905407, -0.009193497709929943, 0.014811908826231956, -0.0003766064182855189, -0.015111640095710754, 0.0026940684765577316, -0.0452716201543808, -0.03433053940534592, -0.00690824817866087, 0.030214449390769005, 0.0443904809653759, -0.0046965377405285835, -0.03784552216529846, -0.05038747936487198, -0.006070285569876432, 0.03444017469882965, 0.04770294949412346, 0.0025831221137195826, 0.008905643597245216, -0.02714824117720127, 0.055260512977838516, -0.025204112753272057, -0.0723855271935463, 0.020000062882900238, -0.00942292995750904, -0.022814173251390457, 0.029015367850661278, -0.009163670241832733, -0.022136567160487175, -0.011509818956255913, -0.013805714435875416, -0.004753671586513519, -0.013255452737212181, -0.018759237602353096, 0.03127038851380348, 0.008927901275455952, -0.0051039522513747215, 0.033958662301301956, -0.00441777054220438, 0.012592299841344357, -0.016871310770511627, 0.011700548231601715, -0.00014565799210686237, -0.026334429159760475, 0.02486618421971798, -0.013333612121641636, 0.017362559214234352, -0.044415183365345, 0.004384990315884352, 0.012264509685337543, 0.0062117925845086575, -0.008713837713003159, 0.011677335016429424, -0.025425879284739494, 0.028555026277899742, -0.03671940788626671, -0.002795285312458873, 0.003568013897165656, 0.013013623654842377, 0.0051458594389259815, 0.002706564497202635, 0.020795896649360657, -0.025858094915747643, -0.033708713948726654, 0.0030470991041511297, 0.0271652452647686, -0.0010286348406225443, -0.008053382858633995, -0.006725866347551346, -0.004868375137448311, -0.04940740391612053, 0.02025318518280983, -0.029180122539401054, 0.04188759997487068, 0.03138497471809387, -0.026358449831604958, 0.003648004261776805, 0.02656269073486328, 0.010900354012846947, 0.016772059723734856, -0.04974597692489624, 0.026016423478722572, -0.01632758043706417, -0.004237995948642492, -0.05612270534038544, -0.0480816625058651, 0.033263128250837326, 0.017376892268657684, -0.04598258063197136, -0.030888080596923828, -0.003469698131084442, -0.00236176117323339, -0.03153381869196892, -0.023140491917729378, 0.03830459713935852, -0.02655353583395481, 0.003872525179758668, 0.008701778948307037, 0.01605330780148506, 0.08112865686416626, -0.033082909882068634, -0.005787449423223734, 0.04027106240391731, -0.03486335277557373, -0.019205458462238312, -0.03852900117635727, 0.0329282209277153, -0.010997393168509007, 0.035855311900377274, -0.04535391181707382, -0.024399040266871452, 0.027244459837675095, -0.024872850626707077, -0.0021226629614830017, 0.01921488158404827, 0.010995853692293167, -0.002496622037142515, -0.026396488770842552, -0.015626905485987663, -0.05020966753363609, 0.0031976562459021807, -0.028942611068487167, 0.01714405044913292, -0.0027175056748092175, -0.0164499431848526, 0.011405006051063538, 0.00043072618427686393, -0.014646639116108418, -0.024640895426273346, 0.09975269436836243, -0.02285901829600334, -0.009742246940732002, -0.004511128179728985, 0.008278459310531616, 0.0141499238088727, 0.02122732810676098, 0.03103772923350334, -0.004231215454638004, -0.04335087537765503, -0.03419885411858559, -0.04057132825255394, -0.01892033778131008, 0.010375700891017914, 0.07872358709573746, -0.0036296071484684944, 0.05686108395457268, 0.03149118274450302, -0.016561584547162056, -0.012791112065315247, -0.026368893682956696, 0.006130327470600605, 0.010575249791145325, 0.003903573378920555, 0.055176202207803726, -0.016362620517611504, -0.005150478333234787, 0.0662444457411766, 0.03624863177537918, 0.0013521763030439615, 0.02253659814596176, 0.0015477301785722375, 0.005056959111243486, -0.004406049381941557, 0.04702761024236679, -0.044296588748693466, 0.055689793080091476, -0.0284383837133646, 0.028646571561694145, -0.028499573469161987, -0.043447159230709076, 0.024701252579689026, 0.03943104296922684, -0.024202562868595123, -0.04192393645644188, -0.017060814425349236, -0.0015972984256222844, 0.00043982340139336884, 0.006160846445709467, 0.005582786630839109, 0.04786021634936333, -0.005441099870949984, 0.051540594547986984, 0.018058637157082558, 0.03306260704994202, -0.036072053015232086, -0.021706126630306244, -0.021069549024105072, -0.0036655424628406763, 0.0020492642652243376, 0.01336265541613102, -0.005519876256585121, -0.013385633938014507, 0.016916939988732338, -0.05302247032523155, -0.003272484987974167, -0.007051658816635609, 0.03229954466223717, 0.03976179286837578, 0.09867336601018906, 0.03647232428193092, 0.0361672081053257, -0.01941579207777977, -0.03887571021914482, 0.11392481625080109, 0.07081296294927597, 0.048476215451955795, -0.0601673498749733, 0.039876338094472885, -0.027444109320640564, 0.03580845147371292, -0.04976527765393257, 0.007021085359156132, 0.004143005236983299, 0.00046592476428486407, 0.040956735610961914, 0.05721016600728035, -0.01407395675778389, -0.012101524509489536, 0.014993386343121529, -0.04999672994017601, -0.005297117400914431, 0.02189207263290882, -0.008605645038187504, -0.021298754960298538, -0.0021015868987888098, -0.013937866315245628, 0.011652774177491665, -0.037331320345401764, -0.03825657069683075, -0.0141310328617692, -0.028810972347855568, -0.01569988951086998, -0.01470519695430994, -0.0029178240802139044, -0.0006809277110733092, 0.04346971958875656, -0.03365601971745491, -0.04664412513375282, 0.015158206224441528, 0.011952978558838367, -0.009500144049525261, 0.012102700769901276, -0.004393515642732382, -0.01625877246260643, -0.012926406227052212, 0.04424378648400307, 0.03741735592484474, -0.029608627781271935, -0.031869176775217056, -0.04543197527527809, 0.0445367768406868, -0.02048039622604847, -0.004294967278838158, -0.024841802194714546, -0.025552527979016304, 0.0069613284431397915, -0.011904595419764519, 0.008598164655268192, 0.029548684135079384, 0.02990538626909256, -0.014772439375519753, 0.007089313585311174, -0.03315094858407974, -0.026567762717604637, -0.030230194330215454, 0.031323645263910294, -0.019973434507846832, -0.05492723360657692, -0.0226285420358181, -0.01624450273811817, 0.05288787931203842, -0.018185479566454887, -0.001061097951605916, -0.019581357017159462, 0.011191741563379765, -0.03938678279519081, -0.007326869294047356, 0.02863316982984543, -0.003798283403739333, 0.016557764261960983, -0.01415836252272129, -0.04749323055148125, 0.01179527398198843, -0.05551481246948242, 0.012444342486560345, -0.01849759928882122, -0.03370106965303421, -0.018465863540768623, 0.016400402411818504, 0.015889732167124748, 0.04059315472841263, -0.010806773789227009, 0.0011048332089558244, -0.034756094217300415, 0.04303944855928421, 0.03841284289956093, -0.03643118962645531, -0.009309396147727966, -0.024764327332377434, -0.014617900364100933, -0.019471943378448486, 0.007986039854586124, 0.03422190621495247, 0.06529907882213593, 0.02434127777814865, -0.022335516288876534, 0.006665157154202461, -0.019252508878707886, 0.025233209133148193, 0.03658688813447952, -0.0028759418055415154, 0.005220008548349142, 0.03138020634651184, 0.01712772250175476, -0.035417698323726654, 0.005327328573912382, -0.015759548172354698, 0.02004939131438732, 0.0000274368157988647, -0.011324882507324219, -0.05484842509031296, 0.0008198064169846475, -0.021497946232557297, 0.033954769372940063, -0.06275111436843872, -0.015298503451049328, -0.0698019489645958, 0.0040068430826067924, 0.030261075124144554, -0.005992009770125151, -0.04398053511977196, 0.03199111670255661, -0.00044772590626962483, 0.0017409772844985127, 0.06299035996198654, 0.013679909519851208, 0.011563868261873722, -0.023440204560756683, 0.018486736342310905, -0.01651432365179062, 0.030080633237957954, -0.037330374121665955, -0.03950681537389755, 0.03436257690191269, -0.03217647224664688, -0.0162081029266119, -0.005577307194471359, 0.01113494485616684, 0.022753702476620674, -0.004214285872876644, 0.02977827750146389, -0.02328161522746086, 0.03531939536333084, -0.015176763758063316, -0.011344533413648605, 0.0011372219305485487, 0.01044656615704298, 0.035374898463487625, -0.020943138748407364, -0.00010135742195416242, -0.010883452370762825, -0.0001313974498771131, -0.005694965831935406, 0.04592633619904518, 0.030907947570085526, -0.011360129341483116, 0.019565047696232796, -0.02585536055266857, -0.012555376626551151, 0.048663605004549026, 0.002439951989799738, 0.06781227886676788, 0.030927840620279312, -0.023188622668385506, -0.013591419905424118, -0.026090119034051895, 0.004043062217533588, -0.05120234563946724, -0.005104204639792442, -0.02596256136894226, 0.0011632511159405112, 0.03673436865210533, -0.05641208216547966, 0.021707260981202126, 0.025321083143353462, -0.06497182697057724, 0.02692641317844391, 0.00414498383179307, 0.0008606577757745981, -0.021427156403660774, 0.022311411798000336, -0.0134009700268507, 0.07934102416038513, 0.02466789074242115, 0.001651510363444686, 0.02562263049185276, 0.01419877726584673, 0.021892040967941284, -0.03106670081615448, 0.002292143413797021, -0.014932979829609394, -0.016056958585977554, -0.05515272170305252, 0.049793489277362823, 0.003070375183597207, 0.009771359153091908, 0.025458907708525658, -0.04554712027311325, 0.0008969097398221493, 0.017098980024456978, 0.043061282485723495, 0.0032241521403193474, 0.00832157302647829, 0.006571308244019747, 0.006304360926151276, 0.03509688377380371, -0.044185277074575424, 0.017612293362617493, -0.02284127101302147, 0.01293252594769001, 0.022527923807501793, 0.03214117884635925, -0.02853965014219284, -0.018666047602891922, -0.020765509456396103, -0.0217753816395998, -0.016018174588680267, -0.0007796040736138821, -0.013236640021204948, -0.018598658964037895, -0.0013203894486650825, 0.03917635604739189, -0.010392158292233944, -0.025332637131214142, 0.051835693418979645, 0.01899547316133976, -0.01687118224799633, 0.021962491795420647, -0.010233180597424507, -0.034244488924741745, 0.032726310193538666, 0.034899309277534485, -0.04382557421922684, -0.05614904314279556, -0.01907532475888729, 0.029052017256617546, -0.024117350578308105, -0.05609673261642456, -0.024434557184576988, -0.03745872154831886, 0.030197227373719215, 0.015511061996221542, -0.01278875581920147, 0.013817911967635155, -0.0116633465513587, 0.0163467675447464, -0.04028020426630974, 0.04028641805052757, -0.0021012036595493555, -0.051295097917318344, -0.0044397334568202496, -0.013196758925914764, -0.03364459052681923, -0.006135739851742983, 0.024822447448968887, -0.02829529158771038, 0.000819018401671201, -0.0012587237870320678, 0.018535621464252472, 0.024275919422507286, -0.06557418406009674, 0.04781363531947136, -0.024177130311727524, -0.01762291230261326, 0.006705602165311575, -0.03412497788667679, 0.0339062362909317, 0.01750926859676838, 0.008689473383128643, 0.008989391848444939, 0.04006170108914375, 0.028947675600647926, -0.017389321699738503, 0.005320080555975437, -0.00046936082071624696, -0.029862895607948303, 0.07419148087501526, 0.013686642982065678, 0.007525192573666573, 0.02534172311425209, 0.013837958686053753, -0.06192808970808983, 0.004677820950746536, -0.04360146075487137, -0.037785038352012634, -0.000512103084474802, 0.02920042909681797, -0.002203322248533368, -0.06220202520489693, -0.018571432679891586, 0.020704224705696106, -0.01952284760773182, -0.009444751776754856, 0.04595031216740608, 0.017519982531666756, 0.008223309181630611, 0.019345195963978767, 0.029170265421271324, 0.01676708273589611, -0.0035636965185403824, 0.004396619740873575, 0.028866510838270187, 0.034851569682359695, -0.0004487998376134783, 0.010417084209620953, -0.00034379950375296175, -0.021550070494413376, 0.028596296906471252, -0.036859169602394104, 0.00747377285733819, -0.04088326543569565, -0.016435058787465096, -0.0064013563096523285, -0.01348875556141138, 0.00510544516146183, -0.0012970734387636185, -0.02851703204214573, 0.027067208662629128, -0.0480954647064209, 0.005218539386987686, 0.02142011560499668, 0.04044800624251366, -0.00540047837421298, -0.014777225442230701, 0.04383730888366699, -0.0022267657332122326, -0.005963179282844067, -0.013041221536695957, 0.014459841884672642, -0.008443912491202354, -0.017522703856229782, -0.013937555253505707, 0.005376643035560846, 0.027310602366924286, -0.014472262002527714, -0.03414735198020935, -0.01929689384996891, -0.010019643232226372, 0.003268008353188634, 0.005279213655740023, 0.03127789869904518, -0.005395927466452122, -0.02597099170088768, -0.017870621755719185, 0.014447994530200958, 0.08467275649309158, -0.06019001081585884, 0.0004911907017230988, -0.012192323803901672, -0.03128357604146004, 0.014174236916005611, 0.0002889677416533232 ]
<p>I am having trouble interpreting the z values for categorical variables in logistic regression. In the example below I have a categorical variable with 3 classes and according to the z value, CLASS2 might be relevant while the others are not. </p> <p>But now what does this mean?</p> <p>That I could merge the other classes to one? <br> That the whole variable might not be a good predictor?</p> <p>This is just an example and the actual z values here are not from a real problem, I just have difficulties about their interpretation. </p> <pre><code> Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(&gt;|z|) CLASS0 6.069e-02 1.564e-01 0.388 0.6979 CLASS1 1.734e-01 2.630e-01 0.659 0.5098 CLASS2 1.597e+00 6.354e-01 2.514 0.0119 * </code></pre>
49,483
[ -0.028669534251093864, -0.02689107321202755, -0.0001923226227518171, 0.008171613328158855, 0.04144773259758949, 0.013789229094982147, 0.015187850221991539, 0.00001289647934754612, 0.012366225011646748, -0.026904774829745293, 0.03364258259534836, 0.03898246958851814, 0.04755045846104622, 0.0028996290639042854, 0.032659921795129776, 0.023689616471529007, 0.0034890868701040745, 0.013344828970730305, 0.012731061317026615, 0.00581369549036026, -0.024199452251195908, 0.023043496534228325, 0.06216832250356674, 0.01550803892314434, 0.006846132222563028, 0.04792305454611778, 0.03991270065307617, 0.0158535223454237, 0.010128116235136986, 0.03554738312959671, -0.0021911165677011013, -0.03174658119678497, -0.00023228615464176983, 0.031155789270997047, 0.0013099906500428915, 0.005118408240377903, -0.006480102892965078, -0.013250739313662052, -0.02819701097905636, 0.03771192952990532, -0.009642590768635273, -0.004076048266142607, 0.01912897452712059, 0.019230805337429047, -0.022194307297468185, 0.012571167200803757, -0.003720549400895834, 0.01757475733757019, 0.032160576432943344, -0.008640920743346214, 0.03873150423169136, -0.01240203995257616, 0.014007847756147385, 0.02335699461400509, -0.020526094362139702, 0.009287218563258648, 0.05351835489273071, 0.07595089077949524, -0.019942669197916985, -0.03292202204465866, -0.011741762980818748, -0.05033104494214058, 0.014390305615961552, -0.027375033125281334, -0.010125641711056232, 0.0439794547855854, 0.0008002281538210809, -0.032606955617666245, 0.03892485797405243, 0.01336891669780016, 0.0344771184027195, 0.0023462942335754633, 0.03819893300533295, -0.009693613275885582, 0.02359682135283947, -0.04062596336007118, -0.02413308061659336, 0.04333722963929176, 0.061998456716537476, 0.025330763310194016, -0.010574082843959332, -0.00487112021073699, 0.04266790300607681, 0.016834475100040436, -0.0029281897004693747, -0.016270212829113007, 0.06974620372056961, 0.012533984147012234, 0.020868152379989624, 0.005947938188910484, -0.0077427146025002, 0.01924414001405239, 0.038118407130241394, -0.01771702617406845, -0.01571330614387989, 0.04565124586224556, -0.004564347211271524, 0.019562531262636185, -0.010751918889582157, 0.0010869719553738832, 0.0029322311747819185, -0.01146869920194149, -0.00311474222689867, 0.020119529217481613, -0.0454624742269516, 0.00019761901057790965, -0.039934467524290085, -0.028554745018482208, -0.012427843175828457, -0.04168693721294403, 0.011586912907660007, 0.017482629045844078, 0.02907995879650116, -0.009853465482592583, -0.004776382818818092, -0.025505555793642998, -0.02614331804215908, 0.009751888923346996, 0.018373118713498116, 0.018790176138281822, 0.051432326436042786, -0.032750848680734634, 0.004408794920891523, -0.0019560197833925486, -0.061766695231199265, -0.00180977419950068, -0.00895264558494091, 0.007344099693000317, -0.006548606790602207, 0.05993378907442093, -0.022310681641101837, -0.02829386666417122, 0.024596497416496277, 0.029023149982094765, -0.005249091889709234, 0.00445564417168498, -0.05353038012981415, -0.01015168521553278, 0.0006542479968629777, -0.013164154253900051, 0.01875353418290615, -0.04473746567964554, -0.02064245566725731, 0.02539968490600586, 0.037466615438461304, 0.033295802772045135, 0.026014205068349838, 0.05182261765003204, 0.014279398135840893, 0.05229898914694786, -0.02700289525091648, 0.014741195365786552, -0.053106144070625305, -0.01582176424562931, -0.00968021247535944, -0.05074281990528107, -0.00849861092865467, -0.018190767616033554, -0.045775193721055984, -0.03661496937274933, 0.011303257197141647, -0.013755830004811287, -0.01923190988600254, 0.008194763213396072, -0.004009625408798456, 0.0112486332654953, 0.05475132539868355, -0.006105722859501839, 0.020628243684768677, 0.057640619575977325, -0.006954161915928125, 0.0011969025945290923, 0.03570790961384773, 0.06353412568569183, 0.02046980895102024, 0.0016208813758566976, -0.010640017688274384, -0.10626503825187683, 0.02608237788081169, -0.00013586609566118568, -0.0651669129729271, -0.043745141476392746, -0.0341268852353096, 0.007721574977040291, -0.004883055575191975, 0.06009773164987564, -0.002894623903557658, -0.028524871915578842, 0.07042323052883148, -0.04378814995288849, -0.06515062600374222, -0.033176206052303314, 0.03040090762078762, -0.024441903457045555, -0.008488587103784084, 0.024517733603715897, 0.030614543706178665, 0.02904519811272621, -0.035328347235918045, 0.0032129811588674784, -0.04326653480529785, -0.00980173610150814, 0.0129161411896348, -0.029009228572249413, 0.01527873519808054, 0.07040194422006607, 0.0412345826625824, -0.018961027264595032, 0.04718820005655289, -0.04188475385308266, -0.05603087693452835, 0.057352758944034576, 0.012029294855892658, 0.0083423787727952, -0.015308416448533535, -0.02795582450926304, 0.03292713686823845, 0.010796732269227505, -0.03470838442444801, -0.0018820668337866664, -0.06793203204870224, 0.06540393829345703, 0.043881312012672424, 0.0018487178022041917, -0.013408755883574486, -0.008632904849946499, -0.01256023719906807, 0.03786296397447586, -0.0343639962375164, 0.009616460651159286, -0.04230823367834091, -0.03190286457538605, 0.050207432359457016, 0.011922789737582207, -0.05354156717658043, -0.012794850394129753, 0.01378592848777771, 0.012149280868470669, -0.002618113998323679, 0.051621194928884506, -0.018167011439800262, 0.005290716886520386, 0.027096185833215714, 0.01752307265996933, -0.004627874121069908, -0.017729828134179115, 0.022706961259245872, 0.0023360340856015682, 0.07313799858093262, -0.025570295751094818, -0.032365910708904266, 0.06561414152383804, -0.029378142207860947, 0.0019506423268467188, -0.022039087489247322, -0.009792575612664223, 0.021031556650996208, -0.014349289238452911, 0.019848277792334557, 0.07719123363494873, 0.01811175048351288, 0.01512715220451355, -0.011297919787466526, -0.00855712778866291, -0.005274956580251455, 0.07388445734977722, -0.03818374127149582, 0.005416984669864178, -0.004571813624352217, -0.04293398559093475, 0.01800628751516342, -0.011719060130417347, -0.06915049999952316, -0.032682426273822784, 0.026395484805107117, 0.03138856962323189, -0.006860588677227497, -0.004790313076227903, -0.01004576962441206, -0.0472160167992115, -0.02853940799832344, 0.00003564407234080136, 0.052045565098524094, 0.008838705718517303, -0.06351131200790405, -0.032602980732917786, -0.010464012622833252, -0.04271674528717995, 0.04424293711781502, -0.012970777228474617, -0.03395039215683937, 0.014260484836995602, -0.015039258636534214, -0.032706789672374725, -0.019701965153217316, -0.01666143909096718, 0.0006337311351671815, -0.005357755348086357, 0.002526090247556567, 0.03105928562581539, -0.034514911472797394, -0.045754022896289825, 0.010643580928444862, -0.037751298397779465, -0.05823122337460518, -0.026824625208973885, -0.050742145627737045, 0.033375922590494156, -0.0068480647169053555, 0.008747952990233898, 0.016093537211418152, -0.02355942316353321, 0.015321392565965652, -0.03782161697745323, -0.07214117795228958, 0.004907411057502031, -0.010961253196001053, 0.0002958997501991689, -0.014211404137313366, -0.005657888483256102, 0.10154715925455093, -0.02564430795609951, -0.02835603803396225, -0.04514656588435173, 0.031327709555625916, -0.052098244428634644, -0.020131569355726242, 0.01585996523499489, 0.03791633993387222, 0.050634272396564484, 0.031146377325057983, -0.043088559061288834, 0.014909089542925358, 0.03721833974123001, -0.002982937963679433, 0.007198780309408903, 0.0247031357139349, 0.006426590029150248, -0.029269449412822723, 0.02758358046412468, 0.02904323674738407, -0.03056127391755581, 0.04069441184401512, 0.010242863558232784, 0.0525764524936676, -0.0006760629476048052, -0.0444398932158947, 0.008311385288834572, -0.019707437604665756, 0.0040700095705688, -0.001301625627093017, 0.027567632496356964, 0.01670265384018421, -0.04612269625067711, 0.015807488933205605, -0.015055366791784763, 0.05209653452038765, -0.01814204826951027, 0.005134515464305878, 0.058530114591121674, 0.028195861726999283, -0.019755439832806587, 0.020444873720407486, -0.014498339965939522, 0.0026652594096958637, 0.04649136960506439, -0.023810939863324165, -0.02002588100731373, 0.037537213414907455, 0.057414498180150986, 0.011235482059419155, -0.03109528310596943, -0.02829740010201931, 0.012554831802845001, -0.06621257215738297, -0.007622674107551575, -0.014477170072495937, 0.023331569507718086, 0.007299285382032394, 0.08248187601566315, -0.0005314570153132081, -0.010289604775607586, 0.00597983505576849, 0.005204275716096163, -0.04415162652730942, 0.006024270784109831, 0.010954244062304497, -0.0010862250346690416, 0.0014161975122988224, -0.06580621004104614, 0.007401739712804556, -0.053123895078897476, 0.013252790085971355, -0.013793780468404293, 0.00010913364531006664, -0.023230237886309624, -0.01251356489956379, 0.03370034322142601, 0.03139327093958855, -0.004005026072263718, -0.0010029079858213663, -0.009500283747911453, -0.014171639457345009, 0.00013789863442070782, 0.07485286146402359, 0.011960076168179512, -0.016213472932577133, -0.02288484387099743, 0.00781638827174902, 0.057212430983781815, 0.05919094756245613, 0.03564610704779625, 0.005895849317312241, -0.00040240027010440826, 0.019323039799928665, -0.007270723581314087, 0.05519956350326538, 0.034656964242458344, 0.008725835010409355, -0.02072654850780964, -0.020849095657467842, -0.02499290183186531, -0.020528100430965424, 0.018217727541923523, 0.004291994031518698, 0.03208612650632858, 0.08785470575094223, 0.0211655143648386, -0.07609696686267853, 0.004211823455989361, 0.043774496763944626, 0.020205698907375336, -0.01936672255396843, -0.04383810609579086, -0.016453804448246956, -0.03649020567536354, -0.008095561526715755, 0.04424537718296051, -0.021415406838059425, -0.016659989953041077, 0.008228699676692486, 0.0334952212870121, -0.019889455288648605, -0.05522722378373146, -0.06454866379499435, 0.03380759060382843, 0.005935922265052795, 0.02357931062579155, -0.0510576069355011, 0.013893193565309048, 0.0342547670006752, 0.018834203481674194, 0.006334767676889896, 0.032539740204811096, -0.10004431009292603, 0.0021020977292209864, 0.0066809686832129955, 0.039701662957668304, -0.03902512043714523, -0.02916477993130684, -0.0385272353887558, -0.0015200212365016341, -0.0036753248423337936, -0.01966884918510914, 0.034796517342329025, -0.02495788037776947, 0.04039199650287628, -0.03104100003838539, -0.032211292535066605, -0.07454010844230652, 0.02000519447028637, -0.03182986006140709, 0.00721949664875865, -0.019570423290133476, -0.020646939054131508, -0.042285941541194916, 0.03228018060326576, -0.01067401748150587, 0.034052323549985886, -0.048217594623565674, -0.02330823615193367, 0.0047444445081055164, 0.035662949085235596, 0.020484449341893196, -0.0646241083741188, -0.014818220399320126, -0.00591165479272604, 0.0052157738246023655, 0.055410031229257584, -0.03484564274549484, -0.029063059017062187, -0.0032480608206242323, 0.029951002448797226, -0.022901952266693115, -0.004975996911525726, -0.012851524166762829, 0.019742898643016815, 0.014510098844766617, 0.0017532060155645013, 0.06463377922773361, 0.014341102913022041, -0.012644524686038494, -0.007049765437841415, -0.0615379773080349, 0.007646556943655014, -0.010219525545835495, -0.03210484981536865, -0.03518427163362503, 0.01636616326868534, 0.010361980646848679, 0.025534210726618767, -0.0034336524549871683, -0.018241247162222862, -0.03151572123169899, -0.015015268698334694, -0.010792518965899944, -0.009259119629859924, -0.023492755368351936, -0.012785221450030804, -0.012923793867230415, 0.012233090586960316, -0.008907722309231758, -0.0029980051331222057, 0.025909442454576492, -0.03052535094320774, -0.009579883888363838, -0.008174187503755093, -0.038315411657094955, 0.005636963527649641, 0.00009608152322471142, -0.02241850458085537, 0.051181551069021225, -0.029553581029176712, 0.0077445534989237785, 0.0011757705360651016, 0.016060957685112953, 0.01635504700243473, -0.01867189072072506, -0.022877570241689682, 0.031008495017886162, 0.017625585198402405, 0.0515717975795269, -0.0060248468071222305, 0.016192901879549026, 0.028949055820703506, -0.008511506021022797, -0.049722034484148026, -0.015367195010185242, 0.02315770462155342, -0.012519435957074165, -0.07165601849555969, -0.027332523837685585, -0.03917974233627319, 0.006021040491759777, -0.03766047954559326, -0.01253690104931593, 0.0593147799372673, -0.03813044726848602, -0.03051617182791233, -0.012373045086860657, 0.006894734688103199, 0.07314884662628174, 0.02524747885763645, -0.002986437641084194, -0.001769178081303835, -0.02334861271083355, -0.010282400995492935, 0.020444877445697784, -0.00734913581982255, 0.0035315132699906826, -0.02140277624130249, 0.0018084950279444456, 0.007358272094279528, 0.01205621287226677, -0.012011228129267693, -0.007241654209792614, -0.010181271471083164, -0.00451621925458312, 0.02493900991976261, -0.005143065005540848, 0.020362289622426033, -0.01884676143527031, 0.011826037429273129, 0.009877367876470089, 0.013648255728185177, -0.024208176881074905, 0.02433207631111145, 0.053446851670742035, 0.002877438673749566, -0.031819988042116165, 0.014878647401928902, 0.07455078512430191, 0.039034780114889145, 0.017031166702508926, -0.040554020553827286, -0.05125975236296654, 0.06628403812646866, 0.02718648687005043, -0.022416282445192337, 0.03011743724346161, 0.07231008261442184, 0.012085833586752415, 0.022681787610054016, -0.05399138480424881, -0.0062524969689548016, 0.046440862119197845, -0.01646236889064312, 0.01185231376439333, 0.033699724823236465, 0.02172515168786049, 0.0022560730576515198, -0.04131948575377464, -0.012889082543551922, 0.016596594825387, -0.022903822362422943, 0.04203537106513977, 0.004049408249557018, -0.012771327048540115, 0.012140190228819847, -0.02052619867026806, 0.026763007044792175, -0.010526851750910282, 0.0059589967131614685, 0.009590934962034225, 0.005443193018436432, -0.0396416112780571, -0.04787746071815491, 0.04730072245001793, -0.035526342689991, 0.005268741399049759, -0.023089151829481125, -0.024838950484991074, 0.019199980422854424, 0.013989864848554134, 0.013557233847677708, -0.0909900814294815, -0.01847635954618454, -0.04877658560872078, 0.018732845783233643, -0.009980839677155018, -0.036072053015232086, 0.05942452698945999, -0.0076042888686060905, 0.0192977637052536, 0.009416520595550537, 0.03440551087260246, -0.013373017311096191, -0.08286793529987335, -0.03857859596610069, -0.02777927927672863, -0.016578717157244682, 0.008624742738902569, 0.004691745154559612, -0.017440946772694588, 0.00004819823880097829, -0.053123604506254196, 0.04297204315662384, 0.012639460153877735, 0.03708351403474808, 0.012566201388835907, 0.03336509317159653, 0.01816430501639843, 0.031644176691770554, -0.0034173442982137203, -0.03908891975879669, 0.11302480846643448, 0.08098900318145752, 0.04372047632932663, -0.03099839948117733, 0.013724323362112045, 0.014077759347856045, -0.002458035247400403, -0.00020682680769823492, -0.016716185957193375, 0.03192225471138954, 0.0001322578318649903, 0.061497196555137634, 0.01644076034426689, 0.051620326936244965, -0.030292725190520287, 0.06330519169569016, -0.05580243095755577, -0.002694774651899934, 0.00034365218016318977, 0.03634963557124138, -0.00043442222522571683, -0.029256492853164673, -0.053478773683309555, -0.026897557079792023, 0.0004417149175424129, -0.018806669861078262, -0.05239151045680046, 0.021502967923879623, -0.0013261092826724052, -0.026074031367897987, -0.018840579316020012, -0.01711515337228775, -0.00014083473070058972, 0.00853137020021677, -0.015604163520038128, -0.022892631590366364, -0.004704867023974657, -0.011545556597411633, 0.027081958949565887, 0.010322381742298603, -0.018508069217205048, 0.004042160231620073, -0.008802282623946667, 0.023839237168431282, -0.0637764185667038, -0.030270511284470558, -0.03847230225801468, 0.06196111813187599, -0.005762902088463306, -0.009658638387918472, -0.0063017881475389, 0.02924920991063118, 0.005000040400773287, -0.009481233544647694, -0.021238625049591064, 0.01927168294787407, -0.004702035803347826, -0.007086940109729767, -0.010372627526521683, -0.017927194014191628, 0.007893400266766548, 0.03750096261501312, 0.030686218291521072, 0.004682641476392746, -0.03208354115486145, -0.00740501843392849, -0.033048950135707855, 0.03699421510100365, 0.0031428562942892313, 0.023873476311564445, 0.026226790621876717, 0.013450990431010723, -0.0063864681869745255, -0.0013855433790013194, 0.017737869173288345, -0.030252551659941673, -0.007668547332286835, -0.011998988687992096, 0.0020903004333376884, -0.034358058124780655, -0.028695812448859215, 0.033613067120313644, -0.030920008197426796, -0.0014768861001357436, -0.049648117274045944, 0.02807937003672123, 0.02637121081352234, 0.04347281903028488, 0.027799105271697044, 0.021393895149230957, -0.014367581345140934, 0.06615869700908661, -0.053103551268577576, -0.031757716089487076, 0.008951264433562756, 0.019084839150309563, -0.053581010550260544, 0.005209567490965128, -0.022392718121409416, 0.10288414359092712, 0.061368677765131, 0.02713226154446602, 0.014924739487469196, 0.01527493167668581, 0.008572912774980068, -0.010450443252921104, 0.009834373369812965, -0.017392555251717567, 0.007403628434985876, 0.01627301052212715, 0.015213425271213055, -0.030824096873402596, 0.01694346033036709, -0.0540914312005043, -0.0642973855137825, 0.011813701130449772, -0.02778766304254532, -0.03288767859339714, -0.015914611518383026, -0.026406841352581978, 0.005909282248467207, -0.0017065649153664708, -0.025657756254076958, -0.05062688887119293, 0.014913052320480347, -0.06089344620704651, -0.04519915208220482, -0.02959228679537773, -0.0056177605874836445, 0.01104538794606924, 0.001152888755314052, 0.018334807828068733, 0.015640240162611008, 0.006201340816915035, -0.013902606442570686, 0.029527422040700912, -0.006232075393199921, 0.03234358876943588, -0.008942419663071632, -0.021720167249441147, 0.01037659216672182, -0.018468422815203667, -0.012080511078238487, 0.05195705592632294, -0.012951213866472244, 0.04069330543279648, 0.003131609410047531, 0.015605445951223373, -0.027561966329813004, 0.02329748123884201, -0.003987382631748915, -0.024491269141435623, -0.04802532121539116, -0.01403111219406128, -0.03361323103308678, 0.0014420723309740424, -0.013402007520198822, 0.027254469692707062, -0.015758004039525986, 0.002603002591058612, 0.06900931149721146, -0.004253741353750229, -0.00808652862906456, 0.015255820006132126, -0.002662240993231535, 0.06333896517753601, 0.017038680613040924, -0.0304944459348917, 0.049818750470876694, 0.049631185829639435, -0.003908616025000811, 0.01948663964867592, -0.005507593974471092, 0.02597459964454174, -0.09640274196863174, -0.019343433901667595, 0.020564956590533257, 0.020436152815818787, 0.0468587651848793, -0.05465368181467056, 0.024382183328270912, 0.00038637418765574694, 0.005764314904808998, 0.005261989310383797, 0.0031300147529691458, -0.029527321457862854, -0.057713259011507034, 0.0013492282014340162, 0.004508025012910366, 0.04487520456314087, 0.05926394462585449, 0.00388374924659729, 0.02621276304125786, 0.011239873245358467, -0.0137410257011652, -0.025736048817634583, -0.03740059211850166, 0.015729602426290512, 0.004657732788473368, -0.030425170436501503, 0.03591562807559967, -0.031500328332185745, -0.0305187851190567, 0.004215921740978956, 0.0026529296301305294, -0.0021617100574076176, 0.0721755400300026, 0.03174203634262085, 0.032162003219127655, 0.037534963339567184, 0.052547305822372437, -0.0011311568086966872, -0.04046979546546936, 0.018286027014255524, 0.03547857701778412, -0.0021661219652742147, -0.012907497584819794, 0.008584773167967796, -0.015583643689751625, -0.018672587350010872, -0.029536303132772446, 0.013135041110217571, -0.00681057246401906, 0.015897156670689583, -0.014757640659809113, -0.00013814331032335758, -0.023875979706645012, -0.04571333900094032, 0.045044757425785065, -0.03752727434039116, -0.01755056343972683, 0.043357063084840775, 0.062152471393346786, -0.009695717133581638, -0.0015672063454985619, 0.0013219856191426516, -0.02136235311627388, 0.0101784598082304, 0.014021102339029312, -0.013043534941971302, -0.029939010739326477, 0.006442143116146326, -0.0023607523180544376, -0.04022544249892235, -0.038603637367486954, -0.004409477114677429, -0.038325224071741104, 0.05505678430199623, -0.027075299993157387, 0.0036729832645505667, 0.0029238525312393904, -0.012592235580086708, 0.03298443928360939, -0.081879623234272, 0.059304188936948776, 0.0029815055895596743, 0.011908252723515034, -0.0485013984143734, -0.006256517488509417, -0.04256332293152809, 0.03514477238059044, 0.0662546306848526, 0.010985112749040127, 0.0074346596375107765, -0.03226987272500992, 0.047862838953733444, -0.002076295902952552, -0.029311589896678925, 0.029023734852671623, -0.0011764740338549018, -0.05280757322907448, -0.03459256887435913, 0.004778258502483368, 0.003917830064892769, 0.003435672726482153, 0.07651229202747345, -0.028454728424549103, 0.004825034644454718, -0.009881122969090939, -0.004998081363737583, 0.03180842474102974, -0.02331777848303318, -0.020015375688672066, 0.0651245042681694, -0.013004409149289131, 0.012357267551124096, 0.04904046654701233, -0.010184905491769314, -0.058992620557546616, 0.025593258440494537, 0.006496512331068516, -0.0037211899179965258, 0.026539573445916176, 0.009417884983122349, 0.043658290058374405, -0.06421007215976715, 0.024694133549928665, 0.012715774588286877, -0.044425152242183685, 0.014755813404917717, 0.03653234988451004, 0.026666566729545593, 0.03895784169435501, -0.026476580649614334, 0.013829403556883335, -0.026852481067180634, -0.048632606863975525, 0.03806157410144806, 0.028732240200042725, 0.0010150407906621695, -0.00004444357182364911, 0.03762592002749443, 0.009666995145380497, 0.02130509912967682, 0.01703503169119358, 0.016736628487706184, 0.07069923728704453, -0.023720871657133102, 0.023588547483086586, 0.013535943813621998, 0.010976271703839302, 0.03522978350520134, 0.031979646533727646, 0.0028947123792022467, 0.0378531739115715, -0.05898689478635788, -0.008977815508842468, -0.03642060607671738, -0.025947678834199905, -0.017132362350821495, -0.01213157456368208, 0.039707060903310776, 0.024493176490068436, 0.000957147334702313, 0.007238356396555901, 0.0226557869464159, -0.010386665351688862, -0.012788774445652962, 0.013364573009312153, 0.016407493501901627, -0.02132229693233967, -0.008004361763596535, -0.0021286173723638058, -0.013097725808620453, -0.027139462530612946, 0.0004121001693420112, 0.006803530268371105, 0.05529805272817612, 0.0030893313232809305, -0.02948547713458538, -0.0217052660882473, -0.021301649510860443, 0.003013199893757701, -0.04557958245277405, -0.022498035803437233, -0.02875509299337864, 0.0274567361921072, 0.014881380833685398, -0.04608771204948425 ]
<p>I want to use the inverse normal distribution in winbugs but I don't find it there. Please help me to find a solution.</p> <p>I have here truncated normal distribution for y</p> <pre><code>for (j in 1:P) { y1[i,j] ~ dnorm(mu1[i,j], psi1[j])I(thd[j,z1[i,j]], thd[j,z1[i,j]+1]) } </code></pre> <p>where <code>y</code> is treated as a missing variables and augmented with the posterior analysis. Variable <code>z</code> are ordered categorical variables and <code>thd</code> set of thresholds. </p>
73,550
[ 0.012658752501010895, -0.017993224784731865, 0.026239974424242973, -0.018517877906560898, 0.029601266607642174, 0.001079524983651936, -0.04064701125025749, -0.0033952186349779367, -0.01067665871232748, -0.025034639984369278, 0.06708608567714691, 0.024928634986281395, 0.07073665410280228, 0.019912974908947945, 0.02711797133088112, 0.00623730756342411, -0.03064770996570587, -0.01009680237621069, -0.03897545114159584, -0.020966028794646263, -0.03641744330525398, 0.010499664582312107, 0.006391881033778191, 0.0028022234328091145, -0.021927960216999054, 0.003359487745910883, 0.015679238364100456, 0.0010016498854383826, 0.005286691710352898, 0.05913737043738365, -0.027739398181438446, -0.016528915613889694, -0.01164290588349104, 0.009126515127718449, -0.006651873234659433, -0.01410800963640213, 0.003490664064884186, -0.01822647824883461, -0.00884994026273489, 0.011463558301329613, 0.0012626835377886891, 0.013700183480978012, -0.013217753730714321, 0.025827370584011078, 0.0023484532721340656, 0.013727952726185322, 0.00955547858029604, -0.021903693675994873, 0.03487462177872658, -0.029791831970214844, 0.07160799205303192, -0.03444378823041916, 0.021404936909675598, 0.003174062119796872, -0.0000786678574513644, -0.04132167249917984, 0.05445844680070877, 0.08488145470619202, 0.01188461109995842, -0.08215051144361496, -0.014776717871427536, -0.04728584364056587, -0.02425762265920639, -0.01983775943517685, -0.047735266387462616, -8.048896233958658e-7, -0.0321747250854969, -0.03589663654565811, 0.018346402794122696, -0.013786382041871548, 0.002378649776801467, 0.023396356031298637, 0.02684767171740532, -0.0316079705953598, 0.0355883352458477, -0.053576767444610596, 0.01876218244433403, 0.0145189817994833, 0.012444807216525078, 0.023869112133979797, 0.028299402445554733, 0.02250007353723049, 0.022458646446466446, 0.011640212498605251, 0.017997801303863525, -0.019496489316225052, 0.1041126549243927, -0.04563342034816742, 0.02534865215420723, 0.04955514892935753, -0.049968503415584564, -0.0053437016904354095, 0.049320343881845474, 0.007815674878656864, -0.020641500130295753, 0.028315817937254906, -0.00067092728568241, 0.05301859602332115, -0.03492184728384018, 0.005320883356034756, 0.0005068925092928112, -0.03143787384033203, -0.012441479600965977, 0.0554376095533371, -0.05368606746196747, -0.016921306028962135, -0.057171281427145004, 0.01443357765674591, 0.02344685234129429, -0.03231792896986008, -0.0356890968978405, 0.017999600619077682, -0.02985006384551525, -0.027434419840574265, 0.015055499970912933, 0.013461248949170113, 0.00556105887517333, 0.017225677147507668, 0.03930896893143654, 0.054616741836071014, 0.04293001815676689, -0.013668950647115707, 0.030794266611337662, -0.0366782583296299, -0.031942665576934814, -0.02111612632870674, 0.007781027350574732, -0.01871793530881405, -0.02726193144917488, 0.04200585559010506, -0.039436809718608856, -0.022299885749816895, 0.06589613109827042, -0.026102673262357712, 0.0431860014796257, 0.0029477723874151707, -0.025837715715169907, -0.07093591243028641, 0.018943263217806816, -0.00047259448911063373, 0.02727396972477436, -0.07713327556848526, 0.0012326011201366782, 0.030330728739500046, 0.03597317263484001, 0.04092928767204285, 0.04903807491064072, -0.010829979553818703, -0.008138632401823997, 0.017601193860173225, -0.0062243579886853695, -0.020261825993657112, 0.0017606824403628707, -0.017291883006691933, -0.025867434218525887, -0.10920381546020508, 0.05613964423537254, 0.019014548510313034, -0.025342106819152832, -0.0016563937533646822, 0.044726867228746414, 0.009905817918479443, -0.011490493081510067, -0.03416287153959274, -0.027984365820884705, -0.053509123623371124, 0.05654163658618927, -0.020898625254631042, 0.01020070444792509, 0.016512252390384674, -0.022876104339957237, -0.0020867798011749983, -0.006614778656512499, 0.026958897709846497, 0.021523306146264076, -0.019469158723950386, -0.0390293151140213, -0.022074759006500244, 0.030901357531547546, 0.017291203141212463, 0.013827484101057053, -0.010800663381814957, 0.004940712824463844, -0.007011824753135443, 0.040000345557928085, -0.017059674486517906, 0.008798100054264069, -0.036432914435863495, 0.026945263147354126, -0.026621447876095772, -0.014686338603496552, 0.0006260406807996333, 0.004813343286514282, 0.01451376173645258, 0.007090154103934765, 0.026044581085443497, 0.012062153778970242, 0.032661937177181244, 0.023972362279891968, 0.015427916310727596, -0.03536325320601463, -0.04980821907520294, 0.04257763549685478, -0.013298564590513706, -0.016712281852960587, 0.05665745958685875, 0.06220931187272072, -0.05359147861599922, 0.03322084620594978, -0.011989888735115528, -0.008376519195735455, -0.007331883069127798, -0.03474856913089752, -0.02224772609770298, -0.0074042100459337234, 0.008453103713691235, 0.029802806675434113, 0.02098727598786354, -0.003964223898947239, -0.0028619118966162205, -0.044441334903240204, 0.011970406398177147, 0.0779583603143692, 0.009141109883785248, -0.0049248868599534035, -0.037542924284935, 0.0022805635817348957, 0.04291205480694771, 0.008395776152610779, 0.01644040271639824, -0.04565361887216568, 0.0010226789163425565, 0.022927824407815933, -0.007144654635339975, -0.05715624615550041, 0.02036384679377079, 0.03242718428373337, -0.011787842959165573, 0.04221295565366745, 0.041649725288152695, -0.0011434433981776237, -0.017318343743681908, 0.013567660935223103, 0.007430821657180786, 0.03306031972169876, 0.005440790671855211, -0.015471971593797207, -0.0017816501203924417, 0.025060128420591354, -0.014580504037439823, -0.006415040697902441, 0.04902252182364464, -0.017658600583672523, -0.010579951107501984, -0.04336897283792496, -0.029583163559436798, 0.042194388806819916, -0.02016928419470787, 0.01730574481189251, 0.041790809482336044, -0.018983488902449608, -0.00710070738568902, -0.000985821709036827, 0.0027354771737009287, -0.0020714299753308296, 0.029771622270345688, -0.011505075730383396, 0.03661543130874634, 0.009512114338576794, -0.041394010186195374, 0.017637573182582855, -0.03822242096066475, -0.014393632300198078, -0.08443286269903183, 0.009137751534581184, 0.04991869628429413, 0.04807046800851822, -0.0030514257960021496, -0.027742447331547737, -0.01728867180645466, 0.0008831534651108086, 0.010178888216614723, 0.013322577811777592, 0.010349594987928867, -0.030624663457274437, 0.018745997920632362, -0.010217088274657726, 0.0005718630272895098, 0.009105229750275612, -0.009884119965136051, -0.009657624177634716, 0.021592216566205025, -0.0025099008344113827, -0.04643166437745094, -0.027481090277433395, -0.009980665519833565, 0.023903116583824158, -0.008720598183572292, -0.033839527517557144, 0.031503599137067795, 0.05356404557824135, -0.02684195153415203, 0.004641231615096331, -0.01131065096706152, -0.051868267357349396, -0.029636064544320107, -0.001668834127485752, 0.008682417683303356, 0.02039753645658493, 0.017308862879872322, 0.03382391855120659, -0.012157232500612736, 0.02764352783560753, -0.08716531097888947, -0.07193845510482788, 0.020403651520609856, 0.04379000887274742, 0.007776463869959116, 0.017856337130069733, 0.015576045960187912, 0.09972988814115524, 0.010415785014629364, -0.0057640462182462215, -0.03316798433661461, 0.014881037175655365, 0.010161898098886013, -0.029204590246081352, -0.0001997918589040637, 0.008027656935155392, 0.037282366305589676, 0.035873930901288986, -0.022623049095273018, 0.026518836617469788, 0.035933706909418106, 0.0023357816971838474, 0.011443102732300758, 0.03752221539616585, -0.009068113751709461, -0.044386520981788635, 0.050447121262550354, -0.03803563490509987, 0.009268717840313911, -0.010558010078966618, -0.0023090271279215813, 0.02857341431081295, 0.008373009040951729, -0.01792321912944317, 0.012235315516591072, 0.0015972454566508532, 0.03084561601281166, -0.056293077766895294, -0.0001288220373680815, 0.032068900763988495, -0.02486027404665947, -0.006000523455440998, 0.03626421093940735, 0.03434867039322853, -0.04383840784430504, -0.013600975275039673, 0.07016079872846603, 0.00743896933272481, -0.035903170704841614, -0.03672052174806595, 0.003725487506017089, -0.013229337520897388, 0.042778827250003815, -0.022821485996246338, 0.005505034700036049, 0.04384054243564606, 0.06127401813864708, 0.022217895835638046, 0.0067400033585727215, -0.04189062863588333, 0.04134952276945114, -0.05042996630072594, 0.04067118465900421, -0.034308165311813354, 0.054876528680324554, 0.0030830467585474253, 0.012537412345409393, 0.039700090885162354, 0.008148779161274433, -0.01767684333026409, 0.006097946781665087, -0.06464039534330368, 0.0072729396633803844, 0.001480868086218834, -0.024934982880949974, -0.02772624045610428, -0.005168471485376358, 0.02806895412504673, -0.001666222233325243, 0.021511249244213104, 0.009072731249034405, -0.0007162760011851788, -0.02750646509230137, 0.004757234361022711, -0.017365533858537674, 0.013461208902299404, -0.01607963629066944, 0.020844591781497, 0.0012446666369214654, -0.011663923971354961, -0.01460451353341341, 0.04305972903966904, 0.015937108546495438, -0.021320311352610588, -0.006969653535634279, 0.006982819177210331, 0.0193130224943161, 0.04448871314525604, 0.07263055443763733, 0.04732876643538475, -0.04489276558160782, -0.01035586278885603, -0.0010382109321653843, 0.053594235330820084, 0.0250969547778368, 0.02792690508067608, -0.005593461450189352, -0.0156814306974411, -0.009441801346838474, 0.013476086780428886, 0.02722339704632759, -0.02935625985264778, 0.03248891979455948, 0.017545951530337334, 0.011985423974692822, -0.08112097531557083, 0.03182853385806084, 0.06016477197408676, 0.018189219757914543, 0.018537700176239014, -0.010023311711847782, 0.00234067696146667, -0.020389355719089508, -0.02198280580341816, 0.009262205101549625, 0.03216342628002167, -0.022858189418911934, -0.02955528348684311, 0.041030820459127426, -0.009179686196148396, 0.007371475920081139, -0.013655269518494606, 0.0012149030808359385, 0.01573948748409748, 0.021317826583981514, 0.011195686645805836, 0.038815781474113464, 0.03691361844539642, 0.030046600848436356, 0.02239544875919819, -0.023022007197141647, -0.09341798722743988, 0.012247550301253796, 0.018680788576602936, 0.06856485456228256, -0.016025889664888382, 0.002661579754203558, -0.046171970665454865, -0.019525030627846718, 0.03437774255871773, -0.05338794365525246, 0.0246930830180645, -0.01378021389245987, 0.03793249651789665, -0.00397156598046422, -0.004543366841971874, -0.04978233203291893, 0.05098061263561249, -0.02106361836194992, 0.010969683527946472, -0.019849708303809166, -0.0120167201384902, -0.07608436793088913, 0.020856734365224838, -0.006525582168251276, 0.08043572306632996, -0.033472295850515366, -0.025934170931577682, 0.018256090581417084, 0.012499361298978329, -0.016006864607334137, -0.027391668409109116, 0.011682594195008278, 0.007101870607584715, -0.027347713708877563, 0.06869600713253021, -0.019832931458950043, 0.0198248028755188, 0.016703715547919273, 0.020089538767933846, -0.03513480722904205, -0.015846876427531242, -0.00787646509706974, 0.025379104539752007, 0.040649544447660446, 0.0008274284773506224, 0.05701374635100365, 0.01883517950773239, -0.014962171204388142, -0.0354301743209362, -0.05792705714702606, -0.021889397874474525, -0.05555511638522148, -0.01284120511263609, -0.048111461102962494, -0.007441310212016106, 0.018093569204211235, 0.026658689603209496, 0.010497603565454483, 0.021888313814997673, -0.04379922151565552, -0.029875528067350388, -0.004725291393697262, 0.0015785348368808627, -0.023365112021565437, 0.005410535726696253, 0.010837171226739883, -0.008341877721250057, -0.004672279115766287, -0.007711238693445921, 0.033005956560373306, -0.012776726856827736, -0.006433042697608471, 0.0239640511572361, -0.03572525829076767, 0.02364734373986721, -0.012657958082854748, -0.02527947723865509, 0.02821844443678856, -0.006268247030675411, -0.017405979335308075, -0.008733183145523071, 0.04667598009109497, -0.021513909101486206, 0.0022254951763898134, 0.010249977000057697, 0.00046522292541339993, -0.01691543124616146, 0.006907534785568714, -0.03948862478137016, 0.07499314099550247, -0.0057371086440980434, 0.016839640215039253, -0.07489046454429626, -0.03663492947816849, 0.02082265168428421, -0.012956300750374794, -0.04624798148870468, -0.048412024974823, -0.03294774144887924, 0.0024118146393448114, -0.015811488032341003, -0.008311653509736061, -0.0076050469651818275, -0.032049208879470825, -0.0029707348439842463, -0.027834119275212288, 0.004779347684234381, 0.05162014439702034, -0.00954265333712101, -0.001884695258922875, 0.043730415403842926, 0.004576786421239376, -0.004383841063827276, -0.02151315286755562, -0.0012071614619344473, -0.016980106011033058, 0.016389042139053345, -0.010207682847976685, 0.015948403626680374, 0.04112955182790756, -0.03781295195221901, -0.05513428524136543, 0.026930954307317734, 0.02534705586731434, -0.014257854782044888, -0.04563267529010773, -0.04275861755013466, -0.021251218393445015, -0.01976078562438488, -0.047394078224897385, 0.007573396898806095, -0.00863501988351345, 0.016967112198472023, 0.01856369338929653, 0.0023769414983689785, 0.004445725120604038, 0.01902705617249012, 0.08567752689123154, 0.015659965574741364, 0.02962464839220047, -0.012918679974973202, -0.03983698785305023, 0.025840118527412415, 0.056461889296770096, -0.0259071197360754, -0.011045415885746479, -0.00037049385719001293, -0.03284889832139015, 0.00010405993816675618, -0.06591366231441498, 0.017861098051071167, 0.013341024518013, 0.018093565478920937, 0.028951773419976234, 0.009313243441283703, -0.0015979100717231631, -0.025417901575565338, -0.024363914504647255, -0.0019030150724574924, 0.021159177646040916, 0.001028797123581171, 0.060860633850097656, 0.0045136562548577785, -0.026172131299972534, 0.05567792057991028, 0.044627971947193146, 0.009633766487240791, 0.06646787375211716, 0.02500191517174244, -0.001381309819407761, -0.006995359901338816, -0.050453606992959976, -0.013271176256239414, 0.0281753558665514, -0.043952494859695435, 0.021560050547122955, 0.0065727513283491135, -0.009959453716874123, 0.05572284758090973, -0.014044110663235188, -0.006918045692145824, -0.04778758063912392, -0.007061347831040621, -0.010662942193448544, 0.017507921904325485, 0.034779466688632965, -0.03573569655418396, 0.011289382353425026, 0.0023266004864126444, 0.013619538396596909, -0.01717970333993435, 0.037528712302446365, -0.007671233266592026, -0.06152830272912979, -0.07203484326601028, -0.02447466365993023, -0.010198060423135757, 0.005237479694187641, -0.011030524037778378, -0.0025800166185945272, 0.03674466907978058, -0.045417360961437225, 0.04898689314723015, -0.009962581098079681, 0.04704003781080246, 0.02891498990356922, 0.08399496972560883, 0.03243538364768028, 0.04674184322357178, -0.0008577131666243076, -0.036669690161943436, 0.13940678536891937, 0.07940120249986649, 0.07000195980072021, -0.03927474096417427, 0.01995658501982689, 0.019020168110728264, 0.0072866398841142654, 0.011553509160876274, -0.005011942703276873, 0.0014694408746436238, -0.03160111978650093, 0.07142425328493118, 0.035066645592451096, 0.00329037569463253, 0.02410782501101494, 0.016226714476943016, -0.050497449934482574, -0.041314758360385895, 0.007144743110984564, 0.03274552896618843, -0.006611007731407881, -0.05454504117369652, -0.051273684948682785, 0.032648298889398575, 0.0015222112415358424, -0.03411735221743584, -0.015637114644050598, -0.033921875059604645, 0.0006753758061677217, 0.010571759194135666, -0.014065280556678772, -0.007432251702994108, -0.00001184635857498506, 0.03075285255908966, 0.027505949139595032, -0.031349752098321915, -0.011206340976059437, -0.039656057953834534, -0.011581050232052803, 0.047310780733823776, 0.046876657754182816, 0.009543130174279213, -0.01870056614279747, -0.012151330709457397, -0.04499206691980362, -0.008514423854649067, 0.03190966323018074, 0.048823025077581406, -0.04905720427632332, 0.0005921355914324522, -0.013125302270054817, 0.029919704422354698, 0.010906090028584003, -0.032205332070589066, -0.014513686299324036, 0.04700132831931114, 0.03897999972105026, 0.03232896327972412, -0.020645443350076675, 0.008045431226491928, -0.009537541307508945, -0.00011963913857471198, 0.04908530041575432, -0.0075330669060349464, 0.00450658006593585, -0.03175419196486473, -0.011300072073936462, 0.04903653636574745, -0.0036112277302891016, -0.014954796992242336, 0.012662717141211033, -0.04595947265625, -0.0065940991044044495, -0.031162168830633163, 0.029592815786600113, -0.026498522609472275, 0.01003712322562933, 0.01784801296889782, -0.02748679183423519, -0.058141034096479416, -0.025897948071360588, 0.03456428274512291, -0.038409680128097534, -0.005866049788892269, -0.009145760908722878, 0.009647914208471775, 0.034091509878635406, 0.053245965391397476, 0.01498577743768692, -0.0014904310228303075, 0.005945704877376556, 0.07518361508846283, 0.019897503778338432, -0.03337296470999718, -0.03657645359635353, 0.001847767853178084, -0.030533378943800926, 0.01619950868189335, 0.010442138649523258, 0.04182645305991173, 0.0326848141849041, 0.03609738498926163, -0.021255452185869217, 0.06138760596513748, -0.02675415761768818, -0.0008334683370776474, -0.013690792955458164, -0.06251303106546402, -0.013714855536818504, -0.0060296389274299145, 0.007401232607662678, -0.020514879375696182, 0.008890105411410332, -0.01128936093300581, -0.011189538985490799, 0.011470290832221508, -0.0200637336820364, -0.03617459163069725, -0.05275063216686249, 0.010994100011885166, -0.017037104815244675, 0.0055318474769592285, 0.004363448359072208, 0.006279710680246353, -0.005879490170627832, -0.02359137497842312, -0.047540828585624695, -0.03310449793934822, 0.019564922899007797, -0.02175286039710045, -0.012147347442805767, 0.019038841128349304, 0.021568171679973602, 0.0322272852063179, 0.028041662648320198, -0.02568656951189041, 0.014072485268115997, 0.016444621607661247, 0.0033413569908589125, -0.0072664483450353146, 0.00016003201017156243, -0.08546478301286697, -0.02733379788696766, 0.00016866430814843625, 0.03902575746178627, 0.012990877032279968, -0.0022486671805381775, -0.0068131303414702415, -0.05151621624827385, 0.05656501278281212, -0.015258305706083775, -0.030690176412463188, -0.010806036181747913, -0.009141418151557446, -0.0007930279243737459, -0.00011769992124754936, -0.006988687440752983, 0.006597280967980623, -0.019766071811318398, 0.02738817408680916, 0.0360293947160244, 0.01765965111553669, -0.015000538900494576, 0.030177025124430656, -0.003656214103102684, 0.01939060539007187, 0.005102615803480148, -0.021301325410604477, 0.02637999877333641, 0.050155408680438995, -0.001482156221754849, 0.019726043567061424, -0.039443355053663254, 0.011727950535714626, -0.10624939948320389, -0.05088911950588226, 0.022754009813070297, -0.021901516243815422, 0.031840648502111435, -0.05287546664476395, 0.028688816353678703, 0.009412338025867939, -0.037492427974939346, 0.03503504768013954, -0.021470369771122932, -0.013919822871685028, -0.003066006116569042, 0.01128336787223816, -0.009451569989323616, 0.02504195086658001, 0.008993564173579216, 0.0015374262584373355, 0.04954028129577637, 0.011947708204388618, 0.024653134867548943, -0.05241607874631882, -0.01663263328373432, 0.024005858227610588, 0.055939506739377975, -0.047931358218193054, 0.016457512974739075, -0.036885034292936325, 0.0014613339444622397, 0.006653110962361097, -0.02092597261071205, 0.015281029976904392, 0.016903189942240715, 0.04389578104019165, 0.004082525614649057, 0.05940459296107292, 0.03859829902648926, 0.01025652140378952, 0.022407852113246918, -0.01457405835390091, 0.04557020589709282, 0.01844295859336853, 0.014725415967404842, 0.022404279559850693, 0.020556271076202393, -0.013417261652648449, -0.010799731127917767, 0.03289247676730156, -0.02642964944243431, -0.02757537178695202, -0.021654024720191956, -0.01308074314147234, 0.012082431465387344, -0.04527992755174637, 0.005427324213087559, -0.051881950348615646, -0.031832195818424225, 0.061929021030664444, 0.043061669915914536, -0.016002481803297997, 0.04568111151456833, -0.01107469666749239, -0.0561775267124176, 0.006762659642845392, 0.016710205003619194, -0.014075489714741707, -0.04162042960524559, 0.02903776988387108, -0.0018497994169592857, -0.01137886755168438, -0.04403862729668617, -0.026691030710935593, -0.07028549164533615, 0.03974056616425514, -0.038669101893901825, -0.03261939063668251, -0.006972364615648985, 0.003799187485128641, 0.03240613266825676, -0.057941753417253494, 0.05419118329882622, -0.008720126003026962, -0.05552339181303978, 0.014968608506023884, 0.02174568735063076, -0.02387974224984646, 0.0031826954800635576, 0.04888495057821274, -0.01870592124760151, -0.023913469165563583, -0.022063784301280975, 0.04491499438881874, 0.03170740604400635, -0.05282370746135712, 0.011317565105855465, -0.00769724091514945, -0.05634318292140961, 0.0035867460537701845, 0.008653810247778893, 0.006934318691492081, 0.020118428394198418, -0.0029104510322213173, -0.008241253904998302, -0.006314685568213463, 0.034363847225904465, -0.007039733696728945, -0.004398157354444265, -0.028741778805851936, -0.0308255385607481, 0.04892408847808838, -0.007073408458381891, 0.022101840004324913, 0.024546993896365166, 0.039116207510232925, -0.021387336775660515, 0.04244733229279518, -0.03835175186395645, -0.03231858089566231, -0.0026288803201168776, 0.0007705460884608328, -0.011615138500928879, -0.06172413378953934, -0.02995285578072071, 0.03103410080075264, -0.03297446295619011, -0.002398774726316333, 0.00584971159696579, 0.0035727517679333687, 0.049615081399679184, -0.0045257131569087505, 0.023356394842267036, 0.007967076264321804, -0.013323135673999786, 0.07449979335069656, 0.029021427035331726, -0.06109069287776947, -0.010662092827260494, -0.005239157006144524, -0.01770913414657116, -0.015555664896965027, 0.060569584369659424, -0.0037954833824187517, 0.058852314949035645, -0.004730314947664738, -0.023958997800946236, 0.00645466148853302, -0.02314482070505619, 0.05782406032085419, -0.0008527821046300232, -0.006629184354096651, 0.03437905013561249, -0.01234752219170332, 0.011524559929966927, -0.02775505557656288, -0.020841794088482857, -0.05549997836351395, 0.012751509435474873, -0.00019400514429435134, 0.029269874095916748, 0.0004162758414167911, 0.006587451323866844, 0.027396855875849724, -0.007751064840704203, 0.02279338613152504, -0.03379667177796364, -0.006411232985556126, -0.025346653535962105, -0.02380603924393654, 0.010073114186525345, -0.015682434663176537, -0.029236124828457832, -0.026997312903404236, -0.0008114601369015872, 0.040162552148103714, 0.03829720616340637, -0.02878406271338463, -0.03718438744544983, -0.0053886235691607, 0.03933335840702057, -0.03579900786280632, -0.007087534759193659, -0.01773141883313656, 0.0050931707955896854, 0.012998687103390694, -0.046349555253982544 ]
<p>Suppose that we have an $M/GI/\infty$ queue, that is, we have infinitely many servers, a Poisson arrival process with rate $\lambda$ (i.e., random arrival times $0=t_0 &lt; t_1 &lt; t_2 &lt; \dots &lt; t_n &lt; \dots$, with inter-arrival times $\theta_n = t_n - t_{n-1}$ being independent exponentially distributed with mean $1/\lambda$ ), and i.i.d delays (independent of arrivals) with finite mean $\tau$. We know (e.g., from the book of Takacs[1962]) that there exists a stationary distribution such that the size $q(t)$ of queue at time $t$ (in the steady-state) follows a Poisson distribution with mean $\lambda \alpha$, that is,</p> <p>$ P(q(t) = k ) = \dfrac{e^{-\lambda \tau}(\lambda \tau)^k}{k!}, \qquad $ for all $t \ge 0$.</p> <p>Now suppose that we want the distribution of the size of queue at the time of the $n$ arrival, assuming that it is in the steady state. That is, we want $p_k = P(q_n = k)$, where $q_n = \lim_{t \to t_n^-} q(t)$. How can we obtain $p_k$?</p>
35,948
[ -0.009438544511795044, -0.02827530913054943, 0.04451870173215866, -0.015724141150712967, 0.04797053709626198, 0.0046958355233073235, 0.006360962055623531, 0.012463542632758617, -0.0027926950715482235, 0.0033965480979532003, 0.02152794413268566, 0.05107817426323891, 0.025675393640995026, 0.01272295881062746, 0.02416904643177986, 0.016968214884400368, -0.03510094806551933, -0.02249022200703621, -0.022535592317581177, -0.0052335225045681, 0.011472661979496479, 0.04908803105354309, 0.034540142863988876, -0.06091900169849396, -0.05367834493517876, 0.004747916013002396, -0.01302562840282917, -0.005348869599401951, 0.0161453764885664, 0.055811405181884766, -0.07094031572341919, 0.02496436983346939, 0.0008528752950951457, 0.06555691361427307, 0.012836565263569355, 0.01668722741305828, -0.03174733743071556, -0.045722343027591705, 0.013518625870347023, 0.00004855979568674229, -0.04079888015985489, -0.009810266084969044, -0.014042683877050877, -0.009928734973073006, 0.006030883174389601, 0.020994003862142563, -0.030232049524784088, -0.05137118324637413, 0.02496386505663395, -0.0530659556388855, 0.03753333538770676, -0.019221214577555656, 0.026981988921761513, -0.007153473794460297, 0.022824270650744438, 0.000814928556792438, 0.05364485830068588, 0.04266062378883362, 0.0033374533522874117, -0.018676837906241417, 0.0166494008153677, -0.00956251285970211, 0.013406907208263874, -0.026242101565003395, 0.0010531558655202389, 0.005924704484641552, -0.008463812991976738, -0.00799141637980938, 0.03419826924800873, -0.02826785482466221, 0.004739033989608288, 0.011884894222021103, 0.025459179654717445, -0.013584491796791553, 0.00414229417219758, -0.0036038528196513653, 0.04815027117729187, -0.0007996107451617718, 0.0339118130505085, 0.026577087119221687, 0.0027462164871394634, 0.0047709825448691845, 0.0429263673722744, 0.03948774188756943, -0.004562493413686752, -0.013735980726778507, 0.09015028923749924, 0.0254850871860981, 0.01592858135700226, 0.010492976754903793, 0.004284853581339121, 0.006738810800015926, 0.01733294129371643, -0.02427542954683304, -0.04188242554664612, 0.012391673400998116, -0.00503526208922267, 0.026827313005924225, -0.004440646152943373, -0.008114206604659557, 0.010805405676364899, -0.05386120453476906, 0.023731358349323273, 0.035544369369745255, 0.00782636646181345, -0.0012578845489770174, -0.026337286457419395, 0.0019623241387307644, -0.06440503895282745, -0.026395369321107864, -0.03876658156514168, 0.027042722329497337, 0.02305220626294613, 0.01815943792462349, -0.005418514367192984, -0.016603857278823853, 0.02702375501394272, -0.02635049633681774, 0.05565136671066284, 0.0994047075510025, 0.018487218767404556, -0.010167303495109081, 0.015792448073625565, -0.02331128716468811, -0.05434897914528847, 0.02021135576069355, 0.006921340245753527, -0.01634170487523079, -0.08236642181873322, 0.04081149399280548, -0.01447328832000494, -0.010468820109963417, 0.02283882349729538, 0.03169761225581169, 0.058767180889844894, -0.014883955009281635, -0.08087988197803497, 0.0021736337803304195, 0.040061067789793015, -0.04705200716853142, 0.006893637124449015, -0.06823793798685074, -0.00676212040707469, 0.06163248047232628, 0.04683377593755722, -0.0295732244849205, 0.04491168633103371, -0.06158490851521492, -0.0035714691039174795, -0.016752835363149643, -0.051264721900224686, -0.02806614525616169, -0.005952545907348394, -0.007237852085381746, 0.018310265615582466, -0.07664971798658371, 0.01670212112367153, 0.04185475781559944, 0.03936092182993889, -0.022135155275464058, 0.06778270751237869, -0.0026381611824035645, -0.03336784243583679, -0.044491253793239594, 0.015434088185429573, -0.039416320621967316, 0.0877954363822937, 0.01784798502922058, 0.013585461303591728, -0.01102366205304861, 0.03703007474541664, 0.0024007479660212994, -0.0007457153405994177, 0.042794369161129, 0.007367131765931845, -0.030549440532922745, -0.025880377739667892, -0.01713230274617672, 0.01882910542190075, 0.05136784538626671, -0.0037826471962034702, 0.0014103499706834555, -0.036044564098119736, 0.012215857394039631, 0.015807507559657097, 0.0369860976934433, 0.001100615132600069, 0.05745988339185715, 0.02209463343024254, -0.02118760347366333, -0.05665016546845436, -0.05628989264369011, 0.0483725480735302, 0.014281559735536575, 0.00430795643478632, 0.05091571435332298, 0.016578806564211845, -0.015276171267032623, -0.01639501191675663, -0.007813538424670696, 0.001429338357411325, -0.023730510845780373, 0.013285365886986256, -0.07460329681634903, 0.004930922295898199, 0.07180337607860565, 0.02568691223859787, 0.020276909694075584, 0.05072832480072975, -0.009466302581131458, -0.0642932578921318, -0.00962897203862667, -0.053225576877593994, 0.05790010467171669, -0.029475299641489983, -0.005112168844789267, -0.026452671736478806, -0.0029090752359479666, 0.02015073411166668, 0.010028574615716934, -0.04066628962755203, 0.031904563307762146, 0.06749872863292694, 0.04871999844908714, 0.01646941713988781, -0.0030414070934057236, -0.007779859472066164, -0.007135506719350815, -0.0037586542312055826, -0.041425541043281555, -0.036489371210336685, -0.042214229702949524, 0.04795711115002632, 0.024213505908846855, -0.011261247098445892, 0.02016911655664444, 0.03851393610239029, 0.04254363104701042, 0.004513951484113932, 0.026731833815574646, -0.04483494907617569, 0.0006370112532749772, 0.0519883967936039, 0.0311423409730196, 0.01140813808888197, 0.02081964910030365, -0.004661473911255598, -0.01252586767077446, -0.0001658433029660955, -0.006163608282804489, 0.002086327411234379, 0.012177119962871075, 0.0006016748957335949, 0.012601807713508606, -0.010608835145831108, -0.06249991059303284, 0.026838691905140877, -0.004533165600150824, -0.0017092128982767463, -0.00836830772459507, 0.007514873519539833, 0.028422847390174866, 0.02073935978114605, -0.05419057980179787, 0.018700873479247093, -0.007977579720318317, -0.020237846300005913, -0.02564386837184429, 0.02543211355805397, -0.03723365440964699, 0.030204571783542633, -0.0015012959484010935, -0.06587989628314972, -0.011910956352949142, 0.0367506705224514, 0.03611968830227852, 0.02520488016307354, 0.005786258261650801, -0.010439394041895866, -0.03648144379258156, 0.034270718693733215, -0.016266167163848877, 0.036112815141677856, 0.010175109840929508, -0.03394848108291626, -0.0009929012740030885, 0.004949761554598808, -0.0605299174785614, 0.025134047493338585, 0.02123282477259636, 0.03250656649470329, -0.0059118084609508514, -0.032244984060525894, -0.03244350478053093, -0.02586434595286846, -0.038398806005716324, 0.01959327794611454, -0.02452334389090538, -0.01577131077647209, 0.03968400880694389, 0.00935906358063221, -0.007486468181014061, 0.014408398419618607, -0.03275229036808014, -0.05302870646119118, 0.0034286745358258486, 0.019729219377040863, 0.033133167773485184, -0.04813053458929062, 0.0450509712100029, 0.024748224765062332, -0.019168348982930183, -0.013117359019815922, -0.057936109602451324, -0.07042622566223145, 0.004926461260765791, -0.020829305052757263, 0.06853490322828293, -0.004824909381568432, -0.06385475397109985, 0.04579532518982887, 0.022850774228572845, 0.016222519800066948, 0.025125160813331604, 0.014134773053228855, -0.033062998205423355, -0.025497477501630783, 0.010378320701420307, -0.034024838358163834, -0.05733813717961311, 0.03820816054940224, 0.032450247555971146, 0.04118427261710167, 0.061398036777973175, 0.0010349939111620188, -0.010379265062510967, 0.025564752519130707, -0.0047636982053518295, 0.03347039967775345, 0.005954436492174864, 0.006405019201338291, -0.019321005791425705, -0.000670688459649682, 0.0011756999883800745, 0.038739655166864395, -0.009083922952413559, -0.01731751672923565, 0.0029762464109808207, -0.003790971590206027, 0.013606341555714607, -0.053266994655132294, 0.03794967383146286, -0.011824813671410084, -0.044352639466524124, 0.0036590672098100185, 0.033495061099529266, 0.004356635734438896, -0.05440002307295799, 0.008236351422965527, 0.03728213161230087, 0.04581166431307793, -0.022496139630675316, -0.05827239155769348, -0.03175051137804985, -0.03265615180134773, 0.01617228053510189, -0.010585998184978962, -0.006657884456217289, 0.00359571841545403, 0.019663793966174126, -0.004044453147798777, -0.022020168602466583, 0.004783210344612598, -0.02635466307401657, -0.06694868952035904, 0.010573310777544975, -0.003914091736078262, 0.0444890558719635, 0.05109051987528801, 0.04833156615495682, -0.0015107246581465006, -0.006003028247505426, 0.0062520792707800865, 0.03154343366622925, -0.09322720021009445, -0.011600269936025143, -0.026246802881360054, 0.008503610268235207, 0.009614860638976097, 0.006878666579723358, 0.039030514657497406, -0.019693462178111076, 0.016952943056821823, 0.014502120204269886, 0.0021714726462960243, -0.03469781577587128, 0.0003723080735653639, -0.04733596742153168, -0.04040472209453583, -0.015908578410744667, -0.01439718808978796, 0.0005062081036157906, -0.012720761820673943, 0.005060975439846516, 0.04787082225084305, -0.007913320325314999, -0.01588178053498268, -0.027030181139707565, 0.013601402752101421, -0.004464064259082079, 0.00736408494412899, 0.06453122943639755, 0.039592500776052475, -0.005357319954782724, 0.01954931952059269, 0.008290299214422703, 0.023409727960824966, 0.03884849697351456, 0.04491255059838295, 0.035593949258327484, -0.05895998701453209, -0.010100153274834156, 0.023034119978547096, 0.02577660232782364, 0.021749243140220642, -0.04742481932044029, 0.06624753028154373, 0.024919141083955765, -0.03600618615746498, 0.014188733883202076, 0.04132217541337013, 0.02176077477633953, 0.0020261502359062433, -0.01973339542746544, 0.009352777153253555, -0.0027214924339205027, 0.017400868237018585, -0.009452790021896362, 0.01094161905348301, 0.02149263769388199, 0.01957418955862522, 0.017933135852217674, -0.025402944535017014, 0.008986224420368671, -0.029682353138923645, -0.0020460786763578653, 0.04637005925178528, 0.011013789102435112, 0.006375163793563843, 0.013483540154993534, 0.00800469983369112, -0.001677089836448431, 0.015520165674388409, -0.019734714180231094, -0.0648018941283226, -0.03587764501571655, 0.02910950966179371, 0.008306088857352734, 0.00562925823032856, -0.007831491529941559, -0.04514903575181961, -0.02154485322535038, 0.034498557448387146, -0.02127094194293022, 0.05356615409255028, 0.018154995515942574, -0.04266556724905968, 0.009565391577780247, 0.0028029270470142365, -0.019408948719501495, 0.025720316916704178, 0.0023377644829452038, 0.018309159204363823, -0.019700724631547928, -0.0038490474689751863, -0.04256012663245201, -0.028426848351955414, 0.01059550791978836, 0.06651750206947327, 0.0016843132907524705, -0.00742065766826272, -0.012469490990042686, 0.02003120817244053, -0.0009404493612237275, -0.08534687757492065, 0.0337095633149147, -0.01767650991678238, -0.0007391475955955684, 0.04794967174530029, -0.03722978010773659, -0.041184186935424805, 0.031055022031068802, 0.03059895895421505, -0.0190755445510149, 0.010377899743616581, -0.038057826459407806, 0.06412490457296371, 0.0014133303193375468, 0.014108301140367985, 0.07166885584592819, 0.024134084582328796, 0.007798781618475914, -0.0033962070010602474, -0.007702924311161041, 0.030378835275769234, -0.010568139143288136, -0.01684381812810898, -0.041220638900995255, 0.004970415960997343, -0.046536561101675034, 0.04129895940423012, 0.019532358273863792, -0.008440070785582066, -0.0005788240814581513, -0.003199497703462839, -0.002230985788628459, 0.02132454328238964, 0.021066857501864433, -0.0032899428624659777, 0.006859396118670702, 0.015941958874464035, 0.00786140002310276, -0.00897486973553896, 0.016584808006882668, -0.02193515934050083, 0.02871890924870968, 0.01183148380368948, 0.006252114195376635, 0.038266487419605255, -0.03804263100028038, 0.006262799259275198, 0.039417002350091934, -0.012880530208349228, 0.04074691981077194, -0.013203754089772701, 0.026993287727236748, 0.03313937783241272, -0.04504246637225151, -0.014212924987077713, -0.010414136573672295, -0.008266431279480457, 0.01847263053059578, -0.04371296241879463, 0.03387519344687462, 0.0153144346550107, -0.011415328830480576, -0.12775835394859314, -0.01993129588663578, 0.02908056043088436, -0.006493190303444862, -0.009470452554523945, -0.04186737537384033, -0.00830803345888853, -0.005670706741511822, -0.049456458538770676, 0.008122486993670464, 0.03203340992331505, 0.03490253910422325, -0.024414749816060066, -0.0019378503784537315, 0.043874192982912064, 0.04692772403359413, 0.022826015949249268, 0.0028678986709564924, 0.009098958224058151, -0.03993586450815201, -0.014137827791273594, 0.0031302457209676504, 0.04150277003645897, -0.015494161285459995, -0.006548530422151089, -0.025057107210159302, -0.01864865981042385, -0.01910368539392948, -0.017372896894812584, -0.052741680294275284, 0.012081961147487164, 0.012234624475240707, 0.015267791226506233, 0.00412452407181263, -0.006667712237685919, 0.02310016192495823, 0.0060312398709356785, -0.03087403066456318, -0.0159522145986557, 0.026618560776114464, 0.007214227691292763, 0.03574362397193909, -0.005580464377999306, 0.006521549541503191, 0.010018525645136833, 0.06227196380496025, -0.03128288686275482, -0.017143946141004562, 0.0006435935501940548, 0.002634488046169281, 0.01938377320766449, -0.005149641539901495, -0.0342741496860981, 0.02738160453736782, -0.03100057691335678, -0.02166350744664669, -0.04435531049966812, -0.06434279680252075, 0.017554808408021927, 0.029827918857336044, -0.009887460619211197, 0.04654579609632492, -0.010519025847315788, 0.0010495750466361642, -0.0008712021517567337, 0.018258927389979362, -0.020680859684944153, -0.027753794565796852, -0.0045175631530582905, 0.03126557543873787, -0.02488815411925316, 0.0073399473913013935, 0.04412122070789337, -0.010877312161028385, 0.0206246767193079, 0.023188505321741104, -0.00812079943716526, -0.021970195695757866, 0.02424057200551033, -0.028790073469281197, -0.03399966284632683, 0.04502498358488083, -0.03865503519773483, -0.0017268747324123979, 0.005091765895485878, -0.037721168249845505, 0.06605758517980576, 0.026419689878821373, 0.03142765536904335, -0.016563797369599342, 0.005860918667167425, -0.05713871493935585, 0.02416880615055561, 0.009987025521695614, 0.033276259899139404, 0.019969988614320755, -0.0035769082605838776, 0.02118358388543129, 0.016601720824837685, 0.032925527542829514, 0.0009839701233431697, -0.05159924179315567, -0.05594451352953911, -0.04333619028329849, -0.0359245166182518, 0.042325299233198166, 0.009310852736234665, -0.03811139613389969, 0.007168132811784744, -0.038240160793066025, 0.027769843116402626, 0.0024872561916708946, 0.04367474094033241, -0.04327338561415672, 0.10058409720659256, 0.015323420986533165, 0.01922258920967579, 0.005527872126549482, 0.010317375883460045, 0.12392748892307281, 0.06637786328792572, 0.02507544681429863, -0.08485197275876999, 0.019997013732790947, -0.00778278848156333, -0.02806295081973076, -0.03924540430307388, 0.007194227539002895, 0.014513871632516384, -0.01280208770185709, 0.028011882677674294, 0.03499160334467888, -0.005435082130134106, -0.017827291041612625, 0.07321032136678696, -0.044273603707551956, -0.03947203606367111, 0.014960329979658127, 0.019328434020280838, -0.009391531348228455, -0.014834830537438393, -0.03050469048321247, 0.027839461341500282, -0.01468010526150465, 0.012534720823168755, -0.0003921944589819759, -0.008962241932749748, -0.038511697202920914, -0.00850855652242899, -0.024812577292323112, -0.018331384286284447, 0.03277980163693428, -0.013033471070230007, 0.0364476703107357, 0.01950123906135559, -0.02397969737648964, -0.020380668342113495, 0.03149251639842987, 0.06733798235654831, 0.005344786215573549, -0.025769494473934174, 0.04144339635968208, 0.007394560147076845, -0.03231877088546753, -0.0330161489546299, -0.023270312696695328, 0.01887868344783783, -0.02438441850244999, 0.01969359815120697, -0.0166653860360384, -0.02953675575554371, -0.0241160299628973, -0.03850221261382103, 0.01379518210887909, 0.0058153122663497925, 0.04253324121236801, -0.04343710467219353, -0.0013413883280009031, -0.026631029322743416, 0.007975378073751926, 0.018474318087100983, 0.01713431440293789, 0.036640360951423645, -0.0518055334687233, -0.006496731657534838, -0.016226913779973984, 0.05012036859989166, -0.0029764522332698107, -0.00828323420137167, -0.03278111666440964, -0.014518084935843945, -0.030432380735874176, 0.012065121904015541, -0.009922804310917854, -0.010357016697525978, 0.030615560710430145, -0.02084631845355034, 0.0001951197482412681, 0.009805070236325264, -0.03732902184128761, 0.015267270617187023, -0.019614089280366898, -0.03996030241250992, -0.029186364263296127, -0.006878788582980633, -0.026469232514500618, 0.02681906148791313, 0.0062100766226649284, 0.012684270739555359, -0.012517663650214672, 0.04431716725230217, -0.000649786670692265, -0.03519764170050621, -0.008595582097768784, -0.027325313538312912, -0.04731272533535957, 0.0005603869212791324, -0.01177984569221735, 0.03311518207192421, 0.03987286239862442, 0.04082237556576729, 0.0007843864150345325, -0.0012994740391150117, -0.01313073467463255, 0.021352779120206833, 0.00603482685983181, -0.019088782370090485, -0.001489261514507234, 0.043834079056978226, 0.050824981182813644, -0.023564493283629417, -0.03287156671285629, 0.010848750360310078, 0.015812784433364868, -0.008362843655049801, -0.01595231704413891, -0.017489228397607803, -0.016891781240701675, -0.004777120891958475, 0.00955259520560503, -0.061932522803545, -0.015615763142704964, -0.0007975822663865983, -0.0037146860267966986, -0.01883556693792343, 0.009636483155190945, -0.013499923050403595, 0.007530261296778917, -0.014569763094186783, -0.04743684455752373, -0.014986127614974976, 0.038278982043266296, -0.006227411329746246, -0.003027678467333317, 0.009607050567865372, 0.01085253618657589, 0.018857695162296295, -0.06206941977143288, -0.017839228734374046, 0.04246865585446358, -0.03564966097474098, -0.009318385273218155, 0.01562800444662571, 0.005944640375673771, 0.06196316331624985, 0.02031945064663887, -0.019560378044843674, -0.022015025839209557, 0.008542196825146675, -0.046187613159418106, -0.017573272809386253, -0.011024781502783298, -0.004966197535395622, 0.030164476484060287, -0.017787886783480644, -0.014134631492197514, 0.028599681332707405, 0.005484124645590782, -0.00789640098810196, 0.03666293993592262, -0.01578483358025551, -0.0088335070759058, 0.017760954797267914, 0.017871003597974777, 0.006387542001903057, 0.021895218640565872, 0.003442349610850215, 0.024609949439764023, 0.08326131105422974, -0.024639571085572243, -0.005243012215942144, -0.05719198286533356, -0.0036714051384478807, -0.08653780072927475, -0.008037697523832321, 0.012479354627430439, 0.02027476765215397, 0.08672434091567993, -0.03593574836850166, -0.03073757141828537, 0.03355623409152031, -0.06771755963563919, 0.037937942892313004, 0.0006859906134195626, -0.007179702632129192, -0.05352022498846054, 0.013184958137571812, -0.05865061655640602, 0.024399781599640846, 0.058572303503751755, 0.022103326395154, 0.054664067924022675, 0.030122974887490273, 0.006336020305752754, 0.01126018539071083, -0.010570955462753773, 0.03074447438120842, 0.007960368879139423, -0.026805806905031204, 0.0634383112192154, -0.04332219809293747, -0.02181890420615673, 0.04695947840809822, -0.012758268974721432, -0.004655233584344387, -0.0020951577462255955, 0.022692112252116203, -0.019693410024046898, 0.04690162092447281, 0.05261871591210365, 0.013517171144485474, 0.04005451872944832, -0.0232797022908926, 0.045631490647792816, 0.03249023109674454, -0.0042071775533258915, 0.012687310576438904, 0.05423768237233162, -0.0382869690656662, -0.0012659011408686638, 0.019600216299295425, -0.020446816459298134, -0.03640838339924812, 0.03867635503411293, -0.005663031712174416, 0.0018577752634882927, -0.01114653330296278, 0.034451741725206375, -0.02093617431819439, -0.03544927015900612, 0.02432415634393692, 0.028896702453494072, -0.0009628810221329331, -0.0007330800290219486, -0.02281312458217144, -0.02806522138416767, 0.013121337629854679, 0.01292000338435173, -0.02153557725250721, -0.0515880323946476, 0.0033458829857409, -0.030071230605244637, -0.007139023393392563, -0.009666617959737778, -0.04508764669299126, -0.040227241814136505, 0.0260043703019619, -0.008792907930910587, -0.0030391451437026262, -0.005730357952415943, -0.013123064301908016, 0.015656674280762672, -0.02694602869451046, 0.04429422691464424, 0.0053859916515648365, 0.008567115291953087, -0.03565208986401558, -0.0566241592168808, -0.03252702206373215, 0.0016228333115577698, 0.054794978350400925, 0.010104483924806118, -0.018261384218931198, 0.0058210077695548534, 0.02140611782670021, 0.011029982008039951, -0.05549300089478493, 0.0016976211918517947, -0.047033075243234634, -0.025203421711921692, -0.02579648233950138, -0.014115572907030582, 0.041257020086050034, 0.000981353223323822, 0.017318768426775932, 0.0028440463356673717, 0.02166992425918579, 0.025202274322509766, -0.052315905690193176, 0.02963102236390114, -0.004316199570894241, -0.010190978646278381, 0.03987860679626465, -0.025314921513199806, 0.0143425352871418, -0.01670934446156025, -0.014094740152359009, -0.07660504430532455, 0.010438305325806141, -0.015286640264093876, 0.011707262136042118, -0.04921773821115494, 0.010611469857394695, -0.004325253888964653, -0.060659054666757584, -0.023780906572937965, 0.047216542065143585, -0.02891172096133232, -0.027330627664923668, 0.021740740165114403, 0.036697834730148315, 0.04898781701922417, -0.006590686272829771, -0.024927690625190735, 0.014150883071124554, 0.027835993096232414, 0.017338361591100693, 0.06180763617157936, -0.013604293577373028, -0.04581736400723457, 0.04013725742697716, 0.02529394067823887, -0.030402380973100662, 0.033496350049972534, -0.0036105653271079063, 0.04373797029256821, -0.023991044610738754, -0.04618053138256073, 0.027546560391783714, -0.022442398592829704, 0.021038180217146873, 0.01937682367861271, -0.0024248873814940453, 0.07585163414478302, 0.0028093368746340275, 0.05258389562368393, -0.006195250898599625, -0.018326187506318092, -0.015243773348629475, -0.02923591248691082, -0.024525489658117294, 0.028688611462712288, -0.035466380417346954, 0.013480383902788162, -0.0018211334245279431, -0.0029882185626775026, 0.012202974408864975, -0.056274160742759705, -0.003571116365492344, 0.04857534170150757, -0.025870222598314285, -0.03486347198486328, -0.051045361906290054, -0.00047611494665034115, -0.04246804490685463, 0.0391150638461113, 0.04875263571739197, 0.03632984310388565, 0.01214136928319931, -0.002786483382806182, -0.013322841376066208, 0.07099749892950058, -0.044760897755622864, -0.004525211174041033, -0.05752997845411301, -0.03658047690987587, 0.010735584422945976, -0.003931373357772827 ]
<p>I'm a programer, but I know very little about statistics and am not even sure where or how to ask this. Lets say you have 2 variables about people in general, var A and var B, that are tangible characterists of these people. People either possess A or B. </p> <p>I then take 11 different measurements about the person and use those to determine if they are actually A or B without looking at them. The program successfully determines if someone is A or B in a group of 10 people. But as I test more and more people, I find that some people have slight differences or exceptions in their variables that I have to account for.</p> <p>Example: All A people have the first variable in a range of 12 to 13, the 2nd variable in a range of 5 to 6, but then I find an A person who has a range of 1 for the 2nd variable. So I add to the formula that if the 2nd variable = 1, then the person has A. </p> <p>My question - How many people would I have to test out to get an accuracy rating above 80% of the program, or is that even possible. As I add more and more subjects that fit that equation, does that translate into an increase in accuracy of the program when used on the general population?</p>
73,551
[ -0.03743366152048111, 0.018222201615571976, -0.014871999621391296, -0.02928350865840912, 0.0636412724852562, -0.0023393381852656603, -0.03129231557250023, -0.03342624008655548, 0.009788327850401402, 0.01566419005393982, 0.031238438561558723, 0.02808133326470852, 0.03941521793603897, 0.014483507722616196, 0.03274140506982803, -0.013383530080318451, -0.02768910862505436, 0.03918163478374481, 0.03003505989909172, 0.004364167805761099, -0.019064750522375107, 0.012257492169737816, 0.04428812488913536, -0.025451170280575752, 0.00021588568051811308, 0.02928333543241024, 0.02350582554936409, -0.04978799819946289, 0.03808853030204773, 0.026727670803666115, -0.019183587282896042, -0.011434227228164673, 0.04469411447644234, 0.02033889852464199, 0.04299230873584747, -0.006830045022070408, -0.05500158295035362, -0.012859320268034935, -0.012709707953035831, 0.018628111109137535, -0.05945933237671852, -0.002358360681682825, -0.0029263056349009275, 0.04034813866019249, -0.015906991437077522, -0.014519455842673779, -0.01689315028488636, -0.04533649981021881, 0.03140499070286751, -0.0643097534775734, 0.07934238761663437, 0.035090964287519455, 0.06298285722732544, 0.0342930406332016, -0.006458266172558069, -0.010002357885241508, 0.04592880606651306, 0.0623648427426815, 0.005410070065408945, -0.04054991900920868, -0.017711861059069633, -0.0003075969871133566, -0.03310077264904976, -0.010714382864534855, -0.017570827156305313, 0.041891910135746, -0.036956869065761566, -0.015233403071761131, 0.019616371020674706, -0.011178921908140182, 0.034739404916763306, 0.04093652591109276, 0.026918591931462288, 0.0026427798438817263, 0.016748985275626183, -0.03080299124121666, 0.021550124511122704, -0.009998657740652561, 0.04929342493414879, 0.006887790746986866, -0.04213967174291611, 0.0007592181791551411, 0.05097648873925209, 0.04895208775997162, 0.0382872000336647, -0.03103967197239399, 0.03293720260262489, -0.03814643248915672, 0.04408016428351402, 0.01984150893986225, -0.029163159430027008, -0.004972053691744804, 0.053194861859083176, 0.013277567923069, -0.040804456919431686, 0.04485065117478371, -0.04529901593923569, 0.026497699320316315, 0.004807010293006897, -0.0021572320256382227, -0.005306930281221867, 0.02845151536166668, 0.014070319943130016, 0.04118696600198746, -0.016719887033104897, -0.027277633547782898, -0.01375950314104557, -0.04287055879831314, 0.008107943460345268, -0.01030943263322115, -0.00866258330643177, -0.0038152290508151054, -0.004014667123556137, -0.000015284778783097863, 0.0463934950530529, -0.005595131777226925, -0.005000064615160227, -0.03356923907995224, 0.07411924004554749, 0.029287168756127357, 0.05867641419172287, -0.015947464853525162, 0.026459306478500366, 0.0022506259847432375, 0.012270969338715076, 0.00188753055408597, 0.0006294146296568215, -0.015125327743589878, -0.05661015957593918, 0.01802435889840126, 0.00553905451670289, -0.019402965903282166, 0.043205566704273224, -0.0022659923415631056, 0.009272088296711445, -0.02359069511294365, -0.11964129656553268, -0.04814741387963295, 0.0009011244401335716, -0.001062789000570774, 0.026140443980693817, -0.0715266689658165, 0.012665707617998123, 0.05028185993432999, 0.04519394412636757, 0.02697623334825039, 0.053852833807468414, 0.009822315536439419, 0.02289629355072975, 0.012942910194396973, -0.021971845999360085, 0.01228121668100357, -0.03355279564857483, -0.03240177407860756, -0.020635686814785004, -0.09393978118896484, 0.013749899342656136, 0.01705717295408249, -0.030440405011177063, -0.030431700870394707, 0.004117097705602646, 0.02712811902165413, -0.014005218632519245, -0.023716364055871964, 0.040720291435718536, 0.024677488952875137, 0.08174686878919601, -0.014767922461032867, 0.025588760152459145, 0.029841987416148186, 0.012334463186562061, 0.028762197121977806, 0.036678995937108994, 0.040820613503456116, 0.04906989261507988, -0.006697625387459993, 0.006522985640913248, -0.025688305497169495, 0.018389832228422165, 0.001439036917872727, -0.037424176931381226, -0.028707966208457947, -0.014661774970591068, 0.006843297742307186, 0.0427318699657917, 0.004974322859197855, -0.009671212173998356, 0.014470010995864868, 0.04643930494785309, -0.03129182755947113, -0.05117054283618927, -0.07519840449094772, 0.0008459907257929444, -0.0031818756833672523, -0.04825045168399811, 0.006985465530306101, 0.011529690586030483, 0.020307401195168495, -0.0010319524444639683, -0.00979528296738863, -0.0391380749642849, 0.003930764738470316, 0.045440398156642914, -0.04884565621614456, 0.030559981241822243, 0.061355672776699066, 0.05253837630152702, -0.02903330698609352, 0.06173565611243248, -0.0321585051715374, -0.05631578341126442, -0.010226650163531303, -0.0536937415599823, 0.024864375591278076, -0.0013620470417663455, -0.01332767028361559, 0.005002365447580814, 0.020349552854895592, -0.0006442457670345902, 0.04732314497232437, -0.058922041207551956, 0.07779137045145035, 0.05451897904276848, 0.0022325473837554455, 0.00045891496120020747, 0.00708844605833292, 0.019625920802354813, -0.03971751406788826, -0.013986540026962757, -0.028405940160155296, -0.08054644614458084, 0.003291577100753784, 0.005546802654862404, 0.012532232329249382, -0.041205741465091705, 0.004737799987196922, 0.0500333271920681, 0.024344583973288536, -0.019626909866929054, -0.002447456121444702, 0.016943862661719322, -0.03223941847681999, 0.003167992690578103, 0.018407445400953293, 0.02044149674475193, 0.030514605343341827, 0.045736003667116165, 0.0246723759919405, 0.014061170630156994, 0.007366674952208996, 0.02416827343404293, 0.021100185811519623, -0.006525328382849693, 0.01555849052965641, -0.006155414041131735, 0.012914914637804031, 0.03219751641154289, -0.020508892834186554, 0.0027116239070892334, 0.025824550539255142, 0.007668922655284405, -0.02806810848414898, -0.042999520897865295, -0.02097725123167038, 0.019251897931098938, 0.05524221807718277, -0.010011769831180573, -0.02936585806310177, 0.0001187658854178153, -0.044489044696092606, -0.0009994696592912078, -0.046089060604572296, -0.00811794400215149, -0.03979150205850601, 0.020234739407896996, 0.029587045311927795, 0.02101169340312481, 0.0350906141102314, -0.005074598826467991, -0.02425428479909897, 0.008076168596744537, -0.022614944726228714, 0.014208542183041573, -0.01811440847814083, -0.07706888020038605, -0.01964365690946579, -0.006444786675274372, -0.018508974462747574, 0.03474213182926178, -0.012892605736851692, -0.016165969893336296, 0.04621967300772667, -0.009471015073359013, -0.04539434239268303, -0.022250551730394363, -0.040305495262145996, -0.018433216959238052, -0.027926284819841385, -0.023683711886405945, -0.0015664692036807537, 0.029777705669403076, -0.03942301496863365, 0.019927097484469414, -0.055295784026384354, -0.015536383725702763, -0.04903339594602585, 0.008660071529448032, 0.015489964745938778, 0.02532942406833172, 0.004089397843927145, 0.037118662148714066, -0.01675984263420105, -0.025158056989312172, -0.07434399425983429, -0.08451690524816513, 0.017817074432969093, 0.016084324568510056, 0.04110880196094513, -0.003642849624156952, 0.01587667316198349, 0.08833299577236176, 0.023172957822680473, -0.033062443137168884, -0.015448096208274364, -0.0019347242778167129, -0.00965609960258007, 0.00538305239751935, 0.02677176706492901, 0.02585628256201744, -0.027740485966205597, 0.03254513069987297, -0.004144464619457722, 0.04984140768647194, 0.06706634163856506, -0.026745617389678955, -0.021382082253694534, 0.023188553750514984, 0.021892201155424118, -0.009551137685775757, 0.013697585090994835, 0.025298450142145157, -0.03950345143675804, 0.011568425223231316, -0.0004356010176707059, 0.04042026773095131, 0.015560155734419823, -0.028629064559936523, 0.0282626673579216, -0.017128897830843925, 0.037086423486471176, -0.0374424010515213, -0.00001772927316778805, -0.03757262974977493, -0.01848706416785717, 0.0006803799187764525, 0.03644724190235138, 0.03621763363480568, -0.02353770285844803, -0.02582092024385929, 0.06886062026023865, 0.04662445932626724, -0.01215722132474184, -0.017847314476966858, 0.001757450751028955, -0.014923423528671265, 0.010479185730218887, -0.011350993998348713, -0.031134827062487602, 0.03333340957760811, 0.061125244945287704, 0.023423191159963608, -0.027805883437395096, -0.030102262273430824, 0.023977108299732208, -0.054467834532260895, -0.019738448783755302, -0.013167588040232658, 0.029637116938829422, -0.013326209038496017, 0.039293866604566574, -0.00903556402772665, 0.003911780193448067, 0.010141540318727493, 0.01342441700398922, -0.04994992911815643, 0.0170761551707983, -0.02448762208223343, -0.022553497925400734, -0.0021176510490477085, -0.022326765581965446, 0.038071468472480774, -0.034662242978811264, 0.0034387654159218073, 0.005862906575202942, 0.04803476110100746, -0.013914762996137142, 0.004912988748401403, -0.0061934026889503, -0.006533629726618528, -0.029635988175868988, 0.021338870748877525, -0.04043322056531906, -0.013414815999567509, 0.0644678995013237, 0.034848231822252274, -0.011318941600620747, -0.022332264110445976, -0.03675021976232529, 0.0004817513981834054, 0.03318850323557854, 0.05591919645667076, 0.03971333056688309, 0.05925503000617027, -0.07545921951532364, 0.03744539991021156, -0.024745754897594452, 0.05417528748512268, 0.029767297208309174, -0.008469624444842339, -0.034000810235738754, -0.03892512992024422, -0.058345917612314224, -0.012313018552958965, 0.006687123328447342, 0.005948573816567659, -0.0038631949573755264, 0.019747896119952202, 0.02657567337155342, -0.05252638831734657, 0.019001217558979988, 0.06561235338449478, -0.016714705154299736, 0.00497033167630434, -0.0012332804035395384, -0.0026487656868994236, -0.03315101936459541, -0.031410910189151764, 0.004618403501808643, -0.0027847401797771454, -0.02753267250955105, 0.010311447083950043, 0.05484544485807419, -0.02268030121922493, -0.048440877348184586, 0.009309634566307068, 0.0017594457603991032, 0.029038719832897186, 0.02331622876226902, -0.023903926834464073, 0.01647981069982052, 0.007876395247876644, 0.03649076819419861, 0.010376466438174248, 0.010733619332313538, -0.08845393359661102, 0.031838785856962204, 0.04554757475852966, 0.04122353717684746, -0.05821759253740311, -0.016390500590205193, -0.008628955110907555, 0.004615924321115017, 0.04568486288189888, -0.03965551778674126, 0.02800382301211357, -0.013419774360954762, 0.016520906239748, -0.042818762362003326, -0.021294426172971725, -0.01899888925254345, 0.008573446422815323, -0.03833436220884323, 0.04652364179491997, -0.016650086268782616, 0.010891701094806194, -0.02050558291375637, 0.028650324791669846, 0.029760578647255898, 0.08545443415641785, -0.05518300086259842, -0.03192858397960663, 0.015764940530061722, -0.009993471205234528, -0.05172514170408249, -0.05406155809760094, 0.022333115339279175, -0.021432064473628998, 0.003965544048696756, 0.01890869438648224, 0.02099911868572235, -0.052878741174936295, -0.0025442657060921192, 0.018740138038992882, -0.013820618391036987, -0.03800290822982788, -0.006688243709504604, 0.0531260147690773, 0.01960083469748497, -0.0043572839349508286, 0.034345950931310654, -0.02322542667388916, 0.006125316955149174, 0.005380210932344198, -0.0016812094254419208, -0.020098190754652023, 0.0063857426866889, -0.03154536336660385, -0.028997091576457024, -0.020039962604641914, 0.0035400590859353542, 0.03394019231200218, 0.011050662957131863, 0.04260265827178955, -0.0540863461792469, 0.005156387109309435, -0.0017607396002858877, 0.030317071825265884, 0.0021053298842161894, 0.021529432386159897, 0.0026126226875931025, 0.010476099327206612, 0.006915673613548279, -0.01766195520758629, 0.005943169351667166, -0.015139701776206493, -0.014990689232945442, 0.009407641366124153, -0.03203912451863289, -0.0056120362132787704, -0.034106988459825516, -0.02760993503034115, -0.016393939033150673, -0.021772298961877823, 0.04117848351597786, -0.004718252923339605, 0.03416209667921066, -0.020535821095108986, -0.05649707466363907, -0.0358872264623642, 0.0007990764570422471, 0.00628616102039814, 0.07152212411165237, -0.02340068481862545, 0.023940201848745346, -0.04010626673698425, 0.007467112969607115, -0.05360957235097885, -0.01755412109196186, 0.006148704793304205, 0.009862643666565418, -0.019226720556616783, -0.043555475771427155, -0.0024189576506614685, -0.004349518101662397, 0.004880777094513178, -0.041523780673742294, 0.04583951085805893, 0.01562960259616375, -0.025358248502016068, 0.004878667648881674, -0.022408461198210716, 0.08106040209531784, 0.02214711345732212, -0.012100789695978165, -0.004334567580372095, -0.015533408150076866, 0.0074552008882164955, -0.014838237315416336, -0.02173229679465294, -0.047397416085004807, -0.030484169721603394, -0.027798308059573174, 0.03114740177989006, 0.025936346501111984, 0.00007407856173813343, 0.004085893742740154, 0.004244995303452015, -0.002637414960190654, 0.03715386986732483, -0.033918023109436035, -0.00421098992228508, -0.02772284857928753, -0.02130275033414364, -0.016266779974102974, 0.008344825357198715, -0.01808164082467556, 0.016008682548999786, 0.03632592409849167, 0.0068288883194327354, -0.036216482520103455, -0.005855504889041185, 0.07300394773483276, -0.0003761334519367665, -0.0035701277665793896, 0.0024641428608447313, -0.022373951971530914, 0.054456986486911774, 0.04422181099653244, -0.04714799299836159, -0.012426366098225117, 0.0458902083337307, -0.022904371842741966, 0.00476321903988719, -0.008598693646490574, 0.009583264589309692, 0.04990781098604202, 0.014375180006027222, 0.034273549914360046, 0.061686452478170395, 0.03037443943321705, -0.025317858904600143, -0.027880001813173294, -0.004092116840183735, -0.025774139910936356, 0.0016609152080491185, 0.029574410989880562, 0.0035071426536887884, -0.01696237362921238, 0.0070889494381845, 0.036152854561805725, 0.033025581389665604, 0.012338141910731792, 0.00746189896017313, 0.0250846017152071, 0.003600402968004346, -0.013678271323442459, -0.03823244199156761, 0.026273192837834358, -0.045184846967458725, -0.0018343522679060698, -0.03053360991179943, 0.00014890752208884805, 0.01734057627618313, 0.04248526319861412, 0.009341780096292496, -0.03212697058916092, -0.06573259085416794, -0.04639746621251106, 0.020283611491322517, 0.006503000855445862, -0.006578887812793255, 0.03759884834289551, 0.0016468223184347153, -0.0027570854872465134, 0.02991960011422634, 0.019170314073562622, -0.050379715859889984, -0.10839695483446121, -0.03212812542915344, -0.026930976659059525, -0.049673184752464294, 0.0396973192691803, 0.017495742067694664, -0.01286868005990982, 0.004863126669079065, -0.03386322781443596, 0.04806086793541908, 0.021513257175683975, 0.019353102892637253, -0.020543226972222328, 0.060647621750831604, -0.0020945603027939796, 0.04040518030524254, 0.005897172726690769, 0.0434444285929203, 0.09465085715055466, 0.07856553047895432, 0.010067201219499111, -0.038851749151945114, 0.02228611335158348, 0.016881944611668587, -0.011076387949287891, -0.005417110864073038, 0.012371210381388664, 0.01832681894302368, -0.018252599984407425, 0.034446004778146744, 0.03120415471494198, 0.05148843675851822, 0.013657525181770325, 0.10286803543567657, -0.02488645724952221, -0.029782840982079506, 0.027670608833432198, -0.01042942889034748, -0.002380711492151022, -0.0008578777778893709, 0.006091063376516104, 0.0017630603397265077, 0.005447259172797203, 0.005860768724232912, 0.005860093981027603, 0.023566724732518196, 0.0060817482881248, -0.012116951867938042, -0.03564027324318886, 0.02299346961081028, 0.013471685349941254, -0.007993615232408047, -0.04977197200059891, -0.04758049547672272, 0.015775877982378006, -0.03354715183377266, 0.0007180539541877806, 0.019492274150252342, -0.030178414657711983, 0.0036736843176186085, -0.003975760191679001, 0.031433962285518646, -0.03264549374580383, -0.006783607415854931, -0.011421900242567062, 0.03986737132072449, -0.000027888823751709424, -0.02609979175031185, -0.006370757706463337, 0.010959413833916187, -0.019013961777091026, -0.08010657876729965, -0.0446937158703804, 0.012803150340914726, 0.015325446613132954, -0.009290182031691074, -0.01163660641759634, 0.0048626805655658245, 0.042867518961429596, -0.024453166872262955, 0.008142150938510895, 0.036784689873456955, -0.0400877445936203, 0.01103279273957014, -0.014841408468782902, 0.022510087117552757, -0.024287866428494453, 0.002189049730077386, 0.0038090983871370554, -0.015347594395279884, -0.03013482317328453, -0.004897729959338903, 0.00989513099193573, 0.04812832176685333, -0.006293436046689749, 0.0012780858669430017, 0.026875970885157585, 0.0003242469974793494, 0.0020725284703075886, -0.005023429170250893, -0.012663439847528934, 0.019162509590387344, -0.01221937034279108, -0.011859769001603127, 0.0620005838572979, 0.017804360017180443, 0.0036659936886280775, 0.013205889612436295, -0.014956957660615444, 0.04162372648715973, -0.023363057523965836, -0.031111696735024452, -0.022445064038038254, -0.007075829431414604, -0.06988374143838882, 0.03312557935714722, -0.05128218233585358, 0.06712216138839722, -0.004751113243401051, 0.009047804400324821, 0.003356008790433407, 0.016304440796375275, -0.02536151371896267, 0.02273833565413952, -0.0020050660241395235, -0.06353262811899185, 0.00035485479747876525, -0.004203632473945618, -0.013890794478356838, -0.02805073745548725, -0.03521402180194855, -0.06449887156486511, -0.019114652648568153, 0.05627722293138504, -0.015795839950442314, -0.01406523771584034, 0.01353263296186924, 0.00040134775917977095, -0.03799164667725563, -0.010737891308963299, 0.009106838144361973, -0.017151713371276855, 0.00245393137447536, -0.01146110612899065, -0.006249597761780024, -0.010533352382481098, 0.00006056910933693871, -0.019258564338088036, 0.004742573015391827, 0.03036012127995491, -0.014736476354300976, 0.01959029771387577, -0.021317025646567345, 0.016653308644890785, 0.004113486036658287, 0.06257931888103485, -0.025478847324848175, -0.013490669429302216, 0.07403669506311417, -0.06922044605016708, -0.014312622137367725, 0.04092571884393692, -0.011199727654457092, 0.025721244513988495, 0.026274947449564934, -0.004204731900244951, 0.00565838860347867, 0.07050664722919464, -0.000926405075006187, 0.0011578702833503485, -0.015850668773055077, 0.03327590227127075, -0.00495763448998332, 0.011762863025069237, 0.023608408868312836, 0.015838513150811195, -0.038236793130636215, 0.041380416601896286, 0.06033807247877121, 0.004168500192463398, -0.0074321068823337555, -0.023399094119668007, 0.01241297461092472, -0.002347236732020974, 0.022318385541439056, -0.0063637057319283485, 0.02992207184433937, 0.027418477460741997, -0.029804321005940437, -0.006632404401898384, -0.015695540234446526, 0.03040337562561035, -0.07662307471036911, -0.027243025600910187, 0.021850861608982086, 0.030164038762450218, 0.03159043937921524, -0.035304438322782516, -0.00019905537192244083, -0.0015049806097522378, -0.033146440982818604, 0.00020482669060584158, -0.006978441495448351, 0.021435843780636787, -0.04640432074666023, 0.02180025726556778, -0.04374169185757637, -0.01402971800416708, 0.024105945602059364, 0.02900092490017414, 0.03277742117643356, 0.016193922609090805, -0.005435827653855085, -0.04605056717991829, -0.00018709208234213293, 0.025312073528766632, 0.013926348648965359, -0.060939379036426544, 0.0019157289061695337, -0.031202035024762154, -0.04140815511345863, 0.024220092222094536, -0.034234337508678436, 0.045565009117126465, 0.006304279901087284, 0.04129475727677345, 0.0087451646104455, 0.047827836126089096, 0.04923950135707855, 0.0054361093789339066, -0.029267800971865654, 0.03138405457139015, -0.017439313232898712, 0.03910926356911659, -0.007386889774352312, 0.005150812678039074, 0.04341450706124306, 0.005921788047999144, -0.05518488585948944, 0.024393608793616295, 0.01622314378619194, -0.011893276125192642, 0.0010567763820290565, -0.008847924880683422, 0.03162132203578949, -0.037991542369127274, 0.009897717274725437, -0.06038796529173851, -0.009490026161074638, 0.013030917383730412, 0.03083925135433674, 0.0021339256782084703, -0.012723700143396854, -0.015264342539012432, -0.021784557029604912, 0.05598122254014015, 0.021365759894251823, 0.010264559648931026, -0.0582294836640358, -0.001002822769805789, 0.0014552422799170017, 0.009458881802856922, 0.023175818845629692, -0.02151649072766304, 0.004168885760009289, 0.019585534930229187, -0.012756585143506527, -0.012491868808865547, 0.01951608993113041, -0.0046313246712088585, -0.022179879248142242, -0.09149083495140076, 0.09883416444063187, 0.006884478498250246, 0.01411543507128954, -0.06643745303153992, 0.02354532852768898, -0.04245380312204361, -0.009096109308302402, 0.02295994758605957, -0.006899720057845116, -0.014787931926548481, -0.012580960057675838, 0.004381928592920303, -0.022174352779984474, -0.05407504737377167, 0.0478331632912159, -0.013280696235597134, -0.04512271657586098, -0.05196637660264969, 0.005708304233849049, 0.0038122767582535744, -0.029892003163695335, -0.0135637316852808, -0.020697500556707382, -0.010160000063478947, -0.010545551776885986, -0.005004251375794411, 0.02364654652774334, 0.019483406096696854, 0.009441614151000977, 0.019100885838270187, -0.007222202140837908, 0.014208892360329628, 0.002431959845125675, -0.00009071765816770494, -0.01824362203478813, 0.032492831349372864, -0.021035674959421158, 0.0013311433140188456, 0.009525304660201073, 0.004924523178488016, -0.030916165560483932, -0.04924122244119644, 0.02075338177382946, 0.025782864540815353, -0.012391154654324055, 0.010315231047570705, 0.03066951595246792, 0.021146679297089577, 0.013214384205639362, -0.01635850965976715, 0.005708443466573954, 0.017026690766215324, -0.02633184753358364, 0.0017595450626686215, 0.028180371969938278, 0.030359352007508278, 0.02261480875313282, 0.007226642221212387, 0.05086229741573334, 0.0029474732000380754, 0.024858327582478523, 0.017001857981085777, 0.03654949739575386, -0.04203617572784424, 0.029592763632535934, 0.018703341484069824, -0.018455352634191513, 0.034503355622291565, 0.02457975037395954, -0.021406156942248344, 0.06023043394088745, -0.03559300675988197, -0.021450558677315712, -0.023617200553417206, 0.0060041239485144615, 0.0015589286340400577, -0.021273132413625717, 0.03624932840466499, 0.02136922813951969, 0.013407157734036446, -0.0012642118381336331, -0.017579274252057076, 0.003195042023435235, 0.04196537286043167, 0.0025322912260890007, 0.022797944024205208, -0.01981479674577713, 0.008029387332499027, -0.01942494511604309, 0.014340482652187347, -0.03908928483724594, -0.023230988532304764, 0.04522893950343132, 0.024051187559962273, 0.040318991988897324, -0.04705234616994858, -0.06829465180635452, 0.008136802352964878, 0.008332733996212482, -0.06357353925704956, -0.04492700845003128, -0.07047618180513382, 0.03941238671541214, -0.019909054040908813, -0.027554765343666077 ]
<p>I am searching for a good measure to capture clustering in time based events. Say that for a given interval of 5 minutes, cars randomly pass in front of house ... say one car at every 10 seconds (for a total of 30 cars). For another interval of 5 minutes, 3 cars passes at every thirty seconds, and the time between the three cars is 0 (again 30 cars over 5 minutes). The difference between both intervals is that for the second intervals, the arrival of cars "clusters". What can be a good measure to capture clustering? I would like a measure that indicates that there was more clustering in the second interval than the first one. </p>
73,552
[ -0.02577914297580719, -0.024684753268957138, -0.023078666999936104, 0.004596726968884468, 0.050089698284864426, -0.008451280184090137, 0.0009918971918523312, -0.010881667956709862, 0.020424162968993187, -0.007632997818291187, 0.018659217283129692, 0.050370074808597565, -0.0005707023665308952, 0.020782822743058205, 0.019998684525489807, 0.0026569869369268417, -0.0148475281894207, -0.010646985843777657, -0.02112514153122902, -0.025176595896482468, -0.0057336511090397835, -0.028784023597836494, 0.030098652467131615, -0.010108024813234806, -0.05742901936173439, 0.0217637550085783, 0.00003229203502996825, 0.0025886553339660168, -0.001119433669373393, 0.05648644641041756, -0.051367975771427155, -0.03833868354558945, 0.002100451849400997, 0.04322674497961998, 0.013995879329741001, 0.014998968690633774, -0.010722572915256023, -0.02470061182975769, -0.04354631528258324, -0.0012596086598932743, -0.04964199662208557, -0.02132611908018589, -0.02044409140944481, 0.0329413041472435, -0.03146766871213913, 0.00035270710941404104, 0.03054889291524887, -0.03562365844845772, 0.0349174328148365, -0.04110930860042572, 0.11346887052059174, -0.00898987241089344, 0.025972111150622368, 0.0041178264655172825, -0.017944898456335068, -0.004116683267056942, 0.031626202166080475, 0.0428064726293087, -0.017262252047657967, -0.013966254889965057, -0.044665005058050156, -0.029991164803504944, 0.026125485077500343, -0.0192735455930233, -0.054173991084098816, 0.03770870342850685, -0.0169399194419384, -0.02415962517261505, 0.0498550720512867, 0.009712647646665573, -0.04004301875829697, -0.01781219057738781, 0.07988610118627548, -0.008942235261201859, -0.004231741186231375, -0.05046674981713295, 0.013816691003739834, 0.024200841784477234, 0.07831431180238724, 0.025158293545246124, 0.013450468890368938, -0.01446769293397665, -0.006419967859983444, 0.043572910130023956, 0.048486482352018356, -0.02993643283843994, 0.07053906470537186, -0.05214931443333626, 0.007441799156367779, 0.03958447277545929, -0.045732591301202774, -0.00007017235475359485, 0.03212103620171547, 0.01961204968392849, -0.05885079503059387, 0.029221396893262863, -0.008867282420396805, 0.024450022727251053, 0.04018089920282364, 0.0088620251044631, 0.00006799970287829638, -0.0680566057562828, -0.003383147530257702, 0.05490484833717346, -0.008152438327670097, 0.0028060826007276773, -0.07221295684576035, -0.020336594432592392, -0.024700600653886795, 0.02782154083251953, -0.019140956923365593, -0.005829468369483948, 0.04214490205049515, 0.02755165845155716, 0.03418447822332382, 0.0032619675621390343, -0.005503231659531593, 0.01962996833026409, 0.04233773052692413, 0.07084232568740845, 0.05636874586343765, -0.03633713349699974, 0.004420981276780367, -0.02310657873749733, -0.06015067920088768, 0.01912350207567215, -0.0013408937957137823, -0.017143310979008675, -0.01692289300262928, 0.0636231005191803, 0.014356272295117378, -0.008126805536448956, 0.02442394569516182, -0.05983597785234451, 0.04050624370574951, -0.012658840976655483, -0.05536175146698952, -0.022396516054868698, 0.00016802913160063326, 0.020340966060757637, 0.00909064244478941, -0.03243090957403183, 0.004554847255349159, 0.00044244385208003223, 0.05633799359202385, 0.048671986907720566, 0.0350412093102932, -0.010360653512179852, 0.03616655245423317, -0.0013431477127596736, -0.017015375196933746, -0.03649367392063141, -0.01899932697415352, -0.00277892267331481, -0.0018415775848552585, -0.04398897662758827, 0.009496992453932762, 0.04115293547511101, -0.0035957302898168564, 0.0018919631838798523, 0.024506138637661934, 0.01935736835002899, -0.012763743288815022, 0.007524247746914625, 0.03447258472442627, -0.005768878851085901, 0.04348435252904892, -0.02530038356781006, -0.011742249131202698, -0.01051096897572279, 0.038582444190979004, 0.03720206767320633, 0.0422167032957077, 0.026437118649482727, 0.05924133583903313, -0.03708852455019951, 0.0027483003214001656, 0.0505807101726532, -0.00495381373912096, 0.012597013264894485, 0.006209975108504295, -0.009865930303931236, -0.0005222414038144052, 0.008568506687879562, -0.00583352567628026, 0.004834445659071207, -0.014861859381198883, -0.01776883192360401, 0.009037983603775501, -0.015306835994124413, -0.022196928039193153, -0.056281495839357376, 0.00590974185615778, 0.005681448616087437, -0.016008924692869186, 0.044876113533973694, -0.017766613513231277, 0.008591257967054844, -0.007827307097613811, -0.019958600401878357, -0.03711364418268204, -0.02356981486082077, 0.012390980497002602, -0.051010385155677795, -0.003707202384248376, 0.02526748925447464, 0.024837983772158623, -0.026685046032071114, 0.04042784869670868, -0.00010115308396052569, -0.026310740038752556, -0.024452390149235725, -0.016259757801890373, 0.024914616718888283, -0.02897542342543602, 0.012980770319700241, 0.031074073165655136, -0.013950483873486519, -0.022120848298072815, 0.014698312617838383, -0.0389784537255764, 0.06281521171331406, 0.05248228833079338, 0.029971132054924965, -0.0027098809368908405, -0.0037183265667408705, -0.008031033910810947, 0.002724817954003811, -0.013824806548655033, -0.06993670016527176, -0.05154934898018837, 0.024970008060336113, 0.04913996905088425, 0.021216601133346558, -0.04532795771956444, 0.0037472539115697145, 0.08695628494024277, 0.03149187192320824, 0.00015044219617266208, 0.04479955509305, -0.021821387112140656, -0.007792510557919741, 0.029520690441131592, 0.04068392142653465, 0.024352077394723892, -0.033285025507211685, 0.05251934751868248, -0.01989705301821232, 0.02602420188486576, -0.003255535615608096, -0.019216030836105347, 0.005059127230197191, 0.022547127678990364, 0.013302776962518692, -0.03286145627498627, -0.019182750955224037, 0.011211743578314781, -0.009157984517514706, -0.00563461659476161, 0.007103584706783295, 0.028156593441963196, 0.011918834410607815, 0.009330946952104568, -0.03664602339267731, 0.03706527128815651, 0.018167756497859955, -0.0433206669986248, -0.0020963563583791256, 0.005837786011397839, 0.005728363990783691, 0.0460573211312294, 0.006560741923749447, -0.00016805328777991235, -0.05523691698908806, -0.009848803281784058, 0.053281594067811966, -0.0026456015184521675, 0.00769196217879653, -0.016059553250670433, -0.00567798363044858, -0.019453739747405052, 0.03120383992791176, 0.011774703860282898, 0.022056253626942635, -0.05966341868042946, 0.015288189984858036, 0.019408175721764565, -0.014853304252028465, 0.014932697638869286, 0.0008340058266185224, -0.0490773469209671, 0.018305057659745216, 0.004777180962264538, -0.05178437381982803, 0.010355439968407154, -0.01536101009696722, 0.030525291338562965, -0.019084928557276726, -0.012335793115198612, 0.03157858923077583, 0.0005038179224357009, -0.08147528767585754, 0.04195583984255791, -0.045705489814281464, -0.005806974601000547, -0.058431584388017654, -0.001619824324734509, -0.00022104110394138843, -0.03802626579999924, 0.028348421677947044, 0.03134128078818321, -0.019499000161886215, 0.012880914844572544, -0.02694779820740223, -0.090965636074543, -0.01919352449476719, -0.03728577494621277, 0.049692150205373764, -0.012155321426689625, -0.03761144354939461, 0.03176866099238396, 0.038952019065618515, -0.023584026843309402, -0.02054639905691147, 0.011225830763578415, -0.024987300857901573, 0.012520012445747852, 0.02470226399600506, 0.01301948819309473, 0.012712644413113594, 0.0037051518447697163, 0.023885512724518776, 0.04845154285430908, 0.06685511767864227, 0.007516534999012947, -0.00809579435735941, 0.017528081312775612, 0.00014602321607526392, 0.01089294720441103, 0.024232584983110428, 0.03684334084391594, -0.08054759353399277, 0.018493719398975372, -0.02908913791179657, 0.020110158249735832, 0.023048823699355125, -0.04469260573387146, 0.011330082081258297, -0.01247396320104599, -0.016315683722496033, -0.015833336859941483, 0.02514856494963169, -0.0011335985036566854, -0.01081941369920969, -0.022465646266937256, 0.05253168195486069, 0.028947407379746437, 0.0001390075485687703, -0.00809275172650814, 0.054806940257549286, 0.06511775404214859, -0.021448377519845963, -0.03303675726056099, -0.029306989163160324, -0.04480893164873123, 0.026734095066785812, -0.0243896022439003, -0.02094600349664688, 0.005457300692796707, 0.013522211462259293, 0.028171351179480553, -0.0013579054502770305, -0.03744177892804146, -0.0054845926351845264, -0.051645830273628235, 0.009039051830768585, 0.0015321222599595785, 0.033985741436481476, 0.013618183322250843, 0.03674797713756561, 0.006433405447751284, -0.028076952323317528, 0.02878083847463131, -0.04484705254435539, -0.068357914686203, 0.02695649117231369, -0.026318075135350227, -0.035967376083135605, -0.02030784823000431, -0.002964687766507268, 0.005116591230034828, -0.011915788054466248, 0.04051445797085762, -0.014117170125246048, 0.05175969749689102, -0.0554053895175457, -0.010050581768155098, -0.03338246047496796, -0.008987854234874249, 0.004067287314683199, 0.00715969642624259, 0.0330447219312191, 0.019738957285881042, 0.04422982409596443, 0.010296959429979324, 0.007002702448517084, -0.018459206447005272, 0.006534704938530922, -0.02039925754070282, -0.005330691114068031, 0.007432865910232067, 0.02818894386291504, 0.02092260867357254, -0.03427848219871521, 0.02364841289818287, -0.005047339480370283, 0.0280714463442564, 0.02038334310054779, 0.00013571357703767717, -0.010014697909355164, -0.03115890361368656, -0.035201720893383026, 0.03423323482275009, 0.022624963894486427, 0.0026205023750662804, 0.014767940156161785, 0.036254171282052994, 0.024008112028241158, -0.029088718816637993, 0.007042052689939737, 0.038831207901239395, 0.01638662815093994, -0.013776857405900955, -0.057227637618780136, -0.0029393292497843504, 0.05636872723698616, -0.014028182253241539, 0.0039540803991258144, 0.024584298953413963, 0.022622443735599518, 0.003355453023687005, 0.017368651926517487, 0.0012176053132861853, -0.0202022735029459, -0.01191939227283001, -0.002742771292105317, 0.011444199830293655, 0.019689414650201797, -0.03941814973950386, -0.00047900888603180647, 0.038931701332330704, 0.031243029981851578, 0.06493403017520905, -0.03661609813570976, -0.08925271034240723, -0.006779720075428486, 0.0257357656955719, -0.0006514223641715944, -0.029686618596315384, -0.009046773426234722, -0.0009546935907565057, -0.0019282025750726461, 0.03148213401436806, -0.04506129026412964, 0.01179385744035244, -0.030711911618709564, -0.023652253672480583, -0.0071422564797103405, -0.004453557077795267, -0.025903059169650078, 0.008467914536595345, 0.009098258800804615, 0.06258915364742279, -0.018441643565893173, -0.021448921412229538, -0.05092056095600128, 0.026354443281888962, 0.015368204563856125, 0.03765171021223068, -0.02354368008673191, -0.005087465513497591, -0.019343946129083633, 0.029783450067043304, -0.012444957159459591, -0.06564698368310928, 0.02084939181804657, 0.015064699575304985, -0.005107076372951269, 0.0370473712682724, -0.016659805551171303, -0.0032508058939129114, -0.014473490417003632, -0.03196042403578758, -0.008303235284984112, 0.0179122481495142, -0.03764382377266884, 0.05395372956991196, 0.03490598127245903, 0.04293123260140419, 0.016870707273483276, 0.036507800221443176, 0.041934553533792496, 0.03791641816496849, 0.021599404513835907, 0.030874093994498253, -0.048389215022325516, 0.0052294000051915646, -0.014198902994394302, -0.01282375305891037, -0.06392545253038406, 0.05034526437520981, -0.04650649055838585, 0.028985362499952316, -0.01638207770884037, -0.017424587160348892, 0.007233046926558018, 0.033237941563129425, -0.0020238375291228294, 0.01950446330010891, -0.023338619619607925, -0.003310245228931308, 0.025600772351026535, 0.001953576924279332, 0.020489629358053207, -0.05925163999199867, -0.01158799696713686, 0.00925152562558651, -0.013734248466789722, 0.014868032187223434, -0.02975326031446457, -0.01947755366563797, 0.024479776620864868, -0.02057243511080742, 0.03672743961215019, -0.04609588533639908, 0.026431314647197723, -0.0019704471342265606, -0.019572993740439415, -0.01279933750629425, 0.028100689873099327, -0.014154034666717052, 0.07515887916088104, -0.06575559824705124, 0.04827601835131645, 0.00652853911742568, -0.017379235476255417, -0.07602006942033768, -0.06369105726480484, 0.05965263769030571, 0.010008561424911022, -0.039183199405670166, -0.04701985418796539, -0.0051786755211651325, -0.009865516796708107, -0.025927096605300903, -0.010850311256945133, 0.05840509757399559, 0.027369923889636993, -0.027933822944760323, -0.024653803557157516, 0.011195148341357708, 0.07253097742795944, 0.01450277864933014, -0.015200088731944561, 0.0006215589237399399, 0.008200549520552158, -0.028079913929104805, 0.009053446352481842, 0.02306404896080494, -0.0284064169973135, 0.023184727877378464, -0.021612778306007385, 0.017689671367406845, 0.03984219208359718, -0.0670744776725769, -0.02170417085289955, -0.0010341124143451452, -0.007161412388086319, 0.011304558254778385, -0.008435814641416073, 0.013714466243982315, -0.020892351865768433, -0.05229037255048752, -0.019413672387599945, -0.011939095333218575, -0.009331837296485901, -0.02289058081805706, 0.021597646176815033, 0.016673250123858452, -0.025939103215932846, -0.013810285367071629, 0.06358809769153595, 0.060524724423885345, -0.03906286880373955, 0.04192803055047989, 0.007348627783358097, 0.03290082514286041, -0.036281004548072815, -0.020987272262573242, 0.029313398525118828, 0.023905640468001366, -0.01775212399661541, -0.010735779069364071, -0.020834065973758698, -0.005943640135228634, 0.04811231046915054, -0.01616770215332508, 0.06909021735191345, 0.06892044097185135, 0.017316367477178574, -0.009018751792609692, -0.008487737737596035, 0.027458639815449715, 0.001387419062666595, 0.024781422689557076, 0.02980264648795128, -0.02486368641257286, -0.003958968911319971, 0.000630345253739506, 0.031506821513175964, -0.0018736361525952816, 0.04320526123046875, 0.0153622105717659, 0.03839660435914993, 0.048018816858530045, -0.03634292259812355, -0.04869840294122696, -0.010126524604856968, -0.03327746316790581, 0.011653244495391846, -0.030169792473316193, -0.007059410680085421, 0.033868636935949326, 0.06753843277692795, -0.008381136693060398, -0.009507125243544579, -0.004339249804615974, -0.051710497587919235, -0.009818938560783863, 0.013162166811525822, -0.042473629117012024, 0.02264246717095375, 0.03096543624997139, 0.014347444288432598, 0.028230423107743263, -0.023020504042506218, 0.0026855405885726213, -0.04694904759526253, 0.0017707205843180418, -0.03403065353631973, -0.031176378950476646, 0.02361641637980938, 0.020724058151245117, -0.04454854130744934, 0.007649009581655264, 0.029643774032592773, -0.022584114223718643, 0.0037870933301746845, 0.014576621353626251, 0.008744676597416401, 0.08926156163215637, 0.04679195210337639, 0.020941823720932007, -0.017734840512275696, -0.011181348003447056, 0.09285195171833038, 0.06729768961668015, 0.027921656146645546, -0.009296353906393051, 0.026174409314990044, 0.02739892341196537, 0.008249795995652676, -0.04973142221570015, 0.03275395184755325, 0.04597102478146553, -0.0010427883826196194, 0.04430661350488663, 0.05315818637609482, 0.007951089181005955, -0.02707454189658165, 0.06215037778019905, -0.02487647719681263, -0.029522502794861794, -0.023831915110349655, 0.038283850997686386, 0.02884960174560547, -0.023349471390247345, -0.09711373597383499, 0.04608328267931938, 0.027593592181801796, 0.014473222196102142, 0.0019202105468139052, -0.011422261595726013, -0.0024698993656784296, -0.017296092584729195, 0.011876057833433151, 0.020852483808994293, 0.0387105830013752, 0.012453468516469002, -0.05289790406823158, -0.009564177133142948, 0.025359440594911575, 0.011630736291408539, -0.0025625270791351795, 0.0174625925719738, 0.02672921121120453, -0.016493698582053185, -0.03530961275100708, 0.01494022086262703, -0.0513639897108078, -0.028783602640032768, -0.04055808112025261, 0.041136302053928375, -0.008336925879120827, 0.026716850697994232, -0.007438382599502802, 0.03378552943468094, 0.024581095203757286, -0.05926278978586197, -0.03933146595954895, -0.019708847627043724, 0.016765154898166656, -0.030620230361819267, -0.028215890750288963, -0.048357002437114716, 0.021902786567807198, 0.004394990857690573, -0.011437281966209412, 0.013255810365080833, 0.01790158450603485, -0.037286970764398575, -0.030750621110200882, 0.05309528484940529, -0.018396787345409393, -0.029873864725232124, 0.010190506465733051, -0.046059656888246536, -0.017843903973698616, 0.016211172565817833, -0.015327404253184795, -0.0008493784116581082, 0.02393483743071556, 0.023191524669528008, -0.007803633343428373, 0.011162316426634789, -0.011787637136876583, -0.0073599242605268955, -0.02435031533241272, -0.033556465059518814, -0.022081537172198296, 0.004700807388871908, 0.026153013110160828, 0.042364221066236496, -0.009725650772452354, 0.03532439097762108, -0.015035200864076614, 0.039200495928525925, 0.00502393813803792, -0.0214768685400486, 0.01504853181540966, -0.004071525298058987, -0.022077711299061775, 0.011120414361357689, -0.000753888685721904, 0.04529519006609917, -0.0008271248661912978, -0.052237823605537415, 0.022558454424142838, 0.028312336653470993, -0.00848433468490839, 0.019983593374490738, 0.009238493628799915, -0.043167077004909515, -0.043663181364536285, -0.013954387977719307, 0.005509751383215189, -0.03144875913858414, -0.0397547110915184, -0.005750613287091255, 0.004225758835673332, -0.014769695699214935, -0.02821670100092888, -0.014813941903412342, -0.009750566445291042, -0.028549326583743095, 0.03195682913064957, -0.028915634378790855, 0.008454423397779465, -0.05344851315021515, -0.010854451917111874, -0.04613272473216057, -0.04125344753265381, -0.02540985681116581, 0.007052173372358084, 0.025296101346611977, 0.009193850681185722, 0.04179932922124863, 0.0004384047642815858, 0.01715601421892643, -0.039216797798871994, 0.013454671949148178, -0.007710565347224474, 0.0656401515007019, -0.06336289644241333, -0.013848645612597466, 0.0716787725687027, -0.07685967534780502, -0.04503455385565758, 0.03662412613630295, -0.013901382684707642, 0.02719101496040821, 0.008048194460570812, 0.01439353171736002, 0.013967983424663544, 0.047976329922676086, -0.026775941252708435, -0.0456903837621212, 0.004056910518556833, 0.013603853061795235, -0.02980837970972061, -0.03100394271314144, -0.005603489000350237, 0.020177224650979042, -0.03534123674035072, 0.004743260331451893, 0.06087607145309448, -0.021189190447330475, -0.0017385020619258285, 0.004767755512148142, -0.013002004474401474, 0.017076510936021805, -0.028718112036585808, -0.02000800520181656, 0.03694523498415947, 0.057848863303661346, -0.0646335706114769, 0.009016115218400955, -0.015632621943950653, -0.0056409756653010845, -0.05868329852819443, -0.005114263389259577, -0.0070314607582986355, 0.01152897160500288, 0.05824267864227295, -0.053386133164167404, -0.02378060296177864, 0.03685846924781799, -0.026708582416176796, 0.040530819445848465, -0.005448402836918831, -0.012466869316995144, -0.05322588235139847, -0.0036111525259912014, -0.001133341109380126, 0.03135158121585846, 0.03697260096669197, 0.03303012251853943, 0.022679060697555542, 0.0463838204741478, -0.014427533373236656, -0.039635200053453445, 0.00533780874684453, 0.019811080768704414, 0.047080155462026596, -0.002085066633298993, 0.05061688646674156, -0.04751959070563316, -0.03075305186212063, 0.048986658453941345, -0.026454022154211998, 0.01599009335041046, 0.019811704754829407, 0.023677395656704903, -0.02156001143157482, 0.039038900285959244, 0.020281745120882988, -0.005278604105114937, 0.020181506872177124, 0.005630688741803169, -0.013421440497040749, -0.00999316107481718, -0.01767376996576786, 0.008890808559954166, 0.05332214757800102, 0.015495418570935726, -0.04048270359635353, 0.008017613552510738, 0.02358459308743477, -0.03860417753458023, 0.0032990407198667526, -0.013730807229876518, 0.013683702796697617, 0.007170381490141153, -0.003390909405425191, -0.011122940108180046, -0.007557418197393417, 0.042830947786569595, 0.034182630479335785, -0.03609435260295868, 0.0012622596696019173, -0.05190752446651459, -0.03876702859997749, 0.018591761589050293, -0.007898365147411823, -0.015765734016895294, -0.06615210324525833, -0.02348051406443119, 0.0032733180560171604, 0.02382957749068737, -0.022147847339510918, -0.01356206089258194, 0.03438139706850052, 0.06912946701049805, -0.016369057819247246, -0.04707228019833565, 0.0573783740401268, 0.012592309154570103, 0.022571908310055733, -0.07147683948278427, 0.02658854052424431, 0.012427795678377151, 0.013093055225908756, -0.05187991261482239, -0.019075503572821617, -0.06723741441965103, 0.012599430046975613, 0.06839528679847717, 0.011705254204571247, -0.031053900718688965, -0.0013798987492918968, 0.022822845727205276, 0.028897741809487343, -0.024332920089364052, 0.012131144292652607, -0.02191801927983761, -0.019734129309654236, -0.004303250461816788, -0.025008132681250572, 0.02727341838181019, -0.01793074421584606, 0.032208651304244995, 0.003294112626463175, -0.022274276241660118, -0.04221738502383232, -0.00981373991817236, 0.05406547337770462, 0.020358117297291756, -0.0018946458585560322, 0.02047918550670147, -0.006639136467128992, 0.00947872456163168, 0.02718166634440422, -0.011656231246888638, -0.048769496381282806, 0.024765463545918465, -0.0341220498085022, -0.03691747784614563, 0.02647918090224266, 0.008306734263896942, 0.010569003410637379, -0.057383596897125244, -0.045852918177843094, 0.00810232013463974, -0.022072607651352882, -0.002955842763185501, 0.04174326732754707, 0.03268476203083992, 0.05270842835307121, -0.006528201047331095, 0.04022636637091637, 0.001178482547402382, 0.026632776483893394, -0.01847909204661846, 0.04811840504407883, 0.030586061999201775, 0.002311223652213812, 0.020846866071224213, -0.012546871788799763, -0.03513770550489426, 0.04734225943684578, -0.002955879783257842, 0.035196926444768906, 0.021210070699453354, -0.014337207190692425, 0.018222598358988762, -0.02377738244831562, 0.016758868470788002, 0.015495950356125832, 0.03616207838058472, 0.02104119397699833, -0.024306489154696465, 0.00400306424126029, -0.05426619574427605, -0.004347898531705141, -0.05009891837835312, 0.02196553908288479, 0.016731204465031624, 0.021075747907161713, -0.017628582194447517, 0.017573745921254158, -0.011684497818350792, -0.02015126682817936, 0.03608996793627739, -0.03792303800582886, 0.05272786319255829, -0.025885535404086113, -0.01172463595867157, -0.04358696937561035, -0.0030202986672520638, -0.06217395141720772, -0.024195857346057892, -0.002419457770884037, 0.06422975659370422, 0.03126190975308418, -0.004355081357061863, -0.023626210168004036, -0.004686415661126375, 0.040213920176029205, -0.053966082632541656, -0.006531196646392345, -0.060092099010944366, 0.024778343737125397, -0.019170625135302544, -0.025823606178164482 ]
<p>I am testing a self-implemented PCA on a set of image data ($N \times d$, $N = 10000$ sample size, $d = 28 \times 28$ feature size). When I observed the classification accuracy, I found the accuracy increase somehow with the increased <em>target reduced dimension</em> $k$ and decresed from then on. See the image below:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/upcc3.png" alt="y: accuracy out of 10k, x: reduced dimension"></p> <p>The maximum accuracy corresponded to $PoV = 89\%$.</p> <p>I also tried reducing the data to $k = d$, the accuracy was still much lower than the maximum showed in the graph.</p> <p>Is these what is expected for <strong>PCA</strong>? Or my <strong>classifier</strong> is not working?</p> <p><em>How can I interpret the "information lost" for different $k$ in PCA?</em></p> <p>ps: I even tried the "princomp' built-in function, it yield similar result.</p> <hr> <p>UPDATE: </p> <p>Sorry for not stating clearly. For both training set itself and a separate test set as test set, I got similar result as in the graph.</p>
35,950
[ -0.005627719219774008, 0.007421622984111309, 0.004736398346722126, -0.018552009016275406, 0.04898762330412865, -0.01785382628440857, -0.0504273995757103, -0.04175876826047897, 0.0032250606454908848, -0.07215838879346848, 0.01145388837903738, 0.021321222186088562, 0.06919369101524353, 0.06317376345396042, -0.02712612971663475, -0.005319435149431229, -0.04498128592967987, 0.01649540290236473, 0.013928390108048916, -0.0266973078250885, -0.020797263830900192, 0.024292388930916786, 0.03979117423295975, -0.006924347020685673, -0.02011500671505928, 0.044402267783880234, 0.004104530904442072, -0.0036911803763359785, 0.014657784253358841, 0.06147972494363785, -0.016595853492617607, -0.030304018408060074, -0.01309108454734087, 0.05948315188288689, 0.019450129941105843, 0.005029059015214443, 0.004113012924790382, -0.06795236468315125, -0.016875142231583595, 0.055256396532058716, 0.001379341701976955, -0.02655813656747341, 0.013294940814375877, 0.06088877096772194, -0.01745648868381977, 0.01468603778630495, -0.0014395267935469747, -0.030436471104621887, 0.03665025904774666, -0.04228771850466728, 0.07686017453670502, 0.019071530550718307, 0.04726487770676613, 0.01664000377058983, -0.016097793355584145, -0.003806646913290024, 0.05210474133491516, 0.09181427210569382, -0.04251593351364136, -0.05126504600048065, -0.004213355481624603, -0.03135515749454498, 0.019323913380503654, 0.004027445800602436, -0.031804487109184265, 0.036937322467565536, -0.0249615665525198, -0.046305980533361435, 0.022809285670518875, -0.010694448836147785, 0.008613629266619682, 0.02569420076906681, 0.018406257033348083, -0.012876288034021854, 0.015535742044448853, -0.010690419003367424, 0.005173093639314175, 0.04413586109876633, 0.025794824585318565, 0.03362655267119408, -0.007751309312880039, 0.030815651640295982, -0.00044170449837110937, 0.012370171956717968, 0.02008150704205036, 0.004838187247514725, 0.06253668665885925, -0.02435622178018093, -0.011795537546277046, -0.0196082666516304, -0.01369299367070198, 0.010068787261843681, 0.030707947909832, -0.03266614302992821, -0.02741691842675209, 0.0016201842809095979, 0.007154036778956652, 0.04577368125319481, 0.009660896845161915, -0.036920640617609024, 0.015593294985592365, -0.040048543363809586, 0.0021677890326827765, 0.060017265379428864, 0.01647103577852249, -0.016672620549798012, -0.019877847284078598, 0.0015380672411993146, -0.007126096170395613, -0.02183312363922596, 0.009260757826268673, 0.014528252184391022, 0.0005284101353026927, -0.007059133145958185, 0.005020527634769678, -0.019141647964715958, -0.012106593698263168, -0.0063559142872691154, 0.04464515671133995, 0.061207570135593414, 0.02002912014722824, -0.030087660998106003, 0.013113891705870628, -0.035520654171705246, -0.048903293907642365, 0.036787379533052444, 0.02221725694835186, -0.04328397661447525, -0.035083286464214325, 0.04854835569858551, -0.011731171049177647, -0.012677949853241444, 0.05739842727780342, -0.036932773888111115, 0.039926402270793915, -0.013199281878769398, -0.06684429198503494, -0.022474786266684532, 0.051091305911540985, 0.0008807303966023028, 0.02130451798439026, -0.060549795627593994, -0.0011669270461425185, 0.03718617558479309, 0.0352090448141098, -0.030015265569090843, 0.03279139846563339, 0.03922118619084358, 0.03276485577225685, 0.003893359797075391, -0.04664335399866104, -0.005693976767361164, -0.045556116849184036, -0.00006525460776174441, -0.05044182017445564, -0.05614023655653, 0.02223956026136875, 0.03451230749487877, 0.009168524295091629, -0.026691455394029617, 0.029208282008767128, -0.015458962880074978, -0.02645796723663807, -0.004703763406723738, 0.005346229765564203, -0.03355871140956879, 0.059843484312295914, 0.02539944089949131, 0.0523393340408802, -0.0100110387429595, -0.003276737406849861, 0.0163747426122427, 0.04406564310193062, 0.03682646155357361, 0.041173942387104034, 0.014183364808559418, -0.001711494754999876, -0.014322374947369099, 0.004142066463828087, 0.01804979518055916, -0.034855641424655914, -0.06630459427833557, -0.030384670943021774, -0.0035296755377203226, -0.007604432292282581, 0.04223109036684036, -0.022208495065569878, -0.041548386216163635, 0.032360296696424484, -0.010775410570204258, -0.06767530739307404, -0.06412087380886078, -0.0007182066328823566, 0.008142059668898582, 0.010840354487299919, 0.013586119748651981, -0.0027775997295975685, 0.002826328156515956, 0.03139389306306839, -0.01634986326098442, -0.018152741715312004, -0.039593879133462906, 0.018192041665315628, -0.04591012001037598, -0.02282009646296501, 0.027952510863542557, 0.03539179638028145, -0.005853363778442144, 0.036450326442718506, -0.0323311947286129, -0.02560979314148426, 0.016110405325889587, -0.02361263707280159, -0.005509847775101662, -0.04685722663998604, -0.027332890778779984, 0.01045313011854887, -0.018880529329180717, -0.009825042448937893, 0.04203653335571289, -0.04148923233151436, 0.08631882071495056, 0.07601425796747208, -0.010234898887574673, 0.008632650598883629, 0.008742369711399078, -0.00964877475053072, 0.019124841317534447, -0.04938405752182007, -0.01395635399967432, -0.03517575189471245, 0.006711920257657766, 0.04735318198800087, 0.02301402948796749, -0.06136489659547806, 0.012640259228646755, 0.0396571084856987, 0.024654367938637733, 0.03231821954250336, 0.01088692620396614, 0.028309756889939308, -0.03390171006321907, -0.0006971915136091411, 0.04254016652703285, -0.02347560226917267, -0.024567648768424988, -0.009377801790833473, -0.006113274022936821, 0.057130806148052216, -0.0030189852695912123, 0.0003075241402257234, 0.03993711248040199, -0.03844707831740379, -0.003918152302503586, -0.00858590193092823, -0.004404978360980749, 0.0386040024459362, -0.010676604695618153, -0.012190094217658043, 0.022744080051779747, -0.01906396821141243, 0.020872702822089195, -0.0333939790725708, -0.01256620418280363, 0.02371087856590748, 0.03422395512461662, -0.026472844183444977, 0.003274565562605858, 0.011487935669720173, -0.04050222784280777, 0.01946084387600422, -0.01838882640004158, 0.007939458824694157, -0.011317788623273373, 0.05426962673664093, 0.06771697103977203, -0.01125557441264391, 0.013954219408333302, -0.05302078649401665, 0.0035890480503439903, -0.00907250214368105, -0.009375340305268764, 0.06678413599729538, 0.02813342958688736, -0.06141583248972893, -0.0014048292068764567, -0.03276720643043518, 0.005216072779148817, 0.010645093396306038, -0.02160705253481865, -0.027708619832992554, 0.00890576746314764, -0.006678715813905001, -0.024650538340210915, -0.019061751663684845, -0.023724926635622978, 0.05681702122092247, -0.039056889712810516, -0.03595031052827835, 0.05031753331422806, -0.003722887020558119, -0.006769084371626377, 0.011382813565433025, 0.007424043957144022, -0.014085480943322182, -0.009394808672368526, -0.003266371786594391, -0.00482974061742425, -0.015160104259848595, -0.025412268936634064, 0.05323163419961929, -0.01291480753570795, -0.02890666387975216, -0.06459859758615494, -0.07759780436754227, 0.050176650285720825, -0.010703077539801598, 0.009538392536342144, 0.004259076900780201, -0.005220598075538874, 0.06583284586668015, 0.033354464918375015, -0.01663419045507908, -0.06942836195230484, 0.015350212343037128, -0.056473731994628906, -0.0454089492559433, -0.0014813352609053254, -0.012379930354654789, 0.009279787540435791, 0.041564248502254486, 0.005869980435818434, 0.017969399690628052, 0.0620303601026535, -0.017550364136695862, -0.040045712143182755, 0.051261045038700104, 0.0025509586557745934, -0.010426703840494156, 0.003953137900680304, 0.02976108156144619, -0.024499716237187386, 0.003138005966320634, 0.018867406994104385, 0.013409240171313286, -0.013660725206136703, -0.039753783494234085, 0.02130311354994774, -0.046862248331308365, 0.02443595603108406, -0.021285895258188248, 0.012077193707227707, -0.0009629235137254, -0.01737907901406288, -0.016512678936123848, 0.024060070514678955, 0.034521400928497314, -0.033384665846824646, 0.024889934808015823, 0.014591952785849571, 0.01672142930328846, 0.03143860399723053, -0.02600150741636753, -0.016440369188785553, -0.0355023555457592, 0.02104797214269638, 0.022350003942847252, -0.0033335238695144653, 0.05211696773767471, 0.041937436908483505, 0.03523043915629387, 0.0481039322912693, -0.0027235625311732292, 0.04480993002653122, -0.0590694360435009, 0.010638468898832798, -0.028851768001914024, 0.03786174952983856, 0.03340747579932213, 0.032801177352666855, 0.028850432485342026, -0.011142020113766193, -0.017159195616841316, 0.011983341537415981, -0.07546006143093109, -0.012300139293074608, 0.005651445593684912, -0.0193141121417284, -0.0029749281238764524, -0.029927963390946388, 0.040318265557289124, -0.004606998059898615, 0.02324921451508999, 0.005897089838981628, 0.027576377615332603, -0.0683838278055191, 0.006327745970338583, 0.029288116842508316, 0.0456082709133625, -0.05031009763479233, 0.01481951680034399, 0.03795010969042778, -0.04171397536993027, 0.034545205533504486, 0.03176048398017883, -0.02922723814845085, -0.009720575995743275, -0.04454109072685242, 0.00901081133633852, 0.024112507700920105, 0.031362589448690414, 0.011005021631717682, 0.028649112209677696, -0.04187050834298134, 0.003999986685812473, 0.002690825378522277, 0.05092710256576538, 0.02391720749437809, -0.012073648162186146, -0.018619738519191742, -0.04853689670562744, -0.010793652385473251, 0.0005435778293758631, 0.037158574908971786, -0.017698397859930992, -0.01506531611084938, 0.014366643503308296, 0.028985148295760155, -0.05005045607686043, 0.007687760982662439, 0.030555905774235725, 0.010475737042725086, 0.008825612254440784, -0.02373245730996132, -0.008886950090527534, -0.03168521448969841, -0.009412301704287529, 0.037076376378536224, -0.012856953777372837, -0.0201293732970953, -0.021449297666549683, 0.04463929310441017, -0.0312638022005558, -0.023566044867038727, 0.010292910039424896, -0.0038469356950372458, 0.009343182668089867, 0.012652908451855183, 0.03758688643574715, 0.002542674308642745, 0.030703861266374588, 0.05250637233257294, 0.0070003024302423, 0.009225738234817982, -0.06834126263856888, -0.0050318269059062, 0.038417402654886246, 0.05319644883275032, -0.007361573167145252, -0.009828516282141209, -0.059342462569475174, -0.014861082658171654, 0.000876301433891058, -0.044268619269132614, 0.032525110989809036, -0.005079761613160372, 0.024190392345190048, -0.035231854766607285, -0.016672231256961823, -0.033327385783195496, -0.016035042703151703, -0.016186412423849106, 0.05428123474121094, -0.007654294371604919, -0.03304605558514595, -0.02322644181549549, 0.0027898207772523165, -0.004682821221649647, 0.046346694231033325, -0.002439569914713502, -0.024881303310394287, -0.009467704221606255, 0.00986892357468605, -0.03394974395632744, -0.08796645700931549, 0.01915043033659458, 0.02468058280646801, 0.008210144005715847, 0.05318383127450943, -0.02749292552471161, -0.031391117721796036, 0.028831174597144127, 0.00037921854527667165, -0.01238714437931776, -0.029298387467861176, -0.02707056514918804, 0.0439051128923893, 0.03599826991558075, -0.03982717916369438, 0.05151863768696785, -0.023620691150426865, -0.0020786705426871777, -0.003922789357602596, -0.029419323429465294, 0.04966593533754349, -0.038287609815597534, -0.029027046635746956, -0.05234934017062187, 0.0038402159698307514, -0.021116217598319054, 0.05265567824244499, 0.011920265853404999, 0.030850090086460114, -0.020280465483665466, -0.003803461790084839, 0.002124729799106717, 0.011594442650675774, -0.00003006924998771865, 0.041888076812028885, -0.024722842499613762, 0.052484143525362015, -0.004210035782307386, 0.01836368814110756, 0.025839626789093018, 0.006151857785880566, -0.024802112951874733, 0.048166148364543915, -0.02200387604534626, -0.023526746779680252, -0.02814379334449768, -0.01789103075861931, -0.020657137036323547, -0.02732222154736519, 0.04286932200193405, -0.005870155990123749, 0.0163564495742321, 0.011903746984899044, -0.03598426282405853, -0.0024386479053646326, -0.018194202333688736, -0.0000839379572425969, 0.052585143595933914, -0.029802748933434486, 0.028887001797556877, -0.01376865804195404, 0.008149511180818081, -0.056483447551727295, -0.049218643456697464, -0.002266931114718318, 0.03161013126373291, -0.015491878613829613, -0.006442646030336618, -0.014524541795253754, 0.011698250658810139, -0.02649955078959465, -0.01779324561357498, 0.04329610988497734, -0.023560333997011185, 0.005088494159281254, 0.028589768335223198, -0.011468283832073212, 0.05174648389220238, -0.04427460953593254, 0.013169803656637669, 0.0007077261689119041, -0.01759566180408001, -0.01216094195842743, 0.00043184662354178727, 0.017129171639680862, -0.04514447599649429, -0.0004535609914455563, -0.0371493324637413, 0.015142412856221199, 0.06249118596315384, -0.009962642565369606, 0.014219935052096844, 0.015788547694683075, -0.001476725097745657, -0.006785733159631491, 0.0006948203663341701, -0.016778074204921722, -0.02245423011481762, -0.00483860494568944, -0.010554413311183453, -0.013476588763296604, -0.008692298084497452, -0.01367331575602293, 0.015817740932106972, 0.02568094991147518, -0.01642250083386898, 0.017106229439377785, 0.05310001224279404, -0.02967471443116665, 0.036290790885686874, -0.02096913568675518, -0.044109173119068146, 0.04165931046009064, 0.006985930725932121, 0.023333748802542686, 0.01244279183447361, 0.02826484479010105, -0.06250188499689102, -0.01946006901562214, -0.045855652540922165, 0.02422148920595646, 0.056722141802310944, 0.025201871991157532, 0.04283842444419861, 0.003052176209166646, -0.004433872643858194, 0.0361805260181427, -0.028732938691973686, -0.014793244190514088, 0.011737031862139702, -0.0012463676976040006, 0.05852344259619713, 0.001515395357273519, -0.021397726610302925, 0.03939834237098694, 0.013252309523522854, 0.0326337032020092, 0.04671050235629082, 0.007661737501621246, 0.014019890688359737, 0.00888955406844616, -0.03719492256641388, -0.05167550966143608, 0.0056946901604533195, -0.0311907771974802, 0.002697262680158019, -0.014934292994439602, -0.005015778820961714, 0.058380257338285446, 0.026962069794535637, 0.016343899071216583, -0.03399784117937088, -0.01967940293252468, -0.06177280470728874, -0.010089240036904812, 0.014227895066142082, 0.022028885781764984, 0.012875913642346859, -0.035379212349653244, 0.009687801823019981, 0.01530679501593113, 0.02068239636719227, 0.0011432442115619779, -0.054903868585824966, -0.05443280190229416, 0.007601950783282518, -0.018835052847862244, 0.02361084148287773, -0.0065424176864326, -0.035260140895843506, 0.03823980316519737, -0.02616012468934059, 0.058170136064291, -0.0013693703804165125, 0.03673778846859932, 0.01637287065386772, 0.03242146968841553, 0.020002074539661407, 0.04260052740573883, 0.004061791114509106, -0.037749532610177994, 0.12995858490467072, 0.09427614510059357, 0.04566826671361923, -0.04116649180650711, 0.01453296560794115, 0.02275151014328003, -0.01717112399637699, -0.0445435494184494, 0.06154472380876541, 0.03358374163508415, -0.023382918909192085, 0.014530925080180168, 0.060087140649557114, 0.0043726577423512936, -0.030660472810268402, 0.034552596509456635, -0.03992851823568344, -0.007210868876427412, 0.04895733296871185, -0.001874161884188652, -0.0018847479950636625, -0.051427435129880905, -0.0153956925496459, 0.03739915415644646, -0.023150663822889328, -0.02197123132646084, -0.024722877889871597, -0.003917990252375603, 0.013451254926621914, -0.030081529170274734, -0.011770691722631454, -0.010502037592232227, 0.005976453423500061, 0.0007899904157966375, -0.0168475229293108, 0.011594697833061218, -0.0013627286534756422, -0.007309919223189354, -0.016376500949263573, 0.03995430842041969, -0.0026867003180086613, -0.006586966570466757, 0.0072471038438379765, -0.01083146221935749, -0.03830490633845329, -0.05000819265842438, -0.05448399484157562, 0.04929018020629883, -0.011588530614972115, 0.01776481606066227, -0.012463764287531376, 0.00047067395644262433, -0.03791159763932228, -0.06440931558609009, -0.030319934710860252, 0.02847237139940262, 0.008852574042975903, 0.010083193890750408, -0.03746356815099716, -0.0388692244887352, 0.017946476116776466, 0.003996069077402353, 0.02725374884903431, 0.011207683943212032, -0.00019900246115867049, -0.014566253870725632, -0.013680903241038322, 0.0504169687628746, 0.03627282753586769, 0.004395229741930962, 0.0036586830392479897, -0.0268243420869112, 0.018779775127768517, -0.04435213655233383, -0.00451207859441638, -0.008204561658203602, 0.030041467398405075, 0.01496696937829256, -0.04187546297907829, -0.0047906311228871346, -0.05346023663878441, 0.007740887347608805, -0.03968837484717369, 0.02157747745513916, -0.05035766214132309, 0.01398448459804058, 0.019650937989354134, 0.04550005495548248, 0.029280904680490494, 0.041074082255363464, 0.0006496619898825884, 0.05147254839539528, -0.014345100149512291, -0.03440896421670914, -0.024098100140690804, 0.004841864109039307, -0.0434437058866024, 0.02814546786248684, 0.03109794482588768, 0.05365942791104317, 0.05232056975364685, 0.006763331592082977, 0.024207714945077896, 0.055869318544864655, -0.027056578546762466, 0.0010597420623525977, 0.01055738516151905, -0.03595464304089546, 0.033542338758707047, -0.017224356532096863, -0.006711726076900959, -0.03973887860774994, -0.016137048602104187, -0.03306649252772331, -0.019169406965374947, 0.019839050248265266, 0.021901439875364304, -0.010899228975176811, -0.010881340131163597, -0.013953855261206627, 0.02902643196284771, -0.017654461786150932, 0.0007421796908602118, -0.027549011632800102, 0.0041326736100018024, -0.03024590201675892, -0.02036648988723755, -0.009011383168399334, 0.008926299400627613, 0.00875092949718237, -0.0048172189854085445, 0.05182808265089989, 0.00899781659245491, 0.00226931506767869, -0.005633804481476545, -0.0052484311163425446, 0.030925177037715912, 0.054725006222724915, -0.03045537881553173, -0.006888225674629211, 0.04261812940239906, -0.07081202417612076, -0.025814877822995186, 0.05077540874481201, -0.00827345997095108, 0.02973279356956482, 0.03637209162116051, 0.01929537206888199, -0.041095416992902756, 0.046286892145872116, 0.0012042815797030926, -0.032234031707048416, 0.01497570052742958, -0.009694000706076622, -0.02929357998073101, 0.02281922847032547, 0.0013767271302640438, 0.011358369141817093, 0.009481672197580338, 0.03376341983675957, 0.014525136910378933, 0.03151405602693558, -0.03911258652806282, 0.02816218137741089, -0.0296916663646698, 0.014472794719040394, 0.016342315822839737, -0.002338685095310211, 0.05539349839091301, 0.009966275654733181, -0.021743854507803917, 0.018811022862792015, -0.007737241685390472, 0.004792133346199989, -0.11958039551973343, 0.011423851363360882, -0.006663737818598747, 0.03212696313858032, 0.01198746170848608, -0.0961269736289978, 0.03475838154554367, 0.036039598286151886, -0.05968192592263222, 0.03318512812256813, -0.008814850822091103, 0.02443951554596424, -0.026002483442425728, 0.01310409139841795, -0.037636879831552505, 0.013070096261799335, 0.029092198237776756, 0.02781854197382927, 0.0537935271859169, 0.04430686682462692, -0.013026964850723743, -0.015716684982180595, -0.04317931458353996, 0.04053477570414543, -0.03345739096403122, -0.05947704613208771, 0.048890311270952225, -0.018485739827156067, -0.056761790066957474, 0.0028350367210805416, -0.0273125097155571, 0.0038952999748289585, 0.02976580709218979, 0.028486283496022224, 0.0007307365303859115, -0.006466205231845379, 0.06306346505880356, -0.027798885479569435, 0.034295547753572464, -0.005791355390101671, -0.0015683210222050548, 0.016867507249116898, 0.01237881276756525, 0.04008607193827629, 0.036493804305791855, -0.030046993866562843, -0.010782044380903244, -0.028392763808369637, -0.008845771662890911, -0.028422389179468155, -0.01559517066925764, -0.008186993189156055, 0.006537767127156258, -0.04986307770013809, -0.0058366707526147366, -0.030125407502055168, -0.02891981601715088, 0.03486248850822449, 0.012899555265903473, 0.0013146423734724522, 0.018978560343384743, 0.0006736499490216374, -0.053357500582933426, -0.027103766798973083, 0.00736661022529006, 0.00650806026533246, -0.07119420170783997, 0.014466222375631332, 0.02472168579697609, -0.02561483532190323, -0.004635966382920742, -0.031375374644994736, -0.0351547971367836, 0.032918620854616165, 0.003389282850548625, 0.030146701261401176, 0.01750531606376171, -0.033904023468494415, -0.0013662861892953515, -0.09041771292686462, 0.03720993548631668, -0.000724511279258877, -0.0607583113014698, -0.024578163400292397, 0.004296193830668926, -0.01676475629210472, 0.006433320231735706, 0.03993571177124977, 0.020032718777656555, -0.018449122086167336, -0.006913032382726669, 0.01952945441007614, 0.008936632424592972, -0.06942369043827057, 0.03262617439031601, -0.05009939521551132, -0.004021862987428904, -0.0036485714372247458, -0.05070551112294197, 0.0071406252682209015, 0.04696999117732048, 0.021425776183605194, 0.00880279578268528, 0.0024664015509188175, 0.0001479102356825024, 0.004669496323913336, 0.036843568086624146, -0.020396677777171135, 0.008654780685901642, 0.05738414451479912, 0.038247402757406235, 0.0315367728471756, 0.03352588042616844, -0.009573785588145256, -0.04014981910586357, -0.011251645162701607, -0.03032773919403553, -0.01827649213373661, 0.016683457419276237, 0.008021483197808266, 0.02826632931828499, -0.046275027096271515, -0.013078595511615276, 0.03183124214410782, -0.03529328480362892, -0.02004099264740944, 0.04019322246313095, 0.015458735637366772, 0.018021173775196075, 0.023525573313236237, 0.05033576115965843, 0.014955219812691212, -0.011869991198182106, 0.015483848750591278, 0.017028670758008957, 0.012266361154615879, -0.02172493003308773, 0.04026727005839348, -0.00014426592679228634, -0.009019311517477036, -0.014489410445094109, -0.009325521998107433, 0.07262841612100601, -0.027449339628219604, -0.018894106149673462, -0.00591626251116395, -0.03255428001284599, 0.012019454501569271, -0.03652765229344368, -0.007758578285574913, 0.082046277821064, -0.02320764772593975, 0.017808066681027412, -0.03632216155529022, -0.037239089608192444, 0.0018952927784994245, 0.010859455913305283, -0.0017707159277051687, 0.048047054558992386, -0.008965511806309223, 0.016003569588065147, 0.017118623480200768, -0.013216560706496239, 0.037947412580251694, -0.015149752609431744, 0.010377654805779457, 0.006013441830873489, -0.012636122293770313, -0.015735918655991554, -0.012435232289135456, 0.018982483074069023, -0.0036110305227339268, 0.019730890169739723, 0.030985908582806587, 0.018047992140054703, -0.016293436288833618, -0.055726710706949234, 0.021535521373152733, 0.03209861367940903, -0.08572375029325485, 0.0028097780887037516, -0.04932498559355736, -0.004717950243502855, 0.014218645170331001, -0.017767656594514847 ]
<p>I hope this is the right forum to ask this question.</p> <p>Sequential filtering frameworks perform 2-steps essentially:</p> <p>Process model (forecast) : $x_{t+1} = f_t(x_t) + v_t$</p> <p>Observation model (update): $z_t = h_t(x_t) + w_t$</p> <p>Here, $v_t, w_t$ are uncorrelated zero-mean noise processes, and $f_t, h_t$ are functions (may be linear or non-linear).</p> <p>For the particular case of Kalman filters, $f_t, h_t$ are <em>linear</em> and the noise processes are <em>Gaussian</em>.</p> <p>In my application, the user <em>learns</em> the observation model using historical data (linear regression, for example). Since that is the case, the user might as well learn an <em>inverse observation model</em>, such that $$x_t = g_t(z_t) + \eta_t$$</p> <p>Here, the underlying state vector is expressed as a function of observations $z_t$. Assume that $\eta_t$ is Gaussian.</p> <p>With the inverse observation model, the update step is simplified. Apply $g_t$ to $z_t$ and then simply <em>assimilate</em> the resulting vector (call it $\hat{x}_t$) to $x_t$. The assimilation here is a weighted addition of two Gaussian distributed variables where the weights are in inverse proportion of their covariance matrices (for Kalman optimal solution).</p> <p>So my question is: is there anything wrong with this approach of using an inverse observation model instead of an observation model? The advantage is that I can define the weighted addition as an operator in my data structure.</p>
73,553
[ -0.006163391284644604, -0.02126690000295639, 0.00012890865036752075, -0.003482625586912036, 0.02741316519677639, 0.005954364780336618, -0.000058229092246619985, -0.025304345414042473, 0.046763595193624496, 0.004777661059051752, 0.009957759641110897, 0.011202256195247173, 0.06950708478689194, -0.007775433361530304, 0.005928087048232555, 0.004950784146785736, -0.0392303541302681, -0.02365441806614399, -0.03216829150915146, 0.012215586379170418, -0.008788523264229298, 0.0705169066786766, -0.003617445472627878, -0.00009426221367903054, -0.04601014405488968, 0.021539265289902687, 0.014468370005488396, -0.005901589524000883, 0.003224102081730962, 0.053318705409765244, -0.01280248910188675, -0.010364985093474388, -0.005661600269377232, 0.053762033581733704, 0.022604020312428474, 0.005106496158987284, -0.04429659619927406, -0.04780358076095581, -0.016270512714982033, 0.02406824193894863, -0.023248078301548958, -0.01501530408859253, -0.01362181268632412, -0.0030851128976792097, 0.019436750560998917, 0.0226962398737669, -0.03826436400413513, 0.006555375177413225, 0.032145410776138306, -0.014664243906736374, 0.05537516251206398, 0.008497552014887333, 0.027075471356511116, 0.02460552379488945, 0.0015484857140108943, -0.028024813160300255, 0.05940134450793266, 0.07156962901353836, -0.00044932193122804165, -0.0018649185076355934, 0.013050395995378494, -0.03683055192232132, -0.006078664213418961, 0.00011181674926774576, -0.020848117768764496, 0.022076191380620003, 0.005132876802235842, -0.014522998593747616, 0.0004007132083643228, -0.04053206369280815, 0.004045877140015364, -0.017660461366176605, -0.0073914737440645695, -0.015035713091492653, 0.020383330062031746, -0.059976641088724136, 0.002581146312877536, 0.03559830039739609, 0.0443544015288353, 0.010088205337524414, 0.007729690987616777, -0.02803497575223446, 0.0018800453981384635, 0.044238511472940445, -0.0002787344274111092, -0.0033813277259469032, 0.0728595033288002, -0.04785425215959549, 0.027707403525710106, 0.026222923770546913, -0.025842178612947464, 0.021259844303131104, 0.033532511442899704, -0.020529473200440407, -0.03017314337193966, 0.04403247684240341, -0.023516027256846428, 0.03902393952012062, 0.010403567925095558, -0.014154049567878246, -0.015834156423807144, -0.06147719919681549, 0.0011195401893928647, 0.04447740688920021, -0.03406738117337227, -0.02392973005771637, -0.006871252320706844, -0.0017911185277625918, -0.032447438687086105, -0.047913070768117905, -0.041980501264333725, -0.007991521619260311, -0.024527737870812416, -0.00738939456641674, 0.028799431398510933, -0.006451947148889303, 0.006590685807168484, -0.022546103224158287, 0.025828218087553978, 0.09557193517684937, 0.08626210689544678, -0.005552767310291529, 0.015154191292822361, -0.02753273956477642, -0.038275010883808136, 0.01951286569237709, 0.01099195796996355, -0.050398144870996475, -0.08057998865842819, 0.040873266756534576, 0.0025544522795826197, -0.04795738682150841, 0.03960759937763214, 0.007071676664054394, 0.0000845232789288275, -0.01682286337018013, -0.07063499838113785, -0.027988238260149956, 0.03421672061085701, -0.026237282902002335, 0.028542881831526756, -0.10376232862472534, 0.009951282292604446, 0.04411512613296509, 0.056161098182201385, 0.04673447832465172, 0.029119936749339104, 0.025908801704645157, 0.03372858464717865, 0.0007740744622424245, -0.04815789684653282, -0.0076990388333797455, -0.017407363280653954, -0.03312253952026367, -0.006423290353268385, -0.05189128220081329, 0.036103181540966034, 0.011196013540029526, -0.030117861926555634, -0.00008840996451908723, 0.06905784457921982, 0.017342746257781982, -0.028843704611063004, 0.004496801644563675, 0.025021109730005264, -0.04569781571626663, 0.03622766584157944, 0.0076609724201262, 0.07212436199188232, 0.01498313620686531, 0.03876348212361336, -0.014583303593099117, -0.004221116192638874, 0.02177409455180168, 0.06189677491784096, -0.04622187837958336, -0.009637312963604927, -0.02420908585190773, -0.00605836370959878, -0.014503218233585358, -0.014979878440499306, -0.024634813889861107, 0.007229477167129517, -0.0038104113191366196, 0.026490960270166397, 0.02460240013897419, 0.009714119136333466, -0.00174681656062603, 0.026885975152254105, -0.060324929654598236, -0.0022632379550486803, -0.046063803136348724, 0.00007379196176771075, 0.0022980014327913523, 0.017719358205795288, 0.059252940118312836, -0.021138371899724007, 0.020501304417848587, 0.016452113166451454, -0.01200122945010662, 0.0027690655551850796, -0.03631405159831047, 0.035628437995910645, -0.034380458295345306, 0.005122594069689512, 0.04399385303258896, 0.04565929248929024, -0.007505708374083042, 0.040616702288389206, -0.023310363292694092, -0.0346277616918087, -0.023934949189424515, -0.016714032739400864, 0.021016800776124, -0.0021180068142712116, -0.009203480556607246, 0.026020873337984085, -0.028254393488168716, -0.019610831514000893, -0.005239612422883511, -0.06272026896476746, 0.0343572273850441, 0.11882707476615906, -0.01783488504588604, 0.019972311332821846, 0.04665258899331093, 0.015285605564713478, 0.04322965443134308, -0.011233949102461338, -0.030521443113684654, -0.0628349557518959, 0.0060091824270784855, 0.027111230418086052, 0.04612281173467636, -0.04664694517850876, 0.047469351440668106, 0.020596059039235115, 0.045990388840436935, 0.01635958068072796, 0.01980500854551792, 0.0019388102227821946, 0.00886550359427929, 0.06319928914308548, -0.012628152035176754, 0.047878656536340714, -0.006264976225793362, -0.019356416538357735, 0.0046814135275781155, 0.018689142540097237, 0.011216665618121624, -0.0003976345469709486, 0.023035896942019463, -0.014180993661284447, 0.020213115960359573, -0.010199069045484066, -0.021206066012382507, -0.003531517693772912, -0.03998237103223801, 0.023325884714722633, 0.03837853670120239, -0.027820127084851265, -0.01764342188835144, -0.006551964674144983, 0.02628789097070694, -0.030830539762973785, 0.009227313101291656, -0.01634407974779606, -0.0045774332247674465, 0.030151674523949623, -0.025913415476679802, -0.006214677821844816, -0.01733684353530407, -0.019226498901844025, -0.04198649525642395, -0.005093079060316086, 0.012031272053718567, 0.010076051577925682, -0.004975761286914349, -0.02638026885688305, -0.029012342914938927, -0.02151831053197384, 0.008935810066759586, 0.03172186762094498, 0.05643583834171295, -0.01611606404185295, 0.02062159590423107, 0.008843496441841125, -0.010649002157151699, 0.034959059208631516, -0.0024530161172151566, 0.03097035363316536, -0.0401516854763031, -0.03660545498132706, -0.054566700011491776, -0.022896617650985718, -0.048246484249830246, 0.005225932225584984, 0.024080127477645874, -0.060667358338832855, 0.07313847541809082, 0.019929377362132072, -0.027310151606798172, 0.03423735499382019, -0.038779523223638535, -0.022974159568548203, -0.03962310031056404, -0.012393645942211151, -0.01181310135871172, -0.006279537919908762, 0.04759890213608742, 0.05278429761528969, -0.0365627184510231, 0.02963753417134285, -0.09734935313463211, -0.03382110595703125, 0.05404987186193466, 0.03355245292186737, 0.029956845566630363, 0.04404274374246597, -0.001836996409110725, 0.05788606032729149, 0.039128731936216354, -0.016507025808095932, -0.015782149508595467, -0.017447760328650475, 0.0014308665413409472, -0.048646505922079086, 0.011071220971643925, -0.024541523307561874, -0.044529009610414505, 0.012555200606584549, -0.011089523322880268, -0.0007862927741371095, 0.019349629059433937, 0.01258881576359272, -0.0005504136788658798, -0.002238369779661298, -0.002183169825002551, 0.03948487341403961, 0.05114547908306122, 0.00926769059151411, 0.028514781966805458, 0.000585941772442311, 0.00017289217794314027, -0.02203575149178505, 0.032242488116025925, -0.03637943044304848, 0.007246178109198809, -0.014978625811636448, -0.030322296544909477, -0.050608161836862564, 0.03595811128616333, 0.015544302761554718, 0.007545818109065294, -0.050741858780384064, 0.024052584543824196, 0.019216109067201614, -0.03720409795641899, 0.024673722684383392, 0.03140212595462799, 0.036342792212963104, 0.011694265529513359, 0.006678297650068998, 0.019223608076572418, -0.027943821623921394, 0.012502332217991352, -0.02996039390563965, -0.001246448140591383, 0.030139271169900894, 0.029812052845954895, -0.0037936714943498373, -0.005651385057717562, -0.028876766562461853, -0.0026139633264392614, -0.08382444083690643, 0.013851295225322247, 0.007360209710896015, 0.06532071530818939, -0.02040594443678856, 0.030600519850850105, 0.029913973063230515, 0.00007266554166562855, 0.014702308923006058, -0.003931304439902306, -0.06904540210962296, 0.04391232877969742, 0.027973510324954987, -0.013747131451964378, 0.005994307808578014, -0.008066652342677116, 0.028392614796757698, -0.02689819596707821, 0.0063073523342609406, -0.0015590200200676918, 0.015072058886289597, -0.05427789315581322, -0.004876932594925165, -0.034832339733839035, -0.010272222571074963, -0.003992858342826366, 0.0007320652366615832, 0.04548156261444092, -0.059566933661699295, 0.03963765874505043, 0.03843884542584419, -0.0043265013955533504, 0.010730277746915817, -0.03933216631412506, 0.037218376994132996, 0.030208567157387733, 0.0380433052778244, 0.014185602776706219, 0.012925561517477036, -0.02886262908577919, 0.0883651152253151, 0.0015742338728159666, 0.013334973715245724, 0.011954091489315033, -0.014264416880905628, -0.013785257004201412, -0.04769594594836235, -0.055566832423210144, 0.04980543628334999, 0.009826570749282837, 0.024255000054836273, 0.0023452998138964176, 0.04022170603275299, 0.0015421262942254543, -0.00015640439232811332, 0.010477873496711254, 0.05857476964592934, -0.0016830164240673184, 0.010308493860065937, -0.004759492818266153, 0.030138647183775902, 0.0012033057864755392, -0.019134314730763435, 0.0754452794790268, 0.0007221805863082409, -0.011145652271807194, 0.0035882529336959124, -0.005097446963191032, -0.010651903226971626, -0.00381225417368114, 0.010848334059119225, 0.029789619147777557, 0.05864778533577919, 0.026991035789251328, -0.025222525000572205, -0.0013704354641959071, 0.062423285096883774, 0.06035708263516426, 0.04532342404127121, 0.017792321741580963, -0.11388891190290451, 0.0063242074102163315, 0.01076708547770977, 0.016648069024086, -0.0010326538467779756, 0.00012961201719008386, -0.03202458471059799, -0.05654970183968544, 0.034504614770412445, -0.01646057516336441, 0.03449675813317299, -0.0493733175098896, -0.009410184808075428, -0.019413821399211884, -0.04814000800251961, 0.011402972042560577, 0.020409291610121727, -0.012860466726124287, 0.036155182868242264, 0.006061979103833437, -0.021794399246573448, -0.017185162752866745, 0.006091790273785591, 0.019857589155435562, 0.04365188255906105, -0.0045832302421331406, -0.044344138354063034, 0.01138413604348898, 0.03196917474269867, -0.057649850845336914, -0.025291500613093376, 0.0009814496152102947, -0.0011208998039364815, 0.009163879789412022, 0.011484012939035892, -0.02800547145307064, -0.01435154303908348, 0.025392068549990654, 0.014426583424210548, -0.00805772002786398, -0.04565763846039772, -0.004901455249637365, 0.03370695188641548, 0.019751369953155518, 0.006802061107009649, 0.042302750051021576, 0.032085321843624115, -0.027914920821785927, 0.02772234007716179, -0.005017103161662817, -0.012401043437421322, -0.04689596965909004, -0.014437512494623661, -0.030930139124393463, -0.00021856609964743257, -0.025830235332250595, 0.045897968113422394, 0.012893245555460453, 0.05855606496334076, -0.02453748695552349, -0.011949647217988968, 0.028835821896791458, 0.05431446060538292, -0.040344104170799255, -0.018569283187389374, -0.01525123231112957, 0.045977506786584854, -0.012664568610489368, -0.02587134577333927, 0.013384269550442696, -0.012212810106575489, -0.00379327405244112, -0.011232061311602592, -0.03808802366256714, 0.03276985138654709, -0.027770543470978737, 0.003483286127448082, 0.024957528337836266, -0.032072558999061584, 0.014148477464914322, -0.023023907095193863, 0.027438025921583176, 0.027548661455512047, -0.060640472918748856, 0.03935853764414787, 0.0039718193002045155, -0.011068257503211498, -0.008261589333415031, -0.033044472336769104, 0.023563018068671227, 0.005036427639424801, 0.01107530202716589, -0.049654606729745865, -0.043389126658439636, 0.02794426493346691, -0.045663949102163315, -0.026112083345651627, -0.032385848462581635, 0.06140834465622902, -0.050371382385492325, -0.031174436211586, -0.044469963759183884, 0.02320551685988903, -0.02463896945118904, -0.011850591748952866, 0.031678758561611176, 0.05102378875017166, 0.07174566388130188, 0.023065930232405663, 0.030926629900932312, 0.04352349787950516, -0.02155286632478237, -0.017796294763684273, -0.00545685226097703, 0.005365503951907158, -0.012863443233072758, 0.01809033192694187, -0.028771689161658287, -0.01647084206342697, 0.030158815905451775, -0.021266182884573936, 0.0020911949686706066, 0.052746959030628204, 0.004109841771423817, -0.025045473128557205, -0.04847361147403717, -0.021945035085082054, -0.05518786609172821, -0.00017510144971311092, -0.005015905015170574, 0.002641984960064292, 0.031117601320147514, 0.004541365429759026, 0.04116624966263771, -0.006687616929411888, -0.025927867740392685, -0.009936460293829441, 0.05466198921203613, -0.021127549931406975, 0.01834189146757126, 0.022895140573382378, -0.02269676886498928, 0.060302674770355225, 0.021803811192512512, -0.01611245609819889, 0.03249933198094368, 0.014084224589169025, -0.05043170228600502, -0.009737156331539154, -0.030759252607822418, -0.017149334773421288, 0.09729296714067459, -0.04296134412288666, 0.05262354388833046, -0.007972846738994122, 0.0434534028172493, -0.020446112379431725, -0.02574201673269272, -0.0005601156735792756, -0.017087096348404884, -0.013528916984796524, 0.03743567317724228, 0.005617369897663593, -0.015628736466169357, 0.003730206750333309, 0.02348259836435318, 0.03638838231563568, -0.0015858063707128167, 0.0007332120439969003, 0.04044764116406441, -0.012192334048449993, -0.023928014561533928, -0.042867522686719894, 0.016296321526169777, -0.05701100081205368, -0.0196845680475235, -0.017756853252649307, -0.04620245099067688, 0.03672483563423157, 0.020225565880537033, 0.00595432473346591, -0.03769445791840553, -0.031011667102575302, -0.048164062201976776, -0.0051909275352954865, -0.011261903680860996, -0.020326033234596252, 0.02353685162961483, -0.010450772009789944, 0.04857373610138893, 0.0035954248160123825, 0.031107380986213684, -0.03504263982176781, -0.12390372902154922, -0.02532433345913887, -0.011866968125104904, -0.028102107346057892, 0.018251927569508553, 0.00552500830963254, -0.02406720072031021, 0.0037294013891369104, -0.0015389008913189173, 0.02415076456964016, 0.015551991760730743, 0.030611926689743996, -0.024053120985627174, 0.0760846957564354, -0.011169642210006714, -0.0038560687098652124, -0.03693484514951706, 0.009438619948923588, 0.11681035161018372, 0.03767288103699684, 0.04851911962032318, -0.018240107223391533, -0.00463618291541934, -0.012599697336554527, -0.012915397062897682, -0.0007233689539134502, 0.04914438724517822, 0.029213687404990196, -0.0010441022459417582, -0.018956903368234634, 0.026108620688319206, 0.0009720356320030987, -0.00934514869004488, 0.033332459628582, -0.0672331154346466, 0.00030171178514137864, 0.008351627737283707, 0.005427334923297167, -0.0013637392548844218, 0.014925271272659302, -0.030145902186632156, 0.015153084881603718, -0.03278828784823418, 0.0007816988509148359, 0.016195036470890045, -0.0031464456114917994, -0.03002895414829254, -0.018961653113365173, -0.020860809832811356, 0.03388470411300659, -0.004462122917175293, -0.018319085240364075, -0.013594862073659897, 0.016407744958996773, -0.03906264901161194, 0.00801630225032568, 0.02177419885993004, 0.009813579730689526, 0.03476448729634285, 0.005589239299297333, 0.02216438390314579, -0.0032503355760127306, -0.028295235708355904, 0.0015109952073544264, -0.03467446565628052, 0.0457269549369812, -0.020447898656129837, 0.0063342866487801075, -0.010977745056152344, -0.0032511402387171984, 0.0074424706399440765, -0.07841438800096512, 0.009104687720537186, 0.014525266364216805, 0.03634513542056084, 0.010808045044541359, -0.010992349125444889, -0.029354481026530266, 0.037446197122335434, -0.0018026171019300818, 0.012190572917461395, 0.028763459995388985, -0.05796897038817406, -0.009248770773410797, 0.014552198350429535, 0.042585767805576324, 0.016827812418341637, -0.004138140939176083, 0.015892870724201202, -0.020671915262937546, -0.023636728525161743, -0.024672605097293854, 0.01939188316464424, -0.02074742689728737, 0.04947749152779579, -0.024968622252345085, 0.013479401357471943, -0.029176432639360428, -0.06975149363279343, 0.008965321816504002, 0.022290078923106194, -0.000809736258815974, -0.012171993032097816, -0.00810186006128788, -0.00240313820540905, 0.02027217298746109, -0.017766114324331284, 0.021113606169819832, 0.018303867429494858, 0.02524350769817829, -0.008486345410346985, -0.0412580780684948, -0.03261009231209755, 0.012464184314012527, -0.00609362218528986, 0.016924472525715828, -0.0034897432196885347, 0.08130664378404617, 0.021954432129859924, 0.06584007292985916, -0.04239038750529289, 0.050612177699804306, 0.0021494959946721792, 0.020152322947978973, -0.006562475115060806, -0.03217409551143646, 0.023225365206599236, -0.019780198112130165, 0.039951056241989136, -0.04281993210315704, -0.006888020783662796, -0.037882644683122635, 0.012951911427080631, -0.028912147507071495, -0.022355329245328903, -0.031290680170059204, 0.031136110424995422, -0.031584154814481735, 0.03237474709749222, -0.00753855612128973, 0.02886759117245674, -0.0181425828486681, -0.0014056058134883642, -0.028777362778782845, -0.026953037828207016, -0.012892602942883968, 0.01704571582376957, -0.03189466893672943, -0.020723838359117508, 0.013442977331578732, -0.004569754004478455, 0.023948093876242638, -0.012310233898460865, -0.015196181833744049, -0.025204692035913467, 0.03068200685083866, -0.04274170100688934, -0.04367690533399582, 0.02625991962850094, -0.0023187354672700167, -0.04153462499380112, 0.02476990409195423, 0.020739760249853134, 0.039145294576883316, 0.004756734240800142, -0.04719046503305435, -0.04554367437958717, 0.03891611099243164, -0.016070842742919922, 0.010017846710979939, 0.00680698174983263, -0.02483556419610977, -0.015392948873341084, -0.01489751785993576, 0.055050089955329895, 0.004911521449685097, 0.01944095455110073, -0.026305072009563446, 0.04116262122988701, 0.019193869084119797, 0.010681907646358013, -0.018187126144766808, -0.004942259285598993, 0.011066373437643051, -0.007040874566882849, -0.01678680256009102, 0.0449790321290493, 0.02353779412806034, -0.027151279151439667, -0.02924431674182415, 0.016515793278813362, 0.016682134941220284, -0.05350546911358833, 0.03360657021403313, 0.06084325909614563, -0.0003080904425587505, 0.01335772406309843, -0.04414749890565872, 0.01807226985692978, 0.03185010328888893, -0.03835045546293259, 0.027422994375228882, -0.02740698680281639, -0.021135395392775536, -0.032654307782649994, 0.024351900443434715, -0.04352995753288269, 0.0304489117115736, 0.02545887418091297, -0.00013582734391093254, 0.02187999337911606, 0.02398882620036602, 0.04508689418435097, -0.03692060708999634, -0.024235650897026062, 0.018809659406542778, 0.03747265040874481, -0.013255409896373749, 0.06150468438863754, -0.03201594948768616, -0.016959713771939278, 0.030817894265055656, -0.01393940206617117, 0.020418774336576462, -0.011184198781847954, 0.07463326305150986, 0.006206524092704058, 0.05534280464053154, 0.05037524923682213, -0.037200819700956345, -0.003930483013391495, -0.0018025938188657165, 0.02843603305518627, 0.014233257621526718, 0.02236172743141651, 0.031995754688978195, 0.0025858301669359207, 0.0014223939506337047, -0.04784006252884865, -0.008195780217647552, 0.006301557645201683, -0.013678234070539474, -0.009783189743757248, -0.012563544325530529, 0.009732667356729507, -0.0430254265666008, 0.005935132969170809, 0.0005962580326013267, -0.010357563383877277, -0.012672443874180317, -0.017228858545422554, -0.03383972868323326, -0.022267745807766914, -0.021187065169215202, -0.06874317675828934, 0.025603385642170906, -0.015326865948736668, -0.0010542349191382527, -0.07197674363851547, -0.01932387612760067, 0.027165405452251434, -0.03694367781281471, -0.08034950494766235, -0.014133124612271786, -0.040286798030138016, 0.09450609236955643, -0.0033978314604610205, -0.006901199463754892, 0.028315821662545204, -0.013188239187002182, 0.003925889264792204, -0.05488920211791992, 0.061859797686338425, 0.008063261397182941, -0.03198368102312088, 0.014907239936292171, -0.0032200596760958433, 0.0004619205428753048, -0.004518007859587669, 0.0564681775867939, -0.020261278375983238, -0.0005278678145259619, 0.008413516916334629, 0.02070373110473156, 0.012187644839286804, -0.03296596556901932, 0.01958303712308407, -0.015305345878005028, -0.020754314959049225, 0.009099834598600864, -0.05961179360747337, -0.004982534795999527, -0.000961270765401423, 0.03445016220211983, -0.007421428803354502, 0.0157239381223917, 0.011909670196473598, -0.004537544213235378, 0.016799120232462883, 0.030879197642207146, 0.0070091234520077705, 0.036397386342287064, -0.03441951796412468, 0.005555237177759409, 0.026186196133494377, 0.0021347517613321543, -0.07215678691864014, 0.0316663533449173, -0.031227458268404007, -0.034350208938121796, -0.009379326365888119, -0.006303297821432352, 0.014531845226883888, -0.05766553431749344, -0.027376394718885422, 0.01923939771950245, -0.039672113955020905, 0.028197403997182846, 0.012905667535960674, -0.03242407366633415, 0.03989774361252785, 0.011561864987015724, 0.026230111718177795, 0.05707428604364395, 0.01448548212647438, -0.009206517599523067, 0.0491228923201561, 0.03152523934841156, -0.017871594056487083, 0.0317603163421154, -0.0006402611033990979, -0.007220915984362364, 0.011268219910562038, 0.0016262840945273638, 0.02355492115020752, 0.005653855390846729, -0.004594575148075819, 0.005890260450541973, 0.025970853865146637, -0.027338149026036263, 0.0022264171857386827, -0.015842927619814873, 0.0369129441678524, -0.037368498742580414, -0.017478089779615402, -0.005798840895295143, 0.02785617671906948, -0.039321769028902054, 0.02196979895234108, -0.017029235139489174, 0.020904937759041786, -0.0015058409189805388, -0.011624258011579514, 0.03543839231133461, 0.005729890428483486, -0.01649056375026703, -0.049860630184412, 0.017546137794852257, -0.004276638850569725, -0.00929917674511671, 0.012484402395784855, -0.01717788726091385, -0.04921513423323631, -0.03381099924445152, 0.005480282474309206, 0.04382280260324478, 0.031443074345588684, -0.02036610245704651, -0.031724292784929276, -0.04240797460079193, 0.03589222580194473, -0.07833558320999146, 0.009919967502355576, -0.013133162632584572, -0.01790536381304264, 0.015031730756163597, -0.024254027754068375 ]
<p>I want to train a model but the number of examples of the categories differ a lot 1 category : 100 examples 2 category : 2000 examples 3 category : 50 4 category : 4500</p> <p>if I take the 50% of the examples of each category as training and the other 50% as test set, the fact that I have very few examples for the category 1 and 3 will affect my model?</p>
73,554
[ -0.04170053079724312, -0.0037541736382991076, 0.003391385544091463, 0.032860226929187775, 0.02230319008231163, -0.012364059686660767, -0.006768102757632732, -0.027883870527148247, 0.057906027883291245, 0.017181577160954475, 0.05878232792019844, 0.022086501121520996, 0.05222678184509277, 0.008938333950936794, -0.0026795503217726946, 0.01369955763220787, -0.006045510061085224, -0.0019863026682287455, 0.020412573590874672, -0.005372033454477787, -0.028124477714300156, 0.04304927587509155, 0.02297024056315422, 0.010757341049611568, -0.04306921362876892, 0.04078532010316849, 0.03655758127570152, -0.005693285726010799, 0.01576456055045128, 0.027187854051589966, -0.03442240133881569, -0.04401642084121704, 0.026274364441633224, 0.07197010517120361, 0.04167528450489044, -0.012245642021298409, -0.029306787997484207, -0.04181274399161339, -0.007334134075790644, -0.025317249819636345, -0.0034850710071623325, 0.028670914471149445, 0.025088291615247726, 0.028492813929915428, -0.003764152294024825, 0.0027458283584564924, 0.0012175901792943478, -0.020894141867756844, 0.031026652082800865, -0.022306768223643303, 0.07994642853736877, 0.009897720068693161, 0.022967511788010597, 0.07509545236825943, 0.01903284527361393, -0.0006851294310763478, 0.04229240491986275, 0.07885578274726868, -0.015197175554931164, -0.02940620854496956, -0.021160461008548737, -0.05111725255846977, 0.05490061268210411, -0.04112876579165459, -0.04321035370230675, 0.06754273921251297, -0.01447338331490755, -0.014277488924562931, 0.018258819356560707, -0.009046350605785847, 0.03290122002363205, -0.007845661602914333, 0.04004833847284317, -0.0011469870805740356, 0.0025217044167220592, 0.003045222256332636, 0.009488033130764961, 0.03741630166769028, 0.062147896736860275, 0.04837540164589882, -0.01453491859138012, 0.013829088769853115, -0.0016581722302362323, 0.022298047319054604, 0.02296769618988037, -0.027815081179142, 0.06494719535112381, -0.033766601234674454, 0.014770392328500748, 0.006596043705940247, -0.02245175652205944, -0.011403709650039673, 0.060745470225811005, 0.001348037039861083, -0.019884968176484108, 0.02121657505631447, 0.005285271909087896, 0.03391444310545921, 0.004178816918283701, 0.04438026249408722, -0.041171785444021225, -0.03677748143672943, 0.020343413576483727, 0.019936610013246536, -0.04471457377076149, 0.008968809619545937, -0.0358685739338398, -0.015287136659026146, -0.00881277397274971, 0.0016707770992070436, 0.009293654933571815, 0.02955884486436844, 0.0252368226647377, 0.028805838897824287, 0.02223978005349636, -0.009292181581258774, 0.00699425907805562, -0.037071309983730316, 0.026394817978143692, 0.030966781079769135, 0.05317038297653198, -0.05143091082572937, 0.01809602975845337, -0.03190413489937782, -0.02427266351878643, 0.00830716174095869, -0.005188227165490389, -0.040449559688568115, -0.04211067035794258, 0.04929144307971001, -0.06307415664196014, -0.010797684080898762, 0.020786140114068985, -0.0037348917685449123, 0.026758592575788498, -0.0018283529207110405, -0.09374681115150452, -0.009075040929019451, 0.011162335984408855, -0.057469021528959274, -0.013156259432435036, -0.026181815192103386, 0.024805333465337753, 0.03169805184006691, 0.023702261969447136, 0.005106949247419834, 0.04317745193839073, 0.03298412263393402, -0.009705799631774426, 0.04017012193799019, -0.015322582796216011, -0.012607683427631855, -0.037033215165138245, 0.016208555549383163, -0.01283778715878725, -0.09990597516298294, 0.0010655156802386045, 0.00706546101719141, -0.028354350477457047, 0.011462124064564705, -0.033927071839571, -0.0008615652332082391, 0.005321672651916742, -0.005109946243464947, 0.03128267079591751, -0.007582648657262325, 0.07407144457101822, -0.019816679880023003, 0.061299510300159454, 0.030691001564264297, 0.0012728495057672262, 0.017621975392103195, 0.01621672883629799, 0.03321331739425659, 0.040434807538986206, 0.003157063154503703, 0.003773820586502552, -0.017561735585331917, 0.005822642706334591, 0.006967383436858654, -0.041693754494190216, -0.024114973843097687, -0.01518704742193222, 0.04459485784173012, -0.00847428385168314, 0.019477911293506622, 0.025920957326889038, -0.02047666907310486, 0.016565971076488495, -0.021130211651325226, -0.05950217321515083, -0.04477078840136528, -0.0014445413835346699, -0.04397225007414818, -0.019913770258426666, 0.0208755973726511, -0.0017812144942581654, 0.04552809149026871, -0.01808648183941841, -0.027032122015953064, -0.044338107109069824, -0.04137473180890083, -0.004276260267943144, -0.03999284282326698, 0.033014629036188126, 0.026295170187950134, 0.0056471084244549274, -0.03051677532494068, 0.0497078076004982, -0.03652241453528404, -0.053416915237903595, 0.03589126095175743, -0.0073727769777178764, 0.00040789745980873704, 0.0032727851066738367, -0.005610628519207239, 0.006825319025665522, -0.004888276569545269, -0.023803777992725372, 0.08140042424201965, -0.044426079839468, 0.08815797418355942, 0.06261859089136124, -0.007478814106434584, -0.0001280867145396769, -0.02641255222260952, -0.025350676849484444, 0.03180229291319847, -0.011584030464291573, -0.00559108005836606, -0.05935956910252571, 0.02444186806678772, 0.009451535530388355, 0.01798059232532978, -0.032004643231630325, 0.027728620916604996, 0.05931374430656433, -0.019078940153121948, 0.029617177322506905, 0.0034164036624133587, 0.0357084758579731, 0.006198700051754713, 0.03911180421710014, 0.03541543334722519, 0.046906255185604095, -0.013647899031639099, -0.0057684737257659435, -0.007475778926163912, 0.03045036643743515, 0.0025779670104384422, -0.021967468783259392, 0.05826644226908684, 0.022481108084321022, 0.011075354181230068, -0.0045621562749147415, 0.011892789974808693, 0.008865782991051674, -0.014446643181145191, -0.03901483863592148, 0.0677691251039505, 0.019770139828324318, -0.021067608147859573, 0.020383719354867935, -0.026302186772227287, 0.01949908770620823, 0.05667511373758316, -0.01823558658361435, -0.007139227353036404, 0.03228486329317093, -0.06755048036575317, -0.019654231145977974, 0.011936520226299763, -0.031072251498699188, -0.09011855721473694, 0.030227940529584885, 0.03735744208097458, -0.029182981699705124, 0.01450944971293211, -0.02619457244873047, -0.02149518020451069, 0.015677111223340034, -0.001887195510789752, 0.04758942499756813, -0.05030615255236626, -0.05020090937614441, 0.011058783158659935, -0.036436453461647034, -0.016682758927345276, 0.02441561408340931, -0.016004130244255066, -0.0245907511562109, 0.01447557844221592, -0.030452417209744453, -0.006566709838807583, -0.044212982058525085, -0.041233472526073456, 0.06499927490949631, -0.0025852504186332226, -0.05433034524321556, 0.047041382640600204, 0.04005846381187439, -0.02760602906346321, -0.0012503041652962565, -0.0234959926456213, -0.029882336035370827, -0.030977077782154083, -0.006355135701596737, 0.006152931600809097, -0.04112360626459122, -0.014547540806233883, 0.05315806344151497, 0.0012486708583310246, -0.0031975763849914074, -0.03458134084939957, -0.06190398707985878, 0.010179754346609116, 0.023151114583015442, 0.013500186614692211, 0.014804437756538391, -0.005722105968743563, 0.0928482860326767, 0.04242376238107681, -0.03243149444460869, -0.014621313661336899, -0.02961583435535431, -0.0438796728849411, -0.05165836960077286, 0.022742291912436485, 0.01118517853319645, -0.005046413745731115, -0.015731357038021088, 0.04185713082551956, 0.045390527695417404, 0.039866574108600616, -0.008824183605611324, -0.02881384827196598, 0.01950679160654545, 0.00888709258288145, -0.024671483784914017, 0.026149950921535492, 0.043579474091529846, -0.01332549937069416, -0.003988378681242466, -0.044592805206775665, 0.06836242973804474, 0.00747331976890564, -0.015148160979151726, 0.04073933884501457, -0.030750004574656487, 0.02423185110092163, 0.017465123906731606, 0.050653208047151566, 0.008925593458116055, -0.034324705600738525, -0.021161090582609177, 0.026969384402036667, 0.021610351279377937, -0.022178005427122116, -0.027935056015849113, 0.03950158506631851, 0.05021308735013008, -0.03216398507356644, -0.01753028854727745, -0.03808414563536644, -0.009130151942372322, 0.024469010531902313, 0.011224365793168545, -0.01577700674533844, 0.04253675416111946, 0.009652731008827686, 0.02783171832561493, -0.008423211984336376, -0.023792045190930367, -0.0071736848913133144, -0.06647057086229324, -0.01437339000403881, 0.006848691031336784, 0.07653816789388657, 0.018317559733986855, 0.045303359627723694, 0.009307703003287315, -0.027756599709391594, -0.01918322779238224, 0.009980855509638786, -0.05678849667310715, 0.032725851982831955, 0.016776127740740776, -0.007183091714978218, 0.03129495680332184, -0.03466200456023216, 0.03415076807141304, -0.0378277525305748, -0.0011830737348645926, -0.006434191018342972, -0.021570267155766487, -0.03961797431111336, 0.020833555608987808, -0.016266293823719025, 0.017437653616070747, 0.00013284629676491022, 0.03768572211265564, -0.004010939039289951, 0.011661957018077374, 0.006454390939325094, 0.013062415644526482, 0.015247484669089317, -0.031803350895643234, -0.048656269907951355, 0.038372840732336044, -0.021212968975305557, 0.05920151621103287, 0.02707555517554283, 0.01658930629491806, -0.06895307451486588, 0.0389559380710125, -0.009545642882585526, 0.02395869791507721, 0.07376263290643692, 0.0019429941894486547, -0.01472892053425312, -0.05817010998725891, -0.009549174457788467, 0.003077926579862833, 0.04151887446641922, 0.0004908325499854982, -0.02811162918806076, 0.035396184772253036, 0.01043981034308672, -0.03473319485783577, -0.017962858080863953, 0.049261413514614105, 0.007219454739242792, -0.04344016686081886, -0.02284826524555683, -0.004187652841210365, -0.021530069410800934, 0.009067594073712826, 0.006313778460025787, -0.004709989298135042, -0.027921101078391075, 0.03554050624370575, 0.013875005766749382, 0.0031553765293210745, -0.042250677943229675, -0.01086821686476469, 0.03889862447977066, 0.018772829324007034, -0.03346997871994972, -0.027726802974939346, 0.007916615344583988, 0.01887761428952217, 0.023752178996801376, 0.0018292551394551992, 0.001774053554981947, -0.09594746679067612, -0.006109069101512432, 0.03826930746436119, 0.036540787667036057, -0.05661027505993843, -0.0021435595117509365, -0.031159739941358566, 0.011523154564201832, 0.026739265769720078, -0.03906910866498947, 0.008821620605885983, -0.012900130823254585, 0.017419658601284027, -0.017486894503235817, -0.025036899372935295, -0.03864975646138191, 0.026942742988467216, -0.049177385866642, 0.049531903117895126, 0.021170657128095627, 0.0016795364208519459, -0.012784735299646854, 0.008890592493116856, 0.02114609070122242, 0.07695768773555756, -0.057969264686107635, 0.0011259528109803796, 0.00974362064152956, 0.019567081704735756, -0.013446100056171417, -0.07368970662355423, 0.03458352014422417, -0.013793358579277992, -0.00231075007468462, 0.010968983173370361, -0.002395265270024538, -0.021896202117204666, 0.024442870169878006, 0.024504663422703743, -0.03552479296922684, -0.018725909292697906, -0.015422909520566463, 0.004936686716973782, 0.007106272969394922, 0.006160493474453688, 0.04892837256193161, 0.01456849928945303, 0.029775219038128853, 0.007922548800706863, -0.007999008521437645, 0.057815831154584885, -0.012247329577803612, -0.02782839722931385, -0.043669234961271286, -0.01902969926595688, -0.019255228340625763, 0.04825982823967934, -0.011742626316845417, 0.05278278514742851, -0.02206956408917904, -0.02580598182976246, 0.014186624437570572, 0.03272658959031105, 0.020771751180291176, -0.03629477694630623, -0.015036240220069885, 0.025436105206608772, -0.007228838745504618, 0.005495181307196617, 0.009310442954301834, -0.022334996610879898, 0.018154025077819824, 0.014496914111077785, -0.000008276492735603824, 0.012721769511699677, -0.05094312131404877, -0.0295473150908947, -0.009041156619787216, -0.018477804958820343, 0.01064830832183361, -0.012378267012536526, 0.05491631478071213, 0.009560620412230492, -0.019124863669276237, -0.010794026777148247, 0.03524601459503174, -0.003732802579179406, 0.01523643359541893, -0.04905630275607109, 0.04723874852061272, -0.025558562949299812, -0.0008218302973546088, -0.08444777131080627, -0.07145505398511887, 0.030291054397821426, 0.024106714874505997, -0.013659576885402203, -0.018482476472854614, -0.028557932004332542, -0.03468199446797371, -0.033862024545669556, -0.046404145658016205, 0.0989903062582016, -0.021713700145483017, -0.013190029188990593, 0.002063167979940772, -0.017416013404726982, 0.08479052782058716, 0.037213943898677826, -0.02458438277244568, 0.006234958302229643, 0.012664349749684334, -0.018601711839437485, -0.0003831305366475135, 0.011367234401404858, -0.04171197488903999, -0.03598502650856972, -0.01712063141167164, 0.000024387496523559093, 0.034700021147727966, -0.04716925323009491, -0.002170310355722904, 0.022146442905068398, 0.01525372825562954, 0.02813311293721199, -0.06293094903230667, 0.004213521257042885, 0.021628674119710922, -0.023009592667222023, -0.008905859664082527, 0.025679465383291245, 0.0003167627437505871, -0.005014931783080101, 0.06027678772807121, 0.020194247364997864, -0.018727220594882965, 0.018893776461482048, 0.09453897923231125, -0.006702162325382233, 0.004209370817989111, -0.018403317779302597, -0.026771949604153633, 0.0498659573495388, 0.005181538872420788, 0.013900764286518097, -0.002581861801445484, 0.05635804310441017, -0.016674967482686043, 0.02661421149969101, -0.015300029888749123, -0.025550657883286476, 0.044455405324697495, 0.004648060537874699, 0.0306609645485878, 0.045103784650564194, -0.004019054118543863, 0.02096138522028923, -0.029263826087117195, -0.016782104969024658, -0.010351133532822132, -0.001378033310174942, 0.0387471579015255, 0.013757677748799324, -0.0048357658088207245, 0.040823958814144135, 0.004333931021392345, 0.02505146525800228, 0.0268495324999094, -0.016451776027679443, -0.0026287317741662264, 0.02728758007287979, -0.03518924489617348, -0.03248376399278641, 0.021840639412403107, -0.02331879734992981, 0.0030240595806390047, -0.021714242175221443, -0.012879284098744392, 0.06487160921096802, 0.01965068280696869, 0.0021516550332307816, -0.052389729768037796, -0.025644425302743912, -0.037545014172792435, 0.044598910957574844, 0.02676563151180744, 0.03148503229022026, 0.009524197317659855, 0.01313052885234356, 0.014701361767947674, -0.03059929423034191, 0.026390712708234787, -0.03285912796854973, -0.044743143022060394, -0.0609714575111866, -0.016717396676540375, 0.009846248663961887, 0.012689894996583462, 0.00503412215039134, -0.013352819718420506, -0.003304596059024334, -0.021233949810266495, 0.05042670667171478, 0.007317639421671629, 0.02814815193414688, -0.017125282436609268, 0.025635603815317154, 0.02111540362238884, 0.03601812943816185, -0.014325222000479698, 0.044251520186662674, 0.1263733059167862, 0.05955810099840164, 0.03587851673364639, -0.04125751927495003, -0.008017887361347675, -0.008766626939177513, -0.02064308524131775, -0.03139522299170494, -0.02243179827928543, 0.011429142206907272, 0.03542144224047661, 0.020956894382834435, 0.03211018443107605, 0.038191214203834534, 0.005325008183717728, 0.04560215026140213, -0.012248729355633259, -0.006938214413821697, 0.024890752509236336, -0.0016911301063373685, 0.02082829736173153, 0.006204770412296057, -0.04703609645366669, 0.004123116377741098, 0.022501861676573753, 0.024705277755856514, -0.022239364683628082, -0.021694626659154892, 0.010212160646915436, 0.011827858164906502, 0.009655357338488102, 0.0010357039282098413, 0.002510847756639123, 0.0004083148669451475, -0.006229635328054428, 0.001698835869319737, -0.01050388254225254, -0.036422837525606155, -0.009088071994483471, 0.026609355583786964, 0.009239393286406994, -0.001242652884684503, -0.03394438698887825, 0.021785007789731026, -0.035856373608112335, -0.023320820182561874, -0.06265194714069366, 0.04135056585073471, 0.010599842295050621, -0.026529908180236816, -0.0019840258173644543, 0.027498958632349968, 0.001042262651026249, -0.056563183665275574, -0.04942476376891136, 0.0276433564722538, -0.0018665812676772475, -0.02920556254684925, -0.02087097056210041, -0.030854929238557816, 0.035805296152830124, -0.011102834716439247, 0.014054249972105026, -0.027417344972491264, -0.024542290717363358, -0.027836471796035767, 0.0009196483879350126, 0.05316642299294472, 0.02402021735906601, 0.01727345585823059, 0.02882388047873974, -0.05052906274795532, -0.03740505501627922, -0.021757978945970535, -0.00015084062761161476, 0.03185843303799629, 0.008641524240374565, -0.02945088781416416, -0.042886681854724884, 0.01181693747639656, -0.011361182667315006, -0.02311166562139988, 0.04079701751470566, 0.02180132269859314, -0.04851679876446724, 0.0004292470111977309, 0.006220937706530094, 0.017606142908334732, 0.04253197833895683, -0.013787093572318554, 0.023592615500092506, 0.05448906123638153, 0.0012715219054371119, -0.04969629645347595, -0.012183628045022488, 0.014015872031450272, -0.06704973429441452, 0.03932490944862366, -0.0131578603759408, 0.0847504734992981, 0.003504684194922447, -0.005612562410533428, 0.002685890067368746, 0.03884612396359444, 0.0027971090748906136, 0.0417720265686512, 0.008399087004363537, -0.0749523937702179, 0.005964984651654959, 0.053074222058057785, -0.00004877659375779331, -0.04888011887669563, -0.03206561505794525, -0.03012957237660885, -0.02770810015499592, 0.018817109987139702, -0.013568862341344357, -0.030286334455013275, 0.03270316496491432, -0.0010596897918730974, 0.031114397570490837, -0.00781219033524394, -0.013355704955756664, -0.05338619649410248, 0.009150062687695026, -0.014371506869792938, -0.02947109565138817, -0.0017316857120022178, -0.015847237780690193, 0.004404780920594931, -0.00022572759189642966, 0.013926057144999504, -0.016099590808153152, -0.014972416684031487, 0.0030199852772057056, 0.0028709936887025833, 0.01934708282351494, 0.050801150500774384, -0.03413786739110947, -0.031232383102178574, 0.039262805134058, -0.03386317193508148, -0.013779016211628914, 0.005870459601283073, -0.026808585971593857, 0.06937490403652191, 0.017762312665581703, -0.013185515999794006, -0.019306816160678864, 0.07545164972543716, 0.004039342049509287, -0.019791370257735252, -0.018452487885951996, 0.0148911252617836, 0.037497036159038544, 0.003622859949246049, 0.008505212143063545, 0.012803792022168636, -0.03221416845917702, 0.014049253426492214, 0.04906124249100685, -0.0011166277108713984, -0.07520326972007751, 0.01669304445385933, -0.015551767311990261, 0.015532494522631168, -0.015055891126394272, 0.041309017688035965, 0.021066728979349136, 0.01307588443160057, -0.019972791895270348, 0.02338869497179985, -0.01889173872768879, 0.02705565094947815, -0.07404487580060959, -0.04854447767138481, 0.02635389193892479, -0.0028063973877578974, 0.02832995355129242, -0.03130529075860977, 0.0363425686955452, 0.024452736601233482, -0.0642700120806694, 0.02180580608546734, -0.012952862307429314, -0.039215900003910065, -0.04425549507141113, -0.009120832197368145, -0.022697601467370987, -0.014535438269376755, 0.015208380296826363, 0.011531757190823555, 0.017440535128116608, 0.006168787367641926, 0.015225834213197231, -0.020863454788923264, -0.02793963998556137, 0.005704405251890421, 0.006933215074241161, -0.04294879361987114, -0.00863499566912651, -0.0038604354485869408, -0.08929897844791412, 0.04734554514288902, -0.01202842965722084, -0.03404966741800308, 0.026090962812304497, 0.016525905579328537, 0.017833435907959938, 0.03083699941635132, 0.01868310384452343, -0.003011926542967558, 0.009195164777338505, -0.007859556935727596, -0.012107877992093563, -0.0023376564495265484, 0.008949771523475647, 0.006858978420495987, 0.0605689138174057, -0.010005551390349865, -0.017008451744914055, 0.03217409923672676, 0.0000865046022227034, -0.03748929128050804, 0.00807239394634962, 0.029702050611376762, -0.005611910950392485, -0.02642342820763588, 0.0034754551015794277, -0.02262583188712597, 0.043132197111845016, 0.020029159262776375, -0.003428816329687834, 0.0017297982703894377, -0.0086862463504076, -0.041214704513549805, -0.027457909658551216, -0.02585121989250183, 0.0351746641099453, -0.024929840117692947, -0.05910845100879669, -0.01138803455978632, 0.0030644715297967196, 0.01776065118610859, -0.018157240003347397, -0.06946101039648056, -0.03624200448393822, 0.03896374627947807, -0.00530519662424922, 0.003029365325346589, 0.003129096468910575, 0.010348975658416748, -0.008538062684237957, -0.0885675773024559, 0.051789239048957825, -0.005465480033308268, -0.02692992240190506, -0.039584457874298096, 0.015652205795049667, -0.061006855219602585, 0.009417844004929066, 0.038458000868558884, 0.027936331927776337, 0.006369668059051037, -0.026776041835546494, -0.0037231137976050377, -0.000182075789780356, -0.02917780540883541, 0.014685235917568207, 0.015037531033158302, -0.03563498705625534, -0.02134302817285061, -0.005693280603736639, 0.012495982460677624, -0.00890805572271347, -0.016383979469537735, 0.020121203735470772, 0.010367910377681255, -0.014813478104770184, -0.004487588535994291, 0.020016981288790703, 0.01780424453318119, 0.008164896629750729, 0.02864816226065159, -0.01674651727080345, 0.0223978403955698, -0.006262910086661577, -0.008106390945613384, -0.05436500534415245, -0.010508211329579353, -0.04909351468086243, 0.0010009376564994454, 0.03834985941648483, -0.0007716177497059107, 0.01741156354546547, -0.03050445392727852, -0.003240002319216728, 0.016761211678385735, -0.026306800544261932, 0.026913929730653763, 0.029228759929537773, 0.042457886040210724, 0.04230523854494095, -0.02266732044517994, 0.015062307938933372, -0.025650296360254288, -0.0180346742272377, 0.0006018619169481099, 0.01550420094281435, -0.037586912512779236, 0.0168171264231205, 0.03750193491578102, 0.029198063537478447, -0.025989076122641563, -0.004057364538311958, 0.013209372758865356, 0.03754519671201706, -0.00260346382856369, -0.00895751267671585, 0.01903194561600685, -0.010097110643982887, -0.01843496970832348, 0.008243882097303867, -0.007535205222666264, 0.035685550421476364, -0.05446192994713783, -0.005654370877891779, -0.04501466080546379, -0.012991669587790966, 0.0031213813927024603, 0.011769292876124382, 0.015935231000185013, 0.03473537415266037, 0.01151766162365675, -0.04101531580090523, -0.0033880567643791437, -0.02711816504597664, 0.0309588722884655, -0.017655642703175545, -0.007872235029935837, -0.014796474948525429, -0.01690991036593914, 0.024121060967445374, 0.010874498635530472, -0.035210300236940384, 0.012499868869781494, 0.029663801193237305, 0.04275958240032196, 0.050655797123909, -0.035294309258461, -0.029840704053640366, 0.013841889798641205, 0.002601351821795106, -0.03580097854137421, -0.04126330092549324, -0.04385415464639664, 0.02573120780289173, -0.013619261793792248, -0.06475261598825455 ]
<p>I started evaluating and comparing some methods in forecasting. I used Price of dozen eggs in US, 1900–1993, in constant dollars in the R software FMA package. I held out the last 10 years for assessment of forecast. Below are the results:</p> <p>I used auto arima method in the R software. Obviously the results are way off. Am I doing something incorrect ? Below is the forecast. It does not recognize the declining trend. </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/KIM9O.jpg" alt="auto arima"></p> <p>I also used an unobserved components model (UCM) and obtained a good forecast, as below.</p> <ol> <li>Without outliers/level shifts there are very large standard errors and therefore wide confidence bands. <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/dlIXM.png" alt="UCM without outliers level shifts"></li> <li>After some iterative work, below is the output with outliers/level shifts (I know I'm overfitting here) but it did a pretty good job in forecasting; there are also narrow confidence bands. <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/5SrYJ.png" alt="UCM with outliers level shifts"></li> </ol> <p>In looking at just this example the UCM seems to predict the hold-out sample more accurately than auto.arima.</p> <p><strong>Why is auto.arima not providing a reasonable forecast?</strong></p> <p><strong>Are state space models/UCMs better for forecasting long range?</strong></p> <p><strong>Are there any benefits of using one method over other?</strong></p>
49,926
[ -0.010229025967419147, -0.03677895665168762, 0.016649842262268066, 0.001525898464024067, 0.01600971445441246, -0.035100556910037994, -0.026166802272200584, -0.014683372341096401, 0.03284475579857826, -0.01859908178448677, 0.015126995742321014, 0.03993871808052063, 0.03279545530676842, 0.03367903083562851, 0.001660953857935965, -0.005503123160451651, -0.0023164553567767143, -0.015102816745638847, -0.009967693127691746, 0.007861903868615627, -0.0013128083664923906, 0.011541261337697506, -0.038285765796899796, -0.01657421700656414, -0.012935162521898746, 0.050091229379177094, 0.03362903743982315, -0.02012871578335762, -0.0031146963592618704, 0.03666107356548309, -0.018276583403348923, 0.0013018727768212557, 0.010608077049255371, 0.012295946478843689, 0.06247832253575325, 0.017247958108782768, 0.03384871035814285, -0.04630666971206665, -0.004098340403288603, 0.04798617959022522, -0.055248744785785675, -0.03540182113647461, -0.003982214257121086, 0.04112842306494713, -0.04081268981099129, 0.013117117807269096, 0.015331098809838295, -0.011974402703344822, 0.04403814300894737, -0.008321376517415047, 0.031155981123447418, -0.004194502253085375, 0.009886487387120724, 0.04375132545828819, -0.03682493045926094, -0.026490990072488785, 0.04845558479428291, 0.06096259132027626, -0.002221663249656558, -0.052204616367816925, 0.04289509356021881, -0.01864783838391304, -0.016603147611021996, -0.025185365229845047, -0.03993448615074158, 0.04607488960027695, -0.033270321786403656, -0.028896519914269447, 0.013885922729969025, -0.034835055470466614, 0.024260425940155983, -0.010589172132313251, 0.009680437855422497, 0.016900913789868355, 0.011789783835411072, -0.02136423997581005, -0.021872898563742638, 0.024776065722107887, 0.0460362583398819, 0.054025694727897644, -0.005964349955320358, 0.04823174700140953, 0.04023730009794235, 0.050221145153045654, 0.027137286961078644, 0.002040813211351633, 0.06989500671625137, -0.04242507368326187, 0.011293466202914715, 0.04220113903284073, -0.0314914733171463, 0.011661268770694733, 0.06582584232091904, -0.013583803549408913, -0.03362080827355385, 0.03041115403175354, -0.012933334335684776, 0.011906931176781654, -0.004157927352935076, -0.008799015544354916, 0.0075106630101799965, -0.023686131462454796, 0.016640910878777504, 0.0811791718006134, 0.01651841774582863, -0.016346793621778488, -0.00031267813756130636, -0.07786314189434052, -0.00419116485863924, -0.03504001349210739, -0.03921124339103699, 0.017535915598273277, -0.013269604183733463, -0.004088369198143482, -0.005178376566618681, 0.02887316793203354, 0.015602689236402512, -0.03585859760642052, 0.003281043842434883, 0.039401423186063766, 0.026520533487200737, 0.009785981848835945, -0.007359251845628023, -0.03633202612400055, -0.059928443282842636, 0.001991108525544405, -0.011979937553405762, -0.002206325065344572, -0.09453009068965912, 0.06016319617629051, 0.00811406597495079, -0.025101011618971825, 0.003579020034521818, -0.035740941762924194, 0.045487385243177414, 0.007405283860862255, -0.09607923775911331, -0.05601713806390762, 0.04203977808356285, -0.013475845567882061, 0.038639672100543976, -0.05698748305439949, -0.004940446466207504, 0.00799976009875536, 0.05438017100095749, 0.020058102905750275, 0.04616117849946022, 0.008218628354370594, 0.018780287355184555, -0.021279120817780495, -0.05800004303455353, 0.025035463273525238, -0.011158880777657032, -0.017910262569785118, -0.0009387395693920553, -0.07883068919181824, -0.008020849898457527, 0.03149370476603508, 0.01623374968767166, 0.021269764751195908, 0.03157941624522209, 0.015819555148482323, -0.0046781618148088455, -0.05784706771373749, -0.018403559923171997, -0.01877366378903389, 0.07352650165557861, -0.00556139275431633, 0.02728964202105999, 0.01511816680431366, -0.03262738510966301, 0.045930854976177216, 0.013226025737822056, 0.008418580517172813, 0.05520521104335785, -0.020018693059682846, 0.05819704011082649, -0.038184281438589096, -0.03648805245757103, 0.026488810777664185, -0.03658762946724892, -0.010059253312647343, -0.007964445278048515, -0.030838456004858017, 0.021918436512351036, 0.0352368988096714, -0.022416288033127785, -0.0032022958621382713, 0.04245610907673836, -0.09383605420589447, -0.03744763135910034, -0.0345848985016346, 0.0017934583593159914, -0.03669188916683197, 0.02263355441391468, 0.0510929636657238, -0.03331449255347252, 0.0435326024889946, 0.007675911765545607, -0.011492094956338406, -0.05217590928077698, 0.01265010517090559, 0.013690775260329247, -0.053387776017189026, 0.03182346373796463, 0.04749730974435806, -0.0015823381254449487, -0.010070626623928547, 0.036387138068675995, -0.04704945161938667, -0.018113451078534126, 0.024685628712177277, -0.05286616086959839, 0.02128642052412033, 0.015593960881233215, -0.009759150445461273, 0.047933921217918396, -0.0487799309194088, -0.0046892617829144, 0.05172465741634369, -0.041336070746183395, 0.0029825353994965553, 0.024228209629654884, -0.03311098739504814, 0.0018885948229581118, 0.03797154501080513, 0.010904709808528423, 0.04039965197443962, -0.02037644386291504, -0.031547751277685165, -0.06128406897187233, 0.014083754271268845, 0.029019532725214958, 0.03283357247710228, -0.01807173155248165, 0.026050901040434837, 0.05717391520738602, 0.011355187743902206, 0.003094219136983156, 0.03821539878845215, 0.0023810225538909435, -0.03178848698735237, 0.01993311196565628, 0.014753978699445724, 0.027822306379675865, 0.037562184035778046, 0.0013293471420183778, -0.01871979795396328, -0.00839201733469963, -0.005455471575260162, 0.0027288657147437334, 0.06018097698688507, -0.012009863741695881, -0.02250536158680916, -0.015305432491004467, 0.0030843792483210564, 0.0060335793532431126, -0.05614631623029709, -0.02160489559173584, -0.009807604365050793, 0.030341792851686478, -0.028188632801175117, 0.013578253798186779, -0.03033408708870411, 0.009840701706707478, 0.0490814670920372, -0.011847596615552902, 0.01320978719741106, 0.017746824771165848, -0.052827730774879456, 0.0001819413446355611, -0.05711667239665985, -0.015741119161248207, -0.03617070987820625, -0.011777582578361034, 0.04878055304288864, 0.010776814073324203, -0.01458020694553852, -0.013759974390268326, -0.008557441644370556, 0.01621365174651146, 0.00307251769118011, -0.002678575925529003, -0.0030838651582598686, -0.03851993754506111, 0.03552025184035301, 0.0006277923239395022, 0.019609427079558372, 0.05570455640554428, 0.018977349624037743, -0.009383706375956535, 0.0276879221200943, -0.006157774478197098, -0.05517599359154701, -0.06470295786857605, -0.0012141186743974686, 0.026347368955612183, -0.003041551448404789, -0.06284034252166748, 0.06440968811511993, 0.01432795450091362, 0.019287576898932457, 0.0025199013762176037, -0.04658333212137222, -0.0014663063921034336, -0.023398829624056816, 0.021271605044603348, -0.01026844885200262, 0.01002472173422575, -0.0013384099584072828, 0.004272769670933485, -0.045754700899124146, -0.01695614866912365, -0.060635145753622055, -0.05365796759724617, 0.006699211895465851, -0.030217966064810753, 0.03465399518609047, 0.02263415791094303, -0.007745771668851376, 0.016287919133901596, 0.03898738697171211, -0.045029185712337494, -0.05899795517325401, 0.00001013636665447848, -0.03656167536973953, -0.03020116686820984, -0.026078836992383003, 0.02285955473780632, 0.010755060240626335, 0.009704770520329475, -0.029280660673975945, 0.01366081926971674, 0.031747084110975266, 0.02898639626801014, -0.018181107938289642, -0.005207914859056473, -0.04739164933562279, 0.024205612018704414, 0.06594384461641312, 0.017250606790184975, -0.023517685011029243, -0.02945096045732498, -0.0011401009978726506, 0.029018757864832878, 0.00895640254020691, -0.06388497352600098, 0.016179531812667847, -0.014823324978351593, 0.007440206129103899, -0.036153849214315414, 0.019992314279079437, -0.008461017161607742, 0.0005424196715466678, -0.00855682510882616, -0.014284077100455761, 0.015808099880814552, 0.0049820845015347, 0.004062423948198557, 0.04195782542228699, 0.04240582510828972, 0.005579065997153521, -0.00014468525478150696, -0.019626600667834282, 0.021434549242258072, 0.050592027604579926, -0.05783471092581749, -0.005162271670997143, 0.020880017429590225, 0.029414795339107513, 0.006243040319532156, 0.017410870641469955, -0.04562244936823845, 0.023120082914829254, -0.08919385075569153, -0.010555674321949482, -0.04272729903459549, 0.06884115189313889, -0.006713542155921459, 0.04101238399744034, 0.015809334814548492, 0.009056279435753822, 0.02162475511431694, -0.014965247362852097, -0.05801408365368843, 0.03984968364238739, 0.010911158286035061, -0.011381180956959724, -0.011202646419405937, -0.031343720853328705, -0.001347908517345786, 0.0017685716738924384, 0.05461401119828224, -0.04650292918086052, 0.04318121075630188, -0.04588530957698822, 0.03605323284864426, -0.01819656230509281, 0.006439614109694958, -0.05164328217506409, -0.04780814051628113, 0.047469861805438995, -0.014522391371428967, 0.06000372767448425, 0.03337767720222473, -0.025435157120227814, -0.017744634300470352, -0.059982214123010635, 0.04125209152698517, 0.037713028490543365, 0.033331453800201416, 0.040765970945358276, 0.04408556595444679, -0.08675280213356018, 0.028841247782111168, 0.09266426414251328, 0.03233828768134117, -0.014623385854065418, -0.019946200773119926, -0.03750326484441757, -0.010218496434390545, -0.00931208860129118, 0.02888166904449463, -0.006886396557092667, 0.00629095733165741, 0.010042782872915268, 0.05503290891647339, 0.020212844014167786, 0.0018240934005007148, 0.010769669897854328, 0.04337147995829582, 0.009555845521390438, 0.038396839052438736, -0.02985193207859993, -0.024448754265904427, -0.00462966738268733, -0.0015836500097066164, 0.03955072909593582, -0.009632267989218235, -0.008749779313802719, -0.011952697299420834, 0.05030682310461998, -0.014366433955729008, -0.04750749468803406, -0.008541138842701912, -0.005543723702430725, 0.020415781065821648, -0.0009361952543258667, -0.01746015064418316, 0.02644062042236328, 0.033603735268116, 0.03129224851727486, 0.05996451899409294, 0.017412303015589714, -0.09074576944112778, 0.015461213886737823, 0.0354568287730217, 0.01833057776093483, -0.01484642643481493, -0.0020508128218352795, -0.06191835552453995, -0.04851989448070526, 0.011451694183051586, -0.040784116834402084, 0.0605379082262516, 0.0027416222728788853, 0.03573733568191528, -0.009786388836801052, -0.069595567882061, -0.03935566172003746, -0.028319645673036575, -0.007935309782624245, 0.05140911787748337, -0.03048221580684185, -0.030599569901823997, -0.021536938846111298, 0.005240550264716148, -0.03064638562500477, 0.02110220678150654, -0.042771872133016586, -0.010556637309491634, 0.029945623129606247, 0.013574785552918911, -0.02070513926446438, -0.04079916328191757, -0.0168426763266325, -0.0012720151571556926, -0.02271193452179432, 0.03996863588690758, -0.007959814742207527, -0.04266413673758507, -0.003698069602251053, 0.0032472831662744284, 0.0509352944791317, -0.03657957538962364, -0.02714729681611061, 0.028374936431646347, -0.004347566980868578, -0.01292431354522705, 0.03552570194005966, 0.04029649496078491, -0.0005070222541689873, 0.004091336391866207, -0.011755246669054031, -0.009531809948384762, -0.015538845211267471, -0.028187748044729233, -0.024427898228168488, -0.016238462179899216, -0.04555583745241165, 0.013361498713493347, 0.015306448563933372, 0.049062907695770264, -0.07367754727602005, 0.009589715860784054, 0.010689382441341877, 0.008157205767929554, -0.037809304893016815, -0.00845558475703001, -0.02244233712553978, -0.010368183255195618, -0.02065996825695038, 0.022146858274936676, -0.0030558088328689337, -0.06772606819868088, -0.00459781801328063, 0.03324849158525467, -0.05578460916876793, 0.010767772793769836, -0.013693667948246002, -0.01809174194931984, 0.020630456507205963, -0.055209167301654816, 0.04416196420788765, -0.009005606174468994, 0.07478760182857513, 0.027317536994814873, -0.0438879057765007, -0.010117050260305405, 0.04203201085329056, -0.0012306825956329703, 0.04900187999010086, 0.002336114412173629, 0.05023491010069847, 0.01197973731905222, 0.0021280364599078894, -0.035960618406534195, -0.05805928632616997, 0.049781639128923416, 0.04712114483118057, -0.06153508275747299, 0.017976347357034683, -0.006777077913284302, -0.018687743693590164, 0.019167371094226837, -0.05590398982167244, 0.0258778128772974, -0.013449201360344887, -0.0008940929546952248, 0.036048535257577896, 0.0203819889575243, 0.06543445587158203, 0.004183192737400532, -0.012171827256679535, 0.028809865936636925, 0.01159057766199112, -0.02887807972729206, 0.022727491334080696, 0.021053222939372063, -0.02152155712246895, -0.0027547271456569433, 0.000142046861583367, -0.008812092244625092, 0.048284176737070084, -0.021762704476714134, -0.007093972992151976, 0.09115380048751831, 0.0038617958780378103, 0.006859814748167992, -0.005703630391508341, -0.0024290154688060284, -0.044401559978723526, -0.024278828874230385, -0.02488912269473076, -0.0023921621032059193, 0.03254593163728714, -0.025633038952946663, 0.023671390488743782, -0.019051669165492058, -0.006586737930774689, 0.018959084525704384, 0.04054564982652664, -0.0007579078082926571, -0.0035909577272832394, -0.009203825145959854, -0.004326395690441132, 0.03623859956860542, -0.013990700244903564, 0.017946597188711166, 0.012612381018698215, 0.008406124077737331, -0.029698001220822334, -0.05924341455101967, -0.0018756907666102052, 0.02191382646560669, 0.03220711275935173, -0.006678539793938398, -0.004999639932066202, 0.0269236508756876, 0.011657997965812683, -0.007656621281057596, -0.02720862440764904, -0.0007877702009864151, 0.01346798986196518, -0.011055639013648033, 0.020135562866926193, -0.019201058894395828, 0.02423829399049282, 0.027269994840025902, 0.00561559246852994, 0.02097776159644127, 0.013198812492191792, 0.012241221033036709, 0.011891501955688, -0.01688237302005291, -0.001139432773925364, -0.05171941593289375, 0.012570592574775219, 0.008653795346617699, 0.03165263310074806, -0.02811458520591259, -0.016467487439513206, 0.030395712703466415, 0.039056748151779175, 0.020058423280715942, -0.055144667625427246, 0.006327738054096699, -0.06491172313690186, 0.001249729422852397, 0.017506973817944527, -0.0034527324605733156, -0.0024998888839036226, 0.03275376558303833, 0.0630970224738121, 0.005880066193640232, 0.0049766432493925095, -0.025171373039484024, -0.06567975133657455, -0.007983841001987457, -0.030474290251731873, -0.01362338662147522, 0.03596000373363495, -0.026376133784651756, 0.0023340629413723946, 0.018109753727912903, -0.01638830080628395, -0.012788120657205582, 0.005655395332723856, 0.02741212211549282, -0.003441644599661231, 0.0593717135488987, -0.028703011572360992, 0.008426772430539131, -0.028527352958917618, -0.0184631384909153, 0.16833247244358063, 0.04780925065279007, 0.006158932577818632, -0.041238799691200256, 0.02483726292848587, -0.005194852594286203, -0.016088008880615234, 0.0007680165581405163, -0.023203950375318527, 0.024366827681660652, 0.0004558847867883742, 0.012794945389032364, 0.07062353193759918, -0.04636546969413757, 0.017143908888101578, 0.02951926365494728, -0.03477822616696358, 0.012687374837696552, 0.015238423831760883, 0.02493228390812874, 0.003154963022097945, -0.022334106266498566, -0.05374070256948471, 0.03431526944041252, -0.011625404469668865, -0.009241350926458836, 0.004400034435093403, -0.023150919005274773, 0.008806406520307064, -0.006358519196510315, 0.0002852367179002613, 0.009024606086313725, 0.023481585085392, 0.038095392286777496, 0.0423421747982502, 0.009319408796727657, 0.03455856069922447, -0.053688421845436096, 0.03772559389472008, 0.023233309388160706, 0.015920789912343025, -0.0261903814971447, -0.01143268495798111, -0.0036481928545981646, -0.009755279868841171, -0.04255885258316994, -0.05316140130162239, 0.020181912928819656, -0.0017434220062568784, 0.01863783225417137, 0.009439234621822834, 0.004628333728760481, -0.0027048683259636164, -0.018227357417345047, -0.006619341671466827, 0.020084623247385025, 0.020610349252820015, -0.06897218525409698, -0.02315410040318966, -0.022848021239042282, -0.003928027115762234, 0.015804218128323555, 0.01955414190888405, 0.0391247533261776, -0.04057357832789421, 0.007272598333656788, 0.008862634189426899, 0.0635809674859047, -0.020127031952142715, 0.010136650875210762, -0.008605516515672207, 0.027828577905893326, -0.014723259024322033, -0.011461421847343445, 0.008581199683248997, -0.0009502774919383228, 0.04141928628087044, 0.011739453300833702, 0.006209622602909803, 0.005112724844366312, -0.015168397687375546, 0.022766118869185448, -0.012995398603379726, 0.015192484483122826, 0.0005126012256368995, 0.009269922971725464, -0.03716271370649338, -0.026723934337496758, 0.01657453179359436, 0.04370579123497009, -0.043353624641895294, 0.035435259342193604, 0.01973121613264084, -0.021800795570015907, -0.013576388359069824, -0.013143985532224178, -0.06853015720844269, -0.0008552270592190325, -0.011353857815265656, 0.0733829140663147, 0.0340738445520401, -0.014138873666524887, -0.012836186215281487, 0.0677013024687767, 0.017206624150276184, -0.022876016795635223, 0.040118277072906494, -0.03746502473950386, -0.02368188463151455, -0.0009682163945399225, -0.003751665586605668, -0.025165598839521408, -0.013257686048746109, -0.026444485411047935, -0.03045104257762432, 0.017626145854592323, -0.011058707721531391, -0.04267781972885132, 0.05346689745783806, -0.01789121888577938, 0.026223639026284218, -0.007480891887098551, 0.011681872420012951, -0.005934694316238165, -0.037607476115226746, -0.03372523561120033, -0.04373985901474953, -0.03188967704772949, 0.05843659117817879, -0.04977358505129814, -0.002886800793930888, 0.0403154157102108, -0.004656909499317408, -0.0028540112543851137, -0.012008980847895145, 0.004469030536711216, 0.002785339020192623, 0.04044574126601219, -0.009116968140006065, -0.02045898512005806, 0.009893902577459812, -0.0008915665675885975, -0.046063780784606934, 0.018351003527641296, -0.02101985365152359, 0.008460708893835545, 0.0065218135714530945, 0.000885290908627212, 0.03830350190401077, 0.007510536350309849, -0.05169284716248512, 0.04347866028547287, -0.005179428495466709, 0.04929077997803688, 0.05341608077287674, 0.0303654745221138, 0.007745574694126844, 0.009033703245222569, 0.008331298828125, -0.009067247621715069, 0.049364328384399414, 0.012877092696726322, 0.0009357792441733181, -0.008319311775267124, -0.0485524907708168, -0.010940252803266048, -0.025470415130257607, -0.00011463819828350097, 0.0225075576454401, 0.05068645626306534, -0.029243387281894684, -0.010143835097551346, -0.018801100552082062, -0.0016756831901147962, -0.040401000529527664, -0.024243386462330818, 0.015207215212285519, 0.01868654415011406, 0.0372944176197052, -0.0358530692756176, 0.003898885566741228, 0.029840292409062386, -0.01744312420487404, 0.02087044157087803, -0.03737696260213852, 0.03581790253520012, 0.0027154090348631144, -0.04572434723377228, -0.020501654595136642, 0.00980320107191801, 0.008878047578036785, -0.015011564828455448, 0.010774771682918072, 0.046759337186813354, 0.006182345561683178, -0.026037007570266724, -0.015181747265160084, -0.002605585614219308, 0.0038875401951372623, -0.01332706119865179, 0.036486074328422546, -0.03459852561354637, -0.0033672144636511803, 0.031081760302186012, -0.06622163206338882, 0.06473562121391296, 0.023688677698373795, 0.0033771509770303965, -0.005291775334626436, 0.020007651299238205, 0.025105856359004974, 0.00852929800748825, -0.002107692416757345, -0.009008659981191158, 0.007465226575732231, -0.00919363833963871, -0.005749616771936417, 0.029186949133872986, 0.007122913375496864, -0.040876053273677826, -0.019382908940315247, -0.007217466365545988, -0.02388782612979412, 0.008347648195922375, -0.004080209415405989, -0.004095755983144045, -0.056175172328948975, 0.002560651395469904, -0.02089422196149826, 0.0021881351713091135, -0.01350870355963707, 0.025950690731406212, 0.04626964405179024, -0.02018027938902378, -0.0011700782924890518, 0.00389614119194448, -0.03764176741242409, 0.029386581853032112, -0.028148310258984566, -0.020457161590456963, -0.0170762799680233, 0.02197527512907982, 0.0018828458851203322, -0.008078438229858875, -0.06481828540563583, 0.022784806787967682, -0.05982387438416481, 0.03383363038301468, -0.008916386403143406, -0.033365149050951004, 0.055999044328927994, -0.01799388788640499, 0.011772925034165382, -0.0681295096874237, 0.04993105307221413, -0.00035385132650844753, -0.02478650026023388, -0.0004884376539848745, -0.022338226437568665, -0.01613069511950016, 0.036008868366479874, 0.05476009473204613, 0.015645623207092285, 0.035369180142879486, 0.03428135812282562, -0.005558706820011139, 0.03993487358093262, -0.014854867942631245, 0.03829015791416168, -0.03684524446725845, 0.011247671209275723, 0.017417162656784058, -0.03008631244301796, 0.024394957348704338, 0.02622191794216633, 0.024006791412830353, -0.030302485451102257, 0.030094198882579803, 0.06473370641469955, 0.043340325355529785, -0.005415597930550575, -0.011750351637601852, -0.00432499498128891, 0.05388140305876732, 0.03347932547330856, 0.015119136311113834, 0.02134988084435463, 0.00200258893892169, -0.0500401146709919, 0.03526768088340759, -0.03151140362024307, -0.0021238697227090597, -0.012282763607800007, -0.004865763243287802, 0.005236849654465914, -0.06536349654197693, -0.05413486063480377, 0.04527781903743744, 0.017062770202755928, 0.0224781334400177, 0.010799585841596127, -0.008672390133142471, -0.011324042454361916, 0.015165651217103004, 0.028762541711330414, 0.018249167129397392, 0.007267564069479704, -0.023237664252519608, 0.01037384383380413, 0.04434291273355484, 0.008616818115115166, 0.006862306967377663, 0.03966521844267845, -0.012802202254533768, -0.0019724240992218256, -0.009117181412875652, 0.046362195163965225, -0.03921756520867348, -0.026385556906461716, 0.0030893159564584494, -0.003782985731959343, 0.00386427016928792, 0.025546057149767876, -0.030661677941679955, 0.04796881228685379, -0.03678787872195244, -0.01607230119407177, 0.0018565887585282326, 0.02320082113146782, -0.02208389900624752, 0.012993721291422844, -0.012672649696469307, 0.0014589123893529177, -0.004795578308403492, 0.023945612832903862, -0.005849047563970089, -0.005169149022549391, 0.036620333790779114, -0.02454988844692707, -0.020839126780629158, -0.01293837372213602, -0.01625130884349346, -0.024440823122859, -0.03484893590211868, -0.025187889114022255, -0.0006421937723644078, 0.03973371908068657, 0.030754052102565765, 0.029720796272158623, -0.028884457424283028, -0.016262207180261612, 0.03098502941429615, 0.04470374435186386, -0.05228602513670921, 0.005970357451587915, -0.02606506459414959, -0.027382783591747284, -0.018292514607310295, -0.040377821773290634 ]
<p>What are some Goodness-of-Fit tests or indices for the case of continuous variables?</p> <p>For example, I am looking at the Kolmogorov&ndash;Smirnov test. What I don't get is how one gets the emprical CDF in the first place? What I mean is, let's say I do a regression analysis with Gaussian errors. I have the maximum-likelihood estimate of the parameters. Now I also need to do a density estimation for the empirical CDF? Aren't they the same thing? Isn't my likelihood already giving me a goodness of fit? Why do I need K&ndash;S? Really confused.</p>
35,952
[ -0.021384717896580696, 0.020885786041617393, -0.015493928454816341, -0.0012739005032926798, 0.04604865983128548, 0.04297945648431778, -0.01247814018279314, -0.03400815650820732, 0.01915343850851059, -0.033071815967559814, 0.024413522332906723, 0.03668365627527237, 0.035598982125520706, 0.0040762536227703094, 0.03492236137390137, -0.006559048313647509, -0.025024792179465294, 0.003376139560714364, -0.004063867963850498, -0.022631371393799782, 0.0053978413343429565, 0.04367862641811371, 0.03973391279578209, -0.006396591663360596, -0.029752593487501144, 0.03966570273041725, 0.0010013347491621971, -0.0017857026541605592, 0.035874780267477036, 0.07586068660020828, -0.040670521557331085, -0.04545500874519348, -0.00692201592028141, 0.0341033972799778, -0.011941592209041119, 0.0002996449766214937, -0.012782735750079155, -0.016054147854447365, -0.047035977244377136, 0.04891834408044815, -0.05729221552610397, -0.03255569189786911, 0.014570729807019234, 0.021357381716370583, -0.0032973787747323513, 0.029643749818205833, 0.022142209112644196, -0.06708469241857529, 0.04604009911417961, -0.052523888647556305, 0.0738845095038414, 0.0039137620478868484, 0.05723540484905243, 0.024787716567516327, -0.006037645973265171, -0.008659865707159042, 0.024529777467250824, 0.03655904904007912, -0.04983799159526825, -0.049251049757003784, -0.007453392259776592, -0.0475405678153038, 0.0012101008323952556, 0.012889870442450047, 0.006339398678392172, 0.03353111818432808, -0.012006894685328007, -0.031825195997953415, 0.030257729813456535, -0.02624182216823101, 0.013067830353975296, 0.007123763207346201, 0.037362199276685715, -0.00741958525031805, 0.015397127717733383, -0.01889745332300663, 0.00877335388213396, -0.017194442451000214, 0.05568079650402069, 0.03779452666640282, 0.005832868628203869, -0.007516399025917053, 0.006502093747258186, 0.03998631238937378, 0.03114432841539383, -0.02831425704061985, 0.06703481078147888, -0.02044629119336605, 0.03025066666305065, 0.016801297664642334, -0.039316628128290176, -0.006444988306611776, 0.06399120390415192, -0.029418854042887688, -0.04079095646739006, 0.008040988817811012, -0.008325989358127117, 0.025308968499302864, -0.002529231598600745, -0.005110669881105423, -0.009175252169370651, -0.04191015288233757, 0.02662048488855362, 0.07376197725534439, -0.014343280345201492, 0.012851436622440815, -0.00809218268841505, 0.003819890320301056, -0.027756473049521446, -0.0013038309989497066, 0.011354335583746433, 0.03895096480846405, 0.008888725191354752, -0.004841223359107971, 0.03597855567932129, 0.04148763418197632, -0.009681330062448978, -0.04248936101794243, 0.05342504754662514, 0.07900574058294296, 0.054880548268556595, -0.0306440070271492, 0.03115227445960045, -0.03220869228243828, -0.07665981352329254, 0.030247371643781662, 0.01654185727238655, 0.008359738625586033, 0.0022355299443006516, 0.043341003358364105, -0.03280138969421387, -0.04340050742030144, 0.034283459186553955, 0.010024124756455421, 0.009917925111949444, -0.023354319855570793, -0.07935136556625366, -0.04903414100408554, 0.013660992495715618, -0.0007702647126279771, -0.027182532474398613, -0.06697124987840652, 0.02280285395681858, -0.0009806016460061073, 0.019741149619221687, 0.01606862246990204, 0.01698954403400421, -0.03038398176431656, 0.05702437087893486, 0.016285639256238937, -0.04716844484210014, -0.037131328135728836, -0.0378674753010273, -0.03366152197122574, -0.020972268655896187, -0.06266201287508011, 0.05217576026916504, 0.00921202264726162, 0.013586150482296944, -0.03659602254629135, 0.06357920914888382, 0.018053820356726646, -0.03148803487420082, 0.009247051551938057, 0.014856096357107162, -0.017195628955960274, 0.06971833109855652, 0.016363056376576424, 0.0305441003292799, 0.03132124990224838, 0.024468082934617996, 0.0067680892534554005, 0.018006684258580208, 0.05502764880657196, 0.01300695352256298, -0.05247712880373001, -0.016829097643494606, -0.059883084148168564, 0.04974546283483505, -0.02352879010140896, -0.0015295728808268905, -0.020288359373807907, 0.009783359244465828, -0.006367396097630262, 0.005937143228948116, 0.05258285999298096, 0.031152259558439255, -0.0026622742880135775, 0.031768959015607834, -0.06946876645088196, -0.04087773337960243, -0.03968752548098564, 0.013914108276367188, -0.023085175082087517, -0.05032492056488991, 0.06789959222078323, 0.03708839789032936, 0.024350596591830254, -0.03373730555176735, -0.017814064398407936, -0.03689007833600044, -0.02139727585017681, 0.009971276856958866, -0.033975325524806976, 0.01033529918640852, 0.040622562170028687, 0.04706548899412155, 0.007205293979495764, 0.05813570320606232, -0.040503621101379395, -0.05340905115008354, -0.02651306241750717, -0.061061516404151917, 0.008950629271566868, -0.026237409561872482, -0.003835307667031884, 0.000059177938965149224, 0.004607255570590496, -0.0021906299516558647, 0.009435187093913555, -0.05317593365907669, 0.05733126774430275, 0.0683324933052063, 0.036987707018852234, -0.005289193708449602, 0.008348366245627403, -0.0021521891467273235, -0.021924905478954315, -0.005490843206644058, -0.017933480441570282, -0.06182271987199783, -0.0341193787753582, 0.05549869313836098, 0.028091005980968475, -0.042881663888692856, 0.020482704043388367, 0.0633033886551857, 0.025738520547747612, -0.001882005832158029, 0.039654236286878586, -0.030074384063482285, -0.038012463599443436, 0.012313584797084332, 0.010755362920463085, -0.014045080170035362, 0.014085875824093819, 0.046362996101379395, 0.015432126820087433, 0.04444526880979538, -0.01580793410539627, 0.0024518780410289764, 0.02563411369919777, -0.049815986305475235, -0.0000952413392951712, -0.03610900789499283, -0.03463832288980484, 0.028720734640955925, -0.004178368952125311, -0.01956462487578392, 0.013402383774518967, -0.030396856367588043, 0.03042268380522728, -0.008721372112631798, -0.019444122910499573, 0.03403438255190849, 0.007067198399454355, -0.05320879444479942, -0.0358797125518322, 0.0303878765553236, -0.049688924103975296, 0.019886214286088943, -0.010250573977828026, -0.022262493148446083, -0.038351211696863174, 0.0023920019157230854, -0.0076233986765146255, 0.0008604959002695978, -0.0003122679190710187, 0.014725655317306519, 0.002671752357855439, -0.005112817045301199, -0.01319730281829834, 0.03164169192314148, 0.024432873353362083, -0.010043743997812271, 0.01720222271978855, -0.002356037963181734, 0.004793668165802956, 0.042844709008932114, 0.0059897867031395435, -0.003176997182890773, 0.005239241756498814, -0.02881326898932457, -0.040668535977602005, 0.010860448703169823, -0.011725702323019505, 0.0077701229602098465, -0.03606405854225159, 0.0014915926149114966, 0.043224483728408813, -0.019999101758003235, -0.02687135525047779, 0.019575292244553566, -0.04790419340133667, -0.020483428612351418, -0.06011955812573433, -0.02294887974858284, 0.023502858355641365, 0.0000024438181753794197, 0.03860751911997795, 0.012452357448637486, -0.0506967231631279, 0.006139788776636124, -0.07895749062299728, -0.05816381052136421, 0.03139648959040642, -0.024728601798415184, 0.021306710317730904, 0.008758476004004478, -0.03241679444909096, 0.04928813502192497, 0.043061986565589905, -0.03959721699357033, -0.01261813659220934, 0.005421443842351437, -0.06847338378429413, 0.009196998551487923, -0.005503047723323107, -0.007095377426594496, 0.005307877901941538, 0.012329335324466228, 0.012130538932979107, 0.021600738167762756, 0.029727648943662643, -0.0077351853251457214, 0.026087108999490738, 0.062438398599624634, 0.020810959860682487, -0.019996484741568565, 0.04870159551501274, 0.039688654243946075, -0.021110940724611282, 0.020803675055503845, 0.020673200488090515, -0.012281103059649467, 0.04727723076939583, -0.02248375304043293, 0.020625967532396317, -0.004738099407404661, -0.006604521535336971, -0.04337284341454506, 0.012417299672961235, -0.00451786071062088, -0.029320038855075836, 0.006982016377151012, 0.04504704102873802, 0.010095097124576569, -0.021171679720282555, -0.002664980012923479, 0.006534431595355272, 0.026950372382998466, -0.004123244900256395, -0.01013921294361353, 0.002614363795146346, -0.02772599831223488, 0.015526550821959972, -0.04490257427096367, -0.03897622600197792, 0.03598135709762573, 0.030541403219103813, 0.032111894339323044, -0.04370010644197464, -0.05515459552407265, -0.0037515645381063223, -0.044272955507040024, 0.006368620786815882, -0.016673922538757324, 0.04673724249005318, 0.031156620010733604, 0.02936352789402008, 0.017123514786362648, 0.017563920468091965, -0.01228968147188425, 0.006470701657235622, -0.07718008756637573, 0.032126810401678085, -0.024131106212735176, -0.01306502427905798, -0.014460377395153046, -0.00502146827057004, 0.05753965303301811, -0.020744668319821358, 0.02067606709897518, 0.027453450486063957, 0.03761691972613335, -0.012532233260571957, -0.052312321960926056, -0.036518581211566925, -0.05395808443427086, -0.006234930362552404, -0.03809128701686859, 0.031865283846855164, -0.019132163375616074, 0.05345673859119415, 0.033217526972293854, -0.024067791178822517, -0.02665434591472149, -0.007669111713767052, -0.005467509385198355, 0.032802335917949677, 0.03864170238375664, 0.0342392735183239, -0.010238345712423325, -0.033696357160806656, 0.03815873712301254, 0.004885618109256029, 0.10539350658655167, 0.03706945478916168, -0.01839342899620533, -0.019352376461029053, -0.046605292707681656, -0.003822206286713481, -0.01745433174073696, 0.01172728929668665, 0.02025260031223297, 0.012620597146451473, 0.055587731301784515, 0.01955152116715908, -0.029875313863158226, 0.023515647277235985, 0.06297958642244339, -0.006780515890568495, 0.018387004733085632, 0.003492390038445592, 0.004179496318101883, -0.02364228293299675, 0.028510108590126038, 0.01872790977358818, 0.00980814453214407, 0.021511290222406387, 0.022206256166100502, 0.03564846143126488, -0.038901738822460175, 0.005265696905553341, -0.04477445408701897, 0.03919435292482376, 0.051589831709861755, -0.03053443878889084, -0.0447433702647686, 0.0635136216878891, 0.017365915700793266, 0.06783579289913177, 0.025087527930736542, -0.010953008197247982, -0.05759536847472191, 0.033548712730407715, 0.05375273898243904, 0.024536289274692535, -0.007688460871577263, -0.02261616289615631, -0.07908332347869873, -0.011514653451740742, 0.06844110786914825, -0.01935660094022751, -0.0033414640929549932, -0.007681653369218111, 0.007181096822023392, -0.02223397232592106, -0.00355969718657434, -0.04594344645738602, 0.012227616272866726, 0.025085467845201492, 0.04561593756079674, -0.050680287182331085, -0.016834182664752007, -0.05814839154481888, 0.03371322527527809, 0.014768240973353386, 0.043500471860170364, 0.027561679482460022, -0.02690449170768261, 0.028230126947164536, -0.002426491118967533, 0.010603274218738079, -0.0466071180999279, 0.005502638407051563, -0.005434471648186445, 0.01982923410832882, 0.0137253412976861, 0.018993938341736794, -0.02285049669444561, 0.014312739484012127, -0.01804487593472004, -0.029474986717104912, -0.0000064695964283600915, -0.02289964258670807, 0.0368068628013134, 0.01348844077438116, 0.022532008588314056, 0.06343339383602142, 0.023887448012828827, 0.01925528049468994, 0.008032718673348427, -0.036871787160634995, 0.039925310760736465, -0.017997827380895615, -0.008191944099962711, -0.04654507711529732, -0.013796178624033928, -0.01746494509279728, 0.006933902390301228, 0.0151666896417737, 0.014126341789960861, -0.027550458908081055, 0.0015657152980566025, -0.004324142821133137, 0.04820236191153526, 0.013868075795471668, -0.010796665214002132, 0.01136211771517992, 0.016113821417093277, 0.019364597275853157, -0.021317914128303528, 0.05512396991252899, 0.008502339012920856, -0.004741162993013859, -0.0071419402956962585, -0.03082323633134365, 0.009870943613350391, -0.03256671130657196, -0.0044936202466487885, 0.015400368720293045, -0.0038027751725167036, 0.04057316109538078, 0.003458727151155472, 0.025574449449777603, 0.006832909770309925, -0.013827605172991753, -0.008887247182428837, 0.017444653436541557, -0.006664190907031298, 0.07095126062631607, -0.037384260445833206, 0.023029247298836708, -0.018396873027086258, -0.006855858024209738, -0.09111245721578598, -0.022845599800348282, 0.020788034424185753, -0.013985867612063885, -0.01930755376815796, -0.06388796865940094, 0.026471182703971863, -0.006133717950433493, -0.0011521438136696815, 0.007243415340781212, 0.07819811999797821, -0.008751039393246174, -0.024580487981438637, -0.013954617083072662, 0.04974674433469772, 0.048193372786045074, 0.02117241360247135, -0.029751284047961235, 0.008167874068021774, -0.0032179018016904593, -0.015706636011600494, 0.02250857651233673, 0.0012495707487687469, -0.016191083937883377, 0.005586481187492609, -0.022328155115246773, -0.02545573003590107, -0.018694644793868065, -0.009310568682849407, -0.02639611065387726, 0.0008711133268661797, 0.0013836477883160114, 0.00853139627724886, -0.01615479588508606, 0.0005591242806985974, -0.035995882004499435, 0.004496924579143524, -0.0054352423176169395, 0.0010369974188506603, 0.001562286983244121, -0.02548499032855034, 0.05406062304973602, -0.02138112112879753, 0.017283013090491295, 0.039707448333501816, 0.05304994806647301, -0.017667733132839203, 0.02048402465879917, 0.008641310036182404, 0.02213495410978794, 0.012306873686611652, -0.0328243225812912, -0.028302745893597603, 0.004648453090339899, 0.04112451523542404, -0.05057033523917198, -0.02132466249167919, -0.06072769686579704, -0.025891609489917755, 0.037303343415260315, -0.016029663383960724, 0.0651814192533493, 0.05301680043339729, 0.023648913949728012, -0.008670510724186897, -0.008891994133591652, -0.016214486211538315, -0.003792539704591036, -0.02781754918396473, 0.038082584738731384, 0.004300711210817099, 0.008622759953141212, 0.026368794962763786, 0.04765762388706207, -0.022352175787091255, 0.025327229872345924, -0.006779666058719158, 0.07572969049215317, 0.027351010590791702, -0.0126116331666708, -0.03895733132958412, 0.07960961014032364, -0.0399581640958786, 0.030578745529055595, -0.015219733119010925, -0.012628065422177315, 0.040631260722875595, 0.04330405965447426, -0.02156788855791092, -0.03619549795985222, -0.04502028971910477, -0.03955599665641785, 0.03631245344877243, 0.03976161777973175, -0.05092811584472656, 0.01999606005847454, -0.0030405933503061533, 0.026906663551926613, 0.0072973622009158134, 0.01805071532726288, -0.010008458979427814, -0.055293843150138855, -0.049714844673871994, -0.025902006775140762, -0.03318960964679718, 0.003988983575254679, 0.004527105018496513, -0.057707712054252625, 0.019178422167897224, -0.03722257539629936, 0.028211703523993492, 0.026204796507954597, -0.006093292962759733, -0.006732650566846132, 0.0610681027173996, -0.022468890994787216, -0.011859226040542126, -0.031112540513277054, -0.021968426182866096, 0.09930072724819183, 0.07192079722881317, 0.03152666240930557, -0.07537467777729034, -0.017685452476143837, -0.002828809432685375, 0.036124274134635925, -0.03726842254400253, 0.040089234709739685, 0.01360825914889574, 0.0007022016798146069, 0.02912444807589054, 0.04298948869109154, 0.02621881291270256, 0.013045110739767551, 0.04179587960243225, -0.017732664942741394, -0.017106428742408752, -0.02350105531513691, 0.0010249406332150102, -0.015684373676776886, -0.0017744448268786073, -0.030315686017274857, 0.018195847049355507, -0.00576539384201169, 0.001121732871979475, -0.003940175753086805, -0.004685711115598679, 0.01352707576006651, -0.0070214043371379375, -0.027918297797441483, 0.00854327529668808, 0.04959387704730034, -0.00024235169985331595, -0.01087113469839096, 0.003714669030159712, 0.009747606702148914, 0.004273903556168079, 0.0010388068621978164, -0.005690682679414749, 0.007103778887540102, 0.00031051808036863804, -0.004394152667373419, -0.009601186960935593, -0.021192699670791626, -0.04030630737543106, -0.045483093708753586, 0.03890769183635712, -0.023787176236510277, -0.01039431244134903, -0.01860097050666809, 0.027723724022507668, -0.014273525215685368, -0.03611156344413757, 0.000625853834208101, -0.0011778753250837326, 0.03214161843061447, -0.056010015308856964, -0.005340624134987593, -0.02991192787885666, 0.037215784192085266, -0.02418312057852745, 0.02541784755885601, 0.021734843030571938, -0.04266195744276047, 0.002610065508633852, -0.02259792760014534, 0.05214060842990875, -0.025262458249926567, -0.05883730947971344, 0.016351159662008286, -0.01570894382894039, -0.03534642606973648, -0.003962768241763115, 0.0032882760278880596, -0.03311561420559883, 0.01058780774474144, 0.0009142878116108477, 0.0058346157893538475, -0.038308028131723404, -0.0040679192170500755, 0.02467340975999832, -0.035091910511255264, -0.005607597064226866, -0.06929498165845871, -0.006529736332595348, 0.03765181824564934, 0.034467700868844986, 0.07891418784856796, 0.026071837171912193, -0.0041917674243450165, 0.022190198302268982, 0.027639131993055344, -0.04674483835697174, -0.01794118620455265, -0.012525882571935654, 0.018925925716757774, -0.0007117231143638492, -0.032139852643013, 0.03582073003053665, 0.03131859377026558, 0.031920965760946274, 0.00009860972932074219, 0.02499436028301716, -0.02457236684858799, 0.04961884766817093, -0.020347466692328453, -0.05039317533373833, 0.0008130006026476622, 0.025422146543860435, 0.008599820546805859, -0.01402802113443613, -0.052806783467531204, -0.05629146844148636, -0.002515599364414811, 0.0042240493930876255, 0.01337953470647335, -0.032859500497579575, -0.020407916978001595, -0.011381002143025398, 0.039244819432497025, -0.03841139003634453, -0.00862237811088562, -0.02664116956293583, -0.005794997327029705, -0.025742296129465103, -0.00656725512817502, 0.028095901012420654, -0.0071427179500460625, -0.014415709301829338, 0.008646328002214432, 0.02096242643892765, 0.00966342817991972, -0.007771889213472605, 0.0022327147889882326, 0.015770548954606056, 0.0002535145031288266, 0.029253894463181496, -0.02445557340979576, 0.0007715382962487638, 0.03278293088078499, -0.03413169085979462, -0.05549256503582001, -0.0012877925764769316, 0.014637145213782787, 0.011774943210184574, -0.003110916120931506, 0.009361251257359982, -0.03482824191451073, 0.0379982553422451, -0.012159010395407677, 0.020436329767107964, -0.02537469007074833, -0.015148449689149857, -0.0028437592554837465, -0.00733186025172472, 0.00004192191772744991, -0.002345296088606119, -0.02833859622478485, 0.04494389891624451, 0.016428470611572266, 0.017673924565315247, 0.029850758612155914, 0.02826373651623726, -0.008472870104014874, -0.005171386059373617, 0.02684522047638893, 0.01027997862547636, 0.04514630138874054, 0.05569746717810631, 0.01710350438952446, 0.029285229742527008, 0.0006451581139117479, 0.03564668074250221, -0.0698147565126419, -0.02391248755156994, 0.018248166888952255, -0.0009100331226363778, 0.024254435673356056, -0.061886195093393326, -0.02168678119778633, 0.03921819478273392, -0.054857879877090454, 0.024397455155849457, -0.011732094921171665, -0.026221003383398056, -0.03305503726005554, -0.0049123624339699745, -0.002672143280506134, 0.045849911868572235, 0.04634665697813034, 0.00401008315384388, 0.00962735339999199, 0.026778750121593475, 0.0029231130611151457, 0.010767514817416668, 0.023845424875617027, 0.04216213896870613, 0.016059542074799538, -0.06622979044914246, 0.08126043528318405, -0.0200313962996006, -0.014282350428402424, 0.03500810265541077, 0.018669022247195244, 0.011151996441185474, 0.004552419297397137, 0.010323691181838512, 0.013034663163125515, 0.05994941666722298, 0.04438156262040138, 0.015551809221506119, -0.030610041692852974, -0.012967628426849842, -0.0006828489131294191, 0.026889007538557053, -0.03156363591551781, 0.020735381171107292, 0.01427756529301405, -0.03599051758646965, -0.05862017348408699, 0.0009671624284237623, 0.02440497651696205, -0.004294700920581818, -0.00650439877063036, -0.00637208204716444, -0.009098961018025875, 0.02315295860171318, 0.044867679476737976, -0.053982555866241455, -0.012836551293730736, -0.0022032270208001137, 0.021661149337887764, -0.020931219682097435, 0.021681969985365868, -0.006802944466471672, -0.02229343354701996, 0.03998975455760956, 0.007067147642374039, -0.009833358228206635, -0.05044187232851982, -0.004141018260270357, -0.021478798240423203, -0.012511305510997772, -0.011931609362363815, -0.017165549099445343, -0.04176801070570946, 0.0583658404648304, -0.010820082388818264, -0.01474740169942379, 0.03997473418712616, -0.02298969030380249, -0.00786103866994381, -0.08739908784627914, 0.06890594959259033, -0.005534844938665628, -0.013194059021770954, -0.02047332003712654, 0.0157989040017128, -0.011260990053415298, -0.014957783743739128, 0.03008665330708027, 0.02195296809077263, 0.010143009014427662, 0.014293833635747433, 0.013931919820606709, -0.015880266204476357, -0.09064719825983047, 0.006207069847732782, -0.024271665140986443, -0.02254233881831169, -0.005600196309387684, -0.01435044128447771, 0.0075696357525885105, 0.003781456034630537, 0.01722235418856144, -0.02195165678858757, 0.016861679032444954, -0.009856324642896652, -0.00837781187146902, 0.052561890333890915, 0.0210588239133358, -0.018322739750146866, 0.03952318802475929, -0.01596793904900551, 0.018826516345143318, 0.010656685568392277, -0.014374854043126106, -0.040001124143600464, 0.03983926400542259, 0.005259035620838404, -0.04689210653305054, -0.008443896658718586, 0.006441627629101276, 0.003806241089478135, -0.06382034718990326, -0.016231026500463486, 0.019935352727770805, -0.05210030451416969, 0.007452641148120165, 0.03617238625884056, 0.027856595814228058, 0.06867042183876038, -0.0275169275701046, -0.0065599363297224045, 0.03252261504530907, 0.006483427248895168, -0.019000548869371414, -0.005203616805374622, 0.08336018025875092, -0.031002869829535484, -0.008582073263823986, 0.003093078499659896, -0.03218162804841995, 0.023821843788027763, -0.03036058135330677, 0.03620652109384537, -0.07015551626682281, -0.05045033618807793, 0.018140234053134918, -0.01103945355862379, 0.006542382296174765, -0.005708689801394939, -0.016268733888864517, 0.04751874879002571, -0.050356775522232056, -0.007126234006136656, -0.006340382620692253, -0.028111256659030914, -0.020303955301642418, 0.0032800983171910048, 0.009947512298822403, 0.010540544986724854, -0.0008174326503649354, 0.019878029823303223, 0.004440945107489824, -0.013720016926527023, 0.039545465260744095, -0.007878841832280159, 0.015640554949641228, -0.004000307526439428, -0.018644167110323906, 0.001561689074151218, 0.013656126335263252, -0.005757525563240051, -0.029341591522097588, 0.015554110519587994, 0.0321243479847908, 0.0006980555481277406, -0.017059365287423134, -0.047176945954561234, -0.010921791195869446, 0.030026689171791077, -0.07246018946170807, -0.012205705977976322, -0.03421778976917267, 0.02172367088496685, -0.005617149174213409, -0.013596152886748314 ]
<p>I'm doing one-way ANOVA power calculations (in R) for an RCBD trial with 15 groups, 3 blocks, and n = 3 per group. How is it possible that two different ANOVA models have exactly the same power even if the response variables are different? Even if the responses are somewhat related, I don't understand why the power is the same even to 7 significant figures. The fact that the power is very low makes sense. </p> <p>Here are the calculations for two possible responses:</p> <pre><code> groups = 15 n = 3 between.var = 0.3422844 within.var = 1.026853 sig.level = 0.01 power = 0.2162478 groups = 15 n = 3 between.var = 1.759788 within.var = 5.279365 sig.level = 0.01 power = 0.2162478 </code></pre>
28,476
[ -0.050131794065237045, 0.01943444274365902, -0.02391166239976883, -0.022058455273509026, 0.042481664568185806, 0.020813914015889168, -0.012507104314863682, -0.019315576180815697, 0.013637062162160873, -0.018756471574306488, 0.03399503976106644, 0.003535347990691662, 0.05000976845622063, -0.004179385956376791, 0.025740860030055046, -0.016329322010278702, -0.004204785451292992, 0.02572786435484886, 0.026873962953686714, 0.010682116262614727, -0.012086127884685993, 0.05734694004058838, -0.010700682178139687, -0.011876300908625126, -0.024390531703829765, 0.046619951725006104, 0.011396820656955242, -0.02362634800374508, 0.022637005895376205, 0.038775116205215454, -0.0010956856422126293, -0.020416170358657837, -0.01618134044110775, 0.02227621152997017, -0.008736765943467617, 0.01785357855260372, -0.010737525299191475, -0.006811332888901234, 0.018046995624899864, 0.03049802966415882, -0.0077909124083817005, -0.019969521090388298, -0.037163231521844864, 0.051526155322790146, -0.008372096344828606, 0.020643873140215874, -0.009985784068703651, -0.004956336226314306, 0.035617679357528687, -0.02773009054362774, 0.0659087598323822, 0.016619736328721046, 0.08203442394733429, 0.06835528463125229, -0.025770913809537888, -0.0047714137472212315, 0.07575396448373795, 0.07145634293556213, -0.011424446478486061, -0.08498718589544296, -0.0450461320579052, -0.0314265713095665, 0.02636805549263954, 0.020409120246767998, -0.039356380701065063, -0.009966346435248852, 0.0006423312006518245, -0.02144189551472664, 0.034150443971157074, 0.003958104643970728, 0.05493920296430588, 0.02090565487742424, 0.03283202648162842, -0.018184183165431023, 0.0006064350600354373, 0.014220496639609337, 0.030161583796143532, -0.00897951703518629, 0.04990502819418907, 0.04832998290657997, -0.038113679736852646, 0.026342332363128662, 0.0018117176368832588, 0.03426523506641388, 0.0056624868884682655, 0.0052541568875312805, 0.05176743119955063, -0.018519507721066475, 0.007465475704520941, 0.0036344127729535103, -0.044957276433706284, -0.017197078093886375, 0.06085538491606712, 0.00935162790119648, -0.012915987521409988, 0.022088296711444855, -0.026551643386483192, 0.004899417050182819, 0.009538963437080383, 0.012032330967485905, -0.02840052731335163, -0.01581694930791855, 0.021428242325782776, 0.013412746600806713, -0.004287122283130884, -0.004562762565910816, -0.017845317721366882, 0.0016398256411775947, 0.005430801305919886, 0.005396778229624033, 0.005497075617313385, 0.01636248640716076, -0.017790058627724648, -0.03211783245205879, 0.01776726543903351, -0.0664648488163948, -0.02893483079969883, -0.008592037484049797, 0.0925670936703682, 0.03256019949913025, 0.05222673714160919, -0.05005708336830139, -0.011507697403430939, -0.05193560943007469, -0.00860997848212719, -0.01470466423779726, -0.0016009698156267405, -0.01443969551473856, -0.053616464138031006, 0.0574541799724102, 0.03644225746393204, -0.01668069325387478, 0.017030702903866768, -0.013256842270493507, 0.06475049257278442, 0.0036098097916692495, -0.07404229789972305, -0.05096402391791344, 0.035862572491168976, -0.032641440629959106, -0.0033465283922851086, -0.041028767824172974, -0.008391449227929115, 0.009394519031047821, 0.0730195865035057, -0.017921343445777893, 0.030570155009627342, 0.022740459069609642, 0.027368798851966858, 0.008398264646530151, 0.027790049090981483, 0.016399338841438293, -0.027962401509284973, -0.03752729296684265, -0.010582503862679005, -0.09065654128789902, -0.0076638576574623585, -0.007099307607859373, -0.03913196176290512, -0.002420505741611123, 0.02295178361237049, 0.003467034315690398, 0.00660988362506032, -0.02427784726023674, 0.022963818162679672, 0.0065156626515090466, 0.05949874222278595, -0.04413450509309769, 0.01539425179362297, 0.04315352439880371, -0.018869031220674515, 0.03103921376168728, -0.02510801889002323, 0.053347207605838776, 0.017421577125787735, 0.0029805481899529696, -0.007259114645421505, -0.02365565113723278, 0.02483156882226467, 0.050027087330818176, -0.06243733689188957, 0.00710700498893857, -0.043253954499959946, -0.028779922053217888, 0.026742957532405853, 0.030775049701333046, -0.024636810645461082, 0.01803615689277649, 0.04361361265182495, -0.03203503042459488, -0.037245865911245346, -0.07249252498149872, 0.0007469009142369032, -0.011644168756902218, -0.03313351050019264, 0.019398432224988937, -0.0009730190504342318, 0.009363205172121525, 0.008126335218548775, 0.016621194779872894, -0.012314572930335999, 0.005069273058325052, 0.03261364996433258, -0.027033448219299316, 0.029199518263339996, 0.017031565308570862, 0.045939553529024124, -0.019786907359957695, 0.06391152739524841, -0.016373516991734505, -0.04482674226164818, 0.0313226543366909, -0.03815080225467682, -0.01601165533065796, -0.007010620553046465, -0.030361369252204895, 0.016604704782366753, 0.02941029891371727, -0.03085414133965969, 0.06598768383264542, -0.03216709569096565, 0.06316526979207993, 0.055449388921260834, 0.01040096115320921, -0.011038955301046371, 0.023599574342370033, -0.0033767609857022762, 0.053036242723464966, -0.04386133328080177, -0.03231966868042946, -0.039617445319890976, -0.013997525908052921, 0.025656212121248245, -0.0007719968562014401, -0.047469623386859894, 0.007861115969717503, 0.036811843514442444, 0.011833087541162968, 0.024925177916884422, 0.033174779266119, 0.03658910095691681, 0.017327919602394104, 0.01785319484770298, 0.039725665003061295, 0.007363573182374239, 0.015510900877416134, 0.029032057151198387, 0.030092479661107063, 0.05252937972545624, 0.031364358961582184, -0.00031657307408750057, 0.057102303951978683, 0.006902391090989113, -0.005678566638380289, -0.012760813347995281, 0.007930636405944824, 0.028704555705189705, -0.020728284493088722, 0.00406798068434, 0.025340961292386055, 0.006142609752714634, 0.003869373118504882, -0.0038312822580337524, -0.055686429142951965, 0.04613008350133896, 0.00910487212240696, -0.02527535893023014, -0.003999535925686359, -0.004881481174379587, -0.014981421642005444, 0.01964612305164337, -0.027331437915563583, -0.02149309776723385, -0.012599675916135311, 0.040848519653081894, 0.004323709290474653, 0.0066185579635202885, 0.04925146698951721, -0.0519157312810421, -0.011611809954047203, -0.03281951695680618, -0.011868529953062534, 0.04106961935758591, -0.0023389607667922974, -0.05207977071404457, -0.005968451499938965, -0.0461609847843647, 0.03450007364153862, 0.022795675322413445, -0.0259797852486372, -0.03373789042234421, 0.06891050189733505, 0.004531885497272015, -0.04827047511935234, -0.00229524914175272, -0.0352613739669323, 0.003878282383084297, 0.010867387987673283, -0.010242330841720104, 0.03923430293798447, 0.034519921988248825, -0.02909652516245842, 0.025006044656038284, -0.014500546269118786, 0.004333127290010452, 0.050609290599823, 0.008512988686561584, 0.005749109201133251, 0.008682160638272762, 0.05300507694482803, 0.009295090101659298, -0.05297437682747841, -0.05764523893594742, -0.04349100589752197, -0.046531710773706436, 0.0055143157951533794, 0.017434384673833847, 0.039565280079841614, -0.033735014498233795, -0.007509421557188034, 0.06795749068260193, 0.02226739376783371, -0.04287333786487579, -0.05008401721715927, -0.021158384159207344, -0.05786038935184479, -0.017042480409145355, 0.046680301427841187, 0.030991660431027412, -0.016831325367093086, 0.012366587296128273, -0.007055723108351231, 0.05094491317868233, 0.06566176563501358, -0.01726069115102291, -0.01797008328139782, 0.001204785192385316, 0.013803742825984955, -0.0070860665291547775, 0.03450353443622589, -0.02393471822142601, -0.011868172325193882, -0.0072465562261641026, 0.011277006939053535, 0.02060755155980587, -0.03006824105978012, -0.04265652596950531, -0.01278783194720745, -0.016940690577030182, 0.04441975802183151, -0.06142681464552879, 0.017414139583706856, 0.0026166357565671206, -0.030792053788900375, -0.00847315788269043, 0.04097721353173256, 0.037803079932928085, -0.04500029608607292, -0.00818974431604147, 0.03190647438168526, 0.0280753243714571, -0.012736423872411251, -0.04107978567481041, -0.020390070974826813, -0.0068467361852526665, 0.014339031651616096, -0.002276334213092923, 0.0055901044979691505, 0.024174010381102562, 0.01242882665246725, -0.01582840457558632, -0.029960885643959045, -0.031037038192152977, -0.018096622079610825, -0.047521963715553284, 0.03548645228147507, -0.054853297770023346, 0.020581208169460297, -0.00695027643814683, 0.06980758160352707, -0.01223156601190567, -0.027151646092534065, -0.02397000603377819, -0.021763164550065994, -0.02242523431777954, 0.03628014028072357, 0.0006593986763618886, -0.017680075019598007, 0.007378759328275919, -0.02186805196106434, -0.0016915724845603108, -0.016225406900048256, 0.013619043864309788, -0.0012299176305532455, 0.00993760023266077, 0.004102565813809633, -0.026936691254377365, -0.0431203693151474, 0.005010279826819897, -0.01846117153763771, 0.05879930034279823, 0.002613038057461381, -0.036733657121658325, 0.02758885733783245, -0.012300561182200909, -0.009324779734015465, -0.0283356923609972, -0.02086121402680874, -0.014161857776343822, 0.050004541873931885, 0.0560358427464962, 0.04484006389975548, 0.044415317475795746, -0.029677318409085274, 0.026353830471634865, 0.005094519350677729, 0.0195141714066267, 0.0511946864426136, -0.01025364175438881, -0.016163578256964684, -0.03244207426905632, -0.0130905881524086, 0.002346194814890623, 0.01974845491349697, -0.006156512536108494, 0.01252963487058878, 0.026456888765096664, 0.017625058069825172, -0.055269088596105576, 0.0037357970140874386, 0.02280838042497635, 0.029547307640314102, -0.03373892605304718, -0.030795173719525337, 0.016242798417806625, -0.023259462788701057, -0.03899553045630455, 0.01030217856168747, 0.0020518782548606396, 0.009153705090284348, -0.01437362376600504, 0.029049603268504143, -0.02008761093020439, -0.022740762680768967, -0.00905986875295639, 0.02124331332743168, 0.023638848215341568, -0.014430650509893894, -0.030675197020173073, -0.01626487635076046, 0.0378350205719471, 0.02509629726409912, 0.01756458729505539, 0.017518077045679092, -0.06925579905509949, -0.012536788359284401, 0.02015497162938118, 0.04564360901713371, -0.03328805789351463, -0.006336502730846405, 0.0037586428225040436, 0.0002640406310092658, 0.012816906906664371, -0.07172814011573792, 0.06475558131933212, -0.018984517082571983, 0.011259297840297222, -0.04863211140036583, -0.007401502691209316, -0.03388526290655136, -0.015225314535200596, -0.009525801986455917, 0.013610129244625568, 0.003303570207208395, -0.007112408056855202, -0.024360449984669685, -0.010086898691952229, 0.04199831932783127, 0.01933201216161251, -0.060557231307029724, 0.0017484843265265226, 0.032058000564575195, 0.0456557497382164, -0.00703075248748064, -0.034536488354206085, 0.0640961229801178, -0.031644150614738464, -0.0014032900799065828, 0.0701230987906456, -0.04270808398723602, -0.04164833575487137, 0.014633175916969776, -0.011564365588128567, 0.013238994404673576, -0.038407549262046814, -0.00783497653901577, 0.034574080258607864, 0.03068082593381405, -0.008629673160612583, 0.05297901853919029, 0.034219276160001755, 0.002686968771740794, -0.022597508504986763, -0.051204707473516464, 0.032599471509456635, -0.0040496657602488995, -0.06581159681081772, -0.038199618458747864, -0.01337882038205862, -0.004365849774330854, 0.0472012422978878, 0.017406068742275238, 0.04736531898379326, -0.026655791327357292, -0.011176088824868202, 0.02840530127286911, 0.018019873648881912, 0.02591809630393982, 0.0050867279060184956, 0.02030133083462715, 0.014552065171301365, -0.0036349643487483263, -0.03168550133705139, 0.019227242097258568, -0.003863584715873003, -0.0012827746104449034, 0.0030150418169796467, -0.05562099441885948, 0.01891983114182949, 0.004442112520337105, -0.026754092425107956, 0.0040385182946920395, -0.05933687463402748, -0.010422689840197563, -0.014082885347306728, 0.011348600499331951, -0.01358247920870781, -0.0597759485244751, -0.01294236071407795, 0.017706971615552902, -0.01615314558148384, 0.020464569330215454, -0.004074924625456333, 0.028104858472943306, 0.0022132459562271833, -0.02848968282341957, -0.07968562096357346, -0.024578645825386047, 0.022086208686232567, 0.02000907063484192, 0.004842550493776798, -0.009652473963797092, -0.022407913580536842, 0.0084238201379776, -0.02764967642724514, -0.05058496445417404, 0.06118761748075485, -0.018560100346803665, -0.013540013693273067, -0.010044949129223824, 0.010026575066149235, 0.0746375247836113, -0.0013194397324696183, -0.016385842114686966, 0.006566799711436033, -0.03298842906951904, -0.005232957191765308, 0.009436565451323986, 0.0057487040758132935, -0.013817568309605122, -0.005700097419321537, -0.03013213910162449, 0.008158906362950802, 0.06285115331411362, -0.035171106457710266, -0.02689756639301777, 0.00909788440912962, -0.009118696674704552, 0.02255832776427269, -0.03921162709593773, -0.00195320718921721, -0.0009909889195114374, 0.030876532196998596, -0.05305388942360878, -0.015394971705973148, -0.03254406154155731, -0.0010242711286991835, 0.007373294793069363, -0.01808232069015503, -0.0044062165543437, 0.007450159173458815, 0.09044800698757172, -0.019517937675118446, 0.016662495210766792, -0.01967446692287922, -0.020285101607441902, 0.03831561654806137, 0.010643805377185345, 0.0022387250792235136, -0.00935067143291235, 0.03520528972148895, -0.0324099026620388, -0.008490702137351036, -0.036832474172115326, 0.00926031544804573, 0.05725570023059845, 0.01779618300497532, 0.04481755569577217, 0.046994294971227646, -0.03144971653819084, -0.012128709815442562, -0.014982025139033794, -0.02855057269334793, -0.020405085757374763, 0.03497825935482979, 0.08061464130878448, -0.04152010753750801, -0.04066399484872818, 0.033569950610399246, 0.015382504090666771, 0.042050961405038834, 0.0498388446867466, 0.049856867641210556, 0.009986314922571182, 0.003921999596059322, 0.02630550041794777, -0.017652196809649467, 0.04437350854277611, -0.022838838398456573, 0.019691381603479385, -0.025404784828424454, 0.00842283945530653, 0.04812489449977875, 0.029650790616869926, -0.011362679302692413, -0.06450727581977844, -0.028611404821276665, -0.054148584604263306, -0.011540870182216167, 0.030919251963496208, -0.002238477347418666, -0.008345176465809345, 0.028561390936374664, 0.03399225324392319, -0.01486121490597725, 0.043813712894916534, -0.04463585466146469, -0.05087597295641899, -0.02271578647196293, -0.004434326663613319, -0.020991263911128044, 0.06347663700580597, -0.022620491683483124, -0.023799864575266838, 0.009364711120724678, -0.04135029390454292, 0.009241336025297642, -0.024602361023426056, 0.009287596680223942, 0.016448315232992172, 0.05600442364811897, 0.006042830646038055, 0.0436607226729393, 0.019207961857318878, -0.01238623820245266, 0.09683433920145035, 0.06230739504098892, 0.013874083757400513, -0.058909617364406586, 0.0637657642364502, -0.013557574711740017, 0.0020194631069898605, -0.036494653671979904, -0.005529362242668867, 0.010767006315290928, -0.010813003405928612, 0.06205366551876068, 0.06786436587572098, 0.04073082655668259, 0.014927941374480724, 0.03784557431936264, -0.005932768806815147, -0.03403284773230553, 0.021636558696627617, 0.010506081394851208, 0.009479113854467869, -0.04565794765949249, -0.0007401244947686791, 0.018781855702400208, 0.02473849430680275, -0.016782620921730995, -0.018296601250767708, -0.008748089894652367, 0.00014776951866224408, 0.0048062182031571865, -0.024602359160780907, 0.015961335971951485, -0.004043981898576021, 0.009057060815393925, -0.028277451172471046, 0.0038170740008354187, 0.018494807183742523, -0.03442755341529846, 0.014462986961007118, 0.025750884786248207, -0.012973446398973465, 0.01107669435441494, -0.006766953971236944, 0.024534711614251137, -0.0549505241215229, -0.03759600222110748, -0.004047313705086708, 0.000340562459314242, 0.009244686923921108, -0.02010185830295086, -0.01938731037080288, 0.027482951059937477, -0.029483702033758163, -0.037455350160598755, -0.050512101501226425, 0.02551206387579441, 0.01894434168934822, -0.06847364455461502, -0.043960314244031906, -0.030641742050647736, 0.005284297280013561, -0.015627793967723846, 0.027421358972787857, 0.018723279237747192, -0.041006844490766525, -0.013035355135798454, -0.05620443820953369, 0.06098193675279617, -0.012620910070836544, 0.0029771847184747458, 0.015629736706614494, -0.0032021591905504465, -0.009896303527057171, 0.012348153628408909, 0.007651946507394314, 0.02535201981663704, 0.020714523270726204, -0.005823270883411169, 0.00012126342335250229, -0.041993655264377594, -0.044153131544589996, 0.023788783699274063, -0.021564271301031113, 0.004369421862065792, -0.02906404435634613, -0.013140927068889141, 0.024520788341760635, 0.028883013874292374, 0.027691690251231194, 0.01162633579224348, -0.021073859184980392, 0.017216738313436508, 0.0349155068397522, -0.08289948850870132, -0.02136029303073883, 0.020250095054507256, -0.05120638757944107, -0.02773764729499817, 0.0034416918642818928, 0.036282770335674286, 0.0018006974132731557, 0.01614425703883171, -0.009520826861262321, 0.03730006515979767, -0.028174052014946938, -0.012327870354056358, -0.0008104759035632014, -0.05627043545246124, 0.037112586200237274, 0.008976590819656849, 0.004272963851690292, -0.009570561349391937, 0.004251496400684118, -0.042628128081560135, -0.029420169070363045, 0.024480238556861877, -0.031094996258616447, 0.011065973900258541, -0.04678977280855179, -0.01421334408223629, 0.0005820320802740753, -0.015115924179553986, -0.002523391740396619, -0.05596516281366348, 0.015626590698957443, -0.015838364139199257, -0.010565322823822498, -0.015171285718679428, 0.018780384212732315, -0.025808947160840034, 0.004620005842298269, 0.04127355292439461, -0.007692541927099228, 0.03062896430492401, -0.043827157467603683, 0.014861672185361385, -0.001956269843503833, 0.06501993536949158, 0.01817447319626808, -0.03847614675760269, 0.05605974793434143, -0.05133930221199989, -0.07783554494380951, 0.013446244411170483, 0.009522456675767899, 0.031941499561071396, 0.03446195647120476, -0.015065306797623634, -0.03671139106154442, 0.05202646180987358, -0.024572690948843956, -0.02846452407538891, -0.010405777022242546, 0.0192713662981987, 0.016009574756026268, -0.012392616830766201, 0.009280109778046608, 0.02655770815908909, -0.0050000823102891445, 0.0582546591758728, 0.04935990273952484, 0.006257542874664068, -0.028558170422911644, 0.011407963931560516, -0.003846018575131893, 0.015641381964087486, -0.00014640552399214357, 0.017533868551254272, 0.026275012642145157, 0.063385009765625, -0.03946307674050331, 0.03004220314323902, -0.02268240414559841, 0.03354164958000183, -0.05730866640806198, -0.03490235656499863, -0.014436658471822739, 0.0022683024872094393, 0.025818955153226852, -0.05531275272369385, 0.013587997294962406, 0.030678365379571915, -0.074100062251091, -0.004648224916309118, -0.037189729511737823, 0.00257062423042953, -0.03439192846417427, 0.019181784242391586, -0.009248410351574421, 0.01000438816845417, 0.012549355626106262, 0.029799290001392365, 0.0220356248319149, 0.012055552564561367, -0.01696026138961315, -0.024486813694238663, -0.032871343195438385, 0.02603580802679062, 0.02388734556734562, -0.061238180845975876, 0.022090191021561623, -0.010969272814691067, -0.03485706448554993, 0.00723810400813818, -0.045277323573827744, -0.006350670475512743, 0.0175632331520319, 0.028288593515753746, 0.01908930018544197, 0.06970392912626266, 0.031204136088490486, -0.007221869193017483, -0.008512817323207855, -0.012576054781675339, 0.018680008128285408, 0.007570067886263132, 0.0014594396343454719, -0.0038949446752667427, 0.05290525034070015, -0.02301289327442646, 0.008531387895345688, 0.009988765232264996, -0.0017580778803676367, -0.05202076584100723, 0.0144529202952981, 0.00047906755935400724, 0.010031458921730518, -0.048291947692632675, 0.0004412214329931885, -0.046671587973833084, -0.006915409117937088, 0.05961132049560547, 0.02128424681723118, -0.02832258678972721, 0.02991109900176525, -0.011721067130565643, -0.016849353909492493, 0.007380930241197348, 0.02617076225578785, -0.00011094491492258385, -0.028925135731697083, -0.012201866135001183, 0.008438128046691418, -0.01914222724735737, -0.03137217462062836, -0.023968489840626717, -0.049671828746795654, 0.025569461286067963, -0.0010079428320750594, 0.020114364102482796, -0.009317709133028984, -0.02120971865952015, -0.010700979270040989, -0.11972496658563614, 0.05792691186070442, -0.010715271346271038, -0.021311890333890915, -0.06851143389940262, 0.0271734818816185, -0.025863541290163994, 0.021600445732474327, 0.06658682227134705, 0.024844713509082794, -0.002198726637288928, 0.02403402514755726, 0.02600632607936859, -0.010460777208209038, -0.04503666236996651, 0.03606995567679405, 0.030408989638090134, -0.00036885536974295974, 0.000614076154306531, -0.003726938972249627, 0.00526580773293972, 0.046356022357940674, -0.024453526362776756, -0.03356921672821045, -0.008360081352293491, -0.00777727784588933, -0.002462453907355666, 0.050092533230781555, -0.00614203792065382, -0.024986494332551956, 0.0466633066534996, 0.0034103633370250463, 0.002984705613926053, 0.03615780547261238, 0.04575898498296738, -0.022699495777487755, 0.023563923314213753, -0.021436436101794243, -0.013933793641626835, 0.006511931773275137, 0.02197312004864216, 0.019390152767300606, -0.047758642584085464, -0.007180908229202032, 0.04135388508439064, -0.02510496787726879, -0.00516521604731679, 0.04689587280154228, 0.038129281252622604, -0.0032277777791023254, 0.029826108366250992, 0.018940964713692665, -0.012018551118671894, 0.017943130806088448, 0.004140627104789019, 0.024740971624851227, 0.040474094450473785, 0.02239295281469822, -0.02142333798110485, 0.027661068364977837, -0.022056538611650467, 0.03343112766742706, -0.026291707530617714, 0.03961213305592537, -0.0014331964775919914, -0.028734711930155754, -0.004971946589648724, -0.020606856793165207, 0.025128087028861046, -0.012576412409543991, -0.018049899488687515, 0.0772201269865036, -0.029245179146528244, 0.012747521512210369, 0.005416864063590765, 0.004026136826723814, 0.02004542201757431, -0.01962578482925892, 0.03021104633808136, 0.024752886965870857, 0.014369138516485691, 0.004734872840344906, 0.01240856759250164, -0.04502156376838684, -0.022990629076957703, -0.027234194800257683, 0.026495030149817467, -0.025366676971316338, -0.013350758701562881, -0.05701269954442978, -0.0029490136075764894, -0.051223933696746826, -0.03283432498574257, 0.05576959624886513, 0.011879839934408665, 0.0281141996383667, -0.030284954234957695, -0.0583345964550972, 0.0380840003490448, 0.07546333968639374, -0.05940082296729088, -0.04003371298313141, -0.0030838893726468086, 0.006015086080878973, -0.00494959345087409, 0.01545773632824421 ]
<p>I'm reading up on the Guass-Markov theorem on <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gauss%E2%80%93Markov_theorem" rel="nofollow">wikipedia</a>, and I was hoping somebody could help me figure out the main point of the theorem.</p> <p>We assume a linear model, in matrix form, is given by: $$ y = X\beta +\eta $$ and we're looking for the BLUE, $ \widehat\beta $.</p> <p>In accordance with <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Errors_and_residuals_in_statistics" rel="nofollow">this</a>, I would label $\eta = y - X\beta$ the "residual" and $\varepsilon = \widehat\beta - \beta$ the "error". (I.e the opposite of the usage on the Gauss-Markov page).</p> <p>The OLS (ordinary least-squares) estimator may be derived as the argmin of $||\text{residual}||_2^2 = ||\eta||_2^2$. </p> <p>Now, let $\mathbb{E}$ denote the expectation operator. To my understanding, what the Gauss-Markov theorem tells us is that, if $\mathbb{E}(\eta) = 0$ and $\text{Var}(\eta) = \sigma^2 I $, then the argmin, over all linear, unbiased estimators, of $\mathbb{E}(||\text{error}||_2^2) = \mathbb{E} (||\varepsilon||_2^2)$ is given by the same expression as the OLS estimator. </p> <p>I.e. $$ \text{argmin}_{\text{} \widehat\beta(y)} \, ||\eta||_2^2 \;=\; (X'X)^{-1}X'y \;=\; \text{argmin}_{\text{linear, unbiased } \widehat\beta(y)} \, \mathbb{E}(||\varepsilon||_2^2)$$</p> <p>Is my understanding correct? And if so, would you say that it deserves more prominent emphasis in the article?</p>
45,561
[ -0.005071710795164108, -0.0278770811855793, 0.02241571992635727, -0.010362764820456505, 0.03205582872033119, 0.014940551482141018, -0.009419352747499943, -0.04262290522456169, 0.005278772674500942, -0.042764123529195786, 0.034583669155836105, 0.023112380877137184, 0.08895796537399292, 0.050536494702100754, 0.019949082285165787, 0.01623975671827793, -0.0383002944290638, 0.0011661943281069398, -0.0004108327557332814, 0.009894751943647861, 0.015588663518428802, 0.020429443567991257, -0.031032610684633255, 0.004481772892177105, -0.05232170596718788, 0.026425229385495186, 0.04169974848628044, 0.011839864775538445, 0.023056956008076668, 0.07558809965848923, -0.05173303931951523, -0.021728159859776497, 0.019199762493371964, 0.012648668140172958, 0.016705729067325592, 0.015497221611440182, -0.020114928483963013, -0.001187903922982514, -0.006161015015095472, 0.038919564336538315, -0.037321627140045166, -0.01939789392054081, -0.03148246183991432, 0.05856300890445709, -0.011733263731002808, -0.0018948162905871868, 0.0404767282307148, -0.017152875661849976, 0.02899300679564476, -0.030972370877861977, 0.07403238117694855, -0.044485267251729965, -0.021490123122930527, 0.0024092900566756725, -0.01150601264089346, 0.006188519299030304, -0.004733975976705551, 0.012813528999686241, 0.019910434260964394, -0.0370769239962101, 0.023028399795293808, 0.007698756642639637, 0.026166610419750214, -0.0393671877682209, -0.010871070437133312, -0.005591533146798611, 0.05289733037352562, -0.03166165202856064, 0.04077087715268135, 0.024026431143283844, -0.013762625865638256, 0.036627087742090225, 0.016738150268793106, -0.016646919772028923, 0.05458313226699829, -0.004839626606553793, -0.011841107159852982, 0.00856215599924326, 0.030933985486626625, 0.0006216404144652188, 0.011556075885891914, 0.01394021138548851, 0.007248342037200928, 0.0421113520860672, 0.02391018532216549, 0.00854236539453268, 0.050885654985904694, -0.04686923325061798, 0.03460201993584633, -0.005628416780382395, 0.009513874538242817, 0.010766665451228619, 0.02555183880031109, 0.006546917371451855, -0.030861051753163338, 0.05023285001516342, 0.00866146944463253, 0.04061511904001236, 0.00034846560447476804, 0.005758197046816349, -0.0033569016959518194, -0.05271122604608536, -0.002226768061518669, 0.04572965204715729, -0.011310852132737637, -0.033178701996803284, 0.026028357446193695, 0.007678730878978968, -0.032706864178180695, -0.06991403549909592, -0.08214151859283447, 0.028023412451148033, -0.03281932696700096, 0.04889557510614395, 0.01980024389922619, 0.009176294319331646, 0.02156999334692955, 0.023501142859458923, -0.0014181461883708835, 0.07695019245147705, 0.031591229140758514, -0.00005850828529219143, 0.026136375963687897, -0.017100227996706963, -0.05070012807846069, 0.057468947023153305, 0.028741875663399696, -0.02708621323108673, -0.0711650401353836, 0.062375009059906006, 0.016117341816425323, -0.018071644008159637, 0.02548963762819767, 0.05565279349684715, 0.01826116442680359, -0.026894202455878258, -0.11266204714775085, -0.07873620092868805, 0.029584914445877075, 0.02303966134786606, 0.022520573809742928, -0.06716889142990112, -0.030250370502471924, 0.033136170357465744, 0.05369049310684204, 0.0007403101189993322, 0.04233983904123306, -0.00296736229211092, -0.0018267278792336583, 0.0057688201777637005, -0.027505135163664818, -0.017251530662178993, -0.04282538592815399, -0.020946383476257324, -0.009902918711304665, -0.07486075162887573, 0.012316274456679821, 0.021171506494283676, -0.035016629844903946, 0.005043316166847944, 0.021076515316963196, 0.015539112500846386, -0.04477233067154884, -0.02892596460878849, -0.018984075635671616, -0.05719485878944397, 0.07790958881378174, 0.015059366822242737, 0.03335684537887573, 0.034944988787174225, -0.033231914043426514, 0.017398709431290627, 0.014235051348805428, 0.07328137010335922, 0.03984794393181801, -0.016933687031269073, -0.018559254705905914, -0.0460483655333519, -0.01649264618754387, 0.034098632633686066, -0.07838930934667587, -0.022250274196267128, -0.009111718274652958, -0.0015822965651750565, -0.021664563566446304, 0.01709083467721939, 0.03226223587989807, 0.032581865787506104, 0.050244953483343124, -0.04360732436180115, -0.008602865040302277, -0.04015509784221649, 0.044508859515190125, 0.003727185307070613, -0.017475111410021782, 0.018035022541880608, -0.0002079644618788734, -0.028766002506017685, 0.0036903901491314173, 0.006734785158187151, -0.008905722759664059, 0.03490762412548065, 0.02999798394739628, -0.024926045909523964, 0.02729852683842182, 0.05161060765385628, 0.04912121966481209, 0.03454739600419998, 0.047398488968610764, -0.05092552304267883, -0.016074802726507187, 0.018228648230433464, 0.018731744959950447, 0.032388582825660706, -0.010040320456027985, -0.04301274195313454, -0.0021509716752916574, -0.016828160732984543, -0.027983803302049637, -0.01641140691936016, -0.07850886881351471, 0.025556016713380814, 0.09388598054647446, -0.0016872353153303266, -0.004631492309272289, 0.021975809708237648, 0.013596945442259312, 0.009355466812849045, -0.03649415075778961, 0.04230032488703728, -0.00030019620317034423, -0.015099743381142616, 0.024459833279252052, 0.031827326864004135, -0.012113279663026333, 0.031069517135620117, 0.03219054266810417, 0.020472850650548935, -0.008842811919748783, 0.01997196674346924, 0.00897381640970707, -0.021978287026286125, 0.011528730392456055, -0.018162524327635765, 0.007827652618288994, 0.043060675263404846, -0.010684738866984844, 0.0025947745889425278, 0.06926227360963821, -0.01326811220496893, -0.018076961860060692, 0.03229255974292755, -0.0008082673884928226, 0.019318167120218277, -0.026618411764502525, 0.0200740285217762, 0.03678017854690552, -0.00440551433712244, 0.03645484521985054, 0.012133111245930195, -0.018446192145347595, 0.004317731596529484, -0.033867668360471725, -0.0170675590634346, 0.02348613552749157, -0.019658301025629044, -0.038035646080970764, 0.0006158071919344366, 0.02748824656009674, -0.010279189795255661, -0.015869015827775, 0.009165388531982899, -0.03869471326470375, -0.037835948169231415, -0.0026104673743247986, 0.007572859525680542, 0.04032982140779495, -0.03506927564740181, -0.01642267033457756, -0.015416670590639114, -0.009569026529788971, -0.02237331122159958, 0.027665214613080025, 0.01314800139516592, -0.02837204374372959, 0.005002601072192192, -0.01275212224572897, 0.0215812586247921, 0.02487507276237011, -0.006103192921727896, -0.017681721597909927, 0.02954336628317833, 0.007332949433475733, -0.027941996231675148, -0.043939199298620224, -0.026634173467755318, -0.055124782025814056, -0.059356316924095154, -0.03998083621263504, 0.020870018750429153, -0.0222336258739233, -0.03204856067895889, 0.04285988584160805, -0.05642315000295639, -0.03978662192821503, -0.06460032612085342, -0.008915320970118046, 0.03437487408518791, -0.020754005759954453, 0.03329479321837425, -0.006484854035079479, 0.014011933468282223, -0.007153369951993227, -0.05279630795121193, -0.03788751736283302, 0.019741516560316086, -0.035219259560108185, -0.003586371662095189, 0.011013922281563282, -0.021794894710183144, 0.09555771946907043, 0.002733385656028986, -0.007729560136795044, -0.006188396364450455, 0.014137082733213902, 0.008394444361329079, -0.042732059955596924, 0.005447831936180592, -0.015469953417778015, -0.0009008878841996193, 0.02544795721769333, -0.038982417434453964, 0.025394869968295097, 0.04078778624534607, -0.0019374237162992358, 0.021405329927802086, -0.030472658574581146, -0.05278026685118675, -0.019312698394060135, 0.04676214978098869, 0.04249635338783264, 0.0027554796542972326, 0.02672496624290943, 0.02206215262413025, 0.04518476501107216, 0.012365845963358879, -0.03806164115667343, 0.025079065933823586, -0.02526467852294445, -0.029071331024169922, -0.014453916810452938, 0.057671837508678436, 0.009529015980660915, -0.009282603859901428, 0.0057372464798390865, -0.0026285802014172077, 0.011400792747735977, -0.032304465770721436, 0.0014011895982548594, 0.01199409831315279, 0.06167338043451309, 0.003496341174468398, 0.004043117631226778, -0.025823311880230904, -0.0034754551015794277, 0.03573143854737282, -0.05071142688393593, -0.04587843269109726, 0.05326097458600998, 0.057671405375003815, -0.023966852575540543, 0.018805107101798058, -0.026568681001663208, -0.021385403349995613, -0.050640642642974854, 0.02121588960289955, 0.020258326083421707, 0.045974861830472946, -0.021563060581684113, 0.031052561476826668, -0.009256884455680847, -0.022200530394911766, 0.045526765286922455, -0.0031976280733942986, -0.06144773215055466, -0.02082003280520439, 0.020411740988492966, -0.038724277168512344, 0.04855866730213165, -0.05939020961523056, 0.06124959513545036, -0.043256308883428574, 0.004062683787196875, -0.056782566010951996, 0.04366369545459747, -0.04086654260754585, 0.031415775418281555, -0.03233872726559639, -0.01494732964783907, -0.0005858888034708798, -0.012018772773444653, 0.0011878962395712733, 0.008391779847443104, -0.020105136558413506, 0.02694798819720745, -0.026027046144008636, -0.0003783876891247928, -0.009588141925632954, 0.016507018357515335, 0.04493860900402069, 0.04319841414690018, 0.02039758674800396, 0.052384935319423676, -0.0066924672573804855, -0.00444512814283371, -0.017642410472035408, 0.0745866522192955, 0.01711214892566204, 0.00715991435572505, 0.0027723931707441807, -0.018784621730446815, -0.022997843101620674, -0.0315963476896286, 0.03932768851518631, 0.011880963109433651, -0.007545336615294218, 0.060887470841407776, 0.021762441843748093, -0.014775303192436695, 0.04981309548020363, 0.04490296542644501, -0.00005752453216700815, 0.0343124158680439, -0.0245214831084013, -0.00417523505166173, 0.011840283870697021, 0.0049860128201544285, 0.015525182709097862, -0.025082526728510857, -0.022281235083937645, -0.04185998812317848, 0.02966737560927868, 0.01943136937916279, 0.007550204172730446, -0.01464249286800623, 0.0567711666226387, -0.004738407209515572, -0.005827074404805899, -0.030165843665599823, 0.012234999798238277, 0.011016428470611572, 0.04756069928407669, 0.044261328876018524, 0.005967848934233189, -0.07406101375818253, -0.01537296362221241, 0.026469456031918526, 0.01193517167121172, 0.004115861374884844, 0.009215784259140491, -0.007257204037159681, -0.03508876636624336, 0.00012325207353569567, 0.012430732138454914, 0.030033797025680542, 0.016397830098867416, 0.013781913556158543, -0.008374602533876896, -0.038665033876895905, -0.013693919405341148, -0.02109583094716072, -0.007914749905467033, 0.012438038364052773, -0.010562609881162643, -0.03351942449808121, -0.05092884972691536, -0.017458485439419746, 0.0062187048606574535, 0.0430733859539032, -0.03717964142560959, 0.009178253822028637, 0.006296657491475344, 0.0698113664984703, -0.04387432336807251, -0.05192124843597412, 0.029520131647586823, 0.00463453121483326, -0.01165874395519495, 0.037792280316352844, 0.033634163439273834, -0.02863554283976555, 0.018128717318177223, 0.030578915029764175, -0.021027052775025368, 0.019096562638878822, -0.00022527502733282745, 0.06548753380775452, 0.03895146772265434, 0.03348221257328987, 0.06012066453695297, -0.002580115105956793, 0.03846593201160431, -0.0013814292615279555, -0.028651760891079903, 0.035925157368183136, -0.032683152705430984, -0.0017459975788369775, -0.029096068814396858, 0.006955498829483986, -0.006449988577514887, 0.010165414772927761, -0.014612657949328423, 0.058891668915748596, -0.0038425337988883257, -0.054982855916023254, 0.004293906502425671, 0.02465774677693844, -0.0236606877297163, -0.00016507298278156668, -0.040222398936748505, 0.0439753383398056, -0.010786696337163448, 0.0055033136159181595, 0.03844521939754486, -0.03200162574648857, -0.013269244693219662, 0.016316363587975502, -0.015591677278280258, 0.027546867728233337, -0.04524840787053108, -0.028336869552731514, -0.021379100158810616, -0.020476728677749634, 0.01895863749086857, -0.004865276161581278, 0.025096306577324867, -0.020897982642054558, -0.007361144293099642, -0.07089325040578842, 0.016921740025281906, -0.01536421850323677, 0.021025078371167183, -0.014882707968354225, -0.00401699123904109, 0.030109407380223274, 0.011032105423510075, -0.06597492843866348, -0.03240290656685829, 0.027378063648939133, 0.004994981922209263, -0.022605834528803825, 0.007836838252842426, -0.02419593185186386, -0.010362940840423107, -0.003017059061676264, 0.00012569544196594507, 0.029414130374789238, -0.009309398010373116, 0.012266094796359539, -0.00551132345572114, 0.0055806259624660015, 0.04899878427386284, -0.025453219190239906, -0.020852508023381233, 0.014957948587834835, -0.006387726869434118, -0.009403246454894543, 0.010825980454683304, 0.023176025599241257, -0.009046854451298714, -0.00566826481372118, -0.017087383195757866, -0.020039258524775505, 0.02667517587542534, -0.00765262171626091, -0.03796752542257309, 0.028690878301858902, 0.023252781480550766, 0.01531123835593462, -0.007764218840748072, -0.02552736923098564, -0.0231183972209692, 0.02054554969072342, 0.009583520703017712, -0.05356387421488762, 0.02685016393661499, 0.014715581201016903, 0.02555783838033676, -0.008981660008430481, -0.018969345837831497, -0.0169083122164011, 0.07314585149288177, -0.02791108749806881, -0.01097266748547554, 0.030761897563934326, 0.0020783471409231424, 0.023364845663309097, 0.030619999393820763, -0.000289237592369318, 0.01736818067729473, -0.014315640553832054, -0.04828948900103569, -0.026505766436457634, -0.083859883248806, 0.05112292245030403, 0.07942438125610352, -0.02452554553747177, 0.05135832354426384, 0.03174517676234245, -0.0024141769390553236, 0.003667236538603902, -0.0488467663526535, -0.006857868283987045, -0.03756171837449074, -0.00633239047601819, 0.0030592961702495813, -0.040954601019620895, -0.026732971891760826, 0.009114165790379047, 0.009269758127629757, -0.0260013360530138, 0.008206052705645561, -0.008679046295583248, 0.05156749486923218, 0.034245338290929794, -0.03261248394846916, -0.04739673063158989, 0.04692976549267769, -0.030539704486727715, -0.003298833966255188, -0.012154408730566502, 0.0007272865623235703, 0.02784004621207714, 0.022420791909098625, 0.051208484917879105, -0.0024031458888202906, -0.006010432727634907, -0.08889368921518326, 0.007444840390235186, 0.005789888557046652, -0.008838500827550888, 0.020321780815720558, -0.023497505113482475, 0.021516084671020508, 0.002978276228532195, 0.01920250430703163, -0.03247995302081108, -0.0763557180762291, 0.02650211751461029, -0.012293146923184395, -0.04306565225124359, 0.0029115949291735888, 0.00291175814345479, -0.012711763381958008, 0.006808314472436905, -0.042794909328222275, 0.03329850360751152, 0.04742762818932533, 0.05558319762349129, -0.05168503522872925, 0.05000351741909981, -0.008923080749809742, 0.016069486737251282, -0.04040064662694931, 0.003727828385308385, 0.12319154292345047, 0.048957739025354385, 0.05458085611462593, -0.04155333340167999, -0.008525585755705833, -0.02066783793270588, 0.0028729671612381935, -0.026205912232398987, -0.01955675333738327, -0.01843450590968132, 0.0023995214141905308, 0.010426449589431286, 0.03733423724770546, 0.021745113655924797, -0.04146324098110199, 0.008698718622326851, -0.032290007919073105, -0.026773126795887947, 0.011271134950220585, 0.024432476609945297, -0.03737735003232956, 0.02832460217177868, -0.005009552463889122, 0.006864988245069981, -0.012398948892951012, -0.0043143536895513535, -0.0187979843467474, -0.02526826411485672, -0.01441399846225977, 0.0261369701474905, -0.05581573024392128, 0.004211099818348885, -0.023135565221309662, 0.023045042529702187, -0.042599547654390335, 0.020680872723460197, 0.020817354321479797, -0.001240908750332892, 0.018466519191861153, -0.005116594955325127, 0.008072475902736187, 0.02433011494576931, 0.011309734545648098, -0.004817021079361439, 0.0006252782768569887, -0.07010813802480698, -0.02342299558222294, 0.08632531017065048, -0.02179110236465931, -0.013424565084278584, 0.004145618993788958, -0.022590922191739082, 0.02300948090851307, -0.06569641828536987, 0.004251592792570591, 0.0033873533830046654, 0.013242816552519798, -0.03251958265900612, 0.01256829034537077, -0.004089483059942722, 0.04748541861772537, -0.012165739201009274, -0.014613074250519276, -0.006179998628795147, -0.056051015853881836, -0.010879551991820335, -0.00998731330037117, 0.04889779910445213, -0.0008289453107863665, 0.02896936982870102, -0.01015129592269659, 0.006622993852943182, -0.0608360655605793, -0.03493732586503029, 0.0082007497549057, -0.011402306146919727, 0.04397160932421684, -0.00932170171290636, -0.022407546639442444, -0.02880333922803402, -0.0316871777176857, 0.017054777592420578, -0.041417207568883896, -0.013766270130872726, -0.006286645773798227, -0.0005742544308304787, 0.04362703859806061, 0.02129778079688549, -0.028709301725029945, 0.0036942188162356615, 0.03519229218363762, 0.047986190766096115, -0.005225760862231255, -0.03389226645231247, -0.04351247474551201, 0.02257884107530117, -0.026560448110103607, -0.0022923853248357773, 0.03149013966321945, 0.033027779310941696, 0.024053435772657394, 0.048724185675382614, -0.010578866116702557, 0.02380451001226902, -0.00043320495751686394, -0.02027732878923416, -0.010456892661750317, -0.0379110686480999, 0.010461067780852318, 0.06527037918567657, 0.01978810876607895, -0.032499272376298904, 0.011340080760419369, -0.030549678951501846, -0.03803294152021408, -0.0031542270444333553, 0.00019967634580098093, 0.00514957495033741, 0.020699379965662956, 0.0001998379739234224, 0.03709729015827179, -0.03339008614420891, -0.02031295746564865, 0.022582992911338806, 0.001003565383143723, 0.003539876313880086, 0.02495567686855793, -0.029389968141913414, -0.019282842054963112, -0.0030794916674494743, -0.040400758385658264, 0.04664899408817291, 0.018857911229133606, 0.016751248389482498, -0.011432237923145294, -0.015607920475304127, 0.006055711302906275, 0.0489681176841259, 0.002535085193812847, -0.006849287077784538, 0.03176819533109665, -0.016649529337882996, -0.04139983281493187, 0.043418850749731064, 0.013399685733020306, 0.0026275801938027143, -0.0005312560242600739, 0.02333085797727108, -0.06469697505235672, 0.04158073663711548, -0.03320685774087906, 0.04334395378828049, -0.032786350697278976, -0.043481193482875824, 0.003057706169784069, 0.018304143100976944, 0.03919336944818497, 0.001858451752923429, 0.02625662088394165, 0.008288075216114521, 0.03095836378633976, -0.015515336766839027, -0.007538823876529932, 0.014023637399077415, -0.023328548297286034, -0.025095675140619278, -0.009896021336317062, -0.02938758209347725, -0.002065103268250823, 0.047886066138744354, -0.02106836624443531, 0.006543600931763649, 0.01607801765203476, -0.014990023337304592, -0.1171279177069664, -0.007653710898011923, 0.02016446553170681, 0.04548799991607666, 0.06321088969707489, -0.04930126294493675, 0.005098350346088409, 0.030787648633122444, -0.05605027452111244, -0.034170471131801605, -0.00442410446703434, -0.019056638702750206, -0.05076959729194641, 0.011577272787690163, -0.0405120849609375, 0.04713010415434837, 0.012015968561172485, 0.027970178052783012, 0.021084263920783997, 0.04647170379757881, -0.0033110245130956173, -0.05782657861709595, 0.0006015074905008078, -0.005052654538303614, 0.032410625368356705, -0.010253148153424263, 0.005789177492260933, -0.04198816791176796, 0.005628954619169235, 0.05061858519911766, -0.011545522138476372, 0.03590289130806923, -0.0323936901986599, 0.002126724226400256, 0.001644618227146566, 0.02109391987323761, 0.03418784216046333, -0.015776008367538452, 0.01212429627776146, -0.027891365811228752, 0.012229595333337784, 0.006622236222028732, -0.005007642786949873, 0.020326951518654823, 0.003721246961504221, -0.013498546555638313, -0.061020128428936005, 0.059950873255729675, 0.005071634892374277, -0.033876098692417145, 0.03354698419570923, -0.003637962508946657, -0.02776413969695568, -0.033122289925813675, 0.049328457564115524, -0.03664318844676018, 0.006780398543924093, 0.027672475203871727, 0.038841258734464645, -0.04099751636385918, 0.03345711529254913, -0.007912556640803814, -0.05466065928339958, 0.01446871180087328, -0.010916557163000107, -0.01586969755589962, -0.05260171368718147, 0.0018288552528247237, -0.008973091840744019, -0.025569332763552666, 0.009390178136527538, -0.0220975149422884, -0.03374679759144783, 0.019314158707857132, 0.018192384392023087, 0.0057961163111031055, -0.012820783071219921, -0.01485183835029602, 0.015788942575454712, -0.06249624863266945, 0.07875418663024902, 0.01046814862638712, -0.016657540574669838, -0.020090600475668907, -0.0021934465039521456, 0.006003880873322487, -0.008093259297311306, 0.045619018375873566, 0.01891935244202614, 0.0013924849918112159, 0.004411644767969847, 0.02143765613436699, 0.033664003014564514, -0.0016028252430260181, 0.04643745720386505, -0.011432734318077564, 0.005067766644060612, -0.02269706130027771, 0.0062154862098395824, 0.010573877952992916, 0.025890644639730453, 0.027125099673867226, -0.00919498223811388, 0.008918230421841145, -0.007787695620208979, -0.029780592769384384, 0.03872805833816528, 0.025885237380862236, -0.00007535122858826071, 0.052405308932065964, -0.029110336676239967, -0.0008298064349219203, 0.0389169305562973, -0.08675779402256012, -0.04710904881358147, 0.003334461012855172, -0.007792181335389614, -0.03311187028884888, 0.0027955651748925447, -0.02861236035823822, 0.0291045680642128, -0.015183974988758564, 0.005992543417960405, 0.04053143411874771, -0.022255856543779373, -0.016807129606604576, 0.023012563586235046, 0.02723790891468525, 0.02659529261291027, 0.02562638185918331, 0.004656912758946419, 0.03497179597616196, -0.028764111921191216, 0.0284146536141634, 0.0035542703699320555, 0.031017687171697617, -0.004864837974309921, 0.03162940591573715, 0.011415046639740467, -0.025234157219529152, 0.0261745173484087, 0.02453453093767166, 0.006474510300904512, -0.02793104387819767, -0.023367518559098244, 0.0043487874791026115, -0.007738292682915926, -0.01570497266948223, 0.007137315347790718, -0.0660872682929039, 0.080297090113163, -0.056562986224889755, -0.0014808813575655222, -0.03032446652650833, 0.04503217712044716, -0.029734915122389793, -0.02538158744573593, -0.009994653053581715, -0.020639697089791298, -0.01937755011022091, 0.025688551366329193, -0.014505603350698948, 0.0247077364474535, -0.017434339970350266, 0.008359811268746853, -0.02329559251666069, 0.04849321395158768, -0.026406778022646904, 0.009285107254981995, -0.01794774830341339, -0.028746096417307854, -0.023545105010271072, -0.0036909617483615875, 0.04536531865596771, 0.005076522473245859, -0.010307016782462597, -0.033373694866895676, -0.012660011649131775, 0.04547654837369919, -0.0558113157749176, 0.017210984602570534, -0.01888323202729225, 0.010982731357216835, -0.008264071308076382, -0.017220716923475266 ]
<p>Seismic exploration involves the excitation of seismic waves using the industrially made explosive charges. </p> <p>What could be the distribution of explosion energy of such a charges? </p> <p>My guess is that it could be gaussian with mean that can be derived from the charge specs and with very small dispersion. However, the acquisition of the explosion wavefield on the earth surface suggests that the distribution has very strong skewness (right tail is very long).</p>
73,555
[ -0.01975535973906517, -0.0061514535918831825, 0.0006221187650226057, -0.025614425539970398, 0.06861059367656708, 0.030216960236430168, -0.02266733907163143, -0.02104579657316208, 0.016295380890369415, -0.03880051523447037, 0.05082667991518974, 0.05929197743535042, 0.04430996999144554, 0.028897985816001892, 0.0003786375164054334, -0.030146757140755653, -0.007807278074324131, -0.014291513711214066, -0.006082283332943916, -0.03633180260658264, 0.01169516984373331, 0.009418942965567112, -0.03462105989456177, -0.01745348609983921, -0.06014920026063919, 0.04988374933600426, 0.013061979785561562, -0.030855342745780945, 0.02239854820072651, 0.048335928469896317, -0.0041269781067967415, -0.016989510506391525, 0.00846901349723339, 0.01120972353965044, 0.03534790128469467, -0.0063243736512959, -0.03427400812506676, -0.027811061590909958, -0.004437449853867292, 0.029706673696637154, -0.02582365833222866, -0.021781230345368385, 0.039900269359350204, 0.05636448785662651, -0.03831882402300835, 0.02929536998271942, -0.008137311786413193, -0.07115142792463303, 0.04771173372864723, -0.03952237218618393, 0.049016308039426804, -0.006354312878102064, 0.027330728247761726, 0.002971943933516741, -0.006181243807077408, 0.01564961113035679, 0.05968400835990906, 0.04410680755972862, 0.02008442021906376, -0.05640780180692673, 0.011129326187074184, 0.009991288185119629, 0.0023872382007539272, -0.017318421974778175, -0.013646923936903477, 0.03951871022582054, 0.00011858119250973687, -0.03261634707450867, 0.0238819383084774, -0.010854790918529034, 0.03617788106203079, 0.018045613542199135, 0.009872029535472393, -0.019453564658761024, -0.0027176132425665855, -0.014423719607293606, 0.04251222312450409, 0.016227934509515762, 0.010671203024685383, 0.02689514495432377, 0.018834426999092102, -0.00515920203179121, -0.011920292861759663, 0.04403886944055557, 0.029537303373217583, 0.012794974260032177, 0.05177704617381096, -0.032922349870204926, 0.006822559516876936, 0.015406491234898567, 0.0064660366624593735, 0.020583508536219597, 0.03445328399538994, 0.036511559039354324, -0.015812000259757042, 0.041266411542892456, 0.008673513308167458, 0.06085595116019249, 0.01569998264312744, 0.006121769081801176, 0.01246692892163992, -0.03325076401233673, 0.01965879648923874, 0.05723902955651283, -0.011400479823350906, -0.021660776808857918, -0.04176221787929535, -0.0004359207523521036, -0.05242032930254936, -0.028711704537272453, -0.013484813272953033, 0.020203277468681335, 0.029205434024333954, 0.017353679984807968, 0.020447606220841408, -0.001308088074438274, 0.026895999908447266, -0.0404815636575222, 0.015779990702867508, 0.008583568036556244, 0.03142549842596054, 0.021671779453754425, 0.049550022929906845, -0.04091934114694595, -0.050084978342056274, -0.008476595394313335, 0.04247279092669487, -0.03545239195227623, -0.037850260734558105, 0.033172741532325745, 0.02315266616642475, -0.01157077681273222, 0.012147852219641209, -0.023649541661143303, 0.0025726293679326773, -0.03372303023934364, -0.07995891571044922, -0.042024336755275726, 0.03574343025684357, -0.024099579080939293, 0.013762379996478558, -0.07734501361846924, -0.04183480516076088, 0.03793276846408844, 0.01253741979598999, -0.04623381420969963, 0.015079187229275703, 0.0008159965509548783, 0.04914296418428421, -0.013307854533195496, -0.01543116569519043, -0.0048868702724576, -0.021875325590372086, -0.050720904022455215, -0.00029264134354889393, -0.0694572851061821, 0.03081137128174305, 0.005686900112777948, -0.006190393585711718, 0.022581882774829865, -0.01601635292172432, -0.009245343506336212, -0.036859169602394104, 0.0008164651226252317, 0.018088772892951965, -0.01690187305212021, 0.0948323905467987, 0.021596258506178856, 0.022749703377485275, 0.048866353929042816, -0.016340091824531555, -0.004633211065083742, 0.04365205392241478, -0.01427457295358181, 0.05061795189976692, -0.06740628182888031, -0.0003921995230484754, -0.04364650323987007, 0.024355370551347733, 0.003585376311093569, -0.033680856227874756, -0.029901212081313133, -0.011664644815027714, -0.012752876617014408, 0.055536698549985886, 0.018824370577931404, 0.019402366131544113, -0.018178990110754967, 0.014368432573974133, -0.01949801854789257, -0.012158584780991077, -0.038981009274721146, 0.07406637817621231, 0.008883249014616013, -0.008124095387756824, 0.008655410259962082, -0.030785035341978073, 0.0016590454615652561, -0.02018750086426735, 0.02499653398990631, 0.02256068028509617, 0.01409512385725975, -0.009446455165743828, 0.0032659550197422504, -0.007710893172770739, 0.046113546937704086, -0.008747822605073452, 0.013055373914539814, 0.03710626810789108, 0.03245658427476883, -0.04671890661120415, 0.0034553352743387222, -0.038958340883255005, 0.021088916808366776, 0.013680348172783852, -0.0076301125809550285, -0.013535416685044765, 0.017669791355729103, -0.0042327470146119595, 0.01900528185069561, -0.021675772964954376, 0.037272822111845016, 0.06625307351350784, -0.004841897636651993, -0.009847664274275303, 0.01596006564795971, -0.011438756249845028, 0.04974421486258507, 0.03259192407131195, -0.04176304116845131, -0.07187021523714066, -0.024469422176480293, 0.03275202214717865, 0.03803157061338425, -0.019589828327298164, 0.002169976243749261, 0.08606651425361633, 0.007967689074575901, 0.02193577215075493, -0.0160624161362648, -0.008143470622599125, -0.05539250001311302, 0.042640991508960724, 0.003497655503451824, 0.002081312006339431, 0.0010982120875269175, 0.012764111161231995, 0.0006660777144134045, 0.001675023348070681, -0.05772111937403679, 0.04048021137714386, 0.01539219357073307, -0.025137944146990776, 0.0026780683547258377, -0.016352733597159386, -0.015990089625120163, 0.016456685960292816, 0.004190904088318348, 0.011544686742126942, 0.02717088907957077, -0.021353313699364662, -0.03596293181180954, -0.013307197950780392, 0.00228776759468019, 0.015644000843167305, 0.013090104795992374, 0.021981295198202133, -0.010424666106700897, 0.02576417662203312, -0.05046737939119339, -0.001471908763051033, 0.007515358738601208, -0.03716849908232689, 0.005004441365599632, 0.019334495067596436, 0.05101418122649193, 0.03031848929822445, -0.004969480913132429, -0.03029911033809185, -0.03173191100358963, 0.012074432335793972, 0.017903601750731468, 0.006122982129454613, 0.017961982637643814, -0.021470243111252785, 0.00932940375059843, -0.05532455071806908, -0.02942991629242897, 0.00002986203253385611, -0.013131925836205482, -0.00020958035020157695, 0.05384085699915886, -0.007049766834825277, -0.03183247148990631, 0.016340577974915504, 0.028701327741146088, -0.004973775241523981, -0.02755867689847946, -0.004898188170045614, 0.054841961711645126, -0.010638347826898098, -0.012063617818057537, 0.022721804678440094, -0.034014828503131866, -0.018103424459695816, -0.028777949512004852, 0.0016180557431653142, 0.02225506864488125, 0.003008762141689658, 0.05592656880617142, 0.05045327544212341, 0.0020016455091536045, -0.010788524523377419, -0.06748312711715698, -0.06163375452160835, 0.012735102325677872, -0.009003429673612118, 0.06169163063168526, -0.042840391397476196, -0.03136230632662773, 0.05741695314645767, 0.052648477256298065, -0.019241947680711746, 0.026645570993423462, -0.03544842079281807, 0.03017951175570488, 0.015821708366274834, 0.03792421892285347, 0.00907602533698082, 0.013382920995354652, 0.0163577813655138, 0.008318396285176277, 0.052547212690114975, 0.010693979449570179, 0.022222507745027542, 0.007193086668848991, 0.033292751759290695, -0.00008221762254834175, 0.04572249948978424, 0.03119516186416149, 0.038981471210718155, -0.03459985926747322, 0.04672439768910408, -0.004744884558022022, -0.008820966817438602, 0.03064817748963833, -0.04678061231970787, 0.029650427401065826, 0.016264628618955612, -0.010772052221000195, -0.03773155063390732, 0.03371288254857063, 0.03020409680902958, -0.00040338447433896363, -0.0009463353198952973, 0.06463463604450226, 0.028217585757374763, -0.01311075035482645, 0.012548266910016537, -0.003778132377192378, 0.044293589890003204, -0.03133756294846535, -0.04847359284758568, -0.019317859783768654, 0.022488083690404892, -0.012012697756290436, -0.002288122195750475, -0.01934477873146534, -0.01139396894723177, 0.005969657562673092, 0.019922038540244102, -0.01653723604977131, -0.024236250668764114, 0.01426608394831419, -0.07868409901857376, -0.024952439591288567, -0.0302582960575819, 0.043575551360845566, 0.025377683341503143, 0.06340866535902023, 0.01614922471344471, -0.014730595983564854, 0.036704495549201965, 0.009541662409901619, -0.05691550299525261, -0.02304142713546753, -0.04263557121157646, -0.005509437993168831, -0.024784207344055176, -0.01780546084046364, -0.023358147591352463, 0.018439587205648422, -0.027326414361596107, -0.016697073355317116, 0.007376230321824551, -0.04744787514209747, 0.044942501932382584, -0.02877163328230381, -0.040464919060468674, 0.003206165973097086, 0.03880196809768677, 0.02070695534348488, 0.0038235930260270834, 0.00984947383403778, 0.003631856059655547, -0.006328139919787645, 0.0193321593105793, 0.01048268936574459, -0.0029435972683131695, 0.015656493604183197, 0.051715463399887085, -0.04371445253491402, 0.009202065877616405, 0.01916457526385784, 0.019633876159787178, 0.008266918361186981, 0.06022019311785698, 0.041710466146469116, -0.018141549080610275, -0.03927348926663399, -0.042994316667318344, 0.0036768747959285975, 0.04218451306223869, -0.005907336249947548, 0.00962307583540678, 0.0249880813062191, 0.004361163359135389, 0.02331271767616272, -0.02421795018017292, 0.024656835943460464, 0.04649768024682999, 0.009955319575965405, 0.02278151549398899, -0.011333638802170753, 0.015309784561395645, -0.030461935326457024, -0.03958987817168236, -0.013575536198914051, 0.011637967079877853, 0.008136076852679253, 0.01930004544556141, 0.025674346834421158, 0.022903820499777794, -0.044051628559827805, 0.045279331505298615, -0.02099504880607128, 0.003934770822525024, -0.031054887920618057, -0.011860926635563374, 0.019936054944992065, -0.011611856520175934, 0.03866877779364586, 0.03352799639105797, -0.01739983819425106, -0.026384063065052032, 0.0012792174238711596, 0.04176441580057144, 0.019777217879891396, -0.04151180014014244, -0.013524367474019527, -0.04579298570752144, 0.0011035972274839878, 0.005457786843180656, -0.03626306354999542, 0.03445776551961899, -0.02409612573683262, 0.03687421232461929, -0.017398057505488396, 0.0010616971412673593, -0.06578930467367172, 0.024842403829097748, 0.003422627691179514, -0.02029406651854515, -0.04793386906385422, 0.002621868858113885, -0.005516940262168646, 0.04175717383623123, 0.05683411657810211, 0.06030257046222687, 0.003918688744306564, -0.026254290714859962, -0.03927960246801376, 0.004596254322677851, 0.0274434145539999, -0.03136426582932472, -0.015098702162504196, -0.016261138021945953, -0.019606346264481544, 0.05912158638238907, -0.056660640984773636, -0.05778849124908447, 0.04160264506936073, 0.019974946975708008, 0.01849932037293911, -0.01105504110455513, -0.02991785667836666, 0.03826314955949783, 0.03424295037984848, 0.02098914422094822, 0.03951716423034668, 0.03808118775486946, -0.01948697119951248, 0.006466432474553585, -0.05282390117645264, 0.021516256034374237, -0.025815123692154884, 0.023827191442251205, -0.010114778764545918, 0.05044740438461304, -0.052803199738264084, 0.008774149231612682, -0.02885935828089714, 0.024736154824495316, -0.025690624490380287, -0.028695128858089447, 0.01645485684275627, 0.014817745424807072, 0.0014479473466053605, 0.04232015460729599, 0.019492343068122864, 0.05699727311730385, -0.015259049832820892, 0.034799959510564804, -0.023560307919979095, -0.005235122982412577, 0.028771040961146355, 0.046388573944568634, -0.04933757334947586, 0.0006511516403406858, -0.06038375943899155, -0.014263344928622246, 0.03254349157214165, -0.050067443400621414, 0.06919201463460922, 0.016278652474284172, 0.0013420394388958812, 0.04025541618466377, -0.013136345893144608, -0.0037600963842123747, 0.034686725586652756, 0.013069935142993927, 0.051851291209459305, -0.04485110938549042, 0.016651157289743423, -0.02223500981926918, 0.03143669292330742, -0.0759119838476181, -0.023561283946037292, 0.043349843472242355, 0.014819527976214886, -0.007501862943172455, -0.03159875050187111, 0.015343262813985348, 0.0159987173974514, -0.005522359162569046, 0.012601136229932308, 0.04526186361908913, -0.010951315984129906, -0.004643844906240702, -0.003430199110880494, 0.020171411335468292, 0.06555355340242386, -0.007155121769756079, -0.019040323793888092, 0.058010876178741455, 0.01784314587712288, -0.015044665895402431, -0.037250664085149765, 0.019972216337919235, -0.02507130056619644, -0.04446394741535187, -0.014009302482008934, 0.018532769754529, 0.0158308707177639, -0.060089439153671265, -0.02206352911889553, -0.02370607852935791, 0.03455992415547371, -0.038468923419713974, 0.001957672880962491, 0.013080253265798092, -0.009572822600603104, 0.008467622101306915, -0.06469828635454178, -0.01747044362127781, -0.050756774842739105, 0.008850127458572388, -0.014237922616302967, 0.002509606536477804, 0.016229460015892982, 0.02381010167300701, 0.04463914409279823, -0.025373542681336403, -0.030167123302817345, 0.03243523836135864, 0.00359380547888577, 0.013317208737134933, -0.0012681693769991398, 0.0031880526803433895, 0.006912526674568653, -0.003027800004929304, -0.009577718563377857, -0.01653185300529003, -0.05321637541055679, 0.024470403790473938, 0.08443142473697662, -0.016682665795087814, 0.04233080521225929, 0.046910371631383896, -0.01676192134618759, -0.013706391677260399, -0.03415600210428238, -0.0038248873315751553, -0.019368723034858704, -0.0191506240516901, 0.019847474992275238, -0.03898978233337402, -0.0016047334065660834, 0.0018519223667681217, 0.026621108874678612, -0.012109183706343174, 0.038980185985565186, 0.017902543768286705, 0.028604233637452126, 0.011751661077141762, -0.05853532627224922, -0.07314746081829071, 0.0438692644238472, -0.06143660470843315, 0.04030126333236694, 0.019039923325181007, 0.0027119601145386696, 0.024206552654504776, 0.015223379246890545, -0.03311227634549141, -0.014206020161509514, 0.0168763417750597, -0.037408165633678436, -0.004343845881521702, 0.024065131321549416, 0.02592744678258896, -0.034305915236473083, -0.0009504390764050186, 0.01652129925787449, -0.0010457822354510427, 0.024572011083364487, 0.011991401202976704, -0.042928483337163925, 0.013545232824981213, -0.014078235253691673, -0.09158465266227722, 0.026108581572771072, -0.04839746654033661, -0.01601581647992134, 0.015088938176631927, -0.04505173861980438, 0.03665296360850334, 0.004388764966279268, -0.006633507553488016, -0.0009904301259666681, 0.10046619176864624, 0.0015280622756108642, -0.011269203387200832, -0.04046642407774925, 0.002998441457748413, 0.1280973106622696, 0.07227876037359238, 0.035398148000240326, -0.027628906071186066, -0.013810819946229458, -0.03713318705558777, -0.0020526086445897818, -0.00576509814709425, 0.006413517519831657, 0.007814881391823292, 0.008628801442682743, 0.0006193336448632181, 0.014667811803519726, -0.014352376572787762, -0.0005591454682871699, 0.03473219275474548, -0.016170399263501167, -0.03020116128027439, 0.00335376407019794, -0.001792742870748043, -0.020145775750279427, 0.02740841917693615, -0.0742199569940567, 0.02967683970928192, -0.003687408287078142, -0.027045046910643578, -0.01993606798350811, -0.05459641292691231, -0.008627023547887802, 0.009354200214147568, -0.030873777344822884, -0.010143492370843887, 0.026024362072348595, -0.012610134668648243, 0.019595401361584663, -0.000596641912125051, 0.019215889275074005, -0.007112748455256224, -0.021814027801156044, 0.018189195543527603, 0.008021239191293716, 0.0014545861631631851, 0.02241973951458931, 0.04667703062295914, -0.020734097808599472, -0.004483940079808235, -0.020806891843676567, 0.027792328968644142, -0.0344720333814621, -0.02520712837576866, -0.06535043567419052, -0.013804827816784382, 0.01318882405757904, -0.05325377359986305, -0.04294886067509651, 0.007131259422749281, 0.043607912957668304, -0.009501061402261257, -0.022394731640815735, -0.04230869561433792, -0.019195031374692917, 0.011322258971631527, 0.039117734879255295, 0.008718090131878853, 0.02168687991797924, 0.007095712702721357, -0.024554073810577393, 0.05864560231566429, 0.002252597128972411, -0.05162285268306732, -0.02236233651638031, -0.04563725367188454, -0.08289797604084015, -0.006234870292246342, -0.04065176472067833, 0.015311638824641705, 0.048372115939855576, 0.03074044920504093, 0.002264995826408267, -0.03850390762090683, -0.04072341322898865, 0.06476442515850067, -0.010510088875889778, -0.02235131524503231, -0.023842783644795418, -0.028013238683342934, 0.008165068924427032, 0.043294116854667664, 0.0037565608508884907, 0.01688484102487564, -0.003541861195117235, 0.01946406066417694, 0.04719150438904762, -0.03455932065844536, -0.023587118834257126, 0.023629508912563324, -0.027228709310293198, -0.026953013613820076, 0.019549332559108734, -0.019471026957035065, 0.007223880384117365, -0.03529253229498863, 0.04041885584592819, 0.004606099333614111, -0.022108998149633408, -0.016257453709840775, 0.0302568431943655, -0.040227748453617096, -0.04105784371495247, 0.03592921793460846, 0.0071898032911121845, -0.042380306869745255, -0.01750161126255989, -0.015470682643353939, 0.02112061157822609, -0.023723280057311058, 0.027629584074020386, -0.02265445701777935, -0.027732225134968758, -0.04745262861251831, 0.03248349949717522, 0.0004124263650737703, -0.01696290634572506, 0.009364265948534012, 0.007396305911242962, -0.04516354575753212, 0.024458743631839752, -0.03559845685958862, 0.012839004397392273, -0.035594940185546875, -0.00742619251832366, 0.009015231393277645, -0.018168263137340546, 0.023308023810386658, -0.0012007835321128368, -0.0036809241864830256, -0.02641620673239231, 0.048429831862449646, -0.025770166888833046, -0.01564326137304306, 0.002901258645579219, -0.04278552532196045, -0.07979971170425415, 0.045434799045324326, -0.026965608820319176, 0.008039683103561401, 0.005731986835598946, -0.0033449544571340084, -0.033307649195194244, 0.03898990526795387, -0.0035655703395605087, -0.01922554150223732, 0.013491104356944561, 0.0026577264070510864, 0.013620948418974876, -0.0009729024022817612, 0.016284963116049767, 0.031730201095342636, 0.006683005951344967, 0.0414862222969532, -0.02595227211713791, 0.0036894562654197216, 0.012798063457012177, 0.03541981428861618, -0.052743762731552124, -0.0075416830368340015, 0.008242870680987835, -0.015297585166990757, 0.0395624116063118, 0.02561449632048607, -0.028823653236031532, 0.0185965858399868, -0.007069726008921862, 0.004887837916612625, -0.0735270082950592, -0.0359446220099926, -0.01877736672759056, 0.00023382282233797014, 0.03401724621653557, -0.03949417173862457, 0.016133371740579605, 0.021681908518075943, -0.12271400541067123, 0.024549400433897972, -0.03602764755487442, -0.03459469601511955, -0.055148378014564514, 0.0013154975604265928, -0.03232520446181297, 0.03488641232252121, 0.003808595472946763, 0.0701889842748642, 0.051124218851327896, 0.053106121718883514, -0.0344131663441658, 0.031934451311826706, -0.011939221993088722, 0.02751571498811245, 0.04817582294344902, 0.017509225755929947, 0.08731667697429657, -0.02754238061606884, 0.011489896103739738, 0.028712961822748184, -0.02763092704117298, 0.009247816167771816, 0.007971612736582756, 0.017890531569719315, -0.0016380812739953399, 0.05579490214586258, 0.05789802223443985, -0.009473642334342003, 0.010147600434720516, 0.01561205554753542, 0.039455048739910126, 0.03262113407254219, -0.018419846892356873, -0.019146548584103584, -0.007005114573985338, 0.006259284447878599, 0.01799272932112217, 0.053537383675575256, 0.014423757791519165, -0.021286699920892715, -0.027804594486951828, -0.0042978753335773945, 0.009316197596490383, 0.00699448911473155, 0.019363651052117348, -0.03837503492832184, 0.007750985212624073, 0.025186853483319283, -0.028932735323905945, -0.012972380965948105, 0.03026793897151947, -0.020355165004730225, -0.02927304618060589, -0.02603508159518242, -0.016448920592665672, -0.032444123178720474, -0.044682856649160385, 0.033243805170059204, -0.010026125237345695, 0.019819695502519608, 0.0009114929707720876, -0.002860257402062416, -0.013895894400775433, 0.08744392544031143, 0.03272521123290062, 0.04788784310221672, 0.008643650449812412, -0.03553428500890732, -0.03340533748269081, -0.08892437070608139, 0.04045435041189194, -0.01374757383018732, -0.04591282829642296, -0.009325108490884304, -0.06244746595621109, 0.034107815474271774, 0.013663843274116516, 0.03523503243923187, 0.004348445683717728, -0.03181857243180275, 0.02960185334086418, -0.014828627929091454, 0.020447038114070892, -0.047347456216812134, -0.003859090618789196, -0.008031059056520462, -0.0020655037369579077, -0.03904721140861511, -0.040812600404024124, -0.02212449163198471, 0.03339967131614685, -0.0003926929202862084, -0.029177937656641006, -0.02661050856113434, -0.01880567893385887, -0.009462794288992882, 0.06731203198432922, 0.005983569659292698, -0.025953082367777824, 0.05321121960878372, -0.0036447285674512386, -0.005546775180846453, -0.023434333503246307, -0.018871484324336052, -0.04712891951203346, 0.001263289712369442, -0.017890198156237602, -0.035104990005493164, 0.029971981421113014, -0.015792934224009514, 0.027759891003370285, -0.04694143310189247, -0.02802813984453678, 0.024605894461274147, -0.017970668151974678, 0.007396564818918705, 0.009003938175737858, -0.007783559150993824, 0.047095127403736115, 0.03215779736638069, 0.04104359447956085, -0.00828817579895258, -0.008277448825538158, -0.01610921137034893, 0.011231819167733192, -0.010580646805465221, -0.057187922298908234, -0.004305435344576836, 0.040741343051195145, -0.014959609135985374, 0.010398355312645435, 0.047843869775533676, -0.003744907444342971, -0.022946935147047043, -0.030287254601716995, 0.05507487431168556, -0.011246580630540848, -0.0034425377380102873, -0.008859297260642052, -0.049626972526311874, 0.03890180587768555, 0.01644255965948105, -0.004357496742159128, -0.05643949285149574, 0.005442335270345211, -0.016556842252612114, -0.0008595837862230837, -0.018838904798030853, 0.0050550783053040504, -0.001073987688869238, 0.022548818960785866, -0.008203106932342052, 0.035128455609083176, 0.02653825655579567, -0.03737667575478554, -0.009683867916464806, -0.0004794681735802442, 0.02214924618601799, 0.021108102053403854, 0.00178252172190696, -0.016137000173330307, -0.007963207550346851, 0.025944160297513008, 0.04548751190304756, -0.010852975770831108, 0.02231976017355919, -0.015776721760630608, -0.0462789423763752, 0.04777015745639801, -0.017192184925079346, 0.024476008489727974, -0.017874864861369133, 0.0350010059773922, 0.008038001134991646, -0.005904966965317726 ]
<p>Let's say you wanted to map the intersections between n different online communities. For example:</p> <ul> <li>80% of CrossValidated users also have a Stack Overflow account</li> <li>50% of Hacker News users also have a Reddit account</li> <li>etc.</li> </ul> <p>What would be a good way to visualize this? Any examples of existing diagrams?</p> <p>I've seen <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/6234/visualizing-the-intersections-of-many-sets">this question</a>, which provides an answer. But I'm curious to know if there are other visualization techniques that would specifically lend themselves to comparing the relationships between communities. </p>
73,556
[ -0.05220728740096092, 0.008762478828430176, -0.0038404096849262714, -0.011467375792562962, 0.023558147251605988, 0.02152085490524769, 0.02688370645046234, -0.0011619385331869125, 0.026641305536031723, -0.009226972237229347, 0.026967352256178856, 0.03992445766925812, 0.04216206818819046, 0.046214520931243896, 0.030390741303563118, 0.011233185417950153, -0.01442350260913372, -0.012830337509512901, -0.021327687427401543, -0.007761858869343996, 0.014339147135615349, -0.02032201923429966, 0.04124719277024269, -0.016054468229413033, -0.01345222257077694, 0.04313797503709793, 0.02790115401148796, -0.031431835144758224, -0.006659931968897581, 0.020580729469656944, -0.019639162346720695, -0.04242444783449173, 0.00983295775949955, 0.06233769282698631, -0.0050163171254098415, 0.025352032855153084, -0.02843339741230011, -0.0006367529276758432, -0.0231245718896389, 0.016584647819399834, -0.01703023351728916, -0.013139918446540833, -0.021617868915200233, 0.07101644575595856, -0.03454600274562836, 0.008457157760858536, -0.005378344561904669, -0.011403300799429417, 0.013232095167040825, -0.03273962065577507, 0.0719195082783699, 0.011776392348110676, 0.02207629568874836, 0.02737591788172722, -0.010779578238725662, 0.023575909435749054, 0.02779201790690422, 0.05493001639842987, -0.006704634055495262, -0.06872212886810303, -0.04843843728303909, -0.015070367604494095, -0.017052767798304558, -0.02748427540063858, -0.034213025122880936, 0.07944518327713013, -0.015434430912137032, 0.0064871348440647125, 0.026418782770633698, -0.0027238517068326473, -0.040749214589595795, 0.055239979177713394, 0.06632050126791, -0.020974328741431236, 0.02524610422551632, -0.05223540589213371, 0.019934864714741707, -0.008579924702644348, 0.05405893176794052, 0.041230592876672745, -0.04166561737656593, 0.005314130336046219, -0.0045637995935976505, 0.03450261056423187, 0.0350281298160553, -0.022090503945946693, 0.06819669902324677, -0.03012159653007984, -0.03684229403734207, 0.026934102177619934, -0.0021276287734508514, -0.014605124481022358, 0.02101089619100094, 0.018760981038212776, -0.05628789961338043, 0.02713751047849655, -0.00745256245136261, 0.0011417189380154014, 0.03741850703954697, -0.017523212358355522, -0.027029674500226974, -0.00564902788028121, 0.0018973116530105472, 0.032715003937482834, 0.013485778123140335, -0.012687886133790016, -0.046945471316576004, -0.022538285702466965, -0.02908341772854328, -0.008880330249667168, -0.037612054497003555, -0.0040719397366046906, 0.035813719034194946, 0.060640204697847366, 0.008978578262031078, -0.025522537529468536, 0.030537767335772514, -0.00620273407548666, 0.0645132064819336, 0.06384816765785217, 0.037823837250471115, -0.010783853009343147, 0.04134858772158623, -0.030903449282050133, -0.05622268095612526, 0.010673468932509422, 0.027074724435806274, 0.008880294859409332, -0.027379408478736877, 0.042872797697782516, -0.03509075567126274, 0.0032475381158292294, 0.021494505926966667, -0.044141367077827454, 0.04186548292636871, 0.003145165042951703, -0.08218767493963242, -0.050654392689466476, 0.006444519851356745, 0.02565292827785015, 0.0003778976097237319, -0.03889065608382225, 0.02547634392976761, 0.018470734357833862, 0.018895450979471207, 0.011259891092777252, -0.009069789201021194, -0.006535330321639776, 0.04423897713422775, -0.002067024353891611, -0.020138729363679886, 0.005011197179555893, 0.0002568648778833449, 0.006700887344777584, -0.004654459655284882, -0.05454481020569801, 0.0053939432837069035, 0.020851632580161095, -0.014063520357012749, -0.00524021964520216, 0.05795905739068985, 0.010806654579937458, -0.015222502872347832, -0.0018588933162391186, 0.03198296204209328, -0.010956677608191967, 0.07164120674133301, -0.01186293363571167, 0.0225263312458992, 0.009754861705005169, -0.029681511223316193, 0.042079370468854904, 0.048468898981809616, 0.028355935588479042, 0.032012321054935455, -0.0268930122256279, 0.02179461531341076, -0.005490630399435759, -0.02186555415391922, 0.006568077486008406, -0.037955883890390396, -0.04499969631433487, -0.034844838082790375, 0.018191717565059662, 0.03719652071595192, 0.04012919217348099, -0.016635622829198837, -0.03603033348917961, 0.0529763363301754, -0.06035958230495453, -0.027043772861361504, -0.062201615422964096, 0.02848997712135315, -0.018338104709982872, -0.01797294430434704, 0.017680699005723, 0.0239250510931015, -0.015973379835486412, -0.032106369733810425, -0.01735031232237816, -0.026152852922677994, -0.00836279708892107, 0.031491514295339584, -0.04264606162905693, -0.029438240453600883, 0.02520112879574299, 0.024472571909427643, -0.04952702298760414, 0.01994934305548668, -0.04755515232682228, -0.06441575288772583, -0.0013863748172298074, -0.03652605041861534, 0.030276773497462273, -0.0018843596335500479, 0.013486994430422783, -0.01991444081068039, 0.038695551455020905, -0.03272726759314537, 0.020641392096877098, -0.03873622417449951, 0.04448731243610382, 0.036274056881666183, 0.0026161677669733763, -0.006833372637629509, -0.03264215961098671, 0.030103866010904312, 0.0258900485932827, -0.0043404740281403065, 0.027555366978049278, -0.09179644286632538, 0.013096407055854797, 0.044254183769226074, 0.020859617739915848, -0.04700557887554169, 0.01809714175760746, 0.04491794481873512, 0.03665512427687645, -0.04879987984895706, -0.026147054508328438, -0.040938202291727066, -0.02507568523287773, -0.006158409174531698, 0.06317673623561859, 0.01621256209909916, 0.005262846127152443, 0.026275157928466797, -0.013673385605216026, -0.015209726989269257, 0.011283332481980324, -0.026654889807105064, 0.050528693944215775, -0.00855657085776329, -0.006259491201490164, -0.04035033658146858, 0.00520652299746871, 0.0637212023139, -0.0025643378030508757, -0.01604815572500229, -0.0030888384208083153, -0.024640878662467003, -0.008308030664920807, 0.009007679298520088, -0.0204880740493536, 0.016871899366378784, 0.02340490184724331, -0.021958129480481148, -0.003560695331543684, 0.01939559169113636, -0.05160754173994064, 0.03743891045451164, -0.017652982845902443, -0.012740131467580795, -0.059782348573207855, 0.02454187162220478, 0.05403593182563782, -0.010943399742245674, 0.0066304998472332954, -0.03713438659906387, -0.08501077443361282, 0.01870175264775753, 0.0012570273829624057, -0.0014570729108527303, 0.007962783798575401, -0.05629744380712509, 0.011663948185741901, -0.019624564796686172, -0.03162502869963646, -0.0021763069089502096, -0.013839312829077244, -0.02233893796801567, 0.01468633022159338, 0.0000778172689024359, -0.035910896956920624, -0.018737928941845894, -0.02935362234711647, 0.04210655391216278, -0.00481156213209033, 0.0000028155172913102433, 0.03887270763516426, -0.0072230082005262375, -0.054084230214357376, 0.04805324971675873, -0.00023334902653004974, -0.04264567419886589, -0.04420981556177139, 0.0021075664553791285, 0.044113535434007645, -0.024372275918722153, -0.014698932878673077, 0.03012942150235176, -0.023945631459355354, 0.0048918635584414005, -0.0801546722650528, -0.07136375457048416, 0.00408314960077405, 0.0195494145154953, 0.014766205102205276, 0.011652949266135693, -0.01984582655131817, 0.04963069409132004, 0.010703777894377708, -0.05703229084610939, -0.06639103591442108, -0.01608201302587986, -0.048020604997873306, -0.0001329564693151042, 0.027221012860536575, 0.027605416253209114, -0.01929905265569687, -0.006957473233342171, 0.019140418618917465, 0.022573120892047882, 0.06118691340088844, 0.01381174847483635, 0.010730623267591, 0.016222016885876656, -0.006708292756229639, 0.0009409580961801112, 0.03912346065044403, -0.003975671716034412, -0.05264931172132492, 0.03316487744450569, 0.006557608023285866, 0.011969848535954952, 0.039248112589120865, -0.034192077815532684, -0.0027469636406749487, -0.02414795570075512, -0.010639389976859093, -0.025084370747208595, -0.016007142141461372, 0.01798909157514572, 0.00926247052848339, 0.01493990607559681, 0.07270844280719757, 0.0533907525241375, -0.026993315666913986, -0.012984250672161579, 0.05030393972992897, 0.03822336345911026, -0.03955379128456116, -0.0077997371554374695, -0.011923561803996563, -0.010700508020818233, -0.01270637009292841, -0.013812405988574028, -0.006780089344829321, 0.022672465071082115, 0.030944816768169403, -0.009488166309893131, 0.0009277632343582809, -0.0435304157435894, 0.00481296656653285, -0.07784541696310043, 0.01348351314663887, -0.05136074870824814, 0.050090134143829346, -0.023500049486756325, 0.04120698571205139, 0.008395718410611153, -0.010784188285470009, -0.030576782301068306, -0.0020910887978971004, -0.05295316502451897, 0.017564984038472176, -0.02513856068253517, 0.004918988328427076, -0.014940794557332993, -0.03220020607113838, 0.030375828966498375, 0.030820440500974655, -0.018938152119517326, 0.011222874745726585, 0.03511340171098709, -0.010760127566754818, 0.00132359832059592, -0.004151446279138327, -0.02144119143486023, 0.005538127850741148, 0.036087196320295334, 0.031902577728033066, 0.010167810134589672, 0.03817936033010483, 0.038805801421403885, -0.008276096545159817, -0.03586317226290703, -0.012900535948574543, 0.024014001712203026, 0.009948345832526684, 0.02111215516924858, -0.009159859269857407, 0.03982594609260559, -0.027863211929798126, 0.015381908044219017, -0.009444073773920536, 0.05365489423274994, 0.023268334567546844, -0.010422266088426113, 0.036782845854759216, -0.05273190885782242, -0.014213317073881626, 0.002089424291625619, 0.046311333775520325, -0.029854506254196167, 0.04524984210729599, 0.025563228875398636, 0.029958881437778473, -0.0583699494600296, 0.05091927945613861, 0.04431843385100365, 0.01452734973281622, -0.03694423288106918, -0.004667520523071289, -0.02024700865149498, 0.014809951186180115, 0.001126876100897789, 0.005813810974359512, 0.007843947038054466, 0.00813230685889721, 0.01925337314605713, 0.04670140892267227, 0.016219791024923325, -0.05386004224419594, 0.013897684402763844, -0.030113104730844498, 0.010149667970836163, -0.03989410772919655, -0.02662372961640358, 0.007104978431016207, 0.02566506341099739, 0.06834064424037933, 0.017680548131465912, -0.018854107707738876, -0.12395229935646057, 0.001968726282939315, 0.0493297316133976, 0.0068049682304263115, -0.023854883387684822, -0.05002457648515701, -0.041292961686849594, 0.002325223758816719, 0.034203775227069855, -0.014128689654171467, 0.028198909014463425, -0.0027523052413016558, 0.017724253237247467, -0.04266069456934929, 0.006264022085815668, 0.0020635616965591908, 0.018253978341817856, -0.013516073115170002, 0.028313234448432922, -0.041571833193302155, 0.023091569542884827, -0.04122000187635422, 0.04811885580420494, 0.0548173151910305, 0.05655942112207413, -0.0032700086012482643, -0.006677917670458555, -0.005090440157800913, 0.04170580208301544, 0.007448776625096798, -0.044055771082639694, 0.07186536490917206, 0.029886113479733467, -0.03442713990807533, 0.06933608651161194, 0.015686549246311188, -0.016457093879580498, 0.007202424108982086, -0.01033919770270586, -0.017090220004320145, -0.0014462110120803118, -0.003497785422950983, 0.05810509994626045, 0.04618540778756142, 0.03231305629014969, 0.05559609830379486, 0.05112621560692787, -0.0021635107696056366, -0.002716291695833206, 0.00039022197597660124, 0.024975694715976715, -0.024914218112826347, -0.004351770970970392, 0.011302490718662739, 0.00032786643714644015, -0.03431825712323189, -0.00022142476518638432, -0.03189776837825775, 0.019523173570632935, -0.012306846678256989, -0.005535508971661329, -0.02385648712515831, 0.0059279282577335835, 0.0011142867151647806, 0.00006327441951725632, 0.05041302368044853, 0.004519256297498941, 0.027361562475562096, -0.0057218195870518684, 0.05076306313276291, -0.03474639356136322, -0.016050102189183235, -0.015101917088031769, -0.03520902246236801, 0.02174275368452072, -0.059211429208517075, -0.013198656029999256, 0.005340375937521458, -0.026986079290509224, 0.043002963066101074, 0.0023884293623268604, 0.056017786264419556, -0.008227873593568802, -0.024640552699565887, -0.021739672869443893, 0.03281060606241226, 0.00699455663561821, 0.0014671686803922057, 0.005839776247739792, 0.026229746639728546, -0.0050806025974452496, -0.013221296481788158, -0.051804423332214355, -0.05667189136147499, 0.02506597526371479, -0.0007187437149696052, -0.03178519010543823, -0.05045051872730255, -0.001731440075673163, -0.0027853616047650576, 0.012267997488379478, 0.024723296985030174, 0.04930953308939934, -0.026588937267661095, -0.022672319784760475, -0.01854695752263069, -0.010968394577503204, 0.06574457883834839, 0.01972372457385063, -0.017858952283859253, -0.00970150250941515, 0.046177901327610016, 0.009424535557627678, 0.019429929554462433, 0.02201477251946926, -0.02139955386519432, -0.04556562751531601, -0.021090514957904816, 0.02487523853778839, 0.04091208428144455, -0.02804654650390148, 0.017455151304602623, 0.0032549502793699503, -0.014607055112719536, -0.008745385333895683, -0.001335670123808086, -0.001297575538046658, -0.012139606289565563, 0.0018969412194564939, -0.022283373400568962, 0.03593076393008232, -0.02314157411456108, -0.021942276507616043, 0.013060124590992928, -0.006529769394546747, -0.02510622888803482, 0.00043247267603874207, 0.05585328862071037, -0.000881959858816117, -0.004569469019770622, 0.0011449196608737111, -0.0491182804107666, 0.061484694480895996, -0.04450257122516632, 0.003032875945791602, 0.021569911390542984, 0.0477791503071785, -0.016567081212997437, -0.041513558477163315, -0.006148799322545528, -0.03207094967365265, 0.058072417974472046, -0.01546282134950161, 0.07174260914325714, 0.06834861636161804, -0.02626846171915531, 0.040354084223508835, 0.0188880767673254, 0.01071741059422493, -0.02734988182783127, 0.019185081124305725, 0.04173104837536812, -0.05455588921904564, -0.017243118956685066, 0.03381029888987541, 0.043074991554021835, 0.027930013835430145, 0.03792203590273857, 0.009322958998382092, 0.05067681521177292, 0.0601092129945755, -0.03658665344119072, -0.046928245574235916, 0.03861841559410095, -0.060719165951013565, 0.029208486899733543, -8.691117159287387e-7, -0.027458278462290764, 0.03214786946773529, 0.018978586420416832, -0.01210753619670868, 0.02456982433795929, -0.036171335726976395, -0.026517443358898163, 0.009965052828192711, 0.015169125981628895, 0.030275966972112656, -0.027926528826355934, 0.006305516231805086, 0.05886097997426987, -0.02391650527715683, 0.03649118170142174, -0.01435733214020729, -0.07214266806840897, -0.01627180725336075, -0.012761589139699936, -0.02937367744743824, -0.011030156165361404, -0.00842310581356287, -0.02461056597530842, 0.03399813175201416, -0.03024708852171898, -0.021382033824920654, -0.008952263742685318, 0.017688171938061714, -0.036695968359708786, 0.06026030331850052, 0.005243244580924511, 0.053378876298666, 0.0028525060042738914, -0.018828775733709335, 0.11464937776327133, 0.08889543265104294, 0.024088101461529732, -0.06043297052383423, 0.034680649638175964, 0.011566514149308205, 0.01742980256676674, -0.03330850973725319, 0.013609720394015312, 0.012764576822519302, 0.01952870935201645, 0.05800114572048187, 0.04733928292989731, 0.041125793009996414, 0.01523269060999155, 0.06497221440076828, -0.031147602945566177, 0.0012538519222289324, -0.002005690708756447, -0.013804495334625244, -0.03965314105153084, -0.013840703293681145, -0.09302599728107452, 0.03233630210161209, -0.003737810766324401, 0.0009849247289821506, -0.0012377381790429354, -0.02712848410010338, 0.014909450896084309, 0.014958138577640057, -0.018948357552289963, 0.027729582041502, 0.022545866668224335, -0.02832324244081974, -0.00861632451415062, -0.01643858477473259, 0.021062172949314117, 0.014040454290807247, 0.015210498124361038, 0.030976152047514915, -0.0050045703537762165, -0.01464961376041174, -0.050034720450639725, 0.013128027319908142, -0.04432624205946922, -0.04087361320853233, -0.06537836790084839, 0.015432994812726974, 0.002545758616179228, -0.001177054364234209, -0.04117535054683685, 0.01570129580795765, 0.03439819812774658, 0.0034852554090321064, -0.056991979479789734, -0.0055549414828419685, 0.028224747627973557, -0.010377958416938782, -0.015652000904083252, -0.03754769265651703, 0.04945101961493492, -0.02155344933271408, 0.01116934884339571, 0.005765604320913553, -0.011430708691477776, -0.05206660181283951, -0.047211989760398865, 0.03588229417800903, 0.00965897087007761, -0.019931768998503685, 0.020263751968741417, -0.01371030043810606, -0.019709495827555656, -0.014033682644367218, -0.013897759839892387, 0.034785445779561996, 0.026337485760450363, 0.030112940818071365, 0.004938122816383839, 0.010843222960829735, 0.005068954546004534, 0.020022235810756683, -0.0001007195605779998, -0.0332951620221138, -0.00822373852133751, -0.01778227463364601, 0.06368352472782135, 0.0011131268693134189, 0.022391391918063164, 0.02274608053267002, -0.0014825845137238503, 0.02477489598095417, 0.01823410764336586, -0.04370767995715141, -0.010447331704199314, -0.012705475091934204, -0.0484318770468235, -0.019381200894713402, -0.025009678676724434, 0.03901565074920654, 0.015062573365867138, -0.04268649220466614, 0.043154653161764145, 0.036494214087724686, 0.013235908932983875, 0.018678082153201103, -0.0025790289510041475, -0.061053093522787094, -0.011054422706365585, 0.01863127574324608, 0.0015690375585108995, -0.027514265850186348, -0.008234956301748753, -0.020915808156132698, -0.012221398763358593, 0.024958275258541107, -0.010467668063938618, -0.024376245215535164, 0.000790246413089335, -0.0344543419778347, 0.0459202416241169, -0.017283055931329727, -0.031059550121426582, -0.07205658406019211, -0.06208128109574318, -0.03723419830203056, 0.00738796591758728, 0.011072296649217606, 0.016870491206645966, 0.023120900616049767, 0.0004827143857255578, 0.0011335982708260417, 0.009469502605497837, -0.01192434225231409, 0.0015249507268890738, -0.009259199723601341, 0.04016712307929993, 0.019273018464446068, -0.04490969330072403, -0.03336992487311363, 0.03271029517054558, -0.04340951517224312, -0.03647497296333313, 0.008317750878632069, -0.03449014574289322, 0.05628784000873566, -0.03224142640829086, -0.04490523412823677, -0.010199255309998989, 0.04954987391829491, -0.0025026032235473394, -0.019357984885573387, 0.006933579221367836, 0.02669859305024147, 0.025316135957837105, 0.02156125009059906, -0.03355003893375397, -0.012419010512530804, 0.006752052344381809, -0.010412337258458138, 0.0440995879471302, -0.006325073540210724, -0.03852635994553566, -0.014768476597964764, -0.012784677557647228, 0.01869237795472145, -0.01709672622382641, 0.00039224987267516553, 0.06099860742688179, 0.015171152539551258, -0.052741676568984985, -0.000842985522467643, 0.0006152977584861219, 0.006679974962025881, -0.07375992089509964, -0.00351320649497211, -0.004239927977323532, -0.004824881441891193, 0.06095479801297188, -0.05174063518643379, 0.014054914936423302, 0.0116131491959095, -0.07214021682739258, 0.024895910173654556, 0.02827279269695282, -0.009924128651618958, -0.056078679859638214, 0.003093112027272582, -0.010513871908187866, 0.04118436202406883, 0.010306711308658123, 0.054108306765556335, 0.023157136514782906, 0.002579243155196309, -0.013624468818306923, -0.029574014246463776, -0.02671334333717823, -0.01652568392455578, 0.022083671763539314, -0.059957582503557205, 0.035394087433815, -0.044194627553224564, -0.036202605813741684, 0.03476564213633537, -0.017917517572641373, 0.0007316142437048256, 0.04666449874639511, -0.010405607521533966, 0.012169801630079746, -0.005727914161980152, 0.028786057606339455, -0.027600649744272232, -0.04174099862575531, 0.005988831631839275, 0.004185956437140703, 0.03655010089278221, 0.027450866997241974, 0.029269065707921982, 0.041668880730867386, -0.0091258455067873, -0.044740136712789536, 0.03228643164038658, -0.014091812074184418, -0.04816524684429169, -0.02212986722588539, -0.04534530267119408, 0.05639752745628357, -0.023478243499994278, 0.010262384079396725, -0.03724151849746704, -0.0017319204052910209, 0.046717870980501175, -0.02523556910455227, 0.01427147164940834, 0.017081504687666893, -0.03573666140437126, -0.04366832226514816, -0.0029908688738942146, 0.025615327060222626, 0.012547087855637074, -0.04230891540646553, 0.0015306314453482628, -0.00994932185858488, 0.0018406165763735771, 0.02310730516910553, -0.009633670561015606, -0.01323345024138689, 0.053801096975803375, -0.021953491494059563, -0.001479427912272513, 0.032205574214458466, -0.012315415777266026, 0.017610589042305946, -0.01983228698372841, 0.029255757108330727, 0.013878535479307175, 0.009291185066103935, -0.017977183684706688, 0.03293037787079811, 0.007912873290479183, -0.00501720467582345, 0.04020858556032181, -0.014842131175100803, 0.007484669331461191, -0.02899067848920822, 0.02347394824028015, 0.011510269716382027, -0.03961601108312607, 0.0056120529770851135, -0.016173701733350754, -0.05935565009713173, 0.011272519826889038, -0.018876181915402412, -0.002748607425019145, -0.0018771031172946095, 0.013420096598565578, -0.007476666010916233, -0.009832154959440231, -0.0072392551228404045, -0.02553861401975155, 0.014359643682837486, -0.004140665289014578, -0.04073880985379219, 0.026868805289268494, 0.027483943849802017, -0.014694112353026867, 0.020279431715607643, -0.0210120752453804, 0.004693512339144945, 0.04189491271972656, -0.03822384774684906, -0.030129479244351387, 0.004870080389082432, -0.007785161025822163, -0.022370874881744385, -0.05757027119398117, 0.00967333372682333, -0.006019883789122105, -0.034419264644384384, -0.0001501755614299327, 0.03017106093466282, 0.005538571160286665, 0.029871603474020958, -0.010236070491373539, 0.03406717628240585, 0.004265636205673218, -0.027739332988858223, 0.025339120998978615, 0.008086804300546646, 0.030425267294049263, 0.03035683184862137, 0.014926078729331493, 0.02449423260986805, 0.03729946166276932, 0.03276678919792175, 0.007036182563751936, 0.03390802815556526, -0.012242930941283703, 0.012297652661800385, 0.06126369908452034, -0.017324691638350487, 0.006910418625921011, 0.030706647783517838, 0.00795822311192751, 0.0506281852722168, -0.028709422796964645, 0.04133671149611473, -0.045801062136888504, -0.03632224351167679, -0.03405090793967247, 0.031899720430374146, -0.008936706930398941, 0.02420094981789589, -0.012444518506526947, 0.021419525146484375, -0.026758980005979538, 0.002311264630407095, 0.017672017216682434, -0.00598871661350131, 0.0359138548374176, -0.026784397661685944, 0.0008338931947946548, 0.0006641776999458671, -0.0180729441344738, 0.010389399714767933, -0.01403842680156231, 0.03908725827932358, 0.05169502645730972, 0.0076076979748904705, 0.006067843642085791, -0.018550364300608635, -0.013688256964087486, 0.018880318850278854, -0.060583360493183136, -0.029989758506417274, -0.05337094888091087, 0.010129259899258614, 0.01534534152597189, 0.01881513185799122 ]
<p>I'm wrestling with a question regarding random effects that I haven't been able to figure out with my regular resources. I am examining the effects of two treatments (heat and water) on plant biomass data that I've collected for 4 years in 20 plots (each plot has 4 quadrants that are not independent but are measured separately).</p> <p>My <code>lme</code> model (using <code>nlme</code> in <code>R</code>) has two nested categorical random effects: year is nested within plot and quad such that my R script is the following:</p> <pre><code>lme(biomass ~ heat*water + ... + elevation, data, random=~1|plot/quad/year) </code></pre> <p>There are no error messages given and the model appears to run smoothly. I only have 4 levels for year (80 for plot/quad) and have read that that a low number of levels will make it hard to get accurate estimates of variance. I tried adding year as a fixed effect and get completely different results (there is a lot of year-to-year variability in my dependent variable). </p> <p>My questions: </p> <ol> <li><p>Is the small size of the second-level random effect much of a problem? Is it only the number of levels of the main random effect that I should worry about?</p></li> <li><p>If you think having only 4 levels is a problem, how can I test to see if it is messing up my model? Collecting data for several more years just to correct this issue is not possible.</p></li> </ol> <p>Below are the summary output of the model:</p> <pre><code>&gt; summary(model) Linear mixed-effects model fit by REML Data: data AIC BIC logLik 2327.316 2359.081 -1154.658 Random effects: Formula: ~1 | plot (Intercept) StdDev: 13.89338 Formula: ~1 | quad %in% plot (Intercept) StdDev: 11.32595 Formula: ~1 | year %in% quad %in% plot (Intercept) Residual StdDev: 18.00256 7.39362 Fixed effects: forbs ~ h * w + elevation Value Std.Error DF t-value p-value (Intercept) 1290.2549 2576.2021 183 0.5008360 0.6171 hy -10.6171 10.5874 15 -1.0028063 0.3319 wy -13.6224 10.3395 15 -1.3175078 0.2074 elevation -0.3382 0.7265 15 -0.4654946 0.6483 hy:wy 37.1865 15.0869 15 2.4648273 0.0263 Correlation: (Intr) hy wy elevtn hy -0.222 wy -0.189 0.503 elevation -1.000 0.220 0.187 hy:wy 0.275 -0.728 -0.713 -0.274 Standardized Within-Group Residuals: Min Q1 Med Q3 Max -0.76090000 -0.23913835 -0.02857524 0.19955752 1.39996632 Number of Observations: 257 Number of Groups: plot quad %in% plot year %in% quad %in% plot 20 74 257 </code></pre> <p>Thanks for your help, and please let me know if I can provide any additional info. I'd be happy to send you my data and script if it helps.</p>
73,557
[ -0.04978877305984497, 0.00313204200938344, 0.014197854325175285, 0.02582477778196335, 0.019457591697573662, 0.006284275557845831, 0.0039301845245063305, -0.04841754958033562, 0.024136805906891823, -0.07271581143140793, 0.04320186376571655, 0.04665184020996094, 0.06898292154073715, 0.01433178037405014, 0.016512611880898476, -0.004564833827316761, 0.01028310228139162, 0.007242382038384676, 0.009137925691902637, 0.023449817672371864, -0.04921131208539009, 0.02761160582304001, 0.008363381959497929, -0.014202235266566277, -0.004118283279240131, 0.047486741095781326, 0.007436342071741819, -0.02680540643632412, 0.01734471693634987, 0.024009931832551956, -0.009745517745614052, -0.011637241579592228, 0.016236236318945885, -0.005899500567466021, 0.016697729006409645, 0.00861880648881197, 0.0008444958366453648, -0.025385476648807526, 0.012497731484472752, 0.03759334608912468, -0.021939095109701157, 0.022091113030910492, -0.033478882163763046, 0.03014129213988781, -0.010277302004396915, 0.015099379234015942, 0.019329369068145752, 0.01771378517150879, 0.10959247499704361, -0.009734086692333221, 0.054559726268053055, 0.007187969982624054, 0.032515715807676315, 0.04853828623890877, -0.03501478582620621, -0.006414977367967367, 0.04701091721653938, 0.07935483753681183, -0.013970883563160896, -0.016584960743784904, 0.00008605248876847327, -0.022377748042345047, 0.026717565953731537, -0.007981128059327602, -0.026844408363103867, -0.02491709776222706, 0.03857821226119995, -0.01068598311394453, 0.03265151008963585, -0.016129406169056892, 0.03576405346393585, -0.007973016239702702, 0.03046572022140026, 0.015978779643774033, 0.028327981010079384, -0.005694432649761438, 0.012557202950119972, 0.014045159332454205, 0.024031421169638634, 0.02355712652206421, -0.014763948507606983, 0.01722143590450287, 0.003619028255343437, -0.010414988733828068, 0.024105744436383247, -0.0006802994757890701, 0.0423547700047493, -0.027615047991275787, 0.025128740817308426, -0.01421799324452877, 0.006888242904096842, 0.045673470944166183, 0.07995650917291641, 0.039451900869607925, -0.02540070191025734, 0.017355112358927727, -0.025542326271533966, 0.00906490720808506, -0.0045496323145926, 0.025447331368923187, -0.0029070626478642225, -0.03390255942940712, 0.03898715600371361, 0.08000179380178452, -0.021946312859654427, -0.049647487699985504, -0.0047758654691278934, -0.012612876482307911, 0.0012462945887818933, -0.061249781399965286, -0.0031650483142584562, 0.03945336863398552, -0.022602764889597893, -0.03151669725775719, 0.007833055220544338, -0.04665183648467064, -0.01961672492325306, 0.028006218373775482, 0.06683040410280228, 0.05397086963057518, 0.03887501731514931, -0.03192179650068283, 0.024896638467907906, -0.05429809167981148, -0.0388210155069828, 0.02262096293270588, 0.014642227441072464, -0.04696609079837799, -0.043551597744226456, 0.04039663448929787, 0.057830631732940674, 0.0188773050904274, 0.050190892070531845, -0.04146633297204971, 0.03343938663601875, -0.006318048108369112, -0.05815504491329193, -0.06057390198111534, 0.03225331008434296, -0.02537943795323372, 0.025098754093050957, -0.045506708323955536, -0.008132314309477806, 0.007686127442866564, 0.025676056742668152, -0.034080520272254944, 0.031280647963285446, -0.004608639050275087, 0.02069728635251522, 0.0016927338438108563, -0.02370365522801876, 0.015145198442041874, -0.02806572988629341, -0.02835298888385296, -0.029553446918725967, -0.10230702906847, 0.039714425802230835, 0.0008838519570417702, 0.006685070227831602, 0.0328080952167511, 0.040425073355436325, 0.03915807977318764, 0.01936321333050728, 0.0018293880857527256, 0.013455599546432495, -0.041546739637851715, 0.06384352594614029, -0.028406338766217232, 0.027172977104783058, 0.03521079197525978, 0.006448834203183651, -0.01558610051870346, -0.008136671967804432, 0.018811006098985672, 0.03125558793544769, -0.017537793144583702, 0.041905418038368225, -0.002590480260550976, 0.002118946984410286, 0.044635336846113205, -0.07548181712627411, 0.0064699952490627766, -0.04176568239927292, -0.03963613882660866, 0.019147077575325966, -0.0027932478114962578, -0.03659646213054657, -0.02101355418562889, 0.035780977457761765, -0.02813379466533661, -0.03848964720964432, -0.06832807511091232, -0.006843973882496357, 0.021853026002645493, -0.004767483565956354, -0.00031843798933550715, -0.013354279100894928, 0.035870250314474106, 0.00014099049440119416, 0.004094433505088091, -0.047315698117017746, 0.02348615787923336, 0.04147680848836899, -0.018007822334766388, 0.0352897122502327, 0.02792588621377945, 0.04907397925853729, -0.005150686949491501, 0.03774627298116684, -0.020176688209176064, -0.010866895318031311, 0.014400304295122623, -0.0259383674710989, -0.008762937970459461, 0.007817788980901241, -0.03726759925484657, -0.007635288406163454, -0.001878063310869038, -0.024964597076177597, 0.025877030566334724, -0.05148926377296448, 0.05550530552864075, 0.049112383276224136, 0.0005128507036715746, -0.015229308046400547, 0.03820985555648804, 0.01654854603111744, 0.008200857788324356, -0.04726317524909973, -0.027564944699406624, -0.03818058222532272, 0.015693852677941322, 0.047111716121435165, 0.02936491183936596, -0.013340001925826073, 0.030688554048538208, 0.03759321942925453, -0.017944730818271637, 0.013945527374744415, 0.028909871354699135, -0.005456010345369577, 0.015144472941756248, 0.02003859356045723, 0.032042860984802246, -0.0005129813798703253, 0.011331767775118351, 0.025366326794028282, -0.02451738715171814, 0.01780078560113907, -0.02389284037053585, -0.01482122391462326, 0.03935137018561363, -0.0005778853083029389, -0.00370449828915298, -0.019845126196742058, 0.006108000874519348, 0.051358722150325775, -0.012393271550536156, 0.024857180193066597, 0.057445064187049866, 0.022302258759737015, -0.00261168135330081, -0.026149580255150795, -0.00703508872538805, 0.050703030079603195, 0.01144594606012106, -0.055560510605573654, -0.048496294766664505, 0.012625303119421005, -0.012107460759580135, 0.030363917350769043, -0.019168272614479065, -0.04630273953080177, -0.05309438332915306, 0.012431579641997814, 0.0017720231553539634, -0.0032924036495387554, 0.02408205159008503, -0.03738132119178772, 0.01268073171377182, -0.011679509654641151, 0.036495815962553024, 0.028584323823451996, -0.03343791887164116, -0.02798880822956562, 0.0004935252945870161, -0.023569757118821144, 0.009035558439791203, 0.00628162594512105, -0.01665240153670311, -0.05521903187036514, 0.04291098937392235, -0.0010866750963032246, -0.051389262080192566, -0.030027765780687332, -0.03411616012454033, -0.008159308694303036, -0.05433120205998421, -0.01978760026395321, 0.045305103063583374, 0.001938036410138011, -0.016576793044805527, -0.019343847408890724, -0.020011475309729576, 0.007900111377239227, 0.024050049483776093, 0.012573988176882267, -0.006208314094692469, 0.0006840478163212538, 0.005868196487426758, 0.004768725484609604, -0.02831767126917839, 0.010975297540426254, -0.07302860170602798, -0.07380695641040802, 0.004399365279823542, 0.02588612772524357, 0.044438838958740234, -0.018867280334234238, -0.020164940506219864, 0.04303203523159027, 0.04600702226161957, -0.009192576631903648, -0.050805602222681046, 0.002539014909416437, 0.0005047962768003345, -0.026839852333068848, 0.042114995419979095, -0.0033792725298553705, 0.01830943115055561, 0.034552376717329025, -0.009796245023608208, 0.04315200448036194, 0.0031720027327537537, -0.017909208312630653, 0.0068518719635903835, 0.03519808501005173, 0.01092945970594883, -0.04846693202853203, 0.013292149640619755, 0.017373565584421158, 0.01454085297882557, 0.0015236210310831666, -0.014397397637367249, 0.009626382030546665, -0.028280533850193024, -0.04619240388274193, 0.004833581391721964, -0.020544258877635002, 0.04354400187730789, -0.0400710254907608, 0.033633824437856674, 0.019175786525011063, -0.03891369327902794, 0.014089620672166348, -0.017760099843144417, 0.02852826751768589, 0.02681770920753479, 0.02130296267569065, 0.0392838679254055, 0.06396971642971039, -0.0221403781324625, 0.02815254218876362, -0.007531058508902788, 0.005188481882214546, 0.010902035050094128, -0.029828641563653946, 0.015677504241466522, 0.0421472042798996, 0.026846252381801605, 0.005527385976165533, -0.023018013685941696, -0.031712085008621216, -0.0032062078826129436, -0.05142799764871597, 0.007994141429662704, -0.05553561821579933, 0.038648635149002075, 0.014063162729144096, -0.006982293911278248, -0.022787978872656822, -0.03859870508313179, 0.0030228677205741405, -0.013286720961332321, -0.028520617634058, 0.0002955382224172354, 0.004757460672408342, 0.010451085865497589, 0.01112707145512104, -0.018912099301815033, 0.012952366843819618, -0.039255283772945404, 0.01071223709732294, 0.01025353092700243, 0.016127927228808403, -0.0034133046865463257, -0.0017476585926488042, -0.018327893689274788, -0.020869294181466103, 0.0013351659290492535, 0.01287347637116909, 0.018094206228852272, -0.0337161049246788, 0.030904144048690796, 0.03317791596055031, -0.0035774342250078917, -0.01578972488641739, -0.05743871256709099, -0.01966813951730728, 0.026381297037005424, 0.022738639265298843, 0.003736101556569338, -0.024703344330191612, -0.02972068078815937, 0.026658672839403152, 0.028340013697743416, 0.013519472442567348, 0.051197998225688934, 0.015921959653496742, -0.010949444957077503, -0.0080906692892313, 0.003012616652995348, 0.03668908402323723, 0.004692391958087683, 0.002515732776373625, -0.00919665303081274, 0.02596101351082325, 0.03423208370804787, -0.055308908224105835, 0.025466805323958397, 0.04657741263508797, -0.012759181670844555, 0.008792436681687832, -0.03381483629345894, -0.031393591314554214, -0.018958985805511475, 0.0142964543774724, 0.04709726944565773, 0.011566835455596447, -0.0018628498073667288, 0.006366428919136524, 0.0841587632894516, -0.04728490114212036, -0.04744385927915573, 0.0488622672855854, -0.007869512774050236, -0.012060234323143959, -0.010526841506361961, -0.010499401018023491, 0.0047735534608364105, 0.010891095735132694, -0.003767728805541992, 0.011542223393917084, 0.02590397745370865, -0.07855293899774551, -0.046486105769872665, 0.03204026073217392, 0.042448852211236954, -0.034129247069358826, 0.021892132237553596, -0.05416169390082359, -0.01979813724756241, -0.03105117380619049, -0.023868344724178314, 0.02814965322613716, -0.03778144344687462, 0.03597182035446167, -0.017527202144265175, -0.07935905456542969, -0.03806593641638756, 0.0018877092516049743, 0.0032583766151219606, 0.026185302063822746, 0.0015403914730995893, -0.011014933697879314, -0.01995941251516342, 0.05513456463813782, 0.02176581509411335, 0.028667693957686424, -0.02135820873081684, -0.02233961597084999, 0.028199046850204468, 0.001454178593121469, -0.0022163812536746264, -0.0505966916680336, 0.04557105526328087, -0.04883451759815216, 0.027402352541685104, 0.03909460827708244, -0.01604137197136879, -0.026417698711156845, 0.038361839950084686, 0.048185646533966064, -0.008027157746255398, -0.021818194538354874, 0.005819298326969147, 0.04462716355919838, 0.02699815109372139, 0.026505524292588234, 0.0558064728975296, 0.02795998938381672, 0.009847404435276985, 0.024076102301478386, -0.05941121280193329, 0.029973510652780533, -0.036776237189769745, -0.08289827406406403, -0.0725511908531189, -0.00453348271548748, -0.01542941015213728, 0.02092675119638443, -0.038504939526319504, 0.01586584560573101, -0.06903792917728424, -0.037890687584877014, 0.04273855313658714, 0.026282761245965958, 0.019358687102794647, -0.0208023339509964, -0.011687475256621838, 0.022363049909472466, -0.009869898669421673, 0.013899004086852074, -0.023013321682810783, -0.0020881129894405603, 0.01301780715584755, 0.0034305176232010126, -0.037667885422706604, 0.0018081042217090726, 0.004458203446120024, -0.02437986433506012, -0.021446185186505318, -0.010463790968060493, 0.00538165308535099, 0.011605332605540752, 0.01812131144106388, -0.026312144473195076, -0.02332436479628086, -0.009069663472473621, 0.007357408292591572, -0.012308118864893913, 0.032403554767370224, 0.018713319674134254, 0.01149974949657917, -0.006092713214457035, 0.014625540003180504, -0.043651409447193146, -0.05482577532529831, 0.0026303448248654604, -0.01444314606487751, -0.00916332472115755, -0.025144539773464203, -0.07889845967292786, -0.011864254251122475, 0.01413995772600174, 0.0033523603342473507, 0.05380008742213249, -0.04370340704917908, 0.023578781634569168, -0.027025720104575157, 0.026131192222237587, 0.0592932365834713, -0.02279849722981453, -0.014560805633664131, 0.01681814156472683, -0.0555216446518898, -0.03496134653687477, -0.019083790481090546, -0.004690307192504406, -0.037041474133729935, -0.0019603888504207134, -0.02412174828350544, 0.004994738847017288, 0.04678153991699219, -0.02517049014568329, -0.025109389796853065, 0.039128780364990234, 0.03166862949728966, 0.0007377703441306949, -0.045864686369895935, 0.014594821259379387, 0.012169509194791317, 0.02187289297580719, -0.01791122741997242, -0.004632708616554737, -0.0036743348464369774, -0.024780768901109695, -0.0031226868741214275, -0.0385880284011364, -0.03467173874378204, 0.028664089739322662, 0.10283814370632172, 0.01773929037153721, 0.01955978199839592, -0.02184106595814228, -0.011412008665502071, 0.007358659524470568, 0.012837697751820087, -0.026728864759206772, 0.04150741174817085, 0.0348353274166584, -0.04362388327717781, -0.04353749006986618, -0.0031945391092449427, 0.00571092776954174, 0.05621792748570442, -0.0019454791909083724, 0.02793268673121929, 0.03768434748053551, -0.025757277384400368, 0.021933309733867645, -0.035202667117118835, -0.022869952023029327, 0.0017735458677634597, 0.007449197582900524, 0.08303254842758179, -0.023609455674886703, -0.007020310964435339, 0.02240714617073536, -0.006854103412479162, -0.010523322969675064, 0.04186472296714783, 0.002942507853731513, 0.02061563730239868, 0.009935823269188404, -0.029042456299066544, -0.05594625324010849, 0.004853346385061741, -0.03341887518763542, 0.0086050508543849, -0.035984329879283905, -0.021632961928844452, 0.03835485503077507, 0.08519445359706879, -0.02118251472711563, -0.08225514739751816, -0.01975165493786335, -0.08230861276388168, 0.0057326387614011765, -0.0037756147794425488, 0.013674916699528694, 0.013077391311526299, 0.021327096968889236, 0.044474221765995026, 0.007925153709948063, 0.008087472058832645, -0.03071121871471405, -0.07059397548437119, -0.012551389634609222, -0.0017408306011930108, -0.008182558231055737, 0.02962701953947544, -0.013466074131429195, -0.030561277642846107, -0.013619044795632362, -0.05333640053868294, 0.01710662432014942, 0.0006832584040239453, 0.031105993315577507, 0.015777580440044403, 0.03253210708498955, -0.0017336043529212475, -0.02422393672168255, -0.03573949262499809, -0.007722153794020414, 0.14100176095962524, 0.06877283751964569, 0.04001426324248314, -0.08054953068494797, 0.03907216712832451, 0.07269345968961716, 0.0016810860252007842, -0.00967476237565279, -0.05816201493144035, -0.02070530317723751, -0.03495537489652634, 0.03737092763185501, 0.04850451648235321, 0.010126598179340363, -0.02318928763270378, 0.06529787182807922, -0.01246459037065506, -0.000642782892100513, 0.022663775831460953, -0.005058398470282555, 0.011182950809597969, 0.01825532503426075, -0.05791406333446503, 0.005775181110948324, 0.01510460302233696, -0.003041311865672469, -0.027208084240555763, 0.006370164919644594, -0.012429950758814812, 0.020950620993971825, -0.018441936001181602, 0.003041815012693405, 0.017049459740519524, 0.018902193754911423, 0.004177512601017952, -0.008216497488319874, -0.0043483916670084, -0.030577166005969048, 0.017680661752820015, 0.04988125339150429, -0.03322344273328781, -0.012305368669331074, 0.017737342044711113, 0.011290482245385647, -0.022443057969212532, -0.058400776237249374, -0.03061346337199211, 0.05136774107813835, -0.0038485880941152573, -0.044422220438718796, -0.007950922474265099, -0.015072048641741276, 0.004135962575674057, -0.015062077902257442, -0.0015324228443205357, 0.03920595347881317, 0.02393055334687233, -0.01982666179537773, -0.019613562151789665, 0.018116390332579613, 0.0341891311109066, -0.03452738747000694, 0.020644914358854294, 0.028312616050243378, -0.027989335358142853, -0.0345354825258255, -0.061125248670578, 0.09429126232862473, 0.03211113065481186, 0.03356928005814552, 0.007898593321442604, -0.013668798841536045, -0.003240560879930854, -0.019917022436857224, 0.0013497917680069804, 0.028532017022371292, 0.030126284807920456, -0.018195124343037605, -0.05123031139373779, -0.012670493684709072, -0.0529690757393837, -0.017423398792743683, 0.01255914568901062, -0.0027403458952903748, -0.05711444839835167, 0.007354936096817255, -0.005230095703154802, 0.03201897069811821, 0.011301061138510704, 0.026878688484430313, 0.0022135572507977486, 0.07208827137947083, -0.0006733055342920125, -0.0538964569568634, -0.029243631288409233, 0.012973638251423836, -0.02210993506014347, -0.057679735124111176, -0.0028289526235312223, 0.023086244240403175, 0.008822673000395298, 0.011239935643970966, 0.008124231360852718, 0.057318124920129776, -0.01591157168149948, -0.011336534284055233, 0.05291471257805824, -0.03813625127077103, 0.009258822537958622, -0.012386895716190338, -0.011150116100907326, -0.01894248090684414, 0.006173021625727415, -0.04130631312727928, -0.042651500552892685, -0.007219500374048948, 0.0003595445887185633, -0.03457365185022354, 0.014277178794145584, -0.030360164120793343, -0.021540023386478424, -0.02031632512807846, 0.008421280421316624, -0.03996841982007027, 0.0041823433712124825, 0.00038591449265368283, -0.02899833954870701, 0.006602651905268431, 0.030872168019413948, -0.027867035940289497, 0.0008152705850079656, 0.044232212007045746, -0.015425832942128181, -0.01445851381868124, -0.025955267250537872, 0.01972881518304348, 0.025037843734025955, 0.052446141839027405, -0.004683138336986303, -0.030453430488705635, 0.03734560310840607, -0.020279230549931526, -0.01566184312105179, 0.02387489192187786, -0.026429517194628716, 0.01388359535485506, 0.06111215427517891, -0.0015857419930398464, -0.02963491715490818, 0.06706546992063522, -0.006670006085187197, 0.0014490745961666107, -0.02153242751955986, 0.015011566691100597, 0.03165315464138985, 0.016560053452849388, -0.0023235122207552195, -0.005313740111887455, -0.0005030282191000879, 0.048801276832818985, 0.04344309866428375, -0.0005563749000430107, 0.009458818472921848, 0.009056083858013153, -0.053453244268894196, 0.025952810421586037, 0.0014884041156619787, 0.0022124892566353083, 0.024008722975850105, 0.07093218713998795, -0.02558167278766632, 0.03936774656176567, 0.01477106474339962, 0.024284036830067635, -0.0763208195567131, -0.015599740669131279, 0.019138075411319733, 0.05599156394600868, 0.005075459834188223, -0.03639691323041916, -0.011279083788394928, 0.03827374055981636, -0.0278170183300972, -0.004182160831987858, -0.013395016081631184, 0.004433616064488888, -0.05677377060055733, 0.022585691884160042, -0.024760013446211815, -0.021855365484952927, 0.020690979436039925, 0.03475765883922577, 0.01801231876015663, 0.03346806392073631, 0.0009340336546301842, -0.03109804540872574, 0.02605990134179592, -0.00926380604505539, 0.02819274179637432, -0.041356638073921204, 0.0074866642244160175, -0.03205854073166847, 0.00019382622849661857, 0.005459570791572332, -0.013177006505429745, 0.04771986976265907, 0.01187740359455347, 0.005427782889455557, 0.021185794845223427, 0.06581735610961914, 0.012673324905335903, -0.016552280634641647, 0.0054316408932209015, -0.02514467015862465, 0.017561744898557663, 0.03265451639890671, -0.025204332545399666, 0.0020541795529425144, 0.007311534136533737, 0.007828210480511189, 0.00043234246550127864, 0.01790618896484375, -0.03385250270366669, -0.01757505163550377, -0.0013020875630900264, -0.005770232994109392, -0.009095732122659683, -0.032227251678705215, -0.0184220802038908, -0.005787471309304237, 0.010015251114964485, 0.06287283450365067, 0.028658060356974602, -0.008182979188859463, -0.035533107817173004, 0.004839771892875433, -0.006085592787712812, 0.009864121675491333, -0.0008812119485810399, -0.035026270896196365, -0.045063599944114685, -0.0017084720311686397, -0.007555422838777304, 0.012167749926447868, -0.013533192686736584, 0.0249429140239954, -0.07200457900762558, 0.04463933780789375, -0.006361457519233227, 0.008047429844737053, -0.04818795621395111, 0.014159299433231354, 0.016396474093198776, -0.0979747548699379, 0.06279057264328003, 0.00725181307643652, -0.02322482317686081, -0.062378719449043274, -0.0161550585180521, -0.022335907444357872, 0.04668102040886879, 0.011897934600710869, 0.024498796090483665, 0.013086587190628052, 0.01106620579957962, 0.06505206972360611, 0.007746610790491104, -0.05375073850154877, 0.04144502803683281, 0.02316281944513321, 0.018611900508403778, -0.014795548282563686, -0.05196589231491089, 0.004769765771925449, -0.00820230133831501, 0.0020251483656466007, -0.009485905058681965, 0.012007259763777256, -0.005023402627557516, 0.0028142461087554693, 0.0165402851998806, -0.019218463450670242, -0.038006268441677094, 0.0240777637809515, -0.004195311572402716, 0.002359077101573348, 0.0013538033235818148, 0.013614135794341564, -0.03603559359908104, -0.007684333249926567, -0.035535912960767746, -0.025871846824884415, 0.024846360087394714, 0.011276256293058395, 0.012529135681688786, -0.061061348766088486, 0.03853175789117813, 0.017491290345788002, -0.019395137205719948, -0.02656954899430275, 0.04993780329823494, 0.033289846032857895, 0.06062186136841774, 0.01602928340435028, 0.008846593089401722, 0.011495172046124935, -0.004849719814956188, 0.023311622440814972, 0.004710185807198286, 0.022127114236354828, 0.0016341254813596606, -0.027029892429709435, 0.020455269142985344, -0.008990158326923847, -0.006168130319565535, 0.004923585802316666, 0.06210092082619667, -0.009711822494864464, -0.0252491794526577, 0.04987505450844765, -0.017753124237060547, 0.014626260846853256, 0.0015960680320858955, 0.00645523751154542, 0.061962347477674484, -0.027633624151349068, -0.00295543042011559, -0.02321486920118332, -0.028222598135471344, 0.008892019279301167, 0.029866071417927742, -0.0029077210929244757, 0.046015843749046326, 0.012413877993822098, 0.0006271383026614785, -0.017990754917263985, -0.013946485705673695, 0.0293666310608387, -0.05381835997104645, 0.027457645162940025, -0.016280625015497208, 0.016454821452498436, -0.0017561408458277583, -0.021083539351820946, -0.013645446859300137, -0.06923136860132217, 0.007193244528025389, 0.006721867714077234, 0.009642216376960278, -0.014298895373940468, -0.0650034174323082, 0.032672859728336334, 0.05398276075720787, -0.018343579024076462, -0.03874925151467323, -0.04836682602763176, 0.0200591329485178, 0.019962014630436897, -0.02969735860824585 ]
<p>I have an integral equation of the form $$ T_1(x) = \int_0^x g(T_1(y)) \ d\hat{F}_n(y) $$ where $\hat{F}_n$ is the empirical cdf and $g$ is a function. I have a contraction mapping and so I am trying to solve the integral equation by using the Banach Fixed Point theorem sequence. </p> <p>However, this runs very slowly in R and I am thinking it is because I am integrating using the sum() function for $x \in \hat{F}_n$ over and over again.</p> <p>Is there a faster way to integrate using the empirical distribution with a function such as integrate()? </p>
35,956
[ -0.03600391745567322, 0.018483037129044533, 0.025682879611849785, -0.02384559065103531, 0.008041842840611935, -0.0026610412169247866, -0.009128895588219166, -0.04651281237602234, 0.017016729339957237, 0.0055746580474078655, 0.06995439529418945, 0.06389562785625458, 0.06990335136651993, 0.009675481356680393, 0.024845454841852188, -0.04480365663766861, -0.010684718377888203, 0.0034222870599478483, -0.01241067424416542, -0.009138239547610283, -0.019536441192030907, 0.017416618764400482, -0.010541743598878384, -0.03661426901817322, -0.005545929539948702, -0.0036006749141961336, 0.002106825355440378, -0.02064044401049614, 0.022711772471666336, 0.09741737693548203, -0.05743112415075302, -0.021975798532366753, 0.020999658852815628, 0.025878585875034332, -0.014793370850384235, 0.03718335181474686, -0.03839677944779396, -0.0451451800763607, -0.01119853463023901, 0.001976525876671076, -0.054879870265722275, -0.040079265832901, -0.008744503371417522, 0.03383500874042511, 0.040546804666519165, 0.05672752857208252, 0.012190877459943295, 0.016681229695677757, 0.014457577839493752, -0.0329362228512764, 0.07884421944618225, 0.000212481536436826, 0.04249092563986778, 0.02924482710659504, -0.00542233232408762, -0.03536919131875038, 0.03612079098820686, 0.03928396850824356, 0.03257241100072861, -0.029603373259305954, -0.014172355644404888, -0.09745215624570847, -0.009529036469757557, -0.013222935609519482, -0.01489193644374609, 0.05143843591213226, 0.018194960430264473, -0.024900544434785843, -0.012865222990512848, -0.034737758338451385, -0.02311348170042038, 0.008319135755300522, 0.009710307233035564, -0.03489311411976814, 0.02118081972002983, -0.0009485034388490021, 0.04700257629156113, 0.043866030871868134, 0.03282112255692482, 0.047509100288152695, 0.008039629086852074, 0.018967576324939728, 0.05654388293623924, 0.005388218909502029, 0.026616506278514862, 0.021834449842572212, 0.05156600847840309, -0.003563933540135622, -0.01796664111316204, 0.03524100407958031, -0.012517445720732212, 0.02106606215238571, 0.06610215455293655, 0.020473727956414223, -0.004484664648771286, 0.030775411054491997, 0.012394282966852188, 0.02375948615372181, 0.0012181417550891638, -0.017295705154538155, -0.00420367531478405, -0.06298364698886871, -0.0017644308973103762, 0.05319884791970253, -0.0058441367000341415, 0.010680953972041607, -0.029575632885098457, -0.047992561012506485, -0.005727396812289953, -0.010796299204230309, -0.044847458600997925, 0.002395980292931199, -0.019888242706656456, 0.02192206121981144, 0.02514534257352352, -0.01423072349280119, -0.024187399074435234, -0.027885016053915024, 0.04231080785393715, 0.0938667505979538, 0.08599862456321716, -0.006706881336867809, 0.0565057173371315, -0.028637588024139404, -0.04223645105957985, 0.01269233226776123, -0.01940838061273098, -0.018222486600279808, -0.04428182914853096, 0.05042412132024765, 0.030207542702555656, -0.07992223650217056, 0.04804238677024841, -0.016489069908857346, 0.037139393389225006, -0.002093650633469224, -0.01245852094143629, -0.08412119001150131, 0.035483285784721375, -0.02098109759390354, 0.006210437044501305, -0.07709943503141403, 0.026703590527176857, -0.0142423240467906, 0.056567855179309845, 0.045619942247867584, 0.018152348697185516, -0.0039802901446819305, 0.050953034311532974, -0.0035191827919334173, -0.04734070226550102, -0.046004269272089005, 0.006550421006977558, 0.001099216635338962, -0.025661364197731018, -0.06541254371404648, 0.049618903547525406, 0.049415744841098785, -0.035895247012376785, -0.04133587330579758, 0.05118173733353615, 0.022658389061689377, -0.00877831969410181, -0.011520171537995338, 0.020294934511184692, -0.026585642248392105, 0.026110544800758362, 0.02699100784957409, 0.02874954417347908, 0.018891049548983574, -0.028629183769226074, 0.04059486463665962, -0.005738799460232258, 0.033924419432878494, 0.023985840380191803, -0.07433267682790756, 0.016396138817071915, -0.013641409575939178, 0.007798629347234964, 0.06026596575975418, 0.02436077781021595, -0.01105805579572916, -0.023555085062980652, -0.04148142412304878, 0.015089950524270535, 0.04150957241654396, -0.0026593785732984543, -0.01790090650320053, 0.013066872954368591, -0.07294206321239471, -0.04470349848270416, -0.0703989714384079, 0.0019710478372871876, 0.018119260668754578, -0.006773036904633045, 0.021847635507583618, 0.0050606499426066875, 0.052667293697595596, 0.02159976027905941, 0.036528944969177246, -0.026500506326556206, -0.007785968482494354, 0.028656991198658943, -0.06327161192893982, -0.0009817411191761494, 0.03234584257006645, 0.05022599920630455, -0.020176736637949944, 0.03256286308169365, -0.030285431072115898, 0.001783972606062889, -0.04284415766596794, -0.0444038100540638, 0.02312108315527439, -0.007420108187943697, 0.0045069982297718525, 0.009384012781083584, -0.034889593720436096, 0.009366526268422604, 0.0026688892394304276, -0.03658859804272652, 0.039925962686538696, 0.07128501683473587, 0.046673957258462906, 0.017963649705052376, -0.006630295887589455, 0.023998800665140152, 0.0011827163398265839, -0.011650064028799534, -0.017404869198799133, -0.0500665083527565, -0.01709705777466297, 0.03760390356183052, 0.06458137184381485, -0.010071803815662861, -0.012421841733157635, 0.07772877812385559, 0.013660923577845097, 0.00829165056347847, 0.03952639922499657, -0.027946367859840393, -0.020045872777700424, 0.00812665093690157, 0.010342228226363659, 0.005889955908060074, 0.0051978351548314095, 0.007066396996378899, 0.0024199665058404207, 0.06317280232906342, 0.028991982340812683, -0.03391579911112785, 0.0076622734777629375, 0.013837302103638649, 0.0013946129474788904, -0.005233404692262411, 0.018353931605815887, 0.010497398674488068, -0.04220836982131004, -0.00358870648778975, 0.011768064461648464, -0.0013619714882224798, 0.005455216392874718, 0.0062611522153019905, -0.03523188829421997, 0.052586499601602554, 0.017898527905344963, 0.0175003744661808, -0.0027161934413015842, 0.023088067770004272, -0.015117451548576355, 0.025013815611600876, -0.030172258615493774, -0.006422943435609341, -0.04851685091853142, 0.02729649469256401, -0.015995832160115242, 0.035055972635746, 0.003941696137189865, -0.06407316774129868, -0.00034539715852588415, 0.02292584255337715, -0.01669042557477951, 0.054788507521152496, 0.007796058431267738, -0.0631503090262413, -0.002253351965919137, -0.03408030420541763, -0.02321062795817852, 0.05032580718398094, 0.0021035470999777317, -0.025189870968461037, -0.00762166827917099, 0.012836630456149578, -0.059622056782245636, 0.01654578000307083, -0.022172942757606506, 0.015089171007275581, -0.061048511415719986, 0.011690140701830387, 0.04437582194805145, 0.002088697627186775, -0.05097510665655136, 0.0344487763941288, -0.04634525626897812, -0.049054306000471115, -0.04747595638036728, -0.004490389488637447, 0.019194943830370903, 0.005306609906256199, -0.006889767479151487, -0.013542494736611843, -0.05508141219615936, 0.020604901015758514, -0.09136078506708145, -0.030853712931275368, 0.01241826731711626, -0.018330400809645653, 0.015116986818611622, 0.0006441948935389519, -0.04459376633167267, 0.04404422640800476, 0.07076657563447952, -0.04158715903759003, -0.03340979665517807, -0.009898001328110695, -0.002372174523770809, 0.008827812038362026, 0.012996060773730278, 0.02164682000875473, -0.007766186259686947, 0.0018790088361129165, -0.012315362691879272, 0.016963426023721695, 0.09381886571645737, 0.0007321775774471462, 0.017625469714403152, 0.027752798050642014, -0.02466474287211895, 0.007720679976046085, 0.042743515223264694, 0.02396298199892044, -0.020955082029104233, 0.007002831436693668, 0.005121693015098572, -0.014294249936938286, 0.004429900087416172, -0.040298640727996826, 0.011764083988964558, 0.006431016605347395, 0.018748600035905838, -0.03384977579116821, 0.03537863492965698, 0.020905323326587677, -0.025305580347776413, -0.005020562559366226, 0.07457027584314346, 0.05391542240977287, -0.036503713577985764, 0.0158797949552536, 0.015079515054821968, 0.039617039263248444, -0.03184984251856804, 0.012092928402125835, -0.004842149559408426, -0.04153319448232651, 0.018612971529364586, -0.04340818524360657, -0.030206555500626564, 0.022948570549488068, 0.05461496114730835, 0.027975529432296753, -0.0004657623067032546, -0.011042599566280842, 0.02355533465743065, -0.017249785363674164, -0.024111641570925713, -0.00165476743131876, 0.030603446066379547, 0.035639870911836624, 0.013484669849276543, 0.02511836402118206, -0.03143748641014099, -0.009776067920029163, -0.009888569824397564, -0.0926491916179657, 0.03710831701755524, 0.0028084765654057264, -0.03518735617399216, -0.01828884705901146, 0.020650815218687057, 0.03246483579277992, -0.013216710649430752, 0.028792791068553925, -0.01872672140598297, 0.02460673823952675, -0.006863427814096212, 0.018953945487737656, -0.012998462654650211, 0.002890929114073515, -0.0129389064386487, 0.03189397230744362, 0.04004034772515297, -0.01522322278469801, 0.01788574829697609, 0.0421365424990654, -0.010482670739293098, 0.01846384070813656, -0.023451022803783417, -0.015310903079807758, -0.006497001275420189, 0.026898613199591637, 0.012720860540866852, 0.0497804693877697, 0.0011165430769324303, -0.007166923955082893, 0.006472785025835037, 0.0526764877140522, 0.04259299859404564, -0.04693573713302612, 0.008973234333097935, -0.07055775821208954, -0.021555425599217415, 0.0202944315969944, 0.026411594823002815, -0.0023714639246463776, -0.02474926970899105, 0.056671831756830215, 0.020974239334464073, -0.019726119935512543, 0.003726612078025937, 0.06808916479349136, 0.006123384926468134, -0.006144088692963123, -0.05854595825076103, -0.02450132742524147, -0.004037949722260237, 0.011150029487907887, 0.0385439395904541, 0.008093615993857384, -0.02805555984377861, 0.010171497240662575, 0.03638027608394623, -0.013862960040569305, 0.01528286561369896, -0.025004059076309204, 0.014991188421845436, 0.02718639001250267, -0.0030968282371759415, -0.0439896285533905, 0.03106161206960678, 0.06489931046962738, 0.011885074898600578, 0.00779616879299283, 0.013332451693713665, -0.06036188453435898, 0.02201532945036888, 0.07316231727600098, 0.026727890595793724, -0.026044728234410286, 0.00040936359437182546, -0.04143080487847328, -0.006610474549233913, 0.06265680491924286, -0.0201264601200819, 0.00363373477011919, -0.029288941994309425, -0.021780528128147125, -0.008177674375474453, -0.02944663166999817, -0.05548463016748428, 0.006644661072641611, 0.007892968133091927, 0.045086465775966644, -0.06350374966859818, 0.016996154561638832, -0.015523298643529415, 0.04826447740197182, 0.00033367579453624785, 0.0400736927986145, -0.05626116320490837, -0.012555016204714775, 0.009648644365370274, 0.005846693180501461, -0.0005615069530904293, -0.031303372234106064, 0.019041771069169044, -0.007239412050694227, -0.012580705806612968, 0.01360595878213644, -0.00012736803910229355, -0.031370796263217926, 0.023002075031399727, -0.00007307906344067305, 0.01122544426470995, -0.006210289429873228, -0.04742550104856491, 0.028152799233794212, 0.04415331408381462, 0.017848677933216095, 0.024384748190641403, 0.04074878990650177, 0.00992186926305294, 0.07033491879701614, -0.036019109189510345, 0.03937873616814613, -0.043492354452610016, -0.003666945733129978, -0.005806961562484503, -0.033443599939346313, -0.023640643805265427, 0.03572699800133705, 0.033011965453624725, 0.028820587322115898, -0.043309424072504044, 0.0338037870824337, 0.0517919547855854, 0.022739998996257782, 0.003803010331466794, -0.009365798905491829, 0.017302487045526505, 0.05550002306699753, 0.003624055767431855, -0.02610120177268982, 0.03901732340455055, -0.005949527490884066, 0.00428533973172307, 0.03547247499227524, -0.011799640953540802, 0.0031630611047148705, -0.04205932840704918, -0.007603808771818876, -0.005634278059005737, -0.038141366094350815, 0.01768595725297928, -0.003604260506108403, 0.040692009031772614, 0.021702226251363754, -0.0228979904204607, -0.01795005053281784, -0.0037064191419631243, 0.021569445729255676, 0.0354754701256752, -0.05723429098725319, 0.009138300083577633, 0.007578305434435606, 0.003002217737957835, -0.07435881346464157, -0.045510146766901016, -0.0034948710817843676, -0.030601579695940018, -0.0022729046177119017, -0.06710321456193924, 0.030479012057185173, -0.003257790580391884, -0.006291304249316454, -0.02308141253888607, 0.0252138189971447, 0.017045514658093452, 0.01755634695291519, 0.002990469802170992, 0.0006376386154443026, 0.03427693992853165, -0.00044356868602335453, 0.0278560072183609, 0.04698854684829712, -0.0063102697022259235, -0.04059216007590294, 0.011196797713637352, 0.020411238074302673, -0.04522445425391197, -0.010401287116110325, -0.018430203199386597, -0.0191568061709404, 0.016194652765989304, 0.011750617995858192, -0.026903966441750526, 0.02743995189666748, 0.0013774691615253687, 0.02176748402416706, -0.029034091159701347, 0.00013839862367603928, 0.011011417955160141, -0.005020001903176308, -0.01305716298520565, 0.014136070385575294, 0.005030504893511534, -0.01675303280353546, -0.008715850301086903, -0.027265312150120735, -0.003045970806851983, 0.032531194388866425, 0.051905207335948944, 0.004250105004757643, -0.027700871229171753, 0.00264620129019022, 0.005400525406002998, 0.05170677974820137, 0.009723109193146229, -0.055384304374456406, -0.010355127044022083, 0.005012149922549725, -0.048441771417856216, -0.010921196080744267, -0.04566174000501633, 0.011357154697179794, 0.05786461383104324, -0.0020441818051040173, 0.06258033215999603, 0.015825478360056877, 0.024498075246810913, -0.00884523056447506, 0.026750419288873672, 0.01164071075618267, -0.0029833419248461723, -0.012225729413330555, 0.004625947680324316, 0.01671270653605461, 0.001529986271634698, 0.02168249525129795, 0.013272293843328953, 0.03073592111468315, 0.016122709959745407, -0.010533995926380157, 0.008372779004275799, 0.022658871486783028, -0.02025618962943554, -0.03691699728369713, 0.0059035406447947025, -0.03671935573220253, 0.05161670967936516, -0.010689943097531796, -0.039634279906749725, 0.04895692691206932, 0.01960308477282524, -0.05219537392258644, -0.023335842415690422, -0.025423860177397728, -0.019161328673362732, -0.0006342946435324848, 0.032717783004045486, -0.04673561826348305, 0.05743233114480972, 0.00019922743376810104, 0.0024334408808499575, -0.017749618738889694, 0.024510081857442856, -0.0507371723651886, -0.0638597160577774, 0.009737427346408367, -0.030804291367530823, -0.0684107318520546, 0.01185923907905817, -0.001461812644265592, -0.006012891419231892, 0.022542042657732964, -0.024286409839987755, 0.014648028649389744, -0.012098729610443115, 0.0066577354446053505, -0.011516482569277287, 0.10177253186702728, -0.009813589043915272, 0.03517090901732445, -0.02662627212703228, 0.018495019525289536, 0.10552643239498138, 0.024213915690779686, 0.01737370155751705, -0.04170268401503563, -0.0388609878718853, -0.013042474165558815, -0.008387051522731781, -0.04818511754274368, -0.0009120549657382071, -0.014022043906152248, -0.00009533915726933628, 0.04069068282842636, 0.05767132714390755, 0.001401976915076375, 0.010606958530843258, 0.01836911030113697, -0.03415004163980484, -0.002037949860095978, 0.021636653691530228, 0.009733556769788265, -0.0031504754442721605, -0.014655735343694687, -0.046218883246183395, 0.031096963211894035, -0.03077060915529728, -0.012506217695772648, -0.027572989463806152, 0.007243379019200802, 0.013151198625564575, -0.014357798732817173, -0.03646538034081459, 0.010335364378988743, 0.0022797316778451204, -0.0305114034563303, 0.01596892438828945, 0.00851749163120985, 0.016052408143877983, -0.003305460326373577, 0.031893230974674225, 0.028872760012745857, 0.00932874996215105, 0.015250187367200851, 0.010746159590780735, 0.006225238554179668, -0.022457581013441086, -0.022914158180356026, -0.020482193678617477, 0.04943795129656792, -0.0050788684748113155, 0.017633002251386642, 0.023644844070076942, 0.007718277163803577, 0.03397829458117485, -0.055224452167749405, -0.00144137442111969, 0.005502270068973303, 0.021798040717840195, -0.010575148276984692, -0.017811575904488564, -0.042465418577194214, 0.033913299441337585, -0.03149525076150894, 0.0217652078717947, -0.011951555497944355, -0.0026404510717839003, -0.00687019806355238, 0.016663484275341034, 0.04331950843334198, 0.0010150851448997855, -0.046412140130996704, 0.010364768095314503, -0.029575033113360405, 0.01696549542248249, 0.001228664885275066, 0.026329021900892258, -0.04471806436777115, 0.03664655238389969, -0.014156211167573929, -0.014330551959574223, -0.04816357418894768, -0.048931095749139786, -0.0007843442726880312, 0.00596814276650548, -0.00037780203274451196, -0.0287089254707098, -0.04641225188970566, 0.02605898305773735, -0.011249436065554619, 0.03598954156041145, -0.0074457465671002865, -0.02569529414176941, 0.03897787630558014, 0.042083654552698135, -0.016860688105225563, -0.060448914766311646, -0.026285890489816666, 0.02978864312171936, -0.013268530368804932, -0.03152885288000107, 0.02449788525700569, -0.010110730305314064, 0.017155224457383156, 0.013047892600297928, 0.01739417389035225, -0.017529321834445, 0.024716824293136597, -0.033205535262823105, -0.019705550745129585, 0.0015100834425538778, -0.013617542572319508, 0.012476779520511627, -0.01644836738705635, 0.00017417827621102333, -0.051088254898786545, 0.010347203351557255, -0.005756382830440998, 0.03454187139868736, -0.03840876743197441, 0.04259385168552399, 0.005675117485225201, 0.044456493109464645, -0.01505978498607874, 0.03758205845952034, -0.039471548050642014, -0.02072114311158657, -0.02324136160314083, 0.00005523183062905446, 0.004879653453826904, 0.040029287338256836, 0.0038989048916846514, -0.009346346370875835, 0.05719662085175514, 0.0209499578922987, 0.002690511057153344, -0.031542740762233734, 0.03157792612910271, -0.044380106031894684, 0.01951322704553604, -0.023829752579331398, 0.004101162776350975, 0.061779603362083435, -0.03841434791684151, -0.017222773283720016, -0.012585523538291454, -0.0020337668247520924, 0.017852365970611572, 0.0007239383412525058, -0.023448605090379715, -0.038558728992938995, 0.04186498373746872, -0.024354565888643265, -0.0035870459396392107, 0.010159613564610481, -0.02662062831223011, 0.026707559823989868, 0.02373681031167507, -0.012246746569871902, -0.00369842117652297, 0.01471643801778555, -0.00949709303677082, 0.027679961174726486, -0.02021750621497631, 0.002246635966002941, 0.02085646241903305, -0.010472201742231846, -0.01577158272266388, -0.01542588323354721, -0.0161447711288929, 0.028602302074432373, 0.06496292352676392, -0.013990845531225204, 0.029064403846859932, -0.01551857776939869, 0.02129620872437954, -0.07335495203733444, -0.01654316484928131, -0.020731108263134956, -0.0008138352422975004, 0.07079976797103882, -0.05425410345196724, -0.004745047073811293, 0.02980962209403515, -0.0425734668970108, 0.04267523065209389, -0.023777225986123085, -0.010046875104308128, -0.07130272686481476, -0.0016989614814519882, 0.00012890818470623344, -0.025518594309687614, 0.05089889094233513, 0.04306134954094887, 0.019609108567237854, 0.03308694437146187, 0.008116776123642921, -0.01586773991584778, 0.013530269265174866, -0.0017882362008094788, 0.01046197209507227, -0.06347508728504181, 0.04445243254303932, -0.021328935399651527, -0.0005250101094134152, -0.007671238388866186, -0.0013453846331685781, 0.0015035206452012062, 0.0162151250988245, 0.033631984144449234, 0.0025771749205887318, 0.04589974135160446, 0.029937436804175377, -0.01622304692864418, 0.03624163195490837, 0.025366580113768578, 0.014634222723543644, -0.008881830610334873, -0.024130215868353844, 0.004677365999668837, 0.016169564798474312, 0.014570778235793114, -0.06927048414945602, 0.01879626326262951, 0.0453714020550251, 0.004548488184809685, -0.029598692432045937, -0.054903481155633926, -0.013088686391711235, -0.0005387724959291518, -0.0037993676960468292, -0.015158943831920624, 0.030353836715221405, 0.02869793213903904, 0.02579564042389393, -0.021724281832575798, 0.0022005930077284575, -0.032114941626787186, -0.032716426998376846, -0.022730853408575058, 0.01030066516250372, 0.0009492948302067816, -0.029677072539925575, -0.00048771800356917083, 0.021529190242290497, 0.0010214013746008277, -0.003451758297160268, -0.0005551982903853059, -0.030365172773599625, 0.026714356616139412, -0.036373432725667953, -0.01013224758207798, 0.03041050210595131, -0.01806717738509178, -0.014338378794491291, -0.06737318634986877, 0.051853977143764496, -0.013706889003515244, -0.010944632813334465, -0.005994932260364294, -0.007864954881370068, -0.056357190012931824, -0.028568871319293976, 0.04527439549565315, -0.02434505522251129, 0.018706880509853363, 0.003266620682552457, 0.002955331699922681, 0.028054751455783844, -0.05308469384908676, 0.013194520026445389, -0.013382785022258759, 0.004485485143959522, -0.0017111784545704722, -0.005911761429160833, 0.009773788042366505, 0.025390466675162315, 0.004617504775524139, -0.020769814029335976, 0.00006907247006893158, -0.007977519184350967, -0.0454258993268013, 0.005293137859553099, 0.0356287881731987, 0.007877320051193237, 0.08341085910797119, -0.03137202188372612, -0.03618105873465538, 0.019067363813519478, -0.010254766792058945, -0.010045208968222141, 0.019726166501641273, -0.028063682839274406, -0.022108836099505424, -0.008840013295412064, 0.014192354865372181, -0.013637324795126915, -0.07787134498357773, -0.01611078344285488, 0.0025419166777282953, -0.024328112602233887, -0.0009826605673879385, 0.01211500819772482, -0.00233146152459085, 0.04976515471935272, 0.01433807983994484, 0.011802302673459053, -0.008511797524988651, 0.006555145140737295, -0.024413952603936195, -0.0032423110678792, 0.0023554677609354258, -0.04945603758096695, 0.0123964948579669, -0.0037878495641052723, -0.02015753835439682, 0.03441993147134781, 0.0018219453049823642, 0.08113976567983627, -0.03716346621513367, -0.07767942547798157, 0.02093057706952095, -0.017285170033574104, 0.028916606679558754, -0.01132168434560299, -0.017656641080975533, 0.07546073198318481, -0.030961379408836365, 0.050872135907411575, -0.0006691031157970428, -0.02312835119664669, -0.049250055104494095, 0.03715135529637337, 0.02470700442790985, 0.017338750883936882, 0.002289022086188197, 0.0011233126278966665, -0.02457667514681816, 0.004009857773780823, -0.01946764811873436, -0.0511091873049736, -0.004709766246378422, -0.007709136698395014, -0.01772882230579853, 0.007623886689543724, -0.009854043833911419, -0.053553853183984756, -0.021038459613919258, -0.024851834401488304, 0.048179760575294495, 0.019568759948015213, -0.04495356231927872, -0.03315068781375885, -0.0089266924187541, 0.04933273792266846, -0.08180434256792068, -0.012627830728888512, -0.027757326140999794, -0.006279073189944029, 0.0016773708630353212, -0.015736142173409462 ]
<p>I have been trying to find good resources on the internet describing what Wisard Neural Networks are and their differences with traditional Neural Networks but failed to find anything substantial. Can anybody please explain their main characteristics please? </p>
6,783
[ 0.011640692129731178, -0.05891415476799011, -0.024242788553237915, -0.026916779577732086, 0.03697230666875839, -0.03095994144678116, -0.013188436627388, -0.018909860402345657, 0.04447909817099571, -0.030402841046452522, 0.028533361852169037, 0.037853341549634933, 0.020045969635248184, 0.03364741429686546, 0.010681705549359322, -0.0015989692183211446, -0.019826970994472504, 0.0021806356962770224, -0.0031976678874343634, -0.010932277888059616, -0.01647462137043476, 0.028646819293498993, 0.010366073809564114, -0.014013108797371387, -0.021192757412791252, 0.02163936197757721, -0.032370153814554214, -0.014281212352216244, 0.02173050306737423, 0.045451752841472626, -0.0028460766188800335, -0.01639615185558796, -0.017258139327168465, 0.04231769219040871, -0.011581984348595142, -0.014694353565573692, -0.030605770647525787, -0.06751154363155365, -0.02582789771258831, 0.012470687739551067, -0.009702157229185104, -0.009143726900219917, -0.006742308847606182, 0.02279212884604931, -0.03773176297545433, 0.030847037211060524, -0.015815960243344307, -0.07245923578739166, 0.0007360535673797131, -0.04887283220887184, 0.060777824372053146, 0.0008052047342061996, 0.0172641072422266, 0.028567679226398468, -0.004906675312668085, 0.031208988279104233, 0.0586477667093277, 0.034913137555122375, -0.017495468258857727, -0.07908042520284653, -0.0030511650256812572, -0.014677795581519604, 0.01890503242611885, -0.029215224087238312, -0.0381922721862793, 0.0343344509601593, 0.00819998700171709, -0.07114068418741226, 0.01730934903025627, -0.011978116817772388, 0.0415223054587841, 0.006108236499130726, 0.025157779455184937, -0.03261345997452736, -0.024806179106235504, -0.027157669886946678, -0.014875777065753937, -0.00406223488971591, 0.05142494663596153, 0.012917781248688698, 0.02106988988816738, 0.04768173024058342, 0.0029662000015378, 0.04170290753245354, 0.036817584186792374, -0.014840691350400448, 0.08758506923913956, -0.006201078649610281, 0.004087427631020546, 0.016894666478037834, -0.039448875933885574, -0.011481044813990593, 0.04729592427611351, -0.018291130661964417, -0.022457357496023178, -0.009593306109309196, 0.006667225155979395, 0.015244796872138977, 0.043285589665174484, -0.029289068654179573, 0.02770885080099106, -0.011031920090317726, -0.008967899717390537, 0.060600582510232925, -0.014554417692124844, -0.040424659848213196, -0.024923978373408318, 0.017462799325585365, -0.037092842161655426, 0.018368231132626534, -0.043917328119277954, 0.03370923176407814, 0.007863681763410568, 0.012585634365677834, 0.017582645639777184, -0.02203245274722576, -0.008224441669881344, -0.004858786705881357, -0.0004041639913339168, 0.09466001391410828, 0.02668876387178898, -0.043425533920526505, 0.03756946697831154, -0.021156052127480507, -0.056698910892009735, 0.009284231811761856, 0.01828901469707489, 0.01709521934390068, -0.032442186027765274, 0.043419621884822845, 0.00199749693274498, -0.04134528338909149, 0.0551532544195652, 0.01706661842763424, 0.008139630779623985, -0.021175986155867577, -0.07571760565042496, -0.039021413773298264, 0.05302440747618675, -0.02339080162346363, 0.04715605080127716, -0.0628453940153122, 0.0365193635225296, 0.020665166899561882, 0.0667017251253128, 0.037224180996418, 0.022253848612308502, 0.027126701548695564, -0.00017077017400879413, -0.013188345357775688, -0.050535451620817184, -0.005757393781095743, 0.004560879897326231, -0.008946786634624004, 0.004179154057055712, -0.04901571944355965, 0.04442368820309639, 0.016224361956119537, -0.030698658898472786, -0.04309087619185448, 0.022391419857740402, -0.019489964470267296, -0.011698119342327118, 0.020440034568309784, -0.017781447619199753, -0.009928037412464619, 0.06216009706258774, 0.008275661617517471, 0.013399751856923103, 0.03677605092525482, -0.0184326209127903, 0.02379557490348816, 0.047896187752485275, 0.04232976958155632, 0.0117308609187603, 0.0019325257744640112, -0.02929157204926014, -0.003098726039752364, 0.057648979127407074, 0.016709353774785995, -0.05168478190898895, -0.0427636057138443, -0.008247564546763897, 0.015020049177110195, -0.02138606272637844, 0.04037521407008171, 0.011854304932057858, -0.022026576101779938, 0.01622244156897068, -0.04601290076971054, -0.007538794074207544, -0.031351521611213684, 0.011112521402537823, -0.022498738020658493, -0.01208341121673584, 0.020484033972024918, 0.028171047568321228, 0.004773131106048822, -0.015038578771054745, -0.02273256704211235, -0.048524435609579086, 0.030534891411662102, 0.02280833013355732, -0.023752186447381973, -0.001153116230852902, 0.0033199889585375786, -0.02659909799695015, -0.023868344724178314, 0.03928510099649429, -0.03904344141483307, -0.06265176087617874, 0.002276601269841194, -0.01455917302519083, 0.0045463708229362965, 0.003996558021754026, -0.041681353002786636, 0.04259873926639557, -0.00405815988779068, -0.012086398899555206, 0.019186021760106087, -0.02905943989753723, 0.05188985541462898, 0.03942728787660599, 0.02679961733520031, -0.008723495528101921, 0.019144423305988312, -0.013682431541383266, -0.016808148473501205, -0.0037765963934361935, -0.017854535952210426, -0.0591871552169323, -0.0004639011749532074, 0.054833609610795975, 0.031062114983797073, -0.04944480583071709, 0.05727255716919899, 0.022298593074083328, 0.03099675662815571, 0.0495137982070446, 0.017676405608654022, -0.015248879790306091, -0.0172355305403471, -0.013043511658906937, 0.02206622250378132, 0.03059978410601616, 0.016024941578507423, 0.02470250613987446, 0.04770955443382263, 0.01620698906481266, -0.003314580302685499, -0.05103987827897072, 0.07159749418497086, -0.03367725759744644, 0.0034172304440289736, -0.0010319888824597, -0.02964654006063938, 0.013273046351969242, -0.023538541048765182, -0.0024923437740653753, 0.003012517699971795, 0.0027903947047889233, -0.0025983727537095547, -0.03600834682583809, -0.0193750262260437, 0.010749143548309803, 0.016332020983099937, -0.001359028392471373, 0.0018732886528596282, 0.0323236845433712, -0.045374877750873566, 0.038169749081134796, -0.04369799420237541, 0.0032157008536159992, -0.06867863237857819, 0.016606876626610756, 0.03289470449090004, 0.037803538143634796, 0.022147255018353462, 0.011854873038828373, -0.03087279386818409, 0.017862625420093536, -0.039461005479097366, 0.020141512155532837, -0.001025113626383245, -0.044441498816013336, 0.028392812237143517, -0.01213331613689661, 0.020596636459231377, 0.05516117066144943, -0.026738855987787247, -0.008104108273983002, -0.015789121389389038, -0.03233704715967178, -0.04575926437973976, -0.0015630972338840365, -0.06112080067396164, 0.03400866687297821, -0.0026449153665453196, -0.016762223094701767, 0.03672844171524048, -0.021238435059785843, -0.03651390224695206, 0.026326574385166168, -0.025750087574124336, -0.0159797053784132, -0.04131225869059563, 0.007637963630259037, 0.0191886518150568, -0.004306676797568798, -0.0015973409172147512, 0.051133621484041214, -0.09563510119915009, 0.028676297515630722, -0.059899039566516876, -0.07875658571720123, 0.05044815316796303, -0.003663271199911833, 0.011509972624480724, 0.01204374898225069, 0.007739110384136438, 0.07118268311023712, -0.010031715966761112, -0.02825772389769554, -0.036741454154253006, 0.004159867763519287, -0.012283670715987682, -0.03219273313879967, -0.0053879511542618275, 0.03455434367060661, 0.02816162258386612, -0.00041104419506154954, 0.018767740577459335, 0.01314899604767561, 0.061257656663656235, -0.0329124741256237, -0.02813699282705784, 0.030674127861857414, -0.007720953784883022, -0.02957754023373127, 0.02393127977848053, 0.029260864481329918, -0.03715764358639717, 0.013418582268059254, 0.008878719061613083, -0.02662951871752739, 0.004474076442420483, -0.008624361827969551, 0.03641799837350845, 0.0019756904803216457, 0.00695869280025363, -0.011761888861656189, 0.006384745705872774, -0.03876952826976776, 0.014408808201551437, -0.006658030673861504, 0.03164706006646156, 0.058537811040878296, -0.011050337925553322, -0.0060819280333817005, 0.03387729823589325, 0.022725015878677368, -0.006751090753823519, 0.04153771698474884, -0.014931946992874146, -0.03967548534274101, 0.005560771096497774, -0.0035653228405863047, 0.018914638087153435, 0.06557638198137283, 0.026874450966715813, 0.02522994950413704, 0.03440228849649429, -0.02518347278237343, -0.0246890876442194, -0.054878585040569305, 0.026605406776070595, -0.03312665969133377, 0.07028333097696304, 0.003867301158607006, 0.029644174501299858, 0.027361776679754257, 0.03823478892445564, 0.0351400300860405, -0.011057286523282528, -0.07457845658063889, 0.03299306333065033, -0.022754676640033722, -0.0059388200752437115, 0.014808770269155502, -0.031023608520627022, 0.009873149916529655, -0.017348702996969223, -0.04809730499982834, -0.019911596551537514, -0.018733587116003036, -0.047730203717947006, 0.040213387459516525, -0.023006118834018707, -0.0020834673196077347, -0.03100224956870079, -0.028002355247735977, 0.012412426993250847, -0.01706736534833908, -0.027136486023664474, 0.030226033180952072, -0.005593715235590935, -0.007730357814580202, -0.0076001533307135105, -0.006111633963882923, 0.028440071269869804, 0.020181775093078613, 0.052132077515125275, 0.02829485572874546, -0.0453934371471405, 0.010648767463862896, 0.01165584847331047, 0.05938775837421417, 0.040691524744033813, 0.018261374905705452, -0.02792622335255146, -0.08390597254037857, -0.00363339064642787, -0.014346219599246979, 0.06332652270793915, -0.011494000442326069, 0.00961135234683752, 0.043771326541900635, 0.004107053857296705, -0.04108824208378792, -0.010458662174642086, 0.03701551631093025, 0.000824832241050899, -0.015054752118885517, -0.034375615417957306, -0.013104993849992752, 0.011216197162866592, -0.0071688322350382805, 0.04139779880642891, -0.021755188703536987, -0.011618239805102348, -0.0010561156086623669, 0.02669026516377926, -0.047832030802965164, -0.020043328404426575, -0.024119865149259567, 0.011936476454138756, 0.029559427872300148, -0.0038125519640743732, -0.01072752196341753, -0.028824303299188614, 0.03674192354083061, 0.07847870886325836, 0.01403165701776743, -0.010178139433264732, -0.0988548994064331, -0.00437815859913826, 0.05499942973256111, 0.03379083052277565, -0.021723126992583275, -0.00860867090523243, -0.05225247144699097, 0.005384176503866911, 0.05471859499812126, 0.011898914352059364, 0.046273939311504364, 0.011953111737966537, -0.0272853821516037, -0.033619947731494904, 0.02795906737446785, 0.04549253731966019, 0.018142767250537872, -0.015321950428187847, 0.06075621023774147, -0.016935845836997032, -0.011030697263777256, -0.06303980201482773, -0.04266567528247833, 0.02737457863986492, 0.05743714049458504, 0.02394934557378292, -0.0015130758984014392, 0.029082641005516052, 0.03955245018005371, 0.004371482878923416, -0.09011733531951904, -0.005659561138600111, 0.02471308410167694, -0.022917384281754494, 0.04762997850775719, -0.012862787581980228, -0.03521525487303734, 0.0048227934166789055, -0.0261655542999506, -0.040778737515211105, -0.029546061530709267, -0.015563850291073322, 0.03273038938641548, 0.03553379699587822, 0.021960424259305, 0.049570232629776, 0.028545193374156952, -0.03044223226606846, -0.025599362328648567, -0.0023052834440022707, 0.01919110119342804, -0.0506080724298954, -0.01783929206430912, -0.03932267054915428, 0.002218211069703102, -0.03972316533327103, 0.05592573806643486, 0.021265177056193352, 0.04029493406414986, -0.042374249547719955, -0.02176401950418949, -0.005059466697275639, 0.03538195416331291, -0.001868058112449944, -0.01838868483901024, -0.0068298159167170525, 0.0334194041788578, -0.021811509504914284, -0.04274163022637367, 0.035405103117227554, -0.010035994462668896, 0.014347176998853683, 0.0248116422444582, -0.012069537304341793, -0.016166748479008675, -0.048659536987543106, -0.02866125851869583, 0.043611664324998856, 0.004662110470235348, 0.05944015458226204, 0.016008663922548294, 0.004828897770494223, 0.03054085373878479, -0.06217517703771591, -0.01215535867959261, 0.000571330776438117, -0.03913640230894089, 0.0013549119466915727, -0.034617334604263306, 0.030827555805444717, 0.02279816009104252, -0.019162127748131752, -0.08243342489004135, -0.056234508752822876, 0.053880564868450165, 0.0022016989532858133, -0.02682885341346264, -0.0008855697815306485, 0.04496502876281738, -0.004224918317049742, -0.03094691038131714, -0.012552795931696892, 0.08137691766023636, -0.01339845173060894, 0.03125273063778877, 0.02169150859117508, -0.013457000255584717, 0.06126030907034874, -0.00013118537026457489, 0.0002570483775343746, -0.009045230224728584, -0.036340635269880295, 0.00006449578359024599, 0.0008620055159553885, 0.032783567905426025, -0.035265859216451645, -0.004736448172479868, -0.03464687615633011, -0.028396593406796455, 0.057027142494916916, -0.01616528630256653, 0.030451280996203423, 0.006961558014154434, 0.01020023226737976, -0.015037606470286846, -0.024836542084813118, -0.012236500158905983, -0.017000475898385048, 0.026638204231858253, -0.002674779389053583, 0.016354134306311607, -0.0290790107101202, -0.03451698273420334, 0.027885213494300842, 0.009117607027292252, 0.0030576966237276793, 0.00875233206897974, 0.04986298829317093, -0.02546769380569458, 0.02127416618168354, 0.00956826563924551, -0.03518877923488617, 0.039237357676029205, 0.011668285354971886, 0.05254970118403435, -0.02855497971177101, 0.04147803783416748, -0.0306499395519495, -0.05915512889623642, -0.04813956469297409, -0.0051766145043075085, 0.057907383888959885, -0.004336841404438019, 0.055309802293777466, 0.029238423332571983, -0.012629413977265358, -0.036325495690107346, -0.027375150471925735, -0.014314583502709866, 0.028463339433073997, -0.0332929827272892, 0.02792227268218994, -0.002021101536229253, -0.013298161327838898, 0.021535655483603477, 0.04722050204873085, 0.015660297125577927, 0.024099506437778473, -0.0004941594088450074, 0.00030253786826506257, 0.001056936918757856, -0.008983147330582142, -0.06015965715050697, 0.032165251672267914, -0.02421370893716812, 0.029941122978925705, 0.010164080187678337, -0.0075757927261292934, 0.048624247312545776, 0.009567636996507645, 0.014603687450289726, -0.05122002586722374, -0.025109989568591118, -0.033611949533224106, 0.033055663108825684, 0.0043209451250731945, -0.02619730867445469, -0.025109456852078438, 0.014161507599055767, -0.01215892843902111, -0.01207245048135519, 0.026729872450232506, 0.006087176967412233, -0.060228489339351654, -0.01713963784277439, -0.05841561034321785, -0.0563671700656414, 0.0006450272048823535, 0.0015860064886510372, -0.06683830916881561, 0.04443900287151337, -0.02480980195105076, 0.045258283615112305, -0.0031109272968024015, 0.05024096369743347, 0.020505543798208237, 0.06340339034795761, -0.0105249909684062, -0.007833343930542469, 0.022952649742364883, 0.00014401751104742289, 0.12367158383131027, 0.07246804982423782, 0.017607759684324265, -0.08948951214551926, 0.002653858158737421, -0.008153299801051617, -0.004904685076326132, -0.019522707909345627, 0.03499853238463402, 0.014959372580051422, 0.005598839838057756, -0.011323989368975163, -0.00500227976590395, 0.0005761184147559106, -0.00029949090094305575, 0.02693401463329792, -0.04089534282684326, -0.05412772670388222, 0.0258944071829319, 0.0016601047245785594, 0.011191836558282375, 0.008536101318895817, -0.05705368518829346, 0.014019970782101154, 0.004474529530853033, -0.004705225583165884, 0.01140453852713108, -0.015994036570191383, 0.044504065066576004, -0.020032275468111038, -0.03006047010421753, 0.002995999762788415, -0.013170607388019562, 0.0050745694898068905, -0.018932288512587547, 0.04389778897166252, 0.009973296895623207, -0.021591240540146828, 0.040027033537626266, 0.015693623572587967, 0.041645608842372894, -0.05419120192527771, 0.017901143059134483, 0.019449206069111824, -0.03615941107273102, -0.02082853578031063, -0.052105795592069626, 0.005708098411560059, -0.00929071381688118, -0.005334094166755676, 0.010436231270432472, 0.011891025118529797, 0.041140273213386536, -0.03716213256120682, -0.0026229312643408775, 0.0006689252913929522, 0.01998002640902996, -0.033231738954782486, -0.010422617197036743, -0.03312684968113899, -0.007906370796263218, -0.02261757105588913, 0.048743363469839096, 0.0016426874790340662, -0.032186076045036316, 0.02481546811759472, -0.01988915167748928, -0.002462793607264757, -0.013711084611713886, -0.0007556617492809892, -0.00017655598639976233, 0.006301937159150839, -0.017851440235972404, -0.015582268126308918, 0.01896240934729576, 0.011224565096199512, 0.018520677462220192, -0.016344107687473297, -0.028422048315405846, 0.014097072184085846, -0.06494826078414917, 0.0011420785449445248, -0.003919788170605898, -0.004709015134721994, -0.01984037086367607, -0.011269810609519482, 0.09791682660579681, 0.0209544338285923, 0.020190149545669556, 0.05197528749704361, -0.04109854996204376, -0.008392681367695332, 0.048528142273426056, -0.04619970545172691, -0.011790848337113857, 0.05630261078476906, -0.019119344651699066, 0.014974534511566162, -0.019781827926635742, 0.04625067859888077, 0.04415077716112137, -0.008137974888086319, -0.0165098849684, -0.0052760629914700985, -0.002957376651465893, 0.009116392582654953, 0.01011099573224783, -0.07606569677591324, -0.008371107280254364, -0.010612040758132935, 0.01841774769127369, -0.053034428507089615, -0.014802128076553345, -0.06239485740661621, -0.002269176999107003, -0.033273130655288696, 0.04274441674351692, -0.0039038171526044607, -0.0031682539265602827, -0.007090383674949408, 0.037783026695251465, -0.010805617086589336, -0.03464452549815178, -0.03275463730096817, 0.041801877319812775, -0.012207678519189358, -0.01031604316085577, -0.013700750656425953, 0.01402050070464611, 0.021638480946421623, -0.01011828612536192, 0.015651652589440346, 0.01993032544851303, -0.01694532111287117, 0.00397837208583951, -0.019001072272658348, -0.015461510047316551, 0.05762530490756035, -0.021806733682751656, -0.032056067138910294, 0.02875824272632599, -0.021730545908212662, -0.020025620236992836, 0.011377234011888504, -0.028701866045594215, 0.008261660113930702, 0.03703133389353752, -0.04634556174278259, -0.0024365910794585943, 0.038426149636507034, -0.015168730169534683, -0.011156246066093445, 0.0031118241604417562, -0.0034270482137799263, -0.0022750776261091232, 0.010360443964600563, 0.012328684329986572, -0.011269954033195972, -0.01170748844742775, 0.02546003647148609, 0.04826797544956207, 0.029994379729032516, -0.030401241034269333, 0.03089492954313755, 0.013627495616674423, 0.008343221619725227, 0.002193780615925789, 0.0018174733268097043, 0.03211512789130211, 0.022569650784134865, -0.033281393349170685, 0.028522543609142303, -0.007618226110935211, 0.025991322472691536, -0.08923351764678955, 0.022659022361040115, 0.01726933941245079, -0.019321739673614502, 0.05838652700185776, -0.030552688986063004, 0.016290191560983658, 0.022701265290379524, -0.0673031359910965, 0.0092142503708601, -0.010621481575071812, -0.026176614686846733, -0.01595686562359333, 0.004649185109883547, 0.013522914610803127, 0.0643567219376564, 0.0018562136683613062, 0.019542282447218895, 0.01570107787847519, 0.002852286212146282, -0.019170090556144714, -0.0010661070700734854, -0.06059596687555313, 0.01780310645699501, -0.008246682584285736, -0.03991448134183884, 0.03384019806981087, -0.03135441243648529, -0.05434107035398483, 0.09092032164335251, -0.016689840704202652, -0.0036557160783559084, 0.011137550696730614, 0.028987687081098557, 0.019068708643317223, 0.012801463715732098, 0.016454346477985382, -0.022401204332709312, -0.008376680314540863, 0.005056376103311777, 0.04339175298810005, 0.00042272056452929974, -0.01134974043816328, 0.02573319710791111, -0.004185216035693884, -0.0037813077215105295, -0.021969223394989967, -0.010608971118927002, -0.029107410460710526, -0.01410528551787138, -0.002552777761593461, 0.008991469629108906, 0.010708514600992203, -0.04600885137915611, 0.013289663009345531, -0.020373903214931488, -0.0021786887664347887, -0.010990766808390617, 0.02272297814488411, 0.0032431622967123985, 0.03193539381027222, 0.0019366606138646603, -0.031220080330967903, 0.006173248868435621, -0.006826338823884726, 0.02188240736722946, -0.053791336715221405, 0.012345553375780582, 0.02156550996005535, 0.005270371213555336, -0.019175322726368904, 0.003441071603447199, -0.006055030506104231, 0.0604843832552433, -0.006703942082822323, -0.015058720484375954, 0.018162429332733154, -0.035919006913900375, 0.023538006469607353, -0.017432402819395065, 0.04983685165643692, -0.0026648419443517923, -0.01239232812076807, -0.02131337858736515, -0.011048480868339539, -0.009164396673440933, 0.0036890716291964054, 0.0761447548866272, -0.0388132743537426, 0.012666678987443447, -0.01507569383829832, 0.03480227664113045, -0.012943965382874012, -0.042520973831415176, 0.013894407078623772, -0.015054577961564064, -0.032858364284038544, -0.015185929834842682, -0.0486525297164917, 0.01122916117310524, 0.01513330265879631, 0.013878506608307362, -0.001532570575363934, 0.00035462348023429513, 0.009322630241513252, -0.008332784287631512, 0.03702040761709213, 0.005599575582891703, 0.002954812254756689, 0.05620904266834259, -0.03128743916749954, 0.004154539201408625, 0.013938352465629578, 0.0006350473267957568, -0.015831395983695984, 0.0366639569401741, -0.001799754798412323, -0.0005320964264683425, 0.003482365980744362, 0.009035671129822731, 0.03894675150513649, -0.09043087810277939, -0.04481161758303642, 0.040193162858486176, -0.016124576330184937, 0.010779252275824547, 0.07096480578184128, 0.023656386882066727, 0.026790307834744453, 0.017357828095555305, -0.009525645524263382, 0.0023473422043025494, 0.008153358474373817, -0.0018623201176524162, 0.03604327142238617, 0.03677394241094589, 0.006194941233843565, 0.02601335197687149, 0.005153643433004618, -0.046509772539138794, 0.0669114887714386, -0.012109569273889065, 0.026065101847052574, -0.04533516988158226, -0.021724538877606392, 0.01848074421286583, 0.009769919328391552, 0.015171860344707966, 0.017571240663528442, 0.00974948052316904, 0.08907512575387955, -0.016699008643627167, 0.015013100579380989, -0.0007223054417409003, 0.007040641736239195, -0.03675118461251259, -0.02848876267671585, 0.0073679350316524506, 0.015025199390947819, 0.005287642125040293, 0.0010212329216301441, 0.002766034100204706, 0.009809467010200024, 0.030573096126317978, -0.003911080304533243, 0.01952587626874447, -0.021159565076231956, 0.018435174599289894, -0.0029218997806310654, -0.004236055072396994, -0.018941087648272514, 0.024249257519841194, 0.01235114224255085, 0.040725767612457275, 0.021718239411711693, 0.0003414392122067511, -0.011387995444238186, -0.04698320850729942, 0.0355244055390358, -0.08606471866369247, 0.01199355535209179, -0.023454196751117706, 0.015394465066492558, 0.000424012920120731, -0.012860355898737907 ]
<p>I have a data set with a small number of samples (322) and a large number of features (318.976). My data consists of images, and I want to train a binary classifier.</p> <p>Since I have such a small amount of data available, I have employed the following strategy:</p> <ul> <li>Reduce dimensionality using a few hand-written rules (from 318.976 to 12.000 features)</li> <li>Train Sparse Filter to reduce dimensionality further (from 12.000 to 1000 features <ul> <li>To train the sparse filter, I construct additional data by shifting my images horizontally which my problem is invariant under. This gives me 19.320 samples instead of 322.</li> </ul></li> <li>Now my data set has 19.320 samples and 1000 features</li> <li>In the training set, only around 2% of the samples are positives</li> <li>Now I train a random forest on the data set weighting the positive samples up so they in total achieves the same weight as the negative samples</li> </ul> <p>Here my problem arises. I get a quite good OOB-estimate from my random forest, but it is overly confident. The problem is that when I shifted my data to obtain more samples and then trained the sparse filter, I get some some sets of features which are just shifted versions of each other. When I then train my random forest, these features have a very high correlation, and the OOB-estimate does not take into account that some of my features are very highly correlated, consequently over-estimating the predictive power.</p> <p>Since I have so few samples originally, I have no good way to do cross-validation, especially since I have a highly imbalanced data set. Is there any way to get slightly more accurate error-estimates?</p>
73,558
[ -0.037371546030044556, -0.009224516339600086, 0.02349243499338627, 0.0005976780084893107, 0.06016921252012253, -0.0009827774483710527, -0.039267443120479584, 0.003230030182749033, 0.02133164368569851, -0.03327826410531998, 0.02366114966571331, 0.041979797184467316, 0.027801983058452606, 0.02556345798075199, -0.03612503036856651, -0.030424602329730988, -0.001972751459106803, 0.009981309063732624, -0.0034706031437963247, -0.03199758380651474, -0.020213807001709938, 0.02181035466492176, 0.08206988871097565, 0.02394968830049038, -0.027654780074954033, 0.06334377080202103, 0.027340911328792572, -0.012739810161292553, 0.02329298108816147, 0.0056348275393247604, -0.046551696956157684, -0.01380663737654686, 0.006200819741934538, 0.046276215463876724, 0.026597145944833755, -0.002947193803265691, -0.01405237801373005, -0.03060006909072399, -0.01718277856707573, 0.010582933202385902, 0.014503474347293377, -0.01377952191978693, -0.013400189578533173, 0.05735984444618225, 0.002464814344421029, 0.031136663630604744, 0.003355933353304863, -0.03077343851327896, 0.049277812242507935, -0.05687364563345909, 0.06031328812241554, -0.02286521904170513, 0.05003013461828232, 0.07626890391111374, -0.016727382317185402, -0.034854114055633545, 0.06393279880285263, 0.08742295205593109, -0.022296098992228508, -0.00332957087084651, -0.003607309190556407, -0.021153466776013374, 0.015217961743474007, 0.03028794378042221, -0.015611386857926846, 0.047930989414453506, -0.0007347696810029447, -0.011481978930532932, 0.017214331775903702, -0.0063893455080688, 0.04620867222547531, 0.0066934628412127495, 0.035287123173475266, -0.0007777201244607568, 0.003215717151761055, -0.023664584383368492, 0.003247442189604044, 0.02430024929344654, 0.03685615211725235, 0.006855000741779804, 0.003736603306606412, 0.02179206907749176, 0.009630930610001087, 0.023831864818930626, 0.06138963624835014, -0.028603896498680115, 0.04557636007666588, -0.03184686601161957, 0.0431920662522316, 0.0012293605832383037, 0.01748873107135296, 0.004178448114544153, 0.052872184664011, -0.03581637516617775, -0.02744605392217636, 0.04387678951025009, -0.021050946786999702, 0.02663639932870865, 0.00802697241306305, 0.015887629240751266, -0.03339020535349846, -0.03292936086654663, 0.022803250700235367, 0.05424398556351662, -0.044532712548971176, -0.009591583162546158, -0.04767666384577751, -0.0023992513306438923, -0.013075831346213818, -0.0067528653889894485, -0.036911457777023315, -0.013451610691845417, 0.01682889275252819, -0.026590323075652122, 0.026064433157444, -0.03330565243959427, -0.006421519909054041, -0.012286238372325897, 0.0352478101849556, 0.05780009552836418, 0.02635577693581581, -0.02598315104842186, 0.029515903443098068, -0.033615097403526306, -0.05805113539099693, 0.018467506393790245, 0.03805158659815788, 0.004201910924166441, -0.028359903022646904, 0.04067050665616989, 0.02191239409148693, -0.03585755452513695, 0.035306185483932495, -0.008059896528720856, 0.017262499779462814, 0.02799464948475361, -0.10265066474676132, -0.038240112364292145, 0.026549680158495903, -0.044840309768915176, 0.017917225137352943, -0.048179756850004196, -0.03036166913807392, 0.02447015605866909, 0.07072629034519196, -0.008157797157764435, 0.03530485928058624, 0.020085059106349945, 0.007316327188163996, -0.013764253817498684, 0.0005352930747903883, -0.02265026606619358, -0.06040924787521362, 0.03640906885266304, -0.03586586192250252, -0.093929223716259, 0.01751372590661049, 0.014392123557627201, -0.017130374908447266, -0.02144993469119072, 0.013066831976175308, 0.004895140882581472, -0.02870349772274494, -0.012384005822241306, -0.016857733950018883, -0.05230628326535225, 0.05902286246418953, 0.02182815968990326, 0.05236693099141121, 0.011982332915067673, -0.02200142666697502, -0.016231926158070564, 0.04362750053405762, 0.001525883562862873, 0.04426027461886406, 0.009861031547188759, -0.002528673969209194, -0.03479251638054848, 0.022759733721613884, -0.006743104662746191, -0.014872969128191471, -0.04977710172533989, -0.03322094678878784, -0.007495768368244171, 0.053060147911310196, 0.014166336506605148, -0.0063715735450387, -0.039509840309619904, 0.046426817774772644, -0.05870240926742554, -0.029120659455657005, -0.04501540958881378, 0.005696175619959831, -0.007802795618772507, 0.0049699414521455765, 0.03527029976248741, -0.0008913355995900929, 0.010438141413033009, -0.0035271532833576202, -0.010819909162819386, 0.0011324695078656077, -0.009623001329600811, 0.05876963213086128, -0.021510625258088112, 0.0033035355154424906, 0.056315310299396515, -0.012277958914637566, -0.005788156297057867, 0.06490001827478409, 0.0002793060557451099, -0.06737964600324631, 0.02182329073548317, -0.04106597229838371, 0.0015548050869256258, -0.05940164998173714, -0.016263620927929878, 0.05246832221746445, -0.029997246339917183, 0.0006720108794979751, 0.007458800449967384, -0.024157417938113213, 0.07861347496509552, 0.07861946523189545, -0.018013570457696915, 0.018346253782510757, 0.026325300335884094, 0.008637978695333004, -0.008146161213517189, -0.053845055401325226, -0.027131754904985428, -0.04898656904697418, -0.04734652116894722, 0.035959359258413315, -0.020967833697795868, -0.03388180583715439, 0.001928215380758047, 0.04797494411468506, 0.029000738635659218, 0.026751426979899406, 0.03740754351019859, 0.002124820603057742, -0.007980689406394958, 0.0035279334988445044, 0.015676245093345642, 0.01216564979404211, -0.01686100848019123, -0.03232754394412041, -0.011975315399467945, 0.010890288278460503, -0.007776182144880295, -0.03410272300243378, 0.005482489708811045, 0.01924094371497631, -0.0017476233188062906, -0.016183212399482727, -0.04132012277841568, -0.010268866084516048, -0.0001853612338891253, -0.011074387468397617, 0.03649643063545227, 0.0030474134255200624, 0.035456929355859756, -0.008652480319142342, -0.0312962643802166, 0.026956185698509216, 0.0432482585310936, -0.011940352618694305, 0.023412741720676422, 0.01747727580368519, -0.08100845664739609, 0.019743554294109344, 0.011959915049374104, -0.037494149059057236, -0.024997562170028687, 0.029145745560526848, 0.03406207635998726, 0.021734444424510002, 0.034405458718538284, -0.011242277920246124, -0.006768557708710432, -0.015948424115777016, -0.007247045170515776, 0.035789962857961655, 0.011828786693513393, -0.03951511159539223, -0.008681369945406914, -0.02387453243136406, -0.021013179793953896, 0.018456023186445236, 0.03249267488718033, -0.01633583754301071, -0.020721662789583206, 0.01048328261822462, -0.039370935410261154, -0.02173832803964615, -0.013581621460616589, 0.02462342008948326, -0.006574408151209354, -0.042077142745256424, 0.052305757999420166, -0.012791118584573269, -0.03886302560567856, 0.02179609052836895, 0.03839704394340515, -0.0028799481224268675, -0.038458168506622314, -0.00714975455775857, 0.017105182632803917, 0.00984115805476904, 0.02097005397081375, 0.016337532550096512, 0.0037479079328477383, -0.020463626831769943, -0.04686450585722923, -0.04996966943144798, 0.006044527515769005, 0.021075334399938583, 0.03441772982478142, 0.037716273218393326, 0.010423789732158184, 0.06798803061246872, 0.02997586317360401, -0.03442474454641342, -0.03237718716263771, -0.023635977879166603, -0.0576496347784996, -0.03398900106549263, 0.015720179304480553, 0.021155182272195816, 0.029255010187625885, 0.0579875148832798, -0.0004888069815933704, 0.02070413902401924, 0.05402357131242752, -0.004175710026174784, -0.03230389580130577, 0.030655546113848686, 0.00212417752481997, -0.005991517566144466, 0.042558182030916214, 0.00035798895987682045, -0.019345607608556747, 0.0035136754158884287, 0.02007114514708519, -0.016151128336787224, 0.02474403753876686, -0.07332339882850647, -0.012129551731050014, -0.016803722828626633, 0.0577273927628994, -0.02626802772283554, 0.011616168543696404, -0.004674569237977266, -0.04278826341032982, -0.025494694709777832, 0.019253823906183243, 0.08889717608690262, -0.006876323837786913, 0.01284407451748848, 0.021531280130147934, 0.033386219292879105, 0.020586976781487465, -0.0022166878916323185, -0.025945933535695076, 0.004645183216780424, 0.015582900494337082, -0.009024395607411861, -0.0020532242488116026, 0.04832072556018829, 0.0384158156812191, 0.002667999593541026, -0.016879985108971596, -0.03289986401796341, 0.038280997425317764, -0.02678622119128704, -0.01724889501929283, -0.029213599860668182, 0.04909290000796318, -0.0017565590096637607, 0.03210391104221344, 0.028641240671277046, -0.04954792559146881, 0.0294436514377594, 0.03531422093510628, -0.07262831926345825, -0.0032080041710287333, 0.027651678770780563, 0.004961566533893347, 0.0052766441367566586, -0.012802635319530964, -0.012638617306947708, -0.05035664513707161, -0.0017917121294885874, -0.005138276610523462, 0.05946328490972519, -0.010494265705347061, -0.010233016684651375, -0.02792860008776188, 0.00882669072598219, -0.016142720356583595, 0.031662434339523315, 0.02257205732166767, -0.03130543231964111, 0.013441056944429874, 0.03751961886882782, 0.007472100201994181, -0.0018037400441244245, -0.05774647369980812, 0.04586685448884964, -0.01130751520395279, 0.043489743024110794, -0.00018409285985399038, 0.0220771674066782, -0.07017810642719269, 0.01124987006187439, -0.0003225123800802976, 0.003660791553556919, 0.005715542938560247, 0.002855656435713172, 0.0008700012695044279, -0.036613207310438156, -0.054710932075977325, 0.019616497680544853, 0.014097086153924465, 0.0036674279253929853, -0.010791143402457237, 0.041551001369953156, 0.029367120936512947, -0.06425165385007858, -0.0012773256748914719, 0.06148819252848625, -0.0013376943534240127, 0.00563297001644969, -0.03701991215348244, -0.0053531392477452755, 0.018896784633398056, -0.001813333248719573, 0.05036889389157295, 0.008977272547781467, -0.02243875153362751, -0.021718299016356468, 0.03489525616168976, -0.010267551988363266, -0.039604295045137405, 0.015150207094848156, -0.004484194330871105, 0.04784757271409035, -0.023515908047556877, -0.000436779810115695, 0.003716514678671956, 0.02999803237617016, 0.028849881142377853, 0.030231494456529617, 0.004300749860703945, -0.09702382981777191, -0.002619731007143855, 0.034301869571208954, 0.04090414196252823, -0.01716403290629387, 0.021923892199993134, -0.050921499729156494, -0.010361685417592525, 0.032869961112737656, -0.06873493641614914, -0.01921331137418747, 0.00985577329993248, 0.019621673971414566, 0.011193004436790943, -0.025755880400538445, -0.027615878731012344, -0.00763946957886219, -0.060455791652202606, 0.04115864261984825, 0.012846522033214569, -0.04273112118244171, -0.011040511541068554, 0.03832260146737099, 0.016366230323910713, 0.05675683170557022, -0.008710667490959167, -0.00937317218631506, -0.0036164652556180954, 0.019136175513267517, -0.024218890815973282, -0.06077216565608978, -0.011551076546311378, 0.013803079724311829, -0.016537649556994438, 0.043546147644519806, -0.004514939151704311, -0.05013763904571533, -0.014975995756685734, 0.004736809991300106, -0.03750600665807724, -0.03470365330576897, -0.06680592149496078, 0.03147644177079201, 0.04909519851207733, 0.036530911922454834, 0.04401625692844391, 0.04779962822794914, -0.0053326841443777084, 0.009697352536022663, -0.011554155498743057, 0.020916154608130455, -0.013184291310608387, -0.024254294112324715, -0.027556244283914566, -0.0001640016125747934, -0.02118859626352787, 0.03048846498131752, 0.007712686434388161, 0.05469182878732681, 0.03877094015479088, -0.00911867618560791, -0.01945512183010578, 0.010993525385856628, -0.04355163499712944, -0.013853946700692177, 0.018412401899695396, 0.04116351157426834, 0.006561880931258202, 0.015208641067147255, -0.0056831021793186665, 0.030084993690252304, 0.005920743569731712, -0.010441776365041733, -0.054650068283081055, -0.009031344205141068, -0.06843262910842896, 0.013525374233722687, -0.022565582767128944, 0.01858564093708992, 0.031223313882946968, 0.011919706128537655, 0.05583672970533371, -0.01931069605052471, -0.03898606449365616, 0.012990116141736507, 0.013656103052198887, -0.000867795548401773, 0.016399884596467018, -0.05008643865585327, -0.010190529748797417, -0.017726514488458633, -0.005428342614322901, -0.06545523554086685, -0.034498702734708786, -0.00022782808810006827, 0.03513519465923309, 0.03042859397828579, -0.050650592893362045, -0.006477366667240858, 0.013272931799292564, -0.018264325335621834, -0.02299688756465912, 0.011157154105603695, 0.021250948309898376, -0.010745519772171974, -0.0016474643489345908, -0.004822415299713612, 0.055478405207395554, -0.04440002143383026, -0.0222132820636034, 0.03225655108690262, -0.013440021313726902, -0.02149640955030918, 0.026291169226169586, -0.01061381958425045, -0.03316328674554825, -0.025375565513968468, -0.04311086982488632, 0.018555976450443268, 0.02829495631158352, 0.01647883839905262, 0.017924010753631592, 0.0015448809135705233, 0.008478277362883091, -0.006124340929090977, -0.03444376215338707, -0.002378186210989952, 0.0154537009075284, -0.01930508203804493, -0.029088139533996582, 0.014318338595330715, 0.00017219501023646444, -0.036513201892375946, -0.001937533961609006, 0.02187405340373516, -0.0146111398935318, 0.0015171935083344579, 0.03893514722585678, -0.026081033051013947, 0.021556133404374123, 0.005262274295091629, -0.06410767883062363, 0.05340803787112236, 0.006314996164292097, 0.013381917029619217, 0.003661712631583214, 0.04032803699374199, -0.06684745103120804, -0.018766332417726517, -0.04164215922355652, 0.00859939306974411, 0.056412920355796814, 0.012493643909692764, 0.023739458993077278, 0.019633250311017036, -0.015009486116468906, 0.010961598716676235, -0.033636171370744705, -0.00873686745762825, 0.022580377757549286, -0.003289593616500497, 0.02306872047483921, 0.021467525511980057, 0.017303716391324997, 0.016513995826244354, 0.012700183317065239, 0.03374944627285004, 0.03784561902284622, 0.026460351422429085, 0.046588409692049026, 0.024332653731107712, -0.06054622679948807, -0.018010210245847702, 0.012557359412312508, -0.01506697479635477, -0.012708100490272045, 0.017031323164701462, -0.007842794992029667, 0.07991161942481995, 0.03588851913809776, 0.02159861847758293, -0.02533831261098385, -0.0644899383187294, -0.06751055270433426, -0.0033733027521520853, -0.025966955348849297, -0.018746061250567436, 0.014393058605492115, -0.008748368360102177, 0.001083637005649507, 0.030728869140148163, 0.02137897163629532, -0.0404917374253273, -0.07477962225675583, -0.0449131540954113, -0.037695806473493576, -0.03832852095365524, 0.0334445983171463, 0.007762367837131023, -0.034275297075510025, 0.02091830037534237, -0.026420842856168747, 0.019141504541039467, 0.006819738540798426, 0.05762007087469101, -0.010832695290446281, 0.01911267451941967, 0.015199429355561733, 0.012530390173196793, 0.01090469304472208, -0.001802227459847927, 0.13857847452163696, 0.06638984382152557, 0.05877598002552986, -0.034119121730327606, 0.00960020162165165, -0.017993459478020668, -0.051494479179382324, -0.035119082778692245, -0.0027226002421230078, -0.00829207245260477, -0.0019588905852288008, -0.000019528486518538557, 0.024361995980143547, 0.042627736926078796, -0.04441538825631142, 0.026239408180117607, -0.004883658140897751, 0.007088272366672754, 0.01285508181899786, 0.024026382714509964, 0.05063159018754959, -0.02455793507397175, -0.061330396682024, 0.014259885996580124, -0.01634102128446102, -0.0317668654024601, -0.024510597810149193, 0.005462584551423788, 0.007714833132922649, -0.01554650254547596, 0.0070565929636359215, 0.003632908221334219, 0.028808096423745155, 0.0011655407724902034, 0.017713159322738647, 0.00996476598083973, 0.014400224201381207, -0.020774148404598236, 0.014709684997797012, 0.016800418496131897, -0.0073902481235563755, 0.007126583252102137, -0.009692061692476273, -0.004536768421530724, -0.05195572227239609, -0.03066234290599823, -0.06832229346036911, 0.03585709258913994, 0.02737286686897278, 0.002890690928325057, 0.029049549251794815, -0.0016217679949477315, 0.008924318477511406, -0.07176356017589569, -0.022632699459791183, 0.022473936900496483, 0.015469672158360481, -0.018860185518860817, -0.07666023075580597, -0.0004169105086475611, 0.028554916381835938, 0.05412088707089424, 0.023131513968110085, 0.00718257762491703, -0.004460085183382034, -0.008427116088569164, -0.018862063065171242, 0.07104679197072983, 0.01606675796210766, 0.035263802856206894, 0.000289554096525535, 0.008578876033425331, 0.00436387350782752, -0.030327102169394493, -0.0013879711041226983, 0.03919462114572525, 0.01698138564825058, -0.013746839016675949, -0.030021503567695618, -0.018181446939706802, -0.03412625938653946, 0.006483736913651228, -0.043014924973249435, -0.008486039936542511, -0.016693390905857086, -0.00115491496399045, -0.023015260696411133, 0.03198109194636345, 0.045845020562410355, -0.0011248755035921931, -0.0061165038496255875, 0.045244354754686356, -0.012997312471270561, -0.018953412771224976, -0.05325636267662048, -0.05494334548711777, -0.034673888236284256, 0.042747922241687775, 0.0523749403655529, 0.07806678861379623, 0.021057061851024628, 0.020130807533860207, -0.014705748297274113, 0.05668061971664429, -0.011574639938771725, -0.011755180545151234, 0.013603262603282928, -0.033589377999305725, -0.011486200615763664, -0.00898594968020916, -0.004809610079973936, -0.02362835593521595, -0.02481849305331707, -0.02288748510181904, -0.03982672467827797, 0.021439794450998306, -0.004151022061705589, -0.03097911924123764, -0.003342149779200554, -0.017675451934337616, 0.05104055628180504, -0.0025461025070399046, -0.02271593175828457, -0.0463797003030777, 0.008253365755081177, -0.030106516554951668, -0.04161226004362106, 0.00918587576597929, 0.023684300482273102, -0.037491824477910995, -0.027779240161180496, 0.040536701679229736, -0.015143265947699547, 0.020868072286248207, 0.001138945808634162, 0.013729877769947052, 0.021257247775793076, 0.024292785674333572, -0.024113358929753304, -0.0170783419162035, 0.022868920117616653, -0.031116735190153122, -0.023351047188043594, 0.038425929844379425, -0.03416990488767624, 0.044897910207509995, 0.030359061434864998, 0.004042792599648237, -0.02223917655646801, 0.028043260797858238, -0.026573166251182556, -0.02543693408370018, 0.002933650044724345, 0.02562354877591133, 0.005112584680318832, 0.04242829233407974, 0.006114935968071222, -0.01605466566979885, -0.02114943414926529, 0.017936978489160538, 0.02152470499277115, 0.025728821754455566, -0.025490721687674522, 0.002631856594234705, -0.032339200377464294, 0.028394123539328575, -0.003239551093429327, 0.0009520847233943641, -0.011534202843904495, 0.05902044475078583, -0.04671824723482132, 0.014906266704201698, 0.010753724724054337, 0.024809421971440315, -0.0920504629611969, -0.024715809151530266, 0.053970690816640854, 0.014188007451593876, 0.028014367446303368, -0.05234358087182045, 0.0045101214200258255, 0.018743539229035378, -0.02465420588850975, 0.04853401705622673, -0.008288019336760044, -0.02551637589931488, -0.04031055048108101, 0.004921023268252611, -0.030180757865309715, -0.02605401910841465, 0.01587102748453617, 0.019031424075365067, 0.01883321814239025, 0.049326781183481216, -0.010580380447208881, -0.025114672258496284, -0.027551895007491112, 0.023143362253904343, -0.0010179247474297881, -0.04044303670525551, 0.013350791297852993, -0.02822217345237732, -0.025396129116415977, 0.031154487282037735, -0.026144538074731827, -0.013592666946351528, 0.04361478611826897, 0.0199434794485569, 0.0035628208424896, 0.04679890722036362, 0.03408908098936081, -0.028574161231517792, 0.026772411540150642, -0.011451161466538906, -0.0016411960823461413, -0.0070845820009708405, 0.009096537716686726, 0.06040829420089722, -0.012583638541400433, -0.01457344088703394, 0.026050306856632233, 0.056359708309173584, -0.025595039129257202, -0.021504534408450127, 0.010830904357135296, 0.01928173191845417, 0.01783102937042713, -0.022045280784368515, -0.017635587602853775, -0.03556198999285698, 0.039691533893346786, 0.034283533692359924, -0.022705595940351486, -0.028922798112034798, 0.009210784919559956, -0.026463216170668602, -0.04819393903017044, -0.006914344150573015, -0.025600191205739975, -0.0046728868037462234, -0.06345228105783463, 0.011323232203722, 0.016426559537649155, -0.004376410506665707, -0.011926528066396713, 0.006632822100073099, -0.03152204304933548, 0.07511670887470245, -0.015689635649323463, 0.03397757560014725, -0.002113394206389785, -0.030535301193594933, -0.035775717347860336, -0.100082166492939, 0.04280850291252136, 0.014248008839786053, -0.04172497242689133, -0.008625577203929424, 0.000990845263004303, -0.009083019569516182, 0.005322336684912443, 0.04892536252737045, 0.020841989666223526, 0.016768136993050575, -0.017412934452295303, 0.01927039958536625, 0.012180767953395844, -0.06652401387691498, 0.021905502304434776, 0.007954389788210392, -0.021953364834189415, 0.011191721074283123, -0.02354373224079609, -0.011177277192473412, -0.007838030345737934, 0.0147181311622262, -0.007471892982721329, 0.0027110022492706776, 0.045459844172000885, -0.007147540803998709, 0.04792006313800812, -0.030494412407279015, 0.01880619116127491, 0.04195550084114075, 0.018616942688822746, 0.0030722699593752623, -0.0011283311760053039, 0.008722284808754921, -0.0479845367372036, 0.004859522450715303, -0.038818977773189545, -0.023077698424458504, 0.02015741728246212, 0.05665015056729317, 0.025277400389313698, -0.05010310560464859, 0.009862188249826431, 0.021122463047504425, -0.03321325406432152, 0.03317687287926674, 0.03187703713774681, -0.0017783137736842036, 0.016178276389837265, -0.009720656089484692, 0.02013905718922615, 0.019675223156809807, -0.03855564445257187, 0.017955418676137924, 0.011939715594053268, -0.007559610530734062, -0.0017684558406472206, 0.04682343453168869, 0.0029926684219390154, 0.007547126151621342, 0.01039085816591978, -0.008535844273865223, 0.028198406100273132, -0.044776562601327896, -0.00664488272741437, -0.020482687279582024, -0.010261714458465576, 0.03786482661962509, -0.0061351945623755455, -0.0014810520224273205, 0.06463777273893356, -0.03513694927096367, -0.026361726224422455, -0.04561256617307663, -0.04402060806751251, 0.008101982064545155, 0.013980554416775703, -0.013239555060863495, 0.06618490815162659, 0.02115711383521557, 0.02751273103058338, 0.001292714267037809, -0.005287862848490477, 0.011891806498169899, -0.010320630855858326, 0.026719719171524048, -0.001020663301460445, -0.04301810637116432, 0.043577469885349274, -0.00038120991666801274, -0.0008258315501734614, -0.028982095420360565, -0.02710840478539467, 0.04045197740197182, 0.03881004452705383, -0.009928684681653976, -0.01255718432366848, 0.00964460801333189, 0.036125123500823975, -0.07424966245889664, 0.009892191737890244, -0.06400216370820999, 0.009174206294119358, -0.01871557906270027, -0.00474754860624671 ]
<p>In a multiple regression, the regression coefficient of the two subsamples is opposite to that of the full sample. Both coefficients are significant. The sum of the number of obs in the two subsamples is equal to that of the full sample. Is this normal? What are the possible causes? Thanks.</p>
49,779
[ -0.015562327578663826, 0.007207570131868124, -0.019707541912794113, -0.0010416709119454026, 0.054838504642248154, 0.03575251251459122, -0.005995842162519693, -0.02048271708190441, 0.017767760902643204, -0.05315723270177841, 0.01706499420106411, 0.018645450472831726, 0.0508008748292923, -0.03797054663300514, 0.01742730848491192, -0.009684103541076183, -0.010013196617364883, 0.05778354033827782, 0.013801556080579758, 0.006662008818238974, -0.04012458398938179, 0.05245358869433403, 0.043999962508678436, -0.03257407620549202, -0.029083827510476112, 0.0598062202334404, 0.017708981409668922, 0.010490565560758114, 0.02400645799934864, 0.044514622539281845, -0.0031592724844813347, -0.028355643153190613, 0.014222489669919014, 0.035416293889284134, 0.03551577031612396, -0.0028976197354495525, 0.00004638804239220917, -0.03144187852740288, 0.005142899230122566, 0.04095323383808136, -0.01892252080142498, -0.019125454127788544, -0.021338636055588722, 0.03960300609469414, -0.010037473402917385, 0.01956656388938427, 0.012257283553481102, -0.023658238351345062, 0.05511181801557541, -0.04844936355948448, 0.07171360403299332, -0.021458564326167107, 0.07272221893072128, 0.021490691229701042, -0.03712663799524307, 0.02578889951109886, 0.04354574903845787, 0.059400349855422974, -0.01730968803167343, -0.03292267769575119, 0.006237376946955919, -0.010679071769118309, 0.022832488641142845, 0.02579168789088726, -0.055015917867422104, 0.02271891199052334, -0.016587352380156517, -0.004188849590718746, 0.03683923929929733, 0.013092170469462872, 0.005157363135367632, 0.00603479752317071, 0.046093981713056564, -0.03923618420958519, -0.014011045917868614, -0.02488027885556221, 0.024627232924103737, 0.028478829190135002, 0.021871624514460564, 0.04880951717495918, 0.030714716762304306, 0.003502536565065384, 0.012468893080949783, 0.016964023932814598, 0.02416077069938183, -0.004582654219120741, 0.04529031738638878, -0.02947026491165161, 0.019797610118985176, 0.011652186512947083, -0.02205321379005909, 0.03419549763202667, 0.058692626655101776, 0.012490561231970787, -0.042260754853487015, 0.042893171310424805, -0.010551792569458485, 0.05027361586689949, 0.03747575730085373, -0.017326558008790016, -0.009132332168519497, -0.011666868813335896, 0.036595024168491364, 0.04569479450583458, -0.03153130039572716, -0.005167326889932156, -0.03977262228727341, 0.023076973855495453, 0.01663738116621971, -0.013463279232382774, 0.005344080738723278, 0.00762208504602313, 0.02120114117860794, -0.01315575372427702, 0.02786862850189209, -0.006797692738473415, 0.0011603710008785129, 0.0029367280658334494, 0.03650730848312378, 0.06266269087791443, 0.03913882374763489, -0.03702782467007637, -0.00316189625300467, 0.0007670946652069688, -0.040945760905742645, 0.008721204474568367, 0.018854785710573196, -0.015091287903487682, -0.05034925788640976, 0.05714453384280205, 0.02027021534740925, -0.024647802114486694, -0.0004342714964877814, -0.021595386788249016, 0.04896368458867073, 0.013498999178409576, -0.06764497607946396, -0.07226891815662384, 0.029895130544900894, -0.03958544880151749, -0.01123115699738264, -0.026174061000347137, -0.03325113281607628, 0.03392437472939491, 0.055422332137823105, -0.018923146650195122, 0.02775759808719158, 0.009151367470622063, 0.038728777319192886, 0.027765342965722084, 0.008042657747864723, -0.02501295879483223, -0.024916209280490875, -0.010993480682373047, 0.003498847596347332, -0.11993548274040222, -0.008618666790425777, 0.016703495755791664, -0.008455757983028889, 0.022293083369731903, -0.023816000670194626, 0.02264571003615856, -0.026897991076111794, -0.0007250307826325297, 0.009888921864330769, -0.05081098526716232, 0.052502233535051346, -0.005078940186649561, 0.009405544959008694, 0.037012647837400436, 0.00016597907233517617, 0.020127806812524796, -0.001564273377880454, 0.06296432763338089, 0.027035340666770935, -0.020937183871865273, 0.0024032124783843756, -0.012470957823097706, 0.04492625594139099, 0.04557926580309868, -0.07281717658042908, -0.03767396882176399, -0.008868636563420296, -0.0014353340957313776, 0.009885505773127079, 0.03874923661351204, 0.01730278879404068, -0.019887708127498627, 0.02789669670164585, -0.054410193115472794, -0.01794486865401268, -0.046325404196977615, -0.004451015032827854, -0.019546331837773323, -0.060862429440021515, 0.01333210151642561, 0.04958559200167656, 0.015700984746217728, -0.006783029064536095, -0.03203275054693222, -0.027962617576122284, -0.020745089277625084, 0.03328694403171539, -0.043211646378040314, 0.04012065380811691, 0.050331275910139084, 0.0477609857916832, -0.011217473074793816, 0.055395182222127914, -0.03253260254859924, -0.019243936985731125, 0.022324655205011368, -0.030068855732679367, 0.0016524243401363492, -0.040718208998441696, -0.04311748594045639, 0.02308417111635208, -0.023469051346182823, -0.014813904650509357, 0.04391992464661598, -0.0586165152490139, 0.04656844586133957, 0.057458359748125076, 0.005261688493192196, -0.035613104701042175, 0.0010690424824133515, 0.035556286573410034, 0.026848940178751945, -0.014721271581947803, -0.022863902151584625, -0.03931781277060509, -0.002903274493291974, 0.024802478030323982, 0.02084612101316452, -0.05778364837169647, 0.014700263738632202, 0.041342660784721375, 0.04488518461585045, 0.01666194014251232, 0.010804597288370132, 0.005025044083595276, -0.04047314450144768, -0.007414477877318859, 0.014981296844780445, 0.008975004777312279, 0.04104199260473251, 0.02397327497601509, 0.02175493724644184, 0.016210470348596573, 0.0025551465805619955, 0.006215451285243034, 0.05334385111927986, 0.009559092111885548, 0.008975937962532043, -0.014093437232077122, 0.002534593688324094, 0.02943728119134903, -0.04108334705233574, 0.02292049676179886, 0.03914830833673477, 0.04589366167783737, -0.007352575659751892, 0.007702635135501623, -0.0056711225770413876, -0.008562013506889343, 0.006652790121734142, -0.04593797028064728, 0.007843626663088799, 0.020049551501870155, -0.03259178623557091, -0.0026829128619283438, -0.050295550376176834, 0.003804274834692478, -0.03283672407269478, -0.01589793525636196, 0.04022759199142456, -0.0010846403893083334, 0.05947450175881386, -0.009187360294163227, -0.029504477977752686, -0.04635929688811302, -0.028266793116927147, 0.030303023755550385, -0.021033350378274918, -0.043337803333997726, 0.019905822351574898, -0.008308246731758118, -0.03284614160656929, 0.02894328348338604, -0.021400345489382744, -0.028982428833842278, 0.042283739894628525, -0.021642224863171577, -0.0404830165207386, -0.056645993143320084, -0.03430695831775665, -0.009880228899419308, -0.028797753155231476, -0.016681626439094543, 0.054552413523197174, 0.010700547136366367, -0.04361744597554207, -0.0057269735261797905, -0.027506329119205475, -0.020640604197978973, -0.025797443464398384, -0.0306397657841444, 0.009802987799048424, 0.011983992531895638, 0.023000594228506088, -0.0013048513792455196, -0.051132682710886, 0.0058865672908723354, -0.04514379799365997, -0.08680333197116852, 0.020996462553739548, 0.006225757300853729, 0.046420868486166, -0.04589453712105751, -0.017131539061665535, 0.04437929019331932, 0.025093458592891693, -0.007826617918908596, -0.009029109962284565, 0.011361845768988132, -0.02930697239935398, -0.02430635876953602, 0.04390865936875343, 0.028446434065699577, 0.026847928762435913, 0.07188678532838821, -0.010124578140676022, 0.043601423501968384, 0.04492669552564621, -0.012841782532632351, -0.005476996768265963, 0.020618418231606483, -0.0032202028669416904, -0.0014111889759078622, 0.01223610807210207, 0.02676110714673996, -0.009770199656486511, -0.0009341007680632174, 0.004381622187793255, 0.024411091580986977, 0.01657033897936344, 0.009798566810786724, 0.0347064808011055, -0.010816548019647598, 0.010137069970369339, -0.027402348816394806, 0.026089532300829887, 0.023195624351501465, 0.006559036672115326, -0.06749998778104782, -0.009021332487463951, 0.004188583232462406, -0.033217232674360275, 0.00007108166755642742, 0.03198036924004555, -0.00011076628288719803, -0.006891687400639057, -0.019564736634492874, -0.024615982547402382, 0.008067669346928596, 0.025038165971636772, -0.030064035207033157, -0.04920278489589691, 0.06581704318523407, 0.048729922622442245, 0.00983815360814333, -0.007767686620354652, -0.05815746262669563, 0.0030896500684320927, -0.06495298445224762, -0.032749686390161514, -0.004893461242318153, 0.05389783903956413, -0.03056352213025093, 0.01901967264711857, 0.01472593005746603, 0.006469177082180977, -0.006366771645843983, 0.011228921823203564, -0.06498053669929504, 0.042874254286289215, -0.021227514371275902, -0.015383115969598293, 0.00802625622600317, -0.014285489916801453, 0.0272542592138052, -0.04831303656101227, 0.007930589839816093, -0.022946707904338837, 0.0431995652616024, -0.03665349632501602, 0.008915449492633343, -0.015636945143342018, 0.02011965401470661, 0.0014694975689053535, 0.017379051074385643, 0.022236905992031097, -0.014058530330657959, 0.01598105952143669, 0.03145395591855049, -0.030995670706033707, -0.02370956353843212, -0.07075515389442444, 0.021627455949783325, 0.007551716640591621, 0.024619823321700096, 0.05028320103883743, 0.028650229796767235, -0.02478499710559845, 0.02903747744858265, -0.01352822408080101, 0.04074666276574135, 0.044947270303964615, 0.010070779360830784, -0.039940834045410156, -0.007617218419909477, -0.03378614783287048, 0.002945343730971217, 0.028300028294324875, 0.021893026307225227, -0.019613558426499367, 0.04863211512565613, 0.02942347340285778, -0.05387642979621887, 0.03367641195654869, 0.06013518571853638, 0.026787621900439262, 0.02138768695294857, -0.01513290498405695, -0.002702886937186122, -0.00861603394150734, 0.008451252244412899, 0.03129258006811142, 0.010342506691813469, -0.03798992931842804, -0.037293583154678345, 0.0385514460504055, -0.031141027808189392, 0.0053464737720787525, -0.0042638410814106464, -0.021305561065673828, 0.04201298952102661, 0.0018840156262740493, -0.013216732069849968, 0.03259870782494545, 0.036132730543613434, 0.025675596669316292, 0.04965683072805405, 0.0006472835666500032, -0.07616963237524033, 0.020056281238794327, 0.018293920904397964, 0.03603285551071167, -0.04059770703315735, 0.03816083073616028, -0.011353088542819023, 0.014899997971951962, 0.04820740967988968, -0.023602090775966644, 0.049711499363183975, -0.0011840054066851735, 0.024206683039665222, 0.016969779506325722, 0.023166408762335777, -0.06981779634952545, 0.02235444076359272, -0.03947209194302559, 0.009109923616051674, -0.020430345088243484, -0.016651427373290062, -0.0822247713804245, 0.015262620523571968, 0.005441407207399607, 0.06609424203634262, -0.0075033875182271, -0.04324515908956528, 0.011882436461746693, 0.042787712067365646, -0.0027648804243654013, -0.03533647209405899, 0.015242543071508408, 0.008934738114476204, -0.024749591946601868, 0.023128481581807137, -0.03143930435180664, -0.037506069988012314, 0.01602085866034031, 0.007201605010777712, -0.009355871938169003, -0.03220616653561592, -0.025734510272741318, 0.009061518125236034, 0.030623963102698326, -0.010694460943341255, 0.06811220943927765, -0.015330572612583637, 0.0027092292439192533, -0.008068879134953022, -0.026732685044407845, 0.017318887636065483, -0.028734123334288597, -0.04602076858282089, 0.0006551590631715953, 0.008752339519560337, -0.014246221631765366, 0.01531922910362482, -0.003651014529168606, 0.013172986917197704, -0.01894872821867466, -0.023575983941555023, 0.0033400249667465687, 0.014229265041649342, -0.0068917591124773026, -0.012141473591327667, 0.031399067491292953, 0.03820972144603729, -0.0268415417522192, -0.02255120873451233, 0.05538545548915863, -0.018442323431372643, 0.015018555335700512, 0.05100962147116661, -0.022635340690612793, 0.02944990061223507, -0.03780205175280571, -0.012630817480385303, -0.01684018224477768, -0.03573709353804588, -0.012270539067685604, -0.03541238233447075, 0.026278696954250336, 0.007367090787738562, -0.04550279304385185, -0.0163869746029377, 0.0169694684445858, 0.0014088593889027834, 0.029314380139112473, -0.03959907218813896, 0.0699336975812912, 0.021045461297035217, -0.007657379377633333, -0.07638829201459885, -0.07785069197416306, -0.006188294384628534, 0.019065190106630325, 0.01824500970542431, -0.022178472951054573, -0.013834705576300621, -0.02327832020819187, -0.026272010058164597, -0.02279815822839737, 0.04059063270688057, -0.04879334196448326, -0.013092396780848503, 0.016783185303211212, -0.0014093759236857295, 0.06486371159553528, -0.007096767891198397, -0.00417825672775507, 0.020216304808855057, -0.012780613265931606, -0.045979294925928116, 0.004913985729217529, 0.029626673087477684, -0.023528490215539932, -0.025267956778407097, -0.045409660786390305, -0.016686851158738136, 0.0323001965880394, -0.017905218526721, -0.03109144978225231, -0.01779814250767231, 0.010456036776304245, 0.028770895674824715, -0.005579095333814621, 0.001846632338128984, -0.006290503311902285, 0.010071354918181896, -0.00687713036313653, 0.000716525362804532, -0.010310802608728409, -0.030170779675245285, 0.0009509772062301636, 0.018137119710445404, -0.01765275001525879, 0.001247034640982747, 0.07005993276834488, -0.013241642154753208, 0.004137872252613306, 0.0025103760417550802, -0.025643054395914078, 0.028851507231593132, 0.017852477729320526, -0.008340566419064999, 0.01942780800163746, 0.05721750482916832, -0.04624345898628235, -0.02867216058075428, -0.014341496862471104, 0.010781042277812958, 0.030838575214147568, -0.040381889790296555, 0.06755909323692322, 0.09174828231334686, -0.017267655581235886, -0.00338940043002367, -0.060464680194854736, -0.005503279156982899, -0.0031738090328872204, 0.023130957037210464, 0.019200192764401436, -0.038652922958135605, 0.0005963722942396998, 0.014529339037835598, 0.0321754552423954, 0.004123950842767954, 0.04253486543893814, 0.02288012020289898, 0.01674466021358967, -0.018018536269664764, 0.004301903769373894, -0.058271002024412155, 0.03642669692635536, -0.009361941367387772, 0.027001941576600075, -0.026842279359698296, 0.005968460347503424, 0.051684070378541946, 0.04133353754878044, 0.04302406311035156, -0.044253718107938766, -0.04150970280170441, -0.016244245693087578, 0.020413294434547424, -0.02303127944469452, -0.00669484818354249, 0.014889353886246681, -0.01828060857951641, 0.0276653915643692, 0.016125723719596863, 0.05839122086763382, -0.05606973543763161, -0.04324864596128464, -0.027665773406624794, 0.0021347671281546354, -0.02822265960276127, 0.0189883504062891, -0.04284460097551346, -0.01866467297077179, 0.05390669032931328, -0.03418333828449249, -0.005398570094257593, -0.0006887436029501259, 0.036613453179597855, 0.0013496042229235172, 0.06269708275794983, 0.02657790668308735, -0.0019298914121463895, 0.008818318136036396, -0.02132849022746086, 0.10235480964183807, 0.07644423097372055, 0.003839335637167096, -0.06188691779971123, 0.031920403242111206, 0.015985989943146706, -0.01676959916949272, -0.032543640583753586, 0.007076593581587076, 0.007091081701219082, -0.013190431520342827, 0.03572709858417511, 0.07445744425058365, 0.018860965967178345, -0.01436602883040905, 0.0288600604981184, -0.026807062327861786, -0.0394846610724926, 0.013156904838979244, 0.008598421700298786, -0.0009210791322402656, -0.012972029857337475, -0.048977356404066086, 0.0034673032350838184, -0.018603798002004623, -0.020267440006136894, -0.025765547528862953, -0.01006880309432745, -0.03164098039269447, 0.017197951674461365, -0.024818507954478264, -0.009248370304703712, 0.049047790467739105, -0.00533716706559062, -0.042527467012405396, -0.0036251526325941086, 0.04991608485579491, -0.010716075077652931, -0.01098236721009016, 0.021435394883155823, -0.012168855406343937, 0.00544767314568162, 0.024108223617076874, -0.0011021558893844485, -0.07380480319261551, -0.0031281544361263514, -0.007589434273540974, 0.042517419904470444, 0.02687854692339897, -0.005051942076534033, -0.016397887840867043, 0.009383409284055233, -0.00505167618393898, -0.05110100656747818, -0.03577370196580887, 0.021591654047369957, -0.0024611824192106724, -0.0769215077161789, -0.03598105534911156, -0.05217907577753067, 0.005990359932184219, 0.014552460983395576, 0.028055276721715927, -0.007902642711997032, 0.0007942714146338403, -0.0352393314242363, -0.018109189346432686, 0.04804300144314766, -0.017250262200832367, -0.003289869986474514, 0.028100335970520973, -0.014211620204150677, -0.02000684291124344, 0.02398207038640976, 0.01619570329785347, -0.02293838933110237, 0.02502473257482052, 0.01631842739880085, -0.038778532296419144, -0.028839828446507454, -0.03867105394601822, 0.007596180774271488, -0.024372022598981857, -0.013143148273229599, -0.07466597855091095, -0.0160673838108778, 0.0278623104095459, 0.007014190778136253, 0.01578245870769024, 0.007172892801463604, 0.040660224854946136, 0.06421316415071487, 0.022173555567860603, -0.07009410113096237, -0.04210545867681503, -0.020559797063469887, -0.0006461400771513581, -0.008114049211144447, 0.006776298396289349, 0.03418376296758652, -0.0014663906767964363, 0.025721970945596695, 0.010061976499855518, 0.021321792155504227, -0.010022580623626709, -0.0017096300143748522, 0.027799313887953758, -0.044234778732061386, 0.013341264799237251, 0.029394812881946564, 0.00045462348498404026, -0.006634440738707781, 0.020175252109766006, -0.027113186195492744, 0.01486936490982771, 0.0029258427675813437, -0.006132055073976517, -0.044938988983631134, 0.023591062054038048, -0.008646401576697826, 0.025903012603521347, -0.039980631321668625, -0.0327158160507679, -0.04833873361349106, -0.0013328352943062782, 0.029745550826191902, -0.00012375805818010122, -0.013782831840217113, 0.0018532270332798362, -0.03496534004807472, 0.0005235618446022272, 0.035531092435121536, 0.025873592123389244, 0.04826309159398079, -0.00999678298830986, 0.02485068142414093, 0.002806764328852296, 0.07632288336753845, -0.01482375431805849, -0.009370953775942326, 0.03818214684724808, -0.03312937542796135, -0.029127249494194984, 0.01898530311882496, -0.004013238474726677, 0.03709230571985245, 0.002605495508760214, -0.012008868157863617, -0.055062972009181976, 0.05274299532175064, -0.023422613739967346, 0.015187667682766914, -0.012521851807832718, 0.027063682675361633, 0.04393814131617546, -0.0011326284147799015, -0.040044981986284256, 0.02405497431755066, -0.0225078072398901, 0.014928735792636871, 0.05459972470998764, 0.014494804665446281, -0.012408076785504818, -0.025170473381876945, 0.010622670873999596, 0.007815741002559662, 0.010553160682320595, 0.005366131197661161, 0.020289916545152664, 0.05024023354053497, -0.05902263522148132, 0.04478712007403374, 0.0019582947716116905, 0.02299734577536583, -0.07975645363330841, -0.057634662836790085, -0.0023558891844004393, -0.009920087642967701, 0.022741055116057396, -0.04984432831406593, -0.005838893819600344, 0.059009384363889694, -0.036024920642375946, -0.01625172421336174, -0.03868885710835457, -0.05179797112941742, -0.050253771245479584, -0.02145732380449772, -0.030575517565011978, 0.03333680331707001, 0.0403374619781971, 0.01869979128241539, 0.03225335478782654, 0.009540198370814323, -0.0069220224395394325, -0.014323938637971878, -0.03142627328634262, -0.024483539164066315, -0.012526972219347954, -0.05446723476052284, 0.03481651097536087, -0.03353703022003174, -0.026985498145222664, 0.053837910294532776, -0.03743381425738335, -0.005855165887624025, 0.03668423742055893, 0.0415690653026104, 0.03463675081729889, 0.06230223551392555, -0.00694067869335413, 0.021803654730319977, 0.004749712068587542, -0.006445431616157293, -0.006741937715560198, 0.024049341678619385, -0.04496478661894798, 0.02365928329527378, 0.006603932939469814, 0.004060057923197746, -0.019282029941678047, 0.011782280169427395, -0.011616211384534836, 0.0002538092667236924, -0.022353224456310272, 0.013095692731440067, -0.0013273886870592833, -0.04848198965191841, 0.028495140373706818, -0.05359557271003723, -0.006831448059529066, 0.024511173367500305, 0.038145776838064194, -0.05182836577296257, -0.012207722291350365, 0.018904704600572586, -0.031044207513332367, 0.019098730757832527, -0.02157234214246273, -0.014220804907381535, -0.04341467097401619, -0.028348421677947044, 0.02834099903702736, 0.012035222724080086, -0.03873705491423607, -0.020030329003930092, -0.019858580082654953, 0.046939488500356674, -0.011139828711748123, -0.007939967326819897, -0.01630312204360962, -0.03351297229528427, -0.03947421535849571, -0.09319278597831726, 0.04817492514848709, 0.0037478050217032433, 0.007705369498580694, -0.030460016801953316, -0.04799330234527588, -0.008879049681127071, 0.004562975838780403, 0.03045850805938244, -0.012750901281833649, 0.007575772237032652, 0.0034165254328399897, 0.028980182483792305, 0.01807812787592411, -0.023647354915738106, 0.04731777310371399, 0.031150901690125465, -0.03644609451293945, -0.00926943589001894, -0.025584915652871132, 0.048516895622015, 0.003677460364997387, -0.0002441734541207552, -0.031214110553264618, 0.021944060921669006, -0.001097213476896286, 0.0023314363788813353, 0.034614987671375275, -0.003409799886867404, -0.003137758234515786, 0.04962506145238876, -0.007130547426640987, 0.024593139067292213, 0.04224919155240059, -0.011911598965525627, -0.056513093411922455, 0.001913573476485908, 0.014668888412415981, -0.02271134965121746, 0.0044782524928450584, 0.021348020061850548, -0.005422539543360472, -0.029582343995571136, -0.015010681934654713, 0.006045124027878046, -0.018635232001543045, 0.009167737327516079, 0.05733258277177811, 0.014529391191899776, 0.03654798865318298, 0.0036868418101221323, 0.028311824426054955, 0.017736731097102165, -0.01691436767578125, 0.055390551686286926, 0.03889288008213043, 0.02142981067299843, 0.031160136684775352, 0.008239964954555035, 0.026209816336631775, -0.018035607412457466, 0.0452432781457901, -0.02510877326130867, -0.016282355412840843, -0.0264812633395195, -0.018902713432908058, 0.01824052631855011, -0.006812364794313908, 0.043156854808330536, -0.0016003120690584183, 0.033262524753808975, 0.038304056972265244, -0.07249995321035385, 0.011991669423878193, -0.017270071431994438, 0.0263308547437191, -0.05530814453959465, -0.030011046677827835, -0.011438580229878426, -0.009434867650270462, 0.01064271293580532, -0.03376118093729019, 0.01988890767097473, 0.0028486507944762707, 0.024877477437257767, -0.012671690434217453, 0.04424241930246353, -0.010183320380747318, -0.03404245153069496, -0.0012832399224862456, 0.019529573619365692, -0.032322924584150314, -0.03100522793829441, 0.007293412461876869, 0.05372883751988411, -0.0013425928773358464, -0.03526634722948074, -0.016896624118089676, 0.008055555634200573, 0.06399853527545929, -0.06340736150741577, -0.017875296995043755, -0.0335921011865139, 0.020922943949699402, -0.011585400439798832, -0.04659773036837578 ]
<p>I have this confusion about which transformation to use in my data. The histogram of my original data looks like this </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/ANDSY.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>Now I have seen at most of the places to take log transformation in case the data is positively skewed. But when I take log transformation I get something like this which is negatively skewed, not what I desire.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/aorf0.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>If I take square root transformation and cube root transformation I get like this </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/hwls7.jpg" alt="enter image description here"> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/uJ70C.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>Now the data is pretty much close to normal. But I didn't get the intuition behind this. Why didn't it work with the log transformation when I see at so many places people mentioning about log transformation useful when data is positively skewed. Here square root and cube root worked.</p> <p>I want to know at which condition we should use log transformation and at which condition to use cube root transformation. Suggestions?</p>
73,559
[ -0.03325868025422096, -0.011127274483442307, 0.0012144007487222552, -0.014071066863834858, 0.018709899857640266, 0.00941187608987093, -0.0023467845749109983, -0.012268029153347015, 0.006448825355619192, -0.031834058463573456, 0.04605988785624504, -0.004250833299010992, 0.042635902762413025, 0.018599430099129677, 0.029911495745182037, 0.01419404149055481, -0.02583429589867592, -0.010553000494837761, -0.019838184118270874, -0.004477396607398987, -0.020034464076161385, 0.020565180107951164, -0.012919297441840172, 0.011855308897793293, -0.03920207545161247, 0.03916455805301666, 0.004592421464622021, 0.003370798658579588, 0.0063980198465287685, 0.07269299775362015, -0.020012810826301575, -0.006840911228209734, 0.0077535840682685375, 0.049762725830078125, 0.013091676868498325, 0.000598614220507443, -0.02405651845037937, -0.0012855665991082788, -0.01780470460653305, 0.04000056907534599, -0.006971993483603001, 0.01062092836946249, -0.024148542433977127, 0.0772184282541275, 0.002564632100984454, 0.03022431954741478, -0.012829462997615337, -0.0007248830515891314, 0.01682952791452408, -0.05247315764427185, 0.07623671740293503, -0.02042900212109089, 0.01873812824487686, 0.03436364606022835, -0.009125097654759884, 0.0012289719888940454, 0.08351185917854309, 0.059043999761343, -0.021549731492996216, -0.045675672590732574, -0.007961749099195004, -0.014177423901855946, -0.030527347698807716, -0.010016929358243942, 0.013856776058673859, -0.009527865797281265, -0.009811620227992535, -0.03170651197433472, 0.05190955474972725, -0.0335431843996048, 0.023728499189019203, 0.020129643380641937, 0.06388963013887405, -0.02511594444513321, 0.00674055190756917, -0.0423784963786602, -0.002829840639606118, 0.025728104636073112, 0.046018850058317184, 0.006956603843718767, 0.01048994343727827, 0.016042735427618027, 0.014710276387631893, 0.034462664276361465, 0.013922261074185371, -0.01137528382241726, 0.07097338140010834, -0.018917091190814972, 0.025143807753920555, 0.05277816951274872, 0.002924074651673436, -0.007729039061814547, 0.043740205466747284, -0.020770210772752762, -0.0199589766561985, 0.01981755532324314, 0.00975873228162527, 0.03494766354560852, -0.0029923487454652786, -0.004790090024471283, 0.0025718261022120714, -0.02907220646739006, -0.0038005595561116934, 0.027150409296154976, 0.0035920680966228247, 0.04062139242887497, -0.011921633966267109, 0.012519113719463348, -0.025659432634711266, -0.054773420095443726, 0.007320989854633808, 0.0021402528509497643, -0.003963026218116283, -0.010345871560275555, 0.011683402583003044, -0.021262552589178085, -0.014948911964893341, -0.013041323982179165, 0.03877599164843559, 0.012095963582396507, -0.0033516064286231995, 0.009872699156403542, 0.010714543052017689, -0.024807186797261238, -0.04081161320209503, 0.015968425199389458, 0.01794189028441906, -0.008167924359440804, -0.06368175148963928, 0.035304054617881775, 0.04292621836066246, -0.04968120902776718, 0.05357430875301361, -0.0036772764287889004, 0.03347788006067276, 0.0023887339048087597, -0.10673042386770248, -0.0348789319396019, 0.04845661297440529, 0.0031233676709234715, 0.038932859897613525, -0.06239517778158188, -0.023348120972514153, 0.06391473114490509, 0.061915621161460876, -0.006296503357589245, 0.04186013340950012, 0.016738831996917725, 0.022887086495757103, 0.036011792719364166, -0.020738845691084862, -0.01093575730919838, -0.03523014113306999, -0.0457623191177845, -0.0004195048240944743, -0.04531649500131607, -0.010402555577456951, 0.01142602413892746, -0.02327846921980381, 0.010915926657617092, 0.05617130175232887, 0.01688273809850216, -0.014670212753117085, 0.014959356747567654, -0.020100411027669907, -0.023513782769441605, 0.10291344672441483, -0.012186480686068535, 0.002903335727751255, -0.008806968107819557, -0.0239095538854599, 0.02595301903784275, 0.021408718079328537, 0.06453141570091248, 0.05871482193470001, -0.02336694300174713, 0.020212633535265923, -0.032234661281108856, 0.030151864513754845, -0.008419273421168327, -0.05405057221651077, -0.01964503340423107, -0.008974511176347733, -0.020352596417069435, 0.007277030032128096, 0.06574268639087677, -0.026171833276748657, -0.03607109561562538, 0.06429837644100189, -0.04189867526292801, -0.05479131266474724, -0.031029745936393738, 0.03856829181313515, -0.0190344899892807, -0.022499751299619675, 0.012253301218152046, 0.021074527874588966, 0.057032570242881775, 0.001763065462000668, -0.029158007353544235, 0.03154843673110008, -0.0002902088453993201, 0.022542433813214302, 0.006685780361294746, 0.00455808499827981, 0.037901971489191055, 0.031774841248989105, -0.012637860141694546, -0.026863116770982742, -0.056187864392995834, 0.0027095761615782976, 0.03639470040798187, -0.0159844271838665, -0.005044770427048206, -0.008826096542179585, -0.03168094903230667, -0.005974451079964638, -0.001169712864793837, -0.02400396019220352, 0.04333531856536865, -0.03835407644510269, 0.0463595874607563, 0.04923355579376221, -0.014534113928675652, 0.02851228229701519, 0.027067923918366432, -0.0016488548135384917, 0.028383836150169373, -0.008766984567046165, -0.03766579553484917, -0.0430406853556633, 0.007828951813280582, 0.019406525418162346, 0.031573060899972916, -0.043650198727846146, -0.03358098119497299, 0.05748075619339943, 0.015449169091880322, -0.006402923725545406, 0.027060551568865776, 0.014627918601036072, -0.03340400755405426, -0.00783106405287981, 0.0217245202511549, 0.037198506295681, -0.010776622220873833, 0.01330407615751028, -0.017917504534125328, 0.06054080277681351, -0.03471516817808151, -0.04329501837491989, 0.02510065771639347, 0.006148666143417358, 0.02211708389222622, -0.025120940059423447, 0.005443901754915714, 0.00166712561622262, -0.0320638008415699, -0.006219000555574894, 0.034370243549346924, 0.01681160368025303, 0.003160232910886407, -0.03512425720691681, 0.030827447772026062, 0.03452378138899803, 0.03416265919804573, -0.0049752239137887955, -0.01576198823750019, 0.0072891549207270145, -0.053423505276441574, -0.008859490044414997, 0.007836132310330868, -0.03393504023551941, -0.019734293222427368, 0.025040199980139732, 0.051272500306367874, 0.02694256231188774, 0.00764381792396307, -0.0425441600382328, -0.03927423059940338, -0.017118507996201515, -0.005809693597257137, 0.023774152621626854, 0.01171465776860714, -0.02882961742579937, -0.033598631620407104, -0.023450495675206184, 0.003774043405428529, -0.0009635565220378339, 0.0023978857789188623, 0.004213038831949234, 0.011685206554830074, 0.004222513176500797, -0.012670814990997314, -0.036374904215335846, -0.010772794485092163, 0.02820580080151558, -0.004670029040426016, -0.0509566031396389, 0.10335556417703629, 0.0007448064861819148, -0.008696424774825573, -0.00469472398981452, -0.017238156870007515, -0.043469883501529694, -0.03198368474841118, 0.033367425203323364, 0.00016236388182733208, -0.02116992510855198, 0.038960617035627365, -0.012462502345442772, -0.030395762994885445, 0.010240503586828709, -0.06217649206519127, -0.04637814685702324, 0.011881302110850811, 0.018643811345100403, 0.039257824420928955, -0.008866013027727604, -0.04597977176308632, 0.07835839688777924, 0.0356549508869648, -0.039843033999204636, -0.0768926665186882, -0.012914967723190784, -0.06156186759471893, -0.022939424961805344, 0.019878625869750977, 0.01715022698044777, 0.021048104390501976, 0.0569426566362381, -0.02909870818257332, 0.05501122772693634, 0.01393437385559082, 0.0067294263280928135, -0.0432516448199749, 0.010893963277339935, -0.0008523325668647885, -0.02727074734866619, 0.014848284423351288, 0.03605150058865547, 0.022226985543966293, 0.022524680942296982, 0.012314719147980213, 0.010959608480334282, 0.006939599756151438, -0.08114057034254074, 0.011326107196509838, 0.005650002975016832, 0.005594436079263687, -0.03045564889907837, 0.008881830610334873, 0.039877235889434814, -0.039786841720342636, -0.04497145116329193, 0.022239601239562035, 0.010102416388690472, -0.001671544392593205, -0.0042125266045331955, 0.045059364289045334, 0.03524969890713692, 0.024750573560595512, -0.03497401997447014, -0.0004202371055725962, -0.03863392025232315, 0.04028624668717384, -0.027270125225186348, -0.006698689889162779, 0.02930804155766964, 0.06297839432954788, -0.0012918146094307303, -0.026964249089360237, -0.052973877638578415, 0.006221764720976353, -0.043981581926345825, 0.024981815367937088, -0.0011244273046031594, 0.047936923801898956, 0.01717066578567028, 0.03320068493485451, 0.05064552649855614, -0.003654262749478221, 0.0001995898492168635, 0.004895493853837252, -0.049511365592479706, 0.02422996237874031, 0.0031405624467879534, 0.03163140267133713, 0.048905499279499054, -0.035272981971502304, 0.018678711727261543, -0.05424529314041138, 0.024158965796232224, 0.03102153353393078, 0.03265649825334549, -0.02512936480343342, 0.004556381143629551, -0.002553093247115612, 0.007549370173364878, -0.021254800260066986, 0.015454300679266453, 0.027930213138461113, -0.04385843127965927, 0.025058241561055183, 0.046693988144397736, 0.019004497677087784, 0.010290834121406078, -0.016724491491913795, 0.03588950261473656, 0.04278486222028732, 0.04976467415690422, -0.030241966247558594, -0.020490337163209915, -0.01834018900990486, 0.030668379738926888, 0.023107141256332397, 0.03740082308650017, 0.012094208970665932, -0.010500550270080566, -0.0386241152882576, -0.028799744322896004, -0.025395292788743973, -0.006154967471957207, 0.0076792011968791485, 0.010718588717281818, 0.046700749546289444, 0.029714740812778473, 0.026274025440216064, -0.05241495370864868, 0.02060580439865589, 0.09944921731948853, 0.021117277443408966, -0.018108902499079704, -0.01801924780011177, -0.018003642559051514, -0.004407854750752449, -0.01916792429983616, 0.03167491406202316, -0.023846661671996117, -0.03358068689703941, -0.03835386410355568, 0.06357459723949432, -0.017380835488438606, -0.008363539353013039, 0.026399126276373863, 0.012472424656152725, 0.06408573687076569, -0.008357178419828415, 0.0059415376745164394, 0.02882598713040352, 0.013105938211083412, 0.046259019523859024, 0.009253907017409801, -0.004356703255325556, -0.05650705471634865, 0.022728048264980316, 0.018001822754740715, 0.02818519063293934, 0.0010810209205374122, 0.003476387122645974, -0.04102255403995514, -0.008740040473639965, -0.0010437234304845333, -0.0595201700925827, 0.045132312923669815, -0.013767614960670471, 0.027188777923583984, -0.014009663835167885, -0.04390124976634979, -0.04869266226887703, 0.015794439241290092, 0.004889617208391428, 0.017456281930208206, -0.015458840876817703, -0.051649753004312515, -0.042483191937208176, 0.020532067865133286, -0.01480370108038187, 0.009512524120509624, -0.02093403972685337, -0.0050078751519322395, -0.01974322646856308, 0.059609394520521164, -0.0428256131708622, -0.08006034046411514, 0.006752633955329657, -0.009789131581783295, -0.010778299532830715, 0.057820990681648254, 0.021745719015598297, -0.04959253594279289, -0.004102679435163736, 0.007791438139975071, -0.007926956750452518, -0.037734903395175934, -0.023193052038550377, 0.041410282254219055, 0.047553908079862595, -0.005909907631576061, 0.055830057710409164, 0.04340106248855591, -0.019824733957648277, -0.012813275679945946, -0.04030599072575569, 0.01773807406425476, -0.05331283435225487, -0.017212679609656334, -0.03249097988009453, 0.029157066717743874, -0.030138742178678513, 0.030179183930158615, -0.011899327859282494, 0.06580239534378052, -0.036521900445222855, 0.01485463511198759, 0.030533434823155403, 0.01106282975524664, 0.022532213479280472, 0.013182693161070347, -0.006166819483041763, -0.0008667364600114524, -0.015612591989338398, -0.03437906131148338, -0.009919130243360996, -0.030170787125825882, 0.007240929640829563, 0.00899517722427845, -0.018124595284461975, -0.0010078249033540487, -0.003692452795803547, -0.0018725236877799034, -0.0004857685707975179, -0.044686321169137955, 0.02343561500310898, 0.017385728657245636, 0.0037535661831498146, 0.03703389689326286, -0.026997903361916542, 0.05690106377005577, -0.016397997736930847, -0.022122714668512344, 0.046868689358234406, -0.05011030659079552, 0.0011416920460760593, 0.017862645909190178, 0.02136986143887043, -0.05076196417212486, -0.06029539182782173, 0.0230355616658926, -0.03388771787285805, -0.01683095470070839, -0.0261221956461668, -0.057118095457553864, 0.004255139268934727, -0.034164559096097946, -0.022772422060370445, 0.06296344846487045, -0.002302051056176424, -0.03674763813614845, 0.013824721798300743, 0.03867853060364723, 0.07831231504678726, -0.06076307222247124, 0.016871610656380653, 0.024193132296204567, 0.005053899250924587, -0.06845938414335251, 0.05368835851550102, 0.0665566548705101, -0.006899503991007805, -0.05536432936787605, -0.010347274132072926, -0.010741238482296467, 0.02435091882944107, -0.027986308559775352, 0.0005121830618008971, -0.008434413932263851, 0.025937996804714203, 0.030335403978824615, 0.020418232306838036, 0.005130720790475607, 0.02361912466585636, 0.027242593467235565, -0.014869749546051025, -0.0037994387093931437, -0.05610261484980583, -0.0172689538449049, 0.033258941024541855, 0.010584656149148941, 0.023890908807516098, 0.04292400926351547, 0.06321928650140762, -0.010871229693293571, 0.00349046615883708, -0.02731911465525627, -0.0322449766099453, 0.02757757157087326, 0.004568758420646191, 0.022790851071476936, 0.02788395620882511, 0.02166256122291088, -0.04783599451184273, -0.01666010357439518, -0.0006181646604090929, 0.023933179676532745, 0.06155290827155113, 0.002081512473523617, 0.059686265885829926, 0.04021821171045303, -0.00455108005553484, 0.009331095963716507, -0.026474423706531525, -0.014492589980363846, -0.03491578996181488, 0.019958682358264923, 0.04004611819982529, 0.006384594365954399, 0.04128316417336464, -0.037612058222293854, 0.008229369297623634, 0.0028259113896638155, 0.012409032322466373, 0.019906556233763695, 0.017683129757642746, 0.010884027928113937, 0.005879868753254414, -0.023730451241135597, 0.028356583788990974, -0.02567715384066105, 0.0502556711435318, -0.013952969573438168, -0.011131102219223976, 0.05828932300209999, 0.04010997340083122, 0.0032762179616838694, -0.06018644571304321, 0.0017340381164103746, -0.07785800099372864, -0.03787587583065033, 0.03761035203933716, -0.028414245694875717, 0.014497298747301102, 0.016244418919086456, 0.058618079870939255, 0.010097600519657135, -0.0036355936899781227, -0.04068951681256294, -0.06308563798666, -0.009886368177831173, -0.014595957472920418, -0.016398290172219276, 0.022236712276935577, -0.026800306513905525, -0.0031156293116509914, -0.005047289188951254, -0.027889225631952286, -0.010035335086286068, 0.03140263259410858, 0.02220933511853218, -0.004215916618704796, 0.06754746288061142, 0.0086431335657835, -0.018598798662424088, 0.0005275437142699957, -0.011719899252057076, 0.11236084997653961, 0.07990982383489609, -0.010383064858615398, -0.07458273321390152, 0.020212020725011826, -0.04763356223702431, 0.013791007921099663, -0.01945536956191063, 0.012560625560581684, 0.00744736148044467, 0.03284267336130142, 0.022672738879919052, 0.04393291845917702, 0.015451105311512947, -0.03587259724736214, 0.04033907502889633, -0.03577341139316559, -0.01261997688561678, 0.01220190990716219, 0.018067410215735435, -0.03721719980239868, -0.0142879793420434, -0.06023246794939041, 0.012281409464776516, -0.015281056053936481, 0.001248180284164846, 0.015076455660164356, -0.016616424545645714, -0.018012579530477524, -0.007093469146639109, -0.018016193062067032, 0.024977125227451324, 0.04460589587688446, -0.008569213561713696, -0.011515413410961628, 0.020042210817337036, 0.004434569738805294, -0.009810233488678932, 0.02764056622982025, 0.017130950465798378, -0.027416961267590523, -0.002540129702538252, 0.03127113729715347, -0.005915277171880007, -0.034500639885663986, -0.012133252806961536, -0.05510556697845459, 0.03823821246623993, 0.010916557163000107, -0.004327355418354273, -0.015001687221229076, 0.002452316926792264, -0.0075702546164393425, -0.05408750846982002, 0.002727712970227003, 0.01720050349831581, 0.027569353580474854, -0.011185134761035442, -0.0637352466583252, -0.008323158137500286, -0.014926377683877945, 0.01489862147718668, 0.02412802167236805, 0.015098582953214645, 0.0008156784460879862, -0.01830855943262577, -0.008775295689702034, 0.05000025033950806, -0.026018545031547546, 0.015803851187229156, -0.00738184479996562, -0.010434766300022602, -0.009316056966781616, -0.01829475909471512, 0.026821935549378395, -0.007700157351791859, 0.06150897592306137, -0.004613560624420643, 0.015539182350039482, -0.03894692286849022, -0.059568438678979874, 0.02911328710615635, -0.031435057520866394, 0.014857947826385498, -0.07284479588270187, -0.0029605571180582047, 0.014884798787534237, 0.05111346393823624, 0.0030183361377567053, 0.03057880885899067, -0.0017443510005250573, 0.0400322750210762, 0.018041783943772316, -0.03598002716898918, -0.04142889380455017, 0.06779298931360245, -0.03219139948487282, -0.027034442871809006, -0.02051844820380211, 0.06447908282279968, 0.026525601744651794, 0.011875173076987267, -0.05728170648217201, 0.04419261962175369, -0.014106630347669125, 0.008062895387411118, 0.016435498371720314, -0.009223931469023228, 0.023198114708065987, 0.04347505792975426, -0.022558055818080902, -0.019781460985541344, -0.01538778841495514, -0.011643909849226475, -0.00774869741871953, -0.00045658316230401397, 0.004325271584093571, -0.03079812601208687, -0.0071878316812217236, -0.040121424943208694, 0.028329305350780487, -0.018969954922795296, 0.011603954248130322, -0.05730953812599182, 0.001685761148110032, -0.014071798883378506, -0.03370247781276703, -0.012599149718880653, 0.01090692263096571, 0.02398722432553768, 0.016978103667497635, 0.04501618444919586, 0.009233001619577408, 0.022386157885193825, -0.0402512364089489, -0.015624003484845161, -0.02233283966779709, 0.0330674983561039, -0.03087081015110016, -0.03664156794548035, 0.048242729157209396, -0.011880097910761833, -0.012740833684802055, 0.04576215520501137, 0.004207429476082325, 0.006860892288386822, -0.006439816672354937, 0.018505144864320755, 0.008707535453140736, 0.05679546669125557, -0.0036178904119879007, -0.006887668743729591, -0.03447289764881134, -0.04248131811618805, -0.0038844298105686903, 0.007861255668103695, 0.014724431559443474, -0.0032456298358738422, -0.02631869539618492, 0.05406083166599274, 0.04295453056693077, -0.004082547500729561, 0.005165551323443651, -0.049391794949769974, -0.013301772065460682, 0.042465973645448685, 0.0034352163784205914, 0.012499915435910225, 0.04679271951317787, 0.013859392143785954, -0.05595467612147331, -0.00608084537088871, -0.021240713074803352, -0.01621820032596588, -0.022398799657821655, -0.0012624779483303428, 0.0499597005546093, 0.014754737727344036, 0.05297956243157387, -0.06742848455905914, 0.0009812071220949292, 0.026103029027581215, -0.014931287616491318, -0.0011224893387407064, -0.033014532178640366, -0.004221088252961636, -0.03951626271009445, -0.01686929166316986, 0.006529351696372032, 0.03384847939014435, 0.034470073878765106, 0.041339211165905, 0.03536791726946831, 0.007193374447524548, -0.01848790794610977, 0.014106879942119122, -0.00791999977082014, 0.0253810565918684, 0.039366524666547775, -0.031050950288772583, 0.013368036597967148, -0.053806617856025696, -0.04179755225777626, 0.032381851226091385, -0.055682145059108734, -0.012605900876224041, 0.011414814740419388, 0.03703710809350014, 0.003728897077962756, 0.0302329882979393, 0.03219273313879967, -0.0396498404443264, -0.02465784177184105, 0.016737619414925575, 0.02374594286084175, 0.036178041249513626, 0.0032907144632190466, -0.0036930523347109556, -0.026132451370358467, -0.030379341915249825, 0.008451491594314575, -0.01796172372996807, -0.027694405987858772, -0.011492575518786907, -0.016765551641583443, 0.001620096038095653, 0.021354464814066887, -0.0037956866435706615, 0.013093491084873676, -0.05033945292234421, 0.0035417485050857067, 0.06289402395486832, 0.023936325684189796, -0.01784449629485607, -0.01518692634999752, -0.022462597116827965, -0.067024365067482, -0.002599419327452779, 0.005012657959014177, -0.0420764721930027, -0.02879699505865574, -0.020305683836340904, 0.00015944593178573996, -0.042089469730854034, -0.013713691383600235, 0.01835954561829567, -0.025638220831751823, 0.08659712225198746, -0.019653314724564552, 0.028780043125152588, 0.046338506042957306, -0.04570508003234863, -0.027528351172804832, -0.09028909355401993, 0.0671711415052414, -0.0009689199505373836, -0.01953139528632164, -0.014747310429811478, -0.009909727610647678, -0.0387633815407753, -0.02096814475953579, 0.02696917951107025, 0.018951483070850372, 0.002860489534214139, -0.020867671817541122, 0.006588642485439777, -0.008902695961296558, -0.032675471156835556, -0.0011255196295678616, -0.012656505219638348, 0.00003474258483038284, 0.0014946830924600363, -0.03173190727829933, -0.006834153551608324, 0.002196141052991152, -0.029657511040568352, -0.07495716214179993, 0.029153713956475258, 0.014861781150102615, -0.017477212473750114, 0.017421575263142586, -0.0027636331506073475, -0.06231914460659027, 0.04530435800552368, 0.0015932495007291436, -0.0337630920112133, 0.021738875657320023, -0.0031816025730222464, -0.05090271681547165, 0.02053675800561905, -0.024575093761086464, -0.02338811755180359, 0.014790763147175312, 0.013174165971577168, 0.04820084199309349, -0.050058625638484955, -0.0047485241666436195, 0.017323456704616547, -0.044409360736608505, -0.02002030424773693, 0.023587070405483246, 0.009840407408773899, -0.000517548352945596, 0.004865586291998625, 0.0321405790746212, 0.0005737146129831672, -0.03770916536450386, 0.02779725380241871, 0.0023461696691811085, -0.02076958678662777, 0.007756017614156008, -0.01565779373049736, 0.027074625715613365, -0.00971301645040512, 0.04565231502056122, -0.028027208521962166, 0.0658436194062233, -0.02916482277214527, -0.00740238931030035, 0.034667275846004486, -0.026428835466504097, 0.0052708229050040245, -0.010689601302146912, -0.017675476148724556, 0.02815452218055725, -0.018292566761374474, 0.0024103866890072823, -0.022355109453201294, -0.03193681314587593, -0.0038352443370968103, 0.01876162551343441, 0.0161603894084692, 0.005823720712214708, -0.010730179026722908, 0.002520384034141898, 0.004739648662507534, -0.027817273512482643, 0.02004857361316681, -0.018573248758912086, 0.003216029843315482, -0.01105048879981041, -0.017341608181595802, 0.03197462484240532, -0.04337168112397194, -0.02073279395699501, 0.0028358339332044125, 0.011047464795410633, 0.03794856369495392, 0.007160637062042952, -0.018600983545184135, -0.046535246074199677, -0.025734564289450645, 0.04785719886422157, -0.04592229053378105, -0.01090032048523426, -0.037114229053258896, 0.015963047742843628, 0.014861930161714554, -0.0350065678358078 ]
<p><strong>Is it appropriate to include intermediate outcomes in a predictive model?</strong> </p> <p>It is quite clear that one should not control for post-treatment variables / intermediate outcomes when the goal is causal inference, but I wasn't sure if the same advice should hold when one's goal is to build a model for prediction.</p> <p>Here is some context for my question: I'm trying to build a model that predicts if a college student will earn a bachelor's degree within 6 years of high school graduation using a large observational data set. I have data on students' high school variables (HS GPA, test scores, number activities participated in, etc.), some data on the students' college experiences (delayed enrollment in college, full-time / part-time status, transferred within two years of enrolling), as well as data on the characteristics of the college they attend. In other words, I have student level and institutional level data. I would account for the nesting of students within a particular institution. </p> <p>Some have told me that the student level data on college experiences are intermediate outcomes and I shouldn't include them in the model. It isn't clear to me if I should / could include the college experience variables (which could be considered intermediate outcomes) in the predictive model, and if I do include them, how they should be treated. </p>
73,560
[ -0.04010232165455818, -0.02932230569422245, -0.012421461753547192, -0.014882133342325687, 0.02494184486567974, 0.043568868190050125, -0.023985179141163826, -0.012462656013667583, 0.05439640209078789, -0.04900858923792839, 0.027633048593997955, 0.049321699887514114, 0.01863137073814869, -0.009144434705376625, 0.02378857508301735, 0.031036678701639175, 0.013635331764817238, 0.0213349387049675, -0.015876593068242073, 0.026851685717701912, -0.007922942750155926, 0.01789504662156105, -0.031522445380687714, 0.01765403151512146, -0.017343807965517044, 0.029765348881483078, -0.0007372067775577307, -0.02235588990151882, 0.023264339193701744, 0.020002910867333412, 0.0076028103940188885, -0.01179599855095148, 0.006988026667386293, 0.04623756930232048, 0.0007328363717533648, -0.0068705035373568535, -0.022996721789240837, -0.03616630285978317, -0.005103264003992081, 0.03693271800875664, -0.022956321015954018, 0.0008684181957505643, -0.017711583524942398, 0.04938783496618271, 0.0013188248267397285, 0.009354478679597378, -0.023504042997956276, -0.0437888577580452, 0.04702247306704521, -0.020505128428339958, 0.02480352856218815, -0.004218365531414747, 0.03332033380866051, 0.04560974985361099, -0.018448397517204285, -0.023059485480189323, 0.07136040180921555, 0.053751248866319656, -0.009636210277676582, -0.023050399497151375, 0.0028244697023183107, -0.04774598032236099, -0.011957503855228424, -0.0019099103519693017, -0.04487045481801033, 0.04138097167015076, -0.01765650510787964, -0.02756686322391033, 0.048032842576503754, -0.04793922230601311, 0.03527003526687622, 0.00011505862494232133, 0.02292775921523571, 0.019711777567863464, 0.01946093887090683, -0.0198564101010561, 0.007642744109034538, 0.01903487555682659, 0.032917484641075134, 0.044630322605371475, -0.016896987333893776, -0.008399603888392448, 0.01391526497900486, 0.03576710447669029, 0.0005681937327608466, 0.0089585455134511, 0.030766526237130165, -0.03002293035387993, 0.020577630028128624, 0.025911711156368256, -0.04637753590941429, 0.013616236858069897, 0.018418509513139725, -0.030184194445610046, -0.047775231301784515, 0.027798669412732124, -0.017983771860599518, 0.0327904038131237, -0.0021108028013259172, 0.006471165921539068, -0.03267178684473038, -0.04509856551885605, -0.011961574666202068, 0.07507923990488052, -0.009880500845611095, -0.03354557976126671, -0.05892820283770561, -0.029265062883496284, -0.01420991774648428, -0.06984199583530426, -0.014265280216932297, 0.04418444260954857, 0.011557252146303654, 0.01370678935199976, 0.002311832271516323, -0.04038355499505997, -0.03705104440450668, -0.004012287128716707, 0.04061933606863022, 0.05294976755976677, 0.048992421478033066, -0.033038925379514694, 0.0451926663517952, -0.015041887760162354, -0.06544259190559387, -0.02853180095553398, 0.02955556847155094, -0.03433476388454437, -0.010669004172086716, 0.025366751477122307, 0.00749329524114728, 0.021863415837287903, 0.02809811197221279, -0.030085936188697815, 0.062021758407354355, 0.02067033015191555, -0.05441705882549286, -0.04808705300092697, 0.0026840518694370985, -0.02052507922053337, -0.0033952451776713133, -0.05705442652106285, 0.008486115373671055, 0.016286669299006462, 0.07188941538333893, -0.015322036109864712, 0.02136092819273472, 0.006285097450017929, 0.022069543600082397, 0.030014580115675926, -0.05054242163896561, -0.01612847112119198, -0.0168209969997406, -0.04254557564854622, 0.009766203351318836, -0.0650344118475914, 0.016425807029008865, 0.03205583617091179, -0.0004937955527566373, 0.0118830855935812, 0.05846285820007324, -0.026837049052119255, -0.020684368908405304, -0.008745597675442696, 0.024441152811050415, -0.023020578548312187, 0.036880120635032654, 0.00046247217687778175, 0.06641463935375214, 0.023719249293208122, 0.0009035750990733504, 0.005339345894753933, 0.011068189516663551, 0.036734260618686676, 0.020206473767757416, 0.017245925962924957, 0.0006521755713038146, 0.012259959243237972, 0.009405422955751419, -0.01102585718035698, -0.044312987476587296, -0.02477291412651539, 0.009555453434586525, -0.018333682790398598, -0.023509003221988678, 0.043638668954372406, 0.021206190809607506, -0.029371965676546097, 0.021112095564603806, -0.020195912569761276, -0.039687447249889374, -0.07809710502624512, 0.04555528238415718, 0.019871879369020462, -0.030103245750069618, 0.0468929149210453, -0.023943617939949036, 0.05432731285691261, -0.03791837766766548, 0.018157416954636574, -0.048149581998586655, -0.0037326014135032892, 0.016985438764095306, -0.06502214819192886, 0.006800757255405188, 0.04604761302471161, 0.05755052715539932, 0.0010118671925738454, 0.0363980196416378, -0.04223788157105446, -0.04155857488512993, -0.021611174568533897, -0.04736502841114998, 0.038201794028282166, -0.06200733780860901, 0.000046918270527385175, 0.014448613859713078, -0.04470379278063774, -0.016646303236484528, 0.05509073659777641, -0.0679062157869339, 0.07418611645698547, 0.06729404628276825, -0.0037305292207747698, 0.028695713728666306, 0.008382716216146946, 0.016032230108976364, 0.0017185990000143647, -0.06681884080171585, -0.011197976768016815, -0.04187500476837158, -0.007794651202857494, 0.0027729570865631104, 0.01011791080236435, -0.051495544612407684, 0.04563470557332039, 0.02816554345190525, -0.00417430279776454, 0.017343956977128983, 0.04236875846982002, 0.0014194725081324577, -0.04140869155526161, 0.011072126217186451, 0.010263311676681042, -0.015017560683190823, 0.011520870961248875, 0.028419125825166702, 0.02954021841287613, 0.007116139400750399, -0.015819383785128593, 0.023932483047246933, 0.038117825984954834, -0.004959506448358297, 0.027697691693902016, -0.003138467203825712, -0.03778660297393799, 0.04395230859518051, -0.012860641814768314, -0.0048403870314359665, 0.025751426815986633, 0.027335302904248238, -0.010359718464314938, -0.011012043803930283, 0.0034846884664148092, 0.0044084349647164345, 0.02198173850774765, -0.03827796131372452, 0.020388400182127953, 0.006957593839615583, -0.006849430501461029, 0.02023109793663025, -0.024704085662961006, -0.023411275818943977, -0.029838019981980324, 0.0020744134671986103, 0.04333529993891716, -0.006479186471551657, 0.018856512382626534, -0.05294723063707352, -0.035613611340522766, 0.012228419072926044, -0.0058265021070837975, 0.015404704958200455, 0.027660854160785675, -0.02797926776111126, 0.02086561545729637, -0.053055375814437866, -0.029815319925546646, 0.04702277109026909, -0.02731478586792946, -0.056021712720394135, 0.006275085266679525, 0.0014891944592818618, -0.04558650404214859, -0.014314983040094376, -0.030304979532957077, -0.0048125493340194225, -0.02090734988451004, -0.051905013620853424, 0.03658454865217209, 0.006535942200571299, -0.02701045759022236, 0.011916217394173145, -0.011813667602837086, -0.011330763809382915, 0.00977709237486124, 0.007451761048287153, 0.03760940209031105, 0.025240091606974602, 0.01690739206969738, 0.03411603718996048, -0.020736927166581154, -0.01635286957025528, -0.08525802195072174, -0.08323180675506592, 0.04976470023393631, 0.012562611140310764, 0.024647751823067665, 0.018025200814008713, -0.012116295285522938, 0.05443359538912773, 0.01918788067996502, -0.003925391938537359, -0.03507908061146736, -0.025735169649124146, -0.014826403930783272, -0.008901459164917469, -0.02756057120859623, 0.01461376715451479, -0.008216548711061478, -0.010124007239937782, -0.014927570708096027, 0.013719234615564346, 0.015463003888726234, 0.01398866344243288, 0.00890961941331625, 0.013325018808245659, 0.029706064611673355, -0.0004030252166558057, 0.014634998515248299, -0.0019473216962069273, -0.011189491488039494, 0.005016591399908066, -0.024428406730294228, -0.005783792585134506, -0.03425329178571701, -0.03315306827425957, 0.022852499037981033, -0.02517884597182274, -0.012484721839427948, -0.023082317784428596, -0.0005712741403840482, 0.01744818687438965, -0.04262281954288483, 0.01986820064485073, 0.01015246007591486, 0.01987120322883129, 0.005092649254947901, 0.037654079496860504, 0.015824561938643456, 0.01580916903913021, -0.014396971091628075, 0.00907674990594387, -0.02797333523631096, 0.00298180989921093, 0.01452537253499031, -0.016708601266145706, 0.008939666673541069, 0.027129562571644783, 0.040546875447034836, -0.007301131263375282, 0.005790007300674915, -0.05278961360454559, 0.011509662494063377, -0.06498906016349792, 0.05746348574757576, -0.060144223272800446, 0.05637282133102417, -0.011269420385360718, 0.01439144928008318, 0.010414285585284233, -0.0018204597290605307, -0.00821495521813631, 0.03241486847400665, -0.03640710934996605, -0.0022414664272218943, -0.004153784364461899, 0.037180643528699875, -0.01190127246081829, -0.004609392024576664, 0.04212263599038124, -0.006286651361733675, 0.009884282946586609, -0.0014430891023948789, 0.0027306457050144672, 0.002110264962539077, -0.004339392296969891, -0.03796904534101486, 0.0015833931975066662, -0.028184467926621437, -0.02895880863070488, 0.03180961683392525, -0.012411776930093765, 0.016760611906647682, 0.051885440945625305, -0.031523555517196655, -0.008326668292284012, -0.04784470051527023, 0.0008134710369631648, 0.028497664257884026, 0.04021498188376427, 0.06303158402442932, 0.02568794973194599, -0.03968319296836853, 0.04311903566122055, 0.021609336137771606, 0.037033919245004654, 0.04664985090494156, -0.04536355286836624, -0.038829244673252106, -0.04049723967909813, -0.01867426186800003, 0.013664864003658295, 0.02051731012761593, -0.0013191401958465576, -0.02977711334824562, 0.05954878777265549, 0.01685432530939579, -0.06790687888860703, 0.043078936636447906, 0.06187155097723007, 0.04447733238339424, -0.0058820960111916065, -0.03241432085633278, -0.0022020821925252676, -0.014371214434504509, -0.023915356025099754, 0.03812782093882561, -0.02422487735748291, 0.018735025078058243, 0.008466420695185661, 0.008347171358764172, -0.03166314586997032, -0.030268467962741852, 0.004947904963046312, -0.026564080268144608, 0.06783697754144669, 0.028774071484804153, -0.0706493929028511, 0.009758591651916504, 0.07193011045455933, 0.016326989978551865, 0.03891194984316826, 0.02085203118622303, -0.07933574169874191, -0.003561929799616337, 0.04582175239920616, 0.02930298261344433, -0.009668413549661636, -0.034057460725307465, -0.03950626775622368, -0.0320001095533371, 0.03157106414437294, -0.01940714754164219, 0.013895390555262566, -0.009252150543034077, 0.006834386382251978, -0.032416000962257385, -0.07785138487815857, -0.04545224830508232, 0.01790238358080387, -0.030247464776039124, 0.05606766417622566, -0.0005155493854545057, -0.0034816646948456764, -0.03204552084207535, 0.005530408583581448, 0.015200712718069553, 0.052208516746759415, -0.004235018510371447, -0.028578829020261765, 0.011648417450487614, -0.000729259685613215, -0.0013253538636490703, -0.07086644321680069, 0.014442655257880688, 0.0058493404649198055, -0.0017538229003548622, 0.056405384093523026, -0.02074698731303215, -0.017299305647611618, 0.014832455664873123, 0.03801465779542923, -0.037149783223867416, 0.0024183858186006546, -0.027419541031122208, 0.05188365280628204, -0.01633315719664097, -0.012332969345152378, 0.051347941160202026, 0.011387058533728123, 0.020404187962412834, -0.0027575059793889523, -0.0057009924203157425, 0.0393717885017395, -0.0247518178075552, -0.02427700161933899, -0.042844515293836594, -0.04221328720450401, -0.003240147139877081, 0.06635861843824387, -0.02796863205730915, 0.02935163490474224, -0.05394064262509346, 0.007654467597603798, 0.026891561225056648, 0.03056248649954796, -0.011680282652378082, 0.0012889299541711807, -0.03720388188958168, -0.010362555272877216, -0.005966582335531712, -0.014513789676129818, 0.002696031704545021, 0.005606277845799923, 0.024636361747980118, -0.0000402918885811232, -0.04074343293905258, 0.024325579404830933, -0.02751421183347702, -0.034529611468315125, 0.016757208853960037, -0.002274990314617753, 0.021668942645192146, -0.0006650646682828665, 0.030908143147826195, -0.007695919368416071, -0.016420671716332436, 0.01695995405316353, 0.03403226286172867, -0.021693643182516098, -0.01739458739757538, 0.012844687327742577, 0.02440626733005047, 0.009430157020688057, 0.003793960204347968, -0.07742917537689209, -0.0600881464779377, -0.014890847727656364, 0.0003161646891385317, -0.035961881279945374, 0.003256344934925437, 0.037443313747644424, -0.01852266676723957, -0.041017502546310425, -0.015715809538960457, 0.05741913616657257, -0.03716244921088219, -0.015334696508944035, 0.022542888298630714, 0.012752245180308819, 0.04341323301196098, 0.003233260242268443, -0.010161329992115498, 0.028920264914631844, -0.004262808244675398, -0.025481965392827988, 0.011596933007240295, 0.023395556956529617, -0.01565811038017273, -0.018592186272144318, -0.033247850835323334, 0.0010906534735113382, 0.05120011419057846, 0.012328698299825191, -0.03712140768766403, 0.022958125919103622, -0.04600932076573372, 0.023510560393333435, -0.021577103063464165, 0.007854274474084377, -0.020238002762198448, -0.002911841496825218, 0.03206358850002289, 0.03552689403295517, 0.0047030081041157246, -0.015921542420983315, 0.03386523947119713, 0.013562997803092003, 0.004165599122643471, 0.019009150564670563, 0.024479469284415245, -0.017314674332737923, 0.03061012737452984, -0.011102118529379368, -0.02801649644970894, 0.04850732162594795, 0.0027410006150603294, -0.013456495478749275, 0.01890624314546585, 0.015454532578587532, -0.03784581646323204, -0.03594060242176056, -0.04732891172170639, 0.005903597921133041, 0.06437254697084427, -0.015786385163664818, 0.03486783802509308, 0.02860298939049244, -0.014762107282876968, -0.0015972087858244777, -0.0637054368853569, 0.029452508315443993, 0.009478277526795864, -0.012957001104950905, 0.08052965253591537, -0.018754703924059868, -0.03267931565642357, 0.02363196201622486, -0.019204536452889442, 0.004189514555037022, 0.03371800482273102, 0.030781490728259087, -0.004034745041280985, 0.01857331581413746, -0.007931915111839771, -0.029840251430869102, 0.001962261274456978, -0.06251684576272964, -0.01298443228006363, -0.036389417946338654, -0.021698107942938805, 0.03255101293325424, 0.053448840975761414, 0.025150371715426445, -0.045087385922670364, -0.02554890140891075, -0.04893545061349869, -0.02176729217171669, 0.02559535577893257, 0.0065662916749715805, 0.040174636989831924, -0.009353747591376305, 0.04304344207048416, 0.02420264668762684, 0.01058032177388668, -0.044397156685590744, -0.08025316148996353, -0.03864651545882225, -0.03858431056141853, 0.007168026641011238, 0.017748069018125534, 0.02119564637541771, -0.012889262288808823, 0.027931226417422295, -0.031922727823257446, -0.00723477965220809, -0.002428836189210415, 0.03183487430214882, -0.005760835483670235, 0.05370217189192772, 0.00532875768840313, -0.01688811555504799, 0.018435411155223846, -0.011072124354541302, 0.11745209991931915, 0.10890637338161469, 0.02859494835138321, -0.06570430099964142, 0.047442659735679626, 0.00019010227697435766, -0.00044439834891818464, -0.012187380343675613, -0.030090143904089928, 0.0010407728841528296, -0.05685454607009888, 0.01451806165277958, 0.02446943335235119, -0.002261187881231308, 0.010993200354278088, 0.061260025948286057, -0.07632921636104584, -0.00935924518853426, -0.0023762774653732777, -0.025091571733355522, 0.014151373878121376, 0.015922248363494873, -0.015196533873677254, -0.01667732186615467, 0.01404560450464487, -0.030568314716219902, 0.022470613941550255, 0.029352279379963875, 0.006249424070119858, 0.010820564813911915, 0.010889132507145405, 0.002463043201714754, 0.03220396861433983, 0.0172796081751585, -0.003836605930700898, 0.009964311495423317, 0.008205866441130638, -0.013751707971096039, 0.016523169353604317, 0.006459758151322603, -0.012360296212136745, 0.011470207944512367, 0.03304954245686531, 0.029781142249703407, -0.05072115361690521, -0.0462271049618721, -0.016955005005002022, 0.03900735452771187, 0.010114566422998905, -0.0272725448012352, -0.05618645250797272, 0.006227761972695589, 0.02297210320830345, -0.035019878298044205, -0.03202956169843674, 0.019289804622530937, 0.02568935975432396, -0.0314931757748127, -0.005015581380575895, -0.02036949433386326, -0.007590823341161013, -0.016638971865177155, 0.025425976142287254, 0.017623428255319595, -0.05636328086256981, -0.026299651712179184, -0.02899954281747341, 0.032143522053956985, 0.004116522613912821, 0.025122584775090218, 0.016177497804164886, 0.011231508105993271, -0.03546592965722084, -0.01886206865310669, 0.013251939788460732, -0.026324670761823654, 0.04198627918958664, -0.0019126578699797392, -0.004782370291650295, -0.050935856997966766, -0.010497165843844414, -0.0001803428604034707, -0.0064436402171850204, 0.0007830820977687836, -0.043754760175943375, 0.02020471729338169, -0.0010833779815584421, 0.03845879063010216, 0.005717272404581308, 0.03649931401014328, -0.02533198706805706, 0.043176379054784775, 0.030890358611941338, -0.018495382741093636, 0.0142917325720191, -0.033898938447237015, -0.023050252348184586, 0.013922750018537045, -0.021049026399850845, 0.06664656847715378, 0.00513751246035099, 0.04243500530719757, -0.017423948273062706, 0.04624350741505623, 0.011902322992682457, 0.035154085606336594, 0.029466088861227036, -0.050786297768354416, 0.011423910968005657, 0.014603672549128532, 0.025797776877880096, -0.01858702301979065, 0.013885580003261566, -0.016913387924432755, -0.027451371774077415, 0.041400015354156494, -0.045576952397823334, -0.045449770987033844, 0.031027216464281082, -0.023740718141198158, 0.04608649015426636, -0.03799356147646904, -0.031204579398036003, -0.038779716938734055, -0.021027354523539543, -0.009622541256248951, -0.04179832339286804, 0.008362628519535065, 0.014507604762911797, -0.003508877707645297, -0.007273598108440638, 0.006547317840158939, -0.015135437250137329, -0.000818189640995115, -0.03967732563614845, 0.021663280203938484, 0.0011915267677977681, 0.06161430850625038, -0.02941945195198059, -0.05553831532597542, -0.0016253632493317127, -0.024141959846019745, -0.012580601498484612, 0.03177288547158241, -0.006651482079178095, 0.02983878180384636, 0.0411677360534668, -0.021188542246818542, -0.006497363559901714, 0.014749482274055481, -0.016298828646540642, -0.019966041669249535, -0.008015969768166542, 0.02613629400730133, -0.02235262840986252, -0.028154635801911354, 0.0011988517362624407, 0.009508630260825157, -0.0031760591082274914, 0.011871926486492157, 0.04224918410181999, 0.04297440126538277, 0.0037489812821149826, -0.004617130383849144, 0.006588377989828587, 0.04070385545492172, -0.00537906726822257, 0.021785767748951912, 0.03847694769501686, 0.010529653169214725, -0.017061250284314156, 0.05904525890946388, 0.019657792523503304, 0.013506879098713398, -0.1122584193944931, -0.021565387025475502, 0.003089661942794919, 0.051209110766649246, 0.03095552884042263, -0.033219244331121445, -0.010406102053821087, 0.0053299847058951855, -0.04380729794502258, 0.022754255682229996, 0.008126272819936275, 0.029611412435770035, -0.015262548811733723, 0.014045585878193378, -0.02793681062757969, 0.015724720433354378, 0.03443051874637604, 0.05139105021953583, 0.023935604840517044, 0.016044477000832558, 0.028186457231640816, -0.029870934784412384, -0.026226462796330452, -0.002826881827786565, -0.007854316383600235, -0.050497397780418396, 0.050452932715415955, -0.007122632581740618, -0.04016555845737457, 0.03216623142361641, 0.021875491365790367, 0.019227296113967896, 0.03117794543504715, 0.005515832453966141, 0.021608779206871986, 0.049013104289770126, 0.0147904297336936, -0.02106742560863495, 0.0003721860412042588, 0.027530668303370476, 0.007423242554068565, 0.03822256997227669, -0.03523927181959152, 0.003350371029227972, 0.02816113829612732, -0.007425044663250446, -0.030335381627082825, 0.023165948688983917, -0.006995207164436579, -0.0021739418152719736, -0.02782384306192398, -0.021639658138155937, -0.014514191076159477, -0.02997785434126854, 0.0197194442152977, -0.038351915776729584, -0.03718414902687073, 0.07126488536596298, 0.037266187369823456, -0.017876869067549706, 0.021210668608546257, -0.005586522165685892, -0.032740794122219086, 0.005065226461738348, 0.00863014068454504, -0.012766125611960888, -0.0571867972612381, 0.006989708635956049, 0.001617448404431343, -0.04221483692526817, -0.028143132105469704, 0.010237257927656174, -0.07127735018730164, 0.04939716309309006, -0.02915007807314396, 0.014476172626018524, 0.043226178735494614, -0.04674144834280014, 0.02230227179825306, -0.07787918299436569, 0.0763719230890274, 0.0065077850595116615, -0.004621419124305248, -0.02144407108426094, -0.025050004944205284, 0.020521748811006546, 0.006327264476567507, 0.06864988803863525, 0.007973182946443558, -0.004613243509083986, 0.027953917160630226, 0.04517371580004692, -0.03422781080007553, -0.04453904181718826, 0.022837940603494644, -0.008758150041103363, -0.00027239526389166713, -0.05732380226254463, -0.0018528257496654987, 0.004062865395098925, 0.028553377836942673, 0.01329764723777771, 0.0012395199155434966, 0.04523148760199547, 0.05591990426182747, 0.033361684530973434, 0.02157895639538765, 0.022518569603562355, -0.019770018756389618, 0.053191669285297394, 0.03120688535273075, 0.017059413716197014, 0.037506379187107086, -0.043693020939826965, -0.061510875821113586, 0.03476620092988014, -0.031420428305864334, -0.012087129056453705, -0.0030181535985320807, 0.018449192866683006, -0.04988311603665352, -0.05828940495848656, -0.0034621923696249723, 0.018288524821400642, -0.07460528612136841, -0.004576484207063913, 0.03776705637574196, -0.011000932194292545, 0.03811191767454147, -0.014660973101854324, -0.007568725850433111, 0.02454657480120659, -0.03150095418095589, -0.011967377737164497, 0.03487278148531914, 0.05111201852560043, 0.03242117911577225, 0.017195500433444977, 0.019261153414845467, -0.01112503744661808, 0.01265565212816, 0.0020831646397709846, 0.07154891639947891, -0.03879277780652046, -0.01075371541082859, -0.004158401861786842, 0.02593105100095272, 0.029385598376393318, -0.011645863763988018, -0.0014678641455247998, 0.03248931095004082, -0.006031580734997988, -0.010029924102127552, -0.03315477445721626, -0.01041606068611145, -0.025091227144002914, 0.020940450951457024, 0.008136109448969364, 0.034506767988204956, 0.010388455353677273, 0.00835682824254036, -0.009947776794433594, -0.04278460517525673, 0.013382870703935623, 0.016019191592931747, 0.011877119541168213, -0.010510960593819618, -0.017003320157527924, 0.02256750501692295, -0.009177273139357567, -0.00036016025114804506, -0.01493899431079626, 0.045646846294403076, 0.059063542634248734, 0.04811196029186249, -0.04210431128740311, -0.017337540164589882, 0.014917551539838314, 0.054086457937955856, -0.08044720441102982, 0.013764720410108566, -0.07046052068471909, 0.0027954864781349897, -0.005067594349384308, 0.0010568343568593264 ]
<p>I have a dataset with ~90000 observations and less than 10 features (all continuous). The problem is that the response variable has ~300 categories. Currently I would try to fit a multinomial linear model or a random forest. I have to predict probabilities for the 300 categories. I need some inspiration and would like to know which model others would use?</p>
73,561
[ -0.0398583747446537, -0.035021163523197174, 0.03217260539531708, -0.0006875331746414304, 0.03527291864156723, -0.026965515688061714, -0.007026371546089649, -0.014157086610794067, 0.021949732676148415, -0.02124057151377201, 0.015688173472881317, 0.030794918537139893, 0.024569937959313393, 0.00684296665713191, -0.023735731840133667, 0.03218831866979599, 0.0046643284149467945, -0.0010320963338017464, -0.0031003274489194155, -0.00864444114267826, -0.018596915528178215, 0.0006561441114172339, 0.013596585020422935, 0.0030857734382152557, -0.05118206515908241, 0.04686550423502922, 0.056967657059431076, -0.0026594246737658978, 0.014102003537118435, 0.017827223986387253, -0.029248487204313278, -0.0423133447766304, 0.015874316915869713, 0.047050364315509796, 0.001079393201507628, -0.012242646887898445, -0.031381893903017044, -0.0353294312953949, -0.03235520422458649, 0.010258639231324196, -0.015670744702219963, 0.012311329133808613, 0.004918689839541912, 0.03091849759221077, -0.032862503081560135, 0.017051395028829575, 0.017983563244342804, -0.030271511524915695, 0.03583474084734917, -0.03654865920543671, 0.08112726360559464, -0.008556302636861801, 0.049086764454841614, 0.035533927381038666, -0.023525945842266083, -0.020601188763976097, 0.04780950769782066, 0.07706589251756668, -0.008981450460851192, -0.04164808616042137, -0.03669152408838272, -0.03672625869512558, 0.00027862974093295634, -0.01801091991364956, -0.01395629346370697, 0.03051074594259262, -0.013130081817507744, -0.01635548658668995, 0.038825370371341705, 0.023968804627656937, 0.049384865909814835, -0.007384545635432005, 0.05146440863609314, 0.013624858111143112, 0.020630277693271637, 0.0063560642302036285, 0.002293775323778391, 0.020451411604881287, 0.04166524112224579, 0.037946946918964386, 0.003724251640960574, -0.012002942152321339, -0.01746908202767372, 0.043860990554094315, 0.022331852465867996, -0.0309803057461977, 0.05243879184126854, -0.0231962651014328, 0.01756655052304268, 0.008870777674019337, -0.04676806181669235, -0.029937243089079857, 0.057972777634859085, 0.02014673687517643, -0.052774734795093536, 0.03161947801709175, -0.025263763964176178, 0.04221572354435921, 0.04741036519408226, 0.030005620792508125, 0.0019407549407333136, -0.005060090683400631, -0.0011761491186916828, 0.04568208381533623, -0.05203845724463463, 0.022733544930815697, -0.0634051188826561, -0.015308568254113197, 0.0017863282701000571, -0.01934245601296425, 0.00034257874358445406, 0.03953900560736656, 0.018270470201969147, -0.02694237232208252, 0.037736888974905014, -0.022756779566407204, -0.0023622082080692053, -0.028888709843158722, 0.024574225768446922, 0.06514627486467361, 0.02530749887228012, -0.04816097766160965, 0.03022426925599575, -0.011076884344220161, -0.030533505603671074, -0.011274134740233421, 0.01983567886054516, -0.029073653742671013, -0.025298938155174255, 0.051431138068437576, -0.03784302994608879, -0.023767832666635513, 0.050093360245227814, -0.02869397960603237, 0.023850519210100174, -0.024757541716098785, -0.06140222027897835, -0.043042656034231186, -0.018449783325195312, -0.013338991440832615, 0.014473503455519676, -0.012210726737976074, 0.016459884122014046, 0.030906058847904205, 0.03990566357970238, 0.024242838844656944, 0.04004070535302162, 0.051070019602775574, 0.028656188398599625, 0.009946107864379883, -0.026882413774728775, 0.004278761800378561, -0.05927510932087898, 0.020292051136493683, -0.011974350549280643, -0.07590369880199432, 0.0493997223675251, -0.0247770007699728, 0.019921911880373955, -0.010135401040315628, -0.0016694063087925315, -0.015192236751317978, -0.0010367629583925009, -0.0055551775731146336, 0.025415292009711266, -0.01347449142485857, 0.07746438682079315, -0.01490155141800642, 0.05783043056726456, 0.020072191953659058, 0.03248212859034538, 0.01870986446738243, 0.07975434511899948, 0.052271317690610886, 0.04947289824485779, 0.0010371776297688484, 0.013939624652266502, -0.006417877972126007, 0.03411763533949852, 0.007135153282433748, -0.0037139987107366323, -0.049638841301202774, -0.027614107355475426, -0.02752803824841976, 0.02368398942053318, 0.0034697209484875202, -0.0128943445160985, -0.048653777688741684, 0.048955000936985016, -0.029260627925395966, -0.042124178260564804, -0.03307401388883591, 0.024083320051431656, -0.027421722188591957, 0.01038406416773796, 0.05126137286424637, 0.01840157061815262, -0.013497122563421726, -0.021338526159524918, 0.003323052544146776, -0.05852016061544418, -0.03585023060441017, 0.042771585285663605, -0.026128971949219704, -0.012291714549064636, 0.021629132330417633, 0.022833149880170822, -0.028235023841261864, 0.03061635047197342, -0.022378303110599518, -0.06694316118955612, -0.008053204044699669, -0.023812776431441307, 0.009029626846313477, -0.05120047554373741, -0.00726587837561965, 0.005901280790567398, -0.018017977476119995, -0.028349285945296288, 0.04289812222123146, -0.060607414692640305, 0.08195088803768158, 0.04283147305250168, 0.0020079337991774082, 0.0033094496466219425, 0.00730800349265337, -0.01803317479789257, -0.02566545084118843, -0.008879467844963074, -0.02822689153254032, -0.05582230165600777, 0.01857970468699932, 0.060197584331035614, -0.009282545186579227, -0.03347953408956528, 0.005884641315788031, 0.04070103541016579, 0.0071470169350504875, 0.05283962935209274, 0.041342101991176605, -0.011332760564982891, 0.016617313027381897, 0.006208606064319611, 0.018343864008784294, 0.0010000444017350674, -0.009439016692340374, 0.011288574896752834, 0.0049202824011445045, 0.02015608921647072, -0.012021653354167938, -0.029723981395363808, 0.034396521747112274, 0.037423275411129, 0.03984861075878143, -0.02922860160470009, -0.03266650810837746, 0.014672193676233292, -0.011975056491792202, -0.016357433050870895, 0.04294734075665474, 0.004285458475351334, 0.021122992038726807, 0.03554724529385567, -0.026980288326740265, 0.028362346813082695, 0.05402141436934471, -0.06509014964103699, 0.015081046149134636, 0.029851015657186508, -0.06563255190849304, 0.040964338928461075, 0.03134015202522278, -0.05460921302437782, -0.04365716874599457, 0.0552651584148407, 0.012249449267983437, 0.021369274705648422, 0.036481473594903946, 0.0048201181925833225, -0.026650594547390938, 0.022981083020567894, -0.027293605729937553, 0.03591593727469444, 0.005658295936882496, -0.045055560767650604, -0.032576292753219604, -0.01485065184533596, -0.0206425990909338, 0.03311648219823837, 0.003523010527715087, -0.07716955989599228, 0.014309574849903584, -0.04841567575931549, -0.051078155636787415, -0.002014224650338292, -0.01791984587907791, 0.028243593871593475, -0.015068482607603073, -0.039643801748752594, 0.005389090161770582, -0.010160017758607864, -0.03769237920641899, -0.01123798917979002, -0.02860126830637455, 0.001125755370594561, -0.03238055109977722, -0.0044267186895012856, -0.024199582636356354, 0.007693189196288586, 0.012290239334106445, 0.03152880445122719, 0.012324817478656769, 0.022991061210632324, -0.06282415241003036, -0.047268010675907135, 0.012332267127931118, -0.0006083525368012488, 0.0200906191021204, 0.02547731250524521, 0.009225236251950264, 0.04366682097315788, 0.04437164217233658, -0.042952198535203934, -0.007160332519561052, -0.029580581933259964, -0.030548909679055214, -0.0026970375329256058, 0.0323907770216465, 0.015801820904016495, 0.017906010150909424, -0.003353830659762025, -0.013938198797404766, -0.028544653207063675, 0.03826369717717171, -0.0030777924694120884, -0.006298100110143423, 0.046950723975896835, -0.020773211494088173, -0.012452804483473301, 0.0296387430280447, 0.012393366545438766, -0.03325960040092468, 0.029060592874884605, -0.022860603407025337, 0.0056541683152318, 0.015971411019563675, -0.05057905241847038, -0.006679173093289137, -0.01937653310596943, 0.035728879272937775, -0.009191709570586681, 0.02029269002377987, -0.004056274425238371, -0.047698959708213806, 0.02718202956020832, 0.029358550906181335, 0.046713583171367645, -0.02828294411301613, 0.009225023910403252, 0.025599971413612366, 0.04728751257061958, -0.007894397713243961, 0.020008353516459465, -0.022191939875483513, -0.023685969412326813, 0.029711555689573288, -0.012477444484829903, 0.02324264869093895, 0.029122045263648033, 0.008122103288769722, 0.03306691721081734, 0.004089976195245981, -0.023470088839530945, 0.013986792415380478, -0.037879377603530884, 0.00791795551776886, -0.02898857370018959, 0.04277743026614189, 0.03304966539144516, 0.03325052559375763, -0.00041462507215328515, -0.045248035341501236, -0.012802130542695522, 0.04732222110033035, -0.03750636801123619, 0.03192147985100746, -0.0165886078029871, 0.03988707438111305, -0.0039883689023554325, -0.00929738488048315, 0.040160734206438065, 0.0007517538033425808, -0.015971504151821136, -0.00042811722960323095, 0.011351358145475388, -0.03603624179959297, -0.02650296501815319, -0.018518615514039993, -0.01905985176563263, -0.0034785347525030375, -0.025010311976075172, -0.01794663444161415, 0.02128935605287552, 0.030300168320536613, 0.017430568113923073, -0.0057497210800647736, -0.02330826409161091, -0.012680429965257645, 0.003919373732060194, 0.0019790325313806534, 0.05046849325299263, 0.0025206224527209997, 0.008343667723238468, -0.049381107091903687, 0.011692946776747704, 0.0024437096435576677, 0.014924723654985428, 0.046621326357126236, -0.0063440920785069466, -0.0051361327059566975, -0.07504963129758835, -0.012247756123542786, -0.004419561009854078, 0.0012484996113926172, 0.019149532541632652, -0.0006619304767809808, 0.06351305544376373, 0.0183064267039299, -0.07315123826265335, -0.010952788405120373, 0.059562645852565765, 0.010842549614608288, -0.04269212484359741, 0.006868611555546522, 0.02615342289209366, 0.0017723984783515334, 0.016688238829374313, 0.02473800629377365, -0.011909372173249722, -0.005044241901487112, -0.02158297784626484, 0.03653337061405182, -0.03401879966259003, -0.04769263416528702, 0.0022680708207190037, 0.008034678176045418, 0.0714913159608841, -0.01625370979309082, -0.06217890977859497, 0.029905391857028008, 0.03995097801089287, 0.024479981511831284, 0.010936940088868141, 0.004004621412605047, -0.10734173655509949, 0.019888708367943764, 0.041353605687618256, 0.03671133890748024, -0.07550475746393204, -0.02618505246937275, -0.05214091017842293, 0.002061640378087759, 0.01534494012594223, -0.03274437040090561, -0.02612358331680298, -0.003146491711959243, 0.03808239847421646, 0.010076847858726978, -0.015471382066607475, -0.04653099551796913, 0.014482125639915466, -0.006296411156654358, 0.04248368367552757, -0.00037944517680443823, -0.004905015230178833, -0.05618913471698761, 0.026180395856499672, 0.050995729863643646, 0.03437812626361847, 0.0032429106067866087, -0.022553954273462296, 0.04832767695188522, 0.011302116326987743, 0.0030978310387581587, -0.054533980786800385, 0.017002766951918602, -0.006747965235263109, -0.025830103084445, 0.039730604737997055, -0.005269329063594341, -0.04747870936989784, -0.012668181210756302, 0.0013090696884319186, -0.032018132507801056, -0.025897270068526268, -0.021020876243710518, 0.00913070049136877, 0.009139522910118103, 0.011209340766072273, 0.03838793560862541, 0.05660874769091606, -0.002293894998729229, -0.0027726986445486546, -0.026192881166934967, 0.015602093189954758, 0.019576717168092728, -0.0188710018992424, -0.042582932859659195, -0.015351522713899612, -0.02444341965019703, 0.03105848655104637, -0.02337818033993244, 0.020329110324382782, -0.03580746799707413, -0.04116351157426834, -0.017035184428095818, 0.014650033786892891, -0.029173795133829117, -0.0002336545439902693, -0.003470849012956023, -0.002898242324590683, 0.021412242203950882, -0.008456469513475895, 0.011572863906621933, -0.006398497149348259, 0.03852972760796547, 0.010610763914883137, -0.05419032275676727, 0.01562998630106449, -0.06375647336244583, -0.03174455091357231, 0.004640309605747461, -0.03465443104505539, 0.044818222522735596, 0.005549432244151831, 0.06418382376432419, -0.008404762484133244, -0.06680731475353241, -0.014902645722031593, 0.0077972146682441235, 0.012487095780670643, 0.06268114596605301, -0.026549506932497025, 0.04995642602443695, -0.044016752392053604, -0.02444222941994667, -0.05970657244324684, -0.0798504501581192, 0.027615251019597054, 0.04529283568263054, -0.01880999654531479, -0.05099721625447273, 0.043502628803253174, -0.050983648747205734, -0.009888683445751667, -0.02362855337560177, 0.07142656296491623, -0.010324039496481419, 0.02573608048260212, -0.025927022099494934, -0.022797614336013794, 0.04551296308636665, 0.004329991992563009, -0.0033078461419790983, 0.052560530602931976, 0.019363489001989365, 0.004091339185833931, -0.017630264163017273, 0.01754034124314785, -0.034174609929323196, -0.0008010187884792686, -0.012260308489203453, 0.019722845405340195, 0.06438273191452026, -0.05277234688401222, 0.03294205665588379, 0.017951352521777153, 0.011364299803972244, 0.0058467574417591095, -0.01605997420847416, 0.02085193432867527, 0.02579037845134735, -0.025650298222899437, -0.02313583344221115, 0.013580072671175003, -0.009968096390366554, 0.021713700145483017, 0.028401019051671028, 0.011029341258108616, 0.00985406618565321, 0.019831210374832153, 0.04506905376911163, 0.011679395101964474, 0.01625119522213936, -0.026568226516246796, -0.02699689380824566, 0.03882598131895065, 0.02955755405128002, -0.002217612462118268, 0.024409951642155647, 0.04608752578496933, -0.024127038195729256, -0.012255746871232986, -0.05057491734623909, -0.01760026440024376, 0.04055440053343773, 0.011145662516355515, 0.027312742546200752, 0.03156217560172081, 0.029363276436924934, 0.0072439261712133884, -0.03349016234278679, -0.01786147430539131, 0.03523792698979378, 0.013809778727591038, 0.02993500418961048, 0.01408426184207201, 0.04539654031395912, 0.003666639793664217, 0.01024119183421135, 0.009878525510430336, 0.07468266040086746, 0.014127783477306366, 0.03835015743970871, 0.029479891061782837, -0.06290770322084427, -0.02225256897509098, 0.021656785160303116, -0.040839456021785736, -0.00032266441849060357, -0.0034359947312623262, -0.025198236107826233, 0.05289764702320099, 0.044345635920763016, -0.0014477380318567157, -0.03078318014740944, -0.02798929624259472, -0.02433745004236698, 0.01008300855755806, 0.025054851546883583, 0.010450657457113266, 0.006332383491098881, 0.006054469384253025, -0.003398401429876685, 0.015412699431180954, 0.026513762772083282, 0.00498233875259757, -0.0754299908876419, -0.05331959202885628, -0.02516002580523491, -0.056505899876356125, -0.009525882080197334, 0.029370443895459175, -0.020766980946063995, -0.0022480934858322144, -0.0390511192381382, -0.014696476981043816, -0.010788367129862309, 0.029698316007852554, 0.009428702294826508, 0.03982001915574074, -0.005805188789963722, 0.012599227949976921, -0.001110830344259739, -0.007533312309533358, 0.11689966171979904, 0.08677219599485397, 0.07027241587638855, -0.0639224499464035, 0.018360959365963936, -0.008048487827181816, -0.02736702561378479, -0.03372848406434059, 0.014566317200660706, 0.014848683960735798, -0.011362562887370586, 0.04058357700705528, 0.022147150710225105, 0.035988230258226395, 0.01886543072760105, 0.05430293083190918, -0.01028659287840128, 0.014467173255980015, 0.00005258603414404206, -0.013834639452397823, 0.03584485873579979, -0.03512362018227577, -0.021325793117284775, 0.04693968966603279, -0.0010925305541604757, -0.02492363378405571, -0.03973069787025452, -0.014701172709465027, 0.0016111761797219515, -0.009681311435997486, 0.023148588836193085, -0.007457657717168331, 0.022522998973727226, 0.0547855980694294, 0.031381916254758835, 0.018302513286471367, 0.011428172700107098, -0.010002588853240013, -0.00250106118619442, 0.005068494938313961, -0.029760628938674927, 0.0020928720477968454, -0.01886550523340702, -0.009909809567034245, -0.04672389104962349, -0.018578574061393738, -0.06672312319278717, 0.02603817544877529, 0.015338042750954628, -0.0038319628220051527, -0.01213877648115158, 0.02149004489183426, 0.0009217907791025937, -0.013057691976428032, -0.014635476283729076, 0.025011135265231133, 0.00884313602000475, -0.022603146731853485, -0.058127377182245255, -0.014479250647127628, 0.03833121061325073, 0.006539535708725452, 0.05058944225311279, 0.01778395287692547, -0.026034554466605186, -0.007240278646349907, -0.016432486474514008, 0.01085104700177908, 0.027733920142054558, 0.006642403081059456, -0.0009102939511649311, -0.02054022252559662, -0.011469122022390366, -0.004459626507014036, 0.008103074505925179, 0.0019351152004674077, 0.012710252776741982, -0.01381868589669466, -0.029899155721068382, -0.015481083653867245, -0.011320387944579124, -0.02489946410059929, -0.005946709308773279, 0.021207649260759354, -0.03993725776672363, 0.019775569438934326, -0.028286360204219818, 0.03260565549135208, 0.011876118369400501, 0.021607715636491776, 0.017119651660323143, 0.060401834547519684, -0.011200759559869766, -0.057538244873285294, 0.007357124704867601, -0.029010018333792686, -0.04153302311897278, 0.03449885547161102, 0.009402905590832233, 0.10715106874704361, -0.005687416065484285, 0.029112987220287323, -0.004529179539531469, 0.0474189929664135, 0.00010046103852801025, 0.022544989362359047, 0.006376468576490879, -0.08665121346712112, 0.0009744876297190785, -0.007255710195749998, 0.010144512169063091, -0.03733081370592117, -0.037141475826501846, 0.002529945457354188, -0.04734423756599426, -0.017912404611706734, -0.018554111942648888, -0.036241356283426285, 0.01843186467885971, -0.01655063033103943, 0.019927123561501503, 0.01166384294629097, -0.020106565207242966, -0.0325501449406147, 0.014603197574615479, 0.009291412308812141, -0.0354950912296772, -0.02196381986141205, -0.00906213466078043, -0.0031309090554714203, 0.0007131993770599365, 0.012988714501261711, 0.003905985038727522, -0.023822026327252388, 0.005371816456317902, 0.01798473298549652, -0.000018623919459059834, 0.03632824867963791, -0.038389913737773895, 0.004972654860466719, 0.024483151733875275, -0.06610500067472458, -0.0048464443534612656, 0.020642610266804695, 0.007762759458273649, 0.059652697294950485, 0.027298932895064354, 0.014257332310080528, 0.002867724746465683, 0.025049442425370216, -0.01826433651149273, -0.06184105575084686, -0.002781832590699196, 0.026236673817038536, 0.004911384545266628, 0.026705292984843254, -0.014633855782449245, 0.007530141621828079, -0.019407421350479126, 0.00482145044952631, 0.04689769446849823, 0.0067882235161960125, -0.041843514889478683, 0.020891260355710983, -0.028876762837171555, 0.009655552916228771, 0.00831875205039978, 0.017553741112351418, -0.004785133060067892, 0.014434793964028358, -0.030261944979429245, 0.03325454518198967, 0.01019548811018467, 0.029625125229358673, -0.05982612818479538, -0.06290837377309799, 0.018076343461871147, -0.02721993811428547, 0.06754598021507263, -0.05664847046136856, 0.007100443355739117, 0.054617784917354584, -0.04616563022136688, 0.010900953784584999, 0.01483234204351902, -0.018934940919280052, -0.01301418524235487, 0.008984933607280254, 0.005645455326884985, -0.010059645399451256, 0.01803097315132618, 0.03722871467471123, 0.028095485642552376, 0.01898205280303955, -0.008637325838208199, -0.059912245720624924, -0.008704974316060543, 0.0317554734647274, 0.020278189331293106, -0.06952546536922455, 0.053049881011247635, -0.05840140953660011, -0.03664908558130264, 0.04872545227408409, -0.00008989323396235704, 0.0012408825568854809, 0.08024856448173523, 0.005649681203067303, -0.013083298690617085, 0.053202033042907715, 0.027472427114844322, -0.02863943576812744, -0.0010603293776512146, 0.02569153532385826, 0.020069081336259842, 0.009286453016102314, -0.021398527547717094, 0.01626967266201973, 0.03368958830833435, -0.016073578968644142, -0.01889418624341488, 0.03282797709107399, -0.014019357971847057, -0.021042168140411377, 0.020203644409775734, 0.004490483086556196, -0.024990292266011238, -0.020981311798095703, -0.0005084858858026564, -0.05425543710589409, 0.03147129714488983, 0.04338318109512329, -0.006251563783735037, 0.020068258047103882, -0.0024945870973169804, -0.0429491251707077, -0.04192618280649185, -0.0266875047236681, -0.011143559589982033, -0.0022915545850992203, -0.05069587752223015, -0.00950048677623272, 0.0014751143753528595, -0.019393054768443108, -0.02915014885365963, -0.018072087317705154, -0.05301815643906593, 0.0339222326874733, -0.029595395550131798, 0.03221355006098747, 0.04663538560271263, -0.003968187142163515, 0.025383567437529564, -0.08319848030805588, 0.04817165061831474, 0.013826264999806881, -0.0023928345181047916, -0.022996407002210617, 0.012859074398875237, -0.0471591055393219, -0.014952274039387703, 0.04710955545306206, -0.0288490392267704, -0.0126593466848135, -0.042246460914611816, 0.015040287747979164, 0.03201563283801079, -0.049251265823841095, 0.011900797486305237, -0.00889758300036192, -0.027854839339852333, -0.06978391855955124, -0.001838918775320053, 0.04085078835487366, -0.027713419869542122, 0.027707699686288834, 0.019345184788107872, -0.007885787636041641, -0.004703879822045565, 0.008961298502981663, 0.03763645142316818, -0.011827332898974419, 0.010205891914665699, 0.004601296968758106, -0.008555548265576363, 0.005479356739670038, 0.022565508261322975, -0.014911293052136898, -0.02286209538578987, 0.02273259125649929, -0.03403151407837868, -0.02442091517150402, 0.020710313692688942, 0.055839650332927704, -0.01015473436564207, -0.05759122967720032, 0.018873602151870728, 0.029935747385025024, -0.03031853958964348, 0.010027972050011158, 0.025517402216792107, -0.010337840765714645, 0.06893862038850784, -0.010433388873934746, 0.015642300248146057, 0.004463880322873592, -0.009862401522696018, -0.010312912985682487, -0.01925368793308735, 0.0176687054336071, -0.019499124959111214, 0.04858947917819023, 0.019440576434135437, -0.029276074841618538, -0.0005917463568039238, 0.01448735035955906, 0.026978008449077606, -0.020739911124110222, 0.008160090073943138, 0.00516559649258852, -0.005513201002031565, 0.01829511858522892, -0.004710566718131304, -0.0007164862472563982, 0.06485819816589355, -0.03385041281580925, -0.01749395951628685, -0.06404052674770355, -0.02758735977113247, -0.03370242938399315, 0.00590942520648241, -0.006364442873746157, 0.06887287646532059, 0.008395901881158352, 0.02947663888335228, -0.0016094560269266367, 0.010433816350996494, 0.04524925723671913, -0.023337790742516518, 0.024271048605442047, -0.03189726173877716, -0.03360617533326149, -0.030947193503379822, -0.012274623848497868, 0.01180288102477789, -0.03185699135065079, 0.029804330319166183, 0.035344384610652924, 0.02340981364250183, 0.00020498412777669728, -0.008531851693987846, -0.024045882746577263, 0.003799757454544306, -0.05620349571108818, 0.01900312677025795, -0.07169388234615326, 0.031829338520765305, -0.010989760048687458, -0.03376103565096855 ]
<p>I have some observed (i.e., not generated by any hypothesized distribution, but generated by real processes) data that I believe is bi-modal (it may have more modes than two).</p> <p>In this dataset, there are 241,792 observations. The deciles are the following values:</p> <pre><code>MIN - 0.1472 10th - 0.3072 20th - 0.4094 30th - 0.6267 40th - 0.9396 50th - 1.4678 60th - 2.4125 70th - 4.2814 80th - 7.8145 90th - 16.7443 MAX - 241.0211 </code></pre> <p>How can I identify modes using R?</p> <p>Once identified and assuming that each mode is the location of central tendency for a local, somewhat Gaussian distribution, how should I determine where one tail ends and the next begins?</p> <p>The end result is that I'm trying to treat the set of data as the composition of partitions, where each partition can be analyzed on its own. </p>
73,562
[ -0.019961943849921227, -0.00214058393612504, 0.0200587660074234, 0.007500417530536652, 0.03266998380422592, 0.01513171847909689, 0.011074144393205643, -0.037148624658584595, 0.035463493317365646, -0.04109055921435356, 0.03054777719080448, 0.049436312168836594, 0.0460350327193737, 0.048517607152462006, 0.04908047616481781, -0.00974295660853386, -0.02466622367501259, -0.013209395110607147, -0.006352389231324196, -0.023597698658704758, -0.02345477230846882, -0.017598267644643784, 0.019671177491545677, -0.01724369078874588, -0.04510551691055298, 0.0533621609210968, 0.02740543521940708, -0.014785938896238804, -0.001911525847390294, 0.03972817584872246, -0.0074672638438642025, -0.03479653596878052, 0.016445830464363098, 0.04277748987078667, 0.02665834315121174, -0.001314424560405314, -0.012458395212888718, 0.02003457024693489, -0.02323933131992817, 0.017991002649068832, -0.06732355803251266, -0.023312490433454514, -0.023763421922922134, 0.005923567805439234, 0.02012159302830696, -0.014554712921380997, 0.010664696805179119, -0.025385858491063118, 0.017627062276005745, -0.03818565979599953, 0.09894268214702606, 0.03919606655836105, 0.03544733300805092, 0.016562003642320633, 0.006621866952627897, -0.02070680819451809, 0.05449516698718071, 0.11935189366340637, 0.03533726930618286, -0.09138286858797073, -0.032711293548345566, -0.022157596424221992, -0.01963789388537407, -0.005545224994421005, -0.03256664425134659, 0.026643548160791397, 0.016972025856375694, -0.011082181707024574, 0.03684194013476372, 0.005381970200687647, -0.004709974862635136, 0.02136375568807125, 0.05510839447379112, -0.011212928220629692, 0.00402173213660717, -0.014669111929833889, 0.021345527842640877, 0.022613046690821648, 0.03918867185711861, -0.00025433700648136437, 0.03401414304971695, -0.017160527408123016, -0.012355266138911247, 0.03526457026600838, 0.03127396106719971, 0.008443324826657772, 0.09782035648822784, -0.038459762930870056, 0.013907331973314285, 0.02422347478568554, -0.02115926891565323, 0.0010711740469560027, 0.03542463853955269, 0.005006563849747181, -0.040952932089567184, 0.05184745416045189, 0.013609510846436024, 0.019547119736671448, -0.032613299787044525, 0.005235031712800264, -0.007310134824365377, -0.0219486802816391, 0.007084447890520096, 0.05849863588809967, -0.02492201142013073, 0.01335934642702341, -0.060644201934337616, -0.005676695145666599, -0.02397451363503933, -0.0005764898960478604, -0.023507926613092422, 0.02704666554927826, 0.042346131056547165, -0.004760209936648607, 0.022242601960897446, 0.014496121555566788, -0.028300980105996132, -0.015644755214452744, 0.027876606211066246, 0.05736997351050377, 0.05881113559007645, -0.004741452168673277, 0.0005187572678551078, -0.04196090251207352, -0.045493483543395996, 0.017785802483558655, 0.02253604121506214, 0.006298698950558901, -0.05221742019057274, 0.03810851275920868, 0.01728937029838562, -0.024563871324062347, 0.03547785431146622, -0.016845783218741417, 0.01674162968993187, 0.01735236868262291, -0.08565627783536911, -0.032677192240953445, 0.03173103928565979, 0.003474934259429574, -0.008970153518021107, -0.032396551221609116, -0.010369133204221725, 0.07335183769464493, 0.0075115058571100235, -0.023666469380259514, 0.043441832065582275, 0.003295094007626176, 0.005049141589552164, -0.007991831749677658, 0.007223933003842831, -0.006371128372848034, -0.028036147356033325, -0.0018702942179515958, -0.018150610849261284, -0.06394900381565094, -0.008500460535287857, 0.03858580440282822, -0.01546424999833107, -0.0162949338555336, 0.019913852214813232, 0.0020308049861341715, -0.016634857282042503, -0.011411674320697784, 0.01766660064458847, -0.00331082078628242, 0.07512339949607849, 0.01686837337911129, 0.028622861951589584, 0.04106744006276131, -0.0012915256666019559, 0.02766193263232708, 0.01930457353591919, 0.04124625772237778, 0.022903403267264366, -0.00520202936604619, 0.0014205020852386951, -0.043044645339250565, 0.018467571586370468, 0.043745774775743484, -0.0048154378309845924, -0.022182567045092583, 0.007622638251632452, -0.004289358388632536, -0.0020918508525937796, 0.032952260226011276, 0.0015333209885284305, -0.0289138313382864, 0.06898381561040878, -0.055387504398822784, 0.0031058641616255045, -0.04171227663755417, -0.008443823084235191, -0.02067584916949272, -0.026876285672187805, 0.010380030609667301, 0.015984775498509407, 0.019726965576410294, -0.04310858994722366, -0.02976510487496853, -0.00761363236233592, 0.02154754102230072, 0.05980381742119789, -0.014668523333966732, 0.016098469495773315, 0.04714579880237579, 0.02296360954642296, -0.023160021752119064, 0.044647932052612305, -0.011632596142590046, -0.030134357511997223, 0.029806101694703102, -0.04246791452169418, 0.016512587666511536, -0.03177948668599129, -0.025419676676392555, -0.0000865810870891437, 0.0021134475246071815, -0.037231091409921646, 0.020801585167646408, -0.0438062846660614, 0.05055372044444084, 0.08495448529720306, 0.01296775508671999, -0.00539395259693265, -0.015819789841771126, -0.011331941932439804, 0.030461641028523445, -0.05959970876574516, 0.004649588372558355, -0.041900258511304855, -0.012874441221356392, 0.07436346262693405, 0.002525429939851165, -0.03319980949163437, 0.013252878561615944, 0.03500434756278992, -0.0005508901667781174, 0.028807194903492928, 0.04087575525045395, -0.01453395001590252, 0.010933924466371536, 0.011405718512833118, 0.015860844403505325, 0.01686962880194187, -0.0012686072150245309, 0.045631587505340576, 0.015295866876840591, 0.019418084993958473, -0.0036579046864062548, 0.017027998343110085, 0.05945967882871628, -0.003491876879706979, 0.027035098522901535, -0.030980456620454788, -0.007686309516429901, 0.07172060757875443, -0.027937710285186768, 0.039927151054143906, 0.014596788212656975, -0.003974808380007744, -0.022949209436774254, -0.0008976233075372875, -0.005930488463491201, 0.019569331780076027, 0.04727451503276825, -0.04044722020626068, -0.001994738820940256, 0.01542853843420744, -0.006901448126882315, 0.004328442271798849, -0.01744207926094532, -0.0308364424854517, -0.029790950939059258, 0.02657485008239746, 0.0625166967511177, 0.04360118880867958, 0.016063060611486435, -0.014794017188251019, -0.03248925879597664, -0.0006594473379664123, -0.020052148029208183, 0.0003950153768528253, 0.004781603813171387, -0.040881164371967316, 0.008816402405500412, 0.005099492613226175, 0.021909324452280998, -0.006763704586774111, 0.03666757792234421, -0.00621075090020895, 0.002436406211927533, 0.01096575241535902, -0.0493905209004879, 0.003934154286980629, -0.011691009625792503, -0.021511750295758247, -0.05271401256322861, 0.01839866302907467, 0.02931693196296692, 0.04186099395155907, -0.040085017681121826, 0.029224829748272896, -0.06031688302755356, -0.04997247830033302, -0.02380124107003212, -0.02027362771332264, 0.03901757299900055, 0.04792061448097229, 0.04096197709441185, 0.03253001719713211, 0.013663142919540405, 0.03737417981028557, -0.0673212856054306, -0.0744309201836586, -0.027308516204357147, -0.003914128057658672, 0.04732475057244301, 0.02201477624475956, -0.008217780850827694, 0.04340600222349167, 0.017456959933042526, -0.0628993958234787, -0.022221695631742477, 0.0153671158477664, 0.006624883972108364, -0.021476101130247116, 0.02131536416709423, 0.010423272848129272, 0.029148980975151062, -0.025925438851118088, 0.014555878937244415, 0.031376149505376816, 0.04243721440434456, 0.009546232409775257, -0.021148715168237686, 0.021978851407766342, -0.03687403351068497, -0.02658105455338955, 0.015847718343138695, 0.026598073542118073, 0.027486570179462433, 0.011961609125137329, -0.04648623615503311, 0.013663649559020996, 0.012569569051265717, -0.028361141681671143, -0.0008132299990393221, -0.046514708548784256, 0.018080515787005424, -0.02140410989522934, -0.0031260494142770767, 0.012885525822639465, -0.05035349354147911, 0.02301752008497715, 0.012802891433238983, 0.0638008713722229, -0.02292845956981182, -0.028034843504428864, 0.060012392699718475, -0.00950830802321434, -0.01617356948554516, 0.004175128880888224, 0.021664170548319817, -0.014980706386268139, -0.018555782735347748, -0.01835780031979084, -0.03645649179816246, 0.044136058539152145, 0.040705204010009766, 0.06798096746206284, -0.008801753632724285, -0.039287496358156204, 0.02991705760359764, -0.0696813315153122, 0.003329543163999915, -0.015303628519177437, 0.049614954739809036, -0.009739510715007782, 0.05066084861755371, 0.039428915828466415, 0.0021550622768700123, 0.0007431172416545451, 0.004997379146516323, -0.06509315967559814, 0.03519916534423828, -0.010921139270067215, 0.041568782180547714, -0.025460872799158096, -0.04499482363462448, 0.012747363187372684, -0.03826720267534256, 0.026569359004497528, 0.01336789969354868, -0.005724003538489342, -0.02708388864994049, 0.020882613956928253, -0.059352435171604156, -0.032010164111852646, -0.009282791055738926, -0.020167220383882523, 0.044762980192899704, -0.005422506481409073, 0.03359387069940567, 0.02618093229830265, 0.011029316112399101, 0.006453872658312321, -0.04343317076563835, -0.016380643472075462, 0.0017252392135560513, 0.05704924091696739, -0.0022382319439202547, 0.013900762423872948, -0.020742937922477722, 0.03183318302035332, 0.0157172754406929, 0.0662727877497673, 0.0316365510225296, -0.02864236943423748, -0.010464089922606945, -0.00349495280534029, -0.0072279321029782295, 0.010059908032417297, -0.012291690334677696, -0.011030222289264202, 0.01516162883490324, 0.04728112369775772, -0.002218580339103937, -0.06744434684515, 0.056217506527900696, 0.039265815168619156, 0.04094123840332031, -0.01983754150569439, -0.058207426220178604, -0.020433245226740837, 0.0008916436927393079, -0.028381336480379105, 0.008435559459030628, -0.015692729502916336, 0.025723068043589592, 0.04321526736021042, 0.03531791269779205, -0.009344616904854774, -0.012227728962898254, 0.003163267159834504, -0.008217803202569485, 0.040977347642183304, -0.01273269858211279, -0.05555954948067665, -0.008766120299696922, 0.03537067770957947, 0.029267454519867897, 0.006366098765283823, -0.0013338428689166903, -0.11287613213062286, 0.03545317426323891, 0.05404242128133774, 0.058795299381017685, -0.009203934110701084, -0.00616284878924489, -0.0717441737651825, 0.0015428756596520543, 0.015031896531581879, -0.05470724776387215, 0.03213835507631302, -0.028608262538909912, 0.02652464061975479, -0.0058038863353431225, -0.016981026157736778, -0.04233557730913162, 0.005581054370850325, -0.028569284826517105, 0.015540719032287598, -0.010583550669252872, -0.06723259389400482, -0.08145472407341003, 0.029596175998449326, -0.011658473871648312, 0.02464355155825615, -0.010520484298467636, -0.03003326989710331, -0.030058030039072037, 0.02446514181792736, -0.004080499522387981, -0.06377231329679489, -0.0007899082265794277, -0.011959354393184185, 0.01974366419017315, 0.049142178148031235, 0.010337374173104763, -0.052441999316215515, 0.027986204251646996, 0.015508722513914108, 0.03192375227808952, 0.012637397274374962, 0.005672527942806482, 0.08180166780948639, 0.03217490389943123, 0.020999900996685028, 0.022621426731348038, 0.007390381768345833, -0.01302303560078144, -0.03188993036746979, -0.018080249428749084, 0.013890939764678478, -0.013199809938669205, -0.004320675972849131, -0.04543696343898773, 0.01640945114195347, -0.010559295304119587, 0.006828927900642157, -0.024841278791427612, 0.04302382096648216, -0.026761798188090324, -0.02332245744764805, 0.013743526302278042, -0.001404972979798913, 0.006272881757467985, -0.03611314669251442, 0.010930493474006653, 0.029519042000174522, -0.001658898196183145, 0.010085037909448147, 0.017683910205960274, -0.045083679258823395, 0.008778387680649757, -0.0014435994671657681, -0.05720580369234085, 0.02180648408830166, -0.06344752013683319, -0.02385724149644375, -0.0047460594214499, -0.007038768380880356, 0.030693555250763893, -0.012113915756344795, 0.0075125847943127155, 0.05222288891673088, -0.010014434345066547, -0.013824963942170143, -0.0026602738071233034, 0.06461275368928909, 0.0287200715392828, 0.002353130606934428, 0.04291322082281113, 0.009387698955833912, -0.013325321488082409, -0.10812198370695114, -0.030728820711374283, 0.03946375474333763, 0.022908130660653114, -0.04614412412047386, -0.057824984192848206, 0.003810326801612973, -0.010974718257784843, -0.011233054101467133, -0.00038397821481339633, 0.021715279668569565, -0.008761031553149223, -0.0014322760980576277, -0.005347102414816618, 0.019940808415412903, 0.08503322303295135, -0.02335861511528492, -0.0023573634680360556, 0.029583970084786415, 0.021305840462446213, -0.020594513043761253, -0.0065607051365077496, 0.010513450019061565, -0.024507224559783936, 0.023071207106113434, -0.0011786222457885742, -0.014308220706880093, 0.041746530681848526, -0.011665968224406242, -0.01318072248250246, -0.03175421059131622, -0.027129704132676125, -0.014890058897435665, -0.03937912732362747, -0.019780386239290237, -0.026473114266991615, -0.021073205396533012, -0.012429093942046165, 0.01788625866174698, 0.006056994199752808, -0.03652415797114372, 0.05126887187361717, -0.01672162115573883, -0.0227689016610384, 0.03353755176067352, 0.030659891664981842, 0.00886254757642746, 0.009075132198631763, -0.01263998169451952, 0.0012331202160567045, 0.025240154936909676, 0.015774264931678772, -0.007107445038855076, 0.007284240331500769, 0.0036717907059937716, -0.021029554307460785, -0.005078450310975313, -0.05081157013773918, -0.010174638591706753, 0.06830675154924393, 0.014710062183439732, 0.022823547944426537, 0.022274499759078026, -0.016414372250437737, -0.0018056280678138137, -0.004581928718835115, 0.003381244605407119, -0.0193297378718853, 0.02245033159852028, 0.0752013698220253, -0.028487466275691986, -0.03133702278137207, -0.005536913406103849, 0.0002856727223843336, 0.007825085893273354, 0.06434909254312515, 0.007025919388979673, 0.018450705334544182, 0.047442637383937836, -0.0181324053555727, -0.02321212738752365, 0.004832975100725889, -0.03837301582098007, 0.007282605394721031, -0.0416409969329834, -0.001007705694064498, 0.004176250193268061, 0.030030515044927597, -0.02852374128997326, -0.04638439416885376, -0.0063805002719163895, -0.05186557024717331, -0.005584842525422573, 0.04057742655277252, -0.02367899753153324, 0.025229433551430702, 0.044778596609830856, 0.028458844870328903, 0.04073921963572502, 0.014546560123562813, -0.009563665837049484, -0.018607977777719498, -0.03286708518862724, -0.01807013526558876, -0.035031337291002274, 0.051374778151512146, -0.013908382505178452, -0.022808246314525604, 0.023528965190052986, -0.01886765845119953, -0.008523650467395782, -0.0067419204860925674, 0.025372037664055824, -0.005554108414798975, 0.0644322857260704, 0.01643705554306507, 0.009678597562015057, 0.012771351262927055, -0.0037250530440360308, 0.12427084147930145, 0.08476058393716812, 0.040164828300476074, -0.029995648190379143, 0.017670104280114174, 0.05414398014545441, -0.010712893679738045, -0.021957114338874817, 0.01719844341278076, 0.02019333466887474, -0.010816656053066254, 0.07174188643693924, 0.03566408157348633, 0.0019111278234049678, 0.02163114957511425, 0.04704277217388153, -0.03880489617586136, -0.03487859293818474, 0.00589123135432601, 0.007062658201903105, -0.016735579818487167, -0.026682427152991295, -0.04624092951416969, 0.06188375502824783, -0.0021280215587466955, -0.017025398090481758, -0.032219838351011276, -0.04727941378951073, -0.0004412895650602877, 0.027818026021122932, -0.016601257026195526, -0.02315451204776764, 0.023311471566557884, 0.008725831285119057, -0.0008807657868601382, -0.01531127281486988, 0.016785748302936554, -0.009323601610958576, 0.03377395495772362, -0.001579617033712566, -0.006954610347747803, 0.013699290342628956, -0.0038366529624909163, 0.03278222307562828, -0.03367312252521515, -0.029528070241212845, -0.03088904730975628, 0.04464615508913994, -0.008049729280173779, -0.023133208975195885, -0.018159527331590652, -0.0007626886363141239, 0.02659464441239834, -0.025906268507242203, -0.01650157757103443, -0.005892830900847912, 0.02437867969274521, -0.03477301821112633, -0.026690926402807236, -0.002834874205291271, -0.013210540637373924, -0.011849677190184593, 0.014207832515239716, -0.002732848050072789, -0.007211977615952492, -0.0401713028550148, -0.040264010429382324, 0.07813902199268341, -0.002779456088319421, -0.0033069050405174494, -0.018707867711782455, -0.050493624061346054, -0.019383898004889488, 0.02170405164361, 0.02671661786735058, 0.02233857288956642, -0.01635422743856907, 0.02286064811050892, -0.013456635177135468, -0.045624807476997375, 0.004254383035004139, 0.008742675185203552, -0.009173004887998104, -0.008123891428112984, -0.007916085422039032, -0.033818893134593964, 0.020623017102479935, 0.05256194621324539, -0.000672750233206898, 0.03884308040142059, 0.012657258659601212, 0.05217333137989044, -0.021654900163412094, -0.05486377328634262, -0.010639122687280178, 0.008659504354000092, -0.017274068668484688, 0.008122451603412628, -0.01742604747414589, 0.09209605306386948, -0.005280498880892992, -0.012240980751812458, 0.006600003689527512, 0.038112543523311615, -0.02803034707903862, 0.006912974175065756, 0.02063453383743763, -0.03508773818612099, 0.006282501388341188, 0.00810361560434103, -0.014544605277478695, -0.055603303015232086, -0.037271928042173386, -0.021725021302700043, -0.017897943034768105, 0.019287237897515297, -0.018037283793091774, -0.03150889649987221, -0.011155721731483936, -0.01630222611129284, -0.003927423618733883, -0.024566326290369034, -0.0015703031094744802, -0.04727266728878021, 0.005551534704864025, -0.02021578885614872, -0.005907776299864054, 0.012494116090238094, 0.022418459877371788, -0.003317948430776596, -0.049015164375305176, 0.02970290370285511, 0.03823031485080719, 0.05099432170391083, -0.018655987456440926, 0.0055502355098724365, -0.014009852893650532, 0.0389106422662735, -0.010546782985329628, -0.036140430718660355, 0.02203386090695858, -0.037870872765779495, -0.05395583435893059, 0.010295608080923557, 0.010855886153876781, 0.03420624881982803, 0.016035642474889755, -0.005264969542622566, -0.00027229831903241575, 0.02500392682850361, -0.004944934044033289, -0.008612042292952538, -0.007928743027150631, 0.02981298603117466, 0.00669433455914259, -0.01484579686075449, 0.006902738008648157, -0.008982391096651554, -0.04178592935204506, -0.005221288185566664, 0.028575384989380836, 0.007550234440714121, -0.006664068438112736, -0.002044853288680315, -0.018715914338827133, 0.008644947782158852, -0.025248441845178604, 0.02432379685342312, 0.03721078112721443, 0.03413229063153267, -0.055163610726594925, 0.016022363677620888, -0.06193079799413681, 0.008418802171945572, -0.07701810449361801, -0.03884345293045044, 0.0027125102933496237, -0.0037057918962091208, 0.013953151181340218, -0.04045141860842705, -0.01660112477838993, 0.022571736946702003, -0.02216680906713009, 0.032472528517246246, -0.029052020981907845, 0.031108269467949867, -0.05738873779773712, 0.04593232274055481, -0.05291804298758507, 0.05332396924495697, 0.004836753010749817, 0.015460552647709846, 0.05167064815759659, 0.036818698048591614, -0.028311530128121376, -0.027347255498170853, -0.022939182817935944, -0.016953393816947937, 0.05206049606204033, -0.0617329366505146, 0.020759226754307747, -0.038426924496889114, -0.040755078196525574, 0.025594035163521767, -0.027756482362747192, 0.023162662982940674, 0.009218099527060986, 0.0017507586162537336, 0.014289305545389652, 0.06630784273147583, 0.03966206684708595, 0.003361298469826579, 0.0048558395355939865, 0.02149818278849125, 0.03236900269985199, 0.02414572797715664, -0.059181105345487595, -0.020681224763393402, 0.011569790542125702, 0.03703062981367111, -0.017246900126338005, 0.007829447276890278, -0.00964357890188694, -0.01321027148514986, -0.0487804040312767, 0.01893124170601368, 0.005863809026777744, -0.04222675785422325, 0.026709016412496567, -0.055664896965026855, -0.01812819018959999, 0.02590767666697502, 0.015109557658433914, -0.038538672029972076, 0.045831069350242615, 0.004698994569480419, -0.04056825116276741, -0.003226382192224264, 0.025282982736825943, -0.01256263256072998, -0.02022266387939453, 0.007064250763505697, -0.020761292427778244, 0.0037957318127155304, -0.037384726107120514, 0.005202324595302343, -0.02316715009510517, 0.051850564777851105, -0.00687383534386754, 0.039807602763175964, -0.013004766777157784, -0.02724059484899044, 0.027267398312687874, -0.10211551189422607, 0.026222698390483856, 0.00592837342992425, 0.025328803807497025, -0.05260981246829033, -0.047678083181381226, -0.03851698338985443, 0.017303556203842163, 0.037302181124687195, 0.037593111395835876, 0.028354214504361153, -0.010057696141302586, 0.02069958858191967, 0.0005726194940507412, -0.07828862220048904, 0.014291402883827686, -0.034406740218400955, -0.01967296004295349, -0.004833264276385307, -0.04430153965950012, -0.0009526312351226807, -0.009124844335019588, 0.002102239988744259, 0.008135014213621616, -0.01338889915496111, 0.011642287485301495, -0.009411316365003586, 0.03526921942830086, -0.02686481364071369, 0.011389781720936298, 0.06238722801208496, 0.006129169836640358, 0.020146973431110382, 0.043274179100990295, -0.012445149011909962, -0.032204270362854004, 0.012907433323562145, -0.05013761669397354, -0.022543340921401978, -0.007638835813850164, -0.009399917908012867, 0.03128081187605858, -0.0381258949637413, -0.010311981663107872, -0.0030161605682224035, -0.05341358482837677, 0.012212218716740608, 0.006388181354850531, -0.017709845677018166, 0.02616240456700325, 0.02261943183839321, -0.0006553442217409611, -0.010292687453329563, -0.032468222081661224, 0.005666909273713827, 0.010102301836013794, 0.02237861417233944, -0.017534533515572548, -0.0008971899515017867, 0.02735026180744171, -0.03935803100466728, -0.0021365988068282604, -0.04003804922103882, 0.012026500888168812, -0.01778855361044407, -0.029328100383281708, 0.022276228293776512, -0.010390042327344418, -0.02948312647640705, -0.024071982130408287, -0.026941295713186264, 0.029268311336636543, 0.014167184941470623, -0.016191422939300537, -0.025471286848187447, -0.02405957318842411, 0.019855791702866554, 0.031230460852384567, 0.027919651940464973, 0.00015975629503373057, -0.001875587971881032, 0.03543490916490555, 0.011604036204516888, -0.008609253913164139, 0.03355051949620247, -0.006799592636525631, 0.039047613739967346, -0.02874782867729664, 0.00726758548989892, 0.05339156836271286, -0.03314531594514847, -0.0391165092587471, -0.04066324979066849, -0.00019049608090426773, 0.005555388052016497, 0.03404032811522484, -0.017055261880159378, -0.035712335258722305, -0.004971078597009182, 0.05605749413371086, -0.05147557705640793, 0.003870139131322503, -0.011191483587026596, -0.006446306128054857, -0.04489375650882721, -0.0174031313508749 ]